id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04811v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04811v1 | A Large-Scale Multilingual Study of Visual Constraints on Linguistic Selection of Descriptions | 2023-02-09T17:57:58 | 2023-02-09T17:57:58 | Uri Berger, Lea Frermann, Gabriel Stanovsky, Omri Abend | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a large, multilingual study into how vision constrains linguistic
choice, covering four languages and five linguistic properties, such as verb
transitivity or use of numerals. We propose a novel method that leverages
existing corpora of images with captions written by native speakers, and apply
it to nine corpora, comprising 600k images and 3M captions. We study the
relation between visual input and linguistic choices by training classifiers to
predict the probability of expressing a property from raw images, and find
evidence supporting the claim that linguistic properties are constrained by
visual context across languages. We complement this investigation with a corpus
study, taking the test case of numerals. Specifically, we use existing
annotations (number or type of objects) to investigate the effect of different
visual conditions on the use of numeral expressions in captions, and show that
similar patterns emerge across languages. Our methods and findings both confirm
and extend existing research in the cognitive literature. We additionally
discuss possible applications for language generation. | [
-0.7832817435,
-0.5051656365,
0.3683389127,
0.4444029629,
-0.5072291493,
-0.115012452,
-0.5219936371,
-0.9110987782,
0.2612256408,
0.740262568,
-0.1757716984,
-0.2003932744,
-0.6341112256,
0.5709489584,
-0.0031163022,
0.5437975526,
-0.1251804829,
0.1828809828,
-0.3151839375,
-0.4270662665,
-0.7155865431,
-0.5279147625,
-0.2087316811,
0.0996832848,
0.5661622286,
0.2576589882,
1.0888130665,
0.5247647166,
0.8892153502,
0.3942416012,
0.0596759692,
0.1771844327,
0.0527962372,
0.0821697563,
-0.1077009067,
-0.7166762948,
0.4038432539,
-0.2026711553,
0.8374015093,
0.8292421699,
0.3660373688,
0.087155357,
-0.2930887043,
0.6824873686,
-0.774912715,
0.597678721,
-0.5763711929,
0.2396395355,
-0.3702421188,
-0.3481317163,
-0.5221897364,
-0.0151389958,
0.2418418676,
-0.6456125975,
0.2771634459,
0.2160508931,
1.0824126005,
0.4738001227,
-0.5071825981,
-0.1484116167,
-0.4160133898,
0.7007777095,
-0.2494105548,
0.4384460151,
0.5149583817,
0.3516179919,
0.3480497301,
-0.3228609264,
-0.415352881,
-0.4230098128,
-0.4749065936,
-0.0015058091,
0.183979407,
-0.121134989,
0.5097127557,
0.2255589068,
-0.4902449548,
0.093975462,
-0.758580029,
-0.2686570287,
0.5852072835,
-0.0391868614,
0.6443561316,
-0.2802641988,
-0.1873906553,
-0.4140098393,
-0.7268282771,
-0.0849823132,
0.1901245415,
0.2856994271,
-0.1077129319,
0.8462554216,
-0.1986703575,
0.9729792476,
-0.4037686884,
-0.077121608,
0.3664276302,
-0.3228271902,
0.0399849787,
0.0781985372,
0.7979376912,
0.6948443055,
0.6535407305,
0.0019387832,
0.0258839484,
0.4247556627,
-0.0261615515,
-0.5773056746,
0.0592659302,
-0.3455367684,
-0.1570135206,
-0.366055727,
0.0916385278,
-0.8744618297,
-0.488592416,
-0.3131425381,
0.0042026355,
-0.4746351242,
-0.1105333194,
0.1057238951,
-0.2319641411,
0.4669829309,
0.0988632068,
-1.1504976749,
0.0980230495,
0.1765278131,
0.6177241206,
-0.1227843687,
-0.6321457624,
-0.3605981767,
0.0221608859,
-0.6118103266,
0.6798863411,
-0.8111824393,
-0.1621813625,
0.2237855941,
0.0144598885,
0.0888955519,
-0.4999934733,
-0.0012927993,
-0.6504990458,
0.0170033257,
-0.1450918615,
-0.0991226807,
-0.2898187637,
0.0541589074,
-1.1929883957,
0.6012846828,
-0.1057773158,
-0.694519639,
0.7133561373,
-0.3118027747,
-0.6616434455,
0.3105824888,
-0.8561919332,
-0.2100674361,
0.3920675814,
0.2385089099,
0.289563179,
-0.1129538268,
0.3482818902,
-0.1152283102,
0.0050602877,
0.6696616411,
-0.2441387922,
0.70707798,
0.2531246245,
-0.4852496684,
0.0152221601,
-0.6089192033,
-0.1091950759,
0.2193831503,
-0.0640780777,
-0.3349849284,
-0.1255113184,
0.2933987975,
0.2736513913,
0.1640078723,
-0.4019542336,
-0.0687975287,
-0.2299515456,
0.3945293128,
0.3578903377,
-0.0692409649,
0.5264010429,
0.0501753688,
0.5688129663,
0.0029697728,
0.0834512189,
-0.2930340171,
-0.5770468116,
-0.7990425229,
-0.0962425992,
0.3739541471,
0.5182961226,
-1.1986825466,
-0.1237599775,
-0.2838416696,
0.0512034521,
-0.3891949654,
0.1068831161,
0.6175044179,
-0.1602160186,
-0.0083850771,
-0.4743394852,
-0.5172743201,
-1.3276017904,
0.2285210639,
0.0001585068,
0.2070018053,
0.2207412422,
0.4544819891,
0.1507890522,
0.5741456151,
-0.5129037499,
-0.3205132484,
-0.1823186129,
0.048365254,
-0.1894243062,
0.1346565038,
0.9225237966,
-1.1492756605,
-0.2767049372,
0.2300671637,
-0.8269107938,
0.0112777334,
-0.2765215039,
-0.0564548895,
0.5490140915,
0.6570755839,
-0.4195998311,
0.574568212,
0.6185709834,
-0.4085223079,
0.3388057649,
-0.3228982389,
0.027427474,
-0.7000581026,
-0.1223011538,
0.2123102993,
0.1577054709,
-0.2672814131,
0.4310787022,
0.1555236429,
-0.2288871557,
-0.6057109833,
0.5744642615,
-0.681111455,
-0.2137888819,
0.0249277204,
0.2161435038,
-0.0658082291,
0.51092273,
0.6929419637,
0.5612875223,
0.5982260108,
-0.4213299155,
0.2164987624,
0.5457244515,
-0.5832942128,
0.5707389712,
-0.3472853303,
-0.3321861327,
-0.3973719776,
-0.081264697,
-1.0440582037,
-0.3559372723,
-0.0441825576,
-0.3864662051,
0.3655637205,
0.1267033517,
-0.6950035095,
-0.0747679621,
0.0103076622,
0.4670512378,
0.1017933637,
-0.4183112085,
0.3618447483,
0.2523967624,
-0.0483910441,
-0.4568515122,
-0.9156163335,
0.3288144171,
-0.2490399927,
-0.5473162532,
0.068889685,
-0.145939827,
-0.5314927697,
-0.2895266116,
0.1702934653,
-0.1119807735,
0.0169153661,
0.308948338,
0.610637188,
-0.0338584147,
0.1743166298,
-0.3422279954,
0.167143181,
0.024502445,
-0.0799906403,
0.2951953113,
-0.346453011,
-0.0588625669,
-0.0505852364,
0.5125771761,
0.5883640647,
-0.6729985476,
0.4976558089,
0.5118302703,
-0.0054133283,
-0.0835555419,
-0.584597528,
0.0945762917,
-0.4049066007,
0.4246645272,
-0.595413506,
-0.8165854216,
0.2817856669,
0.391685307,
-0.2344493568,
0.4274602532,
0.4545511603,
0.2308145314,
0.7095699906,
0.5452899337,
0.2463498861,
0.6485681534,
-0.2815177143,
0.0367334485,
-0.5563505888,
-0.2957095504,
-0.2994231582,
-0.2998640239,
-0.95376122,
-0.303096503,
0.1877975911,
-0.2343530953,
0.1575548947,
0.197217986,
-0.5524776578,
0.5884394646,
0.629933238,
0.1191020235,
0.1574889272,
0.1261878461,
-0.3216024041,
-0.2055156529,
-0.6184280515,
-0.4275344908,
0.9373136163,
-0.1230460256,
0.4208278954,
0.2663366497,
0.3641441464,
-0.068352215,
0.1715075672,
-0.6887407303,
0.6856659651,
-0.2192981094,
-0.8190352321,
-0.38236624,
-0.2783080637,
-1.1295536757,
0.4460961223,
-0.4679290354,
-0.6056222916,
0.207139641,
-0.1259027719,
-0.2077289373,
0.0725904852,
-0.7499516606,
0.7989775538,
-0.6213473082,
-0.4949436486,
0.0354353115,
-0.9318167567,
0.2601675391,
-0.0455958843,
0.4836447239,
0.0479111001,
-0.02515487,
0.4486196637,
-0.0707888231,
1.0873514414,
0.2008695602,
-0.0539598987,
0.219728142,
0.084273234,
-0.0892075673,
0.0317531824,
0.3834969699,
0.2024777383,
0.1254361272,
-0.3428025544,
-0.5016816854,
0.4554741681,
-0.7455729246,
-0.4604229927,
-0.3333538473,
-0.7377206683,
-0.2469778508,
0.3109620512,
0.6267050505,
0.5330786109,
-0.0767327398,
0.2069682777,
0.448774606,
-0.5870484114,
0.6060060859,
0.2122760266,
-0.4879350066,
-0.5496105552,
0.953979373,
0.4079646766,
0.4384273887,
0.7064933777,
0.2153568417,
-0.2093076706,
-0.5129711628,
-0.4257545471,
0.2514187098,
-0.8181156516,
-0.0207500644,
-0.0669511259,
-0.0224547405,
-0.2852660716,
-0.2582704723,
0.1440622509,
-0.6729686856,
-0.1454283446,
-0.0988697484,
0.2828353047,
0.7175245881,
0.0982433483,
0.1935244501,
-0.4283345044,
0.4976391792,
0.4398904443,
0.4307470322,
-0.1469085217,
-0.1239295676,
-0.1677303016,
-0.195991084,
-0.1152257919,
-0.8031210899,
0.4844861031,
0.2610574365,
0.4963386953,
0.4234925807,
0.0229335036,
0.3522440791,
-0.5940910578,
0.631983459,
0.430411756,
-0.5539469123,
0.5346032977,
-0.2861792147,
0.5213021636,
0.4746213853,
0.2215331495,
-0.3311108947,
-0.6343812943,
-0.6786862612,
-0.6379142404,
0.1142708212,
0.3311165273,
0.081942901,
-0.3375353515,
0.0659964904,
0.0543750748,
0.1203756779,
-0.827657342,
-0.1813979149,
-0.2060005665,
-0.0249802899,
-0.3590498567,
-0.1177317724,
-0.14617984,
-0.2011721134,
0.1437514871,
-0.2747977674,
0.0277470052,
0.1858537048,
-0.4213127494,
0.2348679155,
0.1929478645,
0.8946003318,
0.7113677859,
0.1592487097,
0.4924821556,
0.046734564,
-0.4233590961,
-0.2408487946,
0.0494343005,
-0.3244686723,
0.4631708562,
0.4457608759,
1.1112664938,
0.3746514022,
-0.7631106973,
0.3179928362,
0.0816119313,
-0.5039621592,
-0.5074440241,
-0.2898265421,
-0.1944895834,
0.1234261021,
0.0274098646,
-0.0625526085,
0.0795269534,
-0.5133537054,
-0.0119075393,
0.4437300861,
-0.3472996354,
-0.2406895608,
0.6488884687,
-0.0249943435,
-0.0052351751,
0.5209130645,
-0.2305839509,
-0.4106212258,
0.8132194877,
0.3321441114,
0.5278323889,
0.1308311671,
0.4262314737,
0.3774463832,
0.5226851106,
-0.1898085773,
0.2600086033,
0.0963007212,
-0.959690094,
-0.6043742299,
-0.4803736806,
-0.3592856228,
-0.0949808136,
-0.5253984332,
0.2701594234,
-0.3505230546,
-0.2604562342,
0.5223159194,
-0.3084923923,
-0.9207044244,
0.2397907823,
0.8589470983,
0.5596020818,
-0.9372382164,
0.6054609418,
0.8681752086,
-0.8328123093,
-0.5655912757,
-0.6438025236,
-0.1127116159,
-0.7847085595,
1.0701473951,
0.240255937,
0.0990497917,
-0.3090237975,
-0.7926049232,
-0.8180605769,
0.6067683101,
0.4598237872,
-0.3048483431,
0.1533851773,
0.5325244665,
0.5696283579,
-0.3654918671,
-0.0237146281,
0.3735394776,
0.761618495,
0.3149132133,
-0.9637711644,
0.0293828342,
-0.3500932157,
0.309081614,
0.3761152327,
-0.6649608612,
0.4999454021,
-0.5013863444,
-0.192080155,
0.0706174001,
0.3758297265,
0.1469212472,
0.0438239686,
0.2780392468,
0.4615158141,
0.4199840724,
-0.1227014139,
1.1480305195,
-0.1943392456,
0.0253453422,
1.0131951571,
-0.0511961058,
0.8048319817,
0.8597220778,
-0.0247424208,
0.4069687724,
0.5484927893,
-0.4419337809,
0.4836099744,
0.5076960325,
-0.1748102009,
-0.1209883168,
-0.420637548,
-0.0700877532,
0.6655449271,
0.3809240162,
-0.4275881946,
0.2102306783,
0.2236917913,
-0.1132748947,
0.2377004325,
-0.264477998,
0.6278334856,
0.0503177382,
-0.8497573733,
0.7306898832,
-0.4744843841,
0.450045526,
-0.4281199276,
-0.0153014446,
-0.1250099987,
-0.0662535876,
-0.2672883868,
-0.939869225,
0.2319036275,
-0.3094750941,
0.0931516886,
-0.2988863885,
0.3308807313,
-0.4272322059,
-0.866938293,
0.128987655,
0.3925945461,
0.2844820321,
-0.001289174,
0.0020087473,
0.2126193345,
0.0279752314,
0.0877341107,
0.2369390726,
0.7507616282,
-0.5217657685,
0.3786785007,
0.2878192961,
0.193224296,
0.2883507311,
0.2830316126,
0.4664210975,
-0.7373769879,
-0.3881716132,
-0.7491297722,
0.2718424201,
-0.1941639632,
-0.460049361,
0.5137799382,
0.5324184895,
1.0672360659,
-0.4636926651,
0.874812305,
-0.0779040381,
-0.4675700366,
-0.5940856338,
0.3202296793,
-0.3232771456,
-0.0966882184,
-0.2276169509,
-0.8379728198,
-0.8668841124,
0.5735124946,
-0.4171673954,
-0.3960134387,
1.0569194555,
0.5343295932,
0.3764141202,
-0.1502710432,
0.5798804164,
-0.2137336731,
-0.1714283228,
0.37327075,
0.9900787473,
-0.036939878,
0.7576832771,
-0.4123847783,
-0.1375291646,
0.0670620501,
-0.6697981954,
-1.1106255054,
-0.7823235393,
-0.4792601168,
-0.0430407859,
-0.2557773888,
0.4293497503,
0.4822644889,
-0.603700757,
-0.4064314067,
0.1138943508,
-0.0308069289,
-0.2116442621,
-0.1227897033,
0.2065913379,
-0.4281128347,
-0.5611377954,
-0.178896904,
0.2313755453,
0.1624312252,
-0.4158464968,
0.1709814072,
-0.0687649399,
-0.2333285809,
0.8046094179,
0.2100835294,
-0.947250545,
-0.3244954646,
0.1991766542,
-0.0319287106,
0.2178075761,
0.8466784358,
-0.570720017,
0.6323167086,
0.4630299211,
0.4466637671,
0.626142025,
-0.4844834507,
0.5249200463,
-0.7266589403,
0.6132760644,
-0.1126215011,
0.6254174113,
0.5089438558,
-0.0698596463,
0.7049145699,
0.1168070957,
0.0067628226,
-0.336561054,
0.550794661,
-1.0752153397,
-0.3956284821,
1.3244103193,
0.2834866643,
-0.2719869018,
0.1308659315,
-0.4853907526,
-0.0795535371,
-0.1540380567,
0.6557815671,
0.8958833814,
0.1736314297,
-0.6394754648,
-0.9466565251,
0.3019142151,
0.1648608446,
-0.5883682966,
-0.1319834441,
0.8955379128,
-0.1392803937,
0.6734510064,
0.163112253,
-0.2610760629,
0.1673413068,
-0.0180865675,
0.2897842228,
0.1913386732,
-0.2709533274,
-0.3118584752,
0.1744446009,
0.2760080695,
-0.2214208096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04790v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04790v1 | Massively Multilingual Language Models for Cross Lingual Fact Extraction from Low Resource Indian Languages | 2023-02-09T17:29:56 | 2023-02-09T17:29:56 | Bhavyajeet Singh, Pavan Kandru, Anubhav Sharma, Vasudeva Varma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Massive knowledge graphs like Wikidata attempt to capture world knowledge
about multiple entities. Recent approaches concentrate on automatically
enriching these KGs from text. However a lot of information present in the form
of natural text in low resource languages is often missed out. Cross Lingual
Information Extraction aims at extracting factual information in the form of
English triples from low resource Indian Language text. Despite its massive
potential, progress made on this task is lagging when compared to Monolingual
Information Extraction. In this paper, we propose the task of Cross Lingual
Fact Extraction(CLFE) from text and devise an end-to-end generative approach
for the same which achieves an overall F1 score of 77.46. | [
-0.5102196932,
-0.8822564483,
0.202631712,
0.3088005185,
-0.4042865634,
0.2209265083,
-0.3280097842,
-0.8317893147,
0.2710037231,
0.3172170818,
-0.3772979081,
-0.2433056831,
-0.6803814173,
0.3191500902,
-0.4598278701,
0.8976092339,
0.1372720003,
-0.146151498,
-0.3540538847,
-0.2324659079,
-0.3908872306,
-0.3893496096,
-0.4551579356,
-0.1675388217,
0.277279377,
0.7759357095,
0.6016607285,
0.3529950082,
0.173604697,
0.3098271191,
0.0383142531,
0.5225813389,
-0.4651192427,
0.0550294816,
-0.4478948414,
-0.3599099219,
-0.1186453104,
-0.114365913,
0.5805071592,
0.718310535,
0.1126302853,
0.1135782227,
0.0890449509,
0.4877334535,
-0.5573524833,
0.5765776634,
-0.4302767813,
0.0544713475,
-0.3602347076,
-0.2585979998,
-0.523806572,
-0.1819319874,
0.2535281479,
-0.7242779732,
0.206178084,
0.3380796611,
0.9150982499,
-0.0505125411,
-0.5950456858,
-0.5739361644,
-0.7021335959,
0.9295833111,
-0.4556564987,
0.6643164158,
0.2531337142,
0.0621397048,
0.2753289938,
-0.5299597979,
-0.7028580904,
-0.0728100762,
-0.5127702951,
-0.1831362396,
-0.0084536104,
-0.3533617258,
0.2619281709,
0.478153795,
-0.4449242651,
-0.093061313,
-0.5896317363,
-0.3073077202,
0.6982089877,
0.0290613975,
0.6966246963,
-0.5789025426,
-0.6114813685,
-0.0115726832,
-0.7035785913,
-0.1421784461,
0.0878882036,
0.3354050517,
-0.3920333683,
0.7325407267,
-0.3260273933,
0.7693006396,
0.0007784802,
-0.5049673915,
0.4065549374,
-0.5802140236,
-0.1022090465,
0.1665918976,
1.0365512371,
0.2363029569,
0.5203620195,
-0.3902242482,
0.0527458601,
-0.1941888034,
-0.4398784637,
-0.7508248687,
0.2012502253,
-0.1149614677,
-0.4252468646,
-0.0859960839,
-0.2921370566,
-1.3601642847,
-0.4199054837,
-0.3416330814,
0.03608758,
-0.5977165103,
-0.6148461699,
-0.2769081593,
-0.042948056,
0.4544292092,
0.0665315911,
-0.9508360028,
-0.0632161796,
0.4012982547,
0.9475594759,
-0.3903341293,
-0.3103253841,
-0.3618063033,
0.3586988747,
-0.1985041052,
0.7894333005,
-0.7588403225,
-0.6778361797,
-0.001103287,
0.0572498515,
-0.1224452034,
-0.2643185854,
0.6141095161,
-0.7077264786,
0.3900337815,
-0.4438706934,
-0.3207376897,
-0.3489017487,
0.3916529119,
-0.9617516994,
0.9965971708,
-0.0327881351,
-0.9876645207,
0.4211831391,
-0.7165485024,
-0.8488745689,
0.0838131234,
-0.1387078911,
0.1018132195,
-0.237741068,
0.4861819446,
0.3927073181,
-0.8900984526,
0.3015032411,
-0.3060238957,
0.1000459641,
-0.0782627314,
-0.649571836,
1.0128520727,
0.3314058185,
-0.2943896353,
-0.2692931294,
-0.9853674769,
0.0891679898,
0.0389160551,
-0.3848888278,
-0.729850471,
-0.2972236574,
0.1736620665,
0.5531279445,
0.3850651383,
-0.8135458231,
0.0005414365,
-0.4755775332,
0.1412619203,
0.4717977047,
0.0683040842,
0.4107619524,
0.0509017892,
0.4497110546,
0.058569584,
0.0113091599,
0.1433332115,
-0.6177864075,
-0.7920873761,
-0.3753802776,
0.5378759503,
0.6622448564,
-1.2276895046,
-0.0757325515,
-0.5092355609,
-0.395363003,
-0.3942662776,
0.5166725516,
0.5488532782,
0.4051061869,
0.2608071864,
-0.0193779115,
-0.5631370544,
-0.9281467199,
-0.1902376115,
-0.0173107162,
0.3566028178,
-0.085718073,
0.4710029066,
-0.1473113596,
1.1646639109,
-0.6302525997,
-0.2355539203,
-0.3807825148,
0.3963929117,
-0.0998613983,
0.2229322493,
0.4439319074,
-1.3478301764,
-0.9076992869,
0.5551481247,
-1.0140146017,
-0.0894943997,
0.1657810062,
-0.2513262928,
0.3988966942,
0.4559609294,
-0.8772468567,
0.2916820645,
0.4826855361,
-0.1274304241,
0.3664554656,
0.068802774,
0.2186982334,
-1.1005877256,
0.2508376241,
0.0091211135,
-0.3957750201,
-0.5650265813,
-0.0137808695,
-0.1110148653,
-0.0448871814,
-0.4478089511,
0.9078577757,
-0.7750967145,
-0.0335800424,
-0.1755353957,
0.3613345623,
0.0113831507,
0.6600967646,
0.1877281517,
0.6364019513,
0.2603807151,
-0.4857031405,
0.5472370386,
0.2453231066,
-0.3339759707,
0.4949439466,
-0.2327833772,
-0.28023085,
-0.0945194513,
-0.2511726916,
-0.7298460603,
-0.1633471996,
0.0977275074,
-0.3963413835,
0.3501114845,
0.0650920272,
-0.5050724745,
0.033573702,
-0.1229727715,
0.408097595,
0.2364121228,
-0.6249670386,
0.7022041678,
0.813364625,
-0.4639600217,
-0.7680143118,
-0.6519603729,
-0.0857376084,
0.0564861223,
-0.7006511688,
0.1008509323,
-0.0216063559,
-0.3182235062,
0.2766498029,
0.145232141,
-0.1976547688,
-0.3866500854,
0.0712318197,
0.3355435729,
-0.1714841574,
0.0969261602,
-0.0796414018,
-0.055719398,
0.0725038797,
0.011860366,
0.5292361975,
-0.1361704767,
-0.2261170298,
0.0291057751,
0.7956837416,
0.7531136274,
-0.3812506199,
0.7062520385,
0.798904717,
-0.6052618027,
-0.2341616452,
-0.4944337308,
0.2544326186,
-0.3471714556,
0.3032324016,
-0.4093072712,
-0.6004663706,
0.4337306321,
-0.0851271749,
-0.0057998216,
0.830553174,
0.6547630429,
0.3202038109,
0.8868796229,
0.9775378108,
-0.0795264691,
0.1442144066,
-0.1964712143,
0.474031508,
-0.306135565,
-0.5522001982,
-0.3850311935,
0.2126244158,
-0.6452347636,
-0.3595322371,
0.3647704124,
0.0827540532,
0.4099608064,
0.0631758645,
-0.1547127962,
0.3535765111,
0.4214010537,
-0.1102945283,
0.614869535,
0.3138030171,
-0.3722112179,
0.0556967631,
-0.736512959,
-0.0932454467,
0.9186748862,
-0.0225576106,
0.4848781824,
0.1904473901,
0.4470182955,
0.422912091,
0.634137094,
-0.6264469624,
0.5108377337,
-0.2285071313,
-0.9850178957,
-0.5193621516,
-0.4777218401,
-0.4833757877,
0.521227777,
-0.2858409286,
-0.3170002699,
0.336492151,
-0.1541679204,
-0.025520334,
0.2352479547,
-0.9359434247,
0.7430358529,
-0.219828397,
-0.4605850875,
-0.2135301232,
-0.5824922323,
0.7629623413,
-0.3658116758,
0.8108685017,
0.0353037193,
0.1152565107,
0.7811067104,
-0.6064497828,
0.9695404172,
-0.1422716826,
-0.2377871722,
0.5627808571,
-0.2164234072,
0.415261358,
0.0690841898,
-0.0174367465,
0.1889918,
-0.0020234778,
-0.4222034812,
-0.4315054417,
0.7702292204,
-0.6318657994,
-0.4365727901,
-0.4929417074,
-0.5623668432,
-0.4329368472,
0.3337857723,
0.2536532581,
0.5190769434,
-0.2160041332,
0.0813464671,
0.6132214665,
-0.1799265742,
0.7905076146,
0.4327024221,
-0.1726103425,
-0.4258502424,
1.1394869089,
0.1386234313,
0.2848043442,
0.6337631345,
0.0493537821,
-0.5709024072,
0.0417447574,
-0.8007811308,
0.3631606698,
-0.9405582547,
-0.2538269758,
-0.7331338525,
-0.2325445861,
-0.4309735894,
-0.0591522492,
-0.1076889485,
-0.4540351331,
-0.0337836854,
-0.1009503081,
0.3568113148,
0.7434352636,
-0.3103589714,
0.0612329729,
-1.0337508917,
0.4599869847,
0.2956161499,
0.1672172546,
0.1250391006,
-0.1298586428,
-0.448363483,
0.0145509653,
0.0424572937,
-0.8137485981,
0.4946967065,
0.2603179216,
0.6179264188,
0.331741184,
0.0309932735,
0.6715536714,
-0.2936908007,
0.6269610524,
0.5006023645,
-0.8780636191,
0.0865527615,
0.0846045464,
0.1841227114,
0.2261732817,
0.794213593,
-0.5950905681,
-0.0577739999,
-0.2756014466,
-0.7099483013,
0.6294128299,
-0.0997253805,
-0.1492078453,
-0.0184556656,
-0.0518605001,
0.3795686662,
0.0244608186,
-0.8842439055,
-0.1216020435,
-0.0886663422,
-0.2546251416,
0.016574543,
-0.3776654899,
-0.0499226302,
-0.1477867216,
0.7921597362,
-0.1596344858,
-0.206560418,
0.1965383887,
-0.5850018859,
-0.0530070625,
0.485571593,
0.4544088542,
0.7018791437,
0.1753652245,
0.0632480681,
0.3535176218,
-0.5552082658,
0.0389716625,
0.2555638254,
-0.2177164257,
0.1428239495,
0.6725183129,
0.5102233887,
0.3466530144,
-0.7834774852,
0.572886765,
0.0666538179,
0.0658902377,
-0.237020269,
-0.3169423938,
0.0626784936,
0.0835676044,
0.362382412,
-0.0781550258,
0.0866789445,
-0.5587131381,
0.1842394918,
0.4264751971,
-0.1549919546,
-0.2215815336,
0.50529176,
0.5649462342,
0.1481742114,
0.4167768359,
-0.3879092932,
-0.5577682853,
0.2636004686,
0.4942524731,
0.5738264918,
-0.1396644562,
0.2351035774,
0.4471645355,
0.298587501,
0.0859022066,
0.260471493,
-0.0812711492,
-0.5306406617,
-0.8965426683,
-1.0055985451,
-0.1573445946,
-0.0261977781,
-0.280862391,
0.4709151089,
-0.1951728463,
0.2993279099,
0.1065432876,
0.1402225345,
-0.6967515945,
0.4514866471,
0.2532305121,
0.8453857303,
-0.964266479,
0.9509600997,
0.3628129661,
-0.6109207273,
-0.6319832802,
-0.2133126408,
-0.0481547676,
-0.7952663302,
1.0109130144,
-0.0869045034,
-0.3070927262,
-0.2065961659,
-0.3450726271,
-0.9597200155,
0.8299589753,
0.2897561491,
-0.5680982471,
-0.3213374317,
0.5269254446,
0.4509422481,
-0.4476267099,
0.2164987177,
0.2781474292,
0.6359786987,
0.0658175349,
-0.8460165858,
0.1974131912,
-0.4069415331,
-0.2278172821,
0.192382291,
-0.7300073504,
0.9189329147,
-0.1613426507,
-0.4334315658,
-0.3167636991,
0.7470866442,
-0.0839867294,
0.2284220159,
0.7833223343,
0.4263741374,
0.6903951764,
0.2507923245,
1.0074453354,
-0.5345957279,
0.4201677442,
0.8041065931,
-0.2649343908,
0.6321325898,
0.4362534285,
0.0876054838,
0.5538365245,
0.4501299262,
0.3214842677,
0.5003196001,
-0.2900987864,
-0.2247357368,
-0.3215066195,
-0.2661887705,
-0.3924634457,
0.6680163741,
0.5784546733,
-0.2638305724,
-0.3847024441,
0.1695767045,
0.2369998544,
-0.2093268335,
-0.3085775375,
0.5207745433,
0.1171465665,
-0.8174258471,
0.6815924644,
0.0242305603,
0.6333156228,
-0.567692101,
-0.4128467441,
-0.1381196827,
-0.0858448222,
-0.3099617958,
-0.6022226214,
0.413959533,
0.2397712171,
-0.6470734477,
-0.1943879277,
0.9562439322,
-0.7933669686,
-0.5793682933,
0.5923153758,
0.6819213033,
-0.0067654857,
0.2796185911,
-0.3739389181,
-0.0498584434,
0.1929736137,
-0.1154242158,
0.114868395,
0.6904124022,
-0.2639231086,
0.4476332068,
0.7428008914,
-0.0244599786,
0.2998202145,
-0.2427057028,
0.7281965613,
-0.6453542709,
-0.5763137341,
-0.7777223587,
0.3525742292,
-0.5546287298,
-0.34308815,
0.6689988375,
0.6357911229,
0.8993128538,
-0.0895368233,
1.0577186346,
-0.6502659321,
0.5597261786,
-0.5280427933,
0.7641116381,
-0.6936144233,
0.1134791374,
0.0263923034,
-0.6989764571,
0.0901742801,
-0.0492648147,
-0.1983150095,
-0.248821646,
0.8917500377,
0.6858001351,
-0.2158980966,
0.384711802,
0.3850947917,
0.2867495716,
0.1222401708,
0.4575048983,
0.5840970278,
-0.155389905,
1.1152951717,
-0.3257639408,
-0.3505637944,
-0.1667506099,
-0.7473062277,
-0.7859575748,
-0.8327907324,
-0.0921482742,
-0.1276610196,
-0.2751733959,
0.6237505674,
0.7688171864,
-0.8064880371,
-0.0370085575,
0.3327105045,
0.4731112719,
0.113653183,
-0.2855012715,
0.475730747,
-0.3290609419,
-0.8886412382,
0.3373965919,
0.1702647656,
-0.3840275407,
-0.4577048719,
-0.0686946288,
-0.697914958,
-0.0202170312,
0.8833384514,
0.5029475689,
-0.4768453836,
-0.3414563835,
-0.1924259216,
-0.2726236582,
-0.0772039816,
0.7682273984,
-0.5790324211,
0.4096059203,
0.7106489539,
0.7385115027,
0.517077446,
-0.2554885745,
0.4603382945,
-0.8448206782,
0.2029610872,
-0.2493767589,
0.3986150324,
0.6407517195,
-0.4012807608,
0.5705397129,
0.6573612094,
-0.2186610103,
-0.6606122851,
0.1474934667,
-0.7759548426,
-0.2880615294,
1.2344876528,
-0.1007490754,
-0.5947075486,
-0.2297027111,
-0.0746602938,
0.385432303,
-0.0722024515,
0.4758117497,
0.9653390646,
0.017344581,
-0.077762261,
-0.6144453287,
0.4492488205,
0.1718328297,
-1.0278896093,
0.0265522264,
0.432885319,
0.4767611027,
0.6891348958,
0.6902120709,
-0.2656701505,
0.0806660876,
0.1854843348,
0.1602616757,
0.1124709472,
-0.3563529253,
0.1757131517,
0.6404583454,
-0.2784855068,
-0.1097881943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04761v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04761v1 | Toolformer: Language Models Can Teach Themselves to Use Tools | 2023-02-09T16:49:57 | 2023-02-09T16:49:57 | Timo Schick, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Roberto Dessì, Roberta Raileanu, Maria Lomeli, Luke Zettlemoyer, Nicola Cancedda, Thomas Scialom | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) exhibit remarkable abilities to solve new tasks from
just a few examples or textual instructions, especially at scale. They also,
paradoxically, struggle with basic functionality, such as arithmetic or factual
lookup, where much simpler and smaller models excel. In this paper, we show
that LMs can teach themselves to use external tools via simple APIs and achieve
the best of both worlds. We introduce Toolformer, a model trained to decide
which APIs to call, when to call them, what arguments to pass, and how to best
incorporate the results into future token prediction. This is done in a
self-supervised way, requiring nothing more than a handful of demonstrations
for each API. We incorporate a range of tools, including a calculator, a Q\&A
system, two different search engines, a translation system, and a calendar.
Toolformer achieves substantially improved zero-shot performance across a
variety of downstream tasks, often competitive with much larger models, without
sacrificing its core language modeling abilities. | [
-0.0420956947,
-0.3423022926,
0.6435032487,
0.1310100257,
-0.0302588735,
0.1482993215,
-0.1774331182,
-0.3065916002,
-0.0213311762,
0.5616297722,
-0.5710989237,
-0.353073597,
-0.4853113592,
-0.0135321766,
-0.4306060672,
0.854139626,
0.038608972,
0.2190032899,
-0.3732111156,
0.0068040602,
-0.6030813456,
-0.545238018,
-0.8486102819,
-0.4790455103,
0.5653195381,
0.3975609541,
0.72640872,
0.7148244381,
0.2210218906,
0.3602218926,
0.1818364561,
-0.2938967943,
-0.2888995111,
0.0662103221,
-0.1036580205,
-1.0894824266,
-0.1877248138,
-0.0094826752,
-0.0307567772,
0.7507840991,
0.0157482084,
0.5088426471,
-0.2539021373,
0.2270874828,
-0.294599086,
0.3388105035,
-0.7862425447,
-0.0445531718,
-0.0624139905,
0.1125620678,
-0.4956504405,
-0.2934918106,
-0.0427869596,
-0.5431525707,
0.2106689215,
0.0512250364,
0.453319788,
0.4486215413,
-0.3293331563,
-0.230243057,
-0.6881220937,
0.8002239466,
-0.7991913557,
0.5992822647,
0.4342968166,
0.6420457959,
-0.0397340991,
-0.9428232908,
-0.4403546751,
-0.2542104423,
-0.0580386929,
-0.1202241182,
-0.187380895,
-0.1192487478,
0.2770668864,
0.2325270623,
-0.4708667994,
0.360499233,
-0.6035171747,
-0.3402213156,
0.3228927553,
0.0447519124,
0.3521632552,
-0.2018290758,
0.0200074371,
-0.1435964853,
-0.7586188912,
0.3304417133,
0.2902799547,
0.698315084,
-0.0619615279,
0.5671123266,
0.1689923704,
0.5880755782,
0.1228570566,
-0.2544970214,
-0.0098842308,
0.1091991663,
-0.4316191971,
-0.003555038,
0.6997115016,
-0.1244644821,
-0.0220001657,
-0.3903432786,
-0.3298303485,
-0.0599461459,
0.3864379227,
-0.9194342494,
-0.3979113996,
0.4487851262,
-0.3423452079,
-0.3134600222,
-0.3907316625,
-0.1392164379,
-0.4302227795,
-0.6008783579,
0.6563668251,
-0.3048553467,
-0.2745217383,
-0.1125000119,
-0.196606487,
0.0579001233,
0.3611655533,
-0.7993678451,
0.5366125107,
0.7176151872,
1.1331270933,
0.0151490746,
-0.2527822554,
-1.0014336109,
-0.203535676,
-0.473990351,
0.8029637933,
-0.4691334367,
-0.4768771529,
-0.1350256503,
0.1857340932,
0.2282441854,
-0.3941492736,
0.2825099528,
-0.4386838377,
0.5040130019,
0.0724503621,
-0.6364563704,
-0.1609849781,
0.0010008126,
-0.8232111931,
1.3060160875,
0.2527208328,
-0.339188844,
0.453786552,
-0.8128406405,
-0.3107506335,
0.1973998696,
-0.1704011708,
-0.2022164613,
0.3839556873,
0.2031641603,
0.4119301438,
-0.0085332869,
0.1424102783,
-0.4265559316,
-0.3317340314,
-0.0216998272,
-0.2491614074,
0.7626972198,
0.161177814,
-0.2822027504,
0.4617221355,
-0.7242926955,
0.0670117512,
0.0988710225,
-0.2142331749,
-0.3985103965,
-0.1151903719,
0.1509521753,
0.4671869576,
0.141888082,
-0.6257947683,
0.2692928314,
-0.8835448027,
0.4899230003,
0.796056807,
-0.5705378652,
0.7065408826,
-0.2306780815,
0.7522457242,
-0.1143924743,
0.1807678193,
-0.3802947402,
-0.4442980587,
-0.9200363159,
0.1037264243,
0.3797806799,
0.4457164407,
-0.7244116068,
0.2195273042,
-0.1455684453,
-0.9471614957,
-0.8385426998,
0.5632953048,
0.1508829892,
0.3728902936,
0.1797542125,
-0.2747338414,
-0.6113423109,
-0.5673038363,
-0.268221736,
-0.3427216411,
-0.1715273857,
0.0716157779,
0.3360415995,
0.1302512586,
1.0827693939,
-0.2352094501,
-0.0938530117,
-0.5479955673,
0.1325930804,
0.4483471811,
0.3279101253,
0.5040521622,
-0.6330847144,
-0.4074160755,
-0.0742972866,
-0.4079677165,
-0.2160942554,
-0.1255341321,
0.0379052386,
0.3248104751,
0.5599170923,
-0.4319211841,
0.2453058958,
0.6900674105,
-0.2396803647,
0.542763412,
-0.2747870684,
-0.502710104,
-1.0544142723,
0.0398514383,
-0.157328397,
-0.6698886156,
-0.5299116373,
-0.0643938035,
0.1898088306,
-0.3891052902,
-0.6959426999,
1.0797079802,
-0.3490777612,
-0.0499529019,
-0.5432933569,
-0.0249525215,
-0.0549762174,
0.270347476,
-0.0114650223,
1.0801327229,
0.6551312208,
-0.45518291,
0.3618466556,
0.0405434482,
-0.1569860578,
0.2236465365,
-0.8072575331,
0.2814242542,
-0.0942655429,
-0.0651604533,
-0.8436686993,
-0.0237527322,
-0.1079225913,
-0.4237708151,
0.1789133251,
-0.5772902369,
-0.6781995893,
-0.581464529,
-0.2844911814,
-0.1817354858,
0.5828309655,
-0.7121744752,
0.9541913867,
0.3655290902,
-0.2536781728,
-0.5099271536,
-0.6090998054,
0.0763454512,
-0.0454474017,
-0.1324027628,
-0.0993321016,
-0.283176899,
-0.0280893892,
0.0737914965,
-0.1420149356,
-0.0751862004,
0.2528444827,
0.7078130841,
0.3441235125,
-0.2884762585,
0.6288805008,
-0.1091531366,
-0.1766060293,
0.1072857603,
-0.4587436914,
0.7082887888,
-0.1560925692,
-0.7846612334,
-0.3457502723,
0.0071223658,
0.5110672116,
-0.2630397379,
0.6579182148,
0.6670141816,
-0.2314753979,
-0.1702958792,
-0.6818068624,
-0.3008119166,
-0.5583719611,
0.2936732769,
-0.4911186099,
-0.8231177926,
0.3793021142,
-0.2216708362,
0.4247331917,
0.2332666069,
0.6635549664,
0.1985870004,
1.2676993608,
1.1176826954,
-0.2498324215,
0.6822153926,
-0.2282317877,
0.404093653,
-0.3764323592,
-0.0616110265,
-0.3890878856,
-0.1290788502,
-0.4469586909,
-0.4512326121,
0.1288568079,
0.1456664205,
-0.2951140702,
0.5588609576,
-0.4009942114,
0.6854465604,
1.0261291265,
-0.2702071071,
0.1551312953,
-0.0814524889,
-0.2195932716,
-0.0675474629,
-0.8097932339,
-0.8596668243,
1.3937078714,
0.4784310162,
0.8661492467,
-0.002430554,
0.8593375087,
0.0128692118,
0.7372552752,
-1.2198210955,
0.3193045855,
-0.1399351656,
-0.5761367679,
-0.2353192866,
-0.1584194601,
-0.7180526853,
0.2122801989,
-0.0114147961,
-0.6425400972,
-0.0966469869,
0.2233953625,
-0.4405202568,
0.4199559689,
-1.0701469183,
0.9343379736,
-0.5307959914,
-0.2635308802,
0.099358961,
-0.3675864935,
0.0557785705,
-0.1081149355,
0.5608205795,
-0.0642548725,
-0.1083606258,
0.5544818044,
-0.4091756642,
1.305701375,
-0.1869624555,
-0.1638825387,
0.0593037009,
0.5501012802,
0.2853182554,
-0.1020387411,
-0.1645911634,
-0.1326578408,
0.429466188,
-0.2827883363,
-0.8608925939,
0.6604344845,
-0.7507758737,
-0.6310103536,
-0.1128277034,
-0.4656274915,
-0.0566875823,
0.5314347744,
-0.230699122,
0.6727884412,
-0.0544916764,
-0.0855062902,
0.1791327447,
-0.0382994451,
0.6032740474,
0.6020440459,
-0.69376719,
-0.0853424743,
0.8418107629,
0.0223537255,
0.2997798324,
0.1317811012,
0.3773290515,
-0.5292942524,
-0.1924200505,
-0.7018293738,
0.2118670642,
-0.9959471226,
-0.3254834712,
-0.5442807078,
-0.0586396307,
-0.4582814574,
-0.1666919291,
-0.5529729128,
-0.6440570354,
-0.1052201167,
-0.2151575834,
0.4068094492,
0.9028457999,
-0.0732847378,
0.5922088027,
-0.7489676476,
-0.1705565602,
0.4581028521,
0.5613226295,
-0.0670796856,
-0.3840785027,
-0.1104402468,
-0.1572046131,
-0.3652773798,
-0.6370288134,
0.471455127,
0.2236323357,
0.5710708499,
0.341812402,
-0.0906147584,
0.6093209386,
-0.6891804934,
0.8093771935,
0.0454615057,
-1.1311738491,
0.7414526343,
0.1060894281,
0.331899792,
0.311049968,
0.464012593,
-0.7909272909,
-0.615640223,
-0.5213784575,
-0.6406251192,
0.8116369843,
-0.0365319364,
0.5396238565,
0.1252050549,
0.2348738015,
0.4530480206,
0.1876720637,
-1.077152729,
-0.2022313774,
-0.4387435317,
-0.4846273661,
-0.1111931279,
0.1436260492,
-0.1196233183,
-0.2283869386,
0.5818544626,
-0.4466302395,
0.0910506994,
-0.161746949,
-0.3556001484,
-0.1815362722,
0.4033213258,
0.1731888652,
0.8242439628,
-0.0242784005,
0.3860128224,
0.3454279006,
-0.1914430708,
0.0513497256,
0.0986127928,
0.0672249645,
0.1343303621,
0.3825321794,
0.8324540854,
0.4934459329,
-1.0021268129,
0.6079586148,
-0.1310639977,
0.0296542868,
-0.3504680991,
0.1338060796,
0.4379168749,
0.3105552495,
0.1147227809,
-0.0497174188,
0.0850732028,
-0.5235402584,
0.0332094915,
0.3440638781,
-0.6620163321,
-0.4767887592,
0.6983717084,
0.1281311959,
-0.621301353,
0.0973392427,
-0.2120735347,
-0.6233427525,
0.4097429514,
0.7645349503,
0.6681792736,
-0.1559929401,
0.2510620952,
0.1087263525,
0.2328945696,
-0.1162191555,
0.2691623271,
-0.0749490857,
-0.5130509138,
-0.670345962,
-0.625334084,
-0.4890342355,
0.332909435,
-0.3763313591,
0.4279339314,
-0.4622195065,
-0.162710011,
0.1995282769,
-0.1129748598,
-0.9871929884,
-0.0226666983,
0.1654358953,
1.141141057,
-0.8290945888,
0.7931270003,
1.0342568159,
-0.629976809,
-1.0078239441,
-0.5323386192,
0.2501198351,
-1.035589695,
1.013780117,
0.3586501777,
-0.2658236921,
0.0854798034,
-0.5106035471,
-0.7718797922,
0.860951364,
0.4790652096,
-0.5582747459,
-0.2248580009,
0.1011334062,
0.5225684643,
-0.1836955845,
0.5764480829,
0.3186451197,
0.0470081866,
0.1232529804,
-1.3507987261,
-0.104353033,
-0.1827574819,
-0.0727674738,
0.1598437428,
-0.207856074,
0.8328270316,
-0.280315876,
-0.2374534309,
-0.116581209,
0.3661792278,
-0.0923905745,
0.0902735814,
0.5381296873,
0.3619712889,
0.5935609937,
0.0931860656,
1.0401685238,
-0.4363066852,
0.2253074944,
1.3485921621,
-0.0185364373,
1.162370801,
0.5643783808,
-0.1820153594,
0.6226401329,
0.4956428707,
0.085973382,
0.2487153858,
0.0259665493,
-0.0179895293,
-0.5238153934,
-0.0498847216,
0.0462942757,
0.6194809079,
0.156263575,
-0.1409542412,
-0.5116418004,
0.199899286,
0.0808997229,
0.2380578369,
-0.3025547862,
0.9446527958,
0.1659791321,
-0.3754133582,
0.1692457348,
-0.0446371064,
0.7269909382,
-0.5517838001,
-0.0132945795,
-0.0083851721,
0.2815561891,
0.1121535823,
-0.7081209421,
0.2339715809,
-0.1155028492,
0.0003393466,
-0.3575880229,
0.8261471391,
-0.3475552201,
-0.8526090384,
0.3108300269,
0.8839076757,
0.1551548839,
-0.1578028202,
-0.6885008812,
-0.2183030844,
-0.5264184475,
0.0290952232,
0.1608289182,
0.4308781624,
-0.034446355,
1.1182963848,
0.8567103148,
0.4628881812,
0.1368418783,
0.3777833879,
0.8829792142,
-0.456537962,
-0.5291228294,
-0.8644421101,
0.2945942879,
-0.2064481974,
-0.0453971028,
0.7593258023,
0.7129879594,
1.0944318771,
-0.182922855,
0.9080625772,
0.0929803923,
0.7822646499,
-0.2533470094,
0.6344979405,
-0.5509916544,
0.1650962383,
0.186123237,
-0.5745409131,
-0.3254811168,
0.5086661577,
-0.6348505616,
-0.0903655589,
0.3754157126,
0.6774198413,
-0.3390962183,
-0.1360553503,
0.3195088804,
-0.1469387561,
0.6128938198,
0.1375523061,
0.703605473,
-0.2195453644,
0.7199997902,
-0.4785504639,
-0.0344148949,
-0.1571982354,
-0.8417610526,
-1.2949073315,
-0.5651750565,
0.061446391,
0.0937248841,
-0.2383731455,
1.3498464823,
1.096983552,
-0.8679990768,
-0.4728092551,
0.0268057324,
0.1791721582,
0.0443018377,
-0.2011278868,
0.1568451077,
-0.928491652,
-0.809763968,
0.3627285659,
0.2874770463,
0.191534698,
-0.4995981455,
0.1613400877,
0.3444368541,
0.031215094,
0.7183455825,
0.2713121474,
-1.0748716593,
-0.3502628803,
0.1351787746,
0.0467901528,
-0.064871043,
1.010199666,
-1.2247869968,
0.7255930901,
0.0671170279,
0.6710087657,
0.2539294064,
-0.342458427,
0.7106817365,
-0.8156926036,
0.2998296916,
0.0987362415,
0.3581597805,
0.4553011656,
-0.2629190385,
0.2508799732,
-0.1344025135,
-0.3447535038,
-0.9323133826,
0.2003812939,
-0.5369231701,
-0.3812528551,
0.7587744594,
0.0040524672,
-0.3405903578,
-0.3710586429,
-0.5171611905,
0.24933891,
-0.3092404902,
0.8530884385,
0.5926830173,
-0.036795117,
-0.4117161036,
-0.8341447711,
0.6041442156,
0.2474906445,
-0.7565965056,
0.1228572205,
0.1102557927,
0.7331810594,
0.2396067083,
0.6267858744,
0.1709943116,
0.0784053802,
-0.081949614,
0.1341959089,
-0.3889112175,
-0.1200729981,
-0.4005540013,
-0.0815188885,
0.609688282,
-0.0307534263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04725v1 | Lightweight Transformers for Clinical Natural Language Processing | 2023-02-09T16:07:31 | 2023-02-09T16:07:31 | Omid Rohanian, Mohammadmahdi Nouriborji, Hannah Jauncey, Samaneh Kouchaki, ISARIC Clinical Characterisation Group, Lei Clifton, Laura Merson, David A. Clifton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | Specialised pre-trained language models are becoming more frequent in NLP
since they can potentially outperform models trained on generic texts. BioBERT
and BioClinicalBERT are two examples of such models that have shown promise in
medical NLP tasks. Many of these models are overparametrised and
resource-intensive, but thanks to techniques like Knowledge Distillation (KD),
it is possible to create smaller versions that perform almost as well as their
larger counterparts. In this work, we specifically focus on development of
compact language models for processing clinical texts (i.e. progress notes,
discharge summaries etc). We developed a number of efficient lightweight
clinical transformers using knowledge distillation and continual learning, with
the number of parameters ranging from 15 million to 65 million. These models
performed comparably to larger models such as BioBERT and ClinicalBioBERT and
significantly outperformed other compact models trained on general or
biomedical data. Our extensive evaluation was done across several standard
datasets and covered a wide range of clinical text-mining tasks, including
Natural Language Inference, Relation Extraction, Named Entity Recognition, and
Sequence Classification. To our knowledge, this is the first comprehensive
study specifically focused on creating efficient and compact transformers for
clinical NLP tasks. The models and code used in this study can be found on our
Huggingface profile at https://huggingface.co/nlpie and Github page at
https://github.com/nlpie-research/Lightweight-Clinical-Transformers,
respectively, promoting reproducibility of our results. | [
-0.0910122991,
-0.52026999,
0.8994774818,
0.2546775937,
-0.2158620656,
-0.0722329095,
-0.4431395233,
-0.5240010619,
0.1807728261,
0.5441868305,
-0.2908495367,
-0.5897318721,
-1.0141590834,
0.2521628737,
-0.5598682761,
1.2640498877,
0.0107524628,
0.1688947678,
-0.4150857031,
-0.6343458295,
-0.2371946871,
-0.3594048917,
-0.4054107666,
-0.5026140809,
0.419876188,
0.2583510876,
0.7881008983,
0.530849874,
0.7357444763,
0.3397584558,
-0.2824344635,
-0.0740437508,
-0.2820942402,
0.3245664239,
-0.0531278327,
-0.4347153306,
-0.6841831207,
-0.1668596566,
0.3625697792,
1.1161103249,
-0.3879288137,
0.1701404154,
0.0579067059,
0.8034612536,
-0.4627427459,
0.1654076725,
-0.5148864985,
0.107544966,
-0.0969039947,
-0.1310982108,
-0.5720764995,
-0.2618978918,
0.3717336357,
-0.3243398964,
0.6781230569,
-0.2349133044,
0.5404337645,
0.4659343958,
-0.0897610933,
-0.6793051958,
-0.7219996452,
0.7760932446,
-0.8456590176,
0.3703500032,
0.3683774173,
0.4502789974,
0.082566686,
-1.3907781839,
-0.2677682638,
-0.3863095641,
-0.5343334079,
0.0986799523,
-0.3697375357,
0.3133436143,
0.2923583686,
0.4891033769,
-0.600256443,
0.0546860099,
-0.5028354526,
-0.1153816134,
0.3526863754,
0.2258734107,
0.2544115484,
-0.2496570945,
-0.2244686186,
0.0120401904,
-0.2175178081,
-0.3389575779,
-0.2506264746,
0.1028710231,
-0.1359875947,
0.6132015586,
-0.2305357456,
0.6766828299,
0.0607722774,
-0.5890771151,
0.2797682285,
-0.472548753,
-0.1743743122,
0.2721999288,
1.0604952574,
0.1864733845,
0.1111440808,
-0.3038172424,
-0.2279195189,
0.1562986523,
0.629952848,
-1.0444369316,
-0.604742825,
0.3586515188,
-0.7648326755,
-0.3942116797,
-0.5121517777,
-0.6803402305,
-0.4845431149,
-0.3240817487,
0.2116513401,
-0.6407109499,
-0.0103020668,
0.4481517971,
-0.1726083457,
-0.3047716916,
0.3629864454,
-0.9785581827,
0.6098727584,
0.2802889347,
0.956161201,
-0.1459857523,
0.2339938283,
-0.5401299,
-0.1052436158,
0.2078402936,
0.6921502948,
-0.1361716986,
-0.3841707706,
-0.0715174675,
0.0054124696,
-0.1221245974,
-0.7238259912,
0.9299762249,
-0.146050483,
0.0470318235,
0.0978258625,
-0.4779345095,
0.2025647908,
0.1109753475,
-0.8815148473,
0.7157088518,
0.3892301619,
-1.0026019812,
0.2946048677,
-0.3859728575,
-0.6715992689,
0.2080914527,
-0.183583349,
-0.5910868049,
0.2743363678,
0.3296895921,
0.7511909604,
-0.4524300396,
0.451277107,
-0.1260358393,
-0.1324078292,
-0.0148611935,
-0.2245169878,
0.589166224,
0.2364061028,
-0.1707914174,
0.1301791519,
-0.8005967736,
-0.2564526498,
0.0792487785,
-0.0931045264,
-0.4623926282,
-0.1547838897,
0.3079944551,
0.0795241743,
0.239425987,
-0.5785399675,
0.1229865551,
-0.3318781555,
0.5401558876,
0.0537569635,
-0.1438565105,
0.5932248831,
-0.317012161,
0.5626215935,
-0.0637413263,
0.307253778,
-0.0555764064,
-0.4180653989,
-0.5546503067,
-0.4962685704,
0.3519171178,
0.3672162294,
-0.821547091,
0.3696732819,
-0.2931693792,
-0.8006160855,
-0.7640205622,
0.2816583216,
0.2719290853,
0.917668581,
0.6687235236,
-0.2006813735,
-0.5070900321,
-0.9066846371,
-0.0378232822,
-0.1548175216,
-0.2451487631,
0.0430332981,
0.3320453167,
-0.6706524491,
0.9393763542,
-0.7581294179,
-0.5580488443,
-0.6414589882,
0.2791421115,
0.3426222801,
0.4030513763,
0.7199662924,
-0.8593062758,
-0.3746225834,
-0.0333816521,
-0.8133409619,
-0.3071689308,
-0.1292699575,
0.2529937625,
-0.0669574589,
0.7172262073,
-0.7227561474,
0.2564848363,
0.6638715267,
-0.0588959791,
0.412207216,
-0.386969924,
-0.1191758439,
-1.0770596266,
0.3875748515,
0.0593957715,
-0.7361735702,
-0.725951612,
-0.1733573377,
0.1266311407,
-0.0151131647,
-0.4620975256,
0.4611906707,
-0.2481338531,
0.4608264863,
-0.2649432421,
0.2822329104,
0.1561721563,
0.2897815108,
0.2781472802,
0.3073948622,
0.3159913123,
-0.4535558522,
0.2362797409,
0.4655273557,
-0.1485542059,
0.3289861381,
-1.0483342409,
-0.2601090074,
-0.2496656477,
0.1919219345,
-0.871186018,
-0.1611109823,
-0.0886414945,
-0.288949281,
0.5349155068,
-0.2536602318,
-0.6536493897,
-0.2551355958,
-0.1468586475,
0.3110269606,
0.8250496387,
-0.2738597393,
0.5047258139,
0.4856104851,
-0.462169677,
-0.2504369915,
-0.638252914,
-0.2251555026,
-0.1598279029,
-0.4150354564,
0.5861882567,
0.0298049375,
-0.1107451096,
0.0620471276,
-0.1660989076,
-0.3177521229,
-0.0058999276,
0.2021039575,
0.2742217481,
-0.1435166746,
0.3891740143,
0.2736449242,
-0.3183738589,
-0.0194381066,
-0.0210003871,
0.4717567265,
-0.169991672,
-0.1290951222,
-0.3347075582,
0.1697848439,
0.6696252823,
0.0621138848,
0.9735680819,
0.9870109558,
-0.4897243679,
-0.015338609,
-0.4783676267,
-0.2647688985,
-0.4528391957,
0.2372553945,
0.1307540238,
-0.9470555186,
0.4168087244,
-0.1931492388,
0.0787687004,
0.6600771546,
0.7037965059,
-0.0469901524,
0.9709441066,
0.7430403829,
0.1045359746,
0.0954654813,
-0.1148811579,
-0.0382485017,
-0.6003864408,
0.0019170801,
-0.5428596139,
-0.1838301867,
-0.532962501,
-0.3529547155,
0.5760514736,
0.1424930245,
0.4396940172,
0.6156547666,
-0.7069379687,
-0.0334654041,
0.1198876947,
0.1058906764,
0.4503629804,
-0.3838409781,
-0.162558943,
-0.210504204,
-0.8368707895,
-0.5803202987,
1.1475750208,
0.4440925717,
0.8228001595,
-0.1500281692,
0.6586925387,
0.1210589409,
0.6375316381,
-0.782366395,
0.3082265258,
-0.4682587683,
-0.3265151978,
-0.0408732891,
-0.4664245546,
-0.9733376503,
-0.0054718363,
-0.48193416,
-0.5074709058,
-0.085822247,
0.1144295633,
-0.5328131914,
0.1386318803,
-0.6736124754,
0.9235675335,
0.0340612382,
-0.1568949223,
-0.0854735225,
-0.8730435371,
0.4212830663,
-0.282771498,
-0.0784643218,
0.0653882325,
0.1123295501,
0.6971445084,
-0.6337176561,
0.7401266098,
-0.0801526234,
0.0182605032,
0.1997528821,
-0.1280767024,
0.1429537684,
0.3645537496,
0.0298496429,
0.2611894906,
0.4709261358,
-0.2844325006,
-0.5201695561,
0.4678846002,
-0.3526973724,
-0.180361405,
-0.369368434,
-0.4118139148,
-0.1307415515,
0.2063486278,
0.3800046146,
0.7187954783,
-0.2118617147,
0.4826625884,
0.7602582574,
-0.4252227843,
0.2211263925,
0.4657496512,
-0.0755672082,
-0.1377378106,
0.3519484997,
-0.1294012219,
0.3608564436,
0.554528594,
0.2814065218,
-0.3580748439,
-0.8669706583,
-0.3091884851,
0.327542752,
-0.6028940678,
-0.2668788135,
-1.1974008083,
-0.3378136456,
-0.5074524283,
-0.1589945704,
-0.677716732,
-0.5730772614,
-0.2906466722,
0.1769015342,
0.442350477,
0.6110028028,
0.2891242206,
0.4805949032,
-1.2406601906,
0.6761708856,
0.0104231546,
0.3021341562,
-0.2219085693,
-0.3135957718,
-0.3209653795,
-0.2989954054,
-0.3037897348,
-0.578932941,
0.6053325534,
0.1515740454,
0.3971230388,
0.3565588892,
0.3660804033,
0.6635079384,
-0.7097454071,
0.4619146585,
0.2176035494,
-0.6215833426,
0.5029652119,
-0.0811673999,
0.4941291213,
1.154728651,
0.5076572299,
-0.4719921649,
-0.5180729628,
-0.7842812538,
-0.8745716214,
0.4517253637,
0.4253230691,
-0.2109772265,
0.0023393885,
0.4295124412,
0.4532652795,
0.4060741961,
-0.3641869426,
-0.2868303359,
0.2626124024,
-0.6684751511,
-0.1298407763,
-0.1820632666,
-0.085593164,
-0.2333689332,
0.2727665603,
-0.3476998508,
0.1861930788,
0.5561679602,
-0.3320850134,
0.1596130729,
0.2392285466,
0.3899032474,
0.481682986,
-0.3512184024,
0.0831847787,
0.1085000038,
-0.8648232222,
-0.2177619487,
0.4263231158,
0.1190291643,
0.4713819623,
0.6562973261,
0.4749288857,
0.392921716,
-1.0426626205,
0.6382223368,
-0.5791602135,
-0.1228953972,
-0.4199933112,
-0.098177433,
0.174409017,
0.0362405702,
-0.1630879045,
0.5162745714,
0.4959646463,
-0.3426291049,
0.495719403,
0.1143537909,
-0.6057844758,
-0.4130701125,
0.8702213168,
0.114976503,
0.0522996038,
0.7318813205,
-0.1356867105,
-0.2887514532,
0.1738333702,
0.3036667407,
0.7629746795,
0.1013434008,
0.2207324207,
0.3005624115,
0.0637156367,
-0.2775691748,
-0.1552907825,
-0.3623552322,
-0.4296304286,
-0.5533722043,
-0.9135938287,
-0.4252508879,
-0.0405519009,
-0.915196836,
0.4409874678,
-0.3652345836,
-0.3113987446,
0.1815567017,
-0.1520605385,
-0.7625336647,
0.1367509961,
0.0073939757,
0.8684098721,
-0.730243206,
0.88826406,
0.6247531772,
-0.2393432558,
-0.5261451602,
-0.2013775408,
-0.0891589895,
-0.4785223305,
0.5401498079,
0.2631501555,
0.2330117375,
-0.3849187493,
-0.0442337319,
-0.332015425,
1.0499693155,
0.3365627229,
-0.7343367338,
-0.3159687221,
0.2020072043,
1.0110641718,
-0.0420066193,
0.4221567214,
0.7808158994,
0.0350253955,
0.0855457336,
-1.2253551483,
0.0660750046,
-0.2787853777,
-0.3867356181,
0.2641246915,
-0.2904914618,
0.6794016361,
-0.0804502219,
-0.0882826,
0.3109877706,
0.3558984101,
0.3142888844,
0.4066027701,
0.4989452958,
0.5525830984,
0.6057325006,
-0.0789972097,
1.0989910364,
-0.2902973592,
0.3292530775,
0.9920748472,
-0.3783617914,
0.4813872278,
0.5218987465,
-0.1090375483,
0.4508084953,
-0.0948469564,
0.2270960063,
0.3503641486,
-0.0803412944,
-0.3006969094,
-0.0424728245,
-0.1119479686,
-0.1860000789,
0.3456676602,
0.3715908527,
-0.6605193615,
-0.3073449731,
0.1027755737,
0.1348837316,
0.3046619296,
-0.0653415471,
0.8484996557,
0.4079297483,
-0.6160526276,
0.5401595235,
0.0085101333,
0.6064618826,
-0.8840065598,
-0.0133912871,
0.1156919897,
0.5226057172,
-0.1658933908,
-0.5283460021,
0.6088030934,
0.0544366203,
-0.1033257917,
-0.5777025819,
0.9284869432,
-0.3834217191,
-0.5278550386,
0.2866102159,
0.3881196082,
-0.0726990551,
0.0116787031,
-0.6127400398,
-0.1035948098,
-0.1363799572,
-0.1628652811,
0.423162967,
0.3923124373,
0.1180511713,
0.674367249,
0.3753536642,
0.3920658827,
-0.2051084787,
0.2175611109,
0.90876472,
-0.5254959464,
-0.3911965489,
-0.7647249103,
0.5177281499,
-0.1839512885,
-0.3055147231,
0.545358479,
0.3940344751,
0.3825310171,
-0.2094554603,
0.5436710119,
-0.1400254518,
0.6735255122,
-0.5804969668,
0.886689961,
-0.4367536604,
0.1334228516,
-0.4585388303,
-0.5832208991,
-0.4472565651,
0.3902264237,
0.0691902488,
-0.1106837168,
0.8409240842,
0.2626897991,
-0.042383153,
0.247579813,
0.200450182,
0.174200654,
0.4637562931,
0.5630323291,
0.2337228954,
-0.5392795205,
0.5281244516,
-0.5509482622,
-0.1543069482,
-0.1551202685,
-0.7392353415,
-0.9605436325,
-0.4628139734,
-0.4226386249,
-0.3112249076,
-0.3080533445,
0.7855675817,
0.7654334307,
-0.6711623669,
0.2856247127,
-0.2122181803,
-0.2319808006,
-0.2263454497,
-0.177375719,
0.4437501729,
-0.4904287755,
-0.6680785418,
0.285951823,
0.3286658227,
-0.0572266318,
-0.1913050562,
0.0648611337,
0.0648545697,
-0.3511025608,
0.6354777217,
0.0708981007,
-0.1287115216,
0.1597741842,
-0.0383081883,
-0.2550888062,
0.036178425,
0.9353322983,
-1.1057478189,
0.4982432127,
0.4588156641,
0.5615823865,
0.6115096807,
-0.0529551879,
0.5218017697,
-0.9051373005,
0.4795367122,
0.7219998837,
0.5401821136,
0.4102821052,
-0.1258157492,
0.4833742082,
0.1522303969,
-0.6902256012,
-0.7862069607,
0.0659231842,
-1.2537126541,
-0.1562658548,
0.9407452345,
-0.0050499379,
-0.0765080675,
-0.2058515549,
-0.3620320261,
0.3390495777,
-0.1079492271,
0.6293987632,
0.3205372095,
-0.2513962388,
0.0771370977,
-0.8005704284,
0.7038264275,
0.3636762798,
-0.6931197643,
-0.0527290627,
0.1493920088,
0.2295731455,
0.5050055981,
0.770919919,
-0.5428599119,
0.2130678147,
-0.0763937682,
0.0231594928,
0.2439632267,
-0.1644787788,
-0.2707042694,
0.2568300664,
0.0194217935,
0.2174763829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04716v1 | Improving the Generalizability of Collaborative Dialogue Analysis with Multi-Feature Embeddings | 2023-02-09T15:58:32 | 2023-02-09T15:58:32 | Ayesha Enayet, Gita Sukthankar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conflict prediction in communication is integral to the design of virtual
agents that support successful teamwork by providing timely assistance. The aim
of our research is to analyze discourse to predict collaboration success.
Unfortunately, resource scarcity is a problem that teamwork researchers
commonly face since it is hard to gather a large number of training examples.
To alleviate this problem, this paper introduces a multi-feature embedding
(MFeEmb) that improves the generalizability of conflict prediction models
trained on dialogue sequences. MFeEmb leverages textual, structural, and
semantic information from the dialogues by incorporating lexical, dialogue
acts, and sentiment features. The use of dialogue acts and sentiment features
reduces performance loss from natural distribution shifts caused mainly by
changes in vocabulary.
This paper demonstrates the performance of MFeEmb on domain adaptation
problems in which the model is trained on discourse from one task domain and
applied to predict team performance in a different domain. The generalizability
of MFeEmb is quantified using the similarity measure proposed by Bontonou et
al. (2021). Our results show that MFeEmb serves as an excellent domain-agnostic
representation for meta-pretraining a few-shot model on collaborative
multiparty dialogues. | [
-0.8583042026,
-0.5425083041,
0.572295785,
0.2759462595,
-0.1692764014,
0.541893065,
-0.0909466892,
-0.3407593966,
0.645447433,
0.6014171243,
-0.5796045661,
-0.4167969823,
-0.8014559746,
0.0577194057,
0.0247493666,
0.9578721523,
0.0043749548,
-0.0057194252,
-0.4677059054,
-0.6144305468,
-0.5278658271,
-0.7868877649,
-0.4125486016,
-0.3521885276,
0.349827677,
0.2560528815,
0.7696970701,
0.1480942369,
0.5204235911,
0.4572018981,
0.2025761008,
0.3118561208,
-0.51178509,
0.3353354037,
-0.1008612067,
-0.1602873653,
-0.5318183303,
0.1220369413,
0.5290172696,
0.5736328959,
-0.2472843826,
-0.1316324472,
0.4421443641,
0.0394393057,
-0.4431635141,
0.4404088259,
-0.7381876707,
0.0683552623,
0.2420950383,
-0.0339103602,
-0.3225618303,
-0.1222576275,
0.6055216193,
-0.7231882215,
0.1604271233,
0.2825042307,
0.6974282265,
0.3322798014,
-0.1501515508,
-0.1586874425,
-0.4997544885,
0.9606585503,
-0.3423041105,
0.1196397319,
0.1799742579,
0.2445771098,
-0.3542794287,
-0.3421977758,
-0.4049131274,
-0.047804378,
0.08364667,
0.3056591153,
-0.115593791,
0.4436352253,
-0.1479001641,
0.1496347785,
-0.2949703336,
-0.1408058256,
0.212376684,
-0.3751680255,
0.3371755779,
0.3008182347,
0.079924643,
-0.0224804841,
-0.3423887491,
0.0060630119,
-0.0165672842,
-0.0543797016,
-0.0530100018,
0.2061272413,
-0.2554572821,
0.0965462178,
0.1494280249,
0.1061788872,
-0.0259081069,
-0.1538150012,
0.4205393493,
-0.4766342044,
-0.1750075966,
-0.2869521081,
0.7951210141,
0.4514719844,
0.0157184564,
-0.0910830349,
0.2248350382,
-0.0421598777,
0.2798316777,
-0.8705270886,
-0.3349151909,
0.1128634736,
-0.4745094478,
-0.2042153776,
0.0447176136,
-0.772777319,
-0.380870223,
-0.1611025482,
0.1777229756,
-0.4730061889,
-0.4923720062,
-0.1520147026,
-0.1860695481,
-0.1508121639,
0.6405745745,
-0.443908453,
0.4004375935,
0.6140921712,
0.9113286138,
-0.0133033572,
-0.4633122981,
-0.5301332474,
0.1249746084,
-0.1748538613,
0.8175927401,
-0.8329777718,
-0.5613979101,
0.104113996,
-0.0274466984,
-0.3510696292,
-0.5153148174,
0.2744752765,
-0.0874868929,
0.1774202138,
-0.1283888072,
-0.440195322,
-0.2402846664,
0.3809134066,
-0.9170107245,
0.4611831307,
0.0532698594,
-0.5995431542,
0.3726270199,
-0.8532405496,
-0.0439971723,
-0.2054138929,
-0.3672609627,
-0.81688416,
0.0335259624,
0.1497633159,
0.4888851643,
-0.3249554038,
0.267889291,
-0.8281098008,
-0.1668031514,
0.2446355969,
0.0557667576,
0.221597746,
0.0897490457,
0.0917056501,
-0.0524492152,
-0.3266656697,
0.1058957726,
-0.0792491436,
-0.1187239438,
-0.3291376829,
0.0097340969,
-0.362414211,
0.2690360248,
-0.1560918391,
-0.4744388163,
0.2035020888,
-0.266728729,
0.0443412885,
0.6482778788,
0.1016557738,
0.5673984289,
-0.2674992383,
0.5564341545,
0.2864333689,
0.0479127876,
-0.2410061806,
-0.7723527551,
-0.5252751112,
-0.5954138637,
0.3142741919,
0.5556596518,
-1.0634863377,
0.3366229534,
-0.2046650499,
-0.2113955021,
-0.8835392594,
0.2584494948,
0.5875361562,
0.0349997543,
0.4080900848,
-0.7852836847,
-0.6808941364,
-0.6798613667,
-0.0243462995,
-0.1451514363,
0.0716236383,
0.580224812,
0.4038393795,
-0.2425339818,
0.9590674639,
-0.4541472197,
-0.5364711285,
-0.4817875624,
0.6892294288,
-0.0129689798,
0.4375867546,
0.5966539383,
-0.6763675213,
-0.5251181126,
-0.1179913655,
-0.7410667539,
0.0068086232,
-0.0432204641,
-0.2160508484,
-0.0139700221,
0.1601451635,
-0.2675729692,
0.3771253228,
0.7951068878,
-0.2391861528,
0.2111462951,
0.0706417263,
0.4074029326,
-1.3844227791,
-0.3854286075,
0.0003815006,
-0.1621089727,
-0.6331751943,
-0.3345700502,
-0.3282650411,
-0.2105472684,
-0.4137868285,
0.1949794143,
-0.343986541,
0.0562311895,
-0.2703762352,
0.2022316903,
0.1764507443,
0.6554998159,
0.0486259796,
0.6988261938,
0.1886097789,
-0.3918818831,
0.0804012641,
0.5112290382,
0.0288695861,
0.6168206334,
-0.2848570347,
0.3646843731,
0.0678823218,
0.324172169,
-0.8233667612,
-0.0212757085,
0.1986551881,
-0.5049926639,
0.2347677499,
-0.2447688878,
-0.1959857196,
-0.2312155366,
-0.5517114997,
0.2184782773,
-0.0547430627,
-0.1956734359,
0.844065547,
0.6295930147,
-0.2200655788,
-0.6942896843,
-0.4160547256,
0.0480027013,
-0.0600626916,
-0.8474314809,
0.548558414,
-0.1889538169,
0.0106402608,
0.2604841888,
0.1781069189,
-0.5590392947,
0.2915843725,
0.6313676238,
0.170973286,
-0.2447422147,
0.273150146,
-0.0531633049,
-0.2391420156,
-0.2073854357,
0.0712344646,
0.4585604966,
-0.241100505,
-0.1979760826,
-0.1731845438,
0.5881353021,
0.4224232733,
-0.1727549583,
0.9379799962,
0.8396693468,
-0.1906770915,
-0.1473875195,
-0.629916966,
-0.0795645267,
-0.4130368233,
0.5378706455,
-0.4250383675,
-1.3072397709,
0.6010654569,
-0.6188243628,
-0.0747967139,
0.2699121833,
0.3864511549,
-0.1627457589,
0.9563171268,
1.0175415277,
-0.3654341102,
0.4362221062,
-0.4365422428,
0.0463339202,
-0.8156626225,
-0.1180831194,
-0.4342143238,
-0.2324629575,
-0.5659728646,
-0.6636619568,
0.2706416249,
-0.1567353904,
0.119840242,
0.3131917417,
-0.3035472631,
0.4099715948,
0.2041663527,
-0.2533758581,
0.0249391142,
-0.1472464949,
-0.3898798823,
-0.3438070416,
-0.5624215007,
-0.3571990728,
1.0024427176,
0.343988955,
0.4748131037,
0.2386778444,
0.9843853712,
0.2852989137,
0.3461096585,
-0.7037481666,
0.3519883156,
-0.0580971241,
-0.4041805565,
-0.2497045398,
-0.3065995574,
-0.9592117667,
0.7060385942,
-0.6777133346,
-0.6630163193,
-0.012354238,
-0.1329813302,
-0.4904212058,
0.1730753332,
-0.7448366284,
0.736946702,
0.2444453537,
-0.2057641447,
-0.5089655519,
-0.2341759801,
0.1656962037,
-0.1657569259,
0.3815207481,
-0.3110622466,
0.1009298414,
0.6606407166,
-0.2625466585,
0.9016270638,
-0.1676272005,
0.3787135482,
0.4844273329,
0.0544651411,
0.2806918025,
0.0583198406,
-0.1363815069,
0.1267883033,
-0.2576959431,
-0.3084529042,
-0.6895974874,
0.5997614264,
-0.8484238386,
-0.7646247149,
-0.254037261,
-0.4795034826,
-0.3915765584,
-0.1529325098,
-0.0543374009,
0.2713287771,
-0.6962010264,
0.3502517045,
0.4819462597,
-0.1847495884,
0.5847926736,
0.2579016984,
-0.1124014407,
-0.7005592585,
0.9367854595,
0.2636605799,
0.1461359859,
0.1220899224,
-0.0141144609,
-0.0120768975,
-0.4630857408,
-0.1341987103,
0.0321619958,
-0.4762239754,
-0.4148248732,
-0.6966618896,
-0.121015422,
-0.1387573481,
-0.118525058,
-0.4014798403,
-0.3182904422,
-0.3163333535,
-0.077498652,
0.0538398549,
0.7210790515,
0.0559127554,
0.4284365773,
-1.0016144514,
-0.0442272127,
0.2327201068,
0.3513293564,
-0.1530974954,
-0.2933962643,
-0.6009004712,
-0.2404114902,
-0.9827151895,
-0.7540584803,
0.3672962785,
0.4889346659,
0.7124284506,
0.3274691403,
0.0155802425,
0.6506887674,
-0.3866148889,
0.8118478656,
0.3836670816,
-1.0205048323,
0.4265348911,
-0.102890715,
-0.0794631988,
0.4530733526,
0.3907061815,
-0.1342255473,
-0.5913247466,
-0.7741017342,
-0.389459461,
0.6669753194,
0.3769254684,
0.2078842521,
0.1407463849,
-0.1220248193,
0.1134996787,
0.4324049354,
-0.3590544164,
-0.1414016187,
-0.2990593612,
-0.0970411897,
-0.0031988143,
-0.2406786829,
-0.2563546002,
-0.1671014577,
0.323076874,
-0.3398035765,
0.7283643484,
0.056471739,
-0.1088689044,
-0.0314523168,
0.2930923402,
0.4410954714,
0.3354096115,
-0.2131793797,
-0.0208188631,
0.5969722867,
-0.2445682138,
0.2197997272,
0.0016458803,
0.6063357592,
0.2118502855,
0.4796903133,
0.6586683393,
0.3523829281,
-0.1102117449,
0.8122912645,
-0.0892974958,
-0.458583504,
-0.0655824766,
-0.0067224908,
0.0794469938,
0.5989955664,
0.0726125687,
0.2213839293,
0.4163539112,
-0.5723071098,
0.4829216897,
0.473351866,
-0.34633255,
-0.3105857968,
0.2059202194,
0.6151515841,
-0.0891453773,
0.1131768376,
-0.4610560834,
-0.7637497783,
0.5921244025,
0.2448614389,
1.0088200569,
-0.5413800478,
0.4206508994,
0.1536164135,
0.0746159554,
0.2473712713,
0.0193540249,
0.3353568316,
-0.9629217982,
-0.5335659385,
-0.2434720695,
-0.8909151554,
-0.0496333241,
-0.3089293838,
0.1264285445,
-0.7337241173,
-0.6766593456,
0.119914189,
0.2013558596,
-0.8827326894,
-0.062659502,
0.1929722875,
0.2364035547,
-0.6640200615,
0.9230951071,
0.4496211112,
-0.3793208301,
-0.4808545113,
-0.1165913865,
0.2954501212,
-0.6016275883,
0.3093929887,
0.316914469,
-0.1462692767,
-0.4127735198,
-0.4837672412,
-0.8612494469,
1.171267271,
0.47162655,
-0.3298123479,
0.2394205481,
0.1133291647,
0.4541709721,
-1.0100485086,
0.4453312159,
0.2361631095,
0.2192103565,
0.1527207494,
-1.0919144154,
0.0381886587,
-0.1171284467,
0.10641101,
0.1327762753,
-0.7578055263,
0.7942627668,
-0.2217756212,
-0.0886633098,
-0.0906357318,
0.6853569746,
-0.0739220455,
0.4683743715,
0.5329961181,
0.5509642959,
0.851326704,
-0.232985124,
0.7642224431,
-0.0591238439,
0.5062270164,
1.1806502342,
-0.2115117013,
0.6721878648,
0.28189978,
-0.0532009043,
0.8408620358,
0.1413203776,
-0.1294965148,
0.6370578408,
0.0984045118,
-0.1580634564,
-0.4642206728,
-0.4665792286,
-0.314153403,
0.5193654299,
0.4654095471,
-0.5912539959,
-0.0307011139,
0.051578898,
0.0775077268,
0.0215338208,
0.0260663778,
1.0672757626,
0.278582871,
-0.419514358,
0.5149741769,
-0.2952836156,
0.623120904,
-0.2195091546,
-0.3229923248,
0.1696960181,
0.0987955704,
-0.123994194,
-0.8210095167,
0.296051234,
-0.5314639807,
-0.1295799762,
0.0723633543,
0.7437334657,
-0.4806835055,
-0.0898942724,
0.8634536266,
0.8643878102,
-0.1374615729,
-0.2332961708,
-0.9095532298,
0.2660918534,
0.1094147414,
-0.0714602545,
0.5163004398,
0.4904430807,
0.2366539538,
0.6336280107,
0.3371366858,
-0.324115485,
-0.2980001867,
0.1385490894,
1.1554424763,
-0.5585912466,
-0.2933330834,
-0.7059237957,
0.7165991664,
-0.3885755837,
-0.0812187195,
0.2690711319,
0.2121478766,
0.4938943386,
0.0436425805,
0.937312901,
0.2537541687,
0.4331505597,
-0.2365378737,
0.4840478897,
-0.2170225531,
-0.0121150017,
-0.6508846879,
-0.8446666002,
-0.2324895412,
0.5079872012,
-0.0964557976,
-0.1345390528,
0.7798017859,
0.5679720044,
0.0110679008,
0.1440665871,
0.6023548245,
-0.0449420437,
0.5051359534,
0.7327085733,
0.8276946545,
-0.1929946244,
0.8667771816,
-0.250751704,
-0.3208624423,
-0.3729120493,
-0.8875322938,
-1.2156426907,
-0.6679708958,
-0.4621113241,
-0.3612862229,
-0.0418699123,
1.174683094,
0.7600006461,
-0.7806268334,
-0.10639254,
0.4798775017,
0.2685415149,
0.0165526494,
-0.1424157619,
-0.0898752436,
-0.4499893785,
-0.5233370066,
0.21817635,
0.2562376261,
0.1072421446,
-0.0031734079,
-0.3997336328,
-0.1620254815,
0.1974855661,
0.6489700675,
-0.0266868975,
-0.7363305092,
-0.6344973445,
-0.1771670878,
0.035080079,
0.2584936619,
0.6830106378,
-0.4632929564,
0.5968190432,
0.1862992346,
0.8489130735,
0.3193018138,
-0.0706930831,
0.8416888714,
-0.8792104125,
0.2414412051,
0.1820403486,
0.51411587,
0.2623330057,
-0.1568022817,
0.6589149833,
0.3794396222,
-0.5017886758,
-0.3880023956,
-0.0687680021,
-0.7827364206,
-0.0245341621,
0.6814829707,
-0.7007805705,
0.0910053253,
-0.3811600804,
-0.3746291697,
0.4090182483,
-0.8759570122,
0.7047784925,
1.0698126554,
-0.0909085199,
-0.2313787937,
-0.3059394658,
0.6266184449,
0.4365273118,
-0.6662399769,
-0.197619319,
0.2509407997,
-0.0495672561,
0.6596845984,
0.5555485487,
0.3115139008,
0.1943389773,
0.0269230213,
0.0648318082,
-0.0589078031,
-0.4572564065,
-0.0427570753,
0.3551889956,
0.2027441561,
-0.4595924616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04700v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04700v1 | Augmenting NLP data to counter Annotation Artifacts for NLI Tasks | 2023-02-09T15:34:53 | 2023-02-09T15:34:53 | Armaan Singh Bhullar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | In this paper, we explore Annotation Artifacts - the phenomena wherein large
pre-trained NLP models achieve high performance on benchmark datasets but do
not actually "solve" the underlying task and instead rely on some dataset
artifacts (same across train, validation, and test sets) to figure out the
right answer. We explore this phenomenon on the well-known Natural Language
Inference task by first using contrast and adversarial examples to understand
limitations to the model's performance and show one of the biases arising from
annotation artifacts (the way training data was constructed by the annotators).
We then propose a data augmentation technique to fix this bias and measure its
effectiveness. | [
-0.7104324698,
-0.8956498504,
0.2001680881,
0.0931199417,
-0.0787967518,
0.0411598496,
-0.0329451896,
-0.9161276817,
0.3026469052,
0.7726053596,
-0.6971078515,
-0.0802288204,
-0.7427638173,
0.1385197788,
-0.4355024993,
1.1738942862,
0.1274396777,
0.165306136,
-0.4568737745,
-0.2686437368,
-0.5498152375,
-0.5900301933,
-0.6318494081,
-0.5330659151,
0.0192735381,
-0.1144707501,
0.922935605,
0.6318463683,
0.4908506572,
0.257705301,
-0.1595136374,
0.4771293402,
-0.1888981611,
0.0289035961,
-0.0650088489,
-0.664170146,
-0.4691262841,
0.1711503565,
0.5071851015,
0.9763631821,
0.3791944087,
0.1636891514,
0.1965565681,
0.4250025451,
-0.6696057916,
-0.0263977498,
-0.6044241786,
0.2155200392,
-0.3158787489,
-0.237300545,
-0.2624135017,
-0.0510461368,
0.2590282559,
-0.9464864135,
0.3217810988,
0.1289247125,
0.8953077793,
0.8125947714,
-0.0619209707,
-0.2069435865,
-0.7490649819,
0.9200009704,
-0.9175490141,
-0.0083851274,
0.5655465126,
-0.0414360352,
-0.2117314935,
-0.6951878667,
-0.6984727383,
-0.2293610275,
-0.3768232465,
0.0525505058,
0.0781039372,
0.006408745,
0.7879631519,
0.5928180814,
-0.4548507631,
0.2774183452,
-0.1235376745,
-0.0504367836,
0.7183753848,
0.0609557591,
0.3418468535,
0.0043819761,
-0.3774800599,
-0.0160733983,
-0.5845336914,
-0.2635647953,
0.3328611255,
0.1622050107,
0.3001802564,
0.5587357283,
-0.2661661208,
0.8268799782,
-0.0705142096,
0.3251922429,
0.5868378878,
-0.3604661822,
-0.2772942781,
-0.0114586903,
0.4624730945,
0.120347932,
0.4209952652,
-0.3411855102,
-0.1642794758,
0.1966873854,
0.5234636664,
-0.443023771,
-0.3878307939,
0.3723672628,
-0.2346444726,
-0.337362498,
-0.0546892434,
-0.7035323977,
-0.6595233679,
-0.5532109141,
0.6916062236,
-0.1994866729,
-0.1796471626,
-0.0571311787,
-0.2453356385,
-0.2330127358,
0.0752653107,
-0.6861785054,
0.3236988783,
0.6812589169,
0.6363530159,
-0.0126909502,
-0.5360527635,
-0.5806343555,
-0.1776841879,
-0.4823382199,
0.7097404599,
-0.4910202026,
-0.1927880943,
-0.003824031,
-0.0089065246,
0.0587544739,
-0.6346842051,
0.7584580183,
-0.3120798767,
0.2427011728,
-0.3669020236,
-0.6952382922,
-0.1952300668,
0.2687318623,
-1.0046395063,
1.343606472,
-0.0409885794,
-1.02039814,
0.7530905604,
-0.9753567576,
-0.4922737181,
0.256505698,
0.0765058026,
-0.3862518072,
0.1406430751,
0.5778162479,
0.3191280067,
-0.0740193948,
0.1346824914,
-0.2426798493,
-0.6857801676,
0.2847243547,
-0.2645985782,
0.80524683,
-0.0997392014,
-0.5057681203,
0.0956423208,
-0.8378810883,
-0.1404272914,
0.0592270233,
-0.1084885448,
-0.6976505518,
0.093328543,
0.0113954237,
0.2048503011,
0.1213407889,
-0.5623573065,
0.1734886318,
-0.5815083385,
0.0578881949,
0.5234077573,
-0.1084887385,
0.2732720673,
-0.5149415731,
0.1048725247,
-0.0090495376,
0.1027536541,
-0.1816482097,
-0.664142251,
-0.9764793515,
-0.0416650921,
0.4251597822,
0.5437543988,
-1.0814633369,
0.5580217242,
-0.4779392779,
-0.4239747226,
-0.8465682864,
0.1908040792,
0.2144284695,
0.6132836342,
0.7882803679,
-0.4547245502,
-0.7877213955,
-0.8759362698,
-0.249224022,
-0.0193054881,
-0.4230629206,
0.0629381016,
0.5661084056,
-0.0877110958,
0.9095700383,
-0.314516753,
-0.3983588517,
0.1093611568,
0.7794778347,
0.088083446,
0.7649998665,
0.4075525105,
-0.806278348,
0.1631965935,
-0.271941185,
-0.825850904,
-0.4026162028,
-0.5528439283,
0.0717919841,
0.1783232242,
0.6442236304,
-0.4146735966,
0.5291903615,
0.4836145043,
-0.2536692917,
0.4679742455,
-0.0941993818,
0.2381460369,
-0.7121629119,
0.2674511075,
-0.0399323218,
-0.0762950256,
-0.9243090749,
0.161144346,
-0.2250282913,
0.2774271667,
-0.0323485695,
0.4134717882,
-0.246232301,
-0.0701472759,
-0.5791187286,
0.0940687656,
0.3089166284,
0.3367371261,
0.3418619037,
0.7616227865,
0.3088072836,
-0.6017916799,
0.2502468228,
0.4145374,
-0.2753842771,
0.6133399606,
-0.6410278678,
0.1514015198,
-0.1467260867,
0.1758213937,
-0.8659604192,
-0.0500928722,
0.2279162407,
-0.3266219497,
0.1981009543,
-0.0633139685,
-0.5193850398,
-0.2925515473,
-0.2818843126,
0.2693189085,
0.2698560059,
-0.8147113919,
0.637530148,
0.1766670197,
0.1321119517,
-0.7940331697,
-1.1488279104,
0.4066052437,
-0.2361192405,
-0.3790149987,
0.4429156482,
0.0025035047,
-0.2002205104,
-0.032534793,
0.1840017885,
-0.1545034796,
0.3135516047,
0.4607160687,
0.2292216718,
-0.2187452167,
0.3427538574,
-0.1634909064,
-0.1008481756,
0.1736782193,
-0.1427160949,
0.4337200522,
0.2284284979,
-0.6235231161,
-0.2826875746,
0.2488184273,
0.3158076406,
-0.3284199536,
0.8066003323,
0.8975468278,
-0.518740952,
0.0292133335,
-0.9291089773,
-0.2684151232,
-0.3751813471,
0.3772368431,
-0.3367312849,
-0.4815879166,
0.5315890908,
-0.0503130294,
0.3416692019,
0.5514693856,
0.0229808409,
0.0334066562,
0.899461925,
0.1394175887,
-0.2074310333,
0.394349426,
-0.2312540859,
0.2129592001,
-0.9727706909,
0.1469997764,
-0.486392349,
-0.3610219955,
-0.4905453026,
-0.3818075061,
-0.0663933754,
0.2188183814,
-0.0577413552,
0.1271639913,
-0.5590218902,
0.2350610793,
0.8072376251,
0.2401703894,
0.2691974044,
-0.2813943624,
0.4152935743,
-0.1614660472,
-0.6475037932,
-0.3812729716,
1.1041299105,
0.2824480832,
0.2557837963,
-0.2367891073,
0.4126147926,
0.3605158627,
0.3506569564,
-0.3549386561,
0.3519342244,
-0.2057653368,
-0.6618921757,
-0.2724765837,
-0.1694362015,
-0.7276902199,
0.0604547672,
-0.8201303482,
-0.6646755934,
0.2772598267,
0.1522654891,
-0.1217847839,
0.3350680172,
-0.6051592231,
0.7005138397,
0.0098336479,
-0.391800493,
0.1624336541,
-0.531339407,
0.3290933073,
-0.1381654292,
0.097641699,
0.2139507383,
0.0912266448,
0.8666809201,
-0.2742168009,
0.7272714376,
-0.2994876802,
0.2022422999,
0.221268639,
-0.1976300031,
0.7303013802,
-0.0861128345,
-0.1322058141,
0.3032456636,
-0.3009298444,
-0.6753992438,
-0.7145550847,
0.4023590982,
-0.3271640539,
-0.4759237468,
-0.1968930364,
-0.6102643609,
-0.2122716606,
-0.0438013189,
0.3059221804,
0.4029254317,
-0.0611545406,
-0.0509289876,
0.5536406636,
-0.1046947315,
0.5229780674,
0.0678460076,
0.0085727861,
-0.0940544978,
0.8085559011,
0.1750227213,
0.1562775671,
0.0752984658,
-0.1056479588,
-0.1978116035,
-0.986436069,
-0.5693343878,
-0.2020691782,
-0.6686599851,
0.0821733028,
-0.5837219954,
-0.240066573,
-0.2141284943,
0.0560214072,
-0.2618010044,
-0.5106460452,
-0.2205528915,
-0.193030417,
0.4275350273,
0.6934525967,
0.0101336902,
0.3534834981,
-0.5796875358,
0.2865300775,
0.1921929866,
0.1936290115,
0.0073267031,
-0.385550946,
-0.3164873421,
0.2075112462,
0.0404697768,
-0.5007786751,
0.2629200518,
0.1461463571,
0.4682874382,
0.2060298622,
0.096253857,
0.7651441693,
-0.2459339797,
1.0771708488,
-0.3153283894,
-0.9960130453,
0.4208737016,
-0.0600778386,
0.4447184503,
0.6025922298,
0.1667986065,
-0.2586276531,
-0.6359071136,
-0.6977747679,
-1.0930280685,
0.3323159218,
0.3882006109,
0.1284521371,
-0.0393354669,
0.4634036422,
-0.0346355066,
0.1886950731,
-0.7255892158,
-0.3246643245,
-0.3201331794,
-0.1361121833,
-0.0855488405,
-0.2526963353,
-0.1206917912,
0.0388643257,
0.823379159,
-0.145658046,
-0.0420358665,
0.390897274,
-0.3927975893,
0.0989560932,
0.025739193,
0.5176238418,
0.702835083,
-0.1473117918,
0.1064229533,
0.6530374885,
-0.5966259837,
-0.2827348709,
0.4341955185,
-0.155059889,
0.0983034,
0.7500147223,
0.6465517879,
-0.006192266,
-0.531680584,
0.3542553782,
0.0545565039,
-0.0588169582,
-0.3811168671,
-0.0127734253,
-0.2315154821,
0.1717637181,
0.6153128147,
0.1273670942,
0.4526344538,
-0.1071060449,
0.3406108916,
0.5146083236,
-0.5636054873,
0.0299932342,
0.6268547773,
0.0601231605,
-0.2748944759,
0.5688897967,
-0.1074718162,
-0.5511672497,
0.4480185807,
0.2331979573,
0.5687768459,
-0.2950329483,
-0.0810424536,
0.3076512516,
0.5369582772,
-0.0591842867,
0.0073542623,
0.0116812875,
-0.6416413784,
-1.0443367958,
-0.3474141955,
-0.3060587049,
0.4199214876,
-0.7205681801,
0.1113451272,
-0.1363501251,
-0.0703637525,
0.2789742649,
-0.0073048598,
-0.6031733155,
0.6916792393,
0.0642205849,
0.7494857311,
-1.1755521297,
0.5274165869,
0.5296227336,
-0.4409321845,
-0.1796117574,
0.0274048205,
-0.1739186198,
-0.5151714087,
0.5868605375,
0.1736913323,
0.1749424934,
-0.2918668687,
-0.3419102728,
-0.4845975637,
0.5729219317,
-0.0070733186,
-0.2185724825,
0.1391987205,
0.4068904817,
0.6932132244,
-0.1895792186,
0.4436451495,
0.7261171341,
0.5218228698,
-0.3603164852,
-0.7926219702,
0.2231506705,
-0.5202904344,
-0.0917756334,
0.1915759444,
0.0347236283,
0.6586798429,
0.3100972176,
0.0917685851,
0.0693016127,
0.3974121511,
-0.0623738132,
0.4169692099,
0.7920876741,
0.8560143709,
0.6941928864,
-0.3767127395,
1.1251597404,
-0.0746084005,
0.1200067699,
1.4361581802,
-0.0459218137,
0.5873349309,
0.6318171024,
-0.0780573338,
0.1789782345,
0.5687752366,
-0.3226248324,
0.1558665782,
0.2224600315,
-0.3101578653,
-0.1131425202,
-0.5294792056,
-0.3306362033,
0.4618725777,
0.3166460991,
-0.4213043451,
0.1611164212,
0.0874888897,
-0.0339437053,
0.2000752687,
-0.1245118603,
0.9430553317,
-0.3045384884,
-0.6390247941,
0.3721133471,
-0.4667946994,
0.7862486839,
-0.2137235403,
-0.2915705442,
0.0356198773,
-0.0871761292,
-0.3684184551,
-0.6682679057,
0.6793047786,
-0.275999397,
-0.1360723227,
0.0908128247,
0.531065464,
-0.2633216977,
-0.4533573687,
0.209780097,
0.2806776166,
0.1313123405,
-0.2224140167,
-0.5176457763,
-0.2107515037,
-0.2233158201,
-0.3406767845,
0.1099391505,
0.1759708673,
0.050399702,
0.5230119228,
0.7215000391,
0.3269770145,
0.0600637794,
0.1596330702,
0.6883003116,
-0.2412782162,
-0.2963786423,
-0.9070530534,
0.6710804701,
-0.5780376196,
-0.3576640189,
0.5725533962,
0.4647599161,
0.8578225374,
0.0796355158,
0.8103582859,
0.2210676372,
0.7290512919,
-0.7154981494,
0.5558115244,
-0.3944016397,
0.3098521233,
-0.4351761937,
-0.7667520642,
-0.51135993,
0.5837535858,
-0.3778438866,
0.0123569155,
0.4986389577,
0.6535027623,
0.0350750275,
0.4195594788,
0.1498529911,
0.1411379427,
0.2046675533,
0.3562526107,
0.8238106966,
-0.6796579957,
0.226379931,
-0.4504615963,
-0.014339665,
0.0673629344,
-0.9318644404,
-0.9108946919,
-0.6282894015,
-0.5128701329,
-0.3753531873,
0.0773963332,
0.5918782353,
0.7000758052,
-0.9846208096,
0.2620007992,
-0.360383153,
0.0548555367,
-0.3752080202,
-0.2286443114,
0.4696724415,
-0.5101466775,
-0.940053463,
0.3121050596,
-0.1067416593,
0.2021134496,
-0.2441028953,
0.2301087528,
-0.4158497453,
0.0306492299,
0.2268864959,
0.0897012427,
-0.6619744897,
-0.4303319454,
-0.3307189047,
0.3618137538,
0.1414514929,
0.6557140946,
-0.872397244,
0.7177987695,
0.2540597916,
1.0001661777,
0.4370604157,
0.068019852,
0.5584666729,
-1.0130007267,
0.3586665988,
0.2253876179,
0.345928371,
0.5535339713,
-0.4529035687,
0.7512330413,
-0.0802364796,
-0.489081949,
-0.9572518468,
0.0939256996,
-0.5770354271,
-0.3525374532,
0.6385436058,
-0.3246774375,
0.1173220947,
-0.5524184704,
-0.1525716931,
0.3299094737,
0.1925727874,
0.9840611815,
0.881901145,
-0.0578525811,
-0.0051152492,
-0.8227504492,
0.8007791638,
0.7628182173,
-0.951798439,
0.017496869,
0.2496918142,
-0.1901463866,
0.760764122,
0.2043016255,
0.1368379593,
0.1159797236,
0.2357664257,
0.1286263317,
-0.2339970171,
0.0091965999,
-0.435855031,
0.0810840651,
0.1980296671,
-0.3407033682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04643v1 | A Novel Approach for Auto-Formulation of Optimization Problems | 2023-02-09T13:57:06 | 2023-02-09T13:57:06 | Yuting Ning, Jiayu Liu, Longhu Qin, Tong Xiao, Shangzi Xue, Zhenya Huang, Qi Liu, Enhong Chen, Jinze Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the Natural Language for Optimization (NL4Opt) NeurIPS 2022 competition,
competitors focus on improving the accessibility and usability of optimization
solvers, with the aim of subtask 1: recognizing the semantic entities that
correspond to the components of the optimization problem; subtask 2: generating
formulations for the optimization problem. In this paper, we present the
solution of our team. First, we treat subtask 1 as a named entity recognition
(NER) problem with the solution pipeline including pre-processing methods,
adversarial training, post-processing methods and ensemble learning. Besides,
we treat subtask 2 as a generation problem with the solution pipeline including
specially designed prompts, adversarial training, post-processing methods and
ensemble learning. Our proposed methods have achieved the F1-score of 0.931 in
subtask 1 and the accuracy of 0.867 in subtask 2, which won the fourth and
third places respectively in this competition. Our code is available at
https://github.com/bigdata-ustc/nl4opt. | [
-0.5648996234,
-0.5520303249,
0.4059435129,
0.3473414481,
-0.3184801936,
0.1397456378,
-0.1951507479,
-0.3919039369,
0.4150198102,
0.3923384249,
-1.0096483231,
-0.184083268,
-0.4240772128,
0.5802842975,
-0.1205053777,
0.9255050421,
-0.1855638176,
-0.2022314817,
-0.467817843,
0.2449580282,
-0.3617869616,
-0.1109329015,
-0.9513406754,
-0.2109175771,
0.1555924118,
0.2381433249,
0.3348178566,
0.4886566401,
0.506125927,
0.3620539904,
0.2048689127,
0.1793994009,
-0.1058364809,
0.0529978015,
-0.3156635761,
-0.1565500647,
-0.4467492104,
-0.0359542519,
0.4356506169,
0.4266267121,
-0.2019363791,
0.1147573814,
0.1806689054,
0.5692502856,
-0.6892356277,
0.348821491,
-0.7315800786,
0.4941772819,
-0.1227041781,
-0.5512855053,
-0.1652160883,
-0.0775910169,
0.381327033,
-1.2911812067,
0.2582143843,
0.0901146978,
1.0401021242,
1.0342624187,
0.062345732,
-0.5354189873,
-0.4591159523,
0.8651090264,
-0.7696986794,
0.1432027817,
0.0309341811,
0.2495304495,
-0.3995251358,
-0.5739091635,
-0.3751551509,
0.1061146334,
-0.0287139118,
0.3664165735,
-0.4455683827,
-0.0059620733,
0.1259243935,
-0.056895189,
-0.6679803729,
0.2025245577,
-0.080756709,
-0.3817703426,
0.741294384,
0.2068241239,
0.0956511497,
-0.191131562,
-0.5559922457,
0.3603154123,
-0.4088072181,
-0.2733931839,
0.3511893153,
0.1490128636,
0.0615950897,
0.3506279588,
-0.4909430444,
0.4816711545,
0.2845100164,
-0.1104307696,
0.488627255,
-0.5531551838,
-0.1606227756,
-0.2224611938,
0.7287759781,
0.1542508155,
0.1829530299,
-0.2725544572,
-0.3327689767,
-0.1870300919,
0.4985572994,
-0.4280005395,
-0.4564482868,
0.1242358983,
-0.0535786413,
-0.322380513,
-0.3010019958,
-1.0400561094,
0.187041074,
-0.7007313967,
0.6046171784,
-0.1131149307,
-0.1969109774,
-0.0801156908,
0.030645499,
0.3361722231,
0.2368874401,
-0.9787238836,
0.5872705579,
0.5988183022,
0.5623781681,
-0.2614760101,
-0.1890866905,
-0.3204831779,
0.0970074087,
-0.5325008631,
0.788657546,
-0.0645863339,
-0.175719589,
-0.3346368074,
-0.3651279211,
-0.1184325591,
-0.5362388492,
0.2708299458,
-0.4347211421,
0.1482988298,
-0.2020073533,
-0.5218517184,
-0.0601645,
0.251609534,
-0.6246877313,
1.1047055721,
0.2102778256,
-0.7435891628,
0.5543750525,
-1.0798932314,
-0.2902494073,
0.6369464993,
-0.2106582671,
-0.5952832699,
0.1371177882,
0.305362314,
0.1843667328,
-0.2771955431,
0.1603101194,
0.1584765613,
0.1416088939,
-0.3775318563,
0.0240454637,
0.5763397217,
0.185800299,
-0.6209202409,
0.0650697798,
-0.3532057405,
0.410290271,
0.4032138884,
-0.247857675,
0.0285734944,
-0.1868917793,
-0.2351747453,
0.1679673046,
0.644939661,
-0.4014948308,
0.1717814803,
-0.5262798667,
0.6157971025,
0.7433296442,
0.1539001018,
0.4702518582,
0.4145871103,
0.923363328,
-0.4122779071,
0.3844712675,
0.3081848025,
-0.4458609521,
-0.8623902202,
0.0916066691,
0.6157365441,
0.6500951052,
-0.8670400977,
0.5335276723,
-0.0169312116,
-0.3077729344,
0.0305973161,
0.0506891347,
0.499186784,
0.6453300714,
0.4650842249,
0.0668084398,
-0.9373252392,
-1.3013253212,
-0.1445254534,
0.0942446217,
0.2648139,
0.3763713539,
0.9410600662,
-0.2230471671,
0.9679140449,
-0.638664484,
-0.4022550285,
-0.2968980372,
0.3271060884,
-0.1073016077,
0.5923551917,
0.4775709212,
-0.9251075983,
-0.5653364062,
-0.1600878686,
-0.7162823081,
-0.1719469726,
0.1337737143,
-0.4202260375,
0.4561194479,
0.5531358123,
-0.4760794044,
0.3036630452,
0.3041453063,
0.1918638647,
0.6555575132,
-0.1501564831,
-0.3656700552,
-1.1189552546,
-0.0003981629,
-0.0827402696,
-0.1242443621,
-0.0137698837,
0.2518965006,
-0.4008595347,
-0.2314578146,
-0.3086141944,
0.4388318956,
-0.511521101,
-0.1115480214,
-0.1882458776,
0.0266096666,
-0.0786337331,
0.583427012,
0.1028884798,
0.6653912663,
0.5333563089,
-0.5087805986,
0.5644993782,
0.1352384239,
-0.0573559962,
0.3972310424,
-0.773470521,
0.3328483403,
-0.1840431094,
0.2926347554,
-0.7570958734,
-0.5569052696,
0.4181424677,
-0.4231188297,
0.1921736002,
-0.0414581373,
-0.5164319277,
-0.4839152992,
0.0588673204,
0.3369427621,
0.3571046293,
-0.2518062294,
0.7219060063,
0.581915915,
-0.2802371979,
-0.5896556377,
-0.3999720514,
0.0884307772,
-0.3314478993,
-0.3725298643,
0.7003465295,
0.0783901066,
0.3487809896,
0.2477469146,
-0.2404037416,
-0.1109442264,
0.0986344218,
-0.108720988,
0.0635127276,
0.0322574601,
-0.1411036402,
0.1588101238,
-0.9740296602,
0.0565016717,
-0.6438034773,
0.5531517863,
-0.2440609485,
0.1086049154,
-0.5522599816,
0.5814942122,
0.0145160696,
-0.4932880998,
0.1939209849,
0.4533409178,
-0.7475306392,
-0.4675472677,
-0.2182151973,
-0.14558357,
-0.4848216176,
0.4073784053,
-0.5902812481,
-0.3896795809,
0.0705417022,
-0.2925747633,
0.2344250977,
0.5979386568,
0.7022232413,
0.0028414433,
1.1589018106,
0.6646606922,
0.0781444833,
0.1560739875,
-0.6071996093,
0.4916466177,
-0.9387274384,
-0.5601417422,
-0.4506140053,
-0.5445362926,
-0.4624783993,
-0.2429060042,
0.6634531617,
0.0821178183,
0.108299993,
0.8137871027,
-0.9075588584,
0.6226437688,
0.8049501777,
-0.3938776851,
0.0527471155,
0.0016265761,
-0.5452962518,
-0.4828693569,
-0.7319625616,
-0.360930711,
0.8339397907,
0.0113967312,
0.2864849269,
-0.0526042767,
1.2192964554,
0.0686554238,
-0.0368425213,
-0.6827437878,
0.7248119712,
-0.0883723944,
-0.7344591022,
-0.3368423879,
-0.4027331471,
-0.9118121862,
-0.0762243122,
-0.0085000191,
-0.6857064962,
0.0024427194,
0.2717811167,
-0.6707267761,
-0.2108260393,
-0.6677232385,
1.2349076271,
-0.3697629273,
-0.0883881152,
0.1265378296,
-0.6495258212,
-0.1377925724,
-0.0794293731,
0.1888700128,
-0.1201401204,
-0.4312423468,
0.907715857,
-0.3902383447,
0.20722197,
-0.2620567381,
0.1196907237,
0.2095486671,
-0.1834023148,
0.5673640966,
0.3246592581,
-0.0606068186,
-0.2322158217,
-0.2883237302,
-0.2848637402,
-0.800752461,
0.6213547587,
-0.3213412464,
-0.2207304835,
-0.4682425857,
-0.3398824036,
0.043693617,
0.4881192446,
0.7855756283,
0.371675998,
0.0689010546,
-0.0893354118,
0.2143082172,
-0.0026367081,
0.6089516878,
0.4130839407,
0.0625815764,
-0.4610922337,
1.1452146769,
0.0999099687,
-0.0028324611,
0.4882660806,
0.2661110163,
-0.6027449369,
-0.932272017,
-0.5696024895,
-0.0710795596,
-0.4381515086,
-0.3693420589,
-0.680588007,
-0.0686456263,
-0.3778500557,
-0.2341779619,
-0.7254943848,
-0.2378342897,
-0.1230279133,
0.0314685293,
-0.1027605608,
0.4071284533,
-0.3753707111,
-0.1159179062,
-0.1466886848,
0.3586151302,
0.2454826236,
0.0306491703,
-0.3730636537,
0.0803564861,
-0.3553089201,
-0.1278748959,
-0.2614380717,
-0.5797600746,
0.5535020828,
0.2759833336,
0.5963338017,
-0.0070424117,
0.0405766182,
0.6578170061,
-0.4818791151,
0.459258765,
-0.1114553064,
-0.8979016542,
0.8612172008,
-0.2186339796,
0.1279827356,
0.929392755,
0.5199885964,
0.1198533848,
-0.1996901482,
-0.8184420466,
-1.1844632626,
0.5414885879,
0.7282948494,
-0.0315870754,
0.0805500671,
0.514672935,
0.0333891585,
0.5485905409,
-0.6852974892,
-0.1815465689,
-0.2624183893,
-0.1217228472,
0.2419354171,
0.1472236663,
0.0410932228,
-0.3247659802,
1.0368311405,
-0.2811907232,
0.4597370625,
0.1557011455,
0.1612666398,
0.0711130872,
-0.035243962,
0.4021787345,
0.4543288946,
0.0933559909,
-0.2227694988,
-0.0453036427,
-0.2435350418,
-0.0264345016,
0.38750121,
-0.4445384145,
-0.0447309725,
0.4254941344,
0.5587440133,
0.279109776,
-0.502461493,
0.2176995873,
0.1273027062,
-0.3427081704,
-0.6942102313,
-0.0077904705,
0.0093471883,
0.1151764318,
0.3575019836,
0.2512534857,
0.6355294585,
-0.0369784236,
0.2261579335,
0.6086376309,
0.0048716753,
-0.1541628689,
0.8077688217,
0.3379621208,
-0.4737900794,
0.5111860037,
-0.9310389161,
-1.016461134,
0.759914577,
0.5456206799,
1.01108706,
0.0069912686,
0.1400454789,
0.6294407845,
0.2250456661,
0.2099086642,
0.1977171749,
-0.0337470397,
-0.5899552107,
-0.4661014676,
-0.7905663848,
-0.414786607,
0.1766795218,
-0.5838117003,
0.3372213542,
-0.4973011911,
-0.1544971168,
0.5108559132,
0.4223358631,
-0.7176309824,
0.4078625143,
0.0042942665,
0.3340286911,
-0.3904859424,
0.3165653944,
0.8730382323,
-0.3076422811,
-1.0638533831,
-0.0614402778,
0.2050043941,
-0.4882461429,
0.5616958141,
-0.0296978317,
-0.0400149934,
0.4644750357,
-0.3286674321,
-1.1783542633,
0.7282653451,
0.377969712,
-0.312899828,
-0.5754165649,
-0.0396212116,
0.298240006,
-0.5612663627,
-0.0568751656,
0.4637621939,
0.618052125,
-0.122269243,
-1.1193089485,
-0.1459597349,
-0.5339394212,
-0.0474470258,
0.5512729287,
-0.462546587,
0.7787742019,
-0.2111980766,
-0.1044558361,
0.2783621252,
0.4896506071,
0.0010049583,
0.1755787283,
0.5237548947,
0.9979031086,
0.3891987503,
-0.1087062061,
0.9542882442,
-0.0699266046,
0.7344574332,
1.2151429653,
0.0193057954,
0.5552514791,
0.4569175541,
-0.3767375648,
0.5317668319,
0.5485442877,
-0.1538455188,
0.8127231002,
0.3273406625,
-0.1274422556,
-0.3123471439,
-0.0541460514,
-0.3844635785,
0.6861376166,
0.2935266197,
-0.0831487551,
-0.6008375883,
-0.0662017241,
-0.1312706918,
-0.0185207464,
0.235999912,
0.937867105,
-0.0033567147,
-0.873410821,
0.5306731462,
0.1957591623,
0.5111144185,
-0.4560848176,
-0.1514004916,
0.1730948091,
0.0353411622,
-0.2954081595,
-0.3285549283,
0.6458418369,
-0.2449623495,
-0.0704676807,
-0.1410404593,
0.5268362761,
-0.0726821572,
-0.6183953285,
0.1128556803,
0.1969772726,
0.2046910524,
-0.0820560306,
-0.988180995,
-0.2119333893,
-0.0956445411,
-0.0371444412,
-0.1372815073,
0.2512290776,
0.1009484082,
0.5122474432,
0.5872373581,
-0.4207000136,
0.1853162348,
-0.1341325045,
0.5358998179,
-0.3106644452,
-0.7161775231,
-0.7734262347,
0.3305083215,
-0.1822094172,
-0.7463718057,
0.6485429406,
0.9006381631,
0.8293528557,
-0.0526583716,
0.7730517983,
-0.3349226117,
0.521797657,
-0.5724443793,
0.1107186675,
-0.7475705743,
-0.0299135707,
-0.584212482,
-1.0271670818,
-0.1895935684,
0.9008709192,
-0.2974303067,
0.061099492,
0.6942434311,
0.4587036371,
0.0673435256,
0.0940254629,
-0.2844615877,
-0.0299917478,
0.1322840154,
1.0335857868,
0.4413040578,
-0.4558705688,
0.4310162663,
-0.6914995313,
-0.1537711173,
-0.2536131442,
-1.016019702,
-0.4085902274,
-0.5693953037,
-0.5958160162,
0.0450820923,
0.0681027174,
0.9610410333,
0.940833509,
-0.5480880141,
0.2592282593,
-0.8294672966,
-0.0322687589,
-0.2854895592,
-0.3006354868,
0.2372845262,
-0.4991638362,
-1.0349215269,
0.4665731788,
0.3454997241,
-0.0800581947,
-0.3165386915,
-0.0957592055,
-0.0767167509,
-0.173740238,
0.3947256505,
0.2489957809,
-0.7008523345,
0.0719750971,
0.1026385725,
0.290648222,
-0.0160548016,
0.8182886839,
-0.9341894388,
0.3044179976,
0.3585409224,
0.6721392274,
0.4980854094,
0.0052697165,
0.6139238477,
-0.6657270789,
0.1560940295,
0.7198646069,
0.1305163503,
0.2040513456,
-0.4178615212,
0.80889678,
0.3062758744,
-0.4075274169,
-0.6769848466,
0.5205683708,
-1.0358018875,
0.0917137042,
0.6714601517,
0.0685120821,
-0.0711965561,
-0.2961619496,
0.0116177378,
0.1596229374,
-0.4750414491,
0.4901775718,
0.5313965678,
-0.6008051634,
-0.0175026525,
-0.8678107858,
0.765237689,
0.7227763534,
-1.0496094227,
-0.4604967237,
0.1550930589,
0.2975430191,
0.5019800663,
0.6188084483,
-0.1207527071,
0.2979218364,
0.0241412465,
-0.2768454254,
-0.1549100429,
-0.5281385779,
0.3383762836,
0.0984074026,
-0.3533181846,
-0.3122431338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04618v1 | Robust Question Answering against Distribution Shifts with Test-Time Adaptation: An Empirical Study | 2023-02-09T13:10:53 | 2023-02-09T13:10:53 | Hai Ye, Yuyang Ding, Juntao Li, Hwee Tou Ng | cs.CL | cs.CL | A deployed question answering (QA) model can easily fail when the test data
has a distribution shift compared to the training data. Robustness tuning (RT)
methods have been widely studied to enhance model robustness against
distribution shifts before model deployment. However, can we improve a model
after deployment? To answer this question, we evaluate test-time adaptation
(TTA) to improve a model after deployment. We first introduce COLDQA, a unified
evaluation benchmark for robust QA against text corruption and changes in
language and domain. We then evaluate previous TTA methods on COLDQA and
compare them to RT methods. We also propose a novel TTA method called online
imitation learning (OIL). Through extensive experiments, we find that TTA is
comparable to RT methods, and applying TTA after RT can significantly boost the
performance on COLDQA. Our proposed OIL improves TTA to be more robust to
variation in hyper-parameters and test distributions over time. | [
-0.2154591978,
-0.8641334176,
0.3477502763,
0.158336252,
-0.5071775913,
0.1944721192,
0.1876085699,
-0.4571537673,
-0.1627759486,
0.2553501129,
-0.6849617362,
-0.2004188895,
-0.2387761325,
0.1560247689,
-0.3402148485,
0.93731004,
0.0053908443,
-0.1389762908,
-0.0623511374,
-0.4374162555,
-0.5614110827,
-0.1617118865,
-0.6430020332,
0.0649088323,
-0.0600605644,
0.0660077855,
0.9015968442,
0.7588133216,
0.4027932286,
0.288598299,
-0.1338993609,
0.2583864033,
-0.5618308187,
0.1653189659,
-0.1532270759,
-0.7141917944,
-0.241032511,
-0.2616167963,
0.6680111885,
0.2108915746,
-0.5729365945,
0.2297266871,
-0.0987820178,
0.3091478348,
-0.8068479896,
-0.1112134308,
-1.024112463,
-0.154359147,
0.1343272477,
-0.2573935986,
-0.2373884618,
-0.6637116075,
0.2989930511,
-1.0449368954,
0.5347819924,
0.0311950296,
1.0501493216,
0.3384995759,
-0.4506733716,
-0.0547204576,
-1.0242100954,
0.8456439376,
-0.7914204001,
0.4770824611,
0.360841006,
0.5560432673,
0.0940520018,
-0.5761222839,
-0.6249043345,
0.0734688491,
0.4358841479,
0.3524401486,
-0.1019812226,
-0.2879091203,
0.1287450045,
0.1404392272,
-0.5032633543,
0.052587565,
-0.1154754683,
0.0118943397,
0.3968730867,
0.1371686161,
0.1947657019,
0.1358489394,
-0.4788917601,
-0.5952087641,
-0.5494697094,
0.1135770828,
0.2922607064,
0.0958852619,
-0.0086591626,
0.1270774305,
-0.0775072947,
0.495130837,
0.2711364627,
0.1552113295,
0.1512418091,
-0.3463670015,
-0.2833914459,
-0.249914363,
0.3203678727,
0.4103822708,
0.2092045993,
-0.1030479297,
-0.2630084157,
-0.0950908586,
0.4389561415,
-0.6355608106,
-0.1213736087,
0.162845999,
-0.4734980464,
-0.3682559729,
0.027299976,
-0.9472954273,
-0.363502115,
0.1664853245,
0.6155264974,
-0.3643010259,
-0.4797689021,
0.0934198722,
-0.2464043796,
0.5631685853,
0.2056771666,
-0.7654607296,
0.3405401707,
0.5278294683,
0.785662353,
-0.2239161432,
-0.2572467923,
-0.5545041561,
0.1362774968,
-0.5330833793,
0.9556923509,
-0.3638979793,
-0.3692673743,
0.0995204151,
0.0401308611,
-0.2767233253,
-0.904073894,
0.3537839949,
-0.9237757921,
0.346160233,
-0.2244758755,
-0.4074366689,
0.1239929274,
0.4143954217,
-0.6336106062,
1.1501638889,
0.3912820816,
-0.7798354626,
0.651016295,
-0.7254270911,
-0.2876843214,
-0.175291419,
0.5253345966,
-0.9339412451,
0.0185225084,
0.5985164642,
0.1755530238,
-0.0272007473,
-0.268149823,
-0.6712141037,
-0.4840219915,
0.5918805599,
-0.2674383223,
0.8851404786,
0.3052071333,
-0.2062000483,
-0.0618745796,
-0.6528869271,
0.5100079179,
0.130597651,
-0.0111599062,
-0.5366606116,
0.0950023532,
0.0192535818,
-0.0743558109,
-0.1799362749,
-0.3590799868,
0.065271385,
-0.5658438802,
0.6221596599,
0.9010375738,
0.3533085585,
0.3882811368,
-0.4074023664,
0.7504467964,
0.3246349096,
0.4990396798,
0.3433838487,
-0.380332768,
-0.4558246434,
0.0662026554,
0.3660053909,
0.8411824107,
-0.9686470628,
0.0924149528,
-0.2574400604,
-0.463114053,
-0.5294325948,
0.217928037,
0.1782329828,
0.3409713805,
0.5167437196,
-0.3927902579,
-0.3457725048,
-0.4890392125,
-0.510119915,
-0.4554235935,
-0.1454633623,
0.117895171,
0.2207580209,
-0.1651721746,
0.9282482266,
-0.4998042285,
0.1308166683,
-0.2383241355,
0.0406455733,
-0.1378031671,
0.2629155815,
0.7635043859,
-0.9199056625,
-0.362529397,
-0.2202034593,
-0.3922900259,
-0.0040486283,
-0.0750419423,
-0.2863094509,
0.0908308625,
0.279430598,
-0.4863865972,
0.3239809573,
0.5417529941,
-0.4338856041,
0.3877191544,
-0.0606383644,
0.2062643021,
-1.5499269962,
-0.1870802343,
-0.1346773356,
-0.2722657919,
-0.5698623657,
0.2125663608,
0.2201054394,
-0.2242053449,
-0.4999837875,
0.5342412591,
-0.2167644203,
0.046782881,
-0.1103702262,
-0.0941182747,
-0.0422092043,
0.0108259441,
-0.2259492874,
0.9400479794,
0.3399680853,
-0.7723866105,
-0.0079277642,
0.5284528136,
-0.3419861794,
0.5017226934,
-0.8007534146,
0.3519880176,
-0.1718764454,
0.0901524648,
-0.8139473796,
0.0291412901,
0.045886144,
-0.200097993,
0.0774517432,
-0.1469808668,
-0.1900483221,
0.0203246381,
-0.3891710341,
0.3863939345,
0.5731180906,
-0.4581327438,
0.3849193156,
0.0080616986,
0.0012142293,
-0.5205735564,
-0.4621507823,
-0.3005051613,
-0.5662799478,
-0.278244704,
0.1798572838,
-0.3233172297,
-0.2580129206,
0.0378452539,
-0.0693860054,
-0.5769043565,
0.5057391524,
-0.1411862373,
0.0331616513,
-0.355874896,
0.1603690535,
0.2248946875,
0.1876637638,
-0.0531906709,
-0.0824588686,
0.0739776045,
0.1904584318,
0.0488220304,
-0.4364557266,
0.3669249713,
0.5121510625,
-0.1784248054,
0.9491615295,
0.610450685,
-0.2378187031,
-0.4982163906,
-0.3029382527,
-0.3992256224,
-0.5251451731,
0.3081003129,
-0.2845146656,
-0.447042793,
0.5176388621,
-0.0533572808,
0.1171446815,
0.4292978942,
0.2399968654,
-0.3601099551,
1.020239234,
0.9812124372,
0.093174696,
0.7932010889,
-0.0513554215,
-0.1257493049,
-0.3482867777,
0.2537554801,
-0.6547868252,
-0.1686147302,
-0.6841424704,
-0.1641352475,
0.5586500168,
0.1318695992,
-0.2934631109,
0.1074030846,
-0.1607305855,
0.5575144291,
0.3534852862,
0.3012976348,
0.1525046676,
0.1222435236,
0.242342785,
0.0685209036,
-0.7563632727,
-0.1257401407,
1.1340794563,
0.2133259326,
0.6507513523,
0.25255391,
0.2241292,
0.1901628822,
0.4173143506,
-0.2496420443,
0.2083587348,
0.0715422407,
-0.5115424991,
-0.4159711003,
-0.5361148715,
-0.8880949616,
-0.0874760821,
-0.2428443879,
-0.3636109233,
0.2061597854,
0.2676836252,
-0.4269705713,
0.2546750903,
-0.9598667622,
0.857473731,
-0.0437521301,
-0.0449899025,
-0.0657072887,
-0.5136367679,
0.1369520128,
0.0175774898,
0.0683530793,
0.0750450864,
-0.1578578353,
0.6324889064,
-0.2182477862,
0.7770500183,
-0.2359047681,
-0.0519107208,
0.1696675569,
0.1120078191,
0.6595088243,
0.2058699578,
-0.2668860853,
-0.1416607946,
0.6555168033,
-0.8840370774,
-1.0381536484,
0.3336546719,
-1.2292257547,
-0.4365213215,
-0.3458973765,
-0.536532104,
-0.6934754848,
0.0020424749,
0.387072295,
0.3042860031,
-0.3311309814,
0.0145358425,
0.9359303117,
-0.1387642473,
0.486556083,
0.5264369845,
0.050067436,
-0.4031971097,
0.569666326,
-0.0511315726,
0.7736095786,
0.4676696956,
0.4343782961,
-0.5342620611,
-0.717176199,
-0.737870872,
0.0881958157,
-0.5311551094,
-0.0820372999,
-0.3750715554,
-0.075668171,
-0.6068717837,
-0.0273303688,
-0.3995630145,
-0.3816524446,
-0.2370934784,
-0.0284609776,
0.5836632252,
0.6386381388,
0.3603613079,
0.2798806131,
-0.7374588847,
0.4192239046,
0.5446255207,
0.3907972276,
-0.2906191051,
-0.8361033797,
-0.2509018481,
0.1464080065,
-0.5381273627,
-0.9590566754,
0.2130498141,
0.671210885,
0.2746266723,
0.411673367,
0.3696987629,
0.7326017618,
-0.1455284953,
0.7838362455,
-0.4443727732,
-0.9432466626,
0.4591026008,
-0.3500715792,
0.7112611532,
0.4426689446,
0.3469423056,
-0.3201530874,
-0.5114093423,
-0.5180737972,
-0.4739723802,
0.1410878152,
0.2720382214,
0.3846578002,
0.3561656177,
0.6642507315,
0.4291192889,
0.0914114267,
-0.451600641,
-0.1310096085,
-0.6369476914,
-0.132548064,
-0.2544558346,
-0.1415349543,
-0.2001339197,
-0.1374070942,
0.5991876125,
-0.4864133894,
0.4046114683,
0.1511802673,
-0.0824496225,
-0.1804348826,
0.5325337648,
0.5890284181,
0.9987775683,
-0.2491536289,
-0.0338732302,
0.4870509803,
-0.5199352503,
0.2234284133,
0.0448029079,
-0.5292469859,
-0.1315823644,
0.2799351215,
0.7447853088,
-0.0731924176,
-0.6135385036,
0.2512174249,
-0.3077129722,
-0.0591660179,
-0.0606889576,
0.1258306354,
-0.1576386839,
0.176071316,
0.4055024683,
0.0253624003,
-0.0075606671,
-0.7389798164,
0.0500594825,
0.4130270779,
-0.3060474098,
-0.4435380399,
0.8286505342,
-0.0809873864,
-0.2512449324,
0.6526573896,
-0.1396989971,
-0.4989118874,
0.7134343982,
0.7422497869,
0.9571390748,
-0.5439289808,
0.6397425532,
-0.0141039854,
0.3659276664,
-0.0337499939,
0.6229166389,
0.1460940838,
-0.8612005711,
-0.3077907264,
-0.3765437007,
-0.5362980962,
-0.0130474828,
-0.8103015423,
-0.0121044433,
-0.5434393883,
-0.0274313372,
-0.4230652452,
-0.1951424032,
-0.6586135626,
0.3773177564,
-0.5729722977,
0.8268849254,
-1.0041537285,
0.6779415607,
0.8467395306,
0.1542001516,
-0.7870159149,
0.4830661714,
-0.382376492,
-0.591948688,
-0.0930267572,
-0.2357475013,
0.169794023,
0.2050981671,
-0.4607023001,
-0.7450060248,
1.1041334867,
0.6552618742,
-0.2533491254,
0.2622122169,
0.1961487383,
0.8167007565,
0.00932243,
0.3755811751,
0.3133335412,
0.0189620666,
-0.1855993569,
-0.9740762115,
0.0435387194,
-0.0976674929,
0.0339966714,
0.217120856,
-0.8462796807,
0.391207546,
-0.2732765973,
-0.337623775,
0.2037292123,
0.6437093019,
0.002631922,
0.51226753,
0.8686698079,
0.5179879069,
0.8231341839,
0.0192329958,
1.121958971,
-0.020120794,
0.4426188469,
0.8609703779,
-0.3460819721,
1.0457894802,
0.3801553249,
-0.1480417699,
0.6851148605,
0.7436617613,
0.3402991295,
0.8080563545,
-0.0323686004,
-0.1071058363,
-0.4287181795,
0.0261148084,
-0.636941433,
0.2440082729,
-0.0025877152,
-0.0668484792,
-0.1992848068,
0.141364038,
-0.3626468778,
0.0953429565,
-0.1615844369,
0.8623365164,
-0.1820682734,
-0.5005580783,
0.8391497135,
-0.0626573041,
0.1733586639,
-0.6103089452,
0.1358329058,
-0.5133644342,
0.3598262668,
0.1614697129,
-0.3052985668,
0.2736498415,
-0.2759220302,
-0.1668967456,
-0.2558668852,
0.4234020114,
-0.2027275711,
-0.4994443953,
-0.1000504121,
0.6710833907,
-0.204746902,
0.052818872,
-0.7951834798,
-0.064784959,
-0.3102147579,
-0.2790111601,
0.446900934,
0.4357441366,
-0.2516198754,
0.9989081621,
0.4903597236,
0.0129070841,
0.4587774277,
-0.170811519,
0.6459487677,
-0.6652809978,
-0.7834905386,
-0.4654962718,
0.1098759323,
0.068764329,
-0.6799004078,
0.7363703847,
0.3143837452,
0.7590420842,
-0.2850167453,
0.7541734576,
0.1670355797,
0.6877191663,
-0.7163714767,
0.6838145256,
-0.5505365133,
0.1413466334,
-0.1934977323,
-0.9512290955,
-0.0695354566,
0.0410218313,
-0.1179580167,
0.0311280172,
0.8402817845,
0.9904953241,
-0.3547102511,
0.0656578243,
0.1884995997,
0.2590627074,
0.1862590313,
0.467685014,
0.8071115017,
-0.7264517546,
0.7287757993,
-0.3075391352,
0.0850637704,
0.1532582939,
-0.8614152074,
-0.7382386327,
-0.5517597198,
-0.5798989534,
-0.7076978087,
0.4073288441,
0.6912364364,
0.8676053286,
-1.1206938028,
0.075624384,
-0.0023156519,
0.0961711109,
-1.0977379084,
-0.2902428806,
0.4338264763,
-0.0654007047,
-0.6670002341,
0.5385699272,
-0.2711467147,
0.2267891318,
-0.1943714619,
0.1217348874,
-0.0108130472,
0.3206173182,
0.2220231146,
0.4551617205,
-0.1883924901,
-0.5655923486,
0.1978696287,
0.1745457947,
0.111998342,
0.9281554818,
-0.6726786494,
0.5513304472,
0.3627537489,
0.9990721941,
0.2725325823,
0.351991266,
0.7905743122,
-0.6317593455,
-0.0446805321,
0.1872180253,
-0.221162051,
0.2508338988,
-0.4929733574,
0.2390644252,
0.3740892112,
-0.561440587,
-1.0251075029,
0.1885922104,
-0.8319211602,
-0.2305443883,
1.0754054785,
-0.1180986539,
-0.1917145401,
-0.4605863392,
0.0821584091,
0.2535986006,
-0.2420565635,
1.4858865738,
0.6386685371,
0.1542973816,
-0.344663918,
-0.4974278212,
0.7025758028,
0.6901634932,
-1.1559579372,
-0.1518047303,
-0.0292829946,
0.8360189199,
-0.3075833023,
0.2805143595,
0.1937132776,
0.5425749421,
-0.2574687004,
-0.4883180559,
0.0449894294,
0.0181279499,
-0.5153525472,
0.3266941905,
0.3183082938,
-0.4444326758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04580v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04580v1 | Generating a Structured Summary of Numerous Academic Papers: Dataset and Method | 2023-02-09T11:42:07 | 2023-02-09T11:42:07 | Shuaiqi Liu, Jiannong Cao, Ruosong Yang, Zhiyuan Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.7 | Writing a survey paper on one research topic usually needs to cover the
salient content from numerous related papers, which can be modeled as a
multi-document summarization (MDS) task. Existing MDS datasets usually focus on
producing the structureless summary covering a few input documents. Meanwhile,
previous structured summary generation works focus on summarizing a single
document into a multi-section summary. These existing datasets and methods
cannot meet the requirements of summarizing numerous academic papers into a
structured summary. To deal with the scarcity of available data, we propose
BigSurvey, the first large-scale dataset for generating comprehensive summaries
of numerous academic papers on each topic. We collect target summaries from
more than seven thousand survey papers and utilize their 430 thousand reference
papers' abstracts as input documents. To organize the diverse content from
dozens of input documents and ensure the efficiency of processing long text
sequences, we propose a summarization method named category-based alignment and
sparse transformer (CAST). The experimental results show that our CAST method
outperforms various advanced summarization methods. | [
-0.5207298994,
-0.4557087123,
0.4730412662,
0.1344673932,
-0.2333776355,
0.2489922196,
0.0591109209,
-0.0323071033,
0.7640678287,
0.1888413131,
-0.1698094755,
-0.5261260271,
-0.4933303893,
0.376452297,
-0.8494056463,
1.5112806559,
0.2072660029,
-0.2811121047,
-0.2200694531,
-0.0056551402,
-0.0756565556,
-0.1421638578,
-0.19074139,
-0.0938917994,
0.6557666063,
0.3268357217,
0.1937218159,
0.5804040432,
0.802968204,
0.2975602448,
-0.0888553783,
0.4456228316,
-0.6806895733,
0.1678905636,
-0.0541643091,
-0.0258829836,
-0.7869818807,
-0.1077804416,
1.0222305059,
0.9385312796,
-0.2013047785,
0.4388841093,
0.3152523637,
0.611333549,
-0.5682635307,
0.0386867374,
-0.3024379313,
-0.0289529748,
-0.3727746308,
-0.1610772908,
-0.2808676064,
-0.4162733555,
-0.310230732,
-0.7315969467,
0.4714181423,
-0.0060755424,
0.4830953479,
0.1189933941,
-0.5759751201,
-0.065146625,
-0.8451988697,
0.7104532719,
-0.3990328312,
-0.1900965571,
0.0967616066,
0.1444575638,
-0.1337366849,
-0.8764320612,
-0.365093559,
0.364667207,
-0.2476286441,
0.4344819486,
0.1419136971,
0.0330495574,
0.2886164486,
0.4625883698,
-0.7355694771,
-0.1243261024,
-0.8372340798,
0.269664675,
0.83716923,
0.5100072026,
-0.2975999415,
-0.2696759105,
-0.0176570229,
-0.1875660717,
-0.4521312118,
-0.2276197374,
0.185040608,
0.2149401754,
0.1247214675,
0.7251139283,
-0.1135075167,
0.7459026575,
0.1122140065,
-0.5727945566,
0.1809603423,
-0.648884356,
-0.2564303577,
0.2778261304,
0.8142701983,
0.4413338304,
-0.2735385299,
0.1355541646,
0.1339215487,
-0.2669972777,
0.5241504908,
-0.8233882785,
0.0332068168,
0.5615429282,
-0.585246563,
-0.1997923255,
0.2829498053,
-0.990301609,
-0.2954590321,
-0.38438043,
-0.2879532278,
-0.1581403464,
-0.082167156,
-0.1539832205,
-0.1362156123,
0.0318900384,
0.3738651574,
-0.7405136824,
0.3181266487,
0.8612978458,
0.979154706,
-0.3608875871,
-0.2598139942,
-0.2540111244,
0.4915730357,
-0.4095348418,
0.8464115262,
-0.32613343,
-0.5358247161,
0.0604851134,
-0.1239181906,
0.1193788722,
-0.316531986,
0.6418649554,
-0.1545548439,
0.4242323041,
0.0585132465,
-0.3637095094,
0.089474991,
0.2562432885,
-0.6698948145,
0.8935402632,
-0.0478325114,
-0.8224777579,
0.386329025,
-0.5368136764,
-0.6484544873,
0.0374121442,
-0.1301618963,
-0.6338674426,
0.2910515368,
0.2676292956,
0.6630674005,
-0.2190720141,
0.7772710919,
-0.0629560426,
-0.4574838281,
0.0261682495,
0.0142523376,
0.5350484848,
0.3103449941,
-0.0053467196,
0.047940895,
-0.8593992591,
-0.271571815,
-0.2837554216,
-0.2606528401,
-0.5512269735,
0.1310336441,
0.253176719,
0.1110182777,
0.0957350358,
-0.5621664524,
0.4263182878,
-0.156606555,
0.2352233976,
0.3171578348,
0.0013914438,
0.2257555872,
-0.5973981023,
0.6435474157,
-0.1345422268,
-0.1259741783,
-0.4480262399,
-0.1951105595,
-0.1975924224,
-0.5863718987,
0.4632197917,
0.1400828809,
-0.4180563092,
0.5626315475,
-0.799310863,
-0.4611856937,
-0.3656527996,
-0.1691676974,
0.4424157441,
0.4664537013,
0.2947244346,
-0.1079447269,
-0.6432587504,
-0.8933905959,
0.1063721254,
0.2781472206,
-0.2713620663,
-0.2778767943,
0.716982305,
0.3070702255,
0.8394301534,
-0.9938159585,
-0.513018012,
-0.0948287696,
0.2478708029,
0.4453009665,
0.4527335763,
0.4443086088,
-0.7284257412,
-0.2562811077,
-0.1200407222,
-0.5949984193,
0.1870599985,
-0.2665396333,
-0.1788534671,
-0.223756209,
0.6359602809,
-0.4173974395,
0.0237093959,
0.5312950015,
-0.1705347002,
0.4374070168,
-0.0910029411,
0.2372560352,
-1.4796382189,
0.6004494429,
0.1012917385,
-0.0656865388,
-0.2818164527,
-0.0626984462,
-0.086191304,
-0.4391925335,
0.0775943771,
0.2980698645,
-0.3798051775,
0.0544620492,
-0.1640444249,
0.0983738527,
0.1213946864,
0.3301617205,
-0.0089922501,
0.5650847554,
0.0535703786,
-0.3562124968,
0.1954695582,
0.7285131216,
-0.1969148368,
0.8319186568,
-0.7392095327,
-0.3542068899,
-0.5802428722,
0.7640035748,
-1.2256686687,
-0.5364513993,
-0.1200549006,
-0.3056677878,
0.3792648017,
-0.1406036615,
-0.1434885114,
-0.4852130413,
-0.6961296201,
0.3086346388,
0.2337836176,
-0.2880719304,
0.6002514958,
0.4128172398,
-0.8492487073,
-0.6965456009,
-0.3943497241,
0.31238693,
-0.3132507801,
-0.3342293501,
0.4235298336,
0.0816535726,
-0.1537382603,
-0.0717778131,
-0.2084236592,
-0.0845854953,
-0.2970784307,
0.4230448306,
0.277210027,
-0.0382874757,
0.0597540326,
0.3009105325,
-0.0080485614,
0.1065459177,
-0.2920246124,
0.1999376565,
0.3400332928,
-0.1965559721,
0.1445250511,
0.9366030693,
0.7548748851,
-0.1556987911,
0.4089300931,
0.2333029956,
-0.2038185447,
-0.1899953485,
-0.3273561299,
0.2709181607,
-0.3234461248,
0.3946586251,
-0.2135910392,
-0.7001289725,
0.2917794883,
-0.1930480748,
0.6748465896,
0.6948540211,
0.3708090782,
-0.2118490487,
0.8473502398,
0.3722935021,
-0.1401772648,
0.3387155235,
-0.2673267722,
0.2620608509,
-0.664509356,
-0.4693248272,
-1.0636589527,
-0.4981439412,
-0.3744072616,
-0.1673035324,
0.7346363664,
-0.390668273,
-0.1661920995,
-0.0511254668,
-0.8239777684,
0.4845702648,
0.5591934919,
-0.0232487693,
0.5405598879,
0.4728277028,
0.3162749708,
0.1008988172,
-0.6068117023,
-0.4872226715,
1.072586298,
-0.0214504227,
0.8732171059,
0.0385872573,
0.8043475151,
0.0472132377,
0.3248427808,
-0.5170891285,
0.3013422787,
-0.4403582811,
-0.5081021786,
-0.4191921651,
-0.447404027,
-1.199125886,
0.3699657917,
-0.3124082088,
-0.1255650222,
0.2596778572,
0.0283611007,
-0.4326829612,
0.1267920136,
-0.2821018398,
0.2296159714,
0.0215616301,
-0.374197185,
-0.0931543708,
-0.6936277747,
0.8870671988,
-0.3980743289,
0.2915697396,
0.4007332921,
0.2153040171,
0.9585110545,
-0.4240236282,
0.524189353,
0.1301060468,
-0.1009241194,
0.1490868777,
-0.1677618921,
0.2765598297,
0.125051856,
-0.0976361185,
-0.0819064304,
-0.0050092018,
-0.6475893259,
-0.3591338396,
0.5863656998,
-0.3529348075,
-0.1840999722,
-0.7236216068,
-0.6615764499,
-0.1254344583,
0.1658081412,
0.2312591672,
0.7919668555,
-0.3036112785,
0.3431125283,
0.6196112633,
-0.0147348195,
0.486889571,
0.0839911848,
-0.0411663502,
-0.8081001639,
0.7605318427,
0.2740510404,
-0.2623483837,
0.36207968,
-0.1245165542,
-0.1110706553,
-0.6613903642,
-0.3224004805,
0.3081150651,
-0.065144524,
-0.6125804782,
-0.8271052837,
-0.1533117592,
-0.5714217424,
-0.6750752926,
-0.0366992727,
-0.5500682592,
0.0002833303,
-0.0798876137,
0.1434925795,
0.9280509353,
-0.0125464797,
0.3461094499,
-0.8187695146,
0.6961144209,
0.1864080131,
0.4279609323,
-0.0345341899,
-0.1987308413,
-0.3843918741,
-0.1841336042,
-0.2516489923,
-0.3667805195,
0.4261130095,
0.2478260249,
0.3024757802,
0.569950223,
0.0936097801,
0.7409234643,
-0.2798064947,
0.7599089742,
0.4260605276,
-0.4526958466,
0.3233181834,
-0.7576176524,
0.4886600375,
0.8399915099,
0.6552992463,
-0.118618995,
-0.3923919201,
-0.6827876568,
-1.2073959112,
0.4481652379,
0.0056478688,
-0.0663097054,
0.1559744328,
0.1049885601,
0.3339766562,
0.4588932097,
-0.3255112171,
-0.1235476732,
-0.215772599,
-0.5009259582,
-0.4174063802,
-0.2963492572,
-0.6429445744,
-0.1523137987,
0.68871665,
-0.1448625475,
0.0154586658,
0.2266767472,
0.1383026093,
0.1474269629,
0.3178604841,
0.8450335264,
1.0014423132,
-0.3581893742,
0.2858268023,
-0.2292760164,
-0.9174356461,
0.2350791246,
0.4081659615,
-0.2561653852,
0.2130823284,
0.4607557952,
0.2332041562,
-0.0535143949,
-0.4624847472,
0.3273929656,
-0.0759416297,
-0.5648601651,
-0.2530101836,
-0.310156852,
-0.0146889845,
-0.1813283861,
0.7099758983,
-0.2089070082,
0.3123521209,
-0.3447341323,
0.1017408594,
0.1479740739,
-0.0005759359,
0.0323791467,
0.7174699903,
0.3057915866,
0.2919305861,
0.5421200395,
0.0583876222,
0.0549918376,
0.5352346301,
0.4588866234,
0.6448354125,
-0.066768676,
0.2555330396,
0.6694306731,
0.1758241951,
-0.3992595673,
0.0425987057,
0.080931969,
0.1045161262,
-1.0601730347,
-0.8092444539,
-0.4332502186,
0.2821432948,
-0.569935143,
0.0555369519,
-0.3026198149,
0.0356508829,
0.1430228353,
0.0238074791,
-0.0130352704,
0.2051121593,
-0.2832128704,
0.7271270752,
-1.0883411169,
0.2028253973,
0.8139235377,
-0.1667295098,
-0.5525348186,
-0.3080263138,
-0.1153759509,
-0.1884183884,
0.2239062935,
-0.2757534683,
-0.0113559505,
-0.1655354351,
-0.6140837073,
-0.7562764883,
0.8521093726,
0.0135175856,
-0.7513365746,
-0.1390758008,
-0.0386548266,
0.4990998209,
-0.1363566518,
0.1641622335,
0.33074224,
0.6155819893,
0.327678293,
-0.6532758474,
-0.0327479914,
-0.5471717119,
-0.245249033,
0.7328032851,
-0.5493456721,
0.7673281431,
0.2052818537,
0.0756410137,
-0.1872400939,
0.5507388711,
0.2875173688,
0.5555582047,
0.0397586264,
0.6087385416,
0.7233026028,
-0.0621123277,
0.9311211705,
-0.0951024741,
0.1864348352,
1.2046136856,
-0.1911208779,
0.3618010283,
0.2823051214,
-0.2906754315,
0.1502118707,
0.3661602437,
-0.2976031601,
0.1942488849,
0.2712438405,
-0.2291305661,
0.0600610673,
-0.0903363898,
-0.5637224317,
0.5591947436,
0.4689971805,
-0.303601712,
-0.5880012512,
0.0094165504,
0.1742956638,
0.096921742,
-0.4851827323,
0.8312113881,
-0.0869508833,
-0.8854881525,
0.4126879871,
-0.1572830677,
0.6539764404,
-0.6785876155,
-0.2192615867,
-0.3938547969,
-0.0899184793,
-0.5593627691,
-0.6985724568,
0.4127523303,
0.1275552958,
-0.3874705732,
-0.496424824,
0.5295535922,
-0.4238941669,
-0.7576627135,
-0.5791586041,
0.4338897169,
0.245173499,
0.1456162632,
-0.0213104226,
-0.2722679377,
-0.2720398307,
-0.2411076128,
0.4966127276,
0.3746374547,
-0.1697957218,
0.1912188679,
0.5519136786,
0.164643541,
-0.1494724751,
-0.3014727533,
0.8304004073,
-0.7040500045,
-0.573900044,
-0.4670771658,
0.5163674951,
-0.4451586902,
-0.5370513797,
0.7017305493,
1.1765384674,
0.4207559228,
-0.0079692863,
1.0077447891,
-0.4195259809,
0.7136219144,
-0.2784463465,
0.5343212485,
-0.4905896187,
-0.2742840052,
-0.4247677326,
-0.9732806683,
-0.6001020074,
0.3574024141,
0.1267856956,
-0.1070933342,
0.736017108,
0.399120599,
-0.3582256138,
-0.1391097903,
0.0629013553,
0.0653741062,
0.1235860214,
0.2884341776,
0.4641144276,
-0.1656371802,
0.6355406046,
0.1253397912,
-0.2885243893,
-0.2800362706,
-0.8789858222,
-0.6566689014,
-0.8509123921,
-0.3225026131,
-0.5301863551,
0.0155516099,
0.5470288992,
0.5964372754,
-0.9320207834,
-0.2525697947,
0.1667174101,
0.0545080863,
-0.2327272743,
-0.2326285392,
0.7817717195,
-0.1200974509,
-0.7868210673,
0.164855808,
0.2686906457,
-0.2267628908,
-0.0870629102,
0.5151066184,
-0.3365548253,
-0.2400362045,
0.7636232376,
0.388142854,
0.0700974688,
0.2936105132,
-0.1789485514,
-0.1600029916,
0.0723376945,
1.0359871387,
-0.6461475492,
0.0517044365,
0.5894303918,
0.5602306724,
0.7631331682,
0.4979807734,
0.4962245524,
-0.7372723222,
-0.1158274785,
0.263536185,
0.3100733459,
-0.0133947432,
-0.1935962141,
0.7068371177,
-0.1443540007,
-0.6200067401,
-0.7698113322,
-0.1555312574,
-1.449870348,
-0.485262841,
0.8045763969,
0.1490811855,
-0.0862967223,
-0.3939983845,
-0.3014926016,
0.1662943959,
-0.4873274863,
1.0133365393,
0.4373570383,
-0.1847743243,
0.201390937,
-0.3117758036,
0.3037231565,
0.1307958066,
-1.1073777676,
0.1483370215,
0.9695463181,
-0.011331819,
0.475341171,
0.4867725372,
-0.2313062847,
-0.0144203613,
0.158122018,
0.119552955,
-0.2710027993,
-0.3604410291,
-0.3692384362,
0.9707837701,
-0.30730322,
0.0414154418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04562v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04562v1 | NLP-based Decision Support System for Examination of Eligibility Criteria from Securities Prospectuses at the German Central Bank | 2023-02-09T11:00:58 | 2023-02-09T11:00:58 | Christian Hänig, Markus Schlösser, Serhii Hamotskyi, Gent Zambaku, Janek Blankenburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As part of its digitization initiative, the German Central Bank (Deutsche
Bundesbank) wants to examine the extent to which natural Language Processing
(NLP) can be used to make independent decisions upon the eligibility criteria
of securities prospectuses. Every month, the Directorate General Markets at the
German Central Bank receives hundreds of scanned prospectuses in PDF format,
which must be manually processed to decide upon their eligibility. We found
that this tedious and time-consuming process can be (semi-)automated by
employing modern NLP model architectures, which learn the linguistic feature
representation in text to identify the present eligible and ineligible
criteria. The proposed Decision Support System provides decisions of
document-level eligibility criteria accompanied by human-understandable
explanations of the decisions. The aim of this project is to model the
described use case and to evaluate the extent to which current research results
from the field of NLP can be applied to this problem. After creating a
heterogeneous domain-specific dataset containing annotations of eligible and
non-eligible mentions of relevant criteria, we were able to successfully build,
train and deploy a semi-automatic decider model. This model is based on
transformer-based language models and decision trees, which integrate the
established rule-based parts of the decision processes. Results suggest that it
is possible to efficiently model the problem and automate decision making to
more than 90% for many of the considered eligibility criteria. | [
-0.161261633,
-0.6580002904,
0.5250859261,
0.3509150445,
-0.1828384399,
-0.0329205915,
-0.2075856328,
-0.4444105923,
-0.0125499722,
0.7337042093,
-0.2624123991,
-0.5954523087,
-0.4793440402,
0.3389220834,
-0.7149341702,
1.1025930643,
-0.3697500229,
-0.000681448,
-0.4103349149,
0.295871079,
-0.4097990692,
-0.5594662428,
-0.9733972549,
-0.3557709157,
-0.2192794234,
0.170788914,
0.4614279568,
0.0756791607,
0.8657423258,
0.3106134832,
-0.1494219899,
-0.3210113645,
0.2231663316,
-0.1385909468,
-0.2662426233,
-0.5082806945,
-0.5032974482,
0.1353402138,
0.5103841424,
0.5177525878,
-0.4505516887,
0.417501986,
0.0876564533,
0.609813273,
-0.3505876958,
0.3206269443,
-0.4290752709,
0.3390385211,
-0.1913613379,
-0.5033406019,
-0.5683353543,
-0.2173164636,
0.4553673565,
-0.3612106442,
0.6132544875,
0.0537654012,
0.8797639012,
0.027487576,
-0.0391094349,
-0.47217682,
-0.8732506633,
0.4501665533,
-0.4915231168,
0.2615555227,
0.6053059101,
0.6775456667,
0.0081533473,
-0.6583189964,
-0.130847007,
-0.4326218069,
-0.3060200214,
0.0437434465,
-0.2438217402,
0.1380506307,
0.2738906741,
0.1579554975,
-0.6588400006,
-0.0105283577,
-0.5612049699,
-0.5788900256,
0.4583738148,
-0.0879184082,
0.1066002771,
-0.533737123,
-0.248403579,
-0.1244180351,
-0.1271170229,
0.0756068453,
0.5371711254,
0.4540033042,
0.0089441389,
0.7869247794,
-0.37864995,
0.9412050247,
0.0668776259,
0.0153577803,
0.0373929329,
-0.2756224275,
-0.2880189419,
0.3752058446,
0.2929086089,
-0.0086812777,
0.0932957828,
-0.292865634,
-0.6664143205,
0.2203399688,
0.4964521825,
-0.2848680913,
-0.0980707482,
0.5607767701,
-0.7299780846,
-0.358173579,
0.3581730425,
-0.7528465986,
0.0681435615,
-0.5817112923,
0.3696264923,
-0.3725710213,
-0.1597155482,
0.4401635826,
-0.5829928517,
0.3692823946,
0.1807170063,
-0.7639187574,
0.4276293218,
0.4006869495,
0.6270112395,
-0.1076635271,
-0.0027805252,
-0.4278576672,
0.0886408091,
-0.0660760924,
0.8492857814,
-0.7155461907,
-0.3010436594,
0.0520328581,
0.0684861913,
-0.2132061869,
-0.6135879755,
1.1217074394,
-0.9250693321,
0.4560441673,
0.3011703789,
-0.3368011117,
-0.0137294708,
0.4435417056,
-0.6616494656,
0.6994567513,
0.3848927319,
-0.7851577997,
0.4583104253,
-1.0630691051,
-0.213344112,
0.2837311924,
-0.0115766684,
-0.5153698325,
-0.2190994322,
0.1777702123,
0.359020859,
-0.3721447885,
0.5524630547,
-0.2198651284,
-0.2460067719,
0.0221572723,
-0.5502836108,
0.8310163021,
0.0366129391,
-0.2408422232,
0.1464562714,
-0.743798852,
-0.0887750164,
0.2845763564,
-0.4204475582,
-0.3635504544,
0.0422253534,
0.1741048843,
0.3273819089,
0.3342179358,
-0.3300813138,
-0.0892754197,
-0.3509473801,
0.2343992144,
0.6702906489,
-0.1881536245,
0.5005838871,
-0.1976661384,
0.8639899492,
0.0048646894,
0.2919031084,
0.3012683392,
-0.2597058117,
-0.7509647608,
0.0813352764,
0.7193289995,
0.8205570579,
-0.5069301724,
0.6524493098,
0.1642122865,
-0.2820435166,
-0.2707517147,
-0.092427887,
0.0180088002,
0.4692163169,
0.2323377579,
-0.1211340874,
-0.8832604289,
-1.0966545343,
0.0984544456,
-0.3412012458,
-0.0717020556,
-0.0116026094,
0.5771221519,
-0.2853634953,
1.192440629,
-0.3718800843,
-0.5208432674,
-0.2041254193,
0.0801120996,
0.477355957,
0.2358377278,
0.5917629004,
-1.0937021971,
-0.1095867306,
0.1781194508,
-0.8701552153,
-0.1392918378,
-0.3983714581,
-0.041386418,
0.3256213665,
0.4170720279,
-0.5145031214,
0.4992226362,
0.4483339787,
-0.4541495144,
0.6229913235,
-0.5118192434,
-0.0531647094,
-0.7306698561,
0.3695163131,
0.3498467803,
-0.2441439927,
-0.3444927037,
-0.3045153618,
0.0536113866,
-0.221360907,
-0.1687898487,
0.5785464644,
-0.2387102395,
-0.1744690984,
-0.2719914615,
0.2101296186,
-0.1396607012,
0.1929669231,
0.3076071739,
0.5445495844,
0.640899837,
-0.7959859371,
0.4048210382,
0.4066596627,
-0.2670230865,
0.7154590487,
-0.5457027555,
-0.3531769812,
-0.1868589371,
0.3248586953,
-0.4341416359,
-0.063583672,
0.4621122181,
-0.1724589169,
0.1261044145,
0.0009672588,
-0.1796079874,
-0.8096551895,
0.1963004768,
-0.1558260322,
0.1338429898,
-0.404733777,
0.8468437195,
0.4149965346,
-0.4032464921,
-0.5259664655,
-0.2748669088,
0.2461672872,
-0.3988839388,
-0.3475927413,
0.5534790754,
0.3344981968,
-0.1929179281,
0.2212680429,
-0.0888255611,
0.036977496,
0.1986262649,
0.0207117628,
0.675544858,
0.0113576641,
-0.0233011041,
0.0436411835,
-0.6239284277,
0.2707678378,
-0.6677975655,
0.4325002432,
-0.1127420142,
-0.5235099792,
-0.4531349838,
0.3872464597,
0.3127213717,
-0.3050898314,
0.4518850148,
0.3364148438,
-0.5126711726,
-0.3539010882,
-0.2513132989,
-0.0452308804,
-0.4434419572,
0.1970328838,
-0.4550571144,
-0.5873508453,
0.4642810524,
-0.1907597184,
0.1116318256,
0.7932676673,
0.5919888616,
-0.0159186162,
0.8730978966,
0.8574435115,
0.1474030614,
0.3895652294,
-0.1119296178,
0.3502118289,
-0.4552072883,
-0.3019011021,
-0.7387298942,
-0.1250280738,
-0.3961409926,
-0.1098572984,
0.3985449374,
0.019474389,
0.1783702821,
0.5947604775,
-0.6058886647,
0.15037103,
0.4523173571,
0.0020824126,
0.2245052904,
-0.0012226858,
-0.2799134552,
0.1992101818,
-0.7195753455,
-1.0985094309,
1.1662267447,
0.2397619933,
0.3495866954,
-0.0572783314,
0.6052920818,
0.9627586007,
0.4672668874,
-0.5550000668,
0.6330761313,
-0.0486676469,
-0.7167212963,
-0.3312511146,
-0.3625807166,
-0.9308950901,
-0.1535512358,
-0.3116801977,
-0.7095436454,
0.2056980431,
-0.0835723951,
-0.521388948,
-0.0000201556,
-0.8167255521,
0.9190232754,
-0.2532765865,
0.3856365681,
-0.2249537855,
-0.392449975,
0.3293788731,
-0.5649478436,
-0.0986027494,
-0.0089183468,
0.2143253386,
1.0382370949,
-0.2413360775,
0.7213779688,
-0.410099864,
-0.0303778462,
0.3677812517,
-0.232167393,
0.4102092087,
0.2671117187,
-0.632017374,
0.2009132206,
0.3948874474,
-0.1890961528,
-0.3476333916,
0.1964253634,
-0.5292837024,
-0.5277762413,
-0.6925433278,
-0.1056814864,
-0.1611839086,
0.2968519628,
-0.0888028368,
0.1237651706,
-0.5777027011,
-0.0083052218,
0.05777812,
-0.0285894852,
0.4179910123,
0.5227301121,
-0.314373076,
0.019887425,
0.649356544,
0.1516356021,
-0.0882170573,
0.319775939,
0.1168034226,
-0.6231637597,
-0.6816304922,
-0.4119089544,
0.0946423337,
-0.7717255354,
-0.2393020689,
-0.6462404132,
-0.5450953245,
-0.3652411401,
-0.1373834759,
0.0309352633,
-0.3288230002,
-0.1773987561,
-0.1173146144,
0.0874448419,
0.3520275056,
-0.0618140884,
0.0848252922,
-0.8966023922,
0.5969366431,
0.158545807,
0.6867843866,
-0.2819958925,
-0.563565433,
-0.3221772611,
-0.1838924289,
-0.2507086098,
-0.7511516809,
0.1878819615,
-0.0452509746,
0.7502552867,
0.3742988408,
0.2335697114,
0.14001441,
-0.1148732603,
0.1950116456,
-0.1931916624,
-0.9299330115,
0.895755887,
-0.3035194576,
-0.0801488906,
0.6075581908,
0.2241598368,
-0.7984421253,
-0.4741026759,
-0.8683772683,
-0.7058755159,
1.1877355576,
0.2852856517,
0.0110576125,
0.080823116,
0.4097091258,
0.122042872,
0.1579616964,
-0.5445689559,
0.1623398662,
0.0278311335,
-0.1049433574,
0.2569871843,
-0.1183305904,
-0.3495693207,
0.0470443778,
0.8931130767,
-0.1615993977,
0.2137475759,
0.1965894401,
0.1261133254,
0.0358509906,
0.3331616819,
0.1880685389,
0.6754315495,
-0.4309974015,
-0.2655157149,
0.0984466299,
-0.2299659997,
0.1341955066,
0.608795464,
-0.5702847242,
0.2342838347,
0.0606890842,
0.6951320767,
-0.1569895893,
-0.8547701836,
0.4452540278,
-0.2707100213,
-0.3791159093,
-0.7228372097,
-0.0000287864,
-0.0727993622,
0.2866291702,
0.325183928,
0.335426122,
0.2486146986,
-0.1819215566,
0.4897511601,
0.316911906,
-0.2307091504,
-0.0796619654,
0.489299655,
0.2804632187,
-0.6466745138,
0.6930705309,
-0.3412499726,
-0.3549535871,
0.7539628744,
0.7912122607,
0.8625734448,
-0.0839193687,
0.776537478,
0.2931260169,
0.2989004254,
-0.3810193539,
0.167914927,
0.0460972376,
-0.8355746269,
-0.2307939827,
-0.8422570825,
-0.6312679648,
-0.1177529618,
-0.5853555799,
0.6564453244,
-0.4341237843,
-0.5479252934,
0.1292172819,
-0.2515944242,
-0.684679091,
0.3499853909,
0.4269680977,
1.011578083,
-1.0443419218,
0.4843579233,
0.7420524955,
-0.1767648458,
-0.3696347475,
-0.0931639075,
-0.0551590696,
-0.4743276238,
0.4789633453,
0.1708046198,
0.1190875396,
-0.2551059127,
0.0228948351,
-0.6017733216,
0.7531178594,
0.397401154,
-0.4757960141,
-0.2648533881,
0.2470974624,
0.5471664071,
-0.0740773827,
0.2312680185,
0.8832677007,
0.8655464649,
-0.0326619409,
-0.819796145,
-0.2688487172,
-0.447453171,
-0.2440841645,
0.3081264794,
-0.3352283537,
0.3033862114,
0.2048582733,
-0.3545300066,
-0.3258115649,
0.6510300636,
0.2657584846,
0.3868326545,
0.8056203723,
0.2947383523,
0.8015777469,
-0.1700513065,
1.0538493395,
-0.3703939915,
0.3434179127,
0.6477156878,
-0.3362814188,
0.7282082438,
0.3705979586,
-0.3804869652,
0.2366116941,
0.7892172933,
-0.211798802,
0.1303982735,
0.1061928272,
-0.1692563295,
-0.3069401383,
-0.204692319,
0.0503282435,
0.9931391478,
0.3406728804,
-0.4243554771,
-0.4475860596,
0.0276959073,
-0.5049016476,
0.0238338355,
0.0119010797,
0.5181230903,
0.0230088085,
-0.6735407114,
-0.119483307,
0.4953620136,
0.4250199497,
-0.9758045077,
0.1094837561,
0.2894307077,
0.133607626,
-0.2725230455,
-0.8135690093,
0.7924048901,
0.274774164,
-0.3512562215,
-0.4889302552,
0.8454520702,
-0.0441778004,
-0.9527776837,
0.5323886275,
0.5331729054,
0.0149128372,
-0.0766300783,
-0.9295468926,
-0.3431209624,
-0.1303651184,
-0.3283583224,
0.1552682519,
0.3314227164,
-0.433154285,
0.409288764,
0.7756736279,
0.2200160623,
-0.5015890598,
0.3051567972,
0.5708591342,
-0.6122289896,
-0.6077447534,
-0.6921716332,
0.2792247534,
-0.3215416074,
-0.2230814993,
0.3850201368,
0.6285381913,
0.7384428382,
0.1721508205,
0.9772279859,
-0.2244560421,
0.3527684808,
-0.6842620373,
0.5735817552,
-0.3112717271,
0.3802212179,
-0.0822865516,
-1.0846149921,
-0.4370051324,
0.5663813353,
-0.4824545681,
0.010678065,
0.4677931368,
0.6690496206,
-0.0739186853,
0.2694154084,
-0.124052234,
-0.3642966449,
0.3227171004,
0.3715319335,
0.5655922294,
-0.2736054063,
0.6343114972,
-0.1757648289,
-0.2500822544,
-0.3960421681,
-0.8557849526,
-0.5180617571,
-0.6035339236,
-0.3445035219,
-0.2023132294,
-0.2455508858,
0.9759571552,
0.3354604244,
-0.8270466328,
-0.281509012,
0.0852272809,
0.1193503365,
-0.3785767257,
-0.2282616943,
0.6262862086,
-0.3696219027,
-0.5980954766,
0.1431156993,
0.5956431031,
0.0524468943,
-0.2539981604,
-0.0008292868,
-0.0136276819,
-0.0083506908,
0.4127016068,
0.2793904841,
-0.3612753153,
-0.1640135497,
-0.0156046497,
-0.2492477447,
-0.1245289221,
0.8751049638,
-0.6140081882,
0.5575400591,
0.4904352129,
0.8465612531,
0.2610789537,
-0.0208704267,
0.660089016,
-0.3254579008,
0.1859060079,
0.3678346276,
0.4325474799,
0.1105335131,
-0.4090298414,
0.4854675233,
0.1881882548,
-0.2573320866,
-0.4754136503,
-0.1591300517,
-1.0140311718,
-0.279609859,
0.9897998571,
0.1586912721,
-0.3014727235,
-0.3929438293,
-0.4769126177,
0.2872017622,
-0.2264135331,
1.0548121929,
0.9982165694,
-0.0262245983,
0.0946453586,
-0.6440113783,
0.4095136225,
0.4526318312,
-0.8782368302,
0.03995822,
0.2061346471,
-0.2714594305,
0.2202118486,
0.940907836,
-0.1893311888,
0.4329165518,
-0.0125219384,
0.0960282758,
0.1623718292,
-0.3609404564,
-0.3657375574,
0.3845520914,
-0.0655376986,
0.0027464929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04555v1 | Data Augmentation for Robust Character Detection in Fantasy Novels | 2023-02-09T10:47:03 | 2023-02-09T10:47:03 | Arthur Amalvy, Vincent Labatut, Richard Dufour | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a low-level task often used as a foundation
for solving higher level NLP problems. In the context of character detection in
novels, NER false negatives can be an issue as they possibly imply missing
certain characters or relationships completely. In this article, we demonstrate
that applying a straightforward data augmentation technique allows training a
model achieving higher recall, at the cost of a certain amount of precision
regarding ambiguous entities. We show that this decrease in precision can be
mitigated by giving the model more local context, which resolves some of the
ambiguities. | [
-0.5011998415,
-0.5506035089,
0.2905106246,
-0.47803092,
0.1335159242,
-0.0315956101,
0.093052879,
-0.9342765212,
0.4872301817,
0.7495288849,
-0.6910110116,
-0.3855686784,
-0.3589190841,
0.6639891267,
-0.2487102896,
0.9293928742,
-0.0449919738,
-0.2663208246,
-0.2665766478,
-0.1802327782,
-0.7445083857,
-0.7566813231,
-0.7702857256,
-0.4093219042,
0.6331056356,
0.3077663481,
0.9926860929,
0.7787266374,
0.8251142502,
0.3387419283,
-0.0769767016,
0.4162358046,
-0.5532945991,
0.4982511997,
-0.2352983207,
-0.7517272234,
-0.3807134628,
-0.4063896537,
0.6841472983,
0.6036430597,
0.2881044447,
-0.2854016125,
-0.0408750735,
0.7000466585,
-0.6878646016,
-0.2019573897,
-0.4117597342,
0.2287789583,
-0.3240775764,
-0.2881847918,
-0.2948467731,
-0.2343144715,
0.096422337,
-0.9106069207,
0.8018157482,
0.1857555807,
1.2507202625,
0.2113508582,
-0.489700079,
-0.2704731226,
-1.1076011658,
0.788523972,
-0.6824012995,
0.2979099154,
0.4798603058,
0.2690885961,
-0.1397534311,
-0.1630190611,
-1.0345486403,
-0.1517067105,
-0.3806840479,
-0.2443073243,
-0.2476875931,
0.0380791835,
0.7898087502,
0.6687304378,
-0.3512907028,
0.010321728,
-0.1699299663,
-0.3665854633,
0.6906237602,
0.4412017763,
0.5819944143,
-0.2204540968,
-0.1017170027,
-0.224042967,
-0.8164620996,
-0.03296078,
0.6998650432,
0.2336534858,
0.1147614345,
0.6983323097,
-0.0026418085,
0.6635014415,
0.4423336983,
-0.1215445325,
0.6196005344,
-0.229007259,
0.0314079188,
0.2786895633,
0.2239630669,
0.2301939726,
0.1547152251,
-0.1873055696,
-0.4880478382,
0.2326393127,
0.3040969074,
-0.7764774561,
-0.2561046183,
0.051716689,
-0.3912198544,
-0.1980141848,
-0.1499183774,
-0.5776237845,
-0.8317394853,
-0.4671660662,
0.5226083994,
-0.6146170497,
-0.2657432854,
0.0199669488,
-0.5406128168,
0.5016385913,
0.4750672579,
-0.9709779024,
0.1650229841,
0.4474665821,
0.6006022096,
-0.1517209411,
-0.067156978,
-0.6346078515,
0.2113232315,
-0.666229248,
0.8914727569,
-0.6224271059,
-0.2986786366,
-0.3747417331,
0.321049124,
0.0262574703,
-0.5230995417,
0.7733451724,
-0.5866017342,
0.0495442562,
-0.5690931678,
-0.6884682775,
-0.4330990613,
0.5649350286,
-1.1609581709,
0.8856685758,
0.2563685775,
-0.9659525752,
0.4905845523,
-0.170843944,
-0.4908449054,
0.2133680284,
-0.1144381016,
-0.4451391697,
0.1491930932,
0.557867825,
0.2886742353,
-0.1837824285,
0.0640313476,
-0.296785593,
-0.7370111942,
0.3611829281,
-0.5767988563,
0.5483286381,
-0.1207769066,
-0.0767567158,
-0.3800705671,
-0.7739569545,
-0.2471494079,
0.0246096347,
-0.1405199617,
-0.9346495867,
-0.2130385786,
0.0952280611,
-0.2760557532,
0.0843759179,
-0.6028666496,
0.1039143205,
-0.7628862262,
-0.0732390434,
0.1841152459,
0.237206012,
0.557092905,
-0.739126265,
0.6494479775,
-0.0013393322,
-0.4507068098,
-0.4718112946,
-0.2080708444,
-1.1060379744,
-0.2237553,
0.6494970322,
0.681415081,
-1.3374826908,
0.6295547485,
-0.1045973301,
-0.4254475534,
-0.3348822296,
-0.2417140603,
0.2796713412,
0.7817589045,
0.4577876329,
-0.1011850834,
-0.6389061809,
-0.7604163289,
-0.3804921806,
0.1061936021,
-0.2970122993,
0.1800984293,
0.602063477,
-0.3264006376,
0.8848747015,
-0.3664213121,
-0.5674610138,
-0.3753341734,
0.0399267375,
0.3579692841,
0.7387875915,
0.5097615719,
-1.099968195,
-0.5012024045,
0.1598296165,
-0.8635156155,
0.1272958517,
-0.3598847985,
0.2141835988,
-0.0563556664,
0.4142908752,
-0.4281276166,
0.6974751353,
0.0476786122,
-0.2845787108,
0.5538253784,
-0.3497821093,
0.5229725838,
-1.1524400711,
0.0417357162,
0.2046321481,
-0.2347219139,
-0.9858543277,
0.0791470259,
0.2123886645,
-0.0645822287,
-0.0441707931,
0.8568892479,
-0.8751583099,
0.1565801352,
-0.284958154,
-0.1174719557,
0.4049923718,
0.2504201829,
0.4261987805,
0.8659646511,
0.4930498004,
-0.8427173495,
0.3836103082,
0.3114649057,
-0.2519052029,
1.1009610891,
-0.5596458316,
0.1960243881,
-0.5169731379,
-0.1516719609,
-0.8402326107,
-0.6142069697,
0.194975242,
-0.4487870932,
0.5760501623,
-0.314222455,
-0.2328947186,
-0.2258764654,
-0.0856840163,
0.4739774764,
0.2716250718,
-0.6930115819,
0.8816156983,
0.5166679621,
-0.1455459148,
-0.7374759912,
-0.9158744812,
0.1100213304,
-0.5248129964,
-0.3982850313,
0.8816812038,
0.2343626767,
-0.1625988334,
0.0694151223,
-0.1283168495,
-0.407042861,
-0.1930727661,
-0.0371479876,
0.2954483032,
-0.3111459613,
0.3263436854,
0.1737154573,
-0.3948169053,
-0.3125083148,
0.269882232,
0.2283176035,
-0.054666914,
-0.4135729373,
-0.5817324519,
0.4238119125,
0.1546352208,
-0.1607818156,
0.4776933789,
0.6439034343,
-0.9142902493,
-0.0858492479,
-0.5866102576,
-0.2127818465,
-0.5344893336,
0.3125673234,
-0.5779880285,
-0.7313969135,
0.8512134552,
0.2687467337,
-0.4590056837,
0.5526813269,
-0.1544626355,
-0.0136439335,
1.0114878416,
0.7818284035,
0.0721532032,
0.4435565472,
-0.0815574974,
0.37435022,
-0.9490761757,
-0.1491871178,
-0.7036454678,
-0.5555592775,
-0.5985856056,
-0.4227510989,
0.4086838961,
0.1452391297,
-0.0523659289,
0.7263945341,
-0.5350203514,
1.11729002,
0.4365108609,
0.2511853576,
0.5071348548,
0.0748824328,
0.3812491,
-0.5629834533,
-0.3038223386,
-0.4801633954,
0.8863342404,
0.2667060494,
0.9260127544,
0.2854270935,
0.870141089,
0.4733913541,
-0.1229150295,
-0.8028882742,
0.3162602782,
-0.1864237934,
-0.8092036247,
-0.3710329831,
-0.4323756695,
-0.8884067535,
-0.0205869414,
-0.6326647997,
-0.760848105,
1.1071554422,
0.1493052393,
-0.6801176667,
0.327696234,
-0.5922180414,
0.5772657394,
-0.0069620563,
-0.2011665106,
0.0552746058,
-0.3898723423,
0.2274558991,
-0.0179780871,
-0.2931140661,
0.2370636612,
-0.0212601274,
0.5005807281,
-0.3314599991,
0.5916927457,
-0.1191838384,
0.0518872663,
0.288738519,
0.3180012703,
0.8241039515,
-0.0190548766,
-0.4490999877,
0.2000362724,
0.0900129676,
-0.1289917976,
-0.7558062077,
0.5842276216,
-0.3721555471,
-0.2845697999,
-0.7343400121,
-0.8144955039,
-0.0980792046,
0.3457037508,
0.2920177281,
0.7650874853,
-0.2259616107,
0.2969659269,
1.0188148022,
-0.3213403225,
0.2842098773,
0.3123956621,
-0.054490149,
-0.4375319779,
1.0276098251,
0.2686691582,
-0.0465251841,
0.7021442652,
-0.1885092705,
-0.3842650056,
-0.6248942018,
-0.5216752887,
0.1118811369,
-0.8239512444,
-0.2919202149,
-0.7476755381,
-0.4699748755,
-0.1671035439,
-0.4167284966,
-0.0864138007,
-0.4233057499,
-0.6370250583,
-0.0308404956,
0.4916357696,
0.5560576916,
0.0960552767,
0.4867653549,
-0.7660525441,
0.4936378598,
0.0005257116,
0.058605317,
-0.1098223329,
-0.5591862798,
-0.0894292369,
0.0011296158,
-0.0387488082,
-1.0493340492,
0.9419679046,
0.3156888485,
0.3850541413,
0.4687020481,
0.1973329484,
0.9828744531,
-0.2182314098,
0.4930489361,
0.0800532028,
-0.8772891164,
0.2779664993,
-0.4652477801,
0.2221776247,
0.7838336229,
0.434458673,
-0.6814830303,
0.0763992742,
-0.4501793385,
-0.5639461279,
0.8022716641,
0.1969278753,
0.4259063601,
0.0930586159,
0.6562729478,
0.1791452169,
0.148058787,
-0.7790285349,
-0.2878218293,
0.3301386535,
-0.1212690324,
-0.0622734465,
-0.1485754997,
0.3053005934,
-0.363568902,
0.7373124957,
-0.1475317627,
0.482437402,
0.5339641571,
-0.2664837837,
-0.0087982854,
0.1255107224,
0.1537789106,
0.1062582508,
-0.127068013,
-0.0080528269,
0.2855260372,
-0.5779698491,
0.1014475375,
0.2840126753,
-0.5399369597,
0.1587278396,
0.5307591558,
0.9353154302,
0.0389163569,
-0.3136676848,
0.4675655365,
0.0446880832,
0.0706210285,
-0.198739484,
0.3042967916,
-0.3759821951,
0.3984139562,
0.4433751106,
0.5078939795,
0.5280880332,
-0.3245464265,
0.3803313971,
0.4497202039,
-0.5867968202,
-0.0416817404,
0.3747541904,
0.0176966079,
-0.4467150867,
0.5577966571,
-0.6015581489,
-0.5604864359,
1.0026420355,
0.8438995481,
0.7398262024,
-0.2332000136,
0.2861328721,
0.5973988771,
0.4299713969,
-0.1029722318,
0.1947859973,
0.140307948,
-1.08723104,
-0.3048972487,
-0.4722189009,
-0.4707057476,
0.1676754653,
-0.5610327721,
0.6648845077,
-0.2722272277,
-0.2372714281,
0.1363835931,
0.0685076565,
-0.5933850408,
0.2913626432,
0.0501703732,
0.4933166504,
-0.6891741157,
0.5885090828,
0.432169795,
-0.4438970983,
-0.8202685118,
0.2313785702,
0.0034264133,
-0.2844549716,
0.4136451483,
0.5528044105,
0.0166850165,
0.1751553863,
-0.066732727,
-1.178311944,
0.8425854445,
0.4240771532,
-0.6890368462,
-0.3573507965,
0.0161845479,
0.7454531193,
-0.4337223172,
0.607691288,
0.2994507253,
0.4322371483,
0.2128102034,
-0.6261792183,
-0.0076840697,
-0.4392684102,
0.0680625513,
0.4765041471,
-0.0038290445,
0.9960291386,
-0.2889826298,
-0.4767606258,
0.1194704548,
0.6961650252,
0.0124062821,
0.5090481043,
0.3759596348,
0.4998287857,
1.2593381405,
-0.1831686646,
1.0873343945,
0.1498248428,
0.1988420188,
1.1497015953,
-0.3988681138,
0.469812721,
0.2453248948,
-0.0942866951,
0.631817162,
0.6796858311,
-0.305668056,
0.5091915727,
-0.1390241981,
-0.3042201996,
-0.3480839133,
-0.2478227615,
-0.5313561559,
0.2515285015,
0.4720181227,
-0.2812303603,
-0.1249453202,
0.2713075578,
-0.1884733588,
0.2413685769,
-0.4647387862,
0.6694857478,
-0.0724093094,
-0.494420439,
0.6071446538,
-0.0194831826,
0.7252354622,
-0.4235349298,
-0.3908492327,
0.0332027748,
0.4528771043,
-0.3369565308,
-0.6013095975,
0.5669380426,
-0.2136267126,
-0.5441555977,
0.0840333328,
1.3084117174,
-0.5266122222,
-0.821006,
-0.0068167658,
0.2553132772,
0.0956647471,
-0.2352281213,
-0.4912523329,
-0.1890725791,
-0.0697910935,
0.1082364768,
-0.0041427314,
0.5242524147,
-0.1296373606,
0.5716469884,
0.6533064246,
0.0377041437,
-0.2903210223,
-0.1086986363,
0.62213099,
-0.683635056,
-0.6691613793,
-0.7398964167,
0.3607538044,
-0.3108978868,
-0.2892582119,
0.9724740386,
0.4393258989,
0.7518413663,
-0.1899895668,
0.7404099703,
-0.1940632164,
0.7901933789,
-0.4144390821,
0.6383594275,
-0.4389092624,
0.4292743206,
-0.4193794727,
-1.0838243961,
-0.5590892434,
0.8063495755,
-0.618742466,
0.0533594079,
0.5574952364,
1.0848865509,
-0.2592309415,
0.3616852462,
0.4107190669,
-0.1387460679,
-0.0887097716,
0.5985087156,
0.854450047,
-0.9557692409,
-0.037886776,
-0.2183065712,
0.041932568,
-0.0221092924,
-0.9433489442,
-1.1979138851,
-0.4521211386,
-0.4032978714,
-0.4088968337,
0.1149710491,
0.8329614997,
0.6900172234,
-0.9936442375,
0.2247028649,
-0.222011283,
0.4192019105,
-0.3146675229,
-0.2658419907,
0.1450035721,
-0.0029190874,
-0.9323196411,
0.5363044739,
-0.0050464403,
0.300077498,
-0.1740559489,
-0.1616407633,
0.0008658863,
0.0726247355,
0.0900119469,
0.3466267288,
-0.35221228,
-0.1257631481,
0.1787767708,
0.1275396943,
0.3714521527,
0.6877684593,
-0.9701334834,
0.6259827614,
0.5999741554,
0.9117081165,
0.5066847801,
0.0800854415,
0.6857004166,
-0.8138434291,
0.0048531513,
0.443464458,
0.1900862753,
0.7376645803,
-1.0421030521,
0.349750638,
0.3115872443,
-0.5180690885,
-1.0437438488,
0.2427503914,
-0.6555886269,
0.0902433693,
0.9450228214,
0.0646032989,
-0.2322865427,
-0.5085841417,
-0.2694702744,
0.0389868096,
-0.3185723722,
0.3642562926,
0.6553149819,
-0.1279550493,
-0.1134897098,
-0.3542296886,
0.6151001453,
0.1188139766,
-0.8512122035,
-0.106122084,
0.6267877817,
0.0514841527,
0.556928575,
0.5526242852,
0.0440286621,
0.1198241562,
0.2134303153,
0.1446243376,
-0.0082177995,
-0.5494520664,
-0.5528981686,
0.0333876312,
-0.3099782467,
0.166563645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04542v1 | Efficient Attention via Control Variates | 2023-02-09T10:16:20 | 2023-02-09T10:16:20 | Lin Zheng, Jianbo Yuan, Chong Wang, Lingpeng Kong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Random-feature-based attention (RFA) is an efficient approximation of softmax
attention with linear runtime and space complexity. However, the approximation
gap between RFA and conventional softmax attention is not well studied. Built
upon previous progress of RFA, we characterize this gap through the lens of
control variates and show that RFA can be decomposed into a sum of multiple
control variate estimators for each element in the sequence. This new framework
reveals that exact softmax attention can be recovered from RFA by manipulating
each control variate. Besides, it allows us to develop a more flexible form of
control variates, resulting in a novel attention mechanism that significantly
reduces the approximation gap while maintaining linear complexity. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that our model outperforms state-of-the-art efficient
attention mechanisms on both vision and language tasks. | [
-0.388563484,
-0.5957714915,
0.2111026049,
0.1496253312,
0.1786811352,
-0.0773919001,
-0.1267133504,
-0.3815791309,
0.1694259495,
0.5259529352,
-0.9307543039,
-0.2666303813,
-0.3525844216,
-0.161756739,
-0.1705787778,
0.9516885281,
-0.2368169278,
-0.3490312397,
0.1198974848,
-0.5556536317,
-0.3731359839,
-0.2360715866,
-0.0382232442,
-0.1239902005,
0.9405568838,
0.1680436432,
0.6570564508,
0.4910907745,
1.0607846975,
0.3363027275,
0.0613237433,
0.2278781831,
-0.811634779,
-0.0346321128,
-0.2626933157,
-0.6128352284,
-0.1809822917,
0.026669791,
0.6988322735,
0.846211195,
-0.1623676568,
0.3363453746,
-0.0383724868,
0.8183064461,
-0.8644506335,
-0.0138882156,
-0.6122800112,
0.5154892206,
-0.0552436821,
-0.2934311032,
-0.2394911647,
-0.2437709123,
0.1203720942,
-0.7038626075,
0.471629113,
-0.096330367,
0.9465501308,
0.4541834295,
0.0425555818,
0.1641576141,
-1.2293150425,
1.0117729902,
-0.068077147,
0.4091252387,
0.143592149,
0.2620719969,
-0.1644119918,
-0.5945959687,
-0.2923915982,
-0.0983427539,
0.3281960189,
0.1828028709,
-0.1811537892,
0.2764531374,
0.2917990088,
0.3475878835,
-0.2172557116,
-0.0925850719,
-0.4191127419,
0.0936011821,
0.1873334348,
0.2714068294,
0.130295977,
0.1272212267,
-0.6462944746,
-0.1882415414,
-0.5088956952,
0.1544057876,
0.1572569758,
0.2393486202,
0.0693436787,
0.8122987747,
-0.0823735073,
0.7862817645,
0.1203513816,
0.1361851245,
0.0918817893,
-0.398075819,
-0.6858551502,
-0.8437582254,
0.4046469331,
0.1394113302,
0.2630453706,
-0.3952767849,
-0.2706957161,
-0.0577674285,
0.4626268446,
-0.244086802,
0.2052729577,
0.3675734699,
-0.6869975328,
-0.1925161779,
0.1228211299,
-0.7709756494,
0.0816932246,
-0.2603343725,
0.4626334608,
-0.3231507242,
-0.0469071046,
0.1747824848,
-0.080171898,
0.5391795635,
0.3844916224,
-1.1841641665,
0.5031869411,
0.5679202676,
0.9231747389,
-0.2135809809,
-0.1437530965,
-0.4415698349,
0.0587977245,
-0.5612103343,
0.6797715425,
-0.5552811623,
0.1173130721,
-0.05687714,
-0.3984580934,
-0.2008320987,
-0.5873167515,
-0.0922517851,
-0.6295579076,
0.3363001943,
0.1262871027,
-0.1196412593,
-0.1302392632,
-0.0616343431,
-0.9652078748,
0.918759346,
0.6509248614,
-0.5376423001,
0.5757331848,
-0.6553219557,
-0.0882894993,
-0.0842175484,
-0.234034732,
-0.416248709,
0.3223905861,
-0.080674082,
0.526889801,
-0.0872145593,
-0.3067137301,
-0.7006753683,
-0.3956426978,
0.5287542939,
-0.3833382726,
0.2967022955,
0.2096452862,
-0.3342241645,
0.2218159884,
-0.6937484145,
0.0810795054,
-0.1318106055,
-0.1164564416,
-0.457693398,
-0.036829032,
0.3972711563,
0.2257157564,
0.0494876653,
-0.2082913518,
0.1861974001,
-0.6387586594,
0.1030890495,
0.7496868968,
-0.0611774512,
0.8602395654,
-0.3409785926,
0.6576526761,
-0.3602227271,
0.4477201998,
0.1413335204,
0.0314469002,
-0.6217204928,
-0.6846348643,
0.1820558757,
0.3632528484,
-0.2416935861,
0.2573310733,
0.0886724964,
0.0272267777,
-0.6158722043,
0.389983058,
0.5415645838,
-0.2440559119,
0.1233946756,
-0.5840052366,
-0.1789674163,
-0.9261616468,
-0.1540262699,
0.1820139736,
-0.3451195359,
0.5472719073,
0.1477795839,
0.0828345194,
0.887177527,
-0.4642498195,
-0.7093843818,
-0.3950981796,
0.0650734082,
0.3131991327,
0.2528472841,
0.7503966689,
-0.8126713037,
-0.2279551774,
0.0793204829,
-0.4359841049,
0.1422362477,
-0.3597931266,
-0.1228241622,
0.1157547235,
0.1857687533,
-0.7158046365,
0.4959166646,
0.3168114722,
-0.3557929099,
0.245418191,
0.0054974048,
0.0787008256,
-0.612640202,
0.312607944,
0.0835096911,
-0.2188744843,
-0.6845859289,
0.2011282891,
-0.1833266765,
0.1644729227,
-0.4074958563,
0.3060824871,
-0.5787343383,
-0.4064690769,
-0.1628035456,
-0.1165475994,
-0.2398951203,
1.0204343796,
0.0282697547,
0.464510709,
0.1792563796,
-0.279773891,
0.0611284003,
0.1129110828,
-0.1828166991,
0.4393850863,
-0.4993185401,
-0.0531418771,
-0.2916294336,
-0.0142915593,
-1.2739425898,
-0.4037377536,
0.1786275953,
-0.4515526295,
0.5412926674,
0.1698237658,
-0.0913353041,
-0.3792142272,
-0.6870464683,
0.2062393129,
0.317759335,
-0.3083411455,
0.8528780341,
0.224729687,
0.0076039326,
-1.0748177767,
-0.7331985235,
-0.196392417,
-0.0959599242,
-0.1665755063,
0.2106681168,
0.0065578874,
-0.446626395,
0.1558362991,
-0.1560160667,
-0.2882629335,
0.0466519333,
0.2394834757,
0.1236211434,
-0.1578016579,
0.1942479312,
-0.225421384,
-0.020622652,
-0.1810820252,
0.0464967526,
0.4346750677,
0.0847314894,
-0.1397137344,
-0.6136401296,
0.7086787224,
0.8206067681,
-0.1942954212,
0.357295841,
0.4824120998,
-0.379432559,
-0.7310576439,
-0.590169251,
-0.3807732761,
-0.4545364082,
0.5849840045,
-0.442255795,
-0.9415278435,
0.7098869681,
0.339812845,
0.2246980369,
0.2560780942,
0.6002271175,
-0.1967061162,
1.0034193993,
1.0961537361,
0.0214821901,
0.9508038759,
-0.3658358157,
-0.0748214871,
-0.6924159527,
-0.2639003992,
-0.4518026412,
-0.4976557493,
-0.4621776342,
-0.6425014138,
0.037084192,
-0.1740519702,
-0.1760764271,
0.09926337,
-0.6135637164,
0.4248830974,
0.5294463038,
0.2161038816,
-0.0641681626,
0.0595584661,
0.3202564716,
-0.2745721638,
-1.1007432938,
0.0293467529,
0.9666495919,
0.5709736943,
1.2051441669,
-0.054390803,
0.4537515044,
0.2661265433,
0.543284297,
-0.8468647599,
0.1580607891,
-0.2012425959,
-0.6425030828,
-0.4313941002,
-0.3865593672,
-0.7629147172,
0.2912620306,
-0.0738166198,
-0.8243178129,
0.552660048,
0.2223158181,
-0.7105577588,
0.1612997502,
-0.9205743074,
0.6789280176,
0.2864483297,
-0.7472734451,
-0.2186352462,
-0.7755300403,
0.5482804179,
-0.0031422698,
-0.0628958941,
-0.1923440099,
-0.3024930656,
0.6505213976,
-0.4124227166,
1.0293081999,
-0.1061974913,
0.0879731253,
0.065912962,
-0.2691533267,
0.4015661776,
-0.100118421,
0.6125677824,
-0.3826873004,
-0.4202810824,
-0.549864471,
-0.7640752792,
0.4543700218,
-0.6969974637,
-0.3044468462,
-0.4139125943,
-0.7640245557,
-0.1983978301,
-0.0109817851,
-0.1527395844,
0.5084214807,
-0.2553957105,
0.2578186989,
1.2313945293,
-0.151518479,
0.534219563,
0.5852896571,
0.1349720359,
-0.3808121085,
0.5591710806,
0.2245348543,
0.3095178604,
0.9841091633,
-0.2657424808,
-0.2387770712,
-0.5682375431,
-0.1046979204,
0.3073841035,
-0.3953100145,
-0.3195429444,
-0.8783066273,
-0.1531700343,
-0.1276853979,
-0.4696382284,
-0.5152660608,
-0.3328650892,
-0.2820214331,
0.0513148196,
0.4678919613,
0.7760054469,
-0.1836422086,
-0.0030117049,
-0.3790990114,
0.6525132656,
0.5778715611,
0.6356726289,
-0.0551172718,
-0.2656799257,
-0.1913213134,
-0.5641949773,
0.2006434202,
-0.6427253485,
0.4894599319,
0.4280252755,
0.5726297498,
0.3502274752,
-0.3077326417,
0.4273133278,
-0.4653048515,
0.4646664262,
0.4563837051,
-0.7429751158,
0.2672184408,
-0.3508748114,
0.6107935309,
0.4286889136,
0.0018708474,
-0.0673492178,
-0.8316934109,
-0.5283219814,
-0.947255969,
0.9949746728,
0.2241179645,
0.2639717162,
0.3267148137,
0.2295107394,
0.0268577375,
0.0027310061,
-0.5132061243,
-0.1842146963,
-0.0055935252,
-0.4449845552,
0.1650021225,
-0.2429294437,
-0.5762921572,
0.2279449403,
0.0122532668,
-0.1454354376,
0.7571209669,
0.2918176055,
0.0237227716,
-0.4232148528,
0.1025747135,
0.8381872177,
0.6528288722,
-0.6295247674,
0.1677284092,
0.2043056935,
-0.6560179591,
0.1427367032,
0.0902197137,
-0.0591268539,
-0.0349898152,
0.3626297414,
0.6859747767,
0.50239712,
-0.6033734083,
0.5299215913,
-0.1499880999,
-0.3069446087,
0.0425076447,
0.2163805217,
-0.3654289544,
0.3954233527,
0.6900237799,
0.5354213119,
0.2782178521,
-0.1896515489,
0.6845881343,
0.4804470241,
-0.6061992645,
-0.1001880243,
0.9357566833,
0.2114741206,
-0.191253379,
-0.1800590903,
0.5132164359,
-0.0701164529,
1.0098619461,
0.2789925635,
0.9426755905,
-0.3258368075,
0.2630084753,
0.0205385741,
0.5130643845,
0.1784220785,
0.4798353016,
-0.2017681152,
-0.7006781697,
-0.7588248849,
-0.4290094376,
-0.377995342,
0.2443773001,
-0.7237826586,
-0.2349308729,
-0.8703666329,
-0.169646278,
0.2427657843,
0.0702216998,
-0.9141492844,
0.3756322563,
-0.0575687476,
0.8714695573,
-0.6938564181,
0.581671536,
0.3376369476,
-0.3829316795,
-0.733387053,
-0.1168419793,
-0.2344779819,
-0.7283731103,
0.5472820401,
0.1306830049,
-0.4868124425,
-0.1285177916,
-0.5697668195,
-1.0743141174,
0.8275945783,
0.0930019245,
-0.6362798214,
0.3512806594,
-0.256621331,
0.4980397522,
-0.2902415991,
0.1037589088,
0.4255124032,
0.2817743719,
0.0177539028,
-0.5624466538,
-0.1968448758,
-0.3111691177,
0.2522875071,
0.3177450597,
-0.919436574,
0.2950508595,
-0.4415685833,
-0.186333552,
-0.0374312066,
1.1316136122,
0.0277775433,
0.0577988513,
0.4185124636,
0.3974611759,
0.3244559765,
-0.1012333706,
1.0421800613,
-0.0403223746,
0.4893457294,
0.7193875909,
-0.3146654665,
0.7449939847,
0.6848275065,
-0.4191049635,
0.1403850764,
0.4901532531,
0.0861872062,
0.8710930943,
0.0917628333,
-0.3011260033,
0.0933568776,
-0.0333870761,
-0.1102472693,
0.4153831303,
0.4145516753,
-0.5413745642,
0.0812519416,
0.2439785898,
-0.1423307508,
0.0182641,
-0.4986026585,
0.8282521963,
-0.201652512,
-0.6374469399,
0.7036310434,
-0.240645498,
0.6968269944,
-0.9786599874,
-0.0460687317,
-0.5111179948,
0.4932525754,
0.0687351301,
-0.6450936198,
0.2561789453,
-0.0372473784,
-0.5368418694,
-0.2343430668,
0.796295166,
-0.7493380308,
-0.1557724327,
0.2207994163,
0.147303611,
-0.2619026601,
0.3624939024,
-0.5686509609,
0.0401939899,
0.0142998993,
-0.677544415,
0.259596467,
0.3075068593,
0.0696352795,
0.729508698,
0.2764619887,
0.0062363315,
0.2312452942,
0.0986576006,
0.9737868905,
-0.7804582119,
-0.3567710817,
-0.3111357689,
0.2287528366,
-0.1080429628,
-0.5715106726,
0.4295571446,
0.185692206,
0.5481056571,
-0.453904599,
0.9119157195,
-0.1460538507,
0.43361485,
-0.5229591727,
0.5855609179,
-0.5108109713,
-0.217709139,
-0.0224724542,
-0.8491848707,
-0.8622054458,
0.4520076811,
-0.0475323051,
0.2988768816,
0.7772149444,
0.9170188904,
-0.1499492079,
-0.5996952653,
0.5671698451,
0.1407382935,
0.0165455416,
0.8448185325,
0.5125623345,
-0.0145802833,
0.4859399199,
-0.1660920978,
-0.6238065958,
-0.439568758,
-0.4774726629,
-0.805736959,
-0.4434143901,
-0.0615692399,
-0.2964535654,
0.318652004,
0.8755259514,
0.849709332,
-1.0522614717,
0.0101566929,
-0.1691047102,
0.2271322906,
-0.7931793928,
-0.2851768434,
0.5244128108,
-0.6696266532,
-0.8780872226,
0.157938242,
0.804918766,
0.0247221924,
-0.6640210152,
0.22746858,
-0.1365360171,
0.533806622,
0.4928612709,
0.6545547247,
-0.6947206259,
-0.2980480194,
0.3289948404,
-0.5099880695,
0.0365843996,
1.0259901285,
-0.495877862,
0.4645567238,
0.8104467392,
0.5375372171,
0.5394327044,
0.0053413534,
0.9262990355,
-0.7323636413,
0.3886070848,
0.4263899624,
-0.0634687245,
0.1530219167,
-0.4240186214,
0.5395943522,
0.3048607409,
-0.3786860704,
-0.6210410595,
0.1657449305,
-1.5079922676,
-0.2557415664,
1.1090033054,
-0.0835383534,
-0.7420434952,
-0.3097710609,
-0.1438355744,
-0.01398018,
-0.432610929,
1.026512146,
0.4176418483,
-0.1036875024,
-0.3806420863,
-0.4883610904,
0.8442283869,
0.6733867526,
-0.6560907364,
0.250225991,
0.3534055054,
0.1324859858,
0.052269239,
0.7067536116,
-0.1470781416,
0.6296275258,
0.0178341474,
0.2964927852,
0.2544180453,
-0.6340814829,
-0.4750507176,
0.7757714987,
-0.2766591311,
-0.4325374365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04511v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04511v3 | A Large-Scale Analysis of Persian Tweets Regarding Covid-19 Vaccination | 2023-02-09T09:08:19 | 2024-01-13T04:44:21 | Taha ShabaniMirzaei, Houmaan Chamani, Amirhossein Abaskohi, Zhivar Sourati Hassan Zadeh, Behnam Bahrak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI, I.2.7 | The Covid-19 pandemic had an enormous effect on our lives, especially on
people's interactions. By introducing Covid-19 vaccines, both positive and
negative opinions were raised over the subject of taking vaccines or not. In
this paper, using data gathered from Twitter, including tweets and user
profiles, we offer a comprehensive analysis of public opinion in Iran about the
Coronavirus vaccines. For this purpose, we applied a search query technique
combined with a topic modeling approach to extract vaccine-related tweets. We
utilized transformer-based models to classify the content of the tweets and
extract themes revolving around vaccination. We also conducted an emotion
analysis to evaluate the public happiness and anger around this topic. Our
results demonstrate that Covid-19 vaccination has attracted considerable
attention from different angles, such as governmental issues, safety or
hesitancy, and side effects. Moreover, Coronavirus-relevant phenomena like
public vaccination and the rate of infection deeply impacted public emotional
status and users' interactions. | [
-0.4400839806,
-0.8877305388,
0.2608558536,
0.2836546898,
-0.321883291,
0.213559553,
-0.1995715201,
-0.3722532988,
0.5046347976,
-0.1079079509,
-0.1963531226,
-0.5219601989,
-0.6782801151,
-0.1360084563,
-0.5787181258,
0.7280890346,
0.2448473275,
-0.1127216667,
0.2740470171,
0.4216167629,
0.1549234688,
-0.4914345145,
-0.6582688093,
-0.1610524356,
0.8412981629,
0.479829967,
0.4458600879,
-0.406403929,
0.2334041744,
0.1851594001,
-0.336831212,
-0.3333274126,
-0.5623965263,
-0.1263004243,
-0.5614851117,
-0.443926692,
-0.4042755067,
0.3078238666,
0.3916121125,
-0.1949648261,
-0.1948433965,
0.351072073,
-0.1569437385,
0.326380223,
-0.4416712821,
-0.4389614463,
-0.4986923635,
0.043931473,
-0.5248054266,
-0.2309666723,
-0.0351534933,
-0.1698051989,
0.1495058089,
-0.1542634219,
0.0968284458,
-0.2345935255,
0.9994467497,
-0.3830574453,
-0.658600986,
0.2154060304,
-0.8492155075,
0.9140934348,
-0.4176218808,
-0.187812537,
0.3776796162,
0.4499506354,
-0.3196624219,
-0.159098193,
-0.5898860693,
0.2893311083,
0.2994268239,
0.2812883854,
-0.7532501817,
-0.0540013611,
-0.053780999,
0.4945531785,
-0.5585323572,
-0.3314362764,
-0.4266965985,
0.1731611341,
0.8892951012,
0.0779427066,
0.8607617617,
-0.385648489,
-0.1898510158,
0.1384752393,
-0.400935173,
0.475872606,
0.0910390243,
-0.1773482561,
-0.548766315,
0.5551036596,
-0.276566118,
0.2989721298,
0.5481703281,
0.0452124588,
-0.076454781,
-0.4759440124,
-0.2964111567,
-0.2567666173,
0.8210340142,
0.3084197044,
0.1032339334,
-0.0604353957,
0.2985738814,
-0.1307981014,
0.4142816365,
-0.9100711942,
0.0386630222,
0.6472494602,
-0.4842871726,
-0.3769517541,
0.310893774,
-0.9129343033,
-0.6758601069,
0.1626649499,
0.1589804888,
-0.1049284041,
-0.2803978324,
0.2940380871,
-0.6248158216,
0.3654997349,
0.7794488072,
-0.5129265189,
0.08911632,
1.0171518326,
0.5858294964,
-0.1151451841,
0.4823768139,
-0.3149223626,
0.0501853265,
-0.3860717118,
1.1703515053,
-0.7089477777,
-0.215525493,
-0.1775105298,
-0.1398735642,
-0.2148315459,
-0.1438028365,
0.2497162968,
-0.4131239653,
0.1809035242,
-0.3901158869,
-0.1753982604,
-0.0553184897,
0.4112502337,
-0.0465181135,
0.4194789827,
-0.3065697849,
-1.1118788719,
0.182621479,
-0.5762845278,
-0.6258340478,
0.1989842951,
-0.3446652591,
-0.4648513198,
0.3050736487,
0.2846158147,
0.4699520171,
-0.5982940793,
0.5001932979,
-0.3767287135,
-0.1251662672,
0.1858490258,
-0.07705345,
0.9285324812,
0.0914935917,
-0.1591874063,
0.210968554,
-0.2653598487,
-0.4731428027,
-0.1382443458,
0.1118803248,
-0.3685564101,
-0.104051508,
0.1823088676,
0.6468527913,
-0.1031873897,
-0.9709108472,
0.0715770423,
-0.5874193907,
0.4648917913,
0.1422488689,
1.139705658,
0.2152128369,
-0.4573989809,
0.8932620883,
0.1997364908,
0.6363558173,
0.3197021782,
-0.7847367525,
-0.1999367028,
-0.3406339884,
-0.4489359856,
0.4827178717,
-0.191878736,
-0.0036221535,
0.0736006051,
-0.9830821753,
0.1175754219,
-0.5553188324,
0.0837843865,
0.1978395283,
-0.0940497518,
0.0474522635,
-0.3365560174,
-0.7222302556,
-0.673275888,
-0.2745394111,
0.4241086245,
0.3692232966,
0.5860975981,
0.1779908836,
0.4227505922,
-0.6873387694,
0.0027732549,
-0.1128333881,
0.573530376,
0.1922128499,
0.0826404318,
0.591332674,
-0.9195705056,
-0.6498135924,
0.3277362585,
-0.2406499833,
0.14551121,
-0.0882913694,
-0.1298015565,
-0.2194605321,
0.1775587797,
-0.4119690955,
0.8869177699,
0.2679833174,
-0.119478561,
0.5679208636,
0.2098436207,
0.6397023797,
-1.5528401136,
0.3092375994,
0.4119387567,
-0.0135700125,
-0.8017278314,
-0.0093548223,
0.0351611786,
-0.265768379,
-0.8235422969,
0.4855018556,
0.2946879566,
0.2519732714,
-0.0885877013,
-0.259013772,
0.3285803199,
-0.3082254827,
0.023388477,
0.9074841142,
0.5652963519,
-0.3641749918,
0.5572524071,
0.282769382,
-0.2222191542,
0.5382459164,
-0.5619007945,
-0.3682170808,
-0.1644911021,
0.5616639256,
-0.6542935967,
-0.5624964237,
0.3421842456,
-0.6186323166,
-0.383259356,
0.3153912127,
-0.0901079625,
-0.7480912209,
-0.4765667319,
0.0393680148,
0.3480303586,
-0.0949440151,
0.5657160282,
0.6652919054,
-0.0519104265,
-0.2985557616,
-0.5103573799,
0.4911627173,
-0.5112717152,
-0.5834178329,
0.442076683,
0.4462649524,
-0.5401530266,
-0.1309127957,
-0.1170103997,
-0.4308793545,
0.2538443506,
0.3852925301,
-0.4607791305,
0.0670144036,
0.3694576323,
-0.0285024755,
0.0077522132,
-0.1622707695,
0.2563541532,
0.4533587396,
-0.0240072254,
-0.1690818518,
-0.9589378238,
0.6182690859,
0.4312916696,
-0.2773728371,
0.7047954202,
0.6554099917,
-0.506054759,
-0.0207249317,
-0.454964757,
-0.0032254385,
-0.3287223577,
0.2489855587,
0.0833217129,
-0.5390870571,
0.2099906206,
-0.0330448076,
-0.387364924,
0.6785229445,
0.5264526606,
-0.3209837079,
0.745428741,
0.4028243423,
-0.3051244318,
0.5797583461,
0.0061840513,
0.283059746,
-0.5695840716,
-0.418366015,
-0.8575260043,
-0.0045318045,
-0.2511236072,
-0.3831379116,
0.3233534694,
-0.0712080672,
-0.3570715487,
0.3516744971,
-0.3143573999,
0.0360776223,
0.3483056724,
0.2987896204,
-0.0264055841,
0.0213845652,
0.4570967257,
0.0152831692,
-0.451210022,
-0.2017747164,
0.3759128749,
0.0353455581,
0.7669391632,
0.1025446206,
0.7947351933,
0.5306503177,
-0.0231346916,
-0.5420752764,
0.2386189997,
-0.5320286155,
-0.6701336503,
-0.2004228681,
0.0216052011,
-1.1031750441,
-0.2628575861,
-0.2338683456,
-1.134062171,
0.5943683386,
-0.0984300151,
-0.686784029,
0.1240500063,
-0.5035896897,
0.4097649753,
-0.0835779458,
-0.2068925053,
-0.8910170794,
-0.410344094,
0.4085770845,
-0.2854945362,
0.1658255607,
-0.3373838067,
0.311388433,
0.5701251626,
-0.5717824697,
0.6942254901,
0.1439929008,
-0.0021671937,
0.3476279676,
-0.3720327914,
0.0669064149,
0.4538876116,
-0.3348320425,
-0.0168771297,
0.0269468017,
-0.5905395746,
-0.1601978838,
0.5670199394,
-0.9715114832,
-1.2912088633,
-0.7746340632,
-0.1885566413,
0.1601032466,
-0.2010830492,
0.1088621989,
0.3915444613,
-0.5053525567,
0.0215046257,
0.3794079423,
-0.9115837216,
0.3599058092,
0.0781868324,
-0.3260602057,
-0.3469041288,
0.6842061877,
0.1107261181,
0.131236434,
0.5512223244,
0.5615690947,
0.3795010746,
0.1322095841,
-0.1691890955,
0.178173095,
0.0002209814,
-0.0355155244,
-0.7309997678,
-0.4011085629,
-0.449319452,
-0.0511000268,
-0.3717014492,
-0.186135456,
-0.4336353838,
0.2063840628,
0.6495030522,
0.9472608566,
-0.0786349326,
0.3041065335,
-0.6765033603,
0.5659813881,
0.4949758649,
-0.0072873635,
0.0664774403,
-0.2551439703,
-0.3351690471,
-0.0301148128,
-0.6418058276,
-0.7198652029,
0.377568841,
0.1770808548,
0.0236571543,
0.9308347106,
0.3675203323,
0.8832845688,
0.0449213013,
1.0471856594,
0.1588781923,
-0.9661799073,
0.6968218684,
-0.5644114614,
0.5001955628,
-0.0000512673,
0.2469650954,
-1.0989313126,
-0.4235027432,
-0.5566048026,
-0.4483423531,
0.721470952,
0.2043081671,
0.1593604386,
-0.129470855,
0.0535789505,
-0.0384615436,
-0.0394521393,
0.1030704528,
-0.3133440912,
-0.1210953221,
0.4321629405,
0.0135537293,
-0.1336745322,
-0.0637719706,
-0.364074409,
0.5091254115,
0.8099099994,
0.2996563911,
0.1840737611,
0.3067318201,
-0.4501870275,
0.5837232471,
0.8085808158,
0.6290799975,
-0.3686620295,
0.2372580469,
-0.3922748864,
-0.5578901172,
0.1191335097,
-0.108188048,
0.0155302156,
-0.1937268972,
0.1072151363,
0.5026251078,
-0.2300027311,
-0.2916655838,
0.8610102534,
-0.0715388581,
-0.0504469573,
-0.1918277442,
-0.0472073108,
0.3467203081,
0.4676606357,
0.6256601214,
0.2371505797,
0.3074696958,
-0.5147207975,
0.3484423161,
0.6539737582,
-0.4019289315,
-0.8979917169,
0.6173014641,
0.2785995901,
-0.1657125056,
0.0410746038,
0.2301861793,
-0.5994859934,
0.9830064178,
0.3663914502,
0.7503578663,
-0.5210822225,
0.9084612727,
0.5822774768,
-0.0017088476,
0.0503233671,
0.432654351,
0.248905465,
-0.4264401197,
-0.3715837598,
-0.1353907585,
-0.2549447715,
0.2579468191,
-0.7186770439,
0.3785772324,
-0.1913525611,
-0.6363061666,
0.2080693841,
0.0782722831,
-0.5986613631,
0.4387419224,
0.3140470386,
0.9239754677,
-1.228613019,
0.6670996547,
0.8263850808,
-0.5144660473,
-0.5014189482,
0.6642972231,
-0.1170756444,
-0.5825701952,
0.4476904869,
0.0316043608,
0.2495332211,
-0.3263299763,
-0.6913181543,
-0.9179583788,
1.0154591799,
-0.0773976371,
-0.2372927815,
0.3967687488,
0.216644153,
0.5561862588,
-0.3386307359,
0.0002308343,
0.1299681813,
0.3008340299,
0.0966869667,
-0.5835610032,
-0.1398021579,
-0.3129269779,
0.0976387337,
0.1278479844,
-1.0204116106,
0.7063922882,
0.0960384309,
-0.3439334333,
-0.2860353589,
0.449670881,
-0.0111741871,
0.7217000127,
-0.0375460684,
0.2382058501,
0.5553458929,
0.4792222381,
1.2949244976,
-0.0387527049,
0.2061321735,
0.7527274489,
-0.0264222305,
0.8392153978,
0.7293127179,
-0.252387017,
0.154765889,
0.5590337515,
0.3025370836,
0.4749020636,
0.2064546645,
-0.3363202214,
-0.4792795479,
-0.6584362984,
-0.5125205517,
0.3084346354,
0.5143564939,
-0.1958471388,
-0.5325256586,
0.343362689,
0.1369033307,
-0.0959712639,
-0.3394982517,
0.7124294043,
0.1523227543,
-0.3893086612,
0.1358245611,
0.1576743126,
0.1307755709,
0.0106266309,
0.0920876414,
0.0398307219,
-0.0846322775,
-0.2703766823,
-0.6903758049,
0.5189622045,
0.1686720252,
-0.070297651,
0.1625028253,
0.9302364588,
-0.1647454947,
-0.4484699368,
0.0519780479,
0.67843467,
0.2058836222,
-0.4739075303,
-0.8168716431,
-0.0260420218,
-0.0293177087,
-0.6117480993,
0.3068673313,
0.3723569214,
-0.412533015,
0.271790117,
0.1708301306,
0.1182371899,
-0.2220024467,
-0.04666676,
0.7029933929,
-0.6388854384,
-0.08955089,
-0.8996106982,
0.4117907882,
-0.4485413134,
-0.3489536345,
0.8975185156,
0.4113455415,
0.0301430337,
0.1402589232,
0.9951399565,
-0.2001914382,
0.371622175,
0.4690360725,
1.0461335182,
-0.5911262631,
-0.0658228546,
-0.2388710678,
-0.2515425384,
-0.5535464883,
0.305655539,
-0.9884823561,
-0.2286346704,
0.4569960535,
0.6121193171,
0.1395352185,
0.1499147713,
0.2685919404,
0.4833757281,
0.2946408391,
0.0908292532,
0.7989576459,
-0.3480213583,
0.0400689095,
-0.2725994885,
-0.363558501,
-0.6482157707,
-0.8017072082,
-1.0386712551,
-0.6005123258,
-0.4415652752,
-0.4413052499,
0.3973875344,
1.2267402411,
0.2722835839,
-1.0795857906,
-0.0943066403,
-0.1678567678,
0.1873834133,
0.0423225239,
-0.2105554044,
0.7510711551,
0.0815888718,
-0.3933435082,
-0.1011945829,
0.4769422412,
-0.1734790653,
0.2318412662,
0.337438941,
-0.615419805,
0.4659895003,
0.5065012574,
0.4879756868,
-0.7339120507,
-0.2552087903,
-0.01612298,
-0.6258727908,
0.1917058825,
0.1938588619,
-0.4743828773,
0.3515601456,
0.7884855866,
0.3414191306,
0.6053084731,
0.5213881731,
0.8258068562,
-0.1291522533,
-0.0852795467,
-0.112907894,
-0.1134794429,
0.1256935,
-0.3355008662,
-0.0229539704,
0.2715908289,
-0.390063107,
-0.3553667367,
0.3337637782,
-0.9794788957,
-0.1535962671,
1.4982144833,
-0.0550454184,
-0.5889920592,
-0.236795783,
-0.29186818,
0.4402599633,
-1.0021435022,
1.0111265182,
0.6030949354,
-0.0421697944,
-0.1773588359,
-0.2171879113,
0.225849539,
-0.0065776869,
-0.9009098411,
-0.5090588331,
-0.1571137756,
0.0092572002,
-0.4398283064,
0.3990473747,
-0.046904467,
0.4175576866,
-0.241056785,
0.2919133306,
0.3408403099,
0.0267234053,
-0.3278734386,
0.2429499626,
-0.1488411129,
-0.0301811844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04465v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04465v1 | Detecting Contextomized Quotes in News Headlines by Contrastive Learning | 2023-02-09T07:04:11 | 2023-02-09T07:04:11 | Seonyeong Song, Hyeonho Song, Kunwoo Park, Jiyoung Han, Meeyoung Cha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Quotes are critical for establishing credibility in news articles. A direct
quote enclosed in quotation marks has a strong visual appeal and is a sign of a
reliable citation. Unfortunately, this journalistic practice is not strictly
followed, and a quote in the headline is often "contextomized." Such a quote
uses words out of context in a way that alters the speaker's intention so that
there is no semantically matching quote in the body text. We present QuoteCSE,
a contrastive learning framework that represents the embedding of news quotes
based on domain-driven positive and negative samples to identify such an
editorial strategy. The dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/ssu-humane/contextomized-quote-contrastive. | [
-0.2722892165,
-0.6935946941,
0.6039784551,
0.2791025639,
-0.7438212633,
-0.0542566888,
0.0740731061,
-0.3746751249,
0.3559614718,
0.5237675309,
-0.7179231048,
-0.6732861996,
-0.5315562487,
0.1065866649,
-0.4343054891,
1.1870734692,
0.0794747844,
0.3230955899,
-0.3219890296,
-0.2209892869,
-0.4737772942,
-0.3547306359,
-0.5663154721,
0.1215174869,
0.4635803699,
0.4184788167,
0.5771817565,
0.4917553663,
0.3712790906,
0.0442856103,
-0.2033637613,
-0.2618487179,
-0.3741171062,
0.243427217,
-0.4597867429,
-0.4049091339,
0.3292636275,
0.3795097768,
0.5734189153,
0.7681182027,
0.0893941224,
-0.0692913532,
0.2324490845,
0.7951792479,
-0.8568618894,
-0.0229294002,
-0.788841486,
0.2093532383,
-0.0033309646,
-0.108791396,
-0.3180359006,
-0.7146959305,
0.1275321692,
-0.5063716769,
0.0612078272,
-0.061751619,
0.8946864605,
0.2758206129,
-0.8443102241,
-0.5807462335,
-0.3695242405,
0.8256478906,
-0.5728580952,
0.3234920502,
0.3178541064,
0.1086236164,
-0.0775427073,
-0.4488180578,
-0.3464490175,
-0.2909854949,
-0.2455997169,
0.226755932,
-0.0234745052,
-0.2465708554,
0.2598641515,
0.2541313767,
-0.3407706916,
-0.0637435913,
-0.0928404257,
-0.2161180973,
0.2897300422,
-0.2850755155,
0.1464754492,
-0.3707151115,
-0.6932486296,
-0.0292554535,
-0.7058606148,
-0.0707779676,
0.3055276275,
0.4996828437,
-0.0997218341,
0.3924431801,
-0.3063594699,
0.5010861158,
0.0664188117,
0.1139447242,
0.2550116777,
-0.1751617044,
-0.145038411,
0.4006071091,
0.3529914618,
0.4947530925,
-0.0379724056,
-0.0923293084,
-0.0571565293,
0.2334690243,
0.2753061354,
-0.7297240496,
0.0233312119,
0.1076834351,
-0.324084729,
-0.6026496887,
0.1910202354,
-0.8321895599,
-0.7438787818,
-0.1168378368,
0.3488349319,
-0.2726334929,
0.2768647373,
-0.1601213664,
-0.5701303482,
0.4015572667,
0.2875978649,
-0.2907133996,
-0.1119383425,
0.3040559888,
0.7633781433,
-0.10914094,
0.123838909,
-0.6002064347,
0.1035605669,
-0.5118271112,
0.9203083515,
-0.6127774715,
-0.3836417198,
0.2426182777,
-0.0309132431,
0.1614866257,
-0.4265771806,
1.3955243826,
-0.5174711347,
0.4532528818,
-0.6830881238,
-0.6816769838,
0.0249589514,
0.2742821872,
-0.6506419778,
0.7285159826,
0.0668912381,
-1.0174421072,
0.6293332577,
-0.487886548,
-0.7450015545,
-0.090605326,
-0.1618821323,
-0.7251935601,
0.1277492046,
0.1917059124,
0.335901767,
-0.0169835519,
0.062409129,
-0.2883630097,
-0.0600651652,
0.3411497772,
-0.1775792986,
0.8974473476,
0.4834316075,
-0.2913203239,
-0.240317151,
-0.7535662055,
-0.18038553,
0.0139943529,
-0.3511506617,
-0.7958304286,
0.2607438266,
0.179201439,
0.3591522872,
0.1602818072,
-0.5187795758,
-0.0049499664,
-0.1883056462,
0.2572416365,
0.6243168712,
0.5463661551,
0.4078065753,
-0.4209499359,
0.2920166254,
0.5004876852,
0.0720505044,
-0.1797552556,
-0.0898604989,
-0.4200316966,
-0.4040133953,
0.236146912,
0.5941949487,
-0.7684601545,
0.6306861639,
0.2680672407,
-0.2702742219,
0.1250242442,
0.0119387424,
0.1692234725,
0.8432900906,
0.6372942328,
-0.0350253284,
-0.7886463404,
-1.0013103485,
-0.9198150635,
0.2408130914,
0.0807490349,
0.2034101039,
0.5880322456,
-0.0129535999,
1.1712216139,
-0.699875772,
-0.4500519037,
0.2276124507,
0.2740334868,
0.1316304803,
0.5702374578,
0.5633589625,
-1.3123075962,
-0.4002077878,
-0.3569309413,
-0.918276906,
-0.296520263,
-0.3659351468,
-0.3168749809,
-0.2518554926,
0.8217943907,
-0.4857862294,
0.1894525886,
0.4117208421,
-0.3920638263,
0.6467955709,
0.3081779778,
0.2271960974,
-1.3811142445,
-0.0558963902,
0.2443324029,
-0.1143932566,
-0.5300554037,
0.1051845253,
0.1244646162,
-0.2011498064,
-0.6047942638,
0.3098757565,
-0.4205788076,
0.0952615887,
-0.1782280207,
0.2807095349,
0.3064540029,
-0.0189254899,
0.1774151921,
0.8976837993,
0.4912446439,
-0.4750556648,
-0.0926767215,
0.2994052768,
-0.6850515604,
1.1625974178,
-0.3778228462,
-0.1801795512,
-0.1507116854,
0.5942998528,
-1.0054883957,
-0.3511690199,
0.1422602981,
-0.195569694,
-0.223484993,
0.0308552776,
-0.161268726,
-0.0635247529,
-0.6547884941,
0.3152909875,
0.2879729867,
-0.5463954806,
0.1717164218,
0.4034661055,
-0.0922546312,
-0.7700541019,
-0.9617041349,
0.32030949,
-0.2981563509,
-0.0463888086,
0.3929319382,
-0.1511345655,
-0.1291633248,
0.1173862815,
-0.316179961,
-0.3632622361,
0.3137210011,
-0.015338677,
0.1254042089,
-0.2664704025,
0.2083627284,
0.4165523648,
0.2951970994,
0.0630784705,
-0.2017775476,
0.2463741452,
0.2285331935,
-0.1866259724,
-0.7147516608,
0.533206284,
0.4864231944,
-0.0352497138,
0.9154429436,
0.209246546,
-0.5519589186,
-0.0004815728,
-0.3853891492,
-0.2480973303,
-0.359362483,
0.2053040117,
0.0677669868,
-0.7209221125,
0.4894987643,
-0.1694643199,
-0.3765026927,
0.5492281318,
0.1661814898,
-0.3628720343,
0.8405925632,
0.3071510494,
-0.0754270926,
0.8737233877,
0.0868394226,
-0.0706085488,
-0.6906294823,
0.0116678691,
-0.63176018,
-0.1247532144,
-0.439958781,
-0.1194867492,
0.2327638119,
0.3722716272,
-0.1993150264,
0.3508174717,
-0.4903324544,
0.7846361995,
0.3801766038,
0.3099182248,
0.3476353884,
-0.0330687687,
-0.1251821369,
-0.1142932922,
-0.2317223698,
-0.5534666181,
0.6619698405,
0.0406621099,
0.7223502994,
-0.0007937602,
0.6867597699,
0.7612264156,
0.2284409404,
-0.7810051441,
0.3848752677,
-0.0286661014,
-0.6057053208,
-0.0207400192,
-0.3730401397,
-0.8102043271,
0.1929730773,
-0.4299757481,
-0.4879392087,
0.7242748737,
-0.1262001544,
-0.2299411744,
0.0965618491,
-0.6473622918,
0.8442816138,
0.1554469019,
-0.0241920874,
-0.2294144779,
-0.570992291,
0.3090147674,
-0.142403096,
0.4292000532,
-0.1037993878,
-0.1113014221,
0.7515152097,
-0.0887669176,
0.9045161605,
-0.2525636554,
-0.1874542385,
0.2749802172,
-0.0266090054,
0.6892623901,
0.1498431116,
-0.083771728,
0.0393442586,
-0.3047380745,
-0.6577090025,
-0.2910501659,
0.7584068179,
-0.5373755693,
-0.3558501005,
-0.5480672121,
-0.3266880214,
-0.3022398651,
0.2512383759,
0.441062361,
0.3707803786,
-0.6386358738,
0.4882445633,
0.4220096767,
0.0019856475,
0.365960151,
0.3196461499,
0.2735404372,
-0.628546834,
0.6507803202,
0.2003066242,
0.0644022971,
0.5036640763,
0.0860613957,
-0.1429809034,
-0.4959740937,
-0.0399865136,
0.0213033594,
-0.9435750246,
-0.3542094231,
-0.2858295441,
-0.0725751072,
-0.3392627239,
-0.6491262317,
-0.2236073166,
-0.5217257738,
-0.5940613151,
-0.1780898869,
-0.1264187247,
0.4649670422,
0.1010276228,
0.2867178619,
-0.5683876872,
0.1507085562,
0.3476021886,
0.1529940814,
-0.5931025743,
-0.3541061878,
-0.530466795,
0.1309665442,
-0.5639033914,
-1.1252924204,
0.2116606236,
0.0642978325,
0.5233240128,
0.5107005835,
0.5085017681,
0.1586417705,
-0.4489949048,
1.0046541691,
0.3146954775,
-1.1400970221,
0.7857390642,
-0.3805779815,
0.0925373435,
0.8263078928,
0.6779095531,
-0.5189418793,
-0.5849809647,
-0.4688926339,
-0.6692237854,
0.4373135567,
0.0996971354,
0.2776322663,
-0.4150485992,
0.3581734896,
0.1282105297,
0.4341952801,
-0.9232624173,
-0.2268050462,
-0.4798186719,
-0.1725934893,
0.0344114304,
-0.4683417082,
-0.4073544443,
0.0121102668,
0.5785874724,
-0.2120662034,
0.2110764831,
0.4336600006,
-0.4310908616,
0.0734076276,
0.5425395966,
0.8923637867,
0.5158575177,
-0.2098381221,
0.2552870512,
0.0224631317,
-0.4022425711,
0.0369563587,
0.0579890944,
-0.2010300905,
-0.0040581403,
0.2998220325,
0.5255622268,
0.5159395337,
-0.4615093172,
0.8016590476,
0.055261977,
-0.2513365448,
-0.4157803059,
-0.1986584514,
-0.1680259109,
0.3450846672,
0.9141450524,
0.4228444993,
0.42578125,
-0.6656376123,
0.4559169114,
0.6735683084,
-0.6077164412,
-0.1616372168,
0.7003547549,
0.3552421927,
0.09744405,
0.2049777061,
-0.1647926122,
-0.6071335077,
0.5494617224,
0.5575412512,
1.0886017084,
-0.170223251,
0.4814529419,
0.238220349,
0.2147154659,
-0.0211448967,
-0.1281009763,
-0.1203416809,
-0.8878613114,
-0.1755459458,
-0.3812337816,
-0.5935204029,
-0.0311929937,
-0.9008466005,
0.4517244101,
-0.524667263,
-0.0316966102,
-0.0088107502,
-0.057200294,
-0.1818525046,
0.5973913074,
0.2054862082,
1.0370362997,
-1.2545492649,
0.7976698875,
0.5741516948,
-0.5754861832,
-0.1120408252,
0.6680628657,
-0.1502870619,
-0.454048425,
0.656486392,
0.209880501,
-0.0644862652,
0.0555696748,
-0.7649502754,
-0.4495122433,
0.864482522,
0.6836352944,
-0.1639661193,
0.065486908,
-0.100583382,
0.2579224408,
-0.6918737292,
0.0720614642,
0.2358338535,
0.4861326814,
0.1070994437,
-0.3332527578,
0.1925450116,
0.160146758,
-0.0939029604,
0.0044038352,
-0.6482697129,
0.9368006587,
0.0218106899,
-0.2458171248,
-0.1482478827,
0.6345203519,
-0.2414928526,
0.489495784,
0.5638330579,
0.5108550191,
0.7626919746,
-0.0101835933,
0.9956691265,
-0.3105903566,
0.7066888809,
0.9167709947,
-0.3032041192,
0.9941709638,
0.5750334859,
0.1029162779,
1.1004906893,
0.4021564126,
0.0679481849,
0.9284290671,
-0.3257267177,
-0.5158222914,
-0.3140521944,
-0.2682803273,
-0.3642320931,
0.3670687675,
0.3822875321,
-0.5909764767,
-0.6363078356,
0.1127488911,
0.1262490451,
0.4518721998,
-0.2676686049,
0.6735062599,
0.2561924458,
-0.4119733572,
0.3674972951,
-0.1463835537,
0.3940993249,
-0.3564043641,
-0.0161102638,
-0.179016605,
0.0513620414,
-0.2552277744,
-0.7122790217,
0.4190770984,
-0.2493840754,
-0.4662129879,
-0.0339855738,
0.5804593563,
-0.4430097044,
-0.2693799436,
0.0886570588,
0.3533271849,
-0.2790947556,
-0.2154304683,
-0.910508275,
-0.0578617454,
-0.1052691266,
-0.4050551951,
0.4127296805,
0.2882304192,
0.0694504529,
0.3064323068,
0.6860129237,
-0.222622782,
-0.4092693925,
-0.1234441772,
0.8997465968,
-0.9008386731,
-0.8534682393,
-0.9261546731,
0.3259961009,
-0.6508506536,
-0.2380957156,
0.9506989121,
0.8208150864,
0.5391848087,
-0.2949111462,
0.8326800466,
0.2160397768,
0.6170963645,
-0.6992332339,
0.5484598875,
-0.431109041,
0.1307657212,
-0.3738794923,
-0.8480269313,
-0.6161302924,
0.8215949535,
-0.591344595,
0.0201124884,
1.0207923651,
0.6022905707,
0.0329002179,
0.2156207561,
0.3174768984,
0.2755197585,
0.0922791883,
0.3067150116,
0.7948996425,
-0.3993848562,
0.5412691832,
-0.1286052018,
-0.0430436283,
-0.4336695969,
-1.3737845421,
-0.8600557446,
-0.54303509,
-0.6808525324,
-0.3713124096,
0.2508502603,
0.9600537419,
0.5226985216,
-1.0082125664,
0.1417491734,
-0.4524243176,
0.4411470592,
-0.3614939749,
-0.3353152871,
0.3882688284,
-0.6294151545,
-0.5617833734,
0.3600800931,
0.034819141,
-0.0077848737,
0.1214023083,
0.314414233,
-0.5416831374,
0.5399050713,
0.5214714408,
0.3305267692,
-0.2801721394,
-0.7372789979,
-0.468696326,
-0.4805312753,
0.1247501373,
0.9343221188,
-0.8534376621,
0.0866196156,
0.3189747036,
0.6146954894,
0.1230427548,
0.3391093314,
0.1415731907,
-1.136102438,
0.2383836359,
0.230050385,
0.4073196054,
0.4601276517,
-0.5142356157,
0.2157950848,
0.7242826819,
-0.4567321539,
-0.8194248676,
0.3020295501,
-1.1490670443,
-0.5301445723,
0.9844602942,
-0.0101275668,
-0.2779836357,
-0.1898630559,
-0.3410328031,
0.0235128403,
-0.4589658082,
0.6700880527,
0.6900318861,
0.1453539282,
0.1189493686,
-0.3855235875,
0.6055083275,
0.2430285364,
-0.7974805832,
-0.067795679,
0.6043378711,
0.2565622926,
0.166786775,
0.3195623457,
0.1658283919,
0.3284214437,
0.082717672,
-0.023382904,
0.2306061387,
-0.0179710016,
-0.37127316,
0.3589024246,
-0.1676100045,
-0.3301668167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04460v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04460v2 | Bag of Tricks for Training Data Extraction from Language Models | 2023-02-09T06:46:42 | 2023-06-01T10:14:55 | Weichen Yu, Tianyu Pang, Qian Liu, Chao Du, Bingyi Kang, Yan Huang, Min Lin, Shuicheng Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | With the advance of language models, privacy protection is receiving more
attention. Training data extraction is therefore of great importance, as it can
serve as a potential tool to assess privacy leakage. However, due to the
difficulty of this task, most of the existing methods are proof-of-concept and
still not effective enough. In this paper, we investigate and benchmark tricks
for improving training data extraction using a publicly available dataset.
