id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00378v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00378v2 | An Empirical Study on the Transferability of Transformer Modules in Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning | 2023-02-01T11:20:18 | 2023-02-22T16:56:58 | Mohammad Akbar-Tajari, Sara Rajaee, Mohammad Taher Pilehvar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Parameter-efficient fine-tuning approaches have recently garnered a lot of
attention. Having considerably lower number of trainable weights, these methods
can bring about scalability and computational effectiveness. In this paper, we
look for optimal sub-networks and investigate the capability of different
transformer modules in transferring knowledge from a pre-trained model to a
downstream task. Our empirical results suggest that every transformer module in
BERT can act as a winning ticket: fine-tuning each specific module while
keeping the rest of the network frozen can lead to comparable performance to
the full fine-tuning. Among different modules, LayerNorms exhibit the best
capacity for knowledge transfer with limited trainable weights, to the extent
that, with only 0.003% of all parameters in the layer-wise analysis, they show
acceptable performance on various target tasks. On the reasons behind their
effectiveness, we argue that their notable performance could be attributed to
their high-magnitude weights compared to that of the other modules in the
pre-trained BERT. | [
-0.7603198886,
-0.2416276932,
0.4230322242,
0.1122587249,
-0.2033256441,
-0.2695203125,
-0.3677211106,
-0.3648504317,
-0.2256499082,
0.3531179428,
-0.5324581265,
-0.0311364569,
-0.8395519257,
-0.2736987174,
-0.7430686951,
1.0864282846,
-0.0026698227,
-0.343646884,
-0.0961148739,
-0.1057102308,
-0.2553335726,
-0.0996424854,
-0.7315227985,
-0.7629334927,
0.9512298107,
0.3925018609,
0.5175673962,
0.4130730629,
0.6928440332,
0.288004458,
-0.0209928788,
0.1030937806,
-0.6648145318,
-0.1348021626,
-0.5215203762,
-0.6745534539,
-0.2540020347,
-0.198877573,
0.4013340175,
0.5292899609,
0.0139042856,
0.4531980455,
0.2211414427,
0.8250430226,
-0.5565303564,
0.1281512231,
-0.9195645452,
0.0688427612,
-0.0679128915,
-0.1770645827,
-0.420141995,
-0.3454423547,
0.3554897606,
-0.6495178938,
0.2329588383,
0.1041774526,
1.2402721643,
0.5083138943,
-0.1873917282,
-0.0056670983,
-0.905520618,
0.7724006772,
-0.7242962718,
0.2042189389,
0.1699114889,
0.6149867177,
0.1366399527,
-0.9610500336,
-0.2224109024,
-0.0650500953,
-0.3518264592,
0.2364601791,
-0.4511551559,
0.1126307473,
0.2444031388,
0.2100167125,
-0.1021846086,
0.5046940446,
-0.6228919625,
-0.1389504522,
0.4110660553,
-0.0113078598,
0.0831275433,
-0.1111758724,
-0.3292258978,
0.0710955486,
-0.3276686966,
0.2317690253,
0.4221794903,
0.4209904671,
0.0838095099,
0.2724683583,
-0.2912002504,
0.6758161783,
0.2195971906,
0.1289429516,
-0.2294004261,
-0.2704996169,
-0.3240581453,
-0.2053627074,
0.4750601649,
0.0472614393,
0.5163637996,
-0.5280893445,
-0.2950334251,
-0.5675342679,
0.8290449977,
-0.613578856,
-0.7384009957,
-0.0348834805,
-0.7120168209,
-0.1973533332,
-0.0274832286,
-0.3541381955,
0.0846616104,
-0.6014407873,
1.1597571373,
-0.5841221213,
-0.3386440277,
0.0167550258,
-0.418507427,
0.4992690682,
0.3422959149,
-0.919736743,
0.2500860691,
0.6925302744,
0.7455937266,
-0.2078019083,
-0.2247479856,
-0.069787994,
0.0906404182,
-0.1316079348,
0.6230397224,
-0.1089069545,
0.1611322016,
-0.193143785,
0.164272815,
-0.5626374483,
-0.4406713545,
0.5630510449,
-0.793241322,
-0.2325250655,
-0.3971099555,
-0.5356001854,
-0.0978696942,
-0.0541190617,
-0.6797828078,
0.6500463486,
0.1152101234,
-0.5017535686,
0.498968035,
-0.5708667636,
-0.7306066751,
-0.0368216112,
0.4121104777,
-0.393799454,
0.2460704595,
0.0870793909,
0.7906512022,
-0.1533017159,
-0.1723465621,
0.0138341291,
-0.4708198905,
0.0018817915,
-0.2323726267,
0.4887805581,
0.4281985164,
-0.4632851183,
0.0236358549,
-0.7563307285,
0.1198276654,
-0.218285054,
-0.4187922478,
-0.3423533738,
-0.0887473077,
-0.1478509307,
-0.0106889261,
0.1082553715,
-0.4834861159,
0.0788331181,
-0.1392886341,
0.7114376426,
0.8931909204,
-0.2838138342,
0.8555611372,
-0.4779972136,
0.1935428977,
-0.018787872,
0.4433184862,
0.219960928,
-0.3868807852,
-1.0572371483,
-0.2813192606,
0.6785940528,
0.2410036772,
-0.7399011254,
0.4642526209,
-0.1804505438,
-0.9273080826,
-0.4993208051,
0.0613181293,
0.1737016588,
0.6068449616,
0.5948646665,
0.0690497607,
-0.2614310086,
-1.3542306423,
-0.3946233988,
0.0773310736,
-0.0478545949,
0.3850136101,
0.425552845,
0.0811634958,
0.8673997521,
-0.367667079,
-0.4686557949,
-0.5483809114,
0.2510119677,
0.4649153352,
0.8774067163,
0.6942844391,
-0.5999940038,
-0.4857448339,
0.3718158007,
-0.3107594252,
-0.0570084713,
-0.3170706034,
-0.4350397885,
-0.1446217149,
0.3369952142,
-0.7000508904,
0.2177152336,
0.4411197901,
0.2435973138,
0.308960706,
-0.4957893789,
-0.0311081652,
-0.9070259929,
0.2098755538,
-0.1902836561,
-0.1326849163,
-0.506667912,
-0.123733364,
0.1253332049,
0.3302253187,
-0.3637498617,
0.1120704785,
-0.1726255119,
0.0913266987,
-0.0156984366,
-0.1991385967,
-0.2692470849,
0.6182581186,
-0.523557663,
0.5721665025,
0.5749726295,
-0.8548136353,
0.2903081179,
0.085636571,
-0.6561475396,
0.475017041,
-0.8124732971,
-0.1245011315,
-0.1827876717,
-0.0080751972,
-1.0376541615,
0.0584459119,
-0.1063880175,
-0.226385951,
0.3673014641,
-0.4048900902,
-0.238422215,
-0.2432034165,
0.0977343023,
0.1655740142,
0.920326829,
-0.5787129402,
0.7700180411,
-0.0265433192,
0.3247230947,
-0.4956567585,
-0.9008060098,
-0.2002393603,
-0.2408436537,
-0.5855529308,
0.5389344692,
0.2298960686,
0.3894377351,
0.2654194236,
-0.309866637,
-0.1540577263,
-0.0114625916,
0.1091695353,
-0.2350045741,
-0.3868805468,
0.0188001171,
0.3389471471,
-0.3389122188,
0.0500859655,
-0.5367616415,
0.2910422385,
-0.1160288006,
-0.3806091547,
-0.5880531669,
-0.0624079108,
0.6625475883,
0.0096361367,
1.0125988722,
0.9385270476,
-0.093100518,
-0.661152482,
-0.677254796,
-0.1670182794,
-0.4846598804,
0.3358319998,
-0.5150423646,
-0.7792158127,
0.6820232272,
-0.3200805187,
0.124365516,
0.6602481008,
0.1981721371,
-0.3215303123,
0.8545798659,
0.745654881,
-0.1470678151,
0.494199574,
-0.4449480474,
0.2644107938,
-0.7443874478,
-0.453938067,
-0.7068375945,
-1.0541408062,
-0.6395781636,
0.0735567883,
0.2759567499,
0.1432345808,
-0.2984749079,
1.0022479296,
-0.5464765429,
0.523909986,
0.9256215692,
0.2839262486,
0.065962404,
-0.0365771316,
-0.2089268118,
0.2035451829,
-1.1998097897,
-0.1352328807,
0.6445137262,
0.2747903168,
0.8019153476,
0.0188668407,
0.404891789,
0.2933609784,
0.1326620281,
-0.7126812935,
0.4938257337,
-0.5450810194,
-0.5756931305,
-0.5816084146,
-0.6564057469,
-0.99586308,
-0.0092110615,
-0.3097720742,
-0.6462393999,
0.3417192101,
0.0794468522,
-0.3450572491,
0.7948198318,
-0.7939314842,
0.6317634583,
-0.0244108308,
-0.0952481255,
-0.3182051182,
-0.8440855145,
-0.0103045329,
-0.1343896836,
-0.2321772128,
-0.0582373701,
0.1185921431,
0.7068021894,
-0.3007296622,
0.5994194746,
-0.2428583354,
-0.0193591099,
0.0243606754,
0.0001273279,
0.3645975888,
-0.0616402514,
-0.2821582556,
0.3221363723,
0.0215583947,
-0.4444590509,
-0.7624427676,
0.5070791841,
-1.1528344154,
-0.4054351449,
0.2693285048,
-0.5095117688,
-0.0729110539,
0.3436441422,
0.5395015478,
0.5827251673,
0.2615145147,
0.7203608155,
0.8965328932,
-0.0846716315,
0.6531174779,
0.282717824,
0.4421425462,
0.0011637311,
0.9136203527,
0.4348670542,
0.3419727087,
0.834050715,
0.2212413102,
0.072144419,
-0.8780041933,
-0.3076078296,
-0.104364939,
-0.6056696773,
-0.4472705722,
-0.4871670008,
-0.7319195271,
0.1158873588,
-0.2592559755,
-0.6939344406,
-0.4822004437,
-0.2494778931,
-0.0580906495,
0.260866195,
0.760966897,
-0.2322450131,
0.5734140873,
-0.764220655,
0.1067595929,
0.8335353732,
0.5256655812,
0.2132932693,
-0.7349715829,
-0.4174188673,
-0.2504300475,
-0.0214119647,
-0.3001198173,
-0.0567857474,
0.3126914203,
0.8165770769,
0.3229809999,
0.2122204155,
0.7879058719,
-0.4011169672,
0.5877484083,
0.0595134236,
-0.9757224321,
0.3973504603,
-0.2033937722,
0.1903637946,
0.6287051439,
0.3742122054,
0.218221426,
-0.2367488742,
-0.5894391537,
-1.0204440355,
0.9208459854,
0.5788266063,
0.3595347106,
0.7505328655,
0.7244201303,
0.3389922976,
0.0635820255,
-0.273309201,
-0.1809396148,
-0.1045599431,
-0.1518398374,
0.0858202279,
-0.0051049711,
-0.0264391396,
-0.515642643,
0.5971700549,
-0.081527859,
0.3766617477,
0.1588272303,
-0.0809937716,
-0.0728619397,
0.1134886593,
0.5397160053,
0.8751237988,
-0.3183770478,
0.5512530208,
0.6341931224,
-0.4458459318,
0.0162020288,
-0.1342000365,
-0.1113080755,
-0.1562496573,
0.4964773059,
0.7903730273,
0.2557378709,
0.0017898816,
0.2994565964,
-0.0677016005,
-0.4036489725,
0.1597659737,
0.5371882319,
-0.0670062676,
0.5188643932,
0.3862283528,
0.5934028029,
0.0010540567,
-0.0439543538,
0.248230502,
0.4202070534,
-0.4486002624,
-0.4084875286,
0.506896019,
0.1068990603,
-0.1938464493,
0.5796758533,
0.3273749053,
-0.4022070765,
0.7741494179,
0.3443689048,
0.6603929996,
0.096085839,
0.1841410995,
0.2669537663,
0.7245913744,
-0.1377658546,
-0.2413448989,
-0.276604712,
-0.7241197824,
-0.4971078038,
-0.7125649452,
-0.2302637696,
0.0582166053,
-0.8935264945,
0.1863515228,
-0.2790086865,
-0.3272327483,
0.0791595429,
-0.3573663235,
-0.9252328277,
0.2745291293,
-0.1730128974,
1.1195905209,
-0.575961709,
0.7005428672,
0.7597852349,
-0.1242338344,
-1.1380258799,
-0.2330508679,
-0.7328836918,
-1.0083441734,
0.7716184855,
-0.2226317078,
-0.0896681175,
0.2225384563,
-0.3450660408,
-0.9110805392,
1.2281295061,
0.5796517134,
-0.5029513836,
-0.1165885255,
0.2939409316,
0.4364481866,
0.04722495,
0.482267946,
0.5853111148,
0.6902052164,
0.24924317,
-1.0732166767,
0.0528337993,
0.0058240588,
0.1739607602,
0.2044848502,
-0.8596467376,
0.8144200444,
0.0856425017,
0.1179895028,
0.093327947,
0.6231762767,
-0.5947937369,
0.0166797992,
0.7469646335,
0.5714313388,
0.3664010167,
-0.2644753456,
0.8764523864,
-0.3235885501,
0.475522697,
0.5404546857,
0.5229101181,
0.7072526217,
0.4440411925,
-0.1418865621,
0.5104703903,
0.2707921863,
-0.0600137264,
0.8526084423,
0.3407979906,
0.3475963175,
-0.5930130482,
0.1598479003,
-0.2567429841,
0.3936119974,
-0.0711534098,
-0.3212816715,
-0.1903782487,
-0.1403826326,
-0.2498041093,
-0.5233072042,
-0.5219202042,
0.8546373248,
0.1515810937,
-0.6301857829,
0.3484295607,
-0.2237695605,
0.650282383,
-0.8894106746,
0.3107607663,
-0.2252372652,
0.4688417017,
-0.529968679,
-0.7303091288,
0.44716537,
-0.4147469401,
-0.2331538945,
-0.4388429821,
1.1771767139,
-0.1341934651,
-0.0808216631,
0.1966699511,
0.5802613497,
-0.0806170702,
-0.00650906,
-0.4553379118,
-0.3492879868,
-0.1996185035,
-0.3783775866,
0.4495843947,
0.5626032352,
0.502338171,
0.6327470541,
0.516117394,
0.2815324962,
0.1702490449,
0.0581116043,
0.9300125837,
-0.3392403722,
-0.3034468889,
-0.6752336621,
0.7428433299,
-0.0455669053,
-0.3668246865,
0.9146264791,
0.1469891518,
0.8208191395,
-0.2008458376,
0.5640972853,
-0.0584599525,
-0.0427592024,
-0.6023579836,
1.0248982906,
-0.6778061986,
0.1239998937,
-0.238321349,
-1.0180654526,
0.0008130065,
0.5709143877,
-0.1139660329,
0.0563104637,
0.4700320065,
0.5519129038,
-0.4559084475,
0.2351403534,
0.3755442202,
0.1296637207,
0.1541796774,
0.7096998096,
0.9070198536,
-0.5261887908,
0.7036705613,
-0.3413438201,
-0.2088204771,
-0.1340499073,
-0.8911984563,
-0.994638443,
-0.5623645186,
-0.2582591772,
0.0282983687,
0.019309191,
0.4152794182,
1.2601372004,
-0.8416350484,
-0.0095771942,
-0.2927093506,
0.2514608204,
-0.5179877877,
-0.1914136261,
0.2181333899,
-0.6746119261,
-0.402877748,
0.0164154172,
0.1501681805,
-0.2059962451,
-0.2068316042,
0.1883415878,
0.0861622766,
0.2923126221,
0.7083780169,
-0.0251494795,
-0.3348077834,
-0.6467942595,
0.0319231227,
0.1653171778,
-0.3335691988,
1.0121787786,
-0.7138864994,
0.0220399033,
0.7493357658,
0.9685406685,
0.6823446155,
-0.0207453165,
0.4877197444,
-0.7353137732,
-0.216321975,
0.071427241,
0.2131665647,
-0.1846953481,
-0.243483454,
0.5313231349,
0.0446889587,
-0.772392869,
-0.515348196,
-0.021815503,
-1.0839915276,
-0.2987675071,
1.0660616159,
-0.1532701552,
-0.0411006883,
-0.0611854568,
-0.0816520751,
0.3961430788,
-0.1497639716,
0.7884492278,
0.4782712162,
-0.4102661908,
-0.1140752286,
-0.417088151,
0.5836717486,
0.8001848459,
-0.662835598,
-0.3434212804,
-0.4226855934,
0.3050066829,
0.3059539199,
-0.0324520543,
0.3140468895,
-0.2235096991,
-0.2946374118,
-0.4758472741,
-0.3988538682,
-0.6109347343,
0.0225096997,
0.3999784291,
-0.2190157473,
-0.2093354762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00340v1 | Attention Link: An Efficient Attention-Based Low Resource Machine Translation Architecture | 2023-02-01T09:52:36 | 2023-02-01T09:52:36 | Zeping Min | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformers have achieved great success in machine translation, but
transformer-based NMT models often require millions of bilingual parallel
corpus for training. In this paper, we propose a novel architecture named as
attention link (AL) to help improve transformer models' performance, especially
in low training resources. We theoretically demonstrate the superiority of our
attention link architecture in low training resources. Besides, we have done a
large number of experiments, including en-de, de-en, en-fr, en-it, it-en, en-ro
translation tasks on the IWSLT14 dataset as well as real low resources scene on
bn-gu and gu-ta translation tasks on the CVIT PIB dataset. All the experiment
results show our attention link is powerful and can lead to a significant
improvement. In addition, we achieve a 37.9 BLEU score, a new sota, on the
IWSLT14 de-en task by combining our attention link and other advanced methods. | [
-0.5325543284,
-0.3834383488,
0.3158738017,
0.4502657056,
-0.1197245792,
0.0260115191,
-0.3408117294,
-0.3192001581,
0.116496563,
0.2754993439,
-0.6443452835,
-0.1484868079,
-0.6629303694,
0.3760984838,
-0.2987326384,
0.9315644503,
0.0382944979,
0.0027244301,
0.1218224913,
-0.4465270936,
-0.2785867751,
0.0912634134,
-0.7351973653,
-0.1869854182,
0.8572716713,
0.433316499,
0.8402490616,
0.8891339898,
1.1897475719,
0.3024877608,
-0.1873324662,
0.1060542762,
-0.7444152832,
-0.1667403579,
-0.4631280601,
-0.4795181453,
-0.7083415389,
-0.2338164002,
0.6431981921,
0.4981777072,
0.3445180655,
0.5577764511,
0.1841917932,
0.8925807476,
-0.5386603475,
0.0646287277,
-0.6933147907,
-0.0480892994,
-0.2554436922,
-0.1187452525,
-0.5719237328,
0.12753959,
0.0402584597,
-0.3297277987,
0.4704448581,
0.4027222097,
0.7577984333,
0.9898107052,
-0.2606047094,
0.2802342772,
-0.8111638427,
0.7671832442,
-0.3484579623,
0.7772059441,
0.0460690558,
0.3061302602,
0.2547409236,
-0.5652350187,
-0.3207993805,
-0.055061128,
-0.2233988345,
0.3546684086,
-0.5330893397,
-0.1146637946,
0.4249153435,
0.5075232983,
-0.4725141525,
-0.1436799467,
-0.4320009053,
0.0730052441,
0.2262445688,
0.2846617699,
0.1081995741,
-0.1700666398,
-0.630694747,
-0.149687171,
-0.6036468148,
-0.1745267659,
0.1014633328,
0.4057545066,
-0.5560342073,
0.5215519667,
-0.2282472104,
0.5215730071,
0.4145751894,
0.2050157189,
0.2300337106,
-0.2054098696,
-0.2598803937,
0.1998168081,
1.0042896271,
0.0544846915,
-0.1086616665,
-0.5455933213,
-0.1849048287,
-0.0765572712,
0.5836026073,
-0.7228742242,
0.0773475021,
-0.0657853037,
-0.7118990421,
-0.0327074267,
-0.3793760836,
-0.4662370086,
0.1725293547,
-0.1657319367,
0.4108481109,
-0.5409475565,
0.0203382261,
-0.1387047619,
0.5030571222,
0.2999637127,
0.191228658,
-0.9438245296,
0.2792648375,
0.3673653007,
0.9666416049,
-0.3287820518,
-0.230327487,
-0.6071125269,
0.2789928913,
0.0531087145,
0.7137248516,
-0.2015167773,
0.1231005862,
-0.4537625015,
0.1132684276,
-0.4676328003,
-0.5694007874,
0.639511168,
-0.6729537249,
-0.1151429266,
-0.1056066453,
0.0842555091,
-0.1681125164,
0.2642090917,
-0.975284636,
1.1103898287,
0.2431158572,
-0.904523313,
-0.3508388102,
-1.0600614548,
-0.5582529306,
0.1929813474,
0.2165444344,
-0.2606521249,
0.203697145,
0.2106167525,
0.2306332737,
-0.8460478783,
-0.0712645128,
0.0362478346,
-0.4172560871,
0.0725704506,
-0.718475461,
0.4887075722,
0.3077329695,
-0.6720535755,
0.0636319369,
-0.6881628633,
-0.1858948767,
0.212341696,
-0.571391046,
-0.1824824065,
-0.4553115666,
0.3914549649,
0.3101433218,
0.4249332249,
-0.4920686781,
0.0241227355,
-0.7019881606,
0.3770616353,
0.4133380651,
-0.2419742942,
0.7412461042,
0.0088500474,
0.5991941094,
0.0301216431,
0.2087254673,
-0.0968557075,
-0.4194106758,
-1.043893218,
-0.0848789513,
0.3370204866,
0.4212560952,
-0.8718541861,
0.3046043813,
-0.59438622,
-0.3711481094,
-1.266736269,
0.2501427829,
0.6493358612,
0.6658803821,
0.7799655795,
-0.116385147,
-0.2142967135,
-1.2330034971,
-0.2219865471,
0.2401316762,
-0.1305551976,
0.444753468,
0.2861919105,
-0.2963669896,
0.6573301554,
-0.2601469755,
-0.562515676,
-0.5330935717,
-0.2130864263,
0.426004976,
0.2004532665,
0.4722301066,
-0.7752475739,
-0.9000498652,
0.3151271045,
-0.4674710035,
0.0159661919,
0.1122769862,
-0.3827424049,
-0.0769888908,
0.304897964,
-0.5449280143,
-0.0422272123,
0.6133640409,
0.0049517183,
-0.268651545,
-0.0094352039,
0.2449086607,
-1.1113843918,
0.4174969196,
0.1139465123,
-0.2944692075,
-0.3933980167,
-0.0144399386,
0.2963421941,
-0.2464132756,
-0.9286404252,
0.4710843861,
-0.2343765497,
-0.0403863043,
-0.1209182069,
0.1277339756,
-0.1077676266,
1.0030790567,
-0.2178973407,
0.7825908065,
0.1027144492,
-0.3662624359,
0.3930621743,
0.6374461055,
-0.0362092555,
0.4967395365,
-0.6839880943,
0.3399454355,
-0.1460046321,
-0.1181207448,
-0.9519463181,
-0.0500385277,
0.4477615654,
-0.2959490716,
0.2899755538,
0.151962176,
-0.4006471634,
-0.3290019333,
-0.0057908348,
0.5304351449,
0.3816718459,
-0.5382704735,
0.5416992307,
0.0574894845,
-0.0336603001,
-0.4578145742,
-0.7033066154,
0.1217900664,
-0.1829858273,
-0.5421378613,
0.5283529162,
0.014446388,
0.1416871101,
0.335108608,
-0.2174350023,
-0.0363723747,
-0.0483403057,
0.0305325463,
0.1091079861,
-0.5460582972,
0.0719116405,
-0.0951449126,
-0.4373036027,
-0.148551628,
-0.0393169932,
0.5921177864,
-0.4064437151,
-0.1571686566,
-0.6007793546,
0.3640584052,
0.8522140384,
-0.5508795977,
0.7632936239,
0.8302941322,
-0.1821570992,
0.0267409701,
-0.5514674187,
-0.1576057822,
-0.4434583783,
0.5792570114,
-0.4634643495,
-0.7338980436,
0.1974855065,
-0.1055637822,
-0.1930972189,
0.661054492,
0.7603442669,
-0.2247954309,
0.9359415174,
0.6427987814,
-0.542347908,
0.4752915204,
-0.4398382604,
0.4745877087,
-1.1863574982,
-0.0469579399,
-0.4846919179,
-0.8844258785,
-0.4144139886,
-0.5801486969,
0.4912082553,
-0.1145384312,
-0.216335997,
0.9051778316,
-0.6445368528,
0.3190551698,
0.694958806,
0.3627440929,
0.2683387697,
-0.1550859064,
0.2267036587,
-0.3306233585,
-1.0742008686,
-0.4451160431,
0.7981419563,
0.4457596838,
0.7592790723,
0.1290610731,
0.4429068863,
0.20236063,
0.3379072845,
-0.8939730525,
0.510987401,
-0.1602456272,
-0.3849999607,
-0.3242347836,
-0.4444153309,
-0.7795101404,
0.1707437187,
-0.1736264974,
-0.2286565751,
-0.031085629,
0.2670642436,
-0.2651301324,
0.1725162864,
-0.7093417048,
1.168127656,
-0.3877910078,
-0.7008370757,
-0.4152734578,
-0.7846090198,
0.1336876899,
-0.1019037887,
-0.0993788615,
-0.010432004,
-0.076477401,
0.5888453126,
-0.0382507741,
0.6251637936,
0.2141124606,
0.0364175774,
0.1836528182,
-0.2134595811,
0.7699419856,
-0.1545289159,
-0.0095463023,
0.1641792655,
-0.7699480653,
-0.2730905414,
-0.5518328547,
0.701475203,
-0.7360998988,
-0.4966769516,
0.0359365456,
-1.0340433121,
-0.1569928974,
0.31017223,
0.391810745,
-0.0117158527,
-0.1216165796,
0.6514442563,
0.9161924124,
-0.0782856271,
0.5524019599,
0.529397428,
0.6573033333,
-0.40056476,
0.7681872249,
-0.1427338719,
0.2964047492,
0.9154279828,
0.0605593026,
-0.3096336722,
-0.1551847011,
-0.5832480788,
0.3428712189,
-0.4733016789,
-0.6169607043,
-1.0959807634,
-0.2370761186,
-0.2406678647,
-0.0559655763,
-0.8191062212,
-0.1389040649,
0.0987491757,
0.1975708306,
0.3507384658,
0.328755945,
0.4374522865,
0.5919060111,
-0.9960606098,
0.6621924043,
0.1497020423,
0.2947703302,
0.2488602698,
-0.5584749579,
-0.7763901353,
-0.2576953471,
-0.4314920902,
-0.7169158459,
0.2633381188,
0.0834206268,
0.5301648378,
0.2357850671,
0.2652052343,
0.4549199939,
-0.8370286822,
0.0707616955,
0.278177917,
-0.9181044102,
0.4386749864,
-0.3607545495,
0.6521650553,
0.4808740616,
0.3559301794,
-0.348573029,
-0.6082727909,
-0.5858097076,
-0.7073163986,
1.0857946873,
0.498244971,
0.05348102,
0.042357415,
0.0671436787,
-0.2428768873,
0.1838788837,
-0.7994239926,
-0.3186308742,
0.1379704773,
-0.5975479484,
0.2468132675,
-0.203874439,
0.0439501144,
-0.026018925,
0.7384830713,
-0.1475655735,
0.2500142157,
0.0567647517,
-0.255874604,
-0.3758972883,
0.3210240006,
0.2394257337,
0.0448353179,
-0.1123316661,
0.114398323,
0.5838480592,
-0.4102337956,
0.1882799268,
-0.1944941878,
-0.1593452096,
-0.0322510526,
0.3157111406,
0.9868050218,
0.7313361764,
-0.3053452373,
0.4734949768,
0.1420710981,
0.2211401165,
0.3980000019,
0.0517519861,
0.432931006,
0.6280904412,
0.1037016958,
0.4999244809,
0.239076823,
-0.147075966,
0.0416682884,
0.1001071408,
-0.7159638405,
-0.3209454119,
1.1779768467,
0.5632479787,
-0.478107214,
0.3199544549,
-0.1383863688,
-0.4497354627,
0.4534000456,
0.6722028255,
0.9702869654,
-0.5079152584,
-0.1520489305,
0.4484632015,
0.6442529559,
-0.0534336194,
-0.1008818075,
-0.244906798,
-0.2933341563,
-0.5765123367,
-0.6234862208,
-0.370434165,
0.1156735048,
-0.6765465736,
0.5667108893,
0.0440539606,
0.0370840393,
-0.2118544281,
-0.2518077195,
-1.0920357704,
0.2905959785,
-0.0260676332,
0.8184044957,
-0.7908576727,
0.9870706797,
0.8343847394,
-0.3891281486,
-0.4486559927,
-0.0450384244,
-0.4817792773,
-0.7458687425,
0.9200498462,
0.1763902456,
-0.4686337709,
0.5264843106,
-0.037691582,
-1.1031355858,
1.0593096018,
0.7155251503,
-0.9389363527,
-0.1931000054,
0.1958917826,
0.5494111776,
-0.1868900061,
0.1066039056,
0.3635679185,
0.4131579697,
-0.0929124877,
-0.7624800205,
0.0735097304,
-0.2233964354,
0.2393828779,
0.3426216543,
-1.1225020885,
0.4737853706,
-0.2458870858,
-0.2381380498,
-0.2210775614,
0.7523459196,
-0.2419482768,
0.1851131618,
0.4441780746,
0.5750878453,
0.1531272233,
-0.0140444301,
0.8851268888,
-0.679060638,
0.5088351965,
1.1317974329,
-0.0496121645,
0.7307004929,
0.5837105513,
-0.0549651906,
-0.1013646126,
0.2483202219,
-0.1833058894,
0.9276390672,
-0.2087933868,
-0.0732287914,
-0.312161833,
-0.4219949543,
-0.3147317171,
0.4353177845,
-0.0022776215,
-0.5553721786,
-0.2912315428,
0.2927122116,
-0.3315123022,
0.1765123308,
-0.2808556557,
0.6730738878,
0.0994279906,
-0.3617072105,
0.5602769852,
0.0975075662,
0.4612181485,
-0.3105994761,
0.0185166188,
-0.2693790793,
0.4963019192,
-0.126927048,
-0.3623336554,
0.4247849286,
0.2449987084,
-0.6172047257,
-0.4348758161,
0.5241125226,
-0.4904845059,
-0.3828246295,
0.5416610837,
0.4335975051,
-0.1235693768,
-0.1313774139,
-0.6695776582,
0.201562807,
0.0808857605,
-0.4041969478,
0.176983878,
0.5516709685,
-0.0529144667,
0.5480523109,
0.3695475459,
-0.150322035,
0.0779696703,
-0.1047745794,
0.7867295742,
-0.7835717797,
-0.5086342096,
-0.8190766573,
0.4560868442,
0.0621061102,
-0.1362990439,
0.6205245852,
0.8055759072,
0.6300423741,
-0.3770677149,
0.5873565674,
0.0384882838,
0.3732799888,
-0.2014493942,
0.6854675412,
-0.4844728708,
-0.0118521256,
0.0098864837,
-1.4153698683,
-0.0889378935,
0.5489732027,
-0.2026383132,
-0.3723326623,
0.8538328409,
0.5618225932,
-0.4740010202,
-0.397244215,
0.5097337961,
0.3100553453,
-0.0211509243,
1.0498427153,
0.4713838696,
-0.9042479396,
1.0053715706,
-0.2111280262,
-0.1456570476,
-0.4177918732,
-0.3883064985,
-1.0276255608,
-0.3383067846,
-0.343686372,
-0.1616887599,
-0.1596657038,
0.9190815687,
0.3204422295,
-0.6479900479,
0.0361097232,
0.0647523254,
-0.0414220914,
-0.3122910559,
-0.1527529657,
0.4519533813,
-0.4981844127,
-1.2062659264,
0.6092661023,
0.8781183958,
-0.1620435864,
-0.0961794704,
-0.1320340484,
-0.1998538524,
-0.1927217096,
0.5409764051,
-0.080467321,
-0.6841289997,
-0.0898310766,
0.3628396988,
-0.610396266,
0.3124756217,
0.5433143377,
-0.5292335153,
0.2424166501,
0.5130884647,
1.1418622732,
0.5983905196,
-0.1131658331,
0.420856595,
-0.7327300906,
0.4507817626,
0.2365559936,
0.3412525654,
0.4066925645,
-0.4699053168,
0.8218982816,
0.0685615912,
-0.3063978851,
-0.534353435,
0.113766335,
-1.1101739407,
0.4344893992,
0.7664664388,
0.0215823855,
-0.6292800307,
0.1551269293,
-0.3401501775,
0.5096094012,
-0.3513971269,
0.888076067,
0.3242242932,
0.1383091807,
-0.2902721167,
-0.6854627728,
0.2032477558,
0.5642191172,
-0.6636148691,
-0.0434303991,
-0.1479491144,
-0.1129027829,
0.3591108322,
0.3029328585,
0.0169157702,
0.2125249207,
-0.1623549908,
0.1147072911,
-0.0893270224,
-0.3154331446,
-0.1092684343,
0.1251726002,
-0.2338555753,
-0.5943496823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00326v1 | Evaluating TCFD Reporting: A New Application of Zero-Shot Analysis to Climate-Related Financial Disclosures | 2023-02-01T09:11:05 | 2023-02-01T09:11:05 | Alix Auzepy, Elena Tönjes, David Lenz, Christoph Funk | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | We examine climate-related disclosures in a large sample of reports published
by banks that officially endorsed the recommendations of the Task Force for
Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). In doing so, we introduce a new
application of the zero-shot text classification. By developing a set of
fine-grained TCFD labels, we show that zero-shot analysis is a useful tool for
classifying climate-related disclosures without further model training.
Overall, our findings indicate that corporate climate-related disclosures grew
dynamically after the launch of the TCFD recommendations. However, there are
marked differences in the extent of reporting by recommended disclosure topic,
suggesting that some recommendations have not yet been fully met. Our findings
yield important conclusions for the design of climate-related disclosure
frameworks. | [
-0.200982824,
-0.8176714778,
0.4958500266,
0.2995888889,
-0.3664708436,
0.1922718287,
0.0163337924,
-0.7729985714,
0.1667175144,
0.8511626124,
-0.3277227283,
-0.6823262572,
-0.5892084241,
-0.3208931983,
-0.5300263166,
1.2961959839,
0.0302273203,
-0.1082502007,
0.0390062742,
0.108508572,
-0.686080873,
-0.3107866049,
-0.5592685342,
-0.1878435761,
0.5660446286,
0.7318126559,
0.3503349125,
0.3963786364,
0.6557245255,
0.1611246467,
-0.1550117731,
-0.64990592,
-0.303374052,
0.0012070321,
-0.2180621326,
-0.0860971585,
-0.3338170052,
0.4578216672,
0.4033234417,
0.5963312387,
-0.1507530063,
0.470393151,
-0.1301443577,
0.5134026408,
-1.179653883,
0.3801744282,
-0.0997136682,
0.2510763109,
-0.0580845177,
-0.4451751411,
-0.6055935621,
0.1056226715,
0.7055423856,
-0.1508129835,
0.7864360809,
0.1811304092,
0.2705344856,
-0.1075356752,
-0.7702016234,
-0.3266542256,
-1.0545625687,
0.5999532938,
-0.3669666946,
0.1695061773,
0.0527467988,
0.319140017,
0.3168466389,
-0.2355708629,
-0.3878268301,
-0.1422459334,
0.0551023185,
0.169498086,
-0.3602898717,
0.0567720458,
-0.0308278725,
0.3929086328,
-0.6193559766,
0.0560509451,
-0.2704941332,
-0.3252719641,
0.5351989865,
-0.0187548734,
-0.2555884421,
0.0626926869,
-0.4816006124,
-0.4438904524,
-0.372739315,
0.0091073047,
0.0563564599,
0.650693059,
-0.4710233212,
0.2889997661,
-0.4913061261,
0.6736727953,
0.0458135568,
-0.1526035666,
0.0663630217,
-0.4466047883,
-0.5680644512,
0.831620574,
0.1587465703,
0.8094456196,
-0.1420808136,
-0.3602471054,
-0.1423503608,
-0.2471933067,
-0.1208576187,
-1.0983331203,
-0.1360510588,
0.0213185009,
-0.3828555048,
-0.7587857842,
0.4415165186,
-0.655557394,
-0.5462075472,
0.0532758832,
0.2171230763,
0.1615515649,
-0.3621761501,
0.0661670789,
-0.9587869048,
0.3613423109,
0.5953335166,
-0.6040574908,
0.1911074817,
0.6415510178,
0.8369355798,
0.0633185804,
0.044486165,
-0.5888888836,
0.4177561104,
-0.4036946595,
1.328866601,
-0.718622148,
-0.647254467,
-0.0502561294,
0.0439287946,
0.2356258929,
-0.3833409548,
0.2081567496,
-0.4074435532,
0.1696298718,
-0.3861727417,
-0.2503465712,
-0.3183976114,
0.0690559372,
-0.3074099422,
0.5521218777,
0.6998211741,
-0.6821997762,
0.8428611755,
-0.8736050129,
-0.0620141327,
0.2061161548,
0.1601837128,
-0.2665573955,
0.0023306925,
-0.2754983902,
0.4721504152,
-0.4924634099,
0.1406548172,
-0.5042442679,
-0.2925212085,
0.0847427249,
-0.5454524755,
0.7101870179,
0.2321826965,
-0.5048031211,
0.1682597101,
-0.6321558952,
0.0187538955,
-0.276411742,
0.1766335368,
-0.2625276744,
-0.3969290555,
0.1700324118,
-0.0404227749,
0.2231303453,
-0.6804234982,
-0.1138471365,
-0.1135651842,
0.2010327727,
0.6940432191,
0.3840300143,
0.4308552444,
-0.2742250264,
0.8120316863,
0.342131108,
-0.0575279556,
-0.5333699584,
-0.0299171247,
-0.6924173832,
-0.0004180032,
0.3068411052,
0.6788973212,
-0.3410333395,
0.1337041557,
0.2261446118,
-1.0203818083,
0.2018158734,
-0.2109375447,
0.3597972989,
0.8786114454,
0.1885262579,
-0.4290128946,
-0.153203994,
-0.7702870965,
-0.0696842447,
-0.1929621547,
0.1477970779,
0.2211069018,
0.416211009,
0.1826980114,
0.905380249,
-0.8054255247,
-0.0543066747,
-0.0631747618,
0.4647322297,
0.2685055435,
0.4780088365,
1.2114192247,
-0.2879900038,
-0.5805978775,
0.1917932928,
-0.1018105969,
0.1266979277,
-0.0760033503,
-0.010757843,
0.2059138119,
0.2869096994,
-0.1221318394,
0.6613282561,
0.2514198124,
-1.0350136757,
0.4752559364,
-0.2814746201,
0.2942545414,
-0.546980381,
0.010552872,
0.3697397709,
-0.3629247248,
-0.6377817988,
-0.2337598056,
-0.0521325171,
-0.3472647071,
-0.363666445,
0.7277376652,
-0.2778483927,
0.0614792481,
-0.3852209449,
-0.0175354872,
-0.0411785878,
0.0876825303,
0.1014234275,
0.280323714,
0.9190400243,
-0.676155448,
0.4401649237,
0.0762446448,
-0.1183642223,
0.5648556352,
-0.2265578657,
0.1526958495,
-0.2428274602,
0.592025876,
-0.9052762389,
0.0078428611,
0.4593608081,
-0.174381569,
0.3852892816,
0.0780745074,
-0.1844368875,
-0.4100751579,
-0.6277022362,
0.2149903923,
0.0243935194,
-0.0981613472,
0.223350361,
0.1379576176,
-0.0830897838,
-0.3258930743,
-0.918939352,
0.0896351859,
-0.2043259442,
-0.2091249973,
0.4522482455,
-0.3225198686,
-0.2292090803,
0.2785971761,
-0.6171164513,
-0.2757762074,
0.338236481,
0.1463984549,
0.4019224346,
-0.425308466,
-0.3479851782,
-0.5071420074,
-0.3236254752,
0.1080879644,
-0.0819870532,
0.3555709422,
-0.119984746,
0.3036791682,
-0.5958737731,
0.313249737,
0.2015188336,
0.1034133285,
0.9019504786,
0.362347424,
-0.2950229645,
0.0298473407,
-0.4755555987,
0.1830820441,
-0.4511082768,
-0.0365013182,
0.2479385734,
-0.9714916945,
0.302674979,
0.1710159332,
0.0619920567,
0.8422797918,
0.2151793987,
-0.152007103,
0.465529412,
1.5486861467,
-0.0374598391,
0.7612006068,
-0.3411612511,
0.4125515521,
-0.251358062,
-0.5016892552,
-0.9380723834,
-0.0327216312,
-0.890889585,
-0.1107923239,
0.0769666508,
0.150545001,
-0.4452015758,
0.5402421355,
-0.6410784125,
0.6611955166,
0.3336374164,
-0.3715559542,
0.1374877989,
-0.1397909075,
0.1790805757,
0.490914017,
-0.3594621122,
-0.1876535714,
0.8077682853,
0.1232151762,
0.1719179899,
0.0183063038,
0.7382990718,
0.7691067457,
0.6942993999,
-0.7162079811,
0.2568821609,
-0.1894986928,
-0.7045026422,
-0.3206778467,
-0.3729531765,
-0.5418919921,
0.0393008292,
-0.0211125445,
-0.8712012172,
0.4620731771,
0.010782931,
-0.7646667361,
-0.04654295,
-1.0679551363,
0.8006598949,
-0.0773540586,
0.2269785851,
-0.4313096404,
-0.1518405229,
0.5429235697,
-0.3285366893,
0.0243999772,
-0.4358032644,
0.0104387477,
0.9252431393,
-0.4752685428,
0.7861577272,
-0.7136050463,
-0.2450162172,
0.5677976012,
-0.0418362655,
-0.0803459361,
0.1906355917,
-0.2244118303,
0.2241124362,
0.7433382869,
-0.5021532774,
-0.3508172929,
0.5621308684,
-0.3521928191,
-0.7296501994,
-1.3033082485,
-0.430010736,
-0.224770382,
0.3177061677,
-0.1081486642,
0.4814126492,
-0.4223649204,
0.3693971932,
0.023827251,
-0.1458131075,
0.872151792,
0.9636572003,
-0.1144953892,
-0.38783288,
0.668726325,
0.4097119272,
0.0793027803,
0.2768037021,
0.4349664152,
-0.0999655053,
-0.6115181446,
-0.0037481694,
-0.0208835918,
-0.3591577113,
-0.5494565368,
-0.0356342271,
-0.4880747199,
-0.8438078761,
-0.3702476621,
-0.1293010861,
-0.4319502413,
-0.2542094588,
-0.4537715614,
0.5433143973,
0.9535737634,
-0.102510944,
0.4884975255,
-0.7557358146,
0.2181133777,
-0.1348009408,
0.4212640822,
-0.1301670074,
-0.3334302306,
-0.5099023581,
0.1033930928,
-0.6387946606,
-0.8890419006,
0.4343883693,
0.205448702,
0.3772272468,
0.8834223747,
0.5867401958,
0.7710623145,
-0.0209251307,
0.9208943248,
0.675968349,
-1.1391177177,
0.6248878837,
-0.2906078994,
0.4409169853,
0.4941905141,
0.3004670441,
-0.7855846286,
-0.5091978312,
-1.0732519627,
-0.7790804505,
1.0969638824,
0.0529587157,
0.3285834491,
-0.0256752074,
0.4600111544,
0.125597775,
0.4406530559,
-0.1572726071,
-0.4594935179,
-0.1960624009,
0.5757521987,
-0.2479249537,
-0.496769309,
-0.0288494732,
-0.2476771176,
0.4206584692,
-0.0522419177,
0.1151373386,
0.3417471945,
0.4169675112,
-0.2195422202,
0.3157010376,
0.7079743147,
0.8920664787,
-0.6117101312,
0.0473304838,
-0.0206639394,
-0.4055334926,
-0.0066077122,
0.0219218973,
-0.1968033016,
-0.0036321227,
0.5802812576,
0.5477957129,
0.2545389831,
-0.4357330203,
0.4917848408,
-0.0763481483,
-0.3779082,
-0.1552376449,
0.2417627275,
-0.174459219,
0.276065886,
0.4437271655,
0.391695559,
0.4063614309,
-1.2317289114,
0.2694757283,
0.2432934791,
-0.9485512972,
-0.2930373251,
0.5247910023,
0.3048533797,
0.0189056396,
0.6010733247,
-0.1678711027,
-0.1920024157,
0.7818095684,
0.5454227924,
1.2200369835,
-0.2746953666,
0.8047391176,
0.1104454473,
0.0432977453,
0.214888081,
0.1205110103,
-0.609605968,
-0.6647658944,
-0.2099068761,
-0.611672461,
-0.5500298738,
-0.0519055538,
-0.6928766966,
0.3736675382,
-1.1262820959,
-0.2643897533,
0.5487521887,
0.1637036502,
-0.5646044016,
0.1954712272,
0.2576061785,
1.0830107927,
-0.6334974766,
0.6199486852,
0.1766644865,
-0.1695171297,
-0.3064040244,
0.0574093908,
0.3788001835,
-0.4894298613,
0.5445228219,
0.3401166201,
-0.2551669478,
-0.3066859543,
-0.6251118183,
-0.6648253798,
1.3642787933,
0.5856390595,
-0.4368969798,
0.3278715312,
0.0394386239,
0.3536075056,
-0.4973731041,
0.3734841943,
0.7464952469,
0.7735806108,
0.6078599095,
-1.0226328373,
-0.1342161447,
-0.0710702091,
-0.2486949265,
0.0730926171,
-1.0291124582,
0.1767374575,
-0.4141984284,
-0.2618865967,
-0.2120712847,
0.6879089475,
-0.1230923012,
0.980679214,
0.4996390343,
0.2513036728,
0.826149106,
-0.0910346135,
1.0958465338,
-0.2627947032,
0.4267756343,
1.0140858889,
-0.3889800608,
0.9913563728,
0.149174124,
0.1845874339,
0.3286665082,
0.8454944491,
-0.2959645391,
0.7466748953,
0.1229845434,
-0.4109689295,
0.1232080683,
-0.8938320875,
-0.2665113807,
0.5109550953,
0.01912155,
-0.1760441959,
-0.7196695805,
-0.0968836993,
-0.0859622285,
-0.4109589458,
-0.3506267667,
0.7768122554,
0.0708464384,
-0.2400455624,
0.0460584275,
0.3300879896,
0.6174480319,
-0.431134522,
0.0213227682,
-0.0108400658,
-0.0938562378,
-0.336968869,
-1.0224832296,
0.8371983171,
0.4204105139,
-0.2512652278,
-0.8860890865,
0.3611371815,
-0.1813602895,
-0.3928222358,
0.2084728777,
0.1324922144,
0.0113859912,
-0.2856867909,
-0.4777496755,
-0.3985419273,
0.0040450236,
-0.0810204521,
0.2965175807,
0.4617972672,
0.0293369275,
0.381709069,
0.6390969157,
-0.2310799211,
-0.2827437222,
0.048901502,
0.62460953,
-1.3629082441,
-0.339908421,
-0.6372501254,
0.1923325807,
0.0530224554,
-0.4833331108,
0.6517595649,
0.8586414456,
0.7293711305,
0.0092123384,
0.5074455738,
-0.2604257166,
0.0573520362,
-0.4857244194,
0.6255570054,
-0.0925965905,
0.2829068601,
-0.2398061752,
-1.1970328093,
-0.3683402538,
0.1286658049,
-0.3727172911,
0.1102334708,
0.9188242555,
0.5170989037,
0.285492152,
0.2682524323,
0.4493606091,
0.3614711761,
0.4184021354,
-0.2086027563,
0.3693267405,
-0.1340235174,
0.6084988713,
-0.8307629824,
-0.0550070032,
-0.2920522392,
-1.2760977745,
-0.5024890304,
-0.5205462575,
-0.9922139049,
-0.1759742349,
-0.2775470614,
0.3278434277,
0.6164419055,
-0.9231249094,
-0.1669358909,
0.0251209773,
-0.0764331743,
-0.0444535576,
-0.3871790767,
0.3671520352,
0.1152418703,
-0.4726839662,
0.3067528903,
0.6959005594,
0.3367381394,
-0.0985288173,
0.1786909997,
0.2522716522,
0.1326873004,
0.5322594643,
0.2172005177,
-0.3515994847,
-0.5942314267,
-0.1184943318,
0.1864922047,
-0.0170698203,
0.9975624084,
-0.6441886425,
0.174129501,
0.5743939281,
0.2391103357,
0.7760517597,
-0.1789722741,
0.4648166001,
-0.5123208165,
0.2721276879,
0.0241030827,
0.0154144,
0.014432108,
-0.6679471135,
0.3503136635,
0.1359260082,
-0.1275731027,
-0.7159669399,
-0.4576755464,
-1.4336696863,
-0.3480318189,
0.8597444892,
-0.0068954094,
-0.5336494446,
-0.009128808,
-0.1647271514,
-0.0984347388,
-0.8011342883,
0.464381814,
1.0864340067,
-0.3380550146,
-0.1735592782,
-0.7407538295,
0.2113883495,
-0.1540074795,
-0.4220135808,
0.4126664996,
0.5220391154,
0.6082761884,
0.2030209899,
0.9197466969,
0.0489586145,
0.4070518315,
-0.0420722663,
-0.3431710601,
-0.0235447567,
-0.4059334397,
-0.3769099116,
0.1753580719,
0.0132041713,
-0.0781661049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00321v1 | An Evaluation of Persian-English Machine Translation Datasets with Transformers | 2023-02-01T08:55:08 | 2023-02-01T08:55:08 | Amir Sartipi, Meghdad Dehghan, Afsaneh Fatemi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Nowadays, many researchers are focusing their attention on the subject of
machine translation (MT). However, Persian machine translation has remained
unexplored despite a vast amount of research being conducted in languages with
high resources, such as English. Moreover, while a substantial amount of
research has been undertaken in statistical machine translation for some
datasets in Persian, there is currently no standard baseline for
transformer-based text2text models on each corpus. This study collected and
analysed the most popular and valuable parallel corpora, which were used for
Persian-English translation. Furthermore, we fine-tuned and evaluated two
state-of-the-art attention-based seq2seq models on each dataset separately (48
results). We hope this paper will assist researchers in comparing their Persian
to English and vice versa machine translation results to a standard baseline. | [
-0.3169070482,
-0.4146200418,
0.535517931,
0.2199741751,
-0.1659130603,
0.2576121092,
-0.5386957526,
-0.1783145517,
-0.0364637822,
0.4980718195,
-0.4334286749,
-0.3842905164,
-0.8267218471,
0.6133949757,
-0.7485517859,
1.0408093929,
-0.254581362,
0.2442141175,
-0.2408299744,
-0.4490219951,
-0.585272491,
-0.3259957135,
-0.3881231248,
0.0330942683,
0.2397742718,
0.7400496602,
1.0718034506,
0.3508060575,
0.9646522403,
0.2956574559,
0.0463498384,
0.3604518473,
-0.538280189,
0.1407785714,
-0.4360477924,
-0.2968840897,
-0.3563096821,
-0.1160142049,
0.7341250181,
0.6873380542,
0.2231471539,
0.6123149395,
0.2086134553,
0.8641598225,
-0.4547098577,
-0.1378560513,
-0.5400773883,
0.2372246832,
-0.4348567128,
-0.0414207578,
-0.53761518,
-0.3888350427,
-0.1833094805,
-0.4314307868,
0.0833600536,
0.3915560246,
0.7726777792,
0.4393629134,
-0.6665601134,
0.0075456151,
-1.1365386248,
1.2370493412,
-0.3442635834,
0.4236963689,
0.0672424361,
0.568200469,
0.0741345063,
-0.6771656275,
-0.3482477367,
0.010608851,
-0.4568009079,
0.354260087,
-0.590492785,
-0.6461759806,
0.2462130934,
0.5257616639,
-0.9409780502,
-0.0206520464,
-0.6322262883,
0.2905607224,
0.3935358822,
0.3153112829,
0.3694737256,
-0.143972978,
-0.4809640646,
-0.263389945,
-0.4985734224,
-0.1675395072,
0.0835496187,
0.0585098006,
-0.1146023497,
0.9171136022,
-0.1990103722,
0.2760232091,
0.1818471402,
0.2597498894,
0.4627964199,
-0.4738028347,
-0.2111133635,
-0.2744046152,
1.026930213,
0.4701417685,
0.3686083853,
-0.4979736209,
-0.1193634719,
0.1479962766,
0.3607530594,
-0.6709073782,
0.1097383648,
0.3619826436,
-0.5547223687,
-0.1638573706,
-0.1883167028,
-0.7554074526,
-0.1143545136,
-0.3493085206,
0.2309767753,
-0.3441819251,
-0.3233016133,
-0.1016109437,
-0.0985905156,
0.150573507,
-0.0795468763,
-0.4012815356,
0.6526656151,
0.595954597,
0.742767632,
-0.7419651747,
-0.1400344074,
-0.1461672336,
-0.0013606731,
-0.4475332499,
0.9150646329,
-0.4275339246,
-0.117058605,
-0.2338939309,
0.34779948,
-0.325285852,
-0.5839042664,
1.0860261917,
-0.3831089139,
0.6106513739,
-0.0674189627,
-0.3324891627,
-0.1957336962,
0.0556736588,
-0.5641273856,
1.1334912777,
0.2832255363,
-0.911288321,
-0.113395296,
-0.4640400708,
-0.5291208625,
-0.0303497333,
0.0053016422,
-0.5917226076,
0.3293685615,
0.3850835264,
0.4605504572,
-0.8609073162,
0.4723434746,
0.0780998245,
-0.4075133801,
0.4577198327,
-0.427418977,
0.6114058495,
0.5690606236,
-0.3664927781,
0.1185134426,
-0.6179699898,
0.0809635147,
0.150911957,
0.4267704487,
-0.3560943604,
0.1167288572,
0.456935972,
0.4168878794,
0.2420580238,
-0.4782519937,
-0.3424661756,
-0.4231107235,
0.3039896786,
0.2048539668,
-0.1818362623,
0.5218487382,
-0.204295069,
0.6048424244,
0.0302995257,
0.0599565245,
0.133372739,
-0.4072096944,
-0.6703564525,
-0.0923256129,
0.5195833445,
0.7248680592,
-0.59232831,
0.2525711656,
-0.5638824701,
-0.6904739141,
-0.7383184433,
-0.1444779783,
0.4567574859,
0.3302758038,
0.6658372283,
-0.3541263938,
-0.5442376137,
-1.4107820988,
-0.5386748314,
0.3329292238,
-0.2277622521,
0.3135141432,
0.2617756724,
-0.185973078,
0.5791032314,
-0.2145311087,
-0.2489178628,
-0.4932257533,
-0.0502324738,
0.4092846513,
0.4135167301,
0.4558686614,
-0.6752378941,
-0.8851242661,
0.2563132644,
-0.7213472128,
-0.019104464,
-0.1386333257,
-0.3779041767,
0.1496426761,
0.3202122152,
-0.5230193734,
0.2854907811,
0.7754781246,
-0.2347244918,
0.2097036541,
0.017535273,
0.5999789834,
-1.3278067112,
0.51711303,
-0.1515881568,
-0.4478905797,
-0.673388958,
0.0318051055,
0.5306905508,
-0.1252409667,
-0.4594016075,
0.3746278882,
-0.4670523107,
-0.3694649041,
-0.2495920062,
0.1677628309,
-0.1605522782,
0.4616436064,
0.0675331876,
1.1225339174,
0.3443190157,
-0.3475221097,
0.1761416495,
0.5953050256,
-0.2348545492,
0.580286324,
-0.846162498,
0.1854247302,
0.0982215106,
-0.0729598179,
-0.9407458305,
-0.0716308132,
0.2308781594,
-0.6721968055,
0.2191683203,
0.1071583405,
-0.5996330976,
-0.4351962507,
-0.1880545616,
0.3369836211,
0.837808609,
-0.2634404004,
0.3158089519,
0.4220711887,
-0.4325256348,
-0.3701563179,
-0.586594224,
0.2914581299,
-0.4326089621,
-0.4873025119,
0.3402774036,
0.1861510575,
-0.3282099068,
0.1015454233,
-0.1755349934,
-0.0800034329,
0.1035876423,
0.2004201114,
0.266254425,
-0.2576372921,
-0.0680690408,
0.232278809,
-0.3422117829,
0.1086203754,
-0.1310471445,
0.3114736378,
-0.0434242338,
-0.0345463529,
-0.2688748837,
0.3802922964,
0.5618926287,
-0.5397992134,
0.8735048771,
0.6107051373,
-0.3065559268,
0.0800481215,
-0.3550629914,
-0.0271911714,
-0.3786215484,
0.5341534019,
-0.3342113793,
-0.6350186467,
0.0658890828,
-0.2367269695,
0.0463522114,
0.9597821832,
0.8975178003,
-0.1487439275,
1.2856925726,
0.4074851573,
-0.0260623731,
-0.0930346772,
0.1419388354,
0.209553808,
-0.8556807041,
0.0428889506,
-0.8283880353,
-0.3537293375,
-0.7146548033,
-0.5160033107,
0.42708233,
-0.1362935156,
-0.2433769554,
0.7905315161,
-0.5350059867,
0.4297171831,
0.4496205747,
-0.1688439548,
0.3352161646,
0.2930149734,
0.0628124848,
-0.1553345472,
-0.438441962,
-0.7227375507,
1.3963829279,
0.2047327906,
0.3329131901,
0.2427582145,
0.1112072468,
0.4055880606,
-0.0840159357,
-0.4676429629,
0.2737844586,
-0.514241755,
-0.4876101017,
-0.2601772845,
-0.4103350341,
-1.0389760733,
0.184908554,
-0.1133297533,
-0.2536554635,
-0.0118460907,
-0.2134487182,
-0.153825894,
0.0085779559,
-0.4980630279,
1.0554263592,
-0.2775213122,
-0.3711388111,
-0.5437511206,
-0.6646248102,
0.3162174225,
-0.2596496642,
0.302752316,
-0.1787810773,
0.0174129214,
0.6218791008,
-0.1970357746,
0.0894432589,
0.2602175474,
0.1154704317,
0.0162055418,
-0.0322036371,
0.4256763756,
-0.1058710888,
-0.0652597696,
0.2441574037,
0.0941739082,
-0.5330212116,
-0.2626836598,
0.6565213203,
-0.8758349419,
-0.3918793797,
-0.5175131559,
-0.5691527128,
-0.505828321,
0.1829895079,
0.2780090868,
0.1343799978,
-0.3816462457,
0.4249213934,
0.6014852524,
-0.3857631087,
0.1669216603,
0.5671433806,
-0.1653973609,
-0.4039711058,
0.5790733099,
-0.1471899599,
0.1948297024,
0.3724903762,
-0.1897367835,
-0.1796043813,
-0.1581865102,
-0.9877366424,
0.1719579101,
-0.212217018,
-0.3146710396,
-0.7434761524,
-0.3237841129,
-0.352231741,
0.2041084021,
-0.5416342616,
-0.8899896741,
0.0515857488,
0.1236739382,
0.3584400415,
0.608854413,
0.1217790842,
-0.0470009893,
-0.9110937119,
0.4806735218,
-0.097690545,
0.0549288131,
-0.3301892281,
-0.8172190189,
-0.5529885292,
-0.0428025983,
-0.3217556179,
-0.9780024886,
0.6038782001,
0.0177986082,
0.2855190337,
0.029606238,
0.0473523214,
0.5266726613,
-1.0593069792,
0.625061214,
-0.0469769575,
-0.7435495853,
0.4810799062,
-0.2490097731,
0.1751466393,
0.5139924884,
0.5187697411,
-0.8291077018,
-0.5694693923,
-0.4871513844,
-0.8018736839,
0.7868024111,
0.8258885145,
0.0880144015,
0.1724619716,
-0.1566314995,
0.1820402145,
0.1275752187,
-0.2945665717,
-0.5933601856,
0.0532625839,
-0.4706563056,
-0.3967594802,
-0.1138849407,
0.0247953665,
-0.1261608601,
0.7330912352,
0.3045170903,
0.3517485261,
-0.1180995628,
-0.3842290938,
-0.2888133526,
0.6125982404,
0.3461693525,
0.3583651781,
-0.1536387354,
0.065598011,
0.4314960241,
-0.4672971964,
0.0810445622,
0.2270036787,
-0.3419221044,
0.2933636606,
-0.1636070013,
0.7392789721,
0.1851845533,
-0.7200409174,
0.4793590903,
-0.1642979234,
0.0290759783,
-0.6487298608,
-0.2409624159,
0.129015848,
0.120136261,
0.213343218,
0.5793586373,
0.5246933699,
-0.2151304334,
0.0603172965,
0.1220649406,
-0.5263198614,
-0.3231536746,
0.7504570484,
0.1323433965,
0.0290055983,
0.4733233452,
-0.1210064739,
-0.5408092737,
0.6265573502,
0.4176584184,
0.9213231206,
-0.2145830244,
0.0474286191,
0.6266240478,
0.4989458919,
-0.2651345432,
0.1241772249,
0.2348127067,
-0.3383197486,
-0.3920014501,
-0.4667096436,
-0.5732674599,
-0.032515794,
-1.0158983469,
0.3789111078,
0.2828567326,
-0.1069585904,
-0.1782011837,
0.0044680601,
-0.8981455564,
0.1556310505,
0.0308675058,
0.7078673244,
-0.8549702764,
0.914183259,
0.8806425333,
-0.2136359215,
-0.4902873039,
-0.1562901586,
-0.1877070069,
-0.5662744641,
0.4774437547,
0.059209086,
-0.0323348008,
0.1568774879,
-0.1814825684,
-1.2459999323,
0.9637949467,
0.0485154018,
-0.7158665657,
0.3175233305,
0.650975883,
0.6917866468,
0.025621742,
0.5626636744,
0.6613833308,
0.4118277431,
-0.3895100057,
-0.9437266588,
-0.0355038308,
-0.4038285315,
0.1036736593,
0.3094865382,
-0.6770778894,
0.7042739987,
0.2965360582,
-0.4598048031,
0.3311651945,
0.6859718561,
-0.084653914,
0.2198685557,
0.2830958366,
0.5481987,
0.3901967406,
-0.0111862551,
0.9296050668,
-0.6317494512,
0.3919211924,
1.1793105602,
-0.3639421761,
1.1106927395,
0.2964190841,
-0.4834520519,
0.3968134224,
0.3036595583,
-0.2665191591,
0.4848738909,
0.0668927878,
0.1695411652,
-0.249063462,
-0.0945961699,
-0.4889511466,
0.1706934124,
0.3606363237,
-0.5026701093,
-0.1202550605,
0.0756512061,
0.155057624,
0.426097393,
-0.0983448327,
0.6974012852,
0.0283954982,
-0.8430474401,
0.4988822341,
0.3505910933,
0.385420084,
-0.0209471639,
0.2463977933,
-0.5031585097,
0.354057163,
-0.1335263401,
-0.7125100493,
0.6400831938,
0.6537705064,
-0.3250568211,
-0.4166662097,
0.658591032,
-0.4029483795,
-0.7887699008,
0.0883514881,
0.8229680061,
0.4858783484,
-0.148043409,
-0.5914800763,
-0.1755005419,
0.0226270631,
-0.1574487835,
0.1387612224,
0.5191830993,
-0.1716982275,
0.2598031759,
0.2846266627,
-0.1392759234,
-0.1198493689,
-0.1099724025,
0.6039181948,
-0.6867390871,
0.0634312034,
-0.5815757513,
0.5733026266,
-0.2698712647,
-0.2752184868,
1.2939944267,
1.0180835724,
0.757226944,
-0.2785185874,
0.773984313,
0.0169192422,
1.3417215347,
-0.2085537016,
0.6720794439,
-0.5272314548,
0.0725784227,
-0.1254738271,
-1.0117092133,
-0.1292688847,
0.3589994311,
-0.2828427851,
-0.3419067562,
1.0496306419,
0.747269094,
-0.2689210176,
0.0769634545,
0.3252565563,
0.3468331099,
-0.4791409969,
0.775993228,
0.874515295,
-0.8691843748,
0.7114911079,
-0.1930964589,
-0.0351814777,
-0.0243490301,
-0.3660402596,
-1.0037325621,
-0.4868422449,
-0.2340702713,
-0.2300477475,
0.3561182618,
0.7858381271,
0.1551065445,
-1.3655312061,
-0.2912977934,
0.050190717,
-0.2050983012,
-0.4243445694,
-0.0967604443,
0.6039193869,
-0.4378011525,
-1.0423523188,
0.3949366212,
0.1819901466,
-0.3402889073,
-0.060624823,
0.0154592944,
0.2187351882,
0.0555479825,
0.4556170702,
-0.0341777988,
-0.5285556912,
0.1464953572,
0.4756016135,
-0.5452237129,
0.1693891138,
0.4921301007,
-0.9095365405,
-0.0752527863,
0.3949375153,
0.5924206972,
0.3946984112,
0.0639794022,
0.6238595247,
-0.5966764688,
0.000677578,
0.0707899854,
0.2563557029,
0.3757927418,
-0.1373521239,
0.906611383,
0.0254025087,
-0.7341319919,
-0.6494618058,
0.0194685496,
-0.7073758245,
-0.2372459471,
1.1494169235,
-0.0898871422,
-0.0514976121,
-0.0272679199,
-0.2750025392,
0.3420810699,
-0.1130137593,
0.4948720038,
0.4817387462,
0.3406392336,
-0.0630855337,
-0.8166950941,
0.415561378,
0.9103198051,
-0.7439191937,
-0.1087970808,
0.3201088011,
-0.0103944791,
-0.0257238112,
0.0542737469,
-0.2679106593,
0.2918410003,
-0.225287497,
0.0432703383,
0.314134419,
-0.2550342977,
-0.3180961311,
-0.0422676541,
-0.1133410633,
-0.1016457081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00239v1 | Filtering Context Mitigates Scarcity and Selection Bias in Political Ideology Prediction | 2023-02-01T04:34:48 | 2023-02-01T04:34:48 | Chen Chen, Dylan Walker, Venkatesh Saligrama | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | We propose a novel supervised learning approach for political ideology
prediction (PIP) that is capable of predicting out-of-distribution inputs. This
problem is motivated by the fact that manual data-labeling is expensive, while
self-reported labels are often scarce and exhibit significant selection bias.
We propose a novel statistical model that decomposes the document embeddings
into a linear superposition of two vectors; a latent neutral \emph{context}
vector independent of ideology, and a latent \emph{position} vector aligned
with ideology. We train an end-to-end model that has intermediate contextual
and positional vectors as outputs. At deployment time, our model predicts
labels for input documents by exclusively leveraging the predicted positional
vectors. On two benchmark datasets we show that our model is capable of
outputting predictions even when trained with as little as 5\% biased data, and
is significantly more accurate than the state-of-the-art. Through
crowd-sourcing we validate the neutrality of contextual vectors, and show that
context filtering results in ideological concentration, allowing for prediction
on out-of-distribution examples. | [
-0.5206262469,
-0.3926631212,
0.5149654746,
-0.1879516989,
-0.4524800181,
-0.0625878423,
-0.0637756139,
-0.0644144788,
0.5227484107,
0.7525246143,
-0.6835922003,
-0.6862980127,
-0.9199160933,
-0.4137613773,
-0.4112446606,
1.0669153929,
0.4948243797,
0.2298731357,
-0.328486681,
-0.3252875209,
-0.2892689705,
-0.5854311585,
-0.152145505,
-0.5363596082,
0.2681312561,
0.3664258718,
0.6281801462,
1.0029511452,
-0.0763643309,
0.1254594028,
-0.0537318252,
-0.2286783457,
-0.5468723178,
0.3260999918,
-0.4223428965,
-0.3831518888,
0.2264581025,
0.4598334432,
0.4053280354,
0.4473996162,
0.0333618373,
-0.1384028941,
0.222160995,
0.6031326056,
-0.9812477827,
-0.0424983166,
-1.166744113,
-0.0313497186,
-0.3637646735,
-0.0349542648,
-0.6500586271,
-0.1102033183,
0.150200218,
-0.4701858759,
0.079826206,
0.0565497018,
0.6037572622,
0.3849416077,
-0.65877074,
-0.4223254621,
-0.3760675788,
0.9429420829,
-0.139245078,
0.1904265285,
0.5766913295,
0.125799194,
-0.0675135478,
-0.4488067031,
-0.4254074693,
0.3179268241,
-0.1378891021,
0.25153175,
0.095254384,
-0.0802338645,
-0.2039420903,
-0.2133544832,
-0.1232319623,
0.0332225934,
-0.3423481584,
-0.049509421,
0.4612265229,
-0.2173497379,
0.0134724909,
-0.7481302023,
-0.7093961239,
-0.1127063036,
-0.5445600748,
-0.1787566692,
0.6205903292,
0.2231082618,
0.128064692,
0.4192155302,
-0.2356381565,
0.597979486,
0.1958419085,
0.2125622332,
-0.1342562139,
-0.2035736591,
-0.1187659502,
0.0503046773,
0.6908761859,
0.2665994167,
-0.1916739196,
0.3315989673,
-0.0424978249,
0.1201008186,
0.0127892839,
-0.7568476796,
-0.5220428109,
0.1928394884,
-0.627527833,
-0.4599651694,
0.0399337858,
-1.0264443159,
-0.8744391799,
-0.3048606217,
0.0694789067,
-0.3245953619,
0.0064629773,
-0.3982109725,
-0.3583280742,
-0.034916684,
0.1593087465,
-0.671531558,
-0.216433689,
0.7717866302,
0.8439521194,
-0.2191850245,
0.0960779116,
-0.6052763462,
0.1782356203,
-0.3543295562,
1.1217899323,
-1.2367887497,
-0.1890237033,
0.2043138295,
-0.2236411422,
0.2641891837,
-0.4264717102,
0.6562408209,
-0.5549756289,
0.4144370556,
-0.2871474624,
-0.7066425681,
-0.1051348597,
-0.0026224938,
-0.7505422831,
0.8423557878,
0.1122078523,
-0.9388551712,
1.0120586157,
-0.526224196,
-0.1422353834,
0.1257725507,
-0.2087845951,
-0.4477967322,
-0.2019327879,
0.4339116216,
0.7624845505,
0.1308249384,
0.5646480918,
-0.7538747787,
-0.2871996462,
0.0490981899,
-0.3287580907,
0.9745104909,
0.3158315122,
-0.3035029471,
0.3569211662,
-0.7672409415,
-0.2912323475,
-0.4904613197,
0.0040345816,
-0.8874030709,
0.5768049359,
0.0694016963,
0.4087792039,
0.1031257063,
-0.550051868,
0.2187017798,
-0.4569592476,
0.3973571062,
1.0793046951,
0.0863162205,
1.0121028423,
-0.0670174956,
0.1901450753,
-0.0060768826,
0.0324910805,
0.0078406865,
-0.4686995447,
-0.3290897906,
-0.515981257,
0.2469772995,
0.5370519757,
-0.8624850512,
0.627220273,
0.0531314388,
-0.485915333,
-0.1186226979,
0.050579071,
0.0615073405,
0.3361217678,
0.2745903432,
-0.0527856611,
-0.714895606,
-0.8758710623,
-0.5195296407,
-0.2093690783,
-0.1733293682,
0.1139561757,
0.7624433041,
-0.2655623853,
1.1247788668,
-0.5680450797,
-0.6594063044,
-0.1729970723,
0.2843798101,
0.185986504,
0.2838828564,
0.2782054245,
-0.8456466794,
-0.3477970064,
-0.0947467163,
-0.3492246568,
-0.1616649181,
-0.2074941844,
-0.4222622216,
0.30998227,
0.303491503,
-0.2005088478,
0.6185984015,
0.4863388836,
-0.6014959812,
-0.0299053881,
0.0115910424,
-0.2317327708,
-1.3423413038,
-0.1606515348,
0.2515383065,
-0.0896190777,
-0.4008576572,
-0.3915776014,
0.1097401679,
0.0196952485,
-0.5616435409,
0.5519677401,
-0.103899762,
0.0756297112,
-0.3086308539,
-0.0101080043,
0.0790686682,
0.2400361896,
0.3380574286,
0.4215370119,
0.2585970461,
-0.2244167775,
-0.0123720979,
0.2570811212,
-0.5903829932,
0.7203373909,
-0.2829946876,
-0.0630184337,
-0.4492788911,
0.7509480119,
-1.1608140469,
-0.4244893789,
0.3655774593,
-0.2238482833,
0.1019771397,
-0.4677429795,
-0.0368651114,
0.1309659779,
-0.2828683257,
0.0774599686,
0.3479570746,
-0.5982041955,
0.4814353883,
0.8105677962,
0.1992736459,
-0.9335095882,
-0.3171162009,
-0.3001486659,
-0.4600288272,
-0.152753219,
0.311347276,
0.2387053818,
-0.1730352938,
0.2513746917,
0.0555319935,
-0.213176474,
-0.1494739801,
0.2709113359,
0.2842174172,
0.3777767122,
0.434251219,
0.2859337926,
-0.0737439394,
0.1022586972,
-0.6511033177,
0.3387751281,
0.4722775221,
-0.1650287658,
-0.2974728346,
0.6723114848,
0.5492209792,
-0.0980552807,
1.1154665947,
0.5925776362,
-0.367991358,
-0.6171964407,
-0.4003606439,
-0.3642728925,
-0.3922554553,
0.5481496453,
0.1016701907,
-0.3405052423,
0.4260244966,
0.0191209558,
-0.038696792,
0.5346298218,
0.5337219238,
-0.118053697,
0.9793385267,
0.4761823416,
-0.1977639347,
0.7251998782,
-0.3748838603,
0.2166429907,
-0.4491269588,
-0.2386671454,
-0.493321389,
-0.3939065337,
-0.7030975819,
-0.4226820767,
0.413186878,
-0.1525329053,
-0.2356829196,
-0.0386267602,
-1.0831753016,
0.7029788494,
0.6703048348,
0.0337814949,
-0.2381723374,
0.1228982359,
0.1575526297,
-0.2670066953,
-0.6671053171,
-0.3955463171,
1.4421499968,
0.1544333845,
0.5173268318,
-0.4431257546,
0.7291259766,
0.5391018391,
0.7690401673,
-0.5637731552,
0.2641913891,
-0.5173601508,
-0.8903756142,
-0.3538672328,
-0.2304621339,
-0.7322244644,
0.6392300725,
-0.4461299181,
-0.6561738253,
0.6258282065,
-0.0234963037,
-0.1118723378,
0.5748807192,
-0.3387715816,
0.7200778723,
0.0954428986,
-0.5375807285,
-0.280998379,
-0.6118750572,
0.2521698177,
-0.0706737712,
0.4043439329,
-0.332647115,
-0.1779549867,
1.1299971342,
-0.1759334803,
1.0276346207,
-0.524630487,
0.3412087858,
0.1345703304,
-0.3062486351,
0.5162588358,
0.0375309549,
-0.4356151819,
0.2659052908,
0.0786911398,
-0.4044019282,
-0.4801565111,
0.6801457405,
-0.948984623,
-0.5140761137,
-0.5624611378,
-0.5990794301,
0.1804826707,
0.0856267512,
0.6660176516,
0.4159141183,
-0.03138851,
0.7352629304,
0.6044206023,
-0.0876402408,
0.2536642253,
0.0901069045,
0.1286101192,
-0.6922948956,
0.6989244819,
0.7610917091,
-0.0689407215,
0.2902340889,
0.4656590223,
-0.6229484081,
-0.2602398694,
-0.1952790767,
-0.1526220292,
-1.0794883966,
-0.2460904568,
-0.6197875142,
0.0814048648,
-0.3269607425,
-0.4068625867,
-0.3777501583,
-0.2239412516,
-0.4334480464,
0.0878367797,
0.0863381103,
0.9643331766,
-0.0314503834,
0.3587898612,
0.0788635761,
0.0255274139,
0.0481197871,
0.3328939974,
-0.5459254384,
-0.4550410211,
-0.0873829797,
0.0691343918,
-0.5978345275,
-1.3882828951,
0.5820298195,
0.2284157723,
0.3744705915,
0.6709674597,
0.805365026,
0.3764117956,
-0.3238044083,
0.7875456214,
0.0076809828,
-0.9099459052,
0.7098478079,
-0.3386062682,
-0.14575468,
0.4527999163,
0.5961863995,
-0.0847312361,
-0.5942105055,
-0.574681282,
-1.0896517038,
0.7779501081,
-0.0325613916,
0.1792450249,
-0.1184546873,
0.2926736772,
0.381911248,
0.0841152221,
-0.7161534429,
-0.2266759872,
-0.585878551,
-0.1848541498,
-0.1370887756,
-0.3603710532,
-0.1281691343,
-0.3836906552,
0.8670763969,
-0.1903660297,
-0.0310778283,
0.154745996,
0.3614896238,
-0.0184303727,
0.2098364085,
0.4268994629,
0.6236299276,
-0.2034277171,
0.0549153611,
0.0486469977,
0.0148457382,
0.1688430011,
-0.1598784178,
-0.3954362273,
0.3522514701,
0.0311541464,
0.5313414335,
-0.0311261099,
-0.0186980907,
0.6093803048,
0.2885896862,
-0.1655828357,
-0.7427969575,
-0.2031794786,
0.0813541487,
0.1489114463,
0.4715104401,
0.4311290383,
0.253679961,
-0.4987681806,
0.5032817721,
0.8524640799,
-0.4881138504,
-0.0507021621,
1.0213048458,
0.3501985967,
-0.0678833723,
0.2820078433,
-0.168712303,
-0.6821687818,
0.4799622893,
0.2805372477,
0.7518485785,
-0.1830261797,
0.4344809353,
0.2782230079,
0.1077046841,
0.065666154,
-0.1567884237,
-0.199952051,
-0.6666889787,
-0.2528874278,
-0.5087374449,
-0.4455492496,
0.3351481855,
-0.655231297,
0.3294534385,
-0.3917357326,
-0.1725720018,
-0.108368434,
0.3753840625,
-0.4667626619,
0.1327535957,
0.06203302,
0.6824868917,
-1.3422833681,
1.1268876791,
0.5077049136,
0.1047372073,
-0.4599736333,
0.2280422151,
0.1145053878,
-0.5474522114,
0.7685112357,
0.2674924135,
0.1021005958,
-0.380851239,
-0.6001785398,
-0.9026628733,
0.6981436014,
0.4763569832,
-0.2292934954,
0.2277626693,
-0.2297970057,
0.0981134474,
-0.6570805311,
0.2156788111,
0.4159394205,
0.5032280087,
0.182165578,
0.0514154471,
-0.1640263945,
-0.1325667799,
0.0221371241,
0.1640410125,
-0.4254850745,
0.92771101,
0.4847206473,
-0.1917694062,
-0.2524579465,
0.751232326,
0.0859923586,
0.6205625534,
0.4939797521,
0.1405957192,
0.7753391862,
-0.1610364467,
1.0691908598,
-0.6034252644,
0.307104975,
0.8768660426,
-0.3313820958,
1.0145050287,
0.6605543494,
0.2408545315,
0.6939864159,
0.6931737065,
0.165564537,
0.8121741414,
-0.0570985898,
-0.1995790899,
-0.2701290548,
-0.4014751315,
-0.153967008,
0.5321959257,
0.4537473321,
-0.4797884524,
0.0819800124,
0.0647767335,
0.0928198993,
0.4535318613,
-0.1485096067,
0.6517992616,
-0.3192543387,
-0.9407289624,
0.4172908962,
-0.1646665335,
0.7625166774,
-0.4400698245,
0.0077907369,
-0.1060160026,
0.2591530681,
-0.2076377869,
-0.8571032286,
0.5485497117,
-0.3935564458,
-0.3894411027,
-0.5961399674,
0.9160038829,
-0.5982941985,
-0.4520057738,
0.41119802,
0.2328153998,
-0.0059040366,
-0.0838495791,
-0.4307981431,
0.122183226,
0.0419667885,
-0.5289306045,
0.411955893,
0.3088589311,
-0.1444606185,
0.5612623692,
0.747726202,
0.1993418336,
-0.3927075267,
-0.4482003748,
0.8937772512,
-0.1189660728,
-0.9436429739,
-0.8991991878,
0.421230495,
-0.4851040244,
-0.2095056176,
0.3816844523,
0.2891309857,
0.9161644578,
-0.0422368646,
0.9737555981,
0.1428597718,
0.4170423746,
-0.2988536954,
1.1832494736,
-0.4534394741,
0.2782544792,
-0.0384674221,
-0.7806398869,
-0.179241702,
0.7329294682,
-0.7686947584,
-0.242376402,
0.3538828492,
0.7556391954,
-0.0362269282,
-0.1610900015,
0.422460109,
-0.1056755409,
0.0891180709,
0.4090154767,
0.6443197131,
-0.0330223516,
0.627596736,
-0.5743657351,
-0.2838658988,
-0.185911119,
-0.8940718174,
-1.0215901136,
-0.9437273145,
-0.2142052203,
-0.3289351761,
0.0739944354,
0.8991008997,
1.2475376129,
-0.8061167002,
-0.1188026071,
0.1330324262,
0.587374568,
0.011044357,
-0.2581436634,
0.4589460194,
-0.2553097904,
-0.789863646,
0.0638790578,
0.1931610405,
-0.5656867623,
-0.4178604484,
-0.0645484403,
-0.2613735497,
0.4359163344,
0.4688679576,
-0.1902319342,
-0.9279720187,
-0.5495898128,
-0.3876834512,
0.006240278,
0.026352413,
0.5994517803,
-1.1469109058,
0.4882938266,
0.5711177588,
0.4861828983,
-0.0049757296,
0.2382582426,
0.442630291,
-0.9749379754,
0.4488670528,
0.270206213,
0.4810319543,
0.1842696667,
-0.5944471955,
0.3852992058,
0.3639309108,
-0.4914028645,
-0.7714959383,
0.469106704,
-0.3283159733,
-0.6510384083,
1.08951509,
-0.0688182637,
-0.4042876661,
-0.3270195127,
-0.2692516744,
0.4382823408,
-0.6401103735,
0.7395213246,
0.6460167766,
0.1820844859,
-0.146338135,
-0.5319091678,
0.4499075711,
0.3585988283,
-0.3704402745,
0.0647200495,
0.4543194175,
0.2486700118,
0.0418506674,
0.5030257702,
0.3828918934,
0.0438711978,
0.0118513908,
-0.1666173786,
0.0693937168,
-0.3030303419,
-0.2429800034,
0.7790975571,
-0.4545932412,
-0.3394293189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00200v1 | A Transaction Represented with Weighted Finite-State Transducers | 2023-02-01T03:05:14 | 2023-02-01T03:05:14 | J. Nathaniel Holmes, Homayoon Beigi | cs.FL | cs.FL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, math.RA | Not all contracts are good, but all good contracts can be expressed as a
finite-state transition system ("State-Transition Contracts"). Contracts that
can be represented as State-Transition Contracts discretize fat-tailed risk to
foreseeable, managed risk, define the boundary of relevant events governed by
the relationship, and eliminate the potential of inconsistent contractual
provisions. Additionally, State-Transition Contracts reap the substantial
benefit of being able to be analyzed under the rules governing the science of
the theory of computation. Simple State-Transition Contracts can be represented
as discrete finite automata; more complicated State-Transition Contracts, such
as those that have downstream effects on other agreements or complicated
pathways of performance, benefit from representation as weighted finite-state
transducers, with weights assigned as costs, penalties, or probabilities of
transitions. This research paper (the "Research" or "Paper") presents a complex
legal transaction represented as weighted finite-state transducers.
Furthermore, we show that the mathematics/algorithms permitted by the algebraic
structure of weighted finite-state transducers provides actionable, legal
insight into the transaction. | [
-0.1293228418,
-0.2495671213,
0.8549499512,
0.0971098915,
-0.2586484253,
0.0900255144,
0.2588323057,
-0.6815791726,
0.3616264462,
0.4962548018,
-0.0814023837,
-0.1702244729,
-0.7229908109,
-0.2620574832,
-0.7236163616,
1.2267382145,
-0.1972202063,
0.0054709921,
-0.0689452514,
0.0661220476,
-0.3788168132,
-0.3580901623,
-0.4352924824,
-0.6400607228,
0.2659639418,
-0.2528261542,
0.8703184128,
0.4737001359,
0.3881494701,
0.2903647423,
0.0123165287,
-0.6615499258,
-0.1650010347,
-0.1322541684,
-0.2401576787,
-0.6449733377,
-0.3717030883,
0.3094188273,
0.6643320322,
0.8475006223,
-0.4038524926,
0.0480080061,
-0.3864571154,
0.7939302325,
-0.8074744344,
0.3067950904,
-0.1596437395,
0.1428983063,
-0.4281041026,
-0.251186043,
-0.591627717,
-0.5579365492,
0.0914904401,
-0.8751084805,
-0.35639745,
-0.1215757281,
0.6757099032,
0.4725969732,
-1.0341739655,
-0.3134057224,
-1.1295610666,
0.5173093677,
-0.2208802402,
0.4564684927,
-0.0579839833,
0.4892355502,
-0.1944172084,
-0.7316181064,
-0.2957243025,
-0.4819038212,
-0.3859213293,
0.076714918,
-0.5128017664,
0.2975703776,
0.4707069099,
0.3881369233,
-0.1835504621,
-0.2496507615,
-0.4369743466,
-0.620474577,
0.6676248312,
0.3277759254,
0.3833334446,
0.1256700456,
-0.31878227,
0.0287817121,
-0.4922970831,
0.2612154484,
0.5542855859,
0.1495964825,
-0.2747169137,
0.4992726743,
-0.0278168842,
0.8288280368,
0.0252455696,
-0.2350597531,
0.2859255075,
0.097620517,
-0.1847761571,
0.3658530116,
0.4341371953,
-0.0469561368,
0.4359844923,
-0.4587205052,
-0.3890878558,
-0.0090396376,
0.3552260399,
-0.5922214985,
0.1594478488,
0.1105225086,
-0.5204809904,
-0.0239384789,
0.4815407097,
0.0292914864,
-0.1885356456,
-0.4360173941,
0.7070781589,
-0.4046813846,
-0.3988228738,
0.5490627885,
-0.153011784,
0.4052629173,
0.1652272791,
-0.5665202141,
0.944437325,
0.7545480132,
0.7073646784,
0.1693784446,
0.1588464826,
-0.3409560919,
0.4247721136,
-0.4367954135,
0.5533691645,
-0.3058807552,
-0.5479251742,
-0.0942315534,
-0.2879072428,
-0.0179052409,
-0.0713751316,
0.2216801941,
-0.697717011,
-0.0847430453,
0.0291020628,
-0.7196321487,
-0.1069310308,
0.2231473178,
-0.9301823974,
0.1871069521,
0.305085659,
-0.4498854578,
0.3484861553,
-0.9508777857,
-1.0147783756,
0.1410582811,
-0.1915806681,
-0.1286021769,
0.1785327196,
-0.6543145776,
0.1051384881,
-0.3403660655,
-0.1262015998,
-0.0427747257,
-0.4639959633,
0.6219223142,
0.1815919876,
0.9869143963,
0.5533348322,
-0.2734324336,
-0.2879034877,
-0.6240562201,
-0.0680241287,
-0.0649021938,
-0.6607023478,
-0.5309271216,
-0.0849275365,
-0.1538943648,
0.064737767,
0.4649505913,
-0.8405932784,
0.2698475122,
-0.4062815309,
0.4419777393,
0.5508352518,
0.0079721157,
0.8482047915,
-0.167844519,
0.5815774202,
0.3556792736,
0.2101212442,
0.4314705431,
-0.2334467322,
-0.3994809091,
-0.0542830229,
0.6903380156,
0.6115010381,
-0.5144075155,
-0.0369651504,
-0.2784833014,
-0.3717970848,
-0.1545385569,
-0.6096270084,
0.2494468391,
0.1870411783,
0.0974897221,
-0.042275425,
-0.2392397672,
-0.9529477358,
-0.585442543,
-0.3834096789,
0.2527481318,
-0.2063779235,
0.4495245516,
0.2069864124,
0.6033607721,
-0.8022331595,
-0.2326151878,
0.3126030266,
0.4128527045,
0.5526910424,
0.7653023601,
0.5576661229,
-0.7892963886,
-0.4258989096,
-0.0602610298,
0.0003676366,
0.3962596953,
-0.6840084791,
-0.413767159,
-0.1638668031,
0.5091071725,
-0.8184072971,
0.3837563097,
0.0875548944,
-0.8375996351,
0.4614278972,
-0.3693151474,
0.2772177458,
-0.5866947174,
0.050765235,
-0.1399305761,
-0.3880296052,
-0.6856569648,
0.0034709482,
0.2752688825,
0.1593926102,
-0.261542201,
0.0895237699,
-0.4637988508,
-0.4641653299,
-0.1976256669,
-0.4916723669,
-0.4147459865,
0.205071345,
-0.2144450694,
0.6856531501,
0.6269444227,
-1.0193064213,
0.060406629,
-0.003911416,
-0.1678406298,
1.1052170992,
-0.3692156374,
-0.1173805073,
-0.1355971247,
0.2463199198,
-0.355109185,
0.288837105,
0.2664780915,
-0.3571887612,
0.2380923182,
-0.5078814626,
-0.2587651312,
-0.1209633201,
-0.0973735005,
0.6570588946,
0.4178114533,
0.28676489,
1.0773807764,
0.3721134067,
0.5003057122,
-0.5202127695,
-1.0536698103,
0.1948171556,
0.0523963533,
-0.2141901106,
0.6484417319,
0.2632640004,
-0.3036396205,
0.4408173263,
0.0636654198,
-0.1463588774,
0.3369733989,
0.5017106533,
-0.0992001668,
0.0039748857,
0.0087398002,
0.0909307748,
-0.511115253,
0.6953175068,
-0.7700639963,
0.2684818506,
0.1092319712,
-0.3727712929,
-0.2742983401,
0.2136340588,
0.7462901473,
-0.1572973877,
0.4111263156,
0.18387492,
-0.7020944953,
-0.1213713065,
0.1177369431,
0.2187633663,
-0.3670044243,
-0.203377828,
-0.7400076985,
-0.7001940608,
0.646402061,
-0.1866601408,
0.3901812434,
0.7535107136,
0.5696849823,
-0.1900785416,
0.6713649035,
0.4324177504,
0.288038969,
0.526211977,
-0.3644556701,
0.1057813093,
-0.5388556719,
-0.4704886079,
-0.4970912337,
-0.4922333658,
-0.6800798178,
-0.175119549,
0.6691839099,
-0.3907422423,
-0.7261723876,
0.6082075834,
-0.1853513867,
0.3927578032,
0.4656059742,
0.1836418062,
0.4264936745,
-0.2120993286,
-0.1687853485,
0.0946077853,
-0.1634827554,
-0.1019213125,
0.951259613,
0.2443031222,
0.9797087908,
0.66573596,
0.9241176248,
0.614107728,
0.1839835048,
-1.0030734539,
0.3062214851,
-0.0791117176,
-0.8413193226,
-0.408441633,
-0.7742198706,
-1.2486150265,
0.0115246531,
-0.2635289431,
-0.3445227444,
0.7246335745,
0.0524310917,
-0.6208897233,
0.1665881574,
-0.3195397556,
0.3864153326,
-0.1958888918,
0.1387087852,
-0.6559602618,
-0.4711084366,
0.5737136602,
0.0659103692,
0.2746056616,
-0.0560588315,
-0.4988892078,
0.8388483524,
-0.7727351189,
0.4025001824,
-0.4827697873,
-0.4407749176,
0.3723444045,
0.892611444,
0.4488842487,
-0.1058155224,
0.0564975999,
-0.2838772833,
0.3957752287,
-0.2778730094,
-0.5508969426,
0.2830452621,
-0.6046165228,
-0.1013299376,
-0.814512372,
-0.6214336753,
-0.2392435521,
0.2535840571,
0.0143245924,
0.2912281156,
-0.0117746135,
-0.3763225377,
0.5068487525,
0.3287230134,
0.1656649858,
0.8385778069,
0.2218776494,
-0.2349968851,
0.8609951735,
0.4781964421,
0.1556023955,
0.4313112199,
0.029574573,
-0.4412336051,
-0.6001334786,
-0.0368622616,
0.2235954851,
-0.7873188257,
-0.4990431666,
-0.2368092537,
-0.2007935792,
-0.2247952223,
0.0169503912,
-0.2858780921,
-0.744818151,
-0.1998645365,
-0.1899766326,
0.3119788468,
0.8181740642,
-0.4755837619,
0.0130432462,
-0.7309831977,
0.2735010386,
0.4704974592,
0.6201502681,
-0.071459122,
-0.4279957414,
-0.524268806,
-0.1973080188,
0.050261002,
-0.9936919212,
-0.2349196821,
0.2222858965,
0.6093953252,
0.2947613895,
0.3076111972,
0.543687582,
-0.3883809745,
0.2567255497,
0.4870089889,
-1.3924787045,
0.1383187473,
-0.2370210886,
0.0172109976,
0.5376979709,
0.3925299942,
-0.64854002,
-0.3293913007,
-0.5659928322,
-0.5375363827,
0.3664110899,
0.4173197746,
0.1409866661,
0.3525049984,
0.8434976339,
-0.404320538,
0.2500680983,
-0.7591866851,
-0.2371262908,
-0.1180563122,
-0.3138232827,
0.4721395969,
0.1451944709,
-0.4642287791,
0.0025504483,
0.4647833109,
0.1567067653,
0.3320790231,
0.2506839335,
-0.4372940063,
-0.2466320992,
0.2252388448,
0.5502538085,
0.721822083,
0.1651936173,
0.3842143118,
-0.1138933152,
-0.7365115285,
0.9044679403,
0.2255311906,
-0.4676088393,
-0.3834644556,
0.5469945669,
0.5101069212,
0.3615517616,
-0.2930420637,
0.4540240169,
0.0951036885,
-0.731939435,
-0.1514251083,
0.0481148288,
0.082161352,
0.3662640154,
0.564348042,
-0.1199359074,
0.6777830124,
-0.5231217742,
0.3355044723,
0.4101130962,
-0.4265953898,
-0.0453966521,
0.728420794,
0.3159005344,
0.0331835859,
0.424227953,
-0.1689486802,
-0.343342185,
0.6732982397,
0.2349323779,
0.62759763,
-0.0550606214,
0.4541468024,
0.2177388966,
0.6523004174,
-0.2161677927,
0.4718543291,
-0.1813568771,
-0.6195402741,
-0.7093127966,
-0.404102385,
-0.2903493643,
-0.5722417235,
-0.8843652606,
-0.1858761162,
-0.6485158205,
-0.5544039011,
0.0181286838,
0.0730228126,
-0.5019282699,
0.2017966062,
0.3563260734,
0.7571307421,
-0.8003908992,
0.5405176282,
0.7637101412,
-0.2904073298,
-0.7445063591,
-0.1489210278,
-0.133111164,
-0.7516262531,
0.6283481121,
-0.3851014972,
-0.3100122809,
0.1167580932,
-0.3581645191,
-0.9497939348,
1.0463614464,
1.042757988,
-0.6493829489,
0.0691712797,
0.4596433043,
0.3022403717,
0.1111369729,
-0.1935658008,
0.7112720609,
0.8434038162,
0.0084921932,
-0.7499411106,
0.3897618651,
0.2143955082,
-0.1034278423,
0.7713780403,
-0.5266512036,
1.212259531,
-0.1616934091,
-0.5076746345,
-0.2622851431,
0.7700840831,
-0.1522023976,
0.0807193741,
1.1441429853,
0.8615742326,
0.5266712308,
-0.3219604492,
0.9712274075,
-0.2320772409,
0.4998286664,
0.2526933849,
-0.1124851182,
0.3179381788,
0.3651595116,
-0.5639546514,
0.9510540366,
0.4594995081,
0.0933065787,
0.2742656469,
0.7203396559,
-0.1512404829,
-0.6794951558,
0.0065377597,
-0.0188537091,
0.2877651751,
0.1364860386,
-0.1881256998,
-0.2927614748,
-0.0439910889,
-0.1049611941,
0.1584964842,
-0.5033032894,
0.751081109,
0.3564798832,
-0.1414570957,
-0.0348757803,
0.1230428964,
0.446755439,
-0.9360040426,
-0.2180781811,
0.123913303,
-0.115828082,
-0.5769504905,
-0.9468358755,
0.3559679985,
-0.3111380935,
-0.187463969,
-0.5143600702,
0.3675560057,
-0.1847862154,
-0.5206256509,
0.1836200655,
0.0530053601,
0.2541738153,
-0.0113479802,
-0.8076084852,
-0.1528688967,
-0.4449523687,
-0.2365737557,
0.1004276052,
0.4125782251,
-0.2082383335,
0.4610463679,
0.314987421,
0.4029546678,
-0.0339610502,
0.0643297806,
0.5844255686,
-0.8996888399,
-0.9612439275,
-0.6879243851,
0.6923515201,
0.0770941749,
-0.0651974306,
0.1677036136,
0.6397971511,
0.4953500628,
0.2508792877,
0.5660822392,
-0.249307856,
0.1301089972,
-0.8774008751,
0.8095692992,
-0.302298665,
-0.076382868,
-0.1608477533,
-0.6061656475,
-0.2523753047,
0.5056222677,
-0.1910363734,
0.0757604465,
0.7578660846,
0.0752472207,
-0.0082797147,
-0.3673159778,
0.1999300271,
0.0681550652,
0.3143748939,
0.8815292716,
0.4567963183,
-0.5579526424,
0.7547197342,
-0.0920534059,
-0.0959396809,
-0.0376664139,
-0.5955424309,
-0.0948972926,
-0.9232573509,
-0.4854556322,
-0.6760305166,
-0.3118730187,
0.4836222827,
0.7059744596,
-0.6881977916,
-0.6862119436,
-0.0729613006,
0.2721566856,
-0.4014605284,
-0.1296290308,
0.1903634518,
-0.1899448335,
-0.4300281107,
0.0761629567,
0.0836434662,
0.5011206865,
-0.6428744197,
-0.3441383243,
0.0662974045,
0.3881835938,
0.4768905044,
0.5571886897,
-0.0378245972,
-0.0696079209,
-0.6630373001,
-0.4265089333,
-0.2753517628,
1.6281043291,
-0.383413136,
0.0367240161,
0.504109621,
0.6259487867,
0.8511218429,
-0.140584439,
0.8766480684,
-0.2583819926,
0.2870292068,
0.5029829144,
0.3586822152,
-0.1743565798,
-0.6916181445,
0.5767523646,
0.1083075106,
-0.10636314,
-0.5840555429,
0.4744052887,
-0.9729763865,
-0.4458892345,
0.5004825592,
0.0638344884,
-0.3653096557,
-0.2360169291,
0.3216350377,
0.1896825731,
-0.2248207629,
0.3371018767,
0.5563024282,
-0.4071748555,
0.2332890481,
-0.4181525409,
0.6131629944,
0.1954225004,
-0.6873843074,
-0.4129903615,
0.5220102668,
0.2726432979,
0.4608462453,
0.7985008955,
-0.3073587716,
0.5266730189,
-0.0782326311,
0.0037843077,
-0.2447473705,
-0.0385193452,
-0.4501594007,
0.2538142502,
0.0500510782,
-0.4574422836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.12038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.12038v1 | Grading Conversational Responses Of Chatbots | 2023-02-01T02:54:43 | 2023-02-01T02:54:43 | Grant Rosario, David Noever | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Chatbots have long been capable of answering basic questions and even
responding to obscure prompts, but recently their improvements have been far
more significant. Modern chatbots like Open AIs ChatGPT3 not only have the
ability to answer basic questions but can write code and movie scripts and
imitate well-known people. In this paper, we analyze ChatGPTs' responses to
various questions from a dataset of queries from the popular Quora forum. We
submitted sixty questions to ChatGPT and scored the answers based on three
industry-standard metrics for grading machine translation: BLEU, METEOR, and
ROUGE. These metrics allow us to compare the machine responses with the most
upvoted human answer to the same question to assess ChatGPT's ability to submit
a humanistic reply. The results showed that while the responses and translation
abilities of ChatGPT are remarkable, they still fall short of what a typical
human reaction would be. | [
-0.4452470839,
-1.0222783089,
0.2322851866,
0.2115202546,
0.0027782388,
0.1187228411,
-0.309286505,
-0.4815064371,
-0.0248975102,
0.3533393145,
-0.5215739608,
-0.1538430154,
-0.4815677702,
0.1890146434,
-0.4455754161,
1.4250938892,
0.2395910919,
0.0776555166,
-0.1733327359,
-0.2520997226,
-0.4861251414,
-0.6686724424,
-0.8603950739,
-0.2950602174,
0.5963021517,
0.2799642682,
1.0933215618,
0.1786085516,
0.8561375141,
0.3167092204,
0.0519317389,
-0.0412811525,
-0.5048418641,
-0.149090156,
-0.1111150905,
-0.6029088497,
-0.5480995774,
0.1085613519,
0.271483928,
0.5479063988,
0.1397447735,
0.4257106483,
0.2093269825,
0.847857058,
-0.1307078004,
0.1351480037,
-0.5393440723,
0.3070423603,
0.0600659959,
-0.257922858,
-0.4354522228,
-0.8883026242,
0.1231402606,
-0.5076087713,
0.3779401481,
-0.0397525653,
0.729747355,
0.3213338554,
-0.0063793166,
-0.3722842336,
-0.8888850212,
0.6127818823,
-0.444158107,
0.0286941864,
0.2323118299,
0.5547516942,
-0.016908126,
-0.4621176422,
-0.6801220775,
-0.3673779368,
-0.2042932808,
0.3939619064,
-0.4806244373,
-0.0504038781,
0.4546128809,
0.4834035039,
-0.8001045585,
0.0503836796,
-0.5202236176,
-0.2220883369,
0.5770040751,
0.2700382173,
0.3108956218,
-0.1306946129,
-0.2735195458,
-0.3174123764,
-0.3023643792,
0.1740240753,
0.3181776404,
0.0115170032,
0.031200394,
0.8330050707,
-0.3594670892,
0.5517248511,
-0.0212104935,
0.325979352,
0.0524581969,
-0.3427802324,
-0.2178426534,
-0.2263170183,
0.9479576945,
0.9152143002,
0.8991595507,
-0.1310341209,
0.1035751477,
0.1105512306,
0.5398430824,
-0.7105007172,
-0.2225597054,
0.2430684119,
-0.3504953682,
-0.1645211279,
-0.0179687869,
-0.8071017265,
-0.5862846375,
0.0535889082,
0.5371102691,
-0.2191784531,
0.0206301417,
0.0101976162,
-0.2360389829,
0.4631996155,
0.7766336203,
-0.4389123321,
0.1729101241,
0.4703133702,
0.9133267403,
-0.0537590161,
-0.2259971648,
-0.4781967998,
-0.3463230729,
-0.3329958022,
0.9624414444,
-0.2621052563,
-0.3627480865,
-0.0624509752,
-0.2263908982,
-0.151734367,
-0.5793827772,
0.5038564205,
-0.5798415542,
0.4853127301,
-0.0170324333,
-0.3541504741,
-0.3550417721,
0.4627690911,
-0.2268033177,
0.714964509,
0.3464236259,
-0.7732772827,
0.0679573119,
-0.9565290809,
-0.1509905457,
0.1909077168,
0.1559365094,
-0.0744548067,
-0.2125074714,
0.2546308935,
0.4219915569,
-0.270909369,
-0.1542896628,
-0.1733555943,
-0.2788974941,
0.9415059686,
-0.561363101,
0.523943305,
0.2869914174,
-0.1173480004,
0.2009515315,
-0.4453246593,
0.2992193401,
0.0207374562,
-0.3919976056,
0.2432335913,
-0.09828832,
0.0950330123,
0.4326241612,
0.1551964283,
-0.6150865555,
0.0982263386,
-0.4762178659,
0.5538267493,
0.8486098647,
0.020128902,
0.1497603506,
-0.6281036735,
0.6826030016,
-0.2341311574,
0.1021776795,
-0.0336203799,
-0.9034498334,
-0.8886333704,
0.0598677285,
0.0037015711,
0.7597843409,
-0.4142590463,
0.3900430799,
-0.553604722,
-0.8693971634,
-0.7218803167,
-0.0175608471,
0.3770402074,
0.5883304477,
0.3795767426,
-0.4916606247,
-0.0448933132,
-0.9598343968,
-0.6054044366,
-0.5828121901,
-0.566776216,
0.4238472879,
0.351937741,
0.1084161699,
0.7557965517,
-0.6005197167,
-0.2158496082,
-0.0303098522,
-0.1008067951,
0.2363746911,
0.174892053,
0.2712161541,
-0.6485105753,
-0.5407109261,
0.3616868258,
-0.6051489711,
0.142594859,
0.0417948626,
-0.1329329163,
-0.0146336956,
0.3939972222,
-0.7486081123,
0.3492811322,
0.3153815269,
-0.2216901183,
0.3673287928,
-0.1007735729,
0.4906581342,
-1.0343146324,
0.2805297673,
-0.060512431,
-0.4067007005,
-0.6566876769,
-0.0363631956,
-0.236300379,
-0.3576907516,
-0.609931469,
0.6842569709,
0.3752993345,
-0.2055690736,
-0.0473772027,
0.4988650978,
-0.3536234796,
0.7761021852,
-0.0884874612,
0.7835069299,
0.2901722193,
-0.6972630024,
0.6965028644,
0.4914934635,
-0.0357373953,
0.7183046937,
-1.0442099571,
0.5360751152,
-0.0893062726,
0.3772187829,
-1.3758856058,
-0.4567785263,
0.4922427833,
-1.1391986609,
-0.4226743579,
-0.3003581464,
-0.6702688932,
-0.5451194048,
-0.2116720229,
0.0579508692,
0.6648697257,
-0.1880296171,
0.2358059287,
0.1054970771,
-0.3427538872,
-0.2182941884,
-0.5555754304,
-0.044645492,
-0.2371709049,
-0.6673263907,
-0.0691959187,
-0.4988222122,
-0.2079941928,
-0.2823322713,
0.0750790387,
-0.1866487563,
-0.0172493048,
0.2104356587,
-0.0449604876,
-0.287463516,
-0.0004501697,
-0.4610881209,
-0.034170758,
0.086606279,
0.0205857344,
0.8870444894,
-0.4696008563,
-0.4370904267,
-0.3739646673,
0.0972149372,
0.6890279651,
-0.1706973165,
0.3531497121,
0.6826279163,
-0.1148035005,
0.4254330099,
-0.2616736591,
-0.1960979104,
-0.460465163,
0.2873757482,
-0.0327314995,
-0.9310739636,
0.518746376,
0.3264614046,
0.3263729215,
0.6257164478,
1.0096172094,
-0.2807393968,
1.2036119699,
0.108190611,
-0.0376692191,
0.2648483515,
0.0189036075,
0.3028859794,
-0.4556946754,
-0.2548235953,
-0.9284062386,
-0.4509625435,
-1.0964379311,
-0.3423029184,
0.3640263379,
-0.1824846715,
-0.2789026797,
0.4466718137,
-0.5860540867,
0.4286532998,
0.6841490865,
0.0179405101,
0.193413347,
-0.1885153204,
0.5247013569,
0.2417534292,
-0.4533093572,
-0.8382206559,
0.8326537609,
0.4151165783,
0.4727735519,
0.2416246235,
0.2303150594,
0.5271912217,
0.4247876108,
-1.0186418295,
0.6913144588,
0.0862575769,
-0.6966404915,
-0.3800584078,
-0.4773234725,
-1.068698287,
0.1148052886,
0.1125475094,
-0.8290631771,
-0.4825499058,
0.093113482,
-0.1285669655,
-0.0102748517,
-0.8602734804,
0.8262286186,
0.0127928024,
-0.0908744931,
-0.2531196177,
-0.8673490286,
0.0400578231,
0.0149884541,
0.2212071121,
-0.2481746078,
0.1615773141,
0.7615217566,
-0.1604340374,
0.758182466,
-0.1316910684,
-0.0156771895,
0.3927227557,
0.3145090342,
-0.1101930067,
0.2355714589,
-0.1053708717,
-0.0047239005,
0.000747562,
-0.6148951054,
-0.7101821303,
0.526101768,
-0.8767071962,
-0.4591227472,
-0.2406433374,
-0.224235341,
-0.2261710614,
0.0964380652,
0.301558733,
0.2038290352,
-0.396913141,
0.0785780028,
0.3398038149,
-0.3094688356,
0.4573484361,
0.4592979252,
-0.1372597963,
-0.3953805268,
0.8201887012,
-0.2004922479,
0.3260753453,
0.3893039525,
0.2640042603,
-0.3005439341,
-0.1607184261,
-0.9616660476,
-0.0449503623,
-0.7209868431,
-0.2603091002,
-0.6051424146,
-0.3366351128,
-0.2767659426,
-0.1452270001,
-0.1737600267,
-0.7146435976,
0.1526025981,
0.0144062052,
0.3795163631,
0.7817365527,
0.2877157927,
0.3194078505,
-0.9976719022,
0.229637444,
0.4356226325,
0.2827223837,
-0.1476896107,
-0.6629503965,
-0.1292078793,
0.2339013666,
-0.7643700242,
-0.7036601305,
0.0212670844,
0.2504172623,
0.3328834772,
0.1977131963,
-0.0598081648,
0.5185872316,
-0.2939671576,
1.2339562178,
0.0580326207,
-0.6136420369,
0.7891259789,
-0.5010390878,
0.3185959756,
0.3992456198,
0.3904001117,
-0.9152551293,
-0.5706065893,
-0.5342819691,
-0.5272601247,
0.6940426826,
0.6656709313,
0.7062957883,
-0.0439366624,
0.1335121542,
0.1074821055,
0.2420107722,
-0.7951711416,
-0.0916926488,
-0.3319389522,
0.0815059394,
-0.3143075705,
0.4513815641,
-0.073021099,
0.0327483863,
0.3224339485,
-0.1151456907,
0.5698109269,
0.1355063319,
-0.11563541,
0.0324323028,
0.4577435851,
0.6849956512,
0.3270202875,
-0.2773704231,
-0.2531092167,
0.0488800518,
-0.3276089132,
0.0864927992,
-0.0829812586,
0.0969896615,
-0.2386676818,
0.3730315268,
0.5242123604,
-0.4068223834,
-0.7291542292,
0.488932848,
-0.3513228297,
-0.168222934,
-0.1077313349,
0.3977486491,
-0.1293402016,
0.0145568261,
-0.0191036891,
0.4311932027,
0.0049269861,
-0.6668889523,
0.083374083,
0.1236673146,
-0.8145056963,
-0.4151052237,
0.5163887143,
0.3726404905,
-0.8328122497,
0.8554418087,
0.0980867073,
-0.6785458326,
0.4561652839,
0.2586860359,
0.9608544111,
-0.1037820652,
0.3265963197,
0.4885791838,
0.2229661345,
0.2581731677,
0.1592099965,
-0.2147448063,
-0.6318983436,
-0.223250553,
-0.4955581129,
-0.7721181512,
-0.126963079,
-0.5867580175,
0.1971544772,
-0.4271181226,
-0.214450717,
0.0942829847,
-0.1600541621,
-0.958548069,
0.3842393458,
-0.2750909328,
0.4643864632,
-0.6642830968,
0.2566328943,
0.9543937445,
-0.821836412,
-0.4634307623,
0.236361891,
-0.2517072856,
-0.8694548607,
0.3920647502,
0.3240560889,
-0.1450922787,
0.2024223357,
-0.4437770545,
-0.2407517135,
0.5418999791,
0.1813706458,
0.1490853876,
0.018252261,
0.4193328321,
1.0928294659,
0.1472963244,
0.7892687321,
0.4346835315,
0.4012804329,
-0.1918628961,
-1.3042823076,
-0.2374045551,
-0.3822934031,
-0.4097496867,
-0.0081585441,
-0.8207505345,
0.3808990717,
-0.0989302471,
-0.1224029735,
0.1193866357,
0.3902398348,
0.0194640849,
0.4429321289,
0.3837078512,
0.2330658585,
0.5471093655,
-0.1369575709,
1.2252255678,
-0.0613293871,
0.182428211,
0.5567646623,
0.0450884178,
0.8917463422,
0.2942267954,
-0.4527270496,
0.3144690692,
0.7156814933,
0.0641336069,
0.181452632,
0.6254208088,
-0.0361720137,
-0.0486866683,
-0.2128452212,
-0.1817139089,
0.5755773783,
0.1910464466,
-0.0659377575,
-0.1417098343,
0.025840601,
0.0889531001,
0.1878708154,
-0.2823050618,
1.1177277565,
-0.0404143296,
-0.9891014695,
0.6961361766,
0.0902895629,
0.4029165506,
-0.2500016391,
0.0501151979,
-0.6299583316,
0.1720086336,
-0.1748846024,
-1.1704450846,
0.1768696904,
0.4249104559,
0.022061253,
-0.1443321556,
0.2807132304,
0.0283174459,
-0.3050947785,
0.0682052299,
0.6116693616,
0.6731439829,
-0.1885966361,
-0.650434196,
-0.5624397993,
-0.129610762,
-0.0475481339,
0.220742777,
0.4070843756,
-0.0373080857,
0.9227275252,
0.6473583579,
-0.2364383042,
0.0515568219,
0.0021922493,
0.833271265,
-0.5055171251,
-0.4201203287,
-0.8409413099,
0.4413051903,
-0.1436271369,
-0.6123220325,
0.7860149145,
0.6314440966,
0.8417075872,
-0.3230689168,
0.7663045526,
-0.1536851376,
0.791746676,
-0.43346861,
0.6214737296,
-0.2826943099,
0.0405077562,
-0.5545074344,
-1.1934940815,
-0.2680754364,
0.56218189,
0.0200012289,
0.2857640088,
0.5152007341,
0.8198888898,
0.0631866157,
0.1071356609,
0.3956017196,
-0.0296633057,
0.5663350224,
0.5084014535,
1.2219692469,
-0.4062160552,
0.9391698837,
0.0400775336,
-0.1481344402,
-0.2809996009,
-0.5192499161,
-1.0414171219,
-0.4458008707,
-0.3508690894,
-0.493681252,
-0.0649788603,
0.8322607875,
0.403519243,
-0.6580200791,
-0.1615989208,
0.0685805604,
-0.01291072,
-0.2009480894,
-0.2882740796,
0.3449840248,
-0.1207640022,
-0.9004841447,
0.1144063994,
0.177311793,
0.1227573901,
-0.0285637975,
-0.064025566,
0.4257380366,
0.2349509448,
0.6338343024,
0.1879809201,
-0.6546853781,
-0.673615098,
0.371909678,
-0.1652827114,
0.4376202524,
0.7488185167,
-0.5812534094,
0.3231953084,
0.6529901624,
0.4687693119,
0.2438357323,
0.2433485687,
0.5495235324,
-0.6519392133,
-0.1606090963,
0.5043088794,
-0.2134611607,
0.5157063603,
-0.0506697185,
0.5310102701,
0.0017155987,
-0.9268525839,
-0.481441766,
0.1955727339,
-1.1118816137,
0.1509507596,
0.936883986,
-0.2145254612,
0.0976901129,
-0.1248682216,
-0.6748410463,
0.1494737566,
-0.4735111892,
0.8298404813,
0.9689207077,
-0.4139326811,
0.084597297,
-0.7015383244,
0.4059406817,
0.4009461403,
-0.9817602038,
0.2380539477,
0.4261515737,
0.0973525643,
0.2525688112,
0.8825938702,
-0.2760745883,
0.5239689946,
-0.3017643392,
-0.1736979038,
0.5658906698,
0.0288647898,
-0.2698239982,
0.1230846271,
0.3948423862,
-0.236635685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00189v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00189v2 | Detecting Lexical Borrowings from Dominant Languages in Multilingual Wordlists | 2023-02-01T02:44:28 | 2023-02-21T08:13:54 | John E. Miller, Johann-Mattis List | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language contact is a pervasive phenomenon reflected in the borrowing of
words from donor to recipient languages. Most computational approaches to
borrowing detection treat all languages under study as equally important, even
though dominant languages have a stronger impact on heritage languages than
vice versa. We test new methods for lexical borrowing detection in contact
situations where dominant languages play an important role, applying two
classical sequence comparison methods and one machine learning method to a
sample of seven Latin American languages which have all borrowed extensively
from Spanish. All methods perform well, with the supervised machine learning
system outperforming the classical systems. A review of detection errors shows
that borrowing detection could be substantially improved by taking into account
donor words with divergent meanings from recipient words. | [
-0.2680040598,
-0.5167600513,
0.192242831,
0.4238141179,
-0.2848474979,
0.4033876359,
-0.2564868331,
-0.8232375383,
0.4773280025,
0.6937945485,
-0.3296250701,
-0.1428866386,
-0.7700497508,
0.2335971296,
-0.3992099166,
1.0155272484,
-0.1817591488,
-0.1109565869,
-0.1137272939,
-0.443772316,
-0.059524931,
-0.495867908,
-0.4108613133,
-0.4652198851,
0.4559566975,
0.4810763299,
0.9051429033,
0.5553650856,
0.4169008732,
0.3787569404,
-0.1693712771,
0.2902299464,
-0.037997894,
-0.0417768918,
-0.4507986605,
-0.7191502452,
-0.0997969955,
-0.2647592127,
0.575219512,
0.4458942413,
0.1571222842,
0.0107876826,
-0.0487791523,
0.9574462771,
-0.8592975736,
0.2096337378,
-0.8039408922,
0.1618002355,
-0.6028291583,
-0.4500917494,
-0.423579216,
-0.4492166042,
0.3448895812,
-0.0476627387,
0.5077303052,
-0.120328024,
0.6565839052,
-0.2621449828,
-0.3222209811,
-0.5572429299,
-0.603120625,
0.7209364772,
-0.3489554524,
0.4891272485,
0.7342495918,
-0.0952636376,
0.19893758,
-0.2443934977,
-0.4386675954,
-0.5377013087,
0.1520381272,
0.0031183765,
-0.3310051858,
-0.2316712588,
0.1291448176,
0.4020239711,
-0.2010583431,
-0.0135669988,
-0.485632658,
-0.2997193933,
0.5143162012,
-0.3894559145,
0.3936534524,
-0.0443489328,
-0.4585178494,
-0.3049343824,
-0.9013849497,
-0.2339218557,
0.6435531378,
0.6526870728,
-0.2490839958,
0.3982933462,
0.5197925568,
0.5950268507,
-0.0655186102,
-0.1658685058,
0.3162736893,
-0.6258978844,
0.1692458093,
0.1257192343,
0.6679142714,
0.1291901767,
0.7581470609,
-0.1739685833,
-0.016606342,
-0.1291152686,
-0.1434623301,
-0.1563736647,
-0.0888933316,
-0.5228794813,
-0.1191399843,
-0.133332178,
0.303183943,
-0.660522759,
-0.5445114374,
-0.2964861393,
0.0136113642,
-0.5408509374,
-0.6387383342,
0.0384347551,
-0.3539102674,
0.5516844988,
0.063477695,
-1.0954370499,
0.1943285763,
0.5746790767,
0.9201831818,
-0.5662515163,
-0.4183620811,
-0.4087891579,
-0.2180892229,
-0.2207864225,
1.0572735071,
-0.3122439981,
-0.5702183247,
0.3300772309,
0.2418573797,
-0.1938215792,
-0.8961386681,
0.4089577198,
-0.5523200035,
-0.1580207795,
-0.4012237489,
-0.2931292057,
-0.1404758394,
0.0471518822,
-0.6005448699,
0.9070991278,
0.1858967096,
-0.8664792776,
0.5398899317,
0.07713826,
-0.6863232255,
0.1389233172,
0.2430856526,
-0.4285445809,
0.1479854286,
-0.3259840906,
0.1574058533,
-0.0134276627,
0.0406474657,
-0.4519787729,
0.0589549243,
0.0281022005,
-0.432148546,
0.757948935,
0.2529632449,
-0.5501842499,
-0.0159629844,
-0.6212645769,
-0.3911898732,
-0.0088332947,
-0.1940918267,
-0.6769318581,
0.0175297633,
0.3327452242,
0.0950217471,
0.2911801934,
-0.6104620695,
0.2678191066,
-0.2403907329,
-0.0272603184,
0.4687633514,
-0.2953342795,
0.4020611346,
-0.2791941166,
0.5313552618,
0.1125669256,
-0.3088256419,
0.0183144808,
-0.2903277874,
-0.716863811,
-0.3054717183,
0.2512328625,
0.8176619411,
-0.5725291371,
0.4092366099,
0.1419332325,
-0.1534856856,
-0.1476841271,
0.3866855502,
0.5904200077,
0.0021653832,
0.279112041,
-0.4172441363,
-0.7626012564,
-0.9703803062,
-0.3611723781,
-0.3629832864,
0.3698439002,
0.4420081675,
0.4105524123,
-0.112093851,
0.9501211047,
-0.1288291067,
-0.413995266,
-0.3202605844,
-0.2189186066,
-0.0344318151,
0.4756833911,
0.6675370336,
-0.6782277822,
-0.7680290341,
0.5873543024,
-0.6557420492,
-0.1187400371,
0.052486103,
0.1120940223,
0.4187139571,
0.8127191663,
0.0517470613,
0.2761293948,
0.7520550489,
-0.5778740644,
0.5968714952,
-0.4456396103,
-0.2109481394,
-1.0185296535,
0.251786679,
-0.0239895079,
-0.3385801017,
-0.6083792448,
-0.1582752466,
0.3494785428,
0.6240909696,
-0.5663386583,
0.3960042894,
-0.6593558192,
-0.0450631753,
-0.5069174767,
-0.0785915405,
-0.4017617106,
-0.146242708,
0.2638569474,
0.6306208372,
0.3202650547,
-0.3981822729,
0.4287348688,
0.2837616205,
-0.1797290742,
0.7783187032,
-0.3715412021,
0.1747198105,
-0.3124207556,
-0.1345365494,
-1.1741578579,
0.2556301951,
-0.0721630901,
-0.3789389729,
0.3757027686,
-0.4359405041,
-0.3423588872,
-0.2580647171,
-0.3188357949,
0.3407494426,
-0.1561741531,
-0.7076715827,
0.2670668662,
0.4583546221,
-0.069477573,
-0.8387501836,
-0.6649625897,
0.0284507126,
-0.3818741441,
-0.3174683452,
0.0755356774,
0.3817636073,
-0.4216966033,
-0.0944596753,
0.0194504522,
-0.2899519503,
0.3860048056,
0.113965258,
0.5680052638,
0.0711843595,
0.0051020458,
0.0078693014,
0.1897777021,
-0.1498174816,
-0.6031048894,
0.7222388983,
-0.1554430425,
-0.4684280455,
-0.184880048,
0.2851105332,
0.8380161524,
-0.284265846,
0.7081956863,
0.3746731281,
-0.22181198,
0.0961538032,
-0.7824608684,
0.0797734708,
-0.4225857258,
0.2517008781,
-0.5092841387,
-0.6416344643,
0.6090568304,
0.0433356464,
0.0184626076,
0.4792808592,
0.6024249196,
0.3354443908,
0.483387053,
0.9239377975,
-0.6295896769,
0.9158914685,
-0.2893275321,
-0.0960630178,
-0.4507429004,
-0.0361472704,
-0.742295146,
0.038479235,
-0.7997332811,
-0.4659640193,
0.0142861977,
0.1615664214,
0.4012383819,
0.9609031677,
0.0081144776,
0.6758517027,
0.4570304453,
-0.1521799862,
0.6749879122,
0.1394759715,
-0.5625117421,
0.0889233202,
-0.2050302476,
-0.2237001956,
1.1053122282,
-0.0689334869,
0.5041414499,
0.0857286304,
0.9803312421,
0.5882383585,
0.2748859525,
-0.8609342575,
0.0470237844,
-0.2682319283,
-0.3559008539,
0.0169459917,
-0.1744346321,
-1.2984336615,
0.4379128516,
-0.311852783,
-0.8222377896,
0.4606600702,
-0.0805679411,
-0.0268255267,
0.481023401,
-0.3968773782,
0.5586414337,
-0.0514095202,
-0.5138290524,
-0.3262322247,
-0.471876204,
0.2680575848,
-0.1142648906,
0.2321764529,
-0.0892729759,
0.2760944366,
0.4526612163,
-0.1795823276,
0.5932701826,
-0.0681060255,
-0.5311570168,
0.3048644066,
0.30646047,
0.5047162175,
-0.254545927,
-0.2412015945,
-0.1602130532,
0.3656628132,
-0.5672070384,
0.118603155,
0.6564312577,
-0.6729370356,
-0.1381365806,
-0.4291630387,
-0.5670018196,
-0.2753888965,
0.0616020449,
0.3995040655,
0.0274676979,
-0.4878559113,
-0.0075255991,
0.2136398256,
-0.0419677198,
0.4266393185,
0.6604062319,
-0.1402740777,
-0.2092040479,
1.0140407085,
-0.116323933,
0.3594376445,
0.1040267348,
0.3153389394,
-0.4396747649,
-0.5390488505,
-0.6351879239,
0.5245518684,
-0.1818018705,
0.0452178158,
-0.5255404115,
0.2368452251,
-0.3214988112,
-0.0424111709,
-0.5649168491,
-0.3876100481,
0.0080174077,
-0.0119304154,
0.2511259317,
0.721491456,
-0.3876112401,
0.0321233757,
-1.1955287457,
-0.0741222948,
0.2967133522,
0.0682283416,
-0.1471113861,
-0.4088799953,
-0.1211223975,
-0.2474585027,
-0.4120049477,
-0.9048454165,
0.512975812,
0.4691449106,
0.5145349503,
0.7911514044,
-0.1432020813,
0.4446514547,
-0.4573125243,
0.2742718756,
0.2789606452,
-1.0048481226,
0.3941275477,
-0.4133926928,
0.1164313704,
0.7717701197,
0.5053369403,
-0.8419246674,
-0.4267403483,
-0.8032487631,
-0.813267827,
0.6533402205,
-0.230608508,
0.228820771,
-0.2843934596,
0.001393573,
0.1896484941,
0.1415854394,
-0.3480915129,
-0.2786812186,
0.4784846306,
0.0571024828,
-0.2840515673,
0.0036000821,
0.0990502089,
-0.0642315522,
0.2618445456,
-0.3268283904,
-0.0559476539,
0.2676596642,
-0.5570607185,
-0.201056689,
0.1403964758,
0.5529494286,
0.59712255,
0.0486822277,
0.3006677628,
0.3309103847,
-0.6152313352,
0.0714049563,
0.1588205397,
-0.0584161505,
0.1940455139,
0.4320257306,
0.6918379068,
0.0524396673,
-0.6489369273,
0.5934029222,
0.2326121628,
-0.357364893,
-0.2871912122,
-0.3537969589,
0.1579438001,
0.0309675187,
0.140554443,
0.2821366191,
0.1602784693,
-0.9185344577,
0.4206295907,
0.8062772751,
-0.6051084399,
-0.646941483,
-0.0185624324,
0.0860851184,
-0.2973946631,
0.4542658925,
0.0963536799,
-1.0529998541,
0.7264845371,
0.7654904127,
0.7057324648,
-0.4064693451,
0.2421653569,
0.228147313,
-0.1047954187,
-0.469799906,
0.1439742148,
-0.5697144866,
-1.1194638014,
-0.2536293566,
-0.4005261064,
-0.7309262156,
-0.3183982372,
-0.9595424533,
0.2469172031,
-0.3025991321,
-0.0421923697,
0.1362191886,
-0.1622772664,
-0.4618972838,
-0.5792120695,
0.6854704022,
0.6039994955,
-1.1440724134,
0.9952819943,
0.5796051025,
0.0597201064,
-0.3691090643,
-0.1272018403,
0.2930250764,
-0.8441942334,
0.9798711538,
0.0086154584,
-0.4411044121,
-0.0362649374,
0.0384250209,
-0.8172988892,
0.365413487,
0.3892600834,
-0.4547554851,
0.2490826398,
0.0210997723,
0.4873220325,
0.1131892204,
0.3712088168,
1.1761747599,
0.4164854586,
0.1262014806,
-1.374723196,
-0.2262590826,
0.0365564637,
-0.3530514836,
0.6674531698,
-0.5190576315,
0.6938830018,
-0.3150169253,
-0.3988342583,
0.1605501175,
0.5014514923,
0.2887943387,
0.0883021951,
0.7781336904,
0.6084919572,
0.9153078198,
0.1163211837,
0.6712511182,
-0.3988836408,
0.4394846857,
0.6162406206,
-0.4638358951,
0.8351327777,
0.5352545977,
-0.7071864009,
0.6743043661,
0.1463605016,
-0.0677019507,
0.1397466511,
0.6640111208,
-0.5920359492,
-0.0125926184,
-0.2479980439,
-0.3870747685,
0.6630941629,
0.4564877152,
-0.4250802398,
-0.4018817842,
0.216598317,
0.2586811483,
0.1428286284,
-0.1086076275,
0.9325307012,
0.0087438608,
-1.0898941755,
0.8048038483,
-0.3574270606,
1.1226161718,
-0.5031493902,
0.092771396,
-0.3712185323,
0.7926467657,
-0.4884603024,
-0.522108376,
0.5077915788,
0.0943820402,
-0.0967396349,
-0.0145129468,
0.636970818,
-0.7054587603,
-0.233345747,
0.7838881612,
0.966940105,
0.1649613827,
-0.0586762428,
-0.513641715,
-0.2577491701,
0.0265963115,
0.311511606,
0.5613473654,
0.062752746,
-0.4696641862,
0.4936273694,
0.7322648764,
0.5768272281,
0.2583016753,
0.3394015431,
0.4225762486,
-0.5240715742,
-0.3626698852,
-1.1254637241,
-0.4393278062,
0.0959189385,
-0.2755860686,
0.964630425,
0.5663295388,
0.8105157614,
-0.2489335537,
0.6621079445,
-0.0554998517,
0.328702867,
-0.0672496408,
0.3077997565,
-0.1351825893,
-0.0999450237,
-0.5896309614,
-0.8055461645,
-0.4278493524,
0.7327387929,
-0.1410015821,
-0.5285776258,
0.7555876374,
0.510761261,
-0.0183972828,
0.1146399528,
0.1107751131,
-0.3946252465,
0.0694269165,
0.5727524757,
1.0795536041,
-0.2703004777,
0.5119681358,
-0.2439099848,
-0.3787614405,
-0.1170346737,
-0.6748110652,
-0.6639570594,
-0.5596027374,
-0.2292470038,
-0.5657024384,
0.1438531876,
1.2526952028,
0.5894046426,
-1.1780481339,
-0.7861241698,
-0.1682011932,
0.2962757945,
-0.417801857,
-0.1954562366,
0.4727269113,
-0.4826686978,
-0.9791267514,
0.4983963072,
0.1084919721,
0.1268863678,
-0.0641615689,
0.345451653,
-0.3951617777,
-0.2835821807,
0.6882579923,
0.7584937215,
-0.4297977388,
-0.0981219262,
-0.0721633136,
-0.1213020533,
0.1256372035,
1.2147750854,
-0.6989970803,
0.4239854813,
0.8923652768,
0.5714637637,
0.6684627533,
0.050550662,
0.485386759,
-0.5605596304,
0.3951203227,
0.1313070953,
0.5374906063,
0.500066936,
-0.1716183126,
0.293727994,
0.7079516649,
-0.1338225901,
-0.5816794038,
0.2613905966,
-0.7642819285,
-0.1155295968,
1.1891762018,
-0.3382304311,
0.0286256429,
-0.6223897934,
-0.4810951352,
0.120338656,
-0.1347503513,
0.4734547138,
0.7224773169,
0.0134943873,
-0.0478173792,
-0.2550902665,
0.5772322416,
0.5379545093,
-0.3788415492,
0.1330422163,
0.1700858325,
0.441532135,
0.5384842157,
0.3982498646,
-0.4244819582,
0.3204465806,
-0.4096795022,
0.0408382826,
0.3115404546,
-0.1276849955,
-0.4566705823,
0.0769291222,
0.2700462937,
-0.21979177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00178v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00178v1 | Program Generation from Diverse Video Demonstrations | 2023-02-01T01:51:45 | 2023-02-01T01:51:45 | Anthony Manchin, Jamie Sherrah, Qi Wu, Anton van den Hengel | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | The ability to use inductive reasoning to extract general rules from multiple
observations is a vital indicator of intelligence. As humans, we use this
ability to not only interpret the world around us, but also to predict the
outcomes of the various interactions we experience. Generalising over multiple
observations is a task that has historically presented difficulties for
machines to grasp, especially when requiring computer vision. In this paper, we
propose a model that can extract general rules from video demonstrations by
simultaneously performing summarisation and translation. Our approach differs
from prior works by framing the problem as a multi-sequence-to-sequence task,
wherein summarisation is learnt by the model. This allows our model to utilise
edge cases that would otherwise be suppressed or discarded by traditional
summarisation techniques. Additionally, we show that our approach can handle
noisy specifications without the need for additional filtering methods. We
evaluate our model by synthesising programs from video demonstrations in the
Vizdoom environment achieving state-of-the-art results with a relative increase
of 11.75% program accuracy on prior works | [
-0.4417847693,
-0.6837675571,
0.3430234492,
0.2328220904,
-0.4299874306,
-0.3520981967,
-0.2446469665,
-0.1580242962,
0.0712010711,
0.7831377387,
-0.7414637208,
-0.6494237781,
-0.5787975788,
-0.1145635694,
-0.7447598577,
1.139752388,
-0.0659331158,
-0.2444615364,
-0.0562817864,
-0.1056994796,
-0.3919582367,
-0.1019374207,
0.1842696816,
-0.2356385589,
-0.3690675199,
0.6634803414,
0.4266373813,
0.4828399122,
0.4423780441,
0.4074441791,
0.3149000406,
0.816146493,
-0.2576140463,
0.0404644199,
-0.0779940262,
-0.2325201035,
-0.1528157592,
-0.1374510974,
0.6495193839,
0.3786583543,
0.030414816,
0.2899516821,
0.0833346769,
0.5668165684,
-0.6670996547,
0.1383692622,
-0.6203007102,
0.1482824534,
0.5661332607,
-0.3879962564,
-0.3125712276,
-0.5304895639,
-0.0091213314,
-0.6406859159,
0.6253420711,
-0.5345999599,
0.691532433,
0.4228465259,
-0.122005254,
-0.322943449,
-1.0497515202,
0.6314195991,
-0.7066563964,
-0.0775390193,
-0.1046001986,
0.6377232075,
-0.1315637976,
-0.9088555574,
-0.5145655274,
0.1078245565,
0.0857840925,
0.1334981918,
-0.0780567303,
0.1721952409,
0.5275228024,
0.3082037866,
-0.4019494653,
-0.3089689314,
-0.6784735918,
-0.0106037408,
0.7486451864,
0.3121065497,
0.4535115957,
-0.3351847231,
0.0303663183,
-0.176049307,
-0.4078024924,
0.3876194954,
0.446918577,
0.1895437837,
-0.2466254532,
0.8030357957,
-0.6742531657,
0.629291296,
-0.1320344955,
-0.4391208589,
0.1167802066,
-0.3377903402,
-0.5570136309,
-0.3644439876,
0.5945588946,
0.8562769294,
0.5010349154,
0.1220346093,
0.0446821377,
0.1981699169,
0.3164473176,
-0.9875317216,
-0.4373904467,
0.1240610778,
-0.5912616253,
-0.2631620169,
0.3718908429,
-0.9603408575,
-0.1178458706,
-0.6458972096,
0.4181462824,
-0.5182194114,
-0.1586796194,
0.0585487746,
-0.492064327,
0.3821723461,
0.5718230605,
-0.9039067626,
0.4312452078,
0.5517951846,
0.7091448903,
0.0764324889,
-0.4778634906,
-0.9317858219,
0.3962920308,
-0.2307500988,
0.7175769806,
-0.4870786667,
-0.4702908397,
0.1450495422,
-0.1094391793,
0.0089851366,
-0.6116899848,
0.0264149252,
-0.0129172308,
0.0787315518,
0.1122015789,
-0.3406937122,
-0.3230092227,
0.0683392659,
-0.4235682487,
0.5486229658,
-0.1498134434,
-0.5916057229,
0.4328558445,
-0.6712108254,
-0.766507566,
-0.2424451858,
-0.5242134929,
-0.4128118157,
0.1577268541,
0.751734972,
0.4507872462,
0.0358532965,
0.284719795,
-0.1013829187,
-0.3965680301,
0.0133844912,
-0.3106604815,
0.3223827779,
0.0960843563,
-0.4022597373,
0.3900758326,
-0.7959820032,
0.0394354612,
-0.2294461727,
-0.1473006904,
-0.0326143131,
0.1480652988,
-0.4038629532,
0.4046787918,
-0.2162498236,
-0.2024043798,
0.3920337558,
-0.1627620757,
0.4279685616,
0.6301618218,
0.3737626076,
0.260966897,
-0.3458632827,
0.6879134178,
-0.1530017257,
0.3707883656,
-0.5915729403,
-0.6230832934,
-0.5469754338,
-0.3447008133,
-0.4014926851,
0.4812682271,
-0.7914401293,
0.00061424,
-0.3846116066,
-0.0879592672,
-0.4072949886,
0.539173007,
0.215299502,
0.2463860661,
0.527893126,
-0.114463307,
-0.6688566208,
-0.9198663235,
0.1040376201,
0.047290802,
-0.2876197696,
0.3081357181,
0.516903162,
-0.1964748055,
0.7706724405,
-0.7441266775,
-0.1847418994,
-0.4579405487,
0.3921836913,
0.3050630093,
0.4367610216,
0.3367720842,
-0.8825488091,
-0.2552666366,
0.1426093727,
-1.1031718254,
0.1611246765,
-0.4951154888,
-0.1937638968,
-0.2585169673,
0.6598003507,
-0.4477581382,
0.8505932093,
0.2762845755,
0.2883480191,
0.8217046857,
-0.3905216157,
0.3919848204,
-0.9669225812,
-0.1837326586,
-0.0589702316,
-0.035915833,
-0.5561728477,
0.1602375954,
-0.258115232,
-0.1637997031,
-0.4342197776,
0.0759215429,
-0.3362621665,
-0.1847951859,
-0.2478611767,
-0.0430788733,
0.1696726382,
0.6903685331,
0.0638790578,
0.619905591,
0.7516388893,
-1.1421265602,
0.5790458918,
0.1830651015,
-0.36179322,
0.310957253,
-0.6292171478,
-0.2729418278,
-0.3482258916,
-0.3125085831,
-1.0482941866,
-0.6341436505,
0.0097297318,
-0.5257176757,
0.1975220442,
-0.376739502,
-0.0677963719,
-0.4645721614,
-0.3848606348,
0.0282335617,
0.7077513337,
-0.5951639414,
0.9284290075,
0.214801684,
-0.1664365381,
-0.4299997985,
-0.4343104362,
0.0022102611,
-0.3300201595,
-0.7597562075,
0.2525483668,
-0.0457845554,
-0.285474658,
-0.0512664467,
-0.0135273617,
0.0063750912,
-0.083873786,
0.6037870049,
0.1662415713,
0.0115631409,
-0.1704606563,
0.3069428205,
0.3151678145,
0.1178013757,
-0.3855873644,
0.2304448038,
-0.043564178,
-0.5179386139,
-0.4697329998,
0.8618102074,
0.6634310484,
-0.2757160068,
0.0060607018,
0.5410918593,
-0.2600756288,
-0.566642344,
-0.4526298046,
-0.0579120629,
-0.5109208226,
0.4776472449,
-0.5373113751,
-0.4226065874,
0.4333736598,
-0.3239319026,
0.2939157188,
0.326590091,
0.5597376227,
-0.0440233164,
1.2412643433,
0.7880005836,
0.2693183124,
0.6383224726,
-0.7344231009,
-0.150871858,
-0.6445428133,
-0.3026480973,
-0.0988080055,
-0.121919699,
-0.4801895618,
-0.3068672121,
0.6545410156,
0.070206672,
0.0773618892,
0.1732383966,
-0.5623341799,
0.6402523518,
0.7938770056,
0.3732447922,
0.2993634939,
0.4398131669,
-0.1161594018,
0.1056953222,
-0.4381857216,
-0.5256256461,
1.1075811386,
-0.1373557001,
0.7994439602,
0.2853818536,
0.8569000363,
0.580534339,
0.2029968351,
-0.6448603868,
0.6476979852,
-0.4452694058,
0.019461602,
-0.2892743349,
-0.2707360983,
-0.6224542856,
0.1859569848,
-0.1242419034,
-0.755866766,
-0.2351004779,
0.0613002665,
-0.4013391435,
0.2829203308,
-0.6495479941,
0.8430093527,
-0.1287662387,
-0.3340836465,
-0.4646077752,
-0.8346905708,
0.9178875685,
0.4323154688,
0.3194739819,
0.1175504923,
0.695748806,
0.4015903473,
-0.610453248,
0.8707021475,
-0.2097877711,
0.300360024,
0.7533615828,
-0.0524772331,
0.1867719889,
-0.0947210342,
0.4311611056,
-0.510120213,
-0.2320390046,
-0.1931312531,
-0.6979971528,
0.2830408812,
-0.8653215766,
-0.637619853,
0.2841000557,
-0.6172736883,
0.1937194169,
-0.0891674384,
0.2694683671,
0.6778234243,
-0.3532391489,
-0.1216463745,
0.5807680488,
-0.3531853259,
0.5387867689,
0.092687197,
-0.3582748473,
-0.610601604,
0.9723446369,
-0.2505045533,
0.4431293309,
0.3317228854,
0.0298633482,
-0.0260051228,
-0.6169859171,
-0.6984850764,
-0.038015198,
-0.929895699,
-0.0049705538,
-0.628621459,
-0.2346680164,
-0.7573257089,
-0.1406695694,
-0.0397382565,
-0.5452526808,
-0.1441494375,
-0.1807653308,
0.1009804904,
0.9083842039,
-0.3008351028,
0.3914556205,
-0.7832016349,
0.9521470666,
1.1800464392,
-0.0621397495,
-0.1977744401,
-0.5214056969,
-0.2496519536,
-0.0836662576,
-0.5891077518,
-0.8181636333,
0.5009983182,
0.5688579679,
0.8492939472,
0.6419952512,
-0.0559446402,
0.9515180588,
-0.49235636,
0.7477057576,
0.267077744,
-0.8499603868,
1.0836187601,
-0.11028485,
0.2105798274,
0.3548983634,
0.2105381042,
-0.2662801743,
-0.594199419,
-0.5597447157,
-0.7732732892,
0.4217351973,
0.0474344902,
0.1101335585,
0.1002576277,
0.0908454955,
0.3146085143,
0.2610991597,
-0.2569637299,
0.2117783278,
-0.7512019277,
-0.0616353117,
0.1545253843,
0.0514549986,
-0.2044962347,
-0.2907786667,
0.5718518496,
-0.3531211615,
-0.0977563486,
0.3044061661,
-0.4870573878,
0.2051857412,
0.2882215679,
0.8129506707,
0.6791514754,
-0.2250822634,
0.0781152323,
-0.1530147046,
-0.3559385836,
0.1169604883,
0.1199083701,
-0.415287137,
0.1419832408,
0.3626842499,
0.6944798827,
-0.2230989784,
-0.8050345778,
0.5219334364,
0.0015367719,
-0.3556632698,
-0.2430355996,
0.349645704,
-0.3818998039,
0.3853629529,
0.3089782298,
0.1114815921,
0.5353239179,
-0.5423666239,
0.6170491576,
0.2575764358,
0.2297795415,
-0.3291882277,
0.784704864,
0.1843225062,
-0.1096571013,
0.8042181134,
-0.4530016184,
-0.5567936301,
0.9231352806,
0.2076434642,
0.8726607561,
0.0173114091,
0.5323059559,
0.66638273,
0.2265743762,
-0.1357622892,
0.4584544301,
-0.3861730695,
-0.6310546398,
-0.813154459,
-0.4504546821,
-0.7049700618,
-0.1847265512,
-0.8858833909,
0.3772224486,
-0.4329626262,
0.0344111398,
-0.0247162655,
-0.4516681731,
-0.729454577,
0.1052417681,
0.4347767234,
0.5956842899,
-1.316118598,
0.7989879847,
0.606595993,
-0.6576513052,
-0.8054977059,
-0.3190498054,
-0.2208486348,
-0.6015140414,
0.4505698681,
0.4406274259,
-0.0947560221,
-0.3284519315,
-0.7497864962,
-0.2371265143,
0.8758960366,
0.2383974642,
-0.0626493469,
-0.0568083674,
0.0477762856,
0.2300309986,
-0.6519917846,
0.2561343312,
0.6649483442,
0.2156629711,
0.4380351305,
-0.7044395208,
-0.2820094526,
-0.6994342208,
-0.1163223311,
-0.1469389945,
-0.3068417609,
0.8457238674,
-0.8978205323,
-0.0662210286,
0.0008149545,
0.7308891416,
0.27202636,
0.2957660556,
0.2376066148,
0.3853512406,
0.566470027,
0.3359775841,
0.9319540262,
-0.0277192909,
-0.0277974214,
1.4726133347,
0.0284597334,
0.4028783143,
0.4545392096,
-0.1903386265,
0.6905990839,
0.1979950368,
-0.2324139029,
0.7977439761,
0.1994260252,
-0.2285041958,
-0.4784060121,
-0.002609354,
-0.1899194121,
0.6306518912,
0.4766434133,
-0.4115006924,
-0.302342236,
0.1274569929,
-0.4449918568,
0.2854257226,
-0.681370914,
0.894734621,
-0.2470999807,
-0.8873794675,
0.4084267616,
-0.0974534601,
0.5652967095,
-0.6305459738,
-0.5618661642,
-0.1413302273,
0.1841175556,
-0.3393032849,
-0.7058725357,
0.3384575248,
0.089347139,
-0.1109694391,
0.0060828282,
0.3938778043,
-0.4876486659,
-0.6430212259,
-0.1269458234,
0.4472277462,
0.5563054681,
-0.0447453521,
-0.0778759271,
-0.222245872,
0.3700697422,
0.161744982,
0.0887848213,
0.5282750726,
-0.1905300319,
0.5902525187,
0.5106396675,
0.0178051889,
0.5317803621,
0.3159115911,
1.0780484676,
-0.487872541,
-0.5312588215,
-0.9244884253,
0.7174289227,
-0.3549450934,
-0.123865895,
0.5269887447,
0.4718865156,
0.8335919976,
-0.3891795278,
1.1494643688,
-0.0078723179,
-0.0219259821,
-0.7377442718,
0.0569510609,
-0.3257624507,
0.0685644671,
-0.4516753852,
-0.5525173545,
-0.2679367065,
0.5468387604,
0.0026276722,
-0.4084965289,
0.3460032344,
0.7359601855,
-0.1410611421,
0.1382303983,
0.3824826479,
-0.1188664213,
0.6137016416,
0.7921698093,
0.8285084367,
-0.3442282975,
0.8971198797,
-0.42783916,
-0.2845210433,
-0.1920588911,
-0.8888879418,
-0.9526923299,
-0.1788072437,
-0.4074686468,
-0.0670135468,
-0.0219209865,
0.8641377687,
0.8829630613,
-0.8039938211,
-0.3620218933,
-0.0763415322,
0.331420958,
-0.6310045719,
-0.1926856637,
0.2202863097,
-0.3262239695,
-0.7692021132,
0.4068460464,
0.2577464581,
0.1610800028,
-0.0597681813,
-0.1358079761,
0.1102143899,
-0.1995743364,
0.6673967242,
0.4802120328,
-0.5429097414,
-0.3505465984,
-0.1065292433,
0.3603793085,
0.150503993,
0.9238019586,
-0.7549803853,
0.6090245247,
0.5023872256,
0.308562398,
0.9163447022,
0.3633866608,
0.6027376056,
-0.8230423927,
0.2377800345,
-0.077332966,
0.4269958735,
0.3560355008,
-0.0467734784,
0.5227124095,
0.238173753,
-0.3116653562,
-0.4836552143,
0.5022917986,
-0.8576011658,
-0.2793631554,
0.9870883226,
-0.1043234542,
0.0625957251,
0.1430983245,
-0.2473949045,
0.3956922889,
-0.2876996696,
0.8699240685,
0.2848063111,
-0.3766489625,
-0.2661803663,
-0.6192684174,
0.1566600651,
-0.2321863621,
-0.7541595101,
-0.1245468184,
0.7459436655,
0.3665696681,
0.067220673,
0.4864228368,
-0.0853246972,
0.5337089896,
0.1361174583,
0.3926855326,
-0.337233901,
-0.7326133847,
-0.1638345271,
0.4875630736,
-0.1193033159,
-0.5387497544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00129v1 | Universal Topological Regularities of Syntactic Structures: Decoupling Efficiency from Optimization | 2023-01-31T22:35:11 | 2023-01-31T22:35:11 | Fermín Moscoso del Prado Martín | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Human syntactic structures are usually represented as graphs. Much research
has focused on the mapping between such graphs and linguistic sequences, but
less attention has been paid to the shapes of the graphs themselves: their
topologies. This study investigates how the topologies of syntactic graphs
reveal traces of the processes that led to their emergence. I report a new
universal regularity in syntactic structures: Their topology is communicatively
efficient above chance. The pattern holds, without exception, for all 124
languages studied, across linguistic families and modalities (spoken, written,
and signed). This pattern can arise from a process optimizing for communicative
efficiency or, alternatively, by construction, as a by-effect of a sublinear
preferential attachment process reflecting language production mechanisms known
from psycholinguistics. This dual explanation shows how communicative
efficiency, per se, does not require optimization. Among the two options,
efficiency without optimization offers the better explanation for the new
pattern. | [
-0.1815586835,
-0.8808758855,
0.3538541496,
-0.0756610036,
-0.3490848839,
0.0695508793,
-0.455520004,
-0.3467902243,
0.6493974924,
0.2384146899,
-0.2517799437,
-0.3993647099,
-0.4875293374,
0.2596693635,
-0.4233483672,
0.7445811629,
0.1659653783,
-0.3590004742,
0.0321805105,
-0.2059892863,
0.0731033906,
-0.7762792706,
-0.7107256651,
-0.3921945095,
0.4001510143,
0.2028188854,
1.0173250437,
1.0478919744,
0.4269211292,
0.4550591111,
-0.1566097885,
0.1348233521,
-0.7163597941,
0.1956683546,
0.2803825438,
-0.5622317791,
-0.289914459,
0.0102092205,
1.0579234362,
1.4017484188,
-0.2830854356,
0.005162573,
0.2520807087,
0.893540144,
-0.2621114552,
0.1936401874,
-0.357416749,
0.1255651414,
-0.5904186368,
-0.5215675831,
-0.1140223965,
-0.5261795521,
-0.1833848059,
-0.671708703,
0.0980718359,
0.026773978,
0.8139193654,
0.1577705741,
-0.2093413621,
-0.1386375874,
-0.7837241292,
0.3420582712,
-0.0881219879,
0.7091539502,
0.2083019316,
0.1106546596,
-0.5940628052,
-0.6881055236,
-0.2909401059,
-0.0364119485,
-0.2040841877,
0.0092858011,
-0.582550168,
0.2104931772,
0.1654723585,
0.3484306335,
-0.8394426107,
0.2076838464,
-0.2842216492,
-0.1695707887,
0.3505555093,
0.0835787877,
0.6106568575,
-0.0601981059,
-0.0051271925,
0.0644677058,
-0.5913572311,
0.1698809415,
0.4877208471,
0.1361400485,
-0.1304154545,
0.4112408161,
-0.2753701508,
0.6902594566,
-0.3288667202,
-0.1334528178,
-0.0961184353,
-0.6464628577,
-0.095351547,
-0.2461111546,
0.6834564209,
0.2138468176,
0.9562277198,
-0.5231005549,
-0.021203937,
0.2457997799,
-0.0115584973,
-0.2391153127,
-0.493047297,
-0.2639669478,
-0.4532343745,
-0.3336658478,
-0.1017761901,
-0.1231700554,
0.0230878182,
-0.1284936219,
-0.1850542277,
-0.191218257,
-0.3700188398,
0.2615447342,
-0.2444123775,
0.0349271484,
0.1165995076,
-0.7626373172,
0.7517873049,
0.6264042854,
0.912646234,
-0.0384550467,
-0.3251437843,
-0.2958871424,
0.1642653048,
-0.6757842898,
0.8454777002,
-0.3979227245,
-0.189726308,
-0.2893906236,
0.0453807227,
-0.1571024507,
-0.4603326321,
0.460921824,
-0.1619647741,
0.1174247712,
-0.1115005091,
-0.3139400482,
-0.3256458342,
-0.2612029016,
-0.5822914243,
0.7656946182,
0.0835817754,
-0.45651564,
0.4542140067,
-0.7216777205,
-0.4919572771,
0.2913796902,
-0.1345601827,
-0.0716404468,
0.3220299184,
-0.4779115021,
0.0904280916,
-0.3054761589,
0.1703396589,
-0.1041270941,
-0.4207229614,
0.0914312899,
-0.1748543233,
1.1140516996,
0.3230246902,
-0.3050064147,
-0.0281693768,
-0.6721790433,
-0.0080128042,
0.2786154747,
-0.4523243308,
-0.6111629009,
-0.0066841785,
-0.2132632583,
-0.0579477921,
-0.1283875853,
-0.3719865382,
0.3909382224,
-0.4905960858,
0.3107351065,
0.5735666752,
0.1087136641,
0.3321693838,
-0.3385614455,
0.4658768475,
-0.3246432245,
0.1680944562,
0.264364928,
-0.6247839928,
-0.7278120518,
-0.3886706233,
0.2642197013,
0.3276893497,
-0.004295981,
0.3900491893,
-0.3661190271,
-0.2567115724,
-0.1000249013,
0.0326200426,
0.5154171586,
-0.0175640937,
-0.3292953372,
-0.9170376658,
-0.5204046369,
-0.8204056025,
-0.4220563471,
-0.0339850746,
0.3083042502,
0.1325790286,
0.0377992094,
0.1236144006,
0.5392522216,
-0.4738018513,
0.0887598246,
-0.400932461,
-0.194893226,
0.3954719603,
0.4238618612,
0.7016177773,
-0.5949978828,
-0.5847367644,
0.0055498113,
-0.5709161758,
-0.0695655197,
-0.169592768,
-0.3950257599,
0.4076272845,
0.4755606353,
-0.6760390997,
0.3918145001,
0.2154598236,
-0.3448719978,
0.4819708467,
-0.1819344908,
-0.1592270732,
-0.7703298926,
0.2351068109,
-0.2063005567,
-0.3416044712,
-0.798705101,
0.3403690755,
-0.6484798789,
-0.2849442959,
-0.0278884303,
0.3032069802,
-0.8884600401,
-0.4213350415,
0.0847195685,
0.5183524489,
-0.2511176467,
0.6427764297,
-0.3561304212,
0.4393835664,
0.7061622143,
-0.5335479975,
0.146320343,
0.1392561942,
-0.2335954905,
-0.0133078834,
-0.4849048555,
0.0231596176,
-0.0898462236,
0.2327467203,
-1.0814038515,
-0.3840384781,
0.2621636689,
-0.4157846868,
0.2501316965,
-0.0050170831,
-0.5198000073,
-0.092826739,
-0.4203082621,
0.4415830374,
0.5296397209,
-0.157465741,
-0.0287873317,
0.6202976704,
0.0258541275,
-0.1390211433,
-0.4456629455,
0.1513457149,
-0.1244819462,
-0.8402424455,
-0.0888981745,
0.0271270219,
-0.4345232248,
-0.1175622791,
-0.3047148287,
-0.228290379,
0.5831608772,
-0.0336648747,
-0.1405962557,
-0.1875700355,
0.0314116254,
-0.0117431991,
-0.2318231761,
-0.1121109799,
-0.5383986831,
0.6998718977,
0.1998084038,
0.0987576544,
-0.7568333745,
0.5410319567,
0.5448054671,
0.0183535777,
0.4905682206,
0.1398336142,
-0.4479858279,
0.0133286696,
-0.3403983116,
-0.0786555037,
-0.4623312056,
0.1436049789,
-0.54934901,
-0.677811265,
0.4317459464,
-0.1310940236,
-0.2233410031,
0.3279895484,
0.4571706653,
0.0515785553,
0.6720415354,
0.7421608567,
0.1414531767,
0.517038703,
-0.4801065922,
0.4289669991,
-0.5285416842,
-0.1173480153,
-0.7226125598,
-0.303196013,
-0.9758331776,
-0.1561109722,
0.4701294601,
0.3883549571,
0.092953369,
0.5561471581,
-0.4936420023,
0.6408863664,
0.6474493742,
-0.3505671322,
0.5155954957,
0.2190916985,
-0.284191519,
0.0351759084,
-1.029414773,
-0.3420956731,
0.7331050634,
-0.0981039926,
0.5883983374,
0.2186714709,
0.997197032,
0.1177359372,
-0.2008046657,
-0.6102646589,
0.5210986137,
-0.2820573747,
-0.1493157446,
-0.4224552512,
-0.4413971603,
-1.4986793995,
0.1339885592,
-0.1571471095,
-1.2226884365,
0.5224758387,
0.1582825631,
-0.0226640739,
0.1966823786,
-0.7744508386,
0.8777224422,
0.1302074939,
-0.0176902171,
-0.25539428,
-0.6996549964,
0.2844055295,
0.1327755004,
0.1524197459,
0.1503372937,
0.0839569271,
0.7003084421,
-0.1912568808,
0.6485571861,
0.2331477106,
0.0315265432,
0.2749202847,
0.4361623824,
0.5477302074,
-0.3568481505,
0.0549613163,
0.1925028563,
-0.2079091221,
-0.3993673921,
-0.6397479177,
0.4722019434,
-0.5484951138,
-0.5177380443,
-0.1086813956,
-0.4816660881,
0.1471461505,
0.5255985856,
0.334492296,
0.8643767834,
-0.158943072,
0.1636280417,
0.1274955422,
0.1329151094,
0.5471306443,
0.0021903082,
0.0319570191,
-0.0317700766,
0.852055192,
0.49832654,
0.4360042214,
0.2303826064,
0.314732492,
-0.196314767,
-0.6257075667,
-0.0812386274,
0.3704308867,
-0.6318452358,
0.1271595061,
-0.6772029996,
-0.0815180317,
-0.5219948292,
-0.3430753946,
-0.0807169303,
-1.1580835581,
0.2356218845,
0.0160072856,
-0.039421767,
0.9702521563,
-0.4899111688,
0.0236324389,
-0.4536451995,
0.3317718804,
0.0357764326,
0.331050247,
0.02452817,
0.0529112294,
-0.2830159366,
-0.1301017702,
-0.3435360193,
-0.7919362783,
0.0933575854,
0.5761169195,
0.6387062073,
0.3698335886,
-0.1074616089,
0.4815452695,
-0.3113506436,
0.4358504117,
0.1033887193,
-0.7956729531,
0.1982932687,
-0.6919630766,
0.1737792343,
0.1698784679,
0.3986783922,
-0.7426863313,
-0.8423168659,
-0.8875025511,
-0.7333421707,
0.4907009602,
0.5080702305,
-0.0505232699,
-0.1318100393,
0.6628258228,
0.0132841198,
-0.009663851,
-0.6172383428,
-0.4608114064,
0.150235787,
0.1008734256,
-0.0673260689,
-0.0698940605,
-0.4088234007,
-0.2807432115,
0.0860292986,
-0.0717768446,
0.3710375726,
0.2794748545,
-0.224735558,
-0.2979592681,
0.1803504825,
0.7482586503,
0.806851387,
0.1500409544,
0.1537271291,
-0.2760635614,
-0.3510786593,
0.062352553,
-0.2541669011,
-0.1471367925,
0.0376448408,
0.6031301618,
0.5719664693,
0.2250592262,
0.0036143276,
0.1004971936,
0.2149640024,
0.0680274814,
-0.0087787434,
0.36476776,
-0.0740882456,
0.1651169807,
0.1213908195,
0.1413114965,
0.4976717532,
-0.991753161,
0.2804379463,
0.5845094919,
0.09244553,
-0.5307913423,
0.3301836252,
0.2531636655,
-0.7151378989,
0.4874025285,
-0.3024716675,
-0.6075527072,
0.4292942286,
0.7028140426,
1.1431207657,
0.1451230645,
0.1426535696,
0.3235249519,
0.3551213443,
0.4025409222,
0.3419617414,
-0.4842047989,
-0.6313816309,
-0.3129223883,
-0.5703960657,
-0.2490150928,
-0.5444374681,
-0.4868205786,
0.0741541237,
-0.2630570531,
-0.0254284386,
0.2331728637,
-0.0409582704,
-0.3958995342,
-0.0793001354,
-0.0229845084,
0.6849077344,
-0.5792417526,
0.6311530471,
0.5681034923,
-0.1633707583,
-0.7597684264,
0.1026190296,
0.1635801345,
-0.7284026146,
0.550963521,
-0.0463199578,
-0.4455456734,
0.3324081898,
-0.2492342293,
-0.9719042182,
0.521995008,
0.7575464249,
-0.2758779526,
-0.2713873386,
0.0243150443,
0.6008982062,
-0.3330612779,
-0.0963484421,
0.6727710366,
0.4799075127,
-0.457683146,
-0.9347034693,
0.4224191904,
-0.3819013536,
0.0808300376,
0.8827274442,
-0.6975085139,
0.3772912025,
-0.4186478257,
-0.8841423988,
0.1214430034,
0.0051772813,
-0.3429980278,
-0.2091867626,
0.3200578094,
0.5484580398,
0.5964082479,
-0.4018215537,
1.4059218168,
-0.5136517882,
0.3661193252,
0.4363307655,
0.3013787568,
0.2007611394,
0.3346801698,
-0.2274820209,
0.6281499863,
0.5167027712,
0.3344124556,
0.2270224541,
0.5624524355,
0.2813026309,
-0.3266719878,
-0.3557537794,
-0.1387583464,
0.6850044727,
0.1139933094,
0.1169614866,
-0.4519504905,
-0.5836812854,
0.1132172346,
0.0471187942,
0.1711999327,
0.9046468735,
0.0170156211,
-0.6378679276,
1.0473947525,
-0.3123356104,
0.1358059347,
-0.5663451552,
-0.0120381461,
-0.4407573342,
-0.3018000424,
-0.3159533441,
-0.4870639443,
0.5547420979,
-0.3610918224,
-0.0020539793,
-0.1126535311,
0.5787618756,
-0.3475399315,
0.0351867937,
0.3307659626,
0.5181875825,
0.6707659364,
0.4788896143,
-0.3522301316,
0.0316542946,
-0.2005694956,
-0.274525255,
0.0850408301,
0.4807220399,
-0.340254426,
0.4883674681,
0.8921589851,
0.3296872973,
0.2662932277,
0.1583131999,
0.737883985,
-0.8003014922,
-0.6116116643,
-0.7076789737,
0.4717011452,
-0.014593984,
-0.5289612412,
0.6274783015,
0.5189477205,
0.827418685,
0.2966356575,
0.2285352498,
0.0071761003,
-0.0850797147,
-0.46122545,
0.6991336942,
-0.6324603558,
-0.185553059,
-0.4921712577,
-1.0853136778,
-0.5474669337,
0.4056580961,
0.2329208404,
-0.0866947547,
1.0345890522,
0.5921791196,
-0.009400567,
-0.1533766538,
0.5221181512,
0.3115397692,
0.0366435945,
0.3784586191,
0.4012987316,
-0.0343574956,
0.4402520657,
-0.3099551201,
-0.5529940724,
-0.1066400185,
-0.4725602567,
-0.4426681399,
-0.7283737063,
-0.1493139565,
-0.1197691485,
0.4145854712,
0.7454638481,
0.5852632523,
-0.397726655,
-0.6030299664,
-0.4511953294,
0.4094368219,
-0.2391427159,
-0.2285063416,
0.4753044248,
-0.5785985589,
-0.6140760779,
0.5037023425,
0.5868201256,
0.0818988457,
-0.0150036132,
0.1679618508,
-0.1948520839,
0.1240794286,
0.3758844137,
0.4606100023,
-0.508540988,
-0.2187119424,
0.0237353146,
-0.0275325663,
0.2516109049,
1.1227362156,
-0.275514245,
0.4497677982,
0.7156900764,
0.3099505305,
0.1118820459,
-0.1105912104,
0.862682879,
-0.6367708445,
0.3427064121,
-0.0566905402,
0.4417801797,
0.2250288129,
-0.3374315798,
0.8026080132,
0.6352730393,
-0.5166435242,
-1.0032646656,
0.6409047246,
-0.9020642638,
-0.0094701648,
0.764377594,
0.0843407884,
-0.2134094238,
-0.3460542262,
0.0202384554,
0.5255355835,
-0.1986812353,
0.7878060937,
0.5293750763,
-0.6691593528,
0.1580838263,
-0.1709736288,
0.7404991388,
0.4118072391,
-0.6517712474,
0.0337715372,
0.372905314,
0.1912234873,
0.4566652775,
0.915489912,
-0.0403740108,
0.6069197655,
0.0777556747,
-0.1197097003,
0.1125966683,
-0.6818763018,
-0.3186748922,
0.0928756371,
0.2233117372,
-0.2024082541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00119v1 | Machine Translation Impact in E-commerce Multilingual Search | 2023-01-31T21:59:35 | 2023-01-31T21:59:35 | Bryan Zhang, Amita Misra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Previous work suggests that performance of cross-lingual information
retrieval correlates highly with the quality of Machine Translation. However,
there may be a threshold beyond which improving query translation quality
yields little or no benefit to further improve the retrieval performance. This
threshold may depend upon multiple factors including the source and target
languages, the existing MT system quality and the search pipeline. In order to
identify the benefit of improving an MT system for a given search pipeline, we
investigate the sensitivity of retrieval quality to the presence of different
levels of MT quality using experimental datasets collected from actual traffic.
We systematically improve the performance of our MT systems quality on language
pairs as measured by MT evaluation metrics including Bleu and Chrf to determine
their impact on search precision metrics and extract signals that help to guide
the improvement strategies. Using this information we develop techniques to
compare query translations for multiple language pairs and identify the most
promising language pairs to invest and improve. | [
-0.3304994702,
-0.7215798497,
0.2229589671,
0.1591214091,
-0.2511470914,
0.2457009852,
-0.0857078433,
-0.7934049368,
0.2979522645,
0.4461033046,
-0.4054504335,
-0.2431274951,
-0.6989946961,
0.3968037665,
-0.2627200782,
0.6170909405,
0.0709840134,
0.1134416163,
0.218751207,
-0.2611773908,
-0.5369123816,
-0.816293776,
-0.5996748805,
0.1452995539,
0.5095700622,
0.3390561938,
0.7260249853,
0.2017974406,
1.0419048071,
0.2619028687,
0.2108789235,
0.3109627068,
-0.7007519007,
0.2709470689,
-0.0906017572,
-0.5568454862,
-0.3401507437,
-0.0560341254,
0.5624290109,
0.5403815508,
-0.3988811374,
0.1821360141,
0.1303747445,
0.881930232,
-0.6535525322,
-0.0090784859,
-0.6684067249,
-0.0086601311,
-0.3110888898,
-0.5218217969,
-0.5305856466,
-0.2631186545,
0.0519437492,
-0.5918254256,
0.2667701542,
0.4778403938,
1.0255306959,
0.077366218,
-0.6659998894,
-0.2812930942,
-0.614330411,
0.8486769795,
-0.5399678946,
1.0253517628,
0.3552814126,
0.2067082971,
-0.1077052802,
-0.6002152562,
-0.1204369441,
0.1287536323,
-0.4241620302,
0.227123633,
-0.213781625,
-0.2020701617,
0.095130384,
0.3218252659,
-0.7923035622,
-0.1513482332,
-0.539824605,
-0.1798162013,
0.6630362272,
0.277911216,
0.3182169497,
-0.0051171756,
-0.1406662464,
-0.3817582428,
-0.5689427257,
0.1638391018,
0.3264242113,
0.551271975,
0.1830337048,
0.6242178082,
-0.3187455237,
0.6881845593,
0.0540439412,
-0.1692881286,
0.3896906674,
-0.6095845699,
-0.0956937596,
-0.027881952,
0.68229568,
0.5536828637,
-0.2000533342,
-0.2322989553,
-0.3396191001,
-0.4114802182,
0.4544392824,
-0.7599467039,
0.2350934446,
0.1291377246,
-0.7088356614,
0.1297571212,
0.4981766939,
-0.6070070863,
0.06140038,
-0.2771161199,
0.4161468744,
-0.1596304029,
-0.4355663657,
0.0895235389,
-0.336332798,
0.2198336422,
0.0503049046,
-0.665712893,
0.0952540562,
0.4957909584,
0.8168495297,
-0.1831807494,
-0.1960360408,
-0.629881084,
0.3106697798,
-0.3102715611,
0.5856273174,
-0.4592244327,
-0.5047795773,
0.0171320252,
0.2588082254,
-0.2662834823,
-0.7196445465,
0.8999700546,
-0.9704050422,
0.1256512552,
-0.2688586116,
-0.2359453738,
-0.4590910971,
0.2882719636,
-0.7476983666,
1.0612552166,
0.0466998257,
-0.4464863241,
0.5468776226,
-0.5139561892,
-0.8533790708,
0.2103827298,
0.4012800157,
-0.3495370746,
0.3857298493,
0.2399511039,
0.3157210648,
-0.3203314841,
-0.0219525639,
-0.1869813949,
-0.3492585719,
0.2287849933,
-0.272872895,
0.5216920376,
0.31131953,
-0.2930786312,
-0.1672692597,
-0.485703826,
0.3163620532,
0.0028660228,
-0.5334693193,
-0.5004164577,
-0.1144115701,
0.2976467609,
0.2632673681,
0.2196946889,
-0.3202641308,
-0.0354918689,
-0.3416749835,
0.2980959713,
0.4714465141,
-0.106511116,
0.1253495663,
-0.17587246,
0.6640274525,
-0.0846965164,
0.3438595235,
0.052076187,
-0.7528618574,
-0.5548993945,
0.04548705,
0.4992601871,
0.5102926493,
-0.6912319064,
0.1174567938,
-0.4774504602,
-0.1596105248,
-0.97416538,
0.2123146057,
0.3766351044,
0.1205039471,
0.4258264899,
-0.640270412,
-0.3995930851,
-0.9107928276,
-0.5178303719,
0.0309121106,
-0.0338976644,
0.4159420431,
0.1504623145,
-0.0850861445,
0.4597277641,
-0.3876209557,
-0.3462394774,
-0.0918672755,
-0.0498435423,
0.3017617166,
0.2561480403,
0.4015467763,
-1.101021409,
-0.8602874875,
0.2951776683,
-0.4835197628,
-0.0473505519,
0.2982152104,
-0.3893369138,
0.4671324492,
0.2701957822,
-0.3267870545,
0.4352849722,
0.7192547321,
-0.1486552805,
0.346878171,
-0.40987131,
1.0025323629,
-0.759378016,
0.2975133657,
0.0695609599,
-0.0302336775,
-0.6089448929,
0.2782150209,
0.3698751628,
-0.0124092791,
-0.6656352282,
0.1306785345,
-0.2631673813,
-0.2512780428,
0.0133306636,
0.2777623236,
0.3965643942,
0.1548355222,
-0.2059241384,
0.9749013782,
-0.0363835804,
-0.7737064362,
0.0858528391,
0.1416755915,
-0.3156933188,
0.9033077955,
-0.6903401017,
-0.0038374709,
0.2246039808,
-0.0719328895,
-0.893802464,
0.003645164,
0.2155770361,
-0.7851148844,
0.4938839972,
-0.2737181187,
-0.8860926628,
-0.3324494958,
-0.1193821952,
0.3855964839,
0.1971019357,
-0.3241926134,
0.1467099488,
0.355068177,
-0.1750757992,
-0.5806009769,
-0.8250685334,
0.3947538733,
-0.1616178006,
-0.8524819613,
0.2321386486,
-0.0995153859,
-0.0631291792,
-0.040238928,
0.134327665,
0.0544341914,
0.3381446004,
-0.2730198801,
0.0762848854,
-0.2109692246,
0.0826767758,
0.3012877703,
-0.253290385,
-0.059541896,
-0.5760592222,
0.5448256135,
-0.0226549469,
-0.4634797573,
-0.4112551212,
0.4022948146,
0.3395792246,
-0.7266889811,
0.9272074103,
0.542860508,
-0.1903478801,
0.3652548492,
-0.5407029986,
-0.1161521152,
-0.4486839771,
0.1713110656,
-0.7625546455,
-0.7214188576,
0.203691408,
0.1763076782,
-0.2504180074,
0.7189113498,
0.3390029371,
-0.0876580626,
1.5594136715,
0.6421545148,
0.1329332888,
0.240396902,
-0.1136256084,
0.4049758613,
-0.7785555124,
-0.48159042,
-0.8418326974,
-0.4324857593,
-0.925555408,
-0.2606106699,
0.424438715,
0.2304421216,
-0.0325330049,
0.456810683,
-0.5006039143,
0.1070233732,
0.8712191582,
0.281524688,
0.6003564596,
0.3824127018,
-0.221710816,
-0.2839339375,
-0.6389245987,
-0.3361740112,
1.2563701868,
-0.0418914109,
0.3643659055,
0.6180791259,
0.2024169415,
0.3280810416,
0.09354119,
-0.6366234422,
0.0065574576,
-0.197538659,
-0.8655911684,
-0.1679705381,
-0.7922064066,
-1.2576755285,
0.3417912126,
-0.1423736215,
-0.4563384354,
0.0397680029,
-0.2097150534,
0.0541095622,
0.1228268147,
-0.5799723864,
0.8608495593,
-0.7977340221,
-0.6231404543,
-0.5269554853,
-0.6149668694,
-0.0812387764,
-0.2150840014,
0.4705675244,
0.1540497094,
-0.1503739655,
0.3983444273,
-0.1502203494,
0.2779630125,
0.1355163455,
-0.0437520631,
-0.0880302936,
0.3175985217,
0.5114696026,
-0.3232890964,
-0.3657975793,
0.4319451153,
0.0559208654,
-0.6994264126,
-0.4819984734,
0.5655243993,
-0.5320560932,
-0.6229192019,
-0.0718037635,
-0.4601389766,
-0.0326047949,
0.4936987162,
0.2416652292,
0.1399766207,
-0.1046694219,
0.2746156156,
0.3942272067,
-0.2903677821,
0.271730572,
0.5948790908,
-0.2642783225,
-0.6498893499,
0.9318141937,
0.1991081685,
0.4850995243,
0.728272438,
0.1352717131,
-0.5966774225,
-0.4655388296,
-0.8960447311,
0.1579883844,
-0.6416577697,
-0.1517967433,
-0.540700376,
0.2767502666,
-0.6371157765,
0.067083329,
-0.0292494595,
-0.4172655642,
0.0573407821,
0.0447840355,
0.1591050625,
0.7368523479,
-0.0538271405,
0.4204398394,
-1.1055480242,
-0.082017675,
-0.0649590418,
0.4142926037,
-0.1283257306,
-0.6408860087,
-0.8254975677,
0.336710155,
-0.4297398925,
-0.5343831182,
0.6699235439,
0.0488000065,
0.8241454959,
0.5364516377,
-0.0856455415,
0.7715333104,
-0.2749888301,
0.6036351323,
0.2259945422,
-0.8870962858,
0.6266813874,
-0.2062050849,
0.0150267445,
0.604824543,
0.6090380549,
-0.6576421261,
-0.1732579172,
-0.4690605402,
-0.7374084592,
0.6356914043,
0.3824456334,
-0.0066354345,
0.219163388,
0.163171187,
0.1311775744,
0.4830388725,
-0.27279827,
-0.336268574,
0.0731802434,
0.1462171078,
-0.3830107152,
-0.073558487,
0.0407483876,
-0.1861615628,
0.7201499343,
0.0524833165,
-0.1315006912,
-0.0034491881,
-0.5010700822,
-0.3391179144,
0.128937602,
0.4974144697,
0.6364675164,
-0.1257323325,
-0.083558023,
0.138101235,
-0.3713619113,
0.0672870874,
-0.0772077069,
-0.1715436727,
0.1034201831,
0.0889495611,
0.3600969315,
-0.103318505,
-0.5003564954,
0.3105394244,
-0.1573128104,
0.0597363375,
0.218822524,
-0.3750373125,
-0.1098788828,
-0.0618356653,
0.4390832186,
-0.0384450555,
0.6651548147,
-0.6121762991,
0.2418246865,
0.3815917671,
-0.6394127607,
-0.1668120325,
0.5956994295,
0.2428296357,
-0.5805633664,
0.8420683742,
-0.1516981721,
-0.7736591101,
0.5007298589,
0.4728262424,
0.6457318068,
-0.4863137007,
0.0084962249,
0.4827336371,
0.7228213549,
-0.0309579261,
0.208984673,
0.2832326591,
-0.3586417437,
-0.4932385683,
-0.3677612543,
-0.3339625895,
-0.4628431499,
-0.7797074914,
0.4611956775,
0.1311798692,
-0.3597240746,
-0.392111063,
0.2312583476,
-0.8415455818,
0.1670744419,
-0.1948398203,
0.4546326101,
-0.4607471526,
0.4670725167,
0.6985456347,
-0.6737650037,
-0.5406095982,
-0.1182974428,
-0.129658103,
-0.6349025965,
0.8144071698,
0.3441004157,
-0.3807340264,
-0.0323638767,
0.0162915476,
-0.9694156647,
0.8406270742,
0.2131454945,
-0.6701639295,
0.4822436869,
0.6660142541,
0.5465915799,
-0.0992321819,
0.5139297247,
0.4276749194,
0.6426500082,
-0.2693662941,
-1.2458944321,
-0.0163561963,
-0.1888388842,
-0.1098972484,
0.676135242,
-0.7593226433,
0.4119853377,
-0.1011814997,
-0.4661845565,
-0.090135254,
-0.0479011126,
-0.0716026425,
0.6708412766,
0.2036333233,
0.7187539935,
0.6946468353,
-0.1219719797,
1.2038514614,
-0.7225356698,
0.4249610007,
0.7099224329,
-0.1257368922,
1.2334346771,
0.521705687,
-0.2850311697,
0.2953362763,
0.8350902796,
0.1960737705,
0.4024640918,
0.2017829865,
0.0003240994,
-0.3049800992,
-0.2183781117,
-0.4737659991,
0.1159821302,
0.5385767221,
-0.3902398944,
0.176776439,
-0.0614535362,
-0.2273896635,
-0.0306154285,
-0.1177703589,
0.6416047215,
-0.006595497,
-0.5089226961,
0.641576767,
0.1948248297,
0.5434637666,
-0.1324258894,
0.0474520288,
-0.3624391854,
0.1974976361,
-0.3573258221,
-0.5302308202,
0.3591050208,
-0.2908391058,
-0.0954369903,
-0.2204871923,
0.4173638225,
-0.2008797526,
-0.7879575491,
0.74074018,
0.904835403,
0.3343980312,
-0.3143212795,
-0.9337954521,
0.1380431801,
-0.1778606772,
-0.2346657813,
0.2734346092,
0.6660683751,
0.119522661,
0.5355728269,
0.9953471422,
-0.0598657355,
0.2733233869,
-0.027003793,
0.4253697991,
-0.7380989194,
-0.2132824957,
-0.5763641,
0.3943079114,
-0.1649917066,
-0.1914392561,
0.8905096054,
1.0879781246,
1.1923489571,
0.2677153051,
0.7666713595,
0.1236609742,
0.45942536,
-0.3566371799,
0.7320901752,
-0.996510148,
0.4130055904,
-0.2694776356,
-0.9616266489,
-0.4595773518,
0.27760005,
-0.1147522107,
-0.1435199529,
0.8834477663,
1.0111343861,
-0.3227758408,
-0.1039351299,
0.6309905052,
0.0815546587,
0.1947891265,
0.2627671957,
0.7808493972,
-0.8559068441,
1.0638682842,
-0.1605878919,
-0.0574606434,
-0.468773216,
-0.4878206849,
-0.4143414199,
-0.4101562202,
-0.1863992214,
-0.4945884943,
0.2367229313,
0.5899550915,
0.6837848425,
-0.769507587,
-0.5832821131,
0.3663832545,
0.1686214209,
-0.4399824142,
-0.2219545841,
0.3341998458,
-0.5179889202,
-0.721578896,
0.2749731243,
0.4293397665,
-0.1837490499,
-0.0733683854,
-0.2509484887,
-0.207419917,
-0.1819794327,
0.9683345556,
-0.1832635105,
-0.5998424292,
-0.0845039263,
0.663942337,
-0.2289184332,
0.3195702434,
0.8314981461,
-0.3179971576,
0.6445965767,
0.485388577,
0.670622468,
0.6851982474,
-0.169162631,
0.763050139,
-0.3377750814,
-0.1297663301,
-0.0702129602,
0.2003916204,
0.2864561081,
-0.3097527027,
0.7169080973,
0.3070952594,
-0.5391036868,
-0.6049432755,
0.1542912871,
-0.7144541144,
-0.28080827,
1.029935956,
-0.2121442705,
0.0213304684,
-0.3997990191,
-0.1202460751,
0.1243535429,
-0.5119363666,
0.7173948288,
0.6558221579,
-0.0640645325,
-0.0989811048,
-0.8377300501,
-0.1632099003,
0.419178009,
-0.4339828193,
-0.3838573396,
0.3998270333,
0.0176284779,
0.0711909011,
0.1188518256,
-0.2162128985,
0.1477371305,
-0.1946902126,
0.0759865195,
0.3800439239,
-0.0549641959,
-0.17663306,
0.2250014544,
0.2333876193,
-0.087530829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00102v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00102v3 | Towards Detecting Harmful Agendas in News Articles | 2023-01-31T21:08:58 | 2023-08-02T17:16:48 | Melanie Subbiah, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Yilun Hua, Tharindu Kumarage, Huan Liu, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Manipulated news online is a growing problem which necessitates the use of
automated systems to curtail its spread. We argue that while misinformation and
disinformation detection have been studied, there has been a lack of investment
in the important open challenge of detecting harmful agendas in news articles;
identifying harmful agendas is critical to flag news campaigns with the
greatest potential for real world harm. Moreover, due to real concerns around
censorship, harmful agenda detectors must be interpretable to be effective. In
this work, we propose this new task and release a dataset, NewsAgendas, of
annotated news articles for agenda identification. We show how interpretable
systems can be effective on this task and demonstrate that they can perform
comparably to black-box models. | [
-0.2875780761,
-0.9096688032,
0.546295464,
0.1396318525,
-0.3098967075,
-0.2182771415,
0.1487309784,
-0.8461728692,
0.2711002231,
0.7753821611,
-0.4952896535,
-0.5172936916,
-0.8209475875,
0.0452609845,
-0.8070554137,
1.2610266209,
0.0201330148,
-0.3152973652,
0.1418608427,
-0.013452854,
-0.5404045582,
-0.074136287,
-0.5435010195,
-0.2802079618,
0.4912112951,
0.0401292779,
0.7476509809,
1.0579309464,
0.2855756581,
0.1611298621,
-0.1367453188,
0.4176861346,
-0.5318517685,
0.1351780891,
-0.2054634392,
-0.4918248951,
-0.3139501214,
0.3116569817,
0.1397401243,
0.4437389076,
0.1063934267,
0.3789763451,
0.0203800295,
0.5812731981,
-0.4554553628,
0.2484517246,
-0.6997671723,
-0.0082615335,
-0.4163157344,
-0.1830873638,
-0.5382216573,
-0.4410122335,
-0.205967173,
-0.7687247992,
-0.2677368522,
0.2414869964,
0.7563945651,
0.3477706313,
-0.6953328848,
-0.621425271,
-0.6491953135,
0.6552203894,
-0.4698264301,
0.5067043304,
0.5924099088,
0.1156651452,
-0.3153703213,
-0.4228922725,
-0.4378862083,
0.1225941554,
-0.0861871913,
-0.1271110177,
-0.7888669372,
-0.2695451379,
0.2026213259,
-0.0764679983,
-0.4988208413,
0.3512949646,
-0.534152627,
-0.4908671081,
0.6852633953,
0.0600670874,
0.3186568618,
-0.5465170741,
-0.264051348,
0.4159311056,
-0.5770915747,
-0.2341955453,
0.8707075715,
0.2223361731,
-0.112565957,
0.5907171369,
-0.2332198918,
0.8952859044,
0.2833333313,
-0.0042302804,
0.2447550893,
-0.1028308719,
-0.1103304103,
0.292650193,
0.370210588,
0.8056849241,
0.1443643123,
0.0442282967,
-0.1987641007,
0.31676054,
0.5967989564,
-0.4827460051,
-0.2369118929,
0.3697746396,
-0.6957286596,
-0.4916338921,
0.1306310296,
-0.9122284651,
-0.6193771958,
-0.3462364674,
0.536275804,
-0.0517265052,
-0.0898772702,
0.223857224,
-0.5432834029,
-0.2683871984,
0.3706105649,
-0.3154914081,
-0.2466441989,
0.8339983821,
0.802921474,
-0.1079926565,
0.2856473327,
-0.5405769944,
0.104306601,
-0.3080178499,
0.7924759388,
-0.5306115746,
0.0253510512,
0.0447823219,
0.2028643191,
0.4272840619,
-0.3145293295,
0.6360170841,
-0.896232307,
0.2110144645,
-0.0593185425,
-0.423304528,
-0.5641488433,
0.4193419516,
-0.8782733083,
0.4381346703,
-0.0138581097,
-0.7447127104,
0.5115852356,
-0.8000000715,
-0.4784255624,
-0.1437691897,
0.3676746786,
-0.6891996861,
-0.0756380185,
0.3850765824,
0.3367801905,
0.4116959572,
0.414968282,
-0.1946308613,
-0.0872891992,
0.2544705868,
-0.7516179681,
0.9482200742,
0.4635569453,
-0.4124875069,
0.2628261745,
-0.7895408273,
-0.275930047,
-0.2056168169,
-0.4024383724,
-0.8239483237,
0.188988328,
0.1026345417,
0.1121219695,
0.2313743979,
-0.4436329603,
0.1053333879,
-0.213035807,
0.1484709531,
0.8531185389,
0.4746071994,
0.189058274,
-0.5540508032,
0.11053361,
0.2677006423,
0.385479182,
-0.0424619466,
-0.6509245038,
-0.503883779,
0.0027551835,
0.0752341002,
0.5864182115,
-0.9403554797,
0.5581089258,
-0.0513052903,
-0.5971782804,
-0.2784442902,
-0.044794824,
0.3378911912,
0.4374238849,
0.4670202434,
-0.0633694008,
-0.5675885677,
-0.9573762417,
-0.8572033048,
0.0464570634,
-0.1538674682,
-0.1205491945,
0.4574072063,
-0.1250144243,
0.6216871142,
-0.3987309039,
-0.3270685673,
0.2460769117,
0.5520293117,
0.2559209466,
0.2825056314,
0.4866129458,
-1.2483422756,
-0.2989658713,
-0.0570599772,
-0.685792923,
-0.4715555012,
-0.2792593837,
0.074004136,
-0.1201153025,
0.381593138,
-0.1217016727,
0.6690889597,
0.3183459342,
-0.6286023259,
0.5246748924,
0.1246244088,
0.3648324013,
-0.7266459465,
-0.0631301254,
0.2483208179,
-0.5361096859,
-0.8812671304,
-0.2903573513,
0.2172553539,
0.0639227852,
-0.8518491387,
0.2425548881,
-0.4192740023,
0.2172936946,
-0.4407140911,
0.1720214933,
0.1450465769,
0.1756064743,
-0.3177947402,
0.4532876909,
0.1688618511,
-0.7428712249,
0.3086323142,
0.554587841,
-0.5746395588,
0.7767474651,
-0.1584749222,
-0.1399112493,
-0.5297600627,
0.2460401654,
-0.4136033952,
-0.2999327183,
0.6450611949,
-0.2194343358,
0.0625944808,
-0.0575737581,
-0.0669920892,
-0.2765741348,
-0.367569387,
0.0940497369,
0.0400540568,
-0.4979500473,
0.2021703571,
0.8379160762,
0.327984184,
-0.7636978626,
-0.6775593758,
0.1594326347,
-0.4723621905,
0.035842631,
-0.0553582646,
0.3929255605,
-0.5338452458,
0.5106753707,
-0.1707760096,
0.098582387,
0.3270093501,
0.4155806899,
-0.0075598117,
0.037763264,
0.3011440635,
0.0660091415,
-0.2818247378,
0.1164652556,
-0.3681286573,
0.2284670919,
0.2962499261,
-0.3003601432,
-0.8420023918,
0.4392304718,
0.7670515776,
-0.4566725194,
0.6248255968,
0.5623966455,
-0.7498469949,
-0.0502826646,
-0.3130086958,
0.0266559254,
-0.3980228603,
0.5291144252,
0.2398492545,
-0.4422723055,
0.4226269722,
-0.0531399623,
0.1712839901,
0.5871860981,
0.4262988269,
0.3382154405,
1.2105755806,
0.299406141,
-0.3063723147,
0.6407708526,
-0.0171212126,
-0.0083470196,
-0.5632155538,
-0.2561833858,
-0.5368605852,
-0.468536377,
-0.4960727692,
-0.0896760523,
0.5065333843,
-0.252304554,
-0.2657244802,
0.3160645068,
-0.9908609986,
0.5613622069,
0.4534665048,
0.3325865567,
0.5451235771,
-0.1296612769,
0.6635504961,
0.1881402135,
-0.2229317278,
-0.872158587,
1.0376330614,
0.3182722628,
0.8895025253,
0.117721267,
0.1493775547,
0.8161612749,
0.8514530659,
-0.7152844071,
0.0991243199,
-0.1195724085,
-1.178432703,
-0.2190556228,
-0.1249761656,
-1.1772762537,
0.100670062,
-0.4346814156,
-1.1169124842,
0.5508472323,
-0.0252721831,
-0.1449190229,
0.6509752274,
-0.4697751701,
0.6285473704,
-0.3633743525,
-0.27027753,
-0.2878258526,
-0.3892296851,
0.2751266062,
-0.2839318514,
0.4884850681,
-0.2919510305,
-0.2166971117,
1.0655448437,
0.1077641845,
1.0020849705,
-0.3135925233,
-0.1186076477,
0.2101317644,
-0.0162871946,
0.5107530355,
0.0776635483,
-0.4887701273,
0.4118152559,
-0.0961005315,
-0.1598500311,
-0.1325645,
0.4754281938,
-0.4635362923,
-0.7862914205,
-0.4224099517,
-0.8399326801,
0.147807017,
0.6539248824,
0.1179403961,
0.5685545206,
-0.0393910371,
0.2835556269,
0.3726390302,
0.0912072659,
0.2779901624,
0.4980757236,
-0.3253705204,
-0.0704611167,
0.7586541772,
0.5536990166,
-0.0993153378,
0.2983445525,
0.0645488277,
-0.3059034646,
-0.8505529165,
-0.507692337,
-0.3571873605,
-0.587433517,
-0.4773250222,
-0.573073864,
0.1315779835,
-0.0010841676,
0.0157754403,
-0.1121653691,
-0.2561454773,
-0.8253563643,
-0.1355608851,
0.2976136804,
1.0786474943,
-0.3351744711,
0.4156858027,
-0.6837599874,
0.4877342284,
0.1043598801,
0.384187609,
-0.267411232,
-0.1123930886,
-0.1678895652,
0.4522200823,
-0.6973063946,
-1.413220048,
0.4788332283,
-0.1972433627,
0.6128889322,
1.0037111044,
0.5355778337,
0.3959174454,
-0.2156355381,
0.6073064208,
-0.1315145046,
-0.8023388982,
0.6720468402,
-0.5661139488,
-0.0803464949,
0.458948791,
0.8342778087,
-0.4620914757,
-0.6654734015,
-0.5357307196,
-0.5056043863,
0.6627824306,
0.0133974105,
0.0846383944,
-0.1877658963,
0.421313405,
0.4807225168,
0.4946294129,
-0.6868975163,
-0.3512208462,
-0.2421474159,
-0.24767524,
0.1213517264,
-0.2894170284,
-0.246312499,
0.2262157053,
0.8831289411,
0.1174648479,
0.0943469852,
0.1810475588,
-0.1627254784,
-0.4276694059,
0.2056456953,
0.4610130787,
0.72003299,
-0.1024577096,
0.3723789155,
-0.2252915055,
-0.5407814384,
0.2386202216,
0.1008982435,
-0.5419832468,
-0.1378222853,
0.3171475232,
0.7474548817,
0.0854428336,
-0.2737432718,
0.491602838,
0.2026873231,
-0.0934810489,
-0.1744919717,
0.0613434911,
-0.1572259963,
0.3566732407,
0.5588867664,
0.1449914128,
0.3592282832,
-0.5993839502,
0.5131178498,
0.6776412725,
-0.7799479365,
-0.2810473144,
0.9181314707,
0.2463232875,
-0.6948927641,
0.3007992506,
-0.3921723664,
-0.7683636546,
0.6590816379,
0.6319311261,
0.1749563664,
-0.2586825788,
0.2799929678,
0.0028173903,
0.7486959696,
-0.0062445332,
0.1208396852,
0.3036740124,
-0.7084287405,
-0.1683341712,
-0.1953415722,
-0.2874942422,
0.6527418494,
-0.7012511492,
0.2486062199,
0.0151031595,
-0.1231149435,
0.5814358592,
0.0167925004,
-0.3793025613,
0.1084197685,
-0.0100331437,
0.7916474938,
-1.2489936352,
0.3555145562,
0.6385337114,
-0.0503031611,
-0.4127496183,
0.1142815724,
0.4736708999,
-0.6224768162,
0.0266122036,
0.3710878193,
0.4193204641,
-0.0607729368,
-0.5537343025,
-0.5465282202,
0.6016485691,
0.2460541874,
-0.4248636067,
0.2446361929,
-0.0783838332,
0.2468752414,
0.0052118604,
-0.1487713903,
0.4456819296,
1.2386512756,
-0.5939494371,
-0.7436342239,
0.1205739826,
0.0345507078,
-0.7428018451,
0.7231545448,
-0.4369359612,
0.885144949,
0.19922328,
-0.3236112297,
-0.3170702159,
0.415235877,
-0.4790666699,
0.9063290954,
0.7193501592,
0.294054389,
0.8073758483,
-0.120761916,
0.7639858723,
-0.047922641,
0.3212418556,
0.5350409746,
0.1465047747,
0.380841136,
0.4524756372,
0.0252859797,
0.2035967112,
0.510479033,
-0.2155834138,
0.5036286116,
0.0195713006,
-0.1791880429,
-0.3772141635,
-0.3688301742,
-0.1367295384,
0.7730140686,
0.8412277699,
-0.3329991102,
-0.5601863265,
0.5418696404,
0.1799390167,
0.3434181511,
-0.6953670382,
0.5794908404,
-0.1857836097,
-0.5142222643,
-0.0446327887,
0.0397170074,
0.7118567228,
-0.4287061095,
-0.2727375627,
0.5041542053,
0.0532949194,
-0.4460829794,
-0.8663898706,
0.75999403,
-0.0238081161,
-0.1127380654,
-0.2907665372,
1.2081660032,
-0.3824833035,
-0.37306422,
-0.0240728837,
0.7197551727,
0.1272407919,
-0.1594175547,
-0.4927739203,
0.0897951722,
0.2129302621,
-0.5328518748,
0.0909980312,
0.1486487985,
-0.6010377407,
0.579671979,
0.9264634848,
0.0589850396,
-0.3729535043,
-0.5939962864,
0.7661318183,
-0.2819237709,
-0.8454979062,
-0.6829658747,
0.2442119569,
-0.2771626413,
-0.1679608077,
0.8492820859,
0.5829734206,
0.6155938506,
0.0015622353,
0.6807385683,
-0.0887319371,
0.5174213648,
-0.3680276275,
1.146967411,
-0.475614816,
0.1841226369,
0.1235044822,
-0.481122762,
-0.6008209586,
0.4647600949,
-0.6089273095,
-0.454549402,
0.2394784838,
0.6564996839,
-0.2231483757,
0.4069545567,
0.0731945708,
0.341222465,
0.4378356338,
0.1654776633,
0.8106651306,
-0.2335736006,
0.5840915442,
-0.3184399009,
-0.3214711249,
-0.4152131081,
-1.1873937845,
-0.8068381548,
-0.6057431102,
-0.3199559152,
-0.1744402051,
0.4156217873,
0.581037879,
0.54947716,
-0.8146672845,
0.4562190175,
0.0472755693,
0.7940382957,
-0.5044690371,
-0.2557580173,
0.587849915,
0.2276440412,
-0.8519799709,
0.2339796424,
0.1797362566,
-0.1279456913,
-0.2941690981,
0.5249559283,
-0.4980539083,
0.174507767,
0.4346018732,
0.3752539158,
-0.411634624,
-0.9783207774,
-0.4719352126,
0.1222750843,
-0.1850096583,
0.5488774776,
-0.827314198,
0.433794111,
0.2416874319,
0.4387901425,
0.2463182956,
0.1700035483,
0.064519383,
-0.7582446337,
0.3636292517,
0.2377391309,
0.066166997,
0.0871529505,
-0.8670941591,
0.2664607167,
-0.013469521,
-0.4575965405,
-0.9317023754,
0.1558790356,
-0.7918741107,
-0.328333348,
1.0700737238,
0.1266429871,
-0.5356464982,
-0.9473873377,
-0.3087131977,
0.5464765429,
-0.4152856469,
0.8689201474,
0.547849834,
-0.2560844123,
0.3823737502,
-0.7694963813,
0.2993251979,
-0.2304172814,
-0.8898692727,
0.036742989,
0.7499908805,
0.1245872229,
0.549705565,
0.2994543612,
-0.0055645159,
0.2178926617,
0.0368733481,
-0.2764179111,
-0.7551925182,
-0.2524711192,
-0.1164790466,
0.2166841924,
-0.5016074777,
-0.5394250751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00093v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00093v3 | Large Language Models Can Be Easily Distracted by Irrelevant Context | 2023-01-31T20:48:57 | 2023-06-06T08:36:20 | Freda Shi, Xinyun Chen, Kanishka Misra, Nathan Scales, David Dohan, Ed Chi, Nathanael Schärli, Denny Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models have achieved impressive performance on various natural
language processing tasks. However, so far they have been evaluated primarily
on benchmarks where all information in the input context is relevant for
solving the task. In this work, we investigate the distractibility of large
language models, i.e., how the model problem-solving accuracy can be influenced
by irrelevant context. In particular, we introduce Grade-School Math with
Irrelevant Context (GSM-IC), an arithmetic reasoning dataset with irrelevant
information in the problem description. We use this benchmark to measure the
distractibility of cutting-edge prompting techniques for large language models,
and find that the model performance is dramatically decreased when irrelevant
information is included. We also identify several approaches for mitigating
this deficiency, such as decoding with self-consistency and adding to the
prompt an instruction that tells the language model to ignore the irrelevant
information. | [
-0.4726628065,
-0.9486183524,
0.6975825429,
0.3340554535,
0.0492475629,
-0.4511961043,
-0.3075684607,
-0.331872493,
-0.424785763,
0.2862796485,
-0.5114272237,
-0.2168646008,
-0.7206140161,
-0.0328405201,
-0.2184072584,
0.6292099953,
-0.0595663004,
-0.1437250227,
-0.5267148614,
-0.1423550844,
-0.6641108394,
-0.6965426803,
-0.6491374373,
-0.1475506276,
0.2175831348,
0.4085235298,
0.5599545836,
0.8618709445,
0.2760593891,
0.3444226682,
-0.3469718695,
-0.09506163,
-0.4138838947,
0.1493254453,
-0.5413544178,
-0.3320525587,
-0.1988866478,
-0.1377307177,
0.6814257503,
0.9890066981,
0.0388471186,
0.1693151742,
0.0766750947,
0.7206766009,
-0.936034739,
0.5966866016,
-0.6098207235,
-0.3842681348,
-0.1598321944,
0.0024913165,
-0.641577661,
-0.0571240783,
0.0922180787,
-0.5366503596,
0.109811306,
-0.1900795549,
0.6372828484,
0.5006443262,
-0.1935772896,
-0.4281817377,
-0.7350900173,
0.8886055946,
-0.6341116428,
-0.105903469,
1.2190266848,
-0.1000396088,
0.0103697646,
0.0652880445,
-0.3165558279,
-0.0970708504,
-0.021177806,
-0.0914431438,
-0.2942101061,
0.0326050669,
0.6883704066,
-0.1603054702,
-0.0996139422,
-0.1971130371,
-0.3642474115,
0.0773722008,
0.2923403084,
0.1925908178,
0.3720878661,
-0.2471081764,
0.1916059107,
0.20423536,
-0.8746972084,
0.0932734683,
0.1340866089,
0.2291987389,
0.0130466418,
0.4668112993,
-0.2591716349,
1.0106517076,
0.0242892969,
-0.0706735626,
-0.032553155,
-0.1585958004,
-0.0974886641,
-0.162438646,
0.2859086692,
-0.0420592688,
0.3742904663,
-0.1223794818,
-0.1892924309,
-0.0010809097,
0.1170527562,
-0.8265308738,
-0.19896245,
0.2196860164,
0.0387866385,
0.269058913,
-0.4299173057,
-0.2817631662,
0.163761735,
-0.3634817898,
0.6418129802,
-0.4699490964,
0.0251287073,
-0.1635804921,
0.14216429,
-0.2363512516,
0.4103666246,
-1.0652962923,
0.1621111035,
0.7130155563,
0.7401878238,
0.15544568,
-0.2430921048,
-0.7230939269,
0.1562372297,
-0.6171030998,
0.5719107985,
-0.7185461521,
-0.3834187686,
-0.2470079064,
0.0599191785,
-0.4115209579,
-0.8041822314,
0.7694325447,
-0.4242995679,
0.0827191919,
-0.4691435099,
-0.6219487786,
-0.4929848611,
0.2555803359,
-0.5815297961,
0.8582213521,
0.0512917936,
-0.4712099135,
-0.1653070897,
-0.5011557937,
-0.4562691748,
0.0964023098,
-0.0418702401,
-0.0537938774,
0.2066673487,
0.2367566079,
0.3373733461,
-0.3071440458,
0.5470445156,
-0.2287747711,
-0.6787216663,
0.2250842601,
-0.6441323161,
0.5249208212,
0.1030722186,
-0.334857136,
-0.3105127513,
-0.8722730279,
0.0376207978,
0.0554890484,
-0.2352783084,
-0.7825305462,
0.1068854034,
-0.2898446321,
0.5856451392,
-0.0171240643,
-0.2141956687,
-0.1893464327,
-0.170177862,
0.5222761631,
0.6063141823,
-0.1759611368,
0.2826506197,
-0.5753679276,
0.3529118598,
-0.0112858033,
-0.263333112,
-0.5918390155,
-0.3384293616,
-0.760155499,
-0.3546402156,
0.1405542493,
0.4773923457,
-0.7447395325,
0.2450896949,
-0.376462549,
-0.1596348733,
-0.1282725185,
0.0394227542,
0.5027574301,
0.8805241585,
0.217467472,
0.3526791632,
-0.2513412237,
-0.812071979,
-0.4114818573,
0.1280756593,
-0.090389587,
0.3841311038,
0.4770807326,
0.0868003145,
0.8433920741,
-0.3362081349,
-0.1431055516,
0.0808970928,
0.120842196,
0.1805834025,
0.8035061955,
0.1869972497,
-0.7633177638,
-0.4087027609,
-0.3705624044,
-0.7351307273,
-0.2581615746,
0.0545530953,
0.204081431,
0.2170609981,
0.7679005265,
-0.7609623075,
0.6215032935,
0.3598159254,
-0.1852996945,
0.4865296781,
-0.2315749675,
0.0712533519,
-0.7063317299,
0.4583730698,
0.1599384099,
-0.0328495614,
-0.7594308853,
-0.1114556417,
0.2749671042,
-0.3926849365,
-0.3856535852,
0.8088533282,
-0.523860991,
0.2317545861,
-0.315186739,
0.2458587885,
0.2123447806,
0.4705599546,
0.1529272646,
1.0328038931,
0.3983215988,
-0.8368365169,
-0.4058447778,
0.1438727975,
-0.468773514,
0.5403526425,
-0.6208829284,
-0.1066711918,
-0.2984391749,
0.0920836926,
-0.9598023295,
-0.4300158322,
0.2122292966,
-0.2603739202,
0.210868597,
-0.36956653,
-0.3655492365,
-0.276412338,
0.0674067214,
0.7290628552,
0.4962075055,
-0.5814294815,
0.3589192927,
0.1238472238,
-0.6652209759,
-0.5302301049,
-0.5980665088,
-0.0744079724,
-0.1379454285,
-0.3936255276,
0.1935288161,
-0.2474065572,
-0.4624865949,
0.01205175,
-0.1998746544,
-0.436819315,
0.2101184875,
0.4004020691,
0.4084719718,
-0.1027276888,
0.7332234383,
-0.2396276593,
-0.1689958125,
0.4387442172,
0.0374229066,
0.3014887869,
0.0612101965,
-0.4890534878,
-0.5022700429,
0.360774368,
0.6047148705,
0.0582961626,
0.7888429761,
0.0344847739,
-0.6013903022,
0.089478679,
-0.6319417357,
0.0818981454,
-0.4462125301,
0.5984289646,
-0.4979714155,
-0.7262026668,
0.5592334867,
0.2058139592,
-0.0905371979,
0.3399688303,
0.3154425025,
0.398947984,
1.2154654264,
0.3237668574,
0.1346537024,
0.5752544999,
0.202875331,
0.2228394747,
-0.8485479355,
-0.0751618221,
-0.7543185353,
0.2861484587,
-0.0672752783,
-0.4564365149,
0.1077307835,
0.3221547604,
-0.4385865033,
0.0168093052,
-0.3949172497,
0.9016653895,
0.3900622129,
-0.1379766315,
0.2813089192,
-0.0657617077,
0.0458367653,
-0.2684468627,
-0.8862164021,
-0.4713148177,
0.8253728747,
0.1111692712,
0.648494184,
0.0428026021,
0.16741018,
0.017912792,
0.4443351328,
-0.8311240673,
0.3269632161,
-0.0269305762,
-0.8650916219,
-0.3956354558,
-0.8358669877,
-0.7763078809,
0.5003907084,
0.1387839317,
-1.1034270525,
0.0535438024,
0.0885958299,
-0.5174564719,
0.1655856371,
-0.956685245,
0.729783237,
0.1943711489,
-0.7173301578,
-0.0018197518,
-0.2064610273,
0.5355448723,
-0.24129951,
0.7418521047,
-0.4370594323,
0.0693840161,
0.4927323163,
-0.485494256,
0.6724931598,
-0.0234384835,
-0.27279374,
0.3777444065,
0.3687547743,
0.6963960528,
-0.080257304,
-0.3649674952,
-0.0514464229,
-0.1713465601,
-0.7079798579,
-0.413511008,
0.9415314198,
-0.4177516699,
-0.985812664,
-0.2744603157,
-1.0254939795,
-0.3697606027,
0.1777471304,
0.3209721148,
0.7921788096,
0.1211373433,
0.1647674888,
0.7289072871,
-0.1250191331,
0.8039113879,
0.4158869684,
0.0402835757,
-0.0497139245,
1.0945253372,
0.5480182767,
0.5552565455,
0.1690029502,
0.0319860615,
-0.4343993664,
-0.204559207,
-0.6355781555,
0.0750661641,
-1.0224947929,
0.1352417171,
-0.8204805851,
-0.2600957453,
-0.1266435832,
-0.1302617341,
-0.3390820026,
-0.4017874897,
-0.4530928135,
0.2490445971,
-0.0569982864,
0.7633915544,
0.011486195,
0.1967659742,
-0.8240070939,
0.0472795032,
0.3767110407,
0.359500736,
0.4917092621,
-0.6808622479,
-0.3135498762,
0.04469667,
-0.008956193,
-0.3665951192,
0.1761525422,
0.0046148947,
0.5025741458,
0.3599009812,
0.1478562951,
0.6763296127,
-0.423348546,
0.5350699425,
0.0519939661,
-1.444855094,
0.1807633489,
-0.5448326468,
1.0320239067,
0.4141699374,
0.2667458355,
-0.3901863992,
-0.3503199816,
-0.5195820332,
-0.7029209733,
1.0689482689,
0.2630693614,
0.1370826364,
-0.2399901152,
0.2930290401,
-0.1853290051,
-0.0090978416,
-0.9376330376,
-0.1872061044,
0.0441379286,
-0.1430080086,
-0.089900203,
-0.3479907811,
-0.1033047661,
-0.1713143587,
0.6516545415,
-0.0639565885,
0.0396247208,
0.0725530908,
-0.1083983555,
-0.2216465026,
0.3589503765,
0.9909293652,
1.0466303825,
0.0722276941,
0.3057198226,
0.284090668,
-0.3225151598,
0.3031959236,
0.1968300939,
-0.2571875751,
0.0877667144,
0.3417685032,
0.3605383337,
0.4113286436,
-0.9307858944,
0.4604417086,
0.0752567574,
-0.1273573488,
-0.0876323357,
0.0763222799,
0.3434697688,
-0.2198516726,
0.639123857,
0.2589548528,
-0.0263367295,
-0.3683225214,
-0.0976913944,
0.4350457191,
-0.5317309499,
-0.2185639292,
0.5957819819,
-0.0245116632,
-0.3317403495,
0.3877749443,
-0.2485601306,
-0.5647438169,
0.9734532833,
0.7178227305,
0.3784191906,
-0.2627158463,
0.0490441322,
0.5404370427,
0.3075260818,
-0.297007829,
-0.1788588762,
-0.1665298641,
-0.2574725449,
-0.7111712098,
0.1252971441,
-0.2110984474,
0.4702771902,
-0.6555040479,
-0.0012708586,
-0.5039314628,
-0.0048066792,
0.3056527078,
-0.3841483593,
-0.3954644203,
0.2867583334,
-0.0394222923,
0.6696936488,
-0.4794344008,
0.6848866343,
0.3344353437,
0.0172820278,
-0.8420205116,
0.1751375049,
-0.1321041137,
-0.4706956148,
0.7641510963,
0.4834325612,
-0.1471290141,
-0.142495513,
-0.5003657341,
-1.0584789515,
0.3358543813,
0.3720974624,
-0.5253921151,
0.1844981313,
-0.2612291276,
0.3993675709,
0.0026931067,
0.216335997,
0.3836714327,
0.4334540665,
0.347499162,
-0.763153255,
0.2962515652,
-0.3364144266,
-0.0800247416,
0.4259375334,
-0.7583835721,
1.2109336853,
-0.2193045616,
-0.3447379172,
0.0035621871,
-0.0675110891,
0.2163578421,
0.3342948258,
0.2072076648,
0.3151610196,
0.5398980975,
-0.0823680758,
0.8235630989,
-0.2355438471,
0.3980042934,
1.3682413101,
-0.2413960248,
0.7523342967,
0.3602692187,
0.037363641,
0.031955868,
0.3080487251,
0.3127405345,
0.379475981,
0.1114628017,
-0.545284152,
-0.5342748165,
-0.0481324494,
-0.5355083346,
0.339858979,
0.6467100382,
-0.1959865689,
-0.4693881571,
-0.1454547197,
0.3037699759,
0.1347246617,
-0.4570197761,
0.4268947542,
0.0906324983,
-1.2686423063,
1.0302273035,
0.1126878336,
0.2193040699,
-0.4583993852,
-0.0291289743,
-0.1436377019,
0.2412915081,
0.0419148803,
-0.3967039585,
0.4804534018,
-0.0972297117,
-0.5900632739,
0.0949980021,
0.4984064102,
-0.3655665815,
-0.4107636511,
0.0451237746,
0.6572057009,
-0.0146826729,
-0.2803821266,
-0.4797123969,
0.0005999382,
-0.0571575426,
-0.1563249826,
0.4944523871,
0.664886415,
-0.2330704927,
1.1540414095,
0.6171340346,
-0.2297003269,
-0.2139881998,
-0.3153978884,
0.7613429427,
-0.7355337143,
-0.5852755904,
-1.1491322517,
-0.1239539683,
0.1360292584,
-0.3371869028,
0.9916043282,
0.3937931061,
0.5465984344,
-0.0478174649,
0.7335898876,
0.1616115421,
0.5749700665,
-0.4656574428,
0.5502466559,
-0.3205114305,
0.5450796485,
-0.2358726263,
-0.7820649147,
-0.3400320113,
0.5118803382,
-0.7574722767,
0.3217567503,
0.6724542975,
0.6458813548,
-0.0157970097,
0.1656711102,
0.7174577117,
0.0734846592,
-0.046266377,
0.7583728433,
1.0668922663,
-0.165407747,
0.5986196399,
-0.1049291715,
-0.1138419211,
-0.4224773347,
-0.8490611911,
-1.1499723196,
-0.3832319677,
-0.2719454169,
-0.3375279903,
0.06605535,
0.7994559407,
0.9417031407,
-0.7836461663,
0.0919075236,
-0.1596495956,
0.4595674574,
0.0132528841,
-0.2304955572,
0.4063902795,
-0.4972945452,
-0.8595082164,
0.2463787347,
0.3643838465,
0.3667028844,
0.0040033287,
0.2540496588,
-0.2407132834,
0.2797323167,
0.579264462,
0.4219098985,
-0.6516939998,
-0.2505350113,
-0.159004733,
-0.2903083861,
0.1950268596,
0.6405138969,
-0.6242902279,
0.4389050901,
0.1303797513,
0.533639729,
0.2656096518,
0.4368976057,
0.3204054236,
-0.6087921262,
0.4539511204,
0.1529190689,
0.1584045887,
0.429059267,
-0.5183027387,
0.3400712311,
0.2066304833,
-0.5105937123,
-0.6008768678,
-0.0026370373,
-0.3336547613,
-0.6082234383,
1.1658718586,
-0.4888681471,
-0.4075968266,
-0.5873036385,
-0.2320805341,
-0.3016629219,
-0.3168635666,
0.8994601369,
1.402513504,
0.158626169,
-0.1994443387,
-0.8642815948,
0.5099942684,
0.9800851941,
-0.7754408717,
0.3762714863,
0.6458753347,
0.3773353994,
0.2200952917,
0.5032488108,
-0.0191556532,
0.4317732155,
0.342811197,
-0.2273500115,
-0.0190014672,
-0.2820334435,
-0.3945356309,
0.2428067923,
0.0453095548,
0.0206884444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00083v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00083v3 | In-Context Retrieval-Augmented Language Models | 2023-01-31T20:26:16 | 2023-08-01T12:10:15 | Ori Ram, Yoav Levine, Itay Dalmedigos, Dor Muhlgay, Amnon Shashua, Kevin Leyton-Brown, Yoav Shoham | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Retrieval-Augmented Language Modeling (RALM) methods, which condition a
language model (LM) on relevant documents from a grounding corpus during
generation, were shown to significantly improve language modeling performance.
