id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17580v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17580v4 | HuggingGPT: Solving AI Tasks with ChatGPT and its Friends in Hugging Face | 2023-03-30T17:48:28 | 2023-12-03T18:17:21 | Yongliang Shen, Kaitao Song, Xu Tan, Dongsheng Li, Weiming Lu, Yueting Zhuang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Solving complicated AI tasks with different domains and modalities is a key
step toward artificial general intelligence. While there are numerous AI models
available for various domains and modalities, they cannot handle complicated AI
tasks autonomously. Considering large language models (LLMs) have exhibited
exceptional abilities in language understanding, generation, interaction, and
reasoning, we advocate that LLMs could act as a controller to manage existing
AI models to solve complicated AI tasks, with language serving as a generic
interface to empower this. Based on this philosophy, we present HuggingGPT, an
LLM-powered agent that leverages LLMs (e.g., ChatGPT) to connect various AI
models in machine learning communities (e.g., Hugging Face) to solve AI tasks.
Specifically, we use ChatGPT to conduct task planning when receiving a user
request, select models according to their function descriptions available in
Hugging Face, execute each subtask with the selected AI model, and summarize
the response according to the execution results. By leveraging the strong
language capability of ChatGPT and abundant AI models in Hugging Face,
HuggingGPT can tackle a wide range of sophisticated AI tasks spanning different
modalities and domains and achieve impressive results in language, vision,
speech, and other challenging tasks, which paves a new way towards the
realization of artificial general intelligence. | [
-0.5608612299,
-0.9786029458,
0.5604438186,
0.3861933947,
-0.0745147467,
0.3017199039,
-0.2491043359,
-0.5312691331,
0.4237235487,
0.3129024804,
-0.8032565117,
-0.2843912542,
-0.8523606062,
-0.2183509916,
-0.2630457878,
1.3312220573,
-0.1266733259,
-0.2065134645,
-0.3452915549,
-0.0249661207,
-0.2682272196,
-0.6605350971,
-0.8568980694,
-0.8538100123,
0.4610563219,
0.0790862814,
1.0075964928,
0.3580483198,
0.5525984168,
0.470466435,
0.0825314447,
0.1214808598,
-0.2704144716,
0.0272792913,
-0.1512023509,
-0.3810530901,
-0.9640414715,
0.1786891222,
0.3326041996,
0.4159758389,
-0.2042463869,
-0.103248328,
0.1539643705,
0.4619533718,
0.0800229162,
0.588948369,
-0.4974234998,
-0.1653800607,
0.0580976307,
0.2155292779,
-0.0073906332,
-0.1917264611,
0.1712788343,
-0.5560442805,
-0.0125537468,
-0.1208654866,
0.8376685977,
0.5928149819,
-0.2108070254,
-0.1631328315,
-0.5519296527,
0.4487289786,
-0.3566023111,
0.1553046852,
0.3384772837,
0.4595729411,
-0.3145785332,
-0.6837819219,
-0.6764630079,
-0.5960726738,
0.0626600981,
-0.09643621,
-0.3580236733,
0.3404317498,
0.140758574,
0.0982130691,
-0.5528290272,
0.0132678943,
-0.0863006935,
-0.2186784148,
0.7691492438,
-0.0517036468,
0.7298775315,
0.0957271829,
-0.415563643,
0.0714691728,
-0.4974451065,
-0.108830452,
0.0990810618,
0.4044278562,
-0.2253108621,
0.6043906808,
-0.0699711367,
0.4761819243,
0.0765450671,
0.0002910873,
0.029186707,
0.0277288798,
-0.3036985695,
-0.2311095744,
0.9452211261,
0.2242061347,
0.7077888846,
-0.3598191142,
-0.2661186159,
0.1151349992,
0.3490067422,
-0.5835608244,
-0.3560434878,
0.2591726482,
-0.1725560576,
-0.154393509,
-0.307186693,
-0.478066355,
-0.3703043759,
-0.4723266661,
0.4445705712,
-0.4072334468,
-0.4831436276,
-0.1634627879,
0.0789806694,
0.4389753938,
0.4993926883,
-0.8592445254,
0.4847235084,
1.0197890997,
0.916036129,
-0.1699213535,
-0.6341607571,
-0.6127313375,
0.0108406534,
-0.0359207615,
0.8743383288,
-0.7178096175,
-0.2851394713,
-0.1097769886,
-0.052600123,
-0.3425852358,
-0.4430647492,
0.2543926835,
-0.3509349823,
0.031340804,
0.045398429,
-0.580375433,
-0.2283043861,
0.6086165309,
-0.4639391899,
0.8214019537,
0.1075208336,
-0.3255545497,
-0.1547155678,
-0.7780997157,
-0.3438389897,
0.2850067317,
-0.2898949981,
-0.3266676664,
-0.0796116069,
0.2169484198,
0.8336160779,
-0.0933302641,
0.2152987272,
-0.3875260651,
-0.118509613,
-0.0903275982,
0.1314008087,
0.5650106072,
0.0010990765,
-0.3760166466,
0.4952039719,
0.0291417632,
0.0270641297,
0.3264086246,
-0.1399641931,
-0.0439627804,
-0.0006974673,
0.1352863908,
0.1068754718,
0.3640043437,
-0.3015853763,
0.8179656267,
-0.0533331558,
0.8309871554,
0.6183883548,
-0.2372542322,
0.4361993372,
-0.5489256978,
0.8013296127,
-0.3439842463,
0.0720015317,
0.1808331311,
-0.7662026882,
-0.5629860759,
-0.3821552396,
0.0632779747,
0.7786749601,
-0.8549846411,
0.3179596663,
-0.2866687775,
-0.6889016032,
-0.6673053503,
0.1467353553,
0.350299269,
0.2265870124,
0.2426292598,
-0.260997951,
-0.0108590154,
-0.8338221908,
-0.2943854928,
-0.4627227187,
-0.2273570448,
0.4831225872,
0.371445477,
-0.4589726925,
0.9416493773,
-0.1792399585,
-0.4731485546,
-0.4348537624,
0.1276025921,
-0.0697998255,
0.3880453706,
0.4264388978,
-1.0376021862,
-0.3804035187,
0.3036789596,
-0.7110154629,
-0.0793484673,
-0.0933705345,
-0.1785416901,
0.1189951524,
0.5329114795,
-1.0389646292,
0.1541734785,
0.6571037769,
-0.3908326328,
0.6395263672,
-0.018229099,
0.1432774961,
-1.0000075102,
0.0205572676,
-0.0033819319,
-0.5306766033,
-0.7519356012,
0.2836537659,
-0.2236062735,
-0.2034107,
-0.4262314737,
0.6827642918,
-0.2713229954,
0.0596683808,
-0.5053550005,
0.4637416899,
-0.4610166848,
0.6917248964,
0.1224254519,
0.6811232567,
0.7589532137,
-0.4379520714,
0.8011484742,
0.4902454317,
0.2603942454,
0.4271589518,
-0.9350163937,
0.2870637476,
0.0885406435,
0.2647869289,
-0.6657989025,
-0.4298619628,
0.4800907075,
-0.6765538454,
0.4029272497,
-0.3249373138,
-0.3410801291,
-0.2604101598,
0.0782142654,
0.351357162,
0.6385143399,
-0.5160922408,
0.9992699623,
0.5016176105,
-0.4169119596,
-0.2197270542,
-0.4139253199,
0.2506372929,
-0.2557891309,
-0.6928931475,
0.3681993186,
-0.2262218446,
-0.3585788608,
0.1816639453,
0.212624386,
-0.0874809176,
-0.008205913,
0.4266931713,
0.1051288694,
0.0475089364,
0.0012021885,
-0.1728096604,
-0.2428127974,
0.01182748,
-0.2323241085,
0.6482101679,
-0.5521377921,
-0.528175056,
-0.3856576681,
0.3641348481,
0.6420658231,
-0.3374129236,
0.3976872861,
0.5970543623,
-0.3742402792,
-0.2154551297,
-0.4522636831,
-0.0270488709,
-0.4463503957,
0.2335517555,
-0.539367795,
-1.2143176794,
0.5306632519,
-0.1450094134,
0.0809913054,
0.2483459413,
0.921169281,
-0.0338994525,
0.9474976659,
1.0187333822,
-0.8975211382,
0.5892443657,
0.1187259257,
0.2026149929,
-0.5992717147,
-0.1863631755,
-0.240449965,
-0.4009011984,
-0.773409307,
-0.5852532983,
0.3567976654,
-0.0176299643,
-0.1816764176,
0.4842325449,
-0.7239685655,
0.5103474259,
0.7023623586,
0.2694736719,
0.1279613674,
-0.1891829371,
0.3053379953,
0.430616051,
-0.5051310658,
-0.5053294301,
0.4422776997,
0.4512563944,
0.5772072673,
0.008736657,
0.6053191423,
0.2507189214,
0.3859851956,
-1.0178074837,
0.7589901686,
0.0279044714,
-0.2899315655,
-0.1402481049,
-0.3818970323,
-0.7277149558,
0.0769247189,
0.0582407154,
-0.9924519062,
-0.4776180089,
0.1144117191,
-0.0763369203,
0.3736539185,
-0.6443816423,
0.8300871253,
-0.0764466301,
-0.1658505201,
-0.341992557,
-0.695366323,
0.4192715287,
0.3120465279,
-0.1172233447,
-0.3879022002,
-0.066675894,
0.3963575661,
-0.2589274645,
1.0212546587,
-0.1591778696,
-0.0445876978,
0.3193048835,
0.3573034108,
0.6010001302,
-0.2171110958,
0.1371540129,
0.2779352367,
-0.0862402692,
-0.6263397336,
-0.8128464222,
0.6688950658,
-0.7722734809,
-0.7482185364,
-0.3038944602,
-0.5745694637,
-0.2348161638,
0.0049083647,
-0.0625008568,
0.0841729641,
-0.3573603332,
-0.4487152994,
0.3357639611,
0.0899425596,
0.3334908485,
0.1251113713,
-0.3419737518,
-0.1548841298,
0.9408095479,
-0.2582950294,
0.2597484589,
0.244592756,
-0.0342377387,
-0.1210677475,
-0.3127410114,
-0.543664813,
0.3668800592,
-0.2038459778,
-0.1800613105,
-0.5763568282,
-0.5271993876,
-0.2437689304,
-0.3844476342,
-0.2464356273,
-0.2403412312,
0.1920670271,
0.0580455065,
0.5961816311,
0.9876530766,
-0.0123958476,
0.5204800963,
-0.7411244512,
0.4156385362,
0.4657498598,
0.3892084956,
-0.2607210875,
-0.0886819884,
0.0859084725,
-0.0223884452,
-0.3347712159,
-0.7921034694,
0.2905427516,
0.3219181895,
0.5583459735,
0.2872040868,
-0.1413775682,
0.4789830148,
-0.6475376487,
0.7073905468,
-0.0696409196,
-0.8870603442,
0.5891919732,
-0.6472286582,
0.180967465,
0.207992807,
0.4987661541,
-0.7439943552,
-0.6151362658,
-0.6892600656,
-0.5496047139,
0.4859294295,
0.3263865709,
0.2471496314,
0.1534001827,
0.569804728,
-0.1887276024,
0.3058280945,
-0.5892581344,
-0.1385008991,
0.0788103789,
-0.1940750182,
-0.0986190662,
0.1335672438,
-0.2119628936,
-0.036688976,
0.7794758677,
-0.4123433232,
0.5950414538,
0.1397422701,
0.0758574307,
0.0183778219,
0.0097923186,
0.3050144315,
0.17116943,
0.2178017348,
0.0310166366,
0.0034908489,
-0.4179447889,
-0.0713881105,
0.4690103233,
0.0376590341,
-0.4619930387,
0.4553790987,
0.6358194351,
-0.0591217354,
-0.752785027,
0.4790886343,
-0.2451854646,
-0.155187428,
-0.0323827341,
0.3227163553,
0.3316195607,
0.7244833112,
0.0135859279,
-0.0301388279,
-0.0944217071,
-0.4436362684,
0.4315789938,
0.7259879708,
-0.4131364822,
-0.4670947194,
0.7016131878,
0.2560290098,
-0.6352056861,
0.983545661,
-0.1664604545,
-1.203699708,
0.7455015779,
0.3236808479,
1.0961377621,
-0.2651820779,
0.2822210789,
-0.0288167205,
0.2776494324,
0.214844808,
0.0713915527,
-0.2910751998,
-0.7855829,
-0.5371580124,
-0.5855746865,
-0.7774711847,
-0.1418661177,
-0.1899452209,
0.0660936236,
-0.4936641455,
0.0593389943,
-0.2057352066,
0.2693991065,
-0.7075947523,
-0.010611766,
0.3014777601,
0.8682474494,
-0.7165474296,
0.8096030951,
0.9506357908,
-0.3807046115,
-0.8731302619,
0.0667454079,
0.2309143096,
-1.16086936,
0.2518848181,
0.2547179759,
-0.1482947171,
0.056870915,
-0.8213757277,
-0.4724748135,
0.9271188378,
0.382853061,
-0.3531040549,
-0.1204947755,
0.0619223118,
0.5625308752,
-0.3668675721,
0.3101473153,
0.6530352831,
0.4804195166,
0.2681171,
-1.3777561188,
0.0126842801,
-0.4544882476,
-0.4221546352,
0.260298878,
-1.0663667917,
0.4724152684,
-0.2715456188,
-0.0040611038,
0.1230343431,
0.7926324606,
0.2576570809,
0.3565054834,
0.5560042858,
0.50480479,
0.7539327145,
-0.0734991208,
0.9695358276,
-0.1496885419,
0.2987754047,
0.7888140082,
-0.1862542033,
0.6966433525,
0.2434154153,
-0.256545037,
0.2322296947,
0.7564604878,
-0.004884162,
0.1187220141,
0.1286371797,
-0.6025334001,
-0.3607052565,
-0.405788511,
-0.103754133,
0.5015020967,
0.3102652729,
0.1651834995,
-0.3211533427,
0.1669340283,
0.321265161,
-0.0154237105,
-0.4020944834,
0.9393935204,
0.202915892,
-0.6918507218,
0.2686424255,
-0.2085957974,
0.6108580232,
-0.6945082545,
-0.0765728354,
-0.1476806253,
0.1516508907,
-0.1568769366,
-0.8614521623,
0.3925364316,
0.0375651196,
0.0334227905,
-0.4548041523,
0.8716063499,
-0.5453631878,
-0.2898844182,
0.4979788959,
0.7604930997,
0.5769782662,
-0.4892291427,
-0.9274306297,
0.0553734414,
-0.0712639764,
-0.4603532255,
0.5616395473,
0.5269135833,
-0.0240818765,
1.206933856,
0.3525176346,
0.1006296501,
-0.2450087667,
-0.1838600338,
1.2557080984,
-0.5238921642,
-0.2527870238,
-0.8399376273,
0.3178313076,
0.2336703986,
-0.1571155041,
0.3716351688,
0.1084289625,
0.6812593341,
0.2879599035,
0.9784185886,
-0.491263479,
0.225834161,
-0.3636471629,
0.7561796308,
-0.584728539,
-0.2951630652,
-0.0765032321,
-0.8632804751,
-0.3229491711,
0.5407540798,
-0.3660300672,
0.3132775426,
0.1475852728,
0.5942512155,
-0.1384130418,
0.0319998935,
0.4138924778,
0.2551977634,
0.6246826053,
0.7391081452,
0.7276985049,
-0.0559922494,
0.343395263,
-0.1976932585,
-0.5170446038,
-0.0310163815,
-0.9115983248,
-1.0697841644,
-0.6869709492,
-0.4066512883,
-0.1263681203,
0.1038620099,
1.1703824997,
0.9370267987,
-0.5690421462,
-0.0242566485,
0.0465443619,
0.2525681853,
-0.2182519883,
-0.2252263278,
0.2888399363,
-0.5075577497,
-1.1200591326,
0.5513362885,
0.1363937259,
-0.0282750428,
-0.2838409543,
-0.1667236686,
0.1572039276,
-0.1271554381,
0.5761795044,
0.5357327461,
-0.6100714207,
-0.4001622498,
-0.1490830332,
-0.0890196189,
-0.1017893031,
0.7928984165,
-0.9257686138,
0.13515912,
0.2158284187,
0.9556942582,
0.4417940676,
0.253039211,
0.6823535562,
-0.5164310932,
0.0043688873,
0.3004935682,
0.2432489395,
0.2105694264,
-0.4754975438,
0.5951932669,
0.1182335168,
-1.0863875151,
-0.3179866374,
0.4031163752,
-1.2577002048,
-0.0608190447,
0.9214162827,
-0.1800188422,
-0.4113728702,
0.1770775765,
-0.4449301362,
0.2428932339,
-0.6210168004,
0.7980428934,
0.7607138753,
-0.663028419,
-0.3832427263,
-0.6867064238,
0.5897612572,
0.3956666291,
-0.8587180972,
0.2659254074,
0.3324715495,
0.1149479598,
0.0925906971,
0.7657883763,
0.2284316272,
-0.0300636329,
-0.2696329355,
0.2426430434,
-0.1735134721,
-0.4186163843,
-0.3217308819,
0.0897061825,
0.0432443134,
-0.1997392923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17574v1 | Elastic Weight Removal for Faithful and Abstractive Dialogue Generation | 2023-03-30T17:40:30 | 2023-03-30T17:40:30 | Nico Daheim, Nouha Dziri, Mrinmaya Sachan, Iryna Gurevych, Edoardo M. Ponti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Ideally, dialogue systems should generate responses that are faithful to the
knowledge contained in relevant documents. However, many models generate
hallucinated responses instead that contradict it or contain unverifiable
information. To mitigate such undesirable behaviour, it has been proposed to
fine-tune a `negative expert' on negative examples and subtract its parameters
from those of a pre-trained model. However, intuitively, this does not take
into account that some parameters are more responsible than others in causing
hallucinations. Thus, we propose to weigh their individual importance via (an
approximation of) the Fisher Information matrix, which measures the uncertainty
of their estimate. We call this method Elastic Weight Removal (EWR). We
evaluate our method -- using different variants of Flan-T5 as a backbone
language model -- on multiple datasets for information-seeking dialogue
generation and compare our method with state-of-the-art techniques for
faithfulness, such as CTRL, Quark, DExperts, and Noisy Channel reranking.