Because most existing extraction methods use a pipeline of
generating-then-ranking, i.e., generating text candidates as potential training
data and then ranking them based on specific criteria, our research focuses on
the tricks for both text generation (e.g., sampling strategy) and text ranking
(e.g., token-level criteria). The experimental results show that several
previously overlooked tricks can be crucial to the success of training data
extraction. Based on the GPT-Neo 1.3B evaluation results, our proposed tricks
outperform the baseline by a large margin in most cases, providing a much
stronger baseline for future research. The code is available at
https://github.com/weichen-yu/LM-Extraction. | [
-0.2202231288,
-0.6117814183,
0.4730132818,
0.0183654111,
-0.2260881811,
0.1954454631,
-0.3759003282,
-0.3385743797,
-0.1157108396,
0.4599506259,
-0.2609513402,
-0.753790617,
-0.7541751266,
-0.0918649137,
-0.6972991228,
1.3277754784,
0.1985030323,
-0.1546347141,
-0.0608262531,
0.1163037419,
-0.2684418559,
-0.6692954302,
-0.3200850785,
0.068373248,
0.4787969291,
0.3658153415,
0.2808571458,
0.9198733568,
0.5444791913,
0.2161819786,
-0.0899256095,
0.0181988198,
-0.4881495237,
-0.061436817,
-0.1014321521,
-0.4145087898,
-0.285556227,
0.2824339271,
0.903514266,
0.4333324134,
-0.1072437614,
0.3175537288,
0.1082233191,
0.6231649518,
-0.9415279627,
0.2211898863,
-0.8995857239,
-0.074677594,
-0.5806923509,
-0.2970554531,
-0.406652391,
-0.512684226,
0.0952079594,
-0.155372709,
0.4571401775,
0.0071785916,
1.0783851147,
-0.0566231199,
-0.0377962179,
-0.1788187176,
-0.4723619521,
0.6836714149,
-0.7211484909,
0.3239023089,
0.6547327042,
0.5323395729,
0.0594161712,
-0.8168241978,
-0.2591665685,
-0.2876708806,
-0.0841359645,
-0.169705838,
-0.0407405458,
-0.2692214251,
0.6106364727,
0.3811600208,
-0.4416766763,
0.2215425521,
-0.394181639,
-0.1076472998,
0.7519363761,
-0.2378947884,
0.1719707847,
-0.2613653839,
-0.3815157413,
-0.3890464604,
-0.7685349584,
0.104407452,
0.8424441814,
0.4393021762,
-0.1447430998,
0.3430511951,
-0.2714002728,
0.5195229053,
-0.261175245,
-0.0858249366,
0.3598212898,
-0.3343552351,
-0.1015404388,
-0.1199982166,
0.9664200544,
0.0119982278,
0.499624759,
-0.6740444303,
-0.3269541264,
-0.3425762653,
0.1884203553,
-0.8447733521,
-0.4815312624,
0.2080489099,
-0.5036805868,
-0.8268606663,
0.4476988912,
-1.1113375425,
-0.3720707297,
0.1202702746,
0.3407706618,
-0.3082870543,
-0.5500314832,
0.1388240308,
-0.3888622522,
0.2726744413,
-0.1783182472,
-1.253587842,
0.5308721066,
0.9098855257,
0.9006446004,
-0.435238272,
-0.0374691077,
-0.9352471828,
-0.0193121135,
-0.1578907967,
0.6561851501,
-0.5929906964,
-0.3224070072,
0.0791343302,
-0.0067772157,
-0.1219048053,
-0.5863344073,
0.3527525961,
-0.3643288612,
0.4626306295,
-0.030877253,
-0.6089645028,
0.2375653535,
0.1923934817,
-0.7139518857,
1.0172629356,
0.0235401392,
-0.8321626186,
0.3129108548,
-0.7636322975,
-0.3051912189,
0.152978003,
-0.2594917119,
-0.7712619305,
0.0915317982,
0.4510002732,
0.5696132183,
-0.1584316343,
0.1862318218,
-0.1811482161,
-0.3870725334,
0.5725215673,
-0.4541635513,
0.9605396986,
0.1955845654,
-0.4940795898,
-0.3117517531,
-0.7690620422,
0.2302383035,
0.2466941476,
-0.4245579243,
-0.3339569867,
-0.2194011956,
-0.1620825678,
0.0553017184,
0.0746932179,
-0.5092930198,
0.2675969303,
-0.5529585481,
0.2377831638,
0.768134892,
0.158676818,
0.5433496833,
-0.1767952144,
0.5861470103,
-0.3109003007,
0.0477450266,
-0.1576749235,
-0.4211162329,
-0.4449092448,
-0.5107302666,
1.0209063292,
0.5375571251,
-0.5704959631,
0.5119313002,
-0.5011854768,
-0.6152406335,
-0.6290569901,
0.2954051495,
0.5741167068,
0.2046671212,
0.1522251964,
-0.2724462748,
-0.2428121418,
-0.7038294077,
-0.6613644361,
-0.0181227364,
-0.0978588909,
0.172075212,
0.5487368107,
0.1920026392,
1.1070863008,
-0.5096806288,
-0.1339188665,
-0.1412399709,
0.2358607352,
0.0560445562,
0.7041996717,
0.4771221578,
-0.7705563307,
-0.228023544,
-0.0851415172,
-0.6841544509,
-0.0173250977,
-0.0306945927,
-0.1064703539,
0.0021645469,
0.3584083319,
-0.4055190384,
0.5389148593,
0.4471512735,
0.0346972011,
0.4922014177,
0.0254629124,
-0.2146380246,
-1.0705298185,
0.3381402493,
0.1140117124,
-0.4872395992,
-0.5514819622,
0.1552584916,
0.3295800388,
-0.2226739079,
-0.6876583099,
0.6693275571,
-0.6560918689,
-0.0217076093,
-0.206310451,
-0.0209939498,
-0.2520131469,
0.5191559196,
-0.0216966551,
0.5376861691,
0.6443876028,
-0.4404633939,
0.1800284833,
0.009203081,
-0.5484877229,
-0.0822624713,
-0.3881323934,
0.6858936548,
0.1610968858,
-0.1459267735,
-0.7898031473,
-0.0404838771,
0.5266080499,
-0.4165026546,
0.6075518131,
-0.4927909076,
-0.7151826024,
-0.0577979647,
-0.4681181312,
0.0220601503,
0.5675128698,
-0.7189062238,
0.0529213101,
0.5895196795,
-0.189285472,
-0.9246178269,
-0.4919676185,
0.0670117289,
-0.5311591625,
-0.0494100414,
0.3066353202,
0.213520959,
-0.1808855236,
-0.043332044,
-0.197231546,
-0.0057456209,
0.4567953944,
0.032111723,
0.213323161,
0.2490801066,
-0.0617433749,
-0.0534826629,
-0.301764518,
0.2106684744,
-0.1487774998,
0.5589567423,
-0.0770776346,
-0.2746030092,
-0.3147737384,
0.2291860878,
0.0629836619,
-0.3649943769,
0.6540731788,
0.4994660318,
-0.4633184373,
-0.3752042055,
-0.4436654449,
-0.4122136831,
-0.4725747705,
0.3334459662,
-0.1485671699,
-0.3735831082,
0.2190035135,
-0.3174670637,
0.2925503552,
-0.0171250403,
0.2207972109,
0.0841740221,
1.0631961823,
0.7241501808,
-0.3038540184,
0.7299695015,
-0.413261503,
0.2475339323,
-0.4233255982,
-0.1151994392,
-0.7906427979,
-0.1522554606,
-0.8788269162,
-0.1753167063,
0.1238476112,
0.2134129852,
0.354952246,
0.5292431712,
-0.4133976996,
0.6756421924,
0.551271081,
0.0100977933,
0.2619389296,
0.4094505608,
-0.0353230126,
-0.0109637082,
-0.6003652215,
-0.5871647,
1.3786292076,
0.5420398116,
0.4042463899,
0.0115898177,
1.2262749672,
0.0236975662,
0.4667585194,
-0.5286538005,
0.6392717361,
-0.1516076475,
-0.6960178614,
-0.3245222569,
-0.6654288769,
-0.9695227742,
0.1895535588,
-0.3262091577,
-1.0804824829,
0.1558919251,
-0.1621571183,
0.0303098317,
0.1227161735,
-0.6567075253,
0.9295022488,
-0.3193020523,
-0.4888209999,
0.273719579,
-0.6506338716,
0.3272621036,
-0.2388126701,
0.252051115,
-0.1444696486,
0.1897641271,
0.9486738443,
-0.3101430237,
0.6209874153,
-0.4195103049,
-0.0187775213,
-0.1230563447,
-0.0485275239,
0.6696830392,
0.124990195,
0.0200624466,
0.3648605645,
-0.0066379574,
-0.2162642628,
-0.7686556578,
0.3614260554,
-0.4115311205,
-0.3981881738,
-0.4144275784,
-0.2299147993,
-0.3282352388,
0.2191023231,
0.3855520785,
0.4779869318,
-0.1045564637,
0.380736798,
0.4857552052,
-0.1753858626,
0.608930409,
0.4366379082,
-0.1843457967,
-0.3419092894,
1.3046401739,
0.0566046946,
0.1353719831,
0.3341641128,
0.3868936002,
-0.4173189998,
-0.7424382567,
-0.3278553784,
0.2359945178,
-0.637819171,
-0.2426522076,
-0.4798431993,
-0.4973429739,
-0.5634426475,
0.4157717824,
-0.3157922924,
-0.6339927912,
0.1270639747,
-0.3313367665,
0.2331504077,
0.3236353099,
-0.1133584157,
0.2904910147,
-0.6683042645,
0.2167157829,
0.1667844057,
0.1783684045,
-0.2989838421,
-0.1459614336,
-0.3310206831,
-0.1716432571,
-0.3156898618,
-0.8764205575,
0.5180239081,
-0.009383169,
0.723993957,
0.4736820757,
-0.1366548091,
0.5610812902,
-0.3441106379,
0.5999967456,
0.0426302217,
-0.6290895939,
0.6473337412,
-0.3165642619,
-0.1545992941,
0.7809584737,
0.3113770187,
-0.2951855361,
-0.5950289965,
-1.0437617302,
-0.8441449404,
0.7585339546,
0.5675770044,
0.066878289,
0.2618345618,
0.3649971187,
0.3828279376,
0.4378130734,
-0.9565569162,
-0.1978702992,
0.1022535264,
-0.247651577,
0.0114204874,
0.1266244352,
-0.0357114375,
-0.0977897272,
0.5278326869,
-0.0161719061,
0.1098121107,
-0.322632283,
-0.1151818633,
0.2659886479,
0.2944172025,
0.0640079677,
0.675773561,
-0.3569566309,
-0.0502553731,
-0.1055629477,
-0.6052548289,
-0.1869412512,
0.4840791225,
-0.3449349999,
0.0968413502,
0.3053873777,
0.4750380814,
0.2071256489,
-0.6342359781,
0.8211320043,
-0.2206694186,
-0.3110851645,
-0.1388210505,
0.3821342289,
-0.1348742098,
-0.0702588707,
0.3311713934,
-0.2009516507,
0.1314765662,
-0.4418793917,
0.3272800446,
0.5272484422,
-0.1077002585,
-0.1198354587,
0.3972539902,
0.0174525306,
-0.5490489006,
0.5140776038,
-0.1898611635,
-0.2687501609,
0.3618640602,
0.4395066798,
0.9495685697,
0.0336348638,
0.3804944158,
0.2340248525,
0.2370598167,
-0.324252069,
0.0824129209,
-0.4346935451,
-0.6294434071,
-0.2016827017,
-0.4063355327,
-0.3754045665,
0.4872069359,
-0.8725360632,
0.4771153331,
-0.2833444774,
0.0699959472,
0.0180188846,
0.2505451739,
-0.8081457615,
-0.0584238619,
0.2009174526,
0.8311748505,
-0.829164505,
0.9602993131,
0.2909254134,
-0.3225018084,
-0.8262530565,
0.2316876948,
-0.140492782,
-0.6719799638,
0.3467757404,
0.3299432099,
0.1597970724,
-0.0344816893,
-0.7972138524,
-0.5873838663,
0.6818342209,
0.5373886228,
-0.6757310629,
-0.1806459874,
0.2756269276,
0.2817107737,
-0.2840208411,
-0.0656640008,
0.7192946076,
0.3552900255,
-0.469129473,
-0.68031317,
0.0451187901,
-0.3908161819,
-0.3322820365,
-0.0012283316,
-0.1909654588,
0.5744700432,
0.0609322563,
-0.4218538404,
0.1031131521,
0.265319407,
0.4601025581,
0.2793866396,
0.6404898167,
0.3544576764,
0.9729096293,
0.0392484404,
1.1415344477,
-0.1390217096,
0.4132996798,
1.0427899361,
-0.1261701286,
0.812856257,
0.3303679824,
0.1939520985,
0.3990576863,
0.4896334708,
-0.1378624141,
0.9593794942,
0.2969193161,
0.0340149552,
-0.0379415415,
0.2650056183,
-0.43495363,
0.5968111157,
0.1740358025,
-0.506162405,
-0.2265940309,
-0.0945616141,
0.2881946862,
-0.1200308502,
0.0768225417,
1.1179792881,
0.0422384776,
-0.6520498395,
0.4842078984,
0.0974190384,
0.3998867273,
-0.4882255197,
-0.1002774909,
-0.0965930894,
0.1188064069,
-0.0553051643,
-0.4935274124,
-0.1259451956,
0.500395,
0.2978389561,
-0.5797151327,
0.9484115839,
-0.3407256901,
-0.4505545795,
0.0350017697,
0.7745209336,
0.591556251,
-0.1363902688,
-0.6969854832,
-0.1806273013,
-0.1316497922,
-0.221012488,
0.5685773492,
0.3549035788,
0.1858723015,
0.2426649481,
0.9219177961,
0.5469653606,
-0.0775064006,
0.1422367394,
0.9336256385,
-0.6533030272,
-0.6551383138,
-1.1855629683,
0.3669581115,
-0.6490359306,
-0.4162071645,
0.8437478542,
0.7426825762,
0.7883146405,
0.1687313616,
0.9687228799,
0.160432592,
0.5860878229,
-0.7495083213,
0.8158393502,
-0.2563373446,
0.4295918941,
-0.5321546793,
-1.026301384,
-0.1313288361,
0.5920712352,
-0.4037972689,
-0.0653505251,
0.7518384457,
0.889829576,
-0.0908053368,
0.0852963328,
-0.0034069845,
-0.199544996,
0.6321724653,
0.3724871874,
0.9441407919,
-0.4712276757,
0.64520818,
-0.5955587626,
-0.2860483825,
0.0006122476,
-1.183793664,
-0.962302804,
-0.4893321395,
-0.4389201105,
-0.3600898385,
0.2028461099,
0.5796244144,
1.0574924946,
-0.6530516744,
-0.0179373287,
-0.1625560671,
0.2031834722,
-0.4569697082,
-0.2112374455,
0.4613296986,
-0.2767117321,
-0.7540742755,
0.4909235835,
-0.1613294631,
-0.0752785653,
-0.1541032493,
0.1293576807,
0.0705763176,
-0.3073522449,
-0.0333748311,
0.3538121879,
-0.1689029485,
-0.333108902,
-0.1258972287,
0.0115972208,
-0.0477726869,
1.0314164162,
-0.7496454716,
0.3005677462,
0.4717450738,
0.6731960177,
0.7289733887,
0.2241317779,
0.5123126507,
-1.1861222982,
0.1205087975,
0.2071797103,
0.1492978632,
0.3556102514,
-0.3549586833,
0.6602633595,
0.2155178785,
-0.3261931837,
-1.3067663908,
-0.1638342142,
-0.7042941451,
-0.1855611056,
1.3234465122,
-0.1537965983,
-0.4658347368,
-0.0340845808,
-0.0671121851,
0.2281539142,
-0.3084269166,
1.0568965673,
0.7382264733,
0.2524398565,
-0.0235953797,
-0.8103108406,
0.6729550362,
0.068811506,
-1.0108804703,
0.4255336821,
-0.0197606571,
0.5323440433,
0.0308667179,
0.6653225422,
-0.4828704,
0.3199289739,
-0.2295108736,
-0.2534451187,
-0.1889306158,
-0.4844384789,
-0.4626618028,
0.2292284071,
-0.2336602807,
-0.6027669311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04459v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04459v1 | Global Constraints with Prompting for Zero-Shot Event Argument Classification | 2023-02-09T06:39:29 | 2023-02-09T06:39:29 | Zizheng Lin, Hongming Zhang, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Determining the role of event arguments is a crucial subtask of event
extraction. Most previous supervised models leverage costly annotations, which
is not practical for open-domain applications. In this work, we propose to use
global constraints with prompting to effectively tackles event argument
classification without any annotation and task-specific training. Specifically,
given an event and its associated passage, the model first creates several new
passages by prefix prompts and cloze prompts, where prefix prompts indicate
event type and trigger span, and cloze prompts connect each candidate role with
the target argument span. Then, a pre-trained language model scores the new
passages, making the initial prediction. Our novel prompt templates can easily
adapt to all events and argument types without manual effort. Next, the model
regularizes the prediction by global constraints exploiting cross-task,
cross-argument, and cross-event relations. Extensive experiments demonstrate
our model's effectiveness: it outperforms the best zero-shot baselines by 12.5%
and 10.9% F1 on ACE and ERE with given argument spans and by 4.3% and 3.3% F1,
respectively, without given argument spans. We have made our code publicly
available. | [
-0.3523249626,
-0.6120147109,
0.6251446009,
-0.0035086358,
-0.4496958852,
-0.5340243578,
-0.366415143,
-0.5522003174,
-0.046798639,
0.2404683232,
-0.8127241731,
-0.5868247151,
-0.5148988962,
0.2687399089,
0.0921643898,
1.3578335047,
-0.2155851573,
-0.1789107472,
-0.3966349065,
-0.0023177858,
-0.7709910274,
-0.5443676114,
-0.702342689,
-0.0531809106,
0.6926222444,
0.692378521,
0.1676314771,
0.49482584,
-0.1966338605,
0.1083641052,
0.021369407,
0.1828544736,
0.0742254183,
0.3798328936,
-0.298235476,
-0.4265599549,
-0.1382074356,
0.1894772947,
0.4342933595,
0.3857184052,
0.1565004438,
0.1445655674,
-0.0491673611,
-0.2033138275,
-0.9553903341,
0.3552031219,
-0.861296773,
0.1792919487,
-0.4107806087,
-0.3457223475,
-0.5513854027,
-0.1036092639,
0.2596545517,
-0.6695497632,
0.5172808766,
-0.2081728876,
0.9775971174,
0.1347188503,
-0.400674969,
-0.2284890264,
-0.636829555,
0.7274913788,
-0.3329421282,
0.1032775566,
0.1417114735,
0.0960186347,
0.0274179503,
-0.4864601493,
-0.5018916726,
-0.3624557853,
0.0313815922,
0.1151185632,
-0.1620628536,
0.3760710955,
0.3993257284,
-0.1640532613,
-0.5814967752,
0.2899898291,
-0.3116713762,
-0.3028745055,
0.606864512,
0.2443850487,
0.1912903339,
-0.2884287834,
-0.3866718709,
0.2800079882,
-0.6642028689,
0.3757584095,
0.031333182,
0.525192976,
-0.1710234582,
0.2925198972,
-0.3980900645,
0.8353784084,
0.3550560176,
0.145194605,
-0.3587172329,
-0.2177241743,
-0.1486716121,
0.1237854883,
0.7145537138,
0.3136934042,
0.5209465623,
-0.1488812715,
0.3567846417,
0.051674515,
0.0455643348,
-0.9383201599,
0.1381380707,
0.19641985,
0.0535679646,
-0.2490463257,
0.1142960191,
-1.0320886374,
-0.5396124125,
-0.1945909113,
0.4102221429,
0.0124756377,
0.309317708,
-0.0617135391,
-0.1668115407,
0.1459920406,
0.7086619735,
-0.8335709572,
-0.1030990779,
0.4503142238,
0.8534604907,
-0.1775186211,
-0.1015146077,
-1.2197285891,
0.1637320518,
-0.0654269904,
0.9957648516,
-0.8300700784,
-0.3929764628,
0.2084267735,
0.0487468354,
-0.1624152064,
-0.2869236171,
0.8677543402,
-0.3016904294,
0.5008058548,
-0.1151909679,
-0.7294617891,
-0.032674171,
0.1772329211,
-0.3655773699,
0.5077835917,
-0.2980543673,
-0.5042567849,
0.8135665655,
-0.8006803989,
-0.3737187088,
0.4207333028,
-0.4579952061,
-0.4051084816,
0.0766708553,
0.7564790845,
0.685678184,
-0.143386215,
0.4911837578,
-0.5016186237,
-0.1236166731,
-0.1656710058,
-0.2944779098,
0.5531108975,
-0.1427152753,
-0.4671467841,
0.3507775068,
-0.7685160637,
-0.088424325,
-0.0275876522,
-0.051536072,
-0.0918845683,
0.089130275,
-0.2642762959,
0.1641649902,
0.0096535664,
-0.7093643546,
0.6148952842,
-0.3248053789,
0.0605819039,
0.7392004728,
0.4518770576,
0.4182119071,
0.1066806689,
0.8185510635,
-0.0863982067,
0.2818297148,
-0.3621180654,
-0.7774630785,
-0.3510147631,
-0.299677521,
0.3000472188,
0.867688477,
-0.5268117189,
0.3690763712,
0.0524682775,
-0.3445812762,
-0.083327502,
-0.027310567,
0.118653506,
0.6402917504,
0.4057305753,
0.109813951,
-0.8403514028,
-0.6224994063,
-0.0664740354,
-0.3641348183,
-0.1486617774,
0.2086500525,
0.2785250247,
0.1959082484,
1.0947813988,
-0.5527293086,
-0.5371341705,
-0.4552358985,
0.4563799798,
0.095759131,
0.3569646776,
0.4045965374,
-0.4563747644,
-0.5407927632,
0.1210462898,
-0.7190881968,
-0.6103774905,
-0.5823881626,
0.1641424298,
0.2711311877,
0.4399357438,
-0.7088622451,
0.9352825284,
0.0145822493,
-0.3158696592,
0.7308320403,
0.165810436,
-0.189701587,
-0.7625774741,
0.0452772304,
0.0998275727,
0.0506846793,
-0.8519595861,
-0.1192623377,
0.0173141751,
-0.1350706518,
-0.4078296125,
1.0262174606,
-0.3194732666,
0.5700393319,
-0.2601110637,
0.2033436596,
0.1361911148,
0.3667360246,
0.6071853638,
0.4447083175,
0.7736344337,
-0.7725340128,
0.1710037589,
0.3325300813,
-0.2991734445,
0.7287707329,
-0.5515527725,
-0.0565759912,
-0.213711381,
0.4317677617,
-0.7283363938,
-0.2579590976,
0.3288297057,
-0.4510729015,
0.3985362649,
-0.5608156323,
-0.0679969117,
-0.2026206255,
-0.1623148322,
0.2023288906,
0.2936131358,
-0.6077245474,
0.5231827497,
-0.057765495,
-0.2192133516,
-0.7546213865,
-0.3553975821,
0.0064344006,
-0.3133072257,
-0.5059909821,
0.3072251081,
-0.0690462962,
0.2145341337,
-0.1499651968,
-0.260086298,
-0.0839945748,
0.0452863276,
0.4658970833,
0.4690612853,
-0.2424880713,
0.0961878523,
0.0473200604,
-0.1875363588,
-0.1719685048,
-0.4375394285,
0.080697313,
0.189919576,
-0.2471071631,
-0.7858408689,
0.6216749549,
0.351418227,
-0.2605984211,
0.5787234902,
0.5922310352,
-0.2979140878,
-0.2752087414,
-0.5763737559,
-0.2327947021,
-0.4143042266,
0.3095077276,
-0.1573489606,
-1.1152441502,
0.4573705792,
0.1098965779,
0.2993888855,
0.2706124783,
0.4383231997,
0.2421343029,
1.0802477598,
0.240122512,
-0.0398146473,
0.6124085188,
0.1151778474,
0.0716774613,
-0.5937204361,
-0.1779455692,
-0.5990079641,
-0.1567701101,
-0.0400702283,
-0.3839676678,
0.4852475822,
0.521217227,
-0.150166437,
0.1876875907,
-0.4944550097,
0.6256854534,
0.4782136083,
-0.4374315143,
-0.0716646761,
-0.1046600863,
-0.246495828,
-0.1812740713,
-0.6657294631,
-0.3120676875,
0.8345932364,
0.056173034,
0.4152218997,
-0.3400736153,
1.0354722738,
0.1834475845,
0.4185495973,
-0.7779942751,
0.6451399326,
0.1959907711,
-0.9443936348,
-0.3286177814,
-0.26745525,
-1.2640366554,
0.266261965,
-0.1542619318,
-1.5703392029,
0.3902804255,
0.0937798321,
-0.8215081096,
0.4126816392,
-0.58264184,
1.0970470905,
0.0693992898,
-0.2929252088,
0.2974782586,
-0.4569563866,
0.1476376504,
0.2657473683,
0.0223544221,
-0.2994376719,
0.0674921721,
0.5922447443,
-0.1894361675,
1.1645985842,
-0.6526497602,
0.1417401433,
0.7506378293,
0.1370804906,
0.5861489177,
0.3140785396,
-0.0321710035,
0.0275666248,
-0.0270840377,
-0.102781415,
-0.6876511574,
0.3203472197,
-0.4885261953,
-0.8464083672,
-0.2846101224,
-0.3336187601,
-0.3533974588,
-0.0254033152,
0.5142326951,
0.6251068711,
-0.2675489783,
0.0815898478,
0.1791068017,
-0.0229029004,
0.6658305526,
0.6179804802,
0.0994070098,
-0.436812371,
0.7627474666,
0.190621078,
0.0624201223,
0.2854580879,
0.4533903897,
-0.4637160897,
-0.5074151158,
-0.8170292974,
-0.058211159,
-0.6864572763,
-0.4663136303,
-0.6549504995,
0.0197463371,
-0.4949149787,
-0.5171473026,
0.1161421314,
-0.6024614573,
-0.5546076894,
-0.3622172177,
0.1377000213,
0.4249669015,
-0.2906600237,
0.2805435956,
-0.9443987012,
0.0591394827,
0.3863495886,
0.1754225194,
0.0894179121,
-0.4338257909,
-0.1428314894,
-0.490873158,
-0.5318123102,
-1.1647408009,
0.1642250717,
0.6110044122,
0.714179039,
0.6829601526,
0.4744647741,
0.7252934575,
-0.6073891521,
1.1157461405,
0.1851939708,
-1.1532406807,
1.0332735777,
-0.2386516929,
0.2552098334,
0.5015112162,
0.5060344934,
-0.5594576001,
-0.5328196287,
-0.7126368284,
-0.6876205802,
0.9719087481,
-0.0426750742,
-0.1107199267,
-0.2914865613,
0.4936880469,
0.1841650307,
0.0276588667,
-1.0102107525,
0.0662095845,
0.0111993384,
-0.0623782612,
0.2866829932,
-0.1470374912,
0.0123127569,
-0.2539753318,
0.4763132334,
-0.333037138,
0.034321472,
0.4922308028,
0.0707520768,
-0.3342229724,
0.56595397,
0.7618803978,
0.3168489635,
-0.0958482176,
-0.0094386358,
0.5037136078,
-0.1112649441,
0.1281181425,
0.2283258438,
-0.5031450391,
0.1433537006,
0.5943383574,
1.0055507421,
0.0689049065,
-0.3943935633,
0.5174875259,
0.0032715402,
-0.3652708828,
0.0268025063,
0.1940817833,
-0.3171327412,
0.2994391024,
0.1943683028,
-0.2125737369,
-0.0132548045,
-0.2417803258,
0.3676308095,
0.5328035355,
-0.5783270597,
-0.457523495,
0.8170533776,
0.2367815673,
0.0750875175,
0.2471449971,
-0.4234043956,
-0.5111781955,
0.5005879998,
0.4344713092,
1.095212698,
-0.4039396346,
0.402182281,
0.6105357409,
0.1776436269,
0.3503995836,
0.3117839992,
-0.3088525832,
-0.5374457836,
-0.6256962419,
-0.5689454079,
-0.4996866584,
0.318151921,
-0.6265305281,
0.4297769666,
-0.5359874964,
-0.115391098,
0.2062172145,
0.024836272,
-0.5779479742,
0.0489656031,
0.6292080879,
0.8242263794,
-0.8994705677,
0.7834760547,
0.5742182732,
-0.5473439097,
-0.4920372665,
0.0121966982,
0.1870571524,
-0.398476541,
0.6062164903,
0.5162215233,
0.2408956289,
-0.3639676571,
-0.6505521536,
-0.5512216091,
0.5976177454,
0.3922095299,
-0.2143761963,
-0.1468927413,
0.055401545,
0.2341644913,
-0.5174465179,
0.1868428141,
0.016665237,
0.6650761962,
0.2945905924,
-0.9362254143,
0.1869508624,
0.1095162109,
-0.2722298205,
0.1199778616,
-0.2208839059,
0.6701824069,
-0.3436686397,
-0.556748271,
0.1210050508,
0.8119028807,
0.1416714936,
0.6801191568,
0.4956222177,
0.1953430921,
0.7934073806,
-0.0410773456,
0.9416118264,
0.0602160767,
0.1936014444,
1.236738801,
-0.6968386769,
0.7510629892,
0.1553811431,
0.232665509,
0.6337177753,
0.4482194483,
-0.0378470197,
0.3897565305,
0.1092109829,
-0.5279312134,
-0.6963890195,
-0.3305931985,
-0.1578587741,
0.4008493125,
0.4718391299,
0.1303835213,
-0.6437885761,
0.0118420422,
0.0967107117,
-0.1983111948,
-0.3757644594,
0.6761136055,
-0.0938613266,
-1.0406825542,
0.5327412486,
-0.1421726942,
0.5136350393,
-0.7400558591,
0.0334682167,
-0.048806224,
0.0612919144,
-0.1270780414,
-0.6830906868,
0.3477349877,
0.1869836599,
-0.1381287873,
0.1276754141,
0.7424359918,
-0.5446097851,
-0.1416119486,
0.2164562643,
0.286816895,
-0.0319468603,
-0.2894977629,
-0.4347656369,
-0.1093673706,
0.0236272011,
-0.1527409405,
0.4013028145,
0.6052082777,
-0.4639583826,
0.3644675016,
0.496571213,
0.0982332304,
0.1439440548,
0.004225492,
0.483188659,
-0.5862144828,
-0.5114987493,
-0.9922705293,
0.7155801058,
-0.2240174264,
-0.4456639588,
0.4302762151,
0.1777636856,
0.6205117106,
-0.1347968578,
0.8644630313,
0.0659859627,
0.2485485971,
-0.3424231112,
0.1281211674,
-0.5405727029,
-0.3333461583,
-0.1022269502,
-0.4113828838,
-0.7154328823,
0.4377256036,
-0.4661533535,
-0.3269189596,
0.4679582715,
0.5877872705,
0.1681078523,
0.264108181,
0.4662241936,
-0.3513818681,
0.527256906,
0.8057783246,
0.9158404469,
0.1129679978,
0.6512089372,
0.0776600242,
-0.3012738824,
-0.4345449805,
-1.2583452463,
-1.0888849497,
-0.5061651468,
-0.7899824977,
-0.1480006725,
-0.0622067004,
1.2777665854,
1.0141631365,
-1.1413420439,
-0.0359104089,
0.0432912074,
0.2026797086,
-0.202791661,
-0.2514753342,
0.2678129077,
-0.7158491015,
-0.6426271796,
0.6815888286,
0.2774487734,
-0.0033794655,
0.2097425908,
0.1992857158,
-0.1691011786,
0.3303900957,
0.5779640675,
0.8148130178,
-0.9107448459,
-0.6572865844,
-0.345477283,
0.346188426,
0.0291283764,
0.8679122925,
-0.7006432414,
0.4512672424,
0.2751327753,
0.5841013789,
0.4142502546,
-0.1174905151,
0.5762575269,
-1.3987721205,
0.2599402666,
0.2610265911,
0.3770127892,
-0.081080474,
-0.5320315957,
0.4059796035,
0.3513331413,
-0.4662647247,
-0.8106856942,
0.3891429305,
-1.0793566704,
-0.1356642693,
1.0879355669,
-0.301294595,
-0.1073851213,
-0.3010528684,
-0.3743282259,
0.3041629195,
-0.4288273454,
0.537135005,
0.6943533421,
-0.3697885275,
-0.2729869783,
-0.5638008714,
0.5460938811,
0.2620892525,
-0.6494554281,
0.359100759,
0.7043088078,
-0.0100467121,
0.3113628924,
0.5221720934,
0.1716002822,
0.4481067061,
-0.2046581656,
0.2473306358,
-0.3026942909,
-0.7316339612,
-0.4868488908,
0.6524299383,
-0.1717030406,
-0.4028637111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04456v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04456v2 | ERNIE-Music: Text-to-Waveform Music Generation with Diffusion Models | 2023-02-09T06:27:09 | 2023-09-21T09:30:00 | Pengfei Zhu, Chao Pang, Yekun Chai, Lei Li, Shuohuan Wang, Yu Sun, Hao Tian, Hua Wu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, eess.AS | In recent years, the burgeoning interest in diffusion models has led to
significant advances in image and speech generation. Nevertheless, the direct
synthesis of music waveforms from unrestricted textual prompts remains a
relatively underexplored domain. In response to this lacuna, this paper
introduces a pioneering contribution in the form of a text-to-waveform music
generation model, underpinned by the utilization of diffusion models. Our
methodology hinges on the innovative incorporation of free-form textual prompts
as conditional factors to guide the waveform generation process within the
diffusion model framework. Addressing the challenge of limited text-music
parallel data, we undertake the creation of a dataset by harnessing web
resources, a task facilitated by weak supervision techniques. Furthermore, a
rigorous empirical inquiry is undertaken to contrast the efficacy of two
distinct prompt formats for text conditioning, namely, music tags and
unconstrained textual descriptions. The outcomes of this comparative analysis
affirm the superior performance of our proposed model in terms of enhancing
text-music relevance. Finally, our work culminates in a demonstrative
exhibition of the excellent capabilities of our model in text-to-music
generation. We further demonstrate that our generated music in the waveform
domain outperforms previous works by a large margin in terms of diversity,
quality, and text-music relevance. | [
-0.4357208908,
-0.5913204551,
0.7399360538,
0.5669655204,
-0.2078301013,
-0.3808985054,
-0.3932585716,
-0.3899653852,
0.2630703151,
0.6630637646,
-0.8736881614,
-0.7538492084,
-0.4667052627,
0.0986533016,
-0.8785277009,
1.4670380354,
0.2396250069,
-0.1686190367,
-0.4704217613,
0.1961529851,
-0.6224712133,
0.1466521174,
-0.5649236441,
-0.1457539201,
0.6245465279,
0.1765431762,
0.2338982224,
0.2091046125,
0.18891792,
0.185012728,
-0.0963818058,
0.0227779131,
-0.3208525479,
0.5175597072,
0.1352241933,
-0.3459473848,
-0.2361043841,
0.1354932487,
0.4284942448,
0.6306078434,
-0.2771375775,
0.2616623938,
-0.0325738192,
0.7902534604,
-0.0624077506,
-0.3343888819,
-0.8445104957,
-0.0246194061,
-0.4435507059,
-0.1952175945,
-0.6232066154,
-0.4433413744,
0.230404228,
-0.7583217621,
0.3980083764,
0.0541904867,
0.533280313,
0.0804577768,
-0.4420578778,
-0.8840712309,
-0.9648019671,
0.5597621202,
-0.2933842838,
0.1274748296,
0.3105150163,
0.262280643,
-0.0255786218,
-0.7138506174,
-0.3056617677,
-0.3935079575,
0.3255963922,
0.3223067522,
-0.2574689984,
-0.1727962941,
0.1724528521,
0.3772042692,
-0.5742608309,
-0.3801014721,
-0.4426490664,
0.0217556041,
0.5926916003,
-0.1235485673,
0.5172258615,
-0.2306911796,
-0.4837512076,
-0.0552193969,
-0.834231317,
0.2191291153,
0.7623128891,
0.2848403454,
-0.0192460399,
0.5171837211,
0.26297912,
0.6646363735,
0.2021510154,
-0.1994639635,
0.1048454717,
-0.1426624507,
0.0038038071,
0.3603801131,
0.8491545916,
0.1791846603,
-0.0592633486,
-0.1906109452,
-0.5311945677,
0.1778755337,
0.0926476344,
-0.6602166295,
-0.1351915896,
0.083712019,
-0.7316133976,
-0.1087980866,
0.0187665801,
-0.703561902,
-0.1825476736,
-0.2922072113,
0.6876142621,
-0.520708859,
-0.2394643724,
0.0276530422,
-0.5138641,
-0.617824316,
-0.0033712918,
-0.8766213655,
0.0404538959,
0.5283195376,
0.8407379985,
-0.286110878,
0.3094474971,
-0.1921544075,
0.3259388208,
-0.2514313459,
0.967813611,
-0.4859311879,
-0.9411576986,
0.2300382107,
-0.4877400696,
0.2659884989,
-0.6272040009,
0.7604675293,
-0.4114028215,
0.5608123541,
-0.0818061829,
-0.6894785166,
-0.037041124,
-0.4704538882,
-0.6993026733,
0.9277756214,
0.2082860619,
-0.5594375134,
0.3214462996,
-0.6557082534,
-0.5197207928,
-0.1665789485,
-0.1323135048,
-0.4429415762,
0.2658058405,
0.0469585061,
0.1184717938,
-0.5195395947,
0.4418408275,
-0.2043941617,
-0.313161552,
0.4818150699,
-0.6022012234,
0.4357789159,
0.3783334494,
-0.1696209311,
-0.0833551213,
-1.1133503914,
-0.170369193,
-0.0509443954,
-0.3861335814,
-0.5725329518,
0.2318902761,
0.457000941,
0.0305363573,
0.0613112077,
-0.4232728779,
0.0899494141,
-0.3198979199,
0.2638455629,
0.5056803226,
0.2327927649,
0.6504389644,
-0.7117211819,
0.5738479495,
-0.2329971641,
0.0072835251,
-0.6697185636,
-0.7956749797,
-0.1822143346,
-0.3522345424,
0.4668927193,
0.36111027,
-0.6621329188,
0.1839740425,
0.0431875698,
-0.5215815902,
-0.6704569459,
0.0618792363,
0.0365210399,
0.8263036609,
0.5385282636,
-0.227163434,
-0.552537024,
-0.8184667826,
-0.0082524028,
0.0001215056,
-0.5285280347,
0.5371735692,
-0.1279839128,
-0.2100565583,
0.8789329529,
-0.3627675772,
-0.3020260334,
-0.0256132409,
0.4523206651,
0.6708828807,
0.676517725,
0.8142045736,
-0.7592625618,
-0.4646510184,
-0.5199649334,
-0.286478579,
-0.8407048583,
-0.2799975276,
-0.4107708335,
-0.2421103567,
0.2356240451,
-0.6025061607,
0.1673959345,
0.6694350839,
-0.252492696,
0.2441283613,
0.1789146513,
0.2444473505,
-0.9238848686,
0.0884081423,
-0.0517204292,
0.0511233062,
-0.6241535544,
-0.4755578935,
-0.2098046988,
-0.3057956398,
-0.2119639814,
0.2207549661,
-0.2820647061,
0.0526245274,
-0.374004066,
0.3335253298,
-0.0449469127,
0.1226677075,
0.0136390068,
0.6958627701,
0.8581260443,
-0.8063709736,
0.0057387948,
0.2595299482,
-0.4652809501,
0.846834898,
-0.8884020448,
-0.1008559465,
-0.2724271417,
0.2715976238,
-1.2145955563,
-0.1430653483,
0.0796553716,
-0.4470287263,
0.3505408168,
-0.0677116215,
-0.2925363183,
-0.27500844,
-0.1478872448,
0.6345754862,
1.0581204891,
-0.5101134777,
0.5143310428,
0.1008005813,
-0.3292284906,
0.1263570637,
-0.5164230466,
-0.1607923806,
-0.380240202,
-0.8983845115,
0.7681598663,
-0.4493575394,
-0.2132286876,
-0.0408637673,
-0.0440472849,
-0.0570997521,
0.0875311494,
0.4590575695,
0.3554231226,
-0.3247973919,
0.5704001188,
0.559024334,
-0.0516201928,
0.1318632364,
-0.7435567379,
0.2479611635,
0.7476346493,
-0.3423279524,
-0.4285458326,
0.7301249504,
0.1274385452,
-0.239332065,
0.1221990883,
0.4071474373,
0.1479996443,
-0.5492486358,
-0.0442893431,
-0.0441831872,
-0.5031131506,
-0.2975462675,
0.158902213,
-0.6856260896,
0.2252151221,
-0.230770573,
0.081309028,
0.5891775489,
0.4573715925,
-0.3196209371,
1.1519401073,
0.6052117348,
0.516474545,
0.9903666377,
0.0263528004,
-0.2672168016,
-0.7087717056,
-0.2396548688,
-0.8081221581,
-0.25430879,
-0.6694449186,
-0.2337814122,
0.6151498556,
-0.1640746593,
0.0403299481,
0.0506184064,
-0.7569496036,
0.0612395443,
0.6079865694,
0.2260796577,
0.1197648272,
0.1630463153,
-0.1519986391,
0.1270804107,
-0.3500142992,
-0.4299445152,
1.3594300747,
0.1101892963,
0.6518036127,
0.4289730191,
0.963865459,
0.7150511742,
0.5604016185,
-0.5202413797,
0.2614043653,
-0.2291128039,
-0.6399863362,
-0.0336624309,
-0.224836871,
-0.9501137137,
-0.0550656728,
-0.3647748232,
-0.4267617166,
-0.1693018228,
0.2309004068,
-0.3262454867,
-0.2170228809,
-0.6287802458,
0.4187226892,
-0.0014423253,
-0.2717880905,
0.0867285207,
-0.3204829991,
0.5198962092,
-0.2037299424,
0.5268626213,
-0.4423255324,
-0.1479916722,
0.712885201,
-0.1999149472,
0.5375977159,
-0.1521565765,
-0.5384601951,
0.6371750832,
0.0315169021,
0.2411943674,
0.3628341258,
-0.06677448,
-0.2014540583,
-0.4380550385,
-0.2059853524,
-0.438419342,
0.6998782754,
-0.5166765451,
-0.6632544398,
0.322375983,
-0.5322993398,
-0.3375067115,
0.1899116933,
0.5325285196,
0.7285652161,
-0.0488081984,
0.1716807932,
1.0131533146,
-0.2386600673,
0.7687009573,
0.3571325541,
-0.5288365483,
-0.6754735708,
0.7931545377,
-0.1683617234,
0.2312710434,
0.5521608591,
0.1579678655,
-0.4006571472,
-0.4812233448,
-0.5139743686,
0.1144039184,
-0.5340417624,
0.0050164098,
-0.4599100649,
0.3856748044,
-0.2445393354,
-0.0851376206,
-0.0002856531,
-0.6462727189,
-0.7336054444,
0.1706792265,
0.4201924205,
0.8070290089,
-0.1023233086,
0.3476785719,
-0.9318560958,
0.4275292754,
0.4241862595,
0.2126735747,
-0.0216133259,
-0.5537854433,
-0.0953916684,
-0.0942522585,
-0.3683127463,
-1.3137382269,
0.1240632981,
0.2672282755,
0.3921412826,
0.2733628154,
-0.1285440326,
0.3268843889,
-0.8487235904,
1.1093548536,
0.4122953713,
-0.943143487,
0.9576674104,
-0.7144449353,
0.0802804604,
0.2357566506,
0.3583414853,
-0.5028058887,
-0.5689089894,
-0.6779471636,
-1.0998141766,
0.3585127592,
0.3008812666,
0.4082551599,
-0.2048227191,
0.1666803658,
0.4958935082,
0.4200643599,
-0.733340621,
-0.2886267006,
-0.4528078735,
-0.5290749073,
-0.1360617578,
-0.0671923533,
-0.1477294862,
0.0172073357,
0.7325450182,
0.174466908,
0.5066716671,
0.3420735598,
0.0846110135,
-0.1786756665,
0.2893501222,
0.8085610271,
0.1645602733,
0.14893049,
-0.0660813674,
-0.5606897473,
-0.3031062484,
0.0967536122,
0.1455418915,
-0.7241114378,
0.3701843917,
0.3317057192,
0.8817585111,
0.2039625794,
-0.7093101144,
0.4749521315,
-0.0424274504,
-0.176988095,
-0.3327196538,
0.4008721113,
0.110034883,
-0.0030642292,
0.6715118885,
0.2467435002,
0.3010542095,
-0.2488269508,
0.4783046842,
0.1945614964,
-0.530107677,
-0.1740908772,
1.2301568985,
0.3426760435,
-0.4675081074,
0.2346146703,
-0.0332247019,
0.1562665999,
0.6849451065,
0.7665042877,
0.9537548423,
-0.0828207657,
0.290288955,
0.1989656985,
-0.1571607441,
0.058765091,
0.3636099398,
-0.5637548566,
-0.0261774659,
-0.0049575311,
-0.631963551,
-0.0288813077,
-0.1733466983,
-0.6859412789,
0.1664533764,
-0.2764455676,
-0.482131362,
0.1191392839,
-0.5729840398,
-0.3803200424,
0.121318616,
0.261420995,
1.0450630188,
-0.8760777712,
0.4726281464,
0.4049812853,
-0.40479213,
-0.6705486178,
0.3775985837,
-0.2104542553,
-0.2907619178,
0.4840566516,
0.1540006697,
0.0830919668,
0.1752444506,
-0.6053940058,
-0.7894895077,
0.910594821,
-0.0491398275,
-0.5982542038,
0.266083777,
-0.3045193851,
0.5456005335,
-0.4576464295,
0.219521299,
0.2384632826,
0.5083857179,
0.3885279894,
-0.4831821322,
-0.2968999445,
-0.2016240507,
0.2694987357,
0.3651687503,
-0.4043658376,
1.1041654348,
0.0504322201,
-0.125795126,
0.6071079969,
0.9446489215,
0.1293634176,
0.5013356209,
0.4983721673,
0.2388314754,
0.7404509187,
-0.1786564589,
1.0149152279,
-0.2374212742,
0.2340922505,
0.7081516385,
-0.220509246,
0.6220103502,
0.5360770226,
-0.1113776863,
0.7690015435,
0.6933367848,
-0.0971280038,
1.0135990381,
0.2978463173,
-0.7097600698,
-0.1712756008,
-0.3237583339,
-0.4390884042,
0.311134994,
0.2463721633,
-0.7860646844,
-0.0723297894,
0.3590641022,
-0.1349066198,
0.3691469431,
-0.4904005527,
0.5740292072,
-0.210491389,
-1.0007424355,
-0.0082283709,
-0.1480150968,
0.8550096154,
-0.6618509293,
-0.1809088886,
-0.1847955883,
-0.3947659135,
-0.0599410348,
-0.6890205145,
0.0667796209,
0.1336412877,
-0.6497578025,
-0.5506169796,
0.6941529512,
-0.767126441,
-0.3604853451,
0.1220754236,
0.2208676636,
-0.1240380928,
0.2484912574,
-0.3145340681,
-0.0569708236,
0.1425635964,
-0.0864310116,
0.1061539873,
0.6004918218,
0.1927392781,
0.2069966048,
0.770175457,
0.1668903828,
0.1737545878,
0.1633951813,
0.5970634818,
-0.4053240418,
-0.630284369,
-0.5826891661,
0.548836112,
0.2001899928,
-0.3842705488,
0.5762886405,
0.4438595474,
0.653547883,
-0.293993324,
0.9248216152,
-0.2276547551,
0.7230192423,
-0.8135557771,
0.7316626906,
-0.6640007496,
0.3184659481,
-0.444526732,
-0.6221974492,
0.052196376,
0.1285956949,
0.0410821624,
0.2371012866,
0.319578886,
0.6385597587,
0.0875924528,
0.2282964885,
0.1882278472,
-0.1274636388,
0.2946537137,
0.6408393979,
1.0600516796,
-0.3382265866,
0.6958007812,
-0.1941915452,
-0.1273875386,
-0.0501272753,
-1.0201356411,
-0.7428314686,
-0.8015691638,
-0.1180711687,
-0.1576707065,
-0.2962856293,
0.8930651546,
0.5281475186,
-0.5386865139,
-0.0129752476,
-0.0079672439,
0.358645469,
-0.1229210868,
-0.1972053498,
0.1735297889,
-0.1835632026,
-0.7604997754,
0.5237981081,
0.1849962473,
0.5458176732,
-0.2194276452,
-0.0538398884,
0.301035285,
0.4886516929,
0.6203864217,
-0.0270448327,
-0.4736920893,
0.0057439497,
0.0842546597,
-0.0801925957,
-0.0116436323,
1.0318022966,
-0.7534421086,
0.2661971152,
0.4342632592,
0.2668258846,
0.3548759818,
-0.028213555,
0.3042050302,
-1.0209805965,
0.0853070542,
0.1357235014,
0.1343338042,
0.1728900075,
-0.2374428213,
0.0482432507,
0.4413061738,
-0.4707414508,
-0.6374003887,
0.2987247705,
-1.0537903309,
-0.2039155215,
1.1871526241,
0.1223697439,
-0.3598484099,
0.1745176613,
-0.5278223753,
0.2531554401,
-0.5590188503,
0.8813806176,
0.539132297,
-0.2823832333,
0.1004681811,
-0.4705528319,
0.6026565433,
0.1652217954,
-0.5076164007,
-0.2869938314,
0.7808594108,
0.1367980242,
0.2835763097,
0.5733162761,
0.0859858543,
0.6298230886,
0.0615710467,
0.0516125076,
-0.1459714323,
-0.3825922906,
-0.071517773,
0.483291477,
0.0063156672,
-0.1885758936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06407v1 | Correcting Real-Word Spelling Errors: A New Hybrid Approach | 2023-02-09T06:03:11 | 2023-02-09T06:03:11 | Seyed MohammadSadegh Dashti, Amid Khatibi Bardsiri, Vahid Khatibi Bardsiri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spelling correction is one of the main tasks in the field of Natural Language
Processing. Contrary to common spelling errors, real-word errors cannot be
detected by conventional spelling correction methods. The real-word correction
model proposed by Mays, Damerau and Mercer showed a great performance in
different evaluations. In this research, however, a new hybrid approach is
proposed which relies on statistical and syntactic knowledge to detect and
correct real-word errors. In this model, Constraint Grammar (CG) is used to
discriminate among sets of correction candidates in the search space. Mays,
Damerau and Mercer's trigram approach is manipulated to estimate the
probability of syntactically well-formed correction candidates. The approach
proposed here is tested on the Wall Street Journal corpus. The model can prove
to be more practical than some other models, such as WordNet-based method of
Hirst and Budanitsky and fixed windows size method of Wilcox-O'Hearn and Hirst. | [
0.178660959,
-1.1316103935,
0.4412922561,
0.1134529635,
-0.0412901379,
0.443836391,
-0.3688269854,
-0.6804580092,
0.6452083588,
0.3039585352,
-0.5795421004,
-0.5359889269,
-0.3586955369,
0.3554728925,
-0.2672561705,
0.516898036,
-0.3572024405,
0.3406129479,
-0.1138248965,
-0.0521030426,
-0.6088414788,
-0.5705230832,
-0.1589481682,
0.1145077646,
0.4562292099,
0.4091206789,
0.762377739,
0.5953032374,
0.4545279443,
0.2190618515,
-0.2067580819,
0.6116742492,
-0.2314917445,
-0.2003843486,
-0.2295622528,
-0.7569354773,
-0.3493688703,
0.1602038741,
0.7544804811,
0.7070534825,
-0.3194703758,
0.0241151676,
-0.117252402,
0.5221834183,
-0.9583107233,
-0.3198404014,
-0.5384654999,
0.087879926,
-0.5486057997,
-0.110052973,
-0.444078356,
-0.5793025494,
-0.0309582017,
-0.7933165431,
0.4974846244,
0.3528190553,
0.9001734853,
0.1519573629,
-0.0947868749,
-0.0659332797,
-1.1232893467,
0.6423701048,
-0.7777064443,
0.4269156158,
0.2959280312,
0.2175215036,
-0.3307432234,
-0.4500630498,
-1.1083889008,
-0.2853792608,
-0.1886944771,
0.146314621,
-0.1050951183,
0.3836153746,
0.1695400476,
0.4205077589,
-0.4861702621,
0.1312719733,
-0.3023120165,
-0.5496787429,
0.3624994755,
0.0864332169,
0.5241732001,
-0.0900392681,
-0.1060691327,
-0.1667322218,
-0.5526506901,
-0.212045908,
0.4621527493,
0.2802759111,
0.0585190468,
0.8003019094,
-0.2296269536,
0.9167577624,
-0.0312247965,
-0.3829957545,
-0.0228942223,
-0.4827875495,
-0.1257092208,
0.1393716931,
0.2666943669,
0.2295947075,
0.1866270304,
-0.1450039446,
-0.0660072044,
0.4896636903,
0.2689656913,
0.0443387181,
-0.1084177122,
0.0483961105,
-0.2385199368,
-0.1534522623,
0.1123199165,
-0.6278208494,
-0.1408181489,
-0.3597872257,
0.7355992198,
-0.5642321706,
-0.0509737059,
0.3596500754,
-0.2024110556,
-0.1698331386,
0.1112350076,
-0.4823588133,
0.2607327402,
0.6524552703,
0.7258127928,
0.1248165891,
-0.4013677537,
-0.4023124874,
0.2949421406,
-0.2288258523,
0.9497556686,
-0.4999136627,
-0.2485926002,
0.1701779366,
-0.336671412,
-0.4470857978,
-0.7469360232,
0.5970309973,
-0.477057606,
0.5331742167,
-0.4192111194,
-0.7209903598,
-0.1235463023,
0.4254225492,
-0.7345721722,
0.9074121714,
0.1203183383,
-0.8513470292,
0.5374426246,
-0.4505819976,
-0.3494810462,
0.2267779708,
0.3409106731,
-0.4744800031,
0.0350718908,
0.1507169604,
-0.0466106683,
0.1618393213,
0.181129396,
-0.3370556533,
-0.3495249152,
0.23970595,
-0.1700577736,
0.6858014464,
-0.1563053429,
-0.046088852,
0.0213367753,
-1.0578408241,
-0.0547429696,
-0.0151858833,
-0.4029839039,
-0.6236377954,
-0.0911402404,
-0.0633907616,
-0.0036340442,
0.3399803042,
-1.0477507114,
0.3327213526,
-0.4170767069,
0.0756595284,
0.2681540549,
-0.0027072551,
0.2678116858,
-0.3383597136,
0.6640712023,
-0.1166470051,
0.1992911398,
0.5331351161,
-0.2299002707,
-0.7977229953,
-0.4105273783,
0.9093317389,
1.0038211346,
-0.6848269105,
0.4326919615,
-0.0664287582,
-0.457239151,
-0.6765040159,
-0.0161753297,
0.540756762,
0.4495255053,
0.4210895598,
-0.0550665259,
-0.9370948076,
-0.6736640334,
-0.858566761,
-0.1276922375,
0.4490662217,
-0.1531971842,
0.1386743486,
-0.171218276,
1.1531690359,
-0.6672871113,
-0.350631386,
-0.1769283712,
0.2610992491,
0.0521846712,
0.1926634759,
0.3114204109,
-0.578227818,
-0.2399542481,
-0.4240136445,
-0.4267737865,
-0.3224978149,
0.1816761345,
-0.088700816,
0.1823319346,
0.4383348823,
-0.4920546114,
0.5885190368,
0.5376959443,
-0.2189145833,
1.0288527012,
-0.550306201,
-0.1676396877,
-0.91181916,
-0.2508529425,
0.3207834065,
-0.154775396,
-0.666199863,
0.0966665521,
0.2269528508,
0.0742832646,
-0.3007673025,
0.3820968866,
-0.3625776172,
0.207859695,
-0.1679417789,
0.0410219729,
-0.1858650297,
0.086234577,
-0.0623216778,
0.7727560997,
-0.0513132736,
-0.5761676431,
0.5549045205,
0.2225978822,
-0.1316744238,
0.5753836632,
-0.1822189093,
-0.2065047324,
-0.2937080264,
0.6383674145,
-1.1107747555,
-0.2186245471,
0.3214327991,
-0.18991822,
0.2910396457,
0.3126447201,
-0.7540608048,
-0.779656291,
-0.1756541133,
0.4526014924,
-0.0401166938,
-0.543264091,
0.2345048785,
0.2423240244,
0.0835099444,
-0.4246705472,
-0.5319592953,
0.2808578908,
0.0321302712,
-0.799965024,
0.6390599608,
0.1557087898,
-0.3767775893,
0.1994136721,
0.105784215,
-0.0368642397,
-0.1241240278,
-0.259113282,
0.6989332438,
0.010266752,
0.0857234746,
-0.2124868482,
-0.2599958181,
-0.4712629318,
-0.49680686,
0.3693607748,
0.2010866851,
-0.2040085047,
-0.4964635074,
0.2273118794,
0.2722576559,
-0.3402099311,
0.7867879272,
0.4588625729,
-0.6892276406,
-0.2808198631,
-0.9090560675,
-0.0771362782,
-0.3648515344,
0.1356813461,
0.0547276698,
-0.8241165876,
0.2571591735,
0.1034937948,
-0.2588778138,
0.4155606627,
0.4512482285,
-0.1261587888,
0.7487785816,
0.7456762195,
0.2139074802,
0.3112801015,
-0.1303829253,
0.9771966338,
-0.6382302642,
-0.151638791,
-0.3950403333,
-0.5407431126,
-0.6198772788,
-0.2527080178,
0.6304124594,
0.0583745316,
0.5193476677,
0.7464958429,
-0.444535464,
0.2431215495,
1.0013308525,
0.2731578946,
0.3406199217,
-0.0631433725,
-0.612829268,
-0.2372443974,
-0.71644485,
-0.3640681803,
0.8138329387,
0.0597289465,
0.4924426079,
-0.1144366935,
0.7504734397,
0.1610264778,
0.0144389234,
-0.6159237623,
0.6314756274,
-0.3492311537,
-0.8439390063,
-0.2703474462,
-0.2220506668,
-0.5108207464,
0.2065542489,
-0.741797328,
-0.7153809667,
0.2253659219,
0.4971597493,
-0.8793985248,
0.6379120946,
-0.8029863834,
0.6604875326,
-0.2256654203,
-0.4204533994,
-0.5026088953,
-0.4027852714,
0.4746885598,
0.0396815725,
0.3019882739,
0.0633312985,
0.2145886868,
0.7268741727,
-0.658177793,
0.7490065694,
-0.0477627292,
-0.0203551613,
0.2781471908,
0.197835207,
0.5559649467,
-0.4878141284,
-0.0093380716,
-0.1407577097,
0.3583651185,
-0.1709671915,
-0.3558157384,
0.2014031857,
-0.3505501449,
-0.3345527351,
-0.5517811775,
-0.7360454798,
-0.4422079027,
-0.0000954773,
0.6049287319,
0.302744627,
-0.3294065893,
-0.1814506352,
0.1760453433,
-0.1454586834,
0.2392683029,
0.4606271088,
-0.0141594252,
-0.3132999241,
0.8082965016,
0.6572244763,
-0.0499977209,
0.4699242711,
0.4371334016,
-0.3150163293,
-0.4682387114,
-0.1040573642,
0.6425394416,
-0.2114739865,
0.0288076047,
-0.6997754574,
-0.1861997396,
-0.542157352,
-0.1414114088,
-0.1439823359,
-0.4838040173,
-0.2169806063,
-0.0008583465,
0.1022546217,
0.583039403,
-0.3180800676,
0.5473636985,
-0.8589069247,
0.3634515703,
0.4335005879,
0.4193993509,
-0.2302924544,
-0.1742039621,
-0.1478003412,
0.21499075,
-0.3355554044,
-0.9623072147,
0.3842346668,
-0.002471959,
0.4815409482,
-0.0468553901,
-0.0930813029,
0.8270902038,
-0.2030323893,
0.6997148991,
0.1546032131,
-0.8381558657,
0.3248400092,
-0.2801672816,
-0.1492479742,
0.5707076192,
0.0576400198,
-1.0047852993,
-0.2684865892,
-0.9241304994,
-0.538413465,
0.4570803046,
-0.0265845191,
-0.4338185489,
0.0234469976,
0.4487594962,
-0.177945748,
0.1396143287,
-0.4666870534,
0.1588367671,
0.4074417055,
-0.3431168795,
0.1503443271,
-0.6799925566,
0.0514416732,
-0.3411953151,
0.9995115995,
0.1624086797,
0.0259897821,
0.2917439044,
-0.3337662518,
-0.3469190001,
0.3559055626,
0.6399739981,
0.7287827134,
-0.3173407018,
-0.0136834923,
0.3608635366,
-0.5016331673,
0.0880405903,
0.0354272686,
-0.3316845894,
0.2257179171,
0.4513094723,
0.5032865405,
0.3447655737,
-0.489240855,
0.5470725894,
0.2814438045,
-0.4734819829,
-0.2904867828,
-0.1031388417,
-0.0231570005,
-0.1429912746,
0.079071641,
0.1678159535,
-0.0328887887,
-0.6595336795,
0.0732633546,
0.4725888073,
-0.0763727278,
-0.2542811334,
0.5356152654,
0.1425318122,
-0.4914407432,
0.3659648895,
-0.4574806094,
-0.9835479259,
0.2915571928,
0.9738420844,
0.6762968302,
-0.1871972829,
0.3175331056,
0.3684365451,
0.1213304996,
-0.5579844117,
0.408451438,
0.4884602726,
-1.0098690987,
-0.5054373741,
-0.526565671,
-0.6276236773,
0.0758338049,
-0.2796168625,
0.4046176672,
-0.652184844,
-0.1830598265,
0.0057498608,
0.0797563642,
-0.4394032359,
0.3679074347,
0.3424119353,
0.7927343845,
-1.0085633993,
0.5102444291,
0.8548640013,
-0.1748053879,
-0.9900035858,
0.1159285828,
0.2467886209,
-0.814781487,
0.2904692888,
-0.1892139018,
-0.1171085313,
-0.0749726519,
-0.5852720737,
-0.7753100395,
0.7551982403,
0.1701934189,
-0.9299541712,
-0.3569753766,
0.04839902,
0.5959841013,
-0.0194971357,
-0.1589046717,
0.6729858518,
0.5451921821,
0.0271286201,
-1.226926446,
-0.3049503565,
0.0714211389,
0.1086879522,
0.4216983318,
-0.5158858895,
0.817520082,
-0.126521185,
-0.2510852814,
-0.000214352,
0.5338090062,
0.310939908,
0.2584782839,
0.7232407331,
1.017374754,
1.0723763704,
0.0621608272,
0.8653191924,
-0.3172161579,
0.3821319342,
0.7107711434,
-0.3487734497,
0.8320525289,
0.4755266905,
-0.4827481508,
0.6247027516,
0.4345484376,
0.1426234245,
0.192385748,
0.3515938222,
-0.4742093086,
-0.2764520347,
-0.1844139248,
0.0664874464,
0.5636621118,
0.3694781363,
0.074373357,
-0.3720751703,
0.0011064358,
0.0992306024,
0.6393350363,
-0.1069085523,
0.4002002776,
-0.094767347,
-0.7173142433,
0.3761418462,
0.4633672237,
0.9876490235,
-0.2967776358,
-0.0469226502,
0.1206462383,
0.3915683329,
-0.3414590061,
-0.4367204607,
0.36488989,
0.012739378,
-0.1607501954,
0.1679546833,
0.9220731258,
-0.5956460238,
-0.8967123628,
0.1325419098,
0.345635891,
-0.3520382643,
-0.106095612,
-0.294018805,
-0.3041204512,
-0.1654579788,
0.5524679422,
-0.2608949244,
0.1050331965,
-0.2867365181,
0.3659325838,
0.7591435313,
0.7494556904,
0.4316912591,
-0.0543563329,
0.2237702608,
-0.6130846143,
-0.88929528,
-0.6497017145,
0.064724952,
-0.0484452471,
-0.2705034614,
0.6572399735,
0.5018294454,
0.870762229,
0.0447447896,
0.9669387937,
0.0205408148,
1.1207876205,
-0.5723782182,
0.0495871753,
-0.3662091196,
0.0387216061,
-0.4092158675,
-1.0556932688,
-0.7114766836,
0.4141554534,
-0.6681829095,
-0.441432327,
1.0058119297,
1.0177019835,
-0.246189177,
0.1995067,
0.0254498664,
0.2110127062,
-0.0308220219,
0.3604298234,
0.7248407602,
-0.3003739119,
0.3341653049,
-0.4458749294,
-0.4029726684,
-0.5831348896,
-0.7414032817,
-0.3285211325,
-0.425599128,
-0.3474107683,
-0.6106498241,
0.2794748545,
1.2176921368,
0.3986369967,
-0.6988270879,
-0.0282747913,
-0.0102793369,
-0.122052595,
-0.512907505,
-0.164263308,
0.3229456544,
-0.152273044,
-0.3812304735,
0.3110454977,
0.2934426963,
0.0087611554,
-0.1479192227,
0.3017433286,
-0.5592952967,
0.0081461631,
0.3079155684,
0.3710101843,
-0.6602450609,
-0.6487806439,
0.1091436297,
-0.2058946639,
0.0631744862,
0.8780732751,
-0.557267189,
0.5424692631,
0.7749196291,
0.4523746371,
0.244163543,
0.2126417756,
0.6748664379,
-0.620267272,
0.2685517967,
0.095432736,
0.3523594141,
0.3973683715,
-0.6220071912,
0.2650634348,
0.8750808835,
-0.1467503607,
-0.5195037127,
0.0788115188,
-0.8711966276,
-0.1668273658,
1.1812918186,
0.5319515467,
-0.51719594,
-0.0072732917,
-0.4147280455,
0.7104387879,
0.130482614,
0.8755858541,
0.9800272584,
0.114812158,
0.1369806528,
-0.3345319331,
0.2397274226,
0.5332192779,
-0.4819864035,
-0.0521255247,
0.5163853168,
0.4320471883,
0.3383947909,
0.5058403611,
-0.0822762549,
0.3177591264,
-0.1713183671,
0.232945919,
0.1124202386,
-0.2449292094,
-0.1792318225,
0.0270530544,
-0.0824090987,
-0.4673706591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04449v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04449v3 | Read and Reap the Rewards: Learning to Play Atari with the Help of Instruction Manuals | 2023-02-09T05:47:03 | 2023-10-26T08:23:48 | Yue Wu, Yewen Fan, Paul Pu Liang, Amos Azaria, Yuanzhi Li, Tom M. Mitchell | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | High sample complexity has long been a challenge for RL. On the other hand,
humans learn to perform tasks not only from interaction or demonstrations, but
also by reading unstructured text documents, e.g., instruction manuals.
Instruction manuals and wiki pages are among the most abundant data that could
inform agents of valuable features and policies or task-specific environmental
dynamics and reward structures. Therefore, we hypothesize that the ability to
utilize human-written instruction manuals to assist learning policies for
specific tasks should lead to a more efficient and better-performing agent. We
propose the Read and Reward framework. Read and Reward speeds up RL algorithms
on Atari games by reading manuals released by the Atari game developers. Our
framework consists of a QA Extraction module that extracts and summarizes
relevant information from the manual and a Reasoning module that evaluates
object-agent interactions based on information from the manual. An auxiliary
reward is then provided to a standard A2C RL agent, when interaction is
detected. Experimentally, various RL algorithms obtain significant improvement
in performance and training speed when assisted by our design. | [
-0.2379639745,
-0.2023575157,
0.4852752686,
0.0873468891,
-0.1030238047,
0.0975830778,
-0.0717928931,
-0.7810814381,
0.2016322166,
0.6457120776,
-0.7838993073,
-0.238223508,
-0.4793216884,
0.0658006817,
0.137315914,
1.0425151587,
-0.1044637188,
-0.2893443406,
-0.2137604356,
-0.0952635631,
-0.4064597487,
-0.2660808265,
-0.928894639,
-0.6778950691,
0.9929203391,
0.6933825016,
0.5051950812,
1.0547003746,
0.4799397886,
0.3575494289,
0.0989035144,
0.3848174214,
-0.4880094528,
0.624545157,
-0.1644115448,
-0.8638250828,
-0.0955855772,
-0.0698050708,
0.1613694131,
-0.1474420279,
-0.0912292898,
0.2098455727,
-0.1029197127,
0.9089643955,
-0.7796122432,
0.3740474582,
0.0859939232,
0.3272903264,
0.2461616844,
-0.7173622847,
-0.6630432606,
-0.2813062668,
-0.1565364897,
-0.8840664625,
0.0275718831,
-0.0112881893,
0.8545041084,
0.3009220064,
-0.2459862679,
-0.6508942842,
-0.7449949384,
0.7795529962,
-0.2689141631,
0.4472252727,
0.5244752765,
0.3014393747,
-0.1119806916,
-0.6218183637,
-0.491269052,
-0.4005011916,
-0.1710481644,
0.114427112,
0.0390462428,
0.0247327909,
0.4347909987,
-0.0119801946,
-0.2580045462,
-0.0552294441,
-0.4050486088,
0.0750265568,
0.9113703966,
0.3161811829,
0.4477508366,
-0.0135651324,
-0.6599342227,
-0.6838749647,
-0.597255826,
0.7873060107,
0.4901448488,
0.0148437545,
0.0860944912,
0.497623235,
0.0922627002,
0.4289106429,
-0.1882092506,
-0.3318940699,
0.2433695644,
-0.136742115,
0.129636094,
-0.1746232063,
0.1622885913,
0.2732798159,
0.3452428877,
-0.3511404693,
-0.7925568223,
-0.3901101649,
0.6330197453,
-0.5814638734,
-0.246537894,
0.3754791617,
-0.8519979715,
-0.3168021739,
0.0656026676,
-0.7798629403,
-0.7841446996,
-0.6419407129,
0.5880922079,
-0.3247410655,
-0.1482247114,
0.047028888,
-0.7070528865,
0.4483199418,
0.5087615848,
-1.0288603306,
0.1782161295,
0.7972460389,
0.7818999887,
-0.1089024246,
-0.4708506465,
-0.7197327614,
0.1451020539,
0.0095906621,
1.2020246983,
-0.4058485031,
-0.2718077004,
0.1413463503,
0.1365946978,
0.0040958771,
-0.4626169205,
0.0817923918,
-0.7502304912,
-0.2007471174,
-0.1956860423,
-0.4966332316,
-0.2705353796,
0.3233102262,
-0.9092144966,
0.6775798798,
-0.0789275542,
-0.3879584074,
0.4364813566,
-0.7363914251,
-0.7802549005,
-0.1347175241,
0.1403106451,
-0.079899393,
-0.0641032979,
0.1831206679,
0.1253387183,
-0.0430373847,
-0.2669173181,
0.184539035,
-0.7025392056,
0.1622857451,
-0.4900713265,
0.6806263924,
0.2624042034,
-0.7003666162,
0.2012753338,
-0.3321659565,
0.2968081534,
-0.1805464178,
-0.7474970222,
-0.1131991446,
0.4422092438,
0.0128443204,
-0.0390936844,
0.2563830316,
-0.2066671997,
0.4360604882,
-0.1191660091,
0.0183203537,
0.8773522377,
-0.0124232732,
0.4346709847,
-0.6186011434,
0.894611299,
-0.1018355042,
0.1642908901,
-0.2964397967,
-0.0841160864,
-0.6545827389,
-0.3991535008,
0.2882865667,
0.9329354167,
-1.0075331926,
0.2870363593,
0.113209188,
-0.5691688657,
-0.5139735341,
0.2582736909,
0.6455990076,
0.0683050901,
0.3610040843,
-0.3402178586,
-0.2456633002,
-0.6057406664,
-0.1801516563,
-0.4318658113,
-0.1949352473,
0.8958033919,
0.2893239558,
-0.0064931964,
0.5320270658,
-0.6152768731,
-0.4297675192,
-0.3060665429,
0.2622136772,
-0.0444294177,
0.3257800639,
0.0739548057,
-0.7181074023,
-0.2583681345,
-0.0299797226,
-0.7926532626,
0.0459217951,
-0.3063839376,
-0.1502068192,
0.2070243955,
0.6391865015,
-0.1949362606,
0.5083952546,
-0.0282242447,
-0.6123353243,
0.315756768,
-0.6279582381,
0.4242904186,
-0.3746351898,
0.1552214921,
-0.1490438879,
-0.418495059,
-0.3198923171,
0.2016564012,
0.0005217651,
0.2337682098,
-0.4957216084,
0.4570533335,
-0.4963403642,
-0.2065426707,
-0.3037025332,
0.0289809853,
0.060286928,
0.6217120886,
0.4589045644,
1.0709471703,
0.0905848145,
-0.6850115061,
0.442275703,
0.1470443755,
-0.2535698116,
0.277048856,
-0.5450882912,
0.0531539731,
-0.4233548045,
0.2175471187,
-0.6404550672,
0.1968742162,
0.4362829924,
-0.347930789,
0.4131795168,
0.1942398697,
-0.1367228776,
0.1236364841,
-0.3539613783,
0.0171354543,
0.4552949667,
-0.6524047852,
0.8105377555,
0.5659662485,
0.1514108032,
-0.9274665117,
-0.464019835,
-0.2444757372,
-0.0124138026,
-0.2339176834,
0.0208907239,
0.0440234169,
-0.0760111958,
0.1744674891,
0.1674095094,
-0.0883137211,
0.2685406804,
0.3967072368,
-0.0893125013,
-0.2771205306,
0.4217954576,
-0.3501193225,
-0.2956038415,
0.0061920825,
-0.1952934116,
0.2944519222,
-0.0095035816,
-0.0550797172,
-0.3514369726,
0.3669557273,
0.3091447949,
-0.3344735801,
0.5462056994,
0.3790245652,
0.0840876028,
-0.226240769,
-0.1270360351,
-0.3571166694,
-0.4338615239,
0.3970764577,
-0.2389615476,
-0.3478995562,
0.2709340155,
-0.059765663,
0.524273634,
0.0055361362,
0.2636499405,
-0.259190321,
0.934771955,
0.6792302728,
-0.102137588,
0.8885636926,
-0.3739873767,
-0.1974566132,
-0.5248176455,
-0.5885187984,
-0.6216547489,
-0.8610140085,
0.0594824664,
-0.4192473888,
0.0038214053,
-0.0489725359,
-0.3723858893,
0.2556801438,
-0.5526057482,
0.8593112826,
0.8129585981,
0.4366841614,
0.2286759466,
0.0208456609,
0.1228485331,
0.1498099566,
-0.5224131346,
-0.4434260726,
1.0539711714,
0.3653973639,
0.9267832637,
0.4400946796,
0.982345283,
0.9539274573,
0.413576901,
-0.8647901416,
0.3589038551,
-0.023467185,
-0.3968240023,
-0.5754511356,
-0.1938024908,
-1.1527837515,
0.1146529391,
-0.204667151,
-0.6721926332,
0.4781820774,
0.1899258643,
-0.429245919,
0.2759683132,
-0.8636550307,
0.8632751703,
-0.4272989929,
-0.4699736238,
-0.3103561997,
-0.6846058965,
0.1498540789,
0.5040696263,
0.1369136423,
0.3389107287,
-0.4084806144,
0.5717496276,
-0.1531823725,
0.602689445,
-0.3660921156,
-0.1342520267,
0.2467489243,
0.2285686433,
0.5035741925,
0.087105073,
-0.0702980459,
-0.3430424929,
0.1687580496,
-0.4183028936,
-0.8114535809,
0.1465899646,
-1.1356041431,
-0.5050407648,
-0.6745374203,
-0.7098213434,
0.0248206966,
0.0611186065,
-0.1427753717,
0.4778710902,
0.13883847,
0.2107940763,
0.7409709692,
-0.0454505235,
0.2289991379,
0.6414028406,
0.0521760844,
-0.1629237831,
1.2463866472,
-0.2806339562,
0.2486912459,
0.6523099542,
-0.1933657676,
-0.5204709172,
-0.1732815355,
-0.57453686,
-0.1087179333,
-0.7877373099,
-0.2282173783,
-0.3836003542,
-0.0382600464,
-0.0900093243,
-0.2407559603,
0.0817482695,
-0.0804561079,
-0.3478213549,
0.092080839,
0.3943522573,
1.1374810934,
-0.5022678375,
0.1609591991,
-0.788472712,
0.2416563183,
0.2549151182,
0.1791731566,
0.3671440482,
-0.1266246885,
-0.3380183578,
0.0589832813,
-0.3289092779,
-0.785887301,
0.3661533594,
0.0199626945,
0.454277724,
0.4108802378,
0.0488793291,
0.40561077,
-0.4546313584,
0.512332201,
-0.186546877,
-0.6017742157,
0.0766567737,
0.2221115232,
-0.0674080551,
0.6127911806,
0.204700619,
-0.6506441832,
-0.2378869504,
-0.5576035976,
-0.8849704862,
1.1501915455,
-0.2689836025,
-0.1740905643,
0.2164401412,
0.3742713034,
-0.0650081336,
0.2715714872,
-0.4933120012,
-0.2903100252,
-0.1197416782,
-0.2647564113,
-0.4623934925,
-0.2305574268,
-0.0950073227,
0.0908285156,
0.6943279505,
-0.0419886895,
0.3498270214,
0.4133959711,
-0.3320500553,
-0.1552498043,
0.0528076254,
0.8163985014,
0.3693345487,
-0.3459355235,
0.2634063065,
-0.3938545287,
-0.6656491756,
0.5652338266,
-0.1032459959,
-0.2540394962,
-0.4829722345,
0.6325077415,
0.7648227811,
0.3524870276,
-1.2411586046,
0.2759419084,
-0.4824875891,
-0.2622564733,
-0.1220038459,
0.6421294212,
0.0712818578,
0.8556362391,
0.1317038387,
0.0509291515,
0.1007425487,
-0.6402665973,
0.6755157113,
0.1900855154,
-0.5262126327,
0.2568953335,
0.3497052789,
0.2952744961,
-0.8615558147,
0.7069941759,
-0.2032310367,
-0.5366960168,
1.0435376167,
0.5435180664,
0.5914231539,
0.3517859876,
0.5890440345,
0.0872463137,
0.3160039783,
-0.1566240191,
0.4217413366,
-0.3884488046,
-0.510232985,
-0.1135835201,
-0.3001527488,
-0.544369936,
-0.2004317939,
-0.6502736807,
-0.1064587608,
-0.3980673254,
0.2178023905,
-0.0557818301,
0.377294898,
-0.6626974344,
-0.0997868404,
-0.1948139071,
0.9126482606,
-0.6772400737,
0.4918405712,
0.6648137569,
-0.8594995141,
-1.1647884846,
0.0390858129,
-0.3690181971,
-0.7599953413,
0.9848240614,
0.0650725067,
0.035352122,
0.2336907685,
-0.3612166643,
-0.5924975276,
1.287353754,
-0.0645584315,
-0.2826133966,
-0.0480901897,
-0.3024445176,
0.4600914419,
-0.4023989439,
0.5737560391,
0.5277518034,
0.5884191394,
0.1404809058,
-0.2741996646,
-0.0784912556,
-0.1910418272,
-0.3738976419,
0.1912070215,
-0.4101630151,
0.8476195931,
-0.3595324457,
-0.065063864,
0.0123254778,
0.6798278689,
0.4169762433,
0.4627650082,
0.7172281146,
0.2652747631,
0.8752666116,
0.1848089993,
1.2511407137,
-0.1696391255,
0.2308644801,
0.6065813899,
-0.2985121608,
0.9842727184,
0.4333688617,
-0.2231706232,
0.6477149129,
0.6086822152,
0.0851320922,
0.6567600369,
0.2445954978,
-0.4735414982,
-0.4632597566,
-0.1824976206,
-0.2047350258,
0.1752974242,
0.2113692611,
-0.2739548981,
-0.3580367267,
0.0547292344,
-0.3331312239,
0.1043815762,
-0.4211519361,
0.9585288167,
-0.1740716845,
-1.0150316954,
0.3480148315,
-0.0777568743,
0.5894215703,
-0.6057679057,
-0.5719681978,
-0.194559589,
0.5813255906,
0.0198258497,
-0.8479340076,
-0.1237943023,
-0.0367592201,
-0.4291846752,
-0.2636851668,
0.7355104089,
-0.4362428784,
-0.0670897588,
0.1572808027,
0.4653507173,
0.4513597786,
0.322696805,
-0.7767964602,
-0.1525213867,
0.1038056239,
-0.4308458269,
0.4341948032,
0.4448980391,
0.1167157218,
0.8732992411,
0.6854454279,
0.2409509271,
-0.3132275045,
-0.4246698022,
0.5613506436,
-0.7117715478,
-0.6243695021,
-0.4291898012,
0.2789290845,
0.0010048948,
-0.3304855525,
0.2556996047,
0.5188625455,
0.6163221598,
-0.1388811022,
0.6250049472,
-0.1434394419,
0.29807356,
-0.7505011559,
0.9348198175,
-0.8396161795,
0.1588532776,
0.3554801345,
-0.4411746562,
0.0066664689,
0.7086086869,
0.0585965253,
-0.0555490591,
0.5874980688,
0.7922065854,
0.1781934053,
0.0108460533,
0.2316113412,
-0.316110611,
0.4877370596,
0.7166268229,
0.5619158149,
-0.1536401957,
0.4802992642,
-0.1288729906,
-0.2603989244,
-0.3151064813,
-0.8284192085,
-0.8500044346,
-0.4100271463,
0.237868309,
-0.6761803031,
0.6011861563,
1.1437239647,
0.2958872616,
-0.6540828347,
-0.4298355281,
0.0586949103,
0.8213217854,
-0.7948714495,
-0.2373357415,
0.5053654909,
-0.601795435,
-0.6958078742,
0.2501647174,
0.0551418737,
-0.1753884405,
-0.4507740438,
-0.51554811,
-0.3888763785,
0.0676762238,
0.2937460244,
0.9533269405,
-0.3958920538,
-0.4446924329,
0.2063487917,
-0.1989232302,
-0.1481547207,
1.2465561628,
-1.1465595961,
0.3187000453,
0.6186580062,
0.9202744961,
0.1344392896,
0.0894472972,
0.7521838546,
-0.3181188703,
0.222780332,
0.2572665513,
0.0089629563,
-0.2334721833,
-0.4705054462,
0.5053565502,
0.0643998459,
-0.6899587512,
-0.8348277807,
0.1938859522,
-0.4498718977,
-0.324717164,
1.030487299,
-0.413726151,
-0.6438968778,
-0.3045249283,
-0.514721334,
0.2477615774,
-0.658528626,
0.8782755733,
0.5578398108,
-0.1226625741,
-0.2571013272,
-0.5369916558,
0.8195157051,
0.3302169144,
-0.852003634,
0.1396107972,
0.4405213892,
0.0759667307,
-0.0568899103,
0.7344669104,
0.2282207608,
0.7005155087,
0.1590092629,
0.41329512,
-0.5960180163,
-0.7403556108,
-0.2744745016,
0.118607901,
0.1151991785,
-0.1974974573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04443v1 | Enhancing E-Commerce Recommendation using Pre-Trained Language Model and Fine-Tuning | 2023-02-09T05:20:52 | 2023-02-09T05:20:52 | Nuofan Xu, Chenhui Hu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR | Pretrained Language Models (PLM) have been greatly successful on a board
range of natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, it has just started
being applied to the domain of recommendation systems. Traditional
recommendation algorithms failed to incorporate the rich textual information in
e-commerce datasets, which hinderss the performance of those models. We present
a thorough investigation on the effect of various strategy of incorporating
PLMs into traditional recommender algorithms on one of the e-commerce datasets,
and we compare the results with vanilla recommender baseline models. We show
that the application of PLMs and domain specific fine-tuning lead to an
increase on the predictive capability of combined models. These results
accentuate the importance of utilizing textual information in the context of
e-commerce, and provides insight on how to better apply PLMs alongside
traditional recommender system algorithms. The code used in this paper is
available on Github: https://github.com/NuofanXu/bert_retail_recommender. | [
-0.4922853112,
-0.7050807476,
0.3145707846,
0.0746265203,
-0.5971220732,
-0.096013397,
-0.4342945218,
-0.7137046456,
0.176156193,
0.8310357928,
-0.7696435452,
-0.6215837598,
-0.1664986163,
0.0192459598,
-0.1086439118,
1.3274828196,
0.2376386225,
0.0407651961,
-0.2346072495,
0.0410983339,
-0.663274765,
-0.8447272182,
-0.5935032368,
-0.3269814551,
0.1659857929,
0.2799070179,
0.4953825176,
0.1971318275,
0.6309601665,
0.3178498149,
0.2210212499,
0.4592844844,
-0.680646956,
0.0687894449,
-0.2183227837,
-0.4829070866,
-0.6688864231,
-0.0985798612,
0.0778401569,
0.595813334,
-0.4716828763,
0.1228686869,
0.2143079937,
0.8793644309,
-0.642927289,
-0.0459348969,
-0.5773826241,
-0.1668360084,
-0.0481540896,
-0.3681309521,
-0.5311528444,
-0.2677358389,
0.7709480524,
-1.0588541031,
0.1676391214,
0.5497004986,
0.8196353912,
0.0410137065,
-0.0851068944,
-0.5256376863,
-1.1555337906,
0.9589240551,
-0.6642743349,
0.3895688653,
0.7437030077,
0.1317907423,
-0.0765812397,
-0.894454062,
-0.1269797236,
-0.2560476065,
-0.3422780633,
0.0049835364,
-0.2762557864,
0.0546878502,
0.2006477863,
0.4884551466,
-0.4068588316,
-0.0308823939,
-0.3176213503,
0.1670431048,
0.5176237226,
0.0710493773,
0.1772108525,
0.4226148129,
-0.3248051107,
-0.0552779958,
-0.4358149767,
0.1060107201,
0.408996582,
0.3831226826,
-0.0154489484,
0.2304225713,
-0.3814243376,
0.9063743949,
0.2529188991,
0.0337816253,
0.2480902225,
-0.490762502,
-0.2972324789,
-0.1041165292,
0.4287195206,
0.7144600749,
0.7465674281,
-0.015813062,
-0.1619277298,
-0.2623039484,
0.5096711516,
-0.6262496114,
-0.3693131506,
0.0130056515,
-0.6031510234,
0.0218533203,
0.471624136,
-0.5004669428,
-0.0722141489,
-0.595469892,
0.3369835913,
-0.3328958452,
0.0113890953,
0.5729392767,
-0.0972741842,
-0.1267429888,
0.160602659,
-0.829149127,
0.7239254713,
0.652633667,
0.5475583673,
0.0595654659,
-0.1725259125,
-0.2530723512,
0.2429627329,
-0.0485836007,
0.9208053946,
-0.6399960518,
-0.2896060944,
0.2922262549,
0.1022100672,
0.2109635323,
-0.7524974942,
0.8438139558,
-0.5697077513,
0.0288028046,
-0.1721766144,
-0.844755888,
-0.2359755188,
0.2031970769,
-0.725069344,
0.805028379,
-0.1811017394,
-0.3219821155,
0.6281147003,
-0.4817241132,
-0.7131964564,
0.228812471,
0.5580585599,
-0.4804368019,
0.1984646171,
0.474529326,
0.5827817321,
-0.2774088681,
0.1400252581,
-0.5063348413,
-0.6700719595,
0.0815832317,
-0.03367557,
0.4227854609,
0.2869699895,
-0.121442385,
-0.0448377132,
-0.6570322514,
0.0541332178,
0.0036548157,
-0.0499817282,
-0.647270143,
0.175176248,
0.3512240648,
-0.0896343216,
0.3703715205,
-0.2234736979,
0.0587683581,
-0.7634453177,
0.2821847796,
0.5494908094,
-0.1931194365,
0.5329089165,
-0.7355468869,
0.4556611776,
-0.3170196712,
0.2490454912,
-0.3160306513,
-0.3181807995,
-0.8961794376,
0.0809464082,
0.4569807053,
0.426938653,
-0.5199533105,
0.6964008808,
0.0475442447,
-0.4406291842,
-0.4336357415,
0.2846370637,
0.1781228483,
-0.0757220313,
0.5409368277,
-0.4617347419,
-0.7543962002,
-0.7050154805,
-0.6705191731,
0.0232806038,
-0.1566803753,
0.5439575315,
-0.0669434965,
-0.2875417471,
0.7877614498,
-0.615427196,
-0.6894193888,
-0.3374413848,
-0.0058507626,
0.3869016171,
0.376837194,
0.5488106012,
-0.5138007402,
-0.6596776843,
-0.1281357706,
-0.0573951118,
-0.2469967008,
-0.0102284597,
-0.0268150084,
-0.0199311767,
0.1856046319,
-0.1574904323,
0.2932097614,
0.4155053198,
-0.2852952182,
0.4393902123,
-0.7730149031,
0.195310995,
-0.9322850704,
-0.326936543,
0.4632714391,
-0.3885262311,
-0.6631515026,
-0.1813074946,
-0.0866781771,
0.1374993622,
-0.3661179841,
0.2667980194,
-0.2533771098,
0.1012369543,
-0.4236115515,
-0.0953193158,
0.2398156226,
0.3469708562,
0.1776812673,
0.505833745,
0.3919576406,
-0.9421775341,
0.0134612788,
0.1661946625,
-0.6217550039,
0.5872378349,
-0.6843920946,
0.1259984225,
0.1032593548,
0.1826690882,
-0.6518378258,
0.2912837565,
-0.0695916563,
0.0917926803,
0.1480959356,
-0.0277996417,
-0.5398219824,
-0.2132227868,
-0.3509077728,
0.3230811954,
0.5698596835,
-0.5629171133,
0.4040985107,
0.3043610156,
-0.3029129505,
-0.105947271,
-0.3947110772,
-0.0070298291,
-0.16891554,
-0.5119259357,
0.7426927686,
-0.3850310147,
-0.0685154051,
-0.2711165249,
0.1641370654,
0.1545787901,
0.2841474414,
0.0312511213,
0.3254998028,
-0.2268506736,
0.1752837747,
-0.0926151425,
-0.3204894066,
-0.0319760367,
-0.6556138992,
0.6028752923,
-0.4058052301,
-0.1882551759,
-0.6120371819,
0.0063928319,
0.1760100722,
-0.2107855976,
0.6770848036,
0.531244874,
-0.2096508145,
-0.538176775,
-0.7454895377,
-0.3049114645,
-0.5346107483,
0.2017220557,
-0.1433936059,
-0.8679746985,
0.0047311201,
-0.3593667448,
-0.3375680447,
0.263792783,
0.4861273766,
-0.3384718597,
1.079077363,
0.9573925734,
-0.0260962192,
0.7065749764,
-0.1730569452,
0.5557185411,
-0.4459016621,
-0.1139715761,
-0.5615150928,
-0.3734154105,
-0.6910619736,
-0.0187332947,
-0.1417617947,
0.3440201283,
-0.1803924739,
0.3191808462,
-0.3698633313,
0.5974550843,
0.8048036695,
0.3850852847,
0.3930934966,
0.2961613238,
-0.1452747732,
-0.0084152622,
-0.6152279973,
-0.5994713306,
1.0628162622,
0.1122066751,
0.7924749255,
-0.0235882923,
0.095411703,
0.2570100129,
0.1065395325,
-0.6480810046,
0.3159282207,
-0.9077736139,
-0.2830661535,
0.1736682951,
0.0356448069,
-0.7355385423,
-0.2405451238,
-0.4670008421,
-0.3596138656,
0.1488680243,
0.1753979176,
-0.663749218,
0.0773032159,
-0.7401524186,
0.7319253087,
-0.6798326373,
-0.4655200541,
-0.2881427705,
-0.2179031074,
-0.1597855538,
-0.1849717945,
0.2153228819,
-0.0056214589,
0.210439235,
0.9049198031,
-0.4706395268,
0.7382919192,
0.035592135,
0.1503520757,
0.0663161054,
-0.1290451735,
0.4954587519,
-0.0987393111,
-0.0986527503,
0.2418875694,
0.0940501019,
-0.2150419801,
-0.3283689022,
0.6877188087,
-0.6938115358,
-0.6577048302,
-0.1150395945,
-0.3085328937,
-0.488815248,
0.3012593389,
0.006606522,
0.252027452,
-0.388646096,
0.5953764915,
0.5166404247,
-0.248013854,
0.2753402293,
0.8338193893,
-0.2044525743,
-0.4047982395,
0.7427497506,
-0.0363307521,
-0.01133681,
0.2881810963,
0.3449104428,
-0.3842584789,
-0.7122613788,
-0.0594054274,
0.0705191866,
-0.4552683234,
-0.0587888323,
-0.4379113615,
0.2187424898,
-0.3319760263,
-0.2653383613,
0.036125157,
-0.0527958944,
-0.490478456,
-0.2261086702,
0.3967344165,
0.920994103,
0.3928318024,
0.5791763663,
-0.905123353,
0.184951514,
0.2033329904,
0.9167064428,
0.0094676297,
-0.3033284247,
-0.7284325957,
0.220888719,
-0.1103425846,
-0.224717319,
0.5259420872,
0.3851490617,
0.5997687578,
0.7622953057,
0.1400841922,
0.7780828476,
-0.4530079365,
0.6267727017,
0.0354885384,
-0.789224565,
0.4923165739,
-0.376441747,
0.2891894281,
0.7348988652,
0.5587015748,
-0.1361985207,
-0.1255591959,
-0.333332181,
-0.7281509042,
0.871556282,
0.0764153004,
0.2147178501,
0.130196929,
0.3121943176,
0.3989960253,
0.3973551989,
-0.4310872555,
-0.4083478153,
0.0380766205,
-0.1433934271,
-0.5741561651,
-0.6389019489,
0.2229559273,
-0.3197589815,
0.8158772588,
0.1889723688,
-0.3185487986,
-0.0827653483,
-0.3529116809,
-0.1864904165,
0.1610113531,
0.4755333662,
0.6828148961,
-0.4677458405,
-0.3727027774,
-0.0574052334,
-0.3882466555,
-0.1842012852,
0.1745945513,
-0.1101907119,
-0.151263237,
0.016495591,
0.8557316661,
0.2958402932,
-0.6696211696,
0.3120576143,
-0.3333407938,
-0.0932904556,
-0.2701646984,
-0.1123579443,
-0.0222098008,
-0.0210333373,
0.1896020174,
0.1650206,
0.2534928322,
-0.5603553653,
0.2888411582,
0.3951738477,
-0.4046759605,
-0.1829832047,
0.3023777008,
0.4097673595,
-0.4863892794,
0.4045560658,
0.3170975149,
-0.5037142038,
0.3827735186,
0.734454155,
0.9139173031,
-0.1127911583,
0.104115665,
0.0630370751,
0.4451652467,
-0.3207892478,
0.0223491304,
-0.0785401762,
-0.8610755205,
-0.3314013183,
-0.8851296902,
-0.266625911,
-0.0099590803,
-0.6589459181,
0.7437499166,
-0.5675894022,
-0.3125038743,
-0.2385539412,
0.2393659055,
-0.9899206758,
0.4139168561,
0.1784089953,
0.582691133,
-0.5856826901,
0.7422354817,
0.6402050257,
-0.1935132444,
-0.5112996697,
-0.0833966509,
-0.4634309411,
-0.3175808787,
0.3416631818,
0.2814501822,
-0.2408362329,
0.0179805011,
-0.016703479,
-0.5691990852,
0.8369720578,
0.2444736212,
-1.0134465694,
0.3635383248,
0.2272832394,
0.875416398,
-0.631536603,
0.4540636241,
0.6483608484,
0.3291489184,
-0.2403141558,
-0.9677510262,
-0.1786533743,
-0.2974728048,
-0.0237495322,
0.1394776851,
-0.2287872583,
0.7168756127,
0.0482588038,
-0.0714736283,
0.2256452739,
0.1013995185,
0.0857973695,
0.4917215407,
0.5711963773,
0.8113116622,
0.7276973724,
0.0545997359,
1.1722941399,
-0.4937535226,
0.3413015902,
1.2796814442,
-0.6600058675,
1.0207053423,
0.1742909849,
-0.3255492747,
0.8217753172,
0.7145522833,
-0.1796227694,
0.5654091835,
-0.0049431459,
0.1070628762,
-0.2694619596,
-0.1809802055,
-0.3790362179,
0.0630269349,
0.3230062723,
-0.4558950961,
0.0223640203,
0.0744913295,
-0.4876075387,
0.1230903193,
-0.4775877893,
1.1194080114,
0.1021111533,
-0.4093074203,
0.5454553366,
0.0999524891,
0.9188066125,
-0.6958350539,
-0.1418356597,
0.1309596598,
0.327070415,
-0.1151064113,
-0.1884905696,
0.0308154672,
-0.1966821253,
-0.2662369609,
-0.5778753161,
1.1513121128,
-0.3656950891,
-0.6848903894,
0.5330443382,
0.5559171438,
-0.2845792174,
-0.1747165322,
-0.6604608893,
-0.3798800111,
-0.1446260959,
-0.0981320813,
0.290725261,
0.1657813936,
0.2269989699,
0.5303854942,
1.0691878796,
0.0181471314,
-0.1946060508,
0.311982125,
0.5392969847,
-0.6647135019,
-0.8838134408,
-0.8644891381,
0.3053456247,
-0.0700395778,
-0.105564855,
0.9545254707,
0.4981376827,
1.2830982208,
-0.2333577126,
0.705132246,
0.5828952193,
0.5137101412,
-0.5639820099,
0.7717704773,
-0.4641289413,
0.8688133359,
-0.2400730103,
-1.1721417904,
-0.3964186013,
0.441299051,
-0.5848017335,
0.3124343753,
0.7036512494,
0.7355274558,
-0.0269792397,
0.3437758386,
0.4527275264,
0.1462541372,
-0.2272534817,
0.2862155139,
0.7023358345,
-0.2675193846,
0.4212772548,
-0.5216873884,
0.0278060716,
-0.4827991426,
-0.8774989247,
-1.0114070177,
-0.3713801503,
-0.2532294095,
-0.1192287654,
0.3403562307,
1.1393179893,
0.793884933,
-1.0171071291,
-0.4407800436,
-0.0484669209,
-0.1069413349,
-0.4954110682,
-0.1602285951,
0.2055743784,
-0.3095073998,
-0.6934425831,
0.314902097,
0.3362309039,
0.050324887,
0.0134270098,
-0.0623907223,
-0.2802073658,
0.1459632218,
0.6852191687,
-0.4077821374,
-0.6618584991,
0.1849144697,
-0.0042540366,
0.2941340804,
-0.0349335372,
1.2666893005,
-0.9116666913,
0.5933351517,
0.3929838538,
0.4661887288,
0.3731306195,
0.1661590189,
1.0562182665,
-0.4322834909,
-0.0027756081,
0.1469583958,
0.4911372364,
0.1231658682,
-0.314076215,
0.2344553918,
-0.041825369,
-0.4277645051,
-0.4855917692,
-0.0149263591,
-0.7285903096,
-0.5198923349,
0.9302558303,
-0.1852817088,
-0.0243642926,
-0.522197485,
-0.4120360911,
-0.0713709518,
-0.4076010287,
0.7751166224,
0.7210761309,
0.2995256186,
0.0652517155,
-0.2310724109,
0.4386288524,
0.5854675174,
-0.5319385529,
-0.0953339487,
0.2415664345,
0.1183911264,
-0.1414074153,
0.4190879464,
0.4641416073,
0.2048791945,
-0.6956592798,
-0.1920952946,
-0.2276180387,
-0.3377751708,
-0.5042628646,
0.2348843515,
0.2546179295,
0.2117302865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04434v1 | Real-Time Visual Feedback to Guide Benchmark Creation: A Human-and-Metric-in-the-Loop Workflow | 2023-02-09T04:43:10 | 2023-02-09T04:43:10 | Anjana Arunkumar, Swaroop Mishra, Bhavdeep Sachdeva, Chitta Baral, Chris Bryan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | Recent research has shown that language models exploit `artifacts' in
benchmarks to solve tasks, rather than truly learning them, leading to inflated
model performance. In pursuit of creating better benchmarks, we propose VAIDA,
a novel benchmark creation paradigm for NLP, that focuses on guiding
crowdworkers, an under-explored facet of addressing benchmark idiosyncrasies.
VAIDA facilitates sample correction by providing realtime visual feedback and
recommendations to improve sample quality. Our approach is domain, model, task,
and metric agnostic, and constitutes a paradigm shift for robust, validated,
and dynamic benchmark creation via human-and-metric-in-the-loop workflows. We
evaluate via expert review and a user study with NASA TLX. We find that VAIDA
decreases effort, frustration, mental, and temporal demands of crowdworkers and
analysts, simultaneously increasing the performance of both user groups with a
45.8% decrease in the level of artifacts in created samples. As a by product of
our user study, we observe that created samples are adversarial across models,
leading to decreases of 31.3% (BERT), 22.5% (RoBERTa), 14.98% (GPT-3 fewshot)
in performance. | [
-0.487187922,
-0.5043089986,
0.2443597019,
0.1824092567,
-0.2215195596,
0.0936009362,
-0.143809393,
-0.6523259878,
0.1390846521,
0.5828387737,
-0.4764652252,
-0.4256846905,
-0.3380511403,
-0.0311782062,
-0.5644196868,
0.9877518415,
-0.080947794,
0.2693399787,
-0.4513217211,
-0.2384954542,
-0.5273841619,
-0.5663804412,
-0.434268564,
-0.2010620683,
0.6075260639,
0.4355051517,
0.5721469522,
0.724767983,
0.465692848,
0.273323983,
-0.0321221016,
0.4364342093,
-0.4455243647,
0.3637706041,
-0.3312079906,
-0.8837537766,
-0.5024726391,
0.0907368362,
0.4272460043,
0.5520967841,
-0.5109075308,
0.5114110708,
0.1425421238,
0.6962431669,
-0.7625851631,
-0.0996104926,
-0.602373302,
0.1038006172,
-0.6798798442,
-0.1334863305,
-0.0486492738,
-0.3283001482,
0.0181406289,
-1.0304704905,
0.7117068768,
0.1717965454,
1.2105908394,
0.5898096561,
0.1328718662,
0.2823515534,
-0.8362034559,
0.5921347737,
-0.6407631636,
-0.0124402344,
0.3354578614,
0.8168839216,
0.0068978369,
-0.8186049461,
-0.576887846,
-0.0053773243,
0.336378485,
0.1448446065,
-0.1628301144,
-0.3686909974,
0.4228139818,
0.0841526836,
-0.3540799916,
0.1242765561,
-0.4085592628,
0.0539385229,
0.6502214074,
0.4561422169,
-0.0378518701,
0.0698307455,
-0.1830982864,
-0.5572274923,
-0.6171891093,
-0.1906309128,
0.1506504416,
0.0886667743,
0.099127084,
0.3215022087,
-0.5013694167,
0.6365457177,
-0.0423367694,
0.2717984021,
0.2718607485,
-0.1297826171,
-0.2274159044,
-0.4502054751,
0.6121154428,
0.498434186,
0.4034368694,
-0.0975456387,
-0.2083539516,
0.3247586787,
0.8322831392,
-0.6697915196,
-0.3760427535,
-0.1226951182,
-0.4356246889,
-0.523276031,
0.0629259869,
-0.9389419556,
-0.6859314442,
-0.5376303196,
0.213658452,
0.0074259359,
-0.3939689398,
-0.225658685,
-0.2363920957,
-0.0644416437,
0.7062441111,
-0.3874907494,
0.515494287,
0.7953854799,
0.9296883345,
0.076508373,
-0.5618084669,
-1.0274492502,
-0.0422722101,
-0.4427382052,
1.2193955183,
-0.3848044574,
-0.4796714783,
0.0200634804,
-0.1929103285,
0.1912656426,
-1.1433404684,
0.3426556289,
-0.1577432305,
0.1056892797,
-0.575493753,
-0.4285390377,
0.102695778,
0.2351004779,
-0.5928652883,
1.3075218201,
-0.1053283215,
-0.5028440952,
0.837305069,
-0.6448864341,
0.0907093659,
0.5065916777,
-0.3069200218,
-0.42830953,
0.289432019,
0.3426338136,
0.2770096064,
-0.3438780308,
0.268422246,
-0.5258710384,
-0.3734140694,
0.173973009,
-0.3384069204,
0.3314365745,
0.1835142523,
-0.7816042304,
0.3899946511,
-0.8704039454,
-0.0101903724,
0.0053587439,
-0.0328297243,
-0.2817214727,
0.2536730766,
0.3647550344,
0.3985013664,
-0.4504087269,
-0.3067266941,
0.1884142756,
-0.0655806959,
0.1849196106,
0.8295633793,
-0.0948991701,
0.0847490057,
-0.4606656432,
0.6713665128,
-0.2897092998,
0.3177782297,
0.20846349,
-0.4246734083,
-0.9740161896,
-0.1044895947,
0.4297276735,
0.4064311385,
-0.7795831561,
0.0677526295,
-0.353757441,
-0.8772685528,
-0.8783243299,
0.2561399341,
0.6482535601,
0.6814317107,
0.3032772243,
-0.7742075324,
-0.4898599982,
-0.9582933784,
-0.2862452269,
-0.3286716044,
-0.3652558029,
0.21147497,
0.4757224619,
0.1443482488,
0.7603257895,
-0.3787886202,
-0.3717111349,
0.3034471571,
0.6500604153,
-0.0794764757,
0.3849622607,
0.5435141325,
-0.6003844142,
-0.2984164059,
-0.3248774707,
-0.7640948892,
-0.4765502512,
-0.0073145083,
-0.3675923944,
0.0520515703,
0.6383038759,
-0.2312164009,
0.5599915981,
0.4714984298,
-0.3148833811,
0.7930340767,
-0.1565828025,
-0.0242502429,
-0.8517490029,
0.3870886564,
0.3015729189,
-0.2766550779,
-0.3813126385,
-0.0291316435,
0.0706349462,
-0.1712599546,
-0.4674590826,
0.6609773636,
-0.4473133087,
-0.0667166039,
-0.4583315849,
0.1412412375,
0.1750349402,
0.3373610079,
0.0492614098,
0.6952265501,
0.4464851916,
-0.5820881724,
0.1588397622,
0.2187773734,
-0.7656267285,
1.1877634525,
-0.9101475477,
-0.0750683472,
-0.0156835504,
0.394911319,
-0.546258688,
-0.1237916946,
0.0471715927,
-0.3525327742,
0.037377473,
-0.0429711677,
-0.7969564795,
-0.3884035647,
-0.1118227392,
0.326759696,
0.4952692986,
-0.7253033519,
0.1324899197,
0.3403146267,
0.0732509792,
-0.360592097,
-0.722958684,
0.3388400674,
-0.0666149855,
-0.5462909937,
0.4933564961,
-0.0345210359,
-0.591432333,
0.0687059164,
-0.0463380031,
-0.0682681501,
0.2078218162,
0.4876285195,
0.0890592858,
0.0751013011,
0.2109608948,
-0.4834338725,
-0.2220084071,
0.0507463403,
-0.1781116575,
0.2147048265,
-0.2374179065,
-0.4825798273,
-0.5228213072,
0.403819859,
0.7114165425,
-0.4689907432,
0.4317926764,
0.935708344,
-0.2437105179,
-0.481911242,
-0.7397299409,
-0.2461989671,
-0.4371367991,
0.1923520565,
-0.1576849073,
-0.5278144479,
0.5423905253,
-0.0784862116,
0.0262452364,
0.4210316837,
0.7174235582,
-0.1776635945,
0.9588823318,
0.5060030818,
0.0399305448,
0.557166636,
-0.3723375201,
-0.1120080054,
-0.8548309803,
-0.2745144367,
-0.6337897182,
-0.4504705071,
-0.2994189858,
-0.6844646931,
0.4768627882,
0.1954025179,
0.0230874084,
0.0914772451,
-0.8201099634,
0.3084260225,
0.9125006199,
-0.043873474,
-0.033952985,
-0.3319298029,
0.0954151005,
-0.2689416409,
-0.7381930947,
-0.4332672656,
0.9919266105,
0.0104281828,
0.6266044974,
-0.1330345422,
0.5177567601,
0.55251652,
0.6260449886,
-0.3053349257,
0.456512332,
0.1525006443,
-0.5531596541,
-0.0151020093,
-0.0863939375,
-0.87139678,
0.4801637828,
-0.4899121523,
-0.6430758238,
0.4943060279,
0.4304823577,
-0.2426622659,
0.4377593398,
-0.536334753,
0.8629478812,
-0.1964781433,
-0.8018802404,
-0.2367611229,
-0.3825366795,
0.1419340819,
0.0656801462,
0.2172182202,
-0.3658606708,
-0.0869056135,
0.6989268661,
-1.1450579166,
0.9831603169,
-0.4396542907,
0.0650189742,
0.2796498835,
0.0030884051,
0.7812803984,
0.066896975,
-0.1404803395,
0.243966639,
-0.2553197443,
-0.6781499386,
-0.5212017894,
0.6298103333,
-0.4571486712,
-0.5280506611,
-0.330491364,
-0.3155583739,
-0.27987203,
-0.0363469124,
0.343912065,
0.4862865806,
-0.1819687486,
0.2097945362,
0.3890370727,
0.1928784549,
0.4560993016,
0.615491569,
0.0334492996,
-0.3673970401,
0.6969847083,
0.1902248859,
-0.0118708163,
0.1313147247,
-0.0842421949,
-0.0901479349,
-0.6409957409,
-0.5939388275,
0.0801592618,
-0.4440341592,
-0.1282627583,
-0.3294035792,
0.389937222,
-0.0967119932,
-0.2916912735,
-0.6063740253,
-0.1637950689,
-0.2150092125,
0.1598400921,
0.188282907,
0.4934391379,
-0.0030038336,
0.0887776539,
-0.6559438705,
-0.0156676732,
0.4462245405,
0.5616685152,
0.2466242909,
-0.1599545926,
-0.5713687539,
-0.174957782,
-0.161906898,
-0.5515485406,
0.5922426581,
0.1177191213,
0.6613625884,
0.1190985069,
-0.0809847936,
0.8709337711,
-0.3702383041,
0.977047801,
0.0404045507,
-1.005402565,
0.4378728271,
-0.4470555484,
0.5292279124,
0.7387597561,
-0.1736712009,
-0.6931997538,
-0.5638409257,
-0.6673730016,
-0.9817274809,
0.4713279903,
0.2567796409,
-0.2583908141,
0.1561716348,
0.07820943,
0.070910044,
0.3528632522,
-0.1844040006,
-0.0127361501,
-0.4107162058,
0.3024031818,
0.0224958304,
0.063327834,
-0.3457534909,
-0.286303848,
0.5336276889,
-0.1611606032,
-0.1088520586,
0.2628034949,
-0.0281506386,
-0.1977921575,
0.0774265379,
0.653132081,
1.0164815187,
-0.2287487388,
-0.1638939232,
0.0998722017,
-0.0924680158,
-0.2951289713,
0.1772293448,
-0.1027825475,
0.2285380661,
0.3588241637,
0.9530690312,
0.0544583946,
-0.8439664245,
0.4965821803,
-0.3041343689,
-0.6063425541,
-0.3625624478,
0.149826467,
-0.1440309733,
0.3152215183,
0.4156540334,
0.3715970516,
-0.0337344073,
-0.2369525731,
0.1672337055,
0.1769486815,
-0.4616971612,
-0.376285404,
1.1815886497,
0.4983251393,
-0.4921188354,
0.4987200201,
-0.0974966809,
-0.2079062164,
0.6148237586,
0.0602389313,
1.0413011312,
-0.0107956175,
0.3784584403,
0.3836678267,
0.0426894315,
-0.292277813,
0.1408938766,
-0.205309093,
-0.244610846,
-0.4265272617,
-0.4564529061,
-0.7598085999,
0.156983763,
-0.9666131139,
0.1663836986,
-0.402747035,
-0.203645125,
0.3712007701,
-0.249875918,
-0.841760397,
0.3202808797,
0.2083415389,
0.7432994843,
-0.8457689881,
0.8050032854,
0.7834647894,
-0.4825208485,
-0.587644577,
0.0055822018,
0.4719501734,
-0.4861241579,
0.4043190777,
-0.0497207642,
0.0911064371,
-0.43426162,
-0.6515790224,
-0.7968034744,
1.0539495945,
0.1198832169,
-0.7371809483,
0.1972392648,
-0.3382726312,
1.0516885519,
-0.1835213453,
0.1780630201,
0.0519781932,
0.5112043023,
-0.292139411,
-0.9750836492,
0.0323942453,
-0.9983333945,
0.3257160783,
0.4081155658,
-0.7221604586,
0.8313284516,
0.2008851171,
-0.1836721599,
-0.1466833502,
0.5876820087,
0.2265069783,
0.2683538198,
0.6363505125,
0.7305653691,
1.0138173103,
-0.0866865814,
1.3889859915,
-0.1199705601,
-0.0492994413,
1.2283265591,
-0.3191126585,
0.9888777137,
0.5479828715,
-0.1608723104,
0.5854925513,
0.5748289824,
-0.596046865,
0.3270527124,
0.482716769,
-0.1069818437,
-0.308858037,
-0.5042024255,
-0.4541484416,
0.3698772192,
0.0968289003,
-0.1089849174,
-0.1277650148,
-0.0945306718,
0.04504098,
0.5207018852,
-0.2127909362,
0.5682065487,
-0.1815035343,
-1.0119535923,
0.961137116,
-0.2927469611,
0.7814786434,
-0.3245534599,
-0.0925882086,
-0.2918566167,
0.2803966701,
-0.1857836992,
-0.4050835967,
0.3368021846,
0.2314770967,
-0.3757255971,
-0.2951691449,
0.343077451,
-0.3378687799,
-0.3999054134,
0.1015109643,
0.5226827264,
0.0901845545,
-0.3327192366,
-0.6653105021,
-0.0700884163,
-0.2001092434,
-0.2624445558,
0.3902965486,
0.1013387144,
-0.4547554553,
0.6689607501,
0.7862884998,
0.2728468776,
-0.0535781272,
0.5329014063,
0.7263765931,
-0.4920421243,
-0.4651115239,
-0.5800533295,
0.5621569157,
-0.5377381444,
-0.8201697469,
0.7452498674,
0.4415245652,
1.0616509914,
-0.0670329332,
0.8813681006,
0.0980298221,
0.5943187475,
-0.1929756403,
0.7371829748,
-0.9321649075,
0.1388763189,
-0.4147276282,
-0.8666910529,
-0.2390696704,
-0.0201527104,
-0.0519795567,
-0.290690273,
0.5020626783,
0.9037754536,
0.211081773,
-0.2662985623,
0.0666802004,
-0.1689279675,
0.6708179116,
0.2942789495,
0.6378695965,
-0.1814422011,
0.7823935151,
-0.4726112187,
-0.1230427697,
-0.537722826,
-0.8727727532,
-0.6256100535,
-0.7351942658,
-0.4631048739,
-0.4104669988,
0.183802247,
0.4968175292,
1.0947451591,
-0.5758734941,
-0.3442664146,
-0.1971872896,
-0.2918304801,
-0.8059298992,
-0.2488782108,
0.2546734214,
-0.3048005104,
-0.9215527773,
0.3799352646,
0.2562038004,
-0.2140114903,
-0.4117284417,
-0.0717145577,
-0.0176967345,
0.0777126551,
0.2237220407,
0.6365606785,
-0.7359746099,
0.0079490803,
-0.2503040135,
-0.1368685812,
0.0124518974,
0.8472910523,
-0.8273437023,
0.9360969067,
0.5773974657,
0.5909800529,
0.9148693085,
0.1871871352,
0.9072806835,
-0.6608813405,
0.1221937314,
0.353104949,
0.1954505146,
0.4415487051,
0.0101367049,
0.9214761257,
0.4709439874,
-0.5810947418,
-1.1025696993,
0.0031895232,
-0.8703862429,
-0.1959418207,
0.763869524,
0.1057797298,
-0.5072978139,
-0.0053684763,
-0.0852325633,
0.1489339322,
-0.3092380762,
1.2554217577,
0.6549577117,
-0.0083950721,
0.0866683424,
-0.6833985448,
0.600615561,
0.7939465046,
-1.0294629335,
0.0101461448,
0.5887855887,
0.0702078119,
0.1575877368,
0.5641889572,
-0.0585899353,
0.5217068791,
0.3687096536,
0.5610437989,
-0.3446135521,
-0.0935290679,
-0.0601163246,
0.1893803626,
0.0628190711,
-0.3292961717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04424v1 | A Transformer-based Response Evaluator for Open-Domain Spoken Conversation | 2023-02-09T03:38:07 | 2023-02-09T03:38:07 | Vrindavan Harrison, Rishi Rajasekaran, Marilyn Walker | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many open-domain dialogue systems rely on multiple response generators, any
of which can contribute a response to the dialogue in a particular context.
Thus the ability to compare potential responses and then select the best plays
an important role in ensuring a dialogue system is coherent and engaging.
Dialogue coherence goes beyond simply remaining on topic -- some trivia may be
on topic and engaging when mentioned out of the blue, but may not be coherent
and grounded in the context of the conversation. We carry out experiments on
response selection in the Athena system, an Alexa Prize SocialBot that has
dedicated content and multiple topic-specific response generators for a large
number of topics. First, we collect a corpus of Athena conversations with live
human traffic, where potential responses from all enabled response generators
are logged and subsequently annotated for response quality. We compare several
off-the-shelf response ranking methods for open-domain dialogue to
Athena-Heuristic, a heuristic response ranker that was field-tested in Athena
during the third Alexa Prize competition. We also compare these to a
transformer-based response ranker we call Athena-RR, that we train on our
Athena conversations. Athena-RR uses both the conversational context and the
dialogue state to rank the potential responses. We find that Athena-RR with a
Recall@1 of 70.79\% outperforms Athena-Heuristic and all of the off-the-shelf
rankers by a large margin. We then conduct a live A/B study comparing
Athena-Heuristic to Athena-RR in a 6,358 conversations with Alexa users. We
show that Athena-RR leads to significantly longer conversations that receive
significantly higher user ratings than the heuristic rule-based ranker. | [
-0.8410044909,
-0.7456262708,
0.3810691237,
0.0410226472,
-0.2534319162,
0.3903165162,
-0.2268973887,
-0.5035911798,
0.3490933478,
0.2559994757,
-0.3620791435,
-0.167893216,
-0.6353741288,
0.1897462606,
-0.2981063426,
0.9139427543,
0.3872132301,
0.0191259868,
-0.2286502272,
-0.4720148146,
-0.6378649473,
-0.477158159,
-0.8688358665,
-0.5374686122,
0.2909506857,
0.4641143084,
0.8142092228,
-0.2030612826,
0.5960439444,
0.3096762002,
-0.2872399092,
0.0070359069,
-0.6310843825,
0.4602884352,
-0.1530610621,
-0.232284978,
-0.6056985259,
0.0091801705,
0.2665078342,
0.6329377294,
-0.1480893791,
0.2727364302,
0.3770545721,
0.3515829444,
-0.5742670298,
0.1597867608,
-0.6182467937,
0.1600245237,
0.2568456233,
-0.3357706368,
-0.6773586273,
-0.4857279062,
0.7557809353,
-0.6127868891,
0.1169106439,
0.3803628385,
0.9410903454,
0.3375215828,
-0.1723903865,
-0.0956251621,
-1.2253595591,
0.9822471142,
-0.5181775689,
0.4189979434,
0.4180016518,
0.5900073051,
0.0259087123,
-0.4976365864,
-0.758404851,
-0.2246964276,
0.0016431969,
0.4820298553,
-0.7133535147,
-0.1125255078,
0.0441106893,
0.6494809389,
-0.3727039695,
-0.1780967563,
-0.1654997468,
-0.1165015474,
0.2059028596,
0.1198101118,
0.0331164896,
-0.0182933211,
-0.1087047458,
-0.3790901899,
-0.4519631565,
0.1556575298,
0.2224462181,
0.2554205954,
0.0548380613,
0.646016717,
-0.3381025493,
0.4262539148,
0.4308077395,
-0.0749470815,
-0.1088358909,
-0.0968370363,
-0.1817783266,
-0.0051313383,
0.8826255798,
0.4104313552,
0.1944068074,
-0.2790578604,
0.2089639604,
0.1186131462,
0.6012054682,
-0.847777009,
-0.0124062793,
0.392989248,
-0.6584368348,
-0.0581264347,
-0.0375607349,
-0.8159575462,
-0.0426856801,
-0.0043723914,
0.5162925124,
-0.1596889049,
-0.2439859509,
0.0521429405,
-0.177523911,
0.0089172991,
0.2901355624,
-0.7724314928,
0.6968854666,
0.6967237592,
0.6229211688,
-0.1993139684,
0.0568467081,
-0.7565144897,
-0.313374877,
-0.4160384834,
0.9115568995,
-0.6847649813,
-0.594953835,
0.0080125472,
-0.1035179645,
-0.0076732254,
-0.7534441352,
0.8794239163,
-0.780754447,
0.7465153933,
-0.008456002,
-0.3902098835,
-0.1322558224,
0.1926651895,
-0.6680619717,
0.9794345498,
0.0060951393,
-0.6740162373,
0.532728672,
-0.703130424,
-0.3419887125,
0.0126734851,
0.0954878703,
-0.6540520191,
0.1431204379,
0.1163780391,
0.1523843706,
-0.3659619391,
0.0569319949,
-0.3244975805,
-0.3458928764,
0.4268805087,
-0.5519164205,
0.2844982743,
0.2838491797,
-0.502587378,
0.3169801533,
-0.6328508258,
0.2683858871,
0.0765131339,
-0.3762145936,
-0.1753361523,
0.1148278862,
-0.3591520488,
-0.0992434919,
-0.2169382423,
-0.8847765326,
-0.1711040735,
-0.4370114803,
0.1638531834,
0.5818060637,
0.018581789,
0.3713004589,
-0.4825370312,
0.5554079413,
-0.2803487182,
0.166812703,
-0.2121344209,
-0.9221826792,
-1.063609004,
-0.1654949337,
0.2573087811,
0.4635393023,
-0.507679522,
0.9131578803,
-0.409706533,
-0.3705615103,
-0.8200511932,
-0.6471901536,
0.4448812902,
0.563467145,
0.5860363245,
-0.5219702721,
-0.263076365,
-0.8048619628,
-0.1236722171,
-0.4195985198,
-0.2491123527,
0.7056854367,
0.1887755543,
0.2813796997,
1.1874233484,
-0.6778515577,
-0.1088185683,
-0.3976673782,
0.2439186275,
0.1514820158,
-0.029063059,
0.2498019934,
-0.4715436399,
-0.6566566229,
-0.0036282262,
-0.5477644801,
0.082004644,
0.2830452919,
-0.0336951576,
0.2001918256,
-0.1060537621,
-0.7482609749,
0.7137038708,
0.5609126687,
-0.4427146316,
0.2769667208,
-0.1344402581,
0.6631658077,
-1.3667997122,
0.1895692199,
-0.2806091011,
-0.2345849723,
-0.6456490159,
-0.1281389147,
-0.4613284469,
-0.4129273295,
-0.3552588522,
0.4645802975,
0.0129320594,
-0.2774835527,
-0.2391650081,
-0.0018890342,
-0.0164856762,
0.5862964392,
0.2091372907,
0.9596655965,
0.2252468169,
-0.5776723623,
0.1870542765,
0.8660056591,
-0.5455470085,
0.7845199704,
-0.9759048223,
0.5522120595,
0.2651727498,
0.5685715079,
-1.3089860678,
-0.137049377,
0.2553026378,
-0.5944471359,
-0.1474160254,
-0.112514928,
-0.2978137434,
-0.4688279331,
-0.1541391313,
0.3119849563,
0.6176643968,
-0.682711184,
0.6298586726,
0.3326844573,
-0.4629775584,
-0.4823150635,
-0.0231516846,
0.1532624364,
-0.319424957,
-0.7485515475,
0.0811418667,
-0.4412092566,
-0.3061522245,
-0.2534527481,
-0.2456433326,
0.0198029671,
0.2060865462,
0.1362982988,
0.2832021713,
-0.2482236326,
-0.0761451796,
0.0307827555,
-0.381849587,
-0.1302866787,
-0.1349578947,
0.9049834609,
-0.1941254884,
-0.6461825967,
-0.8184242249,
0.4135646224,
0.819630444,
-0.2842635512,
0.6361855865,
0.3451443613,
0.0171256848,
0.1195832118,
-0.4004458785,
-0.6587448716,
-0.4357682168,
-0.0223276559,
-0.3993645608,
-1.1300985813,
0.5176995993,
0.0287317503,
0.3092820942,
0.3130751252,
0.5856335759,
-0.0158043783,
1.2941455841,
0.4753430486,
-0.03180556,
0.422179848,
-0.1335133165,
0.7114981413,
-0.8694649339,
-0.1100777909,
-1.0252456665,
-0.4608170688,
-0.4949375391,
-0.1886128336,
0.7162948847,
-0.2993357778,
-0.1795608699,
0.3567979038,
-0.5141561031,
0.2218043208,
0.6188839078,
-0.0710337162,
0.5068252087,
0.1153512895,
0.0244285781,
-0.0272869039,
-0.6147794724,
-0.5400318503,
1.0564571619,
0.4865465462,
0.8736082315,
0.3247611821,
0.4348082542,
0.299005419,
0.2140693069,
-0.9932721257,
0.6817971468,
0.2406293452,
-0.4511666,
-0.6516937017,
-0.2069826424,
-1.2736411095,
0.4796333015,
-0.3133175671,
-0.9027659893,
-0.0265913997,
-0.0667054802,
-0.7370074987,
0.1219268665,
-0.3753155172,
0.489341706,
0.4414986372,
-0.281865567,
-0.4175676405,
-0.4579183161,
-0.1608178169,
0.1986540556,
-0.1684238613,
-0.0411856547,
0.5702495575,
0.6621071696,
-0.6087127924,
0.6121637821,
0.1089159176,
-0.0515665635,
0.3356644213,
0.1013583317,
0.2198346108,
0.044486165,
0.0874386877,
0.1624006182,
-0.2754943967,
-0.0831664577,
-0.5684350729,
0.3210712969,
-0.9014019966,
-0.7620132565,
-0.2451462448,
-0.1483159065,
-0.4122550488,
0.06202906,
0.46381253,
0.5514935255,
-0.4893610775,
0.6069110632,
0.8728259802,
-0.3080275655,
0.3645234406,
0.5427946448,
-0.0991521254,
-0.6365247369,
0.6402243376,
-0.3540335596,
0.4955577254,
0.3771337569,
0.4690373242,
-0.2842507362,
-0.1851892471,
-0.5516116023,
-0.2400358021,
-0.3674981892,
-0.1671324074,
-0.7656411529,
-0.2156211287,
-0.3176566362,
0.1205110699,
-0.3776496947,
-0.738275826,
0.128939867,
-0.1599203646,
0.1725514978,
0.6784178019,
0.2709967196,
0.3186534643,
-0.7564604878,
0.36673522,
0.636072278,
0.3841848969,
0.0300029181,
-0.5931640863,
-0.0490678363,
-0.0143024726,
-0.7181207538,
-0.5994626284,
0.2136922926,
0.2924891114,
0.6878021359,
0.4672144651,
0.2123615593,
0.4521170855,
-0.4894122183,
1.1381781101,
0.1287733614,
-0.9125570655,
0.6487405896,
-0.2675742507,
0.3784705997,
0.4593515694,
0.1666375846,
-0.5793257356,
-0.8241506219,
-0.6346497536,
-0.7469933033,
0.7856129408,
0.6605071425,
0.3368842006,
-0.0628359839,
-0.1664701551,
0.2466838509,
0.2333357185,
-0.4124031961,
-0.2927412391,
-0.2370560467,
0.1125744209,
-0.089085944,
-0.0285099745,
-0.4724491835,
-0.0218020268,
0.5201920867,
-0.3753587604,
0.6544793844,
0.1147780344,
0.1993798912,
-0.5309855938,
0.6240065694,
0.592241168,
0.5251146555,
-0.310198307,
-0.1029012948,
0.1304829717,
-0.3575845957,
-0.0630595982,
0.037356548,
0.0277864654,
0.0457995534,
0.2494502515,
0.8086468577,
0.1466376185,
-0.4687815011,
0.4805268943,
-0.6407476664,
-0.0637127608,
-0.0973824784,
0.0895019248,
-0.1756218225,
0.1590095311,
0.4297509193,
0.2759859562,
0.3126713634,
-0.7176470757,
0.1048406214,
0.5763427615,
-0.4873158932,
-0.3528565168,
0.7241120338,
0.5436288118,
-0.7558269501,
0.6440572143,
0.0407205373,
-0.6142789125,
0.3385091424,
0.4846827388,
1.2526555061,
-0.3716185689,
0.2320170999,
0.3782669902,
-0.1834216565,
0.2224212289,
0.2506484985,
-0.4884777665,
-0.7968835831,
-0.2928779125,
-0.6513075829,
-0.9221535921,
0.1732770205,
-1.0077457428,
-0.1079800576,
-0.2073805183,
-0.610140264,
0.0263990555,
-0.0536094718,
-0.4874337614,
0.0302031804,
-0.108732231,
0.8455354571,
-0.5435730219,
0.254624933,
0.5593791008,
-0.2394977212,
-0.6746528149,
0.4111929536,
-0.1906030178,
-0.5989260674,
0.4567000866,
0.0088390354,
-0.5773062706,
-0.206390366,
-0.2846052647,
-0.8010786772,
1.0506544113,
0.1344505697,
-0.1242707521,
0.3033392727,
0.2045468092,
0.7986131907,
-0.3035316169,
0.6454975605,
0.3534125388,
0.1592377871,
0.4677128196,
-1.5662033558,
-0.2937017977,
-0.2624171972,
-0.2387574464,
0.1894956231,
-0.8823962212,
0.4110028148,
-0.0506322086,
-0.2092274576,
0.6103588939,
0.5801091194,
0.240386337,
0.4499722123,
0.5034585595,
0.75173527,
0.5550889969,
-0.3589898944,
1.0316257477,
-0.5184357166,
0.4485760629,
0.976352334,
-0.301091373,
1.275690794,
0.1795773059,
-0.1307035089,
0.7351798415,
0.4967434108,
0.4746544063,
0.6189337373,
-0.066126056,
-0.5478439927,
-0.2463919818,
-0.2033156157,
-0.3552846611,
0.5048828721,
0.1724234074,
-0.0403335243,
-0.1376580298,
0.0405064188,
0.0180388559,
-0.0825071707,
0.1926953346,
1.2087315321,
0.0274932235,
-1.2422058582,
0.5809713602,
-0.2399378568,
0.2251601815,
-0.3833851516,
-0.0547777005,
-0.2658739388,
0.253864795,
0.0017441486,
-0.8510961533,
0.3580824137,
0.0116949473,
-0.0804387927,
-0.3577819765,
0.6755523682,
-0.240523383,
0.1236043125,
0.2300385386,
0.4978150129,
0.1328483373,
0.0517202541,
-0.3568992913,
0.1832624525,
-0.3045006394,
-0.2754693329,
0.1256174296,
0.0646666065,
0.0143831279,
0.7743886709,
0.7218264937,
-0.3976719677,
-0.3804039955,
0.2726892829,
0.8228645921,
-0.1969109625,
-0.8040832281,
-0.3733932078,
0.5774888992,
-0.3341720104,
-0.399160862,
0.7073130012,
0.6156433821,
0.5544376969,
0.1044492051,
0.7270758748,
0.1622310728,
0.822684288,
-0.1603990942,
0.614651978,
-0.2917223275,
0.2388921231,
-0.2987536192,
-1.1479272842,
0.0504865386,
0.7890752554,
-0.3143005073,
-0.0312823877,
0.7163612247,
0.4915776849,
-0.0873520076,
0.5329565406,
0.5014523864,
0.1270463467,
0.5290442705,
0.1810550541,
1.2961506844,
-0.1990227848,
0.7427544594,
0.3014304936,
-0.5106914043,
-0.3385624886,
-0.4420682192,
-1.0005975962,
-0.6058365703,
-0.0868958533,
-0.6148748994,
0.066858165,
0.8306214213,
1.0449924469,
-0.8562727571,
-0.3313914239,
0.1692697853,
-0.0054364474,
-0.2054581046,
-0.2707363963,
0.0740626156,
-0.279694438,
-0.9255955219,
0.5754484534,
0.473044306,
-0.1405117512,
-0.2292405814,
-0.1084466875,
0.4786481559,
0.5105599165,
0.8077683449,
0.1653827876,
-0.7803525925,
-0.6975533366,
0.3485673666,
0.0572643168,
0.3241528571,
0.7869286537,
-0.8701962829,
0.4985991716,
0.5383105278,
0.5607026815,
0.4320732057,
0.1164234504,
0.7468955517,
-0.4919295013,
-0.2910623252,
0.37855497,
0.2926267385,
0.1131351069,
-0.1305688322,
0.3488174975,
0.0159684457,
-0.8635735512,
-0.6286111474,
0.4630060196,
-1.1437687874,
-0.0345031209,
0.9128965735,
-0.226361379,
0.1264290959,
-0.2769935131,
-0.3625445366,
-0.0047717094,
-0.7307143807,
1.1007599831,
0.7744137049,
-0.4573779106,
0.149747014,
-0.226254195,
0.4748447835,
0.5319925547,
-0.9392529726,
-0.1537913382,
0.3445993364,
0.196959421,
0.7587150931,
0.6891037226,
0.0732135102,
0.3036153316,
-0.1353180707,
-0.2788950801,
0.5980579853,
-0.4574128985,
-0.2241870761,
0.4709281027,
0.1919107735,
-0.3945881128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04415v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04415v3 | Few-Shot Table-to-Text Generation with Prompt Planning and Knowledge Memorization | 2023-02-09T03:04:11 | 2023-08-17T01:51:48 | Zhixin Guo, Minyxuan Yan, Jiexing Qi, Jianping Zhou, Ziwei He, Zhouhan Lin, Guanjie Zheng, Xinbing Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained language models (PLM) have achieved remarkable advancement in
table-to-text generation tasks. However, the lack of labeled domain-specific
knowledge and the topology gap between tabular data and text make it difficult
for PLMs to yield faithful text. Low-resource generation likewise faces unique
challenges in this domain. Inspired by how humans descript tabular data with
prior knowledge, we suggest a new framework: PromptMize, which targets
table-to-text generation under few-shot settings. The design of our framework
consists of two aspects: a prompt planner and a knowledge adapter. The prompt
planner aims to generate a prompt signal that provides instance guidance for
PLMs to bridge the topology gap between tabular data and text. Moreover, the
knowledge adapter memorizes domain-specific knowledge from the unlabelled
corpus to supply essential information during generation. Extensive experiments
and analyses are investigated on three open domain few-shot NLG datasets:
human, song, and book. Compared with previous state-of-the-art approaches, our
model achieves remarkable performance in generating quality as judged by human
and automatic evaluations. | [
-0.4283599555,
-0.6928264499,
0.5392918587,
0.0653079525,
-0.2978901267,
-0.3969499171,
-0.10561046,
0.1716137975,
-0.1728911102,
0.657376349,
-0.9000495672,
-0.7706926465,
-0.1846731752,
0.2687833011,
-0.1169909462,
1.1193809509,
0.3077208996,
-0.3944268525,
-0.1998237222,
0.1396058649,
-0.7435970306,
-0.1316848099,
-0.5616128445,
-0.2113608122,
0.5353572965,
0.9094340205,
0.5415113568,
0.6523008943,
0.2350371182,
0.1375192106,
0.0820481703,
0.3447462022,
-0.596635282,
0.1804415435,
0.0517423786,
-0.4372293651,
-0.5217424035,
-0.0871596858,
0.5927680135,
0.6900374889,
0.0464839861,
0.2206638306,
0.2863890529,
0.925321579,
-0.3593698144,
-0.0153657133,
-0.9726313353,
0.2010774761,
-0.4038750231,
-0.3885524273,
-0.5872898698,
-0.4471892715,
0.1148473546,
-0.8434714675,
0.2886537611,
0.4134509861,
0.4878045619,
0.3997540772,
-0.1781767905,
-0.1449394971,
-0.5530699492,
0.4616727233,
-0.5651963949,
0.1578843594,
0.4303435385,
0.4406053126,
-0.5429998636,
-0.9470527768,
-0.7572128177,
-0.0929262042,
-0.094022654,
0.1511265934,
-0.074005723,
-0.0149305724,
0.4574001133,
-0.1894469708,
-0.8704992533,
-0.0565002784,
-0.0355618969,
0.0747759491,
0.3384431601,
0.3031777143,
0.2999102771,
-0.4276996851,
-0.5429637432,
-0.1152920648,
-0.9407141805,
-0.0062931436,
0.2113010883,
0.6041073203,
-0.1018819287,
0.5216284394,
-0.1748941392,
1.0415638685,
0.0405676439,
-0.3547698259,
-0.2090729624,
-0.3822949231,
-0.2157054543,
0.1477707028,
0.8177515864,
0.2932842374,
0.0655906796,
-0.1151912212,
-0.1606701016,
-0.0014605751,
0.0956148133,
-0.7063616514,
-0.4267101586,
-0.2735730708,
-0.2406746745,
-0.0481793247,
-0.2967075109,
-0.9981704354,
-0.4508199394,
-0.1137603894,
0.4723112881,
-0.4506268799,
0.1493950486,
-0.1654052585,
-0.1086243168,
-0.0024588536,
0.3142546415,
-0.7223260403,
0.0715578794,
0.3190261126,
0.7853959799,
-0.2018311471,
-0.27119115,
-0.6787857413,
0.4298174679,
-0.493478328,
1.0519304276,
-0.1031381413,
-0.5820486546,
0.066826202,
-0.4562381506,
-0.0484339632,
-0.4390025139,
0.4855046272,
-0.3110723197,
0.3712435961,
-0.4725011587,
-0.5608490109,
0.0885880142,
0.2543941438,
-0.5521373153,
0.7909241915,
0.2499171495,
-0.7488691807,
0.8507287502,
-0.6490111947,
-0.359993875,
0.4000426233,
-0.3029874563,
-0.5049754977,
-0.0766094476,
0.1079908982,
0.4081112146,
-0.5796843171,
0.2307020575,
0.0897969231,
0.034947399,
0.0819469765,
-0.2158952206,
0.2683065236,
0.2336130589,
0.0393103063,
0.1753560901,
-0.951479733,
0.1554898024,
0.1872238517,
-0.6038336158,
0.0030270978,
-0.071937263,
0.0170476753,
0.5126672387,
-0.0493362024,
-0.1258580238,
0.3460181355,
-0.449187547,
0.1722473502,
0.3525208831,
0.433730036,
0.8525679111,
-0.7076475024,
0.6420224905,
0.0763132498,
-0.1643430144,
-0.5758181214,
-0.4519532323,
-0.6827402115,
0.1148080304,
0.1236665547,
0.4453645051,
-1.1030888557,
0.3301897645,
-0.2884136438,
-0.2587808371,
-0.1276217699,
0.2427860051,
0.2037869245,
1.0297116041,
0.389456898,
-0.121385619,
-0.40147838,
-0.6376039982,
-0.2788819075,
-0.0350092649,
-0.1240525022,
0.3144107461,
0.1990124285,
0.0534756631,
1.3303791285,
-0.5017136335,
-0.7248453498,
-0.6736594439,
0.3737978637,
0.1794304848,
0.5076133013,
0.5301803946,
-0.3049893975,
-0.6168238521,
-0.2393842191,
-0.4767882228,
-0.1469793022,
-0.407240361,
-0.408195436,
0.1884534061,
0.2670460939,
-0.5025699139,
0.2216389477,
0.0791571662,
-0.2934692502,
0.3807343841,
0.0408372842,
-0.1435525417,
-1.2623120546,
0.0918728411,
-0.044388067,
-0.1369644403,
-0.8157467246,
-0.498760432,
-0.2709427476,
-0.5016366243,
-0.556481421,
0.9035229087,
-0.3968170285,
-0.081744276,
-0.3133834898,
0.357449919,
0.0236623734,
0.6732480526,
0.1735298485,
0.7789801359,
0.2592009306,
-0.8577849865,
-0.203281492,
0.8386593461,
-0.4089137614,
0.5951286554,
-0.3304045796,
0.2209055275,
-0.1711203009,
0.1093976274,
-0.9404469728,
-0.3168966472,
0.2547544837,
-0.4548009336,
0.2858727276,
-0.2841509283,
-0.4821940362,
-0.3567713499,
-0.1479393244,
0.1226196289,
0.702321589,
-0.4025075734,
0.3484533727,
0.2013994753,
-0.3064054847,
-0.2439785451,
-0.5920539498,
-0.0530453101,
-0.1979516,
-0.7275206447,
0.3199799061,
0.0391917042,
0.0471861251,
-0.2278172523,
-0.1293658763,
-0.1783963889,
-0.0365043394,
0.1788811833,
0.0920594335,
-0.2458688766,
0.2853848934,
0.1764903814,
-0.1842294037,
-0.0335106365,
-0.48118487,
0.6561442614,
0.2621538043,
0.0266965162,
-0.2853066027,
0.3413708806,
-0.005454056,
-0.0549146645,
0.5387941599,
0.5570967793,
-0.3227367699,
-0.7232387066,
-0.2577041686,
-0.3944267333,
-0.4719130397,
0.0684287623,
-0.3961738646,
-0.5717336535,
0.2736889124,
-0.4541131556,
0.1914814413,
0.2514201105,
0.4086839557,
-0.1705210656,
0.6007177234,
0.6727731824,
0.2795242965,
0.4316421449,
-0.1802497804,
-0.0316094086,
-0.4991185665,
-0.0341351405,
-0.6532345414,
-0.3188230991,
-0.2738952637,
-0.2420293242,
0.6320342422,
0.319835484,
-0.1317609549,
0.2121560127,
-0.3449019194,
0.353376925,
0.827254355,
0.0440831073,
0.2136710286,
0.0028730773,
-0.2236587256,
-0.156551972,
-1.4397720098,
-0.7413128614,
0.9041807652,
-0.0726510286,
0.6016353369,
-0.1944084167,
0.9434545636,
0.2064848244,
0.0719885156,
-0.5972869992,
0.6391185522,
-0.1343317628,
-0.4200379252,
-0.4685091972,
-0.4064304233,
-0.8623694181,
-0.1413848996,
-0.5999727845,
-0.4128555357,
-0.027688263,
0.5686369538,
-0.6416585445,
0.0086015873,
-0.7194705606,
1.1171928644,
-0.0832480565,
-0.6155669093,
0.2533231378,
-0.7405756712,
0.5052422285,
-0.1818280369,
-0.0323345698,
-0.2111168802,
0.1940002143,
0.9873554707,
-0.5073868632,
0.8189026117,
-0.3224001229,
0.2879056633,
0.7332948446,
0.3504951894,
0.5872072577,
0.0446789712,
0.0610771626,
-0.3762558699,
-0.467261672,
-0.1158418506,
-0.2371863127,
0.4043438137,
-0.4418281913,
-0.4768013358,
-0.0327312835,
-0.659565568,
-0.3803396225,
0.3400239944,
0.7604126334,
0.2212303281,
-0.3378905654,
-0.128084451,
0.7195090055,
-0.5543011427,
0.7547460794,
0.4131925106,
-0.0448372178,
-0.3722341955,
0.8063526154,
0.1051707491,
0.0763448104,
0.452984333,
0.1599631906,
-0.3920204937,
-0.4670647979,
-0.5767731667,
0.0070015662,
-0.5382175446,
-0.57913059,
-0.6440555453,
0.0003073945,
-0.3528942466,
-0.3249785602,
-0.0930464789,
-0.4047802985,
-0.6983523369,
0.0791262984,
0.5178093314,
0.456597656,
0.0882736519,
1.0042034388,
-0.9986148477,
0.5519102812,
0.479665637,
0.0895184353,
-0.2304429859,
-0.412768811,
-0.0288404282,
-0.3508940339,
-0.3953878582,
-1.0890769958,
0.596447587,
0.5336378217,
0.3832215071,
0.3196730912,
0.3159058094,
0.46959126,
-0.7924406528,
0.7839788198,
0.4382445812,
-0.7539486289,
0.8286775947,
-0.4786981642,
0.5702780485,
0.7195315957,
0.1594498605,
-0.4714041054,
-0.0936090872,
-0.3421013057,
-0.7479603291,
1.0609529018,
0.0223864615,
-0.1663502753,
-0.0818016827,
0.2558453679,
0.5049804449,
0.4341560006,
-0.7857035398,
-0.0766039118,
-0.2767637074,
-0.1862035096,
0.1017324403,
-0.3222698867,
-0.0684547722,
0.2967911065,
0.4746936262,
-0.3220332563,
0.1594548672,
0.0115358625,
-0.323307693,
-0.2305036932,
0.6384160519,
0.7062875032,
0.4892091155,
0.1700997949,
0.0532250889,
0.1046033576,
-0.217765823,
0.1994700432,
-0.0727163851,
-0.5962326527,
0.0961367488,
0.2004921585,
1.0076310635,
0.0710039362,
-0.3524264991,
0.5041744709,
0.0999430567,
-0.2167555094,
-0.0004930668,
0.2414131016,
-0.0767419264,
-0.0238093268,
0.3916733265,
0.1183607951,
-0.0871200114,
-0.1622075737,
0.4689674675,
0.3662437499,
-0.0113898544,
-0.2951600254,
0.9081248641,
0.4139726162,
-0.3584611714,
0.384470582,
-0.5368462205,
-0.1905129105,
0.2886539996,
0.7189189196,
0.7192450166,
0.0145289944,
0.3600363731,
0.4791818857,
0.3687266111,
-0.1472393125,
0.4602056742,
-0.2104816735,
-0.5814122558,
-0.2208685577,
-0.6568313241,
-0.1264125407,
0.0937777311,
-0.2322887927,
0.5519323945,
-0.6623660326,
-0.4428632557,
-0.2576568425,
-0.0335074216,
-0.946823895,
0.0986076966,
0.0128868828,
0.880030632,
-0.8146883249,
0.78977561,
0.4801938534,
-0.3962228894,
-0.8795627356,
0.0828966796,
-0.1119335666,
-0.6247399449,
0.5656092763,
0.0198129453,
0.2497904748,
0.4228654206,
-0.3755250871,
-0.4718453288,
1.0612232685,
0.2826171219,
-0.8116441369,
-0.3256928623,
0.3427944779,
0.3145827651,
-0.2762879133,
-0.1198685318,
0.6667404771,
0.6302871108,
0.1520197093,
-0.5456408858,
-0.1294956207,
0.1531536877,
0.083155565,
0.1766845733,
-0.2500401735,
0.5975831151,
-0.2687620223,
-0.5220282674,
-0.0573560111,
0.7151792645,
0.4117185771,
0.4687275887,
0.2850018442,
0.5561469793,
0.5530552864,
-0.1353355944,
0.6326304674,
-0.3208587766,
-0.210515365,
1.3557317257,
-0.5133816004,
0.5379700065,
0.3689492047,
-0.0450866781,
0.034644302,
0.4117324352,
0.1330964118,
0.6504827738,
0.0154167181,
-0.1677475125,
-0.1618580669,
-0.3244358897,
-0.2275140733,
0.2225371152,
0.3069116771,
-0.2803155184,
-0.5750367641,
0.1180212721,
-0.1736402661,
0.2821186483,
-0.4075942934,
1.2613976002,
0.086088635,
-0.7413470745,
0.5162985921,
-0.1301714629,
0.4146793485,
-0.5726645589,
-0.0261375345,
-0.2799642682,
-0.3227878511,
-0.1585464776,
-0.6190651059,
0.089338772,
0.1426475644,
-0.240307197,
-0.4006369114,
0.9117058516,
-0.6628902555,
-0.0882928073,
-0.2719291151,
1.0064690113,
-0.047388047,
0.0528477095,
-0.3405026793,
-0.4072241187,
-0.0064765774,
-0.1753114313,
0.2304313183,
0.6358473897,
0.0447449721,
0.3787201941,
0.5058781505,
0.0201158579,
0.3954402208,
-0.0257922001,
0.7229095697,
-0.6697204113,
-0.7771946788,
-0.6643179059,
0.4994755387,
0.3053386807,
-0.5682736039,
0.4884316027,
0.556050539,
0.4809451401,
-0.4083565772,
0.7746701241,
0.1415133029,
0.5504119992,
-0.7104976773,
0.8816401362,
-0.2455475628,
0.1086075231,
-0.3179751039,
-1.0618242025,
-0.3069513142,
0.3454702199,
-0.1469279528,
-0.2329101861,
0.5813819766,
0.6888165474,
0.2109540105,
-0.2486400455,
0.4915098846,
-0.0103428699,
0.1388874799,
0.7668700814,
0.8067271709,
-0.1082885414,
0.7434659004,
-0.0383103639,
-0.0855270624,
-0.1431141943,
-0.9832905531,
-1.1074615717,
-0.7063623071,
-0.1021499783,
0.047010418,
-0.0853165761,
1.0339229107,
0.642213583,
-0.3507329226,
-0.0496748909,
-0.5266962051,
0.1703358591,
0.1141360775,
-0.2061987817,
0.2608277202,
-0.6098848581,
-0.3564642072,
0.5349950194,
0.3291431069,
0.4617848396,
0.0810880587,
-0.0428559706,
0.0856852606,
-0.0229128879,
0.5709001422,
0.3203551769,
-0.3724838793,
0.1930705309,
0.0560198687,
-0.1888298392,
0.2553973198,
1.0095791817,
-1.0868779421,
0.1822207868,
0.6009650826,
0.6229271293,
0.3714663088,
0.0216440111,
0.5557622313,
-1.3201782703,
0.2736114562,
0.4729993939,
0.1074274927,
0.2461093962,
-0.2256017774,
0.2883540392,
0.0302578732,
-0.5138561726,
-0.6377665997,
0.4408200979,
-0.9290766716,
-0.1653892547,
0.977653563,
0.0546234809,
-0.2808305621,
0.1312675029,
-0.2511948347,
0.3992286921,
-0.5935157537,
0.7479626536,
0.2808941007,
-0.1918909252,
-0.2657241225,
-0.3001827896,
1.130224824,
0.2193751782,
-1.2386592627,
0.0682322979,
0.7922880054,
-0.1261704713,
0.0492004231,
0.8073279262,
0.2320177853,
0.4702107608,
0.0874466673,
0.0747442916,
-0.1525758654,
-0.6658552885,
-0.1175304875,
0.4199534357,
0.3397962153,
-0.0622879788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04391v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04391v7 | The Re-Label Method For Data-Centric Machine Learning | 2023-02-09T01:09:57 | 2024-01-14T13:50:20 | Tong Guo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In industry deep learning application, our manually labeled data has a
certain number of noisy data. To solve this problem and achieve more than 90
score in dev dataset, we present a simple method to find the noisy data and
re-label the noisy data by human, given the model predictions as references in
human labeling. In this paper, we illustrate our idea for a broad set of deep
learning tasks, includes classification, sequence tagging, object detection,
sequence generation, click-through rate prediction. The dev dataset evaluation
results and human evaluation results verify our idea. | [
-0.5466274023,
-0.5683342814,
0.104186371,
-0.1740644127,
-0.3328903317,
0.2019279301,
-0.1755916625,
-0.5100699663,
0.3606477976,
0.5490096211,
-0.7331764698,
-0.8232423067,
-0.2487829924,
0.0141210081,
-0.5588188171,
0.8741511106,
0.1456956267,
-0.3211304545,
-0.3931107521,
0.0871596709,
-0.5595453978,
-0.6859303713,
-0.6582329273,
-0.3705215454,
0.6782585382,
0.671666503,
0.6300079823,
1.0334405899,
0.6113798618,
0.2925878763,
0.0852633417,
0.0675503388,
-0.4702188969,
0.4884374738,
0.0688514411,
-0.4729514718,
-0.5279126167,
0.2217215896,
0.2389970571,
0.8717137575,
0.2365851551,
0.4276202619,
-0.0592633523,
0.8579375744,
-0.3886622787,
0.2921729386,
-0.3233871162,
0.5224040151,
-0.1855352521,
0.0437412784,
-0.7106465101,
-0.1564202309,
0.0834080502,
-0.728659451,
0.6363425851,
-0.0622096993,
0.7175388932,
0.6616554856,
-0.0428468771,
0.2090108544,
-0.7720015049,
1.2919249535,
-0.3056542575,
0.7583266497,
0.5230929852,
0.1849394441,
0.1396394372,
-0.8516086936,
-0.0427269749,
-0.0396111347,
0.4119618535,
-0.2180822492,
0.1313177049,
-0.2988798618,
0.2921652198,
0.3105828762,
-0.1833297312,
0.5480701923,
-0.4389620423,
-0.5062973499,
1.1234819889,
0.3885598183,
-0.1474130601,
0.5031929016,
-0.2670029402,
-0.1815758944,
-0.2351908386,
-0.1932681203,
0.2594605088,
0.5602110624,
0.3187402785,
0.2298203409,
-0.7996073961,
1.1102547646,
0.2637277246,
-0.2193269879,
1.0469315052,
-0.2661037445,
-0.308642149,
0.2405388951,
0.504036963,
0.3862077296,
0.3545255661,
-0.4828186631,
-0.3980611861,
0.0217633583,
0.6417553425,
-0.8509720564,
-0.441924125,
0.2319444269,
-0.4965355396,
-0.6699187756,
-0.172811985,
-0.8460432291,
-0.685762763,
-0.9002689123,
0.2162638903,
-0.1327486187,
-0.3036353886,
0.2729329765,
0.1944075823,
0.0403111763,
0.2772417665,
-0.5698508024,
-0.1054296643,
0.7884554863,
0.4403559566,
-0.1588382572,
-0.2444266677,
-0.298491478,
-0.1628669202,
-0.3579840064,
0.7618952394,
-0.4126075506,
-0.4226707816,
-0.4634738863,
0.0184704028,
0.3598711193,
-0.6367003918,
0.6359020472,
-0.4475715756,
0.0425585844,
-0.1522067636,
-0.4699425995,
-0.5948702693,
0.1798585653,
-0.8517969847,
0.5900511146,
0.1311339736,
-0.5034430027,
0.9094765782,
-0.2477128804,
-0.7166696191,
0.0477059074,
-0.0001544235,
-1.0780565739,
-0.1265016049,
0.0173481815,
0.5323919654,
-0.1491532922,
0.6268313527,
-0.4494779706,
-0.3938322663,
0.4212975502,
-0.4110805988,
0.5628137589,
0.536423564,
-0.2282241881,
0.0812621266,
-1.0404149294,
0.4087155461,
-0.287227273,
-0.630392611,
-0.0321504734,
-0.336157918,
-0.2422026098,
0.0562674701,
0.0211325455,
-0.5854263902,
0.3953464627,
-0.0478624403,
0.2865660787,
0.6254316568,
-0.1479837596,
0.3738819361,
-0.2100242078,
0.4737384319,
0.1238941327,
0.2296058238,
0.0780248865,
-0.7482100725,
-0.7104568481,
-0.419404,
0.701546967,
0.2805789709,
-0.3082079589,
0.5790051222,
-0.1106548086,
-0.6613224745,
-1.0791852474,
0.3369268477,
0.2549470663,
0.9760421515,
0.4135584533,
-0.4451785386,
-0.9809579849,
-1.100620389,
-0.1542919874,
0.1204698533,
-0.0323317237,
0.214502424,
0.1290196776,
-0.7987825871,
1.1215612888,
-0.5501093864,
-0.4726783037,
0.0265628584,
0.6275145411,
0.2107145786,
0.4918296337,
-0.1601795554,
-0.859136641,
-0.2010164857,
-0.2527018487,
-0.7028169036,
-0.3075649738,
0.0428853855,
0.0783532709,
0.2320674211,
0.6332873106,
-0.0961787403,
0.5999034643,
-0.0869065374,
0.1401015818,
0.4178448617,
0.1896915585,
0.1249450445,
-0.8354979753,
0.0967414826,
0.230681628,
-0.0910659283,
-0.5299129486,
-0.3139132857,
-0.2872833014,
-0.4133927524,
-0.4690569043,
0.0696719587,
-0.3504981995,
-0.0538579449,
-0.402351141,
-0.1818133742,
0.3309378028,
0.4459729195,
0.2744614482,
0.5295648575,
0.6256085038,
-0.7824730873,
0.6423484087,
-0.0574796237,
-0.4213904142,
0.3506835699,
-0.4148336053,
0.577455163,
-0.4585096836,
0.2025472671,
-1.14325881,
-0.1635246426,
0.367703259,
-0.3885889053,
0.4504550993,
-0.2156975865,
-0.2917842865,
-0.4956684709,
-0.2250641882,
0.5400412083,
0.3833915889,
-0.3985337019,
0.0938234404,
0.6429051161,
0.4335416257,
-0.4328324497,
-1.0727748871,
-0.0360495225,
-0.4384686947,
-0.5777834058,
0.4512208104,
0.1254698634,
0.0170650352,
-0.0855732113,
-0.0119528137,
-0.5005586743,
0.2153177559,
0.5606373549,
0.0746876895,
-0.217291981,
0.4565139413,
-0.5785869956,
-0.6277042031,
0.071698904,
-0.1227658615,
0.1334257722,
0.0295472667,
-0.0908742249,
-0.8117679954,
0.1479249597,
0.2006198913,
0.0864098221,
0.185956791,
1.0557204485,
-0.4358090758,
-0.0927984565,
-0.2460241616,
-0.2527020574,
-0.4689003229,
0.5188227892,
-0.5428884625,
-0.414557904,
0.2516842484,
-0.3299899697,
-0.0477398448,
0.3603079319,
0.3684180379,
-0.0872183144,
0.9653522968,
0.5544688106,
-0.5037586689,
0.2310108989,
-0.5642475486,
0.3863524795,
-0.624360323,
-0.4563736022,
-0.4905970097,
-0.9487420321,
-0.2920567393,
-0.2655081153,
-0.1265194267,
0.1688635647,
-0.503159523,
0.4184102714,
-1.2213127613,
0.1572346687,
0.736561358,
0.3487030864,
0.3522137403,
0.0512021556,
0.3652864099,
-0.2908752561,
-0.4259606898,
-0.1285998225,
1.1174811125,
0.473323226,
1.2276184559,
-0.2229260206,
0.9898958206,
0.5621734262,
0.448854804,
-1.0109639168,
0.4291262031,
-0.0906470194,
-0.6151199341,
-0.373554647,
-0.2593188882,
-1.1253852844,
-0.3150893152,
0.1217326522,
-0.7105591297,
0.4787710309,
-0.0103989756,
-0.4346472621,
0.0278612077,
-0.9891755581,
0.7725773454,
-0.27427122,
-0.3121682107,
0.1197103709,
-0.4280106425,
0.2612512708,
-0.2554847002,
0.0602778718,
-0.0818246007,
-0.0713248029,
1.2667908669,
-0.3441844583,
1.3095359802,
-0.2485068738,
-0.1285671443,
0.7908118963,
-0.0977028757,
0.2478251755,
0.0220029373,
-0.2731954157,
0.0592032894,
-0.7231535912,
-0.0296401083,
-0.3229998946,
0.6853500009,
-0.7371634245,
-0.4902525246,
-0.1908790767,
-0.4963260591,
-0.0590796731,
0.1506493986,
0.3051849306,
0.3069178462,
0.2948694229,
0.3405721784,
0.8728705645,
-0.0305247288,
0.2617586255,
0.5330924988,
-0.1883336604,
-0.3975995183,
1.2854378223,
0.3119049668,
-0.3176376224,
0.1786862761,
0.0074354671,
-0.4164511561,
-0.1933919191,
-0.3696014881,
-0.2730194032,
-0.4725542367,
-0.6386916637,
-0.5504757166,
-0.2962548137,
-0.3043025732,
-0.240184471,
-0.773509264,
-0.0189051013,
-0.7413939238,
-0.2322434783,
0.5985220075,
0.6033963561,
-0.0859562233,
0.1611310542,
-0.3960780799,
0.4266459346,
0.3404724598,
0.6839618683,
0.0444206819,
-0.5849140882,
-0.4004067183,
0.3401972353,
-0.3916819096,
-0.5689284205,
0.2450301647,
0.0206279065,
0.4733153582,
0.3192266822,
0.1676169485,
0.5739599466,
0.1123584807,
0.2842327654,
0.052668646,
-0.6482118368,
0.6137696505,
0.2400567234,
0.1020657271,
0.7443799973,
0.4380824268,
-0.2370276451,
0.2145820558,
-0.6220160723,
-1.040594101,
0.5051410794,
-0.4225721955,
-0.1921367198,
0.3244582415,
0.3668942451,
0.3887277246,
0.2900544405,
-0.2949535847,
-0.2915443778,
-0.0561012104,
-0.0575209558,
0.0146837691,
-0.1160838529,
0.3056638837,
-0.4566182494,
0.5380210876,
0.1210820675,
0.2508413792,
0.2036621869,
0.0582003146,
-0.1889081448,
0.0849265233,
0.1671824753,
0.4191257954,
-0.48923105,
-0.0994038954,
-0.1844954342,
-0.6437262893,
0.5369347334,
-0.0180595703,
-0.3370752335,
-0.0473601669,
0.1485307068,
0.5385357141,
-0.0078305611,
-0.220039621,
0.0747524574,
0.0832206607,
-0.3564153612,
-0.1958646774,
0.1242058352,
0.0320499688,
-0.0165482443,
0.2221210599,
0.34050107,
0.4503521323,
-0.3125244975,
0.894428134,
-0.1242602766,
-0.9088521004,
-0.1694648564,
0.8585371971,
0.4186444879,
-0.6187809706,
0.9941382408,
-0.416867137,
-0.4197362065,
0.8045048714,
0.2186492383,
0.9659647942,
0.0011261227,
0.3296278715,
0.4012341797,
-0.0190367401,
-0.0306508448,
0.4847189188,
0.0646447167,
-0.663525641,
-0.7862952948,
-0.270426631,
-0.2749491632,
0.3435716629,
-0.8287490606,
0.5730736852,
-0.4083384275,
-0.4968133569,
0.4599836469,
0.2952426672,
-0.9244299531,
0.6942685843,
0.3751102686,
0.6871651411,
-0.8428188562,
0.9729599953,
0.5001689196,
-0.3603105545,
-0.5578627586,
-0.3881280422,
-0.0490949675,
-0.55923599,
0.9124187231,
0.4104765654,
-0.0758627206,
0.0488893017,
-0.6986735463,
-0.7707709074,
0.9577188492,
0.0645812973,
-0.8419901133,
0.766792357,
0.101472266,
0.5571368933,
-0.5123258233,
-0.2026671767,
0.5813122988,
0.5949690342,
-0.0342480689,
-0.2801715732,
-0.0452998914,
-0.1292884052,
-0.4777818322,
0.1767176688,
-0.6739418507,
0.70385921,
-0.5646201372,
-0.0340463407,
-0.2355778217,
0.84854877,
0.1081160679,
0.8450496197,
0.5617847443,
0.9508665204,
1.0277330875,
0.0134352408,
0.6405967474,
0.1934417486,
0.4556575418,
1.2449734211,
-0.2870606184,
0.3593364656,
0.2607344389,
-0.1649416685,
0.0357109755,
0.9632268548,
-0.4336663783,
0.6954858303,
0.8118321896,
-0.0817348734,
-0.3538354039,
-0.4990493059,
-0.5982754827,
0.3868542314,
0.1557718217,
-0.5225702524,
0.0544242114,
0.0744094253,
-0.0153283775,
-0.1690251231,
-0.208081618,
0.7893258333,
-0.1116089523,
-0.3344567418,
0.7197300196,
-0.0474634655,
0.7168874741,
0.196087569,
-0.0443540514,
-0.2244918048,
0.2903820872,
-0.3626911342,
-1.1167571545,
0.359207809,
-0.2394732535,
-0.5683265924,
-0.1816994548,
0.7815090418,
-0.2803945243,
-0.5905444622,
-0.075404495,
0.1928190291,
0.4990305901,
-0.0662393644,
-0.6802923679,
0.2703823447,
0.5482956767,
-0.2484660745,
0.2618634105,
0.5587228537,
-0.0255701207,
1.0965038538,
0.414141804,
-0.4746530652,
0.0069027133,
0.2971464097,
0.830666244,
-0.9352025986,
-0.2114283741,
-0.5334211588,
0.3390491307,
-0.1024106219,
-0.491574347,
0.3552290797,
0.7755755782,
0.8084807992,
-0.1574580967,
0.7877408862,
0.0827859491,
0.5947809815,
0.0960918963,
0.3043860495,
-0.0812521055,
0.4348731339,
-0.0730739981,
-0.7143318653,
-0.4697340131,
0.447963655,
-0.366466105,
0.1483975798,
0.1185962558,
0.7703488469,
-0.1184567958,
0.1190237105,
0.2011623681,
0.079625845,
0.1211038679,
0.6570323706,
0.6564619541,
-0.5305735469,
0.6067985296,
-0.9211573601,
0.0531816036,
-0.3580418229,
-0.7880784273,
-0.5333856344,
-0.4955077767,
-1.1197066307,
-0.4204098284,
-0.1805550307,
0.1946409941,
1.0165380239,
-0.8499920368,
0.2068337351,
0.031230526,
0.3093211651,
-0.5151388049,
-0.2970902324,
0.3485509753,
-0.3111411929,
-0.706361115,
0.2364343256,
-0.0883611888,
-0.0920228362,
-0.3335080743,
0.0467986502,
-0.0417693853,
-0.7976176739,
0.227236107,
0.2416655123,
-0.2495314479,
-0.2126410604,
-0.2876271307,
-0.1622445732,
0.0389460586,
0.8072618246,
-1.3873167038,
0.5916360021,
0.5946151018,
0.7365347147,
0.3418971896,
0.303024888,
0.4568833113,
-1.0237898827,
0.2629100084,
0.2616763711,
-0.016760109,
0.4500901699,
-0.7660601735,
0.8483363986,
0.201806128,
-0.7285910845,
-0.6131988168,
0.008940218,
-0.9773206711,
-0.1357730627,
0.7961153984,
-0.1295174807,
-0.4130657613,
-0.569239974,
-0.1708217561,
0.2200761586,
-0.6097259521,
1.1362110376,
0.239010334,
-0.2353061438,
-0.0241044946,
-0.3953199983,
0.3836267591,
0.1950362325,
-0.3225921988,
0.0287256371,
0.2038995177,
0.177160874,
0.2566201091,
0.3246626854,
0.0516088754,
-0.0124848112,
0.1822178364,
0.3868172467,
-0.4689449966,
-0.4092400372,
-0.1055510938,
0.1221291274,
-0.0206747577,
-0.9650233388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06451v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06451v1 | Ordered Memory Baselines | 2023-02-08T22:36:25 | 2023-02-08T22:36:25 | Daniel Borisov, Matthew D'Iorio, Jeffrey Hyacinthe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Natural language semantics can be modeled using the phrase-structured model,
which can be represented using a tree-type architecture. As a result, recent
advances in natural language processing have been made utilising recursive
neural networks using memory models that allow them to infer tree-type
representations of the input sentence sequence. These new tree models have
allowed for improvements in sentiment analysis and semantic recognition. Here
we review the Ordered Memory model proposed by Shen et al. (2019) at the
NeurIPS 2019 conference, and try to either create baselines that can perform
better or create simpler models that can perform equally as well. We found that
the Ordered Memory model performs on par with the state-of-the-art models used
in tree-type modelling, and performs better than simplified baselines that
require fewer parameters. | [
-0.3431707025,
-0.7949024439,
0.5490353107,
-0.0990210623,
-0.1416996717,
-0.2808371186,
0.1328280717,
-0.6910362244,
0.107152015,
0.6065062881,
-0.3095403612,
-0.4363983274,
-0.7245641947,
-0.0258616377,
-0.7756479979,
0.8542088866,
0.2342026532,
0.1171662882,
-0.2054340988,
-0.4499455988,
-0.4951958954,
-0.7608385682,
-0.7339398861,
-0.6370829344,
0.2025325,
0.0787988678,
1.1613363028,
0.7103646398,
0.4770614803,
0.3784709275,
-0.4207886755,
-0.1203933656,
-0.1677545905,
0.1104297563,
0.0204542931,
-0.3767898381,
-0.6399822831,
0.1575927734,
0.3832200766,
0.9618110657,
-0.3599544466,
0.0583626367,
-0.0864359885,
0.6627762318,
-0.707192719,
0.1312645376,
-0.6858109832,
0.1385601163,
0.1690007299,
-0.3105452657,
-0.5690360069,
-0.4189880192,
0.6493293643,
-0.2871773839,
-0.1179843917,
-0.1622255296,
1.0971672535,
0.21433492,
-0.1795001179,
-0.3536881804,
-0.5619288683,
0.7333250642,
-0.9425976872,
0.343542546,
0.3223032951,
0.1699461192,
-0.1864484996,
-0.9333721995,
-0.2113670409,
-0.0792219117,
-0.357139647,
0.1072091311,
-0.2538364828,
0.1900750697,
0.1970454007,
0.4676688612,
-0.3673204482,
0.0587951913,
0.0801779106,
0.3109364212,
0.0641715601,
0.3584900796,
0.4591776133,
-0.5622050762,
-0.2469391823,
0.3002866805,
-0.4026125669,
0.0426003635,
-0.0726386085,
0.4023329616,
0.0150978798,
0.5883746147,
-0.6223106384,
1.006976366,
0.058762867,
-0.084422335,
0.1726423055,
-0.3687866032,
-0.5278278589,
0.0363297425,
0.4174710214,
0.5127545595,
0.4663000405,
-0.0910647586,
-0.2746198177,
0.2724037468,
0.3733413517,
-0.8821638823,
-0.4009799957,
0.0615100898,
-0.6154612899,
-0.2794666886,
-0.2488848567,
-0.5871244669,
-0.0732770115,
-0.5662724376,
0.2627035975,
-0.7008823752,
0.0350254104,
0.2822391391,
-0.0428212211,
0.3437882364,
0.3352966607,
-1.0079386234,
0.7989094257,
0.7499992847,
0.7263422012,
0.132424131,
-0.0649954453,
-0.4202271402,
-0.0643331036,
-0.5151876807,
0.752981782,
-0.7055623531,
-0.0902468786,
-0.0062876325,
-0.4025115967,
0.0292193871,
-0.5473732352,
0.5514039397,
-0.6695300341,
0.5749880075,
-0.2122787088,
-0.5993734598,
-0.1994291097,
0.3254621327,
-0.5355096459,
1.2724386454,
0.1153707355,
-0.9425848126,
0.3902204633,
-0.2625840306,
-0.3993817568,
0.0854703113,
-0.1984838098,
-0.1203651205,
0.3168189228,
0.3341241479,
0.4164052606,
-0.1026055887,
0.5638570786,
-0.2327920496,
-0.2355675697,
0.0634922609,
-0.2347070724,
0.945417285,
0.287448287,
-0.0687035322,
0.0091752438,
-0.8168721199,
0.317470938,
-0.0919942781,
-0.5023674369,
-0.6214681864,
0.4511354566,
-0.2922774553,
0.3738640249,
0.230696559,
-0.4368652999,
-0.0236403588,
-0.8016996384,
0.9284982085,
0.3867934942,
-0.0302645471,
0.8494676948,
-0.0462407432,
0.0041377549,
0.0169057623,
0.0576406009,
-0.3298278153,
-0.4697456956,
-0.8249462843,
0.2137990594,
0.1414193958,
0.6831102371,
-0.3501018584,
0.4128268957,
-0.4095771313,
-0.0519345924,
-0.3410155475,
-0.2312745005,
0.381870687,
0.7600406408,
0.432294786,
-0.3320846856,
-0.7860305309,
-1.0556833744,
-0.0615250096,
-0.5274403095,
0.0299077444,
0.2252397984,
0.1318749934,
0.0637128428,
0.9583160877,
-0.4912443161,
0.3347927034,
-0.2354971468,
0.3759737909,
0.299885273,
0.2088912129,
0.5434599519,
-0.5902489424,
-0.142898798,
-0.1975177526,
-0.5865524411,
0.0111608757,
0.2228942811,
-0.2075338811,
0.4788975418,
0.6798095107,
-0.8693678975,
0.489402324,
0.2887845039,
-0.1623617411,
0.0331707597,
-0.019143559,
-0.0798224956,
-1.2473558187,
-0.2408106774,
-0.3709436953,
-0.391222775,
-0.7646144629,
-0.0058986731,
0.0707308874,
0.0439778976,
-0.2982783914,
0.127104044,
-0.491238147,
-0.4572159052,
-0.3744511306,
0.0050091101,
0.1446264684,
0.2870792449,
0.283166647,
0.4705783725,
0.5806209445,
-0.616648078,
-0.1454327852,
0.1080257595,
-0.4775155485,
0.7319883704,
-0.478389889,
-0.1179527119,
-0.3423552215,
0.122552596,
-1.1622222662,
-0.0344604403,
-0.1310854405,
-0.6600171328,
0.3292537928,
-0.199267298,
-0.5224000812,
-0.3772661388,
0.0824890658,
0.1440194398,
0.634945631,
-0.4401479661,
0.5176258683,
0.3988612294,
-0.1136992499,
-0.4605858326,
-0.7094498873,
0.1886504591,
-0.1752096415,
-0.4290870428,
0.6924304366,
0.0614356436,
-0.4460723996,
0.2906552553,
-0.0125069926,
-0.2206020653,
0.2242231369,
0.2294442505,
0.2920562625,
-0.7063341737,
0.1744424701,
-0.4344961047,
-0.2039902955,
0.0730942711,
-0.2427683771,
0.6976629496,
-0.4136506319,
0.3343816698,
-0.4420174062,
0.2655489743,
0.456784308,
-0.0916047022,
0.7251873612,
-0.1120480075,
-0.796525836,
-0.0450014435,
-0.3020169139,
0.0213994123,
-0.4933031201,
0.3434847593,
-0.2555172145,
-0.7487915158,
0.1524420679,
0.1484705508,
0.357472986,
0.3399466872,
0.4372985959,
-0.3717896342,
1.0682524443,
0.5920843482,
-0.3163547218,
0.6274913549,
0.0260892939,
0.349847883,
-0.5360096097,
0.0642346814,
-0.5227924585,
-0.2904984653,
-0.4422708154,
-0.1089359671,
-0.228358537,
0.4413023889,
-0.4594864547,
0.5734057426,
-0.5637459159,
0.6341549158,
0.5433043838,
-0.1309013218,
0.1665340662,
0.1174779162,
-0.2899648547,
0.1466808021,
-0.6966711283,
-0.8270366192,
0.4552257061,
0.1600874513,
0.451554358,
-0.3177604377,
0.7759478688,
-0.1625047028,
0.2580622137,
-0.8650566339,
0.7757950425,
-0.4392145276,
-0.4897092879,
-0.1489506364,
-0.0668570027,
-1.096257925,
0.3070228398,
0.053337276,
-0.8243914247,
0.0871691704,
-0.1684305966,
-0.6989953518,
0.2133278251,
-0.8452367187,
0.6660724878,
-0.1558965892,
0.3182782233,
-0.0650446936,
-0.6547862887,
0.2940850854,
0.6738370061,
-0.1659187227,
-0.2347135544,
-0.0626045242,
0.7647173405,
-0.6225173473,
0.6717660427,
0.0138571411,
0.593033731,
0.5638972521,
0.2449864,
0.1880415082,
-0.2229142636,
-0.3419077992,
-0.0876565427,
0.063426517,
-0.4160865247,
-0.490439713,
0.7616620064,
-0.9294099808,
-0.4838436544,
-0.3964930177,
-0.5291445851,
-0.2884159982,
0.240231961,
0.207138598,
0.5068227053,
-0.227003485,
0.1974229813,
0.3138289452,
-0.1433173567,
0.8667598963,
0.4528828263,
-0.1636686176,
-0.5229151249,
0.1368531138,
0.6670275927,
0.2771619856,
0.5795372128,
0.159842819,
0.0576582067,
-0.9639359117,
-0.0975891501,
-0.11328803,
-0.8471672535,
-0.3008264601,
-0.9983698726,
-0.6529042125,
-0.3778816462,
-0.2316672355,
-0.4792262614,
-0.6606242657,
-0.2551476657,
-0.6428158879,
0.4467694163,
0.8807020783,
0.3838701844,
0.4783684909,
-0.6351785064,
0.5009812117,
0.2088567764,
0.4400137663,
0.2142398208,
-0.4284338653,
0.0185350403,
-0.1773584634,
-0.1859790236,
-0.7862807512,
0.7020594478,
-0.0255437121,
0.5039613247,
0.1768949181,
-0.1532436162,
1.253559351,
-0.7583898306,
0.5245836973,
-0.0038127287,
-0.7690250278,
0.6161490679,
-0.2202773988,
0.4968731105,
0.7746514082,
0.252944231,
-0.5742599368,
-0.2421716154,
-0.7771766186,
-0.9496670365,
0.7332872748,
0.2130043954,
0.2273474634,
-0.53679353,
0.6119919419,
0.0476082042,
0.1724611521,
-0.6694890261,
-0.2851658463,
-0.1826075464,
-0.1568655819,
-0.1269904226,
-0.5430258512,
0.3609178364,
-0.3466167748,
0.3221915066,
0.2119790614,
0.2021303922,
-0.0055037979,
-0.0498680323,
-0.0761160702,
0.3310569823,
0.1417129636,
0.4570484161,
-0.3604903519,
0.3894588947,
0.1918110102,
-0.1146694198,
-0.0702175796,
-0.2015615553,
-0.6212845445,
0.0783304572,
0.3335615993,
0.7774013877,
0.6658592224,
-0.2737311423,
0.1494319141,
0.0660915598,
-0.0125179486,
-0.4007644951,
-0.0711800084,
0.5838187337,
-0.0474548675,
-0.1042416468,
0.197927177,
0.1624446064,
-0.848382771,
0.5993694067,
0.4314644039,
-0.3748978376,
-0.3791741133,
0.3317770362,
-0.1597782224,
-0.5507663488,
1.0933587551,
0.1584725827,
-0.3698446155,
0.6016398072,
0.4898295403,
0.9235684872,
-0.2274620086,
0.2183662057,
0.6388235092,
0.2227267623,
-0.3032034636,
0.5852413774,
0.1372185051,
-0.9693636298,
-0.2055965662,
-0.872246027,
-0.2451011091,
0.1953915209,
-0.8249752522,
0.1612863392,
-0.8085175157,
-0.3006110489,
0.2596109509,
-0.0905667096,
-0.545735836,
0.3406051993,
0.4155832827,
0.8456062078,
-0.5551812053,
1.0120450258,
0.473290503,
-0.2780550122,
-0.5750332475,
-0.2576006055,
-0.0690036044,
-0.8416000009,
0.6957849264,
0.4659298956,
0.032380987,
-0.042871654,
-0.4447903037,
-1.4071165323,
1.0064820051,
0.1426989287,
-0.174006924,
-0.2291173637,
0.0571295433,
0.9603139162,
-0.7464033961,
0.3680181503,
0.5876781344,
0.1253366619,
0.2684749067,
-0.4387832582,
-0.1282034814,
-0.3469756544,
0.1855653077,
0.4728207886,
-0.1374080479,
1.1783736944,
0.13900657,
-0.5884889364,
0.3509893715,
0.7727091908,
0.1402838975,
0.2068258375,
0.3239237368,
1.1700435877,
0.630710721,
-0.0086801378,
1.3281092644,
-0.2757568061,
-0.2694843411,
1.6917434931,
-0.4856780767,
1.4889054298,
0.2927307785,
-0.1681605726,
0.7417674661,
0.8053747416,
0.3872181475,
0.5188438296,
0.0421001688,
0.271520704,
-0.1635243595,
-0.233107388,
-0.0347692668,
0.1812789589,
0.4225980937,
-0.516685605,
-0.6107825637,
-0.3224769235,
-0.0394790508,
-0.0242880583,
-0.4555380344,
1.0026493073,
0.1922779232,
-1.0286095142,
0.6340807676,
0.1591064334,
0.5661823153,
-0.2151693106,
0.1164839119,
-0.1163552254,
0.16631791,
-0.1126592904,
-0.8957890868,
0.6158712506,
0.0014023335,
-0.2737095654,
-0.5891082287,
0.6620141268,
-0.104978241,
-0.4242967665,
0.6256539226,
0.3907245696,
0.0419762768,
0.0324481316,
-0.7717138529,
-0.4734091163,
-0.6008090377,
-0.4661510885,
0.4143589437,
0.4102573097,
-0.2923003435,
0.4822180271,
0.3648707271,
-0.2628914416,
0.5511045456,
0.2255615294,
0.6028004289,
-0.940605104,
-0.5651122928,
-1.0352535248,
0.3163270056,
-0.1124584675,
-0.2511877716,
0.6698053479,
0.6312866807,
0.7849898934,
0.2965666354,
0.3265444934,
0.0330211185,
0.4682153761,
-0.4478051662,
0.2108374089,
-0.2038682401,
0.0611477159,
-0.1718747467,
-0.8177399039,
-0.409311831,
0.5922471285,
-0.5646744967,
-0.1124060303,
0.7673177719,
0.6397906542,
0.006231566,
0.3225513697,
0.3154598773,
0.4703792632,
-0.1466237158,
0.7481635213,
0.944853127,
-0.4211230278,
0.3257066905,
-0.5427904725,
0.2374013215,
0.0253622551,
-0.7854494452,
-0.7674041986,
-0.399835676,
-0.2688982785,
-0.1986460984,
0.048452381,
0.702624321,
0.7498879433,
-0.9487766027,
-0.3495229781,
-0.6471114755,
0.0836103112,
-0.0499764718,
-0.2137869895,
0.1238847822,
-0.5481146574,
-0.5186792612,
0.2687121034,
0.6933577657,
0.1326740235,
0.1201113015,
0.0468793064,
-0.6351143122,
0.4332307577,
0.9545423985,
0.0126167098,
-0.9390357137,
-0.3472620249,
0.0858317614,
-0.5702771544,
0.6308428049,
0.6406961679,
-1.1424082518,
0.1114147156,
1.0833604336,
0.6102990508,
0.2525863647,
0.0874877572,
0.4989857376,
-0.3434684873,
-0.080894269,
0.2801963091,
0.7279085517,
0.2532197237,
-0.1699400544,
0.5585792065,
0.0035143297,
-0.2298460007,
-0.5934879184,
0.3156771362,
-0.8976606131,
-0.6401792765,
0.7930372953,
0.0907799602,
-0.3811335564,
-0.1439633071,
-0.0054771635,
0.1029256657,
-0.1172395796,
0.6021639109,
1.0077960491,
-0.2233281434,
-0.3807631433,
-0.6449486017,
0.3418684304,
0.6649023294,
-0.8229106665,
0.0291546658,
0.6417053342,
0.1641801149,
0.1386588216,
0.8483299613,
-0.4962237179,
0.0713315085,
-0.1467244625,
-0.2353850305,
0.4003515542,
-0.4559513628,
-0.3704843819,
0.5556893349,
0.1258203387,
0.0578238852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04359v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04359v1 | Sentiment analysis and opinion mining on educational data: A survey | 2023-02-08T22:14:08 | 2023-02-08T22:14:08 | Thanveer Shaik, Xiaohui Tao, Christopher Dann, Haoran Xie, Yan Li, Linda Galligan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis AKA opinion mining is one of the most widely used NLP
applications to identify human intentions from their reviews. In the education
sector, opinion mining is used to listen to student opinions and enhance their
learning-teaching practices pedagogically. With advancements in sentiment
annotation techniques and AI methodologies, student comments can be labelled
with their sentiment orientation without much human intervention. In this
review article, (1) we consider the role of emotional analysis in education
from four levels: document level, sentence level, entity level, and aspect
level, (2) sentiment annotation techniques including lexicon-based and
corpus-based approaches for unsupervised annotations are explored, (3) the role
of AI in sentiment analysis with methodologies like machine learning, deep
learning, and transformers are discussed, (4) the impact of sentiment analysis
on educational procedures to enhance pedagogy, decision-making, and evaluation
are presented. Educational institutions have been widely invested to build
sentiment analysis tools and process their student feedback to draw their
opinions and insights. Applications built on sentiment analysis of student
feedback are reviewed in this study. Challenges in sentiment analysis like
multi-polarity, polysemous, negation words, and opinion spam detection are
explored and their trends in the research space are discussed. The future
directions of sentiment analysis in education are discussed. | [
-0.6156794429,
-0.7659161091,
0.2954386175,
0.1300884336,
0.0443409197,
0.3429379165,
-0.1077742279,
-0.4146339893,
0.1371530592,
0.2202795446,
-0.4614158273,
-0.7079927921,
-0.5906687975,
-0.0256904028,
-0.2956731617,
1.1418406963,
0.1829275638,
0.4877244234,
-0.6178719997,
-0.3127540946,
-0.2373840511,
-1.0308687687,
-0.9751212597,
-0.3548761308,
0.3081172705,
0.4657661915,
0.3442907929,
-0.109995082,
0.5172841549,
0.305337429,
-0.2592640221,
-0.3082717955,
-0.0767726526,
0.1183747202,
0.0009621771,
-0.602586627,
-0.6127802134,
0.3295087814,
0.5330356359,
0.8381304145,
-0.0120751634,
0.0926789716,
0.1967745274,
1.2036936283,
-0.5028585792,
0.1012712866,
0.046397388,
0.5211777687,
-0.367223531,
0.0219521727,
-0.2441419065,
-0.5032460093,
0.322917074,
-0.1152928695,
0.0529808998,
-0.2825176716,
0.3775340319,
0.1596253663,
-0.3731567264,
-0.5975396037,
-0.6476435065,
1.1374098063,
-0.677210331,
0.3472219706,
0.1943507493,
0.0425275043,
0.0813090801,
-0.4190838039,
-0.5021217465,
0.2402863353,
0.2176580578,
0.5224425793,
0.0982728824,
0.2990991771,
0.2329121977,
0.5257021189,
-0.1469667256,
0.0267383512,
-0.2793847024,
0.0892067924,
0.5492298603,
0.1821724772,
0.322298646,
-0.4786913991,
-0.4470936954,
-0.2124128789,
-0.2422387302,
0.5068226457,
0.8601323962,
0.1559454203,
0.2655147314,
0.4969356656,
-0.1158863232,
0.5622501373,
-0.0647059008,
0.0399032533,
0.3036701083,
0.0525647663,
-0.0162117612,
0.2889759839,
0.7965416312,
0.5512900949,
0.3651601374,
0.5149984956,
-0.2417956442,
0.5814740658,
0.3410626054,
-0.5835866928,
-0.2049309909,
0.3640990555,
-0.6353858709,
-0.7395910621,
0.1486744881,
-1.4775626659,
-0.5911781192,
-0.379666239,
-0.0112251779,
-0.2088088393,
-0.3987565041,
0.0535793416,
0.0369057134,
0.3662906885,
0.2812084258,
-0.7813709378,
0.3341759741,
0.8586127162,
0.6650406122,
-0.1167841628,
-0.1967530251,
0.1773845106,
-0.6181163192,
-0.11241927,
0.7592766881,
-0.9099746346,
-0.5628493428,
0.3394092917,
-0.3363620937,
-0.0078374287,
-0.2901932299,
0.6662992239,
-0.2295970619,
0.5106165409,
-0.0862224251,
-0.8792250156,
-0.4977574348,
0.5490628481,
-0.3549547791,
1.18450284,
0.0848149136,
-0.7447674274,
0.1392794549,
-0.9168948531,
-0.559636116,
-0.1319450885,
0.1183572337,
-0.4124704897,
0.2340553999,
0.3868162334,
0.4513064325,
-0.0059766807,
0.1429644227,
-0.3113424778,
-0.2930037677,
0.3100267649,
-0.1697232127,
0.7967172265,
0.09149234,
-0.4408876598,
-0.1331444532,
-0.4799079001,
0.1506956518,
-0.280926615,
-0.2501274645,
-0.5344389081,
0.3089026511,
-0.0105356406,
0.1836602241,
0.2802314162,
-0.5257532597,
0.2769669592,
-0.5084887147,
0.3032906055,
0.7094417214,
0.2118489742,
0.5559533238,
0.3181171715,
0.7417904139,
-0.0190585349,
0.482907474,
0.0519730113,
-0.5708501339,
-0.7496326566,
0.2201613635,
0.3289609253,
0.4704745114,
-0.3078785241,
0.1643526405,
0.2292434275,
-0.3638522327,
-1.0201002359,
0.0724788532,
-0.0050380016,
0.5000531673,
0.3592591286,
-0.2998677194,
-0.6639356613,
-0.5563467741,
-0.5215204358,
-0.4795902967,
0.406227082,
-0.1011524647,
0.2869057655,
-0.224794209,
0.9013036489,
-0.5077503324,
-0.3846271336,
-0.3193996549,
0.3474270105,
-0.054885,
0.2138465941,
0.5187990665,
-0.7689568996,
-0.5341950059,
-0.2624471188,
-0.8137138486,
-0.0988726988,
-0.0793537349,
0.0193033554,
0.4105096757,
0.1340485662,
-0.275072515,
0.3419493139,
0.1925058514,
-0.2724030018,
0.3116077483,
0.3877325058,
0.2647324502,
-0.694190681,
-0.351333946,
0.3863451779,
0.1176100522,
-0.6203635335,
-0.1187295839,
-0.2727213502,
-0.1210306734,
-0.2173337638,
0.3335765302,
-0.1850527525,
0.1747757345,
-0.6909782887,
0.2583259046,
-0.030691389,
0.2515169084,
0.0441830941,
0.1932762414,
0.7644110918,
-0.0013180049,
0.4818139374,
0.0209937971,
-0.0586900599,
1.0795754194,
-0.2922102213,
0.1587921381,
-0.1959441155,
0.1835123897,
-0.6076437831,
0.0170587264,
0.367901504,
-0.7177852392,
0.1315092891,
-0.1230919138,
-0.0641013309,
-0.4665592313,
-0.8898256421,
-0.2301258147,
0.3762899041,
-0.6144771576,
0.6698977947,
0.6087042689,
-0.2050671875,
-0.6907228827,
-0.1717702597,
0.0912426114,
-0.3203551471,
-0.1830214709,
-0.4346842468,
-0.0765294209,
-0.6451348662,
0.1882323474,
-0.203979224,
-0.195988223,
0.1710914671,
0.742967546,
0.5997428894,
-0.0530501828,
0.1147509962,
0.149060443,
-0.0890268683,
0.6916341186,
0.0218630042,
0.3395650983,
-0.5440728068,
0.0145876678,
-0.1971205324,
0.4849782586,
0.6041110158,
-0.0622139499,
0.5158963203,
0.6218369603,
-0.4541039169,
-0.3394688368,
-0.4109498262,
-0.269577235,
-0.3822386563,
0.379999727,
0.0247649755,
-0.5142331123,
-0.0395511538,
-0.1929077953,
0.0004568198,
0.4894936681,
0.4495228827,
-0.5948016047,
1.0972969532,
0.6787135601,
-0.5114268064,
0.6667804718,
-0.3657684326,
0.6127823591,
-0.7553063035,
-0.3243195415,
-0.4333534837,
-0.6681070328,
-0.4833158553,
0.2809586823,
0.0153282862,
0.0068227933,
0.2527403533,
-0.3969556689,
-0.6888443828,
0.3842148483,
0.5569534302,
-0.1239595711,
-0.1533967853,
0.0530397408,
0.4293332994,
-0.1324038804,
-0.3608310819,
-0.6977275014,
0.978962481,
0.4149047434,
0.3280571401,
-0.4099455774,
0.8150961995,
0.3804189563,
0.5843270421,
-1.1652355194,
0.7924095988,
-0.2112374306,
-0.5520592928,
-0.2408145219,
-0.209110111,
-0.4302722812,
0.2038440704,
-0.5798818469,
-0.2410912812,
0.101538606,
-0.2596059442,
-0.0290018953,
0.4151791036,
-0.7096751332,
0.5861139894,
-0.1539229304,
-0.3193182945,
-0.2201517373,
-0.5695012212,
0.1462678611,
-0.0090701282,
0.2700588107,
0.160073489,
0.4556368887,
1.3456647396,
-0.2323419899,
0.8863018751,
-0.653193295,
0.1847368181,
0.8122138977,
-0.3126294017,
-0.1575344354,
-0.0642516017,
-0.2365881056,
0.2578507066,
0.036960844,
-0.1234702691,
-0.5497359037,
1.0104191303,
-0.9666976929,
-0.6546180248,
-0.812073946,
-0.2680395842,
-0.2522526085,
-0.103530176,
-0.0057774219,
0.283046335,
0.102957055,
0.1766066551,
0.486798048,
0.1372754127,
0.6074917316,
0.0333254971,
-0.0379689783,
-0.3403933346,
1.2147028446,
0.3689239621,
-0.449642539,
0.106449753,
0.4173118472,
-0.2889973819,
-0.4475898743,
-0.243161723,
0.0646274313,
-0.9058263302,
-0.0495117232,
-0.6146437526,
-0.0418227613,
-0.50432235,
-0.4490015507,
-0.2325363755,
-0.4718354344,
-0.2718038261,
-0.4267653227,
0.2325781882,
0.9441100359,
-0.0018185582,
0.3304400742,
-0.6501336694,
-0.0513639674,
0.263097614,
0.3061704934,
0.1561801583,
0.1264801472,
-0.1975600421,
-0.1352636069,
-0.4416892529,
-0.9353501201,
0.3455279469,
0.1825356781,
0.1552579552,
0.5911400914,
0.0461556725,
0.2414253503,
0.126838401,
0.9633236527,
0.086191617,
-0.8794294596,
0.658436656,
0.1410169005,
-0.2227319181,
0.5545839667,
0.4738796651,
-0.6267365813,
-0.406055361,
-0.688877821,
-1.1643283367,
0.6999348402,
-0.3189295232,
0.0591113754,
0.119040437,
0.4299910963,
0.1571685523,
0.4295636714,
-0.5258295536,
-0.408367306,
-0.5527326465,
-0.6234571338,
0.0670084432,
-0.3881285489,
0.0286527872,
-0.2613129914,
0.6513192058,
0.1849077344,
-0.138549149,
-0.0818526596,
0.0759471506,
-0.0409994796,
0.6574829221,
-0.1330288798,
0.1701407731,
-0.2096148282,
0.0983474478,
0.2085360438,
-0.7847523093,
0.0077283136,
-0.2667531967,
-0.1102534011,
-0.0413098596,
0.2230835706,
0.5239982605,
-0.0681217462,
-0.329660356,
0.6122047305,
-0.0456144139,
-0.0470045097,
-0.5075900555,
0.0117608197,
-0.2107875943,
0.1237792596,
0.1596042812,
0.1803885698,
0.4401809275,
-0.7639481425,
-0.3027837574,
0.3492310643,
-0.7111709714,
-0.5315785408,
0.3348756135,
0.3707187772,
-0.160873577,
0.8361061215,
0.3750979006,
-0.7408297062,
0.5448755622,
0.2293767184,
0.9691268802,
-0.3356915414,
0.4450469017,
0.3070147336,
0.0946322754,
-0.0037270132,
0.4358476102,
-0.0200141426,
-0.5298159122,
-0.0187904239,
-0.7207866907,
-0.8091700077,
-0.2750615776,
-0.8096821308,
0.2382058501,
-0.5512575507,
-0.3014929593,
0.0265550073,
0.3027026653,
-0.4181681275,
0.8134863377,
0.2958572507,
0.3050681949,
-1.0280382633,
0.5457237959,
1.3778856993,
-0.0939238518,
-0.5233282447,
-0.2968719006,
0.196028173,
-0.1655638069,
0.5242182016,
0.2984084189,
-0.2364526838,
-0.1985176504,
-0.5889057517,
-0.036608275,
0.4390245676,
-0.3924393654,
-0.439653337,
0.1670654118,
0.1741202772,
0.9710671306,
-0.4010215402,
0.3813955784,
0.6108696461,
0.4262563288,
-0.2886653543,
0.2525669932,
-0.3844106495,
-0.499861896,
-0.4809103608,
0.2698699534,
-0.3762353063,
0.8267863393,
0.0830249935,
-0.0618753918,
-0.5539927483,
0.5752676725,
-0.1332427263,
0.755456984,
0.5634607673,
0.5095223784,
0.7422676682,
-0.4124667943,
0.9024083614,
-0.4209694862,
0.4484386742,
0.5918340683,
-0.2325491905,
0.8709798455,
0.5309865475,
-0.2548849881,
0.6561192274,
0.7583845258,
-0.1792325079,
0.1968081295,
0.0849307179,
-0.3875646591,
-0.1480748355,
-0.1329618394,
-0.3395364285,
0.4056011736,
0.5755364895,
0.1062145457,
0.2591403723,
0.2991253436,
0.0723194107,
0.1174177751,
-0.674824059,
0.6869690418,
0.1364535093,
-0.2866231501,
-0.2992149591,
-0.0636836812,
0.6175499558,
-0.3456734121,
-0.0417273939,
-0.268035531,
0.1512274742,
-0.7722024918,
-1.0814477205,
0.2082121223,
0.2018086016,
-0.2807686925,
-0.2522210181,
0.9690275788,
-0.1493047476,
-0.3474702537,
0.3200212121,
0.3964862525,
0.0001352685,
-0.0069300835,
-0.5239997506,
-0.0960101336,
-0.0965876356,
-0.6571771502,
0.3610800207,
0.4694220126,
-0.0967321396,
0.4019843936,
0.5498894453,
0.255523622,
0.0736237392,
0.3682588637,
0.6738203168,
-0.8373957276,
-0.325278312,
-0.8385871053,
0.4241076112,
-0.183503449,
-0.2753411233,
0.9936570525,
0.282702297,
0.8298125863,
-0.1112059206,
0.9092466235,
0.0256730169,
0.4025901556,
-0.1551530659,
0.5612973571,
-0.4272646606,
0.1458981037,
-0.4662610888,
-1.1572557688,
-0.415731281,
0.6389003992,
-0.5297745466,
-0.0627551004,
0.6467469335,
0.0809580162,
0.5512967706,
0.7325359583,
-0.0106795412,
0.0349700153,
0.207957238,
0.1446753442,
1.1931385994,
-0.2807407975,
0.1699403822,
-0.6040487885,
-0.3878926933,
-0.3100353777,
-0.3020630479,
-1.0010560751,
-0.3037307858,
-0.5420305133,
-0.2497816533,
-0.1704850644,
0.8215864301,
0.266489923,
-0.8113945723,
-0.3035119176,
0.2267258912,
0.4627020657,
-0.1904863715,
-0.3645655513,
0.3587827682,
-0.4826142192,
-1.0314306021,
0.2868735492,
0.2553652525,
-0.1978984475,
-0.3744793832,
0.2191332132,
-0.0014542902,
0.1249234155,
0.7460813522,
0.2127153575,
-0.3168941736,
-0.3616606593,
0.0673982948,
0.0042613577,
0.1400097162,
0.8170580268,
-0.5694078803,
0.7583674788,
0.4485354125,
0.4469641149,
0.0548750609,
-0.0447152592,
0.0353528112,
-0.5554833412,
-0.2049734592,
0.3426087499,
0.329934448,
0.4982904792,
-0.4031587541,
0.4729597569,
0.1875833273,
-0.6552254558,
-0.6945495605,
-0.1642250866,
-0.9291710258,
-0.2098581046,
0.7313357592,
-0.0936261266,
-0.2814503014,
-0.0108987568,
-0.4357689321,
0.1163321584,
-0.5193966031,
1.0092356205,
0.8809518814,
-0.3073740304,
-0.0428474136,
-0.504011631,
0.3864616156,
0.4158302546,
-0.9086600542,
-0.1961529851,
0.2153867781,
-0.1159412488,
0.2381721288,
0.2658448517,
-0.2520323098,
-0.1460409164,
-0.2133157998,
0.4279737473,
0.1640768349,
-0.4745548368,
-0.6483394504,
0.7739217281,
-0.0619924143,
-0.2376758009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04343v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04343v1 | CRL+: A Novel Semi-Supervised Deep Active Contrastive Representation Learning-Based Text Classification Model for Insurance Data | 2023-02-08T21:23:52 | 2023-02-08T21:23:52 | Amir Namavar Jahromi, Ebrahim Pourjafari, Hadis Karimipour, Amit Satpathy, Lovell Hodge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Financial sector and especially the insurance industry collect vast volumes
of text on a daily basis and through multiple channels (their agents, customer
care centers, emails, social networks, and web in general). The information
collected includes policies, expert and health reports, claims and complaints,
results of surveys, and relevant social media posts. It is difficult to
effectively extract label, classify, and interpret the essential information
from such varied and unstructured material. Therefore, the Insurance Industry
is among the ones that can benefit from applying technologies for the
intelligent analysis of free text through Natural Language Processing (NLP).