In addition, they can mitigate the problem of factually inaccurate text
generation and provide natural source attribution mechanism. Existing RALM
approaches focus on modifying the LM architecture in order to facilitate the
incorporation of external information, significantly complicating deployment.
This paper considers a simple alternative, which we dub In-Context RALM:
leaving the LM architecture unchanged and prepending grounding documents to the
input, without any further training of the LM. We show that In-Context RALM
that builds on off-the-shelf general purpose retrievers provides surprisingly
large LM gains across model sizes and diverse corpora. We also demonstrate that
the document retrieval and ranking mechanism can be specialized to the RALM
setting to further boost performance. We conclude that In-Context RALM has
considerable potential to increase the prevalence of LM grounding, particularly
in settings where a pretrained LM must be used without modification or even via
API access. | [
-0.3335981965,
-0.8421259522,
0.5610784292,
0.0077493633,
-0.297575146,
0.1112592816,
-0.4116361737,
-0.5565744638,
-0.1830301136,
0.5933301449,
-0.0580933802,
-0.3410538435,
-0.4167021513,
-0.1087756529,
-0.425471127,
0.8223493099,
0.096670866,
-0.0843393952,
-0.6038274765,
-0.3658135235,
-0.4988394678,
-0.9981120825,
-0.2440476269,
-0.6540645361,
0.3793621063,
0.2846631408,
0.7203871012,
0.5076819658,
0.4185401797,
0.144158572,
-0.2604809105,
0.2649546862,
-0.3252034783,
0.3944295645,
-0.2580788434,
-0.4052695334,
-0.2391999513,
-0.0133835422,
0.6425535679,
0.783059597,
-0.1903848797,
0.048476208,
0.1262662113,
0.7732153535,
-0.9309136868,
-0.2126375735,
-0.6586512327,
-0.2836692333,
-0.1972766668,
-0.5801646709,
-0.8380606771,
-0.226212725,
0.0773605332,
-0.2609579861,
0.2668560147,
0.3224301934,
0.7504820228,
0.1360709965,
-0.3033304513,
-0.4250146747,
-0.8306596279,
0.7258430123,
-0.6948827505,
0.5106391907,
0.7288188338,
0.2444552481,
0.0579560287,
-0.6337398291,
-0.1184353679,
-0.4639263153,
-0.3970929086,
-0.1153852046,
0.0526182763,
0.0402430519,
0.3091195524,
0.3136444986,
-0.28424716,
-0.2164011449,
-0.1609728485,
0.0320323855,
0.2030652761,
-0.0499690771,
0.3680860698,
-0.0630686581,
-0.2440671325,
-0.0258856099,
-1.1052442789,
-0.0470433906,
0.1754774898,
0.6857579947,
0.165935725,
0.6435442567,
-0.1230012327,
0.8732292056,
0.0738060176,
0.0077823433,
0.2018046081,
-0.1706816405,
-0.3798508644,
0.0714112595,
0.2312883288,
0.0681560189,
-0.2420292944,
-0.38101542,
-0.5640779734,
0.0253414083,
0.3648273945,
-0.6909111142,
0.1083979532,
0.0026273285,
-0.3780787587,
-0.2766596377,
-0.0151474215,
-0.2446137816,
-0.187371552,
-0.5087552667,
0.5724897981,
-0.604547143,
-0.2361534536,
-0.1294799,
-0.0902520493,
0.2266522348,
0.258284241,
-0.687502861,
0.3199949563,
0.5783594251,
0.8932192326,
0.0338289142,
0.2008211911,
-0.7844780684,
0.2299838215,
-0.549268961,
0.7706946731,
-0.8654744625,
-0.5688570738,
0.190133065,
-0.2189152092,
0.0512596667,
-0.7120263577,
0.6173323989,
-1.0235985518,
0.3526054323,
-0.4153776467,
-0.5198276639,
-0.0690159723,
0.3547754586,
-0.4739707112,
1.3890805244,
0.0284497626,
-0.9158961773,
0.3564003706,
-0.6217951179,
-0.597822547,
0.0882839859,
-0.2148094326,
-0.1410449594,
0.2340299487,
0.1301064193,
0.1995540708,
-0.175626114,
0.425922662,
-0.021788124,
-0.6454232931,
-0.0626821369,
-0.321493715,
0.6875503063,
0.4042264223,
-0.2603919208,
-0.0235103015,
-0.8036250472,
0.056022305,
-0.1270040572,
-0.6094306707,
-1.0496346951,
0.2064538896,
0.0767877549,
0.2629325688,
0.1018959358,
-0.3411773443,
0.0252658781,
-0.7165770531,
0.1657263935,
0.2767467499,
-0.0670660362,
0.8988034129,
-0.3076976538,
0.4013581276,
-0.3034743369,
-0.2848931849,
-0.3695217669,
-0.2522847354,
-0.5889682174,
-0.4320313334,
0.0613828078,
0.3807127178,
-0.601518929,
0.2772552669,
-0.2592217326,
-0.3629879951,
-0.6027744412,
0.0587790906,
0.6371797919,
0.8519461751,
0.3944811225,
0.1017034724,
-0.6683853269,
-0.6684980989,
-0.3821670413,
-0.0108716628,
0.0882353261,
0.3834041953,
0.170379445,
-0.2474169582,
1.4775862694,
-0.0986391678,
-0.0849725232,
-0.3001247346,
0.1346605867,
0.2086542994,
0.5007168651,
0.5387004614,
-0.973798573,
-0.4552258253,
0.0412186049,
-0.8977493644,
-0.2761369944,
0.3847982883,
0.0397314616,
0.4163626134,
0.5490966439,
-0.5710421801,
0.4905686975,
0.3221950531,
-0.0869350508,
0.3598878384,
-0.7006021142,
0.1370845735,
-0.7221805453,
0.4231026471,
-0.4128094018,
-0.370949775,
-0.7806792855,
0.5643447638,
0.4332159162,
-0.3146779835,
-0.5428744555,
0.8522338867,
-0.6168284416,
-0.2612167597,
-0.5337713957,
0.190758571,
0.3479545712,
0.045180738,
0.2151341736,
1.0456957817,
0.4324037731,
-0.790558219,
-0.155491963,
0.1574124843,
-0.4308697283,
0.4029879272,
-0.5378912091,
0.42207551,
-0.5249462724,
0.4732364714,
-0.813650012,
-0.1022258326,
0.1411371678,
-0.2048328966,
0.4346258342,
-0.2945404649,
-0.4948845506,
0.0367769934,
-0.306286335,
0.5281472206,
0.5360907316,
-0.7502508163,
0.7609190345,
0.058172401,
0.1575217247,
-0.6096806526,
-0.8268694878,
0.1640261859,
-0.5383982062,
-0.6341755986,
0.5728664398,
-0.0825520977,
-0.5779730678,
0.0287157279,
0.0419268273,
0.1255173087,
0.210060209,
0.2860680223,
0.1452627033,
-0.3415049613,
0.3764092624,
-0.1495720148,
-0.1090277135,
-0.1896752864,
-0.0927773491,
0.5051048994,
-0.0345225632,
-0.3989489973,
0.037553668,
0.5015521049,
0.4667063355,
-0.4427937269,
0.9508167505,
0.1504341215,
-0.471154213,
-0.088442497,
-0.6745424867,
-0.1164463535,
-0.4890019298,
0.0713526234,
-0.4536983669,
-0.6887215972,
0.5026586652,
0.0571790189,
0.0005420952,
0.1961540282,
0.5049236417,
-0.1131541356,
0.8954917192,
0.8177791834,
0.0165951326,
0.5882457495,
-0.0040903408,
0.3809934556,
-0.9833412766,
-0.1877191514,
-0.7323809266,
0.1833953559,
-0.0956767648,
-0.478142947,
0.2390974313,
0.414219588,
-0.1785927564,
0.2217984796,
-0.4082687199,
0.4217602313,
0.4357936084,
0.0781480148,
0.5223523378,
0.1496045887,
-0.2301600724,
-0.0082402611,
-0.7233157158,
-0.7065380812,
1.0109924078,
0.1023936197,
0.6443407536,
0.114129521,
0.5416769385,
0.3353711069,
0.832131505,
-0.3815795481,
0.2598526478,
0.0382171385,
-0.8285423517,
-0.1160059124,
-0.1793331951,
-0.6035346389,
0.5768873692,
-0.0384692922,
-0.540935874,
0.1035917476,
0.240287438,
-0.3427812159,
0.1393777132,
-0.6653152704,
0.3763114214,
-0.1571036875,
-0.4474981725,
-0.2427828461,
-0.5310871601,
0.2943278849,
-0.2268949002,
0.6677126884,
0.045283597,
0.0235389099,
0.3417580724,
-0.5028954148,
0.5595697761,
-0.3418996632,
-0.2324550003,
0.3283341527,
0.0260118302,
0.7559995651,
0.0565078631,
-0.5572217107,
-0.2604874372,
-0.3492132723,
-0.2357673347,
-0.8325774074,
0.8158255219,
-0.6005158424,
-0.7285565734,
-0.2505769432,
-0.5630993247,
-0.2587519288,
0.2131592035,
0.5021234751,
0.8335068226,
-0.1361902207,
0.4399303496,
0.6260524392,
-0.273540169,
0.364369154,
0.6586433649,
-0.2913737297,
-0.1226861551,
0.6743189096,
0.1323528141,
0.3071900308,
0.5223146677,
0.120926924,
-0.5006132722,
-0.4913182557,
-0.2031551749,
0.0641580522,
-0.998306632,
-0.1580064446,
-0.8090913296,
-0.0494910143,
-0.3361879885,
-0.4416529536,
-0.3002880812,
-0.0921148211,
-0.3068848848,
-0.1144613177,
0.3605700135,
0.4475985467,
0.080969274,
0.324586302,
-0.6711599827,
0.1745827496,
-0.1360930949,
0.3449110985,
0.0124409404,
-0.814842999,
-0.3842890561,
0.2002841085,
0.1194057241,
-0.4944785237,
0.3442443609,
0.3228091002,
0.6023044586,
0.1569596231,
0.2426457703,
0.7872617245,
-0.6918759346,
0.6226238012,
-0.2864212394,
-0.7470762134,
0.6374379992,
-0.47492522,
0.0878364369,
0.5174916387,
0.1636258066,
-0.350105077,
-0.4286567569,
-0.4148420095,
-1.0530831814,
0.6914003491,
0.0885863677,
0.4591449499,
-0.2377202511,
0.4430700541,
-0.1017525569,
0.1440835595,
-0.6204628944,
-0.1967883259,
-0.0666828677,
0.1362353563,
-0.0608400404,
-0.4829305112,
-0.1529663503,
-0.2298882008,
0.7322174311,
0.1095414162,
0.1508126259,
0.2720024288,
-0.6306781769,
-0.2110869735,
0.2259226292,
0.6976748109,
0.8089704514,
-0.6278350353,
0.3314629197,
0.1138535514,
-0.0329133421,
0.2819434404,
-0.2747775614,
-0.3790294528,
0.207190305,
0.3448361754,
0.6090916991,
0.718960762,
-0.7299100161,
0.3320587575,
0.2480606884,
-0.0235566348,
-0.2353098691,
-0.0729735866,
-0.0102767926,
0.0140830902,
0.7097874284,
0.1708055735,
-0.00702187,
-0.5777848363,
0.4109593034,
0.4672682583,
-0.1555906087,
-0.1537761092,
0.7082133889,
0.0169464797,
-0.4680972099,
0.4340187609,
0.0411939546,
-0.258947432,
0.1846031398,
0.9441960454,
0.6466459036,
-0.1557343155,
-0.0784947574,
0.1866301149,
0.1483048797,
-0.3754161298,
-0.2119920403,
-0.1293143779,
-0.7905887365,
-0.394536525,
-0.491048038,
-0.2679424584,
-0.0184002277,
-0.7757108212,
0.3205047846,
-0.3354537487,
-0.1183817685,
-0.5495077968,
-0.1143102273,
-0.5503772497,
0.2792397738,
0.1311656237,
1.031535387,
-0.724632144,
1.0727757215,
0.8508675098,
-0.4079998136,
-0.388594538,
-0.0451801717,
-0.352691263,
-0.484822005,
0.8450178504,
0.17410402,
-0.3862445652,
0.1452375203,
-0.3855683208,
-1.0756970644,
0.9670765996,
0.4571880698,
-0.1656868458,
-0.1969771981,
-0.1159631386,
0.5211037993,
-0.5525516272,
0.3235215545,
0.3186528981,
0.2916930318,
-0.033610031,
-0.5115557909,
0.0366920456,
-0.1516786367,
0.2450913042,
0.03969137,
-0.2437257469,
0.758464396,
0.0828623623,
-0.4011830091,
0.0262431502,
0.5649594069,
0.4461131096,
0.239287138,
0.3386126459,
0.4350847304,
0.8282040358,
0.1957660317,
1.2735340595,
-0.4280002713,
0.2683364749,
1.1494848728,
-0.5322913527,
1.0520347357,
0.4784101844,
0.1975263655,
0.4530017376,
0.231458053,
0.6093236208,
0.8880254626,
-0.122097373,
-0.3829774559,
-0.2291511446,
-0.1097414121,
-0.692302227,
0.2076759487,
0.3605310917,
-0.3078370392,
-0.5405834913,
0.4019566774,
-0.1479501426,
0.5231579542,
-0.1247337312,
0.3932347,
0.1064142287,
-0.5079067945,
0.7242531776,
0.2731449008,
0.8582224846,
-0.515579164,
0.0466313176,
-0.3946706653,
0.0377732962,
-0.1550439745,
-0.1395102441,
0.6715691686,
0.1135551482,
-0.5207442641,
-0.6627759933,
1.1268926859,
-0.4091301858,
-0.3421526253,
0.4866862893,
0.5224909782,
-0.0041976511,
-0.1924889386,
-0.3260591924,
0.2285116911,
-0.4044200182,
-0.4900566638,
0.6759490967,
0.3598555326,
-0.2676785588,
0.7699647546,
0.8002098203,
-0.1618033648,
0.0001313588,
0.0884339809,
1.0008276701,
-0.5895556808,
-0.4694934189,
-0.9170725346,
0.5359544158,
0.099082835,
0.151418969,
0.889546454,
0.5961632729,
0.6410239935,
0.0305520538,
0.7847909331,
-0.1640994847,
0.6647264957,
-0.4616366923,
0.7725177407,
-0.6503181458,
0.4764699936,
-0.3991843164,
-0.9719156623,
-0.4552402496,
0.7351059318,
-0.4033873677,
-0.0739187896,
0.4906844497,
0.782831192,
-0.1615208983,
-0.3435270786,
0.5571815372,
-0.1101565585,
0.4197974801,
-0.0917771533,
0.8317413926,
-0.3473038077,
0.2517978251,
-0.0615156107,
-0.1247802377,
-0.4751378,
-1.0363054276,
-0.7235165238,
-0.3838511407,
-0.0458155572,
-0.2487591654,
0.1906365603,
1.0011079311,
0.6816997528,
-0.5883750319,
-0.0931843296,
-0.0226532705,
0.0331662074,
-0.0148569047,
-0.2300003767,
0.3130620718,
-0.6967955828,
-0.4515188634,
0.9608244896,
0.1665445566,
-0.2841882706,
-0.0087393736,
-0.2916818559,
-0.3784044683,
0.0071791005,
0.7608568668,
0.2529936731,
-0.8073603511,
-0.4714234769,
0.031135438,
-0.3049410582,
0.2051612586,
0.8863418102,
-1.1528685093,
0.3879772723,
0.3995670378,
0.8015652299,
0.3268311918,
0.414809376,
0.7321404219,
-1.138663888,
0.5372313857,
0.2188152224,
0.2089806795,
0.4787962437,
-0.3688517213,
0.3302056193,
0.1052226946,
-0.3039661944,
-1.1259682178,
-0.0206529479,
-0.4268131852,
-0.2347252667,
1.1336536407,
-0.0814990774,
-0.0111681502,
-0.3045520186,
-0.171376422,
0.1880527586,
-0.2132137716,
0.4973038435,
0.6752145886,
0.2962489724,
-0.0706957802,
-0.6222471595,
0.5515348911,
0.523976922,
-0.4618852735,
0.2056721449,
0.4225670695,
0.403643012,
0.1267751306,
0.9379011989,
-0.156759724,
0.0014359038,
-0.3163387775,
0.043289803,
-0.1985189915,
-0.3014094234,
-0.4295923412,
0.2672010362,
0.3633417487,
0.0513983965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13868v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13868v1 | PADL: Language-Directed Physics-Based Character Control | 2023-01-31T18:59:22 | 2023-01-31T18:59:22 | Jordan Juravsky, Yunrong Guo, Sanja Fidler, Xue Bin Peng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GR | Developing systems that can synthesize natural and life-like motions for
simulated characters has long been a focus for computer animation. But in order
for these systems to be useful for downstream applications, they need not only
produce high-quality motions, but must also provide an accessible and versatile
interface through which users can direct a character's behaviors. Natural
language provides a simple-to-use and expressive medium for specifying a user's
intent. Recent breakthroughs in natural language processing (NLP) have
demonstrated effective use of language-based interfaces for applications such
as image generation and program synthesis. In this work, we present PADL, which
leverages recent innovations in NLP in order to take steps towards developing
language-directed controllers for physics-based character animation. PADL
allows users to issue natural language commands for specifying both high-level
tasks and low-level skills that a character should perform. We present an
adversarial imitation learning approach for training policies to map high-level
language commands to low-level controls that enable a character to perform the
desired task and skill specified by a user's commands. Furthermore, we propose
a multi-task aggregation method that leverages a language-based multiple-choice
question-answering approach to determine high-level task objectives from
language commands. We show that our framework can be applied to effectively
direct a simulated humanoid character to perform a diverse array of complex
motor skills. | [
-0.2944781184,
-1.2612000704,
0.3191550076,
0.5927377343,
0.1869850457,
0.5975535512,
0.0542849973,
-0.2068428546,
0.4411691427,
0.4362767637,
-0.5781061649,
-0.3096286356,
-0.4336956739,
0.0600443222,
-0.28039518,
0.9927286506,
-0.2735901773,
0.0714486465,
0.2859093845,
0.2472263128,
-0.3535678089,
-0.5085964799,
-0.8192029595,
-0.6814634204,
0.475079149,
0.0806732848,
0.8343507051,
0.4874187112,
0.4726702869,
0.2645730972,
0.100696601,
0.462600112,
-0.4558601975,
-0.0775862038,
-0.3835398853,
-0.3207721412,
-0.4559069872,
-0.1044379324,
0.5856829882,
0.783074379,
-0.1096732691,
-0.4180761576,
-0.0836048201,
0.6603506207,
-0.4339335263,
0.101220943,
-0.0357953012,
0.5054624677,
0.2409506738,
-0.4032741487,
-0.3160356581,
-0.1486842781,
-0.4569019973,
-1.0062073469,
0.2041522264,
0.1634129435,
0.6498300433,
-0.079656437,
-0.267187655,
-0.4127546251,
-0.6599263549,
0.7230016589,
-0.2140732855,
0.4677241445,
0.36537081,
0.3292012513,
-0.4210732579,
-0.4322187304,
-0.693436563,
-0.3523406088,
-0.0904086828,
0.1266298443,
0.1163339093,
0.3866679668,
0.3414044678,
-0.0089384504,
-0.6998048425,
0.311214298,
-0.3327302635,
-0.1478812844,
0.7028543353,
0.1766759306,
0.6190496683,
-0.1607488543,
-0.4611563087,
-0.4166908264,
-0.8648340702,
0.2308803797,
0.5779557228,
0.3925186992,
-0.3415155411,
0.8522197008,
-0.0672761798,
0.4868915677,
0.4250386953,
-0.1184559241,
-0.0429439209,
0.051381398,
-0.1303382814,
0.2041721046,
0.8449249268,
0.2894007266,
0.2120330334,
-0.2559459805,
0.013747395,
0.0226027835,
0.2685853541,
-0.6066687107,
-0.1674197912,
0.2034071982,
-0.3102630079,
-0.1856305748,
-0.0456597283,
-1.0175225735,
-0.8070798516,
-0.6882464886,
0.2447662801,
-0.6140293479,
-0.2466034144,
0.2052287459,
-0.2062289715,
0.3712748587,
0.3595996499,
-1.2411688566,
0.5975929499,
0.6848554611,
0.7150533199,
-0.3215671182,
-0.5391979218,
-0.8884664178,
0.367061764,
-0.6619108915,
0.4170790315,
-0.6106740832,
-0.7013248205,
-0.1041800976,
-0.0460714251,
-0.0797640383,
-0.3357319534,
0.1728791147,
-0.3746579587,
0.1832193732,
-0.0096839713,
-0.4088985324,
0.0746119395,
-0.0720714033,
-0.3989854753,
0.5880479217,
-0.0861622617,
-0.3412538767,
0.2425229698,
-0.9338083863,
-1.0252307653,
0.0174309947,
-0.2882035077,
-0.0807702094,
-0.1822210997,
0.1945239604,
0.5406345129,
0.02464878,
0.4613829553,
-0.1916053444,
-0.2678767741,
0.4060580432,
-0.5210561752,
0.6508122683,
0.3289485276,
-0.2648618817,
0.1289126277,
-0.7237945199,
0.0207999088,
-0.1954674125,
-0.1398121566,
0.1418016702,
0.1837645471,
0.1647072732,
0.0834798068,
0.1884343475,
-0.2782754898,
0.1845082641,
-0.4192588627,
0.114066191,
0.4226284325,
0.1136085764,
0.7960031033,
-0.2680946887,
0.8698901534,
-0.5786601305,
-0.0187107716,
-0.175563246,
-0.5180670619,
-0.4844728708,
-0.364477545,
-0.4034687877,
0.5844582915,
-1.0102373362,
0.6343975067,
0.1563357413,
-0.3412537277,
-0.3687893748,
0.1663645208,
0.6103157997,
0.6168262959,
0.5323778391,
-0.020706879,
-0.2410701513,
-0.5057764053,
-0.1589641124,
-0.3917122781,
-0.4816997349,
0.1945821345,
0.0672728494,
0.259619534,
0.6067183018,
-0.4587073326,
-0.0302836858,
-0.506986618,
0.6055178642,
0.1538349539,
0.8291732669,
0.3046536744,
-0.9200974703,
-0.3806138635,
0.4075483084,
-0.816894412,
-0.1607651561,
-0.5347177386,
-0.2901154459,
-0.0674300715,
0.5322291255,
-0.8062491417,
0.2997556031,
0.341912061,
-0.3699955344,
0.6265205145,
-0.6112989187,
0.4669031799,
-0.5880023241,
0.5625395179,
-0.0324196182,
-0.1269637793,
-0.8376106024,
0.5384830832,
0.0062917555,
-0.6384806037,
-0.731423974,
0.8352947235,
-0.1716129035,
-0.1951894313,
-0.3881815374,
0.1148093417,
0.3136158884,
0.7633870244,
0.4574420154,
0.7663747072,
0.7282162309,
-1.041115284,
0.4183726609,
0.2362620831,
0.0340229236,
0.7606095076,
-0.6356713176,
-0.032541763,
-0.2139871418,
-0.0139116365,
-0.3534838259,
-0.4478748441,
0.380141139,
-0.3755962253,
0.7387974262,
-0.0416552871,
-0.4385887086,
-0.2882688344,
-0.1172533408,
-0.0506703742,
0.6656615138,
-0.4625815749,
0.6606692672,
0.3818272948,
-0.0966675803,
-0.5115185976,
-0.8646640778,
0.0948454812,
-0.0907266438,
-0.1657461077,
0.481497854,
-0.4422937036,
-0.0778234378,
-0.3114049137,
0.2637503743,
-0.2671135068,
0.0430237949,
0.0546773151,
0.198031798,
0.0697971508,
-0.0693948343,
0.4117001891,
-0.0426887721,
-0.1272026598,
0.1922824383,
0.6684315801,
-0.1014294177,
-0.7454966903,
-0.6081357002,
0.2347916663,
0.514329195,
-0.0834201053,
0.222080484,
0.5396150947,
-0.0920692831,
-0.0394034125,
-0.0273191649,
-0.0765647218,
-0.5786266327,
0.5121207833,
-0.3346672952,
-0.6397377253,
0.3983255923,
-0.0205704309,
0.0923273042,
0.1555516422,
0.3982035816,
-0.4167582989,
1.1441050768,
0.4305958152,
0.00266812,
0.438950181,
-0.2413210869,
0.2379655391,
-0.6307141185,
-0.2443291694,
-0.463624984,
-0.6800731421,
-0.4988468885,
-0.6775133014,
0.2216507941,
0.4277601242,
-0.409176141,
0.5248743892,
-0.2716059685,
0.6400892735,
0.2764199078,
0.0278349053,
0.0725960135,
0.1242708489,
-0.06834995,
0.0740512311,
-0.7115569115,
-0.5066436529,
0.6170209646,
0.2956597805,
1.2007880211,
-0.0901057795,
0.4858861268,
0.3620244265,
0.0181664247,
-0.560305357,
0.748839736,
-0.3999114335,
-0.4662197828,
-0.4931688011,
-0.3794410825,
-0.95911479,
0.0437898375,
-0.2223309129,
-0.8378461599,
0.1561164856,
0.4381108582,
-0.150001213,
0.3696160913,
-0.7793291807,
0.7541412115,
-0.4216111898,
-0.6421597004,
-0.479742527,
-0.5585215092,
0.2753027081,
0.150841713,
0.1850684285,
-0.0359133147,
0.0176417418,
0.2335843444,
-0.0697582215,
0.9035506248,
-0.3485620916,
-0.0509129129,
0.451146692,
0.452032268,
0.2767758071,
0.0510334298,
-0.1802302301,
-0.2071453184,
-0.2255038917,
-0.3245242536,
-0.8368160129,
0.7710738182,
-0.656814754,
-0.2463821471,
-0.0787065402,
-0.4555391371,
-0.2721105814,
0.1477137804,
-0.0719364434,
0.5497884154,
-0.4276569486,
0.1209338531,
0.6030965447,
-0.7346332669,
0.5326195359,
0.6444156766,
-0.6648135185,
-0.3418006897,
1.2262451649,
-0.5243244767,
0.3299281299,
1.0315160751,
0.1857628822,
-0.3663326502,
-0.0757573172,
-0.6963561773,
0.0572525784,
-0.3675895929,
-0.087691322,
-0.2395014763,
-0.3291024268,
-0.2182041109,
-0.8686382174,
-0.2847333848,
-0.4994418323,
-0.4509714842,
-0.0596903563,
-0.0212650932,
0.6191186309,
0.0540968329,
0.2857686579,
-0.5508451462,
0.9087985158,
0.3415555954,
0.3702360094,
-0.3661360145,
-0.1131871268,
0.0667575747,
0.101614289,
-0.5017710328,
-0.49802652,
0.5570687652,
0.4281212389,
0.5843164921,
0.4842284024,
-0.1222981364,
0.6590591669,
-0.6997637749,
0.8531662226,
0.6692122817,
-0.8896701336,
0.628628552,
-0.2321960479,
0.3384053111,
0.1859032959,
0.3384792209,
-0.6527399421,
-0.5555003881,
-0.4104367197,
-0.2650525272,
0.6410284638,
0.2073864937,
0.2261658013,
-0.0947346464,
0.2007265985,
0.0752772018,
0.3686333895,
-0.5399289727,
0.0305277482,
-0.3421117663,
-0.2428773493,
-0.0328554548,
0.4722240269,
-0.0269341301,
0.132919535,
0.4913769066,
-0.4217412174,
0.2742310464,
0.1725237817,
-0.0692965984,
-0.2863437533,
0.0786805451,
0.6568043232,
0.3588365614,
0.1095427424,
0.0097358637,
-0.3242084682,
-0.3601954281,
0.1319412738,
0.1425352246,
-0.2553608716,
-0.267814368,
0.2542640269,
0.991129458,
0.4307006896,
-0.9448663592,
0.3301232755,
0.2901962101,
-0.2034051269,
0.292509824,
0.3541736901,
-0.2228000909,
0.07781443,
0.1442839503,
0.1043435782,
0.0257141143,
-0.3530112803,
0.2621206045,
0.3386735022,
-0.2823342681,
-0.5767152309,
0.8243554831,
0.2916733325,
-0.5571490526,
0.2516967356,
-0.3867568672,
-0.3211235702,
0.8849143386,
0.5226390362,
0.7932239771,
-0.2388291359,
0.637147069,
0.4075076878,
0.2059064358,
0.1729122698,
0.4446759522,
0.033508379,
-0.6262884736,
-0.6295112371,
-0.6133223176,
-0.4730971158,
-0.0332391448,
-0.2940054238,
0.5589532852,
-0.9677725434,
0.136714533,
-0.2823011279,
-0.118864648,
-0.5917457342,
0.0974965766,
0.0267618559,
0.7072780728,
-0.6530342102,
0.6787105799,
0.5882770419,
-0.6279274225,
-0.416051805,
-0.245929569,
-0.1990586221,
-0.8629288673,
0.9935469627,
-0.0998687372,
-0.1599167734,
-0.1602337658,
-0.4008107483,
-0.4246980846,
0.7251337767,
0.3454756141,
-0.2864026427,
-0.1504864246,
0.1853785813,
0.7392317057,
-0.1155902371,
0.0329328775,
0.1553915292,
0.4186898172,
0.0856305435,
-0.9092136621,
-0.4177736044,
-0.250448674,
-0.1760375798,
0.2101606727,
-0.6319875717,
0.3342201114,
-0.0736566409,
-0.1946434081,
0.0279512666,
0.7032749653,
0.6186096072,
0.3942432106,
0.1557103992,
0.0062181093,
0.6766309738,
0.259547621,
1.2222504616,
-0.6593888402,
-0.0139022982,
0.9507594705,
-0.4980398417,
0.6990606785,
0.5016224384,
-0.4667808115,
0.3717985153,
0.0124777453,
0.1890272498,
0.5483951569,
0.2185565382,
-0.283842355,
0.1011871845,
-0.2322265655,
0.0698274449,
0.2122028917,
0.613720715,
0.00666859,
-0.075104177,
0.3293792605,
-0.1582488716,
0.4827527404,
-0.3467926383,
0.4241871834,
-0.1134138256,
-0.6494457722,
0.2351945937,
0.0055003767,
0.4482348561,
-1.061920166,
-0.2992125452,
-0.2132162303,
-0.2259576172,
0.0556904972,
-1.0068737268,
0.1814353317,
0.2021623552,
0.1592991501,
-0.8454737067,
0.8005234003,
-0.577645123,
-0.4074380994,
-0.1467547566,
0.2054460645,
0.3240927756,
0.4780851305,
-0.7425456047,
-0.0415931717,
-0.1624597162,
-0.0981360972,
0.4356964231,
0.2791168094,
0.1152104065,
1.0121644735,
0.4166726768,
0.347510159,
0.109822236,
0.0782328621,
0.5700415969,
-0.3397863209,
-0.6477789283,
-0.2264226824,
0.4221197367,
-0.1781707257,
-0.2436581999,
0.3715876639,
0.5515571237,
0.5546171069,
-0.2883014977,
0.7019637227,
-0.2880418599,
0.5091661811,
-1.076141119,
0.7695220113,
-0.2286810875,
0.0371606611,
-0.1534093618,
-0.6046623588,
-0.428750515,
0.7541492581,
0.0191682652,
0.1845006496,
0.6483460069,
0.8570969701,
-0.2555904686,
-0.2246825844,
0.6073759198,
-0.2353924513,
0.7458622456,
0.3490663767,
0.6058466434,
-0.0773473978,
0.2296704352,
-0.3156382143,
-0.115187481,
-0.0663839057,
-1.0696601868,
-0.7673392892,
-0.3008082211,
-0.4633535743,
0.1354443878,
0.0898794904,
0.9376434088,
0.8229562044,
-0.9748699665,
-0.5050522089,
-0.6648879051,
0.0028671571,
-0.3527490795,
-0.2887315154,
0.3540472984,
-0.5704888105,
-0.9571854472,
1.0556600094,
0.4592324793,
0.2033384889,
-0.4754927456,
-0.6958291531,
-0.0644976571,
-0.2650936246,
0.6135222316,
1.0592260361,
-0.7307100296,
-0.1912391037,
0.0651345178,
-0.0445176139,
-0.2133424133,
1.1253271103,
-0.6756818891,
0.8080189228,
0.463558048,
0.8654193282,
0.4272233546,
0.0370418169,
1.0139991045,
-1.0343043804,
0.2483745366,
0.1919553578,
0.0737616569,
0.3213909268,
-0.2187727392,
0.3103719056,
0.107867457,
-0.311101228,
-0.3539046943,
0.3294167221,
-0.9236569405,
-0.2916617393,
1.0018347502,
-0.0475322939,
-0.0812349543,
0.0732394531,
-0.6637570858,
0.1325317323,
-0.4361909926,
0.5905908942,
0.4772410095,
-0.5680654645,
-0.1717218459,
-0.4128335714,
0.617505908,
0.0475943312,
-0.9722350836,
0.2677372694,
0.5685768723,
-0.445263356,
0.2645581961,
0.4494153857,
-0.1217490882,
0.1490952969,
-0.2085371912,
0.3880631924,
0.0513170362,
-0.5818737745,
-0.2529674172,
0.1783540994,
-0.107649982,
0.0348256156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13867v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13867v2 | Mathematical Capabilities of ChatGPT | 2023-01-31T18:59:03 | 2023-07-20T17:59:14 | Simon Frieder, Luca Pinchetti, Alexis Chevalier, Ryan-Rhys Griffiths, Tommaso Salvatori, Thomas Lukasiewicz, Philipp Christian Petersen, Julius Berner | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We investigate the mathematical capabilities of two iterations of ChatGPT
(released 9-January-2023 and 30-January-2023) and of GPT-4 by testing them on
publicly available datasets, as well as hand-crafted ones, using a novel
methodology. In contrast to formal mathematics, where large databases of formal
proofs are available (e.g., the Lean Mathematical Library), current datasets of
natural-language mathematics, used to benchmark language models, either cover
only elementary mathematics or are very small. We address this by publicly
releasing two new datasets: GHOSTS and miniGHOSTS. These are the first
natural-language datasets curated by working researchers in mathematics that
(1) aim to cover graduate-level mathematics, (2) provide a holistic overview of
the mathematical capabilities of language models, and (3) distinguish multiple
dimensions of mathematical reasoning. These datasets also test whether ChatGPT
and GPT-4 can be helpful assistants to professional mathematicians by emulating
use cases that arise in the daily professional activities of mathematicians. We
benchmark the models on a range of fine-grained performance metrics. For
advanced mathematics, this is the most detailed evaluation effort to date. We
find that ChatGPT can be used most successfully as a mathematical assistant for
querying facts, acting as a mathematical search engine and knowledge base
interface. GPT-4 can additionally be used for undergraduate-level mathematics
but fails on graduate-level difficulty. Contrary to many positive reports in
the media about GPT-4 and ChatGPT's exam-solving abilities (a potential case of
selection bias), their overall mathematical performance is well below the level
of a graduate student. Hence, if your goal is to use ChatGPT to pass a
graduate-level math exam, you would be better off copying from your average
peer! | [
-0.5490402579,
-0.84311378,
0.4096061587,
0.2705077827,
-0.0964304581,
0.1447223574,
-0.2404935658,
-0.450486213,
-0.0736154839,
0.2107943743,
-0.5308628678,
-0.1900214553,
-0.4960884154,
-0.0739060119,
-0.4152921438,
1.2622987032,
0.089248836,
0.2153846622,
-0.439705044,
0.1406420171,
-0.2912237346,
-0.6782562733,
-0.749512136,
-0.1834883392,
0.2595012188,
0.0608316958,
1.0303515196,
0.1741851568,
0.8723648787,
0.1995116323,
0.2288623005,
-0.1250119805,
-0.477776289,
-0.2509034872,
0.2247998565,
-0.2786447108,
-0.533044219,
0.1784285009,
0.5149475932,
0.7830005288,
-0.1882873476,
0.1694889665,
0.1735055149,
0.6740968823,
-0.2218720913,
0.6902925372,
-0.4659453034,
-0.0659201667,
-0.4583650827,
0.1771237701,
-0.0839574113,
-0.7959964275,
0.403401196,
-0.6903216243,
0.424217999,
-0.1970780194,
0.7411524057,
0.1229049563,
-0.1888333559,
-0.5650724769,
-0.5131469965,
0.6573119164,
-0.4416215718,
0.4515816867,
0.4815977514,
0.8570411801,
-0.0048861378,
-0.8444163799,
-0.1473766267,
-0.5059233904,
-0.0742925555,
0.1880390793,
-0.2690645456,
-0.0670582205,
0.4387610555,
0.5974042416,
-0.8428567648,
-0.3867799938,
-0.5960843563,
-0.3279711008,
0.5515940189,
0.0363317654,
0.3386595845,
-0.0042907018,
0.0266923178,
-0.0525662787,
-0.7659243941,
-0.1796389967,
0.4491492808,
0.1939044148,
-0.1330285221,
0.621727705,
-0.0069473558,
0.4509219825,
-0.5868347287,
0.1421661228,
0.0447328277,
-0.4451572001,
0.1616349071,
-0.2885600924,
0.7228239179,
0.1041104868,
0.4954238534,
-0.0706981122,
-0.1499645859,
0.3428428769,
-0.0902477205,
-0.7483881116,
-0.9759482741,
-0.2060982585,
-0.0871347636,
-0.0833493844,
-0.2894151509,
-0.9850389361,
-0.2037576735,
-0.360368222,
0.5167444944,
-0.6078509688,
-0.0837752372,
0.2225896865,
-0.0349515602,
0.1150110289,
0.4064179361,
-0.9285424948,
0.8782734871,
0.8808113933,
0.9497571588,
-0.1077220291,
-0.121513918,
-0.418517828,
-0.406219244,
-0.224855125,
0.7376182675,
-0.6093540192,
-0.2883970439,
-0.0403840914,
-0.5425745249,
-0.0257643852,
-0.3609910309,
0.8374667168,
-0.3533515036,
0.4893450141,
-0.4388061464,
-0.4713691473,
-0.0922815055,
0.069630526,
-0.4878052771,
1.1294653416,
0.1775899231,
-0.5776006579,
0.0678322017,
-0.9078598022,
-0.1054536551,
0.0235881563,
-0.256498903,
-0.4827842712,
-0.0179870874,
0.3735523224,
0.09127222,
-0.5605975389,
0.0154759521,
-0.3145896494,
-0.3437172174,
0.2369866222,
-0.7437980175,
0.7280247211,
0.2233982086,
-0.0523835309,
-0.506698966,
-0.4782760739,
0.1089997664,
0.2764824629,
0.0430958718,
0.0418300368,
0.0007767106,
-0.1549738795,
0.0185199566,
0.3720329106,
-0.3235170543,
0.1560077667,
-0.2113171369,
0.4992477,
0.5567827821,
-0.0140134804,
0.2381563336,
-0.348846525,
0.6290259361,
-0.4670191705,
0.195222497,
-0.1449464113,
-0.9766888022,
-0.5377929807,
-0.3213809133,
0.6383670568,
0.6028650999,
-0.5631757379,
0.0938407481,
-0.2087524533,
-0.5551036,
-0.1895601153,
-0.1531513035,
0.3751008213,
0.4300090373,
0.2063699514,
-0.2147266269,
-0.2914130092,
-0.7355049253,
-0.5507577658,
-0.0855110735,
-0.1676312238,
0.3831316829,
0.4379298985,
0.1448979229,
0.8302867413,
-0.7166947126,
-0.1765337586,
0.1456426978,
0.1730737537,
0.3100182414,
0.1958313733,
0.6701285839,
-0.579420507,
-0.4808196127,
0.0003715985,
-0.8030204177,
-0.2500886321,
0.2802120149,
-0.1077674031,
-0.2181132436,
-0.0916062593,
-0.5058332682,
0.420884043,
0.5653536916,
-0.2440633178,
0.5370260477,
-0.1464657485,
-0.0331591442,
-0.5174474716,
-0.2260934412,
0.0258195493,
-0.1464419216,
-0.5717813969,
-0.0781667978,
0.0502825603,
-0.7251917124,
-0.0133098047,
0.4792143404,
-0.4186403751,
-0.4146447182,
0.1286729276,
0.3035554588,
-0.2619656622,
0.505521059,
-0.2178990245,
0.9378603101,
0.8264139891,
-0.407404989,
0.3929845095,
0.1314157695,
-0.3027047217,
0.4932696223,
-0.7805121541,
0.2584280074,
0.1521139294,
0.1060696542,
-0.9424756765,
-0.2694131136,
0.2998552024,
-0.6133657694,
-0.1083587706,
-0.3611736,
-0.47756657,
-0.3153091669,
-0.0342873521,
0.3546701074,
0.8706530929,
-0.2958752811,
0.4430928528,
0.448225528,
-0.4097796977,
-0.237710014,
-0.5465622544,
0.161748305,
-0.0869239867,
-0.8085395098,
-0.003193303,
-0.1607492864,
-0.2566794753,
0.0511317775,
-0.1155641153,
-0.2658795714,
-0.0430122726,
-0.0220794603,
0.2587117255,
-0.2763158381,
0.0002973277,
-0.1793931127,
-0.4627170265,
0.2393362075,
-0.2685060799,
0.5004907846,
-0.5733741522,
-0.75082618,
-0.0615941547,
0.0901650041,
0.1742368042,
-0.3974874914,
0.1850409657,
0.5495933294,
-0.5337549448,
0.1708677262,
-0.507671833,
-0.367321521,
-0.451330483,
0.2475181818,
-0.5157228708,
-0.6868023872,
0.6214029193,
0.0924441665,
0.2999531031,
0.3076029718,
0.4946461916,
0.3254857063,
0.9737092853,
0.0330585688,
0.0335257836,
0.2873488963,
-0.2736471593,
0.399498105,
-0.4498431981,
-0.0552396886,
-0.6044862866,
-0.0805198997,
-0.5905079246,
-0.286131978,
0.5696558356,
-0.0540964566,
-0.0769322291,
0.289090991,
-0.4562718272,
0.7580507398,
0.497363627,
0.0404336751,
0.4014517069,
0.1074245349,
-0.0040167435,
-0.4189217985,
-0.5053320527,
-0.5170540214,
1.2308778763,
0.2285363674,
0.6966632009,
0.2151499391,
0.4961408079,
0.0469523296,
0.3076810241,
-0.6012827754,
0.4955328703,
-0.1083381251,
-0.6394874454,
-0.2458661199,
-0.741854012,
-0.8974014521,
0.2225959152,
0.1681196988,
-0.6571149826,
-0.2061342448,
0.0793775469,
-0.2102882862,
0.0981899276,
-1.0819215775,
0.8128755689,
-0.1009029746,
-0.2053185552,
-0.0748711228,
-0.3600368202,
0.4488269389,
-0.2085482925,
0.2075846493,
-0.3366102874,
-0.0181347504,
0.5324012637,
-0.3752475679,
0.6393809319,
-0.1267031431,
-0.0111434925,
0.3341077566,
0.3866868615,
0.335701108,
0.3892051876,
-0.1670902222,
0.3378251493,
0.3230174184,
-0.5056523085,
-0.8171987534,
0.6353055239,
-0.7227200866,
-0.406943351,
-0.5817587376,
-0.3742067814,
-0.3276510835,
0.1807746738,
0.2157664001,
0.8942594528,
-0.2642564178,
0.0866051987,
0.4793869257,
0.0943352282,
0.2099456191,
0.2037909776,
-0.4114223123,
-0.3873667121,
1.0467687845,
0.4154211581,
0.2142904103,
0.1222329438,
0.3765639365,
-0.4981091619,
-0.4307788014,
-0.3224468827,
0.237139523,
-0.6123358011,
0.0413147584,
-0.3947114646,
-0.3712628782,
-0.3199458718,
0.0502241962,
-0.4304557443,
-0.660210371,
0.1016759202,
0.2730382085,
0.4292431176,
0.6777982116,
-0.1768811494,
0.0494075008,
-0.5471884012,
0.3401838541,
0.5060561299,
0.4160835147,
-0.3524499238,
-0.32489869,
-0.0112326536,
0.2698425651,
-0.5162827373,
-0.6329318285,
0.1551162899,
0.2126747817,
0.4525232911,
0.2590542734,
-0.0770821497,
0.5435633659,
-0.5784181952,
0.7707021236,
-0.0756649598,
-0.8772733808,
0.2315172851,
-0.7104336619,
0.0401944518,
0.312279284,
0.2817954123,
-0.4614430666,
-0.2194044292,
-0.7721008658,
-0.1138012558,
0.5233638883,
0.9309547544,
0.1917501986,
0.0987361073,
0.3026965261,
0.0854450464,
0.1852151901,
-0.3604672551,
-0.1271693408,
-0.2284488678,
-0.1798530817,
-0.1303298175,
-0.110329628,
-0.2088057846,
-0.1927933544,
0.3373582065,
-0.0677729025,
0.7033884525,
-0.1950190663,
0.2606324255,
0.312641263,
0.0205343813,
0.4731653035,
1.143702507,
-0.2066872716,
0.1414217502,
0.3096916676,
-0.8988779783,
-0.1557278335,
0.4687619507,
0.1555444747,
0.1154123023,
0.1752317846,
0.4786821902,
0.3694410622,
-0.4448128641,
0.4935750663,
-0.200424239,
-0.3462610841,
-0.5492349267,
0.09142977,
-0.0140653532,
-0.0665596575,
0.3407494724,
0.2202084064,
0.2640427947,
-0.4013794065,
0.3420002162,
0.3327792287,
-0.1706672609,
-0.555262208,
0.5940648317,
0.0139474068,
-0.3596560359,
0.6405575275,
-0.3114699423,
-0.5507363081,
0.5103283525,
0.2984354198,
0.5570218563,
0.0182190482,
0.2327205539,
0.3153550625,
0.295340836,
-0.3740757406,
0.1737685055,
0.1704611927,
-0.5391275287,
-0.4067709446,
-0.1932838261,
-0.7493136525,
-0.0617285371,
-0.5998723507,
0.4631182551,
-0.4585726857,
-0.0885233581,
0.0051169177,
0.3804574013,
-0.6665292978,
-0.0749521181,
-0.157196328,
0.6569862962,
-0.5649303198,
0.4432346523,
0.4093519449,
-0.2631535232,
-0.4733831584,
-0.1138320863,
0.302996099,
-0.9624236822,
0.1984256506,
-0.0578245819,
-0.0088909473,
0.1394836903,
-0.3796904683,
-0.7359996438,
0.8324257731,
0.6998927593,
-0.244875893,
-0.0866537392,
0.2372732759,
0.5212066174,
0.028854847,
0.6705852151,
0.5570435524,
0.3356626928,
0.2679460645,
-1.0799274445,
-0.3380698264,
-0.2432038188,
-0.1856377274,
0.3760468662,
-0.7301838398,
0.9629061818,
0.0761654302,
-0.1758784503,
0.0883498862,
0.6130594015,
0.4000328183,
0.4251891971,
0.1587174237,
0.5454169512,
0.9920234084,
-0.6447674632,
1.1162749529,
-0.2014654726,
0.4983665347,
0.7879836559,
-0.073299408,
0.5338432193,
0.0429645665,
-0.6790570617,
0.2074148208,
0.5960457325,
-0.0194142163,
0.3961510062,
0.2981946766,
-0.4119866788,
-0.1744915247,
0.1797829866,
-0.7065140009,
0.1796926409,
0.4420172274,
0.2281284928,
-0.5576341748,
-0.1749107838,
0.2048989087,
-0.0721391067,
-0.0469093435,
0.3647727966,
0.2661607265,
-0.3953017294,
0.4650284052,
-0.2511245608,
0.1672752202,
-0.7411204576,
-0.156250298,
-0.3547952473,
0.2297938168,
0.0450269058,
-0.8625264764,
0.3414718509,
0.0762849599,
0.410921216,
-0.0316850655,
0.6187678576,
-0.1134808585,
-0.6843701005,
-0.1965813935,
0.5821500421,
0.544496417,
-0.269151777,
-0.7499517202,
-0.0021753537,
-0.2053610384,
0.0041571185,
0.344399929,
0.7993472219,
-0.028103834,
0.7637597919,
0.7270465493,
0.0916842446,
0.2817862332,
0.0464499928,
0.9700388908,
-0.3906669617,
-0.3879721761,
-0.8009915948,
0.1310409009,
-0.1634702832,
-0.4289787412,
1.0148561001,
0.8332326412,
0.6753453016,
0.1123234704,
0.8396161199,
0.0123996129,
0.5630348921,
-0.5727269053,
0.3898968697,
-0.1221845374,
0.2822020054,
-0.3564063609,
-1.0508579016,
-0.4046198726,
0.6165403128,
-0.6950297356,
0.3668186665,
0.7725240588,
0.7211252451,
-0.3289495111,
0.4743667543,
0.3255629539,
-0.3803226352,
0.5218089819,
0.7191016674,
0.955466032,
-0.4619742036,
0.8540529609,
-0.3650315702,
-0.364053756,
-0.0456094556,
-0.7225038409,
-1.2027232647,
-0.4198653996,
-0.3060648739,
-0.2409190983,
0.1140460372,
0.5204850435,
0.5806285143,
-0.5956686139,
-0.2496542633,
-0.2421632111,
-0.1154800355,
-0.2370748371,
-0.2212249786,
0.5094988346,
-0.2992140651,
-0.730923295,
0.1651148051,
0.1204039901,
0.0361183286,
-0.4217298031,
-0.0437915996,
0.3759795725,
0.0050262311,
0.324200213,
0.2732845545,
-0.3098470867,
-0.1854724437,
0.2198843658,
-0.0378610715,
0.0262711458,
0.8664575815,
-0.4153160453,
0.3887687624,
0.568130672,
0.7142572999,
0.5790100098,
-0.0418016762,
0.547737956,
-0.4182240367,
0.1139346659,
0.2743058503,
0.2557897568,
0.1581811458,
-0.1294001341,
0.7729189396,
0.4031248689,
-0.6575936079,
-0.7525858879,
0.1533812881,
-0.6451931596,
0.2071992159,
0.9727122784,
-0.1292819977,
0.0996843651,
-0.2359084636,
-0.312135905,
-0.1634082049,
-0.5074862838,
0.7469510436,
1.0715432167,
-0.3597783446,
-0.3184916079,
-1.2515156269,
0.6710566878,
0.3485319614,
-0.8981098533,
0.0494619496,
0.4020276666,
0.080491215,
0.0898917615,
0.6646742821,
-0.4420628548,
0.3025070429,
0.2530727983,
-0.3435394466,
-0.1318428218,
-0.142720297,
-0.1343039572,
-0.0250632428,
-0.0309570003,
-0.1375654638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13848v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13848v1 | Benchmarking Large Language Models for News Summarization | 2023-01-31T18:46:19 | 2023-01-31T18:46:19 | Tianyi Zhang, Faisal Ladhak, Esin Durmus, Percy Liang, Kathleen McKeown, Tatsunori B. Hashimoto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown promise for automatic summarization
but the reasons behind their successes are poorly understood. By conducting a
human evaluation on ten LLMs across different pretraining methods, prompts, and
model scales, we make two important observations. First, we find instruction
tuning, and not model size, is the key to the LLM's zero-shot summarization
capability. Second, existing studies have been limited by low-quality
references, leading to underestimates of human performance and lower few-shot
and finetuning performance. To better evaluate LLMs, we perform human
evaluation over high-quality summaries we collect from freelance writers.
Despite major stylistic differences such as the amount of paraphrasing, we find
that LMM summaries are judged to be on par with human written summaries. | [
-0.2468779087,
-0.3683757484,
0.7034503222,
0.2274214923,
-0.479516834,
0.1143295988,
-0.4085049629,
-0.3693756759,
0.0974041522,
0.4557211101,
-0.3992263973,
-0.588442564,
-0.6355516911,
0.4345446527,
-0.4660340548,
1.2321285009,
0.0673393086,
0.2364349812,
-0.3906866908,
-0.2451114655,
-0.1574439555,
-0.4006134868,
-0.6203681827,
-0.3183535337,
0.7321561575,
0.4037339985,
0.6830662489,
0.8016738892,
0.635820508,
0.1708465368,
-0.1911783069,
0.1292176396,
-0.7586678863,
-0.2655993998,
0.050652612,
-0.5698550344,
-0.6830605268,
0.1872857213,
0.9064149261,
0.9014572501,
0.0874874517,
0.4095736444,
0.0024890241,
0.858397603,
-0.5973622203,
-0.0484672189,
-0.4547162056,
-0.0659978166,
-0.0635196641,
-0.1401657015,
-0.2401490957,
-0.6007829905,
-0.0339000113,
-0.2550990582,
0.3761747777,
0.0528861396,
0.9740032554,
0.2848795652,
-0.5821894407,
-0.1699697077,
-0.5171923041,
0.7542430162,
-1.1130324602,
0.1200832278,
0.3021851778,
0.2237645388,
0.0454145335,
-0.5067638755,
-0.1862464994,
-0.436239481,
-0.0395896174,
0.1214432493,
-0.14910236,
0.007246661,
0.2059756815,
0.5456429124,
-0.7815132737,
0.5073068738,
-0.4048024714,
-0.1513294876,
0.8323982954,
0.4565957189,
0.0404674597,
-0.060964223,
-0.0398969539,
0.0014062106,
-0.9362038374,
-0.230252251,
0.5320539474,
0.2351109982,
-0.1289954484,
0.6754396558,
-0.5712334514,
0.8441007733,
-0.1833514124,
-0.3314814568,
0.1430229396,
-0.3643788993,
-0.2074761093,
-0.0011186543,
0.8410839438,
1.0018899441,
0.3877281845,
-0.3126038909,
-0.377555728,
-0.1581389904,
0.1647512615,
-0.9667147398,
-0.0247304942,
-0.0687138662,
-0.5094279647,
-0.3126349747,
0.0647276491,
-0.6242755055,
-0.4954129457,
-0.357134521,
0.4532245398,
0.0822213888,
-0.0156924706,
0.2070073336,
-0.265717119,
0.1996405423,
0.4588241875,
-0.7876009941,
0.3186416924,
0.7029365301,
0.9195383787,
-0.3623021841,
-0.4258515239,
-0.5597645044,
-0.0731323659,
-0.5670962334,
1.0024974346,
0.0154477814,
-0.3210008442,
-0.1268867105,
-0.1607501209,
0.0757244378,
-0.7368856668,
0.4220657647,
-0.3756273091,
0.2164307833,
-0.5183365345,
-0.7596502304,
-0.0208795965,
0.2146497667,
-0.5863244534,
0.6007478833,
0.1759475917,
-0.5643292069,
0.3541027606,
-0.2566359937,
-0.6576328278,
-0.3135153353,
-0.0091506373,
-0.4061164856,
0.583326757,
0.2612532675,
0.7017568946,
-0.3758559525,
0.1482537687,
-0.2129920125,
-0.5890142322,
0.0835815221,
-0.3362828791,
0.4833962917,
0.2151349932,
0.0934196264,
0.2676872313,
-0.7896881104,
-0.2234511226,
0.1517565548,
-0.5891359448,
-0.0699689761,
-0.1927558482,
-0.0357091725,
0.0081029357,
0.1745480001,
-0.2440391332,
0.1204912886,
-0.41214329,
0.4078120887,
0.4426660836,
0.0659106523,
0.4049081206,
-0.7074885368,
0.5477597117,
-0.2431147397,
-0.2509542704,
-0.5469439626,
-0.0754972547,
-0.8067081571,
-0.137020871,
0.4054244757,
0.3558959663,
-0.3397868574,
0.3157089651,
-0.3518488407,
-0.5432836413,
-0.4117959142,
0.4212123752,
0.4599081874,
0.4811576605,
0.0901242495,
-0.4306777418,
-0.4621516168,
-1.049069047,
-0.6215898395,
0.0866349265,
-0.2941845953,
-0.0732726827,
0.4189298153,
0.1840337813,
0.8669570684,
-0.4333357215,
-0.1730342954,
-0.6844940186,
0.4588054121,
0.3413476348,
-0.0300341472,
0.666277945,
-0.2872062325,
-0.3380245864,
-0.4188835025,
-0.7890940905,
-0.366414994,
-0.1839669347,
0.2431444824,
0.331979543,
0.7298631072,
-0.677246511,
0.2450832576,
0.4345415533,
-0.0642352924,
0.7887784839,
-0.3245103657,
0.07048738,
-0.9275144339,
0.0328796618,
0.1911190152,
-0.5326756835,
-0.2614030242,
-0.0236491896,
0.2035760731,
-0.2344214618,
-0.5226508379,
0.6236017346,
-0.7332344651,
-0.5217117667,
-0.5882884264,
0.3356962502,
0.1464605629,
0.3140929341,
-0.0086310701,
0.8709275126,
0.1643263698,
-0.637978673,
0.3504123688,
-0.2202144116,
-0.856292963,
0.3603591025,
-0.9442119002,
-0.047431007,
-0.3074503839,
0.4282444417,
-0.8912472725,
-0.38587448,
-0.2553219199,
-0.2919749916,
0.2711246908,
0.1883756816,
-0.6754505038,
-0.2903439105,
-0.6581720114,
0.0599590577,
0.4844090044,
-0.2451303005,
0.2810553908,
0.317794174,
-0.3169721365,
-0.3642889857,
-0.5885683894,
0.488974154,
-0.1754374951,
-0.2666874528,
0.1310486645,
-0.0469569489,
-0.4347132444,
-0.0624773651,
-0.297342658,
0.0654710233,
0.2091945559,
-0.1106297299,
0.2545727491,
-0.4340506494,
0.0208387244,
-0.1293217838,
-0.0991861075,
0.0660186708,
0.1535524726,
0.3689934611,
0.0003070029,
-0.2654314637,
-0.5033918023,
0.1823141873,
0.7103251815,
-0.1847744584,
0.5846980214,
0.4209710062,
-0.1265969723,
-0.0268241856,
-0.7712405324,
-0.0736583695,
-0.3332602382,
0.6403278112,
-0.0450018458,
-0.8031845093,
0.4278671443,
0.01577935,
0.2554110289,
0.6790923476,
0.6998217106,
-0.2011749595,
0.9040350318,
0.6422744393,
-0.4395217001,
0.3337089419,
-0.0332598798,
-0.1839928776,
-0.5762835741,
0.2041436881,
-0.510027349,
-0.4102629721,
-0.2221001387,
-0.119433403,
0.3989154994,
0.1438156664,
-0.0645259768,
0.1634834558,
-0.006851003,
0.934625566,
0.5194533467,
-0.2127797902,
0.5984043479,
-0.2103053331,
0.1988710612,
0.1179575026,
-0.710465312,
-0.7499107122,
1.2383282185,
0.4190939963,
1.0873122215,
0.0379008874,
0.730910778,
0.2284210324,
0.4697384238,
-0.7630698085,
0.6080974936,
-0.3153424859,
-0.4743207693,
-0.3143337667,
-0.5900970101,
-0.7128646374,
0.3292408288,
-0.1545571536,
-0.5345228314,
-0.2983764112,
0.1636369824,
-0.7054930925,
0.1307043284,
-0.747240603,
0.8117513657,
-0.3618964255,
-0.1132067442,
-0.3215393424,
-0.6339712739,
0.6111165285,
-0.0412580408,
0.2589425743,
-0.383192271,
-0.2584817708,
0.7548490763,
-0.2432478219,
0.9488061666,
0.2033312768,
-0.2198628783,
0.045178432,
-0.0529690385,
0.2099145055,
0.0593525395,
-0.0844913051,
0.1780800074,
-0.1180841252,
-0.300837785,
-0.4277766943,
0.7113577724,
-0.9136166573,
-0.6758967638,
-0.2773863077,
-0.6849392056,
-0.3098298013,
0.1935760379,
0.4754333496,
0.5001292229,
-0.4181438982,
0.3723763824,
0.4015859962,
-0.2008420676,
0.5822437406,
0.7459398508,
-0.4221491814,
-0.3772016466,
0.7674239874,
0.2549726665,
0.3618671298,
0.5044591427,
0.1770952046,
-0.1685549617,
-0.7835027575,
-0.6170995831,
0.4905774593,
-0.5874069929,
-0.1896906495,
-0.4908612967,
-0.1774542779,
-0.4373771548,
-0.1105061993,
-0.4536622167,
-0.5301895738,
-0.3626645803,
-0.044544097,
-0.1052956209,
0.9500377178,
0.1746509969,
0.4238642454,
-1.0549246073,
0.5179001689,
0.2884107232,
0.2799226344,
0.01626979,
-0.8427263498,
-0.5799567699,
-0.2053236514,
-0.3351272047,
-0.6818823218,
0.3929441869,
0.1591928005,
0.6137025952,
0.4239958227,
0.0772843733,
0.5447138548,
-0.5049581528,
0.8043435216,
0.0668506622,
-0.8320118785,
0.407268405,
-0.5374668837,
0.7129821777,
0.6397320628,
0.3863128424,
-0.5387857556,
-0.5570152402,
-0.2910319567,
-0.7431308031,
0.6438482404,
-0.1474144161,
0.119002901,
0.1013383269,
0.4648957253,
0.1721157283,
0.3219404221,
-0.5656818748,
-0.0693981349,
0.0454329737,
-0.1592700183,
-0.6489347219,
-0.5886177421,
-0.0375645161,
-0.0618772656,
0.5167322159,
0.0167073738,
-0.1253880709,
-0.013157987,
-0.4889312387,
-0.3264421225,
0.1833590716,
0.9665936232,
1.1642560959,
-0.3260849416,
0.1328061819,
0.4295522273,
-0.1914218366,
0.0113072675,
-0.0261564814,
-0.1251855046,
0.2094948888,
0.9786791801,
0.8521130085,
0.5355172157,
-0.8330647945,
0.5034363866,
-0.2071112394,
-0.3613321483,
-0.1149793863,
0.224119395,
0.3163589239,
0.1871284693,
0.4300569296,
-0.1960537732,
-0.0190463997,
-0.5915081501,
-0.104377158,
0.3145058751,
-0.045172058,
-0.3841985762,
0.6500903964,
0.3300980628,
-0.3815931082,
0.4281364083,
-0.1605982482,
-0.220237717,
0.6556890607,
0.3281611204,
0.8953296542,
0.0135935014,
-0.0781352147,
0.3906834722,
0.461686492,
-0.4415038228,
-0.1014509276,
0.0397317857,
-0.5471981168,
-0.7238105536,
-0.6213648915,
-0.7496573329,
0.3622175157,
-0.7808489799,
0.3391346335,
-0.3524677157,
-0.0228562001,
0.0954525322,
0.1246652901,
-0.4557893574,
0.1410664469,
0.1438703388,
1.0963451862,
-0.9027200341,
0.5598684549,
0.667114675,
-0.3591352105,
-0.4988984466,
0.1678679585,
0.1762951761,
-0.736228466,
0.5168502331,
0.2653828561,
0.005032694,
0.1021763831,
-0.3101068139,
-0.5980827212,
1.0667871237,
0.7047097087,
-0.8627241254,
-0.2419352829,
-0.0254937746,
0.5360378623,
-0.2583419681,
0.2295131832,
0.5216473937,
0.2795376182,
-0.0403941274,
-1.1369786263,
-0.3041838109,
0.0262220036,
-0.0608590804,
0.0370084308,
-0.7072484493,
0.9054473042,
-0.4392744303,
-0.1895489991,
0.131535992,
0.6468728185,
-0.0062610256,
0.3092340827,
0.2972132266,
0.6997294426,
0.5432830453,
0.0730793551,
1.381886363,
-0.3205147386,
0.2999911308,
1.4549156427,
-0.2926549911,
0.8175703287,
0.1693092138,
-0.3235163987,
0.042247802,
0.6402385235,
-0.0021592902,
0.3426150978,
0.3164149821,
-0.0652682558,
-0.3404115438,
-0.0009478889,
-0.3299160898,
0.5235729218,
-0.0757811666,
-0.4598604143,
-0.6478583813,
-0.1754317433,
0.0768355504,
0.1639396399,
-0.5591148138,
1.0208981037,
0.2643843293,
-0.7361257076,
0.5807098746,
0.1926110089,
0.6820824742,
-0.5216284394,
0.2706440985,
-0.4312003255,
0.1472082883,
-0.0269902516,
-0.6371173263,
0.349690944,
0.3209657967,
-0.2366574258,
-0.1748245358,
0.5089742541,
-0.3028893769,
-0.5147381425,
-0.0231400952,
0.7382955551,
0.3573075533,
-0.1467255056,
-0.2145715207,
0.2095493376,
-0.2763176858,
-0.5364432931,
0.6439083815,
0.3409456611,
0.0727814808,
0.5959683061,
0.5458368063,
0.3340747952,
-0.2093722373,
0.5022639036,
0.7301081419,
-0.8303291798,
-0.4431182444,
-1.2452203035,
0.1780968159,
-0.0601515584,
-0.3848146498,
1.0045355558,
0.8093569875,
0.7317510843,
-0.1382563114,
0.6638607383,
0.5245972276,
0.6711733937,
-0.6419960856,
0.9598801136,
-0.5793286562,
0.3061311543,
-0.0515590534,
-1.1654373407,
-0.4980867207,
0.4362094998,
-0.326598078,
0.0725741014,
0.5205286145,
0.6422406435,
0.1458472461,
-0.211974591,
0.5889856815,
0.2474328279,
0.0703489333,
0.4070759118,
0.9241389036,
-0.1397440732,
0.6571249366,
-0.0463685021,
-0.085949786,
-0.5086496472,
-1.3155140877,
-1.2344961166,
-0.1262398958,
-0.2268185914,
0.09983702,
0.1872730106,
0.8796453476,
0.7463549376,
-0.6677600145,
-0.4547852874,
0.1732263714,
0.1900733858,
-0.0035752542,
-0.1508455724,
0.1732429415,
-0.4104926884,
-0.7624180317,
0.3713817298,
0.3836337626,
-0.0031712728,
-0.4800439477,
-0.027226042,
0.0934394076,
-0.0226918589,
0.6286280155,
0.1526058018,
-0.6624212265,
-0.0748290792,
-0.2100248486,
-0.3170758188,
-0.0578491837,
0.8656869531,
-0.6009891629,
0.0657830313,
0.4212480783,
0.6557255387,
0.4935190678,
0.1130881086,
0.6639298201,
-0.8056121469,
-0.0067963391,
0.0869051144,
0.3804073632,
0.3460793197,
-0.0508038253,
0.3695758283,
0.1202956438,
-0.6882305741,
-0.96071136,
-0.1317017823,
-0.7641413212,
-0.338989526,
1.1333298683,
-0.1917913854,
-0.2083476931,
0.2030930668,
-0.1550671458,
0.2239311337,
-0.2436946332,
0.7993087769,
0.7536026835,
-0.0456888117,
-0.3952669501,
-0.7942858934,
0.2734842598,
0.2267751694,
-0.8888745308,
0.160484165,
0.6264434457,
0.4950395823,
-0.2304328978,
0.7262914181,
0.1457409561,
0.4130962491,
-0.1772411168,
0.0332625918,
-0.3055715859,
-0.3237995803,
-0.6368606091,
0.0944793373,
0.3444608748,
0.0607398115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13844v1 | Do Multi-Document Summarization Models Synthesize? | 2023-01-31T18:40:46 | 2023-01-31T18:40:46 | Jay DeYoung, Stephanie C. Martinez, Iain J. Marshall, Byron C. Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-document summarization entails producing concise synopses of
collections of inputs. For some applications, the synopsis should accurately
\emph{synthesize} inputs with respect to a key property or aspect. For example,
a synopsis of film reviews all written about a particular movie should reflect
the average critic consensus. As a more consequential example, consider
narrative summaries that accompany biomedical \emph{systematic reviews} of
clinical trial results. These narratives should fairly summarize the
potentially conflicting results from individual trials.
In this paper we ask: To what extent do modern multi-document summarization
models implicitly perform this type of synthesis? To assess this we perform a
suite of experiments that probe the degree to which conditional generation
models trained for summarization using standard methods yield outputs that
appropriately synthesize inputs. We find that existing models do partially
perform synthesis, but do so imperfectly. In particular, they are
over-sensitive to changes in input ordering and under-sensitive to changes in
input compositions (e.g., the ratio of positive to negative movie reviews). We
propose a simple, general method for improving model synthesis capabilities by
generating an explicitly diverse set of candidate outputs, and then selecting
from these the string best aligned with the expected aggregate measure for the
inputs, or \emph{abstaining} when the model produces no good candidate. This
approach improves model synthesis performance. We hope highlighting the need
for synthesis (in some summarization settings), motivates further research into
multi-document summarization methods and learning objectives that explicitly
account for the need to synthesize. | [
-0.5165120363,
-0.498732239,
0.7457803488,
-0.1386591494,
-0.1278984398,
0.0222799685,
0.0806059092,
-0.5761509538,
0.3602267206,
0.1998858452,
-0.6594874263,
-0.2584926188,
-0.4722249806,
0.2582803369,
-0.7506453991,
1.4932340384,
-0.1476539671,
0.1331504732,
-0.2412835658,
-0.1103594229,
-0.1768263429,
-0.5198238492,
-0.0999346748,
-0.4064007401,
0.5105907321,
0.0560923591,
0.3584477305,
0.2131966949,
0.3884295821,
0.3750714064,
0.015020133,
0.3087935746,
-0.3520908654,
0.4750917852,
0.006144614,
-0.3896676302,
-0.6244136691,
0.5832502842,
0.6913892031,
0.8907406926,
0.1609329879,
0.2579531968,
0.3031265438,
0.4144378006,
-0.5519122481,
-0.0650486276,
-0.6247333288,
0.0237289574,
0.25050506,
-0.1305595934,
-0.4900931418,
-0.1963336319,
0.0381571315,
-0.3123744428,
0.9388789535,
-0.3311623037,
0.6902762055,
-0.1684048772,
-0.6463089585,
-0.4433411956,
-0.8566234112,
0.5491508842,
-1.0433267355,
0.0861802772,
-0.0404824167,
0.2001161575,
-0.0477067903,
-0.7971820831,
-0.4988718927,
-0.2722008526,
-0.3960681558,
0.6573960781,
0.172753036,
0.2064453363,
0.2741825879,
0.5235900283,
-0.3175751567,
-0.1930508167,
-0.6556898355,
-0.3706367612,
0.5897905827,
0.3656746447,
0.1333077103,
-0.3268380463,
-0.1727264374,
-0.1128553376,
-0.5618464351,
-0.0503684208,
0.5908290744,
0.3239143193,
-0.1328057051,
1.0793018341,
-0.1618598253,
0.4395179152,
0.2309520543,
-0.1409329921,
0.0363080055,
-1.0544117689,
-0.0274342857,
0.0052120243,
0.7440066338,
0.614644289,
-0.2057302594,
0.0793890134,
-0.5123178959,
0.4447891414,
0.2768769264,
-0.7560622692,
-0.1249189824,
0.5852699876,
-0.5317765474,
-0.4160791039,
0.0617752858,
-0.5742127299,
-0.2944638133,
-0.5616058707,
0.3511095345,
-0.2927133739,
-0.0095374379,
-0.1776612997,
-0.8876748681,
-0.1565981805,
0.3501866758,
-0.9778056741,
0.2454695851,
0.2252721339,
0.725461781,
0.0263078306,
-0.6321662068,
-0.512542367,
0.2455657721,
-0.4409334064,
0.8856338263,
-0.1019658446,
-0.6025935411,
-0.0683146939,
-0.3080699146,
-0.0845308751,
-0.2638585567,
0.1213406771,
0.0740186945,
0.5720499158,
-0.2489677817,
-0.70458287,
0.0775202587,
0.1317788363,
-0.6120509505,
0.2577197552,
0.0913639143,
-0.72059232,
0.3538901508,
-0.3409882486,
-0.6775591969,
-0.713060379,
-0.0243114866,
-0.3031553626,
0.6391612887,
0.2381548136,
0.1707813144,
-0.1635928154,
0.3073237836,
-0.4250378013,
-0.0622271784,
0.4810223877,
-0.3452826142,
0.3425203562,
0.230606392,
0.0557102859,
0.2769718766,
-0.7484000325,
-0.1332600266,
0.0381335728,
-0.3135660589,
-0.0558743849,
0.0522993356,
0.0505645275,
0.1967372,
0.0572461225,
-0.3512936234,
0.0717207193,
-0.5521510839,
0.4270875454,
0.481210798,
0.4028899968,
0.7019127011,
-0.6718618274,
0.3784615993,
-0.0946928412,
0.1089955866,
-0.6664915085,
-0.2811297774,
-0.6766437888,
-0.1326373667,
0.3472830951,
0.0210396089,
-0.3772307932,
0.1624924541,
0.1379657537,
-0.3431781232,
-0.3562476635,
-0.1292638481,
0.3620274067,
0.4885498285,
0.1668792814,
-0.4031045139,
-0.6694535017,
-0.9689232111,
-0.1478265077,
-0.3377541602,
-0.081848532,
-0.27265203,
0.4321474135,
0.229670614,
0.6769024134,
-0.5750789046,
-0.2943412066,
-0.6050229073,
0.4316259921,
0.2762194574,
0.2191423774,
0.6522806287,
-0.6011322737,
-0.1999068409,
-0.173483178,
-0.7928008437,
-0.0509926826,
-0.4727069139,
0.0503755696,
-0.0257915314,
0.429754138,
-0.7370433211,
0.1438183933,
0.5086310506,
0.2261942327,
0.6089524627,
-0.5063636303,
0.2715525925,
-1.2023353577,
0.0642919317,
-0.0861370414,
0.0060933898,
-0.8468764424,
0.1508730948,
0.004985603,
-0.1867890507,
-0.3637917042,
0.4080754519,
-0.5554863811,
-0.2163981348,
-0.2973739207,
0.1352201402,
0.3298442662,
0.4648640454,
0.1621942073,
0.332909137,
0.2123529017,
-0.5633317232,
-0.1067107245,
0.1885772794,
-0.0475739874,
0.4641900659,
-0.7992786169,
-0.2130894661,
-0.4074143171,
0.5003292561,
-1.1243946552,
-0.6435603499,
0.0448595621,
-0.5111535788,
0.2696050107,
-0.1964875162,
-0.1622619033,
-0.2499524802,
-0.547316134,
0.0520982705,
0.3421004415,
-0.0201092511,
0.856311202,
0.3758237958,
-0.4077908397,
-0.1191267222,
-0.740866065,
-0.1016076431,
-0.0237821341,
-0.3678378165,
0.4697184265,
-0.2985234857,
-0.1558608413,
-0.1023400873,
-0.0657139048,
0.0831557587,
-0.1372125,
0.2101109922,
0.4740758836,
0.1077618971,
-0.0322144255,
0.4930829108,
0.1092266068,
-0.0441588722,
-0.0367052481,
0.1918269098,
0.4110920727,
-0.4293110669,
-0.0112233488,
0.665204525,
0.7552958727,
-0.4584695995,
0.3344218135,
0.3525755703,
-0.244014889,
-0.2965359986,
-0.3049246073,
-0.4357816577,
-0.4118298292,
0.2559028268,
-0.4201482534,
-0.3567758501,
0.795075953,
0.2752971351,
0.4006385207,
0.6498087645,
0.6196650863,
-0.3093580604,
1.2219657898,
0.2225588858,
0.5664767027,
0.5912440419,
-0.2538771033,
0.1475374997,
-0.8404917121,
0.0517229997,
-0.4731938541,
-0.2539942563,
-0.6631771326,
0.2232239246,
0.9121777415,
-0.0955231041,
0.365110904,
0.0952668712,
-0.3806271851,
0.4055898786,
0.5446010232,
-0.0708071887,
0.1376007497,
-0.1622465849,
-0.1110071689,
0.1624579728,
-0.7342746258,
-0.3645145297,
1.2744932175,
-0.0500257909,
0.4425747395,
0.1291075945,
1.1728304625,
0.1692978889,
0.5124100447,
-0.3498782218,
0.3456527889,
-0.103053607,
-0.737678051,
-0.0325404778,
-0.3370916545,
-0.8498278856,
0.5065098405,
-0.6300621033,
-0.2246783674,
0.3018184304,
0.2307836562,
-0.380631417,
-0.0703398809,
-1.1008695364,
0.5500234962,
-0.0814432278,
-0.0928979591,
-0.1726475358,
-0.5055013299,
0.810354054,
-0.1928724945,
0.1399467587,
0.0779400691,
0.4721343815,
0.5109163523,
-0.3075734377,
0.7359396815,
0.1468479037,
0.1076583117,
0.5252924562,
0.2444069386,
0.423107475,
0.0103420047,
0.1163424626,
-0.1529672146,
0.160987258,
-0.1875620782,
-0.47764045,
0.558041811,
-0.5228241682,
-0.801982522,
-0.3007700443,
-0.6618249416,
-0.1565079391,
0.3072171807,
0.6475917697,
0.6647365093,
-0.5199347734,
-0.3598971963,
0.1066547185,
-0.2232960761,
0.3838685155,
0.4471570253,
-0.218724668,
-0.5502550006,
0.5627971888,
0.3901327848,
0.5636496544,
0.2589067221,
0.0395122021,
-0.222306177,
-0.6775833964,
-0.4252497256,
0.1926475614,
-0.9146459103,
0.0125106908,
-0.6708117723,
-0.3394685686,
-0.7307611108,
-0.204120487,
-0.3653248847,
-0.6825814247,
-0.1382408291,
-0.3727267385,
-0.2923031449,
0.9129103422,
-0.1501341313,
-0.1513970643,
-0.8872932792,
0.747035265,
0.3818340003,
-0.0911885872,
0.1276795417,
-0.3074331284,
-0.1332644075,
0.230283305,
-0.5639253855,
-1.1552869081,
0.281660974,
0.105767116,
0.5999470949,
-0.089393355,
0.0961430296,
0.2454562038,
-0.5023961067,
0.8353794217,
0.4062076807,
-0.8540123701,
0.5354977846,
-0.5857682228,
0.5978730917,
0.461673826,
-0.0712011084,
-0.2555671632,
-1.2246470451,
-0.6299566031,
-0.8549218774,
0.6412069798,
0.4150667787,
0.314529717,
-0.2522288263,
-0.0093828412,
0.2984581292,
0.28371948,
-0.610701859,
-0.0847737342,
-0.2852599919,
-0.1746319681,
-0.1974271536,
-0.2332209051,
-0.3063130677,
0.2514218688,
0.5259208083,
-0.1016725451,
0.1216979399,
0.232344836,
-0.0076968037,
0.0101857819,
0.4338911474,
0.7681102753,
0.938137114,
-0.4319321215,
0.3266726732,
-0.2094025314,
0.017585434,
0.2114885002,
0.2424063683,
-0.571081996,
0.2407922447,
0.6073874831,
0.544831872,
-0.0747910962,
-0.3097694516,
0.4407559037,
-0.162549451,
-0.3995503783,
-0.0389863811,
0.2781318724,
0.1276759654,
0.0933047086,
0.2802790701,
0.3831793368,
0.4065998495,
-0.8775965571,
0.0315825753,
0.3280544281,
0.2322064638,
-0.4389371574,
0.8568381071,
0.243551001,
0.1505663246,
0.3997809291,
-0.1709166467,
-0.1521623582,
0.7092977762,
0.4663710594,
0.9579955935,
-0.0072885421,
0.4022702575,
0.5728952885,
0.2914372385,
-0.1489341706,
0.040762268,
0.2030048966,
-0.600615561,
-0.3097220659,
-0.4710131884,
-0.4625371397,
-0.2466845363,
-0.5581616759,
0.2368256599,
-0.2344988137,
-0.4547456801,
0.7247743607,
-0.7340897322,
-0.4486747384,
0.178446725,
0.1711684465,
0.122801818,
-1.0738507509,
0.4326183796,
0.5016232133,
-0.9387888312,
-0.4644444883,
-0.108788386,
0.0758658499,
0.0204905178,
-0.0714371726,
-0.1150650755,
0.0682976767,
-0.3679387271,
-0.1491874158,
-0.6683554053,
0.6972925663,
0.4137544334,
-0.3030663431,
-0.1319552809,
-0.0805099085,
0.8012871146,
-0.5451905131,
0.280698806,
0.128940478,
0.3514363766,
0.0165926777,
-0.7195053101,
-0.0714008659,
-0.4306553304,
-0.1536488533,
0.1141264215,
-0.3716939688,
1.0212819576,
-0.4924193919,
-0.3072912097,
0.2749567628,
0.5114509463,
0.3784120083,
0.5955070853,
0.0920938328,
0.0638056397,
0.5505539179,
-0.0158136059,
1.4502315521,
-0.3023034036,
0.1393292248,
1.5351922512,
-0.5176895261,
0.4926993847,
0.6503179669,
-0.2739747167,
0.0694667771,
0.4953159392,
0.0346327908,
0.5389743447,
0.0129885254,
0.052161891,
-0.1967852116,
-0.063136898,
-0.2753399611,
0.2538345158,
0.0387058407,
-0.6581338644,
-0.2530736029,
-0.1590031236,
-0.3631116152,
0.0198571123,
-0.009954364,
0.9390848279,
0.157381013,
-1.2835735083,
0.5158180594,
0.2950538993,
0.0622777753,
-0.908552289,
-0.1138237789,
-0.6225122213,
0.0102810031,
-0.1180396825,
-0.64418751,
0.272775203,
-0.0668762401,
-0.5873074532,
-0.1927198321,
0.55793643,
-0.7050051689,
-0.7669690251,
-0.0803537369,
0.6632582545,
-0.144549787,
0.2900233269,
-0.1320893019,
-0.2665204704,
0.0774239078,
-0.1499989331,
0.5271649361,
0.0657646805,
-0.1042373255,
0.1138076559,
0.8070181012,
0.3139927685,
0.012727065,
0.3667334616,
0.6881526113,
-0.2187552303,
-0.6048460007,
-0.6233866215,
0.7197909355,
-0.025040295,
-0.4076128006,
0.7409541011,
0.5397267342,
0.6979030967,
-0.3268828392,
1.0683102608,
-0.0727370232,
0.1487702876,
-0.7640118599,
0.3966959119,
-0.5267333388,
0.2128290683,
-0.2033870816,
-1.2028290033,
-0.0855816379,
0.0483839586,
-0.129014194,
-0.0130638015,
0.8592566252,
0.7237977982,
-0.1424799114,
-0.070129551,
0.1544524729,
0.1166046262,
0.3596630692,
0.3230559826,
0.8606030345,
-0.4462116659,
0.2873033583,
-0.1083959118,
0.1517218053,
0.1311564147,
-0.6445863247,
-0.7274267077,
-0.6369671822,
-0.3408073485,
-0.3808259368,
0.11961402,
0.6840797067,
0.3806290627,
-0.8731487393,
-0.1632431746,
-0.0387599207,
0.2467306405,
-0.3010410964,
-0.1114394814,
0.2960669398,
-0.3402461112,
-0.831058681,
0.4171688259,
0.2107721418,
0.408695519,
-0.2562450767,
0.0069723469,
0.0126223164,
0.4740847051,
0.4018378854,
-0.1084556654,
-0.5194019675,
-0.0211512521,
-0.0766256079,
-0.0940019041,
-0.0746729746,
0.9299705625,
-0.3475747406,
0.772693038,
0.8635654449,
0.0121421022,
0.7678222656,
0.0452230163,
0.9381999969,
-0.9106070995,
0.0391215496,
-0.1088090986,
0.669144094,
0.2879483104,
-0.1733619571,
0.3300977945,
-0.0257259626,
-0.151195392,
-0.7545795441,
0.4432175756,
-0.6765035987,
-0.494228363,
1.0542397499,
0.0733351484,
0.0440231487,
0.3501141667,
-0.2058469206,
0.3269998431,
-0.2029486746,
0.9370850921,
0.6579253674,
-0.2512569427,
0.1148065627,
-0.2573476136,
0.187638402,
0.264082551,
-0.7040498853,
0.0404196419,
1.0758392811,
0.2110583633,
0.2591001689,
0.7589319348,
-0.1710473001,
0.4956261814,
0.2675918937,
0.0225093774,
-0.1633024514,
-0.215693295,
-0.107487984,
0.4102064073,
0.0486383848,
0.1240886077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13823v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13823v4 | Grounding Language Models to Images for Multimodal Inputs and Outputs | 2023-01-31T18:33:44 | 2023-06-13T21:54:58 | Jing Yu Koh, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Daniel Fried | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | We propose an efficient method to ground pretrained text-only language models
to the visual domain, enabling them to process arbitrarily interleaved
image-and-text data, and generate text interleaved with retrieved images. Our
method leverages the abilities of language models learnt from large scale
text-only pretraining, such as in-context learning and free-form text
generation. We keep the language model frozen, and finetune input and output
linear layers to enable cross-modality interactions. This allows our model to
process arbitrarily interleaved image-and-text inputs, and generate free-form
text interleaved with retrieved images. We achieve strong zero-shot performance
on grounded tasks such as contextual image retrieval and multimodal dialogue,
and showcase compelling interactive abilities. Our approach works with any
off-the-shelf language model and paves the way towards an effective, general
solution for leveraging pretrained language models in visually grounded
settings. | [
-0.3263624012,
-0.8212246895,
0.5719094872,
0.2391972691,
-0.5655690432,
-0.2313761562,
-0.4511730671,
-0.1259747446,
-0.094862245,
0.5773934722,
-0.4464754462,
-0.504627347,
-0.5906434655,
-0.2621988058,
-0.3579139411,
0.8161941171,
-0.0636248291,
0.1203567535,
-0.5509297252,
-0.2886490524,
-0.5351826549,
-0.5143409967,
-0.3093654811,
-0.4440178871,
0.2480774671,
0.4963944554,
0.6965122223,
0.6334689856,
0.2628149092,
0.205515787,
0.3998830616,
0.0193495844,
-0.6127418876,
0.2600318789,
-0.1468749493,
-0.2234965265,
0.0288013238,
0.313776195,
0.6146637201,
0.636760056,
0.1535223573,
-0.0872613713,
-0.2004902214,
0.3096530437,
-0.6560898423,
0.2429690361,
-0.8199346066,
0.0336267278,
-0.0210081022,
-0.6052160859,
-0.6888770461,
0.0474601984,
-0.1034587398,
-0.6869222522,
0.0076131942,
-0.2020059973,
1.1826831102,
0.2591174841,
-0.414975673,
0.0672080517,
-0.6261883378,
0.6856690645,
-0.4344065189,
0.6278645992,
0.5670648813,
0.3100011945,
0.2419145852,
-0.755161047,
-0.6887785792,
-0.4626629353,
0.0488592386,
0.3078228235,
0.0671188235,
0.1764870435,
0.3675348163,
0.2930411994,
-0.3861714602,
-0.0547707304,
-0.0636099577,
0.1504670233,
0.1448883563,
-0.293194741,
0.7233971953,
-0.0159214903,
-0.3320949376,
-0.4104585648,
-0.7560563684,
0.0705639049,
0.0276437327,
0.2881845534,
-0.2971325517,
0.9434904456,
-0.1759725809,
0.7136930227,
0.1280040443,
-0.260445714,
0.0623646304,
-0.2502776682,
-0.3040840924,
-0.2248165011,
0.7348796725,
0.6503098607,
0.298630625,
-0.3400451243,
-0.3401126564,
0.3738835156,
0.1597845852,
-1.051784277,
-0.2910724878,
-0.093822673,
-0.3757291436,
-0.3721322119,
-0.3065859973,
-0.6937229037,
-0.2699121535,
-0.4352276325,
0.6959136724,
-0.5539957881,
-0.3510763943,
-0.2139965445,
-0.117945157,
0.1856251955,
0.3312793672,
-0.813572526,
0.3310427964,
-0.0309044402,
0.6303910017,
0.3086224496,
-0.3238267004,
-0.8486847281,
0.2304439545,
-0.4907106459,
0.6991633177,
-0.662294507,
-0.0820031315,
0.1514510512,
0.0065843984,
0.0815687552,
-0.2626952827,
0.325509727,
-0.5811841488,
0.2378251106,
0.1616795808,
-0.3775077462,
-0.1243728176,
0.3327044547,
-0.6052085757,
0.9253823757,
-0.0626578629,
-0.7649629712,
0.4376517534,
-0.4207521379,
-0.4563018978,
0.0815190151,
-0.5979120135,
-0.2705846727,
0.2116694599,
0.4652460217,
0.709482193,
-0.4293157458,
0.6021942496,
-0.288897723,
-0.2485327125,
-0.1610336304,
-0.495238483,
0.411161989,
0.0506626181,
-0.5425103307,
0.2100917995,
-1.0008206367,
0.2329049408,
0.4030035734,
-0.1752451956,
-0.4429744184,
0.1584165841,
0.4425424635,
0.6031422615,
-0.0283441264,
-0.3975332379,
0.0711792782,
-0.1968362331,
0.3001073003,
0.4015645981,
-0.3098042905,
0.7316204309,
0.075212732,
0.4922576249,
0.2660736442,
-0.3733628988,
-1.0598809719,
-0.2638788521,
-0.9487602711,
-0.426994741,
0.1252701283,
0.4442434311,
-1.278699398,
0.207478404,
-0.3767933249,
-0.5610890388,
-0.3474689126,
0.0326449722,
0.6819938421,
0.7596242428,
0.3743129373,
-0.2317991704,
-0.2577717304,
-0.9709120989,
-0.0805125311,
0.0298839696,
0.149202019,
0.240829885,
0.3255486488,
-0.2583141029,
0.9459866881,
-0.2880055606,
-0.0423115939,
-0.1357679963,
0.4335279167,
0.0269660968,
0.8709421158,
0.71990031,
-0.900144577,
-0.3427884877,
0.2550355792,
-1.1127133369,
-0.0731436461,
-0.1596038193,
-0.1324784011,
0.1008928642,
0.7155974507,
-0.7229856253,
0.5128497481,
0.6818653345,
-0.3337818682,
0.1640528738,
-0.1004851162,
0.4500665963,
-0.9000675082,
0.2378987968,
-0.0342782177,
-0.5879259706,
-0.7799781561,
0.3656639457,
0.2751350403,
-0.870801568,
-0.399255842,
0.656111896,
-0.696819663,
0.0690544844,
-0.193724677,
-0.0442087203,
0.2093329579,
0.5531807542,
0.4999358952,
0.8214630485,
1.062051177,
-0.5308507085,
0.0711988732,
0.0958098844,
-0.3649768531,
0.5090809464,
-0.7024599314,
0.1812253892,
-0.5165995955,
0.0542003661,
-1.1270128489,
-0.3780010939,
0.155112043,
-0.325995177,
0.4082935452,
-0.2655050159,
-0.4928020835,
0.0299856998,
-0.0163913388,
0.7979743481,
0.5237637162,
-0.5441640019,
0.6366279125,
0.2769446075,
-0.0352410711,
-0.4119135737,
-0.6997380853,
0.2899028063,
0.0112095168,
-0.6404768229,
0.189365074,
-0.050866887,
-0.0071594738,
0.0552316122,
0.2202088237,
-0.3031353652,
-0.0396419391,
0.4467329085,
0.0424902849,
-0.4145494103,
0.1764885783,
0.0961733982,
-0.1499721855,
-0.2976720631,
-0.3048660457,
0.6254990101,
-0.0782147124,
-0.5068116784,
-0.407584101,
0.6639267802,
0.906075418,
-0.4542528987,
0.7309898734,
0.4325000048,
-0.6180561781,
0.021997638,
-0.4550403059,
-0.0842195153,
-0.415139854,
0.3413077295,
-0.5420520902,
-0.7392080426,
0.240470469,
-0.0792143047,
-0.0202173702,
0.1521692872,
0.5245031714,
-0.1654239148,
1.1024742126,
1.0503765345,
0.473018229,
0.6240486503,
-0.0567022115,
0.3479941487,
-0.3013280034,
-0.0493875854,
-0.1640049368,
0.0507806204,
-0.058359731,
-0.6640276909,
0.2194880396,
0.5471397638,
0.0149742486,
0.2970829606,
-0.2516774833,
0.6848461628,
0.5972518325,
0.2429431081,
0.1003361121,
0.386980325,
-0.5016500354,
-0.3658527136,
-0.7041902542,
-0.5357091427,
0.9330143332,
0.281645298,
0.8878363967,
-0.3394996524,
0.4490435123,
-0.0827851743,
0.4324758649,
-0.7397110462,
0.4996607304,
-0.1196789443,
-0.3333505988,
-0.0913751572,
-0.1810164452,
-0.4897587001,
0.3960225284,
-0.4911074936,
-0.3826309443,
-0.0690131858,
0.3625455499,
0.0402463786,
0.2919018269,
-0.8123381138,
0.9811156392,
-0.2983452976,
-0.5759100318,
-0.0248795077,
-0.6640754342,
0.5064146519,
0.0028374961,
0.2819468975,
-0.0353409685,
0.3400278389,
0.4205085635,
-0.2809277475,
0.9099909067,
-0.3146004975,
-0.2602989972,
0.2233303636,
0.2381573617,
0.1141038984,
-0.0173567496,
0.2002889961,
0.167523846,
-0.2107492536,
-0.4342451096,
-0.5048441887,
0.5451934338,
-0.8544381261,
-0.2400983721,
-0.1929798126,
-0.5571014881,
-0.2933239043,
0.6308572888,
0.4057600498,
0.8702276945,
-0.2507671416,
0.3323118687,
0.5926289558,
-0.358099699,
0.5623237491,
0.1571425647,
-0.4014084935,
-0.6568527818,
0.8356665969,
-0.0316482149,
0.3210783005,
0.5357183218,
-0.1868535876,
-0.3503556848,
-0.2437601686,
-0.5886318088,
0.0899557397,
-1.1249278784,
-0.2390883565,
-0.8125757575,
0.0061506312,
-0.3637189865,
-0.429533571,
-0.5212290287,
-0.2330762744,
-0.295244962,
-0.0621192753,
0.1636492312,
0.3666105568,
0.1175729409,
0.6461670995,
-0.7840306759,
0.8481785655,
0.4778683782,
0.3782297075,
-0.2244494408,
-0.2378149629,
-0.206737861,
0.1328240037,
-0.0956805199,
-0.7709770799,
0.3291490972,
0.4654354453,
0.5221863985,
0.5474131703,
-0.1972786784,
0.9679644108,
-0.8824455738,
0.6996007562,
0.7485539317,
-1.1467233896,
0.7167972922,
-0.6096198559,
0.4687547982,
0.4580643773,
0.2425800264,
-0.4808926582,
-0.1896556467,
-0.395450443,
-0.8218862414,
0.6232641339,
0.2585842311,
0.3118329942,
-0.1547337174,
0.1831323951,
-0.0330738164,
0.4808656573,
-1.3577849865,
0.1017354205,
-0.6646307707,
-0.1578051001,
-0.2157581598,
-0.3605593741,
-0.3770950139,
-0.3626514971,
0.3736333549,
-0.464643389,
0.3023062646,
-0.0019846116,
-0.691752553,
-0.2580604553,
0.0434666201,
0.6672512889,
0.6432698965,
0.0337301679,
0.6186904311,
-0.3177159429,
-0.1643260419,
0.432954222,
-0.2387088686,
-0.2852354944,
0.0651174262,
0.423748672,
1.159175396,
0.4131305814,
-0.881798327,
0.8093411326,
-0.1368774772,
-0.3306393325,
-0.1026774496,
-0.4262852669,
-0.1088809073,
0.1122406051,
0.1929363757,
0.374578625,
-0.3850324452,
-0.5079366565,
0.4672335982,
0.4126988947,
-0.3732819557,
-0.4204936624,
0.8385333419,
0.1737780422,
0.0168555081,
0.5188375115,
0.0925574228,
-0.3721697032,
0.3779135644,
1.0247850418,
0.8207573891,
0.0377835147,
0.3017598987,
0.2980838716,
0.3866610825,
0.0332145952,
0.3121812344,
-0.1794754863,
-0.9256331325,
-0.483813554,
-0.4660400748,
-0.1199520901,
0.2887696028,
-0.5182323456,
0.5008049607,
-0.6652467847,
-0.0406637192,
-0.3467506766,
-0.6995828748,
-0.7812518477,
0.691226244,
0.6123126745,
0.6627987027,
-1.1711901426,
0.8502925634,
0.9802879095,
-0.5980674028,
-0.571087718,
-0.138579607,
-0.4497060478,
-0.8575962782,
1.0088784695,
0.5778939724,
-0.3403023481,
0.2018266022,
-0.9806053638,
-0.7728391886,
0.7105281949,
0.7152918577,
-0.2297655791,
0.1116510481,
-0.1245515123,
0.2771804929,
-0.5103509426,
0.3958714008,
0.0647601411,
0.3190325499,
0.1347628236,
-0.6451182365,
-0.0331942625,
-0.7397105098,
0.2455534041,
-0.1367978007,
-0.3260148764,
0.9825913906,
0.0656665936,
-0.5464189053,
-0.0350264423,
0.688780427,
0.2629109621,
0.0437352322,
0.5569559336,
0.8794981241,
0.4440955818,
-0.0290030781,
0.8064348698,
-0.4389262795,
0.1760066599,
0.9784184098,
-0.3765985668,
0.7526301146,
0.7165124416,
0.547606051,
0.2505097091,
0.4218842387,
0.2506030202,
0.9948040843,
-0.1202764809,
-0.2825933993,
-0.6747492552,
-0.2933895886,
-0.3404777646,
0.4818525314,
0.148995623,
-0.255020082,
-0.6742608547,
0.406240046,
-0.0417069644,
0.4166651666,
-0.1501792371,
0.476937145,
-0.1274719834,
-0.6656333804,
0.9143853784,
0.1768691838,
0.5541012883,
-0.6271831393,
-0.3578398228,
0.0882702991,
-0.016148502,
-0.0259982497,
-0.5212578177,
-0.0152958091,
0.0695834458,
-0.3557444513,
-0.7819090486,
0.958697319,
-0.8034130335,
-0.4863992333,
0.3023431003,
0.4187442958,
0.0316435955,
-0.181276381,
-0.3596968949,
0.1323361248,
-0.3142894804,
-0.1550243646,
0.1797519624,
0.6076766253,
-0.1616219282,
0.4790704846,
0.7529592514,
-0.2740404904,
0.363596946,
0.2120894045,
1.1915411949,
-0.6166990995,
-0.6075046659,
-0.7256473899,
0.9042913914,
0.070293583,
-0.2713939548,
0.499563396,
0.28512609,
0.687782228,
-0.4521331191,
0.779674232,
-0.1207679957,
-0.0583239123,
-0.9300790429,
0.8395262957,
-0.7722401619,
-0.431414634,
-0.4791392088,
-0.92744416,
-0.5201248527,
0.8678972721,
0.0170349553,
-0.1296799481,
0.7675805092,
0.5730141997,
-0.3881776035,
-0.4011892676,
0.8006877303,
0.0102315033,
0.3918054104,
0.1698308885,
0.9227840304,
-0.5739135146,
0.1580046415,
-0.222330153,
-0.4291169643,
0.1225766465,
-1.2762798071,
-1.2351216078,
-0.5558838248,
-0.2708177567,
-0.0966252312,
-0.2164671272,
0.8523985147,
1.1408946514,
-0.5847192407,
-0.227802515,
-0.3035818636,
-0.3329912126,
0.1128392592,
-0.177009657,
-0.0868967921,
-0.5236076117,
-0.6825495958,
0.6614232659,
0.5111805797,
0.1380000114,
-0.0862220079,
0.0759968609,
-0.3967713118,
-0.0134781674,
0.8969382644,
0.1574375778,
-0.667863071,
-0.290750891,
-0.0322498716,
-0.1438397318,
0.1267999411,
0.862821579,
-0.8943224549,
0.5887165666,
0.2888326347,
0.8831633329,
0.5478124022,
-0.0766310245,
0.8455833197,
-1.0535782576,
0.8914123178,
0.1937219799,
0.4285620153,
0.5140722394,
-0.1784359813,
0.1340628415,
0.3014964461,
-0.1308729053,
-0.8401580453,
0.3203715682,
-0.953538239,
-0.1098755226,
0.9614607692,
-0.2272399366,
-0.0900414512,
0.3210650682,
-0.2232209891,
0.2974932194,
0.0148363747,
0.1797715127,
0.7258606553,
0.4940948188,
-0.8266155124,
-0.4370708764,
0.238234669,
0.5557193756,
-0.7846759558,
-0.0495848246,
0.7778931856,
0.0742571428,
0.1843697727,
0.9556317925,
-0.1917724013,
0.1005429626,
0.0736156926,
0.5432781577,
0.0572182834,
-0.8303664923,
-0.4113864601,
0.2530449033,
-0.0843224749,
-0.1963957846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13826v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13826v2 | Attend-and-Excite: Attention-Based Semantic Guidance for Text-to-Image Diffusion Models | 2023-01-31T18:10:38 | 2023-05-31T15:42:00 | Hila Chefer, Yuval Alaluf, Yael Vinker, Lior Wolf, Daniel Cohen-Or | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG | Recent text-to-image generative models have demonstrated an unparalleled
ability to generate diverse and creative imagery guided by a target text
prompt. While revolutionary, current state-of-the-art diffusion models may
still fail in generating images that fully convey the semantics in the given
text prompt. We analyze the publicly available Stable Diffusion model and
assess the existence of catastrophic neglect, where the model fails to generate
one or more of the subjects from the input prompt. Moreover, we find that in
some cases the model also fails to correctly bind attributes (e.g., colors) to
their corresponding subjects. To help mitigate these failure cases, we
introduce the concept of Generative Semantic Nursing (GSN), where we seek to
intervene in the generative process on the fly during inference time to improve
the faithfulness of the generated images. Using an attention-based formulation
of GSN, dubbed Attend-and-Excite, we guide the model to refine the
cross-attention units to attend to all subject tokens in the text prompt and
strengthen - or excite - their activations, encouraging the model to generate
all subjects described in the text prompt. We compare our approach to
alternative approaches and demonstrate that it conveys the desired concepts
more faithfully across a range of text prompts. | [
-0.0509308726,
-0.7587990165,
0.8627870679,
0.4884201288,
-0.2765807509,
-0.6649228334,
0.0168876145,
-0.2881844044,
0.1431578547,
0.6268412471,
-0.8741490245,
-0.4683653712,
-0.8062593937,
0.1679921895,
-0.483979553,
0.9201951623,
-0.1207113415,
-0.0689441711,
-0.3991123438,
-0.088189885,
-0.732855022,
-0.1179615483,
-1.0241724253,
-0.0935646221,
0.6266827583,
0.0672658831,
0.5059606433,
0.3597694635,
0.5995126963,
0.1937322319,
-0.3692257404,
0.3150354326,
-0.4942140877,
0.4722346663,
-0.1923321933,
-0.1725999266,
-0.0480598435,
-0.118941173,
0.474011004,
0.8323092461,
0.0071251835,
-0.1502069831,
0.2991251647,
0.6601490974,
-0.6280986071,
0.1942849159,
-0.4987426698,
0.3467736542,
0.2196977586,
-0.4306088984,
-0.7718456984,
-0.2427807748,
0.4758892953,
-0.9158321023,
0.4803814888,
-0.1763087511,
0.6979761124,
0.5084593892,
-0.4385040402,
-0.357621938,
-0.6473536491,
0.5818831325,
-0.2243871987,
0.0942776874,
0.322427243,
0.1843415797,
-0.3912105262,
-0.8135037422,
-0.1943694502,
-0.2510680556,
0.080163382,
0.6953074336,
-0.0652562156,
0.1251432151,
0.2559916675,
0.1776524782,
-0.5558692813,
-0.3375583887,
-0.0096204374,
0.0992228389,
0.0328400172,
0.183228448,
0.7279083133,
0.1042440161,
-0.6169938445,
-0.0073272404,
-0.59475106,
-0.3966492116,
0.0797373056,
0.1885827631,
-0.0706842691,
0.6471818686,
-0.2003376186,
0.9441057444,
-0.1583648175,
0.3077656925,
-0.1657057852,
-0.5477551818,
-0.2363892943,
0.0410724655,
0.6809463501,
0.6026983857,
0.1111858338,
-0.3263027668,
0.2281915992,
0.4933206141,
0.3372769058,
-0.6305885315,
-0.4998522699,
0.2315410376,
-0.7097914219,
-0.2932772934,
-0.3089607954,
-0.6599892378,
-0.319060266,
-0.24128519,
0.526381135,
-0.4652118981,
-0.2414846271,
0.1427267194,
-0.5441455245,
0.008981172,
0.7186833024,
-0.8391939998,
0.000548643,
0.1501472145,
1.1074578762,
-0.4448709488,
-0.2420445532,
-0.5550992489,
0.436175853,
-0.3206855655,
0.9668174386,
-0.4765927494,
-0.6316459775,
0.0924975201,
0.1583580822,
-0.2387251705,
-0.4324946105,
0.6044846177,
-0.5685015321,
0.1914327145,
-0.2796683908,
-0.3829807341,
0.0557666793,
0.204460755,
-0.7371731997,
0.6588119864,
0.390416503,
-0.6136296988,
0.3289116621,
-0.7189028859,
-0.3226709068,
-0.0107817519,
-0.0271216538,
-0.3157960176,
0.1200828403,
0.2667758465,
0.4105454385,
-0.0775498375,
0.2779273987,
-0.2291104496,
-0.1322944462,
0.0676404014,
-0.5202297568,
0.6542903781,
-0.0542810671,
-0.0962384939,
0.4115380943,
-0.6231840253,
0.0334452651,
0.1918734759,
-0.1331631988,
-0.3780949712,
0.0028918886,
0.2302180976,
0.2805072367,
-0.2792421281,
-0.2864947617,
-0.1541260332,
-0.3395421803,
0.3608097136,
0.4848969579,
0.2924832404,
0.6777304411,
-0.2947809398,
0.4093656838,
0.1987141073,
0.1643665731,
-0.9459416866,
-0.8542184234,
-0.6177123189,
-0.3767463565,
-0.0865142718,
0.2796830535,
-1.0172704458,
-0.0148747498,
-0.178429395,
-0.1500147879,
-0.527150929,
-0.2275899202,
0.2424506545,
0.9266283512,
0.508364737,
-0.1375013143,
-0.1814942807,
-0.6408107877,
-0.0751035064,
0.0816798955,
0.0276347976,
0.3626556993,
0.2933974862,
-0.1551877409,
0.5853814483,
-0.39311257,
-0.7040085196,
0.0435454436,
0.2691701651,
-0.1862603873,
0.3755276203,
0.5013719797,
-0.9579117894,
-0.4548512101,
0.0357496031,
-1.0547506809,
-0.0030437945,
-0.2735720575,
-0.5995864272,
0.077835463,
0.4030552506,
-0.4430303872,
0.8476552367,
0.3908588886,
-0.5280668736,
0.4085825682,
-0.215774402,
0.2179258317,
-1.1104109287,
-0.0441508777,
0.002093541,
-0.2402832061,
-0.4517976344,
0.1821658313,
0.1502154768,
-0.3548936248,
-0.3900227249,
0.7948557734,
-0.5801348686,
0.2977223396,
-0.5447390079,
0.0244580992,
0.254417628,
0.3435162604,
0.6059814692,
0.4656839371,
1.0108817816,
-0.83739537,
0.4734176993,
0.6091913581,
-0.1921127141,
0.8578287959,
-0.6808926463,
-0.113849774,
-0.3660258651,
0.4224592745,
-1.340284586,
-0.6203799844,
0.5109186769,
-0.3752789497,
0.2861345112,
-0.1748506278,
-0.2813562155,
-0.2069641948,
-0.0793988109,
0.5004665256,
0.4525354803,
-0.7527458072,
0.6624077559,
-0.0819500834,
-0.2894764543,
-0.2150986344,
-0.9129013419,
0.2337975949,
-0.0192214157,
-0.62293154,
0.6834350824,
0.1040470377,
0.2554141581,
0.4832733572,
0.291436106,
0.0742252916,
-0.1400215775,
0.2823880613,
0.4459781051,
-0.1253581792,
0.1328402907,
0.1997400969,
-0.3054751456,
0.07934957,
-0.5296273232,
0.2913022339,
0.4815839827,
-0.682074964,
-0.7308189273,
0.8405891061,
0.4427478909,
-0.0275426321,
0.7712323666,
0.4446557164,
-0.41959849,
-0.0642797127,
-0.1826714724,
-0.2048403919,
-0.4200886488,
0.4103849232,
0.1364845932,
-0.4502261579,
0.5222103596,
-0.0538467877,
0.0376850367,
0.1809832454,
0.5388686061,
-0.0776595399,
0.943905592,
0.6517567039,
0.4850565493,
0.5484573245,
-0.1547317803,
-0.0625593737,
-1.1044054031,
-0.3527956009,
-0.2285604626,
-0.2284951508,
-0.0081653846,
-0.5925364494,
0.5427413583,
-0.3885108829,
0.045821622,
0.0502589494,
-0.7313807607,
0.2367829233,
0.492962122,
0.3714847267,
0.1801181138,
0.2569596767,
0.0245531425,
-0.1263412088,
-0.7108049393,
-0.2076859921,
0.6774437428,
0.0642489418,
0.9296795726,
0.068081975,
0.55329597,
0.027409194,
0.5466507077,
-0.8205232024,
0.4144454002,
0.0508052483,
-0.2545213401,
-0.2049665451,
-0.4501125515,
-0.8459708095,
0.1832856983,
0.2456172407,
-0.5773259401,
0.3969721198,
0.2215611041,
-0.3500454426,
-0.081922017,
-0.8712279797,
0.9616565108,
0.1626875103,
-0.4591310322,
0.2267366648,
-0.6194030643,
0.3510699272,
0.0815573931,
-0.2667681575,
0.0479006916,
-0.3110052347,
0.4578105807,
-0.3098435998,
1.0071673393,
-0.0614498258,
-0.1503996849,
0.3402679563,
-0.0930668339,
0.5567671061,
-0.1670443118,
0.0861607492,
-0.3217386603,
-0.4393699765,
-0.3176183701,
-0.7393021584,
0.6370110512,
-0.3667444587,
-0.2130233198,
-0.1406030506,
-0.5690611601,
-0.1221194342,
0.0235891677,
0.827133894,
0.5867275596,
-0.1517286003,
-0.1251481175,
1.0988721848,
-0.2920657992,
0.4532961249,
0.154068768,
-0.1972839683,
-0.4174667597,
0.90425843,
0.0417979248,
0.5638083816,
0.233704254,
-0.0268624667,
-0.5036825538,
-0.2223641872,
-0.7352289557,
0.0238284357,
-0.9657773972,
-0.248144418,
-1.0966719389,
-0.2578772306,
-0.2829087675,
-0.20121786,
0.0118440334,
-0.063389495,
-0.8906494975,
0.1402054429,
0.5186626911,
0.4098303914,
0.3112089336,
0.3778877258,
-0.7566658258,
0.4553619921,
0.21551615,
0.1188903376,
0.3361399472,
-0.8725928664,
0.1990806758,
-0.2704260051,
-0.3480145335,
-1.1050333977,
0.3200799823,
0.432148695,
0.5198899508,
0.4641523957,
0.0337141789,
0.5896881819,
-0.7333486676,
0.7230687141,
0.6298344135,
-0.439456284,
0.9502028227,
-0.5287318826,
0.4355096519,
0.1546893567,
0.459795177,
-0.6286200285,
-0.6769722104,
-0.6643188596,
-1.2240840197,
0.7700421214,
0.1613526791,
0.557974875,
-0.477193296,
0.2799599171,
-0.0096115684,
0.127692312,
-0.7250021696,
-0.3191244006,
-0.0657530501,
-0.4451753199,
0.4817109704,
-0.395103842,
-0.080851689,
0.2564098239,
0.6988512278,
-0.2313470691,
0.5944409966,
0.3748061955,
0.2438807487,
-0.1004642919,
-0.1854903549,
0.4097777903,
0.2579499781,
0.2782465219,
0.0375419855,
-0.1579490304,
-0.5108751059,
0.2080012262,
0.1844954193,
-0.4831052423,
0.3006998301,
0.2002619356,
0.8698278666,
0.3218071461,
-0.3761124015,
0.4475704134,
-0.1587694436,
-0.1960654706,
-0.0706451684,
0.2386064827,
0.1733356118,
-0.0719068795,
0.1269263774,
0.2881468534,
0.2859502137,
-0.4595687091,
0.0956744999,
0.4611988664,
-0.7511720061,
0.0812467337,
1.0170543194,
0.1794165373,
-0.1169779971,
0.5328400135,
-0.2006642967,
-0.2593932748,
0.7846447825,
0.7579948306,
1.0270730257,
-0.1573231518,
0.4222201407,
0.2831616998,
0.0389887951,
-0.4362356365,
0.3463547826,
-0.1012416258,
-0.5742043853,
-0.5471913218,
-0.3851919174,
-0.2758693695,
0.0236658566,
-0.7924838066,
0.1177574322,
-0.0532249734,
-0.346467346,
-0.0493439771,
-0.7803348899,
-0.4414761961,
0.3046560287,
0.097107321,
0.883820951,
-0.9621698856,
0.2099121809,
0.88755548,
-0.5017846823,
-0.6486173868,
0.1791366488,
-0.1621244103,
-0.5170201659,
0.5597599745,
0.2502979934,
0.0463040136,
0.2780863941,
-0.47353971,
-0.7118339539,
0.7245061398,
0.1516998261,
-0.1741592139,
-0.0990925506,
-0.2680614889,
0.3796776831,
-0.2760211527,
0.3530431986,
0.148361817,
0.2223615348,
0.6739760041,
-0.3302091956,
-0.0652379915,
-0.1817494929,
0.3341114223,
-0.0275851693,
-0.4569482207,
0.445920825,
-0.494596988,
-0.2376323789,
0.469704777,
0.942551434,
0.2119943798,
0.5187467337,
0.2499476969,
0.6553689241,
0.8150152564,
-0.3667996526,
1.2384643555,
0.2184229195,
0.2026148736,
1.1047148705,
-0.4846631587,
0.6713753939,
0.4491378665,
0.0609448962,
0.1920125484,
0.7299633622,
0.0381527953,
0.9720914364,
-0.0850112811,
-0.7172848582,
-0.1344137937,
-0.5662824512,
-0.3377895355,
-0.2376008183,
0.4788024426,
-0.7610971332,
-0.5886952281,
0.614308238,
-0.4025167525,
0.0242325608,
-0.3123959303,
0.821713388,
0.2049389184,
-0.9351539016,
0.234315142,
-0.3415955007,
0.3117515147,
-0.4900090396,
-0.3487812877,
-0.097605899,
-0.052650746,
-0.059173651,
-0.7687277198,
0.3828193247,
-0.1290659308,
-0.5282331109,
-0.3517867327,
0.8865542412,
-0.549603045,
-0.4415171444,
0.2984885275,
0.2849014401,
0.1984312683,
-0.1902115345,
-0.5865300894,
0.0670510978,
-0.0562679544,
-0.1455594152,
0.3551586568,
0.7085167766,
0.0400097296,
0.606803596,
0.4825018644,
0.0571366772,
0.0435371846,
0.4102557302,
0.8424854875,
-0.2863494456,
-0.671020627,
-0.8432462215,
0.554094255,
-0.0723996907,
-0.3971004486,
0.3390628397,
0.1410961002,
0.5143030882,
-0.40436396,
0.7987504005,
0.1084038317,
0.1841418892,
-0.6734280586,
0.7657302618,
-0.6242468953,
-0.2811226845,
-0.2231496274,
-0.7910119891,
-0.3049875796,
0.6923261881,
-0.1987940073,
0.1805784404,
0.6603730917,
0.7869870067,
-0.0044875932,
0.2385801822,
0.4420598745,
-0.2535099387,
0.1027518809,
0.6332427859,
1.3105840683,
-0.3425806165,
0.3685174882,
0.1756551415,
-0.3864539862,
-0.4050557911,
-1.0962895155,
-0.7494139075,
-0.5094544291,
-0.7160289288,
-0.6130673885,
0.1295976043,
0.5679590702,
0.6689807177,
-0.3884245753,
0.6545535326,
-0.5444905758,
0.0184338428,
-0.2966578305,
-0.2628494203,
0.5467703938,
-0.7436466813,
-0.8353564739,
-0.045957204,
0.656637609,
0.4259265065,
-0.1663627028,
0.2645399272,
0.1236410812,
-0.1190226674,
0.5437682867,
0.0959641635,
-0.4388952255,
0.3440599442,
0.1333161592,
-0.4468027055,
-0.1776058227,
0.5248396993,
-0.8623868227,
0.5894184113,
0.2446884364,
0.8455405831,
0.0812211856,
-0.0580685809,
0.3702711165,
-0.7149753571,
0.1417826116,
0.3513810039,
0.2739312351,
0.4949519038,
-0.6536046267,
0.4484401643,
0.4188502133,
-0.5199822783,
-0.5891759992,
0.3550743461,
-1.0076272488,
-0.0463285632,
1.3639644384,
-0.4328440428,
-0.5982079506,
-0.2228639871,
-0.4776123166,
0.1786371917,
-0.0968923345,
0.6046605706,
0.7505004406,
-0.0956094936,
-0.1105289981,
-0.7812017202,
0.4797475636,
0.6873693466,
-0.7962981462,
0.0946076065,
0.5103061795,
-0.0647767559,
0.1912063956,
0.7810159326,
-0.2120558023,
0.6852083802,
-0.1354140043,
-0.2611061633,
0.0767466277,
-0.5452914834,
-0.1110831425,
-0.1792128235,
-0.2328312099,
-0.4871692359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13816v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13816v4 | Execution-based Code Generation using Deep Reinforcement Learning | 2023-01-31T18:02:26 | 2023-07-19T19:55:31 | Parshin Shojaee, Aneesh Jain, Sindhu Tipirneni, Chandan K. Reddy | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL | The utilization of programming language (PL) models, pre-trained on
large-scale code corpora, as a means of automating software engineering
processes has demonstrated considerable potential in streamlining various code
generation tasks such as code completion, code translation, and program
synthesis. However, current approaches mainly rely on supervised fine-tuning
objectives borrowed from text generation, neglecting unique sequence-level
characteristics of code, including but not limited to compilability as well as
syntactic and functional correctness. To address this limitation, we propose
PPOCoder, a new framework for code generation that synergistically combines
pre-trained PL models with Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) which is a widely
used deep reinforcement learning technique. By utilizing non-differentiable
feedback from code execution and structure alignment, PPOCoder seamlessly
integrates external code-specific knowledge into the model optimization
process. It's important to note that PPOCoder is a task-agnostic and
model-agnostic framework that can be used across different code generation
tasks and PLs. Extensive experiments on three code generation tasks demonstrate
the effectiveness of our proposed approach compared to SOTA methods, achieving
significant improvements in compilation success rates and functional
correctness across different PLs. | [
-0.156878531,
-0.4391595721,
0.3424885571,
0.3179045618,
-0.1036381871,
0.1755995899,
-0.3594034314,
0.1184778512,
-0.2530867755,
0.604978919,
-0.5315668583,
-0.3758045435,
-0.119113639,
0.0098684672,
0.0362984464,
1.3122509718,
-0.2743074298,
-0.0322902314,
0.0047939294,
0.3420357406,
-0.3533272147,
-0.4456751347,
-0.4340714812,
-0.0545144714,
0.115787901,
0.6397850513,
0.495539397,
0.362177223,
0.4878698885,
0.3268361986,
0.4224260747,
0.2622044683,
-0.5243450403,
-0.1564088315,
-0.1620540321,
-0.2152821273,
-0.3609452248,
-0.1937410235,
0.471945554,
0.3060599267,
-0.3090110421,
-0.0183035638,
0.0664632991,
0.4254151881,
-0.9207862616,
0.0537419915,
-0.4354605079,
0.2375357598,
0.312509954,
-0.4037536979,
-0.3581101298,
-0.5867983699,
0.0850691125,
-0.615858674,
0.0182624552,
-0.207054317,
0.5882406235,
0.2871150374,
-0.1215835661,
-0.5890592933,
-0.7146773934,
0.90038836,
-0.8721307516,
-0.0034752598,
-0.1008886024,
0.1976576447,
-0.3629844487,
-0.8345010877,
-0.7218466997,
-0.686044991,
0.0862162188,
0.1243531927,
0.1012619361,
0.3278504014,
0.1456392407,
0.4919933081,
-0.593439281,
0.2781080306,
-0.2219063491,
-0.2446289361,
0.6144595742,
0.0470044389,
0.1696340144,
0.0202478338,
-0.3056665361,
-0.1784703285,
-0.6454280019,
0.2815699875,
0.6976600289,
0.1745020598,
-0.0745619014,
0.3266823888,
-0.1020624936,
0.4343505502,
0.0950404406,
0.149938494,
0.2262192667,
-0.2289115191,
-0.3802777529,
-0.062237177,
0.9249950051,
0.18927145,
0.2281723619,
-0.0666200146,
-0.2924945951,
0.3105396032,
0.599339366,
-0.9458979368,
-0.4645441771,
0.2409856468,
-0.3027386963,
-0.6842291951,
0.1770063937,
-0.4765541852,
-0.0362785012,
-0.3442821801,
0.1480262578,
-0.4277072549,
-0.3664935231,
0.0234210417,
0.1604529023,
0.2414231449,
0.062669307,
-0.5558655858,
0.1184667572,
0.9014554024,
0.4516856968,
0.0130486945,
-0.4815125465,
-1.0723934174,
0.0052683325,
-0.7766320705,
0.3142105937,
-0.6843557358,
-0.3075221479,
0.0261599962,
-0.1268182546,
0.0568693355,
-0.6026955843,
0.1681086421,
-0.5860564709,
0.0285819974,
0.2622869015,
-0.5451968908,
0.1570000052,
-0.0047954679,
-0.1746115535,
0.8006988168,
0.3208322823,
-0.4574499726,
0.4309756458,
-0.7688118815,
-0.6022027731,
0.0400272459,
-0.4892775118,
-0.7976002693,
0.3245692849,
-0.1171932444,
0.3445774317,
-0.0712016746,
0.4272262156,
-0.0928723589,
-0.4956604242,
0.0561381318,
0.0767007321,
0.3888069093,
0.4128841162,
-0.7707843184,
0.5624216795,
-0.6415183544,
0.2225738317,
-0.0598159358,
-0.4401049614,
0.076349102,
0.1076060981,
-0.1774906367,
0.3766272068,
0.2519148588,
-0.3880644739,
0.367098093,
-0.3421934247,
0.5867900848,
0.8184415698,
0.053059455,
0.5190156698,
-0.1047745124,
0.7349846363,
-0.0643937886,
0.4147619605,
-0.176131472,
0.0014485224,
-0.4890187681,
-0.2155710608,
0.1829869598,
0.7367190123,
-0.9214061499,
0.549013555,
0.1924948245,
-0.3184974492,
-0.2513642311,
0.3528754413,
0.8864848018,
0.4851609468,
0.2059516758,
-0.5989776254,
-0.7052482367,
-0.6787332296,
0.083587572,
-0.1283738613,
0.1207839251,
0.3923629224,
0.5376164913,
-0.2462053597,
0.6674252152,
-0.3679065704,
-0.1694906652,
-0.3782892525,
0.2951637506,
0.2204876244,
0.8302605152,
0.2581549585,
-0.8411577344,
-0.3663128018,
0.175782904,
-0.5742484331,
-0.1015718058,
-0.3923744559,
-0.1053031087,
0.3592180312,
0.6546735168,
-0.0421531089,
0.0108581996,
0.7816566229,
0.077006951,
0.8897426724,
-0.6294795871,
-0.0210637003,
-0.7394001484,
0.2988032103,
-0.3885416985,
0.0339728184,
-0.255550772,
0.4941832125,
-0.0766187981,
-0.3980577886,
-0.5617317557,
-0.0987750813,
-0.2620172799,
-0.1953572482,
-0.4066332281,
-0.4459653795,
-0.0390513577,
0.6403245926,
0.3038440347,
1.1989017725,
0.5676565766,
-0.8186092377,
0.159101516,
-0.042938754,
-0.3614243865,
0.1490563452,
-0.870667696,
0.3369221687,
0.1319837719,
0.1613774151,
-0.5111086369,
-0.0966148302,
0.0748676211,
-0.2778815329,
0.2828980684,
-0.2644832432,
-0.357558459,
-0.3043094277,
-0.3484284282,
0.1470792592,
0.7025473714,
-0.203720212,
0.144013688,
0.1423715204,
-0.1026007608,
-0.7119363546,
-0.2375510633,
-0.2133865356,
0.1024288982,
-0.2995359302,
0.4570300877,
-0.0935309529,
0.0141219385,
-0.1103193536,
-0.2950162292,
-0.0621969178,
0.222579807,
0.1569586843,
0.1707348675,
-0.3083897233,
-0.2033028156,
0.1804976314,
-0.1937503517,
-0.1950398982,
-0.6437742114,
0.618578732,
-0.2466726005,
-0.1497238874,
-0.5128703117,
0.2237561792,
0.329102397,
-0.5321641564,
0.517077446,
0.4001935124,
0.2744336426,
-0.4980621338,
-0.1376125813,
-0.0412235335,
-0.5005733371,
0.3559758663,
-0.5077500939,
-1.0287926197,
0.2250961214,
-0.484318763,
0.2115196288,
0.0131824538,
0.4782016575,
-0.1408622861,
0.9242970347,
0.8247164488,
0.1261223555,
0.7150160074,
-0.5317518711,
0.3074884415,
-0.6778441668,
0.0236619897,
-0.2178347111,
-0.0861335769,
-0.8762044311,
-0.5444683433,
0.1449307799,
0.5205296278,
-0.4113682508,
0.7135631442,
-0.7145208716,
0.5192468166,
0.7211537361,
-0.1036421955,
-0.0602323711,
-0.2189458311,
-0.2514766157,
0.1769768149,
-0.6750264168,
-0.4865353405,
0.9600871205,
0.0744434968,
0.6064657569,
-0.1902417243,
1.0139452219,
0.3965632915,
0.1542420089,
-0.1680902243,
0.4343654811,
-0.3752455413,
-0.0709179044,
-0.2163150012,
-0.7097661495,
-0.668874979,
-0.0559488349,
0.1102627739,
-0.3754073381,
0.2275535017,
0.4347119927,
-0.6277336478,
-0.0807771981,
-0.8573321104,
1.2981668711,
-0.5012839437,
-0.5952452421,
-0.302298218,
-0.5725650191,
0.059115842,
0.0156942867,
-0.0100656524,
0.125524804,
-0.0516879596,
0.2334638387,
-0.894993186,
0.6410375834,
-0.5358710289,
-0.3383373618,
0.5205065608,
0.2326895297,
0.803161025,
0.2272672206,
-0.0651864111,
-0.107250616,
-0.299213022,
-0.2877908349,
-0.5497829318,
0.6633502245,
-0.7565897703,
-0.1796847284,
-0.1502864361,
-0.5373706818,
0.0888912603,
0.2118353546,
0.269559741,
0.3438383043,
0.0355315506,
0.0650074258,
0.5003032684,
-0.7821811438,
0.355117172,
0.5774205327,
-0.1027010158,
-0.3937675059,
1.2716389894,
-0.2969467938,
0.0850797892,
0.661041379,
0.0257208906,
0.0266236383,
-0.8009866476,
-0.1229514927,
-0.2246271521,
-0.0937616751,
-0.1486809254,
-0.3246310651,
-0.0780892968,
-0.427580744,
-0.5500497818,
-0.4705978036,
0.0021739078,
-0.0478484407,
0.1275753528,
-0.0502519011,
0.401576966,
-0.1214682981,
0.440384537,
-0.5873999,
0.3041892648,
0.2223089486,
0.3844044507,
-0.4553443789,
-0.0154750291,
-0.088625282,
-0.1828707159,
-0.5316550136,
-0.4648480713,
0.2410247177,
0.2406441122,
0.3997926414,
0.2067696899,
0.334995538,
0.5129944682,
-0.4893880188,
0.4858154058,
0.2248880267,
-1.0343691111,
0.8687226176,
-0.2677079439,
0.0692711025,
0.6646792293,
0.1322064102,
-0.0256797746,
-0.599498868,
-0.5804110169,
-0.8938362002,
0.6342006326,
0.2818237245,
0.2243518233,
-0.0857325494,
0.0618996471,
0.2030394226,
0.5571740866,
-0.5205643177,
0.3899554312,
-0.3260405064,
-0.0595760085,
-0.0298268273,
0.0133163631,
0.2186641097,
0.020750571,
0.6041382551,
-0.4674579203,
0.3443398476,
0.0654674768,
-0.4645674527,
0.1069533601,
0.309720993,
0.9928247929,
0.8220271468,
-0.1344759464,
-0.247473225,
-0.1873324364,
-0.2719887793,
0.048619885,
0.1400698125,
-0.1176412702,
-0.4298044145,
0.2416265309,
0.9566636682,
0.3324826658,
-1.0928885937,
0.6423879266,
0.1838936359,
-0.2467187792,
-0.5540416837,
0.5185145736,
-0.3148574829,
0.4070761204,
0.2145369947,
0.0916122422,
0.1619874537,
-0.457490176,
0.6140820384,
0.1328284889,
-0.20243752,
-0.2309406549,
0.6249071956,
0.3422705829,
-0.1899517775,
0.7912330627,
-0.5689997673,
-0.5620001554,
0.921587646,
0.4881494641,
0.8152397275,
-0.0631390959,
0.414845854,
0.1873541623,
0.0141666895,
0.3364421427,
0.4843226075,
-0.379445523,
-0.4145237505,
-1.0743863583,
-0.8769595623,
-0.3688715696,
0.1642178893,
-0.3804742098,
0.2312327623,
-0.8834642768,
0.0137465745,
-0.2990378439,
0.1373625249,
-0.2941431105,
0.0566639975,
0.164653033,
0.6959864497,
-0.5218490958,
0.9331672788,
0.8363220692,
-0.6391168237,
-0.8132683635,
0.1978072077,
-0.3990527391,
-0.4803282917,
0.7915762663,
0.0868495628,
0.0316631086,
0.1067863703,
-0.4036103487,
-0.2557119429,
0.6904218793,
0.6183791757,
-0.818295598,
-0.2253720015,
0.0524972565,
0.5479076505,
-0.4524740875,
0.2620848417,
0.2887260616,
0.1490964592,
-0.040101096,
-1.0709652901,
-0.2159686983,
-0.2668457031,
0.3389005363,
0.365485549,
-0.577919364,
0.8629593253,
-0.498252511,
0.1726807654,
0.0752260908,
0.6210412979,
0.5468860865,
-0.0174632967,
0.2808858454,
0.4230580628,
0.4444617629,
0.2849919796,
1.2628564835,
-0.5816540718,
0.218241334,
1.2605745792,
-0.5223844051,
0.6694116592,
0.3553541899,
-0.1612334698,
0.7542811036,
0.4197918773,
-0.1104932278,
0.7761992216,
0.4667439759,
-0.0341303982,
-0.1420948207,
0.0021057706,
-0.3249869645,
0.4236065149,
-0.0148115102,
-0.4808592796,
-0.1174335629,
0.0275677219,
0.0686899573,
0.1985806525,
-0.241087079,
0.8670076132,
-0.0885730982,
-0.8781884909,
0.5789344311,
0.0497810841,
0.7643427849,
-0.6775991321,
-0.3462844193,
-0.1791203618,
0.7590274215,
-0.1467519253,
-0.5350589752,
0.4108085632,
0.016352877,
-0.1256946325,
-0.4944333136,
0.4702726007,
-0.1446559429,
-0.2066577226,
0.1394494623,
-0.1187630445,
0.006829184,
-0.010408679,
-0.8107480407,
0.0960547403,
0.0649341643,
-0.047674153,
0.3672845662,
0.4081269205,
-0.0547401309,
0.4079250693,
0.8189818859,
0.0633083582,
0.1465255916,
0.006936322,
0.7757041454,
-0.164512679,
-0.8454002142,
-0.6935510635,
0.4738264382,
-0.0936025754,
-0.4181076288,
0.5832496285,
0.8499461412,
1.210901618,
-0.2991897464,
0.8560070992,
-0.4394112527,
0.0420065075,
-0.5231299996,
0.4643719792,
-0.2652363181,
0.1039338559,
-0.6069108248,
-0.8809423447,
-0.0598320365,
0.9108516574,
-0.6164612174,
-0.0588719919,
0.5046393871,
0.8275783658,
0.0175620075,
-0.2219453454,
0.078606002,
-0.132621333,
0.2769751549,
1.0489192009,
0.8707577586,
-0.2476769388,
0.6842350364,
-0.3100946546,
-0.3283410966,
-0.3071210384,
-0.9857316613,
-0.4377300441,
-0.3573240936,
-0.529859364,
-0.125303477,
0.3864071369,
0.8141109943,
0.9088054895,
-0.947111547,
-0.399718523,
-0.9671861529,
-0.0882982239,
-0.6005202532,
-0.2624824941,
0.1675855517,
-0.9225984216,
-0.5472080112,
0.403921634,
0.2297994792,
-0.3015445471,
-0.0941789523,
-0.7042559385,
0.1523832828,
-0.2672995925,
0.5228877664,
0.5211986303,
-0.2092960477,
0.0569027774,
-0.0156837702,
-0.072256498,
0.0102568977,
1.344438076,
-0.7725750208,
0.1438031197,
0.5651224852,
0.7126509547,
0.2638560832,
-0.1317719668,
0.9271795154,
-0.9777732491,
0.2364849597,
0.5871644616,
-0.0809147209,
-0.0132632917,
-0.3540349603,
0.3729255199,
-0.0410195962,
-0.6324853897,
-0.9549252391,
0.3726694286,
-0.4996986985,
-0.4106981158,
0.8063440919,
-0.3902258575,
-0.0571035035,
0.125177756,
-0.224379912,
0.2425721437,
-0.5038448572,
0.4754350185,
0.0407046042,
-0.3738084733,
-0.4136629701,
-0.5070891976,
0.6306695938,
0.4861347377,
-0.8779743314,
0.0575754866,
0.6183828712,
0.1870614588,
0.1163295433,
0.6671031117,
-0.0569977164,
0.6036791801,
-0.0619983822,
0.3252567649,
-0.3155623376,
-0.5825554132,
0.0233700406,
0.3391230404,
0.1601754576,
-0.2495617121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13808v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13808v3 | Large Language Models are Versatile Decomposers: Decompose Evidence and Questions for Table-based Reasoning | 2023-01-31T17:51:45 | 2023-04-27T11:24:10 | Yunhu Ye, Binyuan Hui, Min Yang, Binhua Li, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table-based reasoning has shown remarkable progress in combining deep models
with discrete reasoning, which requires reasoning over both free-form natural
language (NL) questions and structured tabular data. However, previous
table-based reasoning solutions usually suffer from significant performance
degradation on huge evidence (tables). In addition, most existing methods
struggle to reason over complex questions since the required information is
scattered in different places. To alleviate the above challenges, we exploit
large language models (LLMs) as decomposers for effective table-based
reasoning, which (i) decompose huge evidence (a huge table) into sub-evidence
(a small table) to mitigate the interference of useless information for table
reasoning; and (ii) decompose complex questions into simpler sub-questions for
text reasoning. Specifically, we first use the LLMs to break down the evidence
(tables) involved in the current question, retaining the relevant evidence and
excluding the remaining irrelevant evidence from the huge table. In addition,
we propose a "parsing-execution-filling" strategy to alleviate the
hallucination dilemma of the chain of thought by decoupling logic and numerical
computation in each step. Extensive experiments show that our method can
effectively leverage decomposed evidence and questions and outperforms the
strong baselines on TabFact, WikiTableQuestion, and FetaQA datasets. Notably,
our model outperforms human performance for the first time on the TabFact
dataset. | [
-0.3770458698,
-0.9837934375,
0.8325178027,
-0.158845678,
-0.3915349841,
-0.2829537392,
-0.2933565676,
-0.4159493744,
-0.2805600166,
0.8234913349,
-0.2404957414,
-0.5366979837,
-0.2676189244,
0.0286007877,
-0.6000346541,
0.7269278765,
0.2054697871,
0.000061238,
-0.3119341731,
0.0102915168,
-0.2927600741,
-0.5279650688,
-0.4441500008,
-0.5999500155,
0.5787139535,
0.402789712,
0.823859334,
0.8928592205,
0.4338537157,
0.2574372888,
-0.2657968402,
0.3095567226,
-0.492523104,
0.1266490817,
-0.4726289511,
-0.3793093264,
-0.4667309225,
-0.4301747382,
0.4415206909,
0.8268408179,
-0.4464056492,
-0.0042222627,
-0.3020327687,
0.5375059247,
-0.5488452911,
0.3789138198,
-0.9648010731,
0.066326052,
-0.004637822,
-0.0216500293,
-0.933224678,
-0.352040112,
-0.0466554873,
-0.2325971425,
0.1101074219,
-0.0429107659,
0.6245445013,
0.2636626065,
-0.4312003851,
-0.0539923012,
-0.8563925028,
0.5614119172,
-0.870628953,
0.6675365567,
0.3405281007,
0.2514981925,
-0.5146026611,
-0.7777616978,
-0.7362346053,
-0.392950505,
-0.2269532979,
-0.3720937669,
-0.0332911238,
0.1346175373,
0.5674131513,
0.4632562101,
-0.7578647733,
0.0881865248,
-0.0720350221,
-0.0279085469,
0.4472622573,
0.3136326075,
0.543767333,
-0.0536965542,
-0.0174859092,
-0.1935486943,
-0.8306120634,
-0.283364296,
-0.2386335731,
0.3574002087,
0.2063125223,
0.4996634424,
-0.1486630142,
0.7452545166,
-0.3775684536,
-0.174658075,
-0.1987430751,
0.0339798443,
-0.3662835658,
0.0570939742,
0.5872812271,
0.349380672,
0.1485952884,
-0.3602155149,
-0.1982059181,
0.4053285122,
0.0137197161,
-0.8768421412,
-0.5285887122,
0.2745756209,
-0.3387517631,
0.1148770526,
-0.2852507532,
-0.8221435547,
-0.5474304557,
-0.373927027,
0.478453964,
-0.2688170075,
-0.1855920255,
0.4320028424,
0.0309388526,
0.3248467445,
0.5932794213,
-0.9639191031,
0.5246368647,
0.976636529,
0.4298400879,
0.017817473,
-0.0728181079,
-0.6460803747,
0.3227692544,
-0.4569983482,
0.908201158,
-0.5430963039,
-0.0896010995,
0.0397969224,
-0.0378420204,
0.2652367651,
-0.7031471729,
0.8069748282,
-0.5643232465,
0.0913540348,
-0.5981804729,
-0.5326849818,
-0.3184773326,
0.4583581984,
-0.9428557158,
0.7527339458,
-0.2241631001,
-0.5035387874,
0.3569612801,
-0.6093298197,
-0.5064960718,
0.0873790383,
-0.0839242414,
-0.3036632538,
0.0774603412,
0.4787811339,
0.4603329301,
-0.6404725909,
0.6105574965,
-0.2732664943,
-0.2705331147,
0.0537401028,
-0.2725751996,
0.5487598777,
0.0777768642,
-0.2915921211,
0.1260603219,
-0.7036338449,
-0.0748208761,
0.2182986587,
-0.5155430436,
-0.3033559918,
0.4181277454,
-0.076090984,
0.1930261999,
-0.189162612,
-0.4566843808,
0.3192573786,
-0.3950548172,
0.5797566772,
0.3822492659,
-0.0883804783,
0.3623497486,
-0.1581034511,
0.0705037192,
0.058402203,
-0.2030763328,
-0.2297011167,
-0.1753981858,
-0.6971750855,
-0.1788422316,
0.29414168,
0.4915169775,
-0.7703555226,
0.3109244108,
-0.4787689149,
-0.3584655523,
-0.1130835861,
-0.1679638028,
0.2742343545,
0.7401043177,
0.6300091743,
0.2288101315,
-0.4592247605,
-0.9240347147,
-0.3087894619,
-0.0693492666,
-0.0548462607,
-0.0751523748,
0.6713567972,
-0.2033670098,
0.5541530848,
-0.4848821759,
0.0318785496,
-0.6152461767,
-0.0459779017,
0.2367311567,
0.3808410168,
0.0290094391,
-0.6117745042,
-0.0286103599,
0.1374478489,
-0.8771116138,
0.0113012828,
-0.1769738942,
-0.2167132795,
0.2847011983,
0.4544388056,
-1.1254506111,
0.3687726557,
0.1421416402,
-0.4616997838,
0.4402637482,
-0.0248064138,
-0.0518503189,
-0.6662456393,
0.1068663746,
-0.1858018935,
-0.328589648,
-0.624157548,
0.2074103057,
0.0366001464,
-0.1970883012,
-0.119410105,
0.617511332,
-0.5233135819,
-0.1471948177,
-0.1377842724,
0.0641896427,
0.217096597,
0.3842763007,
0.2427736372,
0.45632267,
0.1776121408,
-0.5085263252,
0.1145199612,
0.3979507685,
-0.6408116221,
-0.0096593536,
-0.6311303377,
0.1274866164,
-0.2759748697,
0.4758949876,
-0.8378324509,
-0.3167037964,
0.1004378498,
-0.0046145078,
0.3412750959,
-0.0652694926,
-0.6100224257,
-0.3564460576,
-0.1724439114,
0.3149552345,
0.4547129571,
-0.7941153049,
0.9152997136,
0.4404858053,
-0.1092024595,
-0.7057912946,
-0.7862873673,
0.3203888535,
-0.1650596261,
-0.6475905776,
0.4862174392,
0.0767154694,
-0.7255913019,
0.104501687,
-0.29573524,
0.0683514401,
-0.1706744581,
0.0288384072,
0.1565343887,
-0.2453762293,
0.3361902535,
0.093056947,
-0.1073701531,
0.2721265852,
0.0083758943,
0.7212659717,
-0.1659133583,
-0.2353985757,
-0.3243513703,
0.5382899642,
0.852748692,
-0.324560225,
0.9792956114,
0.2006197125,
-0.6873181462,
-0.5529705286,
-0.9551926255,
-0.487539202,
-0.4047207236,
0.4544782937,
-0.4677903056,
-0.890019834,
0.7290299535,
-0.0505009182,
0.2205835134,
0.3286387622,
0.7026786804,
0.1954237968,
0.9365113974,
0.1259576976,
0.1050831825,
0.0124627193,
-0.2328593135,
0.3685356379,
-0.5298387408,
-0.3920739889,
-0.6319668293,
-0.1297657192,
-0.078793332,
-0.5699096322,
0.0187379476,
-0.0971974656,
-0.4690515697,
0.010047771,
-0.5350598693,
0.8420245051,
0.3529395461,
0.3305842578,
0.5017634034,
-0.0576477535,
0.1338401735,
0.1252183318,
-0.741705358,
-0.5388876796,
0.7595567703,
0.4778834879,
0.9342060089,
-0.0617084391,
0.500487864,
0.2388175279,
0.3736308217,
-0.7356618643,
0.8943622708,
-0.2037241608,
-0.571400404,
-0.4559494853,
-0.7616443634,
-0.7326866388,
0.6039242744,
-0.1939238012,
-0.8296981454,
0.067448847,
0.2697141767,
-0.1340114325,
0.5681182742,
-0.651743412,
1.0547494888,
-0.0591357686,
-0.4607714415,
-0.2267470807,
-0.4883087277,
0.7482634187,
0.1057647094,
0.327303201,
-0.0597855337,
0.2362036407,
0.694051981,
-0.6650484204,
0.5357244015,
-0.2627348006,
-0.3194233179,
0.3674166799,
0.5623658299,
0.7321451306,
0.0941966325,
-0.1612743884,
0.107708022,
-0.0102224834,
-0.1526413858,
-0.7502468228,
0.6379421949,
-0.387340188,
-0.7991188765,
-0.210146293,
-0.6682888865,
-0.1750096083,
0.0119032282,
-0.0965582654,
0.6593205333,
0.0810045153,
0.4458224773,
0.8377795219,
-0.2625584602,
0.3653762639,
0.2573387623,
-0.3774522245,
-0.4429970384,
0.4407036901,
-0.0602620803,
0.0778234005,
0.729377687,
0.418749541,
-0.6109468341,
-0.7580695152,
-0.2499144226,
0.285084933,
-0.8532813191,
-0.3572346568,
-0.781455636,
0.041618336,
-0.0556104369,
-0.0492659844,
-0.2793080211,
-0.3627966046,
0.1845854223,
-0.2938156128,
0.1165871844,
0.3599089682,
-0.0629303008,
0.0523542836,
-0.8649139404,
0.7142035961,
0.5563847423,
0.2987122536,
0.2379806638,
-0.3994560838,
-0.002540845,
-0.0382251292,
0.2400427908,
-0.9772446752,
0.3751483262,
-0.0228442643,
0.5881803632,
0.1271214634,
0.1196948811,
0.6902475953,
-0.4964160919,
0.5684473515,
-0.0187852234,
-1.1083288193,
0.3307437897,
-0.5507430434,
0.3229118586,
0.5297544003,
0.1452792138,
-0.3451268077,
-0.0573701039,
-0.0845496804,
-0.957333982,
0.6332010031,
-0.0437333174,
-0.1205557808,
-0.0922730267,
0.4358441234,
0.1450491697,
-0.0343024284,
-1.2102475166,
0.3364695609,
0.079142414,
-0.1370601952,
0.2315027863,
-0.4889053404,
-0.1057580486,
-0.657741785,
0.566604495,
-0.0862294883,
0.157923758,
0.112155959,
-0.2848922312,
-0.1050632074,
0.4997814894,
0.5658559799,
0.7809742093,
-0.2248223871,
0.5053403378,
0.393068701,
-0.279242605,
0.055731222,
-0.0636059344,
-0.1202078909,
-0.1942348182,
0.4469455779,
0.5038671494,
0.1867656559,
-0.8815686703,
0.1294180751,
-0.1283516139,
-0.2365089059,
-0.1621139646,
-0.0031342574,
0.3873904347,
0.2886402607,
0.324265331,
-0.4660713673,
0.1592055559,
-0.8180718422,
0.216841802,
0.3959085345,
0.136602819,
-0.0407162793,
0.6197904348,
0.0256252028,
-0.3128576577,
0.8229666948,
-0.1257538944,
-0.5793021321,
0.5045530796,
0.6866613626,
0.6475327015,
-0.1528516561,
0.0719689876,
0.3875922561,
0.4693993628,
-0.5719150305,
0.4571669698,
0.0216749478,
-0.7214019895,
-0.8512766361,
-0.6732373834,
-0.3642861545,
0.5623779297,
-0.3152708113,
0.0312631279,
-0.4572755694,
0.1337231696,
0.1120978072,
-0.3248610497,
-0.4168767631,
0.1617298722,
0.2380376309,
0.978002131,
-0.7632238865,
0.5959598422,
0.2688963413,
-0.2333503813,
-0.951982975,
-0.1346656382,
-0.2578688562,
-0.247996673,
0.536418736,
0.2695627511,
-0.0304014254,
-0.2494497299,
-0.6117515564,
-0.6155689359,
0.6222229004,
0.6267493367,
-0.6330126524,
-0.1426900476,
0.3241014779,
0.5003825426,
-0.1808702648,
0.1180294678,
0.8336148262,
0.6471325159,
0.191787228,
-0.7625081539,
0.4399369657,
-0.1466631293,
-0.2503007352,
0.649502039,
-0.172314465,
0.8731272221,
-0.1723352373,
-0.0990432426,
-0.2138203382,
0.5285576582,
0.1351789236,
0.3334574401,
0.5632233024,
0.9447522163,
0.6121891737,
-0.2377628833,
0.8859212995,
0.055968456,
0.1372270584,
1.29669559,
-0.4259873927,
1.0364120007,
0.3029984534,
-0.0565608256,
0.735263586,
0.3003561795,
-0.0191502068,
0.364808917,
0.4092337191,
-0.211317271,
-0.7123755813,
0.0187236946,
-0.3060301244,
0.6929000616,
0.6721529961,
-0.2242582142,
-0.5809692144,
-0.2193327695,
0.1743687242,
0.2139957994,
-0.3883716762,
0.8277253509,
0.0240612999,
-0.8327598572,
0.7688361406,
-0.0448640846,
0.0084895259,
-0.3846987486,
-0.4001456201,
-0.2838205099,
0.2869122922,
-0.3080534041,
-0.6942928433,
0.3989383876,
-0.0633472726,
-0.0435019135,
-0.13626194,
0.8403601646,
-0.4747834802,
-0.2799927294,
0.1153435111,
0.4661047459,
0.0153040159,
-0.2668417096,
-0.2353709191,
0.2952207625,
-0.1179912314,
-0.3217999041,
0.2750972211,
0.493768692,
-0.0878327042,
0.8116680384,
0.7108979821,
-0.2090573311,
-0.2527166307,
0.2223912627,
1.178319931,
-0.9815887809,
-0.4072856009,
-1.2213679552,
0.6587989926,
-0.0695528388,
0.1791340113,
0.3760153651,
0.7126663327,
0.3723224401,
-0.1439938098,
0.3702788353,
0.1562529802,
0.453124702,
-0.6628080606,
0.7278676629,
-0.4306430221,
0.3495057523,
-0.3738843501,
-1.0509084463,
-0.6410104632,
0.7168092728,
-0.3401269913,
-0.0479252636,
0.6957977414,
0.7319882512,
-0.0039776764,
0.1506147832,
0.3110045493,
0.3568202555,
0.5127664208,
0.7728020549,
1.0049766302,
-0.08837571,
0.6286423802,
-0.081693463,
-0.1146664321,
-0.1888346672,
-0.8839672208,
-1.2455283403,
-0.3808663487,
-0.2095493525,
-0.2863533497,
0.0205924325,
0.9175018668,
0.492911309,
-0.6530478597,
-0.1056434289,
-0.2901912034,
0.2633092403,
0.0043070656,
-0.2327256948,
0.5779669881,
0.0253874734,
-0.3088240027,
0.4939233959,
0.3175192773,
-0.2230489552,
-0.2203510404,
0.2404531837,
-0.3293682933,
0.0998693407,
0.9559720159,
0.2418821305,
-0.8151686788,
-0.3973066807,
-0.0598959886,
0.1180788577,
0.1077680439,
0.74047786,
-0.81962955,
0.1494292766,
0.8496408463,
0.7564563751,
0.8013256192,
0.1320572495,
0.4231151342,
-0.2346249223,
0.0652191415,
0.5257383585,
0.5653179288,
0.3136802316,
-0.1708098948,
0.6501607299,
-0.150953263,
-0.6708759665,
-1.2736498117,
0.2584245801,
-1.035746932,
-0.5526949167,
1.094773531,
0.042178303,
-0.4141072333,
-0.1036500484,
-0.184946835,
0.104560405,
-0.2958464622,
1.1335930824,
0.5561873913,
-0.094142206,
-0.6049280763,
-0.3436336219,
0.5603403449,
0.3170564175,
-1.3147222996,
0.6675055027,
0.8874998689,
-0.0690124109,
0.1726455986,
0.2869954407,
-0.279625833,
0.2719628513,
0.3416170776,
0.0763468966,
-0.2342235446,
-0.5610031486,
-0.144462809,
0.5889172554,
-0.0136303483,
0.2408514321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13771v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13771v1 | The Touché23-ValueEval Dataset for Identifying Human Values behind Arguments | 2023-01-31T17:15:33 | 2023-01-31T17:15:33 | Nailia Mirzakhmedova, Johannes Kiesel, Milad Alshomary, Maximilian Heinrich, Nicolas Handke, Xiaoni Cai, Barriere Valentin, Doratossadat Dastgheib, Omid Ghahroodi, Mohammad Ali Sadraei, Ehsaneddin Asgari, Lea Kawaletz, Henning Wachsmuth, Benno Stein | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the Touch\'e23-ValueEval Dataset for Identifying Human Values
behind Arguments. To investigate approaches for the automated detection of
human values behind arguments, we collected 9324 arguments from 6 diverse
sources, covering religious texts, political discussions, free-text arguments,
newspaper editorials, and online democracy platforms. Each argument was
annotated by 3 crowdworkers for 54 values. The Touch\'e23-ValueEval dataset
extends the Webis-ArgValues-22. In comparison to the previous dataset, the
effectiveness of a 1-Baseline decreases, but that of an out-of-the-box BERT
model increases. Therefore, though the classification difficulty increased as
per the label distribution, the larger dataset allows for training better
models. | [
-0.8207790256,
-0.335133791,
0.2236620635,
0.062039353,
-0.2973189652,
-0.18381612,
-0.0353492498,
-0.4316747487,
0.1507843286,
0.303419143,
-0.5721716881,
-0.2767399251,
-0.6446661949,
0.052955471,
-0.1575023979,
0.970929265,
0.2414953113,
0.0811542571,
-0.0661124215,
-0.3094675243,
0.106661804,
-0.5920497775,
-0.299518466,
-0.1644658148,
0.7485979795,
0.7891847491,
0.518578589,
0.5438830256,
0.3163303733,
0.283228755,
0.0350785777,
0.0846508145,
-0.3344752789,
-0.2093355209,
-0.2064466625,
-0.1125145406,
-0.3370267451,
0.450039506,
0.2491439581,
0.479044795,
0.089644812,
0.353662312,
-0.0987183452,
0.6352625489,
-0.4558421075,
-0.0549707413,
-0.6145738959,
-0.284986943,
-0.3578470945,
0.0141331814,
-0.4445268512,
-0.7849641442,
0.0801024362,
-0.4083301723,
0.2000344545,
-0.0480574183,
1.4205232859,
0.0956563652,
-0.4126654565,
-0.4674803019,
-0.1457547843,
0.951493144,
-0.6148986816,
0.3665576577,
0.6253906488,
0.0822369233,
0.0489103235,
-0.4323501587,
-0.6389703155,
0.1376602352,
0.1375967711,
0.1144327298,
-0.2306839228,
0.11477492,
0.367656976,
0.0044296738,
-0.0057230885,
0.2367174327,
-0.5281630158,
-0.1889558583,
0.8291127086,
0.0167102963,
0.0281736981,
-0.4990930855,
-0.3895266652,
-0.5633755922,
-0.4629509747,
0.4290066063,
0.683142662,
0.1365034282,
0.0719978511,
0.3525355458,
-0.134393543,
0.6948990226,
0.4008359611,
0.2643755674,
0.2682050765,
-0.2332844734,
-0.0134931384,
-0.1724909693,
0.7226185203,
0.5597695112,
0.6986518502,
0.3045889139,
0.0682565942,
-0.0966910273,
0.3577421308,
-1.088080883,
-0.179215163,
0.2167065591,
-0.9176121354,
-0.5317678452,
0.2107483894,
-0.8583590984,
-0.8833796382,
-0.4567052722,
0.0641952902,
-0.3549775481,
-0.1736164987,
-0.1239731833,
-0.3172988892,
0.4506319165,
0.7646016479,
-0.9694643617,
0.3744316399,
0.5478314757,
0.5805069208,
-0.179647699,
-0.047835853,
-0.508051157,
-0.463873446,
-0.4196416438,
1.3044888973,
-0.7992661595,
-0.1987214684,
-0.097945556,
-0.0258797798,
0.1669323742,
-0.7594880462,
1.0010750294,
-0.6508688927,
0.4154714942,
-0.9715507627,
-0.8952536583,
-0.2995275855,
0.1844452471,
-0.9228462577,
0.9783114195,
-0.1696765274,
-0.6438909173,
1.0698338747,
-1.1984122992,
-0.2117491663,
0.3957737386,
-0.311689198,
-0.5655605197,
0.1270637065,
0.2266350687,
0.6074548364,
-0.1533714831,
0.19795385,
-0.5419453979,
-0.0203938521,
0.2826619446,
-0.5896960497,
1.1592086554,
0.1599535197,
-0.2838152647,
0.0396014042,
-0.7595140338,
0.1547548324,
-0.1193070337,
-0.3352190852,
-0.3892377317,
0.3485041559,
0.28580302,
0.3740137815,
0.1123023406,
-0.7861242294,
0.2133717686,
0.0010926308,
-0.0267140735,
0.9801105857,
0.1638467759,
-0.1479776502,
-0.2448267937,
0.2884415686,
0.07280384,
-0.0114808353,
-0.0537918322,
-0.8409131765,
-0.4997832775,
-0.2688525319,
0.2592616677,
0.6044011712,
-0.0265734419,
0.5504390597,
-0.0979085863,
-0.4048351049,
-0.7131666541,
0.0377835818,
-0.0605990179,
0.5508921742,
0.5093927979,
0.2876058817,
-0.5640848279,
-1.1044640541,
-0.4695844352,
-0.5369961262,
-0.4928874373,
0.3912593126,
0.5042549968,
-0.0833659619,
1.1703072786,
-0.1401260495,
-0.0336760543,
0.248177126,
0.6808674932,
0.0495879874,
0.248458609,
0.2363543063,
-0.9513661265,
-0.1605717391,
-0.1818081886,
-0.6311493516,
-0.5025020838,
-0.1956523359,
0.0554128289,
0.0702758878,
0.1652721912,
-0.0807824507,
0.5863410234,
0.132152468,
-0.723595798,
0.2645637989,
0.1644996256,
0.5220842361,
-1.3098398447,
-0.016246492,
0.505682826,
-0.078097783,
-0.5562127233,
-0.4337880909,
0.2043392062,
0.1944792718,
-0.5019550323,
0.4866303504,
-0.1170664877,
0.2243320644,
-0.2539062798,
-0.0543126091,
0.0809331611,
0.0370019972,
0.3962249756,
0.7077049017,
-0.1771758497,
-0.2185712606,
0.7310153246,
0.39702636,
-0.2162571549,
1.0246453285,
-0.6402198076,
-0.022652356,
0.0700575188,
0.2806575596,
-1.0551718473,
-0.3929677904,
0.028690815,
-0.521073401,
-0.4169148505,
-0.3385565579,
-0.4088462293,
-0.2130167186,
-0.5898271799,
0.0932602286,
0.2624373138,
-0.8020297885,
0.385435909,
0.5731143951,
-0.1600753218,
-0.3413539529,
-0.2751862705,
0.409680903,
-0.6515461802,
-0.6605567336,
0.2684575617,
0.0483241603,
-0.5972422957,
-0.1728109419,
0.5037767887,
-0.2130626291,
-0.0033714757,
0.4766669571,
0.1868639737,
0.0208179895,
0.3524233699,
-0.0814952776,
-0.152321741,
0.3401530683,
0.0954078957,
0.1312713474,
-0.5341088176,
-0.4628321528,
-0.521432519,
0.5254719853,
0.5717279911,
0.0581600964,
0.5405175686,
0.4946486354,
-0.6441650987,
0.1791553348,
-0.8196593523,
-0.354018718,
-0.5106480718,
0.16152215,
-0.1679854393,
-0.3866251409,
0.6441206932,
-0.1899443269,
0.3838604987,
0.564752996,
0.8598484397,
-0.3782891631,
0.8933873773,
-0.1828747243,
-0.1760923266,
0.4057689905,
-0.0321314856,
-0.1948897988,
-0.4547584057,
-0.3158439696,
-0.5304874778,
-0.4014089406,
-0.4910524487,
-0.3632574677,
-0.0120763965,
-0.0229655653,
-0.2662291229,
0.225658074,
-0.5985867381,
0.2947996855,
0.4616762996,
0.0728414208,
-0.0394423977,
-0.0330601223,
0.083091028,
-0.2107328326,
-0.293353647,
-0.957706213,
0.8948606849,
0.4609025717,
0.5620506406,
-0.0025943418,
0.6737332344,
0.9554021358,
0.7219443917,
-0.7999185324,
0.424164176,
0.0685456619,
-0.8758978844,
-0.4624640346,
-0.3242028356,
-1.1807876825,
0.2893451154,
-0.1243679374,
-0.8612684011,
0.5075410008,
0.0635106191,
-0.4664075971,
0.4291404486,
-0.9334688783,
0.9159507155,
-0.3823797703,
-0.3630716503,
-0.1703900099,
-0.5193814039,
-0.0997002646,
0.1888322979,
0.1310211122,
-0.2296873331,
-0.0377341546,
1.3235679865,
-0.4886350334,
0.8529452085,
-0.6313907504,
-0.1865757704,
0.3999602795,
-0.5472710133,
0.3173575699,
-0.0454633534,
-0.3350024819,
0.0114002908,
0.0207568984,
-0.6646973491,
-0.1750407666,
0.3928124905,
-0.8755796552,
-0.4077361822,
-0.3389666378,
-0.1171066388,
-0.0963772759,
-0.1168915629,
0.1991019994,
0.4011801481,
-0.3093293905,
0.4487654567,
0.6391929984,
-0.0310067628,
0.690222919,
0.2503011823,
0.2834151089,
-0.53252244,
0.8565863967,
0.2672910094,
-0.0173129663,
-0.1359134763,
0.4184303582,
-0.6278444529,
-0.0963248536,
-0.9114241004,
-0.2146457136,
-0.6523949504,
-0.2045024335,
-0.3933987916,
0.278544426,
-0.0144064175,
-0.3330363631,
-0.2545773685,
-0.2715405524,
-0.5481756926,
-0.4143811464,
0.8642992973,
0.7801488042,
-0.1079598367,
-0.0629043132,
-0.711194098,
0.5041970015,
0.5579760075,
0.5412311554,
-0.3381953835,
-0.4551535249,
-0.1803488135,
0.3615774512,
-0.3455225527,
-1.290414691,
0.1579041034,
0.1641922891,
0.5662514567,
0.9075872898,
0.4095424414,
0.7296252251,
-0.1012905017,
0.7531540394,
-0.1281634718,
-1.08436656,
0.4388986528,
-0.3529578745,
-0.1083382145,
0.8276482821,
0.6890147328,
-0.4659156799,
0.2335344404,
-0.8786957264,
-0.5519530773,
0.4716414213,
0.0511476845,
-0.0922749415,
-0.1435169429,
0.2057747841,
0.1194004193,
-0.2022385299,
-0.6118180156,
0.3217269182,
-0.5116890669,
-0.3753632009,
0.6599037647,
0.0996865705,
-0.2138520777,
-0.3797209561,
0.3437384665,
-0.4633731544,
0.1017769799,
-0.0039466922,
-0.044334475,
-0.2396573275,
0.305503279,
0.6571588516,
0.6786174774,
-0.2444788516,
0.0595607013,
0.5986618996,
-0.3128465712,
0.2125423104,
0.2237225622,
0.1001098305,
-0.2500201166,
0.4105715752,
0.5794428587,
-0.3390805423,
-0.5940215588,
0.6466555595,
0.0331661291,
-0.2000839561,
-0.4017000496,
-0.3258954287,
0.3110048175,
0.0230419822,
0.7622033358,
0.0279524252,
0.1513580084,
-0.3885146081,
0.6339464188,
0.4523775876,
-0.5025185347,
-0.477740854,
0.5064899325,
0.5827182531,
-0.3697207272,
0.6111406684,
-0.1276028156,
-0.6956912875,
0.61374259,
-0.0654880777,
0.5770974159,
-0.2161838859,
0.1977987438,
0.2407586575,
0.0430907719,
0.2673391998,
0.4738556445,
-0.1213737652,
-0.922469914,
-0.4281870723,
-0.0997760296,
-0.6813716888,
0.1339911819,
-0.9874765873,
0.4150297642,
-0.3508644104,
-0.1343235075,
0.359868288,
0.3942833245,
-0.6430568099,
0.5775336623,
0.3725296557,
0.775934875,
-1.4076478481,
0.7297313809,
0.6727922559,
-0.4017128348,
-0.3011645973,
-0.0836931542,
0.232624054,
-0.7125050426,
0.7974242568,
0.1463934481,
-0.221346423,
-0.3122490346,
-0.7185356021,
-0.3012653589,
0.7233006954,
0.0521770753,
-0.2249649614,
0.3855542839,
0.068944931,
0.3628894091,
-0.2826087475,
0.6425846219,
0.2867831588,
0.9142773151,
-0.1111609414,
-0.5155470371,
0.0232980698,
-0.4838473201,
-0.5275096297,
0.1671565175,
-0.7470730543,
0.565782845,
-0.1570407748,
0.0267408919,
-0.465899229,
0.6238799095,
0.4159351289,
0.3575648069,
0.9180896282,
0.5704120994,
0.9081559181,
-0.0280800406,
0.6912430525,
-0.091519773,
0.1930304468,
0.4910100102,
-0.3061515987,
1.0750463009,
0.4423305988,
-0.290774405,
0.5740860701,
1.0210874081,
-0.3096619844,
0.1381563991,
0.2715350688,
-0.2411390543,
-0.5538594723,
-0.177765429,
-0.2104425132,
0.3789470196,
0.6351772547,
-0.1453874558,
-0.1702237576,
-0.1768137217,
0.3164390922,
0.1556432694,
0.0405193269,
0.9915726185,
-0.3636293411,
-0.5905132294,
0.6448791623,
-0.1436000615,
0.5080360174,
-0.1305830032,
-0.3349671662,
0.002136268,
0.021339491,
-0.352897346,
-1.1700023413,
0.1068664417,
0.4133769572,
-0.1391103119,
-0.6295102239,
0.8142669201,
0.077984482,
-0.4703460932,
0.1897224635,
0.411018461,
0.2332126349,
-0.1650405377,
-0.6479591727,
-0.1061468869,
0.0336994678,
-0.6014699936,
0.182807371,
0.4880901575,
-0.4160048962,
0.4676201642,
0.8644818664,
-0.1269541681,
0.0577931367,
0.0245435964,
1.0318439007,
-0.8797779679,
-0.1599428505,
-0.9808189869,
0.4942877591,
-0.7312289476,
-0.6881057024,
0.4465115964,
0.6671460867,
0.4504867792,
0.1763281077,
0.8414800167,
-0.0848816782,
0.8846239448,
-0.0347622372,
0.759454608,
-0.148998633,
-0.0430889837,
-0.3376064599,
-0.3952771425,
-0.1542234719,
1.0155622959,
-0.2799511254,
0.147872448,
0.0384642966,
0.4692063928,
-0.06251809,
0.3534925282,
0.2272543311,
-0.2376774848,
0.5422017574,
0.3139978349,
0.9676764011,
-0.2712799311,
0.4365610778,
0.0763484538,
-0.4697304666,
-0.4377544224,
-1.2765551805,
-0.8594652414,
-0.743583262,
-0.4210478067,
-0.3646394908,
-0.1725917608,
1.4428014755,
1.1819957495,
-1.2230758667,
-0.3231106102,
0.0617595538,
-0.0247869976,
-0.048342254,
-0.24731116,
0.3441794813,
-0.0898075774,
-0.5537018776,
0.3604741991,
-0.0744152516,
-0.2345501333,
-0.0751815438,
-0.1158149987,
-0.4953435957,
0.562545836,
0.4483977854,
0.4918502569,
-0.8760431409,
-0.7151188254,
-0.1215819269,
0.0535078533,
0.3273696005,
0.617974937,
-0.9132801294,
0.4949858487,
0.5179864168,
0.788811326,
0.3188581169,
0.695679903,
0.3190939724,
-0.6016831398,
-0.1419738978,
0.3815865815,
0.3686568439,
0.3280799091,
-0.0341504663,
0.1822095662,
0.3672907054,
-0.572758019,
-0.4529441297,
0.2294614911,
-1.0848580599,
0.1032998189,
1.1350291967,
-0.3299199641,
0.1048779786,
-0.4437614083,
-0.418361783,
-0.1087922305,
-0.7865490913,
1.1149902344,
0.9638625383,
-0.3109666705,
-0.4408469498,
-0.171299994,
0.4580401778,
0.261601001,
-1.3305723667,
0.2267598361,
0.681581378,
0.0954196379,
0.1986524761,
0.2232833356,
0.0716703087,
0.3005051613,
-0.1394641846,
0.1665676385,
0.0654608086,
0.0586706512,
-0.1433189213,
0.5485573411,
-0.0153117208,
-0.5025328398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13753v1 | Dynamic Scheduled Sampling with Imitation Loss for Neural Text Generation | 2023-01-31T16:41:06 | 2023-01-31T16:41:06 | Xiang Lin, Prathyusha Jwalapuram, Shafiq Joty | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art neural text generation models are typically trained to
maximize the likelihood of each token in the ground-truth sequence conditioned
on the previous target tokens. However, during inference, the model needs to
make a prediction conditioned on the tokens generated by itself. This
train-test discrepancy is referred to as exposure bias. Scheduled sampling is a
curriculum learning strategy that gradually exposes the model to its own
predictions during training to mitigate this bias. Most of the proposed
approaches design a scheduler based on training steps, which generally requires
careful tuning depending on the training setup. In this work, we introduce
Dynamic Scheduled Sampling with Imitation Loss (DySI), which maintains the
schedule based solely on the training time accuracy, while enhancing the
curriculum learning by introducing an imitation loss, which attempts to make
the behavior of the decoder indistinguishable from the behavior of a
teacher-forced decoder. DySI is universally applicable across training setups
with minimal tuning. Extensive experiments and analysis show that DySI not only
achieves notable improvements on standard machine translation benchmarks, but
also significantly improves the robustness of other text generation models. | [
0.2225402445,
-0.4517783821,
0.566904068,
0.4726536572,
-0.1950166225,
0.1402562261,
0.0817112327,
-0.0971770957,
-0.056730669,
0.3285014033,
-1.0392668247,
-0.1466246396,
-0.4301351011,
0.0914812535,
-0.4514095485,
0.8556866646,
-0.236188367,
0.1775219738,
-0.0545709319,
0.1840859205,
-0.7587859035,
-0.2405730337,
-0.515845418,
-0.5500831604,
0.3879131377,
-0.0295448601,
0.3457625806,
1.0891302824,
0.0061545004,
0.2644143701,
-0.1514600217,
0.1907502264,
-0.4467176497,
0.1308359206,
0.1170853749,
-0.7620872855,
-0.160909608,
0.2000672966,
1.0188097954,
0.7118381262,
-0.3493452966,
0.0898934901,
0.262909323,
0.4613794088,
-0.8970113993,
0.0670380741,
-0.8014870286,
0.4301869273,
-0.1482968032,
-0.5455745459,
-0.6682003736,
-0.3223706186,
0.0145520028,
-0.7120611668,
0.4193833768,
-0.2688816786,
0.6192957759,
0.5314029455,
-0.5253396034,
-0.2616476119,
-0.7467712164,
0.8874676824,
-0.6118503213,
0.1759811193,
0.1800765991,
0.1993325055,
-0.2709644437,
-0.5939068794,
-0.6143468618,
-0.1941376776,
0.0269284528,
0.5370257497,
0.2182773054,
-0.0461842902,
0.3080616593,
0.3220341802,
-0.2774859071,
0.1532340944,
-0.0335026421,
-0.0567920953,
0.2956060469,
0.4551100433,
0.2331957221,
-0.0194516275,
-0.2206057012,
-0.2068611979,
-0.6824440956,
-0.0797755644,
0.9830234051,
0.0217446722,
0.0533335172,
0.2635589838,
0.0675519109,
0.889431417,
0.4060403407,
-0.1108996347,
0.0325583331,
-0.3286556005,
-0.1395406574,
0.3722330332,
0.3250427246,
0.4319041967,
0.0842886716,
-0.0218225345,
-0.2790168524,
0.0359655693,
0.3442253768,
-0.8567205667,
-0.2660245001,
-0.2158403099,
-0.4432136714,
-0.9205775857,
-0.0517693684,
-0.7521819472,
-0.3014647961,
-0.5123000145,
0.2947869897,
-0.5463219285,
0.0797384381,
-0.1093809083,
-0.3462884426,
-0.210321486,
0.1714289635,
-0.7974845171,
0.1271913946,
0.1611051708,
0.7629231811,
-0.4192245007,
-0.3479896188,
-0.6090209484,
0.3329486847,
-0.5247002244,
0.3631191552,
-0.1837390065,
-0.3028977215,
0.0982249752,
-0.1872589886,
-0.4366550148,
-0.4425992966,
0.1077208072,
-0.6665925384,
0.2275512218,
-0.0870295838,
-0.5932768583,
0.1804691702,
0.2148639858,
-0.557479918,
0.9807013273,
0.1852609366,
-0.6279876828,
0.6265408397,
-0.3907165527,
-0.3790959716,
-0.0222243406,
-0.1146908849,
-0.4159090519,
0.0846804753,
0.1916428208,
0.0487350561,
0.1582947671,
0.4640443325,
0.0768631697,
-0.6340289712,
0.4852900803,
-0.9609614611,
0.7847465277,
0.34333992,
-0.5932638049,
-0.2424365729,
-1.0205265284,
0.2164779454,
0.1612608582,
-0.7631344795,
-0.4590828121,
0.3465021253,
0.292439729,
-0.0306323692,
-0.0847012252,
-0.5658982992,
0.2252445668,
-0.7578825355,
0.4881601036,
0.9790529013,
0.2443321198,
0.5523053408,
-0.5985919237,
0.3952184319,
0.0552252866,
-0.174670741,
-0.4749226868,
0.1321460605,
-0.6761737466,
-0.2440591604,
0.272495836,
0.5855688453,
-0.8444749117,
0.4696148336,
-0.5526408553,
-0.300417006,
-0.2107699066,
-0.2011077702,
0.3905825615,
0.5320582986,
0.1658583283,
0.1182990223,
-0.6088704467,
-0.5937457681,
-0.3422603309,
0.2397574037,
-0.0623918921,
0.0903350785,
0.3099981844,
0.0794162974,
0.705898881,
-0.4900960326,
-0.1910771877,
-0.395141542,
0.1388933957,
0.1856635511,
0.4995856881,
0.7087355852,
-0.6483684182,
-0.5217827559,
-0.6033795476,
-0.415153414,
-0.2973508239,
-0.7234844565,
-0.111922279,
0.3542203605,
0.4397460222,
-0.1094560698,
0.7209149599,
0.6212972999,
-0.2210978717,
0.4479887486,
-0.1563798487,
0.0766236484,
-1.2228447199,
-0.0080340616,
-0.3817233145,
-0.1798179895,
-0.3642773032,
-0.2539734244,
0.0105178421,
-0.09519016,
-0.3820520043,
0.5238271952,
-0.4391466975,
0.2368436456,
-0.4613384306,
-0.3538644016,
0.155429095,
0.2613048255,
-0.1232668832,
1.2026956081,
0.1142837405,
-0.9074978232,
-0.0679602996,
0.3547875881,
-0.5565609336,
0.1778754145,
-0.4633878469,
-0.0782746524,
-0.1650883108,
0.6190539598,
-0.5341989994,
-0.0659164935,
0.3313616514,
-0.1841531247,
0.459982425,
0.0282528643,
-0.2969500124,
-0.2372843027,
-0.1081874296,
0.4496458769,
0.5892261863,
-0.7262084484,
0.2970697284,
0.0541133583,
0.2581939697,
-0.7207898498,
-0.9168692827,
-0.0015439811,
0.0038560289,
0.0047424086,
0.9290431142,
-0.0946119875,
-0.0168424193,
0.0116354488,
-0.2713598013,
-0.1023917273,
-0.0146232909,
0.2443170249,
0.1610613763,
-0.0905234814,
-0.0303277671,
0.2463784814,
-0.013528089,
0.0325105973,
-0.6369746923,
0.7280859947,
0.6218259931,
-0.526684165,
-0.7336294651,
0.3308918178,
0.5643063188,
-0.0401979871,
0.6667264104,
0.3026787639,
-0.270318538,
-0.548815608,
-0.3914833963,
-0.114956297,
-0.5052725077,
0.4756091535,
-0.3510641754,
-0.0692926198,
0.1680040658,
0.31898579,
0.0718083605,
0.236229375,
0.4867970347,
-0.0994981527,
0.9834668636,
0.4807784855,
-0.0424818434,
0.9741869569,
-0.3137078285,
-0.1053493097,
-0.5317132473,
0.0534194522,
-0.1192730591,
-0.4951223433,
-0.5933260322,
-0.1867998391,
0.2835905552,
-0.4579494596,
-0.239086628,
0.0542530157,
-0.5093362331,
0.5491398573,
0.9837320447,
0.3730522394,
0.0623962842,
0.3170260191,
-0.1192718968,
-0.3418761492,
-0.9071252346,
-0.4948256314,
0.9590714574,
-0.0132302446,
0.6016472578,
-0.2643221021,
0.826834619,
0.2341578901,
0.181700021,
-0.5995289087,
0.5574797988,
-0.083400026,
-0.5072801113,
-0.027516339,
-0.480234772,
-0.7799309492,
-0.2312120944,
-0.1653765291,
-0.4321515262,
0.2485837936,
0.4513075054,
-0.2711707354,
0.5487883687,
-0.3157173693,
0.4433650672,
-0.150055781,
-0.3712518513,
-0.2523941696,
-0.4305902421,
0.2039216757,
-0.0914177746,
-0.2894770801,
0.0087564019,
0.1452278793,
0.6534137726,
-0.2717054188,
1.023042798,
-0.3403207958,
0.2237785459,
0.4700094759,
0.2130125016,
0.4261279106,
0.0609024465,
-0.2158131152,
-0.1081954688,
0.0527979285,
-0.2503838837,
-0.5534926653,
0.5957491994,
-0.7350914478,
-0.3117165864,
-0.7303218842,
-0.9679834247,
-0.037542332,
0.2950056493,
0.6377429962,
0.5383531451,
-0.2552867234,
-0.0451149195,
0.6214930415,
-0.3679166436,
0.645411253,
0.2395044565,
0.2719452083,
-0.5116800666,
0.934258461,
0.2915213704,
0.2662122548,
0.4801483154,
0.1612114757,
-0.0996092036,
-0.726769805,
-0.636084795,
-0.0011887598,
-0.5187264085,
-0.1062474772,
-0.5993866324,
-0.3772388399,
-0.447057277,
-0.1183880344,
-0.2269571126,
-0.3225933611,
-0.3985341191,
-0.0654375628,
-0.1122741252,
0.3655374348,
0.2145677954,
0.7141364813,
-0.9007595181,
-0.0119314026,
0.0215358716,
0.2871893644,
-0.1346400529,
-0.6772307754,
0.0061273091,
0.2971081436,
-0.7059314251,
-1.0199154615,
0.5281099677,
0.2866489887,
0.6569335461,
0.2492747456,
0.1596584916,
0.7228422761,
-0.8889346123,
0.6058897376,
0.0156206945,
-0.7669276595,
0.5106167793,
-0.5303192139,
0.3764314055,
0.5572085977,
0.0022369239,
-0.415479809,
-0.3380364478,
-0.5320167542,
-0.6475177407,
0.9096167088,
0.3997379541,
0.4673258066,
-0.0297628492,
0.539573133,
0.0684258491,
0.3677863181,
-0.7487738729,
-0.1631225944,
-0.349067241,
-0.6567752957,
-0.0239007454,
-0.388738215,
-0.0198203456,
-0.1046907976,
0.8916789889,
0.0795597062,
0.377405107,
0.1535707414,
-0.0521403626,
-0.1046544313,
0.0346880145,
0.6463412046,
0.5970047712,
-0.0956961513,
-0.0859630555,
0.2540456951,
-0.8101468682,
0.3900459707,
0.1079136506,
-0.7007779479,
0.210467577,
0.273494333,
0.8154780865,
0.1495146751,
-0.613353014,
0.4415393174,
0.0863688737,
-0.2924155891,
-0.6065339446,
0.1700689048,
-0.3320659697,
0.0248011407,
0.3542323709,
0.2242556214,
-0.0191061813,
-0.3226677775,
0.2875280678,
-0.0003392473,
-0.4094701111,
-0.2269629985,
0.879073143,
0.087228477,
-0.2491440922,
0.8336884379,
-0.1669673026,
-0.4046606421,
0.8804410696,
0.8847811818,
0.7568079233,
-0.3220295608,
0.1121378392,
0.5256714821,
0.2146676034,
-0.0558046587,
0.00762258,
0.0345182829,
-0.5873097777,
-0.410490185,
-0.631064713,
-0.1226434261,
0.3285122514,
-0.6590943336,
0.4381513894,
-0.2766192257,
0.0034387892,
-0.1188254207,
-0.3787719607,
-0.4745243192,
0.2831644714,
0.0561725125,
0.8848946095,
-0.8083542585,
0.7384868264,
0.6704292297,
-0.1678687483,
-0.6835910082,
0.6020056009,
0.0624068454,
-0.597325623,
0.6533669233,
0.3126412332,
0.1988001019,
0.2756091058,
-0.1680793613,
-0.7746675014,
1.0620920658,
0.3711311519,
-0.5469114184,
-0.4447729588,
0.0930081084,
0.3254680037,
-0.2386634797,
-0.0174382348,
0.286996752,
0.3033140898,
-0.0111863706,
-0.4535689652,
-0.0738435239,
-0.1082604378,
0.1162267774,
0.1834104955,
-0.3447789848,
0.7214418054,
0.0303373151,
-0.281699121,
0.2969377935,
0.5236620903,
0.1912800223,
0.530708611,
0.7149257064,
0.2099589109,
0.4513684213,
-0.1535373032,
0.9983486533,
-0.4247626364,
-0.1516590267,
1.2110486031,
-0.191866532,
0.3398706317,
0.6379624605,
0.0472887196,
0.3244148791,
0.6132339835,
-0.2359529436,
0.7845236659,
0.3746856451,
-0.334202677,
-0.1348800957,
-0.0205393732,
-0.0674789473,
0.4800567627,
0.1471033096,
-0.6123759151,
-0.2349532545,
0.274941206,
-0.0705875754,
0.558124125,
0.0292621925,
0.5659278035,
-0.2711129785,
-1.0239640474,
0.4170935154,
-0.0399097279,
0.4728484154,
-0.5555461049,
-0.0986946821,
-0.1070402041,
0.5099995732,
0.1644789428,
-0.1904075593,
0.5440974236,
-0.237491563,
-0.4401071668,
-0.6875951886,
0.3638905287,
-0.4043608308,
-0.5862237215,
-0.1480368823,
0.1982420981,
-0.3169926405,
0.0500025153,
-0.4712795615,
-0.1982614845,
0.0230195429,
-0.41916278,
0.4207254648,
0.2073283195,
0.0522712655,
0.4446749985,
0.5102711916,
0.2756784856,
0.3365161419,
-0.0913127586,
0.7838350534,
-0.3358511031,
-0.6314455867,
-0.8214977384,
0.331338197,
-0.2301754653,
-0.3119757473,
0.4944266677,
0.6374070644,
0.7057996392,
-0.423371762,
0.8409563899,
0.0806964263,
0.4711931348,
-0.6743319631,
0.9557318687,
-0.4659511149,
0.1303385347,
-0.0669426024,
-0.8690024018,
0.0534806624,
0.4262578487,
-0.1552063078,
-0.1264646202,
0.8014320135,
0.7442960143,
-0.1787773818,
-0.1668924242,
0.1528282017,
-0.1622445434,
0.4014131427,
0.4615564942,
0.9210259914,
-0.6438212991,
0.6965616345,
-0.4498316348,
-0.1784039438,
0.0822017118,
-1.0646178722,
-0.8429287076,
-0.4566481411,
-0.3602995872,
-0.362118423,
0.5242728591,
0.8902419209,
0.6022056937,
-0.5276197195,
-0.0083228052,
-0.57611835,
-0.1273154318,
-0.5933011174,
-0.2435073853,
0.3074959219,
-0.5460757017,
-1.3133277893,
0.6391169429,
-0.2785824537,
0.3706671,
0.1083466113,
0.2855525613,
-0.1223069355,
0.2257185131,
0.1223034486,
-0.1305932254,
-0.4180478454,
-0.0860962868,
0.268867135,
-0.2154756784,
-0.1016056612,
1.0477766991,
-0.7156919837,
0.3759066463,
0.4560429454,
0.7977941632,
0.4403167963,
-0.1433951408,
0.758617878,
-1.0960866213,
0.3821572363,
0.4171405733,
0.1204786822,
-0.0390732959,
-0.5203641057,
0.2003559917,
0.6160466671,
-0.4950894415,
-0.9804691076,
0.3274289072,
-0.7595400214,
-0.1974368393,
1.0777026415,
0.0438415855,
-0.3441691697,
0.1528997868,
-0.2005319446,
0.6094929576,
-0.1468836516,
1.0206382275,
0.5893188715,
0.331425041,
0.2312372923,
-0.8554179072,
0.4662282765,
0.476442039,
-0.3782387674,
0.0460342616,
0.6227694154,
0.4652262628,
0.0059646559,
0.6639613509,
0.068893224,
0.2848218977,
0.1626904011,
0.0705775768,
-0.4414850473,
-0.2738182545,
-0.0503381677,
-0.1523405015,
-0.3962040544,
-0.6987924576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13741v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13741v3 | UPop: Unified and Progressive Pruning for Compressing Vision-Language Transformers | 2023-01-31T16:18:52 | 2023-06-30T03:25:27 | Dachuan Shi, Chaofan Tao, Ying Jin, Zhendong Yang, Chun Yuan, Jiaqi Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Real-world data contains a vast amount of multimodal information, among which
vision and language are the two most representative modalities. Moreover,
increasingly heavier models, \textit{e}.\textit{g}., Transformers, have
attracted the attention of researchers to model compression. However, how to
compress multimodal models, especially vison-language Transformers, is still
under-explored. This paper proposes the \textbf{U}nified and
\textbf{P}r\textbf{o}gressive \textbf{P}runing (\textbf{\emph{UPop}}) as a
universal vison-language Transformer compression framework, which incorporates
1) unifiedly searching multimodal subnets in a continuous optimization space
from the original model, which enables automatic assignment of pruning ratios
among compressible modalities and structures; 2) progressively searching and
retraining the subnet, which maintains convergence between the search and
retrain to attain higher compression ratios. Experiments on various tasks,
datasets, and model architectures demonstrate the effectiveness and versatility
of the proposed UPop framework. The code is available at
https://github.com/sdc17/UPop. | [
-0.3251480758,
-0.1556710601,
0.4736877084,
0.3321466744,
-0.1964877695,
-0.0371602662,
-0.5835371017,
-0.1395299733,
0.1071535125,
0.4513240457,
-0.5639313459,
-0.1092681885,
-0.1288414598,
0.0141528472,
-0.4851462543,
0.5581322312,
0.1589760631,
-0.3266769648,
0.0129687907,
0.02096764,
-0.5403309464,
-0.6154900789,
-0.3091785908,
-0.3741220236,
0.1196138114,
0.4389674366,
1.0241602659,
0.556050539,
0.4835282862,
0.453083694,
-0.0917255655,
0.1250144243,
-0.1740346849,
0.2044391632,
-0.0088534486,
-0.34144032,
-0.3577896357,
-0.2366537601,
0.7211586237,
0.5772259235,
-0.6452299953,
0.0165485889,
-0.076268658,
0.6058039665,
-0.7408239245,
-0.108714439,
-0.5476859212,
0.3191299438,
-0.1576301157,
-0.315998286,
-0.5258006454,
0.1746893078,
-0.1104653403,
-0.7396988273,
0.2515613139,
0.02371433,
0.9995975494,
0.2601817846,
-0.1893831491,
0.3264929056,
-0.9743564129,
1.1849418879,
-0.3882886767,
0.5681355,
-0.3839312494,
0.3849689364,
0.0529726595,
-0.8677811623,
-0.5533407331,
-0.2482746243,
-0.1136358529,
0.3428172767,
-0.1941390634,
0.4236782193,
0.0282104369,
0.7296730876,
-0.3014118671,
-0.130381763,
-0.2920404673,
-0.2934805453,
0.3746167719,
-0.0825668201,
0.4783790112,
-0.1991136968,
-0.6958842874,
-0.4755884111,
-0.5128023028,
-0.1882511526,
0.2299872041,
-0.1706983447,
0.1613789499,
0.5142511129,
-0.3278730512,
1.1443219185,
-0.3390821815,
-0.2110998482,
0.0551255234,
-0.3789724708,
-0.4892448783,
-0.4778755009,
0.6050320268,
0.7006229758,
0.7583509684,
-0.3653515577,
-0.215611577,
0.3910988271,
0.7098428607,
-0.4624028802,
-0.3666820824,
-0.0199330281,
-0.3897389174,
-0.4779323339,
0.2928229868,
-1.0689799786,
0.1378559023,
-0.5743433833,
0.3476273715,
-0.1801928431,
-0.2912424505,
0.4442007542,
-0.2082954496,
-0.1531491429,
0.2279570848,
-0.7906745076,
0.0185826644,
0.361173749,
0.8325024843,
-0.0774071068,
-0.3112484515,
-0.2398517728,
0.286939621,
0.1057146713,
0.5550047755,
-0.7673506141,
-0.1346047223,
0.163075909,
-0.1440772116,
-0.2985927761,
-0.4596826732,
0.8265227079,
-0.2784721553,
0.3890420198,
0.4982242584,
-0.1118674949,
-0.2994350493,
0.2485543787,
-0.4589260221,
0.9968874454,
0.1598682702,
-0.6754483581,
0.0660345331,
-0.5608074665,
-0.1333067864,
-0.0779497102,
-0.5171423554,
-0.4307727218,
0.586740613,
0.5414138436,
0.4855415821,
-0.6396108866,
0.4518741965,
-0.1793181151,
-0.3479582965,
-0.0183638018,
-0.6430091262,
0.7783675194,
0.2111825794,
-0.1205065548,
0.2788524032,
-0.9990655184,
0.0449832231,
0.2584066093,
-0.6204123497,
-0.2233725339,
-0.0066278945,
0.1327343434,
0.1906688362,
-0.0504525192,
-0.8785601258,
0.6900064945,
-0.1938425004,
0.6004613638,
0.7294082046,
-0.265488714,
0.5168648958,
-0.1841961294,
0.5178297162,
-0.2478681654,
0.6721471548,
-0.1824065,
-0.4020137191,
-1.0203710794,
-0.4506263733,
0.1475806683,
0.5373354554,
-0.7310990095,
0.4383004606,
-0.5430013537,
-0.2982775271,
-0.2031814754,
-0.1335559785,
0.281965822,
0.5775761604,
0.4084016383,
-0.3120752871,
-0.6564283371,
-0.8700072169,
0.1804989874,
-0.0813642144,
-0.6551777124,
0.1719000787,
-0.0068214377,
-0.2593814731,
0.919239819,
-0.7308516502,
-0.6048644185,
-0.2681979537,
0.2028788775,
0.1389717013,
0.3862990439,
0.4630002379,
-1.2169913054,
-0.2680664659,
-0.1840822399,
-0.6774458885,
-0.1148539037,
-0.1812877357,
0.105709292,
-0.202856198,
0.3002187908,
-0.6717009544,
0.3590542376,
0.9414176941,
-0.0293270964,
0.5849032402,
-0.5218371153,
0.0204171911,
-1.0423254967,
-0.0646874085,
-0.1664624363,
-0.1212725565,
-0.6908485293,
0.2688946426,
-0.0524506569,
-0.6041691303,
-0.5125638247,
0.0109487772,
-0.8047716618,
-0.0595346577,
0.0923328698,
-0.0962818637,
0.058240708,
0.782580018,
0.2867031693,
0.5028908253,
0.9803638458,
-0.802007854,
0.6043127775,
0.0556233004,
-0.2008505166,
0.4151502848,
-0.7979032993,
0.1773232967,
-0.0891957432,
0.0826526582,
-0.6950740218,
-0.4009551704,
0.1859471947,
-0.2321320623,
0.3677884936,
-0.1373305917,
-0.3715223372,
-0.5546984076,
-0.4758124053,
0.5281846523,
0.4534603655,
-0.6819032431,
0.9080228209,
0.5368468165,
0.1535830647,
-0.5220066309,
-0.6068732142,
0.0096937325,
-0.3106669188,
-0.9913140535,
0.9034432769,
-0.2787612081,
0.0783911496,
-0.2294622064,
-0.2538121641,
-0.1734908521,
-0.123131983,
0.0213876199,
0.3327795863,
0.2621628046,
-0.0278202239,
-0.3211186528,
-0.2543826103,
-0.3430799544,
-0.350082159,
0.6465528607,
-0.1281592101,
-0.2113263607,
-0.0230686143,
0.3615570664,
0.6128470302,
-0.2228741795,
0.1983466148,
0.4915684164,
-0.1369383633,
-0.1201647669,
-0.38454175,
-0.181145072,
-0.5445762873,
0.1850385666,
-0.3339281976,
-0.8899584413,
0.222941339,
-0.2219849676,
-0.0048523415,
0.1111458912,
0.5339649916,
0.0913266242,
1.2372876406,
1.1064647436,
0.0389012583,
0.6698946953,
-0.2171519399,
0.0268153083,
-0.8370022774,
0.0434221253,
-0.2603432536,
-0.2474640459,
-0.3804746568,
-0.4722450674,
0.5363525152,
0.2449172884,
0.3153339028,
0.5704522729,
-1.1610554457,
0.4521179497,
0.5515479445,
-0.1158218011,
0.3670288324,
0.4630559385,
-0.2124874294,
-0.0159363896,
-0.9139108658,
-0.0588180237,
0.8827574253,
0.3029688597,
0.9496938586,
-0.0565117113,
0.4173111022,
0.2020744383,
0.1718304753,
-0.5503694415,
0.7142366171,
-0.1858919114,
-0.6404072642,
-0.3530094028,
-0.4570234716,
-0.9008116126,
0.3909392953,
0.0895898789,
-1.1564259529,
0.5558695197,
0.541258812,
-0.3018784821,
0.3771033883,
-0.5699443221,
0.8534796238,
-0.2229808569,
0.1999520957,
-0.1971465945,
-0.674044013,
0.1842126548,
0.2442147285,
0.0983738154,
0.0610337816,
0.0063354638,
0.5399410129,
-0.2441031486,
0.6117575765,
0.0489103645,
0.0304260012,
0.3431748152,
0.04102052,
0.2354024649,
0.1985190362,
0.3437930942,
0.3184819818,
-0.2810719609,
-0.156816572,
-0.6520366669,
0.38046363,
-0.3685036302,
-0.1817118227,
-0.3925895393,
-0.6584968567,
0.0194163267,
0.1152706593,
0.5003168583,
0.8242964149,
0.1349079907,
0.3820334673,
0.3438480794,
0.0000738828,
0.6055528522,
0.4083672464,
-0.331056565,
-0.408197403,
1.2049331665,
-0.1165596619,
0.2149694413,
0.6753610373,
0.2528936565,
-0.1258117557,
-0.3497663438,
-0.5034344792,
-0.0038236983,
-0.5725685954,
-0.419988811,
-0.1933893263,
0.0808022171,
-0.3086513877,
-0.2275370657,
-0.5820957422,
-0.2842600346,
0.1537757069,
0.4329456687,
-0.1829769313,
0.339017272,
-0.3818885386,
0.4209291041,
-0.9016877413,
0.5268483758,
0.4814949036,
0.3529300094,
-0.3185078502,
-0.3528990149,
-0.0191907976,
-0.0450349599,
-0.3381829262,
-0.8617528081,
0.4651577771,
0.6166357994,
0.3072115481,
0.4199528992,
0.1688133031,
0.4711228311,
-0.3230258524,
0.5184110999,
0.4303628206,
-0.6429066062,
0.3866229057,
-0.0824371278,
0.2582111061,
0.5097460151,
0.3422426283,
-0.6407827735,
-0.2464012951,
-0.575573504,
-1.0448226929,
0.5882921815,
0.2900743484,
-0.0270184353,
0.2027818561,
0.1441613585,
-0.2177832723,
0.3977248967,
-0.9318524003,
-0.1097768173,
-0.066754885,
-0.1528995186,
0.0276307799,
-0.342066139,
-0.2664616108,
-0.429250598,
0.4118039906,
-0.2773517072,
0.6926451921,
0.3091442585,
-0.347132802,
0.0685310736,
0.4876232743,
0.3946033418,
0.5530505776,
-0.3602600098,
0.1258648485,
-0.3691076338,
-0.4967788458,
0.2984052598,
0.1278070807,
-0.7049896717,
0.0266264025,
0.0721147507,
0.732185185,
0.4936714768,
-0.5912026167,
0.475948602,
-0.2321685106,
-0.0082749194,
-0.455561012,
0.021810839,
-0.3789277971,
-0.0554294176,
0.3168161809,
0.326153487,
0.1169946864,
-0.4977073073,
0.2139714062,
0.1385690868,
-0.3797776401,
-0.4621004164,
0.4471417069,
0.4431478679,
-0.2520490587,
0.7822436094,
-0.0847396478,
-0.6963947415,
0.0735467896,
0.335465312,
0.7545508742,
0.0706685036,
0.2217407823,
0.0497701988,
0.310084492,
-0.1313983053,
0.2938975096,
-0.4069769382,
-0.9033782482,
-1.0101954937,
-0.7545880675,
-0.2505721748,
-0.03946824,
-0.5411615372,
0.1784848273,
0.1276532263,
-0.0193970967,
-0.1675540507,
-0.5399547219,
-0.5319960713,
0.3780561388,
0.3938285708,
0.7689446211,
-0.6651234031,
0.958496511,
1.0255894661,
-0.4361540675,
-0.7014277577,
0.1136197373,
-0.0525679514,
-0.5996409655,
0.4398522675,
0.3549740613,
-0.1353720874,
0.2449407727,
-0.4167999625,
-0.7118071914,
0.9399456978,
0.7834641933,
-0.7094502449,
-0.4258224666,
0.2002842575,
0.2209457457,
-0.3108661175,
0.2905336618,
0.4104938805,
0.6529448032,
-0.0493777581,
-1.0045050383,
-0.2080962062,
-0.1078603119,
0.1395187378,
0.3123266697,
-0.6738688946,
0.899502039,
-0.0313439444,
-0.5484968424,
-0.1093528718,
0.723449409,
-0.0928647444,
-0.1537830979,
0.8933957219,
0.9905663133,
0.2952724397,
-0.3890680671,
1.110445857,
-0.3429343998,
0.6863105893,
0.6971393824,
0.2040658295,
0.470166266,
0.6290540099,
-0.0619390495,
0.3907767236,
0.1172602922,
-0.0327262729,
0.4886432588,
0.1045276672,
-0.1586039811,
-0.4514620006,
-0.1825915128,
-0.1774062365,
0.6331556439,
-0.0836210921,
0.0209713522,
-0.3982373476,
0.0729785636,
-0.1147404164,
0.1037014127,
-0.2940551043,
0.2621674836,
-0.0791977271,
-0.7514010072,
0.633790791,
0.0129795959,
1.0641325712,
-0.676271677,
0.0286909658,
-0.0919005349,
0.5217399597,
0.0887881741,
-0.7353004217,
0.4102321565,
-0.3047807217,
-0.0581933409,
-0.5970854759,
1.1065541506,
-0.3698559105,
-0.3645859957,
0.5082342625,
0.0856921449,
0.041118715,
-0.5929043293,
-0.7730422616,
0.2815937698,
0.1666864455,
-0.590618968,
0.3636882901,
0.1411118507,
0.1666233391,
0.8618035913,
0.4597752392,
0.1436804235,
0.2165471762,
0.1590584815,
0.9947199225,
-0.421647042,
-0.3942162693,
-0.5621773005,
0.8067433834,
-0.3133922815,
-0.4770459831,
0.6479387879,
0.2178449035,
1.1492093801,
-0.2933605313,
0.2856942713,
-0.4994997084,
0.2053189427,
-0.4524562955,
0.2156721652,
-0.8407741189,
-0.1201695129,
-0.1151055396,
-1.2190499306,
-0.4025188088,
0.7146345377,
0.2891854942,
-0.1852169633,
0.4369976819,
0.6534469724,
-0.3570592105,
-0.504128933,
0.5070651174,
-0.1559263915,
0.2941601872,
0.4872977734,
0.5329611301,
-0.2324075103,
1.0837589502,
-0.8237906694,
-0.309487015,
-0.0514677316,
-1.0549277067,
-0.5320641398,
-0.5061843395,
-0.2327842861,
0.1345492601,
-0.098992534,
0.5227506757,
1.1119837761,
-0.5227039456,
-0.2508287132,
-0.6336034536,
-0.2225124687,
-0.4750284255,
-0.2885871828,
0.0240329225,
-0.190158993,
-0.7410844564,
0.7218316197,
0.655516088,
-0.1938477308,
-0.5553766489,
-0.1154077724,
-0.1656233817,
-0.064301379,
0.4976585507,
0.5148181915,
-0.4398067296,
-0.4382053912,
-0.0147911413,
0.3713552356,
0.0895706788,
1.0998804569,
-0.7061085105,
0.6162728667,
0.6176073551,
0.2815413475,
0.3083346486,
0.0391383246,
1.0315784216,
-1.2816215754,
0.543196857,
0.2766799629,
0.5914743543,
0.4025504291,
0.0709175095,
0.7657030821,
0.5303182006,
-0.7824177146,
-0.8004550934,
0.6341325641,
-1.07366395,
-0.1053021327,
0.9698042274,
-0.1430066228,
-0.2613622546,
0.1368295848,
-0.46502918,
0.2857217789,
-0.2998601794,
0.78438133,
0.4380308092,
-0.0753079578,
-0.1435202658,
-0.3941325247,
0.2928884625,
0.6449893117,
-0.4710614085,
0.1576273441,
0.4327113926,
-0.1584705263,
0.7099177837,
0.4119007587,
-0.0211508647,
0.1238236278,
-0.1427642703,
0.5372820497,
-0.3172351122,
-0.9713542461,
-0.3154098094,
0.4226745963,
-0.2443351597,
-0.3393865824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13720v1 | Zero-shot cross-lingual transfer language selection using linguistic similarity | 2023-01-31T15:56:40 | 2023-01-31T15:56:40 | Juuso Eronen, Michal Ptaszynski, Fumito Masui | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study the selection of transfer languages for different Natural Language
Processing tasks, specifically sentiment analysis, named entity recognition and
dependency parsing. In order to select an optimal transfer language, we propose
to utilize different linguistic similarity metrics to measure the distance
between languages and make the choice of transfer language based on this
information instead of relying on intuition. We demonstrate that linguistic
similarity correlates with cross-lingual transfer performance for all of the
proposed tasks. We also show that there is a statistically significant
difference in choosing the optimal language as the transfer source instead of
English. This allows us to select a more suitable transfer language which can
be used to better leverage knowledge from high-resource languages in order to
improve the performance of language applications lacking data. For the study,
we used datasets from eight different languages from three language families. | [
-0.6241564155,
-0.4020044506,
0.642518878,
0.3503570259,
-0.1116545871,
0.1491544992,
-0.38442114,
-0.9241629243,
0.4279570878,
0.3490378559,
-0.325799346,
-0.2488407493,
-0.3573514819,
0.3899612129,
-0.1571429819,
0.8303436637,
-0.2463412434,
-0.086714074,
-0.0255634133,
-0.2433282137,
-0.3807058334,
-0.1902353615,
-0.7302556038,
-0.547332406,
0.4164058864,
0.4559301734,
0.5823116302,
0.4136748314,
0.6354704499,
0.170264408,
0.2813989818,
-0.4463707209,
-0.3565517962,
0.067867361,
-0.7638112903,
-0.6392498016,
-0.0245963931,
-0.3360368609,
0.4650053084,
0.8104183674,
0.419179529,
0.3904106915,
-0.2248907983,
0.6047309637,
-0.8550522923,
0.0956858769,
-0.5963181853,
0.5166239142,
-0.2858999968,
-0.3197541237,
-0.2360839993,
-0.3799197972,
0.3394062817,
-0.6054869294,
0.0288928784,
0.0976110622,
0.9469928145,
-0.0706342682,
-0.2491121888,
-0.1050550938,
-0.6981976032,
0.9901704788,
-0.5364864469,
0.6008883715,
0.2948896885,
0.2854777277,
0.5166065693,
-0.1213469058,
-0.5455165505,
-0.3177516162,
-0.1462676674,
0.0603143759,
-0.2366653532,
-0.1360674202,
0.0797892362,
0.2063633353,
-0.8655759096,
0.0870527253,
-0.2826262712,
-0.253241688,
0.529507339,
-0.0886265039,
0.5928464532,
-0.1847288162,
-0.4314745069,
-0.1041716263,
-0.6045880318,
0.0746878311,
0.2680713236,
0.5102452636,
-0.0756819025,
0.3446713984,
-0.5656033754,
0.8356333375,
-0.0445678458,
-0.2512092888,
0.3055715263,
-0.3749230206,
-0.2201491296,
0.383905679,
0.9161763191,
0.5852475166,
0.7071986198,
-0.4515308738,
0.0511152148,
-0.1070391685,
-0.0668862537,
-0.6246381998,
0.0563145578,
-0.3162919581,
-0.3419263661,
-0.3510538936,
-0.240776822,
-0.8224355578,
0.2173600197,
-0.380949825,
0.2311691642,
-0.61134094,
-0.258317709,
0.1036278158,
-0.2570917308,
0.5594974756,
0.0359584875,
-1.0237355232,
0.47243312,
0.4720616639,
0.9996166229,
-0.6715480089,
-0.4693050981,
-0.3401997089,
0.1446138471,
-0.4869599342,
1.031681776,
-0.7736919522,
-0.3395164311,
-0.0154199926,
-0.0648751184,
-0.2335674018,
-0.5378616452,
0.2510656118,
-0.3512899876,
0.3684413135,
-0.4131788313,
-0.2731409371,
-0.4197757542,
0.2267273217,
-0.6238899827,
1.1085330248,
0.3766003251,
-0.6403022408,
0.5314536691,
-0.6012759209,
-0.7751803398,
0.2616689503,
-0.0086355321,
0.0466087945,
-0.0342413597,
-0.0467459075,
0.5417907238,
-0.3005677462,
-0.2839813828,
-0.4567407966,
-0.3719346523,
0.0188581795,
-0.0347370431,
0.9244065881,
0.4179350436,
-0.4501027465,
-0.310287416,
-0.8167728186,
0.1880411357,
0.0928585231,
-0.1997031271,
-0.7552212477,
-0.4711104035,
0.1675244421,
0.3756777644,
0.2507038713,
-0.7289094925,
-0.0653418899,
-0.4325679839,
0.0232803635,
0.1931652427,
-0.0441991314,
0.8397600055,
-0.1863983423,
0.774071753,
0.039260041,
-0.1687667817,
0.2826580703,
-0.2423838377,
-0.6932410598,
0.0044263038,
0.453841567,
1.0186905861,
-1.1186538935,
0.1276812255,
-0.5003946424,
-0.2435450852,
-0.7743631005,
0.2038754076,
0.434995085,
0.6250824332,
0.2683115304,
-0.5062250495,
-0.5667753816,
-1.0291353464,
-0.3650176525,
-0.267087549,
0.1121787727,
0.1594047099,
-0.0601189174,
0.2368676811,
0.8033402562,
-0.5340439677,
-0.1989252269,
-0.5036740303,
0.036873199,
0.0491158292,
0.0645487085,
1.2535437346,
-0.3331829011,
-1.1521062851,
0.6645848155,
-0.7624439597,
-0.4517413974,
-0.2112551332,
-0.3474908769,
0.5913197994,
0.3883835971,
-0.4326761663,
0.1122133881,
0.5742326975,
-0.2761370838,
0.3642449081,
0.1255980432,
0.4419922829,
-1.0578651428,
0.3991259336,
0.0484391935,
-0.4527047873,
-0.6985387206,
-0.1041224524,
-0.0671555474,
0.024031328,
-0.8845630884,
0.8867385387,
-0.576544404,
-0.3847785294,
-0.2214999944,
0.2961389422,
-0.0932827592,
0.4815640152,
0.330077678,
0.6811764836,
0.9845751524,
-0.3108060956,
0.4963594377,
0.0700260624,
-0.2408184409,
1.0292806625,
-0.3104862273,
-0.0509258844,
0.1534867883,
-0.4006058276,
-0.7350280881,
0.3482806087,
0.3277849555,
-0.4166972339,
0.4156078696,
-0.0843390375,
-0.0000465453,
0.1495692283,
-0.2903560996,
0.3974755108,
0.4130332172,
-0.1507344693,
0.039962355,
0.1185435653,
-0.5121231675,
-0.6119228601,
-0.9265967607,
0.1830231845,
-0.2707105875,
-0.3441595733,
0.2294919789,
0.0727333426,
-0.1442245245,
0.3464147449,
0.1367700845,
-0.1038024798,
-0.1823560297,
-0.1096135452,
0.4144630134,
-0.4930985868,
-0.2203681469,
-0.0777420402,
-0.2221103907,
-0.0997935832,
-0.2186188698,
0.3593509495,
0.0361941531,
-0.2202828825,
-0.0802962258,
0.5887141228,
0.3882752359,
-0.1173896343,
0.6064621806,
0.6966154575,
0.0495634936,
-0.1418540329,
-0.4357784092,
0.2160493582,
-0.358595252,
0.3308490813,
-0.813313067,
-0.9221861362,
0.4619615972,
0.2885023355,
-0.1328367889,
0.3646424115,
0.5107323527,
0.2894574106,
0.509269774,
0.7419281602,
-0.6125289798,
0.7312908173,
0.0957819894,
0.4327983558,
-0.4618279636,
0.0587913059,
-0.6234942675,
-0.4123115242,
-0.6278350353,
-0.2369191349,
-0.1993904561,
-0.1498181373,
0.0477034636,
0.8748956919,
-0.2962171137,
0.6210716963,
0.5780435205,
-0.4903053045,
0.3232032955,
0.4408941865,
-0.3632245362,
-0.0438424535,
-0.574696362,
-0.1545513123,
0.6998948455,
0.0053940723,
0.5797586441,
0.0772674531,
0.8009636998,
0.1179381981,
-0.2143006027,
-0.9942117333,
0.743245542,
-0.3351955116,
-0.2384302914,
-0.4194603264,
-0.5223520994,
-1.1054465771,
0.1904673725,
-0.1629630923,
-0.7607065439,
0.1459558904,
-0.5502392054,
-0.143445462,
0.2820958495,
-0.5231614113,
0.758253336,
-0.2317611426,
-0.1152625456,
-0.1386031955,
-0.6355797052,
0.1205271855,
-0.1467048526,
0.0992824361,
-0.1701746881,
0.046828866,
0.544267416,
0.1659839153,
0.256773591,
0.0704035684,
-0.0625891984,
0.15039289,
0.6771268845,
-0.2016527206,
-0.4519720078,
-0.2928714752,
0.5487944484,
0.2688470781,
-0.3054943681,
-0.5848050714,
0.9544085264,
-0.6615649462,
-0.3259177506,
-0.3036826253,
-0.4303346574,
-0.2462302893,
0.5591329336,
0.2899108827,
-0.0948933214,
-0.2771414518,
-0.0602527969,
0.1409811974,
-0.2570064664,
0.8003218174,
0.7371871471,
-0.3825280666,
-0.1268225759,
1.1525716782,
0.3099593222,
0.4784400463,
0.8242989779,
-0.0290828217,
-0.2861790657,
-0.3311345577,
-0.715323329,
0.236212492,
-0.4643915296,
-0.2561822534,
-0.4520897567,
-0.2348552495,
-0.5145666003,
-0.5241790414,
-0.2411088347,
-0.7408586144,
-0.0948699713,
-0.2278418243,
0.3113137782,
0.3787159324,
-0.1399304569,
-0.1695129126,
-0.9814277291,
0.4869305193,
0.2288538069,
0.5513472557,
-0.2077207863,
-0.4653661549,
-0.1065615043,
-0.1743755937,
-0.1677455455,
-1.0103136301,
0.5253723264,
0.4364778399,
0.7710793614,
0.2096292228,
0.0150670642,
0.6220043898,
-0.500933826,
0.7397833467,
0.5263267159,
-0.937939465,
0.5392284393,
-0.1091727391,
0.2110726982,
0.6860739589,
0.6273255944,
-0.6913046241,
-0.297249347,
-0.4802808762,
-0.6219701767,
0.8504585028,
0.1251405925,
-0.0519861057,
0.0297004655,
-0.0099298591,
0.2518297434,
-0.1429272592,
-0.6411713958,
-0.1412296295,
0.1182600185,
-0.1038084775,
0.0841536298,
0.2727217972,
0.2056906968,
-0.2035094947,
0.4752624035,
-0.3008023798,
0.2059360147,
0.1028190479,
-0.2592074573,
-0.5156855583,
0.4464301765,
0.3474833369,
0.416182369,
0.087611407,
0.2444286495,
0.6667363644,
-0.3519254327,
0.2626340687,
-0.13087143,
-0.24770087,
0.3252165318,
0.3255504966,
0.9615408778,
0.4077353776,
-0.5547988415,
0.4737168252,
0.1428523809,
-0.2100723982,
0.058838997,
0.0047665061,
0.0652131736,
0.1500100344,
-0.15430893,
-0.0315445699,
0.4549206793,
-0.8350091577,
0.2039040923,
0.5501639247,
-0.4452371001,
-0.3637878597,
0.0970249474,
0.0844995081,
-0.3436882794,
0.5385909081,
-0.1947197914,
-0.4140900373,
0.3895882368,
0.5346659422,
0.9955458641,
-0.3550958633,
0.5359984636,
0.3419578373,
-0.0672763288,
-0.02375957,
0.3201285899,
-0.1609914601,
-0.7762737274,
-0.6622387171,
-0.8688187599,
-0.3891484141,
-0.2151656151,
-0.7694648504,
0.4830132723,
-0.2232413441,
0.0166916959,
0.0170870144,
0.0521125235,
-0.8291454911,
0.1052972972,
0.627358079,
0.733425796,
-0.9590429664,
0.9837601185,
0.8249790668,
-0.3876615763,
-0.7857183218,
-0.2118960768,
-0.0572203547,
-0.9713149071,
0.8427709341,
-0.2937878668,
-0.2618909478,
-0.2490061671,
-0.0406370014,
-0.9391390681,
0.8892647028,
0.6727063656,
-0.4218896627,
0.0569670163,
0.5854658484,
0.7224822044,
-0.4438744485,
0.4044765532,
0.8561057448,
0.29716295,
0.4101050198,
-1.4890284538,
0.1722080261,
-0.0893345475,
0.1413265467,
0.4108888805,
-0.6082051992,
0.5616776347,
-0.0893178657,
-0.1931193024,
-0.319896102,
0.1833822429,
0.0459759049,
0.2094547153,
0.2424787134,
0.7238571048,
0.0983073264,
0.2766410112,
0.7185221314,
-0.4797121882,
0.43029055,
0.8717275858,
-0.6540262699,
1.2042769194,
0.5891496539,
-0.421979636,
0.4934263229,
0.2323690802,
-0.0142292166,
0.5810542107,
-0.2122584134,
-0.1360787749,
0.0217002183,
-0.3190000057,
-0.15512833,
0.6162272692,
-0.0082969302,
-0.2895109057,
-0.5979890227,
0.0199915748,
0.0643986315,
-0.1907010525,
-0.2284071594,
0.9888188839,
0.1117932647,
-0.8882768154,
0.7528569102,
-0.2407925725,
0.7772946358,
-0.5414289832,
-0.0086835967,
-0.3578263223,
-0.1814521104,
-0.3288223147,
-1.2605929375,
0.6920058727,
-0.0122708185,
-0.060263887,
-0.5729002357,
1.0139364004,
-0.5847289562,
-0.4249910712,
0.7572898269,
0.7372718453,
0.5075317025,
0.0568615943,
-0.7026181221,
-0.2171094269,
0.2390857488,
-0.1301848441,
0.8175884485,
0.6729677916,
-0.1204885319,
0.5329991579,
0.5717366338,
0.7987191081,
0.17261599,
0.1291729361,
0.3919058144,
-0.885869801,
-0.532132268,
-0.7390788794,
-0.0159294009,
-0.0208248887,
-0.1891113669,
0.8234021664,
0.4543330371,
1.2057257891,
-0.3312652409,
0.9310508966,
-0.2771304548,
0.6287274361,
-0.4060764909,
0.576143682,
-0.5409838557,
-0.0950707868,
-0.4730841815,
-1.3358002901,
-0.3457493782,
0.6654179096,
-0.4769313633,
-0.2021043003,
0.854842484,
0.7790817618,
-0.2043281347,
-0.2205388844,
0.9073960185,
-0.2509085238,
-0.0657579079,
0.9006683826,
0.553697288,
-0.2279326916,
0.593634367,
-0.2969146967,
0.0019235139,
-0.2008509338,
-0.9526370764,
-0.6714811325,
-0.4145935774,
-0.4407092929,
0.1461933404,
-0.005779,
0.717533648,
0.6546706557,
-1.0464891195,
-0.4725490212,
0.2238884866,
0.0513225868,
-0.1160494015,
-0.368008703,
-0.0187157188,
-0.5692867041,
-0.6248899102,
0.190884307,
0.5964638591,
-0.0401610211,
-0.1746481657,
-0.0274309069,
-0.2720325291,
0.0124252774,
0.9145601988,
0.5803316236,
-0.6410216689,
-0.6258735657,
0.1365155131,
-0.1151469126,
0.1824971735,
0.912098825,
-0.7368636727,
0.2530731261,
0.9865563512,
0.7253911495,
0.3341550827,
-0.3727238476,
0.5350750089,
-0.6876353025,
0.2530919611,
0.0854242519,
0.2816992402,
0.4251574874,
-0.3586232662,
0.5524833798,
0.2139319479,
-0.3896712363,
-0.388392508,
0.134325996,
-1.1978354454,
-0.314486295,
1.4046702385,
-0.1558472812,
-0.1769141555,
-0.276643306,
-0.3390754163,
0.0697611794,
-0.2808254659,
0.4146676958,
0.8473449349,
-0.4550583363,
-0.4844071865,
-0.4165276289,
0.4177261591,
0.4558352828,
-0.7163673043,
-0.2995560467,
0.2753010392,
0.7057210803,
0.340721041,
0.669354856,
-0.1440989226,
0.0647098124,
-0.0607595816,
0.1695616692,
0.388338536,
-0.1562146991,
-0.3331252635,
0.305798322,
0.1858823746,
-0.1802418828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13714v1 | Recursive Neural Networks with Bottlenecks Diagnose (Non-)Compositionality | 2023-01-31T15:46:39 | 2023-01-31T15:46:39 | Verna Dankers, Ivan Titov | cs.CL | cs.CL | A recent line of work in NLP focuses on the (dis)ability of models to
generalise compositionally for artificial languages. However, when considering
natural language tasks, the data involved is not strictly, or locally,
compositional. Quantifying the compositionality of data is a challenging task,
which has been investigated primarily for short utterances. We use recursive
neural models (Tree-LSTMs) with bottlenecks that limit the transfer of
information between nodes. We illustrate that comparing data's representations
in models with and without the bottleneck can be used to produce a
compositionality metric. The procedure is applied to the evaluation of
arithmetic expressions using synthetic data, and sentiment classification using
natural language data. We demonstrate that compression through a bottleneck
impacts non-compositional examples disproportionately and then use the
bottleneck compositionality metric (BCM) to distinguish compositional from
non-compositional samples, yielding a compositionality ranking over a dataset. | [
-0.4684827626,
-0.7798998952,
0.3598236144,
0.5133708119,
-0.1201955602,
0.3052987456,
-0.30732885,
-0.5622521043,
0.1260625124,
0.4791892767,
-0.6213158369,
-0.3377299905,
-0.5502801538,
0.5415985584,
-0.4327253699,
0.9170711637,
0.0498810001,
-0.0243332963,
-0.9169815779,
-0.3914380074,
-0.7689501643,
-0.5066848993,
-0.6776081324,
-0.53551507,
0.3825971484,
0.0150389625,
0.4761063159,
0.683421433,
0.4623681009,
0.4564774334,
-0.137477234,
0.3481849134,
-0.3150800467,
0.4551784396,
-0.0750475526,
-0.7396305203,
-0.0331249051,
-0.205886364,
0.5567013025,
1.1174637079,
-0.0314966254,
0.1761920303,
0.0946059823,
0.9664531946,
-0.4512186944,
0.3859395981,
-0.4688854516,
0.4071053863,
0.1239679232,
0.0399184041,
-0.1849562973,
-0.4672847688,
0.2779825032,
-0.2641226351,
0.2878670096,
0.065423131,
0.2500149608,
0.5242083669,
-0.1176124662,
-0.3698555231,
-0.4764073789,
0.8890628219,
-0.6599066257,
0.2623207867,
0.0278443731,
-0.0739569068,
0.0397671871,
-0.4689458311,
-0.552624464,
-0.2312844098,
-0.1713830978,
-0.0785858333,
-0.6302587986,
-0.0168001074,
0.2512660325,
0.6384961009,
-0.6719400287,
0.0224947743,
-0.3608514369,
-0.2178707868,
0.5836277604,
0.4712320864,
0.2978829741,
-0.2596419752,
-0.143247664,
0.1379001439,
-0.4121584892,
-0.1575049907,
0.3229055703,
0.5268874168,
-0.1101753339,
0.6527563334,
-0.272472918,
0.882830441,
-0.0164383929,
-0.0287737474,
0.355478704,
-0.4855546355,
-0.2242107093,
0.0085129309,
0.9165704846,
0.3599033058,
0.4024089575,
-0.335706085,
-0.2777743638,
0.3123523891,
0.2637189329,
-0.8119934201,
-0.3900670111,
0.2320331037,
-0.210137099,
-0.4141537547,
-0.3321860731,
-0.5638656616,
-0.4217844903,
-0.5094112158,
0.4122928381,
-0.1973914206,
-0.3340043426,
0.0846790969,
-0.0257966593,
-0.2153921574,
-0.1739664525,
-0.6987226009,
0.367982626,
0.7472952604,
1.4342958927,
-0.1503805816,
0.1390405595,
0.057508193,
-0.6611000896,
-0.3545002639,
0.4941506386,
-0.112732105,
-0.5614655018,
-0.254722327,
-0.0298970677,
-0.369191885,
-1.0659644604,
0.4338907003,
-0.1534829736,
0.2613251209,
-0.2233039141,
-0.7149267197,
-0.2241397053,
0.4279251993,
-1.0595988035,
0.9878431559,
0.3836007118,
-0.7635114193,
-0.1086852551,
-0.5884503126,
-0.8087729216,
-0.1115901023,
-0.0037097,
-0.526989162,
0.5751590133,
-0.0562730767,
0.3760778606,
-0.4016284049,
0.0733353943,
-0.1052765846,
-0.1971477419,
0.4438978136,
-0.3748279512,
0.6482973695,
0.150986895,
-0.1183104739,
-0.242564261,
-0.7860587835,
0.1865552962,
0.0143153369,
-0.3721633554,
-0.1370100826,
0.0473601408,
-0.4190374911,
0.1073353961,
0.3840613067,
-0.4951139092,
0.2207131237,
-0.6210300922,
0.7157142162,
0.4542731047,
0.0265249666,
0.271785289,
-0.7645874619,
0.4637447298,
0.1570199877,
-0.2229152024,
0.0583914258,
-0.4088963568,
-1.0023107529,
0.0616708845,
0.1391268969,
0.6586678028,
-0.7091633081,
0.5809215903,
-0.4393871427,
-0.4443997443,
-0.4658828676,
0.1879506111,
0.4403224885,
0.7492200732,
0.302600503,
-0.7104523182,
-0.6033844352,
-0.9308370948,
-0.1819411963,
-0.1605652273,
-0.0435006768,
0.347894907,
0.2826768458,
0.0922375396,
0.7349976301,
-0.3736004829,
-0.0109768994,
-0.1623361856,
0.8449774981,
0.3972734213,
0.5169919133,
0.1796414703,
-0.4525274634,
-0.3486447334,
-0.1120781973,
-0.5421449542,
-0.4201697409,
0.0660841018,
0.2941080034,
0.3306860626,
0.2889923751,
-0.9811224341,
0.0251840632,
0.4428288639,
-0.1281234026,
0.6670914888,
0.0406606682,
-0.2629820108,
-0.6423515677,
-0.0031810577,
0.1014127135,
-0.2851566076,
-0.629970789,
-0.1245285794,
-0.3918899,
0.0033182413,
-0.1873931438,
-0.1292466521,
-0.2177357972,
-0.312944442,
-0.2226862013,
-0.0154305734,
0.2335871756,
0.497757107,
0.1690675765,
0.7303076982,
0.412442714,
-0.6432417035,
0.5143256187,
-0.2231612802,
-0.3749864399,
0.7706018686,
-0.8043255806,
0.0442331396,
-0.2031807899,
-0.0158080552,
-0.8625058532,
0.1882276982,
0.0683074743,
-0.4949609637,
0.204167217,
-0.1568261236,
-0.5021113157,
-0.214557603,
-0.1642341465,
0.7036730647,
0.3370004594,
-0.0642054975,
0.4345995188,
-0.0273476113,
0.068501845,
-0.4768089056,
-0.8708125353,
-0.0157064442,
-0.2736609578,
-0.6780837178,
0.3644875884,
-0.0933341458,
-0.0796754435,
0.057780683,
-0.1921778917,
-0.1197263449,
0.1710696518,
0.229502961,
-0.0494218655,
-0.4427568018,
0.2790367305,
-0.3090325296,
0.1110334992,
0.466355592,
-0.2993853688,
0.6759323478,
-0.4299621582,
-0.0258083772,
-0.4042556584,
0.2702495754,
0.6286056042,
-0.0701849908,
0.492441386,
0.4433037341,
-0.2658264637,
-0.4590220749,
-0.2241676748,
0.0111631984,
-0.4386951923,
0.4071857631,
-0.1572189331,
-0.8885415196,
0.2960488498,
-0.0939374492,
-0.1689326316,
0.4168711305,
0.4358817339,
-0.132755205,
0.8495342135,
0.3100286424,
-0.2865073681,
0.1424442679,
-0.607108891,
0.202917248,
-0.7687054873,
-0.0727778077,
-0.3740470111,
-0.6034795642,
-1.0014030933,
-0.5046337843,
0.3292317688,
0.0136481915,
-0.4291279912,
0.3742958903,
-0.6388037205,
0.645921886,
0.4012533426,
-0.0565481558,
0.3563235104,
-0.1583359689,
0.1150494218,
0.0117905326,
-0.7879201174,
-0.0668990314,
0.7396071553,
0.2240157723,
0.2932577729,
0.2555791736,
0.5091568828,
0.390191406,
0.2958545387,
-1.2370262146,
0.4722051919,
-0.5443751812,
-0.4127830863,
-0.1118712276,
-0.8917407393,
-0.9593092799,
0.1830085814,
-0.1279878616,
-0.5949069262,
0.1981153041,
0.0267091896,
-0.2629559636,
0.1878527403,
-0.3638238013,
0.8587970138,
-0.3302691579,
-0.1858419329,
-0.0081062261,
-0.6276800632,
0.4383571744,
0.1084031016,
0.1514173299,
-0.1215271577,
0.0649715662,
0.5657334328,
-0.6085442305,
0.884514153,
-0.133882001,
0.1085664406,
0.4541465044,
0.3651157916,
0.2091236711,
-0.4150413871,
0.0992461517,
0.282315582,
0.0366665982,
-0.1479370296,
-0.8282750249,
0.6514331698,
-0.7695608735,
-0.2341990471,
-0.3041202724,
-0.4217667282,
-0.3834141195,
-0.120449923,
0.2644581795,
0.284668535,
0.0720899105,
0.3180462718,
0.4794229269,
-0.040396601,
0.5141426325,
0.1320912689,
0.1366557926,
-0.3147876561,
1.2662605047,
0.2690657675,
0.3785794973,
0.3697653115,
0.3737324178,
-0.4808643758,
-0.5182581544,
-0.4086606801,
-0.0379576273,
-0.6018229127,
-0.5389986634,
-0.2494101077,
-0.408280462,
0.0574037246,
0.1927738935,
-0.6337159872,
-0.7142756581,
-0.3749170005,
-0.1688731611,
0.1416348368,
0.6985904574,
-0.1157839075,
0.2954588234,
-0.6166611314,
0.0694052726,
0.1797105819,
0.2824324071,
0.3509974182,
-0.3091312349,
-0.2227088213,
-0.0579717383,
-0.5976251364,
-0.6765807867,
0.5556246638,
0.4756825268,
-0.0251186341,
0.3304470778,
-0.0490135513,
0.5302454233,
-0.1258898377,
0.778331697,
0.3577450812,
-1.1207174063,
0.0162357409,
0.0520817973,
0.2881909311,
0.6035848856,
0.3996666968,
-0.6604765058,
-0.2102731019,
-0.2455814481,
-0.9664434195,
0.1477639973,
0.2343554944,
0.3603877425,
-0.1797411442,
0.3719063401,
-0.0175540466,
0.5243625641,
-0.9917290211,
-0.2816137075,
-0.3202215731,
-0.4637387693,
0.1760260165,
-0.0075580697,
0.0735902861,
-0.3593673408,
0.2590697408,
-0.0183665194,
0.2880495787,
0.3034830689,
-0.0655239671,
0.0273709279,
0.1062676385,
0.5678580403,
0.5201015472,
-0.0488126427,
0.3512913287,
0.1427800208,
-0.2153264433,
0.2964141965,
-0.1567814648,
-0.0887215957,
0.1379708797,
0.7099238634,
0.7600107193,
0.1343859136,
-0.6056078672,
0.4989692271,
0.025695296,
-0.2342530787,
-0.2556571066,
-0.065541096,
0.2172849178,
0.2075172216,
-0.0022033481,
0.0480211526,
0.2687287927,
-0.5269715786,
0.085832499,
0.5309258699,
-0.2292024046,
-0.2786943316,
-0.0000685114,
0.1643775553,
-0.2547442615,
0.8975738287,
-0.296208024,
-0.7045578361,
0.8246129155,
0.3388001323,
0.8775350451,
-0.1119487658,
0.164464578,
0.4187193215,
0.3024716377,
-0.0424325392,
0.3309689462,
-0.260915041,
-0.8972558975,
-0.7057334781,
-0.8224150538,
-0.1833917201,
0.2425308526,
-0.6196627617,
-0.1526944935,
-0.6368789077,
-0.326556921,
0.1209363043,
0.0282742772,
-0.6003015041,
0.3671759665,
-0.0771660581,
0.485248208,
-0.8420929313,
0.3079720736,
0.2130157799,
-0.3046350181,
-0.4762528241,
-0.3821555376,
-0.3148978651,
-0.638191998,
0.747007072,
0.4778318107,
-0.2830246389,
-0.1824411899,
-0.3887040615,
-0.5469124913,
0.8752143383,
0.25134781,
-0.6857780218,
0.0149833318,
0.7076530457,
0.9018333554,
-0.5449555516,
0.0580360889,
0.6471349597,
0.509393692,
0.213355571,
-0.8351134062,
0.1109798849,
-0.2097728848,
-0.225032717,
0.4152944982,
-0.4333064258,
1.1698372364,
0.1683341861,
-0.5126154423,
0.29047364,
0.3111619949,
-0.1665201634,
0.58612746,
0.6973813176,
1.1410776377,
0.6572648287,
-0.3314389288,
0.8858498931,
-0.4246081114,
0.3514211774,
1.1650639772,
0.1234482303,
0.6747302413,
0.4032743871,
-0.4369663,
0.5678671002,
0.5406621695,
-0.1281260997,
0.2755715549,
0.9867086411,
-0.5952994823,
-0.1145049557,
-0.3516823649,
-0.1890599281,
0.624483943,
0.3898535371,
-0.549944818,
-0.0766894519,
-0.2913422287,
0.0696334168,
0.0806690902,
-0.3293152153,
0.9672790766,
0.2302265614,
-0.7161724567,
0.9059348106,
0.2080934942,
0.6418672204,
-0.2067948282,
0.1673448831,
-0.3702644706,
-0.1704424024,
-0.3712042272,
-0.6185164452,
0.9687494636,
-0.1882890016,
-0.3006595969,
0.1004230082,
0.4084107876,
-0.502202034,
-0.6036609411,
-0.0024621412,
0.6471357942,
0.1853133738,
-0.2992878258,
-0.6224055886,
-0.0014580304,
-0.247889176,
0.1300354302,
-0.0415760316,
0.4716833234,
0.0697345883,
0.7023101449,
0.5104349256,
0.1952477247,
-0.1575399339,
0.051123105,
0.6576558352,
-0.72698915,
-0.1478443593,
-1.193359375,
0.172120586,
-0.0297625847,
-0.1508588791,
0.4466746151,
0.6132148504,
0.7285927534,
-0.0088140601,
0.6449030042,
0.0939685181,
0.1808395088,
-0.4213274717,
0.5183057785,
-0.4956996441,
0.2690611184,
0.1144367233,
-0.8836590648,
-0.2664346099,
0.7255040407,
0.0504371934,
0.1007802337,
0.5071252584,
0.6944504976,
0.0469926,
0.2014191896,
0.1358383149,
0.1706759036,
-0.0715768114,
0.9108501673,
0.8946290016,
-0.0027740768,
0.2319316566,
-0.5719941258,
0.1385985166,
-0.0261804275,
-1.0958155394,
-0.7623274326,
-0.5013356209,
-0.4219351113,
-0.223135367,
-0.2483815998,
0.7479007244,
0.8064746261,
-0.6390625238,
-0.3739890456,
-0.75489223,
0.4762323499,
-0.1150895581,
-0.3562116623,
0.1374116987,
-0.3460154235,
-0.5158398151,
0.3632735908,
0.1704740673,
0.1753945947,
-0.6746638417,
0.273267746,
0.2539655268,
0.3280957937,
0.7632254362,
0.2889583707,
-0.3945282102,
-0.1734093577,
-0.2253178954,
0.2914229035,
0.1957404166,
1.0415973663,
-0.615701139,
0.5344671607,
0.6817575693,
0.8276394606,
0.3447241187,
0.1718456149,
0.4681333005,
-1.3507560492,
-0.2462121099,
0.5388383269,
0.2418897599,
0.6198419929,
-0.3267873228,
0.4339495599,
0.5661550164,
-0.4191361368,
-0.721988678,
0.396992892,
-0.9391570091,
-0.3680033684,
0.5951297879,
-0.1430591196,
-0.2851022184,
-0.0349818617,
0.1657097936,
0.054735288,
-0.0519753247,
0.8277108669,
0.9941545725,
-0.4995129704,
-0.1468722969,
-0.4132142365,
0.4959629476,
0.4971813262,
-0.6611925364,
0.0473540053,
0.5788908601,
0.1749005616,
0.411919713,
0.1932608783,
0.041973874,
-0.0622170791,
-0.1002055407,
-0.1902893484,
-0.1938794851,
-0.1949817389,
-0.2149883956,
0.3224163353,
-0.0781774819,
-0.1528601497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13688v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13688v2 | The Flan Collection: Designing Data and Methods for Effective Instruction Tuning | 2023-01-31T15:03:44 | 2023-02-14T16:33:33 | Shayne Longpre, Le Hou, Tu Vu, Albert Webson, Hyung Won Chung, Yi Tay, Denny Zhou, Quoc V. Le, Barret Zoph, Jason Wei, Adam Roberts | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We study the design decisions of publicly available instruction tuning
methods, and break down the development of Flan 2022 (Chung et al., 2022).