Extensive automatic and human evaluation shows that EWR systematically
increases faithfulness at minor costs in terms of other metrics. However, we
notice that only discouraging hallucinations may increase extractiveness, i.e.
shallow copy-pasting of document spans, which can be undesirable. Hence, as a
second main contribution, we show that our method can be extended to
simultaneously discourage hallucinations and extractive responses. We publicly
release the code for reproducing EWR and all baselines. | [
-0.64673388,
-0.8075888753,
0.387210995,
0.0454460531,
-0.3167660534,
-0.1046712399,
-0.1982378215,
-0.8572917581,
0.4582996368,
0.4761480987,
-0.5752881765,
-0.1895783991,
-0.568631649,
0.273041904,
-0.6756588817,
1.1539615393,
0.0631341487,
0.1283461303,
0.0239072312,
-0.1475358903,
-0.1263641268,
-0.2437828928,
-0.5423688293,
-0.2572380602,
0.7724471688,
0.176192075,
0.7429980636,
0.5882307291,
0.4115095735,
0.2353736758,
-0.0071246075,
-0.1040972099,
-0.8603355885,
0.1853746176,
-0.1463073194,
-0.4765563011,
-0.3808101118,
-0.0599113517,
0.4980215728,
0.7281057239,
-0.2746473849,
0.0287426189,
0.2339506596,
0.541729033,
-0.5579349995,
-0.0048650755,
-0.8500285745,
0.2876475751,
0.0195510946,
-0.5689457655,
-0.4419331253,
-0.3404425383,
0.265088886,
-0.8938763738,
0.4183484912,
0.1688787788,
1.0533304214,
0.3521104455,
-0.1501683146,
-0.4960325658,
-1.0194616318,
0.9585893154,
-0.6742989421,
0.3201411664,
0.4648332298,
-0.04960059,
-0.1275016963,
-0.4692749977,
-0.4527512193,
-0.1801150888,
0.0701624528,
0.1700964123,
-0.1954983026,
0.3647382855,
0.4522699118,
0.4399512708,
-0.3970661759,
-0.113553144,
-0.858966291,
-0.4543119073,
0.5934504271,
0.0208733492,
0.158780247,
-0.0406448357,
-0.2101673186,
-0.1732873768,
-0.6743166447,
-0.2540894449,
0.7458256483,
0.1294112504,
0.329795897,
0.7120580673,
0.0162497032,
0.2086584866,
0.17152372,
-0.1011833474,
0.0990254506,
-0.106619671,
-0.0181534924,
0.3284361064,
0.4902184904,
0.4594024718,
0.2673265338,
-0.3034366071,
-0.5488935709,
0.1469822526,
0.5578352213,
-0.7445752621,
-0.1765197515,
0.2171722949,
-0.6804257631,
-0.3753811419,
0.1256982833,
-0.9412082434,
-0.3324500918,
-0.335147351,
0.4235974252,
-0.4854117334,
-0.4504711926,
0.0127045782,
-0.260098964,
0.2464884967,
0.6114757061,
-0.6541580558,
0.6017811894,
0.4770252109,
0.52561903,
-0.1290159523,
0.0308154151,
-0.7098203897,
0.106144011,
-0.3197896183,
0.6444501281,
-0.6233581901,
-0.3320015371,
-0.1080820262,
-0.025140211,
0.2039604485,
-0.7364297509,
0.5884193778,
-0.3697677851,
0.5260574222,
-0.2533251345,
-0.5063145161,
-0.4088273644,
0.0038252485,
-0.7948025465,
0.869110465,
0.318857044,
-0.5135713816,
0.2940889895,
-0.1488121003,
-0.4160813093,
-0.0411390476,
-0.1975017637,
-0.2774157226,
0.342169553,
0.128838554,
0.0597951114,
-0.4631766677,
0.1402391493,
-0.5151475072,
-0.5189025402,
-0.0131799532,
-0.6189525127,
0.3669455349,
0.4527186751,
-0.625588119,
-0.1793045849,
-0.8169679642,
0.0212419294,
0.0199527983,
-0.0766017959,
-0.4724948108,
0.0280936491,
0.0373803861,
0.2029932886,
-0.0840895325,
-0.5775834322,
-0.0423717313,
-0.7772786021,
0.1461158991,
0.8152604699,
0.2106886506,
0.3710383475,
-0.690585196,
0.6673049331,
0.0587893315,
-0.0605465099,
0.037675336,
-0.34637025,
-0.7456421256,
-0.2875643075,
0.078037709,
0.367054224,
-0.742715776,
0.2486745864,
-0.1222308949,
-0.228702724,
-0.7273384929,
0.2367925197,
0.5023687482,
0.4389524162,
0.5757138133,
-0.4405077994,
-0.6274566054,
-0.9169670343,
-0.6018020511,
-0.335031718,
-0.390237689,
0.1882529855,
0.2664739788,
0.1346117407,
0.8138692975,
-0.3597288728,
-0.3559554219,
-0.1215322316,
0.4625654519,
-0.136416316,
0.4908881783,
0.4405190945,
-0.8574390411,
-0.1424946189,
-0.2966609597,
-0.7261505723,
-0.3947700858,
-0.3900670409,
0.1005457118,
0.4510957599,
0.201299265,
-0.6972375512,
0.7061533332,
0.2250958234,
0.0950043127,
0.451471895,
0.0210753381,
0.0810586959,
-1.0371879339,
0.0535318106,
0.157217294,
-0.2621788979,
-0.5955488682,
-0.0211607255,
-0.3168852627,
0.1374788135,
-0.2394258678,
0.4890661538,
-0.3907728493,
-0.0766787529,
-0.0766671002,
0.3890238404,
0.2587069869,
0.7067226768,
0.1031766087,
0.475037545,
-0.0483564511,
-0.5557281375,
0.002768747,
0.0596281849,
-0.137813881,
0.5494537354,
-0.6997331977,
0.2475456446,
-0.3614056408,
0.1284751445,
-1.0327593088,
-0.0563127659,
0.474896729,
-0.3662205338,
0.2752206624,
0.0365811177,
-0.0697227269,
-0.0763068944,
-0.4919736087,
0.1646091491,
0.4430179298,
-0.2908151448,
0.7473450899,
0.2993582487,
-0.4859783947,
-0.49542135,
-0.6737543941,
-0.0470083095,
-0.2910932899,
-0.3904963136,
0.3929419518,
-0.1375831813,
-0.4484054148,
0.0155341579,
-0.5035786033,
-0.0846315026,
-0.1025663465,
0.1029115766,
0.0499496348,
-0.1436791867,
0.2050333023,
0.2292990834,
-0.0238546822,
0.337769866,
-0.32807374,
0.5247177482,
-0.0720692351,
-0.4411130846,
-0.5602293611,
0.3298991323,
0.5673079491,
-0.0815469101,
0.6712761521,
0.787442863,
-0.5037461519,
-0.0633808151,
-0.8674391508,
-0.6461871266,
-0.4725221097,
0.2887910008,
-0.3201170266,
-0.6356042027,
0.6350838542,
0.0003815686,
0.228205353,
0.5489854813,
0.2905694246,
-0.0993200764,
1.3490943909,
0.2319896221,
0.1365550905,
0.4648452103,
-0.0557276234,
0.3359600902,
-0.7394371629,
-0.1510396749,
-0.673820436,
-0.2204914838,
-0.4024190307,
0.1020265147,
0.2134782672,
0.1417022496,
0.2267595828,
0.2528686523,
-0.6252642274,
0.1296986639,
0.1807643473,
0.2204115242,
0.2533768117,
0.1420560777,
-0.0699897334,
-0.3078788817,
-0.4364127517,
-0.5756101608,
0.9770559669,
0.3140813708,
0.9249183536,
0.1683471203,
0.7067289948,
0.3440998793,
0.3144360483,
-0.7929241657,
0.547850728,
0.4068098366,
-0.4844391048,
-0.4129392803,
-0.9032452106,
-0.8146460056,
0.3599008024,
-0.2727634609,
-0.8558163047,
0.1402090341,
0.1452950388,
-0.3076960742,
0.345363766,
-0.603872478,
0.2605392039,
0.0417657048,
-0.5513909459,
-0.4586495161,
-0.4709247053,
0.2897510231,
-0.2306029201,
0.0922828466,
0.0384614095,
0.1349641681,
0.7480844259,
-0.4311634004,
0.5653028488,
-0.3392975926,
-0.4216011167,
0.2976479828,
0.4658288658,
0.7538614869,
0.0936494246,
-0.1210569516,
-0.0034301644,
0.3056109548,
-0.1649189591,
-0.8804357648,
0.2917336226,
-0.6819627285,
-0.6688959002,
-0.1505030543,
-0.5050294399,
0.0986031741,
0.3305829763,
0.3123298585,
0.738086164,
-0.1830374151,
0.4901409149,
0.8052943945,
-0.288797766,
0.1215231568,
0.4032794833,
-0.2405029088,
-0.4570947587,
0.9871467948,
0.3345141709,
0.3042623997,
0.4260600209,
0.1560062319,
-0.2711435556,
-0.5133915544,
0.0292508509,
-0.0212459657,
-0.5976768136,
-0.0753122419,
-0.8310346007,
-0.0896790326,
-0.3817181289,
-0.072671853,
-0.4025431275,
-0.8241074681,
-0.3557209671,
-0.1920221299,
0.1725552231,
0.7453287244,
0.0892326459,
0.0198280942,
-0.7624595761,
0.5012034178,
0.0831828564,
0.2027505189,
0.1396859437,
-0.5707371831,
-0.0908824131,
0.427595526,
-0.3946923912,
-0.7723497152,
0.5959273577,
0.2237771153,
0.6324543953,
0.7462610602,
0.5120723248,
0.7656111121,
-0.1073680893,
0.72375983,
0.1131149903,
-0.9224194884,
0.2571662366,
-0.345985204,
0.1220659241,
0.6372166872,
0.2798133492,
-0.3283945918,
-0.8867456913,
-0.7278578281,
-0.9092516899,
0.715472877,
0.3418188393,
-0.0239330456,
-0.0309067369,
0.4398813248,
0.176659897,
0.5849835277,
-0.587618351,
0.0870909691,
-0.2434906662,
-0.2973504066,
0.2538451552,
-0.2098131478,
-0.3374034762,
-0.315043211,
0.7485180497,
-0.0895166993,
0.4642418027,
0.4664034247,
-0.427090019,
-0.5591896176,
0.2840259969,
0.9191793799,
0.6325561404,
-0.3434780538,
-0.0012406633,
0.3043372631,
-0.6100879312,
-0.0740571022,
-0.0861276537,
-0.0348445997,
0.0219167713,
0.3053555787,
0.5743937492,
0.1176242456,
-0.5315688848,
0.36365062,
-0.225782752,
-0.5567058921,
-0.5429897904,
-0.0043716552,
-0.4751244783,
0.0463239513,
0.6561295986,
0.37355721,
0.3147614002,
-0.3833573759,
0.3387126029,
0.2735030651,
-0.6667711139,
-0.5294902921,
0.642354846,
0.164732635,
-0.4209198058,
0.75592345,
-0.1165198386,
-0.499919951,
0.4647543132,
0.4621876776,
1.0106669664,
-0.1550176889,
0.1257038862,
0.2305569202,
0.6095887423,
-0.0834919438,
0.3047786355,
-0.0252694748,
-0.7804179788,
-0.1349645406,
-0.4241135716,
-0.3707437515,
0.2792520821,
-1.1943702698,
0.0443286896,
-0.5161309838,
-0.1921223551,
-0.1452134848,
0.0790056586,
-0.520321548,
-0.0054209307,
-0.0033967909,
0.6385256052,
-0.478007257,
0.5999184847,
0.220182687,
-0.4401345551,
-0.9002920985,
0.186492756,
0.281930536,
-0.3010092676,
0.1975843906,
0.2897357941,
-0.4855349362,
-0.0039747716,
-0.6322827935,
-0.5981823802,
0.7636088729,
0.6857879758,
-0.43915838,
-0.1678407937,
0.0044360571,
0.6278920174,
-0.3013808429,
0.6138887405,
0.3379458487,
0.6188841462,
0.1668248922,
-0.7992133498,
0.1534652412,
-0.4999999106,
-0.1696196198,
0.1016448736,
-0.5780370831,
0.7444155216,
-0.0238409676,
-0.4202980399,
0.1777261347,
0.540922761,
0.0210740659,
0.0872083232,
0.7599591613,
0.3562268913,
0.9808197021,
-0.0383742265,
0.8767988086,
-0.6264420748,
0.1900865287,
0.9901954532,
-0.661246717,
0.512203753,
0.8716615438,
0.1441414356,
0.4122543931,
0.4080717862,
-0.0286787376,
0.4339779019,
0.1968401372,
-0.1593772471,
-0.0761664063,
-0.191784516,
-0.328972131,
0.3646937311,
0.5515062809,
-0.3628581762,
-0.1139053181,
0.0382633992,
-0.0184037108,
-0.0789447948,
0.0090909358,
0.9598392248,
0.1953450441,
-0.8215292096,
0.8222597837,
-0.108240068,
0.3707446456,
-0.6577761769,
-0.3898257017,
-0.1344337016,
0.206548363,
-0.3620798588,
-0.2738589048,
0.351426512,
-0.2362545431,
-0.0530242287,
-0.3918258846,
0.7214630246,
-0.591516614,
-0.121004045,
0.5088914633,
0.3228349388,
0.3771133423,
0.0411045179,
-0.5965994596,
-0.0057096696,
0.1374395192,
-0.6429582238,
0.2666687667,
0.3308231235,
0.1133807749,
0.6658778191,
0.666754365,
0.2814776301,
-0.1480021626,
0.1384658515,
1.0320006609,
-0.3878472745,
-0.3053696752,
-0.5220361352,
0.1863555461,
-0.1510072798,
-0.2346068025,
0.6975471377,
0.5285142064,
0.8655846119,
0.0764054731,
0.7511466146,
0.0473162867,
0.4176695645,
-0.5135666132,
0.6728381515,
-0.6904243231,
0.584320426,
-0.753410399,
-1.3809986115,
-0.0151099563,
0.7846283317,
-0.1911116689,
0.2041518837,
0.905264318,
1.1475627422,
0.1178318039,
0.4979656339,
0.2513847649,
0.2464182526,
0.3352658451,
0.3083285093,
0.8410735726,
-0.4857284725,
0.7835477591,
-0.0547043979,
-0.0309874378,
-0.1047351882,
-0.637283206,
-0.7310954332,
-0.4773443043,
-0.1220458224,
-0.4972671568,
0.1224480346,
1.242903471,
0.5758134723,
-0.8120667934,
-0.0450000353,
-0.1545090526,
0.1061836407,
-0.4371713102,
-0.2901054323,
0.0233925506,
-0.1302371472,
-0.6270356178,
0.2923526466,
0.2020816058,
0.0651535764,
-0.4426539838,
-0.1692492366,
0.0420315489,
0.3250980079,
0.2480926514,
0.2809935808,
-0.6931991577,
-0.568125248,
-0.0077732438,
-0.151729092,
0.2272658497,
0.6580506563,
-0.6743295789,
0.4512078762,
0.5588037968,
0.370803982,
0.596953094,
0.1369239241,
1.0335662365,
-0.6690539718,
0.3710458577,
0.4400235415,
0.1543969363,
0.1174044609,
-0.5558227897,
0.4580494761,
0.1942992061,
-0.268801719,
-1.0595805645,
0.0187286083,
-0.5929630399,
-0.1294871122,
0.9354692101,
-0.14489308,
-0.3012363315,
-0.385546416,
-0.2268891484,
0.3095385134,
-0.6032519937,
1.070469141,
0.8231710792,
0.1682465971,
-0.4053911269,
-0.4801616967,
0.5093559027,
0.6911978126,
-0.5390393138,
-0.0125072245,
0.4002912641,
-0.0328454785,
0.2942422628,
0.50198102,
-0.2212786674,
0.1012221947,
0.0915548578,
0.3537718952,
-0.0591615401,
-0.6055030823,
-0.350319773,
0.2926312387,
-0.1447036266,
0.4750257432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17564v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17564v3 | BloombergGPT: A Large Language Model for Finance | 2023-03-30T17:30:36 | 2023-12-21T06:21:11 | Shijie Wu, Ozan Irsoy, Steven Lu, Vadim Dabravolski, Mark Dredze, Sebastian Gehrmann, Prabhanjan Kambadur, David Rosenberg, Gideon Mann | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-fin.GN | The use of NLP in the realm of financial technology is broad and complex,
with applications ranging from sentiment analysis and named entity recognition
to question answering. Large Language Models (LLMs) have been shown to be
effective on a variety of tasks; however, no LLM specialized for the financial
domain has been reported in literature. In this work, we present BloombergGPT,
a 50 billion parameter language model that is trained on a wide range of
financial data. We construct a 363 billion token dataset based on Bloomberg's
extensive data sources, perhaps the largest domain-specific dataset yet,
augmented with 345 billion tokens from general purpose datasets. We validate
BloombergGPT on standard LLM benchmarks, open financial benchmarks, and a suite
of internal benchmarks that most accurately reflect our intended usage. Our
mixed dataset training leads to a model that outperforms existing models on
financial tasks by significant margins without sacrificing performance on
general LLM benchmarks. Additionally, we explain our modeling choices, training
process, and evaluation methodology. We release Training Chronicles (Appendix
C) detailing our experience in training BloombergGPT. | [
-0.2506404817,
-0.7023335099,
0.14640297,
0.4437794089,
-0.2571070194,
0.2754724622,
-0.374301821,
-0.4259707034,
-0.1667107344,
0.5431885719,
-0.1189916357,
-0.6235863566,
-0.6261245608,
-0.2594259381,
-0.7163048983,
1.5149044991,
0.1663486362,
0.1578129977,
0.3240985572,
0.3758123815,
-0.0061785495,
-0.5291850567,
-1.2926036119,
-0.1805436462,
0.4816263914,
0.1175430119,
0.8229619265,
0.6390459538,
0.7452507615,
0.1922227144,
0.0450988598,
-0.1738889068,
-0.2768206,
-0.3773198426,
-0.1569086164,
-0.025228519,
-0.6944671273,
0.0626186654,
0.3851518929,
0.9247311354,
-0.5333245993,
0.2156555504,
-0.1483208239,
0.5664326549,
-0.3359104097,
0.5686802268,
-0.5680987835,
0.0336617604,
-0.2846139669,
0.1497833282,
-0.3533383608,
-0.1876247823,
0.3558854163,
-0.4251848161,
0.1983056515,
0.3595784605,
0.6018931866,
0.0284760501,
-0.6283977628,
-0.3079878092,
-0.8684704304,
0.4679989517,
-0.8743850589,
0.5643382668,
0.3593610823,
0.4772898257,
0.102617301,
-0.9925147891,
-0.3623301685,
-0.7259141207,
0.2051045001,
0.2218937427,
-0.1088824198,
0.0043419162,
0.3486455083,
0.2292330563,
-0.5609838963,
0.2426204085,
-0.5808227658,
0.1258625537,
0.5452361703,
0.0897013769,
-0.0414614566,
-0.1269630641,
-0.4359496534,
-0.2613222599,
-0.5676667094,
-0.1764455438,
0.4441362619,
0.59834373,
-0.0659850314,
0.6291279197,
-0.0647598207,
0.8768533468,
-0.3251134753,
-0.1685934812,
-0.2198587805,
-0.1016381234,
-0.5431035161,
0.1381216198,
0.7064498067,
0.1947831661,
0.4687672853,
-0.3382647634,
-0.3339220881,
-0.5689538121,
0.3364444971,
-0.6763592362,
-0.439253509,
0.2042604238,
-0.2008079886,
0.1233013198,
0.2418644726,
-0.8085722923,
-0.3952152133,
-0.4424256682,
-0.1042886451,
-0.5342918038,
-0.1985760778,
0.4089952111,
-0.1240739152,
0.3100009859,
0.1097202525,
-1.2058051825,
0.4622402787,
1.2364280224,
0.7761535645,