In this paper, CRL+, a novel text classification model combining Contrastive
Representation Learning (CRL) and Active Learning is proposed to handle the
challenge of using semi-supervised learning for text classification. In this
method, supervised (CRL) is used to train a RoBERTa transformer model to encode
the textual data into a contrastive representation space and then classify
using a classification layer. This (CRL)-based transformer model is used as the
base model in the proposed Active Learning mechanism to classify all the data
in an iterative manner. The proposed model is evaluated using unstructured
obituary data with objective to determine the cause of the death from the data.
This model is compared with the CRL model and an Active Learning model with the
RoBERTa base model. The experiment shows that the proposed method can
outperform both methods for this specific task. | [
0.3107215762,
-0.8248132467,
0.0711260512,
0.1963409781,
-0.2861390114,
0.3357574046,
-0.0995083004,
-0.9645257592,
-0.1991002709,
0.5502057076,
-0.256768316,
-0.6177262068,
-0.451779604,
-0.2120412737,
-0.2869778275,
1.1984211206,
-0.0371288434,
0.2509307265,
0.0369374417,
-0.1368025839,
-0.1074774563,
-0.5407682657,
-0.9762544632,
-0.361562252,
0.2694316506,
-0.0928934366,
0.6834237576,
0.3281293511,
0.4870591164,
0.309563458,
-0.2749444246,
0.0826978534,
0.0026932165,
-0.0353511237,
0.2386067063,
-0.5593924522,
-0.2784727514,
0.0499299578,
0.4573285282,
0.5889285207,
-0.3388993144,
-0.1769793928,
0.1106042415,
0.4241390526,
-0.5358014107,
0.1850305945,
-0.5088682771,
0.3416717947,
0.0089925397,
-0.3320592344,
-0.7205227613,
-0.3701914251,
0.3831309378,
-0.3304796219,
0.385730952,
-0.0895583332,
1.0142806768,
0.1863488704,
-0.860781312,
-0.598508656,
-0.7994683385,
0.9346727729,
-0.4829490483,
0.3741067052,
0.0026206463,
0.5071612597,
0.395488739,
-0.7082314491,
-0.4539264441,
-0.1455431581,
-0.2503014803,
0.4616795778,
-0.1897769272,
0.0913658589,
-0.2774771154,
0.6345677972,
-0.2640999854,
0.3492772579,
-0.3342151344,
-0.4486422539,
0.7429230213,
0.1504982114,
0.2814707458,
0.0399545431,
-0.7453098297,
-0.114745535,
-0.4009283185,
0.2489000559,
0.1953991205,
0.2879396081,
-0.3706586957,
0.3425544202,
0.0308006611,
0.5968331099,
-0.2156567723,
-0.1103993207,
0.6368228197,
-0.1478070766,
-0.3221365809,
0.4308529496,
0.7320469618,
0.2188245654,
0.0556062087,
-0.0453057438,
-0.2588569522,
0.3454224765,
0.2878524661,
-0.488668263,
-0.173222959,
0.1703080088,
-0.5406005979,
-0.6766145229,
0.0530020855,
-0.7486595511,
-0.4411917627,
-0.1623742282,
0.109098874,
-0.2425287217,
-0.0420359783,
0.4934768975,
0.0343087874,
0.2418189198,
0.4444021285,
-0.200688228,
0.0822931752,
0.1955442578,
0.5422478914,
-0.2608932555,
0.3331542015,
-0.3431379795,
0.2738017142,
0.1454330832,
0.9814227223,
-0.5600987077,
-0.0057965661,
0.5439807773,
-0.0266778767,
-0.0247675125,
-0.2775943279,
1.026976347,
-0.8600433469,
0.4427374005,
0.7657421231,
-0.4152249396,
-0.4474934638,
0.5393606424,
-0.9097297788,
0.6871875525,
0.1533806622,
-0.8658619523,
0.4122413397,
-0.3811198175,
-0.4550819993,
0.2282107323,
-0.2189957649,
-1.3175938129,
-0.2083072513,
0.014897638,
0.6305934191,
-0.2743465602,
0.1983814538,
-0.4293276966,
-0.054049693,
0.4817353785,
-0.6943470836,
0.8247460723,
0.0462782271,
-0.1821425408,
0.2242155224,
-1.0165228844,
-0.0726733878,
0.156809479,
-0.5011011958,
-0.5702547431,
-0.1419788599,
0.438324362,
0.1973024756,
0.3303428292,
-0.6486950517,
0.0193323474,
-0.4744167924,
0.1717769951,
0.4419386685,
0.2802462578,
0.6504501104,
-0.4166941047,
0.267209053,
0.3070762753,
0.1616942585,
0.0380462445,
-0.2368779182,
-0.6455224752,
-0.2363331914,
0.4520780146,
0.793586731,
-0.5021581054,
0.3945638537,
0.1417107731,
-0.4929773211,
-0.6428389549,
-0.044376336,
0.3126824498,
0.5720034242,
0.5700529218,
0.1376978457,
-0.5768917203,
-0.9923789501,
-0.0858546421,
0.2057448179,
-0.0070622079,
0.1075524092,
-0.0132516483,
-0.5016034842,
0.556297183,
-0.7167031765,
-0.8778685331,
-0.7044931054,
0.3509028554,
0.1005188897,
0.3278472722,
0.3853038847,
-1.4285029173,
-0.5063691735,
0.1680202186,
-0.8241072893,
0.1613116562,
-0.397038877,
0.1868955344,
0.211990431,
0.137627095,
-0.3867447674,
0.6809430122,
0.377576977,
-0.3814460039,
0.3333460689,
-0.3891041577,
-0.164475739,
-0.9823277593,
-0.1812339425,
0.5045918822,
-0.2852486074,
-0.6234635711,
-0.115494214,
0.267591387,
-0.2873540521,
-0.245544225,
0.5026073456,
-0.6614266038,
0.3511446714,
-0.227156058,
-0.1679232866,
0.0735802278,
0.5168953538,
0.3869850039,
0.5032664537,
0.6576737761,
-0.6520261168,
0.2676489949,
0.4067813456,
-0.1934021562,
0.074838981,
-0.4381022155,
-0.3660693169,
-0.1591818333,
0.3328751624,
-0.7019031048,
0.1856261045,
0.1412755251,
-0.2796418071,
0.3337344825,
0.136416465,
-0.169279471,
-0.1494278908,
-0.2199982256,
0.2568166256,
0.4675216079,
-0.2281479985,
1.0290558338,
0.5259006023,
-0.0963599905,
-0.4590086341,
-0.976999402,
-0.0016258652,
-0.182138741,
-0.5567319989,
0.675211966,
0.2526914477,
-0.2393193245,
0.3129632771,
-0.0598514266,
-0.3825724721,
-0.0145290997,
0.0326337069,
0.5223948956,
-0.1054529399,
0.2344639897,
-0.0316778868,
-0.605866313,
-0.1362036616,
0.1979170591,
0.3330975175,
0.1183297411,
-0.143820107,
-0.7654670477,
0.3362686634,
0.2971217334,
-0.4764769673,
0.8389230371,
0.3157235384,
-0.3025314808,
-0.5503730178,
-0.490096271,
0.1164376661,
-0.4359591007,
0.2079244703,
0.1397861987,
-0.7571956515,
0.6919754744,
-0.2329917848,
0.145282492,
0.7791599035,
0.6302569509,
-0.0715921298,
0.9206233025,
0.9211425781,
-0.0962277502,
0.6560801864,
-0.4411866069,
0.0730954409,
-0.279237777,
-0.6131597757,
-0.5348235369,
-0.1605604589,
-0.2867048681,
-0.3470289409,
0.3559268117,
-0.1407367736,
0.112384595,
0.2660084963,
-0.7329828739,
-0.0178618208,
0.0638322458,
0.4497773945,
0.5836662054,
0.051971186,
0.0536797568,
0.1661165804,
-0.2899996936,
-0.4697635472,
0.7902097702,
0.4455543458,
0.8693761826,
0.021148039,
0.3958508968,
0.8278520703,
0.5323421955,
-0.5291541815,
0.2332388163,
-0.419275254,
-0.4171298146,
-0.125558123,
-0.6655105352,
-0.9747322202,
-0.0761658251,
-0.3945575655,
-0.2025491297,
0.4191343486,
0.0194368921,
-0.4579839408,
0.2371122986,
-0.4747723937,
0.7132503986,
-0.4189590812,
-0.1390175372,
-0.2413462996,
-0.5044283271,
0.2317606062,
-0.0848560184,
0.2363230139,
0.1653896868,
-0.1591106057,
0.6370171309,
-0.1616477072,
0.9875755906,
-0.1644750834,
-0.0757287219,
0.5087155104,
-0.2370416969,
0.7362655401,
0.2326054573,
-0.3149318397,
0.0240713973,
-0.3645034432,
-0.3966818154,
-0.5643680096,
0.3633976877,
-0.716409862,
0.2201807201,
-0.5811988711,
-0.2574512064,
-0.2769809961,
0.1134209707,
0.054458186,
0.5823766589,
0.0258118976,
0.2996096313,
0.7384366393,
-0.340308696,
0.4020625353,
0.9032176733,
0.2602444887,
-0.4383589923,
0.7219536304,
0.0873042345,
-0.0873443335,
0.6749272943,
0.0461750776,
-0.3496010602,
-0.7681893706,
-0.3047932982,
0.0664676353,
-0.6337715387,
-0.4898155332,
-0.9346068501,
-0.6430726647,
0.0497995913,
-0.284267664,
-0.1541971713,
-0.1081408411,
-0.4683443308,
-0.2596476078,
0.1559978575,
0.4845813513,
0.4874102175,
0.282397151,
-0.867223084,
0.3165155947,
0.0451955833,
0.3476005793,
0.0253050327,
-0.2605211139,
-0.1899323314,
-0.187121585,
-0.3345832229,
-0.9553155899,
0.3977741003,
0.1069141701,
0.7366208434,
0.4551659822,
0.5159574151,
0.4166957736,
-0.182945326,
0.293710649,
0.3091293275,
-0.4425893128,
0.2667396069,
-0.1017505527,
-0.0688040704,
0.7575399876,
0.4492903948,
-0.3883315325,
-0.4331178963,
-0.7740428448,
-0.9090955853,
0.3624735177,
0.202384308,
0.2019133568,
0.0540852137,
0.2394158095,
0.0256794654,
0.0960932374,
-1.1263195276,
-0.1814174503,
0.0650595427,
-0.5388825536,
0.2444138229,
-0.4424876273,
0.1728794575,
0.1184176058,
0.7709548473,
0.0464852974,
0.4579332769,
0.2773070931,
-0.1007592827,
-0.0874571279,
0.3773858845,
0.4203552306,
0.1973802447,
-0.1820482612,
0.1456804425,
0.1448838711,
-0.1537603438,
-0.0086055612,
0.4799118638,
-0.2049382627,
0.1299495101,
0.6991537809,
0.5788018107,
0.3431909382,
-0.7919868231,
0.859267652,
-0.1520495266,
-0.1700359136,
-0.8652429581,
0.0431344137,
-0.2581894398,
0.1653697342,
0.7866561413,
0.3667546213,
0.3842187524,
-0.5872876644,
0.5802834034,
0.3493598998,
-0.9925161004,
-0.0962738693,
0.4780237675,
0.3271932006,
-0.226904884,
0.5309316516,
-0.0299920533,
-0.7013449073,
0.6124585867,
0.4589768052,
0.7546691298,
-0.1651286185,
0.2516155243,
0.1144970059,
-0.0457420275,
-0.0421785861,
0.1849958152,
0.111656487,
-0.8540660739,
-0.488766551,
-0.7710978985,
-0.3198794127,
0.1876047701,
-0.6388463378,
0.3247459531,
-0.3552625477,
0.1998240501,
0.1159463599,
0.1087891832,
-0.5790433884,
0.4684543014,
-0.0109570306,
1.0112882853,
-0.9563384056,
0.7130123377,
0.7084792852,
-0.5889903307,
-0.6862775087,
0.0599217378,
-0.2418659478,
-0.7478689551,
0.514143765,
0.3564321995,
0.1209517717,
-0.1093628258,
-0.1996681243,
-0.2364037037,
0.7893657684,
-0.0660969839,
-0.6130275726,
-0.1881857663,
-0.0492227897,
0.823821187,
-0.306731075,
0.1202431545,
-0.142118305,
0.368052423,
0.1386688203,
-0.4556319714,
-0.0912647843,
-0.4901878834,
-0.4552703798,
0.4482739866,
-0.6613587141,
0.5866318345,
0.1179242283,
-0.3067448735,
-0.1359421313,
0.8034169674,
0.0208342988,
0.6743491292,
0.5810497403,
0.4844047129,
0.5631252527,
0.0209095087,
1.2702242136,
-0.1806556731,
0.6624669433,
0.7146407962,
-0.3663317859,
0.6437093019,
-0.0572458468,
-0.1104508266,
0.7287124991,
0.4969732463,
-0.2962651849,
0.6051228046,
-0.0473856628,
-0.6223136783,
-0.5660647154,
-0.0666242465,
-0.1065222993,
0.3882022798,
0.2384511083,
-0.6106038094,
-0.5684203506,
0.4056534171,
-0.3932151496,
0.3329854608,
-0.2267524004,
0.9568197131,
0.0833967105,
-0.1618330628,
0.0277319159,
0.2649809718,
0.7153123617,
-0.8507944942,
-0.2298109978,
0.106923677,
0.528046906,
-0.2464777827,
-0.7889010906,
0.5908855796,
-0.2091097236,
-0.4088769853,
-0.3871872425,
1.0665346384,
-0.5600726604,
-0.784501493,
0.4608040452,
0.0815389007,
-0.1595117152,
0.0284117665,
-1.0043362379,
-0.2016032338,
0.1465077847,
-0.4480904639,
0.3322423398,
0.5785347819,
-0.3729024231,
0.9283150434,
0.7646228671,
0.1515228301,
-0.3036957085,
-0.0071807392,
0.9381170273,
-0.7045220733,
-0.8505373597,
-0.7121636271,
0.8004211783,
-0.4022251368,
-0.3000212312,
0.5230508447,
0.7883276343,
0.4545318782,
0.0863324553,
0.7283272743,
0.1126613319,
0.8266977668,
-0.6003969312,
0.637853086,
-0.7015064359,
0.3536980152,
0.0636961982,
-0.5915041566,
-0.8029528856,
0.56603688,
-0.3816978335,
-0.0353040099,
0.5406657457,
0.3191268444,
-0.1249368638,
0.0827987418,
0.164752543,
0.1686324477,
0.1237403601,
0.2671616375,
0.4186944664,
-0.4126879573,
0.9768818617,
-0.1877586544,
-0.2771496773,
-0.3696732521,
-0.6966785789,
-0.8908976316,
-0.3903390169,
-0.4977702498,
-0.3278740346,
-0.1123699099,
0.5586331487,
0.367659241,
-0.845208168,
0.2481784225,
-0.0870471075,
-0.0006483655,
-0.291564703,
-0.2794086039,
0.6995242834,
-0.2485125363,
-0.3571534157,
0.2919782698,
0.354903996,
0.2240059078,
-0.1289263368,
0.0988235027,
-0.08237461,
-0.1726338714,
0.3204536438,
0.0671012178,
-0.3427138329,
0.0746477321,
-0.4611658156,
-0.4902710021,
0.0964888483,
0.8408080935,
-0.7702599168,
0.1685572863,
0.3528552949,
0.9515770078,
0.4637075067,
0.1908564121,
0.4163399339,
-0.4888827503,
0.2898038328,
0.6171053648,
0.3819959164,
0.1581583917,
-0.834036231,
0.364190042,
0.1054574251,
-0.3841013312,
-0.7431815267,
0.286013484,
-1.393574357,
-0.5606199503,
0.8720733523,
0.0565154329,
-0.2702178359,
-0.5398643017,
-0.2980507314,
0.4833755791,
-0.5175721049,
0.8400887251,
0.0009379716,
-0.073009409,
-0.6603896022,
-0.5303827524,
0.4153223336,
0.1360024661,
-0.7401741743,
0.0490366891,
0.1618874222,
0.1552381665,
0.2928463221,
0.3988216817,
-0.2605784833,
0.2025600374,
-0.2623734176,
0.3541444242,
-0.4081357419,
-0.2111279219,
-0.284637928,
0.7218176126,
-0.3437148333,
0.0377805568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04269v1 | Diagnosing and Rectifying Vision Models using Language | 2023-02-08T18:59:42 | 2023-02-08T18:59:42 | Yuhui Zhang, Jeff Z. HaoChen, Shih-Cheng Huang, Kuan-Chieh Wang, James Zou, Serena Yeung | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Recent multi-modal contrastive learning models have demonstrated the ability
to learn an embedding space suitable for building strong vision classifiers, by
leveraging the rich information in large-scale image-caption datasets. Our work
highlights a distinct advantage of this multi-modal embedding space: the
ability to diagnose vision classifiers through natural language. The
traditional process of diagnosing model behaviors in deployment settings
involves labor-intensive data acquisition and annotation. Our proposed method
can discover high-error data slices, identify influential attributes and
further rectify undesirable model behaviors, without requiring any visual data.
Through a combination of theoretical explanation and empirical verification, we
present conditions under which classifiers trained on embeddings from one
modality can be equivalently applied to embeddings from another modality. On a
range of image datasets with known error slices, we demonstrate that our method
can effectively identify the error slices and influential attributes, and can
further use language to rectify failure modes of the classifier. | [
-0.3002904952,
-0.6284836531,
0.4536171556,
0.0117879706,
-0.2354440242,
0.0528256185,
-0.2260028571,
-0.4319362044,
-0.0509050526,
0.4354213178,
-0.1395391971,
-0.2175396383,
-0.6412502527,
-0.0779909045,
-0.3010100126,
0.8937895894,
-0.1605029106,
0.4034259915,
-0.4837189913,
-0.276761055,
-0.6273024082,
-0.2548305988,
-0.6624388099,
-0.0491669625,
0.3924458325,
0.1094496623,
0.8696082234,
0.5085443258,
0.6332569122,
0.3156848848,
0.2772074342,
0.5224176645,
-0.1746276915,
-0.2124495506,
0.0833663866,
-0.4256018102,
-0.0972837433,
-0.095585674,
0.6424667835,
0.9304468632,
-0.1984413862,
-0.2448908091,
0.1925780326,
0.5914781094,
-0.6837005019,
0.5639017224,
-0.4247888923,
0.2216629237,
0.0474590398,
-0.2682873309,
-0.5634552836,
-0.1536231488,
0.2080676109,
-0.7074138522,
0.4194730818,
0.2529502809,
0.9167225361,
0.4752376378,
-0.4621650577,
-0.0495201498,
-0.7444043159,
1.0098831654,
-0.37765944,
0.5814809203,
0.4011489749,
0.5723509192,
0.1715419888,
-0.3897779286,
-0.415637821,
-0.2189140171,
-0.4284332693,
-0.0369170122,
-0.1626058519,
0.0997162834,
0.1399172246,
0.4141435623,
-0.2542698383,
-0.013265783,
-0.4365566075,
-0.4675655067,
0.404456079,
0.1857558191,
0.3666214645,
0.053051468,
-0.4293512404,
-0.2284823656,
-0.4013241529,
-0.0942788348,
0.0131681142,
0.2268085927,
-0.4112144411,
0.2786012292,
0.0367506668,
0.8984918594,
-0.0146670463,
-0.1946762055,
0.4717493951,
-0.2962318659,
-0.3813463449,
-0.303196162,
0.4297080934,
0.5705810189,
0.1266509742,
-0.1810829788,
-0.4986154437,
0.07746429,
0.4673971534,
-0.4600926638,
-0.4157364368,
-0.0640098974,
-0.5269264579,
-0.471603781,
0.037210159,
-0.918651402,
-0.7929269075,
-0.2363762408,
0.6561194062,
-0.3776592612,
-0.2329040319,
0.1323091984,
-0.2765860856,
0.2561570108,
0.4625375271,
-0.7245460749,
-0.0444805771,
0.2284260392,
0.7719886303,
0.1835774183,
-0.2808446884,
-0.4614636302,
0.0478802435,
-0.5405111313,
0.7249096632,
-0.4946591854,
-0.0635419041,
0.1684810817,
0.1531324983,
-0.4685315788,
-0.8311880827,
0.2801979482,
-0.421464026,
0.1895743608,
-0.2094822824,
-0.4816858768,
-0.481957376,
0.5879105926,
-0.8467892408,
0.6581562161,
0.3044155836,
-0.7100971937,
0.4902501702,
-0.806219399,
-0.4070885777,
0.0598881394,
-0.1321116984,
-0.5842989087,
0.1983412653,
0.1884417534,
0.8439366221,
-0.1022242904,
0.2926065922,
-0.2046155035,
0.1289693713,
0.2224263549,
-0.4266071022,
0.4176945388,
0.0081075095,
-0.1550981253,
-0.0289541744,
-0.7986166477,
-0.2410408109,
0.2943773568,
-0.4788931906,
-0.4847341478,
0.3572995365,
0.0362382606,
-0.1089457348,
0.0400054753,
-0.6249806881,
-0.0933019742,
-0.1907845438,
0.3490049243,
0.4967646003,
-0.0330845565,
0.2724003196,
-0.3726014495,
0.4492845833,
0.4970068932,
0.2683335543,
-0.5552788377,
-0.4083216786,
-1.019506216,
-0.4724927545,
-0.1187935099,
0.415748626,
-1.0643724203,
0.0786945969,
-0.0540756248,
-0.1275598258,
-0.4468635619,
0.252604723,
0.6066128016,
0.7714042664,
0.3971558809,
-0.3414762318,
-0.5813261867,
-1.0948905945,
0.1699806154,
-0.0678489655,
0.2402123213,
0.6283888221,
0.4122235477,
-0.3842737377,
0.5193586946,
-0.4761410654,
-0.2661367953,
-0.1563513577,
0.1156208068,
-0.1742952168,
0.4287697673,
0.6480810046,
-0.9282869101,
-0.0983640701,
0.1527549028,
-0.939640224,
0.1499520838,
-0.3065024912,
0.1050081179,
0.2750150263,
0.5032433867,
-0.0110046351,
0.3258273005,
0.673030138,
-0.4253362119,
0.5045316815,
-0.2326222062,
0.2192300558,
-0.8061391711,
-0.1210960895,
0.2701016068,
-0.1938489825,
-0.6334623098,
0.1072281003,
0.1381899118,
-0.0122571327,
-0.256066978,
0.1971776038,
-0.2773467004,
0.1210302189,
0.0335587636,
-0.0784904063,
0.149941951,
0.2326883078,
0.101284638,
0.4496777058,
0.7614996433,
-0.6647080779,
0.5182953477,
0.142898798,
-0.2927188873,
0.799207747,
-0.5802749395,
-0.4274076819,
-0.3703475296,
-0.0750626624,
-1.3912388086,
-0.5467586517,
0.2755706608,
-0.1466398239,
0.3770754039,
-0.4219106138,
-0.376388669,
-0.1772697419,
-0.0555017255,
0.5876372457,
0.1707187742,
-0.8615460396,
0.6394321322,
0.2811722755,
0.1950320005,
-0.3662064672,
-0.6526730061,
-0.075068064,
-0.2670978308,
-0.6668512821,
0.0703516752,
0.1506373435,
-0.1983433664,
-0.111385271,
0.3407737017,
-0.5019609332,
0.3998361826,
0.3466295004,
0.5035924315,
-0.2500661314,
0.5745622516,
-0.3908705115,
-0.1875337958,
0.0670230091,
0.2928982675,
0.3411718607,
-0.4086543024,
-0.4256976843,
-0.166351378,
0.1762349606,
0.7464588881,
-0.3882598281,
0.5918130279,
0.5618152618,
-0.340985328,
-0.1882434785,
-0.52080369,
-0.1181267649,
-0.4216034412,
0.5036136508,
-0.0290717203,
-0.4955651462,
0.3895141482,
-0.1382169724,
-0.0338683277,
0.3279039264,
0.1463479102,
-0.2295733839,
1.0519793034,
1.0130198002,
0.0978221297,
0.4584538341,
-0.3696726263,
0.3005105555,
-0.7776165009,
-0.6471133828,
-0.2141815871,
-0.2487136126,
-0.2603254318,
-0.4544924796,
0.5705335736,
-0.0820098221,
-0.1246382669,
-0.0039559421,
-0.4197075069,
0.4224498272,
0.2475642413,
0.357419312,
0.1589148194,
0.1601808965,
-0.1291500181,
-0.2131017447,
-0.6226093769,
-0.443951875,
0.828720808,
0.51523453,
0.8769082427,
-0.0052445633,
0.4076419473,
0.1038265005,
0.3301176429,
-1.193508625,
0.181547001,
-0.3087825179,
-0.4885731339,
-0.00860136,
-0.3505250216,
-0.7813396454,
0.241072461,
-0.3086893559,
-0.2926210761,
0.3590869009,
0.532110393,
-0.3469749689,
0.4951756299,
-0.9347010255,
1.1379767656,
-0.3351546228,
-0.1190060526,
-0.2809171081,
-0.4755189419,
0.4540093839,
0.0711218119,
0.4137596786,
0.0925923511,
-0.0183820147,
0.6735680103,
-0.0756797642,
1.2975767851,
-0.4566675723,
-0.0324682295,
-0.1880531013,
0.2269159555,
-0.0097718509,
-0.3475226462,
0.3490654528,
0.0267472267,
0.0554879606,
-0.1930081546,
-0.7002475262,
0.2869173288,
-0.6384190917,
-0.0780467018,
-0.199665159,
-0.3850524724,
-0.4942814112,
-0.081860587,
0.0470658429,
0.7118570209,
-0.108116582,
0.2745222151,
0.6936793327,
-0.4263883233,
0.5596745014,
0.5801728368,
-0.2041152716,
-0.2524282336,
1.092779994,
-0.0271267518,
0.2564471364,
0.2124210298,
0.2153235674,
0.1273998767,
-0.3854321539,
-0.5166957378,
0.1226257756,
-0.7691816688,
-0.334269315,
-0.2874219418,
-0.1240995899,
0.1860001385,
-0.3800930977,
-0.6856818795,
-0.1692543924,
-0.1539485008,
-0.1134417728,
0.168051973,
0.799815774,
-0.0481436104,
0.2564770877,
-0.7440173626,
0.2522798181,
0.3464338183,
0.6083626151,
0.1726677269,
-0.4244740307,
-0.434111923,
0.0939265639,
-0.3334893286,
-0.7938593626,
0.4801169336,
0.5470249057,
0.7821410894,
0.6998873353,
-0.2592006922,
0.5762070417,
-0.2216620445,
0.7558577061,
0.3724682629,
-0.7840707302,
0.7632807493,
-0.0416901559,
-0.1692580879,
0.2275931984,
0.513857305,
-0.4475435913,
-0.2406154722,
-0.4178853929,
-0.7129272223,
0.405382961,
-0.4021806419,
0.2100555599,
-0.1401207298,
0.2072719783,
0.1288846135,
0.1031639725,
-0.6640423536,
-0.206147179,
-0.5228523612,
-0.2183535844,
-0.1833011359,
-0.2430989295,
-0.4747666419,
-0.3931587636,
0.4470505714,
-0.4196155071,
0.2869921327,
0.1200275198,
-0.415482372,
0.0387194343,
0.1444863081,
0.5060310364,
0.6955199242,
0.0742031261,
0.46096614,
-0.0087517444,
-0.200643748,
-0.0905439183,
-0.0241279602,
-0.0893324465,
-0.0560183674,
0.5937714577,
0.8277081251,
0.5766534805,
-0.7483050227,
0.8966189027,
0.1275263578,
-0.0702028498,
-0.2140739262,
-0.1685528755,
-0.2672049701,
0.2916409671,
0.239263311,
0.3714163303,
0.2162982374,
-0.5997179747,
0.2322769165,
0.6320919991,
-0.6348192096,
-0.3884299397,
0.3534720242,
0.438038528,
0.1623211056,
0.7141672373,
-0.0872393399,
-0.6314192414,
0.6661966443,
0.4541563094,
0.7099739313,
0.0224092677,
0.6379910111,
0.3675067127,
0.3281722069,
-0.1458521336,
0.2095777094,
0.1029007435,
-1.2886594534,
-0.3020010293,
-0.5525183082,
-0.225779742,
-0.055176653,
-0.8060156703,
-0.1162292361,
-0.7459509969,
0.0318865031,
0.2187948823,
-0.4670200348,
-0.8081054091,
0.3363500237,
0.2714268267,
0.4981183708,
-1.394318819,
0.4487802386,
0.9476617575,
-0.7169519663,
-0.6574870944,
-0.3066688478,
-0.0067164851,
-1.1477458477,
0.7615118027,
0.2754487693,
-0.0637595057,
-0.2810377777,
-0.770273149,
-0.393733561,
0.9367331862,
0.4025421739,
-0.3943236768,
0.3113953769,
-0.2510853708,
0.5558854938,
-0.5771551132,
0.0408329852,
0.3786374927,
0.5065769553,
-0.027055975,
-1.0534704924,
0.1080588773,
-0.0954720825,
-0.1063646376,
0.1701151729,
-0.4508579075,
0.6644166708,
-0.6063361764,
-0.2956856787,
-0.1745094955,
0.1122381389,
-0.3207923174,
0.3873286247,
0.7042598724,
0.6873278022,
0.7571892142,
-0.2965285182,
1.2075836658,
-0.1954076141,
0.2794109285,
0.7896119356,
0.1131820455,
0.983396709,
0.6658667922,
-0.0726000369,
0.68976897,
0.2578805387,
-0.3536277115,
0.6114006639,
-0.0913118348,
-0.2471911162,
-0.7334389091,
-0.2492349595,
-0.1417411566,
0.7357626557,
0.3553498983,
-0.7374138236,
-0.3809375465,
0.4270156026,
-0.2413224429,
0.0590122826,
-0.232880801,
0.7997148037,
-0.2726952434,
-0.2529743612,
0.5477198958,
-0.1523115933,
0.6641231179,
-0.3110384941,
-0.3379583359,
-0.1558827013,
0.2788349688,
-0.4630647898,
-0.7678786516,
0.5330890417,
-0.3656541705,
-0.4223127663,
-0.1095869988,
0.348031044,
-0.3752770424,
-0.5790308118,
0.210163027,
0.5053520799,
0.094336167,
0.0045162099,
-0.3894716501,
0.12464948,
-0.055838313,
0.1740233749,
0.1407033205,
0.1192730218,
0.0219617542,
0.9291558266,
0.3083617985,
-0.0385359451,
0.0659229532,
0.0972732678,
0.8528485894,
-0.5213751197,
-0.0823318735,
-0.7693621516,
0.8500607014,
-0.0051336922,
-0.1983677447,
0.4707861841,
0.4885264635,
0.7893524766,
-0.2431944162,
0.7904517651,
-0.0716830567,
0.3758235276,
-0.5151390433,
0.4570277929,
-0.6639527678,
0.4024407566,
0.0816634968,
-0.4296393991,
-0.6582223773,
1.0136315823,
-0.1577638388,
-0.0491152033,
0.62288028,
1.0071233511,
-0.2707583606,
-0.1865611523,
0.4827040434,
0.2991034389,
0.2098627687,
0.4715695083,
0.9863851666,
-0.3249511123,
0.5315358043,
-0.3862503171,
-0.4697078466,
-0.2803481519,
-0.8641260862,
-0.7976663113,
-0.6940989494,
-0.622640729,
-0.1992233545,
-0.0990614891,
0.6085672379,
0.8571276069,
-0.7571672201,
0.195718646,
0.1922604442,
0.235919401,
-0.2334603071,
-0.2832641006,
0.153174594,
-0.5726234913,
-0.4302294552,
0.4080578387,
0.2854681909,
0.1548111439,
-0.5547010303,
-0.0845603123,
0.3128176332,
-0.1837276518,
0.7924154401,
0.2829052806,
-0.7804972529,
-0.5292169452,
-0.2952251732,
0.0255045611,
0.0631760359,
0.7046563625,
-0.6980295181,
0.9432505369,
0.2541896105,
0.6968792081,
-0.0386083759,
-0.3626683652,
0.6547034383,
-0.7991107702,
-0.0576887503,
0.100517638,
0.732144177,
0.7025607824,
-0.1739859283,
0.4969757497,
0.4389905632,
-0.2467098087,
-0.6716470718,
0.2878958285,
-0.9623475075,
-0.102783069,
1.001793623,
-0.3889900446,
-0.0604598187,
-0.2533535659,
-0.373449862,
-0.1214032546,
-0.0209300704,
0.9790050983,
0.4897372425,
-0.0596266985,
-0.3559208512,
-0.4837413132,
0.3531170189,
0.1766719073,
-0.6703122854,
0.0336334184,
0.8729526997,
0.5293783545,
0.4094728827,
0.0873207673,
-0.2793595195,
0.3496897221,
0.1879548877,
0.0278070532,
-0.3806737363,
-0.3667943776,
-0.4836359918,
0.2646318674,
0.1394211203,
-0.532196939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04197v1 | Hierarchical Event Grounding | 2023-02-08T17:09:41 | 2023-02-08T17:09:41 | Jiefu Ou, Adithya Pratapa, Rishubh Gupta, Teruko Mitamura | cs.CL | cs.CL | Event grounding aims at linking mention references in text corpora to events
from a knowledge base (KB). Previous work on this task focused primarily on
linking to a single KB event, thereby overlooking the hierarchical aspects of
events. Events in documents are typically described at various levels of
spatio-temporal granularity (Glavas et al. 2014). These hierarchical relations
are utilized in downstream tasks of narrative understanding and schema
construction. In this work, we present an extension to the event grounding task
that requires tackling hierarchical event structures from the KB. Our proposed
task involves linking a mention reference to a set of event labels from a
subevent hierarchy in the KB. We propose a retrieval methodology that leverages
event hierarchy through an auxiliary hierarchical loss (Murty et al. 2018). On
an automatically created multilingual dataset from Wikipedia and Wikidata, our
experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the hierarchical loss against
retrieve and re-rank baselines (Wu et al. 2020; Pratapa, Gupta, and Mitamura
2022). Furthermore, we demonstrate the systems' ability to aid hierarchical
discovery among unseen events. | [
-0.2198054045,
-0.583802402,
0.6404432654,
-0.0866158009,
-0.1478748918,
-0.0345395096,
0.0289720539,
-0.4719091058,
0.3986820579,
0.0001108324,
-0.7227185369,
-0.7685261965,
-0.3671802282,
-0.3127017319,
-0.4106778502,
1.2759147882,
-0.0610911101,
-0.4848563373,
-0.4121350646,
-0.2123529464,
-0.2141139358,
-0.9613109827,
-0.5740384459,
-0.717615366,
0.6641204953,
0.5285719633,
0.8186325431,
0.7896549702,
0.4991545975,
0.0898241997,
-0.3418207765,
0.1801936775,
-0.6424784064,
0.0521676764,
-0.3685488999,
-0.2997716963,
-0.3720673323,
0.029785974,
0.7299205661,
1.0775380135,
0.1244633123,
0.0583892018,
-0.0711281449,
0.4373245239,
-0.8073852062,
0.3692008555,
-0.7998539805,
0.3986852765,
-0.4374573529,
-0.782253623,
-0.429320842,
0.0983893052,
-0.1035149246,
-0.8299614191,
0.4578292072,
0.1986427903,
1.1788388491,
-0.019230403,
-0.3007436097,
-0.2615211606,
-0.511352241,
0.4268746078,
-0.1218814179,
0.4983526468,
0.6048368812,
-0.0657832995,
-0.2140279859,
-0.6656123996,
-0.3513661921,
-0.4168470502,
-0.3064832091,
0.2258697152,
-0.2535287142,
0.0346802138,
0.199314326,
0.3007367551,
-0.2248816937,
-0.1103121415,
-0.1130177453,
-0.0818880945,
-0.0136794252,
0.2294220775,
0.3576124012,
-0.6355064511,
-0.0271223448,
0.2085980773,
-0.8360353112,
-0.1798864901,
0.2255280167,
0.365431726,
-0.0751286745,
0.6384065747,
-0.3913937211,
0.1749453396,
0.601903975,
-0.4342139363,
0.1139999405,
-0.6531665325,
0.0159848053,
0.1942712814,
0.3141827583,
0.5857477188,
0.1202665716,
-0.6933353543,
0.3294773698,
-0.0523752905,
0.0074009923,
-0.4484201372,
-0.5214139819,
-0.0640653446,
-0.5850621462,
-0.3712730408,
-0.0870617107,
-0.3427862227,
-0.6454865932,
-0.2856085002,
0.3829137683,
-0.5288102031,
-0.0814262554,
-0.5726701021,
-0.5553961396,
0.0997583196,
0.36776039,
-0.8739469051,
0.1610465646,
0.637175262,
0.6515097022,
-0.130223617,
-0.463904202,
-0.53183496,
0.8275933862,
-0.5219356418,
0.712092936,
-0.4696163237,
-0.3171702027,
-0.0450693592,
-0.0982827991,
0.1038753316,
-0.5668856502,
0.6478053331,
-0.7489387393,
-0.1064933538,
-0.3402550817,
-0.4003619552,
0.2003673166,
0.4329500794,
-0.3126105666,
1.2697982788,
-0.1828085631,
-1.1862720251,
0.621132493,
0.0888435021,
-0.6240653992,
0.0626842007,
-0.6497480869,
-0.0518929623,
0.0489706807,
0.2062021643,
0.2859692872,
-0.0335880741,
0.431584239,
-0.090247564,
-0.192614004,
-0.6501102448,
0.2472966313,
0.3759591877,
-0.4007460773,
-0.4377526343,
0.0248982403,
-1.0552020073,
-0.385186106,
-0.1269643307,
-0.5075086355,
-0.8737353086,
0.4335557222,
-0.0561363213,
0.3277564347,
0.1536077559,
-0.1699935794,
0.3424032927,
-0.0632294193,
-0.4160434604,
0.3246968389,
0.4433191121,
0.7499644756,
-0.1105928719,
0.169546172,
0.4215064347,
-0.0168523286,
-0.4619151652,
-0.5276773572,
-0.8704217076,
0.1975575089,
0.0363424309,
0.5606422424,
-0.88007164,
0.676079452,
-0.5770182014,
-0.3943968713,
-0.2295313627,
-0.189894706,
0.2384593934,
0.9172958732,
0.4495929778,
0.2999593914,
-0.9560703039,
-1.0908565521,
-0.0019730767,
-0.6762144566,
-0.2046180516,
0.1696210504,
0.4330480695,
-0.3883663714,
0.8483829498,
-0.2048917413,
-0.5211236477,
-0.030200664,
0.5164729953,
-0.0454405062,
0.4338021278,
0.4227319658,
-0.7082987428,
-0.1599002331,
0.4658150971,
-0.9355370998,
-0.218376115,
-0.24276492,
-0.2119517028,
0.2484763414,
0.7297579646,
-0.572702527,
0.5223088264,
0.0844019651,
-0.3368348479,
0.4888144135,
0.0666291788,
0.3671622574,
-0.9105770588,
0.1341897398,
-0.469209224,
-0.0802587643,
-0.4818274677,
0.0127371084,
0.236522913,
0.1901674271,
-0.0077171717,
0.1501220316,
-0.4388327897,
-0.3355006576,
-0.1928239763,
0.3933888078,
-0.0585978478,
0.5179623961,
0.3692687452,
0.4619409442,
0.4483900666,
-0.6433368325,
0.0170468912,
0.3864851296,
-0.0238053724,
0.7650848627,
-0.0862333626,
-0.1018131301,
-0.4272275269,
0.3810964525,
-0.7525375485,
-0.1948174983,
0.1410793513,
-0.650018394,
0.0258509554,
-0.583352387,
-0.7510881424,
0.103788726,
-0.3845802844,
0.202863276,
0.1325735003,
-0.5536533594,
0.537604928,
0.6770120263,
-0.1927942485,
-0.4511612058,
-0.4516756833,
0.4955981076,
-0.1438876837,
-0.5441884995,
0.6434636712,
0.1100561246,
-0.229287371,
0.1666807979,
-0.5167960525,
-0.0114970058,
-0.1199047267,
0.3891774714,
0.0517639108,
-0.362770021,
0.2835926712,
-0.0115677333,
-0.1828708798,
-0.0413950197,
-0.4947525561,
0.3012348413,
0.1393890977,
-0.1257748157,
-0.4995568395,
0.6246579885,
0.5019042492,
0.3505862653,
0.8952202201,
0.4349822104,
-1.0237284899,
0.2087182999,
-0.5779532194,
0.2180146575,
-0.3308120072,
0.2832100987,
-0.6481832862,
-0.5825566649,
0.770773232,
0.0587116741,
-0.2037671357,
0.9086946845,
0.4441132247,
-0.1879018843,
0.8201770782,
0.7194364071,
-0.3469206393,
0.3714192808,
0.0357827023,
0.0463961922,
-0.6827197671,
-0.6938095093,
-0.8367511034,
-0.0491604172,
-0.2975800633,
-0.549921751,
0.4746591449,
0.5383321047,
-0.0881233066,
0.3591784835,
0.1590177417,
0.5223062634,
0.6630197167,
-0.1738538593,
0.7733638883,
-0.0130233439,
-0.3816305101,
-0.2620287538,
-0.9914554954,
-0.3728919327,
0.2508660257,
0.1904000938,
0.5465690494,
-0.212462008,
0.8187329173,
0.0724007115,
0.4068606794,
-0.6479317546,
0.2856357992,
0.2524923086,
-0.5602384806,
-0.3291036487,
-0.3600779772,
-0.7826036811,
0.2399943918,
-0.1317885071,
-0.8138129115,
0.4840832055,
-0.0949167907,
-0.0218046661,
0.3523741663,
-0.2894012332,
0.6418984532,
0.4694687724,
0.0246286765,
-0.1278847009,
-0.780147016,
0.1113547757,
0.0232197698,
0.46668908,
-0.0218219124,
-0.1081752703,
1.0194140673,
-0.1115983799,
0.6285381317,
0.1011163369,
-0.1745790988,
0.0655403584,
0.15082407,
0.6921104193,
0.1470163316,
-0.0953415632,
-0.0055092196,
-0.0978014395,
-0.2417226434,
-0.468310535,
0.9602268338,
-0.761885345,
-0.3622991443,
-0.0814919025,
-0.4498630762,
-0.4286350608,
0.2711867988,
0.4647696316,
0.5169522762,
-0.1883912086,
0.399448216,
0.6379180551,
0.1164869592,
0.2033631653,
0.5001023412,
0.0980877727,
-0.3338616192,
0.4577439725,
0.267419368,
-0.207399413,
0.9484478235,
-0.016238546,
0.0335378759,
-0.7469647527,
-0.4114945233,
-0.0781277716,
-1.1363255978,
-0.5017610788,
-1.0896356106,
-0.0473937467,
-0.4905491173,
-0.4716356993,
-0.1033244058,
-0.7320359945,
-0.2252711654,
-0.6150663495,
0.0052305744,
0.48719877,
-0.2095655501,
0.2446365654,
-0.7333696485,
0.7703679204,
-0.2109409273,
0.3010790944,
0.2024160028,
-0.415168792,
-0.299139142,
-0.5463067293,
-0.1767315269,
-0.9491183162,
-0.0449324884,
0.3443892896,
0.7714265585,
0.4488294721,
0.1694449782,
1.1469376087,
-0.9616979957,
0.6151155829,
0.2342978418,
-0.8426629305,
1.0840698481,
-0.8221119046,
0.3311988115,
0.6771817803,
0.6798841953,
-0.8241761327,
-0.7650270462,
-0.9555875063,
-1.2539830208,
0.9105213881,
0.5382968783,
-0.1926379055,
-0.3964743316,
0.3947873712,
-0.0900782347,
0.175873667,
-0.7942531109,
-0.7723211646,
0.3913078308,
0.1865892112,
0.0382819511,
-0.4520068169,
-0.2356403321,
-0.2154384255,
0.7441564798,
0.1074934825,
-0.1946789622,
0.3983026445,
-0.2879912555,
-0.5075640082,
0.0456142426,
-0.0751908571,
0.6973674297,
-0.3340528607,
0.4870244265,
0.2991825044,
-0.2713389397,
-0.1234952435,
0.1429997832,
-0.3339431882,
0.3695274591,
0.951559484,
0.4467191994,
0.9689531922,
-0.2359344512,
0.2050032765,
0.4450425506,
-0.068537578,
-0.0298152976,
-0.3784971535,
0.1525670588,
0.1256362349,
0.9810321927,
-0.3549118936,
0.3933092356,
-1.0207027197,
0.6995403171,
0.0366334058,
-0.3449047208,
-0.1708213538,
0.6666088104,
0.2169850916,
0.0112073962,
0.478223145,
-0.0425390229,
-0.4071854949,
0.5640354156,
0.4750780463,
0.4485331774,
0.0270103291,
0.0868373588,
0.3959388733,
0.6197527647,
0.463888526,
-0.2094597816,
-0.1861633956,
-0.4957196116,
-0.2519926131,
-0.692612052,
-0.4445936978,
0.2696032226,
-0.5889676213,
0.1082460657,
-0.0915518031,
0.0193633605,
0.4414427578,
0.1720688641,
-0.3501672745,
0.1692343652,
0.583070159,
1.1845531464,
-0.8084028959,
0.5740821958,
0.932041049,
-0.4167854488,
-0.3581461906,
0.2854177356,
-0.0295066703,
-0.207968846,
0.8747399449,
-0.2021247298,
-0.0780772939,
-0.064727284,
-0.0265347697,
-1.0239946842,
0.9159529805,
0.1154819652,
-0.1343251616,
-0.4700220823,
0.0028053259,
0.6735737324,
-0.2441581041,
0.025398504,
0.5985107422,
0.515722692,
0.3046887815,
-1.0690699816,
-0.0308674462,
-0.226815924,
-0.1041153595,
0.4233128726,
-0.1032402217,
0.4970904589,
-0.0097957831,
-0.3869335353,
-0.0110245207,
1.0474972725,
0.3640283048,
0.6413656473,
0.2776984274,
0.5595592856,
0.947920084,
-0.0568401329,
0.9775277376,
-0.0217826348,
0.3852711916,
1.0727035999,
-0.1265016049,
0.7017881274,
0.536555469,
-0.0362190865,
0.4459551275,
0.6581485868,
0.565077126,
0.7027594447,
0.1698017716,
-0.1729055792,
-0.370539397,
-0.2798317075,
-0.4633763134,
-0.1395337135,
0.4309638739,
-0.0426456667,
-0.892919004,
-0.0409726128,
0.1426777393,
-0.1279633343,
-0.7018756866,
0.864397049,
-0.1229347885,
-0.6076367497,
0.3252588212,
0.1711947769,
0.3251794875,
-0.6577463746,
-0.0635918155,
-0.2857822478,
0.076328285,
-0.2991191447,
-0.4844412506,
0.5534249544,
-0.1611593068,
-0.7550818324,
-0.0528154373,
0.8783863187,
-0.4373264313,
-0.2899906039,
0.5701501369,
0.5026690364,
-0.007155749,
-0.0929206833,
-0.2504529953,
0.1012604162,
-0.4521956742,
-0.2437825799,
0.4578676224,
0.791811347,
-0.5520657897,
0.4273970425,
0.4083405733,
-0.3570313454,
0.1031007841,
0.3051689267,
0.961771071,
-0.7725208402,
-0.8892138004,
-0.4883835614,
0.2384548634,
-0.1763652712,
-0.0868132114,
0.9047852159,
0.8881314397,
0.8652988076,
-0.1363576502,
0.7103810906,
-0.2627922297,
0.2680167258,
-0.3106008768,
0.5307475924,
-0.3001174331,
-0.0842459127,
-0.4344869554,
-0.4241293967,
-0.4337576032,
0.3863448799,
0.0491074957,
-0.3506260812,
0.90073663,
0.3409170806,
-0.1053133011,
-0.1782639325,
0.4849912226,
0.1081751958,
-0.0253743734,
0.3515333235,
1.0282719135,
-0.4946762025,
0.6564048529,
-0.2374652177,
-0.4281779528,
-0.3073892891,
-1.0432631969,
-0.9145717621,
-0.8981965184,
-0.5662003756,
-0.2060458213,
0.6250986457,
0.6130101085,
0.7493972778,
-1.0098536015,
0.0317003168,
0.1660794765,
0.2601385713,
0.0376986489,
-0.1953513473,
0.5834669471,
-0.5742608309,
-0.4728166461,
0.5648199916,
0.3851412535,
-0.2556756437,
0.4723542631,
0.2936568558,
-0.4888586104,
-0.2172575891,
0.8227062225,
0.1109946892,
-0.5179054141,
-0.6605953574,
-0.3426428437,
-0.1946318001,
-0.0432314388,
0.9207488894,
-1.035639286,
-0.3899371326,
0.6539924741,
0.5679509044,
0.4511939585,
0.0805276558,
0.3124037981,
-1.4028271437,
0.1160783097,
0.1677409559,
0.4321390092,
0.0820377171,
-0.6446222663,
0.5693434477,
0.5501865149,
-0.1954465359,
-0.6476381421,
-0.0172993168,
-1.1072567701,
-0.1190506145,
1.1953657866,
0.1970352978,
0.2088569254,
-0.4261986911,
-0.2514919043,
0.2482034862,
-0.0085214358,
0.7725642323,
0.9217520356,
-0.2398468703,
-0.0224600155,
-0.3044061065,
0.6623159051,
-0.0390778854,
-0.778902173,
0.3015082479,
0.8385344744,
-0.055012431,
0.7458947897,
1.0510758162,
-0.0619674437,
0.3887690902,
0.1357875019,
-0.0052101444,
0.1958156377,
-0.8683163524,
-0.0285921115,
0.5244443417,
-0.2386964709,
0.0130614219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04185v1 | Efficient Joint Learning for Clinical Named Entity Recognition and Relation Extraction Using Fourier Networks: A Use Case in Adverse Drug Events | 2023-02-08T16:44:27 | 2023-02-08T16:44:27 | Anthony Yazdani, Dimitrios Proios, Hossein Rouhizadeh, Douglas Teodoro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Current approaches for clinical information extraction are inefficient in
terms of computational costs and memory consumption, hindering their
application to process large-scale electronic health records (EHRs). We propose
an efficient end-to-end model, the Joint-NER-RE-Fourier (JNRF), to jointly
learn the tasks of named entity recognition and relation extraction for
documents of variable length. The architecture uses positional encoding and
unitary batch sizes to process variable length documents and uses a
weight-shared Fourier network layer for low-complexity token mixing. Finally,
we reach the theoretical computational complexity lower bound for relation
extraction using a selective pooling strategy and distance-aware attention
weights with trainable polynomial distance functions. We evaluated the JNRF
architecture using the 2018 N2C2 ADE benchmark to jointly extract
medication-related entities and relations in variable-length EHR summaries.
JNRF outperforms rolling window BERT with selective pooling by 0.42%, while
being twice as fast to train. Compared to state-of-the-art BiLSTM-CRF
architectures on the N2C2 ADE benchmark, results show that the proposed
approach trains 22 times faster and reduces GPU memory consumption by 1.75
folds, with a reasonable performance tradeoff of 90%, without the use of
external tools, hand-crafted rules or post-processing. Given the significant
carbon footprint of deep learning models and the current energy crises, these
methods could support efficient and cleaner information extraction in EHRs and
other types of large-scale document databases. | [
-0.150442332,
-0.644254148,
0.7007381916,
-0.0793683827,
-0.3354168832,
-0.0694340169,
-0.2951798737,
-0.8071466684,
0.2030401528,
0.7221075892,
-0.2184477299,
-0.3308514059,
-0.725256443,
-0.0153394416,
-0.2860048115,
1.0557729006,
-0.2215023488,
0.2013996094,
-0.3736701608,
-0.3001743257,
-0.2341046482,
-0.4195663929,
-0.9180854559,
-0.5474296808,
0.961145997,
0.1560560614,
0.4314017594,
0.6289980412,
1.3194969893,
0.2788060308,
0.2840061188,
0.0307109505,
-0.3078227639,
0.4050008953,
-0.0035840629,
-0.2147803605,
-0.4907278419,
-0.5157265067,
0.4074580371,
0.6737658381,
-0.275080204,
0.1751359254,
-0.304204613,
1.1258997917,
-0.7731269002,
0.4573475122,
-0.2347462177,
0.3018400073,
-0.226380825,
-0.1812229604,
-0.2699711919,
-0.0526700802,
0.488812089,
-0.7592375278,
0.1889230758,
0.0907252654,
1.0591417551,
0.1880160719,
-0.439120084,
-0.2829747796,
-0.706556499,
0.6373220086,
-0.3436425924,
1.0584545135,
0.3398242295,
0.2989191711,
-0.1408845931,
-1.1029604673,
-0.3539016247,
0.1705468446,
-0.2059656382,
0.2661196887,
-0.2255000621,
0.220591262,
0.2554008067,
0.3527043164,
-0.6730270386,
-0.0463864394,
-0.6160014272,
0.0135200471,
0.5677469373,
0.1389956921,
0.2853155434,
-0.0686655417,
-0.5726114511,
-0.1639416218,
-0.5901637077,
0.0061648209,
-0.1519185603,
0.2590972185,
-0.1040499806,
0.3056953847,
0.0387692228,
0.3236398399,
0.1092391908,
-0.1418606341,
0.4023406208,
-0.1252260059,
-0.5422821641,
0.2501579225,
0.9578008652,
0.1925921291,
0.0040760501,
-0.5543498397,
-0.1009912938,
-0.3301430643,
0.3555524349,
-0.8569793105,
-0.7582010627,
0.4637694657,
-0.6895850301,
0.044028528,
-0.0851978585,
-1.0422974825,
-0.2564281821,
-0.5334091783,
0.3342570066,
-0.6149468422,
-0.151206553,
0.0855663121,
-0.1707581133,
0.1182570904,
0.2789634466,
-0.9138377309,
0.6435336471,
0.582567513,
0.490411073,
-0.3005225658,
0.1254068166,
-0.6786894202,
0.1536069363,
-0.0618764274,
0.6793323755,
-0.2437119931,
-0.2779466212,
-0.1992040128,
0.025287563,
-0.2855909169,
-0.6498897076,
0.3618980944,
-0.8251150846,
0.2754564285,
-0.2404584885,
-0.4921486378,
0.0160458628,
-0.1150458828,
-0.9237771034,
0.7475369573,
0.1773319244,
-0.8229137063,
0.4226849973,
-0.4795010686,
-0.5030189753,
0.1729842871,
-0.3019747138,
-0.8834905624,
-0.1054030284,
0.2712525427,
0.4999985993,
-0.6159228683,
0.4685641229,
-0.2370271236,
-0.1363638341,
0.1543646008,
-0.1657735109,
0.5443039536,
0.2919678092,
0.0610514916,
-0.127721712,
-0.822378397,
-0.2663351297,
0.3058169484,
-0.5065432787,
-0.4841708243,
-0.206776008,
0.214791581,
0.0857468471,
-0.0667447001,
-0.5071168542,
-0.2507546246,
-0.4052594602,
-0.0831811801,
0.2524271607,
0.4527941942,
0.3881784976,
-0.2831389606,
0.2507307529,
0.115297541,
0.2595035136,
-0.015082458,
-0.0727882385,
-0.5012971163,
-0.2865365744,
0.5460124016,
0.3745797575,
-0.7797839046,
0.2991164029,
-0.434435308,
-0.0244662818,
-0.213020891,
0.2504379451,
0.637583077,
0.745013237,
0.5192795396,
-0.425693512,
-0.4167819917,
-0.9120581746,
-0.193855986,
-0.2099365741,
-0.0710403323,
0.3432990611,
0.2343593389,
0.0445322432,
0.5561780334,
-0.4906630218,
-0.3682031333,
-0.1972997934,
-0.1054440588,
0.1736759245,
0.3530587256,
0.3356148601,
-1.0974128246,
-0.4909378588,
0.1567548066,
-0.9764274955,
0.168944791,
-0.2233791351,
-0.1639011651,
-0.1729913801,
0.4319427311,
-0.5305025578,
0.1344471723,
0.1169868857,
-0.0955226496,
-0.0672781691,
-0.2582765818,
0.0469962806,
-1.0061674118,
0.1535377204,
0.3583966196,
-0.2746765316,
-0.7191979289,
-0.0751032233,
0.1563160866,
0.0961355343,
-0.427049309,
0.3302102685,
-0.7324486375,
0.0896113515,
0.1485870481,
-0.0023541423,
0.3476170599,
0.6570507288,
0.0909552649,
0.1988210976,
0.2999905646,
-0.3925018311,
0.3298242688,
0.363959372,
-0.057618089,
0.5221543312,
-0.3770573437,
-0.0751678497,
-0.2734479606,
0.0509607047,
-0.4137567878,
-0.4877105057,
0.4528179765,
-0.1941351593,
1.0493956804,
-0.1729461104,
-0.367536813,
-0.3341727555,
-0.1506944299,
0.3099642396,
0.406614989,
-0.6239923835,
0.6211184859,
0.7790516615,
-0.283934921,
-0.5074026585,
-0.6499735117,
-0.0998923853,
-0.1743290424,
-0.3331668079,
0.4339813292,
0.515411973,
-0.2274604887,
0.2171802372,
-0.2387041003,
-0.42258358,
-0.0854404718,
0.3462538421,
0.4097704589,
-0.3313224316,
0.6974900365,
0.1539081037,
-0.0894281715,
0.2670977414,
-0.1081697121,
0.2287630141,
0.0395365432,
-0.2114811838,
-0.5035076737,
0.6480808854,
0.490147382,
-0.161026001,
0.6459977627,
0.554403007,
-0.8157905936,
0.1071792766,
-0.4385554492,
-0.1114691272,
-0.3928366005,
0.4217860997,
0.0280621424,
-0.6887847781,
0.437146008,
-0.3270871341,
-0.0397624709,
0.7168765664,
0.291693002,
-0.1025235653,
0.321337074,
0.3170069158,
0.224670276,
0.4763950408,
-0.2574022412,
0.392621845,
-0.9867491126,
-0.6333667636,
-0.2086965293,
-0.1445176601,
-0.2657671571,
-0.1195325404,
0.6151089668,
0.2468527555,
-0.2769466639,
0.3192636669,
-0.3667369187,
0.2758584917,
0.210771516,
0.419811666,
0.138360858,
0.2214833498,
-0.0851923227,
0.0271230936,
-0.4772739112,
0.0147419116,
1.3205707073,
0.4057988226,
0.3690156639,
0.1520306766,
0.9341177344,
-0.0094118891,
0.3223201036,
-0.6519637108,
0.1954574734,
-0.2669343352,
-0.2651229203,
-0.3600392342,
-0.4984116852,
-1.0484149456,
0.0507763587,
-0.4904143214,
-0.8679301143,
0.5652654171,
-0.0959203318,
-0.6885324717,
0.398031354,
-0.6758753657,
0.6332972646,
-0.1374717802,
-0.5588726997,
-0.0035136025,
-0.9537152052,
0.3147821426,
-0.307269454,
0.0651622489,
-0.0792473033,
0.1726651788,
1.0244269371,
-0.4427872002,
0.2366454303,
-0.0299431309,
0.1752869785,
0.2396284491,
-0.1886690408,
0.4305685461,
0.1540025026,
0.0176104158,
0.312402457,
0.1508708149,
-0.0784988105,
-0.6629009843,
0.6287916303,
-0.5256399512,
-0.1598274112,
-0.4473894238,
-0.3184019327,
-0.2553798854,
0.2968965769,
0.1535077989,
0.7243926525,
-0.0976353735,
0.1897868216,
0.7557014227,
-0.2583593428,
0.4505088329,
0.30935058,
0.041955322,
-0.5924455523,
0.8550059795,
0.088252075,
0.0498157591,
0.7360730767,
0.0714517757,
-0.4229284227,
-0.5097706318,
-0.4568115175,
0.2954601347,
-0.517803669,
-0.4511753917,
-1.0463328362,
-0.4321895838,
-0.3310372233,
0.1420897692,
-0.5143693089,
-0.3201496303,
-0.2973663211,
0.0893749818,
0.4197933078,
0.4725084007,
0.0278096758,
0.2170819044,
-1.106393218,
0.5758299232,
0.147362873,
0.4733394682,
0.0233955402,
0.09449476,
-0.3196163177,
-0.3306914568,
-0.3244802952,
-0.7232930064,
0.3588745296,
0.1940881014,
0.4463572204,
0.4435126781,
0.2533709407,
0.6191405058,
-0.2961893678,
0.3905870616,
0.7843363881,
-0.388641715,
0.258074373,
-0.1913442016,
-0.0561051369,
0.8605851531,
0.4015398622,
-0.470941633,
0.1507241428,
-0.5214523673,
-1.0189955235,
0.6967158914,
0.1731962413,
-0.3045463562,
-0.0897774249,
0.5755086541,
-0.0492079183,
0.0050691883,
-0.2767418921,
-0.5085462332,
0.450671494,
-0.4261165857,
0.2973894179,
-0.0995176435,
-0.0440108329,
-0.1454073936,
0.6729513407,
0.1235984266,
0.5959248543,
0.7146316171,
-0.0094836019,
-0.4342502654,
0.3177935183,
-0.0522950515,
0.2059152424,
-0.3786565661,
0.2341974825,
0.0546263009,
-0.765833199,
-0.1407442987,
0.5134036541,
0.3737669289,
-0.1132034808,
0.4808955491,
0.6603546739,
0.1972451955,
-0.581692934,
0.6044655442,
-0.4620556533,
-0.2985885143,
-0.3598882258,
0.0235604737,
0.0773115084,
0.4747018218,
0.1236432865,
0.1186282709,
0.4206974208,
-0.1491234601,
0.6053540707,
0.1585112363,
-0.7153862715,
-0.1034377068,
0.5745646954,
-0.0741349533,
-0.2789982855,
0.7226040363,
0.0043896339,
-0.0642877817,
0.5937049985,
0.386954546,
0.8183449507,
-0.0437986925,
-0.0429000147,
0.3461532295,
-0.3072704673,
-0.1452984065,
0.2199058831,
-0.2763614058,
-0.4234937131,
-0.1788337082,
-0.7211216092,
-0.2714824975,
0.1139667109,
-0.8854065537,
0.2317863256,
-0.4492731988,
-0.2253944278,
0.3904723227,
0.1103983074,
-0.7137579322,
0.1576479375,
0.1423618793,
0.3663773537,
-0.5434457064,
0.7966166139,
0.3006497324,
-0.1861528754,
-0.9174610972,
-0.1510038078,
0.0482785292,
-0.3657464385,
0.5567976236,
0.0274217278,
0.2631958127,
-0.3641918302,
0.1632092744,
-0.8676275611,
1.2055139542,
0.198773995,
-0.9760348797,
-0.2155504227,
0.1447705626,
0.677418232,
-0.1306907535,
0.0818048418,
0.4534928501,
0.1008212417,
0.2420573831,
-0.8053793907,
0.1524119079,
-0.4769347906,
-0.3212605119,
0.7506508231,
-0.4395077527,
0.6548842192,
-0.2795990109,
-0.4319811463,
-0.2491890043,
0.3828567266,
-0.0327890366,
0.6894153357,
0.3553718328,
0.5969411731,
0.8396750689,
0.0373031721,
1.1066795588,
-0.2415586859,
0.3539857566,
1.2420165539,
-0.5613572598,
0.7715080976,
0.6245458126,
-0.3034138381,
0.397326082,
0.3809774816,
0.0301794168,
0.6359753609,
0.0672030151,
-0.4553467929,
-0.1759171039,
-0.1554082334,
-0.293486625,
0.2017117441,
0.5185856223,
-0.814113915,
-0.345469594,
-0.0034748237,
-0.1533072144,
-0.2079516649,
-0.021788286,
1.0613187551,
0.5345270038,
-0.5743870139,
0.2209579945,
-0.1806945354,
-0.0145267751,
-0.4039842188,
-0.2296689153,
0.2363614738,
0.412016511,
-0.2134878337,
-0.3976877928,
0.3457710743,
-0.215305075,
-0.2365117967,
0.0175167229,
0.8501248956,
-0.4619812071,
-0.4408775568,
0.4969708323,
0.4532047808,
-0.0377281308,
0.2639196515,
-0.6336451769,
-0.2196847498,
-0.2326485813,
-0.3186369836,
0.5397588611,
0.2625518143,
-0.0378453918,
0.2172727138,
0.8817263842,
0.3117157817,
-0.2718268037,
0.0716430247,
0.8733731508,
-0.3192767501,
-0.1989088953,
-0.721339345,
0.110907428,
-0.2282320559,
-0.2137297243,
0.0570451245,
0.5816976428,
0.5057008266,
0.2921873629,
0.4689306319,
0.2480639815,
0.5086609125,
-0.5496858954,
0.6791769862,
-0.4775717854,
0.3189739585,
-0.0850320682,
-0.5748579502,
-0.7413951159,
0.3062404692,
-0.2273673862,
-0.2281874567,
0.8026726246,
0.3584279418,
-0.1240202039,
0.2618878186,
0.1696464717,
-0.0855022371,
0.457247287,
0.9002828002,
0.1626585424,
-0.8648201227,
0.236293897,
-0.5453727841,
0.0317906104,
0.0354291163,
-0.4885238111,
-0.8552438021,
-0.5270785093,
-0.576525867,
-0.2824755013,
0.2633790672,
1.2580533028,
0.6788479686,
-0.7668185234,
0.3829548061,
-0.0687374473,
0.0760096535,
-0.1577223837,
-0.2133618444,
0.9469014406,
-0.1206093282,
-0.2763782144,
0.0841209143,
0.5808638334,
-0.0472555906,
0.2231411487,
-0.0751612186,
-0.2023820728,
-0.2483207434,
0.2913339436,
0.3982421756,
-0.2931378186,
-0.0320549384,
-0.0380082913,
-0.2339994013,
0.194873035,
0.8190764785,
-0.7005885243,
0.6098484993,
0.446526885,
0.7583348751,
0.6527255177,
-0.228850916,
0.3660942912,
-0.4144620299,
-0.2047666162,
0.3024561703,
0.4534693658,
0.1734359413,
-0.7665530443,
0.3155813515,
0.2400398552,
-0.5290040374,
-0.5221683979,
-0.1910178512,
-1.1534885168,
-0.1710523516,
0.821698308,
-0.2849514186,
-0.4508363605,
-0.424446255,
0.1928246766,
0.5768754482,
-0.399821341,
0.6681767702,
0.1231548116,
-0.5435293913,
-0.3306037784,
-0.5552929044,
0.4022679329,
0.0766440704,
-0.7323594093,
0.1304593086,
0.1929706931,
0.276719451,
0.2519047856,
0.7532376647,
-0.5044696331,
0.3467751443,
-0.0893422961,
0.0220563691,
-0.2314319611,
-0.4531438351,
-0.3962484002,
0.2851117551,
-0.3907327056,
-0.0341735184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04166v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04166v2 | GPTScore: Evaluate as You Desire | 2023-02-08T16:17:29 | 2023-02-13T16:19:05 | Jinlan Fu, See-Kiong Ng, Zhengbao Jiang, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) has enabled the development of
sophisticated models that are capable of producing high-caliber text, images,
and other outputs through the utilization of large pre-trained models.
Nevertheless, assessing the quality of the generation is an even more arduous
task than the generation itself, and this issue has not been given adequate
consideration recently. This paper proposes a novel evaluation framework,
GPTScore, which utilizes the emergent abilities (e.g., zero-shot instruction)
of generative pre-trained models to score generated texts. There are 19
pre-trained models explored in this paper, ranging in size from 80M (e.g.,
FLAN-T5-small) to 175B (e.g., GPT3). Experimental results on four text
generation tasks, 22 evaluation aspects, and corresponding 37 datasets
demonstrate that this approach can effectively allow us to achieve what one
desires to evaluate for texts simply by natural language instructions. This
nature helps us overcome several long-standing challenges in text
evaluation--how to achieve customized, multi-faceted evaluation without the
need for annotated samples. We make our code publicly available at
https://github.com/jinlanfu/GPTScore. | [
-0.0256545711,
-0.9065586925,
0.8386160135,
0.2849404812,
-0.3256699741,
0.0903327763,
-0.3618427217,
-0.2034057379,
-0.2906238735,
0.2543126345,
-0.4155106246,
-0.6732105613,
-0.687253654,
0.1121404693,
-0.5726112723,
1.6051279306,
-0.1314853728,
-0.2974281609,
-0.4072822034,
0.2064388096,
-0.2091265768,
-0.2485936433,
-0.5219524503,
-0.3633569777,
0.0109408926,
0.1431467831,
0.5500884056,
0.3753810227,
0.4413422048,
0.422957629,
0.1073930711,
0.0600880533,
-0.5153380632,
0.1669716239,
-0.0727942064,
0.1207955778,
-0.5001839995,
0.381406337,
0.6801866293,
0.1751626879,
0.0789169148,
0.4789367318,
0.3485966921,
0.5176665187,
-0.5472158194,
0.1599707901,
-0.4295034707,
0.2474543899,
0.0534251928,
-0.1580685973,
-0.532320559,
-0.5546905398,
0.4250048995,
-0.4390473664,
0.365246743,
-0.4025667906,
0.7388201356,
-0.0482513197,
-0.2523526847,
-0.5167707205,
-0.8381246924,
0.7654244304,
-0.2145939916,
-0.0546398386,
0.0680609643,
0.4460017979,
0.3368913233,
-0.9168847203,
-0.5149768591,
-0.7688115239,
0.0993104205,
0.5616989136,
-0.075417228,
0.15898785,
0.0685528591,
0.8642309904,
-0.6738907099,
-0.1989632994,
-0.1464431882,
-0.0765350014,
0.6896070838,
0.1503659636,
0.5883536339,
-0.4697001278,
-0.4875191748,
0.0210621115,
-0.2041608989,
-0.1410266459,
0.5175060034,
0.1894836426,
-0.1513008773,
0.6963341832,
-0.1302867979,
0.6597073078,
0.0102145113,
0.172016561,
0.3074146807,
-0.572840035,
-0.4484576285,
-0.3112337887,
1.1009311676,
0.2015330344,
0.3250699937,
-0.4318879843,
-0.3755589128,
0.3082764447,
0.7213927507,
-0.9594727755,
-0.2504760325,
0.2428333014,
-0.4217028022,
-0.5959589481,
0.0744727328,
-0.7408612967,
-0.1916722953,
-0.2047905624,
0.7929098606,
-0.7837107182,
-0.166813761,
-0.0036871335,
-0.2060576975,
0.0852370188,
0.3855377734,
-0.8306796551,
0.1784376651,
0.5378922224,
0.9911620617,
-0.1504680216,
-0.4502028227,
-0.4443601072,
-0.0864740089,
-0.2809342146,
1.0347973108,
-0.6427190304,
-0.6347826719,
-0.2408115715,
-0.5234357119,
-0.2310771942,
-0.3098731637,
0.7995325327,
-0.2372658253,
0.3672175705,
0.1241365597,
-0.4302160442,
-0.0268739443,
0.50735569,
-0.4754365683,
1.0269833803,
0.4409437478,
-0.4080373645,
0.2938293219,
-1.0414469242,
-0.6511671543,
0.4259690642,
-0.3048115671,
-0.5042355061,
0.4510427117,
0.2947476208,
0.2767494023,
-0.5164425969,
0.3200009763,
0.1774054021,
-0.4229136705,
-0.0997717977,
-0.7305001616,
0.5277118683,
0.225739941,
-0.5900789499,
0.5366805792,
-0.5146286488,
0.6239213943,
0.0936646163,
-0.2489241362,
0.0689261183,
0.0087229023,
0.1263407022,
0.1020936668,
0.246941328,
-0.4831610918,
0.0933668539,
-0.3176770508,
0.479470402,
0.7785832286,
0.1152149886,
0.4269298613,
-0.2485401481,
0.7727323771,
-0.1879324913,
0.5172400475,
-0.2963249683,
-0.4841578603,
-0.5979792476,
-0.1667672694,
0.1732088178,
0.3205412626,
-0.9037231803,
0.5659094453,
-0.4609985948,
-0.9174470305,
-0.4974942803,
0.1802182645,
0.7402666211,
0.5005757213,
0.4276585579,
-0.4821962714,
-0.191255033,
-0.7843639255,
-0.3439952135,
-0.153198123,
-0.3125712574,
0.241693601,
0.5149994493,
-0.1547312737,
0.9949125051,
-0.3880617619,
-0.2352066189,
-0.540715456,
0.6217155457,
0.0612704493,
0.5608111024,
0.44305709,
-0.6514210105,
-0.5323609114,
0.0528092869,
-0.8373960853,
0.0995957628,
-0.2439991832,
-0.0282926541,
-0.3353552818,
-0.0286393221,
-0.7985162735,
0.202889055,
0.503610611,
-0.2464385778,
0.8359402418,
-0.3094859123,
0.5501381755,
-0.833348155,
0.081497252,
0.2373379916,
-0.0403183438,
-0.4935251772,
0.3291878104,
-0.1529425681,
-0.4691859186,
-0.3032047451,
0.4458644688,
-0.6241897941,
-0.111023955,
-0.0527217649,
0.1964727342,
0.2362528145,
0.1883471459,
-0.0928037018,
0.9821432233,
0.4111497104,
-0.4793639779,
0.3617624044,
0.0899174213,
-0.8615723252,
0.6245997548,
-0.9066357613,
0.4930611551,
-0.129321903,
0.0529064387,
-0.6299630404,
-0.1008078009,
0.1154100373,
-0.540160656,
0.0848362669,
-0.1112307161,
-0.4919595718,
-0.5569046736,
-0.4423019886,
0.2320578545,
0.6357049346,
-0.3891998827,
0.7392060757,
0.0991998166,
-0.094282642,
-0.1799736172,
-0.3568443358,
0.2154387981,
-0.0021227531,
-0.3502624035,
0.343996793,
-0.3298322856,
0.1196892038,
0.1491942853,
0.0910197049,
0.0314200595,
0.1153415143,
0.3023989201,
0.2115174234,
-0.2816636264,
0.0391188897,
0.1596200019,
-0.2410880178,
-0.0420931391,
-0.5998896956,
0.4517793953,
-0.4463210106,
-0.3962029815,
-0.2640666664,
0.4149769843,
0.4563938975,
-0.5238863826,
0.2432882637,
0.7956180573,
-0.3804269433,
-0.3759531081,
-0.2702545822,
0.3040674031,
-0.4784444273,
0.647477448,
-0.429272294,
-0.735509336,
-0.0753935799,
0.1176204607,
0.0232735705,
0.8488494754,
0.6641962528,
0.0597056933,
1.123467207,
0.4501830637,
0.2646291554,
0.308080107,
-0.271681726,
0.1979969889,
-0.7449350953,
-0.1057955027,
-0.4448392987,
-0.0800212398,
-0.3116233945,
-0.4694242179,
0.4652121961,
0.1132218912,
-0.4088256359,
0.2082825303,
-0.9603797793,
0.7055693269,
0.4157653153,
0.2585126758,
0.3192367852,
0.0457681865,
-0.0037127899,
0.1284964234,
-0.4411180019,
-0.8871994019,
1.1594290733,
0.2716124356,
0.32505548,
-0.1304502487,
0.7062460184,
0.6060386896,
1.0457416773,
-0.9030100107,
0.5702422857,
-0.4521641135,
-0.5537221432,
-0.2178402394,
-0.682298243,
-0.6245222688,
-0.011653495,
-0.2647308111,
-0.7487951517,
-0.5392269492,
0.0486842766,
-0.4940054417,
0.1483526528,
-1.2182095051,
1.1149657965,
-0.6232026219,
-0.2401656806,
-0.1139540002,
-0.2238369435,
0.3499594629,
0.0124416407,
-0.1052634045,
-0.0005039061,
0.266639024,
0.7557678223,
-0.2290260643,
0.6844624877,
-0.2793323398,
0.0382636189,
0.7725681663,
-0.0248383973,
0.0535687655,
0.062888965,
-0.3043126762,
-0.0999405086,
-0.1638621688,
-0.2823891044,
-0.8349149227,
0.7194763422,
-0.8697773814,
-0.4512587786,
-0.3281773627,
-0.2675271928,
-0.2210486382,
0.334966898,
0.488628,
0.5049113035,
-0.7205209136,
-0.1936696172,
0.2174996734,
-0.1560304612,
0.4693732262,
0.1039265618,
-0.1612278968,
-0.5949867964,
1.2367055416,
-0.0267274864,
0.1157805994,
0.2003627867,
0.2817205191,
-0.3932948411,
-0.9046368003,
-0.9415481687,
-0.3036222756,
-0.4890553653,
-0.3069637716,
-0.5759940147,
-0.4644883871,
-0.2148969173,
-0.0960340947,
-0.4240655303,
0.0778477341,
-0.3752042651,
-0.2290130407,
0.113215901,
1.1234409809,
0.3167341948,
0.4357991517,
-1.0827383995,
0.388345778,
0.4819686413,
0.7432855368,
0.108733125,
-0.3779059052,
-0.1768965274,
-0.0462875664,
-0.5553303957,
-0.7550038099,
0.2234953493,
0.3971478641,
0.4199306667,
0.3397004604,
-0.2105654925,
0.5746490359,
-0.6542785168,
0.9387530684,
0.391546309,
-1.3533661366,
0.7174096107,
-0.3204918206,
0.4176569879,
0.8327264786,
0.3932502568,
-0.1200405508,
-0.1202844828,
-0.7005295753,
-0.7453010678,
0.4089453518,
0.5042564273,
0.587210834,
-0.2494313121,
0.4202392995,
0.2378519028,
0.3274510205,
-0.7430664897,
0.2288869917,
-0.5051592588,
-0.3927627504,
-0.3362698853,
-0.3892625868,
-0.0270766076,
-0.0858687833,
0.3751471937,
-0.1935312152,
0.4042362869,
0.209908843,
-0.2997670174,
0.1140549108,
0.499527216,
0.3771343231,
0.4438148141,
-0.1105040759,
-0.0058818464,
-0.1550862044,
-0.7773352265,
0.2091831863,
0.2049178481,
-0.3140183985,
-0.164320454,
0.5210869908,
0.8102200627,
0.0812811032,
-0.5242766738,
0.6397285461,
-0.1000941694,
-0.1377836317,
-0.1277167946,
0.0817054585,
-0.2789135873,
0.0193547588,
0.512309134,
0.1353521347,
0.1495153755,
-0.5375363827,
0.3528753221,
0.2882100046,
-0.6961578131,
-0.5368805528,
0.5030027628,
0.4578422308,
-0.3774116337,
0.8324196339,
-0.6812731624,
-0.6644870043,
0.4660503268,
0.5506093502,
1.3980218172,
-0.2340924889,
0.8063390255,
0.3376193941,
0.4718988538,
0.1183534637,
0.1161974818,
-0.3179338276,
-0.6441799402,
-0.5059068203,
-1.0368008614,
-0.3580912054,
0.0779869631,
-0.512766242,
0.0310715251,
-0.5524178743,
-0.2668266892,
-0.1706314385,
0.0599848963,
-0.7070075274,
0.7577798367,
-0.0515252836,
0.7084954977,
-0.8106331229,
0.5025551915,
0.7336499095,
-0.6166872978,
-0.5293157697,
0.164646402,
-0.3019361496,
-0.5829946399,
0.3125428855,
0.508577466,
-0.1277235895,
0.2208695412,
-0.2937279344,
-0.2387687117,
0.9423885345,
0.3620826602,
-0.1873388737,
-0.2845827639,
-0.033114329,
0.8667009473,
-0.5026131868,
0.8802625537,
0.5674661994,
0.4385233223,
-0.1444154829,
-0.6277694106,
-0.1534562856,
-0.6813285351,
0.1369139105,
-0.0392888822,
-0.3504993916,
0.631669879,
-0.324754566,
-0.534206152,
0.1694090962,
0.7196537256,
0.0396616831,
0.2068719864,
0.5586815476,
0.5539295673,
0.3784006536,
-0.1675487161,
1.5044189692,
-0.0245728362,
0.5063920021,
1.125311017,
-0.1425441802,
0.6543701887,
0.0090814317,
-0.3072222769,
0.4482395351,
0.4881694019,
-0.1292598397,
0.3263052106,
0.3434140384,
-0.402325213,
-0.2744947672,
-0.0340928808,
-0.2848779559,
0.7325139046,
0.0516709611,
-0.4999846816,
-0.3932997584,
-0.1076644734,
-0.3456115723,
0.4022796452,
-0.2419371456,
0.6347282529,
-0.1791209131,
-0.6489061713,
0.1721176803,
0.028827291,
0.564414978,
-0.6466715932,
-0.0189407654,
0.1237232685,
-0.1031318083,
-0.1826549619,
-0.8876241446,
0.3943580091,
0.3736247122,
-0.1945558935,
-0.4196958244,
0.561638236,
-0.0327796377,
-0.838981092,
0.2013353109,
0.7084317803,
0.0454099327,
-0.2740589082,
-0.8108667731,
0.0215014629,
-0.0926444754,
-0.4254549742,
0.1545110643,
0.3650754392,
0.1539606899,
0.2525103986,
0.6771371961,
0.0278766099,
-0.2709467709,
0.3002942801,
0.8045010567,
-0.6116515398,
-0.3640718162,
-0.8209602833,
0.6511262655,
-0.1461092681,
-0.6689192057,
0.6140274405,
0.7307906151,
0.5636523366,
-0.2348843813,
1.1289265156,
-0.2086269855,
0.222911939,
-0.4011265635,
1.0286887884,
-0.2069753706,
0.0083163781,
-0.609760344,
-1.0728548765,
-0.085916169,
0.4788599312,
-0.6936295033,
0.552077651,
0.6394456625,
0.1289966404,
0.0285284389,
0.2913203537,
0.2716695964,
0.0820592865,
0.3921233714,
0.7758939862,
0.9953593016,
-0.5873120427,
0.542190671,
-0.1413065642,
-0.5908593535,
0.363232702,
-1.0221198797,
-0.7754628062,
-0.6182661057,
-0.343981564,
-0.1479620337,
0.2089112848,
0.5352290869,
0.5392824411,
-0.5346112251,
0.0020676279,
-0.3341493011,
-0.0384900793,
-0.2410968691,
-0.2738445997,
0.4285438955,
-0.5559678674,
-0.9073782563,
0.4453424513,
0.4868420362,
0.0803765953,
-0.2566444278,
0.102573216,
0.1023941636,
-0.1177737713,
0.9110537171,
-0.0431142859,
-0.2349878401,
-0.4737199545,
-0.180547297,
-0.209373191,
-0.0031922271,
0.7918394804,
-0.7619843483,
0.5831260085,
0.233653605,
0.7273560762,
0.483332634,
0.2499342859,
0.6788457632,
-0.5403506756,
-0.2755989432,
0.569898963,
-0.1297227889,
0.4231757522,
-0.2992694974,
0.2683544755,
0.0723404288,
-0.3523393571,
-0.5866679549,
0.233283177,
-0.7814982533,
0.0408825018,
0.8003941774,
-0.4070107639,
-0.1325565875,
0.2120941132,
-0.053818889,
0.3226636946,
-0.1377703846,
0.8925769925,
0.4613318741,
-0.0488730185,
-0.0914460197,
-0.5039740801,
0.5436460376,
0.4660537839,
-1.1290823221,
-0.2282824963,
0.3928223252,
0.0588404648,
0.271164,
0.8013506532,
-0.3363788128,
0.2512376308,
0.1697231084,
0.0099980095,
-0.1646573097,
-0.4601614475,
-0.2513546348,
0.5870856047,
0.0249827709,
-0.1687642485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04156v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04156v1 | Prompting for Multimodal Hateful Meme Classification | 2023-02-08T16:04:08 | 2023-02-08T16:04:08 | Rui Cao, Roy Ka-Wei Lee, Wen-Haw Chong, Jing Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.MM | Hateful meme classification is a challenging multimodal task that requires
complex reasoning and contextual background knowledge. Ideally, we could
leverage an explicit external knowledge base to supplement contextual and
cultural information in hateful memes. However, there is no known explicit
external knowledge base that could provide such hate speech contextual
information. To address this gap, we propose PromptHate, a simple yet effective
prompt-based model that prompts pre-trained language models (PLMs) for hateful
meme classification. Specifically, we construct simple prompts and provide a
few in-context examples to exploit the implicit knowledge in the pre-trained
RoBERTa language model for hateful meme classification. We conduct extensive
experiments on two publicly available hateful and offensive meme datasets. Our
experimental results show that PromptHate is able to achieve a high AUC of
90.96, outperforming state-of-the-art baselines on the hateful meme
classification task. We also perform fine-grained analyses and case studies on
various prompt settings and demonstrate the effectiveness of the prompts on
hateful meme classification. | [
-0.7091395259,
-0.7566510439,
0.2979302108,
0.2862855792,
-0.2439228892,
-0.1102797687,
-0.2548074722,
-0.1189399064,
0.1955767572,
0.1617229432,
-1.0323117971,
-0.3732065856,
-0.7524957061,
0.236503005,
-0.244185701,
1.0584402084,
0.3677631617,
0.0695573315,
0.1744753867,
-0.3436045945,
-0.7488046288,
-0.5401036143,
-0.7691627741,
0.4122542143,
0.9835585356,
0.5847458243,
0.435246855,
0.1266562045,
0.00046047,
0.2815111578,
0.3140357137,
-0.0564744882,
-0.2675471604,
0.5705422163,
-0.3763905168,
-0.312892437,
0.1024275646,
0.5943974257,
-0.0030549995,
0.3492894173,
-0.0263539776,
0.1706361473,
0.0441491939,
-0.0842215642,
-0.5788900852,
-0.2311744094,
-0.5458196402,
-0.0800668523,
-0.2830522358,
-0.2593204677,
-0.6708911061,
-0.486310035,
0.2240646333,
-0.5102775693,
0.100431256,
0.1629748344,
0.3697625101,
0.1667074114,
-0.5350520611,
-0.5666093826,
-0.3491033614,
0.9007216692,
-0.5738911033,
0.3144401908,
0.1614516079,
0.5178789496,
0.0955104083,
-0.4043722153,
-0.9381664395,
-0.3829827607,
0.1073861718,
-0.0097274827,
-0.4423589706,
-0.1969093829,
0.5760009289,
0.0437770002,
-0.7256963849,
0.3123341799,
-0.2395103425,
-0.4860988557,
0.1077695489,
0.1120307297,
0.7280017734,
-0.547393024,
-0.9004702568,
-0.316914022,
-0.4004980028,
0.1366853267,
0.3276044428,
0.3752371669,
-0.1335076541,
0.3872684538,
0.0256293938,
0.6330654621,
0.0703946501,
-0.1177689135,
0.0824587569,
0.1716525406,
0.0632488951,
-0.1649814993,
0.6484976411,
0.5905009508,
0.3286599815,
0.0633125901,
0.0343044885,
0.6554760933,
0.2958579957,
-0.8637010455,
-0.1213191375,
0.0667589232,
-0.2401983887,
-0.2284897268,
-0.3705031276,
-1.202837348,
-0.8886614442,
-0.3188064694,
0.272682637,
-0.5833976269,
-0.0133939469,
-0.5832869411,
-0.4934022427,
0.1614989787,
0.7800748348,
-0.565246582,
-0.1136932001,
0.1960163862,
0.6781269312,
-0.0683976784,
-0.1832596064,
-0.8165041208,
-0.0725969523,
0.0009855593,
0.8596081138,
-0.7508236766,
-0.0486017466,
0.1117523611,
0.0997759402,
0.0883065388,
-0.2716490924,
0.8342758417,
-0.6309574842,
0.6213425398,
-0.3327713013,
-0.4309107363,
-0.5347986221,
0.406671375,
-0.4585884809,
0.4591156542,
0.2090595365,
-0.7420179844,
0.4572802186,
-0.5448927879,
-0.2273117304,
0.2031766027,
-0.1026598737,
-0.1540920138,
-0.1311546713,
0.2490684539,
0.6752944589,
-0.261416167,
0.1540026665,
-0.6559906006,
0.2475747615,
0.1019049436,
-0.6484367251,
1.0397971869,
0.6834158897,
-0.4330727458,
0.4503498375,
-0.5844843984,
-0.3528731465,
0.2041728646,
-0.013233833,
-0.69672364,
-0.362840265,
0.1140356585,
0.5238716602,
0.0288015138,
-0.7237430215,
0.1230260804,
-0.0557705089,
0.2594088912,
1.0986802578,
-0.1130149141,
0.4347980022,
-0.5523737073,
0.6922062635,
0.0004491757,
0.3070760667,
-0.2676757872,
-0.6788244247,
-0.4043217301,
-0.3731220365,
-0.2105263472,
0.7354296446,
-0.8256219029,
0.0012511942,
0.2626187205,
-0.3944420815,
-0.1112708449,
0.0023802209,
0.2512101233,
0.6943925023,
0.6386523247,
0.1713131219,
-0.744560957,
-0.8806461692,
-0.2036494911,
-0.0660364032,
-0.0832502693,
0.4304449558,
0.1181877926,
-0.3104708195,
0.6579917669,
-0.2285290062,
-0.1780004799,
-0.125036329,
0.6379333735,
-0.0636930838,
0.4966285229,
0.8062162995,
-0.6820229888,
-0.4767581224,
-0.5379069448,
-0.6776944995,
-0.6765272617,
-0.1356023401,
-0.1188386008,
-0.0948326439,
0.4358076751,
-0.2075200081,
0.1214658245,
0.474673301,
-0.543600738,
0.7752702236,
0.3438920081,
0.7751010656,
-1.1141594648,
-0.2400968224,
0.0082641039,
-0.1912419796,
-0.7316423059,
-0.05965003,
0.0397174396,
-0.3932073414,
-0.6107001305,
0.690703094,
-0.2569950223,
0.4732000232,
-0.1580644399,
-0.0628115609,
-0.3068553805,
0.6218364835,
-0.0783530176,
0.8428846598,
0.5272765756,
-0.8024433255,
0.4283528924,
0.3341797888,
-0.1384723485,
1.0044455528,
-0.1003112346,
0.1097530201,
-0.1746746153,
0.0527548827,
-1.2528156042,
-0.3090772927,
0.7197636366,
-0.4307556748,
0.2134736776,
-0.1763511896,
-0.1965193003,
-0.4594088495,
-0.4278555512,
0.6861736774,
0.5827362537,
-0.8848572969,
0.5753335357,
0.3002466857,
-0.2892198861,
-0.5125860572,
-0.2357349247,
0.0204721447,
-0.6695686579,
-0.5756604075,
0.0415596701,
-0.4995575547,
-0.060579624,
-0.389226675,
0.1864463985,
-0.1507402807,
-0.0194117185,
0.449377507,
-0.0638431609,
-0.2631412148,
0.0806977749,
0.0963784084,
-0.1451862752,
0.0587888286,
-0.0882088691,
0.6702148914,
0.0702471063,
-0.262802124,
-0.6315339208,
0.5163567662,
0.823215723,
-0.0085386913,
0.4444665313,
0.5173345804,
-0.3541686535,
-0.4779066741,
-0.9545781612,
-0.4833159745,
-0.3935878873,
-0.0360651165,
-0.1179171726,
-0.9875562191,
0.4822559953,
-0.1817635894,
-0.0109008169,
0.2985284925,
0.3970123827,
-0.2529300153,
1.0309933424,
0.2691655457,
-0.0900549814,
0.7039474845,
0.2084470987,
-0.087365374,
-0.2878695428,
-0.0925076306,
-0.6703808904,
-0.273011446,
-0.0807353407,
-0.6789816618,
0.4685051739,
0.0339856185,
-0.2634829581,
0.2177034765,
-0.323802501,
0.2947743833,
0.6331117749,
0.1143541709,
-0.1647166461,
0.2329778075,
-0.2026487738,
-0.4040476978,
-0.5486622453,
-0.4870418608,
0.6984266043,
0.199124977,
0.7479628325,
0.2345291972,
0.230450809,
0.7252570391,
0.5079138875,
-0.5957905054,
0.5494889021,
-0.0940269902,
-0.5682006478,
-0.191144228,
-0.2486605048,
-0.7898856997,
-0.0806286931,
-0.2215511203,
-0.4084684551,
-0.0351867788,
0.3948153555,
-0.3461284041,
0.2745558918,
-0.7008906603,
0.9842916727,
-0.0473675206,
-0.1683027744,
-0.5315169096,
-0.6700589657,
0.3935302198,
0.1898856312,
0.6396638155,
-0.2513639927,
-0.0003011897,
1.0477684736,
-0.4960854352,
1.2239447832,
-0.5625396967,
0.0036444138,
0.5091575384,
0.3671542108,
0.3734171093,
-0.1516545862,
0.097039938,
0.0130012017,
-0.4138562977,
-0.4911416471,
-0.7762004137,
0.6601928473,
-0.5591378212,
-0.6047861576,
-0.3094566464,
-0.44149068,
-0.2729719281,
0.0359836221,
0.3478040993,
0.5933408737,
-0.1256349087,
-0.0852052346,
0.744499445,
-0.4489915669,
0.3297798038,
0.7134056687,
-0.0000504502,
-0.3843000233,
0.9277422428,
0.0604619458,
-0.015044474,
0.2297028303,
0.4367933869,
-0.494628042,
-0.2947783172,
-0.7539789081,
-0.07034944,
-0.9060902596,
-0.4183966517,
-0.7917914391,
0.26234743,
-0.3573799431,
-0.4128273726,
0.0183769148,
-0.3061964214,
-0.19597058,
0.1475555599,
0.5261935592,
0.8387354612,
-0.2613783479,
0.714197576,
-0.6715479493,
0.2795594335,
0.68851614,
0.0946300849,
-0.001076653,
-0.975430429,
0.3204823136,
-0.0466855802,
-0.1992868185,
-1.5950661898,
0.1776452065,
-0.1845110953,
0.6833429337,
0.6960469484,
0.4627456069,
0.5377264023,
-0.4637354016,
0.8002393842,
0.4962700903,
-0.764934063,
0.782853663,
-0.4011572599,
-0.0172876529,
0.3766192794,
0.8536176682,
-0.6875498295,
-0.6540432572,
-0.5424952507,
-0.3219169974,
0.7829700708,
-0.1807582378,
0.3561417758,
-0.492302686,
-0.0404274687,
0.4269725084,
0.1099087596,
-0.9777195454,
-0.422073245,
-0.4823736846,
-0.1640917361,
0.1515783817,
-0.7076396942,
0.0455918089,
-0.146583885,
0.8184538484,
-0.0598618388,
-0.0380318016,
-0.1085445285,
-0.5408124328,
0.0534253791,
0.4585052133,
0.6170039773,
0.2852947712,
-0.0518220402,
0.3643273711,
0.2338283658,
-0.0617820174,
0.397446692,
-0.179860279,
-0.0486503504,
-0.1438082159,
0.1234885529,
0.5844490528,
0.3358854949,
-0.585069418,
1.0217505693,
-0.1809484363,
0.0885138437,
-0.144522205,
-0.1780596673,
-0.2999086678,
0.3100308478,
0.1839710325,
0.3737799227,
0.2849453986,
-0.1647371501,
0.5128141642,
0.5329861045,
-0.3204596043,
-0.4087738991,
0.6464005113,
0.3483717442,
0.0823451206,
0.4011564255,
-0.4104310274,
-0.7856613398,
0.3270364702,
0.5936143398,
0.5821737647,
-0.8772290945,
0.4776506126,
0.7724727988,
0.3362763822,
0.4907058775,
0.0936786085,
-0.2536454499,
-0.5943036079,
-0.1096948907,
-0.7454863191,
-0.2433820367,
0.5156904459,
-0.2820903063,
0.4705392122,
-0.8462260962,
0.1360131502,
0.0867894888,
-0.444222182,
-0.6236135364,
0.3557406962,
0.4488076866,
0.8943205476,
-1.1363260746,
0.2842745781,
0.6291584969,
-0.6611973643,
-0.7220493555,
-0.278883636,
0.3105566502,
-0.9900868535,
0.4742335081,
0.4532643855,
0.0218371041,
0.0350651629,
-0.9230911732,
-0.4750100374,
0.2485759556,
0.2996218204,
-0.3330189288,
0.3628046215,
-0.4101346731,
0.159508422,
-0.5076500177,
0.4670509994,
-0.0841525868,
0.4144023955,
0.1525788009,
-0.4721539617,
0.3444437087,
-0.2691343129,
-0.2925953567,
-0.0747062415,
-0.3145536482,
0.8564904928,
-0.2080533653,
-0.4923297167,
-0.1336734295,
0.8074059486,
-0.0859512165,
0.3785201907,
1.0427907705,
0.3537035286,
0.802873373,
0.2014754266,
0.8202995062,
-0.0495765358,
-0.2269482315,
1.0310488939,
0.1655821949,
0.5956463814,
0.1612686664,
-0.0517584831,
0.81238693,
0.5942877531,
-0.0145924827,
0.3642597497,
0.1059004366,
-0.6815757155,
-0.5162574649,
-0.4137082696,
-0.3352154195,
0.2421410978,
0.4931041598,
-0.1386132687,
-0.6230621934,
0.7805979848,
0.172428757,
0.3286968768,
-0.4149428308,
0.8365565538,
-0.1835844815,
-0.5776593089,
0.6099698544,
0.0035247458,
0.9613568783,
-0.6766095757,
0.0384896435,
0.0378708057,
-0.2169686556,
-0.1151911244,
-0.5061420202,
0.3078078032,
0.2005786449,
-0.5400072932,
-0.2048913687,
0.614308238,
-0.4883648157,
0.0918991491,
0.349255532,
0.5128815174,
0.2912829816,
-0.3697854877,
-0.821066618,
-0.1426351517,
0.106959492,
-0.0863634646,
0.3477914333,
0.5695931911,
-0.3895645738,
0.6071967483,
0.8594674468,
-0.4302460551,
0.4154279232,
0.414747566,
0.9204344749,
-0.6730853915,
-0.6961733103,
-0.8374350071,
0.4379611015,
-0.1695495248,
-0.2488495111,
0.9648624659,
0.2553415298,
0.6723250151,
-0.4409898818,
0.9320299029,
-0.1900918037,
1.0271873474,
-0.2082463801,
0.4330244362,
-0.5711907148,
-0.0757128075,
-0.2029229105,
-0.5896824598,
-0.2025507838,
0.616651535,
-0.3820146024,
-0.0675633475,
0.5169430971,
0.8368260264,
-0.0225093514,
0.3663907051,
0.4701866806,
0.4250881672,
0.2640743852,
0.4034428895,
1.3855739832,
-0.05213302,
0.625252068,
-0.4756548107,
-0.7369214892,
-0.1972583681,
-0.7509330511,
-1.0670382977,
-0.6872422695,
-0.3571677506,
-0.4555895329,
-0.1542496383,
1.299038291,
0.781916976,
-1.1510865688,
0.1295534223,
0.1660321355,
0.1660429835,
0.0785737485,
-0.2656359673,
-0.0262327474,
-0.6336641908,
-0.8183048964,
0.5233806968,
0.1351530552,
0.2514500916,
0.0604685619,
-0.0665457249,
-0.3502450287,
0.0832255632,
0.7771410942,
0.3834981918,
-0.9124693871,
-0.1900265962,
-0.2596111596,
-0.1840993464,
-0.2343536615,
0.972502172,
-0.796459794,
0.4088722765,
0.3389957547,
0.5613963604,
-0.2305826843,
0.1540379077,
0.3433966637,
-0.9542460442,
0.3767021894,
0.4089196622,
0.4443311989,
0.3223494589,
-0.3742593825,
0.109694995,
0.5445389152,
-0.3272859454,
-0.5862403512,
0.3364439905,
-1.1742573977,
-0.5737010837,
0.9799287915,
-0.0705461055,
-0.2287026197,
-0.3613449633,
-0.6803702712,
0.2299299687,
-0.7310869098,
0.5286573768,
0.6171182394,
0.2775531411,
-0.2074304521,
-0.3363962173,
0.7807754278,
0.7096281648,
-0.6536691189,
0.2710494995,
0.9719700813,
0.2518872619,
0.2753611207,
0.5018292665,
0.3061460555,
0.5500408411,
-0.0802979171,
0.1607280225,
-0.1341428459,
-0.689489305,
-0.2655872703,
0.5997219682,
-0.2389090508,
0.0065032998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04116v1 | Training-free Lexical Backdoor Attacks on Language Models | 2023-02-08T15:18:51 | 2023-02-08T15:18:51 | Yujin Huang, Terry Yue Zhuo, Qiongkai Xu, Han Hu, Xingliang Yuan, Chunyang Chen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large-scale language models have achieved tremendous success across various
natural language processing (NLP) applications. Nevertheless, language models
are vulnerable to backdoor attacks, which inject stealthy triggers into models
for steering them to undesirable behaviors. Most existing backdoor attacks,
such as data poisoning, require further (re)training or fine-tuning language
models to learn the intended backdoor patterns. The additional training process
however diminishes the stealthiness of the attacks, as training a language
model usually requires long optimization time, a massive amount of data, and
considerable modifications to the model parameters. In this work, we propose
Training-Free Lexical Backdoor Attack (TFLexAttack) as the first training-free
backdoor attack on language models. Our attack is achieved by injecting lexical
triggers into the tokenizer of a language model via manipulating its embedding
dictionary using carefully designed rules. These rules are explainable to human
developers which inspires attacks from a wider range of hackers. The sparse
manipulation of the dictionary also habilitates the stealthiness of our attack.
We conduct extensive experiments on three dominant NLP tasks based on nine
language models to demonstrate the effectiveness and universality of our
attack. The code of this work is available at
https://github.com/Jinxhy/TFLexAttack. | [
0.0142225791,
-0.6725434661,
0.3328053653,
-0.0136821354,
-0.14765279,
0.133885324,
-0.1055672541,
-0.3650420308,
0.2384314537,
0.707118988,
-0.5688980222,
-0.7879709005,
-0.6655004025,
-0.2702200413,
-0.8860476017,
0.9597847462,
0.1710898578,
-0.0927079469,
0.4948005676,
-0.0861971974,
-0.4994945824,
-0.7492280602,
-0.5240674019,
-0.0268612523,
0.6098530293,
0.1336601526,
1.0995707512,
0.2760149539,
-0.1646863818,
0.2245043367,
-0.0216918215,
-0.4254358411,
-0.5572923422,
0.0177463982,
-0.4659365714,
-0.3966284394,
-0.3230425417,
-0.1134889126,
0.6139368415,
0.7934639454,
-0.082096979,
0.0755344182,
0.0269809775,
0.4199390709,
-0.9548769593,
-0.1199356914,
-0.9391927719,
0.2727701664,
-0.2213281542,
0.1141604856,
-0.5215399265,
-0.1961029619,
-0.3154018223,
-0.3199582696,
0.3474569023,
0.080865249,
0.662328124,
-0.025201926,
-0.0340746604,
-0.2480246872,
-0.3103259802,
0.7148570418,
-0.655223608,
0.8231906891,
0.4829846621,
0.1415913701,
-0.3299485743,
-0.3852913678,
-0.512784481,
-0.4063122272,
0.0212928187,
-0.3840348721,
-0.5090457201,
0.201367259,
0.2145026773,
0.1206367463,
-0.710855186,
0.2777727246,
-0.0964381844,
-0.3018943071,
0.3715242147,
0.1913487464,
0.5622614026,
0.0189128611,
-0.1392298192,
-0.1378859878,
-0.5473586917,
-0.1982147545,
0.4189594686,
0.5455104113,
-0.2877342403,
0.5541148782,
-0.0690735728,
0.5130953789,
-0.1118176356,
0.2959286273,
-0.0421717539,
-0.3072550297,
-0.0816538483,
0.1293454766,
0.6680341363,
0.0314127728,
0.3383792639,
-0.71833992,
-0.5877854824,
0.1063935459,
0.3186666965,
-0.7246831059,
0.1788529754,
0.5047921538,
-0.1369636953,
-0.8236241937,
-0.1525272429,
-0.8682959676,
-0.3255474567,
0.5920621157,
0.6274960637,
-0.6001119614,
-0.2949051857,
0.1309529543,
-0.1029607505,
0.3719080985,
0.0456990413,
-1.1945118904,
0.5749906898,
1.0781755447,
0.9935743809,
0.2554009557,
-0.3789117932,
-0.9491577148,
0.2794050574,
-0.6976462603,
0.3902696669,
-0.60542804,
-0.4837516248,
0.1815599501,
-0.1908575147,
-0.1057213843,
-0.2404617369,
-0.1007699966,
-0.7909293771,
-0.0242616199,
0.10075555,
-0.366930604,
-0.0692001209,
0.4743105769,
-0.7998912334,
0.5990568399,
0.0010724696,
-0.7620058656,
0.0763171688,
-0.5487390757,
-0.1955609322,
-0.0661264881,
-0.0369297266,
-0.2833484411,
0.385946095,
0.2898833454,
0.1508411765,
-0.0633320138,
0.0446300581,
-0.4454316497,
-0.2232339084,
0.425154835,
-0.2280977815,
1.1946825981,
-0.0044726999,
-0.395488888,
-0.0359488204,
-0.71852386,
0.0545823649,
0.1083107516,
0.0344610102,
-0.4713928998,
-0.2482449561,
-0.0485064164,
0.2230114341,
0.0084724324,
-0.8728288412,
0.1468473524,
-0.9980945587,
-0.0807909891,
0.7449035645,
0.11001876,
0.4052414,
-0.179402411,
0.535295248,
-0.1257854104,
0.3148447275,
-0.1229815558,
-0.4233234227,
-0.5471917391,
-0.2735216022,
0.46245116,
0.5716220737,
-0.7451279759,
0.1570323855,
-0.1434841901,
-0.5856220126,
-0.3139229119,
0.3243923485,
0.7668147087,
0.1567776948,
0.2578322589,
-0.2759124041,
-0.1505475789,
-0.5839512348,
-0.8552051187,
0.036385417,
-0.1663803011,
-0.128611207,
0.7189308405,
-0.3455038667,
0.8499796391,
-0.3257699013,
-0.3506717682,
-0.3005958498,
-0.0389831103,
0.0405395404,
0.6844479442,
0.6350905299,
-0.2777697444,
-0.1905545294,
-0.2527986169,
-0.6179021597,
-0.2505716681,
-0.0249913093,
-0.0030472262,
0.2870151103,
0.5124050975,
-0.520809412,
0.7660650015,
0.6719481349,
-0.4941592813,
0.4163637161,
0.0516365319,
-0.3264360726,
-1.0330392122,
0.0791583881,
-0.4232660532,
-0.1071362048,
-1.0700399876,
0.5807725787,
0.3084871173,
-0.5969631076,
-0.6607717276,
0.932649374,
-0.1485149115,
-0.0076064751,
0.0459808446,
-0.0138730565,
-0.2058983892,
0.6768308282,
-0.231595397,
0.4959668219,
0.5002222061,
-0.3386240005,
0.2578820288,
0.1095859483,
-0.1972631663,
0.0496066883,
-0.5613282919,
0.5605851412,
0.1200750843,
0.0456709787,
-0.9293643236,
-0.005486059,
0.4856863022,
-0.7486120462,
0.4912800193,
-0.1251116991,
-0.8308568597,
0.2614384592,
-0.6005213261,
0.2610086799,
0.2416100651,
-0.6705362201,
0.7236335874,
0.0409594886,
0.1895849258,
-0.7052317262,
-0.8373286128,
0.4219817519,
0.2458259314,
-0.5566138625,
-0.0481262356,
0.0154815633,
-0.3474801183,
-0.2548493147,
-0.0650789216,
-0.2676216364,
0.456771642,
0.2788122892,
0.0277428795,
0.0854814649,
0.1017096564,
-0.0199416578,
-0.3436267972,
0.0673160851,
-0.5952913761,
0.6114855409,
0.0275785569,
-0.444193393,
-0.6126820445,
0.7358894348,
0.3652347028,
-0.2323687524,
1.1003004313,
0.2565738559,
-0.5522016883,
-0.2865422368,
-0.5195516348,
-0.3816740513,
-0.4991435111,
0.4924510717,
-0.2567533851,
-0.7345530391,
0.4193437099,
0.3631201982,
0.4152158201,
0.0212283656,
0.3664446175,
0.3903707266,
1.1069492102,
0.8433968425,
-0.1909808367,
0.3762948811,
-0.1465782225,
0.1408947855,
-0.2402233481,
-0.034621913,
-0.5617645383,
0.0759623051,
-0.4856204689,
-0.1143213063,
0.0797158107,
-0.2168971747,
-0.1312906444,
0.2168759555,
-0.019574903,
0.4632939398,
0.2129145563,
0.1094990447,
0.2173722982,
0.1933771372,
-0.5025877357,
0.0506657362,
-0.645300746,
-0.1260348856,
1.212225914,
0.4057702422,
1.0512803793,
0.3744024038,
0.9335425496,
0.0669580773,
0.0123806521,
-0.6800330877,
0.6031054258,
-0.0669210777,
-0.6944398284,
-0.1284804642,
-0.2846500874,
-0.9387756586,
0.1400453001,
-0.2945759892,
-0.9271967411,
0.1657131612,
0.2735865414,
-0.4277374148,
0.7312778234,
-0.7483115196,
0.8078759313,
-0.3049005866,
-0.3737596571,
-0.4086041152,
-0.4996566772,
0.3135618567,
-0.5366354585,
0.5153914094,
0.213508293,
-0.1723029315,
0.5960215926,
-0.7579380274,
1.1919907331,
-0.2902279794,
-0.2812770307,
-0.2956029177,
0.7899186611,
0.4588375986,
0.1576119065,
0.0712956861,
0.622816503,
-0.0427298136,
-0.5632529259,
-0.6319314837,
0.4742609262,
-0.6502246857,
-0.8449070454,
-0.553987205,
-0.3840464652,
-0.3082558215,
0.2019162923,
0.1306594163,
0.4968650937,
-0.0748110339,
-0.0290144961,
0.5886549354,
-0.4910855293,
0.4811648428,
0.5193927288,
-0.3397328556,
-0.4503338039,
0.8656557798,
-0.152076751,
0.5965182185,
0.5058767796,
0.2935090363,
0.1560143232,
-0.4175057113,
-0.2514162958,
0.2609741092,
-0.529730916,
-0.1974322796,
-0.6770548224,
-0.2956605554,
-0.5867603421,
-0.1889199317,
-0.6390367746,
-0.6388260722,
-0.1103565916,
0.1465290189,
0.3195206225,
0.6707053185,
-0.1065646335,
0.3442270756,
-0.9510714412,
0.2147381902,
0.5719745755,
0.4906955361,
0.1874520779,
-0.4127644598,
-0.4413666427,
0.070774354,
-0.0588708371,
-1.0861210823,
0.602766037,
0.2494274229,
0.3232077956,
0.2829571962,
-0.1935359687,
0.3001671433,
-0.6208972931,
0.7633185387,
0.1339690387,
-1.1189231873,
0.5724458098,
-0.1399820447,
0.3939453959,
0.3350414038,
0.1194365919,
-0.7609169483,
-0.7381941676,
-0.5873507857,
-0.6828287244,
0.6379032731,
0.2863538861,
0.3269837797,
0.2350119948,
0.4075119793,
0.1600271761,
0.3527912498,
-0.6558689475,
0.0916396528,
-0.4681777954,
-0.0697018206,
-0.0838074759,
-0.2817662358,
-0.0555435866,
0.0140737668,
0.461605221,
0.0332158543,
0.106526494,
-0.1384004354,
-0.5666800737,
-0.0442667827,
0.3567298353,
0.4947653413,
0.3801113069,
-0.0542532615,
0.080587402,
0.4171850085,
-0.6770466566,
-0.0528268293,
-0.0396022946,
-0.1266362667,
0.0610639937,
0.5831242204,
0.3843791783,
0.672655046,
-0.6543547511,
0.7191221118,
-0.3036822081,
-0.1779545099,
-0.4363248348,
0.1899804473,
-0.2389683127,
0.2776444554,
0.124386549,
-0.2213329673,
-0.2352503985,
-0.4426461756,
0.1536748558,
0.747956574,
-0.4781062603,
-0.5228429437,
0.5428633094,
-0.2345063239,
-0.5064598918,
0.5726796389,
0.1777821183,
-0.7125374675,
0.2245433778,
0.5602841377,
1.2631528378,
-0.5036296248,
-0.1794677228,
0.0243304744,
0.7000715733,
0.3426302075,
0.1206867248,
-0.276728332,
-0.7066368461,
0.0709042847,
-0.6421117783,
-0.423397243,
0.0876758546,
-0.304704845,
0.205753386,
-0.9488276839,
0.3374339938,
-0.1270256937,
-0.1776224375,
-0.332486093,
-0.0295024049,
0.2786839306,
1.1969354153,
-0.7025879025,
1.0751695633,
0.197676599,
-0.2938432992,
-0.6616585255,
0.1062363014,
0.129379794,
-0.8846617341,
0.8432564735,
0.0460378379,
-0.3255239129,
-0.0967206135,
-0.9047808647,
-0.7981947064,
0.5069280267,
0.4623522758,
-0.3281719387,
-0.3493979275,
0.3413036168,
0.2858777046,
-0.1510992944,
-0.2644987106,
0.4051080346,
0.1197646931,
-0.0778094009,
-0.7738275528,
0.1142769158,
-0.1989909261,
0.0829994753,
0.2169711441,
-0.376149267,
0.9709849954,
-0.137867555,
-0.2702061236,
0.1417557895,
0.5314427018,
0.2731176019,
-0.0123159559,
0.6086140275,
0.6305071712,
0.2704643607,
0.301312089,
0.9388795495,
-0.4715970755,
0.2583678663,
1.0138303041,
-0.1627855897,
0.8239849806,
0.521166563,
0.3827930093,
0.4240096509,
0.1501028836,
-0.0236726385,
0.5445177555,
0.0886926353,
-0.2628515065,
-0.1201383546,
0.2536486685,
-0.3097299337,
0.5457322598,
0.7221324444,
-0.1964195371,
-0.6527300477,
0.2902123928,
0.4931277037,
-0.0288256425,
-0.4092576206,
0.7202704549,
0.0669008568,
-0.2014552504,
0.8858214021,
0.1391347051,
0.6134520769,
-0.9101936817,
0.0592986532,
-0.2988420725,
0.3139590919,
-0.1714465022,
-0.4132873416,
0.2738936543,
0.2542062104,
0.298941195,
-0.1745199114,
0.5547158718,
-0.2598562241,
-0.4059837759,
0.5682092905,
0.1758814454,
-0.0232772697,
-0.1706132293,
-0.6268507838,
-0.0010012607,
-0.1888504326,
-0.1692377776,
0.491992116,
0.0605843887,
-0.0805791244,
0.6298778057,
0.7140916586,
0.2271990776,
0.2612263858,
-0.013884211,
1.1007077694,
-0.8691706061,
-0.8395672441,
-0.9461278915,
0.0664703026,
0.1309978068,
0.0936518013,
0.8961179256,
0.5097474456,
0.8194322586,
0.2105356008,
0.4811781645,
0.3728681505,
0.4822821319,
-0.5746133327,
1.1390855312,
-0.6081625223,
0.3832146525,
-0.4788013995,
-0.3694683909,
-0.5970954299,
0.1518495083,
-0.2111821324,
0.065560326,
0.6496415138,
1.2544602156,
0.0258338619,
0.1604445428,
0.5024653673,
0.451797843,
0.5428093672,
0.6318367124,
0.6301288605,
-0.3466908634,
0.6686992049,
-0.4661381841,
-0.3822740018,
-0.1598927826,
-0.7128348947,
-1.3155217171,
-0.2639468014,
-0.0102971643,
-0.7555346489,
0.5971069932,
0.9930025935,
0.3951872587,
-0.9735596776,
-0.4111483991,
-0.0063496004,
0.2412249148,
-0.1484893113,
-0.1257033348,
0.2337107658,
-0.5175205469,
-0.2224029154,
0.345893383,
0.1373448074,
-0.0342537537,
-0.263363719,
0.2905872166,
-0.3105520904,
0.1375623494,
0.2685847282,
0.4943662584,
-0.5452417731,
-0.4602385163,
-0.1118309572,
-0.1139590219,
-0.1897671521,
0.8500746489,
-0.8867900372,
0.56425488,
0.2232156545,
0.5532581806,
0.2424858809,
-0.5935130715,
0.5078271031,
-1.1397845745,
0.6257140636,
0.2357594669,
0.1550104916,
0.1779130995,
-0.3638007939,
0.0693099052,
0.3314903378,
-0.0402801372,
-0.9643297791,
0.2942188382,
-0.4993745983,
-0.540132165,
1.0764628649,
0.1532629877,
-0.7480980158,
-0.274838239,
0.139182657,
0.1450553536,
-0.4406856,
0.811747551,
0.4563711584,
0.4414787292,
0.062041387,
-0.6284900904,
0.5576425195,
0.340283215,
-0.3190477788,
0.232759133,
0.1127091646,
0.4998063445,
0.0695872381,
0.1416672319,
-0.3491675556,
0.5292860866,
0.2543390095,
0.0999667197,
-0.1333081275,
-0.2034244239,
-0.9073691368,
0.4077024162,
-0.0517691001,
-0.2683880925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04084v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04084v2 | Reception Reader: Exploring Text Reuse in Early Modern British Publications | 2023-02-08T14:37:35 | 2023-04-18T13:41:20 | David Rosson, Eetu Mäkelä, Ville Vaara, Ananth Mahadevan, Yann Ryan, Mikko Tolonen | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.HC, J.5 | The Reception Reader is a web tool for studying text reuse in the Early
English Books Online (EEBO-TCP) and Eighteenth Century Collections Online
(ECCO) data. Users can: 1) explore a visual overview of the reception of a
work, or its incoming connections, across time based on shared text segments,
2) interactively survey the details of connected documents, and 3) examine the
context of reused text for "close reading". We show examples of how the tool
streamlines research and exploration tasks, and discuss the utility and
limitations of the user interface along with its current data sources. | [
-0.7897898555,
-0.3660574257,
0.5534482598,
-0.1531170905,
-0.4956661761,
-0.3047758937,
0.218586877,
-0.8998352885,
0.534694612,
0.6079168916,
-0.608556509,
-0.4832670093,
-0.2423319072,
0.5266769528,
-0.6158997416,
0.3329933286,
-0.0884732455,
-0.268032819,
-0.3603219986,
-0.2560020983,
-0.1256138533,
-0.202045992,
-0.8255645037,
-0.4868760407,
0.6078518033,
0.6207929254,
0.4375556409,
0.1869169623,
0.6114988923,
0.343732208,
-0.3527110219,
0.1993897855,
-0.6264764071,
0.5359013677,
-0.2973636091,
-0.6058116555,
-0.2101775706,
-0.0464505516,
0.5763533115,
0.879950881,
-0.1536979079,
-0.0176626872,
0.0934262574,
0.634678483,
-0.6722610593,
-0.1184573621,
-0.2558434904,
0.0720782205,
-0.4760272205,
-0.6515868306,
-0.9107353687,
-0.3818960488,
0.2773525417,
-0.7936214209,
0.4285701215,
0.2911879718,
0.5590894222,
-0.4565529823,
-0.9212269187,
-0.7196382284,
-0.6264736652,
0.743573606,
-0.3499277234,
0.6647174358,
0.630879283,
0.4267094135,
-0.2182155997,
-0.9923793077,
-0.5591009855,
-0.0689066574,
-0.4835478365,
0.3230546415,
-0.0647621602,
-0.0339070484,
0.0991745666,
0.3259553015,
-0.3616707325,
-0.4947179556,
-0.4418498576,
-0.2052236944,
0.4932788312,
0.3383108675,
0.4711547494,
-0.2921502888,
-0.0399428494,
0.1309133321,
-0.7506130338,
0.0565043055,
0.3391826749,
-0.1042443514,
0.0526234768,
0.5129365325,
-0.0113063697,
0.8967200518,
-0.0857364908,
0.2330460399,
0.1293197274,
-0.3142529726,
0.1377821863,
-0.0119867465,
0.3272069395,
0.6932142377,
-0.0548950024,
0.0584448166,
-0.0823099539,
-0.4619023204,
0.1817085892,
-0.6074268818,
-0.2352704257,
0.0647204146,
-0.9230656028,
-0.0006939825,
0.0622291714,
-0.5946316719,
-0.2972361445,
-0.1673425585,
-0.1840195656,
-0.3146397769,
-0.1525778621,
0.1467167586,
-0.6799112558,
0.5285782814,
0.5071576238,
-0.983574748,
0.3343144953,
0.3945388198,
1.050144434,
0.03688192,
-0.2257127166,
-0.1283924282,
0.3803379536,
0.0547801405,
1.0914894342,
-0.5095104575,
-1.0862952471,
0.2778787911,
0.6032117605,
0.4490037858,
-0.0437555723,
0.8623615503,
-0.72923702,
0.5901178718,
-0.5808878541,
-0.4684219956,
-0.2416840643,
0.3234320879,
-1.1033730507,
0.7958374023,
0.1226206869,
-1.0762685537,
0.4496597052,
-0.4208723903,
-0.4025784731,
0.0857941508,
0.1016867086,
-0.0675079599,
0.3147826493,
0.0771664381,
0.1057761461,
0.1368620098,
-0.6835852265,
-0.256475687,
-0.5265408158,
0.1029064581,
-0.1933129877,
1.071287632,
0.5944344997,
0.1330801696,
-0.4606021941,
-0.8209412098,
-0.3237090707,
0.0805474594,
-0.4269270003,
-0.9847661853,
0.4577710032,
0.399471879,
-0.4782421887,
0.2032274008,
-0.8794208169,
0.4733599424,
-0.3669206798,
0.5129454732,
0.2299149185,
0.1890548021,
0.2366877645,
-0.5571013093,
0.5888807178,
-0.162532106,
-0.0395889543,
-0.7339161634,
-0.6791964173,
-0.3998048306,
0.0712348968,
0.1312621385,
0.1730864793,
-0.6174976826,
-0.1168419644,
0.0188731756,
-0.5082255602,
-0.6336663365,
-0.2447699606,
-0.0507755205,
0.2013041824,
0.2276031375,
-0.3586000204,
-0.4062541723,
-0.5952082276,
-0.4442329407,
-0.0065731541,
-0.166244477,
0.4792923331,
0.2133993506,
-0.4841173291,
0.7100175023,
-0.4463528991,
-0.1176356301,
-0.2315168828,
0.3145499527,
0.1199019104,
0.1085960642,
0.4866289496,
-0.8470166326,
-0.5506813526,
0.2444250882,
-0.5244308114,
-0.4785033166,
-0.3115108609,
-0.2927446961,
-0.0156753268,
0.6055952311,
-0.108614482,
0.3527075946,
0.4716296792,
-0.718526125,
0.344778955,
-0.057201609,
0.6247645617,
-1.2522424459,
0.425362438,
-0.2375774831,
-0.6454583406,
-0.3682458103,
0.2242617905,
0.1870165169,
-0.1503707469,
-0.5181561708,
0.6143991351,
-1.0449142456,
0.0166670512,
-0.4753323197,
0.6737594604,
0.4727367759,
-0.4818909466,
0.2786971033,
0.5633507967,
0.0006006826,
-0.447730571,
0.198172003,
0.7352223992,
-0.0471620522,
0.7442504168,
-0.4770293832,
0.3176579773,
-0.4311329126,
0.0424205922,
-1.468616128,
-0.0579521433,
-0.0346408077,
-0.6827533841,
0.0645866543,
-0.1581911445,
0.2615272403,
-0.1610850245,
-0.4892372191,
0.6010810733,
0.158847779,
-0.7419050336,
0.8985210657,
0.279078573,
-0.3369163871,
-0.5715811253,
-0.8996421099,
-0.1044265479,
0.215377003,
-0.6218634844,
0.1800234467,
0.1431357116,
-0.3954199553,
0.1661867201,
-0.049116388,
-0.0510985218,
-0.1023533493,
0.2160801888,
-0.0234435424,
0.1104551256,
-0.2598386109,
0.1727632731,
-0.1185144708,
0.0971017256,
0.0925131217,
0.6075913906,
0.2992606759,
-0.3858502507,
-0.6829177141,
0.8021590114,
0.468359828,
0.3079813421,
0.5252428055,
0.0402848683,
-0.2860122323,
-0.1732073724,
-0.4504721463,
-0.1577910483,
-0.5707248449,
-0.0987636968,
-0.6039237976,
-0.5353616476,
0.6025475264,
-0.0413592309,
0.582318902,
0.400739193,
0.21230793,
-0.5373075008,
0.4653536975,
0.705033958,
0.1894743741,
0.7304521799,
-0.1594878137,
-0.0543548279,
-0.8629834056,
-0.6350779533,
-0.9454838037,
-0.4892448485,
-0.2080822736,
0.0349689946,
-0.1434829533,
0.0747837201,
0.2907192409,
0.4547535479,
-0.5478378534,
0.6885372996,
0.4928635061,
0.1885533035,
0.8612061143,
0.0706461444,
-0.0454551466,
-0.1220907345,
-0.0640128627,
-0.6560314298,
1.2775142193,
0.0725245699,
1.01118505,
0.3181236684,
0.9579803944,
0.6975451112,
0.4713663161,
-1.0365941525,
0.5772176385,
0.2854257524,
-0.6509703994,
-0.0513807088,
-0.2645459473,
-1.554141283,
0.2900505066,
0.141343236,
-0.4503293335,
0.617387116,
0.369696945,
0.1235354915,
0.1667620242,
-0.570708096,
0.5011538863,
0.1247024536,
-0.3115594089,
-0.422718823,
-0.2487902343,
0.1071154326,
0.312674433,
0.1725606769,
0.5737168789,
-0.1643058062,
0.7845275998,
-0.2154383063,
0.5244878531,
-0.0132301385,
-0.0498236082,
0.464926064,
0.6357406974,
0.5654975176,
-0.0757770464,
-0.1610215753,
-0.1254661977,
0.7209635377,
-0.5160699487,
-0.142204389,
0.5448887944,
-0.6527619958,
-0.3928992748,
-0.9017444849,
-0.0825705677,
-0.0119374441,
0.5260357857,
0.1759328842,
0.6438871622,
-0.4579878449,
0.5622674227,
0.3434855938,
0.0169414431,
0.4552816749,
0.7231226563,
-0.4838381708,
-0.1877287477,
0.2484822571,
-0.089298062,
0.3231254518,
0.6613405347,
-0.0078933882,
-0.774095118,
-0.7521137595,
-0.0671828464,
0.1664544195,
-0.8048088551,
0.3730893433,
-0.5430521965,
0.2910929024,
-0.0119200619,
-0.6141644716,
0.1546731442,
-0.1769567132,
-0.2593311965,
-0.0824688077,
0.1903259158,
0.7655126452,
-0.0772654638,
0.7925589085,
-0.8147978187,
0.297552526,
0.0869614705,
0.4251463413,
-0.1606886387,
-0.2051490098,
-0.1665992141,
-0.2352076322,
-0.3407437205,
-1.5289299488,
0.2892481685,
-0.0243219752,
0.5883770585,
0.7223315835,
-0.1348609626,
0.080016084,
-0.3212179542,
0.9693900943,
0.2521861792,
-0.7591798306,
0.4576536417,
-0.6287225485,
0.3537578583,
0.8793886304,
0.9240263104,
-1.1491231918,
0.0110740699,
-0.3860880136,
-0.9666341543,
0.4408342242,
-0.1477335095,
-0.1985142529,
-0.2201175243,
0.3399091959,
0.354983151,
0.2374688536,
-0.6689644456,
-0.1564704031,
-0.0501175895,
-0.0880321041,
0.0152007714,
-0.4579553008,
-0.1545234472,
-0.1349729896,
0.5680983663,
0.1452321261,
0.4157990515,
0.5711854696,
-0.4594144523,
-0.1390662342,
0.1977245808,
0.0303885359,
0.9262027144,
-0.4407174885,
0.2200240791,
-0.1572803557,
-1.1638801098,
0.2412102669,
-0.1242555752,
-0.5425394773,
0.3093235493,
0.4176149666,
0.1460664272,
0.076530613,
-0.4901582897,
0.1473284662,
-0.474527061,
-0.0856308416,
-0.484305948,
-0.1773028821,
0.2616552711,
0.0092820171,
0.4039105177,
-0.2143890113,
0.6662365198,
-0.9588803649,
0.4333889186,
0.3608316183,
-0.0370931774,
-0.1629926264,
0.7874029875,
0.7906864882,
-0.6436693072,
0.6472846866,
-0.2931702435,
-0.0596278198,
0.1663477272,
0.6896603107,
0.7674949169,
-0.0525546148,
0.3106301725,
0.1226292327,
0.3412868679,
0.1807236373,
0.7800984383,
-0.1823976636,
-0.5507457256,
-0.1117196083,
-0.4810219705,
-0.7614363432,
-0.1024598852,
-0.7571445107,
0.2179370224,
-0.2256304175,
-0.4187344015,
-0.0761398152,
0.1665198654,
-0.9615774751,
-0.0026472642,
0.0668921098,
1.1878626347,
-0.765111506,
0.3785372674,
0.8069173098,
-0.254152298,
-0.2814460695,
-0.0068969387,
0.2268461138,
-0.5592047572,
0.2167731673,
0.0811399147,
-0.5179550052,
0.3863825202,
-0.1553899348,
-0.5241366625,
1.0657590628,
-0.3204698265,
-1.3114283085,
0.1777506918,
-0.0386695452,
0.335598737,
0.1454164386,
1.1076871157,
0.4620994031,
0.4677502811,
-0.0626051202,
-0.5924050808,
0.0070073102,
-0.2164693177,
-0.3764835,
0.6239578128,
-0.6111264825,
0.325696528,
0.2255926132,
-0.4797001183,
0.2085127383,
0.6268416643,
-0.1224617511,
0.5934009552,
0.4196861982,
0.6383310556,
0.8404350281,
-0.367320478,
0.9382551312,
-0.1075459644,
0.4731663167,
0.6454752684,
-0.179147616,
1.0186929703,
0.6983323693,
-0.4776443243,
0.6838299632,
0.8017506599,
0.2339164913,
0.5263904929,
0.0074068429,
-0.5766287446,
0.2515875697,
-0.0353201367,
-0.5541982651,
-0.071624741,
0.1799426824,
-0.2350438833,
-0.3038072288,
0.043210268,
-0.319674015,
0.157402426,
-0.389138788,
0.6870537996,
0.2174465358,
-0.5294775963,
0.259003222,
-0.1950197369,
0.5709693432,
-0.7532895803,
0.0610268041,
-0.5046195388,
0.1020984352,
-0.4297318459,
-1.1296819448,
0.4182958901,
-0.3989491761,
-0.1029011905,
-0.1686724126,
0.768473804,
-0.1503006071,
-0.1548051238,
0.4737879634,
0.5358536839,
0.4929566085,
0.3172785342,
-0.3826147914,
0.302108109,
0.2221047878,
-0.8994031549,
0.022776762,
0.3645058572,
0.3020081222,
0.6140992045,
0.4824303389,
0.3170836568,
-0.0259659961,
0.1632351279,
0.5110553503,
-1.2188284397,
-0.6333621144,
-0.5568082333,
0.5166056752,
-0.2007129639,
-0.4678172767,
0.8461474776,
0.6565079093,
0.9602607489,
-0.0508317947,
1.0233187675,
-0.3148246706,
0.5555204749,
-0.2226334661,
0.6776614189,
-0.6848977804,
-0.0527356006,
-0.1442274153,
-1.0561084747,
0.0626273751,
0.7278004289,
-0.2602651119,
-0.2612685561,
1.0072865486,
0.5349366069,
-0.3188238442,
0.4815752804,
0.0781438053,
-0.0324427038,
0.3304455578,
0.2771657407,
1.0436606407,
-0.1232519373,
0.3830123544,
0.0629008189,
-0.2488090396,
-0.4517264664,
-0.7290236354,
-0.9740333557,
-0.6286413074,
0.0901419222,
-0.5666549206,
0.2124681622,
0.6910349727,
0.3090786338,
-0.7547084093,
-0.2227540016,
0.070429638,
-0.246058166,
-0.1127790734,
-0.2390941978,
0.3624041378,
0.0607692637,
-0.998462975,
0.3807012737,
-0.0468586199,
0.0837048665,
-0.3217352331,
0.2614896894,
-0.1979680359,
0.0340214409,
0.5808646679,
0.6068525314,
-0.0441653095,
-0.1450949609,
-0.0547742136,
0.0798892453,
-0.090166904,
1.1061025858,
-0.6025648713,
0.9051440358,
1.0795686245,
0.6607425809,
0.8598727584,
0.2811840773,
0.5319864154,
-0.4868946075,
0.4105342329,
0.4312408864,
0.7169183493,
0.0966214612,
-0.444414854,
0.2693538368,
0.4659008384,
-0.7764616609,
-0.7684934139,
0.2403400689,
-1.3065007925,
-0.3154732883,
0.7267093658,
0.0314330906,
-0.3648145497,
-0.5479722023,
-0.7563350797,
-0.0702979788,
-0.6336473227,
0.7525178194,
1.091979146,
-0.000314723,
-0.3885746896,
-0.8688314557,
0.2519215345,
0.2774330974,
-0.7594078183,
-0.2938682735,
0.7144596577,
0.4462344944,
0.0731167793,
0.8866852522,
-0.1017657518,
0.1222723648,
0.2795797288,
0.1071456969,
-0.150811553,
-0.5003912449,
0.0973636806,
0.3155962229,
0.1332036108,
-0.1682926118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04054v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04054v7 | Towards Inferential Reproducibility of Machine Learning Research | 2023-02-08T13:47:00 | 2023-10-09T15:05:36 | Michael Hagmann, Philipp Meier, Stefan Riezler | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.AP, stat.ML | Reliability of machine learning evaluation -- the consistency of observed
evaluation scores across replicated model training runs -- is affected by
several sources of nondeterminism which can be regarded as measurement noise.
Current tendencies to remove noise in order to enforce reproducibility of
research results neglect inherent nondeterminism at the implementation level
and disregard crucial interaction effects between algorithmic noise factors and
data properties. This limits the scope of conclusions that can be drawn from
such experiments. Instead of removing noise, we propose to incorporate several
sources of variance, including their interaction with data properties, into an
analysis of significance and reliability of machine learning evaluation, with
the aim to draw inferences beyond particular instances of trained models. We
show how to use linear mixed effects models (LMEMs) to analyze performance
evaluation scores, and to conduct statistical inference with a generalized
likelihood ratio test (GLRT). This allows us to incorporate arbitrary sources
of noise like meta-parameter variations into statistical significance testing,
and to assess performance differences conditional on data properties.
Furthermore, a variance component analysis (VCA) enables the analysis of the
contribution of noise sources to overall variance and the computation of a
reliability coefficient by the ratio of substantial to total variance. | [
-0.2486328185,
-0.9544731379,
0.43889153,
0.1623680741,
-0.130951941,
-0.0605832227,
-0.1148095801,
-0.4668063521,
0.0769501626,
0.4143028855,
-0.3884285986,
-0.1081806496,
-0.464743644,
-0.1620200127,
-0.5741524696,
0.8986464739,
-0.191062659,
0.5563814044,
-0.7093791366,
-0.2190529704,
-0.2112015337,
-0.6015544534,
-0.1809560508,
-0.4675891697,
0.4785394073,
0.1976860315,
0.7257052064,
0.4149226546,
0.7354158759,
0.1946420223,
0.0980950296,
0.2577798069,
-0.3633445501,
0.2729942203,
-0.2649793625,
-0.5198532343,
-0.301525116,
0.2475514263,
0.9416852593,
0.7955651283,
0.052207619,
0.0512725264,
0.4305675328,
0.579834938,
-0.5703253746,
0.0523767211,
-0.4330746531,
0.1534072161,
0.0479713157,
-0.2841128409,
-0.5141826272,
-0.4852212965,
-0.1069912463,
-0.3425343037,
0.5203163028,
-0.2994087338,
0.8000748754,
0.4756655097,
-0.0576270521,
-0.2414834648,
-0.9917405844,
1.106870532,
-0.7188219428,
0.5693231821,
0.64987427,
0.3233022392,
-0.3701705635,
-0.6353199482,
-0.1165884882,
-0.6955881119,
0.0178223234,
0.1516659558,
0.0146694127,
-0.177207917,
0.244973287,
0.3463922143,
-0.4269619286,
0.1177931279,
-0.3180711567,
-0.0642617941,
0.5479542017,
0.0541536771,
0.0422932133,
0.3664121628,
-0.0617071278,
0.0574302822,
-0.3726144433,
0.1201612502,
0.5380929112,
0.3623413444,
0.2165377438,
0.6423322558,
0.0861761048,
0.3968507051,
-0.0526745953,
-0.328597784,
0.459045887,
-0.406232208,
-0.4227458835,
-0.4958406687,
0.5693670511,
-0.0930756629,
-0.2006940842,
-0.4925850332,
-0.1189366207,
-0.1154916957,
0.5044930577,
-0.7938073277,
-0.1335644573,
0.2131605744,
-0.80779773,
-0.437576592,
0.2748446763,
-0.7995567918,
-0.1275174171,
-0.5425471067,
0.6736140251,
-0.4210351706,
-0.4327826202,
-0.2143478096,
-0.2764577866,
-0.0445809364,
0.2243072689,
-0.4542370141,
0.2020037919,
0.6127767563,
0.6293045878,
-0.3590165675,
-0.4666954875,
-0.4424260855,
-0.3512941897,
-0.3952859342,
0.1097165719,
-0.6868026853,
-0.5509707332,
-0.3702040315,
0.0498317555,
-0.2995279729,
-0.6976020336,
0.6695892811,
-0.355043143,
0.2730973065,
-0.0794983134,
-0.9851713777,
-0.3534047902,
-0.0294281915,
-0.5111862421,
1.2254607677,
0.4185012877,
-0.6207997799,
0.5280900002,
-0.6066595316,
-0.3637812436,
-0.5410203934,
-0.1387956887,
-1.1991971731,
0.3814690113,
-0.0012755786,
0.3398794234,
-0.0408236496,
0.4534116685,
-0.7431612611,
-0.5815054178,
0.5420306325,
-0.7218823433,
0.6368422508,
0.1270873845,
-0.6569561362,
-0.003261504,
-1.2548029423,
0.1601099819,
-0.1853563637,
-0.1514271051,
-0.2238370776,
0.0850476548,
-0.3978978992,
0.1670580953,
-0.1394920349,
-0.2456250191,
-0.1209473833,
0.0660022795,
0.1492762417,
0.6043637991,
0.1788596958,
0.3742654324,
-0.4356020093,
0.4045096338,
0.241151914,
0.3785579801,
0.2097313255,
-0.5643681288,
-0.6649753451,
-0.6748444438,
0.439838171,
0.1087375209,
-0.4724647403,
0.2041119039,
0.1630206853,
-0.5723992586,
-0.6607279181,
0.2274698168,
0.2154550105,
0.6531166434,
0.4485401809,
-0.2832430005,
-0.7569931149,
-0.8522822857,
-0.1369808912,
-0.0995153412,
-0.1395775676,
0.1972344369,
0.870764792,
-0.3949553967,
0.8368051052,
0.3892430067,
0.3651765585,
0.1629113704,
0.3087996244,
0.0589301251,
0.6852197051,
0.5056835413,
-0.269592911,
-0.0740279555,
-0.1486842185,
-1.0623115301,
0.0361321196,
0.0638122186,
0.0193283167,
0.1149917841,
0.3543282747,
-0.2142405659,
0.6433489919,
0.403662473,
0.0816664547,
0.8333486915,
-0.1904188693,
0.4374530017,
-0.3707201183,
0.2340916991,
-0.0212083012,
-0.099087894,
-0.3678337038,
-0.1135157868,
-0.1054991558,
-0.0585219972,
0.0739845186,
0.1043011621,
0.0094252573,
-0.4882445633,
-0.383518368,
-0.2686244249,
0.1277738065,
0.0952994004,
-0.2509293854,
0.7860426903,
0.3108133972,
-0.6488565207,
-0.0786939636,
-0.4206893742,
-0.2228781283,
0.7593923807,
-0.712325871,
-0.0127864713,
0.027989462,
0.0055691181,
-0.7774008512,
0.089666076,
0.3161131442,
-0.4965490699,
0.1417672038,
0.0027705079,
-0.2757698298,
-0.1876629293,
-0.148906514,
0.11288587,
0.3680739105,
-0.5305187106,
0.2281145304,
-0.0202644616,
0.2433361113,
-0.5623358488,
-0.7085054517,
-0.233694315,
-0.2329235524,
-0.621794641,
-0.0822953358,
-0.1276117116,
-0.4493741095,
0.1122186333,
0.0899694189,
-0.4622005224,
0.5092126727,
0.4911107421,
0.4908227921,
-0.3535242081,
0.3239621818,
-0.2614257336,
0.0999522656,
0.3088524342,
-0.1796553135,
-0.1581617892,
0.1279714555,
-0.7353078723,
-0.6677910089,
0.142426312,
0.5021999478,
0.0926090032,
0.7703052759,
0.7356380224,
-0.1474348903,
-0.4361050427,
-0.1999796331,
-0.4398858547,
-0.3040916324,
0.4596872032,
-0.3892299831,
-0.6383789778,
0.2988787591,
0.0102237323,
0.1671321541,
0.6384789944,
0.397464633,
-0.4518578053,
0.6557683945,
0.4758816361,
-0.1000111178,
0.5068877935,
-0.1087531969,
0.0658329725,
-0.4682472348,
-0.0575516671,
-0.8025544882,
-0.2335036993,
-0.6431775093,
-0.594645083,
0.0623164997,
0.0322001763,
-0.4684922397,
-0.2827824354,
-0.2946844697,
0.2144419551,
0.6170649529,
0.2297981232,
0.4038943648,
0.1721546501,
-0.0586543307,
-0.3294319808,
-0.5187994242,
-0.4229506552,
1.4256783724,
0.6239185929,
0.6403013468,
-0.339643091,
0.5404363275,
0.5051847696,
0.3575211763,
-0.3584422469,
0.0369068794,
0.1081082895,
-0.476106137,
-0.3435595334,
-0.826166451,
-0.6786487103,
0.371935606,
-0.0866419449,
-0.5495861769,
0.2094911635,
-0.0079879817,
0.2792126238,
0.5548757315,
-0.2120050192,
0.4147753119,
-0.1567331851,
-0.5196083188,
-0.3211383522,
-0.4510690868,
0.7217761874,
-0.0946863294,
0.3827723265,
0.2410141081,
0.3151044548,
0.8310512304,
-0.5095240474,
0.8189588785,
-0.2283768952,
0.1021534055,
0.3449008465,
-0.0664414912,
0.7368944883,
-0.2258520275,
-0.394413203,
0.3708884418,
-0.2093400359,
-0.4385556877,
-0.638926208,
0.5292900801,
-1.026683569,
-0.0588221438,
-0.2403752655,
-0.6355581284,
-0.315615356,
-0.1660157889,
0.226100713,
0.0397384465,
-0.3495517075,
0.3678331375,
0.7723351121,
-0.0682992339,
0.0867128074,
0.1994597018,
-0.2371234,
-0.6779525876,
1.1046572924,
0.4332241416,
0.2801763415,
0.0328819752,
0.1495186687,
-0.1174700186,
-0.5883811116,
-0.097159721,
-0.0589701459,
-0.5138394237,
0.242902264,
-0.3601851761,
-0.4961654246,
0.0896849334,
-0.0465370044,
-0.6204339266,
-0.4812388718,
-0.4655664563,
-0.2436817884,
0.0651832297,
0.8922066092,
-0.3612343967,
0.1894036382,
-0.2983134091,
0.3668711782,
0.2698860466,
0.2871508002,
0.111324504,
-0.8630258441,
-0.5012487769,
0.1722892821,
-0.4127165973,
-0.2846750915,
-0.0142555926,
0.0216172095,
0.8242883682,
0.2764954269,
-0.2372235656,
0.5401602983,
-0.0012926169,
0.7633056641,
0.1784608215,
-0.7545833588,
0.3747383058,
-0.0909753591,
-0.5356404185,
0.4322261214,
0.1786317378,
0.2623134553,
-0.6817706823,
-1.0558662415,
-0.5295789242,
0.1019400135,
0.4423260689,
-0.4739612043,
0.3842355311,
0.3407148719,
0.4827493727,
0.2252613008,
-0.3389964402,
-0.3743864298,
-0.4234250188,
0.0615948513,
-0.244705081,
-0.2662792802,
-0.1111546233,
-0.3447619677,
0.9846782088,
0.1119974777,
0.120026879,
0.1111941561,
-0.2144670486,
-0.1609586179,
0.3030509949,
0.6106855869,
1.0929576159,
-0.4366513491,
0.0550861359,
-0.0074683605,
-0.4456441104,
0.3760040998,
-0.1319509894,
-0.5291220546,
0.4408344924,
0.4323635995,
0.4916297793,
0.2183598578,
-0.0371160917,
0.13295044,
-0.0115335183,
-0.4469765127,
-0.1578880847,
0.0612562336,
-0.1774849892,
0.3022405207,
0.2267059684,
0.3614921868,
0.1478603482,
-0.2803304493,
0.6804172993,
0.4940335155,
-0.6898615956,
-0.1705243886,
0.5398467183,
-0.0094696004,
0.0291148033,
0.5570220351,
0.0872982293,
0.0281097274,
0.8646494746,
0.2591687739,
0.8449987769,
-0.2388813496,
0.4121452272,
0.4427586794,
0.4154829085,
-0.1824665517,
0.2551130354,
0.2818370163,
-0.2503114939,
-0.4403800666,
-0.4892430305,
-0.8903931379,
0.1020014212,
-0.8380199075,
-0.1012892574,
-0.3262122869,
-0.1920995265,
0.0316703618,
0.1019375995,
-0.5018268824,
0.3253017366,
-0.3091776669,
0.4430728257,
-0.8502280712,
0.6887136102,
0.0244907569,
-0.4201064408,
-0.4917402565,
-0.2064937949,
-0.0377745852,
-0.5955782533,
0.5423005223,
-0.1503238827,
0.0987589955,
-0.5718954206,
-0.6714351773,
-0.4909942746,
0.8824902773,
0.6174649,
-0.4609736204,
0.6480194926,
0.3166061938,
0.3601804674,
-0.2485978901,
0.5009152293,
0.5698032975,
0.6035152674,
0.0640853047,
-0.7341374159,
-0.1897121966,
0.061826434,
-0.2327511311,
-0.1945342422,
-0.3837878108,
0.9439373612,
-0.1279931813,
0.2636104822,
0.028964743,
0.7276526093,
0.5535997152,
0.6256749034,
0.0964568704,
0.6775586009,
1.3132910728,
0.0067247944,
0.7664205432,
0.1090243608,
0.5108351707,
1.4742195606,
-0.1428377926,
0.5793633461,
0.7321243882,
-0.717838645,
0.3743466437,
0.5982955694,
-0.3317183852,
0.3188382387,
0.5712236762,
-0.1010744944,
-0.0383241139,
-0.0295882616,
-0.6347443461,
0.1388072371,
-0.104092367,
-0.9410483241,
-0.135851264,
0.0548420772,
-0.0779646859,
-0.1470242739,
-0.2080742568,
0.4423609078,
0.1619891524,
-0.2224246562,
0.3988115788,
-0.2407571524,
0.4323518276,
-0.5693512559,
-0.262531966,
-0.2128967345,
0.3866339326,
-0.3507961035,
-0.3795602024,
0.5708405972,
-0.2204414159,
-0.6048350334,
0.1820806861,
0.5321778059,
-0.1100505069,
-0.9499816895,
0.3458620906,
0.6493255496,
0.347746402,
0.0646265373,
-0.4540616274,
0.066021055,
-0.019356519,
-0.3057204187,
0.7581202388,
0.4468043447,
0.2433325201,
0.687112391,
0.7531725764,
0.0303621329,
0.1305220872,
0.069087036,
0.6489629745,
-0.5601237416,
-0.1196434572,
-0.98080796,
0.4917835891,
0.1676895618,
-0.1782717556,
0.8177032471,
0.5083152056,
0.4699091911,
0.0890404284,
1.1668834686,
0.2787134647,
0.4435413182,
-0.3687745929,
0.6901391149,
-0.4654839039,
0.298618108,
-0.2772004604,
-0.498255223,
-0.1581650376,
0.4616661966,
-0.0417966247,
0.1759490669,
0.5037958026,
0.7688271403,
-0.1782333851,
0.3050046563,
0.6678520441,
0.1271773577,
0.4261976779,
0.015565699,
0.8561258912,
-0.4971981049,
0.314709425,
-0.569478631,
-0.1065585092,
-0.2684354782,
-0.7160425186,
-0.7415931821,
-0.2377973199,
-0.4907085598,
-0.6836813092,
0.2285138965,
0.2970148027,
0.5193318129,
-1.0631456375,
-0.3097386062,
-0.06895224,
0.5069767833,
-0.8033644557,
-0.2666947544,
0.5684396625,
-0.6188164353,
-0.3402990103,
0.3414299786,
-0.011636111,
-0.0001130538,
-0.3801057041,
-0.2963371873,
0.1293072253,
-0.0527711734,
0.3666572571,
0.2276873142,
-0.5017552376,
-0.2474417239,
-0.2016070187,
0.004283512,
0.1690561324,
0.6217640638,
-0.4369850159,
0.4725351036,
0.3001658618,
0.692748785,
0.3419211805,
-0.2136894315,
0.6137322187,
-0.421091944,
-0.0075371969,
0.1212062761,
0.4912953079,
0.0631670952,
-0.2965557277,
0.7779855728,
0.4443986416,
-0.9493672252,
-0.8551930189,
-0.3678610027,
-0.4742606878,
-0.2228751183,
0.8246718645,
-0.5469555259,
-0.0886821672,
-0.1864013523,
0.2027271539,
0.2031545192,
-0.1774515361,
0.8429429531,
0.8446009755,
-0.3924912512,
-0.1821478754,
-1.0140584707,
0.2031231523,
0.337700367,
-0.6401680708,
-0.0317310095,
0.2065181285,
0.449326098,
-0.1355418712,
0.3132252693,
-0.293616116,
0.2394523025,
0.3307246864,
0.0281179324,
-0.122556448,
-0.2452555448,
-0.3378706574,
0.4635971487,
0.0482594296,
-0.4824862778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04045v1 | Revisiting Offline Compression: Going Beyond Factorization-based Methods for Transformer Language Models | 2023-02-08T13:36:06 | 2023-02-08T13:36:06 | Mohammadreza Banaei, Klaudia Bałazy, Artur Kasymov, Rémi Lebret, Jacek Tabor, Karl Aberer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent transformer language models achieve outstanding results in many
natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, their enormous size often
makes them impractical on memory-constrained devices, requiring practitioners
to compress them to smaller networks. In this paper, we explore offline
compression methods, meaning computationally-cheap approaches that do not
require further fine-tuning of the compressed model. We challenge the classical
matrix factorization methods by proposing a novel, better-performing
autoencoder-based framework. We perform a comprehensive ablation study of our
approach, examining its different aspects over a diverse set of evaluation
settings. Moreover, we show that enabling collaboration between modules across
layers by compressing certain modules together positively impacts the final
model performance. Experiments on various NLP tasks demonstrate that our
approach significantly outperforms commonly used factorization-based offline
compression methods. | [
-0.8333046436,
-0.5144267678,
0.1715426743,
-0.1486749351,
-0.1470798701,
0.2065149248,
-0.4299502075,
-0.5544104576,
0.2992679477,
0.4199475944,
-0.5715799928,
0.2483678162,
-0.4058869481,
0.2873094678,
-0.4855094254,
0.5479722023,
0.0717441142,
-0.1635496616,
-0.3197936714,
-0.0823493674,
-0.3264196813,
-0.560249567,
-0.7186479568,
-0.6022580266,
0.2438344061,
0.1909329891,
0.8296133876,
0.8345077634,
0.7845136523,
0.447250843,
-0.1588131487,
0.240483135,
-0.4043181539,
-0.0151452823,
0.0764274374,
-0.3925212622,
-0.2215934396,
-0.1875768006,
0.4714241326,
0.9154645801,
-0.4771903157,
0.1784597784,
0.0365907811,
0.9500151873,
-0.6226603985,
-0.0187838823,
-0.4581082463,
0.181789875,
0.2225831449,
-0.3121608198,
-0.585541904,
-0.231796816,
-0.0341980644,
-0.1752399504,
0.5810752511,
0.2703079879,
0.7594335675,
0.7048996091,
-0.238325879,
-0.2853218615,
-1.2037367821,
0.537923336,
-0.7563174367,
0.4548038542,
0.5513493419,
0.2599878907,
-0.0046049929,
-0.6964300275,
-0.6337575316,
0.1969740242,
-0.3992074728,
-0.1460622549,
-0.6240559816,
0.1832554191,
0.2625408471,
0.9053746462,
-0.4684172571,
0.0322195999,
-0.2447875142,
0.1327846795,
0.3972039819,
-0.1825721562,
0.2310090214,
-0.2032321244,
-0.0226969812,
-0.2604494393,
-0.77643466,
0.0382136442,
0.4142820239,
0.2194424719,
0.0461854339,
0.5560349822,
-0.1302348077,
0.6993104815,
0.31221807,
0.2043602467,
-0.0418975949,
-0.3740060627,
-0.4444561899,
-0.0249463823,
0.6149095297,
0.1411946118,
-0.2355478555,
-0.5075499415,
-0.2545260489,
0.0086362818,
0.5909717083,
-0.8104020953,
-0.544265449,
0.4625740349,
-0.7404584885,
-0.3572659492,
0.0286089052,
-0.8911214471,
-0.2182964385,
-0.3580407202,
0.6271371841,
-0.0018036857,
-0.261471808,
0.1771374494,
-0.0007405994,
-0.1671943665,
-0.1581929326,
-1.1592991352,
0.4782706499,
0.5657910705,
0.9622009993,
0.1283220202,
0.1117983684,
-0.6422357559,
-0.2222906351,
-0.0091240397,
0.8109590411,
-0.3545954525,
-0.2801117301,
-0.0086338213,
-0.2447486967,
0.1111699939,
-0.594116509,
0.3452720344,
-0.5611783266,
0.2962812185,
-0.165501073,
-0.4049651027,
-0.2591708899,
0.1022460312,
-0.9399958253,
1.1751196384,
0.2361248434,
-0.4915502369,
0.0380502492,
-0.6755985618,
-0.3632028401,
-0.1965545565,
0.0860211775,
-0.5357429981,
0.511572659,
0.3718968034,
0.4821453989,
-0.7139813304,
0.3318459392,
-0.1488065869,
-0.2731060982,
0.1914907843,
-0.365051657,
0.5526237488,
0.0736214742,
-0.489418745,
0.028620258,
-0.7906614542,
-0.1014557704,
0.0022616633,
-0.2515720129,
-0.0840890631,
-0.0178099517,
-0.1999807805,
0.6233087778,
-0.0545639247,
-0.7694761753,
0.2930786312,
-0.6513095498,
0.7682576776,
0.3251583576,
-0.2778946459,
0.7089660764,
-0.4763739705,
0.3742947876,
-0.4629925489,
0.3678095639,
-0.3961396813,
-0.2206700444,
-1.288656354,
-0.302182585,
0.2683367729,
0.3110546172,
-1.0983644724,
0.7387129068,
-0.5838532448,
-0.7521854639,
-0.5471824408,
0.0920129344,
0.280230552,
0.3391183317,
0.6637167335,
-0.1685325354,
-0.6435017586,
-0.8501608968,
0.1990387142,
-0.3326404691,
-0.1927359253,
0.2927452624,
0.3013545275,
-0.1588967592,
1.2489100695,
-0.667660594,
-0.4364096224,
-0.5556948185,
0.5976500511,
0.1115108579,
0.5495673418,
0.2878784239,
-0.6640673876,
-0.2903330624,
-0.1350242645,
-0.2835358977,
-0.2983370721,
-0.2521601915,
0.2937990427,
0.2957268059,
0.4638578296,
-0.6434854865,
0.2876757085,
1.040604949,
-0.1489502788,
0.1098951921,
-0.5253958106,
0.049037315,
-0.9588932991,
0.1326671392,
-0.2498687804,
-0.4811733961,
-0.9383904934,
0.1382801384,
-0.0807514638,
-0.2727145553,
-0.4413464665,
0.0627404749,
-0.6335842609,
-0.0948340818,
-0.4974965751,
-0.1527661085,
0.2675326765,
0.6884074807,
0.1032642573,
0.5322315097,
0.2960028946,
-0.319740653,
0.3405875862,
0.3687976897,
-0.1011753976,
0.1140467823,
-0.6819955111,
0.307406038,
-0.3876527548,
0.6244171858,
-0.8251120448,
0.136138007,
0.0110073388,
-0.1731764823,
0.5895701647,
-0.3937728405,
-0.7150626183,
-0.1898310333,
-0.3869406581,
0.5835208893,
0.7214026451,
-0.8623891473,
1.0106446743,
0.5047191381,
0.1036618128,
-0.0838453844,
-0.9372143149,
0.3998334408,
-0.3145599961,
-0.6874717474,
0.7176419497,
-0.2101832479,
-0.1004175171,
-0.0831640363,
-0.0383545794,
-0.2192218006,
-0.1327043772,
0.166646421,
0.2563003004,
-0.1293123215,
-0.1158362404,
-0.1538428813,
-0.2010082901,
-0.091434665,
-0.3710128069,
0.6867795587,
-0.0213537049,
-0.209554106,
-0.0940539986,
0.5467030406,
0.1622126997,
-0.1037075222,
0.8912318945,
0.6288841367,
-0.4364944994,
-0.3013113141,
-0.8091694713,
-0.3211818039,
-0.6033971906,
-0.1640508622,
0.014539538,
-1.1461261511,
0.3871667683,
-0.2690962851,
-0.0415016785,
0.1981017143,
0.4884357154,
0.0710986555,
0.9531437159,
0.855722487,
0.2031123042,
0.3862453401,
-0.2864084244,
0.5802038312,
-0.6564628482,
-0.0908927694,
-0.6941990852,
-0.2321966887,
-0.5080422759,
-0.7130114436,
0.2094226182,
0.2449204773,
0.3342514038,
0.8241390586,
-0.5516170859,
0.5574287176,
0.1469328701,
-0.0719668418,
0.2009467632,
-0.0193498805,
0.1568696946,
0.2273194492,
-1.0820975304,
-0.0978237391,
0.6192388535,
0.3266640007,
0.2436560839,
0.4301879406,
0.4121360481,
0.2150470763,
0.3234450817,
-0.6525965929,
0.3994404972,
-0.314299047,
-0.5345333815,
-0.2516527474,
-0.6856060028,
-0.8815607429,
0.1811451614,
-0.3383667171,
-0.8702939749,
0.36475721,
0.2528175116,
-0.5584739447,
0.5550302267,
-0.560505569,
0.3189511299,
0.2216858566,
-0.2205767035,
-0.2193570137,
-0.5183829665,
0.0477562845,
-0.3316954374,
0.3661752939,
0.2102794051,
0.0943186358,
0.6452178955,
-0.8308057785,
0.7690800428,
0.1291937679,
-0.1601987183,
0.211823687,
0.1342744082,
0.589740634,
-0.1282870173,
0.0361780673,
0.4458772242,
-0.042016305,
-0.2409581095,
-1.0324963331,
0.6630722284,
-0.4991380274,
-0.196177721,
-0.1664429307,
-0.2819062173,
-0.2133389115,
0.0373513736,
0.3493320346,
1.0153484344,
0.106419988,
0.2816621959,
0.6023617983,
-0.2705140114,
0.9571346641,
0.5290602446,
-0.1455906779,
-0.5212920904,
1.0484378338,
0.151726827,
0.1950891018,
0.6845433116,
0.334695369,
-0.3717280924,
-0.4950695932,
-0.4775742292,
0.0834125355,
-0.7626079321,
-0.3676090837,
-0.7166211009,
0.0028051285,
-0.2678738832,
-0.3741045594,
-0.9405865073,
-0.5595030189,
-0.0860183239,
0.1663446277,
0.0425379537,
0.8481191993,
-0.1994499713,
0.2945277095,
-1.1125421524,
0.2295708358,
0.0768482089,
0.4698106349,
0.1719071716,
-0.3345549405,
-0.5001798868,
-0.1774341315,
-0.0239628348,
-0.6107190847,
0.4513212442,
0.3839786053,
0.1567165852,
0.2987076342,
0.4612281919,
0.6435818076,
-0.5919350982,
0.7486121058,
0.102729708,
-1.0295243263,
0.1131581962,
0.0023552142,
0.3124457002,
0.5605507493,
0.2667559981,
-0.4453940988,
-0.1132291257,
-0.5860182643,
-1.1157208681,
0.6027631164,
0.7015010118,
0.0599304959,
0.0438552462,
0.3588016629,
0.0965939388,
0.0851411447,
-0.5122830868,
-0.4608144462,
-0.2152838558,
-0.0527459867,
-0.2230729908,
-0.2410543561,
0.130790472,
-0.2397730649,
0.5796973109,
-0.2148014754,
0.6700258255,
0.3008495569,
-0.265294075,
-0.3047669828,
0.2661560774,
0.4408590496,
0.1480341703,
-0.125160709,
0.3583763242,
0.2228533924,
-0.2380806059,
0.2636014521,
0.1678832918,
-0.0985748917,
0.0541976839,
0.3160963655,
0.8106169701,
0.275832355,
-0.4531341195,
0.4407559335,
-0.3837771118,
-0.0278247297,
-0.1944152266,
-0.1371157765,
-0.1601326764,
0.0721611455,
0.2808219194,
0.391605258,
0.223306641,
-0.2575367093,
0.0784403086,
0.2787129879,
-0.5874075294,
-0.4386370182,
0.4140666425,
0.3541097343,
-0.345985055,
0.5246915817,
-0.1016559228,
-0.5070999861,
0.1490646005,
0.4439665675,
0.9746683836,
0.1007897258,
0.0837567896,
0.275415659,
0.4937497675,
-0.4507864714,
-0.1148356572,
-0.3193892539,
-0.663214922,
-0.899582088,
-0.4774313569,
-0.4101980031,
0.0026751831,
-0.5858861804,
0.2919975221,
-0.19835563,
-0.149529174,
-0.1995742321,
-0.166503191,
-0.4331810474,
0.2685642838,
0.2533257604,
0.7690786719,
-0.6433339715,
0.8467797637,
0.4827263057,
-0.1861419231,
-0.7284978628,
-0.033453431,
0.0342048742,
-0.0600358844,
0.3069006801,
0.256406337,
-0.2008019686,
0.2799936533,
0.1104507148,
-1.0637813807,
0.9253945947,
0.3054237664,
-0.3819780648,
-0.121384874,
0.5348565578,
0.6175001264,
-0.0770489424,
0.6533308029,
0.500205934,
0.3095263839,
0.0983072147,
-0.8795560598,
0.2110382766,
-0.5476458669,
-0.1169149429,
0.552249074,
-0.50893116,
0.5343873501,
0.3148930669,
-0.3076764047,
-0.2136894763,
0.5724140406,
-0.5027869344,
-0.1059314907,
0.7349360585,
0.4128744304,
0.428634733,
0.0692124516,
1.11165905,
-0.4782911539,
0.5052725673,
0.8305181861,
-0.123672016,
0.9453312755,
0.6606345177,
-0.144636482,
0.2480541319,
0.1480009407,
-0.0048291562,
0.2915326953,
0.0686231107,
-0.1453879476,
-0.2876275182,
-0.3480842113,
-0.0696430132,
0.4225495458,
-0.2310495675,
-0.0694108307,
-0.2602188885,
-0.0149592366,
-0.053619016,
-0.0801258162,
-0.083100751,
0.7507061362,
-0.0073033334,
-0.8235931396,
0.7081244588,
0.3620435596,
0.8455441594,
-0.4302383065,
0.1598048508,
-0.1143272221,
0.1213771552,
-0.2931124568,
-0.2418275625,
0.9709345102,
-0.0785280615,
-0.2000697553,
-0.7284107804,
0.9014596939,
-0.3866583705,
-0.3260707557,
0.2266922444,
0.4939718843,
-0.1085155606,
-0.2034154236,
-0.3175292909,
0.181396246,
-0.0942812487,
-0.3697030842,
0.4904767871,
-0.1473529339,
0.2751863897,
0.6619742513,
1.0311443806,
0.0743877366,
-0.1734652519,
-0.1210465878,
1.1256192923,
-0.267360568,
-0.5059585571,
-0.988720119,
0.4691657126,
0.0726820976,
-0.125805527,
0.5906992555,
0.4828301668,
0.7342818975,
0.1151603982,
0.3641435206,
-0.1287802011,
0.1951630712,
-0.5657314062,
0.6910015941,
-0.5353668928,
0.4862903655,
-0.2811102271,
-0.9734259248,
-0.5921410322,
0.4754182994,
0.0580722168,
-0.1315712631,
0.7579981089,
0.7865020037,
-0.0016810023,
0.318159014,
0.3372079432,
-0.0721332282,
0.4684325457,
0.2499803156,
0.639110744,
-0.4697323442,
0.8126403093,
-0.8095829487,
-0.1040980071,
-0.0330039077,
-1.3008493185,
-1.1662658453,
-0.6852657795,
-0.4644654691,
-0.1880546808,
-0.2835838795,
1.3964412212,
0.8338001966,
-0.5981230736,
-0.1039716303,
-0.3280909956,
-0.4315935969,
-0.2069930583,
-0.1016501039,
0.3177061975,
0.0647796765,
-0.5190293789,
0.6806969643,
0.4708680212,
-0.1061863527,
-0.6069628596,
0.0715356395,
-0.0055637201,
0.3671588004,
0.5907534361,
0.1309457123,
-0.2599689364,
-0.0853281394,
0.004642325,
0.2080890983,
0.26449278,
1.2283670902,
-0.9137691259,
0.2765666842,
0.9128087759,
0.6936839223,
0.3920160234,
0.1060568616,
0.7815951109,
-0.8866668344,
0.101585798,
0.0668495223,
0.4080531299,
0.6243671775,
-0.2755002975,
0.4558134675,
0.0178088918,
-0.6546066999,
-0.9026798606,
0.1970739067,
-0.6520798802,
-0.314979285,
1.2104096413,
-0.28053087,
-0.1172361895,
-0.4059409201,
-0.1301210076,
0.447288394,
-0.1588691771,
1.0876932144,
0.5400786996,
-0.1879386157,
-0.3521520793,
-0.2411087304,
0.5363612771,
0.4521069825,
-0.8539751172,
0.1666035354,
0.1566859186,
-0.3694775403,
0.3283486366,
0.2720820308,
0.2043376416,
-0.1397417039,
-0.0489050969,
0.1066789851,
-0.4390208721,
-0.2721404135,
-0.7656313777,
0.3244943023,
-0.1614123732,
0.3898871541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06466v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06466v1 | ChatGPT versus Traditional Question Answering for Knowledge Graphs: Current Status and Future Directions Towards Knowledge Graph Chatbots | 2023-02-08T13:03:27 | 2023-02-08T13:03:27 | Reham Omar, Omij Mangukiya, Panos Kalnis, Essam Mansour | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Conversational AI and Question-Answering systems (QASs) for knowledge graphs
(KGs) are both emerging research areas: they empower users with natural
language interfaces for extracting information easily and effectively.
Conversational AI simulates conversations with humans; however, it is limited
by the data captured in the training datasets. In contrast, QASs retrieve the
most recent information from a KG by understanding and translating the natural
language question into a formal query supported by the database engine.
In this paper, we present a comprehensive study of the characteristics of the
existing alternatives towards combining both worlds into novel KG chatbots. Our
framework compares two representative conversational models, ChatGPT and
Galactica, against KGQAN, the current state-of-the-art QAS. We conduct a
thorough evaluation using four real KGs across various application domains to
identify the current limitations of each category of systems. Based on our
findings, we propose open research opportunities to empower QASs with chatbot
capabilities for KGs. All benchmarks and all raw results are available1 for
further analysis. | [
-0.3696332574,
-0.9332838058,
0.5114279389,
-0.2696963847,
-0.084014684,
0.5609747767,
0.2114705443,
-0.6241682172,
0.2036487013,
0.5530918837,
-0.5620447397,
-0.2851398289,
-0.3734092414,
-0.0550680459,
-0.256221652,
0.711737752,
0.1345933974,
-0.1297247261,
-0.9614952207,
-0.1383170485,
-0.6410617828,
-0.6740514636,
-0.8406886458,
-0.3320638537,
0.5158001184,
0.3139619827,
1.1393629313,
-0.0386723615,
0.4380727112,
0.3202721477,
-0.0841965154,
0.3120553792,
-0.5939723849,
0.2035989016,
0.4038187563,
-0.3937480152,
-0.3817672133,
-0.1498514861,
0.2563769519,
0.7808824182,
0.1342826337,
-0.0025307054,
-0.1826795787,
0.7430933118,
-0.3873914182,
0.5858381391,
-0.3638632298,
0.0196134485,
0.3559356034,
0.0417833887,
-0.1484816223,
-0.8548104763,
0.5128231645,
-0.8362255096,
-0.3313492835,
0.2822955549,
0.7872402668,
0.1474922448,
-0.5953632593,
-0.5770760775,
-0.743260026,
0.2885042727,
-0.7095350623,
0.7143438458,
0.1462233812,
0.8915119171,
-0.2388850152,
-1.0395838022,
-0.6953964829,
-0.1878944337,
-0.24765113,
0.2894372046,
-0.5331540704,
0.0592480376,
-0.0896549076,
0.2044995278,
-0.6982188821,
-0.0521705449,
-0.4871811867,
-0.2483624816,
0.5010715723,
0.2325260043,
0.4303803146,
-0.2007611394,
-0.2903776467,
-0.2196430862,
-0.5768671632,
0.0998262763,
0.3355276287,
0.1314594746,
0.1004984975,
0.4534585178,
-0.7302905917,
0.726364553,
-0.265252471,
-0.1035572588,
-0.0598405972,
-0.0938292891,
-0.1727051884,
-0.2189451605,
1.0273879766,
0.5285664201,
0.3210154474,
-0.7508530617,
0.3833129108,
-0.2575542927,
0.0121395178,
-0.8482391238,
-0.4385778308,
0.4053632915,
-0.127509132,
-0.2701981068,
-0.2197455466,
-0.8119733334,
-0.6645898223,
-0.0948233157,
0.3715404272,
-0.5228863358,
-0.3175660968,
0.0213604793,
-0.5269649625,
0.2510753274,
0.3440936506,
-0.5330199003,
0.208212927,
0.5426751375,
0.5173304081,
0.0661473721,
0.0790266916,
0.0886208788,
-0.1106872559,
-0.2258769274,
0.7594029307,
-0.604126215,
-0.4707516134,
-0.0843253657,
-0.3952350318,
-0.2636967897,
-0.5781900883,
0.4826486409,
-1.115542531,
0.5899577141,
-0.374034524,
-0.719446063,
-0.4340908527,
0.4887422919,
-0.4446984529,
0.7538269758,
0.2901482582,
-0.6617717147,
0.1389349252,
-0.7834074497,
-0.1258142143,
0.220301196,
0.0043274113,
-0.0800149739,
-0.6288976669,
0.3652334809,
0.2771621048,
-0.5082374215,
0.1990031749,
-0.4912120104,
-0.0153987911,
0.5536259413,
-0.3973556459,
0.5445173383,
0.5348557234,
0.1363892704,
-0.0175630953,
-0.4706285596,
0.5014292598,
0.2364311963,
0.0241884757,
-0.0349937566,
0.2529576421,
-0.5628978014,
0.2940094173,
0.3264707625,
-0.5815472007,
0.0803965703,
-0.2107697725,
0.6367819309,
0.3051642478,
0.1600347608,
0.3663181961,
-0.1883635074,
0.7950074673,
-0.2188753933,
0.3492400348,
0.0950648412,
-0.7731763721,
-0.4816124141,
-0.0287520662,
0.3751184642,
0.6311654449,
-1.1498435736,
0.1327004433,
-0.6710819006,
-0.801158309,
-0.3294244707,
-0.2300117761,
0.2481645942,
0.7026091814,
-0.0115073221,
-0.2861019075,
-0.3158388436,
-0.7010026574,
-0.3386084735,
-0.6343702674,
-0.1682388633,
0.7773516178,
0.1434373707,
0.1416429728,
1.4485738277,
-0.6917627454,
0.0993383601,
-0.3968997598,
-0.2262658179,
-0.0661662072,
0.014938483,
0.5628350973,
-1.1247458458,
-0.6394615769,
0.2476523072,
-1.0366737843,
0.1441351026,
0.3572535217,
-0.0378004313,
-0.1796792746,
0.4507395625,
-0.7989358306,
0.3692461252,
0.5573992729,
-0.2641943991,
0.4331663549,
0.3640586734,
0.5149140358,
-0.9285332561,
0.0978032053,
-0.6173078418,
-0.1700727642,
-1.0794969797,
-0.004432688,
-0.0921960622,
-0.6412832141,
-0.4905358255,
0.6990260482,
-0.032840874,
-0.0315716341,
-0.1661801934,
0.608322382,
0.0434261262,
0.5829200149,
-0.1168089211,
0.7490337491,
0.2814537287,
-0.5462801456,
0.774076879,
0.6933426261,
-0.0361372791,
0.3441716433,
-0.8624565601,
0.4061335921,
-0.0855980217,
0.4992951453,
-1.0845528841,
-0.3132888079,
0.6455021501,
-0.9228324294,
-0.1186700612,
-0.3626070917,
-0.5382778645,
-0.8097257018,
0.0149335563,
0.1310266107,
0.7165215611,
-0.2053196132,
0.4116914272,
0.4427948594,
-0.40658319,
-0.4282717705,
-0.0643948466,
0.2890427411,
-0.167327404,
-0.9792832136,
-0.1695853323,
0.1611323506,
-0.19743523,
0.2531759143,
-0.0875267908,
-0.4172556996,
0.0822500885,
0.1353476495,
0.1784766018,
-0.2610066235,
0.1976986825,
-0.1257608235,
-0.0934842452,
-0.074287951,
-0.5208482742,
0.7194951773,
-0.1795854419,
-0.3713497818,
-0.3606023788,
0.1215158105,
0.6139401793,
-0.2964309156,
0.8437101245,
0.402038455,
-0.1131024212,
0.5388272405,
-0.3800158501,
-0.1221623346,
-0.5115007162,
0.4155153036,
-0.1424344629,
-1.0651783943,
0.5077855587,
-0.1891004592,
0.0630510002,
0.3345009685,
0.2597749531,
-0.2021202147,
0.9504112601,
0.285280019,
-0.1682265997,
0.3144944012,
-0.0508163311,
0.6612050533,
-0.4359871149,
-0.2933406234,
-0.62324965,
-0.163698718,
-0.5162463784,
-0.0549184158,
0.6706946492,
0.1818601489,
-0.0157598313,
0.1911645234,
-0.2406280935,
0.4557902813,
0.5987094641,
-0.1362071484,
0.2074750811,
-0.27506423,
0.3201574087,
0.2216130048,
-1.1713280678,
-0.5206845999,
1.099996686,
0.0012284153,
0.3949562013,
0.1583010107,
0.259419024,
0.1222421005,
0.1852214485,
-0.6759368777,
0.6516922116,
0.2200448364,
-0.7169762254,
-0.6307133436,
-0.6707826853,
-1.0550447702,
0.312836647,
-0.0830341205,
-0.8181651831,
-0.1782310158,
0.0479626209,
-0.3240222633,
0.6174650788,
-0.9685338736,
0.978045702,
0.0313752592,
0.0512041561,
0.1780656874,
-0.8969090581,
0.1907336712,
0.3096426427,
0.0848269612,
-0.13730672,
0.4842588007,
0.7156133652,
-0.2994891703,
0.9080682397,
-0.3512643278,
-0.047818359,
0.8139929175,
-0.0787663683,
0.4987114966,
-0.1914237142,
0.0438107327,
-0.1372016519,
0.4187416434,
-0.4954816997,
-0.8697696328,
0.3409113586,
-0.7890728116,
-0.4755236506,
-0.0661254302,
-0.6753352284,
-0.8477948308,
0.2965791523,
-0.1275765151,
0.5492620468,
-0.4066140056,
0.1604610384,
0.3936883211,
-0.3603029251,
0.0976877734,
0.3414031863,
-0.4255374968,
-0.3609855771,
0.9715861082,
0.0238394439,
0.561073482,
0.4384973347,
0.0944584608,
-0.5039013028,
-0.4433224201,
-0.6371940374,
-0.036161162,
-0.7179659009,
-0.1281874478,
-0.795247376,
-0.3619002998,
-0.8212485909,
0.1399437338,
-0.1190934107,
-0.6589327455,
0.1116167679,
0.0570652299,
0.4926683009,
0.6870232224,
0.4511472881,
0.3314153254,
-1.0482941866,
0.2910626531,
0.8693355918,
0.1818264723,
0.0534038059,
-0.1448402703,
-0.0596212558,
0.321308285,
-0.4522968531,
-0.8816052675,
0.2036948651,
0.0172922481,
0.4908653498,
0.4024412334,
0.2971812189,
0.5614840984,
-0.1777026951,
0.851057291,
0.0561145581,
-0.2573739886,
0.2734397054,
-0.468434304,
0.1469257325,
0.4616501331,
0.5104609132,
-1.2450168133,
-0.447753787,
-0.7288636565,
-0.5199282765,
0.6031196713,
0.4128445387,
0.1559281498,
0.1462598145,
0.3182150722,
0.1582541615,
0.5318722129,
-0.2296753824,
-0.1478357911,
-0.147489652,
-0.251798749,
0.09219677,
0.0441353284,
-0.1574840695,
0.0673961043,
0.5312433243,
-0.1568567008,
0.5730983615,
0.0560867153,
0.0845567957,
0.2615579367,
0.3658649027,
-0.0519685261,
0.6278658509,
-0.1543646902,
-0.178753525,
0.2607066631,
-0.3600725532,
-0.1613406092,
0.1113807485,
-0.374189198,
-0.2811954021,
0.1270182431,
0.8227855563,
-0.0044393009,
-0.7555787563,
0.3761119246,
-0.0527140014,
-0.2047679424,
-0.1830970794,
0.2818195522,
0.4731599092,
0.3873363137,
0.1773692518,
-0.0212603696,
-0.0532482788,
-0.5473429561,
-0.1608267576,
0.5390815139,
-0.7996496558,
-0.2098909169,
0.7286480069,
0.2795515358,
-0.2904863954,
0.7470268011,
-0.3091337979,
-0.7169770598,
0.7095389962,
0.2306521088,
0.5706681013,
0.351936698,
0.541135788,
-0.0057082726,
0.0034711096,
0.5414043069,
-0.0110782022,
-0.0906981602,
-0.8910111189,
-0.1822536886,
-0.2315820456,
-0.914175868,
-0.2480533123,
-0.3203763068,
-0.3003710508,
0.0136290593,
0.0188599154,
-0.1782975644,
0.0606792793,
-0.4920809269,
0.1363756657,
0.0054991138,
0.7041884661,
-0.4895220697,
0.5980294347,
0.6278330088,
-0.2444446534,
-0.5925114751,
-0.2292858213,
-0.2040351927,
-0.7600625753,
0.3093791306,
-0.1832362711,
0.0567781962,
0.1607951969,
-0.5031648874,
-0.7837145925,
1.4719069004,
0.186014384,
0.0151405651,
-0.1955091059,
0.5174031854,
0.5852432847,
0.0518722646,
0.2689138353,
0.5505851507,
0.4540552795,
0.462904036,
-0.9100792408,
-0.3362305462,
-0.1282904297,
-0.5016815662,
0.2681059539,
-0.9647814631,
0.2535676956,
0.0221570898,
-0.3724890053,
0.3058154285,
0.7471553087,
0.0205079354,
0.5505272746,
0.3978801072,
0.3632503748,
0.890168488,
-0.2999210954,
1.1444928646,
-0.1974621713,
0.1913746297,
0.6111267805,
-0.3092464209,
0.4647374451,
0.2555095851,
-0.6686463356,
0.3216910362,
0.6184927225,
0.4223561585,
0.3698680699,
-0.1479893476,
-0.2971478403,
-0.1651355922,
-0.0765318125,
-0.400219053,
0.2541842461,
0.2065612376,
0.273232609,
-0.236642167,
-0.0780321434,
0.2629562318,
-0.2006530762,
-0.0645590052,
0.8728586435,
-0.1079737544,
-0.7031190395,
0.3702458739,
-0.3131687641,
0.1450626254,
-0.8447666764,
0.2163660079,
-0.2848474681,
-0.3311904073,
0.0820674077,
-0.5935645103,
0.0232931208,
-0.1556162983,
0.3018246591,
-0.0165930856,
1.111779213,
-0.1583948433,
-0.1412300915,
-0.1760744005,
0.9183762074,
0.2422650605,
-0.2113482952,
-0.5447463989,
-0.5706298351,
-0.1288261563,
-0.1158875078,
0.2540680766,
0.5411401987,
-0.057563439,
1.1534645557,
0.655223608,
-0.2621874809,
0.2589939237,
-0.188892886,
1.0385987759,
-0.3783590794,
-0.4974675179,
-0.2376866937,
0.0854539722,
-0.1994230449,
-0.2565132976,
0.84216398,
0.3950870037,
0.4604654014,
0.1360980123,
0.8487875462,
-0.448433876,
0.5582481027,
-0.4003643692,
0.7978374958,
-0.2543469369,
-0.1321033388,
-0.1583675146,
-0.5314586759,
-0.1770622581,
-0.156232208,
-0.5299287438,
0.1098240018,
0.4802157879,
0.6849743128,
0.1766110361,
0.6561124325,
0.4042111635,
0.0249103978,
0.5329334736,
0.511500597,
1.2005519867,
-0.3419844806,
1.0426332951,
-0.1254177541,
0.093885392,
-0.1642581522,
-0.2859215736,
-0.6409935951,
-0.5028558969,
-0.1069530249,
-0.1640431583,
0.2785202563,
0.3707182109,
0.4253026247,
-0.6705678105,
0.1402252764,
0.116537407,
0.3035589457,
-0.222330898,
-0.2470806837,
0.4689646959,
-0.2616672218,
-0.707728982,
0.3148627877,
0.1207643449,
0.0987250209,
0.0045054019,
-0.1806849986,
0.1821163893,
0.0467610396,
0.6698890328,
0.7064025402,
-0.3782148659,
-0.5598325133,
0.4214940965,
0.1121722683,
0.087294586,
0.6266208291,
-1.0017157793,
0.4430001676,
0.6572417021,
0.8444051147,
0.4096800685,
-0.0211730115,
0.4558936357,
-0.4637192786,
-0.1043322831,
0.3891006708,
-0.1739944518,
0.148833856,
0.0219173674,
0.540859282,
0.2306431532,
-0.5721305609,
-0.5109573007,
0.3611232638,
-0.8003439307,
-0.2396821529,
1.0272777081,
-0.1165719703,
-0.106588155,
-0.4730113447,
-0.3862937391,
0.2067073137,
-0.2160204053,
0.5804201961,
0.7016619444,
-0.3693603575,
0.1906802654,
-0.7813690305,
0.3583215773,
0.2424127609,
-0.9345554113,
0.0636039376,
0.4746121168,
0.0210071877,
-0.0045487229,
0.7271464467,
-0.2649651468,
0.3405094743,
0.1561937481,
0.0704982802,
-0.1474726945,
-0.0751380846,
0.2276248634,
0.4831891656,
0.0388510823,
-0.2249450833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04023v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04023v4 | A Multitask, Multilingual, Multimodal Evaluation of ChatGPT on Reasoning, Hallucination, and Interactivity | 2023-02-08T12:35:34 | 2023-11-28T09:01:12 | Yejin Bang, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Nayeon Lee, Wenliang Dai, Dan Su, Bryan Wilie, Holy Lovenia, Ziwei Ji, Tiezheng Yu, Willy Chung, Quyet V. Do, Yan Xu, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper proposes a framework for quantitatively evaluating interactive
LLMs such as ChatGPT using publicly available data sets. We carry out an
extensive technical evaluation of ChatGPT using 23 data sets covering 8
different common NLP application tasks. We evaluate the multitask, multilingual
and multi-modal aspects of ChatGPT based on these data sets and a newly
designed multimodal dataset. We find that ChatGPT outperforms LLMs with
zero-shot learning on most tasks and even outperforms fine-tuned models on some
tasks. We find that it is better at understanding non-Latin script languages
than generating them. It is able to generate multimodal content from textual
prompts, via an intermediate code generation step. Moreover, we find that
ChatGPT is 63.41% accurate on average in 10 different reasoning categories
under logical reasoning, non-textual reasoning, and commonsense reasoning,
hence making it an unreliable reasoner. It is, for example, better at deductive
than inductive reasoning. ChatGPT suffers from hallucination problems like
other LLMs and it generates more extrinsic hallucinations from its parametric
memory as it does not have access to an external knowledge base. Finally, the
interactive feature of ChatGPT enables human collaboration with the underlying
LLM to improve its performance, i.e, 8% ROUGE-1 on summarization and 2% ChrF++
on machine translation, in a multi-turn "prompt engineering" fashion. We also
release codebase for evaluation set extraction. | [
-0.4831545949,
-0.8668237329,
0.5302571058,
0.64422369,
-0.0666317269,
0.1687600464,
-0.6251888275,
-0.2906885445,
0.2661649585,
0.1614310294,
-0.5604029298,
-0.6442473531,
-0.4683774114,
0.0325809792,
-0.1387111098,
0.936742723,
0.1135571525,
0.1377714723,
-0.1740154326,
-0.0356457457,
-0.4852496088,
-0.6695590615,
-0.6098994613,
-0.1983443201,
0.5993946791,
0.2980021238,
0.8479760289,
0.0672583058,
0.6046786308,
0.3135633171,
0.1106553376,
0.4173110425,
-0.5438760519,
0.0547789112,
0.0562104322,
-0.2531713843,
-0.4787645638,
-0.1488591433,
0.3289815784,
0.411244303,
-0.2582276464,
-0.0514257848,
0.1799328327,
0.4181244075,
-0.3390627503,
0.6727924347,
-0.5557866693,
0.1663105488,
0.1077992767,
-0.4680308402,
-0.5201771259,
-0.2316341251,
0.1806780994,
-0.6302760243,
-0.0938198864,
0.1409646124,
0.4766464829,
0.3924533129,
-0.418928653,
-0.5207320452,
-0.5744943619,
0.7852933407,
-0.6059699059,
0.6757802367,
0.3556602299,
0.4157181084,
-0.2144991755,
-0.6309367418,
-0.5910873413,
-0.7501353621,
-0.095001176,
0.4694981575,
-0.0878966078,
0.2085486948,
0.3428420424,
0.2644593716,
-0.8088653684,
-0.1814699173,
-0.2297114432,
-0.2647326589,
0.4215678275,
0.1609131545,
0.5031729341,
-0.4217451513,
-0.4928719997,
-0.0575257838,
-0.320017606,
-0.0794789046,
0.2797468901,
0.0945516527,
-0.1809650213,
0.8547340631,
-0.1550213844,
0.4796361327,
-0.3404093385,
-0.2610106766,
0.2979085445,
-0.4112193882,
-0.1562990695,
-0.1298009902,
0.9275166392,
0.6297116876,
0.3105237782,
-0.4462156892,
0.0093355784,
0.042828761,
0.2682369649,
-0.60416466,
-0.299300015,
0.3421941698,
-0.2600004971,
-0.1119951159,
-0.2068943977,
-0.8477135897,
-0.4476341903,
-0.4918185771,
0.4696244299,
-0.8606215715,
-0.1464295983,
0.2617004216,
-0.0327888057,
0.2452082187,
0.6592140794,
-0.7490799427,
0.2429762632,
0.6238092184,
1.0732616186,
-0.6589159966,
-0.4501319528,
-0.2915247977,
-0.1670441031,
0.0117218541,
0.9613529444,
-0.4366249442,
-0.2103895396,
-0.2600590885,
-0.1291840822,
-0.4192894995,
-0.3520727754,
0.5135593414,
-0.2622919381,
0.332995832,
-0.0453116298,
-0.4567349851,
-0.3322962821,
0.5961012244,
-0.6234650612,
1.0272059441,
-0.2111512721,
-0.6824768186,
0.3009001911,
-0.8457958102,
-0.0323267952,
0.1464831531,
-0.2648961246,
-0.0566684641,
-0.2530615628,
0.2712126076,
0.4053315818,
-0.1001328081,
0.4277071059,
-0.2207330316,
-0.552472949,
0.5486550927,
-0.7433190346,
0.6488183737,
0.207026273,
-0.3732092977,
0.290384233,
-0.710197866,
0.2091036886,
-0.1615888327,
-0.4699706137,
0.1404573768,
0.0125308242,
0.1626522243,
0.290781647,
0.1462249756,
-0.3332900703,
0.2194675058,
-0.0628589019,
0.3552384675,
0.4720645249,
0.0914750323,
0.1083773524,
-0.4712942243,
0.6612070799,
-0.2644383013,
0.2089122385,
-0.2773859799,
-0.7347128987,
-0.8487375975,
-0.5358535051,
0.1350270957,
0.8604738116,
-0.9847730398,
0.3169749975,
-0.3196733296,
-0.4542640448,
-0.3114586771,
-0.0831464306,
0.3229605854,
0.2291119844,
0.3168496192,
-0.2914547324,
-0.2959055603,
-0.7097601295,
-0.0094926264,
-0.1922094077,
-0.2568568587,
0.3797521293,
0.4444601536,
-0.2501236498,
0.6347385049,
-0.1614344865,
-0.1481860876,
-0.3050695062,
0.2992455661,
0.1623812914,
0.1654767692,
0.1507323682,
-0.425860852,
-0.4244937897,
0.1787364781,
-0.9571412802,
-0.0445855185,
-0.2904602289,
-0.0596671179,
0.0263305157,
0.1475231797,
-0.775596261,
0.1917783618,
0.5909077525,
-0.1908553094,
0.6564555764,
-0.1887412369,
0.4509413242,
-0.847035408,
0.0094488263,
-0.0824278817,
-0.1375597119,
-0.5918474793,
-0.0037826817,
-0.0734171793,
-0.3764407933,
-0.5442937613,
0.4299381077,
-0.3593513072,
-0.0431438722,
-0.0510747321,
0.5674266815,
-0.0103634233,
0.9273875952,
0.2254911065,
0.8130060434,
0.404135704,
-0.291348666,
0.71623528,
0.1867974848,
-0.577896297,
0.4733547568,
-0.6206378341,
0.272354871,
-0.0155312121,
0.0406861827,
-1.0099666119,
-0.2679210007,
0.3219946027,
-0.5347569585,
-0.067291975,
-0.0200809222,
-0.5437687039,
0.1329536736,
-0.3382670581,
0.0577204973,
0.3095611036,
-0.3675810397,
0.6014341116,
0.1897989661,
-0.242506206,
-0.5409397483,
-0.4828157127,
0.2746653855,
-0.3257301152,
-0.8212901354,
0.0761203617,
-0.2149195224,
-0.3176085055,
-0.2088928819,
-0.0017483637,
-0.0548915602,
-0.2168353051,
0.2747953534,
0.2252337635,
-0.0220487509,
0.3721197248,
-0.2842383981,
-0.2005662471,
-0.0353733413,
0.1545948684,
0.6876992583,
-0.5665508509,
-0.8182036281,
-0.3260371387,
0.0660963506,
0.3707387447,
-0.0849025771,
0.4512488544,
0.9550349116,
-0.1421928853,
-0.0834813192,
-0.6146010756,
-0.1325322688,
-0.3947155774,
0.4422772825,
-0.4019611776,
-0.7781023979,
0.5285162926,
-0.1028287858,
0.113096267,
0.1564131528,
0.8342363238,
0.0547617786,
0.8265603185,
0.1637719423,
0.3536753654,
0.2985881269,
-0.0595786422,
0.244724676,
-0.5823507905,
-0.5338788033,
-0.1415152848,
-0.2097428143,
-0.5604375601,
-0.6607473493,
0.5126538873,
0.0882470459,
0.0517848991,
0.2586048245,
-0.4406718612,
0.3845472932,
0.4849097133,
0.2698045075,
0.6803005338,
-0.0200291425,
-0.1399920285,
-0.2379335314,
-0.6418215632,
-0.7232720852,
0.9813391566,
0.3761278093,
0.8328621984,
0.299469173,
0.4126585126,
0.3502833247,
0.25380826,
-1.1546517611,
0.5771232247,
0.2284810245,
-0.4652785957,
-0.3616808653,
-0.43216905,
-0.7667158246,
0.5763477683,
-0.2280622721,
-0.9103916287,
-0.1270824522,
-0.0321426839,
-0.2599129677,
0.0071778987,
-1.102006793,
0.8898681998,
-0.4702959359,
-0.4743931592,
-0.1417213827,
-0.4540283382,
0.4874114096,
-0.0569775105,
0.1262241155,
-0.2777199447,
-0.0573028252,
0.5470080972,
-0.0046285386,
0.9483035803,
0.0443546697,
-0.0558477864,
0.2209454775,
0.2374124974,
0.3167463243,
0.3239182532,
-0.2058603913,
0.3246031404,
0.2064000368,
-0.0787315965,
-0.9790640473,
0.5986732244,
-0.559848249,
-0.4418358505,
-0.4621339738,
-0.734085381,
-0.3871495724,
-0.0072778575,
0.0173212402,
0.3476326764,
-0.354711324,
0.349414438,
0.4601342082,
-0.4710912406,
0.2783440948,
0.4820474386,
-0.4373099506,
-0.4672691226,
1.0181781054,
-0.0645672455,
0.3156582415,
0.3361111879,
0.0707627982,
-0.410577476,
-0.3248639107,
-0.5704243183,
-0.0111089619,
-0.7805153131,
0.1406219453,
-0.7720217109,
-0.2547464073,
-0.0811580196,
0.0504476503,
-0.2768400908,
-0.5150547624,
0.2136844099,
0.0019363215,
0.3870268166,
0.5714333653,
-0.0275932904,
0.3141424358,
-0.6139554977,
0.2846136689,
0.2110973001,
0.3496993184,
-0.1566281468,
-0.3079483807,
-0.0099028805,
0.0667518005,
-0.3797793686,
-0.8825633526,
0.3777571321,
0.1503748447,
0.6842803955,
0.3285079896,
-0.0940593705,
0.6482067108,
-0.4159998,
0.8813360333,
0.1763670743,
-0.881373167,
0.2205094099,
-0.2917607129,
0.3258984983,
0.4402635396,
0.4954784513,
-0.8236057758,
-0.2443724871,
-0.4413626194,
-0.601200521,
0.5993974805,
0.5240582228,
0.0277011655,
-0.1085812449,
-0.0600480959,
0.2301527262,
0.3003852963,
-0.930675149,
-0.0598903857,
-0.3659633994,
-0.0824131221,
0.0290274546,
-0.1265445799,
-0.0968470722,
-0.0997796282,
0.4975714386,
-0.2659291625,
0.499428302,
-0.0499802604,
-0.2040465027,
0.4918690324,
0.4588642716,
0.6826443076,
0.8695217967,
-0.3622623086,
0.3571064174,
0.3642497659,
-0.407161504,
-0.1444202662,
0.0992255211,
0.2165404856,
0.0712234303,
0.477481097,
0.9074056745,
0.2964618802,
-0.9790737629,
0.5342659354,
-0.2281829417,
-0.1303205043,
-0.279679805,
0.018765334,
0.171964556,
0.4584167004,
0.0938307643,
0.0052644121,
0.1894327551,
-0.4516911209,
0.2647702992,
0.4035477638,
-0.4748184979,
-0.2273873091,
0.4010948837,
0.1445000172,
-0.2922260165,
0.6526007056,
-0.3622417152,
-0.2834835351,
0.3083926737,
0.3426626623,
0.6534444094,
-0.0710068867,
0.4159675837,
0.2521443963,
0.530606091,
0.1218108237,
0.3230738044,
-0.1938545704,
-0.7967523932,
-0.7890172005,
-0.466217041,
-0.7989985347,
0.2313907444,
-0.2950682938,
0.4211028218,
-0.1450188756,
-0.1800032854,
-0.1315024197,
-0.1689382344,
-0.5312464833,
-0.0989679024,
-0.1137546971,
0.5028520226,
-0.4687695801,
0.6786242723,
0.4769847095,
-0.4637269378,
-0.4556598961,
-0.1097772568,
0.1246976405,
-1.014246583,
0.5725893378,
0.2153539807,
-0.2014720291,
-0.146587193,
-0.2909875214,
-0.6954194903,
1.0085333586,
0.4716176987,
-0.3796978593,
-0.0084350295,
0.2673688829,
0.6122818589,
-0.0278711319,
0.7617958784,
0.3319112062,
0.6099552512,
0.3454554975,
-1.1775627136,
-0.1089139804,
-0.374527365,
-0.3019614816,
-0.019131802,
-0.5511978269,
0.5111237168,
-0.1521438509,
-0.2922233641,
-0.2596836388,
0.2562058568,
0.4214144945,
0.2072032541,
0.386557579,
0.3724778295,
0.6854083538,
-0.2252041548,
0.8770019412,
-0.4029646814,
0.4033204019,
1.1724545956,
-0.2744033635,
0.7017284632,
0.5202348828,
-0.2405376285,
0.1096612588,
0.4590754807,
-0.0825767219,
0.2815538645,
0.3306657374,
-0.4237941206,
-0.1985783875,
-0.0574914068,
-0.2718891501,
0.5954934955,
0.4067713022,
0.0624937154,
-0.3864451945,
0.1794888526,
0.0551254191,
-0.2818986177,
0.2038055211,
0.7986654639,
0.1099715009,
-0.6084105372,
0.5131242275,
-0.0100333141,
0.6734545231,
-0.6479705572,
-0.230844751,
-0.151778698,
0.0217850897,
-0.3116689324,
-0.8656381965,
0.429053545,
0.0121969962,
0.3299764395,
-0.3273177445,
0.7342976928,
-0.4019420445,
-0.3491234183,
0.2500973344,
0.7734021544,
0.7103596926,
-0.2931222022,
-0.7376255989,
0.1455186754,
0.0392584912,
-0.4448830783,
0.2369986176,
0.6425450444,
0.0184858926,
0.8761773109,
0.6694610715,
-0.0236125719,
0.1880518347,
0.2597195804,
0.7510065436,
-0.6194532514,
-0.1915121377,
-0.8122098446,
0.5583046675,
-0.03081985,
-0.2672499418,
0.9538323879,
0.597019136,
0.7063212991,
-0.0844973624,
0.7174540162,
-0.1356029063,
0.1926888674,
-0.6990626454,
0.5592422485,
-0.2808406353,
0.3079434037,
-0.2119347006,
-0.9995222092,
-0.4219073057,
0.7435187101,
-0.3937728703,
0.1446383595,
0.9055527449,
0.8433648348,
-0.0704556257,
0.2291430235,
0.6516119242,
-0.1236044839,
0.2738173902,
0.4907255471,
1.2410522699,
-0.2137534022,
0.7241522074,
-0.3816158473,
-0.406799227,
-0.0305226929,
-0.989793241,
-1.0845431089,
-0.5847015977,
-0.1920170337,
-0.2056507468,
-0.0146075767,
1.0654548407,
0.5419501066,
-0.6127265096,
-0.3673261702,
0.1471584737,
-0.0279891882,
-0.1893985569,
-0.3161377907,
0.3446875215,
-0.6266382337,
-0.84291327,
0.5783029199,
0.4672721326,
-0.2131693214,
-0.4053816795,
-0.182565093,
-0.0682141557,
-0.1548344344,
1.0403075218,
-0.1220302731,
-0.7148550153,
-0.2735869586,
0.3572232723,
0.0427263975,
0.2591144741,
0.7626472116,
-0.4779072702,
0.5646342635,
0.4254588783,
0.574383378,
0.677543819,
0.007381082,
0.3538241088,
-0.551640451,
0.1508171409,
0.2478364408,
0.3145675957,
0.153881073,
-0.1630019546,
0.6336560845,
0.0974769667,
-0.6708912849,
-0.5074667931,
0.0849691778,
-1.3870874643,
0.0286076386,
1.2579228878,
-0.1863342971,
0.0229437239,
-0.3396736383,
-0.6162438989,
0.1076865196,
-0.5803907514,
0.9837633371,
0.9938489199,
-0.6743621826,
-0.4499282539,
-1.0065330267,
0.4418074489,
0.2894892097,
-1.060769558,
-0.0657533631,
0.5697453022,
0.0321531482,
0.3181788921,
0.6929126382,
-0.2691487074,
-0.0333288647,
-0.0353190564,
0.4395648837,
-0.1145218015,
-0.2551440597,
-0.1040852293,
0.1784796715,
-0.0008787685,
-0.1179689094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04012v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04012v2 | CodeLMSec Benchmark: Systematically Evaluating and Finding Security Vulnerabilities in Black-Box Code Language Models | 2023-02-08T11:54:07 | 2023-10-23T14:08:09 | Hossein Hajipour, Keno Hassler, Thorsten Holz, Lea Schönherr, Mario Fritz | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE | Large language models (LLMs) for automatic code generation have achieved
breakthroughs in several programming tasks. Their advances in competition-level
programming problems have made them an essential pillar of AI-assisted pair
programming, and tools such as GitHub Copilot have emerged as part of the daily
programming workflow used by millions of developers. The training data for
these models is usually collected from the Internet (e.g., from open-source
repositories) and is likely to contain faults and security vulnerabilities.