Through careful ablation studies on the Flan Collection of tasks and methods,
we tease apart the effect of design decisions which enable Flan-T5 to
outperform prior work by 3-17%+ across evaluation settings. We find task
balancing and enrichment techniques are overlooked but critical to effective
instruction tuning, and in particular, training with mixed prompt settings
(zero-shot, few-shot, and chain-of-thought) actually yields stronger (2%+)
performance in all settings. In further experiments, we show Flan-T5 requires
less finetuning to converge higher and faster than T5 on single downstream
tasks, motivating instruction-tuned models as more computationally-efficient
starting checkpoints for new tasks. Finally, to accelerate research on
instruction tuning, we make the Flan 2022 collection of datasets, templates,
and methods publicly available at
https://github.com/google-research/FLAN/tree/main/flan/v2. | [
-0.5425858498,
-0.5399878621,
0.1168186292,
-0.1549475342,
-0.076580815,
0.0285029933,
-0.305291146,
-0.5113391876,
-0.1601113379,
0.4838045835,
-0.5280159116,
-0.2378876209,
-0.5215195417,
-0.0685151592,
-0.4762856662,
1.0456408262,
0.1178078875,
0.0488243327,
-0.0102855619,
-0.0653553605,
-0.661260426,
0.2107137889,
-0.6269285679,
-0.2559422851,
0.791313827,
0.9545158744,
0.3094701171,
0.9889154434,
0.5803633332,
0.2071649432,
-0.0736772567,
0.3936917782,
-0.855168581,
-0.1828122288,
-0.0325426534,
-0.4583002925,
-0.3981794715,
-0.054641027,
0.4739812315,
0.559736371,
0.0149613917,
0.4656015933,
0.1062414646,
0.7345099449,
-0.958797574,
-0.1585276723,
-0.2264943272,
-0.019348776,
-0.5273154974,
-0.2143952399,
-0.3952210844,
-0.2921391428,
0.0305302497,
-0.5415477753,
0.6444804668,
-0.073310174,
0.6764380932,
0.4159384966,
-0.3961460888,
-0.4259241819,
-0.8401091099,
0.8964725733,
-0.4049129188,
0.38270244,
0.3446441889,
0.3325924575,
0.0900600404,
-0.6223181486,
-0.1725672185,
0.1234857142,
0.1850990206,
0.2425129265,
0.4346268475,
0.2832939625,
0.4346311986,
0.7973512411,
-0.5001180172,
-0.0018282913,
-0.7874447107,
0.1139914691,
0.7258679867,
0.0997894108,
0.0699334741,
0.2394788414,
-0.4466893673,
-0.4394013882,
-0.5254123211,
0.216732651,
0.3897791505,
0.2340195477,
-0.0304611232,
0.4289061129,
-0.0272508115,
1.0826692581,
0.308737576,
-0.1085855737,
0.0032815521,
-0.5080663562,
-0.210935235,
0.1013233885,
0.4073601365,
0.2926719785,
0.1299410015,
0.1418596059,
-0.4593344927,
-0.0409345031,
0.620511055,
-0.7144489884,
-0.5297331214,
0.2194387168,
-0.2690505087,
-0.3982079327,
0.4434451163,
-0.944657445,
-0.4341130257,
-0.5127895474,
0.347150296,
-0.3929619491,
-0.2417583913,
-0.0119905174,
-0.3134166598,
0.2399181724,
0.2058025151,
-1.2720783949,
0.1428929418,
1.1012628078,
0.7328618169,
-0.1033854783,
-0.2022108287,
-0.6265221834,
-0.0855561644,
-0.4714050591,
0.7596275806,
-0.7862035632,
-0.5415242314,
0.1549796164,
0.0005345485,
-0.2327973098,
-0.6153694391,
0.4098146558,
-0.3745942116,
0.1908907145,
-0.7084950805,
-0.8406308293,
-0.0555054359,
-0.2908475399,
-0.9662299752,
0.8049533963,
0.2626288235,
-0.3451766372,
0.5677042007,
-0.8924654126,
-0.7422270775,
-0.1521767527,
-0.0452543385,
-0.3099010289,
0.4422923326,
0.0867719427,
0.0903823152,
-0.179796651,
-0.1545871049,
-0.1143416166,
-0.8283661604,
-0.1582690477,
-0.1176785529,
0.764172852,
0.5747760534,
-0.6534979939,
0.200794816,
-0.5184213519,
0.1217116788,
-0.1401580572,
-0.1853123754,
-0.0163029488,
-0.0532168299,
-0.093205072,
-0.0477943048,
0.1740528643,
-0.4437808394,
0.1295882761,
-0.2894051075,
0.2695619464,
0.7110157013,
0.0016182014,
0.4689657688,
-0.7313990593,
0.5566416979,
-0.0990969986,
0.2702406049,
-0.4288489223,
-0.3245428205,
-0.9859070182,
0.0483085141,
0.2877715826,
0.5236821175,
-0.4687081575,
0.2913933098,
-0.0594547428,
-0.365334332,
-0.555768609,
0.4087775648,
0.5062742233,
0.4964443743,
0.4224495888,
-0.0095987255,
-0.3678179085,
-0.6264757514,
-0.3178689182,
0.4199983478,
-0.0088500418,
0.0381744392,
0.3447657526,
0.3941524327,
0.5042540431,
-0.4076744616,
-0.0964376107,
-0.2370877862,
0.3345784545,
-0.1378776729,
0.5066491365,
0.6079505682,
-0.4403814971,
-0.4199357033,
-0.0590506271,
-0.4139821231,
-0.021182524,
-0.1930460632,
-0.3801279068,
0.1802580059,
0.1448423862,
-0.3552696109,
0.3017690778,
0.1840365827,
-0.2062504292,
0.0798895955,
0.1532409489,
0.3839105368,
-0.829000175,
0.0185034443,
-0.1164553016,
0.1260859817,
-0.5537344813,
0.0279539898,
0.2850568891,
-0.1672180593,
-0.2771783471,
0.3655638993,
-0.4086927772,
-0.0350810364,
-0.56645298,
-0.0667530298,
0.112214759,
0.4007450044,
-0.1789243817,
1.0409510136,
0.028641358,
-0.5559008718,
0.1977382302,
0.0981274471,
-0.4876383543,
0.546557188,
-0.6839257479,
0.1910572499,
0.0544684939,
0.1153609008,
-0.6316419244,
-0.3749974668,
0.2353999466,
-0.0567075536,
0.5090638399,
0.0791241676,
-0.0759233311,
-0.4433154464,
-0.4031354189,
0.2526476681,
0.5891676545,
-0.8002345562,
0.2243493497,
0.0546220876,
0.3817347586,
-0.6346091628,
-0.7584950328,
-0.4583632648,
-0.2458020449,
-0.578286469,
0.403354615,
-0.0461919345,
-0.0937551633,
-0.1511660069,
-0.5978401899,
0.0663977787,
0.1658946127,
-0.0398177691,
-0.0738053694,
-0.4796778858,
-0.0010903258,
0.0703394338,
-0.0076287016,
-0.0258886386,
-0.489305228,
0.1625024974,
0.0473767929,
-0.2972490788,
-0.4962448776,
0.3092185259,
0.3627896607,
-0.3659738004,
0.6881110668,
0.969753623,
-0.3220629394,
-0.4602260292,
-0.4679566026,
-0.416103214,
-0.4998444915,
0.0729117692,
-0.1846355349,
-0.7479698062,
0.2269776165,
0.0636653677,
0.7671483755,
0.1149086505,
0.1400855929,
-0.3441925943,
0.8598657846,
0.5125764608,
0.1141835004,
1.119151473,
-0.5610453486,
0.0753568485,
-0.5831946731,
-0.0304418597,
-0.3689001203,
-0.8071998358,
-0.4160689414,
-0.2682488859,
0.2139541507,
0.1280506104,
-0.3135356605,
0.1750083119,
-0.5730037093,
0.782702744,
0.8033390641,
0.300137192,
-0.0850173458,
0.0468237735,
0.349663496,
0.1757003963,
-0.7244892716,
-0.3820990622,
1.115339756,
-0.0211628824,
0.431427747,
-0.0611730404,
0.7656306624,
0.3864568174,
0.0871116295,
-0.4255333543,
0.269192487,
-0.4209872484,
-0.7475531697,
-0.1936366558,
-0.3085837066,
-0.916044414,
-0.1736686081,
0.1428419352,
-0.4130781889,
-0.0150937429,
0.4554563165,
-0.5096214414,
0.3169939518,
-1.0156505108,
1.1746119261,
-0.5538136959,
-0.7061265111,
-0.32073313,
-0.6369534135,
0.5712170005,
0.1883423626,
-0.0303078704,
0.1289295554,
0.0187246911,
0.6413884163,
-0.604283154,
0.7655739188,
-0.4560373127,
-0.2544919848,
0.5629511476,
-0.2284293622,
0.2338985652,
-0.1751093715,
-0.0652714968,
-0.2141893506,
0.1181802973,
-0.806494832,
-0.8500422239,
0.7245250344,
-0.713790834,
-0.4287453294,
-0.2245696634,
-0.4106032252,
-0.0788145736,
0.2599548399,
0.4540969431,
0.8396986127,
0.0193091873,
0.303919822,
1.0218756199,
0.146030277,
0.2490720451,
0.1181206554,
0.115569599,
-0.4905442595,
1.4844638109,
0.2619281709,
0.3925659955,
0.5447216034,
0.1729093492,
-0.0196051281,
-0.3585558832,
-0.5143910646,
-0.0579203106,
-0.5895484686,
-0.1237420291,
0.127752915,
0.0496884435,
-0.1812080145,
-0.3666699231,
-0.4664662182,
-0.3705724776,
-0.5931841135,
-0.0620964542,
0.3871688843,
1.0005562305,
0.0203992501,
0.4557953477,
-0.6169015169,
0.2180478275,
0.2256392092,
0.5180520415,
0.0544772148,
-0.366859287,
-0.5795340538,
0.3420500755,
-0.5067471862,
-0.5746124983,
-0.2998149991,
0.3964072764,
0.3438415527,
0.6590184569,
0.1424010098,
0.8105517626,
-0.1411469281,
0.8881760836,
-0.1566540003,
-0.586948812,
0.6899104118,
-0.4301263094,
0.5372079611,
0.7686517835,
0.1653469354,
-0.1820322126,
-0.0956420675,
-0.6237226129,
-0.7422014475,
0.9053578973,
-0.1164254546,
-0.1102317795,
0.0774755105,
0.2544189095,
0.3509649038,
0.2252864391,
0.0103769135,
-0.2137032151,
-0.5570302606,
-0.6667105556,
-0.1100438014,
-0.1415894926,
-0.5060110092,
-0.1624670327,
0.6095778346,
-0.0680153072,
0.3127118647,
-0.2649773657,
-0.1551325917,
-0.3391129971,
0.0395123586,
1.1790753603,
0.5666606426,
-0.1503836811,
0.0187646747,
0.0103902351,
-0.4915555716,
-0.1719096452,
-0.0805460215,
-0.2941899896,
-0.4480292797,
0.5619990826,
1.0906758308,
0.5113713741,
-0.4618622661,
0.1409583241,
-0.0186514109,
-0.3703538775,
-0.1457415819,
0.898683846,
-0.0800127164,
0.2136839926,
0.1905809194,
0.1797306538,
-0.1188972443,
-0.0270976163,
0.2313691825,
0.0942022204,
-0.1377243102,
-0.2897078395,
0.6036542058,
0.4549827874,
-0.5191622972,
0.7928341031,
-0.0887311324,
-0.1367738992,
0.7692173123,
0.4368302822,
0.795630753,
-0.0624115877,
0.1358491778,
0.4955565035,
0.2303018719,
-0.1167604774,
0.3553127646,
-0.535931468,
-0.2337605953,
-0.1225378737,
-0.4130649269,
-0.4132544994,
0.2816919684,
-0.7957006693,
0.2908266783,
-0.5758738518,
0.0608097911,
-0.2022584379,
0.3979480267,
-0.5274870992,
0.0921802595,
0.0822252557,
0.9281410575,
-0.7270893455,
0.3712915778,
0.7303571105,
-0.5349310637,
-0.6986516714,
0.1333412677,
0.2692890465,
-0.4090559185,
-0.0166829098,
0.3508216739,
-0.1188001111,
0.0507182181,
-0.4134476781,
-0.7504590154,
1.3117049932,
0.2503554523,
-0.682058692,
-0.0607880726,
0.1166699231,
0.3946745098,
-0.1802226156,
0.3428784609,
0.7969390154,
0.6427398324,
0.2548639774,
-0.5135810375,
-0.277145803,
-0.3481241763,
-0.2298796326,
0.3580198586,
-1.0630800724,
0.6041719913,
-0.0773798898,
-0.2271646857,
0.1764511764,
0.8586043715,
0.0556267798,
0.5336148739,
0.4310275316,
0.4699607491,
0.9738720655,
-0.2825184166,
0.9366327524,
-0.4402494133,
-0.0737051889,
0.9881160259,
-0.0142397201,
0.3840609789,
0.2187556773,
0.003650761,
0.2443516999,
0.9805952907,
-0.1042752117,
0.4561288953,
-0.0238714591,
-0.3741930723,
-0.1501836181,
-0.1103563085,
-0.3789417446,
0.3009111285,
0.5416557193,
-0.2063224316,
0.048934456,
0.0000554886,
-0.1101564616,
0.0229100548,
-0.2192643732,
0.5877107978,
-0.075446263,
-1.0292981863,
0.7876341939,
-0.3683802187,
0.4843135178,
-0.4475200772,
-0.0514768399,
-0.3741739094,
0.3629774451,
-0.3391714096,
-0.4361919463,
0.1363996416,
-0.0997029245,
-0.1250035167,
-0.416131556,
0.417553395,
-0.6305810213,
-0.416169107,
-0.2032633871,
0.240601331,
-0.0916810185,
0.5558947325,
-0.5615723133,
0.3311257064,
0.1135799587,
-0.2949853241,
0.3131997287,
0.2433270663,
0.0605260581,
0.2153337598,
0.3447730541,
-0.1335226297,
0.2726117969,
0.2592957914,
0.519759655,
-0.5295674801,
-0.2635089755,
-0.266513437,
0.6209658384,
-0.1828830391,
-0.7065572739,
0.4978867471,
0.5471940637,
1.2932850122,
-0.0503925458,
0.5980802774,
-0.0434573516,
0.4794700146,
-0.6503491998,
0.4061693847,
-0.7765674591,
0.3236744702,
-0.0070074582,
-0.6327447295,
0.1032859907,
0.6019361615,
-0.2178445607,
0.5694589019,
0.7143712044,
0.6446449161,
-0.3222334981,
0.6479994059,
-0.001304672,
-0.4058720767,
0.268808037,
0.4718304873,
0.6522600055,
-0.3373922408,
0.4123532474,
-0.824945271,
-0.1283584237,
-0.3379884362,
-0.568453908,
-0.9369002581,
-0.499884963,
-0.2317115366,
0.1626059264,
0.2884602249,
0.754404366,
0.6660772562,
-1.001991868,
-0.4940834939,
-0.4904055297,
0.307856828,
-0.6599532366,
-0.2283708602,
0.1929111034,
-0.7472065091,
-0.7615603805,
0.7004183531,
-0.2829488814,
-0.1207990423,
-0.136498794,
-0.0410880372,
-0.1311775297,
-0.2514893115,
0.3003498316,
0.5347331166,
-0.5822662115,
-0.2942219675,
0.2959762514,
0.0296446141,
-0.0637083873,
1.2314634323,
-0.319585979,
0.5701357722,
0.6525384188,
0.8065985441,
0.4523059726,
0.3309907615,
0.7423593402,
-0.6892581582,
-0.1327273697,
0.0370188504,
-0.0830619559,
0.1095194519,
-0.3748856187,
0.634139955,
0.1494487524,
-0.7455790639,
-0.8401421905,
0.0970402062,
-0.6201490164,
-0.1551139057,
0.6822708249,
0.0467011668,
-0.2405370027,
0.1354883015,
-0.0086993398,
0.5409868956,
-0.4061059654,
0.8189818859,
0.6676181555,
-0.4647267163,
-0.2610132694,
-0.7801300287,
0.6655201316,
0.7028950453,
-0.5012845397,
0.0512754023,
0.6096260548,
0.0391299874,
-0.1140621156,
0.1647610813,
0.2334390283,
0.6944701672,
0.1289255917,
-0.3416641653,
-0.4787270427,
-0.8078143597,
-0.2637352049,
0.1703986526,
0.0066065327,
-0.3898108304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13683v1 | Friend-training: Learning from Models of Different but Related Tasks | 2023-01-31T15:00:56 | 2023-01-31T15:00:56 | Mian Zhang, Lifeng Jin, Linfeng Song, Haitao Mi, Xiabing Zhou, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current self-training methods such as standard self-training, co-training,
tri-training, and others often focus on improving model performance on a single
task, utilizing differences in input features, model architectures, and
training processes. However, many tasks in natural language processing are
about different but related aspects of language, and models trained for one
task can be great teachers for other related tasks. In this work, we propose
friend-training, a cross-task self-training framework, where models trained to
do different tasks are used in an iterative training, pseudo-labeling, and
retraining process to help each other for better selection of pseudo-labels.
With two dialogue understanding tasks, conversational semantic role labeling
and dialogue rewriting, chosen for a case study, we show that the models
trained with the friend-training framework achieve the best performance
compared to strong baselines. | [
-0.3428398371,
-0.5610462427,
0.3791952431,
0.0869918391,
-0.1517704725,
-0.0171048753,
-0.0673217252,
-0.5728449225,
0.1763829887,
0.355256319,
-0.9009714723,
-0.0418448411,
-0.5105005503,
0.3511172533,
-0.2522605956,
1.4072881937,
-0.0422052518,
0.4189260304,
-0.5809869766,
-0.3192978799,
-0.4844502807,
-0.809946239,
-0.8696249723,
-0.5957999229,
0.6407799721,
0.3574714959,
0.434170723,
0.2951053977,
0.1435642093,
0.3986215591,
0.4032327235,
-0.2129012346,
-0.6497207284,
0.193578735,
-0.6305232644,
-0.5386001468,
-0.2144768685,
0.4094538689,
0.4901338816,
0.5523690581,
0.1220562011,
0.3260233998,
0.1824010313,
0.3952369392,
-0.3350616693,
0.4128599763,
-0.4572520256,
0.0528271347,
0.1208061278,
0.1412957162,
-0.1558494419,
-0.0388993211,
0.4920184016,
-0.7657540441,
0.5330933928,
0.2414492667,
0.8159486651,
0.1698238403,
0.1001132131,
-0.0886011198,
-0.426707536,
0.9389422536,
-0.4377868474,
0.8591095209,
0.5396255851,
0.2740174234,
0.1305692941,
-0.7126905918,
-0.4242936373,
-0.0749675408,
-0.2066330612,
-0.1415291429,
0.0604087599,
0.2475602776,
0.1206021383,
0.2955088317,
-0.2438001484,
-0.1466243863,
-0.2737366855,
-0.3361847997,
0.5994048715,
-0.02566728,
0.3794191182,
-0.0438858867,
-0.3683634996,
-0.2869409621,
-0.2706937194,
0.3497819602,
0.1766062379,
0.4801057279,
-0.1855400354,
0.187400341,
-0.505956769,
0.8466471434,
0.0893346593,
-0.5220332146,
0.3557950258,
-0.4977453649,
-0.2231681943,
0.1473021358,
0.6557719707,
0.1115938202,
0.4743665457,
-0.5083068609,
-0.1601027995,
-0.1654411703,
0.3515208364,
-0.6709036827,
-0.4510912597,
-0.2228090316,
-0.7039869428,
-0.1098723933,
-0.368680805,
-0.1614892632,
0.1467675865,
-0.5028322339,
0.7573414445,
-0.3096384704,
-0.1172559634,
0.0251779556,
-0.1731527895,
-0.1983617693,
0.0060736774,
-1.0531264544,
0.5470347404,
0.4708244503,
0.6903892756,
0.0690739378,
-0.7734203935,
-0.9530027509,
0.2330005467,
0.1707246602,
0.7954323888,
-0.6971142888,
-0.4371312261,
-0.2734898627,
0.0798453614,
-0.4493387341,
-0.06928242,
0.1188676655,
-0.1876481175,
0.5517466664,
-0.4982100427,
-0.4853310883,
-0.3242566884,
0.4683136642,
-0.4451188445,
1.1538569927,
0.3727062345,
-0.921797812,
0.4556795359,
-0.2155538201,
-0.4790974259,
-0.3621759415,
-0.2259157449,
-0.492795229,
0.0736709088,
0.2606189251,
0.6956008077,
-0.5052626729,
0.0951553583,
-0.5314543843,
-0.3208554983,
-0.1959523559,
0.1526515484,
0.3615679443,
-0.0281021651,
0.0486822017,
0.1057961211,
-0.741507709,
0.0982706323,
0.1175501496,
-0.3551636636,
-0.6548014879,
-0.2705983818,
-0.3612998724,
0.4372789562,
0.3060232997,
-0.9228736162,
0.0271013509,
-0.6385887861,
0.3298555911,
0.2574578822,
-0.0104871141,
0.5167992711,
-0.5291832089,
0.3392725289,
-0.1444357187,
0.1708475202,
-0.0310491305,
-0.4046236277,
-0.873766005,
-0.2043940127,
0.240584299,
0.5270869732,
-1.0747094154,
0.0391159654,
0.0494683236,
-0.4128455818,
-0.6557357311,
0.4702648818,
0.8006345034,
0.7720247507,
0.5513081551,
-0.6065984368,
-0.4438050687,
-0.865326941,
-0.5449154973,
-0.3306751549,
0.3225322664,
0.1584130675,
0.3805774152,
-0.0899141952,
1.1545789242,
-0.2551063597,
-0.5196433663,
-0.6106923223,
0.3380368054,
-0.1136724278,
0.3873176277,
0.5763482451,
-0.5991492867,
-0.7807399035,
-0.2463820875,
-0.4044399261,
-0.0880890861,
-0.1535103917,
-0.0043993304,
-0.0718800128,
0.5281738639,
-0.0060028583,
0.268021822,
0.4522567093,
0.0276641212,
0.2359513938,
-0.4204854667,
0.0421125591,
-1.0137319565,
-0.2928512394,
0.2653529644,
-0.6613978148,
-0.8539862037,
-0.3436340988,
-0.3366774321,
0.0308888964,
-0.2478376031,
0.6466752887,
-0.4067014754,
-0.3811162412,
-0.2564310133,
-0.1594256312,
0.0297306925,
0.7652539611,
0.5878651142,
0.779260993,
0.6590169668,
-0.4536562562,
0.377056092,
0.4996551275,
-0.1267516315,
0.716853857,
-0.5711148381,
0.4080678821,
-0.1115209088,
0.0997407511,
-0.8749389648,
0.1482984424,
0.4296953976,
-0.1418768764,
0.0912229493,
-0.1468480378,
-0.3265804946,
-0.3582136333,
-0.0165710934,
0.246112451,
0.0929476097,
-0.6376476884,
0.7576054931,
0.1907627285,
-0.1031133831,
-0.518772006,
-0.5053117871,
-0.4244893193,
-0.0709267408,
-0.5354495049,
0.4807494283,
0.1221764535,
0.1420826465,
0.0303032454,
-0.1728000343,
-0.3735287189,
0.0273922291,
0.3707384765,
-0.2032336295,
0.1806144863,
0.4001814723,
-0.0459639207,
-0.3141100705,
-0.0945017934,
-0.0973990932,
0.4048302174,
-0.0379565656,
-0.3114150167,
-0.5288447142,
0.4018050134,
-0.2874753177,
-0.4752553105,
0.8219885826,
0.747520268,
0.0393577963,
-0.3900983334,
-0.5659427047,
-0.4162366688,
-0.4495844543,
0.3851440847,
-0.7941564322,
-1.1752170324,
0.1570380926,
-0.0640896633,
0.114004463,
-0.0656216964,
0.324067086,
-0.2935763896,
0.8188554049,
1.231395483,
-0.4502970576,
0.8222888112,
-0.0688670576,
0.4695950747,
-0.4554846585,
-0.2681558728,
-0.50292027,
-0.2043133229,
-0.0873588696,
-0.4705018997,
0.1500880271,
-0.1906980276,
-0.1984582394,
0.664788425,
-0.3168312609,
0.2950732708,
0.9169706106,
0.1455975622,
0.1878825575,
0.1096208319,
-0.1797658354,
0.003135988,
-0.9507633448,
-0.1258812398,
0.7728837729,
0.4631311297,
0.7129257917,
-0.620007515,
1.1374567747,
0.1147882938,
0.222050488,
-0.4494226575,
0.3758066595,
-0.2748737931,
-0.6068848968,
-0.2780635655,
-0.3444111943,
-0.4567648172,
0.2408397645,
-0.2396965027,
-0.8645586967,
0.1043473706,
0.2932242155,
-0.4135361612,
0.1325197816,
-0.798432827,
1.1853935719,
-0.297067821,
-0.1540447921,
-0.4631241858,
-0.830829978,
-0.0528082773,
-0.0476149023,
0.1759124547,
-0.1154138744,
0.4372520745,
0.8219678998,
-0.2526082397,
1.1406612396,
-0.2971581519,
0.0896282271,
0.3764176369,
0.1379033923,
0.3485539556,
0.0276035648,
-0.0457479842,
-0.0632309765,
0.5113865137,
-0.3073680699,
-0.6011000872,
0.2849637866,
-0.8558446169,
-0.7172369361,
-0.3678471148,
-0.7418907285,
-0.5793328285,
-0.0338531807,
0.1120450869,
0.4946870208,
-0.2787156701,
-0.1144180223,
0.4662271142,
-0.0453979447,
0.3836831748,
0.4571382701,
-0.0479871072,
-0.2576506138,
1.245146513,
-0.1678280681,
0.5577629209,
0.4703024328,
-0.0656707361,
-0.2390785068,
-0.1942126751,
0.056181252,
0.448106885,
-0.7249116898,
0.1285363585,
-0.839756012,
-0.1323401034,
-0.445087105,
0.0098716961,
-0.5195905566,
-0.2018654048,
-0.3082759976,
0.0831139684,
0.2253150195,
0.6683374643,
-0.1739069819,
0.7045148015,
-0.9350607991,
0.3579507172,
0.6640489101,
0.3321971297,
-0.1052659154,
-0.4154272974,
-0.4770805836,
0.1063073128,
-0.112897642,
-0.8313548565,
0.2141646147,
0.522531271,
0.8609059453,
-0.0379114896,
-0.2054613382,
0.6676024795,
-0.520213604,
0.50066185,
0.4530845284,
-1.0814362764,
0.4280253053,
0.0353248343,
0.0404097214,
1.0686677694,
0.7795284986,
-0.8008739352,
-0.2149706036,
-0.5702224374,
-0.1464927942,
1.1517180204,
0.1535682827,
0.1576667875,
0.1276296079,
0.486528933,
0.2784893513,
0.3835039139,
-0.9820010066,
-0.1014453694,
-0.5231866241,
-0.323864907,
-0.2558374703,
-0.1959995031,
-0.1276424229,
-0.4735919237,
0.7407090664,
-0.4794589877,
0.5301908255,
0.4882966578,
-0.2102331519,
0.0184661634,
-0.07332436,
-0.1633500457,
0.321801424,
0.0239474792,
-0.0724426731,
0.4243666828,
0.0604169443,
0.2074026018,
0.1239939705,
0.4023549855,
-0.1973450035,
0.4646106362,
1.1269369125,
0.5092478991,
-0.3512255549,
0.5236617327,
-0.2594572902,
-0.2344742417,
0.3283672631,
0.5330190063,
0.1497118026,
0.6181071401,
-0.2739309967,
-0.3466682732,
0.2153083533,
-0.7121795416,
0.3124684691,
0.4078953266,
-0.6653296947,
-0.4099685252,
0.3506295383,
0.2913331985,
-0.4027330577,
0.3474141359,
-0.274504602,
-0.7686451077,
0.2846576571,
0.6475859284,
0.723654151,
-0.381360054,
0.637124002,
0.2649808824,
-0.021944331,
-0.2703206241,
0.4320723712,
-0.7117047906,
-0.8309420943,
-0.360638231,
-0.6746768951,
-0.390884608,
-0.1765996367,
-0.5041435957,
0.1926102936,
-0.3771084845,
-0.0268046074,
-0.028950192,
0.0211070012,
-0.780939281,
0.6883206367,
-0.0029666782,
0.5852236748,
-1.0038688183,
1.236790657,
1.0184131861,
-0.4192599058,
-1.0153353214,
-0.1330077946,
-0.2250272483,
-0.6993936896,
0.9778796434,
0.2138294429,
-0.0120376833,
0.0391665436,
-0.1506990045,
-0.9699494243,
0.7834273577,
0.1224253476,
-0.6923024654,
-0.4818471074,
0.2855261862,
0.6355000138,
-0.7136216164,
0.3085761666,
0.6604076624,
-0.0261799823,
-0.0981340557,
-1.3961166143,
-0.1979116946,
0.0491193756,
0.068681322,
-0.1017222404,
-0.9630068541,
0.6976920962,
0.1004028618,
0.0669815317,
0.1098802388,
0.7277725935,
-0.0571713932,
0.2282782793,
0.9816843867,
0.5460935831,
0.488008976,
0.0429860353,
0.8154429793,
-0.2952631414,
0.3931625485,
1.4707027674,
-0.1664395928,
0.4440428317,
0.4101443589,
0.0014746004,
0.4348029792,
0.6421239376,
0.0116265127,
0.8242984414,
-0.1604632884,
-0.0262005292,
-0.8924187422,
-0.1675182581,
-0.1192020327,
0.4740738869,
0.104262121,
-0.4772620201,
-0.5507403016,
0.3639379442,
-0.1869528145,
0.0384139419,
-0.0400841758,
0.9085162282,
0.4219456017,
-0.6763293147,
0.1562328637,
-0.0498919822,
0.4542565942,
-0.6083177328,
-0.0155736748,
0.0330822505,
0.0482920893,
0.0179463793,
-0.5421287417,
0.3623339534,
-0.1852480769,
-0.182293728,
-0.6381911039,
0.9504498839,
-0.5279891491,
-0.2236713171,
0.6835887432,
0.5950829983,
0.1409254074,
-0.0273675174,
-1.1651518345,
-0.0742723048,
0.244849056,
-0.1490112245,
0.4177590907,
0.1260194331,
-0.0145269502,
0.8448030353,
0.382093519,
-0.0668796897,
0.0005778748,
0.1736633033,
0.9031316042,
-0.4922321737,
-0.7378436327,
-0.5242111087,
0.0969973356,
-0.1246170849,
-0.3607122004,
0.6799231768,
0.2079961151,
1.2297716141,
0.1794188917,
0.6499492526,
-0.0485504121,
0.9550309181,
-0.215689227,
0.3211549222,
-0.6121143103,
-0.0628868341,
-0.2523846924,
-1.1965177059,
0.1818276495,
0.851954639,
-0.7361060381,
0.208967343,
0.6563434005,
0.4293037355,
-0.1769243926,
0.3840751946,
0.2359177619,
-0.203496784,
0.4023147821,
0.7382155657,
0.7596957088,
-0.1294719279,
0.3403317928,
-0.8599763513,
0.1886687577,
0.1643223017,
-0.5547893047,
-1.6840943098,
-0.8805799484,
-0.2795017362,
0.0612936653,
0.4558500051,
0.9972847104,
1.1336215734,
-0.564556241,
-0.2511144876,
0.0679743215,
-0.0484758057,
-0.1126535013,
-0.0453292429,
-0.0221280418,
-0.819467783,
-0.7161825895,
0.4320417047,
0.0606974959,
-0.0039088596,
-0.1656344384,
-0.0470751822,
-0.3062580526,
-0.2048699707,
0.1680066586,
0.3809040487,
-0.4469165206,
-0.5212315917,
-0.3189971149,
0.0215985943,
-0.0030284747,
0.8999290466,
-1.0362131596,
0.6584795117,
0.5225241184,
0.8134283423,
0.7646869421,
0.0916673318,
0.8589610457,
-1.0367491245,
0.3214119971,
-0.1693489254,
0.2161660492,
0.5677450895,
-0.4360644519,
0.4175352156,
0.283097446,
-0.5170080662,
-0.6507274508,
0.0940656886,
-0.5333496928,
-0.3736411035,
0.8570210338,
-0.5178278089,
-0.3555373847,
-0.2883884907,
-0.3218430877,
0.5830618143,
-0.3465885222,
0.6060612202,
0.8349230886,
-0.3293305635,
-0.1613490283,
-0.2107552588,
0.8571403623,
0.7668138146,
-0.7340698242,
-0.2720032036,
0.0295458287,
0.6425759792,
0.0939485803,
0.7611069679,
0.5450816751,
0.0796028078,
-0.313162148,
0.0341611132,
-0.1279523969,
-0.6699599028,
-0.0745729059,
0.0255016889,
0.0131771332,
-0.3460284472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13668v1 | Automated Sentiment and Hate Speech Analysis of Facebook Data by Employing Multilingual Transformer Models | 2023-01-31T14:37:04 | 2023-01-31T14:37:04 | Ritumbra Manuvie, Saikat Chatterjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent years, there has been a heightened consensus within academia and in
the public discourse that Social Media Platforms (SMPs), amplify the spread of
hateful and negative sentiment content. Researchers have identified how hateful
content, political propaganda, and targeted messaging contributed to real-world
harms including insurrections against democratically elected governments,
genocide, and breakdown of social cohesion due to heightened negative discourse
towards certain communities in parts of the world. To counter these issues,
SMPs have created semi-automated systems that can help identify toxic speech.
In this paper we analyse the statistical distribution of hateful and negative
sentiment contents within a representative Facebook dataset (n= 604,703)
scrapped through 648 public Facebook pages which identify themselves as
proponents (and followers) of far-right Hindutva actors. These pages were
identified manually using keyword searches on Facebook and on CrowdTangleand
classified as far-right Hindutva pages based on page names, page descriptions,
and discourses shared on these pages. We employ state-of-the-art, open-source
XLM-T multilingual transformer-based language models to perform sentiment and
hate speech analysis of the textual contents shared on these pages over a
period of 5.5 years. The result shows the statistical distributions of the
predicted sentiment and the hate speech labels; top actors, and top page
categories. We further discuss the benchmark performances and limitations of
these pre-trained language models. | [
-0.5466736555,
-0.9424999356,
0.1569828987,
0.2820855975,
-0.2632156909,
0.1101612374,
-0.2469952106,
-0.3499353826,
0.407594502,
0.5657191873,
-0.525367558,
-0.3897055387,
-0.7108601928,
0.1035601795,
-0.6939258575,
1.0764628649,
0.3697111309,
0.1115830988,
0.2509058118,
-0.1997067481,
0.0830649883,
-0.5564075112,
-0.3632032871,
0.0736568272,
0.6981778145,
0.0030471098,
0.8706229925,
0.2932356596,
0.3458206654,
0.2782097161,
-0.1458085626,
-0.137298435,
-0.6150484681,
0.0711129978,
-0.4759990275,
-0.1144666076,
-0.2416558862,
0.1538767368,
0.5472372174,
0.3833662271,
0.1565882713,
0.420270443,
0.0128674386,
0.1698573381,
-0.3820206225,
-0.0125170099,
-0.6490316391,
0.1482657939,
-0.2690990865,
-0.0590576306,
-0.6457443833,
-0.7526541948,
-0.2300334275,
-0.1994384527,
0.0637891218,
-0.2631590366,
0.642457366,
0.2314432114,
-0.5382676125,
-0.5282605886,
-0.8275565505,
1.1007106304,
-0.734952271,
0.4586679041,
0.0224084612,
0.2084944397,
0.1163412109,
-0.0443881974,
-0.7836409211,
-0.1089516282,
-0.0364298373,
0.204218328,
-0.6328757405,
-0.1430470347,
0.1066503823,
0.2163076103,
-0.5739298463,
0.1951299906,
-0.5037022233,
-0.3398603499,
0.7347522378,
0.0867813528,
0.445576936,
-0.6425464749,
-0.2239487469,
-0.1373970956,
-0.2578208148,
-0.1262476742,
0.5783478022,
0.592564702,
-0.0524535812,
0.6845254302,
0.1022418514,
0.5825129151,
0.0790962055,
-0.2129542977,
0.4385054111,
0.0030660084,
-0.0677311644,
-0.2066185474,
1.0153406858,
0.5909090638,
0.4335694611,
-0.0671021119,
0.1856549084,
0.7258844376,
0.3057025075,
-0.7215206623,
0.0611209981,
0.0813019946,
-0.5065076351,
-0.5806532502,
-0.2212075293,
-1.298271656,
-0.8594010472,
-0.1862681508,
0.0792197436,
-0.1724430621,
-0.6023150682,
-0.507873714,
-0.2074213773,
0.331001699,
-0.0715299174,
-0.3563969135,
0.0768725574,
0.4765767157,
0.6453000307,
-0.4214093089,
-0.0625086129,
-0.4553399682,
-0.0691263229,
-0.3606704772,
0.8210229278,
-0.8503272533,
-0.2599487901,
0.2904701531,
0.0962327793,
0.0362853631,
-0.5280807018,
0.7061979175,
-0.6995151639,
0.0199027956,
-0.0689365789,
-0.4748597443,
-0.3372834325,
0.2423546761,
-0.6063400507,
0.7511687279,
-0.0057172575,
-0.7520766258,
0.1906972378,
-0.5294633508,
-0.4241922796,
-0.025004752,
-0.0642001256,
-0.4186659753,
0.0886045396,
0.0067587649,
0.7194520831,
-0.0037435996,
0.2431970388,
-0.7997398376,
0.0778676793,
0.3724610806,
-0.5143965483,
0.9716052413,
0.4248005748,
-0.3975398242,
0.1521691531,
-0.8632215261,
-0.1777355522,
0.1803162694,
0.0247388221,
-0.4286306798,
0.0633718297,
0.4751393199,
0.6632456183,
-0.2063824236,
-0.7835395932,
-0.2713810802,
-0.4197945893,
0.1485094875,
0.974406302,
0.0137217622,
0.2033859044,
-0.0879885256,
0.7752992511,
0.3475604355,
0.3992314935,
0.2703578472,
-0.5443381071,
-0.2931818962,
0.0924009606,
-0.4866600931,
0.6215568185,
-0.4671090841,
0.0228854325,
-0.133450374,
-0.7466255426,
-0.2813378274,
0.0782571733,
0.3131810129,
0.3935334086,
0.504414916,
-0.0005455578,
-0.6056437492,
-0.9629451632,
-0.6523528695,
-0.3143798113,
0.2847234905,
0.2160478979,
0.1324882358,
-0.5685595274,
0.8652489185,
-0.417301178,
-0.2045285702,
-0.1752139032,
0.2344545275,
-0.1342956722,
-0.102957122,
0.651150167,
-1.1735057831,
-0.9409575462,
-0.1278002262,
-0.5045871139,
-0.3967171907,
0.0722209811,
-0.0261538811,
0.3675339222,
0.242740646,
-0.0800734982,
0.4071416557,
0.9472407699,
-0.2323689163,
0.5996460915,
0.6845464706,
0.174219951,
-1.2947380543,
-0.1132966056,
0.4016546309,
-0.1084318236,
-0.8063119054,
-0.1734780669,
-0.1846972555,
-0.1666643471,
-0.6801441312,
0.3970164061,
0.1072740257,
0.118788287,
-0.2743235528,
0.1293521076,
-0.4771791995,
0.4278341532,
-0.0557583645,
0.4079395235,
0.2823651433,
-0.3342832327,
0.5150009394,
0.1934830099,
0.2170031816,
0.6348231435,
-0.1069414169,
-0.1695378721,
-0.1110823452,
0.1577791572,
-1.154791832,
-0.1588265896,
0.4777472913,
-0.4701195955,
-0.1592716873,
-0.0349270962,
-0.3578341603,
-0.4800269604,
-0.2813154757,
0.2742983103,
0.2756954134,
-0.1740654558,
0.841596961,
0.9719789028,
-0.2892085016,
-0.623329103,
-0.7262596488,
0.1378662437,
-0.4702712297,
-0.4891194403,
0.1034763157,
-0.2217617631,
-0.5297669768,
0.0857696831,
0.187037304,
-0.319358319,
-0.2202680409,
0.5770538449,
-0.0851175487,
0.0137766358,
-0.0438277535,
0.2038994431,
-0.0621134974,
0.3056682646,
0.098961845,
0.5734779835,
-0.2132380605,
-0.1103902385,
-0.4631422758,
0.3248071074,
0.6668680906,
-0.068483755,
0.774584353,
0.7783553004,
-0.2795560956,
-0.1087143049,
-0.6428871155,
0.0046079084,
-0.3803443015,
0.3151222169,
0.2589081824,
-0.7696470022,
0.6246739626,
0.0536804684,
0.1637534201,
0.6470822096,
0.750780344,
0.1605382413,
1.0340524912,
0.606087923,
-0.3518673778,
0.5053793192,
0.0344624445,
0.2685281336,
-0.0407521166,
0.1418518722,
-0.490546912,
0.0907541662,
-0.9112213254,
-0.3644791842,
0.259904325,
-0.6400400996,
-0.0207331199,
0.2647433877,
-0.5031785369,
0.3750208914,
0.1672434509,
-0.1838310957,
0.073143281,
0.1949659735,
-0.0166613311,
-0.107973665,
-0.2259492278,
-0.6009290218,
0.9532740712,
0.17994681,
0.537956059,
-0.023753982,
0.4699521959,
0.7139525414,
0.7270986438,
-0.6862924695,
0.6959898472,
-0.4163047373,
-0.8667776585,
-0.224120304,
-0.3772271574,
-0.5231816769,
0.1136007532,
-0.0539214499,
-0.4791821241,
0.0866820812,
0.168563351,
-0.2415206879,
0.5380353332,
-0.4861180782,
0.7987632751,
0.0016598859,
-0.1944555938,
-0.420730263,
-0.5865038037,
0.3690733612,
-0.4393339753,
0.7545486689,
0.0100484891,
0.31161201,
0.9138380885,
-0.0271554664,
1.0485938787,
-0.4487435818,
-0.3810034394,
0.2483049333,
-0.1401681155,
0.1152363941,
-0.4636410177,
-0.2761100233,
0.3535968363,
-0.09915445,
-0.284971416,
-0.0734526888,
0.6490131021,
-0.8581544757,
-0.1157602519,
-0.2769856751,
-0.2865708768,
-0.1522455662,
0.334633559,
0.082490027,
0.3695597947,
-0.3682359159,
0.1318191439,
0.4503594637,
-0.7112112641,
0.2828493416,
0.436776191,
-0.4550454617,
-0.385628283,
1.1117446423,
0.4020559788,
0.1584907472,
0.164704591,
0.2405805439,
-0.2389990389,
-0.1703825146,
-0.3838419616,
0.2939649522,
-0.7081694603,
-0.1585753858,
-0.8368721604,
-0.1064902171,
-0.4735498726,
-0.1660333723,
-0.485226512,
-0.116378434,
-0.0355604328,
-0.1188499182,
0.0240187682,
0.8274166584,
-0.2927361429,
0.4868699908,
-0.6042451859,
0.5181908011,
0.0494031459,
0.251691103,
-0.102372624,
-0.4942289293,
-0.2453634292,
0.2183901519,
-0.5643877983,
-1.3759989738,
0.6150932908,
-0.2186974287,
0.2878192365,
0.5389710665,
0.166336149,
0.677901268,
-0.3275065124,
0.7618938088,
0.0327829756,
-0.6763845682,
0.4707953334,
-0.4564685524,
-0.2227109224,
0.1230600551,
0.8230502605,
-0.6546704173,
-0.9899110198,
-0.4458019435,
-0.6102076769,
0.7361336946,
-0.0683453903,
0.348528713,
-0.2165022939,
-0.0204863846,
0.1571870446,
0.0305625685,
-1.1216512918,
-0.5046595335,
-0.4828729331,
-0.2134849578,
-0.1886215508,
-0.3911720812,
-0.0899384618,
-0.137895748,
1.0160006285,
-0.0149685629,
0.1324150115,
-0.3791158497,
-0.3184593022,
-0.4191815257,
0.3556330502,
0.3755232096,
0.6333276629,
-0.1320985109,
-0.0748965219,
-0.0761689395,
-0.3817078769,
0.2131737024,
0.3739551902,
-0.1514607668,
0.1472102702,
-0.0619320571,
0.41561234,
-0.0401918329,
-0.5341598988,
0.608641088,
-0.0137323635,
0.0369755961,
-0.7366802096,
-0.2686665058,
0.1964296401,
0.262593478,
0.4900895357,
0.0330969729,
0.1008375436,
-0.385666877,
0.3292702734,
0.4565645754,
-0.5269423723,
-0.5560374856,
0.4342925847,
0.022495674,
-0.2133596539,
0.2629983425,
-0.1962424666,
-0.6640542746,
0.2607715428,
0.3778384626,
0.7940205336,
-0.6852688789,
0.7205227613,
0.2336486578,
0.2567422092,
0.5112502575,
0.0650888085,
0.2592768073,
-0.8159464598,
-0.4542044103,
-0.9955834746,
-0.2797693014,
0.2890460491,
-0.8126655817,
0.1754704267,
-0.3110028207,
-0.2339421064,
0.4722879827,
0.0254802853,
-0.355238229,
0.2979089916,
0.5659829378,
0.352776289,
-1.3417674303,
0.4327227175,
0.6513668299,
-0.4680393934,
-0.6856235862,
0.0494151004,
0.3872075677,
-0.5754906535,
0.4781715274,
0.3148920834,
-0.2708527446,
-0.0396253057,
-0.4909976125,
-0.4546694458,
0.2849870324,
0.1829839051,
-0.430678457,
0.0502967127,
0.7664650679,
0.8508476615,
0.0102571603,
0.1999209672,
0.072453104,
0.3556042016,
-0.1643706709,
-0.7797509432,
0.0217990689,
-0.257751286,
-0.3598016798,
0.2152988166,
-0.6933922768,
0.7124162912,
0.4387767017,
-0.2985203564,
-0.391618669,
0.4633774161,
-0.1372066438,
0.407929033,
0.706568718,
0.3963845968,
0.3261214197,
0.2423566431,
0.6725634336,
-0.3658866882,
0.3282678425,
0.6667103767,
-0.0796225742,
0.7632960081,
0.2732745409,
-0.1784169376,
0.6941248775,
0.268694967,
-0.0115803974,
0.1891917139,
0.1443381459,
-0.1516798884,
-0.1271832734,
-0.2755639255,
-0.1753630191,
0.4881962836,
0.5106989741,
-0.5699001551,
-0.4233391285,
0.4611797631,
0.0502694286,
0.3077053428,
-0.3446966112,
0.8514671326,
0.0401607081,
-0.5137533545,
0.4106480777,
0.0438292064,
0.7779969573,
-0.4034679234,
0.304384321,
-0.0590188839,
0.4330736101,
-0.3655990362,
-0.681038022,
0.8547228575,
0.4072657824,
-0.1947970688,
-0.3332125247,
0.6903347969,
-0.2265986651,
-0.6177753806,
0.7359928489,
0.4155399799,
0.3334839046,
-0.2938311398,
-1.0512443781,
0.2750077546,
0.109736748,
-0.3218334913,
0.3274661005,
0.1748061776,
-0.2033489048,
0.5623419881,
0.5869408846,
0.0803294405,
0.3854705095,
0.2096963227,
1.142650485,
-0.7487196922,
-0.5161339641,
-0.9729710221,
0.1733142138,
-0.0849553868,
-0.0088829082,
1.052937746,
0.6607066393,
0.9079145789,
0.1244076118,
0.8829835653,
-0.1818419844,
1.1506569386,
0.2506867349,
0.6984242201,
-0.6137136221,
-0.2310304046,
-0.8697683811,
-0.7714858651,
-0.4494957924,
0.3950985074,
-0.5368726254,
-0.1411024481,
0.1857249588,
1.079729557,
-0.1511974335,
0.2775598168,
0.1855241954,
0.6239621043,
0.5818831325,
0.0624625944,
0.8975090384,
-0.2002453506,
0.9222761989,
-0.3643432856,
-0.2688759863,
-0.208870694,
-0.5689691305,
-0.8268797398,
-0.5550833941,
-0.2412527949,
-0.5243657231,
-0.0911388919,
0.8224352598,
0.3463718295,
-0.9338721633,
-0.3735730648,
0.2668877542,
-0.0272317491,
-0.1163500622,
-0.365301162,
0.2945707738,
-0.004181623,
-0.7183263898,
0.0147317573,
0.2882808149,
-0.3310505152,
-0.4464247525,
0.0605553538,
-0.2465962619,
0.3008361757,
0.7976706624,
0.2463040203,
-0.8453342319,
-0.116863966,
-0.0628931373,
-0.0664324537,
-0.0952933878,
0.3911642134,
-0.5556898713,
0.3161817193,
0.2842234969,
0.6148112416,
0.0267229769,
0.2162842453,
0.1212497801,
-0.4842097759,
0.009080831,
0.3593232334,
-0.1008678749,
0.3010011315,
-0.1415589005,
0.0336043127,
0.4129391015,
-0.4812999964,
-1.0540730953,
0.2573201358,
-0.8986362815,
-0.2121245265,
1.3452364206,
0.0273629725,
-0.1813907921,
-0.1522869766,
-0.0995580181,
0.5953076482,
-0.3891178071,
0.7830989361,
0.7058182955,
0.0386116393,
0.0368308052,
-0.3011844456,
0.3848928213,
0.2228081673,
-0.6551386118,
0.2636640668,
0.9169198871,
0.2308629602,
0.5099790096,
0.5736697912,
-0.1692557186,
-0.0526027568,
-0.2893051207,
-0.0970634967,
0.3139474392,
-0.170243293,
-0.2494392991,
0.5648275614,
-0.5822318792,
0.2505676746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13631v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13631v2 | TopoBERT: Plug and Play Toponym Recognition Module Harnessing Fine-tuned BERT | 2023-01-31T13:44:34 | 2023-02-03T17:45:11 | Bing Zhou, Lei Zou, Yingjie Hu, Yi Qiang, Daniel Goldberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Extracting precise geographical information from textual contents is crucial
in a plethora of applications. For example, during hazardous events, a robust
and unbiased toponym extraction framework can provide an avenue to tie the
location concerned to the topic discussed by news media posts and pinpoint
humanitarian help requests or damage reports from social media. Early studies
have leveraged rule-based, gazetteer-based, deep learning, and hybrid
approaches to address this problem. However, the performance of existing tools
is deficient in supporting operations like emergency rescue, which relies on
fine-grained, accurate geographic information. The emerging pretrained language
models can better capture the underlying characteristics of text information,
including place names, offering a promising pathway to optimize toponym
recognition to underpin practical applications. In this paper, TopoBERT, a
toponym recognition module based on a one dimensional Convolutional Neural
Network (CNN1D) and Bidirectional Encoder Representation from Transformers
(BERT), is proposed and fine-tuned. Three datasets (CoNLL2003-Train,
Wikipedia3000, WNUT2017) are leveraged to tune the hyperparameters, discover
the best training strategy, and train the model. Another two datasets
(CoNLL2003-Test and Harvey2017) are used to evaluate the performance. Three
distinguished classifiers, linear, multi-layer perceptron, and CNN1D, are
benchmarked to determine the optimal model architecture. TopoBERT achieves
state-of-the-art performance (f1-score=0.865) compared to the other five
baseline models and can be applied to diverse toponym recognition tasks without
additional training. | [
-0.5663230419,
-0.8400389552,
0.027940806,
0.1747901589,
-0.5187351704,
0.0281315353,
-0.4867558479,
-0.4533976018,
0.0450704917,
0.5363382101,
-0.3653491735,
-0.7418465018,
-0.9661941528,
-0.3112524748,
-0.4347189665,
1.0375671387,
0.3014530838,
-0.3482408822,
0.0913655311,
-0.1341268569,
-0.2176501751,
-0.8539792299,
-0.3830085993,
-0.02363622,
0.5824538469,
0.4461306036,
0.8493455052,
0.4609909952,
0.8259090781,
0.3821341395,
-0.1401228458,
0.3109097183,
-0.7158587575,
-0.0108465971,
-0.264588654,
-0.1191508695,
-0.0442673303,
0.1034712791,
0.1272589564,
0.3189270794,
-0.2640866339,
0.2458679527,
-0.0950845554,
0.3547979593,
-0.6380707622,
-0.1754679531,
-0.5230344534,
0.1490579098,
-0.335750103,
-0.4038566947,
-0.0849643275,
-0.7900623679,
0.7211131454,
-0.5772393942,
0.5322799087,
0.3431887627,
1.1452968121,
0.4103335142,
-0.0671817511,
-0.0540863797,
-0.9957008362,
0.8717733622,
-0.503721416,
0.6052781343,
0.7332555056,
0.5437714458,
-0.1221768335,
-0.5405339003,
-0.1758426279,
-0.2114132345,
-0.2613556981,
-0.0047282767,
-0.1993831098,
-0.2126297206,
0.2285136729,
0.3400597572,
-0.8630705476,
0.2533332705,
-0.2039797306,
-0.3110398352,
0.2830232382,
-0.4103275836,
0.0191483609,
-0.0531672351,
-0.8822259903,
0.2093995512,
-0.7165910602,
-0.0855720565,
0.0533444509,
0.2664576471,
-0.2006226778,
0.1801058948,
-0.2108051777,
0.3297529817,
0.2263749689,
-0.0236051306,
0.1131778359,
0.0111098038,
-0.4187650383,
0.2447976321,
0.6050047278,
0.0607888699,
0.5448411107,
-0.5847572684,
0.1100228876,
-0.4627203345,
0.3336154521,
-0.7965008616,
-0.3174610138,
0.3006632924,
-0.5101364851,
-0.3570239246,
-0.0306789111,
-0.549726069,
-0.3012772799,
-0.3121142983,
0.5303041339,
-0.5532726049,
-0.3120693564,
-0.0371943898,
-0.1149703488,
0.3134996891,
0.5298359394,
-0.8882538676,
0.1004281938,
0.6441895962,
0.8457614183,
-0.1293253154,
-0.2786170542,
-0.2432055324,
0.0186831541,
-0.2212621868,
0.8874588013,
-0.1469855756,
-0.0160770547,
-0.0734887123,
0.0591116957,
0.2651420832,
-0.6408390999,
0.3541375101,
-0.5094693899,
0.3012625575,
-0.3277989328,
-0.3355967402,
-0.1169078872,
0.7519066334,
-0.7635460496,
1.4163882732,
0.2045858204,
-0.9201791883,
0.4276450872,
-0.2315668166,
-0.3522698283,
0.3564686775,
0.3871390224,
-0.4654798806,
0.0516095981,
0.5110820532,
0.4010914862,
-0.3537625968,
0.2229450643,
-0.0527347401,
-0.3566978276,
0.0761112422,
-0.466432035,
1.0652778149,
0.0097215334,
-0.3923473656,
0.0755377337,
-1.0031181574,
-0.0597574972,
0.059889216,
-0.4387183487,
-0.6814662218,
0.2019614428,
0.4675027132,
0.1232266724,
0.4358634949,
-0.8122000098,
0.0196406208,
-0.3358214796,
-0.0680498183,
0.5915874839,
-0.0651707053,
0.2152653933,
-0.1903000623,
0.1272397786,
-0.1849095821,
0.2856457829,
0.2071919888,
-0.3538897634,
-0.5851438642,
-0.4576309025,
0.4328658879,
0.9793124795,
-0.4448989332,
0.6717299819,
-0.1280032247,
-0.8612086773,
-0.2511456311,
-0.1391936243,
0.2511145771,
0.5985020399,
0.5949009657,
-0.1126273423,
-0.836158812,
-0.5991052985,
0.0846681818,
-0.0463498086,
-0.1830414981,
0.1600266695,
0.0612126328,
-0.0765265226,
0.880784452,
-0.1956811249,
-0.4993888438,
-0.3220264316,
0.0947099254,
0.0023859548,
0.5098885298,
0.8692375422,
-0.7863138914,
-0.1059462279,
0.0730952173,
-0.5861787796,
0.0206950121,
0.1224748716,
-0.7619162202,
-0.2518153191,
0.0320071578,
-0.6348258257,
0.2710156739,
0.3310304284,
-0.1340847462,
0.397922039,
-0.2697753608,
0.1569553465,
-1.0518257618,
0.2107095867,
-0.0313542187,
-0.1664219648,
-0.7291149497,
0.0025259859,
-0.16327402,
-0.0462447442,
-0.6737691164,
0.4316165149,
-0.1062047631,
-0.0576190129,
0.0042551393,
-0.0247273017,
-0.3628202379,
0.3352609575,
0.1575552076,
0.5610113144,
0.5023781657,
-0.4369930625,
0.3980047405,
0.4254619479,
-0.4656043351,
0.3102631271,
-0.26473701,
0.0948503166,
0.1086035594,
-0.1015887856,
-1.186612606,
-0.3369103372,
-0.0828206167,
-0.3269795775,
0.2121216804,
-0.1639840156,
-0.653490901,
-0.2395445257,
-0.228447184,
0.3114396334,
0.5964515209,
-0.7752498984,
0.2303278893,
0.4518256187,
-0.1814460903,
-0.7732602358,
-0.5987891555,
0.0795300826,
-0.1761075258,
-0.2879781127,
0.3734603524,
0.0814426914,
0.2758904994,
-0.2726647556,
0.1158546507,
-0.652179122,
0.2743490338,
-0.0239394549,
0.169807598,
-0.2270554304,
-0.0372439437,
-0.151086688,
-0.3229365945,
-0.1831997335,
-0.2170309126,
0.3125792444,
0.1756333709,
0.1232946888,
-0.426726073,
0.3869863451,
0.7803683877,
-0.423774153,
0.624769628,
0.6310461164,
-0.8599343896,
-0.1422181726,
-0.5735381246,
0.116695568,
-0.5013554096,
0.1788222492,
0.1851705015,
-0.6660115719,
0.4589613676,
-0.5620850325,
0.2292195559,
0.0561423302,
0.5300451517,
-0.3192898333,
0.3753883541,
0.7235093713,
-0.3474072516,
0.5236009359,
-0.0834059566,
0.492621243,
-0.3133644462,
-0.1759609878,
-0.5140528679,
-0.3813827336,
-0.6472154856,
-0.1337963343,
0.1805833876,
0.048211053,
-0.1933161616,
0.5687787533,
-0.5757246017,
0.4434438646,
0.7771716714,
0.2077911049,
-0.1137300879,
0.4015072882,
-0.1974107027,
-0.2730367184,
-0.5046847463,
-0.3724256456,
0.7596424818,
0.1534041613,
0.7484155893,
0.1933568567,
0.6797922254,
0.417460531,
0.337901473,
-0.6902397871,
0.6192846298,
-0.3857412636,
-0.5102671981,
-0.3868413866,
0.0283324216,
-1.0106568336,
0.133596018,
-0.307333529,
-0.8310385346,
0.1884098202,
0.3738383055,
-0.5435308218,
0.3246247768,
-0.2357054353,
0.5541638136,
-0.4192073047,
-0.187454164,
0.2376680821,
-0.6468092203,
-0.1414257437,
0.030561382,
0.1008851752,
-0.1005734205,
0.4147000909,
0.3912972808,
-0.3266477883,
0.5651454329,
-0.3427051902,
0.0451707244,
0.0812724382,
0.202091679,
0.2829436958,
-0.4312153161,
-0.0951650217,
0.8846045732,
-0.3660731316,
-0.2312228829,
-0.3055416644,
0.5755282044,
-0.6896545887,
-0.2194330096,
-0.0575223826,
-0.4418549538,
-0.0433448516,
0.1727966368,
0.6766762733,
0.6467245221,
-0.4117248356,
0.1564912498,
0.6908417344,
-0.3092218935,
0.4968129396,
0.2170691937,
0.2327126861,
-0.4665086567,
0.9283893704,
0.3599899709,
-0.2558228374,
0.6750169396,
0.2986872196,
-0.183246538,
-0.5424755812,
-0.6965739727,
-0.1159216091,
-0.3792243004,
-0.4070674479,
-0.3039779961,
-0.5289646983,
-0.0176399238,
-0.5669443011,
-0.4568573236,
-0.6769507527,
-0.0791079625,
-0.4323908091,
0.2254553437,
0.4290036559,
-0.1787140667,
0.4774472713,
-0.6789444685,
0.3110128641,
0.065804936,
0.2460615635,
-0.227940619,
-0.1724056453,
-0.4329909086,
-0.4744746983,
-0.131722495,
-0.7575083971,
0.4207808375,
0.1764923036,
0.5847455263,
0.6238549352,
0.0310314968,
0.6607112288,
-0.8108596802,
0.808591783,
-0.1959689111,
-0.5581429005,
0.8485021591,
-0.1803187579,
0.2205354869,
0.3127099872,
0.5459359288,
-0.2757835388,
-0.5425063372,
-0.2236580402,
-0.9490702152,
0.5382713079,
0.4644482434,
-0.1273082197,
-0.0817069784,
0.2008988559,
0.3541811705,
0.1751298457,
-0.4328999519,
-0.2208268642,
-0.19901748,
-0.3372502327,
0.2548150122,
-0.2306540012,
-0.0995978117,
-0.2245174944,
0.4536219537,
0.3135314286,
0.5931869149,
0.319514811,
-0.3960968852,
-0.1474274248,
0.2201547772,
0.4618440866,
0.5960909128,
-0.3627883792,
0.174041912,
0.1268653125,
-0.558077991,
0.2177993357,
0.5008685589,
-0.2121857554,
0.3252130151,
0.609344244,
0.3777710199,
0.6051769257,
-0.2954677939,
0.5045206547,
0.1144492775,
0.1039028168,
-0.2924869955,
0.1065641567,
-0.3476374149,
0.3523570001,
0.6326334476,
0.0089717805,
0.2909818888,
-0.083067663,
0.4241479039,
0.4874088168,
-0.1087922677,
-0.25274086,
0.5059396029,
0.1419091672,
-0.6927106977,
0.4999584854,
-0.0102517037,
-0.8098418713,
0.8759720325,
0.4810528159,
0.9511967301,
-0.7972435355,
0.1454841793,
0.6164512634,
0.6347643137,
0.2196527272,
0.4282977879,
-0.2476783097,
-0.636087954,
-0.0045155808,
-0.5879232287,
-0.456712842,
0.3377464712,
-0.7216271162,
0.0666474104,
-0.6581625342,
-0.1507226527,
0.0080816681,
-0.3165704906,
-0.9283271432,
0.2827037275,
0.4546737373,
0.8188368082,
-0.5187748075,
0.7283068895,
0.7604931593,
0.1967306286,
-0.2607525289,
0.0426894389,
0.0524953082,
-0.3445274234,
0.3747357428,
0.4400455356,
0.0498389751,
0.1353140175,
-0.8135237098,
-1.2559775114,
0.8722758293,
0.2368020415,
-0.6855999827,
-0.0986366272,
0.2896314859,
0.5611668229,
-0.1303104907,
0.3026654124,
0.3765827715,
0.1843673587,
-0.1819711775,
-1.1538211107,
0.1150712594,
0.135014683,
-0.0737265199,
0.3009734154,
-0.7001788616,
0.648121655,
-0.2988731265,
-0.1825755984,
0.0952854678,
0.2890341878,
0.1178351343,
0.2270921171,
0.312114954,
0.5796484351,
0.7975375652,
-0.3469540179,
0.6972630024,
-0.3489489853,
0.8699876666,
0.9613005519,
-0.2038351595,
0.9989029765,
0.1160264537,
0.0069962777,
0.5401920676,
0.7985452414,
-0.0584465154,
1.2599906921,
-0.0434124097,
-0.1213225573,
-0.2374177724,
0.2465348393,
-0.1878198236,
0.5823327899,
0.6263628602,
-0.3176100254,
-0.8534395099,
0.3072277904,
-0.1534717977,
-0.5683972239,
-0.1866074055,
0.7103758454,
-0.3534164727,
-0.3403361738,
0.4789417386,
-0.1028327122,
0.3697285056,
-0.7103466988,
-0.1860619038,
-0.2117801607,
0.229898572,
-0.0499718636,
-0.4056437016,
0.0935651511,
0.0810197592,
-0.1171437502,
-0.0963619947,
0.9646926522,
-0.5260474086,
-0.3930498362,
0.4332706332,
0.4398480654,
0.2490039915,
0.1092912778,
-0.5824073553,
-0.1373399645,
-0.3282238841,
-0.3105608225,
0.1237453669,
0.5608634353,
-0.0233019032,
0.3668994606,
0.9072991014,
0.1111660376,
0.141815573,
-0.0480690971,
0.7792360187,
-0.819662869,
-0.6509211063,
-0.8611044288,
0.5079115033,
-0.1624686718,
-0.5808036923,
0.3607043922,
0.6196885705,
0.8698821664,
0.0040352568,
0.6160764098,
-0.0076889382,
0.6000471711,
-0.2654453814,
0.8521367908,
-0.1471852064,
0.0068331151,
-0.2751902342,
-0.882930994,
-0.395671159,
0.8104337454,
0.0759052187,
-0.4177843332,
0.484215945,
0.5637824535,
-0.4859923422,
-0.1878544986,
0.4001457393,
0.1502384096,
0.0905301496,
0.3788372874,
0.6599148512,
-0.4298934042,
0.3483718038,
-0.4721602499,
-0.4424497783,
-0.450583607,
-0.7689530253,
-0.9456392527,
-0.2740135491,
-0.3382337391,
0.0767143443,
0.1942020208,
1.026025176,
1.10523808,
-0.9344442487,
0.0891603529,
0.1040872112,
-0.0386291631,
-0.1815834492,
-0.2416724116,
0.6133974791,
-0.0097712884,
-0.4427444041,
0.3217539787,
0.4502594769,
0.0284322761,
-0.1813356876,
0.1908700466,
-0.2302892506,
0.3755308092,
0.8540693521,
0.1580420285,
-0.9244100451,
-0.6116434336,
-0.1383247524,
-0.2124895155,
0.1742127836,
0.6905643344,
-0.8593190908,
0.4447613657,
0.2766903341,
0.9461854696,
0.1672397554,
0.3919484615,
0.063858673,
-1.0538380146,
0.2831240594,
0.0119395433,
0.3097284138,
0.4520616829,
-0.9198947549,
0.4178985357,
0.1132081002,
-0.6441316605,
-0.5451897979,
-0.1933662593,
-0.8724268079,
0.041318737,
1.0258879662,
-0.4695406556,
0.1309129447,
-0.3672439754,
-0.4018735588,
0.2321245372,
-0.1463238448,
0.9087792039,
0.9251794815,
-0.1314680427,
-0.171844542,
-0.6305457354,
0.4382023811,
0.173300311,
-0.8882384896,
-0.0821203366,
0.4601536095,
0.5541430712,
0.276615113,
0.5778746605,
0.2259762287,
0.4109262526,
-0.4205766916,
-0.05208195,
-0.0261929799,
-0.551025331,
0.010979943,
0.4596644342,
-0.4103117287,
-0.608445704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13479v1 | Archive TimeLine Summarization (ATLS): Conceptual Framework for Timeline Generation over Historical Document Collections | 2023-01-31T08:58:47 | 2023-01-31T08:58:47 | Nicolas Gutehrlé, Antoine Doucet, Adam Jatowt | cs.CL | cs.CL | Archive collections are nowadays mostly available through search engines
interfaces, which allow a user to retrieve documents by issuing queries. The
study of these collections may be, however, impaired by some aspects of search
engines, such as the overwhelming number of documents returned or the lack of
contextual knowledge provided. New methods that could work independently or in
combination with search engines are then required to access these collections.
In this position paper, we propose to extend TimeLine Summarization (TLS)
methods on archive collections to assist in their studies. We provide an
overview of existing TLS methods and we describe a conceptual framework for an
Archive TimeLine Summarization (ATLS) system, which aims to generate
informative, readable and interpretable timelines. | [
-0.1564989835,
-0.3819008768,
0.5051119328,
-0.1081203893,
-0.2646970749,
0.3308979571,
0.5150468946,
-0.3500650823,
0.6036105156,
0.3210173547,
-0.7937424779,
-0.2310369313,
-0.3887993693,
0.1068160981,
-1.1105755568,
0.9611309171,
-0.0870771855,
-0.4444328249,
-0.0828417316,
0.0327499025,
-0.227039516,
-0.3801349401,
-0.7265321612,
-0.2286201864,
0.1942561418,
0.1675164551,
0.584366262,
1.0179414749,
0.1872856319,
0.2316654921,
-0.3439835012,
0.3909251988,
-0.5502345562,
0.4156104624,
-0.1171411425,
-0.3657214344,
-0.7367359996,
-0.3448859453,
0.9230416417,
0.7425952554,
-0.0438705496,
0.4586077034,
-0.1377303004,
0.7289711237,
-0.8665957451,
-0.1570690572,
-0.1722243726,
0.4333636165,
-0.6312321424,
-0.9968168139,
-0.150391683,
-0.6215543747,
0.0648830608,
-0.7572392821,
0.3469849527,
-0.0784168914,
0.54537642,
-0.0259414837,
-0.4664902687,
-0.4315204322,
-0.8086400628,
0.7571164966,
-0.4927102625,
0.5360258818,
0.4886678755,
0.6040853858,
0.1147647649,
-1.1254092455,
0.0712679997,
0.3658229113,
-0.2214547098,
0.1237325668,
-0.1881117523,
-0.6318637729,
0.2448097169,
0.3982174098,
-0.6509469748,
-0.1204876974,
-0.624527812,
-0.1139778793,
0.5268953443,
0.7066391706,
0.1074904948,
-0.3005731404,
-0.1329213828,
0.0843092874,
-1.0944985151,
-0.104673788,
0.2821524143,
-0.1326715648,
-0.1507107466,
0.7164256573,
-0.3204524219,
0.3753232062,
-0.0093300799,
-0.1482264102,
0.1826464385,
-0.5766503215,
-0.1780409217,
-0.0232091546,
0.2974545956,
0.280585289,
-0.0886576474,
-0.294467926,
-0.2516723871,
-0.2430682182,
0.1548277289,
-0.8556252122,
0.2905976772,
0.3166964054,
-0.7483658791,
-0.4893295169,
0.0520113558,
-0.91343081,
-0.2380467206,
-0.2842622101,
-0.0886902362,
-0.1680656523,
0.0360767543,
-0.4001792371,
-0.6905422211,
-0.0710679665,
0.3634675741,
-0.5801294446,
0.3247830868,
0.5168297291,
1.051281333,
0.1132980809,
-0.1955209225,
-0.8846536279,
0.7721610665,
-0.2325945199,
0.7981513739,
-0.3632495999,
-0.825733304,
0.460236907,
-0.0599366315,
0.3917292953,
0.0405234322,
0.2504763305,
-0.9276546836,
0.4461792111,
-0.1590420902,
-0.7378456593,
0.1173823774,
0.1935607046,
-0.7122353315,
0.6088120341,
-0.3188652992,
-0.7082211375,
0.2867694199,
-0.8341032267,
-0.6034129262,
0.1096247956,
-0.3524575233,
-0.1679356694,
0.0279282257,
0.3662653267,
0.3377803266,
-0.1876303107,
0.5840559602,
-0.2441643178,
-0.195490405,
0.0714877397,
-0.2507166266,
1.0655993223,
0.625967741,
-0.1013415977,
0.0394321568,
-0.5786293745,
-0.1263267249,
-0.0543088801,
-0.2596967518,
-0.1005785316,
0.5713369846,
-0.0016570905,
-0.1412158608,
0.3517982364,
-0.0044545308,
0.160285905,
-0.4675379992,
0.4899518192,
0.5285286307,
0.3115743995,
0.3768617511,
-0.5856859088,
0.6167581081,
-0.2257262021,
0.1729844809,
-0.8679382205,
-0.1275403649,
-0.3715410233,
0.4006659091,
-0.2876242995,
0.365033865,
-0.7773692608,
0.3047457039,
-0.8231098056,
-0.3870705962,
0.2601786852,
0.0147380168,
0.435978651,
0.5130679607,
0.1880060136,
-0.4334284961,
-0.9323911071,
-0.6812733412,
0.0646309704,
-0.5436124802,
-0.4950392842,
0.1415784657,
0.508529067,
0.3132874072,
1.1460386515,
-0.7439182401,
-0.1413169205,
0.1127102599,
0.4437130094,
0.0837023109,
0.0918522775,
0.4671840072,
-1.154558301,
0.04622842,
-0.3181190789,
-1.0384069681,
0.0262803808,
0.0695960969,
0.1785959303,
0.2684406638,
0.8809312582,
-0.10627909,
0.5911252499,
-0.01926337,
-0.5482259393,
0.4885854423,
-0.1400352418,
0.398461014,
-1.2352925539,
0.3297655582,
-0.4147324562,
-0.3350672126,
-0.6236155033,
-0.1439407617,
0.0349622779,
-0.4998465478,
-0.5212842226,
0.626390636,
-0.5903488398,
-0.4863342643,
-0.2595944703,
0.4517472982,
0.2072700113,
-0.0904408321,
0.2196325809,
0.7358055711,
0.2328621298,
-0.5106003881,
0.3060076535,
0.5532333255,
0.049040664,
0.5171982646,
-0.4334027469,
-0.2065037042,
-0.2307804376,
0.6373819113,
-0.5534107685,
-0.2085965127,
-0.0983313918,
-0.6023712158,
0.2818206251,
0.1640443206,
-0.4873790145,
-0.3676636219,
-0.7893884778,
0.1644223332,
0.4965075254,
-0.6142566204,
0.7349531054,
0.4143856168,
-0.0427889898,
-0.7812904119,
-0.6136666536,
0.2573268116,
-0.5077901483,
-0.8182509542,
0.4333485365,
-0.1818239391,
-0.5059627295,
0.303009212,
-0.170179978,
-0.2831509411,
0.050822679,
0.192622751,
0.2332718372,
-0.2721801698,
0.170136109,
0.0551452525,
0.059289068,
-0.2316209525,
-0.5225869417,
0.3079701066,
0.013052539,
-0.2595285177,
-0.062778309,
0.5747810602,
0.5294959545,
-0.1923137009,
0.5732764006,
0.2630946636,
-0.660510242,
0.2670711875,
-0.631413281,
-0.159531936,
-0.4304636419,
-0.0479158908,
-0.2246219814,
-0.7200183868,
0.7780181766,
0.1538674235,
0.3077986538,
0.7518794537,
0.4873350263,
-0.1777505577,
0.5566250682,
0.3511680961,
-0.3309631944,
0.6946922541,
-0.1005056053,
-0.242027849,
-0.7533575892,
-0.1325788796,
-0.6461837292,
-0.0502985902,
-0.125051111,
0.1258680671,
0.2884245813,
0.2044678181,
-0.5053808689,
0.2773089111,
-0.0815259963,
0.3521198928,
0.2767192721,
0.1027444527,
0.6880528927,
0.0710032433,
0.4324128926,
0.1888440698,
-0.4732511044,
-0.5880300999,
1.2974572182,
0.0718546957,
0.4893447757,
0.5524486899,
0.6054221392,
0.8228490353,
-0.0091759274,
-0.1204015836,
0.4203970134,
-0.2787680328,
-0.7461048365,
-0.5446924567,
-0.020075798,
-1.0125240088,
-0.1932289749,
-0.0523965396,
-0.9366101623,
0.3476490378,
0.3425002992,
-0.2877943218,
0.2288760692,
-0.2508436739,
0.3434279859,
-0.0380316451,
-0.3675945103,
-0.2663925588,
-1.0264055729,
0.1773597002,
-0.2543683052,
0.3029560745,
0.4661298096,
-0.3137883842,
0.8357226253,
-0.4876835942,
0.89103508,
0.1261345744,
0.3068977594,
0.1856568456,
0.0863590017,
0.7354721427,
0.0995564833,
-0.0244176667,
-0.3260888457,
-0.1909681261,
-0.0856595412,
-0.5274718404,
0.6175967455,
-0.3372473717,
-0.441015631,
-0.1284015179,
-0.6287770271,
0.1627845764,
0.4209798574,
0.3402894735,
1.0869327784,
-0.3954918683,
0.1872435808,
0.5552999377,
0.2119374871,
0.6503269672,
0.5981137753,
-0.0849203467,
0.0701003224,
0.5522208214,
0.2764798999,
-0.1128682047,
0.729434073,
0.099782005,
-0.3764304221,
-0.6813063025,
-0.4613382816,
-0.0686895922,
-0.9914858937,
-0.2283532917,
-0.4615985155,
-0.0861918032,
-0.7174657583,
-0.6658158898,
-0.0926225036,
-0.8184484839,
-0.627327919,
0.1124468446,
0.2478189766,
0.6698473692,
0.1642299592,
0.2404076457,
-0.9912941456,
0.1862229705,
-0.2642185688,
0.2827077508,
0.0756169632,
-0.4346571863,
-0.2755132914,
-0.4125745296,
-0.5183454156,
-1.103284955,
0.3185817897,
0.170352295,
0.4549150765,
0.572000742,
0.1031740308,
0.7544472814,
-0.6747524142,
1.0355188847,
-0.0525416471,
-0.9001742005,
0.9102131724,
-0.6112071872,
0.3293961883,
0.1067437083,
0.4336336851,
-0.4138961434,
-0.4964566529,
-1.1032363176,
-0.960314393,
0.5979970694,
0.5563526154,
-0.3653260767,
0.1731907874,
0.2631661892,
-0.0802590176,
0.2431698143,
-0.2784569561,
-0.2460193932,
-0.2914883196,
0.103195928,
-0.1059430763,
-0.3920239508,
-0.3642790318,
0.4699790478,
0.8864240646,
0.1221019626,
0.0711915419,
0.0079311626,
-0.2808258832,
-0.2994410396,
0.3828640282,
0.6425568461,
1.2467752695,
-0.3961553276,
-0.0243098196,
0.2122084647,
-0.2761464417,
-0.1877011508,
0.2065474093,
-0.3693839014,
-0.022802731,
0.7447088361,
0.6005136967,
0.0960164145,
-0.5147898793,
0.3746529818,
0.1397201568,
0.0699981898,
-0.9473282099,
-0.3044817448,
0.1432249248,
0.6363939047,
0.7356994748,
-0.4820129871,
0.4865548015,
-0.3758302927,
0.4679255784,
0.2135550827,
0.0101737762,
-0.1981629729,
0.8429139853,
0.1385889202,
-0.3856449723,
0.5825001001,
0.1383606791,
-0.1025568023,
0.6022940278,
0.6500800848,
0.968252182,
-0.2061991096,
-0.2205406874,
0.2702374756,
0.1040743887,
-0.2860676944,
-0.123589009,
-0.1584493369,
-0.2315063477,
-0.2178926319,
-0.2481961846,
-0.2668882012,
-0.0619028434,
-0.8197906613,
0.3466788232,
0.1332309991,
0.1019154042,
0.0258654337,
-0.0631786436,
-0.4101063907,
0.189490959,
-0.0372948833,
1.2315795422,
-0.9449775219,
0.6673073173,
0.5414655805,
-0.4773108065,
-0.2951783538,
-0.157988891,
0.7029413581,
-0.6064690351,
0.8619629741,
-0.45388937,
-0.2025870532,
0.0015503126,
-0.1341966689,
-0.8616066575,
1.6835700274,
-0.1111540198,
-0.3293192387,
-0.4809001386,
-0.3333418369,
0.467638433,
-0.4956980944,
0.2761827707,
0.3888447583,
0.323794961,
0.3141450882,
-0.6104490757,
0.0925598517,
-0.504447639,
0.0031578962,
0.4396311045,
-0.0341223031,
0.6481953263,
0.1968350559,
-0.6044043899,
0.2998327315,
0.7921616435,
0.2553435266,
0.5871655345,
0.2528320253,
0.1922588795,
0.5420354605,
0.010166022,
1.340955615,
-0.0208027568,
0.209577769,
1.3223547935,
0.1426934004,
0.6649445891,
0.5919967294,
-0.1596678048,
-0.0205237381,
0.5694605708,
0.0035866743,
0.418518573,
-0.1563678384,
-0.153721258,
0.1745709479,
-0.2509682775,
-0.6237316728,
-0.2760796547,
0.4811728895,
-0.4737469852,
-0.6937760115,
-0.1913315952,
0.1409107894,
-0.004058253,
-0.4030421972,
0.5853337049,
-0.1152682826,
-0.4310227931,
0.0184242148,
-0.3351964653,
0.2123044133,
-0.8392504454,
0.1178058833,
-0.350489974,
-0.1328269988,
-0.3628614843,
-0.9083842635,
0.7992358208,
0.171137169,
-0.4053922296,
-0.2432258129,
0.7991142869,
-0.1313279718,
-0.2538822889,
0.0425001159,
0.609873116,
0.2701377273,
0.53703475,
-0.2241145819,
0.1546661556,
-0.0331031643,
-0.6056771278,
0.0938146487,
0.1567545682,
-0.6344489455,
0.7124532461,
0.3802068233,
0.1027589664,
0.033500772,
-0.0068224906,
0.9010666609,
-0.5288648009,
-0.8108922839,
-0.8201402426,
0.6792396307,
-0.2312147766,
-0.0763425604,
0.6820226312,
0.7247841358,
0.6960501671,
0.1444087476,
0.6922329068,
-0.2301193625,
0.6399317384,
-0.6178785563,
0.4806337357,
-1.0375795364,
0.5753237605,
-0.1953168064,
-0.8022081256,
-0.4518919885,
0.0700904205,
0.0152252913,
-0.237057209,
0.7421723604,
0.3120134175,
0.0615728311,
0.3752032518,
-0.1510844231,
-0.0940282568,
0.6955251098,
0.2477413863,
0.5168985128,
-0.3027341068,
0.7170287371,
-0.0222550947,
-0.0816636682,
-0.2523960769,
-1.2532799244,
-0.6672173142,
-0.8248372078,
0.1225623935,
-0.3064156473,
0.572805047,
0.449919045,
0.3896913826,
-0.4862785935,
-0.5158439875,
0.2172344923,
-0.0669238195,
-0.051606521,
-0.146772638,
0.9663898349,
-0.1747224182,
-0.6216709614,
0.5676256418,
0.2167489827,
0.0791057423,
-0.1145090908,
-0.106980674,
-0.0518619195,
-0.343244642,
0.5183600187,
0.7026832104,
-0.5772967339,
-0.1971098036,
-0.0508805551,
0.2810133994,
0.0208160561,
1.1729044914,
-0.6995774508,
0.4281332195,
0.7602292895,
0.4326865673,
0.8986759186,
0.1626463085,
0.7601630092,
-1.0084044933,
0.1355405897,
0.0269920006,
0.5873891711,
-0.0069722524,
-0.567855835,
0.6765861511,
0.1122138947,
-0.2687445581,
-0.8000122309,
0.4789601564,
-0.8349646926,
-0.4111996889,
0.6331877112,
0.031932734,
0.1852937192,
-0.2373219728,
0.583089292,
0.4407752156,
-0.4141832292,
0.6209976673,
0.5461572409,
-0.2094422132,
0.0466972776,
-0.5926705003,
0.2502173781,
-0.0023463671,
-0.9531347156,
-0.0875723809,
0.8259339929,
-0.0558520369,
0.5670719147,
1.0128743649,
-0.5810599923,
0.4017601609,
-0.1006744355,
-0.3675214946,
-0.4013087153,
-0.3833023608,
-0.0977181345,
0.3673099279,
-0.282469362,
0.2016260028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13455v1 | ZhichunRoad at Amazon KDD Cup 2022: MultiTask Pre-Training for E-Commerce Product Search | 2023-01-31T07:31:34 | 2023-01-31T07:31:34 | Xuange Cui, Wei Xiong, Songlin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a robust multilingual model to improve the quality
of search results. Our model not only leverage the processed class-balanced
dataset, but also benefit from multitask pre-training that leads to more
general representations. In pre-training stage, we adopt mlm task,
classification task and contrastive learning task to achieve considerably
performance. In fine-tuning stage, we use confident learning, exponential
moving average method (EMA), adversarial training (FGM) and regularized dropout
strategy (R-Drop) to improve the model's generalization and robustness.
Moreover, we use a multi-granular semantic unit to discover the queries and
products textual metadata for enhancing the representation of the model. Our
approach obtained competitive results and ranked top-8 in three tasks. We
release the source code and pre-trained models associated with this work. | [
-0.3982547522,
-0.5572880507,
0.1584511101,
0.2539216876,
-0.5178916454,
0.2604640722,
-0.28978917,
-0.7085564137,
0.0749763325,
0.2050228417,
-0.954140842,
-0.6528856754,
-0.549182415,
0.1085512787,
-0.0983034223,
0.9952374697,
0.0170125682,
0.0549824238,
-0.1303979158,
-0.1152874902,
-0.1490849853,
-0.5996421576,
-0.6039279699,
-0.0198452938,
0.4658075869,
0.2915793955,
0.5618568659,
0.2826726139,
0.5176609755,
0.3615402281,
0.1633584648,
0.2573426962,
-0.5949087143,
0.4022220075,
-0.0908333734,
-0.5960304737,
-0.6968383193,
0.1470009536,
0.0664782152,
0.4159635603,
-0.5282149315,
0.0885344073,
0.2832571864,
0.409837395,
-0.6684962511,
0.3542185426,
-0.6782739758,
0.0955388919,
-0.2585687637,
-0.1740015,
-0.4426887929,
-0.0865764916,
-0.1288808882,
-1.2306730747,
0.4258573949,
0.1291768551,
1.3011885881,
0.3462074101,
-0.3022653162,
-0.3965336084,
-0.6799834371,
1.005599618,
-0.7256662846,
0.6865835786,
0.5227046609,
0.3844424188,
0.0029129321,
-0.7318704128,
-0.6243728995,
-0.0564066581,
0.0796970055,
0.4110946059,
0.3769100904,
0.1342743039,
-0.0856091827,
0.3645485938,
-0.685761869,
0.2417061031,
-0.1515903622,
-0.0333963558,
0.8020537496,
0.1447438002,
0.2107144147,
0.2142730951,
-0.3091532886,
-0.2577911615,
-0.2918519676,
0.388974458,
0.5413166881,
0.49467659,
0.1670705974,
0.2343889922,
-0.8793660998,
0.6902248859,
0.1575980932,
-0.4716581106,
0.4379304945,
-0.7723215222,
-0.1312590688,
-0.1463268399,
0.5389419198,
0.3744635582,
-0.1052019224,
-0.2177653611,
-0.2098209709,
-0.0768094957,
0.5980954766,
-0.9305372238,
-0.341730237,
0.3995635509,
-0.8574263453,
-0.347268343,
0.1422976255,
-0.689684093,
0.2143324316,
-0.3345226049,
0.4071650803,
-0.1539433599,
-0.2111194432,
0.3673143387,
0.1217818409,
0.0563296452,
0.1779480875,
-0.8360677958,
0.1779151261,
0.5648636818,
0.5775102973,
0.0065774238,
-0.4543738663,
-0.383117348,
0.2406746149,
-0.3106178641,
0.8876695037,
-0.3620499074,
-0.1439061016,
0.0623570159,
0.3569634557,
-0.0904434696,
-0.5184105635,
0.834928453,
-1.0122354031,
-0.0686051324,
-0.2425696254,
-0.4376603961,
-0.5208980441,
0.4604083598,
-0.7495123148,
0.8566175699,
-0.1517186463,
-0.4861311615,
0.7447277904,
-0.5409625173,
-0.6231883764,
0.3242050707,
0.1348805428,
-0.8379043937,
-0.1622498184,
0.3965570927,
0.6946553588,
-0.0018364332,
-0.037350148,
-0.734565258,
-0.3065378964,
-0.2054329067,
0.1241003498,
0.6482286453,
0.3841070235,
-0.3425368071,
0.0908197463,
-0.7006517649,
0.3308744133,
0.2800081372,
-0.4838209152,
-0.1434022486,
-0.1038100049,
0.4078098536,
0.5089920759,
0.3526348174,
-0.4903153479,
0.1425172389,
-0.1667268276,
0.255363673,
0.5859287381,
-0.3974573612,
0.2104672045,
-0.0588072836,
0.8001723289,
-0.0427619889,
0.556868732,
-0.1261709034,
-0.4728785455,
-0.4227850437,
-0.179447487,
0.6362369657,
0.4887753427,
-0.751421392,
0.5224890709,
-0.2406265438,
-0.5887092352,
-0.5110615492,
0.2897573411,
0.2518764436,
0.2279507369,
0.29619959,
-0.418528229,
-0.3308150172,
-0.8032742739,
-0.1356332749,
0.345584482,
-0.0113087827,
0.2947503626,
0.1998686641,
-0.3510943353,
0.4176623225,
-0.7379131317,
-0.7859426141,
-0.4137541652,
0.3950403333,
0.1859625876,
0.346375674,
0.544198513,
-1.0358108282,
-0.7720812559,
0.0972042158,
-0.6618496776,
0.1813380569,
0.3470469713,
-0.2683162689,
0.2597259581,
0.4477038682,
-0.6369405985,
0.3589071929,
0.4604372382,
-0.0069632237,
0.6438019872,
-0.3189697564,
0.5192566514,
-1.1584026814,
0.010968443,
0.1330629587,
-0.0651167557,
-0.3682461381,
0.3184615672,
0.1632330269,
-0.2046748847,
-0.5075728893,
-0.0397991538,
-0.1499510258,
0.1057599336,
-0.2938688695,
-0.1332197934,
0.2861587107,
0.5709207654,
0.0651787743,
0.7627217174,
0.3852883875,
-1.0333425999,
0.3915503323,
0.2398611903,
-0.4815944433,
0.489474982,
-0.5936037302,
-0.0894699544,
-0.0028862027,
0.2755679488,
-0.8055848479,
-0.2423179895,
-0.003326047,
-0.2841833532,
0.3187151849,
0.0598104969,
-0.8861653805,
-0.5599068999,
-0.3715823889,
0.5607992411,
0.0983829498,
-0.6127764583,
0.4088423252,
0.3796052039,
-0.2844704688,
-0.4291772842,
-0.3435989618,
-0.2608182132,
-0.1999078393,
-0.8367844224,
0.7993841767,
-0.3778616786,
0.388412714,
-0.3056361377,
0.0416228548,
-0.2652229369,
0.231222257,
-0.2649205923,
0.0446776003,
-0.1516337693,
0.0452299416,
-0.0541109554,
-0.1797014922,
-0.282851994,
-0.1858772933,
0.6907291412,
0.0527080894,
-0.1516683549,
-0.6487175226,
0.2454509586,
0.1924806237,
-0.4193290472,
0.7155678272,
0.8299961686,
-0.3416766226,
-0.3399117291,
-0.1980277002,
-0.2977599204,
-0.5141345859,
0.6522911191,
-0.417755425,
-0.6358758807,
0.4723786414,
-0.1293322593,
-0.3020394444,
0.3412933648,
0.5516063571,
-0.1765010506,
1.5524190664,
0.800419569,
0.0866256207,
0.2545861006,
-0.2006666362,
0.7657676339,
-0.4835913181,
-0.582888186,
-0.5971317887,
-0.2942637801,
-0.7018002868,
-0.0284888651,
0.179952234,
0.3931928873,
-0.1662892997,
0.3056490123,
-0.5567052364,
0.3696856797,
0.884726584,
0.4037536979,
0.0800493434,
0.0047397949,
-0.0843413323,
-0.1992162168,
-0.5758523345,
-0.099343203,
1.3053663969,
0.0198328216,
0.5466555357,
0.0270274729,
0.4197745025,
0.145135656,
-0.2810406387,
-0.6985470057,
0.1755638272,
-0.3723027408,
-0.6300794482,
-0.2222992629,
-0.1475870162,
-0.8326846957,
0.1830209643,
0.0473476127,
-0.3278097808,
0.059760347,
0.0777709559,
-0.8377827406,
0.1019711643,
-0.4913157225,
1.0788549185,
-0.6945869923,
-0.4834243953,
-0.2551178038,
-0.5013515949,
0.1729383469,
-0.0206463691,
0.3285738826,
0.0538725294,
0.0811173171,
0.7852084637,
-0.2690888643,
0.3207625151,
0.0320593789,
-0.0675584227,
-0.0796427429,
-0.0847771093,
0.5416356921,
-0.0414266735,
0.1692546159,
-0.014528702,
-0.0894949883,
-0.7788758278,
-0.6067244411,
0.3589977622,
-0.5475399494,
-0.3622310758,
-0.3262064755,
-0.3319829702,
-0.273914963,
0.4127467275,
0.4340912402,
0.0339349508,
-0.1444413662,
0.3723543584,
0.5928436518,
-0.2530905604,
0.3802929819,
0.3999131322,
-0.1811001003,
-0.2800939977,
1.2217149734,
0.1033405289,
-0.0379920378,
0.3794647455,
0.0412808657,
-0.5005916953,
-0.7120303512,
-0.2835846841,
-0.0754325315,
-0.7219193578,
-0.2222342491,
-0.8220546842,
-0.2192155719,
-0.5809184313,
0.0829729214,
-0.4856897295,
-0.0386454239,
-0.1265112013,
-0.168329522,
0.0150491977,
0.7270684242,
0.026230989,
0.5854583383,
-0.7430719137,
0.4050546587,
0.4889988899,
0.588431716,
0.1755545139,
-0.1355833262,
-0.8126304746,
0.1094557792,
-0.5586816072,
-0.2918085754,
0.5653285384,
0.3951102197,
0.6616398096,
0.7465218902,
-0.0151409609,
0.7365219593,
-0.1854901761,
0.8634409308,
0.0552347563,
-0.6275401711,
0.5391533375,
-0.6246259809,
0.1907607466,
0.664750278,
0.7777887583,
-0.1561453193,
0.0021421255,
-0.4932629168,
-1.0758886337,
0.9484103918,
0.0917290673,
-0.1814420074,
0.3069987297,
-0.039114397,
0.395928055,
0.7906123996,
-0.7112765312,
-0.1893794835,
-0.4109449387,
-0.1651214361,
-0.2298803777,
-0.2558428049,
0.2863869667,
-0.5435169339,
1.0021569729,
-0.0933569521,
-0.1111723632,
-0.4140003026,
-0.1764460057,
0.3125545681,
-0.023937216,
0.69324404,
0.6294531226,
-0.2722700834,
-0.1830186397,
-0.395986259,
-0.5842400789,
-0.0884729251,
0.2651688159,
0.0024062027,
-0.2507748008,
0.0859317482,
0.4771246016,
0.3269753158,
-0.5927776098,
0.3404598236,
-0.1846595556,
-0.1632081717,
-0.043751739,
-0.2607641518,
0.1277741045,
0.1282626241,
0.4322152138,
0.0054482115,
0.5831472874,
-0.4139341414,
0.3352409601,
0.2985443771,
-0.0018460773,
-0.4175613821,
0.8494293094,
0.1850787401,
-0.055969581,
0.6487928033,
-0.5832737684,
-0.9530228376,
0.600761354,
0.3612859547,
0.6540805697,
-0.61951226,
0.4300197363,
0.4194712639,
0.160878405,
-0.305942297,
0.3149886429,
-0.1758088022,
-0.7071899176,
-0.1491637528,
-0.6973755956,
-0.1692695767,
0.3302604258,
-0.6327502131,
0.3472002149,
-0.1693968624,
-0.1327056885,
0.0490676835,
0.4278351367,
-1.095962882,
0.6018838286,
-0.1661069542,
0.1037443057,
-0.5609900951,
0.7735846043,
0.456228137,
-0.7320654988,
-0.5486809611,
-0.0369764976,
-0.3264094293,
-0.4587124586,
0.7070142627,
0.4487482905,
0.0121366726,
-0.1990709603,
-0.517023623,
-0.9297171235,
1.062564373,
0.153544426,
-0.6301289201,
0.0319177769,
0.2026094943,
0.2907791734,
-0.4250861406,
0.1531599909,
0.2746706307,
0.2737666965,
-0.0502398759,
-0.9377301335,
-0.352970928,
-0.4350640476,
0.0007127235,
-0.0880432501,
-0.6964223981,
1.1322368383,
0.0758282691,
-0.103193745,
0.1120878756,
0.3348982334,
0.2702943981,
0.6311992407,
0.229476735,
0.9495918751,
0.7927857041,
0.1605471522,
1.0140522718,
-0.4297309518,
0.469943285,
1.1336320639,
-0.499440968,
0.9925379753,
0.0399331488,
-0.3433160186,
0.3694747984,
1.1332865953,
-0.0088403542,
1.028157711,
-0.0243506506,
-0.1027417481,
-0.5622974634,
-0.0098134987,
-0.4679331183,
0.5041536689,
0.1281112134,
-0.2712596059,
-0.2524983883,
0.2018477619,
-0.2821308374,
0.0143341925,
-0.231662482,
0.7206788063,
-0.0888017043,
-0.4220512211,
0.5547424555,
0.1225682274,
0.9952703714,
-0.4988993406,
0.1446031481,
0.0595858023,
0.5662451386,
-0.170539096,
-0.2026360184,
0.0254693907,
-0.6843825579,
-0.5117515326,
-0.0957330465,
0.6226019263,
-0.3500490487,
-0.9568331838,
0.5900526047,
0.3295932412,
-0.0110023851,
-0.543328464,
-0.9209529757,
0.174888134,
-0.1594160795,
-0.1734718978,
0.5003936291,
0.4273388088,
0.2003745139,
0.5632727742,
0.6478803158,
-0.1453252137,
0.363176167,
0.082949236,
0.4800484478,
-0.4073048234,
-0.9557111263,
-0.3974969387,
0.1110608801,
-0.2692908049,
-0.1828588992,
0.8706375957,
0.8393654227,
1.4024772644,
-0.2507058382,
0.8015208244,
0.366183877,
0.4283263683,
-0.4342534244,
1.1235231161,
-0.7928490043,
-0.2187775671,
-0.1776051074,
-0.8860384822,
-0.134951517,
0.6287715435,
0.1580544114,
0.3950708807,
0.6462876201,
0.7087603211,
-0.3139464259,
0.1201904789,
0.4772740304,
0.173639819,
0.0820391327,
0.3508326709,
0.3316499293,
-0.7532877922,
0.4977968633,
-0.5492240787,
-0.1289100945,
-0.4115108252,
-0.6125386953,
-0.5603820682,
-0.7973363996,
-0.4337810576,
-0.1414014846,
0.0914568901,
0.6854797602,
1.0556844473,
-0.8486209512,
-0.2813344598,
0.1087512672,
-0.0847924277,
-0.7107588649,
-0.2062292844,
0.3406876922,
-0.7566658258,
-0.8235483766,
0.2603251338,
0.016037561,
-0.1432941556,
-0.0728071705,
-0.1064615101,
-0.4253090918,
-0.2265055925,
0.8956955671,
-0.1717105955,
-0.5128245354,
0.3215755224,
0.1529645473,
0.3307934105,
0.1894462258,
0.6189491749,
-0.5454382896,
0.5091617703,
0.3221515715,
0.5245497823,
0.5328745842,
0.0776168108,
0.6621387601,
-0.5354827642,
0.3959201872,
0.2113920599,
0.1421025246,
0.1788273007,
-0.4461219013,
0.3026967645,
0.0861410722,
-0.5905640125,
-0.6870155334,
0.1355038881,
-0.8211942315,
-0.5001689792,
0.8011925817,
-0.1863318384,
-0.3383684456,
-0.4673691094,
0.146816358,
0.3008741438,
-0.3331936896,
1.2758878469,
0.9805417657,
0.1339516491,
0.0186250601,
-0.6595957875,
0.7690283656,
0.3761998713,
-0.7006523609,
-0.3048174381,
0.028791381,
0.122481361,
0.1604348421,
0.4702309668,
0.0523133315,
0.3722697496,
-0.0877248421,
0.2405014038,
-0.0671565235,
-0.5067562461,
0.0303623024,
0.5158174038,
0.0755262077,
-0.5471021533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13382v1 | Numeracy from Literacy: Data Science as an Emergent Skill from Large Language Models | 2023-01-31T03:14:57 | 2023-01-31T03:14:57 | David Noever, Forrest McKee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLM) such as OpenAI's ChatGPT and GPT-3 offer unique
testbeds for exploring the translation challenges of turning literacy into
numeracy. Previous publicly-available transformer models from eighteen months
prior and 1000 times smaller failed to provide basic arithmetic. The
statistical analysis of four complex datasets described here combines
arithmetic manipulations that cannot be memorized or encoded by simple rules.
The work examines whether next-token prediction succeeds from sentence
completion into the realm of actual numerical understanding. For example, the
work highlights cases for descriptive statistics on in-memory datasets that the
LLM initially loads from memory or generates randomly using python libraries.
The resulting exploratory data analysis showcases the model's capabilities to
group by or pivot categorical sums, infer feature importance, derive
correlations, and predict unseen test cases using linear regression. To extend
the model's testable range, the research deletes and appends random rows such
that recall alone cannot explain emergent numeracy. | [
-0.1145274863,
-0.7572007775,
0.3956057727,
0.2004105449,
0.0751144215,
0.0954414904,
-0.1660431176,
-0.0515359119,
-0.2117563039,
0.6379635334,
-0.3904750347,
-0.3848757148,
-0.6193532944,
0.0299183223,
-0.5990355611,
1.0547711849,
0.2741353214,
0.0941301063,
-0.4418929517,
0.1435104162,
-0.3295626044,
-0.5357726216,
-0.2875674367,
-0.2911253572,
0.2109292746,
0.8706772923,
0.8442940116,
0.352137208,
0.751183629,
0.2049927264,
0.0808622837,
-0.054053653,
-0.5899496078,
-0.0561130829,
0.3533074558,
-0.7682198286,
-0.2731318772,
-0.0578132793,
0.7274260521,
1.1114515066,
0.0165861323,
0.2639923394,
0.008630245,
0.7766156793,
-0.3703335226,
0.8361304402,
-0.5759587884,
-0.0261526536,
-0.2461383194,
0.1441646516,
-0.5521255732,
-0.7521051764,
0.0533917174,
-0.483748138,
0.2946643829,
-0.0299023483,
0.2997347414,
0.3421550989,
-0.5751053095,
-0.4600563645,
-0.8692851663,
0.8891574144,
-0.5900690556,
0.2315130234,
0.6687341928,
0.2067398429,
-0.0621509589,
-0.6131538153,
-0.5935807228,
-0.0728813484,
0.0991256759,
0.0208451431,
-0.0585659705,
-0.2287838608,
0.4050264955,
0.5015664101,
-0.4790661335,
-0.1063920557,
-0.6838127375,
0.0284745377,
0.5961691141,
0.3727987409,
0.3977681398,
-0.1791530848,
0.0530020185,
-0.1112261415,
-0.8211519718,
0.0405323543,
0.3088099957,
0.3191441298,
-0.0851325989,
1.0958478451,
0.0509741493,
0.61152637,
-0.3576152027,
0.0309414733,
0.4395168722,
-0.3566197157,
0.0472458526,
0.0898242146,
0.603754282,
0.0843081847,
0.7054976225,
-0.0031701566,
-0.1796341389,
0.0907649919,
-0.0726048052,
-0.7213062644,
-0.5499913692,
0.1356591433,
-0.1651186943,
-0.5592343211,
0.1956489086,
-0.6329337955,
-0.4598567486,
-0.142597124,
0.2319953144,
-0.5553123951,
-0.3560932875,
0.2234221697,
0.024479406,
0.2516336739,
0.1252794713,
-1.1786892414,
0.2937479615,
0.8887649179,
0.9319928288,
-0.0954083949,
-0.1566563398,
-0.1322001368,
-0.0833997652,
-0.4739171565,
0.6451026201,
-0.5821288228,
-0.3461644351,
0.0337223224,
-0.2181652039,
-0.181140855,
-0.3663554788,
0.3584690988,
-0.7000641227,
0.2738138437,
-0.1729629934,
-0.4755412042,
-0.2804556787,
0.134245798,
-1.0376776457,
1.0255486965,
0.2808367014,
-0.6988633275,
0.3327135146,
-0.7567349672,
-0.3272490501,
0.2341610193,
-0.1211737096,
-0.451076448,
0.1721318513,
0.0950649828,
0.4707963765,
-0.2755402029,
0.5339955091,
-0.204148069,
-0.4702972174,
0.5016955137,
-0.8345208168,
0.8624581099,
-0.1245025024,
-0.0074933036,
-0.1415289789,
-0.734647572,
-0.0233367831,
0.1780216992,
-0.2218717933,
-0.1505045742,
0.028940849,
-0.1300261468,
0.1097517684,
0.330206871,
-0.3999880254,
0.3200920522,
-0.6423151493,
0.4688336253,
0.3806251287,
0.0715690255,
0.6644551754,
-0.3051309586,
0.4981664419,
-0.0732421055,
0.0490667485,
-0.4300480783,
-0.863797307,
-0.7158150077,
0.0640256554,
0.3814107776,
0.6966878772,
-0.9137183428,
0.2625558674,
-0.6988533139,
-0.4899963439,
-0.5399747491,
0.1627749354,
0.2019651681,
0.2995257378,
0.236516133,
0.0368876159,
-0.3592718244,
-0.5290296674,
-0.1320788711,
-0.2208190709,
-0.2143736631,
-0.0529077351,
0.7827284932,
0.0335033163,
0.7830636501,
-0.6749681234,
-0.0935278162,
-0.2836774588,
0.2569475174,
0.5836721063,
0.2323103547,
-0.0083393613,
-0.9709444046,
-0.2536485493,
0.0467937626,
-0.8342587948,
-0.002020865,
0.190121457,
0.4252736866,
0.0640866905,
0.4057719409,
-0.5437434912,
0.6404702067,
0.4603306949,
-0.3802500665,
0.5974810123,
-0.2022877634,
0.0574266911,
-0.9130970836,
-0.0455675684,
-0.1883602887,
0.2028297782,
-0.8369384408,
-0.230732426,
0.1135336235,
-0.2354766428,
-0.2095977068,
0.4778414369,
-0.4165669978,
-0.1976454854,
-0.155404225,
-0.241099596,
-0.202474311,
0.0806453377,
-0.115366824,
0.7879921198,
0.2398881763,
-0.2905420661,
0.1625831872,
0.4262315035,
-0.616283834,
0.0141216042,
-0.6825796366,
-0.0670249686,
-0.1388458908,
-0.1288567781,
-1.3225990534,
-0.5856409073,
0.0412522294,
-0.5695295334,
0.0362771899,
-0.2090644389,
-0.6703668237,
-0.4148099422,
-0.08531937,
0.3967579901,
0.6767003536,
-0.2477496862,
0.5721491575,
0.4601554275,
-0.6245878339,
-0.5777760148,
-0.7330906987,
-0.0725789815,
-0.2247277945,
-0.6248822808,
-0.164368242,
-0.0409557931,
-0.517141521,
-0.0818049535,
0.1673685461,
-0.1953729093,
0.1236061454,
0.3425923884,
0.5196745396,
-0.1459344476,
0.2986354232,
-0.0487498417,
-0.2838914096,
0.3724333942,
0.044426553,
0.5540453196,
-0.2863413692,
-0.4337942898,
0.1348610222,
0.0552272461,
0.5733987093,
-0.1317246109,
0.6661963463,
0.3805512488,
-0.3453548849,
0.0200031493,
-0.4675028324,
-0.1976349205,
-0.4125528336,
0.3676703274,
-0.3165251315,
-0.8651497364,
0.4907237589,
0.1392549127,
0.2186734378,
0.3731445074,
0.4390228987,
0.0766445696,
0.9686368108,
0.3658948839,
0.1897226721,
0.3084447086,
-0.381026417,
0.3479593694,
-0.4843019247,
-0.3673650622,
-0.3776667416,
0.0487888083,
-0.3820877969,
-0.6124280095,
0.5292679667,
-0.1810813248,
-0.4499383271,
-0.0034409624,
-0.2987027466,
0.7193146348,
0.444968164,
-0.0331475176,
0.52417624,
0.0936466604,
0.3361074626,
-0.2242932916,
-0.6570577621,
-0.4177127182,
1.4183026552,
0.2015671581,
0.6250084043,
0.1659272611,
0.4332330525,
0.1934541017,
0.6105393767,
-0.8709026575,
0.4743296206,
-0.2307893485,
-0.5267140865,
-0.5991095901,
-0.6172478795,
-0.9330500364,
0.1248134226,
-0.2827394605,
-0.23390086,
-0.0279775225,
-0.1262090355,
-0.2694182098,
0.1586925834,
-0.8219320774,
0.5244075656,
-0.1142192557,
-0.1754168272,
0.0553973131,
-0.6205910444,
0.7384737134,
-0.3924461007,
0.6219767928,
-0.1183823794,
-0.0629886463,
0.8139720559,
-0.1712471396,
1.0649203062,
-0.0092566162,
-0.0406090021,
0.2939587235,
0.2453432083,
0.1185325161,
-0.1443216205,
-0.2695517838,
0.1494437009,
-0.0658059716,
-0.4548051059,
-0.7564653754,
0.4873126149,
-0.7490621805,
-0.4122512341,
-0.5445970297,
-0.6852003932,
-0.1532862186,
0.223153919,
0.0592245571,
0.3534965217,
-0.3999885917,
0.4256967008,
0.8338742256,
0.2085849941,
0.4712987542,
0.2852544188,
-0.2585061491,
-0.6628412604,
0.937017262,
0.5543134212,
0.3553991914,
0.3007622361,
0.2696323097,
-0.3809854388,
-0.4469043911,
-0.1453443915,
0.1758068502,
-0.7889795303,
-0.1251222491,
-0.5038221478,
-0.4158350825,
-0.4012254179,
-0.1325239837,
0.0535433367,
-0.6613241434,
-0.2598446906,
-0.2837100625,
0.4806765318,
1.2415852547,
-0.0169407055,
0.4714309871,
-0.736697495,
0.2311872095,
0.3065501153,
0.010282292,
0.1482901871,
-0.6459243298,
-0.2352482677,
0.0435071364,
-0.0607086569,
-0.7735626101,
0.6186156273,
0.0879477784,
0.2592192888,
0.4531976283,
-0.2181929797,
0.3755061626,
-0.4025241137,
0.745079875,
0.1195999533,
-0.7917301059,
0.2037195265,
-0.3621265292,
0.3729709089,
0.4914715886,
0.5717389584,
-0.3875334859,
0.0410706922,
-0.7192053795,
-0.8734784722,
0.2828784287,
0.2433059365,
0.1553676426,
-0.1224511564,
0.159207657,
0.258071363,
0.309484303,
-0.642783761,
-0.0047993003,
-0.1721420586,
-0.5382761955,
-0.3582491279,
-0.327355355,
0.1072570384,
-0.4058001637,
0.5082031488,
-0.3246860504,
-0.0920034349,
-0.2839157581,
-0.1374640465,
0.1718405187,
0.2942219675,
0.2198601216,
0.6387616992,
-0.0285595451,
0.1764990091,
0.1284681559,
-0.8377342224,
0.2150862813,
0.0412573218,
-0.2023730725,
-0.3500983119,
0.6197929978,
0.4232451022,
0.7535566688,
-0.5719476342,
0.6353268623,
0.0671071708,
-0.3062909245,
-0.7611491084,
0.0491000339,
0.2508363724,
-0.0987489223,
0.454215914,
-0.0801308751,
0.0185389109,
-0.4477146864,
0.2367546558,
0.1837160885,
-0.3936909139,
-0.4488498569,
0.5183086395,
0.0443747193,
-0.1886191964,
1.0342072248,
-0.090300329,
-0.2056045532,
0.7334161401,
0.6008313298,
0.6423003078,
-0.3617213964,
0.3969477713,
0.3115918636,
0.5232108831,
-0.4436573982,
0.5971595645,
0.2109006941,
-1.019839406,
-0.6111508012,
-0.3677166402,
-0.4234901369,
-0.1300205886,
-0.5702310801,
0.2134256214,
-0.1966150701,
0.1484224349,
0.0062314589,
0.0392257869,
-0.7257937789,
0.1714627296,
0.0105066774,
0.73930794,
-1.3584383726,
0.5683687925,
0.2579994798,
-0.5318727493,
-0.7073819041,
-0.2989224792,
-0.1481138915,
-1.148542285,
0.51407969,
0.2533400357,
0.3701904118,
0.3336128294,
-0.7361236811,
-0.9093394876,
1.1019947529,
0.1211731061,
-0.4418120682,
-0.16962336,
0.5934673548,
0.4328753948,
-0.4271352589,
0.5682946444,
0.78648597,
0.6253462434,
0.3508270383,
-0.4795203507,
-0.126735121,
-0.2105525583,
-0.1760163754,
0.2329062074,
-0.3775409162,
1.0725569725,
-0.5321396589,
-0.0255946293,
-0.0226481613,
0.7448270917,
0.2765266001,
0.4620067179,
0.3733212948,
0.5447020531,
0.898812592,
-0.227165252,
0.8557320833,
-0.1442929059,
0.1599780172,
0.9850917459,
-0.3580341935,
0.8815435767,
0.2706900239,
-0.2369209081,
0.5718550086,
0.3370014131,
-0.1335728317,
0.2562280595,
0.1880845428,
-0.4480753243,
-0.1867994815,
0.0595123023,
-0.1938095689,
0.5277045965,
0.7098197937,
-0.3207555413,
-0.0857229903,
0.0906691253,
0.0503611527,
-0.0152449729,
-0.4628045857,
0.8177073002,
0.1980308294,
-0.4728617668,
0.2260298878,
-0.4956001937,
0.2635823786,
-0.5756489038,
-0.3159723878,
-0.0068140654,
0.0473978966,
-0.2947739661,
-1.2842085361,
0.2966150641,
-0.2018155307,
-0.1807227433,
-0.0655547008,
0.794549644,
-0.5400216579,
-0.9073882103,
-0.2839674056,
0.8364881873,
0.4078709781,
-0.116873309,
-0.3051851094,
-0.0225804448,
0.0686098263,
-0.2845031619,
0.1589646786,
0.6896452904,
-0.2778260112,
0.8227193952,
0.8373584747,
0.0170506295,
0.0398185812,
0.1285942942,
0.8248664141,
-0.8185789585,
-0.3140728474,
-0.9186874032,
0.4283325076,
-0.0096143996,
-0.2112083286,
0.8884891868,
0.725736618,
0.4683646262,
-0.2461750507,
1.1267660856,
0.0799127817,
0.1620749086,
-0.403575182,
0.6069494486,
0.1339146793,
0.126316309,
0.015488646,
-0.8148186803,
-0.5324217081,
0.2581023574,
-0.7357213497,
-0.0057407725,
0.6155719161,
0.6720041037,
0.0332375914,
0.4952515066,
0.4757712781,
0.2216537595,
0.0991192237,
0.4597113729,
0.7690241337,
-0.4028305113,
0.4961769879,
-0.07372538,
-0.4631439745,
-0.0215304047,
-0.7054564953,
-1.009974122,
-0.5801310539,
-0.0399055742,
-0.3708511889,
-0.330381304,
0.6258016825,
0.2769786119,
-0.649291575,
-0.1592583507,
-0.1595389694,
0.2576103806,
-0.0325112417,
-0.3236932158,
0.3456504047,
-0.0605779402,
-0.5748882294,
0.3052702844,
0.0010584076,
0.1974403709,
-0.5054600835,
0.2773332596,
0.1659791768,
0.143964991,
0.6220695376,
0.2279411554,
-0.3301789165,
-0.0047137695,
0.2060599923,
0.2252314091,
-0.0699072555,
0.8391702771,
-0.7103176117,
0.3609361053,
0.6222608685,
0.4703012705,
0.353487134,
0.0049575143,
0.4782515168,
-0.3998428881,
-0.0718690604,
0.4429360628,
0.2511900663,
0.4400648773,
-0.3049176931,
0.5662033558,
0.2438811958,
-0.6955802441,
-0.7745878696,
0.1537083536,
-0.6060868502,
0.0005088569,
1.1659550667,
0.021368498,
-0.514996469,
-0.498003006,
0.056804765,
-0.0802173913,
-0.2271569669,
0.8350875974,
0.9290077686,
0.0433343537,
-0.1129614562,
-0.7427511215,
0.3136158586,
0.0709647983,
-0.6994979382,
0.3296748996,
0.3748677969,
0.2234130949,
0.2770008445,
0.671028614,
-0.3510424495,
0.1474726796,
0.1972406954,
0.2058769912,
-0.1820031852,
-0.3543538153,
-0.4725268483,
0.4531517625,
-0.022344403,
0.3857603669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13379v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13379v3 | Faithful Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2023-01-31T03:04:26 | 2023-09-20T22:19:30 | Qing Lyu, Shreya Havaldar, Adam Stein, Li Zhang, Delip Rao, Eric Wong, Marianna Apidianaki, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | While Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting boosts Language Models' (LM)
performance on a gamut of complex reasoning tasks, the generated reasoning
chain does not necessarily reflect how the model arrives at the answer (aka.
faithfulness). We propose Faithful CoT, a reasoning framework involving two
stages: Translation (Natural Language query $\rightarrow$ symbolic reasoning
chain) and Problem Solving (reasoning chain $\rightarrow$ answer), using an LM
and a deterministic solver respectively. This guarantees that the reasoning
chain provides a faithful explanation of the final answer. Aside from
interpretability, Faithful CoT also improves empirical performance: it
outperforms standard CoT on 9 of 10 benchmarks from 4 diverse domains, with a
relative accuracy gain of 6.3% on Math Word Problems (MWP), 3.4% on Planning,
5.5% on Multi-hop Question Answering (QA), and 21.4% on Relational Inference.
Furthermore, with GPT-4 and Codex, it sets the new state-of-the-art few-shot
performance on 7 datasets (with 95.0+ accuracy on 6 of them), showing a strong
synergy between faithfulness and accuracy. | [
-0.3707013428,
-0.9782773852,
0.9610409141,
0.3373375833,
-0.3897437751,
0.441383183,
-0.0188797247,
-0.6579267979,
-0.0984566137,
0.5835464001,
-0.6968458295,
-0.3618310392,
-0.5229558945,
0.2491984218,
-0.4295849204,
0.9686127901,
-0.3994234204,
0.2700221241,
-0.1353352219,
-0.1391503662,
-0.4236312509,
-0.5203198791,
-0.5231789947,
-0.3698560596,
0.4749262035,
0.1515764296,
1.0269286633,
0.6269034147,
0.5160050988,
0.1917927414,
0.0829888284,
0.5651352406,
-0.5535524487,
0.417999506,
-0.6281950474,
-0.7856016159,
-0.4868783653,
-0.1005394384,
0.4038417041,
0.4512979686,
-0.0268159658,
0.090363197,
-0.0026263513,
1.0143625736,
-0.8261348605,
-0.1272684336,
-0.9014174938,
-0.1592678577,
-0.0794921815,
-0.1217484474,
-0.5474833846,
-0.5406672955,
0.0035115951,
-0.6139531136,
0.281908989,
0.1855639666,
0.7447577715,
0.2596126199,
-0.1849351674,
-0.2936899066,
-0.846298635,
0.715352118,
-0.3376453817,
0.6400098205,
0.6123238802,
0.2851758897,
-0.5759681463,
-0.9221310616,
-0.6534821391,
0.0312331226,
0.3954994977,
0.1253867298,
0.1328514516,
0.1119743139,
0.2585297227,
0.5205907226,
-0.3999119997,
-0.6517341137,
-0.0909612179,
-0.0388158299,
0.5920870304,
0.2260385454,
0.049307175,
0.4661285281,
-0.4577030241,
-0.176613003,
-0.756433785,
-0.2022065371,
0.1772135794,
0.1564800739,
0.0840011388,
0.5233193636,
-0.038682878,
0.8119468689,
0.1202024147,
0.0602787472,
-0.095219858,
-0.6380746365,
-0.18737939,
-0.0545968004,
0.7990951538,
-0.0678332597,
0.5251784921,
-0.1592194885,
-0.3472811878,
0.3482755721,
0.4375217259,
-0.4428104758,
-0.1577736139,
0.2914292514,
-0.1497263163,
-0.2174332738,
0.18350555,
-0.4961651266,
-0.0023092031,
-0.4263931513,
0.3362085819,
-0.5962371826,
-0.1832393259,
0.2509143054,
-0.0928479955,
0.2248590887,
0.431384325,
-0.5853598714,
0.6000605226,
0.8629184365,
0.7826991081,
-0.1982106268,
-0.2841777802,
-0.5755360126,
0.2147198617,
-0.7398006916,
0.8949411511,
-0.6864727736,
-0.2109738141,
-0.1641786546,
-0.104897432,
-0.0544053577,
-0.2224333286,
0.4772913456,
-0.6458104849,
-0.0678162575,
-0.8373987675,
-0.6107882857,
0.2172916234,
0.4499918818,
-0.7506297231,
1.141934514,
0.1125442013,
-0.5592646599,
0.434976995,
-0.3121377826,
-0.0825937986,
-0.1285715699,
-0.3583669364,
-0.0726793185,
0.091714859,
0.1867463589,
-0.1254809499,
-0.50552845,
0.3692601025,
-0.3440666199,
-0.4636095762,
0.4661580622,
-0.6365309358,
0.5229046941,
0.4252384901,
-0.3946772516,
-0.1727024913,
-0.5265253186,
0.4189524651,
0.0771000087,
-0.0098191956,
-0.1134049445,
-0.0681687444,
-0.230104208,
0.3792144954,
0.0654301345,
-0.4258853495,
0.3066533506,
-0.3428376615,
-0.0024650206,
0.7868192196,
0.1288601607,
0.2652406394,
-0.3361651003,
0.6085825562,
0.0194234252,
0.3819057345,
0.2884263992,
-0.8826038837,
-0.4072905481,
-0.1021438912,
0.3858644366,
0.3229088783,
-1.0188515186,
0.0821020082,
0.0674360022,
-0.1889688969,
-0.5385571122,
0.2226751894,
0.8124662638,
0.240070641,
0.4755520225,
-0.3679477274,
-0.4205127954,
-0.5548145175,
-0.5885391831,
-0.5087826848,
0.2027959228,
-0.1122379601,
0.5526681542,
-0.0520630851,
0.962179482,
-0.4120871127,
0.0430325307,
-0.3303493857,
0.2735169828,
0.210379079,
0.3726921082,
0.2654974759,
-0.838219285,
-0.4293866456,
-0.0717721134,
-0.7976642251,
0.1212729812,
-0.0982778594,
-0.645743072,
0.2130781263,
0.0760683566,
-0.6117881536,
0.634239614,
0.436773926,
-0.4233454764,
0.8052228093,
-0.1011362821,
0.258767724,
-0.8669920564,
-0.1246481836,
-0.4204168022,
-0.5026473999,
-0.3043144643,
0.3025487661,
0.0686485022,
0.1936240196,
-0.3846520483,
0.333314091,
-0.319414705,
-0.0225909296,
-0.2924865186,
0.2630980909,
0.3282750845,
0.3597700894,
-0.0771293566,
1.1825990677,
0.3778595328,
-0.6981163025,
0.2692809105,
0.420763433,
0.1056841388,
0.3540177345,
-0.5367072821,
0.5075101852,
0.1251785606,
0.4540605843,
-0.7080262899,
-0.0268088933,
0.1429566145,
-0.4835824072,
0.0513089001,
0.181073159,
-0.5508977175,
-0.4851556718,
-0.4004544914,
0.68342489,
0.3278772235,
-0.4923627973,
0.5422390103,
-0.0873337165,
0.4182895422,
-0.8355467916,
-0.7967169285,
-0.0823146105,
0.5532072186,
-0.3869790733,
0.319542855,
-0.0570712164,
-0.4094751477,
0.2315925658,
-0.561442554,
-0.2586654127,
-0.2999025285,
-0.0848967582,
0.343955785,
-0.2831960022,
0.2725703418,
0.028076211,
-0.1631362736,
0.2382914573,
-0.543422699,
0.7437587976,
-0.7418090105,
-0.465274781,
-0.3984320164,
0.2250425816,
0.5362526774,
-0.2201443017,
0.9448533058,
0.3322266042,
-0.3898248076,
-0.168148756,
-0.5330861211,
-0.1384479702,
-0.4477560222,
-0.173556298,
-0.7630872726,
-0.4814548492,
0.5391350985,
-0.0252794642,
-0.0888933539,
0.4650216699,
0.4262902737,
0.0158292241,
1.1886922121,
0.493946135,
0.0856258199,
0.149880439,
-0.3827372193,
0.31658566,
-0.8111369014,
-0.3217141628,
-0.4536274076,
-0.0484846458,
-0.598934114,
-0.585642755,
0.064980045,
0.5103143454,
-0.3180842996,
0.5016370416,
-0.5095275044,
0.6041382551,
0.2999180853,
0.4554252028,
0.4984394312,
-0.21175991,
-0.5271087289,
0.1929171681,
-0.6476408243,
-0.7250550389,
1.1495164633,
0.1106732935,
0.9538863897,
0.0740256235,
0.6968405843,
0.1451725811,
0.1448785067,
-0.4463914931,
0.5260366797,
-0.0406425782,
-0.8498620987,
-0.1746733934,
-0.4835076332,
-0.6915853024,
-0.0133882128,
-0.1994575113,
-0.8381994963,
0.197155267,
0.2348680049,
-0.1684954166,
0.4478727877,
-0.3917908669,
0.4715764523,
-0.3354583085,
-1.0369505882,
-0.2995505929,
-0.608546257,
0.347446233,
-0.0337819122,
-0.0954562947,
0.0233518649,
0.0071167895,
0.4970887601,
-0.5766019821,
0.3346384168,
0.1878347546,
-0.0714389458,
0.6803622842,
0.4634695053,
0.774335146,
0.2226741314,
-0.2636498213,
-0.0158247985,
0.302041769,
-0.4976803064,
-0.9901878834,
0.661149919,
-0.5596849918,
-0.7025814652,
-0.6146041751,
-0.6682357788,
-0.6020867825,
0.1400860846,
0.2612496614,
0.4591600001,
-0.1188854501,
0.0089067435,
0.8352843523,
0.0681204572,
-0.0137279034,
0.0462187529,
-0.4850822091,
-0.616812706,
0.5774052143,
-0.2155238241,
0.8419992924,
0.2683473527,
0.0739473403,
-0.6154797673,
-0.0893432572,
-0.5650442243,
0.3079176247,
-0.8427413106,
-0.3159058392,
-0.6087301373,
-0.3754060864,
-0.0951627493,
-0.2160723656,
-0.7746568322,
-0.4025864303,
0.1752324849,
-0.1122201011,
0.4015083611,
0.8341605067,
0.228423059,
-0.1134022996,
-0.6506586075,
0.6851817369,
0.2579890788,
0.6082783341,
-0.1183846965,
-0.0468889587,
0.0664619654,
0.5255464911,
-0.6253261566,
-0.8851311207,
-0.0375163481,
-0.062512815,
0.546037972,
0.3780849278,
0.1735940129,
1.1399827003,
-0.2679451406,
0.8743895292,
0.4052395821,
-1.1055930853,
0.6463115811,
-0.1794164181,
0.4393185675,
0.9753603935,
0.335408926,
-0.0253639184,
-0.8980234265,
-0.7389758825,
-0.5451917052,
0.4990009069,
0.6915847063,
-0.2412705868,
-0.3404284418,
0.5124035478,
0.1838280112,
0.2435628176,
-0.5380612016,
-0.1920472682,
-0.136166513,
-0.2457064986,
0.4626681507,
-0.016750345,
-0.0741578713,
-0.4356229305,
0.8087751865,
-0.2144061923,
0.6012634635,
0.6810307503,
0.0228067506,
-0.5453695059,
0.1570389271,
0.4730552733,
1.1922954321,
-0.2727779746,
0.3690733612,
0.3381769955,
-0.6680024862,
0.2185703069,
-0.5305821896,
0.1184305549,
0.0592277832,
0.4696128964,
0.4526848793,
-0.0115091186,
-0.4234582782,
0.4201271832,
-0.2119559944,
-0.2285498083,
-0.0856382698,
0.2848732471,
-0.1967895329,
0.1441006809,
0.3119404614,
0.2906976044,
0.0591948666,
-0.827549696,
0.3327051103,
0.3362017274,
-0.5235070586,
-0.2008675933,
0.8199340701,
-0.0908363387,
-0.3752960265,
0.664978385,
-0.1599278003,
-0.7493991852,
0.6586293578,
0.947671473,
1.0018754005,
-0.040462032,
0.2700041533,
0.2998019159,
0.2465474904,
-0.5572306514,
0.687983036,
-0.2738422751,
-0.6767389774,
-0.4811793864,
-0.648205936,
-0.5721130371,
-0.1325472891,
-0.8397752047,
0.1855767518,
-0.5362998843,
-0.2638900876,
-0.4740050733,
-0.0344364345,
-0.7918277383,
0.297416985,
-0.0298196804,
1.2532128096,
-0.4292370379,
0.9648523927,
0.3983955383,
-0.5287394524,
-1.0554910898,
0.3300536573,
-0.2669764161,
-0.5668389201,
0.3221470118,
0.0843157321,
-0.8564673662,
-0.1821437329,
-0.6925916672,
-0.7517886758,
1.1152045727,
0.6231932044,
-0.8559212089,
0.1140944287,
0.2846993506,
0.6708551049,
-0.4012165666,
0.2932478487,
0.5218729973,
0.3237913549,
0.2888519168,
-0.9500561357,
0.1343838871,
-0.1086129993,
0.0670594946,
0.3574863076,
-0.438444078,
0.6956888437,
-0.2649507225,
-0.0596779436,
0.2057540864,
0.592661202,
0.8372823,
0.6380535364,
0.3648955822,
0.4543257058,
0.94644171,
-0.1861217022,
1.3042960167,
-0.4170311093,
0.3057664335,
1.1536067724,
-0.4389374554,
0.8921393752,
0.6794497967,
-0.3168246448,
0.9607228041,
0.3973726928,
0.4057790637,
0.5824113488,
-0.0738386884,
-0.3739605546,
-0.6322346926,
-0.035063386,
-0.6591197848,
0.2111030072,
0.2893281877,
-0.4523299932,
-0.0507266894,
-0.2943674624,
-0.1905329674,
0.3207793236,
-0.2501164675,
0.5228953362,
0.4165143669,
-0.9459444284,
0.69340837,
-0.2670360804,
-0.0773139447,
-0.7662973404,
-0.3227524161,
-0.0807431638,
0.3224362135,
-0.1250866354,
-1.0093886852,
0.4598610699,
0.0925394371,
-0.1418321431,
-0.1597200483,
0.6897608042,
-0.1136120185,
-0.6225953698,
0.4339148998,
0.6784158349,
0.0339646712,
-0.1088419929,
-0.7951210737,
0.1464689672,
-0.3505842686,
-0.1443613023,
-0.0749099702,
0.7849600911,
-0.3679570854,
0.8434531689,
0.8212123513,
0.0711316466,
-0.026329359,
0.2215530276,
1.2203179598,
-0.7860438228,
-0.4464977384,
-0.9679815769,
0.2292185277,
-0.1532963514,
-0.3450302482,
0.4253549874,
0.5913534164,
0.7208903432,
0.0199167449,
0.5356134772,
0.0050491141,
-0.1266880035,
-0.6853752136,
0.3871012628,
-0.267652154,
0.3728284538,
-0.5301049948,
-1.0909638405,
-0.1811952591,
0.6150253415,
-0.3678893149,
0.0161535088,
1.3767291307,
0.6137085557,
0.0041032922,
0.5234521627,
0.3067959249,
0.0223838668,
0.2213523239,
0.7305563688,
1.006431818,
-0.6781596541,
0.4827900529,
-0.2160283327,
-0.0303988233,
0.3885234594,
-0.7120401263,
-0.7883293629,
-0.4447387457,
-0.1223892868,
-0.7246813178,
0.5846844912,
1.1247907877,
0.4660691321,
-0.9431105852,
-0.030228138,
-0.9841167331,
0.2741509378,
-0.6699419022,
-0.2277088165,
0.1652419865,
-0.6327484846,
-0.2679220438,
0.1619840562,
0.2655430436,
-0.3817497194,
-0.1514448673,
-0.3893529177,
-0.4923344254,
0.3863961697,
0.4517582953,
-0.0801679716,
-0.9002369046,
-0.3511207402,
0.1356732249,
-0.1992225647,
-0.0263854396,
0.9514012337,
-1.0133049488,
0.6096445322,
0.4410105944,
0.5881078839,
0.6676282287,
0.2093296349,
0.9161046147,
-0.4478492141,
-0.0036134806,
0.4253662527,
0.2527497709,
-0.0652871504,
-0.5875402689,
0.7647755146,
0.2794193029,
-0.5450252295,
-0.7201721668,
0.4066128135,
-0.9880831242,
-0.2616769075,
1.1038088799,
-0.1988878548,
-0.5914029479,
-0.3746060729,
-0.2112148851,
0.4800542593,
-0.2840857506,
0.7241117358,
0.7735487819,
-0.3419536352,
-0.0390489101,
-0.3750001192,
0.417165637,
0.373486042,
-0.6891096234,
-0.063566871,
0.162971735,
0.1525872797,
0.1304538548,
0.6931309104,
-0.4930258691,
0.602289319,
0.2425447553,
-0.1724502891,
-0.0866176859,
-0.6763342619,
0.1587136686,
0.0185853206,
0.2731590867,
-0.2751478851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13372v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13372v1 | Improving Open-Domain Dialogue Evaluation with a Causal Inference Model | 2023-01-31T02:31:42 | 2023-01-31T02:31:42 | Cat P. Le, Luke Dai, Michael Johnston, Yang Liu, Marilyn Walker, Reza Ghanadan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Effective evaluation methods remain a significant challenge for research on
open-domain conversational dialogue systems. Explicit satisfaction ratings can
be elicited from users, but users often do not provide ratings when asked, and
those they give can be highly subjective. Post-hoc ratings by experts are an
alternative, but these can be both expensive and complex to collect. Here, we
explore the creation of automated methods for predicting both expert and user
ratings of open-domain dialogues. We compare four different approaches. First,
we train a baseline model using an end-to-end transformer to predict ratings
directly from the raw dialogue text. The other three methods are variants of a
two-stage approach in which we first extract interpretable features at the turn
level that capture, among other aspects, user dialogue behaviors indicating
contradiction, repetition, disinterest, compliments, or criticism. We project
these features to the dialogue level and train a dialogue-level MLP regression
model, a dialogue-level LSTM, and a novel causal inference model called
counterfactual-LSTM (CF-LSTM) to predict ratings. The proposed CF-LSTM is a
sequential model over turn-level features which predicts ratings using multiple
regressors depending on hypotheses derived from the turn-level features. As a
causal inference model, CF-LSTM aims to learn the underlying causes of a
specific event, such as a low rating. We also bin the user ratings and perform
classification experiments with all four models. In evaluation experiments on
conversational data from the Alexa Prize SocialBot, we show that the CF-LSTM
achieves the best performance for predicting dialogue ratings and
classification. | [
-0.7319365144,
-0.795681715,
0.6599524617,
0.1621416062,
-0.1640756875,
-0.0926012769,
-0.2677944899,
-0.4607227147,
-0.0100276582,
0.6069531441,
-0.5248572826,
-0.3201581538,
-0.5547611713,
-0.0149844717,
-0.103636004,
0.9751555324,
0.0684481785,
0.2746718526,
-0.4512331784,
-0.0565651692,
-0.5258668661,
-0.5123131275,
-0.6429920197,
-0.5320358276,
0.4040762484,
0.3719622493,
0.8730422854,
-0.2366008162,
0.1388567984,
0.283969909,
0.1237609163,
0.2840624154,
-0.66579175,
-0.1206389368,
-0.27248016,
-0.1413150579,
-0.2855922282,
0.3242785335,
0.0810829923,
0.7359578013,
0.0060877888,
-0.0441478044,
0.1404211223,
0.1801920831,
-0.4675566852,
0.454408884,
-0.460100621,
-0.0037140632,
0.4212771356,
-0.5771190524,
-0.7596819997,
-0.597248137,
0.5852128267,
-0.4083252847,
0.0191193633,
0.096441336,
0.7219985127,
0.1708594859,
-0.5438942313,
-0.2002529651,
-1.087074399,
0.8964684606,
-0.8799123764,
0.4258163869,
0.4159014225,
0.381025672,
-0.2500835061,
-0.410241425,
-0.5239357948,
-0.5990669727,
-0.3114343584,
0.3233309686,
-0.5278230309,
0.1187817231,
0.0813545063,
0.2039121538,
-0.3415770531,
0.1350626945,
-0.0659558773,
0.0504825711,
0.6023693681,
0.1776884794,
0.0538895652,
-0.1293408424,
-0.5050829053,
0.1373892725,
-0.4386359453,
0.208552599,
0.3637490273,
0.2839019001,
0.2418788373,
0.4079549313,
-0.3181412518,
0.5604665875,
0.3528673947,
0.1892773062,
0.0573613904,
-0.1824005693,
-0.4173001349,
-0.1363686919,
0.8950178027,
0.6477380991,
0.4222990274,
-0.1759184003,
0.0177803095,
0.0420474783,
0.4351787865,
-0.7096151114,
-0.1104263812,
0.3482454419,
-0.587000072,
-0.3841252625,
0.1951843351,
-0.5989217758,
-0.3991188109,
-0.5589307547,
0.6360462308,
-0.2848318815,
-0.2521311939,
0.1153921336,
0.0451521017,
-0.1666617692,
0.7959182858,
-0.4032645226,
0.514603734,
0.4091858566,
0.5069528818,
-0.1260045618,
-0.048381377,
-0.5994764566,
-0.3723620176,
-0.339194119,
0.8852180243,
-0.5018180609,
-0.4005156755,
0.1972089708,
-0.0122000733,
-0.2992585897,
-0.3899155259,
0.6255922318,
-0.6307324171,
0.7799909711,
0.0026357407,
-0.5557350516,
-0.2158863544,
0.04390442,
-0.5075225234,
0.7183745503,
0.2075899243,
-0.6793846488,
0.3275089264,
-0.6912559271,
-0.2167019844,
-0.1149643734,
0.1124569848,
-0.3596777916,
0.1098324209,
0.2727152109,
0.3998477161,
-0.5849213004,
0.6852692366,
-0.5265085101,
-0.2072280347,
0.3732422888,
-0.5177645087,
0.5643228292,
0.2971976697,
-0.5490034223,
0.4167405963,
-0.4315334857,
-0.0591956824,
-0.1057391316,
0.1187577322,
-0.3446905613,
0.1937222928,
-0.1550497115,
0.3542686105,
-0.0999649465,
-0.6825373173,
-0.0974603444,
-0.3680254221,
0.0725073293,
0.7173207998,
0.3623004258,
0.2752100527,
-0.2121673971,
0.332380712,
0.1942741126,
0.3273921013,
-0.0014253017,
-0.6683095694,
-0.8913450837,
-0.0222768039,
0.030947905,
0.5574832559,
-0.6119126081,
0.6702010036,
-0.1596589983,
-0.6000640988,
-0.3309795558,
-0.1410786957,
0.5560888052,
0.4969966114,
0.4896766841,
-0.6483690143,
-0.2002715617,
-0.6550299525,
-0.4876123071,
-0.6214283109,
-0.1721268743,
0.7091493607,
0.2762525678,
-0.1539887786,
1.1225665808,
-0.7477416992,
-0.2048042417,
-0.1889133006,
0.5763248205,
0.2283357233,
0.3239068985,
0.2420893013,
-0.4973877966,
-0.2978589833,
0.0351460651,
-0.6067008376,
-0.3294084966,
-0.1785565913,
-0.1135490984,
0.1820586026,
0.3293859363,
-0.655023694,
0.6789878011,
-0.0154581871,
-0.4186015129,
0.6159901619,
0.1668222398,
0.6226729751,
-0.5327939391,
-0.0025152199,
0.2520172894,
-0.2681818008,
-0.7836256027,
-0.3765080273,
-0.4701803625,
-0.0377789028,
-0.4089931548,
0.739387691,
-0.0921619833,
0.0821543187,
-0.082705915,
0.132911101,
-0.1528151184,
0.9318526983,
0.3186925352,
0.2930735052,
0.0084877722,
-0.3581981063,
0.2893254459,
0.3541294932,
-0.691224575,
0.5651507378,
-0.7152543664,
0.2172179818,
0.1043155566,
0.4265781343,
-1.3896678686,
-0.0077727828,
0.2588732541,
-0.6353417039,
0.0311865397,
-0.0399421044,
-0.2586643994,
-0.3924533129,
-0.1576896757,
0.1355493516,
0.384080857,
-0.6172453761,
0.5084799528,
0.2436533868,
-0.2992044985,
-0.2461345494,
0.0738370046,
-0.0092070447,
-0.2469018102,
-0.6660658717,
0.0683056936,
-0.1603211313,
-0.3186070323,
-0.1187837869,
-0.1349180192,
0.0897943974,
0.0564860813,
0.3515793383,
0.1748868972,
-0.1463944018,
-0.0544558614,
0.0747878626,
-0.3150144815,
0.2383511364,
-0.325545311,
0.3999749124,
-0.1572784185,
-0.4281589687,
-0.5356134772,
0.2349268645,
0.4287169278,
-0.0549539849,
0.5300058722,
0.6275895238,
-0.2448234856,
-0.1327162385,
-0.6635357141,
-0.3781616092,
-0.3158496618,
0.1541461945,
-0.2456373125,
-0.8343129158,
0.337035358,
-0.2679347396,
0.1064053625,
0.4308622181,
0.7450937629,
-0.0379830971,
1.3634213209,
0.3182170391,
0.0203430504,
0.4723683298,
-0.0843571872,
0.4588774443,
-0.3951126933,
-0.3397356868,
-0.6912581325,
0.0741053373,
-0.2829128206,
-0.3228600025,
0.5003947616,
0.26895383,
-0.2904413044,
0.33862257,
-0.005181611,
0.0312105231,
0.6224501133,
0.2648181319,
0.4134069383,
-0.0265785288,
-0.1611629874,
0.0601040237,
-0.5258757472,
-0.5173666477,
0.7562129498,
0.5818591714,
0.8028424382,
0.1082150862,
0.3017436564,
0.6110237241,
0.5648425817,
-0.8392291069,
0.4254321754,
0.1067838669,
-0.3801501989,
-0.4167591929,
-0.4825998545,
-0.677113235,
0.2833390534,
-0.1906360835,
-0.9736355543,
0.2658215761,
0.1142749935,
-0.2989059687,
-0.015008769,
-0.6890563965,
1.0229394436,
-0.0102103231,
-0.4042947888,
-0.3914448619,
-0.7187263966,
0.5334191322,
-0.0442029051,
0.163739264,
0.0420923419,
0.6384596825,
0.7709088326,
-0.8280718327,
1.0487678051,
-0.4525673091,
-0.1284843236,
0.4054545462,
0.1501919627,
0.3541432023,
0.1170826256,
-0.0835925192,
0.3107706308,
-0.1341629177,
-0.0808019266,
-0.9366275668,
0.515961349,
-1.0270299911,
-0.7871922851,
-0.151972726,
-0.1074621081,
-0.6053953171,
0.0351986326,
0.0884901285,
0.505037725,
-0.5803925991,
0.0782480985,
0.4534955621,
-0.4697609842,
0.1078327522,
0.6754559278,
-0.2021473497,
-0.5448144078,
0.6021186709,
-0.2256203443,
0.451559335,
0.4505077899,
0.4682966769,
-0.452860415,
-0.2698559761,
-0.5423180461,
-0.077983439,
-0.5735465288,
-0.2793029845,
-0.7439004183,
-0.213043943,
-0.4241430163,
0.1264096498,
-0.0953835249,
-0.5123773217,
-0.2820521891,
-0.2872002125,
0.1495490223,
0.647163868,
0.0916546956,
0.4645071924,
-0.530311048,
0.2486193627,
0.2673175633,
0.3144647181,
0.27441594,
-0.6583408713,
-0.4133782983,
-0.0151871629,
-0.5448994637,
-0.6542438269,
0.3652257025,
0.135221377,
0.6731762886,
0.6767346263,
0.4127252698,
0.5535010099,
-0.383479625,
0.9226347804,
0.3029857874,
-0.9452345967,
0.4733716547,
-0.3464958966,
0.111181587,
0.33262676,
0.5633394718,
-0.3441048563,
-0.6876170039,
-0.517001152,
-0.5676439404,
0.9441976547,
0.1945966631,
-0.0722903162,
-0.1766601205,
-0.1755128205,
0.3542987704,
0.2908330262,
-0.6149828434,
-0.2112649679,
-0.4845583141,
-0.0082149236,
-0.3942591548,
-0.2083582729,
-0.1957223862,
-0.1299507022,
0.7169923782,
-0.1183465198,
0.3821974099,
0.3605309427,
-0.0996566713,
-0.559741199,
0.3748828471,
0.564388752,
0.6226960421,
-0.5701134801,
-0.1236475855,
-0.0136721581,
0.1310195923,
0.005445248,
0.1521272361,
0.103652589,
0.1459244937,
0.4878758788,
1.1951034069,
0.3307585716,
-0.4371048212,
0.7189765573,
-0.1982056201,
-0.0491215773,
-0.3509731591,
-0.0918682292,
-0.2314173132,
0.13821733,
0.2609093785,
0.2656421959,
0.2446237803,
-0.6644704342,
0.2896086276,
0.4768480957,
-0.7354413271,
-0.3666207492,
0.5985401273,
0.5013563037,
-0.236208573,
0.4420390725,
0.1370600313,
-0.5684249997,
0.3492881954,
0.3159984946,
1.3035708666,
-0.5059716105,
0.4509727061,
0.3060352802,
0.0689928085,
0.1930708438,
0.0307906903,
-0.2835988104,
-0.829380393,
-0.2158751935,
-0.7316915989,
-0.6750177741,
0.1404609233,
-0.7426151037,
0.3360680044,
-0.1515786499,
-0.2741334736,
0.1850345731,
-0.0649098754,
-0.7877511978,
0.3279836476,
-0.1389244646,
0.887550056,
-0.8933641315,
0.5030748248,
0.202503562,
-0.4419401884,
-0.4771868587,
-0.136830911,
0.1794450283,
-0.5940660238,
0.6235790253,
0.149327144,
-0.3493226767,
-0.1156591401,
-0.3797360361,
-0.339738369,
0.5917005539,
-0.0571708791,
-0.318885982,
0.1734504104,
0.1518493742,
0.8232760429,
-0.742572546,
0.9787050486,
0.4655587673,
0.4294437468,
0.0881020054,
-1.0495616198,
0.0249495041,
-0.2970791757,
-0.2083746791,
0.0469598621,
-0.3506072164,
0.4137742519,
-0.2397958934,
-0.0260311048,
0.3387594521,
0.6044619083,
-0.0782249644,
0.6704745889,
0.8622905016,
0.3090437651,
0.2305603027,
-0.0755915716,
0.9776437879,
-0.2524833083,
0.3695766032,
1.1152029037,
-0.3787140846,
0.8093812466,
0.1202430651,
-0.0931383446,
0.7212804556,
0.7204379439,
0.1395401359,
0.515288949,
0.2603014708,
-0.2316484004,
-0.3704939187,
-0.2250506431,
-0.142364651,
0.3226727545,
0.344101131,
-0.4568451643,
-0.1499418914,
0.0124314362,
0.0148240635,
-0.0828966647,
-0.1210850924,
1.1573183537,
0.162699163,
-1.1050748825,
0.5558666587,
0.0206279941,
0.2052038312,
-0.4724527001,
-0.0318159573,
-0.2642603517,
0.1079825908,
-0.2439479083,
-0.5240291953,
0.0672526956,
0.022965733,
-0.0328554921,
-0.3415169418,
0.6559491158,
-0.4653690457,
-0.2390402555,
0.5747966766,
0.6629405022,
0.2687522173,
-0.0501518101,
-0.4779695868,
-0.2352874726,
0.0186452493,
-0.4273069501,
0.0711604208,
0.1472472548,
-0.297516048,
0.3813614547,
0.6895991564,
-0.2210611999,
-0.4273558259,
0.5943496823,
0.8328285813,
-0.6924393177,
-0.3683309257,
-0.5985451341,
0.5801422596,
-0.0902385786,
-0.237899974,
0.6370807886,
0.3423676193,
0.8655487895,
-0.256231755,
0.7488901019,
0.2651708126,
0.7141132951,
-0.3540411294,
0.554045558,
-0.3764149249,
0.326944381,
-0.8412936926,
-0.9619437456,
-0.1007312834,
0.2447773963,
-0.5892765522,
0.2156574726,
0.6479263306,
0.6077558398,
0.0076512396,
0.4523277283,
0.4114434719,
0.4804719985,
0.5302152038,
0.376785934,
1.1946614981,
-0.178105846,
0.3821530342,
0.0054889736,
-0.6642568111,
-0.4224794507,
-0.6583086252,
-1.027583003,
-0.4994979501,
-0.345189631,
-0.3914298713,
-0.0133990692,
0.9091810584,
0.6644586325,
-0.8961927891,
-0.3532221913,
0.0945518166,
0.2586096227,
-0.3362666965,
-0.3434716463,
0.1141177565,
-0.4012149274,
-0.7747184038,
0.4429132938,
0.2239035368,
-0.3751829863,
-0.2782041728,
-0.1250517815,
0.0481624566,
0.459949702,
0.9114407301,
0.1290414035,
-0.9647563696,
-0.553430438,
-0.1453640908,
0.1579681486,
-0.1438730955,
1.0379588604,
-0.8726046085,
0.522744894,
0.4534903467,
0.3276605606,
0.46145913,
0.3567360044,
0.9926367998,
-0.322098881,
-0.4605682194,
0.1821855009,
0.2600844204,
0.0799655542,
-0.2778171599,
0.4158846736,
0.2149727046,
-0.6589691043,
-0.8053193092,
0.2633805871,
-1.1124056578,
-0.2500486672,
0.8112798929,
-0.4886055887,
0.3688415289,
-0.4301420152,
-0.2723838985,
0.1315164715,
-0.5362049937,
0.8326231241,
0.6048249602,
-0.522541523,
0.0057882243,
-0.3125549555,
0.5343027115,
0.3907472491,
-0.8110016584,
0.1051144302,
0.6538180113,
0.045727063,
0.3039727807,
0.5560353398,
-0.0839209557,
0.2899295688,
-0.2378739268,
-0.1433980167,
-0.0187010765,
-0.5422343016,
-0.2050345689,
0.1241557971,
-0.0120853446,
0.1313222945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10307v1 | ViewCo: Discovering Text-Supervised Segmentation Masks via Multi-View Semantic Consistency | 2023-01-31T01:57:52 | 2023-01-31T01:57:52 | Pengzhen Ren, Changlin Li, Hang Xu, Yi Zhu, Guangrun Wang, Jianzhuang Liu, Xiaojun Chang, Xiaodan Liang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recently, great success has been made in learning visual representations from
text supervision, facilitating the emergence of text-supervised semantic
segmentation. However, existing works focus on pixel grouping and cross-modal
semantic alignment, while ignoring the correspondence among multiple augmented
views of the same image. To overcome such limitation, we propose
multi-\textbf{View} \textbf{Co}nsistent learning (ViewCo) for text-supervised
semantic segmentation. Specifically, we first propose text-to-views consistency
modeling to learn correspondence for multiple views of the same input image.