0.0456845351,
-0.3162037134,
-0.5840918422,
0.4798621833,
-0.3524984419,
0.6495429277,
-0.5339545608,
-0.3238474131,
-0.0580674149,
-0.4588336945,
-0.0177974422,
-0.5455485582,
0.4535001814,
-0.5030146241,
-0.186999768,
-0.1518044621,
-0.7539538145,
-0.0861172751,
0.3079908788,
-0.6531857252,
0.9852741957,
0.2717011869,
-0.8386144638,
0.7472761869,
-0.9800732732,
-0.2732003927,
0.2171619982,
0.0798180103,
-0.430210501,
-0.2246786952,
0.261585772,
0.6957966685,
-0.5276180506,
0.6420959234,
-0.4492001534,
-0.3793929517,
0.2518953979,
-0.5263450146,
0.3380310237,
0.0206137858,
-0.2086161226,
-0.0296832155,
-0.9551387429,
-0.4302416742,
0.0874406025,
-0.3850142062,
-0.4448004365,
-0.0130826486,
0.5301287174,
-0.0105061149,
0.2363887578,
-0.5745758414,
0.3847956359,
-0.5751309991,
0.6871726513,
0.7387959361,
-0.2890202701,
0.0861583129,
-0.1128168702,
0.4789256752,
-0.1219694465,
0.0893440098,
0.1226172447,
-0.3923983574,
-0.4424053729,
-0.2931413651,
0.4677326381,
0.6646974087,
-0.2793097496,
0.2191410363,
-0.2441169024,
-0.5718236566,
0.0387504511,
0.0337610506,
-0.1839120388,
0.3703493178,
0.3014816046,
0.090685457,
-0.5156382918,
-1.250138402,
-0.1920006275,
-0.1037134901,
-0.3457199335,
0.1951565444,
0.5645927787,
-0.0254934523,
0.964943707,
-0.5219580531,
0.1830856949,
-0.4590449035,
0.2195969373,
0.5293672681,
0.3024355471,
0.5816404223,
-0.8308066726,
-0.4971189499,
0.4286966622,
-0.3560670316,
0.1103820801,
-0.4517736733,
0.0963945463,
-0.2478429079,
0.7555903196,
-0.5511945486,
0.2205280662,
0.5998269916,
-0.3128259778,
0.4503087401,
-0.3138268888,
-0.2148591429,
-1.1978849173,
0.3288737535,
0.4315769076,
-0.3403012156,
-0.4604574442,
-0.2695235908,
0.1987377256,
-0.2689747512,
-0.2523134947,
0.8478109837,
-0.1127365232,
-0.3814910054,
-0.2869817913,
0.1249284446,
-0.4180888236,
0.3902898729,
-0.0005092095,
0.9175218344,
0.5538841486,
-0.376978457,
0.9004374146,
0.1368218809,
-0.5226862431,
0.502181828,
-0.8626241684,
-0.0607782565,
0.0904288813,
0.1141249835,
-0.8898616433,
-0.099231489,
0.1079705134,
0.2461482435,
0.4715809226,
0.0253528357,
-0.677780211,
-0.5525624752,
0.1307394505,
0.1183643863,
0.2159671038,
-0.4911348224,
0.5626642704,
0.1595608592,
-0.7262198925,
-0.6221061349,
-0.4987559021,
0.4282827973,
-0.4514826238,
-0.417142272,
0.2004253715,
0.1200087517,
-0.341774404,
-0.2130353004,
-0.0653887093,
-0.0846494138,
0.0485356972,
0.1533236504,
0.4803778827,
-0.2070126235,
0.1857604831,
-0.3449910581,
-0.3225219548,
-0.0743809938,
-0.6000264287,
0.6388844848,
-0.2001163065,
-0.4648078382,
0.0362289511,
0.3259337842,
0.4626665115,
-0.1258494556,
0.9839450121,
0.5963766575,
-0.0867173001,
-0.3006776869,
-0.4729551971,
0.2994354963,
-0.4950685203,
0.8662694097,
-0.153611064,
-0.9269828796,
0.676897645,
-0.1617791653,
0.3154055774,
0.5180568695,
0.6574704647,
0.2381590158,
0.6978422403,
0.8682035208,
-0.4981065392,
0.5157006979,
-0.0634891838,
0.5802566409,
-0.5358682275,
-0.2521678805,
-0.4903472364,
-0.2251159102,
-0.4143963754,
-0.2294763178,
0.2051710635,
0.0605327263,
-0.812209785,
0.3868258595,
-0.0764865875,
0.567596674,
0.8455685377,
-0.108672224,
0.2080814093,
-0.1885417104,
0.0448587388,
0.0920656919,
-0.5526146889,
-0.513880372,
1.3930984735,
0.5656211376,
0.848492384,
-0.0652485639,
0.1862112284,
0.2286195755,
0.6038433313,
-0.7431990504,
0.3729062974,
-0.5167788267,
-0.4726029932,
-0.3389503956,
-0.6320241094,
-0.7265597582,
-0.2224333286,
0.1557274163,
-0.5598973036,
-0.3163036704,
-0.1381948441,
-0.4878539145,
0.4744293392,
-0.6486344337,
0.9848311543,
-0.396440804,
0.0352343619,
0.2187962681,
-0.3586321771,
0.5296720266,
-0.5677047968,
0.0891622305,
-0.0508804098,
-0.2089796066,
0.8439078331,
-0.4304284453,
0.7834269404,
0.0564066917,
-0.2798010409,
-0.1170515865,
-0.2218580842,
0.7270476818,
0.3880671561,
-0.1478267014,
0.2412041128,
-0.0421501249,
-0.5185313821,
-0.3727114797,
0.4590934217,
-0.5972644091,
-0.4353821278,
-0.3268896937,
-0.830358088,
-0.6109807491,
-0.076748386,
-0.0525216386,
0.0507872812,
-0.3833430409,
0.3051557839,
0.130129233,
-0.3477800786,
0.5229878426,
0.3631788492,
-0.2819197774,
-0.3805143833,
0.6180933118,
-0.0275879893,
0.1425608248,
0.3011827767,
0.2073709667,
-0.351839453,
-0.6590980887,
-0.2306426316,
0.329703182,
-0.6909469366,
-0.0784958899,
-0.4447348416,
-0.4342472255,
-0.4565019906,
-0.106116809,
-0.5817477703,
-0.198776871,
0.0632135123,
-0.5354728699,
0.5583846569,
0.8932187557,
0.0010226902,
0.5012828112,
-0.8836987615,
0.2717343569,
0.5201997757,
0.7070354819,
0.0592233464,
-0.3505354822,
-0.5267230868,
-0.0970407128,
0.038823463,
-0.6473609209,
0.5896453857,
0.1643795371,
0.5548407435,
0.3934897184,
-0.3042225838,
0.5278735757,
-0.4776095748,
0.6393131018,
0.1590411365,
-0.9798663259,
0.2519868314,
-0.7057647705,
0.1884033382,
0.2413832992,
0.4294795096,
-1.025537014,
-0.509126246,
-0.5040287375,
-1.1360313892,
0.6401110888,
-0.0463172384,
0.3303303421,
-0.009580736,
0.7294560671,
0.291162163,
0.5114042759,
-0.9802008867,
-0.1128036678,
-0.2943570316,
-0.2333714962,
-0.2382583916,
-0.1792346388,
0.0188233163,
-0.2365663797,
0.6912017465,
-0.1089651734,
-0.1078360826,
-0.3110275269,
0.5257222652,
0.1861574501,
0.0629428178,
0.4631416202,
0.9561384916,
-0.3445841968,
-0.1859174818,
0.0188006014,
-0.6753264666,
-0.2963505983,
0.4785453081,
0.0805614814,
-0.1824927479,
0.2822313607,
0.7560378909,
0.2805934846,
-0.9278642535,
0.3861459792,
-0.0002422462,
-0.3864952326,
-0.3590318263,
-0.0922220871,
0.4275736809,
0.5731653571,
0.5953198671,
-0.1282729357,
-0.007952217,
-0.4405920208,
0.4422966838,
0.4294166863,
-0.1534244716,
-0.0344384573,
0.8687112331,
-0.1182917282,
0.0609798245,
1.0181832314,
0.0830734819,
-0.3792506754,
0.7282492518,
0.4709410965,
0.8694229722,
-0.0793785304,
0.3151663244,
0.1934410632,
0.4053474367,
-0.3922730386,
0.0792709514,
0.2638600171,
-0.5252191424,
-0.6591652036,
-1.0161772966,
-0.7995842099,
0.4414413869,
-0.4364355206,
0.270365864,
-0.8818236589,
-0.1218371466,
0.3373854756,
-0.1546680629,
-0.6446833014,
0.2284830809,
0.2014688253,
1.1221517324,
-0.6745865345,
0.8396067023,
0.4184548259,
-0.2835198045,
-0.9188472629,
-0.0277555641,
-0.3392041326,
-0.9675110579,
0.9016746283,
-0.1563830376,
0.4384413064,
-0.0502581522,
-0.5134140849,
-0.8198334575,
0.7742120028,
0.6106629372,
-0.8723183274,
-0.1483980119,
0.5416142941,
0.3978068531,
-0.2094796747,
-0.0267718006,
0.5882954597,
0.6092531681,
0.4247673452,
-1.0372517109,
-0.4560370743,
-0.1771763414,
-0.0995413065,
0.4519887567,
-0.6428932548,
1.091301322,
0.1085017473,
0.3229699135,
-0.2011730969,
0.6636629105,
0.1951057017,
0.3293433487,
0.1956245899,
0.4258233309,
0.747443676,
-0.2548342049,
1.2372522354,
-0.4295192659,
0.5818487406,
1.1453775167,
-0.3827826083,
1.0025365353,
0.3250463605,
-0.4676735997,
0.0000421901,
1.023671627,
-0.4591905773,
0.282856226,
0.5235850215,
-0.1955299228,
-0.2287120372,
0.1428052932,
-0.2435886562,
0.5020975471,
0.1659768224,
-0.3148309886,
-0.2925167084,
0.1160483584,
0.0112446574,
-0.3878082037,
-0.5128927827,
0.5256106257,
0.3750971556,
-0.2517675757,
-0.0811695307,
0.2726432383,
0.5373048186,
-0.9374018312,
0.2969910502,
-0.3573973179,
0.1573235095,
0.1716167927,
-0.5826624632,
0.5455708504,
0.2473778427,
0.1411687434,
-0.2848165035,
0.230202511,
-0.3224963248,
-0.9809635878,
0.1714578122,
0.4214880764,
-0.0035621824,
-0.4345084131,
-0.7564963698,
-0.607806921,
-0.2458594739,
-0.5869945288,
0.3385938704,
0.6029333472,
0.1613730341,
0.781914413,
0.8238459826,
0.3323810995,
-0.0517841764,
0.2867493331,
0.7492381334,
-1.1083501577,
-0.7441412807,
-1.0185176134,
0.163226679,
-0.0404215381,
-0.3543203473,
0.7380418181,
0.9080579877,
0.7903443575,
0.0239506774,
0.8482773304,
0.4700520337,
0.4610721171,
-0.7132192254,
0.5012239814,
-0.3612596095,
0.4663625956,
-0.2628393173,
-1.1548599005,
-0.4372545183,
0.5072671771,
-0.6176350713,
0.437943995,
0.4632826149,
0.3142112195,
-0.3982644081,
0.4047365189,
0.4253334105,
0.1854816526,
0.3508560359,
0.489444524,
0.6148453951,
-0.1125406325,
0.5726266503,
-0.1311906725,
0.187994957,
-0.21341905,
-1.0320239067,
-0.9017300606,
-0.3418778479,
-0.2656707168,
0.0565287136,
-0.2025194615,
0.8827145696,
0.6501702666,
-0.6446698904,
-0.501878798,
-0.0978498012,
-0.4493492842,
-0.1806956083,
-0.1651432216,
0.5352522731,
0.0432872847,
-0.8332586884,
0.3421224654,
0.6951093674,
0.3680944145,
-0.412996918,
0.1471949369,
0.1415310949,
0.1619118154,
0.4160884917,
0.1006577313,
-0.3051808476,
-0.1793181747,
0.0926984549,
-0.1072845235,
0.0314056836,
1.0007249117,
-0.2094081193,
-0.0887211114,
0.0440058447,
0.8576341867,
0.7845810056,
0.0314244963,
0.6819554567,
-0.7758870721,
0.2786795497,
0.2304479778,
0.493378073,
0.2767628431,
-0.269092679,
0.518801868,
0.0398802571,
-0.4756802917,
-0.4466933012,
-0.1027193516,
-1.1919130087,
-0.4613372386,
1.0893445015,
0.0550252236,
-0.2580292225,
-0.2298555672,
-0.1977742761,
0.073842153,
-0.5529965758,
0.7884892821,
1.007299304,
0.1548033357,
-0.24981004,
-1.2093925476,
0.399907887,
0.1537303627,
-0.8368902802,
0.4431348145,
0.2331299782,
0.175188452,
-0.1473846734,
0.4991433322,
0.3053133786,
0.0884779543,
0.1989446282,
-0.1533198208,
-0.3333109319,
-0.1233877689,
0.0623924434,
0.4632583857,
0.0576568581,
0.2993076146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17557v1 | Recognition, recall, and retention of few-shot memories in large language models | 2023-03-30T17:26:16 | 2023-03-30T17:26:16 | A. Emin Orhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE | The training of modern large language models (LLMs) takes place in a regime
where most training examples are seen only a few times by the model during the
course of training. What does a model remember about such examples seen only a
few times during training and how long does that memory persist in the face of
continuous training with new examples? Here, we investigate these questions
through simple recognition, recall, and retention experiments with LLMs. In
recognition experiments, we ask if the model can distinguish the seen example
from a novel example; in recall experiments, we ask if the model can correctly
recall the seen example when cued by a part of it; and in retention
experiments, we periodically probe the model's memory for the original examples
as the model is trained continuously with new examples. We find that a single
exposure is generally sufficient for a model to achieve near perfect accuracy
even in very challenging recognition experiments. We estimate that the
recognition performance of even small language models easily exceeds human
recognition performance reported in similar experiments with humans (Shepard,
1967). Achieving near perfect recall takes more exposures, but most models can
do it in just 3 exposures. The flip side of this remarkable capacity for fast
learning is that precise memories are quickly overwritten: recall performance
for the original examples drops steeply over the first 10 training updates with
new examples, followed by a more gradual decline. Even after 100K updates,
however, some of the original examples are still recalled near perfectly. A
qualitatively similar retention pattern has been observed in human long-term
memory retention studies before (Bahrick, 1984). Finally, recognition is much
more robust to interference than recall and memory for natural language
sentences is generally superior to memory for stimuli without structure. | [
-0.2320522517,
-0.7296779752,
0.6299369931,
-0.1316839159,
-0.1291102916,
-0.2387353033,
-0.3313098252,
-0.4455253184,
0.0708793029,
0.5047665238,
-0.048280444,
-0.2504698634,
-0.457821548,
0.0003689306,
-0.640221417,
0.7196390033,
-0.0585590228,
-0.0934411958,
-0.0853023008,
-0.3165823519,
-0.4170357883,
-0.6665096879,
-0.8302620649,
-0.550047636,
0.4573076963,
0.3079835474,
0.1740858555,
0.86927104,
0.2715426087,
0.2734267414,
-0.2004746795,
-0.1495273262,
-0.7459961772,
-0.1544141918,
-0.0061345459,
-0.7206483483,
-0.0193527061,
0.0657192543,
1.1971715689,
0.8529943228,
-0.0323994122,
-0.029003527,
0.1209187433,
0.5351093411,
-0.7185451388,
-0.1417945325,
-0.9446365833,
-0.015003114,
-0.2910871208,
-0.1928717345,
-0.6094231606,
-0.1640417427,
0.2291703373,
-0.3166577816,
0.3342479467,
-0.0335422978,
0.7253262997,
-0.235647738,
-0.3928723633,
-0.1790825278,
-0.8825212717,
0.839607358,
-0.4952050149,
0.3914655745,
0.6373361945,
0.292152673,
-0.2654396296,
-0.5625976324,
-0.6093649268,
-0.5262168646,
-0.0692726672,
-0.1201646551,
-0.20599778,
-0.0550480932,
0.6609551907,
0.2515173256,
-0.5265808702,
0.1725280583,
-0.4041591287,
-0.4370799959,
0.4303830564,
0.3207128942,
-0.0506923757,
0.1379788369,
-0.4028835297,
0.1956091076,
-0.9280415773,
-0.0749920085,
0.0342898555,
0.189760223,
0.097657226,
0.4809524417,
-0.0149040744,
0.4303222895,
-0.0706072003,
-0.3381128907,
0.0721417964,
-0.1656570286,
-0.0702583194,
-0.0302292593,
0.6497317553,
-0.096464105,
0.4766893983,
-0.1204232275,
-0.2024784982,
-0.0126080895,
0.1232723072,
-0.592469573,
-0.2851600945,
-0.2248259634,
-0.4869439006,
0.197701171,
-0.0692129657,
-0.316460073,
-0.4314830303,
-0.0396648347,
0.6275482774,
-0.4735041857,
-0.0474660806,
0.3205852509,
-0.1916056573,
0.2349118441,
0.2754175961,
-0.9699525833,
0.5660839081,
0.5997891426,
0.7747594118,
-0.3064441681,
-0.7443645597,
-0.4618317783,
0.1359971017,
-0.4837900102,
0.8245049715,
-0.266703546,
-0.1953270435,
0.0951792225,
0.0041271853,
-0.1209746078,
-0.8382412195,
0.0625686347,
-0.5489282608,
0.0191558395,
-0.4249188304,
-1.0195994377,
-0.2349076867,
0.3461720347,
-0.6603189111,
0.8969222903,
-0.1584667712,
-0.5535880923,
0.2969897687,
0.0642831102,
-0.2654409409,
-0.0662704632,
-0.1909454465,
-0.3394955993,
0.508541584,
-0.5206829309,
0.4364162982,
-0.0330020562,
-0.2325878441,
-0.3162199259,
-0.6176607013,
0.4433565438,
-0.5928453803,
0.4971927106,
-0.1201964617,
0.0803925321,
-0.2012315392,
-0.7980252504,
-0.1695471257,
0.3956061304,
-0.7784625888,
-0.6116250753,
-0.0978133231,
-0.144138515,
0.0609631427,
0.1144558862,
-0.6771615744,
0.3634854555,
-0.2454811335,
0.3767657578,
0.6238088608,
0.1583263427,
0.4900580347,
-0.4303067625,
0.1667538732,
0.3568541706,
-0.2315147966,
-0.5900820494,
-0.028125437,
-0.9957759976,
-0.1709076911,
0.2255494148,
0.4376558363,
-0.1521553248,
-0.0330884866,
-0.1761742234,
-0.199235931,
-0.1474462897,
0.4654595256,
0.4299041331,
0.3323131502,
0.130655542,
-0.5522639155,
-0.5278724432,
-1.0509364605,
-0.2175511271,
-0.1381578445,
-0.0180071555,
0.2151921988,
0.7112334371,
-0.0371590219,
0.9818111658,
-0.4913626909,
-0.3465936482,
-0.4959694147,
0.0798291564,
0.0149695277,
0.2635326385,
0.6361300945,
-0.3857960403,
-0.32425946,
-0.3096492887,
-0.6304354072,
0.4593343139,
-0.2920459807,
0.2156779319,
0.4531474411,
0.559279561,
-0.6563945413,
0.3713606894,
0.2139168382,
-0.0194257013,
0.4074093699,
-0.4721508622,
-0.2006860375,
-0.8906161785,
0.0047823414,
-0.1039212644,
-0.3410691917,
-0.776173234,
-0.4066906571,
0.2030332536,
0.092229642,
-0.6538776159,
1.0569164753,