This unsanitized training data can cause the language models to learn these
vulnerabilities and propagate them during the code generation procedure. While
these models have been extensively assessed for their ability to produce
functionally correct programs, there remains a lack of comprehensive
investigations and benchmarks addressing the security aspects of these models.
In this work, we propose a method to systematically study the security issues
of code language models to assess their susceptibility to generating vulnerable
code. To this end, we introduce the first approach to automatically find
generated code that contains vulnerabilities in black-box code generation
models. To achieve this, we present an approach to approximate inversion of the
black-box code generation models based on few-shot prompting. We evaluate the
effectiveness of our approach by examining code language models in generating
high-risk security weaknesses. Furthermore, we establish a collection of
diverse non-secure prompts for various vulnerability scenarios using our
method. This dataset forms a benchmark for evaluating and comparing the
security weaknesses in code language models. | [
-0.3112190664,
-0.8648933172,
0.2844699025,
-0.3362236023,
-0.1933112592,
0.155948922,
-0.0439285971,
-0.2718227804,
-0.3091329038,
0.5755362511,
-0.4863352776,
-0.579728663,
-0.3826670647,
-0.0689273551,
-0.4021039009,
0.888825953,
0.0261078719,
0.0036478394,
-0.1206774563,
-0.0331747979,
-0.4646689892,
-0.8580782413,
-0.1797037572,
0.1420128644,
-0.0368640721,
0.241959393,
0.4749428332,
0.0998967066,
0.6017459631,
0.2427991033,
0.05465151,
-0.0334535949,
-0.6024467945,
0.1878886074,
-0.0255341008,
-0.5742548108,
-0.206215933,
-0.1820636839,
0.3062449694,
0.4383555949,
0.019851936,
0.5417873859,
-0.02416851,
0.5500987172,
-0.7188916802,
-0.2663135231,
-1.093991518,
-0.029601682,
-0.2483044714,
-0.3844894469,
-0.5451498628,
-0.4190246463,
-0.3631374538,
-0.0454987064,
0.3003974557,
0.159151718,
0.5534585118,
0.0087013394,
-0.3247081935,
-0.3558758199,
-0.508623004,
0.7146019936,
-0.8099424243,
0.2521860898,
0.3774313629,
0.3988919556,
-0.3003767133,
-0.411871165,
-0.2219553739,
-0.612778604,
0.0397769511,
-0.3535858095,
-0.2264474332,
-0.1934321821,
0.5662201047,
0.1910677701,
-1.0328067541,
0.049928382,
-0.4153809547,
-0.2517349124,
0.8364022374,
0.3297638893,
0.2046005726,
-0.208954975,
-0.3778788149,
-0.1390666217,
-0.9909230471,
0.1090950072,
0.8730288744,
0.1948519647,
-0.3235384822,
0.479760319,
0.0600029416,
0.6734859943,
-0.3749933839,
-0.0207262989,
0.2434449047,
-0.4816879332,
-0.1612302363,
-0.2928195,
0.6505525708,
0.2285711765,
0.1360200197,
-0.1404262781,
-0.3075460196,
0.182761997,
0.5300667882,
-0.5956654549,
-0.3091465235,
0.4522967041,
-0.6079114676,
-0.7158614397,
0.2285818756,
-0.7975639701,
-0.4022322893,
0.1851247847,
0.0037066448,
-0.2588929236,
-0.1688664556,
-0.3167544305,
-0.0417793281,
0.3024230897,
-0.047843352,
-0.383315593,
0.2166055143,
0.8096884489,
0.7139955759,
-0.2465484291,
-0.1717253178,
-0.6532477736,
-0.0878825858,
-0.4389622509,
0.5362376571,
-0.2261205316,
-0.4352281392,
0.1900445074,
-0.0545588918,
0.081519857,
-0.4791620672,
0.4077778459,
-0.4233659506,
-0.4889680147,
0.3657626808,
-0.535800755,
0.351034075,
0.5136035681,
-0.4315839112,
1.0774707794,
0.0188835505,
-0.7968252897,
-0.1420090795,
-0.4153068066,
-0.1355141252,
0.2563441396,
-0.3034840524,
-0.7065979242,
0.2520025373,
0.1047175005,
0.421616137,
-0.2599853575,
0.2972174883,
-0.5170634389,
-0.2398511469,
0.6344655752,
-0.4250775576,
0.932028234,
0.337010324,
-0.3108285069,
-0.0339285433,
-0.6761562228,
0.2596934438,
0.4511204362,
0.1452189982,
-0.4112288356,
-0.1867027432,
-0.0406389944,
0.1873891354,
0.1256513298,
-0.4433225989,
0.2610409856,
-0.3055241406,
0.3791831732,
0.7203968167,
0.3310543895,
0.2259857506,
-0.1755446047,
0.6999210715,
0.0099969227,
0.592597127,
-0.4948652089,
-0.3841991723,
-0.3254586756,
-0.005325688,
0.2153052688,
0.6081906557,
-0.6765039563,
0.3994199634,
0.1034043878,
-0.6410787702,
-0.4885867834,
0.4872946441,
0.6808152199,
0.2424211353,
0.0453617796,
-0.1455991715,
-0.4274274707,
-0.8390154243,
-0.2501310408,
-0.1920812577,
-0.0480566584,
0.2926213741,
0.7314280272,
-0.2375168651,
0.3805728853,
-0.5526785254,
0.217368409,
-0.0557114445,
0.162220493,
0.0020303489,
0.6958202124,
0.606918335,
-0.5601465106,
-0.0700835735,
-0.1683371067,
-0.7331479192,
-0.0602321625,
0.0390760265,
-0.1103477031,
0.4079656899,
0.6743727326,
-0.2103599012,
0.6913128495,
0.8798059821,
-0.1187706664,
0.7696501017,
-0.1443808675,
0.0089050708,
-0.8386682868,
0.3785944581,
-0.2956742346,
-0.2402594686,
-0.7886255383,
0.6807180643,
0.4434747398,
-0.6812717319,
-0.5856062174,
0.5682535172,
-0.5712279677,
-0.3777555823,
-0.0513678864,
-0.0214099698,
-0.1581226885,
0.514085114,
-0.3368227184,
0.8740598559,
0.6103698015,
-0.3636810482,
0.2825593054,
-0.1380344033,
-0.3714492023,
0.4451531172,
-0.5512400866,
0.6284806132,
0.2980392575,
0.0722011104,
-0.9372321367,
0.0829424411,
0.1788857728,
-0.5167277455,
0.1943280846,
-0.4288109541,
-0.5252398849,
-0.5044912696,
-0.5360136032,
0.525529623,
0.592464447,
-0.3173621595,
0.0737439096,
0.3785901964,
-0.1344521791,
-0.3672667146,
-0.5629581809,
0.1445557624,
-0.0624673702,
-0.6701482534,
0.0137706054,
-0.3214304447,
-0.3614121377,
-0.356267333,
-0.1265342683,
0.019913448,
0.4727337956,
0.4730023742,
0.5592606664,
-0.1957552731,
-0.1531578451,
-0.1974701434,
-0.2137827724,
0.0710398704,
-0.3146713376,
0.5063228011,
-0.3330754638,
-0.7690015435,
-0.1629414707,
0.4154248238,
0.2086150348,
-0.5206041932,
0.5070574284,
0.1114118025,
-0.2258306742,
-0.4643983841,
-0.5719313622,
-0.1906248778,
-0.4367054701,
0.0620011277,
-0.3735405505,
-0.6653607488,
0.5843415856,
-0.0335935839,
0.0151373865,
-0.0510836653,
0.6642772555,
0.0616247766,
0.8662285805,
0.4116494656,
-0.0039575165,
0.389567852,
-0.4142202139,
0.3301459849,
-0.4713208973,
-0.1108030155,
-0.7629576325,
0.1760604531,
-0.6538959742,
-0.5203791857,
0.3836797476,
0.171436578,
-0.0147653129,
0.6665952802,
-0.4421361685,
0.3681806326,
0.4521041811,
0.1253586262,
0.1338956803,
-0.2526205778,
-0.4079725444,
0.3993173242,
-0.6558709145,
-0.6011965275,
1.3228683472,
0.4301029742,
0.9439017177,
0.118507497,
1.0903908014,
0.4252580404,
0.0619479716,
-0.3075165153,
0.5281470418,
0.1445688903,
-0.4865113199,
-0.1581835598,
-0.4754348695,
-0.9639851451,
-0.1364207417,
-0.0781955644,
-0.8602835536,
0.1319139898,
0.1744841188,
-0.2801617682,
0.1527973562,
-0.8554579616,
1.1107178926,
-0.3716044426,
-0.5237142444,
-0.0148003753,
-0.5694339275,
0.6059523225,
-0.2448225915,
0.3263389766,
-0.1247364879,
-0.0290633887,
0.3570140302,
-0.5281241536,
0.7596401572,
-0.225444749,
-0.3122548759,
0.2485108376,
0.5329372287,
0.8524814248,
0.1756274253,
-0.1968334466,
0.4648821652,
-0.0540987253,
-0.5954219103,
-0.4527473748,
0.7554893494,
-0.4531675577,
-0.5602586269,
-0.1373522431,
-0.3024824262,
-0.1908550411,
-0.008209384,
0.2328425646,
0.4785135686,
-0.2637391686,
0.0222941674,
0.477878511,
-0.3414720595,
0.5418749452,
0.4249082804,
-0.1002464294,
-0.3544285595,
0.6487228274,
-0.1297581047,
0.4043521881,
0.049333863,
-0.0506321602,
0.0864752755,
-0.8926770091,
-0.3197990954,
0.0109504815,
-0.5817551613,
-0.6616352201,
-0.2731720209,
-0.4649812877,
-0.4426457882,
-0.3423836231,
-0.1927433163,
-0.2106422484,
0.082947515,
-0.130040884,
0.2301624566,
0.3811093271,
0.3713813424,
0.1176727936,
-1.0777142048,
0.3607369065,
0.1502804458,
0.3866079748,
-0.0854546651,
-0.3863171935,
-0.1902954429,
-0.1749264896,
-0.3434830904,
-1.0309414864,
0.3363837898,
-0.4034429193,
0.7795521617,
0.0856821612,
0.2905490398,
0.396766752,
-0.3754480481,
0.8654437065,
0.108229287,
-1.0354882479,
0.7936512232,
-0.2233102322,
0.1856009662,
0.6645647287,
0.0103102019,
-0.2550115883,
-0.7294427752,
-0.9024822116,
-0.6314088702,
0.638635993,
0.6776530743,
-0.02144951,
0.1155275479,
0.0830490515,
0.1995040029,
0.1540996879,
-0.6372401118,
-0.2998292744,
-0.2137988061,
0.0945516452,
0.0492890999,
-0.1773754209,
-0.2469451129,
0.2090090513,
0.4890727401,
-0.2887727618,
0.1801830679,
-0.139414981,
-0.4028780758,
-0.0943822563,
0.4287149608,
0.7410883904,
0.5100679398,
-0.1590348035,
0.3052921891,
0.1612202376,
-0.2555705011,
0.1978895366,
0.1135479435,
-0.2581495643,
-0.0455654152,
0.5339038372,
0.7082325816,
0.1303962767,
-0.9401907921,
0.8517447114,
-0.0410340913,
-0.1024337485,
-0.3798443079,
0.3068146706,
-0.114046298,
0.1596259624,
0.4248444736,
0.0625993907,
-0.0296325516,
-0.5210760236,
0.4277873933,
0.7368597984,
-0.0657499731,
-0.2450134605,
0.4042435586,
0.3185763955,
-0.6958842278,
0.4096779227,
-0.2064467371,
-0.4288026094,
1.0110318661,
0.4506931305,
1.0930197239,
-0.2718756199,
0.084597595,
0.4246763587,
0.5894727111,
0.1841736436,
0.1642754972,
-0.2147182226,
-0.4705050588,
0.1272692829,
-0.3745756149,
-0.3873871565,
0.0653204843,
-0.5335371494,
0.4259547591,
-0.4982329309,
-0.1641942561,
-0.0399886742,
-0.0197714567,
-0.7082926035,
-0.3580504656,
0.3376689553,
0.9777892828,
-0.9148033261,
0.9969566464,
0.4173657298,
-0.2792758048,
-0.5729107857,
0.1246278137,
0.1366639584,
-0.9794664979,
0.4449883103,
0.1131475568,
0.1369725764,
-0.3031309247,
-0.762598753,
-0.4306417406,
0.9181295633,
0.4405009747,
-0.8446917534,
0.1168934926,
0.2388258427,
0.394076705,
-0.3311738074,
0.2126611173,
0.483061105,
0.3006897271,
-0.2635444403,
-0.7027391791,
0.0881821364,
-0.3952369392,
0.2605825067,
0.3263737261,
-0.2585990131,
0.6694428921,
-0.1911249161,
-0.0980048403,
0.1974809915,
0.1123235747,
0.7477045059,
0.4719715118,
0.4293560088,
0.1114803478,
0.5898926258,
0.2312002778,
1.005969882,
-0.5647773147,
0.3857150674,
0.9706081152,
-0.4692557156,
0.852039516,
0.5552044511,
-0.2245021909,
0.2454189658,
0.2596378028,
-0.3279605508,
0.1886482239,
0.4314555526,
0.0506385826,
-0.0952623188,
0.2668121159,
-0.381315887,
0.1824087203,
0.0819977373,
-0.423514396,
-0.2722217441,
0.0479284413,
-0.048466254,
0.1016445234,
-0.2086686939,
0.917527914,
0.1977150887,
-0.6171588302,
0.9079663754,
0.0295615979,
0.5072981715,
-0.7888388634,
-0.0040211603,
-0.4534496367,
0.0902183801,
-0.1281191111,
-0.5823932886,
0.3583489656,
0.4533956349,
0.2535151839,
-0.0592094213,
0.7683087587,
-0.215591073,
-0.5484706759,
0.3542193472,
0.2916638255,
0.1210986152,
0.0854974017,
-0.938034296,
0.3742278516,
-0.0179103576,
-0.0872507021,
0.5356578231,
0.1055446193,
-0.1122110412,
0.5693277121,
0.7274711728,
0.0242865831,
0.21874623,
0.0668535754,
0.834443748,
-0.6740844846,
-0.4308055937,
-0.8361260295,
0.4535449147,
-0.1925977916,
-0.1528780013,
0.8284321427,
0.7052056193,
0.7644798756,
-0.1938247681,
0.7447947264,
0.0865798965,
0.1745547652,
-0.6256566644,
0.5153669119,
-0.2598846257,
0.6148763895,
-0.4610310197,
-0.7389444113,
-0.2127479911,
0.091007337,
-0.2405339479,
-0.1358379275,
0.7388992906,
1.4458557367,
0.0185803585,
-0.1754083037,
0.5860011578,
0.0037162018,
0.3018563688,
0.5493223071,
0.8504155874,
-0.6190660596,
0.6996979117,
-0.3991270065,
-0.0977759361,
-0.4347870648,
-0.9998888969,
-1.0004429817,
-0.4339318573,
-0.3276432753,
-0.3686252236,
0.4403096735,
0.8371565342,
0.663182199,
-0.9744428396,
-0.3079206347,
-0.143794015,
0.2679644823,
-0.27747944,
-0.1794914752,
0.2377763242,
-0.3394096494,
-0.1901347339,
0.3639680445,
0.1890180707,
0.1421850771,
-0.4794727266,
-0.08050441,
0.0801513568,
0.0879601389,
0.2091257125,
0.3165005147,
-0.5651574135,
-0.0986309573,
-0.0760048479,
-0.3849717379,
-0.0568332225,
1.2547185421,
-0.4726078808,
0.2560485601,
0.51371032,
0.6777094007,
0.5015305281,
-0.0183652528,
0.4139819145,
-0.9887875319,
0.4064027071,
0.1983637512,
0.2453926951,
0.1876951009,
-0.3486956358,
0.553217411,
0.093031317,
-0.4216774404,
-1.2503211498,
0.308875978,
-0.7816570997,
-0.4924768806,
1.0737736225,
-0.4081907272,
-0.3736762404,
-0.1782714576,
-0.1222254187,
-0.077384226,
-0.2187718153,
0.4887693524,
0.3377091289,
0.1253278702,
-0.2839856148,
-0.6104408503,
0.3385507762,
0.0343473442,
-1.0636454821,
0.5000730753,
0.3188079,
0.1575204432,
-0.0218240693,
0.4764739871,
-0.2563002706,
0.3948648572,
0.3137003779,
0.2034411579,
-0.2301172167,
-0.1224170402,
-0.6882437468,
0.3858673871,
0.1341598034,
-0.1130920649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04001v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04001v1 | Leveraging Summary Guidance on Medical Report Summarization | 2023-02-08T11:21:58 | 2023-02-08T11:21:58 | Yunqi Zhu, Xuebing Yang, Yuanyuan Wu, Wensheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study presents three deidentified large medical text datasets, named
DISCHARGE, ECHO and RADIOLOGY, which contain 50K, 16K and 378K pairs of report
and summary that are derived from MIMIC-III, respectively. We implement
convincing baselines of automated abstractive summarization on the proposed
datasets with pre-trained encoder-decoder language models, including BERT2BERT,
T5-large and BART. Further, based on the BART model, we leverage the sampled
summaries from the train set as prior knowledge guidance, for encoding
additional contextual representations of the guidance with the encoder and
enhancing the decoding representations in the decoder. The experimental results
confirm the improvement of ROUGE scores and BERTScore made by the proposed
method, outperforming the larger model T5-large. | [
-0.0627985969,
-0.2293523699,
0.8675037026,
0.1422012299,
-0.490074873,
-0.203704372,
0.0307600442,
-0.3880240321,
0.5867637396,
0.7846538424,
-0.1187459081,
-0.807390213,
-0.7940617204,
0.3617071211,
-0.3681097925,
1.4029675722,
-0.009686647,
0.4172542393,
-0.0069822385,
-0.102635242,
-0.5517195463,
-0.5121387839,
-0.5385154486,
-0.2466856092,
0.6233600974,
0.3458620012,
0.510284543,
0.7136108279,
0.8414395452,
0.1210911572,
-0.0044159275,
0.43373698,
-0.2247649282,
0.1850871146,
0.0947787017,
-0.4432797134,
-0.9688282609,
-0.3220311105,
0.4737522304,
0.7192643881,
-0.1716727912,
-0.0131369205,
0.0542613417,
0.7974308133,
-0.5182181001,
0.3367491961,
0.0877678916,
-0.208807677,
0.1860182732,
-0.6501945853,
-0.6144109964,
-0.5827882886,
0.2136810124,
-0.7375189662,
0.0390546098,
-0.0448497273,
0.8574328423,
0.2630799413,
-0.5167259574,
-0.3947377503,
-0.5041603446,
0.5121883154,
-0.8222077489,
-0.210380286,
0.7081782222,
0.4577577114,
0.1562953591,
-1.0123872757,
0.2194016874,
0.1282496005,
-0.6187400818,
0.689007163,
-0.2481879741,
0.4266908169,
0.0492769368,
0.3356805146,
-0.4281629622,
-0.0619414225,
-0.7522922754,
-0.0839291364,
0.6525279284,
0.5543493629,
0.1638633609,
-0.0551095009,
0.1287537515,
-0.0827079788,
-0.5970602632,
-0.4815381169,
-0.1904679835,
0.158403635,
-0.5446525216,
0.4074302018,
-0.1247083172,
0.5734062791,
0.009834121,
-0.2033910304,
0.4312732518,
-0.4463505149,
-0.2364410311,
0.1759858578,
0.6992252469,
0.9111041427,
0.3893657029,
-0.0198531691,
-0.2321820706,
-0.4677611589,
0.3885165453,
-0.95201689,
-0.4154799581,
0.226489231,
-1.1319957972,
-0.1814342588,
0.1121984348,
-0.6189585328,
-0.3610649109,
-0.5321289897,
0.2393234968,
-0.6133083105,
-0.0836027265,
0.1990611702,
-0.3496572375,
0.0319286957,
0.5502424836,
-0.8297108412,
0.5902834535,
0.3058329523,
0.9551599026,
0.1421258599,
0.0493452512,
-0.4017693102,
0.4580947757,
-0.4067857862,
0.6888979077,
-0.5250585079,
-0.7469705343,
-0.0038108502,
0.1032101065,
0.1165807471,
-0.5721438527,
0.3070044219,
-0.2533099055,
0.4148644209,
-0.3516390324,
-0.4503522217,
-0.4973757267,
0.0883353278,
-0.6095478535,
0.3402751982,
0.1614591926,
-0.848757863,
0.4418802261,
-0.5875537395,
-0.7728053927,
-0.1877996624,
-0.2753101587,
-0.2754760385,
0.1140417606,
0.8526299596,
0.6991428137,
-0.0993957296,
0.1395165026,
0.301887244,
-0.5383381844,
-0.4588816166,
-0.0428374149,
0.5812272429,
0.1053982526,
0.0755625516,
0.2262778878,
-0.4704948962,
-0.2430641204,
-0.1913155615,
-0.1781404912,
-0.5715941191,
-0.1274611801,
-0.0533758365,
-0.2614464164,
0.1309299618,
0.0864425004,
0.2315034866,
-0.3984113634,
-0.2005314827,
0.4234508872,
0.5097100735,
0.2265775949,
-0.6309360266,
0.7847414613,
-0.0651705414,
-0.1050709412,
-1.0068440437,
-0.5542703271,
-0.275260359,
-0.5409796834,
0.3960894644,
0.4132716954,
-0.4417640567,
0.3534451723,
-0.4062695801,
-0.1507145613,
-0.5366076231,
-0.5757704973,
0.4271089435,
0.5378208756,
0.7796322107,
0.0233418867,
-0.8426654935,
-1.0262132883,
0.0943457857,
0.0304166023,
-0.4228583276,
0.171872139,
0.4765876234,
-0.326087445,
0.6735363603,
-0.7945364118,
-0.6301639676,
-0.5307707191,
0.3444536924,
0.4160489738,
0.2458423972,
0.6632720232,
-0.3364658356,
-0.3573811054,
0.0908587798,
-1.0303009748,
-0.1397844702,
-0.1769408286,
0.1342386007,
0.1123037115,
0.6927303076,
0.0869724154,
0.310659796,
0.4233032763,
-0.1424422115,
0.3815359771,
-0.8843790889,
0.5634864569,
-1.5709888935,
0.2548307776,
-0.0876032189,
-0.4583973289,
-0.1638658643,
-0.255195111,
0.1173552349,
0.3058435917,
0.348369509,
0.3383170962,
-0.7553281188,
0.2220689505,
-0.2839420438,
-0.0853182003,
0.0657692924,
0.2303613126,
0.3060658872,
0.4140997231,
0.4922001064,
-0.7417119741,
0.0669355467,
0.1722073704,
0.1384502798,
0.1500634849,
-0.7815263867,
-0.3284451067,
-0.4300079048,
0.6707860231,
-0.7161852121,
-0.6347827315,
-0.1353578418,
-0.3887705505,
0.495333463,
-0.1619843543,
-0.5047648549,
-0.1722892821,
-0.5106197596,
0.4225473702,
0.9260776639,
-0.2443570644,
0.651252389,
0.358599633,
-0.3685383201,
-0.4854514003,
-0.7455537319,
0.0052431785,
-0.1840983629,
-0.0444280989,
0.4426675141,
0.2646702528,
-0.2896825671,
-0.0582868345,
0.1517568678,
-0.0942638442,
-0.3964699507,
0.3134506047,
0.4541518986,
-0.2445633113,
0.1927637458,
0.3110871613,
-0.1656514704,
0.4175434113,
0.2063770741,
0.3621549904,
0.1748516858,
-0.1956999451,
-0.3378796279,
0.4059173763,
0.590550065,
0.1035973728,
0.6879383922,
0.2930149734,
-0.4415512979,
0.1527885795,
-0.3582833409,
-0.4781972766,
-0.3412673771,
0.5127411485,
0.0397380479,
-0.364713788,
0.6683987975,
-0.1009895205,
0.2533050179,
0.4658873975,
0.4171510339,
-0.2443296611,
1.216065526,
0.5338215232,
-0.223367855,
0.1087249443,
-0.3995356858,
-0.2111583352,
-0.718266964,
-0.3349614143,
-0.1981664598,
-0.006898337,
-0.3254785836,
-0.2197280973,
0.8672952056,
-0.2327228487,
0.2024051845,
-0.0347930826,
-0.5432554483,
0.66226089,
0.2287018001,
0.290938139,
0.4944728017,
-0.0742426887,
-0.0339312591,
-0.0761793628,
-0.5577890277,
-0.5190376043,
1.468159914,
0.3790875375,
0.8406710625,
-0.0796185359,
0.8017334938,
0.3260249794,
0.2265767008,
-0.6885175109,
0.307895273,
-0.442825824,
-0.2839923203,
0.0744669437,
-0.215334788,
-0.8791493773,
0.1420140564,
-0.0242930055,
-0.2955000997,
-0.1207343265,
0.3347459435,
-0.4924760759,
-0.0525177158,
-0.6368511319,
0.168576166,
0.0536266714,
0.256773293,
-0.4735454023,
-0.8375587463,
0.5509446859,
0.069660686,
0.3296901584,
0.4250933528,
-0.1881064773,
0.879065454,
-0.5538721681,
0.7387227416,
-0.1270145476,
-0.1718938649,
-0.1628109515,
-0.3293426335,
0.3046903014,
0.1179321334,
0.1849978268,
0.0786899477,
0.1415376812,
-0.2223777175,
-0.4698164165,
0.272141546,
-0.3688546121,
-0.1530125886,
-0.2515231967,
-0.596784234,
-0.0740116462,
0.2040120363,
0.763466239,
1.0261839628,
-0.1262949258,
0.0818057507,
0.6341729164,
-0.3500560224,
0.2509231269,
0.4793590009,
-0.2791790366,
-0.6622778177,
0.5409978628,
0.0193560589,
0.1474167854,
0.6178990006,
0.0907519087,
-0.1546152532,
-0.6735352278,
-0.3239642084,
0.5054606795,
-0.6526270509,
-0.322360456,
-0.7378501892,
-0.3072579205,
-0.3642424345,
-0.3479548693,
-0.0294334888,
-0.3255185187,
-0.0986845195,
-0.017731104,
0.4001230299,
1.2582337856,
-0.0242613629,
0.4159941375,
-0.904366672,
0.4527388513,
-0.2141517401,
0.1219777018,
-0.0134704877,
-0.6974989176,
-0.7409949899,
-0.1008047462,
-0.0104287099,
-0.9315487146,
0.4332287312,
-0.1335196197,
0.4283273518,
0.8159272671,
0.2332429737,
0.7828284502,
-0.4640185237,
0.680993557,
0.2270411551,
-0.4829575419,
0.8339009285,
-0.7232013941,
0.6146190763,
0.4806367755,
0.4119734466,
-0.1383132637,
-0.7679945827,
-0.4344527125,
-0.8841364384,
0.9104421735,
0.1514472067,
-0.1501587778,
-0.0290254932,
0.2648339868,
0.1014453843,
-0.1215308681,
-0.213815406,
-0.3194929659,
0.0053399839,
-0.6583135724,
-0.0256124679,
-0.4497048855,
-0.4345554709,
-0.2942366898,
0.5418343544,
-0.0944231525,
0.2383265644,
0.3531750441,
0.0418845713,
0.2958197892,
-0.0228860192,
0.6868221164,
0.9241169095,
-0.4619734883,
0.0085006682,
0.2237254381,
-0.911244452,
-0.184801802,
0.0170815606,
0.1808609366,
0.3913049996,
1.0291397572,
0.2558766305,
0.0661892816,
-0.6485224962,
0.5538554192,
-0.2123844326,
-0.4028066695,
-0.1898759156,
-0.0591079146,
-0.151844278,
-0.1949025244,
0.4485142827,
-0.0594575927,
0.6388092637,
-0.1591719687,
0.1642983556,
-0.0322081894,
-0.2670333385,
-0.3135932982,
0.4800333679,
0.1998327225,
0.4903960824,
0.3160376251,
0.3747936189,
-0.0568301007,
0.6383774281,
0.4845785499,
0.6719635725,
-0.2455131859,
0.1006330326,
0.8537567258,
0.2215104103,
-0.3431310356,
0.116134651,
-0.0063046049,
-0.1691679806,
-0.5099324584,
-0.0163848922,
-0.3227975667,
0.2310106009,
-1.1845123768,
0.3431480229,
-0.3250502646,
-0.0277477559,
-0.1099221185,
-0.5517811775,
0.0198130943,
0.3035753071,
-0.0818552449,
0.7154759765,
-0.5129699707,
0.4483355582,
0.8070582747,
-0.552002728,
-0.8547865748,
0.3419596553,
-0.1015803069,
-0.6998745203,
0.588178277,
0.172385186,
-0.3683592677,
-0.3501153886,
-0.2780684233,
-0.5069594979,
1.1063069105,
0.2112599909,
-0.404402703,
-0.4508360028,
-0.3414515853,
0.6324016452,
-0.4151597917,
0.7534970045,
0.5884848833,
0.2221085727,
0.1183542609,
-1.113604188,
0.0659346133,
-0.394317627,
-0.4357423782,
0.2392981946,
-0.24459517,
0.57348001,
-0.5823609829,
-0.2058138996,
-0.0694962665,
0.3254159391,
0.1327085048,
0.1854677349,
0.0768784285,
0.132895112,
0.5547782183,
0.1326221377,
1.2985191345,
-0.2375217974,
-0.1140252575,
1.2552355528,
0.2111128122,
0.5098426938,
0.0636539161,
0.0657062307,
0.6175773144,
0.4612607658,
0.1588243842,
0.7755687833,
-0.1591780037,
-0.1122918576,
0.0034525925,
0.0792148709,
-0.8206553459,
0.2530849576,
0.5334442258,
-1.1406928301,
-0.3508921862,
-0.0155094136,
0.2763620317,
0.0403479338,
-0.4773762226,
1.1929033995,
0.1366054863,
-0.7155256867,
0.6842902899,
0.0169551913,
0.4839935303,
-0.7837834358,
-0.4735620022,
-0.3017315567,
0.2651897371,
-0.4863820374,
-0.6183184385,
0.286495924,
0.0215907283,
-0.33646065,
-0.2011431754,
0.2492047995,
-0.2828150988,
-0.3739575446,
0.2158940583,
0.1402592212,
0.2073781639,
0.2712857723,
0.0338068716,
-0.35967803,
0.0213653166,
0.0608296096,
0.0705270916,
0.332123518,
-0.0762278363,
0.4842127562,
0.0896175653,
0.4200935364,
-0.4828337729,
0.3648038208,
1.0956954956,
-0.5493240356,
-0.8880833983,
-0.8946438432,
0.5487393141,
-0.2188024968,
-0.1690508127,
0.6490495801,
0.7631656528,
0.1683098972,
-0.1665101349,
0.8449349403,
0.1998095363,
0.7863794565,
-0.8431838751,
0.81965065,
-0.5482258797,
0.49997437,
-0.3279343843,
-0.4561013281,
-0.4327118993,
0.4372794926,
-0.183593154,
0.2231395096,
0.9227184653,
0.5085551739,
-0.0157082193,
-0.085070245,
0.0562789291,
0.1867702305,
0.0851031318,
0.2995282114,
0.4156042933,
-0.2569905818,
0.3762968779,
0.0825763792,
-0.4482980669,
-0.3975202441,
-0.4995730817,
-1.176060915,
-0.5715410709,
-0.145442754,
-0.2696212828,
0.2423983067,
0.6625744104,
0.8793151975,
-0.7728325129,
-0.0804523453,
0.1261842996,
-0.3284950256,
-0.2400761247,
-0.1834461391,
0.7285014987,
-0.4073022306,
-0.5066525936,
0.1182258055,
0.2906577587,
0.2658427656,
0.1133989841,
-0.1879321039,
0.3675117493,
-0.1531834751,
0.5286733508,
-0.1237785071,
-0.5729447007,
0.2770896852,
-0.1211260781,
-0.1758438647,
-0.0985779762,
1.0276581049,
-0.9843534231,
0.5090069771,
0.3255778253,
0.2444694489,
0.4292571843,
0.4082911909,
1.1192220449,
-0.7584754825,
0.0245399419,
0.3640231192,
0.3836645484,
0.0109875668,
-0.5314616561,
0.4299553633,
-0.344774425,
-0.3298374712,
-0.531678021,
-0.200801149,
-0.805416584,
-0.3379217982,
1.0131927729,
-0.1270654947,
0.1251837313,
-0.3390773535,
-0.491355449,
0.1824538261,
-0.5128934979,
0.6883731484,
0.301532656,
-0.3918459415,
-0.2251622975,
-0.4046489,
0.6925808191,
0.1958545595,
-1.0292588472,
0.1022302136,
0.7565006018,
0.1118844524,
0.0843589529,
1.0111489296,
-0.4467755258,
0.4205101728,
-0.0743096918,
-0.1647572815,
-0.2606693804,
-0.4543451369,
-0.4981641769,
0.0293470733,
-0.2110531479,
-0.3589579165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06476v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06476v3 | Is ChatGPT a General-Purpose Natural Language Processing Task Solver? | 2023-02-08T09:44:51 | 2023-11-19T15:43:58 | Chengwei Qin, Aston Zhang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Jiaao Chen, Michihiro Yasunaga, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spurred by advancements in scale, large language models (LLMs) have
demonstrated the ability to perform a variety of natural language processing
(NLP) tasks zero-shot -- i.e., without adaptation on downstream data. Recently,
the debut of ChatGPT has drawn a great deal of attention from the natural
language processing (NLP) community due to the fact that it can generate
high-quality responses to human input and self-correct previous mistakes based
on subsequent conversations. However, it is not yet known whether ChatGPT can
serve as a generalist model that can perform many NLP tasks zero-shot. In this
work, we empirically analyze the zero-shot learning ability of ChatGPT by
evaluating it on 20 popular NLP datasets covering 7 representative task
categories. With extensive empirical studies, we demonstrate both the
effectiveness and limitations of the current version of ChatGPT. We find that
ChatGPT performs well on many tasks favoring reasoning capabilities (e.g.,
arithmetic reasoning) while it still faces challenges when solving specific
tasks such as sequence tagging. We additionally provide in-depth analysis
through qualitative case studies. | [
-0.1216375232,
-1.1227796078,
0.5194914937,
0.2134342045,
-0.351631403,
0.0664002299,
-0.3280106783,
-0.4985412955,
-0.0109718703,
0.2942401469,
-0.5597091913,
-0.4140968025,
-0.6842442751,
0.0891692564,
-0.4711543918,
1.2778587341,
0.1474228501,
-0.2952990234,
0.1621126235,
0.2716396749,
-0.8183299303,
-0.6674546003,
-1.1051148176,
-0.282255888,
0.4727211893,
0.4409050047,
0.5975491405,
0.3222200274,
0.7048394084,
0.1957846284,
0.0004441799,
-0.0955749005,
-0.4397250712,
0.3910248578,
-0.2155451924,
-0.4518721104,
-0.3223367035,
-0.1493336111,
0.5366084576,
0.5535025597,
-0.3195151389,
0.0938571841,
0.2210619897,
0.5729392171,
-0.4314328432,
0.3269585967,
-1.0524092913,
0.1397496015,
-0.1868239641,
-0.2054482102,
-0.4024423659,
0.0485409535,
0.3848672807,
-0.5616935492,
0.6907724738,
0.0888344496,
0.6692852378,
0.4571839571,
-0.3641686141,
-0.46055004,
-0.9433653951,
0.7854260802,
-0.6768001318,
0.090502508,
0.1326439977,
0.3679734766,
-0.4060634971,
-0.4502781332,
-0.4123870134,
-0.1196595579,
0.1418570876,
0.1521386653,
-0.3629505038,
0.2122813612,
0.3428534269,
0.3961601555,
-1.0132068396,
-0.0046220482,
-0.2229288369,
-0.1430926621,
0.2680960298,
0.1973026544,
0.5027961135,
-0.2269435525,
-0.2614228725,
0.2501434088,
-0.4301605225,
0.1793957949,
-0.0719323382,
0.4095441997,
0.100863196,
0.7518989444,
-0.5169953108,
0.7875242233,
-0.3579579592,
0.0836645588,
-0.1264293045,
0.1120386943,
-0.4488156438,
-0.1313653886,
0.9207456112,
0.1818614602,
0.5336596966,
-0.4493196607,
0.027525181,
0.1230128184,
0.3785942197,
-0.619459331,
-0.2964051664,
0.3197461963,
0.2657339275,
-0.0939441919,
-0.5152152777,
-0.4513015151,
-0.1537575126,
-0.3829370439,
0.5423409939,
-0.7142320871,
-0.1251369715,
0.4088608623,
-0.2343587428,
0.5837955475,
0.5313745141,
-0.8421986699,
0.2440363467,
0.846191287,
1.1323189735,
-0.1893906891,
-0.0823037773,
-0.4280958772,
-0.0797160566,
-0.2303711027,
1.1824871302,
-0.6444904804,
-0.3835915327,
-0.2188796103,
-0.2447801381,
-0.458232671,
-0.35087502,
0.8138045669,
-0.3885340095,
0.1873880476,
-0.1693076491,
-0.655451715,
-0.1123182103,
0.6099848151,
-0.299679935,
0.8398138285,
-0.2685135305,
-0.7139267325,
0.2552729249,
-0.7377432585,
-0.2557244897,
0.3576185703,
-0.1262304038,
-0.2499746978,
0.0795667917,
0.2582257986,
0.495225817,
-0.262403667,
0.4119288623,
-0.0507217571,
-0.5455181003,
-0.0010459527,
-0.7148026228,
0.5284051299,
0.0675701946,
-0.2887646556,
-0.1356386393,
-0.5089805126,
0.0946978256,
0.3889170587,
-0.3287545145,
0.0862094089,
0.1555294693,
-0.2673711181,
0.1982272565,
-0.0416671969,
-0.7281850576,
0.4001682997,
-0.4417213798,
0.4092549384,
0.3947144747,
0.1039830148,
0.2565641105,
-0.2910362184,
0.5635181069,
-0.2759399414,
-0.1622334123,
-0.3211106062,
-1.0520017147,
-0.8901624084,
-0.187883541,
0.1820483506,
0.9270715117,
-0.7267709374,
0.123208724,
-0.1947658062,
-0.5186947584,
-0.2440239638,
-0.0669457242,
0.3825721741,
0.6288049221,
0.4354645312,
-0.1788484901,
-0.3628427088,
-0.8936881423,
-0.4697063565,
-0.0475892685,
-0.4417542219,
0.1789102405,
0.4221337438,
0.085437201,
1.1673293114,
-0.4810453653,
-0.5806958079,
-0.3020281196,
0.5363071561,
0.4118041396,
0.2100259662,
0.2924595773,
-0.4607453644,
-0.5787814856,
0.0588749498,
-0.8301379681,
-0.0736367255,
-0.076713033,
0.0433281437,
0.2252223939,
0.1436696053,
-0.8488049507,
0.3524333239,
0.5613206029,
-0.1465893537,
0.7950965762,
-0.2731814981,
-0.0119534163,
-0.734947741,
0.1541555077,
0.1830533892,
-0.1633938104,
-1.015280962,
-0.0894789174,
-0.1745201498,
-0.4954014122,
-0.3969718814,
0.4420104623,
-0.1022717506,
0.0766851604,
-0.4801943004,
0.211556837,
-0.2778749168,
0.807559669,
0.3963233829,
0.6367949843,
0.570940733,
-0.4883547425,
0.2660968602,
0.0984334275,
0.0010436253,
0.4551089406,
-0.9696944356,
0.410248071,
-0.2858949304,
0.1283787042,
-1.0783237219,
-0.2586105168,
0.4843067825,
-0.5993869901,
0.1816308796,
-0.4617242515,
-0.3021060228,
-0.2798795104,
0.1080600843,
0.0305475071,
0.498465836,
-0.0831940249,
0.3721872866,
-0.0600445531,
-0.3300639689,
-0.5473536849,
-0.4035687149,
0.3545556962,
-0.0325549804,
-0.4707266986,
0.1404498816,
-0.0439271443,
0.0852127448,
-0.0101025682,
-0.1904664636,
-0.225695923,
-0.0273764152,
0.1763035357,
0.1150565594,
-0.1547792107,
0.3201531172,
-0.5055810809,
-0.393566668,
-0.1029259264,
-0.1587722003,
0.6799576879,
-0.3815954626,
-0.6617143154,
-0.2024966031,
0.2608938813,
0.0099245198,
-0.3049283028,
0.4856444299,
0.594299078,
-0.1146657169,
-0.2584545612,
-0.534540534,
0.244972229,
-0.420332849,
0.4671354592,
-0.2556600571,
-1.1645735502,
0.2791000605,
0.2271150798,
0.3128201067,
0.4032628834,
0.4637039006,
-0.1138637587,
0.7526764274,
0.4186701477,
-0.1920655668,
0.2105159611,
-0.0342429392,
0.5501019359,
-0.5756452084,
-0.0232656319,
-0.5445674062,
-0.336135447,
-0.4733559191,
-0.4226756692,
0.2566067278,
0.0800432637,
-0.3962551355,
0.3513224721,
-0.7581487894,
0.6484537125,
0.6588028073,
-0.0311784968,
0.5229775906,
-0.0598846041,
0.3663107455,
0.0651137605,
-0.5925664902,
-0.4640913904,
0.9850421548,
0.1483694017,
0.4178203642,
0.0948617533,
0.6503896117,
0.2289272249,
0.1068839431,
-1.0527402163,
0.5732417107,
-0.223710686,
-0.6550514698,
-0.3971751928,
-0.4154927135,
-1.1647386551,
0.4272042811,
-0.0036591578,
-1.0183498859,
-0.3123319745,
0.178161636,
-0.11332459,
0.3906052411,
-1.0544859171,
0.9426719546,
-0.0541346408,
0.0040053278,
0.0952925161,
-0.4561754465,
0.4092522562,
-0.0193453096,
0.0465908423,
-0.6529944539,
0.0852350295,
0.4935441315,
0.0172362514,
0.9607391357,
-0.1916632354,
0.0732646212,
0.3583357036,
0.3021809757,
0.3732510805,
-0.202895537,
0.0888562277,
0.1823831052,
0.0597810447,
-0.4937186539,
-0.7404432893,
0.4132270217,
-0.4851773083,
-0.9378969669,
-0.5487833619,
-0.5625002384,
-0.3730751574,
0.134681955,
0.1878231615,
0.345538944,
-0.3029111624,
0.1485601962,
0.4783287942,
-0.1485240906,
0.5451017618,
0.52847296,
-0.242660895,
0.0736121535,
0.950935483,
0.1181838736,
0.3734865785,
0.4153413475,
0.1111081243,
-0.0169252679,
-0.6853490472,
-0.4321582913,
0.0546392389,
-0.4683766961,
-0.1338244379,
-0.707550168,
-0.4622661471,
-0.0027579777,
-0.1530022323,
-0.2903472185,
-0.3774695992,
0.0512480214,
0.2180942744,
0.2536717355,
0.5687918067,
0.2337764651,
0.4160663188,
-0.6688633561,
0.4914732873,
0.6377765536,
0.4076057673,
-0.1668250263,
-0.4830252528,
0.0506740659,
0.3711166084,
-0.4290241599,
-0.6887362599,
0.4502328336,
0.4648417532,
0.4575279951,
0.0209703241,
0.0083166696,
0.4090248048,
-0.6128643155,
0.9656859636,
0.0964625254,
-0.754537642,
0.5246601105,
-0.6992521286,
0.6363625526,
0.143829152,
0.3694368899,
-0.9530787468,
-0.4810857773,
-0.5475921631,
-0.6688565016,
0.6566408277,
0.550409615,
0.1530184448,
-0.0892144665,
0.3931770027,
-0.1642793715,
0.0754209831,
-0.7243014574,
-0.0275843535,
-0.2288823128,
0.0029357907,
-0.1010590792,
-0.1659586132,
0.3241943419,
0.0028696924,
0.6438043714,
-0.2659447193,
0.4985853136,
0.2588007152,
-0.1164285615,
0.2062401921,
0.8802438378,
0.2923720479,
0.2639024258,
-0.5085858703,
0.0607715547,
0.2140233219,
-0.509898901,
0.1433578879,
-0.0043423446,
-0.1856262386,
0.0034396222,
0.2750882208,
0.6015995741,
0.3673641682,
-0.6547420621,
0.5531134605,
-0.0672021136,
-0.4172233939,
-0.1110114753,
0.3313736022,
0.1992424428,
0.1649113744,
0.4581864774,
0.0943018273,
0.150635004,
-0.4021288753,
0.030258568,
0.6251482368,
-0.4207909107,
-0.3305395544,
0.63456738,
0.0335359983,
-0.5861694813,
0.81650424,
-0.4336004853,
-0.4964309931,
0.4888424873,
0.642157495,
0.9139124155,
-0.0204411577,
0.4657723904,
0.2794578671,
0.2491332889,
0.0087399147,
-0.0396402031,
-0.0582638755,
-1.0300824642,
-1.056419611,
-0.6833519936,
-0.7983393669,
0.1291412562,
-0.3261168003,
0.1793609858,
-0.3257430196,
-0.1324045956,
0.151372388,
-0.0908343866,
-0.805762589,
0.1424399167,
0.2374146581,
0.5892351866,
-0.520530045,
0.8121608496,
0.5186952949,
-0.3896788955,
-0.6743862033,
-0.0631538406,
0.153771624,
-0.9310116768,
0.6064397693,
0.2152242362,
-0.1250967532,
0.0996397957,
-0.5659723878,
-0.7190918326,
0.82293576,
0.5862118006,
-0.5159508586,
-0.3694534302,
0.6941101551,
0.7053596973,
0.0953611955,
0.3235233426,
0.5008762479,
0.1216113865,
0.4142712057,
-1.2492673397,
-0.3429573178,
-0.2442130595,
-0.1335253567,
0.2903490365,
-0.36530599,
0.6448907256,
0.0379774347,
-0.3385134637,
-0.2818623483,
0.1777403951,
0.1604844034,
0.1547366232,
0.2689039111,
0.6765953302,
0.5138241053,
-0.2061702162,
0.9558044672,
0.1202655584,
0.5200536251,
1.1730819941,
-0.2729410529,
0.9941455722,
0.1967111975,
-0.323464781,
0.2817971706,
0.2912638485,
-0.0125751588,
0.2705021799,
0.0719825774,
-0.383387655,
-0.4366611242,
-0.0313266255,
-0.083601661,
0.5170013905,
0.3422985971,
0.1148326322,
-0.7371647358,
-0.2294384837,
0.0721253529,
-0.3367673457,
-0.3381186426,
0.8517303467,
0.0323359482,
-0.6073461771,
0.4008328915,
-0.224652797,
0.7465025187,
-0.7257161736,
-0.1291244179,
-0.0101675969,
0.0263301507,
-0.0976500362,
-1.0406315327,
0.6535024047,
0.1219869778,
0.0083874129,
-0.2007852644,
1.0829149485,
-0.0860389397,
-0.3434004784,
0.0056378483,
0.7245589495,
0.2453129888,
-0.7090272903,
-0.5890856385,
-0.4182201028,
0.1643895656,
-0.3091525435,
0.4939470291,
0.4990515709,
0.2589814663,
0.9033668637,
0.7194100618,
-0.044793658,
0.0851407275,
-0.2056652606,
0.5450786948,
-0.8082422018,
-0.2065116763,
-0.9034839869,
0.5548186302,
0.0404954553,
-0.265768528,
0.6681454778,
0.3715518415,
0.7182229161,
-0.0189891551,
0.8928261995,
-0.1127032861,
0.7168269157,
-0.4155143201,
0.1970656365,
-0.082571514,
0.169292748,
-0.1164649576,
-0.9820461273,
-0.6567080021,
0.497756809,
-0.7496800423,
-0.1905353516,
0.5523763299,
0.6110973358,
0.0209955648,
0.3936342597,
0.5510918498,
-0.1751198322,
0.6336174607,
0.7220952511,
0.7272124887,
-0.132100448,
0.8877027631,
-0.1869415194,
-0.0636597276,
0.0228979252,
-1.0071663857,
-0.8578178883,
-0.3303502202,
-0.2577753067,
0.2957849205,
0.2370859534,
0.8360244632,
0.4226945639,
-0.7454426289,
-0.0265650153,
-0.3864845335,
-0.1198995933,
-0.028177971,
-0.2598885298,
0.2024867088,
-0.997725606,
-0.63775599,
0.2779041529,
0.4869961739,
-0.2006710023,
0.142282933,
0.2105154544,
-0.057398051,
-0.057288602,
0.7210876942,
0.482062459,
-0.6500657201,
-0.5975562334,
0.0772530884,
0.2454283983,
0.3867173791,
0.8168616295,
-0.7447299361,
0.4621586204,
0.1763772219,
0.7147162557,
0.6806201935,
-0.0366062336,
0.5150694251,
-0.8902449608,
-0.0362388007,
0.2638128102,
0.3452240527,
0.1763509065,
-0.0387754254,
0.6742158532,
0.2479484081,
-1.0442596674,
-0.3120010793,
0.136255011,
-1.0590820312,
-0.1120535135,
1.2389557362,
-0.0492521189,
-0.0384698771,
-0.4475760162,
-0.5689983368,
0.0784529746,
-0.5126414895,
0.6287468672,
0.7549576163,
-0.4031775892,
-0.339336127,
-0.9366105199,
0.2471417785,
0.28666085,
-0.6871188879,
0.1045393422,
0.356934756,
0.4030620158,
0.1362273544,
0.7856065631,
0.247788623,
0.0044370997,
-0.1289235204,
0.1423938274,
-0.0438046195,
0.0631915554,
-0.2205363959,
0.2784241438,
0.2554306388,
-0.1474594921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03950v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03950v1 | Improving (Dis)agreement Detection with Inductive Social Relation Information From Comment-Reply Interactions | 2023-02-08T09:09:47 | 2023-02-08T09:09:47 | Yun Luo, Zihan Liu, Stan Z. Li, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | (Dis)agreement detection aims to identify the authors' attitudes or positions
(\textit{{agree, disagree, neutral}}) towards a specific text. It is limited
for existing methods merely using textual information for identifying
(dis)agreements, especially for cross-domain settings. Social relation
information can play an assistant role in the (dis)agreement task besides
textual information. We propose a novel method to extract such relation
information from (dis)agreement data into an inductive social relation graph,
merely using the comment-reply pairs without any additional platform-specific
information. The inductive social relation globally considers the historical
discussion and the relation between authors. Textual information based on a
pre-trained language model and social relation information encoded by
pre-trained RGCN are jointly considered for (dis)agreement detection.
Experimental results show that our model achieves state-of-the-art performance
for both the in-domain and cross-domain tasks on the benchmark -- DEBAGREEMENT.
We find social relations can boost the performance of the (dis)agreement
detection model, especially for the long-token comment-reply pairs,
demonstrating the effectiveness of the social relation graph. We also explore
the effect of the knowledge graph embedding methods, the information fusing
method, and the time interval in constructing the social relation graph, which
shows the effectiveness of our model. | [
-0.6238920093,
-0.6756361127,
0.5566737652,
0.2351690531,
-0.6425843835,
0.2263753861,
-0.350431174,
-0.5846796632,
0.6145060062,
0.1889900416,
-0.4363103211,
-0.5665370822,
-0.9576874375,
0.3044672608,
-0.1910503954,
1.0525478125,
0.0846155435,
-0.0725235492,
-0.5806621313,
-0.3340520561,
-0.0585607961,
-0.428596735,
-0.5442011952,
-0.6683771014,
0.5836539268,
0.1814804077,
0.4512051642,
0.2507084012,
0.5539475679,
0.3125802577,
-0.2502704859,
0.3489363492,
-0.5710734725,
0.3017140627,
-0.3258036077,
-0.0084420284,
-0.5505128503,
-0.0903479457,
0.3539735079,
0.398855716,
0.182744965,
0.2482058704,
0.1073652729,
0.7181408405,
-0.6355134845,
0.7392656803,
-0.7117558718,
-0.0373348221,
-0.1696469635,
-0.1840634197,
-0.7351535559,
-0.3544798195,
-0.2340719402,
-0.4500504732,
-0.0118724881,
-0.3168895245,
0.834857285,
0.0068958257,
-0.2223952413,
-0.2848229408,
-0.5635752082,
0.2403450161,
-0.8607981205,
0.5454787016,
0.3962099552,
-0.0088827163,
-0.4606156349,
-0.6905399561,
-0.8052014709,
-0.1368041933,
-0.5516143441,
0.1992092878,
-0.2261767536,
-0.2808887064,
0.319976449,
0.3451711833,
-0.4382630289,
-0.1749883592,
-0.002257271,
0.084714599,
0.735283792,
-0.0753899068,
0.317897588,
-0.3795205355,
-0.2873609066,
0.3463470042,
-0.5547255278,
-0.1203728616,
0.2857502103,
0.4930057228,
-0.2586612403,
0.4130256474,
-0.4675222337,
0.3795906007,
0.3248654306,
0.1250035316,
0.3753022552,
-0.301076144,
0.0889757127,
-0.1554189175,
1.0734138489,
0.3896953464,
0.408973515,
-0.437666446,
-0.1517005265,
0.3781736493,
-0.2825594842,
-0.7426304817,
-0.5311038494,
-0.1405130923,
-0.6181823015,
-0.2059252113,
0.1570176929,
-0.7576078176,
-0.7058007717,
-0.5761526227,
0.0010471534,
-0.2445561886,
-1.0318994522,
-0.1504441798,
-0.1449671984,
0.3084702492,
0.3121905923,
-0.6587910056,
0.3773477674,
0.7039678693,
0.8798124194,
0.1385975927,
-0.2814553678,
-0.4919400811,
0.2593826056,
-0.1203590631,
0.7940754294,
-0.4958437979,
-0.2372651249,
0.0219297484,
0.0652578771,
0.0360084884,
-0.3348636627,
0.0678367019,
-0.7320299745,
-0.012284765,
-0.2911117077,
-0.7001811862,
0.2454452515,
0.4007074833,
-0.7806288004,
0.8792383671,
-0.0388932899,
-1.064781189,
0.3254345357,
-0.5917189717,
-0.5710128546,
0.1300587058,
-0.3500676453,
-0.414312005,
-0.210197717,
0.2791137695,
0.6775624752,
-0.1763296872,
0.1606438905,
-0.8638733029,
-0.3813802302,
0.4953177869,
0.0838023648,
0.898434341,
0.229071945,
-0.1049758494,
-0.2099818885,
-0.5625229478,
-0.4251004755,
0.2733071446,
-0.2060504109,
-0.6021757722,
-0.0026370166,
-0.4193336368,
0.3419124484,
0.4099523127,
-0.7534734607,
0.2274143547,
-0.1106379777,
0.4901383519,
0.7203151584,
0.1369266957,
0.4145045578,
0.0476216525,
0.1891951859,
0.0389691107,
0.2151009142,
0.2227776051,
-0.3543233573,
-0.6062961817,
-0.0985101163,
0.4160059988,
0.2210510522,
-0.8750930429,
0.6519473195,
-0.6419038773,
-0.2359121591,
-0.2486506402,
0.2281242609,
0.4587962031,
0.3844897151,
0.1807946265,
-0.1955740899,
-0.436244905,
-0.4185509086,
-0.461522311,
-0.4901423156,
0.30436638,
-0.0019220017,
0.3192534447,
-0.203001067,
0.9446524382,
-0.7508711219,
-0.2228147835,
-0.2575231791,
0.3133967519,
0.0223013703,
0.2236620337,
0.6540173292,
-0.8400241733,
-1.0301915407,
0.2566733956,
-0.8946151733,
0.1579980403,
0.3218569756,
-0.2811607718,
0.2332539707,
0.7330116034,
-0.5954972506,
0.6694041491,
0.2132177204,
-0.2721077502,
0.0983709618,
0.0789179951,
0.3192344308,
-1.1217103004,
-0.1532971263,
0.3309158683,
-0.5241441727,
-0.4672839642,
-0.1694320738,
0.0213431232,
0.161662817,
-0.1529722661,
0.2844303548,
-0.5599674582,
0.2640799284,
-0.0797022432,
0.4907029271,
-0.0036462266,
0.6237704754,
0.2628833354,
0.3779706657,
0.1848156005,
-0.4947447777,
0.266425848,
0.504054606,
-0.1479917914,
0.7029959559,
-0.3947454393,
0.5138468146,
-0.2497723848,
0.3323218226,
-1.2753278017,
0.0068198377,
0.6966343522,
-0.8445082903,
0.4116643667,
-0.567956388,
-0.424099803,
-0.1932736933,
-0.4789735973,
0.3763489127,
0.1172777861,
-0.7543394566,
0.8598610163,
0.5391884446,
-0.2711898983,
-0.7871464491,
-0.5703992248,
0.154524222,
-0.0714092851,
-0.5808897614,
0.4337525368,
0.1040707678,
-0.3129937351,
0.360973388,
0.0506369397,
-0.1865264922,
-0.2584837079,
0.1379570663,
0.2112873048,
0.0910030976,
0.2525572777,
-0.0139931953,
-0.2963750958,
0.2201954126,
0.2352288514,
0.4014148116,
0.0707759336,
-0.0732584745,
-0.3549386263,
0.3261242211,
0.7120265961,
-0.2725446224,
0.8101738095,
0.3710973859,
-0.5003474951,
-0.2166965306,
-0.3680410981,
-0.1488227248,
-0.4660488367,
0.2334214449,
-0.4907886684,
-0.491430521,
0.720058918,
-0.3959594071,
0.0172537491,
0.2296934277,
0.2385217696,
0.0197011475,
0.7715380788,
0.601973474,
-0.434841007,
0.7456248403,
-0.3056473136,
0.515994966,
-0.8636584878,
-0.1691235453,
-0.5158954859,
-0.1490067095,
-0.4351921082,
-0.0668099597,
-0.0601459891,
-0.1496024281,
-0.0566513501,
0.5483582616,
-0.499502331,
0.3178581595,
-0.0734396726,
0.5977108479,
0.5216720104,
-0.1353657842,
0.2490191162,
-0.186397329,
-0.4254881144,
-0.2189388275,
0.7169033289,
0.1746322811,
0.8445597887,
0.2626325488,
0.8460319638,
0.6236124039,
0.5524474978,
-0.7819161415,
0.599234581,
-0.2339970618,
-0.0622096732,
-0.1935324967,
-0.6852730513,
-0.7116389275,
0.1634764969,
-0.3313905299,
-0.6047644019,
0.2791873217,
-0.0862561688,
0.0791021734,
0.3145787418,
-0.4474910796,
0.8415030241,
0.103402853,
-0.3542572558,
-0.0747315809,
-0.7903455496,
0.280973047,
0.2598754466,
0.2657875121,
-0.0456298478,
0.5385915041,
0.8391928673,
-0.2254523337,
0.8905824423,
-0.3145464063,
-0.1776718199,
0.2709938586,
-0.0749938041,
0.9449971914,
0.1619918644,
-0.078037478,
0.0795628577,
-0.2443635911,
-0.0615139566,
-0.8019258976,
0.7691948414,
-0.6677271724,
-0.3059079945,
-0.4132367373,
-0.4223486781,
-0.1109493524,
0.0876945183,
0.0277833901,
0.2950780988,
-0.5043698549,
0.1006927043,
0.5868483186,
0.2741623521,
0.3095342815,
0.4938097894,
-0.2775761485,
-0.3319409788,
0.8004168272,
-0.0146043617,
0.2056416869,
0.4725704491,
0.0239562076,
-0.6039322019,
-0.3419451416,
-0.1666068882,
0.5621465445,
-0.9793385267,
-0.4660561085,
-0.8412922621,
-0.1597829014,
-0.8120240569,
0.1486477256,
-0.105480738,
-0.424739629,
-0.1437704265,
-0.1251215488,
0.7263294458,
0.8851450682,
-0.0561058111,
0.1694915295,
-0.6044121385,
0.475158304,
0.0972400531,
0.3400827646,
0.0005836498,
-0.4313612878,
-0.2247096002,
-0.0078427726,
-0.0102994358,
-0.9743426442,
-0.1726025194,
0.0246850029,
0.3395950496,
0.3535369337,
0.4328511357,
0.6570526361,
-0.1641155183,
0.4356407225,
0.2633009851,
-0.9652523994,
0.3913648725,
-0.163006708,
-0.1000794545,
0.6487795711,
0.2462145537,
-0.4725993276,
-0.5272409916,
-0.4565722942,
-0.7441503406,
0.7174652219,
0.07582362,
0.1561147571,
-0.0743720904,
0.620782733,
-0.0426474102,
0.0632167757,
-1.0907386541,
-0.2047980428,
0.0342015997,
-0.3294397891,
0.2221493125,
-0.1717986912,
-0.1357157528,
-0.4557138383,
0.8560556173,
-0.044199083,
0.0741428509,
0.0561072752,
-0.1305348277,
-0.1358564347,
0.1274572313,
0.0233173799,
0.8240514398,
-0.1959004104,
0.2791116238,
0.1061638296,
-0.3581097722,
0.1007470712,
0.3216664195,
-0.0389128812,
0.1941506714,
0.2719477415,
0.282792598,
-0.1546989232,
0.1187285408,
0.8338837624,
-0.5432261825,
-0.0580572709,
-0.1103907898,
-0.1845093518,
0.4447398782,
0.1842336059,
-0.0979022756,
-0.1525274962,
-0.0462680049,
-0.527392149,
0.4622763991,
0.5073980689,
-0.5125213265,
-0.163917616,
0.2198248506,
0.4419867694,
-0.2741413414,
0.4473264515,
-0.5060284734,
-0.566914916,
0.4344719946,
0.4815731347,
0.7524625063,
-0.0322862491,
0.6038144231,
0.3359966874,
0.1400668174,
0.2252275795,
0.141062513,
-0.4363741279,
-0.9093317986,
-0.3718133569,
-0.1800927967,
-0.3483037353,
0.0790409222,
-0.7683790922,
0.5006203055,
-0.3799627721,
-0.2934579849,
0.2028666735,
0.0395632461,
-0.5939731598,
-0.0293973275,
-0.1474857926,
0.4124466479,
-1.022851944,
0.8518483043,
0.6631724238,
-0.6604180336,
-0.5899968147,
0.1745523959,
-0.3348035216,
-0.3719671071,
0.6274092197,
0.0651702657,
-0.5678039193,
-0.1623184979,
-0.4769077003,
-0.1869774312,
0.9369899631,
0.5994503498,
-0.5305777192,
0.3908992112,
0.2216376066,
0.3803267181,
-0.4089023769,
0.1803955883,
0.3563284576,
0.3377883732,
0.0764647275,
-0.407923162,
0.549339056,
-0.5794142485,
-0.1829446554,
0.5243083239,
-0.7749703526,
0.7602627277,
0.2058852017,
-0.4127700031,
-0.1824529022,
0.9411097169,
0.0378913619,
0.6256542802,
0.7991347313,
0.6227798462,
0.5736246109,
-0.0731291994,
0.524930954,
-0.3190439045,
0.6250745654,
1.2346423864,
-0.6360362172,
0.6288374662,
0.5921192765,
-0.3627342582,
1.0149251223,
0.5297863483,
0.3675278723,
0.5622833967,
0.2380420864,
-0.5824848413,
-0.2904065847,
-0.1616935283,
-0.578240931,
0.1107463762,
0.4142468274,
-0.3798342645,
-0.2626413405,
-0.444062084,
0.170333147,
0.543990016,
-0.0010170033,
1.1870832443,
0.1457288265,
-0.4949951172,
0.3273964524,
-0.3454183638,
0.6379407048,
-0.5165034533,
-0.3081247211,
-0.1066223308,
0.2565003932,
-0.4288344979,
-0.7156081796,
0.1619422436,
-0.0109870611,
-0.332763195,
0.356317699,
1.0589230061,
-0.6407288313,
-0.3670048416,
0.8948642612,
0.415810436,
-0.0220600497,
0.1360515952,
-0.5915521383,
0.0949746445,
-0.1854514778,
-0.0206138976,
0.231602326,
0.9958949089,
0.275980562,
0.0993530601,
0.6135934591,
-0.0186944176,
-0.3967948854,
0.2276142389,
1.3100919724,
-0.32350263,
-0.4700938761,
-0.9263399243,
0.3265509605,
-0.6973164082,
0.0188298766,
0.7678897977,
0.2599108219,
0.9210768938,
0.1282007992,
0.9888535142,
-0.1972349584,
0.3730153739,
-0.3200494051,
0.6857357025,
-0.3191375136,
0.2543602586,
-0.6731625795,
-0.8006060123,
-0.3682212234,
0.6141123176,
-0.4307238162,
-0.1343849897,
0.5288589001,
0.7533704638,
-0.2884098589,
0.2293416411,
-0.1357195228,
0.0085455645,
0.4486232102,
0.4691580534,
1.097509861,
-0.5219659209,
0.5339599848,
-0.2915144563,
-0.4630636275,
0.0320764221,
-1.0192731619,
-1.2280875444,
-0.4459028244,
-0.5982832909,
-0.7218495607,
0.004319693,
0.8934397697,
0.4120064378,
-0.5422645807,
-0.1393087655,
-0.1544153541,
0.4023656547,
-0.2099428922,
-0.2714646459,
0.31964463,
-0.2328297645,
-0.4918652773,
0.1050872952,
0.1911655366,
-0.102067709,
-0.1082134023,
-0.3190922737,
-0.5594311357,
0.029693678,
0.6414994597,
0.3098520637,
-0.3384901285,
-0.3717726767,
-0.1803967655,
0.02552226,
0.1446481198,
0.8548521399,
-0.3944887519,
0.5017501116,
0.6705274582,
0.5132706165,
0.6898425817,
0.0956456438,
0.3245714307,
-0.778231144,
0.3638952971,
-0.0263840239,
0.4450955093,
0.6073225141,
-0.8202493787,
0.5826790929,
0.2784641683,
-0.6098532677,
-0.7051257491,
0.2690855563,
-0.8902369142,
-0.3333652318,
0.9931201339,
-0.5496724844,
-0.1095217988,
-0.4452413321,
-0.1778784692,
0.541729331,
-0.6690852046,
0.9175708294,
0.6575534344,
-0.2436757237,
0.1738490313,
0.1914724112,
0.5722370148,
0.1088629961,
-0.8043112159,
0.4607605636,
0.3492875099,
0.1637558639,
0.3327210248,
1.1449469328,
-0.3290174007,
0.1926420331,
-0.238820523,
-0.1528880149,
0.0180553533,
-0.3898964524,
0.0569426678,
-0.1014900729,
0.1131006181,
-0.3736650348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03905v1 | COMBO: A Complete Benchmark for Open KG Canonicalization | 2023-02-08T06:46:01 | 2023-02-08T06:46:01 | Chengyue Jiang, Yong Jiang, Weiqi Wu, Yuting Zheng, Pengjun Xie, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Open knowledge graph (KG) consists of (subject, relation, object) triples
extracted from millions of raw text. The subject and object noun phrases and
the relation in open KG have severe redundancy and ambiguity and need to be
canonicalized. Existing datasets for open KG canonicalization only provide gold
entity-level canonicalization for noun phrases. In this paper, we present
COMBO, a Complete Benchmark for Open KG canonicalization. Compared with
existing datasets, we additionally provide gold canonicalization for relation
phrases, gold ontology-level canonicalization for noun phrases, as well as
source sentences from which triples are extracted. We also propose metrics for
evaluating each type of canonicalization. On the COMBO dataset, we empirically
compare previously proposed canonicalization methods as well as a few simple
baseline methods based on pretrained language models. We find that properly
encoding the phrases in a triple using pretrained language models results in
better relation canonicalization and ontology-level canonicalization of the
noun phrase. We release our dataset, baselines, and evaluation scripts at
https://github.com/jeffchy/COMBO/tree/main. | [
-0.1408934742,
-0.4298048615,
0.2582735717,
0.0362085998,
-0.2790465951,
0.1455222517,
-0.3830480874,
-0.0175462719,
0.1608942449,
0.6709411144,
-0.1110250354,
-0.5473459363,
-0.5138025284,
0.1191793755,
0.0127306115,
1.1583768129,
-0.3097867668,
0.1576233059,
-0.3829574883,
-0.3006862998,
-0.423732698,
-0.5383487344,
-0.2533203363,
-0.3687808812,
0.5806576014,
0.2062409967,
0.9977689385,
0.4528604448,
0.7859208584,
0.1998883039,
0.0847312212,
0.0827338472,
-0.6823359132,
-0.0214795358,
-0.1778764725,
-0.2140513211,
-0.5827832818,
0.2713949084,
0.9441900849,
1.1176146269,
-0.1126449332,
0.1914155036,
-0.2315828502,
0.9228522778,
-1.1519796848,
0.1227478236,
-0.4214568138,
0.0971892625,
-0.395079881,
-0.1303925812,
-0.240153268,
-0.6167098284,
-0.069541119,
-0.9862478971,
-0.2034090012,
-0.1259607077,
0.9941444993,
0.2597009242,
-0.5072903037,
-0.053312283,
-0.8155270219,
0.5949423313,
-0.3140281141,
0.8402118683,
0.3700135648,
0.551777482,
-0.170329079,
-1.0559124947,
-0.4549535215,
-0.3528910875,
-0.3491917253,
0.343803674,
-0.264295429,
0.1091507301,
-0.061577756,
0.7361394763,
-0.4520266652,
-0.246654734,
-0.2932251096,
0.0531945303,
0.3705670536,
-0.2919599414,
0.3656635582,
-0.5174896121,
-0.3047863245,
-0.4235856235,
-0.654001236,
-0.1647705585,
0.8355591297,
0.3669876158,
0.1864634603,
0.7663030028,
-0.5235319138,
0.9818466306,
-0.224370867,
-0.1974550337,
0.5709094405,
-0.7442317009,
-0.29139027,
-0.0429005921,
1.1101757288,
0.2905508578,
0.2910214663,
-1.0349550247,
0.163078323,
-0.1776188165,
0.5263556242,
-0.5038642287,
-0.5630140901,
0.2515735328,
-0.4148765802,
-0.2035463303,
0.4642286897,
-0.5455408692,
0.0416258797,
-0.4143649936,
0.5275366306,
-0.6782687306,
-0.3805286288,
0.2392095625,
-0.3417459726,
-0.076810658,
-0.2229824513,
-0.4155139625,
0.4278719425,
0.9665673375,
0.5562807918,
-0.1893872023,
-0.2610831857,
-0.7028793693,
0.4469472766,
-0.3765059114,
0.4845604599,
-0.5320762396,
-0.2311509848,
-0.1807281375,
-0.3596098721,
-0.2316672355,
-0.623714149,
0.6771258116,
-0.6688106656,
0.1381353736,
-0.3055815399,
-0.6060800552,
-0.09686663,
0.4389083385,
-0.724924624,
1.254345417,
0.2551505864,
-0.8343018293,
0.4869549572,
-0.5591545105,
-0.3395006955,
0.3202675581,
-0.3167355359,
-0.1697468907,
-0.1744955182,
0.0213205647,
0.1811321676,
-0.1490019262,
0.5466247201,
-0.3939668536,
-0.0177800152,
-0.0312831588,
0.1490492374,
0.8092277646,
0.0397012383,
0.1919263154,
-0.1608193368,
-0.8649958372,
0.2950468957,
0.0199490935,
-0.4278637469,
-0.7427089214,
-0.0718468949,
-0.3118415177,
0.1350767016,
0.3972243369,
-0.5816791654,
0.4304403961,
-0.2235715985,
-0.0636170879,
0.3460519016,
-0.1200822517,
0.4308741391,
0.0814322084,
0.4420105219,
0.1145964861,
0.0020424575,
0.144489795,
-0.470787555,
-0.4576594532,
-0.2227038592,
0.9204873443,
0.4773720503,
-0.9856976271,
0.7859041095,
-0.9230780005,
-0.4821549952,
-0.6485590339,
0.2529841065,
0.948441565,
0.470608443,
0.3593578041,
-0.2774819732,
-0.5165967345,
-1.1020922661,
-0.4854047,
-0.2349311411,
-0.0917598754,
0.1548044235,
0.3960080743,
0.1913025081,
1.3852748871,
-0.7801756263,
-0.3645347655,
0.1781800836,
0.342386663,
-0.1541139781,
0.3702242076,
0.4418451786,
-0.954482913,
-0.3213271797,
0.3419317007,
-0.9830604792,
0.1283817589,
0.5639382005,
-0.6043691039,
-0.136572808,
0.6156144738,
-0.3534361422,
0.2723179162,
0.4210703671,
-0.1084382683,
0.3898259997,
-0.2933953106,
0.2327805459,
-1.1843452454,
0.4935091734,
-0.4106902778,
-0.009640852,
-0.6011756063,
0.424778223,
0.4784027338,
0.012302896,
-0.4081882238,
0.333660692,
-0.3613733351,
-0.2805071473,
0.2106747478,
0.264764607,
-0.2249516994,
0.5836778879,
-0.1171859279,
0.5434034467,
0.2156664729,
-0.4366929233,
0.4485747814,
0.3091221452,
-0.3751369715,
0.7577098608,
-0.4880261123,
0.1358804852,
-0.0710346177,
0.5732632875,
-0.9261825681,
-0.3111015558,
0.4224731028,
-0.1942299753,
0.1315973103,
-0.2377849519,
-1.2724677324,
-0.5282264948,
-0.3012443185,
0.5746374726,
0.2649286985,
-0.5822356939,
0.4302356839,
0.1834437996,
0.1631047577,
-0.6532068849,
-0.2227685899,
0.1028486267,
0.246648699,
-0.6353300214,
0.7155684233,
-0.1632394046,
-0.0341166146,
0.3824710846,
-0.1881297976,
0.1067608297,
-0.1508512497,
0.0434427001,
0.1092508212,
-0.2921627164,
0.232708022,
-0.1050767824,
-0.3293648362,
-0.3249813914,
-0.4441772699,
0.5031202435,
0.0328642651,
-0.2437320203,
0.0307234805,
-0.0747110173,
0.2495969385,
-0.074051559,
0.6948795915,
0.3408178687,
-0.3453273177,
0.4163787067,
-0.4300197661,
0.3684803247,
-0.4260068834,
0.0877081454,
-0.4916104376,
-0.5798913836,
0.2238227278,
-0.0464831777,
0.1654191464,
0.125465706,
0.0151355723,
0.2557712793,
0.7740336061,
0.1978049874,
-0.0783464536,
0.0973363072,
-0.1702663302,
0.3776717484,
-0.81693995,
-0.2395614237,
-0.4616006613,
-0.430853188,
-0.5539384484,
-0.242412135,
0.4518604279,
0.8665332794,
-0.2859105468,
0.4177787602,
-0.2320704311,
0.6490382552,
0.7679039836,
0.0037971137,
0.5766502023,
-0.0605753399,
-0.3486738205,
-0.0109353196,
-0.4017623663,
-0.4125101566,
1.4150494337,
-0.160085693,
0.1923184246,
0.3641921878,
0.8848143816,
-0.0492330827,
0.3192008436,
-0.618917346,
0.5639352798,
-0.605496347,
-0.5377724171,
0.0384601355,
-0.7330662608,
-1.0836610794,
0.3909792304,
0.0311551057,
-0.7077885866,
-0.3561834991,
0.0644785762,
-0.3095458448,
0.4260480106,
-0.6621209383,
1.0578694344,
-0.0636690035,
0.1668187976,
0.2943367362,
-0.6485419273,
0.5949414968,
-0.2298912853,
0.1775193661,
0.16957286,
-0.1675329655,
0.9429274201,
-0.6473572254,
0.4738619924,
0.0679953024,
-0.1049430445,
-0.1100247651,
-0.0329693668,
0.2417801768,
-0.1502268761,
0.1422962397,
0.2045906633,
-0.1610599607,
-0.3815231621,
-0.7811012864,
0.7368479967,
-1.0833172798,
-0.0734719113,
0.003874515,
-0.4531448483,
-0.5622529387,
0.445628196,
0.2640567124,
0.3917728364,
-0.2735708654,
0.3030889928,
0.2386602759,
-0.0190154631,
0.2650867701,
0.4889138639,
-0.4891707003,
-1.0165013075,
1.1771223545,
0.3730356693,
0.4155377448,
0.625217855,
0.202644825,
0.0809863508,
-0.2074068338,
-0.5251960158,
0.2209572494,
-0.7386168838,
-0.4692272842,
-0.972205162,
-0.2944625318,
-0.7067301869,
-0.0340776406,
-0.4737143517,
-0.6948719621,
0.04953501,
-0.1327707618,
0.2611179948,
0.6819780469,
-0.1306738853,
0.426628381,
-0.7465109229,
0.8056421876,
0.4592795372,
0.6995194554,
-0.0960464925,
-0.0113655748,
0.0540722273,
-0.0623171963,
-0.5722467899,
-0.6803022027,
-0.1141712666,
-0.0413111076,
0.6557528973,
0.5384920835,
0.0326433517,
0.6692788005,
-0.4914179444,
0.7710900307,
0.3819337189,
-0.671929419,
0.5597529411,
-0.5485529304,
0.3113383353,
0.9075950384,
0.4433918893,
-0.5120372772,
-0.4401216209,
-0.8243171573,
-0.8688493967,
1.0225926638,
0.6437463164,
-0.3247840703,
-0.0755681694,
0.2053711414,
0.3820607662,
0.5464838743,
-0.6805099249,
-0.6460359097,
0.0572032407,
-0.1438055187,
-0.2176212966,
0.0788334981,
-0.267386049,
-0.2975803912,
0.8204054832,
0.0823139176,
0.031015506,
-0.3610737622,
-0.1797261238,
-0.2397862673,
-0.0003327054,
0.2324639112,
0.5559629798,
-0.5472490191,
0.0951490998,
-0.349686861,
-0.5378773808,
-0.1608618647,
0.3669543266,
-0.2557606399,
0.0430410616,
0.4260926843,
0.6518298984,
0.9078661203,
-0.422839582,
0.5942976475,
0.1972510666,
-0.2974656224,
-0.0441544354,
-0.0909229666,
0.0918066949,
-0.3645519614,
0.2443816662,
0.0128951082,
-0.0197992697,
-0.3668656051,
0.0782811344,
0.3655739427,
-0.2267933637,
-0.2526091337,
0.3573318422,
0.0581545606,
-0.2765640616,
0.6229531765,
-0.3590249419,
-0.3930860162,
0.3821143806,
0.203494668,
0.7967506051,
0.017336322,
0.4198469222,
0.4719746709,
0.2372807264,
-0.1031125933,
0.2463835329,
-0.2391682267,
-0.7723904848,
-0.2972726226,
-0.6973295808,
-0.3889279366,
0.1818929315,
-0.9620185494,
0.3120414317,
-0.0508870445,
0.0757833868,
0.2311309427,
-0.0134411706,
-0.7323353887,
-0.0896113366,
-0.0516124554,
0.8397542834,
-0.6174440384,
0.8271906376,
0.9712074399,
-0.6879634261,
-0.6151277423,
-0.0164064039,
-0.2900307775,
-0.7188942432,
0.9902091622,
0.1527812779,
0.2260917127,
0.0065575871,
-0.3688774705,
-1.0176403522,
1.0213977098,
0.3786152601,
-0.1361803561,
-0.1480053961,
0.3507063091,
0.3768253922,
-0.0714894012,
0.1850425601,
0.8392069936,
0.7844507694,
0.1639682353,
-1.1301586628,
-0.1923258156,
-0.2541688979,
0.0599949732,
0.7917914987,
-0.4568698108,
0.7465567589,
0.3836700618,
-0.2124466151,
0.0408912152,
0.5768796206,
0.1528207362,
0.1615395099,
0.4743440151,
1.2235974073,
0.6455873251,
-0.1477761269,
1.1847002506,
-0.1952397078,
0.3358890712,
1.2640404701,
-0.3386408389,
0.9887824655,
0.3853588402,
-0.4105840921,
0.5129855275,
0.3606424034,
0.3476493955,
0.6761440635,
0.1888666898,
-0.0864982903,
-0.126017198,
0.1831577867,
-0.6106853485,
0.2042218745,
0.1511731893,
-0.244170934,
-0.6360359192,
0.2473397851,
0.1490730792,
-0.0990850702,
-0.2823565602,
0.9712666273,
-0.1485775709,
-1.0549695492,
0.5276766419,
-0.0197923612,
0.4930674732,
-0.7344731688,
0.282597959,
-0.0398799814,
0.2160684913,
-0.0565091297,
-0.6497293115,
-0.0829396024,
-0.2939909101,
-0.0725516975,
-0.3117606938,
0.5384837985,
-0.5280118585,
-0.6118124127,
0.4381625354,
0.4644708335,
0.1926834285,
0.0170526057,
-0.3743588924,
-0.0883523822,
-0.3284972012,
-0.0967758745,
0.3947720826,
0.4199611247,
0.0428184494,
0.2051240951,
0.6083852649,
-0.0819455534,
0.2173306793,
0.1105751917,
0.942185998,
-0.5073769689,
-0.5290709734,
-0.5577918291,
0.3235360384,
-0.2961243689,
-0.4905396104,
0.734472096,
0.7469890118,
1.1025824547,
0.0670275986,
0.7217179537,
-0.2191472203,
0.334538877,
-0.5048894286,
0.5798472166,
-0.6203801036,
-0.3025902808,
-0.4949313104,
-1.0754647255,
-0.3712296188,
0.0013449218,
-0.4986836016,
0.1129759252,
0.8008745909,
0.4932267964,
-0.6590526104,
0.2794028819,
0.256391257,
-0.1165023744,
-0.0740484819,
0.1978931874,
0.5225990415,
-0.6679378748,
0.959061563,
-0.5837179422,
-0.3298256695,
-0.2539767027,
-1.0155597925,
-0.6351569295,
-0.669039011,
-0.573599577,
-0.3682530224,
0.0954530016,
0.6565768719,
0.5952868462,
-0.5371413827,
-0.0996598899,
-0.232588008,
-0.0128145861,
-0.421046555,
-0.2591153085,
0.437173605,
-0.4867277443,
-0.3988338113,
0.4174241424,
0.2037985623,
-0.286070168,
-0.1172827035,
-0.1318390518,
-0.3642649353,
-0.2547809482,
0.519790113,
0.3268884718,
-0.6389046907,
-0.2726851702,
-0.3379233778,
-0.0659804344,
0.0747497007,
1.135792613,
-0.8419955373,
0.7402242422,
0.5161699057,
0.5226496458,
0.1182453483,
0.0551857986,
0.7025545835,
-1.2793296576,
-0.1312651783,
-0.0554406978,
0.2106813788,
0.2762326896,
-0.1194351986,
0.9258649349,
0.2590001523,
-0.2068070173,
-0.929751575,
0.1782359183,
-1.0034009218,
-0.3399748802,
1.1559267044,
-0.122711271,
-0.0968619809,
0.0430976637,
-0.0075449776,
0.3039922416,
-0.0968176946,
0.2974185646,
0.9388878345,
0.1532879025,
0.4748317897,
-0.490557462,
0.2006612569,
0.3251842856,
-0.8562434316,
0.0922804102,
0.3977480233,
0.1210508496,
0.5518282652,
0.7998644114,
-0.2203051448,
0.1953825206,
-0.1786169112,
0.2485213578,
-0.0601102263,
-0.3010298312,
-0.0945028812,
0.4156274498,
-0.4318675697,
-0.4294160903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03896v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03896v3 | EvoText: Enhancing Natural Language Generation Models via Self-Escalation Learning for Up-to-Date Knowledge and Improved Performance | 2023-02-08T06:09:55 | 2023-04-13T07:29:20 | Zhengqing Yuan, Huiwen Xue, Chao Zhang, Yongming Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, pretrained models have been widely used in various fields,
including natural language understanding, computer vision, and natural language
generation. However, the performance of these language generation models is
highly dependent on the model size and the dataset size. While larger models
excel in some aspects, they cannot learn up-to-date knowledge and are
relatively difficult to relearn. In this paper, we introduce EvoText, a novel
training method that enhances the performance of any natural language
generation model without requiring additional datasets during the entire
training process (although a prior dataset is necessary for pretraining).
EvoText employs two models: $G$, a text generation model, and $D$, a model that
can determine whether the data generated by $G$ is legitimate. Initially, the
fine-tuned $D$ model serves as the knowledge base. The text generated by $G$ is
then input to $D$ to determine whether it is legitimate. Finally, $G$ is
fine-tuned based on $D$'s output. EvoText enables the model to learn up-to-date
knowledge through a self-escalation process that builds on a priori knowledge.
When EvoText needs to learn something new, it simply fine-tunes the $D$ model.
Our approach applies to autoregressive language modeling for all Transformer
classes. With EvoText, eight models achieved stable improvements in seven
natural language processing tasks without any changes to the model structure. | [
-0.1608302891,
-0.7768808007,
0.3958992362,
0.1459609121,
-0.2296696007,
0.391043216,
-0.178452909,
-0.4407582879,
-0.0842899978,
0.518329978,
-0.4523074925,
-0.3750780523,
-0.4969218969,
0.235829547,
-0.5229186416,
0.8550007343,
-0.0140956007,
-0.315931648,
-0.2883642018,
0.0501175262,
-0.4781606793,
-0.3794188201,
-0.6392390728,
-0.4634832144,
0.1116386876,
0.331194222,
0.5522720218,
0.6171754599,
0.2036148459,
0.3302792609,
0.1185700595,
0.1526108086,
-0.4585199356,
0.6231136918,
-0.0768914074,
-0.2013926357,
-0.1279043257,
-0.209994331,
0.3830293417,
0.1167321131,
-0.3190908432,
0.0527138151,
0.0908831134,
0.6037739515,
-0.5249994397,
-0.0478230938,
-0.9393546581,
0.0338713489,
-0.0013292179,
-0.2308659256,
-0.5335515738,
-0.5657491088,
0.3108058572,
-0.5774814487,
0.3748471737,
0.075618051,
0.8050411344,
0.3077823818,
-0.2867466509,
-0.3412596285,
-0.881198585,
0.5495030284,
-0.5438312888,
0.3479419053,
-0.0037836931,
0.430562824,
-0.0451125577,
-0.979709208,
-0.6770349145,
-0.3547825217,
0.0325792395,
0.2388609499,
-0.1964883059,
0.0611337759,
0.3658571243,
0.4502112865,
-0.4702812731,
0.1908539236,
-0.1985495239,
-0.1756072342,
0.418779701,
0.0516470671,
0.4105297625,
-0.2482147664,
-0.5827746987,
-0.2868724167,
-0.8152424693,
-0.1335024387,
0.5235040188,
0.3894977272,
0.2334941477,
0.2749356627,
-0.101769954,
0.6507385373,
0.1611890644,
0.2847983539,
0.3367564976,
-0.1568872631,
-0.2232615352,
0.140593186,
0.7308578491,
-0.02913028,
0.1709301025,
-0.1032282785,
-0.2461319864,
-0.189715445,
0.3268743753,
-0.8776480556,
-0.3036133349,
0.060422644,
-0.1142148077,
-0.5697779655,
-0.2610607147,
-0.7841415405,
-0.1563194394,
-0.4498159885,
0.8170157075,
-0.7054902315,
-0.4602109492,
0.074123092,
-0.1742292047,
0.2189047039,
0.4059604406,
-0.9846586585,
0.2439735383,
0.3925008774,
0.8214159012,
-0.0165484827,
-0.3640341461,
-0.4172784388,
0.1466639638,
-0.0825106651,
0.9370260835,
-0.5994814038,
-0.1639551222,
0.1467155516,
-0.320361644,
-0.1900105625,
-0.4117181301,
0.4750286341,
-0.4499004185,
0.4633874893,
0.1895535141,
-0.7601823807,
0.0688260496,
0.1147311404,
-0.5904949307,
1.444273591,
0.0541387275,
-0.6932591796,
0.5074815154,
-0.5744591355,
-0.6172884107,
0.1914543658,
-0.2114676982,
-0.6435364485,
0.1683955193,
0.3721840382,
0.5044959784,
-0.1240147054,
0.3030188978,
0.0384740047,
0.1718563586,
-0.2195699811,
-0.3212272525,
0.406750977,
0.3174419999,
-0.3426831067,
-0.0381307527,
-0.9276639223,
-0.0223953016,
0.2985341549,
-0.2897838652,
-0.4605306685,
-0.1414648592,
-0.1106501743,
0.3851085007,
0.2269303054,
-0.5388806462,
0.0664503425,
-0.5335202217,
0.3413082659,
0.7356923819,
-0.0416287296,
0.5226289034,
-0.1239281148,
0.5750145912,
-0.1551238149,
0.1154206693,
-0.604280293,
-0.4342750609,
-0.9033927321,
-0.0115864165,
0.3477218449,
0.3426413238,
-1.0652010441,
0.5893728137,
-0.2152133286,
-0.6097474098,
-0.5279160738,
0.1440833211,
0.0653631985,
0.6462893486,
0.5436244011,
0.0017502533,
-0.5843364,
-0.7118136287,
-0.6778134108,
-0.030065272,
-0.0771140903,
0.0024921782,
0.4513887167,
0.0114679439,
1.054361701,
-0.3964006305,
-0.1238824725,
-0.57562989,
0.667791307,
0.0939722434,
0.4196252227,
0.5595193505,
-0.3778558969,
-0.6788203716,
0.1130855903,
-0.4344421327,
-0.2030243427,
-0.3979436457,
-0.1868492514,
0.08155296,
0.5529641509,
-0.366004169,
0.2753657699,
0.5232552886,
-0.2277456671,
0.2973463833,
-0.6006259322,
-0.0982730314,
-1.2826298475,
-0.1098235771,
-0.0710120499,
-0.417203933,
-0.8541175127,
-0.1956594288,
0.3465405107,
-0.1711772829,
-0.4379006922,
0.4740484655,
-0.4445664883,
0.2064970136,
-0.3682257831,
0.1224409416,
0.0596373938,
0.2969843149,
0.2813396752,
0.7212321758,
0.6641679406,
-0.7326238155,
0.3824957311,
0.3189487755,
-0.3248342872,
0.389836669,
-0.607704699,
0.3681765497,
-0.2657773495,
-0.1126186848,
-0.8884910941,
-0.0672885254,
-0.2073162794,
-0.4412131011,
0.4713683128,
0.0317407735,
-0.4073671699,
-0.5257210732,
-0.1234556437,
-0.0584685504,
0.621406734,
-0.9652168751,
0.8685573936,
0.1338138878,
-0.1239649132,
-0.4203872681,
-0.415522486,
0.1025453657,
-0.1233857572,
-0.6328737736,
0.4353169203,
0.0927038789,
0.1505245268,
-0.2471716106,
0.0419575572,
0.1196809188,
-0.0283758529,
-0.1419161856,
0.071899496,
0.0877240524,
0.6745120883,
0.3883799016,
-0.1590094119,
0.0234872159,
-0.2481954247,
0.5712516904,
0.0924294293,
-0.04363098,
-0.2792485952,
0.1403791606,
0.4683835208,
-0.3125827909,
0.8379849792,
0.4395795166,
-0.2457799613,
-0.5291999578,
-0.5085769892,
-0.317661047,
-0.5490868092,
0.4573709071,
-0.3348974586,
-0.7297169566,
0.3082661927,
-0.4213798046,
0.1203618348,
0.6411707401,
0.5299530029,
0.1544977278,
0.9835164547,
0.7330457568,
0.1333821416,
0.7944289446,
0.0338953733,
0.1616996378,
-0.5845636725,
-0.347648412,
-0.5464661717,
-0.0993169695,
-0.3413822651,
-0.1591324955,
0.0273128562,
-0.3291126788,
-0.3097591698,
0.6697103381,
-0.6108075976,
0.5016834736,
0.5226635933,
0.0326067992,
0.351798296,
0.2892573476,
-0.3521228433,
-0.0237212069,
-0.82779181,
-0.3941302598,
1.1753019094,
0.3777869642,
1.0222085714,
-0.0886333436,
0.6948476434,
0.3807893693,
0.3193917274,
-0.4934205115,
0.2261862159,
0.0228478443,
-0.4163110256,
-0.3666931689,
-0.6438726783,
-0.8853745461,
0.0860669017,
-0.3618016541,
-0.3195458651,
0.1021847203,
0.3590909839,
-0.5059491992,
0.2702309787,
-0.8043615818,
0.7631605268,
-0.4545239508,
-0.3318939805,
-0.1573162377,
-0.507329762,
-0.0138075575,
-0.1763666272,
0.0157260504,
-0.01299458,
0.2882395685,
0.6275877953,
-0.4700314105,
0.6493375897,
-0.1512485743,
-0.2525753379,
0.2419033796,
0.0993013978,
0.9977501631,
-0.1824386418,
-0.0214993227,
-0.2241428196,
-0.5137967467,
-0.0306161959,
-0.6611985564,
0.585788846,
-0.905836761,
-0.4797798693,
-0.263664335,
-0.204797253,
-0.1215095073,
0.17419447,
0.5820615292,
0.4866642654,
-0.341840446,
0.121346347,
0.713013649,
-0.4581118524,
0.4448226988,
0.4402772784,
-0.2239582092,
-0.6156945825,
0.8343530893,
0.0683843419,
0.605987072,
0.5346194506,
0.2670614719,
-0.6166160703,
-0.3927175999,
-0.3123238385,
0.0379337296,
-0.6252462268,
-0.435883075,
-1.0387158394,
-0.296602875,
-0.4949239492,
0.0736887529,
-0.5810158849,
-0.6352882981,
-0.1634082198,
-0.3975527585,
0.6480255127,
0.7916206121,
-0.0725440159,
0.4314890206,
-0.578050077,
0.2496350855,
0.8873742223,
0.2526449859,
-0.0310492888,
-0.7858396769,
-0.3145667911,
-0.0954771638,
-0.5738293529,
-0.8560952544,
0.6695129871,
0.570768714,
0.5791851878,
0.207578361,
0.1743910462,
0.4858507812,
-0.7341044545,
0.4997044802,
0.3733247519,
-1.1492528915,
1.0478479862,
-0.2872717381,
0.274401933,
0.4865164459,
0.2382985353,
-0.47762236,
-0.629945457,
-0.7569743395,
-1.0169101954,
0.6259934306,
0.5367317796,
0.4021525085,
-0.0420397148,
0.3453889191,
0.3088085353,
0.3048062325,
-0.7693908811,
-0.1214861944,
-0.6284087896,
-0.4474612474,
0.1526618898,
-0.0996664837,
0.2416072637,
-0.4387109578,
0.704359889,
-0.1228241175,
0.2424614877,
0.1695231944,
-0.3793067336,
-0.1722983271,
0.227760002,
0.5022985339,
0.4051638544,
-0.1868778616,
0.237221837,
0.3461762071,
-0.6055081487,
0.1236565113,
0.0672802404,
-0.0663081706,
0.0897617191,
0.0287781414,
1.0089354515,
0.1053778827,
-0.3404262066,
0.5240802765,
-0.2592682838,
-0.2410195768,
-0.2985419333,
0.1349960715,
-0.2435972989,
0.1287441701,
0.4872329831,
0.255883038,
-0.0786520019,
-0.2726714015,
0.3469716609,
0.0888740122,
-0.3396770656,
-0.4115662575,
0.8546462059,
0.5291829109,
-0.2282208651,
0.6783078313,
0.0343893357,
-0.5623916388,
0.5782538652,
0.8728346825,
1.1119217873,
-0.6335757971,
0.4462503791,
0.5691250563,
0.4301540554,
-0.1529003084,
0.0183669869,
-0.0605812296,
-0.9216495156,
-0.5102535486,
-0.5781553388,
-0.4188092947,
0.1588229537,
-0.5120760798,
0.3876387775,
-0.287604779,
-0.1136209071,
-0.3590791225,
-0.3128661215,
-0.801489234,
0.1708232909,
0.1666289568,
0.8771522045,
-0.9651052356,
0.8084362149,
0.5133677125,
-0.2056580484,
-0.5826886892,
-0.0706967488,
-0.5807467103,
-0.7994447351,
0.6288272738,
0.3129996359,
-0.0399304777,
0.4579463601,
-0.4705761969,
-0.7697997093,
1.1019873619,
0.5317775011,
-0.5360652804,
0.0487233102,
0.2529799044,
0.6397483945,
-0.4784551263,
0.4213734269,
0.4888482094,
0.288626194,
0.3098684847,
-0.579736948,
0.0049962797,
-0.226406306,
0.1286312938,
0.3100031912,
-0.3449909389,
0.6916597486,
-0.0990769342,
-0.4104680717,
-0.0436726697,
0.7704148293,
0.080677107,
-0.1604339182,
0.4620300829,
0.7200456262,
0.9012744427,
-0.1975590438,
0.9534926414,
-0.3695648313,
0.5932516456,
1.1584230661,
-0.2810842991,
0.7639222145,
0.2488053292,
0.0363955908,
0.5976919532,
0.3335470855,
0.0457478538,
0.6675979495,
-0.0631116107,
-0.3700865805,
-0.7292587757,
0.1454572827,
-0.4759531021,
0.2604646981,
0.3027731478,
-0.5884538293,
-0.4523586631,
0.2481184602,
-0.0786691979,
0.2617268264,
-0.1443991661,
0.820839107,
-0.1295061857,
-0.504535079,
0.353505075,
-0.3207630217,
0.5897818804,
-0.6287876964,
-0.0428017005,
-0.1263798475,
0.1121253967,
0.086588189,
-0.6249892116,
0.180648759,
0.0986894295,
0.0944873467,
-0.6207034588,
0.9402444959,
-0.5284981132,
-0.4800757766,
0.2331124246,
0.5108693838,
-0.3281944394,
-0.1493982375,
-0.6097023487,
-0.3548561037,
-0.059546046,
-0.2841792703,
0.0996613875,
0.6512801647,
0.5259108543,
0.6682716608,
0.5583292246,
-0.0368349366,
0.210071072,
0.2662276626,
0.9555267096,
-0.6058511138,
-0.4683083892,
-0.879468143,
0.4963480234,
-0.4572195709,
-0.2755087018,
0.8360880017,
0.5193344355,
0.6395111084,
-0.0855608806,
1.0144908428,
0.0031463865,
0.6836420894,
-0.568896234,
0.7221355438,
-0.325204283,
0.1290237159,
-0.2528688908,
-0.808085084,
-0.2664913237,
0.6468144059,
-0.4255141616,
0.0350339897,
0.5649712682,
0.5673053265,
0.1648015976,
0.0747770444,
0.4756058156,
0.2451269031,
0.4562313855,
0.3825445175,
1.2732713223,
-0.4883604646,
0.6283940077,
-0.1414415389,
-0.1320971251,
0.0034764374,
-0.9422855377,
-1.099986434,
-0.4305181205,
-0.3782629669,
-0.0841446444,
0.1260597557,
1.0018463135,
0.450001806,
-0.5943600535,
0.0679949,
-0.6635857224,
0.0430734791,
-0.173250407,
-0.2070223391,
0.2010057718,
-0.8140429258,
-0.789332509,
0.3459820151,
0.3100626767,
0.3648341894,
-0.0917628184,
-0.0089727398,
-0.1394872069,
0.1708227992,
0.6039581895,
0.2534320951,
-0.1619505435,
-0.2927680612,
0.0787190124,
0.1626910418,
0.275316298,
0.7909091711,
-1.1808421612,
0.7505362034,
0.6168641448,
0.4885280728,
0.5102465153,
-0.0738945156,
1.021361351,
-1.0728250742,
0.0094048698,
0.1197924688,
0.2307458371,
0.4322577417,
-0.4474928975,
0.1974519193,
0.1444259435,
-0.6132828593,
-0.4603535235,
0.3319125772,
-0.3790259063,
-0.0809191987,
0.9734944105,
0.1528652608,
-0.0956655368,
-0.2235736102,
-0.2118413299,
0.3853798509,
-0.6209747195,
0.8593687415,
0.2471813709,
0.0887199119,
-0.2020296007,
-0.3396574259,
0.7354275584,
0.2828849256,
-0.9393274784,
0.1552129388,
0.1333401352,
0.1101644263,
0.0691020489,
0.1805905253,
0.0592008829,
0.0913926363,
-0.1984018683,
0.3295698762,
-0.1499573588,
-0.4015546441,
-0.3122887015,
0.0870742127,
-0.0503321216,
-0.060798455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03848v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03848v1 | Controlling Personality Style in Dialogue with Zero-Shot Prompt-Based Learning | 2023-02-08T02:45:21 | 2023-02-08T02:45:21 | Angela Ramirez, Mamon Alsalihy, Kartik Aggarwal, Cecilia Li, Liren Wu, Marilyn Walker | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt-based or in-context learning has achieved high zero-shot performance
on many natural language generation (NLG) tasks. Here we explore the
performance of prompt-based learning for simultaneously controlling the
personality and the semantic accuracy of an NLG for task-oriented dialogue. We
experiment with prompt-based learning on the PERSONAGE restaurant
recommendation corpus to generate semantically and stylistically-controlled
text for 5 different Big-5 personality types: agreeable, disagreeable,
conscientious, unconscientious, and extravert. We test two different classes of
discrete prompts to generate utterances for a particular personality style: (1)
prompts that demonstrate generating directly from a meaning representation that
includes a personality specification; and (2) prompts that rely on first
converting the meaning representation to a textual pseudo-reference, and then
using the pseudo-reference in a textual style transfer (TST) prompt. In each
case, we show that we can vastly improve performance by over-generating outputs
and ranking them, testing several ranking functions based on automatic metrics
for semantic accuracy, personality-match, and fluency. We also test whether NLG
personality demonstrations from the restaurant domain can be used with meaning
representations for the video game domain to generate personality stylized
utterances about video games. Our findings show that the TST prompts produces
the highest semantic accuracy (78.46% for restaurants and 87.6% for video
games) and personality accuracy (100% for restaurants and 97% for video games).
Our results on transferring personality style to video game utterances are
surprisingly good. To our knowledge, there is no previous work testing the
application of prompt-based learning to simultaneously controlling both style
and semantic accuracy in NLG. | [
-0.3330575526,
-0.9958354831,
0.7683202624,
0.4509957433,
-0.0603377149,
0.0240954161,
-0.4169377983,
-0.1241564751,
0.162992686,
0.5439914465,
-0.7739348412,
-0.7285141349,
-0.392574966,
0.4038214684,
0.18716003,
1.1080902815,
0.1576271504,
0.0529601909,
-0.1587416679,
-0.159245804,
-1.1976394653,
-0.5557041168,
-0.8600221872,
-0.3365707397,
0.7740749717,
0.5148256421,
0.4997575283,
0.5237529278,
0.0913496017,
0.2258958966,
0.3435424864,
0.0745361,
-0.4366956055,
0.5008025169,
-0.522746563,
-0.3450173438,
-0.0851057321,
0.0992149562,
0.3120230734,
0.4500014484,
0.0510506071,
0.0008883333,
-0.0315758958,
0.583244741,
-0.3188607097,
0.3770938516,
-0.3743030131,
0.168718949,
-0.0667402819,
-0.3579750061,
-0.7033960223,
-0.4912957549,
0.4175385237,
-0.6511913538,
0.0252271369,
0.0508113615,
0.5564482212,
0.25494802,
-0.3297648132,
-0.6385223269,
-0.8241286278,
0.841118753,
-0.4401311278,
0.1391853988,
0.3715264499,
0.3605206013,
-0.0747390911,
-0.2462952882,
-0.6019092798,
-0.4768651128,
-0.1117368266,
0.2289392948,
-0.0198066402,
0.010483765,
0.4791123271,
-0.2204731852,
-0.6023682356,
-0.0133723253,
0.1078164801,
0.0354293734,
0.6066188812,
0.1663915664,
0.3236121535,
-0.4070429504,
-0.3259557188,
-0.3719398379,
-0.5666084886,
0.356376797,
0.2852888107,
0.3482927978,
0.1684068292,
0.4814483821,
-0.2121767104,
0.5648864508,
0.5693277717,
-0.4428488612,
0.0664600581,
-0.4274026752,
0.0893963054,
0.3208616972,
0.815751493,
0.696633637,
0.4790010452,
-0.2981177568,
-0.0045225848,
0.1100255325,
0.4377622604,
-0.5754714608,
-0.2208739668,
0.1082684696,
-0.2493032515,
-0.2438192964,
-0.0015020916,
-0.7175854445,
-0.4463793635,
-0.2966651022,
0.3952436447,
-0.7031795382,
0.087232396,
-0.1261959821,
-0.2769335508,
0.6085726023,
0.3890538514,
-1.0569045544,
0.0234902147,
0.3268532157,
0.9495475292,
-0.3978453577,
-0.1176473871,
-0.7292553782,
0.2569122612,
-0.5590531826,
0.6794703603,
-0.4138117135,
-0.7363116741,
-0.0271949265,
-0.2216749042,
0.0511526167,
-0.5036898255,
0.4894520938,
-0.002989715,
0.3029758334,
-0.5828489661,
-0.5235284567,
0.0935097784,
0.1303046644,
-0.24667041,
0.8505472541,
0.186910525,
-0.241761297,
0.6049248576,
-0.6298874617,
-0.5746344328,
0.3607740402,
-0.2037231326,
-0.1636501998,
-0.1040745527,
0.0405449308,
0.5302452445,
0.2152234763,
0.3765852153,
-0.165294528,
-0.3877676129,
0.4469609857,
-0.0738324597,
0.3798110187,
-0.1060990095,
-0.6605759859,
0.2907511294,
-0.4763709903,
0.0510276929,
-0.0482707731,
0.0563292429,
-0.3255889714,
0.0272721983,
-0.3096197546,
0.4546394348,
0.1213579699,
-0.4697783291,
0.1141494215,
-0.15667063,
0.2739496529,
0.6952013373,
0.2433701754,
0.5309612155,
-0.6539314985,
0.3388446867,
-0.0773866251,
-0.1058615297,
-0.2549947202,
-0.5046294928,
-0.6068813205,
-0.2304121703,
-0.1260249615,
0.808219552,
-1.1055551767,
0.885474503,
0.1341093332,
-0.5956166983,
-0.1705812663,
-0.2538032234,
0.5264960527,
0.9901134968,
0.4986552298,
-0.4390121102,
-0.2103592604,
-0.5701428056,
-0.3070069253,
-0.2943997383,
-0.154485032,
0.7073484659,
0.1749322861,
0.1250962168,
1.0078450441,
-0.529471755,
-0.2062598765,
-0.4792342484,
0.3913897574,
0.0207802523,
0.3857131302,
0.7785434723,
-0.4255827963,
-0.7776818275,
-0.1731719375,
-0.5979088545,
-0.3832462728,
-0.424980402,
-0.124909468,
0.2703997195,
0.3029732406,
-0.3494205177,
0.2757007182,
-0.0660946965,
-0.5309094787,
1.0284234285,
-0.1383880079,
0.1951987296,
-0.9236109257,
-0.0578876399,
0.2417596728,
-0.2999154925,
-0.700764358,
-0.2632084489,
-0.2381529063,
0.0367775261,
-0.3075568676,
0.8146808743,
0.0793999285,
0.0922140181,
-0.2064496726,
0.1217989475,
0.1023052335,
0.9037011862,
0.3561063409,
0.8969282508,
0.5972040296,
-0.754771471,
0.5636355877,
0.4239193499,
-0.3442838192,
1.2562832832,
-0.7309525609,
0.283732444,
-0.3351481259,
0.4290817082,
-1.2230796814,
-0.0213155169,
0.3917629719,
-0.2648591101,
0.0663392097,
0.0221356601,
-0.3810960352,
0.0270106606,
-0.1388298869,
-0.398804158,
0.5982310176,
-0.3352565169,
0.4331393242,
-0.1894736439,
-0.476402998,
-0.2613856196,
-0.7040759325,
-0.0974309668,
-0.3165812194,
-0.2450355291,
0.3746335506,
-0.3953055739,
-0.1391118914,
-0.2559739649,
-0.0812058002,
0.1263373792,
-0.023365315,
0.2153348625,
0.2716200054,
-0.0010579516,
0.1392455548,
0.1136533096,
-0.0227496177,
0.0903148577,
-0.3802373707,
0.5504413247,
-0.0796577185,
0.130630061,
-0.4975790083,
0.4312577844,
0.298286289,
-0.1981540024,
0.7591028214,
0.6883850694,
0.3203229904,
-0.3843924403,
-0.2489645481,
-0.3520449996,
-0.4492343068,
0.2061405182,
-0.3269940615,
-0.8893464208,
0.6866956353,
0.0696701854,
0.1038628668,
0.1310177594,
0.3757559657,
-0.3093325198,
0.8305845261,
0.2802293599,
0.3710344732,
0.8668434024,
0.1383451372,
0.1346307099,
-0.4216274619,
-0.3153716326,
-0.4021009803,
-0.4816378951,
-0.7513025403,
-0.1668181419,
0.32612589,
-0.305454731,
-0.3766411841,
0.439180702,
-0.2903755009,
0.5733367205,
0.640537858,
0.1878392547,
0.1160490587,
-0.3744722903,
-0.3163767159,
-0.3267779946,
-0.3406206965,
-0.3664182723,
0.7736429572,
-0.0169687122,
0.4963174462,
0.3860479891,
0.6726799607,
0.4285876751,
0.0781465918,
-0.9849514961,
0.3955836892,
-0.2527327538,
-0.2781931758,
-0.4610826075,
-0.6507698298,
-0.43745327,
-0.1120743006,
-0.2589416504,
-0.7453526258,
0.1821883172,
0.2354384214,
-0.640270412,
-0.0756228268,
-1.0125063658,
0.8279263377,
-0.1311061233,
-0.4931097925,
0.1811783016,
-0.7585952878,
0.1686814427,
-0.0085435081,
-0.2430613488,
-0.1791313589,
0.1727796793,
0.4132499993,
-0.0521712974,
0.7507279515,
-0.2747426927,
0.0833207145,
0.1408640891,
0.361040622,
0.4414903224,
0.3027472496,
0.0109837707,
0.0545576923,
0.1545387506,
-0.2733488679,
-1.0865929127,
0.6395165324,
-0.815943718,
-0.4596202075,
-0.4806558788,
-0.4083231091,
-0.5749493837,
0.2320064604,
0.3276257813,
0.6134120822,
-0.4051874578,
0.1580941975,
0.9343870282,
-0.479645282,
0.5200429559,
0.4613414705,
-0.1503016353,
-0.2226874381,
1.0276482105,
0.1351353228,
0.3426102698,
0.3966523409,
0.424523741,
-0.6644316912,
-0.1111602709,
-0.6511893868,
0.0657631382,
-0.3695670366,
0.0097519914,
-0.4887267053,
-0.0782305822,
-0.4809247553,
-0.4923773408,
-0.1343735307,
-0.1539327502,
-0.3026406467,
0.075955838,
0.3670288324,
0.6562337279,
0.3640750051,
0.5056880116,
-0.4199536741,
0.0592819229,
0.3999510407,
0.3156778514,
-0.1537264287,
-0.362491399,
0.2254784256,
-0.3132532835,
-0.3416001797,
-1.1214776039,
0.4897542298,
0.1990015358,
0.2027035356,
0.4428485632,
0.0194274597,
0.3497918248,
-0.6691037416,
0.9997408986,
0.1412063241,
-0.9455233812,
0.4844051898,
-0.6016547084,
0.7753325701,
0.7975269556,
0.3891404867,
-1.009898901,
-0.3447678685,
-0.5413429737,
-0.4683300257,
0.8169562221,
-0.0349186957,
0.2853022218,
-0.310141623,
0.4901892245,
0.2731503844,
0.4398041666,
-0.4458256364,
-0.457332015,
-0.5133548379,
-0.1062078848,
-0.0640211329,
0.0600355305,
0.0944151506,
-0.2352716327,
0.5183451176,
-0.4079397619,
0.3305330276,
0.2957752049,
0.145061478,
0.0692958757,
0.3972895443,
0.7697882056,
0.5214731693,
-0.2361210138,
0.0061732931,
-0.0886330977,
-0.2964840531,
0.107566312,
-0.3424909115,
-0.326148212,
0.0998339131,
0.0708774552,
1.0733491182,
0.3080302775,
-0.596737206,
0.5214399099,
-0.2185885757,
-0.2114458829,
-0.1368280947,
0.3866741657,
-0.2494896799,
-0.0946056992,
0.130216226,
0.1058184728,
0.0262116808,
-0.7226044536,
0.3912407458,
0.33928743,
-0.384449631,
-0.2205918878,
0.2799316347,
0.2016913742,
-0.2127145082,
0.5254077315,
-0.6181428432,
-0.200513795,
0.301689297,
0.6826999784,
0.8674426079,
-0.1839078218,
0.8817631006,
0.5064105988,
-0.2146214545,
0.0858951434,
0.2209998667,
-0.4361781478,
-0.8014310002,
-0.6153081059,
-0.5461543798,
-0.727847755,
0.0550000258,
-0.6357533336,
0.3208817244,
-0.9467196465,
-0.1153321192,
-0.005866833,
0.1592724472,
-0.4310829043,
-0.0818954036,
0.0158737488,
0.5017306209,
-0.7327199578,
0.5125007033,
0.7006444335,
-0.4105853736,
-0.9379515052,
0.135005042,
0.0885283649,
-0.476922214,
0.4199734032,
0.0520135947,
-0.1037891209,
0.1978532076,
-0.5346562266,
-0.6116820574,
0.828671813,
0.1562114358,
-0.4341405332,
-0.2929391861,
-0.1510260105,
0.6337025166,
-0.3903311193,
0.4436579049,
0.577860415,
0.4168824255,
0.5874589086,
-0.8076611161,
-0.0813689083,
0.2087584883,
0.0693428069,
0.0700235516,
-0.6663409472,
0.3123231232,
-0.073672846,
-0.1399889588,
-0.0266439486,
0.7624292374,
0.35228917,
0.1281833947,
0.3632659614,
0.1978841722,
0.7833413482,
-0.270408392,
0.860650897,
-0.1507662386,
-0.0686718747,
1.1500083208,
-0.578612268,
0.6099009514,
0.2302856296,
0.2558674514,
0.9404085875,
0.4342580736,
0.013234376,
0.6916217208,
-0.0603187867,
-0.2065092772,
0.0071672755,
-0.5015239716,
0.1591123194,
0.5997622013,
0.2560236454,
-0.3239101171,
-0.1054234207,
0.1589125395,
0.2716859281,
0.2061313093,
-0.2161273658,
1.13390553,
-0.2077148557,
-0.9909338951,
0.2015393376,
-0.0045016492,
0.789085269,
-0.870945394,
-0.0975441411,
-0.1746641099,
-0.2615599334,
0.0872662514,
-0.773793757,
0.324038893,
0.0830644369,
-0.1750917286,
-0.7208203673,
0.521040976,
-0.6715843081,
-0.0317633003,
-0.1393470913,
0.4297209978,
0.1073607057,
0.0571898594,
-0.476220876,
-0.2659371197,
-0.1074113995,
0.1679254919,
0.2854768336,
0.5136742592,
0.0169682056,
0.1863351911,
0.4940118194,
0.0736239254,
-0.0397210307,
0.0114530697,
0.3973466754,
-0.6268136501,
-0.8364439011,
-0.8002906442,
0.1809226722,
-0.013232748,
-0.6703121066,
0.8643571138,
0.1108242422,
0.9758059382,
-0.2539189756,
0.6874452829,
-0.1726755798,
0.3063476086,
-0.421913594,
0.5673769712,
-0.0165382996,
-0.3813950419,
-0.46572873,
-0.8957980275,
-0.1263268441,
0.6850372553,
-0.6325426698,
0.2046314627,
0.7152734995,
0.5634251237,
0.5447856784,
0.0720397234,
0.6383538842,
-0.0785707608,
0.3400726616,
0.518307209,
0.5376799107,
0.2811454535,
0.0341832601,
-0.3317794204,
-0.4149033427,
-0.1029015034,
-0.776995182,
-0.9912446737,
-0.7604626417,
-0.2694269419,
-0.4377845526,
0.0475742295,
1.1435992718,
0.6141842604,
-0.6489343643,
-0.1499554068,
-0.107400462,
0.0219540652,
-0.5893981457,
-0.3423455358,
0.1044311449,
-0.4872010052,
-0.7192124128,
0.4893443286,
0.4021198153,
-0.0944214463,
-0.4213114679,
0.0204989947,
-0.0420706421,
0.3175474703,
0.8253632784,
0.3631322384,
-0.6384127736,
-0.5274980664,
0.3605980277,
-0.1917253137,
0.0997772813,
0.9995384216,
-0.764934659,
0.5714448094,
0.35242033,
0.5124539733,
0.1453025043,
0.286441803,
0.5785464048,
-1.2567849159,
-0.2313561738,
0.216057837,
-0.0969378278,
0.4483411908,
-0.6761113405,
0.0173789915,
0.4534488916,
-0.559191823,
-0.1662350297,
0.5178438425,
-1.010613203,
-0.073636055,
1.2034732103,
-0.1192296743,
-0.2923857272,
-0.1523413658,
-0.4333385229,
0.3339651525,
-0.8739539385,
0.6926136017,
0.9320925474,
-0.6834282279,
-0.1612153798,
-0.4424630702,
0.9011129141,
0.5649050474,
-0.7527707219,
0.0469938777,
0.652054131,
0.2578500807,
0.2554710209,
0.4897151291,
0.00728556,
0.3670675159,
-0.4920057654,
0.0106089925,
-0.0033081123,
-0.571457684,
-0.3786432445,
0.0973701477,
-0.0567264594,
0.1021946818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03822v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03822v2 | Clinical BioBERT Hyperparameter Optimization using Genetic Algorithm | 2023-02-08T01:11:59 | 2023-02-13T03:55:10 | Navya Martin Kollapally, James Geller | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Clinical factors account only for a small portion, about 10-30%, of the
controllable factors that affect an individual's health outcomes. The remaining
factors include where a person was born and raised, where he/she pursued their
education, what their work and family environment is like, etc. These factors
are collectively referred to as Social Determinants of Health (SDoH). The
majority of SDoH data is recorded in unstructured clinical notes by physicians
and practitioners. Recording SDoH data in a structured manner (in an EHR) could
greatly benefit from a dedicated ontology of SDoH terms. Our research focuses
on extracting sentences from clinical notes, making use of such an SDoH
ontology (called SOHO) to provide appropriate concepts. We utilize recent
advancements in Deep Learning to optimize the hyperparameters of a Clinical
BioBERT model for SDoH text. A genetic algorithm-based hyperparameter tuning
regimen was implemented to identify optimal parameter settings. To implement a
complete classifier, we pipelined Clinical BioBERT with two subsequent linear
layers and two dropout layers. The output predicts whether a text fragment
describes an SDoH issue of the patient. We compared the AdamW, Adafactor, and
LAMB optimizers. In our experiments, AdamW outperformed the others in terms of
accuracy. | [
-0.2971875668,
-0.8808193803,
1.0427794456,
0.1216781437,
-0.1752701998,
0.2203617692,
-0.0112942318,
-0.3631270826,
0.6050903201,
0.5066171288,
-0.4988549054,
-0.8262320161,
-0.7957653403,
0.0478127562,
0.1125729904,
1.2187954187,
0.2061404139,
0.3557423055,
-0.3012166917,
-0.2456302643,
-0.0218362976,
-0.3453264534,
-0.6118348837,
-0.3922668397,
0.715478003,
0.4209382534,
0.7015554309,
1.1120160818,
0.8210093975,
0.3315842152,
-0.418585211,
0.0963446647,
-0.3324197233,
0.1490466297,
-0.0599591471,
-0.2476939559,
-0.4982072115,
-0.0986045897,
0.3280435503,
0.7482370734,
-0.2327055186,
0.5683310628,
-0.0612140074,
0.8816503882,
-0.6960087419,
0.0617325678,
-0.429597348,
0.3873742223,
-0.1784741133,
-0.6578462124,
-0.0576782636,
-0.7871643305,
0.3745723963,
-0.5098816752,
0.5082895756,
-0.1452704817,
0.6317224503,
0.2654357851,
-0.3490780294,
-0.1842062622,
-0.6917830706,
0.7334619164,
-0.6358187199,
0.2730887532,
0.4791119397,
0.0471865796,
-0.1226891205,
-0.5947058201,
-0.2780480385,
-0.2901341915,
-0.0847053081,
0.3639800847,
0.0591336563,
0.3813946247,
0.3267061412,
0.1283023655,
-0.54975003,
0.0780016035,
-0.7292359471,
-0.3744618595,
0.80188936,
0.5745928288,
0.1537420899,
-0.284295857,
-0.3798237443,
-0.0020661037,
-0.4010896981,
0.1164130792,
0.0957324132,
0.0901992619,
0.0891361907,
0.3988844454,
-0.005673077,
0.4382789433,
0.0070765889,
-0.3155930638,
0.4083669782,
-0.3311990201,
-0.0200067554,
0.6509449482,
0.7572743297,
0.3505495191,
0.0791422874,
0.0498252697,
0.0903831795,
0.0721991435,
0.528102994,
-0.812409699,
-0.19260481,
0.6222674251,
-0.6706368327,
-0.6281622648,
-0.1924415678,
-1.0668257475,
-0.4954846203,
-0.3823159337,
0.09406735,
-0.3482166827,
0.4925254881,
-0.1292355061,
-0.257212311,
-0.1743736416,
0.2323732823,
-0.964261055,
0.1533385664,
0.4581622183,
0.8659656048,
0.0595524535,
0.0002979269,
-0.5550851226,
0.3432601094,
-0.1991055608,
0.4807272553,
-0.3184964359,
-0.3541305065,
0.0511824526,
-0.0414963774,
-0.0928894356,
-0.4793818593,
0.4908436537,
-0.2096011192,
-0.2404008359,
-0.2984280586,
-0.5206817985,
0.1508290023,
-0.1083152294,
-0.5531775355,
0.707257092,
0.215902403,
-0.6679328084,
0.5895426273,
-0.5708237886,
-0.7377990484,
0.5016422868,
-0.3422454,
-0.7435361147,
0.1201332733,
0.1427204013,
0.6432421803,
-0.369427532,
0.2042625844,
-0.4580179751,
-0.2569482625,
0.1224153638,
-0.0116964048,
0.8355243802,
0.1796420366,
-0.2732138336,
0.2380131781,
-1.1254001856,
0.1729626507,
0.1511488706,
-0.5624735951,
-0.4638197124,
0.2183708698,
0.1585312188,
0.0197395533,
0.1572042853,
-0.9984514713,
-0.1789943874,
-0.212595582,
0.6485237479,
0.6647048593,
0.2562278211,
-0.0878174603,
-0.2731134593,
0.4391701221,
-0.1140958816,
0.4875166118,
0.3710340559,
-0.4715858996,
-0.2262457013,
-0.4426386952,
0.1135483831,
0.6433179975,
-0.3226664364,
0.9377087355,
0.0292943064,
-0.3900631368,
-0.781491518,
0.5255528092,
0.526943326,
0.6629484892,
0.4991424382,
-0.2509305179,
-0.3004807234,
-0.7781199813,
0.2196132541,
-0.0975848883,
0.1613121629,
0.2909229994,
0.3593953848,
-0.5314801335,
0.6132102013,
-0.888043642,
-0.4177577198,
-0.4158378839,
0.0726836696,
0.1586476564,
0.3852351308,
0.5821524858,
-0.5796752572,
-0.256320715,
0.2238072306,
-0.7951506376,
-0.1516916156,
0.1162922457,
-0.2447017431,
-0.14003326,
0.5546902418,
-0.4366773963,
0.6632750034,
0.3501178622,
0.0167713873,
0.436637044,
-0.807502687,
-0.2774994671,
-0.9022750854,
0.1798308343,
0.4335422218,
-0.0152776232,
-0.4775140285,
0.1258744299,
0.0595959909,
-0.1657500863,
-0.3985466659,
0.2298299521,
-0.0253875386,
0.3804676831,
-0.0114112087,
0.0103830807,
0.0927595869,
0.4506961405,
-0.0227875486,
0.360775739,
0.1467636228,
-0.4661176205,
0.4640593231,
0.5273632407,
-0.2860794961,
0.3387205601,
-1.142224431,
0.0484102815,
-0.5009946227,
0.1819809377,
-0.8794212937,
-0.138093695,
-0.072260268,
-0.3203770518,
-0.0154714053,
0.1952623427,
-0.217125982,
-0.4886773825,
-0.6549246907,
-0.0399000347,
0.6062481999,
-0.1930282861,
0.167283088,
0.347887069,
-0.3092731237,
-0.208736822,
-0.5817809701,
-0.3411512673,
-0.168089062,
-0.4187368453,
0.4307740331,
0.0800913498,
-0.0576650761,
-0.1700714231,
-0.0115128709,
0.0580332503,
-0.1105107218,
0.2552405298,
0.4184261858,
-0.2450768352,
0.1611125767,
0.4499286413,
-0.236078456,
0.3181702495,
0.044739984,
0.364387244,
0.0690315962,
0.1014572158,
-0.6472207904,
0.4242222905,
0.5837900043,
-0.2545087337,
1.0080069304,
0.6390411854,
-0.1588875055,
-0.0170549862,
-0.3511713445,
-0.080671154,
-0.4810354114,
0.5012475252,
0.0867719278,
-0.4503470361,
0.6019459367,
-0.0703236982,
-0.0534582958,
0.4014272094,
0.7053732276,
-0.3950971961,
1.2103344202,
0.3331038952,
0.0263864528,
0.186168611,
-0.4264634848,
0.1045603827,
-1.0341815948,
-0.222611621,
-0.5135989785,
-0.2710940838,
-0.9021651149,
0.1004465595,
0.9725416303,
-0.2599495947,
-0.5038479567,
0.2784616649,
-0.6323565245,
0.0747701377,
0.7221875191,
0.9272877574,
-0.0096216053,
-0.0841068625,
-0.4967527092,
0.0997788534,
-0.5972689986,
-0.3874305785,
1.1480978727,
0.4638410211,
0.581723392,
0.0810582265,
0.8677578568,
0.2935594916,
0.1187357903,
-0.6034559608,
0.4377490878,
-0.4648717046,
-0.6988115907,
-0.5627306104,
-0.541760385,
-1.174343586,
0.055628024,
-0.4279920459,
-0.9751264453,
0.4570138752,
0.3739819825,
-0.7898417115,
-0.0906865746,
-0.3725963831,
0.7405885458,
-0.3429316282,
-0.5472662449,
-0.1273844987,
-1.1881171465,
-0.1865862608,
-0.4035243392,
0.0573963933,
-0.2744633853,
0.2400346249,
0.6811350584,
-0.7008505464,
0.5843051672,
-0.0056341309,
0.3226484656,
0.0712251291,
-0.2217885256,
0.2830106616,
0.0359668508,
-0.165289402,
0.2032039464,
0.4642476439,
-0.5227206945,
-0.5189370513,
0.4805271327,
-0.9161253572,
-0.5447599292,
-0.2798014879,
-0.1887926608,
-0.3475058973,
0.0601627342,
0.4546703398,
0.5937929153,
-0.1739960313,
0.2855530381,
0.5714842677,
-0.5873960853,
0.0891446546,
0.3207024634,
0.2135204226,
-0.4245097637,
0.8563298583,
0.0626877472,
0.3576643765,
0.4017121494,
0.931343317,
-0.1570867002,
-0.4676295221,
-0.3301426172,
0.2574555278,
-0.723377347,
-0.0556361005,
-0.6079694629,
-0.4764487743,
-0.4692825079,
-0.4306894839,
-0.0605244637,
-0.007908213,
-0.2830649018,
-0.1894261688,
0.4558218122,
0.3810734749,
0.0832079276,
0.2684341669,
-1.0495988131,
0.3854553998,
0.2089045644,
0.0394804366,
0.0533645861,
-0.1593592018,
-0.1606007814,
-0.0743778646,
-0.5296986103,
-0.7603850961,
0.4251586795,
0.2009106874,
0.5589764714,
0.7471654415,
-0.0085864356,
0.539249301,
-0.5904740095,
0.2670436203,
0.2684982121,
-0.6927610636,
0.9321228266,
-0.2919459045,
0.2136014551,
0.8956094384,
0.6156983972,
-0.2283633351,
-0.2086173892,
-0.5586944222,
-0.9323111773,
0.4393558502,
0.1623231322,
-0.0130486591,
-0.0822700933,
0.5200648308,
-0.0006335579,
0.2350361049,
-0.1489280909,
-0.2793246806,
0.0989752263,
-0.5493562222,
-0.155481562,
-0.122050561,
-0.3754861653,
-0.8301798701,
0.2744535804,
-0.2281738669,
0.2694799304,
0.4840081036,
0.2392251641,
-0.4104880095,
0.0949001536,
0.530411303,
0.8624968529,
-0.6506769657,
-0.0232316982,
0.0169802811,
-1.0071365833,
0.0908003598,
0.1342676431,
-0.2589585185,
-0.1448099464,
0.6530967951,
0.6967282295,
-0.1620201766,
-0.6275312304,
0.4647147655,
0.300624311,
-0.4005060494,
-0.2705204785,
0.2623350918,
-0.2739573121,
0.1198460013,
-0.0001447857,
-0.0919133872,
0.397757411,
-0.5241625905,
0.1270262003,
0.246281594,
-0.5831386447,
-0.088655442,
1.0497245789,
0.3674618006,
-0.3498172462,
0.6510103345,
0.2566694319,
-0.3939599097,
1.0213733912,
0.467368722,
0.7866641879,
-0.0737536922,
0.5479776263,
0.19560799,
0.0578861386,
0.1955132335,
0.3018497229,
0.0744127259,
-0.7143107057,
-0.2172501683,
-0.8669956923,
-0.4727128148,
0.0021810031,
-0.9093477726,
0.123524338,
-0.8486391902,
-0.4449571371,
0.7989733219,
0.0843747333,
-0.7180820107,
0.5547326803,
-0.094936274,
0.4308061004,
-0.7184023261,
0.6795428991,
0.7640841007,
-0.467454493,
-0.5873172879,
-0.0631440356,
0.224665463,
-1.1001056433,
0.5936151743,
-0.1475474685,
0.0089952974,
-0.1818614602,
-0.3898525834,
-0.543104291,
1.0042620897,
0.203920722,
-0.7075542808,
0.2515550256,
0.3268682957,
0.9376693964,
-0.0083993925,
0.0589654557,
0.6074716449,
0.337613672,
0.241730988,
-0.5792911053,
0.2407282591,
-0.173314482,
0.2570309639,
0.4547508359,
-0.7963377237,
0.5584439635,
-0.5295162201,
0.4059590697,
-0.0671750084,
0.0711449608,
0.5137932897,
0.7109405994,
0.0699546635,
0.3797156811,
0.6323450804,
0.2245934755,
1.281239748,
-0.4724644125,
0.3738185763,
0.5669489503,
-0.4945491552,
0.4223741293,
0.4082128406,
-0.4850702584,
0.3591624498,
0.6442863941,
-0.1007129624,
0.5969372392,
0.4116185308,
-0.3869408369,
0.1523882151,
0.0299712885,
-0.2769811451,
0.5255348086,
0.3900752366,
-0.9096662402,
0.2808572054,
-0.1289548278,
0.138895303,
-0.0922192261,
-0.2352872789,
0.766372025,
-0.0996032655,
-0.3778732121,
0.3282673657,
0.0352866612,
0.0671278909,
-0.6202481985,
-0.1328940243,
-0.179966405,
0.4658978879,
-0.3374562562,
-0.6167368889,
0.1775999069,
-0.4523619115,
-0.0528004467,
0.0189914517,
0.726834476,
-0.2365895212,
-0.8129965663,
0.3160900474,
0.3894508779,
0.0739032179,
0.3390599787,
-0.6316986084,
-0.1890354455,
-0.2443489283,
-0.2086029053,
0.2045081258,
0.3156582117,
0.1233358905,
0.4909623861,
0.7800260186,
0.6811877489,
-0.3551656008,
0.071600318,
0.55465734,
-0.763425529,
-0.4595096707,
-0.9455708861,
0.0171225835,
-0.1491778046,
-0.7572170496,
0.5594576001,
0.3847436011,
0.2957062721,
0.034232758,
0.7683953047,
0.2350385487,
0.5381134748,
-0.4803015292,
0.8038285375,
-0.6075168252,
-0.0557892025,
-0.6079685092,
-0.8444008231,
-0.2810112834,
0.5009751916,
-0.101199761,
0.018987067,
0.8286417723,
0.4772150517,
0.2310743481,
0.1700287908,
0.2181496769,
-0.0216954518,
0.1404431015,
0.4293590486,
0.075615637,
-0.0186806992,
0.0130669121,
-0.4500343204,
-0.4747891426,
-0.2672752738,
-0.5296820998,
-0.8127707243,
-0.2819320858,
-0.4528400898,
-0.5038283467,
0.4934027195,
1.0349680185,
0.6482135653,
-0.8292405605,
-0.0330707952,
-0.0815046355,
-0.0738280565,
-0.3614184558,
-0.1798460186,
0.7485408187,
-0.1481262147,
-0.25018242,
-0.1387383044,
0.4170100093,
-0.1421191394,
-0.2776768506,
0.1901557148,
-0.1569543034,
0.2584272623,
0.6915327907,
0.175361082,
-0.3011333048,
-0.1995802522,
-0.1210483983,
-0.2674178183,
0.1441452652,
0.7194757462,
-0.4009476006,
0.3782731295,
0.4034531713,
0.6617522836,
0.3585945666,
0.0830055326,
0.4075441658,
-0.534744978,
-0.0558658689,
0.2273885161,
0.2314033061,
-0.1272444278,
-0.8308262825,
0.5849871039,
0.3835011721,
-0.7170242071,
-0.3899297416,
-0.288202107,
-0.9178779125,
-0.2186326087,
1.1474235058,
0.0948906839,
-0.2818427682,
-0.2205564231,
-0.1928622723,
0.2262896299,
-0.2867281735,
0.9174260497,
0.3404184878,
-0.5483745933,
-0.0143560478,
-0.8983109593,
0.4543974996,
0.5516244769,
-0.8743072152,
-0.4154080451,
0.1311808527,
0.2443971336,
0.1422350407,
0.5303695798,
-0.1329980791,
0.3567776084,
-0.2117843032,
0.1066084132,
0.2786714435,
-0.1926364899,
0.0018739435,
0.0881104916,
-0.4376586676,
-0.3886575699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03815v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03815v1 | Long Text and Multi-Table Summarization: Dataset and Method | 2023-02-08T00:46:55 | 2023-02-08T00:46:55 | Shuaiqi Liu, Jiannong Cao, Ruosong Yang, Zhiyuan Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.7 | Automatic document summarization aims to produce a concise summary covering
the input document's salient information. Within a report document, the salient
information can be scattered in the textual and non-textual content. However,
existing document summarization datasets and methods usually focus on the text
and filter out the non-textual content. Missing tabular data can limit produced
summaries' informativeness, especially when summaries require covering
quantitative descriptions of critical metrics in tables. Existing datasets and
methods cannot meet the requirements of summarizing long text and multiple
tables in each report. To deal with the scarcity of available data, we propose
FINDSum, the first large-scale dataset for long text and multi-table
summarization. Built on 21,125 annual reports from 3,794 companies, it has two
subsets for summarizing each company's results of operations and liquidity. To
summarize the long text and dozens of tables in each report, we present three
types of summarization methods. Besides, we propose a set of evaluation metrics
to assess the usage of numerical information in produced summaries. Dataset
analyses and experimental results indicate the importance of jointly
considering input textual and tabular data when summarizing report documents. | [
-0.4067354798,
-0.4885105789,
0.4173361063,
0.3403904438,
-0.3408758938,
-0.1060057953,
-0.1369583607,
-0.4747011364,
0.4563194215,
0.484330982,
-0.4310187101,
-0.6510962248,
-0.434319526,
0.2565590441,
-0.5281476974,
1.6152185202,
-0.2411615402,
-0.2268503159,
-0.1031397209,
-0.2533568442,
-0.3417636156,
-0.3511548042,
-0.2165336758,
0.1175962836,
0.5738668442,
0.9398921132,
0.525298357,
0.6991618276,
0.9472584128,
0.2676190436,
0.2090230584,
0.479744941,
-0.4724777341,
0.0859989598,
0.1809805036,
-0.2605685592,
-0.7205343246,
-0.0733590424,
0.993526876,
0.5568817854,
-0.1574589461,
0.3354270458,
0.0601073392,
1.2156316042,
-0.4284548163,
0.6336158514,
-0.1082468331,
0.3068661392,
-0.3802247047,
-0.3239156008,
-0.1867340654,
-0.6519830227,
0.0634995028,
-0.6500427127,
0.2997273505,
0.0734976828,
0.429389745,
0.0852898434,
-0.6958284378,
-0.6475892067,
-0.8077738285,
0.7187761068,
-0.7950264215,
0.1084498018,
0.2832156718,
0.2703724802,
0.0992459878,
-0.6431409717,
-0.0630277395,
-0.1981097907,
-0.5343928337,
0.2273021638,
0.1527477503,
-0.2181819975,
0.2939182818,
0.593867898,
-0.7860565186,
-0.1796061993,
-0.6104422212,
0.0952529535,
0.7774903178,
0.3753116727,
-0.0485893004,
-0.0314500146,
-0.369123131,
-0.2632704675,
-0.3942886889,
-0.4543885887,
0.1582451761,
0.3290521502,
-0.2977425158,
0.6603506804,
-0.4273400903,
0.2390555739,
-0.5254496932,
-0.1913400441,
0.2843829393,
-0.7871943712,
-0.119292587,
0.3405225873,
0.4727729857,
0.5952197909,
0.1845968664,
-0.148588866,
-0.2499963492,
-0.1177666783,
-0.0589320175,
-0.7631810904,
-0.0492336191,
0.3146472275,
-0.5231803656,
-0.241041705,
0.2263110876,
-1.1150954962,
-0.3276160657,
-0.424690187,
0.0165266655,
-0.2190319002,
0.0198446866,
-0.2180760056,
-0.5438212752,
0.1116174981,
0.4850048721,
-0.5607380271,
0.7200348973,
0.4875239134,
0.9316238165,
-0.241861403,
-0.378170222,
-0.637491405,
0.6210090518,
-0.3766569495,
0.9386951923,
0.0093564242,
-0.3871109486,
-0.0758983418,
0.0626605824,
0.3179008961,
-0.6224651933,
0.5333630443,
-0.0778721645,
0.2814726233,
-0.473868221,
-0.3704867363,
-0.4054163992,
0.0721819028,
-0.9409174323,
0.964812994,
-0.0296429154,
-0.9918518066,
0.6278543472,
-0.8786574006,
-0.841789782,
-0.0918321908,
-0.1040689126,
-0.6927893758,
0.1829044074,
0.1688934565,
0.4332042038,
-0.2742733359,
0.2843135893,
-0.0245681629,
-0.2695877552,
0.2531119287,
-0.1750681847,
0.0665899515,
0.0892194733,
-0.3183670044,
0.2148946971,
-0.6820722222,
-0.1452526897,
0.2029844075,
-0.2966791391,
-0.229892537,
0.3147495687,
0.4208358526,
-0.0052504078,
0.2109701633,
-0.0004910724,
-0.0520717502,
-0.1781221181,
0.1417345256,
0.2685652673,
0.0877876803,
0.3818345666,
-0.7992404103,
0.2351623029,
0.0212614909,
-0.0790717006,
-0.4185581505,
-0.0048387768,
-0.6782712936,
-0.5412196517,
0.1261232048,
0.6359836459,
-0.3849804997,
0.2374117374,
-0.4029170573,
-0.5140687823,
-0.0020347228,
-0.0965811759,
0.1499221474,
0.4197972417,
0.2695710361,
-0.1902175099,
-0.4639160633,
-1.2592155933,
-0.1210088208,
0.2027939856,
-0.1302499026,
0.0790044814,
0.5883592963,
0.3149672449,
0.7097691298,
-0.9826524854,
-0.5506287813,
-0.3799735606,
0.5327302814,
0.4180562496,
0.1960592568,
0.4980110228,
-0.5004785657,
-0.370852679,
-0.0434941351,
-0.8810926676,
0.2990500927,
-0.2615757287,
0.0124891093,
0.1830376238,
0.1856616884,
-0.4498673677,
0.5491277575,
0.0409964286,
-0.0785435438,
0.5358072519,
-0.5769224167,
0.5023236871,
-0.8601872325,
0.5073707104,
0.1345086247,
-0.3112128377,
-0.463994503,
-0.1089029834,
0.2171201557,
-0.4046964943,
-0.1486708373,
0.3199479878,
-0.6317154169,
-0.3609363139,
-0.0867006928,
0.4929082692,
0.2556146681,
0.4599435031,
0.0951056108,
0.9052286148,
0.1765066087,
-0.8281787038,
0.4411357939,
0.3686981499,
-0.3152849376,
0.3549968898,
-0.6882916689,
-0.1704101413,
-0.4429742694,
0.4437390566,
-1.1205488443,
-0.3558265567,
0.1091048345,
-0.2801324427,
0.4565269053,
0.2509828508,
-0.509789288,
-0.2848272622,
-0.947450459,
-0.0326929502,
-0.0704444349,
-0.0272993892,
0.5106290579,
0.501868248,
-0.7234323621,
-0.5716270804,
-0.923073709,
0.3330735266,
-0.3662980497,
-0.6700855494,
0.1564355046,
-0.2636681795,
-0.3396623433,
-0.1941205412,
-0.1710239202,
-0.1345900297,
-0.0747208521,
0.1492318511,
0.3865009248,
0.0062435842,
0.1637508124,
0.1230143383,
-0.3383687139,
0.0864776224,
0.2659086883,
0.1376929283,
-0.1316875517,
0.1224634573,
-0.3718150854,
0.9266015291,
0.6361572146,
-0.2137484103,
0.7135167718,
0.2377838194,
-0.4250715971,
-0.1008798406,
-0.3345753849,
0.0119679142,
-0.3587643206,
0.5256922245,
0.0036141442,
-0.1753887385,
0.8121675849,
0.0905680284,
0.5338746905,
0.8128137589,
0.4091108441,
-0.2089521885,
0.4582675397,
0.4233835936,
-0.1350367665,
0.1290013939,
-0.1661508828,
0.0967894569,
-0.2231585979,
-0.2462889254,
-0.8532854319,
-0.3050939143,
-0.467512399,
0.0144782234,
0.3894492984,
-0.6114988327,
0.1909407675,
0.234270364,
-0.412197262,
0.411863625,
0.415785253,
-0.0378905348,
0.5230647326,
0.0146889342,
0.4215079844,
-0.1417121887,
-0.472201854,
-0.4128594995,
0.79703933,
0.2970806062,
0.7317487597,
0.2172860354,
0.613291502,
0.6202582121,
0.3292751908,
-0.7742126584,
0.3984314501,
-0.2685879469,
-0.6595119834,
-0.6106502414,
-0.7777053714,
-0.7053477764,
-0.0240292046,
-0.0713542402,
0.0389609784,
-0.0141687011,
-0.0310188495,
-0.1750876009,
0.002983273,
-0.8896622658,
0.415651679,
-0.178055495,
0.0208920147,
-0.2490983158,
-0.5638380051,
0.4483353794,
-0.393263489,
0.6077979803,
-0.0417213254,
-0.1695994735,
1.0002402067,
-0.512670517,
0.5284001827,
0.0767485648,
-0.1554478407,
0.2095215172,
-0.1009892002,
0.6367018223,
0.2490011007,
-0.1008020118,
0.0825534165,
0.023076361,
-0.3352662027,
-0.3561641574,
0.6263591051,
-0.3703274727,
-0.0262688361,
-0.8474603295,
-0.6826007962,
0.1119992658,
0.2548033595,
0.2693590522,
0.7379715443,
-0.3764680624,
0.0079812584,
0.4225601852,
-0.2698555291,
0.6771482229,
0.4341049194,
0.0713755861,
-0.7393331528,
0.7579623461,
0.6875146031,
-0.1293129921,
0.3616047502,
0.0287185609,
-0.1566115022,
-0.2427488118,
-0.4200953841,
0.4797071218,
-0.6404667497,
-0.4683804512,
-0.3675176203,
-0.3053154945,
-0.3926041126,
-0.2825395167,
-0.2654924989,
-0.5280675888,
-0.3394239545,
-0.1783398837,
0.3142808676,
1.0357989073,
-0.0391701646,
0.2546480298,
-0.8830729723,
0.7194085121,
0.1508222818,
0.5541074872,
0.0773571283,
-0.1455915272,
-0.5994653702,
-0.1371051222,
-0.0377761871,
-0.8578006029,
0.5376797318,
0.2214828879,
0.4329466522,
0.2898414135,
0.1465808004,
0.3566034138,
-0.3934778869,
0.3719519973,
0.3065664172,
-0.6990456581,
0.5091853738,
-0.6049795747,
0.556450665,
0.7748795152,
0.222978428,
-0.5472780466,
-0.1716412753,
-0.3034361899,
-1.0891807079,
0.8270813823,
0.2121865302,
-0.3389926553,
0.1840788573,
0.1579448432,
0.3903949559,
0.4146585763,
-0.5042431355,
-0.5013086796,
0.2350584269,
-0.2660061717,
-0.1824121028,
-0.4547397196,
-0.3220743537,
0.1822908074,
0.6715262532,
0.0918095037,
0.0941648409,
0.1466658115,
-0.0462729782,
0.0215617623,
0.4112010002,
0.8416522741,
1.1491991282,
-0.4818819463,
0.089340575,
0.3009922802,
-0.5956584215,
-0.3173530996,
0.306850493,
-0.0385787524,
0.374173671,
0.3769885004,
0.4214664996,
0.2083930671,
-0.5230824351,
0.3337821066,
-0.3727777898,
-0.2895466983,
-0.6013333201,
-0.2839534879,
-0.0741433576,
0.0279216934,
0.5887805223,
-0.1586085111,
0.6615031958,
-0.5994796157,
0.3475347459,
-0.0999889746,
-0.2245624214,
0.0693219677,
0.2024638504,
0.0400238857,
0.0783212185,
0.6469424367,
0.0794724748,
0.0096831294,
0.7229344845,
0.2369081974,
0.5897192955,
0.0834094062,
0.2440835983,
0.3523997962,
0.4742968976,
-0.0346720554,
0.3521161377,
0.0583254546,
0.0748339742,
-0.5345852375,
-0.0202955715,
-0.5661359429,
0.0884025022,
-0.5649963617,
0.4424373209,
-0.3094387054,
-0.1037883759,
0.0930064395,
0.1827645749,
-0.4052854776,
0.2120697349,
-0.0824738741,
0.7041568756,
-0.7378926873,
0.0639542118,
0.1472335309,
-0.3682261109,
-0.2165009975,
-0.4012172222,
-0.1108316183,
-0.2652656138,
0.1904737204,
0.2130195796,
-0.0451255329,
-0.49140504,
-0.4812674522,
-0.8867177367,
0.9669525027,
0.1014709622,
-0.5404847264,
-0.1194571778,
0.2100199908,
0.1450389475,
-0.0267736427,
0.218453005,
0.5628420115,
0.7747042775,
-0.0429837443,
-0.6752048135,
-0.0599508956,
-0.2929346263,
-0.5408366323,
0.6186946034,
-0.7393453717,
0.5052416325,
-0.2419580519,
-0.2623146474,
-0.3381004632,
0.7578749657,
0.2135705203,
0.9400377274,
0.1326360852,
0.2881579101,
0.7583435178,
-0.0784431621,
0.8142427802,
-0.0495176502,
0.2412366122,
1.465927124,
-0.2260811925,
0.5735595822,
0.1636750102,
-0.0880040824,
-0.0368243344,
0.5150904059,
-0.2473188192,
0.3667446077,
0.2748625278,
-0.0127264112,
0.457839191,
0.06307403,
-0.5336290598,
0.2091993392,
0.4574014843,
-0.2858284414,
-0.5299343467,
-0.2003006339,
0.2263921946,
-0.2134941965,
-0.1083389521,
0.9985412359,
0.0558188222,
-0.3832286,
0.1546998918,
0.0864896625,
0.3485140502,
-0.8120616078,
-0.0662505999,
-0.4266525209,
-0.1146958768,
-0.3110347688,
-0.7547521591,
0.5396127105,
0.0303012226,
-0.2857210338,
-0.0273377802,
0.476546526,
-0.2172239274,
-0.5909401178,
-0.0208270345,
0.2998296618,
0.3275236785,
-0.0717383623,
-0.1219468787,
-0.2602564096,
-0.1574472636,
-0.1472149342,
0.1539476067,
0.7505156398,
0.0611332953,
0.441028595,
0.4056169093,
0.0006177962,
-0.2919823527,
0.0995483771,
1.0261774063,
-0.9052215815,
-0.6852635741,
-0.6241573691,
0.5798113942,
-0.2697542608,
-0.2835777402,
0.7584632635,
1.2683759928,
0.0538254753,
-0.0425129272,
0.8327155113,
0.1547259986,
0.5824816823,
-0.3889260292,
0.7589366436,
-0.4971165359,
-0.1202299818,
-0.3052191138,
-1.253436327,
-0.4298015535,
0.2464097738,
-0.2259421796,
-0.0680719614,
0.7456878424,
0.3640476763,
0.0476394892,
0.0936206132,
0.1488834172,
-0.0061457087,
-0.0058641639,
0.0992447659,
0.4144258499,
-0.4454514682,
0.6024039388,
-0.0370289646,
-0.4973222911,
-0.4721125066,
-0.8565199971,
-0.478769362,
-0.5368359089,
-0.3936170936,
-0.1592896432,
-0.1341272146,
0.3890622258,
0.523260951,
-0.8169590831,
-0.5224952698,
0.3400792778,
-0.0251122396,
-0.0743463263,
-0.2479923218,
0.6441275477,
-0.2990551591,
-0.4415130913,
0.2821159363,
0.6089653969,
0.1753326207,
-0.0873077959,
0.2960098386,
-0.1876406819,
0.2567507923,
0.5560501814,
0.0959742963,
0.2829411924,
0.1389923394,
-0.0257530287,
-0.0389772467,
0.2944868505,
0.7883865237,
-0.2092205584,
0.0366050452,
0.5748544931,
0.2491221875,
0.9147537351,
-0.0346378423,
0.415235728,
-0.7101823688,
0.0981984958,
-0.0156470742,
0.3173799217,
0.26687482,
-0.5954087377,
0.6809886098,
-0.2700276077,
-0.6601079702,
-0.4929926097,
-0.2474184334,
-1.042437911,
-0.2708112895,
0.814874351,
0.1261540204,
-0.2504203916,
-0.0633943304,
-0.2911485732,
0.5940953493,
-0.7715132833,
0.8635575175,
0.7713837624,
0.0592728406,
0.1524381489,
-0.6343660355,
0.429783076,
0.1017421708,
-1.4725666046,
0.5635999441,
0.84482342,
-0.0786367059,
0.1252358258,
0.4732874334,
-0.2191101015,
0.0769002661,
0.0108266184,
-0.0770211592,
0.0365135707,
-0.6254784465,
-0.1283639669,
0.3115228117,
-0.1749922931,
-0.1183727384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03780v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03780v3 | Reliable Natural Language Understanding with Large Language Models and Answer Set Programming | 2023-02-07T22:37:21 | 2023-08-30T08:56:37 | Abhiramon Rajasekharan, Yankai Zeng, Parth Padalkar, Gopal Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Humans understand language by extracting information (meaning) from
sentences, combining it with existing commonsense knowledge, and then
performing reasoning to draw conclusions. While large language models (LLMs)
such as GPT-3 and ChatGPT are able to leverage patterns in the text to solve a
variety of NLP tasks, they fall short in problems that require reasoning. They
also cannot reliably explain the answers generated for a given question. In
order to emulate humans better, we propose STAR, a framework that combines LLMs
with Answer Set Programming (ASP). We show how LLMs can be used to effectively
extract knowledge -- represented as predicates -- from language. Goal-directed
ASP is then employed to reliably reason over this knowledge. We apply the STAR
framework to three different NLU tasks requiring reasoning: qualitative
reasoning, mathematical reasoning, and goal-directed conversation. Our
experiments reveal that STAR is able to bridge the gap of reasoning in NLU
tasks, leading to significant performance improvements, especially for smaller
LLMs, i.e., LLMs with a smaller number of parameters. NLU applications
developed using the STAR framework are also explainable: along with the
predicates generated, a justification in the form of a proof tree can be
produced for a given output. | [
-0.4174687862,
-0.9133461714,
0.8136020303,
0.1215213761,
-0.0207469836,
0.191065073,
-0.5369836092,
-0.6773022413,
-0.0899242014,
0.7248196006,
-0.4680117071,
-0.2711691856,
-0.4967114925,
0.143273294,
-0.2249246985,
0.7930278182,
0.1383084804,
-0.056189388,
-0.3411386013,
0.105240494,
-0.4761940539,
-0.4131957293,
-0.8002228141,
-0.5854827762,
0.4221503735,
0.6949445009,
0.9694817662,
0.7737296224,
0.686537981,
0.2657203972,
0.1430005133,
0.0820522681,
-0.3414120376,
0.059703704,
-0.4407413304,
-0.5231484175,
-0.0971977934,
0.0168560743,
0.4891046882,
0.9855029583,
0.150496915,
0.151989758,
0.1737600118,
0.6202487946,
-0.3891422153,
0.4396497309,
-0.594943583,
-0.1487231553,
0.0556270666,
-0.1935848892,
-0.2856733799,
-0.3194814026,
0.1074323803,
-0.7165396214,
0.0608684495,
0.0858753622,
0.8349817991,
0.4532532692,
-0.1552824229,
-0.6145596504,
-0.920566082,
0.8871745467,
-0.7663788795,
0.536742866,
0.6919589043,
0.5895431638,
-0.2538909316,
-0.4989207089,
-0.8218402267,
-0.3889162838,
-0.1597540379,
-0.0153202638,
-0.0678580478,
0.1063240394,
0.3994270265,
0.3426145315,
-0.6664893627,
0.1169791743,
-0.1371252239,
-0.1001781747,
0.5267484784,
-0.2060852051,
0.3272096515,
-0.4041711688,
-0.1424122006,
0.078489922,
-0.8128349185,
0.1387437135,
0.000308719,
0.2605427504,
0.2508225739,
0.6102276444,
-0.2201874554,
1.0146788359,
-0.2794328928,
-0.0343110897,
-0.1922549903,
-0.394461751,
-0.3194115758,
-0.2352731526,
0.5446709394,
0.4057709277,
0.5461857319,
-0.3562683463,
-0.2398426384,
0.4385927022,
-0.02228266,
-0.4928226769,
-0.2666423917,
0.2973190546,
-0.4960061014,
-0.0434272029,
-0.1497670263,
-0.4932174981,
-0.3189647198,
-0.6892922521,
0.4137743413,
-0.5141037107,
-0.2921483517,
0.2736827135,
0.0981039479,
0.442230463,
0.4218415618,
-0.8983162642,
0.4961580038,
0.9191142917,
0.5012803674,
0.1305720508,
-0.1836100817,
-0.8842241168,
-0.0585582629,
-0.3329364657,
0.8511061072,
-0.6499792337,
-0.0926214829,
-0.1497069895,
-0.3876978159,
0.0394527279,
-0.5214019418,
0.5208519697,
-0.5478528738,
0.2676074505,
-0.4502293169,
-0.6793582439,
-0.4102494121,
0.3499358594,
-0.4543229938,
0.6449621916,
-0.0879866928,
-0.5002963543,
0.2057207823,
-0.7843633294,
-0.2898024023,
0.1229983568,
-0.2341409028,
0.0735286549,
0.0661612526,
0.4499513805,
0.6212156415,
-0.5602658987,
0.2769215107,
-0.2650612593,
-0.4019126892,
0.1864133477,
-0.1784147024,
0.6767859459,
0.4201173186,
-0.1411473453,
0.1230051965,
-0.4659378231,
0.2546089292,
0.1545151919,
-0.2596694529,
-0.2035142928,
0.3736753762,
-0.0226658452,
0.2654249668,
0.1426488459,
-0.4146466851,
0.0668267682,
-0.272665441,
0.5557044744,
0.4472988844,
-0.1593356729,
0.3740172982,
-0.3362840414,
0.5122696757,
-0.3236677349,
-0.0814556032,
-0.2329007387,
-0.4603734016,
-0.9283451438,
0.1795048267,
0.089260824,
0.6389665008,
-0.949409008,
0.5000438094,
-0.2128024101,
-0.3296742141,
-0.4634205699,
0.3555100858,
0.4889128804,
0.6605123878,
0.4275248945,
0.1750674248,
-0.5636351109,
-0.9173806906,
-0.5528404713,
-0.3287523389,
-0.273932606,
0.3310873806,
0.4268245995,
-0.0927779004,
1.0856822729,
-0.4447626472,
-0.0285786595,
-0.5414327979,
-0.1251630932,
0.5203842521,
0.3519690931,
0.2227287889,
-0.8090338111,
-0.4411150515,
0.0525160022,
-0.9227902889,
-0.1643400788,
-0.2960200012,
-0.0553756244,
-0.0228842609,
0.5487330556,
-0.5681179166,
0.1863270551,
0.5505154133,
-0.7086439133,
0.6454088092,
-0.0575490333,
0.12004558,
-1.0367696285,
0.2781678736,
0.0660051405,
-0.6114730835,
-0.5899423361,
0.1241543591,
-0.0892955363,
-0.2459742874,
-0.0500420183,
0.5232729912,
-0.334106952,
-0.3378409445,
-0.4369159937,
0.5081176758,
0.0761290193,
0.3535829782,
0.2962689698,
0.5332667828,
0.6482471228,
-0.6486843824,
0.4601320028,
0.379788518,
-0.5329605341,
0.5027720928,
-0.74385041,
0.0474343635,
-0.2224020511,
0.1866325438,
-0.6081951857,
-0.1739135087,
0.1618037075,
-0.6652321815,
-0.1177102625,
-0.071917437,
-0.4823285937,
-0.4243248105,
0.1740034968,
-0.1527409106,
0.5359128714,
-0.6660708189,
0.4476600587,
0.2582127452,
-0.289214313,
-0.725902617,
-0.3743411303,
0.2660560608,
-0.069014594,
-0.6382541656,
0.0767520368,
-0.0835764483,
-0.6025177836,
0.2006499469,
-0.1763756871,
-0.0173614826,
0.242665574,
0.0387629867,
0.1960194111,
-0.392678529,
0.3484324515,
-0.4523360729,
-0.2834863663,
0.1145862937,
-0.4297701716,
0.5348647237,
-0.57184726,
-0.3898846805,
-0.4111491144,
0.5343517065,
0.4154805839,
-0.3982701004,
0.6457946897,
0.3883132041,
-0.5992719531,
-0.3131375611,
-0.52482301,
-0.3631376624,
-0.4024903774,
0.3639209867,
-0.5076027513,
-0.9545183778,
0.521599412,
0.1329917163,
0.4200191796,
0.3309203386,
0.2608597577,
-0.3069034219,
0.8307523131,
0.6472378373,
0.1064773202,
0.253744483,
-0.1006971374,
0.2286965102,
-0.655322969,
-0.0745767578,
-0.5757269859,
-0.3025415242,
-0.1062799022,
-0.5972468257,
-0.1043195501,
0.7531788349,
-0.2116132975,
0.371018827,
-0.3187777102,
0.769325316,
0.5977399349,
-0.1193400472,
0.5354650617,
-0.221287325,
0.250480026,
0.0832109973,
-0.7255995274,
-0.8277639747,
0.8533290625,
0.359790802,
0.656976521,
0.1712156981,
0.519844532,
0.1021750122,
0.520221889,
-0.8874569535,
0.5760096312,
-0.1081972271,
-0.4804750383,
-0.3207418621,
-0.6826669574,
-0.7892959714,
0.2269301414,
-0.4287326038,
-0.8749825954,
-0.3080636859,
0.5110227466,
-0.2560946941,
0.2029772699,
-0.8746372461,
1.0375958681,
-0.2900477946,
-0.1229455173,
-0.2380832732,
-0.4971184731,
0.4233495593,
-0.1071359068,
0.273647815,
-0.1514291763,
0.1953108162,
0.7634818554,
-0.3189431727,
0.6479432583,
-0.1576097757,
0.0762205124,
0.4028950632,
0.0901543498,
0.4692952037,
0.3272877634,
-0.0832177326,
0.042709887,
-0.1426515877,
-0.3874222338,
-0.9979990721,
0.8117754459,
-0.602799356,
-0.8338655829,
-0.1294670254,
-0.5051913261,
-0.227335453,
0.2050810456,
-0.0183779337,
0.2327962369,
0.0784081668,
0.2895306647,
0.4301793277,
-0.1828797758,
0.4433145225,
0.5504799485,
-0.5727389455,
-0.062586695,
0.7290469408,
-0.2374824435,
0.3914925456,
0.5658343434,
0.4017759264,
-0.5455327034,
-0.6126717925,
-0.377346307,
0.1928749532,
-0.8681548238,
-0.153254196,
-0.5162805915,
-0.1219693944,
-0.2180007249,
-0.3062075377,
-0.3613519967,
-0.3600875437,
0.0329047628,
0.0327979438,
0.2778112292,
0.8068808317,
0.0053027943,
0.2143584043,
-0.8848818541,
0.4700378776,
0.3695102036,
0.4840683043,
-0.1868245751,
-0.3755499721,
-0.1304113567,
0.1296349615,
-0.0009843294,
-0.8909837604,
0.2107140422,
0.2252894491,
0.6618148685,
0.3631916344,
-0.1178078428,
0.5936464071,
-0.3865246177,
0.5793582201,
0.1662938744,
-1.0850189924,
0.7246266007,
-0.4035567045,
0.4563053548,
0.4451198876,
0.2257118672,
-0.9244078398,
-0.3461250365,
-0.4917751253,
-0.3706867993,
0.5256991386,
0.3500818014,
-0.3406175673,
-0.1272450835,
0.4509736598,
0.0983300284,
-0.0173682105,
-0.7209299803,
0.0576319583,
-0.1990574598,
-0.1787635535,
-0.5078049302,
0.0814367309,
0.0842036828,
0.0843857974,
0.5032804608,
-0.4279127419,
0.2224362344,
0.1257058084,
-0.2945530713,
-0.0618725643,
0.2344689667,
0.3139451444,
0.9331206679,
-0.0598993674,
0.4390275478,
-0.0633800775,
-0.2315049618,
-0.2221179903,
0.150965631,
-0.0048337579,
-0.1941787452,
0.6508877277,
0.6463832855,
0.1656877846,
-0.8202176094,
0.2276176661,
-0.0039990889,
-0.0566089675,
-0.2970302999,
0.213223055,
0.4713632166,
0.276224494,
0.2732894123,
0.2916255891,
-0.1549377292,
-0.5542157292,
0.3530308604,
0.504519105,
-0.386691153,
-0.2309174985,
0.6837130785,
0.3315178156,
-0.5697854757,
0.8750738502,
0.0009617755,
-0.5382900238,
0.6155692935,
0.7525759935,
0.5441519022,
-0.0226918291,
0.2793743908,
0.2907289267,
0.2634270787,
-0.16345191,
0.4104626775,
-0.125846535,
-1.1108967066,
-1.0993475914,
-0.7988308668,
-0.4700372219,
0.2596027255,
-0.4643613398,
-0.006374252,
-0.5253971815,
0.224463582,
0.1785850972,
0.0793699473,
-0.8651035428,
0.2363542765,
0.1872575134,
0.9463394284,
-0.886505723,
0.7724373937,
0.8124186993,
-0.4241174757,
-0.9949928522,
-0.1038845628,
-0.0287928898,
-0.7666507363,
0.7181082368,
0.4070567489,
-0.0754581988,
0.0953674987,
-0.3558027148,
-0.8542199135,
0.7484994531,
0.3867932558,
-0.5905276537,
0.1190261692,
0.0133825038,
0.3597685993,
-0.3520371914,
0.0887206644,
0.6169894338,
0.576538682,
0.2007309198,
-1.0171343088,
-0.0258114152,
-0.1747718602,
-0.2998292446,
0.1931629628,
-0.0412303209,
0.4699268937,
-0.554248035,
-0.1981446147,
-0.2166040987,
0.7714041471,
0.3624583483,
0.0130579723,
0.6392621398,
0.4436351061,
0.8722162843,
-0.1181128845,
1.1020052433,
-0.1059871688,
0.3017145693,
1.0930880308,
-0.0639182478,
1.0420877934,
0.5239361525,
-0.1371325403,
0.279584825,
0.5980471373,
0.2473436743,
0.0289009511,
0.1988947541,
-0.1644204557,
-0.6724910736,
0.0263070501,
-0.0253106356,
0.7121854424,
0.5317755342,
-0.2479521185,
-0.2845904827,
-0.0219617542,
-0.0064030611,
0.414712429,
-0.4970038533,
0.5518220067,
0.2073251009,
-1.089863658,
0.6257089972,
-0.1298235953,
0.3992883265,
-0.5331066847,
-0.2676624954,
-0.0847742185,
0.3325022161,
-0.1986820251,
-1.0634557009,
0.5690998435,
0.0542975105,
-0.219050616,
-0.3571189642,
0.7621959448,
-0.4512189627,
-0.4228747785,
0.0486468785,
0.702804625,
0.3557414114,
-0.2205847204,
-0.6460900903,
-0.0413703583,
0.2141478509,
-0.2258905917,
0.022060506,
0.107189782,
-0.0150971683,
1.0017546415,
0.8581786156,
0.1224671379,
-0.2839999497,
-0.019527575,
0.7371053696,
-0.7354609966,
-0.4988908768,
-0.8535576463,
0.3259324431,
-0.2359392196,
-0.1409389526,
0.7406995893,
0.4408255219,
0.654406786,
-0.1705956459,
0.8684836626,
-0.1557843238,
0.6001150608,
-0.701980114,
0.6879957318,
-0.3207186162,
0.398789376,
-0.0820095465,
-1.3819410801,
-0.6519831419,
0.9776024818,
-0.4011592269,
-0.0974656567,
0.7384489775,
0.4911705256,
-0.0200156681,
0.2136228085,
0.3811681271,
0.0593064725,
0.5787882805,
0.9098666906,
0.8327965736,
0.0366273038,
0.6291568875,
0.0645710528,
-0.4453572631,
0.0197087545,
-0.8433552384,
-0.9694554806,
-0.5021951795,
-0.2032936513,
-0.2834785879,
0.0262616519,
0.849857986,
0.66377002,
-0.726326704,
-0.1680625826,
-0.3797617257,
0.2850013375,
-0.3248940408,
-0.2077355683,
0.4490025938,
-0.5603866577,
-0.6371163726,
0.5925179124,
0.18218261,
-0.3026889563,
-0.3284771442,
-0.2262241989,
-0.0605009086,
-0.0959757268,
0.5886254907,
0.5662885308,
-0.8709768057,
-0.7704923749,
0.1761609316,
0.1343966573,
-0.1290792525,
0.7689310908,
-0.9901952744,
0.3967724442,
0.5108574033,
0.8446106911,
0.1779860556,
0.0349319689,
0.8584513068,
-0.4086230695,
-0.1906142086,
0.3960627317,
0.3911063075,
0.5042277575,
-0.1382300705,
0.4410105348,
0.0584974736,
-0.7189213634,
-0.423332572,
0.7100833058,
-0.8868216276,
-0.415895462,
1.2096916437,
-0.1806568354,
-0.0918731019,
-0.3747142553,
-0.0604877211,
-0.0132932868,
-0.1218460202,
0.6358450055,
0.7221589684,
-0.3813619912,
-0.4001087546,
-0.7243829966,
0.7133617401,
0.415371865,
-1.0677394867,
0.3417370915,
0.4925930798,
0.2532083094,
0.3309132755,
0.6562885046,
0.1301661879,
0.2203980237,
-0.0770743266,
-0.0227461029,
-0.1271415651,
-0.2797469199,
0.0029666414,
-0.0037831012,
0.2496218085,
-0.1051286161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03773v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03773v1 | What Matters In The Structured Pruning of Generative Language Models? | 2023-02-07T22:05:55 | 2023-02-07T22:05:55 | Michael Santacroce, Zixin Wen, Yelong Shen, Yuanzhi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Auto-regressive large language models such as GPT-3 require enormous
computational resources to use. Traditionally, structured pruning methods are
employed to reduce resource usage. However, their application to and efficacy
for generative language models is heavily under-explored. In this paper we
conduct an comprehensive evaluation of common structured pruning methods,
including magnitude, random, and movement pruning on the feed-forward layers in
GPT-type models. Unexpectedly, random pruning results in performance that is
comparable to the best established methods, across multiple natural language
generation tasks. To understand these results, we provide a framework for
measuring neuron-level redundancy of models pruned by different methods, and
discover that established structured pruning methods do not take into account
the distinctiveness of neurons, leaving behind excess redundancies. In view of
this, we introduce Globally Unique Movement (GUM) to improve the uniqueness of
neurons in pruned models. We then discuss the effects of our techniques on
different redundancy metrics to explain the improved performance. | [
-0.0463579744,
-1.0644863844,
0.3265056908,
0.5180612206,
-0.3337314129,
-0.0501864143,
-0.2906920612,
-0.2182877362,
-0.0329959691,
-0.0065814443,
-0.3660933673,
-0.4239858985,
-0.3082378507,
0.1201178581,
-0.6728351712,
1.1048666239,
0.0073195295,
-0.1420490295,
-0.0093339961,
-0.1256998628,
-0.5351933241,
-0.4392607808,
-0.6180598736,
-0.3624117374,
0.4275164306,
0.0318880118,
0.8841780424,
0.8759065866,
0.3693334162,
0.381504178,
-0.5120006204,
-0.0097480435,
-0.4286565483,
0.1659943461,
0.0719026104,
-0.3550963104,
-0.3998378813,
-0.0972354785,
0.7939742804,
0.7529777288,
-0.6757756472,
-0.1893804669,
0.117484346,
0.4052776992,
-0.3493429124,
0.1964498907,
-0.4774673879,
0.209553495,
-0.36533463,
-0.0071944399,
-0.1871123016,
-0.5831434727,
-0.1168691218,
-0.4267495275,
0.7104251981,
-0.2919191122,
0.8215904832,
0.1087832823,
-0.2381001264,
0.2211709023,
-1.0858470201,
0.6762253046,
-0.7967946529,
-0.1125677004,
0.1328911334,
0.0796532407,
-0.0939612389,
-0.6244527698,
-0.3473618627,
-0.372703582,
-0.1741678119,
-0.0333101824,
-0.111959666,
0.2976407111,
0.2067892551,
0.562815547,
-0.6013381481,
0.1150750965,
-0.4374665618,
-0.088189356,
0.5941818357,
-0.0309718549,
0.5258649588,
-0.1035863906,
-0.2427231669,
-0.3617754877,
-0.8646805286,
-0.3039115369,
0.6184273958,
0.0484112203,
0.1612969637,
0.4659953713,
-0.012257494,
1.1004624367,
-0.1353778094,
-0.1130679548,
0.1279339194,
-0.5650414228,
-0.3661132157,
-0.3103171587,
0.9161615968,
0.1277077198,
0.4964999259,
-0.3161230981,
-0.26867944,
-0.0244037025,
0.375246942,
-0.6276942492,
-0.6623006463,
0.1501634121,
-0.3288044035,
-0.2887156904,
-0.201754421,
-0.17616418,
0.0623980053,
-0.1404401511,
0.0688649416,
-0.7218165398,
-0.5900406241,
0.1612781137,
-0.197146818,
0.0473557487,
0.3602584004,
-1.1949086189,
0.2297073752,
0.8503752947,
0.8289818168,
-0.31242612,
-0.2974258363,
-0.1664330363,
0.0503063761,
-0.4587881863,
0.5457955599,
-0.3900395632,
-0.0908385739,
-0.0248813108,
0.0144846505,
-0.4616762996,
-0.6742514968,
0.4258271456,
-0.232210964,
-0.0109839374,
-0.1565994173,
-0.250217706,
-0.53386271,
0.1395922452,
-0.5877166986,
0.7546413541,
0.2067305893,
-0.5849586725,
0.4957143664,
-0.2561026812,
-0.8548021913,
0.3612255454,
-0.2275923043,
-0.5100824833,
0.6974893212,
-0.0432227924,
0.3704434633,
-0.0257769991,
0.7685142756,
-0.156697005,
-0.3767350912,
0.0389544554,
-0.5709757209,
0.6869193912,
0.0898962319,
-0.1925359517,
0.3991411626,
-0.9129812717,
0.1570864022,
0.2400281876,
-0.4106754959,
-0.2090121061,
0.2736063302,
-0.0019979558,
0.1093383431,
-0.2323101014,
-0.5318953395,
0.302310884,
-0.5534664989,
1.051533699,
0.6234603524,
0.1665531993,
0.35062024,
-0.333407402,
0.5202665329,
0.0074080182,
0.0374175869,
0.036053393,
-0.4216489792,
-0.5991090536,
-0.0733598694,
0.3016842902,
0.2934590578,
-0.2515563071,
0.2292564362,
-0.2489689291,
-0.4453748763,
-0.4023877978,
-0.0309874769,
0.3921519816,
0.2512809932,
0.2793310881,
-0.5916829705,
-0.1450878382,
-1.179900527,
-0.1291603893,
-0.2679903209,
-0.1169013157,
-0.0842438862,
0.2009720206,
0.1353129297,
0.8559167981,
-0.2174988091,
0.1004616767,
-0.3779896796,
0.3833392262,
-0.0770643651,
0.7381293178,
0.4307384193,
-0.7480615377,
-0.34610641,
0.1070518792,
-0.5543655753,
0.1118974164,
-0.4006206989,
0.1834400892,
0.1219658405,
0.2604673207,
-0.9717767239,
0.4047043025,
0.5213109851,
0.1471461803,
0.5299498439,
-0.3343755901,
-0.1760920733,
-0.5103824139,
-0.032468576,
-0.0004952441,
-0.0588482954,
-0.7241839767,
0.1178234667,
0.0953481123,
-0.0579132549,
-0.3496210277,
0.1333150715,
-0.6292551756,
-0.212707743,
-0.0568991229,
0.133483842,
-0.144245863,
0.7106304169,
0.0587939247,
0.7829326391,
0.3107670546,
-0.7230728269,
0.1210290492,
0.1209143624,
-0.3828753233,
0.0247747544,
-0.8061158657,
0.2160466611,
-0.1098373681,
0.0030473324,
-0.8187680244,
-0.0764027461,
0.0766631737,
-0.1780288965,
0.5497663617,
-0.3306258917,
-0.5539557338,
-0.2012552768,
0.0402423292,
0.342766732,
0.4480723143,
-0.1936576962,
0.2461962104,
0.2476047575,
-0.3020720184,
-0.1568285674,
-0.6906562448,
-0.0341617763,
-0.3289344609,
-0.821367085,
0.6305998564,
0.0058009066,
-0.1971440315,
0.0768293962,
-0.494997263,
-0.0708346888,
0.4343566,
0.0646104887,
-0.1896789968,
-0.3059358597,
0.2023805976,
-0.1778467745,
-0.0235087126,
0.0504631437,
-0.2735092938,
0.6505749226,
-0.2284304649,
-0.4727876782,
-0.352184087,
0.3721570075,
0.3722138405,
-0.3391012251,
0.7225766182,
0.6030105352,
-0.0150715448,
-0.2566940188,
-0.2675462663,
0.0062440168,
-0.4406120777,
0.6777133942,
-0.2048580199,
-0.8248856068,
0.2881116867,
0.1881934851,
0.2920310795,
0.4791642725,
0.4116556942,
0.1374062747,
1.0594037771,
0.761030376,
0.1849532425,
0.541267097,
-0.0569095276,
0.4731434286,
-0.7367241383,
-0.1334660202,
-0.4723321199,
-0.3410909176,
-0.6132816672,
-0.2672474384,
-0.1616512239,
0.3285288811,
-0.1431150883,
0.4494202733,
-0.8488083482,
0.3754023314,
0.4829152226,
-0.4283428192,
0.3614987731,
0.4340144694,
-0.0607735477,
0.0885346457,
-1.0504072905,
-0.408193022,
0.501028955,
0.2429452091,
0.5920182467,
0.1347700357,
0.4703083336,
-0.1818535626,
0.7347407937,
-0.7233796716,
0.7871001363,
0.0388179533,
-0.4427278042,
-0.4669466019,
-0.6541376114,
-1.0552685261,
0.5758800507,
0.1557946205,
-0.6382502317,
0.0605196469,
0.2860595584,
-0.4844981432,
0.4536274374,
-0.8767896295,
0.743875742,
-0.2656190693,
-0.3035646677,
-0.3062844276,
-0.2579474151,
0.360864073,
0.0906242207,
-0.1948631108,
-0.0284047071,
0.2172672451,
0.6496677995,
-0.5637475252,
0.7191874385,
-0.0620964542,
-0.0778900981,
0.432711035,
0.2822607458,
0.5555114746,
-0.1466020197,
0.2577314973,
0.1427563578,
-0.3041404486,
-0.1335773021,
-0.5378124714,
0.7173668146,
-0.6320926547,
-0.8582060933,
-0.2641628087,
-0.3548054099,
-0.1222998649,
0.0687524155,
0.1956043392,
0.3615516722,
-0.3830011785,
0.4192106724,
0.3987756073,
-0.2347929776,
0.6777148843,
0.3851907253,
0.1419758946,
-0.2447331548,
0.9151932001,
0.36814484,
0.3706183434,
0.2480149716,
0.0763489082,
0.1570525467,
-1.0144912004,
-0.1658620983,
0.2473282516,
-0.3550723791,
-0.0963093117,
-0.657050848,
-0.4332771599,
-0.3428678513,
0.0214762948,
-0.3169433773,
-0.6492400765,
-0.0190538615,
-0.479016304,
0.1735941023,
0.8145441413,
-0.0156337097,
0.491658181,
-0.7895053029,
0.1870752275,
0.2621444166,
0.3054657578,
0.1052960679,
-0.0791678727,
-0.0390680023,
-0.0486466736,
-0.3251647353,
-1.0028694868,
0.7546945214,
0.2371798605,
0.5262480378,
0.16912736,
-0.3613502979,
0.7437771559,
-0.4470155239,
0.4909849167,
0.2477953583,
-0.5249906778,
0.4161674976,
-0.4782444537,
0.5442262292,
0.311455518,
0.1013768315,
-0.5646848679,
-0.3720647395,
-0.9559283257,
-1.1862468719,
0.6454886198,
0.5429257154,
-0.0607005991,
-0.4171009064,
0.2357188463,
-0.2427909374,
0.3165245354,
-0.8934291005,
-0.1262837946,
-0.0838607103,
0.0574020632,
-0.0369759947,
-0.3129578233,
-0.337778151,
-0.0989151597,
0.516587317,
0.161178112,
0.1204666495,
0.1384438574,
-0.1812611371,
-0.0616135746,
0.3332584798,
0.5159023404,
0.551574707,
-0.1652178764,
-0.2536953688,
-0.1455221027,
-0.5249826908,
0.195431456,
0.0732282251,
-0.6725192666,
0.1649068445,
0.3519753218,
0.9669152498,
0.2754297853,
-0.1804877967,
0.2424419522,
-0.1194536388,
-0.3079738021,
-0.1581639946,
0.2919769287,
0.0733593553,
-0.2792506516,
0.1524889022,
0.5205198526,
-0.2837813497,
-0.3450980186,
-0.00174432,
0.3319920897,
-0.2890289128,
-0.5362510681,
0.3062990308,
0.2289952189,
-0.6401122808,
1.0799568892,
-0.0957936198,
-0.2452248931,
0.8237698078,
0.6633896828,
1.1414519548,
-0.2439949065,
0.3907497227,
0.5713247657,
0.5755636096,
-0.3814729154,
-0.2637618184,
-0.3521858454,
-0.6286492944,
-0.8966915011,
-0.5293511152,
0.0564005114,
0.3449431956,
-0.6023022532,
-0.2712769806,
-0.5595541,
-0.176600188,
-0.2274527997,
-0.1914496273,
-0.4109801948,
0.0234475322,
-0.2077071667,
0.797848165,
-0.8991243243,
0.8127666712,
0.6448793411,
-0.3177178204,
-0.9700347185,
0.0236753412,
-0.0440306999,
-0.4817936122,
0.5698910952,
0.1945685744,
0.0569342785,
-0.0395872965,
-0.5187196732,
-0.970718801,
0.7234579921,
0.3083928525,
-0.7076154947,
-0.2269582897,
-0.2552776039,
0.6165834069,
-0.0114517417,
0.1017824709,
0.5511995554,
0.3096799552,
0.1321895868,
-0.7453712225,
-0.106990017,
-0.3660367727,
0.2392610908,
0.4558305442,
-0.6589378715,
0.86405164,
-0.1902057678,
-0.8479264975,
0.0086302571,
0.6067356467,
0.3247684538,
-0.343652904,
0.3926595747,
0.6435019374,
0.7216483951,
-0.2627322078,
1.1450111866,
-0.2654097378,
0.3104962409,
1.1606551409,
-0.1370416582,
0.5931106806,
0.2163572758,
-0.2628278434,
0.2548610568,
0.4766504169,
-0.1037503481,
0.3617658913,
0.5868721008,
-0.1433988363,
-0.2370882034,
0.2743669152,
-0.4152919948,
0.1794457287,
0.278690815,
-0.0177846011,
-0.364055872,
-0.2459218502,
0.242444694,
-0.0525644273,
0.0609974265,
0.7061239481,
0.1357296258,
-1.0958907604,
0.6008759141,
0.3077923357,
0.3691828847,
-0.7066581845,
-0.0231272802,
-0.5849297643,
0.2283049822,
-0.1412750185,
-0.6391135454,
0.5784838796,
-0.1885407865,
-0.027241841,
-0.7468655109,
0.6137077808,
-0.3875456154,
-0.1936817616,
0.1147169098,
0.3479914665,
-0.0132420743,
-0.0165421814,
-0.5481002927,
-0.0128302602,
0.2704265118,
-0.4605240226,
0.585113287,
0.5894426703,
-0.2251174301,
0.758051157,
0.6406082511,
0.330075264,
-0.0494603477,
0.2550875545,
0.709492743,
-0.7021592259,
-0.199756518,
-0.8330802917,
0.4269171655,
-0.1033633128,
-0.4818006158,
0.9505087733,
0.450717032,
0.7367863059,
0.0100921951,
0.436283052,
-0.2034071833,
0.1019227058,
-0.3905820549,
0.5021580458,
-0.1492907852,
0.3639876246,
-0.0690697208,
-1.0956350565,
-0.3415546715,
0.9206419587,
-0.2393544167,
0.1749150753,
0.6859400868,
0.6881660223,
0.0640413463,
-0.027350178,
0.3406340778,
0.5255334377,
0.3373645544,
0.390291512,
0.6378646493,
-0.1317649931,
0.5244444013,
-0.1455088854,
-0.0579378344,
0.1156519949,
-0.8763831854,
-0.310795784,
-0.4941216707,
-0.7522916198,
-0.1244440675,
0.0772133097,
0.2709502876,
0.9447906017,
-0.5670729876,
-0.1693684161,
-0.7295447588,
-0.0314075612,
-0.6051583886,
-0.2371757925,
0.3051989079,
-0.3925767839,
-0.4716630578,
0.615834713,
0.4385709763,
0.1552096605,
-0.2151542157,
0.4232426882,
-0.1796460599,
-0.3698840737,
0.4453563094,
0.6222570539,
-0.5541402102,
-0.0318185128,
-0.2827689946,
-0.043419648,
0.1356326342,
0.92624861,
-0.8138689399,
0.1209843382,
0.6083306074,
0.278939873,
0.6267449856,
0.3534422815,
1.0482217073,
-1.0081845522,
0.2077695429,
0.4318369031,
0.2719404399,
0.5475184917,
0.0540488847,
0.5306833386,
0.2892281115,
-0.5842388868,
-0.6165204048,
0.3731062114,
-0.6154689789,
-0.2966770232,
1.3028583527,
-0.1513103992,
-0.3400330842,
-0.0496323109,
0.1021291837,
0.0193582121,
-0.060785275,
0.5142473578,
0.8063164353,
-0.0064722295,
-0.1400420964,
-0.6270464063,
0.6898292303,
0.6381142735,
-0.353556335,
0.2242489308,
0.6365815997,
0.3241294026,
0.2373986393,
0.7311510444,
-0.2575545013,
-0.2003251165,
-0.0867808387,
0.0326579511,
-0.108877629,
-0.4243763983,
-0.5507063866,
0.550293386,
-0.0056170248,
0.0486213341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03765v1 | Transformer-based Models for Long-Form Document Matching: Challenges and Empirical Analysis | 2023-02-07T21:51:05 | 2023-02-07T21:51:05 | Akshita Jha, Adithya Samavedhi, Vineeth Rakesh, Jaideep Chandrashekar, Chandan K. Reddy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in the area of long document matching have primarily focused
on using transformer-based models for long document encoding and matching.