Additionally, we propose cross-view segmentation consistency modeling to
address the ambiguity issue of text supervision by contrasting the segment
features of Siamese visual encoders. The text-to-views consistency benefits the
dense assignment of the visual features by encouraging different crops to align
with the same text, while the cross-view segmentation consistency modeling
provides additional self-supervision, overcoming the limitation of ambiguous
text supervision for segmentation masks. Trained with large-scale image-text
data, our model can directly segment objects of arbitrary categories in a
zero-shot manner. Extensive experiments show that ViewCo outperforms
state-of-the-art methods on average by up to 2.9\%, 1.6\%, and 2.4\% mIoU on
PASCAL VOC2012, PASCAL Context, and COCO, respectively. | [
-0.1933071315,
-0.5359099507,
0.6949803829,
0.3140766323,
-0.1542621702,
0.0462282822,
0.0531648956,
-0.7146983147,
0.4913333058,
0.7924645543,
-0.6124795079,
-0.8101739883,
-0.7944714427,
0.2272093892,
-0.3319764733,
0.8106142282,
-0.2827331126,
-0.088939026,
-0.6262268424,
-0.3210542798,
-0.3811298013,
-0.4106394053,
-0.3777345419,
0.228458643,
0.7481005788,
0.4870114923,
0.2903374732,
0.8325956464,
0.4292720258,
0.3260936141,
0.0683081597,
0.747918129,
-0.1370426267,
0.1506566703,
-0.2959516644,
-0.2091128975,
-0.2402086854,
0.1053626016,
0.3790099323,
0.8076970577,
0.1400143951,
-0.4604891539,
0.0340486318,
0.6602823734,
-1.046766758,
0.1912866235,
-0.7500969172,
0.0154325766,
0.2169004083,
0.0438307002,
-0.5329496264,
-0.0689816773,
0.409480691,
-1.0058354139,
0.2964736223,
0.2227985114,
1.0564565659,
0.4370785058,
-0.4915833473,
-0.2398597747,
-0.1481877118,
0.868951261,
0.0889905095,
0.5693657398,
0.6097800136,
0.135507971,
0.1350572258,
-0.6505980492,
-0.3638912141,
0.1308692694,
-0.0357537679,
0.4272100925,
0.2009018064,
-0.1462165862,
-0.0398538969,
0.2244752944,
-0.2405449152,
-0.1828089207,
-0.1636759937,
-0.3787007928,
0.4171594679,
-0.0860084966,
0.1932930052,
-0.2342874259,
-0.951300621,
-0.2136341184,
-0.2103430629,
0.0917629302,
0.1697762907,
-0.0014746614,
-0.1948939711,
0.5836315751,
-0.2551296055,
0.806892395,
0.0932832956,
-0.228094399,
0.058527112,
-0.3171583116,
-0.5408793688,
0.2715107203,
0.7886624336,
0.5172481537,
0.1159616858,
-0.2142081708,
0.2466362715,
0.1646680534,
0.3559899032,
-0.624704361,
-0.6713785529,
-0.0554046817,
-0.1712152809,
-0.4004004002,
0.2766571045,
-0.5895056725,
-0.3894914091,
-0.2025549114,
0.6264697909,
-0.4575123787,
0.0825376287,
0.3392852247,
-0.228246361,
0.2198447585,
0.7783095241,
-1.0799021721,
0.3311268389,
0.5398747325,
0.8953803182,
-0.5246386528,
-0.293810308,
-0.5513504148,
0.3566390574,
-0.5015096664,
0.9242990613,
-0.6191903949,
-0.1555752605,
-0.2447294742,
0.6063537002,
-0.5136925578,
-0.4453828931,
0.2930619121,
-0.233194083,
0.3098110259,
-0.2339833826,
-0.6010172963,
-0.3054514825,
0.8608462811,
-0.6072964072,
0.7774460912,
-0.1012713239,
-0.9203194976,
0.6762532592,
-0.2485936284,
-0.1597668976,
-0.3247039318,
-0.363473922,
-0.8129918575,
-0.2017239928,
0.6008962393,
0.3581074774,
0.1388979256,
0.1447280645,
-0.292922914,
0.0514141358,
0.0399796516,
-0.4777198434,
0.6974110603,
-0.1711101979,
-0.0515231267,
0.3377205729,
-0.6799993515,
-0.1347333938,
-0.0502316803,
0.0777168721,
-0.8535367846,
0.0136447977,
0.0389425047,
0.0733025074,
0.1170834079,
-0.8508194089,
0.1905073673,
-0.3246712685,
0.1866122782,
0.5468447208,
0.2977032065,
0.4837296605,
-0.1391757429,
0.1009929925,
0.5692906976,
0.2084471881,
-0.9491569996,
-0.4472304285,
-0.9461577535,
-0.572784245,
0.2685875297,
0.3567209244,
-0.9149663448,
0.4765478373,
-0.0001794863,
-0.2311114371,
-0.0692525581,
-0.1703636646,
0.3849260509,
0.8219121099,
0.6070755124,
-0.6363630295,
-0.5075845718,
-0.9865732789,
-0.154211849,
0.2041290849,
0.2756172121,
0.2051085979,
0.5693992972,
-0.3019925952,
1.1093809605,
-0.600573957,
-0.7003117204,
0.2411316186,
-0.062196739,
-0.456625551,
0.7922260761,
0.3282824755,
-1.0923955441,
-0.5944448709,
0.2089568526,
-0.8140500784,
0.2264901549,
0.0481898822,
-0.1777081341,
0.3803934455,
0.6314330101,
0.2370582819,
0.7388460636,
0.6214621663,
-0.1431010067,
0.2169416845,
-0.284833312,
0.2567391992,
-1.3754000664,
-0.4772619307,
0.3773980141,
-0.6269419193,
-0.2866827548,
-0.3863117695,
0.4107331038,
0.0654928163,
-0.6366168857,
0.2834315002,
-0.4293242693,
-0.0444462262,
-0.2826157212,
0.0816949308,
0.7356110811,
0.5980252624,
0.6452412009,
0.5419498086,
0.705686152,
-0.5325977206,
0.1795753986,
0.3675966561,
-0.3940202296,
0.7328928113,
-0.5893428922,
0.0889180675,
0.0328627974,
0.3965295255,
-1.0108006001,
-0.3705502152,
0.4619971514,
-0.2885619402,
-0.0131695494,
-0.2331220955,
-0.1187471077,
0.2631486356,
-0.2282218337,
0.734444499,
-0.1828610152,
-0.9129326344,
0.4771975279,
0.3709061146,
0.3334991932,
-0.6488345265,
-0.6256718636,
0.0069615273,
0.1097309664,
-0.7981136441,
0.5703303814,
0.2738543749,
0.110552758,
0.0618867651,
-0.4271513224,
-0.2744467854,
-0.2419644594,
0.42332533,
0.295117408,
0.072087571,
-0.0024638711,
0.1578436941,
-0.1975634545,
-0.1952688694,
-0.6284779906,
0.1798204482,
-0.0318490379,
-0.5382441878,
-0.3441599607,
0.4700734317,
0.1319911331,
-0.382285893,
0.7401515841,
0.2525160015,
-0.5105014443,
0.0955126807,
-0.4610328674,
0.1322634816,
-0.412157923,
0.2824071944,
-0.4126268625,
-0.9387210011,
0.2822518051,
-0.1947873831,
-0.0624458641,
0.5458968282,
0.0923703536,
-0.2309016138,
0.922029078,
1.1328667402,
0.4006415308,
0.4374750853,
-0.3333148658,
-0.0157707091,
-0.9960204363,
-0.8879737854,
-0.3652541041,
-0.0408609025,
-0.4941640794,
-0.7081847191,
0.3201653063,
-0.0308783185,
0.0516972803,
0.4360945225,
-0.7735188007,
0.7315466404,
0.3967585266,
0.2950891256,
0.5076328516,
0.2220618874,
-0.225016132,
-0.2047096789,
-0.6406978965,
-0.3157856166,
0.6517936587,
0.2493799776,
0.9199126959,
-0.4155291617,
0.8722880483,
0.105532974,
-0.1097059622,
-1.0160752535,
0.1888886988,
-0.3081941009,
-0.2825384438,
-0.1072322726,
-0.2906291783,
-0.8389245272,
0.4707607925,
-0.2772627771,
-0.741743207,
0.8099013567,
0.0411115512,
0.026329482,
0.2841702998,
-0.9854215384,
1.1640321016,
-0.0829313621,
-0.5637378097,
0.2970657349,
-0.7961506248,
0.2670567632,
-0.1460162997,
-0.0279583409,
-0.0865782797,
-0.1602328867,
0.7386410236,
-0.66323632,
0.9994654059,
0.0902718082,
-0.3091212511,
0.2081197798,
-0.2009306103,
0.1455408931,
0.1141445264,
0.4426365197,
0.2678722143,
0.1995235533,
-0.4487508237,
-0.4189688861,
0.5809733868,
-0.6962906122,
-0.2757817209,
-0.6989176273,
-0.4140937328,
-0.1452100873,
0.2171605229,
0.4081762731,
0.4597793519,
-0.1707373261,
0.3272688985,
0.967910409,
-0.1701902598,
0.4694981277,
0.0745123923,
-0.2617464066,
-0.6639929414,
0.9289140701,
-0.1119059175,
0.4062415957,
0.7447012067,
-0.0136671867,
-0.307719022,
0.0035263402,
-0.4383155704,
-0.1352228075,
-0.6022899747,
-0.2206074446,
-0.920417428,
-0.2088817805,
-0.4514174759,
-0.400514394,
-0.661064446,
-0.3273194134,
-0.1108680665,
0.2192906588,
0.2184793502,
0.3868029118,
0.1778097153,
0.3062461615,
-0.480475843,
0.5033483505,
0.4175824821,
0.2034059018,
-0.3891538084,
-0.2513584197,
-0.2444647402,
0.0241244864,
-0.4284991324,
-0.6665260196,
0.3038592935,
-0.0279792678,
0.1497885138,
0.4474334121,
0.1335495114,
0.7248117328,
-0.3090263307,
0.4920655191,
0.6858431101,
-1.0102853775,
0.6217860579,
-0.1100955755,
0.3074294329,
0.6404832602,
0.3449886739,
-0.762947619,
-0.2255956084,
-0.498957783,
-0.8507521152,
0.803050518,
0.1679353118,
-0.2739778161,
-0.0322832875,
0.0486556701,
0.4075920284,
-0.0724965557,
-0.7363177538,
-0.0736745,
-0.6007679105,
-0.3523120582,
0.1482239813,
-0.0447485521,
-0.1403213292,
-0.0489498638,
0.4249601066,
-0.4283404946,
-0.1718696058,
0.7924240828,
-0.1515268385,
0.2754401565,
-0.0238378737,
0.5836450458,
0.5529209971,
-0.0195137691,
0.5763236284,
-0.072959438,
-0.6781989932,
0.1740528792,
0.0805889815,
-0.2669522762,
-0.1628613919,
0.3124906123,
0.744820416,
0.1403091252,
-0.3613628447,
0.6686179638,
-0.1460378617,
-0.737306118,
-0.2618741095,
0.091339685,
-0.1924504191,
0.0356144086,
0.1098763347,
0.558945477,
0.0262008086,
-0.4890387654,
0.3214136362,
0.2586677372,
-0.8940435648,
0.1105197594,
0.6063084602,
0.1313827038,
0.0368207917,
0.3008376956,
0.0765560269,
-0.5632335544,
0.8956801295,
0.374298811,
0.8568737507,
-0.003220991,
0.2921557128,
0.3015520871,
0.2992162108,
-0.2019073665,
-0.2309130728,
-0.3338506222,
-0.8300203085,
-0.4553032219,
-0.4128879905,
-0.7615764141,
-0.4069365561,
-0.5924775004,
0.244584918,
-0.4066411853,
0.3531332612,
0.0961136296,
-0.1270689517,
-0.2773702145,
0.755250752,
-0.0714330301,
0.7563701868,
-0.7821043134,
1.0378869772,
0.7729686499,
-0.2767285705,
-0.6957232356,
0.0369494148,
-0.1527033448,
-0.777885437,
0.2339513749,
0.6599863172,
-0.4423092008,
-0.3743605018,
-0.8015258908,
-0.4984766245,
0.9145471454,
-0.0407690331,
-0.5608205199,
0.1469071358,
0.0514555275,
0.1473623961,
-0.7734830379,
-0.0071894894,
0.0453149006,
0.2893974483,
0.6812340617,
-0.570058167,
-0.346735388,
0.1112603173,
-0.0309580974,
0.2586201727,
-0.8582286239,
0.4203828275,
-0.1597859561,
0.042730961,
-0.0511432625,
0.752274394,
0.2167434394,
0.7895014286,
0.6978228688,
0.6728681922,
0.6131021976,
-0.1943234652,
0.6799846292,
0.2631710172,
0.4211848676,
1.3260966539,
-0.3341675103,
0.5795984268,
0.5677437782,
0.3555380106,
0.56539011,
0.7401507497,
-0.0449145995,
0.7573490143,
-0.359498471,
-0.132570222,
-0.615896821,
-0.2797880769,
-0.1257478297,
0.7554744482,
0.1437981725,
-0.4994777739,
-0.1729637086,
0.1190436706,
0.0247400161,
0.3788581491,
-0.2975246906,
0.9047946334,
0.1055161953,
-0.5567082167,
0.1998992264,
0.1115242094,
0.673353374,
-0.4486851394,
-0.1061214283,
0.0446018055,
0.1686557531,
-0.4149426818,
-0.685464561,
0.5246123672,
-0.2391408831,
-0.5038012266,
-0.2840214968,
0.7613569498,
-0.6879943609,
-0.5977603197,
0.1603173763,
0.1542692482,
0.0662106425,
-0.1980053186,
-0.2780067027,
0.2346134037,
0.113436833,
0.3132137358,
0.2592947483,
0.6059371829,
-0.2960559726,
0.3043704331,
0.3648901582,
-0.5382857919,
0.1414874792,
-0.0320695788,
0.6962686181,
-0.6552655101,
-0.4381958246,
-0.721259594,
0.2376837581,
-0.4402543902,
-0.1944654882,
0.7438521981,
1.0572545528,
1.0749316216,
0.0556865856,
0.4064317048,
0.0988361835,
0.2722334266,
-0.6662147641,
0.5030115843,
-0.7791505456,
-0.079503864,
-0.4476219118,
-1.0047085285,
-0.4123967886,
0.7585138083,
-0.3324761689,
-0.0509655848,
0.9987002611,
0.6205855012,
-0.3209605813,
0.1532395929,
0.4719399512,
-0.2846836448,
0.232862547,
0.5584798455,
0.7789658904,
-0.6448602676,
0.5879953504,
-0.4879802167,
-0.2666103244,
0.106722869,
-1.0109944344,
-0.8183066249,
-0.7081538439,
-0.715675056,
-0.1191525757,
-0.0309973955,
0.5229589343,
1.1498527527,
-0.5022082925,
0.1808422953,
-0.2617913783,
0.2900926471,
-0.2466901988,
-0.212434575,
0.544015646,
-0.3260871172,
-1.0187295675,
0.3092970252,
0.8264784813,
-0.0553455167,
0.0047181402,
0.0434473045,
-0.2558887303,
-0.0583660007,
0.5869800448,
0.1624108255,
-0.6232207417,
-0.3842419088,
0.1355015188,
-0.2347295731,
0.3793527186,
0.6315415502,
-0.8272170424,
0.8417590261,
0.1909453869,
0.7009139657,
0.7891366482,
0.2160920948,
0.1275507063,
-0.9050377607,
0.269769311,
-0.0767058954,
0.3561866283,
0.4585722387,
-0.2168766111,
0.3940951824,
0.3766995072,
-0.4502986073,
-0.1530242413,
0.3086157739,
-1.5639656782,
-0.2005875558,
0.7981151342,
-0.3529447317,
-0.6359292865,
-0.2305531204,
-0.5250182748,
0.1423384845,
-0.2690166235,
0.5903602242,
0.4760616422,
-0.0552835241,
-0.5050816536,
-0.0182460584,
0.2113464624,
0.3619939983,
-1.0197154284,
-0.1884572804,
0.6179707646,
0.3692880869,
0.3538728356,
0.4571685195,
-0.1518291533,
0.1362497807,
0.1099614576,
-0.0511417538,
-0.0574692711,
-0.7788593769,
0.0635938868,
0.418219775,
-0.500505209,
-0.8625574112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13352v1 | Sentence Identification with BOS and EOS Label Combinations | 2023-01-31T01:03:07 | 2023-01-31T01:03:07 | Takuma Udagawa, Hiroshi Kanayama, Issei Yoshida | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The sentence is a fundamental unit in many NLP applications. Sentence
segmentation is widely used as the first preprocessing task, where an input
text is split into consecutive sentences considering the end of the sentence
(EOS) as their boundaries. This task formulation relies on a strong assumption
that the input text consists only of sentences, or what we call the sentential
units (SUs). However, real-world texts often contain non-sentential units
(NSUs) such as metadata, sentence fragments, nonlinguistic markers, etc. which
are unreasonable or undesirable to be treated as a part of an SU. To tackle
this issue, we formulate a novel task of sentence identification, where the
goal is to identify SUs while excluding NSUs in a given text. To conduct
sentence identification, we propose a simple yet effective method which
combines the beginning of the sentence (BOS) and EOS labels to determine the
most probable SUs and NSUs based on dynamic programming. To evaluate this task,
we design an automatic, language-independent procedure to convert the Universal
Dependencies corpora into sentence identification benchmarks. Finally, our
experiments on the sentence identification task demonstrate that our proposed
method generally outperforms sentence segmentation baselines which only utilize
EOS labels. | [
-0.1906570196,
-0.8132602572,
0.6079910398,
0.3681180775,
-0.457264632,
0.2310225666,
-0.0713987574,
-0.706997931,
0.5398181677,
0.4059896767,
-0.7220635414,
-0.2826553285,
-0.399304539,
0.5064325333,
-0.3404342234,
1.1973235607,
0.1126461253,
-0.415915817,
-0.3307168186,
-0.1644237638,
-0.4112097919,
-0.3324828446,
-0.2120922655,
0.0214803107,
0.4816767573,
0.3562874198,
0.4260530174,
0.5979115963,
0.3852477372,
0.4001148939,
-0.3351479769,
0.36014691,
-0.2613345683,
0.301841706,
-0.07139723,
-0.1803226024,
-0.1834097356,
-0.0216988493,
0.5681920052,
0.7608866692,
-0.0275572427,
0.1331607103,
-0.118334271,
0.4620701373,
-0.646850884,
0.0399161391,
-0.4861841798,
0.2675158679,
-0.3770637214,
-0.2382126153,
-0.6607729197,
-0.3444104195,
0.2489883751,
-0.8372852802,
-0.0203416683,
0.1828636229,
1.1281725168,
0.2322870195,
-0.3135426044,
-0.4765662849,
-0.5638716221,
0.7604375482,
-0.4327233434,
0.3594250977,
0.1552007645,
-0.1832411587,
-0.2827152312,
-0.4709354937,
-0.3397881389,
-0.398537308,
-0.3946753442,
0.1867503822,
-0.2023795992,
0.0903749242,
0.327499181,
0.219612062,
-0.7458768487,
0.1806255877,
-0.345802784,
-0.3487881124,
0.4826572537,
-0.0283281934,
0.4962126613,
-0.4490294755,
-0.6519933939,
0.1772372425,
-0.3059868813,
0.0240858588,
0.2707719803,
0.1879803687,
-0.0641163513,
0.6338352561,
-0.2167707533,
0.8357701302,
-0.0381272025,
-0.2840653062,
0.4831864238,
-0.2190065682,
-0.4678917229,
0.0024091378,
1.0514216423,
0.1560184062,
0.2968169451,
-0.4473485649,
-0.2327121496,
0.0576144904,
0.3717788756,
-0.5958704948,
0.0906423479,
0.1143669188,
-0.2135298103,
-0.3768932521,
0.1939699203,
-0.7385234833,
0.0774624944,
-0.2568779886,
0.0598097295,
-0.613106966,
0.2820545733,
-0.4756230712,
-0.0207207631,
-0.0013798887,
-0.12143334,
-0.9350113273,
0.3195332885,
0.532220602,
0.8118219972,
-0.1197698861,
-0.1805136353,
-0.6849585176,
0.2241638452,
-0.2803915143,
0.7613063455,
-0.6625480056,
-0.338861078,
-0.3149957955,
0.1861164123,
0.0271497481,
-0.476125598,
0.4443877935,
-0.4874766469,
0.278701216,
0.0290204342,
-0.6111571789,
0.0633718669,
0.0985452831,
-0.5831967592,
1.0911303759,
0.3038652539,
-0.604173243,
0.3214707375,
-0.6602126956,
-0.6798475385,
0.4724713564,
-0.1042710021,
-0.4237287045,
0.3662816584,
0.2317915708,
0.218462646,
-0.1806412637,
0.5381913781,
-0.2809734046,
-0.1445939988,
0.4497385323,
-0.2543016374,
0.7957075238,
0.3811175227,
0.1698043048,
0.3411858976,
-1.1471393108,
0.1236656606,
-0.0506401956,
-0.1944822073,
-0.6379344463,
-0.121153757,
0.1536715925,
-0.1756948233,
0.2948355675,
-0.7477093935,
0.2312031537,
-0.4672029316,
0.3399902284,
0.7894602418,
0.0027173718,
0.5083606243,
0.0424680673,
0.6809262633,
-0.2968947589,
0.0766590089,
-0.4279749095,
-0.5213275552,
-0.3889053166,
-0.6029098034,
0.3010407388,
0.8218945861,
-0.8015612364,
0.7648436427,
-0.0811544731,
-0.4406529069,
-0.2004994601,
-0.0011205383,
0.567045033,
0.5625651479,
0.3634344339,
-0.021654319,
-0.8933945298,
-0.9675992131,
-0.3521085382,
-0.2908716202,
-0.2697746754,
0.0232488662,
0.3307146132,
-0.0117715541,
1.2487699986,
-0.8432025313,
-0.2468759418,
-0.3624635041,
0.2165668905,
0.0037352389,
0.231347084,
0.4147055745,
-0.7610862255,
-0.2657810152,
-0.2572090626,
-0.7885789871,
-0.8418824077,
-0.5749658346,
-0.0286521837,
0.0236554835,
0.6666646004,
-0.3012544811,
0.2427250594,
0.4655204713,
-0.4847667217,
0.5462346673,
-0.5390886068,
-0.3259049654,
-0.9356715083,
0.0874047056,
0.3217537999,
-0.241834417,
-0.5202191472,
0.133040145,
-0.033849787,
-0.1349827498,
-0.3671748638,
0.253765732,
-0.5728917122,
-0.1140678152,
-0.1154801399,
0.1411987841,
0.1410742253,
0.4233619273,
0.0787700266,
0.4850955009,
0.289496243,
-0.6107190847,
0.3346483409,
0.3626443148,
-0.4459372163,
0.4390694797,
-0.6234872341,
0.1765047312,
-0.0496015288,
0.2314085513,
-0.8336785436,
0.0162267629,
0.3459374309,
-0.2125591636,
-0.0823292285,
0.1433522701,
-0.3568354845,
-0.3197841644,
0.0304435827,
0.216492191,
0.1895458251,
-0.2338694632,
0.3980656266,
0.4583311081,
-0.1728105098,
-0.4536979795,
-0.5641987324,
0.1464011222,
-0.2404558212,
-0.4294192195,
0.7233498096,
-0.05700114,
-0.0903833434,
-0.0353126787,
0.0309127606,
-0.3106499612,
0.2878635824,
0.3975523114,
0.5502183437,
-0.0476479158,
0.1826408654,
0.2373621762,
-0.4288088679,
-0.2783583105,
-0.1639450938,
0.3259308934,
-0.1276806444,
0.0201349258,
-0.6224954724,
0.5631331205,
0.6536101103,
-0.3750478327,
0.7289482355,
0.3900324106,
-0.3176441193,
-0.1413235068,
-0.1969925165,
0.1504680216,
-0.479762733,
0.3899112642,
-0.5755416751,
-0.5713781118,
0.2003278881,
-0.0786126405,
-0.124946706,
0.0943531096,
0.1391142607,
-0.0602889583,
0.3578579426,
0.7952635884,
0.049324017,
0.5956298113,
0.1550496966,
0.3379020393,
-0.8875687718,
-0.3149537444,
-0.3238382339,
-0.3851409554,
-0.4456875026,
-0.0669516027,
0.1053802073,
0.1360742003,
0.2572982609,
0.6577349305,
-0.5958174467,
0.6182184219,
0.5980250239,
-0.0161773171,
0.0649392828,
-0.2347393483,
-0.3311806917,
-0.0830610693,
-0.2990802824,
-0.6677120924,
0.6927247047,
0.0604191236,
0.144666478,
-0.0773983523,
0.8978307843,
0.2918255329,
0.3482042253,
-0.9517433047,
1.0600459576,
-0.2618435621,
-0.2515125573,
-0.3922209442,
-0.5679042935,
-1.1267524958,
0.4184789062,
-0.2339888066,
-1.0253721476,
-0.0478525534,
-0.3177338541,
-0.6815444231,
-0.080176197,
-0.858440578,
0.8656489849,
-0.2738945484,
0.0021565256,
0.409060359,
-0.697060883,
-0.1466052085,
-0.2010409087,
0.352907151,
-0.1445743591,
-0.1467309892,
1.0529209375,
-0.7331225872,
0.55073452,
0.0238791816,
0.1258963048,
0.3749118745,
-0.1232291311,
0.2660086155,
-0.0549056791,
0.0259891972,
0.0260143597,
0.0544824935,
-0.0923338756,
-0.4393522143,
0.4917524755,
-0.461565882,
-0.2635430992,
-0.47345227,
-0.5792301297,
-0.1009486243,
0.4648259282,
0.3156083226,
0.3229490519,
-0.4358139038,
0.1616206616,
0.182450071,
-0.3140515685,
0.8180904984,
0.6554911137,
-0.1077093855,
-0.5064285398,
0.7122606635,
0.1224953681,
0.0528336279,
0.684974134,
0.4038007259,
-0.1949577779,
-0.5020199418,
-0.5014075637,
0.1185242087,
-0.206571877,
-0.004794104,
-0.57291013,
0.0340894163,
-0.4281238914,
-0.3461538851,
-0.2250305414,
-0.1714824587,
-0.3869355023,
-0.2312382907,
0.064036794,
0.4585137069,
-0.0529392734,
0.441832602,
-1.003136754,
0.5927598476,
-0.1116780713,
0.0763769671,
-0.4636429548,
-0.2585535347,
0.0512031168,
-0.3612341881,
-0.1865935922,
-1.3682866096,
0.7484232187,
0.2168799341,
0.5180496573,
0.7144331336,
0.2808426321,
0.6083804369,
-0.581228137,
0.5152449012,
0.3159204423,
-1.0439727306,
0.8221663833,
-0.1270011514,
0.3443065882,
0.5138319135,
0.2115114033,
-0.6070332527,
-0.6463105083,
-0.5801968575,
-1.2377644777,
0.8188518286,
0.4281764328,
-0.1704503447,
-0.349282831,
0.3276770115,
0.1272855401,
0.1323968023,
-0.9451588988,
-0.1654181629,
0.313611269,
-0.3870309591,
0.076629214,
-0.2446808964,
0.0338717476,
0.1172991544,
0.6120231748,
0.1464374661,
0.0473144241,
0.2130188197,
-0.477052778,
0.1003875434,
0.4319417477,
0.4450186491,
0.4142723978,
-0.1831520796,
0.0231048763,
-0.0641462132,
-0.4695498943,
0.2739466429,
-0.0105114449,
-0.6268050671,
0.2784164846,
0.3733190298,
0.7602208853,
0.2454613447,
-0.770173192,
0.3154974282,
0.2652629018,
0.1676950753,
-0.338619262,
-0.1591985971,
-0.2381134033,
0.1660255045,
0.4184283614,
0.0190835055,
0.0842804685,
-0.6450148225,
0.4805677235,
0.2385431528,
-0.3319202363,
-0.3370150626,
0.3995467424,
0.314738214,
-0.6914069057,
0.6752311587,
-0.4985001981,
-0.6024731398,
0.9104850292,
0.64733845,
0.9650121927,
-0.3959378302,
0.5615367293,
0.1534770131,
0.4922497571,
0.1556357741,
0.1649222076,
0.0236902647,
-0.8303842545,
-0.4173853695,
-0.7584286332,
-0.1972453743,
0.2254500687,
-0.977202177,
0.3779130578,
-0.4211322665,
-0.0239249356,
0.3548554182,
-0.3517774642,
-0.3102989793,
0.4485580623,
0.580901444,
0.2593547404,
-1.2182799578,
0.7896047831,
0.8010908961,
-0.3032227159,
-0.5327831507,
-0.0370582379,
-0.0523151793,
-0.4990003407,
0.7707315087,
0.4784550369,
-0.0791537762,
-0.2170912176,
-0.1987370998,
-0.7210528851,
0.7639527321,
0.3093118668,
-0.6629425883,
-0.1073613912,
0.1134837493,
0.5258771181,
-0.4876278341,
0.4335630238,
0.2664652169,
0.4367828965,
0.2469204962,
-0.8691465259,
0.3018136919,
-0.1955132037,
0.0201541837,
0.3235616684,
-0.4399431348,
0.6474845409,
-0.3751960993,
-0.3520558178,
0.1943087429,
0.792986691,
0.354537189,
0.5456097722,
0.7771546245,
0.6165137887,
1.2281142473,
-0.1322827041,
0.7309371829,
-0.1044395268,
0.295576185,
1.2783309221,
-0.2948764861,
0.7003446817,
0.4900414348,
-0.2082064897,
0.7580490708,
0.6303178072,
-0.326217711,
0.7091853023,
0.4094797671,
-0.1007121131,
0.0701726303,
-0.0005882892,
-0.1738040745,
0.6955841184,
0.3396264017,
-0.4232417345,
-0.0459451899,
0.2725041509,
0.0925495252,
-0.0531690754,
0.082148172,
0.7416132092,
-0.1120691523,
-0.7688073516,
0.282730937,
0.1572942883,
0.5206463337,
-0.7529126406,
0.2729317546,
-0.0580611564,
0.1233948022,
-0.2154214233,
-0.4525474906,
0.6887078881,
0.1310428977,
-0.1574283838,
-0.5273008347,
0.4805964231,
-0.2901840508,
-0.6389715075,
0.2583244741,
0.3105131984,
0.2780149579,
-0.0432842076,
-0.426179558,
-0.1161434948,
0.1500454098,
-0.2780924439,
0.1400905997,
0.6881451607,
0.0285279304,
0.5938476324,
0.682013154,
0.0719793737,
-0.0797328651,
0.0127247991,
0.5401815176,
-0.8726955056,
-1.0043474436,
-1.0440714359,
0.3509528339,
-0.2390105128,
-0.5681988001,
0.6157785654,
0.8201403022,
0.5160016418,
-0.0944299474,
0.7077226639,
-0.1591659933,
0.3092683554,
-0.4213849604,
0.4124247134,
-0.4116726518,
0.3571919501,
-0.4429011047,
-0.9302443862,
-0.3693029583,
0.6364158392,
-0.2252944559,
-0.4839531779,
1.0787475109,
0.3928658068,
0.1153567061,
0.2838901281,
0.2787569463,
0.0717529133,
0.2626929879,
0.5723102689,
0.7232887149,
-0.1865406036,
0.6750609279,
-0.2259627283,
-0.4751034379,
-0.2534568608,
-0.9497622848,
-0.5306433439,
-0.3875406682,
-0.6824760437,
-0.1854309887,
-0.108783938,
0.8287940621,
0.5688003898,
-0.778635323,
-0.1538729519,
-0.2941243649,
0.1153104082,
-0.4347770214,
-0.2236859649,
0.1785682738,
-0.287109822,
-0.8111057878,
0.8046191931,
0.5108513236,
-0.0289333109,
0.1736422628,
0.2645345032,
-0.2431427538,
0.2203290313,
0.7027981877,
0.2996869981,
-0.718966186,
-0.3433800042,
0.0995257273,
0.0427122004,
0.0277261995,
0.7891863585,
-0.95252949,
0.4591813684,
0.5195688605,
0.341249615,
0.1848399341,
-0.0810682178,
0.5190620422,
-1.0383529663,
0.3169706166,
0.2318408191,
0.4785804451,
0.1049883515,
-0.3262870312,
0.5603852272,
0.4811292589,
-0.2773763537,
-0.9635561109,
0.3245348036,
-1.4101275206,
-0.4321647584,
1.161436677,
-0.3956965804,
-0.184933424,
-0.168003276,
-0.1137023494,
0.4094426036,
-0.3636969626,
0.6334462166,
0.7093302011,
-0.1905436516,
0.0226144362,
-0.1221445501,
0.0089634163,
0.4300936162,
-0.9447523355,
-0.2140408009,
0.5693892241,
0.0021870153,
0.5056714416,
0.5538942218,
0.0979391932,
-0.3383036256,
-0.037687473,
-0.0167777296,
-0.1495964527,
-0.4325272441,
0.1033555716,
0.5837164521,
-0.7183830738,
-0.657338202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13345v1 | Differentiable Entailment for Parameter Efficient Few Shot Learning | 2023-01-31T00:31:11 | 2023-01-31T00:31:11 | Ethan Kim, Jerry Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few-shot learning allows pre-trained language models to adapt to downstream
tasks while using a limited number of training examples. However, practical
applications are limited when all model parameters must be optimized. In this
work we apply a new technique for parameter efficient few shot learning while
adopting a strict definition of parameter efficiency. Our training method
combines 1) intermediate training by reformulating natural language tasks as
entailment tasks \cite{wang_entailment_2021} and 2) differentiable optimization
of template and label tokens \cite{zhang_differentiable_2021}. We quantify the
tradeoff between parameter efficiency and performance in the few-shot regime
and propose a simple model agnostic approach that can be extended to any task
By achieving competitive performance while only optimizing 3\% of a model's
parameters and allowing for batched inference, we allow for more efficient
practical deployment of models. | [
-0.1196907237,
-0.8051514626,
0.4742987454,
-0.04265422,
-0.3817816377,
-0.4420470893,
-0.2127549648,
-0.178603366,
-0.0323345996,
0.4040514827,
-0.6514183283,
-0.5087747574,
-0.6710006595,
0.0733941197,
-0.1167687848,
0.7082757354,
-0.1612523049,
-0.0668466687,
-0.0024757287,
-0.2505541444,
0.0018407088,
-0.2348870635,
-0.8455945849,
-0.3533449173,
0.6023802757,
0.4132860899,
0.2629185617,
0.7021124959,
0.7347243428,
0.2520849705,
0.1250476092,
0.1476465315,
-0.5829584599,
0.0087324521,
0.0663854629,
-0.8472895026,
-0.2785607278,
0.2297651619,
0.7351964712,
0.583768189,
-0.1923619807,
0.2363140732,
0.1331507713,
0.6630675793,
-1.033891201,
0.0256520286,
-0.7332106829,
-0.0788474306,
-0.2860686481,
-0.2362627536,
-0.4298329651,
-0.4513794482,
0.0322072655,
-0.9045058489,
0.1332577467,
-0.106338501,
0.9120977521,
0.4645709395,
-0.1407293081,
0.0857063159,
-0.5436192751,
0.9903751612,
-1.0199706554,
0.5469566584,
0.5212951899,
0.7450398803,
-0.050289344,
-0.9934452176,
-0.4395797253,
-0.3463160396,
0.0655449703,
0.1139908805,
-0.1967091411,
0.2891474664,
0.3824253082,
-0.0450982526,
-0.2234974056,
0.2498792857,
-0.1647632867,
-0.1154038683,
0.4248259962,
0.2823248506,
-0.0865753293,
0.1943411529,
-0.119775407,
0.0721640587,
-0.7704570293,
0.1817895472,
0.7436543703,
0.5723429918,
-0.1663529575,
0.5265443921,
-0.5603896976,
0.9644083977,
0.0782486573,
-0.4986305833,
-0.0368896313,
-0.339722842,
-0.3096272349,
-0.341039896,
0.2991227806,
-0.0230419729,
0.0501313657,
-0.0964971408,
-0.2479928136,
-0.0589354672,
0.243040055,
-0.9813711047,
-0.1320926845,
-0.0844007358,
-0.490642637,
-0.1739574373,
-0.2195895761,
-0.2569183409,
0.0324604921,
-0.3560872972,
0.6230370998,
-0.6637890935,
0.139513582,
0.2262876928,
-0.2814278305,
0.2702967823,
0.4915031791,
-0.9576041698,
0.3539156914,
0.7849390507,
0.8995674849,
0.0264796615,
-0.4402090907,
-0.8280957341,
0.1951486021,
-0.3578210771,
0.7498574257,
-0.8170171976,
-0.1001575217,
-0.1810329258,
-0.3108924329,
-0.2128744721,
-0.477530092,
0.3844622374,
-0.4323549867,
-0.0077658561,
-0.0832039416,
-0.7662692666,
-0.5465889573,
0.4614098668,
-0.4922787547,
0.8316575885,
0.0779760852,
-0.6649888158,
0.7757266164,
-0.6200597882,
-0.3391625285,
0.0880851448,
-0.1074635461,
-0.3855879009,
0.1539838314,
-0.1290701479,
0.5273002386,
-0.3422439992,
-0.1454337686,
-0.3271371424,
-0.495950222,
-0.0545744933,
-0.4305938482,
0.609936893,
0.1469779015,
-0.1169114932,
0.0584797114,
-0.7638555765,
-0.0311829709,
-0.21059452,
-0.8293361068,
-0.3381190002,
-0.129150182,
-0.21309416,
-0.1217917651,
0.0999811068,
-0.3239479363,
0.3318322003,
-0.6737205982,
-0.0129082799,
0.5293582678,
0.2329686135,
0.6460804343,
-0.4430984557,
0.5322861075,
0.0150232241,
0.223987639,
0.0886241347,
-0.4525991976,
-0.8872779608,
-0.8038257957,
0.4607166648,
0.2667449415,
-0.6305873394,
0.0169540271,
0.2177831531,
-0.5526522994,
-0.5480062962,
0.4017886221,
0.4361551106,
0.4360831082,
0.2117010802,
-0.1328718513,
-0.4970051646,
-0.9866328239,
-0.6688078046,
-0.0553429499,
0.0366508476,
-0.0100999083,
0.6453940272,
-0.0915724114,
0.808329761,
-0.6933792233,
-0.2255750149,
-0.5267137885,
0.316965431,
0.3340075016,
0.5507393479,
0.6857714057,
-0.5057774782,
-0.7589349747,
-0.0915722325,
-0.3840745687,
0.1535772979,
-0.2312495559,
-0.2583572268,
0.0678843707,
0.4426435232,
-0.3564353883,
0.3321022689,
0.0996360779,
0.1988477558,
0.3916684091,
-0.2011226565,
0.0379693136,
-0.8374577761,
-0.1686203927,
0.278105557,
-0.4204263389,
-0.8738547564,
0.3182958663,
-0.1080668494,
0.346564889,
-0.8943386674,
0.4723458886,
-0.33991009,
0.3282440603,
-0.4276857376,
-0.1075117737,
-0.0876483843,
0.5422911644,
0.1153558642,
0.245099321,
0.965816915,
-0.8824054599,
0.1928449124,
-0.1531782597,
-0.1753353029,
0.4512473047,
-0.5194216371,
0.150975585,
-0.3425367773,
0.0611231811,
-0.6704456806,
-0.3461013138,
0.4471815526,
-0.1739764214,
0.3288395405,
-0.4078834951,
-0.4883256853,
0.2185586989,
-0.4944878519,
0.1336526573,
0.6048931479,
-0.353192389,
0.5111860633,
0.0433088206,
0.3055926561,
-0.3566141725,
-0.67810601,
-0.5401881933,
-0.4543535709,
-0.2663686872,
0.3361079097,
0.1736704707,
-0.2417430133,
-0.1336498708,
-0.1478423029,
-0.4432755709,
0.1896611303,
-0.1608119309,
0.0336428657,
-0.3580877483,
0.1756730974,
0.1666683108,
-0.18422997,
-0.5056322217,
-0.2643541694,
0.2443504333,
-0.1065499038,
-0.5454003811,
-0.6197418571,
0.342954427,
-0.1117011532,
0.1021862105,
0.8557437658,
0.6378368139,
-0.7054904699,
-0.1708939075,
-0.4840693474,
-0.476408273,
-0.4772447646,
0.2800791562,
-0.6174505949,
-0.5191140771,
0.3509014845,
-0.1952819973,
0.2653737962,
0.4598184824,
0.4282494485,
0.1121556163,
0.7926755548,
0.8668298125,
0.1860248595,
0.4933888316,
-0.4339383245,
0.0214487836,
-0.5640410185,
-0.0730211511,
-0.5298834443,
-0.384973079,
-0.6530017853,
-0.5163642168,
0.2845466435,
0.4198537171,
-0.3435335159,
0.5073006749,
-0.0973235294,
0.6126092672,
0.6910667419,
0.2282365561,
0.3634128869,
-0.2836777568,
0.0133532267,
-0.1612648964,
-0.909681201,
-0.5586668849,
1.0663509369,
0.2017270327,
0.9173057079,
0.269203037,
1.1511483192,
-0.2031513005,
0.1956259459,
-0.9935161471,
0.449131757,
-0.241154626,
-0.6623650789,
-0.4665545225,
-0.1850839406,
-0.7004377246,
0.1902581006,
-0.2349745482,
-0.8596995473,
0.1193724871,
0.3611371219,
-0.3865811825,
0.147559762,
-0.7247548103,
0.7700017691,
0.0488414727,
-0.4850521088,
-0.197713241,
-0.4999915063,
0.185280934,
-0.130497545,
-0.3365595341,
-0.3745834529,
-0.3239767551,
0.8392504454,
-0.3633956015,
1.0316736698,
-0.4311040938,
0.3866687119,
0.418960005,
-0.0631147251,
0.6126507521,
-0.0354403071,
-0.3143033683,
-0.2212575078,
-0.0757711679,
-0.5655267835,
-0.7550278306,
0.3082412183,
-0.4619008303,
-0.6099197268,
-0.1241725385,
-0.287024647,
-0.2383145988,
0.2799780667,
0.632206738,
0.4242036641,
-0.0267618317,
0.2563856244,
0.3202695251,
0.1921253949,
0.6206861138,
0.4504367113,
0.3074352741,
0.2196585238,
0.7582182288,
0.2540868223,
0.3840761483,
0.6325999498,
0.4479404092,
-0.3838331103,
-0.7715224028,
-0.0236964058,
0.2050090283,
-1.0070055723,
-0.2798962593,
-0.3667374551,
0.0271209925,
-0.3293118477,
-0.392200917,
-0.6526354551,
-0.5287514925,
-0.4732514322,
-0.0111088241,
0.4060091376,
0.42260921,
-0.0208471194,
0.6095671654,
-0.5210812092,
0.4046721458,
0.4406870604,
0.3724423349,
-0.1497244984,
-0.7611575723,
-0.3064227104,
-0.0024000504,
-0.4814026356,
-0.8351169825,
0.3114971519,
0.7544413805,
1.081340909,
0.671081841,
0.1813113242,
0.7742477059,
-0.4723109603,
0.5520157218,
0.3367644548,
-0.9988164902,
0.5343925953,
-0.1524606943,
0.2868148983,
0.861142695,
0.7585930228,
-0.1543442309,
-0.3747319579,
-0.4450074732,
-0.7323231697,
0.7489388585,
0.2047434747,
0.209788844,
0.2411281317,
0.4588012695,
0.5272632837,
0.0453723446,
-0.5457208157,
-0.2118717879,
-0.0612744354,
-0.0862511694,
0.0270774178,
0.0234245583,
-0.2627241313,
-0.4040161073,
0.7865380645,
-0.4611858726,
0.2478761971,
-0.1647932976,
-0.1898343265,
0.363483578,
0.3701859415,
0.492344588,
0.5138301849,
-0.2299198955,
0.1612799466,
0.4829857945,
-0.1922990978,
0.2281481326,
-0.1452375501,
-0.1369668543,
-0.0377426445,
0.4500299692,
1.0189307928,
0.1420951039,
-0.2609051466,
0.3493520319,
0.2940507829,
-0.4256266356,
0.1736751646,
0.3748326898,
0.0165901948,
0.4435893297,
0.2679160535,
0.0417723842,
0.4424991608,
-0.3684414327,
0.2113130242,
0.2908637226,
-0.2731924057,
-0.2827579975,
0.5739818811,
0.1444906592,
-0.289783448,
0.1550187021,
-0.4919813871,
-0.1032823846,
0.419505477,
0.6482745409,
1.1361343861,
0.113719821,
0.2920074761,
0.3566551507,
0.217960149,
-0.2378727496,
0.1669737101,
-0.0736350566,
-0.7879046798,
-0.3512426019,
-0.4792357981,
-0.5825253725,
-0.1131314114,
-0.5141880512,
0.569480598,
-0.470405221,
-0.230338648,
0.2864914834,
-0.1497979015,
-0.886819303,
0.1001233906,
-0.1281778365,
0.8437849283,
-0.7557243109,
0.8443652987,
0.8291034102,
-0.461684525,
-0.765017271,
0.2868539989,
-0.0349306948,
-0.5039681196,
0.8416885734,
0.1139270216,
-0.4172410071,
0.0570437536,
-0.5004778504,
-0.5627420545,
0.7521016598,
0.7573999763,
-0.3928007185,
-0.0049482239,
-0.0465166792,
0.3784558773,
-0.4716880918,
0.2790648639,
0.6131017208,
0.4631769657,
0.0993139744,
-0.5660242438,
0.0117520327,
0.0021365625,
0.1046997309,
-0.0278272778,
-0.5421026349,
0.5669229031,
-0.2637327313,
-0.15494138,
-0.2190636694,
0.565764308,
0.2429733276,
0.3615934849,
0.3721874952,
0.3081922531,
0.604352355,
-0.0223689824,
1.0720052719,
0.1142610833,
0.3926254511,
0.9040648341,
-0.1272528023,
0.9682686925,
0.5622856617,
-0.4509930313,
0.16720137,
0.6955005527,
0.3727551401,
0.8201141953,
0.1761484742,
-0.3350970149,
-0.4609664977,
0.1482871771,
-0.0523623936,
0.7781826258,
-0.0191754755,
0.0919682086,
-0.4298046529,
0.0165926628,
-0.0403393246,
0.0119040171,
-0.1325808913,
0.8900687695,
0.0088834558,
-0.5284789205,
0.795127809,
0.2265677601,
0.8342536092,
-0.746244967,
-0.0450379699,
-0.075613305,
0.1724020094,
-0.1995201558,
-0.2744371891,
0.4313932657,
0.0170251299,
0.0208883528,
0.0416979417,
0.6704798937,
-0.331191659,
-0.4833491743,
-0.1229493767,
0.3567394018,
0.2047032714,
-0.0128005333,
-0.6184056997,
-0.356641233,
-0.2060078681,
-0.3899753094,
0.1936774105,
0.2289882153,
0.2545615733,
0.6205862761,
0.3620377779,
0.1412150711,
0.2613656819,
0.1899641603,
0.764667809,
-0.430427134,
-0.584589541,
-1.0109740496,
0.5409454703,
0.0133575182,
-0.4347383082,
0.6971045136,
0.6272829175,
0.8648391962,
-0.2295266092,
0.6861848235,
0.1559013724,
0.3323208988,
-0.7920250297,
0.373552233,
-0.6683405638,
0.1977130324,
-0.1328408867,
-0.8103555441,
-0.4646446109,
0.5918067694,
-0.4083699584,
0.0130525157,
0.7791817784,
0.7605076432,
-0.1152851284,
-0.2036934346,
0.5829029083,
-0.4122425318,
0.1078005582,
0.4154657722,
0.6153123975,
-0.3159464598,
0.209535867,
-0.4612698257,
-0.0816644356,
-0.3116436899,
-1.0371843576,
-0.6946130991,
-0.5840200186,
-0.5720650554,
0.1700567305,
0.2349181175,
0.991157949,
1.0508720875,
-0.6958923936,
-0.1062280461,
-0.3013406992,
0.1706560254,
-0.4175376296,
-0.1701744199,
0.1255094111,
-0.6506660581,
-1.0076388121,
0.3230423629,
0.3140232861,
0.1686198115,
0.0679593086,
-0.2350383699,
-0.4734328091,
0.3296015263,
0.4838235974,
0.2379927784,
-0.6456851363,
-0.3174195588,
-0.0247458983,
-0.0091630155,
0.0574377701,
0.9333354235,
-0.5646464825,
0.4567283988,
0.7748631239,
0.7359484434,
0.8378303051,
-0.1462358236,
0.4175425172,
-1.176512599,
0.6035857797,
0.2582002878,
0.185619995,
0.2387014627,
-0.1804327816,
0.4133691788,
0.2533303797,
-0.1149886474,
-0.717094481,
0.4317204952,
-0.8417739272,
-0.2777757347,
1.2845833302,
-0.4076163173,
-0.1285856813,
0.0224044751,
-0.0606628209,
0.5573929548,
-0.3468538523,
0.3340597451,
0.4124846756,
-0.5480912328,
-0.1066511124,
-0.4912531972,
0.6091246009,
0.3413952589,
-1.0036613941,
-0.4159190655,
0.1777464151,
0.2921356261,
-0.2602880597,
0.7983905673,
0.2634736896,
0.287021935,
0.4505109489,
-0.3256160617,
-0.0558563657,
-0.3607251346,
-0.1712976098,
0.0771025941,
0.3859885037,
-0.7175819874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00003v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00003v1 | The Power of External Memory in Increasing Predictive Model Capacity | 2023-01-31T00:29:39 | 2023-01-31T00:29:39 | Cenk Baykal, Dylan J Cutler, Nishanth Dikkala, Nikhil Ghosh, Rina Panigrahy, Xin Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | One way of introducing sparsity into deep networks is by attaching an
external table of parameters that is sparsely looked up at different layers of
the network. By storing the bulk of the parameters in the external table, one
can increase the capacity of the model without necessarily increasing the
inference time. Two crucial questions in this setting are then: what is the
lookup function for accessing the table and how are the contents of the table
consumed? Prominent methods for accessing the table include 1) using
words/wordpieces token-ids as table indices, 2) LSH hashing the token vector in
each layer into a table of buckets, and 3) learnable softmax style routing to a
table entry. The ways to consume the contents include adding/concatenating to
input representation, and using the contents as expert networks that specialize
to different inputs. In this work, we conduct rigorous experimental evaluations
of existing ideas and their combinations. We also introduce a new method,
alternating updates, that enables access to an increased token dimension
without increasing the computation time, and demonstrate its effectiveness in
language modeling. | [
-0.597050488,
-0.6478675008,
0.4420309067,
-0.1769240499,
-0.1602440923,
-0.3223657608,
-0.3313525617,
-0.501781702,
0.1550159007,
0.4993076324,
-0.4794550836,
0.050583262,
-0.6049472094,
-0.2564077079,
-0.5343261361,
1.0301009417,
-0.0118312957,
0.20935978,
-0.0302758254,
-0.3361954987,
-0.6801308393,
-0.6351642609,
-0.8341960907,
-0.1906760335,
0.7264919877,
0.4864546061,
0.9485169649,
0.7139620185,
0.6303899884,
0.40730685,
0.0195566751,
0.3494507968,
-0.4613437057,
0.1561696231,
-0.1882516444,
-0.5939828157,
-0.2067383528,
-0.2485663444,
1.0853070021,
0.7066711783,
-0.0487164296,
0.0027795178,
0.0519183986,
0.817683816,
-0.4170822203,
0.347890079,
-0.9959934354,
0.0861156881,
-0.1257055998,
-0.2307657599,
-0.4127001464,
-0.0277905352,
0.2759033442,
-0.4183429182,
0.1990735978,
0.0425329804,
0.5527821183,
0.1920512319,
-0.1068534479,
-0.1406460106,
-0.8007524014,
0.3895871341,
-0.4422720075,
0.6706256866,
0.3918977678,
0.3200163543,
-0.1889264137,
-0.8266460896,
-0.4976044595,
-0.5891192555,
-0.2191080302,
-0.2188398242,
0.0585535094,
0.1239075735,
0.4537010789,
0.384152472,
-0.2293787748,
-0.0293507371,
-0.4550810754,
0.1602178067,
0.4316089153,
0.3038961887,
0.2609912157,
0.3578266501,
-0.0636455491,
-0.1661007553,
-0.6478397846,
-0.1615595818,
0.3323279619,
0.7795157433,
0.0784029141,
0.8273113966,
-0.1062096953,
0.7323912382,
0.06486734,
0.5172755122,
-0.0640188903,
-0.4693402052,
-0.2029405534,
-0.0408058874,
0.3520135581,
-0.1347830594,
0.1923028678,
-0.2384903133,
-0.023846969,
-0.3919785619,
0.5041013956,
-0.7632235885,
-0.4188125432,
0.0792325735,
-0.4070557654,
-0.0381378643,
0.1520524323,
-0.7066146135,
-0.5365051031,
-0.341162473,
0.7372648716,
-0.4229981601,
-0.2210981995,
-0.1645961255,
-0.2303988934,
-0.105630286,
0.0305552147,
-0.9157462716,
0.8099694848,
0.4551861584,
1.0060007572,
-0.1661028564,
-0.1417093575,
-0.5711092949,
0.1630306542,
-0.3662005365,
0.5919023752,
-0.5050989985,
-0.2727554739,
-0.0255267285,
0.0843488201,
0.0238972828,
-0.3052682281,
0.094022043,
-0.6932271123,
-0.0053705149,
-0.6551118493,
-0.4479027987,
-0.3022337854,
-0.0362772048,
-1.0846937895,
1.0566658974,
0.0691625625,
-0.77016294,
0.3765536547,
-0.7835667729,
-0.4273529649,
-0.0849514678,
-0.0844026878,
-0.4091641605,
0.4802934825,
0.0267857108,
0.4975734949,
-0.0232649855,
0.2787615955,
-0.3459308147,
-0.3450884819,
0.6553063989,
-0.4248469472,
0.3123765886,
-0.0253946036,
-0.2595311105,
0.2244645804,
-0.7789629698,
-0.0892148688,
0.1796083301,
-0.4190109372,
-0.3964472711,
0.2092659324,
-0.1624559909,
0.122318238,
-0.0203693341,
-0.213976711,
0.1592887789,
-0.5866497755,
0.3335789144,
0.9144194722,
-0.0070510348,
0.4953105748,
-0.4675028622,
0.053693004,
0.2655137777,
-0.1707699895,
-0.1358835995,
-0.4308243394,
-1.0518952608,
0.1669684947,
0.4048038125,
0.2883095741,
-0.5104525685,
0.0988160148,
-0.1655679792,
-0.4674587846,
-0.3908898234,
0.1857434809,
0.2314546406,
0.4127089977,
0.5667558908,
-0.3082531393,
-0.5779418349,
-0.8598630428,
-0.1810729504,
0.030026827,
0.2385660559,
0.6796137094,
0.4146944284,
0.0809500143,
0.4995082617,
-0.4677416384,
-0.0866616368,
-0.4464581609,
-0.1400005966,
0.2374489456,
0.6848370433,
0.2728159726,
-0.5831820965,
-0.3485223651,
0.0644854456,
-0.3706305027,
0.3476585746,
-0.1621883512,
-0.2477017045,
-0.05953563,
0.296427846,
-0.7706452012,
0.311681509,
0.2265362591,
-0.2389376909,
0.1964346319,
-0.3455196619,
0.0000821995,
-0.9094451666,
0.1595372856,
0.0647544041,
-0.0943387747,
-0.8056327105,
0.3240175843,
-0.0725249276,
-0.2901938558,
-0.3219207525,
0.7954130769,
-0.6891967058,
-0.4022499025,
-0.2716892958,
-0.0219120439,
-0.0705926195,
0.4894984961,
-0.0175611209,
0.9228129983,
0.4517786503,
-0.8625010848,
0.2149971128,
-0.1151218191,
-0.1485647261,
0.0603575334,
-0.5891724825,
0.2329477221,
-0.2601564825,
0.0179210324,
-1.1370435953,
-0.0695368126,
0.1955235302,
-0.3414796293,
0.7437725663,
-0.1338686943,
-0.3077026606,
-0.0942056105,
-0.1471488625,
0.3400097787,
0.3758997023,
-0.6027529836,
0.8505817056,
0.7254474163,
0.0249329805,
-0.6652573347,
-0.8027248979,
0.0057484675,
-0.1019748896,
-0.6260938644,
0.39086169,
-0.0834260434,
-0.3995674253,
0.1925436854,
0.1119626313,
0.0156839304,
0.0215629116,
0.2287075818,
0.1638913304,
-0.3762793243,
0.3784477711,
-0.1180185452,
-0.1369503587,
-0.023011975,
-0.529376626,
0.6608507633,
-0.2168336809,
-0.0663091838,
-0.3361240625,
0.5027441382,
0.1193013713,
0.1600299329,
0.9691721797,
0.6666354537,
-0.7171003819,
-0.3526630402,
-0.7020253539,
-0.3841937482,
-0.534234643,
0.7384162545,
-0.5481725931,
-0.5575876832,
0.7482469082,
0.330496639,
0.0543323979,
0.5102735162,
0.5591070652,
0.1620782614,
1.0116744041,
0.7531143427,
-0.0431349017,
0.5818481445,
-0.3973854184,
0.0207396336,
-0.9621310234,
-0.2465927452,
-0.5329163671,
-0.4652810097,
-0.4437370896,
-0.6964757442,
0.046340216,
-0.2585108876,
-0.2608325779,
0.4628373682,
-0.4383800924,
0.436506331,
0.7400621176,
0.2606317103,
0.1119707525,
0.1244237125,
-0.2907620966,
-0.0717916191,
-0.9102863073,
0.0913994089,
1.032815218,
0.5071974993,
0.7238826156,
-0.0784895644,
0.3034881949,
0.1502731442,
0.3913112581,
-0.8864526749,
0.6775249839,
-0.2343455702,
-0.7037297487,
-0.3395666778,
-0.511921525,
-0.7031278014,
0.3624602854,
-0.1595958024,
-0.6602158546,
0.3114423454,
0.3404920995,
-0.300753355,
0.6346624494,
-0.7585758567,
0.5102843046,
-0.2198639959,
-0.7504004836,
-0.34935534,
-0.2818226218,
0.1762751937,
0.2566670179,
-0.0443759672,
0.1933614463,
-0.3371958733,
0.9101739526,
-0.4887464941,
0.7880395651,
-0.3146961033,
0.1251281649,
0.4863438904,
0.2059779763,
0.7447553873,
0.1508150995,
-0.2668862343,
0.2411853969,
-0.2120995969,
-0.0654388294,
-0.7219914794,
0.8891996145,
-0.8281674981,
-0.6187695861,
-0.4274727404,
-0.6208021045,
-0.5011820197,
0.1768250763,
-0.0441906899,
0.6298112273,
-0.0625605583,
0.2388565838,
0.6094179749,
-0.1855694801,
0.4391219616,
0.3069145083,
0.203990072,
-0.3178981543,
1.0221084356,
0.6882620454,
0.1243543997,
0.3665768802,
0.4548452795,
-0.3641252816,
-0.7663782239,
-0.4762673974,
0.0234653689,
-0.7710196376,
-0.3142703176,
-0.8679462671,
-0.5495200753,
-0.2372285575,
0.0089734774,
-0.34130615,
-0.5741326809,
-0.2813089192,
-0.354026705,
0.4681620598,
0.7420327067,
-0.3153880835,
0.4111342132,
-0.5798857808,
0.1859980375,
0.1935786605,
0.6514972448,
0.4568372965,
-0.5687962174,
-0.3819288909,
-0.117615357,
0.0834326893,
-0.9065637589,
0.3840556443,
0.1887843311,
0.7351413965,
0.3539586365,
-0.4026889503,
0.9336352348,
-0.58374089,
0.4925716519,
-0.0221474618,
-0.8323329687,
0.2615032792,
-0.1640864462,
0.0637942925,
0.6108210683,
0.4145163298,
-0.3952600956,
-0.0561408885,
-0.6320323944,
-0.9156528711,
0.6333492994,
-0.0787968561,
0.5284950137,
0.0069241063,
0.6262052059,
0.2518175244,
0.1536835134,
-0.8763352633,
-0.1520144045,
-0.0839647204,
-0.064195171,
0.0546826683,
-0.4893142283,
-0.0079041868,
-0.2893314064,
0.7898409963,
-0.0587415174,
0.5300030708,
-0.0099900393,
0.2530381382,
-0.1161382794,
-0.0324359946,
0.4426562786,
0.7315729856,
-0.1511503756,
0.2988499701,
0.5188567638,
-0.5932155848,
-0.157036528,
0.0882283151,
-0.0600403622,
-0.0049349573,
0.0613142699,
0.8542178869,
0.2459108084,
-0.4141709805,
0.1868562996,
-0.1849674582,
-0.0793878138,
-0.4561068118,
0.198360309,
0.0356194898,
0.1633383632,
0.264565438,
0.0884192362,
0.2951157987,
-0.7352253795,
0.3320425451,
0.6758565903,
-0.7635739446,
-0.1474790722,
0.4367320538,
-0.0764923543,
-0.285051614,
0.5488490462,
0.0922851488,
-0.2158553302,
0.5630756021,
0.7370615602,
0.6054420471,
-0.166227743,
-0.1208365187,
0.4858145714,
0.4417031407,
-0.0481378287,
0.3821820617,
0.0765968636,
-0.7704846859,
-0.2596813738,
-0.350728333,
-0.2478295416,
0.3900822699,
-0.4217109978,
0.0869404227,
-0.6650389433,
-0.2984752953,
-0.0583991818,
0.2402373701,
-0.8879011273,
0.1762183458,
-0.0794545114,
0.9042622447,
-0.5528277755,
0.6721869707,
0.1716713458,
-0.4544471502,
-0.7560524344,
-0.2693395317,
-0.2948594391,
-1.044059515,
0.5321157575,
0.1717094332,
0.1094272658,
-0.1703766733,
-0.3616390526,
-1.4161778688,
0.7137621045,
0.0951463208,
-0.5497990847,
-0.2283494025,
-0.0744666234,
0.3053759634,
-0.3550077081,
0.2713102698,
0.3609182537,
0.5225429535,
-0.0283531379,
-0.356333822,
0.4592164159,
-0.331446588,
0.0275229774,
0.3406152427,
-0.2975252569,
0.9010421038,
-0.4468013942,
-0.2560993433,
-0.0685823336,
0.928614974,
-0.0177930202,
-0.1216548011,
0.3554705083,
0.4231556952,
0.7290244102,
-0.0012845834,
1.1552637815,
-0.2527524531,
-0.1572578847,
1.4593799114,
-0.1692629755,
0.8682750463,
0.4528789818,
-0.1767813414,
0.3462308645,
0.4020388424,
-0.3015664518,
0.5555647612,
0.5052253008,
-0.0301551782,
0.0743467808,
-0.1186566502,
-0.5180833936,
0.1114274934,
0.6582810283,
-0.5580363274,
0.1015986353,
-0.1399932802,
-0.1081940904,
-0.2204908133,
-0.5284720659,
1.0542429686,
0.1788537949,
-0.6803638935,
0.0969475806,
0.2889484763,
0.2509831488,
-0.6343171,
-0.1910967976,
0.0868619308,
0.3402448893,
-0.0793958083,
-0.6214244366,
0.4398244321,
-0.3960886896,
0.0206767637,
0.2901908755,
0.8849098086,
-0.3890792727,
-0.7281392217,
0.3640869558,
0.5052133799,
-0.0716658086,
0.2104706317,
-0.6495593786,
0.0293365903,
-0.6002631783,
-0.3389322162,
0.5026909709,
0.3739270866,
0.2424284369,
0.621699512,
0.7757545114,
0.4339568913,
0.3337206244,
0.1634138077,
1.1147614717,
-0.473636955,
-0.5366492271,
-0.9185989499,
0.5244979262,
-0.2242661417,
-0.2675458491,
0.5780764818,
0.4448645115,
0.7283727527,
0.0213295054,
0.7038570642,
0.1569844037,
0.0929039493,
-0.6235046387,
0.4466529787,
-0.3953120708,
0.0437713116,
-0.1596703678,
-0.7244727015,
-0.1965681911,
0.7324624658,
-0.3207620978,
0.2802814543,
0.7506183386,
0.8338158727,
-0.1406258941,
-0.0091947811,
0.3061487079,
0.176190719,
0.0410913676,
0.4133843482,
0.7223974466,
-0.4554732442,
0.4571386278,
-0.3629778028,
-0.0364018157,
-0.1105731949,
-0.777456522,
-1.1134985685,
-0.7952868938,
-0.1025909483,
-0.7101566195,
0.3002822995,
0.8635412455,
0.8775683045,
-0.8361985683,
-0.2493637204,
-0.2717295885,
0.0364678837,
-0.3173547387,
-0.2394759208,
0.4995892942,
-0.3247809708,
-0.3770249188,
0.4121879041,
0.22161901,
0.216994524,
-0.5848749876,
0.2847168744,
-0.2410145998,
0.4690652192,
0.4113375843,
0.2382056862,
-0.3194876313,
-0.3203362525,
-0.1301616728,
0.2103014141,
0.1259625703,
1.0903235674,
-0.6698788404,
0.2050263137,
0.7550435662,
0.9839653969,
0.6081358194,
-0.0456711501,
0.7249884605,
-0.670383215,
0.1770015657,
0.0929966867,
0.6611856818,
0.3015160263,
-0.8160004616,
0.3913857639,
-0.0478600748,
-0.3795227408,
-0.7514088154,
0.1335538924,
-0.8132532239,
-0.3472774625,
0.9205165505,
0.0523362458,
-0.2671419382,
-0.199194327,
-0.0519250408,
0.2548851669,
-0.4871158898,
0.8454170227,
0.6097735763,
-0.0826161951,
-0.232047841,
-0.7830193639,
0.7738062143,
0.3220506608,
-0.7265514731,
0.2167478055,
0.3535402119,
0.1705948263,
0.0526865423,
0.8301887512,
-0.2520285249,
-0.0123968665,
0.2413841784,
-0.510160625,
-0.3410151899,
-0.7564563155,
-0.3353458047,
0.4209174514,
-0.0150483549,
0.0186801329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13318v1 | Proxy-based Zero-Shot Entity Linking by Effective Candidate Retrieval | 2023-01-30T22:43:21 | 2023-01-30T22:43:21 | Maciej Wiatrak, Eirini Arvaniti, Angus Brayne, Jonas Vetterle, Aaron Sim | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR | A recent advancement in the domain of biomedical Entity Linking is the
development of powerful two-stage algorithms, an initial candidate retrieval
stage that generates a shortlist of entities for each mention, followed by a
candidate ranking stage. However, the effectiveness of both stages are
inextricably dependent on computationally expensive components. Specifically,
in candidate retrieval via dense representation retrieval it is important to
have hard negative samples, which require repeated forward passes and nearest
neighbour searches across the entire entity label set throughout training. In
this work, we show that pairing a proxy-based metric learning loss with an
adversarial regularizer provides an efficient alternative to hard negative
sampling in the candidate retrieval stage. In particular, we show competitive
performance on the recall@1 metric, thereby providing the option to leave out
the expensive candidate ranking step. Finally, we demonstrate how the model can
be used in a zero-shot setting to discover out of knowledge base biomedical
entities. | [
-0.3079893589,
-0.4949732423,
0.8849508166,
-0.4423217773,
-0.3892849386,
0.0831452534,
0.2183770239,
-0.571886003,
0.6129099131,
0.3430268764,
-0.4049722552,
-0.6520450711,
-0.375431329,
-0.119810313,
-0.2496335655,
1.0565906763,
0.1720826179,
0.0954331905,
-0.2292762399,
-0.3456912637,
-0.279163748,
-0.2359206527,
-1.2524172068,
-0.5111177564,
1.0263769627,
0.1885784566,
0.6756914258,
0.8082917929,
0.3712125421,
0.050208766,
0.0353699736,
-0.2102994621,
-0.825363338,
0.1260722429,
-0.7311727405,
-0.5554050207,
-0.3221031725,
0.1550313234,
0.6829138994,
0.9831801057,
-0.0504774526,
0.3110551238,
-0.3307826817,
0.676982224,
-0.9106388092,
-0.0095453253,
-1.1898809671,
0.0658110231,
-0.6235812306,
-0.3867122531,
-0.2724176049,
0.0279283579,
-0.0455632173,
-0.645039916,
0.791146636,
0.0234754197,
0.9825217128,
0.3549910486,
-0.6070167422,
-0.0814703926,
-0.4341717064,
0.4573761523,
-0.2882152498,
0.5582328439,
0.0641100854,
0.2238955051,
-0.2963449657,
-0.4453003407,
-0.4085911214,
-0.1987605542,
0.1574402452,
0.2476838976,
0.085235104,
0.2028512657,
-0.0602751859,
0.0857923925,
-0.5224436522,
0.1093466431,
-0.5219880939,
-0.2833025455,
0.3552384377,
-0.0507816933,
0.0047961897,
-0.008089656,
-0.4507909417,
-0.1100650802,
-1.1185884476,
-0.3152391315,
0.3781220019,
0.5239769816,
0.2998620868,
0.4304602742,
-0.0806724057,
0.4799675047,
0.0934765711,
0.2295258939,
0.1472491771,
-0.228029266,
0.0644564182,
0.3857255578,
0.5537740588,
0.132632494,
-0.1643097401,
-0.578733623,
0.0016495485,
0.2268829495,
0.4739366174,
-0.8954054117,
-0.3150698245,
0.1437386572,
-0.2927433848,
-0.0930970088,
-0.0302394237,
-0.5881020427,
-0.351434648,
0.0872414261,
1.022315979,
-0.4263192117,
0.1293670535,
0.2090980858,
-0.3247916996,
0.0071549457,
0.146678552,
-0.3326063752,
0.2436106056,
0.4466715455,
0.982609272,
0.0781057552,
0.0227003377,
-0.9213716388,
0.5355131626,
-0.539926827,
0.6292937398,
-0.3867841661,
-0.495421797,
-0.2009070367,
-0.0618882589,
0.0943468958,
-0.6700670719,
0.333009541,
-0.7704719901,
-0.1284250617,
-0.2580784857,
-0.6662005186,
-0.0601984076,
0.0297457632,
-0.7025178075,
0.6415320635,
-0.0320532285,
-0.635715425,
0.6193912029,
-0.3745382428,
-0.5042846799,
0.2410040796,
-0.1799211949,
-0.6306918859,
-0.0030681733,
-0.1952425539,
0.6265720129,
-0.1741183102,
-0.0096468627,
-0.7871088386,
-0.7397342324,
-0.3033349812,
-0.0483626574,
0.7424712181,
-0.061178036,
-0.4700961709,
-0.3715589643,
-0.9973330498,
-0.3743068278,
0.3650703728,
-0.2049545497,
-0.8834959865,
-0.0541382208,
-0.6609359384,
0.1677338183,
-0.1085603163,
-0.887866497,
0.392627418,
-0.4095660746,
-0.0333717801,
0.3807920814,
0.4349516332,
0.5520609617,
-0.1006020829,
0.1321067661,
0.2768339813,
-0.0154607082,
-0.0224719774,
-0.5089102387,
-0.7890907526,
-0.2119609416,
0.4497179985,
0.3165023327,
-1.1552523375,
-0.1592192501,
0.0032899173,
-0.670514524,
-0.8587030172,
0.0600653626,
0.6668104529,
1.1342095137,
0.8615640998,
-0.4968436956,
-0.2681682706,
-0.9801280499,
-0.059984386,
-0.5149773955,
-0.3045672178,
0.6420315504,
0.6543594003,
-0.0078409063,
0.4033273757,
-0.6485630274,
-0.4778265655,
0.2866598368,
0.1966016293,
0.2588574588,
0.5163078904,
0.698712647,
-0.6369597316,
-0.2021439075,
-0.3475877643,
-0.5741391182,
0.0338554047,
-0.3327212334,
-0.4980769455,
-0.0568298027,
0.248170808,
-0.5944850445,
0.4762218297,
0.0239491519,
-0.2699760497,
0.2871510983,
-0.0903372616,
0.1040182784,
-0.857051909,
0.3629438877,
0.2605999708,
-0.1424857378,
-0.6542853713,
0.0559753664,
0.2799213231,
-0.1164833233,
-0.4880686402,
0.8986053467,
-0.362647742,
-0.023021372,
0.0979974568,
0.3744314909,
0.2332085371,
0.377530843,
0.1678878814,
0.6302419901,
0.4817284942,
-0.7910096049,
-0.0390605815,
0.2119944394,
0.3333775103,
0.8280298114,
-0.6140007377,
0.1780573726,
-0.6173288822,
0.503188014,
-0.7884933949,
0.0384260379,
0.3662111759,
-0.474168092,
0.627245605,
-0.432422936,
-0.192270577,
-0.2978619635,
-0.672093451,
0.4906574786,
0.2246169299,
-0.6796196699,
-0.1046625301,
0.4114941955,
0.189033702,
-0.5857194066,
-0.4632827342,
0.1079173908,
-0.1120004728,
-0.0308258366,
0.7914620042,
0.1665595472,
0.2376345694,
0.266471833,
-0.2703303695,
-0.0792070106,
0.0473054014,
0.1548671573,
0.565367043,
-0.1060769409,
0.3966065347,
0.0074012293,
-0.276219219,
-0.0937164426,
-0.627075851,
0.0734884664,
0.3826333582,
-0.462344408,
-0.2982032001,
0.2625886202,
0.294970274,
-0.0816537365,
1.0165663958,
0.6753342152,
-0.5847277641,
-0.0654119104,
-0.6750301123,
-0.2586311698,
-0.3392394483,
0.3057973087,
-0.3123461008,
-0.6573655605,
0.5821547508,
-0.0147769814,
-0.2962010205,
0.6723852158,
0.2385312319,
0.0934173688,
0.9211248755,
0.4243505895,
-0.116302982,
0.1821558326,
-0.3181872368,
0.050904911,
-0.8733633161,
-0.5761457682,
-0.6605116129,
-0.3185157478,
-0.4090887308,
-0.4079013467,
0.7342101932,
0.413741976,
-0.5066721439,
0.6208320856,
-0.4080734253,
0.2859943807,
0.9471030831,
0.5249074101,
0.2263097167,
-0.1167435125,
-0.4574455917,
0.0744905919,
-0.9192759395,
-0.1167093888,
1.1680814028,
0.1176205799,
0.5747337937,
0.1857186258,
1.1889357567,
-0.0903765112,
0.2876222134,
-0.7306382656,
0.4438489377,
-0.1366270483,
-0.7814699411,
-0.2787165642,
-0.6194729805,
-0.9757955074,
-0.0279817134,
-0.5033078194,
-0.5819468498,
0.3924040496,
0.1572375894,
-0.4552688301,
0.5382647514,
-0.4449995756,
0.7289046645,
0.2160838544,
-0.6598101258,
-0.1505416334,
-0.8218917251,
0.2252058685,
-0.1712571383,
-0.2488321364,
0.0248387028,
-0.2897494137,
0.6239397526,
-0.2570102811,
0.4673660994,
-0.4927502573,
0.2352778018,
0.2907033861,
0.3779214621,
0.3763976991,
0.4074540138,
-0.2315627337,
0.4870617688,
-0.0708839521,
-0.6605516076,
-0.5400603414,
0.6904520988,
-0.4037254751,
-0.3909044266,
-0.1866775751,
0.0427177437,
-0.291213125,
0.2552092969,
0.243903771,
0.2940500379,
0.0201196782,
0.2697600424,
0.9024735093,
-0.337744236,
0.0724825338,
0.765255928,
0.3763979077,
-0.2456921935,
0.9354819655,
0.3121026158,
0.0850762576,
0.4616628289,
-0.1891121417,
-0.4173357487,
-0.5597022772,
-0.5600996017,
0.5058158636,
-0.2948150337,
-0.7162514925,
-0.5966441035,
-0.1495757103,
-0.3555498123,
-0.2973824739,
-0.7141754031,
-0.2995840013,
-0.4329467118,
-0.0172307994,
-0.0936926007,
0.2278554589,
-0.2761561275,
-0.0680372044,
-0.6048214436,
0.4520088434,
0.0639069453,
0.7549851537,
0.1332173347,
-0.0391856916,
-0.1675076932,
-0.1007795706,
-0.3272041976,
-1.0755847692,
0.0249668248,
0.3578191996,
0.6020287871,
0.6015264988,
0.0927985534,
0.9161502123,
-0.765476048,
0.6585323215,
0.2499020994,
-0.5976806283,
0.6835733056,
-0.1742374301,
0.0590937696,
0.6505613327,
0.8090032935,
-0.4086048305,
-0.2037621737,
-0.7000912428,
-0.9250020981,
0.5422523618,
0.3118889928,
-0.1480114907,
-0.5020858645,
1.0072125196,
0.0881536976,
0.1331287175,
-0.269657433,
-0.5557578206,
0.0681122541,
0.2347168922,
-0.0990126133,
-0.0596132129,
-0.1051241532,
-0.037588235,
1.1011595726,
-0.1165951341,
0.2562111914,
0.4821564257,
0.0711534545,
-0.1850168258,
0.0625997558,
-0.0838027969,
-0.0123616541,
-0.4417929351,
0.1177751049,
0.1182386726,
-0.2246038914,
0.1848112792,
0.1655553281,
-0.3849490285,
0.2146513313,
0.2657646835,
0.5778889656,
0.4785929024,
-0.3617738783,
0.6483017802,
0.2205759585,
-0.311634481,
0.1492033154,
0.0401844271,
-0.1173450351,
0.3285552561,
0.4982836843,
-0.117578961,
0.5644143224,
-0.6631962061,
0.5659455657,
0.7365040779,
-0.6613526344,
-0.3021576703,
1.2583153248,
0.0120635256,
-0.0113439774,
0.5671206117,
-0.5429577231,
-0.19679676,
0.438039422,
0.6266827583,
0.6118753552,
-0.1464333236,
0.6005080342,
0.5725252628,
-0.1339529306,
-0.1116940454,
-0.0380898342,
-0.1018473208,
-0.4612186253,
-0.2065924108,
-0.6285971403,
-0.4071292579,
0.1894211322,
-0.7645789385,
0.3503228426,
-0.3425450921,
-0.2592612207,
0.3312471509,
0.2637061179,
-0.7787076235,
0.2246933877,
0.2208783329,
0.772151351,
-0.6183771491,
0.6667302251,
0.7576951385,
-0.7773515582,
-0.4730666578,
-0.2536862493,
0.304189384,
-0.6297460794,
0.6028792858,
-0.065030925,
-0.1765943468,
0.0693989769,
-0.3170860112,
-0.7363354564,
1.1814790964,
0.4948194921,
-0.4158685803,
-0.3246572018,
-0.2830599546,
0.5228957534,
-0.1596706808,
0.2776874006,
0.203213796,
-0.073874481,
0.5545947552,
-0.6938462853,
0.2898999453,
0.0078777876,
0.0342643782,
0.6311203837,
-0.6906212568,
0.8132798076,
-0.264059037,
-0.4312659502,
0.0820628405,
0.4244836569,
0.2065137029,
0.6736015677,
0.3243409991,
0.6397137642,
0.6323775649,
0.2367079705,
0.6369222403,
-0.363184303,
0.4527710974,
1.0133333206,
-0.3984205127,
0.9275196791,
0.4899803102,
-0.0933610499,
0.3558588922,
0.4988080859,
-0.0238222107,
0.5045000315,
0.233261615,
-0.3283127546,
-0.2814489305,
-0.4307940006,
-0.318467617,
0.1683635116,
0.3158791661,
-0.2732642293,
-0.5576332211,
-0.3262958229,
0.0428958535,
-0.1393992454,
-0.3760222495,
0.666985929,
-0.0026137906,
-0.4070658982,
0.3696304858,
-0.187985301,
0.5025901198,
-0.4680146277,
-0.4076336026,
-0.2241625637,
0.0362594165,
-0.1108648106,
-0.4063530266,
0.1709445715,
-0.3726575375,
-0.0161640383,
0.3183655739,
0.999160707,
-0.5478781462,
-0.2360966951,
0.431383729,
0.5132853985,
0.3275212646,
-0.1829663962,
-0.7051403522,
-0.4276032448,
-0.4440865815,
-0.1943696141,
0.3797715306,
0.1755193919,
-0.0107233031,
0.5576246381,
0.6259785891,
0.4838077128,
-0.2117781341,
0.0855664834,
0.8044096828,
-0.6245833635,
-0.0932488367,
-0.6155810356,
0.0951443315,
-0.2000769377,
-0.0286178868,
0.4132197797,
0.7740662694,
1.1244133711,
0.136796385,
0.3836196661,
0.2579004169,
0.6478672028,
-0.3650658131,
0.7865971327,
-0.8009713888,
0.1548115164,
-0.2861712873,
-1.0248793364,
-0.6094465256,
0.348054409,
0.0258196406,
-0.1219590455,
0.4852182269,
0.9293981791,
-0.2515796721,
-0.6237345338,
0.4656800628,
0.18619515,
0.2503831983,
0.7575055957,
-0.0256187506,
-0.6563743353,
0.6277525425,
-0.353960216,
-0.2512619495,
-0.2823372781,
-0.8333429098,
-0.9515895844,
-0.5162637234,
-0.5559201241,
-0.5425879359,
0.473706007,
0.7422776818,
0.8274630308,
-0.575530827,
0.3813588023,
0.141958937,
0.0243938174,
0.0931239352,
-0.1915797442,
0.3541841507,
-0.3239717782,
-0.5495874286,
0.4945705235,
0.6895822287,
0.0073214783,
-0.3215609193,
0.109331809,
-0.5248758197,
0.1729062498,
0.3643825352,
0.5758712888,
-0.34935233,
-0.4467196465,
-0.1591516435,
-0.063850835,
-0.1285783052,
0.6210249662,
-1.298766017,
0.5692244172,
0.1924706846,
0.7351201773,
0.7330917716,
-0.0726082623,
0.3127829432,
-0.8717907667,
0.0926181674,
0.1743202955,
0.202774629,
0.2396391332,
-0.5990360975,
0.8446090817,
0.585082531,
-0.342022121,
-0.6674978137,
0.1718548685,
-0.7117397189,
-0.3170756102,
0.9063587189,
-0.1645481884,
-0.1634939164,
0.0417448133,
-0.0106404899,
0.6362310052,
-0.4068164527,
1.061183691,
0.211397469,
-0.2823861241,
0.4738458395,
-0.5422484279,
0.427244544,
0.3454472125,
-0.2402560562,
-0.7015880942,
0.3914049864,
0.3632621467,
0.2723547816,
0.7551509142,
-0.1802865416,
0.1010071039,
0.3169004321,
-0.0807776749,
-0.080523178,
-0.5508136749,
-0.1259282678,
0.2255455554,
-0.2291166335,
-0.2679362297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13310v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13310v2 | Alternating Updates for Efficient Transformers | 2023-01-30T22:06:05 | 2023-10-03T21:40:41 | Cenk Baykal, Dylan Cutler, Nishanth Dikkala, Nikhil Ghosh, Rina Panigrahy, Xin Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | It has been well established that increasing scale in deep transformer
networks leads to improved quality and performance. However, this increase in
scale often comes with prohibitive increases in compute cost and inference
latency. We introduce Alternating Updates (AltUp), a simple-to-implement method
to increase a model's capacity without the computational burden. AltUp enables
the widening of the learned representation, i.e., the token embedding, while
only incurring a negligible increase in latency. AltUp achieves this by working
on a subblock of the widened representation at each layer and using a
predict-and-correct mechanism to update the inactivated blocks. We present
extensions of AltUp, such as its applicability to the sequence dimension, and
demonstrate how AltUp can be synergistically combined with existing approaches,
such as Sparse Mixture-of-Experts models, to obtain efficient models with even
higher capacity. Our experiments on benchmark transformer models and language
tasks demonstrate the consistent effectiveness of AltUp on a diverse set of
scenarios. Notably, on SuperGLUE and SQuAD benchmarks, AltUp enables up to
$87\%$ speedup relative to the dense baselines at the same accuracy. | [
-0.3952002525,
-0.5327724218,
0.3331457376,
0.2394429594,
-0.2690117955,
0.214972496,
-0.4174975753,
-0.5310157537,
0.1964161098,
0.3868790269,
-0.399312675,
0.0767871141,
-0.5694774389,
-0.1032460332,
-0.5982054472,
0.4357047081,
-0.074171111,
-0.1711805016,
0.1768263578,
-0.3871364892,
-0.6897209883,
-0.0253071077,
-0.8625582457,
-0.435233742,
0.1987122297,
0.691953063,
1.2105053663,
0.8128557205,
0.7016141415,
0.4484196305,
0.0445141755,
0.176579833,
-0.3925502896,
0.4060994983,
0.0750184059,
-0.4527025521,
-0.2693282366,
-0.3035839796,
1.0579607487,
0.7448515296,
-0.3654848635,
-0.047527425,
-0.12775141,
0.7250820398,
-0.295591265,
-0.0339618735,
-0.7644696832,
0.0371942893,
0.348911792,
-0.0504486486,
-0.4544260204,
0.0358294696,
0.018999055,
-0.613180995,
0.3775626421,
0.2688984573,
0.5871604681,
0.5680555701,
-0.1887013912,
0.3416469097,
-0.7167211175,
0.4689905345,
-0.3446527123,
0.6924580336,
-0.2523342371,
0.5498223305,
0.1326371431,
-0.8789852858,
-0.4499175549,
-0.4637233615,
-0.2891711295,
0.1213849932,
-0.5092844963,
0.2000046372,
0.3796519935,
0.5487630963,
0.0101574967,
0.4543589652,
-0.2360550463,
0.1809011102,
0.6810358167,
0.2202510834,
0.1639255583,
0.2025111318,
-0.459576726,
-0.3348701,
-0.6221987009,
-0.1383112818,
0.3572234511,
0.1495724618,
-0.1612494886,
0.6298722029,
-0.1128271073,
0.5476101637,
0.4752885401,
0.8705135584,
0.1136415005,
-0.003305071,
-0.2885607779,
-0.0876255631,
0.4972123802,
0.0606344603,
-0.3034904003,
-0.3174749315,
-0.3640967906,
-0.2332850099,
0.5510277152,
-0.6993976831,
-0.4666021168,
0.1231099963,
-0.4073781371,
-0.2146226466,
0.037332736,
-0.6983857155,
-0.5597668886,
-0.3601868451,
0.5237925053,
-0.1778321266,
-0.2541880012,
0.0972732604,
-0.1004258543,
0.0659821928,
0.4984298944,
-0.7000348568,
0.3095612824,
0.4479854405,
0.7809562087,
-0.183932811,
-0.3376523554,
-0.5221719146,
-0.2462940663,
-0.5013397336,
0.6153707504,
-0.4794563055,
-0.2846743464,
-0.184209615,
0.063055709,
0.0762781501,
-0.4372931719,
0.2937297225,
-0.7801430225,
-0.1510900557,
-0.1546137482,
-0.3732909262,
-0.0263689905,
-0.0540093035,
-1.091766119,
1.2794507742,
0.3971394897,
-0.3771216273,
0.0745043531,
-0.5686441064,
-0.3186577559,
-0.1428625286,
0.0269539449,
-0.5330485106,
0.4734877944,
0.2536104023,
0.246467337,
-0.2985385358,
-0.0249646921,
-0.1174067557,
-0.5853427052,
0.1819006503,
-0.668890357,
0.4207325578,
-0.0337227434,
-0.358748138,
0.2015964985,
-0.7969899178,
-0.4434034228,
0.0215867143,
-0.3148914278,
-0.1296877861,
-0.260145843,
-0.0908887535,
-0.058676634,
-0.0134808859,
-0.5035434961,
0.5089739561,
-0.2103367746,
0.1143348515,
1.0420491695,
0.0052462993,
0.6961407661,
-0.3894545138,
0.5505577922,
0.0961828232,
0.0629962161,
-0.3314197958,
-0.3710710406,
-1.2317951918,
-0.2318373322,
0.6547729969,
0.2267202139,
-0.8144111037,
0.4584878683,
-0.550239563,
-0.4690031409,
-0.8673712015,
0.156178996,
-0.070394367,
0.2309445888,
0.8957875371,
-0.3027688265,
-0.6396700144,
-0.7938030362,
-0.4226288795,
0.0025726999,
-0.1053717583,
0.4139663875,
0.0291442424,
-0.3682591915,
0.6539363861,
-0.6012640595,
0.1685702205,
-0.3335908949,
0.3135948777,
0.3585255742,
0.6047962308,
0.360632956,
-0.6624848247,
-0.7806349397,
0.1499052048,
-0.1729027927,
-0.1262270212,
-0.3732085824,
0.0690181404,
-0.147916615,
0.5114178658,
-0.7896101475,
0.1602728069,
0.607832253,
-0.0968559384,
0.2679703534,
-0.3647237718,
0.1666046083,
-0.7267999053,
-0.3022462726,
-0.1282584071,
-0.4456662834,
-0.8039256334,
0.3320585191,
0.0875639915,
-0.2791875303,
-0.2999576628,
0.409692049,
-0.4674061537,
-0.0087959543,
-0.3401774764,
-0.1615662575,
-0.0998589694,
0.4385780692,
-0.1060238928,
0.7733682394,
0.7399849892,
-0.4600597024,
0.262281239,
-0.181452781,
0.0824873298,
0.2282418013,
-0.8693627119,
0.2050691098,
-0.133671701,
0.2773718238,
-1.0296114683,
-0.0719077736,
0.1247972846,
-0.0799770281,
0.6462662816,
-0.1095558479,
-0.3046338558,
-0.3459342122,
-0.1154330745,
0.5067250729,
0.7355332375,
-1.0118989944,
1.0930219889,
0.3332518339,
0.3134949505,
-0.7542144656,
-0.5332597494,
0.0835821778,
0.1850340962,
-0.5968348384,
0.7135677338,
0.36697191,
-0.2098384649,
0.3437353969,
-0.4800063372,
0.1288739741,
0.0002473635,
-0.0528349467,
0.2105154246,
-0.2415304631,
0.1491645724,
0.1052156165,
-0.269634366,
-0.1768674552,
-0.4075738788,
0.5590776205,
-0.3693544865,
-0.4649339318,
-0.2556782067,
0.3629595637,
0.484292239,
0.235321179,
0.5584424734,
0.857064724,
-0.1900933087,
-0.2944823503,
-0.7547690868,
-0.2931970954,
-0.5843557715,
0.3894733489,
-0.3884985447,
-0.7406864166,
0.334112227,
-0.1874071807,
0.2117420584,
0.7519997954,
0.2327101827,
-0.0925979018,
1.0923039913,
0.7544828653,
-0.0972132981,
0.6247208118,
-0.5625429153,
0.3277964592,
-0.8213934898,
0.0829453468,
-0.4559368789,
-0.6926678419,
-0.6984543204,
-0.9849657416,
0.3930648565,
0.0581369773,
-0.062063884,
0.7232750654,
-0.5623032451,
0.3322640061,
0.5074382424,
0.26524508,
0.3040679097,
-0.0273465868,
0.1505787075,
0.3415353894,
-1.1320630312,
0.1695274115,
0.9441939592,
0.4031558037,
0.8778988123,
0.1290447116,
0.4558581114,
0.5924382806,
0.5143864155,
-0.7043186426,
0.4695303738,
-0.1611203104,
-0.2689425647,
-0.3982306123,
-0.4534160793,
-0.8184752464,
0.4778742194,
-0.3559333682,
-0.2893434763,
0.6478883624,
0.3476442099,
-0.2881050408,
0.5728021264,
-0.5980656147,
0.3263767362,
0.1373457015,
-0.2627907693,
-0.6443241835,
-0.6802731156,
0.0281865224,
0.0930471495,
-0.2761052847,
0.1919938475,
-0.2850155532,
0.3370609283,
-0.5015333891,
0.7022538185,
-0.1071802378,
0.246862337,
0.518930614,
-0.1317970455,
0.9990695119,
0.2040462345,
-0.0414125249,
0.3221635222,
-0.687740922,
-0.4474412501,
-0.8980422616,
0.530675292,
-0.906450808,
-0.7524635792,
-0.1976816952,
-0.7184218764,
-0.0901972204,
0.0259792842,
-0.0396685489,
0.3657169044,
-0.0620815195,
0.5257983804,
0.5515814424,
-0.0769624114,
0.5380644798,
0.1817544252,
0.2646140456,
-0.2317740917,
0.4942981601,
-0.0053621726,
0.3268619776,
0.5263600945,
0.2982417941,
-0.4023907781,
-0.5437186956,
-0.6301158667,
0.0002920004,
-0.6167576313,
-0.3926451504,
-1.0032051802,
-0.2009558678,
-0.1976392567,
-0.2028242648,
-0.5899194479,
-0.969938755,
0.0778513253,
-0.2609262466,
0.4824396968,
0.5453945398,
-0.4712716937,
0.6689265966,
-0.7433932424,
0.6318112612,
0.631339252,
0.3072026074,
0.2478727102,
-0.5732240081,
-0.3081538975,
-0.1176829785,
-0.3671992421,
-0.6295742393,
-0.0383876525,
0.0810083002,
0.541403234,
0.2065495104,
-0.0678259358,
0.9021930099,
-0.6732305288,
0.7821121812,
0.4356518984,
-1.0537327528,
0.0741140246,
-0.115769513,
0.1857151538,
0.3698710203,
0.2139763087,
-0.451254487,
-0.4215694666,
-0.954657793,
-1.0095703602,
0.5893911719,
0.190511927,
0.5762341619,
0.090699248,
0.1753413677,
0.0285294838,
0.1385591775,
-0.3724778295,
-0.3827172518,
-0.5585938692,
-0.0457130373,
-0.0004965635,
-0.0933875591,
-0.041394867,
-0.4659467936,
0.8629419208,
-0.0921759084,
0.506819129,
0.1708551943,
-0.255360961,
-0.2701478004,
0.3398274779,
0.2215206325,
0.422634095,
-0.1232552379,
0.1687973887,
0.5655918717,
-0.4180067778,
0.3354912996,
0.4468493462,
-0.0544811413,
0.3006364703,
0.2000323832,
1.0778369904,
0.5228515863,
-0.3665042818,
0.5131520033,
-0.0074823815,
0.0832080171,
0.0809511095,
0.133135438,
-0.1752546132,
0.4195379019,
0.5336180925,
0.7867482901,
0.0735803396,
-0.316005677,
0.2163672298,
0.1215795875,
-0.5616691113,
-0.2228842974,
0.5986142159,
0.3032545447,
-0.4311728776,
0.7366024852,
-0.0487394184,
-0.3778421879,
0.7485332489,
0.4248503447,
1.0281381607,
-0.2956573963,
-0.0307200253,
0.2099362314,
0.5124136209,
-0.2370791584,
-0.0342277512,
-0.0568938665,
-0.8486580253,
-0.4654233456,
-0.1677782238,
-0.449290365,
-0.0962787941,
-0.492187947,
0.4144108593,
-0.2909051776,
-0.0983904749,
-0.3055610061,
0.0160654318,
-0.9535868168,
0.0750511885,
-0.1551056504,
1.2410929203,
-0.7998851538,
0.4839193225,
0.5852856636,
0.0752518922,
-0.8881425858,
-0.031490609,
-0.4261209965,
-0.8719172478,
0.0676020905,
0.1819148064,
-0.0410403833,
0.2538950741,
-0.1071648523,
-0.8229819536,
1.0605874062,
0.0777328685,
-0.760666132,
-0.0069579044,
-0.092241846,
0.6419772506,
-0.3978926837,
0.5334501266,
0.4617928565,
0.6048592329,
0.0646581799,
-0.200192675,
0.3158778548,
-0.1707352549,
0.192244336,
0.337897718,
-0.7451131344,
0.6370947957,
-0.4361158609,
-0.1765109599,
0.0155530609,
1.0602271557,
-0.0261144266,
-0.306144774,
1.0269989967,
0.8097008467,
0.7152346373,
-0.254272908,
1.1066806316,
-0.5453195572,
0.4211170971,
1.168556571,
0.0887265876,
0.4032946527,
0.3736605048,
-0.0662587732,
0.5464938879,
0.3654982448,
-0.4360788465,
0.5201439857,
-0.0961601734,
-0.0623425245,
-0.3602508605,
-0.1051844135,
-0.5324995518,
0.3437564969,
0.04406818,
-0.367679894,
-0.104310289,
-0.1949294806,
-0.211523369,
-0.2439997494,
-0.38986063,
0.4997398853,
0.0947271138,
-0.7483384609,
0.3781802654,
0.1753453612,
0.2789794803,
-0.2313606441,
-0.1501961648,
-0.0290448423,
0.0518674478,
-0.0650954843,
-0.5547798872,
0.1996808648,
-0.3629393876,
0.0217245035,
-0.3222947419,
0.6849120855,
-0.5376361609,
-0.5116564035,
0.0612658784,
0.3038494885,
-0.5537448525,
0.2107416987,
-0.5451490879,
0.0188816823,
-0.3695911169,
-0.2907180786,
-0.1270434558,
0.2515442669,
0.2498951554,
0.4802944064,
0.6803478003,
0.1761741936,
0.3305320144,
0.3596590459,
1.1934856176,
-0.2618916035,
-0.4509907365,
-0.535395503,
0.8074607849,
-0.3989764452,
0.0084786853,
0.5793465376,
0.3245740235,
0.5133205056,
-0.0137599204,
0.6394999623,
-0.0194411781,
0.0037873844,
-0.3218452036,
0.1925593019,
-0.4797851443,
0.5735985041,
-0.0302344002,
-0.874216795,
-0.2114400268,
0.2554541528,
-0.0563592091,
-0.1258294582,
0.6757503748,
0.5653634667,
-0.4227679968,
0.3174210787,
0.1240519807,
0.6290931702,
0.2469433695,
0.1830636859,
1.0352083445,
-0.7686274052,
0.3646716475,
-0.6184666753,
-0.3114088476,
-0.3238551021,
-0.7936583161,
-0.8364098072,
-0.1672575921,
-0.3723687232,
-0.3262965977,
0.0692729503,
0.9401130676,
0.6414901018,
-0.6128268242,
0.0049872966,
-0.3613453209,
0.2844758332,
-0.8367161751,
-0.2306718528,
0.4429892898,
-0.6568599939,
-0.7078158259,
0.4651114047,
0.2948716581,
-0.0174921621,
-0.1524637043,
0.1713287681,
0.0964413732,
0.3560484052,
0.3714392781,
0.0995543003,
-0.3741108775,
-0.5830414295,
0.1248437017,
0.2990779877,
0.263721019,
1.0497293472,
-0.7371125817,
0.5357490778,
0.9291700721,
1.1014719009,
0.7044993043,
0.2394506633,
0.7407903671,
-0.927380085,
0.0937689096,
0.2792427838,
0.5952078104,
0.2371649146,
-0.5943142772,
0.4981059432,
0.2165019959,
-0.4885428846,
-0.9079316854,
0.1853452027,
-0.9102597237,
-0.1938531399,
0.8825455308,
0.0055731446,
0.0397055857,
-0.0494238362,
0.1224201694,
0.3927686214,
-0.4690250754,
0.8916273117,
0.1426979899,
-0.193159312,
-0.1348300576,
-0.1473686099,
0.286532402,
0.4960441589,
-0.5337792635,
0.048210118,
0.092528671,
-0.0434285738,
0.1525660455,
0.4145109951,
0.0358213633,
0.4076036811,
0.1259629577,
-0.3280003071,
-0.1886294186,
-0.731842339,
-0.586510241,
0.0531321093,
-0.2059032619,
-0.0533642992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13298v1 | LongEval: Guidelines for Human Evaluation of Faithfulness in Long-form Summarization | 2023-01-30T21:31:48 | 2023-01-30T21:31:48 | Kalpesh Krishna, Erin Bransom, Bailey Kuehl, Mohit Iyyer, Pradeep Dasigi, Arman Cohan, Kyle Lo | cs.CL | cs.CL | While human evaluation remains best practice for accurately judging the
faithfulness of automatically-generated summaries, few solutions exist to
address the increased difficulty and workload when evaluating long-form
summaries. Through a survey of 162 papers on long-form summarization, we first
shed light on current human evaluation practices surrounding long-form
summaries. We find that 73% of these papers do not perform any human evaluation
on model-generated summaries, while other works face new difficulties that
manifest when dealing with long documents (e.g., low inter-annotator
agreement). Motivated by our survey, we present LongEval, a set of guidelines
for human evaluation of faithfulness in long-form summaries that addresses the
following challenges: (1) How can we achieve high inter-annotator agreement on
faithfulness scores? (2) How can we minimize annotator workload while
maintaining accurate faithfulness scores? and (3) Do humans benefit from
automated alignment between summary and source snippets? We deploy LongEval in
annotation studies on two long-form summarization datasets in different domains
(SQuALITY and PubMed), and we find that switching to a finer granularity of
judgment (e.g., clause-level) reduces inter-annotator variance in faithfulness
scores (e.g., std-dev from 18.5 to 6.8). We also show that scores from a
partial annotation of fine-grained units highly correlates with scores from a
full annotation workload (0.89 Kendall's tau using 50% judgments). We release
our human judgments, annotation templates, and our software as a Python library
for future research. | [
-0.3589922786,
-0.4114312232,
0.5143688917,
0.6276472807,
-0.5138324499,
-0.1203028262,
-0.4170482755,
-0.9104455113,
0.1841573417,
0.4627070427,
-0.2080303431,
-0.3446922004,
-0.575163126,
0.5774937272,
-0.1254173517,
1.3194918633,
-0.2806683481,
-0.0098749669,
-0.7330272198,
-0.4039318562,
-0.1961483359,
-0.4382457137,
-0.0744630396,
-0.3355633318,
0.6447713971,
0.0562230237,
0.926447928,
0.5140016079,
0.9870710969,
0.219354704,
-0.1674790084,
0.240586549,
-0.5739512444,
0.2150876522,
-0.3523835242,
-0.0908170789,
-0.7829845548,
0.1817315817,
0.4868664443,
0.6513212323,
-0.0688736737,
0.5571579933,
0.4699099064,
1.0396438837,
-0.7140260935,
0.201439023,
0.0674740896,
-0.1184858903,
-0.41707775,
-0.095484741,
-0.2228200883,
-0.6271894574,
0.2664460242,
-0.5984708667,
0.1875315607,
-0.038917616,
0.7042655349,
0.2302354574,
-0.2606676817,
-0.1570244581,
-0.4830594063,
0.836879313,
-0.5237306952,
0.1606458873,
0.7726635337,
0.1948443502,
-0.2196843028,
-0.7067218423,
-0.2000430524,
-0.4443095922,
-0.135198161,
0.3536082804,
-0.1571352631,
0.1913147122,
0.3332854509,
0.4729858935,
-0.419041425,
-0.2222011834,
-0.5089854598,
-0.2720142007,
1.0950741768,
0.01685974,
-0.0034659598,
-0.2532745004,
-0.3189558387,
0.0555261783,
-0.4594318867,
-0.0616497695,
0.3105818331,
0.0442944653,
0.1946316808,
0.6378061175,
-0.249524802,
0.3420969844,
0.007442452,
-0.0520663075,
0.2334045321,
-0.6089189053,
-0.0330296159,
-0.0996523201,
0.8759114146,
0.900388658,
0.3335796595,
-0.2501230836,
-0.4192423522,
-0.0051412424,
0.5409992933,
-0.7385511994,
0.0076660337,
0.1473772526,
-0.7182706594,
-0.3690643609,
0.2599475384,
-0.7263422608,
-0.3537906706,
-0.4878277481,
0.4625149667,
-0.3763180375,
0.1149974093,
-0.084830232,
-0.2237248719,
0.0991758928,
0.6738166213,
-0.5140936971,
0.4518990219,
0.8092841506,
0.7882754803,
-0.4609902799,
-0.777159214,
-0.5525814891,
-0.0592363402,
-0.4242664576,
0.5892485976,
-0.1009433493,
-0.4415221214,
-0.1273901016,
0.021864742,
0.3515913785,
-0.468346864,
0.8398729563,
-0.1722427458,
0.3108515441,
-0.4579372704,
-0.4623812139,
-0.0483123101,
0.1267644018,
-0.6871427298,
0.9278562665,
0.2765868008,
-0.6930307746,
0.4357561767,
-0.7391245961,
-0.4952804446,
-0.1110155135,
0.1535048783,
-0.6284105182,
0.3704122305,
0.1712416261,
0.2822124064,
-0.1952089965,
0.2232655138,
-0.2877557874,
-0.6399794221,
0.1821988821,
-0.4330306351,
0.5974017978,
0.1035218388,
-0.324129194,
0.1474536657,
-0.2528421581,
-0.1228104904,
-0.0417612903,
-0.3276852071,
-0.4464672804,
0.1249865666,
0.1930958033,
-0.0502236709,
0.1898747683,
-0.4198882878,
0.3422851264,
-0.2360294759,
0.1110541523,
0.6754889488,
0.007541406,
0.279083848,
-0.775393784,
0.2699867785,
-0.2017312944,
0.402254492,
-0.1190552562,
-0.3531068563,
-0.5073174238,
-0.0263080839,
0.3244693875,
0.218846187,
-0.1787093431,
0.7654185891,
-0.5689852834,
-0.514493227,
-0.5812591314,
0.4144337773,
0.6276388764,
0.3100374043,
0.5385414958,
-0.4589054585,
-0.2555476427,
-0.9906060696,
-0.504606545,
-0.1835624874,
-0.0810494572,
-0.0530484281,
0.9987758398,
-0.2006278634,
0.8926666975,
-0.2726227343,
-0.408844769,
-0.1278732568,
0.3628728688,
-0.0482075401,
0.3314511776,
0.4998193383,
-0.6369258761,
-0.2834140062,
-0.3709568083,
-0.7969939113,
-0.0673411041,
-0.1792558432,
-0.1773822457,
0.3282947242,
0.2737278044,
-0.6496921182,
0.6114524007,
0.2468330711,
-0.304235369,
0.6194000244,
-0.396497339,
0.2409768403,
-0.8645495176,
0.2441184819,
0.0669476837,
-0.5890750885,
-0.1082581878,
0.2893665433,
0.1966958344,
0.1044370681,
-0.0569059886,
0.3786860108,
-0.4935765862,
0.0828283429,
-0.1511119604,
0.1553072631,
0.3784520924,
0.1500371397,
-0.153255716,
0.8881596923,
0.0292247199,
-0.3466055691,
0.4760539234,
0.2781728804,
-0.1959403455,
0.6491672397,
-0.8693888783,
0.143059954,
-0.3930395842,
0.674195528,
-0.6366211176,
-0.4386307895,
-0.011176547,
-0.5141844749,
0.2579612434,
-0.0319676585,
-0.2763223052,
-0.2298606038,
-0.9514916539,
0.4641660452,
0.6419304013,
-0.2889475226,
0.4974590838,
0.0940736756,
-0.1837427616,
-0.6531970501,
-0.7558050156,
0.4368196428,
0.0689444989,
-0.7219680548,
0.4629537761,
-0.0916266516,
-0.4384290874,
-0.1606913209,
-0.1874699146,
0.1846157312,
-0.111757502,
0.4458161891,
0.1863534153,
-0.0611379817,
0.0653859153,
-0.1920674145,
-0.0627235323,
0.2175211608,
0.1482604891,
0.1153495014,
-0.4584586918,
-0.493906498,
-0.5966985822,
0.5818994045,
0.7877888083,
-0.4038263261,
0.1845078617,
0.4862524569,
-0.370924145,
0.2965990901,
-0.8759693503,
0.0798632279,
-0.3232668638,
0.4457383752,
-0.0561565384,
-0.2613387406,
0.4139644504,
0.0978599638,
0.4177050591,
0.8588436842,
0.3702090681,
-0.5378659964,
0.8017261028,
0.3993370533,
-0.1813211292,
0.2250685543,
-0.1259162873,
-0.397133261,
-0.8656018376,
-0.0509748943,
-0.3182212114,
-0.3301921189,
-0.3933708072,
-0.3093980551,
0.2591969371,
0.2913491726,
0.1704821289,
0.0509625301,
-0.4208419323,
0.6091166735,
0.3294398189,
0.1876666248,
0.3094730079,
-0.3192946017,
0.4137122035,
-0.0832445621,
0.0648460686,
-0.6529647112,
1.0807045698,
0.4387110174,
0.6952055097,
0.2232319415,
1.0383511782,
0.5975165367,
0.3772398531,
-0.8152313232,
0.3442944884,
-0.1478013247,
-0.4247739315,
-0.3869210482,
-0.505910337,
-1.0261383057,
-0.0766787156,
-0.1841441691,
-0.3358982205,
-0.0753644407,
0.0558009893,
-0.3681855202,
-0.1750705242,
-0.5097693801,
0.6295975447,
-0.4351272583,
-0.4615607262,
-0.3392531276,
-0.9031879902,
0.1840788871,
-0.1161229834,
-0.0133521678,
-0.0278399847,
-0.1443622857,
0.9542395473,
-0.4941773415,
0.5968692303,
-0.1469504982,
0.1106167436,
0.1521522254,
0.0183774475,
0.5756477118,
0.251026541,
-0.1866313964,
0.2485377491,
0.2296863496,
-0.4723326564,
-0.6530746222,
0.3415494263,
-0.7216154933,
-0.4413908422,
-0.8612405062,
-0.3402775526,
0.0420945175,
0.3380361199,
0.3012506664,
0.2818293571,
-0.5139747262,
0.2704353034,
0.45664379,
0.1641770154,
0.2581517398,
-0.1155298799,
-0.3664703369,
-0.6895872951,
0.6960060596,
0.0897119194,
0.2424868494,
0.0522332937,
0.2948475182,
-0.2259631604,
-0.529840827,
-0.5675064325,
0.3337494433,
-0.5374426246,
-0.2740143538,
-0.0887087807,
-0.0851427764,
-0.2518137097,
-0.15039891,
-0.3519257605,
-0.356610328,
-0.3081949949,
0.1648105681,
0.2548346519,
0.763677597,
0.2916205823,
-0.1486405432,
-0.9549394846,
0.6865473986,
0.2441409379,
0.4749574959,
-0.3870754838,
-0.492128402,
-0.0956560895,
0.223290354,
-0.2753562927,
-0.637478292,
0.0082541117,
0.4016548097,
0.384421289,
0.4131528735,
0.2468831986,
0.9309286475,
-0.1102169305,
0.8287262321,
0.2412969023,
-0.8515331745,
0.4494677782,
-0.3383862972,
0.3992367387,
1.1382690668,
0.2944936752,
-0.4917069972,
-0.3168328404,
-0.3272255063,
-0.7898605466,
0.4141880274,
0.3854656518,
0.2044529617,
0.1599084735,
0.6203427911,
0.2656575441,
0.0156980306,
-0.5119714737,
0.1298587471,
-0.4562319815,
-0.2390555143,
-0.1444867849,
-0.3176371455,
-0.4326432347,
-0.3508305848,
0.413110137,
-0.1093700454,
0.0937050506,
0.5729966164,
-0.4666908979,
-0.1905358434,
0.3629611433,
0.7813518047,
1.2430430651,
-0.5256433487,
0.0421017036,
0.28344962,
-0.7983522415,
-0.2217038721,
0.2478708029,
-0.149086386,
0.0544268899,
0.7530440688,
0.3581480086,
0.0056000454,
-0.3921319544,
1.0537478924,
-0.2423478812,
-0.2641087174,
-0.550808847,
-0.1990197599,
-0.1121701226,
-0.0348608643,
0.3673789501,
0.2341638952,
0.0581219904,
-0.6210386157,
0.0068606888,
0.288125962,
-0.4531983137,
-0.3348276913,
0.3582976162,
0.3693611026,
-0.2187287807,
0.7641145587,
-0.2493224144,
-0.358700633,
0.1498068422,
0.3347946703,
0.9978061914,
0.0260286927,
-0.1023242176,
0.1244275272,
0.2843628228,
-0.4557295442,
0.3623506129,
-0.198632434,
0.0742704198,
-0.5683238506,
-0.7154340744,
-0.5717802048,
-0.3730199635,
-0.8614569306,
0.2627468407,
-0.1417124867,
-0.3619722724,
0.02402048,
0.13558954,
-0.290512681,
0.0551560335,
0.0087525044,
0.9920330048,
-0.5193942189,
0.418851018,
0.5112191439,
-0.7519311905,
-0.1725955904,
0.0545266867,
-0.1537573338,
-0.3845568001,
0.2812615037,
0.1525127143,
-0.1332076341,
-0.6533246636,
-0.4385884106,
-0.4267866313,
1.1736736298,
0.3953150809,
-0.523794651,
-0.4056081772,
0.105846189,
0.701431334,
0.1360955089,
0.343532294,
0.3214203715,
0.6413980126,
-0.1518778205,
-1.1565442085,
-0.0136533836,
-0.3661407828,
-0.2996248901,
0.4279420972,
-0.7049659491,
0.4559434056,
-0.3656783104,
0.0759701207,
0.2176147103,
0.7515647411,
0.171286568,
0.5928711891,
0.4293724895,
0.3495926261,
0.686260879,
-0.1995166093,
1.0253640413,
-0.0532351807,
0.3524677157,
0.9914784431,
-0.1141030639,
0.9331305027,
0.6578165293,
-0.3184559941,
0.2910927534,
0.4319778383,
-0.2297856957,
0.1013857946,
0.2216356248,
-0.0095985942,
-0.1900486499,
0.023571752,
-0.4912991524,
0.5260586143,
0.0136302626,
-0.4676996469,
-0.248319447,
-0.1953734905,
0.1181007251,
-0.0129404683,
-0.2380693108,
0.8371973038,
0.1792803556,
-0.9196768403,
0.5591863394,
-0.1184908301,
0.6843451858,
-0.716146946,
-0.1451578736,
-0.2177609354,
0.0910694897,
-0.6417531967,
-0.9463360906,
0.4271581471,
0.1340802908,
-0.2891195714,
-0.2070412338,
0.4846916497,
-0.0991190523,
-0.4925504327,
0.025084801,
0.3428306878,
0.3247902095,
-0.3508504927,
-0.3361899853,
-0.21645464,
-0.2349104285,
-0.4092536271,
0.4621472061,
0.1249279752,
-0.3708119392,
0.4465952516,
0.7593556643,
0.2984567285,
-0.3228503764,
0.1453565955,
0.7836840153,
-0.8110986352,
-0.1729506999,
-0.9751809239,
0.3623153865,
-0.3706865311,
-0.6314584613,
0.638869822,
0.8364314437,
0.3540341854,
0.1730239093,
0.6500432491,
0.19428128,
0.3060826957,
-0.3267560005,
1.0558451414,
-0.4801568389,
-0.1673596948,
-0.4178270996,
-1.2234168053,
-0.4475362301,
0.4325246513,
-0.0578022152,
0.0224757977,
0.6468872428,
0.2883323431,
-0.0983106643,
0.0362025052,
-0.0236567892,
-0.087274082,
0.3608179092,
0.4024603963,
0.8768468499,
-0.4290798604,
0.5316044092,
-0.454400599,
-0.2171976566,
-0.3003293872,
-1.0590794086,
-0.7613954544,
-0.4172210693,
-0.2096464485,
-0.4420809448,
0.2571389377,
1.2003060579,
0.3523100913,
-0.4537618458,
-0.1549732685,
0.1752122343,
-0.1517981142,
-0.3512858748,
-0.1398011297,
0.7702794671,
-0.2707979381,
-0.3501468897,
0.0929914638,
0.3523830175,
0.0199070629,
-0.3974224031,
-0.2676392496,
0.2678957582,
-0.0828942582,
0.603317678,
0.213043943,
-0.8116086721,
-0.3156959713,
-0.0403889567,
-0.3348887861,
0.1651477665,
0.580606699,
-0.5115429759,
0.594989419,
0.5083529949,
0.4167475104,
0.4546266794,
0.4288019836,
0.4753974378,
-0.499815464,
-0.3565432429,
0.5980761051,
0.4586526155,
0.2063618451,
-0.1314671338,
0.4280297458,
-0.037057694,
-0.9265452623,
-0.9029225111,
-0.0986663401,
-1.2458629608,
0.1172777191,
1.0666371584,
-0.237844348,
-0.356120348,
-0.2405655682,
-0.3516759574,
0.2453414351,
-0.3415338993,
1.0283750296,
0.6670286655,
-0.3679820299,
0.3469998538,
-0.3731129467,
0.5867308378,
0.2895740271,
-0.9652801156,
0.6023026705,
0.5946993828,
0.2022003829,
0.4624770284,
0.5282472372,
-0.2608705163,
0.7129666209,
-0.3052525222,
0.003122838,
-0.3492043018,
-0.1057720706,
-0.4104661047,
-0.0414174907,
0.2259389907,
0.1544534415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13294v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13294v3 | Adaptive Machine Translation with Large Language Models | 2023-01-30T21:17:15 | 2023-05-09T11:04:43 | Yasmin Moslem, Rejwanul Haque, John D. Kelleher, Andy Way | cs.CL | cs.CL | Consistency is a key requirement of high-quality translation. It is
especially important to adhere to pre-approved terminology and adapt to
corrected translations in domain-specific projects. Machine translation (MT)
has achieved significant progress in the area of domain adaptation. However,
real-time adaptation remains challenging. Large-scale language models (LLMs)
have recently shown interesting capabilities of in-context learning, where they
learn to replicate certain input-output text generation patterns, without
further fine-tuning. By feeding an LLM at inference time with a prompt that
consists of a list of translation pairs, it can then simulate the domain and
style characteristics. This work aims to investigate how we can utilize
in-context learning to improve real-time adaptive MT. Our extensive experiments
show promising results at translation time. For example, LLMs can adapt to a
set of in-domain sentence pairs and/or terminology while translating a new
sentence. We observe that the translation quality with few-shot in-context
learning can surpass that of strong encoder-decoder MT systems, especially for
high-resource languages. Moreover, we investigate whether we can combine MT
from strong encoder-decoder models with fuzzy matches, which can further
improve translation quality, especially for less supported languages. We
conduct our experiments across five diverse language pairs, namely
English-to-Arabic (EN-AR), English-to-Chinese (EN-ZH), English-to-French
(EN-FR), English-to-Kinyarwanda (EN-RW), and English-to-Spanish (EN-ES). | [
-0.3218814433,
-0.8924267292,
0.5173325539,
0.3762021959,
-0.3814449012,
0.1355152279,
-0.5537438989,
-0.4079873264,
-0.0805059373,
0.5216695666,
-0.4128731191,
-0.2464726865,
-0.6900684834,
0.5096336603,
-0.3234956264,
0.7766993642,
-0.5251044631,
0.1037120074,
-0.0857149214,
-0.3246945441,
-0.8129328489,
-0.5653257966,
-0.4972439408,
-0.2588637769,
0.1577784866,
0.5271513462,
0.7177799344,
0.6205188036,
0.5208313465,
0.2609983385,
0.1068227291,
0.5936953425,
-0.379714638,
0.3203204274,
-0.2945554852,
-0.1499062777,
-0.4075643718,
-0.2040817291,
0.9269400239,
0.5981193781,
-0.1074254066,
-0.0437520258,
0.2424328178,
0.5200178623,
-0.3465213478,
-0.0297898445,
-0.8799343109,
0.0133739524,
0.1611236036,
-0.2483174056,
-0.502638936,
-0.0761983171,
0.1109399125,
-0.7729394436,
0.0478199981,
0.2575072348,
0.9585907459,
0.2727990746,
-0.4072283208,
-0.3242537677,
-0.680773735,
0.6913151741,
-0.9416312575,
0.5159481764,
0.3363717198,
0.3041794896,
-0.5112739205,
-0.4265444577,
-0.6882874966,
-0.1825717241,
-0.0560230166,
0.1518713385,
0.03753528,
-0.2465039641,
0.1537813246,
-0.0163217373,
-0.5454272628,
0.2098274827,
0.2170549184,
0.067142114,
0.4853798747,
0.1536072791,
0.2039330602,
0.0705864877,
-0.3799427748,
-0.1961637139,
-0.5627649426,
-0.227639854,
-0.1553877592,
0.512943387,
-0.3763363957,
0.2508849502,
-0.1405896097,
0.9118496776,
0.3182400465,
-0.2243418694,
0.2068867236,
-0.3941942751,
-0.3157837689,
0.0857127979,
0.7190160155,
0.1604240984,
0.2249093652,
-0.2226822823,
-0.4742546976,
-0.4185945988,
0.0997113436,
-0.7404871583,
0.1954011768,
0.0202233139,
-0.415690124,
0.1586903036,
-0.1083211154,
-0.4887826145,
-0.1760264337,
-0.4137616754,
0.8997424841,
-0.5859407783,
-0.0924524739,
0.2391248941,
0.2127004564,
0.3463811576,
0.4484436214,
-0.6796345115,
0.2200929523,
0.5032479763,
1.020732522,
-0.292514205,
-0.5536891222,
-0.8525090218,
0.1956902295,
-0.5607655048,
0.6221158504,
-0.4642011523,
-0.1817220747,
0.0982097909,
0.1729889214,
-0.2535040975,
-0.7603852153,
0.3095394373,
-0.5805997252,
0.186123535,
-0.1403398812,
-0.527068615,
-0.1662836224,
0.2733692527,
-0.2586612403,
0.9655250311,
0.3599745631,
-0.3506168425,
0.3505004644,
-0.6944380403,
-0.7105063796,
-0.1232518032,
0.4291493595,
-0.5124471784,
0.2473071218,
0.2099060416,
0.7445503473,
-0.2855958343,
0.3226870298,
-0.2000106424,
-0.5519739985,
0.4766730666,
-0.3965086937,
0.3445687592,
0.3535076678,
-0.2614881396,
0.1797801107,
-0.6441653371,
-0.1927536875,
0.1911642104,
-0.3257352114,
-0.21238482,
0.1349176317,
0.246968165,
0.4928209484,
-0.0117468257,
-0.2506347001,
0.1493910551,
-0.4255702496,
0.6227470636,
0.620200336,
0.0225095246,
0.551839292,
-0.2444271892,
0.2280953079,
0.2468624413,
-0.143855989,
-0.1722749621,
-0.1274779439,
-0.7754741907,
-0.2648191452,
0.4367183149,
0.5789970756,
-1.1019560099,
0.4190906882,
-0.6347023845,
-0.1813842803,
-0.4702329934,
0.2275328189,
0.3641429543,
0.4739525318,
0.5116556883,
-0.440820992,
-0.1935091168,
-0.4826222658,
-0.3311297297,
0.1890996248,
-0.222215578,
0.2218560874,
0.5492148399,
-0.3234876096,
0.6905953884,
-0.2496536672,
-0.2759830654,
-0.1832891554,
-0.126858905,
0.274988085,
0.5193478465,
0.6159552932,
-0.7563635707,
-0.786218226,
0.1597895622,
-0.6235653758,
0.045766335,
-0.2978640497,
-0.354700774,
0.2892066538,
0.3982105553,
-0.3277180493,
-0.1838245839,
0.7848116755,
-0.3979958594,
0.2966266572,
-0.5267288685,
0.3257181346,
-1.5621522665,
-0.1603282392,
0.1045629904,
-0.4768257439,
-0.7480673194,
0.1691973805,
0.2065628916,
0.0051461365,
-0.5647372007,
0.7591380477,
-0.3884159029,
-0.131692186,
-0.4049546719,
0.3287240267,
-0.018596679,
0.4903389215,
0.1485610008,
0.8849896789,
0.3996608853,
-0.7531383038,
0.1649739742,
0.3312687874,
-0.4196969867,
0.7090646029,
-0.3430568278,
0.1178725138,
-0.0467833132,
0.3804261982,
-0.6586177349,
-0.5064936876,
0.3936216235,
-0.4366681576,
0.4147121012,
-0.0523472056,
-0.7918268442,
0.1602587551,
0.0833087787,
0.3257060051,
0.4276071489,
-0.7642785907,
0.5326674581,
-0.0099066133,
-0.0923059359,
-0.2131214142,
-0.4727890193,
0.3850863874,
-0.2059141845,
-0.3764789701,
0.3322425783,
-0.0868885741,
-0.1913377047,
-0.0389989801,
0.031413354,
-0.1602345407,
0.3936322033,
0.0644877031,
0.163585484,
-0.2399897873,
-0.0152690131,
0.1213628426,
0.0562022179,
-0.3171036541,
-0.6860518456,
0.4825204909,
0.1023566127,
-0.2234452665,
-0.2941984832,
0.4217373431,
0.6905873418,
-0.3033926189,
1.0420486927,
0.7217288613,
-0.6123709083,
-0.3190404475,
-0.2806223035,
-0.0607782081,
-0.4343075156,
0.4670056105,
-0.668500483,
-1.0033830404,
0.391207248,
-0.082775414,
0.1623499542,
0.3692035973,
0.6291636825,
-0.2182564139,
1.0491534472,
0.5793251991,
-0.1484683752,
0.5777807236,
0.0348697789,
0.2127066553,
-0.8464878798,
0.1447528452,
-0.3930793703,
-0.3213135898,
-0.5553772449,
-0.5251060128,
0.3346422911,
0.1691435426,
-0.3713791668,
0.5649007559,
-0.1732982099,
0.2992230058,
0.3822577596,
0.2174082249,
0.1812734008,
0.2102727443,
-0.0019789035,
0.0586983785,
-0.8352882862,
-0.464368701,
0.7022132874,
0.2371223122,
0.4901401997,
0.1654783785,
0.2858929634,
0.3222781718,
0.3094188273,
-0.7410740852,
0.248110041,
-0.4104704857,
-0.208257705,
-0.1190625653,
-0.5305905938,
-0.5972921252,
0.4377821684,
-0.4229679406,
-0.2194327116,
-0.0532811284,
0.1756051332,
-0.1607159823,
0.2735788524,
-0.5089536905,
0.8170973063,
-0.4042468071,
-0.4399922192,
-0.1324303299,
-0.6127277017,
0.1311867535,
-0.5586391091,
0.4188902676,
-0.086484246,
0.0235528667,
0.3877513707,
-0.0278481562,
0.6645103693,
0.022320535,
-0.2759782374,
0.0803220496,
0.352032721,
0.6948343515,
-0.0096926149,
-0.1610807627,
0.2495342046,
-0.0304116923,
-0.6416623592,
-0.5793557763,
0.6758412123,
-0.8227549195,
-0.4803957641,
-0.3447265029,
-0.8686878681,
-0.3142538071,
0.1143747121,
0.1732299775,
0.3998420835,
-0.0800470561,
0.0697001889,
0.6616793275,
-0.282156378,
0.4474398494,
0.6262644529,
0.0030122539,
-0.4863981307,
1.0130792856,
0.0386773236,
0.675334692,
0.6159862876,
0.1132249683,
-0.0457373075,
-0.7213898897,
-0.9344315529,
0.1835180968,
-0.4520946145,
-0.3225785196,
-0.5920133591,
0.0196030159,
-0.1994454414,
-0.487970233,
-0.0807435438,
-0.2057493776,
-0.3625737727,
0.3950812817,
0.3944572508,
0.5528027415,
0.4077292383,
0.5024014711,
-1.0833991766,
0.2539412975,
-0.0544598475,
0.3064290285,
-0.2098935694,
-1.18744874,
-0.5527796745,
0.1846244037,
-0.1165756285,
-0.6300179958,
0.4768012464,
0.5322167873,
0.284918189,
0.1344058812,
0.0235854723,
0.755629003,
-0.7787321806,
0.7988192439,
-0.068312645,
-0.9668384194,
0.2824380696,
-0.4145024121,
0.4153314829,
0.307623893,
0.3349713087,
-0.8978398442,
-0.2576585412,
-0.1801363379,
-0.4904695153,
0.6544613242,
0.0062575056,
0.2076420337,
0.0967604443,
0.6737241149,
0.1657438576,
-0.0419425108,
-0.396622926,
0.1987712234,
-0.2360961586,
-0.5235170126,
-0.4016436934,
-0.0856069997,
0.0235929936,
0.0473724529,
0.7297663689,
-0.5644296408,
0.1858033836,
0.080021359,
-0.4780403972,
-0.2401388437,
0.2806426287,
0.8069864511,
0.6097755432,
-0.060926348,
0.0551749505,
0.6654436588,
-0.2090244442,
0.3040878177,
-0.0951563865,
-0.2081444561,
0.0492017269,
0.495190084,
0.846455276,
0.2815622389,
-0.695148766,
0.3301672637,
0.0768164843,
-0.2117119879,
0.0099166892,
-0.0243737586,
-0.0215826426,
0.1767886877,
0.2830349803,
0.2026103735,
-0.2971391678,
-0.7084811926,
0.1195539162,
0.428763181,
-0.5342751145,
-0.4070008993,
0.6073915958,
0.1637588888,
-0.4220302105,
0.480124265,
-0.0988808721,
-0.6798369288,
0.3509723842,
0.9415384531,
0.8622956276,
-0.1141014695,
-0.1489543766,
0.3527523577,
0.0821157768,
-0.4765290916,
-0.0469981916,
0.0710894987,
-0.7759407759,
-0.4726842344,
-0.7979678512,
-0.4616897404,
-0.1897112429,
-0.2798499167,
0.2351982445,
-0.2985903323,
0.1111470312,
-0.4962522686,
-0.0617654622,
-0.5397132635,
0.2383998185,
-0.047058031,
1.0729904175,
-0.8053773642,
1.0612436533,
0.7638888359,
-0.1313977838,
-0.5572192073,
0.3680013418,
-0.2390459329,
-0.4969691932,
0.3805947602,
-0.0911123529,
-0.1947698891,
0.223405242,
-0.4464990497,
-0.9293769598,
0.9896503687,
0.4430191219,
-0.4942311347,
0.2075105458,
0.0447103381,
0.5221639276,
-0.5261649489,
-0.1994818151,
0.380187124,
0.4177778661,
-0.0670196041,
-1.0293786526,
0.1144744009,
0.0734027997,
0.0878183842,
0.3130643368,
-0.6541499496,
0.5464169383,
0.0128540015,
-0.1227235124,
0.103994444,
0.8249148726,
0.1378692985,
0.0585502535,
0.4415982366,
0.2067191005,
0.3697119951,
-0.1779716313,
0.786901176,
-0.3241391182,
0.3085788786,
1.0132377148,
-0.4111997485,
1.1261777878,
0.4786113501,
0.062668629,
0.2652222514,
0.7471028566,
0.1434938312,
0.4700726569,
-0.0778845325,
-0.2535461187,
-0.4399689436,
-0.183595255,
-0.2014617473,
0.3403347433,
0.3783913851,
-0.2248265296,
0.1024470255,
0.217863515,
0.1027044728,
0.3476621509,
-0.2357330769,
0.7898583412,
0.1211151108,
-0.7322887778,
0.848100543,
0.271268636,
0.8362095356,
-0.5386523008,
-0.1469095796,
-0.3050894141,
0.3143076897,
-0.0484618358,
-0.611489594,
0.0875977501,
0.0747230276,
-0.2276469171,
-0.3061729372,
0.6060324311,
-0.6530150771,
-0.5337611437,
0.2735342085,
0.4900893867,
-0.1047855765,
0.001235985,
-0.5375519991,
0.0664513335,
-0.22787489,
-0.0077590845,
0.720592618,
0.5902761817,
-0.2089457065,
0.6571440697,
0.6404563785,
0.0498890169,
0.0064700888,
-0.1649872363,
0.5566139221,
-0.4993006885,
-0.2337251455,
-0.7868451476,
0.1534003317,
0.2280218154,
-0.1538891643,
0.7637776732,
0.399646014,
1.1856359243,
-0.2392290682,
0.6522068977,
0.1130681485,
0.1801852584,
-0.6829450727,
0.7287973166,
-0.8494037986,
-0.0712919012,
-0.2876062095,
-1.0702732801,
-0.5507238507,
0.5608455539,
0.1049816683,
-0.1125973091,
0.5453674197,
0.6992330551,
-0.3118627667,
-0.4157018363,
0.4419818223,
0.209134832,
0.3400998414,
0.5911266804,
0.6344393492,
-0.5981783867,
0.417313844,
0.0292318221,
-0.1911126822,
-0.3829594851,
-0.9299203157,
-0.6650611758,
-0.7291330695,
-0.2561474144,
-0.5128532648,
0.2819799781,
1.5289299488,
0.5426273942,
-0.9271793365,
-0.3531586528,
0.2742573023,
0.0660255849,
-0.6654964685,
-0.1228105873,
0.29973194,
-0.4715082645,
-0.832308352,
0.5919468999,
0.3971447051,
0.0697190464,
0.1459141225,
-0.3583251834,
-0.2263168842,
0.1851172,
0.9016903639,
0.0701750889,
-0.6702108979,
-0.6211791635,
0.1240783408,
-0.258220762,
0.1581772417,
0.6423835754,
-0.5529516935,
0.4006536901,
0.4810199738,
0.9105676413,
0.2064075023,
0.0514541492,
0.6785257459,
-0.6192527413,
-0.0055450178,
-0.1024017707,
0.3503033817,
0.4960788488,
-0.1448604465,
0.3901201487,
0.2651608586,
-0.4900529981,
-0.7049738765,
0.1777852029,
-0.7748472691,
-0.3106757402,
1.1594836712,
-0.2334639579,
-0.1815765351,
-0.0444718115,
-0.2043294013,
0.4014748931,
-0.2167053521,
0.6609100699,
0.7054286599,
0.0113173136,
0.0379105732,
-0.663392365,
0.2596415281,
0.3282546103,
-0.676431179,
0.1273889244,
0.3294575512,
0.4595212936,
-0.136596784,
0.2184514552,
0.1341753751,
0.1843367368,
-0.3858977556,
-0.1910090894,
0.0402652286,
-0.2818527818,
-0.5923138261,
-0.1152420193,
0.254965663,
-0.1171017513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13268v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13268v2 | Contextual Dynamic Prompting for Response Generation in Task-oriented Dialog Systems | 2023-01-30T20:26:02 | 2023-02-10T23:16:02 | Sandesh Swamy, Narges Tabari, Chacha Chen, Rashmi Gangadharaiah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Response generation is one of the critical components in task-oriented dialog
systems. Existing studies have shown that large pre-trained language models can
be adapted to this task. The typical paradigm of adapting such extremely large
language models would be by fine-tuning on the downstream tasks which is not
only time-consuming but also involves significant resources and access to
fine-tuning data. Prompting (Schick and Sch\"utze, 2020) has been an
alternative to fine-tuning in many NLP tasks. In our work, we explore the idea
of using prompting for response generation in task-oriented dialog systems.
Specifically, we propose an approach that performs contextual dynamic prompting
where the prompts are learnt from dialog contexts. We aim to distill useful
prompting signals from the dialog context. On experiments with MultiWOZ 2.2
dataset (Zang et al., 2020), we show that contextual dynamic prompts improve
response generation in terms of combined score (Mehri et al., 2019) by 3
absolute points, and a massive 20 points when dialog states are incorporated.
Furthermore, human annotation on these conversations found that agents which
incorporate context were preferred over agents with vanilla prefix-tuning. | [
-0.549552381,
-1.0393884182,
0.5036053061,
0.3167011738,
-0.2172350883,
-0.2293944508,
-0.3623488843,
-0.3664329946,
-0.0223718565,
0.3358053863,
-1.1245076656,
0.004349512,
-0.0122641446,
0.4252268672,
0.0638204142,
1.0769152641,
0.2073235959,
-0.1137120724,
-0.2042045891,
-0.0625516698,
-1.2246006727,
-0.3182033598,
-0.8186619282,
-0.3948068619,
0.7796618342,
0.3660198748,
0.3391155899,
0.2474213839,
-0.0819484517,
0.3328064382,
-0.0835662559,
0.3348919451,
-0.3053394854,
0.8962365985,
-0.0970507786,
-0.3650335073,
-0.5892990828,
-0.127798453,
0.407713145,
0.6492871046,
-0.0412022844,
0.238183409,
0.3515647352,
0.5644620657,
-0.5464164019,
0.2919855118,
-0.6989078522,
0.2669257224,
0.102647312,
-0.8788220882,
-0.6579883695,
-0.0612468421,
0.4994413555,
-0.7122699022,
0.2263761461,
0.0938446596,
0.2937294245,
0.3697574139,
-0.4895617366,
-0.4921166003,
-0.654330194,
0.6309922338,
-0.4561224878,
0.021019483,
0.1336085498,
0.2551398575,
-0.3549273014,
-0.4767329693,
-0.5737404823,
-0.3072556555,
-0.0176366717,
0.3437479436,
-0.1936007738,
0.0959079266,
0.5759634972,
0.0344159156,
-0.3285262883,
-0.1180524081,
0.1416547447,
-0.1002065018,
0.2135545313,
0.5433334708,
0.036312215,
-0.148009032,
-0.3250263035,
-0.2362195551,
-0.6034577489,
0.3168427944,
0.2274072766,
0.7727074623,
-0.0328821614,
0.1138713583,
-0.3616172969,
1.0366280079,
0.6462661028,
0.0230479613,
0.0766180232,
-0.5550852418,
-0.1251948029,
0.0901726484,
0.5416166186,
0.5871957541,
0.2897013128,
0.175759986,
-0.1466145664,
-0.1684171259,
0.4131833613,
-0.7412096858,
-0.0507024787,
0.1730621606,
-0.3522107601,
-0.3035576642,
-0.1945390552,
-0.8023236394,
-0.3662110269,
-0.4406768382,
0.3659122586,
-0.1493270695,
-0.204902485,
-0.1023496985,
-0.1245064214,
0.1162162721,
0.7157207727,
-1.0226682425,
-0.15765284,
0.3211058974,
0.5313634872,
0.0416158549,
-0.1234969646,
-1.0014003515,
0.0879021659,
-0.1204427332,
0.7898890972,
-0.5304138064,
-0.5766800642,
0.257884413,
0.0643507987,
-0.0881481618,
-0.6823297143,
0.1549643576,
-0.5925201774,
0.3216728568,
-0.7133996487,
-0.2095743716,
0.0248445962,
0.3967376351,
-0.3819881678,
0.9410161376,
0.1794520915,
-0.6517022848,
0.4074909687,
-0.828240931,
-0.354133904,
0.2295195609,
0.0033711772,
0.0492981598,
0.2361486405,
0.3834961057,
0.3329565823,
-0.1949301809,
0.2943535447,
-0.1649865508,
-0.1961397231,
0.3707464337,
-0.6440537572,
0.478192687,
0.2832947075,
-0.4212861955,
0.2863213122,
-0.6338360906,
0.2247737795,
-0.032282237,
-0.5418784022,
-0.2078670412,
-0.0287581962,
-0.1309872568,
0.2652339041,
0.1570203453,
-0.2858486474,
0.3345464468,
-0.2287788838,
0.2476893216,
0.8272124529,
0.1455793083,
0.2332351804,
-0.1789479256,
0.5781396031,
0.0138795376,
-0.1073201299,
-0.740049243,
-0.41909343,
-0.5009521246,
0.0876904353,
0.0821468607,
0.6035229564,
-0.9808005691,
0.4448466003,
0.0516133867,
0.0546769314,
-0.0342628099,
-0.0923089832,
0.4276230633,
0.9931915998,
0.1701059043,
-0.0116132265,
-0.3728896379,
-0.6217178702,
-0.123835437,
-0.377371192,
-0.3136949539,
0.6578093767,
0.0777953416,
0.1438514143,
1.0413751602,
-0.5670761466,
0.0016589751,
-0.3240274489,
0.2907801867,
0.0715388581,
0.3498153687,
0.6092375517,
-0.7240991592,
-0.6372938156,
-0.2086559683,
-0.5959433317,
-0.5571916699,
-0.1897550225,
0.0476166233,
0.0889016837,
0.5407716036,
-0.531422317,
0.1135074422,
0.4577544928,
-0.4733561277,
0.7454811335,
-0.2538848221,
0.1943153441,
-1.2441045046,
0.2640599012,
-0.3055408597,
-0.3721101582,
-0.8538145423,
-0.1650671214,
-0.1974606812,
-0.2228520364,
-0.4218982756,
0.6492047906,
-0.3362690806,
0.1729879826,
-0.5000955462,
0.0911385566,
-0.0750976428,
0.6341243982,
0.0626968816,
0.9591569901,
0.4652849436,
-0.8225435615,
0.5376192331,
0.4417663813,
-0.1708458215,
0.8297775388,
-0.7167688608,
0.253382504,
-0.1495725513,
0.7051697969,
-0.9724776745,
-0.4076236784,
0.3801018894,
-0.2917280495,
0.1164825559,
-0.0495420769,
-0.2943037748,
-0.3488793969,
-0.1420175135,
0.3941168189,
0.3232865334,
-0.6100021005,
0.6006788611,
0.0436508283,
-0.492854327,
-0.3748198748,
-0.2917490005,
-0.0625036806,
-0.1666132361,
-0.379919976,
0.0466723517,
-0.4614140689,
0.0013457043,
-0.3421416879,
-0.0749247521,
0.2913841009,
0.1619726717,
0.4069589972,
0.1223299429,
-0.2014310807,
0.1427299231,
0.1679698825,
-0.1645137519,
0.1657708138,
-0.2594839334,
0.7595754266,
-0.1009963751,
-0.2444598377,
-0.7604765296,
0.5643785596,
0.5106008649,
-0.1302285939,
0.417470485,
0.4491536617,
-0.1610530317,
-0.0199818257,
-0.3104041517,
-0.6313188672,
-0.5727496147,
0.2223392129,
-0.4091836214,
-0.9914777279,
0.4943334162,
-0.1891659647,
0.1111405417,
-0.0565481894,
0.8275878429,
-0.1852486134,
1.4410002232,
0.4069591463,
0.1615010947,
0.850099206,
0.2294917405,
0.186874032,
-0.7559679151,
-0.1354427636,
-0.5606939197,
-0.3460407853,
-0.382527709,
-0.1059950888,
0.6007814407,
-0.1167356595,
0.126102373,
0.0342622884,
-0.2718438208,
0.2100614905,
0.5923499465,
0.0504067056,
0.0074987314,
0.1027482152,
-0.1326894611,
0.0686860457,
-0.7234358191,
-0.38013044,
0.5794478655,
0.1537057608,
0.4946737289,
0.0248293933,
0.3957358003,
0.2678608,
0.0918807834,
-0.9200566411,
0.7710997462,
0.3758829534,
-0.506605804,
-0.4011697471,
-0.2983604968,
-1.2333199978,
0.0505464301,
-0.3792912066,
-0.8664479256,
0.0375191644,
0.6863913536,
-0.9598165751,
-0.2767588496,
-0.5799250603,
0.5643022656,
0.2368787527,
-0.235030219,
-0.1239567399,
-0.7000384331,
-0.1556039602,
0.1591095328,
-0.158348605,
-0.1251035929,
0.3885192573,
0.474080801,
-0.2060296386,
1.0792789459,
-0.6287449598,
-0.3631947935,
0.3185801804,
0.2042637169,
0.71922189,
0.3163309097,
-0.0308249984,
-0.5985446572,
-0.0258895252,
-0.1859398186,
-0.771823585,
0.5904254913,
-0.2057506293,
-0.8575763106,
-0.1362518817,
-0.8999375701,
-0.5586485267,
0.2034880668,
0.2313274443,
0.8234754205,
0.0751293153,
0.2194378376,
0.7708829045,
-0.215437755,
0.532143116,
0.6299769878,
0.0687405616,
-0.0382733345,
0.5996007323,
-0.2516005337,
0.3087495267,
0.1580267102,
0.2831162512,
-0.3944151103,
-0.245560199,
-0.6903768182,
-0.2547873855,
-0.4631799757,
-0.2703737319,
-0.6855451465,
0.1525207311,
-0.3206521571,
-0.2031325251,
-0.0578295365,
-0.1337292492,
-0.3710011244,
-0.0002105981,
0.2394999862,
0.6096944213,
0.1434734464,
0.3012646437,
-1.0448188782,
0.203032881,
0.7976817489,
0.0000918428,
0.2494979352,
-0.332426399,
-0.076752536,
0.2531062961,
-0.4066253901,
-0.8744812608,
0.1372561455,
0.2239262313,
0.4300934374,
0.4464199543,
0.3996402621,
0.7212819457,
-0.7629411221,
1.0804746151,
0.0925165117,
-0.7853027582,
0.8727962375,
-0.7249128222,
0.7555400729,
0.5944954157,
-0.0823380128,
-0.6993942857,
-0.3607980609,
-0.3392530978,
-0.8925668001,
0.9649142623,
-0.125597477,
0.6897287965,
-0.17397286,
0.465054661,
0.2663497925,
0.4103812873,
-0.2831087708,
-0.106704317,
-0.0701212361,
-0.0961225554,
0.1072228178,
-0.3148933947,
-0.4026786089,
0.0534588508,
0.3515097797,
-0.6799687743,
0.5492984653,
0.1430237591,
0.079123795,
-0.3544584811,
0.3233923316,
0.8803557158,
0.7065657377,
-0.1073682904,
0.0152518591,
0.3591042161,
-0.2055975795,
0.1234136522,
-0.0654472038,
-0.1651107222,
-0.1497809887,
0.2176792771,
1.1196386814,
0.0768187046,
-0.661570847,
0.3859483302,
-0.2353963554,
-0.0412174463,
-0.0402357318,
0.3165903091,
-0.1771880686,
0.3869570494,
0.5498511195,
-0.0220369697,
0.2165999413,
-0.6267104745,
0.0176843442,
0.480114609,
-0.4575791955,
-0.5272887945,
0.4770812988,
0.5993113518,
-0.3868693113,
0.5703271627,
-0.132233128,
-0.5948666334,
0.2896657884,
0.8670009375,
0.708686173,
-0.2489767522,
0.2747587562,
0.3990207016,
-0.3553011417,
0.0681153163,
0.2771946788,
-0.5638303757,
-0.5981635451,
-0.3205245435,
-0.4511223435,
-0.4728925526,
0.2849708796,
-0.819473505,
-0.0488434248,
-0.2294264585,
-0.3279226422,
-0.1464000493,
-0.2074771374,
-0.4510483742,
0.1658534706,
0.2183525264,
0.8774165511,
-0.6992061734,
0.4850611985,
0.9274654388,
0.194003582,
-0.8250694275,
0.4597011805,
0.168123275,
-0.5503131151,
0.6691592336,
0.3653342724,
-0.2907402813,
0.0454958081,
-0.3924704194,
-0.5502712727,
0.8864579797,
0.3658513427,
-0.3414850235,
-0.0897091702,
-0.1130975783,
0.6354305148,
-0.4427950382,
0.138458997,
0.2785306573,
0.464871794,
0.0630086362,
-1.0638277531,
0.3297162354,
-0.3197630644,
0.187419042,
0.0453781299,
-0.6493242383,
0.6384399533,
-0.0552448891,
-0.2931876779,
0.2050115168,
0.6438652277,
0.3347920775,
0.3084115982,
0.931677103,
-0.0791037977,
0.6825185418,
-0.182325989,
0.8177292943,
-0.4305563569,
0.0379956402,
1.0962561369,
-0.3764351606,
0.6019973755,
0.7042233944,
0.2263339162,
0.4698830247,
0.5872349143,
0.3461100459,
0.5762653351,
-0.1046745554,
-0.5617281199,
-0.3561000824,
-0.4602565467,
-0.3903015852,
0.4433730841,
0.327775538,
0.0451750122,
-0.2359132767,
0.2204488069,
-0.1219586357,
-0.0925512761,
-0.1301728487,
0.9539037943,
-0.1329189092,
-1.2778875828,
0.6127645373,
-0.4043870866,
0.4869769514,
-0.6549704075,
-0.1221786067,
-0.1619514376,
-0.0736523718,
0.104373917,
-0.6758934855,
0.1177652702,
0.0169316437,
-0.4736970961,
-0.5546528697,
0.5926830769,
-0.521039784,
0.2083196342,
0.1184652969,
0.4303089678,
-0.1725014597,
-0.0450917147,
-0.6539684534,
-0.1440728605,
0.0449546687,
-0.6012160182,
0.4152881503,
0.47253865,
-0.1467591375,
0.6386883855,
0.853271842,
-0.230438143,
-0.1730737537,
0.1808067411,
0.9033272862,
-0.425126493,
-0.625415504,
-0.5538861156,
0.6530430913,
-0.0203443896,
-0.2696250975,
0.5586207509,
-0.0185739286,
0.4804846942,
-0.3431420624,
0.7546951771,
-0.3022261262,
0.4582521319,
-0.599447906,
0.3959946334,
-0.521612227,
0.0827602893,
-0.123064667,
-0.8696186543,
-0.0892696157,
0.5083091855,
0.0226639714,
0.1031778976,
0.3664318323,
0.761043489,
0.2044085264,
0.0641687289,
0.3201282024,
0.029784942,
0.3815872967,
0.3859480917,
0.9978203773,
0.1688315123,
0.2680050433,
0.174848035,
-0.2702944279,
-0.6211821437,
-1.0866146088,
-0.8608086109,
-0.7417085767,
-0.116912663,
-0.4002297819,
0.0444553308,
1.2189172506,
0.6380746365,
-0.8648422956,
0.0868900865,
0.0766376257,
-0.2652668059,
-0.3678314388,
-0.2534720302,
-0.1193089262,
-0.6061038971,
-0.8839181662,
0.685129106,
0.3321141005,
0.2169136554,
-0.028663855,
-0.0229719449,
0.1486841589,
0.1183049232,
0.7188431621,
0.3046604991,
-0.6445317268,
-0.5040177107,
0.1105299741,
0.0103081735,
-0.0452610962,
1.0671471357,
-0.8498385549,
0.5702431798,
0.5540258288,
0.3483851552,
0.1204899177,
0.1012626216,
0.9201275706,
-1.0742995739,
0.3099213243,
0.120644182,
0.0241304878,
0.2077641487,
-0.4759460688,
0.0828077942,
0.0057828077,
-0.5008433461,
-0.9361584783,
0.4812084138,
-1.022809267,
-0.0794112161,
0.994023025,
-0.2514175773,
0.0023681067,
-0.1529254913,
-0.683264792,
0.2370506376,
-0.7160129547,
0.730024755,
0.5672200918,
-0.4128163755,
-0.0475339331,
-0.4949599802,
0.716986239,
0.7275614142,
-0.8040777445,
0.4503787458,
0.6374313235,
0.1116360053,
0.2902383208,
0.7390520573,
0.3340289295,
0.474440515,
-0.2261952609,
-0.3513529599,
-0.1146435961,
-0.4560833275,
-0.3012271523,
0.1920996159,
-0.0218193289,
-0.0557693318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13267v1 | ArchiSound: Audio Generation with Diffusion | 2023-01-30T20:23:26 | 2023-01-30T20:23:26 | Flavio Schneider | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | The recent surge in popularity of diffusion models for image generation has
brought new attention to the potential of these models in other areas of media
generation. One area that has yet to be fully explored is the application of
diffusion models to audio generation. Audio generation requires an
understanding of multiple aspects, such as the temporal dimension, long term
structure, multiple layers of overlapping sounds, and the nuances that only
trained listeners can detect. In this work, we investigate the potential of
diffusion models for audio generation. We propose a set of models to tackle
multiple aspects, including a new method for text-conditional latent audio
diffusion with stacked 1D U-Nets, that can generate multiple minutes of music
from a textual description. For each model, we make an effort to maintain
reasonable inference speed, targeting real-time on a single consumer GPU. In
addition to trained models, we provide a collection of open source libraries
with the hope of simplifying future work in the field. Samples can be found at
https://bit.ly/audio-diffusion. Codes are at
https://github.com/archinetai/audio-diffusion-pytorch. | [
-0.6551069021,
-1.0452913046,
0.5897898674,
0.5428717732,
-0.3199391663,
-0.1768707782,
0.0183970146,
-0.3611249626,
0.1197358221,
0.6793856621,
-0.6824718118,
-0.4241830707,
-0.5013435483,
-0.3342571855,
-0.8241612315,
0.7489369512,
0.1687518507,
-0.013909285,
-0.0964408889,
-0.0324471146,
-0.6787054539,
0.1121549457,
-1.0764567852,
-0.4283071458,
0.127687484,
0.0408700071,
0.3285137117,
0.3932062984,
0.0654423609,
0.2188693583,
-0.4502653182,
-0.2267096788,
0.0617582165,
0.60287112,
0.2553208172,
-0.0237890277,
-0.5365248322,
0.0738258064,
0.6420862675,
0.6964136958,
-0.4842062891,
0.3952642977,
-0.2134504318,
0.4437604547,
-0.3777546585,
-0.3810532987,
-0.3016462624,
0.4469899833,
-0.1460665017,
-0.3462708592,
-0.1124262437,
-0.3056785762,
0.1538923234,
-0.6849014759,
0.5019444227,
0.1860438734,
0.3218604326,
0.4703451991,
-0.2791472971,
-0.3491048515,
-1.046338439,
0.4040432572,
-0.6166604757,
0.4159690738,
0.3991883099,
0.398473829,
0.1360720247,
-0.8080509305,
-0.4839297235,
0.0220775623,
0.4115978777,
0.2945261002,
-0.5340255499,
-0.0659759417,
0.1296245605,
0.6581751704,
-0.5661615133,
-0.0576025285,
-0.278324753,
0.0384977683,
0.3142046034,
-0.0684973076,
0.3856672943,
-0.1321461052,
-0.3208020926,
-0.0136899063,
-0.7852703333,
-0.1124871895,
1.0449192524,
-0.0705801621,
-0.1832977682,
0.2705130279,
0.1469243914,
0.651684463,
0.2289873213,
-0.2281904817,
0.0899139866,
-0.3701880574,
-0.1154315695,
0.4464614689,
0.7898388505,
-0.1132681891,
-0.4553866982,
0.134748742,
-0.5414554477,
0.0122026131,
0.1446092427,
-0.9417136312,
-0.5194877386,
0.4689795375,
-0.5846268535,
-0.2800077498,
-0.5346331,
-0.6977737546,
-0.1184710935,
-0.249328196,
0.5709685087,
-0.352519244,
-0.8461121321,
0.4389005303,
-0.5586479902,
-0.3673017621,
-0.0980515182,
-0.6325384378,
0.3779829443,
0.3384318948,
0.937030673,
-0.0593535416,
0.1089826077,
-0.4793403447,
0.0477686077,
-0.2997422516,
0.8699788451,
-0.3411088288,
-0.5899773836,
0.0149888676,
-0.5548251271,
0.4536119699,
-0.5452605486,
0.530743897,
-0.4328562319,
0.4231647253,
0.2820090055,
-0.4597780704,
-0.0391602367,
-0.5548702478,
-0.7120550275,
0.9489228725,
0.0236372314,
-0.7449558973,
0.4504948258,
-0.9068321586,
-0.5981470942,
0.049961336,
0.0057143932,
-0.8151129484,
0.2055038065,
0.0251167938,
0.4572238922,
-0.3596552908,
0.3706227541,
-0.2792796195,
-0.1304428875,
-0.088006407,
-0.6428490877,
0.6270233989,
0.7703527808,
-0.3602777421,
-0.1359704733,
-0.8742406368,
-0.5076183081,
0.0534267798,
-0.4642248452,
-0.5604929924,
0.1515755057,
0.5871642828,
-0.0237500407,
-0.3765770793,
-0.5250591636,
0.0425882526,
-0.0371528938,
0.4912338257,
0.5801278353,
0.3866693676,
0.6843003035,
-0.2279906273,
0.7272328734,
0.1773002744,
-0.1326470971,
-0.4698534906,
-0.4831923246,
-0.1679261923,
-0.3362492025,
0.2959076762,
0.1324988604,
-0.677690208,
0.2709305584,
0.124981299,
-0.2378477305,
-0.458484292,
0.1280450672,
0.208234936,
0.5288417935,
0.310608089,
-0.43298015,
-0.673500061,
-0.6957167983,
0.2743213773,
-0.0643506274,
-0.4067457914,
0.5647996664,
0.1684413552,
-0.1072973534,
0.8404462337,
-0.4696477354,
0.0386609361,
-0.1286085993,
0.598197639,
0.1699993312,
0.7591879964,
0.7795494199,
-0.9042733908,
0.0373223983,
-0.4690195918,
-0.5530988574,
-0.5753924251,
-0.2621633112,
-0.0536715835,
-0.3271792829,
0.522972703,
-0.4837237298,
-0.0144771775,
0.7610067725,
-0.2948938012,
0.5200411677,
-0.2154373229,
0.1455443203,
-1.2013156414,
-0.1391033679,
0.3239603639,
-0.1697504967,
-0.6221628785,
-0.353215605,
-0.5783013105,
-0.3475126922,
-0.6522764564,
0.5312720537,
-0.484447062,
-0.2907803357,
-0.5120248795,
0.1743002534,
-0.1285598278,
0.2278815955,
0.2943103909,
0.5742042065,
0.9387469292,
-0.8093996644,
0.1956518888,
0.1053888053,
-0.5660526156,
0.8015201688,
-0.8445112109,
0.0067806011,
-0.192604959,
0.4669564068,
-0.9716381431,
-0.0502862148,
0.0586963892,
-0.2409714907,
0.2835307717,
-0.3935478628,
-0.4343639314,
-0.3091222346,
0.3392452896,
0.8745070696,
0.5862290263,
-0.7200006843,
0.7501972318,
0.4820974469,
-0.2842839658,
-0.3011336029,
-0.5935831666,
-0.191678077,
-0.6493695378,
-0.9086998701,
0.3356308341,
-0.2160252929,
-0.4097873867,
0.3780681193,
-0.1579073071,
-0.1045457274,
0.1213457361,
0.5616072416,
0.0096274326,
-0.6444298625,
0.0498021506,
0.4950362146,
0.0871667862,
-0.0429078043,
-0.9704371691,
0.4700632393,
0.2022176832,
-0.2287038267,
-0.1788072735,
0.4827028811,
0.3469817936,
-0.2270760387,
0.0700323209,
0.8561097383,
-0.1240746453,
-0.2956404388,
-0.3454899192,
-0.0336546116,
-0.468293637,
0.0667310283,
-0.2420084774,
-0.7143320441,
0.4073034227,
-0.3520401418,
0.1388331652,
0.429225266,
0.5104644895,
-0.2369180322,
1.0066559315,
0.587628603,
0.3318302631,
0.7851186395,
-0.5863128901,
-0.2585441172,
-0.9968857765,
0.0501780882,
-0.4672868252,
-0.3000282645,
-0.4452611208,
-0.2163220048,
0.1759545356,
0.0022308885,
-0.0739663169,
0.2491342574,
-0.5001111627,
0.4671377838,
0.5734624267,
-0.1078677252,
0.1410031319,
0.2437032908,
-0.2136742324,
0.6027086377,
-0.7015010715,
-0.0809482783,
0.8693429232,
0.3835974038,
0.8087352514,
0.2763374746,
0.6069824696,
0.7624132633,
-0.0103001874,
-0.3245355487,
0.2129707932,
-0.0221881978,
-0.6644562483,
-0.2472290546,
-0.4585683346,
-0.8924719095,
0.4183411002,
-0.4944235384,
-0.2571048141,
0.220352754,
0.0741063803,
-0.4968051016,
0.390419811,
-0.5496219397,
0.484174788,
-0.1981023252,
-0.4078739583,
-0.0981991217,
-0.3517196476,
0.5141577125,
-0.1497739702,
0.3224056959,
-0.329803586,
0.3040473759,
0.7857395411,
-0.0029653686,
0.5018977523,
-0.3294092715,
-0.0170577858,
0.4702858031,
0.1657832414,
-0.0228502806,
0.4002746046,
0.4005539715,
0.0473686531,
-0.1988250017,
-0.2609030902,
-0.0638516843,
0.6745678186,
-0.6312978268,
-0.3831733167,
0.1250591278,
-0.6004904509,
0.1042691767,
0.176490441,
0.601487577,
0.7254520059,
-0.1434765756,
0.0230543613,
0.9780538082,
-0.2614348829,
0.779528439,
0.3933535218,
-0.3763496876,
-0.3198877871,
0.6992428899,
-0.3557913899,
0.1253076345,
0.0128424177,
0.3519746661,
-0.3522913158,
-0.7481185794,
-0.5987637043,
0.090551883,
-0.4347427189,
0.1124965623,
-0.6621499658,
0.3385368288,
-0.275669843,
0.0858802572,
-0.5859948993,
-0.6389229298,
-0.3777204752,
-0.1544050723,
0.1255888045,
0.8377037048,
-0.3524589539,
0.62707901,
-0.5018665195,
0.6172755957,
0.2470039278,
0.3483532965,
-0.053213995,
-0.5237011313,
-0.127946198,
-0.2601104975,
-0.3132759333,
-0.8809450269,
0.3664987087,
0.1078289449,
0.6409774423,
0.5105172992,
-0.3293713629,
0.183180809,
-0.5802140832,
0.8469698429,
0.4641239941,
-0.7408052683,
0.6905922294,
-0.4209471345,
0.2517062128,
0.1752394736,
0.2940188944,
-0.478432864,
-0.6097308397,
-0.8701927662,
-1.0757879019,
0.3010185957,
0.4915907383,
0.1328032762,
0.1401059031,
0.1637788117,
0.1878200322,
0.2699676156,
-0.4499024451,
-0.4212900102,
-0.5072546005,
0.2050770223,
-0.1192038432,
-0.0539444722,
-0.1545975655,
0.100500308,
0.6462899446,
0.2893086672,
0.2368195802,
0.1542398334,
0.0504506081,
-0.2471465021,
0.2507896721,
0.8403391838,
0.24168621,
-0.3101877272,
0.2573669553,
-0.415943265,
-0.4617393315,
0.5186548829,
-0.0483859815,
-0.1450272501,
0.3341511488,
0.0577899441,
1.0845307112,
0.140591681,
-0.1829758286,
0.5188239217,
-0.3199981749,
-0.4303319752,
-0.7046185732,
0.0336053371,
0.293931365,
0.2864029706,
0.5302278399,
0.4692981243,
0.3722821176,
-0.2025340647,
0.4637514651,
0.0246303212,
-0.3111172915,
-0.2108726054,
1.3089952469,
0.1559996158,
-0.4248966575,
0.6299644113,
-0.107910499,
0.042043712,
0.5364787579,
0.5875422955,
1.170653224,
-0.2168850899,
0.1632406116,
0.1027002335,
-0.1322998106,
-0.3051947355,
-0.214260906,
-0.5775595903,
-0.5324887037,
-0.4144423604,
-0.9509602189,
-0.1761032194,
0.1745735258,
-0.521014154,
0.032946799,
-0.1779259741,
-0.4880135357,
0.2132695317,
-0.5457340479,
-0.4282563031,
0.0516611785,
0.2917041779,
0.8007593751,
-1.3193041086,
0.6972483993,
0.3549859226,
-0.490614295,
-0.5833351612,
-0.1881584376,
-0.0543821231,
-0.0425383113,
0.5670819283,
-0.4412758946,
-0.2157245576,
-0.0212718416,
-0.5286956429,
-0.4715507925,
1.0561583042,
0.0718017891,
-0.339625895,
-0.0842297897,
-0.4385676086,
0.4715588689,
-0.6920198202,
0.1584614217,
0.5849958062,
0.3760886788,
0.6061751842,
-0.2290414125,
-0.4636341929,
-0.30963099,
0.0560756363,
0.1854111701,
-0.1129265502,
1.0660996437,
-0.0545217916,
-0.1307733357,
-0.065787442,
0.6970717311,
0.4187278152,
0.4189752638,
0.7344684005,
0.7395150661,
0.4517750144,
-0.1282317191,
1.1349854469,
-0.2166138291,
0.133767128,
1.0323439837,
0.2019557655,
0.477393806,
0.2318448424,
0.1248947755,
0.336350888,
0.8193389773,
-0.0551417731,
0.725069046,
0.1984582394,
-0.5086669922,
-0.3376630843,
0.054737214,
-0.3400306106,
0.332241267,
0.2113479823,
-0.3818292022,
0.0031350232,
0.5311239362,
-0.191812396,
-0.398501426,
-0.1631435007,
0.5825456381,
-0.0423199348,
-0.5012188554,
0.1553439349,
-0.2360123098,
0.813390851,
-0.2376074493,
-0.3449040055,
-0.5177307725,
-0.3200426996,
-0.147051841,
-0.7132891417,
0.1096661836,
-0.145024851,
-0.3007511497,
-0.5027573109,
0.590932548,
-0.5213006735,
-0.2781755924,
0.2623437941,
0.4366578162,
0.268677026,
-0.0680551678,
-0.3661231995,
-0.040460173,
-0.0751225576,
-0.1924298257,
0.0855451897,
0.191266492,
0.2618674934,
0.3986988068,
0.788189292,
0.5368187428,
0.3381818235,
0.2151584774,
0.2575393319,
-0.0387031958,
-0.6217791438,
-0.4065186679,
0.3312723041,
0.2657001317,
-0.2487761229,
0.397993803,
0.7298941612,
0.6362030506,
-0.1465633512,
0.6808903813,
0.0465866886,
0.2336648703,
-0.7845913768,
0.7785103321,
-0.8444551229,
0.5070976615,
-0.4463977814,
-1.0146592855,
0.0300124139,
0.1799327731,
0.1344215125,
0.0116155986,
0.4678403735,
0.4255925417,
-0.4490829408,
0.1283754706,
0.37812832,
0.0997437015,
0.4010297358,
0.237494424,
0.9533634782,
-0.2942260206,
0.5877394676,
-0.2486341596,
0.1049514487,
0.0674347878,
-0.682821095,
-0.3844860196,
-0.865596354,
-0.4415887296,
-0.1790114194,
-0.045575805,
0.3091403544,
0.9734367728,
-0.2788860202,
-0.2451266348,
-0.2072803378,
0.1500654817,
-0.2308107316,
-0.160472393,
0.2375411093,
0.1289108098,
-0.746384263,
0.686006546,
0.2545666397,
0.4266045988,
-0.5350232124,
-0.0458402373,
-0.0565673858,
0.3376871645,
0.4534490108,
0.2091188282,
-0.5455113649,
-0.0789230466,
-0.196217984,
0.0471049324,
0.1776233166,
1.2173656225,
-0.7229120731,
0.3389968276,
0.7306357622,
0.1257558912,
1.1322647333,
-0.0372017585,
0.367744565,
-0.9605788589,
0.2583714128,
0.1534235626,
0.5357240438,
0.3053304553,
-0.0416432731,
0.3645300567,
0.2275212556,
-0.5973552465,
-0.6082378626,
0.2591393292,
-0.9690590501,
-0.4810410738,
1.0763401985,
0.178001523,
-0.0846782252,
-0.1802066714,
-0.1045728847,
0.3372993469,
-0.4193117917,
0.423681438,
0.3463636339,
-0.3434763253,
-0.2942682803,
-0.6933566332,
0.4220083356,
0.0232666265,
-0.4334688485,
-0.1019151509,
0.9581719041,
0.4339912236,
0.5287432671,
0.8224324584,
0.0247672535,
0.6016966701,
0.5163607001,
0.2912513316,
-0.1993027329,
-0.5746841431,
-0.3636793792,
0.5157405734,
-0.1284308434,
-0.1282542795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13155v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13155v2 | Advancing Radiograph Representation Learning with Masked Record Modeling | 2023-01-30T18:33:32 | 2023-02-15T07:33:35 | Hong-Yu Zhou, Chenyu Lian, Liansheng Wang, Yizhou Yu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Modern studies in radiograph representation learning rely on either
self-supervision to encode invariant semantics or associated radiology reports
to incorporate medical expertise, while the complementarity between them is
barely noticed. To explore this, we formulate the self- and report-completion
as two complementary objectives and present a unified framework based on masked
record modeling (MRM). In practice, MRM reconstructs masked image patches and
masked report tokens following a multi-task scheme to learn knowledge-enhanced
semantic representations. With MRM pre-training, we obtain pre-trained models
that can be well transferred to various radiography tasks. Specifically, we
find that MRM offers superior performance in label-efficient fine-tuning. For
instance, MRM achieves 88.5% mean AUC on CheXpert using 1% labeled data,
outperforming previous R$^2$L methods with 100% labels. On NIH ChestX-ray, MRM
outperforms the best performing counterpart by about 3% under small labeling
ratios. Besides, MRM surpasses self- and report-supervised pre-training in
identifying the pneumonia type and the pneumothorax area, sometimes by large
margins. | [
-0.1905095577,
0.0305236895,
0.5869389176,
-0.2076147348,
-0.3559701741,
0.1706126779,
0.1131301671,
-0.6268664598,
0.4536933601,
0.7892382145,
-0.4167709053,
-0.641561985,
-1.0827637911,
-0.0409311615,
0.041029606,
0.9154171348,
0.0715549216,
0.2561583221,
-0.3702537715,
-0.0686144382,
-0.6834762692,
-0.6738040447,
-0.3370230496,
-0.7407730818,
0.456884712,
0.3231021762,
0.6678593159,
0.9762481451,
0.4161490202,
0.1470710933,
0.526951611,
0.3404545188,
-0.2293282002,
-0.0686222389,
0.1235064194,
-0.0507856645,
-0.552713871,
0.3146885335,
0.4591827393,
0.8554137349,
0.1817826331,
-0.0748556554,
-0.19995749,
0.6010460854,
-0.8329315782,
0.3627683222,
-0.199140802,
0.3091113567,
-0.0245518088,
-0.5743881464,
-0.6339646578,
0.1252248585,
0.0171176344,
-0.6823616624,
0.1899055839,
-0.0196898989,
0.8342084289,
0.1337210685,
-0.5117608309,
-0.3291706443,
-0.643201232,
0.4216215014,
-0.2566969693,
0.6522517204,
0.7169469595,
0.3595466614,
0.1219422072,
-1.121008873,
0.1659914553,
-0.1663134843,
-0.5944111347,
0.436955899,
-0.0685276464,
0.3358314633,
0.1247426346,
0.4128004313,
-0.5811071992,
0.0639733374,
-0.4870374203,
-0.5329174399,
0.5669109225,
0.0780512094,
0.1147066876,
-0.2998243868,
-0.5700262785,
-0.2364581227,
-0.3291175067,
-0.3479136527,
-0.0633907914,
0.2859263122,
0.0681951493,
0.2457470596,
-0.4538219869,
0.7877348065,
-0.0418285988,
-0.2656564415,
0.5262811184,
0.1994748116,
-0.4408566952,
0.1715174317,
0.5844975114,
0.0540083013,
-0.1211165488,
-0.0878994316,
-0.2890359163,
-0.1336522996,
0.3926124573,
-0.4779126346,
-0.7536984086,
-0.0273811128,
-0.6990125775,
-0.1144074798,
0.4028299749,
-0.2725625336,
-0.4486783743,
-0.6590302587,
0.7835199833,
-0.4367755949,
-0.2812003493,
0.443600744,
0.0313891768,
-0.0700841621,
0.430595547,
-0.4173846543,
0.3622658551,
0.6040045619,
0.6475977302,
0.2412647754,
0.0311306659,
-0.7899729609,
0.3036735654,
-0.3975177109,
0.7113230824,
-0.4047190845,
-0.2264487892,
-0.2040976137,
-0.0108582033,
-0.2661754489,
-0.6195501089,
0.1620392501,
-0.5190807581,
0.3474738002,
0.1471718252,
-0.4098293185,
-0.4165320992,
0.2264467329,
-0.5639443398,
0.724331677,
0.2361297458,
-0.6096792817,
0.2787001729,
-0.2187633067,
-0.3770827055,
0.102530539,
-0.2646226883,
-0.5954559445,
-0.1424914151,
0.2925979495,
0.8252633214,
-0.030214835,
0.2118970454,
0.051013656,
-0.0567988828,
0.068526037,
0.05327316,
0.5505921245,
0.2721439302,
-0.0135698346,
0.0295824371,
-0.7173754573,
-0.0565179102,
0.0213556476,
0.1434483826,
-0.2015109062,
-0.4963440895,
-0.2699114978,
0.3796717525,
-0.0047901911,
-0.3070109785,
-0.1535382569,
0.1158454418,
0.1273544133,
0.4621630609,
0.1638301462,
0.0706294775,
-0.618298173,
0.6813864112,
0.1524727494,
0.1652607471,
-0.5234834552,
-0.3151931167,
-0.5435054898,
-0.8218140602,
0.6009907126,
0.3151619136,
-0.2755683959,
0.3112804592,
-0.0553622656,
-0.4080035686,
-0.4593052864,
-0.0290083401,
0.6829847097,
0.6847111583,
0.4788115621,
-0.9951457381,
-0.6994003057,
-0.9260756969,
0.0890555233,
-0.0140882125,
-0.1023752093,
0.2476176172,
0.2585600615,
-0.3423672318,
0.6759720445,
-0.7948806882,
-1.066360116,
-0.0199982245,
0.3603457212,
0.0731429309,
0.6291854978,
0.2346676439,
-0.6504029036,
-0.3387326896,
-0.0722150803,
-0.9141528606,
-0.0065358998,
-0.1762573421,
0.0644486025,
0.0245808233,
0.8779663444,
-0.1051215082,
0.4748435915,
0.3098662198,
0.049394045,
0.1548799276,
-0.5636698604,
0.1735197008,
-0.6976197958,
-0.1040666923,
-0.0845764205,
-0.7745597363,
-0.6002122164,
0.0246418081,
0.3861620128,
-0.3632728159,
-0.2916368842,
0.1344880313,
-1.1043413877,
-0.0635104328,
-0.1443567425,
-0.1821596473,
0.2928465307,
0.3986655772,
0.4007558823,
0.0927232206,
0.7379897833,
-0.3369627297,
0.0414548256,
-0.1258840859,
-0.0633371621,
0.1542858034,
-0.2927198112,
0.4583450854,
-0.4198353589,
0.317538619,
-0.7597486377,
-0.5183563828,
0.3379317224,
-0.4169363678,
1.163505435,
-0.4307567477,
-0.2602734864,
-0.3532397449,
-0.0127533441,
0.4697691202,
0.5116798282,
-0.3459275365,
0.8548741937,
0.4597173035,
0.2385221571,
-0.6197074652,
-0.6287550926,
-0.0134131443,
0.0414233431,
-0.3091819882,
0.4022521079,
0.2101101279,
0.2184369564,
0.059478078,
-0.2197635472,
-0.1649236381,
-0.2012903541,
0.4003333151,
0.1616276801,
-0.150645107,
0.2892571092,
-0.5159881711,
-0.5846999884,
0.0346096233,
-0.4110678732,
0.4469921887,
0.1251915246,
-0.421803683,
-0.3187625706,
0.2982825637,
0.2280396819,
-0.2443974465,
0.4067573547,
0.3874304891,
-0.6709591746,
0.038027823,
-0.7742239237,
-0.2216956764,
-0.3537452817,
0.3902862072,
-0.5213734508,
-0.8055169582,
0.5938789845,
0.1129863188,
-0.4798502624,
0.4450612962,
0.2963503599,
-0.2303902954,
0.7251828313,
0.5710181594,
0.0662426874,
0.1231160983,
-0.2749150395,
-0.1609457284,
-0.874007225,
-0.5434353352,
-0.3056136072,
0.1614899784,
-0.3818619847,
-0.5865392685,
0.5672974586,
-0.0076675359,
0.0232080072,
0.1105174869,
-0.8420192599,
0.4473621249,
0.4045354128,
0.712569654,
0.4236496389,
-0.1681738794,
0.2520827651,
-0.1707783192,
-0.9246058464,
-0.2528959811,
1.3427968025,
0.5942922235,
0.6332159042,
-0.3725001216,
1.1321361065,
0.4491298795,
0.3025229573,
-0.6043049693,
0.2236523628,
-0.2780554891,
-0.5404782295,
0.0258704815,
-0.2202984393,
-0.912119329,
0.25123927,
-0.3224973679,
-0.1526918411,
0.1738412231,
0.2835088074,
-0.2929108441,
0.1189082265,
-0.5718401074,
0.7518705726,
-0.0572964661,
-0.1351014972,
-0.1049555838,
-0.9392268062,
0.4573077559,
-0.0529436655,
0.4916700423,
-0.316544801,
0.0552627072,
0.6879709363,
-0.390991509,
1.0368857384,
-0.1621872187,
0.2486274093,
0.1568118632,
0.0761012062,
0.0114588058,
0.0073255314,
0.2319605201,
0.3033502102,
-0.0807544515,
-0.3848773241,
-0.5357311964,
0.2787022591,
-0.8283528686,
-0.5467175245,
-0.8395332098,
-0.5193986297,
-0.0487868749,
0.3177497089,
0.3895130455,
0.8829231262,
-0.081171222,
-0.0541098565,
0.8999388814,
-0.0428401902,
-0.208580181,
0.3617286682,
-0.217761144,
-0.4905703664,
0.870903492,
0.4860935211,
0.3925128877,
0.5931946039,
0.1315990686,
-0.111646831,
-0.4710977077,
-0.1597416401,
0.4603205025,
-1.1346173286,
-0.5943265557,
-0.9738114476,
-0.5760655999,
-0.5784649253,
-0.0495058037,
-0.4138995409,
-0.3996664882,
-0.4520600438,
0.04933732,
0.2294807136,
0.8210118413,
-0.6592273116,
0.1236053258,
-0.5661130548,
0.3032318354,
0.5919724107,
0.2733516097,
-0.1435605437,
-0.6774644852,
-0.3603290021,
-0.4121525884,
-0.1403956264,
-0.7502081394,
0.3659158945,
0.0391700268,
0.43425107,
0.2356753796,
0.3098506629,
0.5966342688,
-0.1755223125,
0.2750635147,
0.3162067235,
-0.7290908694,
0.546269536,
-0.4109446108,
0.1404241472,
0.4227423668,
0.352620393,
-0.3522887826,
-0.3703456819,
-0.8047201037,
-0.6411563754,
0.7674728632,
-0.1133782491,
-0.0473581664,
0.000191642,
0.3839973509,
0.0478364043,
-0.0970845819,
-0.6668942571,
-0.3201447725,
-0.4940386117,
-0.1357848644,
-0.1128177866,
-0.294172436,
-0.2949071527,
-0.3038415909,
0.6280930042,
-0.3255407214,
0.5014745593,
0.5993543863,
-0.3260388672,
0.0397215076,
-0.0873471498,
0.6168624759,
0.7490748763,
-0.5333801508,
0.6593692303,
-0.0752825662,
-0.3624098003,
-0.0084775491,
0.0326323956,
0.1962826848,
0.0200647153,
0.7188138366,
0.7163158059,
0.1102570742,
-0.2663699389,
0.5909165144,
0.0073341099,
-0.4170943201,
-0.3884149492,
0.0750272721,
0.0712404102,
-0.0591031015,
0.5208476186,
0.131245032,
0.2005868405,
-0.4876129925,
0.4846408665,
0.281434685,
-0.8098444939,
0.0989237353,
0.6476711631,
-0.31583184,
0.0186876245,
0.4810691178,
-0.0057879994,
-0.5184820294,
0.66177845,
0.5639298558,
0.5827189684,
-0.2354136407,
0.3145979941,
0.4998803735,
0.4192130864,
-0.0634140149,
-0.3357854486,
0.0007571187,
-0.4943030477,
-0.3570998609,
-0.0255890526,
-0.4555737972,
0.1346940696,
-1.0706034899,
0.3200093508,
-0.6408090591,
0.1205792576,
-0.1321670711,
-0.0724598989,
-0.6803448796,
0.8310263157,
0.2022501081,
0.6865257621,
-0.8318770528,
0.8156715631,
0.5254771709,
-0.4712629914,
-1.0021383762,
-0.2055005729,
0.0654973909,
-1.019276619,
0.5765244365,
0.5187639594,
-0.0089076431,
0.0202841479,
-0.1731253117,
-0.7365976572,
1.1612365246,
0.2613762617,
-0.2714857757,
0.2888665795,
0.1154443324,
0.3023238182,
-0.8771737218,
0.4218500853,
0.345387131,
-0.0210800916,
0.3308124542,
-0.8610910773,
0.1421045661,
0.0672591701,
-0.1375851184,
0.0682046413,
-0.5464337468,
0.5864688754,
-0.1460884959,
-0.2251381129,
-0.4546154439,
0.7062212825,
0.0536612459,
0.4777888358,
0.4137589037,
0.5225639939,
0.8351246715,
0.0503776148,
1.120595336,
-0.0030655696,
0.1896282136,
1.1871165037,
-0.0398360789,
0.3321576416,
0.0975866765,
0.1598602831,
0.5988366604,
0.7403020859,
0.1489330083,
0.5766377449,
-0.1027789786,
-0.1579116285,
-0.7230213284,
-0.0799344257,
-0.5785502195,
0.4467380941,
0.229926765,
-0.4968770444,
-0.1245928332,
0.2734434605,
-0.0012996178,
0.0428661332,
-0.4150620997,
0.9697243571,
0.2567255199,
-0.3795241416,
0.7074576616,
-0.0775698051,
0.3241608739,
-0.6950423717,
0.0066492301,
-0.0990541801,
0.0332311653,
-0.4376916885,
-0.4379490912,
0.5240148306,
-0.6825801134,
-0.4769981503,
-0.3657327592,
1.0826787949,
-0.5222360492,
-0.3460738957,
0.4085784256,
0.2824498415,
0.2990362346,
0.0657408386,
-0.3692260385,
0.1208576635,
0.08240439,
0.0520922057,
0.6474869847,
0.2547475398,
0.0001435353,
0.5546852946,
0.4205252528,
0.0294841081,
-0.1205293909,
-0.0561410226,
0.9076688886,
-0.3612088561,
-0.4709933996,
-0.3256689906,
0.6051855087,
0.0365593061,
-0.0112793483,
0.3370738924,
0.5677397847,
1.0317651033,
-0.1248004809,
0.5446444154,
0.2840999365,
0.6405160427,
-0.8133411407,
0.7499880791,
-0.3811060786,
0.0742995217,
-0.2506004572,
-0.4619370103,
-0.8151127696,
0.7900355458,
-0.1742836535,
0.0327192992,
0.6822490692,
0.8846634626,
-0.2849627435,
-0.295185715,
0.507212162,
-0.214248389,
0.0708750412,
0.5613954067,
0.5642492771,
-0.676073432,
0.3020270169,
-0.5500358343,
-0.4330273271,
-0.0230640359,
-0.9619498253,
-0.9619961381,
-0.6235793829,
-0.9137426019,
-0.4458815753,
-0.004709878,
0.8825579286,
1.2865593433,
-0.4515938461,
0.0588523634,
0.4129578173,
-0.0529977977,
-0.0781133771,
-0.1702287048,
0.6889262199,
-0.3942704499,
-0.1728923023,
0.3581990302,
0.434731096,
-0.0608018488,
-0.0445008911,
-0.1909444928,
0.0705058873,
-0.3028676212,
0.3963955641,
0.3452141881,
-0.3522049785,
-0.3222822249,
-0.2137431353,
-0.3352938294,
0.5532158613,
1.0628188848,
-1.0225510597,
0.9769381881,
0.0578340888,
0.3955779076,
0.9352679849,
-0.1340224892,
0.2672428489,
-0.91539675,
0.28282547,
0.3562654555,
0.1307238489,
0.384996444,
-0.533562541,
0.5634761453,
0.2893984318,
-0.4579808414,
-0.8874774575,
0.199195534,
-0.8790435195,
-0.3781940937,
0.6337059736,
-0.2989881635,
0.0650098249,
-0.397657901,
0.0518092066,
0.4994393289,
-0.0313416198,
0.5369290709,
0.170491159,
-0.4592085779,
-0.721463263,
-0.3760769665,
0.3789592385,
0.3349968791,
-0.4725192189,
-0.2288762033,
0.6138262153,
0.4972590208,
0.2526909113,
1.302421689,
-0.4162420034,
0.4350996315,
-0.21039325,
0.2302878499,
-0.7494769692,
-0.6001252532,
-0.4670163989,
0.4506706595,
0.1496928483,
-0.3239185512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13154v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13154v2 | Protein Representation Learning via Knowledge Enhanced Primary Structure Modeling | 2023-01-30T18:33:15 | 2023-02-15T07:26:47 | Hong-Yu Zhou, Yunxiang Fu, Zhicheng Zhang, Cheng Bian, Yizhou Yu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.MM | Protein representation learning has primarily benefited from the remarkable
development of language models (LMs). Accordingly, pre-trained protein models
also suffer from a problem in LMs: a lack of factual knowledge. The recent
solution models the relationships between protein and associated knowledge
terms as the knowledge encoding objective. However, it fails to explore the
relationships at a more granular level, i.e., the token level. To mitigate
this, we propose Knowledge-exploited Auto-encoder for Protein (KeAP), which
performs token-level knowledge graph exploration for protein representation
learning. In practice, non-masked amino acids iteratively query the associated
knowledge tokens to extract and integrate helpful information for restoring
masked amino acids via attention. We show that KeAP can consistently outperform
the previous counterpart on 9 representative downstream applications, sometimes
surpassing it by large margins. These results suggest that KeAP provides an
alternative yet effective way to perform knowledge enhanced protein
representation learning. | [
-0.0663509369,
-0.4380356967,
0.4402876198,
-0.1821364462,
-0.2417864949,
0.3063969612,
0.2705512643,
-0.5374558568,
0.5728667974,
0.4391826987,
0.024863366,
-0.5537692308,
-1.0057044029,
0.0151489107,
-0.151317656,
0.5350579619,
0.2450557053,
-0.0029751351,
-0.37357077,
-0.152911216,
-0.3910989761,
-0.6184145212,
-0.5262156725,
-0.4796974063,
0.5617163777,
0.3113688827,
0.2383252531,
0.6851992011,
0.5153687,
0.2400130481,
0.0062095029,
0.3402173817,
-0.3634120524,
-0.0518401302,
-0.2116887718,
-0.5923261046,
-0.6675696373,
-0.0468091518,
0.7016054392,
1.196644187,
0.2920179963,
0.1804519147,
0.2497381866,
1.0570642948,
-0.9538579583,
0.4951075613,
-0.7989298701,
0.3656997085,
-0.108353883,
-0.2171127498,
-0.5780507922,
0.2756825387,
0.2519723475,
-0.6117425561,
-0.0085085733,
0.1239726022,
0.8116216063,
0.3358166516,
-0.8192859888,
-0.2213096619,
-0.2740748823,
0.4197645485,
-0.5530764461,
0.5003790855,
0.6563083529,
0.2793557346,
-0.4273709655,
-0.7815659046,
-0.3243059814,
-0.3787935972,
-0.3748396337,
0.1584389508,
-0.0620433614,
0.2835375667,
0.2853808403,
0.4673416317,
-0.3467164934,
-0.1823182404,
-0.523758471,
-0.4798135757,
0.4564631879,
-0.2848852277,
0.2684253752,
-0.4071013927,
-0.3430666029,
-0.2293968946,
-0.6230676174,
0.1947620362,
0.2649103701,
0.2550643682,
0.2081208527,
0.7726717591,
-0.1073424667,
0.671926856,
0.2398029417,
0.2765890956,
0.4510464966,
0.1115942746,
-0.4702803195,
0.1004624814,
0.4741183221,
0.0378843658,
-0.2682164609,
-0.2376094759,
-0.0026817271,
-0.2937458456,
0.3533568084,
-0.5830328465,
-0.6018854976,
0.457039237,
-0.5726153255,
-0.1268265694,
0.1225099713,
-0.6870441437,
-0.3613996506,
-0.0927327648,
0.7943556905,
-0.4893536568,
-0.3004208207,
0.045849625,
-0.5585656762,
0.3660674691,
-0.0500230007,
-0.7512494922,
0.1624844372,
0.2808300257,
0.7254080772,
-0.1292329133,
0.0019851332,
-0.5743665695,
0.6822528839,
-0.3235001564,
0.6047079563,
-0.7500521541,
-0.1714749336,
-0.4545463622,
0.0380372293,
-0.1226881817,
-0.53106004,
0.0900840089,
-0.7083054185,
-0.2173674554,
-0.5198861361,
-0.9839447141,
-0.3961196542,
0.0820565298,
-0.7069362402,
0.6611778736,
0.1460067481,
-0.7971648574,
0.4736136794,
-0.8097515702,
-0.2519514561,
0.1828149706,
-0.298291862,
-0.1200057119,
0.1718037874,
0.4985873997,
0.2828047872,
0.4460403621,
0.0832801312,
-0.3824215829,
-0.0324792787,
0.0243639834,
0.2497560829,
0.5095619559,
0.0819256082,
-0.2169786096,
0.0115067055,
-0.7893974781,
0.002013884,
0.1943550706,
-0.2729043961,
-0.4351788163,
-0.1704964638,
-0.6867849827,
0.0211013425,
0.2422015965,
-0.5189589858,
0.3949151635,
-0.4431380928,
0.4408096075,
0.9250066876,
0.2487411499,
0.7169696093,
0.1065398306,
0.1560868025,
0.2843106389,
-0.1023612097,
-0.0219740402,
-0.6256232262,
-0.8666152358,
-0.1978652328,
0.451351881,
-0.0170779005,
-0.5157583952,
0.5484900475,
-0.0552306399,
-0.2959637046,
-0.5723013282,
0.2064391971,
0.0990988016,
0.6254541278,
0.7286698222,
-0.5129776597,
-0.5280492306,
-0.9255763888,
-0.3492134511,
-0.169395268,
-0.1151197851,
0.3868631124,
0.5770041943,
-0.2552356124,
0.7478064299,
-0.3179109693,
-0.5626234412,
-0.2987050116,
0.1306154728,
0.3078194261,
0.7165790796,
0.3514661193,
-0.6661477685,
-0.4519670606,
0.0493577309,
-0.7174695134,
0.1794864386,
-0.0480854101,
-0.3589247465,
-0.2384856492,
0.5041947365,
-0.504686296,
0.348862946,
0.4859086573,
-0.3999715149,
0.3736002147,
-0.1594089717,
-0.0628095567,
-0.827178359,
0.5198948979,
-0.2740170062,
-0.3114622533,
-0.4343934953,
0.1426640898,
0.1707428992,
-0.4144521952,
-0.0021499761,
0.4746160507,
-0.6722188592,
-0.4162244201,
-0.4009691179,
-0.2032764405,
0.2655424774,
0.787040174,
0.1617031842,
0.4026828408,
0.5666211843,
-0.5792099237,
-0.0792922527,
0.3080464303,
-0.0556836538,
-0.0094451411,
-0.7122362852,
0.54602319,
-0.2928147316,
0.2262512147,
-0.8609087467,
-0.5621951818,
0.5864483118,
-0.6175884008,
0.6566126347,
-0.4249756932,
-0.217353493,
-0.3359077275,
-0.2804102004,
0.3791331351,
0.2915927172,
-0.5508280396,
0.7894180417,
0.7941814661,
0.2250804305,
-0.753393352,
-0.5684966445,
0.0081231268,
0.0720163211,
-0.1853552312,
0.5615380406,
0.223935619,
0.349976331,
0.1928771287,
-0.6286502481,
-0.0391223952,
-0.1791806668,
0.15860717,
-0.198650226,
-0.0093054017,
0.390535295,
0.1831490546,
-0.1577475518,
-0.0406778492,
-0.6527502537,
0.5872371793,
-0.036992684,
-0.4626582563,
-0.409537226,
0.452227354,
0.3735319078,
-0.3918245435,
0.6613108516,
0.4015820622,
-0.538807869,
-0.037732739,
-0.3660756946,
-0.3018359244,
-0.4855512679,
0.5454924107,
-0.3611930609,
-0.4817948639,
0.4650883973,
-0.1198819503,
-0.0518182963,
0.562458694,
-0.0945978537,
-0.3566149473,
1.0315358639,
0.9510229826,
-0.070929572,
0.29613024,
-0.436848253,
0.0652982742,
-0.9634942412,
-0.5448642969,
-0.3080255985,
-0.6908959746,
-0.1480285376,
-0.3971447945,
0.5567312241,
0.54315418,
-0.1668023169,
0.4906481504,
-0.5002794266,
0.4418649673,
0.596980691,
0.4891140163,
0.197945863,
0.4713700712,
-0.3312189877,
0.0773894563,
-1.1306530237,
-0.2230814546,
1.3262959719,
0.5716134906,
0.3470190167,
-0.261288166,
0.7348241806,
0.3923793435,
0.108580634,
-0.7347460985,
0.3062658906,
-0.0193604082,
-0.4319582582,
-0.2228908688,
-0.5284667015,
-0.672373414,
0.0120834792,
-0.0000062209,
-0.6843118072,
0.7072057724,
0.3906828165,
-0.1741608232,
0.2802774608,
-0.8289325237,
0.8105312586,
0.1030763164,
-0.0905338153,
-0.2281465083,
-0.7087180018,
0.0275843497,
0.047792621,
0.0819243193,
0.1613070667,
-0.0323341489,
0.8676475883,
-0.5022238493,
1.0218884945,
-0.3804182112,
0.0423438437,
0.1799788624,
0.0402426459,
0.5974860191,
-0.0259738564,
0.0780809,
0.0333156921,
-0.1982817054,
-0.8126809001,
-0.8088672161,
0.2352789938,
-0.7320181131,
-0.7145850062,
-0.2253848016,
-0.2757783532,
-0.4035023749,
0.1902551055,
0.1745092869,
0.2458658367,
0.5000454187,
0.2309500128,
0.5019332767,
-0.2702175677,
0.1494183391,
0.1991645694,
-0.1481018066,
-0.600243926,
0.8672350049,
0.2985768616,
0.2115121484,
0.4916501939,
0.1458026171,
-0.1993362308,
-0.6451202035,
-0.0652650818,
0.0697478056,
-0.842556119,
-0.4034430981,
-1.1108372211,
-0.2863454819,
-0.5413624048,
-0.0119392537,
-0.4315502346,
-0.5096904635,
0.1407369077,
-0.3699030578,
0.0367981084,
0.4431705773,
-0.449549228,
0.0413657762,
-0.7610390782,
0.3691853583,
0.4031135738,
0.281796962,
0.2094853222,
-0.4553754628,
-0.3086521626,
-0.0438667871,
-0.1764789671,
-1.2643903494,
0.3540730178,
0.4953905046,
0.9639038444,
0.372141242,
-0.0632897243,
0.6225717664,
-0.078087762,
0.5352545977,
-0.0288048629,
-0.7997335792,
0.8544501662,
0.0412212983,
0.4160787761,
0.4579903185,
0.6456261277,
-0.1940758377,
-0.4671070874,
-0.4626087844,
-0.9892755747,
0.4677194059,
0.3292239308,
0.1544212401,
-0.1916046888,
0.4651614428,
0.3678423762,
0.2411270291,
-0.9865812063,
-0.1385092437,
-0.3416060805,
-0.0963046029,
0.3874283433,
-0.3962180614,
0.0311070289,
-0.5296543241,
0.7670263052,
-0.3844164014,
0.6927192211,
0.6304810047,
-0.5779703856,
-0.0647964776,
-0.1491923034,
-0.1594868004,
0.4156500101,
-0.4715656042,
0.4128673375,
-0.0330783837,
-0.6489600539,
-0.3030292392,
-0.0249813758,
-0.0086777136,
-0.1359615922,
0.6695576906,
0.5434163809,
0.0739070028,
-0.4526211619,
0.3795410395,
0.3998756111,
-0.0428379253,
0.1503320485,
-0.0160142444,
-0.0551980771,
0.2939680815,
0.8466044068,
0.1078775078,
0.258302331,
-0.680311203,
0.5092522502,
0.3169009686,
-0.4060638547,
-0.2439320385,
0.3971557617,
0.2591346204,
0.2234037519,
0.595523417,
-0.1383054107,
-0.5537964702,
0.7240685225,
0.6044583321,
0.6391739249,
-0.0684969798,
0.2846673429,
0.6124923229,
0.3240498006,
0.5594596267,
0.0626541749,
-0.4694640636,
-0.7812883854,
-0.2815508842,
-0.844156146,
0.0161117855,
0.3158338964,
-0.5066821575,
0.041941341,
-0.3751529455,
-0.1590142101,
0.0311277024,
0.1221032217,
-0.7116705179,
-0.1973554343,
0.1432302594,
1.1024245024,
-0.5809555054,
0.88005054,
0.8233960867,
-0.5775372386,
-0.5844878554,
-0.0493478999,
-0.5013503432,
-0.7312366366,
0.9453041553,
0.4586568177,
0.18319121,
0.3230612576,
-0.6385779977,
-0.8981567621,
0.9876076579,
0.4115836918,
-0.6238859892,
-0.3421199322,
0.3192861974,
0.2828308344,
-0.5172632933,
0.0120500335,
0.2436483651,
0.3979815245,
0.0343539268,
-0.3924008012,
0.0005474612,
-0.3124293983,
-0.3900744319,
-0.1162127927,
-0.5043573976,
0.3188943863,
-0.2020099908,
-0.4209878445,
-0.492592454,
0.8759309053,
0.1559549719,
0.156416446,
0.3710112274,
0.3727452457,
0.9955420494,
0.382425338,
0.885779798,
-0.2171455324,
0.1331320256,
1.074236989,
-0.078704536,
0.6446466446,
0.6044979095,
-0.074187912,
0.4578990638,
0.5126240849,
-0.0606141128,
0.7540228367,
-0.0435775332,
0.1227689981,
-0.4405573606,
-0.0581151433,
-0.5614660978,
0.525233984,
0.5833675265,
-0.6523287296,
-0.2185947597,
0.0538976267,
-0.5658494234,
-0.1469590515,
-0.6229764819,
0.8943401575,
0.3078693748,
-0.0321888886,
0.4018149972,
-0.2243721187,
0.1178681999,
-0.623190701,
-0.3233497143,
-0.2814502418,
-0.2427870333,
-0.0877418146,
-0.4051571488,
0.3674974144,
-0.3759237528,
-0.1119685695,
0.1605254561,
1.2472236156,
-0.390930891,
-0.3692489266,
0.4758551121,
0.4253860712,
0.0309551153,
-0.2244652063,
-0.5927858353,
-0.2209932208,
-0.2140689939,
-0.2149028182,
0.264401257,
0.2241480201,
0.3191615045,
0.6935888529,
0.5405654311,
-0.1548442692,
0.064497605,
-0.2286569327,
0.9988238811,
-0.7196604609,
-0.4869164526,
-0.6456190944,
0.5110408664,
-0.4717520475,
0.1852064729,
0.5108304024,
0.4221838117,
0.772159636,
-0.3350204229,
0.6227733493,
-0.0158166401,
0.0348680802,
-0.6045863032,
0.9921401143,
-0.3645147681,
-0.0280767735,
-0.0805437043,
-0.8583672047,
-0.3196360171,
0.5000786781,
-0.174036786,
-0.1528580934,
0.6475448012,
0.6265488863,
-0.1525719166,
-0.1227460802,
0.4004113674,
0.4447161555,
0.2027759552,
0.6454126835,
0.5576745868,
-0.5436910987,
0.2762554586,
-0.222891435,
-0.3557180762,
-0.1463187337,
-0.870131731,
-1.0647668839,
-0.5867646337,
-0.3474955261,
-0.1189255193,
0.3334242105,
1.1050797701,
0.9253274202,
-0.9219588637,
0.1717227697,
-0.3252244592,
-0.0420566052,
-0.2241962254,
-0.1800791919,
0.7221306562,
-0.7632480264,
-0.4105413854,
0.8024852872,
0.3323387206,
0.1540692598,
0.0311487,
0.1165464744,
-0.2174929678,
-0.0401329957,
0.6270608306,
0.4306278825,
-0.236795634,
-0.4750814438,
-0.0525151603,
0.0720182359,
0.2127476633,
0.8329467773,
-1.0283623934,
0.524584949,
0.4416268468,
0.8876699805,
0.5160326362,
-0.3181994557,
1.0580359697,
-1.0535340309,
0.0288512614,
0.0805759281,
0.386159718,
0.188070938,
-0.615090549,
0.4037162364,
0.3751106262,
-0.1677638739,
-0.6753783226,
0.3287703097,
-0.835698843,
-0.3228903413,
0.8208295107,
-0.1253108829,
-0.3853205442,
-0.0680178851,
-0.0220438968,
0.4956796169,
-0.2953467667,
1.0762174129,
0.6133365035,
-0.0135114901,
-0.0844323486,
-0.4319187999,
0.8103013039,
0.3927263319,
-0.5411199331,
0.0851618722,
0.1023107171,
0.1601370275,
0.1468937844,
0.6111645103,
-0.454397589,
0.0737573877,
0.1275293231,
-0.1076974347,
-0.461448878,
-0.5836430788,
-0.1068122759,
0.4232320786,
-0.0013388164,
-0.1302866191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13126v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13126v3 | LEXTREME: A Multi-Lingual and Multi-Task Benchmark for the Legal Domain | 2023-01-30T18:05:08 | 2024-01-08T10:08:40 | Joel Niklaus, Veton Matoshi, Pooja Rani, Andrea Galassi, Matthias Stürmer, Ilias Chalkidis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2 | Lately, propelled by the phenomenal advances around the transformer
architecture, the legal NLP field has enjoyed spectacular growth. To measure
progress, well curated and challenging benchmarks are crucial. However, most
benchmarks are English only and in legal NLP specifically there is no
multilingual benchmark available yet. Additionally, many benchmarks are
saturated, with the best models clearly outperforming the best humans and
achieving near perfect scores. We survey the legal NLP literature and select 11
datasets covering 24 languages, creating LEXTREME. To provide a fair
comparison, we propose two aggregate scores, one based on the datasets and one
on the languages. The best baseline (XLM-R large) achieves both a dataset
aggregate score a language aggregate score of 61.3. This indicates that
LEXTREME is still very challenging and leaves ample room for improvement. To
make it easy for researchers and practitioners to use, we release LEXTREME on
huggingface together with all the code required to evaluate models and a public
Weights and Biases project with all the runs. | [
-0.2181546241,
-0.1321070045,
0.4908997118,
0.6376199126,
-0.2652541995,
0.0810989514,
-0.3746123612,
-0.5621654987,
0.0753292665,
0.4660598934,
-0.2281405181,
-0.8935844302,
-0.7393767238,
0.1291899085,
-0.3368031383,
0.8271617293,
0.0471571721,
0.2932015061,
-0.2644782662,
-1.0227062702,
-0.4162678421,
-0.5870761275,
-0.7025003433,
-0.1543480456,
0.2947700322,
-0.1337874383,
0.6476861238,
0.641677022,
0.528441906,
0.3191148639,
-0.2256613523,
-0.014232629,
-0.0691727847,
0.2602728009,
-0.3528748453,
-0.5278814435,
-0.4504865706,
-0.0049710176,
0.7273247242,
0.6093934774,
-0.4143012166,
0.2119355053,
-0.2441011965,
0.6699022055,
-0.7626469135,
-0.000454396,
-0.4306623638,
0.1060020402,
-0.2790196538,
0.1094642654,
-0.4012708962,
-0.28786695,
-0.5281570554,
-0.384164989,
0.045914501,
0.2510333657,
0.7010027766,
0.3976990581,
-0.5370076299,
0.013378961,
-0.3040103018,
0.6320295334,
-0.624019742,
0.6994050741,
-0.1420455873,
0.4059092104,
0.2594605684,
-0.945808351,
-0.1536162496,
-0.4932577312,
0.1022854,
0.2466401458,
-0.5275651813,
-0.2753047049,
0.384480387,
0.0902555734,
-0.7103593349,
0.2640449405,
0.1733887345,
-0.2993773222,
0.6648049355,
0.2327299714,
0.4532471895,
0.0235032421,
-0.5622706413,
-0.4344343841,
-0.6850025654,
0.135653466,
0.3135394752,
0.3904984295,
-0.0352061316,
0.4114549458,
0.195008561,
0.4054307938,
-0.4955694973,
0.187338382,
0.4734868705,
-0.4480133057,
-0.1202394813,
0.0098727951,
1.1677424908,
0.4293116629,
-0.016631024,
-0.3939784467,
-0.4318073988,
-0.0623199679,
0.3273235857,
-0.7815440893,
0.3196958303,
0.1912023425,
-0.4069670141,
0.2198531777,
0.2546862066,
-0.9400715828,
-0.4798759818,
-0.361584723,
-0.0631672591,
-0.4050604999,
-0.2495813519,
0.2265533954,
-0.1104926914,
0.2542876303,
0.0462590568,
-0.4130351841,
0.8172181249,
0.9736372232,
0.8431922197,
-0.3505081832,
-0.316052705,
-0.9957255125,
-0.2374609709,
-0.5036013126,
0.7583510876,
-0.6091511846,
-0.351847589,
0.1677297652,
0.2590608001,
-0.3255901039,
-0.8497180343,
1.211804986,
-0.3989206553,
-0.1409584731,
-0.362873435,
-0.762550056,
-0.0824434683,
0.3561322093,
-0.7281261086,
1.2225594521,
0.1732688248,
-0.4983325005,
0.7404673696,
-0.640802145,
-0.4614825845,
0.5435631871,
-0.1903637052,
-0.4956639111,
0.2552007437,
0.1842855662,
0.3132395744,
-0.329915911,
0.4712089896,
-0.0992255583,
-0.2499076426,
-0.0915711746,
-0.022026848,
0.982668817,
0.1783077419,
-0.5338138342,
0.2513005733,
-0.6941088438,
0.1544271857,
0.1081019342,
-0.2156147361,
-0.381272763,
-0.129510805,
0.5087230206,
0.4665475786,
0.1325432658,
-0.7999277711,
-0.052697584,
-0.2583633065,
0.415749073,
0.2931635976,
-0.3156405091,
0.1775548458,
-0.3365009427,
0.9053158164,
-0.3055832088,
-0.0524536744,
0.0434620753,
-0.4802669287,
-0.3833587766,
-0.149618119,
0.4896408021,
0.6473150253,
-0.1820199937,
0.2600060701,
-0.5034480691,
-0.6406938434,
-0.7832888961,
0.3071480095,
0.4383612871,
-0.0985973999,
0.6485646367,
-0.1446213275,
-0.2921017706,
-0.9808364511,
-0.7643478513,
-0.0340844728,
0.091388166,
0.4912711382,
0.4820067883,
-0.2420188338,
0.4883025289,
0.0449363701,
-0.3939688802,
-0.4030760527,
0.2709155083,
0.2531220019,
0.157426089,
0.9208415747,
-0.8658917546,
-0.7121396065,
0.0721931905,
-0.6305791736,
-0.2866600752,
-0.095029518,
0.1494819522,
-0.0209687036,
0.7028019428,
-0.5535808206,
-0.1235090941,
0.3940790296,
-0.5786614418,
0.6883425117,
-0.2108783871,
0.2866615653,
-1.0095504522,
0.297634691,
0.3615801036,
-0.625394702,
-0.427569896,
0.4944872856,
0.498195231,
-0.0876211375,
-0.7860725522,
0.7182913423,
-0.2490178049,
-0.2252887338,
-0.110070318,
0.1615011245,
0.0245063752,
0.2675530612,
-0.1092676744,
1.042460084,
0.6030923724,
-0.3561600447,
0.4447429478,
0.2510245442,
-0.475549221,
0.7023937106,
-0.8263648152,
-0.1052858308,
0.0325025022,
-0.1532024741,
-0.5844438672,
0.1554301977,
-0.259860605,
-0.0136965346,
0.362116307,
-0.1057559475,
-0.6955648661,
-0.2795360386,
-0.2808140516,
0.3502153754,
0.3217354417,
-0.4243526757,
0.8641657829,
0.6005583405,
-0.2051191032,
-0.7209116817,
-0.4349412918,
0.6737419963,
-0.4341651797,
-0.5354907513,
0.7949003577,
0.0644710064,
-0.6012895107,
0.0518271625,
-0.0677463412,
0.0879712477,
-0.0414862521,
0.3052419722,
-0.0955644101,
-0.3674713969,
0.0307133961,
-0.097382538,
-0.2402217835,
0.4632319808,
0.0397685766,
0.4056539834,
-0.5837883353,
-0.3884913623,
-0.2860394418,
0.2547800243,
0.7399660349,
-0.316647172,
0.4550456405,
0.5927540064,
-0.2094282359,
-0.3487929404,
-0.6763576865,
0.25599581,
-0.3418262601,
0.37890172,
-0.5109840631,
-0.9311552644,
0.489903152,
-0.3774010241,
0.3428727388,
0.7877110243,
0.6520678401,
0.3549481928,
0.8636133671,
0.6120489836,
-0.334751904,
-0.0028996584,
0.1832613051,
0.0246517044,
-0.4125667214,
-0.2300262451,
-0.8162132502,
-0.092392154,
-0.5547584891,
-0.3175446987,
0.2723531723,
-0.108179681,
0.0950986892,
1.0381212234,
-0.4444051385,
0.4733362496,
0.6824068427,
-0.1987410933,
0.1850896776,
-0.4152917564,
-0.531270206,
-0.2448139191,
-0.6541452408,
-0.5345215201,
0.949029088,
0.2428237647,
0.2896413505,
0.2422457635,
0.5407443643,
0.4338606298,
0.1380925477,
-0.7071030736,
0.7636008263,
-0.5336693525,
-0.4834180176,
-0.0560961626,
-0.4528044462,
-0.9901965261,
0.2714820802,
-0.196579352,
-0.4015957415,
0.0456919558,
-0.2759988904,
-0.4882677495,
0.2000517249,
-0.3337472379,
1.1458313465,
-0.3628872335,
-0.8154301643,
-0.2926363647,
-0.6746667624,
0.1436922401,
-0.0784825981,
0.5003064871,
-0.6487526298,
-0.2525810301,
0.9251885414,
-0.6093754172,
0.4447122514,
-0.3272723258,
-0.0259719677,
0.1982500553,
0.0706249028,
0.3423738182,
0.1392126828,
-0.1156699359,
0.1942888647,
0.3933210075,
-0.2776234448,
-0.2780229747,
0.6337428093,
-0.4010569453,
-0.3638047874,
-0.4283776283,
-0.3598163128,
-0.4043225646,
0.2521699369,
0.0079461047,
0.2567227781,
-0.4657236636,
0.3234321773,
0.2644032836,
-0.3480650187,
0.5871537328,
0.753526628,
-0.0099938158,
-0.2103676647,
0.7704482675,
-0.2631910145,
-0.393519789,
0.3730218112,
0.2158178985,
-0.8322647214,
-0.4132801592,
-0.3852216601,
0.292830199,
-0.730158627,
-0.1576102972,
-0.6532722712,
-0.1947569698,
-0.3199624419,
0.0629958063,
-0.6605109572,
-0.215762496,
0.4480193555,
0.0510406233,
-0.0488256738,
0.5258044004,
-0.0806382895,
-0.1418893486,
-0.9382002354,
0.3080455661,
0.3075793982,
0.46375072,
-0.6063959002,
-0.5429106355,
-0.0503464192,
-0.2297109812,
-0.0514387712,
-0.3168171644,
0.3686320484,
0.2944547236,
0.8012201786,
0.2744363248,
-0.0994807258,
0.3740382791,
-0.7989832163,
0.6749562621,
0.2301479727,
-0.9544246197,
0.4126701653,
-0.0947706029,
0.1225559637,
0.9269232154,
0.3779107332,
-0.6676540971,
-0.4664850831,
-0.5087679029,
-0.7655377984,
0.4285942316,
0.2013135254,
0.486766398,
0.0573897325,
0.2455985695,
0.2276477963,
0.1535106301,
-0.796484828,
-0.1219667867,
-0.0728311762,
0.0228844471,
-0.0711587444,
-0.1805240512,
-0.1751033664,
-0.2004138082,
0.5761893988,
-0.0628983006,
-0.1390242428,
-0.2603539824,
-0.2192478925,
0.2660459578,
0.4943580329,
0.58705616,
0.7572591901,
-0.0821884573,
0.1651097536,
0.0430475846,
-0.4297245443,
0.2009336948,
0.3611103296,
0.0795777515,
0.3729605973,
0.5242378712,
0.7403010726,
0.3496844769,
-1.202660799,
0.8883307576,
-0.1337303072,
-0.6349542737,
-0.1504290402,
0.1006340906,
0.1155738309,
0.2754264176,
0.3021391034,
0.0466763377,
0.0998611972,
-0.267088294,
0.5270401835,
0.3567520678,
-0.546072185,
-0.1639896035,
1.3027926683,
-0.0002097414,
-0.2581124604,
0.3053306043,
-0.3757732809,
-0.3634514809,
0.6825202107,
0.1949293613,
0.8269225955,
-0.1835409999,
0.3122785985,
0.6958546638,
0.3987485468,
-0.4618528783,
0.1791869551,
0.0061175656,
-0.6898421049,
-0.5562314987,
-0.716394186,
-0.4001435041,
0.1050510556,
-0.7906633615,
0.2723951638,
-0.1509320736,
-0.4507581294,
0.0902062804,
-0.0397588089,
-0.6860801578,
0.1347103566,
0.1110436842,
1.1031453609,
-0.8373057246,
0.4543021321,
0.8973389864,
-0.1938562244,
-0.1955376863,
-0.357962966,
-0.0269820392,
-0.9309821725,
0.3775808215,
0.4286231697,
-0.0074621802,
-0.1304500401,
-0.3043252528,
-0.3607363999,
0.7229332328,
0.4627459049,
-0.7562074065,
0.1187256426,
0.4926597774,
0.7062984705,
-0.2550600767,
0.0098152794,
0.6652905345,
0.6023450494,
-0.1205912605,
-0.6558039784,
0.1042800173,
-0.6068233848,
-0.1274091303,
0.2828429639,
-0.6019486189,
0.4814026058,
0.0982601345,
-0.4029681683,
-0.2129179835,
0.2090824991,
0.1209570691,
0.2433472276,
0.6696774364,
1.0316361189,
0.5976619124,
-0.2779303789,
0.9947948456,
-0.9210801721,
0.1332308054,
1.2354130745,
-0.6190451384,
0.7361402512,
0.2206371725,
-0.4181340635,
0.2848971486,
0.396969378,
-0.5516053438,
0.0915407538,
0.127486825,
-0.1717286855,
-0.5612447262,
-0.3752419651,
-0.149805367,
0.6005652547,
0.175885722,
-0.2109904736,
-0.5011596084,
-0.0111165056,
-0.0760868564,
0.5185071826,
-0.2411060482,
0.7914515734,
0.1463350356,
-0.7025603056,
0.3046585619,
0.3151929379,
0.4766286612,
-0.4860634208,
0.3216077983,
-0.3309355378,
0.0032119583,
0.0446513072,
-0.7426478267,
0.3892118633,
0.0854539946,
0.3853251636,
-0.5753976107,
0.4339261651,
-0.3052662015,
-0.5886374116,
0.82292974,
0.8968966007,
0.2590867281,
-0.3865773976,
-1.1351698637,
-0.0160018113,
-0.530461967,
-0.2303793728,
0.2961876094,
0.4413875937,
0.0526834764,
0.6477363706,
0.3653228879,
0.1102604195,
0.0962464958,
0.6521367431,
0.7524970174,
-0.652613461,
-0.3704573512,
-0.9231346846,
0.3595000207,
-0.3453210592,
-0.5982031226,
0.8405148983,
1.0328086615,
0.4880385995,
0.2737816572,
0.4559227824,
0.0942796767,
0.4846365452,
-0.4900713861,
0.6053882837,
-0.8562675714,
-0.0126325386,
-0.1174593419,
-1.2323120832,
-0.4416462481,
0.1212386116,
0.1746611446,
0.0283141918,
0.8224284649,
0.573949635,
-0.1238855049,
-0.1097479761,
0.5962954164,
-0.1095789149,
0.0858767927,
0.6697150469,
0.4603906572,
-0.5872300863,
0.5303647518,
-0.1325110495,
0.0269076098,
-0.0231269896,
-0.8755972385,
-0.9076268077,
-0.4090794325,
-0.5043744445,
-0.210434407,
-0.1678656638,
0.7320913076,
0.7300408483,
-1.0614948273,
-0.330945462,
-0.2059005499,
-0.2276622355,
-0.6442254186,
-0.1882553846,
0.2982953489,
-0.7997712493,
-0.7892796993,
0.7332678437,
0.5599267483,
-0.0698747858,
0.069304347,
-0.0150461691,
-0.0955675542,
-0.0782563239,
0.5371084809,
0.212896347,
-0.569229126,
0.1784336269,
-0.0036427309,
-0.3957475722,
0.3302072585,
1.1250299215,
-0.3289243579,
0.310008049,
0.0924011022,
0.9425284266,
0.5977775455,
0.0832024738,
0.4700777531,
-0.7932710052,
0.1918295175,
0.4220506251,
0.889275074,
0.1258496195,
0.0003106594,
0.8622633219,
0.2006673962,
-0.3287778795,
-0.6890496612,
-0.0987879559,
-0.8379075527,
-0.5036224723,
1.0906155109,
-0.1721721292,
-0.0757171139,
-0.2686571479,
0.2551622689,
-0.0864518657,
-0.194116801,
0.5601064563,
0.8488247395,
0.2907851934,
-0.2484203875,
-0.7591772079,
0.543862462,
0.7840021253,
-0.8775222898,
0.2445149124,
0.3632803857,
0.121502474,
0.3375522792,
0.4795215726,
-0.232810691,
0.3161064088,
0.1402139515,
0.1448167264,
-0.100347437,
-0.379960984,
-0.2169472575,
0.6051082611,
-0.2498113215,
0.228422612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13089v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13089v1 | Can an AI Win Ghana's National Science and Maths Quiz? An AI Grand Challenge for Education | 2023-01-30T17:28:33 | 2023-01-30T17:28:33 | George Boateng, Victor Kumbol, Elsie Effah Kaufmann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | There is a lack of enough qualified teachers across Africa which hampers
efforts to provide adequate learning support such as educational question
answering (EQA) to students. An AI system that can enable students to ask
questions via text or voice and get instant answers will make high-quality
education accessible. Despite advances in the field of AI, there exists no
robust benchmark or challenge to enable building such an (EQA) AI within the
African context. Ghana's National Science and Maths Quiz competition (NSMQ) is
the perfect competition to evaluate the potential of such an AI due to its wide
coverage of scientific fields, variety of question types, highly competitive
nature, and live, real-world format. The NSMQ is a Jeopardy-style annual live
quiz competition in which 3 teams of 2 students compete by answering questions
across biology, chemistry, physics, and math in 5 rounds over 5 progressive
stages until a winning team is crowned for that year. In this position paper,
we propose the NSMQ AI Grand Challenge, an AI Grand Challenge for Education
using Ghana's National Science and Maths Quiz competition (NSMQ) as a case
study. Our proposed grand challenge is to "Build an AI to compete live in
Ghana's National Science and Maths Quiz (NSMQ) competition and win - performing
better than the best contestants in all rounds and stages of the competition."