-0.6152319312,
-0.2206189036,
-0.4785007834,
0.177952081,
-0.0864492729,
0.4277179539,
0.1948715001,
0.5601665974,
0.5627565384,
-0.8264122605,
0.0777343661,
0.0541448221,
-0.6510246396,
0.3137212992,
-0.3243638873,
0.5102226138,
-0.2642081082,
0.1103090867,
-1.0335844755,
-0.1572064459,
-0.1386923045,
-0.0775087178,
0.4360192418,
0.0000499116,
-0.4588873982,
-0.3196940124,
-0.2927365005,
0.47488904,
0.6705330014,
-0.5463137627,
0.5482000709,
0.2953230739,
-0.0383281857,
-0.4275281727,
-0.7207279801,
-0.1978374571,
-0.2332295924,
0.0437964648,
0.117642656,
0.097412996,
-0.0910128579,
-0.1630784273,
-0.2647301853,
-0.330380559,
0.1336230487,
0.169651404,
0.1264180839,
-0.120344393,
0.3779112697,
-0.4780689478,
-0.1479943544,
-0.2338985354,
-0.0249025114,
0.6836379766,
-0.2489240468,
-0.2894583941,
-0.5551937222,
0.3702530265,
0.4913583696,
0.1402445585,
0.7418728471,
0.2804031074,
-0.7686259151,
0.0801667944,
-0.852090776,
-0.214117378,
-0.3961049914,
0.6363556385,
-0.6115806699,
-0.7213163376,
0.7745347023,
0.0898882523,
0.0264672711,
0.2599763274,
0.4252215028,
-0.3894099593,
0.701556921,
0.6938904524,
-0.5120383501,
0.6608100533,
-0.2893539071,
-0.1005546451,
-0.7732712626,
0.0524385162,
-0.3653238118,
-0.287525475,
-0.1717053652,
-0.0744441077,
0.010214367,
0.3477601707,
-0.3257512748,
0.3507104814,
0.1314612627,
0.9928612113,
0.5120705962,
0.0568923652,
0.42419824,
-0.1229429916,
0.0544050969,
-0.1477094293,
-0.8092169166,
-0.6080691814,
1.0058742762,
0.4527986348,
0.9909889698,
-0.1140122414,
0.9437919855,
-0.0079313554,
0.2551488876,
-0.9233548641,
0.7828199267,
-0.1533977389,
-0.7212355733,
-0.1547856778,
-0.3394306302,
-1.0949364901,
-0.0770697445,
-0.2400795966,
-0.7821198106,
0.0234860219,
0.5999703407,
-0.4344482422,
0.3983678818,
-0.5614112616,
0.7191166282,
-0.268042773,
-0.2789613605,
-0.3732553422,
-0.4360615015,
0.4492111504,
-0.1620163023,
-0.1856276244,
-0.0104693985,
0.1280382872,
0.7847272754,
0.1510982662,
0.7824336886,
-0.0420631096,
0.221676141,
0.3635851741,
0.2379080802,
0.443741262,
-0.4691330194,
0.1817324758,
0.0990543291,
0.071585834,
-0.4056439698,
-0.4354944229,
0.4799075127,
-0.4809961319,
-0.4437353313,
-0.5083540678,
-0.4282506704,
-0.0149888247,
0.1923436224,
0.2792138159,
0.3640574813,
-0.4910858572,
0.2272185087,
0.8656929731,
-0.2643167675,
0.5168024302,
0.5733650327,
-0.3419047296,
-0.0880986229,
0.825012207,
0.3873446584,
0.5766772032,
0.294164151,
0.2256840318,
-0.0595053025,
-0.8073198199,
0.0444265418,
0.5389297605,
-0.7456607223,
-0.0192335751,
-0.5477415919,
-0.2726974487,
-0.099206537,
0.0577668212,
-0.5373695493,
-0.4396027029,
-0.2548558712,
0.1008611694,
0.3463999927,
0.7819697261,
0.0374454856,
0.3667828143,
-0.8768175244,
0.4148039222,
0.4849637449,
0.329058826,
0.1895080358,
-0.7266463041,
-0.3914172053,
-0.1590865701,
-0.230363816,
-0.6857680678,
0.3371583521,
0.4424320161,
0.6324872971,
0.5094150901,
-0.3444336057,
0.6198046803,
-0.7450611591,
0.7108630538,
0.126753971,
-0.6613736749,
0.2699663341,
-0.0732540712,
0.6095608473,
0.6666400433,
0.4186786711,
-0.7581586242,
-0.2599059641,
-0.5982879996,
-0.4466959536,
0.5919142962,
-0.3375543058,
0.390380621,
-0.3254780471,
0.6212347746,
0.0799004436,
0.0161580835,
-0.5630153418,
-0.0933481231,
0.2526133657,
-0.0659807473,
-0.2423115522,
-0.6359837651,
-0.169608742,
-0.0982177928,
0.4294181764,
0.0417108312,
0.3877087235,
-0.2178824991,
-0.4639214575,
0.1992142498,
0.3995226324,
0.8552229404,
0.4338300526,
-0.3307089508,
0.4226812124,
0.6346042156,
-0.6258796453,
0.1578951627,
-0.3725126386,
-0.1620161086,
-0.020637203,
0.4780177176,
0.7501666546,
0.3894304037,
-0.6384116411,
0.4440856576,
-0.0515779592,
-0.1273566037,
-0.6187630892,
0.1464699954,
0.2379832417,
0.2866400778,
0.3241616189,
-0.1047791541,
-0.1699154377,
-1.0730171204,
0.2154658139,
0.6087095141,
-0.1662209332,
-0.2958897352,
0.4407959878,
-0.1982513368,
-0.436509192,
0.8801938891,
-0.2267910838,
-0.5729860663,
0.4283345938,
0.719583869,
0.7922666669,
-0.2648139894,
-0.2952606678,
0.5068048239,
-0.014521041,
-0.763744235,
0.0969333202,
0.0351812132,
-0.9864141941,
0.0703068823,
-0.4654408991,
-0.3004946411,
0.3312831819,
-0.7373452187,
0.0667400956,
-0.6244334579,
-0.1324039251,
-0.0752642825,
0.0146147776,
-0.6222123504,
-0.0706159845,
0.3117008209,
0.9773419499,
-1.0347570181,
1.1247649193,
0.2225513607,
-0.2903796732,
-0.5835542083,
-0.2098483592,
0.1708231866,
-0.8260256052,
0.6437446475,
0.283716768,
-0.0221250281,
-0.0051422352,
-0.4401911199,
-0.7906085849,
1.0142554045,
0.4748632312,
-0.7701877952,
-0.0083317459,
-0.1438289732,
0.5617718697,
-0.3768007457,
0.0537286885,
0.923025012,
0.0399764366,
0.1141062453,
-0.9408182502,
-0.2961764336,
0.0647345483,
0.0757342651,
0.2799884081,
-0.5785449743,
0.8748217225,
-0.5039768815,
-0.4114479125,
0.315643549,
0.3772577941,
0.5212818384,
0.2629759312,
0.3592432439,
0.570561707,
0.6879832745,
-0.0306819901,
1.2246803045,
0.1974298805,
0.3202103078,
1.3125745058,
-0.3706592619,
1.1880298853,
0.4679661393,
-0.077637136,
-0.025029568,
0.4272366762,
0.0443657935,
0.6249389052,
0.0527511202,
-0.3461204767,
-0.3703396618,
-0.0160377789,
-0.1851830781,
0.410143733,
0.0920209289,
-0.4480198026,
-0.016278699,
0.3158370256,
0.0230648015,
-0.1509429663,
-0.4193311632,
0.9232462645,
0.3679234385,
-0.5024953485,
0.7613793612,
-0.3196875751,
0.4769992232,
-0.6979846954,
-0.0197672006,
-0.3397953212,
0.4880794585,
-0.0094823902,
-0.6476415396,
0.2914815545,
-0.1209990308,
-0.4519409537,
-0.1481822133,
0.6217225194,
-0.6804739237,
-0.3084671795,
0.1784608811,
0.2859196961,
0.5749256015,
0.1017753333,
-0.3306121528,
0.1805465519,
-0.2078206688,
-0.2523382008,
0.6490821838,
0.1231132671,
0.0020431527,
0.7523997426,
0.1765663326,
0.2869607806,
0.4150170386,
0.0915806666,
0.5295330286,
-0.977191031,
-0.007538043,
-0.9683104753,
0.1712465137,
0.1809496433,
-0.2144013643,
0.6465044022,
0.7593614459,
0.9517186284,
-0.2388907671,
0.6165862083,
0.3664591312,
0.6529403329,
-0.7136201859,
0.3966211081,
-0.3855729699,
0.1049921215,
0.0179639328,
-0.8699231744,
-0.2276044339,
0.868254602,
-0.3327133656,
0.0078912275,
0.8810874224,
0.6602617502,
-0.0904241279,
-0.2832973003,
0.5586509705,
0.4700368941,
0.1494969577,
0.9873550534,
0.9514266849,
-0.4932205081,
0.469081074,
-0.1303874403,
0.2069249004,
-0.2641655207,
-0.726947546,
-0.8471444845,
-0.501329422,
-0.2161991745,
-0.1426680833,
-0.0511206761,
1.0321207047,
0.4623988271,
-0.74872154,
-0.3467192948,
0.0966603607,
-0.0834508091,
-0.2002063543,
-0.1455607563,
0.2462623268,
-0.0135626532,
-0.6260565519,
0.4258134067,
0.4004442096,
0.5669289827,
-0.1765367538,
-0.0060703214,
-0.301685065,
-0.0140756527,
0.6446974874,
0.8730993867,
-0.6183458567,
-0.5882467628,
0.0978846923,
-0.369227767,
0.2622915804,
0.800498426,
-0.8901337385,
0.4435441792,
0.4975909591,
0.6660978198,
0.8423189521,
-0.2304383814,
0.2828502357,
-0.6301108003,
0.3056704104,
0.2369400561,
0.5113113523,
0.1867248863,
0.1937681884,
0.190035373,
0.2035439014,
-0.4823519886,
-0.8886083364,
0.4282736778,
-1.0634841919,
-0.1856391728,
1.1083877087,
-0.1948171556,
0.0397356078,
-0.1167775542,
-0.1888486743,
0.1022492424,
-0.0095621943,
0.8642584085,
1.0429228544,
-0.2225657851,
-0.3954435587,
-0.6272767782,
0.3822957873,
0.2955363393,
-0.521037221,
0.2242515683,
0.5636335015,
0.6670498848,
0.1472937763,
0.9439647794,
0.1196811944,
0.3021536171,
0.0538928024,
-0.2681720853,
0.0478563979,
-0.6082026362,
-0.8439578414,
0.1668709069,
0.3291613162,
-0.2220555693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17548v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17548v1 | Whose Opinions Do Language Models Reflect? | 2023-03-30T17:17:08 | 2023-03-30T17:17:08 | Shibani Santurkar, Esin Durmus, Faisal Ladhak, Cinoo Lee, Percy Liang, Tatsunori Hashimoto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) are increasingly being used in open-ended contexts,
where the opinions reflected by LMs in response to subjective queries can have
a profound impact, both on user satisfaction, as well as shaping the views of
society at large. In this work, we put forth a quantitative framework to
investigate the opinions reflected by LMs -- by leveraging high-quality public
opinion polls and their associated human responses. Using this framework, we
create OpinionsQA, a new dataset for evaluating the alignment of LM opinions
with those of 60 US demographic groups over topics ranging from abortion to
automation. Across topics, we find substantial misalignment between the views
reflected by current LMs and those of US demographic groups: on par with the
Democrat-Republican divide on climate change. Notably, this misalignment
persists even after explicitly steering the LMs towards particular demographic
groups. Our analysis not only confirms prior observations about the
left-leaning tendencies of some human feedback-tuned LMs, but also surfaces
groups whose opinions are poorly reflected by current LMs (e.g., 65+ and
widowed individuals). Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/tatsu-lab/opinions_qa. | [
-0.5672345757,
-0.4593767822,
0.4785877764,
-0.0354526676,
-0.011362412,
0.1930346787,
-0.0739650056,
-0.2073162198,
0.0977087319,
0.6643423438,
-0.2824572921,
-0.40411973,
-0.2733930051,
-0.0552190281,
-0.3286386728,
0.909045279,
0.451569289,
0.513897121,
-0.2177113891,
-0.1410512328,
-0.0962733999,
-0.7206988931,
-0.1999985576,
-0.5204343796,
0.736897707,
0.2920794487,
1.5067020655,
0.3267724514,
0.0230191443,
0.1446499527,
-0.1301074326,
-0.2824614644,
-0.5289145708,
-0.2645426691,
-0.1957801729,
-0.4578192532,
-0.3271344006,
0.4234130085,
0.4576351345,
0.896304965,
-0.2502222657,
0.2502713799,
0.1741681993,
0.7778707743,
-0.5969019532,
-0.2324953526,
-0.6455544233,
0.0063149082,
-0.0945900679,
-0.009708574,
-0.5388607979,
-0.6966519356,
0.2177506238,
-0.0295487884,
0.1262987405,
0.1264578104,
0.8554719687,
0.3372936547,
-0.6961007714,
-0.1016255319,
-0.7135695219,
1.0594832897,
-1.1573923826,
0.5867695212,
0.3438905776,
0.2452379912,
-0.3292504549,
-0.1267177165,
-0.7729355693,
-0.0179930534,
-0.0147631951,
0.2200004011,
-0.2186500728,
-0.033643458,
0.1248192564,
0.1545733511,
-0.645712316,
0.1337777376,
-0.4378293157,
-0.0128541691,
0.5475048423,
0.1156223789,
0.3804166019,
-0.2712470591,
-0.3098430634,
0.0168477111,
-0.823667109,
0.3152458072,
0.6796879768,
0.3998885155,
0.1748431772,
0.5570061207,
-0.147525847,
0.8681089282,
-0.1717929542,
0.2299572676,
0.3529848754,
0.0467859358,
-0.254258424,
-0.2223007232,
0.9553568363,
0.7163857222,
0.5485278964,
0.0969203562,
-0.2782106698,
0.0221771169,
0.2768649459,
-0.5440231562,
-0.0960052833,
0.2770943344,
-0.6183333397,
-0.2037179023,
0.2850623727,
-0.8913869262,
-0.9776535034,
-0.451094538,
-0.0021359026,
0.0756081566,
-0.4951677322,
0.3206692636,
-0.0130082183,
0.2930342853,
0.4471306205,
-0.4617399871,
0.3114598095,
0.8347999454,
0.6025642753,
-0.0759530514,
0.011538039,
-0.1949331015,
-0.3719340265,
-0.4300321639,
0.90981251,
-0.7097912431,
-0.5962955952,
0.0910567343,
-0.0977112576,
0.0828253254,
-0.6584980488,
0.2349368781,
-0.5531790257,
0.6999107599,
-0.6105764508,
-0.4847997725,
-0.0639459044,
0.0342113338,
-0.5310252905,
0.9623048306,
-0.118914403,
-0.7349098325,
0.3408327699,
-0.3710110188,
0.2023275346,
-0.0582505353,
-0.393142581,
-0.2414004654,
0.1233578101,
-0.0014798115,
0.2176874429,
-0.4820939302,
0.2686396837,
-0.6763215661,
0.0723445639,
0.7852265835,
-0.2626029551,
0.8579686284,
0.3432432115,
-0.1076208428,
0.1936180592,
-0.4042894542,
0.2147662193,
-0.0772760287,
-0.2677696347,
-0.3632952273,
0.4015611708,
0.1456336975,
0.4510166943,
0.1533008367,
-0.7946741581,
0.2154251188,
-0.4362493455,
0.4346363246,
0.8459025621,
0.0195168722,
0.5941281915,
-0.4852499366,
0.6931962967,
0.0235075112,
0.426577419,
0.3802128136,
-0.7770603299,
-0.6357756257,
0.2995094061,
0.2139942795,
0.25841254,
-0.2677879333,
0.1479518414,
-0.1717459857,
-0.5983871818,
-0.6795920134,
0.0941830203,
0.2805909514,
0.4229618907,
0.1343282759,
-0.2993276119,
-0.3270894587,
-1.1248784065,
-0.5714429021,
-0.7371031642,
0.0528229065,
0.3124878407,
0.4460202754,
-0.097873956,
1.4194350243,
-0.4149655998,
0.3142520487,
-0.0148210181,
0.1649151146,
0.3149279654,
0.1887983084,
0.484815836,
-0.7811896801,
-0.2230156511,
-0.2473829687,
-0.3306910098,
-0.3121652305,
0.1727538109,
-0.2545513511,
0.3359588087,
0.0514029004,
-0.3276021183,
0.239174813,
0.8165498972,
-0.5260328054,
0.5123044848,
0.2539018393,
0.2145502716,
-1.0705879927,
0.0274405181,
0.1815200001,
-0.125177756,
-0.5644958615,
-0.3265084922,
-0.0497868434,
0.0642167702,
-0.612680912,
0.7635138631,
-0.2979474366,
-0.1684072316,
-0.1385103762,
0.0421334729,
0.0207529515,
0.1599732935,
0.0901885256,
0.6278467178,
0.0357619822,
-0.2138841152,
0.0326446444,
0.1726385057,
-0.4880349338,
0.3539511859,
-0.5331667662,
0.5535440445,
-0.3582701981,
0.2820489705,
-0.954716146,
-0.3029981852,
0.2126665264,
-0.6925225854,
-0.347622335,
-0.1144137755,
-0.435957998,
-0.3010773361,
-0.2678443789,
0.1598519087,
0.5753560066,
-0.1417226791,
0.5655814409,
0.8022173643,
-0.3336644471,
-0.8223853707,
-0.5265339613,
0.1039635241,
-0.0445102677,
-0.2993757725,
-0.209590435,
-0.0787756443,
-0.8956158161,
0.1074014232,
0.1621989161,
-0.1307449639,
-0.0455274023,
0.4078966975,
0.2137770206,
-0.122996524,
0.3357276022,
-0.3810070157,
0.1131896526,
0.0600255802,
-0.0369980522,
0.5583098531,
-0.2748185992,
-0.4170553386,
-0.048133783,
0.2343753427,
0.7736159563,
-0.1923067421,
0.7485096455,
-0.0838918313,
-0.3253629804,
-0.090903759,
-0.6372124553,
-0.0214763638,
-0.3909825087,
0.4150734842,
0.1184722334,
-0.841776371,
0.440294832,
0.1873796731,
0.3493967354,
0.2911784053,
0.743927002,
-0.4029833674,
1.3256998062,
0.3418432474,
-0.533033669,
0.4324169755,
0.0753684938,
0.0904872641,
-0.5891483426,
-0.0838869363,
-0.8160295486,
-0.356102109,
-0.3616588712,
-0.3801082373,
0.1218472347,
0.1066131666,
-0.4108285904,
0.0015426114,
-0.3299210668,
0.4321305752,
0.418397963,
0.0773140639,
0.2212523371,
-0.3766628504,
0.1913822144,
-0.0919946432,
-0.5651455522,
-1.0611386299,
0.9964309335,
0.4461658597,
0.8244449496,
0.1787177622,
0.4243455827,
0.5569247603,
0.6562685966,
-0.7893104553,
0.5719255209,
0.0841371566,
-0.8105499744,
-0.4108363986,
-0.5479457974,
-0.7501727343,
0.1893324256,
-0.2118091583,
-0.6052597165,
0.3290781975,
0.1676246524,
-0.2136184275,
0.3571464717,
-0.3493397832,
0.9025115371,
-0.3329949379,
-0.2126882076,
-0.3019312918,
-0.5965634584,
0.2660629451,
-0.0031942143,
0.4475342631,
-0.4828774333,
0.0629437044,
0.8079715371,
-0.6169453263,
0.9765065312,
-0.488193959,
-0.4281719923,
0.2646444738,
-0.0899332613,
0.1044494435,
-0.1929077953,
-0.4513948262,
0.1909177899,
0.0463901348,
-0.4360563457,
-0.6561669111,
0.6399988532,
-0.95238024,
-0.6887639165,
-0.4334502518,
-0.3730326593,
-0.3309985995,
0.054730542,
-0.0004504283,
0.4582470357,
-0.3537436426,
0.0368483402,
0.3137035072,
-0.3011826277,
0.2125905752,
0.5204466581,
-0.6902868748,
-0.4232055247,