There are two primary challenges associated with these models. Firstly, the
performance gain provided by transformer-based models comes at a steep cost -
both in terms of the required training time and the resource (memory and
energy) consumption. The second major limitation is their inability to handle
more than a pre-defined input token length at a time. In this work, we
empirically demonstrate the effectiveness of simple neural models (such as
feed-forward networks, and CNNs) and simple embeddings (like GloVe, and
Paragraph Vector) over transformer-based models on the task of document
matching. We show that simple models outperform the more complex BERT-based
models while taking significantly less training time, energy, and memory. The
simple models are also more robust to variations in document length and text
perturbations. | [
-0.0739181563,
-0.3980313838,
0.8475511074,
0.179700166,
-0.0932084769,
-0.2396054119,
-0.1916177869,
-0.6807656288,
-0.1391799599,
0.500960052,
-0.4705085754,
0.0012103387,
-0.6641162038,
0.3991412818,
-0.7199336886,
0.7870674729,
-0.2212762684,
-0.046748016,
-0.5513533354,
-0.1500950754,
-0.4418231249,
-0.4077421129,
-0.6114227772,
-0.6036599874,
0.5969922543,
0.0493672155,
0.7638821602,
0.7605563402,
0.8985417485,
0.2863828242,
-0.2641640007,
-0.0530946739,
-0.2836131454,
0.1754965186,
-0.0569580682,
-0.6192253828,
-0.1112341881,
0.0662252158,
0.4649304152,
0.6679216623,
0.0915188715,
-0.043972671,
0.0785621628,
0.6495864391,
-0.4574149251,
0.035243541,
-0.5045446157,
0.1463477015,
-0.2845318317,
0.1511533707,
-0.5927326083,
-0.0954897031,
0.2268815339,
-0.5526555181,
0.7349979281,
0.0482275076,
1.0074055195,
0.1904922277,
-0.4001173973,
-0.7165818214,
-0.9830315113,
0.3563295901,
-0.7107388973,
0.511713624,
0.3568778038,
0.2043295056,
-0.0724194571,
-0.8372040987,
-0.8075116277,
-0.184956789,
-0.5192915797,
0.0935829505,
-0.3563016057,
0.1273248792,
0.5601400733,
0.1518400908,
-0.5745070577,
0.5065051913,
-0.3804056048,
-0.0281930398,
0.239694044,
0.1976445466,
0.103365086,
-0.3437737823,
-0.436144352,
-0.2777854502,
-0.2972983718,
0.135218814,
0.4200079143,
0.3316555321,
-0.0218678042,
0.6295953393,
-0.0009014112,
0.6922424436,
0.1800575256,
0.0849597156,
-0.1378757209,
-0.2817814946,
-0.2688553631,
-0.1082423776,
0.5494590998,
0.2717252672,
-0.0233360287,
-0.4404777586,
-0.3741053343,
0.123829402,
0.1932326108,
-0.8033899069,
-0.028592322,
-0.0595191382,
-0.708349824,
-0.3258855939,
0.0026592938,
-0.7418541312,
-0.4586122036,
-0.448220551,
0.69821769,
-0.3816015422,
0.276466608,
0.1118378267,
-0.464633435,
0.8554269075,
0.5003048778,
-0.9968639016,
0.5471186638,
0.8952155113,
1.0546998978,
-0.2558189034,
-0.1728088409,
-0.3524585366,
-0.1278659254,
-0.0937367231,
0.9429918528,
-0.5060280561,
-0.5445975661,
0.0007540595,
0.1400108039,
-0.3656518757,
-0.3852424622,
0.7810028791,
-0.5780878067,
0.4496173561,
-0.260835737,
-0.7989707589,
0.2397943735,
0.1869137287,
-1.1086710691,
1.1271181107,
0.27717489,
-0.6939891577,
0.1906351,
-0.6507287025,
-0.6185885668,
-0.1639048755,
-0.0579705499,
-0.7338894606,
0.3083198965,
0.1100024134,
0.4239805043,
-0.6753438711,
-0.009439786,
-0.1423289031,
-0.5820426941,
0.0479671732,
-0.5712406635,
0.5924829841,
0.0847135857,
-0.3047825098,
-0.0879808366,
-0.8281906247,
-0.5258141756,
0.2633322179,
-0.4843774438,
-0.2369624078,
0.0866481736,
0.2935918272,
0.2739943862,
0.1572274864,
-0.8170905709,
0.2653469443,
-0.2219981104,
0.6638947129,
0.6543009877,
-0.5758484602,
0.6807615161,
-0.6472895145,
0.3155249953,
0.0633584782,
0.1124340817,
-0.363499701,
-0.2283287346,
-0.7140915394,
-0.1765455902,
0.6948989034,
0.4192952514,
-0.4288211465,
0.3435857892,
-0.6435027719,
-0.6895903945,
-0.6706490517,
-0.1243530214,
-0.0813071206,
0.6732347608,
0.3627603054,
-0.1762304455,
-0.2906299829,
-0.9876778126,
-0.0909724832,
0.2520892918,
-0.3033135235,
0.409724474,
0.6372191906,
-0.1436267048,
1.0996587276,
-0.3755444288,
-0.4356011152,
-0.0663005933,
0.05777549,
0.408049643,
0.4775435925,
0.5682505369,
-0.9500463009,
-0.5470634103,
-0.0967737585,
-0.6561893225,
0.135502398,
-0.4167765379,
0.2237315923,
0.2504715323,
0.608781755,
-1.0117279291,
0.6313326955,
0.5475378633,
-0.2441594154,
0.3532674909,
-0.5520793796,
-0.0753708705,
-1.0428669453,
0.2438578755,
0.1542369723,
-0.2738036811,
-0.7151673436,
-0.0072052395,
0.4536812305,
-0.7846269608,
-0.4622067213,
0.5504452586,
-0.513638258,
-0.0387428664,
-0.3908137977,
0.003994422,
0.3321961164,
0.5201184154,
0.0142199984,
0.6316069365,
0.2112933993,
-0.2948327363,
0.2906329632,
0.2691069245,
-0.209345445,
0.6476224661,
-0.9905497432,
0.3456290662,
-0.5245453119,
0.5686282516,
-0.8889545798,
-0.0729263052,
-0.0475572385,
-0.0955595002,
0.5541720986,
-0.1402148753,
-0.5285083055,
-0.5959718823,
-0.3458940387,
0.4911210835,
0.4577626586,
-0.7428196073,
1.3627229929,
-0.467861712,
0.0398154631,
-0.4400569201,
-0.4593985081,
0.0686043426,
-0.0229449719,
-0.8126888871,
0.8122470975,
-0.0085151028,
0.3576747179,
0.1579895318,
-0.2535150349,
0.045715183,
0.1453851461,
0.350625813,
0.2103120983,
-0.2648938,
0.0713818222,
-0.2344453633,
-0.0599165857,
-0.2102043182,
-0.1314816177,
0.3852571547,
0.1730072796,
-0.5818276405,
-0.4159848094,
0.7695515752,
0.8247755766,
-0.2270098329,
0.8851643801,
0.4761642814,
-0.5609394908,
-0.0569428243,
-0.8404237032,
-0.0360117406,
-0.4694882929,
0.3465026021,
-0.5019834042,
-0.7246814966,
0.7023593187,
-0.1193003282,
-0.0862578824,
0.586940527,
0.2331830859,
-0.466833353,
0.6304519773,
0.7666662931,
-0.1972985864,
0.4426324666,
0.062505126,
0.0950398892,
-0.7964015603,
-0.3586145043,
-0.880317688,
-0.4718046784,
-0.5444152951,
-0.4006479383,
-0.0117200166,
-0.2010602802,
-0.0454178378,
0.6826455593,
-0.5689737201,
0.4243349135,
0.7845060229,
0.1267941296,
0.0641462505,
-0.3526531756,
0.1035959125,
0.1180361658,
-0.7122519016,
-0.3362063169,
0.9232788086,
0.524091363,
0.9813614488,
0.0219355151,
0.4205669761,
0.2268700451,
0.0721338391,
-0.86126405,
0.2852958739,
-0.3885153234,
-0.3959826231,
-0.3788588047,
-0.2640278041,
-1.2231473923,
0.1416329294,
-0.380779475,
-0.2875746489,
0.3743548095,
-0.0844129547,
-0.2450755835,
0.3673579693,
-0.5559009314,
0.7491399646,
-0.2499113977,
-0.0620529689,
0.2384643257,
-0.6307855844,
-0.2575375736,
-0.3194898963,
0.0337535068,
0.1752889454,
0.2194602937,
0.9373707175,
-0.3203110695,
0.6516243815,
0.0742963552,
0.0887699425,
-0.0386310779,
-0.2023676336,
0.8397192955,
-0.4352647364,
-0.2946094275,
0.0672198758,
0.042884171,
-0.4702403843,
-0.7630650401,
0.3638579547,
-0.7720946074,
-0.6735878587,
-0.4997244179,
-0.3661996722,
0.2008207142,
0.4856414199,
0.508541286,
0.374694109,
-0.2293876857,
0.5386118889,
0.7092161179,
0.0617752485,
0.7234374881,
0.4488454461,
0.2357334793,
-0.0707427412,
0.4367880225,
0.1202284768,
0.0043845582,
0.557411015,
0.2403514981,
-0.2986971438,
-0.3926099837,
-0.1963239759,
0.2791563869,
-0.634373486,
-0.3620341718,
-0.5879078507,
-0.3039498925,
-0.3096944988,
-0.1727870256,
-0.2971118093,
-0.0955860913,
-0.5903444886,
0.19026573,
0.0417773873,
0.8584133983,
0.2346165478,
0.4502943754,
-0.741373539,
0.380761236,
0.5351881981,
0.7727230787,
0.0775204226,
-0.5792642832,
-0.2802717686,
-0.1575071365,
-0.3328992128,
-0.8166096807,
-0.1859056503,
0.0935245082,
0.3919228017,
-0.0771513581,
0.0441673659,
0.3082317412,
-0.8135584593,
0.6255323291,
0.089223735,
-0.9386767745,
0.3546023071,
-0.1266112924,
0.3065146804,
0.4253416955,
0.4173012376,
-0.6157180667,
0.216994226,
-0.4225805104,
-0.637353003,
0.7336983681,
0.4777865112,
0.2732168138,
0.057805296,
0.5351247787,
-0.0200081114,
-0.2210533917,
-0.5951229334,
0.1264138073,
-0.2214703113,
-0.427378267,
0.0723259225,
-0.1916311383,
0.1855665296,
0.0103633087,
0.3687274754,
-0.1071121842,
0.6911903024,
0.2928147912,
-0.2861258984,
0.0527351126,
0.1358419657,
0.9902589321,
0.168577835,
-0.3201881051,
-0.1332821548,
0.2569087148,
-0.2799428999,
0.1643224955,
0.4351095557,
-0.1149507761,
0.3329435289,
0.5064973831,
1.0581239462,
0.2735560834,
-0.2910563052,
0.7481253743,
-0.2988626361,
-0.3998900354,
-0.2603189647,
-0.2456256151,
0.3147121072,
0.2644792497,
0.4213315845,
0.2740648389,
-0.1990492344,
-0.3887677491,
0.115697965,
0.463432163,
-0.3888478279,
-0.1716840863,
0.7828791142,
0.2067352533,
-0.8537310362,
0.8758834004,
0.4362786114,
-0.5076681376,
0.7492262125,
0.7164212465,
0.595476985,
0.1411295682,
-0.2300076336,
-0.1542531103,
0.1284764111,
-0.4580482841,
-0.3250465393,
-0.0986282974,
-0.5125018954,
-0.1907088012,
-0.559491694,
-0.5146259069,
0.0991274714,
-0.7835732698,
0.4278532863,
-0.1870896816,
-0.3796126544,
0.3293582201,
-0.035941489,
-1.3008824587,
0.129518196,
0.1994752288,
1.3293678761,
-0.8139320016,
0.7825595737,
0.3092974126,
-0.3554368019,
-0.6726067662,
-0.2323908657,
-0.4579019248,
-0.5372402668,
0.6689231992,
0.3116330504,
0.0852108076,
-0.1872202158,
-0.0451240689,
-0.8049622774,
1.2607975006,
0.3675543368,
-0.7842889428,
-0.9314533472,
0.3506296575,
0.53839463,
-0.1005542129,
0.2230610698,
0.4267345071,
0.350147754,
-0.1050002277,
-0.9437465072,
0.0049537802,
-0.1565545499,
0.1595466584,
0.2617564499,
-0.5869153738,
0.8037236333,
0.3439586163,
-0.1909981817,
0.2343708128,
0.7204172611,
-0.2844910622,
0.2439820021,
0.4997348487,
0.6264144182,
0.6007309556,
-0.0522948615,
1.0644795895,
-0.2744065225,
0.6091715693,
1.045166254,
-0.4817231297,
0.7857581377,
0.3285198808,
-0.1461051553,
0.3535819948,
0.2455352098,
-0.5051346421,
0.3080744147,
0.2401551008,
0.0507892668,
-0.1028198749,
0.0445034727,
-0.2410624027,
0.6169017553,
-0.0306072664,
-0.5682673454,
-0.3696068227,
0.1563504934,
-0.248080343,
0.1660677344,
-0.1065649688,
0.8108349442,
-0.0006141972,
-0.5927220583,
0.0122065702,
0.2087617666,
1.0178191662,
-0.5611914992,
0.1722875684,
-0.3069177568,
0.0992836505,
0.1114340723,
-0.6554097533,
0.2348228991,
-0.0950238854,
-0.5748692751,
-0.2425519228,
1.0162582397,
-0.3243359327,
-0.6544664502,
0.3320195675,
0.3117666543,
-0.3715863526,
-0.0394119769,
-0.4670512378,
0.1130772159,
-0.3857562244,
-0.2162987888,
0.455712527,
0.2766598463,
0.0578700006,
0.4568887353,
0.5472245812,
-0.162653178,
-0.0804223269,
-0.0057057883,
0.7034370303,
-0.6733515263,
-0.4675016701,
-0.8947669268,
0.2099940032,
-0.0148795191,
-0.0347894058,
0.3174069524,
0.6340334415,
0.5953612328,
-0.2081690878,
0.6073622108,
0.235907346,
0.2296274304,
-0.4371037781,
0.8488519192,
-0.3789482713,
-0.1091888323,
-0.1180759817,
-1.0430384874,
-0.2031120509,
0.4729633033,
-0.0345701762,
-0.0256143305,
0.5008397102,
0.5236420631,
-0.3708765209,
-0.0025785137,
0.3240002096,
-0.3427060544,
0.5914757252,
0.6534296274,
0.4832862318,
-0.834232688,
0.6132626534,
-0.232993722,
0.0734076202,
-0.4084404409,
-1.0882735252,
-0.8961722851,
-0.6938920021,
-0.0704588965,
-0.3676213026,
-0.0116438773,
0.8281115294,
0.6282085776,
-0.4415945113,
0.0662607402,
0.1664133221,
-0.1128702015,
-0.069858104,
-0.1391772479,
0.7622714639,
0.0234747976,
-0.6103917956,
0.1551949531,
0.0765368417,
0.4934528172,
0.1851653755,
0.2217628211,
-0.115808934,
0.4681920409,
0.7141231298,
0.3425465226,
-0.5766754746,
-0.6619150639,
0.4157480299,
-0.5326654315,
0.1559915245,
0.9343222976,
-0.7033656836,
0.3169894814,
0.4387927651,
1.0426855087,
0.8415278196,
0.0037012252,
0.5563285947,
-0.6794515848,
-0.0087701818,
0.1972283721,
0.5303806663,
0.4638635516,
-0.4179981947,
0.396656543,
0.164207384,
-0.5602197647,
-0.7352232933,
0.0553709529,
-1.1504317522,
-0.1884759367,
0.7042541504,
-0.1398995817,
-0.2022114545,
0.1893996149,
-0.1466277987,
0.5326542258,
0.0230754428,
0.7032546997,
0.8320631385,
-0.0434550531,
-0.0771126673,
-0.1345469505,
0.3522264063,
0.3978397846,
-0.4738149047,
-0.0473736636,
0.0257922523,
0.3616950512,
0.4236156642,
0.360986948,
0.2502563,
0.3853227794,
0.1275686473,
-0.2956419885,
-0.4013766944,
-0.1628887951,
-0.4910782874,
0.324564904,
-0.1851636767,
-0.0095584327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03754v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03754v1 | Augmenting Zero-Shot Dense Retrievers with Plug-in Mixture-of-Memories | 2023-02-07T20:59:31 | 2023-02-07T20:59:31 | Suyu Ge, Chenyan Xiong, Corby Rosset, Arnold Overwijk, Jiawei Han, Paul Bennett | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper we improve the zero-shot generalization ability of language
models via Mixture-Of-Memory Augmentation (MoMA), a mechanism that retrieves
augmentation documents from multiple information corpora ("external memories"),
with the option to "plug in" new memory at inference time. We develop a joint
learning mechanism that trains the augmentation component with latent labels
derived from the end retrieval task, paired with hard negatives from the memory
mixture. We instantiate the model in a zero-shot dense retrieval setting by
augmenting a strong T5-based retriever with MoMA. Our model, MoMA, obtains
strong zero-shot retrieval accuracy on the eighteen tasks included in the
standard BEIR benchmark. It outperforms systems that seek generalization from
increased model parameters and computation steps. Our analysis further
illustrates the necessity of augmenting with mixture-of-memory for robust
generalization, the benefits of augmentation learning, and how MoMA utilizes
the plug-in memory at inference time without changing its parameters. We plan
to open source our code. | [
-0.2531655133,
-0.8070020676,
0.5996891856,
-0.0885009766,
-0.2225529253,
0.102181986,
-0.291418761,
-0.417257756,
0.1543866992,
0.2474583089,
-0.0090712104,
-0.2930143774,
-0.4470533133,
-0.2556906641,
-0.2433677018,
0.8122150302,
0.1190225556,
-0.0697449148,
-0.0527134426,
-0.3070833683,
-0.9228150249,
-0.4807540476,
-0.205592677,
-0.4611877799,
0.6817785501,
0.5327192545,
0.3764391541,
0.4834256768,
0.2631782293,
0.2163655758,
0.0335889608,
0.061021354,
-0.6902899146,
0.1575038731,
-0.2090119421,
-0.7624134421,
-0.246126771,
-0.369402796,
0.5918232799,
0.7650831938,
-0.1976891309,
-0.1000312641,
-0.2887447178,
0.3045701683,
-1.1370853186,
0.0135312155,
-0.8820793629,
0.0273011699,
-0.1036911309,
-0.3930122256,
-0.4052787125,
0.1756783277,
0.1008810028,
-0.3446602225,
0.3981981874,
-0.106492281,
0.7427689433,
-0.082739383,
-0.2689905465,
0.0514706671,
-1.0688860416,
1.092099309,
-0.4718933403,
0.4278635681,
0.208507359,
0.3311744332,
-0.0109702833,
-0.2489994615,
-0.4694259167,
-0.1275940239,
0.1917476952,
0.14746885,
-0.0126114199,
0.003010609,
0.3497225642,
0.7920914888,
-0.5185986757,
-0.0576887317,
-0.4573639929,
0.074168466,
0.2585035264,
0.0109755984,
0.3401675224,
0.2766446769,
-0.1712590456,
-0.0816279948,
-0.6534669995,
-0.3696795106,
0.1921945661,
0.2945139706,
0.0406974852,
0.7666935325,
-0.3613939285,
0.9223415852,
0.262412101,
-0.1350663155,
0.4354581833,
-0.297847122,
-0.2164918184,
0.0780670568,
0.3946301043,
0.0080456324,
-0.1726134717,
-0.6829972267,
-0.4530474842,
0.2158237994,
0.2762646377,
-0.827154994,
-0.2391923666,
0.20476228,
-0.2193589807,
-0.1750439107,
0.059200123,
-0.5514377356,
0.0911531895,
-0.2413208634,
0.9029589891,
-0.7651190162,
-0.1403575689,
0.2312312275,
-0.30302158,
0.2673186362,
0.1374939531,
-0.9861185551,
0.3155920804,
0.4161862731,
0.7157561779,
-0.1103427261,
-0.1482669115,
-0.7919958234,
0.4657362998,
-0.2405903935,
0.9341610074,
-0.7947739959,
-0.3875847459,
-0.0913797468,
-0.4024444222,
-0.0487587489,
-0.9190624952,
0.2985452414,
-0.7283535004,
0.3935467899,
-0.0839933306,
-0.6571167111,
-0.3486008644,
0.2501662076,
-0.4983816147,
1.120574832,
0.2845625877,
-0.5954775214,
0.3081878722,
-0.4340281188,
-0.3754726946,
-0.0546201803,
-0.2077362388,
-0.1253950149,
0.4157194793,
0.1719872206,
0.2466598749,
0.0217046551,
0.3152132928,
-0.580922246,
-0.7043551207,
0.1165972427,
-0.3439984024,
0.6854701042,
0.1325000376,
0.01065116,
-0.0178858619,
-0.8811341524,
-0.3455137312,
0.2151798159,
-0.4224309027,
-0.5569130778,
-0.2773706317,
-0.3090492785,
0.2582136691,
0.4922614694,
-0.68115592,
0.1241115257,
-0.3993227482,
-0.1020320654,
0.3853166401,
0.1131355539,
0.6914702058,
-0.3831550777,
0.0597311594,
0.6055136323,
-0.1077165231,
-0.7971974611,
-0.3380552232,
-0.8579896092,
-0.2470383942,
0.3190466464,
0.607413888,
-0.7844631076,
0.632755816,
-0.1298177987,
-0.3397880495,
-0.3282698989,
0.2088633031,
0.2335454971,
0.7973773479,
0.6029042602,
-0.6704075336,
-0.5079365373,
-0.7129617929,
0.1268069446,
-0.0983556211,
-0.2542196214,
0.4178222716,
0.2637303174,
-0.1469938308,
0.8297365904,
-0.6732744575,
-0.0747759119,
-0.2566592395,
0.3127514422,
0.1401331276,
0.548509419,
0.5034384727,
-0.4856156707,
-0.1813307405,
-0.064874053,
-0.7598093748,
-0.0257418118,
-0.0742450356,
-0.0706186518,
-0.060406372,
-0.0116815567,
-0.6237098575,
0.1870963871,
0.1029696763,
-0.0558647513,
0.569000721,
-0.3451050222,
0.0401139036,
-1.0164587498,
0.1204187199,
0.0561953969,
-0.1478444636,
-0.7096053362,
0.2710166574,
0.1313067824,
-0.1453961134,
-0.4158192277,
0.549597621,
-0.6072051525,
-0.2306398451,
-0.5056211352,
0.0072710351,
0.1172202155,
0.4904823005,
0.0368075743,
0.8631145358,
0.7234708071,
-0.6778360605,
0.1304732412,
0.0045684073,
0.0839208663,
0.5455327034,
-0.384575963,
0.2073013633,
-0.4366045296,
0.1424452066,
-0.7925858498,
-0.110897474,
0.1531694829,
-0.3197335303,
0.6741373539,
-0.0495017804,
-0.5339508653,
-0.0251576081,
-0.2568874061,
0.4187693298,
0.5180328488,
-0.5288822055,
0.6826233864,
0.3327988982,
0.0062972661,
-0.5246545076,
-0.6882972717,
0.0434066765,
-0.1435042471,
-0.4779201746,
0.6238167286,
-0.2101800889,
-0.0553982779,
0.046873562,
-0.035727188,
-0.3304798305,
-0.1210358813,
-0.1935079098,
0.4789554477,
-0.451821208,
0.078727439,
0.0198881254,
-0.0862339363,
-0.3665427864,
-0.3069388866,
0.6141270995,
-0.00122829,
-0.3783043623,
0.0864069015,
0.4109781682,
0.0788782537,
-0.110647887,
0.932105422,
0.7699556351,
-0.3616019785,
0.0842652097,
-0.9459845424,
-0.5342897177,
-0.416071862,
0.1204427034,
-0.4808579981,
-1.0262389183,
0.5588923097,
0.1158844829,
-0.0445826612,
0.2911121249,
0.5530381799,
0.1038896665,
0.8134424686,
0.6671050191,
-0.2461806685,
0.717227459,
-0.2698383629,
0.2440065145,
-0.9075385928,
-0.0772076026,
-0.2980178893,
-0.2963968217,
-0.1828149259,
-0.5856945515,
0.1537147909,
0.1748458594,
-0.0457840338,
0.3409842849,
-0.2345766425,
0.6178185344,
0.6156848073,
0.2585923374,
0.4215219021,
0.2474143952,
-0.4065693915,
-0.0070006149,
-0.7642795444,
-0.1134222671,
1.070857048,
0.1233552769,
0.7530403137,
-0.02095736,
0.8238636851,
-0.0596028231,
0.1352517605,
-0.7373209,
0.4738830328,
-0.0884495601,
-0.5412065983,
0.1654053926,
-0.4483324289,
-0.7131772637,
0.4299409688,
-0.0966734812,
-0.9092774391,
0.3360629678,
0.0917849839,
-0.4791973829,
0.4134690464,
-0.8675928712,
0.6124774218,
-0.1287574321,
-0.6002386808,
-0.3334726095,
-0.6705203056,
0.7075899839,
0.0197748225,
-0.3993705213,
0.1749686003,
-0.1459838301,
0.2140939981,
-0.0994755924,
0.7467410564,
-0.1276755929,
0.0167710688,
0.2878094316,
0.0041750078,
0.2554207444,
-0.3757457733,
-0.1457796842,
0.1354175657,
-0.3394292593,
-0.5920305848,
-0.691454947,
0.7272734642,
-0.6327623725,
-0.323888123,
-0.3597644269,
-0.8522291183,
-0.3138948083,
0.1766620129,
-0.0409030616,
0.5900326967,
-0.133334741,
0.2683663368,
1.024537921,
-0.2621540725,
0.3506927192,
0.7343969941,
-0.1661238223,
-0.2289631963,
1.3987994194,
0.1892475337,
0.2418693006,
0.7363541722,
-0.0239159893,
-0.1644869,
-0.6379336119,
-0.4332728088,
0.3526275754,
-0.3522660136,
-0.1558015496,
-0.8378796577,
-0.2288641036,
-0.2033792734,
0.0197434649,
-0.2880912125,
-0.4580850601,
-0.6285040975,
-0.0484912284,
0.0614879765,
0.3098120391,
-0.1538063288,
0.3649269044,
-0.9512408972,
0.5055339336,
0.165350318,
0.3005556464,
0.1544185132,
-0.6879389882,
-0.3987873197,
-0.135031864,
-0.5322067142,
-0.8183441162,
0.3959221542,
0.0073490762,
0.4721226394,
0.6176567674,
-0.2550287247,
0.8936956525,
-0.4314152598,
0.7095749378,
0.1918648779,
-0.4492343068,
0.3644473553,
-0.4831058383,
0.4395108819,
0.4408385456,
0.1421233863,
-0.1738103032,
-0.3610543311,
-0.738848865,
-0.7195222974,
0.5368650556,
0.0218603145,
0.2449162453,
-0.1765429676,
0.2002545595,
0.233831957,
0.248860538,
-0.4022690356,
-0.2056617737,
0.0111116711,
-0.1400366724,
0.1001363695,
-0.4253247976,
0.0135501539,
-0.0824237913,
0.7470989823,
-0.1817814112,
0.4293851852,
-0.0813622177,
-0.2669593096,
-0.1668821573,
0.4091647863,
0.473310411,
0.5053370595,
-0.5469611287,
0.2138220668,
0.1994123906,
-0.2264033705,
0.0404442176,
0.2982274592,
-0.5416483283,
0.0437014028,
-0.1683003753,
0.8221088648,
0.4846408963,
-0.6841706038,
0.3417402506,
0.0047873622,
0.0617472157,
-0.0020174729,
0.3010385633,
-0.0486352667,
0.1351165324,
0.5057607293,
0.0882975087,
0.3881805241,
-0.5973684788,
0.3050628603,
0.6382416487,
-0.4038043916,
-0.5322178006,
0.3923641145,
-0.1773118526,
0.1269470602,
0.2753071785,
-0.3975238204,
0.0100785615,
0.1718485951,
0.9544945955,
0.848299861,
-0.1879780143,
-0.0233871192,
0.3835454881,
0.151312083,
-0.0576238297,
0.4007043839,
-0.1958831549,
-0.8889853358,
-0.5770229101,
-0.5391388535,
-0.3485373259,
0.2978349924,
-0.3581209779,
0.1624323279,
-0.320663929,
0.0662711933,
-0.3691971898,
-0.0468162112,
-0.5059145093,
0.1740833521,
0.181601584,
0.7755365968,
-0.6548179984,
0.9400062561,
0.5454888344,
-0.7724078298,
-0.6119138002,
-0.0403272361,
-0.1739690304,
-0.5210280418,
0.3953256309,
0.1957987994,
0.0269741341,
-0.1586467773,
-0.3693105578,
-0.8088601232,
0.9718672037,
0.513076365,
-0.3726174533,
-0.0433210954,
-0.1232721731,
0.3909446597,
-0.4452057183,
0.6872757077,
0.3925958574,
-0.0096933302,
0.4582622945,
-0.4406820238,
-0.128490448,
-0.1102272123,
0.1293471754,
0.0916280821,
-0.6235907674,
0.862436533,
-0.1433341503,
-0.1598371565,
-0.1199175417,
0.9999626875,
0.542550981,
0.2497746199,
0.2597035468,
1.0398565531,
0.4983598292,
0.1973394006,
1.0161612034,
-0.2530292571,
0.0663114414,
1.4107166529,
-0.472627759,
0.9246094823,
0.4468048513,
-0.0104643209,
0.6718575954,
0.1919988692,
0.2029291838,
0.4889289737,
-0.2252031565,
-0.8507575393,
-0.0942409858,
-0.4497009218,
-0.2763858438,
0.2457236052,
0.5645159483,
-0.2633159757,
-0.5214345455,
-0.216031,
-0.2414449155,
-0.2889214754,
-0.1197571531,
0.9443101287,
0.1095301807,
-0.6442305446,
0.3504630625,
0.1462208629,
0.7920303941,
-0.4681691229,
-0.1652477384,
-0.1333815604,
0.2335646451,
-0.1222360283,
-0.5280820131,
0.3708158731,
-0.1411193907,
-0.2849521935,
0.2384153157,
1.2761220932,
-0.8917907476,
-0.425778538,
0.3191553652,
0.6926147938,
0.0933925733,
-0.1674955338,
-0.5560028553,
-0.0451894365,
-0.2937114239,
0.0475854576,
0.7141089439,
0.3366619945,
0.141312927,
0.3711536527,
0.772939682,
0.1057650298,
0.4272529483,
0.2637348771,
1.0471628904,
-0.6111992002,
-0.2710293531,
-0.7685640454,
0.3583924472,
0.0099233268,
0.3485136926,
0.6041303277,
0.8867649436,
0.801420629,
-0.2078847587,
0.7790697813,
0.0245530251,
0.59807688,
-0.320353806,
0.2286698222,
-0.4406342506,
0.0738663301,
0.0382043011,
-1.1386852264,
-0.3370741308,
0.4138393104,
-0.3411144316,
0.1294267625,
0.5592232347,
1.0034713745,
-0.670797348,
-0.2124655992,
0.5973725915,
0.0596986972,
0.1949387193,
0.6266120076,
0.5292164683,
-0.604519248,
0.4958671033,
-0.5182477832,
-0.1523598582,
-0.3159403801,
-0.7453962564,
-0.6621769071,
-0.2000097632,
-0.2500950098,
-0.0961569101,
-0.0204741322,
0.7410457134,
0.6523379087,
-0.9005146623,
-0.3121803105,
-0.0387344547,
0.0265124533,
-0.0618737377,
-0.2961214781,
-0.1584113687,
-0.7547715306,
-0.6557845473,
0.6862592697,
0.7805472016,
0.0795993432,
-0.4480744898,
0.0318358541,
-0.5195068717,
0.0865992382,
0.6635806561,
0.5079889297,
-0.5005887151,
-0.1400897652,
0.0488334149,
-0.001528239,
0.5073750019,
0.8107656837,
-1.0362254381,
0.7039072514,
0.665626049,
0.8775477409,
0.6336925626,
0.0286218245,
0.6768891215,
-0.8805992603,
0.241914615,
0.0311373733,
0.4833117127,
0.600810647,
-0.19602184,
0.3712144494,
0.3503358662,
-0.3870867789,
-0.5624705553,
0.0388966389,
-1.0268976688,
-0.042138204,
0.8507318497,
-0.0144168558,
-0.4324618876,
-0.2616888881,
-0.170999676,
0.402210325,
-0.6756568551,
0.8500537276,
0.4911213517,
0.0310426969,
-0.3256592453,
-0.4556585252,
-0.1987778842,
0.5022823215,
-0.6828166246,
-0.4348026216,
0.7180562615,
0.3026887476,
0.4049679935,
0.8241128922,
-0.2018919587,
0.1471695006,
-0.0089582782,
0.097329922,
0.0105478195,
-0.4314204752,
-0.4672149718,
0.3463399708,
-0.0015954247,
-0.1828880161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03693v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03693v6 | Concept Algebra for (Score-Based) Text-Controlled Generative Models | 2023-02-07T20:43:48 | 2024-02-08T02:43:08 | Zihao Wang, Lin Gui, Jeffrey Negrea, Victor Veitch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | This paper concerns the structure of learned representations in text-guided
generative models, focusing on score-based models. A key property of such
models is that they can compose disparate concepts in a `disentangled' manner.
This suggests these models have internal representations that encode concepts
in a `disentangled' manner. Here, we focus on the idea that concepts are
encoded as subspaces of some representation space. We formalize what this
means, show there's a natural choice for the representation, and develop a
simple method for identifying the part of the representation corresponding to a
given concept. In particular, this allows us to manipulate the concepts
expressed by the model through algebraic manipulation of the representation. We
demonstrate the idea with examples using Stable Diffusion. Code in
https://github.com/zihao12/concept-algebra-code | [
-0.1140058637,
-0.7691808343,
0.8141803741,
0.1110068783,
-0.3178331852,
0.8604944944,
0.0563459583,
-0.1497436613,
0.3702135682,
0.0660107285,
-0.1712573171,
-0.664714098,
-0.7704515457,
-0.3076633513,
-0.6112409234,
0.8665700555,
-0.4398525357,
0.169952035,
-0.8647049665,
0.2364743948,
-0.3931236565,
-0.5723585486,
-0.289537847,
-0.5217407942,
0.2609036267,
-0.0275255963,
0.5140770674,
0.5720720291,
0.9145487547,
0.3226729035,
-0.5486409068,
-0.0140130641,
-0.4232806265,
0.1007256582,
-0.0572170541,
-0.7144039273,
-0.3734652996,
0.3354988694,
0.7021896839,
0.742893517,
-0.4323977828,
-0.0219473708,
-0.1347702295,
0.5642333627,
-0.6161594391,
0.2976846099,
-0.3955327272,
0.1899398267,
-0.1048903614,
-0.0318847857,
-0.4755233228,
-0.4036931694,
-0.1005587503,
-0.5907033682,
0.1575170308,
-0.1462325007,
0.902505219,
0.1095533818,
-0.4640612006,
-0.4922313094,
-0.8784538507,
0.817679286,
-0.1216411516,
0.1002074555,
0.4640955627,
0.3005455434,
0.0840910748,
-0.536483407,
-0.4334307313,
-0.2042842358,
-0.2157219797,
0.4855592549,
-0.0909946039,
0.3534258902,
0.2264231294,
0.7996659875,
-0.3957167268,
-0.171720475,
-0.5323985815,
-0.0552930571,
0.7396247983,
0.1291976124,
0.3051159978,
-0.430221349,
-0.5501324534,
-0.0167195424,
-0.501057446,
-0.2005244046,
0.2735787034,
-0.0362550057,
-0.2326157391,
0.63305825,
0.1805125773,
0.8007870317,
0.2186206579,
-0.0727833658,
0.2902951837,
0.0891786963,
-0.2095448822,
0.1809408814,
0.5627571344,
0.1313113719,
0.0765231177,
-0.2111248821,
-0.3749680519,
0.643864274,
0.68489784,
-0.5914309621,
-0.1946766078,
0.0796076953,
-0.6428673267,
-0.5473525524,
0.2228938937,
-0.655020237,
-0.0815736949,
-0.4407651126,
0.75655967,
-0.4485007226,
-0.4162536263,
0.2445348203,
-0.4350430071,
-0.1035988256,
0.2557868063,
-0.9335845709,
0.6167327166,
0.4333181381,
0.922698319,
-0.2518831789,
0.1899137199,
0.1748332679,
0.1388243586,
-0.7219303846,
0.4026596844,
-0.8228393793,
-0.8417615891,
-0.1032390669,
-0.4969163835,
-0.0530603342,
-0.511017859,
-0.0083674807,
-0.9550515413,
0.1698492616,
-0.0222741254,
-1.1000449657,
-0.1955861151,
0.1719849408,
-0.7525435686,
0.7936455011,
0.3437662125,
-0.365369916,
0.0785845071,
-0.7186905742,
-0.023156058,
-0.102598533,
-0.2395459861,
-0.1678463668,
0.5457366109,
-0.2601484358,
0.1687047333,
0.1604867876,
0.145751819,
-0.0480398275,
-0.3629902601,
0.2827759087,
-0.2054785043,
0.4874726236,
0.4105138779,
0.1282860786,
0.0091008907,
-0.6609731913,
-0.1314440519,
0.0901920944,
-0.2707392275,
-0.9040919542,
0.1488374174,
-0.1493356377,
-0.0648641735,
0.5003286004,
-0.4981343448,
0.3856291175,
-0.2147690803,
0.1470278203,
0.799269259,
0.21785748,
0.8081102967,
-0.057049904,
0.6910806894,
0.3998482227,
-0.1070396751,
0.1553818285,
-0.5174255967,
-0.5784423351,
-0.3072479665,
0.5001700521,
0.2239919454,
-0.9462667704,
0.3570015728,
0.0838375986,
-0.5093041062,
-0.4972468615,
0.0273301713,
0.4350633323,
0.3481355906,
0.3592133224,
-0.2605212629,
-0.1116720513,
-0.7417311668,
0.2851279378,
-0.2582179606,
0.2127463371,
-0.1443009973,
0.6924189329,
-0.0305846073,
0.9692983627,
-1.0206320286,
-0.2603532374,
-0.0796084106,
0.3519857824,
0.0696177632,
0.6441235542,
0.7040151358,
-1.1901208162,
-0.331618011,
-0.1788356751,
-0.8626824617,
0.3114983737,
-0.1880236566,
-0.3835213482,
-0.4687507153,
0.6482899785,
-0.8116922975,
0.4658853114,
0.5154750347,
-0.4374870658,
0.294039309,
-0.3671166599,
0.0986456499,
-1.0723378658,
-0.2258371562,
0.1266546994,
-0.2481961101,
-0.5168339014,
0.5929191709,
0.0763632655,
0.0990303904,
-0.1261560023,
0.041315712,
-0.4326930046,
0.1161191463,
-0.2703064382,
0.1740355045,
0.1538863927,
0.4350785315,
0.2758366466,
0.7113361359,
0.6184661388,
-0.813459456,
0.1236958951,
0.5128798485,
-0.3495946825,
0.566131711,
-0.6839514375,
0.0779181048,
-0.4324594736,
-0.1144078821,
-0.6961649656,
-0.1750478446,
0.1523692012,
-0.5575671196,
0.6042330265,
0.0030874982,
-0.4026519358,
-0.0732908919,
-0.0619466603,
0.4247103333,
0.7038339972,
-0.3998576999,
0.4818663597,
0.5494169593,
0.3718408644,
-0.2110429406,
-0.764978528,
-0.437698096,
-0.3300856948,
-0.0081764692,
1.0003944635,
-0.2619267702,
-0.3853399158,
0.4307707846,
-0.1011809781,
-0.1356638819,
0.2563209832,
0.2123123109,
0.2993719876,
0.0075491229,
0.7721726894,
0.4478244185,
0.0081239101,
0.1908481121,
-0.1431052089,
0.3236813247,
0.1701207459,
-0.6698617935,
0.0193473659,
0.6570051312,
0.4696759284,
-0.3914161623,
0.7107239366,
0.1117248312,
-0.7630861998,
-0.4318117499,
0.3919644654,
-0.053605292,
-0.4899950624,
0.3685393929,
-0.3162482977,
-1.0127342939,
0.6395655274,
-0.2119928002,
-0.2256783992,
0.5765037537,
0.5763000846,
-0.4089042246,
1.1051126719,
0.8504812717,
0.0840532184,
0.5358562469,
-0.6150900722,
0.1865376681,
-0.8385487199,
-0.2973674238,
-0.3821141422,
-0.4031611979,
-0.6139082313,
-0.725120604,
0.4327723086,
0.5363128185,
-0.1336178333,
0.0733957142,
-0.575140059,
0.6409320235,
0.374381572,
0.1225266531,
0.1318285316,
-0.0402313843,
-0.2998184562,
-0.1826969832,
-0.5630342364,
-0.4891352952,
0.9832818508,
0.4620151818,
0.8638111353,
0.5176273584,
1.2711486816,
0.5233535171,
0.3708257377,
-0.9583710432,
0.2900674343,
-0.4167618752,
-0.7886958718,
0.1562008709,
-0.6111332178,
-0.4432426691,
-0.03189018,
-0.0603295229,
-0.867054224,
0.3676757514,
0.1004705578,
-0.2255124897,
0.1256148219,
-0.813498199,
0.711274147,
-0.0394283831,
-0.1817993373,
-0.6126637459,
-0.1200455055,
0.4911017418,
-0.0181016158,
-0.0394665785,
0.1628517956,
0.315462172,
0.7330833077,
-0.2708981633,
0.8719134331,
-0.1871074289,
-0.1234415695,
0.6360855699,
0.358515501,
-0.0213080589,
0.1378346235,
0.0893860832,
-0.0419534184,
0.0380310081,
-0.2230908871,
-0.8482292891,
0.5396845341,
-0.8388948441,
-0.5699606538,
-0.6772925854,
-0.2177550495,
-0.304903537,
0.0016463902,
0.1310885698,
0.4550949633,
-0.3202867508,
0.0165877212,
1.0541042089,
0.0165992677,
0.233379662,
0.1978961825,
-0.616509974,
-0.0690565854,
0.9817884564,
-0.0080096554,
0.5650715232,
0.8596861959,
0.0306949969,
-0.4226544499,
-0.4137194455,
-0.2608493865,
-0.077306062,
-0.9631552696,
-0.3522922397,
-0.0472942218,
-0.5543374419,
0.2164668739,
-0.0756252632,
-0.337536037,
-0.4534043372,
-0.8293190002,
-0.7380458713,
0.4681591392,
0.9658657908,
-0.1543961316,
0.5577116609,
-0.6102697849,
0.5941798091,
0.4847813845,
0.6438853741,
0.0742536411,
-0.3035161793,
-0.4485270083,
-0.0110642901,
-0.2807344496,
-1.1196151972,
0.05616102,
0.1481461823,
0.587924242,
0.5616813302,
-0.094874613,
0.601804018,
-0.4225248098,
0.7955677509,
0.2957835197,
-1.252175808,
0.6251026392,
-0.0975317061,
0.1999606937,
0.2990808189,
0.5598325729,
-0.4419912994,
-0.495934099,
-0.565245688,
-0.3806405663,
0.4488818049,
0.1039837822,
0.6093598604,
-0.2694556713,
0.404831022,
0.0097160609,
0.3810515702,
-0.6407501698,
-0.3877399862,
-0.4071339071,
-0.6592487097,
-0.051314231,
-0.4606158733,
-0.1840714365,
-0.1852571964,
0.3357488513,
0.0375831649,
0.5914790034,
0.1217047423,
-0.1165841818,
-0.1333056092,
-0.0739926323,
0.4481980801,
0.5147246718,
-0.4664966762,
0.1747121662,
-0.5535687804,
-0.7397954464,
0.4064304531,
0.0223696139,
-0.3565462828,
0.1877899915,
0.3457196355,
0.8539377451,
0.01209985,
-0.2899179161,
0.2615504265,
0.0238778703,
-0.2859552801,
-0.1493282318,
0.3085805476,
0.2245902419,
0.0986993164,
0.2526216805,
0.242918089,
0.2077961713,
-0.4651022255,
0.1942318529,
0.247212857,
-0.7407733202,
-0.269551754,
0.751016438,
0.029044643,
-0.0893360376,
0.4739509225,
-0.6122424006,
-0.4972858727,
0.6600089669,
0.3789460957,
0.8531751633,
-0.2316538692,
0.8403682709,
0.3961134255,
0.0802207887,
-0.015529681,
0.3127353191,
-0.0914271027,
-1.0685648918,
-0.3160259426,
-0.9184955955,
-0.3334649801,
-0.2580090761,
-0.8617309928,
-0.2449083328,
-0.5634513497,
-0.2571838796,
0.0399877839,
-0.3419768214,
-0.2601079047,
0.421287179,
0.4209667146,
0.9784321189,
-0.8613198996,
0.8778262734,
0.8396983743,
-0.6277354956,
-0.8471761942,
-0.0497878864,
-0.1107221022,
-0.3614388108,
0.7207448483,
-0.2384017259,
-0.1783623248,
0.0721705034,
-0.5848070383,
-0.9100564718,
1.0695623159,
0.0869916379,
-0.637252152,
-0.0293038208,
-0.0184210557,
0.8315646052,
-0.3857488036,
0.0237417277,
0.2573128939,
0.0327786319,
0.1301135868,
-0.3597745299,
-0.3749898374,
-0.2253578901,
0.240090698,
0.2571646273,
-0.547986567,
0.9956793785,
0.0800755024,
-0.3068092167,
-0.0292812549,
0.8367672563,
0.2656946182,
0.2661413848,
0.2403568029,
0.7072899938,
0.6855849624,
-0.2591031492,
1.0114380121,
-0.227303341,
0.7425994277,
0.6142915487,
-0.059742637,
0.7577344775,
0.5804569721,
-0.3854710162,
0.8687467575,
0.6137660742,
0.2226563543,
1.0022422075,
0.3058770299,
-0.3091263175,
-0.3613220453,
0.0567138866,
-0.3360061944,
0.8038287163,
0.748978138,
-0.6270125508,
-0.1528093964,
-0.1612840295,
-0.2596182227,
0.5588845611,
-0.5174587965,
0.8179766536,
0.4431545734,
-0.3905662298,
0.2756355703,
0.2884802818,
0.391269654,
-0.9736962914,
-0.4400513768,
-0.2024845332,
0.2112188339,
0.0263957232,
-0.7732763886,
0.3948427439,
-0.0230788589,
-0.4152614176,
-0.5310193896,
0.6916590929,
-0.5545296669,
-0.7670719028,
0.2053459436,
0.6722402573,
-0.2361423969,
0.3128738701,
-0.539398253,
-0.0109953983,
-0.0654600635,
-0.0841953307,
0.2171612829,
0.2680591047,
-0.2320875674,
0.491055578,
0.2934353948,
0.1166744307,
-0.1805581152,
0.0931343585,
0.8473057151,
-0.5786756277,
-0.8135907054,
-0.7050958276,
0.5431130528,
-0.0437392853,
-0.3077809513,
0.5554948449,
0.2571358681,
0.7785247564,
-0.4595737457,
0.6092482805,
-0.2145823985,
0.3844653368,
-0.8325612545,
0.9908849001,
-0.7043429613,
0.0835746676,
-0.4413214922,
-0.7621593475,
-0.2149138004,
0.8043769598,
-0.3095325828,
0.0191090386,
0.5733972788,
0.5409116745,
-0.1297347248,
-0.1997711658,
0.2137312442,
-0.1797682792,
0.3019322753,
0.5010698438,
1.084954977,
-0.1621578187,
-0.1707002968,
-0.2420226783,
-0.1351043731,
-0.0315945633,
-0.5663852692,
-0.683106482,
-0.7765621543,
-0.6840677857,
-0.0057465592,
-0.1020563319,
0.4616299868,
0.5349137187,
-0.752197206,
-0.1584453732,
-0.4205691218,
0.5542584658,
-0.4154148698,
-0.2133455873,
0.4361362755,
-0.1156370938,
-0.7567606568,
0.192612648,
0.16640158,
0.3310039639,
-0.7296506166,
-0.1121244654,
-0.1147667021,
0.1375338435,
0.549213469,
-0.3335336149,
-0.2200557292,
-0.2543491125,
-0.0439094156,
-0.1846773028,
0.0114215324,
0.6862196326,
-0.8450402617,
0.7501377463,
0.5076428056,
0.3154865801,
0.4649215937,
0.120071128,
0.5262544155,
-1.0964107513,
0.1759616733,
0.3678089082,
0.1994124949,
0.3536963463,
-0.3199099898,
0.1174731106,
0.3190405369,
0.030151505,
-0.5987773538,
0.4953281879,
-0.9284103513,
-0.4143641293,
0.6686502695,
-0.1300038099,
-0.2382805198,
0.4297637045,
-0.0277720429,
0.1081597507,
-0.1665033549,
1.0597648621,
0.882905066,
0.1249675229,
-0.2290173918,
-0.3923155963,
0.7035135031,
0.1017228886,
-0.7204671502,
-0.4210084081,
0.5388898253,
-0.0972421095,
0.7280534506,
0.3813920915,
-0.3160085976,
0.227864638,
0.2331085801,
0.0608741976,
0.1372263432,
-0.2504106164,
-0.3195210099,
0.2213499099,
0.1815668941,
-0.5954079032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03716v1 | Mining Effective Features Using Quantum Entropy for Humor Recognition | 2023-02-07T19:09:09 | 2023-02-07T19:09:09 | Yang Liu, Yuexian Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humor recognition has been extensively studied with different methods in the
past years. However, existing studies on humor recognition do not understand
the mechanisms that generate humor. In this paper, inspired by the incongruity
theory, any joke can be divided into two components (the setup and the
punchline). Both components have multiple possible semantics, and there is an
incongruous relationship between them. We use density matrices to represent the
semantic uncertainty of the setup and the punchline, respectively, and design
QE-Uncertainty and QE-Incongruity with the help of quantum entropy as features
for humor recognition. The experimental results on the SemEval2021 Task 7
dataset show that the proposed features are more effective than the baselines
for recognizing humorous and non-humorous texts. | [
-0.1584050655,
-0.6624599099,
0.7244423032,
0.3460256159,
-0.8821229339,
-0.2205652893,
0.1463822573,
-0.3546159863,
0.6951875091,
0.2960198522,
-0.1548651159,
-0.0987650454,
-0.4797067046,
0.1284196526,
-0.3317939937,
0.8768045306,
0.3992779851,
0.0266186893,
-0.0360590965,
-0.3650379777,
-0.2343476713,
-0.2436226755,
-0.5427596569,
-0.2591049969,
0.5513603091,
0.2074986994,
0.8809885979,
0.5139983892,
0.5902824998,
0.2551580071,
0.011211467,
-0.1438326538,
-0.1902167052,
0.2033108771,
-0.1332935244,
-0.6638695002,
0.1457126737,
-0.3926275074,
0.6539731622,
0.5166369677,
-0.3025732636,
-0.2286665589,
-0.2039204389,
0.3630489707,
-0.483872354,
-0.1668158025,
-0.7415310144,
0.3450754583,
-0.4007028937,
-0.6832473278,
0.0695242956,
-0.5078219771,
0.1595012397,
-0.298176229,
-0.091469273,
0.0741694123,
0.6299806833,
0.2416086495,
-0.5554349422,
-0.5772918463,
-0.4505548179,
0.570825994,
-0.7099217772,
0.370496124,
0.1927143186,
0.1867125481,
-0.2925897241,
-0.37052688,
-0.7668213248,
-0.3359202743,
0.0423715711,
-0.0970069021,
-0.1341270804,
-0.4600249231,
0.3200826645,
0.4222328365,
-0.6977646351,
-0.2771023512,
-0.1720308959,
-0.2583762705,
0.3908562362,
0.1544825584,
0.4054745138,
-0.4927755296,
-0.6652839184,
-0.2862224877,
-0.2911910713,
0.3118981123,
0.5325517058,
0.0230435431,
0.0070595867,
0.3783972263,
-0.2386798561,
0.0226355772,
-0.1927541941,
-0.5419850945,
0.3353903592,
0.1207797974,
-0.125944078,
0.317629844,
0.7202820182,
-0.1032773256,
-0.0489285998,
-0.2351872176,
-0.1116375625,
-0.1959969997,
0.303776443,
-0.4155567586,
-0.6486704946,
0.1574895084,
-0.3701888025,
-0.5214930773,
0.2844225466,
-0.4841212332,
-0.7874763012,
0.1892487556,
0.7046347857,
-0.8463012576,
-0.377787143,
0.0894231424,
-0.8492593765,
0.2376420349,
0.3158831298,
-0.208054319,
-0.0318601578,
0.4772746563,
0.6954964995,
0.3857471943,
-0.1608776897,
-0.4141780138,
0.196273163,
-0.1482942849,
0.9935817719,
-0.5964083076,
0.097502768,
-0.3586518466,
-0.2585827708,
0.1637417525,
-0.4860621989,
0.6546393633,
-0.5504137874,
-0.0401856564,
0.0535643734,
-0.4915076494,
-0.218393892,
0.162769258,
-0.8448011875,
0.7992105484,
0.1266486198,
-1.2377276421,
0.404248327,
-0.4316140711,
-0.6333605647,
0.3528994322,
-0.0692070052,
-0.5124331713,
0.4929118156,
-0.1506220698,
0.0299143214,
0.1230897307,
0.1772940606,
-0.7876545787,
-0.3331409991,
0.8984057307,
-0.424074322,
1.0521546602,
0.5263550282,
-0.3350149393,
-0.3718049228,
-0.932866931,
0.1202628464,
0.3505128622,
-0.3468206525,
-0.5889891982,
0.1109092459,
-0.3749193251,
0.2667712867,
0.3203329444,
-0.3125040233,
-0.1837509722,
-0.4544604421,
0.6213267446,
0.4671252072,
0.1784919649,
0.2166085243,
-0.1200067848,
0.4546718597,
0.4131229818,
0.2078708112,
0.1598825902,
-0.442953229,
-0.632476747,
-0.3438869417,
0.1645489037,
0.9660828114,
-0.9927917719,
0.5319140553,
-0.068967618,
-0.4685765207,
-0.2061947435,
0.1969389021,
0.4037691653,
0.0384426378,
0.1091269106,
-0.5477715731,
-0.3964072764,
-0.8826274276,
-0.5495739579,
-0.4611493945,
-0.1532567739,
0.2013425082,
0.2267355472,
0.2960054278,
0.6408050656,
-0.3942036629,
0.1289995462,
0.1386330575,
-0.0076162755,
0.0833702385,
0.4201604724,
0.3950864673,
-0.880728364,
-0.0852660388,
-0.0808159262,
-0.9992727637,
0.1458202302,
0.1364725381,
-0.1582226455,
-0.1385861635,
0.2749971151,
-0.5947039723,
0.3905457556,
-0.0566076189,
-0.2923729122,
0.480987072,
0.0728321895,
0.2700158656,
-0.825558126,
-0.1197749674,
0.0197596028,
-0.2765623331,
-0.4960443079,
0.1692120135,
0.0636507496,
-0.225471139,
-0.5017831326,
0.451946944,
-0.0951385722,
0.1040111557,
0.0790438652,
-0.0167008843,
-0.0248199906,
0.2272296548,
-0.4273806214,
0.1384560615,
0.4912193716,
-0.5686481595,
0.5682579875,
-0.094653748,
-0.4056812823,
1.039999485,
-0.404608041,
0.1601587385,
-0.044580292,
0.1362150609,
-0.954292953,
-0.4318552613,
0.2528885603,
-0.6421414018,
0.2378118038,
0.2501340806,
-0.9056190252,
-0.2843904197,
-0.766500175,
0.3933566809,
0.4980648458,
-0.3336111605,
0.5046228766,
0.380112052,
-0.0767110884,
-0.4740134776,
-0.5372055769,
0.213667348,
-1.0942618847,
-0.7194010019,
0.0253157429,
0.0985483527,
-0.1376808733,
-0.0487103388,
-0.0596956722,
-0.0332995318,
0.2882241905,
0.2273813933,
-0.3852697909,
-0.0467733257,
0.4801915884,
0.1660563201,
0.2179182023,
-0.0252623428,
-0.1264641583,
0.3925910592,
0.1098982245,
0.0509357713,
-0.5177538395,
0.2432693988,
0.1830021143,
0.2772001326,
0.4853904247,
0.8467942476,
-0.4096690416,
-0.2330007255,
-0.5754244924,
-0.26271981,
-0.4800819159,
0.2517301738,
-0.5753747821,
-1.1066111326,
0.6804659367,
-0.0631084889,
-0.5532928109,
0.4194201231,
0.0746373832,
-0.3025658727,
1.1035101414,
0.6082953811,
0.2703527212,
0.4901711047,
0.4411475062,
0.6528793573,
-0.7908264399,
-0.1122476235,
-0.5719554424,
-0.2808927596,
-0.6353833675,
-0.1366653293,
0.5488068461,
0.8335898519,
-0.30754897,
0.4161465168,
-0.2847752273,
0.257145524,
0.8589452505,
0.303134352,
0.0961197764,
0.2836558819,
-0.4009296298,
0.0430450179,
-0.4768137336,
-0.3886020184,
0.3967383206,
0.4681344628,
0.8176239133,
0.3499010205,
0.9035423398,
0.3094848692,
-0.4154811203,
-0.3873945177,
0.7321337461,
-0.144657746,
-0.4240289927,
-0.3403493762,
-0.8569982648,
-0.6287860274,
-0.2860091329,
-0.2091121972,
-0.9423267841,
0.3266129792,
0.1170924902,
-0.2706545591,
0.1316256672,
-0.8661226034,
0.5332679749,
0.000768543,
0.1380868107,
-0.1903942376,
-0.767442286,
0.3935238123,
0.1138699427,
0.2369696349,
-0.0278990231,
0.2318993658,
0.5480966568,
-0.4306968451,
0.675768137,
-0.1140834764,
-0.1358863711,
0.4838975072,
0.3632461727,
0.4347810745,
0.4120839536,
-0.0596136563,
0.1260079443,
0.0421639197,
-0.5156508088,
-0.7645224333,
0.5907328725,
-0.5043157339,
-0.3219398558,
-0.2960796356,
-0.5617539883,
0.0203452203,
-0.03405191,
0.4621429443,
0.4010950327,
0.1809389591,
0.0402412973,
0.5121079087,
-0.2932657301,
0.3137834966,
0.1115572751,
0.1932459325,
-0.8421569467,
1.2417693138,
0.2307997644,
-0.0035826114,
0.3431370258,
0.2860950232,
-0.260081321,
-0.1904673874,
-0.0283390395,
0.2022997737,
-1.0712043047,
-0.4235928059,
-0.8780977726,
-0.377622366,
-0.5114988089,
-0.1086674482,
0.1157061681,
-0.9056950808,
-0.0216636583,
0.1503242105,
0.5508015752,
0.5417245626,
-0.3568663001,
0.0529425368,
-0.6544690728,
0.0379841961,
0.833523035,
0.3529298604,
0.0978954285,
-0.436691761,
-0.2890950143,
-0.2337589413,
-0.5044344068,
-1.0364495516,
0.1370266676,
0.491602838,
0.3820308149,
0.7441692948,
0.1832270324,
0.4412304163,
-0.3706049025,
0.6997663975,
0.3012725115,
-0.9228082895,
0.8762774467,
-0.1676024497,
-0.0165089332,
0.1776498109,
0.2281269729,
-0.0841299444,
-0.8560802341,
-1.1063787937,
-0.5644071102,
0.2881923914,
0.4533858299,
0.3757608831,
-0.3489420116,
0.4562427402,
0.075020358,
0.5288209915,
-0.7782194018,
-0.0078894803,
-0.199269101,
-0.2453315407,
0.4819169939,
-0.3476234674,
-0.1303867698,
0.0243808031,
0.5513068438,
0.0754248723,
0.3957625329,
0.2303486019,
-0.2771528363,
-0.2312019318,
0.4609741271,
0.5941743851,
0.5041636229,
-0.3864365816,
0.7519809604,
0.0774157494,
-0.4584260583,
-0.1658741981,
0.166509375,
0.092568934,
0.014415903,
0.4263519943,
0.7618875504,
0.1717807651,
-0.5844880939,
0.2260652035,
0.0041905623,
0.0629035234,
-0.249007687,
0.528859973,
-0.0209867638,
0.8677910566,
0.3155651987,
-0.05383249,
0.7538366318,
-0.8760377765,
0.2364195287,
0.6603674293,
-0.3954523206,
-0.3832545578,
0.2985625863,
-0.1857311577,
-0.2300509661,
0.48874259,
-0.8150164485,
-0.8179244399,
0.8196678758,
0.5414226651,
0.6789816022,
-0.3352092803,
0.3875851631,
0.2383568138,
0.2579183877,
0.0874023363,
0.5111039877,
-0.0742860287,
-0.7221000791,
0.0679948851,
-0.8651541471,
-0.2028755546,
-0.1262528896,
-0.4142522216,
0.5045642257,
-0.3153303266,
-0.1318572015,
0.2089513093,
-0.0297002736,
-0.6163623929,
0.3121112287,
0.1851272136,
0.3639639616,
-0.8374355435,
0.5579810739,
0.9427852631,
-0.3231012225,
-0.8063510656,
-0.1395979822,
-0.038644392,
-0.9096044302,
0.3936744332,
0.3152142763,
0.3029455841,
0.0823972523,
-0.7621093988,
-0.4863605201,
1.0171741247,
0.4040023685,
-0.0621852055,
0.2291763425,
0.0060757371,
0.2899854779,
-0.3888546824,
0.178761214,
0.4172222614,
0.2822677195,
0.2223097533,
-0.9281134605,
0.2856528461,
-0.4146250188,
0.2899048924,
0.5155984163,
-0.4074152112,
1.0600934029,
-0.2757331133,
-0.2775560915,
-0.2452770919,
0.4467613399,
0.5106771588,
0.838660419,
0.8413225412,
1.2690279484,
0.7390282154,
0.157729581,
0.811683774,
-0.0120379245,
0.6757518649,
0.8725674152,
-0.2521063685,
0.7001895308,
0.3454850018,
-0.4580524266,
0.8629680276,
0.4503566325,
0.0262363534,
0.6942563653,
0.2818351984,
-0.295281291,
-0.3772661388,
-0.1801623851,
-0.380414784,
0.3116247058,
0.4064413011,
-0.3350004554,
-0.3715762794,
0.245196119,
0.1563324779,
-0.5360772014,
-0.1864897907,
0.9799700379,
0.5045545697,
-0.0207799189,
0.2825545967,
-0.3121726215,
0.5358787775,
-0.2869518399,
-0.3089437783,
-0.057442192,
-0.1942134053,
-0.3184868991,
-0.8639208674,
0.1060559675,
-0.2961375117,
-0.1415581256,
0.7054332495,
0.9975823164,
-0.2910343111,
-0.3615221083,
-0.0555281825,
0.2638403475,
0.5880280137,
-0.2735154927,
-0.5689154267,
-0.1322093159,
-0.2777197063,
-0.0575089976,
0.3437449932,
1.4344820976,
-0.0194912199,
0.4910502434,
0.4446738064,
-0.0205016155,
0.3181386888,
-0.0070077982,
0.6866180301,
-0.9999192357,
-0.8515930176,
-0.7459522486,
0.637016058,
-0.3489860892,
-0.4944793582,
0.7142928243,
0.1015322581,
0.3827935755,
0.0911400989,
0.5798724294,
-0.2064397782,
0.1357230544,
-0.632606566,
0.572090745,
-0.8452878594,
0.1934830546,
-0.262511909,
-1.0430145264,
-0.3182640076,
0.7418377995,
0.089161247,
0.1306635588,
1.0611109734,
0.52196455,
-0.0680617914,
0.0986764506,
0.2729276717,
0.1532867998,
0.1508301347,
0.6379256248,
0.7894214988,
-0.4111317396,
0.5927906632,
-0.7240722775,
-0.1523278654,
-0.5361380577,
-0.9361487627,
-0.7573754191,
-0.557911098,
-0.6504555345,
-0.7758567929,
-0.2672873735,
0.5510257483,
0.3388431966,
-0.5273616314,
0.2172557712,
-0.0883745402,
0.3134577572,
-0.2456002086,
-0.3674362898,
0.3856977522,
-0.4847083688,
0.0385467634,
0.0744926259,
0.7259010077,
-0.1424476951,
-0.1352808923,
0.1935940087,
-0.0080276262,
0.4553100467,
0.5778226852,
0.2515092194,
-0.4493894577,
-0.5570848584,
-0.3527284563,
-0.0272125192,
-0.0237854794,
0.7294009924,
-0.5489236116,
0.4807071388,
0.7056062222,
0.2518257201,
-0.1327172816,
-0.3091936707,
-0.0579948686,
-0.9294819236,
0.1463398039,
0.3068830669,
0.289663285,
0.3828507662,
-0.6467351913,
0.6699724793,
0.4758878946,
-0.5704592466,
-1.210598588,
0.2444518209,
-1.2330576181,
-0.1192938909,
0.7943289876,
-0.0794585943,
-0.43884027,
-0.1367869824,
0.2551929951,
0.2737617493,
-0.3304227293,
0.96593678,
0.8111899495,
-0.3016465008,
-0.3629287183,
-0.5715180039,
0.2685299218,
0.3619406819,
-0.6900786757,
-0.7045760751,
0.1666032225,
0.3884933293,
0.6264061332,
0.5228097439,
-0.1473310143,
0.5441800952,
0.2111032754,
0.1044975072,
0.358776778,
-0.2459865659,
-0.4232320487,
0.2985962033,
0.2008131146,
0.2405547053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04089v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04089v2 | ZipLM: Inference-Aware Structured Pruning of Language Models | 2023-02-07T18:55:28 | 2023-10-26T06:42:40 | Eldar Kurtic, Elias Frantar, Dan Alistarh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The breakthrough performance of large language models (LLMs) comes with major
computational footprints and high deployment costs. In this paper, we progress
towards resolving this problem by proposing a novel structured compression
approach for LLMs, called ZipLM. ZipLM achieves state-of-the-art
accuracy-vs-speedup, while matching a set of desired target runtime speedups in
any given inference environment. Specifically, given a model, a dataset, an
inference environment, as well as a set of speedup targets, ZipLM iteratively
identifies and removes components with the worst loss-runtime trade-off. Unlike
prior methods that specialize in either the post-training/one-shot or the
gradual compression setting, and only for specific families of models such as
BERT (encoder) or GPT (decoder), ZipLM produces state-of-the-art compressed
models across all these settings. Furthermore, ZipLM achieves superior results
for a fraction of the computational cost relative to prior distillation and
pruning techniques, making it a cost-effective approach for generating an
entire family of smaller, faster, and highly accurate models, guaranteed to
meet the desired inference specifications. In particular, ZipLM outperforms all
prior BERT-base distillation and pruning techniques, such as CoFi, MiniLM, and
TinyBERT. Moreover, it matches the performance of the heavily optimized
MobileBERT model, obtained via extensive architecture search, by simply pruning
the baseline BERT-large model. When compressing GPT2, ZipLM outperforms
DistilGPT2 while being 60% smaller and 30% faster. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/IST-DASLab/ZipLM. | [
-0.211815238,
-0.6078086495,
0.5325402617,
0.3489673436,
-0.4039777517,
0.1738821119,
-0.3620199859,
-0.1308360398,
0.0187733676,
0.2585121393,
-0.6889667511,
-0.4110858738,
-0.4296326041,
0.0760306939,
-0.470729053,
0.5412921309,
0.3979368806,
-0.169458732,
-0.266513437,
0.2151371837,
-0.0535205044,
-0.7733263373,
-0.4058292508,
-0.2888450325,
0.5396417379,
0.1863194108,
0.6373056769,
0.6958019137,
0.172980696,
0.3094321787,
-0.5029762387,
0.2983169854,
-0.4681151509,
0.2610016763,
0.2836753428,
-0.2455641478,
-0.3405098319,
-0.1745184213,
0.6214566827,
0.6478120685,
-0.4589757919,
0.3578753769,
0.0171145946,
0.7417538166,
-0.8057997227,
-0.1224410832,
-0.670663476,
-0.0351253375,
-0.3028158844,
-0.1324390769,
-0.6027991176,
-0.4468285143,
-0.5361602902,
-0.2593845129,
0.3275760412,
0.4020825028,
0.7701642513,
0.6263583302,
-0.4060720801,
0.0850288272,
-0.749794662,
0.5951773524,
-0.9139286876,
0.4139265716,
0.1395421326,
0.258114934,
-0.4340208769,
-0.9017268419,
-0.5062750578,
-0.0156522654,
-0.1180204079,
-0.0280043501,
-0.0246298742,
0.1742017865,
0.3994940817,
0.4206008911,
-0.8804605007,
0.1337258518,
-0.533371985,
-0.1876800954,
0.7106249332,
0.0601413175,
0.0613947958,
-0.0088427132,
-0.2695462406,
0.1075100154,
-1.0328072309,
-0.0924324021,
0.5780972242,
0.1865550429,
0.335863322,
0.3958201706,
-0.330743283,
1.0045236349,
-0.2238982022,
-0.1975367516,
0.1539237052,
0.0631833822,
-0.5775639415,
0.1679671407,
0.6517549753,
0.0972613096,
0.1660349965,
-0.0714891106,
-0.2894936502,
-0.2562222481,
0.1834684461,
-1.0453956127,
-0.5611356497,
0.5229786634,
-0.5180342197,
-0.4178819656,
-0.1084156334,
-0.4768622816,
-0.3076305687,
-0.1329581589,
0.1920561194,
-0.3699616194,
-0.2019219249,
0.1842133999,
-0.0331319496,
0.1050949469,
0.2221650034,
-0.8074906468,
0.2161565125,
0.9282987118,
0.9250751734,
0.1744939834,
0.0486127846,
-0.6377329826,
0.0411426611,
-0.2423158288,
0.8448215127,
-0.4107247293,
-0.0668093562,
-0.1906203032,
-0.215962261,
-0.0502422042,
-0.4685105085,
0.8957214355,
-0.4910640419,
0.0316162556,
0.2294920683,
-0.6759254932,
-0.2426950485,
0.1733665019,
-0.6595698595,
1.2218368053,
0.0479906574,
-0.7500749826,
0.0485683456,
-0.2171243727,
-0.5494138002,
0.2341669947,
0.3190020621,
-0.6497795582,
0.4945591688,
0.4046421647,
0.4404632151,
-0.356095314,
0.4610165954,
-0.317569375,
-0.6094341874,
-0.3021274209,
-0.2584202886,
0.9395835996,
0.4779684246,
0.1072756797,
0.3494338989,
-0.8130072951,
0.3887941837,
0.2983952165,
-0.3264737427,
-0.4904653728,
0.2859073579,
-0.1231522635,
0.2926146388,
0.1889475733,
-0.4045211077,
0.600528419,
-0.4285067916,
0.6463273764,
0.6970331073,
-0.1701687723,
0.3370666206,
-0.0939463377,
0.3483461738,
-0.3861272633,
0.4829831719,
-0.2058815807,
-0.1970170438,
-0.7161363959,
-0.6613989472,
0.5813489556,
0.3865444064,
-0.5083588958,
0.7205893993,
-0.4488931894,
-0.522421658,
-0.4631872773,
-0.0558039024,
0.0948795527,
0.4060551226,
0.2154078782,
-0.0489619337,
-0.6598570347,
-0.920828104,
-0.1493768543,
-0.1965438426,
-0.3893565238,
-0.0568447225,
0.2458071262,
0.2555036843,
0.9323832393,
-0.478638947,
0.0805954859,
-0.3140553236,
0.2199975401,
0.3586156666,
0.4032286406,
0.3063209057,
-0.8436151743,
-0.2644662261,
-0.3976394236,
-0.2316710353,
-0.446231246,
0.0828892589,
0.2637660503,
-0.0374813825,
0.1774654388,
-0.5368773341,
0.3446062207,
0.8459130526,
-0.195273295,
0.795356214,
-0.3846638203,
-0.0800180212,
-0.8473681808,
-0.1789096892,
-0.3776465952,
-0.4131756425,
-0.8202326894,
0.010474544,
0.3682590723,
-0.076934956,
-0.4942569137,
0.3251001239,
-0.7868034244,
-0.2135167122,
-0.1430343688,
-0.3005937636,
0.1126284525,
0.5962549448,
0.1348618567,
0.9007986188,
0.4690284431,
-0.5589556098,
0.1457461417,
0.0740915835,
-0.6059963107,
-0.2274998724,
-0.7440860868,
0.4069425762,
-0.0886012539,
0.4948910475,
-0.6331525445,
-0.022653535,
0.0162684377,
-0.1174928546,
0.2320106775,
-0.4658457041,
-0.8167421222,
-0.4008743763,
-0.2878245413,
0.3002113402,
0.9969893694,
-0.5898228288,
0.7210238576,
0.0913920477,
-0.2135024667,
-0.5213826895,
-0.4652518928,
0.0843535438,
-0.3461361229,
-0.7953269482,
0.3840838075,
-0.1105565727,
-0.2696804702,
-0.1730231792,
-0.3459384739,
-0.218067646,
0.2896059453,
0.2303972691,
0.1384871751,
-0.0260628369,
0.2083550245,
-0.0296581127,
0.0932691842,
-0.2452719063,
-0.5304648876,
0.6173834801,
0.0370705128,
-0.2823976278,
0.1123468578,
0.3656582832,
0.3945025504,
-0.3107742667,
0.9437881708,
0.5311122537,
-0.0880777538,
-0.5223343968,
-0.673953414,
-0.1258033365,
-0.4717648029,
0.0903842151,
-0.3758793175,
-0.9850309491,
0.3733213246,
-0.3492111862,
0.1946903467,
0.2229644805,
0.6333693862,
0.0870566443,
0.9686071277,
0.6332063079,
0.0136271035,
0.3860875964,
-0.0077773067,
0.6163164377,
-0.8001468182,
-0.1046839729,
-0.7088188529,
-0.2112424523,
-0.1572498679,
-0.6705785394,
0.1686687618,
0.4524274766,
-0.1717184782,
0.3914892972,
-0.7409733534,
0.4285427034,
0.5955207348,
-0.1812079996,
0.3286367655,
-0.0386756286,
-0.0679794848,
0.2439800054,
-1.1070328951,
-0.4173260033,
0.7526959777,
0.2169343382,
0.7421565056,
0.1499910206,
0.7431857586,
0.2451752126,
0.3336798549,
-0.7392767668,
0.6239008307,
0.063101761,
-0.3306212425,
-0.1588369608,
-0.5686638951,
-0.7364532351,
0.4525375366,
0.0333532952,
-0.8170349002,
0.0742102638,
0.2503716648,
-0.381038636,
0.3808024824,
-0.7461674213,
0.4883183539,
-0.2540034056,
-0.3551723957,
-0.0262309946,
-0.6589750648,
0.6423223615,
-0.1605551839,
0.2769049704,
-0.4138726592,
-0.108504951,
0.5980241299,
-0.8710574508,
0.4418475628,
-0.0080332626,
-0.0391358398,
0.1499661952,
0.2395979464,
0.8045342565,
-0.3909371495,
-0.2596626282,
0.3057320416,
-0.0666752681,
-0.3467516899,
-0.9359792471,
0.4174411893,
-0.1593233496,
-0.646458745,
-0.3307361901,
-0.7762740254,
-0.0608269498,
-0.005336911,
0.110260047,
0.6056306362,
0.1561908722,
0.1182417199,
0.4938694239,
-0.259195745,
0.4162538946,
0.5843524933,
-0.1004250497,
-0.1301816255,
0.7402043343,
-0.0134261819,
0.1508133709,
0.351596117,
0.2266188711,
-0.305329442,
-1.0790022612,
-0.0701257139,
0.0806560889,
-0.5478861332,
-0.3714192808,
-0.5184890628,
-0.2641215622,
-0.7187014222,
-0.0324763209,
-0.3539702296,
-0.7119912505,
0.223075673,
-0.0296205077,
0.2858338654,
0.5173552036,
0.0172202438,
0.3144544959,
-0.8860859275,
-0.0540484898,
-0.0302432105,
0.1286891103,
-0.2348591387,
-0.4559472203,
-0.0775842965,
-0.3506445587,
0.1727110147,
-0.6651979089,
0.7569020987,
0.4180218875,
0.3300281465,
0.2189854234,
0.5727317929,
0.867359817,
-0.7981104851,
0.8187098503,
-0.0079637067,
-0.6836827993,
0.3378577828,
0.0471195057,
0.401955843,
0.3700909615,
0.1061419472,
-0.2998517752,
-0.3806995451,
-0.7070678473,
-1.226757288,
0.4095513523,
0.3679329455,
-0.1620547622,
0.0291664507,
0.1351816058,
-0.1058100462,
0.2745286226,
-0.4175460935,
-0.2493881583,
0.1342814714,
-0.2724818289,
0.0879469588,
-0.6482872963,
-0.0932184756,
-0.2999614477,
0.8104010224,
-0.0248718504,
0.1891492307,
0.1628707647,
-0.3753513396,
0.4090474248,
0.3991415799,
0.6802616119,
0.4772149026,
-0.3437685072,
0.3282341063,
-0.0553642064,
-0.3033814132,
0.2177722752,
0.2516030669,
-0.2695851326,
0.1113335341,
0.4533524811,
0.7438223362,
0.2077990621,
-0.8129691482,
0.3233428597,
-0.1423234642,
-0.2986986041,
-0.2387526035,
0.1221106052,
0.0310812704,
0.1900782585,
0.5057935119,
-0.0868385136,
0.2203742564,
-0.1616935581,
0.2255693972,
0.2943966091,
-0.0386176854,
-0.1173359081,
0.560667634,
0.2072512954,
-0.4957568049,
0.7647908926,
-0.2334954143,
-0.8398361802,
0.4788814485,
0.3729727864,
0.9742325544,
-0.1640274674,
-0.0910519883,
0.5066380501,
0.4541826844,
-0.3211075664,
-0.2001013905,
-0.5092632771,
-0.4476802945,
-0.7868739963,
-0.9754206538,
-0.1610389948,
0.02452261,
-0.45315364,
0.0142661296,
-0.2130892873,
0.2127052099,
-0.3941202164,
0.0828959718,
-0.2535916269,
-0.0944564641,
0.1876707524,
1.4669131041,
-0.7151942253,
1.2960343361,
0.1923349947,
-0.0241038892,
-1.1701766253,
-0.0031822857,
0.1767014712,
-0.4375306666,
0.6102496386,
0.1190588698,
-0.0794158429,
0.2756462991,
-0.4714189172,
-0.749233067,
1.0619000196,
0.5547103882,
-0.9299827218,
-0.1554708183,
-0.3962533772,
0.1909017861,
-0.292937547,
0.3040468693,
0.7137436867,
0.5269138217,
0.4960182905,
-0.767706275,
0.0908889398,
-0.4173000157,
0.1147143096,
0.4300562143,
-0.4148806036,
0.8114876151,
-0.1045099273,
-0.3721308708,
0.1904044896,
0.5884878039,
0.2447636724,
-0.0304322094,
0.6284496784,
0.4826648831,
0.9099981785,
-0.355953902,
1.27305758,
-0.3589484692,
0.5373013616,
1.271933198,
-0.4120179117,
0.6965338588,
0.4953744113,
-0.1393766552,
0.3516769409,
0.8530293703,
0.06862057,
0.5057492852,
0.3315702677,
-0.4489776492,
-0.3798587322,
0.1537234485,
-0.1291180998,
0.0907500833,
0.1516566426,
-0.1262062937,
-0.3463741243,
-0.1331184357,
-0.0692680925,
-0.0940415859,
-0.2303469479,
0.6619930267,
-0.0736345723,
-0.5484284163,
0.7405330539,
0.0384195335,
0.6845522523,
-0.9245015979,
0.0568136424,
-0.15512757,
0.0286873542,
-0.192121774,
-0.4026532769,
0.5041176677,
0.0106781749,
0.0275343563,
-0.5445871353,
1.007440567,
-0.6820611358,
-0.4788176715,
-0.0291994289,
0.2542990744,
0.3987780809,
-0.3247656226,
-0.6146253943,
0.387055397,
-0.0478110053,
-0.6471887231,
0.3172572553,
0.1869221181,
-0.0236208607,
0.8471398354,
0.7318600416,
0.323153615,
0.0871312097,
0.201575011,
0.9021434784,
-0.3977228403,
-0.4019530118,
-0.8435665965,
0.6731172204,
-0.314763993,
0.2266745716,
0.7099577188,
0.7058962584,
0.3436531425,
0.0386266224,
0.4247273505,
-0.3399946392,
0.2468643934,
-0.6693474054,
0.5225923061,
-0.5051457882,
0.3898672462,
0.1385765523,
-0.9022408128,
-0.4195905328,
0.5253310204,
-0.3362145424,
-0.2092036158,
0.6970595717,
0.9415898323,
0.0870624855,
-0.1718819737,
0.5365879536,
0.1297111958,
0.3925605714,
0.5231352448,
0.6401101351,
-0.1481125951,
0.6025375128,
-0.4072631299,
-0.058539059,
-0.1971245557,
-1.2355501652,
-0.7002145648,
-0.5319782495,
-0.2799069285,
-0.1644811183,
0.1950836778,
0.9377087951,
1.0084148645,
-0.4422397017,
0.1223472431,
-0.0718346015,
0.3121964633,
-0.6192067862,
-0.2270159274,
0.3648670018,
-0.2454372942,
-0.8241047859,
0.6709735394,
0.4760015011,
-0.2594307959,
-0.2040656656,
0.0293727852,
-0.1852563173,
0.1483281553,
0.6185299754,
0.2117521018,
-0.6418886781,
-0.2195212543,
-0.4429888725,
0.0400916189,
0.0162868295,
1.2376638651,
-0.9611686468,
0.0666365176,
0.6009138227,
0.4509547055,
0.6385415196,
0.3172578812,
0.7395255566,
-1.1156542301,
0.6490732431,
0.4420635402,
0.437212646,
0.3002376854,
-0.3305260241,
0.7431664467,
0.1082118675,
-0.5364832878,
-1.0801138878,
0.2305512726,
-0.8169234395,
-0.4965791702,
1.111782074,
-0.2502208054,
-0.6381893158,
-0.0813250467,
-0.0782368183,
0.0679734647,
-0.2255384475,
0.5193383098,
0.5364614129,
-0.0047625867,
-0.5389781594,
-0.3969025314,
0.4383644462,
0.165214926,
-0.5728168488,
0.3458678126,
0.6304858327,
0.3037226796,
-0.1292017847,
0.5507913828,
0.1980068982,
-0.118595466,
0.0498751476,
0.2879118621,
-0.7958486676,
-0.3100166619,
-0.4313625991,
0.5659404397,
-0.1302200854,
0.0630737394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03675v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03675v2 | Auditing Gender Presentation Differences in Text-to-Image Models | 2023-02-07T18:52:22 | 2023-02-08T01:55:54 | Yanzhe Zhang, Lu Jiang, Greg Turk, Diyi Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Text-to-image models, which can generate high-quality images based on textual
input, have recently enabled various content-creation tools. Despite
significantly affecting a wide range of downstream applications, the
distributions of these generated images are still not fully understood,
especially when it comes to the potential stereotypical attributes of different
genders. In this work, we propose a paradigm (Gender Presentation Differences)
that utilizes fine-grained self-presentation attributes to study how gender is
presented differently in text-to-image models. By probing gender indicators in
the input text (e.g., "a woman" or "a man"), we quantify the frequency
differences of presentation-centric attributes (e.g., "a shirt" and "a dress")
through human annotation and introduce a novel metric: GEP. Furthermore, we
propose an automatic method to estimate such differences. The automatic GEP
metric based on our approach yields a higher correlation with human annotations
than that based on existing CLIP scores, consistently across three
state-of-the-art text-to-image models. Finally, we demonstrate the
generalization ability of our metrics in the context of gender stereotypes
related to occupations. | [
-0.5246014595,
-0.446564734,
0.4437180758,
0.2773626149,
-0.0499335006,
-0.2139217556,
0.0626169145,
-0.8249288201,
0.0823803693,
0.1859017313,
-0.400400877,
-0.7305127978,
-0.7803688049,
0.5014207959,
-0.7382597923,
0.6860689521,
0.1916917562,
-0.0906218365,
-0.5466216207,
0.0417609885,
-0.8509149551,
-0.3363776207,
-0.3048801422,
-0.2789966762,
-0.0311545152,
0.1747163683,
0.7761042714,
0.8229483962,
0.6010162234,
0.2335405648,
0.0176449027,
0.149175778,
0.1340200454,
-0.1306420416,
-0.4280967116,
-0.2859739959,
-0.5570084453,
0.371527344,
0.491861701,
0.4480717778,
0.1130576506,
0.5239315033,
0.3484219015,
0.6660612822,
-0.7649419904,
0.3356902301,
-0.3632378578,
0.2619219422,
-0.1905025393,
-0.206720531,
-0.3062971532,
0.0672744811,
0.3235217631,
-0.4341793358,
0.5641654134,
0.1528664827,
1.1147330999,
-0.2505658865,
-0.5224266648,
-0.3164711893,
-0.7342243791,
0.6152306199,
-0.4863313735,
0.4251889586,
0.3991163373,
0.2458231151,
0.4653275609,
-0.3925062716,
-0.2104359418,
-0.0558575653,
-0.4520631135,
-0.0429077521,
-0.4126686156,
-0.2472958118,
-0.0658901036,
0.3453059793,
-0.4980897903,
0.0433992557,
-0.240871489,
-0.212279126,
0.9164241552,
0.0321895182,
0.5798556805,
-0.5216983557,
-0.3921419382,
-0.2107474059,
-0.3338543773,
-0.197329402,
0.4713126123,
0.1101792604,
-0.2747599483,
0.3697219193,
-0.1002199873,
0.3054088652,
0.2721539438,
-0.1065118983,
0.207918644,
-0.0244463962,
-0.3164100051,
-0.0484740064,
0.8982715011,
0.8049662113,
0.1070130169,
0.0620993339,
-0.1478504837,
-0.0789437294,
0.1995784938,
-0.7641685605,
-0.3361415565,
-0.3973110318,
-0.7854191661,
-0.4845315218,
0.0303483233,
-0.9219440818,
-0.4142987132,
-0.2998995483,
0.7093798518,
-0.3141428232,
-0.1575999111,
-0.1317027807,
-0.4824335873,
0.0283875857,
0.4338160455,
-1.2179782391,
0.3153781891,
0.5519624949,
0.9701203108,
-0.1354444325,
-0.0202249717,
-0.059652999,
0.157971859,
-0.5506764054,
0.795327425,
-0.5206711888,
-0.4788539112,
-0.1198248789,
-0.0807121098,
0.0922769234,
-0.4417998791,
0.2800537646,
-0.0636588931,
0.5124166608,
-0.2826707661,
-0.4620833099,
0.0274401605,
0.0957244486,
-0.4646902978,
1.0177549124,
-0.0729731321,
-0.8634678125,
0.5119937062,
-0.745639205,
-0.1620186418,
-0.0405801237,
-0.7927675843,
-0.4606653452,
0.1618938893,
0.6179623008,
0.5774106383,
-0.4640229642,
0.3182497025,
-0.1347560883,
-0.0548029281,
0.167614162,
-0.3567633033,
0.2720122039,
0.0840634331,
-0.0289547089,
-0.0031671224,
-0.6274817586,
-0.3735297918,
0.3229630888,
0.3105818629,
-0.6025044322,
0.0357364826,
0.0093118884,
0.236948207,
0.3313712478,
-0.280092299,
0.078163892,
0.1217460409,
0.2584066987,
0.8073114753,
-0.1550792605,
0.5893482566,
-0.2988608479,
0.3287011385,
-0.0897902474,
0.2266665548,
-0.3416992128,
-0.7223109603,
-0.3536329269,
-0.4405246079,
0.3043706119,
0.4940859973,
-0.2375912815,
0.4237605333,
-0.1752019674,
-0.5329823494,
-0.3566655219,
-0.0501134172,
0.496876955,
0.6561691761,
0.3488301933,
-0.8082401156,
-0.1215347052,
-1.4518141747,
-0.6015484929,
-0.3794229031,
-0.544634521,
0.4124042988,
0.6488895416,
0.0730457678,
1.1070127487,
-0.8817532659,
-0.571429193,
-0.0128964093,
0.9548972845,
-0.0696960017,
0.7025918365,
0.837906599,
-0.6399157047,
-0.1853292584,
-0.2876650095,
-0.7538434863,
-0.3460149765,
-0.1808435321,
-0.1872453243,
0.1231885254,
0.3173162937,
-0.1082261577,
0.664254725,
0.6034204364,
-0.5102547407,
0.8324419856,
-0.4208354354,
0.4369319975,
-0.6484392285,
0.0215294119,
0.6492032409,
-0.4149160981,
-0.4372413456,
-0.1050137132,
0.2043828368,
-0.2852360904,
-0.1497329473,
0.553327024,
-0.5488559604,
-0.5520426035,
-0.0015816853,
-0.1519854963,
0.3817161322,
0.2816435695,
0.2888423204,
0.7561129928,
0.2987834811,
-0.4430257976,
-0.2786580324,
0.5224426985,
-0.2022587955,
1.0258356333,
-0.5837899446,
0.3668445945,
-0.3311954439,
0.1624043286,
-1.0806537867,
-0.3931875825,
0.1220881492,
-0.4637762606,
0.5407562256,
-0.4116395116,
-0.3484514058,
-0.08279787,
-0.5466611385,
0.3313660026,
0.5272646546,
-0.3426195979,
0.5672639012,
0.2685008645,
-0.2255478948,
-0.3494403958,
-0.7697829604,
0.268386513,
-0.1720613688,
-0.8505131006,
0.5602097511,
0.1999735534,
-0.0183458887,
-0.2338637114,
-0.0654856563,
-0.3108102679,
0.151190117,
0.2501258552,
0.5891265869,
-0.0266808476,
0.4306658506,
0.1126179993,
0.0061059543,
0.0520160943,
0.0802484229,
0.3621802628,
-0.2427382469,
-0.4401874244,
-0.7440821528,
0.6274020076,
-0.0442074202,
-0.2120369822,
0.5106432438,
0.7902669907,
-0.3609225452,
0.2215570062,
-0.3674166799,
-0.1283962429,
-0.4338961244,
0.5056817532,
-0.2907811999,
-0.5581048131,
0.5370295644,
0.1067493409,
0.127361387,
0.8935530782,
0.1121866927,
-0.5121327043,
1.3045626879,
0.9246110916,
0.3393594921,
0.5352503657,
-0.0040848474,
-0.1258724332,
-0.8026268482,
-0.0830277726,
-0.6762658954,
-0.3372550607,
-0.7012926936,
-0.3808991611,
0.6015828848,
-0.0620386414,
-0.4803721309,
0.1139927953,
-0.6914349198,
0.3209434152,
0.5704703331,
0.0648566112,
0.4148334861,
-0.058690425,
0.3500918746,
-0.4040038288,
-0.2864902914,
-0.8350713849,
1.0132776499,
0.7014684081,
0.6328687668,
-0.0516876243,
0.7702689171,
0.7852995396,
0.5928618908,
-0.4200640619,
0.5725637078,
-0.6902973056,
-0.7504295707,
-0.1753969789,
-0.2764721215,
-0.5074432492,
0.2494401932,
-0.4853614569,
-1.1602636576,
0.5253037214,
0.5673094988,
0.1602538079,
0.2350369543,
-0.772854805,
0.9077715874,
-0.1121336073,
-0.1671989411,
0.1013554707,
-0.5782360435,
0.3745130002,
0.080684267,
0.297057569,
-0.4670408964,
-0.0235074684,
0.8588039875,
-0.071299836,
0.844856143,
-0.0206244532,
-0.1845965385,
-0.1797761917,
0.4215864241,
0.1364788264,
-0.131615594,
0.0820341632,
0.7440444231,
-0.0309051815,
-0.0383707732,
-0.4564785659,
0.1303828806,
-0.8209108114,
-0.5758323669,
-0.2745858729,
-0.4348948002,
-0.0691261664,
-0.1141050756,
0.4052677751,
0.761631906,
-0.468528688,
-0.2364026904,
0.2308592349,
-0.5746693015,
0.2177379727,
0.0739467889,
-0.3961099684,
-0.22497572,
0.7477440238,
0.1649223864,
0.4791295528,
0.3333828151,
0.4508659244,
-0.4329001904,
-0.1131282002,
-0.5897636414,
0.1605168283,
-0.9343940616,
-0.0111307446,
-0.4617012143,
-0.0401192047,
-0.6021693349,
-0.2735975385,
-0.4230186343,
-0.4388720095,
-0.4017626047,
0.3440522254,
0.0745683759,
0.670994401,
-0.067603752,
0.1737783402,
-0.5930011868,
0.4512521923,
0.6525199413,
0.2818284929,
-0.0157023557,
-0.6163533926,
0.1355709285,
-0.0975467414,
-0.6509893537,
-1.0369338989,
0.7704588771,
0.4529387951,
0.0639798343,
0.5664702058,
-0.0988349169,
0.5215587616,
-0.3554545939,
0.9280390143,
0.547991097,
-1.359213233,
0.736308217,
-0.4211645722,
0.0809997097,
0.1177184209,
0.2630606592,
-0.7403043509,
-0.3885126412,
-0.4930998683,
-0.7453356385,
0.5142772198,
0.5468591452,
0.0743571892,
0.0101554813,
0.2411203682,
0.2036426067,
0.2818775177,
-0.6182977557,
-0.3929005265,
-0.4123378396,
-0.330950439,
0.1308540404,
-0.2553688288,
-0.2438009083,
-0.2135496438,
0.4454520941,
-0.3892608583,
0.6658453941,
0.4777980149,
-0.1981880218,
0.2571561933,
0.6618298292,
0.3642577231,
0.6813187599,
-0.465506047,
0.1723786145,
0.0265159532,
-0.4670369923,
0.1344760209,
-0.0607470982,
-0.3063685596,
0.2816731036,
0.4393098652,
0.6968712211,
-0.0149078975,
-0.1386658996,
0.6232121587,
-0.1849020123,
-0.3156439364,
-0.106486015,
-0.0593645275,
-0.0490726009,
0.1093815863,
0.5803140402,
0.0765779391,
0.4254322052,
-0.6907023787,
-0.0876713246,
0.3099984229,
-0.4248341918,
-0.3617197275,
0.8053112626,
0.5072701573,
-0.3279347718,
0.3496596813,
-0.2694646716,
-0.278642863,
0.8338768482,
0.5479491949,
1.1802734137,
-0.056306161,
0.4680505991,
0.2684736848,
0.2754424512,
-0.0718712136,
-0.1525768042,
0.035723839,
-0.6442496181,
0.1313565373,
-0.390550077,
-0.3418953717,
-0.0462151244,
-0.8487789631,
0.3827396929,
-0.2886244357,
-0.4045152664,
0.5466365814,
-0.3887518346,
-0.9031587839,
0.3960241079,
0.6105560064,
0.6363748312,
-1.2473590374,
0.0639408529,
0.6801823974,
-0.3243654072,
-0.4994206429,
0.077202864,
0.3003085554,
-0.5938260555,
0.8023165464,
0.5014167428,
-0.074377194,
-0.3115900457,
-0.527997911,
-0.4936511815,
1.1103972197,
0.4430701435,
-0.6339555383,
-0.3027317226,
0.300526768,
0.4833545685,
-0.682012558,
0.4485659301,
0.3799273074,
0.2741903663,
-0.2826357484,
-1.0517522097,
-0.0839501545,
-0.1201081499,
0.4947196543,
0.1829852015,
-0.2629286945,
0.9481993318,
0.0052042315,
-0.4081581533,
-0.0835011229,
0.7046247721,
0.0338305607,
0.6362118721,
0.7596628666,
0.0632893518,
0.5844732523,
-0.024867611,
0.906789422,
-0.0096861515,
0.601337254,
1.194234252,
0.0203937069,
0.6091067195,
0.1507747173,
-0.1602479219,
0.417745769,
0.3193330169,
-0.3036995828,
0.1006176025,
-0.04862139,
0.1313332468,
-0.5039218664,
-0.260843128,
-0.2993156016,
0.8392920494,
0.1627146155,
-0.8480474949,
-0.3138802946,
-0.1881595105,
-0.0534052439,
0.1017043963,
-0.2428228855,
0.6145500541,
-0.0042145634,
-0.1942639798,
0.1235742643,
0.0970282555,
0.8043688536,
-0.3891303837,
-0.1737188995,
0.0337141864,
-0.2120203823,
-0.2950106859,
-1.0627539158,
0.2319315821,
0.2369458079,
-0.3408849537,
-0.2457927018,
1.0481148958,
-0.3285929561,
-0.6102907062,
-0.0066749402,
0.4319223166,
0.1249236912,
-0.131195426,
-0.6410502195,
-0.3672751784,
-0.3075620234,
0.1568787545,
0.4540840387,
0.1216467842,
-0.4037051499,
0.6130591631,
0.2463621795,
-0.2570554316,
-0.3553410172,
0.1954754144,
0.2561586797,
-0.5073839426,
-0.7851262093,
-0.9035176039,
0.310660243,
-0.3087560534,
-0.4732056856,
0.4249594212,
0.3330653906,
0.6110046506,
-0.2848217189,
0.5686926246,
-0.05787744,
0.2513976991,
-0.2596580684,
0.836345911,
-0.7348505855,
0.1741238534,
-0.908862412,
-0.5667275786,
-0.0333205499,
0.5256108642,
-0.2911318243,
-0.1374813914,
0.2989500165,
0.5709556937,
-0.0309765656,
0.0341595039,
0.2045497596,
-0.2114257216,
0.5320051908,
0.1289697438,
0.8052456379,
-0.4341064394,
0.2067051679,
-0.2532810271,
-0.0891731381,
-0.2439817637,
-1.3761372566,
-0.6392487288,
-0.7858150005,
-0.7766244411,
-0.0125587806,
0.049106691,
0.8939470053,
0.8651877046,
-0.2220255136,
-0.24017331,
0.322125107,
-0.0958053544,
-0.2710240483,
-0.2215069085,
0.4463743865,
0.0823420882,
-0.5618495941,
-0.4373061657,
0.4262204468,
0.2038898617,
-0.3755880594,
0.2550447285,
0.1037572324,
0.2572854161,
0.4467338324,
0.03828118,
-0.3236119747,
-0.660579145,
-0.402951777,
-0.0556289628,
0.4663936198,
0.5639625788,
-0.3051648438,
0.4985663593,
0.4595303237,
0.1713058501,
0.3120797873,
0.1961156577,
0.7730468512,
-1.2907531261,
-0.0959166288,
0.031493865,
0.2738366723,
0.5122612119,
-0.5228794217,
0.438274771,
0.4532719254,
-0.3529137969,
-0.6253532171,
0.1939429194,
-0.9162487984,
-0.2575541437,
0.8281520009,
-0.1248316616,
-0.1314064711,
0.1102909371,
-0.1399721056,
0.1181092709,
-0.5558928251,
0.9956618547,
0.6863052249,
-0.1585298777,
-0.1344114691,
-0.544051528,
0.4765110612,
0.0922282189,
-1.070962429,
0.0011249499,
0.5371559858,
0.5932363868,
0.3465544283,
0.6690312624,
-0.2972498238,
0.323646605,
-0.247747615,
0.4026818871,
-0.0075410251,
-0.2666245103,
-0.1718202978,
0.0592677779,
-0.1811549962,
-0.4495772123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03668v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03668v2 | Hard Prompts Made Easy: Gradient-Based Discrete Optimization for Prompt Tuning and Discovery | 2023-02-07T18:40:18 | 2023-06-01T12:26:45 | Yuxin Wen, Neel Jain, John Kirchenbauer, Micah Goldblum, Jonas Geiping, Tom Goldstein | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The strength of modern generative models lies in their ability to be
controlled through text-based prompts. Typical "hard" prompts are made from
interpretable words and tokens, and must be hand-crafted by humans. There are
also "soft" prompts, which consist of continuous feature vectors. These can be
discovered using powerful optimization methods, but they cannot be easily
interpreted, re-used across models, or plugged into a text-based interface.
We describe an approach to robustly optimize hard text prompts through
efficient gradient-based optimization. Our approach automatically generates
hard text-based prompts for both text-to-image and text-to-text applications.
In the text-to-image setting, the method creates hard prompts for diffusion
models, allowing API users to easily generate, discover, and mix and match
image concepts without prior knowledge on how to prompt the model. In the
text-to-text setting, we show that hard prompts can be automatically discovered
that are effective in tuning LMs for classification. | [
-0.4466758668,
-0.8424156308,
0.8971743584,
0.3970542252,
-0.2825858891,
-0.1282991022,
-0.4151516557,
0.148918733,
-0.2415276468,
0.1419414282,
-1.065649271,
-0.7188624144,
-0.1514705718,
0.327816695,
-0.0264573712,
1.1380157471,
-0.0552175604,
-0.0916141123,
-0.4301813841,
-0.0287199561,
-0.5231873989,
-0.2716189623,
-0.7646626234,
-0.2341094166,
0.8653525114,
0.1375138164,
0.5350832343,
0.8108443022,
0.4401473105,
0.2227306217,
-0.4798202515,
0.351074934,
-0.409866631,
0.4945923984,
-0.3083359301,
-0.2687698007,
-0.0907193571,
-0.2999912798,
0.273625344,
0.7876631618,
-0.2114972025,
-0.1616098732,
0.3142757416,
0.8191534877,
-0.7631429434,
0.0000988749,
-0.3536593914,
0.3785731196,
-0.1978405118,
-0.4355073869,
-0.323082298,
-0.5537698865,
0.0345452204,
-0.954649806,
0.6350964904,
-0.099276334,
0.5039432049,
0.4877418578,
-0.1840111464,
-0.5549567938,
-0.7538747191,
0.8791848421,
-0.0984910578,
0.0828342959,
0.1389190406,
0.3137004972,
-0.3413777053,
-0.8938874602,
-0.4403782785,
-0.1602195352,
0.0557326004,
-0.0142631307,
-0.2232393324,
0.3734888136,
0.4408292472,
0.1729551852,
-0.4612903595,
0.1617702544,
-0.0114010638,
-0.3590745628,
0.3349493742,
0.5268954039,
0.3257219195,
-0.177207306,
-0.3301869631,
-0.2087174058,
-0.7090936303,
0.1430099159,
0.1858066618,
0.5296379924,
-0.2530812621,
0.445469439,
-0.0196504146,
0.7591716051,
0.1699569374,
0.0145730004,
0.1206331998,
-0.3148914874,
0.0852525756,
-0.2735088468,
0.7917864323,
0.3692101836,
0.2106130868,
-0.0379518494,
-0.574023962,
0.1407832056,
0.0513140261,
-0.872520566,
-0.2541277409,
0.186123848,
-0.6542289257,
-0.45574525,
-0.4532912076,
-1.0085711479,
-0.8708558083,
-0.3819054663,
0.2979581654,
-0.1834053546,
-0.0254575945,
0.1045760214,
-0.4204414189,
-0.0501099378,
0.6329432726,
-1.0432066917,
-0.0468795374,
0.6946601272,
1.0703526735,
-0.2930495143,
0.0752169341,
-0.6682714224,
-0.2253774107,
-0.4158049226,
0.743409574,
-0.4789857566,
-0.7852913141,
0.3686808944,
-0.1385796964,
0.1745735705,
-0.4407688379,
0.9789847136,
-0.3268222213,
0.3184292614,
-0.2076786608,
-0.4446048141,
0.1730673611,
-0.0368450359,
-0.6575449109,
1.0490832329,
0.1793432385,
-0.5333819389,
0.1121920571,
-0.8784092069,
-0.3893587291,
0.2638644278,
-0.3600130975,
-0.4121467471,
0.3183797002,
0.2555858493,
0.6784153581,
-0.4370791912,
0.2326588184,
-0.1249846444,
-0.3144592345,
0.1530619264,
-0.5610966682,
0.6928632259,
0.3350252211,
-0.4648548663,
0.2766917348,
-0.7290714979,
-0.0472953059,
0.0282157082,
-0.3924367428,
-0.3346225619,
0.182400167,
0.0571465343,
-0.2108131647,
0.1937399954,
-0.2407088727,
0.4779864252,
-0.1679168791,
0.5246682763,
1.0028787851,
-0.0585555695,
0.6364899278,
-0.1597418189,
0.6875301003,
-0.015391767,
0.2532958984,
-0.5928446651,
-0.5917950869,
-0.6211465597,
-0.470469892,
0.2798815668,
0.7311372161,
-1.0715174675,
0.2645866573,
0.0338106677,
-0.4394983947,
-0.4535755813,
0.37428388,
0.1627356708,
0.9102583528,
0.2237468064,
-0.041253183,
0.0049963943,
-0.9353232384,
-0.0691161305,
0.3060121834,
-0.3141218424,
0.6580660343,
0.341935128,
-0.2745336294,
0.8171824813,
-1.0447033644,
-0.1624473035,
0.091512531,
0.4242852926,
0.4849620759,
0.4944798648,
0.5234872699,
-0.9091706872,
-0.4612407684,
-0.1386681646,
-0.8348529935,
-0.2788294554,
-0.2764001787,
-0.2041466534,
-0.0168889146,
0.7815999389,
-0.8073197603,
0.2768332958,
0.0439580269,
-0.2780583501,
0.4416041076,
-0.264913708,
-0.1156197414,
-0.666918695,
0.0529133156,
0.5412184596,
-0.1597496867,
-0.5053752661,
0.1346971691,
0.2410171479,
-0.4296227694,
-0.495904386,
0.7101294994,
-0.4510025084,
0.4559071064,
-0.0807817504,
-0.1583516002,
0.0478950217,
0.7170792818,
0.0960807279,
0.9314833283,
0.9939603209,
-0.8547508717,
0.425116241,
0.0586935356,
-0.4882897437,
0.9302195907,
-0.8239063025,
0.3503164351,
-0.6558127999,
0.2646677494,
-1.0283806324,
-0.1794583946,
0.4782477617,
-0.0113798482,
0.2695019245,
-0.3124831617,
-0.246814698,
-0.2892870307,
-0.5265411139,
0.626537323,
0.6163465381,
-0.7504938841,
0.6817355752,
-0.242935434,
-0.3344843686,
-0.3847948313,
-0.193490386,
-0.0319359191,
-0.4068111777,
-0.4943417609,
0.5180162787,
-0.4808847606,
-0.0144259902,
-0.1845879853,
0.4484327435,
0.0737320036,
0.2527819276,
0.3491376936,
0.1199383885,
-0.1294606626,
0.3522621095,
0.279039979,
-0.2636784315,
-0.1908947825,
-0.325768292,
0.482717216,
0.072611019,
-0.0859770775,
-0.5910098553,
0.5524303317,
0.4669319093,
-0.0390137881,
0.3601746261,
0.6737760305,
-0.4989742339,
-0.5238812566,
-0.0543753244,
-0.2763055563,
-0.6643888354,
0.124757193,
-0.4494688213,
-0.6787498593,
0.3474474549,
-0.5036894083,
0.0390251353,
0.3182286322,
0.6286607385,
-0.3597526252,
1.5120431185,
0.552677691,
0.3564276397,
0.7262881994,
-0.2025179714,
-0.3504390121,
-0.6063086987,
-0.2896345854,
-0.6923489571,
-0.4118252397,
-0.562930584,
-0.4681542218,
0.7167455554,
0.0245086867,
-0.4213352799,
-0.3172743022,
-1.0379753113,
0.700560987,
0.7999594212,
0.3393519223,
-0.0099695986,
0.3032637835,
-0.0999290496,
-0.1745152324,
-0.6728452444,
-0.3481253386,
0.8689870238,
0.2722837627,
1.0238540173,
-0.0899868309,
0.6248371601,
0.5844221711,
0.162452355,
-1.0614033937,
0.5486126542,
-0.2985509038,
-0.2529959083,
-0.1188343987,
-0.5333968997,
-1.0889918804,
-0.1683530211,
-0.4113708138,
-0.3035594821,
0.4352045357,
0.2413213998,
-0.5877612829,
-0.0329383463,
-0.8640473485,
0.6618949175,
-0.1325165629,
-0.3840361536,
0.1314945519,
-0.3553360105,
0.0532219075,
0.0889671892,
0.1907805353,
0.0367869437,
-0.3315958679,
0.5967097878,
-0.4741382003,
0.9542312622,
-0.4181238711,
-0.3234419227,
0.3161300123,
0.1290124655,
0.6330488324,
-0.1421349645,
-0.081547983,
-0.1521447301,
-0.4507699609,
-0.3770368695,
-0.9604561329,
0.6650423408,
-0.702729404,
-0.4712828696,
-0.1508331746,
-0.085954085,
0.0921330303,
0.0293436907,
0.6271045208,
0.7515105605,
-0.0565803871,
0.0025871457,
1.0398814678,
-0.3530448377,
0.6249635816,
0.095144622,
0.0403435007,
-0.3988327086,
1.1345592737,
-0.3292341232,
-0.1575079113,
0.299054563,
0.4174665809,
-0.4635803699,
-0.7138483524,
-0.8461347222,
-0.0380226523,
-0.7116458416,
-0.4521387815,
-0.3747025132,
0.1248731911,
0.1914335191,
-0.4379112124,
0.0263681617,
-0.4022994339,
-1.0427886248,
-0.0180779677,
0.6271443963,
0.5049898624,
-0.1577285528,
0.584408164,
-0.6364352107,
0.4014737308,
0.5005489588,
0.4946846068,
-0.0270811357,
-0.080949977,
-0.0513771996,
-0.1081329808,
-0.3552809358,
-0.8654906154,
0.1436370909,
0.3820388615,
0.2010546923,
0.4965608716,
-0.0911661536,
0.1342370659,
-0.7120662928,
0.8606470227,
0.5813549757,
-0.8987152576,
0.8875837922,
-0.6920143366,
0.0596618317,
0.5415152311,
0.5381603837,
-0.3879264891,
0.1714921147,
-0.151589334,
-0.9105080962,
0.5513272882,
0.0697125718,
0.6055611968,
-0.0436090231,
0.8540351391,
0.2829396725,
0.2748186886,
-0.598677218,
-0.4951447546,
-0.2502831519,
-0.6630874872,
0.108699508,
-0.2426442802,
-0.5168653727,
-0.2360502928,
0.263110131,
-0.3655960858,
0.2128233761,
0.1133152694,
0.0981602669,
-0.1548221409,
0.108955875,
0.6983028054,
0.3251320124,
-0.0158435106,
0.1298722625,
-0.2093353719,
-0.3946020901,
0.3942263424,
0.1565757245,
-0.6354017854,
0.1122665405,
0.1050585955,
1.2229146957,
-0.1610521227,
-0.6049671769,
0.5302420259,
-0.2557674944,
-0.2638203502,
-0.0328376181,
0.422329247,
-0.2421232462,
0.2400646806,
0.5883589387,
0.0141138611,
0.2413925231,
-0.2794067264,
-0.0665241405,
0.5002486706,
-0.3934009075,
-0.136992082,
0.8113529086,
0.7392480969,
-0.7805649042,
0.5261184573,
-0.3671081364,
-0.3973633647,
0.6504554749,
0.2832478583,
0.9723536968,
-0.0436818935,
0.4877575934,
0.244329229,
-0.1237722114,
-0.1356053948,
0.2685976624,
-0.1349625885,
-0.5500959754,
-0.1837283224,
-0.4506862164,
-0.4294540286,
0.0704035908,
-0.5159457922,
0.5536747575,
-0.7570688128,
-0.4096496105,
0.358667016,
-0.1730277687,
-0.920907259,
0.3562067747,
0.0389115661,
0.8802024722,
-0.7153098583,
-0.0387209654,
0.6559280157,
-0.2042867541,
-0.3810905516,
-0.351090312,
-0.0452598706,
-0.8422638178,
0.4325515628,
0.0576424338,
0.0917944014,
0.2139396667,
-0.9772070646,
-0.3110516071,
0.9653067589,
0.2824900448,
-0.6984490752,
-0.0229868777,
-0.1634178162,
0.5396105647,
-0.1870951205,
0.3125921488,
0.1028776318,
0.4339333773,
0.1309193969,
-0.4780563116,
0.2534862757,
-0.2070559114,
0.124295637,
0.2812335491,
-0.3991305232,
0.9054909945,
-0.2488379329,
-0.4679424763,
0.1530876458,
0.6997454166,
0.1830351651,
0.6566975117,
0.6747457385,
0.3820781708,
1.0435253382,
-0.1545746177,
1.1725614071,
-0.0693457201,
0.2844023108,
0.6576876044,
-0.0199292414,
0.3603589833,
0.382126987,
-0.1227195933,
0.8280580044,
0.9878793955,
-0.1301461607,
0.9601327777,
0.4769437611,
-0.7642639279,
-0.3233646452,
-0.3734086454,
-0.3454507589,
-0.1069386452,
0.5340731144,
-0.4184474349,
-0.244265601,
0.2044651806,
-0.1727515161,
0.0496447608,
-0.5743598342,
0.7812978625,
0.1528896093,
-0.6370790005,
0.6618148685,
0.2010474354,
1.100907445,
-0.4236338139,
-0.0715308934,
-0.3320151269,
-0.2041478455,
-0.1922384799,
-0.8664108515,
-0.2285661399,
0.2596556544,
-0.436537236,
-0.4213919938,
0.9106592536,
-0.2511011958,
-0.5081313848,
-0.2631261349,
0.6404205561,
-0.0013820033,
-0.1202397123,
-0.7518176436,
-0.0218438879,
0.0138426097,
-0.3037062883,
0.0830733925,
0.6707040071,
-0.0996144637,
0.7948406339,
0.807489872,
-0.0657985955,
-0.3891237378,
0.2460851669,
0.9289352298,
-0.8649531603,
-0.4091887176,
-1.0441993475,
0.6022031307,
0.0358529985,
-0.3627423346,
0.1054512039,
0.3012011051,
0.0715260655,
-0.2602013052,
0.9411743283,
0.2848150432,
0.3209199905,
-0.7383576632,
0.5867059827,
-0.7022640705,
0.1280606389,
-0.1957559288,
-0.9560809135,
-0.2240225524,
0.6346047521,
0.0905189663,
0.1734726727,
0.3932397366,
1.0235654116,
-0.1419107765,
-0.1410053223,
-0.2068622559,
-0.2555033565,
0.3110603392,
0.4558000267,
1.0268703699,
0.2102136761,
0.5669902563,
-0.077512756,
-0.5151587725,
-0.2957639992,
-1.4088139534,
-0.9124688506,
-0.706895113,
-0.4616457224,
-0.4719235003,
-0.0812250525,
0.9169366956,
0.588411808,
-0.4382379353,
0.2273682505,
-0.456374079,
0.4809438884,
0.0994999409,
-0.2857891917,
0.5672974586,
-0.2801657021,
-0.8229604363,
0.3588809967,
0.1815535277,
0.5838606358,
-0.3880421817,
-0.0334549434,
0.6134343743,
0.1683072001,
0.573379457,
0.4667941034,
-0.2272224128,
-0.0276702773,
0.193287164,
-0.3528323472,
0.0074639674,
1.0435740948,
-0.8249690533,
0.35981673,
0.5462893844,
0.5335549712,
0.4370979965,
-0.0052544754,
0.7583042383,
-1.1106338501,
0.1140781939,
0.3180405796,
0.1547297239,
0.6074134707,
-0.470518291,
0.4449594319,
0.3584272265,
-0.2328959703,
-1.014205575,
0.2514773011,
-1.015781641,
-0.4127405882,
1.2667694092,
0.1222824901,
-0.1845748872,
-0.0133702839,
-0.5201652646,
-0.0128906555,
-0.5057452917,
0.8622733951,
0.5807137489,
-0.1872530878,
-0.0966813341,
-0.282082051,
1.1649501324,
0.5072071552,
-0.764598608,
-0.1421974748,
0.6516906023,
0.0276811663,
0.2472093403,
0.6841543913,
0.4383462369,
0.3378451169,
-0.3832479417,
-0.2026243806,
-0.1344956607,
-0.3820872009,
-0.524857223,
0.1166323125,
-0.0818229839,
-0.1791484803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03645v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03645v2 | Exploitation and exploration in text evolution. Quantifying planning and translation flows during writing | 2023-02-07T17:52:33 | 2023-02-08T11:25:23 | Donald Ruggiero Lo Sardo, Pietro Gravino, Christine Cuskley, Vittorio Loreto | cs.CL | cs.CL | Writing is a complex process at the center of much of modern human activity.
Despite it appears to be a linear process, writing conceals many highly
non-linear processes. Previous research has focused on three phases of writing:
planning, translation and transcription, and revision. While research has shown
these are non-linear, they are often treated linearly when measured. Here, we
introduce measures to detect and quantify subcycles of planning (exploration)
and translation (exploitation) during the writing process. We apply these to a
novel dataset that recorded the creation of a text in all its phases, from
early attempts to the finishing touches on a final version. This dataset comes
from a series of writing workshops in which, through innovative versioning
software, we were able to record all the steps in the construction of a text.
More than 60 junior researchers in science wrote a scientific essay intended
for a general readership. We recorded each essay as a writing cloud, defined as
a complex topological structure capturing the history of the essay itself.
Through this unique dataset of writing clouds, we expose a representation of
the writing process that quantifies its complexity and the writer's efforts
throughout the draft and through time. Interestingly, this representation
highlights the phases of "translation flow", where authors improve existing
ideas, and exploration, where creative deviations appear as the writer returns
to the planning phase. These turning points between translation and exploration
become rarer as the writing process progresses and the author approaches the
final version. Our results and the new measures introduced have the potential
to foster the discussion about the non-linear nature of writing and support the
development of tools that can support more creative and impactful writing
processes. | [
-0.1102216318,
-0.681736052,
0.7907341123,
0.3101778626,
-0.0873243138,
0.2243467271,
-0.12938416,
-0.3522450328,
0.5965501666,
0.759326458,
-0.8507314324,
-0.5733631849,
-0.5631433129,
0.1710089445,
-0.8514347672,
1.3308593035,
-0.6956275702,
-0.4307582378,
-0.4380509257,
-0.160537526,
-0.3050611913,
-0.2583133578,
-0.3108445704,
-0.2317034602,
0.7550448775,
0.1728796512,
0.3523153961,
0.6748021245,
0.4631123543,
0.2877942622,
-0.0196027234,
0.1315790266,
-0.7108801603,
0.4088267386,
-0.0579237789,
-0.5748010278,
-0.2704582512,
0.0760521069,
0.765615046,
0.8017478585,
0.1460867226,
0.059018217,
0.0551311262,
0.6482163668,
-0.5062605143,
-0.1844641715,
-0.2192095369,
0.3015304804,
-0.4650877118,
-0.6506906152,
-0.3081808388,
-0.3724316657,
0.1508997083,
-0.9259557128,
0.4407888055,
-0.0283945873,
0.3466879427,
0.0493025854,
-0.2615336478,
-0.8852533102,
-0.9474468827,
0.811042428,
-0.3598343134,
-0.3074808717,
0.1307350993,
0.0781702697,
-0.374197036,
-1.1124594212,
-0.5850070715,
0.1075799167,
0.0361029916,
0.0676020235,
-0.131684646,
-0.0662076026,
0.1596543342,
0.3448574543,
-0.386148721,
-0.1062871441,
-0.5487260818,
-0.2645067871,
0.7632846236,
0.3891765475,
0.5626730323,
-0.0052141468,
-0.182601884,
-0.2889521122,
-0.4919422269,
0.30661273,
0.5414416194,
0.1064529121,
0.0656135827,
0.8755511642,
0.1758637875,
0.2555120885,
-0.3974482715,
-0.1060184389,
0.1375280321,
-0.6044384837,
-0.1072955802,
-0.1810463816,
0.8097525835,
0.3465801179,
0.0949941203,
-0.0784623325,
-0.4316292107,
-0.1012144312,
0.6136906743,
-0.4903938472,
-0.1238280088,
-0.0112260608,
-0.2954706848,
-0.6786102653,
-0.0681147203,
-0.8240799308,
-0.7380315065,
0.0198068004,
0.349778682,
-0.3612675071,
-0.1428845972,
0.1695712358,
-0.3676879406,
0.1139345989,
0.3507877588,
-0.7724524736,
0.4330663383,
0.6771800518,
1.1164802313,
-0.1515915245,
-0.615211606,
-0.0693272725,
0.029948432,
-0.667016387,
0.9351465106,
-0.401534915,
-0.5982012153,
0.0703654289,
-0.1440510452,
-0.0228545759,
-0.192645967,
0.8573558331,
-0.1963881403,
0.2708289623,
-0.2030092031,
-0.5883831978,
-0.2827147543,
-0.0337756947,
-0.6295719147,
1.0967091322,
0.1641869545,
-0.5298377275,
0.5760570168,
-0.7380852699,
-0.3271801472,
0.0922551379,
-0.1567398012,
-0.5635450482,
0.3501232266,
0.0060886568,
0.2396875769,
-0.1288570017,
-0.1219900325,
0.0542005934,
-0.340595305,
0.4230211377,
0.1343607903,
0.4255163968,
-0.1478290558,
-0.4268110394,
0.0852576941,
-0.5098450184,
-0.0093022296,
-0.1045351177,
-0.325841099,
-0.2897936702,
0.3007342815,
0.0064422511,
0.001487829,
0.0891170576,
-0.6952695847,
0.555736959,
-0.1339281648,
0.5496493578,
0.4393758476,
0.5375545621,
0.4564329386,
-0.549875617,
0.8590627313,
-0.170470044,
0.12046846,
-0.4171668291,
-0.4469252825,
-0.8200428486,
0.0609786771,
0.01843182,
0.3874846399,
-0.4842155576,
-0.0140332617,
-0.3784092069,
-0.7406561375,
-0.4295944273,
0.1137524471,
0.2757491171,
0.1316789091,
0.3985013962,
0.0100825196,
-0.472641021,
-0.5981249809,
-0.5811622739,
-0.1217645854,
0.0667126551,
0.1355962753,
0.6675668359,
-0.2270703316,
0.7376429439,
-0.4734112918,
-0.383659482,
-0.397628814,
0.996638,
-0.0341131352,
0.5234365463,
0.6378744245,
-0.5814681649,
-0.4651888311,
0.1076569036,
-0.6246064901,
-0.4905244112,
-0.8415888548,
-0.3204012513,
0.0517347939,
0.7065445185,
-0.2490712404,
0.5306831598,
0.3376860619,
-0.407969892,
0.4343761206,
-0.1242416129,
-0.0689698756,
-0.6035903692,
0.3092939556,
-0.3020462394,
-0.1794620156,
-0.7789316773,
-0.0680021942,
0.1512719989,
0.1384454966,
-0.1103439331,
0.0340197496,
-0.7600522041,
0.0568419844,
-0.3587321937,
0.2474536896,
0.0440760069,
0.2756086588,
-0.1322887093,
0.6652137637,
0.3418651521,
-0.2889837027,
0.106354259,
0.0888365954,
-0.441796422,
0.1922318339,
-0.5000306368,
0.375824064,
-0.4135452211,
0.2378659695,
-1.0148222446,
0.069203876,
-0.0694938898,
-0.5720607042,
-0.0416158251,
0.0921154693,
-0.209367469,
-0.2068921477,
-0.503233254,
0.2581853271,
0.2680669725,
0.2671738267,
0.6617875695,
0.2655391395,
-0.5183591843,
-0.4069240391,
-0.698726356,
0.385907799,
-0.1698684096,
-0.5803003907,
0.3503408134,
0.0624309927,
-0.053767588,
0.2509383857,
-0.092666015,
-0.0313738324,
-0.1312029362,
0.1877014339,
0.1280499399,
-0.0451173857,
-0.3002882302,
0.2797284722,
0.016658796,
0.4246636033,
-0.4553870261,
0.3364830017,
0.3975015283,
0.0785651356,
-0.122671552,
0.6278191805,
0.9145513177,
-0.0009935517,
0.5582069755,
0.2639677227,
-0.3343962431,
-0.5586909056,
-0.1309800446,
0.4057208598,
-0.3764961958,
0.1459091306,
-0.1800800264,
-0.4758232236,
0.5781229734,
-0.1835002899,
0.3808758557,
0.6933175325,
0.2521830201,
-0.2113714516,
0.4556131661,
1.013679266,
0.4061188102,
0.324749589,
-0.6418627501,
0.3382630646,
-0.9126594663,
-0.5479431748,
-0.4366185069,
-0.8298230767,
-0.4823275208,
-0.6437759399,
0.46235618,
0.3115964234,
0.4954870343,
0.3573528826,
-0.3228905201,
0.5763033032,
0.2931842804,
-0.3732444346,
0.155156523,
-0.234993726,
-0.3528062701,
-0.3196515441,
-0.2439616174,
-0.7797677517,
1.2076427937,
0.089497,
0.4477998912,
-0.1449133605,
0.7038556337,
0.4199928939,
0.283441782,
-0.6193569303,
0.4595463574,
0.0377227589,
-0.2928274572,
-0.5244624019,
-0.2674290538,
-0.9244184494,
0.0692667142,
-0.367359966,
-0.5483420491,
0.5622833967,
-0.0849027261,
-0.3278879225,
0.3836307228,
-0.4876328111,
0.7764072418,
-0.1501053125,
-0.3421575427,
-0.0927959979,
-0.5972387195,
0.0091284495,
-0.2882958055,
0.1699128598,
0.2385904342,
-0.2946240604,
0.781819284,
-0.3553471863,
0.6922655106,
-0.0434936844,
-0.1110550761,
0.5545998216,
0.3933197558,
0.5088365078,
-0.275087893,
0.1697209328,
-0.3133018613,
0.181834504,
-0.389098227,
-0.625246346,
0.5226734877,
-0.6973736882,
0.0008156627,
-0.5719906092,
-0.658739388,
0.1784707755,
0.3218663037,
0.549036026,
0.3219997287,
-0.4484330714,
0.1891838312,
0.2764515579,
-0.2672543824,
0.5254689455,
0.0060238047,
-0.5266901255,
-0.3437268734,
0.6535069346,
0.3452085853,
0.2686273158,
0.5229665637,
0.1993663013,
-0.2453375161,
-1.0684388876,
-0.2335451543,
0.1449236721,
-0.4911470413,
0.0979294702,
-1.0023988485,
-0.1726649553,
-0.3815826774,
-0.5758095384,
-0.1572196335,
-0.6476950645,
-0.213340506,
-0.1918725967,
0.0231111143,
1.1510692835,
-0.0434267707,
0.2126322836,
-0.4518307447,
0.0800864771,
-0.0879621655,
-0.1274209172,
-0.1535115987,
-0.0616314597,
-0.4398963451,
-0.0527944267,
-0.7031045556,
-0.9150387049,
0.5869334936,
0.1443345994,
0.2643170357,
0.1710793823,
-0.1310154945,
0.6340981722,
-0.1670073122,
0.9081863761,
-0.1387305707,
-1.0432566404,
0.6407362819,
-0.5494832993,
0.1751373559,
0.5178640485,
0.3806465566,
-1.0441004038,
-0.5426209569,
-0.3079488575,
-1.0321348906,
0.4840735495,
0.6609995961,
-0.0516849272,
0.4600495398,
0.6840097308,
0.2557994723,
0.3466454744,
-0.8993534446,
0.0427440666,
-0.2425389588,
0.0849915817,
-0.2555600405,
-0.0541508906,
-0.2161478251,
-0.1448104531,
0.3162457943,
0.0102426587,
0.1474013329,
0.5157622099,
-0.1329218745,
-0.2719091177,
0.0798130631,
0.7319410443,
0.6981496811,
0.0960301086,
0.2312184125,
-0.1713289022,
-0.8715812564,
-0.0496778414,
-0.1868431717,
-0.4461956024,
-0.0364803225,
0.963229537,
0.7769497037,
0.0023167024,
-0.4994918406,
0.4462626874,
-0.0258640219,
-0.5538071394,
-0.4567017555,
0.1913954914,
-0.1515250206,
0.0709158331,
0.2621017694,
0.3397433162,
0.295063138,
-0.6330810785,
-0.1849821657,
-0.043426197,
-0.3190529644,
-0.482427299,
0.4033680856,
0.0808275789,
-0.3779515326,
0.4617398381,
-0.3389744759,
-0.3781628907,
0.5774313211,
0.4252047837,
1.1884577274,
0.1846131682,
0.5361581445,
0.3102278411,
0.6183285117,
0.2039213479,
0.6403465271,
0.0255243983,
-0.3825647235,
-0.5067663789,
-0.5141597986,
-0.1292685568,
0.1735680848,
-0.5354234576,
0.2550115287,
-0.2764257789,
0.0416254364,
0.234926939,
0.0752119943,
-0.315912962,
-0.2167387605,
-0.1969702542,
0.8435727954,
-0.920752883,
0.420147419,
1.0338865519,
-0.170491159,
-0.2657897174,
0.0847021714,
0.2887989581,
-0.3308537304,
0.2381664068,
0.1369484514,
-0.3826217055,
-0.0876991302,
-0.5087737441,
-0.7396848798,
1.2026032209,
-0.1161713526,
-0.3471390009,
-0.0658737347,
0.4892698228,
0.991941154,
-0.4399064481,
-0.2586773336,
0.3022506237,
0.5044534206,
-0.0757697448,
-0.4607158005,
-0.1517693698,
-0.4876172543,
-0.0169683173,
0.7397560477,
-0.2200190127,
0.9571731687,
-0.211920023,
-0.6620152593,
0.2283241302,
0.3856238425,
-0.3781259954,
0.3990071118,
0.3676986992,
0.38371557,
0.7707955837,
-0.2029619515,
1.0243769884,
-0.0197026357,
0.1308928132,
0.5724826455,
0.0382738821,
0.6245154142,
0.6344955564,
0.0573239736,
0.6851851344,
0.2858872414,
0.2742218673,
0.4066491425,
0.4866735041,
-0.2951414287,
0.1651906669,
-0.0353438556,
0.1094077826,
0.220800221,
0.4277190864,
-0.3627660871,
0.0086072413,
0.1516331881,
0.2985224426,
0.3379404545,
-0.0910328031,
0.8184711337,
-0.0479016602,
-0.9962183833,
0.1079557613,
0.0498450212,
0.2331704497,
-0.6420944333,
0.1500343084,
-0.2577277422,
0.0480615087,
-0.1907057017,
-1.1959373951,
0.6682664752,
0.2054107934,
-0.1800662279,
-0.7613937855,
0.3571557105,
-0.3710141182,
-0.6072466969,
0.2362388074,
0.4009823799,
0.130771324,
0.1998317242,
-0.1505008042,
0.1247050017,
-0.0368261971,
-0.2742216885,
-0.1208560988,
1.0887801647,
-0.0891999677,
0.2782697678,
0.6770917177,
0.4591394961,
0.5035719275,
-0.2015321851,
0.6940230131,
-0.8672079444,
-0.4770318568,
-0.8328758478,
0.5171322823,
-0.1940033734,
-0.9276171923,
0.542168498,
0.6697057486,
0.597808063,
0.1961395591,
0.813688159,
-0.1543724537,
0.2733502388,
-0.5073662996,
0.5289000869,
-0.3897454739,
-0.019140454,
-0.4617592692,
-0.7862772942,
-0.2534994483,
0.3825160265,
-0.1800120175,
-0.4491643906,
1.0844620466,
0.3832823038,
0.1628327072,
0.2672694325,
-0.0597316399,
0.2027844489,
0.5639759898,
0.4935830235,
0.9228518009,
-0.3434185386,
0.4935847521,
-0.3256566226,
-0.5167310238,
0.1210766509,
-1.1114263535,
-0.7011963725,
-0.9713472724,
-0.1072144732,
-0.0509125069,
-0.2281601876,
0.3538261354,
0.3526211381,
-0.3765444458,
-0.4675890505,
-0.5161505938,
-0.2075180709,
-0.5440323353,
-0.1458814442,
0.1653671414,
-0.3289757371,
-0.5936251879,
0.3272123933,
0.5400696397,
0.2232274264,
-0.5705123544,
0.162046656,
-0.1086361334,
0.3674800098,
0.458260417,
0.323255688,
-0.1649488807,
0.0516148396,
0.1906017214,
0.0790869072,
-0.0827875435,
1.5743811131,
-0.2919070423,
0.6505441666,
0.9174434543,
0.5995116234,
0.9161064029,
-0.3683714271,
0.7531560659,
-0.7328066826,
-0.1078211293,
0.4865419269,
0.2236590832,
0.2521823347,
-0.4439038634,
0.457916528,
0.2172421217,
-0.7576601505,
-0.8456860781,
0.0691924021,
-0.7939295769,
-0.2415138334,
0.694722712,
0.0319356322,
-0.1424414665,
0.0257891864,
-0.3280107379,
0.1825014353,
-0.0433596522,
0.9702322483,
1.2280699015,
-0.5873780251,
0.0588162504,
-0.8158852458,
0.5739831328,
0.1573538333,
-0.8932493329,
0.1434359252,
0.5378424525,
-0.1801860034,
0.5025513768,
0.8948760033,
-0.1925827265,
-0.1209144592,
0.1205295995,
-0.021513965,
0.1427309811,
-0.5860077739,
-0.011412302,
0.24155882,
-0.234242484,
0.0175130349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03589v1 | CALaMo: a Constructionist Assessment of Language Models | 2023-02-07T16:56:48 | 2023-02-07T16:56:48 | Ludovica Pannitto, Aurélie Herbelot | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a novel framework for evaluating Neural Language Models'
linguistic abilities using a constructionist approach. Not only is the
usage-based model in line with the underlying stochastic philosophy of neural
architectures, but it also allows the linguist to keep meaning as a determinant
factor in the analysis. We outline the framework and present two possible
scenarios for its application. | [
-0.1299420893,
-0.7446164489,
0.4034872353,
0.5232930183,
-0.2187359184,
-0.0567500852,
-0.1708325297,
-0.3439149261,
0.418682307,
0.3733368814,
-0.1469811797,
-0.0719141662,
-0.5128477216,
-0.2828712165,
-0.2400869578,
0.6305630803,
0.0284294207,
0.3053624928,
0.055668924,
-0.2129667401,
-0.5904750228,
-0.3231349587,
-0.8968728781,
-0.3573405743,
0.6174381375,
-0.2042157203,
1.0978028774,
0.8163942099,
0.2736617029,
0.3633368909,
-0.1174821407,
-0.2463595271,
-0.0385122336,
0.0017280891,
-0.4489521682,
-0.9770919681,
-0.2312351167,
-0.0946297497,
0.5594083667,
1.027842164,
-0.1287212521,
0.1996560842,
-0.3312987983,
0.2029571533,
-0.67418015,
0.143598035,
-0.7800986767,
-0.0394643135,
-0.1444825381,
-0.4236156344,
-0.3864492774,
-0.5359393358,
0.2094473541,
-0.0940002576,
-0.0091327336,
-0.1185744703,
0.7058674693,
0.2038799822,
-0.3793039024,
-0.3420678079,
-0.3651291728,
0.7985473275,
-0.9960591197,
0.5241019726,
0.5732281208,
0.3702387214,
-0.2005120218,
-0.3360998333,
-0.4070546329,
-0.7458876967,
0.174379155,
0.107371673,
0.4972376227,
0.0255460721,
0.1435223967,
0.614977181,
-0.3803337812,
0.4062258005,
-0.5876932144,
-0.3961827457,
0.5763082504,
0.1900311857,
0.6133380532,
-0.3566192687,
-0.3095538616,
0.0982349217,
-0.6772503257,
-0.1366820633,
0.7274309993,
0.3245409727,
-0.1036403477,
0.6429270506,
0.2010912448,
0.5757656097,
-0.5468536019,
0.2593981326,
0.0743979514,
-0.0122133484,
-0.3269364238,
0.0055558993,
1.0255428553,
-0.070655793,
0.2729109228,
-0.2478323132,
-0.0178809967,
0.5108621716,
0.4004516602,
-0.7214000225,
-0.1386662722,
0.1589371413,
-0.2789103687,
-0.637509644,
-0.1503598243,
-0.6101202965,
-0.3481580019,
-0.2360531986,
-0.0369022563,
-0.2961164713,
-0.5796756148,
-0.0234474204,
-0.0001561655,
0.1145717576,
0.0843300521,
-1.0023066998,
0.314471066,
0.6661595702,
0.7926866412,
-0.0115473475,
-0.2617580891,
-0.1741612554,
-0.3943369985,
-0.8275744319,
0.7291783094,
-0.4437631667,
-0.3696099222,
0.0836160779,
-0.0290765353,
-0.4256750047,
-0.2305565774,
0.1931190044,
-0.669111073,
0.0689493567,
0.0290035158,
-0.3002201319,
-0.5605123043,
0.2446663529,
-0.8959023356,
0.809909761,
0.3843148649,
-0.487503171,
0.1082229167,
-0.5798187852,
-0.0346846581,
0.2657455206,
-0.3135035038,
0.1812379062,
0.8362001181,
-0.575150311,
0.0069742547,
-0.5804417729,
0.758823812,
-0.3928708434,
-0.0700950399,
0.6903046966,
-0.7411353588,
1.3201658726,
0.5315842628,
-0.4668241441,
-0.2387057543,
-0.8237814903,
0.4082737565,
-0.1978625655,
-0.3269847035,
-0.5667442083,
0.3959598243,
0.1048292369,
0.3117566705,
0.3246867657,
-0.25703457,
-0.0436438434,
-1.1975816488,
0.3059487939,
0.6730009317,
-0.0835702643,
0.2624787092,
-0.3195526004,
0.8044313192,
-0.1436372548,
-0.2744776607,
0.1481409371,
-0.3666389585,
-0.9835233092,
-0.1364283264,
0.607563138,
0.6563568711,
-0.6629674435,
0.0732719675,
-0.160666734,
-0.7770459652,
-0.5591220856,
0.3660779595,
0.8176193237,
-0.1808017194,
-0.1138059869,
-0.8193431497,
-0.5191249251,
-1.1068876982,
-0.2527597547,
-0.4684962928,
0.1550154239,
0.2514207661,
0.4656754732,
-0.1850203127,
0.4493562579,
-0.1039136723,
0.298967123,
0.0575129688,
0.2877893448,
0.3519656658,
0.4888782203,
0.8235591054,
-0.7758613825,
-0.0462679379,
0.3367832005,
-0.8194074035,
-0.2015021741,
-0.039833542,
-0.1782140881,
-0.1902449131,
0.2309844643,
-0.3741835356,
0.6533643603,
0.5365863442,
-0.4020828605,
0.835311532,
-0.2109615654,
0.1120507717,
-1.3964861631,
0.0604291111,
-0.1218856052,
0.0475693941,
-0.8159433007,
0.5822296739,
-0.1055370718,
0.0746428147,
-0.9469701648,
0.6102448106,
-0.2680351138,
-0.1352096647,
-0.650226891,
-0.0513559207,
-0.3008619845,
0.5878280997,
0.0726450011,
0.7580108643,
0.358504951,
-0.6587637663,
0.3062677085,
-0.0297027808,
-0.4589735866,
0.6738593578,
-0.8590180874,
0.0964623168,
0.1082410738,
-0.5573310256,
-1.0091583729,
0.0231046751,
-0.1162533835,
-0.5506836176,
-0.0832551196,
0.1578972638,
-0.6300190687,
-0.2990207374,
-0.1915958077,
0.7198569775,
-0.1080019921,
-0.0275244433,
0.6943067312,
0.4971642196,
-0.1369081736,
-0.1615477204,
-0.7600267529,
0.1448059529,
-0.3596377671,
-0.4401442111,
0.1728781611,
-0.3781404197,
-0.6836502552,
-0.2675922811,
0.1538772285,
-0.6876072884,
0.5762072206,
0.2328272164,
0.324631691,
-0.60625422,
0.0929662585,
0.0684131831,
0.0910563394,
0.2659861743,
0.0419117808,
0.6733958125,
-0.3157092631,
-0.0531758443,
-0.5823868513,
0.1378485113,
0.7642027736,
-0.2133846134,
0.515337348,
0.0445257947,
-0.5157679319,
0.0433192663,
-0.5075216293,
0.1583227664,
-0.4323640168,
0.4874223173,
-0.6829887033,
-0.5359802842,
0.8263265491,
0.0187412221,
0.0926665142,
0.5743159056,
0.9540583491,
0.1935001016,
1.0348566771,
0.5724514723,
0.0548502617,
0.6951838732,
-0.4406217337,
0.1098335534,
-1.1009484529,
0.0792471692,
-0.7754429579,
-0.0163183045,
-0.6126258373,
-0.2979904711,
-0.4640433192,
-0.0610184893,
-0.3547662497,
1.0603065491,
-0.2057046294,
0.1771569103,
0.1824983656,
-0.0771245882,
0.1115647927,
-0.3246887326,
-0.5110493898,
0.0184949357,
-0.5988991261,
-0.8383589387,
0.9447163343,
0.4118995965,
0.6161004305,
0.3415908515,
0.2393185645,
0.0793862641,
0.7400667667,
-1.2651143074,
0.5608720183,
0.0800867602,
-1.1263215542,
0.1668038815,
-0.534817636,
-0.8021739125,
0.6230035424,
-0.0067013241,
-1.1997084618,
0.5154032111,
-0.2424715459,
-0.2926603854,
0.1998796612,
-0.5723834038,
0.8799724579,
-0.6890500188,
-0.3481345773,
-0.3033494651,
-0.0340720005,
0.515191853,
-0.2080111951,
0.4163121581,
-0.2406808883,
-0.2250394672,
0.9500499368,
-0.4018178582,
0.7308241129,
0.085154444,
-0.1726566255,
0.4629788995,
0.7061749101,
-0.1711821556,
0.0992313549,
-0.6172202229,
0.1199924201,
0.5550345182,
-0.1411556751,
-0.7639340758,
0.9104195237,
-0.7692770958,
-0.4660874605,
-0.3957825899,
-0.9336704016,
-0.3868630826,
0.2323802412,
-0.0592803136,
0.758938849,
-0.3910942376,
0.169030726,
0.0681510344,
-0.0234925728,
0.3816081882,
0.3149950504,
-0.1276447028,
-0.7121322751,
0.6549572349,
0.177600503,
0.3378742635,
0.0877986327,
0.3631584048,
-0.367886126,
-0.5146687031,
-0.3369319439,
0.3374701738,
-0.5646436214,
0.1139621288,
-0.2338038683,
-0.2476332933,
0.0575356968,
-0.2143816054,
-0.5476152897,
-0.4968866706,
-0.2833054662,
-0.1593361646,
-0.3437869251,
0.637034297,
0.3713477254,
0.7582816482,
-0.4495933056,
0.0301265493,
0.2288055867,
0.2859906256,
0.0479141772,
-0.5096084476,
-0.2588300109,
0.5060427189,
-0.4368909597,
-1.1899344921,
0.4830248654,
0.0167266745,
0.8551360369,
0.570099771,
-0.4856652319,
0.6341837049,
-0.4351359308,
0.6975033283,
0.4256905615,
-0.9207705855,
0.6450209618,
-0.3702403903,
0.1212128475,
0.9413284659,
0.352481842,
-0.2544320822,
-0.362868309,
-0.9565258622,
-0.5299196243,
0.1668610871,
0.071367681,
0.4919430912,
-0.3826635182,
0.2490474433,
-0.1959569901,
0.428756237,
-0.751756072,
0.1974194795,
-0.1307622045,
-0.3795182705,
0.0284657255,
-0.3297355175,
-0.1192359254,
-0.0627451167,
0.5493921041,
-0.1993438452,
0.2843500674,
-0.2560817599,
-0.4983356595,
0.2453644425,
0.2483099848,
0.5999719501,
1.1672222614,
-0.0020891072,
0.3431725204,
0.3388089538,
-0.2519606948,
0.2146937996,
-0.1043480262,
-0.1236710176,
-0.1624827981,
0.1841214448,
0.7760011554,
0.9739400148,
-0.604531765,
0.335775286,
0.1166025475,
-0.168198809,
-0.3601698279,
0.1177223772,
-0.0213510524,
0.0212178752,
-0.1351129413,
0.2555816174,
0.1425204724,
-0.910652101,
-0.0198860168,
0.2535530329,
-0.966204226,
-0.7707297802,
0.7139860988,
-0.1166268736,
-0.851588428,
0.354475528,
0.0631289631,
-0.7811915874,
0.9692732096,
0.6824972034,
1.0878317356,
-0.5906042457,
0.1182174459,
0.3229942918,
0.2637511194,
-0.1099868938,
0.4516395032,
-0.0398319699,
-0.9106689095,
-0.4402780533,
-0.6665216088,
-0.181198433,
-0.1115623489,
-0.5962081552,
0.1028562561,
-0.7591128349,
-0.4110330045,
0.1574965864,
0.1360232085,
-0.7027736902,
0.2946230471,
-0.2680881619,
1.0025887489,
-0.8362070918,
0.9147384763,
0.6655402184,
-0.6567852497,
-0.8003752232,
-0.6206895709,
0.0058432817,
-0.7071816325,
0.9123630524,
0.1776582748,
-0.0791852027,
-0.1363520175,
-0.0885979906,
-0.6198112369,
0.8345446587,
0.6209716201,
-0.1161881685,
-0.1480715573,
-0.0186845995,
0.8337550759,
-0.6133944392,
0.7060619593,
0.5490490794,
0.1725136936,
0.0517032929,
-1.1369780302,
-0.0345449597,
-0.6013091803,
0.7036056519,
0.071763128,
-0.2129389942,
0.5893365145,
0.0492378101,
-0.4137676358,
0.6310727,
0.6843550801,
0.2960465848,
0.0106865112,
0.4975572228,
0.6877775788,
0.5810784698,
0.0774910897,
1.045968771,
-0.4965049624,
0.2629684508,
1.153621316,
0.1223272458,
1.1661958694,
0.5183150172,
-0.3653985858,
0.8125813603,
0.5352305174,
0.3635061979,
0.4073760808,
0.6760951877,
-0.1583153009,
-0.1911885291,
-0.3198855519,
-0.2859761417,
0.8865081072,
0.5180643797,
-0.558707118,
-0.1370961666,
-0.0284442604,
0.1424059421,
0.2629125416,
-0.3341443837,
0.4384726286,
0.4535811841,
-0.7696387768,
0.3942429125,
-0.1126445457,
0.324377507,
-0.4738459587,
0.1462379098,
0.2131881267,
0.1429785192,
0.0166747477,
-0.3371931612,
0.6400729418,
-0.1952200681,
0.0107957814,
0.1595567465,
0.2406751066,
-0.167379573,
-0.6857699156,
0.3812651336,
0.4801145494,
0.2814446688,
0.3203652501,
-0.8085525632,
-0.104703486,
-0.3779158294,
-0.0152762076,
-0.0316659622,
0.1477680355,
-0.2754063308,
0.5104176402,
0.8456033468,
0.6946581006,
0.009135413,
0.2441683859,
0.5085911751,
-0.6887664199,
-0.599627018,
-0.8190173507,
0.4896682203,
-0.0728752613,
-0.5857431889,
0.6016461849,
0.4828581512,
0.5150828958,
0.1398167908,
0.4129657149,
-0.2163424939,
-0.0972885489,
-0.2405837476,
0.7458458543,
-0.4071308374,
0.3214351535,
-0.1971556097,
-1.0773496628,
-0.392242521,
0.956079483,
-0.7972512245,
0.0711644068,
0.9500849843,
1.0205856562,
-0.0373559557,
0.1604409516,
0.5561990142,
0.1021874994,
0.2911973,
0.7753560543,
1.0817810297,
-0.6622323394,
-0.0392575487,
-0.0932247341,
-0.4578788877,
-0.0110991998,
-0.8270858526,
-1.1408858299,
-0.6970989108,
-0.283716172,
-0.2180953175,
-0.2578807771,
0.7381267548,
0.7914693356,
-0.8875325322,
-0.798222959,
-0.1310177445,
0.1070713699,
-0.3861970603,
-0.2123710811,
0.3871562183,
-0.3360037506,
-0.6955422759,
0.5494000912,
0.1910426766,
-0.2385407835,
-0.6360728741,
0.1008722186,
-0.444223851,
0.4925153852,
0.5150274634,
0.3146378398,
-0.6459177732,
-0.276548028,
-0.1655747145,
-0.1611415446,
-0.2854311764,
0.6722521782,
-0.4485596716,
0.9427842498,
0.814661026,
0.684779644,
0.1234453544,
-0.2839607894,
0.7972041368,
0.0527367853,
0.5012179017,
0.1653378457,
0.7310209274,
0.1482080221,
-0.1583034992,
0.4853395522,
0.3004268706,
-0.1981820762,
-0.7417649627,
0.3537527621,
-0.9357193112,
0.1523102969,
0.9161583781,
-0.1711855382,
-0.5997514725,
-0.0372282267,
-0.1206074655,
0.0112483529,
0.3865177631,
0.8239649534,
0.7644630671,
0.4514453113,
-0.0644402951,
-1.1583465338,
-0.0341505744,
0.4014957547,
-0.6881178617,
-0.4461734295,
0.4854743779,
0.3005304337,
0.5420664549,
0.6635113358,
-0.369807899,
0.6152217388,
-0.0001177788,
-0.1594722569,
-0.0190125089,
-0.4044375718,
-0.1602954268,
0.1834123433,
0.3490401506,
-0.0766080692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03694v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03694v1 | Characterizing Financial Market Coverage using Artificial Intelligence | 2023-02-07T16:03:33 | 2023-02-07T16:03:33 | Jean Marie Tshimula, D'Jeff K. Nkashama, Patrick Owusu, Marc Frappier, Pierre-Martin Tardif, Froduald Kabanza, Armelle Brun, Jean-Marc Patenaude, Shengrui Wang, Belkacem Chikhaoui | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | This paper scrutinizes a database of over 4900 YouTube videos to characterize
financial market coverage. Financial market coverage generates a large number
of videos. Therefore, watching these videos to derive actionable insights could
be challenging and complex. In this paper, we leverage Whisper, a
speech-to-text model from OpenAI, to generate a text corpus of market coverage
videos from Bloomberg and Yahoo Finance. We employ natural language processing
to extract insights regarding language use from the market coverage. Moreover,
we examine the prominent presence of trending topics and their evolution over
time, and the impacts that some individuals and organizations have on the
financial market. Our characterization highlights the dynamics of the financial
market coverage and provides valuable insights reflecting broad discussions
regarding recent financial events and the world economy. | [
-0.2444272786,
-0.9501550198,
0.0078728152,
0.2877628803,
0.1784255505,
0.3842534721,
-0.028439492,
-0.6023347974,
0.4911093116,
0.5546514392,
-0.5940521359,
-0.3820925355,
-0.3800961673,
-0.2419183403,
-0.7075329423,
1.1174352169,
0.2201335132,
-0.3489144444,
0.3964958787,
0.1166956574,
0.1077652425,
-0.1228954643,
-0.5824170709,
0.0140670743,
0.2247916907,
0.3501903713,
0.9383256435,
0.5947508812,
0.399410814,
0.4332567155,
-0.1537982374,
0.0749706477,
-0.3624952734,
-0.241397351,
0.1290650517,
-0.312369138,
-0.3200379908,
0.2247206271,
0.618003726,
0.4159483612,
-0.3725382686,
0.1802599877,
-0.0077400235,
0.5516119003,
-0.4755950868,
0.4493477643,
-0.8652348518,
-0.152696535,
-0.4700182974,
-0.1042191386,
-0.3595677614,
-0.1900036037,
0.7143123746,
-0.7700948715,
0.0347922519,
0.1303449869,
0.8340523243,
0.177535966,
-0.4170224369,
-0.5888627768,
-1.0643547773,
0.5312551856,
-0.3786501288,
0.2339434773,
0.6752631664,
0.8837099075,
0.0476632267,
-0.6166906357,
-0.4737176001,
-0.1267952025,
0.1290029585,
0.249246195,
-0.7399827242,
-0.0076550399,
-0.1575303227,
0.4510569274,
-0.1132013053,
-0.0786476135,
-0.7289412618,
-0.3961520493,
0.7880985141,
0.0446252935,
0.3490974903,
-0.1404642463,
-0.2080444098,
-0.4039766192,
-0.2516980767,
0.3511517346,
0.7778479457,
-0.0758264959,
-0.212048158,
0.5515037775,
-0.2560682893,
0.3190738261,
-0.4283732176,
-0.4514235556,
0.2668453157,
-0.2645282745,
-0.6439985633,
0.4338957667,
0.5494388342,
0.4805172086,
0.2439511418,
-0.0959685296,
0.2164608538,
-0.4255754054,
0.3526114821,
-0.5990518332,
0.0369406603,
0.2221191376,
-0.5628243089,
-0.3606081009,
0.4143987,
-0.8713920116,
-0.2215694487,
-0.197470367,
0.0064401207,
-0.3584042192,
-0.2899487913,
0.2161302119,
-0.582967937,
0.4737622738,
-0.0632165298,
-0.7700326443,
0.2376917005,
0.8029115796,
0.8326033354,
0.4132655859,
-0.0182002299,
-0.305423677,
0.539799273,
-0.1792636812,
0.8828145266,
-0.0275898334,
-0.2248101234,
0.2554161251,
-0.3025823534,
-0.0951218158,
-0.2703627944,
-0.0297484975,
-0.4554544985,
-0.0985928178,
0.0787127987,
-0.5245025754,
-0.470821768,
0.2996070981,
-0.9031945467,
0.4390318394,
0.1486347616,
-0.9102491736,
0.4793711305,
-0.9885106087,
-0.1628479213,
-0.0380904302,
-0.0597855523,
-0.7096824646,
-0.2976078093,
0.4253996909,
0.1709597707,
0.0094157746,
0.2421623021,
-0.3156838119,
-0.1656563431,
1.0314691067,
-0.5978421569,
0.4531317651,
0.2510770261,
-0.4795268774,
0.3731407821,
-0.6735457182,
-0.3560810983,
-0.0861395523,
0.5058848262,
-0.3573035002,
0.3415427804,
0.1544315517,
-0.3516342044,
-0.0927272066,
-0.4273125529,
0.0120598152,
-1.0149405003,
0.9281826019,
0.7066144347,
0.2995391786,
0.5393682122,
-0.4675636888,
0.5418822765,
-0.0620077029,
0.3890218437,
-0.4284490049,
-0.4015421569,
-0.4247712493,
-0.462397635,
0.2983025312,
0.5746411681,
-0.3185542226,
-0.1268221885,
0.1195452809,
-0.6530786753,
-0.781083703,
0.137632221,
-0.2168493569,
0.2350359857,
0.2533888817,
0.4119815826,
-0.6319772601,
-1.3075723648,
-0.3276818991,
-0.2076347321,
-0.2048708349,
0.4210255444,
0.2803941071,
-0.3160874844,
1.1024022102,
-0.8501684666,
-0.5075725317,
-0.448854655,
0.2007652223,
0.2369192392,
-0.0552628934,
0.7229122519,
-0.7878020406,
-0.4312554896,
0.3427993357,
-0.375775516,
0.2343316525,
-0.7401592731,
-0.2492263168,
0.0767416507,
0.7683008313,
-0.2435072511,
0.855872333,
0.3066669703,
-0.3928339183,
0.107946381,
-0.2465745807,
-0.1227636039,
-0.8704840541,
0.0996920615,
0.3097931147,
-0.0522729419,
-0.444717139,
-0.2468043864,
-0.4412922263,
0.091649428,
-0.1697442532,
0.5853278637,
-0.0628458858,
-0.2149960548,
-0.355202198,
0.1840390414,
-0.3244982064,
0.0619011745,
-0.2237197012,
0.8489001393,
0.5035180449,
-0.4837753773,
0.3901206851,
0.4480749369,
-0.6442787647,
-0.0272392854,
-0.7743706703,
-0.2852123976,
0.0048142397,
0.3153226376,
-0.9838439822,
-0.3649485707,
0.382363528,
-0.5473227501,
-0.4147013724,
0.0724009275,
-0.4759406745,
-0.3755671084,
-0.2749233246,
-0.0067671603,
0.4688522816,
-0.2551164925,
0.4987308979,
0.8335216045,
-0.5172598958,
-0.1886781901,
-0.7356141806,
0.1809009612,
-0.4630235136,
-0.7770947218,
0.4857075512,
0.1267617047,
-0.7281710505,
-0.1433783621,
-0.2271052897,
-0.1204307824,
0.2524717748,
0.3925536275,
0.4342450202,
-0.1872183084,
0.0060633286,
-0.1181083471,
-0.2973972559,
0.4810734689,
-0.3250659406,
0.2676544189,
-0.1284085661,
-0.1186964065,
-0.597219944,
0.4448046088,
0.3720737398,
-0.341376394,
0.8032318354,
0.2531908751,
-0.0742943957,
-0.2025437504,
-0.4959377348,
0.0916941315,
-0.5496837497,
0.1329392344,
0.1121885329,
-0.6267294884,
0.9775665402,
0.3957051635,
0.2119871378,
0.8235062957,
0.6288867593,
-0.1779210269,
0.9957427979,
0.958255589,
-0.4607663751,
0.642380476,
-0.4318413138,
-0.1004718468,
-0.002433141,
-0.6290941834,
-0.6021847725,
-0.5949368477,
-0.6500104666,
-0.1083419323,
0.3021427989,
-0.0974958166,
-0.0889240876,
0.1600755006,
-0.4038386941,
0.4953219295,
0.7804707885,
0.0367365107,
0.3076041341,
0.1275414675,
0.0862456039,
0.0830592737,
-0.1199695021,
-0.2639532387,
1.0152088404,
0.7687879205,
0.6602330804,
0.0572191179,
0.0907573104,
0.4515272081,
0.5567691922,
-0.6108071804,
0.1404154599,
0.0312794372,
-0.3406279087,
-0.4322889745,
-0.523180902,
-0.909132719,
-0.3333060145,
0.0340004824,
-0.4139774144,
-0.0390187278,
-0.0057732984,
-0.3944919407,
0.2255639732,
-0.3815662861,
0.6644451022,
-0.1006476805,
0.462500602,
-0.3495529592,
-0.3005612791,
0.3498013616,
-0.0134852147,
0.4621753991,
-0.0482019074,
0.0073030964,
0.826793313,
-0.649518311,
0.8721132278,
0.0166377854,
-0.2839215696,
0.6597266793,
-0.4458873272,
0.1350449473,
0.4960449338,
0.2912134528,
-0.054558143,
-0.0120513989,
-0.6447885036,
-0.4717397392,
0.3137887716,
-0.7834097147,
-0.0289826915,
-0.2996728718,
-0.4996421933,
-0.1206376404,
-0.1103966236,
0.1230559871,
-0.0997013226,
-0.5484626293,
0.0937019661,
0.3679352701,
-0.14781335,
0.6185312867,
0.4890391827,
-0.4653562605,
-0.8923034668,
0.8504479527,
0.1208938509,
-0.0984201357,
0.1594688445,
0.2260525525,
-0.2741575837,
-0.5056927204,
-0.4034731388,
0.0550813898,
-0.2875536978,
-0.1421725154,
-0.6722466946,
-0.4917918444,
-0.5166500807,
0.0197659563,
-0.1366012543,
-0.0365637504,
-0.1110753939,
-0.4982913435,
0.7735509872,
0.9740837216,
0.0515814573,
0.690805614,
-0.9868856072,
0.407308042,
0.4027835727,
0.4306536913,
0.0546907671,
-0.0986822844,
-0.6119334102,
0.3119540513,
-0.3018908203,
-1.0194532871,
0.5080996156,
0.3434702456,
0.9015407562,
0.6809589863,
0.1056332216,
0.712862134,
0.0111816898,
0.4329066873,
-0.0960250497,
-0.8918623328,
0.7526174784,
-0.4406555593,
0.3920556307,
0.4565848112,
0.3177528977,
-0.5461421013,
-0.8779774308,
-0.7630267739,
-0.8843866587,
0.3674375713,
0.5549474955,
0.3566738069,
-0.0365574248,
0.2359104753,
-0.0112547697,
0.1928275675,
-0.4384692013,
-0.168893531,
-0.4628391564,
-0.0854726285,
0.0584002919,
-0.2356324345,
0.0690762624,
-0.1039016694,
0.4468456805,
-0.2132626176,
-0.0862979218,
0.2943468988,
0.112193577,
-0.0189277623,
0.0874106959,
0.7069317102,
0.37708354,
-0.2544428408,
-0.4505064189,
-0.1854622811,
-0.7044153214,
-0.4461198151,
0.3533963263,
-0.3898066282,
0.1928768307,
0.5667462945,
0.7476426959,
0.5179715753,
-1.1599036455,
0.4669712484,
-0.0194931012,
-0.6717583537,
-0.7902671099,
-0.028805105,
-0.0440238565,
0.5403416157,
0.8997588158,
0.1416001767,
0.402792871,
-0.832218051,
0.530577302,
0.2784948945,
-0.5397222042,
-0.4849980175,
0.7404763103,
0.1480693221,
0.0572398081,
0.9989210367,
0.2469859719,
-0.5978161693,
0.9545981884,
0.2608442008,
0.8896891475,
-0.0466234386,
0.5715041757,
0.0278965347,
0.273776114,
-0.0714481324,
0.261128068,
0.1036304608,
-0.4487826228,
-0.755838275,
-0.3755771816,
-0.6526061296,
0.2314773351,
-0.7762075663,
0.2113418579,
-0.3335492015,
-0.1219649836,
0.6451295018,
-0.1149199754,
-0.395299077,
-0.0986685753,
0.2085831612,
1.4043405056,
-0.6185780168,
0.6782969832,
0.3367725611,
-0.3628243506,
-0.5598326921,
0.037728902,
0.122565873,
-0.743612051,
0.5175469518,
0.529479146,
0.2138579786,
-0.3072102368,
-0.472925812,
-0.4996628165,
0.9161772728,
0.2181963623,
-0.2667084634,
-0.2030019611,
0.4068078101,
0.5409403443,
-0.422316581,
0.0491436943,
0.7410354018,
0.6582658291,
0.3800750375,
-0.9053087831,
-0.9122979641,
-0.3767180145,
-0.5754055381,
0.2854544818,
-0.3939571977,
0.4499630928,
-0.1355643719,
-0.1092998385,
0.0197370052,
1.067243576,
-0.03718438,
1.1277345419,
0.6343880892,
0.2081524879,
0.6323620677,
0.1888394803,
1.2490818501,
-0.2230679542,
0.1985570341,
0.8415160179,
0.1442890316,
0.9505586624,
0.0580893606,
-0.2155279964,
0.3054819405,
0.4772643447,
-0.3935607374,
0.2514464855,
0.3660161197,
-0.0716404691,
0.080963552,
0.0325125679,
-0.0852118284,
0.942183435,
0.3493222296,
-0.4309545457,
-0.2425773442,
0.4964745641,
-0.1376549006,
0.2244898528,
-0.6162272096,
0.9800720215,
0.0311754495,
-0.4637412727,
-0.3974127471,
0.0011569312,
0.5152741671,
-0.7872974873,
0.1186462492,
-0.2313943803,
0.2357434332,
0.0286171604,
-0.835573256,
0.9807979465,
0.1985463947,
-0.1016786769,
-0.4562690556,
0.4728469849,
-0.2606178522,
-0.6153542399,
0.2617743611,
0.2351560146,
-0.0451821834,
-0.5132112503,
-0.433899343,
-0.1945593208,
0.2009931207,
-0.248157084,
0.3113168478,
0.3541864455,
0.0998828784,
0.921810627,
0.9092860222,
-0.1282385439,
-0.0191597696,
-0.1480837911,
0.6560969353,
-1.078954339,
-0.8682549,
-0.9866093397,
0.2022681534,
-0.4734850228,
-0.412946403,
0.7548378706,
0.7294068336,
0.4427678287,
0.1770436764,
0.5794645548,
0.4439505935,
0.5305023193,
-0.6175673008,
1.0615106821,
-0.1732405573,
0.4873282611,
-0.0140223792,
-0.5474430919,
-0.1368867606,
0.4626834691,
-0.2932685912,
-0.5059422255,
-0.0935506821,
0.3056874275,
0.0779932067,
0.512419343,
-0.0463402495,
0.4403270781,
0.2494200021,
-0.2010683864,
0.4865632057,
-0.1867689639,
1.1430991888,
-0.241933018,
-0.0757295191,
-0.467259109,
-0.8423091173,
-0.8286960721,
-0.434161067,
-0.4335237443,
-0.3413009048,
-0.3982147574,
0.3190372884,
0.6857248545,
-0.6617389917,
-0.3055284321,
0.1629177928,
0.0686796159,
-0.44291085,
-0.3029604852,
0.3936294913,
-0.1646490544,
-0.5298227072,
0.6362130642,
0.4583167732,
0.3721993566,
-0.634724319,
0.2309595942,
0.2121586949,
0.5161988139,
0.3486590385,
0.2911050618,
-0.4388461113,
0.10435763,
0.4055261314,
-0.0793237761,
-0.0971586481,
0.9896124005,
-0.731216073,
-0.0751018673,
0.3794023097,
0.7583786249,
0.5844779015,
-0.0051405774,
0.6992774606,
-0.50449121,
0.1991717219,
-0.0280364007,
0.121127665,
-0.3327932656,
-0.3587780595,
0.2864354551,
-0.0224901512,
-0.4191709161,
-0.7538704276,
0.0052959486,
-1.1375141144,
-0.488625437,
0.5908880234,
0.1574577242,
-0.5316531062,
-0.1292836964,
-0.3846723139,
-0.1015449315,
-0.6866107583,
0.8239162564,
0.6965537667,
0.2216392457,
-0.2205253094,
-1.0697216988,
0.3478066921,
-0.0213424768,
-0.7624023557,
0.0919599086,
-0.1114925295,
0.2295072079,
0.1472819299,
0.7174236178,
0.1789572984,
0.2648544908,
0.0459587574,
-0.5877686739,
-0.2341764718,
-0.1537524909,
0.1851925403,
0.3195319772,
-0.402017504,
-0.1658539772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03528v1 | Efficiently Upgrading Multilingual Machine Translation Models to Support More Languages | 2023-02-07T15:20:13 | 2023-02-07T15:20:13 | Simeng Sun, Maha Elbayad, Anna Sun, James Cross | cs.CL | cs.CL | With multilingual machine translation (MMT) models continuing to grow in size
and number of supported languages, it is natural to reuse and upgrade existing
models to save computation as data becomes available in more languages.
However, adding new languages requires updating the vocabulary, which
complicates the reuse of embeddings. The question of how to reuse existing
models while also making architectural changes to provide capacity for both old
and new languages has also not been closely studied. In this work, we introduce
three techniques that help speed up effective learning of the new languages and
alleviate catastrophic forgetting despite vocabulary and architecture
mismatches. Our results show that by (1) carefully initializing the network,
(2) applying learning rate scaling, and (3) performing data up-sampling, it is
possible to exceed the performance of a same-sized baseline model with 30%
computation and recover the performance of a larger model trained from scratch
with over 50% reduction in computation. Furthermore, our analysis reveals that
the introduced techniques help learn the new directions more effectively and
alleviate catastrophic forgetting at the same time. We hope our work will guide
research into more efficient approaches to growing languages for these MMT
models and ultimately maximize the reuse of existing models. | [
-0.3789398372,
-0.4002634883,
0.2882634699,
0.1857863367,
-0.1844524592,
0.2153992802,
-0.2260276973,
-0.1651817262,
0.0499607399,
0.6123040915,
-0.0957634896,
-0.0936791301,
-0.5695078969,
0.0078844884,
-0.0750146583,
0.9015014172,
-0.3758464754,
0.1702497154,
-0.0050585899,
-0.4748592079,
-0.6790634394,
-0.5606299639,
-0.9704335332,
-0.3826214075,
0.5478017926,
0.5387460589,
0.7070578337,
0.8084205389,
0.5773445368,
0.3523116112,
-0.0951097906,
0.4807789624,
-0.3405163884,
0.0832722858,
0.116769731,
-0.2955983579,
-0.5829405785,
-0.3993812799,
0.9623112679,
0.8540669084,
-0.3520872891,
0.132025674,
0.0759449154,
0.8503410816,
-0.4056408405,
0.2680009007,
-0.6677042842,
0.0168323442,
-0.1383574903,
-0.5150823593,
-0.5520274043,
-0.11169146,
0.1655127257,
-0.5680783987,
0.1262016594,
-0.2461431473,
0.4334499538,
0.0351364315,
-0.3644658327,
-0.3078847826,
-0.7017792463,
0.8377359509,
-0.5866816044,
0.6752907038,
0.2895804942,
0.5681078434,
-0.0638882071,
-0.4974525869,
-0.1269240379,
-0.3466582894,
0.2622645795,
0.0457827263,
-0.1855458915,
-0.3818748593,
0.2066732943,
0.1813373566,
-0.4469843209,
0.2097458094,
-0.5093299747,
-0.1745241731,
0.3809950948,
-0.0783011094,
0.2247664779,
0.0419990793,
-0.273271203,
-0.2879753709,
-0.945694983,
-0.3737280369,
0.1815738678,
0.5804471374,
-0.0324379802,
0.3713481724,
0.0217335783,
0.5445045829,
-0.2463701218,
-0.0258559063,
0.7129703164,
-0.4523783028,
-0.1190486401,
-0.1819220334,
0.2619594336,
0.1987714767,
0.4275251627,
-0.1539326161,
-0.2813628912,
-0.3211918175,
0.3670123816,
-0.6101061702,
-0.2196705788,
-0.0678587183,
-0.3942856789,
0.0258186683,
-0.4540983438,
-0.37431252,
-0.1054845154,
-0.2683185935,
0.2376288027,
-0.7667810917,
-0.4649162292,
0.241839841,
-0.0568668395,
0.1111077741,
0.5506294966,
-0.7918106914,
-0.0444066636,
0.4381626844,
1.0426744223,
0.1776363105,
-0.5418809652,
-0.5240259171,
0.0851113051,
-0.5263056755,
0.5929760337,
-0.1945049763,
-0.3272514343,
0.0538793281,
0.030358959,
-0.2939046621,
-0.7181907892,
0.4470689297,
-0.6847037673,
0.0920734555,
-0.4521003067,
-0.3991770446,
-0.4141122699,
0.5160045028,
-0.8293845057,
0.8934916258,
0.0897556245,
-0.568990469,
0.1038765609,
-0.7373093367,
-0.5812188387,
-0.1178574339,
0.2766364813,
-0.5561823845,
0.4440563917,
0.2888244689,
0.5429795384,
-0.1312409937,
-0.0047669234,
-0.1654500514,
-0.1280798167,
-0.0614251085,
-0.6003376842,
0.8309279084,
0.4569611549,
0.0981381387,
-0.2030108124,
-0.651858449,
-0.2318850309,
0.0337341279,
-0.7102323771,
-0.5304542184,
0.1130149513,
0.0313075185,
0.2172829509,
0.2171410918,
-0.3793174922,
0.2630858719,
-0.3503483534,
0.4262240529,
0.5885881186,
-0.088788569,
0.5117806792,
-0.5897545218,
0.4568160176,
0.3489567339,
-0.0837068111,
-0.6279407144,
-0.4254748821,
-0.8635245562,
-0.0567042977,
0.2343809158,
0.6137357354,
-1.3116929531,
-0.2566500604,
-0.6448428631,
-0.4458732307,
-0.6135685444,
0.2852779627,
0.3242685199,
0.3715063632,
0.6784204841,
-0.3318893313,
-0.6165786386,
-0.751475513,
-0.0738238841,
-0.1033434495,
0.0042305859,
0.1662800163,
0.4364362955,
-0.2291918695,
0.3428104818,
-0.2236335874,
-0.002638635,
-0.2109751403,
0.0744708776,
0.0582576171,
0.6302068233,
0.5991746783,
-0.8628976941,
-0.6061358452,
0.5164687037,
-0.6409016252,
0.1303246319,
-0.2818333805,
0.0843354538,
0.2713685632,
0.5787569284,
-0.4820627868,
-0.1009757891,
0.585819006,
0.0496536829,
0.6241934299,
-0.6141745448,
0.2750591338,
-1.4476615191,
-0.1470027268,
-0.2731176913,
-0.2153761089,
-0.7349649072,
0.3148297966,
0.3564305604,
-0.0496156216,
-0.829405129,
0.581861794,
-0.86973387,
0.1854268014,
-0.3258760571,
0.0133559257,
-0.1153865904,
0.339248091,
-0.199321568,
0.8476264477,
0.6935654283,
-0.7747807503,
0.1772422194,
0.0654115155,
-0.1311061829,
0.4373238981,
-0.3191742301,
-0.0605480373,
-0.3020815849,
-0.0294403955,
-0.638295114,
-0.02287779,
0.2055598348,
-0.4907395244,
0.4741414487,
-0.3523133099,
-0.627022028,
-0.3176857531,
-0.1744809002,
0.3857788742,
0.282350421,
-0.6391909122,
0.7218319178,
0.3337535262,
0.0014372437,
-0.4977470934,
-0.8595957756,
0.2814762592,
-0.3805193007,
-0.4374817014,
0.3382251859,
0.0082577718,
-0.0337869711,
-0.0858330205,
0.1034317091,
-0.2410668433,
0.3309738934,
-0.2313015461,
0.0464332066,
-0.3403241336,
0.3508358896,
0.0386563353,
-0.3171682656,
-0.2999919951,
-0.7488918304,
0.6870948672,
-0.1305848062,
-0.3606939614,
-0.2313134521,
0.354668349,
0.8876548409,
-0.5125181675,
0.8212703466,
0.7955462337,
-0.4051769376,
0.1039388552,
-0.6662763953,
0.0543697663,
-0.410238266,
0.860938251,
-0.6334062219,
-0.888122201,
0.6161259413,
-0.1626397371,
0.518689394,
0.2350303233,
0.7824496627,
0.0482992195,
0.881523788,
0.8425776362,
-0.2585511506,
0.6712781191,
-0.1068967581,
0.1239448786,
-1.0174002647,
0.0372931287,
-0.5152698159,
-0.0632992536,
-0.7419601679,
-0.9979777932,
0.2909644246,
-0.0408149809,
-0.0716144964,
0.8207032681,
-0.0774068832,
0.3976497352,
0.3866615295,
-0.1630681306,
0.3495822549,
0.405774653,
-0.3615629375,
0.1682917625,
-0.9376074076,
-0.4278722107,
1.3120805025,
0.3820757866,
0.4135279357,
0.4895583987,
0.7258333564,
-0.069998458,
0.5803855062,
-0.5097197294,
0.2377852947,
-0.4344478846,
-0.4582216442,
-0.1925928295,
-0.7748578191,
-0.9598746896,
0.5887967348,
0.0393078662,
-0.4358485043,
0.0087351957,
0.4562832117,
-0.2801590562,
0.586853981,
-0.7501764894,
0.6338184476,
-0.103479296,
-0.0964093059,
-0.3625820279,
-0.2840156257,
0.1174963713,
-0.4194678366,
0.2510016859,
0.0267705191,
-0.0527201854,
0.4575837851,
-0.1360577941,
0.6408660412,
-0.1334408522,
-0.2460224479,
0.1271485388,
0.0506200157,
0.4530339241,
-0.1464748234,
-0.4288096726,
0.1988848597,
-0.1757204682,
-0.6209628582,
-0.6546213627,
0.5824682713,
-0.5375140309,
-0.3288973272,
0.0516536087,
-0.7078294158,
-0.1287925988,
0.2209190428,
-0.0546029583,
0.2999149859,
-0.2326627523,
0.3157773614,
0.641923368,
-0.3602263331,
0.4272191226,
0.6661955118,
-0.2548431158,
-0.3774500191,
1.0157716274,
0.4229298532,
0.50491786,
0.5694214106,
0.0957482159,
-0.1037458107,
-0.6919621825,
-0.80705899,
0.0957014188,
-0.5021666884,
-0.2027228922,
-0.8022531867,
0.0473589525,
-0.3857019246,
-0.039777711,
-0.663756609,
-0.6709864736,
0.0603441224,
-0.0072509483,
0.2304243147,
0.1623511016,
-0.2453403622,
0.6469554901,
-1.0026818514,
-0.0445762165,
-0.1091088206,
0.2392695993,
0.3016701639,
-0.5763114095,
-0.7889336944,
0.1884273142,
-0.4538196623,
-0.7707155347,
0.4861827791,
0.3191590011,
0.69701612,
0.1104150042,
-0.4630607367,
0.8634019494,
-0.9429198503,
0.3100229502,
0.0829641074,
-0.5916632414,
0.2560434937,
-0.3294458091,
0.5640672445,
0.3815009892,
0.5510857105,
-0.9174432755,
-0.1373313963,
-0.3780628443,
-0.8366858363,
0.238672182,
0.0607854314,
0.4143804908,
-0.08381138,
0.4202257395,
-0.1046973765,
0.1848041862,
-0.4866491854,
-0.1575231701,
0.0001453152,
-0.0789658725,
-0.4055078924,
-0.1514421552,
0.1469423473,
-0.1471882313,
0.7694534659,
-0.3218459785,
0.2444208711,
-0.2156177461,
-0.4246002436,
0.1238037944,
0.1653835773,
0.3998287022,
0.502718091,
0.0271802805,
0.1639379859,
0.5676508546,
-0.3720426261,
0.2026883066,
0.0844538212,
-0.3246451616,
-0.0171168875,
0.3408281803,
0.7932286263,
0.4846436977,
-0.5967972279,
-0.0110638486,
0.0837044939,
0.0923828185,
-0.1605750322,
-0.1612249315,
0.3904790282,
0.2134447247,
0.1161864474,
0.4431885481,
-0.0750176162,
-0.5618532896,
0.4780493677,
0.3177056909,
-0.2453515977,
-0.2516166866,
0.31940943,
-0.0665313751,
-0.3945412338,
0.8406350017,
-0.0896263868,
-0.6234415174,
0.4140200019,
0.6218927503,
0.7540077567,
-0.5655865669,
0.3379996121,
0.4443636537,
0.5648248196,
-0.3757783175,
0.0636731535,
0.0497480035,
-1.0173764229,
-0.5236330032,
-0.533051908,
-0.1768270135,
-0.2805399597,
-0.4862241745,
0.0505001694,
-0.1657219827,
-0.1455968022,
-0.177169919,
0.0027727776,
-0.6776378751,
-0.0794471949,
0.0394806899,
1.0454552174,
-0.9101786017,
1.0731909275,
0.7903675437,
-0.3778444529,
-0.8017783761,
-0.3238856792,
0.1357217878,
-0.8370346427,
0.3061155677,
0.0233372282,
-0.0123740314,
0.1507406831,
0.0104047339,
-0.9680933952,
0.9130384922,
0.2969352901,
-0.4359277189,
0.0359839834,
0.1110723391,
0.5498550534,
-0.3251725435,
0.1749865413,
0.3807421923,
0.314999193,
0.1649125814,
-0.8105106354,
-0.1206188649,
-0.213103652,
0.141516149,
0.4424953163,
-0.3939385712,
1.0239197016,
-0.3735633492,
-0.0989597291,
0.1638204604,
0.5609034896,
0.2336000055,
-0.0814718157,
0.4075400531,
0.6508257985,
0.8912706375,
0.1415429413,
0.9667087793,
-0.3575090766,
0.382042855,
1.2136923075,
-0.1098025888,
0.990978837,
0.5069402456,
0.1949543059,
0.1014153212,
0.6410035491,
-0.0929452255,
0.2887389064,
0.0432079732,
-0.2244440764,
-0.1012425423,
0.1219626442,
-0.4813915193,
0.4455235302,
0.1768176258,
-0.3596886992,
-0.5437495112,
0.2617340684,
0.4261364341,
-0.1639339775,
-0.1103091836,
0.5286944509,
0.0931381509,
-0.6294955015,
0.5630283356,
0.3881067038,
0.4400338829,
-0.5312370658,
-0.0603824072,
-0.4579598308,
0.3732952178,
0.2006936967,
-0.3263408542,
0.548641324,
0.0207463391,
-0.2675316036,
-0.543548584,
0.3787035048,
-0.5952611566,
-0.8260208964,
0.4071134925,
0.8803059459,
0.2182154804,
-0.0783326402,
-0.802496314,
0.0196853001,
0.1292844564,
-0.1036766991,
0.3742083013,
0.5114488006,
-0.3551790416,
1.0108932257,
0.8583504558,
0.4290098548,
0.326120466,
0.0593398549,
0.7406641245,
-0.4057751894,
-0.3612701595,
-0.8495916724,
0.4190279543,
0.1294257492,
-0.1526516229,
0.9537619948,
0.5573347807,
1.1440068483,
-0.1959772259,
0.4844944179,
0.1458255798,
0.3364863098,
-0.5065482855,
0.8272092342,
-0.8159060478,
0.4020409584,
-0.3073324859,
-0.8979298472,
-0.581926167,
0.597274065,
-0.0736701936,
0.131636709,
0.5306998491,
0.9809327126,
-0.2057895511,
-0.2886862457,
0.4009986818,
0.3526389301,
0.6064473987,
0.7009356618,
0.486084789,
-0.5427722931,
0.4047347009,
-0.3034555316,
-0.430559963,
-0.0927694738,
-0.9354349971,
-0.4189080596,
-0.4881878495,
-0.4659501612,
-0.1879508048,
0.1363163292,
0.7624758482,
0.7411066294,
-0.6949790716,
-0.4802369475,
0.1838877797,
0.187981084,
-0.6281065941,
-0.0576580875,
0.3566910923,
-0.4703761339,
-0.684452951,
0.493160665,
0.3491010666,
0.1841817349,
-0.1447663605,
-0.2031025887,
-0.3562709093,
-0.0563832819,
0.7879170775,
0.3638544977,
-0.3046073616,
-0.191598475,
-0.0347172432,
0.2251862288,
0.2317282259,
0.8270258904,
-0.566195488,
0.489033699,
0.4137198925,
1.0057399273,
0.3509066105,
-0.3328905106,
0.75340271,
-0.6901909709,
0.1460524499,
0.0001986188,
0.4675880373,
0.6575745344,
0.0517217033,
0.4556819797,
0.153673023,
-0.2443227768,
-0.7544931173,
0.4043826759,
-0.5317975283,
-0.197209239,
0.6176208258,
-0.2950460017,
-0.2027536035,
-0.1480935812,
-0.0016157434,
0.4158089459,
0.1976191252,
0.770796597,
0.6513251662,
0.2566643655,
-0.1649623662,
-0.8249004483,
0.1592881829,
0.5428634286,
-0.5854470134,
0.2409565598,
0.3083037436,
0.3204944134,
0.2420449555,
0.6979945898,
-0.378901422,
0.2167933732,
0.0225655455,
-0.0407394543,
-0.1001534685,
-0.6782978177,
-0.3715003431,
0.0023190947,
-0.0597225279,
-0.2948662639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03512v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03512v3 | A Survey on Arabic Named Entity Recognition: Past, Recent Advances, and Future Trends | 2023-02-07T14:56:52 | 2023-08-08T13:27:29 | Xiaoye Qu, Yingjie Gu, Qingrong Xia, Zechang Li, Zhefeng Wang, Baoxing Huai | cs.CL | cs.CL | As more and more Arabic texts emerged on the Internet, extracting important
information from these Arabic texts is especially useful. As a fundamental
technology, Named entity recognition (NER) serves as the core component in
information extraction technology, while also playing a critical role in many
other Natural Language Processing (NLP) systems, such as question answering and
knowledge graph building. In this paper, we provide a comprehensive review of
the development of Arabic NER, especially the recent advances in deep learning
and pre-trained language model. Specifically, we first introduce the background
of Arabic NER, including the characteristics of Arabic and existing resources
for Arabic NER. Then, we systematically review the development of Arabic NER
methods. Traditional Arabic NER systems focus on feature engineering and
designing domain-specific rules. In recent years, deep learning methods achieve
significant progress by representing texts via continuous vector
representations. With the growth of pre-trained language model, Arabic NER
yields better performance. Finally, we conclude the method gap between Arabic
NER and NER methods from other languages, which helps outline future directions
for Arabic NER. | [
-0.8178429008,
-0.6151541471,
0.4128904343,
-0.2344064415,
-0.1846096367,
0.3132153749,
-0.0728751794,
-0.9436281323,
0.1864809543,
0.6171116233,
-0.0379914083,
-0.5917967558,
-1.000169158,
0.508479476,
-0.6158096194,
0.9759359956,
-0.2484728247,
0.0721186176,
0.2562016249,
-0.1503757387,
-0.4135937989,
-0.7008551359,
-1.1043884754,
-0.146402806,
0.5047276616,
0.1954844296,
0.4834534824,
0.3218893409,
0.7018565536,
0.4345179796,
-0.0295684729,
0.1216743961,
0.1182448342,
0.2363714278,
-0.0062227128,
-0.057239607,
-0.3812224567,
-0.3058685362,
0.8443185091,
0.4176152647,
0.019516794,
-0.0424250513,
-0.2067769021,
0.6992281079,
-0.6500030756,
-0.0461382866,
-0.4494294524,
0.0291481651,
-0.4667911828,
0.1661275327,
-0.1440479904,
-0.4732215106,
0.4557286501,
-0.2450653613,
0.0848767981,
0.0510365814,
1.127848506,
0.0713374615,
-0.5912687778,
-0.6869543791,
-0.8996332288,
0.8018830419,
-0.5648661256,
0.7604529858,
0.2162264436,
0.6462340951,
-0.301372081,
-0.9884555936,
-0.6654020548,
-0.2541905642,
0.0868014991,
-0.2540089786,
-0.2815927863,
-0.1154886782,
0.113052398,
0.1999650896,
-0.1060741618,
0.1305058897,
-0.0251849853,
-0.3427621722,
0.5757405162,
-0.2431649417,
0.6786884069,
0.0033596058,
-0.3044469059,
0.2053095847,
-0.8856559992,
0.0208770968,
0.1938253045,
-0.0139289089,
0.2070332468,
0.318423599,
-0.2489986569,
0.5234438777,
0.113050729,
-0.3138213754,
0.1961993128,
0.0365006365,
-0.1273822188,
0.6255397797,
0.4607428312,
-0.0808069706,
0.3758526742,
-0.2603038251,
-0.2303593308,
-0.2605051398,
0.0771198124,
-1.1086493731,
-0.1876411736,
-0.1129539311,
-0.5431007147,
0.2404877394,
0.0707961097,
-0.5299026966,
-0.4180889428,
-0.307464689,
0.0621126629,
-0.4431147873,
-0.4661424756,
-0.0698729008,
0.0154720452,
0.4554947913,
0.7476527095,
-0.4740997255,
0.544350028,
0.5559370518,
0.4605790973,
-0.1768651456,
0.0519377142,
-0.1718917936,
-0.0442845598,
-0.2451199442,
0.8517424464,
-0.6433392763,
-0.1678720415,
-0.0082740616,
-0.131000936,
0.2505251765,
-0.6932969689,
0.4583339989,
-1.2737385035,
-0.0879134685,
-0.0748470649,
-0.6123630404,
-0.6743028164,
0.3201619387,
-0.8246691823,
0.6505845785,
-0.2020145357,
-0.9730377793,
0.4383743405,
-0.6231406927,
-0.3527792692,
0.3224043548,
-0.3457162976,
-0.5073002577,
-0.0470664985,
0.4695859849,
0.3249839246,
-0.3805618882,
0.2036638558,
0.1825327873,
-0.2660974562,
0.4829844236,
-0.2973433137,
0.4199534357,
0.2790857255,
-0.5207378864,
-0.2387552559,
-0.8769025803,
0.2082756609,
-0.015133067,
-0.1938948929,
-0.3271255195,
0.1727292985,
0.1385624707,
0.0886859819,
0.2452466935,
-0.4347284436,
-0.06112919,
-0.3940736353,
0.2957410812,
0.2945179641,
0.3182297945,
0.412373364,
0.1582903266,
0.4507867396,
0.1353624016,
-0.3616451025,
0.0004307012,
-0.272108525,
-1.0540596247,
-0.1869781017,
0.8366913199,
0.399625212,
-0.5244032741,
0.2395734638,
-0.2205490172,
-0.6139681339,
-0.4059675038,
-0.1715655029,
0.3481143713,
0.3462461531,
0.5451270938,
-0.328418076,
-0.8618478179,
-0.9210122228,
-0.2831921279,
-0.0438397191,
0.2803095877,
0.4088976681,
0.4742603898,
-0.4550642073,
0.9206571579,
-0.3219958544,
-0.1932483166,
-0.4506559968,
0.3113414645,
0.1367712617,
0.3384587467,
0.39567101,
-1.1298713684,
-0.599170804,
0.2447396964,
-0.5128158331,
0.133024767,
0.2341499776,
0.1328880638,
0.2821512222,
0.528005302,
-0.5145067573,
0.5120515823,
0.1254099011,
-0.0522131659,
0.3084684312,
0.2590577006,
0.1315398216,
-0.9816981554,
-0.0396589898,
-0.2008529305,
-0.1314807832,
-0.5715264678,
-0.0598759539,
-0.0392877571,
-0.0651060045,
-0.4078220725,
0.8167240024,
-1.0460755825,
0.0098102149,
-0.5404320955,
-0.1155850217,
-0.4058003128,
-0.1455670446,
0.2731172144,
0.824113071,
0.6235248446,
-1.0717417002,
0.2461897582,
0.204358831,
-0.5518891811,
0.3617645204,
-0.5544562936,
0.4875150621,
-0.359262377,
-0.0574597828,
-0.3937175572,
-0.0436607972,
0.3989920914,
-0.4972142875,
0.671235919,
-0.1350710392,
-0.3249656856,
-0.204283908,
0.3038011789,
0.5581865311,
0.5109599233,
-0.362110287,
0.8169038892,
0.6875542402,
-0.4814744294,
-0.882591784,
-0.2675589621,
0.3579491973,
-0.1681640446,
-0.1847329289,
0.657648325,
0.3538798094,
-0.3590377569,
0.0711178407,
-0.3284598887,
-0.5141040087,
0.2078850418,
0.3286942542,
-0.099295646,
-0.3551424742,
0.2927096188,
0.0196465775,
-0.3127022386,
0.0775977001,
-0.1172540188,
0.525754869,
-0.1061425433,
-0.1600955874,
-0.4787656665,
0.4073743224,
-0.0462345034,
-0.5336110592,
0.7464654446,
0.7035451531,
-0.6542336345,
0.0727931112,
-0.7711489201,
0.0124571659,
-0.4321989417,
0.5103357434,
-0.4551181793,
-0.9164019227,
0.2154533714,
-0.5616329312,
-0.1933303028,
0.608894527,
0.2581920326,
0.0676137879,
0.9209050536,
1.1108772755,
-0.1498070657,
0.4596790373,
-0.0291817784,
0.6228287816,
-0.673807919,
-0.3364738524,
-0.8152894378,
-0.4657399058,
-0.83777529,
0.0737907141,
-0.0821843892,
0.1802427173,
-0.3080111742,
0.5062617064,
-0.3262857497,
0.3750246167,
0.3221900165,
-0.4668940306,
0.1698555201,
0.1171176434,
0.020796407,
-0.2495724857,
-0.0111210793,
-0.8593996763,
0.7067340612,
0.1291502416,
0.4395242631,
0.225376159,
1.136878252,
0.4649225175,
0.4932837486,
-0.559694171,
0.5981847644,
0.2766681612,
-0.5009478331,
-0.1458328366,
-0.1954933703,
-1.1267038584,
-0.1617177576,
-0.0664665774,
-0.6615623832,
0.1511715949,
-0.2438762933,
-0.1793417633,
0.2258755267,
-0.3401579559,
0.3345195055,
-0.3446496427,
0.3213154078,
-0.0010490895,
-0.5982021093,
-0.2073968947,
-0.1064283848,
0.0777871832,
-0.0877610072,
-0.2627693713,
0.9527429342,
-0.1873162538,
0.1727751046,
-0.233943522,
0.0940883532,
0.5210904479,
-0.1491375566,
0.4012125731,
0.1848237365,
-0.0555696897,
0.3816434145,
-0.2469494045,
-0.1690997481,
-0.3813303709,
0.7194908857,
-0.8064160943,
-0.6120857596,
-0.7717347741,
-0.0296927076,
0.0949171707,
0.6544770002,
0.2197127342,
0.1402769983,
-0.4176565111,
-0.0655221641,
0.5472624898,
-0.2468631715,
0.8212641478,
0.54623276,
-0.4162542224,
-0.6272934079,
0.8596484065,
0.3092161119,
-0.4756263793,
0.7958412766,
-0.4546796679,
-0.2003576607,
-1.0486127138,
-0.4522714615,
0.1736824363,
-0.5313484669,
-0.4336000979,
-0.9826791286,
-0.7221087217,
-0.2909347415,
0.0584758744,
-0.1796151102,
-0.1974559426,
-0.4467853606,
-0.0842253789,
0.2958301902,
0.8484857082,
0.4052799046,
0.2182991505,
-0.9744406343,
0.1779834777,
0.2397213578,
0.0069001587,
0.0638956949,
-0.191437155,
-0.2078950554,
-0.2140555382,
-0.1728626639,
-1.0857797861,
0.563088119,
0.2529112101,
0.3871445358,
0.5644634366,
-0.0421789996,
0.5593597293,
-0.7803598642,
0.5392534733,
-0.0171885565,
-0.8422006369,
0.3277695477,
0.3200478256,
-0.07680621,
0.3135646284,
0.7350372076,
-0.6245016456,
0.2460414469,
-0.5890621543,
-0.9037461877,
0.3524069488,
0.2240661234,
0.2482816428,
-0.1421331018,
0.4039023817,
0.2346818596,
0.4216773212,
-0.5764343739,
-0.5412322879,
0.0898602828,
0.0149986353,
0.1796409637,
-0.4334970415,
0.5904094577,
-0.0968781337,
0.7007083297,
0.2380935103,
0.4444356859,
0.1715349257,
-0.4242034256,
0.3392504156,
0.7487567663,
0.1163939312,
0.39374277,
0.0367073528,
0.2162154168,
0.2817136645,
-0.6632224917,
0.2947019637,
0.5480650663,
-0.4079260528,
0.2616315186,
0.097609885,
0.6107603908,
-0.0267891623,
-0.4643681347,
0.2411010414,
-0.1217347905,
0.2007108033,
-0.9494916797,
0.0402629748,
0.0246786736,
0.3354183733,
0.6558613181,
0.1664280295,
0.4187320471,
-0.225418821,
0.0864214003,
0.4806779325,
-0.525854528,
-0.1923262328,
0.2824896276,
-0.0095220422,
-0.5704297423,
0.8766353726,
-0.3332569897,
-0.6240817904,
0.6744463444,
0.6159062982,
0.8310810328,
-0.2512352765,
0.17930682,
0.3893313706,
0.0219572745,
0.2355370373,
0.4864118397,
-0.2153835893,
-0.8679065108,
-0.1326280236,
-0.7280418873,
-0.2865125835,
0.204130128,
-0.2541390657,
0.3413997591,
-0.5949867368,
-0.5627115965,
0.3051001728,
0.3321008682,
-0.990552783,
0.5053414106,
0.3998018801,
0.6732342243,
-0.1298948973,
0.7066295743,
1.1074203253,
-0.4491142333,
-0.6514877677,
-0.0193929672,
-0.1046538502,
-0.4876039922,
1.1166962385,
0.4980260134,
-0.3059309423,
0.3899198472,
-0.4149535,
-1.4188232422,
0.8528957963,
0.0508936495,
-0.563519299,
-0.2333331853,
-0.0021895489,
0.3521956205,
-0.3767791986,
0.5495215058,
0.1944720596,
0.5290620923,
-0.2286467254,
-0.5171477795,
-0.0615870096,
-0.3517032564,
0.1314790398,
0.7336578965,
-0.1680202782,
0.8348267674,
-0.2907436192,
-0.8181993365,
0.3436435759,
1.1383590698,
-0.0717568472,
0.4433649778,
0.1291663349,
0.589551568,
0.7548517585,
-0.0968775302,
0.7223840952,
-0.1749164909,
-0.17484954,
0.9162946343,
-0.4972568452,
0.8685759306,
0.2981183231,
-0.1676197946,
0.899410069,
0.5144911408,
-0.0251041651,
0.5081027746,
0.338223964,
-0.4606790543,
-0.0789608061,
-0.4458425641,
-0.7243378162,
0.5042856336,
0.3513670266,
-0.5638341904,
-0.2616400123,
0.006223883,
0.2654135823,
-0.1584293693,
-0.4287966192,
0.9421725869,
0.2375686616,
-0.3554973304,
0.2074145526,
0.3357554078,
0.5356377959,
-0.3409532607,
-0.5017798543,
0.1607433856,
0.1387295723,
-0.0772064179,
-0.3361616135,
0.0071552107,
0.1073130444,
-0.2133418471,
0.0591090061,
1.1503969431,
-0.0689704195,
-0.4277187288,
0.3278284371,
0.6519711614,
0.3693886101,
-0.2591068745,
-0.3561104834,
-0.2671740651,
-0.299223572,
0.0719225481,
0.3289932907,
0.5052819848,
-0.1017675176,
0.4668834805,
0.5787451267,
0.1196375638,
0.0637564659,
-0.006413396,
0.6311195493,
-1.1374460459,
-0.1451779902,
-0.8162881136,
0.0688013583,
-0.1383576542,
-0.2246151268,
0.6861249208,
0.3336501718,
0.950781405,
0.1110115722,
0.5869393945,
-0.1085099354,
0.6015750766,
-0.4245632887,
0.9634037614,
-0.2844122052,
-0.0680135861,
-0.2554018199,
-1.1200493574,
-0.2018319219,
0.4731763303,
-0.1726137996,
0.3219756484,
0.6693326235,
0.39115116,
0.2132772803,
0.0153350374,
0.0336613096,
0.0818678215,
0.1160192043,
0.2604110539,
0.9824176431,
-0.6368871927,
0.2963117957,
-0.1027850658,
0.3351018727,
-0.2319568992,
-0.8153381944,
-0.6583319306,
-0.470608592,
-0.5384654999,
-0.0308592711,
0.2251903117,
0.9717848301,
0.5553270578,
-1.1472213268,
0.1344262213,
-0.2687787414,
0.3287268281,
-0.2484490275,
-0.1481933892,
0.5280946493,
-0.0519705862,
-0.805873692,
0.1933589578,
0.2333921343,
0.2850804627,
0.2980147004,
-0.1852390617,
-0.2399550825,
-0.1433575898,
0.3655343652,
0.6125748754,
-0.7296841741,
-0.0579148196,
-0.0254700575,
-0.2441078573,
0.1685556769,
0.5536654592,
-1.0393080711,
0.0768312141,
0.2893906832,
1.0748199224,
0.3337461054,
-0.2595916688,
0.2529464066,
-0.1663646996,
-0.2308850288,
0.5615864396,
0.3691107929,
0.554449141,
-0.2972426713,
0.257161051,
-0.1948701739,
-0.4914918542,
-0.4765702784,
0.4022654891,
-0.5567783713,
0.1611035168,
0.6540529728,
-0.0863342583,
-0.0269053541,
-0.523180604,
-0.4485310316,
0.5009092689,
-0.5958895087,
0.5718588233,
0.6292071939,
-0.0913317278,
-0.5145777464,
-0.2787675261,
0.5616018772,
0.2170848548,
-0.8484040499,
-0.7866811156,
0.4253431857,
0.1171059757,
0.3115561903,
0.508777082,
-0.1193619221,
0.1523950994,
-0.282907635,
0.2042253315,
0.1112650633,
-0.6553001404,
-0.0679712072,
0.3028756976,
0.4955560267,
0.0052864086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03508v1 | Cluster-Level Contrastive Learning for Emotion Recognition in Conversations | 2023-02-07T14:49:20 | 2023-02-07T14:49:20 | Kailai Yang, Tianlin Zhang, Hassan Alhuzali, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A key challenge for Emotion Recognition in Conversations (ERC) is to
distinguish semantically similar emotions. Some works utilise Supervised
Contrastive Learning (SCL) which uses categorical emotion labels as supervision
signals and contrasts in high-dimensional semantic space. However, categorical
labels fail to provide quantitative information between emotions. ERC is also
not equally dependent on all embedded features in the semantic space, which
makes the high-dimensional SCL inefficient. To address these issues, we propose
a novel low-dimensional Supervised Cluster-level Contrastive Learning (SCCL)
method, which first reduces the high-dimensional SCL space to a
three-dimensional affect representation space Valence-Arousal-Dominance (VAD),
then performs cluster-level contrastive learning to incorporate measurable
emotion prototypes. To help modelling the dialogue and enriching the context,
we leverage the pre-trained knowledge adapters to infuse linguistic and factual
knowledge. Experiments show that our method achieves new state-of-the-art
results with 69.81% on IEMOCAP, 65.7% on MELD, and 62.51% on DailyDialog
datasets. The analysis also proves that the VAD space is not only suitable for
ERC but also interpretable, with VAD prototypes enhancing its performance and
stabilising the training of SCCL. In addition, the pre-trained knowledge
adapters benefit the performance of the utterance encoder and SCCL. Our code is
available at: https://github.com/SteveKGYang/SCCL | [
-0.4169398844,
-0.6040252447,
0.4302489758,
0.1000286192,
-0.2875290513,
0.082190305,
-0.1571028233,
-0.4251018465,
0.3030497134,
0.3021127582,
-0.5118669271,
-0.9970900416,
-0.5609547496,
-0.0741340742,
-0.1705182195,
0.9144262075,
0.0778742731,
-0.0573772117,
-0.4715923667,
-0.3414190412,
0.0400572531,
-0.8057388067,
-0.6837085485,
-0.0487010963,
0.5002298355,
0.5762326121,
-0.0395838954,
0.1217425317,
0.277577728,
0.3283581734,
-0.6090151072,
0.1481869966,
-0.82063061,
0.1260863245,
0.2340681553,
-0.3795034587,
-0.2186651379,
-0.205708459,
0.2194350511,
0.4109474421,
-0.5494120717,
-0.397434473,
0.1106028706,
0.8060832024,
-0.7960577607,
0.3958700597,
-0.7447767258,
0.3383326232,
0.1578107327,
-0.0333392061,
-0.4030213356,
-0.2665953934,
0.4071696699,
-0.4636884928,
0.0817328021,
0.0885060281,
0.7524576187,
0.4353369474,
-0.4808310866,
-0.408729434,
-0.4499697983,
0.6041527987,
-0.7650682926,
0.3002663255,
0.3941146731,
0.2441877127,
0.3042554259,
-0.4257591963,
-0.6834486127,
0.0923277587,
-0.3240964115,
0.5600770712,
-0.4377868176,
0.1354598105,
0.2409574836,
0.4721555412,
-0.4563058913,
0.165836364,
-0.4469383955,
0.0244689826,
0.2650673985,
0.3317595124,
-0.0702573732,
-0.0864542425,
-0.3978661597,
-0.2959577739,
-0.3732277155,
0.1768753827,
-0.0149356229,
0.2311521024,
-0.5045508146,
0.0177293476,
-0.1595455706,
0.2829891741,
0.351008594,
0.086426802,
0.5129179358,
0.1533656716,
-0.2405006588,
0.2874579728,
0.5928965211,
0.3509525955,
-0.2544235289,
0.3989900053,
0.2191033661,
0.353512615,
0.2167349905,
-0.8518045545,
-0.2083434612,
0.1518435478,
-0.4065359235,
-0.3571934104,
-0.1129762009,
-1.0530523062,
-0.6609887481,
-0.1756048799,
0.1438644826,
-0.3670035005,
-0.1492878348,
0.1527002752,
0.2644464374,
0.1258551329,
0.3683385253,
-0.784942627,
0.4632249773,
0.2282701582,
0.5962553024,
-0.3474141657,
0.0911499262,
-0.4399033785,
-0.0114548551,
-0.202424109,
0.7743521333,
-0.5888122916,
-0.4841385186,
0.1485193521,
-0.1147417724,
-0.06485679,
-0.6381271482,
0.4884977043,
-0.186953038,
0.2989668846,
0.1238932684,
-0.3824289739,
-0.1853320748,
0.3105561733,
-0.2885453105,
0.9488373995,
0.0424867086,
-1.0638583899,
0.0369016901,
-0.5132991672,
-0.4360065758,
-0.1814146936,
-0.1451440603,
-0.5378143191,
0.0829502121,
0.2016796917,
0.584728837,
0.037893068,
-0.1419543326,
-0.428403616,
-0.2540084124,
0.1251490563,
-0.1185393557,
0.2454933077,
0.3419064879,
-0.2653273046,
0.3232196867,
-0.9628652334,
-0.2936301529,
-0.1236007586,
-0.137132585,
-0.5075133443,
0.0572263934,
-0.3656398952,
0.5147237182,
0.1231847703,
-0.5216784477,
-0.3854805231,
-0.4355990887,
0.287173152,
0.7689000368,
0.065755643,
0.3487417102,
0.2408321649,
0.4109063745,
0.7990071774,
0.0769353285,
-0.111922197,
0.0276197474,
-1.2748454809,
-0.3243801296,
-0.1519728899,
0.5771474242,
-0.7350741029,
0.6754283309,
0.0989616513,
-0.5985341668,
-0.6650416255,
-0.1523700655,
0.5130070448,
0.6680054069,
0.5655189753,
-0.2766049504,
-0.4542275071,
-0.8983011842,
0.022018075,
-0.1749962568,
0.0390720665,
0.9311759472,
0.201524362,
-0.3128894866,
0.6274824739,
-0.5889606476,
-0.3760556877,
-0.1357640475,
0.5118021369,
0.0258148275,
0.3592529893,
0.1635621935,
-0.6778789759,
-0.5993177295,
0.3224288225,
-0.7177498341,
-0.219050929,
0.0920663252,
-0.1994330883,
0.2861168683,
0.7906051278,
-0.162580207,
0.7383583784,
0.648694694,
-0.3176837564,
0.1777439415,
-0.2075505704,
0.2477694899,
-1.1034665108,
-0.2410340905,
0.1157387272,
-0.0188638326,
-0.71746099,
-0.632655859,
-0.1080311909,
-0.1543285698,
-0.7433150411,
0.1714639813,
-0.141513288,
-0.059441641,
-0.065649271,
0.3778790534,
-0.248259604,
0.8088648915,
0.3191167414,
0.4147429764,
0.5068623424,
-0.5748242736,
0.1515086144,
0.4166300297,
-0.3192089498,
1.1529347897,
-0.3662204444,
0.1790658087,
-0.2855088711,
0.4117302895,
-1.0078942776,
-0.0640083551,
0.1138967574,
-0.2725998759,
0.1120843142,
0.1776140779,
-0.1083255634,
-0.1629212797,
0.048507072,
0.4604180157,
0.6341986656,
-0.8134467602,
0.9832162261,
0.3030005395,
-0.4254140854,
-0.2693505883,
-0.6353707314,
-0.3044822514,
-0.4504110515,
-0.3108364344,
0.1446656734,
-0.0743288696,
0.0367060788,
-0.1908277273,
-0.2553005517,
-0.0271001346,
-0.1520559043,
0.5831930041,
0.072894983,
0.0958244279,
0.2501912713,
0.2522785664,
-0.1943179369,
-0.0183715783,
0.1811979115,
0.5115714073,
-0.5391743183,
-0.3521643877,
-0.6118159294,
0.4591515064,
0.3510907888,
-0.0770033076,
0.6723992825,
0.7427987456,
-0.3233449161,
-0.1576451808,
-0.4634966552,
-0.2205841094,
-0.4449745417,
0.4655282795,
-0.3061355054,
-1.4254485369,
0.5348758101,
-0.3634321392,
-0.2804678082,
0.3967163265,
0.4520985186,
-0.3484483063,
1.0769551992,
0.5683633685,
-0.16812253,
0.5807956457,
0.0830489546,
0.4284826517,
-0.8716107607,
-0.2150940746,
-0.5629558563,
-0.3647125661,
-0.3520374596,
-0.4015514553,
0.5380027294,
-0.0542361662,
-0.3317476213,
0.0505892485,
-0.3277525008,
0.4094837904,
0.2022653073,
0.3190278709,
0.1216000393,
0.0794361979,
-0.0555828847,
-0.3550144136,
-0.5365163684,
-0.0772643387,
0.3704042733,
0.2039442956,
0.6221756935,
-0.1246468872,
0.8367258906,
0.1386053413,
0.2814168036,
-0.5722004771,
0.6130626202,
-0.322827667,
-0.0871784985,
0.0544999279,
-0.6457149386,
-0.7220640182,
0.3904566467,
-0.419359833,
-0.9123946428,
0.4783700705,
0.153684184,
-0.2071155161,
0.1986890137,
-0.7650045753,
0.8053089976,
-0.0254835058,
-0.1709003747,
-0.5873156786,
-0.9135783315,
0.1359427869,
0.1019808799,
0.2682591379,
0.0663856268,
0.3504524827,
0.6851621866,
-0.3155082464,
1.1855492592,
-0.1804850996,
-0.0278016739,
0.1796310842,
0.0387194008,
0.3861648738,
-0.3150749505,
0.106223993,
-0.0111517459,
-0.1153869778,
-0.394425571,
-0.7207852006,
0.6057732105,
-0.64835006,
-0.3433973789,
-0.2733592987,
-0.3337813616,
-0.3689023256,
-0.1378683597,
0.0079358965,
0.1557901502,
-0.4430859387,
0.3954511881,
0.8756161928,
-0.442078054,
0.0526857525,
0.5387071967,
-0.0296630245,
-0.4545968771,
1.1010529995,
-0.4812577367,
0.3658884764,
0.3749248683,
0.1868005693,
0.0095767612,
-0.0780657828,
0.1677268147,
0.1043488756,
-0.8308595419,
-0.2192213088,
-0.7990460396,
-0.1519088298,
-0.0740148053,
-0.3845347762,
-0.3619452417,
-0.084317252,
-0.592404604,
-0.3168297708,
0.3689266443,
0.5458291769,
-0.1641650945,
0.4303744733,
-0.6793689728,
0.1430327445,
0.5763285756,
0.1777033359,
-0.0416255929,
-0.4828652442,
-0.2610263824,
-0.0767118707,
-0.2907545567,
-0.6326550245,
0.5721482038,
0.2683781683,
0.1312512904,
0.7871044874,
0.3791127503,
0.6713967323,
-0.127014339,
0.7767009139,
0.5150529742,
-1.0861469507,
0.5646967888,
-0.1106220931,
0.2607992589,
0.7109028697,
0.5457258821,
-0.6237544417,
-0.1554769129,
-0.8274896145,
-0.8904378414,
0.7406727672,
0.0174039844,
-0.0692296177,
-0.1746558696,
0.100148797,
0.015418224,
0.2550003231,
-0.604528904,
-0.1760897338,
-0.073186703,
-0.6907663941,
-0.0037457682,
-0.4627025127,
-0.111146979,
-0.1136173606,
0.4884622991,
-0.1498833746,
0.3546393216,
0.1747895032,
0.010595358,
0.0340901725,
0.4714777172,
0.465891242,
-0.1371936202,
-0.2787616551,
0.2890408337,
0.6778796911,
-0.0952422097,
-0.1658220142,
-0.0496952049,
0.4531336427,
-0.3114545643,
-0.0259301085,
1.1697444916,
0.4331127107,
-0.709379375,
0.6079115868,
-0.1249093935,
-0.4307500422,
-0.0568587929,
-0.1468564421,
0.1358680874,
0.5616612434,
-0.0551378317,
-0.0623737089,
0.162715286,
-0.398670435,
0.0030450153,
0.0072483565,
-0.8873157501,
-0.2364017367,
0.1576388776,
0.3561860323,
-0.0188160148,
0.4701074958,
-0.1319604069,
-0.8930981159,
0.2950582206,
0.5908820033,
0.6964017749,
-0.419832617,
0.1948474497,
0.324767828,
-0.2451913208,
0.2948251367,
0.2774054706,
-0.4056130946,
-0.6580452919,
0.0180815551,
-0.4182960689,
-0.6783440113,
-0.298738271,
-0.8287958503,
-0.0312098395,
-0.4368854761,
0.1940655112,
-0.4528527856,
-0.330691576,
-0.6406899691,
0.2645673156,
0.3943573236,
0.5697917342,
-0.9705241323,
0.51276052,
0.4738088846,
-0.0324342772,
-0.5644917488,
-0.3347740471,
0.1246146038,
-0.574316442,
0.5297509432,
0.2102741301,
-0.4217904806,
0.0217036363,
-0.5733107924,
-0.3841532469,
1.0866098404,
-0.0480325036,
-0.5815796852,
0.3640332818,
-0.0908488557,
0.8952943683,
-0.8669077158,
0.3484917581,
0.6105877757,
0.175780654,
0.4348348081,
-0.4299639165,
-0.2019495368,
-0.3777295351,
-0.055508364,
0.0541428998,
-0.5979600549,
0.4393094182,
-0.0953189656,
-0.3276847899,
-0.1191579774,
0.9011207819,
0.4454354644,
0.5840312839,
0.8332577944,
0.7718615532,
0.8120204806,
-0.1978259534,
0.5763734579,
-0.1902551502,
0.235806182,
1.0603302717,
-0.4262816012,
1.2825313807,
0.4218460023,
-0.166371733,
0.9031946659,
0.5939318538,
0.2811180353,
0.6038464308,
0.4451457858,
-0.5729252696,
-0.3345698714,
-0.3863736093,
-0.1066541299,
0.1917201579,
0.8699935675,
-0.0732461065,
0.0067026424,
0.1974855959,
-0.1543798447,
0.1242249832,
-0.2192101926,
1.2596216202,
0.2407547086,
0.012767422,
0.4502524734,
-0.6253600121,
0.8583314419,
-0.4433881938,
-0.0675176457,
-0.2852593362,
0.1539190114,
-0.431910634,
-0.4541073143,
0.0971752256,
0.0596482903,
0.0520765707,
0.022561444,
0.5931138396,
-0.9254771471,
-0.1372470111,
0.4905508161,
0.2086964846,
0.3464615047,
0.0359815694,
-0.422499299,
0.1778559983,
-0.0288142283,
0.0070498115,
0.3917664289,
0.6612645388,
0.2636118829,
0.4323211014,
0.3789415956,
-0.1518482119,
-0.3198338151,
0.1461238712,
1.0897703171,
-0.7577075362,
-0.77737993,
-0.3816154599,
0.7243270874,
-0.3163831234,
-0.2419403046,
0.1628139168,
0.2275768071,
0.7562864423,
-0.0195381567,
0.622594595,
0.1032856181,
0.663557291,
-0.3985489905,
0.422537297,
-0.6248921752,
0.1449027956,
-0.5717762709,
-0.6400944591,
-0.4003271461,
0.8845373988,
-0.3459390402,
-0.1460087895,
0.9449083209,
0.7079271674,
0.0751466006,
0.3501321375,
0.4293595552,
0.5937470198,
0.2176674306,
0.9293115735,
1.0275257826,
-0.1994071156,
0.7007785439,
-0.165484786,
-0.2836050987,
-0.3721458316,
-0.8595372438,
-0.9730834961,
-0.6610252857,
-0.4057394862,
-0.2144909501,
0.0782432109,
0.8194772005,
0.6253780723,
-0.7405016422,
-0.0847361088,
-0.1197324991,
-0.1077223271,
-0.0043654018,
-0.2173651904,
0.4526506364,
-0.2060406059,
-0.4559621513,
0.3244522214,
0.4943679869,
0.055226665,
0.2240383923,
-0.2884086668,
-0.0619082935,
-0.0579271056,
0.7364761233,
0.2035397142,
-0.5896970034,
-0.2796367109,
-0.3477894068,
-0.1921852976,
0.2921135426,
0.6745789051,
-0.7118684053,
0.457646817,
0.3266020119,
0.6321625113,
0.910366714,
0.0830652341,
0.2821356058,
-0.710734427,
0.1879216135,
0.1411243826,
0.3168640137,
0.354564786,
-0.2461202592,
0.3465368748,
0.0224557985,
-0.5056217313,
-0.4200947583,
0.3679813743,
-1.4323430061,
0.0279563628,
0.8921943307,
-0.3790655136,
-0.1551117599,
0.1406726837,
-0.6395071745,
0.0901006758,
-0.6623221636,
0.8925894499,
0.5824601054,
-0.2614581585,
-0.5019268394,
0.0511194319,
0.4001736641,
0.553224206,
-1.1839517355,
0.2362908274,
0.5795974731,
-0.2689265609,
0.1472429186,
0.3812363744,
-0.215056181,
0.0449119769,
0.0516454317,
0.2932404876,
0.2584955394,
-0.1388241202,
-0.578110218,
0.1288447231,
-0.3822106421,
0.109615922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03491v1 | Learning Translation Quality Evaluation on Low Resource Languages from Large Language Models | 2023-02-07T14:35:35 | 2023-02-07T14:35:35 | Amirkeivan Mohtashami, Mauro Verzetti, Paul K. Rubenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Learned metrics such as BLEURT have in recent years become widely employed to
evaluate the quality of machine translation systems. Training such metrics
requires data which can be expensive and difficult to acquire, particularly for
lower-resource languages. We show how knowledge can be distilled from Large
Language Models (LLMs) to improve upon such learned metrics without requiring
human annotators, by creating synthetic datasets which can be mixed into
existing datasets, requiring only a corpus of text in the target language. We
show that the performance of a BLEURT-like model on lower resource languages
can be improved in this way. | [
-0.0902483091,
-0.2429935187,
0.5553489327,
-0.0914635584,
-0.3819289207,
0.3976276219,
-0.619586885,
-0.5605035424,
-0.140029341,
0.5950655937,
-0.4271396995,
-0.475759536,
-0.8855502009,
0.2160511613,
-0.4053122997,
1.0432585478,
-0.0466352664,
0.3506667912,
0.0414358266,
-0.309279114,
-0.2386196107,
-0.5048323274,
-0.3929330111,
-0.5477334261,
0.4601973891,
0.5559139848,
0.6069488525,
0.3715492785,
0.6767753363,
0.3324090838,
-0.1975677907,
0.7185572982,
-0.816202879,
0.1774272323,
-0.4199841917,
-0.4670539796,
-0.3175790906,
0.039448183,
0.8280213475,
1.0163506269,
-0.018381685,
0.2979286611,
0.1399681568,
0.8997408748,
-0.4946403205,
0.0434396565,
-0.6621102095,
-0.0556555539,
-0.0309248641,
0.0086479699,
-0.417268604,
-0.5424190164,
0.1570420712,
-0.4413147271,
0.2772497833,
0.0886840522,
0.9272132516,
0.3852039278,
-0.3259277344,
-0.3662953377,
-1.1679047346,
1.2701218128,
-0.7305104136,
0.7835479379,
0.5642246604,
0.4035829008,
-0.0518284254,
-0.5915618539,
-0.3721264005,
-0.4219263792,
-0.2953593731,
0.0830089971,
-0.1543236375,
-0.1685869247,
0.2772438824,
0.6524467468,
-0.4442115724,
0.2294641286,
-0.7801736593,
-0.2730303109,
0.7919415236,
0.1806156933,
0.1095464453,
-0.0657034516,
-0.1979535073,
-0.3802191615,
-0.7463877201,
-0.219878599,
0.1729558706,
0.3298701942,
-0.1423792541,
0.5583078861,
-0.1608633548,
0.6314556599,
-0.068669796,
-0.3561356962,
0.4409402609,
-0.4444151521,
-0.3153481781,
-0.1331447661,
0.7752103209,
0.127786234,
0.2159788758,
-0.3955221772,
-0.6451945305,
0.0184490662,
0.1425610185,
-0.9465222955,
-0.1998174191,
0.1507621408,
-0.4403295517,
-0.0369237736,
-0.2470191419,
-0.6610623002,
-0.2020144761,
-0.4097527862,
0.1188532189,
-0.546323061,
-0.0798447058,
-0.0900849253,
-0.0034605365,
0.128423959,
0.4357509613,
-0.8558920026,
0.1472065598,
0.3826422989,
0.981338203,
-0.1563997418,
-0.2515389919,
-0.7555833459,
-0.0571187027,
-0.5608299375,
0.4717707038,
-0.2208128721,
-0.5618430972,
-0.02797563,
-0.0475773327,
0.1357317865,
-0.8034541011,
0.4639640749,
-0.6654290557,
-0.0774740428,
-0.1153788269,
-0.6563611031,
-0.2710706294,
0.2617815435,
-0.7475739717,
1.0038355589,
0.5263900161,
-0.4414868355,
0.4268707037,
-0.4043986797,
-0.6772361398,
0.2459704578,
0.1587085277,
-0.1666084528,
0.5048218966,
0.3359867036,
0.3811315,
-0.5853487849,
-0.0485071652,
-0.035005521,
-0.1638652682,
0.3592355251,
-0.4823392928,
0.6224630475,
0.5101915002,
0.1569652855,
-0.2122297287,
-0.7770701647,
0.0158123579,
-0.2120456249,
-0.7374744415,
-0.4934339821,
-0.1086940914,
0.0299189948,
0.09272407,
0.3825227618,
-0.6125192046,
0.0831197873,
-0.5605316758,
0.3411533833,
0.4443972409,
-0.1042148769,
0.6055768132,
-0.1616404653,
0.4252604842,
0.1104277447,
0.0016206207,
0.2598858476,
-0.084253259,
-0.9018341303,
-0.4954964817,
0.5942855477,
0.3858109713,
-0.9615729451,
0.1313678771,
-0.476110816,
-0.6299032569,
-0.9383538365,
0.7872484326,
0.4924092293,
0.3103401959,
0.5296362042,
-0.2549293339,
-0.3572964966,
-0.6545992494,
0.1078790352,
-0.0439348072,
-0.0560918003,
-0.0122064063,
0.4469013214,
-0.3115538955,
0.4170103371,
-0.5038469434,
-0.2037952989,
-0.6385536194,
0.0592466556,
0.3579693437,
0.4159028828,
0.4234547615,
-0.5627911687,
-0.3790997565,
0.3597437739,
-0.6289362907,
-0.0731877536,
0.2779298425,
-0.0785551965,
0.2505603135,
0.6122108698,
-0.3284295797,
-0.0205149129,
1.0828739405,
-0.0216174386,
0.5192816854,
-0.3868936002,
0.2559384108,
-1.0047131777,
0.1757110655,
0.1198907867,
-0.4695004523,
-0.6345388889,
-0.028669931,
0.0804378167,
-0.0503421128,
-0.6820940971,
0.7635748982,
-0.4404645562,
-0.1776276082,
-0.2548323572,
0.2668484747,
0.0841595009,
0.2439599931,
0.1510114223,
0.7516248226,
0.1274050474,
-0.6646162868,
0.4795034528,
0.404966116,
-0.7793462276,
0.6607066393,
-0.4216987789,
0.1010597944,
-0.0503667593,
-0.07789433,
-0.6536107659,
-0.2171052247,
-0.1085497737,
-0.4188171029,
0.3824650049,
-0.5417765379,
-0.5095646381,
-0.1458354294,
0.2059805542,
0.3938670158,
0.8339217901,
-0.6901648045,
0.1707491726,
0.1614945084,
-0.0610107481,
-0.488057375,
-0.8420936465,
-0.0906777829,
-0.145208627,
-0.3165522814,
0.1385678649,
0.0519712418,
-0.1889171004,
0.0799313411,
0.0563024059,
-0.1447618455,
0.1075319424,
0.0062191635,
0.1580703259,
-0.1581745297,
0.378921479,
0.0856462196,
-0.0862163752,
-0.312130481,
-0.5671535134,
0.3921123445,
0.0257187188,
-0.2956557572,
-0.4334436655,
0.0785333291,
0.648445189,
-0.5243127346,
0.724770546,
0.5393113494,
-0.4593494236,
-0.3979065418,
-0.475838393,
-0.2084538937,
-0.4600424469,
0.504899621,
-0.1811418533,
-0.7905622125,
0.2648585141,
-0.2991812229,
0.1709477752,
0.3494181633,
0.821711123,
-0.360176146,
0.8358507752,
0.6049221158,
-0.1995115727,
0.4285570383,
-0.6038259268,
0.0782347172,
-0.7401385307,
-0.1214123964,
-0.5425890088,
-0.3309401572,
-0.7714841366,
-0.5085064769,
0.3095994294,
0.2289531678,
-0.2041000426,
0.3614049554,
-0.0639830381,
0.3917609453,
0.6656273007,
0.1919796616,
0.5288857818,
0.3096032441,
-0.1009068191,
-0.0398693644,
-0.7551950812,
-0.6451830864,
1.0890597105,
0.3208642602,
0.8292719722,
0.1441029161,
0.8617128134,
0.2600342929,
0.4812806547,
-0.9020286798,
0.2431768626,
-0.5715500712,
-0.5248247981,
-0.3977311552,
-0.9545170665,
-0.8356828094,
0.165222913,
-0.2516561151,
-0.4696146846,
0.1920176893,
0.2932372689,
-0.2443259954,
0.2050397098,
-0.6011933088,
0.6678302288,
-0.4993218482,
-0.2534722686,
-0.4502682388,
-0.097328715,
0.1993699819,
-0.3779838979,
0.3773486912,
-0.1414508075,
0.1963948607,
0.6606981754,
-0.6144517064,
0.6257390976,
-0.1023123711,
-0.1098767072,
0.3997115791,
0.4063397944,
0.4049311578,
-0.0380622074,
-0.2777010202,
0.3227162361,
0.0881373808,
-0.6625245214,
-0.6574169397,
0.5397814512,
-0.9820953608,
-0.3021493256,
-0.0943341553,
-0.5950986147,
-0.3207683563,
0.0178808458,
0.2563192844,
0.1272899359,
-0.2263084352,
0.0744758844,
0.4087047577,
-0.3246208429,
0.3184981346,
0.4406887591,
-0.0482648835,
-0.6618003249,
1.0764620304,
0.1884784549,
0.5415952802,
0.2180952281,
0.2429400086,
-0.4078795016,
-0.7297904491,
-0.7017582655,
0.3230295777,
-0.6986528635,
-0.387565881,
-0.1989073455,
-0.2634348869,
0.0801905766,
0.0076923897,
-0.7393321991,
-0.3971115351,
-0.0940582603,
-0.2168650329,
0.4793417454,
0.8674984574,
-0.2931822538,
0.597602725,
-1.4108197689,
-0.1121415868,
0.1133636236,
0.2373065054,
0.1047122404,
-0.8638285398,
-0.8768725991,
0.3138636351,
-0.2218835801,
-0.6391828656,
0.7072015405,
0.1474791914,
0.5337365866,
0.1808513403,
-0.1050610319,
0.5018727183,
-0.4807658195,
0.6276628971,
0.2765095234,
-0.9143806696,
0.4859879017,
0.0086328676,
0.1159238517,
0.667735517,
0.5196969509,
-0.5826579332,
-0.2361468375,
-0.2702076435,
-0.6455299854,
0.6450330019,
0.2589240372,
0.1533550173,
0.2153955698,
0.3953580856,
0.1601318121,
0.2342783213,
-0.540143013,
0.0534277186,
0.0224248003,
-0.3233508468,
-0.5844821334,
-0.181006819,
-0.0620731004,
-0.2249484509,
0.7689644098,
0.1914546639,
-0.2080064118,
0.0262829978,
-0.6391333938,
-0.1172090247,
0.1604740769,
0.3005957007,
0.5981535912,
-0.1554805636,
0.0928727016,
0.4764053822,
-0.4115923643,
0.508014977,
-0.157926783,
-0.1896972656,
-0.0343068913,
0.4866659641,
0.8140728474,
-0.1666599363,
-0.5758525133,
0.2601969242,
0.2480670661,
-0.1320546418,
-0.0438117795,
-0.0201738235,
0.0612512007,
0.4934931397,
0.1378733218,
-0.322591126,
-0.1482020766,
-0.4361643195,
0.095512107,
0.0951889008,
-0.5818837881,
-0.4145761132,
0.1855110228,
0.4438624978,
-0.1126152351,
1.0010414124,
-0.333792299,
-0.5098304152,
0.2061193585,
0.2936136723,
0.5603380799,
-0.4098899066,
0.1512964666,
0.5005196929,
0.5571772456,
-0.3298640847,
0.1148770452,
0.1811103225,
-0.7287014723,
-0.8720724583,
-1.0527373552,
-0.5397809148,
0.2998672426,
-0.4275659025,
0.3017173111,
-0.3155647218,
-0.2340379953,
-0.1718700081,
0.1975763142,
-1.0825417042,
0.3501428068,
0.0990668759,
0.7380506396,
-1.0657235384,
0.7517051697,
0.7392192483,
-0.6086229086,
-0.5746594667,
-0.2333391607,
-0.4510340691,
-0.6000438333,
1.0389277935,
-0.2565438449,
-0.101336956,
-0.0282529052,
-0.2592350841,
-0.8260447979,
0.8227660656,
0.6496381164,
-0.8665794134,
0.0541297123,
0.2782530785,
0.765337348,
-0.134908855,
0.0817962959,
0.6504876614,
0.4236741066,
0.006651198,
-0.9469200969,
-0.1654120535,
0.1986724287,
-0.1271100491,
0.2201510668,
-0.5736609101,
0.5695538521,
-0.141718924,
-0.2768981457,
-0.1459935606,
0.7007699013,
-0.1185640693,
0.1068662181,
0.2797406614,
0.5463377237,
0.9156402349,
-0.0509087481,
0.9631574154,
-0.3008983731,
0.5338503122,
1.1471654177,
-0.211273104,
0.8770567179,
0.4040082991,
-0.197746411,
0.3477768302,
0.6384533644,
-0.0210424978,
0.5021665692,
0.2995797098,
-0.1585954279,
-0.5690931678,
0.0379301235,
-0.0579458699,
0.6044954062,
0.5211540461,
-0.4833206534,
-0.2757616639,
0.002895545,
-0.1406936496,
0.2002438158,
-0.3309196234,
0.8298639655,
0.4096372426,
-0.4880059659,
0.9280346632,
0.0827337801,
0.3679960668,
-0.3311682642,
0.0142159946,
-0.5601002574,
0.1985187978,
-0.290584445,
-0.4818277359,
0.3513152897,
0.2650940716,
-0.2393797487,
-0.0473237932,
0.2794551849,
-0.5761199594,
-0.9703725576,
0.4270588756,
0.9491135478,
0.4399077296,
0.2490985841,
-0.4607285857,
-0.0837917626,
-0.1273663044,
-0.1944934577,
0.2159696966,
0.479893446,
-0.0527560227,
0.6541942954,
0.7197629213,
0.6244816184,
-0.0742412582,
-0.0115248086,
0.7365810275,
-0.5190727115,
-0.1357173324,
-0.9231927991,
0.3238239586,
-0.0850913078,
0.0036312584,
0.4594430327,
0.5663497448,
1.1518630981,
-0.0675768852,
0.9652311802,
0.2373956591,
0.6837728024,
-0.6260162592,
0.8949867487,
-0.6608495116,
0.2525237501,
0.0128563587,
-1.1722166538,
-0.1156048104,
0.5521143079,
-0.3776337802,
-0.1005949304,
0.6784612536,
0.7667569518,
-0.3419987857,
-0.5353659987,
0.7526366711,
0.2399003655,
0.1966297477,
0.5596923828,
0.9718224406,
-0.2501880527,
0.6781050563,
-0.1906658262,
-0.2312393486,
-0.2255276293,
-0.8499242067,
-0.9561943412,
-0.5269606709,
-0.2633837163,
-0.544991672,
0.210247919,
1.1172002554,
0.655541718,
-0.8605009913,
-0.4802862704,
0.2567927539,
0.1808070689,
-0.1071928144,
-0.0247803368,
0.4368329644,
-0.5163615942,
-1.0679001808,
0.5097112656,
0.0026825825,
0.1518456191,
-0.3503655791,
-0.3317952156,
0.1352247298,
0.0236430615,
0.7069998384,
0.1544465572,
-0.3726841807,
-0.2723178566,
-0.1473612785,
-0.2778200805,
0.0666407645,
0.6644614339,
-0.5466638803,
0.3737868965,
0.5067647099,
0.8454449773,
0.7291211486,
-0.1651677042,
0.6988245845,
-0.8436791897,
0.2848455906,
0.1347555518,
0.4515864253,
0.71945858,
-0.0889510438,
0.5436493754,
0.1128383204,
-0.4006916881,
-0.7896255255,
0.3273638487,
-0.5184315443,
-0.050919231,
1.2996981144,
-0.5159636736,
-0.2896643281,
0.1642231643,
-0.0512563959,
0.5011382103,
-0.2806242704,
0.6988193989,
0.6451699734,
0.3052774668,
0.0431109481,
-0.6747255325,
0.6008300781,
0.3021790981,
-0.606815815,
0.1377453804,
0.629183054,
0.417958349,
0.0311945863,
0.2859884501,
-0.1411521584,
0.1507397145,
-0.136774227,
0.2707623541,
0.1105434746,
-0.2689673603,
-0.2521217167,
-0.3357535303,
0.5671850443,
-0.0720210597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03490v1 | Natural Language Processing for Policymaking | 2023-02-07T14:34:39 | 2023-02-07T14:34:39 | Zhijing Jin, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Language is the medium for many political activities, from campaigns to news
reports. Natural language processing (NLP) uses computational tools to parse
text into key information that is needed for policymaking. In this chapter, we
introduce common methods of NLP, including text classification, topic modeling,
event extraction, and text scaling. We then overview how these methods can be
used for policymaking through four major applications including data collection
for evidence-based policymaking, interpretation of political decisions, policy
communication, and investigation of policy effects. Finally, we highlight some
potential limitations and ethical concerns when using NLP for policymaking.