We describe the competition, and key technical challenges to address along with
ideas from recent advances in machine learning that could be leveraged to solve
this challenge. This position paper is a first step towards conquering such a
challenge and importantly, making advances in AI for education in the African
context towards democratizing high-quality education across Africa. | [
-0.5695513487,
-0.7513462305,
0.5486200452,
0.012740084,
-0.20545353,
0.2537214458,
0.1258298308,
-0.325240016,
0.3390896022,
0.131170094,
-0.7133453488,
-0.0510615855,
-0.9332103729,
0.3408187032,
-0.5503628254,
0.6611459851,
-0.2774613798,
-0.077070944,
-0.8295117617,
-0.1830090433,
-0.4045720994,
-0.7459805608,
-0.7667672038,
-0.1434186399,
0.3097181022,
0.5897328258,
0.6168010831,
0.0062823039,
0.4180031419,
0.3459365368,
0.0121607473,
0.7046711445,
-0.1169410497,
-0.0076237451,
0.0617815368,
-0.4855307043,
-0.2129866481,
0.2916021943,
0.3144687414,
0.5419597626,
-0.2612780333,
0.3311816156,
0.0968343616,
0.6184937358,
-0.389726758,
0.175803721,
-0.4658497572,
0.1551389694,
0.0636189654,
-0.1184694171,
0.1992322803,
-0.7637724876,
0.0267838109,
-0.6891635656,
0.1381374002,
-0.1527729779,
1.0429153442,
0.3257844746,
-0.4471601248,
-0.461364001,
-0.6997770667,
0.3168321848,
-0.4595042467,
-0.2340927571,
0.4359104335,
0.7508300543,
0.0488465764,
-0.5396228433,
-0.4444871247,
-0.3640837669,
0.3945933878,
0.3918454051,
0.2711846828,
-0.3442522287,
0.2325580865,
0.1548494548,
-0.4476279914,
-0.2578011155,
-0.4433665574,
-0.3970744014,
0.6887016296,
0.2822900414,
0.4542450011,
0.1875305623,
-0.0148198409,
0.1895660609,
-0.3687517047,
-0.0090424959,
0.4356206954,
0.3135998249,
0.0232087057,
0.4355190694,
-0.4163256586,
0.4100872278,
-0.0226278864,
-0.0847260356,
-0.0489849821,
-0.1524354219,
0.1396274716,
0.2965548635,
0.607688725,
-0.0977572054,
0.269181639,
0.0585693009,
-0.2480147034,
0.4760766923,
0.2428369075,
-0.6109656096,
-0.2906246781,
0.1393819451,
0.0319235325,
-0.2153894007,
0.0777745843,
-0.4774640501,
-0.2409666777,
-0.1192481145,
1.0597602129,
-0.2547558844,
0.1676332355,
-0.1142161489,
0.0071161133,
0.1561058164,
0.6964820027,
-0.8422685862,
0.1702545136,
0.6975244284,
0.8482479453,
0.4502550364,
-0.270064801,
-0.1993116587,
-0.1377304643,
-0.1060132608,
0.494471699,
-0.5381320715,
-0.6247426271,
-0.2829726636,
-0.3153830171,
-0.3008700907,
-0.5751135945,
0.5865266323,
-0.5999619961,
0.4085000157,
-0.4711898267,
-0.3564585149,
0.1221134216,
0.5416605473,
-0.5471048355,
0.6310353279,
0.2383603752,
-0.5007193089,
0.0000812904,
-0.7671144009,
-0.4610415101,
0.2186423838,
-0.3351381421,
-0.4611427188,
-0.0025694163,
0.7187682986,
-0.2119576931,
-0.4563913643,
0.3242452145,
-0.2806592286,
-0.525024116,
0.3451249897,
-0.4958246052,
0.9595180154,
-0.08489158,
-0.6190057993,
-0.2257770002,
-0.3347670734,
0.2547147274,
0.2931972146,
-0.2216061801,
0.310410589,
-0.0445895381,
-0.4347248077,
0.4119299054,
0.1562803388,
-0.6839457154,
0.4001407027,
-0.144944489,
0.407881856,
0.8317415714,
0.08796262,
0.2131893933,
-0.5364732146,
0.7236235738,
-0.3304952681,
0.610031724,
0.4738453329,
-0.8581087589,
-0.7514731884,
0.0324115939,
0.9057445526,
0.8984375,
-1.0852447748,
0.1304656863,
-0.0106666125,
-0.5031007528,
-0.9601793289,
-0.097807005,
0.0262764618,
0.7424070835,
0.1431257874,
-0.2171825469,
-0.3418006599,
-0.7083626986,
-0.2616429627,
-0.2998806834,
-0.1356743127,
0.8672780395,
0.8565049171,
0.0436429866,
0.747320056,
-0.2666855156,
-0.5593560934,
0.2240136564,
0.1709064841,
0.0102463467,
0.3680301011,
0.3633385003,
-1.1084071398,
-0.376178056,
-0.0820689797,
-1.1677007675,
-0.1889978796,
0.1509873718,
-0.1011238098,
0.0322409049,
0.2603982389,
-0.5522979498,
0.4865162969,
0.1633080542,
-0.3803070188,
0.8384292722,
-0.0955437496,
0.3398715258,
-0.3662652373,
0.309445858,
-0.5557634234,
0.0803309977,
-0.3882176578,
0.070078291,
-0.0666370094,
-0.4970659316,
-0.394729197,
0.4994339049,
-0.0463355072,
0.1081052646,
-0.159665674,
0.4165997803,
-0.2145085931,
0.015844116,
-0.3849593699,
0.7585492134,
0.403249383,
-0.6646436453,
0.458811909,
0.5446045995,
-0.5084525347,
0.6338602304,
-0.8841320276,
0.1520063281,
0.0263729356,
0.4140600264,
-0.6966363192,
-0.2633753121,
0.3088916242,
-0.9845162034,
0.082455866,
0.2470413595,
-0.339853406,
-0.6058404446,
0.1650609225,
0.1959007531,
0.5121287107,
-0.5485501885,
0.5533714294,
0.2940337658,
-0.4225495756,
-0.9135970473,
-0.328610599,
0.4009303451,
-0.0830835998,
-0.5521250367,
0.124033317,
-0.0126646934,
-0.0110986326,
0.230999887,
-0.2324813008,
-0.1132047698,
0.7452306151,
0.2464587092,
0.3881412745,
-0.101423189,
-0.2021473646,
0.0309702028,
-0.2049963921,
0.47254619,
-0.5564071536,
0.1870803237,
-0.1499364972,
-0.529471755,
-0.4062321484,
0.5409114361,
0.606990993,
-0.3853715956,
0.7588634491,
0.4911386073,
-0.4753575027,
0.0326688364,
-0.2055795342,
-0.105894655,
-0.4853935838,
0.1702090949,
-0.2673246562,
-0.8945411444,
0.3445625007,
-0.1748259217,
0.0729607642,
0.6585082412,
0.3750056624,
-0.3843248487,
1.2977421284,
0.4779604673,
-0.3146347106,
0.0238432325,
-0.4499529004,
0.0958437771,
-0.6164144278,
-0.6883925796,
-0.8059278131,
-0.7454919815,
-0.2094732523,
-0.0902844369,
0.7973740101,
-0.0176802892,
-0.5197202563,
-0.3389180601,
-0.4012657404,
0.3684709668,
0.8735661507,
0.2978592515,
-0.0180759784,
-0.1092736349,
-0.4018140137,
0.1742317975,
-0.9628528357,
-0.6018737555,
0.8705861568,
-0.2183378339,
0.3133326173,
0.3040280044,
1.0184954405,
0.3245404065,
0.5723298788,
-0.7057017684,
0.5490624905,
0.0150240296,
-0.8493975401,
-0.5521638989,
-0.7022317648,
-0.7213888764,
-0.0334710442,
-0.2596463561,
-0.4421553612,
-0.1440204531,
-0.1650058627,
-0.3434958458,
0.5143566132,
-0.2147522569,
0.69833076,
-0.4590184093,
-0.0782081634,
0.1988774836,
-0.8727548718,
0.1781552881,
-0.2012838274,
0.2975808084,
0.0743403137,
0.063293606,
0.9353938103,
-0.8141307235,
0.4385878146,
-0.5165198445,
0.1695717424,
0.8648559451,
-0.0977199972,
-0.1427525878,
0.1364705712,
-0.0531191528,
-0.0689959377,
-0.263297528,
-0.6714212894,
-0.7806545496,
0.6815519333,
-1.2401745319,
-0.8982573748,
-0.6183008552,
-0.2498351634,
-0.4485054612,
-0.0190706439,
0.2879862785,
0.5153608918,
-0.2237468958,
-0.108036451,
0.4196503162,
-0.0160610173,
0.2224004865,
-0.0264271256,
0.0214091372,
-0.468962878,
1.162191391,
0.3981496394,
0.1537247896,
0.0920931026,
0.1641221046,
-0.4888699949,
-0.3597763479,
-0.820361495,
0.188806355,
-0.6339905858,
-0.2252589017,
-0.5177417397,
-0.4358288646,
-0.3329733908,
-0.2246069014,
0.122196123,
-0.610601306,
-0.4157829583,
0.2440871298,
-0.0090554291,
0.8270007968,
-0.2783146501,
0.0554668978,
-0.6537265182,
0.4582648277,
0.9674352407,
0.0471958481,
0.0883013532,
-0.72022295,
-0.0373938084,
0.2309871316,
-0.6263810992,
-0.5250909328,
0.3777369857,
0.4241596162,
0.5811724663,
0.3361240625,
0.0542270988,
0.5065692663,
-0.3364680409,
1.0742058754,
-0.0374143273,
-0.8189703226,
0.6211758852,
-0.0100288736,
0.4055863321,
0.8139592409,
0.7064374685,
-0.5309508443,
-0.2600880265,
-0.7939601541,
-0.6203895211,
0.426163137,
0.3382810056,
0.1513042897,
0.2015767097,
0.5446123481,
-0.03492219,
0.4579506218,
-0.3002225161,
-0.3779272139,
-0.2009819299,
0.06120288,
-0.0704224482,
0.1968253255,
-0.1722397506,
-0.2208597958,
0.9920325875,
-0.0380670093,
0.4486478269,
0.2307247221,
0.0765844733,
0.0571782738,
0.3284004927,
0.3201011717,
0.5472386479,
-0.0970803052,
-0.2297594994,
0.2544579506,
-0.7095140815,
0.49926278,
0.0581076331,
-0.5386881828,
-0.0599664003,
0.2416304648,
0.4809200764,
-0.1737871766,
-0.4479094148,
0.2215863019,
-0.3651528955,
-0.8690682054,
-0.0778028443,
0.2477064431,
0.0393454432,
0.1729448438,
0.722384572,
0.0253566671,
-0.0666113868,
-0.9143148661,
0.2374493182,
0.5572689772,
-0.3526450098,
0.0802232772,
0.9832946062,
0.3585385382,
-0.6907069683,
1.0992799997,
-0.3647243083,
-1.262219429,
1.3240764141,
0.5930253863,
0.5051984191,
-0.3499469757,
0.6792967916,
0.3210451007,
0.46132797,
0.0467421822,
0.7330825329,
-0.0164129343,
-0.3726232648,
0.0188507494,
-0.3197060525,
-0.9692077041,
-0.1152590141,
-0.4691049457,
0.0160010047,
-0.6350229383,
-0.1256379187,
-0.1885807812,
0.4383627474,
-0.5987468958,
0.722687602,
0.5350663662,
0.7932178974,
-0.6654177904,
0.4561868906,
0.7312153578,
0.1002875939,
-0.7014950514,
-0.4450838268,
0.0669242069,
-0.3972167969,
0.4836787581,
0.2392538935,
-0.0870967358,
-0.156667158,
-0.7236580253,
-0.7524014115,
1.0422018766,
0.2660014629,
-0.137599349,
0.014374041,
0.2055849582,
0.2328486294,
-0.3805605471,
0.5090272427,
0.2314417064,
0.6632739902,
0.2124672085,
-0.8855444193,
-0.3774619997,
-0.3339658976,
-0.5867326856,
0.3813737929,
-0.7345250249,
1.0132273436,
-0.5592150092,
-0.5138190985,
0.3871977925,
0.9007585049,
0.2388861179,
0.9332374334,
0.2524873912,
0.7447252274,
1.0673154593,
-0.4171153307,
0.921344161,
-0.1124901772,
0.3681049645,
0.7548140287,
-0.2762750983,
0.5537954569,
0.0269134082,
-0.3318589628,
0.3783254325,
0.6614644527,
0.1654092371,
0.3212738037,
0.2718443871,
-0.6044546366,
-0.3936010301,
-0.2669231594,
-0.8038541079,
0.612272203,
0.5342227221,
0.2514753938,
0.0311725456,
-0.0146336919,
-0.2401710153,
0.1019246876,
-0.6515735984,
0.3538306057,
0.1976156682,
-0.4594171345,
0.4346258938,
0.0124211777,
0.4654418826,
-0.6314200163,
0.0645406023,
-0.1865423918,
-0.1512324363,
-0.0401546061,
-0.4692623615,
0.0851878375,
-0.1971023828,
0.2533620596,
0.3020612597,
0.5286826491,
-0.2863649428,
-0.5884605646,
-0.2591242194,
0.6858304143,
-0.0500162914,
-0.1402835995,
-0.9267783761,
-0.3121663332,
-0.3171383739,
0.2834503651,
0.5079655051,
0.3655536473,
0.0826049671,
0.8325231075,
0.4499986768,
-0.0336158872,
-0.1542787552,
-0.0741089582,
0.718287468,
-0.4378166497,
-0.7174560428,
-0.6618192792,
-0.0775194764,
-0.1153026894,
-0.5760454535,
0.8926731348,
0.4419286251,
0.6112589836,
0.0300416294,
0.9541722536,
-0.1504176408,
0.0730992407,
-0.2004348338,
0.7796549797,
-0.5838704109,
-0.3103864789,
-0.2108078152,
-0.7907957435,
-0.0978550687,
0.5886286497,
-0.2325418591,
0.1069679484,
0.5994108319,
0.2168188989,
0.2163669914,
0.4590025544,
0.1166892797,
-0.0452869758,
0.1188888326,
1.02394104,
1.1844130754,
-0.6030911207,
0.3925758302,
-0.3519799411,
-0.3872458935,
-0.1943155825,
-0.4179187715,
-0.7273114324,
-0.4232667387,
-0.4034225941,
-0.4810872674,
0.074559547,
0.6799311042,
0.2228156477,
-0.8030285239,
-0.0677188784,
0.5048856735,
0.3128100038,
-0.3200483918,
-0.168749541,
0.3837185502,
0.2895393372,
-0.480622828,
0.2850310504,
0.1140719652,
0.0868572444,
-0.0302817058,
0.1834513545,
-0.354829371,
0.3409961462,
0.6186292171,
0.6731933355,
-0.4288038015,
-0.4416822195,
0.1968805939,
0.0523004383,
-0.2210393548,
0.7532122731,
-1.0172128677,
0.2674832046,
0.0780815408,
1.0441681147,
0.2595196962,
0.093926087,
0.0052119237,
-0.2662339509,
-0.3395038843,
0.6424518228,
0.0557699241,
0.083029218,
-0.5059261918,
0.5616666079,
0.3179545701,
-0.81517452,
-0.6119995713,
0.1532764286,
-0.7523428202,
-0.0710166842,
0.6363751292,
-0.0056632305,
-0.344109565,
-0.1928520352,
-0.2785104215,
0.2888152301,
-0.1659651846,
1.2513828278,
0.687271595,
-0.1522948146,
0.2848707139,
-0.6225898862,
0.1079625711,
0.5864918232,
-1.0108326674,
-0.4896457195,
0.1845228523,
-0.0925910845,
0.0645328388,
0.3787767887,
-0.0668276697,
0.6820537448,
0.1351410151,
-0.5225194097,
-0.3684549332,
-0.7107585073,
-0.4322507679,
0.5585815907,
-0.214817524,
-0.2412688434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13083v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13083v2 | Communication Drives the Emergence of Language Universals in Neural Agents: Evidence from the Word-order/Case-marking Trade-off | 2023-01-30T17:22:33 | 2023-06-01T03:54:09 | Yuchen Lian, Arianna Bisazza, Tessa Verhoef | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Artificial learners often behave differently from human learners in the
context of neural agent-based simulations of language emergence and change. A
common explanation is the lack of appropriate cognitive biases in these
learners. However, it has also been proposed that more naturalistic settings of
language learning and use could lead to more human-like results. We investigate
this latter account focusing on the word-order/case-marking trade-off, a widely
attested language universal that has proven particularly hard to simulate. We
propose a new Neural-agent Language Learning and Communication framework
(NeLLCom) where pairs of speaking and listening agents first learn a miniature
language via supervised learning, and then optimize it for communication via
reinforcement learning. Following closely the setup of earlier human
experiments, we succeed in replicating the trade-off with the new framework
without hard-coding specific biases in the agents. We see this as an essential
step towards the investigation of language universals with neural learners. | [
-0.3162257969,
-0.6148079634,
0.3223131001,
0.1157469749,
0.1455246955,
0.1744609177,
-0.3242114782,
-0.6192837358,
0.4067524374,
0.2474078238,
-0.4978749752,
-0.3247898817,
-0.3618122935,
-0.0236677062,
-0.1722961813,
0.9950121045,
0.6175707579,
-0.0398385935,
-0.0050370842,
-0.1617669612,
-0.1848243624,
-0.7173984647,
-1.288418293,
-0.6414676309,
0.631667316,
0.2630741894,
0.8805431128,
0.626026392,
-0.1292399019,
0.397087723,
-0.1776303053,
0.1481240988,
-0.2219671458,
0.1737992465,
-0.4122809768,
-0.6022590995,
-0.2803215086,
0.2651650906,
0.5540485978,
0.6816179156,
-0.0912744552,
-0.2423905134,
-0.1919839978,
0.5706974268,
-0.4049398601,
0.3247855902,
-0.842982769,
0.1407146752,
0.2666116357,
-0.4415821731,
-0.5410782099,
-0.1651899964,
0.2432249188,
-0.7296581268,
0.0030361859,
-0.1807432771,
0.7529934645,
0.0702919811,
-0.434700042,
-0.2648577094,
-0.6988612413,
0.6340125799,
-0.4014793932,
0.2563963234,
0.394028604,
0.3044186532,
-0.4408832788,
-0.8333166838,
-0.6331367493,
-0.3589013517,
0.0262141433,
0.060265176,
-0.1568887085,
0.4427338243,
0.0308020078,
-0.3328162134,
-0.3120472431,
0.3242526054,
-0.3341451287,
-0.357822746,
0.6190500259,
0.1492109895,
0.6329582334,
0.008796121,
-0.19050394,
-0.2874633372,
-0.9253216982,
0.1041531861,
0.2545364499,
0.593190372,
-0.0717609525,
-0.0137431044,
-0.2390983105,
0.5656235218,
-0.2167146206,
0.2438285202,
-0.0093508707,
-0.2516561151,
-0.1064458936,
0.0774689391,
0.783912003,
0.302058816,
0.7487257719,
-0.2805216908,
-0.117648609,
0.354716599,
0.4151365757,
-0.7304952145,
0.006459788,
-0.1169724017,
-0.1997826993,
-0.5141180754,
-0.0148615064,
-0.5512277484,
-0.1620041728,
-0.4991844296,
0.5015792251,
-0.1109746099,
-0.4065284431,
0.177210331,
0.1225465164,
0.3166361153,
0.2529778779,
-1.1825823784,
0.6731076241,
0.7829660773,
0.4778258502,
-0.0799939856,
-0.6908694506,
-0.6247861385,
-0.1204219833,
-0.6282255054,
0.7297405601,
-0.4185116589,
-0.2945791483,
0.1941498369,
-0.1137604043,
-0.0734614357,
-0.4339101017,
0.2542726099,
-0.5456570387,
0.2335510105,
-0.3401091993,
-0.3232025802,
0.1404073983,
0.0356995799,
-0.4554483891,
0.4890990257,
-0.0259004105,
-0.4734698534,
0.3699231148,
-0.6859527826,
-0.4380222559,
0.2397835851,
-0.6755526066,
0.0100769913,
0.0803722292,
-0.3462574482,
0.4582692385,
-0.1374977976,
0.1634067893,
0.1372859627,
-0.6740820408,
0.5787486434,
-0.6089843512,
0.8601625562,
0.0627808273,
-0.6800627708,
0.1865223646,
-0.6289681792,
0.2237987965,
-0.0217326898,
-0.459351778,
-0.4272432327,
0.0671592057,
-0.0432854146,
0.5479089022,
-0.0989711359,
-0.5225611925,
0.2294047177,
-0.4093969762,
0.5299860239,
0.8216007948,
-0.2723006606,
0.7675695419,
-0.3845449388,
0.4206069112,
-0.0997863486,
0.4087001979,
0.2639094293,
-0.5427415967,
-0.9100210667,
-0.0405277349,
0.313926816,
0.3033280373,
-0.8324339986,
-0.0348612592,
-0.2342037112,
0.1223877668,
-0.7026094198,
-0.0458796509,
0.6142759323,
-0.1061745062,
0.1785677522,
-0.2538392842,
-0.444046855,
-0.8624543548,
-0.08242549,
-0.4944151342,
0.0477617048,
0.2705247998,
0.1340315044,
-0.430205673,
0.965012908,
-0.1908478737,
0.0719544515,
-0.2878708839,
0.1625390947,
-0.0417021737,
0.3731292188,
0.4389054477,
-0.7240363955,
-0.4440804422,
0.2037312686,
-0.5051805973,
0.0384425111,
-0.3016493022,
-0.1338142306,
0.5104885101,
0.8209635615,
-0.7895083427,
0.5498523712,
0.4710930884,
-0.6415916085,
0.6755627394,
-0.488591373,
-0.1497583389,
-1.1371542215,
-0.2812032402,
-0.2403614968,
-0.1747831553,
-1.0119348764,
0.0458640084,
-0.1778333485,
0.2602517903,
-0.5928999782,
0.8203683496,
-0.4070517421,
-0.0474521443,
-0.5277945399,
0.0615523718,
-0.1388386488,
0.6601902246,
0.0442456901,
0.825392127,
0.3539720178,
-0.6264342666,
0.0498356447,
0.2520644963,
-0.1173784807,
0.6119301319,
-0.7469766736,
0.0839728117,
-0.0594693199,
-0.1350038052,
-0.7453205585,
0.1392091364,
0.1813998967,
-0.749154985,
0.3725888431,
-0.0495969765,
-0.2786771953,
0.0450513735,
-0.0114988377,
0.315092057,
0.4306212068,
-0.5763137937,
0.4047734439,
0.2195402831,
-0.0363355838,
-0.3942162395,
-0.640702486,
0.3193718791,
0.0975843519,
-0.3105306029,
0.130877763,
-0.2701488137,
-0.5334207416,
-0.370572418,
0.0130119128,
-0.2267886698,
0.2151174098,
0.3605651259,
0.1845115125,
-0.0997693837,
0.2761199772,
0.150663957,
-0.2450836003,
0.3402127624,
-0.5088293552,
0.4741107821,
-0.375570327,
-0.0696893856,
-0.3940396905,
0.3493067324,
0.6802426577,
0.2388035208,
0.8536988497,
0.1713680625,
-0.0796259418,
-0.4840537608,
-0.399212867,
-0.5408453345,
-0.5784290433,
0.394110322,
-0.4160751998,
-0.8386960626,
0.1862823963,
0.0440908633,
-0.0876183063,
0.0645479038,
0.3878815472,
0.085894458,
0.857303679,
0.7132989764,
-0.2703032494,
0.526679039,
-0.2582100928,
-0.0839090198,
-0.4978731275,
-0.1561761796,
-0.437644273,
-0.0344006009,
-0.7143117189,
-0.2674683034,
-0.056577675,
-0.1774128973,
-0.2926200628,
0.4158884585,
-0.3354735672,
0.7310388088,
0.6542930603,
-0.1916527748,
0.4184800982,
0.2564784288,
-0.5368443131,
0.0772326291,
-0.8129090071,
-0.3693750203,
1.0931919813,
-0.0602389462,
0.3667078018,
0.0296024326,
0.7100719213,
0.3351712525,
0.3351485133,
-0.6344753504,
0.6312652826,
0.1449941546,
-0.5046761036,
-0.347773999,
-0.5699973702,
-1.4411509037,
0.5300521255,
-0.1872257441,
-1.0085058212,
0.3156985641,
-0.2725956142,
-0.1684245765,
0.1201313511,
-0.6332883835,
0.6872625351,
0.0534744188,
-0.3654567897,
-0.058219213,
-0.7785211802,
-0.1071959734,
0.2503647208,
0.3129865825,
0.062514022,
-0.0001005539,
0.5403257608,
-0.2994025648,
1.0300297737,
0.1191795766,
-0.212849319,
0.3796897531,
0.325707078,
0.2663869858,
0.1064546406,
0.073146157,
-0.045798324,
-0.0027154253,
-0.5158501267,
-0.5017821193,
0.637309134,
-1.0522392988,
-0.3109338582,
-0.5288229585,
-0.6395784616,
-0.1728854775,
0.0661713853,
0.1440730989,
0.5258731842,
-0.4706046879,
-0.2422157526,
0.4942347705,
-0.0047096033,
0.7147547007,
0.937258482,
-0.2525870204,
-0.357381314,
1.298430562,
-0.2570965886,
0.6227214336,
0.2946241498,
0.2372078151,
-0.1460226327,
-0.3383797705,
-0.1906291693,
0.3140744865,
-0.572230041,
0.122702457,
-0.4696317613,
-0.472563386,
-0.1176326498,
-0.2032560557,
-0.3935877085,
-0.3429511189,
-0.2880088985,
-0.0794877782,
0.0043236827,
1.0090841055,
-0.4181440473,
0.3446402252,
-0.4237375259,
0.0101902932,
0.8973925114,
0.1623025537,
0.0512392819,
-0.3709970415,
-0.1661128551,
0.5256146789,
-0.1546766758,
-0.5135748386,
0.3141434789,
0.4113917947,
0.5065671206,
0.5636068583,
-0.1783063859,
0.1265806109,
-0.4576717317,
0.3292226493,
0.2429592907,
-0.8232979178,
0.2324023992,
-0.6509560943,
0.2895449996,
0.5207693577,
0.2667527497,
-0.9969424009,
-0.2631670833,
-0.8489399552,
-0.5879914165,
0.7384203076,
0.4204392135,
0.2759088874,
-0.3107563853,
0.4194597602,
-0.0534038022,
0.3401931822,
-0.7078767419,
-0.2891409099,
0.0800614133,
0.0604817644,
-0.2519803345,
-0.0759962052,
-0.2118401229,
-0.3933735788,
0.3358350098,
-0.4503733814,
0.3417114615,
-0.0131164333,
-0.1239505485,
0.0508690029,
0.3644764125,
0.7547346354,
0.6457494497,
0.0511051491,
0.1019265503,
-0.2884036899,
-0.4853711426,
0.4124331474,
-0.0851807073,
-0.4213010073,
-0.005570401,
0.1636572331,
0.8681887388,
0.4087877274,
-0.6999270916,
0.6179628372,
-0.3769754171,
-0.4538522065,
-0.0608682558,
0.110771738,
0.3114383221,
0.3683078289,
0.2922887802,
0.1460942775,
0.0024049685,
-0.8424991965,
0.448322624,
0.5331432223,
-0.6029752493,
-0.6602582335,
0.3326503336,
0.2855966389,
-0.7691811919,
0.5065872669,
-0.4882682562,
-0.6749001145,
0.7863752842,
0.5062271953,
0.8071516752,
-0.2912925184,
0.8840010762,
-0.1350212395,
0.40091905,
-0.0632293895,
0.413243413,
-0.3615446091,
-0.9870707989,
-0.4443332255,
-0.5882745385,
-0.4362211227,
-0.1137902439,
-0.6375568509,
-0.2644506395,
-0.5643555522,
-0.1746531725,
-0.0551345758,
0.0979410261,
-0.5892834067,
0.018262716,
0.2783767581,
0.6267518997,
-0.8083801866,
0.972858429,
0.6218318343,
-0.3791871071,
-0.7787846327,
-0.0540624857,
-0.0755707547,
-0.7466955781,
0.996558547,
0.291487366,
-0.0946755111,
0.2360070348,
-0.5329809189,
-0.7023980021,
0.7711091042,
0.360666424,
-0.1010323986,
-0.0356156416,
0.3389226198,
0.7794366479,
-0.3830864727,
0.5238155723,
0.7541636825,
0.1288880855,
0.1359123886,
-0.8172166944,
0.0231311563,
-0.4310818315,
0.1383416206,
0.2490743697,
-0.6603058577,
0.7006636858,
-0.1910841018,
-0.2801853716,
0.2230604291,
0.5934426188,
-0.0326060764,
0.1100521386,
0.2481385916,
0.2047876865,
0.4733038545,
-0.0710987523,
0.790571928,
-0.0244148504,
0.1644439697,
1.1009447575,
-0.1788112521,
0.8357684612,
0.4843955338,
-0.3960595429,
0.7153739333,
0.3527394235,
0.6334602237,
0.2770777643,
0.678370595,
-0.5402271152,
-0.1459364891,
-0.3107782304,
-0.120032005,
0.4779840112,
0.4323653877,
0.0453384221,
-0.098484844,
-0.1539679468,
0.0443873256,
0.0714230314,
-0.1885686666,
0.9162523746,
0.2006726265,
-0.6079304814,
0.7741120458,
-0.3548555076,
1.0153762102,
-0.6340187192,
0.0227811672,
-0.4756062329,
0.0676390976,
0.1707246155,
-0.1508432627,
-0.0003636547,
-0.5978699923,
-0.0490508787,
-0.1721553355,
0.4612657726,
-0.7777932882,
0.0082427384,
0.6554756761,
0.5585446954,
0.2050380111,
-0.0283419676,
-0.7182043195,
0.0043386072,
-0.2642354667,
-0.1785755903,
0.726300776,
0.2609556019,
0.0639217347,
0.6660123467,
0.7387395501,
0.3837793171,
0.2390276045,
0.179100275,
0.6804975271,
-0.5168287158,
-0.5442455411,
-0.6115807891,
0.274217099,
-0.3658741415,
-0.233757779,
0.4468925297,
-0.0087317443,
0.8592047095,
0.0497713648,
0.542686522,
0.2388397753,
-0.1525784284,
-0.3603664041,
1.022347331,
-0.442702353,
-0.0503584445,
-0.3241189718,
-0.8547441959,
-0.0524522178,
0.5604896545,
0.1251689792,
0.0316346996,
0.9061412811,
0.859038651,
0.2761069834,
0.190618068,
0.7796640396,
0.2292301208,
0.3229542077,
0.6273944378,
0.9168632627,
-0.4044403434,
0.4445562065,
-0.1294501275,
-0.2077364922,
-0.0360814258,
-0.6194201708,
-1.1005115509,
-0.6672503948,
-0.157876879,
-0.4379844368,
0.5324646831,
1.3062571287,
0.7149680257,
-0.6070284247,
-0.5936383605,
-0.5302205086,
0.1610343903,
-0.1072391197,
-0.231483072,
0.1289469302,
-0.5676400065,
-0.7544659376,
0.5815464258,
0.3166205585,
0.2895296216,
-0.218973279,
-0.4906482697,
-0.3740286529,
0.2773014009,
0.7486482859,
0.9421390891,
-0.5289801955,
-0.1394666731,
-0.1842862666,
-0.403642416,
-0.1018687412,
0.9148670435,
-0.8223288059,
0.3552801609,
0.2106477767,
0.8317842484,
0.1256751269,
-0.5878918767,
0.8452069163,
-0.6765385866,
0.5576084256,
0.0578527525,
0.0757061392,
0.178583011,
-0.1914689988,
0.3164433837,
0.4113751352,
-0.5102013946,
-0.6185715199,
0.3882673383,
-0.6344958544,
-0.4328756928,
1.2643861771,
0.1131892279,
-0.3183657825,
-0.2556072772,
-0.2246741652,
0.0870477855,
-0.4376473129,
0.8348344564,
0.3668585718,
0.254029125,
0.1320736408,
-0.4813104868,
0.908308208,
0.6851585507,
-0.9216192961,
-0.3112486303,
0.313685298,
0.3288549483,
0.135445267,
0.9362571239,
0.3967778087,
0.5482058525,
0.0640270486,
0.2696935833,
0.0170831084,
-0.7989166379,
-0.3415408432,
-0.151683718,
0.0804627985,
-0.2539699674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13066v2 | A Human Word Association based model for topic detection in social networks | 2023-01-30T17:10:34 | 2023-07-18T11:39:22 | Mehrdad Ranjbar Khadivi, Shahin Akbarpour, Mohammad-Reza Feizi-Derakhshi, Babak Anari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the widespread use of social networks, detecting the topics discussed in
these networks has become a significant challenge. The current works are mainly
based on frequent pattern mining or semantic relations, and the language
structure is not considered. The meaning of language structural methods is to
discover the relationship between words and how humans understand them.
Therefore, this paper uses the Concept of the Imitation of the Mental Ability
of Word Association to propose a topic detection framework in social networks.
This framework is based on the Human Word Association method. A special
extraction algorithm has also been designed for this purpose. The performance
of this method is evaluated on the FA-CUP dataset. It is a benchmark dataset in
the field of topic detection. The results show that the proposed method is a
good improvement compared to other methods, based on the Topic-recall and the
keyword F1 measure. Also, most of the previous works in the field of topic
detection are limited to the English language, and the Persian language,
especially microblogs written in this language, is considered a low-resource
language. Therefore, a data set of Telegram posts in the Farsi language has
been collected. Applying the proposed method to this dataset also shows that
this method works better than other topic detection methods. | [
-0.442750603,
-1.3248883486,
0.4507450759,
0.2395242751,
-0.6012714505,
0.2015912086,
-0.0583576635,
-0.1904630065,
1.073584795,
0.2884476483,
-0.4837196767,
-0.6427899599,
-0.6854774356,
-0.0203216132,
-0.5622341633,
0.4431396723,
0.0051750322,
-0.3909953535,
0.1849034876,
-0.0631339774,
-0.3759377003,
-0.3094388247,
-0.8148308992,
-0.0905133784,
0.4425360858,
0.3539297283,
0.3613353968,
0.6160507798,
0.4471110404,
0.4703574479,
-0.4241479337,
0.2496074587,
-0.2502925694,
-0.2828947902,
-0.3761075437,
-0.4166100025,
-0.4025894701,
0.0874885917,
0.7274221778,
0.4261678457,
-0.152566582,
-0.0165350307,
-0.0709496737,
0.9223468304,
-0.3385730386,
0.1646682322,
-0.8621171117,
0.0145098921,
-0.6065044403,
-0.2195119262,
0.0396736823,
0.0164243411,
-0.0575256273,
-0.1868565828,
0.452909708,
0.2776349485,
0.7844207287,
-0.3996148109,
-0.0669747218,
-0.4952908754,
-0.2038469464,
0.3449455798,
-0.3917270601,
0.1696831733,
0.6107864976,
0.2116604447,
-0.375987649,
-0.3384531438,
-0.9463873506,
0.1856696904,
-0.0061514731,
-0.232153073,
-0.4812133312,
-0.1436020583,
-0.1122336611,
0.4974206388,
-0.7095544338,
-0.3796799779,
-0.2537977695,
-0.281632036,
0.5776023269,
0.0495400988,
0.7644804716,
-0.5593993664,
0.0261265282,
0.2397952229,
-0.3123835027,
0.0074421992,
0.2175501585,
0.4448719919,
-0.2469729632,
0.3913664222,
-0.6626290679,
0.5564812422,
-0.0381707847,
0.0929936171,
0.3688037395,
-0.1632278115,
-0.0016743994,
-0.0372362919,
0.8093097806,
0.2108789533,
0.4503071606,
-0.3717866242,
-0.1385338604,
0.5720362067,
-0.1355484128,
-0.6071742773,
-0.1868064255,
0.0351764821,
-0.8412172198,
-0.4040187895,
0.3443304896,
-0.5809179544,
-0.1941047311,
0.2046810836,
0.2030881941,
-0.3780056834,
-0.7147212029,
0.216365695,
-0.1332584471,
0.0033662587,
-0.088737011,
-0.6422579288,
0.4365068972,
0.9717420936,
1.3768330812,
-0.2961804271,
-0.1954578906,
-0.4518606961,
-0.073679097,
-0.4001551569,
1.1217998266,
-0.358410418,
-0.2441289276,
-0.1536551863,
0.301800698,
0.1817007065,
-0.1686944366,
0.1320758611,
-0.6368708611,
-0.0587791577,
-0.364969939,
-0.6870789528,
-0.1544880122,
0.1755728126,
-0.4580169618,
0.4300013483,
-0.301720351,
-0.9134303927,
0.3609444797,
-0.8027842641,
-0.3918156922,
0.0393218063,
-0.2919227183,
-0.3147539496,
0.0959934145,
0.1098230556,
0.7743999362,
-0.381539762,
0.4572116137,
-0.4291679859,
-0.663444221,
0.5224824548,
-0.2987227738,
0.3889481425,
0.2831060886,
-0.0247826334,
0.2053401917,
-0.6168431044,
-0.2802782059,
0.3246355653,
0.09445934,
-0.7153143287,
0.3904350698,
-0.1886464804,
0.2113811225,
-0.0126686059,
-0.7248167992,
-0.0671343729,
-0.5606184602,
0.4298147857,
0.7047752142,
0.6694602966,
0.4101587236,
-0.3487046361,
0.2929919362,
0.1699993759,
-0.3269485831,
0.0486759767,
-0.6702534556,
-0.5671533942,
-0.2856459618,
0.1313450485,
0.4542966187,
-0.7826436162,
0.8173832297,
0.047395844,
-0.5127815008,
-0.2299759537,
0.2695066929,
0.3055531085,
0.0527982786,
0.0896229893,
-0.4335604608,
-0.2771695256,
-0.7289965153,
-0.3998203576,
-0.3657403588,
0.037465699,
0.1450765729,
0.4060644209,
-0.1055850089,
0.9083519578,
-0.9124550223,
-0.3870434761,
-0.3009694219,
0.4925540686,
0.4282188714,
0.2520655692,
0.4819878638,
-1.0922628641,
-0.5987070799,
-0.2127135247,
-0.6408803463,
-0.0655902252,
0.190925315,
-0.3605689108,
-0.0709206834,
0.4936643243,
-0.2469413579,
0.6454957128,
0.21479626,
-0.6919153929,
0.0363599993,
0.1314595491,
0.1628115624,
-1.4384628534,
-0.1792110801,
0.5780598521,
-0.0980700552,
-0.6775491834,
-0.2465276718,
-0.1298870295,
-0.3662219942,
-0.2469500154,
0.6972967386,
-0.3377180696,
-0.0451819897,
-0.7526632547,
0.2264634073,
-0.3884391189,
0.5872088671,
0.2276654094,
0.7173827887,
0.6568551064,
-0.5929160714,
0.3354269564,
0.2914169729,
-0.3655573726,
0.352465421,
-0.6606766582,
0.1885910034,
-0.3682301044,
0.0088552758,
-1.2668298483,
-0.0501144603,
0.6234541535,
-0.6771026254,
-0.0975583643,
0.0590150766,
-0.4539411068,
-0.3229471147,
-0.2764448524,
-0.3140870929,
0.1186652929,
-0.1848041266,
0.4815789759,
0.6997810602,
-0.0726527125,
-0.3124491274,
-0.4015944898,
0.2093573809,
-0.3280875981,
-0.6572397351,
0.5231868029,
0.0897752717,
-0.2762254477,
0.153679356,
-0.1504220366,
-0.4207788408,
0.3042446673,
0.2348313481,
-0.0070074098,
-0.1967872679,
0.319799453,
-0.066675283,
-0.2233435959,
-0.2542588413,
0.215993017,
0.8342715502,
-0.2259025872,
-0.1441409439,
-1.0188535452,
0.4374355376,
0.4117901325,
-0.3881087899,
0.6251106262,
0.6558479667,
-0.5148337483,
-0.0597241446,
-0.4054015577,
-0.310587883,
-0.5506563187,
0.4541667402,
-0.3637059629,
-0.5608375669,
0.6063453555,
0.0035965389,
-0.2805097699,
0.2198872715,
0.3249120414,
-0.028915124,
0.6365318298,
0.7699441314,
-0.8151581287,
0.7819653153,
-0.2518531084,
-0.0148767298,
-0.6038038731,
0.4084148705,
-0.4417666793,
-0.2559933066,
-0.5592395663,
-0.4157337844,
-0.2326534539,
0.1238533556,
0.2235941738,
0.4987834394,
-0.3458382785,
0.2316740304,
0.1592086703,
0.5089963675,
0.2326835096,
0.3792771995,
0.2219022512,
0.1965568811,
-0.4264217615,
-0.566124022,
0.6267738938,
0.3103112578,
0.3253152072,
0.2227272391,
0.9502883554,
0.8158537745,
0.4977780581,
-0.7123780251,
0.8554174304,
-0.2870504558,
-0.4546613693,
-0.5946044922,
-0.3574139476,
-0.811591506,
0.3665424883,
-0.2796404958,
-0.9458273053,
0.285335809,
-0.1551023573,
0.0620741025,
0.3758101463,
-0.2354220599,
0.6320898533,
0.1057471931,
-0.3040344119,
-0.4289381206,
-0.0920553952,
0.0461678468,
-0.1255895644,
0.1705332845,
-0.5211983323,
0.0540529639,
1.0238724947,
-0.1634296328,
0.7925817966,
-0.2435445637,
0.1100713611,
0.6103082299,
-0.1590439379,
0.4977852404,
-0.0040996647,
-0.1985544115,
0.0505150966,
-0.3549127579,
-0.3712684214,
-0.4737537503,
0.3827403486,
-0.5083609819,
-0.7073676586,
-0.2786973715,
-0.3430944681,
-0.0445831008,
0.1147052795,
-0.2015443891,
0.3893382847,
-0.5567948222,
0.2042851001,
0.1232222095,
-0.1866482943,
0.5336600542,
0.7774649262,
-0.2815428376,
-0.1754565537,
1.3109328747,
-0.009597633,
-0.2406461686,
0.4472564459,
0.3259653747,
0.1793982089,
-0.5407190323,
-0.0182576403,
0.3620793521,
-0.2830285132,
0.056132786,
-0.8898037672,
-0.0697025508,
-0.3163012564,
-0.1132824868,
-0.1159849986,
0.0590777881,
-0.3891413212,
0.0580177382,
0.5324543118,
0.2037858665,
0.0367137566,
0.6140803099,
-0.6475028992,
0.7851478457,
0.0751771331,
0.1442288905,
0.2490528673,
-0.233447358,
0.1468126029,
-0.0582109019,
-0.2040634155,
-1.1611912251,
0.4167364836,
0.2155654281,
0.5905841589,
0.8232908249,
-0.1142569557,
0.5147809386,
-0.2746967375,
0.2521573901,
0.1350266337,
-0.9371046424,
0.5676909685,
-0.2986950278,
-0.1839471757,
0.4333768487,
0.4613952339,
-0.9098504782,
-0.2846294343,
-0.5677434206,
-0.3969371021,
0.6346724033,
0.369034946,
0.3384549618,
-0.4161853492,
0.5117695928,
-0.5445335507,
0.2296604067,
-0.5052043796,
-0.2204073817,
0.1924645603,
-0.0641894341,
-0.0791180953,
-0.362811625,
0.4305838346,
-0.1348489523,
0.4964076579,
-0.1108215898,
0.5952817202,
0.0898155421,
0.0432415716,
-0.0762217119,
0.0833710954,
0.1805999279,
0.7171504498,
-0.4058094323,
-0.1991327256,
-0.0960057378,
-0.3666836321,
0.1912254989,
-0.0771272406,
-0.0258031525,
0.0382431261,
0.3120352328,
0.4376802444,
-0.0519859195,
-0.3056745529,
0.5470595956,
-0.0845937058,
0.0478772782,
-0.2009100318,
0.3329089284,
0.3540572524,
0.3256734312,
0.5262634754,
-0.2207196206,
0.2052212805,
-0.8471037149,
0.6637765169,
0.46011132,
-0.7369219065,
-0.3625636399,
0.0363472737,
0.1983358711,
-0.784090519,
0.2530917525,
-0.5092437267,
-0.9235010147,
0.9390319586,
0.5016945004,
0.747794807,
-0.2239173949,
0.4920497239,
0.0259022266,
0.048730094,
-0.0739983544,
0.6949526072,
-0.1402504444,
-1.38225317,
-0.136707589,
-0.454211086,
-0.0764547065,
0.1092413217,
-0.4288231432,
0.3740162551,
-0.2848182023,
-0.1433245987,
0.5227895379,
0.3751643002,
-0.1168707088,
0.0668001845,
-0.1056252718,
0.9071738124,
-1.1758164167,
1.0815609694,
0.7225561738,
-0.277520895,
-0.3923413754,
0.3267690837,
0.2279669046,
-0.5512800813,
0.6515167952,
0.0580552444,
-0.121154286,
0.0238604508,
-0.3125335574,
-0.579631269,
1.0634593964,
-0.4229416847,
-0.2475584149,
0.0231375638,
-0.2623454034,
0.4489356279,
-0.5813910365,
-0.4134606421,
0.1411174983,
0.1919075847,
0.0661336556,
-0.3587374985,
0.1741867214,
-0.3287807703,
0.004959756,
0.2731728852,
-0.7074330449,
0.8566412926,
0.3210217357,
-0.3182557225,
0.1741408706,
1.1639180183,
0.4487626553,
0.6358892918,
0.6943506002,
-0.0359017439,
0.6815787554,
0.3334824443,
0.6895022392,
-0.4405159354,
0.3636439145,
0.5847843885,
-0.2647924423,
0.6318563223,
0.2866174877,
-0.2377660424,
0.2818363309,
0.557674408,
-0.0442488529,
0.6828417778,
0.4032554328,
-0.0350000896,
-0.1700091809,
-0.1868032515,
-0.1315435022,
0.7061281204,
0.726421833,
-0.5275173783,
-0.221170783,
-0.133442238,
0.0018601023,
0.3396905363,
-0.3143931925,
0.6885956526,
0.1637927145,
-0.1951381713,
0.2527529001,
0.4385296404,
1.0106642246,
-0.4987612963,
-0.1248074025,
-0.1381621808,
0.0635175183,
0.1966642737,
-0.3592560589,
0.4480860233,
-0.1209755838,
-0.2350760847,
0.3147773445,
1.2949533463,
-0.2317668945,
-0.4803871512,
0.2290741801,
0.7757730484,
0.3082659245,
-0.3653247952,
-0.8030270338,
-0.1005737931,
0.0065928032,
-0.0761348903,
0.197847411,
0.5331721306,
-0.1768204868,
0.5742973089,
0.7040714025,
0.367172122,
-0.7404441237,
-0.3705269992,
0.8418012261,
-0.649944663,
-0.9689770341,
-0.9336519837,
-0.3049061596,
-0.4739297926,
-0.1552734226,
0.5090315938,
0.2328585088,
0.1789397895,
0.2653994262,
0.4480269551,
-0.1208954304,
0.6907715201,
-0.4177433848,
1.1087696552,
-0.5741173029,
0.1476291567,
-0.9154279232,
-0.7834239006,
-0.0232181977,
0.9116558433,
-0.3860386908,
-0.3057376146,
0.4925819337,
1.0310531855,
-0.3511295617,
0.3719469607,
0.345158875,
-0.0691927299,
0.2232336849,
0.1598722339,
0.6831379533,
-0.2732292414,
0.0753310472,
-0.1595775336,
-0.4460340142,
-0.2304747254,
-0.661708951,
-1.2809820175,
-0.7994369864,
-0.2717024088,
-0.3175959289,
0.2055631876,
1.0276106596,
0.5968883038,
-0.833820343,
-0.3315586746,
-0.2093160152,
0.3588024378,
-0.259182781,
-0.2154651433,
0.8109019995,
0.0763862357,
-0.3500897884,
0.3293795884,
0.1639320701,
-0.0945249721,
-0.1543717682,
0.2165250033,
-0.8437464237,
0.1043107584,
0.4883601367,
0.3262521327,
-0.493122071,
-0.2744072676,
-0.031517446,
0.0103315786,
-0.1351311505,
0.899123311,
-0.4181519151,
0.0607736632,
0.74949193,
0.5107911229,
0.3232673109,
0.1786359102,
0.4093298614,
-0.5976551175,
0.5001459122,
-0.4167420864,
0.4583340287,
0.0808838606,
-0.5032275319,
0.4668247104,
0.6306411624,
-0.0286718607,
-0.5137243271,
0.0207982957,
-0.5684006214,
-0.5768698454,
1.0286028385,
-0.1234868839,
-0.4719361365,
-0.5626975894,
-0.1464108974,
0.417339474,
-0.6571732759,
0.972055316,
0.7239135504,
0.086618349,
0.0722962022,
-0.4408895969,
0.2415541708,
-0.0077269641,
-0.631182909,
0.0152302003,
0.0393212549,
0.339436233,
0.3317858577,
1.1864587069,
0.100431703,
0.2210424542,
-0.36466223,
-0.0689314529,
0.056971021,
-0.3074073493,
0.0054583987,
0.2171917856,
-0.3422239423,
-0.3892009258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13042v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13042v1 | The Secret of Metaphor on Expressing Stronger Emotion | 2023-01-30T16:36:02 | 2023-01-30T16:36:02 | Yucheng Li, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Metaphors are proven to have stronger emotional impact than literal
expressions. Although this conclusion is shown to be promising in benefiting
various NLP applications, the reasons behind this phenomenon are not well
studied. This paper conducts the first study in exploring how metaphors convey
stronger emotion than their literal counterparts. We find that metaphors are
generally more specific than literal expressions. The more specific property of
metaphor can be one of the reasons for metaphors' superiority in emotion
expression. When we compare metaphors with literal expressions with the same
specificity level, the gap of emotion expressing ability between both reduces
significantly. In addition, we observe specificity is crucial in literal
language as well, as literal language can express stronger emotion by making it
more specific. | [
-0.1321351677,
-0.4578880668,
0.4709114134,
0.5404569507,
-0.4115792513,
0.2729208469,
-0.1602610797,
-0.7689208984,
0.5635375977,
-0.088709347,
-0.1035419405,
-0.0275886282,
-0.931352973,
0.3019282222,
-0.4552172422,
0.8603805304,
-0.0598793589,
0.0461986735,
0.1563263983,
-0.6491874456,
-0.4639520347,
-0.7820548415,
-0.370226711,
-0.3249470294,
0.9106198549,
-0.1617272794,
1.0665040016,
0.7950475812,
1.0202950239,
0.4186937809,
-0.1712879241,
-0.4987971783,
-0.4066631198,
0.1639188975,
-0.3499040902,
-1.0246772766,
0.2541140616,
0.1619915515,
0.5332019925,
0.5725519657,
-0.0388281606,
-0.0140325082,
-0.2980830669,
0.8479338288,
-0.6522102356,
0.4330130517,
-0.8448614478,
0.4923562706,
-0.0633165911,
-0.2635450959,
-0.1046994105,
-0.2841335833,
0.2722239792,
-0.406149298,
-0.1084745377,
0.1955515742,
1.3666933775,
0.245741874,
-0.6731402278,
-0.2740943432,
-0.5545124412,
0.8804488182,
-0.4443507493,
0.1841977537,
-0.036163684,
0.4663320184,
0.1548893005,
-0.9640210271,
-0.651253581,
-0.3693145812,
-0.1140687391,
-0.0265875161,
-0.2628073692,
0.2226729244,
0.7372980714,
0.6008524299,
-0.2565515041,
-0.226240024,
-0.1896628886,
0.045260381,
0.4508230686,
0.1773264408,
0.7179306746,
-0.2054524571,
-0.7925069332,
-0.2988317013,
-0.5017793775,
0.0470121428,
0.0984013453,
0.1743885428,
0.0480392165,
0.4861488044,
-0.0138457445,
0.279489994,
-0.4328683615,
-0.189701274,
0.2843306065,
-0.2317671031,
-0.2219320387,
0.094668746,
0.6491408944,
0.4025859535,
0.5624588132,
-0.4444233477,
0.1104771048,
0.9232598543,
0.2229498774,
-0.7495603561,
0.3521873057,
-0.0445701517,
-0.4451616704,
-0.3576238751,
0.3191245496,
-0.4180108309,
-0.2580473721,
-0.026546184,
0.2752246857,
-0.2510727942,
0.0053372108,
0.4705089331,
-0.7464634776,
0.4943928421,
0.2757956684,
-0.8994600177,
0.5326126814,
0.8345247507,
0.6226273775,
0.0198790375,
-0.2476922721,
-0.0478202216,
0.1072676331,
-0.5273391604,
0.5968694091,
-0.7424049973,
0.3751911223,
-0.0195707362,
-0.2087879032,
-0.0277411956,
-0.4957903326,
0.9625208974,
-0.3944722414,
0.1912301034,
-0.6506701708,
-0.5729313493,
-0.179975152,
0.0173186231,
-0.6038062572,
0.5863518119,
0.052226916,
-0.8805788755,
0.2122240067,
-0.3688623607,
-0.3186341822,
-0.2082946002,
-0.5627040863,
0.0682959333,
0.7525433302,
0.0043630903,
0.2652423084,
-0.5642635822,
0.207599178,
-0.1640555859,
-0.3857257962,
0.560408771,
-0.1213109791,
0.6584999561,
0.2662493587,
-0.6676681638,
-0.3101021945,
-0.0872653946,
0.0969103426,
0.6005113125,
-0.0159191713,
-0.5170431137,
-0.2070757598,
-0.2604758739,
0.5451456904,
0.0208078139,
-0.5490987301,
0.4350212216,
-0.4516224563,
0.1761500537,
0.6236749291,
-0.1820941269,
0.4231539667,
-0.3965626657,
0.8572665453,
-0.0997937322,
0.0157553647,
-0.2886962295,
-0.5995200872,
-0.5456460118,
-0.207051754,
0.6426844001,
0.6334071755,
-0.3516048193,
0.2333755791,
-0.2433208823,
-0.2948815823,
-0.7187117934,
-0.110423401,
0.6262108684,
0.4303259254,
0.0877625942,
-0.4227500558,
-0.3397735059,
-1.1776590347,
-0.8692741394,
-0.4262498617,
-0.0840728283,
0.2317217439,
0.4019073546,
0.1667293757,
0.7434879541,
-0.519553721,
-0.4007328153,
-0.3086564243,
0.1502616256,
0.0040935925,
0.1109969988,
1.1277096272,
-1.0528361797,
-0.3412330747,
-0.1782797575,
-1.1204758883,
-0.1772455871,
-0.4050708115,
-0.0620219894,
-0.5129580498,
-0.0338617265,
-0.8533238769,
0.5823258162,
0.3604130745,
-0.6763859391,
0.6600487828,
0.1169913337,
0.0983657986,
-0.5769130588,
-0.2858862281,
-0.2230616808,
0.0663125664,
-0.6367861032,
0.5418192744,
-0.0494605489,
-0.1017101333,
-0.7625283599,
0.8306376338,
-0.4157860577,
0.0956384316,
-0.0921156034,
-0.1212507337,
0.2555546761,
0.2817713022,
0.1375580728,
0.2525377274,
0.8824511766,
-0.3908159435,
0.6109122634,
0.0801189542,
-0.1874426454,
0.1378020942,
-0.7664369345,
-0.04637466,
-0.0531864055,
0.2714245617,
-0.5457023382,
-0.0485353507,
0.0788098052,
-0.4125776887,
0.373187691,
0.4555214047,
-0.7765243649,
-0.3548441529,
-0.4415111542,
0.2767797709,
0.7012479901,
-0.4350198209,
0.4180144668,
0.0002189472,
0.1786284894,
-0.8149773479,
-0.8668268323,
0.427664876,
-0.572706461,
-0.7828706503,
0.4183944464,
-0.0808946267,
-0.65528512,
-0.3285747468,
-0.5632321239,
-0.1240584254,
0.1404902339,
0.2554017603,
-0.515435338,
-0.0562328286,
0.3670767546,
0.0192453321,
-0.210844934,
0.3871084452,
0.4301483631,
0.1701915562,
-0.6575577855,
-0.2626211941,
-0.7314199209,
0.4608825743,
0.6814858913,
0.1850091368,
1.0096083879,
0.3962276578,
-0.4479053617,
-0.0297237467,
-0.572396934,
-0.6021108031,
-0.5335801244,
0.0832087547,
-0.4802780747,
-0.6262716055,
0.608905077,
-0.4151786268,
-0.3407042325,
0.3973525167,
0.0511265062,
-0.2120556235,
0.8686752915,
0.599331975,
-0.2670478523,
0.4153485,
0.0153352655,
0.3911509216,
-0.6084039807,
-0.0051029669,
-0.8077038527,
-0.7501829863,
-0.4440239668,
-0.3210406899,
-0.181464389,
0.3585968018,
0.1963604689,
0.2315609157,
-0.3798593581,
0.4788211882,
0.2660596967,
-0.2433236688,
0.1482167095,
0.2790571749,
-0.1757089347,
-0.6569827199,
-0.6790394783,
-0.770155251,
0.5656068921,
0.7233290672,
0.6143834591,
0.0858340934,
0.6076547503,
-0.0319831111,
0.1509843618,
-0.6282583475,
0.7171353698,
0.2467674762,
-0.5967808962,
-0.0984076634,
-0.2969796956,
-1.2217524052,
0.2543997169,
-0.2610619366,
-0.8240725994,
-0.0533655733,
-0.0464781374,
0.1489269286,
0.1915643215,
-0.7817255259,
0.8153067231,
-0.3624264002,
-0.0418296382,
-0.1660863757,
-0.9383932948,
0.0742016658,
0.0661465675,
0.1602778286,
-0.1032264233,
-0.3601758778,
0.771707356,
-0.5925199986,
0.5118815303,
0.1541212052,
0.0679893866,
0.3360782862,
0.2765577137,
0.5998160243,
-0.1569546461,
-0.1660668403,
0.2404178679,
-0.3739801049,
-0.4853149354,
-1.4462606907,
0.4152874649,
-0.3811681569,
-0.8525511026,
-0.5589986444,
-0.5134681463,
0.1067527086,
-0.2110030055,
0.1624685824,
-0.031057287,
0.179781571,
0.2372800261,
0.4387332797,
-0.3884614706,
0.2483570874,
0.2439525127,
-0.2023903728,
0.0530174896,
0.7095041275,
0.1170259193,
0.2820346057,
0.5577080846,
0.808637023,
-0.0180811919,
-0.0240448248,
0.0775618628,
0.5041072965,
-0.7373560667,
-0.1535986215,
-0.7479529977,
0.0524065159,
-0.2830821574,
-0.5988823175,
-0.4933664203,
-0.9238199592,
0.2832113504,
-0.5212337375,
0.6154190302,
0.523321867,
-0.0209868178,
0.1775278598,
-0.5142400861,
0.7086069584,
0.7344779372,
0.1770651489,
-0.2248553634,
-0.2824160457,
0.268796742,
-0.3441872895,
-0.0813566297,
-1.5748735666,
0.4405157864,
0.0873868912,
0.1977513134,
0.9722937346,
0.2174527645,
0.6529960632,
-0.2443314344,
0.9561207891,
0.4599789083,
-1.0875576735,
0.6061418653,
-0.3793077469,
0.1531325877,
0.2356494069,
0.3387617171,
-0.5100902915,
-0.7254726887,
-1.2598969936,
-0.9625368714,
0.3467082381,
0.818105042,
0.6120517254,
-0.1667592674,
0.5158829689,
-0.052548416,
0.5683663487,
-1.0047768354,
-0.8397902846,
0.1668624431,
0.1032309085,
0.1578262746,
-0.3607019782,
-0.2089164108,
-0.5031847358,
0.0182671491,
0.4030049443,
0.6275632977,
0.0674032792,
0.1166559905,
0.0101501895,
0.3277393878,
0.3662732244,
0.2848462164,
-0.0561730564,
0.4762775302,
0.4151352942,
-0.250677079,
0.0593032725,
-0.2461993992,
0.1456636786,
0.5844330192,
0.7492516637,
0.9609561563,
0.1775348634,
-0.7688792944,
0.7397320271,
-0.1392838508,
-0.0058897845,
0.2026004493,
0.0745565072,
0.153460905,
0.2686630189,
0.4745638072,
-0.2382934988,
0.2194044441,
-0.8571203947,
-0.1776807457,
0.4265200794,
-0.1852227449,
-0.2714449167,
0.5517316461,
0.0428117327,
-0.3081590533,
0.3752756417,
-0.1302100569,
-0.8955184817,
1.1177996397,
0.81513834,
0.6179968715,
-0.4538376927,
0.1624906957,
0.2208799124,
0.5578787327,
0.0751902983,
0.4470775723,
-0.0903673992,
-0.558054328,
-0.0458501987,
-0.5479680896,
-0.2913034558,
0.0582804903,
-0.5955942273,
-0.0521719791,
-0.3614757955,
-0.3785912097,
-0.2606122792,
-0.118530713,
-0.8582628369,
0.5916891694,
-0.015986627,
1.0103068352,
-1.1101197004,
0.4413017333,
0.5764566064,
-0.3587146997,
-1.2083511353,
-0.2384423167,
-0.4268401861,
-0.2869268656,
1.2604860067,
0.5683885217,
0.1352182329,
-0.4097493589,
-0.6195296645,
-0.7752463222,
0.7015228271,
0.8447901011,
-0.4152036011,
-0.3051528037,
0.4016129375,
1.0380997658,
-0.3993914723,
0.2999710143,
0.0508236438,
0.72503227,
-0.1492539495,
-0.904532969,
0.3031059206,
-0.1467741281,
0.2564190328,
0.0554637052,
-0.5088433623,
0.6318051219,
-0.2952192724,
-0.4307759404,
-0.18384929,
0.836758852,
0.0753026456,
0.3581413329,
0.0412188321,
0.6405581832,
0.5588257909,
-0.3210651875,
1.5325101614,
-0.2582511604,
0.0481993333,
0.8391216993,
-0.1010044888,
0.5274434686,
0.6335040927,
-0.1173208207,
0.6401764154,
0.198007375,
0.1553635448,
0.4423646927,
0.6622837782,
-0.3435445726,
-0.0037492549,
-0.3446124494,
-0.7051328421,
0.4674222767,
0.3998680413,
-0.7614932656,
-0.1868992448,
0.069740206,
0.2905887067,
0.129695192,
-0.2318295538,
0.4744124115,
0.4769182503,
-0.2946226895,
0.4168006182,
-0.0207788385,
0.4689411819,
-0.7346776724,
-0.0366333835,
0.014428216,
-0.1435779184,
-0.1099423319,
-0.5446259379,
0.4720725417,
-0.1098696589,
0.0697399452,
-0.3722438812,
1.0067163706,
0.0338219553,
0.0545681752,
0.5276761651,
0.4703436196,
0.337438345,
-0.3469362557,
-0.8011380434,
0.1963312924,
-0.4215969741,
-0.6141966581,
0.3517592847,
0.8448286057,
-0.0829804018,
0.7131037712,
0.4216405749,
0.2906109095,
0.1965963095,
0.0491412207,
0.6534649134,
-0.8659349084,
-0.346879065,
-0.7880598903,
0.4253124893,
-0.0499489047,
-0.0917825103,
0.9032433629,
0.2418062687,
0.4114413559,
-0.3562768698,
0.5719149113,
0.0755181462,
-0.2022804022,
-0.2111531198,
0.5334486961,
-0.3792881668,
-0.1423417181,
-0.7049457431,
-1.071587801,
-0.5142980218,
0.9054561257,
-0.1976795793,
0.0921037868,
1.2296361923,
0.245521009,
0.3738880455,
-0.0875857249,
0.4280914366,
0.3083785176,
-0.1481339335,
0.457996577,
1.0697575808,
-0.6928827763,
0.2030001581,
-0.4204966128,
-0.1038843617,
-0.0009104662,
-1.1946913004,
-0.8512946367,
-0.3674244583,
-0.6535753608,
-0.332747072,
0.2154883593,
0.5892973542,
0.462546587,
-0.2301762104,
0.0063396459,
-0.0868835077,
0.3823128343,
-0.5927764773,
-0.3003830612,
0.3334151804,
-0.3060643971,
-0.6008604169,
0.1240143478,
0.4914809763,
0.211410746,
0.2136582285,
-0.04773321,
0.0899648145,
0.5997716784,
0.5377525091,
0.4674924612,
-0.7899640799,
-0.2988639772,
-0.4400304258,
-0.300825268,
0.0933904275,
0.7586773634,
-0.9741868973,
0.3631187379,
0.6941305995,
0.4202124774,
0.0265852083,
-0.0765960887,
0.6344147921,
-0.8027482033,
0.2779547274,
0.2590182424,
0.5108328462,
0.0684856698,
-0.4098851979,
0.6535503864,
0.2928976119,
-0.2181371897,
-0.9084697366,
0.5268767476,
-1.1593325138,
-0.2565998137,
1.2796024084,
-0.1993574649,
-0.1423429251,
0.4195327759,
-0.4488120675,
0.4356579483,
-0.4568926692,
1.1682362556,
0.817820251,
-0.1664418727,
0.2031372637,
-0.3885216117,
0.5676198006,
0.8448799253,
-0.7713313103,
-0.1037404239,
0.0394318439,
-0.1491323411,
0.3240301609,
0.1686956137,
-0.1012950242,
0.2243460417,
0.1180832461,
-0.0750530884,
0.1508281976,
-0.4730681479,
-0.4174257517,
0.5797280669,
-0.0447270535,
-0.0009036231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13039v1 | Representation biases in sentence transformers | 2023-01-30T16:35:23 | 2023-01-30T16:35:23 | Dmitry Nikolaev, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL | Variants of the BERT architecture specialised for producing full-sentence
representations often achieve better performance on downstream tasks than
sentence embeddings extracted from vanilla BERT. However, there is still little
understanding of what properties of inputs determine the properties of such
representations. In this study, we construct several sets of sentences with
pre-defined lexical and syntactic structures and show that SOTA sentence
transformers have a strong nominal-participant-set bias: cosine similarities
between pairs of sentences are more strongly determined by the overlap in the
set of their noun participants than by having the same predicates, lengthy
nominal modifiers, or adjuncts. At the same time, the precise
syntactic-thematic functions of the participants are largely irrelevant. | [
-0.6754280329,
-0.7836181521,
0.7595757842,
0.3656249046,
0.0361519605,
-0.1632331759,
-0.2334266007,
-0.5020624399,
0.502497673,
0.3522196412,
-0.8465908766,
0.0451448485,
-0.6490992308,
0.0657368451,
-0.4686317444,
1.1339045763,
0.0469914898,
0.2193973064,
-0.279540658,
-0.1787279099,
-0.3847904801,
-0.7153598666,
0.2709145546,
-0.2939566672,
0.3438489139,
0.2742267549,
1.1335881948,
0.0935488567,
0.4026925862,
0.2392075658,
0.0192157123,
-0.2593276799,
-0.3097206056,
0.2182161361,
-0.3855387568,
-0.4733552337,
0.0976370499,
0.0333247297,
0.5629720092,
0.8721336722,
0.2905800939,
0.2248027772,
0.2667201459,
0.3286824524,
-0.4786747098,
0.4501585364,
-0.4155801237,
0.0881814957,
-0.2648635507,
-0.0198067185,
-0.5601231456,
-0.2769478559,
0.6467225552,
-0.4494748116,
0.4966156185,
0.0145530654,
1.1973310709,
0.2353658378,
-0.4711193144,
-0.2996340394,
-0.8340838552,
0.643243432,
-0.4426473975,
0.2571412027,
0.154470861,
0.2194481194,
-0.1816670597,
-0.5117254257,
-0.4681455195,
-0.3670161664,
-0.478913039,
0.1665214896,
0.0725652501,
0.2081353068,
0.3647824526,
0.2891968191,
-0.3239381313,
0.1070480943,
-0.2402968556,
-0.1788124591,
0.401860714,
-0.1111349538,
0.2169140726,
-0.6412602067,
-0.4750949144,
-0.3357413709,
-0.728815496,
0.0202506352,
0.668395102,
0.3045346737,
0.050183285,
0.6972361803,
0.237624675,
0.3135101199,
0.2103277147,
0.4640951753,
0.3017301261,
-0.3794406354,
-0.0197036397,
0.2325128913,
0.770852387,
-0.100059554,
0.5456113815,
-0.2275076956,
-0.0299291946,
0.1974501759,
0.5675638914,
-0.3459194601,
-0.0990469381,
-0.0904113725,
-0.6283577681,
-0.0387881808,
0.3937290311,
-0.5230829716,
0.0576719083,
-0.2351732701,
0.5662510991,
-0.5119162202,
0.1783498675,
-0.0672176704,
-0.3739646673,
0.3352742791,
-0.0862984136,
-1.1581909657,
0.5108471513,
0.6092628241,
0.2996512651,
-0.0471288115,
-0.3054394424,
-0.4096057713,
0.0424676016,
-0.2493752688,
0.8195700645,
-0.88826859,
-0.1934439242,
0.2994591296,
-0.0930552781,
0.0533666499,
-0.4985539317,
0.5969523191,
-0.6242203712,
0.5179671645,
-0.573325634,
-0.6983204484,
0.0936885625,
-0.2949368358,
-0.8136315942,
0.9670927525,
0.3508333564,
-0.7583464384,
0.6973312497,
-0.3747765422,
-0.7173039913,
-0.2367794365,
-0.7597786188,
-0.3735355139,
0.4536950588,
0.3455183506,
0.5116649866,
-0.0718302801,
0.4579496086,
-0.0768740997,
-0.5224708319,
0.3126363754,
-0.0701544955,
0.8100388646,
-0.0636907667,
-0.4778763354,
0.2108940035,
-0.618853569,
-0.350638032,
-0.137822628,
-0.1757556051,
-0.3971190453,
0.1784097403,
0.2155510783,
0.1032755226,
0.1985475123,
-0.4651204646,
0.2149000466,
-0.4168055654,
0.4345806837,
0.9288110733,
-0.0642836243,
0.7415304184,
-0.2067543864,
0.4253940582,
0.1392992139,
0.0137932468,
-0.2448033988,
-0.5010181069,
-0.7360402942,
-0.2378678024,
0.4855960011,
0.1804941297,
-0.8905989528,
0.7554132342,
-0.3288730085,
-0.0400072113,
-0.5335869193,
-0.2302818745,
0.2638497949,
0.1097924635,
0.3025359213,
-0.2415985763,
-0.8692862391,
-1.4648844004,
-0.3720464408,
-0.1410686076,
-0.1620002091,
0.2766244709,
0.4405056834,
0.0915606841,
1.278416276,
-0.531644702,
-0.2976748049,
-0.3920621276,
0.2177466303,
0.2911199033,
0.3412106931,
0.8138549924,
-0.5731388927,
-0.4147219062,
-0.5704687238,
-0.5793101192,
-0.1862358749,
-0.4391868412,
-0.0533816442,
-0.0170460753,
0.5288988352,
-0.8901110888,
0.4310893416,
0.4040159285,
-0.5126115084,
0.6041360497,
0.0438776277,
-0.3043255508,
-0.9196279645,
-0.2154745907,
-0.1059372947,
-0.3222354949,
-0.4946124852,
0.2060385048,
-0.114184536,
0.1460031122,
-0.2941280007,
0.0470444933,
-0.2648410797,
-0.5050032735,
0.3281334937,
0.0515801534,
0.0338808782,
0.7118138075,
0.0870275348,
0.7772456408,
0.4046934545,
-0.5036507845,
-0.0244943518,
0.4503058493,
-0.5633204579,
0.2025064528,
-0.7135462761,
-0.0824827328,
-0.2405326068,
0.3595270514,
-0.8718237281,
-0.0698939934,
-0.0185323786,
-0.2838456929,
0.169021368,
0.1911530197,
-0.7342272997,
-0.1700723022,
-0.2951471508,
0.2609152794,
0.6600981355,
-0.3721845448,
0.4854519069,
-0.0466466695,
-0.0601071715,
-0.5687058568,
-0.819455862,
-0.2565305531,
0.1073885337,
-0.573364675,
0.6064832807,
0.3335054815,
-0.2729771137,
0.2119030803,
-0.1237660646,
0.1723415107,
-0.2644569576,
0.2501328886,
0.265373528,
-0.3799169958,
0.4699560404,
0.0792151615,
0.097015202,
0.1718432605,
-0.0816512629,
0.8357569575,
0.1841606051,
-0.3701750934,
-0.2541108131,
0.45629403,
0.3194249868,
0.0106952386,
0.8666092157,
0.4826000035,
0.0274600983,
-0.1355107576,
-0.4450949728,
-0.4490387142,
-0.4533358812,
0.434651494,
-0.5278268456,
-1.0980635881,
0.6387349367,
0.4809525311,
-0.1072074175,
0.6550737619,
0.5907192826,
-0.3870886862,
0.6159507632,
0.3761190176,
0.0170927178,
0.6591723561,
-0.1236470789,
0.468927443,
-0.6312505007,
-0.0709828809,
-0.5995067358,
-0.5351388454,
-0.8534741402,
-0.217874825,
0.2566101849,
-0.2636516392,
-0.3823014498,
0.4872575998,
-0.3207497299,
0.2218698412,
0.8917578459,
0.1641266644,
-0.1064036936,
0.0250395052,
-0.1728274971,
-0.3593921065,
-0.5900114775,
-0.7156774998,
0.9826644659,
0.3831991255,
0.7095216513,
0.0871301815,
0.6081753969,
0.3849573433,
-0.2820321321,
-0.680515945,
0.485180378,
-0.2761878073,
-0.8511024117,
-0.1314715147,
-0.1426079571,
-0.9720873833,
0.012766717,
-0.3719432652,
-0.804815352,
0.5888752341,
-0.2222689837,
-0.4141023159,
-0.0925544351,
-0.8659732342,
0.7241284251,
0.1933796406,
-0.1502612829,
-0.1522553563,
-0.718572557,
0.0236277245,
0.2063478529,
-0.239414528,
0.0153078698,
0.265001148,
0.7217416763,
-0.4483798444,
0.7687520981,
-0.071921289,
0.1198273227,
0.4761568606,
-0.0090318127,
0.2763034701,
-0.0379436426,
0.0378268622,
0.1211969703,
-0.0766818449,
-0.5391754508,
-0.7267546058,
0.3245295584,
-0.9793887138,
-0.9092111588,
-0.3953596652,
-0.4954375625,
-0.2758888304,
0.0489001684,
0.4440875947,
0.5434838533,
-0.3971048892,
0.3141157329,
0.5478438139,
-0.315379858,
0.5219199657,
-0.0459918454,
-0.1518290788,
0.2790040672,
0.2865906358,
0.2387048751,
0.4015194774,
0.5290613174,
-0.066474475,
-0.0609472096,
-0.1015026867,
-0.3386791646,
-0.0562823676,
-0.6145803928,
0.0482389703,
-0.7579523325,
-0.5259513855,
-0.4304449558,
-0.1950408667,
-0.2537093163,
-0.7598757744,
-0.3401409388,
-0.3041457534,
0.189826116,
0.8769674301,
0.1154925004,
0.4986958504,
-0.5735396147,
0.4259689152,
0.4976840019,
0.1327051073,
0.0437128246,
-0.4300637841,
-0.1555983573,
-0.1847244352,
-0.4468849301,
-1.0250502825,
-0.042893637,
0.196302712,
0.546135366,
0.5139120221,
-0.0721206516,
0.4798216224,
-0.7584471107,
1.1582570076,
0.0477656014,
-1.1119642258,
0.5824561715,
-0.257535696,
0.2625686824,
0.5270208716,
0.3706836104,
-0.0193318948,
-0.5010765195,
-0.8386724591,
-0.6655079722,
0.9496795535,
0.5577474833,
0.517990768,
-0.2627874613,
0.3253136575,
0.3985287547,
0.1393275559,
-0.7565202713,
-0.2646268308,
-0.287654072,
-0.2478149682,
0.0336106755,
-0.5680561066,
0.0323475674,
-0.094979167,
0.2284876555,
0.1010647491,
0.6665002704,
0.298955977,
-0.1072296947,
0.178767994,
0.4998634458,
0.2387562245,
0.5165652037,
-0.36308074,
0.4681628644,
-0.0706797466,
-0.3861034513,
0.104122214,
-0.0235230923,
-0.2094874531,
0.3509370387,
0.8524472117,
0.7047685385,
0.3109234571,
-0.6039084196,
0.6870103478,
0.2037730515,
0.0393004008,
-0.2838472426,
0.0994502455,
-0.086920239,
0.3204059601,
0.3956876993,
0.293890357,
0.3282676041,
-1.2345805168,
0.2545066476,
0.2627664506,
-0.5582009554,
-0.5420073271,
0.4005018473,
-0.0335864276,
-0.24519822,
0.7337462902,
-0.1233021691,
-0.6804423928,
0.6206110716,
0.5227755904,
0.8840510249,
-0.0409502089,
0.2364687771,
0.1038791984,
0.325738132,
0.0645442754,
0.3275741935,
-0.0396991707,
-0.9365003705,
-0.5411031842,
-0.4682741463,
-0.0462757871,
-0.2462736219,
-0.9547778368,
0.328365773,
-0.3377564251,
-0.2915983498,
0.2214832306,
-0.4152864814,
-0.824346602,
-0.0137525611,
0.0359978378,
0.7434429526,
-1.0468552113,
0.7054665685,
0.6871390939,
-0.7030139565,
-0.6852439642,
0.2886434793,
-0.4636149406,
-0.6221981645,
1.0682144165,
0.0987317413,
0.2724389732,
-0.5342721939,
-0.4643657804,
-0.8396258354,
0.5485231876,
0.6000164151,
-0.4845319986,
-0.5190965533,
0.4326335788,
0.805544138,
-0.4515706599,
0.2632318735,
0.5448284745,
0.4099967778,
-0.118987672,
-1.0429232121,
0.045352459,
0.1610931456,
0.1991827488,
0.0889240429,
-0.6253224015,
0.8290856481,
0.3149777949,
-0.1380712837,
-0.1882507652,
0.7529815435,
-0.0070719621,
-0.1680155993,
0.3211992085,
0.5290076137,
0.1936444342,
-0.3285275996,
1.1261235476,
0.0261504706,
0.2652475238,
1.2033182383,
-0.0980556756,
0.7729156613,
0.6872644424,
-0.3230038285,
0.9868627787,
0.4209091067,
-0.0838908106,
0.7413925529,
0.1786122024,
0.1713808328,
-0.2057863623,
-0.1139053181,
-0.193106249,
0.6563928723,
0.2461360097,
-0.7065017223,
0.0548041984,
-0.067827113,
-0.0307733119,
0.3443849087,
-0.0224587545,
0.6391462088,
0.1010436043,
-0.797563374,
-0.0173209328,
-0.3103556931,
0.6232529879,
-0.4790328443,
0.0861919969,
0.0632547811,
0.0373766012,
-0.2260609716,
-0.9235506058,
0.597066164,
-0.3017491102,
-0.4046733677,
-0.4891641438,
0.6183914542,
-0.0274267867,
-0.3875345886,
0.2576912045,
0.4903706908,
-0.0901025608,
0.0534876063,
-0.1740695536,
0.0984169394,
-0.0058758627,
-0.3217553496,
0.1619292498,
0.3505426645,
-0.0664110035,
0.1729945093,
0.1667142361,
0.0266119037,
0.2684731483,
0.3194724321,
0.9946522713,
-0.7745379806,
-0.4877799153,
-0.97787112,
0.2781725824,
-0.1868028343,
-0.2593193054,
0.7517775297,
0.5523579717,
0.877359271,
-0.3041472435,
0.6552829146,
-0.1938258857,
0.1275996864,
-0.5893548727,
0.4087218344,
-0.0889299214,
0.1413443387,
-0.2923403382,
-1.4636312723,
0.0079800859,
0.9006060958,
-0.4702673554,
0.1758181006,
0.882837534,
0.4970332384,
-0.1625428945,
0.1703174561,
0.0470821112,
0.3583148122,
0.2887948453,
0.4083699584,
1.0491764545,
-0.4825814962,
0.2946254313,
0.0711580589,
0.0317081437,
-0.3167331815,
-0.5864520073,
-1.1182732582,
-0.6918330193,
-0.1324326694,
-0.2612926364,
-0.0187769979,
0.8963053823,
0.8138951063,
-0.8757673502,
0.0239001215,
-0.1046240628,
0.0337722823,
-0.2967879474,
-0.34336707,
0.6297206283,
-0.6192612052,
-0.7706474066,
-0.041697491,
0.3479628861,
-0.2882805765,
-0.5571841598,
0.3226478398,
-0.3942134082,
0.40205881,
0.5208895802,
-0.2968457043,
-0.8932760954,
-0.721323967,
0.1337759644,
-0.215019986,
0.2991851568,
0.9568972588,
-0.9799368382,
0.4547397792,
0.7143645883,
0.3920775652,
0.5657120943,
-0.1564193964,
0.7687492371,
-1.1748920679,
0.3458715975,
0.3295503855,
0.4795719087,
0.0304212756,
-0.3813119829,
0.3663783371,
-0.1044371575,
-0.3973607421,
-0.4184218645,
0.43591699,
-1.0201156139,
-0.2897791862,
1.0509662628,
-0.1108353958,
-0.1060696617,
-0.1851969808,
-0.2475730032,
0.2914878726,
-0.345469296,
0.7999184728,
1.0866795778,
-0.2487309724,
0.0022760122,
-0.2329900712,
0.4373210371,
0.7627209425,
-0.3554748297,
-0.373568058,
0.4028395116,
-0.0330927446,
0.5142941475,
0.2672615647,
-0.1549192816,
0.0699867383,
0.0970576331,
0.1050165743,
0.3830727935,
-0.1059042215,
0.0371841006,
0.2408253103,
-0.0226594545,
-0.0458577946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13003v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13003v2 | Knowledge Transfer from Pre-trained Language Models to Cif-based Speech Recognizers via Hierarchical Distillation | 2023-01-30T15:44:55 | 2023-05-28T16:13:52 | Minglun Han, Feilong Chen, Jing Shi, Shuang Xu, Bo Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large-scale pre-trained language models (PLMs) have shown great potential in
natural language processing tasks. Leveraging the capabilities of PLMs to
enhance automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems has also emerged as a
promising research direction. However, previous works may be limited by the
inflexible structures of PLMs and the insufficient utilization of PLMs. To
alleviate these problems, we propose the hierarchical knowledge distillation
(HKD) on the continuous integrate-and-fire (CIF) based ASR models. To transfer
knowledge from PLMs to the ASR models, HKD employs cross-modal knowledge
distillation with contrastive loss at the acoustic level and knowledge
distillation with regression loss at the linguistic level. Compared with the
original CIF-based model, our method achieves 15% and 9% relative error rate
reduction on the AISHELL-1 and LibriSpeech datasets, respectively. | [
-0.3147365451,
-0.4320275187,
0.4727122784,
0.037253499,
-0.2100408524,
0.3343230784,
-0.2639831305,
-0.3071816564,
-0.3727424443,
0.4306703508,
-0.2504171133,
-0.3282197118,
-0.7974285483,
-0.1982221156,
-0.5059366822,
0.8753780127,
-0.0940790996,
-0.0108468179,
-0.0521802939,
-0.0693579391,
-0.1054553166,
-0.7338813543,
-0.6880305409,
-0.6237761974,
0.14641729,
0.0964055955,
0.3940952122,
0.4830847681,
0.5485414267,
0.3104979098,
-0.3196511567,
-0.1340664327,
-0.2785660028,
-0.3011412621,
-0.2725518346,
-0.1876682043,
-0.1681016833,
-0.1214769632,
0.5020766854,
0.9235370755,
-0.382329911,
-0.0469616055,
0.5473334193,
0.7205166221,
-0.713891387,
0.3821219206,
-0.7924723029,
-0.0108275348,
-0.1588120908,
-0.2921870053,
-0.2136808187,
-0.3357963264,
0.6345279813,
-0.5625826716,
-0.0690885857,
-0.3190307021,
0.5638156533,
0.4546942711,
-0.4382987916,
-0.5404394269,
-1.226721406,
0.5390613079,
-0.8771951795,
0.4164266288,
0.4888244569,
0.3915944993,
-0.057414405,
-0.857080996,
-0.7057161927,
-0.2588225603,
-0.2637348473,
-0.0246416479,
-0.3094951212,
0.2777909935,
0.0611987747,
0.4432422221,
-0.3602963686,
-0.0037968257,
-0.3215202689,
-0.0490503758,
0.34134835,
-0.1061946079,
0.0465875193,
0.0835140422,
-0.4349204302,
-0.1642305255,
-0.3469652534,
0.2465035915,
-0.1210260987,
0.395197928,
-0.1973485649,
0.1021605283,
-0.0548041724,
0.580786407,
0.4295958877,
-0.7015191913,
0.1814662963,
-0.5795370936,
-0.4280117154,
0.2696657777,
0.7987795472,
-0.0887718871,
0.4033572972,
-0.0790412277,
-0.0535486117,
-0.1695628166,
-0.1616603285,
-0.6378574371,
-0.553976655,
-0.1262166202,
-0.4127932489,
-0.1507234573,
0.0048422143,
-0.2062527239,
-0.2076537162,
-0.5700800419,
0.6746966839,
-0.5840987563,
-0.338206917,
0.2211064249,
-0.3010604084,
-0.0888646618,
0.1452480853,
-0.7256714702,
0.5119453669,
0.3259062767,
0.6461669207,
-0.0429149829,
-0.0734492242,
-0.3916077018,
0.5213857293,
-0.0374790393,
0.4931813478,
-0.3678683937,
-0.5658233166,
-0.186793685,
-0.2639323175,
-0.254299432,
-1.0289566517,
0.3341699541,
-0.4485906363,
-0.1182638109,
-0.1711767465,
-0.5239602923,
-0.3222904503,
0.0150714759,
-0.4948056042,
0.7062973976,
-0.1559113562,
-0.8747802377,
0.4435184002,
-0.6310447454,
-0.6357524395,
-0.0001572266,
-0.1768573076,
-0.211093381,
-0.0376195423,
0.3914340734,
0.271633774,
-0.4128548503,
0.4900101125,
-0.2102123201,
0.0243391227,
0.0052319882,
-0.3947574496,
0.965331614,
0.3763669133,
-0.4843084216,
-0.1346513331,
-0.9247621894,
-0.3027588427,
-0.3760062158,
-0.668076396,
-0.7748389244,
0.0601580739,
0.0064926501,
0.2921624482,
0.2297045738,
-0.3834269345,
-0.1054472849,
-0.0646633431,
0.3492214978,
0.292046845,
0.0327131301,
0.6388542652,
-0.3863455653,
0.1941238642,
0.4322167337,
0.0107983667,
0.1643919945,
0.0287511684,
-0.8324694633,
-0.5140943527,
0.260884285,
0.6623635888,
-1.1850562096,
0.9044566154,
-0.1834060103,
-0.5403382182,
-0.4344946444,
0.1952217966,
0.3828648925,
0.8312013745,
0.4746911526,
0.0066793459,
-0.6300455928,
-0.66418612,
-0.0343412012,
-0.5619316697,
-0.2398204952,
-0.0391106494,
0.2741536796,
-0.1377767324,
0.9800427556,
-0.1401896179,
-0.7443627715,
-0.2409222871,
0.41691342,
0.1348033994,
0.6202873588,
0.3927527666,
-0.652171731,
-0.7168731093,
0.1941046715,
-0.6226985455,
-0.2584507167,
-0.1273881346,
0.1465643644,
-0.1038050875,
0.7332210541,
-0.3491550684,
0.3916278481,
0.624938488,
-0.0666062832,
0.3904683292,
-0.099127844,
0.2992403507,
-1.0575926304,
0.2505414188,
0.0205641408,
-0.1510635167,
-0.7654556036,
-0.4503792226,
-0.0214836877,
0.1603197306,
-0.3133701384,
0.3435521722,
-0.4797038138,
0.0665039942,
-0.3573813736,
-0.1600528955,
-0.0753788874,
0.4066294432,
0.367588073,
0.4946710467,
0.6998836398,
-0.730275929,
0.1849547327,
0.0801238492,
-0.5284506083,
0.3819409311,
-0.5216752887,
-0.0642380491,
0.0255153626,
0.3205620646,
-0.9972854257,
0.21251221,
-0.0614862479,
-0.1857891232,
0.3656743169,
-0.2631410062,
-0.4003968537,
-0.2521721125,
0.1373038739,
0.388060689,
0.6673141122,
-0.6969064474,
0.7399527431,
0.4925940037,
-0.5462623239,
-0.250513345,
-0.7869496346,
-0.0895067528,
-0.4316661358,
-0.5102279186,
0.5514910817,
-0.0536048412,
-0.4124828875,
-0.00760447,
-0.2282934785,
-0.3798047304,
-0.1901434958,
0.0001601503,
0.1824732125,
-0.2817160487,
0.0371669792,
0.1341154426,
-0.0096637486,
0.0250540171,
-0.3475992978,
0.2578170598,
0.0856053159,
-0.344584465,
-0.9398107529,
0.1929519624,
0.8307089806,
-0.1476828754,
0.6422784328,
0.369789362,
-0.3850931525,
-0.0311220977,
-0.8037062287,
-0.0770447031,
-0.4729805589,
0.2147127092,
-0.328371942,
-1.0184276104,
0.5273807645,
-0.3477930725,
-0.0152579276,
0.4060207903,
0.3660133481,
-0.1119664609,
0.8071801662,
0.637013495,
-0.4007902443,
0.5885745883,
-0.0867669433,
0.05490724,
-0.6425831914,
-0.3396292031,
-0.6719578505,
-0.269112587,
-0.1499482989,
-0.4115285277,
0.6197269559,
0.2793067992,
-0.1325736642,
0.287878722,
-0.2218622267,
0.1790423393,
0.5255885124,
-0.0538530163,
0.6657957435,
0.0686269552,
-0.1673375815,
0.0144575993,
-0.7551299334,
-0.1728736907,
0.819588244,
0.5012158751,
1.0130338669,
-0.1375422627,
0.7474627495,
0.232577309,
0.0539704859,
-0.6377668381,
0.1969317496,
-0.6003761292,
-0.3500645459,
-0.4159260988,
-0.5812952518,
-0.3715927899,
0.1482748389,
-0.0214343295,
-0.3541132808,
0.6177690029,
0.1933744252,
-0.6477274299,
0.3545353711,
-0.6778126955,
0.4059438109,
-0.2179488391,
0.1510285884,
-0.1018083394,
-0.5644301772,
0.4166176021,
-0.3058858514,
0.4986107945,
0.1225010753,
0.4245302975,
0.8535985351,
-0.7449614406,
0.573541522,
-0.5750557184,
-0.1398924887,
0.4394702911,
-0.1665172726,
0.526923418,
-0.277027458,
-0.1012602225,
0.1112511903,
0.14390935,
0.2006572634,
-0.5851244926,
0.3945225179,
-0.7403327227,
-0.3528719544,
-0.2108539492,
-0.5226416588,
-0.2286842465,
-0.0771937072,
0.363111645,
0.4352306724,
-0.1299502254,
0.5321840644,
0.7609447241,
-0.0251470841,
0.4860588908,
0.6699152589,
-0.1183179021,
-0.3316653967,
0.4758366942,
0.3656804562,
0.4185291827,
0.4971901774,
0.1910266131,
-0.4461508989,
-0.8200215697,
-0.1376752704,
-0.1719421148,
-0.4317455292,
-0.2000193298,
-0.7491784096,
-0.7384228706,
-0.4994984269,
-0.1258831769,
-0.4393545389,
-0.2934182286,
-0.4877002239,
0.1109232679,
0.34140113,
0.5025534034,
-0.4279217124,
0.5512980819,
-0.993719697,
0.5854520798,
0.6017383337,
0.0260360576,
0.0417358615,
-0.9895986319,
-0.2753974795,
0.1669993252,
0.0544378236,
-0.4968085289,
0.522772193,
0.7028363943,
0.5683479905,
0.4272254109,
0.4257023633,
1.0873845816,
-0.406219691,
0.4069288671,
0.4745013416,
-1.0151270628,
0.3894399107,
-0.1901439726,
0.6481444836,
0.8774223924,
0.5212465525,
-0.1910389662,
-0.4216148257,
-0.222174108,
-0.6240411401,
0.7397397757,
0.2113666385,
-0.3086866736,
0.2952553034,
0.0868691951,
0.1657159328,
-0.0030323537,
-0.46337834,
-0.1953446716,
-0.0559812635,
-0.3013364077,
0.0263210516,
-0.0675229803,
0.028774824,
-0.6887192726,
0.6735229492,
0.132457912,
-0.312838167,
0.1667679101,
-0.2732058167,
0.027881626,
0.3871524632,
0.063042596,
0.3759415746,
-0.1644749939,
0.3899035156,
0.1716319472,
-0.5222980976,
0.2994612455,
0.3660468757,
0.1002073362,
-0.0222146567,
0.228514716,
0.7224436402,
0.2839405835,
-0.3689932823,
0.2722950876,
-0.0281667933,
-0.3659290373,
-0.3641233444,
0.041601859,
0.422098279,
0.5733533502,
0.7020183802,
0.0653115436,
0.5287476778,
-0.6899547577,
0.3868553042,
0.2113765627,
-0.3191764355,
-0.1895147264,
0.5030976534,
0.3400561512,
0.0278631337,
0.5718231797,
0.1424988359,
-0.4060371518,
0.3715317249,
0.452618897,
0.9269271493,
-0.5769254565,
-0.0366049558,
0.3661346734,
0.0713862553,
-0.1666917652,
-0.1257189065,
-0.4581321478,
-0.6805666089,
-0.2565619946,
-0.9393219352,
-0.2199037075,
0.4128719866,
-0.8887863755,
0.1011782885,
-0.4940172136,
-0.239158988,
0.2704369426,
-0.2588461339,
-0.4372093678,
0.1380889714,
0.2568419278,
0.6755155325,
-0.7648718953,
1.3641297817,
0.3456989825,
-0.2091008723,
-0.8771570325,
0.1418714225,
0.0748343989,
-0.4137552083,
0.8800114989,
-0.3524020612,
-0.2807454169,
0.0865809321,
-0.2291855514,
-0.8277204037,
1.118008852,
0.4810989201,
-0.9874190092,
-0.2511050403,
0.3003247082,
0.5689309835,
-0.4444137216,
-0.1607921422,
0.936258018,
0.4005990922,
0.6829707623,
-1.557366848,
-0.3225795329,
-0.2759432197,
0.1272934824,
-0.1449894607,
-0.0301606841,
0.8384054303,
0.0266658105,
-0.3400422335,
-0.1803067774,
0.6194875836,
0.449411124,
0.2411744297,
0.7526333928,
0.4342275262,
0.3934910893,
0.0719500482,
0.4043821394,
-0.1515372247,
0.1035811231,
1.4640752077,
-0.4727815688,
0.9974452257,
0.5584625602,
-0.2773291171,
0.6253876686,
0.1518169045,
0.4121436775,
1.0128314495,
0.046910625,
-0.5763094425,
-0.2290050387,
-0.0778479874,
-0.3715254366,
0.5389556289,
0.4840576649,
-0.3405326605,
-0.3818741441,
0.349401176,
-0.0731446967,
0.1205953956,
-0.2829625607,
1.293397665,
0.2552168667,
-0.459495008,
0.7746003866,
-0.2753030658,
1.0326727629,
-0.8919202685,
-0.0322101936,
0.0748165473,
0.3071429133,
-0.1964148879,
-0.4668874741,
0.6262866855,
0.0473291762,
-0.3765420616,
-0.3505371511,
0.8706800342,
-0.9851128459,
-0.3705463111,
0.5865404606,
0.4022811651,
-0.0682748333,
-0.2657066286,
-0.4731701016,
0.0694180056,
0.0504702777,
0.1351214349,
0.3345293701,
0.4701803625,
0.2708247006,
0.3934019506,
0.6383911967,
0.1651023179,
0.2115900815,
0.0705698356,
1.0142220259,
-0.2006126195,
-0.7268910408,
-0.7353112102,
0.6989204884,
0.1197566539,
0.2764531672,
0.5504521728,
0.2783128321,
0.8444905877,
-0.1052323803,
1.1436710358,
-0.1171699017,
0.76080513,
-0.5490370989,
1.2377333641,
-0.4271221459,
0.3595744967,
-0.3372237384,
-0.699668169,
-0.0271815639,
0.6275287867,
-0.1669741869,
0.0733554885,
0.5403749943,
0.523255527,
-0.0582892932,
-0.1028937027,
0.4875617623,
0.2257052958,
0.2842798233,
0.5676579475,
0.749420166,
-0.2968652248,
0.5408114791,
-0.4437476397,
-0.4326562881,
-0.0937677175,
-0.675118506,
-0.827033937,
-0.9231010675,
-0.4907164574,
0.1702813655,
0.169264853,
0.7723779082,
0.8559499383,
-0.9155941606,
-0.5572983623,
-0.1666235477,
-0.2135509998,
-0.0810672566,
-0.2126228958,
0.3619942963,
-0.1574490815,
-0.4919885397,
0.5596091151,
0.1985535622,
0.2037152648,
-0.0733603537,
-0.1938357502,
-0.4451039433,
-0.0069320025,
0.6454287171,
0.314568907,
-0.5776143074,
-0.253474474,
-0.3426739275,
0.0409771614,
-0.1407600194,
0.7929574847,
-0.9884593487,
0.4345862269,
0.6418578625,
0.5079804659,
0.5107367039,
-0.0061624469,
0.732399106,
-0.6169121861,
0.2153814286,
0.1909217983,
0.3291658759,
0.2582705021,
-0.088907741,
0.164415881,
0.2193088382,
-0.4148409069,
-0.6035235524,
-0.1377624273,
-0.8815625906,
-0.2160970122,
1.1070064306,
-0.3595494628,
0.1191400886,
-0.5416534543,
-0.1578474641,
0.5572776794,
-0.2522280216,
0.7609508038,
0.4856189489,
-0.1199097559,
-0.2417013049,
0.0199863985,
0.7852326632,
0.0786907524,
-0.9200198054,
0.1957641244,
0.4481891096,
0.4047048688,
0.2795040607,
0.7942736745,
-0.2592846155,
0.0627505332,
0.0939149261,
0.1397328228,
-0.2097534835,
-0.5506310463,
-0.3323546946,
0.1884557456,
0.0983978659,
-0.1294768453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12971v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12971v2 | Quantifying Context Mixing in Transformers | 2023-01-30T15:19:02 | 2023-02-08T10:46:38 | Hosein Mohebbi, Willem Zuidema, Grzegorz Chrupała, Afra Alishahi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Self-attention weights and their transformed variants have been the main
source of information for analyzing token-to-token interactions in
Transformer-based models. But despite their ease of interpretation, these
weights are not faithful to the models' decisions as they are only one part of
an encoder, and other components in the encoder layer can have considerable
impact on information mixing in the output representations. In this work, by
expanding the scope of analysis to the whole encoder block, we propose Value
Zeroing, a novel context mixing score customized for Transformers that provides
us with a deeper understanding of how information is mixed at each encoder
layer. We demonstrate the superiority of our context mixing score over other
analysis methods through a series of complementary evaluations with different
viewpoints based on linguistically informed rationales, probing, and
faithfulness analysis. | [
-0.7628005743,
-0.4838828146,
0.2951363027,
0.6300926805,
-0.2991965711,
-0.0814282447,
0.0333284177,
-0.445917666,
0.4259330332,
0.4199171364,
-0.5926381946,
-0.0725166723,
-0.6967763305,
-0.0819238797,
-0.48979491,
1.094389677,
-0.1366728842,
0.0055958112,
-0.2744095922,
-0.6871486306,
-0.9383187294,
-0.7040118575,
-0.2874549627,
-0.4846347272,
0.3885167539,
0.3056135774,
0.7332877517,
0.6236031651,
0.370965153,
0.236565724,
-0.0966116935,
-0.3566027284,
-0.6382126808,
0.3707431257,
-0.341440022,
-0.1411396712,
-0.5743253231,
0.1875551492,
0.4232018292,
0.5896353722,
0.0355270728,
0.3674816489,
0.0534178577,
0.2909670174,
-1.0265176296,
0.119117856,
-0.491664201,
0.3616882265,
0.1059312522,
-0.5576747656,
-0.4051470459,
0.4276175499,
0.0715668648,
-0.1290552765,
0.1089521646,
-0.2402069569,
0.6937827468,
0.8141047359,
-0.5381375551,
-0.0895391852,
-0.8506000042,
0.9578511715,
-0.6374744773,
0.5209343433,
0.0801109076,
0.4465889037,
0.3229658306,
-0.4198209047,
-0.8258517981,
0.5930995941,
-0.2994073629,
0.5482085347,
-0.165979594,
-0.1200708151,
0.0721271113,
0.4920732677,
0.2190593332,
-0.4949629009,
-0.3828536272,
-0.1484398395,
0.414453119,
0.2178180963,
0.2186715454,
-0.3697940111,
-0.586920321,
-0.4779927433,
-0.2808296084,
0.0912957937,
0.0656863526,
-0.0261289179,
-0.2079475224,
0.5697692633,
-0.0867414549,
0.7710267901,
0.4587036967,
0.0980144367,
0.150091961,
-0.5257373452,
-0.5970736742,
0.2303969115,
0.6754595637,
0.6975865364,
0.0102633052,
-0.3571382165,
-0.2752396464,
-0.1709731817,
0.764149785,
-1.0019154549,
0.3049871325,
0.4217103422,
-0.4226191342,
-0.4181007743,
0.0640262365,
-0.6556616426,
0.1202743948,
-0.3513683379,
0.6159079671,
-0.3421601057,
-0.1730963737,
0.0449679494,
-0.2226274014,
0.7392808795,
0.1843638271,
-0.9583230019,
0.2257424742,
0.561452508,
0.7629740238,
-0.5272753239,
-0.2421749383,
-0.2942802012,
0.1364409775,
-0.2846935987,
0.6981112361,
-0.2672969699,
-0.3625089824,
-0.4202854633,
-0.0441248082,
0.0153584322,
-0.4890901446,
0.3935542107,
-0.6900552511,
0.2291787863,
-0.286801964,
-0.5416615605,
0.0666897371,
0.2950440943,
-0.6833925247,
1.1257302761,
0.6035969257,
-0.5780392885,
0.8324468136,
-0.3584010601,
-0.4184543192,
0.1387528777,
-0.1881588995,
-0.257719785,
0.3337509334,
0.1218870059,
0.4154313803,
0.0910478979,
0.3077037036,
-0.1575674117,
-0.6358650923,
0.3256095946,
-0.5093230605,
0.5510518551,
0.1808505654,
-0.5941880941,
0.2459756285,
-0.5285947919,
0.0961129516,
-0.1821626425,
0.1183141917,
-0.2495560795,
-0.1851377636,
0.2350765616,
0.5699496269,
0.0182398856,
-0.4880190194,
-0.0471717939,
-0.2135477662,
0.3391136229,
0.6300767064,
0.1090737581,
0.6500786543,
-0.2550859451,
0.3933195472,
0.3086695075,
0.2315256298,
-0.4671747088,
-0.5222796798,
-1.0902295113,
-0.0380553044,
0.3881992698,
0.1646920294,
-0.3370384574,
0.7062966824,
-0.3689783812,
-0.1635130793,
-0.9225708246,
-0.3838696778,
-0.0653878748,
0.637301445,
0.9738137722,
-0.5032921433,
-0.3454192579,
-0.882085681,
-0.4210394919,
0.3666487038,
-0.3209982216,
0.2968398929,
0.5444971323,
-0.3692777753,
1.5244003534,
-0.1556364596,
-0.4766670763,
-0.0798125267,
-0.023852773,
0.3184450269,
0.5803731084,
0.4100136757,
-0.6988121271,
-0.6026571393,
-0.0319932029,
-0.6742280126,
-0.1168358624,
-0.4002647102,
-0.1705186814,
-0.2237635255,
0.4152088463,
-0.26529634,
0.6438699365,
0.6350429654,
-0.6402177811,
0.0640138537,
0.0221000463,
0.3389824033,
-0.7886661887,
0.0510814711,
-0.158980161,
-0.4044467509,
-0.8919533491,
0.1658853143,
0.4103189707,
0.2848528326,
-0.6219758987,
0.6893504858,
-0.2067755312,
-0.0296288561,
-0.3946453631,
-0.0473998822,
0.2400580943,
0.5804265141,
-0.1584357321,
0.8451869488,
0.139963612,
-0.4992591739,
0.1466656923,
0.1790031046,
0.0696399063,
0.968010962,
-0.9086802006,
0.1286386251,
-0.2098890692,
0.1061364263,
-0.9132668376,
-0.2688196003,
0.4618638754,
-0.4422136843,
0.4264908731,
-0.4161375165,
-0.137396723,
0.1055333242,
-0.189043656,
0.8799648881,
0.5698392391,
-0.5629858971,
0.7259088159,
0.3336713612,
0.4211241901,
-0.583519876,
-0.8847203851,
0.1426022351,
-0.2091139108,
-0.6186959147,
0.7431635261,
-0.2758259177,
-0.0505522825,
0.227011919,
-0.7168130875,
-0.2007559687,
-0.1683641076,
0.2132727802,
0.0564277545,
-0.1382009089,
-0.1974875182,
0.2942018807,
-0.4409010112,
0.2720678449,
-0.4183290303,
0.4060864449,
-0.0069470261,
-0.5547366738,
-0.2177978754,
0.2496790141,
0.8408398032,
-0.0411990844,
0.9571521282,
0.5738521814,
-0.3057630658,
-0.2196703553,
-0.5208089352,
-0.0103930924,
-0.498105377,
-0.0474398918,
-0.506431818,
-0.8559000492,
0.7320221066,
0.3562192321,
-0.2800526023,
0.6844927669,
0.4976780713,
-0.0684498027,
0.9391515255,
0.6423695683,
-0.0575851128,
0.272176832,
-0.2178073525,
0.5116532445,
-0.9437026978,
-0.3297058344,
-0.0020344746,
-0.4679830372,
-0.5472032428,
-0.7251367569,
0.5200695395,
0.1070388183,
-0.1080878377,
0.2708782256,
-0.7028579116,
0.7378273606,
0.1939547211,
-0.0985451415,
0.2093188763,
-0.177523002,
0.0002108458,
-0.1917723268,
-0.633024931,
-0.1054716334,
0.9282748699,
0.3373024464,
0.6026338339,
-0.0825531185,
0.5236821771,
0.1675715595,
0.5481860042,
-0.9808206558,
-0.0001084129,
0.4178038836,
-0.5748092532,
-0.4085836112,
-0.6813365221,
-0.6436491013,
0.7988284826,
0.0306216404,
-0.4773920774,
0.293184787,
-0.2113007903,
-0.2561421096,
0.0591210686,
-0.4057303667,
1.1237835884,
-0.2102507055,
-0.2733007073,
0.0203328244,
-0.5833886862,
0.2501802146,
-0.0935267583,
0.2442238033,
0.0990746841,
0.1415865719,
0.5735114813,
-0.3527135551,
0.589601934,
0.1514270604,
-0.3452530801,
0.2206444591,
0.1519382298,
0.0091424529,
0.2471377105,
-0.0723693222,
0.5047615767,
0.1326277554,
-0.5632940531,
-0.8047199845,
0.7078479528,
-0.7234464884,
-0.4422160685,
-0.4757154286,
-0.4921243489,
-0.1542629004,
0.3182929456,
0.373511076,
0.1838474721,
0.0495592318,
0.4334738851,
0.6195484996,
0.0022859068,
0.3377654552,
0.2073383927,
0.2132443488,
-0.462361306,
0.6620684862,
0.0198974162,
0.4568895698,
0.3065421283,
0.1050555259,
-0.2612946332,
0.210601449,
-0.6774417162,
0.0043726731,
-0.9814700484,
-0.2431747019,
-0.6399027705,
-0.3575153053,
-0.187742874,
-0.2940229774,
-0.6893669963,
-0.1303419173,
-0.11872942,
0.042661678,
-0.1299949586,
0.6646611691,
0.2677033544,
0.3986780941,
-0.727509737,
0.2427946031,
0.3051296175,
1.0267856121,
0.1983403563,
-0.5771974325,
-0.3012065589,
0.1073604822,
-0.2695687115,
-1.1384505033,
0.3392186165,
-0.2280627787,
0.6212572455,
0.4094496071,
0.0055838334,
0.8082751632,
-0.2981127501,
0.754884243,
0.2343966663,
-1.5946443081,
0.202559635,
-0.0183354374,
0.5415763259,
0.5383598804,
0.0643728971,
-0.9145543575,
-0.3756946027,
-0.646628499,
-0.9995266199,
1.0221558809,
0.6906144619,
0.467652142,
0.0853987932,
0.3149501383,
-0.03168777,
0.1754232794,
-0.8789665103,
-0.7406299114,
-0.8624854088,
-0.3592474759,
0.0053396598,
-0.2602589428,
-0.1714840084,
-0.4519923329,
0.1768404692,
-0.1529622376,
0.3226867914,
0.3485380411,
-0.1335120499,
-0.3262375295,
0.2803663909,
0.5428290367,
0.4635309875,
-0.2894916236,
0.3362594247,
0.5423465967,
-0.1741002351,
0.2698143721,
-0.538439393,
-0.2357420325,
0.0243364871,
0.4016623497,
0.8339802027,
0.5271975994,
-0.4092527628,
0.8989286423,
-0.3272125125,
-0.0777964592,
-0.1725376695,
0.1761584431,
-0.0274342429,
-0.0516444035,
0.4207038581,
0.3523358107,
0.2056055516,
-0.372040391,
0.3406065702,
0.2981093824,
-1.0609009266,
-0.4561593831,
0.6358549595,
-0.0286791027,
-0.0393551067,
0.3728379011,
-0.1048379987,
-0.5704394579,
0.6330216527,
0.5903269649,
0.9705405235,
-0.2905443311,
-0.0223167241,
0.201047495,
0.3315154314,
0.2273045927,
-0.1948052943,
-0.6343941689,
-0.9165440798,
-0.6305268407,
-0.6993052363,
-0.5137815475,
0.0177393984,
-0.9140713215,
0.31429106,
-0.086960867,
-0.153511852,
-0.157988891,
-0.7293484211,
-0.8621928096,
0.4618525505,
-0.130777657,
0.5093269348,
-0.6147479415,
0.605457902,
0.4285540581,
-0.3572178781,
-0.5852894187,
0.1821800172,
-0.5374101996,
-0.4881783426,
0.5985822678,
0.4528593421,
-0.2881303132,
-0.1634075344,
-0.3230443299,
-1.1614354849,
0.9995004535,
0.1203793511,
0.0880605578,
0.2232276499,
0.3976125121,
0.6647784114,
-0.4778606892,
0.7669983506,
0.705827117,
0.5641168952,
0.2732895017,
-0.6421633959,
0.2338882834,
-0.3363500237,
-0.2167458385,
0.2165874094,
-0.5977381468,
0.7862482667,
0.3156981468,
-0.4787566364,
-0.6213594079,
0.5574997663,
-0.2076976299,
0.2833020687,
0.4862631559,
0.5024975538,
0.0898652524,
-0.1498436034,
0.9355095625,
-0.7195819616,
0.7779790163,
0.8928411007,
-0.0967562869,
0.3873301148,
0.7779502273,
-0.0207949989,
0.2322987169,
0.2481326163,
-0.0766662508,
0.4191374779,
-0.0708358213,
0.0483558066,
-0.2558405697,
-0.0090087755,
-0.3227519691,
0.6504206657,
0.0670638829,
-0.2204378694,
-0.1904216409,
-0.259357661,
-0.3586582541,
-0.4952284992,
0.1431247592,
0.7250092626,
-0.0273281951,
-0.7077542543,
0.7569525242,
0.2206356525,
0.7110010982,
-0.269228667,
-0.0609340779,
-0.4020653963,
-0.0598269552,
-0.2903205454,
-0.9213215113,
0.7221396565,
-0.1730793566,
-0.1265186071,
-0.7148688436,
0.4105445743,
-0.3146116138,
-0.0959747136,
0.6405881643,
0.4113019407,
-0.2520620227,
-0.1676281244,
-0.1948341727,
0.1503421366,
-0.2044343799,
-0.2947952449,
0.3417420089,
0.5337814093,
0.2819637656,
0.4995490909,
0.5572425127,
-0.1578810662,
0.0410929434,
0.129315719,
0.7972320318,
-1.0483497381,
-0.6111355424,
-1.0634793043,
0.6785922647,
-0.1701850742,
-0.5036706924,
0.8692944646,
0.3353711963,
1.0506532192,
-0.0336523764,
0.5751672983,
0.1526144296,
-0.2982304096,
-0.1323622763,
0.7714933753,
-0.6023145914,
0.1064193323,
-0.3309248984,
-1.1678415537,
-0.15683873,
0.5597623587,
0.1199722514,
0.0925409198,
0.6702031493,
0.1699999124,
-0.4172374606,
0.0032008025,
0.680059731,
-0.0826095268,
0.28314206,
0.0867708847,
0.7161422968,
-0.843077004,
0.315441668,
-0.2828764915,
-0.2288205922,
-0.3611571789,
-0.8910161257,
-0.8184592128,
-0.4423534274,
0.0375054888,
-0.2636054754,
-0.4892607927,
0.4515054524,
1.150496006,
-1.0756831169,
-0.1178317368,
-0.1328953654,
0.1562606543,
-0.2783876061,
-0.3410389721,
-0.0703487471,
-0.4628070295,
-0.5955790877,
0.4579809904,
0.6421410441,
-0.0092153791,
-0.4081289172,
-0.1013728008,
0.5134200454,
0.5420334935,
0.7567409873,
-0.3013707995,
-0.6877997518,
-0.5068975091,
0.2155551761,
-0.196456641,
0.3811522722,
0.9985166788,
-0.8017678857,
0.7021114826,
0.4976156354,
0.688657701,
0.9967078567,
0.2516477108,
0.5337133408,
-1.0098656416,
0.0996418744,
0.1702036709,
0.3535361886,
0.4123190939,
-0.5246439576,
0.3655143678,
0.209539324,
-0.2445001006,
-0.4740954638,
0.1506344974,
-1.0789768696,
-0.2144343257,
0.7860857844,
0.1617091149,
-0.2835161984,
0.058103703,
0.1081867144,
0.4502557218,
-0.277955085,
0.8272989988,
0.7438223958,
-0.037552502,
-0.0586512722,
-0.498693943,
0.2783787549,
0.6956564784,
-0.5004868507,
-0.2315538973,
0.1669061929,
0.5124616027,
0.3555876911,
0.4272696674,
-0.0511735976,
0.0241103191,
-0.08768446,
0.0587819777,
0.0034264617,
-0.3383443952,
-0.4095479846,
0.348908782,
-0.5293723345,
0.1070411652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12969v1 | Using n-aksaras to model Sanskrit and Sanskrit-adjacent texts | 2023-01-30T15:17:06 | 2023-01-30T15:17:06 | Charles Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite -- or perhaps because of -- their simplicity, n-grams, or contiguous
sequences of tokens, have been used with great success in computational
linguistics since their introduction in the late 20th century. Recast as
k-mers, or contiguous sequences of monomers, they have also found applications
in computational biology. When applied to the analysis of texts, n-grams
usually take the form of sequences of words. But if we try to apply this model
to the analysis of Sanskrit texts, we are faced with the arduous task of,
firstly, resolving sandhi to split a phrase into words, and, secondly,
splitting long compounds into their components. This paper presents a simpler
method of tokenizing a Sanskrit text for n-grams, by using n-aksaras, or
contiguous sequences of aksaras. This model reduces the need for sandhi
resolution, making it much easier to use on raw text. It is also possible to
use this model on Sanskrit-adjacent texts, e.g., a Tamil commentary on a
Sanskrit text. As a test case, the commentaries on Amarakosa 1.0.1 have been
modelled as n-aksaras, showing patterns of text reuse across ten centuries and
nine languages. Some initial observations are made concerning Buddhist
commentarial practices. | [
-0.112591885,
-0.4459180236,
0.5000606179,
0.1946913451,
-0.8667377234,
0.0388456658,
-0.2167123109,
-0.4730907381,
0.5294389725,
0.2268243134,
-0.2635234594,
-0.3954909146,
-0.60388726,
0.6295670271,
-0.6560975313,
1.0561699867,
0.0599966124,
0.043984957,
-0.1186934412,
-0.2872435749,
-0.2308685035,
-0.5101621747,
-0.281627059,
-0.1922733486,
0.7602638602,
0.2504516244,
0.4973897636,
0.6165611148,
0.6190325022,
0.3112991154,
-0.57967031,
0.2655011415,
-0.1974042505,
0.1762503088,
0.1686532348,
-0.6644325256,
-0.1797653139,
0.1386424154,
0.940818727,
0.917278111,
0.1224337667,
0.0996887833,
-0.0883165747,
0.8164110184,
-0.523231864,
0.0336175784,
-0.1895049065,
0.0613337979,
-0.3326633871,
-0.3259129226,
-0.5366046429,
-0.6545081735,
0.302744329,
-0.7890136838,
-0.2243358791,
-0.0198329855,
0.8323738575,
0.0478676446,
-0.3021319807,
-0.6024794579,
-0.5502032638,
1.0536305904,
-0.9861038923,
0.1661151201,
0.432354331,
0.2163540721,
-0.2194487602,
-0.4624816775,
-0.4806135595,
-0.2839978933,
-0.421415031,
-0.1799538732,
0.0706920326,
-0.1879859269,
-0.0363555178,
0.6270836592,
-0.3158816993,
0.0181497112,
-0.8297138214,
0.1729956269,
0.250046283,
0.0587054044,
0.3848807216,
-0.6922318339,
-0.5093953013,
0.0932967961,
-0.7907624245,
-0.2722254097,
0.3258427083,
0.6565504074,
0.0283494592,
0.7410052419,
0.0484077595,
0.6996001601,
0.0823485702,
-0.4118660688,
0.1631148905,
-0.3581906557,
-0.327717185,
0.0578439198,
0.3371176422,
0.1915543228,
0.0864945799,
-0.2414291799,
0.3329219818,
0.2217425108,
0.2074629366,
-0.9228829741,
-0.0650266409,
0.0568930022,
-0.8791106939,
-0.3946162462,
-0.3156454563,
-1.0733624697,
-0.4272696078,
-0.491964072,
0.2950543761,
-0.6007493734,
-0.0964950398,
-0.0077129626,
-0.0764841586,
0.5658196807,
0.0726919547,
-0.8795379996,
0.6494535208,
0.7991573215,
1.1408667564,
-0.1283932924,
-0.1440125257,
-0.3865118921,
0.0790018737,
-0.3793588579,
0.8460199237,
-0.9685768485,
-0.7509974241,
-0.202346772,
-0.2285768241,
0.1067323238,
-0.3375743032,
0.6618190408,
-0.4764648974,
0.2424972504,
-0.560082972,
-1.0033086538,
-0.5885152221,
0.1272858679,
-0.3788474798,
0.7534297705,
-0.0453458354,
-0.7258847356,
0.2209335715,
-0.5262652636,
-0.3762660623,
-0.033181902,
-0.3561063707,
-0.1315942705,
0.3923583925,
0.0681886598,
0.0255705211,
-0.2703356743,
-0.0211116113,
-0.1773501933,
-0.5010384321,
-0.0737985447,
-0.0916294754,
0.5387145281,
0.2694061399,
-0.068333149,
0.1084909067,
-0.7244036794,
0.0660867244,
-0.2784908414,
-0.5018759966,
-0.8436540961,
0.1291337758,
0.1316946596,
-0.0412626751,
0.1062420458,
-0.809428215,
0.3422189951,
-0.5566073656,
0.3646212816,
1.1087704897,
-0.0333873928,
0.5484668016,
-0.2235165983,
0.4517439604,
-0.0362781845,
-0.0043990444,
-0.4832986593,
-0.7755764723,
-0.5821706057,
-0.422313273,
0.6983042359,
0.0792960972,
-0.308999896,
0.055574391,
-0.3525409102,
-0.6509839892,
-0.4128993154,
-0.0060908059,
0.389750421,
0.2126000375,
0.0867176056,
-0.5912309289,
-0.7160416842,
-0.7121137381,
-0.4648380578,
-0.0533102751,
0.4100034535,
0.030263951,
0.4947786927,
0.0276922882,
1.1414753199,
-0.7152627707,
-0.1552675217,
0.3411178589,
0.4495646656,
0.0993646309,
0.5356093049,
0.5200995207,
-0.7883954644,
-0.6634352803,
0.1610608399,
-0.7260847688,
-0.1729563475,
0.1930649877,
-0.3983645737,
0.1982558221,
0.6186403632,
-0.4130906463,
0.6518220901,
0.5233997703,
-0.1906815618,
0.6088088751,
-0.1329826713,
-0.0446661264,
-1.3671858311,
0.4549967349,
-0.1807207167,
-0.0986735821,
-0.843710959,
0.4477723539,
-0.2404569834,
0.0413626432,
-0.2405338138,
0.6411722898,
-0.6337652802,
-0.0808742568,
-0.8427318931,
-0.0386929661,
-0.2208473235,
0.5231689811,
-0.130276531,
0.8851802349,
0.1711114645,
-0.6105572581,
-0.2559701204,
0.3614570498,
-0.2687880099,
0.7857553363,
-0.5111153126,
0.1014480516,
-0.3016914129,
0.3688287735,
-0.7275941968,
-0.0158706196,
0.2959278822,
-0.4545007348,
0.0081057381,
-0.0906869695,
-0.6207360625,
0.1521989405,
-0.4824393392,
0.9701096416,
0.6046791077,
-0.5093146563,
0.7581784725,
0.3835281432,
-0.2673868239,
-0.3404982686,
-0.5746803284,
0.1402006298,
-0.4854143262,
-0.1629896164,
0.3312686384,
0.0133930454,
-0.1572976857,
0.2857688069,
-0.329461962,
0.0074144593,
-0.2204877436,
0.4778322279,
0.2875467837,
-0.0605567694,
0.1192077845,
0.0275072418,
-0.263844043,
-0.249422878,
-0.2343021184,
0.605271697,
0.0579784475,
-0.3277424574,
-0.4756150544,
0.9679654241,
0.6917006969,
-0.1693120301,
0.6377872825,
0.1302760094,
-0.558405757,
0.3363415003,
-0.3031735122,
0.0582373738,
-0.46765396,
0.0126175918,
-0.0260007661,
-0.9097297788,
0.5630869865,
-0.2300684005,
0.1032234654,
0.4993122816,
0.4617601633,
0.239204675,
0.712479353,
0.7726300955,
-0.2094684392,
0.4980098009,
0.1200884283,
0.5539064407,
-1.1081168652,
-0.2008587569,
-0.6170961261,
-0.2288494855,
-0.5528366566,
-0.6427852511,
0.3803089857,
-0.035988275,
-0.1396026015,
0.2818012238,
-0.3097674251,
0.7795962095,
0.3768581152,
-0.2354006469,
0.4614090621,
0.1408043653,
-0.3320276737,
-0.140099749,
-0.3943788111,
-0.6393406391,
1.1984196901,
-0.0224096458,
0.5526217222,
0.275170207,
0.8020758629,
0.1165504977,
0.5008754134,
-0.6243072152,
0.5347846746,
-0.5839596391,
-0.593164444,
0.161981836,
-0.3253267705,
-0.8410595059,
0.3732183278,
0.219547689,
-0.8449781537,
0.3627962172,
-0.4979193807,
-0.7186939716,
0.4108822644,
-0.8088694811,
0.2538268864,
0.2978417873,
0.1084607095,
-0.1902441531,
-0.7217727304,
0.4841455817,
-0.1574847847,
0.2605513036,
-0.167548731,
-0.0526059046,
0.8149696589,
-0.6983547211,
1.0865820646,
0.0990906879,
-0.3079203665,
0.3029861748,
-0.0453624874,
0.1646577865,
-0.3262286484,
0.1314553022,
-0.3381690383,
0.2999631166,
-0.5830327868,
-0.6324577928,
0.8388950825,
-0.4648970962,
-0.2324581891,
-0.7576057911,
-0.3812849522,
0.1242646575,
0.4024856389,
-0.1057450026,
0.5505647063,
0.1185798645,
0.0033021295,
0.1279959977,
-0.0039913538,
0.3264860213,
0.3816581368,
-0.6786504388,
-0.558072865,
0.931782186,
0.3006989062,
0.1914454848,
0.0636737496,
0.232702896,
-0.3036899567,
-0.3072513044,
-0.0465821885,
0.2702298462,
-0.6862311959,
-0.2239002734,
-0.3969437778,
-0.1518081576,
-0.1409866959,
-0.2418542951,
-0.1597370207,
-0.5663471222,
-0.3686261475,
0.0811022222,
0.6402983069,
0.9703053236,
-0.2957908511,
0.4344415963,
-0.888902545,
0.2918904722,
0.3184719682,
0.6235530972,
0.3938787878,
-0.1516210735,
-0.1625381559,
-0.1913577914,
-0.0324029811,
-1.1004836559,
0.2112354636,
0.2842921317,
0.2179502249,
0.4458353817,
-0.2243196219,
1.0405716896,
-0.6468259096,
0.7392094135,
-0.0351350941,
-0.9928603768,
0.2237577736,
-0.5900640488,
0.2421068847,
0.7572488189,
0.2168023735,
-1.0233374834,
-0.3215745986,
-0.2658010721,
-0.9440521598,
0.3323495686,
0.6411785483,
0.2421093732,
-0.3709038794,
0.6412418485,
0.4071859419,
0.1128337458,
-0.3185868561,
-0.4062318802,
0.2376888394,
-0.185030356,
-0.1060037985,
-0.474624902,
-0.0710999817,
-0.4753594995,
0.6970709562,
0.0210079476,
0.2299988717,
0.2993193269,
-0.0133671639,
0.2173192948,
0.1527747363,
0.9564819336,
0.3995503187,
-0.2447601706,
0.1908827424,
-0.1533658206,
-0.7292184234,
0.3605154455,
-0.0839125216,
-0.2548060417,
0.1927464306,
-0.0454428531,
0.3334085345,
0.5884513259,
-0.5844214559,
-0.0654315427,
0.0329245292,
0.0734925121,
-0.0613982826,
-0.6015726924,
0.1766003817,
0.0034971947,
0.4077212512,
0.0963671282,
0.0462691411,
-0.6588143706,
0.2672504485,
0.1267697215,
-0.058676172,
-0.1775380969,
0.3879562914,
0.1744064242,
-0.2504191101,
0.2976994216,
-0.5193718076,
-0.6095480323,
0.365755707,
0.4985281825,
0.9176703095,
-0.0559923165,
0.2241364866,
0.4340322018,
0.0334653594,
-0.0600096993,
0.2865672708,
-0.0531931408,
-0.0221422054,
-0.7183231115,
-0.7679469585,
-0.4041513503,
-0.4132581949,
-0.7590305209,
-0.0018313354,
-0.6077435017,
-0.2581771016,
0.1858464777,
0.0521378182,
0.0931371748,
-0.1408275664,
0.1035479903,
0.9447283149,
-0.8820242286,
0.4293274879,
0.4038977325,
-0.469022274,
-0.5939315557,
-0.0262444615,
0.1731158048,
-0.4599612057,
0.4651395082,
0.3969466388,
-0.0718037263,
-0.1603502929,
-0.463314563,
-1.0859909058,
0.7994978428,
0.0181661025,
-0.015058306,
-0.1080674827,
-0.0465788543,
0.7101266384,
-0.1741963774,
-0.0384872295,
0.5398245454,
0.3720717132,
0.2176669985,
-0.6857688427,
0.1286144108,
-0.7370171547,
0.1524916738,
0.6075589657,
-0.7349558473,
1.1259276867,
0.3228910863,
-0.352645725,
0.8210408688,
0.8377843499,
0.3674660027,
-0.0662969276,
0.2517288923,
0.8652026653,
0.8854530454,
0.1861994117,
0.8089504242,
-0.1133177578,
0.3548186421,
1.2101180553,
-0.2382180989,
1.0992256403,
0.9584274888,
-0.414005965,
0.950566709,
0.5071226954,
0.1306475401,
0.6112846136,
0.5663964152,
-0.5086555481,
0.0543845147,
-0.2730922401,
-0.6414939761,
0.4955480099,
0.2117945552,
-0.1552581191,
-0.5510750413,
-0.1461343169,
0.2589918375,
-0.0079875039,
-0.2641682625,
0.6187782288,
0.256087333,
-0.6040699482,
0.3143386543,
0.3765638769,
0.800971806,
-0.4073378742,
-0.1154329255,
-0.2290719002,
-0.0557192266,
-0.1794702113,
-0.2000639886,
0.6812821031,
0.392896682,
-0.1852252781,
0.2802236974,
0.6162025332,
-0.1876768321,
-0.9273677468,
-0.0683715343,
0.1328804642,
0.177028358,
0.146786958,
0.0981359407,
-0.1874514669,
-0.4283997416,
0.2700068653,
0.3708903491,
-0.1072470024,
-0.0434488393,
0.4068050385,
0.813100934,
-0.192487359,
0.6661629081,
-0.2753718793,
0.957079649,
-0.722689271,
-0.7332192063,
-0.9656738639,
0.2010717988,
-0.1278286874,
-0.308036387,
0.9445075989,
0.731466651,
0.25104177,
0.193452239,
0.5968744159,
-0.0365620442,
0.5237028599,
-0.3944752514,
0.6555413008,
-0.6618543863,
-0.0984306708,
-0.4552497566,
-0.6079592705,
-0.4746947587,
0.6444367766,
-0.1663632691,
-0.0389577784,
0.7792666554,
0.3970190883,
0.0243162867,
0.5256831646,
-0.3625478148,
-0.0407790095,
0.2842510641,
0.4099526405,
0.6834676862,
-0.4747410715,
0.1675352454,
-0.1965844631,
-0.0243160948,
-0.1782114357,
-0.9251022935,
-0.6025969386,
-0.6031383872,
-0.0719374418,
-0.1905148029,
-0.0990930647,
0.9689373374,
0.5118443966,
-0.6073994637,
-0.2563871145,
-0.1706545204,
0.0709569156,
-0.1075944826,
-0.1103831977,
0.5314285755,
-0.3872236907,
-0.7126182914,
0.3271455169,
0.4210558534,
0.2422067076,
-0.3593556285,
0.0875762925,
-0.6150890589,
0.4470284879,
0.535237968,
0.6007457376,
-0.6674664617,
-0.213863045,
0.0098468866,
-0.0253436696,
0.3174980879,
0.772444725,
-0.8024915457,
0.4218562245,
0.6306470633,
0.6076383591,
0.2418653369,
0.1360299736,
0.6405121088,
-0.66796875,
0.1253626943,
0.0302737765,
0.0961556956,
0.2481315285,
0.13382034,
0.3430206776,
0.1424655616,
-0.3554275334,
-1.1784981489,
0.2429296672,
-1.0164008141,
-0.2856200933,
1.0801819563,
-0.0940739512,
-0.6486403346,
0.0961799771,
-0.5533261299,
0.2270069271,
-0.1096846983,
0.8721956015,
1.0804424286,
0.3192389309,
0.2558195591,
-0.2681429684,
0.390732199,
0.8744240403,
-0.7343302965,
-0.1145271137,
0.1605584621,
0.1098399162,
0.512422204,
0.8617196083,
-0.3754205704,
0.0854204595,
0.0139278742,
-0.4518190324,
0.3842574358,
-0.2496965528,
-0.7037498355,
0.2155916095,
0.0498893186,
-0.4225324392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12920v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12920v4 | Active Learning for Multilingual Semantic Parser | 2023-01-30T14:19:29 | 2023-10-11T04:08:26 | Zhuang Li, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current multilingual semantic parsing (MSP) datasets are almost all collected
by translating the utterances in the existing datasets from the resource-rich
language to the target language. However, manual translation is costly. To
reduce the translation effort, this paper proposes the first active learning
procedure for MSP (AL-MSP). AL-MSP selects only a subset from the existing
datasets to be translated. We also propose a novel selection method that
prioritizes the examples diversifying the logical form structures with more
lexical choices, and a novel hyperparameter tuning method that needs no extra
annotation cost. Our experiments show that AL-MSP significantly reduces
translation costs with ideal selection methods. Our selection method with
proper hyperparameters yields better parsing performance than the other
baselines on two multilingual datasets. | [
-0.3355274498,
-0.5129265189,
0.4066570103,
0.1710762084,
-0.4914787114,
-0.3105843365,
-0.4422118962,
-0.4602259696,
0.0452229418,
0.3287069798,
-0.476762414,
-0.3214714825,
-0.4981795847,
0.296729058,
0.0054787397,
0.7758861184,
-0.0630746931,
0.300422132,
0.1600177586,
-0.4898100495,
-0.2691143751,
-0.0844900087,
-0.7109469175,
0.1155758798,
0.6338841319,
0.4240911305,
0.8337660432,
0.9267540574,
0.3997806013,
0.3564251065,
-0.2095158994,
0.5799469352,
0.1821672171,
0.3515965939,
-0.3195732236,
-0.4563625753,
-0.192787692,
0.0224740971,
0.7773997784,
0.9840815067,
-0.0669795722,
0.2149727643,
-0.1593871862,
0.7687709332,
-0.987175703,
0.2685526907,
-0.8408741951,
0.308285743,
-0.3053558171,
-0.047907535,
-0.4783618748,
0.0260630716,
-0.3306587636,
-0.5620258451,
0.1575337648,
-0.1121208295,
0.8198100328,
0.2476582974,
-0.5538529754,
-0.0585405268,
-0.5350084305,
0.9717454314,
-0.4473306835,
0.7184122205,
0.5231502056,
0.4780530632,
0.1872137934,
-0.7199293375,
-0.3577886224,
0.0160810165,
0.2191458344,
0.0760669336,
-0.2021361589,
-0.0900099501,
0.201946497,
0.3154493868,
-0.5274671316,
-0.1038734391,
-0.3875863552,
-0.2612124979,
0.4428944588,
-0.2249359339,
0.1918722689,
-0.1562038213,
-0.4839551449,
-0.1515203565,
-0.4235230982,
-0.0255228356,
0.1572422087,
0.618437171,
0.236060515,
0.7228413224,
-0.3777810633,
0.9232683182,
-0.3550078273,
-0.2330026776,
0.4139534235,
-0.4141078591,
-0.2924071848,
0.2837640047,
0.2355844676,
0.0366195031,
0.2504437268,
-0.0155385453,
-0.2001173943,
0.1746785194,
-0.0451682582,
-0.4593853951,
-0.0796375722,
0.0691179708,
-0.4822317958,
-0.000804307,
-0.1841688156,
-0.4074943364,
0.1823649555,
-0.5171998739,
0.0039933519,
-0.3632428646,
-0.177090466,
0.362777859,
0.1446870416,
0.1701555699,
0.3120445013,
-0.7268280387,
0.3226376772,
0.2507726252,
0.6359010935,
-0.1484308988,
-0.4069181383,
-0.9053901434,
0.5428650975,
-0.2673915029,
1.02564466,
-0.4488696158,
0.0885487646,
-0.0313820764,
0.002335906,
-0.1867823154,
-0.5855976343,
0.7336971164,
-0.5194945931,
0.0023778931,
-0.3344264925,
-0.1500059813,
-0.1727793664,
0.2007784098,
-0.6519607902,
0.9651145935,
0.0292417649,
-0.409614414,
0.796604991,
-0.4304841161,
-0.5904026628,
0.2452873886,
-0.1711684465,
-0.1860468388,
-0.1188233942,
0.4453534484,
0.357218802,
-0.0081041828,
0.2088040709,
-0.1579997092,
0.3967776299,
-0.2736553848,
-0.491566509,
0.7778002024,
0.7007120252,
-0.2862176299,
0.1806343496,
-0.8791273236,
0.2528424859,
-0.0225248598,
-0.6347668171,
-0.3786226511,
0.0281220395,
0.089148052,
0.780226171,
0.0969721004,
-0.5631124377,
0.1348680705,
-0.443046093,
-0.0098289605,
0.6612051129,
-0.243872568,
0.3299690783,
0.1338922679,
0.2801076472,
0.2189240903,
0.1836358756,
0.0469732098,
-0.5980502367,
-0.8874334097,
-0.6125606894,
0.285484612,
0.7125763297,
-0.8223276138,
0.5643959045,
-0.0345341787,
-0.1112073138,
-0.6392502189,
0.6722708344,
0.4223801494,
0.3310903311,
0.7430294752,
0.1450412571,
-0.1389116198,
-1.1975771189,
-0.4062140584,
-0.0663235858,
0.1147098765,
0.101845555,
-0.0857758448,
0.0365591682,
0.7335443497,
-0.6071483493,
-0.5005433559,
-0.5599809289,
-0.1748846769,
0.1076433212,
0.4442192614,
0.5094322562,
-0.9401832819,
-0.5663377047,
0.0218664259,
-0.4928959012,
-0.2949729562,
0.0311912,
-0.418018043,
0.0464698896,
0.4630786479,
-0.7312974334,
0.1266949475,
0.3714612722,
-0.5709620714,
-0.1393913031,
-0.0930231586,
-0.1131557301,
-0.9887217879,
0.0748661086,
-0.1059170365,
-0.4748034477,
-0.1815797538,
0.1415778995,
0.4513210952,
-0.474106878,
-0.8185799718,
0.4833348095,
-0.644872129,
-0.0284017175,
-0.1634040624,
-0.0945783406,
0.0982744843,
0.5330073237,
0.1987661421,
0.4243756831,
0.4936326146,
-0.5759656429,
0.4122531116,
0.3207078874,
-0.1129658669,
0.1232812628,
-0.2986452281,
-0.3618416488,
-0.2534029484,
0.0164271742,
-0.8870521784,
0.2269791067,
0.2609435618,
-0.0637265891,
0.3981776237,
-0.3531075418,
-0.6238345504,
0.1093993708,
0.0472781286,
0.2450076193,
0.1282090992,
-0.4208039939,
0.3998191655,
0.1972250789,
-0.3845137656,
-0.3073516488,
-0.6132404804,
0.2126945704,
0.1153965592,
-0.5754882097,
0.1019815803,
0.1114307567,
-0.12960805,
-0.0481032915,
-0.3318823278,
0.1091527715,
0.1426480412,
-0.416295886,
0.0534033328,
-0.425566256,
0.1780210882,
0.3737305105,
-0.5178571939,
-0.247281462,
-0.2638370693,
0.5137856603,
-0.1674092859,
-0.6476076245,
-0.3030090034,
0.6205312014,
0.3944656551,
-0.8948068023,
0.724430263,
0.5749734044,
-0.3267274499,
-0.350739181,
-0.4374931157,
0.1382365972,
-0.4172201753,
0.4069305658,
-0.5120767355,
-0.234530434,
0.0340354852,
-0.1583700925,
0.3605037332,
0.6741577983,
0.4878504276,
0.4698474705,
1.3505154848,
0.2781176865,
0.0545790158,
0.5569030643,
-0.0550463237,
0.0801565051,
-0.2484540194,
-0.0586665608,
-0.5986372828,
-0.2636221349,
-0.2383579165,
-0.3980144858,
0.2778514624,
0.1102312878,
0.0499326475,
0.1552128494,
-0.2153145373,
0.5010613799,
0.4340460896,
0.0376637131,
0.2658478618,
0.2269266993,
-0.2188692689,
-0.0097471857,
-0.6675396562,
-0.4579472244,
0.7892169356,
0.2559969127,
0.446911335,
0.5525065064,
0.4022863805,
0.0484207645,
-0.2458464056,
-0.8740368485,
0.6299992204,
-0.2711987197,
-0.3254239261,
-0.3571860194,
-0.5837860703,
-1.077917099,
0.7671815753,
-0.3036924899,
-0.0777049959,
0.229609251,
0.0376681983,
-0.0389390513,
0.2459259629,
-0.7519830465,
0.8144978285,
-0.424975872,
-0.3987387121,
-0.1255613863,
-0.8446634412,
0.0502449796,
0.2257434428,
0.2572849691,
-0.3622005284,
-0.3038563132,
0.6361716986,
-0.1240433604,
0.499111414,
-0.518656373,
0.0835304335,
0.0623304471,
0.1618182361,
0.401309669,
0.1660605818,
-0.0795052946,
-0.1099231392,
-0.1863471121,
-0.8304994702,
-0.4359301329,
0.5948803425,
-0.6430596113,
-0.2142882496,
-0.4560922682,
-0.4809552431,
-0.4131321907,
0.5098448396,
-0.2151068002,
0.3056953251,
0.2865141332,
0.1660756469,
0.6956273317,
0.0094537316,
0.4104183316,
0.5863723159,
-0.0022796697,
-0.423753947,
0.7145753503,
0.1080374122,
0.4362172484,
0.3009771407,
0.4520776272,
-0.1129129678,
-0.534312129,
-0.8903683424,
0.3007940352,
-0.8963894248,
-0.4468084574,
-0.9210034609,
0.1059129611,
-0.6113651991,
-0.0494177155,
-0.6370375156,
-0.901503861,
-0.0389220379,
-0.2087213248,
-0.0149655771,
0.00008221,
-0.0025776513,
-0.03993541,
-0.8446540236,
0.7296600342,
0.3697241843,
0.2301802188,
-0.3508504629,
-0.1466509253,
-0.2825731337,
-0.1590485126,
-0.3545155525,
-0.7456757426,
0.4198414385,
0.7004392743,
0.9801476002,
0.8034185171,
0.1042758077,
0.6165726185,
-0.5052111149,
0.5644598603,
0.0771880895,
-0.6727023125,
0.9313575029,
-0.0729861632,
0.5714907646,
0.9477806091,
0.4142796397,
-0.4693630338,
-0.2287523448,
-0.5359011292,
-1.115151763,
0.8013895154,
0.1756875515,
-0.0036190115,
-0.2860821187,
0.1293782145,
0.1228879169,
0.111010015,
-0.776281774,
-0.4321931899,
-0.0540020205,
-0.1713150889,
-0.1110936627,
-0.0348949097,
-0.1510319412,
-0.4711902738,
0.819426775,
-0.2484281212,
-0.1128405482,
0.088660568,
-0.4215285182,
-0.2320445925,
0.2555572987,
0.3398462236,
0.5992917418,
-0.0069004879,
0.5096714497,
0.0645406097,
-0.3942269385,
0.0510587506,
0.1518798321,
-0.1235254481,
0.1990593821,
0.4351123273,
0.6945549846,
0.2071174085,
-0.7095879912,
0.7099840045,
0.1069402099,
-0.0448121615,
-0.0461202487,
0.0956424624,
-0.1292742938,
0.1122746393,
0.1808874309,
0.2807928324,
0.2737643421,
-0.441029489,
0.1990200132,
0.1544504166,
-0.4141161144,
-0.0693450496,
0.4635627866,
0.1691521108,
0.1358502358,
0.5657349229,
-0.0722544044,
-0.3701760769,
0.2180506885,
0.6728331447,
0.6468536854,
-0.4276075959,
0.0405349843,
0.2407247275,
0.287231952,
-0.025988359,
0.4581910074,
-0.4664098024,
-0.746730566,
-0.3933426738,
-0.8385688066,
-0.1459545195,
-0.192008689,
-0.8290317655,
0.6221424937,
-0.1298422068,
0.2109319866,
-0.008260902,
-0.0263543073,
-0.4632610679,
0.2585110664,
0.4480296969,
1.1096061468,
-1.2207404375,
0.8676655293,
1.120210886,
-0.4570880234,
-0.3893641233,
-0.4019153714,
-0.2641778886,
-0.8025544286,
0.5969536304,
-0.0666099414,
0.0362558961,
-0.0014293587,
-0.2601215541,
-0.9098190665,
0.5431731343,
0.5065400004,
-0.1119093373,
0.0409435816,
0.1035541371,
0.0445856228,
0.0354418792,
-0.2350381762,
0.1745207012,
0.585310638,
0.1060761213,
-0.6712429523,
-0.1636760831,
-0.3751918375,
-0.2338717878,
0.701832056,
-0.5796591043,
0.8579418063,
0.1759294569,
-0.1314687878,
-0.3928440213,
0.8021349907,
0.2927037776,
0.2264003605,
0.7130252123,
0.6178577542,
0.5684816241,
0.4584554434,
0.7020179033,
-0.2783705592,
0.1880331039,
0.6920695305,
-0.4390535951,
0.8764781356,
0.8995462656,
-0.2224889696,
-0.0897242948,
0.5656052232,
-0.0035179879,
0.7666114569,
0.0042335023,
-0.4380370677,
-0.7039359808,
0.0535576865,
-0.3146029413,
0.6722834706,
0.1991623044,
-0.4346967936,
-0.8416472077,
0.2584534883,
0.2898959219,
0.0505974293,
-0.2327752858,
0.9870762825,
-0.0866411626,
-0.4958950281,
0.519698441,
0.4047124386,
0.244611457,
-1.1384904385,
-0.182068944,
-0.0265789237,
0.1921510845,
-0.2412488759,
-0.4660785794,
0.3000307381,
-0.1808089763,
-0.215247035,
-0.6387773752,
0.5678694844,
-0.517277956,
-0.7944082022,
0.2440510392,
0.7799979448,
0.2762295306,
-0.1369327158,
-0.8075050116,
-0.2205630392,
0.0876402929,
-0.5158679485,
0.5309432149,
0.5182199478,
-0.3171404898,
0.4404171109,
0.9431157112,
0.5074894428,
0.312304914,
0.0677251592,
1.0953656435,
-0.5668017864,
-0.7050623894,
-0.5910063982,
0.3725273311,
0.0459510125,
-0.4560427666,
0.5817616582,
0.9247168899,
0.9574008584,
0.0584155358,
0.6465532184,
0.015607371,
0.4860777855,
-0.8177013993,
0.5551252961,
-0.6308154464,
0.1125631258,
-0.083767727,
-1.2013692856,
-0.5802324414,
0.7985325456,
-0.0615931228,
-0.2232491672,
0.7638334036,
0.458162725,
-0.4975061715,
-0.2586778998,
0.5773374438,
-0.2599178553,
0.0834535137,
0.2538070977,
0.4242838621,
-0.2539806068,
0.5551912785,
-0.4090407789,
-0.4211613536,
0.1127981842,
-0.7192934752,
-0.4947256446,
-0.4167589247,
-0.2482098043,
-0.1679588556,
-0.1109092161,
1.2674174309,
0.5392183065,
-0.8506077528,
-0.171563372,
0.212480396,
-0.0808294341,
-0.5515345335,
-0.0782388896,
0.4685618281,
-0.9419956803,
-0.6051235795,
0.7699787617,
0.1228850782,
-0.3411198854,
0.135656029,
0.1809450239,
-0.8177081347,
-0.2177350074,
0.849191308,
0.1105806977,
-0.5929069519,
0.076656729,
-0.2792146206,
-0.0430765189,
0.2326690406,
0.6970399022,
-0.5483667254,
0.4203875065,
0.4629493058,
0.796854198,
0.4893800318,
-0.1869939417,
0.28221789,
-0.7205227017,
0.4648857415,
0.2518826127,
0.5375087857,
0.0350615084,
-0.1923387647,
0.3863374293,
0.5014132261,
-0.1241122931,
-0.6526786089,
0.306961149,
-1.094337821,
-0.4586038888,
1.3546774387,
-0.0892885104,
-0.2386686802,
-0.3347142935,
-0.4217302799,
0.322924763,
-0.2986737192,
0.1432857215,
0.3629438877,
-0.2683106661,
-0.1447721571,
-0.6512099504,
0.2989317179,
0.5559073091,
-0.6661836505,
0.1270519197,
0.6176772714,
-0.0324837975,
0.0222735405,
0.1589911282,
-0.2528917491,
0.2543861866,
-0.0828351229,
0.2978958488,
-0.2145631015,
-0.5037973523,
-0.2736121714,
0.3396226466,
0.2601812184,
-0.4469076097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12868v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12868v3 | On Robustness of Prompt-based Semantic Parsing with Large Pre-trained Language Model: An Empirical Study on Codex | 2023-01-30T13:21:00 | 2023-03-09T11:01:02 | Terry Yue Zhuo, Zhuang Li, Yujin Huang, Fatemeh Shiri, Weiqing Wang, Gholamreza Haffari, Yuan-Fang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Semantic parsing is a technique aimed at constructing a structured
representation of the meaning of a natural-language question. Recent
advancements in few-shot language models trained on code have demonstrated
superior performance in generating these representations compared to
traditional unimodal language models, which are trained on downstream tasks.
Despite these advancements, existing fine-tuned neural semantic parsers are
susceptible to adversarial attacks on natural-language inputs. While it has
been established that the robustness of smaller semantic parsers can be
enhanced through adversarial training, this approach is not feasible for large
language models in real-world scenarios, as it requires both substantial
computational resources and expensive human annotation on in-domain semantic
parsing data. This paper presents the first empirical study on the adversarial
robustness of a large prompt-based language model of code, \codex. Our results
demonstrate that the state-of-the-art (SOTA) code-language models are
vulnerable to carefully crafted adversarial examples. To address this
challenge, we propose methods for improving robustness without the need for
significant amounts of labeled data or heavy computational resources. | [
-0.4500720203,
-1.0316090584,
0.4086756706,
0.1286167204,
-0.1668995023,
-0.2934317887,
-0.2943040431,
-0.3821866214,
-0.1941695213,
0.510635972,
-0.658118844,
-0.4927289486,
-0.6190289855,
0.4061806202,
-0.2278312892,
0.8818739653,
0.3823602498,
0.3019142449,
-0.0993787944,
-0.1607328504,
-0.6238127351,
-0.6666560769,
-0.6326323152,
0.0972231776,
0.4130009115,
0.0474543758,
0.9707168341,
0.7003867626,
0.4361347556,
0.3417295516,
-0.160278365,
-0.074502632,
-0.3303379416,
0.2877398431,
-0.1834359616,
-0.5912547112,
-0.3867897391,
-0.211136356,
0.4787622392,
0.883831203,
0.2715703547,
-0.0238991342,
0.0856405422,
0.3187963367,
-0.5794984102,
0.0266011208,
-0.8536036611,
-0.2298544496,
-0.2859147787,
-0.2057958245,
-0.6984211802,
-0.2023066729,
0.0249995347,
-0.7263652682,
0.2119012922,
0.0126092257,
0.8431220055,
0.4212890565,
-0.2020151764,
-0.378169179,
-0.3079082072,
0.6901541948,
-0.7586427927,
0.1052505523,
0.5810639262,
0.3906015754,
-0.581582129,
-0.7551245093,
-0.5327744484,
-0.5978632569,
0.0898916945,
-0.1647248268,
-0.2499204129,
0.120686911,
0.5727686882,
-0.0523667261,
-0.7420709729,
0.2929271162,
0.1550079286,
-0.3396095335,
0.2152962834,
0.3282034099,
0.7878378034,
-0.0383454151,
-0.6072583795,
-0.4507895112,
-0.729963541,
0.3060364425,
0.5998896956,
0.5896081328,
0.2376477122,
0.4694299996,
-0.2140175849,
0.8584227562,
-0.1102053225,
0.0459673889,
-0.171308741,
-0.4466985762,
-0.0063414886,
0.0679105595,
0.6467699409,
0.2614854276,
0.3800884783,
-0.2163050324,
-0.1779666543,
0.5228027105,
0.5040414333,
-0.8143215179,
-0.1813827455,
0.0252911355,
-0.3323605955,
-0.3488751352,
-0.0790737197,
-0.7352832556,
-0.4100050926,
-0.0292319525,
0.1632036418,
-0.5265527368,
0.0283372924,
0.2708958685,
0.0127050839,
0.2473858148,
0.3304307759,
-0.893761158,
0.2324177772,
0.64458251,
0.5308824778,
0.1685062051,
-0.4904603958,
-0.6935939789,
-0.1228365898,
-0.3940427005,
0.9027602077,
-0.4762210548,
-0.2553042471,
0.1336795241,
0.0416731499,
-0.1263468266,
-0.4574601054,
0.676081419,
-0.9680925608,
-0.1875417531,
-0.4088344872,
-0.5954959393,
0.2497682422,
0.5040130615,
-0.7077718377,
0.6703348756,
0.1305660009,
-0.9162333012,
0.41956833,
-0.3480768204,
-0.2848953903,
0.0656726435,
-0.0994721949,
-0.1062767357,
-0.1307576746,
0.2214514166,
0.2341909707,
-0.38484779,
0.4729135931,
-0.5394650102,
-0.1599553823,
0.5542670488,
-0.6748695374,
1.0969320536,
0.3437883556,
-0.3398947716,
0.107816875,
-0.9067925215,
0.1224441081,
0.2695716918,
-0.2433146536,
-0.5043764114,
-0.2688571811,
-0.0363709219,
0.3123637736,
0.2044090182,
-0.5816791654,
0.3514417112,
-0.8201364279,
0.1652923971,
0.6063075066,
-0.1628228426,
0.5456354022,
-0.0472613126,
0.5850749016,
-0.2348488122,
0.0959098265,
-0.5026698112,
-0.401108712,
-0.379417032,
-0.28534922,
0.3606179953,
0.514616847,
-0.9375866055,
0.5417591929,
-0.1230476946,
-0.4060200751,
-0.215774864,
0.207630977,
0.5448700786,
0.5841415524,
0.3515182436,
-0.0948216692,
-0.3766900301,
-0.6940129995,
-0.3918199539,
-0.2666416764,
-0.157453984,
-0.0569017604,
0.3103368878,
-0.2690442204,
1.1087273359,
-0.481886059,
0.0904290602,
-0.5392782092,
0.1715260148,
0.0345737711,
0.6278652549,
0.6923510432,
-0.7433997393,
-0.2174264491,
-0.338519007,
-0.6990018487,
-0.3625904322,
-0.0938122049,
-0.1903668195,
0.0744795725,
0.5735839009,
-0.8712556958,
0.5798714161,
0.2308863252,
-0.7329941988,
0.5657646656,
-0.1695335805,
-0.1549546719,
-0.9299199581,
0.1081319302,
-0.3549084067,
-0.0914325267,
-0.806358695,
0.3273647726,
0.1239302978,
-0.4259485602,
-0.5672886968,
0.5632517934,
-0.0843680948,
0.0887725502,
-0.4658349752,
-0.183774367,
0.2220602036,
0.5280413032,
0.1197753176,
0.7401407361,
0.5735303164,
-0.6264052391,
0.3433025777,
0.3893022537,
-0.2174931467,
0.3724429309,
-0.7609322071,
0.0090969419,
-0.0012561752,
0.3798772097,
-0.9824495316,
-0.2306185812,
0.1668122858,
-0.6700650454,
0.5093957782,
-0.1436962038,
-0.643891573,
0.0404430255,
-0.3490441442,
0.5982874036,
0.3290605545,
-0.6230298281,
0.1963928193,
0.0727486387,
-0.2564205825,
-0.5011083484,
-0.5655751228,
0.3647597134,
-0.1279122084,
-0.93934232,
0.011373898,
-0.077521883,
-0.276117295,
-0.1579448581,
-0.0173832998,
-0.228055343,
0.5096875429,
0.055843208,
0.4118088484,
-0.4346394241,
-0.0424433351,
-0.3198785186,
-0.5468133688,
0.3000707626,
-0.2532223761,
0.7472291589,
-0.247647509,
-0.4768581986,
-0.3883197606,
0.5736781359,
0.4466392994,
-0.2587504983,
0.970895648,
0.4089221656,
-0.3773293197,
-0.3696518242,
-0.263951689,
-0.2546230555,
-0.4779714942,
0.2918511033,
-0.1482548863,
-0.6729958057,
0.6113765836,
-0.0750852451,
-0.205205068,
0.4367936254,
0.4525290728,
0.1879634261,
1.2078593969,
0.4177307785,
0.04364492,
0.3460795581,
-0.0650629997,
0.052236937,
-0.3611197174,
-0.0007953442,
-0.9277414083,
0.147222802,
-0.3910356462,
-0.0120794773,
0.0745778829,
0.0848530829,
-0.2847087979,
0.4751106203,
-0.0720262378,
0.3119793832,
0.6266456246,
-0.071037896,
0.0271638669,
-0.2506067753,
-0.1835807264,
0.0977710262,
-0.7851276994,
-0.7654157281,
0.9329124093,
0.3534150124,
0.9727522135,
0.0033206288,
0.2695878148,
0.1882418096,
-0.2625397444,
-0.6790159941,
0.6368800402,
-0.0306049306,
-0.4799790084,
-0.1832871437,
-0.3615823686,
-0.9954054356,
0.1225606948,
-0.1969830096,
-0.6171764731,
0.2218366414,
0.1873566508,
-0.4980890155,
0.1335971206,
-0.7193607092,
1.2242971659,
-0.093544282,
-0.3284058869,
0.3977034986,
-1.0057401657,
0.0727855712,
-0.0156653207,
0.0374806337,
0.2229320854,
0.1095917076,
0.5488046408,
-0.7014564872,
1.0321588516,
-0.3360207975,
-0.2023632526,
0.3797889352,
0.1894615442,
0.7103444338,
0.1419766694,
0.194057405,
0.1275714934,
0.0199508723,
-0.6213845015,
-0.7769793868,
0.5161068439,
-0.5663960576,
-0.465375036,
-0.4127928019,
-0.5581218004,
-0.4560902417,
0.2974085808,
0.6227254272,
0.9395593405,
-0.1179351211,
0.0066216947,
0.7905436754,
-0.5401748419,
0.4707407355,
0.3560629487,
0.2235156,
-0.2874718606,
0.7759255171,
0.0307506453,
0.4164589643,
0.2068839967,
0.083030805,
-0.3037557602,
-0.634131968,
-0.7772563696,
-0.2792688906,
-0.8639243245,
-0.3683289886,
-0.7149351835,
0.0151253706,
-0.5835949779,
-0.3637371361,
-0.4796828926,
-0.3157812953,
-0.2852743566,
0.1193387508,
0.0358222127,
0.4660887122,
0.3932024539,
0.371147573,
-0.9098715186,
0.3190969527,
0.273665607,
0.0853786394,
-0.1194528565,
-0.3259382248,
-0.1418615729,
0.1468468606,
0.0282779839,
-0.8669903278,
0.3406583965,
-0.0620519035,
0.4863241315,
0.4735349715,
0.5560314655,
0.4797477126,
-0.4233238101,
0.8449633121,
0.0562760718,
-0.7097203135,
0.6326932311,
-0.5284305215,
0.4826457202,
0.8786284924,
0.0061452342,
0.0088526942,
-0.5878263116,
-0.6424704194,
-0.8084391356,
0.8742733002,
0.0823448002,
0.2934191227,
-0.3446938694,
0.1914367974,
0.2227503061,
-0.0197225492,
-0.565892756,
-0.0186587889,
-0.3084153533,
-0.3358352482,
0.011368623,
-0.4288955629,
0.1103218272,
0.0730388463,
0.4492608309,
-0.260759145,
0.0171345118,
0.0432855859,
-0.3740784824,
0.2690848708,
0.4831391573,
0.4686252773,
0.441855222,
-0.0061185616,
0.3822587132,
0.1630358994,
-0.5988613367,
0.1721967459,
0.124757722,
-0.2945763171,
-0.2076632529,
0.7583748698,
0.6456153989,
0.30831182,
-1.0089403391,
0.9582475424,
-0.3100173175,
0.1975347698,
-0.2077116817,
0.0215833671,
-0.3213152885,
0.1729533374,
0.0165329576,
0.3636731207,
0.1518704146,
-0.4589679837,
0.1521221399,
0.4780584574,
-0.2290682644,
-0.3663648069,
0.5310955048,
-0.1145246774,
0.0144782709,
0.3691557944,
-0.281455636,
-0.5586017966,
0.7530438304,
0.9372883439,
0.7332506776,
-0.0672999471,
-0.0052458113,
0.1784466058,
0.3635823131,
-0.1393275857,
-0.0918119773,
-0.2138783634,
-0.6223688126,
-0.263843298,
-0.7159487009,
-0.2105246037,
-0.1127192974,
-0.8115565181,
0.1701955348,
-0.5741389394,
-0.2326293588,
-0.2167007923,
-0.1969289184,
-0.5053918958,
0.1577945054,
0.0203541182,
1.1968780756,
-0.778745234,
0.8026282787,
0.829139173,
-0.3417205215,
-0.776071012,
0.012200295,
-0.1572728157,
-0.7047356367,
0.7568762302,
0.2551252842,
-0.1805291325,
-0.2257725149,
-0.5634222627,
-0.5931810737,
0.5684844255,
0.7663239837,
0.0267865099,
0.0527322963,
0.1412482262,
0.591915071,
-0.1040981188,
0.1119015589,
0.4358138442,
0.2591614127,
0.1447068155,
-0.5045166612,
0.154725641,
-0.5011522174,
0.166670233,
0.0638162568,
-0.1811948121,
0.8765210509,
-0.0251793116,
-0.3202273548,
0.3336162865,
0.5918352604,
0.0200014934,
0.4571464658,
0.4741772711,
0.5852472186,
0.5071808696,
0.068819955,
1.3215845823,
-0.2852545381,
0.0916615054,
1.0422053337,
-0.332803905,
0.6391447186,
0.2225368768,
0.0455672182,
0.1118728369,
0.4396117628,
0.1058024466,
0.5785443187,
0.0521102846,
-0.2256245613,
-0.4418795705,
-0.2554764748,
-0.4317975938,
0.5785169005,
0.2089752555,
-0.172431767,
-0.5616081953,
0.2703334093,
0.2135574222,
0.3141542375,
-0.3194440901,
1.0443468094,
-0.1572553515,
-0.7150509357,
0.6624315977,
0.0083439387,
0.5044908524,
-0.9631545544,
0.0229979865,
-0.0231404267,
0.1278546304,
-0.0214073285,
-0.3559148312,
0.3121459484,
0.4116296172,
-0.0224677231,
-0.176667124,
0.994546175,
0.0371877067,
-0.3392876387,
0.3194058239,
0.2888369262,
-0.1223395094,
-0.1066062674,
-0.3217981458,
0.1006694511,
-0.3716581464,
-0.3179959357,
0.7031969428,
0.4626188278,
-0.020434482,
0.5422916412,
0.7498888969,
0.035830304,
0.2451836169,
0.0590647087,
1.2375098467,
-0.5958536863,
-0.8058311939,
-1.1111880541,
0.3193874061,
0.1539390534,
-0.3818971515,
0.8833447695,
0.2066555619,
0.8191120028,
-0.0253985375,
0.6073504686,
0.041745957,
0.1897615939,
-0.8360890746,
0.6502433419,
-0.1408645213,
0.4436694682,
-0.3094182014,
-0.7345833182,
-0.4723508358,
0.4911998808,
-0.2838206887,
-0.0277688839,
0.653427422,
0.9448553324,
0.182633847,
0.2530714571,
0.3915934563,
0.1329415739,
0.2254530042,
0.4706190228,
1.1025596857,
-0.0200545825,
0.5440274477,
-0.0957164913,
-0.3614673913,
-0.0223028921,
-0.7836623192,
-1.0477038622,
-0.429820925,
0.062600866,
-0.5099295378,
0.0061599631,
1.0390908718,
0.3414423466,
-0.829295218,
0.2723262906,
-0.2665306628,
-0.2064534277,
0.0609365404,
-0.1698622704,
0.4165083766,
-0.8816226721,
-0.4109204113,
0.6095080972,
0.0933470502,
-0.046331834,
-0.1562189311,
0.0886369944,
-0.0081384294,
0.0257295705,
0.3892727494,
0.3272585273,
-0.5246134996,
-0.2319178134,
0.1345251501,
-0.3809346855,
-0.1459475011,
0.8265229464,
-0.7950250506,
0.4869988561,
0.4497698843,
1.1798853874,
-0.2341480702,
0.1190405637,
0.4985033572,
-0.6237638593,
0.207020238,
0.2140294909,
0.5679376125,
0.1962543428,
-0.3926463127,
0.0903410539,
0.1953907907,
-0.3523696661,
-0.8095322847,
0.4420394599,
-1.1103579998,
-0.4122425318,
1.2168413401,
-0.5205446482,
-0.4768417478,
-0.4352927506,
-0.4721608758,
0.1701527536,
-0.2515497506,
0.5120000243,
0.6529681087,
0.2382870913,
0.4107270241,
-0.538214922,
0.4633267224,
0.397931546,
-0.713303566,
0.3076663613,
0.482717663,
0.0470770746,
0.1606951803,
0.4692408144,
-0.1429954171,
0.467128098,
0.5099895597,
-0.2498146594,
-0.3887971044,
-0.4044699371,
-0.6087573171,
0.4845578372,
0.3414892852,
-0.0767394975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12867v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12867v4 | Red teaming ChatGPT via Jailbreaking: Bias, Robustness, Reliability and Toxicity | 2023-01-30T13:20:48 | 2023-05-29T17:46:54 | Terry Yue Zhuo, Yujin Huang, Chunyang Chen, Zhenchang Xing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Recent breakthroughs in natural language processing (NLP) have permitted the
synthesis and comprehension of coherent text in an open-ended way, therefore
translating the theoretical algorithms into practical applications. The large
language models (LLMs) have significantly impacted businesses such as report
summarization software and copywriters. Observations indicate, however, that
LLMs may exhibit social prejudice and toxicity, posing ethical and societal
dangers of consequences resulting from irresponsibility. Large-scale benchmarks
for accountable LLMs should consequently be developed. Although several
empirical investigations reveal the existence of a few ethical difficulties in
advanced LLMs, there is little systematic examination and user study of the
risks and harmful behaviors of current LLM usage. To further educate future
efforts on constructing ethical LLMs responsibly, we perform a qualitative
research method called ``red teaming'' on OpenAI's ChatGPT\footnote{In this
paper, ChatGPT refers to the version released on Dec 15th.} to better
understand the practical features of ethical dangers in recent LLMs. We analyze
ChatGPT comprehensively from four perspectives: 1) \textit{Bias} 2)
\textit{Reliability} 3) \textit{Robustness} 4) \textit{Toxicity}. In accordance
with our stated viewpoints, we empirically benchmark ChatGPT on multiple sample
datasets. We find that a significant number of ethical risks cannot be
addressed by existing benchmarks, and hence illustrate them via additional case
studies. In addition, we examine the implications of our findings on AI ethics
and harmal behaviors of ChatGPT, as well as future problems and practical
design considerations for responsible LLMs. We believe that our findings may
give light on future efforts to determine and mitigate the ethical hazards
posed by machines in LLM applications. | [
-0.1283800006,
-0.7381064296,
0.3701227307,
0.2161593437,
-0.0459967665,
0.0989876017,
-0.1669052392,
-0.9973798394,
-0.120623365,
0.7724980116,
-0.5050555468,
-0.2312146574,
-0.6433519125,
0.0937057436,
-0.3109247983,
1.4378010035,
-0.0739414692,
-0.0616410896,
0.0255076271,
-0.4283675253,
-0.6361012459,
-0.8404698968,
-0.7796918154,
-0.1772629172,
0.5372725129,
0.2821015418,
0.783950448,
0.3536140919,
0.8160803318,
0.2958501577,
-0.2803416848,
-0.2389079183,
-0.7991310954,
0.3923284709,
-0.0594238602,
-0.6315103769,
-0.3984497488,
0.2738448381,
0.2724370062,
0.236476928,
-0.1749195307,
0.2033028901,
0.1000914797,
0.7551654577,
-0.5789910555,
0.0335490517,
-0.8388361931,
0.0750576332,
-0.1474328339,
-0.2281143963,
-0.5216075182,
-0.4865023792,
0.0446150079,
-0.3849829137,
-0.1191700026,
0.1889891922,
0.7152194977,
0.5269260406,
-0.149612233,
-0.4617564678,
-0.7249245644,
0.9488375783,
-0.6500687599,
-0.0527946204,
0.3170972764,
0.4744444489,
-0.0811621845,
-0.6968421936,
-0.2870543599,
-0.2464421988,
0.0107518751,
0.147744149,
-0.1900686622,
0.0933910161,
0.1835749596,
0.283439666,
-0.3666268587,
0.3339496851,
-0.5388684869,
-0.095908083,
0.7523867488,
0.2413582951,
0.6942318082,
0.0739095807,
-0.5806267262,
0.0035836769,
-0.9879159927,
-0.3337668777,
0.5374413729,
0.0915036872,
-0.2553318441,
0.6687865853,
0.1606307328,
0.2621311545,
-0.4602054954,
0.1461937726,
0.1252583265,
-0.4531629384,
-0.2179266959,
0.1274762899,
0.9721695185,
0.7771071196,
0.7538390756,
-0.1935240477,
-0.0153847178,
0.0806293488,
0.4405335784,
-0.5582436323,
-0.1819909662,
0.4831107557,
-0.4857647717,
-0.6094620228,
-0.1051372066,
-0.7348706722,
-0.5785084367,
0.0912189111,
0.1926914006,
-0.4923668504,
-0.3130888939,
-0.0752514526,
-0.1847285032,
0.3920999765,
0.082435362,
-0.6574193239,
0.1804587841,
0.7786809206,
0.9619656801,
-0.2183622122,
-0.4617970288,
-0.4183979034,
0.0993056521,
-0.1164361909,
0.5129824877,
-0.2880025506,
-0.3970364928,
-0.1338347495,
-0.1871162206,
0.1039646044,
-0.621525228,
0.5610820651,
-0.4274184406,
0.0980740488,
-0.2069978863,
-0.2990858853,
-0.0246922821,
0.4089925885,
-0.4862497747,
0.5238605738,
-0.284519434,
-1.0794043541,
0.4024999142,
-0.9415321946,
-0.322342664,
0.1366215348,
-0.0472543463,
-0.4532522857,
-0.3408567309,
-0.0363180302,
0.4465440512,
-0.1087100059,
0.2283233106,
-0.4092526138,
-0.394068718,
0.3778444827,
-0.564250052,
1.3347849846,
0.2133942842,
-0.4132766128,
0.223790884,
-0.2974833548,
0.0106730554,
0.2875195146,
-0.2272039801,
-0.3258930147,
0.1285806894,
0.0209834296,
0.218387574,
-0.0038857826,
-0.4314916134,
-0.3082016408,
-0.1822145134,
0.8369135857,
1.0593186617,
0.1210313886,
0.3019311726,
-0.5811846256,
0.5517225862,
-0.3781492412,
0.5265583992,
0.0188411213,
-0.4743984044,
-0.5134423375,
-0.176519528,
0.0264657605,
0.771392405,
-0.4359063804,
0.2059988379,
-0.057040967,
-0.4505417049,
-0.4187715352,
-0.1096802354,
0.457767576,
0.2959215045,
0.2543796599,
-0.0761083215,
-0.520381391,
-0.9393171072,
-0.5366062522,
-0.3668068945,
-0.0124334078,
0.5132170916,
0.5285952687,
-0.3625874519,
0.7375187278,
-0.1922483295,
-0.3701441288,
-0.2804923952,
0.0681006759,
0.0119974241,
0.5146469474,
0.3479401171,
-0.8002637625,
-0.4051422477,
-0.1651367545,
-0.9645433426,
-0.0078931302,
-0.0369875059,
-0.0985330567,
0.441041708,
0.544475019,
-0.4865301251,
0.2478166819,
0.7531894445,
-0.284047991,
0.8072007895,
0.0517956465,
0.0688780323,
-0.8611039519,
0.0659974068,
0.1115969718,
-0.124651663,
-0.5288177133,
0.3002327085,
-0.2534096241,
-0.1035696045,
-0.7487699389,
0.2791276276,
-0.3019781411,
-0.1769491732,
-0.1406133473,
0.2556622624,
-0.4239128232,
0.2147968858,
-0.1643755138,
0.922976315,
0.1797379255,
-0.4673496187,
0.3757214248,
0.1932958961,
-0.2804505825,
0.4507329166,
-0.9419386983,
0.0836695433,
0.1148869917,
0.1299427748,
-0.5865910649,
-0.0331814922,
0.357642144,
-0.56493783,
-0.0104614301,
-0.1307278574,
-0.7147203684,
0.0246805381,
-0.3353072107,
0.4761412144,
0.7497728467,
-0.376973033,
0.0948344246,
0.8150430322,
-0.3548101783,
-0.6151753664,
-0.9604222178,
0.3202422857,
-0.6169891953,
-0.8283873796,
0.0363613516,
0.1015226543,
-0.7940405607,
-0.0734170526,
0.022954639,
-0.0675476342,
0.3332874775,
0.3259230256,
0.3371044397,
0.1191239804,
-0.1915966272,
-0.4981792569,
-0.2985863388,
0.3953845799,
0.2446557432,
0.4636353254,
-0.4962532818,
-0.1951887459,
-0.2398850471,
0.3570185006,
0.5662266016,
-0.1793372929,
0.795214951,
0.3145316541,
-0.1650206298,
-0.0595877357,
-0.4807974994,
-0.2205958515,
-0.508321166,
0.3314097226,
0.39425385,
-1.1344741583,
0.4592668712,
0.1073663533,
0.3929852247,
0.2370480746,
0.6311708093,
-0.2484181821,
0.6635568738,
0.7345199585,
-0.290311873,
0.3474880457,
0.1218742281,
0.3739394546,
-0.7050955892,
-0.1870699227,
-0.5151860118,
-0.18913728,
-0.8924774528,
-0.234333396,
0.5837415457,
-0.2477483153,
-0.5521919131,
0.1857397705,
-0.632014215,
0.7795397639,
0.5204433203,
0.0365087129,
0.5019860864,
-0.3246770501,
0.1511581242,
-0.0891418383,
-0.5869531035,
-0.7336171865,
0.9042798877,
0.6646270156,
0.9002605677,
0.2466079891,
0.753995955,
0.3037457764,
0.3353194296,
-0.6038307548,
0.6325757504,
0.1207576841,
-0.9188913107,
-0.3796038628,
-0.4914308786,
-0.9112914801,
0.0947912261,
-0.059332341,
-0.9939041138,
-0.2680967748,
0.0932015777,
-0.0775377303,
0.3390840888,
-0.9597714543,
0.7373226285,
-0.3458493948,
-0.4575213194,
-0.2091892213,
-0.9599189758,
0.7523584962,
0.0970931649,
0.2254232019,
-0.1389606446,
0.1075785384,
0.7894463539,
-0.4285746515,
1.1779628992,
0.0717088133,
-0.049854748,
0.2193981409,
0.1243619919,
0.562091589,
0.1267228127,
-0.0655730665,
0.3229508996,
-0.0105125178,
-0.3342316449,
-0.1095431224,
0.6984371543,
-0.6643356085,
-0.5914976001,
-0.6502935886,
-0.6142895222,
-0.2771469355,
0.306968689,
0.2367819399,
-0.0830010623,
-0.163975656,
0.1779113114,
0.6841042638,
-0.6833693385,
0.3953463137,
0.2723596394,
-0.1284877062,
-0.1673276126,
0.7634572387,
-0.0922298282,
0.6033472419,
-0.1204835176,
0.090936169,
-0.0782727525,
-0.6874183416,
-0.2143566757,
0.2731247842,
-0.5242564678,
-0.1307682097,
-0.4093564451,
-0.4032141268,
-0.0052323695,
-0.3903404772,
-0.526498735,
-0.0753280446,
-0.0385672227,
-0.139713183,
0.41944471,
0.6988928318,
0.1399743706,
0.0132486932,
-0.7775983214,
0.1413059086,
0.1460864395,
0.4789879322,
-0.2348308265,
-0.1068063304,
0.1070412323,
0.080039531,
-0.2919691503,
-0.5953512788,
0.2043914199,
-0.3779695332,
0.6220054626,
0.0194528736,
0.4067047834,
0.2709462345,
-0.3121856153,
0.8307108283,
0.25076738,
-0.764016211,
0.5038317442,
-0.7308158875,
-0.0948945433,
0.6262418628,
0.3859343529,
-0.6352935433,
-0.7363786101,
-0.731058836,
-0.9676112533,
0.6453462243,
0.5361132026,
0.0900082812,
0.0512074232,
0.1833533496,
-0.069778055,
0.0566028878,
-0.9846909642,
-0.2990351617,
0.116819784,
0.1263709664,
0.0152540561,
-0.3908670247,
-0.3593480289,
0.2892969847,
0.6695403457,
0.2700662017,
0.2979186475,
0.0459897183,
-0.0198461059,
0.1245635077,
0.4528813362,
0.5872123837,
0.5342578292,
-0.2607990205,
-0.0431903303,
0.1629498154,
-0.4472171962,
0.0802806616,
-0.1628806144,
-0.1191501096,
-0.3940008879,
0.4287394285,
0.3171691,
0.0114300698,
-0.9358657002,
0.5651009679,
-0.0786235929,
-0.2377347499,
-0.5002038479,
0.1040363833,
0.0176946558,
0.2590148747,
0.0189402644,
0.1145196706,
0.0332014821,
-0.7905936837,
0.1926851571,
0.5396940708,
-0.4033772945,
0.0741766095,
0.7381695509,
0.4181657732,
-0.2757447362,
0.6599861979,
0.0097323377,
-0.5214838386,
0.6197080612,
0.435256362,
0.913928628,
0.0538418777,
0.1864455789,
0.0881300345,
0.7152992487,
-0.1924231499,
-0.110341087,
0.4328542352,
-0.8518712521,
-0.6241059303,
-0.153504923,
-0.8525375128,
0.0795723274,
-0.5731823444,
0.0796759948,
-0.5926575065,
-0.1120462269,
-0.2798013985,
-0.1651339382,
-0.1277229488,
-0.1356180161,
-0.0640242621,
0.6897900105,
-0.5112147927,
0.4804285467,
0.4599347115,
-0.285197705,
-0.5370616317,
0.154451102,
0.2672369182,
-1.0027928352,
0.5259355307,
0.1925239712,
-0.1437143832,
-0.3413483202,
-0.6598380208,
-0.4009429514,
1.0763700008,
0.3735406995,
-0.4791964889,
0.0400614068,
0.0787382498,
0.3796104193,
0.0927795172,
0.0633442402,
0.6095046997,
0.4753299356,
-0.063797608,
-1.0217686892,
0.2598517537,
-0.206674993,
-0.185068801,
0.3030030131,
-0.8718266487,
0.6617262959,
-0.4311817586,
-0.3450286984,
-0.1143369228,
0.0515430532,
0.5475777388,
0.3122716546,
0.3382374942,
0.347034812,
0.6040732265,
-0.0089790486,
1.1959106922,
-0.0134121673,
0.2059474438,
1.0036158562,
-0.367508024,
0.6015321612,
0.661432445,
-0.2313309461,
-0.0497465879,
0.2457507551,
-0.122950308,
0.3438881934,
0.3128867745,
-0.2587277591,
0.003111138,
-0.0400270708,
-0.2757483721,
0.3385148644,
0.2417156249,
-0.4170002341,
-0.1654672027,
-0.2061365843,
0.3757179379,
0.0191446729,
-0.2416930795,
0.7369677424,
0.2508749366,
-0.536415875,
0.4009087086,
-0.022105366,
1.0313357115,
-0.344296664,
0.0920239314,
-0.0605067424,
0.1696553677,
-0.2706363797,
-0.8901678324,
0.679030776,
0.3605132699,
0.2426889986,
-0.2789359987,
0.850074172,
0.2280575633,
-0.1345945597,
0.3303137124,
0.4263551533,
0.2342104316,
-0.1179067418,
-0.7167474031,
0.3733959794,
0.0937814638,
-0.0237297341,
0.5811473131,
0.1649526358,
0.0764548928,
1.1097453833,
0.5798692703,
0.1246038452,
-0.0463117361,
-0.2618040144,
0.8087512255,
-0.7895026803,
-0.2648860812,
-1.1396279335,
0.3998554647,
-0.1419768035,
-0.2567713261,
0.6864410043,
0.2437761277,
0.7488123775,
0.3314014673,
1.0316135883,
-0.0278990716,
0.3178674579,
-0.7667848468,
1.1510673761,
-0.1398411095,
0.5590341091,
-0.4003101587,
-0.7165353894,
-0.4261693954,
0.5201960802,
-0.3821153641,
0.1809880435,
0.6354758143,
0.591893971,
0.401920706,
0.3309381604,
0.2090500891,
0.3118114769,
0.5287955403,
0.5173977017,
0.9759073257,
-0.2150925696,
0.9382677078,
-0.2210048139,
-0.2868397832,
-0.2309427112,
-1.0832364559,
-0.9571280479,
-0.2482278198,
-0.3523636758,
-0.4236834943,
0.3830804825,
0.6420903206,
0.3738823533,
-0.4873591661,
-0.083573088,
-0.3314660192,
0.2619673908,
-0.1431386471,
-0.2910054922,
-0.0725702122,
-0.3407702148,
-0.505907774,
0.0673895553,
0.294421196,
0.0271139313,
-0.1633199155,
-0.1369035542,
-0.0073655182,
-0.2913739383,
0.6940131783,
0.3939942122,
-0.541829586,
-0.4867468178,
-0.1928622872,
-0.1125370711,
-0.0294659566,
0.7078339458,
-0.3275828362,
-0.0133323064,
0.1548599303,
0.7546446323,
0.121429041,
-0.0815904364,
0.8345358968,
-0.3048199713,
-0.0843054429,
0.7009214759,
0.2958336473,
0.1534048468,
-0.387876749,
0.8295686841,
-0.0492379665,
-1.0905809402,
-1.0063718557,
0.199592486,
-0.9590162039,
-0.2398531735,
1.4490857124,
-0.1204151437,
-0.041458331,
-0.3201361001,
-0.2948495448,
0.0488095284,
-0.3787781,
0.8876579404,
0.5953772664,
-0.270378828,
-0.2622771561,
-0.9855291843,
0.3056612611,
0.3235542476,
-0.8876996636,
0.4280991852,
0.4528532028,
0.4173968136,
-0.0141575783,
0.6997973919,
-0.5112438798,
0.2294214368,
0.0288543217,
-0.014724317,
-0.1981108934,
-0.0000016976,
-0.0872997046,
0.0943053737,
0.2232241482,
-0.1784599274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12866v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12866v2 | N-Gram Nearest Neighbor Machine Translation | 2023-01-30T13:19:19 | 2023-02-07T14:15:26 | Rui Lv, Junliang Guo, Rui Wang, Xu Tan, Qi Liu, Tao Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Nearest neighbor machine translation augments the Autoregressive
Translation~(AT) with $k$-nearest-neighbor retrieval, by comparing the
similarity between the token-level context representations of the target tokens
in the query and the datastore. However, the token-level representation may
introduce noise when translating ambiguous words, or fail to provide accurate
retrieval results when the representation generated by the model contains
indistinguishable context information, e.g., Non-Autoregressive
Translation~(NAT) models. In this paper, we propose a novel $n$-gram nearest
neighbor retrieval method that is model agnostic and applicable to both AT and
NAT models. Specifically, we concatenate the adjacent $n$-gram hidden
representations as the key, while the tuple of corresponding target tokens is
the value. In inference, we propose tailored decoding algorithms for AT and NAT
models respectively. We demonstrate that the proposed method consistently
outperforms the token-level method on both AT and NAT models as well on general
as on domain adaptation translation tasks. On domain adaptation, the proposed
method brings $1.03$ and $2.76$ improvements regarding the average BLEU score
on AT and NAT models respectively. | [
-0.2733558416,
-0.7039170861,
0.3490915895,
-0.1146267578,
-0.3770027161,
0.1941535771,
-0.1364450157,
-0.5490392447,
0.1497942358,
0.2987139225,
-0.225479573,
-0.6719214916,
-0.667843461,
0.3737448752,
-0.4316682518,
0.4166505337,
0.0666174144,
0.0671585128,
0.0628095493,
-0.1123866364,
-0.1537749767,
-0.680175066,
-0.4990110695,
-0.0313316099,
0.219096601,
0.2656626105,
0.7315094471,
0.6886636019,
0.6594338417,
0.2599419355,
-0.360598743,
0.5986115932,
-0.1034759805,
-0.2882347703,
-0.1440273374,
-0.5335949063,
-0.5705615878,
-0.1455619484,
0.9355486631,
0.5842291117,
0.2901863456,
0.1591874063,
-0.1778661162,
0.8637030721,
-0.5735282302,
0.1341918707,
-0.8815977573,
0.1456672102,
-0.2756100595,
-0.2537924647,
-0.5369874239,
-0.6091731191,
-0.2047475874,
-0.3489190638,
0.3277743757,
0.3377171457,
0.9055207372,
0.2933609188,
-0.5753762126,
-0.1051658466,
-0.3696867824,
0.7401609421,
-0.8920838833,
0.6592348218,
0.7077786326,
0.4909460545,
-0.3786607385,
-0.3764757216,
-0.5848436952,
-0.2822030485,
-0.249280557,
-0.1331607103,
-0.4499160051,
-0.0470129475,
-0.0135638118,
0.8174715042,
-0.4891237617,
-0.0714444146,
-0.1099132672,
-0.1994795203,
0.3466319442,
-0.1093573272,
-0.0344136208,
-0.3331093192,
-0.3246694505,
0.0297999792,
-0.496887207,
-0.3554646969,
0.3049779534,
0.6821959019,
0.0177724361,
0.4053832293,
-0.3690922558,
1.0620034933,
0.1806321889,
0.0997345373,
0.6546747088,
-0.3751139045,
-0.064193137,
-0.0125623615,
0.6206586957,
0.4378161132,
-0.0580138117,
-0.5436756015,
-0.2357415855,
-0.1856492162,
0.1870840937,
-0.6397624612,
-0.1937859356,
-0.1369640678,
-0.9040360451,
-0.4654966295,
-0.0041651321,
-0.847069025,
0.0422113054,
-0.0380369425,
0.5438862443,
-0.4407925308,
-0.3554503024,
-0.0532818623,
0.1002767906,
0.2672721148,
-0.1286539137,
-0.5818799734,
0.407171607,
0.5262985229,
1.3273466825,
-0.2279897034,
-0.0276142508,
-0.7586088181,
0.037123397,
-0.4436191022,
0.4867200851,
-0.7455619574,
-0.5784463286,
-0.2920144796,
0.0814765915,
-0.2069333047,
-0.7212022543,
0.3236456215,
-0.8030796647,
0.1154813319,
-0.3148192167,
-0.6790837646,
-0.5203758478,
0.2474385947,
-0.5348937511,
0.9929577112,
0.125497818,
-0.6823379397,
0.0421858244,
-0.9381269217,
-0.3139197826,
-0.2396169901,
0.2687266171,
-0.3905864656,
0.5673997402,
0.5372931957,
0.2569968104,
-0.1449247897,
0.0163410157,
-0.2747918069,
-0.264855504,
0.0860233158,
-0.6009248495,
0.5677680373,
0.2384206802,
-0.0810492933,
-0.1352820694,
-0.7308391929,
0.1569837481,
0.1868776977,
-0.1230255961,
-0.352704376,
-0.2898969054,
-0.2717709243,
0.0974468589,
0.4464732111,
-0.5968491435,
0.3065199256,
-0.4003271461,
0.5727688074,
0.4903095067,
0.0449762605,
0.5876552463,
-0.2913590968,
0.317827791,
0.0356729254,
-0.0623234883,
-0.0771840811,
-0.7383596897,
-0.3900907338,
-0.0983456075,
0.7168003917,
0.3687151372,
-0.8746336102,
0.3886931241,
-0.549087882,
-0.3998034894,
-0.7147539258,
-0.1433504224,
0.6747922897,
0.7659124732,
0.7781133652,
-0.341042161,
-0.1844529063,
-0.7948548198,
-0.2741861343,
-0.1904104203,
-0.0681821853,
0.505182445,
0.3750402927,
-0.332508713,
0.6957429647,
-0.4273930192,
-0.3501570523,
0.1358000785,
0.1742586046,
0.3226949871,
0.3537576497,
0.5321401954,
-0.7927470207,
-0.6890407801,
0.3542940021,
-0.3838410079,
-0.2018709332,
0.3932135105,
-0.2388114333,
0.3909733891,
0.6096580029,
-0.1834817529,
0.5844156742,
0.6683880091,
-0.2215193212,
0.5283304453,
-0.3895577788,
0.2570485175,
-1.1184405088,
0.3805045485,
-0.3237151504,
-0.637801826,
-0.5926325321,
0.2354624271,
0.3885141015,
0.1221372783,
-0.2070090771,
0.7184391022,
-0.6661772132,
-0.3869796395,
-0.6079153419,
0.008170018,
0.1616822779,
0.3602670431,
0.1175873503,
1.0690888166,
0.4383686185,
-0.7354006767,
0.2088163495,
0.3947685361,
-0.1074994057,
0.4595139921,
-0.3108170331,
0.4409003556,
0.0067125708,
0.2413465977,
-0.5250316858,
-0.0285285823,
0.1340027004,
-0.7849746346,
0.4309963584,
-0.4931635559,
-0.631270051,
-0.3383193612,
0.1222816333,
0.567148149,
0.3783022463,
-0.8519397974,
0.4033576846,
0.2898558974,
0.2097661197,
-0.3501675129,
-0.8806486726,
0.3410735726,
-0.2472477406,
-0.3475082815,
0.6717341542,
0.1268429458,
0.1062331721,
0.2125556022,
-0.1855986714,
-0.2086583227,
-0.1535990536,
-0.245306164,
0.0545897,
-0.3257779181,
-0.0325759798,
-0.1847634017,
-0.4330985844,
-0.0968146846,
-0.695156455,
0.385653466,
-0.4815716445,
-0.3320498466,
-0.1316258758,
0.4947836697,
0.4496569335,
-0.4024379551,
0.6432286501,
0.7438111305,
-0.4955696464,
0.1544550955,
-0.3664239049,
-0.0998337045,
-0.5182332993,
0.3669362664,
-0.6655169725,
-0.6961976886,
0.6733848453,
-0.1518339068,
-0.1756323725,
0.2081478983,
0.2811228037,
0.3328252733,
0.8839626908,
0.4618330598,
-0.3886084259,
0.3254897892,
-0.1974725127,
0.5685350895,
-1.1253939867,
-0.1814039648,
-0.4978505373,
-0.4489431083,
-0.5532238483,
-0.9429168105,
0.2503319085,
0.1536151767,
0.0201919321,
0.5691230893,
-0.5595342517,
0.5393536687,
0.67258358,
0.1586754769,
0.4237761796,
0.272872299,
-0.4873349071,
-0.1975806504,
-0.7458399534,
-0.1644526571,
0.9103301167,
0.1202181727,
0.0730401203,
0.5980640054,
0.6655221581,
0.3199576139,
0.1033478826,
-0.7412924767,
0.4794546366,
-0.4507603943,
-0.4894979298,
-0.0474228449,
-0.8959375024,
-0.8480917811,
0.2307060361,
0.0503516085,
-0.7846795321,
0.2748757303,
0.0477726571,
-0.0491361283,
0.7269798517,
-0.5477865934,
0.7458082438,
-0.0646791086,
-0.0709922016,
0.0876751915,
-0.7038538456,
0.0469959304,
-0.2058244795,
0.2697840035,
0.0290902983,
-0.1163932011,
0.215006724,
-0.3902598321,
0.3522647023,
-0.2583143711,
0.0623181537,
0.1781969219,
0.5083300471,
0.633045435,
-0.2328749448,
-0.5236858726,
0.6513301134,
-0.3713925481,
-0.4445221722,
-0.7148835659,
0.7463489175,
-0.4574789107,
-0.3708893955,
-0.1646920741,
-0.5245467424,
-0.224505499,
0.4512259066,
0.3368878663,
0.3131071329,
0.1715136021,
0.0593718439,
0.5458804965,
-0.1336899102,
0.4152920842,
0.6290678382,
-0.2787773311,
-0.5838066936,
1.1730452776,
-0.0680819079,
0.4227618277,
0.6748404503,
0.2242972851,
-0.6888610125,
-0.6636315584,
-0.5439543128,
0.0697890371,
-0.6443133354,
-0.5809575915,
-0.6800841093,
-0.1732322127,
-0.168135643,
-0.1219061688,
-0.4102801383,
-0.3354329467,
-0.2902719378,
-0.0511181988,
0.6592317224,
0.5282763243,
-0.3514243364,
0.2393204421,
-0.9434933662,
0.3792318106,
-0.081030935,
0.5375341177,
0.2239246666,
-0.8676877618,
-0.180848226,
0.0424545072,
0.0190159865,
-1.1959177256,
0.6109765172,
0.3840035796,
0.3697837889,
0.1853403896,
0.1335429996,
0.9679017067,
-0.7591292858,
0.5879040956,
-0.0472284071,
-1.1341483593,
0.46136114,
-0.1852201968,
0.4607519805,
0.6144904494,
0.2138460129,
-0.3314176798,
-0.1157626435,
-0.4832595587,
-0.7942973971,
0.571280241,
0.4087955058,
0.0199489165,
-0.2893388271,
0.4808593094,
-0.0374400243,
0.1200939715,
-0.5825260282,
-0.4468414783,
-0.1029206067,
-0.0704326332,
0.0099392347,
-0.0855812207,
0.4835573733,
-0.3217330873,
0.7864439487,
-0.25329265,
0.7869289517,
0.1556711942,
-0.1070937663,
-0.1118506566,
-0.1154326499,
0.2435528189,
-0.0101547381,
-0.3568546474,
0.2311540693,
0.4839766622,
-0.3059616089,
0.0298030898,
0.0036902148,
-0.2373314649,
0.5156137347,
0.0678800195,
0.5414230824,
0.1454563141,
-0.0369973406,
0.5899587274,
-0.0348681025,
-0.2389805615,
0.0920618474,
-0.285646379,
-0.033023037,
0.1608130932,
0.2929956913,
0.240723297,
0.4203954637,
-0.2908140421,
0.5072510839,
0.4489004016,
-0.4920296073,
-0.1631546617,
0.7303158641,
-0.0731068403,
-0.5810648799,
0.5331076384,
-0.7251268029,
-0.645920217,
0.2784228325,
0.8090683222,
0.9314337373,
-0.2190499604,
0.0383577943,
0.5747984648,
0.2330405116,
-0.0787979811,
0.2523998618,
-0.1581311822,
-0.2825132012,
-0.3863330781,
-0.7536399961,
-0.2036103308,
0.0693797022,
-0.7517427206,
0.0942985862,
-0.0340427533,
-0.3188354969,
-0.3256670833,
0.1101070419,
-0.3143659532,
-0.0119571472,
0.1595626771,
0.9298766851,
-0.50060004,
0.9213821888,
0.7426667809,
-0.0544018298,
-0.5364496708,
0.4485785961,
-0.2201167494,
-0.6996074319,
0.3647782207,
0.1931349188,
-0.2133528888,
0.1772268564,
-0.1553321481,
-1.2971566916,
0.8612110019,
0.3168483078,
-0.4303043783,
0.0607916042,
0.2102286071,
0.4520787001,
-0.3210588992,
0.1100708991,
0.3069934249,
0.5145943165,
0.1510130763,
-1.0536042452,
0.1242352873,
-0.4107031524,
0.2653323114,
0.3420359492,
-0.6782864332,
0.599684,
-0.1278466582,
-0.1429331452,
0.1208558306,
0.882678926,
0.040921431,
0.3008045256,
0.305583626,
0.4052420557,
0.9158777595,
0.0999122933,
0.8800017834,
-0.5624014735,
0.2467397749,
1.2975466251,
0.2255178243,
0.9215140939,
0.2810252607,
-0.1653744429,
0.305598706,
0.3784154952,
0.0538599417,
0.8764141798,
0.2425774634,
-0.2075196058,
-0.1701958179,
0.0000137896,
-0.5874742866,
0.424729228,
0.4401553869,
-0.5730870366,
-0.4284523427,
-0.2540926337,
-0.1713071316,
0.2201340348,
-0.3128729463,
0.624732852,
0.2858358622,
-0.1751856059,
0.9025810957,
0.4969989061,
0.5588696599,
-0.1889083982,
-0.0742249563,
-0.3442752361,
-0.0396353155,
-0.1419391781,
-0.1902669668,
0.6592273712,
0.1094604656,
-0.2831101418,
0.0232541468,
0.5913095474,
-0.331939131,
-0.7167368531,
0.3137652278,
0.3490962684,
0.4351707399,
-0.2970633507,
-0.8386682868,
-0.0681096092,
0.1281683445,
0.143509686,
0.1881478429,
0.6571959257,
-0.1152869761,
0.6550955772,
0.6931828856,
0.0981258303,
0.4774624109,
-0.2277114838,
0.5782293677,
-0.5885139108,
-0.6442976594,
-0.7340344191,
-0.0629272684,
-0.0274528507,
-0.091278106,
0.8916708231,
0.5400757194,
0.6839655042,
0.1380045116,
0.4798285067,
0.0767432749,
0.4205097556,
-0.4529057741,
0.4698115885,
-0.6701875925,
0.1025689393,
-0.2809566855,
-1.075553894,
-0.5183001161,
0.8883013129,
-0.4484985471,
0.0188075341,
0.5033262968,
0.8828687072,
-0.3668230176,
0.0342003889,
0.4929754436,
0.0528987944,
0.122047998,
0.6015965939,
0.3539003134,
-0.8460040689,
0.4865569472,
-0.0333489999,
-0.0392906144,
-0.4433172345,
-0.9464166164,
-0.7626520395,
-0.409212321,
-0.3522086143,
-0.4460953474,
0.1758270413,
0.7452998161,
0.6322342753,
-0.7566832304,
0.2657721937,
-0.2341734469,
0.0788720846,
-0.2923830152,
-0.1850909591,
0.5292435288,
-0.2688739002,
-0.7603508234,
0.7621537447,
0.0725514069,
0.1653690189,
-0.0093568424,
-0.2429723442,
-0.145505935,
-0.0528422296,
0.2677086294,
0.1737163663,
-0.5548960567,
-0.1605687141,
0.1205866635,
0.0237973034,
0.2508209944,
0.3768518269,
-0.6688953638,
0.6058270335,
0.4537237287,
0.7379148006,
0.4149960876,
0.1375804991,
0.4481801093,
-0.9368622899,
0.1653307676,
0.2550934553,
0.1435809135,
0.5553818941,
-0.4725627303,
0.3554278612,
0.1202263311,
-0.4393964708,
-0.8762252927,
0.4399686158,
-0.5216276646,
-0.2018455118,
1.2221767902,
-0.2972769141,
-0.4244733155,
-0.095603399,
0.2391324341,
0.2344037294,
-0.3303569853,
0.7927349806,
0.4461806417,
0.2794887424,
0.0823924914,
-0.6466991901,
0.3471197784,
0.499677211,
-0.0754953474,
0.0879966915,
0.2218261957,
0.1179683506,
0.0773061588,
0.4456966221,
-0.5622906089,
-0.0337346457,
0.0428417623,
-0.202908501,
-0.3877944648,
-0.2702951133,
-0.4280876517,
-0.1111902595,
-0.0354646146,
-0.4891797304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12855v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12855v1 | How Far Can It Go?: On Intrinsic Gender Bias Mitigation for Text Classification | 2023-01-30T13:05:48 | 2023-01-30T13:05:48 | Ewoenam Tokpo, Pieter Delobelle, Bettina Berendt, Toon Calders | cs.CL | cs.CL | To mitigate gender bias in contextualized language models, different
intrinsic mitigation strategies have been proposed, alongside many bias
metrics. Considering that the end use of these language models is for
downstream tasks like text classification, it is important to understand how
these intrinsic bias mitigation strategies actually translate to fairness in
downstream tasks and the extent of this. In this work, we design a probe to
investigate the effects that some of the major intrinsic gender bias mitigation
strategies have on downstream text classification tasks. We discover that
instead of resolving gender bias, intrinsic mitigation techniques and metrics
are able to hide it in such a way that significant gender information is
retained in the embeddings. Furthermore, we show that each mitigation technique
is able to hide the bias from some of the intrinsic bias measures but not all,
and each intrinsic bias measure can be fooled by some mitigation techniques,
but not all. We confirm experimentally, that none of the intrinsic mitigation
techniques used without any other fairness intervention is able to consistently
impact extrinsic bias. We recommend that intrinsic bias mitigation techniques
should be combined with other fairness interventions for downstream tasks. | [
-0.3691142201,
-0.8608344197,
0.4925732613,
-0.101595059,
0.0421201661,
0.1046720892,
-0.1115578637,
-0.4498178065,
-0.2681994736,
0.3475717902,
-0.6978310347,
-0.1818234921,
-0.7914837599,
-0.1041597798,
-0.5396956801,
1.3322606087,
0.0392550938,
0.1933590174,
-0.1382326782,
-0.1967024356,
-0.7524535656,
-0.7199121714,
-0.6443894506,
-0.1321726292,
0.5675269961,
0.3729743063,
0.0636856481,
0.4006450176,
0.5687226057,
0.2224331349,
-0.5404996276,
-0.222836256,
-0.5184357762,
0.3185425401,
-0.3581754565,
-0.7288710475,
-0.1872758269,
0.069299072,
0.8798831105,
0.8120728731,
-0.0706872791,
0.3028821647,
0.3288402557,
0.978701055,
-0.8970167637,
-0.0838753283,
-0.5065413713,
0.2934661806,
-0.293063134,
-0.0705152974,
-0.3692651391,
-0.1216697916,
0.3739640117,
-0.1114348248,
0.3032140732,
0.2511402667,
0.5693913102,
0.3128423393,
-0.6938222051,
-0.3352222741,
-0.8785861731,
1.0639890432,
-0.5672972798,
-0.0398364328,
0.2985722721,
0.3711481988,
0.3436065018,
-0.3305272758,
-0.4014287889,
0.0714678764,
-0.1286030561,
0.0000482525,
-0.316509515,
-0.0504770018,
0.4960622787,
0.3526043594,
-0.2182130516,
0.0121087013,
-0.2814463079,
-0.1606191546,
0.3317604959,
-0.1005748808,
0.3796524107,
-0.0520328023,
-0.1701523066,
-0.0113508347,
-0.7789418697,
0.4372596443,
0.8180521727,
0.2663811147,
0.0735141411,
0.5930339098,
-0.3220240772,
0.1942175031,
0.0403550193,
0.0775478259,
0.0238172244,
-0.475984782,
0.0989594534,
0.3277605176,
0.2365182042,
0.1529966593,
-0.1192886755,
-0.1760775745,
-0.2751381993,
0.001442729,
0.3199148476,
-0.6886883974,
0.1267719418,
0.0972800478,
-0.5086125731,
-0.3921890855,
-0.0222290102,
-0.5122115612,
-0.2912797332,
-0.2218005955,
0.5579255223,
-0.0535253845,
-0.2990299761,
-0.3054426908,
-0.5693455338,
0.2967156172,
0.2663939297,
-1.0013200045,
0.3718457222,
0.8665868044,
0.7735726237,
0.1210330576,
0.0726833791,
-0.6292372346,
0.2687370777,
-0.2684271038,
0.6619131565,
-0.6187002659,
-0.1380766034,
0.0005844,
-0.1605869979,
0.0292305909,
-0.2253828496,
0.7166724205,
-0.159417063,
0.374737829,
-0.524277091,
-0.5004815459,
-0.4558411539,
0.3289299905,
-0.5780997872,
0.7546587586,
-0.1190855205,
-1.1211453676,
0.4839038849,
-0.5578517318,
-0.4476296902,
-0.2308576405,
-0.1833145916,
-0.5758169889,
0.3541544676,
0.1558676362,
0.3310054839,
-0.2169042081,
0.3505464196,
-0.16147995,
-0.5365357995,
0.083760798,
-0.5420978069,
0.5458003879,
-0.3011307716,
-1.0190485716,
0.0520650148,
-0.1737017334,
-0.3030199111,
-0.2057417929,
-0.1257341057,
-0.5758980513,
0.2965717912,
-0.1734036952,
0.3007541001,
-0.1585562527,
-0.6148016453,
-0.1276290119,
-0.3242310584,
0.4690939784,
1.1490125656,
-0.3188839555,
1.1225590706,
-0.4003737867,
0.4548623264,
-0.1342390776,
0.0605606772,
-0.0430555493,
-0.6248170137,
-0.9006599784,
-0.3092510104,
0.411575675,
0.3809244931,
-0.5882091522,
0.3156032562,
-0.3763200641,
-0.3392688334,
-0.3355006278,
-0.1974169761,
0.69927001,
0.8821640015,
0.164651975,
-0.0377001762,
-0.005732019,
-1.1507474184,
-0.7217802405,
-0.0373224467,
-0.0119024608,
0.3048211634,
0.8933753967,
-0.0219952893,
1.0768824816,
-0.3601994514,
-0.6364032626,
-0.0705069005,
0.3672068715,
0.031981688,
0.6150289774,
0.482183367,
-0.984159112,
-0.1284118742,
-0.1403993666,
-0.4675941765,
-0.3988564312,
0.0851993188,
-0.2024399638,
0.2654953003,
0.5267974138,
-0.0756867081,
0.762152493,
0.3648972511,
-0.5788850188,
0.4461841583,
-0.0406033099,
0.258515358,
-0.3727056086,
0.0621483512,
-0.0500825383,
-0.2730853558,
-0.6048691869,
0.2016235739,
0.272113651,
0.1183658242,
-0.4551412761,
0.6993243098,
-0.3071076274,
0.073910147,
-0.2605508566,
-0.1794745624,
-0.1237724796,
0.4939966202,
0.1118820831,
0.5079807639,
0.4763460755,
-0.8436514735,
-0.4314478934,
0.0539661683,
0.1157809272,
0.8603109121,
-0.4167278111,
0.0687366277,
-0.519760251,
0.5469787121,
-1.071297884,
0.2024814934,
0.3569393158,
-0.6864972711,
0.37866956,
-0.3104444444,
-0.272693783,
-0.0496615954,
-0.7964890599,
0.5343735814,
0.410112828,
-0.6434908509,
0.9547592998,
0.2952207923,
-0.3262607753,
-0.7039578557,
-0.9979051948,
-0.1239896789,
-0.497862637,
-0.3936105072,
0.4938726425,
-0.1459925473,
-0.1184658185,
-0.2172879577,
-0.2062798589,
0.1252453178,
0.2291663289,
0.2449058592,
-0.0064072907,
0.2037223727,
0.2873742282,
0.897978723,
-0.211855635,
0.1313409954,
-0.2302809358,
0.4418883622,
0.0204646941,
-0.4303711057,
-0.2931990921,
0.761792779,
0.1703548282,
-0.1059814543,
0.9519659877,
0.8520959616,
-0.5269759297,
-0.1997176707,
-0.6135540009,
-0.3579540849,
-0.4863803387,
0.287152797,
-0.3290838003,
-1.2645576,
0.5261293054,
-0.0440806188,
0.3677784204,
0.5175923705,
0.3027059138,
-0.1605662405,
1.3324579,
0.8352527618,
-0.048402898,
0.3856111169,
-0.040156085,
0.3456592858,
-1.1010812521,
-0.1818795204,
-1.0203893185,
-0.535694778,
-0.7776983976,
-0.2362891138,
0.386004895,
0.1049563363,
-0.5419684052,
-0.1459837854,
-0.5105150342,
0.3861975372,
0.8242381811,
0.3423508108,
0.1437555552,
0.0659795403,
0.0190709569,
-0.2471416742,
-0.6594702005,
-0.5570074916,
0.9859874845,
0.536948204,
0.3781664968,
0.4414405823,
0.482272476,
0.5304167867,
0.5815175176,
-0.5278788209,
0.3837682307,
-0.2583475709,
-0.9330810308,
-0.2861712575,
-0.6798791289,
-0.4224599898,
0.1900578737,
-0.0522847399,
-0.7291895747,
0.2489740252,
0.2303714603,
0.1212172881,
0.4706745148,
-0.7836499214,
0.5543887019,
-0.0383410193,
-0.5562923551,
-0.1516049057,
-0.6577083468,
0.351385504,
-0.2263966054,
0.4477457106,
-0.0966120884,
-0.2364806682,
1.0055811405,
-0.2913819253,
0.8877999783,
-0.2785420418,
-0.2191418558,
-0.1331831664,
0.0498927869,
0.3329369128,
0.0408439189,
0.0440892354,
0.4545574784,
-0.3313890398,
-0.6189297438,
-0.3083064854,
0.6751340032,
-0.3750828505,
-0.498570174,
-0.6078032255,
-0.3212527931,
-0.0836180821,
0.1942981929,
0.2814489603,
0.5105112791,
0.1553478688,
0.1926655918,
0.7600368261,
-0.4778530896,
0.7608786821,
0.5302500129,
0.1543328315,
-0.1636589319,
0.8931637406,
0.0414202735,
0.2301796377,
0.7233587503,
0.5169490576,
-0.4325502515,
-0.3723931015,
-0.3019509017,
-0.0385900214,
-0.8513094187,
-0.1597076803,
-0.6958606839,
0.0712238029,
-0.5539895296,
-0.1753397733,
-0.2907189131,
-0.5051568151,
-0.2014793456,
-0.1537382156,
0.1544202715,
0.5856786966,
0.0406478234,
0.3926702142,
-0.5766578317,
0.0677030906,
0.4141141772,
0.200578317,
0.1778097451,
-0.6345332265,
0.0873383656,
0.1236179471,
-0.2027694583,
-0.6523017287,
0.4734182358,
0.1591365784,
0.5457062125,
0.2875576019,
0.1007034257,
0.4263527691,
-0.7289542556,
0.7485935688,
0.2513903379,
-1.4558475018,
0.6956102252,
-0.4409155548,
0.2257070988,
0.5243214369,
0.3110194802,
-0.373973757,
-0.569062233,
-0.2249818295,
-1.057166934,
0.8410247564,
0.6198861599,
0.3307418227,
0.0591888539,
0.3487302363,
0.2107521445,
0.5587439537,
-0.8586435914,
-0.4589229524,
0.2211319059,
-0.048719503,
0.2147304416,
-0.3257661462,
-0.1910618693,
-0.3764971495,
0.5520427823,
-0.1632422209,
0.6288166642,
0.3285873532,
-0.3012323976,
0.2461508512,
0.4149770141,
0.6780653,
0.3734355569,
-0.1881910861,
0.1142145768,
0.0236715619,
-0.5376640558,
0.1086893678,
-0.0546621047,
-0.4878571332,
-0.0932418332,
0.3291066587,
0.6368624568,
-0.0192020256,
-0.7315709591,
0.6421990991,
-0.3470984101,
-0.2392813861,
-0.1880975515,
0.0203317516,
-0.1514694095,
0.2628113627,
0.7697709203,
0.0298057068,
0.5036348701,
-0.4949650764,
-0.037727423,
0.541418612,
-0.8780056834,
-0.0188051779,
0.7025928497,
0.2811593413,
-0.1494475603,
0.393075794,
-0.1673420519,
-0.941393137,
0.6800507307,
0.2909713984,
0.8575259447,
-0.1966909319,
0.0807436928,
0.1613621116,
0.5479089618,
0.0365084112,
-0.0833012909,
-0.2445247918,
-0.4345548153,
-0.3695186675,
-0.4402013719,
-0.511685729,
-0.5739752054,
-0.5668803453,
0.0665301383,
-0.2277671248,
-0.1184242591,
-0.1816320568,
-0.1267928779,
-0.5604574084,
0.1572621465,
0.2150957733,
0.5846223235,
-0.7498413324,
0.0445318073,
0.5533729792,
-0.223155722,
-0.447976172,
0.1246084049,
0.1009846032,
-0.2897335291,
0.8465095758,
0.5772891045,
-0.2508144975,
-0.212977156,
-0.6490064263,
-0.5428450108,
1.0561727285,
0.2135010213,
-0.6683988571,
0.0520860143,
0.0766828954,
0.219878912,
-0.0496270657,
0.9009976983,
0.4754357934,
0.4857066572,
-0.3581526279,
-1.0675302744,
0.0650969297,
-0.3178451657,
-0.0467271507,
0.1143880934,
-0.4512701035,
0.7886654139,
0.1857795119,
-0.0944879204,
-0.1602992713,
0.417929858,
0.1342399418,
0.5157130957,
0.713183701,
0.4096991122,
0.6771562696,
-0.4035149813,
1.2222229242,
0.1791275889,
0.3155146837,
0.8015930057,
-0.3226554394,
0.6166948676,
0.5906805396,
0.0207994152,
0.4369584322,
0.3811315894,
0.5898670554,
0.5228894949,
0.3715953231,
-0.4235457182,
0.1908744723,
-0.3899915516,
-0.3949795961,
0.2121700644,
0.263961792,
-0.2479597628,
0.0334977843,
0.3778526187,
0.2375859767,
0.0128942588,
-0.4965553582,
0.6123477817,
-0.0313669741,
-0.5863171816,
-0.0891059935,
0.3118534088,
1.3265849352,
-0.5913226008,
-0.0738764927,
-0.3122908175,
0.2737300098,
-0.1134751514,
-0.5410792232,
0.2602541447,
-0.0071062418,
-0.3869695067,
-0.5486272573,
0.9128364921,
-0.294234395,
-0.4053646922,
0.3241263032,
0.3930558562,
-0.3392102718,
-0.5504380465,
-0.4895609319,
-0.2356321961,
-0.1139752641,
-0.1522571445,
0.5601608753,
0.3415399492,
-0.1280440092,
0.8945112228,
0.6442798376,
-0.0811318979,
0.1139353588,
0.1255353391,
0.8969638944,
-0.7119231224,
-0.7824096084,
-0.8515841365,
0.5569190979,
-0.2648415267,
-0.1231783107,
0.8119539022,
0.3599699736,
0.7133745551,
0.0057188082,
0.525911212,
0.1002784893,
0.6733543873,
-0.4088166058,
0.8251842856,
-0.5934078693,
0.4543201625,
-0.6392992139,
-0.9754235148,
-0.2711799741,
0.4561311901,
-0.3236042559,
0.2710636854,
0.8371471763,
0.4876933098,
0.1509976387,
0.1060929,
-0.0237700157,
-0.1060390025,
0.602900207,
0.3106610775,
1.1349309683,
-0.294023782,
0.5442883372,
-0.316000104,
-0.4812293351,
0.150020197,
-1.0408228636,
-0.8437504768,
-0.3406531513,
-0.5132533908,
-0.0950965509,
0.2932216823,
0.2614216506,
0.7885851264,
-0.534787178,
0.1354377568,
-0.3727994859,
0.4154537618,
-0.0907690227,
-0.3379682302,
0.3399749398,
-0.0863516331,
-0.8764481544,
-0.2308797836,
0.3435645401,
-0.2788987458,
-0.2569406331,
0.0370506011,
-0.1649822742,
-0.2051614523,
0.7424844503,
-0.2011278719,
-0.4460710585,
-0.2969043851,
0.026657341,
0.0608426705,
-0.3149110675,
1.093149662,
-0.8437366486,
0.2192984521,
0.6610809565,
0.6900264621,
0.1658302397,
-0.1599818915,
0.6424236894,
-1.130433321,
-0.0265966207,
0.4627766609,
0.1658100337,
0.2188041955,
-0.4061140418,
0.5474927425,
0.1307147741,
-0.5183082819,
-0.9336195588,
-0.0416376702,
-0.7643610239,
-0.5526898503,
1.2180293798,
-0.0346010849,
-0.2250567228,
-0.1726781279,
-0.385342747,
0.2117550522,
-0.5174692869,
0.5815983415,
0.7769852281,
0.0668220595,
-0.1148029193,
-0.6833870411,
0.204225257,
0.773568511,
-0.7411581278,
-0.1355870366,
0.2791083455,
0.0445651934,
0.0792784542,
0.6420689821,
-0.1767897159,
0.1944817752,
-0.3230434954,
-0.240751341,
0.3911013305,
-0.1826927066,
-0.5786604285,
-0.0427755229,
-0.4136419296,
-0.0378601886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12850v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12850v1 | GE-Blender: Graph-Based Knowledge Enhancement for Blender | 2023-01-30T13:00:20 | 2023-01-30T13:00:20 | Xiaolei Lian, Xunzhu Tang, Yue Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although the great success of open-domain dialogue generation, unseen
entities can have a large impact on the dialogue generation task. It leads to
performance degradation of the model in the dialog generation. Previous
researches used retrieved knowledge of seen entities as the auxiliary data to
enhance the representation of the model. Nevertheless, logical explanation of
unseen entities remains unexplored, such as possible co-occurrence or
semantically similar words of them and their entity category. In this work, we
propose an approach to address the challenge above. We construct a graph by
extracting entity nodes in them, enhancing the representation of the context of
the unseen entity with the entity's 1-hop surrounding nodes. Furthermore, We
added the named entity tag prediction task to apply the problem that the unseen
entity does not exist in the graph. We conduct our experiments on an open
dataset Wizard of Wikipedia and the empirical results indicate that our
approach outperforms the state-of-the-art approaches on Wizard of Wikipedia. | [
-0.8385346532,
-0.9651743174,
0.5140314102,
-0.3009730875,
-0.0733831599,
0.2821407616,
0.038079448,
-0.7241283059,
0.433691442,
0.6579296589,
-0.8232667446,
-0.5078441501,
-0.342872262,
-0.160027042,
-0.2580024004,
0.917380631,
0.1251517832,
-0.1034435183,
-0.3814993799,
-0.0628581643,
-0.33833915,
-0.0390694253,
-0.7947256565,
-0.6354426742,
0.2259604931,
0.2824593782,
0.7970558405,
0.2885950804,
0.0540174097,
0.2857853174,
-0.0118637262,
0.4414469004,
-0.8916178942,
0.0353186503,
-0.4720861018,
-0.1374565512,
-0.5144253373,
-0.0949341431,
0.6527199149,
1.0936528444,
0.3234874308,
-0.1886978894,
0.3412635326,
0.3738301396,
-0.3373981416,
0.6551733017,
-0.7616591454,
0.1655945778,
-0.02969262,
-0.3125885129,
-0.3034019172,
-0.1780847162,
0.2255816609,
-1.2076432705,
0.3418524861,
0.3459745646,
1.1424132586,
0.1631290615,
-0.2803916037,
0.0628541037,
-0.811039269,
0.2333049923,
-0.2904755473,
0.3834719658,
0.0336915962,
0.2608314455,
-0.5359686613,
-0.8497698307,
-0.8612546325,
-0.0032920586,
-0.2471013516,
0.2331068814,
-0.4769870937,
0.3667186797,
0.2977610826,
0.317720443,
-0.3231263161,
-0.0287383888,
-0.2161957026,
-0.2962518632,
0.2055480927,
-0.0140138306,
0.5144218206,
-0.1824823767,
-0.3886680901,
0.0875905082,
-0.7591853738,
-0.2888570726,
0.2703560889,
0.1385486871,
0.2123781294,
0.7833701968,
-0.3595607877,
0.6286399961,
0.0576778837,
0.1024950445,
0.3466142416,
-0.1140152439,
-0.1802455634,
0.0680956915,
0.5226737261,
0.5246388912,
0.3899074495,
-0.5149464011,
0.0660514012,
0.0302188583,
0.0620376654,
-0.8523111939,
-0.6172097325,
-0.1761602014,
-0.1696311086,
-0.2211399376,
-0.0525679179,
-0.8815246224,
-0.4966978133,
-0.1584972143,
0.2435235679,
-0.5019652247,
-0.4519505799,
-0.3601900935,
-0.5359639525,
-0.3237906694,
0.7301990986,
-0.3737798333,
0.4786098599,
0.525945425,
0.6893593073,
-0.0443961136,
-0.0444555208,
-0.3950722516,
0.5842018723,
-0.2255809158,
0.8169661164,
-0.8953003883,
-0.7067701221,
-0.3888511956,
0.1149662435,
-0.0687048733,
-0.3632587492,
0.3985649645,
-0.6248456836,
0.3721975982,
-0.073570922,
-0.9408031702,
-0.5804057717,
0.0571577735,
-0.7766720653,
0.9505476356,
0.4834956229,
-0.9545681477,
0.3143178225,
-1.0982439518,
-0.1401576251,
0.3760001063,
-0.4846927226,
0.0211861357,
-0.0006079451,
0.5275599957,
0.0761667788,
-0.262814641,
0.0503843911,
-0.5243452787,
-0.1125011146,
0.0232196879,
-0.4222587943,
0.5861846209,
0.0373248272,
-0.1129845977,
-0.2945978642,
-0.7256699204,
0.3237996399,
0.3237240911,
-0.0509810485,
-0.402107209,
-0.0294033308,
-0.4201015532,
0.0335855894,
-0.063914679,
-0.6905721426,
0.0455363095,
-0.6559610963,
-0.1470179856,
0.7603196502,
0.6543429494,
0.541872263,
0.0309744775,
0.6059815884,
0.2326631993,
-0.2411369979,
0.0636541173,
-0.8398275375,
-0.8170231581,
-0.0923058316,
0.4537499249,
0.4840657711,
-1.4249720573,
0.2164729536,
-0.677718997,
-0.4123362601,
-0.3007166386,
0.0259231906,
0.1882472187,
1.2544322014,
0.424115479,
-0.5620942712,
-0.4960468411,
-0.7068849206,
-0.2017360181,
-0.224747315,
-0.2006652653,
0.7737512589,
0.2238078713,
-0.340211302,
1.2625492811,
-0.9718698263,
-0.0839240849,
-0.1062284485,
0.0245287064,
0.0339768343,
0.4509139061,
0.4535667598,
-0.5959086418,
-0.3256363869,
0.2316807956,
-0.9010068178,
-0.0226608794,
0.2834664583,
-0.3455588222,
0.0042932481,
0.3022631407,
-0.762691319,
0.4738484323,
0.4337402284,
-0.0798228234,
0.2890995145,
0.0315196514,
0.0312020704,
-0.9368628263,
-0.0197849497,
0.0841688737,
-0.2910059392,
-0.5951519608,
-0.2372972369,
-0.4306538403,
-0.6703346372,
-0.1106932908,
0.8357932568,
-0.4663603902,
-0.1287273169,
-0.2484845966,
0.6550798416,
0.220920369,
0.7010981441,
0.1072974354,
0.6708391905,
0.7148059011,
-0.6363620162,
0.2823078036,
0.4762475193,
-0.4134669006,
0.4544890821,
-0.4702063203,
0.255323559,
-0.3936476707,
0.4090652466,
-0.6478762031,
-0.3218380809,
0.6787655354,
-0.6169962883,
0.5087707639,
-0.5370131731,
-0.3633139133,
-0.4291802645,
0.2445410788,
0.0487192459,
0.3041204214,
-0.5775677562,
0.7890368104,
0.6766147017,
-0.234640941,
-0.531293273,
-0.1345877796,
0.0046838555,
-0.0482927561,
-0.7755044103,
0.2032026798,
0.0468423963,
-0.2018035948,
0.5887966156,
-0.4099595547,
-0.090888992,
0.1713829786,
0.4681354463,
0.3735797107,
-0.3121292591,
0.4132334292,
0.259386301,
-0.2821142673,
0.0380884595,
-0.6386548877,
0.4442647696,
0.176294595,
-0.3147187531,
0.0178755168,
0.3046039045,
0.0792194903,
-0.2182462662,
0.5799131393,
0.4597570002,
-0.6755065918,
-0.3599335551,
-0.0493680611,
0.0097950017,
-0.5344195366,
0.3593272865,
-0.4672104418,
-0.6975483298,
0.2407786995,
-0.7752794027,
-0.1234615967,
0.6010134816,
0.0522666387,
-0.0477808826,
1.0781948566,
0.5974596143,
-0.0414531268,
0.4479185939,
-0.2898347974,
0.5202388763,
-0.7446416616,
-0.3936795294,
-0.3551250696,
-0.0061796,
-0.5331211686,
-0.5737458467,
0.7016128898,
0.5038042068,
0.0108149275,
0.3687952459,
-0.4540700912,
0.534442842,
0.4173994958,
0.2164610028,
0.4577986002,
0.3026286066,
-0.3311843276,
0.2563816607,
-0.8192635179,
-0.4546841383,
0.7024220824,
0.157757476,
0.6837375164,
-0.1000928283,
0.5944358706,
0.3276486397,
0.2283162922,
-0.7274576426,
0.7846788764,
0.410779804,
-0.6046407819,
-0.5604867935,
-0.6933794022,
-0.9892545342,
0.3039619625,
-0.3361095488,
-1.2707593441,
0.0479447879,
0.2119957954,
0.0325696617,
0.2864411473,
-0.8451920152,
0.7333362699,
0.1698579639,
0.0377773568,
-0.1630724669,
-0.2400869429,
0.1458583325,
0.0511868373,
0.1245066896,
-0.2204338312,
0.2696452141,
0.5843815804,
-0.5923390388,
0.6372234225,
-0.467983216,
-0.0559709035,
0.5860936046,
0.157815516,
0.8876768947,
0.2140015513,
0.1575364321,
0.1950772703,
-0.4617914259,
-0.1569687724,
-0.980258286,
0.753495574,
-0.5568124652,
-0.7898464203,
0.1864508688,
-0.5081083179,
-0.6504084468,
0.5265331268,
0.281922549,
0.5641360283,
-0.4104139507,
-0.3013934493,
0.6608756781,
-0.1661122441,
0.0837539807,
0.2144886106,
-0.446539849,
-0.2282442153,
1.0741150379,
0.2609023452,
0.0934725255,
0.3689534962,
-0.1278727204,
-0.2055517137,
-0.3515924513,
-0.6160801649,
-0.0107352342,
-1.0759398937,
-0.2266679853,
-1.0770759583,
-0.2461889535,
-0.3740596473,
0.1418223232,
0.0120008616,
-0.852322042,
-0.4946336746,
-0.4212142229,
0.5064403415,
0.6539652944,
0.1835182756,
0.1089423597,
-0.6750897765,
0.3347023129,
0.1736187935,
0.4860938191,
0.1671057343,
0.0122369789,
-0.1705724746,
0.2697965801,
-0.2855812013,
-0.858389616,
0.0798300952,
0.2367090583,
0.7522062063,
0.5898107886,
0.046058163,
0.7312888503,
-0.613768816,
0.553183794,
0.3079508841,
-0.8467413783,
0.6062067151,
-0.3173234761,
-0.1339528114,
0.1033095941,
0.4095546901,
-0.3607924283,
-0.5037472844,
-1.0606665611,
-0.5504438281,
0.7277494073,
0.6275231242,
0.0282830019,
0.0392235294,
-0.067433089,
0.0174531955,
0.1685125381,
-0.4615776539,
-0.5008730888,
-0.3946502805,
0.0809279382,
-0.1086115763,
0.2370113879,
-0.2317550033,
-0.2976189256,
0.9437782168,
-0.2990266383,
0.5218703151,
0.0174235627,
-0.0635120794,
-0.2314910889,
0.0663606822,
-0.0599107929,
0.6138496995,
0.0134471944,
-0.0317230187,
0.3647674024,
-0.2592909038,
-0.4017588496,
0.4001440108,
-0.236785233,
0.4043931365,
0.142997548,
1.022547245,
0.1130227074,
-0.5079430342,
0.2260925919,
0.2469047606,
0.2246616632,
-0.2675240636,
0.4602104723,
0.1046125442,
0.4008250237,
0.1075310186,
0.2055553943,
0.2631632388,
-0.6310850978,
0.1894709021,
0.4825943112,
-0.5198385715,
-0.1572483033,
0.6446174979,
0.311029017,
-0.1646198183,
0.6030338407,
-0.3427006304,
-0.5136487484,
0.4794496298,
0.5690430403,
0.5207330585,
0.2310239077,
0.3754403889,
0.2248624265,
0.0765264556,
0.476339221,
0.0120031787,
-0.1194963157,
-1.0426580906,
0.0278401636,
-0.2808335125,
-0.336450696,
0.1180783063,
-0.3714632988,
0.2344502956,
-0.1930816323,
-0.2132183462,
0.4420259297,
0.0208048727,
-0.8778864741,
0.3358406425,
-0.0501643196,
0.8719593883,
-0.4633314908,
0.8540697098,
0.4958031476,
-0.3999646604,
-0.7905788422,
0.016437456,
-0.1534892619,
-1.00738585,
0.1327964813,
-0.0069737323,
-0.1279271245,
0.3892264664,
-0.4583153725,
-0.8444908261,
1.0567486286,
0.5018771887,
-0.1885936409,
-0.340282917,
-0.092512846,
0.4794717133,
-0.4134010375,
0.2113686204,
0.2394581139,
0.4948705435,
0.2479849458,
-0.681279242,
0.0959530175,
-0.4330905378,
0.0143747423,
0.432254076,
-0.2149385065,
0.4256215394,
-0.2596846521,
-0.796703577,
-0.1147629395,
0.7135782838,
-0.1908282042,
0.376278609,
0.5139107108,
0.6112479568,
1.2145290375,
-0.1064938307,
1.0423016548,
-0.3128696382,
0.5632187724,
1.4260317087,
-0.2072514445,
0.0647386834,
0.052836936,
0.0764526725,
0.657866478,
0.4243127108,
-0.2044395804,
0.5364006162,
0.0510208756,
-0.4719377458,
-0.2271259874,
-0.5796228647,
-0.4523690939,
0.3051400483,
0.60203439,
-0.5390535593,
-0.5087539554,
0.0731265098,
0.0886149555,
-0.2358624488,
-0.4997301996,
0.9639892578,
-0.0010507073,
-0.5724247098,
0.3104218245,
-0.1798026562,
-0.1856019497,
-0.3162159324,
-0.4893943071,
0.1155098528,
-0.1581854373,
-0.2260467261,
-0.8679755926,
-0.0655377135,
-0.1040928364,
-0.1652089953,
0.1163382158,
1.3584440947,
-0.3051384985,
-0.3469308913,
0.3918002844,
0.8649951816,
0.3612599373,
-0.089335762,
-0.4412004352,
-0.5206388235,
-0.0122425817,
-0.0736959875,
0.0856164396,
0.8474711776,
-0.0370246992,
0.6784737706,
0.403989017,
-0.1903253198,
-0.0665700659,
-0.0079966672,
1.3044228554,
-0.29377985,
-0.3992671669,
-0.3426499665,
0.3352995515,
-0.5080145597,
0.1311512589,
0.9227751493,
0.6550334096,
1.1090636253,
0.0217954572,
1.0409874916,
-0.1635015905,
0.5795047283,
-0.4436077178,
0.6670158505,
-0.3108282685,
0.130911842,
-0.6616139412,
-0.968765378,
0.3365122676,
0.129652366,
-0.1012208536,
0.0820172057,
0.6128268242,
0.820718348,
-0.1850310415,
0.3989243507,
0.2753094137,
0.1744986176,
0.0289989803,
0.2065339833,
0.7554799914,
-0.1180321202,
0.5571380854,
-0.128231734,
-0.0666519031,
0.1929440647,
-0.5715427995,
-0.9858122468,
-0.4579357207,
-0.3155483305,
-0.606528163,
-0.1288034916,
0.6725116372,
0.5560588837,
-0.6274976134,
0.4787069261,
-0.2022139281,
0.4874998033,
-0.064860791,
-0.2791672647,
0.0707286075,
-0.0273438487,
-0.8281887174,
0.7378653288,
0.181786254,
0.3675758839,
0.0127007607,
-0.0635928884,
0.2467803657,
0.2313119918,
0.5012352467,
0.2973735332,
-0.4205498099,
-0.6965399981,
-0.3652003706,
0.4040482342,
0.3078939915,
0.7916266322,
-1.0461250544,
0.7519574165,
0.2737898529,
0.5573457479,
0.7242833972,
0.1416385621,
0.5596643686,
-0.9687559009,
-0.0978642479,
0.1922064126,
0.5015310645,
0.0996157452,
-0.515609622,
0.7295034528,
0.5451160669,
-0.0190864485,
-0.5396152735,
0.4467611611,
-0.8199635148,
-0.2242654115,
0.8447555304,
-0.3507104218,
0.0400613099,
-0.2535347939,
-0.0893250704,
0.5897462964,
-0.6060672402,
0.4115731716,
0.5768072009,
-0.3048684001,
0.0124808075,
-0.4852719903,
0.3824003935,
-0.1888771802,
-1.0185031891,
-0.1645010114,
0.7692470551,
0.2852574587,
0.3535625041,
0.6239897609,
0.0091357809,
-0.0727975518,
0.3322386742,
-0.2237301022,
-0.2838706672,
-0.4554647207,
0.1428584158,
0.2591293752,
-0.1198838279,
-0.1414743066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12847v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12847v1 | Finding the Law: Enhancing Statutory Article Retrieval via Graph Neural Networks | 2023-01-30T12:59:09 | 2023-01-30T12:59:09 | Antoine Louis, Gijs van Dijck, Gerasimos Spanakis | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Statutory article retrieval (SAR), the task of retrieving statute law
articles relevant to a legal question, is a promising application of legal text
processing. In particular, high-quality SAR systems can improve the work
efficiency of legal professionals and provide basic legal assistance to
citizens in need at no cost. Unlike traditional ad-hoc information retrieval,
where each document is considered a complete source of information, SAR deals
with texts whose full sense depends on complementary information from the
topological organization of statute law. While existing works ignore these
domain-specific dependencies, we propose a novel graph-augmented dense statute
retriever (G-DSR) model that incorporates the structure of legislation via a
graph neural network to improve dense retrieval performance. Experimental
results show that our approach outperforms strong retrieval baselines on a
real-world expert-annotated SAR dataset. | [
-0.2203155011,
-0.9119470119,
0.8000519276,
-0.2129569054,
-0.751312077,
-0.1084216759,
-0.1844711304,
-0.5919756889,
0.3718624413,
0.6760748625,
0.2467415482,
-0.4475826919,
-0.9455353022,
-0.2141187489,
-0.7369697094,
0.7159502506,
0.1799244881,
0.1270510703,
-0.116790317,
-0.1301447302,
-0.0665300414,
-0.4940910041,
-0.7927321792,