0.6105340719,
0.3293091357,
0.5523418784,
0.0585432388,
0.3476253748,
-0.405423671,
-0.1711247116,
-0.5848077536,
0.2842482924,
-0.7347918153,
-0.0920130089,
-0.3550836444,
-0.0213512089,
-0.1976443082,
0.1961813867,
-0.412089467,
-0.37439394,
-0.1698360592,
0.1216824055,
0.0964418352,
1.0210822821,
0.6656008363,
0.2449282706,
-0.7960124016,
-0.066683501,
0.2940653563,
0.2472732514,
-0.060279984,
-0.3663109541,
-0.1201144308,
0.3902003467,
-0.154285565,
-1.0833562613,
0.2276171744,
0.1022842005,
0.4405887127,
0.3405356705,
0.2882605791,
0.4916748703,
-0.2883099914,
1.1384212971,
-0.0396717638,
-0.778691709,
0.2048809081,
-0.3930552006,
0.4708942771,
0.5223821402,
0.3420203924,
-0.9360507131,
-0.6359744668,
-0.3458628058,
-0.2787967324,
0.4219801128,
-0.0370913893,
0.2088216245,
0.0222461708,
0.2043268681,
0.1796661913,
0.3340440392,
-0.6791145802,
-0.1149283871,
-0.2569407821,
-0.4177034199,
0.0223581847,
-0.1821218282,
-0.0209503192,
0.139371857,
0.5651260018,
-0.0793533698,
0.0131385718,
-0.1125629246,
0.0846496895,
-0.3523421884,
0.6614163518,
0.488771081,
0.8614948988,
-0.1706316173,
0.2292666286,
-0.1206336766,
-0.211439088,
0.2676780224,
-0.2713697851,
-0.4372633994,
0.1152124405,
0.1886294037,
0.5803227425,
-0.0576293655,
-0.6261217594,
0.5623586774,
-0.1710151434,
0.1488430053,
-0.1909445077,
-0.1047992557,
0.2116580009,
0.0922941566,
0.377271831,
0.2026767135,
-0.0527894571,
-0.7593919039,
-0.1422351152,
0.6542651057,
-0.689680934,
-0.6233066916,
0.475818485,
0.2098201215,
-0.4218402207,
0.358761847,
0.2730798423,
-0.648896277,
0.3796245754,
0.130573228,
0.8620298505,
-0.3366258442,
0.3516524136,
0.2085747123,
0.1478533745,
-0.1186451614,
0.4989109337,
0.2570957541,
-1.0304710865,
-0.2822716534,
-0.7476696372,
-0.6674505472,
-0.0451720841,
-0.7677986026,
0.3574742675,
-0.3141921759,
-0.6326622367,
-0.2411481291,
-0.3512586951,
-0.4163869917,
0.3868132532,
0.3158040643,
0.7318147421,
-0.7969083786,
0.7457050681,
0.8913212419,
-0.3310318887,
-0.5821018219,
0.2739561796,
0.2845900357,
-0.6947541237,
0.4617919624,
-0.0989196226,
-0.5055805445,
-0.1164375991,
-0.7247561216,
-0.6798856258,
0.4404390454,
0.3518652618,
-0.6460283399,
0.0143090393,
0.4449905157,
0.6638749242,
-0.3288551569,
0.1890478432,
0.3254687786,
0.3346503377,
-0.4447624385,
-1.0602068901,
-0.2419889867,
-0.3660603762,
-0.1051399335,
0.3942085803,
-0.7153222561,
0.6656262279,
-0.1298019588,
-0.2938344777,
-0.028215291,
0.6025559902,
0.1486565769,
0.1443700194,
0.8804787397,
0.3064457476,
0.6518341303,
0.0885873586,
0.9915058613,
-0.5940340161,
0.4033918977,
1.0620979071,
-0.4025815129,
1.1514828205,
0.5304602981,
-0.4149996042,
0.5732934475,
0.5923178792,
0.4079316854,
0.4050824344,
0.4301162362,
-0.1020170972,
-0.3433912992,
-0.4178691506,
-0.3206703663,
0.3945904672,
0.0985840559,
-0.2612679899,
0.0345311314,
-0.1584304273,
0.0651015565,
0.3247812986,
-0.1958938837,
0.7118961811,
0.1603617966,
-0.7488347888,
0.380625844,
-0.2293673456,
0.3491296172,
-0.2917953134,
-0.0384628512,
-0.1668711156,
-0.1039182097,
-0.4394799471,
-1.1175825596,
0.1247837022,
0.1980158687,
-0.390091002,
-0.2416462749,
0.2015151829,
-0.3483526707,
-0.3780348599,
0.2199976444,
0.7589024901,
0.1634548753,
0.0405062325,
-0.6277192831,
0.0759594142,
0.0346867368,
-0.4329469204,
0.1791410297,
0.0499388762,
-0.2022258192,
0.572191596,
0.4198741913,
0.2461336553,
0.04913776,
0.4266417921,
0.7035729885,
-0.7665059566,
-0.1338288337,
-0.8206635118,
0.5710350275,
-0.0738430992,
-0.5527233481,
0.6789838672,
0.7042459249,
0.8793468475,
-0.0150500266,
0.996019125,
0.216452077,
0.7747420669,
-0.4977218807,
0.7728974819,
-0.4659771025,
0.2547571957,
-0.3220499754,
-1.0630302429,
-0.0796051919,
0.3808670938,
-0.658801496,
0.1484061033,
0.2794304788,
0.9550535679,
0.2962778807,
0.1362913102,
0.2378029823,
0.3320953846,
0.3230528235,
0.2046141922,
1.4572223425,
0.0101124607,
0.1650701314,
0.0686101913,
-0.1365597099,
0.0379777327,
-0.7327736616,
-0.5818610191,
-0.5760297775,
-0.38337484,
-0.4713177979,
-0.137266472,
1.2070885897,
0.5221584439,
-0.94683218,
-0.5221117735,
0.1184691787,
-0.0802951753,
0.2664502859,
-0.2814505994,
0.1715362519,
0.0873939916,
-0.8462331891,
0.0286487062,
0.1097326204,
-0.1825554818,
-0.7141271234,
-0.3144566119,
0.0480121896,
0.2641210556,
0.1293946356,
0.3206183612,
-1.2736973763,
-0.528069675,
0.175567463,
-0.4673461914,
0.1461873055,
0.7467609048,
-0.6973198652,
0.606266439,
0.5658903122,
0.2886258066,
-0.188117519,
0.3572248816,
0.841992557,
-0.3924362063,
-0.1835036129,
0.4673848748,
0.4576060772,
0.4967749715,
-0.0012301119,
0.295101583,
-0.0105372993,
-0.8113381267,
-0.8689741492,
0.3329857886,
-0.7978475094,
-0.1809310466,
1.2294783592,
0.0123937232,
-0.1676386744,
-0.1028750315,
-0.2915595472,
-0.0803778917,
-0.7176910639,
0.7986804843,
0.7688882947,
-0.1597411931,
-0.337921828,
-0.5506775975,
0.430662781,
0.4428074956,
-0.6713854671,
0.2248730361,
0.7240595222,
0.1662522852,
0.0703029558,
0.6874570251,
-0.1135067269,
0.0758823678,
-0.5064029098,
0.3193028867,
0.3710287213,
-0.0822210759,
-0.5111174583,
0.0256581847,
0.4106694162,
0.2011797279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17517v1 | Hindi as a Second Language: Improving Visually Grounded Speech with Semantically Similar Samples | 2023-03-30T16:34:10 | 2023-03-30T16:34:10 | Hyeonggon Ryu, Arda Senocak, In So Kweon, Joon Son Chung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.SD, eess.AS | The objective of this work is to explore the learning of visually grounded
speech models (VGS) from multilingual perspective. Bilingual VGS models are
generally trained with an equal number of spoken captions from both languages.
However, in reality, there can be an imbalance among the languages for the
available spoken captions. Our key contribution in this work is to leverage the
power of a high-resource language in a bilingual visually grounded speech model
to improve the performance of a low-resource language. We introduce two methods
to distill the knowledge of high-resource language into low-resource languages:
(1) incorporating a strong pre-trained high-resource language encoder and (2)
using semantically similar spoken captions. Our experiments show that combining
these two approaches effectively enables the low-resource language to surpass
the performances of monolingual and bilingual counterparts for cross-modal
retrieval tasks. | [
-0.2496225685,
-0.618170321,
0.2214954048,
0.2408638746,
-0.595258832,
0.4971273541,
-0.387512356,
-0.4715359509,
0.2484227568,
0.4851698279,
-0.3831364512,
-0.2237074822,
-0.6781468987,
0.019394448,
-0.2404147238,
0.6036222577,
0.2820864618,
0.6594470739,
-0.0475174189,
-0.5245206952,
-0.7990180254,
-0.361366272,
-0.438878715,
-0.4383554459,
0.2931989431,
0.5484628081,
0.8533120751,
0.4369033277,
0.2736147046,
0.3047278821,
-0.2653515041,
0.0184798539,
-0.502482295,
-0.0732776448,
-0.3647794724,
-0.6397718191,
0.18889907,
-0.1835702062,
0.7967451215,
0.6861786842,
-0.2748931944,
0.1025817767,
0.2426537275,
0.5560740232,
-0.5836110115,
0.3585273921,
-0.633615911,
0.1143866926,
-0.1597725898,
-0.1577009559,
-0.3748986721,
-0.1867545545,
-0.0294520222,
-0.4776133895,
0.2603784502,
0.0564864092,
0.9742258191,
0.4263225198,
-0.3029504418,
0.1777253896,
-0.5142768621,
0.9058955908,
-0.5058256388,
0.7799130678,
0.2787263095,
0.4946581423,
0.5860250592,
-0.3916523159,
-0.7768458128,
-0.2688896358,
-0.2997283638,
0.3016851842,
0.1230969727,
-0.2014365643,
0.2948967218,
0.3087976873,
-0.4323847592,
0.1122220978,
-0.6672736406,
-0.2103888839,
0.3099671602,
-0.2515815198,
0.5779750943,
-0.5080854893,
-0.3314686418,
-0.3542864621,
-0.6761184335,
0.0666422769,
0.3186862171,
0.5854384303,
-0.3514996469,
0.9340364337,
-0.2442359179,
0.7717149258,
-0.0001154194,
-0.2337770909,
0.3311812878,
-0.5608866215,
-0.1817265749,
0.3047333956,
0.4725298882,
0.3590708077,
0.4093726277,
-0.000192713,
0.2168541551,
0.1397996396,
0.1003346294,
-0.5284382105,
-0.0982771739,
-0.5382094383,
-0.5124971867,
0.0575519726,
-0.171569556,
-1.1855180264,
-0.4831922948,
-0.6788899899,
0.2741692364,
-0.5048883557,
-0.5426198244,
-0.2278864682,
-0.1904568821,
0.676782012,
0.1984717846,
-0.9646289349,
0.1971573383,
0.4663783908,
0.833760798,
0.1432628632,
-0.4577986002,
-0.8778714538,
0.2908022702,
-0.2683140934,
0.5240514874,
-0.7671920657,
-0.6057685018,
0.0403914079,
-0.0604186282,
-0.119930245,
-0.6608794332,
0.4449420571,
-0.4946887791,
0.037468031,
-0.6969288588,
0.219543606,
-0.2562981844,
0.0278874952,
-0.5862157345,
0.9654418826,
0.1889423281,
-0.6926230192,
0.7523519397,
-0.3123762608,
-0.5198379159,
0.0318247601,
-0.4251017869,
-0.0094959121,
0.1899265051,
0.3135811687,
0.1272254139,
-0.5710328817,
-0.0527699366,
0.0433288515,
-0.1509665251,
-0.3987662196,
-0.2203836888,
0.511190176,
0.2541256845,
-0.3487859368,
0.1732332706,
-0.8478230238,
0.3521803319,
0.170677036,
-0.224428609,
-0.4256059229,
-0.0300612263,
0.4040921926,
0.2996762097,
0.0839378536,
-0.4951539338,
-0.3550281227,
-0.7104084492,
0.2187484205,
0.4799743593,
-0.3219432235,
0.5147795081,
0.0764873326,
0.3968401551,
0.1934628189,
-0.2042953074,
-0.1206835732,
-0.3885408044,
-0.8382525444,
-0.1876779348,
0.0449404716,
0.7391171455,
-0.9540368915,
-0.0571302697,
-0.3419092298,
-0.3470495939,
-0.7019112706,
0.5340825915,
0.7920945883,
0.6059736013,
0.4666231275,
-0.4600740075,
-0.6645100117,
-1.0850627422,
-0.4208000898,
-0.4061340392,
0.3446151316,
0.3170597851,
0.0051426464,
-0.2169378847,
0.7810513973,
-0.3387781978,
-0.2662576139,
-0.5059371591,
0.1083301604,
-0.1175284609,
0.5012158751,
0.7959196568,
-1.284483552,
-0.8052484393,
0.3112808168,
-0.733104527,
-0.0591522194,
0.3425092101,
-0.1008266136,
0.2145897895,
0.6717624664,
-0.3809437454,
0.2122637182,
0.5761390328,
-0.2243972421,
0.0456580594,
-0.1667722166,
0.3713030815,
-1.1446088552,
-0.2482814938,
-0.0460958146,
-0.0654658675,
-0.4526184499,
0.179416582,
-0.0936242342,
-0.5999486446,
-0.5838988423,
0.6140710711,
-0.6123930812,
-0.0972154289,
-0.4401921332,
-0.078381978,
-0.2732073665,
0.5085483789,
0.2333135307,
0.9432796836,
0.9400399923,
-0.2310825437,
0.416074723,
0.3171707094,
-0.213612169,
0.7824572325,
-0.7365592718,
-0.2263760865,
-0.5539390445,
-0.3063004613,
-1.0212594271,
-0.4748755693,
0.1220167652,
-0.2634509504,
0.6801191568,
-0.3971936107,
-0.6470415592,
-0.0176560096,
0.1469450593,
0.6788588166,
0.8021588326,
-0.7837696671,
0.5626760125,
0.5506677628,
-0.308914423,
-0.4303897023,
-0.9587650299,
0.0343708359,
-0.2872871459,
-0.554913938,
-0.0623849109,
0.2930873334,
-0.3338173926,
-0.007352253,
-0.0644496232,
-0.234262988,
-0.4073375165,
0.3981841505,
-0.0921546742,
-0.3094351888,
0.0775506347,
-0.1184453219,
-0.2061650157,
-0.2725025117,
-0.2102882117,
0.6847358942,
-0.4310716689,
-0.7899017334,
-0.3608671129,
0.7807266712,
0.5829080939,
-0.5874807239,
0.8641498089,
0.9127151966,
-0.4046174288,
0.2464430332,
-0.6388348937,
0.1440291852,
-0.4149833024,
0.4715865552,
-0.5624932051,
-0.7049894929,
0.4948046803,
-0.0751762539,
-0.4700635374,
0.5469095111,
0.6379075646,
0.3275440037,
0.9420930743,
0.9758076668,
-0.1608002484,
0.523519814,
-0.0941901281,
0.494222343,
-0.4353150725,
-0.5181226134,
-0.4570948184,
0.1285324097,
-0.6785543561,
-0.582013905,
0.3932052553,
0.4212001264,
-0.0475175083,
0.3316203654,
-0.4718916118,
0.5776797533,
0.777695775,
0.1004056856,
0.0742397308,
0.2794547379,
-0.1937337965,
-0.4397542179,
-0.773357451,
-0.3855842352,
0.5462017059,
0.1026226431,
0.7734665275,
0.4392408729,
0.5198194385,
-0.0461857915,
-0.0242520273,
-0.7096090913,
0.4631606042,
-0.1589942425,
-0.3414603472,
-0.3467550874,
-0.0871805847,
-0.4888313115,
0.5852467418,
-0.1301802248,
-0.553388536,
0.1196821481,
0.1155850813,
-0.0890277103,
0.1186849549,
-1.1464215517,
0.8409751654,
-0.3956526816,
-0.6129313707,
-0.6217668056,
-0.6621844769,
0.36365363,
-0.0580200069,
0.303976655,
-0.0032449802,
0.143547684,
0.6129730344,
-0.3590135872,
0.7544689178,
-0.249076426,
0.1374079436,
0.5070285797,
-0.2472853959,
0.179293409,
0.1726691872,
0.065385893,
0.1519865543,
0.0195184797,
-0.7128069401,
-0.5554414392,
0.7896154523,
-0.8234555125,
-0.8403390646,
-0.4701282382,
-0.1945174038,
-0.3545142114,
0.3882276714,
0.2265221775,
0.22925964,
-0.0557619072,
0.1928789467,
0.4303282797,
-0.3843074739,
0.4734601378,
0.2627647221,
-0.0931693912,
-0.4710229635,
0.7632434368,
0.0621848926,
0.4131830931,
0.3146348894,
0.2072995305,
-0.5535283685,
-0.2738487124,
-0.5866959691,
0.3105553687,
-0.9307917356,
0.0658221245,
-0.6311822534,
-0.2554017305,
-0.4736289978,
-0.1784004569,
-0.4975354671,
-0.1717716604,
-0.0669115633,
-0.1681712717,
0.309846133,
0.4530945718,
-0.26776281,
0.3590665758,
-0.7619370818,
0.6994057894,
0.5218827128,
0.5196915269,
-0.0153135192,
-0.480179131,
-0.2355125397,
0.2460244447,
-0.0337384678,
-0.8969655037,
0.4615617096,
0.3536192775,
0.7802304029,
0.109793812,
-0.4039048254,
1.0408600569,
-0.8353319764,
0.8116081953,
0.675060153,
-0.938354671,
0.8322507739,
-0.2415594012,
0.2541349828,
0.6277015805,
0.2882604301,
-0.3298462629,
-0.017274553,
-0.3847306371,
-0.7739771605,
0.752096355,
0.1388253719,
0.245085746,
0.0839196891,
-0.06756524,
0.0015859792,
0.1009961367,
-0.7797371149,
-0.0389627889,
-0.730063796,
0.1051333696,
-0.3865925372,
-0.5890982151,
-0.3824055791,
-0.4473342597,
0.4136191905,
-0.1137992144,
-0.06159297,
0.0510635227,
-0.212074697,
-0.183699578,
0.4473512769,
0.5326890945,
0.596013248,
0.0026430176,
0.3095749319,
0.4323666692,
-0.3548833132,
0.2443999797,
0.0328854769,
0.098253347,
0.2357947528,
0.2826118469,
0.8177727461,
0.4194160402,
-0.864936173,
0.376128912,
0.2608623803,
0.3128372431,
-0.1956289709,
-0.1165374145,
0.0375276022,
0.2797040641,
0.2361347675,
0.1668940187,
-0.1672383547,
-0.9437224269,
0.1557241678,
0.3924679756,
-0.4583249986,
-0.1102785245,
0.8767813444,
0.157270506,
-0.2724917829,
0.2077039629,
-0.0729312673,
-0.5778723955,
0.2835825682,
0.5606389046,
0.7536062002,
-0.123175174,
0.1131473035,
0.5586963296,
0.2599442005,
-0.2367324382,
0.4383307397,
-0.2465127558,
-0.3738696873,
-0.3882931769,
-0.7953888774,
-0.2375121117,
-0.3030388951,
-0.6713621616,
0.5212888122,
-0.3150688112,
0.0258225426,
-0.1031293944,
-0.2629518509,
-0.6574134231,
0.1618100852,
0.2026263773,
0.4811123908,
-0.9978736639,
0.6901926398,
0.8022306561,
-0.7324294448,
-0.8457785249,
-0.1067237183,
0.007952163,
-0.7956650853,
1.165573597,
-0.0405245386,
-0.3510995209,
-0.0657933354,
-0.2488638461,
-1.0787522793,
0.764608562,
0.4432180822,
-0.3986807466,
0.0293038543,
0.3173611462,
0.8077555895,
-0.0287153367,
0.0024296918,
0.1574257165,
0.3744618595,
0.2470880896,
-1.3031243086,
-0.1972942203,
-0.2718110681,
0.1643850058,
-0.0452919155,
-0.9218260646,
0.6894136071,
-0.2476216108,
-0.3722242713,
-0.0446229018,
0.8184277415,
0.3045090735,
0.3133808672,
0.3880163431,
0.6267082691,
0.404189378,
-0.1117137894,
0.9830994606,
-0.3194802999,
0.121074222,
0.949290216,
-0.4740776122,
0.7929635644,
0.7202937603,
0.0188965071,
0.1085893437,