This text is from Chapter 7 (pages 141-162) of the Handbook of Computational
Social Science for Policy (2023). Open Access on Springer:
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-16624-2 | [
-0.581587255,
-1.0824218988,
0.5801336765,
0.4495891333,
-0.0552028716,
0.2816561162,
-0.4755495787,
-0.4116654098,
0.0354484841,
1.0629907846,
-0.4282586873,
-0.3926691413,
-0.6005439758,
0.0625739321,
-0.4000855982,
1.0948777199,
0.1148425415,
0.0087731723,
-0.0817481726,
-0.0450000241,
-0.3982753754,
-0.6220909357,
-0.9626592994,
-0.6742770672,
0.2255568653,
0.5084383488,
1.0928120613,
0.6974711418,
0.6620562673,
0.3493263423,
-0.2964202166,
0.082406655,
-0.198537454,
0.0929415375,
-0.4249960482,
-0.6006726623,
-0.1745613962,
0.5021348596,
0.8275814056,
0.6234118342,
-0.0395396799,
-0.0807349235,
0.0050999518,
0.8143921494,
-0.4410457611,
0.3200340569,
-0.5475481153,
0.0672921538,
-0.3439962566,
-0.4318627417,
-0.3014674783,
-0.7874804139,
0.3890628815,
-0.3753871322,
0.3253668845,
0.030066723,
0.663415134,
0.0383863635,
-0.4044544697,
-0.7368661761,
-0.7355946302,
1.0664292574,
-0.7523622513,
0.0847798288,
0.9711347222,
0.3421448469,
-0.4415706694,
-0.9465769529,
-0.5962002873,
-0.0685781762,
-0.0857368931,
-0.4620670676,
-0.147792384,
0.6035654545,
0.2398305833,
0.516823411,
-0.4364073277,
-0.023319507,
-0.4391443729,
-0.3777523041,
0.8319200873,
-0.018050123,
0.4219364524,
-0.6586809754,
0.0882442296,
-0.1020123661,
-0.4206004441,
0.1186434329,
0.6385807395,
0.5367805958,
0.037679106,
0.4398366213,
-0.3151933849,
1.1183282137,
-0.4529509544,
0.0614175685,
-0.1153058633,
-0.6550967097,
-0.2566013336,
0.0076930039,
0.7294495702,
0.1651220024,
0.078648828,
0.0979651585,
0.1429560184,
0.151998058,
0.1886790842,
-0.3399597406,
0.1112294346,
0.2248553485,
-0.6388908625,
-0.5190446377,
-0.3270496726,
-0.9959484935,
-0.4693189263,
-0.6844623685,
-0.239991352,
-0.1058944762,
-0.1438784301,
0.3910313547,
-0.4946218431,
0.4382770658,
0.1952528358,
-0.9087483883,
0.8374955058,
1.0361782312,
0.8325257301,
-0.1950546503,
0.0333320275,
-0.4942390621,
-0.2526428103,
-0.36114344,
0.7342292666,
-0.7504941821,
-0.1243180633,
0.322077781,
-0.0318612941,
0.1160917953,
-0.584638238,
0.8874539733,
-0.3733978271,
0.3044973314,
-0.26054129,
-0.5353276134,
-0.2845797837,
0.3849314451,
-0.999669373,
0.8006727099,
-0.238680914,
-0.4101769626,
0.2596320808,
-1.237662673,
-0.474689573,
-0.1459724158,
-0.0149186701,
-0.1166243106,
0.0628189892,
0.0518265218,
0.5571516156,
-0.4354443848,
0.758511126,
0.0471493006,
0.0898395553,
0.1303892732,
-0.606323719,
1.1288203001,
0.2630545795,
0.0316630341,
0.202402696,
-0.8598167896,
-0.1667421758,
-0.1992830485,
-0.4838376641,
-0.1250034273,
0.4730627239,
0.5007695556,
-0.0219997875,
0.2272840291,
-0.5158803463,
0.131494537,
-0.6578482389,
0.8577536345,
0.3268626928,
0.0742881,
0.8477330208,
-0.2716020346,
0.3702548742,
-0.5652452111,
0.0229150224,
-0.0545231625,
-0.847717464,
-0.3553070128,
0.1907496601,
0.5653640628,
0.6425698996,
-0.8132626414,
0.0838831291,
0.3113336265,
-0.2984868288,
-0.4061182141,
-0.1931875348,
-0.1184919327,
0.1480460316,
0.2677950263,
0.0973886475,
-0.7395300269,
-0.8088164926,
-0.8514271975,
-0.2064479142,
0.1460048109,
-0.0995420441,
0.3776477575,
0.00428358,
1.23244524,
-0.5405171514,
-0.2176316381,
-0.3198638558,
0.8096852899,
0.2254965007,
0.5478692055,
0.3014035225,
-1.0866434574,
-0.152632907,
0.1177939996,
-0.5357394218,
-0.105252713,
-0.2865818739,
0.0982284546,
0.2124988586,
0.3603037596,
-0.3804549873,
0.5661610365,
0.4995371103,
-0.3437991738,
0.2190623581,
-0.1261039823,
0.136998564,
-0.6630081534,
-0.2434244603,
0.1014302522,
-0.5583769083,
-0.9802569151,
0.1205166057,
-0.5048861504,
-0.319211334,
-0.410422653,
0.638702333,
-0.1274972111,
0.1185789257,
-0.728746891,
-0.0550015233,
0.1098052785,
-0.0511894599,
0.3095434308,
0.4469520748,
0.2758576274,
-0.4693934321,
0.5952692032,
0.0039517307,
-0.2744268477,
0.5280080438,
-0.3658220768,
0.1204777285,
-0.2080785036,
-0.0763001591,
-0.4585521817,
-0.3099945486,
0.3166560233,
-0.3085176051,
0.1357434094,
0.0799204558,
-0.4909441173,
-0.1353895068,
-0.3635724783,
-0.2188576907,
0.1533971429,
-0.0528794602,
0.4890598655,
1.0297811031,
-0.2426999807,
-0.4031036794,
-0.7546474934,
0.4017861784,
-0.2507444024,
-0.265592128,
0.4520785809,
0.3027388752,
-0.4769469202,
0.3393892646,
0.2356437445,
-0.7393852472,
0.1307477951,
0.0207720343,
-0.1784952134,
-0.0320120789,
0.1087341681,
-0.0159980338,
-0.2542034984,
0.1588966697,
0.3273843229,
0.4790039957,
-0.2335943133,
0.1098012999,
-0.3436807692,
0.8075179458,
0.2992402613,
-0.0092149442,
0.6417258978,
0.57365942,
-0.5448971391,
0.0052240547,
-0.3876742125,
-0.014611803,
-0.4382371008,
0.0786578506,
0.1946508884,
-0.8220897913,
0.2418958098,
-0.3442211151,
0.4118444622,
0.3171624839,
0.3182412684,
0.1280022264,
0.9246180058,
0.7577175498,
-0.3106635511,
0.4218522012,
-0.0707245916,
0.4647557735,
-0.4256967902,
0.1480358392,
-1.0136054754,
-0.0215989351,
-1.0132791996,
-0.4806533158,
-0.0909053758,
-0.0862854421,
0.1323897988,
0.3687368929,
-0.8084643483,
0.5655562282,
0.7605913877,
-0.4166607857,
0.3344047368,
0.1331245452,
0.7010475397,
-0.2058688104,
-0.4668876231,
-0.9051915407,
0.673606813,
0.3668278158,
0.5279538631,
-0.3811338842,
0.6035984159,
0.6125174165,
0.2345784903,
-0.7823519111,
0.721822083,
-0.1541910768,
-0.8719210029,
-0.7212198973,
-0.3250216842,
-1.0136166811,
0.3788206577,
-0.6067513227,
-0.6945521832,
0.1356747448,
-0.0307925977,
-0.0338726752,
0.3487483859,
-0.3472907841,
0.6665850282,
-0.0377858877,
0.0698866323,
-0.4547535181,
-0.4961482882,
-0.0003371456,
0.2471502125,
0.4066005349,
-0.348100543,
0.154957518,
1.0967746973,
0.1582164913,
0.7181786299,
-0.1493111551,
0.2378265709,
0.5239371061,
-0.4538376629,
0.1951068789,
-0.0607285202,
-0.424072057,
0.3049438298,
0.5412661433,
-0.0936320275,
-0.4613097906,
0.3767745793,
-0.433742106,
-0.4820408225,
-0.7910782695,
-0.6851639152,
-0.0396403819,
0.2639387846,
0.050695464,
0.2641993463,
-0.6364750862,
0.3365023136,
0.3674643636,
-0.2422984689,
0.5014942884,
0.2942902148,
-0.3180446029,
-0.1503242999,
1.0321292877,
0.4576103091,
-0.2197994441,
0.3190854788,
0.5566203594,
-0.2896199822,
-0.4529275,
0.0747361705,
0.0181882679,
-0.7003425956,
-0.0275230203,
-0.3640287817,
-0.3391714096,
-0.3414225876,
-0.2164129615,
-0.1340803802,
-0.5191478133,
-0.3725593686,
-0.0377559178,
0.3338325024,
0.9082488418,
-0.3069876134,
0.5421339273,
-0.3428703249,
0.6049977541,
0.1979648173,
0.3608449697,
-0.478205055,
0.3126165271,
0.1724135727,
0.1979436576,
-0.4610003233,
-1.1147557497,
0.4259890914,
0.2513140142,
0.4323277473,
0.0826682821,
0.1219925582,
0.3576462269,
-0.5943526626,
0.9273898005,
-0.0736527741,
-0.9128722548,
0.7690547109,
-0.3262384236,
0.0859914348,
0.7337741256,
0.4589009881,
-0.7379465103,
-0.3179517984,
-0.5795615315,
-0.8183211684,
0.7251240015,
0.3459409773,
0.328586936,
-0.1190519705,
0.2050297856,
-0.1506264359,
0.3925280273,
-0.5395933986,
-0.1243140101,
0.0963267908,
-0.0069333506,
-0.0472416952,
-0.2560042739,
-0.2846496403,
-0.3052444756,
0.3895688653,
-0.1980490386,
0.0242409129,
0.1824967116,
0.1774200648,
0.151056096,
0.5326077938,
0.5280463696,
0.6059475541,
-0.1659121364,
-0.0161881559,
-0.0544156246,
-0.4251751304,
0.0339883417,
0.097244069,
-0.2282399833,
0.2941430211,
0.2390821278,
0.5005688071,
0.0871558264,
-0.4146334827,
0.2327228487,
-0.1938626915,
-0.1492935568,
-0.2105519027,
-0.1073500067,
0.0663617626,
-0.0608050488,
0.1505918354,
0.0105679687,
0.6178497076,
-0.9208605886,
0.1683833599,
0.5280943513,
-0.2321231663,
0.0180613361,
0.3465153575,
0.3214526772,
-0.7127866745,
0.4245025218,
-0.0394797511,
-0.350528568,
0.7043099403,
0.5363548398,
0.611431241,
-0.148173511,
0.5968930125,
0.0820141584,
0.3838512003,
-0.1541568935,
0.4325206876,
-0.1132365763,
-0.6576194763,
-0.78412503,
-0.5233169794,
-0.8412747383,
0.2819526494,
-0.8051766157,
0.0802086145,
-0.5370470881,
-0.6648273468,
0.5979995728,
0.3805064559,
-0.6379867196,
-0.1040958092,
-0.1007797047,
0.8044237494,
-1.0144110918,
0.3936955929,
0.6416631341,
0.1218506619,
-0.2953270078,
-0.24939695,
0.423371017,
-0.4293961227,
0.2588568926,
-0.0024395385,
0.112097472,
-0.3115209341,
-0.8793803453,
-0.5479064584,
0.1433803737,
0.2654293478,
-0.2100204229,
-0.0895770267,
0.5783402324,
0.4153243601,
-0.0594212189,
-0.1894718707,
1.0846083164,
0.8170534968,
-0.3848184943,
-0.7809054852,
-0.1619206071,
0.1619066298,
-0.0302659459,
0.3535581231,
0.0011951503,
0.6633654237,
0.4785937071,
-0.2370804995,
-0.0954080448,
0.5559216738,
0.0770447552,
0.551333189,
0.2277473658,
0.1020038649,
0.9024683237,
-0.3367978036,
1.1653168201,
-0.1553541273,
0.1414843649,
0.8376592398,
-0.1791070402,
0.5085598826,
0.4785033762,
-0.2350067645,
0.3391058743,
0.5002931952,
0.1840280741,
0.3067942858,
0.3221775293,
-0.2425751686,
0.2546858788,
-0.4553684592,
0.1051476449,
0.6298827529,
0.7424972653,
-0.1058295965,
-0.5155050755,
0.1938923299,
0.1121612191,
0.4743151665,
-0.3734127283,
0.7441801429,
0.2734986246,
-0.8382148743,
-0.1851159781,
0.341530472,
0.4633454382,
-0.5051499605,
-0.73331213,
0.514860034,
-0.1953053176,
-0.1964354515,
-1.4063975811,
1.1883509159,
-0.0388827398,
-0.4089607596,
-0.6643666029,
1.1651912928,
-0.1140991226,
-0.1532001793,
0.1093940735,
0.2392746657,
0.1391364336,
-0.0868427232,
-0.8689416647,
0.29671368,
-0.2236870676,
-0.3971078694,
0.1632599831,
0.2317614257,
-0.3556802571,
0.6350157857,
1.0008904934,
0.7980756164,
-0.1177123338,
0.0560512245,
0.4588580728,
-0.7661088109,
-0.5337249637,
-0.8648252487,
-0.0255353339,
-0.4724322557,
-0.3112810552,
0.4887533784,
0.2611840069,
0.6043176651,
0.371340096,
0.6893348098,
-0.2643302381,
0.5007845759,
-0.4997674823,
0.416328311,
0.0597054325,
-0.0403906181,
0.0735014006,
-0.731618464,
-0.5854834318,
1.0605070591,
-0.5482057929,
-0.4686935246,
0.3270653784,
0.3472549617,
0.2752706707,
0.4808133245,
0.0645110458,
-0.4387846887,
0.380805552,
-0.1349196136,
0.634442687,
-0.2061060071,
0.2224254906,
-0.285012275,
0.0460113212,
0.0956905186,
-0.8924867511,
-0.7558182478,
-0.6640572548,
-0.2230484039,
-0.2826851308,
-0.0283174645,
0.7859806418,
0.9234794378,
-0.7126383185,
-0.5546310544,
-0.3321127295,
0.704372704,
-0.2270493507,
-0.3690251708,
0.1675530225,
-0.5087065101,
-0.8533791304,
0.2795140147,
0.3012691438,
-0.3716055751,
-0.2377332002,
0.2211006284,
-0.6562070251,
0.1638665497,
0.6402419209,
0.7045624256,
-0.6478933096,
-0.1303994656,
-0.5818050504,
0.1015155613,
0.0413915701,
1.0869473219,
-0.6893671751,
0.4868704677,
0.8603051305,
0.7812767625,
0.320656687,
-0.1080610231,
0.8350944519,
-0.5425512791,
0.3182952404,
0.6068237424,
0.0707799643,
0.4585514665,
-0.3642243147,
0.7597442269,
-0.1326215267,
-0.8301063776,
-0.9462786317,
0.2990888655,
-0.7363442779,
-0.3745659888,
0.8554503322,
0.4251973331,
-0.3951130509,
-0.6559090614,
-0.4287008643,
0.1437815875,
-0.3230929077,
0.2222941369,
0.885381937,
-0.168253094,
-0.3077847958,
-1.2150663137,
0.8997263312,
-0.1699520946,
-0.9127011895,
-0.0248510409,
0.1064158157,
0.0170689914,
0.4822003245,
1.0223625898,
-0.1757272929,
-0.0368885174,
-0.252715379,
-0.0873377398,
0.5389432311,
-0.2629497051,
-0.5757348537,
0.1600756496,
-0.0389306508,
0.0023539895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03475v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03475v1 | Entity-Aware Dual Co-Attention Network for Fake News Detection | 2023-02-07T14:00:40 | 2023-02-07T14:00:40 | Sin-Han Yang, Chung-Chi Chen, Hen-Hsen Huang, Hsin-Hsi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fake news and misinformation spread rapidly on the Internet. How to identify
it and how to interpret the identification results have become important
issues. In this paper, we propose a Dual Co-Attention Network (Dual-CAN) for
fake news detection, which takes news content, social media replies, and
external knowledge into consideration. Our experimental results support that
the proposed Dual-CAN outperforms current representative models in two
benchmark datasets. We further make in-depth discussions by comparing how
models work in both datasets with empirical analysis of attention weights. | [
-0.4010131955,
-1.0067740679,
0.5478816032,
0.6077884436,
-0.3451850712,
0.314130336,
0.008643507,
-0.9152286649,
0.602584064,
0.4152468741,
-0.4747306108,
-0.065787755,
-0.752502203,
-0.1169589311,
-0.7866652012,
0.8696383834,
-0.1319463551,
0.0825902969,
-0.1543196589,
-0.2395262271,
-0.3295077085,
-0.3121784329,
-1.024300456,
0.211714223,
0.71132195,
0.2888350487,
0.3779097199,
0.1373655945,
0.5236997604,
0.1651321799,
0.3256433904,
0.4102233052,
-0.4551443756,
-0.2670478523,
-0.2560323179,
-0.383813709,
-0.3787678182,
0.1133598462,
0.6388657689,
0.2353745997,
0.2125332654,
0.4075911939,
-0.0584442951,
0.3171218634,
-0.5413821936,
-0.0878968239,
-0.6052105427,
-0.0122444183,
-0.0989968628,
-0.0170070753,
-0.2893911898,
-0.1865706146,
0.0816635936,
-0.8686080575,
0.3827032149,
0.4366853833,
0.8348196745,
0.1346667111,
-0.9475785494,
-0.3706380427,
-0.6888120174,
0.5158848763,
-0.2389874756,
0.4130505621,
-0.1285123676,
0.4587900341,
0.1835345775,
-0.730104804,
-0.7921863198,
-0.0724402592,
-0.1059654057,
0.330204159,
-0.1541765183,
-0.2208351046,
0.077843979,
0.410115093,
-0.5887405276,
-0.0398604609,
-0.2612972856,
-0.4230235517,
0.8482457399,
-0.3067254126,
0.5754434466,
-0.0601534359,
-0.8933770657,
0.1275731176,
-0.4729896486,
-0.1415940523,
0.6276890039,
0.3391772509,
-0.3857162893,
0.4807238877,
-0.1942503005,
0.2146516293,
0.4216703773,
0.0916700959,
0.1125906855,
-0.6649851203,
-0.3856280148,
0.3769364059,
0.7512568831,
0.3438018858,
0.1232622564,
-0.2655766308,
-0.2066147476,
0.6619385481,
0.4637303352,
-0.5166634917,
-0.028130265,
0.1880782396,
-0.3909435868,
-0.2259615213,
0.2679149806,
-0.7950078845,
-0.2918787897,
-0.4969436824,
0.767370522,
-0.0716411918,
-0.7160614729,
0.1270503104,
-0.4702396989,
-0.3397417367,
0.4428325295,
-0.1003832147,
0.6049482226,
0.5211771727,
0.7241178751,
-0.0201814286,
0.1345156729,
-0.5809612274,
0.1103414968,
-0.2650534213,
1.093296051,
-0.3214757144,
0.3386521339,
-0.3068484664,
-0.0643593967,
-0.0888718665,
-0.5164720416,
0.6683133245,
-1.0408816338,
0.1903649569,
-0.6323160529,
-0.3643068373,
-0.4140898585,
0.2039197832,
-1.0158210993,
0.9827573299,
-0.1005081534,
-1.1527742147,
0.4941482246,
-0.6402710676,
-0.5356907845,
-0.0634583011,
-0.0302120578,
-0.5614537001,
0.2664734125,
0.3392749429,
0.2696751058,
-0.0837491676,
0.5156063437,
-0.6661273837,
-0.1957115233,
-0.0024653645,
-0.5223565102,
0.8393812776,
0.0785576552,
-0.3524588645,
0.1456037909,
-0.8879368305,
-0.3279549181,
0.5045411587,
-0.0247326232,
-0.7068513632,
-0.2299257219,
-0.0009937693,
0.1998969615,
-0.0908572003,
-0.5370435119,
-0.00917756,
-0.0045262733,
0.0214706417,
0.4189576209,
0.3907263577,
0.5513260365,
-0.3910502195,
0.1142787188,
0.492554903,
-0.0042263907,
0.3671000302,
-0.2937296927,
-0.8885525465,
-0.2091435939,
0.1892089844,
0.6899853945,
-0.9031225443,
0.3120816946,
-0.1101453975,
-0.0872142911,
-0.6438169479,
-0.0230218899,
0.3323894143,
0.6071475744,
0.5388595462,
-0.3809185624,
-0.7420966625,
-1.0739660263,
-1.1226255894,
0.1615766436,
0.0933848992,
0.2213418186,
0.6474634409,
0.0879684463,
0.6191675663,
0.0741222277,
-0.2889931798,
-0.0528384782,
0.1365316212,
-0.2077655941,
0.0757843107,
0.4946179092,
-1.460526824,
-0.7168865204,
-0.5195946097,
-0.831223011,
0.0552303642,
-0.2453916967,
-0.0579262301,
-0.0684813708,
0.2095673382,
-0.4170249403,
0.4761627316,
0.5596949458,
-0.4301484823,
0.5905852914,
0.0702257082,
0.414635092,
-1.1215572357,
-0.1226153374,
0.5690814853,
-0.5402698517,
-0.7514870167,
-0.0957372934,
0.2612665296,
0.0312650315,
-0.4074762166,
0.6627117395,
-0.6856154799,
-0.3671914935,
-0.1050838158,
0.3030615747,
0.234512642,
0.2502786219,
0.2484233826,
0.5635316968,
0.5077421069,
-0.6332085729,
0.7823025584,
-0.2550546825,
-0.7226939797,
0.7418417335,
-0.7508064508,
0.1807718873,
-0.309822917,
0.6328533292,
-1.1364530325,
-0.5636630058,
0.6809149384,
-0.3710710406,
0.2100239992,
-0.0073141055,
-0.7968380451,
-0.6217365265,
-0.1660049111,
0.1635788977,
-0.3487100303,
-0.6279624701,
0.4015934169,
0.3996440768,
0.0970964208,
-0.5184587836,
-0.7847098708,
0.0707190335,
-0.1534287333,
-0.9924004078,
0.4726807475,
0.0051934472,
-0.4868236184,
0.5818301439,
-0.3007013798,
-0.1234276965,
0.0002618233,
-0.017630754,
0.0683593228,
-0.4861588776,
0.3931266367,
0.2743322551,
0.1187463179,
-0.0527187847,
-0.2432246655,
0.2537343502,
0.0567757376,
-0.3967622221,
-0.9871868491,
0.8166227341,
0.5651817322,
-0.3505500257,
1.0717931986,
0.6083253622,
-0.7138735056,
-0.3090607524,
-0.6404970884,
-0.284740895,
-0.3761440516,
0.1883920431,
-0.2755329609,
-0.4867991209,
0.439676553,
0.116674535,
-0.2563676536,
0.3577006161,
0.3234274685,
0.0595925041,
0.8589856029,
0.5789590478,
0.0166536625,
0.4904560149,
-0.0599191487,
0.2627988756,
-0.6546671987,
-0.2042851746,
-0.0713659152,
-0.4412444532,
-0.1502092034,
-0.4213497043,
0.2888366878,
0.1020145789,
-0.0498505719,
0.3109624684,
-0.3863126338,
0.2848535478,
0.7073147297,
0.4240463078,
0.5537458062,
0.1564351171,
0.0628773868,
0.252353251,
-0.5612813234,
-0.4103775024,
1.08332932,
0.2481663972,
0.4879287481,
0.1448826343,
0.2443543226,
0.4730058908,
0.5634604692,
-0.3739601374,
0.2972609103,
0.0825972855,
-1.2185430527,
-0.0513638034,
-0.4000524879,
-0.3576878011,
0.3863249719,
-0.1161263287,
-0.3678027987,
0.1265263855,
0.3704913259,
-0.50355196,
0.5118744373,
-1.2399820089,
0.7232478857,
-0.4172742367,
-0.2986870408,
-0.3921431005,
-0.4909479618,
0.5952863693,
-0.1255102158,
0.375582844,
-0.1492338628,
-0.2196390182,
0.620061934,
0.0422872864,
0.8712946773,
-0.2802686393,
0.1614703387,
0.5669115186,
-0.3135793209,
0.7686045766,
0.6349048018,
0.1635300517,
0.0632561296,
-0.3921949267,
-0.3834562302,
-0.3682908714,
0.6171455383,
-0.7194943428,
-0.6231904626,
-0.4122291505,
-0.4291421473,
-0.0628317967,
0.3207156658,
0.4629534483,
0.354660511,
-0.1964054406,
0.0549609065,
0.7990736365,
-0.0268467925,
0.1563303471,
0.7009856701,
-0.1992605329,
-0.1021151468,
0.5766957402,
0.6024941206,
0.153572619,
0.4417026043,
-0.0879059508,
-0.3086389005,
-0.2750712037,
-0.5144920349,
0.377173841,
-0.3470625281,
-0.0017752167,
-0.8211603165,
-0.3135407269,
-0.8126581907,
0.2837737799,
-0.5202720761,
-0.0101870643,
-0.3666920066,
0.0187264811,
0.0067229103,
0.6707471609,
-0.2171968669,
0.1865039766,
-0.3317617476,
1.0225687027,
0.5625849366,
0.5202968121,
-0.0422399156,
-0.3940676153,
0.0686839521,
0.4454364777,
-0.0171167031,
-1.2435069084,
0.2701770067,
-0.1428410709,
0.5705281496,
0.4810887277,
0.269400537,
0.2600014508,
-0.1647897661,
0.2749799192,
0.1174615845,
-0.674456656,
0.3281377852,
-0.2811231315,
-0.0444644839,
0.2722052336,
0.7795960307,
-0.6377385855,
-0.2396418005,
-0.5422349572,
-0.2603194416,
0.8387151957,
0.0178904347,
0.1007257104,
0.2312857509,
0.0735778585,
0.104268007,
0.2929347754,
-0.9643597603,
-0.2876281142,
-0.197728619,
-0.0395608582,
0.0629153252,
-0.4347471595,
-0.1484651566,
0.1158888489,
0.66104877,
0.1483335793,
0.5787801147,
0.3284544349,
-0.32656762,
-0.2203892618,
0.0474705584,
0.5888131857,
0.4515868127,
-0.0881114528,
0.3335085809,
-0.0608725995,
-0.4367546141,
0.0668884814,
0.0948380157,
-0.091263786,
0.0255981199,
0.1475328505,
0.7925984263,
0.0633122399,
-0.1235911772,
0.7963875532,
-0.3251608312,
-0.3403118551,
-0.5127189755,
-0.1205044687,
0.47401914,
0.4299364388,
0.52408427,
0.5858888626,
0.2695437372,
-0.6497576833,
0.1895206422,
0.292714119,
-0.4416086972,
-0.6192299128,
0.6870905161,
0.4130896032,
-0.300839752,
0.4143812656,
-0.374558121,
-0.6701299548,
0.992669642,
0.679273665,
0.4897294939,
-0.23656106,
0.2511488199,
0.1541727334,
0.4555246532,
-0.2058485448,
0.1341922134,
0.0116935149,
-1.0921806097,
-0.1575515121,
-0.2056894451,
0.0270638503,
0.5097122788,
-0.626730144,
0.3549081087,
-0.2865368724,
-0.1365032345,
0.3163937926,
0.2472385764,
-0.8171740174,
0.516495347,
0.4162098467,
0.8953659534,
-1.0699535608,
0.722307086,
0.5575940013,
-0.239205882,
-0.5768224001,
0.2628359795,
0.3724075556,
-0.6807605624,
0.3935090303,
0.4076645374,
0.0322181992,
-0.0380758382,
-0.4721355438,
-1.0609128475,
0.9393476844,
0.5525068045,
-0.8798289299,
-0.2734050453,
-0.1954881996,
0.3178710341,
-0.4745132029,
0.0517655872,
-0.0160205867,
0.4863685369,
-0.0188620742,
-0.7040489316,
-0.1033171117,
-0.0521061309,
-0.3098888993,
0.0417709351,
-1.3224635124,
0.7296655178,
-0.149210304,
-0.8435154557,
-0.5365996957,
0.7846929431,
-0.1698845625,
0.9789518714,
0.5975265503,
0.7188099623,
0.8370173573,
0.0293631423,
1.0655043125,
-0.0353503041,
0.3184739649,
1.374145031,
-0.2567848265,
0.5687550902,
0.287658751,
-0.0292416941,
0.5467171073,
0.6708052158,
0.0287785716,
0.5404965878,
-0.0073809437,
-0.4242124259,
-0.317530781,
-0.2168117464,
-0.3213643134,
0.1477671713,
0.4223253131,
-0.4816581607,
-0.1100122333,
0.1763373315,
0.0235665627,
0.0174770895,
-0.4395151734,
0.5030411482,
0.0914146081,
-0.6663351059,
-0.096626699,
0.0762282237,
0.6425635815,
-0.2621147931,
0.2983321548,
-0.0740014836,
0.1736421287,
-0.0969023854,
-0.5708844066,
0.5077500343,
-0.156058982,
-0.4915561974,
-0.137945056,
1.3070498705,
-0.5582054257,
-0.3905587494,
0.5752084255,
0.4712160826,
-0.1695149392,
-0.6507154703,
-0.795494318,
0.0091460375,
-0.1669318527,
-0.4162729681,
0.1012632623,
0.2574672103,
-0.167473495,
0.4969465137,
0.5432251692,
-0.0119905351,
0.3170430362,
-0.0539298318,
0.8094561696,
-0.1330489218,
-0.5834742188,
-0.4187085629,
0.3102120161,
-0.6371255517,
0.0067912866,
0.8434913158,
0.7709165812,
1.0754264593,
0.0086625246,
1.0336191654,
0.0087794866,
0.9723013043,
-0.197950393,
0.6126781702,
-0.6776444912,
-0.0051041632,
0.1288348287,
-0.7561820745,
-0.2658042312,
0.1211793423,
-0.5663300157,
0.1303527802,
0.7496175766,
0.7643444538,
-0.5534008145,
0.1092490703,
0.1628079563,
0.0564778447,
0.020183241,
0.5260080695,
0.7813671827,
-0.7211189866,
0.4861954153,
-0.2654806972,
-0.0353871882,
-0.6791430116,
-0.6191102862,
-0.930386126,
-0.3350033462,
-0.4256941974,
-0.4315335155,
0.1806740016,
0.504047811,
0.9459379911,
-0.788566649,
0.4363727868,
-0.1794144362,
0.3601608276,
-0.1863942444,
-0.2709231079,
0.3748724461,
0.0232536215,
-0.7498703003,
0.2191099077,
0.3758161366,
0.2325010598,
-0.2147135437,
0.2786133587,
-0.5659951568,
0.5847181082,
0.2568018436,
0.1109580845,
-0.5748969913,
-0.5852661729,
0.0020132582,
-0.4304629862,
0.0351671539,
0.8485334516,
-0.6901909709,
0.5507126451,
0.3590936661,
0.3474096954,
0.4754200876,
0.2353756279,
0.251078397,
-0.9098283648,
0.3009050786,
0.1606070697,
0.0091408007,
0.3541087806,
-0.6332827806,
0.1115475595,
0.8590731025,
-0.2681028247,
-0.6842987537,
0.1203172058,
-0.947232008,
-0.2798897922,
1.1406850815,
-0.1121836007,
-0.4115604758,
-0.3669379652,
-0.0727327466,
0.5729880929,
-0.6170603633,
0.6940165758,
0.6683830023,
0.1610605866,
-0.2259525657,
-0.5664879084,
0.2679299116,
0.0546919331,
-0.9494165182,
-0.414049387,
0.203973785,
0.5648902059,
0.2122501135,
0.6085790396,
0.2203320414,
0.3815371096,
0.5171817541,
-0.3155383468,
-0.1277011782,
-0.7724423409,
-0.0030348329,
0.2380786687,
-0.7498538494,
-0.194270581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04096v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04096v1 | Real-Word Error Correction with Trigrams: Correcting Multiple Errors in a Sentence | 2023-02-07T13:52:14 | 2023-02-07T13:52:14 | Seyed MohammadSadegh Dashti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spelling correction is a fundamental task in Text Mining. In this study, we
assess the real-word error correction model proposed by Mays, Damerau and
Mercer and describe several drawbacks of the model. We propose a new variation
which focuses on detecting and correcting multiple real-word errors in a
sentence, by manipulating a Probabilistic Context-Free Grammar (PCFG) to
discriminate between items in the search space. We test our approach on the
Wall Street Journal corpus and show that it outperforms Hirst and Budanitsky's
WordNet-based method and Wilcox-O'Hearn, Hirst, and Budanitsky's fixed windows
size method.-O'Hearn, Hirst, and Budanitsky's fixed windows size method. | [
0.2576058209,
-1.1674205065,
0.5935934782,
0.3865887225,
-0.0228106324,
0.0131748375,
-0.2700876892,
-0.5906959176,
0.1330492944,
0.3860733509,
-0.6377056837,
-0.6387590766,
-0.4308845699,
0.3709818125,
-0.3394890726,
0.5849837661,
-0.4428891242,
0.2179116905,
-0.0415253229,
-0.038908001,
-0.7400304675,
-0.5564315915,
-0.4264497757,
0.0937110335,
0.5583661199,
0.7288088799,
0.7742884755,
0.6407333016,
0.6521493196,
0.1540389061,
-0.0695630908,
0.6835366488,
-0.3145998418,
-0.1530924588,
0.1560823023,
-0.656626761,
-0.5928831697,
0.2149374783,
0.6735002995,
0.362531215,
-0.2805742025,
-0.1721523106,
-0.064090468,
0.526017487,
-0.6775798798,
-0.0075876885,
-0.3360549212,
0.1758125573,
-0.4605790079,
-0.0615038872,
-0.6790037751,
-0.4408373237,
-0.0247591585,
-0.6802517176,
0.5562084317,
0.402620852,
0.9802396894,
0.2643628418,
-0.2348552346,
-0.2188268155,
-0.7597396374,
0.6435470581,
-0.761413157,
0.2081409544,
0.3813628256,
0.1685862839,
-0.3099915981,
-0.7441533804,
-0.8883427382,
-0.1120423526,
-0.2834591568,
0.1050730795,
-0.2787277997,
0.5138504505,
0.1629421562,
0.3635487854,
-0.3904334605,
-0.2084179521,
-0.1910134256,
-0.230622232,
0.3148435652,
0.0460577942,
0.4029597938,
-0.1418769956,
-0.1406550854,
-0.3017965257,
-0.7548444271,
-0.1971893311,
0.3102364242,
0.3926335573,
0.0858210549,
0.7310069799,
-0.1780970395,
0.9863975644,
-0.1151274592,
-0.1402387023,
0.1400703639,
-0.3909262419,
-0.2983108461,
0.3613335192,
0.265330255,
0.5668732524,
0.3937713206,
-0.1185732335,
0.0635090247,
0.1659383923,
0.4374070764,
-0.4042469561,
-0.1597591639,
0.1819393933,
-0.4686195552,
-0.2720279396,
0.2706972659,
-0.5101751685,
-0.0654799938,
-0.0285555739,
0.6457028389,
-0.5068714619,
0.1189116836,
0.392252624,
-0.3196000755,
-0.2725542188,
0.0537896901,
-0.3923431635,
0.0513792969,
0.6505099535,
0.9414382577,
0.4147445261,
-0.712628305,
-0.8157963753,
0.0327980109,
-0.4491250515,
1.1356620789,
-0.5861313939,
-0.4895578027,
0.0475191176,
-0.0928670317,
-0.4674026966,
-0.5062676668,
0.6131268144,
-0.2327844799,
0.6540526748,
-0.7460077405,
-0.6549987197,
-0.1918655038,
0.4574473798,
-0.5714046955,
0.8638355732,
0.3006710708,
-1.0859507322,
0.380173564,
-0.6886638403,
-0.1574357599,
0.0340790525,
0.3231247663,
-0.5543134809,
0.2013954967,
0.0527880862,
0.2342458814,
0.2569254637,
0.0118698599,
-0.3891441524,
-0.7464299202,
0.1906827539,
-0.4763559699,
0.750731349,
-0.098548986,
-0.2552544177,
0.1560370326,
-1.1123950481,
-0.1396574527,
-0.0721822605,
-0.5639027357,
-0.4182963073,
0.181300357,
0.0817514732,
0.0945477933,
-0.0612848625,
-0.9621487856,
0.3568865657,
-0.3714826405,
0.2385358065,
0.3511780202,
-0.00820613,
0.0403642133,
-0.5537275672,
0.4794607162,
0.0349132866,
0.069495827,
0.1323821247,
-0.4522362947,
-0.6426115632,
-0.434841454,
0.7098457217,
0.93271631,
-0.7268961668,
0.2897273898,
-0.2075710744,
-0.3035928905,
-0.6711245775,
-0.2189710885,
0.5081043243,
0.4649384916,
0.4547420144,
-0.0457159653,
-0.7584962845,
-0.6262062788,
-0.8007874489,
-0.1859412193,
0.1897303462,
0.1093265414,
-0.1405411065,
-0.4550441802,
1.1766188145,
-0.6527766585,
-0.5714970827,
0.1424726993,
0.4704615772,
-0.1097023711,
0.2134571671,
0.4962521195,
-0.5196270347,
-0.4825668633,
-0.4558181763,
-0.2481978685,
-0.3683976531,
0.0396737494,
-0.0245408807,
0.20017685,
0.6126407385,
-0.5563201904,
0.6877354383,
0.6117203236,
-0.6181868911,
0.9459751844,
-0.6041000485,
0.1477195323,
-0.9470461607,
-0.3422317803,
0.1233114079,
-0.2760982215,
-0.863077879,
-0.1164871454,
0.3671174049,
0.4821371138,
-0.3390767574,
0.2853200436,
-0.18133533,
0.3042994142,
-0.3419941962,
0.0737857595,
-0.1251473874,
0.0325491242,
-0.1635543257,
0.8339794874,
-0.0976754054,
-0.5513239503,
0.5218558908,
0.2676691115,
0.0018103359,
0.7787945271,
-0.1755561382,
-0.1536268294,
-0.4465284646,
0.4755506516,
-1.2944717407,
-0.282029599,
0.196453765,
-0.4084982276,
0.1116619185,
0.3691703975,
-0.6349471211,
-0.6138437986,
-0.4413883388,
0.3088256419,
-0.266156286,
-0.8420741558,
0.2581867278,
-0.1593748331,
0.2301416546,
-0.7159170508,
-0.7662089467,
0.2778113782,
0.0200704634,
-0.7542417645,
0.757927835,
-0.1030152291,
-0.4003873467,
0.2736450434,
0.1083763912,
0.0592156611,
0.0663475543,
0.0397338308,
0.3300715089,
-0.0202131644,
0.4097644687,
-0.3263812959,
-0.1438518316,
-0.4015204012,
-0.2179509103,
0.3826940358,
-0.3324146569,
-0.1482486874,
-0.2631157041,
0.0934625119,
0.2897156477,
-0.0401428305,
0.6597054005,
0.7706717253,
-0.6182109118,
-0.0835058913,
-0.745249629,
0.1039680317,
-0.3831040859,
0.2663949132,
-0.1167809069,
-0.9877706766,
0.2114457935,
0.2444483936,
-0.0387592353,
0.6192827821,
0.2560140193,
-0.1145082191,
0.8898407817,
0.7778756022,
0.3169203401,
0.3203188479,
0.0902606845,
0.9341018796,
-0.6935200095,
-0.0450511612,
-0.6355333924,
-0.349989444,
-0.840267241,
-0.2311758101,
0.3105267882,
0.0869518146,
0.1475425065,
0.4390841126,
-0.4094670415,
0.4106379151,
0.9187939167,
0.191302225,
0.3134575188,
0.1944599152,
-0.3663971424,
-0.1252359003,
-0.7879559994,
-0.4451796114,
0.9204413295,
0.1434126049,
0.2229757607,
-0.0079726195,
0.6368618011,
0.1585529596,
0.4132316411,
-0.703240633,
0.2859005928,
-0.6858994365,
-0.7208860517,
-0.238701418,
-0.3429830074,
-0.4476893544,
0.3654113114,
-0.4842560589,
-0.5708370209,
0.360283643,
0.3472137749,
-0.8372716308,
0.686506331,
-0.8403919935,
0.7798964381,
-0.1764368117,
-0.2678516805,
-0.3306829929,
-0.3844486773,
0.3201493621,
0.1364503354,
0.4042568803,
-0.0039185602,
0.2316760421,
0.669893384,
-0.5465539694,
0.6312736869,
-0.1935421079,
0.0514499992,
0.2686482966,
0.0365228616,
0.4199126959,
-0.3595562279,
-0.0448475294,
-0.0840629488,
0.3507190645,
-0.3230462074,
0.0466505885,
0.3345737755,
-0.411841929,
-0.1987348944,
-0.536447525,
-0.6373657584,
-0.3333411515,
0.1793947071,
0.5969999433,
0.2451188266,
-0.3952236772,
0.3858729899,
0.3147206903,
-0.1390219182,
0.6670684218,
0.3190695047,
-0.0477206223,
-0.3624556065,
0.5597540736,
0.4653320312,
-0.2731530666,
0.3577068448,
0.4094418883,
-0.1450120658,
-0.2300778627,
-0.1120761409,
0.3986917436,
-0.3588498831,
-0.1303983629,
-0.6800384521,
-0.0221337043,
-0.3313360214,
-0.0780194998,
-0.2044317275,
-0.3715142906,
-0.5222807527,
-0.1123288125,
0.2583499253,
0.6965167522,
-0.3193756044,
0.9980431795,
-1.0364768505,
0.1872038394,
0.5374943614,
0.7522069216,
-0.2549555302,
-0.1499233097,
-0.0520289093,
0.1806585342,
-0.2044064403,
-0.9541184902,
0.3692828119,
0.1082727313,
0.261905849,
0.1898928583,
-0.1999486089,
0.8218299747,
-0.3042409122,
1.0026654005,
0.1564101577,
-0.8545516133,
0.1098339185,
-0.1777782291,
0.0084015699,
0.4864134789,
-0.0219295491,
-1.2586579323,
0.0842432529,
-0.9660033584,
-0.5468046665,
0.7633707523,
0.0919041038,
-0.3111189902,
-0.2560523748,
0.6623436809,
-0.4009743631,
0.2486732751,
-0.5384867787,
0.074701108,
-0.0242355634,
-0.4701546431,
0.0354658328,
-0.9833855033,
0.0481729545,
0.0523019731,
1.1226168871,
0.0025934419,
0.1968172789,
0.6296287775,
-0.1727360785,
-0.2924739718,
0.461623311,
0.7241093516,
0.6367817521,
-0.5713241696,
0.2178549916,
0.3309556842,
-0.5835840106,
-0.0202384721,
0.0389057621,
-0.0331685804,
0.368460685,
0.5335575938,
0.5832066536,
0.174022764,
-0.4906334579,
0.6727166772,
-0.2935115397,
-0.5625075698,
0.0164833553,
-0.2431121171,
-0.0311039351,
0.0206932593,
0.1452076882,
0.1863608658,
-0.0254261475,
-0.5171201825,
0.1162165105,
0.2077137828,
-0.5014705658,
0.0001799125,
0.4783263206,
-0.1370010823,
-0.6034003496,
0.6393354535,
-0.3948374391,
-0.7616491914,
0.2798269391,
0.6146147251,
0.9152681231,
-0.4161314368,
0.2650023997,
0.2217699885,
0.3998807073,
-0.7933220267,
0.4180724621,
0.434863627,
-0.9349387884,
-0.4141764343,
-0.3821026385,
-0.4926043153,
-0.0726250038,
-0.1732786298,
0.2869940996,
-0.5171531439,
-0.3221117258,
-0.1331827193,
0.0395853035,
-0.329125911,
0.4190816879,
0.1190818772,
0.8251423836,
-0.7803977132,
0.6082164049,
0.7272356749,
-0.0936656296,
-0.831202805,
0.2121135592,
0.1092019677,
-0.5651096106,
0.232714057,
0.1517317146,
-0.1735964715,
-0.1274609566,
-0.649455905,
-0.6543254852,
0.9826214314,
-0.050935965,
-1.0066629648,
-0.3599509895,
0.0495442934,
0.6000950336,
-0.3220478594,
-0.0343596898,
0.7091955543,
0.4876150489,
-0.1513918638,
-1.0332046747,
-0.3370703459,
0.1606752425,
0.334148556,
-0.0819127932,
-0.6495058537,
1.0573269129,
0.0662777945,
-0.1217243373,
-0.1779216677,
0.3685190082,
0.3755172789,
0.2320537716,
0.7303771973,
0.8940874934,
1.0560789108,
-0.2393240184,
0.9860855937,
-0.3907568753,
0.5251194239,
0.9942694306,
-0.1334074289,
0.9297889471,
0.4470789135,
-0.3129397333,
0.5061067343,
0.5635767579,
0.1736772954,
0.1651786566,
0.1429561824,
-0.2303797752,
-0.1667423397,
0.1581175476,
-0.0135574862,
0.5614836812,
0.3358076811,
-0.1678110659,
-0.324867487,
-0.0935519114,
0.3456278443,
0.2531813681,
-0.1348049641,
0.3338997662,
-0.1800549328,
-0.517799437,
0.3858031332,
0.6640185118,
0.9351972938,
-0.2239610404,
-0.0290083736,
-0.1074735224,
0.6323299408,
-0.370346576,
-0.3016500473,
0.4897444248,
0.1401049793,
-0.1867331564,
-0.0270418804,
0.8219091296,
-0.5064894557,
-0.7077023983,
0.1900541633,
0.0998708531,
-0.3611100018,
-0.4974554777,
-0.3249753118,
-0.2637075782,
0.0184161607,
0.1805113107,
-0.3349894881,
0.0876495689,
-0.1413583159,
0.27051723,
0.5383014083,
0.3678193986,
0.344332546,
0.0044004545,
0.1176257581,
-0.6867623925,
-0.7873193026,
-0.8580132723,
0.1545838118,
-0.1270199716,
-0.0813679993,
0.7025917768,
0.48486799,
1.0263358355,
-0.0242395867,
0.8271304965,
-0.0152603751,
0.8548610806,
-0.4353025258,
0.1918551475,
-0.4042619169,
0.1883297563,
-0.2558574975,
-0.9353218675,
-0.9109115601,
0.7673835158,
-0.3917207718,
-0.4178881943,
1.1183258295,
0.9951002598,
-0.1274725497,
0.2555330694,
0.0716267154,
0.4240843356,
0.3069277406,
0.3456537426,
0.5208674669,
-0.7182528377,
0.5255102515,
-0.3354828358,
-0.3790547252,
-0.7128372788,
-0.9360252619,
-0.3584106863,
-0.3389721513,
-0.3914220631,
-0.8160554767,
0.2600156069,
1.1768000126,
0.4379850924,
-0.8193526864,
-0.179238379,
-0.1797455847,
0.1392655224,
-0.5860046744,
-0.1304584146,
0.4779070318,
-0.386505723,
-0.4382050931,
0.2716623247,
0.3490383923,
-0.0364450999,
0.2917602658,
0.2446655631,
-0.5076349974,
0.1756903231,
0.6692422032,
-0.0808592141,
-0.4866160154,
-0.7661516666,
0.1385771483,
-0.0909151658,
0.2717666924,
0.8201919198,
-0.2419615984,
0.6312804818,
0.7657647729,
0.3757515252,
0.2974799871,
0.2186285555,
0.3589880764,
-0.9102649689,
-0.0155879119,
-0.2906103134,
0.3715581894,
0.4822414517,
-0.5963385701,
0.3814688027,
0.7675182819,
-0.3627232909,
-0.585216701,
-0.1138823703,
-0.7341414094,
-0.4982503951,
1.1209309101,
0.2276885659,
-0.4278436303,
0.0604877248,
-0.518627286,
0.5493500829,
0.1515553594,
0.992120266,
1.322655201,
0.0974168256,
0.1075843126,
-0.3163920045,
0.5823550224,
0.2561535537,
-0.4615323544,
0.2556202114,
0.6545056105,
0.4072560668,
0.2879500687,
0.6729399562,
-0.2233359367,
0.4287180603,
-0.076121673,
0.2632876933,
0.0042315046,
-0.3606544435,
-0.4409274459,
0.2917126119,
-0.0036203247,
-0.3806044161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03353v1 | What do Language Models know about word senses? Zero-Shot WSD with Language Models and Domain Inventories | 2023-02-07T09:55:07 | 2023-02-07T09:55:07 | Oscar Sainz, Oier Lopez de Lacalle, Eneko Agirre, German Rigau | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language Models are the core for almost any Natural Language Processing
system nowadays. One of their particularities is their contextualized
representations, a game changer feature when a disambiguation between word
senses is necessary. In this paper we aim to explore to what extent language
models are capable of discerning among senses at inference time. We performed
this analysis by prompting commonly used Languages Models such as BERT or
RoBERTa to perform the task of Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD). We leverage the
relation between word senses and domains, and cast WSD as a textual entailment
problem, where the different hypothesis refer to the domains of the word
senses. Our results show that this approach is indeed effective, close to
supervised systems. | [
-0.3516612053,
-0.700422287,
1.0234571695,
-0.0116262175,
-0.1984177083,
-0.1817256063,
-0.2193980217,
-0.6252207756,
-0.2687253952,
0.2842145562,
-0.4548038244,
-0.4999489486,
-0.742215097,
0.0276362039,
-0.4210458398,
0.5628134012,
-0.096666269,
-0.0852229968,
-0.2495006472,
-0.4773656428,
-0.362616837,
-0.5839477777,
-0.082079187,
-0.6585562229,
0.529681921,
-0.078069739,
0.5798289776,
0.3912518322,
0.1398460865,
0.2768095732,
-0.3215907812,
-0.0422646478,
-0.0940163732,
0.4186571538,
-0.4904396534,
-0.5297992826,
-0.0141678676,
0.2983197272,
0.1082963198,
1.2287602425,
-0.1020661741,
0.0668046921,
-0.0522957928,
0.2096693963,
-0.9261134267,
0.0011030664,
-0.888153851,
-0.0716466978,
-0.0982706696,
-0.0867251456,
-0.6704652905,
0.2620459795,
0.4624111056,
-0.6806972027,
0.4976180494,
0.0307537802,
1.1019541025,
0.1916866153,
-0.5191870332,
-0.2846183479,
-0.7614401579,
0.9829282165,
-0.6895722151,
0.7915937304,
0.4574206471,
0.2151682675,
-0.000894074,
-0.399479121,
-1.0776166916,
-0.0939896703,
-0.0830678642,
0.0326499343,
-0.3012750149,
0.1323186904,
0.4538564086,
0.1065553129,
-0.4449474216,
-0.0082073417,
0.0322642177,
-0.0538677238,
0.2617807984,
-0.1621628851,
0.3264908791,
-0.0809046403,
-0.3828332424,
-0.015538088,
-0.6380865574,
-0.2451577187,
-0.0650125071,
0.2595428824,
0.1001596674,
0.5629638433,
-0.1555221528,
1.3395694494,
-0.163114354,
-0.0521556027,
-0.0711140335,
0.0447093993,
-0.5821479559,
-0.0315065235,
0.1468379796,
0.1312066615,
0.3827363849,
-0.3671738505,
-0.3544187546,
0.5866934657,
0.1301617175,
-0.5487631559,
-0.1314685047,
0.2967943251,
-0.3823501766,
-0.1423865408,
-0.0023870503,
-0.0654634163,
-0.2459827662,
-0.6477457881,
0.7324028611,
-0.6251541376,
-0.2766495943,
0.4191303551,
-0.7295486331,
0.1811149716,
0.2228148431,
-0.943774879,
0.3076814115,
0.6989330649,
0.61529845,
0.1171200424,
-0.2482942194,
-0.3320981264,
0.3923687041,
-0.4393562973,
0.92113024,
-0.8358575106,
-0.5087316036,
0.0229111109,
0.061251387,
-0.1296523362,
-0.5041158199,
-0.0288491249,
-0.6801871061,
0.3317130804,
-0.4895202518,
-1.0308101177,
-0.3323991299,
0.1549695432,
-0.3693282008,
0.7321395278,
0.0774665922,
-0.5253697038,
0.7986314893,
-0.4567912221,
-0.3015364707,
0.2982721627,
-0.0625180602,
0.2869064808,
0.5895212293,
0.1863081902,
0.4583144486,
0.1425222158,
0.1890546829,
-0.3533531427,
-0.3281458616,
0.2114024609,
-0.3166813552,
0.8017907739,
0.208532393,
0.0053000753,
-0.0885053724,
-0.6077224016,
-0.0390952192,
0.2877973914,
-0.0535294823,
-1.2074230909,
0.1732524186,
-0.043108698,
0.0043671187,
0.2461505085,
-0.7206532955,
0.227235198,
-0.483107388,
0.4032048285,
0.427496165,
-0.0162757132,
0.6115121245,
0.0343594551,
0.1885219067,
0.2032834142,
-0.0254801828,
-0.3394365907,
-0.5654473305,
-0.7027868629,
-0.176998049,
0.430837512,
0.1962619275,
-0.8395056129,
0.3378283679,
0.0938825682,
-0.3596582115,
-0.3631854951,
-0.2244984359,
0.3044548929,
0.4024584591,
0.2037767023,
0.034173578,
-0.1607414633,
-0.6139525771,
-0.3807196915,
-0.3331632614,
-0.394883126,
0.2242808789,
0.5642616153,
-0.1260656416,
1.1970462799,
-0.8585826159,
-0.1151736006,
-0.2564183772,
0.3031062186,
0.0892032757,
0.0179500058,
0.8721758723,
-0.8537068963,
-0.2821926177,
-0.1883966029,
-0.8049885631,
-0.1995206326,
0.1690655351,
-0.1270623952,
0.2145873159,
0.4978936613,
-0.6552360654,
0.561178267,
0.595261395,
-0.5098837614,
0.4485580921,
-0.3970182538,
-0.2168474793,
-0.7824601531,
0.0221631136,
-0.0535911918,
-0.1349440366,
-0.9269667268,
0.3444595039,
0.2341506928,
0.057229273,
-0.3329719305,
0.8285226822,
-0.6568797231,
-0.187004745,
-0.3867390454,
0.4130348265,
0.4215891957,
0.3671424389,
0.4005568922,
0.562895596,
0.7362641096,
-0.9526965022,
0.0705850422,
0.3330437541,
-0.5456055999,
0.8694421053,
-0.7271903157,
-0.0279689878,
-0.3691516817,
-0.0625578538,
-0.8999500275,
-0.0310094059,
-0.0478015281,
-0.443033278,
0.0940751731,
-0.1630924046,
-0.3398509026,
-0.3743242323,
0.2364147604,
0.3252353966,
0.3651295304,
-0.6783371568,
0.3549723923,
0.485080421,
0.3107794821,
-0.2889794111,
-0.6038757563,
-0.0669508204,
-0.0711564571,
-0.1221427023,
0.5106667876,
0.0195928738,
-0.6037237644,
0.2447025925,
-0.1554577947,
-0.2378879786,
0.2914623022,
0.1645614952,
0.2773342729,
-0.0388865396,
0.5487897396,
-0.0053489497,
-0.0729681402,
-0.3285593092,
-0.4480602145,
0.515216589,
0.3194587231,
-0.8018482924,
0.1112432256,
0.3344760537,
0.486245513,
-0.5894661546,
0.8704478145,
0.1270416379,
-0.7813383341,
-0.5464929342,
-0.4769181013,
-0.3838759363,
-0.4253333211,
0.0364901647,
-0.6009957194,
-0.8710252643,
0.4981231689,
-0.1405633688,
-0.1020111889,
0.2568958402,
0.2819389999,
-0.047376316,
1.0028712749,
0.851573348,
-0.0757369623,
0.3288230002,
-0.1763364524,
0.5617245436,
-0.8897946477,
0.0105275931,
-0.6307821274,
-0.1645454913,
-0.2733829319,
-0.463920325,
0.2712396085,
0.3999539614,
-0.0014864508,
0.5483170152,
-0.3886343837,
0.5065248013,
0.4772186279,
-0.1020513698,
0.3735609353,
-0.1555431634,
-0.4722187519,
-0.0468769222,
-0.5391702056,
-0.4278055727,
0.6614106894,
0.1599212438,
0.4170873761,
0.0871505812,
0.5763512254,
0.1677112877,
0.1180679947,
-1.0916465521,
0.5456424356,
-0.1322882175,
-0.6647090316,
-0.3110691905,
0.0080487859,
-0.9165912271,
0.4999254942,
0.1031243652,
-0.9198647738,
0.509213984,
-0.1564822644,
-0.3202908337,
0.1952052116,
-0.5612769127,
0.7994872928,
0.1492283046,
0.0235549547,
-0.1993820965,
-0.2123688012,
0.1811046451,
0.085656397,
0.0646231845,
-0.4814415872,
0.038847167,
0.4894928336,
-0.4721307456,
0.6980964541,
-0.4546950758,
-0.4787179232,
0.2998253405,
0.5403219461,
0.2064837962,
-0.4229201376,
-0.1869360656,
0.318628937,
0.2800597847,
-0.155573681,
-0.6575816274,
0.5807933807,
-0.231529668,
-0.5037963986,
-0.4807730615,
-0.4254582822,
-0.3692891896,
0.2373923361,
0.1104302704,
0.5416386127,
-0.3848945498,
-0.2428209633,
0.5725362301,
-0.2932114303,
0.5702733994,
1.1303905249,
-0.2722129226,
0.6176533103,
0.8773297668,
0.0953418016,
0.274071306,
0.2864918709,
-0.0195283536,
-0.4966377616,
-0.303884536,
-0.4497391284,
0.2681525648,
-0.6055878401,
-0.1815844774,
-0.5156547427,
-0.2057634741,
-0.119597666,
-0.1864733398,
0.0081836218,
-0.1825939119,
-0.161170572,
-0.1255041659,
0.484436661,
0.9900253415,
0.1320432425,
0.3891064525,
-0.6575578451,
0.4763404727,
0.2673172057,
0.4840074778,
-0.0656824037,
-0.5463011265,
0.0271188039,
0.1319488436,
-0.013507518,
-1.1956682205,
0.581127584,
0.3918375075,
0.5393098593,
0.6896062493,
0.1322887242,
0.7293114662,
-0.7357008457,
0.9124906659,
-0.0987724513,
-1.1954417229,
0.6298729777,
-0.289898932,
0.4340278506,
-0.0102756945,
0.4214848578,
-1.0016616583,
-0.611390233,
-0.4237519205,
-0.5166341662,
0.4831714928,
-0.1824761778,
0.2461951226,
-0.5308600068,
0.0873038769,
0.1882553548,
0.2196503133,
-0.2440810353,
-0.0107712662,
0.1196436584,
-0.0520211682,
-0.1872121245,
-0.307363987,
0.0311794411,
-0.2287762016,
0.2029037476,
-0.2206496298,
0.280742079,
0.1052451506,
-0.4204112887,
-0.0615523644,
0.3565229475,
0.4093097746,
0.8045754433,
-0.1369412541,
0.3740741611,
0.077491127,
-0.0937557444,
0.0457583927,
-0.2665353119,
-0.341252774,
0.339936018,
0.5600832105,
0.8031104207,
0.4417567551,
-0.7227343917,
0.6454785466,
0.1037451401,
-0.1343928427,
0.0729481354,
-0.0310695507,
0.0443031229,
0.0729781613,
0.4532040954,
-0.0158850458,
0.2092871815,
-0.5971488953,
0.2853200734,
0.7147430182,
-0.4743947387,
-0.3993480206,
0.6279120445,
-0.2388713509,
0.1064156294,
0.3185377121,
-0.3345465362,
-0.7171295881,
0.4295812249,
0.7588002086,
0.6108324528,
-0.3520312607,
0.385571897,
0.290412277,
-0.1155191436,
-0.0585755333,
0.3071309328,
-0.1680431962,
-1.3492141962,
-0.3696166873,
-0.8226351738,
-0.4470941424,
0.0752378926,
-0.8266063929,
0.0073044505,
-0.1432584822,
-0.1200989783,
0.2835753858,
-0.4385876358,
-0.6771816611,
0.2486670464,
0.1444945037,
0.9056434035,
-0.9715735912,
1.0335228443,
0.6314675212,
-0.2968907356,
-0.6357129812,
0.0830616504,
-0.0985623971,
-0.8453400731,
0.8757248521,
-0.092780292,
-0.0308032259,
-0.031097807,
-0.6666024923,
-0.552780211,
0.6687244773,
0.163684994,
-0.5426296592,
0.2029876262,
-0.0253381785,
0.6538249254,
-0.1466923803,
0.202014491,
0.7513902187,
0.4422044456,
0.0884068012,
-0.8745129704,
-0.0988121703,
-0.0991436765,
0.2659755945,
0.1727947444,
-0.0585496388,
0.9549148679,
-0.3054822385,
-0.631919682,
-0.1687661707,
0.5991662741,
0.2230708748,
0.2651278675,
0.6562514901,
0.6540883183,
0.7741776109,
-0.1999919564,
1.0347288847,
-0.5532476306,
0.2251406312,
1.02914083,
-0.7916126251,
1.1412103176,
0.6554861069,
-0.3199433386,
0.4956985414,
0.4946163595,
0.2049625069,
0.7087645531,
0.1170101389,
-0.5649085045,
-0.39035815,
-0.3842013478,
-0.235464111,
0.6944676638,
0.6059229374,
0.0183736011,
-0.5278967619,
0.2618914545,
-0.114069365,
0.2807637155,
0.0445605405,
0.8708295226,
0.0629554316,
-0.662401557,
0.474516511,
0.2752042413,
0.6588020921,
-0.6554841995,
-0.177826494,
-0.2568045259,
0.2957488,
0.2150365412,
-0.7578346729,
0.3946445584,
-0.0673423856,
-0.2551181912,
-0.192851916,
0.9488730431,
-0.6560218334,
-0.3273591995,
0.6534412503,
0.7558813691,
0.124303557,
-0.4500447512,
-0.2122587711,
0.0310746562,
-0.377515018,
-0.0886871219,
0.309790045,
0.7366402149,
-0.3195141256,
0.6037583947,
0.5773618817,
0.3425835669,
-0.0014673321,
0.3735616505,
0.5892852545,
-0.4657971561,
-0.2653630078,
-0.7015975714,
0.0915102363,
0.1037011892,
-0.049266234,
0.917519331,
0.1310671866,
0.9960241914,
-0.4065771997,
0.8795104623,
-0.0858529434,
0.5290010571,
-0.2633011341,
0.8178272247,
-0.7405160666,
0.0182010941,
-0.0745167211,
-0.8563018441,
-0.2726328075,
0.8396841288,
-0.404309541,
-0.1783674359,
0.5568412542,
0.7239617705,
-0.2258259803,
-0.0428456515,
0.7144532204,
0.110323064,
0.2290215045,
0.3296532035,
0.7172759771,
-0.2922343016,
-0.1940770149,
-0.0954605862,
-0.1958207339,
-0.11349608,
-0.8807947636,
-0.6707424521,
-0.9760490656,
-0.0797870681,
0.0756333396,
0.1154314056,
0.5778565407,
0.6084988117,
-0.9839441776,
-0.0805789977,
0.0521939583,
0.1711218804,
-0.3594250679,
-0.2148974389,
0.2090792805,
-0.4745804667,
-0.8203819394,
0.6081234217,
0.3304010034,
0.1443272382,
-0.3697633445,
-0.022015579,
-0.2331339568,
0.4571789801,
0.920003891,
0.1093370914,
-1.0100806952,
-0.7094638944,
0.0651217028,
-0.1464492977,
-0.4931541383,
0.778562963,
-0.8965920806,
0.5687019229,
0.5382210612,
0.1883939952,
0.2247104645,
-0.157604143,
0.5917714238,
-0.892234385,
0.620408237,
-0.0990661457,
0.5313123465,
0.2569719851,
-0.0170673877,
0.3331889808,
0.4917492568,
-0.0677635819,
-0.8461430073,
0.3563773632,
-0.7830954194,
-0.7483695149,
1.0678559542,
-0.1622802317,
-0.2458534688,
-0.2765043974,
-0.168817088,
0.1254060268,
0.1455688924,
0.5950485468,
0.9006260037,
0.1621631086,
-0.0628632754,
-0.6096135974,
0.4609985352,
0.4136104882,
-0.3295447826,
0.117195569,
0.5174109936,
0.3195919693,
0.1164184362,
0.5794666409,
0.118084006,
-0.1440469176,
0.0400888436,
0.2059072703,
0.079807058,
-0.45380494,
-0.1355799139,
-0.0973852947,
0.0581035763,
-0.3479248881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03341v1 | The Effect of Metadata on Scientific Literature Tagging: A Cross-Field Cross-Model Study | 2023-02-07T09:34:41 | 2023-02-07T09:34:41 | Yu Zhang, Bowen Jin, Qi Zhu, Yu Meng, Jiawei Han | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.LG | Due to the exponential growth of scientific publications on the Web, there is
a pressing need to tag each paper with fine-grained topics so that researchers
can track their interested fields of study rather than drowning in the whole
literature. Scientific literature tagging is beyond a pure multi-label text
classification task because papers on the Web are prevalently accompanied by
metadata information such as venues, authors, and references, which may serve
as additional signals to infer relevant tags. Although there have been studies
making use of metadata in academic paper classification, their focus is often
restricted to one or two scientific fields (e.g., computer science and
biomedicine) and to one specific model. In this work, we systematically study
the effect of metadata on scientific literature tagging across 19 fields. We
select three representative multi-label classifiers (i.e., a bag-of-words
model, a sequence-based model, and a pre-trained language model) and explore
their performance change in scientific literature tagging when metadata are fed
to the classifiers as additional features. We observe some ubiquitous patterns
of metadata's effects across all fields (e.g., venues are consistently
beneficial to paper tagging in almost all cases), as well as some unique
patterns in fields other than computer science and biomedicine, which are not
explored in previous studies. | [
-0.6044198275,
-0.2050742656,
0.4172604084,
0.2481092215,
-0.1921587735,
-0.1020707339,
0.3289269805,
-1.1551715136,
0.3574798405,
0.4526618719,
-0.0734170675,
-0.7308707237,
-0.5652812123,
0.2735600471,
-0.3881147206,
1.4222245216,
0.2594329715,
0.1638540179,
-0.6194496155,
-0.1430251449,
0.1234095544,
-0.7387855053,
0.0747224465,
-0.2703539729,
1.1273677349,
-0.2445095181,
0.36120978,
0.7506999373,
1.0203586817,
0.22093606,
-0.1604087949,
-0.0050239242,
-0.0066135977,
0.1037184596,
-0.3937548101,
-0.6595890522,
-0.6091191769,
0.2239701003,
1.0290210247,
0.7641527653,
0.3030989766,
0.4933550954,
-0.0694858432,
0.2975660861,
-0.6413211823,
-0.1302982122,
-0.5249134898,
0.0757597685,
-0.5529485941,
-0.7462248802,
-0.2885429859,
0.0506316423,
0.1776672602,
-0.8083834052,
0.5709612966,
0.3132520318,
0.8637983203,
0.031824246,
-0.3621552885,
-0.0883848593,
-0.8492013216,
0.579587996,
-0.242397666,
0.3000933528,
0.3796656728,
-0.1858518571,
-0.0460180156,
-0.8200685382,
-0.107044965,
-0.1041823849,
-0.1620284617,
0.2016138285,
0.0297696143,
0.0823050812,
0.5784310699,
-0.0254494026,
-0.4720488787,
0.1437045038,
-0.4369004667,
-0.0729784295,
0.5190461278,
0.1687755734,
0.166512534,
0.041320201,
-0.4129094183,
0.0819674805,
-0.5292999744,
0.1200808063,
0.2938915491,
0.3290882111,
0.7135727406,
0.5225201249,
-0.0295456685,
0.6754835844,
-0.2651749551,
-0.2825598717,
-0.0264006015,
-0.7295351028,
0.0333747752,
0.075576961,
0.8250486255,
0.4217915535,
-0.4374143183,
-0.2481819838,
0.1187089235,
0.0393119529,
0.2357063591,
-0.7131676078,
-0.0518993624,
-0.1559183002,
-0.6775670648,
-0.3844134808,
0.1876390725,
-0.707701385,
-0.6722807884,
-0.107383348,
0.4434615374,
-0.1327815205,
-0.0559884161,
-0.3030292988,
-0.2863583863,
0.0628849268,
0.2442061156,
-0.5884817839,
0.2817687094,
0.616609931,
1.1337200403,
-0.0113059795,
-0.4005461633,
-0.160228163,
0.3410516977,
0.0241110772,
1.0306479931,
-0.8332340717,
-0.3974885643,
-0.3091062605,
-0.1755505651,
-0.0605616122,
-0.0966560543,
0.5193668008,
-0.7563533187,
-0.0561334491,
-0.4702146351,
-0.3385959864,
-0.295299232,
0.279717207,
-0.8618932962,
0.8456507921,
-0.4088644087,
-1.0882362127,
0.8390815258,
-0.7223222256,
-0.2338055819,
0.0271556787,
0.1423318386,
-0.6040078998,
0.1515354663,
-0.251127094,
0.3793153465,
-0.4161942899,
0.3464677036,
-0.6927155256,
-0.3413872421,
0.505400598,
0.003629073,
0.5272215605,
0.0276092701,
0.0713749155,
-0.1748354435,
-0.9025853872,
-0.0657058135,
-0.3374495208,
-0.4148083925,
-0.9897504449,
0.0785532966,
0.3600874543,
0.4319092035,
-0.249907881,
-0.6795293689,
0.5248118043,
-0.1484381407,
0.0040724473,
-0.1540634632,
0.1151561961,
0.6231347919,
-0.6031347513,
0.5150789618,
-0.035076689,
-0.1545177102,
-0.2672629952,
-0.693775773,
-0.1259864271,
-0.4002430439,
1.0418512821,
0.3685826957,
-0.1609244347,
0.1759719849,
0.0953120887,
-0.7387911081,
-0.8101605773,
-0.4239609838,
0.092305325,
0.2617973685,
0.4383451045,
-0.4477334023,
-0.6216551065,
-0.6046053171,
-0.6223306656,
0.0643199086,
0.0174389444,
0.484934479,
0.9067570567,
-0.3018134832,
1.2111165524,
-0.388292402,
-0.6010463834,
0.4875137806,
0.5770581365,
-0.3859969079,
0.3272437155,
0.5563778877,
-0.8878145814,
-0.3432307243,
0.0538781509,
-0.4475164711,
-0.4748323858,
-0.2393665314,
0.0452819988,
0.2782816589,
0.2359236628,
-0.6439262033,
0.5658220649,
0.1853301674,
-0.1997550875,
0.6879672408,
-0.1545391828,
0.3154398501,
-0.6369017363,
0.691867888,
0.1908023506,
0.1782722473,
-0.6487628818,
-0.000160823,
0.0296505522,
0.0765846521,
-0.0552957132,
0.5197479725,
-0.6173258424,
-0.2635486126,
-0.3142839968,
0.015057032,
0.4230466783,
-0.198997736,
0.3217768073,
0.2396757603,
0.5603882074,
-0.6211282611,
-0.1412742287,
-0.1029910892,
-0.0855034739,
0.278814584,
-0.3051486015,
-0.3261572719,
-0.3185485601,
0.6968858838,
-0.9616108537,
0.0623000115,
0.2594284117,
-0.3049613833,
0.2989551127,
0.0146079743,
-0.7018849254,
0.0000302832,
-0.3310984075,
0.3272069097,
-0.1765215844,
-0.0872879177,
0.7832289934,
0.1543963253,
0.1104441583,
-0.6356044412,
-0.5071310997,
0.2227425426,
-0.5255259871,
-0.3124459684,
0.8187818527,
0.0716104358,
-0.1807589978,
0.1779950559,
-0.1966035664,
-0.1223205328,
0.3990709484,
0.30279392,
0.0933499634,
0.1252318919,
0.5440397263,
0.0356447771,
-0.0023022376,
0.228783071,
-0.482010603,
0.2852964699,
-0.0922911912,
-0.0063483715,
-0.0602660291,
0.5722452402,
0.3570322692,
-0.61626333,
0.9627996683,
0.9382537603,
-0.1943769902,
0.0503418818,
-0.3095508814,
-0.0670402795,
-0.2731790245,
0.3098003566,
-0.2791180611,
-0.636526525,
0.7518728375,
-0.4426434636,
0.0012619894,
0.6287614703,
-0.0303511452,
-0.6664029956,
0.8397623301,
0.7235814333,
0.2741014659,
0.3501648009,
-0.1686692387,
0.0190181453,
-1.0088176727,
-0.4758970439,
-1.0697778463,
-0.34381935,
-0.9067976475,
-0.4461936951,
0.2028247714,
0.2870880067,
0.1700076014,
-0.0085755326,
-0.7003617883,
0.3511454165,
0.6050488353,
-0.1725810468,
0.5427559018,
0.0316790715,
0.0811817423,
-0.0613742843,
-0.7766986489,
-0.4873467386,
0.7867120504,
0.3132695556,
0.7541913986,
-0.1643571109,
0.9092282653,
0.1414389461,
0.587454617,
-0.7577610612,
0.3276365697,
-0.0633875728,
-0.9578933716,
-0.1016254127,
-0.0800133944,
-1.0292799473,
0.476598233,
-0.4555492401,
-0.5467376709,
0.544744432,
0.0608415231,
-0.34054178,
0.1788426936,
-0.1728385687,
0.3363755345,
-0.345105648,
-0.4721691012,
0.0945711583,
-1.0253813267,
0.2361618727,
-0.5182262063,
0.3007375598,
0.0995659605,
-0.4134034216,
0.9825136065,
0.1358120441,
0.9577005506,
0.0229092427,
0.1218018681,
0.2187164128,
-0.0581661612,
0.1255798042,
0.0178565048,
0.0102223009,
0.5073341131,
0.5854337811,
-0.0946685299,
-0.255843699,
0.5343059897,
-0.6150817275,
-0.4923657477,
-1.1000535488,
-0.7058180571,
-0.0212176237,
0.2710731328,
0.3386701643,
0.1302626133,
-0.1420525014,
0.2411596477,
0.7966295481,
-0.249468565,
0.441006422,
0.8013654947,
-0.4838318229,
-0.2515131831,
0.7740392089,
0.7198137641,
0.0221582912,
0.5560798049,
0.222824052,
-0.1903199852,
-0.3705653548,
-0.0477313176,
0.3862474263,
-0.5884799361,
-0.4385583699,
-1.1170258522,
-0.0783021674,
-0.3896465302,
-0.0705090985,
0.2492732555,
-0.5248422623,
-0.7237929106,
0.3079872727,
0.3755037487,
0.5388181806,
-0.1549911797,
0.4300017357,
-0.9908296466,
-0.1638266593,
-0.3996016085,
0.6230745912,
-0.0750970095,
-0.1816441417,
-0.4241010845,
-0.2393211871,
-0.2430645674,
-0.9762576222,
0.3412515819,
0.5076152682,
0.4636020064,
0.3882878721,
-0.1349817961,
0.5629033446,
-0.5533117056,
0.5167049766,
0.0570849217,
-0.6806694269,
0.2811793387,
-0.6149869561,
0.4448877275,
0.475258708,
1.0434292555,
-0.6299936175,
-0.205092296,
-0.519075036,
-0.8149793744,
0.7784119844,
-0.2219311744,
-0.2773659825,
0.3095404208,
0.2201411724,
0.333217293,
0.2524452806,
-1.0454394817,
-0.1960708201,
-0.0127785224,
0.3550757766,
0.1559177935,
-0.1936266422,
-0.3112103939,
-0.2516407371,
0.6065539122,
-0.046926599,
0.3481231928,
0.3665440381,
-0.0047027692,
-0.0400287732,
0.2374068052,
0.7053079605,
0.3712140024,
-0.2847758532,
0.2651379108,
-0.2358012348,
-0.3765953183,
-0.1947923899,
0.5188449621,
-0.3609681427,
0.1810899973,
0.4340327084,
0.5016654134,
-0.0747046024,
-0.1202148721,
-0.145485878,
0.1970956028,
-0.3650743663,
0.2447773218,
-0.037957415,
0.1020136029,
0.2326685488,
0.4672752619,
0.5131599903,
0.801183939,
-0.44437325,
0.080543153,
0.5975563526,
-0.1599973738,
-0.28101179,
0.49660936,
0.002292054,
-0.1744874716,
-0.2439873219,
-0.0476331599,
-0.5861337781,
0.6379469037,
0.8211365938,
0.3731272817,
-0.191822648,
0.3420853019,
0.1891121119,
0.3625842035,
0.0636949986,
-0.0902483687,
-0.2447925806,
-0.2348612696,
-0.154220596,
-0.9380819201,
-0.29819718,
-0.0649582595,
-0.4839038253,
0.1376214474,
-0.1083875075,
-0.7431543469,
0.5528095961,
0.3192984164,
-0.6379907131,
0.2309010476,
0.1604034901,
0.7386023998,
-1.0533647537,
0.6876264215,
1.0309798717,
-0.414575547,
-0.2152318209,
-0.1186800748,
-0.0360607766,
0.2549822032,
0.9030702114,
0.2876639664,
-0.1650458872,
0.0012788185,
-0.5207723975,
-1.5347185135,
1.0389759541,
-0.4330227971,
-0.5549713373,
0.076670602,
0.2659209371,
1.0825856924,
-0.4424434304,
0.4028113484,
0.253562659,
0.5332330465,
0.1884509474,
-0.9121524692,
-0.1928015202,
-0.2872972786,
0.0204371717,
0.3972861469,
-0.6452963352,
0.5372802019,
0.0022673004,
-0.0750821978,
-0.1378192306,
0.4853509367,
0.1426870972,
0.9015516043,
0.130510658,
0.368999064,
0.9239097834,
-0.1357762814,
0.7303524613,
-0.0944050848,
0.3228396475,
0.7425150275,
-0.606713593,
0.4200442731,
0.448836863,
-0.058102414,
0.3753251135,
0.8431326747,
-0.6199079156,
0.4374310672,
0.3560691476,
-0.3556170762,
-0.0591753498,
-0.6542894244,
-0.6544675231,
0.7007897496,
0.5104902387,
-0.7082993984,
-0.135348469,
0.4020507634,
0.032702148,
-0.3455913663,
-0.3388502896,
0.6231279373,
0.0789500177,
-0.5566284657,
-0.1214784682,
0.3224684,
0.6902484298,
-0.5439071655,
-0.0159859098,
0.2456768602,
-0.084508352,
-0.5865830183,
-0.6599471569,
0.4359458089,
-0.0462375283,
-0.4762966037,
-0.1140088141,
1.2427752018,
-0.5640522242,
-0.5408835411,
0.2512769997,
0.320735842,
0.2830069363,
0.1390841752,
-0.456365943,
0.0410936251,
-0.4962960184,
-0.3044568598,
0.6686362028,
0.3625637591,
-0.4810771346,
0.4355899692,
0.672020793,
0.229073137,
-0.0203899872,
-0.2324889898,
0.8487141728,
-0.6218681335,
-0.2459771484,
-0.6922206283,
0.4130556881,
-0.0916242748,
-0.2824712694,
0.9794047475,
0.6613434553,
0.5424100757,
-0.0506629422,
0.7279846072,
-0.1646835208,
0.1831204444,
0.0050126947,
0.9719263911,
-0.6301397085,
0.1363821477,
-0.3424059451,
-0.859357655,
-1.096794486,
0.2338805348,
-0.2944720387,
0.2391330302,
0.7484636307,
0.2862992585,
0.2149160951,
-0.0172770005,
0.0499183238,
-0.1126983464,
0.248784706,
-0.2984704077,
0.7111667991,
-0.212582618,
0.3928854764,
-0.2292885631,
-0.2440596372,
-0.3074212968,
-1.0733853579,
-0.8764283657,
-0.6501650214,
-0.3506274223,
-0.2696077824,
-0.0020438039,
0.4831092358,
0.3822233677,
-0.4588635862,
0.1463550627,
0.4687531888,
-0.0957200527,
-0.2521847486,
-0.190855816,
0.3254212439,
-0.1587297618,
-0.2863650322,
-0.1457501203,
0.2889062762,
-0.1517797709,
-0.1789431125,
0.4636688232,
-0.7459276319,
0.0952620879,
0.6301655173,
0.1611483544,
-0.6215464473,
0.1063486934,
0.3267305195,
-0.3123771548,
0.0026803121,
0.8352857828,
-0.8504754901,
0.5622021556,
0.4925735593,
0.4288567603,
0.589531064,
0.1992248446,
0.1364826858,
-0.6963026524,
-0.5076705813,
0.4096606076,
0.0104153482,
0.1305915713,
-0.5209065676,
0.466103673,
0.5722129941,
-0.9143302441,
-1.0637618303,
-0.1984575093,
-0.8622034192,
-0.3698913455,
0.9192239046,
-0.1066343114,
-0.0858439133,
-0.2423701882,
-0.1197530925,
0.3000384271,
-0.149191618,
0.923347652,
0.9530165195,
-0.3214654624,
-0.0771121085,
-0.4168542922,
0.5145017505,
0.1789470166,
-0.7817645669,
-0.2310775816,
0.4427449107,
0.1459547281,
0.7214699984,
0.2733977437,
0.0686914399,
0.1817466915,
-0.0346041918,
0.3848201632,
-0.1257167757,
-0.6203643084,
-0.2963398695,
0.3452191949,
-0.1549995542,
0.2325914204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03338v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03338v1 | Learning Manner of Execution from Partial Corrections | 2023-02-07T09:25:58 | 2023-02-07T09:25:58 | Mattias Appelgren, Alex Lascarides | cs.CL | cs.CL | Some actions must be executed in different ways depending on the context. For
example, wiping away marker requires vigorous force while wiping away almonds
requires more gentle force. In this paper we provide a model where an agent
learns which manner of action execution to use in which context, drawing on
evidence from trial and error and verbal corrections when it makes a mistake
(e.g., ``no, gently''). The learner starts out with a domain model that lacks
the concepts denoted by the words in the teacher's feedback; both the words
describing the context (e.g., marker) and the adverbs like ``gently''. We show
that through the the semantics of coherence, our agent can perform the symbol
grounding that's necessary for exploiting the teacher's feedback so as to solve
its domain-level planning problem: to perform its actions in the current
context in the right way. | [
0.0652430654,
-0.9662324786,
0.5376958847,
-0.086179167,
-0.1730390042,
-0.0762793645,
-0.0546243638,
-0.0650745109,
0.1775205731,
0.5211397409,
-0.7181902528,
-0.5043263435,
-0.7903724909,
-0.0225704927,
-0.4337033331,
1.2813248634,
-0.4868839979,
0.2137895972,
0.1329498738,
-0.297683388,
-0.7957594395,
-0.3877491355,
-0.8077651262,
-0.6032326221,
0.1709616035,
0.55167377,
0.6748235822,
0.4742029309,
0.3861422837,
0.3892649114,
0.0681607872,
0.1650874168,
-0.5561908484,
0.01746618,
-0.4497838318,
-0.7783383131,
-0.2959303558,
0.4761452079,
0.1997976303,
0.8900671601,
-0.2984922528,
-0.4409523904,
0.1425806284,
0.619494915,
-0.564648211,
0.3926517069,
-0.3374377787,
0.3214196861,
0.4824430048,
-0.1417905837,
-0.4767489731,
-0.3873971701,
0.2680311501,
-0.7122721672,
0.2015378922,
-0.2839359045,
0.8109383583,
0.2680445015,
-0.5513622761,
-0.6053652763,
-0.8241304159,
0.8388505578,
-0.287522912,
0.0084016295,
0.8493072987,
0.3395627737,
-0.4756388068,
-0.8656309247,
-0.5229455829,
-0.0630118698,
-0.1816090792,
0.1123135388,
0.2730139792,
0.2100456059,
0.512357831,
0.1297814548,
0.198586762,
-0.4474317133,
-0.1707217842,
-0.0791050494,
0.4583013654,
0.1653006971,
0.3682467937,
0.0045120404,
-0.7284764051,
-0.2317454368,
-0.6548314691,
0.4430393279,
0.0121684829,
0.3774375916,
-0.317063421,
0.4742139876,
-0.2645949721,
0.5491623878,
0.3583632708,
-0.148965463,
-0.1942834407,
-0.1417368054,
-0.4356809258,
-0.0085537154,
0.3190693557,
0.4956843257,
0.1197767258,
-0.2606261075,
-0.5508341193,
0.4204980433,
0.3957315087,
-0.5954132676,
-0.3379410207,
0.2031896263,
-0.0395320356,
0.0447689965,
0.143373549,
-0.4021298885,
-0.278203845,
-0.8745184541,
0.640973568,
-0.5417559147,
0.0726273432,
0.2176560163,
-0.2275776714,
0.2795201242,
0.8770158291,
-0.5369887352,
0.6953241229,
0.6694093347,
0.4663827419,
0.2442850918,
-0.4556916058,
-0.7621461749,
0.2967835665,
-0.6517674327,
0.5329562426,
-0.5541393161,
-0.4223439693,
0.1773004979,
0.2874730229,
-0.2285837382,
-0.5611220002,
0.4006344676,
-0.6123161912,
0.2538986206,
-0.5929781199,
-0.6891903877,
-0.7508286834,
0.0451408997,
-0.5625579953,
0.7392194867,
-0.0019863308,
-0.3806558847,
0.6086601019,
-0.3493816257,
-0.7156080604,
-0.1876931638,
-0.454706192,
-0.2671842277,
0.1988606304,
-0.2419691533,
0.5926677585,
0.3502858281,
0.3153539896,
0.0456204787,
-0.6132839322,
0.1172499731,
0.1150562316,
0.8909487724,
-0.1097114757,
-0.8255024552,
0.1443674713,
-0.5707999468,
-0.2152890712,
0.0675759315,
-0.2247152925,
-0.4043557644,
0.2647167146,
-0.3956696391,
0.4272859097,
-0.0373690613,
-0.1905339062,
0.165310815,
-0.4486242533,
0.2775529027,
0.7039530873,
0.2777218521,
0.6875067353,
-0.6188380122,
0.2694351673,
-0.0423506461,
0.1545977443,
0.0538193025,
-0.3963722289,
-0.9423422813,
-0.2669718862,
0.0706225187,
0.4213557839,
-1.0474693775,
0.3049941659,
0.1356378496,
-0.0771263391,
-0.1077647284,
0.204163745,
0.7194707394,
0.573746264,
0.2624945343,
-0.2825906873,
-0.3821565211,
-0.4304110706,
-0.1410826445,
0.0242528133,
0.4606008232,
-0.0477903001,
0.6863590479,
0.232668072,
0.9686269164,
-0.3646271527,
-0.3653253615,
-0.0773451924,
0.3565973341,
-0.02900609,
0.4169018567,
0.3370757997,
-0.959694922,
-0.3114025593,
-0.0361095965,
-0.8947137594,
0.2440758944,
-0.1835832596,
-0.512347579,
0.1845306158,
0.5365011096,
-0.4437085688,
0.8010540605,
0.1633974016,
-0.493743062,
0.3675293028,
-0.2188480794,
0.2869553268,
-0.7747954726,
-0.2580498755,
-0.2601159811,
-0.3204104602,
-0.8383501172,
0.4777756035,
-0.0434931368,
0.2418780476,
-0.8010520935,
0.3148116767,
-0.5402444601,
0.2883178592,
-0.5866467357,
0.0519845784,
0.2397694737,
0.7581079006,
0.3936543167,
0.6624145508,
0.2304208428,
-0.9056473374,
0.2206241786,
0.1437054873,
0.17537646,
0.7179782391,
-0.6487086415,
0.163372308,
-0.1145375147,
0.0518598333,
-0.8938822746,
-0.2284047008,
0.4369734228,
-0.0755043775,
0.5860500336,
-0.2157979161,
-0.1578484327,
-0.0008124321,
-0.5521097779,
-0.0638191923,
0.3159518838,
-0.3842020333,
0.5450760722,
0.2241754532,
0.2422679067,
-0.6834800243,
-0.5163023472,
0.0811741352,
-0.0519248955,
-0.333501935,
0.1569983214,
-0.0595348738,
-0.3859759569,
-0.1313772649,
-0.2018313557,
-0.1002433375,
0.2415692508,
0.4085713327,
0.0506578907,
0.1981152743,
-0.0886521116,
0.2153542638,
0.0501782261,
0.2245565802,
0.3092399836,
0.3762973845,
0.1314702183,
-0.4395126402,
-0.4812797606,
0.4829660058,
0.2299823314,
0.0532974564,
0.6435223222,
-0.0902662277,
-0.742441237,
-0.445345521,
-0.0780532956,
-0.5168665051,
-0.463943243,
-0.0051251901,
-0.4817667007,
-0.3352074325,
0.4980806112,
-0.1142139509,
-0.1071798801,
0.1903418303,
0.5002610683,
-0.1567865312,
0.7245337963,
0.7398428917,
0.344399631,
0.4505514503,
-0.737675488,
0.1625159085,
-0.6606779695,
-0.264923811,
-0.4415982068,
-0.3636154532,
-0.4405841827,
-0.5818664432,
0.1166659892,
0.4183619022,
-0.184727937,
0.4421239495,
-0.325766921,
0.3768555522,
0.6576507688,
0.3771505356,
0.1420253217,
0.0086492887,
-0.3693754673,
0.037110243,
-0.3467490077,
-0.8247801065,
0.582549572,
-0.0368758067,
0.7853053212,
0.2198495716,
0.9889087081,
-0.1446412951,
0.2223445475,
-0.8543670774,
0.5605561137,
0.139280647,
-0.434771359,
-0.2387271523,
-0.0057947543,
-1.0097657442,
0.2404756546,
-0.0436779745,
-0.4266400039,
0.3188551962,
-0.0643510446,
-0.3375096023,
-0.0175288524,
-1.0337795019,
0.7718253136,
0.2420616597,
-0.4756513536,
-0.1153829172,
-0.8547003269,
0.0008791435,
0.2167979032,
0.2526246905,
0.0670153946,
-0.3148771226,
0.7390101552,
-0.7846132517,
1.384955287,
-0.596101284,
-0.117681548,
0.677482903,
0.451872468,
0.8027179241,
-0.2423994988,
0.1574186683,
-0.1968254149,
-0.0254304819,
-0.4570548236,
-0.8348860741,
0.3118866384,
-0.7580302358,
-0.66820544,
-0.5146089792,
-0.1826332062,
-0.0496681966,
0.2183892429,
0.24988316,
0.5769777894,
-0.1898688078,
-0.3789208233,
0.5354077816,
0.1108587161,
0.7274425626,
0.7643321157,
-0.1956084818,
-0.0572475232,
0.5900529623,
0.3575569093,
0.1619001329,
0.2254750133,
-0.0144611476,
-0.1681029648,
-0.4533285797,
-0.1771133393,
0.2752124369,
-0.9366371036,
-0.1979721487,
-0.3931468129,
0.1216847599,
-0.0478395,
-0.58710742,
-0.0348387808,
-0.2564667165,
-0.2544791102,
-0.2560453415,
0.2477784008,
1.1045348644,
0.1362964511,
0.4622781873,
-0.4611414075,
0.2546868622,
0.3762059808,
0.0203561932,
-0.1175031587,
-0.3009927273,
-0.2512921989,
0.1859150678,
-0.5720869899,
-1.0738902092,
0.17283234,
0.3180374503,
0.3158953488,
0.3540267646,
0.25390625,
0.5668245554,
-0.6597722769,
0.7734292746,
-0.0041502696,
-0.9450266957,
0.9171792865,
-0.2723798752,
0.0771249533,
0.4668617547,
0.4699570537,
-0.605540216,
-0.6705701351,
-0.5852748752,
-0.7283880711,
0.9111562371,
0.0455044694,
0.3809801042,
-0.339492023,
0.5503329635,
0.2355436683,
0.3475216031,
-0.4823268056,
-0.2580128908,
-0.0727492571,
-0.037535511,
0.0080052558,
-0.1681103855,
-0.8548395038,
-0.2055382282,
0.5404655337,
-0.2512577772,
0.3519154489,
0.3879512548,
-0.3186191618,
-0.3756619692,
0.0507077686,
0.7254408002,
0.818295598,
0.0153752919,
0.4134339988,
0.0558378696,
-0.5057142377,
0.369822681,
-0.2852008939,
-0.1860954314,
-0.3143108487,
0.6829243302,
0.5114889741,
0.3708707392,
-0.2669734657,
0.8982816935,
-0.0937263742,
-0.0224849954,
0.0188740641,
0.1969147474,
-0.1523073614,
0.1785936952,
0.1199373901,
0.2732299566,
0.3857972026,
-0.661871314,
0.4327340722,
0.1205944419,
-0.3999046385,
-0.6160084605,
0.3405250609,
-0.0950216651,
-0.1469609141,
0.2312123477,
-0.4734642804,
-0.7643478513,
0.7559592724,
0.3944793046,
0.791924417,
-0.2921966612,
0.2610809207,
0.079825975,
0.0487890728,
-0.1747299731,
0.767079711,
-0.1486506611,
-0.7372920513,
-0.61296314,
-0.3529146314,
-0.408813864,
-0.5275580883,
-0.7951028347,
0.4022880495,
-0.9378574491,
-0.0621895418,
0.028781252,
0.233051002,
-0.6482129693,
0.6616345048,
-0.3729003966,
0.6121177673,
-0.9551141858,
0.7746310234,
1.1445633173,
-0.5988748074,
-1.3075937033,
0.0426196307,
0.0732385516,
-1.0236423016,
0.8048118353,
0.124208726,
-0.4115240872,
-0.5109729171,
-0.5876563787,
-0.3828405142,
0.7393968701,
0.3462427557,
-0.2713425159,
0.1677952558,
-0.2430883944,
0.6561603546,
-0.0757870153,
0.0807944834,
0.1315615028,
0.1531244516,
0.3100637197,
-0.6234214902,
0.382668674,
0.1222535297,
-0.0513163432,
0.2818790078,
-0.7509223223,
0.9208091497,
-0.1234116927,
-0.3730968535,
-0.074894622,
0.6571478844,
-0.2427870184,
0.4604196846,
0.2448051423,
0.6148866415,
0.6480100751,
-0.1633748412,
1.1909506321,
-0.1816659719,
0.5199683905,
1.1472927332,
-0.267406553,
0.866042614,
0.5237252116,
-0.3068608046,
0.7045756578,
0.4757834971,
0.6622688174,
0.89325279,
-0.1427959502,
-0.2738809288,
-0.0760831088,
-0.0514706708,
0.0775218084,
0.6034793854,
0.1831849217,
-0.0724464059,
-0.2704070508,
0.0433757529,
0.3196608722,
0.4301460683,
-0.4440999627,
0.8567199707,
0.3219662905,
-0.8648895025,
0.6048006415,
0.0630872399,
0.2097569853,
-0.2369841188,
-0.6240765452,
-0.1564395279,
0.1463909,
-0.316032052,
-0.6909996271,
0.5357263088,
-0.4512929022,
-0.2949025333,
-0.1320065558,
0.5385512114,
-0.3898136616,
-0.0177342221,
0.4934895337,
0.3142331243,
0.0705572665,
0.3660258949,
-0.6341163516,
-0.0541889369,
-0.3315560222,
-0.2007716745,
0.1331956685,
0.7115495205,
-0.1913205385,
0.2869126499,
0.1636335254,
0.0125678703,
0.0336572938,
-0.0560601428,
0.6921247244,
-0.566870153,
-0.3712483943,
-0.7898167372,
0.4497058094,
0.0636398867,
-0.0911711678,
0.7165736556,
0.167619437,
0.8950244784,
0.0190486722,
0.2984854579,
-0.0017190805,
0.4023248553,
-0.7487441897,
0.1639986932,
-0.322645992,
-0.0159139317,
-0.2036283463,
-0.5700907111,
-0.2204275131,
0.9649639726,
-0.5818056464,
0.3781219721,
1.0327675343,
0.5105280876,
0.1234087646,
0.2346877307,
0.485123992,
0.1715838015,
-0.0163273327,
0.5426717997,
0.829094708,
-0.5752843618,
-0.2282793671,
-0.4734730422,
-0.4254714847,
-0.2150496989,
-0.6730741858,
-0.8158744574,
-0.5500543714,
-0.5233069062,
-0.5828375816,
0.1999290437,
1.1430435181,
0.8194381595,
-1.0457978249,
-0.2412176877,
-0.1433706582,
0.3153879046,
-0.4957772791,
-0.1573864371,
0.5853967071,
-0.583213985,
-0.9009841681,
0.1995324641,
0.1485699117,
0.1912424266,
0.2852444649,
-0.2014257461,
-0.3295038939,
0.2121088058,
0.5487009287,
0.1091240123,
-0.6513545513,
-0.6672004461,
-0.3288007379,
-0.3161179423,
0.1720222235,
0.9222531319,
-0.4477992356,
0.4951114655,
0.1597917229,
0.3031964302,
0.2502347529,
-0.2970210314,
0.6719793677,
-1.0261394978,
0.2281868309,
0.1751797795,
0.4184404016,
0.1984385848,
-0.6321767569,
0.5394214392,
0.4341448843,
-0.484201014,
-0.4861425161,
0.3002006412,
-0.7740644217,
-0.3706223369,
0.9659706354,
-0.4937831461,
-0.5916938782,
-0.1122710779,
-0.718811512,
0.5633943081,
-0.3980062604,
0.6076438427,
0.8258897662,
-0.1682578027,
0.2041025609,
-0.3690679669,
0.7665510774,
0.4945622981,
-0.3131114244,
-0.1101497263,
0.5838869214,
0.3749701679,
-0.0486368164,
0.7876401544,
0.1031167731,
0.4666126668,
0.0343722478,
0.1743599921,
0.339101404,
-0.5523945093,
-0.6379516721,
0.2747751474,
0.4487580955,
-0.2867225707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03297v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03297v1 | AutoWS: Automated Weak Supervision Framework for Text Classification | 2023-02-07T07:12:05 | 2023-02-07T07:12:05 | Abhinav Bohra, Huy Nguyen, Devashish Khatwani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Creating large, good quality labeled data has become one of the major
bottlenecks for developing machine learning applications. Multiple techniques
have been developed to either decrease the dependence of labeled data
(zero/few-shot learning, weak supervision) or to improve the efficiency of
labeling process (active learning). Among those, Weak Supervision has been
shown to reduce labeling costs by employing hand crafted labeling functions
designed by domain experts. We propose AutoWS -- a novel framework for
increasing the efficiency of weak supervision process while decreasing the
dependency on domain experts. Our method requires a small set of labeled
examples per label class and automatically creates a set of labeling functions
to assign noisy labels to numerous unlabeled data. Noisy labels can then be
aggregated into probabilistic labels used by a downstream discriminative
classifier. Our framework is fully automatic and requires no hyper-parameter
specification by users. We compare our approach with different state-of-the-art
work on weak supervision and noisy training. Experimental results show that our
method outperforms competitive baselines. | [
-0.138604641,
-0.7202284336,
0.2108005136,
0.0984701365,
-0.1783042401,
-0.1614148319,
-0.0189643856,
-0.6257379055,
-0.0575011373,
0.4498056471,
-0.1699404716,
-0.585483551,
-0.7965427041,
0.212697506,
-0.5584709048,
1.1478356123,
-0.2188001275,
-0.4587768316,
-0.0722417384,
-0.0750091225,
0.0757439286,
-0.4444291592,
-0.4317858815,
-0.1893738955,
0.4986882806,
0.4166905582,
0.9178692102,
0.9885715842,
0.5286957026,
0.4822003245,
0.1302265525,
0.2908983827,
-0.3320203424,
0.3391651511,
-0.0906203985,
-0.2879971862,
-0.6648874879,
0.1221435368,
0.179363057,
0.8388898373,
0.026494924,
0.221978575,
0.2706255019,
0.3095028996,
-0.8900891542,
0.3423298597,
-0.5220945477,
0.2256114483,
-0.178358525,
-0.1516414285,
-0.5122799873,
-0.1298864931,
0.2694711983,
-0.5861298442,
0.3974803388,
0.0819846317,
0.9882870913,
0.6579871178,
-0.4952952266,
-0.1924340427,
-0.7078096271,
0.9025363326,
-0.6040824652,
0.200705424,
0.6372216344,
0.0091651324,
-0.0233614091,
-0.7628401518,
-0.0861269161,
0.1626033932,
-0.1871072948,
0.3341849148,
-0.356177628,
0.2800221741,
0.1115566343,
0.2966052592,
-0.3408818841,
0.3517608643,
-0.195639506,
-0.2919904888,
0.8246587515,
0.072185412,
-0.0827258304,
0.17035909,
-0.4375556409,
0.0983061418,
0.03875513,
-0.3115182817,
0.3434078991,
0.4494325221,
0.1671069711,
0.3678589761,
-0.322042346,
0.9208832383,
0.1790140122,
-0.4147754014,
0.5285042524,
0.0130177615,
-0.5655024648,
-0.0208644252,
0.8708913326,
0.1021034941,
0.0797943473,
-0.3724446595,
-0.5318007469,
-0.0176220722,
0.2318866849,
-0.7285920978,
-0.600625813,
-0.1249778941,
-0.7141087651,
-0.6801996231,
-0.0552782901,
-0.4341642857,
-0.1126787961,
-0.5455070138,
0.6212689281,
0.021381503,
0.0335070454,
-0.0285667423,
-0.1047810167,
-0.203688547,
0.5688750148,
-0.8199677467,
0.3081232309,
-0.0223205108,
0.5268481374,
-0.4527460337,
-0.2519036233,
-0.5289010406,
0.4487966001,
-0.2744906843,
0.8261147738,
-0.1606647074,
-0.1776772738,
-0.1753874719,
0.0109923044,
0.1541921645,
-0.4710594118,
0.3860431015,
-0.2897751927,
0.2247821242,
0.343755573,
-0.5113565326,
-0.0499243997,
-0.1065700874,
-0.4221057892,
1.1860076189,
0.2151885778,
-0.6399888396,
0.6001241803,
-0.1630838364,
-0.8384702802,
0.2308451384,
0.119312346,
-0.9447786212,
-0.1513385028,
0.0904282331,
0.7608475685,
-0.0297925361,
0.4431580007,
-0.376730293,
-0.2710444033,
0.0201207176,
-0.5984780788,
0.8009989262,
0.3751076162,
-0.6148328185,
0.0353649408,
-0.9663248658,
0.13018246,
-0.2000816464,
-0.3513278663,
-0.6103954911,
0.0967979431,
-0.032904584,
0.0195753612,
0.0980295837,
-0.1968940198,
0.2022681683,
-0.4469386935,
0.0395323113,
0.6337197423,
0.0418414474,
0.5189577341,
-0.1237760261,
0.1031534299,
-0.0971136168,
0.4849620163,
0.113821134,
-0.4885810018,
-0.9280427098,
-0.5835979581,
0.269163847,
0.564360261,
-0.6901032925,
0.8599557877,
0.4892931581,
-0.5652558804,
-0.4055558145,
0.7357369065,
0.4722166955,
0.6195980906,
0.7089294195,
-0.3266730011,
-0.4799563885,
-0.9662721157,
-0.0864542872,
-0.4108605981,
-0.0439713933,
-0.0848897919,
0.3012482226,
-0.4943801463,
0.9729955792,
-0.6205372214,
-0.7414705157,
0.0056822738,
0.7336278558,
-0.1279135197,
0.4593709111,
0.5136247873,
-0.6812984347,
-0.6004626751,
-0.4995827377,
-0.8435278535,
-0.5339105725,
-0.075071089,
-0.2263155729,
0.168189019,
0.6299001575,
-0.2245069742,
0.6056423783,
0.2349772155,
-0.2081835419,
0.3473031223,
-0.2373096198,
-0.2592894733,
-0.5740818977,
-0.1685730368,
0.2794773281,
-0.1463839412,
-0.4042984247,
-0.3798222542,
0.02099788,
-0.1409799904,
-0.1624273956,
0.1195083112,
-0.6056518555,
0.176343441,
-0.4422697425,
-0.0813437402,
0.1278661788,
0.5015778542,
0.1632387489,
0.3165580332,
0.8060191274,
-0.8061438203,
0.4541162848,
0.2584561706,
0.1208103895,
0.4194574654,
-0.5187324286,
-0.2035045028,
0.056905929,
0.2445479035,
-0.9661945105,
-0.1648101509,
0.1941410601,
-0.2710115016,
0.5203074217,
-0.146432966,
-0.6021113396,
-0.4500333667,
0.01617302,
0.0681157559,
0.5734725595,
-0.4956097305,
0.3178482354,
0.6248893738,
-0.0223231073,
-0.3748001456,
-0.8693099618,
0.1437083036,
-0.0671449453,
-0.0488120317,
0.2751989961,
0.2014843076,
-0.1701788008,
0.1047408581,
-0.2648253441,
-0.5020481348,
0.2312775701,
0.1327209324,
0.2288993895,
-0.091308251,
0.3815018833,
0.2651381195,
-0.3912007213,
-0.0280131493,
-0.5157673955,
-0.5554773211,
-0.0135059142,
-0.1380870342,
-0.6842055917,
0.0690601766,
0.4226625264,
-0.0342412852,
0.3767023087,
0.6803972721,
-0.18190597,
-0.7557833791,
-0.309895575,
-0.0396816283,
-0.5519297123,
0.2081858963,
-0.0626764819,
-0.4861242473,
-0.1265478581,
-0.2365521193,
0.2325420827,
0.4978010654,
0.4602598846,
-0.3275526166,
1.2255866528,
0.8824777603,
-0.2011051923,
0.2536954284,
-0.1352903843,
0.0686912388,
0.0628013089,
-0.0772167891,
-0.5100707412,
-0.2074310631,
-0.2458192408,
-0.2692772448,
-0.0119883241,
0.1176689938,
-0.1413563192,
0.5876409411,
-1.1624404192,
0.2184197307,
0.5289233923,
-0.1003002301,
0.377869606,
-0.0552569479,
0.1417503655,
-0.0202934314,
-0.8901023865,
-0.4729985893,
0.8733972311,
0.4066245854,
1.1398922205,
-0.1826314777,
0.8264840245,
0.7313235402,
0.6505180001,
-0.9408890605,
0.5316109657,
-0.258482486,
-0.476590097,
-0.4919737875,
-0.6069053411,
-0.9145345688,
0.2338556051,
-0.3379503489,
-0.3089133799,
0.3922121227,
0.4654943049,
-0.1215311587,
0.3467788398,
-1.0949462652,
0.6061839461,
-0.3496308625,
-0.4185592234,
0.4130648077,
-0.6376526356,
0.1225563735,
-0.2493237257,
0.3037573695,
-0.0339280404,
-0.263797015,
1.1004228592,
-0.7341983914,
1.1773906946,
-0.3724439144,
-0.337691009,
0.6435220242,
-0.1323105395,
0.5418368578,
-0.17981866,
0.0376026668,
-0.1840380281,
-0.3841638267,
-0.3859305084,
-0.3179500997,
0.2861714363,
-0.7422176003,
-0.0281562302,
-0.3860323429,
-0.3405286074,
-0.2871745825,
0.2426672727,
0.3863699734,
0.4789861143,
0.0893793553,
0.0901263654,
0.7884429097,
-0.0158036947,
0.3889199495,
0.7080954313,
0.2526107132,
-0.4181755781,
1.115937829,
0.3171987832,
-0.0201112591,
0.2388351709,
0.0276519693,
-0.0744702369,
-0.6591060162,
-0.3000321388,
-0.1763679981,
-0.6950314641,
-0.8182480931,
-0.6505631804,
-0.1101802438,
-0.4000079334,
-0.4307256043,
-0.4938649237,
-0.3661157191,
-0.4221124053,
-0.0937796384,
0.2920345664,
0.6727517843,
-0.0355087481,
0.4282079041,
-0.5825573802,
0.579695642,
0.517252326,
0.5666750073,
-0.0743460953,
-0.446485728,
-0.438423872,
-0.4272687137,
-0.3244874179,
-0.7414210439,
0.4724827707,
0.3768632114,
0.6941310167,
0.6028758287,
0.711932838,
0.5063015223,
-0.164864704,
0.326162219,
0.2629834414,
-0.8988388181,
0.5431399941,
-0.2462110519,
0.1842580438,
0.8030947447,
0.4003694952,
0.2781458199,
-1.1247360706,
-0.7563734651,
-1.2660278082,
0.6621403098,
0.3194991946,
-0.2326096296,
-0.0140107553,
0.1499694139,
0.3218417764,
0.1201574206,
-0.5908281803,
-0.429656744,
-0.2062421739,
-0.4726687968,
0.1817309111,
0.0029354901,
-0.0216875989,
-0.4770219624,
0.9199377894,
-0.2160438299,
0.2221488804,
0.2671142817,
-0.4054051936,
-0.4022285342,
-0.0474056825,
-0.170726046,
0.3143955469,
-0.0841222629,
0.4085528255,
0.3899208605,
-0.4100703895,
0.2578498125,
0.1553419828,
-0.432515949,
0.2335258275,
0.4686539173,
0.6272165775,
0.3167276978,
-0.2678199708,
0.4956930578,
0.0580193512,
-0.6905142665,
-0.089636825,
0.2795827091,
-0.4120694995,
-0.0421268605,
0.6947490573,
0.3727954924,
0.4682654738,
-0.1910783499,
0.49951002,
-0.0118643222,
-0.5846811533,
-0.0190889854,
0.7664607763,
0.5335411429,
-0.1194977239,
0.3166523874,
-0.450925082,
-0.4139334857,
0.5779679418,
0.4119382799,
0.7527951598,
-0.1585926265,
0.210737586,
0.1856480539,
0.279848814,
-0.3078395128,
-0.2304962873,
-0.3399735391,
-0.2938304543,
-0.4987047613,
-0.5643930435,
-0.6752485037,
-0.0396128334,
-0.7207527161,
0.326855123,
-0.2782076001,
-0.3166998029,
0.0915078297,
-0.0050839717,
-0.3281795681,
0.6604034901,
0.1916916072,
0.5003160238,
-1.0511350632,
0.7327241898,
0.667519033,
-0.2170315534,
-0.4200221002,
0.0388002954,
0.1253303736,
-0.1399026364,
0.7269183993,
0.1107029095,
-0.4314951599,
0.1881380677,
-0.8356799483,
-0.7198304534,
0.6849073172,
-0.0086689694,
-0.3612744808,
0.1285562068,
-0.2450159639,
0.701307714,
0.0048265955,
0.0483409204,
0.155580461,
0.5067030191,
-0.112041831,
-0.7934430838,
0.0212696251,
-0.3865476549,
-0.3449322581,
0.2215158045,
-0.6768533587,
0.3041999042,
-0.1785064191,
-0.1419411451,
-0.0964634046,
0.9320786595,
-0.3361358941,
0.603433609,
0.66658777,
0.3777611852,
0.7355232239,
-0.0628686026,
0.3749345243,
-0.102337271,
0.4811127484,
1.0172638893,
-0.2250273973,
0.467908144,
0.135525912,
-0.2640306652,
0.2730700076,
0.4350111187,
-0.5790228844,
0.4528873265,
0.1347845644,
-0.0787946731,
-0.3508670628,
0.2677367628,
-0.0600637048,
0.3476136923,
0.2669676542,
-0.4146000743,
-0.3361456096,
0.3017721176,
-0.0330392644,
0.0304424241,
-0.1081453338,
0.9201086164,
0.0969406441,
-0.3866991997,
0.6519830823,
0.0921762288,
0.9128518105,
-0.546536386,
0.1927026063,
0.1827739477,
0.4901621044,
-0.4961960316,
-0.6816134453,
0.4765467346,
0.1233389527,
-0.0873730406,
-0.7551335096,
1.1249014139,
-0.4887920916,
-0.2203585207,
0.4332176447,
0.4409702122,
0.2619080245,
0.2378216088,
-0.8889785409,
-0.3260905147,
-0.2214055657,
-0.4220622778,
0.3821161687,
0.8189874887,
0.1438810378,
0.5306452513,
0.362315923,
-0.1202128977,
-0.2551971376,
0.0056642001,
0.7526335716,
-0.4562890828,
-0.398553133,
-0.4683144093,
0.2068727016,
-0.2569641471,
-0.4869782031,
1.0434098244,
0.66122967,
0.6463894844,
0.0593931861,
0.9412282705,
-0.0725284591,
0.4424104393,
-0.0616287738,
0.8188720942,
-0.533005774,
0.1179608479,
-0.5246226788,
-0.8263525367,
-0.5972298384,
0.6372629404,
-0.1288637817,
-0.0491014086,
0.517852962,
0.402258426,
-0.1528459638,
-0.1727625877,
0.3197852671,
0.132321164,
-0.0679860339,
0.2080910206,
0.4847992659,
-0.4281920791,
1.0560551882,
-0.5080215931,
-0.4231678545,
-0.2149226815,
-0.5751767159,
-1.034052372,
-0.3958075643,
-0.9100721478,
-0.2269082367,
0.177555874,
0.5196379423,
0.8746220469,
-0.8209283948,
-0.025925966,
-0.2403852642,
-0.0579456165,
-0.3347191513,
-0.3294348717,
0.4690241814,
-0.8625570536,
-0.6372128129,
0.3385309577,
0.2882956266,
0.3558372557,
-0.0038359012,
0.0710177049,
-0.0388420448,
-0.1423790157,
0.6198118925,
0.3614902794,
-0.0086224442,
0.1305826604,
-0.3610000014,
-0.560957253,
-0.2099392265,
0.5157945156,
-0.8108330369,
0.3415206373,
0.5004438758,
0.4028627872,
0.4730009735,
0.1294044107,
0.4254933596,
-0.754095912,
0.1118929237,
0.3913853765,
-0.0421516113,
0.1212787032,
-0.4243178368,
0.5020987391,
0.568564117,
-0.6565885544,
-0.8677443862,
-0.0058229766,
-0.7281956673,
-0.6212412119,
1.0050193071,
-0.1424170136,
-0.1399746388,
-0.862210393,
-0.142871663,
0.5434691906,
-0.3676894903,
0.9077718258,
0.154462263,
-0.2809954882,
0.2654246092,
-0.495166719,
0.6083791852,
0.4021837115,
-0.8050457239,
0.2050987631,
0.4746489525,
-0.0597510524,
-0.0341154188,
0.609151423,
0.0022669993,
-0.0223007966,
0.2052698284,
0.1603125185,
-0.2312171459,
-0.3878165781,
0.0964743048,
0.305931747,
-0.139126271,
-0.0403089635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03269v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03269v3 | PLACES: Prompting Language Models for Social Conversation Synthesis | 2023-02-07T05:48:16 | 2023-02-17T04:11:53 | Maximillian Chen, Alexandros Papangelis, Chenyang Tao, Seokhwan Kim, Andy Rosenbaum, Yang Liu, Zhou Yu, Dilek Hakkani-Tur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Collecting high quality conversational data can be very expensive for most
applications and infeasible for others due to privacy, ethical, or similar
concerns. A promising direction to tackle this problem is to generate synthetic
dialogues by prompting large language models. In this work, we use a small set
of expert-written conversations as in-context examples to synthesize a social
conversation dataset using prompting. We perform several thorough evaluations
of our synthetic conversations compared to human-collected conversations. This
includes various dimensions of conversation quality with human evaluation
directly on the synthesized conversations, and interactive human evaluation of
chatbots fine-tuned on the synthetically generated dataset. We additionally
demonstrate that this prompting approach is generalizable to multi-party
conversations, providing potential to create new synthetic data for multi-party
tasks. Our synthetic multi-party conversations were rated more favorably across
all measured dimensions compared to conversation excerpts sampled from a
human-collected multi-party dataset. | [
-0.4519239664,
-1.1108574867,
0.8806062341,
0.4045027196,
-0.0506189466,
0.4155032039,
-0.2982500494,
-0.3059480488,
0.3469683528,
0.3076091409,
-0.8019131422,
-0.5339925885,
0.054559622,
0.0851817578,
-0.4080907106,
0.8208804131,
0.401412636,
0.1155946553,
-0.2347829789,
0.0393517613,
-0.6275689602,
-0.5855804086,
-0.877165556,
-0.3461657166,
0.6709174514,
0.7934957147,
0.7985137105,
0.2504756749,
-0.1902517378,
0.405742079,
0.0540647507,
0.5980170369,
-0.6364893913,
0.4518994689,
-0.1976606846,
-0.0974676087,
-0.3928978741,
0.1580772549,
0.4973998964,
0.7339107394,
-0.1361946911,
0.176048398,
0.2062173188,
0.5821540952,
-0.3400881886,
0.2619040906,
-0.8950862885,
-0.1918196678,
0.1873473376,
-0.299436897,
-0.5699806809,
-0.5894760489,
0.173937574,
-0.434612751,
0.5429134369,
0.1085957438,
0.4530785382,
-0.16992037,
-0.1534395367,
-0.3434092402,
-0.9785579443,
0.5723775625,
-0.5258005261,
0.2892895639,
0.5392284393,
0.5296645164,
-0.4884575605,
-0.6021422148,
-0.8950758576,
-0.4208131135,
0.018408712,
0.0865046978,
0.0672719479,
-0.031191729,
0.0518657193,
0.0007035544,
-0.3201541603,
-0.3604862392,
-0.5810256004,
-0.0725156516,
0.939068079,
0.4488482773,
0.2603375316,
-0.3132804334,
0.0779330209,
-0.3744341433,
-0.7803992629,
0.1492753029,
0.7395025492,
0.5664995909,
-0.079316169,
0.5053595304,
-0.56146276,
0.5843249559,
0.2024701983,
0.1585550904,
-0.0263838209,
-0.9148336053,
0.2054306567,
0.0451731272,
0.9277922511,
0.7666467428,
0.4960358739,
0.1067981347,
0.1450107992,
0.0968382806,
0.1734993756,
-0.5042055249,
-0.6241014004,
0.4637344182,
-0.355127275,
-0.4047658145,
0.0425086878,
-0.8333982229,
-0.4408599436,
-0.5585415363,
0.0339925736,
-0.2896229327,
-0.2179806828,
-0.0208779089,
-0.2288050503,
0.1130544394,
0.3160283566,
-1.0554132462,
0.2221698612,
0.5841785669,
0.6835760474,
0.056245286,
-0.3780490756,
-0.5913394094,
0.1102872416,
-0.5322952271,
0.9369583726,
-0.6167154908,
-0.7487285137,
-0.0037573653,
0.0419045538,
0.2485701293,
-0.4448750913,
0.116077885,
-0.0277000703,
0.5894019008,
-0.4297344983,
-0.1734761149,
0.1911516339,
0.2955059111,
-0.4834585786,
0.9913465977,
0.1133475155,
-0.2604624033,
0.4150443077,
-0.5834464431,
-0.5543033481,
0.14117302,
-0.1891305,
-0.0699185729,
0.0691423342,
0.5154947042,
0.541970551,
-0.3180997372,
0.5220125318,
-0.3300840855,
-0.1776430905,
0.6928696036,
-0.4462916255,
0.5662897825,
0.2136580199,
-0.0367982164,
0.3780230284,
-0.7481533885,
0.132435292,
0.0057538147,
-0.2616431415,
-0.1654513329,
0.1667071581,
-0.172533378,
0.1530752629,
0.0567303114,
-0.6567509174,
0.0248491596,
-0.6255277395,
0.7155297995,
0.6858218908,
0.4610325694,
0.61086905,
-0.4076214135,
0.4126202166,
-0.2122427076,
0.2865846753,
-0.3014367223,
-0.8094790578,
-0.622885704,
0.1986358166,
0.0688172206,
0.4135065675,
-0.9277095795,
0.3986839056,
-0.1945480853,
-0.5686385632,
-0.5014041066,
-0.0506448746,
0.2826346159,
0.3094951212,
0.1566739827,
-0.0092379004,
-0.4203023612,
-0.6895518303,
-0.1387810707,
-0.504091084,
-0.2556968629,
0.5386278629,
0.0529293679,
0.1084680632,
1.3044575453,
-0.4324340522,
0.1585409343,
-0.3632231355,
0.083996892,
0.0356752425,
0.5431325436,
0.2428155392,
-0.4786882401,
-0.7603489161,
-0.1425386518,
-0.3603354692,
-0.0136167463,
-0.2440290153,
-0.360204041,
0.0070732282,
0.524962306,
-0.7039085031,
0.2465331703,
0.6348227262,
0.0323774964,
0.4264298975,
-0.2626535296,
0.4256014824,
-1.4021718502,
-0.2121417522,
-0.2375784367,
-0.044195421,
-0.8468275666,
-0.4816273749,
-0.2291361988,
-0.5470108986,
-0.6320443153,
0.843243897,
-0.4794653058,
0.1286839247,
0.1117272303,
0.1733061969,
0.0152570186,
0.535220325,
0.1393516958,
0.7161492109,
0.4220763147,
-0.6724805832,
0.3863301873,
0.5614945292,
-0.2989701629,
0.6094861031,
-1.0552043915,
0.551189661,
-0.0458803289,
0.533318758,
-1.4448586702,
-0.8339431882,
0.2563695014,
-0.6589447856,
-0.2858689129,
-0.2206084877,
-0.5634533763,
-0.2732881904,
-0.2359153777,
0.1246088892,
0.5144921541,
-0.4663622975,
0.3618604541,
0.4870524704,
-0.6157332063,
0.0349343941,
-0.357080102,
0.4035321176,
-0.1251437068,
-0.7334436178,
0.2193068564,
-0.2832030058,
-0.2848641872,
-0.2785936892,
0.4927735925,
0.0478710197,
-0.3137444854,
0.4132083952,
0.1647517085,
0.1779616326,
0.0479796492,
0.3363913596,
-0.0972740054,
0.1219382361,
0.0198297165,
0.7089778781,
0.1951528639,
-0.4919923842,
-0.5646860003,
0.6423594952,
0.3580603898,
0.0488222428,
0.5378299952,
0.3804547787,
-0.2751536667,
-0.2346434593,
-0.6879299879,
-0.7728321552,
-0.620044291,
-0.0631858632,
-0.3125002384,
-0.9380884171,
0.5612838268,
-0.002213168,
0.2692667246,
-0.1590470374,
0.6221197844,
-0.0941953212,
1.5914081335,
-0.0372131467,
0.2402389795,
0.5980111957,
0.0914061889,
0.5735887289,
-0.3172892928,
-0.1577066332,
-0.5877252221,
-0.2668272853,
-0.6003274322,
-0.4058797956,
0.4573301971,
-0.3813474178,
0.0903290883,
0.360121429,
-0.6756617427,
0.8053539991,
0.7276445627,
0.2382671982,
-0.056940712,
0.2950780392,
0.1521826982,
-0.0102105485,
-0.7743858695,
-0.522629559,
0.8745653629,
-0.0267254617,
0.6137309074,
-0.1703532934,
0.7767568231,
0.1394841373,
0.0502656698,
-0.6834317446,
0.8587778211,
0.1678224057,
-0.6027776599,
-0.5038665533,
-0.4919108748,
-1.2977826595,
-0.1523164958,
-0.3722309768,
-0.7237004042,
0.1751138121,
0.271530807,
-0.6718202829,
-0.2906344831,
-0.8902613521,
0.6241831779,
0.2516734004,
-0.2705548704,
-0.3044828176,
-0.6570369601,
0.1682247818,
0.1853878349,
0.1655741036,
-0.4055373967,
0.6473097205,
0.3939691186,
-0.4214125872,
0.9623833299,
-0.2341380417,
0.0515412092,
0.7830065489,
0.3652750552,
0.5831752419,
0.2959041595,
-0.2413640916,
-0.0110552134,
-0.0558371134,
-0.1971525103,
-0.7315900326,
0.7371957898,
-0.4789979458,
-0.6155298948,
0.1755716652,
-0.53780967,
-0.555188179,
-0.1365418881,
0.1982378513,
0.6166718602,
-0.3106808364,
0.2848067284,
0.2155002952,
-0.5123354197,
0.2753756642,
0.2861351073,
0.1679140627,
-0.5727803707,
1.0679439306,
-0.0615766495,
0.4396072328,
-0.0562425368,
0.3751110137,
-0.6274900436,
-0.1527803689,
-0.596924901,
0.1168959811,
-0.5779969096,
-0.0036343092,
-0.7252092957,
-0.092829518,
-0.7650678158,
-0.4722476006,
-0.2951138914,
-0.5063272715,
-0.0461929254,
-0.2647064924,
0.4640956819,
0.7475453615,
0.0134146949,
0.3261957765,
-1.130230546,
0.1998064816,
0.6114010215,
-0.0242292713,
0.1207021698,
-0.0353273973,
0.0941598937,
0.3621245921,
-0.2355745584,
-0.8856954575,
0.5920656323,
0.2585666776,
0.5398791432,
0.0573421717,
0.2974565625,
0.8350049257,
-0.719837606,
1.1798683405,
0.2450138181,
-0.9086759686,
0.9134636521,
-0.5766680837,
0.2688425779,
0.7255163193,
0.1385653764,
-0.5307457447,
-0.7498338819,
-0.8103309274,
-0.9750357866,
0.6428027749,
0.3172152042,
0.7191364765,
-0.4311799109,
0.3119504452,
-0.0039180722,
0.2598126531,
-0.2965264618,
0.012892317,
-0.0122051593,
-0.204150185,
0.1573991179,
-0.2205969393,
-0.2322719544,
-0.2743036449,
0.3384322226,
-0.2353901118,
0.2962991595,
0.1246484816,
0.4055881798,
-0.0902215391,
0.275369823,
0.4376634657,
0.8213362098,
0.1979831606,
-0.1076896414,
0.3330695927,
0.0921035931,
0.3007552624,
-0.3183362186,
-0.0247937106,
0.051897645,
0.0126964571,
0.6572767496,
0.146623835,
-0.3528591096,
0.2175222933,
-0.3196261525,
-0.2248286307,
-0.2532780468,
0.4966584742,
0.3627874851,
0.092581965,
0.1503791213,
-0.1906839162,
0.2648662031,
-0.7611878514,
0.0308927372,
0.3005084693,
-0.3955403268,
-0.3917210698,
0.6036891937,
0.5664817095,
-0.7798799276,
0.882463634,
-0.2690073848,
-0.1562920958,
0.2903873622,
0.2502943277,
0.694439292,
-0.4265110791,
0.5933892131,
0.635199666,
-0.1875964105,
-0.1374463886,
0.5058580637,
-0.2951391637,
-0.871360302,
-0.4800362885,
-0.3967958689,
-0.8663049936,
0.0799295604,
-0.4326874316,
0.1906789243,
-0.4421507716,
-0.3217921555,
0.1397895664,
-0.3858555853,
-0.3992879987,
-0.0514907166,
-0.1630702466,
0.3178367615,
-0.8599545956,
0.5994791985,
0.4159072936,
-0.1166750938,
-1.0119395256,
-0.2953172624,
-0.0889703184,
-0.4691314697,
0.1790793538,
0.1186463162,
-0.1253183335,
0.0975360051,
-1.0454181433,
-0.5010565519,
0.6316505671,
0.314044416,
-0.445877403,
0.0206102282,
0.3298085928,
0.7374139428,
-0.2310480922,
0.0164714158,
0.3674895465,
0.4425936639,
0.318844825,
-0.7583982348,
0.1896867305,
-0.3701330423,
0.0819476098,
-0.1716651917,
-0.5583232641,
0.7702944875,
-0.1079723686,
-0.3586353958,
0.1092161909,
0.6434170604,
0.7632672787,
0.399273932,
0.7225856781,
-0.3391459882,
0.685973227,
-0.1300679147,
0.9526500106,
-0.5276081562,
-0.1893474907,
1.1315784454,
-0.6659693122,
0.6488415003,
0.3934874535,
-0.037044663,
0.4894348681,
0.8250669241,
0.2691211104,
0.1393139213,
0.2209284008,
-0.4767689109,
-0.3780393004,
-0.2445164919,
-0.1666008383,
0.3260759413,
0.6523830295,
-0.040715009,
0.0957672969,
-0.113269411,
-0.2237650007,
0.0321453772,
0.2975645363,
1.1310610771,
0.0664357841,
-1.2521827221,
0.4121779501,
-0.26078403,
0.1721666604,
-0.3992374539,
-0.3588410914,
-0.3379589021,
-0.139526844,
-0.0634770691,
-0.9529832602,
0.2449306399,
-0.1942925751,
-0.0082594575,
-0.568490684,
0.6793828011,
-0.7791699767,
-0.3042343557,
-0.0780489743,
0.5891478658,
0.5150404572,
-0.2800798416,
-0.6205549836,
-0.1702409834,
0.0107646827,
-0.1755507886,
0.1876350194,
0.5700340867,
-0.2923180759,
0.5450235605,
1.2926684618,
0.1353625506,
-0.2193581164,
0.569309175,
0.7968904376,
-0.5583388805,
-0.7503401041,
-0.7107484937,
0.6760219336,
-0.3209830821,
-0.2272601575,
0.7897973657,
0.1765919626,
0.6523219943,
-0.0752705857,
0.7996244431,
-0.024648957,
0.5492395759,
-0.476888597,
0.7479970455,
-0.1066767946,
-0.0061434945,
-0.3287835419,
-1.0434134007,
0.1087264195,
0.6963154078,
-0.0798004344,
-0.0808907151,
0.3444466591,
1.2858989239,
0.0010124918,
0.2363900989,
0.3220874667,
-0.1097266674,
0.6763113141,
0.2373708934,
1.3492945433,
-0.0470558293,
0.5101722479,
-0.0699779317,
0.0106724463,
-0.1252258718,
-0.8662313223,
-0.852997601,
-0.9120836854,
-0.3159178793,
-0.5936549902,
0.0517965928,
1.1036138535,
0.9765865207,
-0.9189744592,
-0.2485785484,
-0.1766897887,
0.0205744002,
0.0795238018,
-0.3076514304,
0.0151836788,
-0.2111060321,
-1.0844650269,
0.9387142062,
0.0914672986,
0.2983567119,
-0.4596648216,
-0.0140444953,
0.1108000278,
0.3020558357,
0.6758728623,
0.1126560345,
-0.5890567303,
-0.3956218362,
0.0541515909,
-0.0853009075,
-0.0337371975,
0.9285646081,
-0.611354053,
0.5771574974,
0.9528232813,
0.3008898795,
0.3891980648,
0.3988108039,
1.1093711853,
-1.2228183746,
0.0837868974,
0.0411841795,
-0.0022886307,
0.5837699771,
-0.6012783051,
0.4249127805,
-0.0645323098,
-0.6143395305,
-0.7514836788,
0.1470471025,
-0.7488382459,
-0.1028511524,
1.3563090563,
0.0761303455,
-0.2081119418,
-0.4011900425,
-0.6637360454,
0.1067019179,
-0.9176927805,
0.8767914772,
0.7688568234,
-0.2204661816,
0.0390395299,
-0.3908398747,
0.6490294933,
0.2088239193,
-0.8884109855,
0.2482903302,
0.8320561051,
0.0916486681,
0.1770343184,
1.0000071526,
-0.0206028987,
0.2839877605,
0.1299971044,
-0.1645876467,
0.1043363139,
-0.5723128915,
0.0937131643,
0.1366843581,
-0.2406217754,
0.0708816648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03241v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03241v4 | Continual Pre-training of Language Models | 2023-02-07T03:57:55 | 2023-04-12T10:36:44 | Zixuan Ke, Yijia Shao, Haowei Lin, Tatsuya Konishi, Gyuhak Kim, Bing Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | Language models (LMs) have been instrumental for the rapid advance of natural
language processing. This paper studies continual pre-training of LMs, in
particular, continual domain-adaptive pre-training (or continual DAP-training).
Existing research has shown that further pre-training an LM using a domain
corpus to adapt the LM to the domain can improve the end-task performance in
the domain. This paper proposes a novel method to continually DAP-train an LM
with a sequence of unlabeled domain corpora to adapt the LM to these domains to
improve their end-task performances. The key novelty of our method is a
soft-masking mechanism that directly controls the update to the LM. A novel
proxy is also proposed to preserve the general knowledge in the original LM.
Additionally, it contrasts the representations of the previously learned domain
knowledge (including the general knowledge in the pre-trained LM) and the
knowledge from the current full network to achieve knowledge integration. The
method not only overcomes catastrophic forgetting, but also achieves knowledge
transfer to improve end-task performances. Empirical evaluation demonstrates
the effectiveness of the proposed method. | [
-0.3432282209,
-0.7887660265,
0.4702380002,
0.0530996062,
-0.327021271,
0.4535575509,
-0.4454852939,
-0.1222649217,
0.045551762,
0.6054926515,
-0.5679488182,
-0.3118583262,
-0.5200622678,
0.0606954098,
-0.1655082554,
0.866555512,
-0.0789070576,
0.0096565634,
-0.075348042,
-0.1111480892,
-0.7727828026,
-0.7516345978,
-0.7271137834,
-0.2930215597,
0.3318588436,
0.1562753767,
0.5536061525,
0.2392495871,
0.113472797,
0.2908602953,
0.202516675,
0.3802105486,
-0.6216831803,
0.1506566703,
-0.4363906682,
-0.2356991023,
-0.547599256,
-0.0141763557,
0.9202353954,
1.1222310066,
-0.1733811945,
-0.0298945718,
0.4720020592,
0.7081502676,
-0.7095262408,
-0.0919529423,
-1.0248459578,
-0.2155357897,
-0.1000629365,
-0.3941566348,
-0.6225725412,
0.0110737421,
0.0737661198,
-0.6526953578,
0.1460398138,
-0.1121533513,
0.8459664583,
0.3579190373,
-0.036840003,
-0.2579038739,
-0.8982489705,
0.6405159831,
-0.7292268872,
0.4387551248,
0.2385246307,
0.1426358223,
-0.4693677723,
-0.8074317575,
-0.7451930046,
-0.2831178606,
0.0556502491,
0.0279767569,
0.0378592908,
0.0404344425,
-0.1530760229,
0.0954105929,
-0.5024933815,
0.0601124018,
-0.1313194185,
-0.0027168565,
0.3857317269,
-0.118048951,
0.4286969602,
0.5233103037,
-0.3600761294,
0.0502330624,
-0.7519199252,
-0.2593995333,
-0.0912223458,
0.2359609902,
0.0949501321,
-0.0590546057,
-0.0512201265,
0.8403950334,
0.1537869871,
-0.0726738945,
0.4172334671,
-0.0236975495,
-0.3811760247,
-0.1029001698,
0.4934130013,
-0.1870747656,
0.640529573,
-0.5273265839,
-0.2779762447,
0.1801580787,
0.4748951197,
-0.4989435971,
-0.1669584811,
-0.0366420709,
-0.0708360523,
0.1022485942,
-0.2373435497,
-0.4309226573,
0.2169205397,
-0.6043864489,
0.7244305015,
-0.4249245226,
-0.3947491944,
0.392064184,
0.2369544506,
-0.2436317354,
0.226327613,
-0.955308795,
0.7726283669,
0.5358757377,
0.9827917218,
-0.289863795,
-0.428384155,
-0.774916172,
0.325409621,
-0.4896943867,
0.8380532265,
-0.5192424655,
-0.2043478936,
0.2051257789,
0.2374829054,
-0.5274174809,
-0.7242513895,
0.1555424333,
-0.9167186022,
0.1561505347,
0.1432631463,
-0.6220561266,
-0.034415409,
0.1911918521,
-0.4301240146,
0.934084475,
0.2678315341,
-0.3691749275,
0.3114751577,
-0.5914319158,
-0.2362970114,
0.2780124545,
0.1257199198,
-0.3147315681,
-0.0158277936,
0.0507244654,
0.4615386128,
0.0961305276,
0.4178412855,
-0.3806271553,
-0.4143748581,
0.1580216438,
-0.124062866,
0.6420081258,
0.0281669497,
-0.2218116075,
-0.1167618632,
-0.8099544644,
-0.0772745386,
0.1246017739,
-0.1585321873,
-0.5975329876,
-0.1294365227,
-0.3248888552,
0.3391410112,
0.1411732733,
-0.3039761484,
0.3061262369,
-0.4963076115,
0.2745901346,
0.8380297422,
0.1261687428,
0.6125438213,
-0.3488250673,
0.4698360264,
0.0644713342,
0.0894330069,
-0.3180932999,
-0.2913522422,
-1.03171134,
-0.19524692,
0.4537980258,
0.5103422999,
-0.8681489229,
0.42538324,
-0.4395697117,
-0.1382168531,
-0.3167614937,
0.5904934406,
0.2836890519,
0.4233831167,
0.6438102722,
-0.7492761612,
-0.5052716732,
-0.3633532822,
-0.0649767816,
0.0544401817,
-0.1441271901,
-0.0718479156,
0.5500834584,
-0.4205181599,
1.0785988569,
-0.3492752016,
-0.3654200733,
-0.1560000628,
0.2796394825,
0.3052639365,
0.5595211983,
0.4941861629,
-0.5700736642,
-0.6234048009,
-0.3429099917,
-0.556296885,
-0.2727460861,
-0.3686172664,
-0.3518275321,
0.3868841529,
0.5119089484,
-0.4758407176,
0.10500177,
0.4845880568,
-0.171956867,
0.6788594127,
-0.5623238683,
-0.1370262802,
-0.6126207709,
-0.0136707854,
-0.3290102482,
-0.4027785957,
-0.8681304455,
-0.2307136357,
0.0560023189,
0.0612217858,
-0.3773769438,
0.9704896808,
-0.8153602481,
0.2324962467,
-0.6292225122,
0.254586935,
-0.084634006,
0.811247468,
0.2887440026,
0.520824492,
0.7884191275,
-1.1268877983,
0.0696461871,
0.1246707514,
-0.0567823499,
0.4276252985,
-0.4090376198,
0.7159639597,
-0.2793667614,
0.1433549821,
-0.7750295401,
0.2570376098,
0.3858548403,
-0.2011390477,
0.7510520816,
-0.2559425533,
-0.2959220409,
-0.3040876389,
0.0583494939,
0.2230769545,
0.6664504409,
-0.579505384,
0.5374062061,
0.3517585993,
-0.344922632,
-0.3780654371,
-0.3669399023,
0.3347599208,
-0.138660118,
-0.5023452044,
0.7881671786,
-0.3183768094,
0.0175234247,
0.1138364077,
-0.0554959662,
-0.1657454222,
0.0480899177,
0.0005579253,
0.2637692988,
-0.1954942644,
0.3192058206,
-0.0874942541,
-0.2461283207,
-0.0379469842,
-0.7482224703,
0.7134966254,
0.0487766638,
-0.0784509033,
-0.2261166573,
0.2458025366,
0.1075887531,
-0.0512111671,
1.0227550268,
0.3404552937,
-0.3992166817,
-0.6274072528,
-0.7290118933,
-0.1346892565,
-0.4837239981,
0.162873134,
-0.4581421614,
-0.9179646373,
0.1769926548,
-0.4885350466,
-0.0063149822,
0.1994457096,
0.4575938284,
-0.0784401596,
0.6199942231,
1.0335379839,
-0.1526771337,
0.3794380724,
-0.0961691886,
0.0962529853,
-0.6743755937,
-0.0371149629,
-0.243310824,
0.0066643199,
-0.0480917543,
-0.4872135222,
0.0736948177,
0.5456240773,
-0.4506113231,
0.2874262333,
-0.2536473274,
0.2098112851,
0.2071447223,
0.1072554737,
0.1532295793,
0.0210488476,
-0.079975374,
0.199452877,
-0.8929376006,
-0.5413730145,
1.0882791281,
0.33580935,
0.5241159797,
0.0202642623,
0.6813437939,
0.5066945553,
0.5571503043,
-0.2261009514,
0.5434119105,
-0.191378206,
-0.1361433864,
-0.2394804955,
-0.3072202802,
-0.8575373292,
0.0445802957,
0.002264461,
-0.6264313459,
0.1085830033,
0.4501881599,
-0.2972732186,
0.1130622849,
-0.4914600551,
0.8077836037,
-0.3152622879,
-0.567130208,
-0.2214065641,
-0.473300159,
0.0978754014,
-0.5509845614,
0.3879242241,
-0.0244116914,
-0.0014549552,
0.8439985514,
-0.3688333333,
0.9402810931,
-0.3739683926,
0.0306165982,
0.331089139,
0.0604746342,
0.4362698793,
-0.0099557359,
0.1932342052,
0.1788994372,
-0.2270610034,
-0.5614632964,
-0.7246582508,
0.4299508929,
-0.5236886144,
-0.8429951668,
-0.428592056,
-0.4408306777,
-0.5343961716,
0.1745148301,
-0.1652183384,
0.336810112,
-0.259685427,
-0.0918042585,
0.7689039707,
-0.153253451,
0.4681710899,
0.6466528773,
-0.1695837229,
-0.1751404703,
0.6079587936,
0.1504622847,
0.5089527965,
0.3407468796,
0.0651434809,
-0.2515069544,
-0.5553631186,
-0.3787857294,
0.3954750001,
-0.6037338376,
-0.1147847399,
-0.7846443057,
-0.3631102145,
-0.5131537318,
-0.1353888661,
-0.2834498286,
-0.102291733,
-0.2595727146,
0.2596096396,
0.2527262866,
0.5079013109,
-0.2089811414,
0.4312126935,
-0.8200438619,
0.4169921875,
0.3671152592,
0.4084064066,
-0.0542145409,
-1.2095367908,
-0.3819493949,
0.0855260938,
-0.1018621325,
-0.8199335933,
0.559466064,
0.6848115325,
0.7333894968,
0.1662187129,
-0.0038003211,
0.6153873205,
-0.7991055846,
0.5765585303,
0.1673342288,
-0.9291847944,
0.3855977356,
-0.1263810545,
0.5558690429,
0.5579251051,
0.7705072165,
-0.5490872264,
-0.2984148264,
-0.411282748,
-0.6605366468,
0.4583259523,
-0.0324971117,
0.4183190167,
-0.1317818165,
0.4995113313,
0.0833763853,
0.1961676478,
-0.5731153488,
-0.0330214165,
-0.2718409896,
-0.0899873301,
-0.0685175657,
-0.4932751358,
0.0662068129,
-0.2123253345,
1.1147708893,
-0.227884531,
0.1682259142,
0.0208754707,
-0.5863554478,
0.1661840379,
0.2024089694,
0.4345807731,
1.0296344757,
-0.3087241054,
0.2083864659,
0.4213344753,
-0.6178561449,
0.2183743119,
-0.1537286788,
0.00891787,
0.2092403769,
0.2507739663,
0.6426616907,
0.4187282622,
-0.5708050132,
0.2932705581,
0.1062947661,
-0.1746433228,
-0.5528484583,
0.1101726666,
0.1222077683,
-0.0848103091,
0.3837881982,
0.0643273592,
-0.3138052225,
-0.6993895173,
0.562509954,
0.1399408132,
-0.3200671077,
-0.3116337955,
0.5481756926,
0.0690419227,
-0.3673398495,
0.4951121509,
-0.4017907381,
-0.6737369895,
0.1271627694,
0.8341546655,
0.8446252346,
-0.6393893361,
0.1445498616,
0.3537879884,
0.0604601651,
-0.2807330191,
0.0423858501,
-0.0947067216,
-0.9459871054,
-0.6471518278,
-0.8891999722,
-0.2001425624,
0.3556922972,
-0.3548014164,
0.2894390821,
-0.5000454783,
-0.0368706845,
-0.3767878413,
-0.1523073316,
-0.8231737614,
0.5276751518,
0.261248827,
0.8481453657,
-0.7213651538,
1.2961417437,
0.3740781844,
-0.2804980874,
-0.4327915609,
-0.0576720722,
-0.1566026956,
-0.7008289695,
0.8218000531,
-0.0051147556,
-0.3990016282,
0.0941077247,
-0.3386215866,
-0.9044308066,
0.7013974786,
0.2769368291,
-0.8677538633,
-0.0245527532,
0.2474963814,
0.5867034197,
-0.6334023476,
-0.0433119871,
0.6076173186,
0.1721307486,
-0.0670094863,
-0.8554214239,
-0.0363498889,
-0.4760827124,
0.0529178269,
-0.0105835367,
-0.3026330471,
0.5498080254,
0.0039821705,
-0.3923765421,
-0.1098173782,
0.8143439889,
0.2131781429,
0.147982955,
0.8377204537,
0.4483054578,
0.7543022037,
0.1689885706,
0.4780697525,
-0.5129901171,
0.2134486139,
1.4242757559,
-0.5631324053,
0.7980861068,
0.3494392335,
0.004806425,
0.708239615,
0.3835380673,
0.1469015032,
0.7664369941,
0.4190138578,
-0.5635149479,
-0.318554759,
0.0051031522,
-0.306573838,
0.2458676696,
0.3380991518,
0.0518904403,
0.0148898596,
0.3951921761,
0.2310797423,
0.3594839871,
-0.3987039328,
0.718390584,
0.339809984,
-0.7173407674,
0.982378006,
-0.1232726872,
0.800260067,
-0.8869125843,
-0.0092009054,
-0.2374516428,
0.2937943637,
0.105501838,
-0.1924536824,
0.4027163982,
0.0081446199,
-0.1467101127,
-0.4486984015,
0.7968847156,
-0.5852581263,
-0.2830241323,
0.6363314986,
0.3898757398,
0.0900103599,
-0.2572247386,
-0.6676863432,
-0.0361018926,
-0.4093076289,
-0.2934818864,
0.5662050247,
0.3771141171,
0.041458331,
0.6695464253,
0.7476737499,
0.1907916367,
0.139633745,
0.432815671,
1.0159400702,
-0.5132173896,
-0.6266562343,
-0.7537834048,
0.3428733647,
-0.0111043649,
-0.1096998304,
0.411863178,
0.2770675421,
1.0408486128,
-0.1268475801,
0.7550724149,
0.1732257307,
0.5947428942,
-0.7946472168,
0.7428367734,
-0.5029917955,
0.3099443614,
-0.1402950138,
-0.9628168941,
-0.2153247446,
0.356028527,
-0.2396340519,
0.1805367619,
0.8727985024,
0.7781605124,
-0.1155161932,
-0.3218359351,
0.4741135538,
0.3020358384,
0.0976687521,
0.6645786762,
0.5329162478,
-0.1778717935,
0.3339973986,
-0.1446706355,
-0.3693762422,
0.1142394468,
-0.9420560598,
-0.9601262212,
-0.7983394861,
-0.466337949,
-0.1805854887,
0.5871258974,
0.6447800994,
0.8539336324,
-0.8032389879,
-0.2030465305,
-0.0829264596,
-0.276730448,
-0.3689358532,
-0.141976431,
0.5240941048,
-0.9350793958,
-0.5889331102,
0.6454979777,
0.4019609392,
-0.1941549778,
-0.1897190809,
-0.253828764,
-0.4558756053,
0.0986842066,
0.5450739861,
0.3803467751,
-0.2571460903,
-0.4085660279,
-0.1496693194,
0.1998470724,
0.0787361935,
0.7491188049,
-1.154930234,
0.3869248331,
0.0392026976,
0.9027947783,
0.4878747761,
-0.219464168,
0.7387554049,
-0.7114005089,
0.2819200754,
0.1657833457,
0.3018458486,
0.3986480236,
-0.2433800548,
0.3924923837,
0.5249311328,
-0.5706236959,
-0.692609787,
0.118073836,
-0.9041575193,
-0.5347747207,
0.9606069326,
-0.3816998601,
-0.2315547764,
-0.6753640771,
0.1308155209,
0.3864183128,
0.0311752502,
0.8594069481,
0.3822314739,
0.2293575555,
-0.246775046,
-0.6223114729,
0.6124013066,
0.5534453392,
-0.7940594554,
-0.0799776614,
0.0653006062,
0.4881778657,
0.0159592237,
1.0914521217,
0.0401059911,
0.1969447434,
-0.0138883227,
0.1017444879,
-0.1178211197,
-0.7198109031,
-0.2753815949,
0.1241713092,
0.0136257308,
-0.1422952712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03222v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03222v1 | Bringing the State-of-the-Art to Customers: A Neural Agent Assistant Framework for Customer Service Support | 2023-02-07T03:11:06 | 2023-02-07T03:11:06 | Stephen Obadinma, Faiza Khan Khattak, Shirley Wang, Tania Sidhom, Elaine Lau, Sean Robertson, Jingcheng Niu, Winnie Au, Alif Munim, Karthik Raja K. Bhaskar, Bencheng Wei, Iris Ren, Waqar Muhammad, Erin Li, Bukola Ishola, Michael Wang, Griffin Tanner, Yu-Jia Shiah, Sean X. Zhang, Kwesi P. Apponsah, Kanishk Patel, Jaswinder Narain, Deval Pandya, Xiaodan Zhu, Frank Rudzicz, Elham Dolatabadi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Building Agent Assistants that can help improve customer service support
requires inputs from industry users and their customers, as well as knowledge
about state-of-the-art Natural Language Processing (NLP) technology. We combine
expertise from academia and industry to bridge the gap and build
task/domain-specific Neural Agent Assistants (NAA) with three high-level
components for: (1) Intent Identification, (2) Context Retrieval, and (3)
Response Generation. In this paper, we outline the pipeline of the NAA's core
system and also present three case studies in which three industry partners
successfully adapt the framework to find solutions to their unique challenges.
Our findings suggest that a collaborative process is instrumental in spurring
the development of emerging NLP models for Conversational AI tasks in industry.
The full reference implementation code and results are available at
\url{https://github.com/VectorInstitute/NAA} | [
-0.5859779716,
-0.5080849528,
0.4640359581,
0.3513049185,
0.266145438,
0.2233375311,
0.3184728622,
-0.8987202644,
0.3053771257,
0.636027813,
-0.5698900223,
-0.1886247247,
-0.1148262024,
0.1266751289,
-0.1422486007,
0.617869556,
0.215580374,
0.0466025695,
-0.4150749147,
-0.1303298324,
-0.9127084017,
-0.677731216,
-1.1244115829,
-0.6313886046,
0.308331579,
0.4027431607,
0.8241578341,
0.0853879899,
0.4202733934,
0.3693372011,
-0.0101197409,
0.3131132722,
0.3332939446,
0.5541182756,
-0.0770512521,
-0.3806441724,
-1.0773695707,
-0.2174468488,
0.1100944653,
0.7621451616,
-0.2124769688,
-0.0065331943,
0.042882394,
0.7126275301,
-0.3788001537,
0.18895486,
-0.5455494523,
0.0016147722,
0.4018578827,
-0.1023864895,
-0.3370691538,
-0.1248547956,
0.6022462249,
-0.8939415812,
-0.0305390432,
-0.0430414714,
0.8010442257,
0.4252744913,
-0.0511711426,
-0.4456043541,
-0.8570094705,
0.4470952451,
-0.5861759186,
0.0621869825,
0.1564969718,
0.562232852,
-0.3101407588,
-0.8051993251,
-0.2296343297,
-0.0641289353,
0.0615011193,
-0.0639253333,
-0.3069183528,
-0.0373517647,
-0.0510194637,
0.0785087049,
-0.378064692,
0.2001805156,
-0.1188841909,
-0.0892615542,
0.6158598661,
0.0909538865,
0.2754707336,
0.2997805774,
-0.3367264271,
0.2589733303,
-0.3640193641,
0.1492574662,
0.1027976051,
0.3047034144,
0.1925433874,
0.1476182193,
-0.3744277358,
0.4968174696,
-0.0279078279,
0.3780918419,
0.2639245689,
-0.1394986957,
-0.4163630903,
0.1556021422,
0.5376006961,
0.1652968526,
0.1307612509,
-0.6294929385,
-0.284068346,
0.0212629903,
0.6402053237,
-0.3638261557,
0.2691943944,
0.3248459399,
-0.2005851269,
-0.1211640015,
-0.1578276157,
-0.6153357029,
-0.7277622223,
-0.5314898491,
0.0773153752,
0.1629052907,
-0.4812073708,
0.1204724014,
-0.4052734375,
0.4395775199,
0.1865927726,
-0.7496595383,
0.6133249402,
0.9929109812,
0.602190733,
-0.1856787503,
-0.1657642871,
-0.4027754068,
-0.0856231004,
-0.220078364,
1.0502647161,
-0.3944797814,
-0.1920433342,
0.3895082474,
-0.0279455949,
0.2281461656,
-0.8660945296,
0.542904377,
-0.6818586588,
-0.0352236405,
-0.1880115867,
-0.1471956968,
-0.0714546368,
0.4060716033,
-0.721285522,
0.625595212,
0.1703649312,
-0.0058421218,
0.2844308615,
-1.0188183784,
-0.2296395302,
0.3305137157,
-0.0894877389,
-0.2045407146,
0.0369313285,
0.2203316391,
0.4463883042,
-0.2930602431,
-0.0503147505,
-0.1619774252,
-0.0049161674,
0.3563941121,
0.0429966636,
0.6184409857,
0.271920681,
-0.3318141997,
0.3108826876,
-0.8657873273,
-0.1924685836,
0.0788631514,
0.0354468226,
0.052893158,
-0.2258027941,
0.2981714606,
0.3220850527,
0.2781071961,
-0.2734340429,
0.150295794,
-0.5147279501,
0.5326595306,
0.5233930349,
0.2136733532,
0.8830761313,
-0.3281266391,
0.7321811318,
-0.2049532384,
0.2292332798,
-0.043369811,
-0.8671742082,
-0.7700401545,
0.2367847264,
-0.0980573371,
0.2875468433,
-0.9327896237,
0.2340406626,
-0.0274943262,
-0.3915813267,
-0.4778934717,
0.1784499884,
0.0881082788,
0.581220448,
0.2281483412,
-0.4474244118,
-0.6380349398,
-1.1100076437,
-0.0133184716,
0.0081903702,
-0.1114369854,
0.2471562326,
-0.2245150059,
-0.187009722,
1.2917466164,
-0.3661074042,
-0.7284628749,
-0.2348129451,
0.0583961084,
0.1282261908,
0.407166034,
0.6430947185,
-0.8984156847,
-0.5189155936,
0.3353896737,
-0.8590864539,
-0.0372741371,
-0.06690678,
-0.223893106,
0.5788953304,
0.3453969657,
-0.5363458395,
0.4807991087,
0.3501447141,
-0.5034389496,
0.1626671404,
-0.1375842988,
-0.1001933366,
-1.2999138832,
0.1416920722,
0.1550680697,
-0.3272901177,
-1.0908138752,
-0.1521675587,
-0.5250871181,
-0.4243676364,
-0.3199489415,
0.4221971035,
-0.3713302612,
-0.647326231,
-0.8825314045,
0.126543954,
0.2177708298,
0.7686891556,
0.2155116498,
0.8359408975,
0.4400416613,
-0.7977595925,
0.3987312913,
0.5502934456,
0.0985053256,
0.7102450132,
-0.6956903338,
0.4157675207,
0.3111090958,
-0.0836767852,
-0.5390196443,
0.0196580924,
0.3957844973,
-0.6932579875,
-0.1849712431,
-0.034062814,
-0.2824365199,
-0.0978577584,
0.5505091548,
0.1226031259,
0.4167862535,
-0.3407176137,
1.2035251856,
0.6394850016,
-0.4843258262,
-0.5449653268,
-0.7007442117,
0.5878022909,
0.1862197965,
-0.9352055192,
0.3348794878,
0.0160217099,
-0.2766848803,
-0.1245490983,
-0.1157939583,
-0.5520387292,
0.3673559129,
0.3979561627,
-0.02840974,
-0.3803696036,
0.164956376,
-0.343716979,
-0.2975901365,
0.5023503304,
-0.3960779607,
0.7175916433,
-0.3811374605,
-0.0713922754,
-0.8395120502,
0.4950395525,
0.5981209874,
-0.3455705047,
0.3101215959,
0.3834635019,
-0.4690104723,
-0.4547231197,
-0.518651545,
-0.1283877641,
-0.5843690634,
0.1772906929,
-0.2484416664,
-0.2228971124,
0.671600461,
0.1297168881,
0.2651570439,
0.1066508442,
0.3329099119,
0.2540395856,
0.9848491549,
0.8630560637,
-0.1199474782,
0.5725930929,
-0.3367199898,
0.3550212979,
-0.5737883449,
-0.4584811628,
-0.7874814272,
-0.2695266604,
-0.1510737836,
0.0484655313,
0.2410389185,
-0.4767352641,
0.1256678551,
0.5367677212,
-0.5523686409,
0.0071766311,
0.5826588273,
-0.190975517,
0.3187505901,
-0.0123166107,
0.3684342206,
0.4193458855,
-0.6490886211,
-0.6950003505,
0.4723241329,
0.524841249,
0.2431113273,
0.1184331775,
0.2627496421,
0.4950685501,
0.164133653,
-0.864248991,
0.6193406582,
0.0784260407,
-0.4517459273,
-0.3309997916,
0.1768936515,
-0.9690442681,
-0.1397191733,
-0.1699308306,
-0.4151321054,
0.522077024,
0.0829323828,
-0.5100974441,
-0.1445903927,
-0.7138260007,
0.7817153335,
0.0320598073,
-0.3417216241,
0.0053466014,
-0.2674809992,
-0.221193105,
0.2498752624,
-0.095188126,
-0.0691927671,
-0.0683344007,
0.5958087444,
-0.1920864433,
0.711600244,
-0.5043172836,
-0.1973171085,
0.2851524055,
-0.1527630389,
0.3789345622,
0.0055516032,
-0.2208995968,
-0.1369500309,
-0.2516826689,
-0.6387836337,
-0.9454675317,
0.6730505824,
-0.5368769169,
-0.426094979,
-0.3727758527,
-0.6497878432,
-0.8102253079,
0.2162869871,
-0.421636343,
0.4952806234,
-0.3266829848,
0.298448801,
0.5346876383,
0.2348643839,
0.8910429478,
0.4307976365,
0.0015380293,
-0.3173294663,
0.6827747822,
-0.0922841877,
0.0729518309,
0.0809399262,
-0.1427501291,
-0.2084592283,
-0.7277603745,
-0.4030622542,
-0.1324227452,
-0.7947441936,
-0.1639438868,
-0.6524248123,
-0.1856233776,
-0.796898663,
-0.30238083,
-0.3543555737,
-0.1714258343,
-0.3832068443,
-0.0540976226,
0.0231832732,
0.9945506454,
0.5138239861,
0.3897550404,
-0.8106298447,
0.1052282304,
0.3740323484,
0.2732339501,
0.2232643515,
0.0574193969,
-0.4662380815,
-0.1457538009,
-0.2966684103,
-0.6165270209,
0.4500918388,
-0.0661220178,
0.7766028643,
0.2494052052,
-0.0550699532,
0.2687382996,
-0.0898435712,
1.0223356485,
0.0855672807,
-0.8678085208,
0.1696401536,
-0.1985450685,
0.3820215464,
0.5173763633,
0.146851778,
-0.6536174417,
-0.1327707767,
-0.5175440907,
-0.7636122704,
0.6448393464,
0.2708808184,
0.2205459327,
0.3796911538,
0.3726199269,
-0.1097459197,
0.1671181768,
-0.341809541,
-0.149369821,
-0.1162772849,
-0.0933073089,
0.1261906326,
0.1513988823,
-0.049611073,
0.402456224,
0.9334459901,
-0.6125285625,
0.3325357437,
0.4410919845,
-0.0592786483,
0.1509150863,
0.1151475981,
0.6001703739,
0.8189610839,
0.1368507445,
-0.5577732921,
-0.068516992,
-0.2104569227,
-0.0822954997,
0.0382560045,
-0.0046135108,
0.0147414887,
0.0056583378,
0.6552814841,
-0.0866076201,
-0.6073976159,
0.5266999006,
-0.3152301013,
-0.4040442705,
-0.6960934997,
0.0715862736,
0.0742222294,
0.3485323489,
0.7795058489,
0.3560494483,
0.4266650081,
-0.4871794879,
0.3981783986,
0.4889276326,
-0.7336918712,
-0.2187538296,
0.2152452618,
0.6098537445,
-0.9276177287,
0.1979501843,
-0.1057351828,
-0.3556892574,
0.9364980459,
0.2719766498,
1.2261815071,
0.0155813815,
0.4351835251,
-0.1609521955,
0.0970604941,
0.160556078,
0.2228512913,
0.0679341629,
-0.6481522918,
-0.203304261,
-0.2214432359,
-0.5868421197,
0.0174122155,
-0.7138038278,
0.1545403153,
-0.6655818224,
-0.2752501965,
0.3289930522,
-0.0025953897,
-0.7888935208,
0.0576783828,
0.2071689665,
0.831627965,
-0.5530123711,
0.574499011,
0.7891141772,
-0.6600915194,
-0.6660789251,
-0.1735855192,
-0.3874418736,
-0.612962544,
0.4423483014,
0.0042709457,
-0.2264902294,
-0.3046602607,
-0.372094959,
-0.5477790236,
1.2315385342,
0.0711960271,
-0.2321751714,
-0.3503804803,
0.4736626148,
0.8682367802,
-0.8763434887,
0.2054359764,
0.6212437749,
0.3423080444,
-0.0201871693,
-0.6710139513,
0.0891332477,
-0.3909002244,
-0.0931787863,
-0.2626541555,
-0.5769885182,
0.2585034668,
0.5720211864,
0.0548792742,
0.2520028651,
0.9208946824,
-0.1188737229,
0.8511891365,
0.719822526,
0.1661124378,
0.5337226391,
0.1472039074,
0.600948751,
-0.396735847,
-0.4117331207,
1.0589308739,
-0.4558365047,
0.5908066034,
0.6186355948,
0.3686000109,
0.7311899066,
0.2301302105,
0.1120549664,
0.1174315512,
-0.1642490625,
-0.1473095417,
-0.0641071796,
-0.6390501261,
-0.1641641706,
0.5269522071,
0.2493969947,
-0.2770536244,
-0.0120717324,
0.1532920003,
-0.2668847144,
0.22731556,
-0.3849908113,
1.2372634411,
0.2194972634,
-1.0461714268,
0.4187667072,
-0.3950082958,
0.5000211,
-0.5323107243,
-0.1081107855,
-0.2902359962,
0.1522754729,
-0.2928967774,
-0.2981131673,
0.5654087663,
-0.1539051384,
-0.2063525319,
-0.3778103292,
0.6674589515,
-0.0638348386,
0.1085115671,
0.455098629,
0.3786203563,
-0.0862652287,
-0.3117639124,
-0.8520541787,
-0.0500932038,
-0.3647734821,
-0.0239088777,
0.2280710191,
0.0566174164,
0.0818772018,
0.7385761738,
0.4291786849,
-0.0912021399,
0.1024462804,
0.1998324841,
0.890127182,
-0.308453083,
-0.4810522497,
0.1117633358,
0.6389843225,
-0.4934823513,
-0.5967235565,
0.4300801158,
0.3295084536,
0.5482596159,
0.0813744888,
0.6366256475,
0.2686490119,
0.2434444427,
-0.3462135196,
0.766654551,
-0.5296315551,
0.3219264448,
0.0005783829,
-0.9609234333,
-0.305691123,
0.1612246037,
-0.0457297675,
-0.196040988,
0.56207335,
0.9450739026,
0.2525264323,
0.2116623968,
0.2838430405,
-0.0462409407,
0.7868074775,
0.3589834273,
0.6185381413,
-0.4604105949,
0.6608653069,
-0.2756783068,
-0.0320683718,
-0.106581673,
-0.6596657038,
-0.6403979659,
-0.656306982,
-0.3666376173,
-0.3334650993,
0.0796502903,
1.1181800365,
0.9472965598,
-0.8777595758,
-0.3103814423,
-0.4363915026,
0.0229987949,
-0.7438820601,
-0.2292089015,
-0.1415135562,
-0.8368272185,
-1.0655733347,
0.7247847915,
0.2330397666,
-0.0489876121,
-0.6100252867,
-0.2004302889,
-0.1590937078,
0.2513204217,
0.3275987804,
0.3980483711,
-0.5307750702,
0.0812026411,
0.2436555773,
-0.0269375406,
0.1634123623,
0.9121097922,
-0.7300285697,
0.1906081289,
0.7042973638,
1.4312803745,
0.0592613183,
-0.1142642722,
1.1831406355,
-0.6406177282,
0.0544088855,
0.6207845211,
0.3800254166,
0.4284024537,
-0.6367452741,
0.5106167793,
-0.0016450068,
-0.7954056859,
-0.8010168076,
0.3607511222,
-1.1176329851,
-0.3584949076,
0.8603686094,
-0.1506253481,
-0.3859745562,
-0.6757492423,
-0.3215090334,
0.0814899877,
-0.7581600547,
0.5291931629,
0.4102289081,
-0.1034072265,
-0.0539574325,
-0.3425260782,
0.659784317,
0.6016560197,
-1.1446746588,
-0.0285535343,
0.2920609117,
-0.0540185198,
0.6232712865,
0.4743790925,
0.4360488057,
0.372125566,
-0.0921579227,
0.2825636864,
-0.3568108678,
-0.6763473749,
-0.6305094361,
0.5111593604,
0.3232396841,
-0.1744737029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03205v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03205v1 | An entity-guided text summarization framework with relational heterogeneous graph neural network | 2023-02-07T02:27:21 | 2023-02-07T02:27:21 | Jingqiang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Two crucial issues for text summarization to generate faithful summaries are
to make use of knowledge beyond text and to make use of cross-sentence
relations in text. Intuitive ways for the two issues are Knowledge Graph (KG)
and Graph Neural Network (GNN) respectively. Entities are semantic units in
text and in KG. This paper focuses on both issues by leveraging entities
mentioned in text to connect GNN and KG for summarization. Firstly, entities
are leveraged to construct a sentence-entity graph with weighted multi-type
edges to model sentence relations, and a relational heterogeneous GNN for
summarization is proposed to calculate node encodings. Secondly, entities are
leveraged to link the graph to KG to collect knowledge. Thirdly, entities guide
a two-step summarization framework defining a multi-task selector to select
salient sentences and entities, and using an entity-focused abstractor to
compress the sentences. GNN is connected with KG by constructing
sentence-entity graphs where entity-entity edges are built based on KG,
initializing entity embeddings on KG, and training entity embeddings using
entity-entity edges. The relational heterogeneous GNN utilizes both edge
weights and edge types in GNN to calculate graphs with weighted multi-type
edges. Experiments show the proposed method outperforms extractive baselines
including the HGNN-based HGNNSum and abstractive baselines including the
entity-driven SENECA on CNN/DM, and outperforms most baselines on NYT50.