-0.4754982293,
0.8373754621,
-0.2616511881,
0.7423413992,
0.6943439841,
0.5006223917,
0.3443075716,
-0.5837444067,
0.2293218821,
-0.5261560082,
-0.1498499364,
-0.0068429145,
-0.2853675485,
-0.2148474753,
-0.2357883304,
0.5826488137,
0.2999970317,
-0.320017457,
-0.1704404503,
-0.0885703862,
0.8298023343,
-0.6483346224,
0.4212177992,
-0.581720233,
0.0180238802,
-0.3055567145,
-0.3532023728,
-0.4225194454,
-0.6171939969,
0.2214905173,
-0.6468586922,
0.4593577981,
0.0810702816,
0.9217171669,
0.1567756534,
-0.9759045839,
-0.4208587706,
-0.5441069007,
0.0997258127,
-0.609783709,
0.5459322929,
0.4256555736,
0.0709490702,
0.0396000184,
-0.9878095388,
-0.3397962451,
-0.5281647444,
-0.2753690183,
-0.094436653,
-0.3571779132,
0.1083699316,
0.0765357688,
0.1744855493,
-0.5851408243,
-0.2469660789,
-0.5700232387,
-0.3583906889,
0.7460363507,
0.1860231012,
0.5994505882,
-0.3122009039,
0.0178234223,
0.044152502,
-0.5231963396,
0.0294280984,
0.5631331801,
0.4060716033,
0.1531186253,
0.7635750771,
0.123812668,
0.8629544377,
-0.0906652436,
0.1843110174,
0.0893355757,
-0.4015897512,
0.0089015225,
0.2747704983,
0.7385395169,
-0.1578723788,
0.0952154696,
-0.3174903095,
-0.5412515402,
-0.3901920915,
0.6097530723,
-0.8279100657,
-0.2561146319,
-0.140351668,
-0.5871940851,
-0.1360339224,
0.1388305575,
-0.3990416229,
-0.6416971087,
-0.662293911,
0.2921096385,
-0.7068483233,
-0.1817141771,
0.0514780991,
-0.5687514544,
-0.0139886849,
0.4177538157,
-0.7136502862,
0.3870310485,
0.8354132175,
0.9626733065,
0.3452367485,
0.2681643069,
-0.5202895403,
0.2348169088,
-0.4928965271,
0.8225724697,
-0.7054550052,
-0.1618358493,
-0.2043522894,
-0.1149974838,
-0.069681488,
-0.5756815672,
0.6893888116,
-1.1000775099,
-0.6412808299,
-0.2108315229,
-0.4232985079,
-0.2814126909,
0.190400973,
-1.1058144569,
0.6430174708,
-0.0033993549,
-0.5992411375,
0.5570430756,
-0.4555939734,
-0.7581986189,
0.2173274904,
-0.5722939372,
-0.5408234,
0.2626932859,
0.3196495771,
-0.0173247252,
-0.1924278885,
0.2658168077,
-0.1618504226,
-0.6248219013,
-0.0972005352,
0.0049243104,
1.0286420584,
0.330745697,
-0.1324719489,
0.2534448206,
-0.5879257321,
-0.0474557765,
0.2003832608,
-0.6597353816,
-0.6732459664,
0.1670611352,
-0.0263753701,
-0.170398429,
0.2253528237,
-0.474214375,
-0.0202632342,
-0.1056710705,
0.4887691736,
0.6807588339,
0.2122679651,
0.5143278241,
-0.0559728481,
0.3169323802,
0.0635544434,
-0.1856325567,
0.3904777169,
-0.4621792138,
-0.1667547375,
-0.3882445395,
0.5382618904,
0.4208599627,
-0.5955910683,
0.2341021895,
-0.4074874818,
-0.5067085624,
-0.2838845551,
0.166390568,
0.250412941,
0.4065386057,
0.2116350532,
-0.3078720272,
-0.6566989422,
-0.5702983737,
-0.2793414295,
-0.0300291404,
0.2898833454,
0.8586124778,
0.5752754807,
-0.1102373451,
0.7664236426,
-0.5340061188,
-0.4318880737,
-0.2293966115,
0.3193676472,
0.3039853871,
0.0958620682,
0.5305421352,
-1.2335990667,
-0.3420051038,
0.1972555369,
-0.8242649436,
0.2928768992,
0.3099725246,
0.0413099118,
-0.1369203776,
0.4071861207,
-0.5996195674,
0.5906403065,
-0.3218228519,
-0.4788495004,
0.5062331557,
-0.6008374095,
0.1201428622,
-0.613104105,
0.0708008036,
0.2121047974,
-0.1396339536,
-0.4307523668,
0.2852056623,
0.2830078006,
-0.4436314404,
-0.1231264472,
0.327788651,
-0.6701553464,
-0.2480608672,
-0.2558076978,
0.3751615286,
-0.0281500481,
0.0518467389,
-0.2913665175,
1.2014091015,
0.4462818503,
-0.6731834412,
0.2502965331,
0.4930895865,
-0.3023237288,
0.4930410087,
-0.6528110504,
0.1770285964,
-0.7293886542,
0.2693935335,
-0.616702199,
-0.2224186361,
-0.0479763672,
-0.0158252772,
0.4444319904,
-0.7856153846,
-0.5949257612,
-0.3615208268,
0.1412582844,
0.4349613786,
0.2718649209,
-0.2357805073,
0.6843795776,
0.8807953596,
-0.1054945067,
-0.7932747602,
-0.4610087872,
0.5334665179,
0.0731057525,
-0.5712842345,
0.2503212392,
0.4322023988,
-0.1625479758,
0.5947710276,
-0.1285147965,
-0.5017898083,
-0.0802136436,
-0.0332162417,
-0.0800400674,
-0.4331629872,
0.2728979588,
-0.0681712329,
0.1350127459,
0.0720826462,
-0.4810006022,
0.6844124198,
-0.2397022098,
-0.0878616646,
-0.2778919041,
0.2251340449,
0.1937390566,
-0.6889364719,
0.3767128885,
0.4313365221,
-0.4089167118,
0.0724356696,
-0.4441105127,
0.0864538178,
-0.4272159934,
0.3584623039,
-0.3523521721,
-0.9128797054,
0.4531587958,
0.1090953276,
-0.5540155172,
0.4735241234,
0.1785177886,
0.2702507973,
0.8299819827,
0.3728791475,
-0.1657712907,
0.660595119,
-0.3942930996,
0.4154580235,
-0.7865149975,
-0.416066736,
-0.834233284,
-0.3606949747,
-0.2035813332,
-0.1943807155,
0.5464862585,
0.0939510986,
-0.3530414999,
0.7337738276,
-0.6207079887,
0.5649155378,
0.617210269,
0.8224369287,
0.2741986215,
0.266723454,
-0.3437394202,
0.2848566473,
-0.5211237073,
-0.2397167236,
1.124845624,
-0.2878703475,
0.7164256573,
0.2508195341,
1.0364254713,
0.5424188375,
-0.1110188439,
-0.7097331285,
0.783110261,
-0.6497653127,
-0.5245378017,
-0.4899405241,
-1.0143930912,
-1.3059006929,
0.248280555,
-0.1512587368,
-0.8054537177,
0.4452965558,
-0.2137714475,
-0.4004985094,
0.5313559771,
-0.3052785397,
0.5628432631,
-0.2410504073,
-0.286906451,
-0.5782935619,
-0.2979147434,
0.1550740153,
-0.1120160967,
-0.0274508279,
-0.159856528,
-0.1336012185,
0.6127986908,
-0.5520761013,
0.493476212,
-0.4404748082,
-0.1627436876,
0.8087335229,
-0.0319785886,
0.7533307076,
0.1361925304,
-0.4314421713,
-0.3343292773,
-0.2025475502,
-0.2894930542,
-0.8062940836,
0.6485347152,
-0.7306592464,
-0.5009878874,
-0.4040187001,
-0.7536512613,
0.4228240848,
0.6652603745,
-0.0819691122,
0.859905839,
-0.1375979334,
0.2681000531,
0.6773329973,
0.305321753,
0.2133574784,
0.3577957153,
0.1269645691,
-0.636951685,
1.0509382486,
0.8189128637,
-0.6806635857,
0.3354538381,
0.0724499822,
-0.7030588984,
-0.7726200223,
-0.4654527903,
0.0639093146,
-0.7568371892,
-0.1762551367,
-0.8172937036,
-0.4533039927,
-0.416028589,
0.0709959343,
0.1427870542,
-0.4191513956,
-0.3932702243,
0.0122870961,
0.46910882,
0.8976985812,
0.062249206,
-0.0481908955,
-0.6747329831,
0.4352099895,
0.1791484654,
0.554497838,
0.1175548211,
-0.416883409,
-0.0243381578,
-0.047660429,
-0.0874998644,
-0.602040112,
0.0514425933,
0.145384416,
0.6596580148,
0.2240428329,
0.0876112282,
0.8115238547,
-0.5877426267,
0.3547905087,
0.1376320869,
-0.5672007203,
0.3833563328,
-0.3978698552,
-0.291287303,
0.4218489826,
0.2396170497,
0.1502880007,
-0.1198790595,
-0.3498011827,
-0.9606525302,
0.359809339,
0.1499309093,
0.4132905304,
-0.1562907696,
0.8616485596,
-0.4841496348,
0.1047674268,
-0.3963889778,
0.1373367161,
-0.0719980299,
-0.1943974644,
0.121454075,
-0.1417413652,
-0.2974645197,
-0.3740017712,
0.5735394955,
-0.1114009321,
0.4210315049,
0.5142817497,
-0.3159458339,
-0.0478574112,
0.3755182326,
0.5890827179,
0.7881553173,
-0.1848544478,
0.5432911515,
0.016548628,
-0.7363494635,
0.5017258525,
0.4200557172,
-0.4787813127,
-0.0240850095,
0.0378764309,
0.8122293353,
0.3219202757,
-0.371393472,
0.4769399464,
0.0448262915,
-0.2990824282,
-0.4256471992,
0.2256692499,
0.0398936123,
0.4967520237,
0.7546781301,
0.2185459137,
0.4630060494,
-0.5272879601,
0.8058757186,
0.6090341806,
-0.6793786287,
0.2387304008,
1.0174065828,
-0.2139997929,
-0.4162910283,
0.7773740888,
-0.2291749865,
-0.2279781848,
0.9105020165,
0.8352209926,
0.6378263235,
0.5870655179,
0.2011777461,
0.404120177,
0.3223575652,
-0.2906416059,
0.4195041358,
-0.0320518389,
-0.2670688331,
-0.370161742,
-0.245699212,
0.0623688027,
-0.2176044881,
-0.5414959192,
0.0909045115,
-0.5368201733,
-0.6053040028,
-0.1842233837,
0.1454522908,
-0.3549476564,
0.149391517,
-0.0215866026,
1.0152536631,
-0.1984836012,
0.7503044605,
0.4850899875,
-0.8194237947,
-0.691603303,
-0.0671526119,
-0.040684171,
-0.6284327507,
0.4971680939,
-0.0781543106,
-0.1262244433,
0.110410206,
-0.541341424,
-0.7019677758,
1.3346574306,
0.5395085216,
-0.4129330218,
-0.0716541633,
0.1161896288,
0.749622941,
-0.1600609273,
0.2343450338,
0.2862350643,
0.4526722729,
0.1075293943,
-0.3883517385,
0.3642494977,
-0.5209165215,
0.0922154486,
0.5711327791,
-0.456212908,
0.7422252297,
-0.3432011604,
-0.0878450572,
0.0567118116,
0.6831263304,
0.1595803797,
0.5343261361,
0.5074121356,
0.9448132515,
1.1110767126,
-0.163869977,
1.2875059843,
-0.4660286307,
0.3844420612,
0.9476764798,
-0.3946420848,
0.7867162824,
0.2486916631,
0.1237766445,
0.4950834215,
0.4057282209,
-0.3477027118,
0.3831226826,
0.3463060856,
-0.4524521232,
-0.2397519648,
-0.3425374031,
-0.2329478115,
0.0739043057,
0.1463798881,
-0.4359891713,
-0.3664516807,
-0.3522339761,
-0.1816994846,
0.0953820124,
-0.5855661035,
0.78396523,
0.0792369246,
-0.2996221483,
0.4183761477,
-0.1552797407,
0.0088252239,
-0.598474741,
-0.0636388734,
0.051158525,
0.0743628666,
-0.3070081174,
-1.053773284,
0.3413535357,
-0.0203555543,
-0.1004967242,
0.1441135556,
1.0993260145,
-0.1792611182,
-0.4158401787,
0.5878996253,
0.3141023219,
0.121609278,
-0.2167756706,
-0.7558401823,
-0.2561887801,
-0.5320083499,
-0.1805402488,
0.2637260258,
0.5949048996,
-0.2248025239,
0.6315702796,
0.7054676414,
0.08271911,
0.2100099921,
0.2211893797,
1.0917060375,
-0.4834527075,
-0.4924603403,
-0.5156438947,
0.1993686557,
-0.3746657073,
-0.1238145754,
0.3213403821,
1.0704001188,
0.5500658154,
0.0430815294,
0.6701495051,
-0.4147194922,
-0.1048338264,
-0.4270012081,
1.1598272324,
-0.7195168138,
-0.010718869,
-0.1504923105,
-0.8139303923,
-0.4727952182,
0.4497846067,
-0.4264121652,
-0.0730762929,
0.351169467,
0.9899871349,
-0.6511637568,
-0.0674447715,
0.1231080145,
-0.0511091128,
0.1517022252,
0.1366564035,
0.5461368561,
-0.5552973747,
1.0163646936,
-0.0188766122,
0.211264044,
-0.1195038632,
-0.4528644383,
-0.6171113849,
-0.4836504161,
0.0957652256,
-0.6144829392,
0.3508011103,
0.8918949962,
0.5732092857,
-0.6529408693,
-0.2946849465,
-0.3276502788,
0.0628875196,
-0.1627192795,
-0.1734410822,
0.6224666238,
-0.7547790408,
-0.2418862432,
0.5892854929,
0.1603234857,
-0.0529454499,
0.4072045386,
-0.3207969368,
-0.5370457768,
0.217578724,
0.4088252187,
0.2229100913,
-0.5052429438,
-0.3901985288,
-0.2408011705,
-0.6020240188,
0.2818809748,
1.3659156561,
-0.3280070424,
0.3785788715,
0.7555522323,
0.9247387052,
0.9492884874,
0.0104238847,
0.3611880839,
-0.5352423191,
0.1310515106,
0.2630127966,
0.6967085004,
-0.181603834,
-0.554941237,
0.8735364676,
0.3373120129,
-0.5365402699,
-0.5063522458,
0.037128225,
-0.8826886415,
-0.1727149785,
0.7023197412,
-0.1628596038,
-0.4236879647,
-0.4113973081,
-0.3697969615,
0.4618998766,
-0.439024806,
0.773277998,
0.3361543119,
0.0447084606,
-0.4067993462,
-0.5143945217,
0.0960367844,
0.0109793451,
-0.555952549,
-0.2882038057,
0.4264053702,
0.3481814563,
0.331135571,
0.7958827019,
-0.3954441547,
0.3308481276,
0.1183776855,
-0.1881704628,
-0.4004893005,
-0.3467484415,
-0.2442148328,
0.4577867985,
-0.262380898,
0.5093039274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12810v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12810v1 | Crawling the Internal Knowledge-Base of Language Models | 2023-01-30T12:03:36 | 2023-01-30T12:03:36 | Roi Cohen, Mor Geva, Jonathan Berant, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models are trained on large volumes of text, and as a result their
parameters might contain a significant body of factual knowledge. Any
downstream task performed by these models implicitly builds on these facts, and
thus it is highly desirable to have means for representing this body of
knowledge in an interpretable way. However, there is currently no mechanism for
such a representation. Here, we propose to address this goal by extracting a
knowledge-graph of facts from a given language model. We describe a procedure
for ``crawling'' the internal knowledge-base of a language model. Specifically,
given a seed entity, we expand a knowledge-graph around it. The crawling
procedure is decomposed into sub-tasks, realized through specially designed
prompts that control for both precision (i.e., that no wrong facts are
generated) and recall (i.e., the number of facts generated). We evaluate our
approach on graphs crawled starting from dozens of seed entities, and show it
yields high precision graphs (82-92%), while emitting a reasonable number of
facts per entity. | [
-0.294370681,
-0.5703136921,
0.9368852973,
-0.0382591635,
-0.1539511234,
0.1688290238,
-0.2858457863,
-0.2701931596,
0.1903723329,
0.5012416244,
-0.3330480158,
-0.6337713599,
-0.6172217131,
-0.312694639,
-0.8152783513,
1.0661557913,
0.1404688358,
-0.5139312744,
-0.3957255483,
0.1447873414,
-0.1160533205,
-0.4357245564,
-0.3467746675,
-0.1562660784,
0.6012659073,
0.4739743769,
0.5436923504,
0.9631654024,
0.3770507574,
0.2782568634,
-0.0222751573,
0.2855630517,
-0.7433908582,
0.236667186,
-0.4888665974,
-0.4253916144,
-0.3083031476,
-0.130276069,
0.8485612869,
1.081217289,
0.0599808656,
0.27088359,
-0.002765334,
0.584266603,
-0.4908517897,
0.4557455182,
-0.4395987689,
-0.3264304996,
-0.4929589629,
-0.2004956752,
-0.6539711356,
-0.4346434772,
0.1692304909,
-0.4592604041,
0.2912163436,
0.0527922995,
0.9876428843,
0.077500321,
-0.4571685195,
-0.3017331958,
-0.5838076472,
0.6532004476,
-0.6215742826,
0.6029043794,
0.2894320786,
0.1404756159,
-0.1509629488,
-0.8819606304,
-0.4549612403,
-0.4626919031,
-0.2541329265,
-0.2856290638,
-0.2305808216,
-0.2041290253,
0.2901337445,
0.2927114367,
-0.3883938789,
-0.2548344731,
-0.4222285151,
-0.0598868355,
0.4160235524,
-0.0101817977,
0.5184761882,
-0.0856068805,
-0.2539393306,
-0.1566775292,
-0.8846446276,
-0.0875632986,
0.4378724396,
0.7062263489,
0.1881245673,
0.8369547725,
-0.4892821014,
0.642958343,
0.0235442873,
-0.2980876863,
0.2716984153,
-0.3286886513,
0.1741779596,
-0.0092453547,
0.6778792739,
0.2443884015,
0.5755542517,
-0.746470511,
-0.288864255,
-0.0509116091,
0.5718737245,
-0.701975584,
-0.3365755975,
0.1070333198,
-0.350273937,
-0.2295931727,
0.0046096011,
-0.7736005783,
-0.3558296561,
-0.1945965141,
0.4129800797,
-0.9037222862,
-0.4143584967,
-0.1362835616,
-0.4165812433,
-0.042180784,
0.0899710953,
-0.5546932817,
0.5646885633,
0.6385288239,
1.18544209,
-0.0438652076,
-0.1545529813,
-0.5168206096,
0.4047713578,
-0.3445262313,
0.837957859,
-0.6706629395,
-0.4292256534,
-0.1572559923,
-0.0546343364,
0.0057369098,
-0.1670770794,
0.2171838731,
-0.8476907015,
-0.0115682334,
-0.4476042688,
-0.968323946,
-0.634008646,
0.4295034409,
-0.6068725586,
0.8897640705,
0.1881332546,
-0.9315224886,
0.060108088,
-0.6711344719,
-0.4392871857,
-0.030922832,
0.1316509992,
0.25999704,
0.0339052118,
0.0645070598,
0.2982337475,
-0.1957062185,
0.0667771623,
-0.360873282,
-0.1942988783,
-0.0130995531,
0.1362217516,
0.9018506408,
-0.001626975,
-0.3234245181,
-0.1280170977,
-0.7050753832,
-0.1250747889,
0.2656716108,
-0.5055695772,
-0.6055963039,
0.3132847548,
-0.6644150615,
-0.0636773854,
0.4429088831,
-0.5170568824,
0.6191035509,
-0.6153205633,
-0.1027719006,
0.6833027601,
0.2395689189,
0.6955872178,
-0.3334705532,
0.3726832867,
-0.0594844483,
-0.2535392642,
-0.3819549382,
-0.6046389341,
-0.9603016376,
-0.0570896082,
0.2648388445,
0.248778671,
-0.4723219275,
0.2254556715,
-0.7525882125,
-0.7713634372,
-0.368858099,
0.0927583277,
0.3038494587,
0.8549951315,
0.3403678834,
-0.2053453773,
-0.4450498819,
-0.6158572435,
-0.2863654196,
-0.2319230139,
0.1832845956,
0.142135933,
0.5082031488,
-0.1731337458,
1.1334252357,
-0.6853885055,
-0.1965906024,
-0.0506683812,
0.2478865832,
0.3811424077,
0.387613833,
0.4348358214,
-0.7331343293,
-0.4805614948,
0.0785585493,
-0.5926182866,
-0.0757209361,
0.2571542859,
-0.1775784642,
0.0621470585,
0.5036424398,
-0.8867888451,
0.169332087,
0.3164884448,
-0.1631837785,
0.6632419229,
-0.0670540705,
-0.0078527648,
-0.7627161145,
0.2618209422,
-0.0266845282,
-0.3759945631,
-0.5952481627,
0.6751554608,
-0.0227416623,
0.373578161,
-0.0880529508,
0.5856778026,
-0.5822386742,
-0.1077104658,
-0.2773627937,
0.2971147001,
-0.2216219902,
0.3413649797,
-0.0443028696,
0.6566640139,
0.5665137768,
-0.8796083331,
0.3993240893,
-0.045596011,
-0.3241704404,
-0.0540717654,
-0.3144285083,
0.5553671122,
-0.2492328733,
0.0708014071,
-0.9251698256,
-0.1786766201,
0.2236869484,
-0.6133189797,
0.4422657192,
-0.7544546127,
-0.5581424832,
-0.0464108661,
0.0213061236,
0.1613286585,
0.7298046947,
-0.4678243995,
0.7144448161,
0.8120967746,
-0.1030613631,
-0.4333223701,
-0.2200544924,
0.0414601788,
-0.0904523134,
-0.6663415432,
0.14761585,
0.1921055168,
-0.5912409425,
0.4286826253,
0.0434696749,
0.116448693,
-0.2098472118,
0.304060936,
-0.0963271037,
-0.3611442447,
0.3358499706,
-0.3023636341,
-0.2574005723,
0.20941782,
-0.8514768481,
0.874003768,
-0.2476435304,
-0.4374585152,
0.2731488943,
0.1324059665,
0.4443641007,
-0.4037196636,
0.6607831717,
0.2271937728,
-0.5735887289,
-0.3210452497,
-0.2891207337,
-0.0755756125,
-0.4171372652,
0.1422530413,
-0.3962599933,
-0.3482937813,
0.2775012553,
-0.3571329415,
0.0895454809,
0.6000596881,
0.5270252824,
-0.3173933029,
1.1175128222,
0.9287316203,
-0.0356268547,
0.1318680644,
-0.4636030495,
0.3309351802,
-0.5512527823,
-0.2339721471,
-0.6794672012,
-0.2011620551,
-0.4982256591,
-0.7654262185,
0.3939788043,
0.0372417383,
-0.255983144,
0.5516870618,
-0.2114162594,
0.262576431,
0.9714387059,
0.1846119612,
0.3767966032,
-0.099682793,
-0.3703608811,
0.1891046017,
-0.5766977668,
-0.5886500478,
1.0333851576,
0.154987216,
0.6355447769,
0.2516958416,
0.6552891731,
0.1415290534,
0.4203346074,
-0.884752512,
0.6341110468,
-0.3369149566,
-0.7063733339,
-0.3379982114,
-0.5555193424,
-0.6608120799,
0.0130088162,
0.1495323926,
-1.0089650154,
0.0251841564,
0.2509264052,
-0.1184160039,
0.5615023375,
-0.6522214413,
0.5560467243,
-0.1539275646,
-0.0531346984,
-0.3194511831,
-0.6250721812,
0.5824887156,
0.0028725401,
0.5800641775,
-0.0046738703,
0.0028237826,
0.5607361197,
-0.3632531762,
0.9528056979,
-0.3314602971,
-0.1215022057,
0.3873818815,
0.6827659607,
0.8218569756,
-0.3679236174,
0.0246489719,
0.0184209123,
-0.0773624629,
-0.2724708915,
-0.6732490659,
0.5007634759,
-0.4099774659,
-0.555652082,
-0.4189020395,
-0.5754847527,
-0.2384058386,
0.5601886511,
-0.0282460898,
0.5207733512,
-0.0135462135,
0.1572861224,
0.6572793722,
-0.0570288673,
0.1411318779,
0.4385522008,
-0.5505484939,
0.1406435668,
1.3138452768,
0.31567204,
0.197638154,
0.5777766109,
0.2573223114,
-0.461329639,
-0.5745618939,
-0.4155421555,
0.2293735743,
-0.8824204206,
-0.108757019,
-0.9293397665,
-0.1864922941,
-0.513882935,
0.2478518486,
-0.313005507,
-0.4683754742,
-0.0926728174,
-0.191286996,
0.3921331763,
0.9323962331,
-0.1096613333,
0.2530058324,
-1.0517884493,
0.3577522337,
0.2009137273,
0.3735974431,
0.0670890883,
-0.511798501,
-0.3468583524,
0.1818045974,
0.1291303486,
-1.301692009,
0.367171675,
0.1503067315,
0.3949254155,
0.5688508749,
0.0852094218,
0.7465541363,
-0.5807728171,
0.6081700325,
-0.2708894908,
-0.7855789065,
0.3926487565,
-0.520511508,
0.0139308143,
0.1993847936,
0.6689636707,
-0.6200053096,
-0.501706779,
-0.6563672423,
-0.8548057675,
0.5370944142,
-0.0353633985,
0.1823775321,
-0.1709222794,
0.2458570451,
0.0432121344,
0.1254438907,
-0.5142522454,
-0.1468157172,
-0.0901372135,
-0.2729323804,
0.076613754,
-0.2204420567,
-0.2516160905,
-0.1278420836,
0.8835789561,
-0.418451339,
0.0435349829,
-0.1320175827,
-0.5447177291,
-0.2244299054,
-0.2108147591,
-0.0334057622,
0.8954257369,
-0.277735889,
0.6414777637,
-0.0333311595,
-0.2606827915,
-0.1117482036,
-0.0018007085,
-0.4122669697,
-0.0749288425,
0.5753086209,
0.364161998,
0.344752878,
-0.8812428117,
0.5122213364,
0.3105101287,
0.3447381854,
-0.1934812963,
0.2090429813,
0.5211149454,
0.207949236,
0.2703697383,
-0.0760945678,
0.287242651,
-0.712007463,
0.4905922413,
0.2989850938,
-0.2790787518,
-0.4491513073,
0.3216840625,
-0.0905131921,
-0.1961381733,
0.8821911216,
-0.4432629049,
-0.691983521,
0.4090234339,
0.6727532148,
0.6385774016,
0.0889046788,
0.217851609,
0.6089354157,
0.4337171316,
-0.0807785168,
0.129712671,
0.0811822936,
-0.8975028396,
-0.5728031397,
-0.7501704097,
-0.3207223713,
-0.232057333,
-0.5303046703,
0.1771012396,
-0.1651722938,
0.1154294834,
-0.0858555436,
-0.1107558981,
-0.639333725,
0.3781628609,
0.1257702112,
1.2379250526,
-0.442886889,
0.8308346868,
0.7418467999,
-0.786999166,
-0.6404746771,
0.1540084034,
-0.0484726578,
-0.9769471884,
0.7071153522,
0.067096211,
-0.3135272861,
0.2340982407,
-0.7755180001,
-1.3917518854,
0.6346436739,
0.3809565604,
-0.5611735582,
-0.3150972724,
-0.1483927071,
0.4448319972,
-0.1529418528,
0.1012603641,
0.5800890326,
0.6426975727,
-0.1511108279,
-0.6283124089,
0.374648124,
-0.2280902416,
-0.4479508996,
0.3538852334,
-0.5046810508,
0.9937877655,
-0.4928249121,
-0.5767223835,
-0.1805463731,
0.7624100447,
0.1481265128,
-0.0903859809,
0.9240176082,
0.6954588294,
0.9499757886,
-0.0107506597,
1.2263005972,
-0.5867221355,
0.4042876661,
1.2175505161,
0.0600067787,
0.7196788788,
0.4157608151,
-0.245310694,
0.8351459503,
0.4625607729,
0.2006680071,
0.4892264307,
0.1321488917,
-0.022937987,
-0.3590138257,
-0.068035841,
-0.0714615434,
0.4764102101,
0.5271263123,
-0.3007865548,
-0.5508072376,
-0.5573368073,
0.2169232368,
-0.0671699271,
-0.0436941087,
0.792509675,
0.0248562656,
-0.7800143361,
0.1449031234,
0.0013158199,
0.0665196031,
-0.7492187023,
-0.3339937031,
-0.0265325233,
0.0601563379,
-0.0774526373,
-0.9670985937,
0.3534465134,
0.2734236419,
-0.3304048777,
-0.3432551324,
0.8661806583,
-0.3415544033,
-0.3889285326,
0.5588855147,
0.6003035307,
0.4739191234,
-0.4020169079,
-0.0674720854,
-0.2591355145,
-0.1147156283,
-0.3971431255,
0.1798791587,
0.5845626593,
-0.0917545035,
0.7588754892,
0.9145877361,
0.1475523263,
0.3761311173,
-0.0063937991,
1.123749733,
-0.7086160779,
-0.5430474877,
-0.8552618027,
0.6170526743,
-0.1499266624,
-0.0633848459,
0.8807704449,
0.5757695436,
0.9104074836,
0.1712262183,
0.9618217945,
-0.4937607944,
0.7801864147,
-0.4236177802,
0.7648040652,
-0.5326264501,
-0.0771944523,
0.0021923755,
-0.6438286901,
0.0568314493,
0.4838229418,
-0.1345858872,
-0.0810242444,
0.5641585588,
0.7160169482,
-0.2192400992,
-0.2886117399,
-0.0762715638,
0.6524507403,
0.3942412436,
0.0901098922,
0.8283198476,
0.1302017868,
0.6666278243,
-0.6724674106,
-0.2960375249,
-0.1160758734,
-1.0890272856,
-0.53877455,
-0.7150365114,
0.014098485,
-0.5502204299,
-0.0041393237,
0.7018871903,
0.8755182028,
-0.8002142906,
-0.2001881599,
-0.0271982178,
0.3281726539,
-0.2704997957,
-0.2190556228,
0.3679054379,
-0.7662830353,
-0.67179811,
0.7788690925,
0.1751601696,
-0.1973334551,
-0.3566020131,
0.0509284586,
-0.3372167349,
-0.0642653182,
0.3026654422,
0.2425794154,
-0.4071137905,
-0.5725100636,
0.1647713482,
0.107856907,
-0.0141118132,
0.9102966785,
-0.8860929012,
0.6782266498,
0.7226732373,
0.5958018899,
0.6694842577,
0.1132022887,
0.8124150038,
-1.0474698544,
-0.2226730138,
0.2149644345,
0.5066468716,
0.383741647,
-0.2914269269,
0.547940731,
0.4205643833,
-0.181538403,
-0.9507053494,
0.1880165339,
-0.7192365527,
-0.4368139505,
1.230188489,
-0.2128952891,
-0.4024504125,
-0.0297023505,
-0.108164683,
0.572712481,
-0.2425532788,
0.7624489665,
0.669280231,
-0.0074022012,
0.0828193873,
-0.3897777796,
0.3964393437,
-0.2311227173,
-0.5923380852,
0.0572696887,
0.3430129886,
0.5921133161,
0.6324548721,
0.7716583014,
-0.056137342,
-0.1407775283,
0.2057314962,
0.2350958735,
0.0256095268,
-0.7149938345,
0.183474049,
0.4844065309,
-0.0390819125,
-0.1489952952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12729v1 | Response-act Guided Reinforced Dialogue Generation for Mental Health Counseling | 2023-01-30T08:53:35 | 2023-01-30T08:53:35 | Aseem Srivastava, Ishan Pandey, Md. Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Virtual Mental Health Assistants (VMHAs) have become a prevalent method for
receiving mental health counseling in the digital healthcare space. An
assistive counseling conversation commences with natural open-ended topics to
familiarize the client with the environment and later converges into more
fine-grained domain-specific topics. Unlike other conversational systems, which
are categorized as open-domain or task-oriented systems, VMHAs possess a hybrid
conversational flow. These counseling bots need to comprehend various aspects
of the conversation, such as dialogue-acts, intents, etc., to engage the client
in an effective conversation. Although the surge in digital health research
highlights applications of many general-purpose response generation systems,
they are barely suitable in the mental health domain -- the prime reason is the
lack of understanding in mental health counseling. Moreover, in general,
dialogue-act guided response generators are either limited to a template-based
paradigm or lack appropriate semantics. To this end, we propose READER -- a
REsponse-Act guided reinforced Dialogue genERation model for the mental health
counseling conversations. READER is built on transformer to jointly predict a
potential dialogue-act d(t+1) for the next utterance (aka response-act) and to
generate an appropriate response u(t+1). Through the
transformer-reinforcement-learning (TRL) with Proximal Policy Optimization
(PPO), we guide the response generator to abide by d(t+1) and ensure the
semantic richness of the responses via BERTScore in our reward computation. We
evaluate READER on HOPE, a benchmark counseling conversation dataset and
observe that it outperforms several baselines across several evaluation metrics
-- METEOR, ROUGE, and BERTScore. We also furnish extensive qualitative and
quantitative analyses on results, including error analysis, human evaluation,
etc. | [
-0.5344172716,
-0.8017560244,
0.890344739,
0.0992248133,
-0.2670363784,
0.0257301629,
0.0594349578,
-0.285548687,
0.3108799458,
0.6185742021,
-1.0800739527,
-0.4130956829,
-0.4537729025,
0.2093080282,
-0.0554072894,
1.1540771723,
0.1347732097,
0.3052836061,
-0.2356661558,
0.1379733235,
-0.7979235053,
-0.3881776631,
-0.9342170954,
-0.4006882608,
0.3565727472,
0.2685242593,
0.5688114166,
0.1509996504,
0.3352715373,
0.3166859746,
-0.1004609093,
0.3458228111,
-0.6735451221,
0.236088112,
-0.0530591942,
-0.3041981161,
-0.9207921624,
-0.2719680667,
0.1625890583,
0.2879268229,
-0.5062126517,
0.1439865232,
-0.0672884211,
0.3154235184,
-0.5225271583,
0.0432604626,
-0.4699517787,
0.0868346244,
0.2154845446,
-0.5061384439,
-0.4894049466,
-0.3516407311,
0.3648399115,
-0.8394940495,
0.4404337406,
0.0464277267,
0.42786479,
0.3565176725,
-0.5399119854,
-0.4080162942,
-1.0145769119,
0.5464754701,
-0.698523283,
0.1336078495,
0.7616318464,
0.6000946164,
-0.3496234715,
-0.7078409195,
-0.9113051891,
0.0050951052,
-0.1320404261,
0.5882199407,
-0.3635105193,
0.3469980061,
0.196625188,
0.5134106278,
-0.5333266854,
-0.3711473942,
-0.2301920801,
-0.0578761883,
0.6172428727,
0.707264483,
0.0898461044,
-0.1749252826,
-0.0839490667,
-0.2343043536,
-0.3596456051,
-0.0133800004,
0.0356890596,
0.1667507738,
-0.0333327353,
0.5821756721,
0.1832932979,
0.6394400597,
0.2271871418,
-0.3375253975,
-0.0636738762,
-0.1572637707,
-0.3345337212,
0.2351600081,
0.7822847962,
0.5858846903,
-0.0038728386,
0.1182514876,
0.0367640369,
0.0856067315,
0.9929827452,
-0.7355940938,
-0.0908775255,
0.4876245856,
-0.3503109813,
-0.1085395813,
-0.2494884729,
-0.9860261679,
-0.5067372918,
-0.5197532177,
0.2545274496,
-0.5083352923,
-0.4198587835,
0.3519494236,
0.0006133683,
0.3206579983,
0.3622698784,
-0.6851963997,
0.4823297858,
0.608418107,
0.6029173136,
-0.0523519255,
0.1656226069,
-0.7458080649,
0.1000234708,
-0.0093205469,
0.8354530931,
-0.5476555824,
-1.0000786781,
0.3303237557,
0.0538207665,
-0.1701536328,
-0.4055949748,
0.7312625051,
-0.404427737,
0.5734404922,
-0.3891872168,
-0.3815113902,
0.0966866836,
0.5578440428,
-0.4253598452,
0.7365241647,
0.4029056728,
-0.9649896622,
0.1845903397,
-0.5805139542,
-0.2715438008,
0.0628508553,
-0.1841128618,
-0.433704257,
0.2303958833,
0.3451832235,
-0.0361282937,
-0.4258392155,
0.0315896086,
-0.3014349639,
-0.5204393864,
0.2603800893,
-0.5077573657,
0.3373812437,
0.1328142136,
-0.2793924809,
0.4136973917,
-0.7566441894,
0.1804710925,
0.401234448,
-0.2813578844,
-0.3066492677,
-0.065652959,
0.0883843973,
0.2196601033,
-0.2782957256,
-0.68436867,
0.1715114117,
-0.521894753,
-0.0205694698,
0.6511725187,
0.3534384072,
-0.1433378756,
-0.42320472,
0.8360400796,
0.081631735,
0.2818481028,
-0.2250377089,
-0.4672463536,
-0.480928123,
-0.3648059666,
-0.2290191501,
0.7011676431,
-1.1504112482,
0.3599537313,
-0.13827084,
-0.3696978688,
-0.9671394229,
-0.3064613044,
0.5936530232,
0.8735601306,
0.649558723,
-0.2400102168,
-0.36430794,
-0.555670917,
-0.2248445749,
-0.3284257054,
-0.1647862196,
0.3291406035,
-0.1743076891,
-0.3798995018,
0.9027699828,
-0.8067192435,
-0.2370823026,
-0.425786972,
0.0665960014,
-0.0574291199,
0.0855530947,
0.2838981152,
-0.6953612566,
-0.3715820611,
-0.2002212703,
-0.489877969,
-0.2205064148,
-0.1802069396,
-0.2506135404,
-0.2372958362,
0.0807360709,
-0.5686208606,
0.3941384554,
0.4581685662,
-0.7059457898,
0.6470606923,
-0.4182312489,
0.2128047496,
-1.445322156,
-0.0732162371,
0.076109238,
-0.3550966084,
-0.7880627513,
-0.3399674594,
-0.4056789577,
-0.2534435689,
-0.35649845,
0.4884717464,
-0.0035101715,
0.0896869898,
-0.5658431053,
-0.0151237613,
-0.2080155164,
0.679654479,
0.1310422271,
0.8682922125,
0.2305027246,
-0.4894828796,
0.341188699,
0.7801026106,
0.2724560201,
1.166123271,
-0.7930381298,
0.393006742,
-0.2612400949,
0.5867631435,
-0.7517276406,
-0.1348650008,
0.4760186374,
-0.222581014,
0.2768109441,
0.4292835295,
-0.1794249415,
-0.6665374041,
-0.2013652623,
0.3722193241,
0.3587267101,
-0.3886737525,
0.478751421,
0.2017007321,
-0.2626054585,
-0.4514387846,
-0.265935719,
-0.0719666258,
-0.057289429,
-0.3660624623,
0.347954303,
-0.3608347774,
-0.1800614148,
0.0089925202,
-0.0368256755,
0.1915002167,
-0.2045434415,
0.4553391635,
0.4449333549,
-0.191546008,
0.287196368,
0.4255640507,
-0.407823056,
0.1751879305,
-0.1965091228,
0.6361266971,
-0.3533336222,
-0.6811330318,
-0.3162046671,
0.6828503013,
0.5039435029,
-0.2435203046,
0.7922883034,
0.5979733467,
-0.2035342604,
0.0392044671,
-0.3172695041,
-0.2959744334,
-0.4848327935,
0.1347321421,
-0.275595963,
-0.9375599623,
0.1086104512,
-0.194217369,
0.3607919514,
0.2581680417,
0.8310925364,
-0.0294670817,
1.2693537474,
0.4924321175,
0.2923877537,
0.4990006983,
-0.1595588475,
0.3288036287,
-0.7118067741,
-0.140644595,
-0.2652422488,
-0.2458417863,
-0.4514687061,
-0.2272361815,
0.5979219675,
-0.1500723958,
-0.1573616862,
0.329298526,
-0.7240642905,
-0.1796415746,
0.4691059291,
0.2498294264,
0.4180239141,
-0.1548737437,
-0.2295382321,
-0.397254318,
-0.3166690469,
-0.5582345724,
0.8895335197,
0.1998590678,
0.4737985134,
0.1293091774,
0.6636379957,
0.4199825525,
0.6340677142,
-1.0918207169,
0.5550788045,
0.3701032102,
-0.2896877229,
-0.1792315245,
-0.3858268559,
-1.0633007288,
0.3945084512,
-0.282885313,
-0.7112289667,
0.1785109341,
0.3928574622,
-0.4911925197,
-0.0523765832,
-0.4689678252,
0.7216918468,
-0.028247878,
-0.1062808409,
-0.4114946723,
-0.5318254232,
0.4134506583,
-0.0726623982,
-0.0061561405,
0.0425721221,
0.336666137,
0.2071103305,
-0.6171953082,
0.5307751894,
-0.1251598597,
-0.1726375371,
0.3499764502,
0.0998271629,
0.2467042506,
0.1047295928,
-0.0325604491,
-0.5549201965,
0.5097253323,
-0.2577261329,
-0.7568315864,
0.2308896333,
-0.6550237536,
-0.7824921608,
-0.2270322144,
-0.4557507634,
-0.8265957832,
0.1434021592,
0.3282768726,
0.6090676188,
-0.373309195,
-0.2114132643,
0.6921432018,
-0.389780432,
-0.0085414043,
0.7515361309,
-0.3049032688,
-0.6160103679,
0.8847801089,
-0.3558525443,
0.151047051,
0.044286523,
0.2629261911,
-0.3225055933,
-0.0889500827,
-0.2445296794,
0.4356001616,
-0.4546861351,
-0.1731960475,
-0.6933940053,
-0.2523795068,
-0.4541759789,
-0.1496679783,
-0.0812588707,
0.0510154739,
-0.1921551973,
-0.3297934234,
0.3013403118,
0.6424558163,
0.256981045,
0.6745553017,
-1.0295952559,
0.5319437981,
0.3886556029,
0.1246261597,
0.0346876532,
-0.1779642701,
-0.016756352,
0.0571845472,
-0.8836011291,
-1.1905853748,
0.4213755727,
-0.0271984711,
0.5169804096,
0.6090798974,
0.5600422621,
0.6846346855,
-0.4762786627,
0.7661480308,
0.2989706993,
-0.550372839,
0.7168726921,
-0.4022533596,
0.4315581918,
0.6347355843,
0.2217160761,
-0.8288365602,
-0.5070625544,
-0.7136259079,
-0.5122193098,
0.7531888485,
0.2260268331,
0.4286377132,
-0.3130578697,
0.1409227103,
-0.0331859514,
0.3463784754,
-0.2450665385,
-0.1337739974,
-0.3284845054,
-0.3842806518,
0.1006373167,
-0.3306039274,
-0.5355508924,
-0.0812426358,
0.6509216428,
-0.3558421731,
0.7143437862,
0.4905313849,
0.3327077627,
-0.418466568,
0.4792909324,
0.7987745404,
0.3340399265,
-0.0892316923,
0.0075945077,
0.0978217646,
-0.8319747448,
0.0393821262,
0.1696123034,
0.2077156156,
0.0581241548,
0.2510926723,
1.0360207558,
-0.0952722207,
-0.7704829574,
0.445768714,
-0.4753031731,
-0.2072822005,
-0.1597868055,
0.1645273864,
-0.0319259949,
0.3079884946,
0.0165400822,
-0.2475503385,
0.2294728011,
-0.3916924894,
0.1405842006,
0.1422173083,
-0.6968140602,
-0.3294895589,
0.5528869033,
0.1844590902,
-0.8277896047,
0.7798799872,
-0.0488784499,
-0.523571074,
0.1610401571,
0.9332818985,
1.0569769144,
-0.1764830947,
0.5496101975,
0.3679124117,
-0.1205389127,
0.0061854478,
0.563664794,
-0.3253343105,
-0.3178333938,
-0.1185230464,
-0.5226874352,
-0.586435616,
0.2662313282,
-0.8848090768,
0.045488894,
-0.3542506099,
-0.6410014629,
-0.4556260407,
-0.0871283486,
-0.7503921986,
0.2130613774,
0.0686042905,
0.8156471848,
-0.6150588393,
0.5044656396,
0.7353819013,
-0.2384010255,
-0.873878181,
0.378494978,
0.3806491494,
-0.5778046846,
-0.1600935906,
0.1019964591,
-0.3136556447,
0.0744840577,
-0.1884330213,
-0.2853190899,
1.2034245729,
0.4810768366,
-0.3458777368,
-0.1971922517,
0.2026912719,
0.9888805747,
-0.111241363,
0.4249154031,
0.4513793588,
0.2899381816,
0.5351424813,
-0.8722579479,
0.0717940256,
-0.4174689353,
0.1629768163,
0.1166395769,
-0.4264367521,
0.1802201122,
0.0108191529,
-0.1413680762,
0.0436364189,
0.6002663374,
0.5222753286,
0.4883258641,
0.4297599494,
0.4114454687,
0.6400142312,
0.1991827786,
1.2948784828,
-0.207202211,
0.1749628782,
1.2611486912,
-0.0712890103,
0.7858771682,
0.4906924367,
-0.1494814306,
0.4331254661,
0.656692028,
0.2386119217,
0.4496842325,
0.1393291205,
-0.6278262734,
-0.245782584,
-0.4960652888,
-0.3802173436,
0.168089509,
0.4927402139,
-0.3873621225,
-0.1639211029,
0.1837865263,
-0.0238145497,
0.2100187838,
-0.0921568274,
0.9655514956,
0.4817891717,
-0.8817118406,
0.3833701909,
-0.0399631076,
0.1679592133,
-0.7527062297,
-0.1728947759,
-0.1559802443,
0.2678890824,
-0.0423953719,
-0.7895294428,
0.4376667142,
0.1137291491,
-0.1345337331,
-0.3637681305,
0.8108711839,
-0.2616118789,
-0.4134523571,
0.2188237309,
0.5688037276,
-0.086792767,
0.0540699773,
-0.6629448533,
-0.2239140123,
-0.3226198554,
-0.4623479247,
0.32361269,
0.3032459021,
0.0410267152,
0.5367139578,
0.6259182692,
0.0798715577,
-0.219988063,
0.1668697298,
0.8433764577,
-0.2326951176,
-0.6694589853,
-0.4209706485,
0.6318335533,
-0.2046367824,
-0.4080023468,
0.5875785947,
0.088456504,
0.3844641447,
0.0343249366,
0.53146559,
0.1471749544,
0.6154258251,
-0.1818951964,
0.4244222045,
-0.6433279514,
0.0091530308,
-0.3120369315,
-0.8184399009,
0.115355514,
0.2675488591,
-0.5188292861,
-0.1004142687,
0.4015186727,
0.5757964253,
0.045430243,
0.2629177272,
0.3844532073,
-0.2263456881,
0.663392365,
0.5132548213,
0.7234950066,
-0.0965704992,
0.518510282,
0.1869379133,
-0.0325057991,
-0.105057016,
-0.4291236997,
-0.7645114064,
-0.4900602996,
-0.048829291,
-0.679915309,
-0.1567444056,
1.1767551899,
0.3873818517,
-0.6356210709,
0.1048493311,
-0.1980024874,
-0.1532978565,
-0.4121221304,
-0.2244542837,
0.0253012907,
-0.101565592,
-0.4962884188,
0.3492482603,
0.1493634731,
0.0929896086,
-0.3345079124,
-0.2986557782,
0.3425246775,
0.4428253174,
0.4727021754,
0.4080234468,
-0.6200413108,
0.0336633995,
0.1054072976,
-0.3847280741,
0.0432359278,
1.1238211393,
-0.8318728805,
0.9117867351,
0.216326192,
0.9299796224,
0.4970638156,
0.2350745648,
0.9626629353,
-0.4180716574,
-0.2184751481,
0.3492003977,
0.0354804732,
0.1075280756,
-0.646325767,
0.1829167157,
0.1755240709,
-0.4030048251,
-0.7322408557,
0.3217321336,
-1.0013660192,
-0.0307707712,
0.8964045048,
-0.2242283523,
-0.0047904816,
-0.1517348737,
-0.9449457526,
0.4689435363,
-0.3523717523,
0.9035574198,
0.5198501348,
-0.3867617249,
-0.3239576519,
-0.4869096577,
0.5992498398,
0.4285831153,
-1.1077760458,
0.0066083972,
0.5494470596,
-0.1005163565,
0.0534423999,
1.0555927753,
0.1051068231,
0.3713470101,
0.0120087992,
-0.2984908223,
-0.1423104405,
-0.0261060745,
-0.3068253696,
-0.0559391528,
-0.0590276979,
-0.0782114267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12726v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12726v1 | Specializing Smaller Language Models towards Multi-Step Reasoning | 2023-01-30T08:51:19 | 2023-01-30T08:51:19 | Yao Fu, Hao Peng, Litu Ou, Ashish Sabharwal, Tushar Khot | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The surprising ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to perform well on
complex reasoning with only few-shot chain-of-thought prompts is believed to
emerge only in very large-scale models (100+ billion parameters). We show that
such abilities can, in fact, be distilled down from GPT-3.5 ($\ge$ 175B) to T5
variants ($\le$ 11B). We propose model specialization, to specialize the
model's ability towards a target task. The hypothesis is that large models
(commonly viewed as larger than 100B) have strong modeling power, but are
spread on a large spectrum of tasks. Small models (commonly viewed as smaller
than 10B) have limited model capacity, but if we concentrate their capacity on
a specific target task, the model can achieve a decent improved performance. We
use multi-step math reasoning as our testbed because it is a very typical
emergent ability. We show two important aspects of model abilities: (1). there
exists a very complex balance/ tradeoff between language models'
multi-dimensional abilities; (2). by paying the price of decreased generic
ability, we can clearly lift up the scaling curve of models smaller than 10B
towards a specialized multi-step math reasoning ability. We further give
comprehensive discussions about important design choices for better
generalization, including the tuning data format, the start model checkpoint,
and a new model selection method. We hope our practice and discoveries can
serve as an important attempt towards specialized smaller models in the new
research paradigm set by LLMs. | [
-0.6274420619,
-0.6983488202,
0.9707896709,
0.1856630743,
-0.1404776424,
0.0097243292,
-0.1604665816,
-0.4345112741,
-0.059946958,
0.4747874439,
-0.421875596,
-0.1727487743,
-0.7857362032,
-0.0792334974,
-0.2022062242,
0.7256171107,
0.2109215111,
0.2922449708,
0.060923256,
-0.0053846492,
-0.2997543514,
-0.3955377042,
-0.8479453325,
-0.5594015718,
0.7197051048,
0.3451945186,
0.6881220937,
0.6950601935,
0.5612674356,
0.197308585,
-0.3525065482,
0.1572788954,
-0.1394471377,
-0.0729791746,
-0.0746896565,
-0.6602751017,
-0.7821519971,
0.1228072792,
0.7596015334,
1.0186977386,
-0.1154108793,
0.0533066764,
-0.0783622861,
0.6092039943,
-0.2857453525,
0.1261342615,
-0.6481825709,
-0.1192610487,
-0.2046715468,
0.4628694355,
-0.5396062136,
0.0550726019,
0.0136311073,
-0.2755211294,
0.2584271133,
0.0702842474,
0.4443757832,
0.1784696132,
-0.6085271835,
-0.0119901234,
-1.034193635,
1.0237268209,
-0.9167631865,
0.3633726835,
0.0786004588,
0.5480554104,
-0.0099149449,
-0.6593751907,
-0.2794488668,
-0.4189065695,
0.1585460752,
-0.2506248355,
-0.1399877518,
0.07438761,
0.8418844342,
0.3795527816,
-0.3352319896,
0.188828513,
-0.3472925425,
-0.103267692,
0.5196352005,
0.2507264018,
0.1107420772,
0.0566650555,
0.0376167968,
0.070706889,
-0.843711257,
0.0433379076,
0.2053938508,
0.5868746042,
0.0485379398,
0.6219722629,
-0.2389152199,
0.8029081821,
-0.1198753193,
-0.3599039912,
-0.146391958,
-0.4505732954,
-0.2801350057,
-0.5063585043,
0.4129318297,
-0.2882668972,
0.3416094482,
0.2644110024,
-0.2701945007,
0.043322023,
0.1062926427,
-0.7047361135,
-0.3345948756,
-0.0246004518,
-0.5036786199,
0.013795536,
-0.1836498231,
-0.463876456,
-0.3481194377,
-0.5070166588,
0.3053795695,
-0.3077377379,
-0.3122085631,
0.2912023067,
-0.1199714094,
0.0585386865,
0.5927492976,
-0.9379652739,
0.3808302581,
0.7470856309,
0.6914550662,
0.0640526935,
-0.2462657094,
-0.4033680856,
0.0062976982,
-0.5089381933,
0.797228992,
-0.8624194264,
-0.216296941,
-0.3009153605,
-0.3291161358,
-0.1966881901,
-0.5170413256,
0.5796277523,
-0.4947595596,
-0.1516121924,
-0.3296242356,
-0.4020655155,
-0.2444224954,
0.2379747778,
-0.8044301867,
0.8215834498,
-0.0856098235,
-0.5826749802,
0.3796727955,
-0.6654086709,
-0.3947480619,
-0.168862164,
-0.235336259,
-0.228333503,
0.5124984384,
0.2455285341,
0.3239744008,
-0.6770271659,
-0.0068652201,
-0.6333935261,
-0.2073031217,
-0.005228309,
-0.5452631712,
0.7606748343,
0.1269827336,
-0.102923505,
0.0902443603,
-0.7561828494,
0.1438504755,
0.1176870763,
-0.3850094974,
-0.3459779322,
0.0049512945,
-0.4125906527,
0.5106987953,
0.2235783339,
-0.2350331545,
0.5471279621,
-0.3379694223,
0.4568505585,
0.5363544822,
-0.1321399659,
0.6514956355,
-0.3185462952,
0.630194366,
0.2264624536,
0.2012327462,
-0.1655780971,
-0.8907719254,
-0.9386041164,
-0.4204212129,
0.4007359445,
0.2803471386,
-0.4635054469,
0.0829999223,
-0.1457415521,
-0.5437169075,
-0.4551519454,
0.2207994759,
0.2669917047,
0.1510666758,
0.3648647964,
-0.0606325008,
-0.2959772944,
-1.1813230515,
-0.4318040907,
0.0476662815,
-0.2393916994,
0.1918920428,
0.6549408436,
-0.1168335229,
0.7749269009,
-0.5829740763,
-0.1307082325,
-0.5472213626,
0.1908318698,
0.3998124003,
0.3978093266,
0.3084622622,
-0.7659306526,
-0.4407111108,
-0.0704727918,
-0.3660418093,
0.0946421698,
-0.0178759489,
0.0732424632,
-0.1282249093,
0.5431396961,
-0.7644953728,
0.1866805404,
0.3584438264,
-0.1283768564,
0.4682496488,
-0.3702568412,
-0.2024083138,
-0.9997594357,
-0.2717661262,
0.2164397985,
-0.044036001,
-0.8497863412,
0.1767172515,
0.1650760025,
-0.0462885313,
-0.2165779471,
0.5969315171,
-0.496593684,
-0.0670328438,
-0.3233731687,
0.0057204631,
-0.1136814132,
0.3548885584,
0.122739166,
0.323818922,
0.6027202606,
-0.7536269426,
0.1257055402,
-0.2279367894,
-0.3193441331,
0.3267387748,
-0.5972630382,
0.1780990064,
0.0321887322,
0.2824672759,
-0.8018528223,
-0.2486402243,
-0.1064016595,
-0.1685612351,
0.2395682931,
-0.5151221752,
-0.6703135967,
-0.4932765365,
-0.1082937494,
0.4256851375,
0.5057704449,
-0.2190334946,
0.845253408,
0.2386237681,
-0.2655832469,
-0.3112860024,
-0.6583301425,
-0.0667047277,
-0.2435002327,
-0.6897207499,
0.0470800996,
-0.2742521167,
-0.4781866074,
-0.328256309,
-0.060330037,
-0.0543804169,
-0.0096748052,
-0.1032793522,
0.1950547248,
-0.4443296194,
0.1133607179,
0.3040241599,
-0.302886337,
0.0526182726,
-0.5366861224,
0.437325716,
-0.2306973785,
-0.6349394321,
0.0314089842,
0.3944074512,
0.7216337919,
-0.259817481,
0.6148992181,
0.4320296347,
-0.579449892,
-0.3113425374,
-0.4766317606,
-0.3145109117,
-0.4070570767,
0.36874336,
-0.7823992372,
-0.9021525979,
0.5232912302,
-0.1946995258,
0.2205237895,
0.5927265882,
0.6383488178,
0.1602763385,
1.5691404343,
0.8062613606,
0.1741319001,
0.3348950446,
-0.3055820465,
0.4980576038,
-0.9586983919,
-0.1337127388,
-0.5383288264,
-0.2723846734,
-0.4599804878,
-0.8248804808,
0.3801451325,
0.1922822297,
-0.3529056907,
0.1047189087,
-0.185684815,
0.559201479,
0.4869657159,
-0.0590012446,
0.4531112015,
-0.1140315235,
-0.3282018304,
-0.1437583268,
-0.8211723566,
-0.5143213868,
1.0867233276,
0.5949148536,
0.8834345341,
0.0978977382,
0.5598589778,
-0.0476468094,
0.3332500756,
-0.9508433342,
0.6468581557,
-0.2930247486,
-0.8812326193,
-0.5627450347,
-0.5655784607,
-0.5606328249,
0.5665411353,
0.0071665021,
-0.6059909463,
0.0786232054,
0.1794190258,
-0.4318451881,
0.4504517019,
-0.7916862965,
0.6799381971,
-0.0970059708,
0.0552388653,
-0.3846120834,
-0.4825215638,
0.5644290447,
-0.2157376707,
0.5077552795,
-0.2202823609,
-0.1908809394,
0.5085387826,
-0.1439261585,
0.9172853231,
-0.067924656,
-0.2626318932,
0.1492806226,
0.3569286466,
0.6007386446,
-0.0224103313,
0.0062440392,
-0.0102221752,
-0.2735817134,
-0.5259128213,
-0.5883787274,
0.6036364436,
-0.4754001498,
-0.8816599846,
-0.146493867,
-0.6722248793,
-0.4303798079,
0.2741077542,
0.1220430061,
0.2446399629,
0.1672849357,
0.215398252,
0.9087225795,
0.2813641727,
0.4201813638,
0.4465967119,
-0.2306177318,
-0.2367488444,
0.8067323565,
0.2659359872,
0.6289850473,
0.4223431945,
0.4329921603,
-0.2427723557,
-0.7335582376,
-0.3523782194,
0.3953347504,
-0.940951407,
0.0852372646,
-0.6128795743,
-0.2421887815,
-0.4512189329,
0.1158037707,
-0.5368489027,
-0.6659626961,
-0.122267127,
0.023388762,
-0.0220265817,
0.8789260983,
-0.1277545393,
0.0585745722,
-0.7063110471,
0.2893894315,
0.5605992079,
0.1565732956,
0.2809147239,
-0.8690900207,
-0.3738701642,
0.0070216628,
-0.2384752482,
-0.5245870352,
0.109023273,
0.0102376798,
0.6413981915,
0.5253258944,
-0.3193231821,
0.6039566398,
-0.6220369935,
0.5740621686,
0.1862644404,
-0.9547460675,
0.4592496157,
-0.4957537651,
0.4690520763,
0.1224164665,
0.3996488452,
-0.3248554766,
-0.4281032681,
-0.75626266,
-0.5608825684,
0.5752092004,
0.1232464239,
0.1457634866,
0.2461936921,
0.3381928802,
0.0745718852,
0.1236648709,
-0.9548396468,
-0.1462688148,
0.1732840687,
0.0964902863,
-0.1102116778,
-0.1069581732,
-0.1952726096,
-0.4012802839,
0.4168717563,
-0.3985919952,
0.0660128444,
-0.2440225482,
0.1502134651,
0.0197081938,
0.4174501896,
0.7381614447,
0.8541133404,
0.2101320922,
0.2661523521,
0.3759186864,
-0.2931725085,
0.1540952027,
0.0020818182,
-0.0469035693,
-0.3627888858,
0.537956655,
0.5242131352,
0.292042762,
-0.3208040595,
0.2090757936,
0.0704136044,
-0.2607479393,
0.0346103944,
0.2934136689,
0.3942492902,
0.5390075445,
0.3469845057,
0.3505904078,
0.0574375875,
-0.5919270515,
-0.0197012834,
0.403840065,
-0.0507834889,
-0.3415792882,
0.5423963666,
0.0358936861,
-0.3197897375,
0.4497054815,
-0.310498327,
-0.3262978196,
0.7570028901,
0.4911563098,
0.7394115329,
-0.2195973694,
0.1099199504,
0.3353707194,
0.5537501574,
-0.5938166976,
0.1988183707,
0.1240328252,
-0.7896330357,
-0.6180028915,
-0.5450053215,
-0.429523617,
0.2008142024,
-0.4893541038,
0.3051864803,
-0.5949850678,
-0.1746606231,
0.124318108,
-0.0085854856,
-0.5134780407,
0.251733005,
0.2348445952,
0.9554249644,
-0.973664403,
0.9754940867,
0.6158294678,
-0.4392592311,
-0.8512898684,
0.1521399766,
-0.0526057705,
-0.7412176728,
0.6936901808,
0.0055191279,
-0.0735970587,
-0.0061884471,
-0.4940085411,
-1.0064319372,
0.9310284257,
0.5071995854,
-0.7032309175,
-0.370255053,
-0.0193833821,
0.6127792001,
-0.789447546,
0.1950402111,
0.7979710698,
0.4886269867,
0.2790347338,
-0.9305410981,
0.0038999498,
0.0870269015,
0.2323216349,
0.2837256491,
-0.6467704773,
1.3471980095,
-0.6231355667,
0.1714235693,
0.0624583513,
0.4342443049,
0.5688373446,
0.1634878814,
0.5305730104,
0.6434649229,
0.7243626118,
0.0027836566,
1.0946010351,
0.0249231011,
0.3744697571,
0.9973195791,
-0.1375578344,
0.8758606911,
0.3333742321,
-0.2667104304,
0.4667583704,
0.7201138139,
0.0651882365,
0.2286245376,
0.2273934484,
-0.2177324146,
-0.873837769,
0.237209931,
-0.1553290486,
0.259238869,
0.4566569626,
-0.3470985591,
-0.183657065,
-0.0336875878,
-0.0761671215,
-0.2309407145,
-0.4628825784,
0.5284364223,
0.5110862851,
-0.5590539575,
0.2695835233,
0.1530041546,
0.2780998945,
-0.564872086,
-0.0344617963,
-0.1496943235,
0.2325113714,
0.0386441462,
-0.576744616,
0.1171229109,
-0.1221869886,
-0.4862675071,
-0.1913040131,
0.7247792482,
-0.2429368198,
-0.8021677136,
0.3284222186,
0.7947499156,
0.0875761807,
-0.2731595039,
-0.7888545394,
-0.067399323,
-0.0787137747,
-0.2051376551,
0.4116755128,
0.7012637854,
-0.2822570205,
0.8155691028,
0.5528094172,
0.3206969798,
0.0903622136,
0.4498926103,
0.8535175323,
-0.8243365884,
-0.4074730873,
-0.8862392306,
0.5257057548,
0.0274927821,
-0.1980058551,
0.5956120491,
0.4655076563,
0.6806762218,
-0.138174504,
0.7129024267,
0.0996070877,
0.5427215099,
-0.6067116857,
0.2772704661,
-0.5631912351,
0.4449273646,
-0.1546524614,
-0.9545487165,
-0.4161719978,
0.494331181,
-0.5139077306,
0.5029834509,
0.9713147283,
0.5390876532,
-0.2942197621,
-0.1850774288,
0.6949450374,
0.2367455959,
0.5500535965,
0.657440722,
0.7835972905,
-0.1414276361,
0.6528612971,
0.0198187064,
-0.2868350446,
-0.2163294703,
-0.8035988212,
-1.0511995554,
-0.3437338769,
-0.1567517966,
-0.0589814447,
-0.5798199773,
0.7044637799,
0.9333317876,
-0.6084550023,
-0.2371191829,
-0.2208165377,
0.3251337409,
-0.2658157349,
-0.1445179135,
-0.0446220003,
-0.3296619058,
-0.8306939602,
0.4248139262,
0.3975511193,
0.1920807213,
-0.5460984707,
-0.0376589149,
-0.0189470947,
0.429294914,
0.6766097546,
0.0786937103,
-0.9078170061,
-0.1863919795,
0.0419470072,
-0.0380937941,
-0.0087235086,
1.2262408733,
-0.3613227904,
0.307446003,
0.3946511149,
0.394541353,
0.5302340388,
-0.391694665,
0.5314005017,
-0.5181407928,
0.1007300168,
0.4573594034,
0.617675662,
0.1612549275,
0.0374692678,
0.3488621116,
0.3277110755,
-0.3407377601,
-0.8001191616,
0.7077130675,
-0.6327187419,
-0.3511942327,
1.096704483,
-0.0862644687,
0.1383817345,
-0.0240491107,
-0.1283994615,
-0.1182432473,
-0.2432388663,
0.7084709406,
1.0398145914,
-0.6049343348,
-0.3652750552,
-0.6430678964,
0.4886965156,
0.3821104467,
-0.7825980783,
0.1147076637,
0.3405999839,
0.2456077486,
0.4001845717,
0.5250527859,
-0.1015567631,
0.2045764625,
0.2769101858,
-0.4140247703,
0.1476099789,
-0.7567259073,
-0.5209161043,
0.2650519609,
0.4304337204,
0.2916504741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13852v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13852v1 | ChatGPT or Human? Detect and Explain. Explaining Decisions of Machine Learning Model for Detecting Short ChatGPT-generated Text | 2023-01-30T08:06:08 | 2023-01-30T08:06:08 | Sandra Mitrović, Davide Andreoletti, Omran Ayoub | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | ChatGPT has the ability to generate grammatically flawless and
seemingly-human replies to different types of questions from various domains.
The number of its users and of its applications is growing at an unprecedented
rate. Unfortunately, use and abuse come hand in hand. In this paper, we study
whether a machine learning model can be effectively trained to accurately
distinguish between original human and seemingly human (that is,
ChatGPT-generated) text, especially when this text is short. Furthermore, we
employ an explainable artificial intelligence framework to gain insight into
the reasoning behind the model trained to differentiate between
ChatGPT-generated and human-generated text. The goal is to analyze model's
decisions and determine if any specific patterns or characteristics can be
identified. Our study focuses on short online reviews, conducting two
experiments comparing human-generated and ChatGPT-generated text. The first
experiment involves ChatGPT text generated from custom queries, while the
second experiment involves text generated by rephrasing original
human-generated reviews. We fine-tune a Transformer-based model and use it to
make predictions, which are then explained using SHAP. We compare our model
with a perplexity score-based approach and find that disambiguation between
human and ChatGPT-generated reviews is more challenging for the ML model when
using rephrased text. However, our proposed approach still achieves an accuracy
of 79%. Using explainability, we observe that ChatGPT's writing is polite,
without specific details, using fancy and atypical vocabulary, impersonal, and
typically it does not express feelings. | [
-0.4527148306,
-1.0628777742,
0.5519939065,
0.1819483042,
-0.4281220138,
0.1029114053,
-0.2283817381,
-0.5891646147,
-0.0761955604,
0.3989706039,
-0.5085240602,
-0.2045292854,
-0.6450644732,
0.3372691572,
-0.5407087803,
1.2621685266,
0.0640795752,
-0.1494448036,
-0.0064747217,
0.1362687498,
-0.3315461576,
-0.6391885877,
-0.7468093634,
-0.5447385311,
0.51504457,
0.3672641516,
0.8742710352,
0.3073270619,
0.5878121853,
0.2929880917,
-0.175140366,
0.0541045554,
-0.4878682792,
-0.1885440797,
0.0249325968,
-0.3457130492,
-0.2588465512,
0.0482845567,
0.2980144024,
0.3920050263,
-0.0731771737,
-0.002110065,
0.3345147073,
0.5521957278,
-0.2162925154,
0.0663111433,
-0.660058558,
0.1344939768,
-0.0508225113,
-0.1830710322,
-0.4214245081,
-0.3331060708,
0.3471989036,
-0.3890901208,
0.6584401727,
0.228903383,
0.9718300104,
0.0542550273,
-0.2857844532,
-0.5553973317,
-0.8113105297,
0.549980402,
-0.5309786797,
0.2079943866,
0.3318463564,
0.472260654,
-0.0595091097,
-0.6033769846,
-1.0747097731,
-0.4280986488,
-0.4259233177,
0.2412678152,
-0.3160115182,
-0.0730611384,
0.3054589629,
0.3906895816,
-0.8165098429,
0.0337704867,
-0.3062247038,
-0.3197863698,
0.6485882998,
0.1019519195,
0.3616071343,
-0.6471372247,
-0.5440009236,
0.1840312183,
-0.4910479188,
0.2067161202,
0.6061602831,
-0.0416893698,
0.1495221853,
0.5782431364,
-0.1973059326,
0.2716635466,
0.1452440321,
0.137472257,
0.0056802942,
-0.1883352697,
-0.3050093055,
-0.0032840786,
1.0973266363,
0.4719188213,
0.5435144901,
-0.0701840594,
-0.2495105565,
0.2997886539,
0.4362913668,
-0.909709096,
-0.4997552931,
0.030337045,
-0.7982937098,
-0.6794108152,
0.0420425236,
-0.641515553,
-0.6453306079,
-0.1280439943,
0.4111892879,
-0.4548842907,
-0.1890224069,
0.188186124,
-0.1974712312,
0.2774059772,
0.307762742,
-0.8156257272,
0.1055019498,
0.6044394374,
0.6965888739,
-0.259570986,
-0.3251212239,
-0.0383643918,
-0.4125117362,
-0.0729975849,
1.0788103342,
-0.3827075958,
-0.389993757,
-0.2286190242,
0.0055001643,
-0.1445876807,
-0.4328050911,
0.8367949128,
-0.5486739278,
0.7404852509,
-0.075109385,
-0.5819603801,
-0.2951131165,
0.4015959799,
-0.5284098983,
0.7719138861,
0.0459456369,
-1.0773158073,
0.3858504593,
-0.8122535944,
-0.2714584768,
0.1392966509,
0.1499024928,
-0.8607289791,
-0.1113462523,
0.4403614104,
0.4365018904,
-0.0835302398,
0.1840248108,
-0.1849440187,
-0.5459402204,
0.6306318045,
-0.760481298,
0.6690102816,
0.441019088,
-0.3332167268,
0.1153606251,
-0.3673514724,
0.0001221114,
0.4437081814,
-0.3554951251,
0.0834601521,
0.2017088681,
0.1737864465,
0.0644014552,
-0.017125763,
-0.5010880828,
-0.091201514,
-0.3395808041,
0.7182692885,
0.4665330052,
0.3131452799,
0.3202469945,
-0.5780382156,
0.6122916341,
-0.1074849814,
0.2308409959,
-0.3271897733,
-0.5918132067,
-0.7246223092,
-0.0938685685,
0.3331792355,
0.6271076202,
-0.5792329311,
0.3338607848,
-0.2814464271,
-0.5018638372,
-0.5719383955,
0.0561146401,
0.4897199869,
0.642156899,
0.2810269296,
-0.3409475684,
-0.3956851363,
-0.8859966993,
-0.7569069862,
-0.4373424053,
-0.3381684422,
0.2905913889,
0.514775753,
-0.4349095523,
0.9984813333,
-0.3444556594,
-0.0276465602,
-0.4527159035,
0.2879152,
-0.0448111966,
0.2058109194,
0.344779402,
-1.0970652103,
-0.6100736856,
-0.0423582308,
-0.5383754373,
-0.1074384302,
-0.2296590358,
0.0481974073,
-0.0452895202,
0.2319257557,
-0.6239295602,
0.5347371101,
0.05553893,
-0.2410280257,
0.8351911306,
-0.1690581441,
0.2777969837,
-0.8268877268,
-0.0280944258,
-0.0324351974,
-0.3943218887,
-0.7143815756,
-0.1366421729,
-0.1158601865,
-0.24247621,
-0.3053148389,
0.4462165236,
-0.0582462773,
0.3252061009,
-0.5053219795,
0.3003458977,
0.1657676101,
0.5637304187,
0.0759339109,
0.5626104474,
-0.0564466454,
-0.4067450166,
0.3124145269,
0.3598500788,
-0.4252454638,
0.5342668295,
-0.8252413273,
0.2654809356,
-0.1701720357,
0.2882901132,
-1.0798581839,
-0.407520622,
0.5247679353,
-0.8979463577,
-0.1267588437,
-0.3969907463,
-0.4880654812,
-0.3985152245,
-0.1042894721,
0.1118892506,
0.8388551474,
-0.613468647,
0.4855777621,
0.3354742527,
-0.2769194841,
-0.1997126788,
-0.4314256608,
0.1338700056,
-0.4145130515,
-0.6628317833,
0.2620889843,
-0.0043494296,
-0.2461439222,
-0.0588473938,
0.1399240941,
-0.2561169565,
0.1619963497,
0.3130643964,
0.2093435526,
-0.2924800813,
0.2144892663,
-0.1310774833,
-0.1320436597,
0.269230485,
-0.012241601,
0.6107651591,
-0.417098999,
-0.4365790784,
-0.6591767669,
0.2397994101,
0.4242212772,
-0.1086556166,
0.3612572849,
0.8521386981,
-0.0410483144,
-0.1164521873,
-0.4186334908,
-0.3149382472,
-0.4414590001,
0.3755281866,
-0.2865668833,
-0.6479501724,
0.4732998312,
0.1832464188,
-0.1115653664,
0.5662592053,
0.6336179376,
-0.4799036682,
1.1792197227,
0.5236384273,
-0.0765633285,
0.4875855446,
0.1857316345,
0.4444507658,
-0.3724432588,
-0.0579764545,
-0.4772510827,
-0.2136005014,
-0.7962741256,
-0.1073713973,
-0.0145838391,
0.0466194376,
-0.0656416938,
0.2071655244,
-0.6645302773,
0.6897105575,
0.4287660122,
0.3063547313,
0.3007591069,
-0.0452665351,
0.2208027542,
0.0833707154,
-0.5509935617,
-0.917747438,
0.7937844396,
0.4636519253,
0.5075324178,
-0.0179287829,
0.4404888749,
0.7436067462,
0.3266427815,
-0.8384519219,
0.3605484962,
0.0333909243,
-0.4816242456,
-0.1058749706,
-0.420820713,
-1.0118563175,
0.3284532726,
-0.3387939632,
-0.524790287,
-0.4289476275,
0.3502659202,
-0.1909440011,
0.2485277057,
-1.0871033669,
0.9896296859,
-0.1941706836,
-0.0126324808,
-0.2306282073,
-0.6386415958,
0.287723124,
-0.071589306,
0.0472667217,
-0.0263947435,
0.338992089,
0.7442405224,
-0.4041703939,
0.8485733271,
-0.1368910074,
0.1643740982,
0.6088402271,
0.1149734706,
0.3993327618,
-0.0064015053,
0.1991340518,
0.1318492293,
-0.0979404971,
-0.3879816234,
-0.6915544271,
0.2519464493,
-0.630992949,
-0.4784110487,
-0.1612461507,
-0.2062957436,
0.0340502448,
0.2147147208,
0.4782160521,
0.1211800948,
-0.3214341998,
-0.0352221727,
0.5326618552,
-0.2119585723,
0.3210073411,
0.363702476,
-0.3296662271,
-0.0369339921,
1.0147672892,
-0.4455486238,
0.0737522766,
0.3510521352,
0.562554419,
-0.3343088329,
-0.5229021311,
-0.4914601743,
0.0789390504,
-0.483319521,
0.2302050442,
-0.6129735112,
-0.3284825981,
-0.1098407507,
-0.0008643875,
0.0210577697,
-0.3343789279,
-0.1593237966,
0.1137745753,
0.1634662598,
0.8351378441,
0.4521933496,
0.6956287622,
-0.6551221609,
0.44537431,
0.3434941471,
0.2476304322,
-0.0587912835,
-0.7697558999,
0.1160335243,
0.2181517631,
-0.5103979707,
-1.0187262297,
0.3163683116,
0.0835622102,
0.2315066904,
0.5787425637,
0.024167126,
0.3918483257,
-0.359146297,
0.7735957503,
-0.0351901203,
-0.8300824165,
0.4490686655,
-0.359475255,
0.178450346,
0.2052067518,
0.3272430003,
-0.927714467,
-0.4249067605,
-0.7697900534,
-0.4726183116,
0.4295653105,
0.5442152619,
0.2536973059,
0.1185506061,
0.3899003863,
0.3580877781,
0.2001391202,
-0.9470156431,
0.1650467068,
-0.3350971937,
-0.193604812,
0.0487534516,
-0.4008951187,
0.2665941119,
0.175005272,
0.591242969,
-0.0623652264,
0.5348677635,
0.0716553405,
-0.3933035731,
0.2846468091,
0.5132456422,
0.583599925,
0.4383938909,
-0.0679243505,
0.0721722841,
0.1302396655,
-0.646258831,
-0.2550807595,
0.0809073895,
-0.3530556262,
0.1285667568,
0.4673862457,
0.693590045,
-0.0924221203,
-0.6678317785,
0.7437283993,
-0.3492073119,
-0.2165345848,
-0.3115141988,
0.1232550889,
-0.0185581297,
0.2171566188,
0.1094518527,
0.3603440523,
0.0956514552,
-0.3053240478,
0.1795299798,
0.4312298,
-0.5482411981,
-0.3711848855,
0.6222422719,
0.2662343085,
-0.6070042253,
0.7577353716,
-0.422888279,
-1.0301705599,
0.5493596196,
0.1506743431,
0.9548746943,
0.1874848455,
0.3798696101,
0.1789136231,
0.3116673231,
0.1289704591,
0.0164669529,
-0.3394785225,
-0.8983071446,
-0.2210790813,
-0.5048830509,
-0.5360566378,
0.1393237859,
-0.5089222789,
0.3900295496,
-0.3414491117,
-0.1190738231,
0.2696718276,
-0.0077547329,
-0.5371306539,
0.1278768182,
0.0532275923,
0.5040143728,
-0.9913380146,
0.6068816185,
0.2074855417,
-0.4804886281,
-0.6709866524,
0.3384104073,
0.0364882275,
-0.8257004023,
0.2981561124,
0.4440577328,
-0.1585958898,
-0.1810479462,
-0.4744980335,
-0.0493844412,
0.6280021071,
0.0623168424,
-0.3609058261,
0.0053463494,
0.1771526337,
0.8362483382,
-0.1045164019,
0.5031122565,
0.491019398,
0.3463857174,
-0.0466440022,
-0.9788094163,
-0.1962965578,
-0.2633460462,
-0.2113262117,
0.0807206035,
-0.3890365362,
0.5764338374,
-0.32838884,
-0.4298964739,
0.1784055531,
0.4613723755,
0.0514466353,
0.5354045033,
0.5982735157,
0.1623516232,
0.8017479181,
-0.1138286367,
1.0615035295,
0.0920648947,
0.5421034694,
1.0204728842,
-0.0118424762,
0.8007922769,
0.2813208103,
-0.2243779302,
0.6203427911,
0.7981895208,
-0.2401545942,
0.1894979328,
0.1635454446,
-0.2498755157,
-0.1705639064,
0.0939678997,
-0.0775544122,
0.5682160258,
0.0682030022,
-0.577857852,
-0.1686527729,
0.0632846281,
0.0737743303,
0.1106434762,
-0.2282049358,
0.9485809207,
-0.07789132,
-0.8331804276,
0.3501737416,
0.1468276829,
0.6305356026,
-0.3598427176,
0.129107222,
-0.105215922,
0.3715980351,
-0.266826421,
-0.9407787323,
0.2154534161,
0.2227814198,
-0.4556973577,
-0.3830577731,
0.9146436453,
-0.3784984946,
-0.414037466,
-0.1494285613,
0.5035759211,
0.4661145508,
-0.4334272444,
-0.8363325,
-0.4778283834,
0.2034021616,
-0.1137316525,
0.162313059,
0.433174938,
-0.2270937115,
0.8000203967,
0.7431721687,
-0.2117740214,
-0.0259174202,
-0.0037909006,
0.5576654673,
-0.4753726125,
-0.7122327089,
-1.0929049253,
0.3082006872,
-0.2020868659,
-0.2163027674,
0.6316385865,
0.4741637111,
0.5726931095,
-0.2226870656,
0.8861056566,
-0.0590989552,
0.9058067799,
-0.3934937418,
1.0559306145,
-0.1471740603,
0.320792377,
-0.219308883,
-0.7356184721,
-0.1840680689,
0.6162495613,
-0.4667901993,
0.1321676373,
0.6495002508,
0.8027104139,
-0.2054140717,
0.4311911464,
0.1461298466,
0.0512336455,
0.4289198518,
0.5022388697,
1.3149285316,
-0.2812132239,
0.9873344898,
-0.0904284865,
-0.0207088217,
-0.3034017384,
-0.9097803831,
-1.0502974987,
-0.4392392039,
-0.3041549623,
-0.3796600401,
-0.1662620902,
0.610260427,
0.5125519037,
-0.6857378483,
0.1741963625,
-0.173810035,
0.2718314528,
-0.1556398422,
-0.2964572906,
0.3446668088,
-0.2320526242,
-0.5985652208,
0.0067141051,
-0.0120372986,
0.0795291513,
-0.1310397387,
-0.1198601276,
0.3190912008,
0.0510438941,
0.4877324402,
0.2997781932,
-0.8250394464,
-0.3786891699,
-0.05040152,
-0.1424652636,
0.1890026033,
0.855599761,
-0.6327829361,
0.5633276105,
0.6109287143,
0.5054365993,
0.4245345592,
0.2454389632,
0.3451393545,
-0.5453608632,
-0.2331047654,
0.4689950943,
0.2703509927,
0.4072371721,
-0.4160196781,
0.2078398168,
0.3305767477,
-0.858545661,
-0.600186348,
0.2754820883,
-0.8678380251,
-0.2074388862,
0.8967871666,
-0.1664323658,
-0.0476171635,
-0.3162384331,
-0.640209794,
0.0108558452,
-0.2960639596,
1.1468658447,
0.6674892902,
-0.2879676223,
-0.2705514431,
-0.4545606971,
0.5695348978,
0.2718483806,
-0.7738066316,
0.0175180584,
0.3358034492,
0.506051898,
-0.0110332761,
0.4727656543,
-0.0079949023,
0.5140737295,
-0.168279916,
-0.031917695,
0.0280861985,
0.0060324096,
-0.2775338292,
0.3633061945,
-0.0135596637,
-0.2383649647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12715v1 | Fine-Tuning Deteriorates General Textual Out-of-Distribution Detection by Distorting Task-Agnostic Features | 2023-01-30T08:01:13 | 2023-01-30T08:01:13 | Sishuo Chen, Wenkai Yang, Xiaohan Bi, Xu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting out-of-distribution (OOD) inputs is crucial for the safe deployment
of natural language processing (NLP) models. Though existing methods,
especially those based on the statistics in the feature space of fine-tuned
pre-trained language models (PLMs), are claimed to be effective, their
effectiveness on different types of distribution shifts remains underexplored.
In this work, we take the first step to comprehensively evaluate the mainstream
textual OOD detection methods for detecting semantic and non-semantic shifts.
We find that: (1) no existing method behaves well in both settings; (2)
fine-tuning PLMs on in-distribution data benefits detecting semantic shifts but
severely deteriorates detecting non-semantic shifts, which can be attributed to
the distortion of task-agnostic features. To alleviate the issue, we present a
simple yet effective general OOD score named GNOME that integrates the
confidence scores derived from the task-agnostic and task-specific
representations. Experiments show that GNOME works well in both semantic and
non-semantic shift scenarios, and further brings significant improvement on two
cross-task benchmarks where both kinds of shifts simultaneously take place. Our
code is available at https://github.com/lancopku/GNOME. | [
-0.7298910022,
-0.8041630983,
0.6015041471,
0.0261731241,
-0.4430413246,
-0.3201704323,
-0.4163684249,
-0.4537175,
-0.1282499135,
0.660210073,
-0.5943129659,
-0.6596037149,
-0.6209044456,
0.1748278886,
-0.4231686592,
1.0754916668,
-0.1001874357,
-0.4402190745,
-0.2755146325,
-0.3439335823,
-0.4070265293,
-0.0498788469,
-0.2600262463,
-0.2095445693,
0.0010752598,
0.4216576517,
0.9241441488,
0.6576254368,
0.6933007836,
0.2221423388,
-0.0619447194,
0.4618399143,
-0.5446684361,
0.0782613158,
-0.4613201618,
-0.4140583873,
-0.306643337,
-0.2354803979,
0.6382390261,
0.3908389807,
-0.2289056033,
0.3828351498,
0.2436714768,
0.4947628081,
-1.0920604467,
0.0433561578,
-0.9095515013,
-0.1391577125,
-0.732496798,
-0.4295414984,
-0.585904181,
-0.0823315755,
-0.0266789943,
-0.7993645668,
0.3749603033,
0.1738269776,
0.8544512391,
0.5084342957,
-0.0681648105,
-0.4654321671,
-0.6104156375,
0.9683039784,
-0.6418838501,
0.3080420792,
0.5273969173,
0.1302021742,
-0.518178463,
-0.1162726954,
-0.7213146687,
-0.2263930738,
-0.050491903,
0.0318289436,
-0.2221932411,
0.0623282865,
0.0136667276,
0.5219649076,
-0.3362129033,
0.2599544227,
0.1570824981,
0.1410148293,
0.504994154,
0.1276940405,
0.3254422843,
-0.0702796206,
-0.3286116719,
-0.3399392664,
-0.3440340161,
-0.1439524889,
0.6965482235,
0.1873907447,
-0.051222343,
0.5057862401,
-0.0182961654,
0.6644092798,
0.4171350002,
-0.0687310398,
0.4110758305,
-0.3497927785,
-0.3227699101,
-0.0434004851,
0.7334005833,
0.4481549263,
0.0990126804,
-0.0853397772,
-0.3685847223,
0.3063429296,
0.1760984808,
-0.4231131971,
-0.3973436058,
0.0476669893,
-0.4552399516,
-0.1610294878,
-0.0966598913,
-0.5083547235,
-0.6489575505,
-0.2250861377,
0.3228979111,
-0.799200058,
-0.4182323515,
0.6063622832,
-0.3414267302,
-0.0102737462,
0.34102121,
-1.0915954113,
0.2772901952,
0.6937485933,
0.8226518035,
-0.4109752774,
-0.0569427311,
-0.4959931076,
0.0909717157,
-0.3237516582,
0.940271914,
-0.4879848957,
-0.032402616,
-0.0309069995,
-0.0152846426,
-0.2704466581,
-0.75795573,
0.4929191172,
-0.2147963643,
0.1448476613,
-0.0559922531,
-0.5908781886,
0.2616091967,
0.2499007434,
-0.5138201714,
1.3878211975,
0.3128594756,
-1.0042911768,
0.7060746551,
-0.8030923605,
-0.2426593453,
-0.2220570296,
0.1021377742,
-0.531381011,
0.4601602554,
0.2873771489,
0.3060682714,
-0.13978903,
-0.0370624289,
-0.6098088026,
-0.3167768419,
0.0757100508,
-0.4219171107,
0.6110778451,
0.1077275723,
-0.2880704403,
-0.0727578551,
-0.8281729817,
0.0534883365,
-0.2196802348,
-0.0295120794,
-0.8457922339,
0.0823994204,
0.1450734884,
0.1755047888,
0.0673250929,
-0.7927044034,
0.1343588233,
-0.6034331918,
0.3670691848,
0.5174148083,
-0.1956365407,
0.7237756848,
-0.1582978815,
0.2409372181,
0.1531665325,
0.3432025015,
0.0857164264,
-0.5273526907,
-0.3863281906,
-0.5590441823,
0.0829102993,
0.6516526341,
-0.8916805387,
0.9147953391,
-0.1240645945,
-0.3400803804,
-0.6530590057,
0.3487642705,
0.4226478338,
0.5034806132,
0.6093728542,
-0.3569149077,
-0.0514778905,
-0.5869746804,
-0.5306401849,
-0.2238811105,
-0.0909032896,
-0.2330373824,
0.4421685338,
-0.4159234166,
1.1868402958,
-0.5383836031,
-0.5971918702,
-0.1980720758,
0.2397265434,
0.0154068843,
0.3384556472,
0.8152158856,
-0.4794423282,
-0.3728243411,
0.2522770464,
-0.4417301714,
-0.259873718,
-0.0045385356,
-0.2064760029,
0.44409284,
0.6957161427,
-0.6562253833,
0.5940743089,
0.5334504843,
-0.4182308316,
0.3788565099,
-0.5046001077,
-0.2314388454,
-0.8656551838,
-0.0455045104,
-0.0553624034,
-0.3196438849,
-0.4915173054,
-0.1178926975,
0.2851593792,
0.3640647829,
-0.2754227221,
0.5296313763,
-0.3717757761,
0.1009745821,
-0.202724427,
0.0865089819,
0.0428181179,
0.0112874024,
-0.0350513197,
0.522808969,
0.3176596165,
-0.6781286597,
-0.0675124228,
0.3238002062,
-0.4739247262,
0.9448949099,
-0.1853109002,
-0.0153482361,
-0.3492800891,
0.0657452866,
-1.2260161638,
-0.0306002665,
0.3560048938,
-0.1643682867,
0.3771513402,
-0.0789443702,
-0.7474237084,
-0.0684640482,
-0.5701414347,
0.1352061182,
0.3236560822,
-0.491584301,
0.2226577848,
0.3552217782,
0.220252648,
-0.3943778574,
-0.7816540599,
-0.2656093538,
-0.3880194426,
-0.5504081249,
0.3989994228,
0.1872699708,
-0.19252716,
0.1731334031,
-0.1763978899,
-0.0419108868,
0.1396733969,
-0.0027808202,
-0.1283416748,
-0.1223086268,
0.3467125595,
0.2414194793,
-0.1002537981,
-0.0620390922,
-0.3874469399,
0.4086487293,
0.0523518659,
-0.3887751997,
-0.259629637,
0.1413882822,
0.5141987205,
-0.1383737624,
0.6800202131,
0.9766232371,
-0.0947054848,
-0.5026684403,
-0.3412335217,
-0.1109462008,
-0.4996507764,
0.4992905855,
-0.0503207929,
-0.4733380675,
0.4924194515,
-0.1490299255,
0.1139255613,
0.4254566729,
0.2772723138,
-0.2609054744,
0.9744129181,
0.8255825043,
0.0807528049,
0.822100997,
-0.0559126772,
0.1637518108,
-0.7825769186,
0.3305969238,
-0.4406979084,
-0.2647267878,
-0.6289392114,
-0.4146582782,
0.3617327511,
0.2208714038,
0.0699405298,
0.2782485187,
-0.5340293646,
0.3812635839,
0.3539633453,
-0.0063787675,
0.2736161351,
0.0097726034,
0.0249489564,
0.1375239789,
-0.3685327172,
-0.3492612839,
0.9388283491,
0.3330283761,
0.7851167321,
0.0083604651,
0.7228153944,
0.4193234444,
0.2237659097,
-0.4564402997,
0.3954367042,
-0.6129305363,
-0.406016767,
-0.7504879236,
-0.3170014024,
-0.8335697055,
0.1399599314,
-0.1978610158,
-0.6629402041,
0.5173228979,
0.4268674552,
-0.2473882735,
0.3168350458,
-0.9074262381,
1.0017521381,
0.1105712131,
0.0720835552,
-0.0552777313,
-0.4840568304,
0.2100936174,
0.0450966917,
0.1483632624,
-0.4668128788,
-0.078798078,
0.1807131767,
-0.599640727,
0.6874604821,
-0.3249969184,
-0.4743873775,
0.1839062124,
-0.03117566,
0.6855073571,
0.2691748738,
-0.1445540339,
0.15835087,
0.099593848,
-0.2178555131,
-0.6127144098,
0.5731415153,
-0.7260714769,
-0.1926666945,
-0.2083975673,
-0.6281917691,
-0.3594716191,
0.1543076783,
0.8047962189,
0.2337045819,
-0.0373933613,
-0.048912216,
0.8608316779,
-0.2539332211,
0.3996179998,
0.3736928701,
-0.10679131,
-0.3106889725,
0.8400137424,
0.1423575729,
0.611233592,
0.3873813152,
0.2777166367,
-0.6076874137,
-0.7650348544,
-0.7431675792,
-0.0588138215,
-0.7627942562,
-0.1283138543,
-0.3523288965,
0.2544462085,
-0.2486725599,
-0.0903959125,
-0.4359882772,
-0.1885214895,
-0.4319202006,
0.0804617181,
0.5877518058,
0.4547134042,
0.1860078424,
0.3273970783,
-0.3505334854,
0.5086321831,
-0.0915519521,
0.5328404307,
-0.5334517956,
-0.6384100318,
-0.0747436732,
0.0066246591,
-0.3037184179,
-0.5461570024,
0.3227030337,
0.5820342302,
0.2706772685,
0.6031044722,
0.5431858897,
0.8947963715,
-0.36979568,
0.4937459528,
0.2367331237,
-0.9920635223,
0.4365010262,
-0.4026975632,
0.5796433687,
0.7853834033,
-0.1392129213,
-0.1950044483,
-0.8884410858,
-0.3191288114,
-0.8517743945,
0.912686944,
0.2395647317,
0.119195357,
-0.2411061376,
0.1425543278,
0.5506926179,
0.2431951165,
-0.2739502192,
-0.2464008033,
-0.1816284806,
-0.2730888128,
-0.2733068466,
-0.0290541444,
0.1862143874,
-0.2233318239,
0.2805125415,
-0.2837283909,
0.0989830419,
0.2433838099,
-0.3124174774,
-0.3022511899,
0.4547086954,
0.6116695404,
0.5056810379,
-0.4326522052,
0.2253140658,
0.1315455884,
-0.7898877859,
-0.041110184,
0.0886710212,
-0.3433260918,
0.460326761,
0.1689786017,
0.9001258612,
0.278488636,
-0.4706651866,
0.4924022555,
0.0529444329,
-0.1272562295,
-0.128008917,
0.1709597409,
-0.3145711124,
-0.0886662304,
0.0667205825,
0.5344529748,
0.2917544544,
-0.6713292003,
0.0679815859,
0.5260513425,
-0.4001893997,
-0.4161879718,
0.3983981311,
-0.0708526596,
0.1783724874,
0.3171823919,
-0.6151639819,
0.1132603735,
0.2865881026,
0.535803318,
1.0124593973,
-0.1363727599,
0.4675642848,
-0.3294129074,
0.4130443931,
-0.459900111,
0.4109220505,
-0.1066045091,
-0.8195682764,
-0.351516217,
-0.5847657323,
-0.1110625491,
0.0302229226,
-0.7868928313,
0.6030962467,
-0.2606167197,
-0.3658464849,
0.1486223787,
-0.3314721584,
-0.6553220749,
-0.0131014539,
0.2533248067,
0.7444455624,
-0.8179454803,
0.8290296793,
0.9216095805,
0.1411630511,
-0.1725620925,
0.3353871703,
-0.2169163078,
-0.494620055,
0.2070405334,
0.1292724013,
-0.2337618619,
-0.0319783054,
-0.1765096188,
-0.8163219094,
0.7795206904,
0.9805927277,
-0.6340286732,
0.1327900141,
0.4959941506,
0.6771918535,
0.1050692052,
0.4416183829,
0.7135891318,
0.5217448473,
-0.297252804,
-1.3597153425,
-0.0874447227,
0.0708833262,
0.0994202644,
0.9093741775,
-0.2877991498,
0.9415758252,
0.1407321393,
-0.4125914276,
0.0020746568,
0.2464312166,
-0.0171000157,
0.6594536901,
0.7429291606,
0.8675341606,
0.9030299783,
-0.0602222756,
1.0698624849,
-0.0927908644,
0.4453246891,
0.7916122675,
-0.3567891121,
0.9193472266,
0.58616817,
0.057291206,
0.4061737359,
0.2596702278,
0.3590849042,
0.9186588526,
0.161791414,
0.061330568,
-0.4079960585,
0.0513979606,
-0.5011570454,
0.3146883547,
0.6545734406,
-0.2900779247,
-0.6102691293,
0.3331227899,
-0.0637266636,
0.1287170202,
-0.5624088049,
0.7728852034,
0.0379402526,
-0.5910551548,
0.9063423872,
-0.0111975884,
0.8403175473,
-0.4782563448,
0.1571513563,
0.0103410482,
0.7797136903,
-0.3067622185,
-0.8435633779,
0.4823570848,
-0.3043424189,
-0.4007264376,
-0.3412970006,
0.7654732466,
-0.2715449929,
-0.2742908001,
0.3256217241,
0.1723140776,
-0.190052107,
-0.3616731167,
-0.458209604,
-0.0411039777,
-0.333455205,
-0.1171341613,
0.5928311348,
0.957600534,
-0.4963137805,
0.3838549554,
0.5471245646,
-0.0500495955,
0.2164301425,
-0.0709947273,
0.6685622334,
-0.420406431,
-0.7853458524,
-0.9248159528,
0.3152018189,
-0.106846422,
-0.9084669352,
0.9383957386,
0.1621413678,
0.9595982432,
-0.4123838842,
0.7566334605,
-0.0112929447,
0.228342995,
-0.6275750995,
0.4599776864,
-0.3171420991,
0.2160479724,
-0.5160939097,
-0.8042512536,
-0.4103079736,
0.246214211,
-0.5171967149,
-0.526019752,
0.6621897221,
0.5410609841,
-0.2709521353,
-0.0453480594,
0.2794453502,
-0.0670538768,
0.1554094702,
0.209148705,
0.9259991646,
-0.2751211822,
0.5186747313,
-0.1284271479,
-0.1055701301,
-0.5260668397,
-0.8941492438,
-1.0916002989,
-0.341696471,
-0.536524713,
-0.1054325998,
0.2944010794,
0.6341768503,
0.6124659181,
-1.0283209085,
0.1853410751,
-0.6085866094,
0.0580967516,
-0.6837918162,
-0.198261261,
0.3138058484,
-0.7739372253,
-0.3984113336,
0.22338368,
0.5669855475,
-0.3817107081,
-0.1965507716,
0.0364361815,
0.1494759768,
0.1010450646,
0.5419837832,
0.1207692623,
-0.6612990499,
-0.4534373283,
0.0807189941,
-0.0344504826,
-0.0137684476,
0.5835606456,
-0.5413020253,
0.501034677,
0.7549787164,
0.2674667537,
-0.0351048149,
0.1681492031,
0.4092497528,
-1.1527217627,
0.2690304518,
0.0781260207,
0.1371660084,
0.2544897199,
-0.3705770075,
0.204717949,
0.0944927111,
-0.4433698952,
-1.1414066553,
0.1892150491,
-0.709230125,
-0.1376594156,
1.1527961493,
0.0251150709,
-0.2971424162,
-0.6717269421,
-0.2568458915,
-0.0906116292,
-0.5734971762,
0.8633190989,
0.5644822717,
-0.1223156899,
0.1524358243,
-0.5278916955,
0.8821531534,
0.3730154932,
-0.6682890654,
0.210508287,
0.1975836754,
0.2232672572,
0.4366690218,
0.3669803143,
-0.0302042421,
0.2320236415,
-0.3164614439,
-0.0195065998,
0.0564556941,
-0.1223640144,
-0.2568103671,
0.046924375,
0.0866224617,
-0.625418961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12711v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12711v2 | UzbekTagger: The rule-based POS tagger for Uzbek language | 2023-01-30T07:40:45 | 2023-03-01T14:31:12 | Maksud Sharipov, Elmurod Kuriyozov, Ollabergan Yuldashev, Ogabek Sobirov | cs.CL | cs.CL | This research paper presents a part-of-speech (POS) annotated dataset and
tagger tool for the low-resource Uzbek language. The dataset includes 12 tags,
which were used to develop a rule-based POS-tagger tool. The corpus text used
in the annotation process was made sure to be balanced over 20 different fields
in order to ensure its representativeness. Uzbek being an agglutinative
language so the most of the words in an Uzbek sentence are formed by adding
suffixes. This nature of it makes the POS-tagging task difficult to find the
stems of words and the right part-of-speech they belong to. The methodology
proposed in this research is the stemming of the words with an affix/suffix
stripping approach including database of the stem forms of the words in the
Uzbek language. The tagger tool was tested on the annotated dataset and showed
high accuracy in identifying and tagging parts of speech in Uzbek text. This
newly presented dataset and tagger tool can be used for a variety of natural
language processing tasks such as language modeling, machine translation, and
text-to-speech synthesis. The presented dataset is the first of its kind to be
made publicly available for Uzbek, and the POS-tagger tool created can also be
used as a pivot to use as a base for other closely-related Turkic languages. | [
-0.2379416376,
-0.5582472086,
-0.0151656577,
0.2883222699,
-0.6203776002,
0.1005821973,
-0.225643456,
-0.108012557,
0.2731637061,
0.5666726232,
-0.4194614887,
-0.7978200912,
-0.2227467299,
0.1208275631,
-0.1696507335,
0.8457438946,
0.0488930121,
0.1649158746,
0.2429154813,
-0.0137956208,
-0.636977911,
-0.595909059,
-0.0864351392,
-0.169504419,
0.1218125001,
0.6551676393,
0.5014930367,
0.998893261,
0.4602481723,
0.16576235,
0.0308679696,
-0.1085474417,
0.1945043951,
0.2305534482,
-0.2473279536,
-0.1757631451,
-0.4061728716,
0.0541769154,
0.6131468415,
0.2852448225,
-0.3034815788,
0.4430609345,
-0.4299090207,
0.3749681413,
-0.4174709022,
0.0285161361,
-0.5315814018,
-0.1775640398,
-0.9177057743,
0.0652035996,
-0.2601360679,
-0.1548490971,
-0.0663405582,
-0.5471332073,
0.0197178982,
0.3011410832,
1.0330651999,
0.1074174419,
-0.1526293755,
-0.0750559196,
-0.8284705281,
0.865840137,
-0.669947505,
0.3701931238,
0.4356226325,
0.1806586981,
-0.6724143624,
-0.5323606133,
-0.5895050168,
0.0166817755,
-0.3518320918,
-0.0420544483,
-0.2200794667,
0.2226204127,
0.0465365052,
0.2756601572,
-0.3629155159,
-0.1655582041,
-0.3381607234,
-0.4582436085,
0.5343822837,
0.1398774683,
0.5045486689,
-0.5679965615,
-0.2650194764,
0.3138039112,
-0.6194735765,
0.1254195869,
0.62775594,
0.6054532528,
0.3730010688,
0.9439096451,
-0.6397643685,
0.6513428092,
0.0796249956,
-0.4590190947,
0.2818459272,
-0.4039965272,
-0.21346654,
-0.0808641091,
0.9951689839,
0.1964084953,
0.0982375741,
-0.175260812,
-0.0814661682,
-0.0467206798,
0.0056155063,
-0.4256511927,
-0.5742191672,
-0.0461590923,
-0.3206661344,
0.1246121079,
0.1986957639,
-0.833166182,
-0.4304187,
-0.1146602929,
0.3701091409,
-0.6240888834,
-0.4293879867,
0.0623677522,
-0.0684081987,
0.5285862088,
0.1070151776,
-0.7358769774,
0.3723936379,
0.5662822723,
0.9349882007,
-0.006773286,
-0.2402588725,
-0.6278570294,
0.1874705553,
-0.1542657614,
0.9295829535,
-0.6011137366,
-0.2082570791,
-0.0434885472,
-0.0584836826,
0.1058201864,
-0.4496001601,
0.9269095063,
-0.0472605899,
-0.0444331467,
0.1367857754,
-0.47696051,
-0.0417439826,
-0.3914529085,
-0.4814902544,
1.4298914671,
0.3743236363,
-0.7743792534,
0.5674543977,
-0.6228630543,
-0.6372169852,
0.6833003163,
-0.473518163,
-0.3802661002,
0.0331227444,
-0.0343330875,
0.4728032947,
-0.3173009157,
0.1430751681,
0.3399738669,
-0.2367189974,
-0.0464746766,
0.2802077234,
0.6111957431,
0.2577938139,
-0.0782401934,
0.4547233284,
-0.7410626411,
-0.0403347872,
0.0653946325,
-0.5868265033,
-0.358750999,
0.2582658827,
0.1834560186,
-0.0094649913,
-0.0561128557,
-0.9735349417,
0.5224127769,
-0.2444205284,
0.1643557101,
0.4681510031,
0.1129964665,
0.5138491988,
-0.1118962988,
0.4355783761,
-0.2471813112,
0.3723084331,
-0.0153366765,
-0.4367938638,
-0.5362904072,
-1.1633729935,
0.6308454871,
0.6582480669,
-0.5223875046,
0.8565779328,
0.0142761189,
-0.6538118124,
-0.9218615294,
-0.1221709326,
-0.0008871829,
0.3947452605,
0.3802136183,
0.054609742,
-0.843251586,
-0.8518127799,
-0.4037675858,
-0.043271374,
-0.4391435087,
-0.3035106063,
0.2929045558,
0.0867649093,
1.1407475471,
-0.4825662673,
-0.9939982891,
-0.5559319854,
0.3213300407,
0.2005022615,
0.6504782438,
0.3932534158,
-0.6644811034,
-0.5180957913,
-0.1770451516,
0.1563593447,
-0.2847807705,
0.3071327507,
-0.2686921656,
0.3016729951,
0.2490926087,
-0.5059679151,
0.7251173258,
0.147309348,
-0.462600261,
0.5924275517,
0.0249193273,
0.2054262459,
-0.8587238193,
-0.0123781711,
0.0633791685,
-0.1573022455,
-0.8311752081,
-0.2375400066,
-0.2791620195,
0.3002536595,
-0.4842883348,
0.3457172513,
-0.4981535375,
0.1800780147,
-0.18163535,
0.0174996573,
-0.4067218304,
0.2873250544,
-0.0003875109,
0.8381616473,
0.7831775546,
-0.500131309,
0.8798265457,
0.4214475155,
-0.540756166,
0.4142562449,
-0.4335707426,
-0.0843586996,
-0.0772383064,
-0.1557922065,
-1.0937567949,
-0.4491069317,
0.9230695963,
-0.6808943152,
0.1612452269,
-0.669398427,
-0.6237837076,
-0.1945295036,
-0.3979493082,
-0.0466821305,
0.6460236311,
-0.171975702,
1.0185918808,
0.7419101,
-0.3021000624,
-0.271746546,
-0.396867007,
-0.2156152874,
-0.46421507,
-0.2247788012,
0.2239641398,
0.3275454044,
-0.3589907289,
0.0910669342,
-0.3170026541,
-0.1587002426,
0.1393755376,
0.3295893371,
0.4068332016,
0.083103165,
0.1602473855,
-0.2017686963,
-0.131270051,
-0.2185171694,
-0.1892613471,
0.7779092789,
0.0270151738,
0.0129263029,
-0.564060688,
0.3175480366,
0.0804957226,
-0.5036484003,
0.7219112515,
0.5813338757,
-0.487295419,
-0.1042474285,
-0.1811149269,
0.23462753,
-0.3722771704,
0.1571362168,
-0.5982549191,
-0.4568381011,
0.5239217877,
-0.316588521,
0.0225196499,
0.7457939386,
0.3220575154,
-0.1720854938,
0.8574672937,
0.4603021741,
-0.2925031781,
0.6172193885,
0.0673040599,
0.2249756157,
-1.0026038885,
-0.4192961752,
-0.9523427486,
0.1882461011,
-0.6105800271,
-0.3395795226,
-0.1879067868,
0.4783339798,
0.0658086985,
0.5579695702,
-0.6172694564,
0.3690380156,
0.7064852715,
-0.5184301734,
0.2184664756,
0.0955274627,
-0.0942038,
-0.1559848785,
-0.2613914013,
-0.6891815662,
0.6786550283,
-0.0115052257,
1.0547368526,
0.0692249015,
0.446573168,
0.6823897958,
0.1064672023,
-1.053301096,
0.4895403087,
-0.0555868857,
-0.5910233855,
-0.6283398867,
-0.2709727287,
-0.5974473953,
0.2498042136,
-0.2675914466,
-1.2635784149,
-0.4023753107,
0.0536435209,
-0.1738887429,
0.3647164404,
-0.4940619767,
0.7067006826,
0.1893834472,
0.0827935934,
0.3283920586,
-0.5847223997,
-0.0243856255,
0.3069200218,
0.0337320194,
-0.6335602403,
0.1334749609,
1.2760864496,
-0.4528716505,
0.3129650056,
-0.3666030467,
0.204774335,
0.6222195625,
-0.0157329459,
0.4044245481,
-0.091701135,
0.2034493685,
0.1748647839,
0.1103806645,
-0.3697953522,
-0.1764891744,
0.3605498374,
-0.5676345229,
-0.5412522554,
-0.9200519323,
-0.0391976312,
-0.0622640848,
0.2320429385,
0.299607873,
0.3645381033,
-0.0741406381,
-0.0476823375,
0.1966056079,
0.114607133,
0.0891733915,
0.7302410603,
-0.4200132191,
-0.5432404876,
0.9000046253,
0.3104689717,
-0.3848697543,
0.2560249269,
0.2845646143,
-0.2270492762,
-0.7262393236,
-0.5210522413,
0.3666487038,
-0.2740560472,
-0.5485854745,
-0.4387355149,
-0.0907066613,
-0.6672249436,
0.2598915994,
-0.3984099925,
-0.4574337304,
-0.2226299196,
-0.058942873,
0.8535403609,
0.9603754878,
-0.0640474111,
0.6568493843,
-0.5233243108,
0.3745248914,
-0.2435379773,
0.5799676776,
-0.5941419005,
-0.5858643651,
-0.278395623,
0.0164396446,
-0.0060416921,
-1.0011404753,
0.1509123296,
0.104983978,
0.6745044589,
0.0666050985,
0.5061526299,
0.4679428935,
-0.5162264109,
0.6679670811,
-0.0507877842,
-1.2668919563,
0.465325892,
-0.2960817814,
0.1306376308,
0.4551646709,
0.4876143336,
-0.9412794709,
-0.4746855795,
-0.127468586,
-1.135235548,
1.08885777,
0.1025872901,
-0.2678849995,
0.0005789504,
0.3506814241,
0.1469576657,
0.1168343648,
-0.0712137297,
-0.5625926256,
-0.1578986496,
-0.4668491483,
0.4959371686,
-0.2019854039,
0.2119203061,
-0.4250798821,
1.0404390097,
0.0178157706,
0.2602367401,
0.1835864484,
-0.1600448638,
0.0283316802,
0.5498717427,
0.2890491784,
0.4498340786,
-0.3693389893,
-0.0674134493,
-0.1152122542,
-0.8177289963,
0.079983823,
0.1712494195,
-0.4063140452,
0.0328116864,
-0.0105297463,
0.4210417271,
-0.435842216,
-0.5088427067,
0.5691919327,
-0.0995069668,
-0.1887977123,
-0.3835283816,
-0.0995900556,
-0.126057297,
-0.0152916098,
0.8857110739,
-0.1189816371,
0.1361446083,
-0.2898683846,
0.2549440563,
0.2545125484,
-0.2499807179,
-0.5412244797,
0.2091777176,
0.267570287,
-0.5148370862,
0.3844763041,
-0.3898047805,
-0.8345633149,
-0.0610636733,
0.3069939613,
0.5092365742,
-0.546713531,
0.4532787502,
0.3118311763,
0.3091425598,
0.2089826018,
0.5673851371,
0.020409029,
-0.3655641675,
-0.4698980153,
-0.6658964753,
-0.1700458527,
0.4532510638,
-0.7016428113,
0.3462046683,
-0.4160862267,
-0.2681459486,
0.1618924439,
0.3942450881,
-0.3176988959,
0.1521909833,
-0.2377320379,
0.8282507658,
-0.8696187735,
0.8155385256,
0.905600071,
-0.4338623583,
-0.8021925688,
0.1324732453,
-0.1062521189,
-0.3344881535,
0.482234776,
-0.1646403372,
-0.4209114015,
0.0834423602,
-0.382286936,
-0.8488685489,
0.6401218772,
-0.1212017089,
-0.1244813874,
0.2392074317,
0.0081981113,
0.3586575091,
-0.3023547232,
-0.0568846799,
0.792850852,
0.4742615819,
0.2239267826,
-0.9578584433,
0.1082456335,
0.0206895098,
-0.36025244,
0.7793034911,
-0.6599609852,
0.8721209168,
0.0947207436,
-0.8223258853,
0.5123720169,
0.8974441886,
-0.4544404745,
-0.1985292286,
0.2323291451,
0.2012634724,
0.6065926552,
-0.3980244398,
0.1602006257,
0.1300648302,
0.2639581859,
1.0815043449,
-0.4962955713,
0.7893127799,
0.6012542248,
-0.2618814409,
0.2159897238,
0.2877858877,
-0.2539772689,
0.7115935683,
0.5969406962,
-0.3047623932,
-0.1848001182,
-0.5876569152,
-0.0164007451,
0.8350991011,
0.138515085,
0.1482876688,
-0.1221092641,
0.0669833124,
0.4648531079,
0.1842698455,
-0.3506147861,
0.9872065187,
-0.6896713376,
-0.1951447576,
-0.0047284337,
0.4352210164,
0.7595139146,
-0.7220944166,
-0.2103459686,
0.0070463051,
0.1690451205,
-0.1597700566,
-0.8523793817,
0.2922512591,
0.1423469633,
-0.0071673011,
0.1209080145,
0.8758601546,
-0.6039118767,
-0.2128641605,
-0.02725018,
0.4029254317,
0.2315822095,
0.0214255787,
-0.1036836281,
0.1325305849,
-0.0074960506,
-0.2157638669,
0.0371584333,
0.4184044302,
-0.1441367418,
0.5011608601,
0.4342281222,
0.5502115488,
0.1778362691,
-0.191878438,
0.9018825889,
-0.841940999,
-0.3115220368,
-0.6046636701,
0.3530492783,
-0.0724575818,
-0.2667813599,
1.0186840296,
0.707899332,
0.9673551321,
-0.009245743,
1.0757964849,
-0.5458361506,
1.0838375092,
-0.2473000735,
0.8844106197,
-0.112235412,
-0.3819319606,
-0.2024773806,
-0.5391979814,
-0.3722159266,
0.8833883405,
-0.2628391683,
-0.4172355533,
0.3567372859,
0.3817798793,
0.4136965275,
-0.1167557836,
0.406915158,
0.0615389459,
0.3102152348,
-0.1666334718,
0.9106291533,
-0.2669445276,
0.5460534096,
-0.1751755476,
-0.4094385505,
-0.1943174154,
-0.6787415743,
-0.9197298288,
-0.7918040156,
-0.1876099855,
-0.0622646883,
-0.1034196615,
1.3265627623,
0.4724016786,
-0.7441667318,
-0.1675045341,
0.274633497,
0.1354654133,
0.0185730699,
-0.2595253289,
0.1861641854,
0.052627869,
-0.4842232764,
0.2116136104,
0.1945591867,
0.2270106077,
0.0906392187,
0.0878794342,
-0.7134895921,
0.0898868814,
0.0848214477,
0.3733439445,
-0.6215262413,
-0.364194572,
0.0054573868,
0.0043206364,
0.1558305025,
0.9572535753,
-0.6174883842,
0.1691340059,
0.4149438143,
0.0065713213,
0.0637491867,
0.3277797103,
0.2654722035,
-0.7836064696,
0.1397878379,
0.1371506751,
0.3848708272,
0.5792353749,
0.0066993702,
0.3322873414,
0.2907988727,
-0.4538771212,
-0.6402986646,
0.4242693186,
-0.6239591837,
0.0562797599,
1.0344711542,
-0.3643184006,
-0.5230390429,
-0.4733675122,
-0.8295580745,
0.6303809285,
-0.8027418256,
0.3047348261,
0.7605576515,
-0.2747041285,
0.3083682656,
-0.0173048768,
0.9433804154,
-0.2660319209,
-0.6184051037,
0.4201260507,
0.5040937662,
0.4211728871,
0.2409454733,
0.6463050842,
0.100064978,
-0.0388834551,
0.0417998061,
0.3687182665,
-0.1761961281,
-0.54820472,
-0.1522058845,
-0.2978506088,
0.1374842674,
-0.7033889294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12699v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12699v1 | KG-BERTScore: Incorporating Knowledge Graph into BERTScore for Reference-Free Machine Translation Evaluation | 2023-01-30T07:12:15 | 2023-01-30T07:12:15 | Zhanglin Wu, Min Zhang, Ming Zhu, Yinglu Li, Ting Zhu, Hao Yang, Song Peng, Ying Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | BERTScore is an effective and robust automatic metric for referencebased
machine translation evaluation. In this paper, we incorporate multilingual
knowledge graph into BERTScore and propose a metric named KG-BERTScore, which
linearly combines the results of BERTScore and bilingual named entity matching
for reference-free machine translation evaluation. From the experimental
results on WMT19 QE as a metric without references shared tasks, our metric
KG-BERTScore gets higher overall correlation with human judgements than the
current state-of-the-art metrics for reference-free machine translation
evaluation.1 Moreover, the pre-trained multilingual model used by KG-BERTScore
and the parameter for linear combination are also studied in this paper. | [
-0.5911202431,
0.0797864124,
0.5431640744,
0.3253281116,
-0.4958388805,
-0.0635863692,
-0.1125805154,
-0.6011853218,
0.2712863982,
0.4347175658,
-0.4126826227,
-0.5569700003,
-0.8320297003,
-0.0576286316,
-0.2022506744,
1.1555742025,
-0.3519358933,
0.467022866,
-0.5954989791,
-0.6794761419,
-0.3937436342,
-0.5853285193,
-0.2466876656,
-0.5556886196,
0.7729904056,
0.1744677573,
0.8454608917,
0.2620715201,
0.7761844397,
0.2754045129,
0.124602221,
0.3423404992,
-0.2134153843,
0.0176586621,
-0.098924242,
-0.3252369463,
-0.7387265563,
0.1586548388,
0.7235931158,
0.7689335346,
0.2609966993,
0.1854216903,
0.0426374935,
0.7401652932,
-0.4935870171,
0.3745001554,
-0.4339569807,
0.1221819445,
0.129388392,
0.0482722037,
-0.2185092121,
-0.8205880523,
0.1991452128,
-0.5514732003,
0.0079277921,
0.1128664538,
1.0318309069,
0.2947705686,
-0.9062157869,
-0.4070668817,
-0.5754531026,
0.7689168453,
-0.7193135023,
0.9767772555,
0.489692688,
0.7932054996,
0.2418867499,
-0.7636761069,
-0.4951464832,
-0.4259292781,
-0.4019317925,
0.201423496,
0.0383259729,
-0.0548466444,
-0.1084527448,
0.1669736505,
-0.4022399783,
-0.1193184927,
-0.4119517803,
-0.4276985228,
0.4876082838,
-0.0368274786,
0.097448796,
-0.3203602433,
-0.5508000851,
-0.2649969459,
-0.3014801443,
-0.106963791,
0.3654691875,
0.1201527938,
0.0836738199,
0.4379439056,
-0.1418022215,
0.5901188254,
-0.3099952638,
-0.1545121372,
0.5436464548,
-0.6440317035,
-0.1600019783,
-0.0937435851,
1.172821641,
0.5525808334,
0.4222067595,
-0.8364505768,
-0.1490841061,
-0.1553792208,
0.2427030057,
-0.9549117088,
-0.3517544866,
-0.1276604831,
-0.4523175955,
-0.1658561975,
0.1275123656,
-0.5486933589,
0.0324953049,
-0.2601407766,
0.6634374857,
-0.722843945,
0.1101566851,
-0.2543264925,
-0.2999855876,
-0.0717763901,
0.2734646201,
-0.5015318394,
0.0377116688,
0.4293087125,
0.5213162899,
0.0260645114,
-0.3689602315,
-0.2627670169,
0.233746931,
-0.2878896892,
0.6378813386,
-0.1992108077,
-0.5831395984,
-0.3167428076,
0.1056024581,
-0.2121631652,
-0.5461889505,
0.9526124001,
-0.7252098322,
0.5155363679,
-0.4754344821,
-0.5694653988,
-0.597399652,
0.4096551538,
-0.6648475528,
1.3459991217,
0.2471624315,
-0.7481138706,
0.7304037213,
-0.577152729,
-0.3291321099,
0.0503794737,
0.2079102099,
-0.4656211138,
-0.3082868457,
0.4481696784,
0.334928602,
-0.3500193954,
0.4066248834,
-0.428535074,
-0.0349045359,
0.0915271789,
-0.1218431443,
0.8362599611,
0.3189059794,
0.1115417555,
0.0789469033,
-0.774007082,
0.4666426182,
-0.1906835437,
-0.3298099637,
-0.6463659406,
0.0077491095,
-0.1734089702,
0.3882537186,
0.5983330607,
-0.4459831119,
0.1081123054,
-0.009519292,
-0.0590764396,
0.4437420666,
-0.1603028476,
0.4113361239,
-0.2055109888,
0.398929894,
-0.0652838871,
0.137226373,
0.2474497855,
-0.7441154718,
-0.798863709,
-0.265868187,
0.7767717242,
0.6737155318,
-0.9886943698,
0.4632244408,
-0.615449667,
-0.7554919124,
-0.9315239787,
0.3790414333,
0.6136155128,
0.732825458,
0.5137242079,
-0.5324706435,
-0.5498108268,
-1.0761649609,
-0.2192348391,
-0.2251754403,
-0.1597018391,
0.4345636368,
0.3821445405,
-0.315997988,
0.8851102591,
-0.4555232525,
-0.30290398,
0.1406005621,
0.4170174003,
0.3754579425,
0.4318324924,
0.9662203789,
-0.616107285,
-0.8694398999,
0.1361048073,
-0.9069135189,
-0.3378244042,
0.3477969468,
-0.4495460689,
-0.2004399598,
0.1082026139,
-0.4014094174,
-0.1767333746,
0.5367724895,
-0.3463827074,
0.6572193503,
-0.4047214985,
0.6460500956,
-1.322627306,
0.3035194278,
-0.2916446924,
-0.398254931,
-0.4315356016,
0.2357310206,
0.6138361692,
0.0677570552,
-0.4213308096,
0.4020398557,
-0.1876261085,
-0.1331992149,
0.1088003367,
0.5478758812,
0.127243191,
0.3737449646,
-0.3020587862,
0.7505931854,
0.2046330571,
-0.5233355165,
0.5716930032,
0.3324691653,
-0.6628883481,
0.7440239787,
-0.4215174317,
0.294508934,
-0.0856202692,
0.0916338861,
-0.9187588692,
0.1470879018,
0.1226963848,
-0.6359686852,
0.0580906495,
-0.0098574692,
-0.7380726933,
-0.6913240552,
-0.278551966,
0.4240187705,
0.3379573524,
-0.3732780814,
0.2461396158,
-0.0468638688,
-0.0584005937,
-0.602668345,
-0.7094795704,
-0.0381693803,
-0.1037126631,
-0.7913278937,
0.3392150998,
-0.2787541747,
0.0908275172,
0.327088356,
0.1112342253,
-0.4487873018,
-0.0870295018,
-0.1527892798,
0.3234803975,
-0.2538200319,
0.0585774668,
0.0604504049,
-0.2854465842,
-0.1131211221,
-0.3937300444,
0.2262509167,
0.0716114268,
-0.4005215466,
-0.2871941328,
0.3146980405,
0.8463142514,
-0.1859211922,
0.8724808693,
0.8121287227,
-0.1044500619,
0.3363694251,
-0.4558616579,
0.1269804239,
-0.4029985666,
0.4567050338,
-0.3509887159,
-0.8265514374,
0.4867500365,
0.0144024789,
-0.1468447745,
0.5652245879,
0.438655287,
-0.2732096612,
1.1353542805,
0.4762648642,
-0.3568133116,
0.2311291248,
0.0988738164,
0.3649261594,
-0.823548913,
-0.3429143429,
-0.6927176118,
-0.3841014206,
-0.5596526265,
-0.4857574105,
0.4889492095,
0.4000086188,
-0.2286198884,
0.7146187425,
-0.2340566963,
0.2188285291,
0.6241624951,
-0.1569469422,
0.357613802,
-0.3351418674,
-0.8240272999,
-0.4268140197,
-0.5101634264,
-0.2767630219,
1.171544075,
-0.0464259796,
0.2407273948,
0.1720083654,
0.5343778729,
0.3000738323,
0.5611976981,
-0.9820411205,
0.4482795894,
-0.1715958416,
-0.6342419386,
0.0266298298,
-0.8299247622,
-0.7899263501,
0.6691186428,
-0.1999769062,
-0.7105872035,
-0.1711995155,
-0.0784544423,
0.0361947641,
0.1814633906,
-0.8977743387,
0.84278965,
-0.4743317366,
0.330898881,
-0.1377565265,
-0.4844796658,
0.3704226613,
-0.3540507257,
0.4075630009,
-0.2533540726,
0.2609352171,
1.0077631474,
-0.3275522292,
0.2968268692,
-0.2706932425,
-0.1120806485,
0.1332616508,
0.0752902552,
0.5444049239,
-0.2102071643,
-0.1906805187,
0.2137983888,
0.1006656736,
-0.3167436123,
-0.7010113001,
0.6444918513,
-0.9489431381,
-0.2701885402,
0.0233579278,
-0.9452328682,
-0.5554080606,
0.5098416805,
-0.0739611238,
-0.0610650145,
-0.2531159818,
0.3053517938,
0.1476722658,
-0.0941808075,
0.1503220648,
0.7902662158,
-0.4455137551,
-1.0288410187,
0.8687070608,
0.3403630853,
0.2695620656,
0.5459314585,
0.1339077502,
-0.3541922867,
-0.1025289968,
-0.5375506282,
0.2407323271,
-0.7484514117,
-0.3335055113,
-0.625095427,
-0.0648560375,
-0.5541936755,
-0.1425749511,
-0.2801093757,
-0.744881928,
0.3245761096,
-0.123450309,
0.2002158761,
0.5998791456,
0.0415200666,
0.5120827556,
-1.2787528038,
0.2450754046,
0.4395947158,
0.4172058403,
0.0287429951,
-0.2233890891,
-0.6456810236,
0.1966325194,
-0.4999967515,
-0.8750152588,
0.3451837003,
0.1220705509,
0.9259323478,
0.4234184921,
-0.0573879108,
0.8031318188,
-0.6776067019,
0.684217453,
0.4006827474,
-1.0145307779,
0.2587254047,
-0.2105476558,
0.3387167454,
0.5975764394,
0.6314047575,
-0.8001342416,
-0.5954715014,
-0.3223752975,
-0.7407026887,
0.7319889069,
0.303403616,
-0.1263400167,
0.2563230693,
0.0492762849,
0.1145789027,
0.3672139943,
-0.7294195294,
-0.1930514872,
-0.1610645056,
-0.2492727041,
-0.2357586771,
-0.2177354246,
-0.2034057528,
-0.6031610966,
0.6964552402,
0.0699780732,
0.4663264751,
-0.1139576808,
-0.2249160409,
0.073642306,
0.1673530638,
0.1778805256,
0.317017138,
-0.4757272601,
0.0458963066,
0.4840526283,
-0.2759065032,
-0.0789390206,
0.1959525645,
-0.0078185145,
0.2269354612,
0.4282913208,
0.7309424281,
0.4941027462,
-0.2252481878,
0.3384945393,
0.1921646893,
-0.4051111042,
0.1359220445,
-0.3236795962,
0.4155351818,
0.2082030177,
0.1786287427,
0.0613068864,
-0.1244462356,
-0.1560578793,
0.4199123979,
0.4758274555,
-0.7852603197,
-0.3135811687,
0.7901164293,
0.2436819375,
-0.0568610504,
0.5900168419,
-0.3413069248,
-0.876762569,
0.5729745626,
0.4273250997,
0.788682282,
-0.5134686232,
0.0726230741,
0.4165125787,
0.5346206427,
0.3464249671,
0.2827993929,
-0.4375644624,
-0.8184583187,
-0.4221405387,
-0.6597634554,
-0.4343374074,
-0.3899005651,
-0.7722732425,
0.2672811151,
0.0805082619,
-0.236688599,
-0.0187401306,
0.0351579115,
-0.771672368,
0.2892504334,
-0.1013633758,
0.8505407572,
-0.64251405,
1.3761268854,
0.7431177497,
-0.4010622799,
-0.5625219941,
-0.1170290336,
-0.2655667961,
-1.0036824942,
0.9031475782,
0.0478238389,
-0.1592200994,
-0.2680291235,
0.051318258,
-0.9843213558,
1.3654258251,
0.4916150272,
-0.1403282732,
0.1043088436,
0.3100010753,
0.4957879186,
-0.0491897166,
0.2302391678,
0.282905966,
0.8401001692,
0.1017128974,
-1.3659650087,
-0.1636363566,
-0.2484153658,
-0.1093479767,
0.7487450838,
-0.784304738,
0.5428112745,
0.2176493555,
-0.0496500507,
0.0690474659,
0.4582499266,
-0.3083360493,
0.147791177,
0.4500037432,
1.0197943449,
0.8764834404,
-0.0411684476,
0.8812698126,
-0.5927411914,
0.7776709199,
0.9503292441,
-0.1364399195,
0.7475188971,
0.4793868363,
-0.4905811548,
0.4722185135,
0.291947782,
0.0071529672,
0.7573457956,
-0.2206807137,
-0.2748120129,
-0.1790317595,
0.053249415,
-0.5024605989,
0.1998954415,
0.2017671913,
-0.4953970313,
-0.5565612316,
-0.1618939787,
0.3507884741,
-0.1936507225,
-0.0102398582,
0.6491159797,
0.1444939822,
-0.7531099916,
0.6276673675,
0.0832359493,
0.4848524928,
-0.8975307345,
0.3317195773,
0.0334978513,
0.2373333424,
-0.0399413407,
-0.7533586025,
0.4833110869,
-0.120128125,
-0.3243864179,
-0.3466755748,
0.5191198587,
-0.5330969691,
-0.6161632538,
0.8390533328,
0.6338614225,
0.1146492139,
0.1107715294,
-0.617403686,
-0.6262804866,
0.1145472899,
0.0655984879,
0.4599339366,
0.6255740523,
-0.0349959917,
0.5530887842,
0.6857523918,
-0.254989624,
0.054409042,
0.2072541267,
0.7253570557,
-0.6115554571,
-0.4011797905,
-0.6228691936,
0.3124733269,
0.0042419438,
-0.1736612171,
0.9852300286,
0.6432204247,
0.8312033415,
-0.0719310939,
0.7152289152,
-0.133975789,
0.4408940673,
-0.2208143622,
1.1570740938,
-0.7405395508,
-0.318993032,
-0.4347590804,
-1.0918292999,
-0.3219402134,
0.2622636259,
-0.359528631,
0.0257350337,
0.8889462948,
0.5207927227,
-0.1752168238,
-0.1596523225,
0.5276998878,
0.0475826263,
0.138103947,
0.6165696979,
0.3566360474,
-0.5269477963,
1.0662956238,
-0.2159247994,
-0.1526551545,
-0.1094117761,
-1.0279718637,
-0.6454821825,
-0.6107285023,
-0.0038997678,
-0.2470026612,
-0.0801906362,
0.6499749422,
0.6666743755,
-1.0569403172,
-0.2523877323,
0.4185089469,
0.2246914804,
-0.3340247273,
-0.2054637671,
0.3841414154,
-0.5029178262,
-0.9316948056,
0.3798771203,
0.0708309934,
-0.064266026,
-0.0796701908,
-0.3928821683,
-0.1752194762,
-0.0314294696,
0.6653493047,
-0.216641441,
-0.4781826437,
-0.3511369228,
-0.0926678553,
-0.2198989689,
0.0649120733,
0.7155504823,
-0.7548710704,
1.0209317207,
0.5508187413,
0.6541931033,
0.7009461522,
-0.2187146544,
0.7203276157,
-0.9268792868,
0.2859587669,
0.0272136182,
0.5707580447,
0.3292887509,
-0.0281683244,
0.5201896429,
0.4449442327,
-0.5714089274,
-0.4159244299,
0.2181473672,
-0.9063941836,
0.0275629051,
0.7215639949,
-0.4621373713,
0.0823085532,
0.1230224967,
-0.2537296712,
0.4356557131,
-0.2415797412,
0.7600092292,
1.2372413874,
0.0324467532,
0.1431398988,
-0.8038907051,
0.1021484956,
0.574247241,
-0.5606608987,
-0.5773488879,
0.2472397834,
0.189675495,
0.2268576622,
0.4132466018,
-0.2079927474,
0.1914800853,
-0.1047636047,
0.1982795894,
-0.0345790088,
0.0139018307,
0.3553272188,
0.1307475269,
0.1766196787,
-0.2747090757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12660v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12660v2 | Zero-shot Clarifying Question Generation for Conversational Search | 2023-01-30T04:43:02 | 2023-02-10T17:05:21 | Zhenduo Wang, Yuancheng Tu, Corby Rosset, Nick Craswell, Ming Wu, Qingyao Ai | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | A long-standing challenge for search and conversational assistants is query
intention detection in ambiguous queries. Asking clarifying questions in
conversational search has been widely studied and considered an effective
solution to resolve query ambiguity. Existing work have explored various
approaches for clarifying question ranking and generation. However, due to the
lack of real conversational search data, they have to use artificial datasets
for training, which limits their generalizability to real-world search
scenarios. As a result, the industry has shown reluctance to implement them in
reality, further suspending the availability of real conversational search
interaction data. The above dilemma can be formulated as a cold start problem
of clarifying question generation and conversational search in general.
Furthermore, even if we do have large-scale conversational logs, it is not
realistic to gather training data that can comprehensively cover all possible
queries and topics in open-domain search scenarios. The risk of fitting bias
when training a clarifying question retrieval/generation model on
incomprehensive dataset is thus another important challenge.
In this work, we innovatively explore generating clarifying questions in a
zero-shot setting to overcome the cold start problem and we propose a
constrained clarifying question generation system which uses both question
templates and query facets to guide the effective and precise question
generation. The experiment results show that our method outperforms existing
state-of-the-art zero-shot baselines by a large margin. Human annotations to
our model outputs also indicate our method generates 25.2\% more natural
questions, 18.1\% more useful questions, 6.1\% less unnatural and 4\% less
useless questions. | [
-0.4644901156,
-1.0920130014,
0.577763021,
-0.1200176179,
-0.3446793258,
-0.3166389167,
-0.1561529338,
-0.4321888089,
0.0990873426,
0.57527107,
-0.9286794662,
-0.3194475472,
-0.1820260137,
0.12336386,
-0.406149298,
1.0566445589,
0.0086646415,
-0.2182369828,
-0.4363979697,
-0.141929999,
-0.7229037881,
-0.199246332,
-0.8277918696,
-0.1552347541,
0.3248133659,
0.7182580829,
0.596799612,
0.4249777198,
0.1260780245,
0.1653664857,
-0.0109282751,
0.0807774141,
-0.6922233701,
0.6927366257,
-0.045717217,
-0.6679222584,
0.1497275084,
-0.3001548052,
0.268935591,
0.8401210904,
-0.2078860849,
0.0244004875,
-0.2968281507,
0.4149599671,
-0.8688195944,
-0.2065770924,
-1.1489049196,
0.2723077536,
-0.0327991508,
-0.4239784777,
-0.1168597788,
-0.1747735292,
0.3068084717,
-0.5123550296,
0.9263040423,
-0.0278211739,
1.1997857094,
0.1426887512,
-0.6117228866,
-0.1690930128,
-1.0710185766,
0.5313308835,
-0.7749125957,
0.3307097256,
0.1295433491,
0.5015740395,
-0.0302694216,
-0.4691098332,
-0.7484735847,
0.0403556004,
-0.0275473185,
0.185247153,
-0.2810953856,
0.029887829,
0.4285981655,
0.1885153502,
-0.8519010544,
-0.1784427911,
-0.5508916974,
0.0305284616,
0.5707578659,
0.3254757524,
0.0270345826,
-0.0215878356,
-0.136375919,
-0.0000640053,
-0.7890614867,
0.1602529287,
0.2483531982,
0.3553115427,
0.1893596351,
0.4259426296,
-0.9859355092,
0.7249031663,
0.4684913754,
0.3143489659,
-0.1505863816,
-0.3226240277,
-0.3105504215,
0.0917106569,
0.5443045497,
0.5551516414,
-0.070314303,
-0.1995215714,
0.0713971928,
-0.4193926454,
0.3584223688,
-1.018378973,
-0.0061988495,
0.5832676291,
0.231533289,
-0.1700988859,
0.1102035418,
-0.5414148569,
-0.176000908,
-0.3015524745,
0.4146596491,
-0.1983769685,
-0.157941848,
0.2664228976,
-0.1922618002,
0.6689910293,
0.5311055183,
-0.7434777617,
-0.0392794088,
0.4318652749,
0.3409875035,
0.4163320959,
0.1697933972,
-0.3280413151,
0.2337086797,
-0.5336131454,
0.7304517031,
-0.3493096828,
-0.4486806393,
0.0723968446,
0.0198593605,
0.0556787774,
-0.5725242496,
0.2725256383,
-0.6323212981,
0.7787239552,
-0.4296210408,
-0.3942528963,
-0.1218835413,
0.8453689814,
-0.1760174185,
0.9762281775,
-0.238516897,
-0.3982172906,
0.5550737381,
-0.534157753,
-0.2897461951,
0.5055348277,
-0.4539315701,
-0.4283231795,
-0.1076327413,
0.3648357391,
0.3198308647,
-0.4084695578,
0.2691346407,
-0.0551136136,
-0.2641628087,
0.0640548244,
-0.3031065464,
0.5173150301,
0.1896705478,
-0.7561558485,
-0.1130317897,
-0.3950908184,
0.4712541699,
0.3178981245,
0.0008960188,
-0.1526989937,
-0.4212089479,
-0.654281497,
0.1598428637,
0.2116668224,
-0.7797542214,
0.0147664724,
-0.5631065965,
0.0250154939,
0.4074218273,
0.4787566662,
0.2678352296,
-0.1225697547,
0.8081680536,
0.2868465483,
0.2934298217,
-0.5853296518,
-0.695828259,
-1.0442346334,
0.4539394975,
-0.0076895864,
0.6782876849,
-0.9364569783,
0.309877485,
0.1248236597,
-0.6542787552,
-0.5786738992,
0.0992685333,
0.558031857,
0.9936199188,
0.2258194387,
-0.171617955,
-0.3990171552,
-0.8719208241,
-0.1898110658,
-0.1346073747,
-0.1778554469,
0.9363237619,
0.271879971,
0.419719547,
1.2584459782,
-1.0367382765,
-0.0065071946,
-0.162073493,
0.1053353995,
0.3053920865,
0.4904071391,
0.4296685457,
-0.9242776036,
-0.5698508024,
-0.1601878256,
-1.0157936811,
0.0636285022,
-0.2653279603,
-0.2250775546,
-0.0117049664,
0.6046184301,
-1.0257568359,
0.531537056,
-0.2391186059,
-0.2042516917,
0.5820716023,
-0.149539426,
0.3247277737,
-0.9416851997,
0.3241043985,
-0.2056803703,
0.0080685122,
-1.0398161411,
0.2707665861,
-0.0106382947,
-0.671807766,
-0.7133568525,
0.7056158185,
-0.3823378384,
0.5745699406,
-0.0760797709,
0.2955399156,
0.3727754951,
0.3992116153,
-0.0051018638,
0.4767850935,
0.6077256203,
-0.8588339686,
0.2754419744,
0.3329037726,
0.0649691299,
0.8839713335,
-0.965703249,
0.5255644917,
-0.5581976175,
0.3753389716,
-1.1320656538,
-0.3070042133,
0.2812302113,
-0.5218210816,
0.1417370141,
-0.246228233,
-0.2344031483,
-0.3242862821,
-0.1265137196,
0.716866076,
0.4055341184,
-0.4186795354,
0.0192325469,
-0.1472880095,
-0.1404340118,
-0.6590958238,
-0.2828778923,
0.202512145,
-0.1744582653,
-0.8297486305,
0.1925160438,
-0.2248130143,
-0.0044332803,
-0.1694796383,
-0.2125214785,
-0.1256892085,
-0.108315073,
0.1325194389,
0.1954509914,
-0.339545697,
0.1984175295,
0.0354461372,
0.2737716734,
-0.1842896193,
-0.1205632687,
0.6444226503,
0.1151647046,
-0.5095262527,
-0.3364106417,
0.4565012753,
0.1718311459,
-0.2234948874,
0.666549623,
0.43494156,
-0.2761281431,
-0.1044835672,
-0.8288875818,
-0.6720280051,
-0.4929632843,
-0.1103115007,
-0.3600215018,
-0.8856161237,
0.5859504342,
0.2072200924,
0.035144724,
0.3577268124,
0.2809556425,
-0.0824347511,
1.2012491226,
0.3472166657,
0.2974825799,
0.2544407248,
-0.2970817983,
0.4259426296,
-0.5240109563,
-0.6825224161,
-0.6793313622,
-0.3272241652,
-0.3328458667,
-0.2281884849,
0.4309182167,
0.1643727869,
-0.0132999672,
0.37655285,
-0.5910283327,
0.5695695877,
0.5985807776,
0.1189752668,
0.0330713205,
-0.1401653439,
-0.1263671219,
0.0528953895,
-0.6010633707,
-0.0991311073,
1.1365295649,
-0.1785931289,
0.4409655631,
-0.0614872724,
0.8793186545,
-0.2377961129,
-0.1999571174,
-0.7215382457,
0.6065568924,
0.3317397237,
-1.2408162355,
-0.4593194723,
-0.4374624491,
-1.300673604,
0.1879835427,
-0.0023395866,
-0.5828433037,
0.2576821744,
0.1205646694,
-0.6352043152,
0.165887475,
-0.671711266,
0.7236308455,
-0.0864338502,
-0.5061084032,
0.2427480072,
-0.8386620879,
0.4898487329,
0.2723872066,
-0.3251509964,
-0.1704992503,
0.2616361976,
0.5132933259,
-0.4786172211,
0.7777860165,
-0.5753595829,
-0.0733466372,
0.5372087955,
0.1438934356,
0.3495602012,
0.2292512655,
-0.1117175594,
-0.0869213641,
0.0128706442,
-0.4759744704,
-0.7874893546,
0.4612134099,
-0.3235731423,
-1.0411725044,
-0.0926775336,
-0.4616351724,
-0.2250540853,
0.3776800334,
0.3134659231,
0.2623335123,
-0.2490904629,
0.2458998263,
0.8869253993,
-0.1834225804,
0.0432264805,
0.9623348713,
-0.0004316875,
0.0927373245,
0.6494731307,
-0.1375724822,
0.1794493794,
0.2715269327,
0.1418440044,
-0.2019070983,
-0.3923680484,
-0.6138359308,
0.1787378937,
-0.4967891574,
-0.3282877207,
-0.5132493973,
-0.2766701281,
-0.7260263562,
-0.1311520338,
-0.0996505097,
-0.4631611407,
-0.427569747,
0.0507338569,
0.2639058828,
0.2621246874,
0.2605895102,
0.3862114549,
-0.5905573368,
0.3496006131,
0.5617598295,
0.0965550393,
-0.2163027376,
-0.4933987558,
0.0196567103,
0.3335513473,
-0.7247411609,
-0.764835,
0.2548973262,
0.3173439801,
0.4152193964,
0.8476997018,
0.4000826776,
0.8698632121,
-0.3002049029,
1.0210385323,
0.2305605114,
-0.5288704634,
1.0601320267,
-0.4812853038,
0.6648325324,
0.9500164986,
0.4177289307,
-0.74262923,
-0.3399531841,
-0.9260130525,
-0.9452779293,
0.7647243738,
0.3829826713,
0.4382585287,
-0.1792560667,
0.8068694472,
0.1096844226,
0.4626599252,
-0.1187351495,
-0.2485703677,
-0.210593611,
0.2859503329,
0.1824344546,
0.0530161336,
-0.4127267003,
-0.1682999581,
0.6344789267,
-0.2521573305,
0.2650253475,
0.3965873122,
0.2467669249,
-0.2131234109,
0.4931133687,
0.613792479,
0.4623171389,
-0.538087666,
-0.1051857099,
0.1499030292,
-0.0845505148,
0.0992793962,
-0.0573980995,
-0.7706885934,
0.1058150679,
-0.1361655742,
0.900041163,
-0.0706699193,
-0.8023005128,
0.461242646,
-0.1107271239,
-0.3722386658,
-0.2374085039,
0.2541336119,
-0.151001066,
-0.1234094724,
0.2940691411,
-0.1860443801,
0.2424204946,
-0.6511085629,
0.2418682128,
0.9164164662,
-0.6780040264,
-0.2708525062,
0.6689190269,
0.2358151823,
-0.2872820795,
0.8613032103,
-0.3338954449,
-0.3811758459,
0.7049008608,
0.5029473305,
0.9261087775,
-0.3039336205,
0.3693147302,
0.5074471235,
0.2185100764,
0.3039683402,
0.537353754,
-0.454818368,
-0.7050570846,
0.121928826,
-0.3281746209,
-0.6594876051,
0.3415087759,
-0.7091215253,
0.3864513636,
-0.4847619832,
0.0395705067,
-0.1200802252,
-0.086591132,
-0.9381758571,
0.5857903361,
-0.1251919568,
0.6648752689,
-0.5745384693,
0.3703219295,
0.5049712658,
-0.5218097568,
-0.7399202585,
-0.0173274912,
-0.0297009312,
-0.9313443899,
0.4948731661,
0.2239409983,
-0.0217815917,
-0.1188456342,
-0.8808090091,
-0.5504841208,
1.3621857166,
0.3541907668,
-0.3222538829,
-0.4080391526,
0.4768556952,
0.4937956631,
-0.3898288608,
0.5226674676,
0.393473208,
0.2361976057,
0.8647735119,
-0.7341806293,
0.2044990063,
-0.3408812284,
-0.2315111756,
0.2250353694,
-0.4832666814,
0.6308844686,
-0.2760485113,
-0.4755985141,
0.2112987041,
0.2261238098,
0.269087106,
0.764262557,
0.3861202896,
0.6935241222,
0.6695952415,
-0.0279819798,
0.7712755203,
-0.2967780232,
0.067276597,
1.1955010891,
-0.5748786926,
0.8212455511,
0.4712572694,
0.1393748522,
0.3302118182,
0.4536961317,
0.0698141754,
0.3074729443,
0.2588538527,
-0.5435037613,
-0.3358054161,
-0.3458127677,
-0.5129956603,
0.5012592077,
0.2315110862,
-0.0792361125,
-0.6478484273,
-0.2066717893,
0.2158229202,
-0.165202558,
0.1807185858,
1.0141475201,
-0.2708441019,
-0.9540438652,
0.7909306288,
-0.0619664937,
0.3309713602,
-0.7588526011,
0.1048461869,
-0.6470977068,
-0.0793646574,
-0.2499362528,
-0.5873262286,
0.0788585842,
-0.067550689,
-0.0241870526,
-0.0785194039,
0.5900269151,
-0.5774356723,
-0.3889044523,
-0.3141022623,
0.6550312042,
0.5191758275,
-0.3966815472,
-0.6482667923,
-0.4200787842,
0.1732008457,
-0.0231332127,
0.1567910463,
0.4345307946,
0.0956306159,
0.6101741195,
0.7028362155,
-0.2075537145,
0.1936836839,
-0.0119882021,
0.8496749997,
-0.6901288629,
-0.4032343626,
-0.4424417317,
0.631988585,
-0.1781971157,
-0.3683311343,
0.8106620312,
0.6342199445,
0.6360348463,
0.1059523895,
0.6407625079,
-0.1533945501,
0.4080366194,
-0.2753562629,
0.6049614549,
-0.63348943,
0.202891469,
-0.0239346772,
-0.8800191879,
-0.2382203937,
0.0361834504,
-0.2097626776,
0.1780203283,
0.4366079271,
1.0916813612,
-0.1647498161,
0.1355791241,
0.5165317059,
-0.0717973858,
0.6912870407,
0.5165704489,
0.4971240163,
-0.6450718641,
0.9327175617,
-0.4119446278,
-0.0520478897,
-0.307231307,
-0.7094857693,
-0.6707498431,
-0.626218617,
-0.4961725771,
-0.1372347325,
-0.0659240559,
0.4404586554,
0.8797340393,
-0.7068877816,
-0.1609092802,
-0.3119647503,
0.0150422752,
0.0079168193,
-0.3661698103,
-0.007687185,
-0.5032123923,
-0.5104278922,
0.6069368124,
0.1875507087,
0.1028804258,
-0.2780008614,
0.0076701306,
-0.3935274482,
0.4138059914,
0.3953214288,
0.783371985,
-0.5689198971,
-0.2069272995,
0.2757890821,
0.2004761845,
0.1033901945,
0.8817691207,
-1.1137320995,
0.84271276,
0.2971175909,
0.3317866325,
0.868616581,
0.0857234821,
0.5642249584,
-1.316763401,
0.0170493927,
0.4490001798,
-0.2424453944,
0.4241772294,
-0.6144564152,
0.285782069,
0.0755461752,
-0.3908777237,
-0.7736124992,
0.4603887796,
-0.8756526113,
-0.091185987,
0.868463695,
-0.0132367043,
0.0185502563,
-0.196106106,
-0.2632452846,
0.2175643593,
-0.4689541459,
0.928853333,
0.3887943625,
-0.4590629041,
-0.1675375998,
-0.542845428,
0.4104975462,
0.8450405598,
-0.7776074409,
0.062277507,
0.4050333202,
0.2743664682,
0.2593888938,
0.5500925183,
0.0212300885,
0.4877915084,
-0.1446737945,
0.0993566811,
0.0188282877,
-0.142685011,
-0.255749166,
0.5425504446,
-0.0347989537,
-0.2394011319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12652v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12652v4 | REPLUG: Retrieval-Augmented Black-Box Language Models | 2023-01-30T04:18:09 | 2023-05-24T05:08:07 | Weijia Shi, Sewon Min, Michihiro Yasunaga, Minjoon Seo, Rich James, Mike Lewis, Luke Zettlemoyer, Wen-tau Yih | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce REPLUG, a retrieval-augmented language modeling framework that
treats the language model (LM) as a black box and augments it with a tuneable
retrieval model. Unlike prior retrieval-augmented LMs that train language
models with special cross attention mechanisms to encode the retrieved text,
REPLUG simply prepends retrieved documents to the input for the frozen
black-box LM. This simple design can be easily applied to any existing
retrieval and language models. Furthermore, we show that the LM can be used to
supervise the retrieval model, which can then find documents that help the LM
make better predictions. Our experiments demonstrate that REPLUG with the tuned
retriever significantly improves the performance of GPT-3 (175B) on language
modeling by 6.3%, as well as the performance of Codex on five-shot MMLU by
5.1%. | [
-0.1594844759,
-0.7452189326,
0.2026459724,
-0.1405166239,
-0.3662354648,
0.3660775721,
-0.3101688921,
-0.598667264,
0.3071914017,
0.7732127905,
-0.5350141525,
-0.3647978306,
-0.3130738437,
0.1839204878,
-0.5888699293,
0.8955014944,
0.1953926086,
-0.075399518,
0.0723052472,
-0.0144820083,
-0.5894033313,
-0.5685338378,
-0.6223868132,
-0.6628353596,
0.4676775932,
0.2261302322,
0.9015520811,
0.5811319947,
0.3334947526,
0.2350004166,
0.0525434017,
0.0125318673,
-0.7523252964,
0.2506012022,
-0.2548637092,
-0.6888164878,
-0.3259227276,
0.2008453757,
0.5572693944,
0.3957306743,
-0.4905957878,
0.2739546001,
-0.1105964109,
0.6427041292,
-0.7048758268,
-0.1466007233,
-0.7731871009,
-0.066361405,
-0.0889120623,
-0.3293529153,
-0.7900688648,
-0.2526922226,
0.1431529522,
-0.6159718633,
0.6196184754,
0.2639357746,
0.942497313,
0.2870022357,
0.0049620615,
0.0815669298,
-0.537052393,
0.7593271136,
-0.8189231157,
0.7927299142,
0.6807485819,
0.25407812,
-0.2770621777,
-1.061655283,
-0.3641750515,
-0.3189075589,
-0.3122945428,
0.1551436931,
-0.022749031,
0.0532585159,
0.2054955959,
0.7182094455,
-0.5836563706,
-0.2064527124,
-0.3397658765,
-0.1927154809,
0.5773820877,
-0.109398067,
0.285730958,
0.069099091,
-0.1421681792,
0.0217868052,
-0.7731107473,
-0.310310781,
0.4234223962,
0.3767907619,
0.1305446774,
0.6366220713,
-0.1257873923,
1.1957498789,
0.3506649733,
0.0401619673,
0.2419659346,
-0.2894591093,
-0.4215044081,
0.0036584109,
0.5329069495,
0.1459992677,
0.1499433219,
-0.3905770779,
-0.2171096951,
-0.2774302065,
0.9485287666,
-0.7211329341,
-0.4142807722,
-0.0065732603,
-0.3473224342,
-0.2607916892,
-0.1501482576,
-0.6830572486,
-0.062575005,
-0.2270471752,
0.392980516,
-0.434117049,
-0.3371494412,
0.2797861993,
-0.0357901342,
0.1932132691,
0.2509855628,
-1.0614608526,
0.0919773653,
0.7491579652,
0.6920366287,
-0.1107862219,
-0.2483225167,
-0.98643893,
0.0593688563,
-0.4149123728,
0.7072347999,
-1.0377686024,
-0.3884871006,
0.2270276546,
0.4013590515,
0.199671939,
-0.3241356015,
0.5487790704,
-0.9386606216,
0.3151761293,
-0.1153812334,
-0.6457711458,
-0.2462763339,
0.2737882435,
-0.8633152246,
1.3358929157,
0.3600734472,
-0.538557291,
0.3762577474,
-0.2280878723,
-0.244980216,
0.5136351585,
-0.0146725914,
-0.5823087692,
0.3729838133,
-0.0018833007,
0.104854174,
-0.199034974,
0.1248676404,
-0.4849824607,
-0.6686522365,
0.021400163,
-0.1082367525,
0.3879964948,
0.3007989824,
0.0939775929,
-0.1137158126,
-0.6685658097,
0.1725588739,
-0.0570091233,
-0.7209265232,
-0.3211023211,
-0.1317367405,
0.0614446774,
-0.0671927035,
0.3907884955,
-0.5538814664,
0.3964589536,
-0.5727006197,
0.1634706706,
0.2558579147,
-0.3653418124,
0.5775914788,
-0.2100589871,
0.8334538937,
-0.4884717166,
-0.2477571219,
-0.2327752858,
-0.3726772964,
-0.4898270965,
-0.0209013149,
0.6597434282,
0.4360764325,
-0.8284906745,
0.2255243361,
0.1442099959,
-0.4011889398,
-1.2405408621,
0.1715359688,
0.5147668719,
0.4177248478,
0.3227050304,
-0.0600906387,
-0.5460565686,
-1.0543556213,
-0.4617547393,
-0.123356171,
0.0698842928,
0.3311931789,
0.2903701365,
-0.1482672393,
0.6768019199,
-0.5166643262,
-0.1058931425,
-0.2737443447,
0.2950086296,
0.0156484693,
0.3527470231,
0.5790170431,
-0.827853322,
-0.47835958,
0.2423317581,
-0.5703456402,
-0.3067763746,
0.3721921444,
-0.006946309,
0.4071081281,
0.613225162,
-0.4517694712,
0.4846820533,
0.7253146172,
-0.287545979,
0.9610010386,
-0.3891266584,
0.3821327388,
-0.9679837227,
0.0837967321,
-0.1849762797,
-0.5105332732,
-0.7803015113,
0.4513164759,
0.481636405,
-0.1652228534,
-0.4342928231,
0.6582559943,
-0.5815611482,
-0.1885233372,
-0.8038876057,
0.3008427024,
0.1767238975,
0.3764976263,
0.1167204082,
1.0219677687,
0.3696354926,
-0.2441681623,
0.3889067173,
0.0264744628,
-0.2551718652,
0.4044035673,
-0.6173281074,
0.2765758336,
-0.0077530751,
0.0145081459,
-0.8937795758,
-0.0536697209,
0.0121795386,
-0.5275339484,
0.6957960129,
-0.5798305273,
-0.4903105795,
-0.3623538315,
-0.071616374,
0.5932237506,
0.3387337625,
-0.5377868414,
0.490786612,
0.2777988613,
-0.0585312881,
-0.8627954721,
-0.7374929786,
0.010531364,
0.0035815784,
-0.2015885413,
0.5049594045,
-0.055054713,
0.0439571887,
0.0844411775,
-0.1651802212,
0.1307839155,
0.0759926215,
0.0838581398,
0.1416578889,
-0.2143097669,
0.3948867321,
-0.1515487432,
-0.1394309998,
-0.3179466724,
-0.3263060749,
0.6498084068,
-0.2246773541,
-0.2530438006,
0.2013825178,
0.2813021541,
0.1724606603,
-0.5675548315,
0.6630715132,
0.738244772,
-0.5573759675,
-0.1667705774,
-0.8091911674,
-0.2957811654,
-0.5036059022,
0.2827641368,
-0.5395807624,
-1.2017719746,
0.502826333,
0.2044055313,
0.1198564395,
0.0263344832,
0.6668611765,
0.1440485865,
0.8642202616,
1.0465651751,
-0.1541938335,
0.7448534966,
-0.1163055971,
0.0423426367,
-0.9259946942,
-0.0898161009,
-0.5611499548,
-0.2709792852,
-0.5676773787,
-0.1564267427,
-0.3125057518,
0.6336940527,
0.1654789001,
0.6932575107,
-0.8293349743,
0.6335879564,
0.5205308795,
0.0412927493,
0.4555428624,
-0.0271048136,
-0.273470521,
-0.0720631033,
-0.8250943422,
-0.3729730844,
1.1970471144,
0.1639502198,
0.909234941,
-0.0125660971,
0.8588061333,
0.2693402767,
0.8055451512,
-0.6507276893,
0.2077066451,
-0.1434655637,
-0.7892317772,
-0.2761963606,
-0.3363601565,
-1.1382604837,
0.4972779155,
-0.1153030396,
-0.9217448831,
0.1856364906,
0.2450272739,
-0.2674570382,
0.1332014799,
-0.8625297546,
0.8326590657,
-0.0857858434,
-0.5309183598,
-0.3359614313,
-0.0852639005,
0.4257603586,
-0.1402643174,
0.0430454351,
-0.0490334667,
-0.0109212268,
0.6171995997,
-0.272313267,
0.3717587292,
0.0653270334,
-0.2343757898,
0.1657669097,
0.4589878917,
0.5430678725,
0.2149293572,
-0.2631168962,
-0.172676906,
0.0990293249,
-0.4035858214,
-0.7704904675,
0.981387496,
-0.5300901532,
-1.0226255655,
-0.3553954959,
-0.7045288682,
0.0471319146,
0.4338169098,
0.0672601461,
0.442550987,
0.0364974104,
0.3717991114,
0.4222427309,
-0.2667172551,
0.4047705233,
1.1221247911,
-0.714646697,
-0.4045009911,
0.7339609861,
0.0339924283,
0.2841392457,
0.3649379909,
-0.1093579233,
-0.5193543434,
-0.5163168311,
-0.1781444252,
0.5174589753,
-0.4217013717,
-0.4080345035,
-0.4736623764,
-0.2849232256,
-0.2497264594,
-0.0376697108,
-0.3641463816,
-0.2103066146,
-0.3657095134,
-0.2916725576,
0.5044311285,
0.5397254229,
0.015480347,
0.3813295662,
-0.6419300437,
0.5159298778,
0.1667035222,
0.9386281967,
-0.2527707219,
-0.8652096391,
-0.5222734213,
0.2065360397,
-0.2902263105,
-0.9136669636,
0.6675242782,
0.0882327929,
0.5773870945,
-0.0929824933,
-0.0361965112,
0.7060072422,
-0.6458467245,
0.6641818881,
-0.0378409028,
-0.482540071,
0.5186822414,
-0.2717727125,
0.438960433,
0.4981084466,
0.0381473191,
-0.4236508012,
-0.7853229046,
-0.6849479675,
-0.4113821983,
0.9288056493,
0.060327936,
-0.203806445,
-0.1971654445,
0.632024765,
0.1685598493,
0.3039505482,
-0.7359564304,
-0.2424039543,
-0.2811982036,
0.009061846,
-0.2242171466,
-0.4420958757,
-0.0948450118,
0.0323936716,
0.5827404261,
-0.1481868327,
0.0824921429,
0.2560765147,
-0.3527420461,
-0.4267827272,
0.3110716343,
0.5960780382,
0.5196621418,
-0.6884588599,
0.0523817986,
0.0462741405,
-0.4192195833,
0.2050574273,
0.3498516679,
-0.2817004621,
0.0522003323,
0.072291486,
0.5565478206,
0.5443425775,
-0.3992725909,
-0.0097512277,
-0.1464687884,
-0.2724630535,
-0.0780870169,
0.0116487406,
0.1795588136,
0.3733264208,
0.6109355688,
-0.3059496284,
0.1182510406,
-0.4796075225,
0.5623662472,
0.5605418086,
-0.4292407632,
-0.1546008885,
0.7715635896,
0.0058801915,
-0.8796592355,
0.4461581111,
-0.0845503584,
-0.3171186447,
0.2847835422,
0.8633838892,
0.9031234384,
-0.1698487252,
0.1917525083,
0.251560688,
0.4280990958,
-0.3830467761,
0.1885508746,
-0.0142350243,
-0.7751659751,
-0.7890582681,
-0.8166825771,
-0.2375919074,
0.5772836804,
-0.7759407163,
0.1303132623,
-0.1296282113,
-0.3311083019,
-0.1490991861,
0.3495375514,
-0.5887236595,
0.074995093,
-0.0670827106,
1.1097533703,
-0.3750302792,
1.0973694324,
0.64556247,
-0.4371117353,
-0.576313138,
-0.3768188357,
-0.2483825088,
-0.7502713799,
0.3096494675,
-0.1027918309,
-0.0634234324,
0.2992478311,
-0.553052485,
-0.9571695924,
1.047151804,
0.5647698045,
-0.7985066175,
0.1210576147,
-0.2218410075,
0.7791535258,
-0.3750218749,
0.2395222932,
0.8073762059,
0.3023625314,
-0.1803441495,
-0.951068759,
-0.0327436738,
-0.3402555883,
-0.0910329074,
0.4864027798,
-0.6749153137,
0.5709190369,
-0.0679023415,
-0.3789063692,
0.1332803965,
0.6630889773,
0.5451354384,
-0.0027102849,
0.0518914238,
0.8417975903,
0.58564955,
-0.2344569415,
1.3299275637,
-0.4756194353,
0.4672273993,
1.1592851877,
-0.2042164207,
0.9987059236,
0.3052651882,
-0.0379376225,
0.3357361257,
0.4999273121,
-0.0852972791,
0.5180161595,
-0.0238466952,
-0.1006544977,
-0.2906134129,
0.056289997,
-0.5853412747,
0.0113799796,
0.3856745064,
-0.319581598,
-0.3300613463,
-0.0877761245,
-0.2916541398,
0.2431841791,
-0.3677269518,
0.6756353974,
0.2119899392,
-0.8817394376,
1.0161502361,
0.1238504648,
0.5105926394,
-0.4631233513,
-0.1449545175,
-0.3568888009,
0.1382895559,
-0.1862987876,
-0.7976205945,
0.2235010713,
-0.2581508458,
-0.2794329524,
-0.1866477132,
1.0165331364,
-1.0887150764,
-0.5629455447,
0.4878329039,
0.3560515046,
0.0528763495,
-0.032643877,
-0.8057608008,
0.022393709,
-0.0314284414,
-0.2648631632,
0.5175306797,
0.3504651189,
0.2266580611,
1.0196039677,
0.6885064244,
0.1894062907,
0.1865759194,
0.2887349725,
0.6093536615,
-0.8475344777,
-0.2567543685,
-0.725571692,
0.3559753001,
0.2017202079,
0.136757195,
0.7597156763,
0.6067110896,
0.8883041143,
-0.2137660682,
0.7354501486,
0.2357058227,
0.6421263218,
-0.435041219,
0.7231600285,
-0.6658306122,
0.2536733449,
-0.068654418,
-0.8850437999,
-0.2110273242,
0.4710265994,
-0.3900371194,
0.0174315274,
0.4655597508,
1.0894556046,
-0.0895722583,
-0.0819875449,
0.6395028234,
-0.013309733,
0.2599057853,
0.4402562976,
0.6719630957,
-0.6373854876,
0.7229661345,
-0.1221211776,
-0.0114860637,
-0.4933730364,
-0.7199077606,
-0.9152572751,
-0.4876395166,
-0.1757714301,
-0.4002930224,
0.2326362431,
0.5585891604,
0.7172988653,
-0.78543818,
-0.2293501496,
0.0807318613,
0.3510478437,
-0.1977035552,
-0.2993746698,
0.1343366504,
-0.6218158603,
-0.6166616678,
0.5544863343,
0.3376638591,
-0.0146341221,
-0.1457457542,
-0.2053473443,
-0.6070321798,
-0.1278863698,
0.5330484509,
0.4938184619,
-0.8944032192,
-0.4956519008,
-0.0782029778,
-0.0635006502,
0.0533363521,
0.892377317,
-1.1034502983,
0.6599122882,
0.2865418196,
0.7400814891,
0.8746430278,
0.3238045275,
1.1288551092,
-1.0300991535,
0.2390966564,
-0.0512271486,
0.497181505,
0.2613948882,
-0.2800701857,
0.5995234847,
0.00551335,
-0.6705158949,
-1.0611722469,
0.3418903947,
-0.5910902619,
-0.2550634444,
1.0158979893,
-0.0644771606,
-0.2279075831,
-0.1433425099,
-0.2857326269,
0.3050552309,
-0.5119323134,
0.8989129663,
0.9294481874,
0.335465014,
-0.8536704183,
-0.5572091341,
0.8278279901,
0.4168725908,
-0.4245486259,
0.2751171291,
0.4956455827,
0.3347142935,
0.2329498231,
0.4578175843,
-0.3295468986,
0.6700084209,
-0.1543823183,
0.0731628537,
-0.3281807005,
-0.2384639978,
-0.4770395458,
0.300362885,
0.1241036057,
0.005513066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12642v1 | Exploring the Constructicon: Linguistic Analysis of a Computational CxG | 2023-01-30T03:51:08 | 2023-01-30T03:51:08 | Jonathan Dunn | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has formulated the task for computational construction grammar as
producing a constructicon given a corpus of usage. Previous work has evaluated
these unsupervised grammars using both internal metrics (for example, Minimum
Description Length) and external metrics (for example, performance on a
dialectology task). This paper instead takes a linguistic approach to
evaluation, first learning a constructicon and then analyzing its contents from
a linguistic perspective. This analysis shows that a learned constructicon can
be divided into nine major types of constructions, of which Verbal and Nominal
are the most common. The paper also shows that both the token and type
frequency of constructions can be used to model variation across registers and
dialects. | [
-0.6410354972,
-0.8437370062,
0.541452229,
0.1225229204,
-0.0598085597,
0.5831338763,
-0.5081717372,
-0.7043012977,
0.1356327981,
0.2278937101,
-0.139988631,
-0.5439079404,
-0.621753037,
0.164528802,
-0.3565815687,
0.6224220395,
0.0732093453,
-0.2371680439,
-0.3209592104,
0.2685716748,
-0.3969976008,
-0.7902385592,
-0.6006372571,
-0.2842366397,
0.0901211798,
0.4680084288,
0.986173749,
0.6837442517,
0.1315878034,
0.4662859142,
-0.319988817,
0.0375389941,
-0.2379860729,
-0.3463829756,
-0.0464907475,
-0.3999446034,
0.2664029896,
-0.1085115895,
0.8329948187,
1.2691518068,
0.2107178271,
0.4029194713,
0.0148212481,
0.2873794138,
-0.6465404034,
0.4982116818,
-0.4682030082,
0.1392567605,
-0.3110905886,
0.2673858702,
-0.3860576451,
-0.2027652413,
0.0337317735,
-0.6032524109,
0.0808665976,
0.2301523834,
0.7522034645,
0.0066050715,
-0.5449281931,
-0.2244581133,
-0.5610570908,
0.68275249,
-0.514280498,
0.5461623073,
0.2352031022,
0.1636284441,
-0.2196814269,
-0.839686811,
-0.4183742404,
-0.6250985265,
-0.3873243332,
0.1125663295,
-0.4512690902,
0.2180073708,
0.0641712695,
0.7497628331,
-0.5742250681,
0.3003677726,
-0.4601848125,
-0.4221590161,
0.4297045171,
0.1396695226,
0.5265970826,
-0.4665336907,
-0.198342815,
0.1015053764,
-0.6690139174,
0.1602007747,
0.53109622,
0.3711611331,
-0.3423700035,
0.7369163036,
-0.0559277944,
0.6977471113,
0.1947402954,
0.1924046427,
0.3314114511,
-0.3323388994,
-0.0839821696,
0.0876499265,
0.8994971514,
-0.09658508,
0.3777522445,
-0.3301480114,
0.0458258092,
0.4396873116,
0.7682866454,
-0.2673102617,
-0.3050799668,
0.0372169502,
-0.5122026801,
-0.3231381476,
-0.0669138283,
-0.4784570038,
0.014338972,
-0.6047591567,
-0.0357886776,
-0.5029041171,
-0.4736094177,
0.0052513028,
-0.256762892,
0.054073628,
-0.1351838112,
-0.8093957901,
0.4686842859,
0.9481882453,
0.6944220066,
-0.2228803039,
-0.1678940505,
-0.1618178338,
-0.2368767709,
-0.5581468344,
1.0968322754,
-0.669575572,
-0.7011857033,
0.207556814,
-0.1549887508,
-0.1733510196,
-0.6371151805,
0.1959498972,
-0.3311912417,
0.3237838745,
0.1795566976,
-0.7482668757,
-0.3210144937,
0.3758379519,
-0.6747829318,
1.3759279251,
0.8521491289,
-0.5184494853,
0.5007753372,
-0.5650852323,
-0.3353206515,
0.4883800447,
-0.4845514596,
-0.12804012,
0.6328805685,
-0.2612157166,
0.1242527142,
-0.1719761193,
0.0627205372,
0.0454352908,
-0.378520906,
0.3284834325,
0.3324649632,
0.6857869625,
0.2756340206,
-0.3649921417,
0.0066232695,
-1.0115252733,
0.1507222354,
-0.1712057739,
-0.3179656863,
-0.3794555664,
0.1743656397,
0.1229465753,
0.0021560299,
0.0959797055,
-0.6939919591,
0.1077437103,
-0.81772089,
0.179159224,
0.5794475675,
-0.0039617782,
0.3357780278,
-0.1222396493,
0.5651422739,
-0.0605530106,
0.1143075302,
0.2819213569,
-0.4667215645,
-0.8424392939,
-0.1631484479,
0.3705657423,
0.3032680452,
-0.8397687078,
0.1808740944,
-0.0456584394,
-0.6300776601,
-0.0838371515,
-0.0659483299,
0.7615436912,
0.0427425392,
0.0186954737,
-0.4813685715,
-0.5558018088,
-1.0439577103,
-0.131334126,
-0.7055326104,
0.0617842749,
0.1584966779,
0.3823379874,
-0.1503601819,
0.5185570121,
-0.5360685587,
0.2146517783,
-0.3631860018,
0.4303786755,
0.2314136624,
0.3147479296,
0.9675144553,
-0.4838267565,
-0.4276660681,
0.2670685947,
-0.5434213281,
-0.1373823434,
-0.0894652829,
-0.0858032331,
-0.0761281773,
0.7140035033,
-0.3919555545,
0.2315080762,
0.4278356731,
-0.7306857109,
0.9343808889,
0.3664645851,
0.1212546304,
-0.8049412966,
-0.1089104041,
-0.1128184497,
-0.1421779692,
-0.6155279279,
0.4481292665,
-0.308495909,
0.0459455252,
-0.7103239894,
0.3527369797,
-0.4420861602,
-0.1020894572,
-0.1850856096,
-0.0439210311,
-0.3306157887,
0.6560064554,
0.0952247828,
0.7909796834,
0.533051312,
-0.614607513,
0.1281973869,
0.2567070127,
-0.6161612868,
0.4183165431,
-0.5412405133,
0.2480664402,
-0.0863766,
-0.6274033189,
-1.1843944788,
-0.035817232,
0.2542482913,
-0.7075810432,
0.1111565232,
-0.244341895,
-0.6414253116,
-0.2812805474,
-0.215208143,
0.631641686,
0.2719327509,
-0.4537778795,
0.5425527096,
0.6836476326,
0.0253364872,
-0.1295256019,
-0.1232839152,
0.2086925656,
-0.2933191955,
-0.5430897474,
0.4875007868,
-0.1358674467,
-0.8520817161,
-0.1235314533,
0.2074844092,
-0.3486835659,
0.2690137923,
0.4948426187,
0.1240597889,
-0.3454368412,
0.0242311526,
-0.1820998192,
0.1686459631,
0.3450110257,
-0.158075273,
0.5528609753,
-0.1718021929,
0.176310882,
-0.1162448972,
0.5339546204,
0.2188907713,
0.0475165881,
0.4386933744,
0.249370113,
-0.3684495091,
-0.3238839805,
-0.2796645761,
0.3678670526,
-0.475107789,
0.2604382038,
-0.5977232456,
-1.2549394369,
0.2649643421,
-0.0786342397,
0.0058605857,
0.6851992607,
0.7423158884,
0.075079754,
0.8392032981,
0.8818897605,
0.133870393,
0.4758017361,
-0.1170426905,
-0.0795054436,
-0.4878294468,
-0.19562307,
-0.7305662036,
0.0489174724,
-0.7872686982,
-0.2409641892,
0.5000252724,
-0.1472821683,
-0.4819682837,
0.7515345216,
-0.4958749115,
0.3876681626,
0.6610811353,
-0.2657249868,
0.143336311,
-0.0164553206,
-0.463318646,
-0.0268675778,
-0.7476169467,
-0.4608519375,
0.8692554235,
0.0345966145,
0.1744792461,
0.1498554796,
0.5218418837,
0.5177252889,
0.3100622296,
-1.0560013056,
0.389744252,
-0.4174350798,
-0.4054915011,
0.0998677909,
-0.3685874641,
-0.9570980072,
0.2866250873,
-0.2911553085,
-0.9189786911,
0.139935717,
0.0270415451,
-0.1740344316,
0.1160055101,
-0.6543194056,
0.9036124945,
-0.190143615,
0.1974931508,
-0.1454598755,
-0.3169512451,
0.4481897056,
-0.0123154344,
0.4111436903,
0.1019876227,
0.1541085839,
0.6094095111,
-0.3302049935,
0.9129377007,
0.2590590715,
-0.0392978415,
0.7711607814,
0.4521518946,
-0.1812946051,
0.0229457542,
0.1752490699,
0.5366532803,
0.3905205429,
-0.106997408,
-0.4924060106,
0.3066987693,
-1.0618265867,
-0.3159901202,
-0.4637466073,
-0.2389494628,
-0.4073164463,
0.0690607876,
0.3346986175,
0.532551527,
-0.7611423135,
-0.0330203027,
0.0367290266,
-0.3796855807,
0.3561017811,
0.2854251862,
-0.1000674069,
-0.3723237514,
0.5937681198,
-0.1067540795,
0.0717863366,
0.4427958429,
0.373807162,
-0.3228502274,
-0.573569417,
-0.3647355139,
0.1442204267,
-0.6526359916,
-0.0979704931,
-0.3195734918,
-0.2942370474,
-0.3279289603,
-0.1246734113,
-0.4744378924,
-0.7055233121,
-0.2975874841,
-0.064846985,
-0.023797635,
1.1308125257,
-0.0539520867,
0.8096111417,
-0.6304938793,
0.2618506253,
0.0670463219,
0.4065288007,
-0.2799987197,
-0.305545032,
-0.3235783875,
-0.2677804232,
-0.2404494733,
-0.6308739185,
0.0428456068,
0.222217679,
0.5887576938,
0.3531308472,
-0.349347502,
0.4615285695,
-0.5997132659,
1.1405507326,
0.3620113134,
-1.103402257,
0.2981787026,
-0.330631882,
0.4251646101,
0.6409906149,
0.218943879,
-0.655220449,
-0.5912158489,
-0.759670198,
-0.7309402227,
0.1091506928,
0.3695929945,
0.1106679961,
-0.6775512099,
0.6696192026,
0.1554616094,
0.0816652849,
-0.5548197031,
-0.2530667782,
-0.1942428797,
-0.1358596832,
0.0203982387,
-0.3691605628,
-0.0039267545,
-0.0290882289,
0.2380041778,
-0.154026702,
0.3997260928,
-0.272093147,
-0.2991371453,
0.2175388485,
0.2751418054,
0.2476565242,
0.7726482749,
0.2655049562,
0.4285508692,
-0.0845768154,
-0.4418126345,
-0.032754641,
-0.1418976635,
0.1259392947,
0.1860662401,
0.7102828622,
0.4590636194,
0.4768455327,
-0.7368371487,
0.4009497762,
0.0285938811,
-0.2659231126,
-0.7326660752,
-0.0352850817,
-0.2434325665,
0.0962203294,
-0.1879525036,
-0.3019078672,
0.3641804457,
-0.6393538713,
0.2678467929,
0.2961401641,
-0.4360059202,
-0.6197971702,
0.4768449366,
-0.023130361,
-0.1616273969,
0.7335072756,
-0.2243114561,
-0.5828027129,
0.8653261065,
0.5465816259,
0.9363084435,
-0.0373879708,
0.3785872459,
0.4866308272,
0.3719926775,
0.3009030819,
0.4642473757,
-0.0970505178,
-0.8672447205,
-0.7167518735,
-0.7008605003,
-0.3391804397,
-0.1278855354,
-0.4691331089,
0.0720605403,
-0.5365087986,
-0.225390926,
0.4821915627,
-0.2683868408,
-0.7603775859,
0.3823587596,
0.4365412593,
0.7252429724,
-0.6349478364,
0.2785017192,
0.9901989102,
-0.2990499139,
-0.6651806831,
-0.5171601176,
0.2589565516,
-0.9373711348,
0.8733366728,
-0.0943147913,
-0.2436799109,
-0.2824180424,
-0.4833452702,
-0.909289062,
0.2888234258,
0.2126393914,
-0.3331459463,
0.1138951331,
0.6194422841,
0.7839694023,
-0.3328480422,
0.2096832246,
0.71715343,
0.3589435816,
-0.2349686623,
-1.0431329012,
-0.11138767,
-0.3867685795,
0.109464854,
0.5409192443,
-0.4843484759,
0.6818823814,
0.1482602954,
-0.6493113637,
0.2499559969,
0.5135564804,
-0.1291017532,
-0.1771286279,
0.6868473887,
0.5131976008,
0.3208177686,
-0.1443824023,
1.1827199459,
-0.5927291512,
0.2050267607,
1.0790451765,
0.2865872383,
0.5875431895,
0.2729130387,
-0.4172321558,
0.7602483034,
0.7931326628,
-0.0282529071,
0.0240334272,
0.6461637616,
-0.3905819654,
-0.2329859138,
-0.3159110844,
-0.2021742314,
1.3301013708,
0.4072031677,
-0.4148573279,
-0.1845882833,
-0.2931595445,
0.3697292209,
0.3693909049,
-0.5113607049,
1.0103666782,
-0.026301045,
-0.6972442269,
0.6089114547,
0.0628373176,
0.2016031891,
-0.3909159899,
-0.14421013,
0.0770634636,
0.0244484097,
-0.120101817,
-0.7954159975,
0.6121652126,
-0.1658568531,
0.0269285105,
-0.0057563875,
0.4168272316,
-0.0855155364,
-0.7500482202,
0.2526695728,
0.6793877482,
0.1306669116,
-0.0742840618,
-0.3899199963,
-0.0214256514,
-0.3137308061,
0.1391269863,
0.0865591988,
0.3178140223,
-0.3037570417,
0.1391655654,
0.4740945101,
0.0044682915,
0.0837477222,
0.2031963915,
0.9598071575,
-0.7295084596,
-0.6714482307,
-0.748990953,
0.4220863581,
0.1003692597,
-0.6188189983,
0.716868937,
0.8051593304,
1.0075725317,
-0.1731951535,
0.8079877496,
-0.1948989928,
0.2663998902,
-0.3984771669,
0.2857493758,
-0.1465701908,
-0.2246850282,
-0.3580724895,
-0.9447149634,
-0.3989782035,
0.3623562753,
0.0231746156,
-0.4145368934,
0.7256684303,
0.4349164367,
0.0235955939,
0.0741238743,
0.3912370205,
0.1398928016,
-0.0096418317,
0.4888113141,
1.4013662338,
0.0204105619,
0.3130138814,
-0.4193578362,
-0.3417524993,
0.4008278549,
-0.6667774916,
-1.0503957272,
-0.6004166007,
-0.4332828224,
-0.2331602722,
-0.0041091987,
0.7391539812,
0.709213078,
-0.8113058209,
-0.748395741,
0.2467091531,
0.0006110783,
-0.4074971974,
-0.2828257978,
0.3163278997,
-0.4683976769,
-0.6023247838,
0.5227349997,
0.2324658781,
-0.2168439776,
-0.0939083472,
0.5329955816,
-0.0385047384,
-0.0035976679,
1.0736804008,
0.2928218842,
-0.4954977632,
-0.8343043327,
-0.1844020039,
0.3850319088,
0.3256607056,
1.1870322227,
-0.7956629395,
0.5760605335,
0.2884974182,
0.4299089909,
0.4123121798,
-0.0490029417,
0.6041862965,
-1.0258616209,
0.16454418,
-0.0591369011,
0.4280072749,
0.1728279293,
-0.5459210277,
0.6038013101,
0.258638382,
-0.3248689771,
-0.3712317646,
0.4391952157,
-0.9160262346,
-0.4858379662,
1.1345249414,
0.1922243983,
-0.0415065587,
-0.4071391523,
-0.2263536453,
0.1158391312,
-0.0004945574,
0.8724961877,
0.7609847784,
-0.4167965651,
-0.1253321469,
-0.3853078783,
0.5684629083,
-0.1941963285,
-0.8226345181,
-0.2940841317,
0.8402776718,
0.4122679532,
0.4133779705,
0.3961319923,
-0.3607587218,
0.3150826097,
0.2250960767,
0.0214037746,
0.182293728,
-0.2776136994,
-0.064379096,
0.4081160128,
0.3298005164,
-0.1807899475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12609v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12609v4 | Knowledge Distillation $\approx$ Label Smoothing: Fact or Fallacy? | 2023-01-30T02:05:24 | 2023-10-25T03:10:01 | Md Arafat Sultan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Originally proposed as a method for knowledge transfer from one model to
another, some recent studies have suggested that knowledge distillation (KD) is
in fact a form of regularization. Perhaps the strongest argument of all for
this new perspective comes from its apparent similarities with label smoothing
(LS). Here we re-examine this stated equivalence between the two methods by
comparing the predictive confidences of the models they train. Experiments on
four text classification tasks involving models of different sizes show that:
(a) In most settings, KD and LS drive model confidence in completely opposite
directions, and (b) In KD, the student inherits not only its knowledge but also
its confidence from the teacher, reinforcing the classical knowledge transfer
view. | [
-0.3996624947,
-0.6054301858,
0.8628674746,
-0.1190483719,
-0.2258889079,
0.2140424699,
-0.1364314258,
-0.2413021177,
-0.037064556,
0.1856207103,
-0.142078504,
-0.2304416299,
-1.0505641699,
-0.0672012717,
-0.6638025045,
1.2454200983,
-0.1031652316,
0.1222134978,
-0.3910835087,
0.3009090722,
-0.2135705799,
-0.5255665779,
-0.7340471745,
-0.7065677643,
0.7077130079,
0.20364362,
0.7539039254,
0.5618118644,
0.535972178,
0.3345507085,
-0.0779419914,
-0.0691235065,
-0.6250866055,
0.0920374468,
0.0376196839,
-0.6661790013,
0.111509949,
0.3912614882,
0.3249188662,
0.7734703422,
-0.1531340331,
0.0176516455,
0.4278551042,
1.0611697435,
-0.8760753274,
-0.0600575805,
-0.3070648313,
-0.065557003,
0.3429414928,
0.0784942582,
-0.450103581,
-0.8081211448,
0.5372265577,
-0.6710885763,
0.2447765917,
-0.1250340641,
1.0673105717,
0.7082437277,
-0.600237906,
-0.4305979908,
-1.0374231339,
0.6128237247,
-0.6161950231,
0.5718994737,
0.4290644825,
0.5470103621,
-0.1718790531,
-1.0672323704,
-0.7844914794,
-0.1383210868,
-0.1219687313,
0.2099101692,
0.1119577512,
0.1589590311,
0.5058867931,
0.4678222537,
-0.1081350595,
0.000746612,
-0.5920038819,
-0.0476558544,
0.5624552965,
-0.5113828182,
-0.1298028976,
0.2143538445,
-0.6922648549,
-0.2500376701,
-0.2581342757,
0.1745183021,
0.0560574606,
0.0727373064,
-0.1366844624,
0.2036547065,
-0.2251235396,
0.9123181105,
0.3769974709,
-0.848561883,
-0.0020668493,
-0.0827559531,
-0.3355326653,
0.4274456203,
0.4832214415,
0.7894360423,
0.4938854277,
-0.1577026844,
0.0353897847,
0.2317901105,
0.0708113983,
-0.7838124037,
-0.7772209048,
-0.1255081743,
-0.4725705981,
-0.4971841276,
0.2276809365,
-0.5576151609,
-0.5454326272,
-0.5576227903,
0.4629909098,
-0.145833239,
0.0212729219,
0.1983480155,
-0.5209708214,
-0.1752507836,
0.3760031164,
-0.6683015227,
0.3142315745,
0.605897069,
0.6646035314,
-0.5043829083,
0.1209657714,
0.0775576606,
0.0828681514,
-0.5549880862,
0.6270743608,
-0.5244159698,
-0.5057370067,
-0.2569939792,
-0.0613277406,
-0.0411070362,
-0.4234580398,
0.7193892598,
-0.5023536682,
0.2107399851,
-0.4117858112,
-0.8019682169,
-0.43050915,
0.1586155742,
-0.3312240839,
1.1577144861,
0.0106762052,
-0.8042004704,
0.9867167473,
-0.1559083462,
-0.2131009698,
-0.4795821309,
0.1096658111,
-0.321375668,
0.1610795259,
-0.2788130641,
0.4453255236,
-0.2240016311,
0.2636680305,
-0.5607514977,
-0.3359833956,
0.5541014075,
-0.635579288,
0.4354881644,
0.4180270731,
0.0058290414,
-0.5118744373,
-0.8016332388,
0.043555066,
-0.3743972778,
-0.5590642691,
-1.1115815639,
-0.1983166039,
-0.4154182673,
0.3871379793,
0.1827530861,
-0.7085322142,
0.5214095116,
-0.0672971383,
0.1894632578,
0.557841897,
0.3837548792,
0.6253829598,
-0.6370692849,
0.1145159379,
0.1630331576,
0.0113029573,
0.1574639827,
-0.6101657748,
-0.8717818856,
-0.406039089,
0.9132794738,
0.2749060988,
-0.7951146364,
0.1637328267,
-0.3320660591,
-0.7879464626,
-0.5330154896,
-0.0217912067,
0.3267956078,
0.7332071066,
0.2200550437,
-0.2363214046,
-0.2765755057,
-0.9295553565,
-0.3376351595,
-0.2002542913,
-0.0954585373,
-0.0302887242,
0.3011829257,
0.1986240298,
0.9425000548,
-0.8472397327,
-0.2071735561,
0.3854570091,
0.3261920512,
0.1430342346,
0.5847482681,
0.7673822641,
-0.9566571712,
-0.9707424641,
0.0447964408,
-0.5641850233,
0.0267263036,
-0.1154333428,
-0.1886671931,
0.3134093881,
0.5773103237,
-0.2677949667,
0.7523021102,
0.2671297193,
-0.1909506321,
0.4312514067,
-0.3275643587,
0.601823926,
-0.9873572588,
-0.2947859168,
0.1380468905,
-0.394952476,
-0.8467494845,
-0.3310251534,
-0.0333534926,
0.5362485051,
-0.1812673956,
0.2654783428,
-0.2293745279,
0.0220283642,
-0.567486763,
0.074994728,
0.2406044602,
0.1476570666,
0.0252165496,
0.4558531046,
0.5844838023,
-0.9745172858,
0.5600994825,
-0.0911834314,
-0.3507945538,
0.688542068,
-0.2870796621,
0.0253985785,
-0.160440594,
0.2474495918,
-1.244191885,
0.0723871067,
0.1306884289,
-0.3992679119,
0.5609790087,
-0.1911337376,
-0.1849556118,
-0.5844342709,
-0.1617377698,
0.1346657127,
1.0614211559,
-0.5646400452,
0.3561983705,
0.0478184447,
-0.0477708392,
-0.5528863072,
-0.9124043584,
-0.3522615433,
-0.6026459336,
-0.0751220658,
0.212568,
-0.2026913762,
-0.57688272,
0.067653425,
-0.4199395478,
-0.5352998972,
0.1424717754,
0.1765609235,
0.2417517602,
0.0217112191,
0.1080911458,
0.3659810424,
0.02654415,
-0.0170386545,
-0.3968779445,
-0.0660398751,
0.5505962372,
-0.1898771375,
-0.6445090175,
-0.2542051971,
0.5033249259,
0.6923954487,
0.6608172655,
0.1910333931,
-0.1156923398,
-0.0023996411,
-0.667694509,
-0.451892972,
-0.4250761271,
-0.0438749641,
-0.6093851924,
-0.4535532594,
0.2359711081,
-0.4464906752,
-0.0071388725,
0.3651689291,
0.3487890959,
-0.3175629377,
0.717694521,
0.8090038896,
0.0296603926,
0.218795687,
-0.1670681089,
0.2608428895,
-0.2911274433,
-0.2517951131,
-0.8150358796,
-0.6566650271,
-0.5718063712,
-0.3075695932,
0.1182871386,
0.4849192202,
-0.0946491733,
0.0747121423,
-0.6024515033,
0.5055457354,
0.6775279045,
0.0372791179,
0.6605719924,
0.1400609761,
0.0874243975,
-0.4257955253,
-0.9105449319,
-0.3436675966,
1.1275398731,
0.2247549295,
0.9016768932,
-0.1227088198,
0.7846733332,
0.4752452374,
0.4035299122,
-0.8689444065,
0.2095243186,
-0.2267780006,
-0.5043500662,
-0.2777710259,
-0.276664257,
-0.6648722291,
0.2030396461,
-0.4511453807,
-0.5627021194,
0.7356737256,
0.1438179165,
-0.0791600868,
0.3217067122,
-0.9620205164,
0.4885479808,
0.034187343,
-0.0852331966,
0.0259114038,
-0.698410511,
0.6283683777,
-0.5393225551,
0.4627728462,
0.0618353039,
0.108328566,
1.0257450342,
-0.4905371368,
0.6486028433,
-0.3689784706,
-0.2987067699,
0.3222163618,
0.203859359,
0.2857866287,
-0.3184260428,
0.0283893812,
-0.1722568125,
0.4727197886,
-0.3381515741,
-1.1098725796,
0.6751497388,
-0.6861713529,
-0.5492975116,
-0.5641182661,
-0.5950596333,
-0.0331327356,
0.1194535494,
0.295188725,
0.171304509,
0.1229959205,
0.0817493051,
0.7888867259,
0.3654018641,
0.315844655,
0.5243717432,
-0.4477257431,
0.17268987,
0.8897390962,
0.5035998225,
0.7178834081,
0.3059004545,
0.2474008352,
-0.3663979769,
-0.4035347402,
-0.1065932587,
0.0412011556,
-0.8167717457,
-0.0727669001,
-0.3362637758,
-0.3037217855,
-0.4521942437,
-0.2941155136,
-0.4763630629,
-0.8856775165,
-0.1372041106,
-0.275609076,
0.6078385115,
0.8896270394,
-0.1908588558,
0.2258333862,
-0.596788466,
0.3892114758,
0.4750745595,
0.129346028,
-0.1511464715,
-0.8443899155,
-0.1075602323,
0.2712387741,
-0.3491089046,
-0.8320207,
-0.054383792,
0.3368538916,
0.4474920034,
0.8432157636,
0.6698691845,
0.5477437973,
-0.3854852021,
0.7249538898,
0.4322238564,
-0.5556251407,
0.1055891812,
0.2287439704,
0.0030867793,
0.7135003209,
1.0855920315,
-0.5605558753,
-0.4533082843,
-0.829474926,
-0.3710180223,
0.3713498414,
-0.0715434775,
-0.165842846,
0.3268100619,
0.6152722836,
0.5730670094,
0.3190329075,
-0.4952317476,
-0.7476258874,
-0.1418643147,
-0.1679730117,
-0.2296813428,
-0.4620214105,
-0.1962887496,
-0.3114974201,
0.8488920331,
0.1661734283,
-0.0280302837,
0.385073036,
0.2225378603,
0.2073735893,
0.1390066594,
0.3262498081,
0.7681936622,
-0.1160837784,
0.5608827472,
0.0823191106,
-0.7119861841,
0.4954322577,
-0.093560636,
-0.541895926,
0.1172609627,
0.1063439474,
0.7556992173,
0.1715159714,
0.0024194606,
0.2675432265,
0.0585307367,
-0.6313698888,
0.2413376868,
0.0986777619,
-0.0102444319,
0.232905522,
0.3851446807,
0.3124241233,
0.4731233716,
-0.4294318557,
0.1897553056,
-0.0746190846,
-0.6193327308,
0.0222889464,
0.5588430762,
-0.0712559298,
-0.0085611781,
0.224352479,
-0.0776640922,
-0.4450152516,
0.4287063479,
0.2666510046,
0.5259726644,
-0.2251345515,
0.3240733147,
0.3800674379,
0.0416962579,
-0.5140148997,
-0.0050997469,
-0.1832282841,
-0.6397589445,
-0.3629214466,
-0.7628179193,
-0.2870445848,
-0.1315881759,
-0.8666859865,
0.1803614497,
-0.1351432949,
-0.3859172761,
0.2768580616,
-0.1105141416,
-0.2285437733,
0.3271067142,
-0.0553972498,
0.8751373887,
-1.1420254707,
1.0724781752,
0.6420859098,
-0.0596931539,
-0.9414221048,
0.1109625399,
-0.1938346326,
-0.2567209899,
0.9713610411,
-0.2264769226,
0.0068929992,
0.0213810354,
-0.3869670331,
-0.7650263309,
1.0487111807,
0.1273450106,
-0.6490408182,
-0.0099695623,
-0.0689262897,
0.4761174023,
-0.2429371923,
-0.1669892073,
0.8696678281,
0.6783522367,
0.5232305527,
-1.2447962761,
-0.0268592946,
0.248002395,
0.0526439771,
0.0265750103,
-0.3192107975,
0.5958534479,
-0.1915783286,
-0.0984305441,
-0.1161103249,
0.583578229,
0.1612148881,
0.6243975759,
0.5468440652,
0.6317632794,
0.8413590193,
-0.4110178947,
1.0171831846,
-0.3784882724,
0.4321506917,
0.8395344615,
-0.1059165001,
0.5079509616,
0.6465343237,
-0.61856848,
0.5810365081,
0.7515300512,
0.128347829,
0.9098207355,
0.1920305938,
-0.0968864858,
-0.1411102861,
-0.1352955401,
-0.5263324976,
0.0915038139,
0.1419287175,
-0.2678818703,
-0.1781064272,
0.2635069788,
0.0758935809,
0.5227790475,
-0.4953498244,
0.9226760268,
0.260204494,
-0.7706201673,
0.7753964067,
-0.1819556206,
0.7119722366,
-0.4696551263,
-0.0551113337,
0.0877605155,
0.193722263,
-0.2099477798,
-0.6390630007,
0.1340726018,
-0.3691468239,
-0.4085814655,
-0.1839644015,
1.0489844084,
-0.6468087435,
-0.4259004295,
0.0268517509,
0.4393584132,
0.4806623459,
0.2413434535,
-0.6468775272,
-0.2134704739,
0.1079295874,
-0.1248475239,
0.3879449368,
0.4917258918,
-0.0367532372,
0.7501626015,
0.4742468596,
0.2392859161,
0.3711252809,
-0.197771132,
0.7470343709,
0.0421769954,
-0.6085947156,
-0.768432796,
0.1065988168,
-0.1585837752,
0.1462089568,
1.0484603643,
0.5012293458,
0.7482196093,
-0.2720578611,
0.8342918754,
0.0306024309,
0.764156878,
-0.5431065559,
0.7942255139,
-0.4403424263,
-0.0186168458,
-0.3761235774,
-1.1144251823,
0.0033123088,
0.5741526484,
-0.6321804523,
0.2228320539,
0.9754315615,
0.2608169317,
0.0343015082,
0.0578840375,
0.4361682534,
0.3580656946,
-0.154584989,
0.1556600183,
0.7757444978,
-0.410153538,
0.1606806964,
-0.5956453681,
-0.3228837252,
-0.0281334482,
-0.8391374946,
-0.7641258836,
-0.8404339552,
-0.6938684583,
-0.5131803751,
0.2554463148,
0.4271750748,
0.6369766593,
-0.5174155235,
0.0550343432,
0.0044017201,
0.3190165162,
-0.1640450954,
-0.1860557199,
0.3037940562,
-0.0574685484,
-0.9055375457,
0.0155571382,
-0.1241374537,
0.6316397786,
-0.052735921,
-0.0316470005,
-0.2312493175,
0.0154011259,
0.1931551397,
0.2590771019,
-0.4946353436,
-0.2943321764,
-0.3903109431,
-0.0921377242,
-0.1320057511,
0.6868522167,
-0.9469527006,
0.527566433,
0.638689518,
0.3384785354,
0.7461954951,
0.2419542521,
0.4791873097,
-0.5265980959,
0.3713434637,
-0.2901990116,
-0.1786920875,
0.2124893218,
-0.3983599544,
0.4620752037,
0.4549837708,
-0.7522698045,
-1.0037535429,
0.2760820389,
-0.8287706971,
-0.558154285,
0.8971010447,
-0.3755340278,
-0.1545825601,
-0.3304925859,
-0.254028827,
0.2975153923,
-0.4463349283,
0.9565210938,
0.9451141953,
-0.0536602922,
0.2599499822,
-0.782712996,
1.0530953407,
-0.0073324768,
-0.2270843834,
-0.0623873323,
0.2429551631,
0.4050549865,
0.5079660416,
0.6454610825,
0.1950874776,
0.0947797373,
0.0732123256,
-0.0305778794,
-0.0932357609,
-0.3716695607,
-0.0268161222,
0.0465538688,
0.2077304721,
-0.1125492081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12608v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12608v2 | Evaluating Neuron Interpretation Methods of NLP Models | 2023-01-30T02:04:35 | 2023-11-05T12:57:27 | Yimin Fan, Fahim Dalvi, Nadir Durrani, Hassan Sajjad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neuron Interpretation has gained traction in the field of interpretability,
and have provided fine-grained insights into what a model learns and how
language knowledge is distributed amongst its different components. However,
the lack of evaluation benchmark and metrics have led to siloed progress within
these various methods, with very little work comparing them and highlighting
their strengths and weaknesses. The reason for this discrepancy is the
difficulty of creating ground truth datasets, for example, many neurons within
a given model may learn the same phenomena, and hence there may not be one
correct answer. Moreover, a learned phenomenon may spread across several
neurons that work together -- surfacing these to create a gold standard
challenging. In this work, we propose an evaluation framework that measures the
compatibility of a neuron analysis method with other methods. We hypothesize
that the more compatible a method is with the majority of the methods, the more
confident one can be about its performance. We systematically evaluate our
proposed framework and present a comparative analysis of a large set of neuron
interpretation methods. We make the evaluation framework available to the
community. It enables the evaluation of any new method using 20 concepts and
across three pre-trained models.The code is released at
https://github.com/fdalvi/neuron-comparative-analysis | [
-0.3548988104,
-0.3984694183,
0.3995172679,
0.5969304442,
-0.0863425508,
-0.349489063,
-0.4038694203,
-0.5356898904,
0.2596285045,
0.1578020304,
-0.2022466958,
-0.5217724442,
-0.6053785086,
0.0693970546,
-0.4117796421,
0.9092465639,
0.0268604625,
0.2209490538,
-0.4240257442,
-0.4064810574,
-0.4140321314,
-0.1340609193,
-0.3440309763,
-0.9295530915,
0.2810503244,
-0.0478093512,
0.7005963326,
0.2002950162,
0.6848960519,
0.2073646635,
-0.6246365905,
0.0717426762,
0.0076400219,
-0.226165697,
-0.4058396816,
-0.2913357913,
-0.7833108902,
0.0541784763,
0.4362812042,
0.9326441288,
-0.4322971404,
0.209128961,
0.2222030759,
0.5466935039,
-0.7318165898,
0.1134252399,
-0.5188239217,
0.2754558921,
0.0910363197,
-0.1769137233,
-0.4361537099,
-0.1954580247,
0.507851243,
-0.5115878582,
0.1812175214,
-0.1759648472,
0.6355739236,
0.11667943,
-0.1804253161,
-0.2708759308,
-0.2808878422,
0.5973541141,
-1.1773757935,
0.1523016244,
0.2707766891,
0.5780354738,
0.0354478732,
-0.9080653787,
-0.5820003152,
-0.4841705263,
-0.1099185795,
0.0447697714,
-0.3492215872,
-0.079780288,
0.4335347414,
0.3316745758,
-0.6519728899,
0.2403333336,
-0.1150103882,
-0.2448120415,
0.4798641205,
0.0780916736,
0.1776678264,
-0.5558287501,
-0.4008855224,
0.0506365448,
-0.4654513896,
-0.294900924,
0.5020172,
0.1588330865,
-0.1853502393,
0.3758404851,
-0.325615257,
0.8792175055,
-0.2038096189,
0.2188912481,
0.6301189661,
-0.1906844676,
-0.238057971,
-0.1520358473,
0.9097744823,
0.7789034843,
0.1379673332,
-0.4127671421,
-0.1930084825,
-0.0750274509,
0.6073318124,
-0.735948205,
-0.3255707622,
0.0108088311,
-0.9611483216,
-0.337408185,
-0.3825540841,
-0.9236754179,
-0.5080913901,
-0.186082229,
0.5996762514,
-0.3861759901,
-0.5848259926,
0.3540734351,
-0.1718661338,
0.2688804865,
0.3773690164,
-1.060644865,
0.538258791,
0.7777577639,
1.0761197805,
-0.3775852323,
-0.3644656539,
-0.2973429859,
-0.5507888794,
-0.2826392949,
0.8384501338,
-0.2064111084,
-0.0747945011,
-0.307661742,
-0.1556633413,
-0.2404127717,
-0.5781558156,
0.5155130029,
-0.5570547581,
-0.2504340708,
-0.1836841404,
-0.5842320323,
-0.3734073043,
0.3868785203,
-0.6990448236,
0.6072676778,
0.0851099789,
-0.7552886605,
0.4985385239,
-0.6482040882,
-0.3155258596,
-0.0682672113,
-0.1948355436,
-0.1889930665,
0.3028322458,
0.0759574249,
0.3340377212,
-0.4260483384,
0.3653264046,
-0.4265033305,
-0.319644928,
0.2549943924,
-0.5324315429,
0.8801438212,
0.1592963338,
-0.436946094,
0.1093026027,
-0.8561849594,
0.2749028206,
-0.1690946817,
0.1460742205,
0.005855354,
0.0833060294,
0.1695693433,
0.2857985497,
0.1030988097,
-0.2866048813,
0.0515495986,
-0.3959539831,
0.5453987718,
0.6491895914,
-0.1045279056,
0.2965631187,
-0.1343331635,
0.4623102546,
-0.2881208658,
0.2940755486,
0.1762308031,
-0.5012086034,
-0.3892478049,
0.2158784866,
0.6717344522,
0.189767763,
-0.3828104138,
0.6369823217,
-0.3134678006,
-0.6815202832,
-0.309773922,
-0.0317881182,
0.2550399601,
0.539747417,
0.6038957834,
-0.7216568589,
-0.1998208165,
-1.0177931786,
-0.3295665383,
0.001277347,
-0.042110078,
0.1372200102,
0.7155476809,
-0.0390042365,
0.8459043503,
-0.2080609351,
-0.0659859553,
-0.143803969,
0.4212509096,
0.36925295,
0.7896642089,
0.6879533529,
-0.5849625468,
-0.3135550618,
0.2511009574,
-0.942851603,
-0.0343424752,
0.0047019469,
0.074018918,
-0.3354460895,
0.2910636663,
-0.469434917,
0.6130681038,
0.7768951058,
-0.1579067409,
0.7468124032,
-0.1622352451,
0.0492339581,
-0.6786653996,
0.3297528923,
-0.0074701123,
0.1115172207,
-0.5213816166,
0.0295283441,
-0.0229867268,
0.2315733284,
-0.3806661367,
0.3934588134,
-0.2186235934,
-0.5306153893,
-0.3406390548,
0.2814911008,
0.1524945199,
0.3898706138,
0.0192418005,
0.3755325675,
0.6876320243,
-0.4079532921,
0.2418109328,
0.4483354688,
-0.7386100292,
0.5055157542,
-1.0362715721,
0.2285339981,
0.1015681922,
0.0791334435,
-0.6175720096,
0.1010648161,
0.2557148039,
-0.6950669885,
0.0431993417,
-0.1740892529,
-0.5691683888,
0.2921945453,
0.0094099985,
0.495416522,
0.3264810145,
-0.7400824428,
0.8559753895,
-0.0510196947,
0.1160046905,
-0.8363220096,
-0.7416686416,
0.1886654645,
-0.0658570454,
-0.7045629621,
0.4613564014,
0.0175745077,
-0.324596405,
0.2275831401,
-0.5692828894,
-0.0677066371,
0.2922107875,
0.0451542176,
0.0367351957,
-0.3643918931,
0.0348929316,
-0.0187816247,
-0.3134425282,
0.2730119824,
-0.1830270141,
0.3849768043,
-0.3222260475,
-0.6163319349,
-0.2944010794,
-0.0645798668,
0.3858156204,
-0.4091354311,
0.6278671622,
0.5771683455,
-0.4894914627,
-0.306548357,
-0.270100385,
-0.0110918088,
-0.3613848388,
0.2897636592,
-0.3159328401,
-0.2520498037,
0.5291526914,
-0.1893795729,
0.0528656654,
0.4526778758,
0.2783124149,
0.2179121822,
1.0531510115,
0.5022073388,
0.3313497007,
0.1957976222,
-0.2548194528,
0.1454194039,
-0.9929158092,
-0.223097533,
-0.495855391,
-0.3701705337,
-0.317448616,
-0.2170031667,
-0.1364142299,
0.3145767748,
0.2595154345,
0.4421821237,
-0.4626080692,
0.4626305699,
0.2532396317,
0.0211622622,
0.3191492856,
0.0576103292,
-0.3633810878,
-0.1021373868,
-0.6614870429,
-0.7444553971,
1.1872947216,
0.2317048758,
0.3847089112,
0.0500278883,
0.3784028888,
0.2285044193,
0.5972077847,
-0.7731250525,
0.5135085583,
-0.0983428061,
-0.535358727,
0.1134298146,
-0.5457420349,
-0.6998941302,
0.7185760736,
-0.4730889201,
-1.0086641312,
0.3697974086,
-0.1178654358,
-0.5096283555,
0.2344183475,
-0.7289050221,
1.324966073,
-0.2254022509,
-0.2019952238,
-0.3363681138,
-0.627504468,
0.1983654499,
-0.0486544818,
-0.1353938282,
-0.2170244604,
0.2242937386,
0.8208836913,
-0.1226692051,
0.5807333589,
-0.139612332,
0.0544356368,
0.0968981832,
-0.1002107188,
-0.0179585665,
0.1625776291,
-0.5067825913,
0.700682044,
0.0927793384,
-0.2539488375,
-1.0160602331,
0.5519838929,
-0.4380629957,
-0.1281310022,
-0.5378757715,
-0.5346008539,
-0.172675848,
0.1777243018,
0.3352953196,
0.5668993592,
-0.2136286348,
0.24981305,
0.38208583,
-0.2554854751,
0.3031931818,
0.5083015561,
-0.3453296125,
-0.3922730982,
0.6621959209,
-0.0440323278,
0.2272666246,
-0.05137714,
-0.0200044736,
-0.1775015146,
-1.1279325485,
-0.2149487138,
-0.0912267342,
-0.8951118588,
-0.0991728455,
-0.4391278923,
-0.1495784521,
-0.0701519921,
0.1972295046,
-0.274296701,
-0.3041042984,
-0.1056524664,
-0.0448698401,
0.0192089807,
0.5176804662,
-0.3405206501,
0.5812290311,
-0.6828514338,
0.3025593758,
0.1204226092,
0.6592873931,
0.2009258121,
-0.3787680864,
-0.1926133186,
0.0035078246,
-0.3151596785,
-0.9725326896,
0.2709523737,
0.1041236669,
0.7548629045,
0.2183119059,
-0.2211516351,
0.6347811222,
-0.449793756,
0.4681824446,
0.3595771492,
-1.0979766846,
0.4750765562,
0.1667666882,
-0.0805444196,
0.8432253599,
0.178451404,
-0.4931765199,
0.1616308838,
-0.8301733732,
-0.7989752889,
0.5543270707,
0.494230926,
-0.1421328038,
0.0849419013,
0.4924972653,
0.2405291647,
0.1307329684,
-0.6032974124,
-0.2047853172,
0.0096158776,
-0.1195750386,
-0.2063300014,
0.2800062895,
-0.2336954176,
-0.2287531644,
0.4035402536,
-0.3282248676,
0.1828113049,
0.0273143426,
-0.3231241703,
0.1196609363,
0.0944171399,
0.2669040859,
1.1432465315,
-0.3452567756,
0.075038828,
0.3396760523,
-0.3851427138,
-0.1283611059,
0.2341112792,
-0.235520497,
0.2907791734,
0.668081522,
0.8325573802,
0.0456729867,
-0.5715678334,
0.6228008866,
-0.3357911408,
-0.3764932454,
-0.0848259479,
-0.0316429436,
0.1076023132,
0.4061140716,
0.1555804312,
0.8090295196,
0.3394932747,
-0.2219144404,
0.4086931646,
0.2871367633,
-0.5103817582,
-0.3799331486,
0.3022799194,
-0.0798358694,
-0.3967689276,
0.697968483,
-0.2957793474,
-0.3631484807,
0.8492877483,
0.2378408015,
0.872148633,
0.0728531405,
0.2358667105,
0.2552793324,
0.4061336815,
-0.2793551087,
0.0744046718,
-0.032551948,
-0.8725081086,
-0.863948822,
-0.5938492417,
-0.3679004908,
0.1656849235,
-1.1613349915,
0.0997081548,
-0.2811026871,
-0.4250482023,
0.3646159768,
-0.1462576091,
-0.4062238336,
0.1100079268,
-0.0695811957,
1.2152644396,
-0.9330255985,
0.6317440867,
0.6611785889,
-0.3587968647,
-0.4273341298,
0.1831951737,
-0.1720214933,
-0.5258030295,
0.6415517926,
0.4673670232,
-0.035032507,
-0.2427270263,
-0.5169036984,
-0.4672592878,
0.9084628224,
0.4847222269,
-0.4027253389,
0.0779474825,
-0.3476940691,
0.8259804249,
-0.2521318495,
0.4116464555,
0.7490753531,
0.3815790415,
-0.0981924012,
-1.0766203403,
-0.0023713652,
-0.4761707485,
-0.1716529429,
-0.0782014132,
-0.1733111441,
0.6456005573,
-0.0296610631,
-0.11815162,
0.0979657397,
0.6592883468,
0.2565087974,
0.4363713264,
0.684890449,
0.6353960633,
0.5610566735,
0.0093327444,
0.5859560966,
-0.1916310191,
0.7187373638,
1.2427744865,
-0.3389225006,
0.8895888925,
0.5530685186,
-0.2196762711,
0.3926051557,
0.4533674121,
-0.2334193289,
0.573579967,
0.5053085685,
-0.0201108493,
-0.2314107418,
0.0598998778,
-0.4245377779,
0.3365124166,
0.2578657269,
-0.3087162971,
-0.5206209421,
-0.1553798616,
-0.4969146848,
0.017965531,
-0.0693071261,
0.5318481922,
0.2487674952,
-0.5877991915,
0.5322136879,
-0.1904539466,
0.6694915891,
-0.5095289946,
-0.4043736458,
0.0157984495,
0.2185883671,
-0.5492104292,
-0.656983614,
0.523445785,
0.0204162579,
0.0164762046,
-0.0381666459,
0.5698632598,
0.1426177174,
0.0852123797,
0.6601634622,
0.4689656794,
0.3284011781,
-0.0930791125,
-0.9224455357,
-0.0617698357,
-0.1828591973,
-0.1751709729,
0.3323566616,
0.1128056794,
0.2740527093,
0.618532598,
0.4612841308,
0.1764317006,
0.0259796884,
0.1746452749,
0.5873354673,
-0.3959683478,
-0.1717473865,
-0.8393462896,
0.4593653679,
-0.2717611492,
-0.6058157682,
0.7236573696,
0.3143327832,
0.6423648,
0.229607895,
0.5370723605,
-0.4257177114,
0.0029927213,
-0.5829538703,
0.6568698287,
-0.5534226298,
0.4144345522,
-0.3261484504,
-1.0897811651,
-0.3977532983,
1.1996760368,
-0.3970878124,
0.0353722014,
0.921384573,
0.5951556563,
-0.2176263183,
0.5063068867,
0.1108014807,
-0.1367927641,
0.0648594275,
0.3803279996,
1.1193526983,
-0.4951036572,
0.3619711101,
-0.3343429863,
-0.279543221,
-0.0143709118,
-1.2133853436,
-0.6558045745,
-0.2502266765,
-0.4191356599,
-0.4422521889,
0.1276802272,
0.6898708344,
0.8784629703,
-0.700979054,
-0.1568634361,
-0.2902496457,
-0.0001762404,
-0.8237300515,
-0.142392993,
0.3976053596,
-0.3833684027,
-0.3678689301,
0.50254035,
0.0295107849,
-0.2367002815,
-0.1307976246,
-0.186013788,
-0.0452266447,
-0.3739848137,
0.3470073044,
0.0587477982,
-0.4391409159,
-0.0901624784,
-0.0570470802,
0.0812276602,
0.2173713744,
0.5420373082,
-0.4275987446,
0.4892179966,
0.6596867442,
0.7896026373,
0.6412554979,
-0.2763182223,
0.5951527953,
-0.514097631,
-0.1183847487,
0.4866481125,
0.4244647324,
0.2563925087,
0.0965054259,
0.6319446564,
-0.091760017,
-0.5570499897,
-0.8128700852,
0.2271774709,
-1.0704866648,
-0.2688970268,
0.911998868,
-0.5382987261,
-0.0536147878,
-0.0158602223,
0.2258669138,
0.052372966,
0.0765493289,
0.5433199406,
0.8708229065,
-0.1756603271,
0.1618660986,
-1.005862236,
0.358807981,
0.6828069687,
-0.7226655483,
-0.069517687,
0.3336285949,
0.4339978993,
0.5701583028,
0.4238028526,
-0.2004121542,
0.4807780385,
0.1502094418,
0.3126395643,
0.2127560377,
-0.3324234188,
-0.9074574113,
0.0682929456,
0.1072252542,
0.0306966659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12596v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12596v3 | Learning to Speak from Text: Zero-Shot Multilingual Text-to-Speech with Unsupervised Text Pretraining | 2023-01-30T00:53:50 | 2023-05-27T15:15:39 | Takaaki Saeki, Soumi Maiti, Xinjian Li, Shinji Watanabe, Shinnosuke Takamichi, Hiroshi Saruwatari | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | While neural text-to-speech (TTS) has achieved human-like natural synthetic
speech, multilingual TTS systems are limited to resource-rich languages due to
the need for paired text and studio-quality audio data. This paper proposes a
method for zero-shot multilingual TTS using text-only data for the target
language. The use of text-only data allows the development of TTS systems for
low-resource languages for which only textual resources are available, making
TTS accessible to thousands of languages. Inspired by the strong cross-lingual
transferability of multilingual language models, our framework first performs
masked language model pretraining with multilingual text-only data. Then we
train this model with a paired data in a supervised manner, while freezing a
language-aware embedding layer. This allows inference even for languages not
included in the paired data but present in the text-only data. Evaluation
results demonstrate highly intelligible zero-shot TTS with a character error
rate of less than 12% for an unseen language. | [
0.0225319192,
-0.6466830969,
0.4767988622,
0.0467342697,
-0.5415048003,
0.4263691604,
-0.6253283024,
-0.2905442715,
0.44330585,
0.4719914198,
-0.5274922252,
-0.7291436791,
-0.3600091934,
0.1386359185,
-0.3658181131,
1.0656888485,
0.2102288604,
0.2326850295,
0.0996888354,
-0.1154424027,
-0.3551472723,
-0.6161856055,
-0.4526749551,
-0.1162955761,
0.5581616759,
0.7071396112,
0.3335901797,
0.5161340237,
-0.4587988853,
0.1721781492,
0.2696265876,
-0.0084728794,
-0.4055483043,
0.191209048,
-0.0526329838,
-0.415592283,
-0.0386616476,
-0.1964622587,
0.5261620283,
0.5499236584,
0.0365290977,
0.0902043954,
-0.1264401674,
0.061876148,
-0.6759707332,
0.0516175702,
-0.7256718874,
0.2697220445,
-0.3621880114,
-0.294890672,
-0.7488569617,
0.0871616006,
0.0716086924,
-0.7033865452,
0.132736966,
-0.2520885766,
0.348790139,
0.1819795817,
-0.4504730701,
0.0812996104,
-0.7419716716,
0.9006317258,
-0.4912108481,
0.7072504163,
0.498098433,
0.062319424,
0.546192944,
-0.507098794,
-0.5534976721,
-0.1967518926,
-0.0622113161,
0.3137747943,
0.0042430642,
-0.1635331213,
-0.0721320808,
-0.1709315479,
-0.8528325558,
0.1587669253,
-0.3037134707,
-0.1727745831,
0.4104129076,
-0.4010640979,
0.2848356962,
-0.1484519541,
-0.4075016677,
-0.2280602902,
-0.4461294413,
-0.2135778964,
0.1449565291,
0.935003221,
-0.5130625367,
0.6036766768,
0.0299518909,
0.5848104358,
-0.2483926266,
-0.202269569,
0.2734654546,
-0.1939461976,
-0.3256662786,
0.434573859,
1.0121241808,
-0.0729814246,
0.5986824632,
-0.6488547921,
0.0079121999,
0.0689125657,
-0.0838365033,
-0.6789307594,
-0.022222884,
-0.0066525671,
0.0543035716,
-0.2515103221,
-0.3256729245,
-0.8789402246,
-0.2872769237,
-0.0813183412,
0.5671479702,
-0.2690842748,
-0.5655890703,
0.0071814447,
-0.0200859979,
-0.1643349677,
-0.1877778172,
-0.9540948868,
0.0974803939,
0.0051257322,
0.816588223,
-0.0794080719,
-0.4800530374,
-0.7112053633,
0.4575307667,
-0.5993262529,
0.6716058254,
-0.2305687517,
-0.4366430342,
0.1767151952,
-0.1624267548,
-0.1244994998,
-0.0947425514,
0.4456647635,
-0.1337411404,
0.1212732792,
0.2756622136,
-0.3395960331,
0.1221496761,
-0.0822063088,
-0.3061852753,
0.8921800256,
-0.140956074,
-0.3592547476,
0.2144999653,
-0.5993875265,
-0.8460441232,
0.1246784851,
-0.3439331651,
-0.2681043744,
0.0801682994,
0.330968231,
0.4838880897,
-0.1155879498,
0.5538097024,
-0.0190401338,
-0.1663528681,
0.0035702891,
-0.849190414,
0.5790579319,
0.1595369726,
-0.4196286201,
-0.0421678312,
-0.7932569385,
0.415222317,
0.3356620371,
0.0614856072,
-0.1321145743,
-0.2636319995,
0.5483633876,
0.2162612379,
-0.0001459253,
-0.8506900072,
-0.096010536,
-0.57389009,
0.4401533008,
0.4500392079,
-0.3260651231,
0.5381555557,
-0.1698586643,
0.4434416294,
-0.0311027914,
-0.2732300162,
-0.7580093741,
-0.3796287477,
-0.720415175,
-0.4049549699,
0.4497480989,
0.7864900231,
-1.2307335138,
0.1815278232,
-0.265989542,
-0.3443926573,
-0.5911631584,
-0.0551374443,
0.8161919117,
0.5266394615,
0.5430903435,
0.0103116231,
-0.5151551962,
-0.6785889864,
-0.3211528361,
-0.172772631,
-0.2191809267,
0.0447100215,
0.0984318778,
0.3295912445,
0.771506846,
-0.381444782,
-0.2299283892,
-0.3007633686,
0.274320513,
-0.0996591598,
0.4478347003,
0.506677568,
-0.4291029871,
-0.730260253,
0.0258635152,
-0.7432672977,
0.0355928801,
-0.093543373,
0.0548532531,
0.5179291368,
0.572363019,
-0.3676275015,
0.4848190844,
0.7310814261,
-0.2267426401,
0.1931084692,
-0.3288683593,
-0.0484808497,
-1.1766680479,
0.178727597,
0.0099446848,
-0.5043415427,
-1.1785588264,
-0.2621655464,
-0.0107545061,
-0.6451610327,
-0.7971126437,
0.8634708524,
-0.4343807399,
-0.1047285646,
-0.100148797,
0.21702452,
0.0441589803,
0.7137358785,
0.5092177987,
0.758856833,
0.7126301527,
-0.3837170601,
0.1584723145,
0.4298575819,
-0.3003354073,
0.6783457398,
-0.359431386,
0.3987698853,
-0.2843087316,
0.1037646011,
-0.7091071606,
-0.0613519289,
0.1820318103,
-0.7579994798,
0.5718326569,
-0.1799445897,
-0.4073289037,
0.144159779,
-0.0273315404,
0.4893303514,
0.2017521113,
-0.5293139219,
0.4151879847,
0.4574072361,
-0.2898451984,
-0.6222240925,
-0.9666665196,
0.4048514664,
0.1350617707,
-0.2635141611,
0.4108359516,
-0.13045609,
0.30933249,
-0.1781561971,
-0.0151096452,
-0.6102021337,
-0.3401165605,
-0.0293733403,
0.171251744,
-0.1428188384,
0.3847285211,
-0.057902012,
-0.3747085333,
-0.3925093412,
-0.4787802994,
0.5527229905,
0.3244383335,
-0.375392884,
-0.6154986024,
0.7346083522,
0.6065439582,
-0.2162920535,
0.5077462792,
0.5648365617,
-0.3549772501,
-0.2594578266,
-0.3099800646,
-0.2009816915,
-0.3940492868,
0.4591282904,
-0.3571084142,
-0.7400925159,
0.0819939077,
0.2611183822,
0.0286776163,
0.1946007609,
0.2583504617,
0.0223868284,
0.8548226953,
0.939899385,
-0.1774912924,
0.4756804705,
-0.088202998,
0.2384289354,
-0.201954022,
-0.3209668398,
-0.5527125597,
0.0011711499,
-0.5045261383,
-0.4446368515,
0.3847161233,
-0.0481556058,
-0.4460186958,
0.3693593442,
-0.4125300646,
0.595605731,
0.617223978,
0.1503492892,
0.3350392878,
0.4371049404,
-0.29123348,
-0.2062153071,
-0.8266401887,
-0.1750810891,
1.196148634,
-0.018544754,
0.3884221613,
-0.1270039231,
0.5550469756,
0.0037438336,
0.0378905721,
-0.8867383003,
0.277464956,
-0.4968542755,
-0.7055604458,
-0.4715889692,
-0.4341042936,
-0.6792546511,
0.1558029652,
-0.4203108549,
-0.751134634,
-0.1459282041,
-0.0878318176,
-0.4169012904,
0.5368382335,
-0.8550806046,
0.6872177124,
-0.406884551,
-0.2926505506,
0.0480835065,
-0.6742168069,
0.1307911426,
-0.3889722824,
0.3145299554,
-0.0191674512,
0.0311638862,
0.7518425584,
-0.1101594567,
0.9640257955,
-0.1945792139,
-0.0084835161,
0.2014065236,
-0.0159159061,
0.1677044034,
0.0526961647,
-0.0602635108,
0.4999017417,
0.0672863275,
-0.4992189109,
-0.4461579621,
0.4360870123,
-0.7518870234,
-0.1301098317,
-0.4970375001,
-0.232614845,
-0.6236327887,
0.4520011842,
0.427993983,
0.5753418207,
-0.2749272883,
0.1874942034,
0.5555984378,
-0.4036296308,
0.8680361509,
0.7803297639,
-0.3005456328,
-0.5907586813,
1.1366455555,
0.1802834868,
0.2660396993,
0.6661447883,
0.1449338049,
-0.6263890266,
-0.3109480143,
-0.9959074855,
0.2511150539,
-0.2827264369,
-0.2603035271,
-0.6099202037,
-0.3258596361,
-0.4338174164,
-0.2359784842,
-0.7381219864,
-0.4009419084,
-0.4633847177,
-0.1762367338,
0.3055529296,
0.3973073065,
-0.2110310942,
0.4415890872,
-0.9174300432,
0.5586117506,
0.2268849611,
0.3330838084,
-0.1775001585,
-0.568772018,
-0.2460107356,
0.2809518874,
0.0603338517,
-0.7937213182,
0.6719237566,
0.4435815513,
0.31211707,
0.3188500702,
0.2440744638,
0.667873323,
-0.6481035352,
0.6546350718,
0.683080256,
-1.1420375109,
0.5303816199,
-0.3147703409,
0.4632453322,
0.4354962111,
0.2127277106,
-0.7817568183,
-0.1596434116,
-0.37578547,
-0.5890748501,
0.9467931986,
0.2400230765,
0.3906948566,
0.1996988058,
0.2127921432,
0.0155507587,
0.2953610122,
-0.9560028911,
-0.4672647417,
-0.4869091213,
-0.3429816365,
-0.5146531463,
-0.021019917,
-0.041826047,
-0.0925612077,
0.5138551593,
-0.3237999976,
0.2338579446,
0.089161925,
-0.2170924842,
-0.1732467413,
0.3950226903,
0.6864697933,
0.344073981,
-0.0411321074,
0.166807279,
0.0941933095,
-0.4884353876,
0.4541040659,
0.0360657424,
-0.2901823521,
0.3005008996,
0.2865962684,
1.051076889,
0.4905848801,
-0.6077712178,
0.7127711773,
-0.0070082294,
-0.2723822594,
-0.1875672042,
-0.5383318067,
-0.0890326947,
0.0394439809,
0.2877506614,
0.0312968418,
-0.5118652582,
-0.5969316363,
0.4066007733,
0.2647460997,
-0.6174574494,
-0.4465844929,
0.7421140671,
0.2305656075,
-0.3926921189,
0.3313094079,
0.1080029979,
-0.1548462957,
0.2796607614,
0.8614898324,
0.9110012054,
-0.5185540915,
0.6976484656,
0.2957875133,
0.1929685771,
0.091749981,
0.2874142528,
-0.246638909,
-0.7221531868,
-0.6772984862,
-0.5482422113,
-0.403845489,
0.3440345824,
-0.4753925502,
0.3965602219,
-0.3563776016,
0.0275274254,
0.112347059,
-0.2669152915,
-0.4267528355,
0.44818151,
0.3692862988,
0.5091179609,
-0.8986856341,
1.0143110752,
0.3427721858,
-0.2204902917,
-0.6338466406,
-0.1239738315,
-0.0962908193,
-1.0493336916,
0.4371108115,
0.0900464877,
-0.2183116674,
0.3405746818,
-0.4122700691,
-0.7774769664,
0.6106148362,
0.9377256036,
-0.4246096611,
0.0050674747,
0.4712890089,
0.3399955332,
-0.1641483009,
0.363794744,
0.2060227841,
0.3303698599,
0.3640357554,
-1.0394480228,
-0.506262362,
-0.0071395435,
-0.3115095496,
0.0254009869,
-0.5095769763,
0.6934351921,
-0.0841181576,
-0.4703457952,
-0.154791221,
0.3729337454,
-0.0259724781,
0.3802478611,
0.315924108,
0.5156291723,
0.6260226965,
0.0858139098,
0.6216628551,
-0.3514622152,
0.119629316,
1.1912026405,
-0.3586961627,
1.1012022495,
0.2464829087,
0.1556808949,
-0.0017307687,
0.302016288,
0.3894769251,
0.7945278287,
-0.0084003741,
-0.7087152004,
-0.2311836332,
-0.5030248761,
-0.2213909924,
0.8639418483,
-0.0277835485,
-0.0060382108,
-0.309766233,
0.30147627,
0.2234683931,
0.2264769822,
-0.1065441221,
0.7201157212,
0.0194673352,
-0.3818750679,
0.7480006218,
0.0793207809,
0.8837323785,
-0.7101964951,
0.1002478004,
-0.0653494149,
-0.1587953269,
-0.0440765247,
-0.598017633,
0.3572967649,
0.5283999443,
-0.1771807522,
-0.6627411842,
0.5531743169,
-0.7705749273,
-0.5387696624,
0.5142751336,
0.8636923432,
0.2687932551,
-0.2491824776,
-0.3797007501,
-0.2495049834,
-0.0163018573,
0.0434333198,
0.4431164265,
0.291764766,
0.1228577718,
0.3931742311,
0.7545551658,
0.1300916523,
-0.0321337543,
0.2391618192,
0.5566814542,
-0.6082886457,
-0.6307259202,
-0.6716201901,
0.5036223531,
0.1097359955,
-0.2993108034,
0.472197026,
0.5684030056,
0.9500213861,
0.0494665653,
0.9841960073,
0.3159198165,
0.6514111161,
-0.5568683743,
1.1605428457,
-0.5521172285,
-0.4001738429,
-0.225980863,
-0.6650795341,
-0.4736624658,
0.5523797274,
0.1853748411,
-0.1060176492,
0.6621833444,
0.6551472545,
0.1950615048,
-0.0024243584,
1.0690327883,
0.0268776082,
0.0442413613,
0.5341356993,
0.5200763345,
-0.499063313,
0.7515918612,
-0.1939939409,
-0.2020264566,
0.1953989267,
-0.9483028054,
-0.9245727062,
-0.691552043,
-0.1292262077,
0.0760467649,
0.1111963317,
0.6774200797,
1.008258462,
-0.8157371879,
-0.404607743,
0.0088417502,
-0.0221396238,
0.2307984233,
-0.0956495628,
0.2499128431,
-0.1890849024,
-0.8330336809,
1.0578804016,
0.3838450015,
0.2537781298,
-0.1337172687,
0.0516154505,
-0.2416832447,
0.1143709794,
0.7198084593,
0.6434619427,
-0.3945416808,
-0.1859001219,
0.1232408434,
0.1293178201,
0.1678914577,
0.7567953467,
-0.7780019641,
0.7793741822,
0.1159054488,
0.6582376361,
0.8456327319,
-0.5081054568,
0.5448778272,
-1.3193255663,
0.7401554585,
0.3454788029,
-0.0009443876,
0.3935805559,
-0.0785028711,
0.0858531147,
0.2064451724,
-0.1187011302,
-0.8425481319,
0.1434168816,
-0.7422214746,
-0.3078858852,
0.9209443331,
-0.1843486577,
0.0382557996,
-0.1727380902,
-0.018524373,
0.7231016159,
-0.3789837062,
0.3860837817,
0.2905274928,
0.2174859047,
-0.4900698662,
-0.5433681607,
0.4146874249,
0.3983651698,
-0.8298944831,
0.0574530177,
0.2576150596,
0.0051634256,
0.1314243972,
0.8305804133,
0.1027657613,
-0.1378724873,
0.0753729269,
0.1630388647,
-0.1738354564,
-0.7049141526,
-0.4777932465,
0.1820902973,
-0.4883204103,
-0.4715504944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12586v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12586v2 | Unifying Molecular and Textual Representations via Multi-task Language Modelling | 2023-01-29T23:56:45 | 2023-05-18T00:37:00 | Dimitrios Christofidellis, Giorgio Giannone, Jannis Born, Ole Winther, Teodoro Laino, Matteo Manica | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The recent advances in neural language models have also been successfully
applied to the field of chemistry, offering generative solutions for classical
problems in molecular design and synthesis planning. These new methods have the
potential to fuel a new era of data-driven automation in scientific discovery.