0.3119463921,
0.1083565876,
0.7887914777,
0.0604196452,
-0.2411190122,
-0.3867901862,
-0.5566731095,
-0.6056659222,
0.7505044937,
-0.0859933197,
-0.168803677,
-0.5669152141,
0.3346889913,
-0.39955917,
0.7571835518,
-0.3463278711,
0.6835570335,
0.0777733922,
-0.6379231215,
0.8761940598,
0.0571288951,
0.5052404404,
-0.4725974202,
-0.2145498246,
0.1368043423,
0.0608424582,
-0.1503850669,
-0.6932491064,
0.5568746924,
0.2495766431,
-0.359880805,
-0.4529325962,
0.6301308274,
-0.5975150466,
-0.6723085642,
0.4926524162,
0.6750087142,
-0.0171548668,
0.1758009642,
-0.3259837031,
0.0205100738,
-0.0779199228,
0.3285765648,
0.2552809119,
0.3865060806,
-0.1093697473,
0.5823748708,
0.5508623123,
0.2586685419,
0.5333961844,
0.4184146821,
0.7562589049,
-0.7321802378,
-0.5789001584,
-0.7363705039,
0.3982396126,
-0.0099550989,
-0.0691684708,
0.8039358854,
0.7271894813,
1.090301156,
-0.3358896971,
0.7756137848,
-0.0859220624,
0.6299999952,
-0.7837827802,
0.7366866469,
-0.6196818352,
0.0368138403,
-0.2226239592,
-0.9652177691,
-0.138725087,
0.626299262,
-0.0282850824,
-0.0038378537,
0.5099899173,
0.9095826149,
-0.2429188192,
-0.2152396441,
0.5011808872,
-0.0281738546,
0.0803563595,
0.3512886465,
0.9739693403,
-0.3810578883,
0.438498348,
-0.1577370465,
-0.0398558825,
0.0633755326,
-0.5966103673,
-0.9367038012,
-0.7540609241,
-0.2303554416,
-0.276984632,
0.1185319722,
0.7214974165,
0.8428986669,
-0.64638412,
-0.2516391873,
0.0834907219,
0.0682331249,
0.1024346501,
-0.1722022146,
0.1567673385,
-0.1727930605,
-0.9538211823,
0.4520207345,
0.3936809003,
0.1275630593,
-0.1041370407,
-0.1677998006,
-0.4099179208,
-0.2036159188,
0.7839441299,
0.5085961223,
-1.002456665,
-0.4202306867,
-0.1699220985,
-0.1906268597,
0.01287618,
0.8135293126,
-0.778062582,
0.6722627878,
0.6506243944,
0.6672773957,
0.4487131238,
0.2192393839,
0.4087747335,
-0.6902856827,
0.7966142893,
0.0161094405,
0.4685538411,
0.5685905814,
-0.138021186,
0.4976984859,
0.3943379521,
0.1206981391,
-0.8716250658,
0.4020206034,
-1.2616366148,
0.0333935358,
1.3914318085,
0.2849583328,
0.1130416319,
0.2448789328,
-0.5130434036,
0.5071073771,
0.0509401374,
0.4622963667,
0.7317423224,
0.1841669679,
-0.5534574986,
-0.5051394701,
0.4703068733,
0.6491388679,
-0.4094646275,
-0.1317293942,
0.4567252398,
0.161714226,
0.3530109525,
0.4964920282,
-0.2187875211,
0.2153369635,
0.233620137,
-0.1256687939,
0.1040061936,
-0.3086819649,
-0.4560822546,
0.2275200635,
0.1203178242,
-0.1865185648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17491v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17491v3 | Language Models can Solve Computer Tasks | 2023-03-30T16:01:52 | 2023-11-16T20:15:14 | Geunwoo Kim, Pierre Baldi, Stephen McAleer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | Agents capable of carrying out general tasks on a computer can improve
efficiency and productivity by automating repetitive tasks and assisting in
complex problem-solving. Ideally, such agents should be able to solve new
computer tasks presented to them through natural language commands. However,
previous approaches to this problem require large amounts of expert
demonstrations and task-specific reward functions, both of which are
impractical for new tasks. In this work, we show that a pre-trained large
language model (LLM) agent can execute computer tasks guided by natural
language using a simple prompting scheme where the agent Recursively Criticizes
and Improves its output (RCI). The RCI approach significantly outperforms
existing LLM methods for automating computer tasks and surpasses supervised
learning (SL) and reinforcement learning (RL) approaches on the MiniWoB++
benchmark. We compare multiple LLMs and find that RCI with the
InstructGPT-3+RLHF LLM is state-of-the-art on MiniWoB++, using only a handful
of demonstrations per task rather than tens of thousands, and without a
task-specific reward function. Furthermore, we demonstrate RCI prompting's
effectiveness in enhancing LLMs' reasoning abilities on a suite of natural
language reasoning tasks, outperforming chain of thought (CoT) prompting with
external feedback. We find that RCI combined with CoT performs better than
either separately. Our code can be found here:
https://github.com/posgnu/rci-agent. | [
-0.4210881591,
-0.978302002,
0.7338520885,
0.1785324514,
0.0245008562,
0.1546854824,
-0.5550761819,
-0.4822461009,
-0.0602495372,
0.3098442852,
-0.8195996881,
-0.3179157376,
-0.5108829141,
0.3357487917,
-0.1856333315,
0.8016469479,
0.0555041134,
0.0064209849,
-0.1702279896,
0.2824446559,
-0.6050695181,
-0.4198825061,
-1.0807242393,
-0.7063442469,
0.6402388811,
0.4942082763,
0.8229543567,
0.4429783821,
0.320204854,
0.4213680625,
0.3453574479,
0.3927132487,
-0.2398877144,
-0.0312586017,
-0.190969184,
-0.5165215731,
-0.3894268274,
0.080482766,
0.2638030648,
0.475356549,
-0.3227844238,
-0.1859275103,
0.0133300954,
0.5731275678,
-0.4098363221,
0.3316351175,
-0.4630449712,
-0.2146040648,
0.2938845754,
-0.4262144566,
-0.8434942961,
-0.3929753304,
0.0263536405,
-0.7275056243,
-0.0231661052,
0.1244206876,
0.7743340731,
0.437030375,
-0.2408509851,
-0.6187061667,
-0.5908233523,
0.8994021416,
-0.6857081652,
0.1752449274,
0.2389273047,
0.28163293,
-0.4335705042,
-0.5195223689,
-0.6799985766,
-0.7905910611,
-0.3044362068,
-0.12396539,
-0.3235074282,
0.2272951603,
0.660525322,
0.053972628,
-0.3892919719,
0.2384505421,
-0.0233631283,
-0.1057109982,
0.3936930895,
0.2137099802,
0.470800221,
-0.1113879234,
-0.0857978314,
-0.4459323585,
-0.5687377453,
0.284208566,
0.1790035069,
0.4607794583,
-0.0504142679,
0.2654305995,
-0.236242637,
0.9118497372,
-0.0132119171,
-0.1668886244,
0.0007341017,
-0.078964971,
-0.2658299506,
-0.2550189197,
0.8220427632,
-0.0340429544,
0.7055812478,
-0.0229674987,
-0.3253292739,
0.0792057067,
0.1751565486,
-0.6179885864,
-0.2363316417,
0.2016276717,
-0.2646000385,
-0.161668241,
-0.0565961897,
-0.3832860291,
-0.4279002249,
-0.6496118903,
0.6734464765,
-0.4730620384,
-0.0848958343,
0.1274984628,
-0.1531997025,
0.3687761724,
0.5589559078,
-0.7462077141,
0.5390691161,
0.6952426434,
0.5073948503,
-0.0909389034,
-0.3931520283,
-0.8803677559,
-0.1544240713,
-0.4306488633,
0.8155892491,
-0.5396054983,
-0.1712564528,
0.0537939519,
-0.067815505,
-0.104305163,
-0.7064622641,
-0.0476203114,
-0.5420802832,
0.0862992629,
-0.1629117727,
-0.3058988154,
0.0170517992,
0.4355659187,
-0.6380212307,
0.8482159972,
-0.0952719674,
-0.4285393655,
0.1313923299,
-0.7105007172,
-0.5966123343,
-0.0030274927,
-0.2526198328,
0.0137946894,
-0.2028169334,
0.4058161378,
0.5264358521,
-0.458366245,
0.2489815801,
-0.0415706933,
-0.451798141,
0.2722127736,
-0.3443705142,
0.6649367809,
-0.0583219379,
-0.4574335814,
0.2336506546,
-0.4919361174,
0.2642498314,
0.3063602746,
-0.3266210258,
-0.0530690663,
-0.0849569663,
-0.3507341743,
0.2064257711,
0.1974351108,
-0.4037728012,
0.5037879348,
-0.4898219705,
0.3037346303,
0.7249999642,
-0.1003176719,
0.3647367656,
-0.5353719592,
0.6777386665,
-0.4229015708,
0.0480308197,
-0.2452849001,
-0.413557142,
-0.7693378329,
-0.4660895467,
0.0254528001,
0.77082932,
-0.9744673967,
0.0478577614,
-0.1478377134,
-0.3883472681,
-0.4558505714,
0.2375608385,
0.4857758284,
0.2723086476,
0.4154132605,
0.1263515055,
-0.4442380369,
-0.8749377728,
-0.2331508249,
-0.2841522396,
-0.0424700566,
0.3058599532,
0.339898169,
-0.262365371,
0.8570695519,
-0.3299298882,
-0.2313845605,
-0.6939146519,
0.5749825239,
0.3471196592,
0.363581419,
-0.044308953,
-0.5444369316,
-0.4620380998,
0.2026999742,
-0.6584147215,
-0.3200138509,
-0.4027686715,
0.1176360101,
0.3094480932,
0.5090430975,
-0.8430128098,
0.4366854131,
0.2301540971,
-0.0756015107,
0.5757685304,
-0.5201079249,
0.3141845763,
-0.6019908786,
-0.0599750541,
-0.1640815139,
-0.5304231048,
-0.5545982122,
0.1429511756,
0.0627274662,
-0.1610361785,
-0.353880167,
0.5775895715,
-0.5139529705,
0.0244906694,
-0.8334608078,
0.2093830854,
-0.1603642404,
0.7475183606,
0.3250621259,
0.61725384,
0.4829451442,
-0.8417503238,
0.5175991654,
-0.0434608646,
-0.0200052373,
0.1312506646,
-0.6833608747,
0.3170132041,
-0.1206100434,
0.1911054999,
-0.7518675327,
-0.1647151113,
0.0834125355,
-0.524458468,
0.4420164526,
0.1434842795,
-0.6110723019,
-0.4268098772,
-0.218959257,
0.151807636,
0.7109083533,
-0.694642067,
0.7203406692,
-0.0515184253,
-0.041319903,
-0.6220692992,
-0.4915415347,
0.0549373031,
0.3447756469,
-0.3353054821,
0.2589814961,
-0.1972379833,
-0.3611644208,
-0.0877936929,
0.1392887831,
0.14674595,
0.0104000866,
0.2946383953,
0.400375843,
0.0121466788,
0.0372737348,
-0.2652831674,
-0.3553902507,
0.0363247916,
-0.0935091302,
0.6374806166,
-0.1889742017,
-0.4808057547,
-0.8544484377,
0.3171270192,
0.4303790927,
-0.0790717229,
0.5273171663,
0.2727545202,
-0.3081774116,
-0.4504137933,
-0.6100899577,
-0.4805056155,
-0.5112591982,
0.333008647,
-0.3468089402,
-0.8938392401,
-0.0697427914,
-0.0987642854,
0.233016938,
-0.0056177266,
0.4674101174,
-0.1578782648,
1.2830907106,
0.7378023267,
-0.3084846437,
0.4881021082,
-0.2854786515,
0.2789296508,
-0.2507741451,
-0.1286524087,
-0.5647089481,
-0.0356087871,
-0.4830667078,
-0.3628708124,
0.1318746507,
-0.0571836941,
-0.2285817415,
0.4799924493,
-0.4604430497,
0.5074173808,
0.5579624772,
-0.009709849,
0.2983450294,
-0.0321171209,
-0.1424290687,
0.2212766409,
-0.6913608313,
-0.7008005381,
0.5851128101,
0.2898822427,
0.9374539852,
-0.1090399623,
0.7336655259,
0.5369987488,
0.6695752144,
-0.8808048964,
0.7683441639,
0.0890660882,
-0.242862463,
-0.4704771936,
-0.3474208713,
-0.8468953371,
0.1979348958,
-0.1274967343,
-0.7124336958,
-0.0355030559,
0.4101960063,
-0.1922632307,
0.137540549,
-0.8667833805,
0.7659494877,
-0.1592031121,
-0.2256139815,
-0.5593671203,
-0.2488308549,
0.1093770564,
0.3417764902,
0.3947381675,
0.1102891266,
-0.0452217199,
0.5094684958,
-0.4346764386,
0.7627023458,
-0.2819162905,
-0.0439104401,
0.3562412858,
0.3067837954,
0.9986539483,
-0.2588647008,
-0.0899906009,
-0.4905797839,
-0.0801283121,
-0.374920547,
-1.0665057898,
0.750898242,
-0.6097157598,
-0.9650253654,
-0.3766783774,
-0.514609158,
-0.2729441226,
0.0478149243,
0.0104711466,
0.5146154761,
0.0938273072,
-0.1089797541,
0.5964109302,
-0.322982192,
0.610204041,
0.6651493907,
-0.2048471272,
-0.1637315899,
0.9101707339,
-0.3270294368,
0.3955025971,
0.5446133614,
0.1882693768,
-0.1283052713,
-0.2802828252,
-0.3498458564,
0.4016692936,
-0.8173972964,
-0.2119915932,
-0.6726285219,
-0.0173092447,
-0.2576563954,
-0.336907357,
-0.1869354993,
-0.0515371151,
-0.0767856017,
-0.0403828472,
0.1811193824,
1.0277750492,
0.0399965458,
0.1855118424,
-0.4998538494,
0.4065467715,
0.685195148,
-0.0938714817,
0.2557063997,
-0.3918933868,
-0.1703024656,
-0.0896703228,
-0.2548542023,
-0.8600396514,
0.3879199624,
-0.0567638017,
0.5922711492,
0.2056946307,
0.1334415674,
0.7713413835,
-0.4687204063,
0.4943112731,
0.1623233706,
-0.9630541205,
0.5528771877,
-0.2503727078,
0.4625133574,
0.4036621749,
0.4419730604,
-0.3746560514,
-0.6853524446,
-0.3215534687,
-0.5361439586,
0.9275167584,
0.0361514986,
0.0175074805,
-0.2206123173,
0.1766562611,
-0.1530338526,
0.1232229844,
-0.9732729197,
-0.0991729572,
0.0772700086,
-0.2669687867,
0.0482105054,
-0.0762516782,
0.172267139,
-0.1992222071,
0.9318528771,
-0.3134377003,
0.462349385,
0.4363095462,
-0.3637348711,
-0.0170719437,
0.4596972466,
0.4475463033,
0.4806886315,
-0.0170209538,
0.0642523244,
0.3180208206,
-0.0838958621,
0.2159999609,
-0.0179502182,
0.1398458183,
-0.2407648116,
0.6404314041,
0.5682318211,
0.0977598131,
-1.0237506628,
0.5971288681,
-0.2143732011,
-0.1904987842,
-0.276258558,
0.2395431995,
0.1945532858,
0.2311144024,
0.4838420153,
-0.1542880833,
0.0005579388,
-0.6663114429,
0.0900987089,
0.5426651239,
-0.4341615438,
-0.0703096166,
0.2414750308,
0.0409095846,
-0.6304157972,
0.6846561432,
-0.2696705163,
-0.4823199511,
0.8104932904,
0.7092798352,
0.5998837352,
0.0605845191,
0.3018982708,
0.3489491045,
0.4588139653,
-0.1259354055,
0.2145386636,
-0.3339325786,
-0.6180728078,
-0.6969205737,
-0.3361601532,
-0.5179210901,
0.1099277437,
-0.4100241959,
0.1584758013,
-0.6654481888,
-0.0185012203,
0.0301742796,
0.0260914005,
-0.808693409,
0.2835758626,
0.1412190646,
0.9581912756,
-0.5369382501,
1.0420386791,
0.7035527825,
-0.3365017474,
-1.1222732067,
-0.167288214,
-0.17346403,
-0.5580028892,
0.9537463784,
0.3784627318,
-0.6253182292,
0.0022846961,
-0.7214714885,
-0.5198811889,
0.8943992853,
0.3965451419,
-0.6035923362,
0.0109379925,
-0.0568655059,
0.5684062243,
-0.5065312982,
0.6617352366,
0.4461302161,
0.5468025804,
-0.0895751789,
-0.9123098254,
0.2129450291,
-0.2878138125,
-0.1729346216,
0.1446816921,
-0.3132915497,
0.6381882429,
-0.4661472738,
-0.2564907968,
0.1972363889,
0.6300956011,
0.3916309476,
0.2150714397,
0.7373552918,
0.1666513681,
0.7569453716,
0.014950064,
1.3699953556,
-0.0689147189,
-0.001182901,
1.0254819393,
-0.3261770606,
0.8747090101,
0.4239730537,
-0.0592142865,
0.8892297745,
0.2909706831,
0.3259235919,
0.2905322015,
0.2198114395,
-0.2723392546,
-0.7127278447,
-0.1488356292,
0.1980207711,
0.0341853127,
0.2005011141,
-0.0481899306,
-0.0436940715,
0.352160126,
-0.0985346213,
0.4548526406,
-0.2244932801,
0.8262693286,
0.1384232789,
-1.0855052471,
0.6462296844,
0.0911775604,
0.7617807984,
-0.7362685204,
-0.3278647363,
0.029686382,
0.2228861749,
-0.1401325166,
-0.3615046144,
0.0350911729,
0.0164429676,
-0.2232834995,
-0.4630170465,
0.740457058,
-0.2271223366,
-0.1220745221,
0.5162627101,
0.335742712,
0.0584002547,
0.0030549834,
-0.6425274014,
-0.0805881098,
0.0228300411,
-0.1866241097,
0.2805525362,
0.2193434387,
-0.1071406156,
1.2295327187,
0.745678246,
0.0699546784,
-0.1766581237,
0.2382631898,
0.8477796912,
-0.8420802355,
-0.4413001835,
-0.8941717744,
0.2748430371,
-0.0664934888,
0.281739831,
0.5187097192,
0.2031562179,
0.7002871633,
-0.2684143186,
0.7148150802,
-0.1497894675,
0.5286414623,
-0.5417805314,
0.2728561163,
-0.5133252144,
0.2390501201,
-0.1135172918,
-0.5749419332,
-0.1559487879,
0.5680214167,
-0.4978378713,
0.1612778455,
0.9535979629,
1.0924637318,
0.2293402553,
-0.0474421605,
0.4836018085,
0.032917399,
0.3516628444,
0.6787924767,
1.0741502047,
-0.0354727358,
0.6972923279,
-0.1316518486,
-0.3507901132,
-0.0035927168,
-0.8812345266,
-1.1104342937,
-0.2339453548,
-0.3619471788,
-0.1113587618,
0.1648165733,
1.3631507158,
0.8453041315,
-0.8770100474,
-0.3583285213,
-0.2122685909,
0.3617713153,
-0.4354730546,
-0.2314695716,
0.1394927055,
-0.7313967943,
-0.7480384111,
0.7255334854,
0.1854005307,
-0.0814866573,
-0.2165488452,
-0.3925865591,
-0.2721311152,
0.2656293511,
0.4945091605,
0.4361328185,
-0.8322194219,
-0.2604644597,
0.0695727766,
-0.3057825863,
-0.1005010828,
1.0698009729,
-1.08804214,
0.3020850718,
0.4358361065,
0.6757909656,
0.2891184688,
-0.0326472744,
0.7015981674,
-0.5035502315,
0.1694880128,
0.2008956522,
0.2289604843,
0.3082588017,
-0.3912006915,
0.1010192111,
-0.0468495823,
-0.5692032576,
-0.5196828246,
0.3164251447,
-0.7564399242,
-0.4432319999,
1.051877141,
0.0252991486,
-0.4513629973,
-0.1295270473,
-0.5426079035,
0.1516584903,
-0.5904241204,