Experiments on sub-datasets show the density of sentence-entity edges greatly
influences the performance of the proposed method. The greater the density, the
better the performance. Ablations show effectiveness of the method. | [
-0.3494915068,
-1.0345295668,
0.5461781025,
0.1628231257,
-0.3508656323,
-0.0100626759,
-0.2223401666,
-0.3273069859,
0.5963665247,
0.5220487118,
-0.1692707986,
-0.6741135716,
-0.4537520111,
0.1060428917,
-0.0965027735,
1.1691972017,
0.0708772689,
-0.1460599899,
-0.3079154193,
-0.2249000072,
-0.3170186877,
-0.190504536,
-0.5203999281,
-0.5571260452,
0.6221246123,
0.3127188981,
0.6914108992,
0.7941305041,
0.2593122423,
0.3765860796,
-0.2206300795,
0.248958841,
-0.5379159451,
0.0392797776,
-0.0690602809,
-0.1887197495,
-0.6541468501,
-0.188470304,
0.7748003006,
0.8767105937,
-0.0467534177,
0.0716746897,
-0.0107989432,
0.395783633,
-0.6123990417,
0.3328453898,
-0.4794204533,
0.2596972287,
0.0299486648,
-0.2076574564,
-0.1058616042,
-0.4040244818,
0.226623103,
-0.8378133178,
-0.0446736217,
0.1025847793,
1.033215642,
0.2716079056,
-0.7097907066,
-0.1891030669,
-0.3317924142,
0.3795728981,
-0.5762190223,
0.2455097586,
0.1179230809,
0.0559133328,
0.2969757617,
-0.9434301853,
-0.4127274752,
-0.0937217176,
-0.2851702571,
0.3706333637,
-0.0499209613,
0.0421698391,
0.0891488194,
0.435613066,
-0.4099950194,
0.1192960665,
-0.1650244594,
-0.1396477371,
0.3498016,
0.226086244,
0.5469641685,
-0.4877071679,
-0.5914090872,
0.2554168999,
-0.6196917892,
-0.3791327477,
0.4830515981,
0.2835383117,
-0.0358105153,
0.8823822141,
-0.2801114917,
0.6301739812,
-0.0499520116,
-0.2410561293,
0.315754354,
-0.4630957842,
-0.3311893344,
0.5182615519,
0.8062900901,
0.7295165658,
0.5014898777,
-0.5446779132,
-0.116701737,
-0.1145488471,
0.1273071319,
-1.1494486332,
-0.2305745035,
-0.0679360554,
-0.6608097553,
-0.1208778396,
-0.3261346519,
-0.8041442037,
0.148926273,
-0.4354832768,
0.0696669817,
-0.6720638871,
-0.3259428442,
-0.3897094429,
-0.3418498337,
-0.2684028447,
0.2211100757,
-0.9125153422,
0.3461756706,
0.433014065,
1.0354471207,
0.0094226114,
-0.3643744886,
-0.4682839215,
0.5612207055,
0.0268673655,
0.5264877677,
-0.2422628701,
-0.2446249872,
0.0402437039,
-0.3250786662,
-0.2018848062,
-0.1628333777,
0.1285725981,
-0.6374229789,
0.2339609563,
-0.2400449216,
-0.8414414525,
-0.3831913769,
0.5258342028,
-0.6302546263,
0.6930839419,
0.1326289028,
-1.0338462591,
0.2376532406,
-0.4998112917,
-0.7685643435,
0.0828944594,
-0.2920331657,
-0.4118386209,
-0.1847456694,
0.3839328587,
0.6528415084,
-0.1151524112,
0.2261675298,
-0.2119851708,
-0.3346511424,
-0.3076093495,
-0.0298409835,
0.960619688,
0.1351828277,
-0.052324485,
-0.0586740486,
-0.7272516489,
0.1133513898,
0.0014970815,
-0.419788301,
-0.5184636712,
-0.2526609302,
0.0088963136,
0.0780086145,
-0.0103894975,
-0.2688468099,
-0.0435971208,
-0.4729845524,
0.4136565328,
0.3224405944,
0.4568057954,
0.6811544299,
-0.0358544998,
0.3327729702,
-0.1062427908,
-0.4718400538,
-0.2303082943,
-0.4498663247,
-0.1315673441,
-0.0255247317,
0.3152761459,
0.7575563192,
-1.1807790995,
0.4378977716,
-0.5524370074,
-0.2608824372,
0.0493613742,
-0.0506088138,
0.422290504,
1.0797327757,
0.5216385722,
-0.0083770165,
-0.2655748725,
-0.727653563,
-0.3589116931,
-0.2996521294,
-0.0144375684,
0.4609254301,
0.5417696834,
0.045492731,
0.7577664256,
-0.6664832234,
-0.4306219518,
-0.257720679,
0.1301629841,
-0.0035028744,
0.4485134482,
0.7636110187,
-0.9812967777,
-0.3619276881,
0.0604997613,
-1.1881122589,
0.2443299592,
-0.0523814447,
-0.1170873269,
-0.0545562916,
0.5559580326,
-0.58855021,
0.3338817656,
0.1876487285,
-0.3116701841,
0.3395043015,
-0.2968017757,
0.1005224064,
-1.3503332138,
-0.0051779733,
0.2635962665,
-0.2850141823,
-0.4361703396,
-0.1044391841,
-0.1098165438,
-0.0714681894,
-0.0022811068,
0.1005016565,
-0.7413764596,
-0.1701718718,
-0.1119656265,
0.503975451,
0.0536666773,
0.7028604746,
-0.0132575976,
0.3512479067,
0.2522988021,
-0.6974517703,
0.5344589353,
0.4717793763,
-0.0749347284,
0.7364987135,
-0.7547995448,
-0.2066270858,
-0.4479476511,
0.2562928498,
-0.5339511633,
-0.0963336676,
0.4722411335,
-0.3417136371,
0.3603075743,
-0.164583832,
-0.3293901086,
-0.038334351,
-0.0302506164,
0.1888061464,
0.0963909924,
-0.216437012,
1.2398142815,
0.2549441457,
-0.2616236806,
-0.7405453324,
-0.967181921,
0.3933067024,
-0.1825460494,
-0.7441150546,
0.837962389,
0.353984803,
-0.2300706655,
0.7450560927,
-0.0046318066,
0.0245845653,
0.2118932754,
0.2552884221,
0.3790816963,
-0.4011147022,
0.3296082914,
0.2627871335,
-0.0528217219,
0.2460776716,
-0.6302464604,
0.2899816334,
0.0071503511,
0.0306102652,
-0.1071886867,
0.4971349537,
0.0632848069,
-0.28548491,
0.7824606895,
0.8063331842,
-0.6384584904,
0.0345752724,
-0.092708379,
0.0543286055,
-0.2927695811,
0.7410858274,
-0.5287926793,
-0.8644068241,
0.5391085744,
-0.17366831,
0.0102943797,
0.7078432441,
0.6892213821,
0.1136239544,
0.4922133088,
0.5967782736,
-0.2779271305,
0.5096511841,
-0.2940331399,
0.1857333183,
-0.8372042179,
-0.3267955184,
-0.4189406931,
-0.2460877597,
-0.5025423169,
0.2336552143,
0.3804712892,
0.2063149214,
-0.0715129077,
0.3249319196,
-0.4306913316,
0.447052151,
0.3667458594,
0.1349398792,
0.5504330993,
0.1311331391,
-0.3766369224,
0.2299677283,
-0.7805168033,
-0.271016866,
0.9666410089,
0.176302582,
0.4348040819,
0.1593377143,
0.6851853132,
0.1331948787,
0.337324053,
-0.4810003638,
0.3767217696,
0.0263039153,
-0.3804874122,
-0.5596607924,
-0.9944581985,
-0.4971437156,
0.4237982035,
-0.2310903817,
-0.9476518035,
0.0999211743,
0.1195831373,
-0.3296303451,
0.3110411465,
-0.8782806993,
0.7965920568,
0.1436775029,
-0.1068283767,
-0.0667160898,
-0.8464827538,
0.4981007278,
0.4669540226,
-0.2708684802,
-0.0477408282,
-0.0616202131,
0.5676428676,
-0.4685736597,
0.3599651754,
-0.0809012204,
0.0821175426,
0.2464237958,
-0.2968555093,
0.4943082333,
0.6191193461,
0.0256939474,
-0.1236596256,
-0.4865252972,
-0.240913108,
-0.5253400803,
0.7858113647,
-0.6683716774,
-0.3199095726,
-0.0707020536,
-0.6187940836,
-0.2230585366,
0.4381152987,
0.6580654979,
0.6601305008,
-0.2860464752,
0.0588308163,
0.8182270527,
0.0972734094,
0.6492513418,
-0.1131588817,
-0.3089918494,
-0.6697052121,
0.9780306816,
0.3318009675,
0.1978973001,
0.6917806864,
-0.1799536347,
-0.1805023402,
-0.4801144302,
-0.9142128229,
-0.0156646185,
-0.8571206927,
-0.2624586225,
-1.2525348663,
-0.1495729685,
-0.5152535439,
0.0016510031,
0.0152021106,
-0.3853963017,
-0.3623562157,
-0.2251418382,
0.2660652995,
0.3530050516,
0.2385673672,
0.1737916619,
-0.5682688355,
0.5846208334,
0.3202358186,
0.2425390482,
0.1786562353,
0.082197912,
-0.3051359951,
0.0380858667,
0.1426656991,
-1.0789439678,
0.0206077397,
0.2047302872,
0.4015593529,
0.3636683822,
-0.1917257011,
0.3734480739,
-0.3637554646,
0.4947434962,
0.3632843196,
-0.8175401688,
0.2684659064,
-0.3384998441,
0.3214285374,
0.4361637235,
0.4451726675,
-0.6193750501,
-0.2842945755,
-0.4053076804,
-0.8269011974,
0.5999731421,
0.5398455858,
0.0094853435,
0.1964407265,
0.4034560323,
-0.4365724027,
0.3670629263,
-0.5142969489,
-0.6773481369,
-0.7774724364,
-0.3057590425,
-0.0024815928,
0.0018328547,
-0.1206155345,
-0.038286522,
0.8768330812,
-0.3842407167,
0.2245933414,
0.3147675395,
-0.4127696455,
0.2926939428,
0.0622305647,
0.3683862388,
0.5989630818,
-0.1066342667,
0.1472332925,
0.3214244843,
-0.5293595791,
-0.1386315376,
0.7120957971,
-0.5765116215,
0.2783334255,
0.4728071094,
0.8259061575,
0.0259136278,
-0.0512275957,
0.3463071585,
-0.1413262486,
-0.2736560702,
0.078696765,
-0.0406442769,
0.5272477865,
0.0925537646,
0.2453897893,
0.159372136,
0.3839117587,
-0.5812622905,
0.0129503505,
0.0299737547,
-0.3801165819,
-0.0638771653,
0.6039745212,
0.2147728354,
-0.0092622275,
0.6763399839,
-0.4609224498,
-0.5926619768,
0.7306649685,
0.6268780231,
0.6822756529,
0.177192688,
0.2782174647,
0.2918229401,
0.2960355878,
0.2103726864,
0.0316400193,
-0.0844536647,
-0.7393390536,
-0.4986737669,
-0.1614530236,
-0.1867885441,
-0.4947971106,
-0.3953878284,
-0.1250769198,
-0.2787118852,
-0.0086361524,
0.4678213596,
0.1290197372,
-0.443434298,
0.4400230944,
-0.1550992131,
0.6821053624,
-0.5095686316,
0.4773315787,
0.7784808874,
-0.7957040668,
-1.1154023409,
-0.0844200328,
-0.1013741642,
-0.4504836798,
0.2044851333,
-0.0028931382,
0.0947671682,
0.2278915793,
-0.1216008887,
-0.5684594512,
1.3815598488,
0.3739900887,
-0.2907930911,
-0.5543534756,
-0.1303435713,
0.2758858502,
-0.6353727579,
0.340718925,
0.1820936203,
0.4255630672,
0.0354643315,
-0.3904418647,
0.224785313,
-0.4262029827,
0.2978074253,
0.3790164292,
-0.6066182852,
1.0242700577,
-0.0657248795,
-0.1684305519,
-0.3143976927,
0.9863687158,
-0.1153064817,
0.3924106061,
0.4642392695,
0.8414886594,
0.8608732224,
-0.2295432389,
0.9282696843,
-0.2177753747,
0.4031952918,
1.2582097054,
-0.2890518308,
0.032565847,
0.306047678,
0.2778328657,
0.5788648725,
0.2700522542,
-0.1315345764,
0.3942795098,
0.2425723821,
-0.1381618977,
0.0092506167,
-0.3985497355,
-0.6005083919,
0.3333151937,
0.1205622852,
-0.5495730639,
-0.5845919847,
0.1931579411,
0.2885304093,
0.2400237471,
-0.5156297088,
0.8084716797,
0.1735574156,
-0.7162715793,
-0.156452626,
0.2818992138,
0.3356386423,
-0.309410423,
-0.0371651575,
0.0066980454,
-0.0627144501,
-0.3463114798,
-0.5157506466,
0.3251751065,
-0.0926664993,
-0.2977961004,
-0.2262033522,
1.244376421,
-0.6145511866,
-0.3176176846,
0.0890259594,
0.7058671117,
-0.1691121161,
-0.2898093462,
-0.2839799523,
-0.4867835045,
-0.1435962617,
-0.3546185791,
0.0708852038,
0.9057020545,
0.1028934494,
0.4284795821,
0.2742375433,
-0.0386429541,
-0.2138278037,
0.2790365517,
1.020560503,
-0.5593529344,
-0.88781178,
-0.8472537398,
0.2572101653,
-0.4317608476,
-0.6239626408,
0.6971898079,
0.7053773999,
0.5608056188,
0.2627450824,
0.4832037985,
-0.2168271542,
0.0800997615,
-0.832629323,
0.8924486041,
-0.3207735121,
-0.0317976587,
-0.3699991107,
-1.0640664101,
-0.0888874903,
0.1992989182,
-0.075984247,
0.2852944732,
0.7101365924,
0.288905412,
0.0643832386,
0.3721510768,
-0.0680669695,
-0.0728255585,
0.049722556,
0.5095512271,
0.3934423625,
-0.4015676975,
0.7282401919,
-0.1489436626,
-0.0030241555,
-0.1775589138,
-0.8117582202,
-1.0985887051,
-0.3491846323,
-0.4818732738,
-0.4142261147,
0.1195509955,
0.7471801043,
0.6012123227,
-0.3095338941,
0.2881706059,
-0.144764781,
0.5738039017,
-0.2590148747,
-0.2367669493,
0.4336607754,
-0.1682146043,
-0.5827271342,
-0.0428525805,
0.3743497729,
0.0638583675,
-0.0670050681,
-0.0879569948,
-0.5086014867,
-0.4752069116,
0.4347294569,
-0.0877057016,
-0.2744532526,
-0.0810753927,
-0.000059649,
-0.42744717,
-0.0205030814,
0.7314967513,
-0.7146034241,
0.0145547828,
0.3741215467,
0.8658127785,
0.7225254178,
0.0344618373,
0.5694506168,
-0.9549843073,
-0.1157516241,
0.3392855227,
0.4560530186,
0.1790049225,
-0.6591444612,
0.472294271,
0.3113962412,
-0.2368080616,
-0.3422907591,
0.0245475862,
-0.8325150609,
-0.2784154117,
0.7379896641,
-0.3955410719,
-0.295163542,
0.0598765686,
0.1719557643,
0.6785003543,
-0.4271301031,
0.3580407202,
0.5630840063,
0.0925980434,
-0.0935679749,
-0.181200251,
0.2901218534,
0.2203329057,
-1.0951102972,
-0.4325301349,
0.6114298701,
0.1167685017,
0.3400454819,
0.6051116586,
0.1458146423,
0.232995972,
0.2061046213,
-0.0708488673,
-0.6205903888,
-0.3434557617,
0.0333990045,
0.5464735031,
-0.7236950994,
-0.1268738955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03202v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03202v2 | Exploring the Benefits of Training Expert Language Models over Instruction Tuning | 2023-02-07T02:24:30 | 2023-02-09T04:55:39 | Joel Jang, Seungone Kim, Seonghyeon Ye, Doyoung Kim, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Moontae Lee, Kyungjae Lee, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Language Models (LMs) instruction-tuned on multiple tasks, also
known as multitask-prompted fine-tuning (MT), have shown the capability to
generalize to unseen tasks. Previous work has shown that scaling the number of
training tasks is the key component in making stronger MT LMs. In this work, we
report an unexpected finding that an expert LM fine-tuned on just a single task
can outperform an MT LM trained with 300+ different tasks on 11 different
unseen datasets and on 13 datasets of the BIG-bench benchmark by a mean
accuracy of 3.20% and 1.29%, respectively. This finding casts doubt on the
previously held belief that simply scaling the number of tasks makes stronger
MT LMs. Leveraging this finding, we further show that this distributed approach
of training a separate expert LM per training task instead of a single MT LM
for zero-shot inference possesses many benefits including (1) avoiding negative
task transfer that often occurs during instruction tuning, (2) being able to
continually learn new tasks without having to re-train on previous tasks to
avoid catastrophic forgetting, and (3) showing compositional capabilities when
merging individual experts together. The code is available at
https://github.com/joeljang/ELM. | [
-0.4120295346,
-0.5996522903,
0.3288518786,
-0.0084547764,
0.0939627439,
0.1125789583,
-0.6330595016,
-0.3054603636,
-0.1314257532,
0.5397785306,
-0.5514444709,
-0.4523534477,
-0.920031786,
0.0301798452,
-0.3492988348,
1.0373959541,
0.1289090216,
0.0380184725,
-0.0753270462,
-0.2192723006,
-0.6465082765,
-0.0691362768,
-0.7676583529,
-0.1754662693,
0.6786829829,
0.7649380565,
0.5654008985,
0.9005660415,
0.5903560519,
0.3487699628,
0.3298419416,
0.6243305802,
-0.5319983959,
0.1069594845,
0.0563049577,
-0.6466664076,
-0.6578789353,
0.0535913967,
0.5249160528,
0.7341756225,
-0.1055150628,
0.165463075,
0.2304406017,
0.8270344734,
-0.7448381782,
0.2059693038,
-0.8728196025,
-0.2335149497,
-0.1760343611,
-0.1909926385,
-0.5483627319,
-0.0197200403,
-0.05922883,
-0.5089212656,
0.3817843795,
-0.0290061533,
0.6197449565,
0.6580660939,
-0.3446747065,
-0.0755011588,
-0.6060953736,
0.9301603436,
-0.7932853103,
0.214653641,
0.3372569978,
0.2597259879,
0.0278262813,
-0.2164123654,
-0.3242827654,
-0.1007756889,
0.1350643635,
-0.0650941432,
0.0178002566,
0.2275673747,
0.2952715456,
0.1849330217,
-0.2608625889,
0.4589596689,
-0.0924461037,
0.1750518233,
0.5066959262,
0.1500892341,
0.1887851208,
0.3852409124,
-0.0151151158,
-0.0138419792,
-0.610763371,
0.1158343181,
0.340777725,
0.5165721178,
-0.0067505087,
0.1354675591,
-0.3271619678,
0.9820239544,
0.219587937,
-0.2525890172,
0.0826556608,
-0.1294592917,
-0.0141623113,
-0.1173511967,
0.6783421636,
0.315225035,
0.4866232574,
-0.284822762,
-0.1725619435,
-0.2522269785,
0.434576571,
-0.7237049341,
-0.3738413155,
0.0164934322,
-0.0353094041,
-0.0380572863,
-0.0275859199,
-0.3088876009,
-0.2886715531,
-0.5087070465,
0.5072903037,
-0.3622704446,
-0.3896299303,
0.2114884853,
-0.0224379525,
-0.2799606621,
0.3542194068,
-1.2967385054,
0.2079842538,
0.877736032,
0.6343380809,
-0.1459980011,
-0.6864343882,
-0.627604425,
-0.080238156,
-0.6490868926,
0.8086363673,
-0.6046100259,
-0.0304926485,
-0.1342297196,
-0.205633074,
-0.5563115478,
-0.6566364169,
0.2300665826,
-0.3510780334,
-0.2176080197,
-0.4482890964,
-0.6104184389,
-0.003541125,
0.0903621167,
-0.5082154274,
1.0450564623,
0.0369931348,
-0.4013157189,
0.6044250727,
-0.3844491541,
-0.4241443574,
0.0000147971,
-0.1191470549,
-0.3698219955,
0.291175127,
0.2952086031,
0.6879699826,
-0.105173476,
-0.0333231315,
-0.5470816493,
-0.3353414536,
0.0395193622,
-0.2794055641,
0.2457444221,
0.0860425606,
-0.4834016263,
0.0411315449,
-0.6474311948,
0.2840144932,
-0.2793086469,
-0.5418899655,
-0.3869332969,
0.0737681016,
-0.4161874652,
0.1018633172,
0.1854617447,
-0.4605738223,
0.3290887773,
-0.4204376936,
0.1920684725,
0.6684228778,
-0.1821981668,
0.4497818649,
-0.4435439408,
0.4040141702,
-0.1413099021,
-0.0548419952,
-0.3979874551,
-0.4288089573,
-0.9949464798,
-0.3539936543,
0.1269968748,
0.4930379093,
-0.5728728771,
0.331829071,
-0.2402302772,
-0.5198550224,
-0.9839958549,
0.4508144557,
0.684464097,
0.4557376504,
0.4079299569,
-0.2005183101,
-0.1814750731,
-0.9060621262,
-0.6344674826,
0.3443110585,
0.0965363756,
0.3400222361,
0.3983561397,
0.1377322674,
0.7381987572,
-0.4065047503,
-0.2884424031,
-0.1993565559,
0.4115719795,
0.1468592435,
0.5421137214,
0.4816058874,
-0.2851248682,
-0.9295514226,
0.2376254499,
-0.4888620675,
0.050433591,
-0.2582964003,
-0.0344626419,
0.1815263182,
0.3206637502,
-0.6572104096,
-0.076600939,
0.4029580951,
0.0548357181,
0.4522912204,
-0.5171015859,
0.356434375,
-0.9326870441,
-0.230150044,
-0.0078075733,
-0.1387143284,
-0.8163738847,
0.3416797817,
0.2847838104,
0.1410515606,
-0.1739169061,
0.2736545503,
-0.6098353267,
0.1323837936,
-0.5586858392,
-0.1290133893,
-0.369271636,
0.7619974017,
-0.1004582718,
0.7813634276,
0.9574919343,
-0.5641872883,
0.1601099074,
-0.0491141714,
-0.3958959281,
0.5865859985,
-0.4792137146,
0.3676745296,
0.0073911427,
-0.2682518363,
-0.8199908137,
-0.1145226583,
-0.2288786024,
-0.3583675921,
0.618866384,
-0.125807181,
-0.5218404531,
-0.2767944038,
-0.0715045482,
0.064576149,
0.2471465319,
-0.4326085746,
0.2906654477,
0.2210766971,
-0.0320173018,
-0.7682051659,
-0.5228685737,
0.0652434155,
-0.1281030625,
-0.4516946077,
0.0385043696,
-0.172831431,
-0.1442392021,
-0.0939339548,
-0.4450471997,
-0.1843082309,
0.3291573822,
0.1992757916,
-0.1923790276,
-0.2909830213,
0.3212338388,
0.2144438922,
-0.2173622549,
-0.1376048326,
-0.327093482,
0.1448663473,
-0.1579062641,
-0.5764226913,
-0.4962075651,
0.3603620529,
0.5614420772,
-0.3543850482,
0.9439541698,
0.581413269,
-0.1852020025,
-0.4897624254,
-0.6514911056,
-0.2925713658,
-0.4726016819,
0.497118026,
-0.4331703782,
-0.9704637527,
0.3297759295,
-0.1510204673,
0.3956950009,
0.4485427141,
0.4866771996,
-0.1590930372,
1.3574382067,
0.7004926205,
-0.1139937863,
0.4845385253,
-0.2788263261,
0.0446981825,
-0.5144891143,
-0.0401612073,
-0.6428610682,
-0.4982439876,
-0.4359025657,
-0.335575223,
0.4074531198,
0.1135802418,
-0.2506613433,
0.3017080426,
-0.4724187851,
0.7411327362,
0.8201510906,
0.3646003902,
0.1345167309,
0.0366367176,
0.010534416,
0.0895776078,
-0.914334476,
-0.2559918165,
1.1555713415,
0.1733923256,
0.6425048709,
-0.1608352065,
0.6685389876,
0.1077337936,
0.1205507591,
-0.6731990576,
0.4460375905,
-0.5492251515,
-0.6386733651,
-0.544347167,
-0.3305912614,
-0.7853153348,
0.2075012475,
-0.1990503222,
-0.4326173365,
-0.0193831921,
0.3848149478,
-0.5641090274,
0.4085194767,
-0.9042415619,
0.9248802662,
-0.1912888736,
-0.3377720118,
-0.7287240028,
-0.4956876338,
-0.0126065733,
-0.2855118215,
0.3016808927,
-0.2802498043,
-0.0102488436,
0.6432195306,
-0.3954264224,
0.9612390995,
-0.2101837844,
-0.0027096525,
0.0065840688,
0.0517391451,
0.584459722,
-0.1377121359,
-0.0330884643,
-0.0592943877,
-0.2203689367,
-0.6328744888,
-0.6871504784,
0.8984752297,
-0.8712422252,
-0.8399615884,
0.1424582601,
-0.8146854043,
-0.3099473417,
0.3353930712,
0.0294806752,
0.6576157808,
0.3872416317,
0.4156242907,
0.9057275057,
0.2214808166,
0.3731382191,
0.8093602657,
0.477758199,
-0.1946009994,
0.9179611802,
0.246676445,
0.5107431412,
0.6573958397,
-0.0188724175,
0.2086940557,
-0.7429488897,
-0.451795727,
-0.034220241,
-0.538862586,
-0.1707205027,
-0.6505903602,
0.1897873133,
-0.2890117168,
-0.1628687382,
-0.7763137817,
-0.2995232344,
-0.3126536608,
-0.1074389294,
0.4676926732,
0.8048474789,
-0.0790410563,
0.4402064085,
-0.7719247937,
0.016295962,
0.3993455172,
0.4516953528,
0.1191893667,
-0.5812188387,
-0.8723918796,
0.1884807348,
-0.1901986301,
-0.5896713138,
0.2304787785,
0.5791763663,
0.7773946524,
0.4740032256,
-0.0513565429,
0.8802919388,
-0.7113967538,
0.4416083395,
0.0806061029,
-0.6203325987,
0.3093549907,
-0.541487515,
0.6919296384,
0.7002759576,
0.5149607062,
-0.3817387819,
-0.7999997735,
-0.3686098456,
-0.6615131497,
0.8633102179,
-0.1796090454,
0.2363434881,
0.0065915105,
0.2940919399,
0.5240122676,
0.3312340379,
-0.1904511303,
-0.5282772779,
-0.0007620481,
-0.1788135767,
-0.2794394791,
-0.1125359088,
-0.0804415271,
-0.3409003019,
0.5808131695,
-0.2495187521,
0.1328409761,
-0.25472188,
-0.1504762769,
-0.3222310245,
0.3507695198,
0.6489174962,
0.6968470216,
-0.113968879,
0.3409275711,
0.4612875879,
-0.2218586951,
-0.253980875,
0.1219070256,
0.1846215576,
-0.143364653,
0.6579091549,
1.2226835489,
0.6238620281,
-0.2840591669,
0.1220815554,
0.2111421824,
-0.3855531514,
0.2912228107,
0.519652009,
0.1894893795,
0.2508399785,
0.5848233104,
0.557698071,
-0.159552753,
-0.2707697451,
0.3051838279,
0.4441618025,
-0.2489443868,
-0.3548701406,
0.6343177557,
0.2510426939,
-0.4276134968,
0.3697825074,
-0.1453414559,
-0.309633702,
0.6524752975,
0.2089691758,
0.6118760109,
-0.3528364599,
0.0747140199,
0.4245222211,
0.4054940641,
-0.3008334935,
0.0741647929,
-0.2239202708,
-0.699047327,
-0.6039512157,
-0.3930031359,
-0.3819141686,
0.0184013173,
-0.6055948138,
0.1258581877,
-0.1297217906,
-0.0734568685,
0.0599059798,
-0.0120402733,
-0.8297775388,
0.1319255233,
-0.0935449898,
0.6978601813,
-0.7749625444,
0.9331378341,
0.7449972034,
-0.0675116107,
-1.0084315538,
-0.1966692656,
-0.0952463895,
-0.8581760526,
0.4768159091,
0.1813117862,
0.0252366625,
0.2724989951,
-0.2484328151,
-0.7978500724,
0.77437222,
0.4967018962,
-0.9148997664,
-0.0286379661,
0.1846553683,
0.6759136915,
-0.3917348981,
0.5024225712,
0.5086913109,
0.1622966528,
-0.092549026,
-1.3375902176,
-0.0968234092,
-0.0389839299,
-0.3793728352,
0.4135333002,
-0.5586074591,
0.9329014421,
-0.5068253875,
0.0736033171,
-0.1374085248,
0.4441512525,
-0.1182163358,
0.0632836744,
0.4585917294,
0.6569337249,
0.7768434882,
0.0120561449,
0.9094050527,
-0.5983771682,
0.3230037689,
1.2040416002,
0.1862190664,
0.7927667499,
0.1475082785,
-0.0783202946,
0.3637186289,
0.6345794201,
0.14942725,
0.5880913138,
-0.2450881749,
-0.2659980059,
-0.6780263782,
0.0769323036,
-0.4016244709,
0.2641853988,
0.2167460769,
-0.1385259181,
-0.428534627,
0.1323677599,
0.0381595492,
0.1687987596,
-0.5215016007,
0.6841987967,
0.0735197365,
-0.8118867874,
0.8378568888,
-0.1919559389,
0.6544147134,
-0.4672505856,
0.1123159975,
-0.1571232527,
0.3959698677,
-0.1885211468,
-0.6855671406,
0.1549272239,
-0.1557217687,
-0.1393023878,
-0.6171589494,
0.6455860734,
-0.6643286347,
-0.2280485332,
-0.0036244632,
0.5846034884,
0.1669248194,
-0.2173823416,
-0.6904506683,
-0.3282449841,
-0.0342625938,
-0.3050272763,
0.5720388293,
0.5376075506,
0.1867463291,
0.7919730544,
0.3959894776,
0.1384073794,
0.1926704347,
0.1217293516,
0.7505502701,
-0.2478323281,
-0.2481031716,
-0.8610882163,
0.5765351653,
0.010352158,
-0.4051114917,
0.975135386,
0.3627366424,
0.9857583046,
-0.2774919868,
0.6633868217,
0.1942291409,
0.5924723148,
-0.3225179613,
0.6224998236,
-0.6645900607,
0.0442061014,
0.0104728425,
-0.4610431194,
-0.2586099505,
0.2495732903,
-0.3508135378,
0.1123167053,
0.732282877,
0.7803903222,
0.044400245,
-0.2819522917,
0.4958938658,
0.1237865612,
0.0467332564,
0.5304269195,
0.3344661295,
-0.0612931252,
0.4534898698,
-0.3500455618,
-0.2624911368,
-0.1590131074,
-0.6270853877,
-1.178670764,
-0.5013152361,
-0.3480134606,
0.3332436085,
0.211143136,
0.8826466203,
1.0568019152,
-0.9763979316,
-0.2634668648,
-0.2255068123,
0.11761906,
-0.7430558205,
-0.0772822574,
0.1225995347,
-0.7530791163,
-0.9136589766,
0.5811086297,
0.2057789713,
-0.4438245296,
-0.0755035132,
-0.0918352678,
-0.0181546584,
-0.1406202763,
0.3935635388,
0.1606423706,
-0.5523520708,
-0.3892760873,
0.1466056854,
-0.1568635106,
-0.0384236276,
0.7180330157,
-0.4741179645,
0.6411455274,
0.3987126946,
0.7107667923,
0.3023457825,
-0.2362153828,
0.5840281844,
-0.875564158,
-0.1319677234,
-0.0770366415,
0.16659455,
0.0480590463,
-0.3075148761,
0.2975776792,
0.0766776055,
-0.7987625599,
-0.8301339746,
0.0758111477,
-0.7035383582,
-0.3176314831,
1.0656884909,
-0.2175540179,
0.1735609621,
0.0073341448,
-0.1090956703,
0.3099273443,
-0.6020802259,
0.8948512077,
0.7912597656,
-0.2162623107,
-0.3469978571,
-0.8046401143,
0.6462941766,
0.6952886581,
-0.6815573573,
0.1115538627,
0.1157768443,
0.3437269628,
-0.0467331372,
0.3792932034,
0.595121026,
0.3559191227,
-0.0524513386,
0.1038493738,
-0.4921558499,
-0.5489717722,
-0.1574771851,
0.1518068314,
0.4415711462,
-0.2957880795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03194v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03194v2 | UDApter -- Efficient Domain Adaptation Using Adapters | 2023-02-07T02:04:17 | 2023-02-16T08:17:56 | Bhavitvya Malik, Abhinav Ramesh Kashyap, Min-Yen Kan, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose two methods to make unsupervised domain adaptation (UDA) more
parameter efficient using adapters, small bottleneck layers interspersed with
every layer of the large-scale pre-trained language model (PLM). The first
method deconstructs UDA into a two-step process: first by adding a domain
adapter to learn domain-invariant information and then by adding a task adapter
that uses domain-invariant information to learn task representations in the
source domain. The second method jointly learns a supervised classifier while
reducing the divergence measure. Compared to strong baselines, our simple
methods perform well in natural language inference (MNLI) and the cross-domain
sentiment classification task. We even outperform unsupervised domain
adaptation methods such as DANN and DSN in sentiment classification, and we are
within 0.85% F1 for natural language inference task, by fine-tuning only a
fraction of the full model parameters. We release our code at
https://github.com/declare-lab/domadapter | [
-0.5471799374,
-0.5674589872,
0.2715399563,
0.3259164095,
-0.4232552052,
0.2230877429,
-0.2977682948,
-0.1733878255,
-0.0990304798,
0.442963779,
-0.3919386268,
-0.3064664006,
-0.5901935101,
-0.0532057434,
0.0512994416,
0.9769039154,
-0.0637306571,
-0.1772084087,
-0.4267702997,
-0.1131082922,
-0.4000022113,
-0.4766689241,
-0.6548929811,
-0.453071624,
0.2429774106,
0.432168901,
0.192071557,
0.2780483365,
0.6666971445,
0.3197414279,
0.0210253261,
0.1159942821,
-0.4173869789,
0.1194057688,
-0.2902339697,
-0.400444299,
-0.5257480145,
-0.0348678902,
0.3086440563,
0.7190287113,
-0.2490162402,
0.1912652701,
0.1675460041,
0.9366054535,
-0.7576693892,
0.2479397953,
-0.7462574244,
-0.2173593491,
-0.0713062957,
-0.3132781982,
-0.5605586767,
-0.2114709616,
0.1973670423,
-0.6737556458,
0.2432909906,
-0.1378216445,
0.4730621874,
0.2896184027,
-0.365457803,
0.1027319357,
-0.8570806384,
0.9028006196,
-0.5612729788,
0.3036255538,
0.1545381695,
0.4940341711,
-0.1440982819,
-1.0494788885,
-0.8265958428,
0.1248049587,
0.2197081596,
0.3235104382,
-0.3339971304,
0.1113624051,
-0.0133561473,
0.3334472775,
-0.4766410887,
0.1477276683,
-0.1998118311,
0.0586306378,
0.65740484,
-0.0142477956,
0.1794062108,
0.0120998556,
-0.5705119371,
-0.1940790415,
-0.5453013778,
0.0619638041,
0.2486783117,
0.283456862,
-0.0566725582,
0.2354669869,
-0.082441248,
0.6652134657,
0.2388163656,
-0.1028891727,
0.2564671636,
-0.1936479211,
-0.2916561663,
-0.1856868416,
0.4826923311,
0.535754323,
0.3681666851,
-0.1661013216,
-0.164905712,
0.2795918882,
0.5851099491,
-0.9803569913,
-0.6858069897,
0.2998378277,
-0.4293166995,
-0.0829391629,
0.0832573697,
-1.0136554241,
-0.4376717806,
-0.3362564743,
0.5324593782,
-0.2008888274,
-0.368837148,
0.1560872495,
-0.3349654973,
0.4079319239,
0.5242378712,
-0.7376067042,
0.5582795739,
0.6635124087,
0.8386982679,
-0.5431652665,
-0.3852621615,
-0.3860347867,
-0.0996163338,
-0.0154540809,
1.1685973406,
-0.3983767629,
-0.4050885439,
0.0216670316,
0.0689816251,
-0.5883622169,
-0.7031014562,
0.7811418772,
-0.8395459652,
0.1149181053,
-0.1271666437,
-0.6707330942,
-0.5097601414,
-0.0985052362,
-0.6900324225,
0.8386304379,
0.1794032604,
-0.6352856159,
0.3535783589,
-1.0886881351,
-0.4811065197,
0.0102900034,
0.4911222458,
-0.2743394077,
0.1849320531,
0.2672967315,
0.5915455222,
-0.1812443286,
-0.0970063508,
-0.2133714706,
-0.1882538646,
0.3497768939,
-0.3917755187,
0.857401371,
0.157175228,
-0.1726802588,
0.0817903504,
-0.8307813406,
-0.2007107288,
0.2675967216,
-0.3799794018,
-0.5142009854,
0.0705173239,
0.4338659048,
0.1256663054,
0.0435612127,
-0.503015399,
0.1921817511,
-0.3516862988,
0.3238295317,
1.0198807716,
-0.0554452054,
0.6176438332,
-0.1532479972,
0.49127388,
0.3507871628,
0.0025385104,
0.2306917161,
-0.4624690413,
-0.8534579873,
-0.4918041825,
0.4199352264,
0.4780344367,
-0.7557034492,
0.637296319,
-0.3326588273,
-0.3917694092,
-0.6245474219,
0.3858015239,
0.2148593068,
0.3677030206,
0.316737473,
-0.6251271963,
-0.6343610287,
-0.2847272754,
-0.2799021602,
-0.0365517288,
0.1039474905,
-0.0497414321,
0.6183895469,
-0.3476769924,
0.8669288158,
-0.6011503935,
-0.3291609585,
-0.6365087032,
0.1848434508,
0.1495195925,
0.3630764484,
0.7648011446,
-0.8231669664,
-0.7608962655,
0.0686929598,
-0.4324808419,
-0.1440053433,
0.1694261581,
-0.1220894977,
0.2494986802,
0.0050015752,
-0.7242526412,
0.1906011254,
0.6895077229,
-0.3317706585,
0.2523450255,
-0.1288902164,
-0.1826403439,
-1.2170356512,
-0.0245368592,
0.0821225569,
-0.3959178329,
-1.0852360725,
-0.137462765,
-0.1327632517,
0.1695335954,
-0.3799617887,
0.6157001853,
-0.4504753053,
0.1065402031,
-0.5739787817,
0.2479394674,
0.1354320347,
0.5908941031,
0.0008873526,
0.9800903201,
0.7011722922,
-0.8012953401,
0.2279171497,
0.2273142636,
-0.143766731,
0.6798749566,
-0.6101021767,
0.3632001579,
-0.1290754229,
0.2007392645,
-0.9428089261,
-0.0134561229,
0.2058668733,
-0.2500880957,
0.3069159389,
-0.1229969189,
-0.1936129481,
-0.5283491015,
-0.6840789318,
0.3449481726,
0.6612885594,
-1.0761129856,
0.711674273,
0.5987429619,
-0.0908940881,
-0.366093874,
-0.3547699451,
-0.0871036798,
-0.2299885303,
-0.2307267636,
0.3409671783,
-0.3727839589,
-0.1180812865,
-0.1331903636,
-0.2851673067,
-0.3344809711,
0.1787664145,
0.2904434502,
0.201302141,
-0.2289320827,
-0.2666682005,
0.1885939986,
-0.2221579999,
0.0901931077,
-0.3851011097,
0.4420897663,
-0.0461793356,
-0.1550249606,
-0.8008710742,
0.077997081,
0.6672195196,
-0.1288238764,
0.7698328495,
0.5298657417,
-0.2371108681,
-0.6140888333,
-0.3377089798,
-0.064195618,
-0.46814996,
0.2560276389,
-0.6707517505,
-0.7532380819,
0.4786781371,
-0.3981155455,
-0.1091039255,
0.4480139613,
0.5002137423,
-0.0468709841,
0.940525949,
0.7395992875,
-0.2278625518,
0.3831260204,
-0.4332756102,
0.3498540521,
-1.0436259508,
0.1467922479,
-0.4353323877,
-0.2121927589,
-0.4131622314,
-0.5393723249,
-0.0840021744,
0.2301892638,
0.0557231568,
0.4457941055,
-0.4211192429,
0.5402885675,
0.5904837251,
-0.0487905331,
0.3602398038,
0.034026593,
0.2533728778,
0.0748919919,
-0.5885590911,
-0.3021590412,
1.2755030394,
0.2111602724,
0.704998672,
0.1888417602,
0.4240153134,
0.4551899135,
0.3303558826,
-0.9214670062,
0.4713335335,
-0.5045056343,
-0.3172509372,
-0.0123603949,
-0.2180617154,
-0.7108384371,
0.4467987716,
0.2273136973,
-0.6745747924,
0.5808319449,
0.158511281,
-0.109399721,
0.3560660183,
-0.7388688326,
0.921408534,
0.1814983934,
0.0189702362,
-0.1837881655,
-0.495503217,
0.0897639394,
-0.2342036664,
-0.151242882,
-0.1148655564,
-0.0060883677,
0.951693058,
-0.24901703,
1.1029765606,
-0.6627392173,
0.0527977273,
0.3927647471,
-0.1989109814,
0.4013028741,
0.0629102364,
-0.0180250928,
0.2811819315,
-0.0818852484,
-0.4814893901,
-0.7029141188,
0.4681785703,
-0.8981859684,
-0.465598464,
-0.3718270957,
-0.6460284591,
-0.1957538277,
0.1074326336,
-0.10698919,
0.2659604549,
-0.4900543094,
0.1640502661,
0.5329276919,
0.2097115368,
0.5611048937,
0.7119148374,
0.0989047885,
-0.4326421916,
0.9160717726,
-0.2694015503,
0.2126987725,
0.5417867899,
0.0199626964,
-0.3016151488,
-0.8040924072,
-0.3929682076,
0.1928407997,
-0.7160534859,
-0.4287979901,
-0.6304117441,
-0.2817863226,
-0.3929688036,
-0.0916533172,
-0.3958658874,
-0.4846594632,
-0.303245306,
-0.0922962204,
0.5827537775,
0.5251079202,
0.0440029427,
0.7439172864,
-0.4030190706,
0.550424993,
0.4874290228,
0.2634512186,
-0.2997797728,
-0.8642711043,
-0.1344690472,
-0.0680619627,
-0.2397972047,
-0.4643905759,
0.3123772144,
0.6663566828,
0.5224818587,
0.5977346301,
0.3188588023,
0.6595380306,
-0.4132485688,
0.574491024,
-0.0412982665,
-0.9449699521,
0.4319226444,
0.073786974,
0.28120929,
0.6656343937,
0.3536881506,
-0.0360861123,
-0.1958170533,
-0.1439043283,
-0.5593344569,
0.8115849495,
0.05940447,
0.3579050303,
0.2099775821,
0.3712712526,
0.3113715649,
0.0767242759,
-0.4721744657,
-0.3888193071,
-0.3778400421,
-0.2998442054,
-0.2075442821,
-0.4177041352,
-0.2093995214,
-0.5615225434,
0.666459024,
-0.5658387542,
0.4450045526,
0.0793304592,
-0.566305697,
-0.1263039857,
0.3373928666,
0.4735949337,
0.8602208495,
-0.3734951317,
0.1851302236,
0.2307361215,
-0.8182654381,
0.0925708115,
0.4597009122,
-0.0904211178,
-0.011715373,
0.231548503,
1.0441949368,
-0.071375832,
-0.5150450468,
0.665941,
-0.321018219,
-0.2430989146,
-0.1089513153,
0.079016313,
0.036949005,
0.3068626523,
0.2210332453,
0.2398377657,
0.2085283846,
-0.3192870319,
0.1308863014,
0.3203900456,
-0.3073198199,
-0.7609328032,
0.6235615015,
0.3521000147,
-0.1006831899,
0.2539259791,
-0.1147130579,
-0.5610764623,
0.3266529441,
0.918083787,
1.2488059998,
-0.543407619,
0.3993057609,
-0.1275845766,
-0.0024590897,
0.0184353739,
0.3135620356,
-0.2461997718,
-1.0266337395,
-0.4605251849,
-0.7712916732,
-0.4325967431,
-0.189329505,
-0.71216923,
-0.1612695456,
-0.3156160116,
-0.1084715724,
0.1721273512,
0.0614245683,
-0.6299389005,
0.128987059,
-0.2362069786,
0.9933698177,
-0.8116198778,
1.1509206295,
1.1341632605,
-0.2127310932,
-0.3207079172,
0.1388393492,
-0.1828446239,
-0.7149218917,
0.5080714226,
0.1605674028,
-0.3045940101,
0.2983874679,
-0.1880539507,
-0.3634797335,
1.1278246641,
0.2586613297,
-0.3553714454,
0.3345450759,
0.0187369101,
0.656037569,
-0.4414451718,
-0.0539274924,
0.7324222922,
0.3371808529,
-0.1008132771,
-0.6883940697,
0.1060461849,
-0.3230209053,
0.3236584961,
0.0712424889,
-0.3785819113,
0.5003802776,
-0.3058125973,
-0.1760616899,
-0.0516733639,
0.7957150936,
-0.0570335723,
0.4750596881,
0.7894415855,
0.6029598117,
0.6417328119,
-0.0140661523,
0.8602129221,
-0.2770680487,
0.4402504265,
0.9438846707,
-0.5229973197,
1.032186985,
0.7039495707,
-0.4007124305,
0.6695560217,
0.261924237,
0.15432778,
0.7424614429,
-0.0362988263,
-0.4325323999,
-0.0440698043,
-0.0062780413,
-0.1294862181,
0.5469673276,
0.172889024,
-0.1295286268,
0.0276721399,
0.2025065571,
0.0700601041,
-0.0396422073,
-0.0900397599,
1.121514678,
0.2410277724,
-0.4340137541,
0.5528538227,
-0.0569021404,
0.6545679569,
-0.2799780667,
0.0276156627,
-0.3311481476,
0.644528091,
0.0131897116,
-0.6245618463,
0.1974273622,
-0.0065788585,
-0.2771819532,
-0.1676043868,
0.9943288565,
-0.2244878411,
-0.4250554144,
0.6234495044,
0.552990973,
-0.0784752294,
-0.2859914005,
-0.7065662742,
-0.0810569078,
-0.2485964596,
-0.5676232576,
0.3502527177,
0.2984528244,
0.1986051202,
0.5561810136,
0.6997434497,
0.0577069744,
0.0711560249,
0.4535435736,
1.061965704,
-0.5730844736,
-0.2102463543,
-0.6085668206,
0.6162111759,
-0.2151849121,
-0.1817236841,
0.7215181589,
0.3676266372,
0.9412718415,
-0.3660605252,
0.7758661509,
-0.0282804836,
0.3994364142,
-0.3733792007,
0.6688355207,
-0.4711943865,
0.1936444938,
-0.1510683298,
-1.150478363,
-0.5006220937,
0.5134219527,
-0.1207172126,
0.1200128719,
0.8295717835,
0.7251426578,
-0.2363304794,
-0.0532329492,
0.199761495,
0.2131905109,
0.1914529204,
0.2911245823,
0.6172252297,
-0.5965338349,
0.3619209826,
-0.6110121608,
-0.2892819047,
-0.2086308897,
-0.5853065252,
-1.2480695248,
-0.5978118777,
-0.4791630805,
-0.0980009511,
0.3564617932,
0.7269284725,
0.7789577246,
-1.1894760132,
-0.3433299363,
-0.201480031,
0.1766139716,
-0.5490849018,
-0.3156554997,
0.4354765713,
-0.4063857198,
-0.8889590502,
0.3974587917,
0.2903892994,
-0.2554920316,
-0.0247849021,
-0.1289039403,
-0.1116952226,
0.1485805213,
0.9128290415,
0.1455641091,
-0.5982988477,
-0.2677366436,
-0.2612729371,
0.125954479,
0.284099251,
0.8526212573,
-0.6881385446,
0.5192124844,
0.6113228798,
0.8417434692,
0.3028961718,
0.2394817919,
0.5570218563,
-0.5897253156,
0.0644093975,
-0.121026352,
0.2724263668,
0.2296396196,
-0.1011863574,
0.3422652185,
0.3792919219,
-0.6104445457,
-0.8351763487,
-0.0119324494,
-1.3682748079,
-0.2115656883,
0.9061485529,
-0.2223994881,
-0.3272489905,
-0.2541353703,
-0.2186137289,
0.1318475306,
-0.4286658764,
0.7934753895,
0.1032537743,
-0.1699545234,
-0.2323949039,
-0.4744755626,
0.5586666465,
0.1981581748,
-1.117020607,
0.0923289731,
0.070922114,
0.3609119356,
0.086579375,
0.6669440866,
0.0764151737,
0.2228113413,
-0.0721540153,
0.263335228,
0.1652371585,
-0.517398119,
-0.5728980899,
0.0733160451,
0.3418859839,
-0.5012969375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03183v1 | Capturing Topic Framing via Masked Language Modeling | 2023-02-07T01:23:14 | 2023-02-07T01:23:14 | Xiaobo Guo, Weicheng Ma, Soroush Vosoughi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Differential framing of issues can lead to divergent world views on important
issues. This is especially true in domains where the information presented can
reach a large audience, such as traditional and social media. Scalable and
reliable measurement of such differential framing is an important first step in
addressing them. In this work, based on the intuition that framing affects the
tone and word choices in written language, we propose a framework for modeling
the differential framing of issues through masked token prediction via
large-scale fine-tuned language models (LMs). Specifically, we explore three
key factors for our framework: 1) prompt generation methods for the masked
token prediction; 2) methods for normalizing the output of fine-tuned LMs; 3)
robustness to the choice of pre-trained LMs used for fine-tuning. Through
experiments on a dataset of articles from traditional media outlets covering
five diverse and politically polarized topics, we show that our framework can
capture differential framing of these topics with high reliability. | [
-0.8153934479,
-1.1104785204,
0.4819549918,
0.0922226086,
-0.4264282882,
0.3434402645,
-0.1712813079,
-0.1338747889,
0.5905707479,
0.6185726523,
-0.4755589664,
-0.5247240663,
-1.0203211308,
-0.0630086362,
-0.4085629582,
1.0208729506,
-0.0959847644,
0.1113197654,
0.2430010885,
0.0484442115,
-0.679053545,
-0.5382750034,
-0.3469847143,
-0.0304198172,
0.1949342787,
0.3152527511,
0.5885041356,
0.7627264857,
0.0966004208,
0.2070770264,
-0.4160908461,
0.059159264,
-0.4554811716,
0.0607604533,
-0.3513674736,
-0.4069970846,
-0.3783013225,
0.3147364259,
0.8404845595,
0.7889392376,
0.286303401,
0.2737680674,
0.1816024482,
0.4356632233,
-0.3895706832,
0.0187883377,
-0.9979410768,
0.1893234402,
-0.2476186007,
-0.0707677826,
-0.2922859192,
0.0911853611,
-0.185051173,
-0.0601413436,
0.3323551416,
-0.0176556036,
0.773399353,
0.1217229888,
-0.7063837051,
-0.2501347363,
-0.5469635725,
0.5663055182,
-0.5180347562,
0.0141236298,
0.5988363624,
0.0260914844,
0.0259424914,
-0.4195028543,
-0.456566602,
-0.0253519323,
0.0303390455,
-0.1749142855,
-0.3121642768,
-0.0950876921,
0.3613422811,
0.2865841687,
-0.2024636269,
0.0656380802,
-0.1850439906,
-0.2782806158,
0.5653843284,
0.3987177312,
0.2682790458,
-0.5249113441,
-0.2518511415,
0.398876071,
-0.5128023028,
-0.0965513662,
0.7027102709,
0.5088811517,
-0.2913299203,
0.6008832455,
-0.3484846354,
0.6918407083,
0.4954257607,
0.030642448,
-0.1657845825,
-0.1800721586,
0.0477035083,
0.0975257158,
0.3494770825,
0.6612380147,
0.0050770547,
0.1625409126,
-0.3639324307,
0.2497362345,
0.0622401871,
-0.7387214303,
0.1686640084,
0.1428328305,
-0.3183575869,
-0.3231726289,
0.1156601086,
-0.9563318491,
-0.6241864562,
-0.5272420645,
0.148761034,
0.1415263563,
-0.463095516,
0.2369742244,
-0.0825155675,
-0.0153809534,
0.2212821841,
-0.8204336762,
0.1441669166,
0.9840669036,
1.0079478025,
-0.3461817205,
0.2490707189,
-0.9110730886,
-0.0518875755,
-0.5077405572,
0.6361888647,
-0.7631854415,
-0.0041358527,
0.2850005031,
0.0693694651,
0.30275473,
-0.1557417214,
0.2798205018,
-0.7136365175,
0.1712387651,
-0.2960276306,
-0.5278842449,
0.2321817279,
0.5660419464,
-0.7430013418,
0.5991263986,
-0.2810759544,
-1.1515889168,
0.403424412,
-0.429944098,
-0.2356931269,
-0.0957453772,
-0.2354319096,
-0.4775314927,
0.2126601636,
0.4864673615,
0.7058641911,
-0.1261686236,
1.060407877,
-0.429763943,
-0.387085855,
0.2445863634,
-0.5526616573,
0.5215454698,
0.1364730448,
-0.6145218015,
0.1415310949,
-0.7248601913,
-0.5637248755,
-0.1343083829,
-0.0658001006,
-0.3758858144,
-0.0306752734,
0.1736153513,
0.1319583207,
0.0586873628,
-0.5235661268,
-0.0391118117,
-0.2262875885,
0.699059248,
0.8178463578,
0.1582267433,
0.5182839036,
-0.2199177742,
0.6758531332,
0.1497384757,
-0.3291076422,
-0.3819300532,
-0.4914609492,
-0.4713951647,
-0.4666191638,
0.4770419002,
0.2555890679,
-0.5434396267,
0.2771957815,
0.0206174627,
-0.0655337423,
-0.2405784726,
-0.1878023446,
0.2427722067,
0.3737235665,
0.0233539417,
-0.3387884796,
-0.3868281245,
-0.7137032151,
-0.4062438607,
0.099272579,
0.0782029331,
0.2996094823,
0.3794021606,
-0.1024585292,
1.0160415173,
-0.6027377248,
-0.158470422,
-0.2716223001,
0.5534239411,
0.158925131,
0.3948857486,
0.3924430013,
-1.0143507719,
-0.4775031209,
-0.3765713573,
-0.3547517061,
-0.3323316574,
-0.2266451716,
-0.1329196543,
0.3220169246,
0.861965239,
-0.3972318769,
0.3736785352,
0.6364023685,
-0.6124817729,
0.4699320495,
0.2745430768,
0.0870336741,
-1.4925167561,
0.0173757393,
0.1220479533,
-0.3324663043,
-0.4320961833,
-0.2951843441,
-0.1047039479,
-0.5228974223,
-0.446978569,
0.7943156362,
-0.4409142137,
0.0168098155,
-0.4348778427,
0.1818809509,
0.0624964833,
0.2541619837,
0.2199247777,
0.5305855274,
0.4670123458,
-0.2584034503,
0.1113289297,
0.0063545587,
-0.4566440582,
0.541082561,
-0.5596401691,
0.1343940198,
-0.4687456787,
0.3350777626,
-1.072052002,
-0.3798327148,
0.0941950977,
-0.2984085679,
0.5941527486,
-0.414357692,
-0.2169447094,
-0.0297132321,
-0.3843111992,
0.2370191664,
0.1381191909,
-0.2794662714,
0.2708705664,
0.8402739167,
-0.3156524897,
-0.7733150125,
-0.5805317163,
0.30761531,
-0.425837189,
-0.306848526,
0.4436616302,
0.2153866887,
-0.3661115766,
0.1116549224,
-0.1633608937,
-0.0190337803,
0.1568538249,
0.2526754141,
0.041210331,
-0.3687950373,
0.2848168612,
0.3105027378,
-0.3787203133,
-0.0680976436,
-0.3750694096,
0.7162418365,
-0.1611775309,
-0.4918334186,
-0.2738768458,
0.7534042001,
0.5771769881,
-0.3904498816,
0.7175238729,
0.5657934546,
-0.5322135687,
-0.2987274528,
-0.6531859636,
-0.2894079387,
-0.3908027411,
0.5553900599,
-0.2462395877,
-1.0973360538,
0.7128273249,
-0.0666733757,
-0.3300868273,
0.2846419513,
0.7259535193,
0.2005728036,
1.1334936619,
0.8759610057,
-0.21704036,
0.6668773293,
-0.0532206707,
0.1853968799,
-0.5794286132,
0.2219577581,
-0.4980610013,
-0.4343329072,
-0.4911200404,
-0.4171493948,
0.1466569602,
0.4105007946,
-0.1720073074,
0.1583060473,
-0.3754340708,
0.5939589143,
0.4846684635,
-0.1930404454,
0.3674557805,
0.1327196062,
-0.1506358683,
-0.1346938461,
-0.3856264651,
-0.9963104725,
0.7498269677,
0.6983376145,
0.6621370912,
-0.2787612379,
0.5316945314,
0.3815388381,
0.4622334838,
-0.4988789856,
0.4679600596,
-0.1738462299,
-1.0132857561,
-0.2719389796,
-0.1369325519,
-0.4866873622,
0.1549812108,
-0.2270210534,
-0.8778309226,
0.2037385404,
0.0569474474,
-0.1449592859,
0.5859065652,
-0.3302140236,
0.6597239971,
0.0865047723,
-0.3127279878,
-0.0519858859,
-0.5450001359,
0.2930980921,
-0.2885792553,
0.103878133,
-0.4637684226,
0.0643005446,
0.7257831097,
0.1199969724,
1.3943407536,
-0.1406481713,
-0.0461226441,
0.1976512074,
-0.0072604315,
0.0209504925,
0.6939801574,
-0.1466377378,
0.3306364715,
-0.024364315,
-0.2637293041,
-0.2899889648,
0.477835387,
-0.6418272257,
-0.8997748494,
-0.2743618786,
-0.4939149618,
-0.2831671834,
0.1419945061,
0.3134937882,
0.6087784767,
-0.2735829055,
0.1172412559,
0.4651448131,
-0.1150109321,
0.5301089883,
0.4383817017,
-0.2014482915,
-0.3637145758,
0.5682101846,
0.2733428776,
0.124876447,
0.5000573397,
0.1433208138,
-0.0632493868,
-0.563116014,
-0.6100621223,
-0.0459084101,
-0.7783837914,
-0.5822179317,
-0.6919247508,
-0.1398569196,
-0.0603630506,
-0.3019864261,
-0.4839444757,
-0.2785672843,
-0.4645989239,
-0.340508312,
0.1807931066,
0.5400071144,
-0.1946224272,
0.0271620527,
-0.6875431538,
0.3671678901,
0.2512400746,
0.4828033745,
-0.2158249021,
-0.453286469,
0.0568248406,
0.238324821,
-0.2960111499,
-0.9966832399,
0.2904732823,
-0.1014842466,
0.5199255347,
0.3301225007,
0.4823771119,
0.3220772743,
-0.4960659742,
0.9279385805,
0.0437260121,
-1.2681691647,
0.7909231782,
-0.5209211707,
-0.0125343567,
0.5365870595,
0.5111157894,
-0.4637126327,
-0.6833174229,
-0.2653627098,
-0.7173687816,
0.6312295198,
-0.1825117022,
0.8746439219,
-0.4256736636,
0.3066370785,
0.2336055338,
0.351226002,
-0.8562732339,
0.0660216957,
-0.203648746,
-0.1431089044,
-0.099997282,
-0.4488028884,
-0.3590394855,
-0.116556935,
0.4024793208,
-0.4102445841,
0.1793695092,
0.1206247434,
0.0367149152,
-0.130288437,
0.2166694999,
0.775967896,
0.5145245194,
-0.1779344827,
0.3459673524,
-0.0698823482,
-0.4234902263,
0.1179014295,
-0.0143508269,
-0.2981745005,
0.188448742,
0.408659339,
1.0789438486,
-0.0858207121,
-0.4204238355,
0.5300651193,
0.0323079228,
-0.208108902,
0.0754724592,
-0.3287790716,
0.1857807785,
0.4466290772,
0.2974727452,
-0.1135947704,
-0.1881634593,
-0.6250199676,
0.410535872,
0.5724850893,
-0.7009159923,
-0.3235704005,
0.6920977235,
0.338427186,
-0.435793221,
0.1853608191,
-0.2915710211,
-0.7291177511,
0.6302142739,
0.6624889374,
0.8967279792,
0.1193942502,
0.4849217832,
0.1236576885,
0.138499558,
0.0197856892,
-0.2088952214,
-0.0109915342,
-0.8123142719,
-0.4346961975,
-0.7958831787,
-0.293663919,
0.2300716192,
-0.6852074862,
0.4183661342,
-0.301710099,
-0.5186523199,
-0.0053816116,
0.3435667753,
-0.2621484101,
0.1270104647,
0.620478034,
0.8277384639,
-1.1787638664,
0.6346477866,
0.6438907981,
-0.1726068407,
-0.5565332174,
0.4514646828,
0.1565736234,
-0.6122313142,
0.675239265,
0.3592413366,
-0.1570806801,
-0.2449464947,
-0.4555889964,
-0.6923522949,
0.8252030015,
0.6772530675,
-0.5089020133,
0.078239955,
0.3791748285,
0.3285169303,
-0.8435598016,
-0.1164147332,
0.3090931773,
0.160778597,
0.0333919972,
-0.8766154051,
0.1411449015,
-0.1766885966,
0.151790753,
0.1928877681,
-0.4717159867,
0.9049883485,
0.1421609372,
-0.2092897892,
-0.3962395489,
0.370546788,
-0.0252988338,
0.6132479906,
0.3292341828,
0.0930995569,
0.5664247274,
0.0213669259,
0.7319577932,
-0.5398581624,
0.385843873,
0.7983294725,
-0.2155590057,
0.7866749167,
0.4830107093,
0.2656083405,
0.1088713035,
0.5466545224,
0.1278369129,
0.6802561283,
0.3048564494,
-0.0675008222,
-0.1702271849,
-0.2667207122,
-0.3706998825,
0.6811910868,
0.4029327929,
-0.4099407494,
-0.2771903872,
0.2970277965,
0.0926486403,
0.4766663909,
-0.4296170771,
0.6787999868,
0.2205592841,
-0.6530481577,
0.3850541413,
0.3890907466,
0.8107298613,
-0.221897155,
0.1361996233,
-0.442830503,
-0.110017769,
0.0618117228,
-0.7106765509,
0.8060358763,
0.1158771962,
-0.2998550236,
-0.4417749941,
0.9943907261,
-0.4294261336,
-0.5987529159,
0.1159747019,
0.5390787721,
-0.3986968696,
-0.1063334048,
-0.402125299,
0.4794229865,
-0.1446020901,
-0.4120507538,
0.4652660191,
0.477470845,
-0.3169752359,
0.1736235917,
0.378285706,
0.0327837467,
-0.115887329,
-0.1217026711,
0.8717865348,
-0.6138231158,
-0.6923449636,
-0.9004281163,
0.6127410531,
-0.2632585764,
-0.4049901366,
0.3042790294,
0.151157707,
0.6158149242,
-0.0107912365,
0.528706193,
0.3496614695,
0.3895177841,
-0.7436515093,
0.9999992847,
-0.3453998566,
0.3894376457,
-0.3900617063,
-0.8633362055,
-0.4668115377,
0.5946162939,
-0.5270375013,
-0.2693356872,
0.2360099107,
0.8147525191,
-0.2124702334,
0.0838677734,
0.2207913995,
-0.0651314333,
0.31931445,
0.131220907,
0.7455345988,
0.0017074839,
0.1663176864,
0.0002493262,
-0.2052723467,
-0.2562898993,
-1.2596969604,
-1.1677997112,
-0.8963371515,
-0.6654080749,
-0.2780483067,
0.0052672392,
0.6919508576,
0.9441322088,
-0.6672669649,
0.1509134471,
-0.1472621262,
0.4070343673,
0.2504833341,
-0.2099976242,
0.3810157478,
-0.289246738,
-0.7511552572,
-0.2793183625,
0.3759227097,
-0.1072064936,
-0.3716752827,
0.4211820364,
0.1377622485,
0.373187542,
0.4740308523,
-0.0549923927,
-0.7821053863,
-0.4439263642,
-0.1134548932,
-0.2562167645,
-0.0190059748,
0.9515524507,
-0.5634208322,
0.3567039073,
0.3483775258,
0.8184195757,
0.611684978,
0.1223044842,
0.7400688529,
-1.0034415722,
0.3871449828,
0.3406631052,
0.2117656618,
0.4498770833,
-0.3690718114,
0.0248212684,
0.1637339592,
-0.0560402945,
-1.0993630886,
0.4956856072,
-0.6443722248,
-0.3964944184,
1.1819306612,
-0.096560508,
0.1314969659,
-0.2609662712,
-0.2850601375,
0.2283511162,
-0.105119817,
0.8376168013,
0.902327776,
0.304207176,
-0.1949471682,
-0.6014842987,
0.3971485794,
0.2835205197,
-0.4563423991,
0.1092362404,
0.4042226076,
0.2678505778,
0.2805781662,
0.8210321665,
-0.0914308205,
-0.1939941943,
0.1112062857,
-0.5353073478,
-0.1394588351,
-0.2638700604,
-0.4329569042,
0.4875530005,
-0.1508498341,
-0.1518417746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06474v1 | Applying BERT and ChatGPT for Sentiment Analysis of Lyme Disease in Scientific Literature | 2023-02-07T01:15:05 | 2023-02-07T01:15:05 | Teo Susnjak | cs.CL | cs.CL | This chapter presents a practical guide for conducting Sentiment Analysis
using Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques in the domain of tick-borne
disease text. The aim is to demonstrate the process of how the presence of bias
in the discourse surrounding chronic manifestations of the disease can be
evaluated. The goal is to use a dataset of 5643 abstracts collected from
scientific journals on the topic of chronic Lyme disease to demonstrate using
Python, the steps for conducting sentiment analysis using pre-trained language
models and the process of validating the preliminary results using both
interpretable machine learning tools, as well as a novel methodology of using
emerging state-of-the-art large language models like ChatGPT. This serves as a
useful resource for researchers and practitioners interested in using NLP
techniques for sentiment analysis in the medical domain. | [
-0.2987620831,
-0.8685450554,
0.4918422699,
0.2666420937,
-0.4038137496,
0.14243038,
-0.2121645659,
-0.6275901794,
0.564365387,
0.351878345,
-0.3092178702,
-0.5854970217,
-0.4488564134,
-0.0266607404,
-0.2052799463,
1.5482907295,
0.2347649783,
0.5995960236,
-0.2378465384,
-0.1003915742,
-0.0318241045,
-0.9213667512,
-1.0013792515,
-0.3854331672,
0.7324367166,
-0.0296133216,
0.7802042961,
-0.3414026499,
0.6107673645,
0.1281075031,
-0.4210161269,
-0.0462538674,
-0.1756759137,
0.3495442867,
-0.0794258639,
-0.1199706495,
-0.4588848054,
0.2397884578,
0.428786099,
0.855189383,
0.1811626256,
0.1273424923,
0.1025129929,
0.7247334719,
0.2400159836,
0.1856158972,
-0.1568124294,
0.351331979,
-0.4239701629,
-0.2832886577,
-0.5838062167,
-0.7808172703,
0.501036942,
-0.2415727079,
0.1342980862,
0.1230736822,
0.9327377677,
-0.0169352926,
-0.4750348628,
-0.3517552912,
-0.1543415189,
0.7346461415,
-0.9318380356,
0.0698734969,
0.080587104,
0.0484313108,
-0.2151799649,
-0.9403888583,
-0.2150854915,
-0.6848296523,
0.0051058121,
0.0728882328,
-0.2454559356,
0.2059199959,
0.2093600333,
0.4299907386,
-0.7656026483,
-0.1354395449,
-0.6141722202,
-0.2166128904,
0.4689176679,
-0.1682739109,
0.4338112473,
-0.3795079887,
-0.3621601164,
0.5065892339,
-0.4608888626,
0.2103682011,
0.1789282262,
0.3015637398,
0.217896536,
0.4437030852,
0.2483857572,
0.8838140965,
-0.1864027977,
0.0769353658,
0.3400623798,
-0.0784641057,
-0.1025253832,
0.0564238839,
0.6119355559,
0.671582818,
0.0826194361,
-0.2342699319,
0.0476232655,
-0.0120761832,
0.591014266,
-0.5677044988,
-0.3980913162,
0.6256194711,
-0.8087112904,
-0.33679986,
-0.473490566,
-0.8599172235,
-0.5759271383,
-0.3956248164,
0.1747875512,
-0.6522611976,
-0.3724322319,
0.0114152301,
-0.6707695127,
0.4132530391,
0.1627006829,
-0.4417714179,
0.4729785323,
0.6106308699,
0.807334125,
-0.456025511,
0.1808941215,
-0.1550538689,
-0.3603602946,
-0.1471443772,
0.9504213929,
-0.3490893841,
-0.240640372,
0.105076693,
-0.2591139674,
-0.0872232318,
-0.4126078486,
0.8368023038,
-0.5251572132,
0.0227139667,
-0.1908735484,
-0.6915473938,
-0.4595818818,
0.3017438054,
-0.6679978967,
0.9599695206,
0.321288079,
-1.0978069305,
0.1556098163,
-0.7806111574,
-0.4387765825,
0.0187404696,
0.3129751384,
-0.4367625117,
0.3351902962,
-0.0280730687,
0.5085479021,
0.0240732171,
0.2423046976,
-0.4516589642,
0.2353473902,
0.5436472893,
-0.0686507598,
0.9962001443,
0.3423022628,
0.0587392896,
0.2432007194,
-0.338380903,
0.2490808964,
-0.1027339101,
-0.1083714366,
-0.376247853,
0.4712017775,
0.3567484617,
-0.1660060138,
0.3998188972,
-0.5591626167,
0.7748872638,
-0.7176375985,
0.4795340896,
0.3914400041,
0.5460468531,
0.098672986,
-0.4578770995,
0.3832012117,
0.0020623626,
0.4018149972,
0.1755361259,
-0.9964753985,
-0.6726015806,
-0.0530847386,
0.5367492437,
0.5652705431,
-0.7174052596,
0.385350734,
0.0283170585,
-0.4663918018,
-0.6990022659,
-0.2648079395,
-0.119178541,
0.472725153,
0.3896636069,
-0.4907478094,
-0.508439064,
-0.9356328845,
-0.4400786161,
0.1548876613,
0.2889845967,
-0.0543003082,
0.4078417122,
-0.2243716419,
0.8498174548,
-0.552146256,
-0.2416420132,
-0.2972601652,
0.6308555007,
0.4750539064,
0.4346275926,
0.639082253,
-0.6427889466,
-0.6850776672,
0.2614942491,
-0.5994141698,
-0.1791074574,
0.1086086854,
0.0743818656,
0.4784929454,
0.4387729168,
-0.4499716461,
0.4467220306,
0.5937540531,
-0.3877966106,
0.7056702375,
0.0669131428,
-0.021785602,
-0.763753891,
0.0588211715,
0.2790360749,
-0.6878460646,
-0.7766286731,
0.3723013103,
-0.53236413,
-0.0488588437,
-0.2114095539,
0.0854395851,
-0.2680989802,
0.2072212249,
-0.2641126215,
0.2507790327,
-0.1100666597,
0.0583870225,
0.0330022536,
0.3909613788,
0.7615712285,
-0.3464537263,
0.5482312441,
-0.1357388943,
-0.1859371066,
0.4229384363,
-0.632804811,
-0.1472073495,
-0.2219215333,
0.1908809841,
-0.8611957431,
0.1498605609,
0.3703232706,
-0.895434618,
0.3726451695,
-0.1850860715,
-0.4226830304,
-0.4281726778,
-0.4976707995,
-0.1296191514,
0.5919339657,
-0.1140361875,
0.4505209327,
0.552990973,
-0.441149801,
-0.5008174181,
-0.6165120602,
0.1254215091,
-0.3079125285,
-0.4451052845,
0.2596248388,
-0.1270711571,
-0.3486435115,
0.0864725932,
-0.0146389008,
-0.5081602335,
-0.0803726912,
-0.0087171532,
0.0745252296,
-0.0759828985,
0.3063098192,
-0.1728617847,
-0.0188583396,
0.1712167859,
-0.0887515023,
0.7329295278,
-0.2189846933,
-0.245867908,
-0.2810933292,
0.6144613028,
0.3112109601,
0.0902846009,
0.2975057662,
0.6557186246,
-0.1291619241,
0.0054452629,
-0.2688173056,
-0.1206595674,
-0.3241811395,
0.2664364874,
0.1467697322,
-0.533980906,
0.3300483227,
-0.221094802,
0.170305416,
0.3400059342,
0.7032648325,
-0.4646757245,
0.7576047182,
0.6995403767,
-0.4316992462,
0.2326861024,
0.070460774,
0.455960691,
-0.7389956117,
0.1696037948,
-0.6363262534,
-0.1898133904,
-0.6689120531,
-0.5976466537,
0.6987762451,
-0.0484139472,
0.0554139353,
-0.1985435337,
-0.9413580894,
0.141192019,
0.8236556053,
0.4893789589,
0.1214559004,
0.0894816667,
-0.1816502512,
-0.3053795993,
-0.7349763513,
-0.6198384762,
0.9737483263,
0.4671207666,
0.4253985286,
-0.097080864,
0.724260211,
0.7554879189,
0.8330608606,
-1.3244762421,
0.3506611288,
-0.0657935515,
-0.8345660567,
-0.2252096534,
-0.099922061,
-1.3055386543,
0.1736605465,
-0.0231142435,
-0.9635176063,
-0.1288615316,
0.0875897557,
-0.0862108245,
0.1773956418,
-0.6702170968,
0.7855061293,
-0.1599915922,
0.0341235064,
-0.2274243683,
-0.812138021,
0.5084224343,
0.1578922868,
0.195697546,
-0.0551230013,
0.0915824175,
0.8091298938,
-0.3067069352,
1.1938436031,
-0.2809204161,
0.0566372089,
0.4034208357,
-0.2187734842,
0.0585304387,
0.0901246816,
-0.3233302534,
0.2437387705,
0.4775228202,
-0.3726523817,
-0.1818805486,
0.5078928471,
-0.7420723438,
-0.4501440227,
-1.1022170782,
-0.3551057279,
-0.3040589392,
0.040085528,
0.0931039378,
0.287442714,
-0.4006713927,
-0.0676962137,
0.7317944169,
-0.3854953945,
0.4484898746,
0.3470813036,
-0.4789867103,
-0.4161120951,
0.9027674794,
0.0780367851,
0.1379445344,
0.2295973301,
0.3825341761,
-0.195609957,
-0.4995178282,
-0.2089618295,
0.1555282474,
-0.7396587729,
-0.1551691592,
-0.2710330486,
-0.4733786881,
-0.4072518647,
-0.0489239767,
-0.0175073911,
-0.4002518058,
-0.1481223702,
0.0857110545,
0.7296481729,
0.6792755723,
0.0070304102,
0.4886975288,
-0.8329174519,
0.301455766,
0.0338137783,
0.1842101365,
-0.0594900139,
-0.3371122181,
-0.1779226214,
0.0123361675,
-0.5322678089,
-1.3716224432,
0.7537321448,
0.1625015885,
0.6160663366,
0.1981790811,
0.1188423857,
0.3043687046,
-0.3186326325,
1.183234334,
0.2455757111,
-0.9662443399,
0.6400678158,
-0.4108034372,
0.0069880849,
0.1865341812,
0.96158427,
-0.7360106707,
-0.4802126884,
-0.7644848824,
-1.0020312071,
0.3453597724,
0.0460012555,
-0.2190176547,
0.0636657551,
0.2885909975,
-0.0289503746,
0.0729711577,
-1.0883741379,
-0.4568745196,
-0.1480704695,
-0.2548498511,
0.0120134428,
-0.4152965248,
-0.5336746573,
-0.5581042171,
0.7291530967,
-0.1936285049,
0.621602416,
0.579665184,
-0.1614399403,
0.1788229495,
0.2085640877,
0.4267323017,
0.6598917842,
-0.3918642402,
0.0063695381,
0.0116711613,
-0.6069290638,
-0.2358184308,
0.2209536284,
-0.3058120012,
0.4354321361,
0.3262624145,
0.3416552842,
-0.0535702221,
-0.4459570646,
0.6740754843,
0.2119778395,
-0.1229592711,
-0.4823084474,
-0.3509576619,
0.2613868713,
0.1353995651,
0.3194945455,
0.1199955568,
0.4707660675,
-0.348346293,
0.2437277585,
0.655649066,
-0.6744430065,
-0.2871194482,
0.0430309959,
0.0974930376,
-0.0020546878,
0.5865459442,
-0.0014165402,
-0.4778119624,
0.6614841819,
0.4764241278,
0.7157721519,
-0.1679048687,
0.3229752779,
0.187544927,
0.4464678168,
0.3639883697,
0.5736647844,
0.3429361284,
-0.4885025918,
-0.6726605892,
-0.7377830148,
-0.5569072962,
-0.0061411937,
-0.8310221434,
0.339746505,
-0.3542590141,
-0.6604571342,
0.5647072792,
-0.0404161811,
-0.1242123917,
0.1595606506,
0.1338200569,
0.9084483385,
-0.7381423116,
1.0008997917,
0.9832659364,
-0.6701337099,
-0.4349090457,
0.0835829377,
0.0022044135,
-0.8580597639,
0.6321133971,
-0.0172854234,
0.2593691647,
-0.2174338251,
-0.890825808,
-0.6210614443,
0.3287338614,
-0.2167785764,
-0.2099813223,
0.2814775407,
-0.1190477163,
0.7370444536,
-0.0881960467,
0.1835203469,
0.5283660889,
0.6736838222,
-0.1603555381,
-0.8965879083,
-0.2323105484,
-0.0515834428,
-0.3285390735,
0.0790477768,
-0.3745657206,
0.7393559217,
0.0992325321,
0.1656867415,
-0.0108558582,
0.5680157542,
0.1486508846,
0.3620189726,
0.2081893384,
0.4380051494,
0.8547157645,
-0.3518921137,
1.022708416,
-0.5953231454,
0.4532510638,
0.4483386278,
-0.0602841824,
0.9236828089,
0.6082527637,
-0.3826090395,
0.4899364412,
0.7549884319,
0.005811437,
0.326322794,
0.7253996134,
-0.5838533044,
0.0360966511,
-0.0603850596,
-0.565268755,
0.1070103422,
0.7307143807,
-0.3897235394,
-0.305694133,
0.2034695894,
0.3414290547,
-0.0615961738,
-0.5729899406,
0.7991555333,
0.2979011238,
-0.5773783326,
0.5608855486,
-0.0137658492,
0.6458477974,
-0.8346960545,
-0.1065510511,
0.0711678192,
0.1608878374,
-0.4042180479,
-1.0197179317,
0.8554953933,
-0.1404701918,
-0.4856566489,
-0.1987769455,
0.9003761411,
-0.0701488405,
-0.5123195052,
-0.0667994469,
0.4517254829,
0.5997810364,
-0.0531898402,
-0.8437221646,
0.0261036251,
0.2193235904,
-0.4754260182,
0.3660063446,
0.4332991838,
-0.1614878029,
0.7828836441,
0.5245913267,
0.5066642761,
-0.1102018207,
0.0514449216,
0.9687866569,
-0.8745951653,
0.0317125432,
-0.8812593818,
0.4384592474,
-0.4276907444,
-0.1219291687,
0.7837365866,
0.4087912738,
-0.0085695209,
-0.4422305524,
1.0841317177,
-0.3357753456,
0.8983951807,
-0.3319751918,
0.7605760098,
-0.2539433539,
-0.305352509,
-0.2231447399,
-0.2950657904,
-0.6622125506,
0.7784398794,
-0.2041200101,
-0.1709771156,
1.1457731724,
0.4843306243,
0.3779693246,
0.0483756736,
-0.1507948935,
0.482555002,
0.273278296,
0.3527520299,
0.8929209709,
-0.1418558359,
0.0719780326,
-0.0700635836,
-0.4288519621,
-0.2232512385,
-1.1759722233,
-0.8282868862,
-0.3128021955,
-0.5435559154,
-0.6252120733,
0.2774025202,
1.0050916672,
0.6202225089,
-0.8362593651,
-0.069796674,
0.1804549992,
0.3947322369,
-0.7085174918,
-0.3396498561,
0.5784190297,
-0.9302427173,
-0.5876374841,
0.0181765426,
0.0521888621,
-0.1011200547,
-0.2544668317,
0.5120390654,
-0.1836272627,
-0.0748569071,
0.9865032434,
0.3873657584,
-0.7800462246,
-0.2130325437,
-0.3263842762,
-0.1382358968,
0.1300661564,
0.7409605384,
-0.8315294981,
0.3029380441,
0.3598967791,
0.3453351557,
0.3577667177,
-0.1167618558,
0.6892480254,
-0.6976869106,
0.0058285412,
0.7714609504,
0.261674732,
0.1465753019,
-0.2982002497,
0.4236137867,
0.3470743895,
-0.8991371989,
-0.6687402129,
0.0928490385,
-1.7125487328,
-0.4945506752,
1.0331311226,
-0.1664254367,
-0.2738464773,
-0.5068422556,
-0.834987998,
0.1333136708,
-0.4120444059,
0.7549754381,
0.6302313209,
-0.4822534025,
-0.137963444,
-1.0499562025,
0.8252005577,
0.0830201134,
-0.7340407968,
-0.0814990029,
0.2596009076,
0.2172942162,
-0.0024117779,
0.7503753304,
-0.2603145838,
-0.0645460933,
-0.1660103351,
0.5758466125,
0.4235627055,
0.3711894453,
-0.1821709275,
0.2238049358,
0.3983807564,
0.0685161501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03169v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03169v3 | Data Selection for Language Models via Importance Resampling | 2023-02-06T23:57:56 | 2023-11-18T21:33:01 | Sang Michael Xie, Shibani Santurkar, Tengyu Ma, Percy Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Selecting a suitable pretraining dataset is crucial for both general-domain
(e.g., GPT-3) and domain-specific (e.g., Codex) language models (LMs). We
formalize this problem as selecting a subset of a large raw unlabeled dataset
to match a desired target distribution given unlabeled target samples. Due to
the scale and dimensionality of the raw text data, existing methods use simple
heuristics or require human experts to manually curate data. Instead, we extend
the classic importance resampling approach used in low-dimensions for LM data
selection. We propose Data Selection with Importance Resampling (DSIR), an
efficient and scalable framework that estimates importance weights in a reduced
feature space for tractability and selects data with importance resampling
according to these weights. We instantiate the DSIR framework with hashed
n-gram features for efficiency, enabling the selection of 100M documents from
the full Pile dataset in 4.5 hours. To measure whether hashed n-gram features
preserve the aspects of the data that are relevant to the target, we define KL
reduction, a data metric that measures the proximity between the selected
pretraining data and the target on some feature space. Across 8 data selection
methods (including expert selection), KL reduction on hashed n-gram features
highly correlates with average downstream accuracy (r=0.82). When selecting
data for continued pretraining on a specific domain, DSIR performs comparably
to expert curation across 8 target distributions. When pretraining
general-domain models (target is Wikipedia and books), DSIR improves over
random selection and heuristic filtering baselines by 2-2.5% on the GLUE
benchmark. Code is available at https://github.com/p-lambda/dsir. | [
-0.6151302457,
-0.3895786405,
0.5921553969,
-0.2115202546,
-0.2827267349,
-0.0970337987,
-0.2153456956,
-0.3099064231,
0.1767033637,
0.4591034055,
-0.3559235632,
-0.4448757172,
-0.712544322,
-0.1132151932,
-0.4429797232,
1.1304017305,
0.1786679178,
-0.0551179424,
-0.4007563889,
-0.0993125662,
-0.1092278957,
-0.5304960012,
-0.4059221148,
-0.2799317837,
0.5826402307,
0.4019559324,
0.5450849533,
0.6651775241,
0.803799808,
0.1627601832,
-0.3010219038,
-0.0181303658,
-0.6121287346,
0.2269373089,
-0.0658957511,
-0.2311376333,
-0.3132330179,
0.0644458681,
0.7507738471,
0.8559112549,
0.1913177371,
0.4355551898,
-0.0800701901,
1.0010877848,
-0.914020896,
0.1196423396,
-0.5706418753,
-0.1200113595,
-0.4383893013,
-0.3030897379,
-0.2147871107,
-0.3737363815,
0.1525577456,
-0.2329709083,
0.3782539964,
0.0060084499,
0.813785255,
0.5599271059,
-0.1604491323,
-0.1017052084,
-0.7086213231,
1.023419857,
-0.6153028607,
0.6526603103,
0.8316229582,
0.201815635,
-0.108400546,
-0.6751281023,
-0.1796416491,
-0.1191302836,
-0.0747978315,
-0.0992388949,
0.0903936997,
0.2339073271,
0.3082593083,
0.5097965002,
-0.3542127609,
-0.0079191374,
-0.7071305513,
-0.1209406704,
0.5525506139,
-0.1616721153,
0.223768428,
0.1539532989,
-0.0395889916,
-0.3594900966,
-0.675568223,
-0.0375186056,
0.519669354,
0.3321626484,
0.3634087443,
0.2838046849,
-0.2155060321,
0.8633659482,
0.1060373709,
-0.4442394376,
0.3463313282,
-0.17839396,
-0.1167574674,
-0.0447142385,
0.4601781368,
0.1768614799,
0.0811361074,
-0.155324921,
-0.38551265,
-0.2428072989,
0.4748246968,
-0.9378175735,
-0.2563649118,
0.4019432366,
-0.6059769988,
-0.2533962131,
-0.1581247747,
-0.6947947741,
-0.0817879438,
-0.3434269726,
0.2726974189,
-0.2292056531,
-0.2300778627,
0.106110245,
-0.0903960019,
-0.0980278924,
0.1396987736,
-1.040009141,
0.2968222797,
0.4011866152,
0.557790339,
-0.2033929825,
-0.1959853619,
-0.4109077752,
-0.0155815724,
-0.3465848565,
0.8152826428,
-0.7195982933,
-0.2383264154,
-0.3143545985,
-0.2116607726,
-0.1138598397,
-0.3534083664,
0.7903783917,
-0.828564465,
-0.1576581895,
-0.1895657033,
-0.5046771765,
-0.33785218,
0.0719548613,
-0.9742745757,
1.2155168056,
0.3995255828,
-0.9498972893,
0.730412066,
-0.4046596289,
-0.590770185,
-0.0622309893,
-0.152789861,
-0.703778863,
0.1206742674,
0.1379762292,
0.4646863043,
-0.4362237155,
0.1550878435,
-0.5224823952,
-0.3693005741,
-0.0334235393,
-0.2568171024,
0.3447232246,
0.4472812712,
-0.1852700859,
-0.1710688621,
-0.7511636019,
0.5326273441,
-0.1011495143,
-0.5062257648,
-0.4300075471,
0.1748254448,
0.3014969826,
0.1884535551,
0.0419736132,
-0.1214403212,
0.2205756605,
-0.1412401795,
0.3723912835,
0.3189234138,
0.0767287388,
0.5422919989,
-0.2416490465,
0.6733469963,
-0.2763361633,
0.0831136405,
0.273912847,
-0.2453293651,
-0.5402465463,
-0.3414703906,
0.6935629249,
0.1635404676,
-0.3880763352,
0.5467643738,
-0.5306639671,
-0.4942595959,
-0.7107352614,
0.126543805,
0.3860040605,
-0.0346511379,
0.3689338267,
-0.3050848246,
-0.4736759365,
-0.9881737828,
0.0308889467,
-0.2267253399,
0.0908166319,
0.2530033588,
0.2264940292,
-0.1845986694,
1.1616059542,
-0.686362505,
-0.350181669,
-0.5410357118,
0.0470542088,
0.0739073902,
0.1389511973,
0.8187676668,
-1.0831241608,
-0.5800836086,
-0.1255176961,
-0.2587255836,
-0.3636650741,
0.0937351361,
0.0866393298,
0.1321514249,
0.6289130449,
-0.3956645131,
0.4986654222,
0.5690674186,
0.1125722975,
0.1989204437,
-0.3077988029,
0.3794694543,
-0.8548603654,
0.4373239577,
-0.2546906769,
-0.1808006018,
-0.8318203092,
-0.200474605,
0.1858834475,
-0.0379693359,
-0.2923848927,
0.6097273827,
-0.7044158578,
-0.3547619581,
-0.2797087431,
0.024918003,
-0.0323975496,
0.3568967879,
0.2495399565,
0.6202996969,
0.4130916297,
-0.644474864,
-0.3354150057,
0.1177534312,
-0.5146253109,
0.0927807093,
-0.4195898771,
0.2096324116,
-0.0837958902,
-0.0432920493,
-0.8682528734,
0.0008407873,
-0.0791468993,
-0.3791760802,
0.4984239936,
-0.4268292487,
-0.3684633076,
-0.266444087,
-0.2310978919,
0.5855650306,
0.424366951,
-0.2297121435,
0.2210643589,
0.8596379757,
-0.2153764814,
-0.6319960952,
-0.4582760036,
-0.088363722,
-0.2426266223,
-0.2291931957,
0.3317285776,
-0.1681248993,
-0.1305036396,
0.0960249007,
-0.2408126146,
-0.2951839566,
0.2538339496,
0.2040432096,
-0.1063966155,
0.0988975838,
0.2227371186,
0.0747871399,
-0.3480236828,
-0.3607463539,
-0.1700083017,
0.3994030654,
0.2013098896,
-0.4940074086,
-0.0527742691,
0.2018567175,
0.7690538764,
-0.2500807941,
0.6182301641,
0.6828673482,
-0.2703081667,
-0.2490689456,
-0.6809880137,
-0.2355946451,
-0.3368757665,
0.6014102697,
-0.2649596334,
-0.8207117915,
0.191329807,
0.1690808982,
-0.0902476609,
0.2844887674,
0.3884084523,
0.2655355036,
0.887816906,
0.8291108012,
-0.6270107627,
0.7023360729,
-0.2528686523,
0.5951547027,
-0.7194627523,
0.4484139681,
-0.6408435702,
-0.3768447936,
-0.3284564018,
-0.3386273682,
0.3172849119,
0.230945006,
0.1855020076,
0.1853012592,
-0.4469661713,
0.650752902,
0.4978887737,
-0.0871993229,
0.0522594452,
0.2095759362,
0.3112907708,
-0.1140868142,
-0.5907534361,
-0.3896651268,
1.2534826994,
0.2314706743,
0.5958499312,
-0.0292111039,
0.682755053,
0.3647233248,
0.1484509557,
-0.817106843,
0.3731016219,
-0.3042084277,
-0.6266954541,
-0.5851768255,
-0.4888649583,
-0.8997359276,
0.1240474656,
-0.1519979089,
-0.4898585081,
0.1875035912,
0.0809885263,
-0.4593043923,
0.324280858,
-0.6362837553,
0.6012017727,
-0.0352408327,
0.107600823,
-0.3390142322,
-0.5578302145,
0.0275015626,
-0.5101911426,
0.2556572556,
-0.1736897379,
0.173154369,
0.8247393966,
-0.2833117843,
0.6247620583,
-0.2516848147,
0.1665503234,
0.2094244659,
-0.1297267526,
0.3335052133,
-0.2258731723,
-0.2237390727,
0.2493983209,
0.1014006659,
-0.1651135683,
-0.5589189529,
0.4785616994,
-0.7033564448,
-0.505613327,
-0.2156945169,
-0.468534112,
-0.0252788775,
0.3885293007,
0.2234217823,
0.5682509542,
-0.0802346319,
0.4721142352,
0.4894205034,
0.0753132254,
0.2869229913,
0.4121977389,
0.0949911028,
-0.4018025696,
0.8950118423,
0.5664530993,
0.5816757083,
0.4957142174,
0.0186976939,
-0.2446785569,
-1.0454494953,
-0.1559574604,
0.0275872089,
-0.8012750149,
-0.226352483,
-0.8771653771,
-0.5477637053,
-0.4070803523,
-0.1966087818,
-0.4554755986,
-0.5369072556,
-0.0530033968,
-0.0693782941,
0.4004781246,
0.6313236952,
-0.141882509,
0.1716426611,
-0.8517001867,
0.4158842266,
0.2012215555,
0.3321042359,
-0.1261328757,
-0.622836411,
-0.565979898,
-0.1259387732,
-0.0354502164,
-0.4460208714,
0.590778172,
0.4355806112,
0.8524890542,
0.2894944847,
0.2800113559,
0.5341445208,
-0.4248314202,
0.4232476056,
-0.2423657775,
-0.5589520931,
0.6394236684,
-0.1888248622,
0.1007699147,
0.9627108574,
0.3747221529,
-0.512653172,
-0.2875410914,
-0.6631580591,
-1.0646748543,
0.9059500694,
0.3523931503,
-0.429302305,
-0.1054514796,
0.3882578313,
-0.0547319092,
0.23452802,
-0.4570181668,
-0.3590712547,
0.3651124537,
-0.2200317234,
-0.2569791377,
-0.5562752485,
0.1101474538,
-0.0885633975,
0.7154291272,
-0.0611933731,
-0.0400773697,
0.1803957373,
-0.3449514508,
-0.1352750063,
0.3769890368,
0.3569697738,
0.6706881523,
-0.5230214,
-0.0682394728,
0.075705722,
-1.0654895306,
0.1167557091,
0.0821723938,
-0.2397389561,
-0.1275918335,
0.2320082784,
0.6927248836,
0.3617305756,
-0.4000816047,
0.4760166109,
-0.0823165998,
-0.0333409272,
-0.0614452399,
0.0649587512,
-0.1958889961,
0.1218769699,
0.2483068407,
0.0649967119,
0.2904100418,
-0.1727233082,
0.2668618858,
0.1814765334,
-0.426340729,
-0.2866430283,
0.3489551544,
0.0090105096,
-0.1187280715,
0.4627298415,
-0.3356858492,
-0.4721203744,
0.6116322875,
0.2313438505,
0.9979410768,
-0.2661356628,
0.0941914171,
0.4947836995,
0.3014658093,
-0.5191915035,
0.0188130308,
-0.1309920549,
-0.7820475698,
-0.2966566086,
-0.7351180315,
-0.3043745458,
0.371704638,
-0.7976568937,
0.3809408247,
-0.2245170325,
-0.2021740526,
-0.1576560736,
0.2466076314,
-0.5810533166,
0.343121171,
-0.0739205852,
0.5537082553,
-0.9629680514,
1.0608795881,
0.5083431602,
-0.3451630771,
-0.4836164713,
0.1855908632,
0.0404157527,
-0.5689780712,
0.9069651365,
0.0348387249,
0.0029996331,
0.1994746178,
-0.1798081249,
-1.2983957529,
1.1377784014,
0.3620960712,
-0.467060715,
0.1867703348,
0.0170317851,
0.4728848338,
-0.2398899347,
0.3742593825,
0.7973454595,
0.3270668387,
0.1652738899,
-0.8926212192,
-0.2242922783,
-0.2482816726,
0.1015636399,
0.7147046924,
-0.5494060516,
0.71924752,
-0.1891231388,
-0.2431764752,
-0.2559562325,
0.164275825,
0.2346694171,
-0.0386552662,
0.8055824637,
0.6889281273,
0.8049321175,
0.1706867069,
0.8815845251,
-0.5239493251,
0.4697127342,
0.8580476642,
-0.2874730229,
0.8941383362,
0.5054787993,
-0.4756827652,
-0.1656656861,
0.9371381402,
0.1942234188,
0.8862611651,
0.0283242073,
-0.1189310998,
-0.3245078325,
0.0279682074,
-0.5359349847,
0.2986408472,
0.3843747675,
-0.2792013288,
-0.2447456419,
-0.2603487968,
-0.1173292622,
-0.4191424251,
-0.1734836251,
0.6907610297,
0.0308954399,
-0.4872869849,
0.6200510859,
-0.2515428364,
0.2645488083,
-0.6554808617,
-0.011233313,
-0.2204233855,
0.222398445,
-0.1990404725,
-0.7145366073,
0.2349911183,
-0.2175560147,
-0.6456776857,
-0.3995232284,
0.9547168016,
-0.5681416988,
-0.4310147464,
0.3910304904,
0.3135933876,
0.4950183928,
-0.1769988388,
-0.3510790467,
0.0961891264,
0.1922763586,
-0.503035605,
0.715383172,
0.3610873222,
-0.1819085777,
0.7384848595,
0.7071726322,
0.4672976732,
-0.4817320108,
0.3578698337,
0.9829984307,
-0.5839078426,
-0.5241439342,
-0.5835414529,
0.3993039727,
-0.0098400041,
-0.0901461542,
0.4833141267,
0.3577517271,
0.7115082145,
-0.0129563911,
1.0135893822,
-0.1513479203,
0.6830798984,
-0.6383396983,
0.9470261931,
-0.5483214259,
0.3320702612,
-0.3005823791,
-1.1316821575,
-0.3808944523,
0.5294377804,
-0.6154046655,
0.3063551486,
0.7571246624,
0.8384354115,
-0.1783509105,
-0.3648213148,
0.5913110375,
-0.0931541473,
0.2232928723,
0.2764591277,
0.4055784643,
-0.4213505983,
0.4784883857,
-0.1395974308,
-0.2862846851,
-0.4138689041,
-0.860748291,
-0.9542044997,
-0.8767829537,
-0.3051455617,
0.0423155054,
0.0162125826,
0.9014504552,
0.8876131773,
-0.8079556227,
0.0590075515,
0.2850498855,
0.1590713412,
-0.0707289353,
-0.1497664303,
0.6416664124,
-0.6634951234,
-0.5319546461,
0.3184836805,
0.3480685651,
-0.0272024646,
-0.1029845849,
0.122124657,
-0.1361017376,
-0.3077825308,
0.3965726495,
0.2472568303,
-0.4083082676,
-0.4245343506,
-0.1984979361,
-0.1171204895,
-0.0200420357,
0.7531298995,
-0.5760761499,
0.3709944487,
0.618868649,
0.920214355,
0.4956792295,
-0.124115333,
0.5063365102,
-0.7100227475,
0.250059098,
0.1735470891,
0.3174005747,
0.2791981697,
-0.4908910394,
0.7339375019,
0.1604182124,
-0.9048276544,
-0.9089865685,
0.0221090037,
-0.6512807012,
-0.1301354617,
1.3387107849,
-0.1051624194,
-0.3236448467,
-0.374404043,
-0.1929232478,
-0.1014867127,
-0.2553442717,
0.8470256925,
0.8515570164,
0.2009731382,
-0.1746278852,
-0.7182860374,
0.9230760932,
0.2653614879,
-0.6066298485,
0.2192083299,
0.3360898495,
0.2271761894,
0.1677674651,
0.8600772023,
-0.0631290376,
0.0358545594,
-0.0424476564,
0.3284211755,
0.1641669422,
-0.4679555595,
-0.2562329173,
-0.0126182949,
0.3695412576,
-0.0688663349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03162v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03162v3 | Protecting Language Generation Models via Invisible Watermarking | 2023-02-06T23:42:03 | 2023-08-27T00:13:09 | Xuandong Zhao, Yu-Xiang Wang, Lei Li | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Language generation models have been an increasingly powerful enabler for
many applications. Many such models offer free or affordable API access, which
makes them potentially vulnerable to model extraction attacks through
distillation. To protect intellectual property (IP) and ensure fair use of
these models, various techniques such as lexical watermarking and synonym
replacement have been proposed. However, these methods can be nullified by
obvious countermeasures such as "synonym randomization". To address this issue,
we propose GINSEW, a novel method to protect text generation models from being
stolen through distillation. The key idea of our method is to inject secret
signals into the probability vector of the decoding steps for each target
token. We can then detect the secret message by probing a suspect model to tell
if it is distilled from the protected one. Experimental results show that
GINSEW can effectively identify instances of IP infringement with minimal
impact on the generation quality of protected APIs. Our method demonstrates an
absolute improvement of 19 to 29 points on mean average precision (mAP) in
detecting suspects compared to previous methods against watermark removal
attacks. | [
-0.3444657326,
-0.7786771059,
0.4654445946,
0.0914269462,
-0.4243227839,
0.39067173,
0.1113545224,
-0.4583883584,
0.0059227333,
0.6869191527,
-0.4602700472,
-0.2557623982,
-0.8083944321,
-0.1124429554,
-0.8100773096,
0.7959839702,
0.0685492158,
-0.0875368789,
0.0475575514,
0.0119313924,
-0.3128582239,
-0.2906878293,
-0.3966667652,
-0.3563171625,
0.109591648,
-0.0688076317,
0.422547847,
0.8464768529,
0.4084675908,
0.3287066817,
-0.3695032895,
-0.0520045161,
-0.3565698266,
0.4642692804,
-0.2095740885,
-0.5958729982,
-0.1954220384,
0.1794727594,
0.2894465029,
0.4183393121,
-0.1219769642,
0.2067194283,
0.3160408437,
0.7313571572,
-0.7909076214,
0.2259230465,
-1.3533278704,
-0.0130960047,
-0.7468419075,
-0.1405923218,
-0.5423668623,
-0.1916235983,
-0.0937003344,
-0.3159249425,
0.6217692494,
0.2706224322,
1.4426095486,
0.0335202627,
0.294772625,
-0.262839824,
-0.8782682419,
0.8784700632,
-0.9979623556,
-0.2477206737,
0.2975624502,
0.3541061878,
-0.4113379419,
-0.8864938021,
-0.882320106,
-0.0227929763,
0.1768866181,
0.1743282378,
-0.7973784208,
0.0043386812,
0.5419846177,
0.4599964023,
-0.1647478342,
-0.1247194409,
-0.0458847657,
-0.1685224324,
0.3944955766,
-0.2415391356,
0.598141849,
-0.2329792678,
-0.4556257725,
-0.177686736,
-0.849119544,
-0.1631751209,
0.7860789299,
0.471596688,
0.2853255272,
0.5341291428,
-0.1231161952,
0.4701163769,
0.0693554729,
0.0336961597,
-0.0382164381,
0.0198186655,
-0.1927007586,
0.2083882093,
0.8378161192,
0.0033986147,
0.3396154642,
-0.1420771629,
-0.3604845107,
0.0030736027,
0.0702968538,
-0.7960718274,
-0.2198988497,
0.2666391432,
-0.2732922435,
-0.5880093575,
0.3273719847,
-0.7298614383,
-0.4450386167,
0.1514221281,
0.3974944055,
-0.4331433773,
-0.5678946972,
0.0433132313,
-0.7447511554,
0.0087944726,
-0.3001885414,
-0.9080838561,
0.1248409152,
0.8883764148,
0.7174187303,
0.0868586823,
-0.1796628535,
-0.3087593019,
0.5693828464,
-0.4092815816,
0.6677729487,
-0.3310855925,
-0.4009324908,
-0.1469498575,
-0.1378035098,
0.3379685879,
-0.8043062091,
0.2050629556,
-0.5992196798,
0.197069034,
-0.013957018,
-0.7442462444,
0.0325519741,
-0.1691146344,
-0.8112998605,
0.7976948619,
-0.1154285073,
-1.1356906891,
0.4814965427,
-0.4563284516,
-0.3295523822,
0.3882522583,
0.0789992586,
-0.7188078761,
0.5065027475,
0.378773272,
0.2675796449,
-0.0577941574,
0.4034110308,
-0.3706205487,
0.0191857591,
0.2562947273,
-0.8708507419,
0.853466332,
0.4016634822,
-0.6809889674,
-0.1211523041,
-0.8480840325,
0.1753726602,
0.4781215787,
0.145425871,
-0.9383332133,
0.0131710516,
-0.3503558338,
-0.1321252584,
0.1996213943,
-0.6915689111,
-0.0508480296,
-0.4507863522,
0.39298594,
0.6941773891,
0.2641761899,
0.2368641347,
-0.2088996768,
0.4727404416,
0.1456109732,
0.1823832542,
-0.2135376781,
-0.7891615629,
-0.7760629058,
-0.6168856621,
0.4267423153,
0.4675747454,
-0.9896013141,
0.5238229036,
-0.2021414191,
-0.7461323738,
-0.781381309,
0.0175286084,
0.4236326218,
0.5236533284,
0.3210214674,
-0.0398689546,
-0.3746547103,
-0.7771182656,
-0.5919343233,
-0.3841684759,
-0.3622047901,
0.0272739045,
0.2545296848,
0.0365179516,
1.333170414,
-0.5745973587,
-0.0427214019,
-0.437443167,
0.4762554765,
0.187242344,
0.4418586195,
0.5791641474,
-0.639079392,
-0.3848912716,
-0.2969478369,
-0.6746258736,
-0.7309108973,
-0.1105606556,
-0.1522319764,
-0.117098093,
0.4798476398,
-0.4585677087,
0.4700568318,
0.6606249213,
-0.2101807892,
0.5066726804,
-0.2483619601,
-0.145774141,
-1.1523855925,
0.1176101938,
-0.2348117381,
-0.2531645,
-0.7955206633,
0.3718049526,
0.1599006355,
-0.3691029251,
-0.5556151867,
0.5699733496,
-0.5585597157,
0.5359171033,
-0.590674758,
-0.1762185395,
0.2322642803,
-0.0561499782,
-0.2229709178,
0.841760993,
0.5620753169,
-0.2466767281,
0.1112834066,
0.0003603416,
-0.3741610646,
0.4463786185,
-0.7691258788,
0.1892943829,
-0.3376054466,
-0.0932114199,
-0.8346896768,
0.2270169556,
0.0064240415,
-0.4124976397,
0.4921148717,
-0.3624765873,
-0.3290020525,
-0.3373121917,
-0.306001991,
-0.2978184819,
0.6112197638,
-0.7820611596,
0.4544114172,
0.5351300836,
-0.2373116314,
-0.550953269,
-0.8859357834,
0.2720469236,
-0.5065773726,
-0.3115707934,
0.3996396959,
0.174494192,
-0.3170800209,
0.0995122418,
-0.1453255117,
-0.2092205584,
0.4012620449,
0.406899184,
0.3852787614,
0.118585296,
-0.2843526006,
0.2741610706,
-0.3952649236,
-0.0708310232,
-0.1928624511,
0.6717332006,
0.2299786061,
-0.2909571826,
-0.2828140259,
0.5566290021,
0.5905441046,
-0.3428350091,
0.7899394035,
0.3341158628,
-0.5575660467,
-0.5535228252,
-0.5046998858,
-0.2326472402,
-0.6154646277,
0.1292045712,
-0.4019601643,
-0.4919032753,
0.4090314507,
-0.267924279,
0.2243144214,
0.4787764847,
0.2885987759,
-0.0215184037,
1.0214836597,
0.6155395508,
-0.2866154611,
0.6347117424,
-0.1462413222,
0.4478873909,
-0.5366885662,
-0.0203873739,
-0.6190244555,
-0.0978061929,
-0.2875746489,
-0.1276897937,
-0.0695511401,
0.7451306581,
0.2320916951,
0.723528862,
-0.6965169311,
0.7235835195,
0.7578263879,
-0.2305533886,
0.3348444402,
0.3057053685,
-0.3761278987,
-0.2254832834,
-0.5271701217,
-0.7630162835,
0.9105073214,
0.3262256682,
0.7398681045,
-0.0506411456,
1.2129124403,
0.2952124476,
0.5054376125,
-0.3845656514,
0.7121555209,
-0.1192186773,
-0.7969197631,
-0.2584695518,
-0.5840060711,
-1.0181703568,
0.1782764494,
-0.1321996897,
-0.7217329144,
-0.0354939401,
0.1282338202,
-0.173473686,
0.7045913935,
-0.8013955951,
0.3931201994,
-0.084289439,
-0.3086788058,
0.0396322869,
-0.0701470003,
0.3029502332,
-0.2398436368,
0.3009859622,
-0.5073959827,
0.2918496132,
0.5267322659,
-0.6019682288,
0.5122861266,
-0.5696546435,
-0.1157153845,
0.2861450016,
0.3888969123,
0.5905401111,
-0.1378912777,
0.0764342174,
0.4166822731,
-0.1107957289,
-0.2328982651,
-0.3590725064,
0.6657137871,
-0.3076693118,
-0.9576964378,
-0.5317053199,
-0.2951853871,
-0.0267721582,
0.4088404179,
0.5511988997,
0.0970025137,
-0.1024764106,
-0.07100299,
0.444093138,
-0.288030982,
0.8470007777,
0.5125707984,
-0.2062002122,
-0.228753522,
1.0776057243,
0.0812145025,
0.4968453944,
0.0563030019,
0.4143843949,
-0.3270396292,
-0.8117944002,
-0.4133007526,
-0.0103580169,
-0.4500593841,
-0.2444720566,
-0.6192685962,
-0.3684678376,
-0.1681423932,
0.1921838671,
-0.4728242159,
-0.4398058653,
-0.2270487249,
0.0643708706,
0.1835730374,
0.3549618721,
-0.0163694937,
0.2429771274,
-0.6189318895,
0.494305253,
0.5765974522,
0.2640024126,
0.0567427389,
-0.3232178986,
0.3287907541,
0.2021157742,
-0.3644966781,
-0.8296164274,
0.5916287303,
0.305785358,
0.5531328917,
0.5391387939,
0.2780989408,
0.8451743126,
-1.0242574215,
0.7916449308,
0.3160785139,
-1.3135738373,
0.7750706673,
-0.0265648197,
0.2930122316,
0.3580719531,
0.0426466838,
-0.2872402668,
-1.1174106598,
-0.8621435761,
-1.0603803396,
0.2076189071,
0.3567536473,
0.5068147779,
-0.172857523,
0.0184844956,
0.0931063816,
0.3331951499,
-0.6942042112,
-0.235298112,
-0.198662281,
-0.110851489,
0.3987696171,
-0.2932339609,
-0.1511581093,
-0.0642281473,
0.8797113299,
0.2315765768,
0.0974670351,
-0.0133913886,
-0.0486430153,
0.0984049216,
0.3974426389,
0.173102349,
0.2497708648,
-0.0279855095,
0.363294661,
-0.2389565855,
-0.6004346609,
0.2950257957,
0.1182141677,
-0.4761742353,
0.4661380649,
0.3653348088,
0.6243308783,
-0.4180105627,
-0.5187612176,
0.5435522795,
-0.151371032,
-0.1049807593,
-0.1423815489,
0.3682847619,
0.1440927088,
0.0699971691,
0.5587974787,
0.0112649128,
0.0242138542,
-0.3720958829,
0.2110276371,
0.5107225776,
-0.4334986806,
-0.1922289133,
1.0100077391,
-0.0353778601,
-0.1380860507,
0.1888231337,
-0.1923923939,
-0.3967943192,
0.4315870702,
0.7510996461,
1.1637365818,
-0.3625831306,
0.1462795734,
0.1898311228,
0.342034936,
-0.2804482579,
0.2430475652,
0.2277613133,
-0.8340879679,
0.1505207717,
-0.7392742038,
-0.299708575,
0.4033558965,
-0.6351189613,
0.0141528975,
-0.5034649372,
-0.4724835455,
0.426568538,
-0.480976671,
-0.3250941932,
-0.2482365221,
0.243876785,
0.5590677857,
-0.8601962924,
1.0584022999,
-0.0197140276,
-0.1391030252,
-0.767066896,
0.2120902091,
-0.0012016867,
-0.5710785985,
0.3908528686,
0.1560245752,
-0.0938327387,
0.0840175375,
-0.5886016488,
-0.5919208527,
0.8535127044,
0.6736434698,
-0.7881227136,
0.3494035006,
0.3108125031,
0.4140218496,
0.0844425559,
-0.0648697987,
0.534499526,
0.2715089917,
-0.0563491136,
-0.5688071251,
0.0410845764,
-0.322883606,
0.3671895564,
0.220152393,
-0.0884050354,
0.7468947768,
-0.0710891783,
-0.7768733501,
0.1748862118,
0.4786580801,
0.4765381515,
-0.0697833598,
0.4906819463,
0.5287685394,
0.8554198742,
-0.5054779053,
0.9198963642,
-0.4627579749,
0.3176767826,
1.040201664,
-0.5415986776,
0.7592743039,
0.8039829731,
-0.100409396,
0.3664347529,
-0.0099654039,
-0.2347537428,
0.9050601125,
0.6357310414,
-0.6021348834,
0.1695324481,
-0.2218361646,
-0.3842075765,
0.2278064787,
0.2508052588,
-0.2637943625,
-0.2859658599,
0.140842706,
0.359054029,
0.3633302748,
0.0010545434,
0.7881854773,
0.1211946979,
-0.3886908591,
0.6204689145,
0.1681693941,
0.8872516751,
-0.8593281507,
-0.0248987451,
-0.3270933032,
0.3781393468,
0.1023888737,
-0.5781677365,
0.230456084,
0.4043247104,
-0.2401732057,
-0.3756665885,
0.8866025209,
-0.5564718843,
-0.4966728985,
0.3437560201,
0.426261425,
-0.1901715398,
-0.1559184492,
-0.7052513957,
-0.180302307,
-0.1196897179,
-0.2192476988,
0.099475421,
0.4047299325,
-0.1019824222,
0.7635050416,
0.8990042806,
0.7547770739,
0.2944231629,
0.2677026987,
0.5913405418,
-0.3538792729,
-0.5762322545,
-1.2358106375,
0.2095406204,
-0.5271582007,
0.0333050527,
1.1439629793,
0.4307892323,
0.7037495971,
-0.2298235744,
1.0964509249,
-0.0270373281,
0.4529582858,
-0.3230144083,
1.3358994722,
-0.2484890074,
0.4823285341,
-0.5555867553,
-0.7988992929,
-0.3111240864,
0.1986446232,
0.0399741605,
-0.4038440287,
0.5944594741,
0.8954104781,
-0.0184346084,
0.0943016186,
0.3792818189,
-0.1996903867,
0.8635663986,
0.2255014628,
0.9147822261,
-0.3466197848,
0.3814001083,
-0.3640096784,
-0.3079289794,
0.4399762154,
-1.1192016602,
-0.8535157442,
-0.4127569199,
-0.335957557,
-0.3728819191,
0.0044170367,
0.3968818486,
0.6749258637,
-1.140591383,
-0.0460844636,
-0.3692727089,
-0.0629066676,
-0.4782108963,
-0.2238923758,
0.2803507447,
-0.1600580662,
-0.8648266196,
0.397300899,
0.3623715639,
0.6075066328,
-0.3558327258,
0.3302646279,
0.0089297742,
0.3884467781,
-0.0079719471,
0.2613802552,
-0.6764925122,
-0.4008936584,
-0.3240287602,
-0.2323722541,
-0.2528104484,
0.8100304008,
-0.5733712912,
0.6214991212,
0.5552766919,
0.4845385551,
0.372330904,
-0.1116151735,
0.5527452826,
-1.1364361048,
0.759619832,
0.191030845,
0.4892342091,
0.2932634056,
-0.0456452817,
0.1454832256,
0.5270533562,
0.0145875346,
-0.9664874673,
0.1995239556,
-0.4676648974,
-0.4786685407,
0.9537727237,
-0.4873319268,
-0.36857301,
-0.1561664939,
-0.0770456493,
0.3042934239,
-0.2067051083,
1.1095567942,
0.7820189595,
0.6375210285,
0.0885680988,
-0.5611584187,
0.5528094769,
0.2304215878,
-0.8617205024,
0.348580569,
0.0506909229,
0.3880013824,
0.1919130385,
0.23920919,
-0.4912648797,
-0.328581363,
0.1892119497,
0.2742503881,
-0.3948609233,
-0.2418064475,
-0.1817097515,
0.2965990305,
-0.0095816022,
-0.5578330159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03147v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03147v1 | It's about Time: Rethinking Evaluation on Rumor Detection Benchmarks using Chronological Splits | 2023-02-06T22:53:13 | 2023-02-06T22:53:13 | Yida Mu, Kalina Bontcheva, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL | New events emerge over time influencing the topics of rumors in social media.
Current rumor detection benchmarks use random splits as training, development
and test sets which typically results in topical overlaps. Consequently, models
trained on random splits may not perform well on rumor classification on
previously unseen topics due to the temporal concept drift. In this paper, we
provide a re-evaluation of classification models on four popular rumor
detection benchmarks considering chronological instead of random splits. Our
experimental results show that the use of random splits can significantly
overestimate predictive performance across all datasets and models. Therefore,
we suggest that rumor detection models should always be evaluated using
chronological splits for minimizing topical overlaps. | [
-0.5390146375,
-0.5790246725,
0.7143431902,
0.1758706272,
-0.534660995,
0.6111555696,
0.1653923839,
-0.8468267322,
0.4405087829,
-0.1270899475,
-0.7871182561,
-0.1988639534,
-0.6376317143,
-0.1839986742,
-0.8601998091,
0.9478397369,
-0.0121594677,
-0.0581451766,
0.0388813168,
-0.1080927625,
0.0162762571,
-0.3250079751,
-0.5006476641,
0.0836599246,
0.7042514682,
0.3732596338,
0.6514484882,
0.563477695,
0.2509040833,
0.2473990172,
-0.2307205945,
0.2494379282,
0.0991013795,
0.2935023308,
0.0414385796,
-0.6541060209,
0.1573300362,
0.5246561766,
0.6776625514,
0.6220921278,
-0.2755115032,
0.2547058761,
-0.7260679007,
0.4645660818,
-0.6209882498,
-0.2770999372,
-0.6743732691,
0.1895796806,
-0.5508112311,
-0.2805641592,
-0.1539280117,
-0.5511443019,
0.4340618253,
-0.2852762938,
0.6229766607,
0.3086316884,
1.2883291245,
0.0472517796,
-0.2364393175,
-0.0513615012,
-0.8139861822,
0.5501648188,
-0.4602237642,
0.6181945801,
-0.1902968585,
1.006218791,
0.1480676234,
-0.8654235601,
-0.443051666,
-0.2233856618,
0.5056176186,
-0.1817465574,
-0.4678637087,
-0.7522441149,
0.2181765735,
0.2619104981,
-0.0810393691,
0.2668656707,
-0.6739060283,
-0.2394541204,
0.3115486205,
-0.0641762391,
0.2841199338,
-0.254635781,
-0.4339222908,
0.1854726821,
-0.2180766612,
-0.055742383,
0.6437751055,
-0.109014608,
0.2295900285,
0.1958308816,
-0.4080561996,
0.4418667853,
0.262119472,
-0.3188339174,
0.6321205497,
-0.1809944361,
0.0182556026,
0.2584849596,
0.5841631889,
0.5569096804,
0.3055285811,
-0.4924778938,
0.1894334257,
0.162112236,
0.3676611781,
-0.4937601984,
0.1108428985,
0.1875326037,
-0.5170742273,
-0.7003144026,
-0.0378634781,
-0.9086359143,
-0.2252778262,
-0.0220299773,
-0.0996247306,
-0.3486441076,
-0.3523053527,
0.0448394604,
-0.6979070306,
-0.1370984614,
0.9141184092,
-0.1227594614,
0.0562057085,
0.9200197458,
0.900968194,
-0.1001832485,
-0.4223048687,
-0.1906017363,
-0.0619694591,
-0.5741144419,
1.4015920162,
-0.5273946524,
-0.0720533282,
-0.007306953,
0.0172584597,
-0.2027256936,
-0.3204320073,
0.8183695078,
-0.7573955655,
0.5862113237,
-0.1623168737,
-0.5925167203,
0.0565831885,
0.1785258502,
-0.5463095903,
0.8786015511,
-0.0275892857,
-1.0222328901,
1.3148534298,
-0.1020062193,
-0.4008381963,
-0.1751978695,
0.1625164002,
-0.3934239447,
0.116724968,
0.3618603349,
0.0063267238,
-0.4411044121,
0.2091929615,
-0.6197541952,
-0.3139633536,
0.3255801797,
-0.5365136862,
0.4262686372,
0.5970477462,
-0.1578609645,
-0.0887604132,
-0.7441196442,
0.1645057797,
-0.2457310259,
0.0622716658,
-0.4995509982,
0.1766635478,
-0.2386961728,
0.4109474123,
-0.1965942681,
-0.7748938799,
0.1401339024,
-0.1361450255,
0.3036411405,
0.5652643442,
0.4483633041,
0.458194077,
-0.654255271,
0.4333754182,
0.2851081192,
0.518025279,
0.0587256439,
-0.4399008751,
-0.8119605184,
0.081234917,
0.3753539026,
0.1517825425,
-0.6858943701,
0.0481480882,
-0.3175629973,
-0.8858730197,
-0.4443152845,
-0.4965254664,
-0.2060958892,
0.2592633367,
0.2463424951,
-0.1144565567,
-0.5725128651,
-0.8555250168,
-0.7580412626,
-0.4356843829,
0.1105690151,
-0.0587073788,
0.0614162982,
0.0364078805,
1.1001851559,
-0.3389163613,
0.1059284955,
-0.0612311549,
0.777967453,
0.059999682,
0.0849530846,
0.6124777198,
-0.8450373411,
-0.2129631042,
-0.3651023507,
-0.4925464988,
-0.2319054902,
0.0744279772,
0.1163247675,
0.4638613164,
0.6502788663,
-0.4543066025,
0.4558114111,
0.0651300699,
-0.1769403517,
0.603330195,
0.460755825,
0.5545242429,
-0.8651276827,
-0.5977011919,
0.1178772599,
-0.165254876,
-0.4004342556,
-0.4838011861,
-0.0188123398,
0.2411518991,
-0.5845634937,
0.1658568829,
-0.6724866629,
-0.2822653949,
-0.5473383665,
-0.0664723665,
-0.3708834648,
-0.094859682,
-0.061243277,
0.2417558134,
0.3695600927,
-0.4018175006,
-0.0091721909,
-0.4045189023,
-0.9383422136,
0.4123943448,
-0.2340410203,
0.0772814527,
-0.1832556725,
0.6705777049,
-0.9231553078,
0.1871192455,
0.4749721587,
-0.521265626,
0.1673565954,
-0.5059961081,
-0.716029346,
-0.8173496127,
-0.4521607459,
0.1749267876,
0.7061854601,
-0.5778099895,
0.2286414355,
0.2951273918,
0.3738807142,
-0.597998023,
-0.600646019,
-0.1868869811,
-0.4133117795,
-0.8298883438,
0.3637236655,
0.2676312625,
-0.4941173494,
0.2722715735,
-0.7947052717,
-0.3319112659,
-0.1956685334,
0.3500005305,
-0.0027093976,
-0.199738875,
-0.056427598,
0.0893973112,
-0.061452765,
-0.0527450815,
-0.203198716,
0.3806035817,
0.1551961899,
-0.2404233962,
-0.0978025049,
-0.3659760058,
0.7938370705,
0.1350734979,
0.7994494438,
0.8533769846,
-0.2689016759,
-0.3356609941,
-1.2860127687,
0.1825984716,
-0.4194436967,
0.071410358,
-0.1305487454,
-0.7940975428,
0.4043962955,
-0.1976873875,
0.1033633575,
0.5885583758,
0.2943634391,
-0.0541443452,
0.5091320872,
0.3687315583,
-0.1874470115,
0.6297028661,
0.1133311763,
0.0625643283,
-0.5786992908,
-0.1368449479,
-0.4445437789,
-0.3393298388,
-0.471136272,
-0.8217658997,
-0.1273875087,
-0.0191912316,
0.2920550406,
0.0808483809,
-0.1824790537,
0.4579722285,
0.1582140028,
-0.0828670636,
0.4840956628,
0.3000101149,
0.0032311075,
-0.0637886375,
-0.742197156,
0.0344539881,
0.8781202435,
0.6480482817,
0.6661063433,
-0.3896368444,
0.5203640461,
0.5168932676,
0.6859153509,
-0.3521640897,
0.381778717,
0.0325145572,
-0.7907527685,
-0.3230670094,
-0.2441549599,
-0.6748896837,
0.5670154691,
0.1763379872,
-0.8266031146,
0.7035713196,
-0.5871604681,
-0.3023866117,
0.5715481043,
-0.4813323915,
0.3045993745,
0.0110858707,
-0.0337931588,
-0.4159299433,
-0.5419001579,
0.7790108919,
-0.2857080996,
0.5113388896,
-0.6567700505,
-0.0066149659,
1.1668288708,
-0.7794797421,
0.521505177,
-0.1355145276,
0.3450351357,
0.5238184929,
-0.1886677593,
0.1035560146,
0.1267221719,
0.0821217671,
0.1370816529,
0.082123965,
-0.1068254858,
-0.3771147132,
0.583563447,
-0.6652296185,
-0.641001761,
-0.8942266703,
-0.5179154277,
-0.3783838749,
-0.1981004924,
0.6857705116,
0.1031698212,
-0.1328031421,
0.0512463078,
0.0908138603,
0.1458406746,
0.4272616804,
1.089512825,
-0.277867645,
-0.2933665216,
0.3641859889,
0.5961824656,
0.1014127955,
0.0724683776,
0.0510133989,
-0.1027055606,
-0.6370812654,
-0.1211717501,
0.1937412471,
-0.5498315692,
0.0767244026,
-0.8223429918,
-0.4849441648,
-0.3804266453,
0.1882034838,
-0.6940726042,
-0.6216970086,
0.0688638315,
-0.2138715535,
0.4173527658,
0.5050717592,
-0.226200819,
0.1816667616,
-0.711184144,
0.279409498,
-0.0198634602,
0.110743165,
0.0596066602,
-0.7258911133,
-0.2138547003,
-0.3484247625,
-0.114071846,
-0.8881790042,
0.1627517194,
-0.4163343012,
0.7401285768,
0.190985173,
0.0179713368,
0.6951830983,
-0.8087437749,
0.5365402102,
0.1187556535,
-0.5772958398,
0.4019522667,
-0.320150435,
0.1775263548,
0.5610293746,
0.6007620096,
-0.6175436974,
-0.6003195643,
-1.0647939444,
-0.8062742949,
0.8080175519,
0.1064791828,
-0.3987700343,
-0.012282161,
0.1489702761,
0.1056295186,
0.4964551926,
-0.3446157873,
-0.3977677226,
0.2090969533,
0.68629843,
0.1735734642,
-0.8556693792,
0.0883242935,
-0.4095493853,
0.2716003358,
0.5809146166,
0.1472700089,
0.0639184266,
-0.1026237234,
-0.6423785686,
0.3705135286,
0.1970106065,
0.9594709277,
-0.5516024232,
-0.2239938974,
0.0289368592,
-0.2501734197,
0.2677430809,
0.3273146451,
-0.1129213348,
0.5638096929,
0.4340716898,
0.6127305627,
0.6023365259,
0.1279592216,
0.2135436982,
-0.1568118036,
-0.3763378263,
-0.4435463548,
-0.0565618873,
0.0188724492,
0.5040321946,
0.6417284012,
0.467854321,
0.0254252646,
-0.7522314787,
0.5271232724,
-0.0899204612,
-0.2244241238,
-0.2035437375,
0.4133029878,
-0.074725464,
0.0376315676,
0.56895715,
-0.1768134385,
-0.7214739919,
0.6049946547,
0.0422301963,
0.9291456938,
-0.3877408504,
0.460190475,
0.0883934647,
0.5324029922,
-0.5498582721,
-0.1757276952,
0.0137285022,
-0.7782779932,
-0.2625513673,
-0.5794862509,
-0.41690135,
-0.0786602646,
-0.5909112692,
0.5067106485,
-0.4311078489,
-0.3012866378,
0.3735260963,
-0.138955161,
-0.3137556911,
0.1900907755,
0.1306214631,
1.3306735754,
-0.7959402204,
0.9508426785,
0.2001950294,
-0.3387622237,
-0.649833858,
0.5826638341,
0.2299974263,
-0.3913546503,
0.9247236252,
0.1030983105,
0.3962322176,
-0.5668874979,
-0.3506112695,
-1.0454932451,
1.035245657,
-0.1293625385,
-0.5981886983,
-0.2170442045,
-0.2197171003,
0.6515389681,
-0.3512850404,
0.3317081332,
0.5992898345,
0.3226161301,
0.7075349092,
-0.9216340184,
-0.2389933765,
-0.2000701725,
-0.3485828638,
0.3867277205,
-0.8773447275,
1.126932025,
-0.0240962002,
-0.3624914289,
0.1753300726,
0.736681819,
0.4209950566,
0.9002426267,
1.0069090128,
0.5471874475,
0.7336243391,
-0.3933939934,
1.2938696146,
-0.0660472736,
0.1013563424,
0.9629338384,
-0.3972732127,
0.5749794841,
0.1263535917,
-0.4254530966,
0.779487431,
0.9311100841,
-0.3593408465,
0.6030187607,
0.2381291687,
0.1246533245,
-0.2226812541,
-0.1091170087,
-0.9262866974,
0.0244431924,
0.1452846527,
-0.3820368648,
-0.7791970372,
-0.172177732,
0.2030404061,
-0.4559442401,
-0.2537987828,
0.0106096081,
-0.0729008764,
-0.6349288225,
0.143806085,
-0.0080336863,
0.8198738098,
-0.53676337,
0.3647662997,
-0.1477320641,
0.120799616,
-0.140803799,
-0.670349896,
0.2273258865,
0.0258869119,
-0.2083510458,
-0.0365863331,
1.0586979389,
-0.2298297882,
-0.5171806216,
0.3145242035,
0.6228526831,
0.205055207,
-0.1684060991,
-0.7727306485,
0.2097930014,
-0.0416669622,
-0.3480029702,
0.3695001006,
0.7983335257,
-0.319565475,
0.714982152,
0.8243670464,
-0.094420217,
0.4035972953,
0.4069338739,
0.9470787048,
-0.5429090858,
-0.7139292955,
-0.6822450757,
0.1370993853,
-0.2652871609,
-0.2903644443,
1.2812013626,
0.4917515814,
0.5087302327,
0.1878997236,
0.5865507126,
0.1172619313,
0.9949474335,
-0.4401377141,
0.5853890181,
-0.5512910485,
0.6157206297,
-0.5097259283,
-0.7685299516,
0.2737013698,
0.1012389287,
-0.7463798523,
0.3098810315,
1.1841797829,
0.0607308224,
0.1567230672,
0.6238356829,
-0.0291925035,
0.1990962625,
0.1639343351,
0.2042491883,
1.5712153912,
-0.3908523917,
0.4218412042,
-0.6885104179,
0.037881732,
-0.2626370788,
-0.789926827,
-0.8253400922,
-0.3381890059,
-0.6402384639,
-0.4424748421,
0.5875324011,
0.5152339935,
0.8573691249,
-0.4357096553,
0.0346487537,
0.0832175389,
0.2361505032,
-0.1227830872,
-0.3191295564,
0.0776711255,
-0.3787738383,
-0.5800459385,
0.4842448831,
0.1252361238,
-0.0457124412,
-0.0839037299,
0.5145053864,
-0.5221050978,
-0.0550641902,
0.1505183727,
0.3951266706,
-0.6015510559,
-0.1717631519,
-0.141820997,
0.0253296942,
-0.1982254535,
1.0137431622,
-0.8977905512,
-0.0815801397,
0.4955411851,
0.2758589685,
0.8162647486,
0.1728599817,
0.6926827431,
-0.5345724821,
0.46789518,
0.0262611769,
0.3606916368,
0.1166695505,
-0.3385147452,
0.881295383,
0.6693476439,
-0.4326652586,
-1.1592166424,
-0.3571332395,
-0.919824779,
-0.7195743322,
1.2099263668,
0.2687751651,
-0.5289705992,
-0.2555772364,
0.467861563,
0.0468019918,
-0.5769098401,
0.7568731904,
1.0698195696,
-0.2017681599,
-0.0645194873,
-0.5574226379,
0.4518302977,
0.2028476894,
-0.5051907301,
-0.3120811582,
0.3593893945,
0.5952974558,
0.5958698988,
0.5765935183,
-0.2982778549,
0.619713366,
0.0181469433,
-0.2445417643,
-0.0730039328,
-0.6171290874,
0.1609821618,
0.3873103559,
-0.0851377696,
-0.2899358869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03145v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03145v1 | Techniques to Improve Neural Math Word Problem Solvers | 2023-02-06T22:41:51 | 2023-02-06T22:41:51 | Youyuan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SC | Developing automatic Math Word Problem (MWP) solvers is a challenging task
that demands the ability of understanding and mathematical reasoning over the
natural language. Recent neural-based approaches mainly encode the problem text
using a language model and decode a mathematical expression over quantities and
operators iteratively. Note the problem text of a MWP consists of a context
part and a question part, a recent work finds these neural solvers may only
perform shallow pattern matching between the context text and the golden
expression, where question text is not well used. Meanwhile, existing decoding
processes fail to enforce the mathematical laws into the design, where the
representations for mathematical equivalent expressions are different. To
address these two issues, we propose a new encoder-decoder architecture that
fully leverages the question text and preserves step-wise commutative law.
Besides generating quantity embeddings, our encoder further encodes the
question text and uses it to guide the decoding process. At each step, our
decoder uses Deep Sets to compute expression representations so that these
embeddings are invariant under any permutation of quantities. Experiments on
four established benchmarks demonstrate that our framework outperforms
state-of-the-art neural MWP solvers, showing the effectiveness of our
techniques. We also conduct a detailed analysis of the results to show the
limitations of our approach and further discuss the potential future work. Code
is available at https://github.com/sophistz/Question-Aware-Deductive-MWP. | [
-0.1156538948,
-0.6995036006,
0.2796694338,
0.4668184519,
-0.2045693099,
-0.0372906402,
0.1184344366,
-0.2034113854,
-0.0581529066,
0.2928549349,
-0.4727994204,
-0.0225440916,
-0.7671800852,
0.2419958711,
-0.2415364832,
0.5528020263,
-0.1418592632,
0.4000847936,
-0.5344418883,
-0.2395782918,
-0.5641433597,
-0.601323545,
-0.7313890457,
-0.5666397214,
0.1657827049,
0.048498366,
0.6917698383,
0.475340426,
0.7921532393,
0.3859983683,
-0.2442619354,
0.3585262895,
-0.1249843165,
0.0521345958,
0.1722232699,
-0.2552822828,
-0.2472421825,
-0.2887249589,
0.1642500162,
0.7897519469,
-0.5078829527,
-0.0067259707,
0.1184587628,
0.6596086025,
-0.8014232516,
0.4875600934,
-0.5559042096,
0.4785017669,
0.2462196052,
-0.4097785354,
-0.268556267,
-0.3445389867,
0.0309392195,
-0.5921875238,
0.0969329327,
-0.2284895331,
0.5929110646,
0.4303480685,
-0.1907019913,
-0.5635188222,
-0.3924631774,
0.6557593346,
-0.9643198848,
0.3185419142,
0.3554674685,
0.2282270938,
-0.2267519683,
-0.5108188987,
-0.548951447,
0.2655212581,
-0.0021011652,
0.2285570651,
-0.510931015,
-0.0372603424,
0.3252818286,
0.3993822634,
-0.5590685606,
-0.3659386933,
-0.2663409412,
-0.2238453478,
0.5757780671,
0.4157163799,
0.276242733,
-0.180670768,
0.0183598716,
-0.0823990554,
-0.4525577426,
0.0248375814,
0.1111378595,
-0.1438597143,
0.0142472759,
0.6246365309,
-0.1210602447,
0.9140482545,
-0.0997593254,
0.07999558,
0.2599454224,
0.0911863074,
-0.2154430151,
-0.0236686803,
0.5497079492,
0.2022798359,
0.4645806849,
-0.1549603343,
-0.2220892459,
0.2020459622,
0.2827106118,
-0.9895310402,
-0.0909645557,
-0.0922917649,
-0.3890162408,
-0.1371382177,
-0.1800785661,
-0.4383248091,
-0.2383570224,
-0.3768454194,
0.7674750686,
-0.6145485044,
0.0639471039,
0.7474232912,
-0.347076267,
0.2758297324,
0.2177434415,
-0.9010290504,
0.3692130148,
0.7330160141,
0.5516497493,
0.2672323585,
0.0866740644,
-0.5650402904,
-0.1048225015,
-0.4575496614,
0.3231674433,
-0.5575960875,
-0.1882942319,
0.0637771189,
-0.4121940434,
0.0544008613,
-0.9498599768,
0.2767721415,
-0.8802152872,
0.1779225618,
-0.3123622835,
-0.7173073888,
-0.076541096,
0.6993641853,
-0.4855832756,
0.7093294859,
0.0151443984,
-0.6381120086,
-0.203687802,
-0.9116315246,
-0.3553307056,
0.0084265536,
-0.1959525943,
-0.2791483104,
0.648050189,
0.5682923794,
0.1843805909,
-0.2660682201,
0.2399170548,
-0.0138287749,
-0.4617641568,
0.421993494,
-0.67201823,
0.8347988129,
0.2531212568,
-0.1202938184,
-0.1849251539,
-0.8744510412,
0.2327734679,
0.4376387298,
-0.4085361958,
-0.2251887321,
0.1136048436,
-0.5470436811,
0.1997228861,
0.2884182036,
-0.7626860738,
-0.0089804167,
-0.5874558687,
0.3954999149,
0.6332657933,
-0.0666529536,
0.2284196913,
-0.130821988,
0.544985652,
0.2008774132,
-0.1034779102,
-0.0757574961,
-0.5475637317,
-0.8079009056,
0.2013406605,
0.2657703459,
0.6822507977,
-0.9855002165,
0.4136558771,
-0.0935756415,
-0.0327747911,
-0.5486323833,
-0.0808753744,
0.4845551252,
0.6542387605,
0.6116274595,
0.0290954355,
-0.4549050033,
-0.7012858987,
-0.4958350956,
0.2854264677,
-0.1659002602,
0.1636556387,
0.3179083169,
0.0979724303,
1.014973402,
-0.8798914552,
-0.2202435881,
-0.0564564541,
0.3466506898,
0.1480157375,
0.5864735842,
0.2054888904,
-0.8544543982,
-0.2855091691,
-0.2240435034,
-0.8612836599,
-0.2439445704,
0.2003103197,
-0.1159403995,
0.0264895726,
0.5692275763,
-0.5128290057,
0.5189145207,
0.5335816741,
-0.5116139054,
0.1535766721,
-0.5585947037,
-0.1148889065,
-1.0773439407,
-0.1226737499,
-0.1604157239,
-0.0042543174,
-0.4544864595,
0.3897537887,
0.2235193849,
-0.4355322719,
-0.2701909542,
0.1352322102,
-0.3552634716,
0.1147698984,
-0.3349695206,
-0.1378544867,
0.0657785758,
0.6638749838,
-0.2245925218,
0.8159450889,
0.2764592469,
-0.6087198853,
0.4799898863,
0.4141381681,
-0.0206268094,
0.3924410343,
-0.8805612922,
0.3187687397,
-0.410579443,
-0.0213449951,
-0.7801191211,
0.3278213739,
0.2400900573,
-0.5982961655,
0.2313352078,
-0.1124113128,
-0.7169697285,
-0.2824570835,
-0.2288336605,
0.7064114809,
0.7642112374,
-0.4211013317,
0.7957106233,
0.1497189552,
-0.0997292325,
-0.6366117597,
-0.9235505462,
0.1527606994,
0.2658658922,
-0.7365677357,
0.4379599392,
-0.246450454,
-0.1894737333,
0.058904402,
-0.3762877285,
-0.3275932372,
0.0230798088,
-0.235588938,
0.0517641455,
-0.2464541644,
0.0510579087,
0.1569269896,
-0.457069397,
0.5616067052,
-0.3616364002,
0.7675037384,
-0.1063000038,
-0.3691212833,
-0.0260146726,
0.5681612492,
0.2853266597,
-0.6979512572,
0.4385203719,
0.3362478912,
-0.6871861815,
-0.0979157463,
-0.3975789547,
-0.0014023972,
-0.5740171671,
0.3986615241,
-0.5165452361,
-0.6431705356,
0.5151665807,
0.0149099268,
0.003484145,
0.2622823715,
0.5072487593,
-0.0090354541,
1.2506685257,
0.3881384432,
0.1955636442,
0.252702415,
-0.5706936121,
0.2774227262,
-0.7404952049,
-0.3750590086,
-0.3535770774,
-0.5957214236,
-0.1805049032,
-0.5301802158,
0.3554269671,
0.0783988237,
0.0816697925,
0.2554282248,
-0.5955530405,
0.681306541,
0.1777978837,
0.031192895,
0.1209338382,
0.0701046139,
-0.3739956915,
-0.4020976424,
-0.7833566666,
0.0049811397,
0.7051423788,
-0.0175922345,
0.712063849,
0.184313342,
0.7385689616,
-0.1596895307,
0.1046238393,
-0.9201322794,
0.7464988828,
-0.4483884573,
-0.4154128134,
-0.0250287708,
-0.810608685,
-0.9917606115,
0.4597363472,
0.0385289527,
-0.4053337574,
0.0477238037,
0.1385076642,
-0.2929847538,
0.2007325292,
-0.4678779542,
0.8533535004,
-0.2293050289,
-0.1732439399,
-0.2067300975,
-0.3334744275,
-0.0959705114,
0.1697596312,
0.0259382166,
0.0640905201,
-0.1103489026,
0.5673023462,
-0.8453418016,
0.4218350649,
-0.3648460805,
-0.5546488166,
0.2822309732,
0.2287506461,
0.3967046738,
-0.0137144858,
-0.1522778571,
-0.0840788111,
-0.1750440598,
-0.4266126752,
-1.106564045,
0.5291145444,
-0.4877358973,
-0.4869953096,
-0.2419362664,
-1.0831457376,
-0.388694346,
0.1308907121,
0.2145927846,
0.8764399886,
0.207731843,
0.1737651825,
0.7949844003,
-0.1294104159,
0.7361409068,
0.3659673333,
-0.0316237323,
-0.5863423944,
1.0026346445,
0.2766140997,
-0.0568627492,
0.5814635754,
0.5474545956,
-0.2889859676,
-0.4217680097,
-0.3805038929,
-0.184855029,
-0.8162379265,
-0.5825521946,
-0.4988081157,
-0.3980337083,
-0.1177919433,
-0.1781421155,
-0.1577945352,
-0.4787379205,
-0.1225180179,
0.2367723286,
0.3151661456,
0.2345606536,
0.0970488042,
0.0168419629,
-0.8933874965,
0.7630293369,
0.5939100981,
0.3958269358,
0.0071052476,
-0.4522539675,
-0.0618197024,
0.2121022046,
-0.3128005862,
-0.7617954612,
0.468503356,
0.0468471497,
0.0988284424,
0.1824354529,
0.1619768441,
0.9176375866,
-0.6566953063,
0.1900891811,
0.1556233019,
-1.1678968668,
0.2892254889,
0.0609966107,
0.5487510562,
0.3627375364,
0.0665676296,
-0.475563556,
-0.2019657493,
-0.5086016059,
-0.6031170487,
0.4200645685,
0.4229332209,
0.6248617172,
-0.1026519984,
0.4900269806,
-0.05021061,
0.1999753714,
-0.4311991632,
-0.2172224671,
-0.2608614862,
-0.6908738017,
0.3706257343,
-0.1234129593,
0.0837421045,
-0.658554852,
0.2489067763,
-0.1826430261,
0.4545449018,
0.2349473983,
-0.2171336561,
0.0605345592,
0.3185192645,
0.4488503337,
0.6906652451,
-0.0951616392,
0.2291929871,
0.4326859117,
-0.5960543752,
0.1651081592,
0.5129855871,
-0.2894775867,
0.2064864039,
0.0276131891,
0.3576927781,
0.2585321665,
-0.623842895,
0.6110565066,
-0.0742736906,
-0.4887697995,
-0.3231329322,
0.0294630583,
0.3200512528,
0.094111599,
0.3897645772,
0.3234476745,
0.2741530538,
-0.2492751628,
-0.0609936081,
0.5358262062,
-0.3388415575,
-0.0712871701,
0.5076149702,
0.1556098908,
-0.6873912215,
0.7599292994,
-0.4654314816,
-0.7959302664,
0.7605922222,
0.9949808121,
0.7456688881,
0.186989814,
-0.0523714609,
0.052153945,
0.1299070269,
0.1637107283,
0.8962132931,
-0.0898373574,
-0.8788759112,
-0.6123147607,
-0.3180205822,
-0.2127040178,
-0.0135076065,
-0.5760688186,
0.0040996936,
-0.6450527906,
0.1245925799,
-0.0432417877,
-0.0844907388,
-0.5484521389,
0.2577129006,
0.237737,
0.9594087005,
-0.0887403041,
0.4881331921,
0.7409848571,
-0.1429488212,
-0.7952085733,
-0.0997117683,
-0.2608608305,
-0.9244492054,
0.6071059704,
0.3264627755,
-0.3218042254,
0.2009237111,
-0.5852389932,
-0.5756954551,
0.9151937366,
0.6875699162,
-0.4431554675,
-0.069167465,
0.3290250301,
0.472286731,
-0.0815237463,
-0.0785787478,
0.2450345755,
0.2835848331,
0.1841081977,
-0.5560272336,
0.1448702812,
-0.5809961557,
0.0260613002,
0.6320222616,
-0.2556467354,
0.7910444736,
-0.129919976,
0.026105009,
0.1339759827,
0.6019627452,
0.2862477601,
0.3989250362,
0.3464994133,
1.0368344784,
0.3435974121,
-0.2067712396,
0.9408538342,
-0.2722702622,
0.4291428924,
0.7512174845,
0.0031794207,
0.9442671537,
0.5371990204,
-0.2041561455,
0.4935315847,
-0.050794296,
-0.1689478606,
0.4118828475,
0.8489472866,
-0.1859404892,
-0.297414273,
0.1249958351,
-0.4331450164,
0.5571246743,
0.1558018029,
-0.1945029646,
-0.4395054877,
-0.1252842247,
-0.0182587076,
0.1555324197,
-0.3031073511,
0.6762104034,
0.1519712061,
-0.2864414155,
0.5777994394,
0.3192093968,
0.8802531958,
-0.8080702424,
-0.3606332541,
-0.2455117553,
0.5271887183,
-0.1669557393,
-0.4991818666,
0.6256298423,
-0.062820904,
-0.0767268166,
-0.2468790114,
0.7957594395,
-0.4142019153,
-0.7951665521,
-0.0374367386,
0.6167372465,
-0.1860605031,
-0.2579056025,
-0.7357364893,
-0.2578772008,
-0.4807597995,
0.0932021365,
0.0715008005,
0.7877048254,
0.3193615675,
0.6291199923,
0.6450588107,
-0.1626423746,
0.1417409182,
0.1829211563,
0.8398968577,
-0.7462002039,
-0.5124226213,
-1.0030997992,
0.3443295956,
-0.0355929099,
-0.5498116612,
0.6054957509,
0.577778101,
0.6944842935,
-0.0792166516,
0.1465400159,
-0.0203612242,
-0.1892889589,
-0.6105328798,
0.7949165106,
-0.6032245755,
0.1882565767,
-0.2903039157,
-0.8196091056,
-0.5862793326,
0.8605393767,
-0.008838892,
-0.0873665512,
0.6549171209,
0.5364181399,
-0.1152228862,
0.1788302362,
0.2240199745,
-0.2834822536,
0.1997236609,
0.8169457912,
0.8782251477,
-0.7787061334,
0.8824815154,
-0.3064612448,
0.091386959,
0.0666950122,
-0.8752766252,
-0.6160956621,
-0.1208553091,
-0.4513911605,
-0.2876811922,
-0.1822366118,
0.9995452762,
0.5010768771,
-0.6628754139,
-0.1794608533,
-0.4911138415,
0.0213367064,
-0.4292700887,
-0.2611027062,
0.2088766992,
-0.491035074,
-0.4535629451,
0.1521312743,
0.3488303125,
0.0365985408,
-0.0280686747,
-0.1775318235,
0.0577921458,
0.4025004804,
0.819724381,
-0.0721585155,
-0.2901498973,
-0.0263015553,
0.3367153108,
0.0193652585,
0.1551180631,
1.1531971693,
-0.7729990482,
0.4414108992,
0.7104019523,
1.2219839096,
0.3774052262,
-0.2847825587,
0.66799891,
-0.7476201653,
-0.0246073417,
0.6195888519,
0.6121832728,
0.2720113993,
-0.1069662869,
0.3470582366,
0.2173027694,
-0.0900038406,
-0.499147296,
0.3270591795,
-0.7120993137,
-0.3792339861,
0.6537894607,
-0.1595068276,
-0.1935670525,
0.0152148772,
-0.2667134106,
0.1109546274,
-0.1238631606,
0.8809460402,
0.719258368,
-0.1298385859,
-0.2333235145,
-0.2931698263,
0.0666069463,
0.9829468727,
-0.852129519,
0.0315186083,
0.2961540818,
0.0395809412,
0.4247362912,
0.3869563341,
-0.44311288,
0.3161768615,
0.1161813363,
-0.1598043889,
-0.5230891705,
0.0805337206,
-0.5221536756,
0.3716579378,
-0.3406471908,
-0.4996525347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03126v1 | Context-Gloss Augmentation for Improving Arabic Target Sense Verification | 2023-02-06T21:24:02 | 2023-02-06T21:24:02 | Sanad Malaysha, Mustafa Jarrar, Mohammed Khalilia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Arabic language lacks semantic datasets and sense inventories. The most
common semantically-labeled dataset for Arabic is the ArabGlossBERT, a
relatively small dataset that consists of 167K context-gloss pairs (about 60K
positive and 107K negative pairs), collected from Arabic dictionaries. This
paper presents an enrichment to the ArabGlossBERT dataset, by augmenting it
using (Arabic-English-Arabic) machine back-translation. Augmentation increased
the dataset size to 352K pairs (149K positive and 203K negative pairs). We
measure the impact of augmentation using different data configurations to
fine-tune BERT on target sense verification (TSV) task. Overall, the accuracy
ranges between 78% to 84% for different data configurations. Although our
approach performed at par with the baseline, we did observe some improvements
for some POS tags in some experiments. Furthermore, our fine-tuned models are
trained on a larger dataset covering larger vocabulary and contexts. We provide
an in-depth analysis of the accuracy for each part-of-speech (POS). | [
-0.5714098811,
-0.4430240393,
0.273622036,
-0.043048583,
-0.3562403917,
0.0898411795,
-0.352986306,
-0.643193543,
0.0147497104,
0.1277130842,
-0.2932558358,
-0.9833737612,
-0.8538649082,
0.1152509823,
-0.4999665916,
0.9753491282,
-0.1785377264,
-0.1704080403,
0.2417663038,
-0.4776007235,
-0.4311153293,
-0.4809821844,
-0.2861579657,
-0.0939989015,
0.4380819798,
0.7409320474,
0.9279634356,
0.4428294897,
0.1615645289,
0.2286604345,
-0.1416301578,
0.5812911391,
-0.2692706585,
-0.0138055747,
-0.1612994969,
0.0357549004,
-0.3239246011,
-0.173423171,
0.6364277005,
0.7449637651,
0.1182009801,
0.042386841,
-0.0190204959,
0.6007044315,
-0.9169762135,
-0.0603249595,
-0.4973047972,
-0.2755025625,
-0.1267082542,
0.2522494495,
-0.068311587,
0.0164031424,
0.3998102248,
-0.4671784639,
0.0270025413,
0.0153867202,
1.0148819685,
0.3186495006,
-0.5626948476,
-0.2726446092,
-0.6959415078,
0.9314997792,
-0.6403131485,
0.5797315836,
0.6183245182,
0.1567767411,
-0.086067602,
-0.566316843,
-0.6105791926,
-0.4230495393,
-0.1952740848,
0.111603722,
-0.1354277134,
0.077587299,
0.323954016,
0.1732502729,
-0.3816275299,
-0.1851370335,
-0.1065660119,
-0.3635207117,
0.7446684837,
-0.2656311989,
0.4062999487,
0.0846702531,
-0.2127630711,
-0.3414970636,
-0.6534677744,
-0.0011790331,
0.2379875779,
0.2760363221,
0.0024143069,
0.5584610105,
-0.442974478,
1.0275872946,
-0.0510832779,
-0.0781225488,
0.4135605395,
-0.5538733602,
-0.2573850155,
0.4142411053,
0.0860162005,
0.2122522444,
0.2046886384,
-0.0462584309,
-0.3694370687,
-0.0418568812,
0.1822475791,
-0.763692677,
-0.1103734374,
0.4083621502,
-0.0586455166,
0.1621652693,
0.1991246343,
0.0729899555,
-0.1469076127,
-0.4368443787,
0.6893451214,
-0.8953076601,
0.0856577531,
0.2058830559,
-0.1075860932,
0.3764756322,
0.6037377715,
-0.5358136296,
0.0436763726,
0.6890342832,
0.8856215477,
-0.0119304759,
-0.285127908,
-0.6144919991,
0.2281146944,
-0.415006429,
0.4217372835,
-0.5824522972,
-0.2884683609,
0.1078416109,
-0.3659362793,
0.223960042,
-0.5299102664,
0.9126188159,
-0.5319986939,
0.0640856028,
-0.3215396106,
-0.6024931073,
-0.3985075057,
0.2895914018,
-0.4044062793,
1.0321450233,
0.3263611197,
-0.3959663212,
0.6919377446,
-0.6465570331,
-0.8655486703,
0.0892207846,
-0.1501542032,
-0.2829197645,
0.2372597158,
0.7912587523,
0.1402582675,
0.1080577001,
0.0682205036,
0.0932058468,
-0.5132684112,
0.2361508459,
-0.2747460306,
0.4970937967,
0.2536982596,
-0.2595219016,
0.1417923272,
-0.7655599117,
0.1088794544,
-0.4515314996,
-0.2277103812,
-0.5221960545,
-0.0851063579,
0.2855075896,
0.2931802273,
0.5897539854,
-0.7174585462,
0.1326430887,
-0.8558362126,
0.1271739453,
0.4948525429,
-0.1477506161,
0.3264788091,
-0.3433780372,
0.2457986027,
0.265134424,
0.0769939572,
0.0061089443,
-0.4370677173,
-0.8015960455,
-0.4741076827,
0.6024637818,
0.3745549917,
-0.8627089262,
0.7913140059,
-0.3934382796,
-0.5367261767,
-0.3896274269,
0.0347391069,
0.1931892037,
0.6584473252,
0.5871496201,
-0.3845832646,
-0.4977046251,
-1.1262425184,
-0.292121321,
0.0889850929,
-0.3322882652,
0.4124138355,
0.5612027049,
-0.2472063452,
1.1090773344,
-0.3563888669,
-0.4762246609,
0.0569250323,
0.1537578404,
0.3386928439,
0.4852076769,
0.4642451406,
-0.829003334,
-0.6332119107,
0.0719097108,
-0.250780791,
-0.0760748759,
0.2452435344,
0.0198197179,
0.3376152813,
0.2245481312,
-0.1710829288,
0.7170725465,
0.6221956611,
-0.3825101554,
0.4015308917,
-0.2023735344,
0.2306562364,
-0.9753097296,
0.1701044887,
-0.043424502,
-0.1729056239,
-0.8426335454,
-0.0368091501,
0.1089608148,
-0.0171182975,
-0.5408947468,
0.6152442098,
-0.304359436,
-0.1963028759,
-0.4855683446,
0.1410620958,
-0.0414177142,
0.3014737964,
0.0106467176,
1.2436565161,
0.718288064,
-0.6418892145,
0.2032846212,
0.3679879606,
-0.7648202181,
0.5116564035,
-0.8264060616,
0.2163660079,
-0.1492927223,
0.2275247872,
-1.2536923885,
-0.3269407451,
0.1884237677,
-0.5039835572,
0.1850823015,
-0.0408120714,
-0.5849218965,
0.0905416012,
-0.1976609975,
0.5432966352,
0.5662056208,
-0.728616178,
0.7475728393,
0.1874970347,
0.059625335,
-0.8061010242,
-0.4569436014,
0.2510697842,
-0.1401402801,
-0.8143947124,
0.6627650261,
0.2122876197,
-0.1454392374,
-0.28515625,
-0.4700985551,
0.1623031646,
0.2011306733,
0.3291136622,
0.0439823233,
0.0948065668,
0.4929727018,
0.1680038422,
0.0962290019,
-0.2186162323,
-0.5477191806,
0.5712599754,
-0.2388787866,
-0.3613332808,
-0.2775684297,
0.3392019868,
0.2931367755,
-0.3068163097,
0.8754252791,
0.8806222081,
-0.4682035148,
0.0632671714,
-0.316433996,
-0.3757058084,
-0.4678586721,
0.3980061412,
-0.5260127783,
-0.7567666173,
0.4849885404,
0.0460035615,
-0.0122883888,
0.3430717289,
0.2582238019,
-0.0583478622,
1.3634446859,
0.3477126956,
-0.4268552363,
0.4980913401,
-0.06923794,
0.1128642485,
-0.7351743579,
0.0262439884,
-0.5100169778,
-0.5938996077,
-0.3371583223,
-0.2224793285,
0.6782931685,
0.1576640159,
-0.2833265364,
0.2932336926,
-0.4249375761,
0.1630333066,
0.7648848891,
0.3297606409,
0.2252407521,
0.425430268,
-0.0007126203,
0.0208673887,
-0.5428064466,
-0.5004040599,
1.0158780813,
0.1787727773,
0.3975212276,
0.5724822879,
0.6334283948,
0.5746945739,
0.3173072636,
-0.9201004505,
0.3877646327,
-0.1027832627,
-0.4207839668,
-0.4308592677,
-0.0661242157,
-0.976061821,
-0.0362142548,
-0.0191245805,
-0.8377299309,
0.1632958055,
0.2357467115,
-0.2703534961,
-0.4018021822,
-0.86779809,
0.5804951191,
-0.2487243563,
-0.252111882,
-0.2168314904,
-0.7147789598,
-0.0445383415,
-0.0171663016,
-0.1252893806,
-0.0784500912,
-0.3601060212,
0.8405827284,
-0.7630234361,
0.5369466543,
-0.2158804685,
-0.6139439344,
0.1783076227,
-0.2151497304,
0.6944490671,
-0.0450527631,
-0.0337580442,
0.4115145206,
-0.1967534423,
-0.627399683,
-0.6016530991,
0.5899786949,
-0.9455000162,
-0.6237649322,
-0.5596261621,
-0.7243917584,
-0.6094115973,
0.0640837476,
0.0999853611,
0.4621551633,
0.0704379305,
0.1340122521,
0.2282987237,
-0.1614746153,
0.0785133392,
0.6082094312,
-0.0435359888,
-0.3942528069,
0.8624401093,
0.1063568145,
0.0158496145,
0.2986941934,
-0.0358356684,
-0.5708665252,
-0.7774726152,
-0.4444624186,
-0.0588913523,
-0.6605583429,
-0.110301204,
-0.2491651177,
-0.1955988258,
-0.4616066515,
0.0370234661,
-0.0490148365,
-0.3312780559,
-0.1146343574,
0.123114422,
0.7353429794,
0.3224925399,
-0.1226740927,
0.6000429392,
-0.8287403584,
0.1348067075,
0.110300459,
0.2259005457,
-0.3164761961,
-1.0386561155,
-0.554538548,
0.3993129134,
0.1062609479,
-0.7565677166,
0.4284546375,
0.4446452856,
0.0168973394,
0.3874612749,
0.0456494093,
0.8134208322,
-0.417026937,
0.6825262904,
-0.223497346,
-1.2909806967,
0.8021281958,
-0.2012871355,
0.651009798,
0.4963827133,
0.3453342617,
-0.6012769938,
-0.2565205693,
-0.6213131547,
-0.9439863563,
0.7563506365,
0.5294281244,
0.0528541245,
0.1792080551,
0.3360635936,
-0.0569332875,
0.2142538577,
0.1221357509,
-0.4415731132,
-0.1966447979,
-0.500641644,
-0.479922235,
-0.0696152151,
-0.3320060372,
-0.3482746482,
0.7611130476,
-0.2017131895,
-0.0115790898,
0.3200477362,
-0.3360218108,
0.2027570307,
0.317787677,
0.8980692625,
0.8297622204,
-0.4309719503,
0.1118847579,
0.2525768876,
-0.6571046114,
0.089650102,
0.525254488,
-0.3210521042,
0.134409681,
0.3007861972,
0.7525067329,
-0.3566711545,
-0.9871556759,
0.2792396843,
0.2388586551,
-0.0133798663,
-0.3136499822,
0.1193992868,
-0.4101724625,
0.1294371337,
0.749761641,
0.0586093478,
0.3067893088,
-0.2810844183,
0.4144945443,
0.4938261807,
-0.2499002814,
-0.0115264524,
0.1005055606,
0.1399286389,
-0.1291836202,
0.5240790248,
-0.0113545284,
-0.6846315861,
0.5790216327,
0.3040288389,
0.395165503,
-0.1322031319,
0.0083301794,
0.4468438029,
0.2519285679,
0.321254313,
0.4213458002,
-0.3470848799,
-1.0185244083,
-0.4987217188,
-0.3843342662,
-0.5237765908,
0.3404405415,
-0.559119463,
0.1352431029,
-0.2170905769,
-0.141645506,
-0.0884632692,
0.1735942513,
-0.6760236621,
0.4988259077,
0.0986451283,
0.9126014113,
-0.7845499516,
1.0165013075,
1.0074547529,
-0.2631993592,
-0.7880336046,
0.1622126102,
-0.3324297369,
-1.1608241796,
0.8883348703,
0.3419505358,
-0.2378695905,
0.1521090865,
-0.6103799939,
-1.0677882433,
0.7557829618,
-0.0190639645,
-0.6516473889,
0.4380048513,
0.2370349765,
0.5688139796,
-0.1909047216,
0.137929678,
0.7610204816,
0.6133711338,
0.0628883392,
-0.8248756528,
0.0503680855,
-0.0570685603,
0.0537078641,
0.3191289604,
-0.1680321842,
0.5818547606,
0.039801944,
-0.3325493038,
0.1062136143,
0.9564101696,
0.1633127034,
0.1097221896,
0.6687075496,
0.5969779491,
0.6180858612,
-0.2122096419,
0.789957583,
-0.6165142059,
0.1745823324,
1.2467300892,
-0.3912777305,
0.8201805353,
0.630410552,
-0.1067064628,
0.4183252752,
0.5868262053,
0.0546880327,
0.5227912664,
0.1881599873,
-0.6045646071,
-0.1759776622,
-0.5567811131,
-0.4586719573,
0.7374671102,
0.828102529,
-0.3613744676,
-0.3274741173,
0.2045443505,
-0.1125274077,
0.0281399731,
-0.3121544719,
0.6384240985,
-0.2842079401,
-0.8343164325,
0.9496766925,
0.3472977579,
0.4348081052,
-0.4627720118,
-0.0227309261,
-0.1664066464,
0.1921816021,
-0.1618329138,
-0.8235833049,
0.1321907789,
-0.0827592388,
0.1635722965,
0.0339644812,
0.9033378959,
-0.6526364684,
-0.2978525758,
-0.1873716414,
0.5068306327,
0.0333752073,
-0.3281512558,
-0.5519916415,
0.1709320694,
-0.0868537053,
0.1341346055,
0.0316933766,
0.1202719584,
0.0471275188,
0.3693908155,
0.4935470819,
0.0745464191,
-0.2579453588,
0.213415578,
0.7265188694,
-0.5318359137,
-0.288138032,
-0.7732286453,
0.3614529371,
-0.274535954,
-0.3424243033,
1.1420470476,
0.5081151724,
0.9274759889,
-0.041665677,
0.8540930748,
-0.0103651704,
0.3842371404,
-0.465901196,
0.3901065886,
-0.5619694591,
0.1003638357,
-0.0890057981,
-0.7375807762,
-0.3693522215,
0.756675303,
-0.5934420228,
0.2992190421,
0.2708042264,
0.9768579006,
-0.0918189883,
-0.0952325314,
0.3942539394,
0.1606243253,
0.1650198251,
0.6599541903,
0.9497193694,
-0.633559823,
0.3661994636,
-0.2356197536,
-0.2409395874,
-0.490758121,
-0.721157968,
-0.8239593506,
-0.6198498011,
-0.3772253096,
-0.5522062778,
0.178275764,
0.9100884199,
0.8026154637,
-1.0170221329,
0.0091077667,
-0.1851547658,
-0.0936729982,
-0.4339108467,
-0.1805229485,
0.6958360672,
-0.3042691052,
-0.8686230779,
0.419644177,
0.2289586514,
0.1988506913,
0.0216883831,
-0.1905738562,
-0.289378494,
-0.0525410958,
0.7487867475,
0.3172702491,
-0.7692046762,
-0.7649616599,
-0.1981671751,
-0.0468932949,
0.1469310224,
0.3773879707,
-0.9679840803,
0.3928939104,
0.2196812332,
0.6659591198,
0.2799186409,
0.3236321211,
0.561165452,
-1.3704752922,
0.2882079482,
0.255641222,
0.4497847259,
0.4308452904,
-0.0208537634,
0.4496475458,
-0.1931476444,
-0.2474174649,
-0.4880033135,
0.515602231,
-0.9731020331,
-0.0857880488,
1.0878748894,
0.0038575751,
-0.0364221111,
-0.3453676403,
-0.5677130818,
0.3087589443,
-0.7773698568,
0.7458533049,
0.9703925848,
-0.0933915824,
0.0925920978,
-0.066500023,
0.6840085983,
1.0074650049,
-0.6781284213,
-0.3454397023,
0.6272652149,
0.0174493026,
0.3758240938,
0.0794390738,
0.427110523,
0.4479979277,
-0.321400106,
-0.1773022413,
-0.0210067183,
-0.3667743206,
-0.2984865606,
0.1002641469,
0.2631634772,
-0.494586587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03106v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03106v3 | Efficient and Flexible Topic Modeling using Pretrained Embeddings and Bag of Sentences | 2023-02-06T20:13:11 | 2024-02-10T17:45:03 | Johannes Schneider | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pre-trained language models have led to a new state-of-the-art in many NLP
tasks. However, for topic modeling, statistical generative models such as LDA
are still prevalent, which do not easily allow incorporating contextual word
vectors. They might yield topics that do not align well with human judgment. In
this work, we propose a novel topic modeling and inference algorithm. We
suggest a bag of sentences (BoS) approach using sentences as the unit of
analysis. We leverage pre-trained sentence embeddings by combining generative
process models and clustering. We derive a fast inference algorithm based on
expectation maximization, hard assignments, and an annealing process. The
evaluation shows that our method yields state-of-the art results with
relatively little computational demands. Our method is also more flexible
compared to prior works leveraging word embeddings, since it provides the
possibility to customize topic-document distributions using priors. Code and
data is at \url{https://github.com/JohnTailor/BertSenClu}. | [
-0.320291698,
-1.1272526979,
0.6733624935,
0.0601795278,
-0.4223005176,
-0.1860037148,
-0.2841697633,
0.1462103277,
0.4366985261,
0.5031428933,
-0.384950608,
-0.6277116537,
-0.5210453272,
-0.2691987455,
-0.4912695885,
1.1042658091,
0.1444517672,
-0.2088987082,
-0.3621026576,
0.0348675847,
-0.3437311053,
-0.5497986078,
-0.0938160792,
-0.0040424927,
0.5371196866,
0.2390235066,
0.3366122842,
0.3002646565,
0.3583906889,
0.3015976548,
-0.2706307173,
-0.0751312971,
-0.3978148401,
0.1024095267,
-0.3200612962,
-0.4361419082,
-0.41237849,
0.0351600498,
0.6383126974,
1.0145386457,
-0.5281124711,
-0.1694183052,
-0.0673665032,
0.3630676866,
-0.6778196096,
-0.3448560238,
-0.9382358193,
0.0966076031,
-0.1871792078,
-0.1774624735,
-0.4699240625,
-0.1880082339,
0.4571745098,
-0.4733203351,
0.4463152289,
-0.0931275636,
0.934025526,
0.0658786669,
-0.2490866482,
-0.3364760876,
-0.5622811913,
0.8216677308,
-0.5888854861,
0.2228811979,
0.5111064315,
-0.0556597151,
-0.1065667048,
-0.9531685114,
-0.5813673139,
0.071438916,
-0.077411063,
0.0652325675,
-0.2349535376,
-0.187623769,
0.0506960042,
0.2806505561,
-0.8045402169,
0.0781152099,
-0.167664215,
0.2915548086,
0.606304884,
-0.2192932963,
0.2280766219,
-0.3774602711,
-0.4104330838,
0.0380418152,
-0.4187166095,
-0.3677930534,
0.4847236872,
0.1957137436,
-0.023282744,
0.6495835781,
-0.1549417526,
0.6671255827,
-0.1112260595,
0.2822925746,
0.2389012873,
-0.2563099861,
-0.2476642877,
-0.2242005318,
0.4303518534,
0.1459173262,
-0.0735540092,
-0.31207183,
-0.0725989044,
0.1563887745,
0.593355298,
-0.9268682599,
-0.4132553339,
0.3102681041,
-0.5412379503,
-0.1935007125,
0.2318563014,
-0.870654285,
-0.0248109326,
-0.1106704473,
0.2675009966,
-0.463926971,
-0.239132911,
0.2660011947,
-0.104894273,
0.0311796013,
0.157352075,
-0.9851970673,
0.2099384964,
0.7090147734,
0.9290859103,
-0.2617063224,
-0.05931646,
-0.5000090599,
0.125929147,
-0.3085693419,
0.9776087999,
-0.7512103915,
-0.4279306531,
0.0445177369,
-0.0974342823,
-0.0518483408,
-0.2589129508,
0.4418578744,
-0.6070628762,
0.3662936985,
-0.0072246683,
-0.9260904789,
0.0680215582,
0.2531123161,
-0.3555930257,
0.6726004481,
-0.2734335661,
-0.9656952024,
0.3097612262,
-0.6509354115,
-0.3269608617,
0.0467080995,
-0.2240898311,
-0.5115795732,
0.1686038971,
0.2648244202,
0.7332380414,
0.0238349251,
0.786837101,
-0.496707201,
-0.1095642298,
0.2060435861,
-0.293651253,
0.55537045,
0.4789468646,
0.3210247755,
0.5121228099,
-0.4992321134,
-0.0984848365,
0.0563027263,
0.0046474449,
-0.5240879059,
0.3710769415,
0.0628218949,
-0.2226776928,
0.1817477793,
-0.303214699,
0.4893787205,
-0.4225623012,
0.5198047161,
0.735426724,
0.1082707942,
0.7986451387,
-0.1549840868,
0.4936334193,
-0.0567488149,
-0.2118571252,
-0.5684621334,
-0.4490061998,
-0.3621697426,
-0.4683980346,
0.5514481068,
0.5229189992,
-0.4632012546,
1.1118658781,
-0.1726278812,
-0.4983471632,
-0.0778944045,
-0.1350446939,
-0.061201226,
0.0348352976,
0.1373668313,
-0.3878480792,
-0.3240608573,
-0.6930272579,
0.0496584289,
-0.0073475335,
-0.3696037233,
-0.0912515596,
0.4738021195,
-0.1987697184,
1.2484223843,
-1.1121647358,
0.0107011963,
-0.4449997544,
0.5974799395,
0.1924135834,
0.7138403654,
0.5763516426,
-0.9978868365,
-0.1023568809,
-0.2192680836,
-0.4884062111,
-0.0782208815,
-0.2448700815,
-0.441110462,
-0.0171364862,
0.6002538204,
-0.6132257581,
0.5892947912,
0.346578747,
-0.4611139894,
0.3792945147,
-0.5146310329,
-0.314489305,
-1.451151371,
-0.023644913,
0.1712129563,
-0.2756940722,
-0.4351176023,
0.0340907834,
-0.1883929521,
-0.4429017305,
-0.0984877944,
0.4190063179,
-0.4001532197,
-0.1633284986,
-0.4854335189,
0.1916673034,
-0.0707504749,
0.4539738894,
0.3568535149,
0.2756989002,
0.6719436049,
-0.4702900648,
0.0691723973,
0.3750856817,
-0.4986852109,
0.3632772863,
-0.635484755,
0.1421071887,
-0.3829234242,
0.469328016,
-0.934343636,
-0.0272283014,
0.0884348825,
-0.0663874,
0.2936383784,
-0.1151583865,
-0.5223614573,
-0.2185416371,
-0.2684157789,
0.1107577235,
0.5053906441,
-0.2377932966,
0.5733041763,
0.5230416656,
-0.5720123053,
-0.2823933363,
-0.4422445595,
-0.1264734566,
-0.4289756417,
-0.3346561491,
0.8482921124,
-0.2543462813,
-0.0929773971,
0.3083544075,
-0.1157499105,
-0.4693225324,
0.2094394714,
0.038552206,
0.1655097902,
-0.0409464799,
0.5666944385,
0.1406836063,
-0.0976870656,
-0.3641736507,
-0.2741637528,
0.7534530163,
-0.1611037403,
-0.2292927206,
-0.2814112902,
0.6886054873,
0.0782147273,
-0.5103639364,
0.8052842617,
0.5637522936,
-0.5757524371,
-0.3056325316,
-0.3839465976,
-0.4244278073,
-0.4400137365,
0.5315838456,
-0.3545638025,
-0.6798855662,
0.3061382174,
-0.1690611094,
0.0827399641,
0.0936908424,
0.353212595,
-0.1127777696,
0.4615035951,
0.9572533369,
0.1446589231,
0.7805880308,
-0.3633701205,
0.5095843077,
-0.5267618299,
0.1779070348,
-0.5718368888,
-0.1284870654,
-0.6808561087,
-0.6620112062,
-0.0312914886,
0.5541667342,
0.1171619892,
0.1041689292,
-0.3877232075,
0.485494554,
0.5396715403,
0.0352398083,
-0.0708479583,
0.2054448277,
0.119631134,
0.1673280448,
-0.8900749683,
-0.8674452305,
0.9588214755,
0.2511078417,
0.5581765771,
-0.1447807997,
0.8068162799,
0.3109596074,
0.4051420987,
-0.4575581551,
0.616559267,
-0.5272498727,
-0.5410611629,
-0.5194370151,
-0.1747757345,
-1.0220811367,
0.4743829668,
-0.3774610758,
-1.06216681,
0.1785515398,
-0.0472597629,
-0.4100635052,
0.4456855059,
-0.8655757308,
1.1419456005,
-0.0197330564,
-0.2819620371,
-0.3280211389,
-0.5229661465,
-0.0307969674,
-0.2335327119,
-0.0764688849,
-0.3084053397,
0.1554359198,
0.8508281708,
-0.3749192357,
0.8680140376,
-0.1485501528,
0.0598753616,
0.3449802101,
-0.4776009917,
0.2057081312,
0.0976206809,
-0.2840368748,
0.0428500362,
0.0394646637,
-0.6235787868,
-0.7805991769,
0.4538362324,
-0.4065753222,
-0.6168527007,
-0.4924372435,
-0.4876880348,
-0.0307574384,
0.2243233919,
0.1296920627,
0.2273567915,
-0.3819747865,
0.4100420177,
0.4790817499,
-0.5419870019,
0.6375780106,
0.3770524859,
-0.3502566218,
0.0718595088,
0.8300212622,
0.1455527544,
-0.1247117966,
0.7019371986,
0.360011816,
-0.1041502208,
-0.6872525811,
-0.0494414829,
0.1014110371,
-0.4004130661,
0.0117519833,
-0.9740398526,
-0.0756159723,
-0.4788463414,
-0.5445629358,
-0.3186760843,
-0.2056613266,
-0.3550783098,
-0.3469632864,
0.1378547549,
0.3996194303,
0.0280141719,
0.5206698179,
-0.6868645549,
0.5047554374,
0.3258956969,
0.1836647391,
-0.0633956492,
-0.2170539051,
0.1077589244,
-0.1755210906,
-0.5067195892,
-1.1606488228,
0.4622962773,
0.0789403841,
0.5829774141,
0.5766288638,
0.2897829115,
0.5040248036,
-0.5553008914,
0.7319566011,
0.0666244999,
-1.0665578842,
0.8468561172,
-0.2511720061,
0.0586850829,
0.3350847363,
0.4900770485,
-0.3050999939,
-0.2111920118,
-0.7019677162,
-1.1440410614,
0.4595209062,
0.3752770126,
0.3209002912,
-0.2594087422,
0.332760185,
0.3799160421,
0.3907592595,
-0.6874892116,
0.0273546092,
-0.1464340538,
-0.2249192148,
-0.2513231933,
-0.4493616819,
0.2334193736,
-0.2216359079,
0.7264227867,
-0.0748763233,
0.3414070308,
0.0099374624,
-0.1605918854,
0.3330335617,
0.3967278302,
0.4044751227,
0.8207998276,
-0.424813956,
0.0503372662,
0.1524767429,
-0.1128926948,
-0.004417846,
0.4416519701,
-0.2112819552,
0.0821739212,
0.2756070495,
0.789857626,
0.1195520237,
-0.654340446,
0.5929993987,
0.0398239866,
-0.0179485492,
-0.2618158758,
-0.1649812162,
0.2164894044,
0.2790083587,
0.3245544434,
-0.1890658289,
0.0089426246,
-0.6280764937,
0.5486025214,
0.3185681403,
-0.0241939295,
-0.1996926367,
0.4061812162,
0.3584104478,
-0.2610522509,
0.5722952485,
-0.4697867632,
-0.4115946293,
0.5385357141,
0.4680786133,
0.8408095837,
-0.2752142549,
0.6603713036,
0.1204509139,
0.0338769518,
0.0423283465,
0.2416433841,
-0.096405983,
-0.9047792554,
-0.4077983201,
-0.8495414853,
-0.1853474826,
0.101666376,
-0.6963657737,
0.1800376624,
-0.0899171755,
-0.0782270059,
0.1563896984,
-0.0225294102,
-0.4727276862,
0.2130720913,
-0.0169116966,
0.6484847665,
-0.9787012935,
1.025292635,
0.8367217779,
-0.1497598588,
-0.2337103635,
0.4050129056,
-0.623355329,
-0.2153775692,
0.5234655738,
0.3605126739,
0.3350406885,
-0.0088492306,
-0.313788414,
-0.6286967993,
0.7858453393,
0.1996593028,
-0.6555431485,
-0.2002580017,
-0.3356960118,
0.4391801059,
-0.3977174163,
0.0929384977,
0.1077616662,
0.1936414093,
0.0250970833,
-0.2354554087,
-0.1686671376,
-0.3052286506,
0.1593812108,
0.0986083969,
-0.1589554548,
0.6604975462,
-0.1119131222,
-0.1316441447,
0.2323793471,
1.068439126,
0.3782339096,
0.4836358428,
0.713131547,
0.67514956,
1.0603944063,
0.009480386,
1.0479172468,
-0.0981571823,
0.4297781587,
1.1200296879,
-0.5820732713,
1.0038566589,
0.3471933901,
-0.1736664772,
0.5482820868,
0.6693929434,
-0.033054404,
0.8833771944,
0.6378158927,
-0.1635546982,
-0.264955014,
0.011479279,
-0.34688887,
0.5332177281,
0.3844133615,
-0.1412043273,
-0.1864929497,
0.1889707148,
-0.1751827896,
0.1676820219,
0.0521247201,
0.6500613689,
-0.01807932,
-0.6016107798,
-0.0257317219,
0.2636488676,
0.8823978901,
-0.6880376339,
-0.0349997319,
-0.1902027279,
-0.0267138705,
0.1505328566,
-0.4924583733,
0.5454702377,
0.2293481678,
-0.2548146248,
-0.5894776583,
0.7556296587,
-0.5779902935,
-0.7066056728,
-0.0416838303,
0.5167675614,
0.2635351419,
-0.0997779593,
-0.3794509768,
-0.1353658587,
-0.1981551498,
-0.4324817955,
0.1604413539,
0.4264957607,
-0.1215380728,
0.3854462206,
0.5422651768,
-0.0234623048,
-0.0643467382,
-0.0356792621,
0.6188876629,
-0.7312358618,
-1.069259882,
-0.7202510238,
0.4496470094,
-0.2578579187,
-0.2609239519,
0.3340780735,
0.5637606978,
0.7197985649,
-0.1444470733,
0.6202859879,
-0.0400834531,
0.4418247938,
-0.7695655227,
0.6736069322,
-0.612709105,
0.2431788594,
-0.3778030872,
-0.9470593333,
-0.2210112363,
1.0338172913,
-0.4724182487,
-0.0131241111,
0.7743879557,
0.5563910604,
-0.1770853698,
0.270491153,
0.2443599701,
0.1139257476,
0.4166058898,
0.264008671,
0.6227431893,
0.069654271,
0.1613077968,
-0.364808768,
-0.1951489747,
-0.3516311049,
-1.2177282572,
-0.8103765845,
-0.7566196918,
-0.6165240407,
0.3450081944,
0.1368047893,
0.739541173,
1.0817450285,
-0.6099286079,
0.0649474785,
-0.3903546333,
0.2614788115,
-0.1173151135,
-0.2109756768,
0.7165993452,
-0.3193738759,
-0.7440859079,
0.2690870464,
0.023127595,
0.0918005779,
-0.0234013349,
0.2473253012,
-0.5151877403,
0.1438934654,
0.7857585549,
-0.1208536103,
-0.7059031725,
-0.1408705413,
-0.2467873991,
0.1436931044,
-0.2256924063,
0.9283127785,
-0.5941967964,
0.2537498772,
0.5587084293,
0.8140922785,
0.7884879112,
0.1014533713,
0.7651584148,
-0.9457280636,
0.3833011091,
0.2192345858,
0.4571052194,
0.2215853781,
-0.1418116093,
0.4725129902,
0.2204275578,
-0.2624685466,
-0.9817664027,
0.2972635329,
-1.0369532108,
-0.947255373,
0.8511229753,
-0.3848623931,
-0.0374286249,
0.3035670221,
-0.0891978517,
0.3648003936,
-0.1369332373,
0.8741015196,
0.7482171655,
0.205439046,
-0.0052300878,
-0.4105626047,
-0.0365209952,
0.7411239147,
-1.210562706,
-0.1351216584,
0.3738825917,
0.0191058423,
0.2569297552,
0.6623626947,
0.3347159624,
-0.1844047308,
-0.1262083799,
0.0220484156,
0.3552121222,
-0.5465365052,
-0.1401478201,
0.441464901,
-0.3538453281,
-0.4495132565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03488v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03488v2 | APAM: Adaptive Pre-training and Adaptive Meta Learning in Language Model for Noisy Labels and Long-tailed Learning | 2023-02-06T18:40:04 | 2023-05-02T22:29:38 | Sunyi Chi, Bo Dong, Yiming Xu, Zhenyu Shi, Zheng Du | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Practical natural language processing (NLP) tasks are commonly long-tailed
with noisy labels. Those problems challenge the generalization and robustness
of complex models such as Deep Neural Networks (DNNs). Some commonly used
resampling techniques, such as oversampling or undersampling, could easily lead
to overfitting. It is growing popular to learn the data weights leveraging a
small amount of metadata. Besides, recent studies have shown the advantages of
self-supervised pre-training, particularly to the under-represented data. In
this work, we propose a general framework to handle the problem of both
long-tail and noisy labels. The model is adapted to the domain of problems in a
contrastive learning manner. The re-weighting module is a feed-forward network
that learns explicit weighting functions and adapts weights according to
metadata. The framework further adapts weights of terms in the loss function
through a combination of the polynomial expansion of cross-entropy loss and
focal loss. Our extensive experiments show that the proposed framework
consistently outperforms baseline methods. Lastly, our sensitive analysis
emphasizes the capability of the proposed framework to handle the long-tailed
problem and mitigate the negative impact of noisy labels. | [
-0.3106940985,
-0.6435861588,
0.3477229774,
0.4157963395,
-0.2745023966,
-0.1276959777,
-0.2637102306,
-0.3197030723,
0.3969655037,
0.6155620217,
-0.539558053,
-0.416413039,
-0.7944094539,
0.4125731587,
-0.2449320108,
1.144728899,
-0.1114140674,
-0.2420720607,
-0.0082836589,
-0.3923713565,
-0.2683629096,
-0.514066875,
-0.761911273,
-0.2968513966,
0.6646095514,
0.14023453,
0.6491875052,
0.4714753032,
0.3720062077,
0.3308589756,
0.1255217642,
0.0866670385,
-0.234404102,
0.2330928892,
-0.405081898,
-0.1568752378,
-0.6275140047,
-0.228471294,
0.789526403,
0.7231417298,
-0.4126051366,
0.3196529746,
0.2130789459,
0.909560442,
-0.9660403132,
0.1844167858,
-0.6347562075,
0.0558567569,
-0.2290474772,
-0.0878997594,
-0.3001781106,
0.2137368321,
0.158574596,
-0.8924340606,
-0.1020329073,
0.0351953991,
0.7068595886,
0.619294703,
-0.2148632705,
-0.5522838831,
-0.748778224,
1.051923275,
-0.7584997416,
0.2911882997,
0.6261799932,
0.1647270173,
-0.0832796097,
-0.8019176722,
-0.3883515298,
0.187858969,
-0.0348560661,
0.1815408468,
-0.4358329177,
0.0751120299,
-0.0413831212,
0.3305780292,
-0.4564170837,
0.180972144,
-0.2862811387,
-0.0929352343,
0.4500475526,
-0.0067000869,
0.1503888667,
0.2387144864,
-0.2442441136,
-0.0857527107,
-0.1784417778,
-0.5599474311,
0.4151186645,
0.3743849099,
0.083118014,
0.0027869046,
-0.2556673586,
1.0114886761,
0.0454295464,
-0.1947363615,
0.5618620515,
-0.130603537,
-0.4146121144,
-0.0076467255,
0.826444149,
-0.0031902732,
0.4979545176,
-0.017547287,
-0.1717716455,
-0.3303017616,
0.2932288647,
-0.7380254269,
-0.3931667805,
0.0849327594,
-0.5411590338,
-0.2451723814,
-0.3469252586,
-1.0602521896,
-0.1481708735,
-0.4450995624,
0.7759427428,
-0.1976601332,
-0.4660767615,
0.5221692324,
0.485676825,
-0.1144091412,
0.0537579618,
-0.8458409905,
0.6696352959,
0.348559916,
0.7378180623,
-0.2859085798,
-0.4783234894,
-0.3593891263,
0.2190065384,
-0.0492409281,
0.6890972853,
-0.4784595668,
-0.0331281088,
-0.0724556968,
-0.1447900534,
-0.3147667348,
-0.6929244995,
0.5997337699,
-0.6124113798,
0.2484192699,
-0.0363777466,
-0.2436217964,
-0.2456545979,
0.2268004417,
-0.7687080503,
0.9212367535,
0.1331796944,
-1.0798224211,
0.2058067024,
-0.6901888251,
-0.4928797185,
-0.4415441155,
0.3635994494,
-0.9012506604,
0.0002515573,
0.338252306,
0.3623135984,
-0.073562026,
0.2381242365,
-0.1528893858,
-0.1627113372,
0.013841345,
-0.3057982624,
0.5889701247,
0.4138551652,
-0.0947835594,
0.2032533139,
-1.1562107801,
-0.1195357367,
0.0075415573,
-0.4768749475,
-0.5691412091,
0.1426734179,
-0.2901468873,
0.1323952377,
-0.126648888,
-0.2123766541,
-0.0156173669,
-0.2919934392,
0.2793087363,
0.5217862725,
-0.124335587,
0.4003888071,
-0.1982127726,
0.4376400411,
0.1135538593,
-0.1699712425,
-0.28058815,
-0.1124799922,
-0.792725265,
-0.3850876987,
0.6719613671,
0.5389642715,
-0.6787919998,
0.5031376481,
-0.2549437284,
-0.029471267,
-0.7939167023,
0.4448110163,
0.247616455,
0.7330323458,
0.9239549637,
-0.3488149047,
-0.9100185633,
-0.5931092501,
-0.3345821202,
0.008505078,
-0.2141141295,
0.1108618826,
0.3986288905,
-0.5645061731,
0.8674123287,
-0.4466144443,
-0.79109025,
-0.124391064,
0.5928282142,
0.2249148637,
0.4001968205,
0.2649538517,
-0.7385835648,
-0.5364875197,
-0.454498142,
-0.2679178119,
-0.6246037483,
-0.1978885829,
0.153777346,
0.1009793207,
0.7398086786,
-0.4104807973,
0.1054303199,
0.7265080214,
0.0856277049,
0.6780153513,
-0.2145613134,
-0.3141758442,
-1.2276339531,
0.1186950058,
-0.0511915796,
-0.2653723657,
-0.5401529074,
-0.1244705394,
-0.3229679167,
-0.0556020997,
-0.2355386317,
0.453012526,
-0.5410658121,
0.0077264928,
-0.7771470547,
-0.0511148199,
0.0775325224,
0.5220121145,
0.5673705339,
0.4514236748,
0.6927599311,
-0.853518188,
0.2659255862,
-0.1573001146,
-0.1474411637,
0.5565248132,
-0.5169329047,
0.0235372484,
-0.4164796174,
0.5308329463,
-0.809812963,
0.130246684,
0.5346948504,
-0.3082910776,
0.5731491446,
0.0012989079,
-0.1839562505,
-0.1695535034,
-0.1916839182,
0.6386996508,
0.2639159858,
-0.461355567,
0.7974944115,
0.2377957404,
-0.0696756169,
-0.7513535023,
-0.6927739978,
0.0600918047,
-0.3426837623,
-0.1373812258,
0.5992969871,
0.1602209061,
-0.0758786649,
0.0900142565,
-0.1283213347,
-0.3167725205,
0.0112967528,
-0.1185517386,
-0.4655906558,
-0.362239182,
0.4583750069,
-0.3687408268,
-0.4999671578,
0.2004377395,
-0.444116652,
0.43411237,
-0.0347839259,
-0.1256173849,
-0.1925289333,
0.2630392313,
0.1936329156,
-0.1983786672,
0.8138747215,
1.0403535366,
-0.4103413522,
-0.1865846664,
-0.3152040839,
0.0745502785,
-0.4611847699,
0.7782485485,
-0.2158827931,
-0.3784392774,
0.4454734027,
-0.2236463428,
0.0338911675,
0.5256946087,
0.5151554942,
-0.1178701296,
0.668892622,
0.8180972934,
-0.275839895,
0.5272293091,
0.0042000045,
0.0320656598,
-0.9580561519,
0.0559127256,
-0.3905655146,
-0.3813285828,
-0.3392475247,
-0.4176707268,
-0.1696879417,
0.1121224761,
-0.260530442,
0.2508924007,
-0.3422290981,
0.3459979892,
0.3788616657,
0.0947237983,
0.2343564779,
-0.0613311566,
0.1669312716,
-0.1291488856,
-0.6043653488,
-0.1409032196,
1.1429579258,
0.4991512299,
1.1001067162,
-0.0652146339,
0.680930078,
0.2536821961,
0.4696289599,
-0.7504643202,
0.1649841219,
-0.3011291325,
-0.5135871172,
-0.4099980593,
-0.622348547,
-1.0690762997,
0.293235302,
-0.2543503642,
-0.4562283754,
0.2168502212,
0.3248013258,
-0.4112639129,
0.4489926994,
-0.4679057896,
0.6601343751,
-0.1502803713,
-0.1686896086,
-0.1057407409,
-0.7736602426,
0.2094367445,
-0.4208591878,
0.4462228715,
0.0629238412,
-0.1585338712,
1.0631289482,
-0.0841949955,
1.0951749086,
-0.1137649119,
-0.1516511142,
0.4351873994,
0.0137149515,
0.3087201715,
-0.1087221503,
-0.2441255301,
0.011935629,
-0.1118133962,
-0.4238047004,
-0.5654295087,
0.2359669507,
-0.6552387476,
-0.4080347121,
-0.5650775433,
-0.3890258074,
-0.14956671,
0.3209148347,
0.2444123626,
0.0958193168,
0.0213186871,
0.2007825226,
0.8363689184,
-0.3764272034,
0.3816263378,
0.716453135,
-0.213968575,
-0.5177191496,
1.0732675791,
0.1311327666,
0.2752050161,
0.5862460732,
0.4097428322,
-0.0690826625,
-0.6837456822,
-0.1117822975,
0.0329970196,
-0.6019275784,
-0.4842067063,
-0.7063577771,
-0.2628391087,
-0.2685400844,
0.1426032186,
-0.552800715,
-0.0610860959,
-0.4414674938,
0.064305447,
0.0671025664,
0.3046183884,
-0.245969519,
0.7517623901,
-0.5799121261,
0.5028053522,
0.4772242308,
0.5011184216,
0.0480474681,
-0.7402137518,
-0.2968636155,
-0.0198507383,
-0.4161124527,
-0.745823741,
0.350510776,
0.7964202762,
0.3800395429,
0.3140594959,
0.209297955,
0.5113474727,
-0.4032070339,
0.2864881456,
0.0133316331,
-0.8283637762,
0.3440198302,
-0.0908711329,
0.4701511562,
0.7889196873,
0.6458700299,
-0.3400965035,
-0.0136355329,
-0.4932718277,
-0.9486572146,
0.4378067553,
0.0570108704,
0.2590614557,
0.1037930921,
0.5077331066,
0.1076185554,
0.1318904757,
-1.1942898035,
-0.190444842,
-0.4272156656,
-0.3759366274,
-0.022969218,
-0.3383026123,
0.1101455688,
-0.1646834463,
0.7085471749,
-0.2497206926,
-0.0368173271,
0.2881741524,
-0.3455729783,
-0.0914085805,
0.2882659733,
0.5086348057,
0.7275877595,
-0.447155714,
0.2576240003,
0.466042161,
-0.6724953651,
-0.018471349,
0.0148531124,
0.1256243587,
-0.0393535569,
0.5886591077,
0.6978284121,
0.3656628132,
-0.3045638502,
0.2919842005,
-0.002548161,
-0.2931395769,
-0.0308494847,
-0.2618813813,
-0.0053846058,
-0.2452429235,
0.4048821628,
-0.0004363064,
0.24105528,
-0.6035693884,
0.4973305762,
0.1275219768,
-0.4034040868,
-0.4772870839,
0.3102548718,
0.293962568,
-0.3043822944,
0.4677792788,
-0.1065587997,
-0.6356678605,
0.234787941,
0.9375081062,
0.8111484051,
-0.5260621309,
0.1246510223,
0.4027583897,
0.2345597744,
-0.0906652063,
-0.0995594263,
-0.2392122895,
-0.788608253,
-0.6958031654,
-0.9811536074,
-0.3483889103,
0.351352334,
-0.6922710538,
0.3250467777,
-0.3467784524,
-0.1180036739,
-0.2318835557,
0.0810752586,
-0.2342256904,
0.6509694457,
0.0946156457,
0.6203785539,
-1.1003229618,
0.9410027266,
0.6294054985,
-0.0011569664,
-0.2706930041,
0.2474081665,
-0.305562526,
-0.7018059492,
0.5008622408,
0.0907922909,
-0.1745206714,
0.0073708384,
-0.1078254357,
-1.1059446335,
0.6759426594,
0.3257640898,
-0.4556028247,
-0.0891094133,
0.0441829748,
0.7415453196,
-0.4338826537,
0.0393410139,
0.4464620054,
0.4420006275,
0.1164034158,
-0.741761148,
-0.0614294447,
0.0450763702,
-0.4307401776,
0.2635971308,
-0.5691847205,
0.7801021338,
-0.0002538072,
-0.0779350102,
-0.2456025183,
0.8793579936,
0.1521375626,
0.3847575188,
0.6632499695,
0.670945704,
0.5102239847,
0.2045647502,
0.5222831368,
-0.0886551216,
0.3065522015,
1.5204671621,
-0.1523963958,
0.7478576899,
0.5414995551,
-0.3361821473,
0.6013674736,
0.6220903993,
0.153717801,
0.6872387528,
0.5809591413,
0.061155349,
-0.1984382719,
0.1527457833,
-0.4892624617,
0.4003687501,
0.5448397398,
-0.3892062604,
-0.526651144,
0.1334685832,
-0.1656105071,
0.2046993524,
-0.4159662724,
0.8001896143,
0.4374291301,
-0.3620185554,
0.4720680714,
0.1240196824,
1.043847084,
-0.7669938207,
0.1618328393,
0.1312446743,
0.251457572,
-0.3815117776,
-0.5398827791,
0.8650814891,
-0.5206181407,
-0.3104082644,
-0.2989800274,
0.936036706,
-0.562848568,
-0.5171132088,
0.4269664288,
0.1818243861,
-0.024569964,
-0.1827878207,
-0.9706340432,
0.0293101985,
-0.3721157014,
-0.3689019382,
0.5120936036,
0.3721340597,
0.1353121549,
0.7248001099,
0.3884554505,
0.2029704601,
-0.110626176,
0.0557101332,
0.6559196711,
-0.3639598489,
-0.5318342447,
-0.9935691953,
0.1559061706,
0.1647181213,
-0.2769879699,
0.4963566065,
0.2138903588,
0.6688763499,
0.1010277346,
0.2014899254,
0.2047478706,
0.6463780999,
-0.6251096129,
0.5518214107,
-0.4941246212,
0.2810925543,
-0.4788437188,
-1.1973514557,
-0.6295492649,
0.577573061,
-0.2207273245,
0.219705686,
0.3934853971,
0.4426858425,
-0.230719164,
-0.3217549324,
0.1821609437,
0.1570797861,
0.0660150573,
0.5716737509,
0.4700186253,
-0.5947013497,
0.7017053366,
-0.14786309,
-0.2192432731,
-0.0399769284,
-1.2005578279,
-0.748549521,
-0.5507321954,
-0.5429933667,
-0.1727072597,
0.2374149561,
0.563949883,
0.9273372889,
-0.976510644,
-0.0361162685,
-0.034115389,
0.3016519547,
-0.2809044123,
-0.2073917091,
0.7309829593,
-0.5187345147,
-0.5653403997,
0.190378055,
0.1078361496,
0.0366184264,
-0.0353434384,
-0.0757281929,
-0.3786821961,
0.1171028465,
0.5168715715,
0.5128238201,
-0.1879280061,
-0.0694218948,
-0.4006706774,
0.1198795438,
0.1321164668,
0.6760697961,
-0.9459433556,
0.4705595672,
0.3453943431,
0.6974914074,
0.3687799871,
0.2120408416,
0.7443295121,
-0.9435352087,
0.1770890653,
0.2223023176,
0.157987237,
0.3308848143,
-0.1909062713,
0.3690729141,
0.042739898,
-0.6001960039,
-0.9710357785,
0.1849048734,
-0.5842658281,
-0.455344677,
1.0787502527,
-0.2072952241,
-0.2069460601,
-0.3314630985,
-0.1203947663,
0.2772524357,
-0.0597891547,
0.9564155936,
0.7369463444,
0.0109845549,
-0.1426155418,
-0.3763912022,
0.7790048718,
0.7416619658,
-0.6739755273,
0.1975737661,
-0.1769307703,
0.4140906334,
0.367007345,
0.7076392174,
-0.0352051593,
0.0487117134,
-0.188623026,
-0.0830361992,
-0.2029289752,
-0.4390758574,
-0.5060287714,
-0.051646091,
-0.0484792702,
-0.3057307005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02997v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02997v2 | Erasure of Unaligned Attributes from Neural Representations | 2023-02-06T18:32:17 | 2023-04-18T10:34:01 | Shun Shao, Yftah Ziser, Shay Cohen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the Assignment-Maximization Spectral Attribute removaL (AMSAL)
algorithm, which erases information from neural representations when the
information to be erased is implicit rather than directly being aligned to each
input example. Our algorithm works by alternating between two steps. In one, it
finds an assignment of the input representations to the information to be
erased, and in the other, it creates projections of both the input
representations and the information to be erased into a joint latent space. We
test our algorithm on an extensive array of datasets, including a Twitter
dataset with multiple guarded attributes, the BiasBios dataset and the
BiasBench benchmark. The last benchmark includes four datasets with various
types of protected attributes. Our results demonstrate that bias can often be
removed in our setup. We also discuss the limitations of our approach when
there is a strong entanglement between the main task and the information to be
erased. | [
-0.2776089907,
-0.7386274934,
0.2422829866,
0.1793427318,
-0.0572564937,
0.4683982134,
-0.2513427734,
-0.5091800094,
0.5940446258,
0.4167548418,
-0.6787010431,
-0.351485163,
-0.6175757647,
-0.3700004816,
-0.6134137511,
1.0709486008,
0.0027104013,
-0.0423909947,
-0.3152622879,
-0.2203828245,
-0.5483839512,
-0.0816978663,
-0.9273076057,
-0.5731888413,
0.2569772005,
0.2208559066,
0.7425378561,
1.0522521734,
0.3160742521,
0.3814874291,
-0.3634790778,
0.1175293922,
-0.5990592837,
0.2917175591,
-0.0946531072,
-0.3425966501,
-0.3891278803,
0.2544156313,
0.6838507056,
0.8449190259,
-0.1632336825,
0.2414832562,
0.0872333795,
0.6580082774,
-1.1010680199,
-0.2600136697,
-0.7116593719,
0.3262029886,
-0.038730666,
-0.4625057578,
-0.4227765799,
-0.4024151266,
-0.1708309501,
-0.6893290877,
0.2930021584,
-0.0523106568,
0.8958882689,
0.2234914452,
-0.5177685022,
-0.1362987012,
-0.9804673791,
1.0448639393,
-0.0543245971,
0.0957310572,
0.6131789684,
0.0851173401,
0.237443313,
-0.44933635,
-0.2551532984,
0.3069204688,
-0.1060818359,
0.2114113867,
-0.4538264573,
-0.0603999421,
0.4945643544,
-0.0439994223,
-0.3388063014,
0.0291521214,
-0.7120532393,
-0.4851902425,
0.4759620428,
0.1517068148,
0.294360131,
-0.3925698996,
-0.4345512688,
0.2545709312,
-1.0874522924,
-0.1155227125,
0.5400531292,
-0.2276887149,
0.2582186759,
0.7064756751,
-0.0031705273,
0.2146797031,
0.267354995,
0.2684186697,
0.2162861079,
-0.0371978804,
-0.0299823228,
0.3700501621,
0.5715776086,
0.291915834,
0.1385884136,
-0.5143584013,
-0.3025002182,
-0.0607748888,
0.4220012426,
-0.1805793345,
-0.2040137798,
0.1837622076,
-0.7287893891,
-0.3708965778,
-0.3046122491,
-0.717261374,
-1.004786253,
-0.4462416172,
0.6234341264,
-0.5067132711,
-0.1842135638,
-0.43781811,
-0.0595282093,
0.4624640644,
0.494259119,
-1.0057121515,
0.5455185175,
0.5597150326,
0.5314693451,
0.0925132558,
-0.2317927331,
-0.1728536636,
0.4773342907,
-0.269240886,
0.0768966451,
-0.7099794149,
-0.1714954972,
-0.2280474901,
-0.2721592784,
0.0160201937,
-0.6186115742,
0.2616487443,
-0.7068843842,
-0.1535491645,
-0.4789017439,
-0.5377966762,
-0.2579034269,
0.2016747296,
-0.792830646,
0.6661371589,
-0.1286579967,
-0.3960447311,
0.2628057003,
-0.7328221202,
-0.3653132915,
-0.3832153976,
-0.0240033492,
-0.4488261342,
0.2430377603,
0.4047630429,
0.2103382498,
-0.218424648,
-0.0112622138,
-0.1866662949,
-0.5585825443,
0.4390143156,
-0.5489917994,
1.0045663118,
0.1706827879,
-0.401391387,
-0.0647030175,
-0.8722681403,
0.0176250171,
0.174922213,
0.0729628205,
-0.5958735943,
0.2363915592,
-0.2105334997,
0.0000475317,
0.420476228,
-1.2460196018,
0.1443925649,
-0.2215873599,
0.5959377885,
1.4381808043,
0.2109062523,
0.9471114874,
-0.1211611331,
0.1643011719,
0.3101183772,
0.3155305088,
0.23165977,
-0.0307333209,
-1.0635555983,
-0.3703391552,
0.1596040726,
0.4104278982,
-0.6653317213,
0.2196999341,
-0.092701152,
-0.256739974,
-0.7040283084,
-0.0101244403,
0.6404817104,
0.4819194674,
0.4350219667,
-0.2715791166,
-0.5707343221,
-1.3110421896,
-0.2725328207,
0.1588149965,
0.0319690183,
0.044092685,
0.5686947107,
0.109669812,
0.9682856798,
-0.6807232499,
-0.2784177661,
0.6034609079,
0.4095118642,
-0.0164647587,
0.9889637232,
0.3071995676,
-0.8129187226,
-0.0716698915,
-0.3687345982,
-1.0802170038,
0.0551991276,
-0.0656539425,
-0.3551770747,
0.0270961337,
0.2778017819,
-0.5821445584,
0.8878137469,
-0.0921577811,
-0.2427244335,
0.3594814241,
-0.1662141979,
0.4633978903,
-0.7533602715,
0.2409004569,
-0.0150373885,
-0.2002458572,
-0.7700098157,
-0.2036699057,
0.1892115176,
-0.3223656416,
-0.2690877616,
0.2399357259,
-0.66272223,
-0.2437478453,
-0.1502024978,
-0.2348175496,
0.0276938304,
0.7263478041,
-0.1589866877,
0.5790253282,
0.3162554502,
-0.4387583137,
0.2163355649,
0.4814741611,
0.0308518354,
0.6983767748,
-0.5334816575,
0.2743145525,
-0.5012993813,
-0.3087754548,
-1.2275872231,
0.0487567931,
0.2556024492,
-0.4166367352,
0.3477259576,
-0.0371802077,
-0.3822096884,
-0.0330606513,
-0.6125411987,
0.5362900496,
0.4860191345,
-0.8569753766,
0.6451922655,
0.5249826312,
0.0587513559,
-1.1140955687,
-0.6138420701,
0.026354501,
-0.2287987173,
-0.4733679295,
0.6088520885,
0.285951376,
0.0340901613,
0.5326119661,
-0.2459165156,
-0.3883769214,
0.3161646724,
0.4894342124,
0.2301515639,
0.0615683086,
0.1295396686,
0.3288466632,
-0.1923063248,
0.1795692891,
0.1335101724,
0.5164593458,
0.0853148475,
-0.6447082758,
-0.3173439205,
0.3917813003,
0.3976343572,
-0.3000138402,
0.8188711405,
0.6953915358,
-1.0210232735,
-0.1363468617,
-0.6066648364,
-0.0117351366,
-0.538516283,
0.3821103573,
-0.1577561498,
-0.4019280374,
1.0478754044,
0.2062660605,
0.2872309387,
0.310144335,
0.3081371188,
-0.425983727,
1.2541610003,
0.3472402692,
-0.1168064773,
0.4373155832,
-0.5294746161,
0.4755494595,
-1.2469208241,
-0.3412805796,
-0.275078088,
-0.8147268891,
-0.3086183071,
0.0589062497,
0.3617161214,
-0.0901276693,
-0.3010172248,
0.1939390898,
-0.8138952851,
0.8121836185,
0.8789695501,
0.7917103767,
-0.0143448925,
-0.1453435719,
0.2785384059,
-0.309076339,
0.0268871803,
-0.2021137625,
1.3095953465,
0.1159637943,
0.8333343267,
0.1424758285,
0.7559680343,
0.4699029624,
0.17448847,
-0.4386393428,
0.7221273184,
-0.1178524494,
-0.6056438088,
-0.2481770366,
-0.3715230525,
-0.7710961103,
0.2560660839,
-0.4194380939,
-1.0200853348,
0.4363866746,
0.3305357993,
-0.0751683339,
0.6748155355,
-0.8155278563,
0.4055087268,
0.0353626683,
-0.7901588678,
-0.3586299419,
-0.5858550072,
0.5715447068,
-0.1875952929,
-0.362657398,
-0.0664284825,
-0.141551435,
1.2670156956,
-0.4427168965,
0.7578159571,
-0.696371913,
0.5443490744,
-0.0313505828,
0.1224045008,
0.4273965061,
-0.2099470347,
-0.0357293561,
-0.1160734072,
0.0612708814,
-0.4308607578,
-0.8358764648,
0.5130293369,
-0.988496542,
-0.2746833563,
-0.2688586414,
-0.5718759298,
-0.2751834989,
0.0827526301,
0.2053272426,
0.5371441841,
-0.2340833843,
0.2602689266,
0.5787065029,
-0.43896842,
0.5361418724,
0.1823593974,
0.3462474942,
-0.3378987908,
1.2134339809,
0.375744015,
-0.053715121,
0.0771802366,
-0.1193734929,
-0.1454074234,
-0.732950151,
0.2397837788,
0.1811650246,
-0.9753291607,
-0.3123643696,
-0.3517068923,
-0.3139592111,
-0.2166440338,
-0.3585112095,
-0.5817445517,
-0.6175938845,
-0.1743264049,
0.101989001,
-0.0175875593,
0.7684209347,
-0.2275903374,
0.5615484118,
-0.4147629142,
0.3096403778,
0.1840148866,
0.2415858507,
0.3025542498,
-0.0749774873,
-0.1905819178,
0.3148703873,
-0.5452605486,
-0.7270809412,
0.3070903718,
0.121687524,
0.6293420196,
0.5586776733,
-0.017141195,
0.852157414,
-0.2739297152,
0.5402216911,
0.3258472383,
-1.2228536606,
0.3288925588,
-0.1441144794,
0.1122762486,
0.6731104851,
0.2106328458,
-0.6402566433,
-0.5863201022,
-0.652030468,
-1.0507106781,
0.8526218534,
0.368119508,
0.0788758025,
0.3094541132,
0.5725794435,
-0.155901596,
0.4831668735,
-0.6004008055,
-0.5400460362,
0.0677977949,
-0.4370855689,
0.2178113759,
-0.668147862,
-0.2844799757,
-0.3390143514,
0.8385252357,
0.4527029395,
0.8948690891,
-0.054744862,
-0.5854249597,
-0.0595320314,
0.1214887053,
0.4534240663,
0.6645597816,
-0.149367407,
0.2046880573,
-0.0653306544,
-0.7898133993,
0.4246813059,
-0.3183409572,
-0.4514867663,
-0.5621795654,
0.3266884685,
0.5942304134,
0.1104739755,
-0.0571469031,
0.5824614167,
0.0368003212,
-0.3140127659,
-0.465887785,
-0.1583134681,
-0.2737658322,
0.1289476007,
0.4801116288,
0.6805556417,
0.2617405951,
-0.057693053,
0.3927819431,
0.5303483605,
-0.595726192,
-0.5050294995,
0.7461590767,
-0.0419593416,
-0.0287509505,
0.9605291486,
0.1484658867,
-0.5803575516,
0.863925755,
0.2700380385,
1.0272601843,
-0.0575770475,
0.2215641439,
0.2561901808,
0.532892704,
0.42680493,
0.0793048367,
0.0307501536,
-1.0072034597,
-0.1759300679,
-0.2925055027,
-0.1652920395,
-0.0054206508,
-0.7218378186,
-0.2385039777,
-0.7800960541,
-0.1808568239,
0.4115577042,
-0.0863194764,
-0.5881888866,
0.0543899834,
0.0382892638,
0.2700768709,
-1.0880202055,
0.4550045133,
0.3975201547,
-0.4346929789,
-0.6934869289,
-0.2870308757,
0.4273914993,
-1.1185468435,
0.6986649036,
-0.0641873106,
0.0537094362,
0.0210045818,
-1.0333050489,
-0.8988446593,
0.8262650371,
0.7159075737,
0.4226666391,
-0.0277244467,
-0.0048755105,
0.2098194659,
0.0525215976,
0.2740100026,
0.4951291382,
0.419452399,
0.0972942412,
-0.4071165323,
0.0638804734,
-0.5914855599,
-0.3878326416,
0.4593523443,
-0.4056436121,
1.1718233824,
0.0917463228,
-0.2042642534,
0.0678544492,
0.6506116986,
-0.2457918972,
-0.0778750405,
0.7609664798,
0.6455062032,
1.0168628693,
-0.3530938327,
0.6207962632,
-0.0640724972,
0.4737420678,
0.9894151092,
-0.276381582,
0.3869613409,
0.8075278401,
-0.0021864718,
0.0701289251,
0.4383614361,
0.0133706667,
0.6881967187,
0.1336137652,
-0.42571944,
0.1720974594,
-0.3212586343,
0.1131714284,
0.8040286303,
0.117332913,
-0.4496776462,
-0.3831795752,
0.287637949,
0.0822831541,
-0.0559318066,
-0.3811439574,
0.7010961175,
-0.432818681,
-0.6062150002,
0.5246484876,
0.0450059138,
0.2977693975,
-0.5919399858,
-0.2288194895,
-0.1245433837,
0.4749874175,
-0.4514116943,
-0.7487683296,
0.3525710404,
-0.2737542093,
-0.2578496337,
-0.5140524507,
0.9853867888,
-0.6060118675,
-0.0282829851,
0.2345557213,
0.2651040554,
-0.0984941646,
0.1894445866,
-0.6891462803,
-0.2458297014,
0.1072558463,
-0.494022131,
0.166091308,
-0.1070210263,
0.102388531,
0.7685773373,
0.4135781527,
0.2161216587,
0.4065332413,
-0.2532380819,
0.8801738024,
-0.528437674,
-0.2499569356,
-0.8284724355,
0.2625892162,
-0.4322619736,
-0.0494155921,
0.6665995717,
0.6886845231,
0.3859802186,
0.0445061773,
0.570612669,
-0.2181275487,
0.3996362984,
-0.5492125154,
0.8749002814,
-0.5387766957,
0.1588923633,
-0.4825178385,
-0.9555048347,
-0.2319106311,
0.5580713749,
-0.3158114254,
0.097461462,
0.7698652148,
1.1106789112,
-0.1795876324,
0.3196179867,
0.0810878649,
0.1713250279,
0.3212683499,
0.8013425469,
0.9470425248,
-0.5302131176,
0.1731026769,
-0.6945064664,
-0.2047824711,
0.4766064584,
-0.5304387808,
-0.4030605555,
-0.554912746,
-0.2780745327,
-0.4964995086,
0.1149651334,
0.7487945557,
0.5918118358,
-0.6786213517,
-0.0942030624,
0.2855435312,
0.366038233,
-0.4197900891,
-0.1332944334,
0.6554821134,
-0.0257165879,
-0.6110460162,
0.1042090207,
0.2111483067,
-0.1516355723,
-0.1955636144,
0.0296884533,
-0.5478665829,
-0.0630683154,
0.3347983062,
0.2562888265,
-0.2827987969,
-0.7802119255,
-0.0449462384,
-0.0911462605,
0.1209403053,
0.7141890526,
-0.4716282785,
0.5833847523,
0.5120719671,
0.7135736346,
0.4580015242,
0.173396498,
0.5760231614,
-1.3638436794,
0.2835014462,
0.2724912763,
0.4638994634,
-0.0592091978,
-0.4395929277,
0.5207006335,
0.2525580227,
-0.2869693935,
-0.8294259906,
-0.1516688466,
-0.8496109843,
-0.2268008441,
0.7301509976,
0.0700976625,
-0.6936098337,
-0.0620221421,
-0.0248284396,
0.3700082302,
-0.3147598207,
0.5698928833,
0.6963046789,
0.0021446932,
-0.0869673416,
-0.2102273554,
0.1883351356,
0.5873612165,
-0.5142048001,
0.0750117898,
0.6256047487,
0.0970709622,
0.3039649129,
0.8474385738,
-0.2805022895,
0.3514224291,
-0.1211104766,
0.3557246327,
-0.3546627462,
-0.3443856835,
-0.447745055,
0.3951258957,
-0.1738492548,
-0.6515418887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02962v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02962v1 | LoFT: Enhancing Faithfulness and Diversity for Table-to-Text Generation via Logic Form Control | 2023-02-06T17:49:27 | 2023-02-06T17:49:27 | Yilun Zhao, Zhenting Qi, Linyong Nan, Lorenzo Jaime Yu Flores, Dragomir Radev | cs.CL | cs.CL | Logical Table-to-Text (LT2T) generation is tasked with generating logically
faithful sentences from tables. There currently exists two challenges in the
field: 1) Faithfulness: how to generate sentences that are factually correct
given the table content; 2) Diversity: how to generate multiple sentences that
offer different perspectives on the table. This work proposes LoFT, which
utilizes logic forms as fact verifiers and content planners to control LT2T
generation. Experimental results on the LogicNLG dataset demonstrate that LoFT
is the first model that addresses unfaithfulness and lack of diversity issues
simultaneously. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/Yale-LILY/LoFT. | [
0.2046805471,
-0.8374474049,
0.2556013763,
0.5852914453,
-0.0820692703,
0.1993224621,
0.1102051958,
-0.3666844368,
-0.0496465266,
0.5266253352,
-0.7342674732,
-0.4236632288,
-0.3099435568,
0.115418382,
-0.7122462392,
1.4636905193,
0.0432511382,
0.0249640904,
-0.358943522,
-0.0588022768,
-0.8553373218,
-0.1663994938,
-0.4374027252,
0.0197518282,
0.4331821799,
0.5705247521,
0.9213758111,
0.5538038015,
0.4352099895,
0.1950466931,
0.1949486881,
0.2260610908,
-0.8237530589,
0.3831759393,
-0.383726418,
-0.6312742233,
-0.1737185568,
-0.1042183712,
0.67860955,
0.3427898586,
-0.064686805,
0.1839942932,
-0.044301901,
1.1464351416,
-0.4095042348,
-0.0315679163,
-1.2924146652,
0.3004316688,
-0.295455277,
-0.1297186613,
-0.6123111844,
-0.5933442116,
-0.3357923627,
-0.5755085349,
0.261574924,
0.4781858623,
0.8464218378,
0.2691445649,
-0.5638847947,
-0.3260752559,
-0.7471755743,
0.7783328891,
-0.5764345527,
0.4835615754,
0.1257483214,
0.2692700326,
-0.6664258838,
-0.8771992922,
-0.7956189513,
-0.2462808788,
-0.3122234643,
0.5675449371,
0.0172149446,
-0.3653770089,
0.3965694606,
0.1051555499,
-0.7286220789,
-0.3683578372,
-0.4440966845,
-0.1540361047,
0.5111031532,
0.0707940683,
0.6694762111,
-0.4144802094,
-0.4291065931,
0.3049020767,
-0.9389839172,
0.3594481945,
0.6034916043,
0.1127342209,
0.0947236866,
1.0605231524,
-0.1882002801,
0.4836390316,
-0.2367656082,
0.0684777573,
-0.0716909841,
-0.6854199767,
-0.0897410661,
0.248450011,
0.5611107349,
0.2993141413,
-0.2196730673,
-0.3938751817,
-0.2182207555,
0.2068883479,
0.4111392796,
-0.6965200901,
-0.1186044887,
0.3644767106,
-0.2467236668,
-0.5935279727,
0.4221550226,
-0.6875194907,
0.0115080737,
-0.3031077385,
0.3761472702,
-0.4182693958,
-0.068794705,
-0.046248842,
-0.4404197931,
0.2536878586,
0.2731047273,
-0.5211057067,
0.4089831412,
0.7036568522,
0.7681382895,
-0.431103617,
-0.0887362957,
-0.9037960172,
0.5257194042,
-0.363219887,
0.5718673468,
-0.3417018652,
-0.3105447888,
-0.0711530671,
-0.3602853417,
0.2666274011,
-0.2590657175,
0.7715188861,
-0.4812713563,
0.512969017,
-0.4896018803,
-0.4385720789,
0.3447729945,
0.2639521956,
-0.7858414054,
1.1306096315,
0.3525951505,
-0.934905529,
0.6256789565,
-0.747674346,
-0.7126517296,
0.039174322,
-0.7194830775,
-0.8019734025,
0.1245028675,
-0.1795744002,
0.0310331658,
-0.0055185324,
0.3228778243,
0.0696333498,
-0.0663422495,
0.4911648929,
-0.265237093,
0.8927425742,
0.3363838494,
-0.3650699556,
0.2770271599,
-0.6240926981,
0.178157419,
0.0658123717,
-0.5089796185,
0.2056525946,
0.3264440298,
0.2436996698,
0.3027172983,
0.0426388793,
-0.6379466653,
0.1051506773,
-0.3808576763,
0.3034209609,
0.395750016,
-0.1453104168,
0.2309439629,
-1.0341271162,
0.2549369931,
0.3096148372,
0.0341682024,
0.1900068074,
-0.6679984331,
-0.5638200045,
-0.0416601785,
0.2113976628,
0.674487412,
-0.6638082266,
0.5776175857,
-0.034156464,
-0.1826129407,
-0.1521000415,
0.2418490946,
0.2003371269,
0.688534379,
0.4384880364,
0.1872727275,
-0.5694362521,
-0.8100081086,
-0.4336729646,
-0.009593308,
0.0840051547,
0.0073752431,
0.5285795331,
0.1117578447,
1.4934434891,
-0.2781233788,
-0.549570322,
-0.5764190555,
0.2686620653,
0.1169376522,
0.8634749055,
0.6647997499,
-1.0044045448,
-0.4279138744,
-0.0092646731,
-0.6469243765,
-0.0701553375,
-0.4244930446,
-0.5154105425,
0.6577383876,
0.4252592027,
-0.7183298469,
0.9698907137,
0.3835254908,
-0.477990061,
0.5654764175,
0.0178654063,
0.0492954701,
-1.3073245287,
-0.0198352169,
-0.4546494782,
-0.4236417711,
-0.3465147913,
-0.0496590361,
-0.1307803988,
-0.0225565191,
-0.5061487556,
0.098145321,
-0.3152754903,
-0.2236784995,
-0.0347027816,
0.085898079,
0.3369024694,
0.2062842846,
-0.1038075536,
0.8469295502,
0.1553253829,
-0.3684993982,
0.2532384396,
0.5037705898,
-0.2180366069,
0.4839172363,
-0.773242116,
-0.1619912088,
-0.2854066193,
0.5014113188,
-1.0755465031,
-0.3162484765,
0.1221331283,
-0.5100092292,
-0.0313341953,
0.1022195145,
-0.5766023397,
-0.2377107143,
-0.5116932392,
0.2921088934,
0.7092670202,
-0.3157170713,
0.8040646911,
-0.0286350939,
0.0310794767,
-0.6470220685,
-0.924462676,
-0.0239246562,
0.061818324,
-0.8143585324,
0.6271474361,
-0.2009310573,
-0.3166489005,
0.1919844747,
-0.3305825293,
0.1114723235,
-0.2088261396,
0.2404360622,
0.3120541573,
-0.1411322802,
0.2296163887,
0.5482335687,
0.1307141334,
0.1476937681,
-0.6333841681,
0.4806537032,
-0.1197005734,
-0.3813046515,
-0.4741277397,
0.5479719043,
0.3577207029,
-0.304449141,
0.7220552564,
0.7062184811,
-0.4225429595,
-0.7650591135,
-0.6060314178,
-0.1834546179,
-0.4915715158,
0.3187236488,
-0.3662599027,
-0.9310530424,
0.6421316266,
0.1128755957,
0.5544028282,
0.5087122321,
0.4279344976,
-0.1536586434,
0.6394128799,
0.4769443274,
0.5236090422,
0.1501747072,
0.1224710867,
0.1533479989,
-0.5186654925,
-0.5026815534,
-0.6796115637,
-0.5885813236,
-0.4887585342,
-0.1857229173,
0.3703750074,
0.2705197334,
-0.163815394,
0.2014364302,
-0.5786896944,
0.8279363513,
0.50937289,
0.3272412717,
0.6752827764,
-0.009135752,
-0.0111583173,
-0.2674283981,
-0.8631706238,
-0.4983125031,
0.9474131465,
0.0963127911,
0.5826409459,
0.5037754178,
0.6472573876,
0.3194188774,
0.3379052877,
-0.6409065127,
0.4713590741,
-0.432038635,
-0.7621026039,
-0.391669482,
-0.7475549579,
-0.6624734402,
-0.2464566529,
-0.3760289252,
-0.5733119249,
-0.1596200168,
0.2073824406,
-0.3337073922,
0.326423347,
-0.3407063484,
0.9344829917,
-0.4108588994,
-0.8249659538,
-0.1319572628,
-0.5975283384,
0.6844138503,
-0.1681885272,
-0.0493792892,
0.0063697849,
0.187256366,
0.6825541258,
-0.7044760585,
0.690971911,
0.1205184162,
0.0635701418,
0.5045852065,
0.5815846324,
0.6336168647,
0.7239611745,
-0.1642125249,
-0.3252767324,
0.0594376773,
-0.4723076224,
-0.6095584631,
0.7458159328,
-0.7998101711,
-0.5308166742,
-0.3655611575,
-0.7886062264,
-0.2296927273,
0.294579953,
0.3721635044,
0.3131733239,
-0.1490463018,
0.6431057453,
0.6794665456,
-0.3033726215,
0.3873758912,
0.1315387934,
-0.6621700525,
-0.2420978844,
0.7046379447,
0.1503213644,
0.4914616346,
0.4642227292,
0.4363835752,
-0.4363691807,
-0.5417301655,
-0.4571880102,
-0.2629640102,
-0.5359984636,
-0.4299022853,
-0.7943790555,
-0.3745318651,
-0.4369451404,
-0.3374356925,
-0.2537284493,
-0.8736317754,
-0.1194301173,
-0.2261472046,
0.5639022589,
0.9517025352,
0.0189852454,
0.2662786841,
-0.537946701,
0.6136292219,
0.4806715548,
0.3455488384,
-0.5672240853,
-0.3852331936,
0.4284684062,
0.1016547903,
-0.3350773752,
-0.8707577586,
0.0156455636,
0.165874809,
0.2645865381,
-0.0343772992,
0.1566679627,
0.3536404669,
-0.4620227814,
0.7130287886,
0.4061794877,
-1.1892579794,
0.8318890333,
-0.5160011053,
-0.0076710866,
0.8185560107,
0.0318001285,
-0.2732283473,
-0.5479334593,
-0.5716605186,
-0.7235727906,
0.8194558024,
0.6986236572,
0.0883322582,
0.2164871246,
0.4345069528,
0.448321104,
0.3146927953,
-1.2707579136,
0.1957842559,
-0.9659349918,
-0.3819220662,
0.9032407999,
0.0227248538,
-0.233522594,
-0.1040151417,
0.6433985829,
0.0857307464,
-0.0538756512,
0.3001722991,
0.0876925066,
-0.3228227496,
0.3948115408,
0.6990415454,
0.7430827618,
-0.1727195084,
0.1366568059,
0.1172543615,
-0.3832757175,
-0.025594119,
-0.2875851691,
-0.7722058892,
0.2089085877,
0.0237818304,
0.4236117303,
-0.2502269447,
-0.3618700504,
0.686340332,
-0.0284423307,
-0.491101265,
-0.4465435147,
0.3913830519,
-0.0139569212,
-0.1252582669,
0.1979309618,
0.3854386806,
-0.0226596631,
-0.7784990072,
0.6865378618,
0.6112776399,
-0.3225519955,
0.0664747283,
0.9871571064,
0.2108860314,
-0.2506489754,
0.8389126658,
-0.527202785,
-0.437753588,
0.729473412,
0.9884033203,
0.6400472522,
0.3258674741,
0.4946069419,
0.3149237335,
0.4679564536,
-0.1606418043,
0.5182381272,
0.2707505226,
-0.7777279019,
-0.367171526,
-0.5246326923,
-0.4274255037,
0.0699249059,
-0.3270306587,
0.3781033456,
-0.7997040749,
-0.0015957974,
-0.3658386469,
-0.0855550095,
-0.4612495303,
0.0771438703,
-0.3555496633,
0.861105442,
-0.54071486,
0.8101129532,
0.3848705292,
-0.6492557526,
-1.0746200085,
-0.0472416393,
-0.0324800387,
-0.4779216051,
0.9738889933,
0.1888361871,
-0.2851320803,
-0.0039695948,
-0.7042687535,
-0.4212675095,
1.1979386806,
0.235406518,
-0.5837840438,
0.0303687677,
0.6792183518,
0.207434237,
-0.3626290858,
0.0001300089,
0.3408243358,
0.7793523669,
0.3614528179,
-0.3387148678,
0.1873073876,
-0.3220376074,
-0.0834324211,
0.0287116189,
-0.5305638313,
0.6618529558,
-0.1408729702,
-0.2557975352,
0.1273508072,
1.0953544378,
0.540186286,
0.2644371688,
0.4262157977,
0.4381759167,
0.6182849407,
-0.5491441488,
0.5005764961,
-0.1916318089,
0.0484843962,
1.2881695032,
-0.6780725718,
0.7613406181,
0.5355631709,
-0.0575279295,
0.5711767673,
-0.0844794512,
-0.2088353485,
0.1501866281,
0.4943690002,
-0.1630975157,
0.0059217932,
-0.2807126343,
-0.450789541,
0.3855460882,
0.2922014296,
0.0475778654,
-0.1827308238,
-0.3466538489,
0.1069450527,
0.4695246816,
-0.0063845939,
0.5850886106,
-0.2644167244,
-0.6869442463,
-0.1756397784,
-0.0000996965,
0.5543283224,
-0.8053674102,
-0.2392484695,
-0.3427458107,
-0.1740437597,
-0.7400707603,
-0.9210442901,
0.662437737,
-0.1181613579,
-0.1898614168,
-0.370193243,
0.6389342546,
-0.6042467356,
-0.8065679669,
-0.210507527,
0.5723820329,
-0.3205100894,
0.229020834,
-0.4984428585,
0.096962668,
0.1094477102,
-0.1272166669,
-0.1659372449,
0.756084919,
-0.0917250514,
0.2817132175,
0.915843606,
0.0964814872,
0.2179261893,
0.1367216408,
0.7845303416,
-0.5150033832,
-0.4838358462,
-0.8047753572,
0.7715991139,
-0.3026702404,
-0.455403924,
0.5313017368,
0.9630720019,
0.8474045396,
-0.1638252735,
0.8106153011,
-0.4696606398,
0.3829327226,
-0.8149125576,
0.8971549273,
-0.4564016759,
0.1713680774,
-0.1593891829,
-1.1221145391,
-0.4287539721,
0.5333017111,
0.0806158334,
0.0820788667,
0.9796675444,
0.9346755743,
-0.1496711522,
0.3135179579,
0.1083895043,
0.169647038,
0.5932030678,
0.5380344987,
1.1085309982,
-0.3263812959,
0.6491402388,
-0.082534641,
-0.1512709707,
0.1556806415,
-1.1707493067,
-0.9784901142,
-0.331743598,
-0.3003143668,
-0.5391840935,
0.0971339345,
1.1004167795,
0.4065357447,
-0.8713724613,
-0.1652242988,
-0.849491477,
0.1655550003,
-0.0107337497,
-0.3027497828,
0.3200145066,
-0.6377484202,
-0.1812830418,
0.1323171705,
0.413936913,
0.12975429,
-0.224544093,
0.0156505127,
-0.0512359664,
0.104014948,
0.5555189848,
-0.048006285,
-0.5656062961,
-0.1823101789,
0.0188892484,
-0.1798650771,
0.1959463805,
0.933699429,
-0.770937264,
-0.1944411695,
0.7353186607,
0.8481812477,
0.0677760616,
0.2174301893,
0.5211817622,
-0.8379691243,
-0.0996663421,
0.4189524353,
0.2495927513,
0.1692721993,
-0.6157982945,
0.564129293,
0.342300266,
-0.4924054146,
-0.5583965778,
0.6869499683,
-1.3739767075,
-0.2572174966,
0.7769590616,
0.3047204912,
-0.2632392347,
-0.1432632059,
-0.4659217596,
0.4287581146,
-0.4725222588,
1.0552810431,
0.4943567514,
-0.0770909414,
0.1215128899,
-0.6474161148,
0.8209009171,
0.8838365674,
-1.3594461679,
0.1472825557,
0.5736256242,
0.004172354,
0.0828685239,
0.3270939589,
-0.4418182373,
0.4407688081,
-0.2412730157,
-0.3157909811,
-0.2504658997,
-0.5045484304,
0.459669739,
0.3287762105,
-0.1301216185,
0.3206598759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02900v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02900v1 | Controllable Lexical Simplification for English | 2023-02-06T16:09:27 | 2023-02-06T16:09:27 | Kim Cheng Sheang, Daniel Ferrés, Horacio Saggion | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Fine-tuning Transformer-based approaches have recently shown exciting results
on sentence simplification task. However, so far, no research has applied
similar approaches to the Lexical Simplification (LS) task. In this paper, we
present ConLS, a Controllable Lexical Simplification system fine-tuned with T5
(a Transformer-based model pre-trained with a BERT-style approach and several
other tasks). The evaluation results on three datasets (LexMTurk, BenchLS, and
NNSeval) have shown that our model performs comparable to LSBert (the current
state-of-the-art) and even outperforms it in some cases. We also conducted a
detailed comparison on the effectiveness of control tokens to give a clear view
of how each token contributes to the model. | [
-0.1097555533,
-0.3780295849,
0.1230167672,
0.3430698216,
-0.4886634946,
0.0811541453,
-0.4072306156,
-0.4071854949,
0.0971761346,
0.161371991,
-0.6688560843,
-0.3469262719,
-0.7152411938,
0.5846256614,
-0.461222142,
0.884714663,
-0.0136965597,
0.0463958271,
0.208626613,
0.0326496139,
-0.4889875948,
-0.199796319,
-0.8595237136,
-0.5893595219,
0.5388506651,
0.6771807075,
1.0807141066,
0.2782031596,
0.6821399927,
0.2726545036,
-0.5795013309,
0.512680769,
-0.56051296,
-0.079821676,
-0.3291837871,
-0.3497648835,
-0.2785571218,
-0.4192382097,
0.3142098784,
0.7941942215,
0.0018786591,
0.0945500955,
0.2145434469,
0.36272493,
-0.6705641747,
0.1445731074,
-0.6402606964,
0.0930860192,
-0.012864884,
0.056609679,
-0.6352707148,
-0.6543180943,
-0.2818104625,
-0.6709248424,
0.0871040151,
0.3000303805,
0.89191401,
0.6224317551,
-0.5457758904,
-0.3167425394,
-1.029507041,
1.1016179323,
-0.7184613943,
0.6118525863,
-0.0862468034,
0.361319989,
-0.1904669851,
-1.0449090004,
-0.5283290148,
-0.3531648517,
-0.6454282403,
0.0391625501,
-0.2870566845,
0.4686998427,
0.3789940178,
0.0526844114,
-0.281383276,
0.1309790909,
-0.6655997634,
-0.3437722623,
0.5477284789,
0.1282162815,
0.1869276315,
0.023501616,
-0.3790018559,
0.2379689664,
-0.6280227304,
0.2956713438,
-0.2917694151,
0.438360393,
-0.0107691623,
0.6818922162,
-0.1496306062,
0.4317506552,
0.2119535655,
-0.2754896581,
0.0859427601,
-0.3327522874,
-0.4572864473,
0.0204592664,
0.5663675666,
0.5473816991,
0.7901220322,
-0.4146147966,
-0.5844953656,
0.2319665402,
0.0055337609,
-0.8411982059,
0.1365186572,
0.3494660258,
-0.2934990823,
-0.1891883165,
-0.086436294,
-0.029188877,
-0.0458744764,
-0.740695715,
0.3401867449,
-0.7018954158,
0.2284656763,
0.3592109382,
-0.0301297884,
0.0695801899,
0.4624920785,
-0.6967083812,
0.8064792156,
0.7315781116,
0.5259863734,
-0.3957078755,
-0.1964211613,
-0.2704698741,
0.0413053855,
-0.6546944976,
0.1915099323,
-0.6164417267,
-0.2794294357,
0.0509188361,
0.0943187028,
0.2020990551,
-0.6674556136,
0.5968691707,
-0.3869716227,
-0.0051862057,
-0.0890859067,
-0.823698163,
0.2321430445,
0.1392862201,
-0.6092073917,
0.9000496268,
-0.4283869863,
-0.6634238958,
0.4087717533,
-0.4315879345,
-0.5452810526,
0.0156850871,
-0.0394293144,
-0.2649537027,
0.075074181,
0.0229371842,
0.4769670665,
-0.1036984026,
0.6232112646,
0.1809016466,
-0.6466039419,
-0.0330788456,
-0.43459481,
0.5373719335,
0.4945281446,
-0.2742244005,
0.2596561909,
-0.7721770406,
-0.0306090862,
-0.3433766067,
-0.1069035679,
-0.192632556,
-0.1601724923,
0.106291391,
0.1474155784,
0.6221739054,
-0.7378650308,
0.1489215344,
-0.2790214121,
0.3219992816,
0.0971532464,
0.0803819299,
0.4376628697,
-0.3544351161,
0.3980627954,
0.0866113231,
0.5296961665,
0.0002393851,
-0.0931592956,
-0.8509489894,
-0.2610068023,
0.5799005032,
0.581852138,
-0.6399546266,
0.5254929662,
-0.2764419615,
-0.6927810311,
-0.4953665137,
-0.157886982,
0.4943922758,
0.1307477206,
0.6854750514,
0.2450289279,
-0.2760671973,
-1.0217642784,
-0.3656391799,
0.5759746432,
-0.2344225943,
-0.0924959332,
0.2083161026,
0.2081082761,
0.9981485009,
-0.3075559437,
-0.4016226232,
-0.4729262888,
0.085494563,
0.2092375904,
0.488142401,
0.2040991336,
-0.7756624818,
-0.3797450662,
-0.0822402984,
-0.4468623698,
-0.3732059002,
-0.1669075638,
0.4798991978,
0.1212043166,
1.4035378695,
-0.5177761316,
0.4949175715,
0.4186704755,
-0.3742371798,
0.2835214436,
-0.5137078166,
-0.2808590829,
-1.1078023911,
0.1907034814,
-0.3057240248,
-0.6172609925,
-0.7104728818,
0.0009626221,
0.3932237327,
-0.1047169119,
-0.8513613343,
0.3962135911,
-0.31132707,
0.2960036099,
-0.026714582,
-0.0521140434,
-0.1513389349,
0.5653163791,
-0.315913111,
0.8001637459,
0.1177595183,
-0.6463289857,
0.1503718942,
-0.0315674767,
-0.0517642908,
-0.1016707346,
-1.0198105574,
-0.248613134,
-0.3909348845,
0.2306484133,
-0.9667962193,
0.1787863225,
-0.2169588804,
0.032913655,
0.2297080308,
0.4575368464,
-0.4209080935,
-0.132731244,
-0.2656697035,
0.1958471388,
0.4986262918,
-0.4319833815,
0.6707756519,
-0.120317772,
-0.0648457408,
-0.5523453355,
-0.8099060059,
-0.2165875137,
0.0456752665,
-0.1346236467,
0.6459751725,
0.0359260738,
-0.3787109256,
-0.1470059156,
-0.0872210637,
0.1527764201,
0.0515985638,
0.0853697658,
0.0398859382,
0.2844912112,
0.4210016727,
0.3110167086,
-0.2017873377,
-0.4196863472,
0.1998160034,
0.5475798845,
0.1077517718,
-0.1262356788,
-0.6625520587,
0.2604883611,
0.8527351022,
-0.2711135447,
0.5296415687,
0.1692513973,
-0.4899112284,
-0.405955106,
-0.345089376,
-0.3013386428,
-0.4784402251,
0.1342740506,
-0.6960210204,
-1.0142115355,
0.4710171819,
-0.4090078771,
0.5596168637,
0.4061197639,
0.1914244741,
-0.0350269228,
0.6745945811,
0.749040246,
0.0169927962,
0.3309704959,
0.1034413651,
0.4301849902,
-0.1117682904,
-0.3211890459,
-0.5050988793,
-0.7114219666,
-0.9226008058,
0.0252912492,
0.2973548174,
0.2800361514,
-0.4752958417,
0.4840121269,
-0.4126536548,
0.6353760362,
0.4160208106,
0.1366434395,
0.5934605598,
-0.3902229965,
-0.4826248586,
-0.2071572393,
-0.623134613,
-0.3974031508,
0.6454678774,
0.3967635334,
1.0836898088,
0.0870532244,
0.6493631005,
0.218520835,
0.0727789104,
-0.5937276483,
0.6869697571,
-0.7896002531,
-0.195426017,
-0.5571905375,
-0.0085275704,
-0.9684175253,
-0.0202752687,
-0.3244280219,
-0.4754781723,
0.0073157381,
0.2323833108,
-0.4860408604,
-0.0058296178,
-1.0958036184,
0.5147117972,
0.172360152,
-0.2369984239,
-0.2594952583,
-0.6251398325,
-0.0582046509,
-0.1080333367,
0.296251148,
-0.0481607541,
-0.2212461531,
0.2284167707,
-0.844429493,
0.9591702819,
-0.0583982319,
0.0030429789,
-0.1065226346,
0.3145471215,
0.759008348,
-0.3415710926,
-0.0226628594,
-0.1189365312,
0.1295414269,
-0.1743709445,
-0.6374971867,
0.5337753892,
-0.5163301229,
-0.3787710667,
0.1071466208,
-0.7145311236,
-0.1055721194,
0.3886651397,
0.2251008153,
0.5893995166,
-0.1842146963,
0.3605745137,
0.3109452426,
-0.0706651509,
0.8304823041,
0.2652924061,
-0.480466634,
-0.1429484636,
0.4938952923,
0.3394525349,
0.4179148972,
0.6020219326,
0.2203212082,
-0.174925074,
-0.1815439314,
0.0920076147,
0.1805331707,
-0.5265217423,
-0.3353485167,
-0.3487327695,
-0.3380675614,
-0.3635786772,
-0.4193254709,
-0.3619576395,
-0.6114622355,
-0.0515599549,
-0.0961644799,
0.2962101996,
0.9511592388,
0.2654696107,
0.4938901663,
-0.2150494903,
0.4047819674,
0.1488257051,
0.3457010984,
-0.4471833408,
-0.4711197019,
0.0794358552,
-0.2437821627,
-0.0937238112,
-0.5279054642,
0.3417576253,
0.3291583061,
0.0374219939,
0.2551199496,
0.1389489025,
0.6685063243,
-0.8260596395,
0.7834431529,
0.0657293275,
-1.1847751141,
0.3145661354,
0.0218512304,
0.5946290493,
0.4836761355,
0.2635770142,
-0.5549362302,
-0.8099259734,
-0.8490585685,
-0.7262295485,
0.425381273,
0.3623373806,
0.1267699003,
0.2128089219,
0.4430375099,
0.0011424734,
0.2828000188,
-0.6348255873,
-0.2559013963,
0.1864122599,
-0.6320413947,
-0.2049767524,
-0.3165163696,
0.2061233073,
-0.2204529196,
0.6915254593,
0.0568769649,
-0.3349021971,
0.3321849406,
-0.1113239303,
0.1909217685,
0.5570709109,
0.6567662954,
0.4573520422,
-0.2247263938,
0.3780265152,
0.6997081041,
-0.3167894185,
0.0138497194,
0.0348558985,
-0.6472909451,
0.5938305855,
0.3824895024,
0.6444275975,
0.4043958187,
-0.4612337947,
0.5363665819,
0.0461364165,
-0.3669632673,
-0.1103504971,
-0.0394383222,
0.0853833258,
0.0621988103,
0.0430096798,
0.158414945,
0.0518105887,
-0.110940367,
0.2251244187,
0.2483288348,
-0.3234647512,
-0.1213253215,
0.6226826906,
0.2163687199,
-0.4029380977,
-0.0387080386,
-0.3062041402,
-0.2345746905,
0.5421440601,
0.6999578476,
0.563819766,
-0.4050207734,
-0.2792704403,
0.2950264513,
0.6853452325,
-0.098663792,
0.6143160462,
0.1212871745,
-0.6570446491,
-0.4736676216,
-0.4289191961,
-0.6688085794,
0.1770537645,
-0.4323172569,
0.8519503474,
-0.5975676179,
0.1450305581,
0.2292366177,
-0.0298188701,
-0.7599420547,
0.7362573743,
0.0239092037,
1.5377576351,
-0.9320337176,
0.9672625661,
0.5566678643,
-0.1725967675,
-1.31305933,
-0.0086248368,
-0.4917454123,
-0.4614424407,
0.6464307904,
0.0073897,
-0.3890471458,
0.1766686887,
-0.6692782044,
-0.816624999,
1.1470097303,
0.5841926932,
-1.0165160894,
-0.0816343799,
0.5506818891,
0.7574548721,
0.0110884989,
0.435757786,
0.5945907831,
0.4263811409,
0.08097817,
-1.286785841,
-0.0756713673,
0.0482060611,
0.1833234578,
0.2265759856,
-0.6447485685,
0.6603885293,
-0.024751341,
-0.1425635815,
-0.2648981214,
0.7552163005,
-0.2254871726,
-0.1277317554,
0.712854147,
0.3436170816,
0.8741274476,
-0.1185073033,
0.855995357,
-0.7321309447,
0.606987536,
1.1911796331,
-0.0921262577,
0.8307949305,
0.8690725565,
-0.0449724644,
0.2075214237,
0.203077659,
0.2976114452,
0.578078568,
0.4888817072,
-0.1647588611,
-0.2626008391,
-0.511226356,
0.2191010416,
0.2868296504,
0.3655769229,
-0.1670998037,
-0.6395974755,
0.1384214908,
0.2576859295,
0.2043350637,
-0.5781168938,
0.7606250048,
0.1013043299,
-0.8000613451,
0.5694945455,
0.1805043966,
0.9996920228,
-0.6707823277,
0.0973469988,
-0.555534184,
0.4731619656,
-0.3681330383,
-0.597402215,
0.5021336079,
0.0936626419,
0.1404376477,
-0.51879251,
0.9060273767,
-0.8110499978,
-0.528939724,
0.2498083115,
0.371311903,
0.1036572456,
0.298057586,
-0.2084163725,
0.0067446488,
0.1174544767,
-0.0187657271,
-0.4520462453,
0.568184793,
-0.4036550522,
0.876267314,
0.2024674714,
0.070287399,
0.2111502588,
0.3424150944,
0.7274589539,
-0.7505557537,
-0.4198186994,
-0.7675626278,
0.3331219256,
0.0403389297,
-0.5009480119,
0.351896137,
0.7876852751,
0.8927049637,
-0.1166324094,
0.6094555855,
0.1626433879,
0.8091250658,
-0.5489945412,
0.4434081912,
-0.6611025333,
0.0141480975,
0.2581853867,
-0.5183584094,
-0.7477301359,
0.0415824726,
-0.0381019786,
-0.3137530386,
1.0017018318,
1.1602176428,
-0.3882822692,
-0.0802536532,
0.6525175571,
0.2958570123,
0.2135035098,
0.4142155945,
0.3324033618,
-0.4397036135,
0.6200602055,
-0.4257204533,
-0.0104944212,
-0.0184042286,
-0.9333909154,
-0.8290354013,
-0.3966045976,
-0.1215707734,
-0.0027657724,
0.1433259845,
1.3692339659,
0.2848861814,
-1.0642991066,
-0.0764300749,
-0.4040114582,
-0.1627701074,
-0.2496207505,
-0.1022097692,
0.2860892713,
-0.9970947504,
-1.0053598881,
0.225666061,
0.0257292874,
-0.0550035723,
0.0672090277,
0.1385833472,
0.0785703883,
0.2911988497,
0.4964994788,
-0.2264247537,
-0.9083999395,
-0.452146709,
0.1535820216,
-0.6128875017,
-0.1960102022,
0.7585363984,
-0.6671590209,
0.1708353758,
0.2995944321,
0.4688795805,
0.2442875654,
-0.1303340942,
0.5511614084,
-1.1956595182,
0.2997101545,
0.0530253425,
0.5055857301,
0.1850888282,
-0.1560186893,
0.4098075926,
-0.2120171189,
-0.3240400255,
-0.250770092,
0.1086047888,
-1.030356288,
-0.3403759599,
1.3448607922,
0.141055733,
-0.0857170597,
-0.0441081449,
-0.5611261129,
0.4446342587,
-0.421238184,
0.4862889349,
0.617797792,
0.2024859041,
-0.0962352827,
-0.0738597661,
0.9634655118,
0.9706178308,
-0.7000307441,
0.1108584255,
0.2003500015,
0.2449925542,
0.2037436813,
0.22503905,
0.1429854035,
0.0151587073,
-0.5179297924,
0.5023275614,
-0.0897195339,
-0.3239150643,
-0.6460698843,
0.2585547566,
0.0688205287,
-0.2853697538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02888v1 | Findings of the TSAR-2022 Shared Task on Multilingual Lexical Simplification | 2023-02-06T15:53:51 | 2023-02-06T15:53:51 | Horacio Saggion, Sanja Štajner, Daniel Ferrés, Kim Cheng Sheang, Matthew Shardlow, Kai North, Marcos Zampieri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We report findings of the TSAR-2022 shared task on multilingual lexical
simplification, organized as part of the Workshop on Text Simplification,
Accessibility, and Readability TSAR-2022 held in conjunction with EMNLP 2022.