However, specialized models are still typically required for each task, leading
to the need for problem-specific fine-tuning and neglecting task
interrelations. The main obstacle in this field is the lack of a unified
representation between natural language and chemical representations,
complicating and limiting human-machine interaction. Here, we propose the first
multi-domain, multi-task language model that can solve a wide range of tasks in
both the chemical and natural language domains. Our model can handle chemical
and natural language concurrently, without requiring expensive pre-training on
single domains or task-specific models. Interestingly, sharing weights across
domains remarkably improves our model when benchmarked against state-of-the-art
baselines on single-domain and cross-domain tasks. In particular, sharing
information across domains and tasks gives rise to large improvements in
cross-domain tasks, the magnitude of which increase with scale, as measured by
more than a dozen of relevant metrics. Our work suggests that such models can
robustly and efficiently accelerate discovery in physical sciences by
superseding problem-specific fine-tuning and enhancing human-model
interactions. | [
-0.2591711581,
-0.433003217,
0.8945739865,
0.2041880041,
0.1923628747,
0.2691903114,
-0.5975469947,
-0.4836070836,
-0.0257071406,
0.369741112,
-0.5259326696,
-0.5032921433,
-0.7616254687,
0.172209993,
-0.1390528679,
0.7883437276,
-0.243361935,
0.1829228103,
-0.4657374918,
0.0173494834,
-0.1371572912,
-0.6647219658,
-0.2747739553,
-0.6646031737,
0.6288517118,
0.0383816659,
0.4670901597,
0.358712852,
0.5191903114,
0.347643435,
0.0573078841,
0.412044704,
-0.0508726388,
0.1131396368,
-0.3908126652,
-0.2960763574,
-0.5457877517,
0.0727941617,
0.3746198118,
1.2799254656,
0.0511520132,
-0.1689789742,
0.2358330935,
0.5786175132,
-0.3651177585,
0.5290511847,
-0.5516453981,
-0.1909356266,
0.0361815095,
-0.1353758126,
-0.3314148188,
0.342405349,
0.4736234248,
-1.0207523108,
0.4825639129,
-0.0610324964,
0.5850101709,
-0.0236489698,
-0.5897112489,
-0.2396053374,
-0.8756161928,
0.9799702168,
-0.558547616,
0.4375116229,
0.0616083741,
0.1903491914,
-0.3496943414,
-0.6252581477,
-0.566114068,
-0.4959425032,
-0.0824101791,
-0.1042234302,
-0.0803408623,
0.2711141109,
-0.2433429658,
0.1423524022,
-0.5960329175,
-0.2485353053,
-0.2503997982,
-0.2801254094,
0.4348056316,
0.1865261644,
0.5176220536,
0.0308280569,
-0.401740402,
-0.1315502822,
-0.446690917,
-0.3182998598,
0.028954545,
0.9252747893,
0.0566936359,
0.6681650281,
-0.0987608954,
0.3697644174,
-0.3006317914,
0.4929508567,
-0.0094587384,
-0.903468132,
-0.1321579665,
-0.2046106309,
0.9547015429,
0.1575215161,
0.3966394067,
-0.2988976836,
-0.0211469047,
0.4270028174,
0.3107100725,
-0.769531846,
-0.4224721789,
0.2594232261,
-0.1440480947,
0.0608336665,
-0.1517104059,
-0.7327482104,
-0.5900033712,
-0.6427218318,
0.5644235611,
-0.4557925463,
-0.3176104724,
0.4070385396,
-0.1808249503,
-0.7324928641,
0.3505725563,
-1.0831856728,
0.5762081742,
0.5355085731,
0.6709741354,
-0.2970550954,
-0.551032424,
-0.0493411757,
0.2007550597,
-0.1041789874,
0.7074094415,
-0.5881690979,
-0.1225458011,
-0.2981546521,
-0.0777691677,
-0.0727796555,
-0.667979002,
0.0760420561,
-0.217759639,
-0.007859786,
-0.3045243025,
-0.528228581,
-0.0741236359,
-0.0114138285,
-0.8151090741,
0.8690876961,
0.1584151387,
-0.3977614343,
0.2125149369,
-0.9048751593,
-0.3387010992,
-0.0852678716,
-0.200542137,
-0.3196589351,
0.1326797456,
0.1245214492,
0.5613855124,
-0.7299002409,
0.5838010907,
-0.3090871274,
0.070674181,
0.2935329974,
-0.1607264578,
0.3614455163,
-0.1142567769,
-0.160571292,
0.2286637723,
-0.6506743431,
-0.0139911352,
-0.1090786234,
-0.3802866042,
-0.500454843,
-0.115278177,
0.5155709386,
0.3774994016,
0.408580929,
-0.6646666527,
0.2920570374,
-0.2962892056,
0.4562804103,
0.4978049099,
-0.1703750193,
0.867401123,
-0.2463370562,
0.1595624387,
0.2225840241,
-0.254254669,
-0.1224874407,
-0.5310303569,
-0.4079735279,
-0.1823755056,
0.1708642542,
0.2721437812,
-0.3778765798,
0.1619710624,
-0.3422701061,
-0.5038418174,
-0.5197649002,
0.4437428713,
0.3945130706,
0.1287305206,
0.6963131428,
-0.2578404844,
-0.5829102993,
-0.9395477772,
-0.61744982,
0.1492547542,
-0.1588111222,
0.2407954782,
0.5906417966,
-0.478494823,
0.8126839995,
-0.3145516217,
-0.3743814528,
-0.3114170432,
0.6342868209,
0.2137463689,
0.537620306,
0.282528162,
-0.9355005026,
-0.6439563632,
0.4325138927,
-0.8833740354,
0.0643245429,
0.0049492009,
-0.2581268549,
0.0414089859,
0.2463917583,
-0.7601128817,
0.1894031912,
0.4159690142,
-0.2217347026,
0.362064898,
-0.3731650114,
0.1647350043,
-0.9257238507,
0.2187440097,
0.3213311136,
0.062708497,
-1.0444760323,
-0.0748433694,
0.140005812,
-0.275159955,
-0.3949008286,
0.7532362938,
-0.6671416759,
0.2904348969,
-0.3814946413,
-0.1389104128,
0.2154814005,
0.7864372134,
0.2339745015,
0.6414521337,
0.781662941,
-0.787419796,
0.0179545544,
0.031147873,
0.0450335853,
0.3963542283,
-0.6878301501,
-0.1064429134,
-0.2066170126,
0.1286296248,
-0.817547977,
-0.3367410302,
-0.0293916073,
-0.3432757556,
0.313705802,
-0.0602072254,
-0.4774218202,
-0.0972855836,
-0.0886789858,
0.5679909587,
-0.0424692072,
-0.3297901154,
1.0497868061,
0.4657810628,
-0.2005585432,
-0.2687990367,
-0.6449795961,
-0.0317575037,
0.0360014923,
-0.7211276889,
0.9318310022,
-0.2559856474,
-0.0213439576,
0.0130408406,
-0.4487605691,
-0.3497580588,
-0.1331945211,
0.2263968885,
0.2825580537,
0.0126723275,
0.3308573067,
-0.1113023311,
-0.1823284179,
0.0502346456,
-0.6543717384,
0.5648601055,
-0.1299453825,
0.0174097531,
-0.5153441429,
0.8300776482,
0.9334530234,
-0.2708242536,
0.7754737139,
0.2661979198,
-0.7425426245,
-0.3015143871,
0.0633298606,
-0.4834389091,
-0.4972270131,
0.4458882809,
-0.3032179177,
-0.8057560921,
0.3791707754,
-0.4087640047,
-0.1155577824,
0.3324121237,
0.544314146,
-0.1565165818,
0.9823771119,
0.930198431,
0.202640906,
0.2437806875,
-0.1671845913,
0.3676126301,
-0.707871139,
-0.2985519767,
-0.4126796126,
-0.1778118312,
-0.2486744523,
-0.5919379592,
0.7533304095,
-0.0243375842,
-0.308009088,
0.7282411456,
-0.5460893512,
0.4183022976,
0.580709219,
0.0983726606,
0.2402139306,
0.2612616122,
-0.5203778744,
-0.101041235,
-0.6499767303,
-0.5965711474,
1.4098110199,
-0.043215517,
0.8148491383,
-0.0566388294,
0.6819459796,
0.1064261049,
0.1563308835,
-0.3782898784,
0.4497477114,
-0.3458118439,
-0.744479537,
-0.3338615,
-0.5876622796,
-1.0170373917,
0.325148344,
-0.3288048506,
-0.7754280567,
0.0500651188,
0.1152756736,
-0.303165704,
0.2394560277,
-0.7626561522,
1.0199724436,
-0.140907079,
-0.5282330513,
-0.2261376381,
-0.5173978209,
0.1452089101,
-0.1644221693,
0.3274430633,
-0.3094200194,
0.1531345099,
0.5877016783,
-0.346156925,
0.8221508265,
0.0602053292,
-0.106679678,
0.1874021739,
0.224871546,
0.2254969329,
-0.0805118233,
-0.0624115802,
0.0669750348,
-0.0039588735,
-0.4226403236,
-0.6645303369,
0.8359825611,
-0.5807759166,
-0.2812936604,
-0.3993468881,
-0.872486949,
-0.2879648805,
0.3158103228,
0.0595344231,
0.2893342078,
-0.1555014998,
-0.2213616371,
0.5224973559,
-0.1840756238,
0.3514617682,
0.5046491027,
-0.0790645704,
-0.0695423707,
1.0544688702,
-0.1332178414,
0.3549477756,
0.6790739298,
-0.0260937475,
-0.3063700199,
-0.2529040575,
-0.1458994746,
0.263822794,
-0.5978123546,
-0.0531785116,
-0.8560546041,
-0.0159742273,
-0.3428636491,
0.0628113151,
-0.6935012937,
-0.5414515138,
-0.3683648407,
0.1121794656,
0.4483951926,
0.8282184005,
-0.1626716405,
0.1503320485,
-0.8358507156,
0.7520436645,
0.1445272863,
0.4523377717,
0.031234663,
0.1382694393,
-0.4704220295,
0.1464602202,
-0.2418665439,
-0.8362029195,
0.4770309925,
0.2790580988,
0.5336607695,
-0.402395606,
-0.157994166,
0.3036318421,
-0.5682103634,
0.4928957224,
0.1423204839,
-0.9728103876,
0.3677470982,
-0.5000920892,
0.2510415018,
0.3774074316,
0.6059551835,
-0.619099915,
-0.267624408,
-0.2665506005,
-1.0562764406,
0.438862294,
0.340860337,
-0.137645334,
0.0834570155,
0.0253979713,
0.1529403627,
0.2687284648,
-0.63850981,
-0.3450956047,
-0.0351122618,
-0.4127756357,
0.0145346681,
0.4006036818,
-0.1011001915,
-0.3931111097,
0.6857947707,
-0.2725377381,
0.4480033517,
0.1342293322,
-0.2174735516,
-0.0613012575,
0.4625314176,
0.3682309091,
0.2987290919,
-0.0927124619,
0.4362925887,
-0.3374580443,
-0.4501622021,
0.2826886475,
0.4517209828,
0.3618868291,
-0.0179818757,
0.1698610336,
0.4789867699,
0.2877976,
-0.8217918873,
0.1762963533,
-0.0373461023,
-0.1560721099,
0.2596998215,
-0.090662472,
0.4387992918,
0.2778657675,
0.4222688079,
0.6012765765,
0.1697814912,
-0.6972401142,
0.4033531249,
0.4559914172,
-0.1587348282,
-0.3810687065,
0.9847474098,
0.0449990295,
-0.0256675351,
0.241176635,
-0.21206972,
-0.6478957534,
0.6349580884,
0.3374220431,
0.6988707185,
-0.177912429,
0.205336377,
0.2917790413,
0.1645124555,
-0.0917916149,
0.5202979445,
-0.0313144624,
-0.6932756305,
-0.0336223207,
-0.556979537,
-0.3203865588,
-0.1215626746,
-0.3205333948,
-0.0234595258,
-0.3912192285,
-0.2048947811,
0.6657511592,
0.0859433487,
-0.7595878839,
0.1396320462,
0.0879567564,
0.4112567604,
-0.7348932028,
0.9180612564,
0.6583818793,
-0.418628186,
-0.4272222221,
-0.271037668,
0.2258848399,
-0.2402146012,
0.7095881701,
0.2492945194,
-0.2445247918,
-0.1285306662,
-0.3014978468,
-1.0211161375,
0.8993920684,
0.3518313169,
-0.6045027375,
-0.0353343152,
0.5001518726,
0.75909549,
-0.5375091434,
-0.0682241097,
0.4526092708,
0.4890733659,
-0.1955787987,
-1.1070436239,
0.1409544796,
-0.7183375359,
-0.1185274199,
0.3278348148,
-0.151680842,
1.2807071209,
-0.1175927371,
-0.4669862986,
0.1577931792,
0.5709092021,
0.4063857496,
0.2358660996,
0.0483696721,
0.3327720761,
0.8794946074,
-0.0874596536,
1.0611222982,
-0.5161219239,
0.3630031049,
1.0822380781,
-0.6381272078,
0.598816216,
0.6307681203,
-0.2719284892,
0.3080856204,
0.2132045031,
0.1404802501,
0.5607335567,
0.4756820202,
-0.6411887407,
-0.3769319057,
-0.3220107555,
-0.04505454,
-0.0382375084,
0.5294904709,
-0.189782232,
-0.3174602985,
0.2812919915,
-0.2725165784,
0.4631965756,
-0.1096655428,
0.3752071559,
0.0524567924,
-0.7225943804,
0.5430846214,
0.2441566437,
0.8465244174,
-0.5754609108,
-0.1979284436,
0.1219724789,
0.2616325617,
0.1216486171,
-0.6162338853,
0.168430537,
-0.2510393858,
-0.4820938706,
-0.4473665655,
0.6836947203,
-0.9761762619,
-0.4178413451,
0.7122622132,
0.5700677633,
-0.2321133763,
-0.4923066497,
-0.3804666996,
-0.0257068258,
-0.2951528132,
0.0758641288,
0.2660702169,
0.3177115619,
-0.2029677331,
0.7437280416,
0.6872829795,
-0.2307318896,
0.2771605551,
-0.0424953401,
0.9966914654,
-0.7979335189,
-0.1789312661,
-0.6449271441,
0.5161549449,
0.1594531238,
-0.0732266158,
0.4676988125,
0.6173893809,
0.729683578,
-0.4408680499,
1.034574151,
0.2287738621,
0.3431931436,
-0.4010846615,
0.7850363851,
-0.7358731627,
0.1744336039,
-0.2667971253,
-0.5938031673,
-0.5224893689,
0.3537538648,
0.2283533514,
0.1538195908,
0.9662063718,
0.9459046721,
-0.3498336375,
0.086050041,
0.0038238333,
0.0796399564,
0.376349926,
0.9583023787,
0.6346051693,
-0.4648516476,
0.2668014765,
-0.2707997262,
0.0219102595,
0.1577237695,
-0.6722354293,
-1.0401256084,
-0.9164833426,
-0.2666892111,
-0.0157711692,
-0.0138961738,
1.177221179,
0.9189639091,
-0.8452154398,
-0.5020232797,
-0.5727556348,
-0.2045409083,
-0.2824199498,
-0.1577644348,
0.1709376723,
-0.2177287787,
-0.8880488873,
0.8582418561,
0.4660312235,
0.2943164408,
-0.3202734292,
-0.0669326037,
-0.4022759199,
0.1968026459,
0.5491252542,
0.3344886899,
-0.7189933658,
0.2411049753,
0.2865196168,
-0.3080593944,
0.1802113503,
0.987364769,
-0.7567654848,
0.509865284,
0.3747058809,
0.7333713174,
0.616092205,
-0.5827815533,
1.0313905478,
-0.9803850651,
-0.1215679049,
0.2420096099,
0.391836971,
0.4662909508,
-0.3283628523,
0.3112479448,
0.2152704149,
-0.3271495402,
-0.5514163971,
0.3205736279,
-1.2122632265,
-0.611770153,
0.657136023,
0.1011041179,
-0.2211213708,
-0.0981259346,
-0.0841522738,
0.4323893189,
-0.5423476696,
0.677411437,
0.8796746731,
-0.2592601478,
0.0456541553,
-0.4943310916,
0.5740599632,
0.5978553295,
-1.0449641943,
0.5639944077,
0.3280976713,
0.1057610214,
0.4470568299,
0.4611086249,
0.019754352,
0.2055413574,
-0.1982665062,
0.2130165547,
-0.0409591757,
-0.9286577702,
-0.1883123815,
0.0976711065,
-0.358725369,
0.2237861305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12568v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12568v1 | Schema-Guided Semantic Accuracy: Faithfulness in Task-Oriented Dialogue Response Generation | 2023-01-29T22:32:48 | 2023-01-29T22:32:48 | Jinghong Chen, Weizhe Lin, Bill Byrne | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ensuring that generated utterances are faithful to dialogue actions is
crucial for Task-Oriented Dialogue Response Generation. Slot Error Rate (SER)
only partially measures generation quality in that it solely assesses
utterances generated from non-categorical slots whose values are expected to be
reproduced exactly. Utterances generated from categorical slots, which are more
variable, are not assessed by SER. We propose Schema-Guided Semantic Accuracy
(SGSAcc) to evaluate utterances generated from both categorical and
non-categorical slots by recognizing textual entailment. We show that SGSAcc
can be applied to evaluate utterances generated from a wide range of dialogue
actions in the Schema Guided Dialogue (SGD) dataset with good agreement with
human judgment. We also identify a previously overlooked weakness in generating
faithful utterances from categorical slots in unseen domains. We show that
prefix tuning applied to T5 generation can address this problem. We further
build an ensemble of prefix-tuning and fine-tuning models that achieves the
lowest SER reported and high SGSAcc on the SGD dataset. | [
-0.118106842,
-0.645740509,
0.5913978219,
0.1536364406,
-0.2021657377,
0.0219414309,
-0.0944013074,
-0.0849094093,
-0.0012761657,
0.6759721041,
-0.8161919713,
-0.6445970535,
-0.4972817004,
0.3344299793,
-0.2539145947,
0.748149097,
0.2198391557,
0.3024135232,
-0.4611634314,
-0.1362334788,
-0.424796015,
-0.1955337673,
-0.6569467783,
0.0857927129,
0.2018505931,
0.5222535729,
0.4766840637,
0.6151763201,
0.5303675532,
0.3036459684,
-0.0211730283,
0.6743806601,
-0.5878585577,
0.279301852,
-0.4164631963,
-0.2302141041,
-0.6724791527,
-0.3081585467,
0.5277456641,
0.6878828406,
-0.5646593571,
0.0676323324,
0.2515801489,
0.1622934192,
-0.381478101,
0.4360292852,
-1.0305403471,
-0.1906392425,
-0.1263108999,
-0.4824253023,
-0.6520965099,
-0.3929227293,
0.0399898328,
-0.903691411,
0.7484391332,
0.1668956876,
0.9752489328,
0.6748745441,
-0.2260532677,
-0.5084722638,
-0.5945916772,
0.8187091351,
-0.7896075249,
0.3525335789,
0.6122329235,
0.1675382853,
-0.6383778453,
-0.5864755511,
-0.5568233132,
0.1264506578,
0.0177152026,
0.2255045474,
0.0440199971,
0.4196546376,
0.6244781017,
0.251021564,
-0.4879052639,
-0.1206628978,
-0.3033669293,
-0.332387805,
0.622023046,
0.6123549342,
0.0410146862,
-0.3215305507,
-0.1706091315,
-0.1756841391,
-0.6178944707,
0.0392584652,
0.288469553,
0.4187214673,
0.4141956866,
0.6104787588,
-0.2698766291,
0.867449522,
0.4844379127,
-0.3964894414,
-0.0194027256,
-0.8754976392,
-0.1736946255,
0.0700331554,
0.5444496274,
0.5883558989,
0.0060544922,
-0.211622566,
-0.0119090313,
0.45882985,
0.7643381953,
-0.6720334291,
0.18395935,
0.1001102179,
-0.2810294032,
-0.2691687942,
0.0338406302,
-0.3828116953,
-0.1496274769,
-0.2368577272,
-0.0543539412,
-0.4895605743,
0.1010871679,
0.1860939264,
-0.1302197874,
0.4877101481,
0.4113189578,
-1.0168311596,
0.4330663085,
0.7410069108,
0.3553061783,
-0.130409047,
-0.1545154005,
-0.7877647281,
0.4595124125,
-0.4104243815,
0.8913231492,
-0.5451088548,
-0.7643890977,
-0.3404021263,
0.1001554877,
-0.1247236803,
-0.3639196157,
0.9391796589,
-0.1129079089,
-0.0344737731,
-0.3147786558,
-0.6253961325,
0.1026404202,
-0.220407337,
-0.2858664393,
0.9229001999,
0.4311359823,
-0.4939786494,
0.9452931285,
-0.5087915659,
-0.2580923736,
0.0809573308,
-0.194239676,
-0.3360404968,
0.2739826739,
0.1182332784,
0.2675502598,
-0.3206393719,
0.481659174,
-0.367623657,
-0.3476393819,
0.2034388036,
-0.3306549788,
0.2937115729,
0.1689804792,
-0.1858927906,
0.147615388,
-0.8502397537,
0.31306234,
-0.2282894552,
0.0864066929,
-0.3070863485,
0.2161347568,
-0.4108790755,
0.2405362725,
-0.0856932029,
-0.8365105987,
0.0062622479,
-0.5465974212,
0.4408742487,
0.872105062,
0.148955673,
0.3754441142,
-0.0833415687,
0.1471184492,
0.0549903587,
0.1358176619,
-0.0771958753,
-0.3987768888,
-0.8295090199,
-0.061042577,
0.4098517895,
0.3606735468,
-1.050955534,
0.6752249599,
-0.4165689945,
-0.5656339526,
-0.6954544783,
-0.1610357016,
0.504165709,
0.7675696015,
0.1521219909,
-0.9595550299,
-0.3322503269,
-0.8767876029,
-0.3729905486,
-0.3150958419,
-0.0882770568,
0.7115920782,
0.0535531193,
0.1089929044,
0.9649161696,
-0.5128748417,
-0.013124235,
0.0483576097,
0.2261573076,
-0.1508679688,
0.4328163266,
0.2184009701,
-0.3625873625,
-0.1746344119,
-0.2386148125,
-0.5093858838,
-0.2843761444,
0.0764595121,
-0.2710593045,
0.3655853271,
0.3171178102,
-0.7664527297,
0.6527548432,
0.1745778471,
-0.4902003109,
0.20831424,
-0.0490999632,
0.1333420128,
-1.1703982353,
-0.1423422545,
-0.2462708652,
-0.1559535563,
-0.595508039,
-0.2001885027,
-0.0017319402,
-0.0847623795,
-0.2782185972,
0.3207436204,
-0.015683122,
-0.5080930591,
-0.1172376722,
0.1665950418,
0.0653343797,
0.553742826,
0.0952239633,
0.9406965971,
0.1884659231,
-0.673545599,
0.2874622643,
0.6617183089,
-0.4710915685,
0.9399015903,
-0.7779923677,
0.2045270056,
-0.0315616317,
0.4870018959,
-0.9359341264,
-0.5142070055,
0.2876909673,
-0.4643466473,
0.2132872045,
0.2067825645,
-0.2768386304,
-0.1221237853,
0.1156336665,
0.2879272699,
0.3047055304,
-0.2636960149,
0.6408250332,
0.1747661531,
-0.3588221967,
-0.6904053688,
-0.348472178,
-0.1878875643,
0.1206670776,
-0.8173110485,
0.1814461797,
0.084106259,
0.1297381669,
-0.1449464113,
-0.4417010844,
0.2374229878,
0.1323885471,
0.4414681494,
0.1355303079,
-0.167091921,
-0.014828559,
0.1266516298,
-0.3345946074,
-0.0500431396,
-0.1830965281,
0.5638508201,
-0.0912960693,
-0.5738136172,
-0.3997863531,
0.2316248715,
0.4834544957,
-0.1687382162,
0.4069035053,
0.4048008025,
-0.0812298432,
-0.0963101983,
-0.3686949909,
-0.3208846748,
-0.4715743065,
0.1802504659,
-0.5278460383,
-0.8403258324,
0.4336095452,
-0.0542261526,
0.1690919697,
0.5238444805,
0.2939821482,
-0.1408203989,
1.1750950813,
0.3522486687,
0.5341988802,
0.1562281102,
0.1095543057,
0.4050163329,
-0.7172395587,
-0.1594081968,
-0.7904025316,
0.0676672533,
-0.7763041258,
-0.4675360322,
0.32954368,
-0.0759490058,
-0.1311043501,
0.455301702,
-0.2814219296,
0.2449989617,
0.5632596612,
0.0612496585,
0.3498248756,
0.2495687455,
-0.106931664,
-0.341140151,
-0.8028211594,
-0.4763384759,
0.8909184933,
0.1642628759,
0.8481894135,
-0.0405822285,
0.4980652034,
0.1675647199,
-0.1447809786,
-0.7414728999,
0.6462800503,
-0.2360293716,
-0.1145813242,
-0.4955691695,
-0.5087980032,
-0.7647217512,
0.0274950042,
-0.042889636,
-0.5720410943,
0.2924171686,
0.0678012073,
-0.5175819993,
-0.1257354766,
-0.46622473,
0.7510348558,
0.1624133885,
-0.3278601766,
-0.2096894532,
-0.7226686478,
0.2286351919,
0.048517555,
-0.3044652641,
-0.1863862723,
0.2145222425,
0.2346273363,
-0.6368882656,
0.8026548624,
-0.1516781449,
-0.1653256714,
0.2123989463,
0.1110728979,
0.6736658812,
-0.0917302296,
-0.0954893082,
0.1456316561,
-0.1239048615,
-0.5817213655,
-0.8690152764,
0.4846639931,
-0.5841882229,
-0.6938384771,
-0.3876529634,
-0.4520287812,
-0.533005476,
0.0280283839,
0.2674262822,
0.6014553905,
-0.4148591757,
0.1189689785,
0.7302368879,
-0.1638412774,
0.1351743191,
0.5319872499,
0.3128047287,
-0.2487065643,
1.0790811777,
-0.0452922136,
0.5949544311,
-0.1535438299,
-0.381839633,
-0.3872240782,
-0.3161624968,
-1.0051962137,
0.0506797768,
-0.4224374592,
-0.394952625,
-0.5791172385,
-0.2855628133,
-0.41750893,
-0.0245305635,
-0.2849583328,
-0.6276484132,
-0.1363207102,
-0.2533661425,
0.2633390427,
0.6435319185,
0.209021166,
0.454829067,
-0.7958273292,
0.1692937464,
0.113314949,
0.35418576,
-0.402441442,
-0.429474473,
0.1851782054,
0.2716145813,
-0.4261010289,
-0.5377562046,
0.1332986504,
0.4217714071,
0.391025871,
0.3367697895,
0.0582769923,
0.892919004,
-0.4850913882,
1.1645663977,
-0.0243671555,
-1.0626418591,
0.6635537148,
-0.394517839,
0.2298789173,
0.4671582878,
-0.2054957747,
-0.4613603354,
-0.6328393817,
-1.0487135649,
-0.6193445325,
1.0664651394,
0.452370137,
-0.0302429032,
-0.0240828749,
0.260725677,
0.2807164192,
0.3553407192,
-0.0195095632,
0.0600116849,
-0.4121330976,
-0.240209803,
-0.0945556089,
-0.1031391919,
-0.2228700668,
0.1934468001,
0.6610655785,
-0.4708573222,
0.3617629409,
0.1624859571,
0.125957638,
-0.4122211635,
0.240553081,
0.8863844872,
0.5613740683,
-0.0813006759,
-0.3096654117,
0.3379862905,
-0.4585831761,
0.045600988,
-0.2135783732,
-0.3102096319,
0.1810748577,
0.0637900606,
1.1344860792,
0.2187195122,
-0.3694914877,
0.5790205002,
-0.3501998782,
-0.0917511508,
-0.0443610884,
0.5045826435,
-0.2081407011,
-0.0443002395,
-0.0244780816,
0.3832370341,
0.2341377884,
-0.284937799,
0.1609857827,
0.4485423863,
-0.3569796979,
-0.0878494084,
0.3633422256,
0.3356890678,
-0.0673919544,
0.8165787458,
-0.2467632443,
-0.2202728391,
0.5066590309,
0.5536777973,
0.8577185273,
-0.5396203995,
0.3503806293,
0.4620118737,
0.0771114677,
0.1432909518,
0.4239644706,
-0.3573313951,
-0.7388490438,
-0.4951363802,
-0.7692937255,
-0.5193610787,
-0.1267680675,
-0.9699776173,
0.1476022899,
-0.374081105,
-0.2865902483,
0.0616095215,
-0.2727734447,
-0.4320349395,
0.2433769703,
-0.3676868379,
0.8074383736,
-0.5124338269,
0.5797780156,
0.3643658459,
-0.1066306382,
-1.0007287264,
0.0023103135,
-0.322853148,
-0.6899840832,
0.3502448797,
-0.3713919818,
-0.4229460359,
-0.0912989303,
-0.5871065259,
-0.8975968361,
1.1246855259,
0.2339520603,
-0.3038527966,
-0.08885061,
0.5031226277,
0.595729351,
-0.4154909551,
0.3554134071,
0.7529793382,
0.2995379269,
0.4004198909,
-1.2583734989,
-0.0197747387,
-0.127157256,
0.4126040041,
0.2319938391,
-0.834122479,
0.3054715693,
-0.0111834537,
-0.3159366548,
0.3022300303,
0.7290407419,
0.4051431119,
0.4685024917,
0.4930789769,
0.577003479,
0.7738261819,
-0.6550408006,
0.8017989397,
-0.3685704768,
-0.0031144118,
0.986710012,
-0.4588096738,
0.4568727016,
0.4621683657,
0.0907184184,
0.3624365628,
0.7567024827,
0.132141605,
0.6611149907,
0.0757622123,
-0.2883806527,
-0.4251961708,
-0.5406029224,
-0.264972657,
0.6861407161,
0.9544328451,
-0.3467467427,
-0.2569997311,
-0.1754341125,
-0.3031000495,
-0.0578846857,
-0.3087008893,
1.1142473221,
0.0468379967,
-0.9997189045,
0.6043353081,
0.0569530018,
0.1198557466,
-0.5641428828,
-0.222683385,
-0.2729617953,
-0.0231350847,
-0.2179828584,
-0.6368803978,
0.3518269956,
-0.0047815125,
-0.2706904709,
-0.1836349219,
0.9986107945,
-0.5136806369,
-0.2338128686,
-0.3036492467,
0.3699281514,
0.214302659,
0.4213516116,
-0.4166245461,
-0.044870425,
0.0901260972,
0.1852212995,
0.1335412562,
0.4690697789,
-0.2770652175,
0.4612858891,
0.6770288348,
-0.0547690652,
-0.04195337,
0.0043545356,
0.7280545831,
-0.5990273356,
-0.4414393604,
-0.2609226704,
0.2937530577,
-0.3649422526,
-0.4965088367,
0.6820924878,
0.3092556894,
0.9171559215,
-0.2763712704,
0.7721016407,
0.0560580119,
0.5990518928,
-0.5319880843,
0.2166281939,
-0.2973581851,
0.0764296129,
-0.5188441873,
-0.9667256474,
0.0937093645,
0.7856875658,
-0.2130879164,
-0.1208340824,
0.5868077874,
1.1899678707,
-0.1472102404,
0.6550566554,
0.3339134455,
0.1673378348,
0.0284187626,
0.5116742253,
0.9250962734,
-0.5248345137,
0.2235101908,
0.1011806577,
0.0757669806,
-0.1489464641,
-0.710647881,
-0.5685346127,
-0.565066874,
-0.0700117201,
-0.8622657061,
0.2210787237,
0.7805768251,
0.3625962734,
-0.8122617006,
-0.0911097825,
-0.2706362605,
-0.0817018598,
-0.2703779936,
-0.2284545302,
0.308193326,
-0.5100473166,
-0.8295747042,
0.3935101926,
0.4591228366,
-0.014962282,
-0.093443431,
-0.2652954161,
0.4589078128,
0.2882118821,
0.4776315987,
0.0980163515,
-1.0745714903,
-0.4862631857,
0.2875714302,
-0.4898388684,
-0.0960156247,
0.900403142,
-0.4328659773,
0.4285773635,
0.3555936217,
0.5206163526,
0.4112348258,
0.3097664118,
0.9057724476,
-0.8291449547,
-0.2107162923,
0.2239496559,
0.0930212662,
0.3504608572,
-0.3054633141,
0.7581515908,
0.2973370552,
-0.5412674546,
-0.859455049,
0.4550978541,
-1.1118682623,
0.2425119728,
1.0337995291,
-0.2202634364,
-0.3875096738,
-0.303812772,
-0.4513286352,
0.2591020763,
-0.6195560098,
0.5969994664,
0.9462934732,
-0.3756087124,
0.275804013,
-0.2614867985,
1.03789258,
0.8116053939,
-0.6576041579,
0.188828364,
0.6953001022,
0.065371491,
0.1800839603,
0.5267662406,
-0.0072671408,
0.6138018966,
0.2135700881,
-0.1083658114,
0.2983253598,
-0.2347393781,
0.0512605198,
-0.0517643169,
0.0025274921,
-0.0201824475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12566v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12566v1 | Improving Cross-lingual Information Retrieval on Low-Resource Languages via Optimal Transport Distillation | 2023-01-29T22:30:36 | 2023-01-29T22:30:36 | Zhiqi Huang, Puxuan Yu, James Allan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Benefiting from transformer-based pre-trained language models, neural ranking
models have made significant progress. More recently, the advent of
multilingual pre-trained language models provides great support for designing
neural cross-lingual retrieval models. However, due to unbalanced pre-training
data in different languages, multilingual language models have already shown a
performance gap between high and low-resource languages in many downstream
tasks. And cross-lingual retrieval models built on such pre-trained models can
inherit language bias, leading to suboptimal result for low-resource languages.
Moreover, unlike the English-to-English retrieval task, where large-scale
training collections for document ranking such as MS MARCO are available, the
lack of cross-lingual retrieval data for low-resource language makes it more
challenging for training cross-lingual retrieval models. In this work, we
propose OPTICAL: Optimal Transport distillation for low-resource Cross-lingual
information retrieval. To transfer a model from high to low resource languages,
OPTICAL forms the cross-lingual token alignment task as an optimal transport
problem to learn from a well-trained monolingual retrieval model. By separating
the cross-lingual knowledge from knowledge of query document matching, OPTICAL
only needs bitext data for distillation training, which is more feasible for
low-resource languages. Experimental results show that, with minimal training
data, OPTICAL significantly outperforms strong baselines on low-resource
languages, including neural machine translation. | [
-0.4324603379,
-0.3007130921,
0.6008577347,
0.0288956016,
-0.378005147,
0.09822198,
-0.3344364762,
-0.550314486,
0.2827286124,
0.3118218482,
-0.1666064262,
-0.0968721732,
-0.7684642673,
0.2011610121,
-0.294716537,
0.7661646605,
0.2436815202,
0.332039386,
0.262121439,
-0.1591950655,
-0.1172010675,
-0.2860564291,
-0.5860558748,
-0.4254829288,
0.5878891349,
0.3240200281,
0.7811098695,
0.5047810078,
0.5939153433,
0.3618418574,
-0.2902931869,
-0.0279058442,
-0.7220814228,
-0.2547433972,
-0.4518904984,
-0.6122084856,
-0.1546196193,
-0.1166236103,
0.4862253368,
0.9945885539,
-0.2209309191,
-0.0841227397,
0.2286406904,
0.6984860301,
-0.578787446,
-0.0064576063,
-0.9200139046,
0.2377023399,
-0.461956948,
-0.421897918,
-0.4557715356,
-0.1427582055,
0.3591648638,
-0.7785784602,
0.1347551793,
0.5306136608,
0.8930100799,
0.2535774112,
-0.5464722514,
-0.1025240198,
-0.624535799,
0.7773705721,
-0.3737529218,
0.7549688816,
0.397955358,
0.3473121822,
0.4530385435,
-0.5385838747,
-0.2719559669,
-0.2504754663,
-0.3225125968,
0.0188690126,
-0.2846168578,
-0.1233861446,
-0.1020482406,
0.2710959017,
-0.5296260715,
0.2309719622,
-0.5502274632,
-0.1567158401,
0.3429437876,
-0.0156370644,
0.122625649,
-0.0566215329,
-0.5260149837,
-0.1330757439,
-0.6689838171,
-0.3416266143,
0.3340737522,
0.5457882881,
0.2027996927,
0.5189316869,
-0.1889237612,
0.5566059351,
0.3648591936,
0.0317587256,
0.2773513198,
-0.8347012997,
0.0959906057,
0.4202877879,
0.7969520092,
0.1159386262,
0.0305638555,
-0.3997143209,
-0.3176099956,
-0.4494744241,
0.1799941659,
-0.8088303208,
-0.1134450808,
-0.6108296514,
-0.459045887,
0.0152661279,
-0.3783116639,
-0.895693779,
-0.082640104,
-0.4226406217,
0.4833694696,
-0.3602855206,
-0.4657604098,
0.1025229618,
-0.1572676748,
-0.1240839288,
0.259123981,
-1.2088952065,
-0.0141338771,
0.2028842568,
0.7478814125,
-0.1522923708,
-0.3507402837,
-0.4177643359,
0.1044831872,
-0.3869696856,
0.5578193665,
-0.5863309503,
-0.2614013255,
-0.1849836409,
-0.0041139098,
-0.0736384541,
-0.6699799895,
0.3317944407,
-0.6140633821,
0.2022971064,
-0.2965225875,
-0.0614333674,
0.0933969915,
0.0946383774,
-0.7160066962,
1.0256927013,
0.0904103443,
-0.6527706385,
0.3969926834,
-0.4343748391,
-0.6442407966,
-0.0567491241,
0.0799364671,
-0.0462839231,
0.1838546842,
0.1467803419,
-0.0065223807,
-0.6573389769,
0.1645112187,
-0.0162342954,
-0.2702718377,
-0.5714968443,
-0.7082822919,
0.7540203929,
0.4680642486,
-0.5385996103,
-0.4858682454,
-0.7655339241,
-0.1028347462,
-0.1549120992,
-0.6155954599,
-0.9729574323,
-0.2879600823,
0.2923820019,
0.1811289191,
0.4147660434,
-0.5849302411,
0.1240250096,
-0.3516833782,
0.2879415154,
0.714012146,
-0.5501198173,
1.0213991404,
0.1717623025,
0.5355197787,
0.2706181109,
0.2331997901,
0.3806168735,
-0.2056035101,
-0.6988900304,
0.2024032474,
0.2221340984,
0.6395231485,
-1.3750990629,
0.1049241945,
-0.657751143,
-0.561799109,
-0.7660404444,
0.3456552625,
0.4475238323,
0.7424550653,
0.5935131311,
0.0244104527,
-0.2727414966,
-0.9942685366,
-0.0160507895,
-0.2167379856,
0.2355990559,
0.2992657125,
0.1074911058,
-0.0198148489,
0.5486326814,
-0.5158731341,
-0.4294626415,
-0.4083430469,
0.1673897803,
0.2812234461,
0.3397763968,
0.8152338266,
-1.1429235935,
-0.79966259,
0.3860402107,
-0.5009974241,
-0.2097492516,
0.1878764331,
-0.6367869377,
0.1691804975,
0.413493067,
-0.4034895897,
0.188936457,
0.484589994,
-0.3372086883,
0.1369870007,
-0.3758659959,
0.3966630995,
-1.0069994926,
0.2470612377,
-0.0822537318,
-0.2648974061,
-0.4065921307,
-0.3573572636,
-0.1571080238,
-0.2638772428,
-0.6763094068,
0.5746513605,
-0.6787557602,
-0.0156512149,
-0.1668484062,
0.3289558589,
0.1971910149,
0.4067693651,
0.3724356592,
0.6648216248,
0.4498486519,
-0.4759308994,
0.2654505372,
0.1653464288,
-0.490137428,
0.7541533709,
-0.4098318815,
-0.1701975763,
-0.268756777,
-0.2867340446,
-0.7732064724,
0.6671056747,
-0.1460192949,
-0.08696834,
0.5517654419,
-0.402857542,
-0.3583803773,
0.1060590968,
0.088155061,
0.6658648252,
0.3455004394,
-0.7713788152,
0.6129686832,
0.4720196724,
-0.1246418431,
-0.8593068123,
-0.942861557,
0.0348379277,
-0.2242130935,
-0.6135715246,
0.6196187735,
-0.0099445926,
0.0147446757,
0.1698679179,
-0.1447847188,
-0.2540657818,
-0.0048327106,
-0.5425957441,
0.3583782911,
-0.3363313079,
-0.0113805085,
-0.0556191206,
-0.2992623746,
-0.3557406068,
-0.4472694099,
0.4311840832,
0.0343938135,
-0.1549007148,
0.1003820598,
0.3629229665,
0.5012527108,
-0.2044431567,
0.7462364435,
0.65186584,
-0.0400141031,
-0.0991359055,
-0.462090075,
-0.2281864733,
-0.4814412594,
0.5771089196,
-0.510524869,
-0.640869081,
0.2052599043,
0.0841568261,
-0.1101312786,
0.2118681669,
0.2352211773,
-0.02091497,
0.9438259006,
0.9207290411,
-0.4012840092,
0.8087669611,
-0.2112038434,
0.3812253177,
-0.5493921041,
-0.04877064,
-0.6834255457,
-0.4291354418,
-0.6415413618,
-0.2688903213,
0.5759137273,
0.2299752682,
0.0263305958,
0.6221839786,
-0.625677526,
0.4290795922,
0.7284223437,
0.0987555683,
0.5355303884,
0.326726377,
-0.380987525,
-0.0376495123,
-1.1091915369,
-0.0299852975,
0.7848145366,
-0.130265519,
1.1241084337,
0.135820806,
0.6937109828,
0.0063000973,
0.0875411183,
-0.387650609,
0.4344772995,
-0.6526326537,
-0.7261853218,
-0.3980066776,
-0.8182860613,
-1.031072855,
0.5547447801,
-0.075183183,
-0.2976353765,
0.4874847829,
0.0953286514,
-0.0154454764,
0.3855359256,
-0.7002183199,
0.9267587662,
-0.6774445772,
-0.5885261893,
-0.352058202,
-0.5886107683,
0.0470713302,
-0.1449232548,
0.2828481197,
0.1133905277,
-0.0655262619,
0.4264979959,
-0.4363123775,
0.4209669828,
-0.2186359912,
-0.0922219157,
-0.1028702706,
0.0346765295,
0.2982708812,
-0.2751217782,
-0.2570422292,
0.3598473072,
-0.0806706622,
-0.2211642861,
-0.6075970531,
0.5664153099,
-0.6210254431,
-0.5961395502,
-0.2988819182,
-0.0410555266,
0.0381930806,
0.5321401358,
0.7135065198,
0.1979065835,
0.1003528759,
0.285830617,
0.7042196989,
-0.1786251068,
0.5211876035,
0.8662796021,
-0.1471509635,
-0.2801274657,
1.0314273834,
0.3407428861,
0.3754712641,
1.0054941177,
0.3116959631,
-0.5056362152,
-0.5729478598,
-0.5907238722,
0.154601112,
-0.7140966654,
-0.1108254567,
-0.249879539,
-0.1065975949,
-0.220841378,
-0.0488262363,
-0.695571363,
-0.347266525,
-0.2684870362,
-0.0253265519,
0.0838940889,
0.3104528189,
-0.3367892802,
-0.0254559126,
-0.8044751287,
0.3389868438,
-0.0352588855,
0.3508433402,
0.0821014643,
-0.553704977,
-0.5730654001,
0.0489630923,
-0.0863642395,
-0.4546530545,
0.3813745081,
0.3581668735,
0.7853370905,
0.2520113289,
0.2122850418,
0.9068729877,
-0.7820079923,
0.3787027001,
0.3742864132,
-0.7824890018,
0.5845794082,
0.1436183602,
0.1463932991,
0.8655088544,
0.7402117252,
-0.4181990027,
-0.1433486491,
-0.1144428998,
-0.9007974863,
0.9321959615,
0.1023863107,
-0.071012482,
0.0311859287,
-0.0276322253,
0.0739763677,
0.2052633017,
-0.9334425926,
-0.1839644462,
-0.2199258506,
-0.2669194341,
-0.3156085312,
0.1223921552,
0.2225768417,
-0.2271521389,
0.8282262683,
-0.0864950418,
-0.1659733802,
0.3031074405,
-0.3566502333,
0.0261243097,
0.1681868434,
0.189736411,
0.4672416449,
-0.0166348349,
0.3251741529,
-0.00168481,
-0.5889379382,
0.4820826948,
0.2039542943,
-0.3370670378,
0.2341540754,
0.1753598601,
0.7854519486,
0.4108838439,
-0.5748125911,
0.4437726736,
0.0305091217,
0.1229149997,
0.0127496272,
-0.2686969638,
-0.002121594,
0.223331511,
0.4972607493,
0.066121839,
0.2966026366,
-0.5125719905,
0.0525259376,
0.4703220725,
-0.1320034564,
-0.1666482538,
0.8881208301,
0.2984509468,
-0.0654530302,
0.8506928682,
0.0079868641,
-0.4500228763,
0.1997367889,
0.1496476084,
0.5808286667,
-0.2156630903,
0.0127099128,
0.3058105707,
0.6157634854,
-0.2415703386,
0.0993731916,
-0.4534032345,
-0.6169615388,
0.0468516573,
-0.7393131256,
-0.0037921648,
-0.3271225393,
-0.4666869342,
0.4319600761,
0.0273024086,
-0.3140253723,
-0.0732322484,
-0.0395814851,
-0.7175773978,
-0.0210007019,
0.1771097779,
0.9287557006,
-0.6490050554,
0.9699206948,
0.3163799345,
-0.5937902331,
-0.6121400595,
-0.3834024072,
-0.335164696,
-0.7532247901,
1.2481102943,
-0.1758189499,
-0.2567062676,
0.0445949994,
0.0612017699,
-1.1127910614,
0.9965198636,
0.8365066648,
-0.8855027556,
-0.4596316814,
0.5985490084,
0.559898138,
0.002735456,
0.5817261338,
0.140980199,
0.5038372874,
0.0682318285,
-1.2242093086,
-0.159314543,
-0.3307234943,
0.197543323,
0.2314910889,
-0.7441417575,
0.7021668553,
0.0707995519,
-0.2135400921,
-0.163649261,
0.2818177044,
-0.1508569866,
0.1716868132,
0.676627636,
0.7093726397,
0.4038614929,
-0.2003951818,
0.8394125104,
-0.4455848336,
0.1434104294,
0.9588549137,
-0.3414689898,
0.897130847,
0.754027307,
0.0287758093,
0.1661610752,
0.4790310264,
0.2016512752,
1.0654268265,
0.0295376088,
0.0033417637,
-0.2906320393,
-0.1429812014,
-0.3003028929,
0.4564638734,
-0.17752859,
-0.4534199834,
-0.4358765185,
0.279589057,
-0.2312936485,
-0.0341133662,
-0.2873136997,
0.81847471,
0.017571371,
-0.8505687714,
1.0093119144,
-0.2027519196,
0.90904814,
-0.8012432456,
0.0913785249,
-0.5875540972,
0.1991913021,
-0.0309707485,
-0.5421562791,
0.2106070668,
-0.1150790974,
-0.3764038682,
-0.5615295768,
0.3288868666,
-0.8963731527,
-0.621607542,
0.8559255004,
0.434222579,
0.2129835039,
0.129140839,
-0.6504072547,
-0.1190694124,
0.0627687797,
-0.2389933318,
0.5666866899,
0.7637787461,
0.2319956422,
0.5318376422,
0.6318176389,
0.3611144423,
0.3869395554,
0.0532642417,
0.6858719587,
-0.3441855907,
-0.6882060766,
-0.7272654176,
0.1532244384,
-0.0830204785,
-0.1984312683,
0.5336261988,
0.8590301275,
1.0287332535,
0.0457493588,
0.5335687399,
0.0027430316,
0.2579647899,
-0.7202169299,
0.8561474085,
-1.1177135706,
0.3695740998,
-0.2414517254,
-1.1578398943,
0.3690522611,
0.6434268355,
-0.1068169475,
-0.0058712694,
0.5897834301,
0.8337749839,
-0.465568006,
-0.3852489293,
0.4081234634,
0.0604066886,
0.211592868,
1.0322524309,
0.7144960761,
-0.5085650682,
1.0277490616,
-0.4997646511,
-0.1206348166,
-0.2040235251,
-0.8586511016,
-0.5909098983,
-0.6368402243,
-0.1357403994,
-0.0429531708,
0.0667230263,
0.5855776072,
1.0734831095,
-0.3893644214,
-0.3364009261,
0.0851840526,
0.2269623876,
-0.0527588055,
-0.2755620182,
0.1352966726,
-0.3866480589,
-1.0667667389,
0.5479118228,
0.2596104443,
0.1099447981,
-0.2465340793,
-0.0739503056,
-0.4952282012,
-0.2758091688,
0.516302824,
0.0665619522,
-0.4223587513,
0.0622153506,
0.1461284161,
-0.3877883255,
0.2188016772,
0.6240894794,
-0.5152526498,
0.3466959298,
0.6841784716,
0.7671960592,
0.7351747155,
-0.269192487,
0.6015902162,
-0.5848082304,
0.3293125927,
0.3027750254,
0.5861423016,
0.2521342933,
-0.5566689968,
0.6117238998,
0.3378246725,
-0.3436792791,
-0.7439050078,
-0.1021640077,
-0.7414390445,
-0.404692471,
0.8827178478,
-0.0655410811,
-0.244152531,
0.1554470509,
-0.0655295402,
0.0704631135,
-0.3185894489,
0.7875435948,
0.6728459001,
0.0892003626,
-0.234416455,
-0.2635483444,
0.3814975917,
0.5796740651,
-0.5165944099,
0.0003704161,
0.3367874324,
0.3154057264,
0.4184146523,
0.5516437888,
-0.184864983,
-0.0897349641,
-0.0233270619,
-0.210755527,
0.0136711048,
-0.5004293323,
-0.0382200181,
0.0946228579,
-0.0797832683,
0.0197852049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12564v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12564v2 | A Discerning Several Thousand Judgments: GPT-3 Rates the Article + Adjective + Numeral + Noun Construction | 2023-01-29T22:29:55 | 2023-02-03T19:48:52 | Kyle Mahowald | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge of syntax includes knowledge of rare, idiosyncratic constructions.
LLMs must overcome frequency biases in order to master such constructions. In
this study, I prompt GPT-3 to give acceptability judgments on the
English-language Article + Adjective + Numeral + Noun construction (e.g., "a
lovely five days"). I validate the prompt using the CoLA corpus of
acceptability judgments and then zero in on the AANN construction. I compare
GPT- 3's judgments to crowdsourced human judgments on a subset of sentences.
GPT-3's judgments are broadly similar to human judgments and generally align
with proposed constraints in the literature but, in some cases, GPT-3's
judgments and human judgments diverge from the literature and from each other. | [
-0.619256258,
-0.442825973,
1.0013711452,
0.4529061615,
-0.2910303473,
-0.1625591218,
-0.1688943952,
-0.7637821436,
0.1415435374,
0.137851879,
-0.1241617575,
-0.3648311794,
-0.620423317,
0.8423495293,
-0.3069727719,
0.8963586092,
-0.0486755483,
0.0454023257,
0.063675642,
-0.1435149461,
-0.0709788278,
-0.3198757768,
-0.4688450694,
-0.280803293,
0.6191979647,
0.0505230986,
0.8707446456,
0.5421359539,
0.4526457489,
0.2371775955,
-0.1378201693,
-0.0267923493,
-0.0155099463,
-0.3111562431,
-0.3310739696,
-0.6435977221,
-0.4000777006,
0.4859099686,
0.4670993388,
0.6505094171,
0.0098216143,
0.0107097169,
0.1438499391,
1.0276927948,
-0.4502609372,
0.2855588794,
-0.6336258054,
0.119355157,
-0.1709093302,
0.1731620282,
-0.4816552997,
-0.6304965019,
0.1871297508,
-0.6599506736,
0.610342145,
-0.0500297546,
0.9713715315,
0.0564013273,
-0.4702918231,
-0.3563303947,
-0.304269433,
0.6595679522,
-0.4368134439,
0.344365567,
0.8460735083,
0.1437409073,
0.0227581896,
-0.417185396,
-0.8200044036,
-0.4749202728,
-0.1531597674,
0.2735711932,
-0.0806007385,
0.1252456158,
0.4451463223,
0.5879125595,
-0.5255327225,
-0.152594313,
-0.3691680729,
0.0871468633,
0.6228895783,
-0.1909669489,
0.1601985693,
-0.7213410735,
-0.2481760085,
0.5032796264,
-0.7691274285,
-0.2984297276,
0.6178746819,
0.2204416692,
0.0102409562,
0.3820648193,
-0.5350971818,
0.7877938151,
0.0316148475,
0.196107164,
0.436716944,
-0.2913827002,
-0.2754146755,
-0.2062606961,
0.8913010955,
0.5577138066,
0.5193693638,
-0.2109627426,
-0.2777909338,
0.2645205557,
0.4627491236,
-0.3237177432,
-0.2162321657,
0.0735412911,
-0.5590125918,
-0.1716390997,
0.2380978018,
-0.0894053653,
-0.3230185807,
-0.345525682,
0.3790479302,
-0.5905255079,
-0.0159092471,
0.329220593,
-0.1696831882,
0.0656173378,
0.7598107457,
-0.8730040789,
0.0237196404,
0.6493015885,
0.9468864799,
-0.2735342681,
-0.4245446324,
-0.1190369651,
-0.2760352194,
-0.3271680474,
0.8481960297,
-0.2362510264,
-0.5184561014,
-0.2146088481,
0.0083104512,
-0.0945565626,
-0.4816887379,
0.491495043,
-0.6942496896,
0.3688385189,
-0.2965569198,
-0.4148333371,
-0.2704361975,
0.5030553937,
-0.8476929069,
0.4561886191,
0.4356705248,
-0.5601902604,
0.6910253167,
-0.7065316439,
-0.3866480291,
0.3046311736,
-0.0816793144,
0.0034198435,
0.3129584789,
0.0907433033,
0.285507977,
-0.0720474422,
-0.0566338189,
-0.2531035841,
-0.4038226306,
0.144201532,
-0.3618038893,
0.8556559682,
0.6081483364,
-0.5049568415,
-0.4122565091,
-0.7677587271,
-0.1764347702,
-0.1675853282,
-0.7266798615,
-0.218751207,
-0.187995553,
-0.0236050542,
0.0425665155,
0.0930589885,
-0.5358757377,
0.5732272267,
-0.6458467245,
0.4072461128,
0.6755152941,
0.1044685319,
0.3640558124,
-0.5163166523,
0.5668594837,
-0.1532646865,
0.1095229983,
0.2023334652,
-0.635185957,
-0.851225853,
-0.013983449,
0.2295307964,
0.4786591232,
-0.9295961857,
0.0601664446,
-0.2637113035,
-0.3257440031,
-0.4915879965,
0.2140591741,
0.3875278234,
-0.1092309728,
0.3759690821,
-0.2691607475,
-0.5463252068,
-0.7974611521,
-0.5190518498,
-0.4546734989,
-0.1017346233,
0.1735594422,
0.504778564,
0.093455337,
0.7201551199,
-0.395512253,
-0.3148562014,
0.0214204844,
0.2649757862,
0.4766447246,
0.2724780738,
0.7940937281,
-0.5505619645,
-0.6973398328,
-0.0374925956,
-0.5865911245,
0.2055598199,
0.134523049,
0.1097916067,
0.2720910013,
0.2963481247,
-0.5761272907,
0.1712432355,
0.3088898957,
-0.574960351,
0.4998766482,
0.165883109,
0.2538399398,
-0.899761796,
-0.4351179302,
0.0141208088,
-0.3310748637,
-0.3158372641,
0.1235884205,
-0.0479103588,
0.6064798832,
-0.4995516539,
0.2609989047,
-0.5050689578,
0.188863039,
0.0007870204,
0.0419692844,
0.0358412713,
0.1290924847,
-0.1055030003,
0.6736692786,
0.1619297564,
-0.6078488827,
0.3715260327,
0.1640939415,
-0.5734528303,
1.0858787298,
-0.5353890657,
0.373601526,
-0.1618116349,
0.0780413896,
-0.8676887155,
-0.254991889,
0.0393359028,
-0.6105479002,
-0.2423046529,
-0.0017063302,
-0.536247313,
-0.3068091273,
-0.3212070465,
0.3767469227,
0.3547037244,
-0.578275919,
0.3212535381,
-0.0792834908,
-0.1288847774,
-0.4100206494,
-0.5678973794,
0.2551805675,
-0.1598784924,
-0.229386583,
0.2159781307,
-0.0532317795,
-0.5975706577,
0.0220765136,
-0.000920929,
0.0247696396,
0.1219135746,
0.1622747481,
0.1201517656,
-0.0751301274,
-0.1376510859,
-0.6229981184,
0.1396456063,
0.1597011536,
-0.1498822421,
0.3017827272,
-0.3764953613,
-0.4715537727,
-0.3044579327,
0.0951387733,
0.6405580044,
0.1777814031,
0.1048501655,
0.5334918499,
-0.3347097635,
-0.0167373102,
-0.7403557897,
0.2247161418,
-0.4030261934,
0.0592166819,
-0.7646260858,
-0.8406690359,
0.2324389964,
0.7252594233,
-0.1087122411,
0.821392715,
0.4759435952,
-0.0308771189,
1.0434013605,
0.1825024486,
-0.2008525878,
0.4644082785,
-0.1922252327,
-0.0370332152,
-0.726026237,
0.0195531007,
-0.582898736,
-0.3063340485,
-0.6813918948,
-0.2558961213,
0.3280113935,
-0.1027646363,
-0.3585165441,
0.2837704718,
-0.3986808658,
0.6231032014,
0.7171850204,
0.3661896586,
0.7290740013,
-0.2049607784,
-0.1509326398,
0.0621041134,
-0.1227961034,
-0.6013482213,
0.8860914707,
0.2740423083,
0.3364785314,
0.603233695,
0.7799515724,
0.3303666413,
0.7051852345,
-0.9126323462,
0.4414474964,
-0.2916751504,
-0.4770381749,
0.0294830576,
-0.4564219415,
-0.8731663823,
0.1438760459,
0.124878794,
-0.6672999263,
0.2583752573,
-0.0669988468,
-0.5338215232,
-0.0021181516,
-0.8040197492,
0.416993022,
-0.0725277662,
-0.230036363,
-0.1814057678,
-0.4731807113,
0.3870487809,
0.0431042127,
0.3815113902,
-0.4653996825,
-0.16726017,
0.4244070351,
-0.2937018871,
0.5952608585,
-0.2080850154,
-0.18450661,
0.2040747851,
0.2446915507,
0.3682499528,
0.272444278,
-0.2695486546,
-0.1082572937,
-0.1415258795,
-0.3028345406,
-0.5718762279,
0.5082838535,
-0.8535802364,
-0.6263085604,
-0.626639545,
-0.5058786869,
-0.3748852015,
0.1546673775,
0.4411236346,
0.1860631257,
-0.2478106469,
0.0150313722,
0.0833692029,
0.1291802078,
0.5397191048,
0.5781306624,
-0.2461537421,
-0.4517102242,
0.7711922526,
0.185303539,
0.3695709407,
0.3986828625,
-0.0252115596,
-0.2689215243,
-0.5288012624,
-0.3508473635,
0.1200242788,
-0.436670661,
-0.3651585579,
-0.5778874755,
0.036576014,
-0.3158500791,
-0.244690299,
-0.057963416,
-0.565327704,
-0.3346729279,
-0.3462901115,
0.6456493139,
1.2625473738,
-0.0694965869,
0.1371459514,
-0.6726689935,
0.5198904276,
0.4967206419,
0.6911638975,
-0.2911791205,
-0.5242198706,
-0.1006881595,
-0.0518178195,
-0.1917185336,
-0.7444307804,
0.1327566952,
0.0600687973,
0.3576079607,
0.5769181252,
-0.2178761065,
0.5016028881,
-0.3872050941,
0.9580591321,
0.2220206261,
-0.8165712953,
0.4792662263,
-0.6869971752,
0.5156436563,
0.7485567331,
0.4328569174,
-0.3389813602,
-0.6749995351,
-0.7796314359,
-0.8053091764,
0.5262338519,
0.1064101458,
0.1624217927,
-0.5440020561,
0.3091909885,
0.0721434653,
0.2994036674,
-0.9856966734,
-0.1407278031,
-0.3048858941,
0.114393726,
-0.2495571375,
-0.3436155319,
0.0966134444,
-0.1746671498,
0.4433744848,
-0.0185024682,
0.1960766166,
0.2255058885,
-0.2426911145,
0.3904103935,
0.5373657346,
0.458920598,
0.6162736416,
-0.3780051768,
0.504432857,
0.2530172467,
-0.8782555461,
0.2335187793,
0.0768090859,
-0.2692649364,
0.127602458,
0.3997810781,
0.6150220633,
-0.005489294,
-0.0082145976,
0.5000890493,
-0.1533003151,
-0.4895737171,
-0.1585412472,
0.0972651765,
-0.140255481,
0.0900901631,
0.2406832576,
0.1076094881,
0.469119668,
-0.5896094441,
0.1815689951,
0.3645502031,
-0.4492522478,
-0.3359755576,
0.6821726561,
0.1071087047,
-0.0761630163,
0.6239832044,
-0.8945499659,
-0.5253129005,
0.4025609195,
0.4257431328,
0.9870605469,
-0.1544298083,
0.2668217123,
0.4477692544,
0.280413419,
-0.4067871571,
0.6574879885,
-0.0105447592,
-0.966099143,
-0.4269368052,
-0.8265693188,
-0.4256828725,
-0.0765137076,
-0.6503360271,
0.3324270844,
-0.3738258481,
-0.2959037721,
0.0762761384,
-0.04672442,
-0.9023180604,
0.2440885901,
-0.1314568222,
0.826451838,
-0.8555086255,
0.4747686684,
0.9604557753,
-0.8002692461,
-1.0026011467,
-0.0500857085,
0.2313446403,
-0.9506127238,
0.5205252171,
0.1244532764,
-0.0512189008,
0.1846607625,
-0.3047736883,
-0.476319164,
0.7823411226,
0.4408939183,
-0.3163074553,
-0.0860460475,
-0.1492273659,
0.5058309436,
-0.0914610922,
0.2595153153,
0.9021709561,
0.6190117002,
-0.1267821938,
-1.3362548351,
-0.016552709,
-0.3392473161,
-0.1240151823,
0.0008441922,
-0.5938622952,
0.7867745161,
-0.3524037004,
-0.1311610639,
0.1306837648,
0.4168154299,
0.2435696274,
0.1124872565,
0.765499711,
0.6720487475,
0.6159694791,
-0.2299463749,
1.0220910311,
-0.2319369912,
0.5044764876,
0.7986932397,
0.0396626629,
0.8426932096,
0.4521742463,
-0.9352933764,
0.4492422342,
0.6964641213,
-0.1564330459,
0.4996700287,
0.2664485574,
-0.7359932661,
0.0894266739,
-0.25314641,
-0.5021899939,
0.6260125041,
0.2856429219,
-0.4018897414,
-0.1673957855,
-0.0527906306,
0.2696490288,
0.0537895523,
-0.5912610292,
0.7663767934,
0.4021095932,
-0.8519077301,
0.5185613632,
-0.1241979748,
0.7066245079,
-0.0212523378,
-0.0033943288,
-0.2034344822,
0.0745750368,
-0.5685026646,
-0.8187022805,
0.3088333905,
-0.0774648637,
-0.490462333,
-0.5276521444,
0.2992618978,
-0.11573039,
-0.4226148129,
-0.1483689696,
0.7237527966,
0.3952461183,
-0.2991736531,
-0.2284754962,
-0.2907196283,
0.1009974629,
-0.2922532558,
0.1379017234,
0.7015765309,
0.1217742786,
0.2635352612,
0.3712490797,
0.366759032,
-0.4567685723,
0.5015897751,
0.4478725195,
-0.8392415643,
-0.4840024412,
-1.0032863617,
0.1053178683,
0.2901764214,
-0.2884400487,
0.8535269499,
0.613666296,
0.6713590622,
-0.1434864104,
0.9930322766,
-0.0712422058,
0.5921664834,
-0.5587283373,
0.6529837847,
-0.256192714,
0.316095531,
-0.5584891438,
-0.7987884283,
-0.5961617231,
0.9624278545,
-0.4543133378,
0.2502526641,
0.9632216096,
0.3496701419,
0.0903055742,
0.3718107641,
0.1618219763,
0.2693791091,
0.091551058,
0.5651621222,
1.0706272125,
-0.0932088271,
0.33984375,
-0.007768047,
-0.0089962212,
-0.0458489694,
-1.0136160851,
-0.5071502328,
-0.5989292264,
-0.0725367963,
-0.5159280896,
0.0375173986,
0.9949730635,
0.2265927494,
-0.6414601207,
-0.0940193534,
-0.2625488341,
0.259298861,
-0.2045651376,
-0.2911903858,
0.3560343385,
-0.4393852949,
-0.7979987264,
0.2230520844,
0.1051008925,
0.1080792472,
-0.1474265456,
0.1690353751,
-0.0702595711,
-0.4340805113,
0.9101029634,
-0.0852680802,
-0.6824088693,
-0.748739481,
0.1102758422,
-0.2212272584,
0.096752204,
0.4958207607,
-0.6930146217,
0.4269690216,
0.4131883979,
0.1010274217,
0.1840997785,
0.2491570115,
0.7682672739,
-0.5748248696,
-0.1408978552,
0.2076930255,
0.53244102,
0.4026214778,
-0.2950130701,
0.8629066348,
0.5163608789,
-0.5464969277,
-0.5972535014,
0.3544003963,
-0.899176836,
0.234757036,
1.3904490471,
-0.0689483956,
0.2246932834,
-0.4362822175,
-0.2279416025,
-0.2129334807,
-0.4327815175,
0.9638125896,
1.0947142839,
-0.6221729517,
0.0137914745,
-1.0100879669,
0.6520164013,
0.1449588388,
-0.6934757233,
-0.5036023855,
0.6822265983,
0.3103603721,
0.2250819951,
0.8683612347,
-0.1333784312,
0.5186517239,
-0.1019841284,
0.005729056,
0.2168098688,
-0.060330905,
-0.1518608779,
0.3394585252,
0.7410081625,
-0.1571156234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12534v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12534v4 | Vicarious Offense and Noise Audit of Offensive Speech Classifiers: Unifying Human and Machine Disagreement on What is Offensive | 2023-01-29T20:39:21 | 2023-11-09T13:46:40 | Tharindu Cyril Weerasooriya, Sujan Dutta, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Marcos Zampieri, Christopher M. Homan, Ashiqur R. KhudaBukhsh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Offensive speech detection is a key component of content moderation. However,
what is offensive can be highly subjective. This paper investigates how machine
and human moderators disagree on what is offensive when it comes to real-world
social web political discourse. We show that (1) there is extensive
disagreement among the moderators (humans and machines); and (2) human and
large-language-model classifiers are unable to predict how other human raters
will respond, based on their political leanings. For (1), we conduct a noise
audit at an unprecedented scale that combines both machine and human responses.
For (2), we introduce a first-of-its-kind dataset of vicarious offense. Our
noise audit reveals that moderation outcomes vary wildly across different
machine moderators. Our experiments with human moderators suggest that
political leanings combined with sensitive issues affect both first-person and
vicarious offense. The dataset is available through
https://github.com/Homan-Lab/voiced. | [
-0.330198884,
-0.9530278444,
0.2235437185,
0.1151542142,
-0.27208215,
0.2216081768,
-0.2113638222,
-0.588062048,
-0.0073630842,
0.5402840376,
-0.3680079281,
-0.2010244131,
-0.746905148,
0.0127685405,
-0.7098965049,
1.1217902899,
0.7018764615,
0.114886269,
-0.0035721366,
-0.1946987063,
-0.1704807878,
-0.6364606023,
-0.5328567624,
-0.0332470611,
0.7454839349,
0.1894022226,
0.6391400099,
0.5582078099,
0.5081549883,
0.4677088261,
-0.0326274633,
0.0973424613,
-0.4712891281,
0.0943135619,
-0.4412152469,
-0.2693606019,
-0.5320341587,
0.0570005178,
0.2042746842,
0.2119071931,
0.1134842038,
0.0796828568,
0.008016129,
0.4760131836,
-0.6975807548,
-0.0042465576,
-0.9374921322,
0.0683265179,
-0.2230145633,
-0.0966402441,
-0.4840260744,
-0.3196400106,
0.2346749902,
-0.5666652322,
0.4611160159,
-0.1167284921,
0.5727938414,
0.2443124056,
-0.6418147683,
-0.5219346285,
-0.8871637583,
0.7177161574,
-0.680044651,
0.2227569669,
0.4139831364,
0.1727906615,
0.1849719882,
-0.5197466612,
-0.888872683,
0.0791847035,
0.0754595399,
0.2376425415,
-0.8957480192,
0.0646134019,
-0.0194602106,
0.1974457949,
-0.3725161254,
0.1537539363,
-0.3088814318,
-0.3478706479,
0.6576337814,
0.2441271394,
0.2259300798,
-0.5325881243,
-0.3076856136,
-0.0716031194,
-0.2009249777,
-0.0026496905,
0.9615430236,
0.4050889909,
-0.090254277,
0.1967342198,
0.0597118847,
0.4748770595,
0.16850169,
0.1451345682,
0.0200290214,
-0.0523986444,
-0.2646424174,
0.2875727713,
1.005923748,
0.6482532024,
0.2875780761,
0.0929239392,
-0.344840318,
0.5508099794,
0.6627871394,
-0.4869161546,
-0.2453319579,
0.122808598,
-0.3207530975,
-0.7634518743,
0.2249481678,
-0.7111836672,
-1.0762646198,
-0.2946906686,
0.3401260674,
-0.0977379158,
-0.4143962264,
0.09877792,
-0.4469181299,
0.0655394793,
0.4745761752,
-0.3508425355,
0.3402652144,
1.1604152918,
0.471742928,
-0.0966452435,
-0.079414852,
-0.6413784027,
-0.2398793399,
-0.2428889573,
0.6573149562,
-0.575838089,
-0.3084168434,
0.1835025847,
0.1206685826,
0.2906849086,
-0.7857082486,
0.9339758158,
-0.6962770224,
0.3615728617,
-0.2952113152,
-0.3255505264,
-0.2406914532,
0.0661951229,
-0.2946251333,
0.68139112,
-0.0129962293,
-1.0358736515,
0.4589965045,
-0.6958062649,
-0.5702856779,
0.04850531,
-0.0717159286,
-0.3036057651,
0.1820231229,
-0.1251319945,
0.2750273049,
-0.0284986719,
0.481408149,
-0.2964560688,
-0.363794744,
0.4615734816,
-0.7773609161,
1.0794252157,
0.2699382007,
-0.650151968,
0.4880865514,
-0.7268338203,
-0.4099938273,
0.0786837712,
-0.1634922177,
-0.6057105064,
0.3616451621,
0.1737900823,
0.1426997036,
-0.0015574698,
-0.6853271127,
-0.3304949701,
-0.2751917243,
0.700933814,
1.2853717804,
-0.1085800827,
0.3126134872,
-0.6294683814,
0.3595230579,
0.2875950038,
0.4247331023,
0.4597641826,
-0.526635766,
-0.6046240926,
-0.0279035401,
-0.1024605185,
0.7056155205,
-0.4749738872,
0.4916345179,
-0.3313848674,
-0.5858233571,
-0.435240984,
-0.3032119572,
0.5558464527,
0.3694226444,
0.1665034294,
-0.0998502076,
-0.5727971196,
-0.8822033405,
-0.639003098,
-0.7642996311,
-0.0819731131,
0.6103239059,
0.2893755436,
-0.0539520942,
0.8219113946,
-0.170354858,
-0.2432305515,
0.254707247,
0.3912582994,
0.0314245522,
0.4019227326,
0.3863570392,
-0.8281279206,
-0.3540377617,
-0.0040502711,
-0.4364715517,
-0.3625091612,
0.2025417536,
0.066111654,
0.1721532494,
0.0276325215,
-0.1337267309,
0.3600539863,
0.5123128891,
-0.5382361412,
0.5057861805,
0.1583046913,
0.3389848769,
-0.8555775285,
-0.3702065051,
-0.0156207085,
-0.4084843993,
-0.7908548117,
-0.2789047956,
-0.1494823992,
0.2397331595,
-0.8217805028,
0.1152780876,
0.0591183715,
0.163100034,
-0.2438123226,
0.0170786493,
-0.0067562042,
0.2524489164,
-0.252772361,
0.5991237164,
0.5203829408,
-0.5285261869,
0.4388341904,
0.0053243758,
-0.3884311914,
0.7744768262,
-0.4679096937,
0.5987073183,
-0.1139504611,
0.1591556966,
-1.0039950609,
-0.3362836242,
0.5493591428,
-0.5723400116,
0.0783737227,
-0.213401854,
-0.398126334,
-0.1894198507,
-0.4271412492,
0.4846475422,
0.1985981166,
-0.4477639496,
0.5495978594,
0.9090695977,
0.1447751671,
-0.6134736538,
-0.6392950416,
0.3485673368,
-0.4832763672,
-0.5017735958,
0.1902636141,
0.0845813528,
-0.7072629929,
-0.1002325937,
-0.1739460081,
-0.267393589,
0.1113473102,
0.5128326416,
0.1322368383,
-0.1441781968,
-0.0449877307,
-0.0445137993,
0.4668108523,
0.7842578888,
-0.0473910235,
0.5669955611,
-0.2503673732,
-0.2749665976,
-0.8337070346,
0.3433546424,
0.6467770934,
0.2869008482,
0.1965163499,
0.5636506081,
-0.3196604252,
0.0198582113,
-0.6292948127,
-0.1908411086,
-0.5347607732,
0.4726634622,
0.0418804958,
-0.9282271862,
0.4032447338,
0.3562429547,
0.1661857665,
0.4431286454,
0.393787235,
-0.2163582444,
1.1834931374,
0.2004098743,
-0.1895704567,
0.3928219378,
-0.0157539286,
-0.08041697,
-0.5373084545,
-0.0279936306,
-1.0003288984,
-0.3524804413,
-0.9511498809,
-0.184221223,
0.0631687641,
-0.5170047283,
-0.3061503768,
0.160672754,
-0.7086400986,
0.4901870787,
0.2555118501,
0.332038939,
0.1529482007,
-0.001553557,
0.4148907959,
-0.1009591743,
-0.4600737989,
-0.5888608098,
0.7559421659,
0.274515748,
0.6891446114,
0.4376676381,
0.2629560828,
0.8798821568,
0.3512496054,
-0.9021880627,
0.4854517877,
-0.3957623243,
-1.0268546343,
-0.2473865896,
-0.3920423687,
-0.8875756264,
0.1320591122,
-0.0941387862,
-0.5934054255,
0.5385947227,
0.230307743,
-0.094882898,
0.5682183504,
-0.5778961182,
0.5322582126,
-0.165259555,
-0.5506318808,
-0.2070794702,
-0.7987158895,
0.3127397597,
-0.2157826722,
0.6611285806,
0.0154355066,
-0.1417075843,
1.0675939322,
-0.199652344,
1.3822243214,
-0.3843299747,
-0.2278274149,
0.1907556504,
0.2102183849,
0.2374501079,
-0.1417845339,
-0.0920449421,
0.3906913996,
-0.1174863204,
-0.1665823311,
-0.1996643692,
0.4570407569,
-0.9055299759,
-0.89487499,
-0.5289404392,
-0.2892758548,
-0.1226981133,
0.0954826847,
0.3676929176,
0.4174274206,
-0.5218945146,
0.350656867,
0.6071450114,
-0.3171670139,
0.2530986369,
0.5172836185,
-0.1666814089,
-0.2698381543,
1.1802712679,
-0.0666840374,
0.1481779814,
0.1098682061,
0.5455669165,
-0.1325031519,
-0.271445781,
-0.3463616073,
-0.1675656587,
-0.6138663292,
-0.2565540075,
-0.9255259633,
-0.0704103261,
-0.5375640988,
-0.0322636664,
-0.1770026237,
-0.3076065779,
-0.2850008011,
0.2579692602,
0.0739956051,
1.0952789783,
-0.1924702823,
0.483566016,
-0.5300841928,
0.1933823973,
0.5578219891,
0.016601339,
-0.2171243876,
-0.9287045598,
0.2786808014,
0.1881806254,
-0.4938642681,
-1.1709809303,
0.0454552509,
0.1232167035,
0.2122317404,
1.0205272436,
0.4428373873,
0.4934448004,
-0.3291629851,
0.9145758152,
0.0076607848,
-1.0322824717,
0.4201115668,
-0.4415902793,
-0.132343322,
0.3165663779,
0.2748851776,
-0.5274908543,
-0.6665099263,
-0.6759836674,
-0.3688093722,
0.7824768424,
0.0106588574,
0.6212338209,
-0.360796839,
-0.0135081885,
0.1767861843,
0.2501267493,
-0.6017436385,
-0.3839600384,
-0.4976508021,
0.2231214195,
0.1466951817,
-0.3851573765,
-0.6433282495,
-0.4563362598,
0.4935411513,
-0.0457973816,
0.2414051592,
0.1135590374,
0.0229817051,
-0.3946537673,
0.3197605014,
0.6517864466,
0.8235990405,
0.0084218485,
0.3282506764,
-0.0179906525,
-0.562166512,
0.1373967826,
-0.306342274,
-0.0192428101,
0.1653793603,
0.5346239805,
0.8118650317,
0.2214974165,
-0.3836123347,
1.0511373281,
-0.2985709608,
-0.283801347,
-0.2999581993,
0.1935352981,
-0.0892088413,
0.1800481826,
0.1557758301,
0.3500255942,
0.4225449562,
-0.696639955,
0.0772830769,
0.6209655404,
-0.6860279441,
-0.5485032201,
0.8038032055,
0.1975633055,
-0.8326663375,
0.4565636814,
-0.1435008198,
-0.9615004659,
0.5198643804,
0.4853954613,
0.9212266207,
-0.2993034422,
0.4507363141,
0.1009746119,
0.5039324164,
0.6474540234,
0.2836929262,
-0.2226165682,
-0.8442473412,
0.0316457227,
-0.4095148444,
-0.5362455845,
0.128496483,
-0.7152676582,
-0.0149510698,
-0.7204371095,
-0.4408993125,
0.3419709802,
-0.1117975935,
-0.4668278396,
0.0798561499,
0.0524159782,
0.6496949792,
-0.7868878841,
0.5147230625,
0.5641059279,
0.1695532352,
-0.3135727644,
0.2047412992,
0.5684839487,
-0.7210080624,
0.5581271052,
-0.0090146456,
-0.300993681,
-0.2770367265,
-0.8045912385,
-0.0160411689,
0.3316315711,
0.2824791968,
-0.4231226146,
0.0536558703,
0.2804410756,
0.5996177793,
-0.1439860612,
-0.1072064862,
0.2875677347,
0.4826727211,
-0.3259839416,
-0.8038526773,
-0.0419225842,
-0.0577006973,
-0.3219792247,
0.1135808229,
-0.7585522532,
0.7776085734,
0.2353507578,
-0.4497288465,
-0.4268023074,
0.4374995232,
-0.252533555,
0.6399376392,
1.0244427919,
0.2895125151,
0.7883276939,
-0.1646387577,
0.8883334994,
-0.0119120898,
-0.0449359454,
1.1665334702,
-0.2639296353,
0.6268522739,
0.2574656606,
-0.325496614,
0.4426040947,
0.3649288118,
0.0615009144,
0.1892160624,
0.3005914688,
-0.6073693633,
-0.1984455287,
-0.4260752797,
-0.2751059234,
0.8899324536,
0.2726477683,
-0.1974350959,
0.0468415916,
0.0495406352,
0.2061159462,
0.0830800906,
-0.0997863114,
1.1687258482,
-0.177975744,
-0.4194358587,
0.174188599,
-0.0171100069,
0.7991258502,
-0.2137023509,
0.262763083,
0.0216300357,
-0.1297184825,
-0.2343713194,
-0.831186831,
0.3544431925,
0.3460737467,
-0.1813118458,
-0.0306848809,
0.6590337753,
0.1305204183,
-0.0033760704,
0.3688184321,
0.3684745729,
0.1861011833,
-0.3527978063,
-0.8454397321,
0.2616786361,
-0.1402951628,
-0.1378600299,
0.2949537635,
0.5748348236,
0.0087811407,
0.3398096859,
0.9749208093,
0.0003309803,
0.1982842237,
0.2049298584,
1.0190961361,
-0.3490274847,
-0.3098726273,
-0.9922066927,
0.2668538094,
-0.2564625144,
-0.4224204421,
0.4462767541,
0.8259157538,
0.9161750078,
0.2396762073,
0.5845218897,
-0.098603718,
0.5442258716,
-0.1147120893,
0.8753422499,
-0.546754241,
0.1418376863,
-0.4815182686,
-0.6337214708,
-0.0965105295,
0.4204981625,
-0.0656414703,
-0.169688046,
0.4229994416,
0.8748381138,
-0.0586338975,
0.4503655732,
0.3466529548,
0.5636271238,
0.4654244781,
0.1317984313,
1.2113898993,
-0.1857300848,
0.6134130359,
-0.6367288232,
-0.1821739525,
-0.1219273135,
-0.7643911242,
-0.7494120598,
-0.7098532915,
-0.3603403568,
-0.6498554349,
0.1325726658,
0.7133129835,
0.6635051966,
-0.8699555397,
-0.3287281394,
0.1199959666,
0.0774827078,
-0.0695747137,
-0.389339149,
0.1609056145,
0.1485558003,
-1.1651488543,
0.2975384295,
0.214216575,
-0.3536966443,
-0.3075514138,
0.0357536823,
-0.2963691652,
0.3946230114,
0.6622382402,
0.0403182507,
-1.0496731997,
-0.7247655392,
-0.0758772641,
-0.2839834988,
0.0270308796,
0.8134726882,
-0.501925528,
0.4353621304,
0.5628726482,
0.6633706689,
-0.148868382,
0.1759111434,
0.1711476445,
-0.6448635459,
0.015658956,
0.5027725101,
0.1349172592,
0.2418863475,
-0.5162875652,
0.3278788924,
0.5577697754,
-0.8555148244,
-1.0574252605,
0.0794337019,
-1.1259019375,
-0.3214868307,
0.8269646168,
0.0918909162,
-0.204203099,
-0.3525599539,
-0.286154896,
0.4414628446,
-0.6393067241,
1.0199277401,
0.7678487897,
0.0001446298,
0.1639084071,
-0.5669378638,
0.5408468843,
0.3445521593,
-0.5816777945,
0.3611643612,
0.7585784793,
0.126778841,
0.1650913805,
0.3605181575,
0.0502490327,
0.4077110887,
-0.0398904234,
-0.3675791323,
0.1632380038,
-0.2358110994,
-0.4359480441,
0.1832105964,
-0.436209619,
-0.1243653595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12520v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12520v1 | Producing Usable Taxonomies Cheaply and Rapidly at Pinterest Using Discovered Dynamic $μ$-Topics | 2023-01-29T19:27:08 | 2023-01-29T19:27:08 | Abhijit Mahabal, Jiyun Luo, Rui Huang, Michael Ellsworth, Rui Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Creating a taxonomy of interests is expensive and human-effort intensive: not
only do we need to identify nodes and interconnect them, in order to use the
taxonomy, we must also connect the nodes to relevant entities such as users,
pins, and queries. Connecting to entities is challenging because of ambiguities
inherent to language but also because individual interests are dynamic and
evolve. Here, we offer an alternative approach that begins with bottom-up
discovery of $\mu$-topics called pincepts. The discovery process itself
connects these $\mu$-topics dynamically with relevant queries, pins, and users
at high precision, automatically adapting to shifting interests. Pincepts cover
all areas of user interest and automatically adjust to the specificity of user
interests and are thus suitable for the creation of various kinds of
taxonomies. Human experts associate taxonomy nodes with $\mu$-topics (on
average, 3 $\mu$-topics per node), and the $\mu$-topics offer a high-level data
layer that allows quick definition, immediate inspection, and easy
modification. Even more powerfully, $\mu$-topics allow easy exploration of
nearby semantic space, enabling curators to spot and fill gaps. Curators'
domain knowledge is heavily leveraged and we thus don't need untrained
mechanical Turks, allowing further cost reduction. These $\mu$-topics thus
offer a satisfactory "symbolic" stratum over which to define taxonomies. We
have successfully applied this technique for very rapidly iterating on and
launching the home decor and fashion styles taxonomy for style-based
personalization, prominently featured at the top of Pinterest search results,
at 94% precision, improving search success rate by 34.8% as well as boosting
long clicks and pin saves. | [
-0.6701509356,
-0.4295822084,
0.6826478839,
0.0975651965,
-0.6546961665,
0.5812299848,
-0.2423779666,
-0.2718915641,
1.0897730589,
0.2828111947,
-1.0039724112,
-0.7494698167,
-0.4084790647,
-0.3001190126,
-0.2428840101,
0.7093337178,
0.0226656087,
-0.6098019481,
-0.0250566695,
-0.0992482156,
-0.6210420132,
-0.4893189967,
-0.2609680891,
0.1502373666,
0.8548521399,
0.8070691228,
0.4664837718,
0.8115602136,
0.6652035713,
0.1783835441,
-0.1232706979,
0.2192954123,
-0.5202487111,
0.5120937824,
-0.6997944117,
-0.3488481641,
-0.4141383171,
0.181148231,
-0.0627218038,
0.8184907436,
-0.1693908721,
0.3288557529,
-0.1485775262,
0.5894008875,
-0.5803897381,
0.0877567083,
-1.2370501757,
-0.0836160034,
-0.640742898,
-0.5207673311,
-0.0225797556,
-0.0955832973,
0.2068588436,
-0.6666483879,
0.5262926817,
-0.0485356152,
0.9983774424,
-0.0857349038,
-0.3217484355,
-0.4267597497,
-0.5831827521,
0.6596852541,
-0.1627697945,
0.5259906054,
0.3053314984,
0.16849792,
-0.0370418206,
-1.0813683271,
-0.2532694042,
0.1297406405,
0.1213766932,
-0.0040964279,
-0.0853994638,
-0.3646332622,
0.1865970492,
0.2800894082,
-0.330326438,
-0.2523368597,
-0.151707232,
0.1291030496,
0.5663571358,
0.3564647138,
0.1655531079,
-0.5578705072,
-0.1708735526,
-0.0115254382,
-0.8846597672,
0.0364325792,
0.2556186616,
0.4727337062,
0.4456795752,
0.7983207107,
-0.4201246798,
0.0504521206,
0.5317565799,
-0.1145776212,
0.1407508701,
-0.567491889,
0.4813334346,
-0.0080425506,
0.285582751,
0.6732811332,
0.0841462985,
-0.2500103116,
-0.2905544937,
0.1252356172,
0.5714330673,
-0.5952315331,
-0.4217379391,
0.3222210407,
-0.5981075168,
-0.2431960553,
0.1860509962,
-0.8217042685,
-0.384596318,
-0.5152778029,
0.4718593061,
-0.2565617561,
-0.0425619856,
0.1243098378,
-0.1385554671,
-0.2132033855,
0.3635238409,
-1.0686401129,
0.3370601535,
0.8646079302,
1.1868146658,
-0.3226613998,
-0.1120437607,
0.0275970697,
0.2852064967,
-0.5072464347,
1.0168246031,
-0.3405326307,
-0.3146873713,
-0.2183181942,
0.0767901093,
0.1892189831,
-0.4779546857,
0.4681625664,
-0.3037856817,
-0.1540421695,
-0.6174731851,
-0.4855298698,
0.1324030012,
0.011012123,
-0.4953335226,
0.9434372783,
-0.0754762366,
-1.0156731606,
0.8112336397,
-0.6854328513,
-0.384455502,
0.3493014276,
-0.1737071425,
0.0623234473,
0.4267136455,
-0.0976510718,
0.781591475,
-0.1833905578,
0.4708468318,
-0.3257214427,
-0.4610248804,
-0.0340927504,
0.1413620114,
0.3278450966,
0.1894652992,
-0.5763782263,
0.2500620782,
-0.6164029241,
-0.3411169946,
0.3000283539,
0.0509780198,
-0.773316741,
0.5685899258,
-0.2755404711,
-0.0357215889,
0.2564852536,
-0.391279608,
0.4652817845,
-0.2337314636,
0.4543301463,
1.0314861536,
0.3945820928,
0.3409927189,
-0.4259575605,
0.2050525695,
-0.2787749171,
0.2186330259,
-0.1322337836,
-0.518684268,
-0.9110370278,
-0.3391112387,
0.0052057435,
0.1135386974,
-0.5529420972,
0.579175055,
-0.2061078995,
-1.0137313604,
-0.0153762363,
-0.1852716208,
-0.385032177,
0.3208215237,
0.1402979195,
-0.4501786232,
-0.2501163483,
-0.5840588808,
-0.2159523517,
-0.0064414428,
-0.2642705739,
0.477591604,
0.4610331357,
-0.2466708422,
0.9226309657,
-1.0912392139,
-0.3319004476,
0.328134656,
0.371091783,
0.6812073588,
0.4211388826,
0.8504568934,
-0.6809718609,
-0.5143789053,
-0.321993351,
-0.143324092,
-0.0963690877,
0.103666164,
-0.6978694797,
-0.2291400135,
0.2425926179,
-0.7532096505,
0.4299880862,
0.0509650223,
-0.3913309872,
0.5266560912,
0.0889491886,
0.1361732185,
-1.1296061277,
-0.047978159,
-0.0818243399,
0.2208738476,
-0.5055974126,
0.0719955787,
-0.1355615109,
-0.3346337676,
-0.3027727902,
0.4989300668,
-0.4803363979,
0.4179615378,
-0.1081487909,
-0.0103932032,
-0.1201221421,
0.426586926,
0.1793077886,
0.542966187,
0.5646288395,
-0.6253226399,
0.3514919877,
0.1784002185,
-0.2011447698,
0.8081585169,
-0.5476665497,
0.2877835929,
0.0656514242,
-0.2840371728,
-0.94533813,
-0.364456445,
0.4487807751,
-0.2095161527,
0.139705807,
-0.3792903721,
-0.5806687474,
-0.3357921839,
-0.8500849605,
0.0461561941,
0.2676914036,
-0.8818150759,
0.3605445623,
0.4792011976,
-0.4584282935,
-0.3079882264,
-0.1550447941,
0.1573323309,
-0.5277754664,
-0.552778542,
0.5324599147,
-0.3028285205,
-0.1953760684,
0.0661204308,
-0.4190515876,
0.1293085665,
0.3087797463,
0.3629037738,
-0.0046368795,
0.0952318534,
0.581730485,
0.1903615445,
-0.0724470615,
-0.0210028607,
-0.5556665659,
0.9816064239,
0.018743882,
-0.6157488227,
-0.1067116186,
0.5520133376,
0.7856641412,
-0.3562147319,
0.4266293347,
0.3118726611,
-0.828166008,
-0.2880731225,
-0.4157676995,
-0.4424547553,
-0.5267295837,
0.1726072729,
-0.7411615849,
-0.781891048,
0.3972765505,
-0.1075522006,
0.1791340262,
0.4589576423,
0.5444379449,
-0.2783412635,
1.004114747,
0.6135373712,
0.3861103356,
0.6237422824,
-0.2606109381,
0.4283851087,
-0.6543860435,
-0.5458300114,
-0.6327704191,
-0.4721868336,
-0.8963343501,
-0.4631739259,
0.1995443255,
0.0599398464,
-0.2521134317,
0.4636705518,
-0.8616581559,
0.0688178986,
0.8863871694,
0.4104556441,
0.2586862445,
0.2856682837,
-0.0360164754,
-0.473418951,
-0.5789016485,
-0.6121563315,
1.1557397842,
0.1562708169,
1.3027489185,
0.0641981512,
0.8825162053,
0.4041398466,
0.0387529172,
-1.1482820511,
0.4809602797,
-0.4208836854,
-0.3156852424,
0.0660702512,
-0.0750347748,
-0.8057211041,
-0.1716941744,
-0.4863637388,
-0.966914773,
0.8490994573,
0.308103919,
0.0892553329,
0.5593039989,
-0.4559129179,
0.6098408103,
-0.4678628147,
-0.5064053535,
-0.1230278313,
-0.2869403362,
0.1799263507,
-0.5785093904,
-0.2891167402,
-0.6750761867,
-0.3562090993,
0.9354484677,
-0.3634032309,
0.6467618346,
-0.04133958,
0.0658372492,
0.0015395017,
0.3107596338,
0.1807741523,
0.3204641342,
0.1980777085,
0.1104866415,
-0.0138775092,
-0.1759404391,
-0.5030504465,
0.7210251689,
-0.4515397847,
-0.8432337642,
-0.5766560435,
-0.4221097827,
-0.2510111034,
0.3597768247,
0.2171874642,
0.4936940968,
-0.1007795632,
0.1832201183,
0.666765213,
0.0467917249,
0.1954025328,
0.1861418784,
-0.0016565057,
-0.3876687288,
1.0301822424,
0.3111544549,
0.0599081293,
0.402176559,
0.4304443002,
-0.3461967111,
-0.6286355853,
0.0788739398,
0.5012868643,
-0.5579324365,
-0.2380363941,
-0.816641748,
0.2506808639,
-0.3103279471,
-0.4886517823,
-0.4935956299,
-0.5815054774,
-0.5559187531,
0.1081546247,
0.613700211,
0.4803748429,
-0.1544623822,
0.4283644259,
-0.580306828,
0.4219858646,
0.4680967033,
0.5493268371,
0.014064474,
-0.374987781,
0.0480538383,
-0.0415798873,
-0.1681195199,
-0.8115257621,
0.2999261916,
0.2232723534,
0.6189385653,
0.9546759129,
0.4075321257,
0.6751852632,
-0.5892574787,
0.4930351973,
0.1949986666,
-1.0795511007,
0.9133780599,
-0.4470078945,
-0.0900338888,
0.7231805325,
0.93512398,
-0.8200674057,
-0.1320655793,
-0.7461348772,
-1.0283974409,
0.4640184641,
0.0182712898,
0.3670036495,
-0.2742953598,
0.5286827087,
0.2890318632,
0.6410700083,
-0.0116222715,
-0.205702886,
-0.3381947279,
-0.0374683961,
-0.0386488661,
-0.5324081779,
-0.1663051546,
-0.4429253936,
0.5094602704,
-0.3160456419,
0.4676429331,
-0.1958398968,
0.169984147,
0.0462391973,
0.1245492846,
0.3382380605,
1.1412316561,
-0.7722237706,
0.4556541741,
-0.366263777,
-0.5612217188,
0.1125441343,
0.0228564609,
-0.228142187,
0.2269747406,
0.1114798635,
0.5332719088,
0.0634356886,
-0.6369342804,
0.4344528019,
-0.1111594513,
-0.0210024789,
-0.060370367,
-0.0412297174,
0.1909201443,
0.1827350259,
0.2783203423,
-0.0223865751,
0.068315044,
-0.9704871178,
0.5334420204,
0.4132784605,
-0.172273472,
-0.4004713297,
0.6842672825,
0.1495890021,
-0.4931029379,
0.4797647595,
-0.0507372394,
-0.6312406659,
0.282202065,
0.2468221933,
0.7192158699,
-0.0882995576,
0.2870344222,
0.2752601802,
0.1981052458,
0.0609364137,
0.5184491277,
-0.1389125586,
-0.6968164444,
0.1939317137,
-0.4860705733,
-0.6186455488,
-0.219083488,
-0.6400663853,
0.5652385354,
-0.6654689312,
-0.3960649669,
-0.0006460781,
0.2676022351,
-0.365439266,
0.2035071999,
-0.4094239175,
1.1304831505,
-0.8162570596,
0.3044002056,
0.7770383358,
-0.4428249598,
-0.7267590761,
0.091848813,
-0.019357346,
-0.6063744426,
0.3866323829,
-0.0670476332,
-0.1827355921,
-0.1207154095,
-0.6110158563,
-0.8580927849,
1.1893088818,
0.1067701876,
-0.5287687778,
-0.1531149894,
-0.1185552254,
0.3923106492,
-0.245450139,
-0.0962464213,
0.3758867979,
0.2740927041,
0.4354545474,
-0.2320055962,
-0.0123832608,
-0.3024661541,
-0.2951769233,
0.4649297297,
-0.5417618752,
1.049498558,
0.0309466813,
-0.3043962419,
0.113392815,
0.3870562315,
0.3118543327,
0.4180140197,
0.6496472955,
0.3287053406,
0.9940156937,
-0.4246124625,
0.4172964394,
-0.3969208002,
0.6425311565,
0.9235019088,
-0.2353521734,
0.7756785154,
0.6455370784,
0.0049038273,
0.139490217,
1.1917815208,
-0.1715076268,
0.7960937619,
0.2092716992,
-0.2336120158,
-0.2307870239,
-0.568815589,
-0.3067098558,
0.4503906965,
0.3748324513,
0.0204150509,
-0.0212725531,
-0.1593898088,
0.1947984546,
-0.0565272123,
-0.1605693549,
0.4691206813,
-0.063178502,
-0.2369323969,
0.1667524874,
-0.1194222197,
0.9970800281,
-0.7769112587,
-0.1835372001,
-0.57456249,
-0.0563257523,
-0.1996462643,
-0.8055664897,
0.1910024136,
-0.0614132211,
-0.2058196664,
-0.3725245893,
0.9862242341,
-0.1264344752,
-0.4579463899,
0.0285845771,
0.529409349,
0.1328741759,
-0.3508875668,
-0.2642363906,
-0.150668785,
-0.3149575889,
0.0604028627,
-0.0649767667,
0.5210015774,
-0.2747834325,
0.7259136438,
0.6678171754,
0.3022728264,
-0.0109843994,
-0.1091921106,
0.9819794297,
-0.6740127802,
-0.4037117362,
-0.3527427316,
0.1936222464,
-0.009261094,
-0.2798270881,
0.5233212113,
0.5436351895,
0.9804150462,
-0.208408013,
0.36551103,
-0.3157567084,
0.6683260202,
-0.3447845578,
0.9634810686,
-0.9620050192,
0.1766614765,
-0.5804607272,
-0.8641704917,
-0.2646434903,
0.4976449311,
0.1230176687,
-0.2043530196,
0.7066727877,
0.696595788,
-0.4268487394,
-0.2835642993,
0.0911278948,
-0.1791220754,
0.3919655979,
0.1336602569,
1.0468426943,
0.4114502072,
0.1078777462,
-1.069668293,
-0.2846407592,
-0.1872891337,
-0.8912528157,
-0.7776139379,
-0.7434571981,
-0.2940424979,
0.0955686122,
0.0906157941,
1.0420511961,
0.8019536734,
-0.7121203542,
-0.2329050899,
0.1933670044,
0.181268096,
-0.1670046598,
-0.232914418,
0.8104439378,
-0.0855970681,
-0.7346286178,
0.1362229139,
0.3940626681,
-0.1212868392,
-0.1132443994,
0.4717640579,
-0.4204176366,
0.1392611861,
0.6767923236,
0.0189721137,
-0.5830557346,
-0.5584181547,
0.4786954224,
0.2879365385,
0.1484403759,
1.1886582375,
-0.3141669035,
0.5418621302,
0.7016606927,
0.5257136226,
0.5685108304,
0.1161852852,
0.1692214459,
-0.5203742981,
0.0222778302,
0.165871501,
0.3970912397,
-0.0520983525,
-0.4339814782,
0.5746120214,
0.9130941033,
-0.0348856859,
-0.699488163,
0.2297700197,
-1.252494812,
-0.1466457844,
0.5108841062,
-0.0087177521,
0.0918576419,
0.0692155063,
-0.3061072528,
0.0112659018,
-0.3383090198,
0.9021282196,
0.3085774183,
-0.4958796501,
0.0664549768,
-0.1943998635,
0.1336493194,
0.0321438983,
-0.9052456021,
-0.1418506354,
0.3529219627,
0.4143859744,
0.2779553533,
0.4035575092,
0.1875207126,
0.142848596,
-0.0972986743,
0.0329955295,
0.1319146901,
-0.73116225,
0.2485108525,
0.1594865024,
0.2933035791,
-0.4820704162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13609v1 | Physarum Inspired Bicycle Lane Network Design in a Congested Mega City | 2023-01-29T16:55:49 | 2023-01-29T16:55:49 | Md. Ahsan Habib, M. A. H. Akhand | physics.soc-ph | physics.soc-ph, cs.CL | Mobility is a key factor in urban life and transport network plays a vital
role in mobility. Worse transport network having less mobility is one of the
key reasons to decline the living standard in any unplanned mega city.
Transport mobility enhancement in an unplanned mega city is always challenging
due to various constraints including complex design and high cost involvement.
The aim of this thesis is to enhance transport mobility in a megacity
introducing a bicycle lane. To design the bicycle lane natural Physarum,
brainless single celled multi-nucleated protist, is studied and modified for
better optimization. Recently Physarum inspired techniques are drawn
significant attention to the construction of effective networks. Exiting
Physarum inspired models effectively and efficiently solves different problems
including transport network design and modification and implication for bicycle
lane is the unique contribution of this study. Central area of Dhaka, the
capital city of Bangladesh, is considered to analyze and design the bicycle
lane network bypassing primary roads. | [
-0.3064722717,
-0.6723025441,
0.3723910749,
0.159287855,
-0.4246261716,
0.0170768686,
0.0818947628,
-0.2262521982,
0.4683841467,
0.5712460876,
-0.7834793329,
-0.0522749946,
0.1061922535,
0.2795075476,
-0.1188642606,
0.4826910198,
0.1953946799,
0.0829860121,
0.2177196443,
-0.4081403017,
-0.2896657586,
-0.4274767637,
-0.4085666835,
-0.2883985937,
0.3104339242,
0.216285497,
0.8004793525,
0.3677585721,
0.3568429351,
0.456815362,
-0.5160681605,
0.6009879112,
-0.2253782898,
0.0369440541,
-0.400067687,
0.0271689445,
-0.5653410554,
-0.4841558039,
1.0042970181,
0.9999729991,
-0.014485891,
-0.1093236804,
0.3275833726,
0.8783761263,
-0.8578652143,
0.1752760559,
0.143692255,
-0.164683044,
-0.8051327467,
-0.3277202249,
-0.1408596784,
-0.9137883186,
-0.2535321414,
-0.845464468,
-0.4277918637,
0.2244731337,
0.2751385272,
0.2517889142,
-0.7389166355,
-0.4600823224,
-0.807631731,
0.5112566352,
-0.4611051977,
0.1289995909,
0.0305065848,
0.3149632215,
-0.5781180859,
-0.2869840264,
-0.4667678475,
0.2915045917,
-0.2941661179,
0.1569464803,
-0.2515712976,
0.1003559753,
-0.1985439062,
-0.0819276795,
-0.7655420899,
-0.2108977586,
-0.4280607998,
-0.0813121349,
0.578222394,
0.7601869106,
0.4253739119,
-0.4719679654,
-0.2814885378,
0.2540256977,
-0.5909116268,
0.3463667333,
0.8072857857,
0.3024491072,
-0.1342850477,
0.3152678311,
-0.6849281788,
0.798419714,
-0.069341816,
-0.2082413286,
0.6585193276,
-0.6216635704,
-0.2113044113,
0.1116495281,
0.5106503963,
0.1807459742,
0.4516707659,
-0.3166992664,
0.3634037375,
-0.2161379009,
0.2090404779,
-0.953004837,
-0.5105848908,
0.147145614,
-0.6959564686,
-0.3635411561,
0.1062864885,
-1.1992088556,
-0.2181936651,
-0.1550542116,
0.140562728,
-0.5451273918,
-0.9369037747,
0.4017109275,
0.0316022225,
-0.027246071,
0.1505619437,
-0.6508479714,
0.343123287,
0.2535485923,
0.9504689574,
0.1814209223,
0.0843247771,
-0.0294087548,
0.4276631773,
-0.6063041687,
1.152315259,
-0.3583617806,
-0.6372534633,
-0.2193220258,
0.1840958595,
-0.143723622,
-0.5493966937,
0.5387151241,
-0.372023046,
-0.4206193984,
-0.0419194065,
-0.0642005354,
-0.9405716658,
0.0473793112,
-0.5695046782,
0.2822623551,
0.1664279699,
-0.9232754707,
-0.3002794385,
-0.7642716765,
-1.1130578518,
0.577126205,
0.3292024434,
-0.5556008816,
0.1290146261,
-0.1850411743,
-0.0822574049,
0.1835515052,
0.0018236676,
-0.5875717998,
-0.4981869459,
0.1330304295,
-0.2332675159,
1.5022972822,
0.285613209,
-0.1866803169,
0.1264729649,
-1.0581892729,
0.49130404,
-0.1341830045,
-0.2146300972,
-0.6312106848,
0.2462339699,
0.0781990588,
-0.0455387905,
0.0049954373,
-0.4353017211,
0.2392931879,
-0.6929439902,
0.3437433541,
0.9498398304,
0.5754180551,
0.6696307659,
-0.3213323951,
0.4436244667,
-0.0617085397,
0.411753267,
0.475079,
-0.6838988066,
-0.1776670218,
-0.2760676742,
0.1311147511,
0.5522322059,
-0.6356755495,
0.1730391234,
-0.0115855001,
-0.7112259269,
-0.1741247922,
-0.0349553488,
-0.076668635,
0.1206665039,
0.0541987568,
-0.1625495851,
-0.6106545925,
-0.8880444169,
0.2424164116,
0.1370248646,
0.5509268641,
0.0171945319,
0.4769076705,
-0.5316462517,
0.8800156713,
-0.4535425603,
-0.1575564593,
-0.4732158482,
-0.4571420848,
0.4078706801,
0.7861221433,
0.6120946407,
-1.0304396152,
-0.2580671906,
-0.3097866774,
-0.4051894546,
-0.4353023171,
-0.007580474,
-0.3427503705,
-0.2185673565,
-0.0478190705,
-1.1950200796,
0.7397634983,
0.3378081918,
-0.3316865265,
1.1915435791,
-0.4682793915,
0.1913931519,
-0.8003633022,
0.2321074456,
-0.3337762058,
-0.1691788286,
-0.7062956691,
0.1879119873,
-0.1112197936,
-0.2157841474,
-0.2782330215,
0.1376178414,
-0.3113386035,
-0.0155217433,
-0.6842244267,
0.0441998653,
-0.2929489315,
0.4215530157,
-0.404094696,
0.590721488,
0.6113541126,
-0.8589885831,
0.2347438782,
0.3703972995,
-0.2706181705,
0.6423594356,
-0.2889380157,
0.0334397405,
-0.0852191821,
0.2985701859,
-0.9505329728,
-0.0160051305,
0.7338587642,
-0.0652516708,
-0.1513185799,
0.3657388389,
-0.8688255548,
-0.4796980321,
-0.1253001541,
0.7088595629,
0.5599810481,
-0.3206869066,
0.7469853759,
0.4749001265,
0.0483372658,
0.4704341888,
-0.3687784076,
0.041162923,
-0.1676307619,
-0.5825639367,
0.2431377172,
-0.7009969354,
-0.5250549912,
-0.0415811539,
0.013707906,
-0.0771848336,
0.147634998,
0.6909453869,
-0.0909494981,
0.2157398611,
-0.1412132233,
0.0103062568,
-0.5160489082,
-0.0919216946,
-0.3315485418,
0.5376437306,
0.4052537382,
-0.1518839896,
-1.0685970783,
0.5526738167,
0.8878730536,
-0.3632605076,
0.3010757267,
0.4112851918,
-0.3662851751,
-0.3420287967,
0.231372267,
-0.174158752,
-0.5443640947,
0.2413996905,
-0.2949787378,
-0.3931070864,
0.0490312353,
-0.533403337,
-0.5523445606,
0.0038208112,
0.5967904329,
-0.2374523282,
1.0161497593,
0.5347994566,
0.2599189579,
0.0208520982,
-0.0381905772,
0.7109856606,
-0.7446103692,
-0.5769783854,
-0.6532498002,
-0.3914949596,
-1.1061902046,
-0.1736190468,
0.5575854778,
0.0382045768,
-0.3993458152,
0.2974521816,
-0.6141127944,
-0.2147940844,
0.3459917307,
0.5615323186,
0.0592131093,
-0.2199756056,
-0.2884300947,
0.2117805332,
-1.2003566027,
-0.2313462049,
0.5226151347,
-0.2711029947,
0.2574161887,
0.2791781723,
0.1587734371,
0.2278808653,
0.0872117653,
-0.1353561729,
0.9157935381,
-0.1723085195,
-0.6611849666,
0.0602563061,
-0.5347271562,
-0.990668714,
0.1662851572,
-0.2714092433,
-0.5924551487,
0.3092578948,
-0.1575258821,
-0.8344201446,
0.8971874714,
-0.1896829456,
0.5062009096,
-0.10110984,
-0.5015050173,
-0.5455804467,
-0.5198616982,
0.228706196,
-0.0245278757,
0.9038472176,
0.09691073,
0.2945758998,
0.6025925875,
-0.6902189851,
0.7917160988,
0.0579163507,
0.3341288269,
0.691216886,
0.3134587705,
0.2146374881,
-0.2734138072,
-0.1187103242,
0.0770409033,
-0.4279257059,
-0.5014504194,
-0.1386742294,
0.4069776237,
-0.6144276261,
-0.3018808067,
-0.0227324385,
-0.8756760359,
0.0800114647,
0.3179596364,
0.1485019028,
1.0958441496,
0.4624987841,
0.04891482,
0.39349401,
-0.1560348719,
0.8144379854,
0.3438744843,
-0.124402523,
-0.6047639251,
0.6521682739,
0.4658905268,
0.0903901234,
0.1067766473,
0.2738679647,
-0.0764430538,
-0.6522836089,
-0.4417180419,
-0.0671224892,
-0.2226650566,
-0.1925584525,
-0.3985456228,
-0.0169414412,
-0.6283490062,
-0.1155105904,
-0.2424116433,
-0.2519327402,
-0.1197672039,
0.0618082322,
0.1377984136,
1.120046258,
-0.6620781422,
0.358186394,
-0.4194632769,
0.139744848,
0.1456472725,
0.2319591492,
0.3149599731,
-0.1083516404,
-0.4117141366,
0.063567698,
-0.6270727515,
-1.3678984642,
0.5605927706,
-0.4604554474,
0.6810637712,
0.5705849528,
0.1465502977,
0.7647999525,
-0.4092164934,
0.2159373611,
0.1779248565,
-0.5337505341,
0.3455172777,
-0.4787007868,
0.3183487058,
0.1644956023,
0.2569656074,
-0.0220835935,
-0.2433147132,
-0.4670494199,
-0.5880286098,
-0.1283642352,
0.7192646861,
-0.4188293815,
0.0114738327,
0.5596442819,
0.0071754777,
0.3796904385,
-0.3300641477,
-0.3107923865,
-0.1743077636,
-0.0548859984,
0.0095530534,
-0.1390360892,
0.4502967298,
-0.5667034388,
0.6540650129,
0.2815252542,
-0.1522714943,
0.394302398,
0.2852832079,
-0.2273139209,
0.2082488388,
0.7037422061,
0.6459753513,
-0.0439108126,
0.218163237,
0.1690355986,
-0.3586813509,
0.426135093,
-0.4173292816,
-0.7022137046,
0.0308926422,
0.2026944011,
0.1583928317,
0.4062808752,
-0.3902969062,
-0.0556191169,
0.6890695095,
-0.0708730221,
-0.2003840506,
0.177066341,
0.2324134856,
0.5217522979,
0.6385574341,
0.6447857022,
0.3693840504,
-0.5278379917,
0.0598493777,
0.5215537548,
-0.2413963228,
-0.5118468404,
0.5960026383,
0.1971440464,
-1.0264031887,
0.6012845635,
-0.7023319602,
-0.9467816949,
0.6809260845,
0.4570402205,
0.5388177633,
-0.6167339683,
0.1116341054,
0.5398303866,
0.631945312,
0.2680341899,
0.0452061929,
-0.0263088383,
-0.5100880861,
-0.2824964225,
-0.5295351744,
-0.0360006057,
-0.2819588482,
-0.284439981,
0.1948970705,
-0.3473897278,
-0.2682678103,
-0.8221424222,
0.4466329515,
-0.0734306648,
0.2986918986,
-0.0676177964,
0.9810993075,
-0.7729287148,
0.7008582354,
0.8455814719,
-0.1194791272,
-0.8119912148,
-0.0715826899,
-0.0903017819,
-0.066928871,
0.3625870049,
0.2530684173,
-0.3880276084,
0.1290574223,
-0.3245804608,
-0.5174495578,
1.0198297501,
-0.1580720097,
-0.70337677,
0.0350387245,
0.2228746265,
0.2711020112,
-0.2660651803,
-0.0198236741,
0.1987558305,
0.8372582197,
-0.3522195816,
-0.6733347774,
0.1260470748,
-0.3018892109,
0.0793718472,
0.2299272865,
-1.2661374807,
0.8592891097,
-0.3467440307,
-0.3367460966,
0.7345759273,
0.1287032962,
0.540384531,
0.3773162961,
0.738820672,
0.7484219074,
0.6117247343,
0.4100528359,
0.7877544761,
-0.4525380731,
0.2865613699,
0.3711944818,
-0.284786284,
0.2788641453,
0.4014559388,
0.0876007602,
0.8939358592,
0.554441154,
0.4742007852,
0.9690605402,
0.5250748992,
-0.3049658239,
-0.70448488,
0.1092914715,
-0.2784577608,
0.5502690673,
0.0350759439,
0.6056728959,
-0.5406993628,
0.3863890469,
-0.0089145694,
0.3036024868,
-0.8413841724,
0.3271903992,
-0.1074334607,
0.0654423609,
-0.2996938527,
-0.082139045,
0.2849413753,
-0.6005833745,
0.1809801459,
0.1246809065,
0.5677905083,
-0.299428165,
-0.6339972615,
0.5106992126,
-0.6654842496,
-0.0174234193,
-0.1749640107,
0.9501957297,
0.0581241436,
-0.6643973589,
0.5686392784,
0.2612061799,
0.1019384265,
0.0244039427,
-0.3580651879,
0.2709071338,
-0.143195942,
-0.1774615496,
0.1629084647,
0.4479548037,
0.2443484217,
0.9150164723,
0.717936635,
0.6469448805,
-0.3570418954,
-0.4736410677,
0.682939291,
-0.5711249113,
-1.048794508,
-0.9916645885,
0.3980651498,
-0.0499950908,
-0.1004694849,
0.8257389665,
0.7381583452,
0.149591282,
0.1254394203,
0.664152205,
-0.0821743533,
0.3720232546,
-0.2279713899,
0.8047139645,
-0.2316275984,
-0.1543713808,
-0.158931002,
-0.5867950916,
-0.0451155752,
1.0035897493,
-0.3480386436,
-0.0314149149,
0.6982799768,
0.7911345363,
0.0960219726,
0.5510223508,
0.1602799147,
0.3794526756,
0.0427025966,
0.862570703,
0.5139872432,
-0.1351559013,
0.5196509957,
-0.443641156,
-0.4249226749,
-0.2959801257,
-0.5648959875,
-0.57259202,
-0.5587345958,
-0.4245480299,
-0.2550558746,
0.513138473,
0.4570917785,
1.2289686203,
-0.5991626382,
-0.2756140232,
-0.3494015336,
0.3823562264,
-0.3219892383,
-0.2426303178,
0.3187419176,
0.0495371297,
-0.0426011011,
0.420752883,
0.7128151655,
-0.2118022591,
-0.5125268102,
0.0922575891,
-0.2248886228,
0.010539921,
0.5126460791,
-0.1285536587,
0.3218566477,
-0.3422290683,
-0.3130989671,
-0.0376616679,
-0.0566249639,
1.0020723343,
-0.7907399535,
-0.1734564453,
0.4598246217,
0.1606106758,
0.0712502301,
0.1908935905,
0.1425775886,
0.11997585,
0.3698668182,
-0.007909216,
0.2874594927,
0.015343857,
-0.3096220195,
0.2600330114,
1.1443830729,
-0.776694119,
-0.5090650916,
0.3562346995,
-1.169547081,
-0.7597870231,
1.1263821125,
0.357629627,
-0.726534605,
-0.6841316223,
-0.274745971,
0.2506730855,
0.0399003997,
0.6078763604,
0.245022431,
-0.292732209,
0.0971477628,
-0.7826269865,
-0.0689250305,
0.1224333942,
-0.6292076707,
-0.0718501285,
0.2112629116,
0.6103880405,
0.3789110184,
0.8089268804,
-0.0431275591,
0.3458360434,
0.0637823045,
-0.0512690805,
-0.2408208251,
-0.284968704,
0.1042239964,
1.1005555391,
-0.5984545946,
-0.4307758212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12473v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12473v2 | Large Language Models for Biomedical Knowledge Graph Construction: Information extraction from EMR notes | 2023-01-29T15:52:33 | 2023-12-09T17:31:49 | Vahan Arsenyan, Spartak Bughdaryan, Fadi Shaya, Kent Small, Davit Shahnazaryan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The automatic construction of knowledge graphs (KGs) is an important research
area in medicine, with far-reaching applications spanning drug discovery and
clinical trial design. These applications hinge on the accurate identification
of interactions among medical and biological entities. In this study, we
propose an end-to-end machine learning solution based on large language models
(LLMs) that utilize electronic medical record notes to construct KGs. The
entities used in the KG construction process are diseases, factors, treatments,
as well as manifestations that coexist with the patient while experiencing the
disease. Given the critical need for high-quality performance in medical
applications, we embark on a comprehensive assessment of 12 LLMs of various
architectures, evaluating their performance and safety attributes. To gauge the
quantitative efficacy of our approach by assessing both precision and recall,
we manually annotate a dataset provided by the Macula and Retina Institute. We
also assess the qualitative performance of LLMs, such as the ability to
generate structured outputs or the tendency to hallucinate. The results
illustrate that in contrast to encoder-only and encoder-decoder, decoder-only
LLMs require further investigation. Additionally, we provide guided prompt
design to utilize such LLMs. The application of the proposed methodology is
demonstrated on age-related macular degeneration. | [
-0.1218820065,
-1.2768560648,
0.7420606017,
-0.1290440857,
-0.2059847862,
-0.0255821683,
-0.1554210037,
-0.6406767368,
0.3263791203,
0.7875860333,
-0.0532723069,
-0.9109296203,
-0.8076614141,
0.3852539957,
-0.0655388981,
0.7371332645,
-0.289392978,
0.1930130422,
-0.4360181987,
0.0102298744,
-0.1553325504,
-0.383787334,
-0.7437335253,
-0.4915590882,
0.6897634864,
0.2692785561,
0.3202158809,
0.7565129995,
0.7147494555,
0.296317488,
-0.231802687,
0.4009584188,
-0.2168184668,
0.233068347,
0.0649741217,
-0.1895484775,
-0.7926743627,
-0.3526137173,
0.423864156,
0.8020446897,
-0.0127769085,
0.1467911452,
-0.0402852222,
0.8110992312,
-0.2783353031,
0.5820043683,
-0.3569267094,
0.3721235394,
-0.0465860516,
-0.4292391837,
-0.555293262,
-0.3056510389,
0.0112386737,
-0.5323055983,
-0.2475127578,
0.2229141742,
0.7233828902,
0.1741354465,
-0.7169444561,
-0.6350991726,
-0.397267431,
0.4646362066,
-0.7266610265,
0.5516915917,
0.4722188115,
0.4635266364,
-0.4676395953,
-0.8334937692,
-0.156842947,
-0.4758466482,
-0.1103912443,
0.2697793543,
-0.035593994,
0.3440050185,
0.3413799107,
0.0723323449,
-0.5802263021,
0.2252233922,
-0.6447337866,
-0.1702049524,
0.4591696858,
0.3431527913,
0.3321082294,
-0.37678653,
-0.1827461421,
0.2290552258,
-0.7712313533,
-0.2011504918,
-0.0827129558,
0.1501633227,
-0.0065937322,
0.9693188667,
-0.3043883443,
0.773928225,
-0.0856979415,
-0.4138724804,
0.4520642757,
0.0599595048,
-0.2589358985,
0.1301034093,
0.9639768004,
0.3330847025,
0.2354058921,
-0.4661508203,
-0.1260683835,
-0.3061594069,
0.0731038079,
-0.9075328708,
-0.3507450223,
0.2700154185,
-0.7843375802,
-0.3873452544,
-0.357306093,
-0.8116236329,
-0.4252306819,
-0.4833688736,
0.3104168177,
-0.7054191232,
0.024183372,
0.0139127607,
-0.0313495509,
-0.1086567119,
0.2700267136,
-0.6335641742,
0.1899258196,
0.3328391314,
0.7191289663,
-0.013692488,
0.0068291272,
-0.4462850392,
0.631739974,
-0.2927639484,
0.4638045728,
-0.4100935459,
-0.4798022211,
-0.1505753845,
0.1000611633,
0.0281758085,
-0.6596415043,
0.5424399972,
-0.5962404013,
-0.1267886609,
0.0163360555,
-0.8070884347,
-0.1382041126,
0.3309778869,
-0.6774077415,
0.5716741681,
0.2219342291,
-0.6979929805,
0.1702662855,
-0.7059758902,
-0.6907299757,
0.2053067684,
-0.3736720681,
-0.6157557368,
0.0518369749,
0.2833384573,
0.7378157973,
-0.4227263629,
0.4223143458,
-0.3995288312,
0.1440414339,
0.3486565053,
-0.135994181,
0.4886518419,
0.3690333068,
0.0792956427,
0.0380422287,
-0.9726596475,
-0.0953744426,
0.2185776085,
-0.5682296753,
-0.3163011372,
0.0685766116,
-0.1633608043,
0.1580429375,
0.3037828505,
-0.7113767862,
0.1612125933,
-0.2419328541,
0.5289133191,
0.5117120147,
0.160707131,
0.1016722172,
-0.2356861234,
0.3862704933,
0.1999216825,
0.3262857199,
-0.1765164137,
-0.5239461064,
-0.3285393715,
-0.412801981,
0.2721278965,
0.521350503,
-0.7116716504,
0.4482522309,
-0.461109668,
-0.3536388576,
-0.2461652458,
0.196858421,
0.39633286,
0.8129813075,
0.3901821375,
-0.1974454075,
-0.5284070969,
-0.7624784112,
0.1844539642,
-0.192246154,
-0.0608737841,
0.7052827477,
0.506701827,
-0.5576313138,
0.9136449695,
-0.7383491397,
-0.3623365164,
-0.1357438564,
-0.0381778218,
0.0229843725,
0.2170324475,
0.2890082896,
-0.6882582903,
-0.3056581318,
0.4943039417,
-1.1496363878,
-0.1919136494,
0.301476568,
0.0512178056,
0.1133646742,
0.7780939341,
-0.6748154759,
0.1393097937,
0.3589476943,
-0.2300048321,
0.4182201624,
-0.4822132289,
0.0841851383,
-1.2013609409,
0.5016298294,
0.1159768254,
-0.2505850792,
-0.4704338014,
-0.3263697624,
0.1393647045,
-0.1771839559,
-0.0219215695,
0.5016722083,
-0.3665151,
-0.0275479741,
-0.0138488375,
0.0253523886,
0.0549119078,
0.2847200334,
-0.0900045112,
0.0298913941,
0.2193458825,
-0.4806878567,
0.4591639936,
0.35034132,
-0.3467466235,
0.1446180493,
-0.681419909,
0.0325831808,
-0.376639992,
0.2846676111,
-0.753151536,
-0.4556994438,
0.3851838708,
-0.7006735206,
0.6678487659,
-0.209031105,
-0.5211439729,
-0.5047367811,
0.1186294854,
0.1212221682,
0.5337365866,
-0.1304828227,
0.727535069,
0.7478391528,
-0.4543302357,
-0.4100809395,
-0.5821754932,
0.2297468632,
-0.1193414181,
-0.6069193482,
0.2431485206,
0.2105932981,
-0.1526825279,
0.1637488902,
0.2643854022,
-0.1313142926,
0.0774099082,
0.4476775527,
0.3003186285,
-0.2065140009,
0.3367682099,
0.1568650454,
-0.1057875082,
0.1679859906,
-0.1650334597,
0.3428922296,
0.3160861433,
-0.4281053245,
-0.2107785046,
0.2367162406,
0.8382307887,
-0.3349198699,
0.6382822394,
0.4353215992,
-0.5009590387,
-0.0599467009,
-0.472096473,
-0.0489897616,
-0.4287014306,
0.6759360433,
-0.3989343643,
-0.8700088263,
0.5957994461,
-0.5160052776,
-0.1341006011,
0.4232951999,
0.5631101131,
-0.0142260157,
1.0472831726,
0.5213161707,
0.0181020387,
0.1829019189,
-0.0894790962,
0.1897251457,
-0.973923862,
-0.6956828237,
-0.3580755293,
-0.0409168452,
-0.3263785541,
-0.2844595015,
0.5228351951,
0.1213399768,
-0.2632563114,
-0.0946591645,
-0.323433429,
0.2191241533,
0.0776325241,
0.4325340986,
0.2648078799,
0.0820004493,
-0.3278318644,
0.2174689323,
-0.7439409494,
-0.5144053102,
1.3725634813,
0.5519439578,
0.8732581139,
-0.0515977554,
0.6211646199,
0.1472573578,
0.5795611143,
-0.8088613153,
0.489030838,
-0.2183215171,
-0.3195827901,
-0.3158334792,
-0.8897147775,
-0.9990464449,
-0.1566441953,
-0.1990921646,
-0.7125834227,
-0.1959147602,
0.1229667291,
-0.1386153996,
0.3658436835,
-0.5674974322,
0.8432580233,
-0.4387709498,
-0.2019517124,
0.0590059236,
-0.8097137213,
0.3570196331,
-0.33933267,
0.3739416003,
0.143821314,
0.0989935771,
0.7609161139,
-0.2050363123,
0.8768097758,
-0.0763137043,
-0.1805792749,
0.1865061074,
-0.0612427741,
0.6143836975,
-0.1614018679,
0.0453575291,
0.1607479453,
-0.0939545557,
-0.0769914836,
-0.4341065586,
0.5099315643,
-0.7130685449,
-0.2432069033,
0.0285001118,
-0.5857129693,
-0.2261781543,
0.1807439923,
0.1024981141,
0.7475251555,
-0.1615162641,
0.1428515166,
0.6311137676,
-0.5431507826,
0.0253536031,
0.5600830913,
-0.3992521167,
-0.7110002041,
0.870871067,
0.265386194,
0.1648057401,
0.5846384168,
0.2486847341,
-0.2846438289,
-0.7888680696,
-0.5097243786,
0.2751145959,
-0.7445990443,
-0.2021374553,
-0.7608695626,
-0.2727095187,
-0.6007651687,
0.0643926859,
0.0206495896,
-0.3365726471,
-0.1563981324,
-0.0880264267,
0.5654630065,
0.8857449889,
0.1353837997,
-0.1158488616,
-1.2823632956,
0.3962264955,
-0.0482814945,
0.3009791374,
0.1097248867,
-0.2565799654,
-0.5686170459,
-0.0514810085,
-0.3404109776,
-0.9098317623,
0.5247684717,
0.1497341841,
0.6993970275,
0.5027031898,
-0.1146927923,
0.3996281028,
-0.6994249225,
0.3829934597,
0.3633357286,
-0.4882531464,
0.5839790106,
-0.2908904254,
-0.1692983806,
0.1088594496,
0.3382499218,
-0.4113922715,
-0.1599058211,
-0.3991654515,
-0.9569150805,
0.3637388945,
-0.1035743505,
-0.3995429873,
-0.1925796568,
0.6120790839,
0.0131553914,
0.0526091568,
-0.3906202912,
-0.1864225119,
0.279147476,
-0.7152437568,
-0.0535696931,
-0.2559670806,
-0.2678391039,
-0.0105147613,
0.4585195482,
-0.1989787668,
0.1811000705,
0.4467667937,
-0.2550644875,
-0.2496484965,
0.1913514882,
0.2523735464,
0.5207722187,
-0.2742346823,
0.2120363116,
0.1319779903,
-0.5763862729,
-0.0932836533,
0.1883981973,
-0.1546114832,
-0.1448392272,
0.328112632,
0.563601613,
-0.0143711083,
-0.9060551524,
0.3214719594,
0.1235963777,
-0.1784666777,
-0.2424482405,
-0.2451199293,
0.2010278106,
0.3094004989,
0.0814371705,
-0.2596542835,
0.1351435781,
-0.3059292138,
0.3522481918,
0.4474633038,
-0.4853870869,
-0.1937948614,
0.5983242989,
0.2541488707,
-0.1348508894,
0.6032687426,
0.0225284081,
-0.4785248637,
0.778068006,
0.6916481853,
0.6008635759,
-0.1305472553,
0.0182274692,
0.3137571216,
0.2275721878,
0.1346964389,
0.1198696643,
0.0995893851,
-0.5283551812,
-0.6969777346,
-0.7286111116,
-0.2876825035,
0.0812506899,
-0.4071742296,
0.2932502627,
-0.1854698658,
-0.3231975138,
0.1778302342,
-0.0464795828,
-0.3279832006,
0.2618529201,
0.2930847406,
0.7700705528,
-0.8172125816,
0.8575978279,
0.7362565398,
-0.4067405462,
-0.5879237652,
-0.5755915046,
-0.0961652473,
-0.6705377102,
1.0213350058,
-0.002254402,
0.1990685165,
0.003814633,
-0.2796687484,
-0.6972649097,
1.3109785318,
0.2415727079,
-0.6353327036,
-0.1901859641,
0.319504261,
0.4747520387,
-0.4041028619,
0.2148361355,
0.22461164,
0.2757766247,
0.1677643955,
-0.8923491836,
0.2531459928,
-0.2674642503,
-0.3601064682,
0.5600598454,
-0.4447455406,
0.6277167201,
-0.3291655481,
0.0204350594,
0.0956075415,
0.2964647114,
0.2969462574,
0.5571795106,
0.0596210845,
0.7731657624,
0.8474299312,
0.1728260964,
0.9832677841,
-0.5525515079,
0.2571433187,
0.7360287309,
-0.3396596313,
0.6140773892,
0.4550784826,
-0.1701887101,
0.1433472931,
0.4568759203,
0.0157136936,
0.3328045011,
0.4715507627,
-0.062863864,
-0.0481763482,
-0.095565021,
-0.3626996577,
0.0705685392,
0.6553567648,
-0.9508757591,
-0.0384895876,
0.0393949598,
-0.0181225482,
-0.3707551658,
-0.3181178868,
0.8534037471,
0.4748631716,
-0.3133919835,
0.2263500839,
-0.0684741959,
0.1392157823,
-0.6972325444,
-0.2614354193,
0.1490032077,
0.2291076481,
-0.2102193832,
-0.6178546548,
0.0996109322,
-0.078520596,
-0.2175608724,
0.219746381,
0.837320447,
-0.4459398091,
-0.6683494449,
0.3686856925,
0.5624859333,
0.3264143169,
0.4609258771,
-0.3674021065,
-0.0673160478,
-0.1550685912,
-0.4552229941,
0.3684642613,
0.8274012208,
-0.050426323,
0.8420763612,
0.6268256307,
0.3863695264,
-0.15185754,
0.0768769383,
0.8342311382,
-0.662178874,
-0.0618569478,
-0.9445899129,
0.1880898327,
-0.1391401738,
-0.1384718269,
0.5790125728,
0.7204023004,
0.292794466,
0.0811767653,
0.8406120539,
0.0081330081,
0.4054835737,
-0.8124633431,
0.8813504577,
-0.4738039374,
0.1901299208,
-0.2995996773,
-0.5473204851,
-0.5010206103,
0.3706443012,
-0.2450389415,
-0.1018497348,
0.6309530735,
0.7120153904,
0.027723277,
-0.0423766412,
0.3482515514,
0.4844604135,
0.5472224951,
0.8302138448,
0.6685004234,
-0.2992549241,
0.4801107645,
-0.0232279468,
-0.2521737218,
-0.3085412383,
-0.7131491899,
-0.8289744854,
-0.3471027911,
-0.3017070293,
-0.5015563965,
0.0782633275,
0.8958765864,
0.4281242788,
-0.4896978438,
0.0293257758,
-0.0060385503,
-0.0932031944,
0.1216358617,
-0.0926411673,
0.8897354603,
-0.1793648154,
-0.2314169109,
0.2074275762,
0.357478261,
0.2126920968,
0.0587421805,
-0.2620480955,
0.2433956563,
-0.3015590906,
0.8523433805,
0.2368962318,
-0.5528244376,
-0.0640020296,
0.1555043757,
-0.2656986415,
0.0290277898,
0.641032517,
-0.6378001571,
0.4951485395,
0.5053056479,
0.7072057128,
0.5423897505,
-0.1236711517,
0.518086791,
-0.2561151981,
-0.3147540092,
0.2389874905,
0.5385924578,
0.3802420199,
-0.2532034516,
0.3812615275,
0.1999857873,
-0.794870913,
-0.6038957238,
0.1076980755,
-1.0192556381,
-0.3700303435,
1.3134409189,
-0.221364066,
-0.5284876823,
-0.3108103871,
-0.3671883941,
0.5464017391,
-0.0921806023,
0.8570280671,
0.4247714877,
-0.2717480063,
0.0565568209,
-0.6570182443,
0.2272435278,
-0.0592391789,
-0.9192784429,
0.1347916573,
0.6188083887,
0.3400714993,
0.0547002517,
0.5439413786,
-0.5783580542,
-0.0407246575,
-0.1603161544,
0.139481619,
-0.4019311368,
-0.2230205536,
-0.092442371,
0.4128882587,
0.0198769942,
0.0332512185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12463v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12463v2 | Linguistic Analysis using Paninian System of Sounds and Finite State Machines | 2023-01-29T15:22:10 | 2024-04-16T14:19:58 | Shreekanth M Prabhu, Abhisek Midye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL | The study of spoken languages comprises phonology, morphology, and grammar.
Analysis of a language can be based on its syntax, semantics, and pragmatics.
The languages can be classified as root languages, inflectional languages, and
stem languages. All these factors lead to the formation of vocabulary which has
commonality/similarity as well as distinct and subtle differences across
languages. In this paper, we make use of Paninian system of sounds to construct
a phonetic map and then words are represented as state transitions on the
phonetic map. Each group of related words that cut across languages is
represented by a m-language (morphological language). Morphological Finite
Automata (MFA) are defined that accept the words belonging to a given
m-language. This exercise can enable us to better understand the
inter-relationships between words in spoken languages in both language-agnostic
and language-cognizant manner. Based on our study and analysis, we propose an
Ecosystem Model for Linguistic Development with Sanskrit at the core, in place
of the widely accepted family tree model. | [
-0.5008250475,
-0.7219330072,
0.1113276333,
0.3405281901,
-0.4510747194,
0.3179193139,
-0.2145477682,
-0.3824081123,
0.4917085469,
0.3135724366,
-0.5690447688,
-0.3369581997,
-0.3158123493,
0.2574302256,
-0.4050365686,
0.4098459184,
0.2940248251,
0.0287250075,
0.3295505643,
-0.3003493845,
-0.417906642,
-0.5767216086,
-0.4308025241,
-0.3916581571,
0.0688919947,
0.0236000624,
0.6706927419,
0.6816825271,
0.4280317426,
0.4182851911,
-0.2700332701,
-0.1686399579,
-0.091706112,
0.3001585603,
-0.2489118129,
-0.5896205902,
-0.2136707604,
-0.2694631517,
0.6466012001,
0.7535614967,
-0.0782292783,
0.1102234796,
-0.1183816344,
0.2501187325,
-0.336715132,
0.4613716006,
-0.5402627587,
0.2670015693,
-0.609749198,
-0.3608392477,
-0.0973516554,
-0.3164469898,
0.1027370244,
-0.5953465104,
-0.1435617954,
-0.2051436603,
0.7869972587,
0.2753946483,
-0.0191170387,
-0.6998182535,
-0.7590133548,
0.6321237683,
-0.6805497408,
0.5007992387,
0.3192162514,
0.3255265951,
-0.2238439322,
-0.1582374424,
-0.8604342937,
-0.142888099,
0.0263412427,
0.2909721434,
-0.2254218161,
-0.1068419963,
-0.2673423886,
0.6284931302,
-0.501678288,
0.2017214894,
-0.3252469599,
-0.3148108125,
0.3999722302,
0.2992820144,
0.9900348783,
-0.6033947468,
-0.2550077438,
-0.1998131126,
-0.5946055651,
-0.0348021165,
0.4614737034,
0.6968283057,
0.0002456617,
0.7044069767,
-0.055793561,
0.6266271472,
-0.205202356,
-0.5230107307,
0.0448355787,
-0.4389080703,
-0.1745971292,
0.1192738563,
0.6302980781,
0.0202011783,
0.4783881307,
0.0858530626,
-0.0978402793,
0.847638011,
-0.2537528574,
-0.4027614295,
0.1358284801,
-0.168829903,
-0.3833861947,
-0.1976647526,
-0.3095353246,
-0.9959071875,
-0.1516651213,
-0.5196466446,
0.0719292238,
-1.0097419024,
-0.9508894682,
0.0701918676,
0.0265389625,
0.7103566527,
-0.1570556164,
-0.923312366,
0.7672552466,
0.972499907,
0.9645515084,
0.1639406979,
-0.29117167,
0.1545576006,
-0.0451477841,
-0.2202672958,
0.7244744897,
-0.9864010811,
-0.8177503347,
-0.0100935837,
-0.4177435338,
-0.2782419324,
-0.4974997938,
0.155777216,
-0.4368309081,
-0.0538319163,
-0.132353276,
-0.6001294851,
-0.465795517,
0.0334297195,
-0.4245433807,
0.8588355184,
0.0397260673,
-0.4778768122,
0.4834778011,
-0.8768133521,
-0.5155597329,
0.3857521713,
-0.3536776006,
0.14592655,
0.0364087299,
-0.1235815659,
0.2162488252,
-0.1728707403,
0.3191812932,
-0.0956174955,
0.0332815498,
0.134317562,
-0.0924622491,
1.0436929464,
0.4946455657,
-0.3119969666,
-0.1482610852,
-0.712500453,
0.0307758544,
-0.2554707825,
-0.3750881255,
-0.5881095529,
0.1933420599,
0.2502433062,
0.1027225181,
0.1182478443,
-0.6672284603,
0.1923655868,
-0.7850942612,
0.5845654011,
0.5939152241,
0.0410507582,
0.4127503335,
0.0789279714,
0.6782101393,
0.2807489336,
-0.0142886303,
-0.1643879265,
-0.5141164064,
-0.9215554595,
-0.3560053408,
0.4599898756,
0.7714349627,
-0.3971661031,
0.5780556202,
-0.3436633646,
-0.540158689,
-0.5721157193,
-0.139049381,
0.2972326279,
0.0559353568,
0.1405851543,
-0.6108497977,
-0.5596501231,
-0.8020527959,
0.0001394926,
-0.455598712,
0.3224746287,
-0.0610880293,
0.4053409994,
-0.3287573457,
1.1224740744,
-0.3065927923,
-0.1463351846,
-0.1295210123,
0.2190717608,
-0.0531136282,
0.4393422902,
0.6773225665,
-0.3973832726,
-0.3456732035,
0.342943877,
-0.5624684691,
-0.251378268,
0.3048352301,
-0.1933421344,
-0.0248363223,
0.38778162,
-0.5403187871,
0.5386520028,
0.3147702217,
-0.3327875733,
0.3592467308,
0.1168287769,
-0.0818580538,
-1.3712464571,
0.277112335,
-0.0376392938,
0.0871771425,
-0.6209585667,
0.3679908812,
-0.4038046002,
-0.4735788405,
-0.1128527597,
0.5187323689,
-0.3600268662,
-0.4146143198,
-0.4167717099,
-0.0659264922,
-0.6381281018,
0.4149336517,
0.0170852318,
0.6362149715,
0.9105472565,
-0.8158478737,
0.1619267315,
0.130019635,
-0.2198758125,
0.7356226444,
-0.3990153372,
-0.2390464097,
-0.1297081262,
0.0090913754,
-0.863360703,
-0.039584063,
0.3863103688,
-0.5640391111,
0.0576711111,
0.1450532079,
-0.6089065075,
0.0221106056,
0.1912725121,
0.4356507957,
0.4965034723,
-0.0875648335,
0.502453804,
0.7878800035,
-0.3596137464,
-0.263291657,
-0.4542040229,
-0.0447465107,
-0.4081274569,
-0.7238668203,
-0.0523991883,
0.0434300117,
-0.816436708,
0.0918432698,
0.1309399754,
-0.5349362493,
0.0846099555,
0.3779833317,
0.0713501051,
-0.5876995921,
0.2213932723,
0.276157409,
-0.1695813686,
-0.1167699546,
-0.3847590983,
0.8717281818,
-0.3525146842,
-0.0693775564,
-0.601498127,
0.4073132575,
1.0711261034,
-0.5667651296,
0.2143756747,
0.1729601324,
-0.5669923425,
-0.0082589677,
-0.0365502276,
-0.092451863,
-0.4038760364,
0.0610261187,
-0.6417752504,
-0.6164816022,
0.8598789573,
-0.3721230626,
-0.1078886688,
0.7317373157,
0.6493369937,
0.145476535,
0.4614634812,
0.6421881914,
-0.4319416583,
0.218102932,
-0.219519034,
0.1532488614,
-0.662599802,
0.036289081,
-0.6794352531,
-0.1658386439,
-0.5912231207,
-0.2924779952,
0.1341858953,
-0.1306882948,
-0.0009633547,
0.6180379391,
-0.3136582971,
0.2546473444,
0.3656840324,
-0.3416024745,
0.1180423275,
0.1199687496,
-0.6645339727,
-0.1973883808,
-0.4909765124,
-0.5569962263,
0.6893236041,
0.1460247636,
0.4335175753,
0.2893975079,
0.709728539,
0.2145653963,
-0.0056820759,
-0.9722240567,
0.6433789134,
-0.2348970026,
-0.6908153296,
-0.4213756025,
0.0189477429,
-1.1381164789,
0.6209639311,
-0.0727358833,
-0.6302301884,
0.4106222093,
-0.49113065,
-0.3808815181,
0.146727398,
-0.4197905362,
0.2374580204,
-0.1390667856,
0.1689370126,
-0.4930458665,
-0.4596689343,
0.454413712,
-0.1320792288,
0.4402443767,
-0.1310954988,
0.1166877821,
0.8271439075,
-0.6656857729,
0.9335107207,
-0.0377567559,
-0.0721398368,
0.5897880197,
0.4070527852,
-0.4850544631,
-0.2017226368,
-0.1200767159,
0.0505807549,
0.093891494,
-0.2707496285,
-0.4206911325,
0.8113161325,
-0.9724139571,
-0.2225504667,
-0.6435502768,
-0.4420170486,
-0.1223572716,
0.4807759821,
0.0922236368,
0.5020887852,
-0.2803816497,
-0.2341313809,
0.3395762146,
-0.1874433011,
0.5966348052,
0.6564128995,
-0.501280427,
-0.3495196998,
0.8507207632,
0.5618473291,
-0.0659583658,
0.2528237998,
0.3854056001,
-0.3468953073,
-0.2757420838,
-0.282322377,
0.300927043,
-0.5000839829,
0.0608214661,
-0.3168608248,
-0.2429475039,
-0.4215968251,
0.0592276007,
-0.2831560373,
-0.2569457293,
-0.0593095273,
0.1186108813,
0.2924945056,
0.9616886973,
-0.2220540643,
0.5496710539,
-0.5671066642,
0.0220963415,
0.1816583276,
0.2537667155,
0.1172980741,
-0.1264002472,
0.2675289214,
0.0497971401,
-0.0864816383,
-1.1045303345,
0.4821796715,
0.4143349528,
0.6234939694,
0.4578918815,
-0.4036614895,
0.8493170142,
-0.4971751273,
0.4723677337,
0.1758791357,
-1.4025835991,
0.5846568942,
-0.543566525,
0.1876309961,
0.5218250751,
0.1683354974,
-0.8351649642,
-0.4646400213,
-0.6547813416,
-0.7915406227,
0.2350506783,
0.3219783008,
-0.0255960524,
-0.1929932684,
0.2980853617,
0.3164345026,
0.04691457,
-0.395396173,
-0.0138876783,
-0.1983873844,
-0.089097321,
-0.0552364364,
0.1110197976,
0.1215228587,
-0.4857621789,
0.3057498932,
0.1643493176,
0.262717396,
0.0355681218,
-0.3219156861,
-0.1050353274,
0.3123426735,
0.8314660788,
0.6160783172,
0.3337413669,
0.2186170965,
-0.1446701288,
-0.640381813,
0.2727396488,
-0.3219949007,
-0.0974525586,
0.143566519,
0.2683914006,
0.7408068776,
0.439142704,
-0.3411247432,
0.0585411265,
0.3488533795,
0.0323038474,
-0.4120212197,
-0.0711349323,
0.3859721422,
-0.024872439,
0.2252659053,
0.2091758251,
0.194723472,
-0.7919836044,
0.3782439828,
0.2549759448,
-0.2695611715,
-0.5690380335,
0.2015578449,
0.2827129662,
-0.458653301,
0.7280203104,
-0.1282815188,
-0.7719267607,
0.6883816123,
0.5708856583,
0.69999367,
-0.7813397646,
0.2916024029,
0.3983776271,
0.5370946527,
0.311383903,
0.4540808499,
-0.0225166492,
-0.6787498593,
-0.3550628722,
-1.0855723619,
-0.1540033221,
0.0956923813,
-0.5568814278,
0.2053441554,
-0.5863055587,
-0.2184555531,
0.3124654293,
0.0432637297,
-0.4208654165,
0.2845176756,
0.1529146284,
0.7200181484,
-1.1161272526,
0.8282000422,
0.4700348377,
-0.5263034105,
-0.7578514218,
-0.0477268882,
0.0752913132,
-0.8578176498,
0.9515776038,
-0.0474977046,
-0.4525954723,
0.0428930894,
-0.1847511232,
-1.0825332403,
0.8543487787,
0.0831585824,
-0.3705008924,
0.5665319562,
0.4595710039,
1.0192482471,
-0.4250079095,
-0.0559783429,
0.5914373398,
0.6420413256,
-0.0207218211,
-1.0877412558,
-0.1855732501,
-0.4935199916,
0.0828431621,
0.4942882061,
-0.5169631243,
1.210239768,
0.4073830247,
-0.7617210746,
0.1171653345,
0.6502318978,
0.2144491673,
0.1927235872,
0.439838469,
0.7022520304,
0.7504566908,
0.0472395271,
0.6721746922,
-0.6173664927,
0.3101367056,
0.6629264951,
-0.3048039675,
1.1288561821,
0.4569586217,
-0.4109981954,
0.5503687859,
0.795414269,
0.1712640226,
0.2318893522,
0.7441470027,
-0.3087989092,
0.0072659967,
-0.0494657643,
-0.4785850644,
0.979741931,
0.9234606624,
-0.045897197,
-0.4968596101,
0.1361060292,
0.1610452235,
0.0324469693,
-0.3930159509,
0.6041322351,
0.0626367778,
-0.4779235423,
0.4732703865,
-0.0633739606,
0.7433235049,
-0.4596925974,
0.0296198949,
-0.2092091888,
-0.0386686698,
-0.2101597339,
-0.5558475852,
0.5132336617,
-0.1398412734,
0.0015117446,
0.2529509068,
0.761875093,
-0.3485240042,
-0.6238449216,
0.3713647425,
0.5804182291,
0.4443521202,
0.4639813304,
-0.5301771164,
0.1368559003,
-0.4531962574,
0.2755282819,
0.0059541739,
0.1822375804,
-0.3179857731,
0.6268827319,
0.5769464374,
0.2714332044,
0.6006925702,
-0.2272726595,
0.4175374508,
-0.6092002988,
-0.8923345804,
-0.8591889739,
0.1579565257,
0.1330949068,
-0.4174280763,
0.6151192188,
0.5338684916,
0.4438862503,
-0.121913828,
1.0263646841,
-0.195218578,
0.4296334684,
-0.3214623034,
0.92269665,
-0.2890814841,
-0.0695556924,
-0.3641696572,
-1.0697667599,
-0.4148114324,
0.7108747959,
-0.2224074453,
-0.223418653,
0.6541898847,
0.6679117084,
-0.2214368135,
0.2159386724,
0.2086517662,
0.1083862111,
-0.0324147753,
0.1393781155,
0.7926665545,
-0.0850012675,
0.004993143,
-0.0328442641,
-0.3223395348,
-0.1044464409,
-0.1648654491,
-0.377266258,
-0.9502056837,
-0.0841981322,
-0.0531579554,
-0.1119497567,
0.5517613292,
0.4805998504,
-0.7075412273,
-1.0296729803,
-0.2438427508,
-0.2726505101,
-0.1683982909,
-0.2762074172,
0.3105301261,
-0.3205744624,
-0.7742666006,
0.5361616611,
0.5746868253,
0.0408559926,
-0.8304166794,
-0.0485330261,
-0.5103415847,
0.4854680598,
0.5755468607,
0.6094886065,
-0.9826760888,
-0.2828251719,
0.0115787117,
-0.1209670231,
-0.0254713316,
0.9870080352,
-0.5110803843,
0.618994832,
0.6694859862,
0.4422706962,
0.0678799525,
-0.319593817,
0.6766334176,
-0.1877123564,
0.229744792,
0.0311919469,
0.3040969968,
0.2989835739,
-0.1304101348,
0.3835200667,
0.3786831796,
-0.1821721494,
-0.5798667073,
0.5992390513,
-0.9003511667,
-0.2197081,
0.8615441918,
0.0510596968,
-0.4815654457,
-0.3273937106,
-0.208075583,
0.5143958926,
-0.0711576492,
0.5639541745,
1.0428160429,
-0.1170932725,
0.1110057607,
-0.0926459059,
0.4222178757,
0.4075658619,
-0.6095407009,
-0.2891820669,
0.3102146387,
0.2823789418,
0.8033787012,
0.7081254721,
-0.2590494752,
-0.0305320919,
0.2043985128,
0.0944925994,
0.6264398694,
-0.2613314092,
-0.4480855465,
0.2823376954,
-0.0441390052,
-0.4274620414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12417v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12417v1 | Syrupy Mouthfeel and Hints of Chocolate -- Predicting Coffee Review Scores using Text Based Sentiment | 2023-01-29T10:55:36 | 2023-01-29T10:55:36 | Christopher Lohse, Jeroen Lemsom, Athanasios Kalogiratos | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper uses textual data contained in certified (q-graded) coffee reviews
to predict corresponding scores on a scale from 0-100. By transforming this
highly specialized and standardized textual data in a predictor space, we
construct regression models which accurately capture the patterns in
corresponding coffee bean scores. | [
-0.3612393439,
-0.6841489077,
0.6728439331,
0.7064899206,
0.0634054616,
-0.0908850506,
0.0541523024,
-0.5668081641,
0.4151165187,
0.8239749074,
-0.5940753818,
-0.6637032628,
-0.7728389502,
0.1325303912,
-0.251255542,
1.572548151,
0.1500077546,
0.4194527268,
-0.4704717398,
0.2874073386,
-0.4633781314,
-0.6306843758,
-0.3126254082,
-0.5256976485,
0.6144057512,
0.3227843344,
0.6567633748,
-0.0864836872,
0.6778181195,
0.1064096987,
0.0830888301,
-0.2632902265,
0.0120201139,
0.4118839204,
0.063116625,
-0.8029232621,
-0.4935286939,
0.0552774742,
-0.2472193688,
0.8137494922,
0.3132194281,
0.3300635517,
0.2214194238,
0.5916004181,
-0.3744252324,
0.6814955473,
-0.4086753726,
0.0726989433,
0.2902575731,
-0.0776802152,
-0.7410259843,
-0.7773965001,
0.2650180161,
-0.5946483016,
0.0590032265,
0.2382234484,
0.8277882338,
0.0434400477,
-0.4012047052,
-0.8702353239,
-0.8629036546,
1.0393272638,
-0.6004711986,
0.0973140225,
0.8898304701,
0.5420005918,
0.0806862041,
-0.6972970963,
-0.2927461863,
-0.0866001695,
-0.3178580701,
0.2507241368,
0.1568516791,
-0.1851641089,
0.0583164282,
0.5754654408,
-0.3725026846,
-0.5305923223,
-0.1364853978,
0.0306228045,
0.5335643291,
0.2955104709,
0.0722938254,
-0.4303992093,
-0.4822903275,
0.0239984114,
-0.0724772662,
0.3861104846,
0.2241182625,
0.6645866036,
0.3756077588,
0.4743389785,
-0.4681633711,
0.4850888848,
-0.0550247617,
-0.4340085387,
0.3862376511,
-0.0183254052,
-0.5820751786,
-0.0062091984,
0.8896434903,
0.8357086182,
0.5970594883,
-0.0983428732,
-0.5986648798,
0.3590786159,
0.0954585075,
-0.6894105673,
-0.5595731139,
0.4991089106,
-0.6571463943,
-0.5418562293,
0.2686204612,
-0.8635339141,
-0.375447005,
-0.2554250658,
0.1422479153,
-0.4403617978,
-0.0648653209,
0.0984993204,
-0.6880879998,
0.3089899421,
0.4949617088,
-0.9058080912,
0.5723204017,
0.4833003283,
0.8016505241,
-0.1352535486,
0.091876708,
-0.0237355065,
-0.2117153853,
-0.1389512271,
0.9948192835,
-0.4174508154,
-0.566298306,
0.2633996904,
0.1257181764,
0.0868399292,
-0.6312787533,
0.9889388084,
-0.4357939959,
0.3160153925,
-0.6522738934,
-0.601903379,
-0.2756174505,
0.5783443451,
-0.8083087206,
1.0672254562,
0.6134253144,
-0.7423912883,
0.6392542124,
-0.429977268,
-0.6667470336,
-0.0336629637,
0.2570672631,
-0.4464615583,
0.1344935447,
0.4685127735,
0.2911271155,
0.026650561,
0.3108958602,
-0.6089054942,
0.0254581422,
0.7041857839,
-0.0241256058,
0.7880703211,
0.3805887401,
-0.203280285,
0.0111417379,
-0.7993679047,
0.2107655555,
-0.1680404097,
-0.053152699,
-0.6425372958,
-0.3261366785,
0.3730701506,
0.3029088974,
0.2020301372,
-0.408880502,
0.0284024309,
-0.1093301922,
0.2879969478,
0.5252942443,
0.360271126,
0.3220047355,
-0.4639333487,
0.6242222786,
0.1115425453,
0.46394521,
-0.3252269626,
-0.8370588422,
-0.9127046466,
-0.079350546,
0.5410447121,
0.7516133785,
-0.0814833716,
0.9767686725,
-0.0956169069,
-0.490716368,
-0.535281837,
-0.0856287405,
0.0037594505,
0.7180032134,
0.3185555339,
-0.0678316653,
-0.4482780695,
-0.8728035092,
-0.1200918481,
-0.2178497314,
-0.0190446656,
0.4333148301,
0.6567612886,
-0.0211162847,
1.1742169857,
-0.9481521845,
-0.5854440331,
0.1624005139,
0.3795204759,
0.1259595454,
0.5530464053,
0.5412547588,
-0.5384281278,
-0.6961849332,
0.0834626555,
-0.6515166163,
0.0367830321,
0.2656493783,
0.1246616989,
-0.1019967943,
0.2063091099,
-0.4589770436,
0.4579534829,
0.2371936738,
-0.376580596,
0.7319249511,
0.5766547918,
0.6968904734,
-0.6784379482,
-0.1500897706,
0.2130529135,
-0.1711381823,
-0.5015528202,
-0.5061148405,
-0.0202137548,
-0.1524309665,
-0.1332305521,
0.6830450892,
-0.1836807877,
0.1227538884,
-0.3253605366,
-0.2302828431,
0.6631033421,
0.4599736929,
0.3724469841,
0.1644201577,
0.6568385959,
-0.534532845,
0.1713738441,
0.2099485248,
-0.4611570239,
0.9284616113,
-0.4799233377,
-0.2560500205,
-0.0459907465,
0.3403781056,
-1.6105166674,
-0.2389728427,
-0.0857139677,
-1.0009518862,
-0.1646462679,
0.1127484366,
-0.355956018,
-0.4442817569,
-0.1582462639,
0.0695141479,
0.2834863961,
-0.3094291091,
0.5405938625,
0.2895511985,
-0.1130883917,
-0.3936591148,
-1.2116574049,
-0.2492689341,
-0.3141117692,
-0.3523763716,
-0.0221554041,
-0.2929857373,
-0.4005982578,
0.088070713,
-0.0051085143,
-0.0482880734,
-0.2931576371,
0.5884166956,
-0.0382134058,
-0.1430534571,
0.1422498971,
0.0027913179,
0.0931218415,
0.5382664204,
-0.1778420806,
0.4732923508,
-0.1357604116,
0.3305087686,
-0.4027576745,
0.2985877395,
0.7423506379,
0.1568095982,
0.5305079222,
0.3534690738,
-0.5157079697,
-0.3115058541,
-0.218819201,
-0.4551804364,
-0.3444235623,
-0.1817993522,
-0.7112870812,
-0.4458839297,
0.8885211945,
0.0968397483,
-0.5658169389,
0.3869715333,
0.3739209473,
-0.4467266798,
1.1289153099,
0.4003173113,
-0.1401596814,
0.3418909013,
-0.1238390729,
0.1718061864,
-0.483436197,
-0.6640625,
-0.741632998,
-0.2893939316,
-0.5180532932,
0.0296868216,
0.0107387565,
-0.0254197456,
-0.0415486209,
0.2133304328,
-0.4726979733,
0.3400211632,
0.7240914702,
0.2656791806,
0.0934172571,
-0.100785777,
-0.2424160391,
-0.1779510677,
-0.0521828011,
-0.4880462289,
1.1209959984,
0.6544665098,
0.6750901341,
-0.3006307483,
0.3047912419,
0.7019536495,
0.4536112547,
-1.1133176088,
0.3035188913,
0.2283299863,
-0.9534527063,
-0.0319132246,
-0.1115151197,
-0.4523901641,
-0.2305985689,
-0.218348369,
-0.5454875231,
0.0889312997,
-0.2887262404,
-0.2462059706,
-0.1574178189,
-0.8502411842,
0.8451675177,
-0.2932719588,
-0.2035311908,
0.4725463092,
-0.5924345851,
0.4982357621,
0.2562488019,
0.3408985734,
-0.1819703877,
0.2436115444,
0.79327178,
-0.5189784765,
0.8925358057,
-0.3132393658,
0.000261094,
0.5074980259,
0.314915657,
0.2650976479,
0.2486723363,
-0.3024122417,
-0.0957796276,
-0.1387811452,
-0.6528272033,
-1.0587649345,
0.9818767905,
-0.7327541709,
-0.199693799,
-0.6564421058,
-0.228513211,
-0.7117211819,
0.1607289612,
0.2828662694,
0.002592962,
-0.4352844357,
-0.1365088373,
0.6232646108,
0.0754613355,
0.3902243674,
0.1189750731,
-0.6957671046,
-1.0199462175,
0.6842547655,
-0.2029712796,
0.1018063277,
0.8286701441,
0.4318623543,
-0.5505835414,
-0.3620662093,
-0.3094237149,
-0.1278720498,
-0.788092792,
-0.4251870215,
-0.7038689256,
-0.1879068911,
-0.8397247791,
-0.2460367531,
-0.0903217196,
-0.7780398726,
-0.5319533348,
-0.5109151006,
0.3631702662,
0.7819431424,
0.4275649786,
0.9599078298,
-0.4035697281,
-0.3485080898,
0.0246841516,
0.5357183814,
-0.0299140196,
-0.4918895662,
-0.2131138593,
-0.4097498655,
-0.2556221187,
-0.9756067991,
0.7330294251,
-0.2020352334,
0.0008427221,
0.8279437423,
-0.0179784764,
0.425227195,
0.0317454115,
1.065418005,
0.4485617578,
-0.8352950811,
1.0418368578,
-0.4537502229,
0.2229361236,
0.8908295631,
0.8960164785,
-0.1346899271,
-0.6438605189,
-0.6157967448,
-0.6207545996,
0.1115595177,
-0.0256819278,
-0.0545685329,
-0.1050521061,
0.0771481916,
0.6598138213,
0.5044192672,
-1.2020914555,
-0.2052699178,
-0.5972245336,
-0.2943026721,
-0.0187499374,
-0.2858656645,
-0.0367013551,
-0.4127516448,
0.6254464388,
0.0041824896,
0.0585577637,
0.0188984722,
0.2486560941,
-0.121419169,
0.211455822,
0.4324725568,
0.5110861659,
-0.929364264,
0.2458541691,
-0.5171914697,
-0.2588490546,
-0.0241010673,
-0.3162289858,
-0.440330416,
0.1115825474,
0.3322397768,
0.7643914223,
-0.2769087851,
-0.4838664234,
0.562953949,
-0.2342420667,
-0.2262850851,
-0.5049125552,
0.0031049501,
-0.0960417241,
-0.2561544478,
0.4534132183,
0.2741192877,
0.5424385667,
-0.7562173009,
0.6177628636,
0.3385099173,
-1.0340112448,
-0.4914210737,
0.3421047032,
0.3618310392,
-0.2592282891,
0.5963401198,
-0.0524890982,
-0.4017449021,
0.3877180219,
0.7196572423,
0.9401538968,
-0.2972900569,
0.495577842,
0.6460042596,
0.1892390549,
0.16198726,
0.1505997032,
-0.0595008768,
-0.5895816684,
0.0862747133,
-1.1631696224,
-0.2727731168,
0.4234440625,
-0.8225958347,
0.4993819296,
-0.8152009845,
-0.7079623938,
0.2891307175,
0.2627372742,
-0.3461184502,
1.0860005617,
0.1115618572,
0.8116775751,
-1.4325032234,
0.6693045497,
0.4435913563,
-0.7893097997,
-0.4967068434,
0.1912824661,
-0.1701577604,
-0.5882688165,
0.4555794001,
0.3684134781,
0.042460721,
-0.564050138,
-0.3269807994,
-0.5364801288,
0.6400930285,
-0.2198651284,
-0.3062288165,
0.0032517095,
0.299533695,
0.7347411513,
-0.6661823392,
0.9233837128,
0.823463738,
0.5703786612,
0.1312062293,
-0.5544607043,
-0.1330937445,
-0.3914074004,
-0.2245856971,
-0.1821517199,
-0.778388679,
0.6728326082,
0.1769156158,
0.1408717185,
-0.0283396039,
0.9281144738,
-0.050962586,
0.7367946506,
0.2944836318,
0.6166694164,
0.8233616352,
-0.336170584,
0.9827983975,
-0.2521856427,
0.1666425914,
1.0365575552,
-0.3158969283,
0.8319974542,
0.6107857823,
-0.3483667374,
0.9917268157,
1.0974985361,
-0.057579495,
0.8414011002,
0.2747498453,
-0.0447984934,
0.2749999762,
-0.202590704,
0.028192563,
0.4118528664,
0.6462535262,
-0.7610855103,
0.2511804402,
0.2364010811,
0.1600128859,
0.2800970078,
-0.4940729141,
0.7276405692,
0.279920876,
-0.9105378985,
0.2507051528,
0.0269425884,
0.5879392624,
-0.3673998117,
0.1934305131,
-0.3754638433,
0.1877087653,
-0.3996906877,
-0.904245317,
0.4460720718,
-0.4342645705,
-0.8316407204,
-0.3000006676,
0.8090729117,
-0.4096188545,
-0.9139823318,
0.5083563924,
0.3913328052,
-0.1314011365,
-0.0869578645,
-0.7949536443,
0.1292542517,
0.074049972,
-0.2512305677,
0.210450083,
0.6470900774,
0.1761341095,
0.3871421516,
0.3777282536,
0.1259219199,
-0.023441378,
0.2002847642,
0.5318894982,
-0.9529208541,
-0.7953122258,
-0.6005948186,
0.318778038,
-0.0472948328,
-0.5622801781,
0.8242989182,
0.8632700443,
0.6579571366,
-0.6348030567,
1.214681983,
-0.0157888569,
0.5976279378,
-0.3252468705,
0.5640542507,
-0.2079057395,
-0.0336581953,
-0.472012192,
-0.752699554,
-0.5360118151,
0.2953584194,
-0.4826923907,
0.2934041917,
1.0082460642,
0.684181273,
0.1627089083,
0.4966040552,
0.14561221,
-0.0275955014,
0.1883387119,
0.2432117164,
0.8373275995,
-0.6490948796,
0.3048221767,
-0.1843743324,
-0.3525882065,
-0.3863554895,
-0.7978297472,
-0.9576078057,
-0.6624561548,
-0.4505630732,
-0.9333912134,
-0.1292452514,
0.2311321199,
0.7890080214,
-1.3885382414,
-0.4441629648,
-0.1013024002,
0.080684714,
-0.4571559727,
-0.539174974,
0.2516370714,
-0.4863046706,
-0.7702867985,
-0.0928144008,
0.1518297046,
-0.1032658815,
-0.4792305231,
-0.0606657714,
0.0409208909,
0.4799736738,
0.6243872046,
-0.3006046116,
-0.5929014087,
-0.1406359673,
0.2714959681,
-0.2845900953,
0.2247888595,
1.0128837824,
-0.6372755766,
0.3115205467,
0.5685176849,
0.0580551066,
0.5073052645,
0.1365346462,
0.4286974072,
-0.7658594847,
-0.0873091072,
0.4627300203,
0.2245506793,
0.6153395176,
-0.540068686,
0.0711608976,
0.4499488473,
-0.6396808624,
-0.8326188326,
0.1051554829,
-1.3682531118,
-0.3275457323,
0.9694489241,
-0.2880844176,
-0.763153255,
0.0280015916,
0.08043354,
-0.230729863,
-0.7125789523,
0.9045946002,
0.9845753908,
-0.5856697559,
-0.002958429,
-0.4285310209,
0.835134387,
0.1613976508,
-0.8786437511,
-0.0284783989,
0.3649843037,
0.4800926745,
0.4032816291,
0.7665066123,
-0.183652252,
-0.0704382658,
0.514996469,
-0.04133543,
0.4405569136,
-0.6919872761,
-0.0373614468,
0.4662569165,
0.1376136541,
-0.2723457813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12376v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12376v1 | Enhancing Dialogue Summarization with Topic-Aware Global- and Local- Level Centrality | 2023-01-29T06:41:55 | 2023-01-29T06:41:55 | Xinnian Liang, Shuangzhi Wu, Chenhao Cui, Jiaqi Bai, Chao Bian, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue summarization aims to condense a given dialogue into a simple and
focused summary text. Typically, both the roles' viewpoints and conversational
topics change in the dialogue stream. Thus how to effectively handle the
shifting topics and select the most salient utterance becomes one of the major
challenges of this task. In this paper, we propose a novel topic-aware
Global-Local Centrality (GLC) model to help select the salient context from all
sub-topics. The centralities are constructed at both the global and local
levels. The global one aims to identify vital sub-topics in the dialogue and
the local one aims to select the most important context in each sub-topic.