0.5404751897,
0.6360147595,
-0.1952894181,
-0.3796845973,
-0.5018481016,
0.7295578718,
0.6064351201,
-0.9026700258,
0.1325818449,
0.3803972006,
0.1311121285,
0.0384293236,
0.8715391159,
0.0716682673,
0.5390700698,
-0.342363447,
0.2875951231,
-0.4466786981,
-0.4625404775,
-0.3438937366,
0.1516084671,
0.4461283684,
-0.0403175205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17475v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17475v2 | Efficient distributed representations beyond negative sampling | 2023-03-30T15:48:26 | 2023-10-30T09:34:17 | Lorenzo Dall'Amico, Enrico Maria Belliardo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | This article describes an efficient method to learn distributed
representations, also known as embeddings. This is accomplished minimizing an
objective function similar to the one introduced in the Word2Vec algorithm and
later adopted in several works. The optimization computational bottleneck is
the calculation of the softmax normalization constants for which a number of
operations scaling quadratically with the sample size is required. This
complexity is unsuited for large datasets and negative sampling is a popular
workaround, allowing one to obtain distributed representations in linear time
with respect to the sample size. Negative sampling consists, however, in a
change of the loss function and hence solves a different optimization problem
from the one originally proposed. Our contribution is to show that the sotfmax
normalization constants can be estimated in linear time, allowing us to design
an efficient optimization strategy to learn distributed representations. We
test our approximation on two popular applications related to word and node
embeddings. The results evidence competing performance in terms of accuracy
with respect to negative sampling with a remarkably lower computational time. | [
-0.4110202789,
-0.4946389496,
0.3701679707,
0.2058397084,
-0.0758377239,
0.0126586203,
-0.2611880898,
-0.2252877653,
0.291023761,
0.0204935987,
-0.6407341957,
-0.4561115801,
-0.7123429775,
0.0839571804,
-0.1022001058,
0.3798085153,
-0.1656813622,
0.3298630416,
-0.257031858,
-0.7424915433,
-0.4733315706,
-0.3815819621,
-0.4114694595,
-0.5823818445,
0.3167793155,
0.3926145434,
0.4823032916,
0.5369022489,
0.1066417471,
0.2510561943,
0.1805283129,
0.3653638363,
-1.1790040731,
0.1866692752,
-0.043010585,
-0.6498275995,
0.1840481013,
0.1984482855,
0.8175526261,
0.795332849,
-0.2523826957,
0.0969347134,
-0.0145018706,
0.6048125029,
-0.8283875585,
0.2796002924,
-0.4001244307,
0.3819845021,
-0.032615874,
-0.2910044491,
-0.3915336132,
-0.7491732836,
-0.0456966497,
-0.9826942086,
0.3803648651,
-0.2366249859,
0.4835399091,
-0.029546449,
-0.1571433693,
-0.6077245474,
-0.8174948692,
1.1708579063,
-0.1579164416,
0.5248086452,
0.2301803529,
0.3890410364,
-0.06464196,
-0.4801845253,
-0.5521845222,
0.0289542135,
0.402289629,
0.120905675,
-0.2050767541,
0.1870941371,
0.3411636651,
0.0557112731,
-0.2183930427,
0.0668194667,
-0.2750240862,
-0.2706225812,
0.6489192843,
0.0303150006,
-0.0261517093,
0.0883827209,
-0.315713048,
-0.2709464729,
-0.6969043016,
-0.2696253061,
0.3156800568,
0.1019366458,
0.2135509551,
0.5861968994,
0.2698787153,
0.3539670706,
-0.0640299395,
0.004793549,
0.3972808719,
-0.0842260048,
0.0264118314,
-0.162736237,
0.1126931757,
0.5305979848,
0.4096001089,
-0.1602228582,
-0.3977796733,
0.2257239521,
0.0654217899,
-0.9251234531,
0.0760367364,
-0.105975695,
-0.3954930902,
0.0063010124,
-0.0495029092,
-0.684218049,
-0.6469170451,
-0.4165736139,
0.7269002199,
-0.1609208733,
-0.1584637761,
-0.0002729029,
-0.4368414879,
0.0343523845,
0.4988720715,
-0.6139694452,
0.6093792915,
0.7038814425,
1.1163516045,
0.0644214153,
0.155455634,
-0.6793120503,
-0.202231586,
-0.7041942477,
0.4426964223,
-0.5473051667,
-0.5530612469,
0.2081472129,
-0.3238859773,
-0.0012300216,
-0.6609663367,
0.0710254833,
-0.7579951286,
-0.2550565302,
-0.5350580215,
-0.92457515,
-0.1986987591,
0.2575816512,
-0.6332556605,
1.00704813,
0.4252826571,
-0.7336819172,
0.3523060679,
-0.363440007,
-0.3030562997,
0.0284855999,
-0.4331925511,
-0.4888536036,
0.4110680819,
0.06846416,
0.6646096706,
-0.1490558386,
-0.3693218529,
-0.4744827151,
-0.8467684984,
-0.1946428418,
-0.1105482206,
0.6796683669,
0.3233404756,
-0.3963178098,
-0.2894255519,
-0.5666298866,
0.0397465341,
0.243574664,
-0.1802535355,
-0.6346942186,
0.0560824163,
-0.2134613246,
-0.2984717488,
-0.0034467762,
-0.7352690697,
0.4393271208,
-0.5562650561,
0.5345204473,
1.0093450546,
-0.0303471833,
0.7775348425,
-0.0392874181,
0.6434852481,
-0.2888111472,
0.0709907264,
0.1110860705,
-0.3365750909,
-0.382114023,
-0.390175432,
0.2857628167,
0.2966343164,
-0.7735917568,
-0.1904860437,
-0.2410284728,
-0.5378658175,
-0.4208923876,
0.254440248,
0.0392314009,
0.018351065,
0.3773415089,
-0.1959985793,
-0.4583187401,
-0.5864618421,
0.0124445064,
0.2194412351,
0.0382152423,
0.7861775756,
0.405567348,
-0.6084651947,
0.8327312469,
-0.8498958349,
-0.2537574172,
-0.2880933285,
0.2597743869,
0.4367546737,
0.2451592833,
0.6362866163,
-0.6793519855,
-0.6336011887,
-0.3223343194,
-0.4396423399,
-0.1416353136,
-0.2194535881,
0.0287889615,
0.0865123123,
0.6777349114,
-0.3916538358,
0.4238551855,
0.7742724419,
0.0593146421,
0.3275146782,
-0.5305662155,
-0.187336117,
-0.8648301363,
-0.1698838472,
0.0762564614,
-0.5045049787,
-0.4164348543,
0.102580592,
0.1931195706,
-0.3255229294,
-0.1892000735,
0.2740987539,
-0.9763298035,
-0.1131688803,
-0.0939517543,
0.4158323705,
-0.0908717066,
0.2859406769,
-0.2997355461,
0.759755671,
0.5001012087,
-0.5163451433,
0.3868661523,
-0.0080132382,
0.0176839661,
0.547115624,
-0.7035694718,
0.1464858353,
-0.7075200081,
0.4049091935,
-0.796449244,
0.28727597,
0.0093808006,
-0.3404300213,
0.5320976973,
-0.1541278511,
-0.4099378884,
-0.4111242592,
-0.8651659489,
0.419382453,
0.5165808201,
-0.625792563,
0.3558919132,
0.5926897526,
0.586211741,
-0.7196885943,
-0.6816816926,
-0.2884257138,
0.1397977471,
-0.3857254982,
0.3429254293,
0.0076864064,
0.1102619171,
0.0828065649,
-0.2889970839,
0.1252727211,
-0.0788221732,
0.2651440203,
-0.3391952217,
-0.0648136064,
0.5390180945,
0.0538472272,
-0.1871587485,
-0.350025624,
-0.6059638262,
0.575926125,
0.1196811497,
-0.5284036398,
-0.2466989011,
0.6454946399,
0.3249241412,
0.0108792596,
0.890329659,
0.7048344016,
-0.7415431738,
-0.666056335,
-0.5543327928,
-0.2449560016,
-0.481926918,
0.469686836,
-0.3522732854,
-0.9064911604,
0.5444101691,
-0.2910124958,
0.0585756265,
0.4974865913,
0.5447240472,
-0.0433790646,
1.0363967419,
0.8910903335,
0.0560885631,
0.6655783653,
-0.9313581586,
0.0761373565,
-0.4247395396,
-0.1555875689,
-0.4145770967,
-0.5455995798,
-0.9850949645,
-0.9739845395,
0.4690174162,
0.2746562958,
0.0573489629,
0.3651609421,
-0.5003520846,
0.428581506,
0.553141892,
-0.0081235161,
-0.244212836,
0.1125056446,
-0.3335467875,
-0.1240101606,
-0.906964004,
0.0177824069,
1.1536021233,
0.4854244292,
0.9859936237,
-0.0310856383,
1.2193760872,
0.5009217858,
0.4472406805,
-0.9191042185,
0.3809570968,
-0.2537097335,
-0.3935373127,
-0.3266667128,
-0.6695319414,
-1.0219433308,
0.1055199951,
-0.3522148728,
-0.5415138006,
0.5512956381,
0.1590647846,
-0.0666678175,
0.2450892776,
-0.9304581881,
0.4782568216,
0.5816117525,
-0.1507249624,
-0.9072013497,
-0.3115098476,
-0.4336136281,
0.1201210842,
0.1976596415,
0.0060448688,
-0.2065911889,
0.8930989504,
-0.5185446143,
0.7454525828,
-0.8917855024,
0.2866219878,
0.669270277,
-0.0290212911,
0.776272893,
0.1856490821,
-0.2980476916,
0.0512693711,
0.0181419775,
-0.7069912553,
-0.7355182171,
0.6129125953,
-1.0475735664,
-0.3588909507,
-0.4484082758,
-0.0881791636,
0.0357847586,
0.2005423605,
0.2047605664,
0.7567629218,
-0.1952992976,
0.3655517101,
0.801379323,
-0.2544999421,
0.3956781626,
0.246840179,
0.3077353537,
-0.3600927591,
0.9381347895,
0.8592723012,
0.0253780372,
0.669339478,
0.4540494084,
-0.3525284231,
-0.6806364059,
-0.1857598722,
0.3580465317,
-0.8595484495,
-0.3688185513,
-0.6574372053,
-0.1303186864,
-0.2292503119,
-0.2117579877,
-0.7180777788,
-0.4456318617,
-0.5949152112,
-0.1709240079,
0.1505741179,
0.9729285836,
-0.6011634469,
0.0124173146,
-0.6462740898,
0.2067309171,
0.3594453335,
0.4686860144,
0.1235409454,
-0.0941945314,
-0.4557689726,
0.020422563,
-0.2873317003,
-1.1335505247,
0.1007923409,
0.5850813985,
0.7039406896,
0.4230336547,
0.2026930749,
0.6581660509,
-0.4953456521,
0.5468890667,
0.3456971645,
-0.889151752,
0.0906378999,
0.0879464746,
0.1170408949,
0.4658938348,
0.6914402843,
-0.7228139043,
0.008696083,
-0.3704966009,
-0.8007122278,
0.4162398279,
0.1468657106,
0.6585951447,
-0.0349490345,
0.5748415589,
0.3034084141,
-0.0343771353,
-0.17061764,
-0.4077620208,
-0.3050840795,
-0.1677338332,
-0.4150492251,
-0.513299644,
-0.0988134667,
-0.3140375316,
0.4312788546,
-0.2778491378,
0.6978154778,
0.4179952443,
-0.3870621324,
-0.0987065211,
-0.0457591824,
0.5303400755,
0.6228642464,
-0.0745324194,
0.393897593,
0.4265047312,
-0.6760469675,
0.1526293308,
0.1799023896,
-0.1272629052,
0.0973750502,
0.4078392088,
0.5379958153,
-0.1106831431,
-0.4567162693,
0.9114031792,
-0.2131973654,
-0.2644646168,
-0.1838315129,
-0.1319212466,
0.1334414333,
0.5078976154,
0.5377393365,
0.206218645,
0.1103719026,
-0.2170365006,
0.2876498699,
0.5137696266,
-0.4294218719,
-0.3843723238,
0.2733330727,
0.2066905349,
-0.0785356387,
0.5762972236,
-0.5680397749,
-0.5943456888,
0.4684561491,
0.5029407144,
0.7414364219,
-0.0530064292,
0.3868460059,
0.4591711462,
0.11482694,
-0.0969253033,
0.2865811884,
-0.458650589,
-0.8781462908,
-0.3157102466,
-0.4729238749,
-0.3461669385,
-0.3778747022,
-0.3496922553,
0.2259124815,
-0.6302568316,
-0.4613309801,
-0.2420458645,
0.6034437418,
-0.958610177,
-0.0761592984,
0.2100575417,
0.931219101,
-0.9045532942,
0.5523229837,
0.5993020535,
0.2200627327,
-0.8593273759,
-0.2977237403,
-0.1111364439,
-1.0036138296,
0.3884637356,
0.4140352607,
-0.2052725405,
0.0681428164,
-0.3740153313,
-0.664767921,
1.1325677633,
0.478800416,
-0.6892926097,
0.2585979998,
-0.0218657088,
0.5866057873,
-0.2220668644,
0.3358665407,
0.2256214172,
0.2524827719,
0.1426645815,
-0.3162740767,
0.1469675303,
-0.1365704536,
0.2659732103,
0.1450984329,
-0.5136595368,
0.737898767,
-0.2986006737,
-0.62051934,
-0.4634407461,
0.7007625103,
-0.0469292961,
0.3819123209,
0.6306850314,
0.6293631792,
0.875847578,
0.1222368702,
1.03576684,
-0.0399486423,
0.833396852,
0.5246499181,
0.1077416465,
0.4639260471,
0.5405490398,
-0.2586371303,
0.1233016253,
0.6075152159,
-0.0560797788,
0.6784585118,
0.6321899891,
-0.2094618529,
0.0607152171,
-0.1368986517,
-0.4451226592,
0.1366014034,
0.2785579562,
-0.061867591,
-0.4416965842,
0.03761274,
-0.120480977,
0.2296582907,
-0.3509510756,
0.6389493346,
0.3096306026,
-0.2907601595,
0.9019037485,
0.2262230814,
0.8493389487,
-0.3069960475,
-0.1999201477,
-0.153600499,
0.4072804153,
-0.1871745437,
-0.5035544038,
0.3399502933,
-0.4528800547,
0.1085353121,
-0.5221714973,
0.6752305627,
-0.2672301829,
-0.2536279261,
0.4958364666,
0.2359145582,
-0.1307329386,
0.0945064276,
-0.5141152143,
0.1187352836,
-0.178728193,
-0.5244889855,
-0.0989498198,
0.3515063226,
-0.087250568,
0.587146759,
0.2131073773,
0.3368386924,
0.2283620089,
0.2048045844,
0.9958669543,
-0.2712103128,
-0.5109968781,
-0.8128171563,
-0.0530416109,
-0.0178600345,
0.0347814858,
0.5827240944,
0.317107141,
0.8669311404,
-0.0535117351,
0.5932291746,
-0.001173386,
0.2812033594,
-0.1418288797,
0.5077192783,
-0.7127206922,
-0.088948153,
-0.0722667798,
-1.114033103,
-0.381567657,
0.6365371346,
-0.3707588315,
-0.0283841826,
0.4589851201,
0.9583795071,
-0.1162830591,
-0.0500797443,
0.2571799755,
0.0807111785,
0.4576180577,
0.4281237125,
0.4552494884,
-0.3009890318,
0.2147700787,
-0.2972905934,
-0.5776727796,
-0.4667727053,
-0.8856959939,
-0.8229086399,
-0.6200675368,
-0.1100227386,
-0.3531610072,
0.2598050535,
1.2192189693,
0.9445469975,
-0.8462849855,
0.0028186247,
-0.2901260257,
0.3720266819,
-0.3313736022,
-0.1771616042,
0.5532377362,
-0.0872452185,
-0.7031443119,
0.0212628096,
0.0910969898,
-0.1581194401,
-0.4073864818,
-0.2580896616,
0.0013316049,
0.4377016127,
0.5379924774,
0.2192434072,
0.1123602018,
-0.4726544321,
-0.1292874515,
-0.257348299,
0.0641217604,
1.000161767,
-0.4413491488,
0.9148796797,
0.9677018523,
0.8656593561,
1.1398626566,
-0.0981625691,
0.5232247114,
-0.9200155139,
0.3120056391,
0.5977108479,
-0.0767057613,
0.285485357,
-0.3028591573,
0.1969675869,
0.6858989596,
-0.2566985786,
-0.7089168429,
0.1766617298,
-0.646341145,
-0.2537242174,
1.0655553341,
-0.2452197671,
-0.2545594275,
0.2216731161,
0.0684827939,
0.5253227949,
-0.4774105847,
0.5218573213,
0.3895514607,
-0.0477955043,
0.0743483305,
-0.5754798651,
0.3470518589,
0.1145033762,
-0.0134465331,
-0.2419446707,
0.1015196592,
0.3945853114,
0.10417974,
0.9396030903,
-0.0412137844,
-0.0015540891,
0.3023305833,
-0.1207206622,
-0.0840451568,
-0.1402380317,
-0.1756714433,
0.3355741501,
-0.0706269071,
-0.3436505497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17466v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17466v2 | Assessing Cross-Cultural Alignment between ChatGPT and Human Societies: An Empirical Study | 2023-03-30T15:43:39 | 2023-03-31T15:02:48 | Yong Cao, Li Zhou, Seolhwa Lee, Laura Cabello, Min Chen, Daniel Hershcovich | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent release of ChatGPT has garnered widespread recognition for its
exceptional ability to generate human-like responses in dialogue. Given its
usage by users from various nations and its training on a vast multilingual
corpus that incorporates diverse cultural and societal norms, it is crucial to
evaluate its effectiveness in cultural adaptation. In this paper, we
investigate the underlying cultural background of ChatGPT by analyzing its
responses to questions designed to quantify human cultural differences. Our
findings suggest that, when prompted with American context, ChatGPT exhibits a
strong alignment with American culture, but it adapts less effectively to other
cultural contexts. Furthermore, by using different prompts to probe the model,
we show that English prompts reduce the variance in model responses, flattening
out cultural differences and biasing them towards American culture. This study
provides valuable insights into the cultural implications of ChatGPT and
highlights the necessity of greater diversity and cultural awareness in
language technologies. | [
-0.5757279992,
-0.6047489047,
-0.1913428158,
0.1944456249,
-0.1269107908,
0.4830031693,
-0.4360635877,
-0.5435111523,
0.1415490806,
-0.0283569302,
-0.5863755345,
-0.1334462762,
-0.4654936492,
0.0947210118,
-0.1321291775,
1.0153685808,
-0.0302603319,
0.0713681579,
0.2144016325,
-0.2371016294,
-0.7097877264,
-0.6185296774,
-0.6643757224,
-0.3586184978,
0.2654533982,
0.518814981,
0.9311121106,
0.1776804328,
0.5535889864,
0.1438165754,
0.0316412859,
-0.2264085114,
-0.6950761676,
-0.1369137615,
-0.2366553396,
-0.321739614,
-0.1907235086,
0.1473207474,
0.3328472972,
0.5339586735,
-0.1038835421,