The task called the Natural Language Processing research community to
contribute with methods to advance the state of the art in multilingual lexical
simplification for English, Portuguese, and Spanish. A total of 14 teams
submitted the results of their lexical simplification systems for the provided
test data. Results of the shared task indicate new benchmarks in Lexical
Simplification with English lexical simplification quantitative results
noticeably higher than those obtained for Spanish and (Brazilian) Portuguese. | [
-0.271617949,
-0.2886814177,
0.5759243965,
0.7765641212,
-0.2042071372,
0.2245025933,
-0.2329782844,
-0.8932982683,
0.3199307919,
0.1777775288,
-0.4716807604,
-0.5853868127,
-0.5796923041,
0.5149983168,
-0.1792124808,
0.824238956,
-0.0519449376,
0.2987444997,
-0.2551938891,
0.0726850852,
-0.383123368,
-0.4727410376,
-0.4321190715,
-0.3807123899,
0.7962434292,
0.6047163606,
0.7704390883,
0.6125095487,
0.4917261302,
0.3197005093,
-0.1646929532,
0.1781960726,
-0.1028928831,
-0.1022028401,
0.0136260828,
-0.2712161839,
-0.8270792961,
-0.3919636309,
0.6037105918,
0.80465132,
-0.104867667,
-0.2012636513,
0.3008429706,
0.4887158573,
-0.5637667775,
0.4482855797,
-0.3232770562,
0.1276027113,
-0.1189785823,
-0.330355376,
-0.3278383017,
-0.3777225316,
-0.1168828458,
-0.8740416765,
0.0994858369,
0.1413902938,
0.5374732614,
0.1004949734,
-0.5331505537,
-0.2569102049,
-0.6025049686,
1.0431871414,
-0.2544639111,
0.4506537914,
0.2804400325,
0.0895973593,
-0.0727800652,
-0.7224118114,
-0.1652287245,
-0.064365074,
-0.3063756227,
0.2014879733,
-0.3423421681,
0.205493629,
0.1165905371,
0.0781933963,
-0.5698049664,
-0.0367614739,
-0.6350013018,
-0.5736488104,
0.6276866794,
-0.1438533068,
0.2099271715,
-0.0303022731,
-0.3539059758,
0.2385247648,
-0.7675036192,
-0.3333911896,
0.3454440832,
0.4490659237,
-0.1400826573,
0.4627276659,
-0.6574543118,
0.5666568279,
-0.7286269665,
-0.0610647388,
0.5578999519,
-1.0551577806,
-0.0959736183,
0.1136639044,
0.7090904713,
0.3207316995,
0.2059477568,
-0.284815222,
-0.1545495093,
-0.1744757444,
-0.0806349143,
-0.4215902388,
0.1122741848,
0.0477388874,
-0.3179146647,
-0.0828009248,
-0.0729350671,
-0.8692648411,
-0.0634448454,
-0.3423088491,
0.4973279834,
-0.2290412337,
-0.1918591857,
0.2914496064,
-0.4607034326,
-0.0119588533,
0.734942019,
-0.7984024882,
0.7404849529,
0.808129847,
0.6571335196,
-0.3052915335,
-0.732668817,
-0.2479954064,
0.1007538512,
-0.1027682051,
0.8855906129,
-0.3406120539,
-0.2800329924,
-0.084077917,
-0.0428570732,
0.0309523884,
-0.6192882657,
0.810775876,
-0.0631667748,
-0.0040916917,
-0.5316784978,
-0.1609801352,
0.0407449752,
0.3172107935,
-0.5733319521,
0.9878944755,
-0.3731727004,
-0.7545274496,
0.3613685966,
-0.5909839272,
-0.334035933,
0.042052038,
-0.0389649346,
-0.0370441303,
0.0993310288,
0.1325749755,
0.1433669776,
-0.4179870784,
0.2960427105,
-0.0867596418,
-0.3444592059,
-0.0564192384,
-0.4250286818,
0.5431860089,
0.3262842,
-0.2489636689,
0.1704733968,
-0.6065421104,
0.0730429068,
-0.1992809623,
-0.4718049765,
-0.1697119921,
-0.3454555869,
0.4946852922,
0.3061198294,
0.8980868459,
-0.6800915599,
0.027941348,
-0.1638206393,
-0.0640242547,
0.3318148851,
-0.1975922883,
0.5142322183,
-0.307836622,
0.5773154497,
0.037216831,
0.2591697276,
-0.0676983893,
-0.7318425179,
-0.6725172997,
-0.2758045495,
0.6319605708,
0.5411436558,
-0.6214543581,
0.1084149182,
-0.1949072778,
-0.4367806613,
-0.2798567116,
-0.2135974318,
0.5480706692,
-0.0327906087,
0.3948419392,
0.0346749313,
-0.6136812568,
-1.1206160784,
-0.5424619317,
0.0789863318,
0.0711708739,
-0.2661979198,
0.6632412076,
0.2974115014,
0.5887984037,
-0.5263031125,
-0.1996573657,
-0.3942453563,
0.4278437197,
-0.050461255,
0.6311638355,
0.4232800305,
-1.092881918,
-0.7440008521,
0.3018876016,
-0.4054847956,
-0.2589955628,
0.5488842726,
0.3394484818,
0.4094628394,
0.71223104,
-0.0943168029,
0.4758623242,
0.5778634548,
-0.3742566407,
0.4726916552,
-0.5496091247,
0.3342469335,
-1.0399718285,
0.0873768553,
-0.5708153248,
-0.5008789301,
-0.6593208909,
-0.0308200512,
0.131564483,
0.0672793165,
-0.6029204726,
0.3501825631,
-0.6105793715,
-0.4144764841,
-0.1133833528,
0.0417407826,
-0.0963566378,
0.3309614062,
0.0990356356,
0.6764345169,
0.6113629937,
-0.4777284563,
0.2254848629,
-0.2579672635,
0.049004335,
0.2861246765,
-0.6756283045,
-0.3071528375,
-0.0786886588,
-0.0666644424,
-1.0100363493,
-0.2312886119,
0.0438860655,
-0.6064169407,
0.0597575419,
0.052718237,
-0.850906074,
0.0509596877,
-0.4229735434,
0.5076751709,
0.1909608096,
-0.307171464,
0.5318502188,
0.440353483,
-0.3151469827,
-0.695032835,
-0.9142305255,
0.1915129721,
-0.0535171777,
-0.4665007293,
0.6162233949,
-0.2142369449,
-0.3004645407,
0.020478867,
0.1870346814,
-0.3066257238,
0.0921083614,
0.0848010331,
0.0775499716,
0.19352144,
0.2959606349,
0.1346644163,
-0.2196080983,
-0.1774101257,
0.212494716,
0.7070849538,
-0.1745467335,
-0.0461930782,
-0.1960916966,
0.5904108286,
0.3641133606,
-0.17639184,
0.8455929756,
0.5860013962,
-0.6083037853,
0.1018391326,
-0.2871315777,
-0.0500276312,
-0.4322909415,
0.0794322193,
-0.5204706192,
-1.0322312117,
0.7850217223,
-0.2303249687,
0.1441784948,
0.6446080208,
0.355520606,
0.1499199122,
0.8688746095,
0.8304277062,
0.3327896297,
0.123870939,
0.1267901808,
-0.0558472089,
-0.4896243513,
-0.5364037752,
-1.0349975824,
-0.261174053,
-0.875911653,
-0.4337062538,
0.3935619891,
-0.0179221947,
0.3189100921,
0.4259174466,
-0.1963138282,
0.6042585373,
0.4519928396,
-0.2663410306,
0.7549504638,
-0.0774410069,
-0.5971474648,
-0.2924798131,
-0.4758170843,
-0.2051205635,
1.0008922815,
-0.0471897051,
0.2762028277,
0.2322875857,
1.0243792534,
0.2509490252,
-0.1060930863,
-0.6361505389,
0.6297287345,
-0.0744254962,
-0.4159995615,
-0.2288883626,
-0.4526513517,
-1.1779021025,
0.4031722248,
-0.1693235934,
-0.7550112009,
0.0645022765,
-0.0678164363,
0.1070416942,
-0.1891325265,
-0.6905620694,
0.9534987807,
0.4482277036,
-0.13677077,
-0.6087049842,
-0.4027894735,
0.0706182718,
-0.1407911479,
0.5388391018,
-0.0875470713,
-0.4601979852,
0.7216548324,
-0.3951610029,
0.5648239255,
0.0135581139,
0.0060276794,
-0.0524863862,
-0.2192101181,
0.3258462846,
0.0062873019,
-0.1702800989,
0.0368508585,
-0.0411478579,
-0.5204789639,
-0.2076055259,
0.7371219397,
-0.6609365344,
-0.1626841575,
-0.8116856217,
-0.7077014446,
0.1030843854,
0.4314126074,
0.1998164803,
0.6795523167,
-0.7048376203,
0.2206965089,
0.2453200668,
-0.1331156641,
0.7644637227,
0.5596088171,
-0.5937878489,
-0.4981359541,
0.7596225142,
0.3921049237,
0.337180227,
0.6543138623,
0.194931522,
-0.2578252852,
-0.7236821055,
-0.0061269384,
0.2951402962,
-0.5774791837,
-0.0440346859,
-0.6573135853,
0.0865435079,
-0.7285698056,
-0.0556818284,
-0.4084421098,
-0.8725987077,
-0.1480272263,
0.1822581887,
0.0809497014,
1.1231878996,
-0.4813275635,
0.3483193219,
-0.6260709763,
0.2773857415,
0.1371061951,
-0.0674178153,
-0.4175343812,
-0.2225930542,
-0.4044638574,
-0.1413882822,
-0.3893504739,
-0.7267248631,
0.5630156398,
0.1673976779,
0.4064542353,
-0.1980720609,
-0.156285122,
0.5914664865,
-0.4860836565,
0.5991063714,
0.1117607206,
-1.0452667475,
0.3855200708,
-0.579367578,
0.793059051,
0.4412011504,
0.477296412,
-0.7289382219,
-0.5772292614,
-0.7189571857,
-0.7386526465,
0.7958475351,
0.3786650598,
-0.3626737297,
0.1529681832,
-0.0028588222,
0.0002590192,
0.3921905756,
-0.6542182565,
-0.459612906,
0.5540525913,
-0.0403093807,
-0.1129054353,
-0.2726048827,
0.0482800677,
-0.2951680422,
0.5258882046,
-0.1973173171,
0.3283741772,
0.1889198422,
0.1642631739,
-0.041040156,
0.8330048323,
0.8120139837,
0.8566899896,
0.0282053351,
0.2773162425,
0.4265576899,
-0.5032464862,
-0.1604667604,
0.325728327,
-0.2012240142,
0.3054921627,
0.4275136292,
0.3317144811,
0.3745820522,
-0.465374589,
0.522697866,
-0.3333280683,
-0.4302018881,
-0.3872914612,
-0.2374466658,
0.4176200032,
-0.0373404287,
0.3503253758,
0.3858514428,
0.686617434,
-0.7587259412,
0.0412527286,
0.1624647081,
-0.1607943475,
-0.4454387724,
0.1063919067,
0.0846640319,
-0.0129997209,
0.0508014187,
-0.4828465581,
-0.7137524486,
0.7989216447,
0.5782660246,
0.5488584638,
-0.1835930347,
0.2717142999,
0.3975484669,
0.4362526536,
-0.1923867017,
0.9768490791,
0.0163597502,
-0.6064482927,
-0.4208238721,
-0.5290560722,
-0.5469439626,
-0.2668233514,
-0.7734333277,
0.5401578546,
-0.052439101,
0.0969142765,
0.0605276898,
0.232037738,
-0.5940264463,
0.1542313099,
0.0466192216,
0.7801746726,
-0.908221364,
0.9074398279,
0.7047643661,
0.1508615613,
-0.6590914726,
-0.2668972909,
0.1472804993,
-0.5345608592,
0.7233203053,
0.2531022727,
-0.2946742773,
-0.1345838904,
-0.1227718592,
-1.0506353378,
1.0236595869,
0.4648296535,
-0.3842318952,
0.0565897934,
0.605664432,
0.6478502154,
-0.1190798059,
0.379558444,
0.5436249971,
0.8978990912,
0.1135104373,
-1.6997898817,
-0.0973080099,
-0.2086931318,
-0.4412379563,
0.548748374,
-0.6726734042,
0.9328413606,
0.0293949451,
-0.1683361828,
0.1095157564,
0.776032567,
-0.0858753622,
0.4398389161,
0.2522988617,
0.6450150013,
0.6653795242,
-0.3995545506,
0.8534621596,
-0.0288907029,
0.3489149511,
1.1170740128,
0.1181055531,
0.9426867366,
0.7109187841,
-0.2549281716,
0.0790506825,
0.2745691538,
0.3726134598,
0.5171208978,
0.2217695713,
-0.4618035555,
-0.0944579765,
-0.8891115785,
-0.3180099726,
0.6324281693,
0.3775775731,
-0.0915921926,
-0.5058429241,
0.0435760207,
0.4027355909,
0.1753374189,
-0.4708794653,
0.7923110723,
-0.0323056802,
-0.8774092793,
0.3274911642,
0.3373757899,
0.8386656642,
-0.5938239098,
-0.1044591889,
0.0522730909,
0.3599483669,
-0.3148958683,
-0.8729704618,
0.7764509916,
-0.0283982493,
-0.0349444114,
-0.6562387347,
0.7273521423,
-0.7012678385,
-0.4141843915,
0.714756906,
0.6660286188,
0.4573666751,
-0.2135404944,
-0.4835347831,
0.3100417852,
0.0649840981,
0.0566867962,
0.3874154985,
0.3530887365,
0.1436602324,
0.4685685635,
0.2831653953,
0.0891966298,
0.3776317239,
0.1392233074,
0.8967404366,
-0.6305001378,
-0.4262804687,
-0.7478047013,
0.2508670986,
-0.0705163851,
-0.6302366257,
0.8872045279,
0.9575828314,
0.9398533106,
-0.1158257425,
0.5368964672,
-0.2298249453,
0.4388868213,
-0.3534018993,
0.6210602522,
-0.8758601546,
-0.2533486187,
-0.0610749386,
-0.9032077193,
-0.6174839139,
-0.0675734654,
-0.026487777,
0.0040961411,
1.1454075575,
0.8040522337,
0.1515979469,
0.046019759,
0.6676107645,
-0.0227853116,
0.0171690769,
0.5377493501,
0.5349879265,
-0.5559665561,
0.6743125319,
-0.6092877984,
-0.0402641594,
-0.1101605594,
-0.8839456439,
-0.5563485622,
-0.6482351422,
-0.2956897616,
0.0385965444,
0.1819178611,
0.9297972918,
0.1253633499,
-0.6833122969,
-0.5054432154,
-0.3109022379,
0.2443324924,
-0.1745488048,
-0.2412674129,
0.1000264883,
-0.4151807725,
-1.1741527319,
0.470092088,
0.4764445722,
-0.0346198604,
-0.0329230428,
-0.0357199423,
-0.3312320113,
-0.2767681479,
0.3127690256,
0.0985502973,
-0.562712431,
-0.1279224008,
0.1662014425,
-0.2750423253,
0.175504759,
0.6809771061,
-0.6472779512,
0.4292509556,
0.9916248322,
0.0787416473,
0.3419289291,
-0.5413472652,
0.7301443219,
-0.867513597,
0.2552937567,
0.1144375354,
0.4967837334,
0.3652190268,
-0.053158544,
0.4992571175,
0.1796420217,
-0.7253075838,
-0.6156864166,
0.1610585451,
-1.0804467201,
-0.101792559,
0.808560133,
-0.1361249089,
-0.3804462552,
-0.4286319315,
-0.2325903773,
0.3731241524,
-0.5903858542,
0.0893576592,
0.7895385027,
-0.019244656,
-0.1280831844,
-0.4828302562,
0.7947918773,
0.5209661126,
-1.3170241117,
-0.0427426063,
0.2789742649,
-0.0409572572,
0.4489798844,
0.5173113942,
-0.1969762295,
0.6910705566,
0.0248221196,
0.3379383981,
0.1989278644,
-0.8590428233,
-0.5929592252,
0.1526347548,
0.1388254166,
0.1008419991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02852v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02852v1 | Guide the Learner: Controlling Product of Experts Debiasing Method Based on Token Attribution Similarities | 2023-02-06T15:21:41 | 2023-02-06T15:21:41 | Ali Modarressi, Hossein Amirkhani, Mohammad Taher Pilehvar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Several proposals have been put forward in recent years for improving
out-of-distribution (OOD) performance through mitigating dataset biases. A
popular workaround is to train a robust model by re-weighting training examples
based on a secondary biased model. Here, the underlying assumption is that the
biased model resorts to shortcut features. Hence, those training examples that
are correctly predicted by the biased model are flagged as being biased and are
down-weighted during the training of the main model. However, assessing the
importance of an instance merely based on the predictions of the biased model
may be too naive. It is possible that the prediction of the main model can be
derived from another decision-making process that is distinct from the behavior
of the biased model. To circumvent this, we introduce a fine-tuning strategy
that incorporates the similarity between the main and biased model attribution
scores in a Product of Experts (PoE) loss function to further improve OOD
performance. With experiments conducted on natural language inference and fact
verification benchmarks, we show that our method improves OOD results while
maintaining in-distribution (ID) performance. | [
-0.3986339271,
-0.7055304646,
0.3049928546,
-0.2664302588,
-0.3749068379,
0.1174422726,
-0.0421863534,
-0.2088306695,
0.1328186244,
0.7114384174,
-0.4391808212,
-0.4428632855,
-0.737619698,
-0.2151515186,
-0.062816374,
0.9611797333,
0.0156194437,
-0.0575970784,
-0.2213173509,
-0.236091733,
-0.4344415665,
-0.2441657633,
-0.9618392587,
-0.4693697095,
0.3426722884,
0.7287812233,
0.6925136447,
0.8373613358,
0.7374138832,
0.1986918449,
-0.2772889733,
0.1530302763,
-0.5858178139,
-0.1392657608,
-0.5877217054,
-0.906596303,
-0.3964404464,
0.1269584894,
0.2351370752,
0.427720964,
-0.2455904931,
0.3325878978,
0.3408836424,
0.6099294424,
-0.8444949389,
0.2221989334,
-0.8246058822,
0.0010040608,
-0.03123294,
-0.343998313,
-0.5046067238,
-0.3868837655,
0.1093564704,
-0.4572863281,
0.4636461437,
0.2955920994,
0.6713361144,
0.7118221521,
-0.4512828887,
-0.2015215904,
-0.4989926517,
1.0712007284,
-0.7939466238,
0.1844507456,
0.4431043565,
0.2572350204,
-0.1333950162,
-0.0958589986,
-0.4542215765,
0.0205283239,
0.1050491631,
-0.0500640236,
-0.106768176,
0.2827724516,
0.2282371819,
0.0394517854,
0.0558318533,
0.2549054325,
-0.4924444258,
-0.1015872136,
0.881513834,
-0.0797551572,
-0.2405181974,
-0.0500247441,
-0.7920199633,
-0.1851500869,
-0.7278766632,
0.0658950359,
0.7464475036,
0.1938814223,
0.1621313244,
0.4989813268,
-0.1449998021,
0.4504522085,
0.5218126178,
-0.41432482,
0.4515554011,
0.0396968722,
-0.2366241664,
0.448017031,
0.3790522218,
0.7366113663,
0.3464750648,
-0.0313914083,
-0.1999745667,
-0.1875728965,
0.2594071329,
-0.6184883714,
-0.3839297295,
-0.0993347019,
-0.6628651023,
-0.6560690403,
0.1171584353,
-0.869454205,
-0.6046090722,
-0.5256929398,
0.4836843312,
-0.2640144229,
-0.3371367455,
0.1128441468,
-0.3036181331,
0.063405253,
0.0686935857,
-0.8324207067,
0.5182911754,
0.6765881777,
0.837936759,
-0.4161864817,
-0.1468866318,
-0.8918187022,
0.2945326269,
-0.3583682179,
0.6817904711,
-0.4652380049,
-0.2528955638,
-0.1767693013,
-0.4042834342,
-0.0430570692,
-0.7650226951,
0.3943250179,
-0.5393615961,
-0.0827564597,
-0.5278029442,
-0.4902423918,
-0.3253143132,
0.2052221447,
-0.5473043919,
0.9066370726,
-0.0636674017,
-1.0179809332,
0.9169288874,
-0.6215442419,
-0.2207767665,
-0.4212971032,
-0.2908730805,
-0.4703156352,
0.2327070832,
0.3785046637,
0.3008357286,
-0.060843382,
0.1465676725,
-0.4814499915,
-0.2241697162,
-0.1898295432,
-0.4008789957,
0.7743413448,
0.1503109634,
-0.5591881275,
0.1541392654,
-0.970154345,
-0.3296792805,
-0.2487261742,
-0.2655967176,
-0.7416898012,
0.3452557027,
-0.1532859355,
0.108992897,
-0.199094519,
-0.6096944213,
0.2984390557,
-0.4208875895,
0.5081996322,
1.002597928,
0.4114973247,
0.7416605353,
-0.2424995899,
0.5278425813,
0.2587904334,
0.4620023668,
0.1773103178,
-0.5491376519,
-0.7379538417,
-0.2191435397,
0.1727319509,
0.3155443966,
-0.6839578152,
0.626134932,
-0.0110859312,
-0.3474505544,
-0.6724997759,
0.4463893175,
0.4284952283,
1.0798680782,
0.5316537023,
-0.5569356084,
-0.2214470804,
-0.8145140409,
-0.3556330502,
-0.2661039829,
0.0405573286,
-0.0114518497,
0.4665185511,
-0.0965152085,
1.2916067839,
-0.7305983901,
-0.7047294378,
-0.3106944561,
0.4114479125,
0.142144978,
0.5634445548,
0.6848351359,
-0.6911520362,
-0.4001479745,
-0.1136079729,
-0.261197269,
-0.0042080916,
-0.087294735,
-0.2193567753,
0.1703165919,
0.6929994822,
-0.3690386415,
0.6469591856,
-0.0068901423,
-0.2945067585,
0.3281895816,
-0.3434246778,
-0.0526966788,
-0.9330435395,
-0.1220493391,
-0.0118024889,
-0.0628823787,
-0.1368951499,
0.0012316521,
-0.0637292489,
0.2816417515,
-0.4690319598,
0.396335274,
-0.1508481801,
0.2482886463,
-0.2308232188,
-0.1375001669,
0.2707387209,
0.4792505205,
-0.0746648908,
0.6091884375,
0.652494967,
-0.6237971783,
0.3086903393,
0.3997475803,
-0.5229603052,
0.7582231164,
-0.7243662477,
-0.014937669,
-0.4356810153,
-0.0838361457,
-0.8539280891,
-0.011758808,
0.3493842781,
-0.2317034751,
0.3798106313,
-0.2717938125,
-0.3031663299,
-0.2208295166,
-0.449793607,
0.1007220149,
0.6514012218,
-0.4889114499,
0.4901281595,
0.1346575022,
-0.1034033597,
-0.8388427496,
-0.9038633704,
-0.3101536334,
-0.5856247544,
-0.2374858856,
0.4186533988,
-0.0375015363,
-0.3775872886,
-0.0403637029,
-0.3835598826,
0.0264296588,
0.0594299138,
0.0332733393,
-0.1223395467,
-0.0235911328,
0.4435457885,
0.3224138916,
-0.2599277198,
0.313778609,
-0.0714055821,
0.168542698,
0.4685629904,
-0.6669024229,
-0.5286020041,
0.2495604753,
0.2835043967,
-0.3369383216,
0.5925426483,
0.5420199633,
-0.1277029812,
-0.5390256047,
-0.714617312,
-0.5152577162,
-0.5383251309,
0.4957592487,
-0.2111898959,
0.1088188291,
0.6555637121,
0.1323780864,
-0.1328080744,
0.423514545,
0.2154655159,
0.1220645159,
1.0585689545,
1.0268003941,
-0.5085892081,
0.6232842803,
-0.5056005716,
0.3123241961,
-0.5148553848,
-0.4044884443,
-0.5065658689,
-0.6076183915,
-0.2755984068,
-0.3093663156,
0.233894825,
0.3231300116,
-0.4569984078,
0.0760698542,
-0.5921627879,
0.644867599,
1.0625764132,
0.4497427642,
0.3952186108,
0.2186525911,
0.0401463509,
0.1305596828,
-0.7114111185,
-0.2743606567,
1.2747043371,
0.5776166916,
1.2218267918,
-0.1649337858,
0.7975486517,
0.5992177129,
0.1627253443,
-0.7646429539,
0.2756541967,
0.0970499218,
-0.6037316322,
-0.2012452483,
-0.4075197875,
-0.3395291567,
-0.1758734882,
0.1397763342,
-0.5750965476,
0.7695819736,
0.3879224062,
-0.6525153518,
0.4603907168,
-0.9036123753,
0.7840298414,
-0.1885977387,
-0.3819312751,
-0.3683949411,
-0.4797038138,
-0.0158244725,
0.087946631,
0.0898543075,
0.0023672236,
-0.1836679429,
1.0688509941,
-0.5583581328,
1.0388892889,
-0.5311018825,
-0.0245566256,
0.5790501237,
-0.123261787,
0.5317749381,
0.212274164,
-0.3672448099,
-0.063060008,
-0.3227981925,
-0.4269303381,
-0.5444010496,
0.6129354835,
-0.9124192595,
-0.6509045959,
-0.1395350248,
-0.2462165356,
-0.108525984,
0.2524913251,
0.5755190253,
0.4851677418,
0.1244887561,
0.0996234417,
0.8816601634,
-0.0055504548,
0.3720783591,
0.2835820019,
0.2092133164,
-0.2887595296,
0.6912426949,
0.2838820517,
0.4617260993,
0.3833855689,
0.3926647007,
-0.4186348021,
-0.8160246611,
-0.274810046,
-0.1753706038,
-1.0073328018,
-0.4352076054,
-0.2975171208,
0.2482790649,
-0.4094614089,
-0.1580562294,
-0.3878951669,
-0.0037926305,
-0.3672241271,
-0.4521850944,
0.6579319239,
0.7961098552,
0.0367872268,
0.6747034192,
-0.2767342627,
0.1758319885,
0.3951195478,
0.4691154361,
0.1093352512,
-0.6643115878,
-0.2246977985,
0.0892234743,
-0.6911868453,
-0.8953979015,
0.2091220468,
0.4134695232,
0.7720504403,
1.1580849886,
0.5037556291,
0.6081669331,
-0.1617957205,
0.4857451618,
0.2000025213,
-0.8831050396,
0.6552325487,
-0.1193480194,
-0.0930250511,
0.8128273487,
0.5364080071,
0.1745711416,
-0.2796367109,
-0.6272447109,
-0.831032455,
0.8076043129,
-0.1882645339,
0.0274488013,
-0.0098894946,
0.222775951,
0.3718392551,
0.4921474159,
-0.2820770741,
-0.1763360351,
-0.063744314,
-0.2217162102,
-0.1846502274,
-0.2177140564,
-0.1104352027,
-0.2890232801,
0.576449573,
-0.2086400539,
-0.0765289068,
0.2142864913,
-0.0191092286,
-0.322127521,
-0.0131666986,
0.0881572664,
0.7389615178,
-0.5677093267,
0.1176143587,
0.0722842589,
-0.4896560311,
-0.1471388936,
-0.010621842,
-0.3164725602,
0.0566832833,
0.2438248992,
0.7289338708,
0.2085546851,
-0.3858403265,
0.6598910689,
0.5582894087,
-0.1836522371,
0.0232510045,
0.272565037,
-0.4073545039,
0.3898413181,
0.4322632551,
0.6971177459,
0.3755960464,
-0.5639954805,
0.2787909806,
0.1873019785,
-0.6436448097,
-0.2023397535,
0.8548223376,
0.4155683815,
-0.1683080494,
0.6015270352,
-0.2871792316,
-0.5498611331,
0.8452697396,
0.1269860119,
0.9020030499,
-0.0984154195,
0.2047957331,
0.2543185055,
0.2716890275,
-0.3441399932,
0.2862967849,
-0.0659242198,
-0.6219839454,
-0.3867851496,
-0.3533025384,
-0.295189321,
-0.1075696051,
-1.0357406139,
0.4756067991,
-0.342821002,
-0.3797852397,
-0.1208774373,
0.0256461352,
-0.8894802332,
0.1573737562,
-0.000994702,
1.2330679893,
-1.0260366201,
0.8372475505,
0.4813845158,
-0.6812400222,
-0.5979290009,
-0.022502441,
-0.0541694909,
-0.6217455268,
0.6902543306,
0.0593040884,
-0.0029830285,
-0.0774537623,
-0.4995771348,
-0.665220201,
0.9967226982,
0.415743649,
-0.6179891229,
-0.2754555941,
0.0718174353,
0.3039944172,
-0.3901042044,
0.3528082073,
0.7450567484,
0.251421243,
-0.01590758,
-0.8423889875,
-0.1952033937,
0.0548625961,
-0.3465126157,
0.061084792,
-0.6246882081,
0.801861465,
-0.5447463989,
0.1862555146,
-0.3413796425,
0.4287357628,
-0.1078838184,
0.5118851066,
0.6310744882,
0.5401482582,
0.6682612896,
0.3079347908,
0.7690215707,
-0.0956736952,
0.4315204322,
1.371101141,
-0.0686900392,
0.9710518718,
0.8805620074,
-0.0952239111,
0.4251029491,
0.4882293344,
-0.1086838767,
0.9928611517,
0.1763059348,
0.1669424474,
-0.1647990048,
-0.0886464715,
-0.4694684744,
0.4393182695,
0.1676880568,
-0.7650594711,
-0.3210569918,
0.0676405951,
-0.0807054937,
0.2699058354,
-0.6438660622,
0.7879270911,
-0.1167582721,
-0.5443581939,
0.4725495577,
-0.2252629548,
0.7870433927,
-0.4682185352,
0.024812974,
-0.2309029549,
0.7056717873,
-0.1712083519,
-0.5653065443,
0.425144881,
-0.3596127629,
-0.3211424351,
-0.3252747655,
0.5347901583,
-0.3545669615,
-0.5538178086,
0.2401221544,
0.2130491734,
-0.0979826599,
-0.4067825973,
-0.5868481994,
-0.1802147627,
0.12103232,
-0.4399812222,
0.0628305525,
0.2867550254,
-0.0965659395,
0.748904407,
0.0268049706,
0.1199552566,
0.0514886864,
-0.0534930676,
0.9153145552,
-0.2997168601,
-0.5937293172,
-0.7781725526,
0.4402673841,
-0.3309006095,
-0.6143530011,
0.7072290182,
0.5119383335,
1.1521629095,
-0.3072560132,
0.7876229882,
0.106840387,
0.4974826574,
-0.2600735128,
0.8860021234,
-0.4611277878,
0.1853455007,
-0.1880312413,
-0.8870310783,
-0.0457042493,
0.4228036106,
-0.6158850789,
-0.1672120839,
0.3374801278,
0.8825007081,
-0.2862051427,
-0.2195478976,
0.0962320194,
0.1215869114,
0.3424851298,
0.4009516537,
0.3482657373,
-0.3969328403,
0.623646915,
-0.4936421216,
-0.4289190173,
-0.3237815201,
-1.0347912312,
-1.1884003878,
-0.198748678,
-0.5996643901,
-0.0291430149,
0.1356088966,
0.9884648919,
0.7981645465,
-1.0054557323,
0.1503329575,
-0.2812671363,
0.3087207973,
-0.5904996395,
-0.2013364434,
0.5369382501,
-0.4861547649,
-0.6928911209,
0.0350212194,
-0.113771379,
-0.2069243789,
-0.3542249501,
-0.0586702488,
0.1158898994,
0.1730554253,
0.3800453842,
-0.1001967788,
-0.5689948797,
-0.3527705073,
-0.1472936869,
0.3054127991,
0.0122531587,
0.7795205712,
-0.870855689,
0.6714812517,
0.7574168444,
0.355586499,
0.0272946544,
0.2077996284,
0.6545875072,
-0.7443408966,
0.247920841,
0.0690973401,
0.1954123974,
0.0555846728,
-0.3457471132,
0.2677229941,
0.1036034375,
-0.4907244444,
-0.7761893868,
0.2128412724,
-0.7858748436,
-0.0109046502,
1.0975331068,
-0.1538742185,
-0.2144861668,
-0.308665663,
-0.5562201142,
0.240406096,
-0.7697851062,
1.2179589272,
0.3577516675,
0.1928329766,
0.1041005924,
-0.346580863,
0.7439409494,
0.2742055953,
-0.3122452796,
0.1324563771,
-0.038722422,
0.3737230897,
0.192063123,
0.3150415123,
0.2663017511,
-0.0284082964,
0.0958229154,
0.0884419978,
-0.381821394,
-0.4236116111,
-0.1303225607,
0.118870385,
0.3728342652,
-0.7155838013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02813v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02813v2 | Migration Reframed? A multilingual analysis on the stance shift in Europe during the Ukrainian crisis | 2023-02-06T14:36:33 | 2023-05-19T16:44:59 | Sergej Wildemann, Claudia Niederée, Erick Elejalde | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The war in Ukraine seems to have positively changed the attitude toward the
critical societal topic of migration in Europe -- at least towards refugees
from Ukraine. We investigate whether this impression is substantiated by how
the topic is reflected in online news and social media, thus linking the
representation of the issue on the Web to its perception in society. For this
purpose, we combine and adapt leading-edge automatic text processing for a
novel multilingual stance detection approach. Starting from 5.5M Twitter posts
published by 565 European news outlets in one year, beginning September 2021,
plus replies, we perform a multilingual analysis of migration-related media
coverage and associated social media interaction for Europe and selected
European countries.
The results of our analysis show that there is actually a reframing of the
discussion illustrated by the terminology change, e.g., from "migrant" to
"refugee", often even accentuated with phrases such as "real refugees".
However, concerning a stance shift in public perception, the picture is more
diverse than expected. All analyzed cases show a noticeable temporal stance
shift around the start of the war in Ukraine. Still, there are apparent
national differences in the size and stability of this shift. | [
-0.7185143828,
-0.4271328747,
0.5089555383,
0.2713339627,
-0.4618936181,
0.2541427016,
0.0424830914,
-0.3412346542,
0.7487516403,
0.224433139,
-0.6491453648,
-0.4707473218,
-0.8714853525,
0.3852101862,
-0.5234747529,
0.9527355433,
-0.1730298996,
0.2793576121,
0.3637573123,
-0.5790061951,
0.166621685,
-0.2640499175,
-0.3857364953,
-0.0587627441,
0.6678311229,
0.2670689523,
0.6291500926,
0.3021521568,
0.5816087127,
0.2898948789,
0.0196866784,
-0.5758953691,
-0.2647671103,
-0.1717085838,
-0.5631828904,
-0.6299993992,
-0.1344858259,
-0.0639038906,
0.6506370902,
0.3855859041,
-0.2479648888,
0.4594455063,
-0.0449449234,
0.7417487502,
-0.0238210652,
-0.6327624321,
-0.7105876803,
0.1867233366,
-0.1606488526,
-0.0534330644,
-0.1504484564,
-0.1132755503,
-0.1852887273,
-0.3968349695,
0.6938950419,
-0.5024952292,
0.9977109432,
-0.1484437585,
-0.835193336,
-0.0898936763,
-0.6952148676,
1.0407984257,
-0.1802665144,
0.7239311337,
-0.2998476028,
0.2925271988,
-0.1266628653,
-0.56530267,
-0.5802714229,
0.3014922142,
0.4363688827,
0.5246334076,
-0.3848178983,
-0.5713852048,
-0.0273985509,
-0.1732683629,
-0.2995319366,
-0.1916484088,
-0.7291338444,
-0.4642653167,
0.3878707588,
-0.0160417911,
0.4476683438,
-0.204262808,
-0.654948771,
0.3445107043,
-0.6219352484,
0.1716335565,
0.8132662773,
0.3784694374,
-0.3085567355,
0.389650315,
-0.0147163086,
0.2385694087,
0.5849938989,
-0.0667808726,
0.2635433078,
-0.3640471995,
0.4648813605,
0.0631392002,
0.4176006317,
1.0855126381,
-0.0260021612,
0.1104582474,
0.2145050615,
0.3699375987,
0.578306675,
-0.8416987062,
0.2351133525,
0.2068249732,
-0.719578445,
-0.2128871232,
0.2692995071,
-1.4207509756,
-0.522708118,
-0.0618500635,
-0.4059357345,
0.0777478889,
-0.6068377495,
0.4025616646,
-0.0760573223,
0.6053324342,
0.58811903,
-0.2948671579,
-0.0351383574,
0.5445505381,
0.9120402932,
-0.199462235,
0.0158212949,
-0.3684694767,
-0.3182016611,
-0.4296523631,
1.1466934681,
-0.562723875,
-0.6753457189,
0.2454988807,
0.6044107676,
0.2836610377,
-0.0505168103,
0.6833268404,
-0.3834263384,
-0.0244231597,
-0.3306117058,
-0.1376948059,
-0.1337762028,
0.5642097592,
-0.7306519747,
0.8225326538,
-0.3096176088,
-0.8614984751,
0.7126464844,
-0.3211845756,
-0.1836131066,
-0.4546245039,
0.1030364558,
-0.0790963545,
0.1526806056,
-0.0561572276,
0.090799287,
0.113301076,
0.102879256,
-0.6238355041,
0.1604498923,
0.3184501827,
0.0259960052,
0.7663397789,
0.0594002157,
-0.2264680713,
-0.0122105349,
-0.6336148977,
-0.6162573695,
-0.1644376069,
-0.7988670468,
-0.2017998695,
0.2839241922,
-0.0930029154,
0.821072042,
0.0729797259,
-1.0855994225,
0.4945789278,
-0.5696538687,
0.2936693132,
0.360378623,
0.2378197163,
0.7318890095,
-0.0446867086,
0.6556400061,
0.6567845941,
0.4194594026,
0.2046486139,
-0.5209674239,
-0.9496719837,
0.2480886132,
-0.1717123985,
0.7180911303,
-0.5140734315,
-0.0273383167,
-0.0926165357,
-0.2117166668,
-0.7778906822,
-0.209082067,
-0.2287487388,
0.2862030566,
0.3706160486,
0.1536488533,
-0.9526310563,
-1.1111023426,
-0.5089054108,
-0.4033277333,
0.4818444848,
-0.3740925491,
0.5219403505,
-0.3413359225,
0.7743048668,
-0.1471412033,
-0.039816875,
-0.3720299602,
0.2647702396,
0.058662679,
0.0915976539,
0.6027481556,
-0.9602715969,
-0.6665044427,
0.0990426093,
-0.0090459445,
0.1270759255,
-0.3791230321,
-0.3081227839,
0.369320184,
0.683457315,
-0.5372647047,
0.3439781666,
0.5314526558,
-0.4426367283,
0.3700030446,
0.1854595989,
0.4721457064,
-1.8221375942,
-0.0122113805,
0.2897444963,
-0.0232130252,
-0.8386008143,
-0.0988960639,
-0.1088661924,
0.0988321081,
-0.6402474642,
0.691934526,
-0.142811209,
0.0496199168,
0.0534028374,
0.2700746357,
-0.1578105539,
-0.3716068566,
-0.036823906,
0.2688982189,
0.5128490329,
-0.1698232591,
0.2914417386,
0.2718003392,
-0.2417342961,
0.8384077549,
0.3238186538,
0.1152647138,
-0.456224978,
0.4134720564,
-1.4612803459,
0.2119977623,
0.48489061,
-0.5756035447,
-0.373400569,
-0.6636605263,
-0.132854566,
-0.4291900992,
-0.4006532133,
0.0829518512,
0.1533813477,
-0.1567416787,
0.8381593823,
0.2505618036,
-0.2059192955,
-0.6734519005,
-0.7401149273,
0.3968043327,
-0.7437300086,
-0.3991878331,
0.2524484694,
0.027293209,
-0.6694520116,
0.0311626997,
0.0442413576,
-0.3607679904,
-0.0035847318,
0.1497062594,
0.0476870053,
-0.1091503277,
0.2336579561,
0.0247495323,
-0.2963503599,
0.125196293,
-0.2542441785,
0.338324368,
0.0883271247,
-0.104242824,
-0.602072835,
0.6436665654,
0.9570137262,
-0.120648168,
0.6715531945,
0.9839739203,
-0.0280210339,
0.1267612725,
-0.4242194891,
-0.195792079,
-0.3037902415,
0.2700508237,
-0.0223662183,
-0.4913060665,
1.0382585526,
-0.2656952143,
0.3085506558,
0.708709538,
0.4735858142,
-0.2707482874,
0.8935809731,
0.6421911716,
-0.2622238398,
0.3352130353,
0.0521877445,
0.3214336336,
-0.4810320735,
-0.2118906677,
-0.7442811131,
-0.7518439293,
-0.720133543,
-0.2392568141,
0.0237139799,
-0.062776573,
0.2533744574,
-0.0948599353,
-0.1849513054,
0.0966547802,
-0.2059345394,
-0.117627494,
0.3400383592,
0.1996992379,
0.0289903358,
-0.3950891197,
-0.2801835239,
-0.6101307869,
0.6734492779,
0.0193468351,
0.3647670746,
0.2686376274,
0.58463943,
0.2834725678,
0.8272769451,
-0.9799458385,
0.8553844094,
0.0142535465,
-0.6041687131,
-0.1414668262,
-0.0158118028,
-1.3106894493,
0.3974365592,
-0.4484758377,
-0.6544369459,
0.4056717455,
0.0065559102,
-0.4337983727,
0.5557121038,
-0.0950735733,
0.3833858073,
0.0956789106,
-0.2077800035,
-0.8046705723,
-0.4952428937,
0.0873672143,
0.047359366,
0.6493968964,
-0.2611112893,
-0.4097410738,
0.6088052988,
-0.218120113,
0.9089924097,
-0.3745181561,
-0.2410781682,
0.0764649212,
0.1210953593,
0.186097756,
-0.1295926422,
-0.3898236156,
0.1715042889,
0.0544831455,
-0.4593521357,
-0.1275756508,
0.677010715,
-0.5354784131,
-0.4858808517,
-0.1592457443,
-0.1493115425,
-0.0497001596,
-0.0628624409,
0.4285489321,
0.2636788785,
-0.6085297465,
0.2048649043,
0.2602471113,
-0.1753851473,
0.6905261874,
0.7085527778,
-0.5443033576,
-0.3848104775,
0.4431360662,
0.5548216105,
-0.0616261214,
0.2555267811,
0.3468846679,
-0.3937992752,
-0.2830905914,
-0.7420113683,
0.2027307451,
-0.7745200992,
0.242243275,
-0.4019527435,
0.4912824631,
-0.0576516688,
-0.5126551986,
-0.4809191227,
-0.1161807477,
0.0043201204,
-0.3742236197,
0.218886748,
0.3937109113,
-0.0551511273,
0.1871351004,
-0.6812579632,
0.2802678049,
-0.1257455796,
0.2326620072,
-0.4903725088,
-0.5839907527,
-0.4003381431,
-0.1375085264,
-0.2837834656,
-1.2850502729,
0.0288858134,
-0.0106837396,
0.3696480393,
0.5013071895,
0.0551287122,
0.6466231942,
-0.4360164702,
0.8619807363,
0.2558847666,
-0.3696867824,
0.2609317899,
-0.5091109276,
0.4503237605,
0.5580356717,
0.5692489743,
-0.5505622625,
-0.4681747258,
-0.7505382895,
-0.7842755914,
0.4788498282,
-0.3179039955,
0.6116340756,
-0.0652444363,
0.2268860936,
0.2023411542,
0.0949386358,
-0.6963860393,
-0.0951796621,
-0.1753172874,
0.0046509523,
0.1558351219,
-0.120084919,
-0.1899046004,
-0.5517613292,
0.3963499963,
0.0432841256,
0.167871058,
0.2821896672,
-0.122467123,
-0.2908841074,
0.5001484752,
0.4139437973,
0.8309419751,
0.2578569055,
0.1243188754,
0.1618666798,
-0.5974798799,
0.4041321874,
-0.1162462533,
-0.2590635419,
0.6473862529,
0.2087201476,
0.2981283367,
0.4226675034,
-0.2387478054,
0.5351881385,
0.017967293,
-0.6523886919,
-0.3027127981,
-0.5473179817,
0.2041490823,
0.4106383324,
0.3556963801,
0.0451074131,
0.0532010905,
-0.832768023,
0.1445061117,
0.3439779282,
-0.2801976502,
-1.0053077936,
0.0710863918,
0.5358620286,
-0.2175362259,
0.1194122508,
0.0161991026,
-0.4521779716,
0.4226652086,
0.3035957813,
0.7670217156,
-0.8848313093,
0.8176096082,
0.6702212691,
0.2685323656,
-0.103628993,
0.724255085,
0.1697261035,
-1.1675252914,
-0.1921383888,
-0.4545068741,
0.2091125995,
0.0910924226,
-1.0216076374,
0.3274131417,
-0.4438806772,
-0.626329422,
-0.1536606997,
-0.210096404,
-0.4717391431,
-0.1111118346,
0.1964021325,
0.8119493723,
-1.0088638067,
0.4856460989,
1.0644931793,
0.1519690901,
-0.1756192297,
0.5990057588,
0.460354954,
-0.1944305897,
0.3878081739,
0.3000125289,
-0.5648711324,
0.1975126565,
-0.2713633776,
-0.6130796671,
0.3728375137,
0.6245203018,
-0.3830068707,
0.2978493869,
0.3972376287,
0.6154971123,
-0.2482042164,
-0.4636838436,
0.4580292404,
0.674767673,
-0.2712503076,
-0.5797179341,
-0.3147529066,
-0.1284164041,
-0.5503469706,
0.7031399012,
-0.8514819741,
0.618563652,
0.0902558938,
-0.7282657027,
-0.2893070877,
-0.004232673,
-0.4082015455,
0.2275537997,
0.6491966844,
0.2640394866,
0.3996286094,
-0.1758347452,
0.8199776411,
-0.6126251221,
0.2932952344,
0.4613609314,
-0.2100679576,
1.0053275824,
0.826192379,
-0.1320330799,
0.9285625815,
0.4430223405,
0.2024373561,
0.4067175686,
-0.0487535894,
-0.408115834,
-0.2998174727,
-0.02358073,
-0.0440986007,
0.3385071754,
0.4080249071,
-0.3117006421,
-0.9807761908,
0.2055645734,
0.1851964593,
0.0708226711,
-0.6473173499,
0.8005837202,
0.0385645144,
-0.5793201923,
0.0899997652,
0.111946024,
0.2282431573,
-0.4096186161,
0.0843221247,
-0.3833813369,
-0.0622876734,
-0.4584661424,
-0.9206289053,
0.6737357974,
0.1044373289,
-0.3469052017,
-0.3931840658,
0.5944795012,
-0.2523871064,
-0.789943099,
0.632014811,
0.8620614409,
0.209061861,
0.0770721585,
-1.084479928,
0.1611370891,
0.0322301276,
-0.3543554842,
0.4093807042,
0.6840670705,
-0.1689915508,
0.4507208169,
0.3907844126,
0.1673213691,
0.3452613354,
0.0629344955,
0.6021439433,
-0.680763483,
-0.6491174102,
-1.0458804369,
0.8454138637,
0.0290240217,
-0.3598465025,
0.7307857871,
0.5037788153,
0.5190265775,
0.0788969025,
0.7892490029,
-0.0356948338,
0.591372788,
-0.4426919222,
0.387750268,
-0.6313737035,
-0.3775999844,
-0.1986913234,
-0.6324394345,
-0.225684911,
0.5203542113,
-0.5534968972,
-0.5365186334,
0.6194397211,
0.8645124435,
-0.1037395,
-0.5970879793,
0.0046671424,
0.2774769664,
-0.0818503201,
-0.1003120616,
0.9034574032,
0.1544368714,
0.6337046623,
0.1646304578,
0.3826310337,
-0.4288984835,
-0.8657340407,
-0.4984305203,
-0.9748965502,
-0.2738243639,
-0.5394468307,
-0.1480971575,
0.8458220363,
0.4607201815,
-0.5840352774,
-0.2338958532,
0.1031991914,
-0.0718906894,
-0.0647633821,
-0.1705779433,
0.0048638671,
-0.0053012907,
-0.6072433591,
0.1822167635,
0.299885869,
0.1969198883,
-0.5497045517,
0.3815709054,
-0.4313067198,
0.2797944844,
0.6327047944,
0.259727627,
-1.0102764368,
-0.4212753475,
-0.1689030975,
-0.0068417857,
0.5209420323,
0.8410343528,
-0.4688637555,
0.4490892887,
0.3816436827,
0.4260310233,
0.2432245612,
0.4310828149,
0.3570952713,
-0.5116833448,
0.4733547568,
0.0385145769,
0.3960901499,
0.4886607826,
-0.1372310817,
0.0192978922,
0.5747449994,
0.0673104674,
-0.7015065551,
0.3639830053,
-0.6886570454,
-0.2542782128,
1.2062065601,
0.2472290546,
0.1605003625,
-0.5962657332,
-0.2989481986,
0.2743238807,
-0.5859308839,
1.2948477268,
1.2335855961,
-0.0345850922,
-0.1940535307,
-0.8764920235,
0.2678087652,
0.2336286753,
-0.7791235447,
-0.1676067412,
0.3955608308,
0.272588402,
0.3630793989,
0.4768702388,
-0.0073707956,
-0.0220626574,
-0.2799409628,
0.1560937911,
0.660284698,
-0.5424507856,
-0.4330535829,
0.2570645213,
-0.2638677657,
-0.0296879187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02780v1 | Coherence and Diversity through Noise: Self-Supervised Paraphrase Generation via Structure-Aware Denoising | 2023-02-06T13:50:57 | 2023-02-06T13:50:57 | Rishabh Gupta, Venktesh V., Mukesh Mohania, Vikram Goyal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose SCANING, an unsupervised framework for paraphrasing
via controlled noise injection. We focus on the novel task of paraphrasing
algebraic word problems having practical applications in online pedagogy as a
means to reduce plagiarism as well as ensure understanding on the part of the
student instead of rote memorization. This task is more complex than
paraphrasing general-domain corpora due to the difficulty in preserving
critical information for solution consistency of the paraphrased word problem,
managing the increased length of the text and ensuring diversity in the
generated paraphrase. Existing approaches fail to demonstrate adequate
performance on at least one, if not all, of these facets, necessitating the
need for a more comprehensive solution. To this end, we model the noising
search space as a composition of contextual and syntactic aspects and sample
noising functions consisting of either one or both aspects. This allows for
learning a denoising function that operates over both aspects and produces
semantically equivalent and syntactically diverse outputs through grounded
noise injection. The denoising function serves as a foundation for learning a
paraphrasing function which operates solely in the input-paraphrase space
without carrying any direct dependency on noise. We demonstrate SCANING
considerably improves performance in terms of both semantic preservation and
producing diverse paraphrases through extensive automated and manual evaluation
across 4 datasets. | [
-0.2046702504,
-0.6375014782,
0.5324559212,
0.4926620126,
-0.4856854975,
0.1972782165,
0.1577851176,
-0.3600104749,
0.360956043,
0.4375654459,
-0.319863528,
-0.5045891404,
-0.3421475887,
0.3070232272,
-0.8655648232,
0.9073237777,
-0.0744779855,
0.1724856794,
-0.4752425849,
-0.1041775271,
-0.0747178718,
-0.3920521438,
-0.3185588717,
0.1664669067,
-0.0202950686,
0.0979998484,
0.5122544765,
0.741445601,
0.485247761,
0.2584588826,
-0.4360423386,
0.0614773519,
-0.5140425563,
0.4966258109,
-0.3161770105,
-0.4291567504,
0.0279929657,
-0.2702884078,
0.6566111445,
0.8996997476,
-0.2926267982,
-0.3146125972,
0.4697779417,
0.1944786012,
-0.8030721545,
0.2466774583,
-0.7427399755,
0.071732156,
-0.0116782263,
-0.2008605003,
0.1368743926,
-0.2216052115,
-0.0428049453,
-0.9526047707,
0.4156287909,
-0.4055916369,
0.7552590966,
0.3502100706,
-0.0122878347,
-0.8115335703,
-0.5585103035,
1.0136814117,
-0.6593028903,
0.142583549,
0.4931524396,
0.0220346488,
0.0583266728,
-0.9658187628,
-0.2428897321,
0.259919256,
0.0271528065,
0.4053506255,
-0.1134621277,
0.1555721611,
-0.1360793263,
0.7318259478,
-0.2851985991,
-0.5852876306,
-0.5835502744,
-0.4066351056,
0.2453689277,
-0.0137330238,
0.3430613577,
-0.1951735169,
-0.1013448387,
-0.0438247919,
-0.2339903265,
-0.2470542938,
0.3919849396,
0.1672450453,
0.1166429296,
0.2085296661,
-0.3917284608,
0.3182477355,
0.1705143154,
-0.1972326934,
0.1865419,
-0.5642527938,
-0.0651384667,
-0.1039755791,
0.5086565018,
0.1527643502,
0.0511671565,
-0.4360594451,
-0.0254977774,
0.1228809431,
0.1201467514,
-0.7806874514,
-0.4025315344,
-0.0767582804,
-0.2951298058,
-0.3953944445,
0.0614863299,
-1.2800024748,
0.0191110913,
-0.2301444709,
0.4109910429,
-0.5187011361,
0.0284288526,
0.2674466968,
-0.4446379542,
0.1262831688,
0.3070740402,
-0.7937591672,
0.5137327909,
0.4496410191,
1.1038252115,
-0.3437546492,
-0.4038522243,
-0.1369715929,
0.4799006879,
-0.4201338589,
0.8097426891,
-0.6557350755,
-0.636045754,
-0.2017029226,
-0.2704465985,
-0.2180611044,
-0.840598166,
0.4606611729,
-0.2869324386,
0.3297540843,
-0.0607099757,
-0.5981323719,
-0.1399985552,
0.0583765507,
-0.4440971911,
1.0267324448,
0.1992529035,
-0.5530610681,
0.0692040846,
-0.5233625174,
-0.6351788044,
0.1253803074,
-0.5231207013,
-0.4523200691,
0.1908698976,
0.4179846346,
0.1132324487,
0.1866566837,
0.3450500965,
-0.1490036845,
-0.4657461345,
-0.2180436999,
-0.1907208413,
0.8400094509,
0.5214506388,
-0.5457828045,
-0.1015726998,
-0.7333634496,
-0.0100010717,
-0.0697962716,
-0.2574281693,
-0.4533613026,
-0.1238060743,
-0.20233123,
0.1088160947,
0.2524551153,
-0.5313757658,
-0.3782724142,
-0.5985924006,
0.6275538802,
0.2993985415,
0.5735399723,
0.5823999047,
-0.5645301342,
0.747875154,
0.0337205715,
0.2479098588,
-0.1810812056,
-0.3923735917,
-0.3139557838,
-0.6571440101,
-0.1498536319,
0.4685171843,
-0.6758242846,
0.1260020286,
0.0392917357,
-0.362170279,
-0.538832128,
0.6276677251,
0.2165183872,
0.4132029414,
0.8469282389,
-0.0354717113,
-0.5941260457,
-0.7108752131,
-0.4536316395,
0.0728487596,
-0.3249335587,
0.1793344468,
0.177025035,
-0.182617709,
0.6976207495,
-0.2979855537,
-0.5684500933,
-0.3339636028,
0.2851232886,
-0.0512606949,
0.3721249998,
0.4961104393,
-0.6072232723,
-0.5995898843,
-0.397670418,
-0.9936519861,
-0.3743003309,
-0.4260441065,
-0.1647497267,
-0.2387908101,
0.9081888795,
-0.5333445072,
0.2532107532,
0.4168263972,
0.1330786198,
0.2236346602,
-0.3035241365,
0.0420248322,
-1.4702502489,
-0.1438040584,
-0.428624928,
0.0134530189,
-0.2468807697,
0.4405916929,
-0.1202513799,
-0.3591747284,
-0.4397987723,
0.1059397534,
-0.8000106812,
0.1474826485,
-0.4262813032,
0.2727853954,
0.424947083,
0.2846432328,
-0.2527982891,
0.9137368798,
0.7937585711,
-0.6296002269,
-0.1375824809,
0.457158953,
-0.3368478119,
0.3896587789,
-0.5813164115,
-0.1128131524,
-0.2028976977,
0.0454487503,
-0.9107539654,
-0.0596197248,
0.0912050679,
-0.1770878583,
-0.0760210454,
-0.0494908616,
-0.2168985903,
0.0172917619,
-0.5312417746,
0.6000293493,
0.5673658848,
-0.4775829613,
0.3329033256,
0.4252031744,
-0.3666654527,
-0.2049586922,
-0.6319302917,
0.4572033584,
-0.255235523,
-0.4658965468,
0.495475471,
0.0477096513,
-0.2977747917,
-0.1703905314,
-0.3905271888,
-0.605348587,
0.2037463039,
0.1027439311,
-0.0635714233,
0.0988094583,
0.1079909578,
0.6586752534,
0.2583999038,
0.1547963768,
-0.2863996625,
0.3601517081,
0.0047777183,
-0.3141307235,
-0.4368795455,
0.8527400494,
0.5613031387,
-0.1149117127,
0.3581180573,
0.3505065739,
-0.2061285228,
-0.244904235,
-0.0966954976,
-0.2756358385,
-0.5130267143,
0.3317818046,
-0.503731668,
-0.9089307785,
0.565474689,
-0.0917792469,
0.0490007624,
0.5729030371,
0.2982618809,
-0.4695492387,
0.7780374885,
0.3723630905,
0.4691248238,
0.5433198214,
-0.2605038285,
0.0889539123,
-0.5075510144,
-0.1035994515,
-0.4411390424,
-0.2029280216,
-0.473213017,
-0.6778347492,
0.2916503847,
0.503477931,
0.3852401674,
0.1061267704,
-0.6510555744,
0.5406689644,
0.5742277503,
0.1960200965,
0.3819050491,
0.523745954,
-0.1219594851,
-0.2352595627,
-0.6580395103,
-0.202465862,
1.0638779402,
-0.2315316349,
1.042744875,
-0.0301051941,
1.1389932632,
0.0157864019,
-0.1087098047,
-0.5551992059,
0.5733618736,
-0.1560146809,
-0.578184247,
-0.4405214787,
-0.4500304461,
-1.1428704262,
0.3459377885,
0.0410045199,
-0.4080432653,
0.4934161007,
0.1032996252,
-0.2519775331,
0.3496781588,
-0.1896873713,
0.4352276027,
0.2372732162,
-0.2538508475,
-0.4507735074,
-0.5391760468,
0.0274261944,
-0.1867677569,
0.2355579436,
0.1600336283,
0.0082772104,
0.9331162572,
-0.3299088478,
0.8799571395,
-0.0230642632,
0.2211592197,
0.7536692023,
0.4713507891,
0.1968404651,
-0.1851133555,
-0.0256454442,
0.3781983554,
0.5671924949,
-0.6439873576,
-0.438048929,
0.5926209688,
-0.6501925588,
-0.6990804672,
-0.2062972039,
-0.9505831599,
-0.0586265139,
0.2681959271,
0.4060838819,
0.2543319464,
-0.1403265148,
0.5459056497,
0.6831048727,
0.1089996323,
0.5259174705,
-0.0188578274,
-0.0992425531,
-0.6839677691,
1.1771714687,
0.1795054972,
0.2360774279,
0.461925149,
0.3658260107,
-0.2752941549,
-0.7199587226,
-0.0312954746,
0.4106243551,
-0.9680829048,
-0.0250356216,
-1.10978508,
-0.1513925195,
-0.6599692106,
-0.427867353,
-0.2636772692,
-0.5054242611,
-0.3033930063,
-0.0213883445,
0.0514831729,
0.7064169049,
-0.2478416413,
0.3703099489,
-0.6496760249,
0.4337431788,
0.5167269707,
0.0628654957,
-0.2657831013,
-0.6765583158,
-0.1313077658,
0.0184769221,
-0.4732013941,
-0.9660518169,
0.5322055221,
0.4737966955,
0.7818725705,
0.2733109295,
0.2779477537,
0.7949138284,
-0.096982792,
0.7325230837,
-0.1214768067,
-1.2457506657,
0.4685126543,
-0.3670073748,
0.4913960397,
0.9770100117,
0.2172320187,
-0.2536669075,
-1.1032903194,
-0.6952178478,
-1.0172969103,
0.2209543437,
0.3347179294,
0.2895834148,
-0.4325577915,
0.3918181956,
0.1938275993,
0.468118608,
-0.6264657378,
0.0781704783,
-0.5906637907,
-0.4721817076,
0.1309564114,
-0.3190113902,
-0.2904539704,
-0.3551116288,
0.3632248938,
-0.126741901,
0.0854442716,
0.5175148845,
-0.4777006507,
-0.0303535406,
0.2777852118,
0.679674685,
0.8626192212,
-0.0782269165,
0.3932246864,
0.1844149232,
-0.5258480906,
-0.0297520161,
-0.1871545017,
-0.5179713368,
0.5105572939,
0.4128254354,
0.2521768808,
0.5263633728,
-0.4684124887,
0.4771018326,
0.1661886573,
-0.7866754532,
0.0409315415,
-0.0484906621,
0.1582970023,
0.0432902016,
0.2421932667,
0.0255021323,
0.5338853002,
-0.256983012,
0.3594745398,
0.3744668365,
-0.1164287329,
-0.2274325192,
0.7946667075,
0.0132694123,
-0.1894776672,
0.3535627127,
-0.1989195347,
-0.2922047973,
0.5299169421,
0.8614174724,
1.0917371511,
-0.2209490836,
0.226629898,
0.3444291949,
0.1685125381,
-0.1283451617,
0.4360071123,
-0.6766602993,
-0.3574320078,
-0.3003894389,
-0.7965701818,
-0.5764453411,
0.0462804362,
-0.8901994824,
-0.0910507068,
-0.5939864516,
0.4362893999,
-0.3047650754,
-0.5332558155,
0.0506523885,
0.0655299798,
-0.2380599976,
0.5165004134,
-0.8169270754,
0.5885825753,
0.7504105568,
-0.294714123,
-0.6311697364,
0.4380082786,
-0.3568351269,
-0.683263123,
0.4439302087,
0.1544079185,
-0.2456221581,
0.1823153645,
-0.3807898164,
-0.949180305,
1.0822763443,
0.5446797013,
-0.1703110039,
-0.1887810826,
0.1500340849,
0.7033747435,
-0.0228343587,
-0.1783596128,
0.0462489463,
0.2380547673,
0.3993103504,
-0.5428873301,
-0.0738518015,
-0.0685041621,
-0.1119975001,
-0.0096632214,
-0.2903998792,
1.0708206892,
0.2352996171,
-0.3894149065,
0.0764348879,
0.5278986096,
-0.052548524,
0.3191684186,
0.3317629695,
0.6041422486,
0.6653696895,
0.2938552797,
0.7270243168,
-0.5914365053,
0.3470904827,
1.27161479,
0.1668726355,
0.5152871013,
0.8514853716,
-0.2662957311,
0.2526890039,
0.1822335124,
0.1045574546,
0.7991853952,
0.0515625626,
-0.492642045,
-0.3818920851,
0.0383108743,
-0.4200488329,
0.3748863339,
0.1933546364,
-0.2997422516,
-1.0340681076,
-0.1209571138,
-0.3229516745,
0.5674122572,
-0.2612110972,
1.0148979425,
0.2497883141,
-0.5120482445,
0.5839449763,
-0.1294631213,
0.6116092205,
-0.5975657105,
-0.1418377906,
-0.4505348802,
0.068614915,
-0.2100058049,
-0.5037130713,
0.9826854467,
-0.4986954331,
-0.1336143464,
-0.5426488519,
0.5217494369,
-0.5811730623,
-0.5579791069,
0.5735445619,
0.7528122067,
0.4179201126,
-0.2777760625,
-0.6476163864,
-0.348549813,
0.0018910853,
0.1620916575,
0.5393387079,
0.3835075498,
-0.0329605751,
0.532377243,
0.5794566274,
0.1319841892,
0.3987248242,
-0.0850629583,
0.7862187028,
-0.3974691629,
-0.952282548,
-0.8829950094,
-0.1546702385,
-0.0966724083,
-0.2410574853,
1.0152169466,
0.6175690293,
0.7751281857,
-0.1006099507,
0.6824091077,
0.2292341292,
0.5093351007,
-0.0274679437,
0.5817489624,
-0.3911784887,
0.1332976669,
-0.3679203093,
-0.758022964,
-0.3638799787,
0.8643013239,
-0.1911725402,
-0.2090100795,
0.7919355631,
1.0097367764,
-0.1350848824,
-0.0061908001,
0.8073918223,
0.0196015015,
0.1918398291,
0.0915797874,
0.7704161406,
-0.4623690546,
1.1172454357,
-0.4651270211,
-0.076083608,
0.0011508024,
-0.4216042757,
-0.9263014793,
-0.3799444139,
-0.3762479722,
-0.259411484,
0.2307510674,
0.3070246279,
0.4116147757,
-0.9994949698,
-0.384068042,
-0.8961815238,
0.1949674785,
-0.4513550401,
-0.3242979646,
0.2101910859,
-0.8231771588,
-0.7606407404,
0.6656906605,
0.4510785043,
0.0216839202,
-0.0368489772,
0.2290904075,
-0.449165374,
0.3103061914,
0.3296883106,
0.2935423553,
-0.5133844018,
0.0022485831,
-0.0080518527,
-0.2410310358,
0.2806280851,
0.5416790843,
-0.4372924864,
0.4134575129,
0.5388979912,
0.9068421721,
0.572286129,
0.1348506808,
0.4759577811,
-0.6669101119,
0.1440558881,
0.3928529024,
0.1329284012,
0.1793709546,
-0.2101992369,
0.1435675323,
0.7121915221,
-0.443023771,
-0.7174689174,
0.1049397662,
-0.6342779994,
-0.6904388666,
0.9307096004,
-0.3467653096,
-0.25481686,
-0.5643873215,
-0.0980119407,
0.4766916633,
-0.2065761685,
1.1484338045,
0.6355801225,
-0.0453815646,
-0.040076036,
-0.0426759161,
0.3992480338,
0.9577378631,
-0.7683445811,
-0.1335501224,
0.4531056285,
0.470205605,
0.2592800558,
0.3694335222,
-0.2505067289,
0.2894572616,
0.3424591124,
0.1375236809,
-0.1818972975,
-0.2261705995,
-0.4780650437,
0.7001976371,
-0.1143321469,
-0.3627447486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02676v8 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02676v8 | Chain of Hindsight Aligns Language Models with Feedback | 2023-02-06T10:28:16 | 2023-10-18T07:11:12 | Hao Liu, Carmelo Sferrazza, Pieter Abbeel | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Learning from human preferences is important for language models to match
human needs and to align with human and social values. Prior works have
achieved remarkable successes by learning from human feedback to understand and
follow instructions. Nonetheless, these methods are either founded on
hand-picked model generations that are favored by human annotators, rendering
them inefficient in terms of data utilization and challenging to apply in
general, or they depend on reinforcement learning, which often suffers from
imperfect reward functions and relies on extremely challenging optimizations.
In this work, we propose a novel technique, Chain of Hindsight, that is easy to
optimize and can learn from any form of feedback, regardless of its polarity.
Our idea is inspired by how humans learn from extensive feedback presented in
the form of languages. We convert all types of feedback into sequences of
sentences, which are then used to fine-tune the model, allowing us to take
advantage of the language comprehension capabilities of language models. We
condition the model on a sequence of model generations paired with feedback. By
doing so, the model is trained to generate outputs based on feedback, while
learning to identify and correct negative attributes or errors. Applying our
method to large language models, we observed that Chain of Hindsight
significantly surpasses previous methods in aligning language models with human
preferences. We report significant improvements on summarization and dialogue
benchmarks, with our approach markedly preferred in human evaluations. | [
-0.2383040041,
-0.4092510343,
0.6335116029,
0.1820970327,
-0.1088028103,
0.1862101257,
-0.5889234543,
-0.1908062398,
0.1902353764,
0.5592370629,
-0.702919662,
-0.2724847794,
-0.3509090841,
-0.0173386559,
-0.0154336579,
1.2551841736,
0.0281055961,
0.1716939658,
-0.1275028139,
-0.2778255343,
-0.3421476185,
-0.6371122003,
-0.7013916373,
-0.497985065,
0.8889369369,
0.683645606,
0.5848423243,
0.5665916204,
0.2048989683,
0.2505384088,
0.2332034409,
0.1629703939,
-0.619781971,
-0.0932407603,
-0.4880565405,
-0.3728611171,
-0.0361509621,
-0.035725072,
0.4957961738,
0.8895494342,
-0.3801083267,
0.0986994579,
0.1681480855,
1.1316275597,
-0.6215978265,
0.0170574766,
-0.5212873816,
-0.0015822924,
0.1632352024,
-0.2028994411,
-0.5386353731,
-0.6847808957,
0.308416754,
-0.442727536,
-0.0643294379,
0.1502446681,
0.6713587046,
0.1702755094,
-0.2050145119,
-0.2301631421,
-0.9358765483,
0.8829094768,
-0.7445383668,
0.5277183652,
0.3621752262,
0.3559587002,
-0.107039921,
-0.2362174392,
-0.601762414,
-0.2474657148,
0.1466321349,
-0.0158747844,
0.0999603942,
0.0207741689,
-0.0027503229,
0.0753146037,
-0.4732289016,
0.1853067279,
-0.3818653524,
-0.1670519561,
0.7004137039,
0.0065820832,
0.0093641272,
-0.065618068,
-0.3385746479,
-0.4769858122,
-0.5871254802,
0.1169124469,
0.4994433224,
0.5543463826,
-0.0293779764,
0.3631712794,
-0.4928352535,
0.7214388251,
0.0388009697,
-0.1637765616,
0.2033128589,
-0.0312532894,
0.0927795842,
0.0223486107,
0.8237998486,
0.4558416307,
0.4215999842,
-0.2600640655,
-0.3301472366,
0.3555650115,
0.3304001391,
-0.462647289,
-0.264939338,
-0.0909067765,
-0.3236600757,
-0.6596898437,
0.1034014001,
-0.8975311518,
-0.376008153,
-0.251257807,
0.4323308468,
-0.1384421289,
-0.090306811,
0.1369843632,
0.0457674228,
-0.0562666506,
0.1978208423,
-1.0687949657,
0.4034494162,
0.6453252435,
0.6315509677,
-0.0095944079,
-0.4602768421,
-0.8024952412,
-0.0748642609,
-0.4244116545,
0.5315865874,
-0.3702962995,
-0.1332856119,
-0.0526881292,
-0.2315921634,
0.2589227259,
-0.3686873913,
0.3715500236,
-0.4927947819,
0.3262290657,
-0.1861077398,
-0.3123110533,
-0.4566366673,
0.3234748542,
-0.4217011929,
0.5030996203,
0.027338624,
-0.508980453,
0.3341613114,
-0.3402320743,
-0.516467452,
-0.2922559083,
-0.1193656549,
-0.4589062035,
0.2005607635,
0.1946500391,
0.2529634237,
-0.3349829316,
0.5170555711,
-0.483880192,
-0.0586041175,
0.3081012368,
-0.3559927344,
0.246432066,
0.0131458603,
-0.4857249558,
0.3376691341,
-0.7785686851,
-0.0854397044,
0.0369689129,
-0.3953413963,
-0.4362072349,
0.2798859477,
-0.2454537302,
0.402220875,
0.0745551586,
-0.2894904315,
0.1862501055,
-0.6962473989,
0.4404136539,
1.1284878254,
0.0693274513,
0.5212004185,
-0.1442806572,
0.4345375597,
-0.0742107257,
0.3859646022,
0.0486908965,
-0.2072733939,
-0.8912357688,
0.4924585819,
0.2779794335,
0.3985942602,
-0.6103129983,
0.4521723092,
-0.2698822916,
-0.2170566767,
-0.3317429721,
0.3236932158,
0.5512725115,
0.6542062163,
0.1817988753,
-0.7947052717,
-0.7695904374,
-0.8354852796,
-0.2168841362,
-0.6938579679,
0.1648770124,
0.2367036194,
0.2520315349,
-0.1549168974,
0.7899833918,
-0.6293674111,
0.1210932136,
-0.2175277174,
0.2742291391,
0.2865670919,
0.4414377809,
-0.0747114718,
-0.6144835949,
-0.1173095554,
0.2179727256,
-0.5653021336,
0.1738206446,
-0.0946966559,
-0.1959701478,
0.1367356479,
0.1177725419,
-0.0073918672,
0.0378305502,
0.689211309,
-0.3139303327,
0.6257275939,
-0.1194838211,
-0.1035861596,
-0.8399264812,
0.140940845,
-0.0783986151,
-0.355712831,
-0.3716841042,
-0.212915957,
-0.0817642584,
-0.0758688152,
-0.3030534387,
0.5568693876,
-0.31240502,
0.0050947517,
-0.2292002589,
0.2283674479,
-0.0135306753,
0.9182187319,
0.1581904143,
0.4412097335,
0.2223587036,
-0.5862990022,
0.2422359288,
0.2074488699,
-0.232175082,
0.2889635563,
-0.3735043406,
0.4122297168,
-0.0968014151,
-0.0522987098,
-0.8513130546,
-0.1617768258,
0.3735256493,
-0.4591169953,
0.0609151274,
-0.0102450559,
-0.0629723594,
-0.5439646244,
-0.3779134154,
0.0381651632,
0.4930357039,
-0.6302289963,
0.6114085913,
0.3468410671,
-0.1931613088,
-0.8276531696,
-0.4880655408,
-0.1509715766,
-0.0971049741,
-0.2412667722,
-0.1908717006,
-0.1348554492,
-0.2029482126,
-0.2124961615,
-0.2073166966,
0.0962793455,
0.1132316217,
0.2870341539,
0.4877226055,
-0.0469109863,
0.2593620121,
-0.0280618034,
-0.1744796634,
-0.0435385741,
-0.747102201,
0.580408752,
-0.1782509834,
-0.1601156443,
-0.2112222612,
0.1145150661,
0.4476167262,
-0.0514790788,
0.5405740142,
0.0375591256,
-0.1127811894,
-0.1857949197,
-0.7509079576,
-0.5683282614,
-0.4327307343,
0.3419581652,
-0.0807081759,
-0.8552022576,
0.3947703242,
-0.0985305533,
-0.0241622087,
0.1051345617,
0.3751402497,
0.0615891553,
1.1263172626,
0.8857831955,
-0.5731141567,
0.5042181611,
-0.063883841,
0.2740504444,
-0.5723205209,
-0.1376231611,
-0.3947814703,
-0.2305511236,
-0.3832491934,
-0.1449280232,
0.0480614267,
0.4486076832,
-0.3712293804,
0.2435590625,
-0.3029611707,
0.4417229593,
0.6042445898,
0.3432167172,
0.3697765768,
-0.0653249994,
-0.2102963626,
0.0428189896,
-0.7662233114,
-0.4938100874,
1.0899256468,
0.3493891656,
0.836342752,
-0.0397568569,
0.8794154525,
0.138327837,
0.5197511911,
-0.7423896194,
0.4240626097,
-0.1263742596,
-0.2067749798,
-0.3831689358,
-0.6086345911,
-0.6456714272,
0.0467290655,
-0.1634587348,
-0.7934265733,
0.3394414186,
0.4177928865,
-0.4381638467,
0.0985789821,
-0.7859231234,
0.9653873444,
-0.4261929691,
-0.5486312509,
-0.3382895887,
-0.9460017681,
0.3317554295,
0.0666734055,
0.3097134829,
0.0967438072,
0.2444614917,
0.8843067288,
-0.5617004633,
1.0351994038,
-0.0232177489,
-0.0348594822,
-0.006122503,
0.1902251691,
0.7642594576,
-0.0503316708,
0.0893114805,
-0.2171083838,
-0.4811957479,
-0.1807156503,
-0.8633428812,
0.6110667586,
-0.7453398108,
-0.5973683,
-0.1489769667,
-0.2984139919,
-0.4598352015,
0.1931097806,
-0.1349988729,
0.3735302687,
-0.1956262439,
-0.4083106518,
0.2644404173,
-0.2288065851,
0.3610695302,
0.5632329583,
-0.6423386931,
-0.7347151041,
1.1931371689,
-0.3328773081,
0.5600482225,
0.4281348884,
0.5230429173,
-0.4637026489,
-0.2532975376,
-0.3052771688,
0.4018732011,
-0.7475060225,
-0.1741946191,
-0.336708039,
0.1268305629,
-0.0637011603,
-0.1615088284,
-0.4493323863,
-0.5030295849,
-0.0399379358,
-0.2250527292,
0.206049785,
0.84853971,
-0.2184363008,
0.1076249704,
-0.6501048207,
-0.0268746503,
0.6567891836,
0.4547046721,
0.3300027549,
-0.0998157635,
-0.3532992005,
0.1024427786,
-0.4074734747,
-0.7836736441,
0.3167339265,
-0.0137928668,
0.1614408493,
0.6245735884,
0.0590856336,
0.7627820969,
-0.4555571675,
0.5946251154,
0.4523553252,
-1.1221948862,
0.7290579081,
-0.1562379748,
0.0633996725,
0.8889080286,
0.3431266248,
-0.8234552741,
-0.393029958,
-0.5414716601,
-0.8106606603,
0.6983857155,
-0.1813068986,
-0.1017001197,
-0.0227355026,
0.3273165822,
0.2581539452,
0.5359975696,
-0.7832626104,
0.0576739535,
-0.1383747756,
-0.1269673407,
-0.3949353993,
-0.1625691354,
-0.1439647824,
-0.1502765864,
0.7167484164,
-0.2433525771,
-0.099677287,
0.0244344603,
-0.1696890146,
-0.3411861956,
0.2995271087,
0.6677559018,
0.9762702584,
-0.1766538024,
0.1318091452,
0.0703491271,
-0.1354015768,
0.2858172655,
-0.288724333,
-0.0742157549,
-0.2049060762,
0.2816081047,
1.0815470219,
0.2809258401,
-0.8139923215,
0.3998633027,
0.0489194728,
-0.0311471783,
-0.0509739146,
-0.1796791106,
-0.1387207061,
0.3365541101,
0.1314107329,
0.4181967676,
0.1439266652,
-0.7458119392,
0.3879879713,
0.1336678416,
-0.7037145495,
-0.4609480202,
0.5568111539,
0.296676904,
-0.3920239508,
0.6440246105,
-0.100776583,
-0.8544601798,
0.1033834219,
0.3669778705,
0.9916280508,
-0.3118480146,
0.5383053422,
0.3424425721,
0.0880939141,
-0.4839218259,
0.0627726391,
-0.2101653218,
-0.9726465344,
-0.6808563471,
-0.7285083532,
-0.54285568,
-0.1571004391,
-0.7309708595,
0.1093153805,
-0.599281311,
0.021863278,
-0.2588966787,
-0.1796138883,
-0.3566860557,
0.2469920218,
0.0868622884,
0.5199079514,
-1.0580986738,
0.7864840031,
0.3473819494,
-0.7213458419,
-1.1354848146,
0.1386573166,
-0.0860889032,
-0.8172114491,
0.8932003379,
0.2363411337,
-0.2779744267,
0.0386024341,
-0.2555975318,
-0.4628685713,
0.4816117883,
0.3171221614,
-0.9837130308,
-0.1075111851,
-0.2850897014,
0.5329207182,
-0.3127217889,
0.2145648599,
0.5141915679,
0.3643267453,
0.0065632393,
-0.7194635868,
0.1679585874,
-0.1279677898,
0.2798325121,
0.3920590281,
-0.5206441879,
0.5060857534,
-0.4867126644,
-0.2404781133,
-0.1017041355,
0.6655656695,
0.2189922482,
0.0141287968,
0.7503299117,
0.5809354186,
0.6318024397,
0.0624276176,
1.0518449545,
-0.0222415738,
0.3975556493,
1.2310649157,
-0.2679153979,
1.1261099577,
0.7172323465,
-0.1777897179,
0.8518771529,
0.506393671,
0.330733031,
0.9271202683,
0.264457792,
-0.0932692438,
-0.2724608779,
-0.0485695153,
-0.0238030404,
0.2040652782,
-0.0295126028,
-0.2897403538,
0.0464252494,
0.2287953794,
-0.1249692515,
0.3810730875,
-0.1755827367,
1.1000856161,
0.0040680408,
-0.9700499177,
0.5945822001,
-0.2175505757,
0.6428447366,
-0.5686556101,
-0.0570564382,
-0.1064743474,
0.4488288462,
-0.0314462595,
-0.5594441891,
0.2303839326,
-0.275739789,
-0.3128127754,
-0.0940770805,
0.2061679363,
-0.5553005338,
-0.3806586266,
0.5329535007,
0.1322190613,
-0.1638322473,
-0.0227584783,
-0.4608479738,
0.1622052044,
0.1965101659,
0.0374551751,
0.0882190242,
0.0630748048,
-0.1005325168,
0.7494061589,
0.6718003154,
0.3469609022,
-0.2384572625,
0.2451022416,
0.9406026602,
-0.7978134155,
-0.75122118,
-1.0585939884,
0.5177531838,
-0.1255155355,
-0.2887510061,
0.5361223221,
0.4855121672,
1.108776927,
-0.1199508309,
0.8198488355,
0.2488492131,
0.5583628416,
-0.6051931977,
0.3865943849,
-0.4189803302,
0.3112661541,
-0.4593121111,
-0.8667030931,
-0.290060997,
0.6317200065,
-0.6241066456,
-0.1813081652,
0.7053616047,
0.7780581117,
0.2523356676,
0.0134120388,
0.1508362442,
0.161070779,
0.1435975134,
0.638787806,
0.9189665318,
-0.2897394896,
0.4408887327,
-0.39217785,
-0.2824278772,
-0.253241092,
-0.7096751928,
-0.8759673834,
-0.6389898658,
-0.0906165168,
-0.3873552382,
0.5592314005,
1.0217735767,
0.6662282348,
-0.9210626483,
-0.6061355472,
-0.4093940556,
0.4720386565,
-0.4493199587,
-0.2338932008,
0.0589899421,
-0.4368387163,
-0.3623658121,
0.2918561101,
0.5577700734,
-0.1325372756,
-0.4148830771,
-0.5938578248,
-0.3026665151,
-0.1173967347,
0.5044111013,
0.5769079924,
-0.8547319174,
-0.5470408201,
-0.2437993139,
0.23505193,
0.1167682782,
0.9845728278,
-0.8926137686,
0.6939563751,
0.5001219511,
0.6455435157,
0.5153340101,
-0.0004966291,
1.18230474,
-0.7689022422,
0.2557760775,
0.245976299,
0.099386245,
0.5166037679,
-0.2351527363,
0.3707058132,
0.1413319111,
-0.4834065139,
-0.836301744,
0.34971717,
-0.6781849861,
-0.1351481527,
0.7701506615,
-0.0268815942,
-0.3499318361,
0.0826334506,
-0.1711286902,
0.2291560024,
-0.5496339798,
0.9314693809,
0.6264853477,
0.1422258765,
-0.3779001832,
-0.0155308926,
0.3264844418,
0.5984879732,
-0.6421951652,
0.1587783694,
0.3401743472,
0.0762829483,
0.2854992449,
0.4860093892,
0.1066764295,
0.1805762351,
-0.2644386292,
0.2564096451,
0.2368333787,
-0.4885784686,
-0.5422057509,
-0.1043898761,
0.4431069195,
-0.2174366266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02655v1 | Evolution of grammatical forms: some quantitative approaches | 2023-02-06T09:50:48 | 2023-02-06T09:50:48 | Jean-Marc Luck, Anita Mehta | cond-mat.stat-mech | cond-mat.stat-mech, cs.CL | Grammatical forms are said to evolve via two main mechanisms. These are,
respectively, the `descent' mechanism, where current forms can be seen to have
descended (albeit with occasional modifications) from their roots in ancient
languages, and the `contact' mechanism, where evolution in a given language
occurs via borrowing from other languages with which it is in contact. We use
ideas and concepts from statistical physics to formulate a series of static and
dynamical models which illustrate these issues in general terms. The static
models emphasise the relative numbers of rules and exceptions, while the
dynamical models focus on the emergence of exceptional forms. These unlikely
survivors among various competing grammatical forms are winners against the
odds. Our analysis suggests that they emerge when the influence of neighbouring
languages exceeds the generic tendency towards regularisation within individual
languages. | [
-0.1321979165,
-0.9824509025,
0.9939819574,
-0.0357554853,
-0.0337552987,
0.0552044474,
-0.2397379726,
-0.3020443022,
0.3384759426,
0.0658225045,
-0.6649109125,
0.1910523325,
-0.4452573657,
0.2439658791,
-0.3533680439,
0.8779386282,
0.060328953,
0.1778555214,
-0.4777113199,
-0.073682487,
-0.2393934429,
-0.6222183704,
-0.326512754,
-0.2200120687,
0.4877395332,
0.2359972745,
0.8353723884,
0.5341872573,
0.4895883203,
0.3944808245,
-0.5764334798,
-0.0384948514,
-0.3046734035,
0.4817293286,
-0.0275578424,
-1.1049796343,
0.2509092093,
-0.0360543318,
0.8409093022,
0.9479839206,
-0.3716256022,
-0.2422885597,
-0.210661903,
0.749612391,
-0.3468495905,
-0.026230352,
-0.4108943939,
-0.0448599048,
-0.5102491379,
-0.2006219178,
0.0000709916,
-0.707662642,
0.1957766414,
-0.3634486198,
0.1739297807,
-0.3043183386,
0.6835140586,
-0.3087244332,
-0.176562801,
-0.4951494932,
-0.67868191,
0.4591585696,
-0.5255890489,
0.4784446061,
0.110090822,
0.2595918775,
-0.5445257425,
-0.829559505,
-0.3582648635,
-1.0081751347,
0.051358562,
0.2047693282,
-0.2247827798,
-0.2132923901,
0.1888411194,
0.4285110533,
-0.577630043,
0.1927329004,
-0.644015193,
0.4950793386,
0.3426643908,
-0.0595225804,
0.7280532718,
-0.1449405104,
-0.1111052111,
0.0959435478,
-0.8685157895,
0.1321493834,
0.7168776989,
0.5275150537,
-0.5093674064,
0.3622854352,
-0.0002923514,
0.3747363985,
0.3172570765,
0.0525036976,
-0.0482379161,
-0.3120853603,
0.1286530644,
-0.1016173437,
0.6781225204,
-0.162843734,
0.3437350988,
-0.2150640041,
-0.0269860886,
0.1367183328,
0.0201083086,
-0.133110866,
-0.2835915685,
-0.4154277742,
-0.3146266937,
-0.7643357515,
0.3127271533,
-0.7038651705,
-0.3278411925,
-0.2388689518,
0.1828250885,
-0.415689379,
-0.5535719991,
0.0982381552,
-0.1597330868,
0.0805242136,
0.2170246691,
-1.2185708284,
0.8265314698,
0.7804236412,
0.711794734,
-0.0389980339,
-0.2502723932,
-0.2444376647,
-0.3423247635,
-0.4511524141,
1.1352410316,
-0.7462652326,
-0.2052351534,
0.3046149909,
0.0596333779,
-0.1450537145,
-0.5213794112,
0.2371837348,
-0.4975504279,
0.7297061682,
-0.1692215502,
-0.3456824124,
-0.6978764534,
-0.3576826751,
-0.7058590651,
1.138019681,
0.0166037269,
-0.3048318326,
0.5434717536,
-0.6864325404,
-0.4592446983,
0.3902553618,
-0.2994811833,
-0.3233739138,
0.9141551256,
-0.4339045584,
0.1225543693,
-0.6327781081,
0.1096776351,
-0.5839999318,
0.3220652044,
0.408275485,
-0.3985837996,
0.905962646,
0.135959208,
-0.4909888506,
-0.237154603,
-0.8613155484,
-0.2379374802,
0.1515614092,
-0.2389036864,
-0.3394060433,
0.4213266969,
-0.0439942107,
0.2841865718,
-0.1672899127,
-0.1741710901,
0.4195257723,
-0.3717824817,
0.548871398,
0.3202288449,
0.4559854865,
0.5146482587,
-0.5550231338,
0.6933118105,
-0.2010279447,
0.0624217987,
0.1360932887,
-0.6212226748,
-0.6237931252,
0.1243046299,
0.2324206531,
0.4376803339,
-0.0230907518,
0.119783327,
-0.2281411141,
-0.4218227565,
-0.0144617548,
0.3138855696,
0.1794703454,
-0.3729542196,
-0.2947286963,
-0.2777885199,
-0.4457674026,
-0.6548192501,
-0.1051220372,
-0.5053002834,
0.3801878691,
0.1146195158,
0.3174685836,
0.1322924346,
0.8825367689,
-0.1859764606,
0.5183075666,
-0.3898875713,
-0.0116606075,
0.18465437,
0.5938259959,
1.2572635412,
-0.9270473123,
-0.2548408806,
0.2031193376,
-0.8551157713,
-0.3756131232,
-0.2661253214,
-0.1849097311,
0.1458127648,
0.675737977,
-0.651581347,
0.126995042,
0.3548314869,
-0.3791021109,
0.477365762,
-0.0062596486,
-0.0189220533,
-1.0527477264,
-0.2116443962,
0.0031575118,
-0.2295608073,
-0.8481845856,
0.2110377997,
-0.2525090277,
-0.0758906454,
-0.4808413982,
0.2780004144,
-0.7146930695,
0.0587462485,
0.067535989,
0.1649198979,
-0.316444844,
-0.0542232729,
-0.0027753077,
0.1195513532,
0.6579068303,
-0.7063435316,
0.511906743,
-0.096906364,
-0.0369693227,
0.2272921503,
-0.3749998212,
-0.1518280804,
-0.4802540541,
-0.3139980435,
-1.2326037884,
-0.2365185469,
0.1288815737,
-0.3874239624,
0.4566291571,
-0.26125893,
-0.3222334087,
-0.2800482512,
-0.238872841,
0.1832960099,
0.5797166228,
-0.2252536118,
0.4368324578,
0.0813879967,
-0.6654517651,
0.1040453464,
-0.3674420416,
0.0543752424,
-0.5327432752,
-0.6149264574,
-0.1682037264,
-0.1938126534,
-0.9605626464,
0.1126295924,
0.0371754467,
0.0408588089,
0.4889668226,
0.1479371339,
0.1248859838,
-0.6092233062,
0.1865798235,
0.2984049022,
0.3463496566,
0.0673214421,
-0.325014919,
0.5873618126,
0.2046165317,
-0.0265415087,
-0.5693290234,
0.3225854933,
1.1293953657,
-0.020510776,
0.6691215634,
-0.298250109,
-0.4086459875,
0.0593609065,
-0.7421686053,
-0.1729415506,
-0.424590528,
0.3459032476,
-0.6738417149,
-0.2733730078,
0.5481200814,
0.0319070853,
-0.0827150568,
0.6681084633,
0.6732445955,
0.0018371099,
0.6024465561,
0.8296388984,
0.2331503779,
0.9342748523,
-0.0065701636,
-0.2359190434,
-0.3180757165,
-0.3141121268,
-0.4969584942,
0.1397273839,
-0.888484478,
-0.0153374933,
0.1100621819,
0.7683642507,
0.0632606447,
0.4495177269,
0.1064454317,
0.4277481139,
0.5373369455,
0.0226575322,
0.0021178129,
0.2423004955,
-0.4024989307,
-0.075499028,
-0.7394848466,
-0.4666430354,
0.7590740919,
0.2942444384,
0.7357835174,
0.7053452134,
0.7055194974,
0.2539449632,
0.1700820774,
-0.522279501,
0.3116202056,
-0.2265713364,
-0.289429754,
-0.014499275,
-0.2607148588,
-0.8459933996,
0.0771068111,
-0.4882394373,
-0.6506918669,
0.564475596,
-0.2254472971,
-0.2555330396,
0.0884965062,
-0.4874204099,
0.5975289345,
-0.2912976146,
-0.3477790356,
-0.0546829216,
-0.548487246,
0.3854979575,
-0.200101167,
0.2215654701,
0.0110286819,
0.1548383087,
0.7580749989,
-0.4777843058,
0.8644075394,
-0.0003732687,
-0.2685577273,
0.5747283697,
0.3875707388,
0.3567189872,
0.0683407187,
-0.0434405729,
-0.4506550431,
-0.0153723741,
-0.4171825647,
-0.8717840314,
0.3362853527,
-0.7375146747,
-0.4135018587,
-0.4084931314,
-0.1648776531,
0.0246936753,
0.1289386898,
0.4865907431,
0.6385781169,
-0.2712461352,
0.1993270367,
0.0949937254,
-0.017706329,
0.6091513634,
0.6625319123,
-0.189576,
-0.4868401289,
0.3447165191,
0.2484826893,
0.7252824306,
0.1747755259,
0.6697678566,
-0.2806703448,
-0.4773817956,
-0.1802263707,
0.5443854928,
-0.4749651551,
0.2002982646,
-0.371427685,
0.0258658063,
-0.7227013111,
-0.1763066351,
-0.1597112864,
-0.736867249,
-0.1973969489,
-0.1888785511,
0.6777845025,
1.2626183033,
-0.5862063766,
0.2307619303,
-0.629983902,
-0.1218332648,
0.3545752168,
0.0047442559,
-0.1626092941,
-0.7035714984,
0.0581938662,
-0.026753258,
-0.2081160992,
-1.1318258047,
0.1908377558,
0.4035628438,
0.8092253208,
0.6675677299,
-0.3841339052,
0.5196161866,
-0.7931505442,
0.799942255,
0.3180325627,
-0.5915771723,
0.504884243,
-0.6441812515,
-0.1350551248,
0.5393835306,
0.6271907091,
-0.7375673652,
-0.3603970706,
-0.7478456497,
-0.4814204276,
0.4431233108,
0.1347821206,
0.2403408736,
-0.082464017,
0.8855692744,
0.3255957067,
-0.0345882438,
-0.8752378821,
-0.0926162675,
0.1517664194,
-0.2428933233,
0.0263595302,
-0.2935224473,
0.1011412516,
-0.0767388344,
0.2973605692,
0.2969013751,
0.1856868118,
-0.0995087624,
-0.2439858466,
-0.2239554971,
0.0500357561,
1.1598744392,
0.7852609158,
0.301545471,
0.0233892091,
-0.041471865,
-0.6558694839,
0.3181139827,
0.0938056782,
-0.2109646201,
0.1072906703,
0.5361064672,
0.8664038777,
0.4103395343,
-0.265710026,
0.2303526849,
0.2463916242,
-0.2340496182,
-0.3243944347,
0.067187272,
-0.1094966903,
0.3350011408,
0.1957995296,
0.0933849066,
-0.0196924563,
-1.1394211054,
0.262417078,
0.0936515406,
-0.2488862574,
-0.9397198558,
0.5836009383,
-0.1198347211,
-0.6478921771,
0.1496025622,
-0.2595653832,
-0.6281980276,
0.5487682223,
0.8522800803,
0.8854429126,
-0.3468045592,
0.2301910073,
-0.0288382694,
-0.0468664505,
-0.4547973573,
0.4154424369,
0.0460681655,
-0.3338208199,
-0.1982165128,
-0.5718260407,
-0.288824439,
0.0985495821,
-0.5384691954,
0.5445869565,
-0.1650688499,
0.201144278,
0.3684590757,
-0.231422022,
-0.2172168493,
-0.0801357031,
0.5620786548,
0.5090301037,
-1.1679339409,
0.2168371677,
1.0700799227,
-0.597699821,
-0.4695263803,
0.0019438392,
0.1786773354,
-0.5423780084,
1.0917271376,
-0.1996084005,
0.0151680056,
-0.1356514394,
-0.3809110522,
-1.3390597105,
0.2916489542,
0.3050668538,
-0.4595521688,
-0.2363790721,
-0.177173242,
0.4757915735,
-0.11051891,
0.063580513,
0.3601472676,
0.2721247673,
-0.0961000621,
-0.7448475957,
0.0211292431,
-0.4226725698,
0.0723212585,
0.4469550848,
-0.514361918,
0.9002981186,
-0.1457352936,
-0.5099450946,
0.6545998454,
0.4092127979,
-0.0902647078,
-0.2600096166,
0.1609840095,
0.5466134548,
0.4992644489,
-0.0062395022,
0.9279340506,
-0.5464050174,
0.3797050118,
0.3718875051,
-0.2333776504,
0.808442235,
-0.0021899333,
-0.6277700663,
0.9543184638,
0.5466260314,
-0.0036894621,
0.4298605323,
0.5157796144,
-0.522987783,
0.0325372033,
0.2797632515,
-0.1951274276,
0.7442099452,
0.2585328221,
-0.3145028651,
-0.2795333564,
0.18701832,
0.2808868289,
0.2998894155,
-0.1569579542,
0.9816286564,
-0.0312330294,
-0.6921585202,
0.4905365109,
-0.2707151473,
0.4176519215,
-0.5816600323,
0.02877957,
-0.2931978405,
-0.0789892152,
-0.1537631899,
-0.4430722296,
-0.0181758702,
-0.0814895332,
-0.2563952506,
0.1711866409,
0.4353729486,
-0.3992776275,
-0.5642328262,
0.0444511361,
0.6516623497,
0.4132326245,
0.5576957464,
-0.3118387163,
-0.0651143864,
-0.3475543857,
-0.1329935193,
0.1565679312,
0.6562651396,
-0.2427059412,
0.3141803741,
0.613199532,
0.474493593,
0.5985247493,
0.0937746316,
0.5460938215,
-0.7073020935,
-0.6415908337,
-1.159455657,
0.3570314944,
0.0517566688,
-0.4625371695,
0.4283542335,
0.4872184098,
0.2739575803,
-0.0741749033,
0.549580276,
-0.087234363,
0.3181746602,
-0.7272269726,
0.7040133476,
-0.4823168516,
-0.2651349902,
-0.461622715,
-1.0667151213,
-0.4860895574,
0.6643328667,
-0.3266793787,
0.1209588945,
0.9750689864,
0.3600090742,
0.0516471602,
-0.1178026795,
0.1831756979,
0.3302219808,
0.2068975866,
0.1628911048,
1.0788347721,
-0.1669198573,
0.2274525911,
0.0589422993,
-0.4170255959,
-0.1300609708,
-0.5721003413,
-0.4473703504,
-0.6273733377,
-0.4435676336,
-0.2274834514,
0.3137392402,
0.8728212118,
0.6711878777,
-0.6681349277,
-0.282166481,
-0.6925823092,
-0.2569516599,
-0.1153901964,
-0.2518851161,
0.1331680417,
-0.7795815468,
-0.7353056669,
0.4205835462,
0.2475204319,
0.6013354659,
-0.0348230414,
0.3137784004,
-0.2236216068,
0.0989108607,
0.6281277537,
0.7046233416,
-0.6203613877,
-0.1111840159,
0.0143794622,
0.0747775286,
0.066827029,
0.8706032634,
-0.6404774785,
0.0705821142,
0.7444865108,
0.3626773655,
0.0892818347,
-0.0979249775,
0.8663606644,
-0.2643069923,
0.2549993992,
0.0243280083,
0.3494948745,
0.1049474627,
-0.1567005962,
0.3742295206,
0.9374156594,
-0.3138481677,
-1.0883095264,
0.4626763463,
-0.7315050364,
-0.2669917643,
1.1190582514,
0.1819755882,
-0.1038536504,
0.0408106074,
0.0971070901,
-0.0520947203,
-0.1108288765,
0.7107860446,
0.8104690909,
-0.4345383644,
-0.3638665676,
-0.6279529929,
0.6297545433,
0.4248604178,
-0.8667887449,
-0.0164432768,
0.3937676847,
0.4461117089,
0.5001624823,
0.1177485287,
-0.2461505085,
0.5945101976,
0.1448530406,
-0.1632178873,
0.4262135923,
-0.2597562671,
-0.6237055659,
0.1597823203,
0.3328111768,
-0.1017355323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02568v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02568v4 | Less is More: Understanding Word-level Textual Adversarial Attack via n-gram Frequency Descend | 2023-02-06T05:11:27 | 2024-04-15T08:11:18 | Ning Lu, Shengcai Liu, Zhirui Zhang, Qi Wang, Haifeng Liu, Ke Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Word-level textual adversarial attacks have demonstrated notable efficacy in
misleading Natural Language Processing (NLP) models. Despite their success, the
underlying reasons for their effectiveness and the fundamental characteristics
of adversarial examples (AEs) remain obscure. This work aims to interpret
word-level attacks by examining their $n$-gram frequency patterns. Our
comprehensive experiments reveal that in approximately 90\% of cases,
word-level attacks lead to the generation of examples where the frequency of
$n$-grams decreases, a tendency we term as the $n$-gram Frequency Descend
($n$-FD). This finding suggests a straightforward strategy to enhance model
robustness: training models using examples with $n$-FD. To examine the
feasibility of this strategy, we employed the $n$-gram frequency information,
as an alternative to conventional loss gradients, to generate perturbed
examples in adversarial training. The experiment results indicate that the
frequency-based approach performs comparably with the gradient-based approach
in improving model robustness. Our research offers a novel and more intuitive
perspective for understanding word-level textual adversarial attacks and
proposes a new direction to improve model robustness. | [
-0.757589519,
-1.1224812269,
0.1872735023,
-0.2361045778,
-0.0740490109,
-0.1412473321,
-0.0668002442,
-0.3056453168,
-0.0454304777,
0.437137872,
-0.7384732962,
-0.5730041862,
-1.0048296452,
0.1263418347,
-0.8792800307,
1.2711664438,
0.3579147458,
0.1123391762,
0.1682777107,
-0.0591802113,
-0.2624261975,
-0.6241806746,
-0.9398730993,
-0.2971767187,
0.4610793591,
-0.0664407611,
0.749889493,
0.5020127296,
0.6176587343,
0.2205890268,
-0.4224452972,
-0.1551775634,
-0.7639895082,
-0.0224278681,
0.4435486197,
-0.7923828363,
-0.2281263173,
0.1228575408,
0.39255476,
0.6548568606,
-0.0651454031,
-0.1721275449,
0.153306216,
0.7524930835,
-0.6946622133,
-0.0158161968,
-0.94834584,
0.1874190718,
-0.3088690341,
-0.2114842385,
-0.675663352,
-0.0152096013,
0.0357319824,
-0.8438954949,
0.5291395187,
-0.230688259,
1.0487872362,
0.2186684906,
-0.4286876619,
-0.316257745,
-0.4809435606,
0.582062602,
-0.6178604364,
0.2582814693,
0.5317943096,
0.311273396,
-0.3603774309,
-0.5520450473,
-0.4212339818,
-0.3899532557,
0.1373192072,
0.0604625158,
-0.4539874792,
0.021637138,
0.4835795164,
0.3997976482,
-0.4336572587,
-0.249388352,
0.0849921852,
-0.0675732642,
0.3637364209,
-0.015856158,
0.5117071271,
-0.0404409952,
-0.5555477142,
-0.3658993244,
-0.6904414892,
-0.0545707159,
0.4349691868,
0.276166141,
-0.2635287046,
0.268456012,
0.0353011079,
0.7418103218,
0.2291908562,
-0.1067488194,
-0.0351950489,
-0.2629611492,
-0.2373808473,
-0.0139094554,
0.4504204392,
0.2641233504,
0.3430021107,
-0.2709828019,
-0.2687613368,
0.349715203,
0.5974803567,
-0.7668557167,
-0.2754975557,
-0.2649984956,
-0.4676858485,
-0.7000437379,
-0.0404395834,
-0.8098410964,
-0.7266843319,
0.0359372497,
0.5579901338,
-0.8787106872,
0.0142230745,
0.2995263636,
-0.5322318673,
0.1721903086,
0.1587199122,
-0.972394824,
0.4165203869,
0.8836158514,
0.8097529411,
0.1959344149,
-0.0833554268,
-0.602411449,
-0.1014662012,
-0.3974973857,
0.4713707566,
-0.5653223991,
-0.5382440686,
-0.0182379596,
-0.2323264778,
-0.2354122549,
-0.2536463439,
0.7201920152,
-0.8320086598,
0.3307309449,
-0.1606902778,
-0.4359344542,
-0.4061074555,
0.4449263215,
-0.8441874385,
0.9257115722,
-0.0237432923,
-1.2490016222,
0.3376010954,
-0.5888817906,
-0.4127831161,
-0.1654414237,
-0.0261842385,
-0.2062690556,
0.4279687107,
0.3363215923,
0.1808740646,
-0.2472853363,
-0.2734499574,
-0.5250746608,
-0.4079542756,
0.3005216718,
-1.1157630682,
0.9120203257,
0.2339596599,
-0.2802444994,
-0.2687782943,
-0.9714714289,
-0.2815009952,
0.3841415644,
-0.3557036519,
-0.642850101,
-0.0995428413,
0.0467181094,
-0.1664934456,
0.0165112354,
-0.5165507197,
0.1248699501,
-0.8803831935,
0.2286085486,
0.4589629471,
0.0682013631,
0.4224665463,
-0.5657730699,
0.6131102443,
-0.618755579,
0.282030642,
-0.0014623895,
-0.4055875838,
-0.5000290275,
-0.1211734116,
0.4098705947,
0.4159345627,
-1.0651348829,
0.0625607595,
-0.3316580057,
-0.4525586367,
-0.3299696147,
0.1049090475,
0.4749509096,
0.714417696,
0.4292757511,
-0.0601580776,
-0.2105691135,
-0.5031510592,
-0.535929203,
-0.08146815,
-0.1729593873,
-0.0891159326,
0.4523666799,
0.0080653448,
0.57538414,
-0.576880157,
-0.1794480234,
-0.3489107192,
0.4514577091,
0.0253698714,
0.1361324787,
0.9058315158,
-0.9599699378,
-0.3720279038,
-0.2047173381,
-0.4469252229,
-0.0322350301,
-0.0720028207,
-0.1426849961,
0.1331746429,
0.6384099126,
-0.2885740697,
0.5099712014,
0.4999937713,
-0.3514237702,
0.1987217218,
-0.1179241538,
-0.0378400795,
-0.8286614418,
-0.1829917878,
0.0970181301,
0.049734477,
-0.9252436161,
0.4245262742,
-0.0527150407,
0.0074296445,
-0.2627111077,
0.1974342316,
-0.2810733318,
-0.0345981605,
-0.4785535336,
0.128337577,
0.4551882446,
0.3782980442,
-0.3108793795,
0.5774382353,
0.4514172375,
-0.4130210876,
0.1647991538,
0.1228042915,
-0.1914151162,
0.6012054086,
-0.5088083744,
-0.0933157802,
-0.2629312277,
0.2017608881,
-0.8685432076,
0.0129888132,
0.107120946,
-0.770961225,
0.783393085,
-0.4266720712,
-0.2166168988,
0.0356338471,
-0.7521440387,
0.1512097269,
0.3578181267,
-0.5683770776,
0.3359385729,
0.2802783847,
0.0179375224,
-0.7566256523,
-0.8886531591,
0.3175227344,
-0.3215734065,
-0.5845932961,
0.3294619918,
0.0886974335,
-0.2653207779,
-0.1967546791,
-0.2891767621,
-0.0855068266,
0.84487468,
0.117973946,
0.1303488463,
-0.3473764956,
-0.0603360236,
-0.3382481933,
-0.1295219064,
0.2924051583,
-0.1884058565,
0.9223954678,
0.054448057,
-0.4130847454,
-0.5557948947,
0.4229431748,
0.4070855677,
-0.1908741593,
0.8741466999,
0.8200506568,
-0.5646924376,
-0.328474611,
-0.0282478053,
-0.1973302215,
-0.46568349,
0.4172978401,
-0.287737608,
-0.4239177704,
0.2303498238,
0.2960010469,
0.05090262,
0.6438720822,
0.108885251,
0.0054196399,
1.1435264349,
0.540664196,
-0.2007030845,
0.7588456273,
-0.4298895001,
-0.1264635473,
-0.7815650702,
-0.1298861504,
-0.6841255426,
-0.1187520027,
-0.440268755,
-0.2088030279,
0.2887796462,
0.2258652747,
-0.268199414,
0.2122648954,
-0.2445082963,
0.3178783953,
0.3627449572,
0.0763122439,
0.0047947229,
0.3738487661,
0.0685742199,
0.0216430742,
-0.8049962521,
-0.3595290482,
1.0526629686,
0.3640822768,
0.8054490089,
0.2284930497,
0.6548469663,
0.3933190703,
0.3708971739,
-0.7545266151,
0.2388514131,
-0.7774077654,
-0.5569027066,
-0.2463099808,
-0.4408895969,
-1.1089457273,
0.1929254234,
-0.4545744658,
-0.5041552186,
0.1425274909,
0.0051669953,
-0.3869713247,
0.4294122756,
-0.5611435175,
0.7305127978,
-0.1564250588,
0.1690348387,
0.0584960207,
-0.3744140565,
0.3669961095,
-0.1299353838,
0.5031209588,
0.1369956732,
-0.0400136374,
0.6717090607,
-0.457403332,
0.7495692968,
-0.2680746019,
-0.4806702435,
0.0086596329,
0.1036438718,
0.6608824134,
0.0033856048,
-0.2313416749,
0.1365748644,
-0.3364511132,
-0.3718208075,
-0.7169671059,
0.6978974342,
-0.5687569976,
-0.4689776003,
-0.1720013916,
-0.494653374,
-0.2114851475,
0.0887563005,
0.5191121697,
0.9829974174,
-0.1219802871,
0.3907818198,
0.8663820624,
-0.3437287807,
0.4429928958,
0.3393047452,
0.0539968535,
-0.4398617446,
1.0086205006,
0.2050138563,
0.5239157081,
0.7265473604,
0.1314939559,
-0.3741154969,
-0.9365347028,
-0.502925992,
-0.291941762,
-0.7412016392,
-0.0726295114,
-0.5438498259,
0.0606712028,
-0.4804023802,
-0.1703292578,
0.0153015908,
-0.3535114527,
-0.3394172192,
-0.0621486418,
0.5499866605,
0.7313328981,
0.3509606421,
0.6885582209,
-0.7339225411,
0.654979527,
0.1437861919,
0.1647091508,
0.0387869067,
-0.8681249619,
-0.0998261273,
0.2511840463,
-0.1883196235,
-1.3195552826,
0.5008890033,
0.3813787103,
0.3256449103,
0.6457657218,
0.2695095539,
0.4661666155,
-0.3435594738,
0.7371308804,
0.0378244258,
-0.9714071751,
0.3338753283,
-0.448117733,
0.0316002592,
0.6081233621,
0.250031203,
-0.4485822916,
-0.380579263,
-0.7221770287,
-0.939907074,
0.7776048779,
0.3131453991,
0.1666441113,
-0.0634026378,
0.3968010843,
-0.0782532617,
-0.016524002,
-0.7093437314,
-0.6438626051,
-0.3740654588,
-0.3035746217,
-0.0579985008,
-0.2074719816,
-0.3543655872,
0.3299849033,
0.598818779,
-0.1601636112,
0.1192585602,
0.1203928664,
-0.2842900455,
0.3376452923,
0.2035973817,
0.5788372159,
-0.1163845658,
-0.075784266,
0.2949878871,
0.3419644535,
-0.7475824952,
0.1236724555,
0.201731056,
-0.4391345084,
-0.0278909504,
0.7350925207,
0.7719686031,
0.2864463925,
-0.1972349435,
0.7436913252,
-0.4977069199,
-0.3577964306,
-0.126396507,
0.138506189,
0.0355309881,
0.0613724478,
0.3757518232,
0.1934521645,
0.3235589266,
-0.347171098,
0.3906092048,
0.921558857,
-0.5120702982,
-0.0363105871,
0.7277877927,
0.0652736574,
-0.1815033406,
0.1864064783,
-0.3294292986,
-0.508654654,
0.9397138953,
0.6148487329,
0.7780538797,
0.1145481989,
0.1973823309,
-0.1106703579,
0.5829504728,
-0.0373499244,
0.2149258107,
0.0767817572,
-0.5599557161,
-0.2051739395,
-0.6689925194,
0.0019114579,
0.2597770691,
-1.0925549269,
0.0605991445,
-0.771618247,
-0.2747335434,
0.2250630558,
0.0353831835,
-0.2030239999,
0.2897351086,
0.3774026632,
1.0109890699,
-0.6866352558,
0.6635298729,
0.499896884,
-0.2079920173,
-0.4817824662,
0.3830724955,
0.1940053701,
-0.9465631843,
0.5550593138,
0.2464469969,
-0.3072458804,
-0.0649052486,
-0.3214401007,
-0.8251972795,
0.8409146667,
0.5348393917,
-0.299885422,
0.2053123116,
-0.0504065417,
0.6231913567,
-0.0241625682,
0.1281146109,
0.4065750241,
0.464568764,
-0.12870197,
-0.2078489214,
0.0922515467,
-0.3541958332,
-0.0299188327,
0.5416170955,
-0.4497136474,
1.0384325981,
0.0732333362,
-0.5917966366,
0.0154382745,
0.4969372451,
-0.2790963352,
0.565697968,
0.7024960518,
0.6718499064,
0.5839905143,
-0.0926864818,
1.5817629099,
-0.689919591,
0.1728865802,
0.8972713947,
0.0724166706,
0.6711069942,
0.101505734,
-0.1856346726,
0.3679575622,
0.3058104217,
-0.2435231805,
0.3784320056,
0.3809723556,
-0.2884863615,
-0.1281578988,
-0.1120377779,
-0.483481586,
0.4296959043,
0.3699476123,
-0.2677985132,
-0.508590579,
0.1252576262,
0.3886083066,
0.2818360031,
-0.3882119656,
0.7380088568,
-0.07516177,
-0.1429349184,
0.8736213446,
0.3327339292,
0.9723560214,
-0.7423099875,
0.0764073506,
-0.1894222349,
0.0471394658,
-0.1176684871,
-0.1574041098,
0.2426882982,
0.2839030623,
-0.3253423572,
-0.0876298845,
0.542086184,
-0.1364591569,
-0.5319920778,
0.3201630116,
0.0034156197,
-0.1712749898,
-0.3088649809,
-0.6902341843,
-0.2175224572,
0.0309805106,
-0.2272238135,
0.6591259241,
0.4747322202,
0.0963834301,
0.6666793823,
0.8117727041,
0.2286804914,
0.0824645981,
0.2228512019,
0.6093485355,
-0.5038021207,
-0.2734132409,
-0.95284307,
-0.202458173,
-0.0903424621,
-0.3837794065,
0.9346009493,
0.2314456254,
0.826793611,
0.2157303095,
0.7219173312,
0.2328348458,
0.166115582,
-0.7468303442,
0.8761005402,
-0.610717535,
0.566409111,
-0.2995786071,
-0.2206672281,
-0.3798104525,
0.497974664,
-0.1305647492,
0.03725335,
0.5338270068,
0.7446530461,
0.3458035886,
0.2346232384,
0.369851917,
0.2180198729,
0.3689276874,
0.4826437533,
0.8395524025,
-0.5713509917,
0.9446978569,
-0.3177257776,
-0.0263082515,
-0.0702233762,
-0.7694798708,
-0.7437133789,
-0.0818793401,
-0.1125287563,
-0.2536368072,
0.1180918515,
0.5498932004,
0.3197454214,
-0.6088206768,
0.3484430909,
-0.3039047122,
0.1399811655,
-0.125703454,
-0.2544624209,
0.3159838915,
-0.434120208,
-0.6629454494,
0.6010259986,
-0.0097896187,
0.3362967968,
-0.0665271953,
0.1873015016,
-0.0541576445,
0.2328941524,
0.3571271598,
0.0932368785,
-0.421084851,
-0.0793083087,
-0.1180499569,
-0.180237174,
-0.1563013792,
0.7385531068,
-0.6011438966,
0.157212615,
0.5612211823,
0.8133961558,
-0.0117586898,
0.0707646534,
0.5638059378,
-0.8109179735,
0.0331434496,
-0.0225737095,
0.3471022844,
0.3019292355,
-0.3675745428,
0.2226955891,
0.4519276321,
-0.0306786224,
-0.9645524025,
0.3524946868,
-0.6969649792,
-0.6485635042,
1.2247993946,
-0.3996727467,
-0.2180558741,
-0.3035414219,
-0.2751047611,
0.2890934646,
-0.2886029482,
0.7917228937,
0.7084566951,
0.1415102929,
0.3173779249,
-0.7689890265,
0.8154361844,
0.5265403986,
-0.6399555206,
0.2730337083,
0.3586572111,
0.1125989482,
0.2367511988,
0.2376474142,
-0.0965387523,
0.0711447299,
0.5967859626,
-0.3156073689,
-0.177097261,
-0.2867870927,
-0.8587493896,
0.7069510221,
0.0435043909,
-0.3112086654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03494v8 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03494v8 | A Categorical Archive of ChatGPT Failures | 2023-02-06T04:21:59 | 2023-04-03T20:02:26 | Ali Borji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models have been demonstrated to be valuable in different
fields. ChatGPT, developed by OpenAI, has been trained using massive amounts of
data and simulates human conversation by comprehending context and generating
appropriate responses. It has garnered significant attention due to its ability
to effectively answer a broad range of human inquiries, with fluent and
comprehensive answers surpassing prior public chatbots in both security and
usefulness. However, a comprehensive analysis of ChatGPT's failures is lacking,
which is the focus of this study. Eleven categories of failures, including
reasoning, factual errors, math, coding, and bias, are presented and discussed.
The risks, limitations, and societal implications of ChatGPT are also
highlighted. The goal of this study is to assist researchers and developers in
enhancing future language models and chatbots. | [
-0.3277898431,
-0.9136464596,
0.2242744416,
0.3693392575,
0.2104630768,
0.2198735774,
0.0228852555,
-0.2627577484,
-0.2409773618,
0.424646765,
-0.3889345229,
-0.1186601296,
-0.5904716849,
-0.1653137654,
-0.7239333987,
1.2236007452,
0.1158210263,
0.0001350861,
0.0896197185,
0.1564787328,
-0.8391714692,
-1.0849362612,
-0.9176520109,
-0.0343782045,
0.2403181046,
0.4367625713,
0.7506203651,
0.0314815678,
0.8484134078,
0.2542901933,
0.1233265549,
-0.2790769041,
-0.8339572549,
-0.229473114,
0.0162707902,
-0.523288846,
-0.5661881566,
-0.1154120639,
0.6832610369,
0.7214718461,
-0.3947260976,
0.0154666314,
0.1178557053,
0.4518408179,
-0.2880345881,
0.2623989582,
-0.7099141479,
0.0383025482,
-0.222500816,
-0.1059080213,
-0.4633101225,
-0.5205518603,
0.3322374821,
-0.227897957,
0.2486663908,
0.0697866082,
0.6653932333,
0.2104547918,
-0.5069086552,
-0.6220622659,
-0.9763246775,
0.6516435742,
-0.3919917047,
0.2377926111,
0.3469220996,
0.6004462838,
-0.6122171879,
-0.6463196874,
-0.449610889,
-0.260646373,
-0.0158796012,
0.1206411496,
-0.2465668172,
0.0940118954,
0.1314984858,
0.575379014,
-1.0036132336,
-0.1418551803,
-0.6154649854,
-0.1661577076,
0.270424068,
0.3944633305,
0.7683423162,
-0.2016709596,
-0.2859667242,
-0.4716773629,
-0.8612955213,
-0.096634239,
0.6646232009,
0.1515809447,
-0.1822243184,
0.6114413142,
-0.2277173698,
0.4823409319,
-0.5866295099,
-0.0739946738,
-0.0046490752,
-0.3237270117,
-0.2190217227,
-0.0298732277,
0.91631037,
0.1836774647,
0.521222949,
-0.0819857642,
0.1418565363,
0.1368558854,
0.2839992642,
-0.6603928804,
-0.4263604581,
0.4140532911,
-0.332397759,
-0.2238630056,
-0.0023592121,
-0.7468587756,
-0.3940811157,
0.1936605871,
0.1457000971,
-0.5702024698,
-0.3779712617,
0.3625647128,
-0.1226083934,
0.3981408179,
0.317773968,
-0.771519959,
0.2427681237,
0.833642602,
0.7720158696,
0.132185176,
-0.3145389855,
-0.005060344,
-0.4590627849,
-0.2016527504,
0.7024400234,
-0.5274101496,
-0.4334945679,
-0.0288600475,
-0.1292483211,
-0.2206136286,
-0.1975475401,
0.6180721521,
-0.3988823295,
0.2304855883,
-0.0559788123,
-0.2499198914,
-0.2987023294,
0.4114873707,
-0.5423767567,
0.5112223029,
-0.1938185692,
-0.9499806166,
0.2093683481,
-0.6793449521,
-0.111508444,
0.1221455634,
-0.0715607181,
-0.2812109888,
-0.1210975647,
-0.1029560044,
0.5733519793,
-0.4256137609,
0.775598824,
-0.2133770436,
-0.3424911797,
0.5183131099,
-0.7456780672,
0.8596630692,
0.0145238638,
-0.1452356875,
-0.1127117723,
-0.7345499992,
-0.165304631,
0.3246207535,
-0.2717672884,
-0.006247323,
0.2723328173,
0.1505503058,
0.2389817685,
-0.1179865003,
-0.6887957454,
0.112816602,
-0.1212651059,
0.6619261503,
0.6317822337,
0.0550823659,
0.0361476913,
-0.1247363016,
0.6165656447,
-0.132632032,
0.2820777893,
-0.3752537966,
-0.8171383142,
-0.7660170197,
0.1767779887,
0.3873521686,
0.8465927243,
-0.7370854616,
0.0405213647,
-0.51732409,
-0.8197594881,
-0.186418891,
-0.2822363377,
0.5483813286,
0.2181901336,
-0.2355103344,
-0.5102771521,
-0.5629391074,
-0.8957256675,
-0.1648555845,
-0.6170963049,
-0.1365763545,
0.2742177546,
0.6081288457,
-0.2828702927,
0.8760416508,
-0.4193594158,
-0.1551801264,
-0.1606248468,
0.1733178943,
0.021860959,
0.4987619221,
0.3605351448,
-0.7421157956,
-0.1420730203,
0.0371793471,
-0.665989995,
0.4094431996,
-0.1284662187,
-0.1384670287,
-0.0955501869,
0.1252538115,
-0.6474374533,
0.5026782155,
0.775578618,
-0.2692753673,
0.7836417556,
0.0780015737,
0.0739760473,
-1.0793694258,
0.3105296493,
-0.0458747707,
0.0619877987,
-0.820392549,
-0.1766475439,
-0.1390519887,
-0.7111389041,
-0.5098496079,
0.4941156209,
0.0846858993,
-0.0752583221,
0.0645660535,
-0.0265121683,
-0.7504760027,
0.692027986,
0.1098473221,
0.7761893272,
0.4950622618,
-0.3751579225,
0.5243406892,
0.4117142558,
-0.2842095494,
0.3462257683,
-1.0398372412,
0.3121375144,
-0.2107136846,
0.3505841494,
-1.2230294943,
-0.7846934199,
0.5243172646,
-0.8124284148,
-0.046189446,
-0.2262363583,
-0.636903286,
-0.2316613495,
0.0475411788,
0.376889199,
0.5354651213,
-0.3530103266,
0.0469130054,
0.5524817705,
-0.2675797343,
-0.5720726848,
-0.461792171,
0.3150968552,
-0.1982216388,
-0.6630285978,
-0.630472064,
0.0580140799,
-0.0666961148,
-0.0616906695,
0.2050820738,
-0.177638948,
0.2369703948,
0.4896306992,
0.2305329889,
-0.1948493272,
0.1855382323,
-0.6967067719,
-0.1936783791,
0.1012331992,
-0.0799541324,
0.9086869955,
-0.6022260189,
-0.664683044,
-0.2297219932,
0.3523964584,
0.3880358338,
-0.096155867,
0.8052120209,
0.3647431135,
-0.3267680109,
0.103342317,
-0.1980190426,
-0.0539596565,
-0.4115496278,
0.5700141788,
-0.1013374627,
-1.0962673426,
0.5327185988,
0.3829084933,
0.2945337296,
0.1500068158,
0.4231096506,
0.2753233314,
1.0173742771,
0.4027748406,
-0.1591458619,
0.2739901841,
0.1540118903,
0.6605398059,
-0.2632445991,
-0.290586859,
-0.7680137753,
0.2309229374,
-0.9367099404,
-0.2427348644,
0.4206255376,
-0.2958222628,
-0.6495361924,
0.3447170556,
-0.3416005373,
0.273029089,
0.4980827868,
-0.0927529037,
0.3111032844,
0.2102149427,
0.413335681,
0.2597711086,
-0.7478753328,
-0.7866301537,
1.1289137602,
0.6548908949,
1.1146706343,
0.2554718852,
0.2603560388,
0.064732939,
0.2833748162,
-0.7280341983,
0.5432210565,
-0.0122644464,
-0.9395504594,
-0.5428401828,
-0.5277447104,
-1.0942591429,
0.1652232707,
0.2852379382,
-0.9736975431,
-0.0293551963,
0.3168324232,
-0.0827867165,
0.2429494709,
-0.9671878219,
1.0883587599,
-0.0333495587,
0.1931102127,
0.2359240055,
-0.5613991022,
0.8812453151,
-0.2376936376,
0.0766965747,
-0.1356688738,
0.4272334576,
0.7812728882,
-0.2370037138,
1.1895176172,
0.3038564324,
-0.032440044,
0.4604361653,
0.1639021784,
0.3338036835,
-0.0041253157,
0.247963652,
0.2422206104,
0.0185822397,
-0.6204380393,
-0.4603152573,
0.3541523814,
-0.7292879224,
-0.5415555835,
-0.4269625843,
-0.2777896225,
-0.4497900307,
-0.0456442982,
0.0310617313,
0.7806722522,
-0.4302976429,
0.3708536327,
0.5401936769,
-0.6747976542,
0.2876697481,
0.0813176036,
-0.1760926545,
-0.1842644364,
1.0797257423,
-0.148768276,
0.4277130067,
0.0912365094,
-0.0368255563,
-0.0548762083,
-0.2687067986,
-0.4745570123,
-0.0224722419,
-0.8751911521,
-0.0458624549,
-0.7775449157,
-0.4325365126,
-0.1372997165,
0.2580000162,
-0.5342803001,
-0.1679195911,
0.1936203092,
0.0004487449,
0.2257923186,
0.7353903055,
0.3294818401,
0.5491905212,
-0.9112502933,
0.0244609863,
0.3631192446,
0.537230134,
0.2849633098,
-0.1205737889,
0.2135451585,
0.2316620946,
-0.2647690177,
-0.8084741235,
0.290787369,
0.0985390469,
0.3783942163,
0.2127093822,
-0.0148734143,
0.6030323505,
-0.4792893529,
0.953458488,
0.3590064347,
-0.7821487784,
0.5768309236,
-0.6755886674,
0.2218929976,
0.2404780388,
0.5520675182,
-1.1064807177,
-0.3736947179,
-0.629078567,
-0.726265192,
0.7714878917,
0.6032249331,
0.4255898595,
-0.2298606783,
-0.0133382548,
0.0751548782,
-0.0886297375,
-0.6814933419,
0.0148192327,
-0.1915316582,
0.0016303768,
-0.2643258572,
-0.2603721023,
0.1305312365,
0.3288880289,
0.6982184052,
-0.1276588142,
0.5837305784,
0.0446401462,
-0.0601675548,
0.2719367743,
0.4584615529,
0.6174635291,
0.6812493205,
-0.1721872091,
-0.011142008,
0.0096995952,
-0.7166537046,
0.1419950277,
-0.2582378983,
0.1091680229,
-0.2353821248,
0.4638182521,
0.91140306,
0.2004691213,
-1.0053759813,
0.4910677671,
-0.3264639676,
0.025250366,
-0.5795553923,
-0.0606438965,
-0.0084682051,
-0.1865348816,
0.223813504,
0.0245601553,
0.1810150295,
-0.9346579909,
0.1442791075,
0.3298965991,
-0.5402210355,
-0.3343454003,
0.5056135058,
0.1549245864,
-0.2498146743,
0.8706846833,
-0.0418581292,
-0.7503932118,
0.6798192263,
0.4155249894,
0.7997933626,
-0.1893165261,
0.457126826,
0.3656688929,
0.5134600997,
-0.2773290277,
0.0633156449,
0.3471456468,
-0.7097521424,
-0.5526118875,
-0.6466932893,
-0.7476864457,
0.0852726325,
-0.2615918517,
0.1014023125,
-0.2458143383,
-0.0058200429,
-0.0916319638,
-0.3631927371,
-0.7780435681,
0.1070339829,
0.0267506186,
0.6658031344,
-0.9148822427,
0.4501224458,
0.7695448399,
-0.4660214782,
-0.878732264,
0.0946512967,
-0.0858005807,
-0.9478754401,
0.7981104255,
-0.0176285654,
0.090708822,
-0.1927021891,
-0.6231613755,
-0.7755787969,
0.5833500028,
0.1940817982,
-0.4044085145,
-0.0143577037,
0.7027602196,
0.7076560855,
0.1209974587,
0.5233787894,
0.6001793146,
0.1970397234,
0.2187395692,
-1.4934755564,
0.031726636,
-0.0884950534,
0.1165180951,
0.2427081168,
-0.7277224064,
0.8385670781,
0.1956544667,
-0.3663266897,
0.1312960982,
0.1588145345,
0.1100549176,
0.0254776403,
0.2397980988,
0.3095137477,
0.4894014597,
-0.3469719291,
1.338273406,
0.1256466508,
0.433716476,
0.8121467829,
0.0368319228,
0.7497807741,
-0.0084045222,
-0.323543638,
-0.0718050972,
0.7153478861,
0.1811413616,
0.144461751,
0.3025760353,
-0.1440645903,
-0.1675247252,
0.1686329395,
-0.2183009684,
0.7164791822,
0.5148879886,
-0.0347491167,
-0.3464653194,
0.150458023,
0.0073973597,
-0.5690084696,
-0.200496763,
0.6213264465,
0.0926752985,
-0.7479862571,
0.5620995164,
-0.1790895015,
0.4283694625,
-0.3334270418,
-0.2266858667,
-0.3283329606,
0.1499818116,
-0.1682022512,
-0.9052062035,
0.257432729,
0.0421758294,
0.4054136574,
0.0538718663,
0.9758129716,
-0.0896841064,
-0.3477972746,
-0.2027908564,
0.4182162285,
0.6653969288,
-0.2960470021,
-0.4576154351,
0.2104482949,
-0.0070123062,
-0.1271389425,
0.2896829545,
0.3426833153,
-0.4019903541,
1.0355240107,
0.5445347428,
-0.4374368489,
0.2307920307,
-0.27351138,
0.6792989969,
-0.7453064919,
-0.3284871876,
-0.9004284143,
0.5137805343,
-0.1177789196,
-0.3559328616,
0.774926722,
0.3700836003,
0.7760090232,
-0.2528682351,
0.9148047566,
-0.1971791536,
0.3608748019,
-0.3842952251,
0.6928025484,
-0.0787564814,
0.1600628644,
-0.4569411576,
-0.8989378214,
-0.3518596888,
0.3328506947,
-0.3284731507,
-0.0744657442,
0.5185567141,
0.6918392181,
-0.0934461579,
0.3832855523,
0.458278358,
-0.0938570723,
0.5250863433,
0.7217106223,
1.1957327127,
-0.5417284966,
1.0463268757,
-0.0799905434,
-0.2166341096,
-0.3764470518,
-0.6300660372,
-1.1470872164,
-0.7959284186,
-0.2761746943,
-0.2895720005,
0.2853408456,
0.5071216226,
0.6661167145,
-0.7615077496,
-0.1367415786,
-0.117853865,
0.0905484855,
0.3519441187,
-0.2000101954,
0.3547810614,
-0.3526157439,
-0.6107966304,
-0.0939926729,
0.061189536,
0.0196508095,
-0.2499565184,
0.1574148536,
0.3621005118,
-0.1121337488,
0.6574989557,
0.6093459129,
-0.7194105983,
-0.5675189495,
-0.0325062051,
-0.0350691974,
0.00216645,
0.8919608593,
-0.360396713,
0.2964625359,
0.5758634806,
0.7505289912,
0.0939518362,
0.0471983738,
0.7770169973,
-0.4834939837,
0.1202810407,
0.1442591101,
0.3385039866,
0.3609984517,
-0.1657187939,
0.6563519239,
0.0467385761,
-0.7662297487,
-0.8009585738,
0.2332021743,
-1.0084065199,
0.0045633218,
1.2928470373,
-0.2233115286,
-0.1524715722,
-0.3551391661,
-0.5654050112,
-0.0566753633,
-0.3712467849,
0.7628564835,
1.0407770872,
-0.0417365469,
-0.3775253594,
-1.2687335014,
0.3968240619,
0.1367897838,
-0.8726552129,
0.1124322936,
0.4322268069,
0.3168723881,
0.2209586203,
0.6853068471,
-0.3413989544,
0.3166256547,
0.3655565977,
0.248617813,
0.535469532,
-0.1195773408,
-0.196302399,
0.3443578482,
0.2598145902,
-0.1908596456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02500v1 | TempEL: Linking Dynamically Evolving and Newly Emerging Entities | 2023-02-05T22:34:36 | 2023-02-05T22:34:36 | Klim Zaporojets, Lucie-Aimee Kaffee, Johannes Deleu, Thomas Demeester, Chris Develder, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | In our continuously evolving world, entities change over time and new,
previously non-existing or unknown, entities appear. We study how this
evolutionary scenario impacts the performance on a well established entity
linking (EL) task. For that study, we introduce TempEL, an entity linking
dataset that consists of time-stratified English Wikipedia snapshots from 2013
to 2022, from which we collect both anchor mentions of entities, and these
target entities' descriptions. By capturing such temporal aspects, our newly
introduced TempEL resource contrasts with currently existing entity linking
datasets, which are composed of fixed mentions linked to a single static
version of a target Knowledge Base (e.g., Wikipedia 2010 for CoNLL-AIDA).
Indeed, for each of our collected temporal snapshots, TempEL contains links to
entities that are continual, i.e., occur in all of the years, as well as
completely new entities that appear for the first time at some point. Thus, we
enable to quantify the performance of current state-of-the-art EL models for:
(i) entities that are subject to changes over time in their Knowledge Base
descriptions as well as their mentions' contexts, and (ii) newly created
entities that were previously non-existing (e.g., at the time the EL model was
trained). Our experimental results show that in terms of temporal performance
degradation, (i) continual entities suffer a decrease of up to 3.1% EL
accuracy, while (ii) for new entities this accuracy drop is up to 17.9%. This
highlights the challenge of the introduced TempEL dataset and opens new
research prospects in the area of time-evolving entity disambiguation. | [
-0.5462067127,
-0.6226375103,
0.4337016046,
-0.0233308319,
-0.2829060256,
0.2199653387,
-0.2842538655,
-1.0157220364,
0.1980507374,
-0.1785960048,
-0.6163179278,
-0.3352244496,
-0.3423921466,
0.2184949666,
-0.6881875992,
1.1146746874,
0.0703572258,
-0.6518772244,
-0.3690329194,
-0.1809574068,
0.0163530447,
0.2605068982,
-0.6845690608,
-0.2648887932,
0.9767882228,
0.120148316,
0.9098615646,
0.7984401584,
0.1537781805,
0.2857619822,
-0.1701229662,
0.1581996232,
-0.6373946667,
0.4013577402,
-0.5873547792,
-0.0287140124,
-0.3401995897,
-0.315570116,
0.9454134703,
0.8867586851,
-0.1887909323,
0.4503691494,
-0.0053439159,
0.5121156573,
-0.7326565385,
0.2120366693,
-1.0194915533,
-0.2061131597,
-0.6813693643,
-0.3069847822,
-0.1241744384,
-0.3254341781,
0.583604455,
-0.8428747058,
0.43079409,
0.2928541303,
1.064889431,
0.4743376076,
-0.1827592403,
-0.3438096046,
-0.8533076048,
0.3699840605,
-0.2412459552,
0.6219038963,
-0.1909244806,
0.3063627779,
-0.0997705013,
-1.0023144484,
-0.5828309059,
-0.4402048886,
0.1798300296,
-0.3720051646,
-0.2978162169,
-0.5019122958,
0.3455038369,
0.3250974417,
-0.236702621,
0.0947214663,
-0.5901261568,
0.1415786147,
0.3487684429,
-0.0268282276,
0.2869124413,
-0.1177656204,
-0.3449327946,
0.1605882347,
-0.8154031038,
-0.3615472615,
0.393407613,
-0.017434869,
0.165291056,
0.4985912442,
0.1539219916,
0.3971205354,
0.1824032813,
0.1869706213,
0.2500271797,
-0.2700347602,
0.0285847504,
0.4118157327,
0.4430460632,
0.3620927632,
0.4213525355,
-0.6795244217,
-0.0601359606,
-0.0151492301,
0.4053775966,
-0.5559150577,
-0.4898799658,
0.0253525842,
-0.2737587988,
-0.1946664751,
0.053301733,
-0.7131012678,
-0.2606441081,
-0.1049121991,
0.2138159722,
-0.6589813828,
-0.4924120009,
-0.233975634,
0.087559633,
-0.0854051709,
0.2820990384,
-0.50059551,
0.1572778672,
0.5939558744,
0.7843879461,
-0.2238970399,
-0.6072470546,
-0.2238915861,
0.6312252283,
-0.2124244422,
1.0470551252,
-0.7255770564,
-0.3415138125,
-0.0475705527,
0.1678852141,
-0.0021115988,
-0.5806009173,
0.1614815444,
-0.8722972274,
0.1286433339,
-0.298217237,
-0.6793782711,
0.2503310442,
-0.2177406698,
-1.063800931,
1.1400029659,
0.2303656489,
-0.8147185445,
0.6787171364,
-0.7168377638,
-0.4900422692,
0.2585606575,
0.1878128201,
-0.3740670681,
0.1608022153,
-0.2841663957,
0.1004218534,
-0.3307006359,
0.1392349005,
-0.5021839142,
-0.3779667318,
0.0008326801,
-0.0425883569,
0.6193138361,
0.2753209174,
-0.3710464835,
-0.5741260648,
-0.7894044518,
-0.2072766274,
0.1524533033,
-0.3450312316,
-0.5783851147,
0.4038597643,
-0.2289585471,
0.3021540046,
0.3891119361,
-0.3651225865,
0.3088711798,
-0.1804352254,
0.3620284498,
0.6250318289,
0.5255093575,
0.3976098001,
-0.1891311705,
0.0437522493,
0.1233359575,
0.1492403597,
-0.3003364503,
-0.3548234999,
-0.83701998,
0.3945642412,
0.2947715223,
0.1003620327,
-0.9216080308,
-0.0193364583,
-0.7835300565,
-0.647262156,
-0.2495883852,
-0.0400820486,
0.1016110256,
0.7210327387,
0.6719027758,
0.0726249516,
-0.2863028944,
-1.0491127968,
-0.1561328322,
-0.6860758066,
-0.2864106596,
0.2192844898,
0.5020738244,
-0.0358661897,
0.5573309064,
-0.2823170424,
0.4356569052,
0.3445416391,
0.1752362251,
-0.1637867987,
0.2409966737,
0.8322089314,
-0.6742041707,
-0.354614079,
-0.114119105,
-0.6054903865,
-0.2223015875,
-0.2235806882,
-0.2156600356,
0.1676190197,
0.4239140153,
-0.4324808121,
0.0285664331,
0.3602283895,
-0.4087117016,
0.3323730528,
0.0023159336,
0.2660921812,
-1.0912640095,
0.0801843777,
0.3133428693,
0.3542835414,
-0.4200086892,
-0.3136866987,
0.2295515388,
0.0468869545,
-0.7296073437,
0.5180319548,
-0.729562819,
-0.0585821308,
0.0875971839,
0.1249327809,
-0.1881288886,
0.319117099,
-0.2181190699,
0.7624980807,
0.4643437266,
-1.0130182505,
0.3185926378,
0.061571233,
-0.3810539544,
0.8212405443,
-0.6434388161,
0.1795467883,
-0.2105244845,
-0.0841961503,
-0.2928426266,
-0.0375908911,
0.0734764934,
-0.241064474,
0.8308238387,
-0.0600341894,
-0.3946825862,
-0.3537054062,
-0.2851633728,
0.4951872826,
0.1680876911,
-0.4773792922,
0.4843370318,
0.2964203358,
-0.0687494203,
-0.399817884,
-0.3884534538,
0.3001259565,
-0.1820418835,
-0.8195205927,
0.8351569176,
-0.0158042386,
-0.3454890549,
0.6975360513,
-0.5554547906,
-0.0246407874,
0.1799246669,
0.2109842449,
0.4243909121,
-0.2338554561,
0.4205425382,
0.0689082965,
-0.0031313752,
0.2010942549,
-0.6071910262,
0.2457730323,
-0.0088062491,
-0.179164499,
-0.2629069686,
0.1740614623,
0.740411222,
-0.3507543206,
1.2686201334,
0.2769301534,
-0.6774978042,
-0.1687709093,
-0.6925184131,
0.1086828709,
-0.4146888554,
0.555336535,
-0.2336215675,
-0.574670136,
0.3463493586,
-0.1945478767,
0.3568390608,
0.904281199,
0.2743373811,
-0.4424780011,
0.059797205,
0.5458923578,
0.0817108378,
0.7426800728,
-0.1050391123,
0.2203305215,
-0.7621175647,
-0.8797727823,
-0.5327964425,
-0.4945844412,
-0.9264350533,
-0.2560412288,
0.3670043051,
0.025853198,
-0.4802667201,
0.6517635584,
-0.2223385721,
0.3812924325,
0.3089318275,
0.1649640203,
0.1731552929,
0.1347408742,
-0.0127482284,
0.0289635062,
-0.6711879373,
-0.4940253496,
1.066549778,
0.2106509656,
0.6834259629,
0.2976925075,
0.398743093,
0.6564939022,
0.2436208129,
-0.1416843832,
0.5419550538,
0.209920004,
-0.4847343564,
-0.2509863377,
-0.2607615888,
-1.0280753374,
-0.5159104466,
-0.4668727219,
-0.5913127661,
0.2333950996,
0.1744364202,
-0.0922315046,
0.7121918797,
-0.51935637,
0.5590330362,
-0.1220298111,
-0.8446375132,
-0.3367427289,
-0.6531594992,
0.0180412438,
-0.3121608496,
-0.3853491247,
-0.3640892208,
-0.453961581,
0.608751297,
-0.1507091969,
0.177241683,
-0.0193757825,
-0.0635292232,
0.2794143558,
0.1459611058,
0.6189443469,
0.1349047571,
-0.4078342617,
0.4613292813,
-0.2336686552,
-0.6069584489,
-0.6259360909,
1.110888958,
-0.6252881289,
-0.4529520273,
-0.3246930242,
-0.2249531746,
-0.1843293905,
-0.0433239639,
0.2065046132,
0.3179068863,
-0.4205480218,
0.2227440029,
1.0028299093,
-0.2587082684,
0.571690321,
0.6192480326,
0.4190869331,
0.0748773962,
0.558065474,
0.2467733622,
0.2228024602,
0.3761538863,
-0.4865725935,
-0.4679717124,
-0.4720166326,
-0.2112695575,
0.5407594442,
-0.461247474,
-0.0389461108,
-0.7666707039,
-0.1243500188,
-0.1204776317,
-0.1465391517,
-0.535654664,
-0.4093072414,
-0.1055783033,
-0.0105935698,
0.2679669857,
0.6315385103,
0.1773593873,
-0.4241709113,
-0.5534905791,
-0.0866863355,
0.2838521898,
0.5282498598,
0.1273563057,
-0.1896039397,
-0.4047761559,
-0.2592048049,
0.0004688153,
-1.2566949129,
-0.3336639702,
0.4004673362,
0.6955358386,
0.3637541831,
0.1230438948,
0.5887541175,
-0.8814319372,
0.8010275364,
-0.0580115616,
-0.5442607403,
0.7506213784,
-0.2918033004,
0.2413835078,
0.4093038142,
0.5720496178,
-0.6507030129,
-0.2171373516,
-0.7260634899,
-0.9007357359,
0.3882217109,
0.3566982746,
-0.0352716073,
-0.4029954374,
0.6685461998,
-0.0803331807,
0.4301629961,
-0.188730225,
-0.7190182209,
0.0498608761,
0.2929480374,
0.2714770436,
-0.5402116179,
0.2496313155,
-0.1909864098,
0.851982832,
0.3261391222,
0.5045138001,
-0.2155651599,
-0.3284193575,
-0.1967762709,
0.2468731403,
0.3166292906,
1.0236241817,
-0.1003627703,
0.1079433113,
0.481002301,
-0.30440557,
0.0002067704,
0.3146134615,
-0.2852423191,
0.3774727881,
0.5109431148,
0.7524577379,
0.7212556005,
-0.1799488217,
-0.0076135984,
0.3335959315,
0.3404868841,
-0.4170928001,
0.1504627466,
0.1707395762,
0.4269902408,
0.4676534235,
0.0281185415,
-0.2082629204,
-0.5884252787,
0.2925471961,
-0.1020438224,
0.0342112184,
-0.4928230941,
0.9863992333,
0.2650188506,
-0.3328253329,
0.883141458,
-0.2364545465,
-0.2145034373,
0.3709499836,
0.2509090602,
0.8004816771,
-0.5463132262,
0.0858563706,
0.5997384787,
0.3917219341,
0.0896583796,
-0.320971489,
-0.1364001334,
-0.3593808413,
-0.044726368,
-0.6286264062,
-0.2528857589,
0.1400505602,
-0.7357725501,
0.4377579987,
-0.0625504032,
-0.2131228447,
0.171796754,
0.1749444306,
-0.9852156639,
-0.0433043614,
0.1584704816,
1.1202992201,
-0.6140913963,
0.8160656691,
1.0613309145,
-0.4481728971,
-0.3875775337,
0.2333563864,
0.1119699851,
-0.5305223465,
0.2647362947,
-0.3574085832,
-0.2323371917,
0.122297734,
-0.1955779344,
-0.9460417628,
1.5272450447,
0.4007612169,
-0.6874325275,
-0.6893563867,
-0.0823393613,
0.5871296525,
-0.1551453918,
0.0822806135,
0.4422374368,
0.3888935447,
0.1324748099,
-0.8948798776,
-0.0578737482,
-0.5772216916,
0.1724239737,
0.7217898965,
-0.6109919548,
0.7258141041,
-0.3608960509,
-0.6590152979,
-0.158282727,
0.9555096626,
-0.0199604835,
0.51129812,
0.6375405788,
0.5404116511,
0.9659389257,
-0.2709639966,
0.9452783465,
-0.7362257838,
0.3233596087,
1.2678807974,
-0.2529516816,
0.694049716,
0.4446233809,
-0.1612562239,
0.7287145853,
0.7664898634,
-0.42688483,
0.4998877943,
-0.0143055711,
-0.5897215605,
-0.0975642726,
-0.3784196973,
-0.648794055,
-0.0400113948,
0.2132708579,
-0.4305642247,
-0.5949766636,
-0.2751185298,
0.1971141845,
-0.1185409352,
-0.3217326105,
0.2645718455,
-0.2206018865,
-0.5596835017,
0.1147336215,
-0.3171069622,
0.3935650289,
-0.4524258673,
0.065574266,
-0.262381196,
-0.2630612254,
-0.1648931801,
-0.6520434022,
0.3603956103,
0.1803245097,
-0.3007428646,
0.0280139763,
0.510160327,
-0.4024838805,
-0.24058263,
0.3211691678,
0.6088961363,
0.1207608804,
0.1466621161,
-0.7476900816,
0.1462017,
-0.2639211714,
-0.3282340765,
0.0923649743,
0.8714678884,
-0.1117573902,
0.7417609096,
0.2941308916,
-0.0082802037,
0.172784999,
-0.2140774727,
1.156319499,
-0.6881617904,
-0.2055092901,
-0.7436648011,
0.3147562742,
-0.279671222,
-0.2528437376,
0.5073538423,
0.7339594364,
1.0973351002,
0.3005002737,
0.3274248838,
-0.2485886812,
0.2797189951,
-0.410636276,
0.6730377078,
-0.7981262207,
0.7068902254,
-0.2733104527,
-1.4704440832,
0.3186356723,
0.0974113271,
-0.1382116824,
0.2091988623,
1.0788183212,
0.6521763802,
-0.1225681752,
-0.0929506049,
0.0323141217,
0.2649015188,
0.0740501434,
0.812887907,
0.8305949569,
-0.1078851745,
0.6248090863,
-0.2682922781,
0.2023683637,
0.0456750654,
-1.1083990335,
-0.6133003235,
-0.8719471097,
-0.9005519748,
-0.5559349656,
0.5664921999,
0.9919586182,
0.2519462109,
-0.6612774134,
0.3634317815,
0.4092815518,
-0.0350166745,
0.1465895772,
-0.1606465429,
0.3536646366,
0.001014908,
-0.9846363068,
0.3336638808,
0.5993568897,
0.0480476208,
-0.2773336172,
0.0013629359,
-0.4507504404,
-0.1657859832,
0.3281686306,
0.4788048863,
-0.5308715701,
-0.3905926645,
0.1251572967,
-0.0558906198,
-0.0018023942,
0.6952175498,
-0.7577954531,
0.3464591801,
0.1109617352,
0.6337125897,
0.6228964329,
-0.3042494357,
0.2554706335,
-0.430939436,
-0.0560403168,
0.23665604,
0.3650690019,
0.3468827009,
-0.3060385287,
0.6776115894,
0.4807220995,
-0.3885416687,
-0.6652035713,
0.0597128086,
-0.5819872022,
-0.210535571,
0.8744661808,
-0.0297838729,
-0.2766540349,
-0.1620092392,
0.666988492,
0.5892279148,
-0.3927484155,
1.0470911264,
0.6927842498,
-0.0496944375,
-0.0292544719,
-0.4917962253,
0.462046206,
-0.0228398573,
-0.6663919091,
-0.3935873508,
0.7338392735,
0.542303443,
0.3214116395,
0.2001042962,
-0.0058759069,
0.4059428871,
0.0294449311,
-0.1018595025,
-0.5232242346,
-0.5870967507,
0.2138766348,
0.3335974216,
0.0130420234,
-0.1390414685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02479v1 | Hatemongers ride on echo chambers to escalate hate speech diffusion | 2023-02-05T20:30:48 | 2023-02-05T20:30:48 | Vasu Goel, Dhruv Sahnan, Subhabrata Dutta, Anil Bandhakavi, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Recent years have witnessed a swelling rise of hateful and abusive content
over online social networks. While detection and moderation of hate speech have
been the early go-to countermeasures, the solution requires a deeper
exploration of the dynamics of hate generation and propagation. We analyze more
than 32 million posts from over 6.8 million users across three popular online
social networks to investigate the interrelations between hateful behavior,
information dissemination, and polarised organization mediated by echo
chambers. We find that hatemongers play a more crucial role in governing the
spread of information compared to singled-out hateful content. This observation
holds for both the growth of information cascades as well as the conglomeration
of hateful actors. Dissection of the core-wise distribution of these networks
points towards the fact that hateful users acquire a more well-connected
position in the social network and often flock together to build up information
cascades. We observe that this cohesion is far from mere organized behavior;
instead, in these networks, hatemongers dominate the echo chambers -- groups of
users actively align themselves to specific ideological positions. The observed
dominance of hateful users to inflate information cascades is primarily via
user interactions amplified within these echo chambers. We conclude our study
with a cautionary note that popularity-based recommendation of content is
susceptible to be exploited by hatemongers given their potential to escalate
content popularity via echo-chambered interactions. | [
-0.8910118341,
-0.9365972877,
0.3475003541,
-0.0865580216,
-0.2519819438,
0.1086087674,
-0.1008434445,
-0.5189993382,
0.6945255399,
0.6270048022,
-0.5469361544,
-0.1423416883,
-1.1258420944,
-0.3263776004,
-0.6421946883,
1.3905521631,
0.6728509665,
-0.2664860487,
0.3269174397,
-0.1666656733,
0.0596008413,
-0.7579397559,
-0.6728121638,
-0.3308790028,
1.0156279802,
-0.1825512648,
0.8260622621,
0.5401297212,
0.2769874632,
0.1691950262,
-0.3264365196,
-0.133919999,
-0.984992981,
0.4478113353,
-0.2239112258,
-0.2870790958,
-0.164089933,
-0.1523973048,
0.1939381659,
0.3125724196,
-0.1804573536,
0.1920682639,
0.3107863367,
0.5003574491,
-0.2657117546,
-0.3255794346,
-0.6673386097,
-0.1176905707,
-0.5398017764,
-0.4075694382,
-0.1996401995,
-0.5313551426,
-0.0949464887,
-0.6285442114,
0.275942266,
0.2492555827,
0.2768634558,
0.0108807068,
-0.4047257304,
-0.6677268744,
-0.9060310721,
0.6308683753,
-0.1344285309,
0.1870473027,
0.1410394162,
0.0952104926,
-0.0024080933,
-0.3355257213,
-0.516083777,
0.2457891703,
0.1931134611,
-0.0191848651,
-0.8957632184,
-0.0532261692,
0.2339097857,
0.3970299661,
-0.2618290186,
0.1103944629,
-0.686139524,
0.0066954666,
0.5141665339,
0.2416115403,
0.5910490751,
-0.1078120843,
-0.4507917762,
-0.0370134227,
-0.3624961376,
-0.2047017664,
0.9407425523,
0.4002748132,
0.0704379007,
0.482874006,
0.291459918,
0.3343265951,
0.4703141451,
0.2589526176,
0.036914438,
-0.1679590195,
0.1381774396,
0.4899033308,
0.6302059889,
0.6485837698,
0.3406278491,
0.1708753407,
0.0918415114,
0.2582267225,
0.863293469,
-0.6932440996,
0.0165118556,
-0.0941448957,
-0.4996184707,
-0.562595129,
-0.1187293753,
-1.156214118,
-1.2549397945,
0.1019344032,
0.4939469993,
0.0396247804,
-0.5800930262,
-0.2654455006,
-0.6996731758,
-0.0622908883,
0.2766059935,
-0.4870038927,
0.7691537738,
0.8732424378,
1.0504838228,
-0.1128660813,
0.030818563,
-0.2030771077,
0.0098584108,
-0.2820780277,
0.5787163973,
-0.5182325244,
-0.1980102509,
0.3234900236,
-0.2485333234,
0.2727160454,
-0.7878404856,
0.5275636911,
-0.8124043345,
-0.1474527121,
-0.1490613073,
-0.496244669,
-0.2594844699,
0.1463826299,
-0.4838449359,
0.6429448128,
0.0470382534,
-0.8183764815,
-0.0041902815,
-0.3911904693,
-0.1807889044,
0.0732893124,
-0.0022614065,
-0.3948523402,
0.2647781968,
-0.1437248439,
0.4917305708,
-0.0497942604,
-0.2210031152,
-0.6187672019,
-0.4067644775,
0.2453679889,
-0.1460861862,
0.8573663831,
0.2987253666,
-0.6611872315,
0.0456597768,
-0.1569509506,
-0.5990152955,
0.0115031162,
0.2307014316,
-0.7290614843,
0.0304164384,
-0.0369149521,
0.1868287474,
-0.3601716757,
-0.4290869236,
-0.1904229224,
-0.0419114865,
0.1755391806,
1.1212935448,
0.6712952852,
0.1290270984,
-0.8631817698,
0.5524417758,
0.3425247967,
0.3773492575,
0.4443023205,
-0.5192624927,
-0.4779973328,
0.1829486489,
-0.7669904828,
0.1434232146,
-0.0494016185,
0.0289234985,
0.0925290361,
-0.7813024521,
-0.480288893,
0.0702424869,
0.1977442503,
0.3116698563,
0.5624076724,
-0.1285260618,
-0.5630166531,
-0.9352522492,
-0.6562055349,
-0.2691996694,
0.2617124319,
0.313344419,
-0.0389375761,
-0.4900306165,
0.2095880657,
-0.2258345783,
-0.4298623204,
-0.286757499,
0.5215526223,
0.270000875,
0.025043007,
0.5245687962,
-1.0035393238,
-0.6436471343,
-0.2607012391,
-0.1976360381,
-0.3675197959,
0.0884347185,
-0.2308060676,
-0.279610008,
0.4979493916,
0.0092928307,
0.185878858,
0.6625587344,
-0.2443213612,
0.5821894407,
0.6761450171,
0.4012695253,
-1.0605516434,
-0.2933075428,
-0.0600645393,
-0.0927375406,
-0.8029315472,
-0.0321964845,
-0.7908208966,
0.2237273455,
-0.37413463,
0.0572274141,
-0.084163636,
0.2110602558,
-0.1585728377,
0.4541238248,
-0.3829388022,
0.2086165398,
-0.3614453971,
0.2678436041,
0.6520335078,
-0.5080944896,
0.4728502333,
-0.0026256426,
-0.3053863943,
0.8003714681,
-0.3790508509,
-0.0348681286,
-0.2263311297,
0.3376112878,
-1.0122672319,
-0.230460003,
0.5499984622,
-0.3426164091,
-0.2912386358,
-0.3126909435,
-0.3968320787,
-0.3117760122,
-0.4512210488,
0.509609282,
0.5001917481,
-0.3061640859,
0.399071902,
0.8929877877,
-0.3320448697,
-0.3782609701,
-0.6072331667,
-0.0220038164,
-0.5673593879,
-0.259757936,
0.1218137145,
-0.1089164689,
-0.8245356679,
0.0934091732,
0.0732359812,
0.0299710333,
-0.0802135617,
0.7398809791,
-0.4457267225,
-0.1073106453,
0.2827361822,
-0.0458725356,
0.3542059362,
0.2524099648,
-0.3019214272,
0.8581215143,
-0.0966736749,
-0.2082368135,
-0.417661339,
0.4217187464,
0.759757936,
0.3672506213,
0.949227035,
0.5475658178,
-0.1911660284,
-0.5172162652,
-0.6364609599,
-0.3481544256,
-0.4134722054,
0.1890250891,
0.2335525602,
-0.9062812328,
0.6605911851,
0.116788879,
0.1318830252,
0.5118442178,
0.6085099578,
-0.1519709527,
0.981892705,
0.384732455,
-0.0109761106,
0.4666403234,
0.0476791561,
0.3317343593,
-0.744348526,
-0.0769251585,
-0.4692981243,
-0.3218839169,
-0.663210094,
-0.4443486333,
0.6611565351,
-0.0680608079,
0.0486538783,
0.1474730372,
-0.6055033207,
0.2355404198,
0.1606996953,
-0.0016882196,
0.2312209308,
0.2993594706,
0.228197068,
-0.036655087,
-0.4835607409,
-0.2243834287,
0.88338691,
0.2958700955,
0.7125977874,
0.2564691901,
0.5338326097,
0.8626122475,
0.7109851241,
-0.6994435191,
0.2997942567,
-0.0596268773,
-0.7300752997,
-0.0128113814,
-0.2268217057,
-0.7966222167,
0.0672656894,
0.0356250145,
-0.5326661468,
0.0868517309,
0.4108255208,
-0.3345318139,
0.8464428782,
-0.1045547798,
0.377664268,
0.0458356217,
-0.3815260828,
-0.7859700322,
-0.409227252,
0.2133985609,
-0.0989839956,
0.6378202438,
-0.0663523674,
0.0422138311,
0.9711155295,
-0.122207664,
0.8084700704,
-0.1212513894,
-0.0573810972,
0.539487958,
0.2852199376,
0.2725098133,
-0.3959980309,
-0.2760150135,
0.2808921933,
-0.4657616615,
-0.259554714,
-0.4298261702,
0.6341306567,
-0.8540616035,
-0.5520329475,
-0.1247842163,
-0.100349918,
0.2003744245,
0.0901659429,
0.5913456082,
0.6538312435,
-0.2437097281,
0.2671256065,
0.7916258574,
0.237564683,
0.1364347935,
0.0674525276,
-0.2651095688,
-0.5139112473,
0.8572251201,
0.4367017448,
0.3955790699,
-0.0130548049,
0.4466597736,
-0.158583805,
-0.433912456,
-0.374240458,
0.2137528509,
-0.3515549302,
-0.0786525309,
-0.9458671212,
-0.0561808981,
-0.3593535721,
-0.424547106,
-0.2412559688,
0.0422368571,
0.1193728521,
-0.0030387254,
0.2957752943,
1.3529822826,
-0.3168124557,
0.5395413041,
-0.2009788305,
0.1384614408,
0.4732030928,
0.3735421002,
0.1965991408,
-0.7894381285,
-0.3733845055,
-0.1039335504,
-0.3186722994,
-1.3522303104,
0.0385253504,
-0.2730174363,
0.2963111997,
0.8466579318,
0.2695012391,
0.6332336068,
-0.2613888085,
0.7872610688,
0.1388734281,
-0.4103792906,
0.3065383732,
-0.7200426459,
-0.3066749573,
0.3810971379,
0.8412289619,
-1.103274703,
-0.9813928604,
-1.0021439791,
-0.8114225268,
0.5533366203,
-0.0135615543,
0.3001123071,
-0.1544839442,
-0.2185009718,
0.1031698361,
0.5000219941,
-0.7156969309,
-0.5094640851,
-0.2030241936,
0.1178002432,
0.0716145858,
-0.4881227911,
-0.5314177275,
0.053805206,
0.6357828975,
0.3009550273,
0.1696553826,
0.148208499,
0.2043575048,
-0.6172158718,
0.1176272035,
0.3098768294,
0.3547191024,
-0.2050656527,
0.5488595366,
-0.5204084516,
-0.4167697728,
0.0772844926,
-0.3338858485,
-0.0526396558,
-0.0324691869,
0.1315521747,
0.4836603999,
0.0001429971,
-0.423266083,
0.7331804633,
0.0067330427,
-0.2173116952,
-0.6100051999,
0.1972322166,
-0.0599550903,
0.4011053145,
0.4264534712,
0.311850816,
0.1376560032,
-0.8259524107,
0.4678709507,
0.2305334657,
-0.6877911091,
-0.6837670803,
0.3648393452,
0.0454986803,
-0.5860902071,
0.3600438535,
-0.125235334,
-0.7945097685,
0.4240687191,
0.5542538166,
0.9067019224,
-0.3212251961,
0.3281378448,
0.4690463245,
0.3553391099,
0.297118932,
-0.2971330285,
-0.242386952,
-0.7656061649,
0.3628050685,
-0.6753026247,
-0.1826727837,
0.4099880457,
-0.6891384721,
0.0057599726,
-0.7546308637,
-0.2334504575,
0.2033851743,
-0.1065670773,
-0.3675974011,
-0.2172593772,
0.3703630567,
0.3625740707,
-1.0184415579,
-0.1207657978,
0.4884270132,
-0.1014160812,
-0.3845406473,
0.4576447606,
0.5333306193,
-0.6432988644,
0.3584394157,
0.2683475912,
-0.5302258134,
0.0487991385,
-0.5964449048,
-0.4771688581,
0.1801904589,
-0.2651849687,
-0.4014679193,
0.5159682631,
-0.0529428869,
0.8530427217,
-0.5123922229,
0.1782730669,
0.1016850024,
0.3849566877,
-0.1611937433,
-0.4799647629,
0.1475514323,
-0.3108983338,
-0.3875118196,
0.3713536561,
-0.8548250198,
0.8172305226,
0.084100008,
-0.3116542697,
-0.4432987273,
0.0655644462,
-0.1941440105,
0.3131075501,
0.8463553786,
0.4694240391,
0.3816357553,
0.379542172,
0.7587173581,
-0.1715613604,
-0.1837704927,
0.7636780739,
0.1600395441,
0.7677447796,
0.464466095,
0.1182491705,
0.869679451,
0.277818203,
-0.0494584516,
0.0454947501,
0.355589062,
-0.4648509622,
-0.2040275335,
-0.7990179658,
-0.2962886691,
0.2252673805,
0.5316337943,
-0.5463625193,
-0.1517905146,
0.0871567726,
0.3853590786,
0.2356247455,
-0.5482462645,
0.8328464627,
-0.1593868881,
-0.5134115219,
0.2145313621,
-0.3352066576,
0.5717212558,
-0.5384586453,
0.2438748628,
0.1460079104,
0.0759913251,
-0.2628613412,
-0.7713606954,
0.4815683663,
0.0221499056,
-0.2019436508,
-0.3810832798,
0.5774416924,
-0.3350248933,
0.2149918973,
0.9708321095,
0.3593680263,
0.2718353868,
-0.4030142128,
-0.5137174129,
0.4415071011,
-0.1117353737,
-0.1648682356,
0.3409382999,
0.105626002,
0.0971367583,
0.3502706587,
0.5800881386,
0.4719085097,
0.421448648,
0.1933043748,
1.1609623432,
-0.2840018868,
-0.4719466567,
-0.8822106123,
0.1270097196,
-0.3217042685,
-0.3901032507,
0.9586109519,
0.5169947147,
1.0733721256,
0.3235854506,
0.6930615902,
-0.2114797235,
0.8548582792,
0.2629828751,
0.8095595241,
-0.6139093041,
-0.0083504543,
-0.5045111775,
-0.699688673,
-0.1199086607,
0.1201641262,
-0.2144004107,
-0.2764573991,
0.0764242411,
1.0885722637,
-0.0079214294,
0.1149508283,
0.0990963206,
0.8882958889,
0.3171691298,
-0.0646309555,
1.0437253714,
-0.0800039023,
0.7322411537,
-0.2577150762,
-0.4095963538,
-0.6137740016,
-0.13329117,
-0.7729389071,
-0.5683841705,
-0.0432858132,
-0.4843585193,
0.2889998853,
0.921513319,
0.5813478231,
-0.5369818807,
-0.4835541844,
0.102738142,
0.439712286,
-0.5114902854,
-0.3406373262,
-0.2542058229,
-0.0520983264,
-0.7143459916,
0.0189381726,
0.4086037576,
-0.2656973004,
-0.4181144238,
0.1965544075,
-0.1199231669,
0.5449612737,
0.5254198313,
0.2284701467,
-0.6083011627,
-0.0029631061,
-0.228965044,
-0.2454508543,
-0.009427622,
0.9729493856,
-0.3727841377,
0.491630286,
0.4634297788,
0.4817224443,
0.0622630864,
0.4066435695,
0.2278261632,
-0.5583666563,
-0.1553258598,
0.4890957475,
-0.2333516777,
0.0943492949,
-0.389390111,
-0.0358356424,
0.5146509409,
-0.6450452805,
-0.9669005871,
0.2928975224,
-0.6213856339,
-0.2645077109,
0.9313796759,
0.4772218466,
-0.1140633225,
-0.4122875035,
-0.1417722702,
0.4281319082,
-0.6801920533,
1.1867355108,
0.6147803664,
-0.5461429954,
-0.0662337616,
-0.4618237913,
0.7354117632,
0.3403221071,
-0.5342382193,
0.2183727473,
0.4171939194,
-0.0241324995,
0.6777733564,
0.5878272057,
-0.015432003,
-0.052453015,
0.2107267976,
-0.3915047646,
0.2395955771,
-0.5838246942,
-0.2223591208,
0.7260749936,
-0.4332981408,
0.1614045054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02463v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02463v3 | Nationality Bias in Text Generation | 2023-02-05T19:15:33 | 2023-02-14T21:34:34 | Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Sanjana Gautam, Ruchi Panchanadikar, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang, Shomir Wilson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Little attention is placed on analyzing nationality bias in language models,
especially when nationality is highly used as a factor in increasing the
performance of social NLP models. This paper examines how a text generation
model, GPT-2, accentuates pre-existing societal biases about country-based
demonyms. We generate stories using GPT-2 for various nationalities and use
sensitivity analysis to explore how the number of internet users and the
country's economic status impacts the sentiment of the stories. To reduce the
propagation of biases through large language models (LLM), we explore the
debiasing method of adversarial triggering. Our results show that GPT-2
demonstrates significant bias against countries with lower internet users, and
adversarial triggering effectively reduces the same. | [
-0.3806085587,
-0.6476305127,
0.3271664381,
0.1507055163,
-0.3402860165,
0.1577182114,
-0.2673674822,
-0.4328163862,
0.1439174563,
0.6797099113,
-0.4768308103,
-0.1839129478,
-0.8468456864,
0.1164838523,
-0.0571023114,
1.4518784285,
0.1653984934,
-0.1051905379,
0.1332687289,
0.1272299886,
-0.0472234711,
-0.8491163254,
-0.6787228584,
-0.5647910237,
0.3750992715,
0.2019996941,
0.9034896493,
0.1763436347,
0.3175810575,
0.156128183,
0.0021000225,
-0.1022341624,
-0.6017043591,
0.1903679669,
-0.317325294,
-0.5800575614,
-0.1086581573,
0.0408605225,
0.2305674553,
0.0975025371,
0.3621554077,
0.2869802117,
0.1878015846,
0.7153089643,
-0.2941958308,
0.0165429488,
-0.8842307329,
-0.1343138665,
-0.283785373,
-0.183874473,
-0.2805962265,
-0.5433525443,
0.2220576257,
-0.0776171088,
0.8259826303,
-0.4134826064,
0.5359033942,
0.2907461226,
-0.8334918618,
-0.4086679518,
-0.5770606399,
0.7659252286,
-0.3953756392,
-0.135321781,
0.3709157109,
-0.0489163101,
0.0353709422,
-0.2946950197,
-0.4190540612,
-0.0631845221,
-0.0166675244,
0.1343068033,
-0.0776650161,
-0.3088865876,
0.3853181899,
-0.0247337557,
-0.6053302884,
0.0251430031,
-0.5894999504,
-0.0431974083,
0.7835757732,
-0.1406242698,
0.4945236146,
-0.4488404393,
-0.4479691982,
0.0982608572,
-0.9994628429,
-0.1802974045,
1.2255092859,
0.3512637913,
-0.1713596284,
0.5581368208,
-0.0973448008,
0.2468821257,
0.1125789881,
0.157868579,
0.1463665366,
-0.0169110708,
0.2759158313,
0.272079289,
0.71792382,
0.8330298066,
0.6565333009,
0.0617214106,
0.007256452,
0.3599103391,
0.2579734623,
-1.0406631231,
0.0124968272,
0.0780768543,
-0.4397343099,
-0.5231556296,
0.0303486865,
-1.0560503006,
-0.6234433651,
0.1430585235,
-0.0813315287,
-0.0163087882,
-0.462638855,
-0.1902938932,
-0.3919368982,
0.1396945566,
-0.100593254,
-1.2798041105,
0.1682133079,
0.7555312514,
0.780012548,
-0.1279858947,
0.0441570282,
-0.1236774623,
-0.1497600675,
-0.3399216831,
0.7267585397,
-0.3117848933,
-0.5779266953,
0.133753255,
-0.3096943498,
0.2110279948,
-0.3304324448,
0.3902979493,
-0.5497990251,
0.4420697689,
-0.7474909425,
0.041528631,
-0.0051392009,
0.0642565563,
-0.5862685442,
0.9137582183,
0.3010035157,
-1.2663174868,
0.8191870451,
-0.5316853523,
-0.5776544809,
-0.0404650867,
-0.1939160228,
-0.1911555529,
0.3201241195,
0.2289746255,
0.2085601836,
-0.530602634,
0.5968424082,
-0.183269918,
-0.1251673698,
0.1346006989,
-0.750107944,
1.0896661282,
0.3545602262,
-0.6446954012,
-0.4249273539,
-0.348770231,
-0.3399815261,
0.3196962774,
-0.1738485843,
-0.5586723685,
0.0427461974,
0.2908926904,
0.6409397125,
0.124683015,
-0.5879707336,
0.1859273165,
-0.4906271994,
0.4857571721,
0.5771906972,
0.3126792312,
0.1620131433,
-0.2026910037,
0.612800777,
0.0415764675,
0.0138751287,
0.2321939617,
-0.5984928012,
-0.4740640223,
0.2497314066,
0.0508510917,
0.6404096484,
-1.229293108,
0.0969403163,
-0.2024759054,
-0.2496907264,
-0.2835389078,
0.1377265006,
0.4580385089,
0.3888394833,
-0.0028329622,
-0.1205356345,
-0.4100011885,
-1.1359734535,
-0.6531473994,
-0.5336859822,
-0.246561572,
0.3179906309,
0.5120481253,
-0.0332826003,
1.0715472698,
-0.5764561296,
0.0260847341,
-0.4652873576,
0.209599182,
-0.2001330107,
0.1959923506,
0.7799370289,
-1.0059212446,
-0.8046281338,
-0.2473493814,
-0.6150152087,
-0.3217884302,
-0.095279783,
-0.0952839926,
0.6040109992,
0.0275063626,
-0.6880964637,
0.2503522038,
0.5259771943,
-0.5627165437,
0.4361347854,
0.1303761899,
0.2226555347,
-1.4001277685,
-0.0454041511,
0.4345269799,
0.1227167323,
-0.7420049906,
-0.0057301908,
-0.0486259796,
0.0538209938,
-0.5111242533,
0.6821891069,
-0.2388840467,
0.0639998764,
-0.2984016538,
0.1481641382,
0.0778805912,
-0.0293778647,
0.2306490541,
0.8946654797,
0.1351417005,
-0.1249349192,
0.1815233827,
0.1635512859,
-0.3774039447,
0.602781117,
-0.5551921725,
0.1321054995,
-0.2315586209,
0.4802323282,
-0.6812509894,
-0.3903644383,
0.0994653851,
-0.5802070498,
0.2209998369,
-0.3459349573,
-0.4720174372,
-0.6094059348,
-0.352428019,
0.2372816652,
0.6504364014,
-0.4890825748,
0.0027423098,
0.2695274055,
-0.5035398602,
-0.6227452159,
-0.8421579599,
0.2800361812,
-0.6264485121,
-0.6500986814,
0.1308411509,
0.2677092552,
-0.7129845023,
-0.1798639297,
0.2063494325,
0.1684981585,
-0.0312284213,
-0.0681586638,
0.065870069,
0.0706702247,
0.016528191,
0.2873188257,
-0.1416736692,
0.3071428239,
-0.3208244145,
0.6661127806,
0.2983814776,
0.0900785476,
-0.1607651711,
0.3574398458,
0.3101011813,
-0.0932645351,
0.6803523898,
0.4551441669,
-0.0643548071,
-0.2808018029,
-0.5211533904,
-0.4103516638,
-0.4279049337,
0.6316619515,
-0.2556074262,
-0.7511568069,
0.527251482,
0.3148404658,
-0.179104656,
0.7154373527,
0.7932075858,
0.5517585278,
1.0665253401,
0.5331306458,
-0.3390953541,
0.1266332716,
-0.088151589,
0.2697684467,
-0.7322548032,
0.0041826107,
-0.6757751107,
-0.0743362382,
-1.0423232317,
-0.2533367276,
0.0549877919,
-0.2307068408,
-0.3709437549,
0.0603918843,
-0.5388429761,
0.5586311817,
0.5064014792,
-0.042210035,
0.0038263036,
0.357275039,
0.1899438351,
-0.2525192499,
-0.4797877967,
-0.7167604566,
1.3005297184,
0.2643742859,
0.6232264638,
0.1650957018,
0.59748137,
0.4674912989,
0.5025852323,
-0.3974320292,
0.18922472,
-0.5713038445,
-1.1050391197,
-0.0117177116,
-0.4637119472,
-0.5305138826,
0.1657868624,
0.1182753295,
-0.8974475265,
0.0279536285,
0.1904505342,
-0.2235494107,
0.2981456816,
-0.4772883058,
0.3540148735,
-0.1819242239,
-0.4848941565,
0.0856646895,
-0.4856324196,
0.7223786712,
-0.2411523908,
0.1392473131,
-0.0745214671,
0.174161315,
0.4749250412,
-0.276388526,
0.9018208981,
-0.4380433559,
-0.333206743,
0.4004199505,
0.1369304061,
0.5587162375,
0.2315234393,
-0.4335973859,
0.2527885437,
-0.6162795424,
-0.3193908036,
-0.1164449006,
0.9458273649,
-0.9565819502,
-0.7647157907,
-0.2346964031,
-0.5098427534,
-0.0456626117,
-0.0961645767,
0.8793113232,
0.2828659117,
-0.2005510628,
0.1554177105,
0.3960591853,
-0.4025342166,
0.2607028782,
0.1599116027,
-0.0486101583,
-0.3090978563,
0.6570067406,
0.4640296996,
0.5318534374,
-0.0128245167,
0.2206498981,
-0.43230322,
-0.035958197,
-0.7366500497,
0.0315722227,
-0.5543643832,
0.1042962596,
-0.7702419758,
-0.0148557695,
-0.5070468783,
-0.2745123208,
-0.2146108299,
-0.2917651534,
-0.185401693,
-0.3054918349,
0.344942987,
0.6253000498,
-0.0555193909,
0.748048842,
-0.1037133485,
0.5488422513,
0.3412186503,
0.1731628478,
-0.2386017144,
-0.610329628,
-0.0937151536,
0.0230741389,
-0.4427593648,
-0.98347646,
0.3393334746,
-0.2154727429,
0.2066481262,
0.3623290956,
0.2281731367,
-0.0608503371,
-0.3175683022,
1.2474668026,
0.0158687215,
-0.7457897663,
0.4695951939,
-0.8236760497,
0.2813192606,
0.5075334311,
0.3939559758,
-0.5908674598,
-0.7337975502,
-0.6794954538,
-0.972224772,
0.7653523684,
0.1195700541,
0.666786015,
-0.2960538864,
0.3330737054,
0.3835535645,
0.1703386605,
-0.9992238879,
-0.3268823326,
-0.2992067337,
-0.1391183734,
-0.3041372001,
-0.6494094729,
0.0588342994,
0.3103487492,
0.8628855348,
-0.1479614228,
-0.0292816069,
0.297765851,
-0.0753635541,
-0.2025060952,
0.1246456578,
0.5183423162,
0.6325844526,
0.0707683936,
0.0539213307,
-0.1624815315,
-0.5636630058,
0.3918787837,
0.0955770016,
-0.9396221042,
-0.0202876925,
0.1517658681,
0.7641716599,
-0.4262222052,
0.0832499787,
0.3731113672,
-0.0807707533,
-0.4443112016,
-0.1354836226,
0.0198790673,
0.0738797039,
0.064610973,
0.6226323843,
-0.1116579697,
0.1477117687,
-0.442823559,
0.0038226692,
0.6532371044,
-0.3857866824,
-0.3925146461,
1.0395213366,
0.4297581911,
-0.3300285935,
0.4263334274,
-0.3800718784,
-0.8456293344,
0.9955378175,
0.8674640059,
1.0636261702,
-0.3017095923,
0.7112330794,
0.3551923931,
0.7100143433,
-0.1884312481,
0.268322885,
0.2770957351,
-0.7433453798,
-0.2515141964,
-0.4394386113,
-0.030180024,
0.2295328826,
-0.52370435,
0.2135349661,
-0.2318007648,
-0.5175850987,
-0.1525324881,
0.3190150857,
-0.7166437507,
0.289847821,
0.3274540007,
0.5135577917,
-1.2737408876,
0.6337642074,
0.3940934837,
-0.184094429,
-0.2090765089,
0.5334017873,
0.4452443421,
-0.363206476,
0.8264770508,
0.4660615027,
0.0288440231,
0.0734819472,
-0.3127219081,
-0.7292438745,
0.513073802,
0.3528009951,
-0.2168358713,
0.306674391,
0.5396077633,
0.5880134702,
-0.3047544956,
0.1226788238,
0.7438817024,
0.477665633,
-0.4326719642,
-0.5415578485,
0.1249480844,
-0.0893319249,
0.2905046642,
0.2186512798,
-1.0417387486,
0.9373167157,
-0.1048639938,
-0.0611742027,
-0.3173997998,
0.0271297451,
0.146730274,
0.2750252783,
0.289991498,
0.2236466408,
0.3144636154,
-0.0546231195,
1.0611948967,
-0.436417073,
0.2606626451,
0.9504626393,
-0.578550458,
0.194781065,
0.3225409687,
-0.1466208994,
0.4717116654,
0.5653711557,
-0.0055380152,
0.3783866763,
0.2851645947,
-0.3735456169,
0.209643051,
-0.0817389339,
-0.4820816815,
0.6438729763,
0.1134054139,
-0.6831874847,
-0.2208842039,
0.0254181065,
0.4805851281,
0.1779648364,
-0.2376174033,
0.7826830149,
0.0560500324,
-0.936285615,
0.1086023748,
0.0562263913,
0.8313576579,
-0.3776520789,
0.3920793533,
-0.6120895743,
0.0433310531,
-0.1780340523,
-0.4969854653,
0.2604441941,
0.6449453235,
-0.6432944536,
-0.0690737143,
0.787039876,
-0.3546672463,
-0.670758009,
0.3522771001,
0.5223395228,
0.1001247764,
-0.3330652118,
-0.6182332635,
-0.1946524233,
0.3560885787,
-0.8799387217,
0.4764060378,
0.3851116598,
-0.3330906332,
0.3589093089,
0.5588641167,
0.1291885823,
-0.2972441614,
0.1677069813,
0.5107249618,
-0.5253233314,
-0.5262261629,
-1.2584744692,
0.4018259645,
-0.2538375854,
-0.2890523076,
0.8629137278,
0.6782304049,
0.771186173,
-0.0148094837,
1.4291946888,
-0.2680297494,
0.3958429992,
-0.2794695795,
1.1159164906,
-0.1995463073,
0.0628058538,
-0.2175705731,
-1.1276829243,
-0.1053618789,
0.1852253675,
-0.65871346,
0.3949073851,
0.3798235953,
0.6845145822,
0.2350687683,
-0.1028450429,
-0.0037010605,
0.1485817134,
0.3262090683,
0.2452180684,
0.5791066289,
-0.1310292035,
0.3509038091,
-0.3708344996,
-0.1953613162,
-0.0380320475,
-0.9059882164,
-0.85788697,
-0.2685331702,
-0.1196316853,
-0.6212022901,
0.1118274331,
0.754285872,
0.3831834793,
-0.4874252975,
-0.059689153,
0.17223382,
0.104017809,
0.3108561039,
-0.2976494431,
0.4513927698,
-0.291637361,
-0.7961716056,
-0.2008717954,
-0.1378677487,
-0.0655483231,
-0.6212441325,
0.2313671559,
0.2334767729,
0.2455768287,
0.7067970037,
-0.0727755874,
-0.5786859393,
-0.2736236751,
-0.2757001817,
-0.1374587119,
-0.1113409027,
0.7837680578,
-0.6648225188,
0.378154844,
0.3326697648,
-0.0086791534,
0.1968199015,
0.4818385541,
0.659793973,
-0.8215996623,
0.406871736,
-0.0227981657,
-0.1330210418,
0.5870161057,
-0.8165783882,
0.520426631,
0.217438072,
-0.7286435962,
-0.6856248975,
0.3494062126,
-0.1019755453,
-0.4145467281,
1.5388655663,
0.0868339017,
0.0869412273,
-0.1795192808,
-0.3126758337,
0.2759257853,
-0.4891214073,
1.2085763216,
0.7810516357,
0.2301122099,
0.2222633809,
-0.9412468672,
0.8359286785,
0.0505561009,
-0.7628731132,
0.2791406214,
0.6273635626,
0.3582893312,
-0.0906679407,
0.6635795832,
-0.0718500614,
0.0170099828,
0.3226718605,
0.1237697825,
0.2152501345,
-0.2866592109,
-0.1576200128,
0.1843357086,
-0.0915246308,
0.3676843941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02453v1 | FineDeb: A Debiasing Framework for Language Models | 2023-02-05T18:35:21 | 2023-02-05T18:35:21 | Akash Saravanan, Dhruv Mullick, Habibur Rahman, Nidhi Hegde | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | As language models are increasingly included in human-facing machine learning
tools, bias against demographic subgroups has gained attention. We propose
FineDeb, a two-phase debiasing framework for language models that starts with
contextual debiasing of embeddings learned by pretrained language models. The
model is then fine-tuned on a language modeling objective. Our results show
that FineDeb offers stronger debiasing in comparison to other methods which
often result in models as biased as the original language model. Our framework
is generalizable for demographics with multiple classes, and we demonstrate its
effectiveness through extensive experiments and comparisons with state of the
art techniques. We release our code and data on GitHub. | [
-0.408904314,
-0.8033584356,
0.3225637674,
0.5096966028,
-0.2042942345,
-0.2156211585,
-0.1081233993,
-0.1951975822,
-0.0730832368,
0.7313522696,
-0.3726348281,
-0.6329638958,
-0.6205963492,
-0.2500354648,
-0.3769313991,
0.8009458184,
0.3098502457,
0.722501874,
-0.3691763282,
-0.0604963191,
-0.4992755949,
-0.3361386657,
-0.561216712,
-0.5674853325,
0.2655146718,
0.5652902722,
0.7215563655,
0.5361801386,
0.3753853738,
0.2012201697,
0.0736157224,
-0.4994151294,
-0.6708889008,
0.2776248753,
-0.2027782649,
-0.5495705009,
-0.4100354016,
0.1338667423,
0.2635302842,
0.9304922223,
-0.1826092899,
0.2815733552,
0.0362567417,
0.6717480421,
-0.8355534673,
0.2613184154,
-0.7261943221,
-0.301288873,
-0.2407159507,
-0.1916911304,
-0.6388426423,
-0.5449261665,
0.4178732932,
-0.1124411151,
0.3837670684,
0.1353585124,
0.5533989072,
0.583529532,
-0.8447596431,
-0.1663762033,
-0.4437544346,
1.0945509672,
-0.6193658113,
0.6914886832,
0.8572279215,
0.0826114342,
-0.0513994135,
-0.3840719163,
-0.2236020565,
-0.2895310819,
0.0210241172,
-0.2348190397,
-0.0943330601,
0.0789484084,
-0.0971257016,
0.1147527918,
-0.4205380976,
0.3071751595,
-0.5009201169,
0.0456019454,
0.5206724405,
-0.2396099865,
0.4531836808,
-0.2866284251,
-0.6121606231,
-0.0164391641,
-0.8056788445,
-0.2018672079,
0.8095979691,
0.4374925792,
-0.3009916246,
0.3083383441,
-0.038867604,
0.5959672332,
0.3035088181,
0.1557373852,
0.4352736771,
0.2636756897,
-0.1145526171,
0.1944306493,
0.3953246474,
0.6437122226,
0.500177443,
-0.2622371912,
-0.1920883954,
0.0774180368,
0.3239575028,
-1.0899045467,
-0.2910817564,
0.3404030502,
-0.3964795768,
-0.6435716152,
-0.1528111696,
-1.0612663031,
-0.8433137536,
-0.4148642123,
-0.0739762634,
-0.1277718097,
-0.3151955307,
0.0137950424,
-0.3008269668,
0.1761503667,
0.1317414939,
-1.1163345575,
0.259975493,
0.5952187777,
0.5163841248,
-0.0797097161,
-0.1170033813,
-0.33938393,
-0.0206128955,
-0.3937002718,
0.8772970438,
-0.6749030948,
-0.4366655648,
0.0140084596,
-0.3910511732,
0.2611294389,
-0.675947547,
0.3624690473,
-0.7896835208,
-0.0982773826,
-0.2090840489,
-0.3343877494,
-0.3682285547,
-0.0206772592,
-0.9579399228,
0.9082261324,
0.3733832538,
-0.76832515,
0.9934140444,
-0.2004649639,
-0.4024041593,
-0.1330387592,
-0.0979702622,
-0.5111553669,
0.1259558201,
0.1830773652,
0.2501247525,
-0.6640342474,
0.8500454426,
-1.0121337175,
-0.1088261008,
0.0551542491,
-0.3841796815,
1.3199533224,
0.3479292095,
-0.5241733193,
0.1082336083,
-0.6820875406,
-0.182878688,
-0.1132503897,
-0.2133217156,
-0.8916484118,
0.499339819,
0.3214817643,
0.2091853321,
-0.0541730411,
-0.435773015,
0.047772456,
-0.3940143287,
0.400832206,
0.8697901964,
-0.0054782047,
0.6643149853,
-0.1146464348,
0.3839752376,
0.1037626043,
-0.13603957,
0.2950739264,
0.0992018357,
-0.6533059478,
-0.5134371519,
0.4637836516,
0.5860096216,
-0.3675633371,
0.4346831441,
-0.1572865397,
-0.3848295808,
-0.4070285261,
0.4632086158,
0.344253391,
0.178277269,
0.3728529513,
-0.2259077877,
-0.9352980256,
-1.1585006714,
-0.2705310881,
-0.1079970524,
-0.0885000452,
0.2163743973,
0.4923537672,
-0.6203224063,
1.024409771,
-0.4728635252,
-0.4225352705,
-0.3563014865,
0.2113794237,
-0.2576996386,
0.7089497447,
1.051404357,
-1.0350996256,
-0.3836446702,
-0.4708161056,
-0.4155046642,
-0.5876055956,
0.0729568675,
-0.2264890969,
0.3054400086,
0.6999482512,
0.1582040489,
0.218824774,
0.7179313302,
-0.6253666878,
0.2941646576,
0.2797990143,
-0.0424987003,
-0.864934504,
0.0050900662,
0.2033569664,
-0.4254617989,
-0.4542504251,
0.0330112167,
-0.1350846589,
0.076430127,
-0.3858449161,
0.700853169,
-0.3822963536,
0.1816660613,
-0.2922203839,
0.2758485675,
-0.0803198293,
0.5103774667,
-0.2103314549,
0.5642120838,
0.6995321512,
-0.7311528325,
0.2008720487,
0.2157807499,
-0.7013155818,
0.636567831,
-0.8764815927,
0.0622939318,
-0.5259138942,
0.2122749984,
-0.8387001157,
-0.2340819538,
-0.1357515752,
-0.2125400603,
0.4232444763,
-0.3756859601,
0.0064263521,
-0.2734873295,
-0.3704660237,
0.6772267222,
0.4083888829,
-0.4369419813,
0.3871855736,
1.0090551376,
-0.2707614303,
-0.5840575695,
-0.7812278867,
-0.320381552,
-0.2410199791,
-0.3324707448,
0.2643558681,
0.0614341944,
-0.6644053459,
0.1422572285,
-0.2071599513,
-0.5731703639,
0.3333173096,
0.172618717,
0.255861342,
0.0084697306,
0.0536951236,
0.0737573206,
-0.1435161531,
-0.1216396689,
-0.4103668332,
0.7963696122,
-0.0063902736,
-0.1472388655,
-0.1117442921,
0.1678390503,
0.5922647119,
-0.0842830241,
0.592291832,
0.324087888,
-0.291038096,
-0.2383081913,
-0.6441190243,
-0.1754975766,
-0.4676836431,
0.7211461663,
-0.1711599827,
-0.781652689,
0.4372853935,
0.2641693652,
0.0937438086,
0.2574734986,
0.9483217001,
0.2332135886,
1.1634927988,
0.7786986232,
-0.3360603154,
0.668536067,
-0.0534882657,
0.0440441705,
-0.5473855138,
-0.0218717679,
-0.7004894614,
-0.4088406563,
-0.6967833042,
-0.4018889964,
-0.0741094276,
0.2280266583,
-0.4113659859,
0.2986115813,
-0.019766802,
0.4993931651,
0.8240972757,
0.1752317548,
-0.2004774362,
-0.212170139,
0.0415418744,
0.0352191143,
-0.386849016,
-0.6265869141,
1.2762137651,
0.2956859767,
1.0370301008,
0.2551992238,
0.5595898628,
0.7635261416,
0.5965307951,
-0.6773414612,
0.2581133842,
-0.4331991673,
-1.4012205601,
-0.3251361251,
-0.4845638275,
-0.7045226693,
0.5352140069,
-0.0541958548,
-0.8226464987,
0.5171441436,
0.5462933183,
-0.1514846832,
0.1447821707,
-0.5390620232,
1.0283889771,
-0.133845225,
-0.5522156954,
-0.5306153893,
-0.390368849,
0.6175882816,
-0.1369825751,
0.4535040259,
-0.5572305918,
0.3041197062,
0.8666012287,
-0.2592224181,
1.1483334303,
-0.4399800301,
-0.3170877695,
0.4401960075,
0.3243662417,
0.15552333,
0.1206331849,
-0.4119976163,
0.3031942844,
0.2514902651,
-0.6055403352,
-0.3061598241,
0.7713603973,
-0.6113653779,
-0.5431509614,
-0.1825644225,
-0.5328345895,
-0.3346013427,
0.3776000738,
-0.0811322182,
0.7465682626,
-0.4864685237,
0.5601707101,
0.3087796867,
-0.1969970018,
0.1309639961,
0.4408223033,
-0.2057514191,
-0.4392407238,
0.5535162687,
-0.2231629193,
0.2965959609,
0.213470608,
0.2503993511,
-0.1586663723,
-0.1216948181,
-0.3602774739,
-0.2110159248,
-0.6476374269,
-0.0957318768,
-0.5947099924,
0.5296341181,
-0.7361109853,
-0.1759703755,
-0.4680860341,
-0.3232810795,
0.1218698919,
-0.1732719839,
-0.2239958942,
0.5476617217,
-0.0285768043,
0.4601999819,
-0.4498211741,
0.4722847641,
0.2798339128,
0.5000209212,
-0.0048711202,
-0.3598040938,
-0.0370560251,
0.1634763032,
-0.2405675501,
-0.9979287386,
0.1870778352,
0.0554441176,
0.5652945042,
0.8318147659,
0.2603575885,
0.442702651,
-0.5890136361,
0.458089292,
-0.0105105303,
-1.0487571955,
0.158468008,
-0.3312924504,
-0.1628254205,
1.0397716761,
0.2281233966,
-0.4498890638,
-0.4897811115,
-0.3266277909,
-1.0524449348,
0.8375766277,
-0.2608119249,
0.3070032597,
-0.2056912929,
0.011245816,
0.2144745737,
0.482767731,
-0.8189382553,
-0.2914851308,
-0.0868396014,
-0.4466827214,
0.0293568037,
-0.8605621457,
0.0910427421,
-0.1779213101,
0.9044888616,
-0.0215762258,
-0.1350436062,
-0.137754634,
-0.6393343806,
-0.1360255927,
0.3644668758,
0.5863752961,
0.7456587553,
-0.4193334281,
0.3069914281,
0.1249580383,
-0.5057597756,
0.2324808985,
-0.0605502501,
-0.6193902493,
-0.2363795787,
0.3843680024,
1.0442974567,
0.6473109126,
-0.6434692144,
0.5284535885,
0.326608032,
-0.0959803537,
-0.1663580835,
-0.0407965071,
-0.2563102543,
0.0967715532,
0.1396845132,
-0.0264331587,
0.2534873486,
-0.5308053493,
0.393786937,
0.4897601306,
-0.7265524864,
-0.3085429072,
0.9101966619,
0.660158515,
0.1499371827,
0.3587670922,
-0.249504596,
-0.8272218108,
0.6347672939,
0.6175415516,
1.1663131714,
-0.362241745,
0.1172121093,
0.3840297759,
0.3190946281,
-0.1323157996,
0.0494700409,
-0.0054919729,
-0.7909564376,
-0.1649625152,
-0.8515408039,
-0.2149549574,
-0.1231388673,
-0.7793571353,
0.6010276675,
-0.3158648908,
-0.3659913838,
-0.1542471498,
-0.2684175372,
-0.7029027939,
0.1234081089,
0.2176216841,
0.7243383527,
-0.807179749,
0.6233330965,
0.6328137517,
-0.3914951682,
-0.24707371,
0.2045377642,
0.237852335,
-0.8137035966,
1.1086108685,
0.2465670854,
-0.2259976864,
0.1886838973,
-0.5137514472,
-0.987742722,
0.4620679319,
0.3928775191,
-0.4374715388,
-0.1320843548,
-0.3272371888,
0.0868997723,
-0.1923513412,
0.1765664816,
0.7900986075,
0.5755150318,
-0.2654140294,
-0.5353409052,
-0.0426127426,
0.0856692269,
-0.0727114081,
0.2315239608,
-0.4390622675,
0.8930265903,
-0.3685735762,
-0.2325945199,
-0.3457121849,
0.5847246051,
-0.0828617141,
0.1563412845,
0.8420507908,
0.3656846583,
0.7373048663,
-0.039489571,
0.8538228273,
-0.5261836052,
0.5636867881,
1.3165044785,
-0.4500501156,
0.4513253868,
0.3759582341,
-0.2556302547,
0.8305389285,
0.3669023216,
0.033638753,
0.7584374547,
0.3852636814,
0.1719433516,
-0.3649240434,
0.10106235,
-0.1224739999,
0.6663642526,
0.0257542133,
-0.2304428816,
-0.4510935843,
0.1177947968,
0.3967729211,
-0.0436838083,
-0.1438850313,
0.6066279411,
0.1699199677,
-0.623634994,
0.4555931687,
0.2807362974,
0.6318103075,
-0.5000568032,
0.2407844812,
-0.0972957015,
0.4827907383,
-0.0162402447,
-0.2525716424,
0.2728402913,
0.1367116868,
-0.4560969472,
-0.2008237541,
0.5298342109,
-0.6598610282,
-0.4808128178,
0.3942548931,
0.2801530063,
-0.1070098281,
-0.0154002625,
-0.4919261336,
0.0290302467,
0.1268782467,
-0.5581766963,
-0.0267118458,
0.0983944759,
-0.3080632389,
0.7890512347,
0.4198219478,
0.0271996055,
-0.0393325686,
0.5744122267,
0.3814283013,
-0.6731419563,
-0.6492257118,
-1.2005187273,
0.2371147424,
-0.0784400553,
-0.1651243269,
0.7528295517,
0.5729627013,
0.9080597162,
-0.0705521256,
0.8360862732,
-0.310942173,
0.2962529957,
-0.3745611012,
0.7995870709,
-0.5477758646,
0.0754765645,
-0.3576936424,
-0.8849256635,
-0.3823324144,
0.6995541453,
-0.5508360863,
0.1908656061,
0.5790697932,
0.6948657036,
0.0851007178,
-0.1482757777,
0.1060648933,
0.0856934935,
0.3967578709,
0.3185732961,
0.2115589529,
-0.0364905819,
0.1776660234,
-0.2662897408,
-0.43342188,
-0.5980531573,
-0.8819781542,
-1.3809893131,
-0.4674716294,
-0.2333340347,
-0.2184633613,
0.0164398737,
1.2492291927,
0.8492759466,
-1.2057785988,
-0.1603713483,
-0.014370827,
0.2809239328,
-0.0650215745,
-0.2252049744,
0.2431399226,
-0.6552549005,
-1.0771926641,
0.0248246919,
-0.1112524271,
-0.0569195822,
-0.5184631348,
0.1076721549,
-0.1399102062,
0.3060209453,
0.4978103042,
-0.0816009343,
-0.4672487676,
-0.261582315,
-0.3674760163,
-0.50984025,
-0.2578570545,
1.1320168972,
-0.6142866015,
0.3443297446,
0.5987280607,
0.5025105476,
0.2035996765,
0.2421828061,
0.7879408002,
-0.7173156142,
0.7201600671,
0.0673693269,
0.5900993347,
0.2853029072,
-0.1240834445,
0.4815187156,
0.1244849637,
-0.3513486385,
-1.077991724,
0.4566922188,
-0.5476151705,
-0.5927188396,
1.3423302174,
0.3782333434,
-0.1606842726,
-0.1756098568,
-0.2698231041,
0.3991203308,
-0.3503083885,
0.9021399021,
0.6734220982,
0.5134933591,
0.4110843837,
-0.6430726647,
0.4647906423,
0.4920246303,
-0.5091316104,
0.4279789031,
0.7884408236,
0.4895456731,
-0.204479754,
0.5616807938,
-0.0375542082,
0.1366923451,
0.1537375897,
0.4729943275,
-0.1381032169,
-0.3851252198,
-0.0639266595,
-0.0336462669,
0.1442922652,
-0.0331105255
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.