Specifically, the GLC collects sub-topic based on the utterance
representations. And each utterance is aligned with one sub-topic. Based on the
sub-topics, the GLC calculates global- and local-level centralities. Finally,
we combine the two to guide the model to capture both salient context and
sub-topics when generating summaries. Experimental results show that our model
outperforms strong baselines on three public dialogue summarization datasets:
CSDS, MC, and SAMSUM. Further analysis demonstrates that our GLC can exactly
identify vital contents from
sub-topics.~\footnote{\url{https://github.com/xnliang98/bart-glc}} | [
-0.6020926237,
-0.7271509171,
0.6039198637,
0.0751254037,
-0.747518003,
-0.019393459,
-0.4016306102,
-0.2866497636,
0.5323653221,
0.6226614714,
-0.3560910523,
-0.755068779,
-0.4740137458,
-0.118441157,
-0.3525279462,
1.4561425447,
0.1526991725,
-0.2071124464,
-0.2386782616,
-0.2321551889,
-0.4341841936,
-0.5819479227,
-0.5073012114,
0.0179722756,
0.3505546749,
0.4232456386,
0.4334647655,
0.0169632789,
0.3118761182,
0.2600614727,
-0.6525819898,
-0.0286027845,
-0.598569572,
0.1417965889,
-0.4108525515,
-0.3002485335,
-0.8134486675,
-0.1974775344,
0.6865603328,
0.4939731061,
-0.0948068053,
0.0181267895,
0.0605999231,
0.4935400784,
-0.488504231,
0.27323246,
-0.9515552521,
-0.0385406166,
0.051903639,
0.0246647801,
-0.0879783183,
-0.2625735104,
0.622386992,
-0.4105357826,
0.5783952475,
-0.4153034985,
0.768067956,
0.0938036144,
-0.333268702,
-0.0919041932,
-0.5309261084,
0.607450366,
-0.6176367402,
-0.1319666058,
0.2755742073,
0.5303928852,
0.1796965003,
-0.5157256126,
-0.2079047859,
0.0241389573,
-0.3353837729,
0.488568753,
-0.2169827372,
0.0260888841,
-0.0480457805,
0.6559478641,
-0.3973452449,
-0.5163653493,
-0.2540357411,
-0.1640470177,
0.343718797,
0.3539261222,
0.22817716,
-0.2816178501,
-0.1477932781,
0.5963051915,
-0.5460426211,
0.239072293,
-0.0838825852,
0.6116303205,
-0.4724593461,
0.1362690926,
-0.6047471166,
0.3867975771,
0.212612927,
-0.2507683039,
-0.1693132371,
-1.1474491358,
-0.0752843767,
0.2795958221,
0.3137703836,
0.6829565763,
0.1453624964,
0.0322569534,
0.1877668798,
-0.146715045,
0.2071202844,
-0.768114686,
-0.0830832347,
0.3384746611,
-0.4777274728,
-0.2053107917,
-0.0256555527,
-0.4587005377,
-0.2883576155,
-0.5168640018,
-0.2580743134,
0.0626354218,
-0.245562762,
-0.217520386,
0.1305834651,
0.0074907094,
0.7261245251,
-0.9011963606,
0.3125440776,
0.6535938382,
1.1310281754,
-0.0950111896,
0.1752174795,
-0.467595309,
0.2804191411,
-0.0082101496,
0.8459059596,
-0.5278477669,
-0.449244529,
-0.3560550511,
0.201162681,
0.0297047123,
-0.4501821399,
0.3262046576,
-0.2768930793,
0.3106699586,
-0.504817605,
-0.0628449172,
-0.0287038758,
0.2754835784,
-0.4936668277,
0.3424076736,
-0.0877847448,
-1.0703610182,
0.1665915251,
-0.5390037894,
-0.3046383858,
-0.4349585474,
-0.0852139294,
-0.4969512224,
0.2300162017,
0.6456468701,
0.4654185474,
-0.3387854695,
0.8120766878,
-0.0593632311,
-0.5170134902,
-0.0478750654,
-0.5455624461,
0.4995224774,
-0.0082716113,
-0.1066447422,
0.5375174284,
-0.2757753432,
-0.4535562992,
-0.2874847949,
-0.0054391911,
-0.0929404348,
-0.1229091138,
-0.2485052198,
0.1050621495,
0.2183312774,
-0.197036773,
0.1823953986,
-0.4003435075,
0.2981121838,
0.4901608825,
0.518529892,
0.7040361762,
-0.4364100695,
0.3465658128,
0.10676983,
0.2285612822,
-0.2494064569,
-0.6644238234,
-0.3404549658,
-0.760620594,
0.2051356882,
0.7670977712,
-0.2518180609,
0.5104813576,
-0.1371763796,
-0.6664153337,
-0.2487656772,
-0.1991813928,
0.2449822724,
0.5699511766,
0.2727902532,
-0.4329725206,
-0.2815921009,
-0.7796621919,
0.1717680246,
-0.1413947195,
-0.0276677646,
0.4590784311,
0.1499073654,
-0.0062229228,
1.3744933605,
-0.5721715093,
-0.4292032123,
-0.6127878428,
0.2578085363,
0.4332469106,
0.3096730709,
0.5167844892,
-0.8412287235,
-0.6210507751,
0.179072544,
-0.4846983254,
-0.2852743566,
-0.3140057027,
-0.3654257059,
0.0229241215,
0.2579697967,
-0.6897019744,
0.7437001467,
0.1167696491,
-0.0798626319,
0.6906784773,
-0.2257251292,
0.1232362688,
-1.4589921236,
0.2909348309,
-0.2179342806,
-0.1133919209,
-0.6369097233,
-0.3813670874,
-0.1668937951,
-0.2980773151,
-0.3412625194,
0.5809990168,
-0.3664013445,
-0.3277382255,
-0.3065451682,
0.554751575,
-0.0027694264,
0.5929132104,
0.2537477016,
0.8085494041,
0.5459102392,
-0.3825805783,
0.1644070297,
0.2260560095,
-0.174902603,
0.4321741164,
-0.8412332535,
-0.376865834,
-0.2895199358,
0.7897211313,
-1.00286448,
-0.2739543617,
0.2555384934,
-0.2000483274,
0.1451230496,
-0.4142502546,
0.0648821369,
0.2595463097,
-0.1516869962,
0.4088622332,
0.2062907219,
-0.0891345516,
0.6906802058,
0.5398378968,
-1.0026569366,
-0.591594696,
-0.1572381258,
-0.0910234675,
-0.2316525131,
-0.4461433291,
0.3536655307,
-0.1076893881,
-0.1934416592,
-0.2046517283,
-0.2111327201,
0.0775629133,
0.2157565206,
0.2178682238,
0.3199876845,
-0.0246310532,
-0.0727264807,
0.3086256087,
-0.434173286,
-0.1741830409,
-0.1568963677,
0.358153224,
-0.360681653,
-0.3281101882,
-0.554018259,
0.7332370877,
0.86291188,
-0.5420779586,
0.407300055,
0.455092907,
-0.183855772,
0.3076276779,
-0.3228367865,
-0.1316029876,
-0.3094876111,
0.4649696946,
-0.0244869627,
-0.8866289258,
0.9438001513,
-0.0545118786,
0.1390404999,
0.0510288328,
0.7497745752,
0.4290617406,
0.8300558925,
0.3291435838,
-0.5168305635,
0.8095074892,
-0.3449829221,
0.4037949443,
-0.9301211238,
0.0940957963,
-0.3780425787,
0.0171096213,
-0.1031747162,
-0.5692754984,
0.6271724105,
0.2785771191,
0.2154478729,
0.1625203192,
-0.4678484797,
0.7205355763,
0.2983118892,
-0.1320002526,
0.4376787543,
0.1119517162,
-0.1831695437,
-0.0444552712,
-0.3207055032,
-0.6080996394,
0.6332141161,
0.0880293027,
0.3707867265,
0.3294724524,
0.5818189979,
0.1697694808,
0.4044932127,
-0.3068176508,
0.6501123905,
-0.1586048752,
-0.4235085547,
-0.3858981133,
-0.3034162223,
-0.7393262386,
0.6428169608,
-0.0865477324,
-1.1584495306,
0.1235335618,
0.023434002,
-0.5565853715,
0.3020035326,
-0.5779448748,
0.8044813871,
0.1893927753,
-0.1602546424,
-0.4507115185,
-0.75084126,
0.3619760573,
0.179213807,
0.1139075831,
-0.3862452209,
0.1989652365,
-0.0309235901,
-0.2177114338,
1.0904451609,
-0.2956125438,
-0.1974364966,
0.4562191963,
-0.3141203225,
0.3806166649,
0.7727034688,
0.2821671963,
0.0080759348,
-0.3636191189,
-0.4773569107,
-0.6530660987,
0.5452461839,
-0.6118793488,
-0.8812910914,
-0.1437360495,
-0.5610002875,
-0.1042703316,
0.0548277758,
0.2232404798,
0.9023349881,
-0.5273388028,
-0.0297643747,
0.6478670239,
-0.0977838263,
0.3267724216,
0.5197331309,
-0.1547251046,
-0.7312732339,
1.0137540102,
0.0892423019,
0.542660296,
0.5818724036,
0.125467211,
-0.1602979004,
-0.6194828153,
-0.2027624547,
0.1326753646,
-0.7098712921,
-0.0759633705,
-0.8164118528,
-0.3229907751,
-0.530233562,
-0.6187557578,
-0.2455421388,
-0.5076565146,
-0.3087126911,
-0.0287395883,
-0.0084298877,
0.2984169722,
-0.148155421,
0.180649966,
-0.6807004809,
0.5379416943,
0.7415180802,
-0.1469646245,
0.1530008614,
-0.4570899606,
-0.2265610993,
-0.0351085328,
-0.2536875606,
-0.5627505183,
0.1898645908,
-0.0425399803,
0.6113958955,
0.4838069081,
0.3389747739,
0.4734343588,
-0.1355779767,
1.0156201124,
0.1330500096,
-0.994383812,
0.9040600061,
-0.6249985099,
0.8436796069,
0.6773013473,
0.0446236208,
-0.6134660244,
-0.967266202,
-0.6355525255,
-1.0985820293,
0.7610733509,
0.4442379177,
0.0313220359,
0.014599625,
-0.1124983802,
0.1063688099,
0.2046612054,
-0.3145055175,
0.0439556837,
-0.2862456739,
0.0389508083,
0.1063722298,
-0.1412811279,
-0.2645393312,
-0.164195627,
0.7408524752,
-0.4136295915,
0.3790311515,
0.5732632875,
0.0938196406,
0.2596508563,
0.7317780256,
0.9394375682,
0.5799000263,
-0.5307612419,
-0.1686235368,
0.3218926191,
-0.4580577314,
-0.1930619925,
0.0527541488,
-0.3946512341,
0.248129949,
0.4029814005,
0.7298900485,
0.4225101173,
-0.4370672405,
0.5609089136,
-0.5263318419,
0.2425434738,
-0.0852098241,
0.0520893484,
0.1150192544,
0.356734395,
0.2851997614,
0.2697150707,
0.2488822937,
-0.6396570206,
0.0774096176,
0.270370543,
-0.3716721535,
-0.3148084581,
0.2891434729,
0.4472767711,
0.1735233217,
0.1501336843,
-0.1929645389,
-0.6856337786,
0.6360153556,
0.309045732,
1.0508167744,
0.1361747682,
0.5060074925,
0.4279325008,
-0.0860586166,
0.319118917,
0.1088587344,
-0.7325266004,
-0.5016049743,
-0.3247687519,
-0.2436130196,
-0.8864983916,
-0.3580372036,
-0.873865664,
-0.0299466867,
-0.3047737479,
-0.283033818,
-0.2166152149,
0.1622807235,
0.0625904575,
0.0848108083,
0.1252084821,
0.5339166522,
-0.7198140621,
0.6805900931,
0.4779275954,
-0.2409081757,
-0.333763212,
0.3604435921,
-0.0760228112,
-0.1160122678,
0.0345509276,
0.197347492,
0.0176531505,
-0.4376474619,
-0.326223433,
-0.9263441563,
1.3889322281,
0.3918494284,
-0.5097006559,
-0.1212745234,
-0.1311434954,
0.3908786178,
-0.7705465555,
0.4992834628,
0.5051465631,
0.1111178249,
0.3241616189,
-1.0097477436,
0.0923035815,
-0.1737032384,
0.0794900134,
0.0392475687,
-0.9677419662,
0.81679672,
-0.2401539236,
-0.3145192862,
0.22516343,
0.6131837368,
0.4762018025,
0.4865476489,
0.2792043388,
0.1867278665,
0.9443925023,
-0.228682965,
0.8601410389,
-0.5053309798,
0.2782562971,
1.4373288155,
-0.3322212994,
0.4601779878,
0.1082492992,
0.2168414891,
0.2103520632,
0.2251155525,
0.4379175007,
1.0019497871,
-0.0193794891,
-0.5235239267,
-0.2778384387,
-0.5028551221,
-0.6135857701,
0.1765637696,
0.429036051,
-0.1527834535,
-0.5370098948,
-0.1158359647,
0.1266232282,
-0.145918712,
-0.327056706,
1.050381422,
0.0002426822,
-0.8474562168,
0.4051720202,
-0.178164646,
0.3114299476,
-0.7569454312,
0.1340288371,
-0.5722268224,
0.1072918996,
0.0125917066,
-0.4551661611,
0.491882503,
0.0402063653,
-0.6013261676,
-0.0071135312,
0.8438639641,
-0.6656730175,
-0.121578373,
0.0510033108,
0.2821188867,
0.0672541633,
-0.2411076576,
-0.4714859724,
0.0171338916,
0.1553346664,
0.1052199006,
0.4126577377,
0.6480968595,
-0.3694985807,
0.3196331561,
0.5183847547,
0.1041464135,
-0.6151891947,
0.4660563767,
1.0110510588,
-0.5716233253,
-0.900352478,
-0.3400121927,
0.8202073574,
-0.5713837743,
-0.6196641922,
0.3730863631,
0.3224920332,
0.5046886802,
0.1413764656,
0.7906172276,
0.1713265479,
0.4443401992,
-0.4668409526,
0.7299620509,
-0.1310644448,
0.3610476553,
-0.5509452224,
-0.8368349671,
-0.169663772,
0.5537257195,
-0.6466007233,
-0.4603121877,
0.4751111865,
0.8572326899,
0.0535721593,
0.549893558,
0.3243975639,
0.0885252804,
0.377304703,
0.4461130202,
0.7063714266,
-0.1616886407,
0.4010654986,
-0.0673866421,
-0.2520580888,
-0.2679479718,
-0.7055205107,
-1.1908166409,
-0.393637985,
-0.4053832293,
0.1796301603,
-0.0860495046,
0.7723588943,
0.8358083963,
-1.07213521,
0.0292442124,
-0.1760794818,
0.4927086234,
-0.1356793493,
-0.2152481973,
0.3864253163,
-0.201649487,
-0.5783760548,
0.2873259783,
0.5781660676,
0.220515728,
-0.0878718421,
0.0802054852,
-0.148147285,
0.1531307101,
0.4909513891,
0.1215560734,
-0.9360438585,
-0.1608231217,
-0.3473381698,
-0.0309238546,
0.0327429324,
1.0748007298,
-0.5743458271,
0.3350152671,
0.3438673317,
0.3465098143,
0.4223710001,
0.3586737216,
0.6615658402,
-0.9545295835,
0.2585247159,
-0.0196281355,
0.4205352068,
0.3451755941,
-0.4405712783,
0.4300412536,
0.2345182449,
-0.5941758752,
-0.546256721,
0.2522799671,
-1.0272521973,
-0.2454647422,
0.5869321227,
-0.4195270836,
-0.0392955542,
-0.3416398168,
-0.8388897777,
0.2051358223,
-0.7891780734,
0.8102329373,
0.510694921,
0.1070792377,
0.0506359786,
-0.1641292572,
0.3248350024,
0.3843745291,
-0.8164951205,
0.5021224022,
0.4836831391,
0.0014894356,
0.3813350201,
1.0439184904,
0.0072912099,
0.4502608776,
-0.2012340873,
-0.3497935534,
0.2683394849,
-0.5822409987,
-0.1588258594,
0.3740572333,
-0.5335813165,
0.194328472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12343v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12343v1 | Achieving Timestamp Prediction While Recognizing with Non-Autoregressive End-to-End ASR Model | 2023-01-29T03:47:59 | 2023-01-29T03:47:59 | Xian Shi, Yanni Chen, Shiliang Zhang, Zhijie Yan | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Conventional ASR systems use frame-level phoneme posterior to conduct
force-alignment~(FA) and provide timestamps, while end-to-end ASR systems
especially AED based ones are short of such ability. This paper proposes to
perform timestamp prediction~(TP) while recognizing by utilizing continuous
integrate-and-fire~(CIF) mechanism in non-autoregressive ASR model -
Paraformer. Foucing on the fire place bias issue of CIF, we conduct
post-processing strategies including fire-delay and silence insertion. Besides,
we propose to use scaled-CIF to smooth the weights of CIF output, which is
proved beneficial for both ASR and TP task. Accumulated averaging shift~(AAS)
and diarization error rate~(DER) are adopted to measure the quality of
timestamps and we compare these metrics of proposed system and conventional
hybrid force-alignment system. The experiment results over manually-marked
timestamps testset show that the proposed optimization methods significantly
improve the accuracy of CIF timestamps, reducing 66.7\% and 82.1\% of AAS and
DER respectively. Comparing to Kaldi force-alignment trained with the same
data, optimized CIF timestamps achieved 12.3\% relative AAS reduction. | [
-0.3819167912,
-0.2731075287,
0.2071822882,
-0.0452098697,
-0.4522177577,
0.3334049881,
0.0483346768,
-0.6884576678,
0.2138826549,
0.04682054,
-0.61913234,
-0.2134138942,
-0.6704653502,
-0.1127908751,
-0.318695128,
0.6240859628,
-0.5395451188,
-0.0918989405,
0.105963245,
-0.4747591913,
-0.2035919428,
-0.6132979393,
-0.4862906337,
-0.1941289008,
0.0548503883,
0.1372072846,
0.4692279696,
0.9482164979,
0.5844464898,
0.2526140511,
-0.0968244746,
0.070644401,
0.2669914663,
-0.0841319859,
-0.1212127656,
-0.0099833682,
-0.2362863868,
-0.2987800539,
0.7055479884,
0.1832208633,
-0.2457989603,
0.0557799637,
-0.039525263,
0.4345418215,
-0.9410853386,
-0.0211414471,
-0.2031530291,
0.204668507,
-0.5713863373,
-0.6154140234,
-0.0839246064,
-0.3675760627,
-0.224196732,
-0.4030942321,
0.3657613695,
0.116577968,
0.8340846896,
0.4723910987,
-0.6168080568,
-0.0474753045,
-1.1778992414,
0.4827658534,
-0.7387160659,
0.678273201,
0.036646273,
0.5974600315,
-0.3019970953,
-0.334099263,
-0.7629369497,
0.2158030868,
0.0493501835,
-0.0681317523,
-0.0205060896,
0.0942034051,
0.5089580417,
0.51162076,
-0.5967234373,
0.0557231978,
0.0224098284,
-0.3610712588,
0.5463505387,
0.2386370003,
0.007579043,
0.1818310767,
-0.487413913,
-0.3126366138,
-0.2236101329,
0.4718310535,
0.0618962534,
-0.1183593199,
-0.3431734145,
0.4589226246,
-0.4617474377,
0.6620153189,
0.5409927964,
-0.275975883,
0.1843843013,
-0.6017819643,
-0.3515143991,
-0.1649393439,
0.8571787477,
0.4290284514,
0.1453613043,
-0.1623119116,
-0.2293243855,
0.4933474064,
-0.2290728539,
-0.5997117162,
0.1530027837,
0.1989317685,
-0.5795222521,
-0.1753480434,
-0.1203483567,
-0.8097535968,
0.0213170741,
-0.3729095459,
0.4041742086,
-0.4529506862,
-0.1940406114,
-0.0946202204,
-0.029087076,
0.3436213434,
0.4076485634,
-0.7148127556,
0.2874576449,
0.269236356,
0.9206967354,
0.0491240174,
0.0031267286,
-0.8699797392,
0.3264918923,
-0.2466451824,
1.0273416042,
-0.5226108432,
-0.5248055458,
-0.0657180995,
-0.0052357907,
-0.2793520987,
-0.4984763563,
0.6500365138,
-0.8001922965,
-0.0853512138,
-0.2132861614,
-0.6455037594,
-0.1170727536,
0.0103288963,
-0.4819500744,
0.8822063804,
-0.1144017205,
-0.5722624063,
0.7283724546,
-0.6230009794,
-0.5500487089,
-0.0065074423,
-0.0941126645,
-0.5762684941,
0.0027215991,
0.5865104795,
0.2871472836,
-0.1001925319,
0.5349782109,
-0.5676810145,
-0.1784768254,
0.3282240927,
-0.4556626081,
0.4859465063,
0.2812769413,
-0.4717683196,
-0.1958442032,
-0.6841446757,
0.2432715297,
-0.3581291139,
-0.309210211,
0.1601887345,
-0.0217211712,
0.3051668406,
0.5441471934,
0.179219842,
-0.672878325,
0.0929807425,
-0.1310747862,
0.2500088811,
0.3367950618,
0.4721084535,
0.4291933179,
-0.4498822689,
0.4557316303,
0.0083734421,
0.2635057569,
0.2244834155,
-0.011245003,
-0.5841947794,
0.2167907059,
0.5076087713,
0.608612895,
-0.8783354163,
0.5417896509,
-0.1386150867,
-0.5848101974,
0.019717807,
-0.0307604373,
0.6551373601,
0.5678147078,
0.3909770548,
-0.2609093189,
-0.4707047343,
-0.6022629142,
-0.3120552301,
-0.3890621364,
-0.0111270566,
-0.0831858963,
0.2609972954,
0.2595264018,
0.7576215267,
-0.2799700797,
-0.5232409835,
0.299285531,
0.550850451,
0.0408910215,
0.3804971874,
0.3510157466,
-0.6834983826,
-0.5127840638,
-0.1186040789,
-0.7506463528,
-0.1957761198,
0.0065585091,
-0.0159697942,
0.4398510754,
0.5245405436,
-0.388284564,
0.7908468843,
0.2041907012,
-0.4268658459,
0.1690120548,
-0.0199217014,
0.54826051,
-0.8075053692,
0.1040739715,
0.2488518506,
-0.162686348,
-0.5030903816,
-0.2096179277,
0.5954175591,
-0.1708730012,
-0.4998289645,
0.5503848791,
-0.6611657739,
-0.2652609348,
-0.4493741691,
-0.5965627432,
-0.234994188,
0.4653609395,
0.6444150209,
0.7248944044,
0.1239970103,
-0.6890141368,
-0.0286193881,
0.096000284,
-0.3675347567,
0.5750297904,
-0.2334118336,
0.1940480173,
0.0530429482,
0.435151726,
-0.7471506596,
-0.0961459801,
0.3110302389,
-0.4771759808,
0.644377172,
-0.257384479,
-0.6843878031,
-0.3286543489,
-0.1050007269,
0.4752638936,
0.3772815168,
-0.5876728296,
0.7151325941,
0.121716544,
0.0760646015,
-0.4790678322,
-0.1753477156,
-0.1404836625,
-0.2539781034,
-0.589805603,
0.6405382752,
-0.200891003,
-0.0206323545,
-0.3241210282,
-0.2541191578,
0.0954754949,
-0.3100645542,
0.2127290219,
0.4589962959,
-0.1225453168,
0.0509554297,
0.1819750518,
-0.4740352929,
-0.3672586381,
-0.0404963829,
0.2180113196,
0.1522867829,
-0.3719395995,
-0.5799505115,
0.3112809062,
0.7530304193,
-0.1887961775,
0.5477269292,
0.4280089736,
-0.8241240978,
0.3046623468,
-0.9979435802,
0.0429497249,
-0.4512885809,
-0.3127694428,
-0.1436296105,
-0.5370570421,
0.4630592763,
-0.1562163681,
0.117967315,
0.4843941033,
0.1434258223,
-0.2039184421,
0.6482738853,
0.3796763718,
-0.3217777312,
0.6726053357,
-0.0161485504,
0.0489024073,
-0.978196919,
-0.2585883737,
-0.4299641848,
-0.6480045915,
0.0089652808,
-0.4409247339,
0.4918502867,
0.326796025,
-0.3066637516,
0.5510529876,
-0.4811269641,
0.1733086407,
0.2694125473,
-0.040324863,
0.1056021154,
-0.0629112646,
0.1716042757,
-0.266043812,
-0.1505225897,
-0.2137914002,
1.0684598684,
0.2425007075,
0.7301689386,
-0.0427385345,
0.702996254,
0.3764942884,
0.0415458158,
-0.4060187936,
0.4377224743,
-0.1119455025,
-0.4170670509,
-0.2289922386,
0.0973388925,
-0.1839545518,
-0.1786949188,
-0.1405929178,
-0.7242597342,
0.8502641916,
0.2517692447,
-0.6148596406,
0.3088681996,
-0.5631290674,
0.3879628181,
-0.4015837312,
-0.1848378927,
0.1317897886,
-0.7833124399,
-0.1381691694,
0.088680774,
0.1136869863,
-0.1704542488,
-0.2367048711,
0.9928458333,
-0.7964817286,
0.4658676982,
-0.6013123393,
0.3448162377,
0.3659908473,
-0.0434211008,
0.936001122,
-0.1100726873,
-0.1818654984,
0.2670513988,
-0.0066294591,
0.0816304311,
-0.5940414071,
0.3730616271,
-0.5116110444,
-0.114476651,
-0.7902698517,
-0.3371472955,
0.0017278396,
-0.2214755118,
0.6798538566,
0.6748795509,
0.0002937846,
-0.133569628,
0.4368164837,
0.3959473372,
1.2004725933,
0.912563622,
0.3988321424,
-0.6543880701,
0.5193240047,
0.4659353495,
0.2072787434,
0.759542644,
-0.2590161264,
-0.7952254415,
-0.4407094121,
-0.6203822494,
0.2375760823,
-0.530890286,
-0.7437908053,
-0.8912234306,
-0.5261329412,
-0.5197371244,
-0.608956635,
-0.1115756854,
-0.5164430141,
-0.4405145645,
0.1725651026,
0.6095141768,
0.1394326538,
-0.18236655,
0.4803776443,
-0.8644609451,
0.2190578729,
-0.1210225075,
0.4079852998,
-0.0459867381,
-0.6881757379,
0.0413199179,
-0.2806359529,
-0.5207345486,
-0.6450612545,
0.4867839813,
0.3509560227,
0.1322066635,
0.6678698063,
0.3214787245,
0.9520600438,
-0.3423987031,
0.4370689094,
0.1795140207,
-1.0304219723,
0.4639888406,
-0.2930049896,
0.3691254556,
0.4990281761,
0.0216483753,
-0.5372726917,
-0.25707829,
-0.6462344527,
-0.4921103418,
0.7567849159,
0.0981692523,
-0.6261066198,
0.2645125687,
0.2395581305,
-0.0849356726,
0.1705705225,
-0.4385533631,
-0.0891851857,
0.1328976452,
-0.0170287192,
0.0061124098,
-0.1438762695,
0.2575114965,
-0.0317289345,
0.5556558967,
-0.06705755,
0.5941339135,
0.1913682222,
0.1059715822,
-0.7584686875,
0.4665698111,
0.5708802938,
0.4011254311,
-0.2672916949,
-0.2824427485,
0.2434370518,
-0.093090564,
0.5613411665,
0.4034281969,
0.1575018317,
0.0403727032,
0.487347424,
0.4224641919,
0.1285286397,
-0.0679304898,
0.5180187225,
0.1276543289,
-0.0542890802,
-0.7693971395,
0.1711554527,
0.0197436381,
0.6277236938,
0.5778983235,
0.368511796,
0.2370353639,
-0.0803198516,
0.3286473155,
0.477899313,
-0.0388579555,
-0.3020333648,
1.1289453506,
0.0341329128,
-0.4914361835,
0.4460315704,
-0.0567147844,
-0.4332160056,
0.8087649941,
0.3642096221,
0.9648126364,
-0.84154737,
-0.1198349148,
0.5039541721,
-0.0365790948,
-0.2155523002,
0.4506549835,
-0.5335834026,
-0.573063314,
-0.1033271477,
-0.6565445662,
-0.3979035616,
0.2504533827,
-0.724314034,
0.8014091849,
-0.881377697,
-0.2341008037,
0.351321429,
-0.0722188354,
-0.6724799275,
0.4343357682,
0.0718462318,
0.9316978455,
-1.2429009676,
0.8164258599,
0.3689594567,
-0.2019560784,
-0.6693155169,
0.2884867191,
0.2817061543,
-0.5366164446,
0.4782388508,
0.0789523572,
0.0341041721,
-0.2156513333,
-0.1826459914,
-1.2232916355,
1.3288776875,
-0.0400580354,
-0.8851263523,
-0.1129906103,
-0.1217450798,
0.501370132,
-0.3068366945,
0.3068148494,
0.3832473159,
0.3136352599,
0.6317276955,
-1.0607562065,
0.2141353786,
-0.5587961078,
0.2285753936,
0.8351044059,
-0.7008642554,
0.5119897723,
0.030536253,
-0.4840786755,
0.0090411622,
0.9913023114,
0.2316723317,
0.8869954348,
0.4401917756,
0.5736765265,
0.1217228472,
0.0407597199,
0.707493186,
-0.135848552,
0.1241069213,
1.0323419571,
-0.5782031417,
0.9205695987,
0.4968085289,
-0.388433665,
0.3770794868,
0.9890494347,
0.0227131173,
0.8500859141,
-0.4071146846,
-0.6277114153,
-0.0516107939,
-0.0155406613,
-0.4459750056,
-0.0179566722,
0.4454376101,
-0.4396513402,
-0.3935716748,
0.1998914033,
-0.2723281682,
-0.2586171031,
-0.1036159247,
0.8258262873,
-0.1396617144,
-0.7900497317,
0.6862906218,
-0.046457082,
0.8375392556,
-0.3703286648,
-0.1166535914,
-0.0255945753,
0.1286303401,
-0.2279809415,
-0.5783845782,
0.5256298184,
-0.2525359988,
-0.4045304954,
-0.0955778733,
0.8180421591,
-0.4788451493,
-0.4028790593,
0.4672899544,
-0.0349812917,
0.01691214,
0.0352001265,
-0.3839837015,
0.1943336129,
-0.010417223,
0.0701266602,
0.404821068,
0.2543554902,
-0.2997069955,
0.5031967163,
0.4382824302,
-0.0583106354,
-0.0408024006,
-0.2775831521,
0.7559142709,
-0.6651377678,
-0.6057887077,
-0.6213523149,
0.488355726,
0.1170174032,
-0.2647210956,
0.051328972,
0.456928432,
0.5852248073,
0.0504361726,
0.6651241183,
-0.3122428358,
0.893198967,
-0.6310479641,
0.4625547826,
-0.4467411637,
0.0844199136,
-0.3294641972,
-0.955686152,
-0.1269932389,
0.1113177165,
-0.3963794708,
0.2128598094,
0.7047408223,
0.632345438,
-0.1791899651,
0.2189774662,
0.1778955311,
-0.4291321337,
0.2001854181,
0.7127486467,
0.4555875659,
-0.7405109406,
0.4853001833,
-0.5431663394,
-0.3952290118,
-0.4178838432,
-0.8077772856,
-0.7118325233,
-0.8809604049,
-0.7339364886,
-0.2119213939,
-0.0817168355,
0.9022814035,
0.4605014622,
-0.876921773,
-0.1142797247,
-0.0378176793,
-0.5350767374,
-0.3087242842,
-0.2468885481,
0.4766608179,
0.1135655046,
-0.6243918538,
0.3771553338,
0.4327925146,
0.5519881248,
0.4639394283,
0.1026510373,
-0.226234898,
-0.2124703974,
0.0813345239,
0.8264178634,
-0.7469725013,
-0.5363458395,
0.0392318256,
0.2875697613,
0.1234398261,
0.8381707668,
-0.6446762681,
0.5267291665,
0.3146210611,
0.4674921036,
0.538263917,
0.2750610709,
0.705743432,
-0.4887155592,
-0.0085796556,
0.1483523846,
0.4109882712,
0.3004835546,
-0.9652925134,
0.5953544974,
0.2090796679,
-0.6944823265,
-0.4791009128,
-0.1734935492,
-0.7364654541,
0.4144202769,
0.9112733006,
0.0846896395,
-0.0917194113,
-0.2942378223,
0.2201109678,
0.7807741761,
-0.6212335825,
0.6264661551,
0.7692173123,
-0.6115732789,
-0.477955699,
-0.0505244918,
0.4983059764,
0.200008601,
-0.6444723606,
-0.1822126806,
0.3733554184,
0.5087763071,
0.3145478964,
0.876196444,
-0.4122239649,
0.6070699096,
-0.1223225147,
0.0345091783,
-0.0945510492,
-0.2414744496,
-0.6154285669,
-0.0783325806,
-0.0832903534,
-0.7038711905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12331v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12331v2 | Time out of Mind: Generating Rate of Speech conditioned on emotion and speaker | 2023-01-29T02:58:01 | 2023-01-31T05:30:55 | Navjot Kaur, Paige Tuttosi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Voice synthesis has seen significant improvements in the past decade
resulting in highly intelligible voices. Further investigations have resulted
in models that can produce variable speech, including conditional emotional
expression. The problem lies, however, in a focus on phrase-level modifications
and prosodic vocal features. Using the CREMA-D dataset we have trained a GAN
conditioned on emotion to generate worth lengths for a given input text. These
word lengths are relative to neutral speech and can be provided, through speech
synthesis markup language (SSML) to a text-to-speech (TTS) system to generate
more expressive speech. Additionally, a generative model is also trained using
implicit maximum likelihood estimation (IMLE) and a comparative analysis with
GANs is included. We were able to achieve better performances on objective
measures for neutral speech, and better time alignment for happy speech when
compared to an out-of-box model. However, further investigation of subjective
evaluation is required. | [
-0.5086168647,
-0.7961289287,
0.6307610869,
0.3219338655,
-0.3115310073,
0.2487497628,
-0.5867814422,
-0.3513628244,
0.1565793306,
0.198970288,
-0.8252710104,
-0.354018867,
-0.4892918468,
0.095314227,
-0.4700388312,
1.2100226879,
0.2801857591,
0.1186933443,
0.0926761106,
-0.0228651632,
-0.1543518752,
-0.7147535086,
-0.9212514758,
-0.5473309755,
0.4774571061,
0.2980497181,
0.4934813976,
0.1739592999,
0.3206326663,
0.2319379896,
0.0263803042,
-0.1822279394,
-0.4605276287,
0.3230802119,
0.0810448453,
-0.4205534458,
-0.7299479842,
0.1720374376,
0.6859167218,
0.2372761071,
-0.4243553579,
0.1380351633,
-0.1255149245,
0.8478178978,
-0.4338574708,
0.0903005674,
-0.8636786938,
0.5264681578,
-0.3980202079,
-0.5189083815,
-0.492580384,
-0.3670762479,
0.3117724061,
-0.4370271564,
0.5194683075,
-0.1185389385,
0.7863929272,
0.6835821867,
-0.0568403974,
-0.2764240503,
-0.8107936382,
0.8033590317,
-0.9496903419,
0.4406464994,
0.0936547071,
0.3040669262,
-0.0502545685,
-0.7035114169,
-0.9605509639,
-0.3838740885,
0.173540011,
0.358075738,
-0.3625689447,
0.2337809801,
0.4854317904,
0.3682412207,
-0.4551573992,
-0.1398008019,
-0.0645156056,
0.2318847179,
0.7754061222,
0.324462682,
0.4203956127,
-0.3855630755,
-0.1341646463,
-0.0914238542,
-0.3655875921,
0.0350602232,
0.558414638,
0.1643773019,
-0.0748327971,
0.8084192276,
-0.1610722244,
0.6059672236,
0.3553536534,
-0.1323248297,
0.2619858384,
0.0226697288,
-0.5599706769,
0.2571247518,
0.7656437755,
0.3819077611,
0.3030955791,
-0.2691145241,
-0.0718304217,
0.4085502326,
0.4602059424,
-0.8909143209,
-0.0034770614,
0.1554998904,
-0.2657093704,
-0.2181507945,
-0.3695045412,
-0.9465507865,
-0.1629583985,
-0.4113374949,
0.1387436986,
-0.5023955107,
-0.2635538876,
0.166057393,
-0.1879014373,
-0.1477661729,
-0.0432747118,
-0.7603636384,
0.3137742877,
0.1854653507,
0.7651401162,
-0.2192600071,
0.0566865839,
-0.6249263287,
0.0512681045,
-0.5691381097,
0.387570262,
-0.3852719963,
-0.6371480227,
-0.3670166135,
-0.0521498099,
0.0395393744,
-0.4509188831,
0.555773735,
-0.3888714612,
0.5858975053,
-0.1703827828,
-0.5339217186,
-0.1822097749,
-0.0883774832,
-0.3070332706,
0.8075259328,
0.605709672,
-0.5723424554,
0.4338059127,
-0.9751474857,
-0.5274900198,
0.1502120048,
-0.2472350746,
-0.3815675974,
0.1819051355,
-0.0740299746,
0.3831421137,
-0.5028257966,
0.4791461825,
-0.1700215638,
-0.1614502668,
0.4814302623,
-0.4891529977,
0.4757257104,
0.4857360721,
-0.8152452111,
0.1014463603,
-0.7290778756,
0.3974870145,
0.0046386225,
-0.3450576365,
0.0666988194,
0.1206917539,
0.0112561649,
0.3531254828,
-0.189149946,
-0.7612579465,
-0.2459927946,
-0.6817817092,
0.6202479601,
0.4474931359,
0.3661109507,
0.2256157696,
-0.0987060219,
0.6835645437,
0.0513250679,
0.0976331159,
0.4605184197,
-0.5262371898,
-1.0344942808,
-0.1074402109,
0.0132195596,
0.5945378542,
-0.8635747433,
0.2948034108,
-0.2658717334,
-0.549004972,
-0.6462560892,
-0.1800566018,
0.5236255527,
0.7248927355,
0.3521569371,
-0.5261256695,
-0.5647921562,
-1.0292805433,
-0.1106210798,
-0.3408943415,
-0.2039292157,
0.1403821707,
0.1404412836,
0.1051467881,
0.8738831282,
-0.6064710021,
-0.2121341825,
-0.3538691103,
0.42386356,
0.0475907922,
0.3148488104,
0.6324866414,
-0.5386365056,
-0.5457332134,
-0.2241409719,
-0.5628378987,
-0.1107064411,
-0.0723986849,
-0.0901696682,
0.4386692345,
0.3418989182,
-0.730031848,
0.6709789634,
0.4730260968,
-0.0892156363,
0.2706799805,
-0.0442059636,
0.5382956862,
-0.8349039555,
-0.0811500922,
0.0692801178,
-0.0457649417,
-0.7206827998,
-0.5470314622,
-0.2705504894,
-0.5379631519,
-0.7916871309,
0.3918589056,
-0.425042361,
-0.1369930953,
-0.3184626997,
0.46973297,
0.0904031843,
0.7269833088,
0.1157589853,
1.0230445862,
0.3074365556,
-0.6439223289,
0.3619295359,
0.0809146091,
-0.5609497428,
0.7300269604,
-0.7187342048,
0.3402764201,
-0.1719781309,
0.1101859957,
-0.6383336186,
-0.2483398467,
0.2251831442,
-0.6430071592,
0.4968381524,
0.0762032717,
-0.0581549853,
-0.2382178903,
0.1235751286,
0.1083648577,
0.8115091324,
-0.1469980031,
0.4388746321,
0.5933951735,
-0.404879719,
-0.3977468312,
-0.8539671302,
0.2764112353,
-0.392834574,
-0.5287252665,
0.6172350645,
-0.2473249137,
-0.4026353061,
0.1858972311,
0.2896094322,
0.1363895386,
-0.0898802802,
0.3029952943,
-0.0828436911,
0.0535834357,
0.282425195,
0.0348617323,
0.1174844131,
0.0949923396,
0.2123685777,
0.542424202,
-0.0567212701,
-0.1192052737,
-0.6217491627,
0.591760695,
0.6820973158,
-0.0762137622,
0.5033680797,
0.7613989115,
-0.5175290108,
-0.2899495363,
-0.2676497996,
-0.0637196749,
-0.3975845277,
0.5317596197,
-0.2952281833,
-0.629044354,
0.1785734296,
0.4978249669,
-0.2493464202,
0.4676347375,
0.8282239437,
-0.0434965715,
1.2347706556,
0.496740371,
0.1398466229,
0.7421619892,
-0.1638957858,
0.3950757086,
-1.0449941158,
-0.1891709119,
-0.313383311,
-0.2616609633,
-0.5655400157,
-0.3214867711,
0.4503029585,
-0.3742801547,
-0.1782586575,
-0.0781764984,
-0.5045720935,
-0.0017732254,
0.3969792724,
0.1890891343,
-0.4290891886,
-0.1302013248,
0.2960245311,
-0.3377174437,
-0.5381416082,
-0.3239890933,
0.7669517994,
0.1418385059,
0.5246930718,
0.0561318211,
0.3694198728,
0.5604272485,
0.5219233632,
-0.8527416587,
0.6597091556,
-0.3980995119,
-0.7305712104,
-0.3779447973,
-0.3759405613,
-0.6869907975,
-0.2010241002,
-0.2649590969,
-0.5837352276,
0.1286628246,
0.0887143016,
-0.5195988417,
0.1428166777,
-0.7445999384,
0.395129621,
-0.3007007539,
-0.280741781,
-0.2071296871,
-0.6142174006,
0.3593485057,
0.0986442119,
-0.2761512995,
-0.4623374641,
0.3447976112,
0.8164181709,
-0.1269678622,
0.5605084896,
-0.3493852019,
0.037899036,
0.4916624427,
-0.0672039762,
0.2053878605,
-0.0272415746,
-0.188247025,
0.0430085771,
-0.4826083183,
-0.0434611291,
-0.9066493511,
0.6870916486,
-0.6296256185,
-0.7806349993,
-0.3334671259,
-0.5331402421,
-0.5049179792,
-0.1902073324,
0.6202061772,
0.5286451578,
-0.4091050029,
0.2109082192,
0.5360276103,
-0.4166974723,
0.6417987347,
0.29005301,
-0.1111251637,
-0.6422314644,
0.6429934502,
0.3519006968,
0.5333044529,
0.2644306123,
-0.0663833991,
-0.4271568656,
-0.0619531982,
-0.5373103619,
0.1105025187,
-0.6166427732,
0.051332593,
-0.6541031599,
-0.4095935524,
-0.5331385732,
0.0335497074,
-0.3525816798,
-0.5910553932,
-0.5412909985,
-0.3333851993,
0.3275638521,
0.6329605579,
0.00096134,
0.3276925087,
-0.6494333148,
0.390948981,
0.3711016774,
0.0915894583,
-0.0355777405,
-0.5697923303,
-0.1841641366,
0.0870296806,
-0.2972969115,
-1.032174468,
0.7004344463,
0.3061686158,
0.3875159919,
0.0852895007,
-0.0663962513,
0.6813951135,
-0.5924733281,
1.1825742722,
0.3969460726,
-1.288818121,
0.7175780535,
-0.1238359362,
0.2791940868,
0.1163919568,
0.1907476485,
-0.6858835816,
-0.3451829553,
-0.8550760746,
-0.7573072314,
0.553309679,
0.4840892851,
-0.0599992648,
-0.1923101842,
0.3440338075,
-0.0945834741,
0.5257425904,
-0.4216085076,
-0.2575056553,
-0.3715935051,
-0.166025728,
-0.5654720664,
-0.3194092512,
-0.2710249722,
-0.1065732688,
0.9511941075,
0.0411391035,
0.6516941786,
0.4030555487,
0.1365819871,
-0.4079864025,
0.61867553,
0.7952526808,
0.6107512712,
-0.3831527829,
-0.0175271221,
0.1694121659,
-0.1628197581,
0.4021273553,
-0.0689579993,
-0.1852088422,
0.3180369735,
0.0334238224,
1.3345292807,
-0.250138551,
-0.4157700539,
0.351967454,
-0.2679973841,
-0.060500484,
-0.4007720947,
0.183408156,
-0.0514338166,
0.1890680194,
-0.0560169034,
0.1780061424,
0.201919049,
-0.402182579,
0.0852281451,
0.2672873139,
-0.6003978848,
-0.4533078074,
0.933863163,
0.2360328883,
-0.6227314472,
0.677764535,
-0.2219522148,
-0.4756687284,
0.3976851702,
0.5446146131,
1.452875495,
-0.2860899866,
0.3322584629,
0.1711743325,
0.1440123767,
0.3639163077,
0.6189122796,
0.0554324016,
-0.5468662381,
-0.2400159985,
-0.5609009266,
-0.4174916446,
0.1812499166,
-0.9876914024,
0.1169302538,
-0.2397651821,
-0.9856230021,
-0.0431417301,
-0.1840239614,
-0.83530581,
0.8925905228,
0.2576700449,
0.4740411639,
-0.7460899949,
0.7460801005,
0.4324396551,
-0.3458883464,
-0.6602873206,
0.0334883071,
-0.0412250198,
-0.3398777544,
0.7940368652,
-0.1294195801,
-0.5667299032,
0.1070871279,
-0.3356819749,
-0.5831704736,
0.7944816947,
0.5757719278,
-0.6518822312,
0.035875272,
0.0173117146,
0.9050657749,
-0.4785779715,
-0.0420786776,
0.4934298992,
0.1666192859,
-0.3488263488,
-0.6321059465,
-0.1715139896,
-0.3538471758,
0.2862296402,
0.0962881446,
-0.7292596698,
0.8576093912,
-0.202559486,
-0.4694390297,
-0.1544576734,
0.8457045555,
-0.0442572907,
0.2878647447,
0.6356868148,
0.702863574,
0.6915799379,
-0.1267196834,
1.0567834377,
-0.4181086123,
0.1816592216,
1.2063629627,
-0.3899295628,
0.7834386826,
0.4742688835,
-0.1616384536,
0.3837948442,
0.5735352039,
0.4923032522,
0.7610679865,
0.3334771991,
-0.6585425138,
-0.1708139032,
-0.2411116809,
-0.5353810191,
0.3521832824,
0.572804749,
-0.4940935373,
0.2768411934,
0.2677169442,
0.0932129845,
-0.1152703166,
0.1034144014,
0.4842576385,
0.1389318407,
-0.907592833,
0.5111353397,
-0.2273054868,
0.320132494,
-0.6054288149,
0.1067934856,
-0.1654024571,
0.1890569478,
-0.0250351653,
-0.6896295547,
0.2096994072,
0.280444622,
-0.4566071332,
-0.3035437763,
0.3907189965,
-0.605999589,
-0.2223875523,
0.3299334347,
0.3827581108,
0.2119925022,
0.1361002624,
-0.6643749475,
-0.023665851,
0.1521812677,
-0.4976108372,
0.1074279845,
0.526227653,
0.3276933134,
0.6887860894,
0.4678371549,
0.3845921159,
0.1140211895,
0.5431310534,
0.6558324099,
-0.6975407004,
-0.3377555013,
-0.8279625773,
0.4564431608,
-0.0169531666,
-0.5257468224,
0.4987887442,
0.2809851468,
0.6879823208,
-0.3127118647,
1.0134756565,
-0.2901118696,
0.6228650808,
-0.7297406197,
0.7435210943,
-0.6900884509,
-0.2026555389,
-0.4824081361,
-0.7951763272,
0.0906597525,
0.3449985087,
-0.2074565887,
0.1095394194,
0.8220194578,
0.7362436652,
0.4468966424,
0.0188854523,
0.4868830442,
0.1013211086,
0.4603478611,
0.5997698307,
0.912774682,
-0.1694511473,
0.1906263679,
-0.4229444861,
-0.2115046531,
0.1649236232,
-1.0406222343,
-0.5929633975,
-0.7740780711,
-0.4873261452,
-0.3865108192,
0.1630215943,
0.7762036324,
0.6758529544,
-0.5884181857,
-0.2078533173,
0.1235716119,
-0.4079571962,
-0.1074626073,
-0.2893006504,
0.1004522592,
-0.31770733,
-0.9914485216,
0.6349980235,
0.5697012544,
0.2785092592,
-0.3008973598,
-0.0408482552,
-0.0147876926,
0.2537561059,
0.5782092214,
0.0515397079,
-0.7261106968,
-0.4288417399,
0.0338735357,
-0.0671645403,
0.2592501044,
0.7810631394,
-0.4473755658,
0.5110529065,
0.4768384397,
0.2954558134,
0.5929906368,
0.0449253917,
0.7096863389,
-0.784145236,
0.0900300965,
0.5114370584,
0.388474822,
0.5437601209,
-0.4581247866,
0.492985785,
0.1789543331,
-0.7822680473,
-0.7544334531,
0.3895767927,
-0.9151538014,
0.1841619611,
1.062738657,
-0.275390774,
-0.326304853,
0.2876402438,
-0.2739351094,
0.8676508069,
-0.3974936604,
0.8367004395,
0.8768532872,
-0.62042135,
-0.0740286261,
-0.4498452246,
0.9032052755,
0.5349653959,
-1.0348484516,
0.0022528598,
0.4686347246,
0.19949691,
0.1738187224,
0.8391178846,
-0.1014940068,
0.1030082181,
0.0733160153,
0.4551283419,
0.3916281164,
-0.4037134051,
-0.0670263991,
0.06590572,
0.0174385961,
-0.3074765503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12314v1 | Progressive Prompts: Continual Learning for Language Models | 2023-01-29T00:17:38 | 2023-01-29T00:17:38 | Anastasia Razdaibiedina, Yuning Mao, Rui Hou, Madian Khabsa, Mike Lewis, Amjad Almahairi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce Progressive Prompts - a simple and efficient approach for
continual learning in language models. Our method allows forward transfer and
resists catastrophic forgetting, without relying on data replay or a large
number of task-specific parameters. Progressive Prompts learns a new soft
prompt for each task and sequentially concatenates it with the previously
learned prompts, while keeping the base model frozen. Experiments on standard
continual learning benchmarks show that our approach outperforms
state-of-the-art methods, with an improvement >20% in average test accuracy
over the previous best-preforming method on T5 model. We also explore a more
challenging continual learning setup with longer sequences of tasks and show
that Progressive Prompts significantly outperforms prior methods. | [
-0.0083064614,
-0.9509608746,
0.6689803004,
0.4034016132,
-0.0190933011,
0.2709443271,
-0.3522060513,
0.1364202201,
-0.5093421936,
0.3622123301,
-1.0804870129,
-0.4776144624,
-0.1578860283,
0.1773376018,
-0.2952804863,
0.9528887272,
-0.1104194522,
0.148676753,
-0.1370417178,
-0.1402633935,
-1.0706820488,
-0.1926216185,
-1.2461344004,
-0.4136624038,
0.8673194051,
0.6810144782,
0.3331919611,
0.3554133475,
0.1866249591,
0.3163402081,
-0.0133973146,
-0.1716075987,
-0.4229722321,
0.748372376,
-0.3061168194,
-0.4358310699,
-0.0610137433,
-0.076620169,
0.9757883549,
1.1865468025,
-0.299335748,
-0.0543470979,
0.2053764164,
0.8829222322,
-0.5225917101,
0.0618976392,
-0.2878321111,
0.0885901749,
-0.1958212703,
0.1561705768,
-0.8392644525,
-0.8054666519,
0.1667644829,
-0.4238642454,
0.160358727,
-0.2376445532,
0.6428452134,
-0.1563716978,
-0.233906582,
-0.4873512685,
-0.887874186,
0.915563643,
-0.2832607031,
0.5945060253,
0.2501193583,
0.3872231245,
-0.190203473,
-1.214869976,
-0.5481838584,
-0.8851605058,
0.3878988624,
0.0845489949,
-0.1141544729,
0.0412565172,
0.3029308021,
0.2328119874,
-0.7206953764,
0.091965273,
-0.1053749248,
-0.2032838613,
0.3074677885,
0.485817045,
0.3419515789,
0.3598743379,
-0.2818045914,
-0.037078701,
-0.9094161391,
0.2547767162,
-0.1143208742,
0.2655587196,
0.048400823,
0.1194378436,
-0.0172940232,
0.8319608569,
0.1964808255,
-0.258862555,
0.2369386703,
-0.2949462235,
0.013929355,
-0.5288351774,
0.5450519919,
-0.1449802071,
0.4848781526,
-0.5155136585,
-0.4568592012,
0.097108677,
0.32545048,
-0.2931049764,
-0.3029871881,
0.1303139329,
-0.3101144135,
-0.0311035942,
-0.3553622067,
-0.8531230092,
-0.0762238503,
-0.5776407719,
0.6052090526,
-0.6816498637,
-0.1787780374,
-0.0414680652,
-0.0734317154,
0.0486338139,
0.5003195405,
-0.8147476315,
0.4534127712,
0.4998735785,
1.0728962421,
-0.3834877908,
-0.4354659021,
-0.9295781851,
-0.1221261546,
-0.570158124,
0.7435716987,
-0.7627074122,
-0.623723805,
0.2804579735,
0.2107266784,
-0.1015111059,
-0.5330168009,
0.2365002334,
-0.5252119303,
0.5137855411,
-0.4271118641,
-0.7080196738,
-0.280707866,
0.2037691027,
-0.5046876073,
0.9422742128,
0.3153863549,
-0.1458427757,
0.1460601687,
-0.6669709086,
-0.2584401667,
0.2781084478,
0.2740020454,
-0.1930137426,
0.1081442833,
-0.2583282888,
0.3127281666,
0.0601691157,
0.4091743529,
-0.2589454055,
-0.0179836359,
0.1933371723,
-0.5778574347,
0.5627599359,
0.2425263822,
-0.2734494209,
0.4588748813,
-0.4771242142,
-0.2864513397,
0.1783086807,
-0.3248339295,
-0.0785658285,
-0.0983670726,
-0.2778619826,
0.13812612,
0.2572332323,
-0.3540276289,
0.5328831077,
-0.1860975325,
0.347122103,
1.0126358271,
0.1458057314,
0.5361135006,
-0.6371977329,
0.7216719985,
0.0586588234,
0.3008647561,
-0.8932334781,
-0.4803981781,
-0.8738644123,
0.1412496269,
0.4471444786,
0.8203334808,
-0.9783591032,
0.0686034784,
-0.1363000721,
-0.5200110078,
-0.0332648046,
0.2885569036,
0.3815014958,
0.8840526938,
0.3464139104,
-0.4739903212,
-0.1882884502,
-0.279335022,
0.0028391979,
-0.1965255737,
-0.1446559876,
-0.0359242633,
0.5472643971,
-0.1353688389,
0.8107162118,
-0.2510673106,
0.209715277,
-0.377672106,
0.2972421944,
0.2928369641,
0.6838340759,
0.294246465,
-0.7186467648,
-0.6559247375,
-0.4485146105,
-0.7732599378,
0.0309474971,
-0.5194705129,
0.2208486199,
0.1811210364,
0.5847548246,
-0.6858586073,
-0.1153635159,
0.3417877257,
-0.4672470987,
1.0102243423,
-0.143446371,
-0.1384097487,
-0.7120828629,
0.0210418552,
0.0041533862,
-0.495208919,
-0.8229791522,
-0.0189521499,
0.1039490849,
-0.1276050359,
-0.5460827351,
0.84622401,
-0.5389933586,
0.3662109077,
-0.1929157227,
0.0990196392,
-0.0868616253,
0.3642742038,
-0.0571781807,
0.8794724941,
0.9298369884,
-0.9859446883,
0.6519988179,
-0.0262629688,
-0.0088342614,
0.3997637928,
-0.683144331,
0.4811566174,
-0.2727698088,
0.2951162159,
-1.1106207371,
0.0897946656,
0.4067468047,
-0.4122433364,
0.7042379975,
0.0908305123,
-0.2624699473,
-0.4022265971,
-0.1235759854,
0.1001803428,
0.9580823183,
-0.4433096349,
0.6144390702,
-0.0093704835,
-0.7143173814,
-0.419432044,
-0.3779739141,
0.1607071459,
-0.3132418394,
-0.3217102587,
0.3528496623,
-0.4976583719,
-0.1864416152,
-0.1338598728,
0.0822852999,
0.0236512925,
0.2050796747,
0.1132717356,
0.2123657018,
-0.2640097141,
0.581733346,
-0.2056730241,
-0.300674051,
-0.090767011,
-0.6326674223,
0.7472218871,
-0.2988547385,
-0.0522531494,
-0.5631911159,
0.5755847692,
0.3794995248,
-0.0815155134,
0.786220789,
0.3313442171,
-0.4838452339,
-0.1056332067,
-0.7356023788,
-0.33077389,
-0.5600461364,
0.0036611792,
-0.5481114388,
-0.9176101089,
0.5678354502,
-0.5021900535,
0.3322463632,
0.3167628646,
0.4896842539,
-0.2970535159,
0.9439873099,
1.0673086643,
-0.024099512,
0.8606634736,
0.0238907095,
-0.3353542089,
-0.4339542091,
-0.5633203983,
-0.5607548952,
0.1105318591,
-0.1188653931,
-0.0990785733,
0.0036772776,
0.5544043183,
-0.6180890203,
0.0861591473,
-0.2509236932,
0.3578036726,
0.3907608092,
0.2266307473,
0.0346312299,
-0.208408162,
-0.3426731527,
-0.0453702062,
-0.8021571636,
-0.4783854187,
0.8242409229,
0.4820221364,
0.5071008801,
0.080441162,
0.5861455798,
0.4483270943,
0.6498664618,
-0.6799374223,
0.5835117102,
0.0358869508,
-0.1054596677,
-0.357250154,
-0.3833302557,
-1.2699487209,
-0.3785174191,
0.1895807832,
-0.7859476209,
0.0493042618,
0.2611037493,
-0.4629661739,
0.0513010733,
-0.6515538692,
0.8286082149,
-0.0498140715,
-0.5909008384,
-0.1153923348,
-0.582224071,
0.0304970648,
-0.0409416407,
0.0396983549,
0.1679273099,
-0.2796722949,
0.7781024575,
-0.1528989673,
1.129312396,
-0.3441597223,
0.0618222468,
0.3275738657,
0.2212978005,
0.641210556,
0.0561751984,
-0.0101845143,
-0.1183448061,
-0.35363397,
-0.6191431284,
-0.6221699119,
0.4950030744,
-0.3083071709,
-0.6176935434,
-0.5434355736,
-0.3092755675,
-0.2538936436,
0.2752210796,
0.1079705134,
0.655105412,
-0.0721011013,
-0.1413481981,
1.1180520058,
-0.2259356529,
0.8656137586,
0.7748810649,
-0.1088771448,
-0.4260347486,
0.8535693288,
0.0784527659,
0.3513888121,
0.1799003631,
0.3710312545,
-0.5550940633,
-0.7562168837,
-0.3223623335,
0.3322323263,
-0.9606311321,
-0.1091449708,
-0.6181240678,
-0.0114401355,
-0.3228128254,
-0.2664853334,
-0.2792974412,
-0.075507313,
-0.3462005556,
0.0277480111,
0.3461842835,
0.7548443675,
-0.1699930727,
0.2958272398,
-1.2241545916,
0.1885925084,
0.4713535011,
0.2327734828,
0.0406578928,
-0.656942606,
0.0410542339,
-0.0659471005,
-0.524418056,
-1.1548776627,
0.3700288236,
0.4094773233,
0.7347882986,
0.3284293413,
0.0032559999,
0.5537657738,
-0.8629269004,
1.3628667593,
0.4410039485,
-1.2005665302,
0.7951372862,
-0.3070146739,
0.7939784527,
0.5871529579,
0.7853472233,
-0.7691923976,
-0.2304600477,
-0.6592995524,
-0.7653956413,
0.0192613639,
-0.2030382901,
0.4466499388,
-0.3352434635,
0.758210659,
0.4685647488,
0.2090781331,
-0.606212914,
-0.1869073361,
-0.0526625924,
-0.2609122396,
-0.1975350231,
-0.3695450425,
0.1224257797,
-0.1999650747,
0.5735014081,
-0.1548120528,
0.27135095,
0.1132281944,
-0.1261391193,
0.0029158725,
0.1949221641,
0.810806632,
1.0231750011,
0.1486403644,
-0.0508562811,
0.541980505,
-0.5950559974,
0.2898282111,
-0.3156547248,
-0.1309987009,
0.2117334306,
0.5343508124,
0.7796515822,
0.1078224406,
-0.6024484634,
0.1759248972,
-0.1060116291,
0.0177445542,
-0.7011266351,
0.1949074566,
0.0571560003,
0.200815931,
0.4215545058,
0.1635309756,
-0.0804421604,
-0.8012208343,
0.6673644185,
-0.0876171216,
-0.7789844871,
-0.5130727291,
0.4014415145,
0.1997394711,
-0.6618304849,
1.1619613171,
-0.2999197543,
-0.5177441239,
0.3798103929,
0.7356639504,
0.9896264672,
-0.7354832888,
0.3454940617,
0.4733935893,
-0.0884583667,
-0.7017425895,
0.5220646262,
-0.279173255,
-0.4904941618,
-0.6952842474,
-0.5023390651,
-0.7076438665,
0.0961063504,
-0.6387212276,
0.0788856968,
-0.4573867917,
-0.1478939056,
-0.2597900927,
-0.0718299001,
-0.4840112329,
0.3223274946,
0.1632603407,
1.3848981857,
-0.808483541,
1.0569765568,
0.6584454775,
-0.5121821165,
-0.679022789,
0.0091497265,
-0.0594828501,
-0.4596788287,
0.6502864361,
0.3416169584,
-0.0099415639,
0.2412476093,
-0.6249135733,
-0.6806743741,
0.9701090455,
0.3750970662,
-0.9244207144,
-0.1630208492,
-0.4622405469,
0.3291321397,
-0.3572325408,
0.2096537054,
0.5009379387,
0.4339774549,
0.3096857965,
-0.7468898296,
0.1493350714,
-0.2523713112,
-0.0123411482,
0.0756363869,
-0.4531998932,
0.9187446237,
-0.3620001674,
-0.4683786333,
0.2656252682,
0.9233296514,
0.4569880962,
0.4999365211,
0.6974212527,
0.1320417076,
1.1149042845,
-0.298954308,
1.0551428795,
-0.0761348754,
0.3008840084,
0.8758301735,
-0.2236417532,
0.77886343,
0.3041313887,
-0.1633956432,
0.9043477774,
0.9259181023,
0.112235412,
0.7207708955,
0.2393233925,
-0.5867457986,
-0.4904739857,
-0.0877050757,
-0.2999331057,
-0.2107486874,
0.5273504853,
0.0938523784,
-0.1789223701,
0.5427678227,
0.200553447,
0.1389361024,
-0.4257130027,
0.8552120924,
0.3805561662,
-1.0354845524,
0.705263555,
-0.2940289974,
0.6047611237,
-1.0079277754,
-0.1554400176,
-0.3511748612,
0.1577777565,
0.2670595944,
-0.785017252,
0.3506999016,
-0.1357253045,
-0.1899210662,
-0.4552823007,
0.6058448553,
-0.3873410225,
-0.326166153,
0.0057686544,
0.2452620268,
-0.0280848015,
0.0155319497,
-0.9912981987,
-0.0188900772,
-0.2031934261,
-0.4405054748,
0.1987798959,
0.4122600853,
-0.1136812344,
1.2757656574,
0.6309046745,
0.1251884997,
0.0015464063,
0.1630032063,
0.8831794858,
-0.9419533014,
-0.6063963771,
-1.0726732016,
0.8664319515,
0.0917824581,
-0.3191781044,
0.6696794033,
0.0226371568,
0.6209447384,
-0.233445853,
0.7212676406,
0.2599604726,
0.320392698,
-0.9373095632,
0.3103007674,
-0.3274918199,
0.1903170496,
0.1444164366,
-0.684571445,
-0.3390693069,
0.4353429079,
-0.1815504879,
0.2500008047,
0.8828908801,
0.4787652791,
0.3555417657,
0.0744339302,
0.1929359287,
0.0352691785,
0.3154549003,
0.8208112717,
1.1580108404,
-0.0208149627,
0.2029809803,
-0.2185623497,
-0.3077811003,
0.1676136404,
-0.9338279963,
-0.7985695004,
-0.7724047899,
-0.5893810391,
-0.4626148939,
0.596573174,
0.8074803352,
0.6383798122,
-0.9820671678,
-0.0861665905,
-0.6028435826,
0.1790645868,
-0.5923061967,
-0.215594396,
0.1856638491,
-1.0357382298,
-0.6242892742,
0.5880557299,
0.1863154024,
0.1772593558,
-0.4064120352,
-0.2577875853,
-0.0783996582,
-0.0089616301,
0.5332298875,
0.6080691814,
-0.4501815438,
-0.4302613437,
0.1639044285,
0.028869044,
-0.0321558975,
0.8347402811,
-1.1579357386,
0.4021205902,
0.5613785982,
0.4790320694,
0.3037978709,
-0.2111151218,
0.8584983945,
-0.6714625359,
0.0225123335,
0.5565326214,
0.0938822478,
0.4285755754,
-0.1596767157,
0.1673318595,
0.4875741005,
-0.5568670034,
-0.8662216067,
0.4476549625,
-0.8529894948,
-0.3477003872,
1.0353181362,
-0.6031786203,
-0.1530522257,
-0.4625280201,
0.1413758844,
0.1767938286,
-0.3518815041,
0.5955634713,
0.6081088185,
0.0204000026,
-0.6379613876,
-0.6204453707,
0.5325599909,
0.3796923161,
-0.509503305,
-0.089137949,
0.394292444,
0.7091271281,
0.1713202447,
0.7693058252,
-0.0003142006,
0.5170932412,
0.0988827348,
-0.2002983093,
-0.0405167788,
-0.8289801478,
-0.8319603801,
0.4746256769,
0.1716869175,
-0.1801173389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12307v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12307v2 | MQAG: Multiple-choice Question Answering and Generation for Assessing Information Consistency in Summarization | 2023-01-28T23:08:25 | 2023-09-07T18:20:40 | Potsawee Manakul, Adian Liusie, Mark J. F. Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art summarization systems can generate highly fluent summaries.
These summaries, however, may contain factual inconsistencies and/or
information not present in the source. Hence, an important component of
assessing the quality of summaries is to determine whether there is information
consistency between the source and the summary. Existing approaches are
typically based on lexical matching or representation-based methods. In this
work, we introduce an alternative scheme based on standard
information-theoretic measures in which the information present in the source
and summary is directly compared. We propose a Multiple-choice Question
Answering and Generation framework, MQAG, which approximates the information
consistency by computing the expected statistical distance between summary and
source answer distributions over automatically generated multiple-choice
questions. This approach exploits multiple-choice answer probabilities, as
predicted answer distributions can be compared. We conduct experiments on four
summary evaluation datasets: QAG-CNNDM/XSum, XSum-Hallucination, Podcast
Assessment, and SummEval. Experiments show that MQAG, using models trained on
SQuAD or RACE, outperforms existing evaluation methods on the majority of
tasks. | [
-0.5768576264,
-0.5902785659,
0.5161116719,
0.1323401034,
-0.1182172075,
0.0833431706,
-0.0375160612,
-0.1791092306,
0.4281921983,
0.1299298108,
-0.6987046003,
-0.0787032619,
-0.5161939263,
0.3227833211,
-0.1685189903,
0.990177989,
-0.2267313898,
0.0142639596,
-0.4417748451,
-0.3584006429,
-0.3178890347,
-0.4841524959,
-0.5948714614,
-0.0981512517,
0.3763271868,
0.3025781214,
0.8825711608,
0.5510077477,
0.4112648964,
0.1785230786,
0.2232450992,
0.5914859772,
-0.455229491,
0.1982695758,
0.0262606014,
-0.097242564,
-0.305791527,
0.0676675662,
0.7699611783,
0.3099726439,
-0.2889446318,
0.5362299681,
0.2387804985,
0.5769539475,
-0.9113314748,
-0.1288556308,
-0.3256384432,
-0.0328576639,
0.1621741951,
-0.3494297564,
-0.2751470804,
-0.6820885539,
0.037760742,
-0.3934761286,
0.2368016541,
0.0469067618,
0.9590267539,
0.1261940449,
-0.594283402,
-0.4440140426,
-0.4752835631,
0.6712352037,
-0.6716683507,
0.3475778699,
0.313970834,
0.4995200634,
-0.1618471295,
-0.3581762016,
-0.7244541049,
-0.2852381766,
-0.0280772559,
0.6914771199,
-0.1490349323,
-0.0194520373,
0.1094571054,
0.3610425591,
-0.8404729366,
-0.4318215549,
-0.1879256219,
-0.1708590537,
0.8152631521,
0.2255363315,
0.0908822715,
-0.4711092412,
-0.511064887,
-0.0884578303,
-0.596363306,
0.0661428198,
0.43461743,
-0.0505756736,
0.1262896359,
0.9582076073,
-0.5227478743,
0.5638890266,
0.1104168221,
-0.2889331281,
0.1430818737,
-0.8261107802,
-0.2862083614,
0.0179779455,
0.6048622727,
0.7363959551,
-0.0382231399,
0.1151489988,
0.2112645805,
-0.4771893322,
0.1196584776,
-0.5370138884,
-0.1127621979,
0.5058000088,
-0.5317549706,
-0.141335994,
0.1892931908,
-0.4929092526,
-0.1386481822,
-0.3457895219,
0.6366803646,
-0.3662751615,
-0.2868435383,
-0.1941165924,
-0.5053365827,
0.4420335889,
0.3724701703,
-0.725292623,
-0.0086757494,
0.2765740156,
0.7896848321,
-0.1887480468,
-0.4463869631,
-0.5767233968,
0.3869329393,
-0.3131825626,
0.8015847802,
-0.0236045383,
-0.1367655098,
-0.2578394711,
-0.2848326862,
-0.1209233925,
-0.4902060032,
0.2820064425,
-0.3612671793,
0.4245218039,
-0.5302416682,
-0.7696208358,
-0.1974985152,
0.5950570107,
-0.5738931298,
1.0826355219,
0.3209370673,
-0.9811574221,
0.6262205839,
-0.377227664,
-0.0085994331,
-0.3017807305,
-0.2137903869,
-0.3925970793,
-0.009232684,
0.1930229068,
0.2882838249,
-0.1468055099,
0.2781242132,
-0.2493777275,
-0.2432865351,
0.209530592,
-0.5998932123,
0.7109038234,
0.1980293244,
-0.018743623,
0.0097151399,
-0.578374207,
0.276335299,
-0.15670982,
-0.6240304112,
-0.0779360905,
0.0942006335,
-0.3219589889,
0.2361416966,
0.1879571676,
-0.3194197118,
0.152369678,
0.13500835,
-0.1734453291,
0.4890164435,
0.3948934674,
0.1537451446,
-0.987206161,
0.5383131504,
-0.0298938174,
0.1267911643,
-0.3278268576,
-0.5202534795,
-0.4249055982,
-0.2841140628,
0.5642354488,
0.6239937544,
-0.8387339711,
0.486833632,
-0.3461134732,
-0.5085400343,
-0.4879201353,
-0.0566312261,
0.2366375029,
0.4932162166,
0.430647701,
-0.0422879905,
-0.5643069148,
-0.7926950455,
-0.3809943199,
-0.4227232039,
-0.4022884965,
0.1133264005,
0.3986360729,
0.1242772639,
0.8512363434,
-0.4734588265,
0.2685337365,
-0.2429737002,
0.2719576955,
-0.1124922633,
0.4576741755,
0.4366596639,
-0.6871516705,
-0.1320984364,
-0.4483947754,
-0.9109330177,
-0.0262182504,
-0.2521448433,
-0.3514354527,
-0.1837302446,
0.3512713015,
-0.5141137242,
0.2443029583,
0.5602098107,
-0.1173565239,
1.1312520504,
-0.1052617803,
0.8710426092,
-1.1573857069,
0.0526814722,
-0.3002809584,
-0.3168424368,
-0.5569642186,
0.1058034152,
0.0271958336,
0.1722153276,
-0.3285278082,
0.5949306488,
-0.3025194407,
-0.049028758,
-0.1730746776,
0.4330207407,
0.2611035109,
0.2503688931,
-0.1934153587,
0.8876629472,
0.1922903359,
-0.7889060974,
0.3185239136,
0.4509424865,
-0.1787184328,
0.7921718359,
-0.4588601887,
-0.0675818473,
-0.3493869603,
0.1355631202,
-1.2634190321,
-0.4347959161,
0.1472922713,
-0.8115827441,
0.0065318388,
-0.0140769975,
-0.4480507374,
0.0706045628,
-0.5658020377,
0.4128234088,
0.2977459729,
-0.5016827583,
0.6332211494,
0.1983249187,
-0.5374496579,
-0.837705195,
-0.5087364912,
0.1041247845,
-0.1022913903,
-0.8373699188,
0.017667383,
-0.269040525,
-0.4140920639,
-0.2029081881,
-0.4139428139,
-0.1976594329,
-0.0434051789,
-0.1934812665,
0.0651459768,
-0.405313164,
0.2935416996,
0.3209150732,
0.2079928219,
-0.0884315446,
-0.0430305973,
0.0766185895,
0.1405606121,
-0.4011160731,
0.0909328088,
0.6171576977,
0.297809124,
-0.1961766928,
0.4602579474,
0.4372959435,
-0.2778388858,
0.0668795034,
-0.6027765274,
-0.0138611402,
-0.3887020946,
0.1552015245,
-0.4636336565,
-0.6135631204,
0.4436708689,
0.1297091991,
0.3722265363,
0.5060287714,
0.5003579855,
-0.3917658031,
1.0215828419,
0.39847067,
0.3028116524,
0.2790221572,
0.1593506932,
-0.2513409853,
-0.6047431827,
-0.1454824358,
-0.4553340971,
-0.0654307157,
-0.2099366337,
-0.1275472641,
0.567697823,
0.3382824063,
-0.1415150017,
0.0349465758,
0.002517838,
0.5707547069,
0.6657332182,
0.0257216282,
0.5455237627,
-0.107171692,
-0.0536813997,
0.231657654,
-0.8589680195,
-0.7066034675,
1.0642869473,
-0.0781263188,
0.4493371546,
0.3927705586,
0.8025491834,
0.4192459583,
0.3272067606,
-0.5132559538,
0.216065973,
0.2658391893,
-0.4767885804,
-0.551150322,
-0.675217092,
-0.851919055,
0.5700423717,
-0.5189523697,
-0.3577761352,
0.0235426407,
0.097617887,
-0.4257887304,
0.1039104238,
-0.5886241794,
0.5883140564,
-0.0579914935,
0.0340455249,
0.2203240395,
-0.6268147826,
0.7404970527,
0.1337766051,
0.0861426666,
-0.0672207698,
0.0758224949,
0.8686163425,
-0.2460714132,
-0.0158927124,
-0.0178138483,
0.044366844,
0.5205209851,
0.1610347182,
0.1036043912,
0.2925376594,
-0.2215759009,
-0.1491330713,
0.3770470023,
-0.7591508627,
-0.8278486133,
0.2286662757,
-0.4265406132,
-0.4643700421,
-0.2892306447,
-0.6087774038,
-0.1971561611,
0.297945708,
0.5070489049,
0.4272797406,
-0.3663870394,
-0.0399719402,
0.4945130348,
0.0123145431,
0.2738088667,
0.2600004375,
0.0017739647,
-0.6601359248,
0.4440022111,
0.1860242039,
0.4888299406,
0.1979700774,
0.0974612236,
-0.616160512,
-0.3754363954,
-0.9703566432,
0.0249102358,
-0.6581398845,
-0.3234996796,
-0.4598998427,
-0.2653802335,
-0.2907478213,
0.0110317636,
0.0697941035,
-0.5513135791,
0.0267548971,
-0.2399111241,
-0.0963399708,
0.5092584491,
-0.0204570629,
0.1767706126,
-0.895265758,
0.5736478567,
0.4751883447,
0.2506735921,
-0.1829402894,
-0.3799473345,
-0.222025007,
0.3748039305,
-0.4661681056,
-1.2498356104,
-0.1897887588,
0.1671769172,
0.5878668427,
0.3511502743,
0.1008174345,
0.7081984282,
-0.292930752,
0.919465363,
0.1207782105,
-0.9554767013,
0.3259200454,
-0.3675048053,
0.3874435425,
0.950373292,
0.3286662102,
-0.3893699646,
-0.7605615258,
-0.8950414062,
-0.4104792476,
0.1136311963,
0.5679171681,
-0.2426537126,
-0.0867339522,
0.45016554,
0.0272963196,
0.4561267495,
-0.3803038001,
-0.2516896725,
-0.3379456997,
-0.2327369452,
-0.1671770811,
-0.0973524675,
-0.190227896,
0.2864980996,
0.5425513387,
-0.2599212527,
0.1734963357,
0.452680558,
-0.1114804819,
0.130708009,
0.3568447828,
0.7707802057,
0.9376859069,
-0.2302111834,
0.3643905818,
0.3416621387,
-0.391022712,
0.5582987666,
-0.0482310206,
-0.3391300142,
0.4405449033,
0.2868910134,
0.0489839762,
-0.1793893278,
-0.7789012194,
0.789562881,
-0.1214502603,
-0.4558211863,
-0.189746052,
0.2255584747,
-0.1243610457,
0.1180499047,
0.3633564115,
0.1457275301,
0.4470619559,
-0.4195864201,
0.567905426,
0.3315013647,
-0.246639356,
0.1886673123,
0.4795762002,
-0.3405135572,
0.2068634033,
0.4122435153,
-0.4828239679,
-0.0792710632,
0.7603961229,
0.1247010306,
0.6509841681,
-0.3385944366,
0.4594574869,
0.520108521,
0.4247578979,
-0.3669799566,
0.7803102136,
0.0208173022,
-0.5812363029,
-0.4665856957,
-0.2284173071,
-0.6983759999,
-0.133151114,
-0.6714705825,
0.1478835642,
-0.1207189411,
-0.1069582775,
-0.0868902728,
-0.17922014,
-0.2812822461,
0.4015496075,
-0.1405588984,
0.8874640465,
-0.7710077763,
0.2824200392,
0.3122700453,
-0.6147708297,
-0.7561086416,
0.1577691138,
-0.0502255633,
-0.4000034034,
-0.0497315153,
-0.1475656331,
-0.2040321082,
-0.1938314885,
-0.3857637346,
-0.8907855749,
1.2587639093,
0.4755739272,
-0.0148710934,
0.1668582112,
-0.1850118339,
0.2227332145,
-0.2110475898,
0.5939403176,
0.5636011958,
0.5152661204,
0.0294393525,
-0.7959245443,
0.0789757594,
-0.1912823468,
-0.4200479686,
0.1414332837,
-0.6167930365,
0.6872564554,
-0.437815845,
-0.3505168855,
0.1689887345,
0.737259388,
0.7363838553,
0.426130414,
0.3057146072,
0.2144970596,
1.0533033609,
-0.1897046417,
0.9095743299,
-0.1061965376,
0.2696172297,
1.3539658785,
-0.0568115748,
0.8042066693,
0.4468758106,
-0.1310864538,
0.28691414,
0.6240829229,
-0.1802545637,
0.2490652055,
0.3054647148,
-0.2118024081,
0.0098189618,
0.1300230771,
-0.3386705518,
0.5180149078,
-0.1745532304,
-0.213378638,
-0.590588212,
-0.1916145682,
-0.0335987322,
-0.1811820865,
-0.2546370924,
0.9625400901,
-0.2155607045,
-0.8188781142,
0.734023273,
0.1391379833,
0.1601280719,
-0.6835267544,
-0.1587347835,
-0.3507179916,
-0.5984889269,
-0.3007892072,
-0.8007225394,
0.42435956,
0.0083192801,
-0.27649194,
0.2046840936,
0.4233834743,
-0.5921465158,
-0.2119176835,
-0.3016144633,
0.9916799664,
0.1805884391,
-0.0842733234,
-0.4731070399,
-0.5487933755,
-0.1324631125,
-0.0685276464,
0.1948803961,
0.2729354799,
0.1659014672,
0.499245882,
0.4623812437,
0.0952207372,
0.3160897791,
-0.0921783596,
0.3606018424,
-0.4275282323,
-0.7184150219,
-0.8185011744,
0.4850094914,
-0.2069765031,
-0.4104382098,
0.9799858332,
0.8750567436,
0.5812773705,
-0.0152994217,
1.0804195404,
0.0067510786,
0.430624485,
-0.7822409272,
0.5663685203,
-0.3798161149,
-0.0665055886,
-0.3725514114,
-1.0038255453,
-0.1662696749,
0.305678606,
0.0571247116,
0.0527040623,
0.6327961087,
0.626298666,
-0.1957441568,
0.0895782709,
0.2153174728,
-0.1541710347,
0.14745453,
0.4185536504,
1.1886283159,
-0.5451213717,
0.6163164377,
0.2614348233,
-0.4155213535,
0.0547812581,
-0.8766975999,
-0.5275694132,
-0.5830801129,
-0.305510819,
-0.5269191265,
-0.0555083677,
0.8353539705,
0.5804042816,
-0.6615095735,
-0.2125798613,
0.3273212314,
0.2984284461,
-0.5470196009,
-0.2149197757,
0.4860603809,
-0.307466805,
-0.2502132058,
0.1503174901,
0.2385518551,
0.2666520476,
-0.0091892285,
-0.0464146025,
-0.0216900446,
0.4766212702,
0.6146525145,
0.1642123312,
-0.4756767154,
-0.398660332,
0.105191946,
-0.0502425358,
0.2689161301,
0.6429855227,
-0.243335411,
0.4292850792,
0.659845829,
0.6662451625,
0.2495988905,
0.698374033,
0.5441195965,
-0.890971005,
-0.4963580668,
0.036098659,
0.2605496645,
0.0752125904,
-0.2805142999,
0.2113076001,
-0.3022938371,
-0.5615768433,
-0.5090247393,
0.4359654486,
-0.8767615557,
-0.1216572672,
1.0692727566,
-0.1822775006,
0.1675858945,
-0.2990804017,
-0.3782443106,
0.2232540101,
-0.0961266086,
0.8955200911,
0.853512466,
-0.4377177358,
-0.1054746509,
-0.641156137,
0.6815387607,
0.1439333856,
-1.014564991,
0.0495958664,
0.6356404424,
0.3418160677,
0.1712877899,
0.8769506812,
-0.0763900951,
0.6461171508,
0.0738515258,
-0.1276906878,
0.0214333404,
-0.3104460537,
-0.335607022,
0.4131339788,
-0.1200527251,
-0.1991737932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12303v1 | Presence of informal language, such as emoticons, hashtags, and slang, impact the performance of sentiment analysis models on social media text? | 2023-01-28T22:21:51 | 2023-01-28T22:21:51 | Aadil Gani Ganie | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study aimed to investigate the influence of the presence of informal
language, such as emoticons and slang, on the performance of sentiment analysis
models applied to social media text. A convolutional neural network (CNN) model
was developed and trained on three datasets: a sarcasm dataset, a sentiment
dataset, and an emoticon dataset. The model architecture was held constant for
all experiments and the model was trained on 80% of the data and tested on 20%.
The results revealed that the model achieved an accuracy of 96.47% on the
sarcasm dataset, with the lowest accuracy for class 1. On the sentiment
dataset, the model achieved an accuracy of 95.28%. The amalgamation of sarcasm
and sentiment datasets improved the accuracy of the model to 95.1%, and the
addition of emoticon dataset has a slight positive impact on the accuracy of
the model to 95.37%. The study suggests that the presence of informal language
has a restricted impact on the performance of sentiment analysis models applied
to social media text. However, the inclusion of emoticon data to the model can
enhance the accuracy slightly. | [
-0.0973231718,
-1.1579172611,
0.2485578209,
0.5616624355,
-0.6261262894,
0.3360218108,
-0.3577262163,
-0.7296178937,
0.5388290286,
-0.1404133439,
-0.1579070836,
-0.5975722671,
-0.8825868964,
0.3304766715,
-0.4296053648,
1.0007306337,
0.3184204996,
0.276414454,
-0.1111280099,
-0.0182797518,
-0.0561000407,
-0.7311913967,
-0.8434633613,
0.1881082654,
0.3895565569,
0.2210556567,
0.8590347171,
0.1917360127,
0.6203663945,
0.2948186696,
-0.3825108409,
0.2022370249,
-0.5871964097,
-0.0595555343,
0.2429946959,
-0.0896099359,
-0.3285125792,
0.046118807,
0.4806877971,
0.300747484,
0.0087038586,
0.1401388198,
0.1647791117,
0.4693267643,
-0.4903295338,
0.1845718622,
-0.5976471305,
0.1079421416,
-0.1433489174,
-0.2024704069,
-0.0607852712,
-0.5113499761,
0.1789985895,
-0.198970139,
-0.0775544196,
-0.1070249453,
0.9712926745,
0.0913781449,
-0.239776358,
-0.5506529212,
-0.7481387854,
0.5890718699,
-1.0756579638,
0.1361064166,
0.3786163926,
0.21312356,
0.2190786004,
-0.745628953,
-0.7087419033,
-0.2379529029,
-0.3091123402,
0.1203285232,
-0.1123287827,
0.2340468019,
0.028412573,
0.228087306,
-0.1661912203,
0.0466544069,
-0.6075373888,
0.2389086634,
0.7779793143,
0.0861917436,
0.2808011174,
-0.5439302921,
-0.1785886139,
0.5174555182,
-0.2625140846,
0.2776073217,
0.3758505881,
0.4124311209,
-0.3917208612,
0.5617222786,
-0.2882698774,
0.6086683273,
-0.0730490312,
-0.0693312138,
0.3597257435,
-0.5020613074,
-0.3503462076,
0.0064014578,
1.0661714077,
0.372792691,
0.9491883516,
-0.0113814743,
-0.3489007056,
0.0585407466,
0.3594978154,
-0.6877310872,
-0.15343301,
0.0507385843,
-0.6069547534,
-0.8429269791,
0.2221041471,
-0.5956770182,
-0.5038903952,
-0.1423543692,
0.0895226076,
-0.2677947283,
-0.0983781666,
-0.3394372463,
-0.3012062311,
0.0980271697,
0.3356018662,
-0.6478350759,
0.5020681024,
0.7025126219,
1.142988801,
0.2967828512,
0.0186632089,
-0.0737060755,
-0.3267645538,
-0.2769812047,
0.7367959023,
-0.9966191053,
-0.3939587176,
0.2077788711,
-0.2547610402,
-0.2570669949,
-0.0444877967,
0.6714303493,
-0.4566157162,
-0.0681317151,
-0.0831211805,
-0.7303441167,
-0.2589183152,
0.2456903011,
-0.7263385653,
1.3515901566,
0.0374898911,
-0.9492319822,
0.2753630579,
-0.4716625214,
-0.7568107843,
0.0872738808,
-0.4467460811,
-0.15379031,
0.2665747404,
0.1680205464,
0.9912831783,
0.0458420776,
0.0570342019,
-0.4966439009,
-1.0018981695,
0.7909190059,
-0.5009608865,
0.455193758,
0.2642209232,
-0.652613759,
-0.4581832886,
-0.7585943937,
-0.1698757857,
-0.0881840587,
-0.4186136425,
-0.5833094716,
0.0330279171,
0.3740787506,
0.6266144514,
-0.0731019899,
-0.6389209032,
0.0529849306,
-0.4501007497,
0.2559717894,
0.6994825602,
0.1388268918,
0.220950529,
-0.0219964068,
0.6812046766,
0.0680578128,
-0.0050150342,
0.0844388083,
-0.7559605241,
-0.6024608016,
-0.1351728439,
0.2536423802,
0.3617530167,
-0.654289186,
0.1411172748,
-0.7132748365,
-0.4196313322,
-0.7872874737,
-0.0287320092,
0.2596580684,
0.1308074892,
-0.0671327859,
0.1166075543,
-0.6285970211,
-0.7690765858,
-0.4121876657,
-0.0183361452,
0.2303423882,
0.5234980583,
0.4340013862,
0.1331424564,
0.8346742392,
-0.3236548901,
-0.0297688451,
-0.299621135,
0.2050437182,
-0.0673981681,
0.1310821772,
0.7871413827,
-1.0377429724,
-0.7611271739,
-0.1573277265,
-0.7511342168,
0.0043721199,
0.1599468887,
0.3421864212,
0.5595644116,
0.4723095298,
-0.4435662031,
0.6955490708,
0.7788745761,
-0.3399263024,
0.3583235741,
0.2962914705,
0.5944048762,
-1.1642856598,
0.04911948,
0.5236110687,
-0.0807067975,
-0.8577087522,
-0.2800795436,
-0.1424812526,
-0.0699257776,
-0.658929348,
0.620962441,
-0.2281285673,
0.2753430903,
-0.2123677731,
0.2649434507,
0.0311065111,
0.1491518021,
-0.0174455326,
0.6184809804,
0.4616737664,
-0.5395396352,
0.0743690208,
-0.2411399037,
-0.3214593828,
0.1500796229,
-0.8589684367,
0.1911088973,
-0.2271839529,
0.1843662113,
-1.3837569952,
-0.2958652377,
0.5693038106,
-0.9056771398,
0.3335150778,
-0.0841140375,
-0.6314540505,
-0.072608307,
-0.5649879575,
0.1709051281,
0.353738755,
-0.1287873536,
0.6323661208,
0.2744707465,
0.0372119546,
-0.6930240393,
-1.0210639238,
0.2203926295,
-0.1338002235,
-0.8286420107,
0.0668597594,
0.2485001236,
-0.5310688019,
-0.1159895435,
0.3990561664,
-0.1871884167,
0.2631378472,
0.3665392995,
0.0470380858,
0.0505610146,
0.4267595708,
-0.0510129146,
0.5125018954,
0.0734596401,
0.3845072985,
0.6047400832,
-0.089718923,
0.3170056939,
-0.6830133796,
0.0390346795,
0.4645863473,
-0.0163221508,
1.2033444643,
0.8388453722,
-0.5200260878,
-0.0845722184,
-0.4456685483,
-0.0459317602,
-0.548669219,
0.3195134401,
-0.0584867187,
-0.7751104236,
0.4920239449,
0.3609612286,
-0.4158450961,
0.3161440194,
0.2190437466,
-0.3261550367,
0.9964402914,
0.5671687126,
-0.2558360398,
0.7855200768,
0.0281874575,
0.3951630592,
-0.5008471608,
-0.2167299837,
-0.5248071551,
-0.4651424289,
-1.0748250484,
-0.2122581601,
-0.040718697,
-0.1421693712,
0.1324211657,
-0.1937973052,
-0.3215227127,
0.045548968,
0.1651835144,
0.3075161278,
0.0222378019,
0.2084486187,
0.3298187256,
-0.0549732856,
-0.6619757414,
-0.7960410118,
0.9300208092,
0.4636753201,
0.5449364781,
-0.0120038558,
0.5390555859,
0.7078782916,
0.3707888126,
-0.8700810075,
0.556835711,
-0.4562923014,
-0.5118973255,
-0.0423057862,
-0.4586543441,
-0.5920490623,
-0.2054573894,
-0.2906651497,
-0.8568213582,
-0.0708467364,
-0.097554259,
-0.3217811286,
0.0691394359,
-0.633505702,
0.4364797473,
-0.0278786737,
-0.1096450984,
0.0204022825,
-0.626853466,
0.4115924835,
0.0037772532,
0.5674432516,
-0.0963513181,
-0.1442767531,
0.7483246922,
-0.254157573,
1.3401042223,
-0.052656956,
0.0728884786,
0.5901762843,
-0.1631976664,
0.7699941993,
0.0955287665,
-0.3758815825,
0.4364895225,
-0.3736168146,
-0.2674350441,
-0.707577467,
0.8308149576,
-0.6371929049,
-0.1620948166,
-0.3988613188,
-0.2175249904,
0.1121714488,
-0.2378444523,
0.2181777954,
0.5876477957,
-0.3467192054,
0.2947188616,
0.3059615195,
0.0050029233,
0.7026462555,
0.0973510593,
-0.0544144027,
-0.3442933857,
0.6089637876,
0.5095567107,
0.2236661762,
-0.0231231693,
0.3094698489,
-0.112326704,
-0.3270198107,
-0.4104991257,
-0.0945300385,
-0.9708052874,
-0.0164607298,
-1.021443367,
-0.1429955065,
-0.9042839408,
-0.2409540266,
-0.0578183159,
-0.685644865,
-0.5529048443,
-0.1713478118,
0.7748047113,
0.8904213309,
0.358050853,
0.647829473,
-0.8261035085,
-0.1374886185,
-0.3981322348,
0.4106824994,
0.1885167956,
-0.6424610019,
-0.5056342483,
0.3118155301,
0.1274563819,
-1.0412675142,
0.1576824933,
0.4408684969,
0.1234022528,
0.6504741907,
-0.3024763167,
0.531686306,
-0.0945434123,
1.1849501133,
-0.0420710109,
-0.8570300341,
0.4407660067,
-0.7298981547,
0.2350043803,
0.5968796611,
0.4905667901,
-0.6513232589,
-0.7245297432,
-0.7950574756,
-0.558346808,
0.4986342788,
0.4725137353,
0.7510066032,
-0.487891078,
0.706916213,
-0.219383195,
0.4013446271,
-0.9548831582,
-0.6056680083,
-0.0935783982,
-0.3495924175,
0.0822782889,
-0.3849829137,
0.3769044578,
-0.3643104136,
0.4502792358,
0.1929876208,
0.2005202621,
0.0156206591,
0.1436017007,
0.049576059,
0.179499492,
0.4840963185,
0.4611009359,
-0.0887201205,
0.0080307452,
0.125348717,
-0.639121294,
-0.3154984713,
0.0536144376,
-0.4086540937,
0.571588397,
0.2757369876,
0.5376256704,
0.5772212148,
-0.355620414,
0.6083902121,
-0.0676377863,
0.28911677,
-0.3192781508,
-0.0757037252,
0.0944245681,
-0.0619361438,
0.4044383764,
0.3265661299,
0.3489560783,
-0.697473824,
-0.039069742,
0.3606335819,
-0.7088115215,
-0.3650494516,
0.15160276,
0.1723897159,
-0.3640961349,
0.4085613191,
-0.2563021481,
-0.750363946,
0.6975576282,
0.3681362271,
0.8393027186,
-0.2836785316,
0.4598207176,
0.3650930226,
0.4450460374,
0.070605047,
0.5068637133,
0.1868841052,
-0.6124981642,
-0.0970844105,
-0.7376929522,
0.0554267317,
-0.1000936851,
-0.2268972844,
0.5504285097,
-0.7611382604,
-0.4620735943,
0.0336550176,
-0.0461771153,
-0.8595647812,
0.7654297948,
0.3505121768,
0.6257787347,
-0.9406942725,
0.5239144564,
0.8749851584,
-0.5202522278,
-1.0595555305,
0.1413844973,
0.0047811256,
-0.3098855913,
0.6797280908,
0.4816293716,
-0.3054412305,
0.0007613235,
-0.8445997238,
-0.9480246305,
0.7612018585,
-0.2684423625,
-0.1713888049,
0.2603348494,
0.2913373113,
1.1325161457,
-0.5325653553,
0.5466662645,
0.4572503567,
0.3702640533,
0.0655042753,
-0.9161654711,
0.2093420029,
-0.6145495176,
-0.0025500045,
0.0639599711,
-0.8287428021,
0.8352741003,
0.0867187008,
-0.476295799,
-0.2108183652,
0.6044953465,
0.0343819894,
0.5417490005,
-0.0604746342,
0.2603448927,
0.506545186,
-0.1856628954,
1.3481639624,
-0.2496018559,
0.3242377341,
0.8490290642,
0.0216184612,
0.8977383375,
0.4619605243,
0.0537100174,
0.7111624479,
0.7473639846,
-0.1536011696,
0.2947030663,
0.2353880405,
-0.3645016551,
0.3269660175,
-0.3684509695,
-0.2264304161,
0.788416028,
0.4274136722,
-0.9678707719,
0.177397728,
-0.0368177332,
0.522089839,
-0.042370066,
-0.499671191,
0.7054759264,
0.2199665159,
-0.3703351319,
0.1902174205,
0.2571035922,
1.0970336199,
-0.4657809734,
0.0234777853,
-0.1837300956,
-0.0950882733,
-0.6067352295,
-0.5737326741,
0.3708710968,
0.0941855311,
0.0945201889,
0.3668355942,
1.1788055897,
-0.2246044129,
-1.1072763205,
0.2776369452,
0.4844041169,
0.20156385,
-0.1736504436,
-0.5193188787,
0.0781543851,
-0.337675184,
-0.6158434749,
0.064540796,
0.7427976131,
0.1384637058,
0.4498000443,
0.5768979788,
0.0494726188,
0.2414068431,
0.3701374829,
1.0950436592,
-0.5159187317,
-0.5762261152,
-1.2244814634,
0.5276222229,
-0.3831040561,
-0.3879197538,
1.1069114208,
0.2606859505,
0.5794378519,
0.0634134114,
1.0158632994,
-0.2861559689,
0.1720062792,
-0.4448619485,
1.0310387611,
-0.5885872245,
0.2600986958,
-0.929923296,
-0.7024875283,
-0.4094181657,
0.3768224716,
-0.5460651517,
0.6946122646,
0.5230775476,
0.6727076769,
0.0931469947,
0.2288313955,
0.2427730411,
0.0443635508,
0.1184814572,
-0.2665904164,
0.9445504546,
-0.587574482,
0.2558860481,
-0.521246016,
-0.0632334501,
-0.260340035,
-0.8709807396,
-1.0933119059,
-0.1779477596,
-0.1388880163,
-0.6726449728,
0.1083881408,
1.0437362194,
0.2203815579,
-0.4676088393,
-0.0046675294,
0.2493100762,
-0.1934884042,
0.0090759275,
-0.3997194171,
0.4014441073,
-0.3117618561,
-0.7200435996,
0.0160783473,
0.1079816297,
0.14380759,
-0.051484827,
-0.0181506518,
-0.5395491123,
0.4616421163,
0.7984676361,
-0.2994948924,
-0.5420268774,
-0.4101575017,
0.3164869249,
-0.3649147451,
0.0593351573,
0.7973205447,
-0.5337424278,
0.5264804363,
0.4418070912,
0.3066838682,
0.0204184856,
0.4979673028,
0.3926393986,
-1.1860616207,
0.1079587415,
0.2879668176,
0.2936038673,
0.6001466513,
-0.8601347804,
0.3731521666,
0.246051088,
-0.3470559716,
-0.488442868,
-0.4251362979,
-0.7568792105,
-0.2769981325,
1.7192698717,
-0.0438363738,
-0.1934084296,
-0.2653874755,
-0.1598220617,
0.5340334177,
-0.670951128,
1.2954176664,
0.9299118519,
0.1257693321,
-0.0933669209,
-0.4480948448,
0.7012816072,
0.0524051897,
-0.6558091044,
-0.3653095663,
0.4820666313,
0.2267336696,
-0.0592654608,
0.8321941495,
0.1704982966,
0.2519583702,
-0.0439935438,
-0.1702167839,
-0.1122854352,
-0.0150082624,
-0.5865807533,
0.0295491219,
-0.3516059816,
0.0133258356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.01292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.01292v1 | How learners produce data from text in classifying clickbait | 2023-01-28T20:23:39 | 2023-01-28T20:23:39 | Nicholas J. Horton, Jie Chao, Phebe Palmer, William Finzer | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | Text provides a compelling example of unstructured data that can be used to
motivate and explore classification problems. Challenges arise regarding the
representation of features of text and student linkage between text
representations as character strings and identification of features that embed
connections with underlying phenomena. In order to observe how students reason
with text data in scenarios designed to elicit certain aspects of the domain,
we employed a task-based interview method using a structured protocol with six
pairs of undergraduate students. Our goal was to shed light on students'
understanding of text as data using a motivating task to classify headlines as
"clickbait" or "news". Three types of features (function, content, and form)
surfaced, the majority from the first scenario. Our analysis of the interviews
indicates that this sequence of activities engaged the participants in thinking
at both the human-perception level and the computer-extraction level and
conceptualizing connections between them. | [
-0.2273099869,
-0.8558750153,
0.7150438428,
0.0450308323,
-0.097444661,
0.3031422496,
-0.0583218634,
-0.3333798945,
0.1511896551,
0.4206609726,
-0.345027864,
-0.5658073425,
-0.216883108,
0.320145607,
-0.6802091599,
1.4854432344,
-0.1225430891,
-0.2735985816,
-0.7181305885,
0.0738756731,
-0.6508309245,
-0.78107512,
-0.6275957823,
-0.1844342947,
0.5945823789,
0.5689374804,
0.4989996254,
0.6572794914,
0.4492258132,
0.2784462273,
0.1211508438,
-0.1978190094,
-0.4309186935,
-0.01252052,
-0.4009822607,
-0.7494475245,
0.2939157486,
0.7964417338,
0.3938784599,
1.0837632418,
0.186866805,
0.2560000122,
0.3268584311,
0.540191412,
-0.4789356589,
0.0275258347,
-0.3213464916,
0.0073565901,
-0.5438014269,
-0.5500885844,
-0.6332524419,
-0.2815034389,
0.2525261343,
-0.4692676961,
0.5687098503,
0.2338093966,
0.8550676107,
0.0249015428,
-0.8408678174,
-0.4985132813,
-0.5643634796,
0.653137207,
-0.0221415516,
0.273355335,
0.5586562157,
-0.0249754917,
-0.087050043,
-0.4627909958,
-0.3924458921,
0.1356308758,
-0.3461999893,
0.1755846888,
0.2690713108,
-0.0819449574,
0.2105381191,
0.3424784243,
-0.6067890525,
-0.1074297503,
-0.704946816,
-0.079563722,
0.6229895353,
0.1290471703,
0.3506024778,
-0.7534226179,
-0.4408243597,
0.0347840935,
-0.3254251778,
0.3546961546,
0.6859062314,
0.2464933246,
0.1492538899,
0.5948706269,
-0.1142453924,
0.6282094121,
0.0772795156,
-0.2341312319,
0.3354701698,
-0.1807486266,
-0.1193084121,
0.3997884095,
0.5193758011,
0.2775805891,
0.2203091979,
-0.2117549032,
0.1152789816,
0.0586879179,
0.6059482098,
-0.4805689454,
-0.3234145045,
0.2230302095,
-0.783762753,
-0.749502182,
0.2644452453,
-0.6871696115,
-0.1346704066,
-0.4727214575,
0.4508296549,
-0.2349450737,
0.0996399149,
0.1163551286,
-0.2992359996,
-0.2409964651,
0.4437065423,
-0.9262253642,
0.3368635178,
0.4242215753,
0.5168610215,
-0.7347437739,
-0.2926300168,
-0.2019337118,
0.1757124364,
-0.1038120687,
0.8893171549,
-0.5967398286,
-0.2827374339,
0.0929470509,
0.0042388891,
-0.4642264843,
-0.4386721551,
0.6025149822,
-0.5118390322,
0.5762782693,
-0.1798074096,
-0.5842614174,
-0.6154215932,
0.3157649338,
-0.7105340958,
1.0434830189,
0.0883343518,
-0.8387345672,
0.6415752769,
-0.6436137557,
-0.7050303221,
0.1919340193,
-0.411593914,
0.0572208576,
0.0635333583,
-0.1139983162,
0.5572473407,
0.0138651673,
0.204573065,
0.3782115579,
-0.3711012006,
0.8835122585,
-0.3469721973,
0.5359691381,
0.0633358806,
-0.2023375332,
-0.3771628737,
-0.5411387086,
-0.1640716046,
0.0831393152,
-1.1581089497,
-0.6862698793,
0.0733248293,
0.3803406656,
-0.088306345,
-0.0943651795,
-0.2621870935,
0.2129737288,
-0.0240105391,
0.2208132148,
0.2070342153,
0.3187509179,
0.1682711542,
-0.3419010937,
0.3387841284,
0.2846834064,
-0.1856242865,
-0.423666656,
-0.4984758794,
-0.5569807887,
0.3093947768,
0.4423849285,
0.5124967694,
-0.8100962639,
-0.1732417941,
-0.0245043635,
-0.1627501249,
-0.290995121,
0.234767437,
0.1980825812,
0.48446244,
0.3579702377,
-0.0577174425,
-0.3305438459,
-0.5540406108,
-0.4572805762,
-0.1417952031,
-0.1197262257,
0.1764835268,
0.6692283154,
0.0719767213,
1.1265819073,
-0.6898297071,
-0.2226504385,
-0.4880685508,
0.8502777219,
0.2017908394,
0.6085722446,
0.4612453282,
-1.3639372587,
-0.2806120515,
-0.2915696204,
-0.7572103739,
0.0601127967,
-0.5594943762,
0.1202922389,
0.1166686267,
0.5192883015,
-0.3424528837,
0.6691451669,
-0.0447552353,
-0.4454375803,
0.4636360407,
0.0786688626,
0.7041811943,
-0.7715619802,
0.008568665,
0.3402475119,
-0.0955025181,
-0.6709284782,
-0.3395264149,
-0.2213014811,
-0.2694757283,
-0.328479588,
0.0934794396,
-0.3611013591,
0.0710306615,
-0.3700019419,
0.0773410723,
0.0916067213,
0.3100406528,
0.247115761,
0.5520852804,
0.3527157605,
-0.6282454729,
0.2686927617,
0.423784554,
-0.400431782,
0.6440951824,
-0.3092741966,
0.0029784138,
-0.4318400919,
0.0992804393,
-1.0556316376,
-0.5219952464,
0.0942718163,
-0.678283751,
-0.0361850001,
-0.2198192924,
-0.5703552365,
-0.3681530654,
-0.1543510556,
0.663683176,
0.2353265882,
-0.3271422386,
0.2648354471,
0.3386884034,
-0.1918431818,
-0.0434220619,
-0.5514060855,
0.203664273,
-0.5501309037,
-0.1234673485,
0.3721517026,
-0.0519330241,
-0.2335502654,
-0.0225596111,
-0.0563137867,
-0.3472339511,
0.1856704652,
0.4410693347,
0.2487434596,
0.1237082183,
0.3501853347,
0.1780908853,
-0.0884082168,
0.3137897253,
0.1121937558,
0.2574769258,
0.3974930942,
-0.1788653135,
-0.3662959933,
0.5267369747,
0.3723270595,
0.1972799003,
0.4696436524,
0.3633441031,
-0.146438241,
-0.4386087358,
-0.3730817437,
-0.1044678167,
-0.4264250398,
-0.0721094608,
-0.1418567747,
-0.7094480395,
0.0545704179,
-0.2586111426,
-0.0383780003,
0.2994949818,
0.0677787811,
-0.6440914273,
0.7635421157,
0.7552652955,
0.1631909907,
0.174887076,
0.0122663975,
0.0212775692,
-0.4579045773,
-0.7802507877,
-0.6359764338,
-0.4979092479,
-0.4207488894,
-0.3243469596,
0.338329345,
0.0506873168,
0.1842440665,
0.3834344745,
-0.5709596276,
0.5159738064,
0.7306526303,
0.2527618408,
0.3670900762,
0.1691335738,
0.1364502758,
-0.2805597782,
-0.2476605773,
-0.5941251516,
0.972112298,
0.1279385835,
0.7266524434,
-0.1946651042,
0.7059633136,
0.700889349,
0.1544522345,
-1.0252190828,
0.6196264625,
-0.0809462219,
-0.5569959283,
-0.0446231775,
-0.3672900498,
-0.9434814453,
-0.0092674289,
-0.4339114428,
-0.8356025815,
0.1065873876,
-0.2257320732,
-0.090411596,
-0.0077733058,
-0.42425704,
0.7622760534,
-0.1154780537,
-0.041428078,
-0.1008544564,
-0.4465533197,
0.1081971377,
-0.1933839172,
0.3557024598,
0.1713774204,
0.1686800718,
1.3882379532,
-0.2010314763,
0.8031936288,
0.3214234412,
0.1247294694,
0.6804788113,
0.0127766905,
-0.1510041356,
0.03050467,
0.2140830308,
-0.0457122326,
0.0327672474,
-0.2594885826,
-0.429123491,
0.2292717695,
-0.426399678,
-0.505777359,
-0.406352222,
-0.6757124066,
-0.2068731636,
0.0579988547,
0.3261536062,
0.5596340895,
0.0566296093,
0.3990289569,
0.7381103039,
0.1325251013,
0.6024066806,
0.3380993903,
-0.0832765028,
0.0179249272,
1.097594142,
0.1898051798,
0.1087035388,
0.480796963,
0.1296456605,
-0.0870520025,
-0.6277967691,
-0.2366778404,
0.1828664541,
-0.7084165215,
-0.0211492311,
-0.7012351751,
-0.2299134582,
-0.197394833,
-0.3573204279,
0.2121873945,
-0.1639042944,
-0.4938238263,
-0.2286961079,
0.1389647275,
0.8218808174,
0.1680376828,
0.4636162221,
-0.9624471068,
0.1652621329,
0.47201401,
-0.1687358618,
-0.2929116189,
-0.1696244478,
-0.4406828582,
-0.1460849047,
-0.4739615321,
-1.1534680128,
0.2060344517,
-0.112655431,
0.6160133481,
0.5414935946,
0.0929064974,
0.0581083708,
-0.0237138905,
0.9238764644,
0.0425085984,
-0.9881756306,
0.96630615,
-0.4232813418,
-0.1026484668,
0.7696097493,
1.1021482944,
-0.4337510467,
-0.3033746779,
-0.5479749441,
-0.421381712,
0.6103896499,
0.4646295607,
0.1838166714,
-0.1891177148,
0.4548988938,
0.362959832,
0.6528496146,
-0.7670003176,
-0.2985762656,
-0.0512918681,
-0.3517376482,
0.0546458177,
-0.3605246544,
0.0114643257,
-0.1754079014,
0.1165025607,
-0.2747205794,
-0.089403443,
0.1109273806,
-0.2346538454,
0.161832422,
0.2317042351,
0.0940710828,
0.6191561222,
-0.0399446599,
0.2845964134,
-0.1932089925,
-0.938580215,
0.107005544,
-0.1446031928,
-0.3052242994,
0.3329970241,
0.3051067889,
0.4170076847,
0.5420786738,
-0.6340591908,
0.677179575,
0.0865552351,
-0.3466472626,
0.2373728156,
0.2865171432,
-0.2192413956,
-0.0133375432,
0.8281154633,
-0.0577075407,
0.5189230442,
-0.9014238715,
0.1647642553,
0.0370269231,
-0.1316133291,
-0.4376730323,
0.6769439578,
0.3886447251,
0.0045617479,
0.7183712125,
0.0738791674,
-0.5151162744,
0.685957849,
0.4624436796,
0.6364637017,
-0.0769865587,
0.7921223044,
0.3223973513,
0.147988081,
-0.0910547152,
0.2104658484,
-0.2755544484,
-0.7384973764,
-0.2483933866,
-0.631876111,
-0.467446804,
-0.0050087422,
-0.8496778607,
0.2070868164,
-0.1476650536,
-0.1035230681,
0.3400693536,
-0.1151036248,
-0.531496048,
0.6765242219,
0.2404556274,
0.7990285158,
-1.2755775452,
0.3834312856,
1.1250097752,
-0.7249472141,
-0.6986977458,
0.2782875299,
0.1829470545,
-0.3798272014,
0.9583441019,
0.4828961194,
0.3743655086,
0.0588731915,
-0.6960033178,
-0.6141191125,
0.7172236443,
-0.180224821,
-0.0048742755,
-0.2787387073,
0.395991534,
0.1123417243,
-0.4770434797,
-0.0481436476,
0.4794594646,
0.4269131422,
0.3180740178,
-0.6496925354,
-0.065030545,
-0.0505390055,
-0.2380281091,
0.2023915499,
-0.2643047273,
0.8339617252,
-0.2926549911,
-0.5066207647,
-0.4011774659,
0.5560919046,
-0.2169733047,
0.6022497416,
0.5304717422,
0.3981595039,
0.7310458422,
-0.2605624795,
0.5170645118,
0.2833662033,
0.4893831611,
0.6989885569,
0.1339705139,
0.6099615097,
0.4709464014,
-0.227011323,
0.8046317101,
0.7955849767,
-0.2240345925,
0.4989908934,
0.1242357343,
-0.1575075686,
-0.4408040941,
-0.2352148443,
-0.0469264053,
0.711163938,
0.3779443502,
-0.2791078985,
-0.30520913,
0.5465413332,
0.169559285,
0.1487741172,
-0.5651094913,
0.9285405874,
-0.1614968181,
-0.521721065,
-0.0158988368,
-0.0937860385,
0.5333070159,
-0.2277733386,
-0.1300215125,
0.0601271503,
-0.3448733389,
-0.5399888754,
-1.1207067966,
0.2467805445,
0.0022091628,
-0.5554953218,
-0.4027135968,
0.7396302223,
-0.4708141088,
-0.3423844576,
-0.3415620625,
0.4421003461,
0.7053678036,
-0.2056758404,
-0.3444628417,
0.206007883,
0.1112974212,
-0.2654730976,
0.3712949157,
0.571865201,
-0.0241214857,
0.3333808482,
0.651542604,
-0.2465308309,
-0.2931249142,
-0.0563520193,
0.6958573461,
-1.0441989899,
-0.6190317869,
-0.5038610101,
0.6375231147,
-0.1666121185,
-0.4798279703,
0.7624419332,
0.7831082344,
0.7947351933,
-0.0231955182,
0.7768284678,
-0.0121494606,
0.6547005773,
-0.5381132364,
0.6459769607,
-0.4144218862,
-0.1641869247,
-0.2456232905,
-0.7518857718,
0.1891832948,
0.3118926287,
-0.2152706683,
-0.0092862844,
1.0544556379,
-0.0332464762,
0.0437694229,
0.2228675038,
0.1220349148,
-0.1072514504,
0.0445571356,
0.3340966403,
0.6948495507,
-0.2463582307,
0.5745632648,
-0.1689926982,
-0.414371103,
-0.3087620437,
-0.6920875907,
-1.2108740807,
-0.9009987116,
-0.7128587961,
-0.1590918005,
-0.3294519782,
0.4455466568,
0.3936524689,
-0.4831537604,
-0.2406880707,
0.0790583566,
0.2707776129,
-0.1414883435,
-0.3806006908,
0.2488510013,
-0.5534231067,
-0.8576421738,
0.2941430807,
0.1190079674,
0.2067882419,
-0.058515057,
0.6325066686,
-0.1999978423,
0.0891152546,
0.4975346029,
0.1421544701,
-0.1982169449,
-0.3687674701,
-0.2401753068,
-0.2334286273,
-0.1191083416,
1.1858364344,
-1.1549776793,
0.1538328528,
0.3643269837,
0.6290525198,
0.2995340228,
0.5751788616,
0.1661875397,
-0.6752582788,
-0.1191868261,
-0.0614329837,
-0.0222689956,
0.3168638349,
-0.6866485476,
0.3612802923,
0.6736186743,
-0.5679965019,
-0.6244511604,
-0.128797695,
-1.268245697,
-0.4952470362,
0.9352682829,
0.0661660507,
-0.2378312647,
-0.5071853995,
-0.4657559097,
-0.0160114486,
-0.2090407014,
0.7454973459,
0.6774190068,
-0.1271054447,
-0.0987419263,
-0.6387984753,
0.5911003351,
0.0170968324,
-1.1317976713,
-0.1963404566,
0.4715981185,
0.2123919576,
0.3405452669,
0.4133291245,
0.1718875319,
0.0898111984,
-0.0723161101,
-0.3282489777,
0.0793766454,
-0.6336924434,
0.2625338435,
0.4928684831,
-0.5710214376,
-0.5380691886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12217v1 | Semantic Parsing for Conversational Question Answering over Knowledge Graphs | 2023-01-28T14:45:11 | 2023-01-28T14:45:11 | Laura Perez-Beltrachini, Parag Jain, Emilio Monti, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we are interested in developing semantic parsers which
understand natural language questions embedded in a conversation with a user
and ground them to formal queries over definitions in a general purpose
knowledge graph (KG) with very large vocabularies (covering thousands of
concept names and relations, and millions of entities). To this end, we develop
a dataset where user questions are annotated with Sparql parses and system
answers correspond to execution results thereof. We present two different
semantic parsing approaches and highlight the challenges of the task: dealing
with large vocabularies, modelling conversation context, predicting queries
with multiple entities, and generalising to new questions at test time. We hope
our dataset will serve as useful testbed for the development of conversational
semantic parsers. Our dataset and models are released at
https://github.com/EdinburghNLP/SPICE. | [
-0.5070251822,
-1.1560403109,
0.5387653708,
0.2384712845,
0.0038651463,
-0.0079282615,
0.0202684123,
-0.4156532586,
0.1472138911,
0.9814181328,
-0.7499864697,
-0.6891363263,
-0.3411181569,
0.0506155267,
-0.3839884102,
0.5743377805,
0.2101168931,
0.1913511455,
-0.6395012736,
-0.1351428479,
-0.8206331134,
-0.5961537361,
-0.7211702466,
-0.1900447011,
0.4120725095,
0.3980951309,
0.8809100389,
0.4048845172,
0.1992777437,
0.2898554206,
-0.2050307244,
0.3044171035,
-0.3812070787,
0.5553185344,
-0.3889936209,
-0.3336942196,
-0.0686301589,
-0.4178183973,
0.3989539146,
1.3014175892,
0.0693963468,
0.030215675,
-0.1602056473,
0.3416311443,
-0.4296280146,
0.3325806856,
-0.7773477435,
0.0525547639,
0.2184390873,
-0.0819825083,
-0.3031201363,
-0.0571048744,
0.1212793514,
-0.68714571,
0.1222328022,
0.2780981064,
0.9506438375,
0.0656573549,
-0.5942596197,
-0.5036681294,
-0.5443021059,
0.5598008633,
-0.3027376235,
0.6331217885,
0.3797948062,
0.5966352224,
-0.5686004162,
-0.9306092858,
-0.490884155,
-0.1538595259,
-0.3155285716,
-0.0564848073,
-0.092824474,
0.0686855316,
0.1609340757,
0.165376097,
-0.6999512315,
-0.2758580446,
-0.0850263163,
-0.2408430576,
0.4052410424,
0.4644134045,
0.289059788,
-0.3961566091,
-0.4107041359,
-0.0389499888,
-0.3486950994,
-0.0270320494,
0.1673448086,
0.3219401538,
0.2863732576,
0.5920307636,
-0.7146112323,
1.1301831007,
-0.4063388407,
0.2017296851,
-0.0451169722,
-0.3653893173,
-0.085424602,
-0.048356086,
0.8132936954,
0.4302214682,
0.3990768194,
-0.4945066869,
0.1658893377,
0.114920862,
0.0219613686,
-0.6787058115,
-0.197403878,
0.3916820884,
0.1387022734,
-0.1176751778,
-0.0444429889,
-0.7731716037,
-0.4713448286,
-0.3943077028,
0.16207394,
-0.2991327345,
-0.3196155727,
0.5868198872,
-0.4180491269,
0.5365679264,
0.4354597032,
-0.7015595436,
0.7775478363,
0.8279364705,
0.3632080555,
0.3411369324,
-0.0710543916,
-0.4487962127,
0.3750241697,
-0.2496636659,
0.8306491971,
-0.6502284408,
-0.5690714121,
-0.0601077601,
0.1300272644,
-0.1811141223,
-0.5421506166,
0.6262781024,
-0.8094595671,
0.2826917171,
-0.7271264791,
-0.633703053,
-0.0222249832,
0.716970861,
-0.2834077179,
1.0914263725,
0.1978256255,
-0.6943628788,
0.0848687217,
-0.7466325164,
-0.3443035781,
0.0892526582,
-0.248544395,
0.248467505,
-0.3895548582,
0.3517164588,
0.5296689272,
-0.6820502877,
0.4059796333,
-0.2602716088,
0.2353247851,
0.5227386951,
0.0232704859,
0.4789856374,
0.4420201182,
0.1067674756,
-0.0271968842,
-0.750459969,
0.3600926101,
0.3063564599,
0.2572337091,
-0.2683309913,
0.0694048032,
-0.0534204729,
0.3460586071,
0.1405033618,
-0.6981291175,
0.1111064777,
-0.4468262792,
0.4110428393,
0.3605360985,
0.3856381774,
0.0391396359,
0.1148261651,
0.3155430257,
0.3477551937,
0.0434290916,
-0.035632696,
-0.6781797409,
-0.7563042045,
0.2302132547,
0.2972345352,
0.6377257705,
-0.803434968,
0.3474685252,
-0.4674370885,
-0.2858237624,
-0.2502530217,
0.1689100713,
0.314126879,
0.9422816634,
0.3642039597,
-0.1146891937,
-0.3887840509,
-0.9330217242,
-0.4108178616,
-0.3348400295,
-0.0978060067,
0.7749760747,
0.4122631848,
-0.107777819,
1.5287271738,
-1.0480014086,
-0.1261914074,
-0.3843791783,
0.0708549768,
-0.0679967254,
0.3097274303,
0.3045038581,
-1.1569314003,
-0.2923639417,
0.1957610101,
-0.7179734707,
-0.2227611691,
0.1699832529,
-0.4547537565,
-0.2122924328,
0.6068568826,
-0.8865215778,
0.2611842752,
0.1043311581,
-0.6504757404,
0.2116030306,
0.2419322878,
0.2189735323,
-1.2994593382,
-0.1080142185,
-0.1975940168,
-0.4530929625,
-0.9312078357,
-0.0417179391,
-0.2063643038,
-0.424328804,
-0.5004196763,
0.7065551281,
0.0405460969,
-0.2405909896,
0.0515757091,
0.3934036791,
0.440793097,
0.3203775287,
0.2936410606,
0.5577515364,
0.4238174856,
-0.6793815494,
0.6908756495,
0.5695878267,
-0.0040470762,
0.2812424898,
-1.08172822,
0.1621141732,
-0.1245008335,
0.1925562918,
-1.2343976498,
-0.588747859,
0.5167185068,
-0.7102793455,
-0.1400334835,
-0.582313478,
-0.6759501696,
-0.2303292155,
0.14510037,
0.2344201356,
0.2604646385,
-0.3201440573,
0.6013326645,
0.4470215738,
-0.0485907681,
-0.3348240554,
-0.502882719,
0.1666241586,
-0.118118152,
-1.2038965225,
0.121656023,
0.4101339281,
-0.3857730925,
0.3047942221,
0.1289315373,
-0.2995459735,
0.1858130544,
0.0826745182,
0.0185184758,
-0.4350184798,
0.345128268,
0.0022408809,
-0.2155741453,
0.2141996771,
-0.3195759952,
1.0678144693,
-0.3595232964,
-0.462508142,
-0.1243257597,
0.3831103742,
0.2446153611,
-0.2992707491,
0.9786776304,
0.4667401314,
-0.3666305542,
0.140279904,
-0.5819678903,
0.0156589821,
-0.4479758739,
0.2941252887,
-0.6121106744,
-0.9191255569,
0.9422308207,
-0.1397029161,
-0.3193470836,
0.5391380787,
0.4466267526,
0.0868871361,
0.9978518486,
0.0919235721,
0.0697255805,
-0.1425630003,
-0.1834790111,
0.1249138042,
-0.5183978081,
-0.324092567,
-0.6636081934,
0.209094584,
-0.3897514045,
-0.452857703,
0.2395495772,
0.1798046976,
-0.1001536101,
0.2431635708,
-0.2446273416,
0.5657194257,
0.3540340364,
-0.1848299056,
0.2466402352,
-0.3807366192,
0.0225314144,
0.2425499707,
-0.5535926223,
-0.5014058352,
0.6850454211,
0.0868330076,
0.7490441203,
0.2179971486,
0.3615424335,
-0.0088243345,
-0.3230497241,
-0.7980036736,
0.7549769282,
0.3625704646,
-0.5936251283,
-0.4025241733,
-0.6469903588,
-1.1571724415,
0.5290040374,
-0.0662213489,
-0.8859741688,
0.0025050754,
0.0258411746,
0.0465833172,
0.0952254087,
-0.9560979009,
1.4197922945,
0.0045707417,
-0.1653409898,
0.3492820561,
-0.967517972,
0.2923254967,
0.4144809842,
0.0788539723,
-0.2717657685,
0.1049378961,
0.6590589881,
-0.4709300399,
0.7081022263,
-0.4545029998,
0.2521799803,
0.5259977579,
0.0312704444,
0.2787794471,
0.3076149225,
0.174413681,
-0.1171335578,
0.5088731647,
-0.5471464992,
-0.9104449749,
0.6040556431,
-0.735281229,
-0.6627375484,
-0.3150518835,
-0.601783812,
-0.6751728654,
0.1500174999,
-0.1566874683,
0.567104876,
-0.1985423416,
0.1625379026,
0.7886056304,
-0.2633832097,
-0.2019492388,
0.2355041057,
-0.5547169447,
-0.1694717854,
0.7266888022,
-0.0401377566,
0.4784857929,
0.465929389,
0.3470199108,
-0.4119616151,
-0.2554499507,
-0.447358638,
0.064261578,
-0.8951970935,
-0.1717185527,
-1.1209309101,
-0.1327252388,
-1.0215941668,
0.1173691899,
-0.300357163,
-0.554236114,
-0.1593978256,
0.135880217,
0.5454837084,
0.5781724453,
0.6367754936,
0.2393137366,
-0.7092101574,
0.4904466271,
0.3230429888,
0.1357572228,
-0.3570917845,
-0.1965087503,
0.1518156081,
0.1972557306,
-0.262339294,
-0.8848154545,
0.2819048464,
0.0600285754,
0.3588098288,
0.0656906888,
0.3303226531,
0.9081408978,
-0.299739182,
0.98901546,
-0.0030082173,
-0.7163869143,
0.8804755807,
-0.3958477378,
0.1647085398,
0.6750788093,
0.4584263861,
-1.1273975372,
-0.2337803543,
-0.6297122836,
-0.8477147818,
0.6125309467,
0.1151988879,
0.2368123084,
-0.3604381382,
0.3213533163,
0.0104180565,
0.1291830987,
-0.3035118282,
-0.1530030668,
-0.3066464663,
-0.2390096486,
0.158399716,
-0.2468249649,
-0.2104724795,
-0.1844289005,
0.4526030421,
-0.2191700488,
0.2130384743,
0.2388950586,
-0.256716311,
0.3098382354,
0.5079928041,
0.2383587211,
0.6536793709,
-0.1723459214,
-0.0485649966,
0.2206632644,
-0.1520448476,
-0.0910623744,
0.1324145198,
0.0025865305,
-0.1727834642,
0.1424954236,
0.6873633265,
0.2486029863,
-0.7494902611,
0.6200009584,
-0.3329409957,
-0.3294506669,
-0.372666955,
0.1400730759,
0.456527859,
-0.0038297374,
-0.0531131402,
-0.3915924728,
0.1718718261,
-0.4701448083,
0.0537305959,
0.4274539053,
-0.3849125504,
-0.0782595053,
0.6062989831,
-0.0219863951,
-0.0945860967,
0.6368498802,
-0.2763588727,
-0.6130034328,
0.4657214284,
0.536790967,
0.5083392859,
0.2158430517,
0.2740997374,
-0.1251143813,
-0.071182467,
0.302544862,
0.2747370005,
-0.1486808211,
-1.0098443031,
-0.3145522773,
-0.6142364144,
-0.7288420796,
-0.0682715327,
-0.7392761111,
0.2267716974,
-0.2378008217,
0.1192015484,
0.2611334324,
-0.0471159481,
-0.5964220166,
0.1627312899,
-0.2258465588,
0.9426336884,
-0.8958288431,
0.6408374906,
0.891043663,
-0.4782221615,
-0.6712411642,
-0.385902971,
-0.2239688635,
-0.7572485209,
0.9191671014,
0.0043501807,
-0.0199107472,
-0.0564510226,
-0.266428113,
-0.7327561975,
0.8891247511,
0.2652215958,
0.1670495272,
0.0685569718,
0.8434312344,
0.4481574297,
-0.2657967508,
0.1205342859,
0.6989007592,
0.3156324029,
0.6781250834,
-0.6231229901,
-0.1909312606,
-0.1395196021,
-0.0315456428,
0.437929213,
-0.4272576571,
0.5676209927,
0.3496690094,
-0.0248242468,
0.102005206,
0.8704748154,
-0.1157710031,
0.3868552446,
0.4620872736,
0.684645474,
0.6104720235,
-0.3650560379,
1.1693662405,
-0.30217278,
0.3042047024,
1.0340955257,
-0.454061836,
0.4996916056,
0.5062826276,
-0.2530340552,
0.0670544505,
0.5760492086,
0.4595596492,
0.2143819481,
0.2918347418,
-0.2751224935,
-0.3446361721,
-0.4693829119,
-0.3522188067,
0.4892423153,
0.613266468,
-0.018858565,
-0.5196669698,
0.0086040357,
0.1532128304,
0.0655727088,
-0.1200015917,
1.0065591335,
-0.165528059,
-0.5544207096,
0.2890152633,
0.0619934388,
-0.166549474,
-0.7498936653,
-0.0401681103,
-0.1646526307,
-0.0187632497,
-0.0989319757,
-0.9479208589,
0.3342118561,
-0.1411497444,
0.0459932424,
-0.0716709644,
1.0297931433,
-0.4339307249,
-0.3791787922,
0.1360700279,
0.5881727934,
0.2693637311,
-0.1871760786,
-0.7535915375,
-0.1109459475,
-0.3402769566,
-0.3705396652,
0.4038823843,
0.6868371964,
-0.1404958814,
0.7860081792,
0.5871819854,
-0.1928565502,
0.2898580134,
0.288461417,
1.2602000237,
-0.7743584514,
-0.461448133,
-0.5568855405,
0.3776967227,
-0.2787564993,
-0.2864924073,
0.7779098153,
0.5618633032,
0.7644416094,
0.0704482868,
0.4145688415,
-0.2039036006,
0.6632915735,
-0.692961812,
0.1114253774,
-0.2063639015,
0.3290170729,
-0.3599842191,
-0.7083718181,
-0.3873948157,
0.3894612789,
-0.5637124181,
-0.0673963502,
0.4028081,
0.9874532819,
-0.103777498,
0.3557278216,
0.419965297,
-0.0253939386,
0.6063581109,
0.3268883824,
1.1514387131,
-0.3141852617,
0.4636183977,
-0.3594362736,
0.1861892492,
0.0410829112,
-0.6278605461,
-0.7022038698,
-0.6224743724,
-0.1959366202,
-0.4719990194,
0.1028187647,
0.9957703948,
0.328523308,
-0.7899314761,
-0.1606088728,
-0.1233658493,
0.1629459709,
0.2281492203,
-0.3252622783,
0.292975992,
-0.7777617574,
-0.4129740596,
0.2160153538,
0.1128276438,
-0.1804562509,
-0.0169858225,
0.0635472387,
-0.3552393913,
-0.1191162243,
0.6419160366,
0.2877610922,
-0.662029326,
-0.5127948523,
0.0722903609,
0.1277713627,
-0.0411346108,
0.7621282935,
-0.8835523129,
0.3233666718,
0.366160959,
1.0867017508,
0.4675065577,
0.250382632,
0.2718505561,
-0.987051487,
0.1281085014,
0.3379786909,
0.1724246442,
0.2777983844,
-0.3296636045,
0.5698060989,
0.3480528295,
-0.4464349151,
-0.6711291075,
0.4316883385,
-1.2276616096,
-0.2700527012,
1.2898478508,
-0.0783609003,
-0.3951897323,
-0.5674802065,
-0.3500781655,
-0.1016558856,
-0.1736238003,
-0.0580232218,
0.6875880957,
-0.3098394573,
0.105186142,
-0.5773954391,
0.2670885921,
0.3118025661,
-0.8762265444,
0.399407655,
0.6237021089,
0.3143618107,
0.0635333583,
0.6320065856,
-0.212577045,
0.1940325499,
0.0853937045,
-0.1604127437,
-0.0107711768,
-0.0364450924,
0.1614878625,
0.3906854689,
0.2174397856,
-0.2331290245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12206v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12206v1 | Semantic Tagging with LSTM-CRF | 2023-01-28T14:06:17 | 2023-01-28T14:06:17 | Farshad Noravesh | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the present paper, two models are presented namely LSTM-CRF and
BERT-LSTM-CRF for semantic tagging of universal semantic tag dataset. The
experiments show that the first model is much easier to converge while the
second model that leverages BERT embedding, takes a long time to converge and
needs a big dataset for semtagging to be effective. | [
-0.4767194688,
-0.8252139688,
0.5202484727,
0.1307537556,
-0.4904162586,
-0.1878049523,
-0.4667360783,
-0.8343666792,
-0.0923006311,
0.5047798157,
-0.8093095422,
-0.7527007461,
-0.4413433969,
-0.1523929387,
-0.4222398996,
0.5998315215,
0.1689352691,
0.4153822362,
-0.3118508458,
-0.2974562943,
-0.6840757728,
-0.8240980506,
-0.4524604976,
-0.7571123838,
0.6938168406,
0.3000534475,
0.5567682385,
0.5040784478,
0.8562659621,
0.1370444447,
0.1426960826,
-0.0338716395,
-0.1511008441,
0.346598208,
-0.5839757919,
-0.1961632222,
-0.1688711494,
-0.2492397428,
0.6710418463,
0.6278274655,
-0.0090461466,
0.1592871398,
-0.1918387711,
0.4732517004,
-0.1747472584,
0.0910555422,
-0.6623025537,
-0.0028080903,
-0.0004856403,
-0.1359682232,
-0.4501725733,
-0.2859230042,
0.5857480764,
-0.3477104604,
0.0276933629,
0.0878314152,
1.1689735651,
0.0473072678,
-0.5808758736,
-0.5255166888,
-0.7827079296,
1.1238536835,
-0.7567539811,
0.7817907929,
0.2190883309,
-0.0492970571,
-0.1990027279,
-1.115755558,
-0.3648248315,
-0.3575321436,
0.0485476702,
-0.1396933198,
0.2378466576,
0.0801371634,
0.0854477137,
-0.0463953055,
-0.5999063253,
0.5557020903,
-0.0015419214,
-0.1105119288,
0.3670092225,
0.3542762101,
0.1898888052,
-0.2153138965,
-1.2494102716,
-0.1614541858,
-0.6051893234,
-0.3044182658,
0.1269249469,
0.6886171103,
0.3774490356,
0.5436831713,
-0.0668663904,
0.7981112599,
-0.6622539759,
-0.2761839628,
0.1744688451,
-0.4893363714,
-0.3892506659,
0.0042857034,
0.3336731195,
0.677550137,
0.555990696,
-0.3026095331,
-0.1587249935,
0.4546890259,
0.0394349284,
-0.6530745625,
-0.3019648492,
0.1885393262,
-0.3113793135,
0.3388668597,
0.1033210829,
-0.6998863816,
-0.1582102627,
-0.6002219319,
0.5292299986,
-0.7175453901,
-0.2144855112,
0.190462634,
-0.3514389694,
1.063377738,
0.3018397689,
-0.3438297808,
0.2210471928,
0.9925361872,
0.6555498838,
-0.0615923144,
-0.0888204277,
0.0474149622,
0.2781899571,
0.0701419786,
0.9520325065,
-0.6457217932,
-0.3910728097,
0.2924980521,
0.1030880734,
-0.2484792769,
-0.1018188223,
0.9767821431,
-0.8979023099,
0.0368868224,
-0.60288167,
-1.312245965,
-0.5054025054,
0.3705934882,
-0.7168882489,
1.1350972652,
0.0404461659,
-0.7174417377,
0.6033123136,
-0.5557361245,
-0.1488274038,
0.260677129,
0.0807495043,
-0.4097841084,
-0.3609761894,
-0.2517357171,
0.7184297442,
-0.1557119787,
0.3853343427,
-0.5885754228,
-0.0848074853,
0.3713341951,
0.1181872636,
0.495120883,
0.3375755847,
0.0823408589,
-0.2021070421,
-0.6129586101,
0.3097514808,
0.5237340927,
-0.3513574004,
-0.5350704789,
0.4165571928,
0.3468405902,
0.1055683866,
0.1587811708,
-0.7884902954,
0.3026626408,
-0.2018772513,
0.4071930349,
0.5384713411,
0.0647547618,
0.4699071944,
-0.557856679,
0.0120289819,
-0.1057301387,
-0.3705110848,
-0.1044053733,
-0.6083635092,
-0.7729002237,
-0.22465083,
1.1646271944,
0.64365834,
-0.3494206369,
0.7324220538,
-0.3348051906,
-0.3172127604,
-0.2129863203,
0.0516232923,
0.178260535,
0.3609928489,
0.1276254654,
-0.4956983328,
-0.824878633,
-0.8433187008,
-0.1811729521,
0.0897220224,
0.127199471,
0.2775535285,
0.5444307923,
-0.3454624414,
1.1831557751,
-0.5239120722,
-0.6250169873,
-0.3782731593,
0.1181761175,
-0.0271685496,
0.7759269476,
0.549038887,
-0.716460526,
-0.2388646156,
-0.402721405,
-0.3103732765,
0.0715641081,
-0.043240346,
-0.2336495966,
0.544064045,
0.2385480702,
-0.6906538606,
0.5752199292,
0.0667714328,
-0.1525957882,
0.1675180346,
-0.1290771812,
-0.023658853,
-0.7300072312,
-0.04577142,
0.2907335162,
-0.789583385,
-0.9082414508,
0.4123346508,
-0.0033339001,
0.1097974554,
-0.4930211604,
0.3791716993,
-0.5516563058,
-0.1812263876,
-0.0383941606,
0.7276774645,
0.019339988,
0.6742757559,
0.3979275525,
-0.0754580051,
0.2144429982,
-0.6802685261,
0.2970076203,
0.2441935986,
-0.3703127801,
0.2667022049,
-0.7294866443,
0.0795046911,
-0.0643357858,
0.4992760122,
-1.3527253866,
-0.2988300025,
0.3406125605,
-0.5230643749,
0.3458830714,
-0.2061743885,
-0.9390830398,
-0.605782032,
-0.4835836589,
0.2271540016,
0.6872528791,
-0.8348841667,
0.6064590812,
0.2734643817,
0.1740170568,
-0.2308424711,
-0.8618220091,
-0.1729079932,
-0.3480508327,
-0.8460441232,
0.399564445,
0.0877226964,
0.0323975235,
0.1736923009,
0.0824170187,
-0.0417132005,
-0.0148057844,
0.3904298842,
0.371329397,
-0.131626606,
0.5682499409,
-0.6522815824,
-0.1451302022,
-0.1345742494,
-0.2325115204,
0.955031693,
-0.0806654617,
-0.4744997919,
-0.4063874781,
0.697825253,
-0.1671235263,
-0.1803457588,
0.7470151186,
0.8693290949,
-0.5189188719,
-0.4401192367,
-0.7236859798,
0.0887862965,
-0.375174731,
0.3638539314,
-0.0915874541,
-1.0688991547,
0.607065618,
-0.3311876357,
0.1134457588,
0.4859118462,
0.7512122393,
-0.27347067,
0.9843347669,
0.7821900249,
0.1679038703,
0.4030538499,
-0.3115963638,
0.0245649759,
-0.6389425993,
-0.4637079537,
-0.8261278868,
-0.3914951682,
-0.4929308891,
-0.4455694556,
-0.1702267826,
0.1587964743,
-0.3590644598,
0.4016902745,
-0.8901551962,
0.2488942295,
0.925668776,
0.0807332173,
0.2423595637,
-0.0067567616,
-0.1283362806,
0.0393988378,
-0.8176195621,
-0.2468239367,
0.8057152033,
0.5294847488,
1.0964194536,
-0.0830809847,
0.5028785467,
0.3890581429,
-0.1002826765,
-1.1158182621,
0.6031964421,
-0.1620085239,
-0.8086005449,
-0.0901755691,
0.1137726381,
-0.9654667377,
-0.0075756158,
-0.0685077682,
-0.7646221519,
0.1635582894,
0.0825585425,
-0.0468632989,
0.5041660666,
-0.822337687,
0.5205090046,
0.0360746756,
0.1811411679,
-0.1527791917,
-1.1021162271,
0.3719917834,
0.1868988425,
-0.0378403775,
-0.70144099,
-0.1692756265,
1.1045149565,
-0.3158940375,
0.9410766959,
-0.379624337,
-0.0381957032,
0.827193737,
-0.0723143667,
0.4546627402,
-0.1155158952,
0.2381617725,
0.0833211243,
0.1181063429,
-0.2603493929,
-0.0100977495,
0.9596216679,
-0.6249096394,
-0.3168349564,
-0.6699412465,
-0.2639380097,
-0.2429353893,
-0.0036602959,
0.0320327394,
0.6645968556,
-0.2572201788,
0.1754207164,
0.8285693526,
0.0056759859,
0.9249611497,
0.4399861991,
-0.2676986456,
-0.5054780841,
0.5776587725,
0.261223197,
0.2659666538,
0.1500000507,
-0.2615031898,
-0.6768645644,
-0.0912233219,
-0.1998155117,
0.3986176848,
-0.9168171883,
-0.708855629,
-0.7244932055,
-0.4243570566,
-0.4410889745,
-0.2067862153,
-0.1877841949,
-0.6618196964,
-0.3342399895,
0.2959607542,
0.8633895516,
0.6170418262,
-0.0866993517,
0.7492049336,
-1.0174062252,
0.0615761317,
0.0738038495,
0.6518319845,
0.1187239885,
-0.3117398322,
-0.1618659496,
0.2292578667,
-0.1532532871,
-0.7829406261,
0.10573598,
0.5148317814,
0.5591691732,
0.2132777125,
0.015498396,
0.5998398662,
-0.473359406,
0.8835653663,
0.4156001806,
-0.8077824116,
0.336406827,
-0.2477983534,
0.2377950847,
0.3855663538,
0.5331261158,
-0.6446888447,
0.1454498023,
-0.4991887808,
-0.9012691379,
0.7087299824,
-0.1962128133,
0.0656972229,
-0.1402764767,
0.1747755557,
0.0105605749,
-0.2127146274,
-0.6543931961,
-0.1137166321,
0.0586147197,
-0.1432903111,
0.249635011,
-0.5716478229,
-0.1335156411,
-0.2590267062,
0.6372818947,
0.0553133115,
0.7464781404,
0.6617025733,
-0.3967880011,
0.0036150224,
0.16979298,
0.4488784373,
0.4284719229,
-0.371833235,
0.1117618456,
0.2114920318,
-0.1075057238,
0.0489604026,
0.0495297052,
0.3620952368,
0.2455457747,
0.4746273458,
0.3700782955,
0.1919335723,
-0.844583571,
0.618524611,
0.0754370615,
-0.5520396829,
-0.6415549517,
0.2264653891,
0.6761588454,
0.1576661319,
-0.016325634,
-0.3555400074,
-0.1356023848,
-0.244608894,
0.3811540306,
0.5986127853,
-0.3516352773,
-0.0555115454,
0.5137037635,
0.1783024818,
-0.3317039311,
0.7837421298,
-0.001988695,
-0.8285384774,
0.7167091966,
0.7406517267,
0.6384218335,
-0.1528959721,
-0.2280385047,
0.2715001702,
-0.0374008194,
-0.0385582708,
0.3334028721,
-0.1908954084,
-0.6953228712,
-0.4724787772,
-0.6857783794,
-0.2750006616,
-0.259195298,
-0.7112311721,
0.3930301964,
-0.3475512266,
-0.6573985219,
0.1494339406,
0.2999639511,
-1.0534486771,
0.4248486757,
0.3392254114,
1.3114168644,
-0.4595017433,
0.9740643501,
0.7336552143,
-0.1115831584,
-0.6725308299,
-0.5790502429,
-0.2173206657,
-1.0125368834,
0.8298354745,
0.1713173389,
0.1209023669,
0.1099566817,
-0.9251634479,
-0.9399191141,
1.3168959618,
-0.4376452863,
-0.7617690563,
-0.0759083107,
0.3316599429,
0.4768345952,
-0.62400949,
-0.2890515327,
0.675468266,
0.66068542,
0.5329868197,
-0.6407238245,
-0.1285450608,
0.2126914114,
0.2286136895,
0.5113474727,
-0.8087819815,
0.5454868078,
-0.0629811585,
-0.404027015,
0.4717364311,
0.8223986626,
-0.1299362034,
0.2417007536,
0.6252281666,
1.3548491001,
0.287907809,
-0.4371070862,
0.5368113518,
-0.1962691993,
0.8304092884,
1.334505558,
-0.5085729957,
0.8426151872,
0.1209482849,
-0.0863594413,
0.2793863714,
0.8837430477,
-0.4999894798,
0.440723002,
0.2802988589,
-0.3481071293,
-0.6118934155,
-0.4141541719,
-0.6572530866,
0.3922609389,
0.6924716234,
-0.4013103843,
-0.7664673924,
0.0186981987,
0.2204480618,
-0.3513427973,
-0.3043958843,
0.9008550644,
0.2646943629,
-0.4078138769,
0.3134712577,
0.3066892326,
0.6308660507,
-0.6345969439,
0.0781157389,
0.3358497322,
0.1696833223,
0.0976164564,
-0.9425809979,
0.1943340451,
-0.2551054358,
-0.0120197302,
-0.0598156899,
1.545283556,
-0.6969166398,
-0.2159432173,
0.6650808454,
0.5188050866,
-0.0824031085,
0.6333232522,
-0.8473443985,
0.2703483403,
-0.1171359941,
-0.3448617458,
0.1711572111,
0.0930008814,
0.0899045244,
0.7630999088,
0.4892928004,
-0.3172287643,
0.2994097173,
0.0758431628,
0.9862231016,
-1.0319818258,
-0.2484021634,
-0.8852987289,
0.3232167363,
0.1099786758,
-0.0269654151,
0.691919446,
0.2809931636,
0.683991611,
-0.0050092782,
0.5427948236,
-0.2638722658,
0.8809047341,
-0.4043919444,
0.3089925349,
-0.4348854423,
-0.0362678729,
-0.0617603287,
-0.9904942513,
-0.7152132988,
0.2670724094,
0.0314387158,
0.1776855588,
0.4588191211,
0.676589787,
0.3104647398,
0.2957577705,
0.1332178712,
-0.0016031418,
0.303874433,
0.6974888444,
1.0687379837,
-0.1513576359,
0.0661153644,
-0.317943126,
0.1271577775,
-0.3611258566,
-1.1526474953,
-1.0260061026,
-0.670409441,
-0.1670414358,
-0.4394531548,
-0.1500670463,
1.3233702183,
0.8253322244,
-0.6086258292,
0.2703382969,
0.3389196992,
0.1230383143,
0.5054500103,
-0.2454850972,
0.4386463463,
-0.6214010119,
-0.5511364937,
-0.3940944374,
0.0806287378,
0.2389036566,
-0.0954263955,
0.1465163976,
-0.6819182038,
0.5019927621,
0.5172262788,
0.0245432779,
-0.6595513225,
-0.6794986129,
-0.2218843848,
-0.187165305,
0.0841306522,
0.7777770162,
-0.8442080617,
0.116064474,
0.5283372998,
0.7065833211,
0.2293771803,
0.3616217673,
0.2175103873,
-0.5871188641,
0.0101056686,
0.2055498064,
0.3823415041,
0.1605245918,
-0.1335430294,
0.5808660388,
0.3571089804,
-1.0175981522,
-0.803227067,
0.1735851765,
-1.6468729973,
-0.2555115521,
1.0929611921,
-0.2683936059,
-0.4311250746,
-0.0572156385,
-0.0413767993,
0.4233813286,
-0.2333604097,
0.0538950153,
0.9007521868,
-0.2513485849,
0.2693278491,
-0.2389876992,
0.4607215524,
0.3151331842,
-0.3329858184,
-0.2301548868,
0.4803996682,
0.5462081432,
0.0532502569,
0.4387292266,
0.0057239924,
0.1222907156,
0.0227302127,
0.1819806844,
0.0103237377,
-0.2617765665,
-0.2035752088,
0.21512945,
0.1806597561,
-0.1905260682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12140v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12140v1 | Multilingual Sentence Transformer as A Multilingual Word Aligner | 2023-01-28T09:28:55 | 2023-01-28T09:28:55 | Weikang Wang, Guanhua Chen, Hanqing Wang, Yue Han, Yun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual pretrained language models (mPLMs) have shown their
effectiveness in multilingual word alignment induction. However, these methods
usually start from mBERT or XLM-R. In this paper, we investigate whether
multilingual sentence Transformer LaBSE is a strong multilingual word aligner.
This idea is non-trivial as LaBSE is trained to learn language-agnostic
sentence-level embeddings, while the alignment extraction task requires the
more fine-grained word-level embeddings to be language-agnostic. We demonstrate
that the vanilla LaBSE outperforms other mPLMs currently used in the alignment
task, and then propose to finetune LaBSE on parallel corpus for further
improvement. Experiment results on seven language pairs show that our best
aligner outperforms previous state-of-the-art models of all varieties. In
addition, our aligner supports different language pairs in a single model, and
even achieves new state-of-the-art on zero-shot language pairs that does not
appear in the finetuning process. | [
-0.2364547998,
-0.5939217806,
0.5648800731,
0.2339839488,
-0.1297832578,
0.1676915288,
-0.0682253391,
-0.1469031423,
0.0256349202,
0.0367153659,
-0.4587600231,
-0.2284206152,
-0.772439599,
0.2628775239,
-0.3179620206,
0.8862558007,
-0.2274104357,
0.2601801753,
0.0124821272,
-0.5768619776,
-0.57786268,
-0.2297222316,
-0.2973282039,
-0.2733757794,
0.6500751376,
0.1980442405,
0.6805041432,
0.3848260939,
0.3860931993,
0.4478916228,
0.3124472499,
0.1059972197,
-0.2825279236,
-0.1957778037,
-0.1886401474,
-0.302220434,
-0.3084018826,
-0.1724566221,
0.3333415389,
0.5248321891,
-0.4571653306,
-0.0828285813,
-0.1563209593,
0.3707889616,
-0.5356335044,
-0.1666354388,
-0.5447639227,
0.1124566942,
-0.3396839499,
0.3690165281,
-0.6526415348,
-0.2767466307,
-0.0424220599,
-0.57330966,
0.0764072239,
0.2883446515,
0.9999682307,
0.0846519172,
-0.7571974397,
-0.0392254107,
-0.3853093982,
0.7937548161,
-0.627051115,
0.8729347587,
-0.3058677614,
0.5226618052,
0.199536249,
-0.6683985591,
-0.8575996757,
0.0153583614,
-0.3283542991,
0.424939096,
-0.1286319196,
-0.1979918033,
-0.0570815019,
0.3515984714,
-0.7987325788,
0.4035227299,
-0.2595634162,
-0.3666118979,
0.2626988888,
-0.1016630232,
0.5690060854,
-0.0735352412,
-0.5869784951,
-0.178527832,
-0.4334545732,
-0.0052642585,
0.272551626,
0.2666088641,
-0.1209947765,
0.6063016653,
0.2472193986,
0.6694655418,
-0.1302974224,
-0.0786338523,
0.4335402846,
-0.314104408,
-0.243473053,
0.3053885698,
1.0956009626,
0.1669721901,
0.2956883907,
-0.4823590815,
-0.1396671385,
0.3633252084,
0.2673009634,
-0.8635813594,
-0.0328327157,
0.256347239,
-0.0961026773,
0.0492550395,
0.3555139005,
-0.3603329062,
-0.2287179679,
-0.3695575297,
0.4761691689,
-0.7938040495,
-0.1968583465,
0.1886032671,
-0.1684267074,
0.396361798,
-0.0866469517,
-0.9875053167,
0.275672853,
0.6494175792,
0.7814322114,
-0.3652696013,
-0.7713409066,
-0.8510761261,
0.1529261172,
-0.2820039093,
0.6954978704,
-0.1741657406,
-0.1432469934,
0.0891808122,
0.4725459814,
-0.328379184,
-0.234455809,
0.5208966732,
-0.4070648849,
0.5657370687,
0.0076742074,
-0.6130076647,
0.2164055705,
0.3116230071,
-0.4270428419,
0.8882783055,
0.1932146996,
-0.5129196048,
0.3226420879,
-0.6995813847,
-0.5397320986,
-0.0005774609,
-0.1695530415,
-0.473913461,
0.1145364195,
0.5046347976,
0.2888264954,
0.0728341565,
0.6420180798,
-0.0874614567,
-0.2996194959,
0.373105377,
-0.5278726816,
0.8880863786,
0.1699923724,
-0.1542504728,
0.325402081,
-0.7043232322,
-0.056437958,
0.0269301962,
-0.0496412069,
-0.0196755193,
-0.3059005737,
0.2797703445,
0.3583624959,
0.0727399066,
-1.0705559254,
0.1255454868,
-0.5270220041,
0.5345103145,
0.6464037895,
-0.5760201812,
0.6413391232,
-0.1550919712,
0.5208160877,
0.1404180974,
-0.0309809186,
-0.1175750569,
-0.0972341076,
-0.5446126461,
-0.4613996744,
0.5786566734,
0.916988194,
-0.6004825234,
0.2462845445,
-0.4827312231,
-0.1897763163,
-1.0410158634,
0.2137519866,
0.476677686,
0.3912661076,
0.5785104632,
0.1896788627,
-0.376052767,
-1.1490994692,
-0.2127901018,
0.4355074167,
0.0144583806,
-0.2720332444,
0.2157768011,
-0.2229347527,
0.7533928156,
-0.5318300128,
-0.220159784,
-0.2249243259,
0.2349995375,
0.0839759558,
0.4570998847,
0.6925742626,
-0.7183941007,
-0.716298461,
0.2674386501,
-0.8134759068,
-0.0185178053,
0.0941807926,
-0.3153784871,
0.2688136995,
0.5497097373,
-0.5616059303,
-0.1398335993,
0.9624840617,
-0.231504634,
0.4234787524,
-0.3336496949,
0.1182797551,
-1.363152504,
-0.1410463005,
-0.0730539262,
-0.4500406384,
-0.7386727929,
0.1943575889,
0.6649627686,
-0.4025589526,
-0.7576136589,
0.5211507678,
-0.4517667294,
0.2015884519,
-0.2339100689,
0.4501296282,
0.1274675131,
0.2973293662,
-0.024022378,
0.9335314631,
0.6016132236,
-0.1775541455,
0.1759255975,
0.4817000628,
-0.3838961124,
0.6403667927,
-0.4356086552,
0.2126848102,
-0.2141180336,
0.0440781601,
-0.89408952,
0.0288295783,
-0.1788277626,
-0.1283852607,
0.4631319344,
0.4168255925,
-0.4340662658,
-0.5015658736,
-0.2359300107,
0.2876672745,
0.316038698,
-0.804507792,
0.6368134022,
-0.0652443394,
-0.1129202247,
-0.8860375285,
-0.8137824535,
0.0451041311,
-0.2009601444,
-0.6486110091,
0.4236058295,
-0.1054682136,
-0.15466851,
-0.158383742,
-0.0031679953,
0.0847602114,
-0.1105097979,
-0.0773298219,
0.5483515263,
-0.5406745076,
0.3052481115,
0.0727316514,
-0.1608300954,
-0.285581857,
-0.301679492,
0.5488442779,
-0.3277637959,
-0.3756185472,
-0.4015527666,
0.3530625403,
0.5883902311,
-0.542417407,
1.0977625847,
1.0218678713,
-0.1733706445,
0.2386233807,
-0.6898055077,
-0.0720368996,
-0.4684540331,
0.4803590178,
-0.5484851003,
-1.0453579426,
0.2857237458,
-0.0508038811,
-0.0117343049,
0.4303153753,
0.1742199063,
0.0557617173,
1.1010452509,
0.7432524562,
-0.0183911789,
0.1462723315,
0.173986122,
0.5812149644,
-0.8177152276,
0.1361732781,
-0.2610653937,
-0.2539083362,
-0.6205091476,
-0.0159027707,
0.0946020484,
0.1950594187,
-0.3194321692,
0.5176679492,
-0.3072870076,
0.506757319,
0.2917218506,
-0.1273189932,
-0.0917622969,
-0.1580237299,
-0.3145823479,
-0.2202204615,
-0.6093861461,
-0.5030599833,
0.6498895884,
0.0499684438,
0.2346186638,
0.5200433731,
0.6269167066,
-0.3654577136,
0.4505349696,
-0.7880286574,
0.1936712414,
-0.6135807633,
-0.3976530731,
-0.2499560267,
-0.1457652003,
-0.8206138015,
0.532058239,
-0.4064729512,
-0.8686369658,
-0.0499880426,
-0.1533586383,
-0.3091823459,
0.0965247229,
-0.9740600586,
1.4016492367,
-0.3899629712,
-0.3669912815,
0.1151915044,
-0.6388047338,
0.4395911396,
-0.4516336024,
0.5585213304,
-0.1530512273,
0.2596601844,
0.4074994624,
-0.5984869003,
0.3742192984,
-0.1550799012,
-0.2689225376,
-0.1233825088,
-0.0483839698,
0.4563577175,
0.0297066756,
-0.0811874121,
-0.1142595336,
0.0171692595,
-0.4158786237,
-0.608237803,
0.7856055498,
-0.6497978568,
-0.7969046235,
-0.3900380433,
-0.9373221397,
-0.4025782049,
0.4991586208,
0.1510010511,
0.5801680088,
-0.3085884452,
0.3092024922,
0.2859151661,
-0.231721133,
0.5703188181,
0.7809147835,
-0.3526270092,
-0.4510379434,
0.9219528437,
-0.1438476741,
0.370855093,
0.6335017085,
0.4562092423,
-0.4590225816,
-0.3191481531,
-0.7133424878,
0.2914549112,
-0.5769606233,
-0.1822263598,
-0.8277457952,
-0.1424251646,
-0.5560865998,
-0.5523910522,
-0.2967339456,
-0.2731269002,
0.1763523519,
-0.3226366341,
0.0918867439,
0.2391539067,
0.1032945886,
0.6262143254,
-0.9738477468,
0.3468108475,
0.3336660266,
0.0653939769,
-0.4647046924,
-0.1955380589,
0.0130413864,
0.0138804782,
-0.341408819,
-0.7218343616,
0.2940548956,
0.2524857223,
0.5936301947,
0.2387054265,
-0.1883479059,
0.813890934,
-0.9108427763,
0.6831244826,
0.6068233252,
-1.0744371414,
0.165151149,
-0.166731596,
0.7717031837,
0.5671695471,
0.3149064183,
-0.552228272,
-0.7135555744,
-0.2488024682,
-0.4913147986,
0.7225005627,
0.1096816957,
0.3154257834,
-0.2136136889,
-0.0320210084,
0.3829770088,
0.1501080394,
-1.0612341166,
-0.1674753726,
-0.3987315297,
-0.5812076926,
-0.3610224426,
-0.0429462567,
0.0307740029,
-0.2014810592,
0.7285438776,
-0.1972093135,
-0.0601875819,
-0.0381640457,
-0.4831028581,
0.1157296002,
0.8247458935,
0.5312661529,
0.6087741256,
-0.1428300887,
0.2202795893,
0.3812941909,
-0.2099043429,
0.3566494882,
0.5293393731,
0.132171452,
-0.1583181322,
0.2928273976,
0.838637948,
0.3415557742,
-0.5444735289,
0.7705947757,
-0.1246006191,
-0.3421030045,
0.0624280274,
-0.3818680942,
0.3935045898,
0.1609023213,
-0.0518531129,
0.18398045,
-0.0323384628,
-0.5778746605,
0.168282941,
0.5662631392,
-0.513076365,
-0.1833582819,
0.8410761356,
-0.0369677283,
-0.2765450478,
0.7097867131,
-0.3568098843,
-0.6917284727,
0.388481468,
1.1018972397,
0.5026086569,
-0.5801928639,
0.1872337312,
0.2400743812,
0.2220491469,
-0.1271775961,
0.1527752876,
0.2738561034,
-1.0086215734,
-0.6417629719,
-0.8461436033,
0.0145718819,
-0.1611103714,
-0.5371941924,
0.4844170511,
0.294277817,
0.2210683376,
0.2836054862,
-0.4765456021,
-0.6598953605,
0.024062898,
0.2249300182,
0.7056906223,
-0.8244824409,
1.2165151834,
0.7720094323,
-0.0969801098,
-0.8102517724,
-0.2825365663,
0.053448353,
-0.8247618079,
0.5801537633,
0.5699919462,
-0.3050905168,
0.1106520817,
0.1211703345,
-0.6274529696,
1.1055878401,
0.5911175609,
-0.820492208,
0.3064850867,
0.3105261624,
0.4607726038,
-0.276953131,
0.0809227452,
0.2936191261,
0.4001097679,
-0.0571440943,
-0.9869201779,
0.0486492664,
-0.1438796818,
-0.0273402743,
0.6970816255,
-0.4000762999,
0.8417111635,
0.0536687598,
-0.2687703967,
-0.0072876224,
0.7074573636,
0.0804430619,
-0.0142294914,
0.4836985767,
0.7151864767,
0.8360171318,
-0.1782663465,
0.9580952525,
-0.2938631475,
0.1542726457,
1.2303217649,
-0.5546649098,
1.0181180239,
0.4637838304,
-0.209300071,
0.7884694338,
0.1197558492,
-0.0564702526,
0.4848819375,
-0.0560093708,
-0.0678635761,
-0.1775369346,
0.0429781601,
-0.1989926398,
0.4535501599,
0.0386212282,
-0.1377536058,
-0.1171357334,
0.5091661215,
0.0586651005,
0.3027976751,
-0.0176022667,
0.5622206926,
0.1126254722,
-0.8633137345,
0.396630168,
-0.0963218436,
0.840638876,
-0.7163687944,
0.3874766827,
-0.0632070675,
0.594407022,
-0.1103347838,
-0.5884872675,
0.3337243497,
-0.2491563261,
0.1219245493,
-0.3507763445,
0.5645430088,
-0.7412509322,
-0.649551332,
0.3075456321,
0.758338511,
-0.2533596456,
0.1431611925,
-0.5790743232,
-0.1658522934,
-0.2340419292,
0.1818536073,
0.4130140841,
0.3790669143,
0.0807370767,
0.2003051043,
0.3543235958,
-0.2615105808,
0.0438654646,
0.5289468169,
0.3644720018,
-0.4289139509,
-0.3811119795,
-1.0356810093,
0.5575466752,
-0.1874126792,
-0.154416576,
1.0096580982,
0.8444860578,
0.6948087811,
-0.2254851162,
0.5268887281,
0.1229277402,
0.1672740281,
-0.664465785,
0.4231980443,
-0.5691373348,
-0.315072298,
0.0057751513,
-1.1484949589,
-0.4053339064,
0.3687119186,
-0.1945012361,
-0.4221241772,
1.2918236256,
0.6691192389,
-0.4470151067,
0.2925079465,
0.2958761752,
-0.0162258428,
0.3183533251,
0.3321281374,
0.7025921345,
-0.5403668284,
0.6565667987,
-0.2756227851,
0.003484789,
0.4395062029,
-1.0006437302,
-0.8752025962,
-0.4229839146,
-0.4023929834,
-0.0489124879,
0.0704487786,
0.8003703952,
0.520011127,
-0.9607201219,
-0.2619703412,
-0.2537172735,
-0.3350729942,
-0.4320316911,
-0.2389381826,
0.3517548144,
-0.6541555524,
-0.8592143655,
0.5388349891,
0.166984871,
0.1716934741,
-0.0279901233,
-0.0801336169,
-0.5685582161,
-0.1397996694,
0.7236874104,
-0.1002200916,
-0.8863212466,
-0.3899070024,
0.2367035449,
-0.1816883832,
0.2365711629,
0.5802859664,
-0.573151648,
0.5301734209,
0.0132541358,
0.546213448,
0.4698298573,
-0.0902204067,
0.8223105669,
-0.9520538449,
0.2983022332,
-0.3163179755,
0.8757610321,
0.5103908777,
-0.1600083262,
0.3225053847,
-0.1795503348,
-0.517077744,
-0.5429797769,
0.081634827,
-0.9713413119,
-0.4126469493,
0.9806841016,
-0.0516674258,
-0.279759407,
0.1676899642,
-0.3954130113,
0.4507856667,
-0.0892162398,
0.4438346624,
1.0948514938,
0.1369601041,
-0.2721450329,
-0.4892930686,
0.1115452573,
0.6337525845,
-0.7922909856,
-0.0925302729,
0.3252356052,
0.1083595902,
0.4992552698,
0.242483452,
-0.1220236868,
0.0871250108,
-0.1260556877,
0.0594947636,
-0.0932310373,
0.0435134843,
-0.3170562685,
0.1939906329,
0.0442524515,
-0.1088500097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12139v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12139v3 | Bipol: Multi-axes Evaluation of Bias with Explainability in Benchmark Datasets | 2023-01-28T09:28:19 | 2023-09-16T15:56:11 | Tosin Adewumi, Isabella Södergren, Lama Alkhaled, Sana Sabah Sabry, Foteini Liwicki, Marcus Liwicki | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate five English NLP benchmark datasets (on the superGLUE
leaderboard) and two Swedish datasets for bias, along multiple axes. The
datasets are the following: Boolean Question (Boolq), CommitmentBank (CB),
Winograd Schema Challenge (WSC), Wino-gender diagnostic (AXg), Recognising
Textual Entailment (RTE), Swedish CB, and SWEDN. Bias can be harmful and it is
known to be common in data, which ML models learn from. In order to mitigate
bias in data, it is crucial to be able to estimate it objectively. We use
bipol, a novel multi-axes bias metric with explainability, to estimate and
explain how much bias exists in these datasets. Multilingual, multi-axes bias
evaluation is not very common. Hence, we also contribute a new, large Swedish
bias-labelled dataset (of 2 million samples), translated from the English
version and train the SotA mT5 model on it. In addition, we contribute new
multi-axes lexica for bias detection in Swedish. We make the codes, model, and
new dataset publicly available. | [
-0.6981959343,
-0.2720995545,
0.2658566535,
0.4748741686,
-0.1736022681,
-0.1996188611,
-0.2137341797,
-0.5775568485,
-0.1688733399,
0.4629585743,
-0.7812683582,
-0.494489491,
-0.6163343787,
0.0427780189,
-0.1284277886,
1.3210705519,
0.037625473,
0.8388569951,
-0.4193649292,
-0.646315515,
-0.5305911303,
-0.6683266163,
-0.1089000031,
-0.4751838744,
0.2141009718,
0.1832709461,
0.5592293739,
0.2963169515,
0.265134871,
0.045150198,
-0.3317941129,
0.1556972265,
-0.4438281953,
0.0820492879,
-0.5696015954,
-0.519035995,
-0.4209362566,
0.0764613003,
0.3220712841,
0.9911822081,
0.0707499832,
0.4836450517,
0.208664611,
0.879658103,
-0.5049901009,
0.374655664,
-0.5962329507,
-0.0300979223,
-0.1867332608,
0.1137883067,
-0.3693626225,
-0.1924277991,
0.1952396929,
-0.4133998752,
0.4782634676,
0.2890847921,
0.8440331817,
0.0869411007,
-0.4701374173,
-0.4019009173,
-0.6966062188,
0.7785966396,
-0.5222994089,
0.4016166329,
0.3454757333,
0.5511730313,
0.1772307009,
-0.4876609147,
-0.3457070887,
0.3814761639,
0.022611225,
0.2135766596,
0.0174987931,
-0.2496530563,
0.3724231422,
0.1248642579,
-0.505484879,
-0.0911728069,
-0.2653909922,
-0.5173236728,
0.7596557736,
-0.0251068082,
0.057110969,
0.0887058303,
-0.5437424183,
0.0568371601,
-0.899920404,
-0.1732852012,
0.7411841154,
0.3486071229,
-0.1201507598,
0.3666942418,
0.1101854444,
0.4018467367,
-0.148187995,
0.2383834571,
0.4764627516,
-0.7374328375,
0.1507274508,
0.0531025343,
0.5492067337,
0.5729460716,
0.1946367025,
-0.0508065931,
-0.0754699409,
0.1822572947,
0.0104604857,
-0.6049975753,
-0.0862695798,
0.2738400102,
-0.7775946259,
-0.1226048172,
-0.2217045724,
-1.1080495119,
-0.5639220476,
-0.2501818538,
0.1441256255,
-0.2422035486,
-0.3236019909,
0.1312562674,
-0.2590838969,
0.4116755426,
-0.0142998025,
-0.7210016847,
0.0928397179,
0.5762372017,
0.4382784367,
-0.0833658949,
-0.4468984008,
-0.1777248383,
-0.2103925347,
-0.444540143,
0.8789286017,
-0.4546879232,
-0.1196779087,
0.2557733655,
-0.034991499,
0.2342586517,
-0.6571761966,
0.9017412663,
-0.1283526868,
0.567897439,
-0.7157109976,
-0.3378216326,
-0.1086078361,
0.1379989833,
-0.5438225269,
1.1467580795,
-0.0830116421,
-0.9650378227,
0.6938092709,
-0.5497431755,
-0.3417815566,
-0.1789415032,
-0.1815867126,
-0.4901832044,
0.0992829502,
0.4483776689,
0.1880190372,
-0.7246866822,
0.4985452592,
-0.4912001789,
0.0589358509,
0.0686155185,
-0.4875209928,
1.277253747,
0.0463457406,
-0.2497454286,
0.2147741467,
-0.6780930758,
-0.0866925716,
-0.1775605232,
0.0221014731,
-0.3120654523,
0.0549455769,
0.2594392896,
0.6460145712,
0.1024970114,
-0.5113531947,
0.0132141272,
-0.2126600295,
0.1739694625,
0.656873405,
-0.1182891652,
0.184762761,
-0.1519494355,
0.4868626893,
-0.0421981514,
0.4127362967,
-0.0048385262,
-0.5137408376,
-0.3532557189,
-0.4924751818,
0.5329842567,
0.290363878,
-0.7820550203,
0.2620450556,
0.0224261004,
-0.3434096277,
-0.6946849227,
0.030399099,
0.6587277651,
0.5900858641,
0.4243248701,
-0.1842420548,
-0.6722918153,
-1.2644605637,
-0.5582237244,
0.1581011117,
-0.3326247633,
0.3862994015,
0.5453342199,
0.0016706691,
0.7597976327,
-0.2388264984,
-0.4755547941,
-0.4204217792,
0.3747424185,
0.3659161925,
0.0978342146,
0.8697034121,
-0.7103918195,
-0.4719541073,
-0.4498206973,
-0.6948523521,
-0.6902453899,
-0.0917353183,
-0.2217122316,
0.1107205227,
0.4277906418,
-0.4215151668,
0.2343467474,
0.4820043445,
-0.6465687752,
1.0486252308,
-0.1914778948,
-0.4631688595,
-0.7279111147,
0.057701651,
-0.1003789455,
-0.178777352,
-0.6713585854,
-0.1178599223,
0.10444922,
0.0206949431,
-0.5291274786,
0.3830077052,
-0.5814532042,
-0.3698948026,
-0.0716107339,
0.1886955053,
0.3802880049,
0.5065833926,
-0.1465049684,
0.6680226922,
0.8111801147,
-0.4568014145,
0.0596655682,
0.3997972012,
-0.4225158393,
0.7419709563,
-0.6838388443,
0.0569834076,
-0.3513963223,
0.2766229808,
-1.039729476,
0.2033789903,
-0.107043691,
-0.3818255067,
0.0152638452,
-0.2388267517,
-0.346436888,
-0.2435359359,
-0.456921488,
0.2107309103,
0.1644892097,
-0.7183654904,
0.4578692913,
0.5239195824,
-0.2411667556,
-0.9025201201,
-0.5189913511,
-0.1277064532,
-0.1706252396,
-0.3045650125,
0.3318192959,
-0.1184370369,
-0.0578210652,
-0.1387261748,
-0.3776268065,
-0.0319188051,
-0.0753715411,
0.0027143385,
0.5966362953,
-0.0485681854,
0.0936041325,
0.0500819758,
-0.135620892,
0.4842806458,
-0.2126290947,
0.8304883838,
-0.2429649979,
-0.2305563092,
-0.057274539,
0.2623202801,
0.6140691042,
-0.3275612295,
0.6350232363,
0.6644444466,
-0.33503896,
-0.2609530985,
-0.2575624883,
-0.1078731641,
-0.3199870586,
0.3003682494,
-0.3406407237,
-0.3200733662,
0.8027457595,
0.0071597374,
0.2270966172,
0.3879196346,
0.7712609172,
0.0614706911,
1.4079120159,
0.385037154,
-0.0616763122,
-0.0610417686,
-0.2378242463,
0.3072757125,
-0.8224368095,
-0.3498472571,
-0.6662809253,
-0.2541632354,
-0.4842922986,
-0.311075747,
0.1991616189,
0.0535796769,
-0.0500700101,
0.0323305093,
-0.5385484099,
0.3902651966,
0.4645584822,
-0.196892634,
0.0378924608,
-0.1571753621,
-0.5330787301,
-0.2769049406,
-0.7057589889,
-0.4328397214,
1.4413055182,
0.3365704715,
0.5526325703,
-0.0403399542,
0.1518235505,
0.3601396084,
0.2618346214,
-0.4278865457,
0.2375387251,
-0.0004670339,
-1.1971130371,
-0.179210335,
-0.2153729051,
-0.820158124,
0.6970418692,
-0.5445335507,
-0.5924873948,
0.6244733334,
0.2532886565,
0.0272525828,
0.137307927,
-0.6525512934,
0.9376106858,
-0.4112873673,
-0.8429659009,
0.1086754277,
-0.6803679466,
0.2613539696,
0.1347941905,
0.5940232873,
-0.4996794462,
0.1352928877,
0.850908041,
-0.2375801653,
0.5061951876,
-0.5378817916,
0.0847653523,
0.0013520275,
-0.1412753314,
0.2378903776,
0.0171335544,
-0.0583300963,
0.7147495747,
0.2259255499,
-0.4914346635,
-0.447378993,
0.24760364,
-0.5610124469,
-0.101536639,
-0.4646067917,
-0.7744312882,
-0.4705105126,
0.4079470336,
0.3800375164,
0.3614243567,
-0.1694124937,
0.1828247607,
0.4828737378,
-0.3347376287,
0.1955106258,
0.456353873,
-0.6829729676,
-0.1170306057,
0.8276430964,
0.2177087516,
0.0077731241,
-0.1937525719,
0.4484289289,
-0.5627856255,
-0.5451101661,
-0.4393052757,
0.2502874434,
-0.4721848965,
-0.1455732286,
-0.2644850314,
-0.0468942821,
-0.4259294569,
0.1522632241,
-0.5317173004,
-0.3019813895,
0.3874318898,
-0.2278786004,
-0.1257627755,
0.7875221372,
-0.1641494185,
0.0201768223,
-0.1725472957,
0.3899857402,
-0.0011977444,
0.5322969556,
-0.2809312642,
-0.3267519772,
-0.2149679363,
0.0523187704,
-0.1744453758,
-1.0028930902,
0.612885952,
0.0091116363,
0.689016223,
0.4967948794,
0.2272693366,
0.1153701767,
-0.5491738319,
0.6674160361,
0.1266397685,
-1.0747537613,
0.1436671615,
-0.3455111384,
0.1948315799,
0.6542577147,
0.589225769,
-0.39308846,
-0.0701173618,
-0.5760391355,
-1.1590298414,
0.8094656467,
0.1843027622,
-0.2229727358,
0.2660275698,
0.0390432775,
0.5597390532,
0.5689898133,
-0.6583333015,
-0.5873882174,
-0.3109909594,
-0.1580914855,
-0.0361068137,
-0.5860307217,
-0.575155735,
-0.1720109284,
0.6538283229,
-0.1667100936,
0.4958035946,
0.1097824797,
-0.2320277095,
0.4027579725,
0.4390518963,
0.5365359783,
1.0818471909,
-0.3876644671,
0.3260475099,
0.1872799546,
-0.4263989627,
-0.1461623907,
0.2175752223,
-0.4732935727,
0.3163417578,
0.4641215801,
0.8224457502,
-0.1659981906,
-0.6161617637,
0.6132270098,
-0.0139417928,
-0.5701391697,
-0.2389758676,
-0.4702472389,
0.1202913001,
0.0960917026,
0.3952431679,
0.0018318427,
0.2196910232,
-0.5909786224,
0.1404093653,
0.4077664614,
-0.7056241035,
-0.3290433586,
0.7940044403,
0.2355411202,
-0.141605556,
0.2518379986,
-0.2586929798,
-0.8262804747,
0.6655117273,
0.4851676822,
0.5778750777,
-0.054445859,
0.3297782242,
0.2438438088,
0.6671207547,
0.0445013046,
0.5798482895,
0.2511071563,
-0.9574524164,
-0.30477193,
-0.2621991932,
-0.50087291,
0.3437226415,
-1.1495381594,
0.148282215,
-0.3346790075,
-0.0160250235,
0.3618617356,
-0.2557727098,
-0.9147936702,
-0.172183454,
0.1170560047,
0.8969349265,
-1.2975893021,
0.6291767955,
0.6349323392,
-0.2874652743,
-0.3605975807,
0.0635929257,
0.2015950233,
-0.7926445007,
0.4024460316,
0.3452797532,
0.0827173069,
-0.6162506938,
-0.5182689428,
-0.6253718138,
0.6860697269,
0.5008574128,
-0.3807780445,
0.1200680733,
0.2340595722,
0.7787485719,
-0.5010252595,
0.5207861066,
0.7494519949,
0.6591752172,
-0.5906396508,
-0.6876394749,
-0.1634679139,
-0.1650633216,
-0.1679828316,
-0.1086735055,
-0.6223800182,
0.6646822095,
0.1374510825,
0.0860743746,
-0.7967924476,
0.4153145552,
0.1387438625,
0.723457098,
0.4663414359,
0.2949970365,
0.8999703526,
-0.1950606108,
0.9718968868,
-0.4559111297,
0.4852052033,
1.4257166386,
-0.7357926369,
0.3992456496,
0.5124440193,
-0.2707413137,
0.412024051,
0.3569518328,
-0.0659334064,
0.5519471169,
0.1351379305,
0.0249020625,
-0.0834284127,
-0.3112112284,
-0.2968185842,
0.5411618352,
0.527671814,
-0.1717318296,
-0.3056016564,
0.2668502331,
0.266197443,
0.1879386306,
-0.2630975246,
0.470526129,
-0.2825914323,
-0.6675261259,
0.4056837559,
-0.1645016968,
0.4985351562,
-0.576908052,
0.0849676728,
-0.4512074888,
0.2762618661,
-0.1867964715,
-0.7569454312,
0.4717719555,
-0.0920316353,
-0.301977098,
-0.4882309437,
0.7354826927,
-0.6447899938,
-0.4452583194,
0.6027101874,
0.5582704544,
0.2931115329,
-0.0114184637,
-0.9946362972,
-0.0135312835,
0.1485562921,
-0.1143449917,
0.3803978562,
0.3408041,
-0.1934958696,
0.7479845881,
0.5399087071,
0.1988828927,
0.120473288,
0.2329690158,
0.6885929108,
-0.2026515007,
-0.2534102201,
-0.6291400194,
0.2814720869,
-0.414311409,
-0.4301066101,
0.9801986814,
0.9747369289,
0.7924245,
-0.0284427516,
0.9858694673,
0.0150266802,
0.8620600104,
-0.3616321385,
0.7545834184,
-0.300205797,
0.2276699394,
-0.0984788761,
-1.1309318542,
-0.1755573601,
0.5500721931,
-0.3556011915,
-0.0587388277,
0.8779370785,
0.6918524504,
-0.0577489436,
-0.0653985143,
0.2081857324,
0.4471464157,
0.1432640105,
0.2323388755,
0.4722656906,
-0.2959939837,
0.7202072144,
-0.2613791823,
-0.3639754653,
-0.1611072868,
-0.9304990172,
-0.9851881862,
-0.4073142707,
-0.1428075284,
-0.6345496178,
0.2019206434,
0.7226669788,
0.6245636344,
-0.9943422675,
-0.2408943772,
0.1599482745,
0.546620667,
-0.6348603964,
-0.2082638741,
0.5669443607,
-0.2759704292,
-0.6145532131,
0.1518592834,
0.2100861222,
-0.60615623,
-0.4211485088,
0.0209378712,
-0.4885951877,
0.2289741188,
0.5721580386,
0.2230397463,
-0.3752169907,
-0.2819615602,
-0.0562497862,
0.1366744787,
0.0624926239,
0.9353343248,
-0.3140901923,
0.7134609222,
0.6361790299,
0.4154979587,
0.6277998686,
-0.2333448082,
0.7751908898,
-0.8100602031,
0.2293223143,
0.1058647484,
0.6215532422,
0.3106565773,
-0.0004309631,
0.7278196812,
0.2902896106,
-0.4852249026,
-1.0113471746,
0.3684841692,
-0.6335216165,
-0.421985358,
1.0387046337,
-0.2108117342,
-0.0455264002,
-0.7633396387,
-0.2861557007,
0.0585475378,
-0.0867100582,
0.762183845,
1.0549346209,
-0.3405046463,
0.0129001867,
-0.7893449068,
0.650832355,
0.7565367222,
-0.6686143279,
0.5814242363,
0.4686102569,
0.2537207305,
0.1012833789,
0.3109802902,
-0.4409950674,
0.1925543845,
0.1115588993,
0.6471033692,
-0.0108841993,
-0.4977462292,
-0.4065725207,
0.1226276383,
-0.1089838669,
-0.1906037778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12134v1 | Underwater Robotics Semantic Parser Assistant | 2023-01-28T09:04:43 | 2023-01-28T09:04:43 | Parth Parekh, Cedric McGuire, Jake Imyak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; C.3 | Semantic parsing is a means of taking natural language and putting it in a
form that a computer can understand. There has been a multitude of approaches
that take natural language utterances and form them into lambda calculus
expressions -- mathematical functions to describe logic. Here, we experiment
with a sequence to sequence model to take natural language utterances, convert
those to lambda calculus expressions, when can then be parsed, and place them
in an XML format that can be used by a finite state machine. Experimental
results show that we can have a high accuracy model such that we can bridge the
gap between technical and nontechnical individuals in the robotics field. | [
-0.394747287,
-0.7711287737,
0.8362436891,
-0.0496114679,
-0.4049217999,
0.1233115122,
0.3932988942,
-0.5284692645,
0.0550609492,
0.7035647035,
-0.6947412491,
-0.4105294347,
-0.7221542001,
0.3889689744,
-0.5452185869,
0.7257609367,
0.2708068788,
-0.0421726741,
-0.0207142308,
0.0331644379,
-0.3261292577,
-0.2204493284,
-0.5668181777,
-0.2211852372,
0.2572407424,
0.0395201705,
1.1294958591,
0.6864745617,
0.5524258018,
0.531088233,
0.0404174887,
-0.0120133543,
0.1305288672,
0.0552845448,
-0.5936479568,
-0.5538845658,
-0.3732617497,
-0.0938125923,
0.3455051482,
0.9282616377,
0.1926442683,
0.2318275124,
-0.3194735944,
0.6608346105,
-0.5125812888,
0.5098025203,
-0.3132377267,
0.2324440181,
0.1448033452,
-0.6545159817,
-0.3271267414,
-0.3450801075,
0.5486606359,
-0.7994235754,
0.0776951909,
0.0621803179,
0.5985022783,
0.4894487262,
-0.443872422,
-0.3382039368,
-0.7721165419,
0.8172748685,
-0.995891273,
0.4036056101,
0.3589238524,
0.4934796095,
-0.4532971382,
-0.8960725069,
-1.017072916,
0.0356214941,
-0.0337693207,
0.2634962797,
-0.0260836687,
0.3671659827,
0.2019204646,
0.2956256866,
-0.5905400515,
-0.3339792788,
-0.4896437228,
-0.0756163746,
0.8294044137,
0.2224293947,
0.877546072,
-0.3683024049,
-0.3135981262,
-0.5173194408,
-0.1792010218,
0.4862890244,
0.3618156016,
0.4912851155,
0.034601599,
1.053855896,
-0.2986285388,
1.0495872498,
-0.6055277586,
-0.3243013322,
-0.011658011,
0.0716751665,
-0.5059390068,
0.3233274519,
0.5228441358,
0.2673514783,
0.2778701484,
-0.0779977739,
-0.3856889009,
0.2995656729,
0.5253579021,
-0.1379520595,
-0.2005351335,
0.3267771602,
-0.5147991776,
-0.2241586894,
0.2455391735,
-0.5530032516,
-0.2477848232,
-0.7178419232,
0.6048324704,
-0.5223232508,
0.0259470921,
0.9170568585,
-0.6413234472,
0.3730767369,
0.4953314662,
-0.5055470467,
0.8653773069,
0.8773046136,
0.7728548646,
0.3132377863,
-0.1311033964,
-0.6040266156,
0.1374719441,
0.0442107394,
1.0192594528,
-0.6906241775,
-0.591439724,
-0.1686877012,
-0.0064386302,
-0.1044308469,
-0.2623306513,
0.5915021896,
-0.861788094,
0.302888602,
0.5608228445,
-0.9490897655,
-0.7715300322,
-0.1294210851,
-0.7085482478,
0.7452660203,
0.4074819386,
-0.3183719516,
-0.0647622272,
-0.9371734262,
-0.3322696686,
0.2807337046,
0.0459958464,
-0.1057530716,
-0.0524766147,
0.0791977718,
0.155001089,
-0.4159117341,
0.1263660192,
-0.1914068609,
0.0861671343,
0.2605379224,
-0.1230475977,
0.9635462165,
0.1220207512,
-0.2826880217,
0.1885292977,
-0.852017343,
0.1107451022,
-0.0170333199,
-0.1779652685,
-0.3332277238,
0.4875917137,
-0.1306572556,
0.5522928834,
-0.0566882044,
-0.8810330033,
0.1241224259,
-1.0125963688,
0.66618222,
0.4790689647,
0.0983749554,
0.593672514,
-0.4344839454,
0.5403420925,
-0.2723543942,
-0.0119495792,
-0.2559238672,
-1.0050215721,
-0.72095263,
-0.2901327014,
-0.069403708,
0.9087102413,
-0.8280315399,
0.844715476,
-0.31387043,
-0.4609680176,
-0.8040876389,
0.1453100592,
-0.0213319398,
0.991571486,
0.6539964676,
0.1247036755,
-0.4110508859,
-0.7110086679,
0.0190126635,
-0.0879297182,
-0.4548768103,
-0.0466266908,
0.6327379942,
-0.1581300646,
1.4029951096,
-0.5696697235,
-0.2346463799,
-0.276989907,
0.3720930815,
0.2697840929,
0.4189780056,
0.3092306256,
-1.0121988058,
0.0738914162,
0.0457691401,
-0.7270644903,
0.0910104662,
0.068808727,
-0.0616825558,
-0.0845828578,
0.6054714918,
-0.8297974467,
0.9051237702,
0.5031439662,
-0.4422668219,
-0.0552713312,
-0.1643279642,
-0.2460062653,
-0.9237955809,
-0.1966454238,
-0.219815135,
-0.3313426971,
-0.4680952132,
0.0407346636,
-0.1461807042,
-0.3040504754,
-0.6416612864,
0.5407522321,
0.0600286536,
-0.3804814816,
-0.515166223,
0.4569143355,
0.1829517782,
0.0884013772,
0.5886920094,
0.357773006,
0.5413985252,
-0.9471722841,
1.0537796021,
0.3393511772,
-0.1090330034,
0.1346075535,
-0.9907330275,
0.0457216054,
-0.0977896377,
0.3804269731,
-1.3515701294,
-0.1476329118,
-0.0074395551,
-0.7143384814,
-0.2767225802,
-0.1006895676,
-0.4826390743,
-0.3444583416,
-0.2808187902,
0.5256609917,
0.4222138822,
-0.4646184444,
0.8993439078,
0.3878329098,
-0.4116288424,
-0.1343469024,
-0.5256723166,
-0.0375053883,
-0.0576748326,
-1.2030477524,
0.3381540477,
0.3523824215,
-0.3535680771,
0.142370224,
-0.0030232589,
-0.0866603628,
0.1850290745,
0.0905703828,
0.6603652239,
-0.6248259544,
0.0144922435,
0.0864046589,
-0.3811330199,
0.2741536796,
-0.5020471215,
0.7456940413,
-0.3168791831,
-0.4406651258,
-0.845095098,
0.2768624723,
0.329986006,
-0.2223275155,
0.6375998855,
0.0152443582,
-0.5422231555,
-0.1830538362,
-0.073630169,
-0.3442999125,
-0.5950194597,
-0.0930342972,
-0.2929952145,
-0.7323024869,
0.3529246747,
-0.285258621,
-0.0696770921,
0.6221964955,
0.079823941,
-0.4023776054,
0.9081482291,
0.6662316322,
0.038788069,
-0.0556275472,
-0.2166055888,
0.7041730285,
-0.5559092164,
-0.1174278557,
-0.7602363229,
-0.3108705282,
-0.6710613966,
-0.3355714679,
0.1283554286,
0.0676910654,
-0.2466972172,
0.6506167054,
-0.352297157,
0.2877044082,
0.6373034716,
-0.1199933887,
0.2141655982,
-0.3945615292,
-0.0475405268,
0.1442963928,
-0.4580177665,
-0.9030979872,
0.6180137992,
0.2398346961,
0.7286418676,
0.3549205065,
0.6254450679,
0.4164275229,
-0.309011817,
-1.3023194075,
0.6692650318,
0.0983599648,
-0.1480367184,
-0.7287125587,
-0.0493440665,
-1.0404436588,
0.0391878933,
-0.052528102,
-0.8010732532,
-0.1141753495,
-0.281073153,
-0.4526833594,
0.2923585474,
-0.7017540336,
0.6527314782,
0.0314063728,
0.1453542709,
-0.0941487625,
-1.0855653286,
0.21114856,
0.2457342446,
0.3852511346,
-0.2621499002,
-0.2879199982,
0.4131112099,
-0.7792682648,
0.7830662131,
-0.0503003448,
-0.2071043104,
0.4538482726,
0.4986518919,
0.0889707133,
0.1224631742,
0.215298146,
-0.0375196375,
-0.072041139,
-0.4568103552,
-1.0456660986,
0.0919353589,
-0.93153584,
-0.5849871039,
-0.5648994446,
-0.5072116256,
-0.2100766003,
0.2256328017,
-0.0993988216,
0.2222885042,
0.2182927132,
-0.0659476668,
0.5061042309,
-0.6257520318,
0.7338907123,
0.5298444033,
-0.0407614186,
-0.1093667224,
0.8537611961,
-0.3414156735,
0.2879644036,
0.822031498,
0.2760507762,
-0.5592236519,
-0.0511920862,
-0.3250263929,
0.0629644766,
-0.7157979012,
-0.3975346088,
-0.6526551843,
-0.6599283218,
-0.6405179501,
-0.6296188235,
-0.3180344403,
-0.9539999962,
0.0552012548,
-0.2361641824,
0.5838371515,
0.8006745577,
0.0898001641,
0.3934031129,
-1.2924433947,
0.8088518381,
0.4512075782,
-0.0747938082,
-0.4463459849,
-0.4519736469,
0.5183237791,
0.1324127764,
-0.2784290016,
-0.6093530059,
0.6456182003,
0.3047969937,
0.3668350577,
0.1717377752,
0.1819765121,
0.7327833176,
-0.4466873109,
0.9672106504,
-0.0804895684,
-1.4347906113,
1.1743780375,
-0.4595340788,
0.2419987172,
-0.0835909694,
0.4066867232,
-0.6683046222,
-0.540111661,
-0.632584393,
-0.9527281523,
0.821267426,
0.2864869535,
0.1888379902,
-0.097643666,
0.1386101693,
-0.1482844055,
0.0028163765,
-0.3937586546,
-0.0873975977,
-0.4048692882,
-0.2726965845,
-0.1032573506,
0.1470763087,
-0.0492316894,
-0.3009973764,
0.4045228958,
-0.2088125497,
0.4088056386,
0.2659693956,
-0.2461778373,
0.2184340358,
0.1091422364,
0.8017411232,
0.4790736437,
-0.1410002261,
0.2950668335,
-0.1340511143,
-0.5465981364,
0.083046861,
0.0747439489,
0.2349958718,
0.0532647856,
0.5873347521,
0.2742092907,
0.3128429353,
-0.9562188387,
0.4104092419,
0.0010351569,
-0.0248584785,
-0.1883508116,
0.3241528571,
0.2260088325,
0.1896690577,
0.1811316311,
0.146500662,
0.4460788071,
-0.5617558956,
0.3473303318,
-0.036574807,
-0.0274813101,
-0.1980848908,
0.5997052193,
0.1690182388,
-0.5734049082,
0.9439247251,
0.0046048476,
-0.4160087109,
0.8647395372,
0.5782415271,
0.8160951138,
-0.4691537917,
0.4009935558,
0.2893670201,
0.1890329272,
0.1740568727,
0.4282909334,
-0.2432579249,
-1.0841959715,
-0.4904437661,
-0.7958450913,
-0.5695397854,
-0.2936157584,
-0.832411468,
0.4309939444,
-0.6071821451,
0.0265881456,
0.5686101317,
-0.4320758879,
-0.4273204803,
0.4583944678,
0.2026726007,
1.0734034777,
-0.6444677711,
0.8165071607,
0.7908401489,
-0.5334976912,
-0.6166177988,
-0.4747694135,
0.3145571649,
-0.9547219276,
1.0824834108,
-0.0120479818,
-0.7209951878,
-0.074883759,
-0.4545311332,
-0.9416576028,
0.9544249773,
0.2640138865,
-0.0251589753,
0.0405784436,
0.8411153555,
0.6388679147,
-0.4325052202,
0.1484001875,
0.4613068998,
0.3553907275,
-0.043344032,
-0.8783003092,
-0.0898638293,
-0.515805006,
0.3831002116,
0.0925425962,
-0.3117884994,
0.8778678775,
0.076921016,
-0.1338079721,
0.1222042143,
0.7468500137,
0.0855433494,
0.2931933701,
0.3644336462,
0.4041159451,
0.6508362293,
-0.1460944414,
1.1824146509,
-0.3710590303,
0.268179059,
1.0903782845,
-0.3008192182,
1.0294516087,
0.3767905235,
-0.1564948857,
0.5778197646,
0.3963265419,
0.2332578897,
0.4635920227,
0.2848929763,
-0.6143863201,
-0.0695459992,
-0.0265776329,
0.0359899402,
0.7764482498,
0.7361479998,
-0.0851258039,
-0.499053061,
0.2817767262,
-0.302416116,
0.1859156787,
-0.2768811882,
0.947167635,
0.1774661839,
-0.4542597234,
0.1328822821,
0.2505578399,
0.221783936,
-0.608527422,
-0.4628336132,
0.3225651383,
0.1713128686,
-0.4178906679,
-1.1622676849,
0.7232322097,
-0.0287101585,
0.0111129861,
-0.3356305361,
0.6856045127,
0.0857581124,
-0.2407280058,
0.515938282,
0.2815613449,
0.1192775667,
0.0696186647,
-0.5834387541,
-0.2676770389,
-0.3797037303,
-0.1450631022,
-0.0619473159,
0.473402828,
0.1658264846,
1.0499279499,
0.7275751233,
-0.2515429258,
0.4302319288,
-0.1168560684,
0.8847639561,
-1.0143896341,
-0.3874825835,
-0.7161914706,
0.6689905524,
0.2062179446,
-0.3411062658,
0.5472819805,
0.6022304893,
1.1363480091,
-0.2913243771,
0.8702570796,
-0.0761575848,
0.3647393584,
-0.7071585059,
0.3727803528,
-0.2902924716,
0.0099385679,
-0.294025749,
-0.8766756058,
-0.3550327122,
1.0614498854,
-0.2650586963,
-0.3208251595,
0.6729410291,
0.4595883489,
-0.0572616309,
0.6413234472,
0.4352329969,
-0.1805787683,
0.4040610194,
0.3092103899,
0.9558085203,
-0.5436964035,
0.0541264303,
-0.5192687511,
-0.016600633,
0.0837332532,
-0.6309301853,
-0.4963368177,
-0.63930583,
-0.2302564979,
-0.3081451058,
-0.1875588596,
0.9765545726,
0.4970174134,
-0.6988028884,
-0.4160745144,
-0.5118719935,
0.0935597047,
0.1001461893,
-0.3560332358,
0.2056703418,
-0.7257321477,
-0.858704865,
0.5283272266,
0.6307745576,
0.2276005745,
-0.0750638992,
0.0249300003,
-0.2223221362,
0.2631765306,
0.9274707437,
0.4329537749,
-0.6797971129,
-0.4956377149,
0.09763439,
-0.0111708483,
0.0288255103,
0.665379107,
-0.9717141986,
0.5482402444,
0.5225080252,
1.0330499411,
0.3107276559,
-0.1415619403,
0.8258333802,
-0.3343831897,
0.4027415812,
0.5974032283,
0.4028523266,
-0.0152931474,
-0.2431698591,
0.6025644541,
0.2586541176,
-0.3159229755,
-0.367256403,
0.1423303783,
-1.4343150854,
-0.1687548161,
0.7286798358,
-0.2989915311,
-0.4197409451,
-0.3910367191,
-0.4005487859,
0.3351120055,
-0.1417365521,
0.6713691354,
0.7090088725,
-0.5402895212,
-0.1279405057,
-0.6679855585,
0.4789809585,
0.1501669586,
-1.0180082321,
-0.5155781507,
0.1771940291,
0.1115315855,
0.4604460001,
0.1196348071,
-0.1425733119,
0.4876288474,
0.2065756172,
-0.0655895323,
0.5130009055,
-0.040578194,
-0.1819894314,
-0.0236182306,
-0.3266085088,
-0.224704653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12132v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12132v3 | AutoPEFT: Automatic Configuration Search for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning | 2023-01-28T08:51:23 | 2024-01-29T10:41:51 | Han Zhou, Xingchen Wan, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large pretrained language models are widely used in downstream NLP tasks via
task-specific fine-tuning, but such procedures can be costly. Recently,
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods have achieved strong task
performance while updating much fewer parameters than full model fine-tuning
(FFT). However, it is non-trivial to make informed design choices on the PEFT
configurations, such as their architecture, the number of tunable parameters,
and even the layers in which the PEFT modules are inserted. Consequently, it is
highly likely that the current, manually designed configurations are suboptimal
in terms of their performance-efficiency trade-off. Inspired by advances in
neural architecture search, we propose AutoPEFT for automatic PEFT
configuration selection: we first design an expressive configuration search
space with multiple representative PEFT modules as building blocks. Using
multi-objective Bayesian optimisation in a low-cost setup, we then discover a
Pareto-optimal set of configurations with strong performance-cost trade-offs
across different numbers of parameters that are also highly transferable across
different tasks. Empirically, on GLUE and SuperGLUE tasks, we show that
AutoPEFT-discovered configurations significantly outperform existing PEFT
methods and are on par or better than FFT without incurring substantial
training efficiency costs. | [
-0.7421093583,
-0.6857032776,
0.4551846087,
0.0141248591,
-0.1545352936,
-0.1148275733,
-0.3313961625,
-0.3299850821,
0.1830091476,
0.2779210508,
-0.4840438366,
0.0094301458,
-0.5182097554,
0.0108142272,
-0.28232342,
0.4756741524,
0.0042852876,
-0.6373735666,
0.288993448,
0.0013736465,
-0.4229544997,
-0.3867699504,
-0.7928468585,
-0.2518753409,
0.3433285952,
0.1924636364,
0.8501421213,
0.7665208578,
0.2981775403,
0.2867000699,
0.0437944941,
0.5007267594,
0.0027642972,
0.0275664646,
-0.4212714732,
-0.0641424283,
-0.5400721431,
0.0848284513,
0.3946543932,
0.5678727627,
-0.4754986465,
0.2726192474,
0.0985454097,
0.8804608583,
-0.7566923499,
0.1192640811,
-0.9271636009,
0.2600416243,
-0.0653268099,
-0.1044782624,
-0.1531356424,
0.1258927584,
0.1920568496,
-0.5511958599,
0.2757857144,
0.2501763403,
0.9119707346,
0.6828337312,
-0.2764779329,
0.0930955186,
-0.4835668802,
0.6527982354,
-0.6963772774,
0.6082807183,
0.5339126587,
0.0334244445,
-0.3779971302,
-0.5805386305,
-0.3249252737,
-0.2127289474,
-0.438390255,
-0.0762935579,
-0.2806286514,
0.3576886654,
0.1037754789,
0.3054388463,
-0.8843063116,
0.0898995176,
-0.194051221,
-0.2922639549,
0.6551889181,
-0.072058782,
0.101804696,
0.0890893638,
-0.1486850232,
0.0198310707,
-0.421600461,
-0.1035014838,
0.3949195743,
0.3248674273,
0.2849064767,
0.2776078284,
-0.4659808874,
1.1165671349,
0.6116605997,
0.3274342716,
0.0425434262,
-0.1871170104,
-0.4455679059,
-0.1165610105,
0.8099528551,
-0.0453660637,
0.2207453251,
-0.1319799274,
-0.4819771349,
-0.3061569035,
0.6516247988,
-0.5247052312,
-0.7076550126,
0.1288533211,
-0.6527400613,
-0.0938965902,
-0.2694393098,
-0.3554498851,
0.2230311781,
-0.6183347106,
0.6402657032,
-0.4588109553,
-0.1065226644,
0.3542684615,
-0.0719785467,
0.1828780025,
0.2801686525,
-1.2488958836,
0.2026739419,
0.3886066377,
0.6091035604,
-0.1754101515,
-0.4764557481,
-0.4896540046,
0.1926069707,
-0.4375341237,
1.0308562517,
-0.6059661508,
-0.0995271876,
-0.4356263578,
0.0247791279,
-0.4856877923,
-0.5309954882,
0.2278994024,
-0.3901785612,
0.1154308021,
-0.037715435,
-0.5485301018,
-0.1163282618,
0.0185928252,
-0.7099309564,
1.1820971966,
0.1930011958,
-0.186374411,
0.562482059,
-0.6571109891,
-0.5945368409,
0.0676921904,
-0.1482009292,
-0.2778488994,
0.4420801699,
0.3774450123,
0.60812217,
-0.1622590125,
0.2592214048,
-0.1728743166,
-0.4840396345,
-0.3760419488,
-0.3202668428,
0.617825985,
0.3569247723,
-0.7859910131,
-0.2243438065,
-0.7305901051,
0.0696596056,
-0.043670781,
-0.4360051751,
-0.236476481,
0.1500578672,
-0.1806614548,
0.150802508,
0.4990504384,
-0.1663285643,
0.2817689478,
-0.5603633523,
0.517703414,
0.6328127384,
-0.3210268915,
0.6223384142,
-0.2911505997,
0.3289476931,
-0.4421811998,
0.6647096276,
0.2302599847,
-0.3527215421,
-0.6448351145,
0.010950773,
0.2188079506,
0.3031868637,
-0.1952318251,
0.8624260426,
0.6456722021,
-0.5868630409,
-0.3628263175,
0.202811718,
0.3119781315,
0.4790923893,
0.4754725993,
-0.1523838788,
-0.2270011008,
-1.3994761705,
-0.4018163979,
-0.2377557755,
0.0032514862,
0.4237925708,
0.2610587776,
0.0461584367,
0.7339968681,
-0.5149202347,
-0.3758269846,
0.1759512573,
0.2855984867,
0.3688215613,
0.689723134,
0.9777204394,
-0.7825444341,
-0.6206919551,
-0.0825972855,
0.0483396128,
-0.1878191084,
-0.3025624752,
-0.2963630557,
0.2171056569,
0.6178712249,
-0.6090070009,
0.0114567475,
0.5828382969,
-0.3029004335,
0.4304110408,
-0.597162962,
0.0090233469,
-0.5217434168,
0.2736016214,
-0.1561980695,
-0.0767561644,
-0.2702886462,
-0.0214353316,
0.3308742344,
0.2414407432,
-0.322140485,
0.4847233593,
-0.4796541333,
0.1794570237,
-0.2092803568,
-0.25872159,
0.2723924518,
0.6427910328,
0.0940286443,
0.9333385229,
0.4928221405,
-0.5359616876,
0.0720835701,
0.1968930364,
-0.1019199118,
0.3247096837,
-0.5728363991,
0.215593636,
0.0089921504,
0.0513103716,
-0.9229863882,
-0.0798998475,
0.1243746802,
-0.0759066567,
0.330901444,
-0.3465432227,
-0.6241220236,
0.0537499487,
-0.0545836426,
0.3755452633,
0.4985196292,
-0.5926570296,
0.7282250524,
0.5801589489,
-0.1074370369,
-0.4785832465,
-0.432271719,
0.0955860689,
-0.1028664187,
-0.328569144,
0.8701354861,
-0.237647295,
0.3307974041,
-0.276873976,
-0.392801851,
-0.2167501748,
0.1618370563,
-0.1927029043,
-0.0612505078,
-0.0382168852,
0.2955309451,
0.4597390294,
-0.1612526476,
-0.1520953029,
-0.5254234672,
0.4768885076,
-0.3943127096,
-0.1842532605,
-0.1093114391,
0.5017105937,
0.4083995521,
-0.4627765417,
0.5063707829,
0.6784365177,
-0.3183597326,
-0.557972312,
-0.9130786061,
-0.0589062758,
-0.5879505873,
0.1576149464,
-0.3880767524,
-0.6681821346,
0.2630052865,
-0.1484452039,
0.2677866518,
0.5996005535,
0.4338624179,
-0.2625389397,
1.1163282394,
0.6330657005,
0.2233671993,
0.6222940087,
0.0069681043,
0.1993277222,
-0.4409728944,
0.0039095264,
-0.4255051613,
-0.6152654886,
-0.4865118563,
0.0027020792,
0.4655665457,
0.1186450571,
-0.2919420004,
0.83811903,
-0.9601767063,
0.7389317155,
0.8680272102,
0.0452198051,
0.1196113452,
-0.1983703822,
-0.0782438144,
0.3051422536,
-0.9241030216,
-0.2929852307,
0.8356530666,
-0.0974149108,
0.449208796,
-0.213366285,
0.6276805401,
0.0524759255,
-0.341098547,
-0.5759147406,
0.4416279793,
-0.6953418255,
-0.6182701588,
-0.4609557986,
-0.0877903774,
-0.9093416333,
0.1526203156,
-0.2204426378,
-0.509185791,
0.6546278,
0.7232163548,
-0.8813852072,
0.1687157601,
-0.6722158194,
0.8857698441,
-0.3025925756,
0.0059731063,
-0.3233987987,
-0.6508812904,
-0.236075744,
-0.4177906513,
-0.1588020772,
-0.2761404812,
-0.2703017592,
0.4962588251,
-0.1784932017,
0.4605957568,
-0.1223382428,
0.0262218229,
-0.1962986588,
0.2480597347,
0.570574224,
0.0613401458,
-0.3116796017,
0.1085641459,
0.2395190746,
-0.3581320345,
-0.5422789454,
0.4853548706,
-0.5208485126,
-0.4487342834,
0.0357769839,
-0.4623535872,
-0.2811512649,
0.1966592222,
0.4271047711,
0.3780706227,
-0.0069368905,
0.1748520434,
0.7026699185,
-0.2967712581,
0.6254612803,
0.410651654,
0.2848866284,
-0.0686985627,
0.6007617116,
0.2558651567,
-0.0127291698,
0.4009694457,
0.3341496289,
-0.1830595136,
-0.8123776317,
-0.4379109144,
0.0146883372,
-0.268617779,
-0.266921103,
-0.4396416545,
-0.0713600814,
-0.1913489699,
-0.5122673512,
-0.8394365907,
-0.4537464082,
-0.3113723993,
0.2384116203,
0.2508538067,
0.212284863,
-0.3338150084,
0.3062441647,
-0.6586094499,
0.4106653929,
0.4360614717,
0.7465373874,
-0.3824192286,
-0.4235969186,
-0.3525253534,
-0.256953001,
-0.1447265446,
-0.585994482,
0.3691261709,
0.7833470702,
0.7503472567,
0.0966437757,
0.2101520747,
0.6399693489,
-0.6257932186,
0.4381482899,
-0.1669403017,
-0.8705177307,
0.7112911344,
-0.3615766764,
0.1973925233,
0.8017531633,
0.1668941677,
-0.052626323,
-0.1912124306,
-0.7521523237,
-1.0418068171,
0.6246568561,
0.1993120462,
0.1350570619,
0.0953881815,
0.694991827,
0.38833794,
0.2206866145,
-0.2266920954,
-0.2191432565,
-0.0733944401,
0.0274599679,
0.0907658041,
0.0145808514,
-0.0502318069,
-0.6161525846,
0.7209867835,
-0.3684859276,
0.3857357502,
0.1687161326,
-0.0913906991,
-0.280641973,
-0.0415157266,
0.1328647137,
0.6532709002,
-0.3150096834,
0.0692027584,
0.2633267939,
-0.1338490397,
0.0518960059,
0.3495961428,
0.0492626429,
0.13437365,
-0.0868476704,
0.7768725753,
0.1456697881,
-0.654140532,
0.2983743548,
-0.096684657,
-0.5335668921,
-0.3779031038,
0.6504480839,
-0.0772848353,
0.565572083,
0.1379630268,
0.2259658426,
0.4561626017,
-0.1632624567,
0.4330195785,
0.650259316,
0.1048655659,
-0.0688780025,
0.5359174609,
-0.0116707077,
-0.4838590622,
0.5860134363,
-0.1072023883,
-0.0922814757,
0.5702631474,
0.1068707034,
0.9979358912,
-0.2853477001,
0.2222804278,
0.1473589391,
0.4021875858,
-0.2483064532,
0.2154829651,
-0.2002746761,
-0.5605983138,
-0.555444777,
-0.9024492502,
-0.3488571346,
0.304418385,
-0.384316355,
0.2655113637,
-0.426743716,
-0.1901308894,
0.0934694111,
-0.1167941466,
-0.6861361861,
0.2823763192,
0.2494008392,
0.9409113526,
-0.5702738762,
0.9072290063,
0.7708183527,
0.0896909982,
-0.8381309509,
-0.0003137472,
-0.2371208966,
-0.6127327681,
0.3398251534,
-0.2483747602,
-0.1005770043,
0.1695503294,
-0.2844545543,
-1.2207239866,
0.731159389,
0.8788443208,
-0.8159036636,
-0.5315266848,
-0.0587379187,
0.3783228397,
-0.0539557375,
0.1355107278,
0.9109290838,
0.6456143856,
-0.2722849548,
-1.3710237741,
0.0245958529,
-0.389071852,
-0.073041819,
0.5135951638,
-0.868786037,
0.8969165087,
0.4391837716,
0.1115371734,
-0.2225884348,
0.1259507537,
-0.0815726593,
-0.2976584733,
0.8339163065,
0.2864485681,
0.435007453,
0.1601358056,
0.5473141074,
-0.7818779945,
0.3604415655,
0.983133018,
0.1835728437,
0.7718586922,
0.4937092364,
-0.1900178641,
0.041586522,
0.9069623351,
-0.2182596624,
0.5625081062,
-0.0548670515,
0.1390564889,
-0.7302539945,
0.4062381387,
-0.0997803956,
0.6270887256,
0.2717647254,
-0.3903243244,
-0.3518016934,
-0.2260617316,
-0.3056801856,
-0.2199642509,
-0.0022356792,
0.7735655308,
0.0274893474,
-0.8196222782,
0.7326513529,
-0.1657001376,
0.5659146309,
-0.6361800432,
-0.1066066846,
-0.2289612889,
-0.0118292188,
-0.1833339185,
-0.4300471246,
0.6738523245,
-0.5723257065,
-0.0155600337,
-0.5730435848,
0.7969903946,
-0.4012982845,
-0.14691329,
0.382876128,
0.6634924412,
-0.2045020908,
-0.5153775811,
-1.1542980671,
-0.3082221448,
-0.1985626966,
-0.8075431585,
0.5295229554,
0.1265977174,
0.2670396566,
0.226577118,
0.4943832755,
0.1487719715,
-0.1446852535,
-0.3296103776,
0.6677275896,
-0.4084143639,
-0.6453641653,
-0.8056077957,
0.3520264924,
0.0859240368,
-0.4697559178,
0.0588018447,
0.3648978174,
0.9289165735,
-0.0077156541,
0.5971282125,
-0.1034892872,
0.2033884078,
-0.6871762276,
0.8797169924,
-0.8587727547,
0.1374570727,
-0.2917766273,
-1.0732477903,
-0.3392507434,
0.9585445523,
-0.0968306288,
-0.1698463112,
0.6764971018,
0.8754284382,
-0.4853426218,
0.0107127661,
0.3285420835,
-0.0256518871,
0.0838169679,
0.5600765347,
0.4121563733,
-0.1928200275,
0.4730457962,
-0.4418123364,
-0.2505541444,
-0.2057947218,
-1.1057788134,
-0.6670401692,
-0.8569051027,
-0.4108207226,
0.3627030551,
0.2786876261,
1.1986825466,
1.0945293903,
-0.741961658,
-0.1940147579,
-0.3728571832,
-0.4192496538,
-0.4195663631,
-0.1038606465,
0.5871286392,
-0.7121859789,
-0.6636040807,
0.8385465741,
0.4534465969,
-0.2253491282,
0.0214351416,
0.1956263185,
-0.2478205115,
0.2346947938,
0.4920387268,
0.2542129457,
-0.5224481821,
-0.2840954363,
-0.0591438115,
0.2419196963,
0.2563431263,
0.6890739799,
-0.8239878416,
0.2139460593,
0.5454363227,
0.6784028411,
0.4941514134,
-0.3908510208,
0.9560491443,
-0.6571602225,
-0.0671596378,
0.2193758935,
0.5534723401,
-0.2696942091,
-0.4619541466,
0.5812679529,
-0.1034425646,
-0.7035306692,
-0.5000356436,
0.2237700075,
-0.7581666112,
-0.7025778294,
0.7894532681,
0.1036804169,
0.1014262363,
-0.3229934871,
-0.3947931826,
0.1146008,
-0.4149653316,
1.08426404,
0.4741835594,
-0.8426436186,
-0.1230021343,
-0.4516386688,
0.958773613,
0.8506580591,
-0.5556431413,
0.1335322708,
0.3532829285,
0.0759268329,
-0.0704952329,
0.3585300446,
0.1821896136,
0.3605803251,
-0.3171271682,
-0.275734067,
-0.2632118165,
-0.4233569205,
-0.1921138316,
0.366050601,
0.0224112868,
0.0421530157
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.