0.3596368432,
0.4281536341,
0.435446471,
-0.2941764891,
-0.1318188012,
-0.5706412196,
0.2571186721,
-0.0137909809,
-0.1868844479,
-0.1242484152,
-0.3782488406,
0.5279417634,
-0.3684373796,
0.2837740481,
0.1490363479,
0.8172557354,
0.231526196,
-0.7766853571,
-0.3580376804,
-0.7695453763,
0.5522894263,
-0.1995311528,
0.5178880095,
0.0500353165,
0.4490353167,
-0.2204005718,
-0.3653061092,
-0.4728557169,
-0.0787575394,
-0.0523973741,
0.5469964147,
-0.1067768931,
-0.3569205403,
0.0839230716,
0.2854624093,
-1.0255135298,
-0.0800279453,
-0.5551244617,
-0.5240716338,
0.5195567608,
0.1041509137,
0.7586264014,
-0.1687783003,
-0.5353428125,
-0.1949387491,
-0.5931882858,
0.4925448596,
0.429705292,
0.3138446212,
-0.4239827991,
0.3296252489,
-0.0525259301,
0.460919112,
-0.1305618137,
-0.0286033582,
-0.2043294311,
-0.2469548881,
0.2066739202,
0.2080972046,
0.7436346412,
0.9206616879,
0.6901197433,
0.0356256105,
0.29425776,
0.1073893756,
0.1791305244,
-0.8081995249,
-0.2027479857,
-0.0260786451,
-0.5013930202,
0.2268553972,
0.0775225982,
-0.513820529,
-0.4990047812,
-0.1198848858,
0.0697269961,
-0.4444044828,
-0.2553578913,
0.0245046988,
-0.2905063033,
0.7168959379,
0.3782176077,
-1.0587240458,
0.13850151,
0.7489851713,
0.9434953332,
-0.3089851439,
-0.31488204,
0.1255060136,
-0.3125312626,
-0.2755409181,
0.7046088576,
-0.5199270248,
-0.6028088331,
-0.1639618576,
0.0788169354,
-0.0989632383,
-0.0774648339,
0.5391399264,
-0.3995420337,
0.7369125485,
-0.6854867339,
-0.1086329892,
-0.2169135511,
0.5328091979,
-0.3018675148,
0.767211318,
-0.1869981438,
-0.8091680408,
0.6022955775,
-0.5319600701,
-0.2511469722,
0.0740870014,
-0.1957419515,
0.1139684319,
-0.2208977044,
0.4127747118,
0.0715390369,
-0.2859171331,
0.0318158828,
-0.1886336803,
-0.6056628227,
0.4073190093,
-0.7712426186,
1.0550349951,
0.5779732466,
-0.0446533523,
-0.2585531175,
-0.4261003435,
-0.2079347968,
0.1261966825,
-0.1950430721,
-0.2232275456,
0.0263262354,
-0.0411442593,
0.2978807986,
0.2660918236,
-0.6044259667,
0.1989621818,
0.0027433098,
0.5735681653,
0.5479279757,
0.0677803606,
0.4517791569,
-0.4106995463,
0.8370539546,
-0.2588003874,
0.2167762667,
-0.0855208561,
-0.6826177835,
-0.3633353412,
-0.0557378046,
0.1940895319,
0.9832535386,
-0.2285719365,
0.194068566,
-0.4452906549,
-0.529705584,
-0.5619615912,
-0.2961106002,
0.0534037128,
0.6363949776,
-0.1045709401,
-0.7305447459,
-0.4233079851,
-0.9369840026,
-0.3641929328,
-0.4339148402,
-0.307805419,
0.4002168179,
0.2499187887,
0.1652732342,
1.0803308487,
-0.2652367949,
0.1837437451,
-0.0519023426,
0.0948284715,
0.026668774,
0.3568236232,
0.3033798933,
-0.6825610399,
-0.918555975,
0.3461517394,
-0.5697559714,
-0.2156736553,
-0.2391589284,
-0.3795513213,
0.0404054038,
0.2248646468,
-0.1167727113,
0.3641459644,
0.859606564,
-0.4839836657,
0.46859622,
0.0266941991,
0.7412859797,
-1.4067521095,
0.0732752606,
-0.3301134408,
-0.0758424103,
-0.6072899103,
-0.3275975287,
0.1436941028,
-0.5717663765,
-0.2058259845,
0.7337549329,
-0.2715186179,
-0.1493612975,
-0.0324840024,
0.3090126216,
0.0664120093,
0.2018084377,
0.3623832762,
1.1982989311,
0.2579944134,
-0.226008907,
0.1546109319,
0.6114240885,
-0.2492789924,
1.0032631159,
-0.7044301629,
0.3367214203,
-0.0343783759,
0.5016666055,
-1.2395648956,
-0.2237907052,
0.3647062778,
-0.7110823989,
-0.2695758045,
-0.4332534075,
0.0196887068,
-0.2197970897,
-0.0488510504,
0.4025604725,
0.8585640192,
-0.4351212084,
0.3488766551,
0.1613529921,
-0.5348142982,
-0.6645402908,
-0.4655069411,
0.2726561427,
-0.5052598119,
-1.1484470367,
0.068241559,
-0.0635607094,
-0.3741663396,
-0.4482793808,
-0.1356512308,
0.0149499653,
0.1743048877,
-0.0046710838,
0.0993669704,
-0.3974470794,
0.1902516335,
-0.3266224265,
0.159565568,
-0.032991834,
-0.2634221315,
0.6688497066,
-0.2014589161,
-0.5718753338,
-0.3733534813,
0.4623380303,
0.313318938,
-0.2891609967,
0.5514919162,
0.8335087895,
0.0817092285,
0.3702867925,
-0.4704823494,
-0.307824105,
-0.3944912851,
0.375151366,
-0.2679941952,
-0.8535506129,
0.9766724706,
0.2330771387,
0.0813382193,
0.0073050107,
0.5978188515,
-0.1073705405,
0.866117239,
0.4043520391,
-0.0730476305,
0.5360072851,
0.409188509,
0.3380824625,
-0.5630732179,
-0.0043991967,
-0.6902472973,
-0.5212776661,
-0.9140518904,
-0.2765862346,
0.2946486175,
-0.1504708976,
-0.2994623184,
0.2099596858,
-0.5226649642,
0.4826561809,
0.5500050187,
-0.1718295217,
0.2968967557,
-0.1318908185,
0.2020609528,
-0.1180084869,
-0.67465204,
-0.7403246164,
0.6537476778,
0.2796499729,
0.8703110814,
0.3634716272,
0.4760075212,
0.3423576057,
0.151775524,
-0.7608243227,
0.2585296035,
-0.0375976488,
-0.7346745729,
-0.1741933823,
-0.1641457975,
-1.1646975279,
0.3814755976,
-0.1029819921,
-0.8900541663,
-0.0351121016,
0.2383737564,
-0.2304736078,
-0.1212267652,
-1.2307971716,
1.0191781521,
-0.1642674655,
-0.0712818131,
0.1742489934,
-0.8325832486,
0.1318983585,
0.0571912266,
0.1477590799,
-0.3177622855,
0.1431322098,
0.6107448936,
-0.064142108,
1.0571395159,
0.1281127185,
-0.2363744527,
0.3141141236,
0.1311579049,
0.1978235692,
0.1784607917,
0.2157736123,
0.2297241688,
0.2324054539,
-0.6633073688,
-0.4703665376,
0.3490086794,
-1.0053282976,
-0.7543573976,
-0.1510269791,
-0.9483832717,
-0.2916487455,
-0.0171395447,
0.4394879639,
0.2784638703,
-0.5689851046,
0.0330524147,
0.4304015338,
-0.3776074052,
0.2763011754,
0.4182572067,
-0.2012105733,
-0.0543983951,
0.5387108326,
0.0315939821,
0.416192919,
0.1587021351,
0.3282098472,
-0.2917324305,
-0.0204055756,
-0.6321642399,
-0.0715916976,
-0.7423932552,
0.4324174225,
-0.3491432071,
0.0621290766,
-0.7237874866,
-0.3177057803,
-0.0742110759,
-0.3713195324,
0.276694417,
0.1728759259,
0.3246017396,
0.5299009085,
0.2503696382,
0.4455224872,
-0.9473650455,
-0.260571301,
0.5274081826,
0.1072582603,
-0.3587129712,
-0.690566659,
0.022591833,
0.1995098889,
-0.2027163655,
-0.9879682064,
0.0440055951,
0.2322784513,
0.504956007,
0.2045825571,
0.1830705404,
0.8335303664,
-0.4754975438,
1.2392418385,
-0.1562555134,
-0.7704643011,
0.3379077613,
-0.4874049723,
0.7304845452,
0.3421631455,
0.4995730817,
-1.4561028481,
-0.4016593993,
-0.4825721681,
-0.4947265089,
0.4546191096,
0.0693591237,
0.5818677545,
0.0672404468,
-0.0715444908,
0.2644607127,
-0.1856060177,
-0.7232301831,
0.1484848857,
-0.4491013288,
-0.0784647837,
0.0635839403,
0.1541708857,
-0.3403779566,
0.1923398972,
0.3834469914,
-0.1149566323,
0.1851370633,
0.1898118854,
-0.3753894269,
0.058913853,
0.5516346693,
0.6651293635,
0.6503052711,
-0.0851312727,
-0.0488329753,
0.3329530358,
-0.7286484838,
0.0345402025,
-0.034122441,
-0.0869075358,
-0.358245492,
0.3105558753,
0.6730844975,
-0.2561346292,
-0.4359577596,
0.315982908,
-0.586674571,
0.0994390994,
-0.1661748141,
0.0967787579,
0.0571503565,
0.323343873,
0.3422459662,
-0.0769550279,
0.025886517,
-0.5249927044,
0.1292714179,
0.6727625132,
-0.5740059614,
-0.4304500818,
0.511769712,
0.5277205706,
-0.642324388,
0.6025210619,
-0.0470461026,
-0.7114657164,
0.4362627864,
0.6185635924,
0.6692779064,
-0.2796767354,
0.2023229152,
0.3372989595,
0.4306415915,
0.3106351197,
0.1439421028,
-0.1288897097,
-1.0543507338,
-0.5042040348,
-0.3262150288,
-0.5488309264,
-0.3718998134,
-0.6560547948,
0.3302527666,
-0.1026731506,
-0.1115909442,
-0.3574173748,
-0.0566933304,
-0.5840694308,
0.0898059532,
0.3017651141,
0.8608435988,
-1.1725385189,
0.5521306396,
0.9192366004,
-0.2243634164,
-0.9046970606,
0.4338126183,
0.4618599713,
-1.132404089,
0.4486221075,
0.220280692,
-0.113249056,
-0.0005572787,
-0.2501493394,
-0.7701244354,
0.8798246384,
0.1908827722,
-0.0325957201,
0.3770954609,
0.2622088492,
0.6092494726,
-0.2106393129,
0.4590180218,
0.5742623806,
0.2184816748,
0.1063456982,
-1.409009099,
-0.0387189277,
-0.2342253625,
0.0457525216,
0.3955495954,
-0.7552313209,
0.606228888,
0.0946232304,
-0.3693813682,
-0.1732241511,
0.3999362886,
0.0470257588,
0.0115456423,
0.4791176021,
0.1001690477,
0.7606995106,
-0.1384779513,
0.793048203,
-0.3415857255,
0.2655909956,
0.8985181451,
-0.4149554074,
0.5190779567,
0.5017185211,
-0.4231955409,
0.502885282,
0.8440280557,
0.1145234257,
0.1288678795,
-0.0765082687,
-0.2014691234,
0.0312540047,
-0.2751653194,
-0.5365668535,
0.8751098514,
0.1968349665,
-0.0015057481,
-0.2697635293,
-0.1882595122,
0.1595515609,
-0.0854926258,
-0.0671563596,
0.8710253239,
-0.2084327191,
-1.1601227522,
0.5989766121,
-0.5782641172,
0.5688849092,
-0.5034115314,
0.1740392745,
-0.5284661055,
-0.2586783171,
-0.0521383658,
-0.7581144571,
0.21394068,
0.1386722028,
0.0391137972,
-0.1102929041,
0.5474814177,
-0.4368457198,
-0.0993617699,
-0.0876504108,
0.5066732168,
0.3966596723,
0.1880693734,
-0.7243207097,
-0.0327997729,
0.315533638,
-0.1253791898,
0.4215340018,
0.4676107168,
-0.4590114951,
0.4931519628,
0.5101691484,
-0.1225289404,
0.0079783509,
0.0469419137,
0.2227812707,
-0.4856486917,
-0.7184735537,
-0.7291507721,
0.6729168892,
-0.1997486949,
-0.5298867226,
0.834852457,
0.2384399623,
0.8860118389,
0.0430142581,
0.9053457975,
-0.4136782587,
0.2578404248,
-0.4395298362,
0.6436313391,
-0.2836746275,
0.2062946707,
-0.0214106422,
-1.002294302,
-0.0386922285,
0.558575213,
-0.5143657327,
0.1208184212,
0.6078779697,
0.8593014479,
-0.1081826761,
0.5237796903,
0.2521679699,
-0.1917208582,
0.3133223057,
0.2535941005,
1.2221961021,
0.0175112449,
0.9109743237,
-0.2266476452,
-0.3627976179,
-0.0043255286,
-1.0741577148,
-0.7232236266,
-0.584346652,
-0.1377857625,
-0.2919453681,
-0.1320136636,
1.2303087711,
0.6379762292,
-0.7351314425,
-0.3631822467,
0.5718541741,
-0.2388875782,
-0.1967620105,
-0.2331898957,
0.2349904031,
-0.3490150273,
-0.8415197134,
-0.1052900106,
0.0902319625,
0.2140747607,
-0.1465755403,
-0.0180993397,
0.1190624312,
-0.0885593221,
0.4351798296,
0.413885504,
-0.6646856666,
-0.7869330049,
0.4469711483,
-0.0592522509,
0.1826040149,
0.8854406476,
-0.3982155025,
0.4918347895,
0.6445425749,
0.5150743723,
0.0773601681,
0.4251591265,
1.0831177235,
-1.0348031521,
0.4550458491,
0.1568886638,
0.3627989888,
0.5185158253,
-0.3918202817,
0.4605303407,
-0.0683014318,
-1.0792584419,
-0.3784137964,
0.4691894054,
-0.885904789,
-0.09585765,
1.0552484989,
-0.1612671614,
0.046818655,
-0.4961901009,
-0.6130516529,
0.2365748137,
-0.5667108297,
0.9775072336,
1.077136755,
-0.2712713182,
-0.1478733867,
-0.5994226933,
0.2848781049,
0.6318590045,
-0.4982251227,
0.0728171319,
0.4785645306,
0.4940358698,
0.2294775993,
0.5406592488,
0.0315923691,
0.4289570749,
-0.1841175556,
0.261020273,
0.6011933684,
0.3276638389,
-0.3334361911,
-0.1422686577,
0.3488422632,
-0.0928440019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01005v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01005v3 | Federated Learning Based Multilingual Emoji Prediction In Clean and Attack Scenarios | 2023-03-30T15:31:49 | 2023-07-07T00:51:43 | Karim Gamal, Ahmed Gaber, Hossam Amer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Federated learning is a growing field in the machine learning community due
to its decentralized and private design. Model training in federated learning
is distributed over multiple clients giving access to lots of client data while
maintaining privacy. Then, a server aggregates the training done on these
multiple clients without access to their data, which could be emojis widely
used in any social media service and instant messaging platforms to express
users' sentiments. This paper proposes federated learning-based multilingual
emoji prediction in both clean and attack scenarios. Emoji prediction data have
been crawled from both Twitter and SemEval emoji datasets. This data is used to
train and evaluate different transformer model sizes including a sparsely
activated transformer with either the assumption of clean data in all clients
or poisoned data via label flipping attack in some clients. Experimental
results on these models show that federated learning in either clean or
attacked scenarios performs similarly to centralized training in multilingual
emoji prediction on seen and unseen languages under different data sources and
distributions. Our trained transformers perform better than other techniques on
the SemEval emoji dataset in addition to the privacy as well as distributed
benefits of federated learning. | [
-0.1709367335,
-0.7982278466,
0.1328519583,
0.3222685754,
-0.0182224829,
0.3610341251,
-0.4699697196,
-0.5453796983,
0.4506755471,
0.5358450413,
-0.5892322659,
-0.4474442005,
-0.5415696502,
0.3776784539,
-0.0668352768,
1.0487179756,
0.0183036886,
0.1738090217,
-0.0291546825,
-0.3857999146,
-0.3288570046,
-0.5371519923,
-0.4150972068,
-0.2382506132,
0.5321172476,
0.6106123328,
0.6580317616,
0.2472672909,
0.4827834368,
0.3530884385,
0.2815581858,
-0.0025933243,
-0.6144627333,
0.3538258672,
0.044244796,
-0.590008378,
0.0131884729,
0.1294749379,
0.3722811937,
0.409760505,
-0.1962550282,
-0.0685018301,
-0.2262513191,
0.4567580521,
-0.6998527646,
0.3733969033,
-0.6745567322,
0.5015899539,
0.0054620137,
0.1424368471,
-0.6983419657,
-0.2385281175,
-0.2198561132,
-0.3726492226,
-0.0541229546,
-0.0030623851,
0.6211431623,
-0.0223876089,
-0.4211616218,
-0.0120212678,
-0.5911638141,
0.7616509795,
-0.2191938907,
0.695876658,
0.1928658634,
0.7251921892,
0.0704344362,
-0.6152436137,
-0.4453967512,
0.0219119005,
-0.4433939457,
0.19860439,
-0.3773015141,
-0.0522304215,
0.0985371098,
0.290145278,
-0.3513523638,
0.3104071319,
-0.055067461,
-0.2154711038,
0.6646952033,
-0.1829298437,
0.3796823621,
-0.019501742,
-0.7477710843,
-0.1414215714,
-0.6637442112,
-0.008718838,
0.4537483454,
0.6055209637,
-0.2961592972,
0.3235763609,
-0.4440431893,
0.3643069863,
0.3674945831,
-0.2207260132,
0.5887509584,
-0.2164461017,
-0.2493023872,
-0.0625619888,
1.0431623459,
0.0327479355,
0.3022039533,
-0.5029311776,
-0.5065060258,
-0.2567249238,
0.0524788499,
-0.8995933533,
-0.4019289911,
0.2709726095,
-0.2864560485,
-0.4202236235,
0.0278745331,
-0.8473874927,
-0.5489994287,
-0.1280872673,
0.2690787017,
-0.4613663852,
-0.3243887722,
-0.5842258334,
0.0168543998,
-0.153731212,
0.3656602204,
-1.2042816877,
0.1197601035,
0.7835447192,
0.6707038283,
0.4302208722,
-0.4494978786,
-0.6373143792,
-0.1446372867,
0.0892685652,
0.481304884,
-0.6446270943,
0.1142237708,
0.3270031214,
0.1599540561,
-0.3621416986,
0.003712208,
0.2974061668,
-0.5970924497,
0.1345486194,
0.0241027754,
-0.655636549,
-0.2156674117,
0.4110455811,
-0.9416145682,
0.1756498516,
-0.0647013709,
-1.1598417759,
0.478341341,
-0.6390138865,
-0.7576357722,
0.2206340432,
-0.0857413486,
-0.8401744366,
-0.0732051283,
0.5491092205,
1.0701019764,
0.2865651548,
0.1945155263,
-0.6927204728,
-0.2948857248,
0.4221248031,
-0.3889983296,
0.9855775833,
0.4216870666,
-0.3821797967,
-0.0576753914,
-0.452973187,
-0.0036791458,
0.264893204,
-0.0066077355,
-0.3162277043,
-0.322347194,
0.337210834,
0.2519711852,
0.1075247079,
-0.9591114521,
-0.0627933294,
-0.4199486077,
0.3554780483,
0.6359694004,
0.0072100461,
0.5854910016,
-0.1061278284,
0.3925688565,
0.1508355588,
0.4565380514,
-0.4441849589,
-0.5615508556,
-0.301325053,
-0.4701997638,
0.3001483977,
0.4809262156,
-1.1907049417,
0.0886016414,
-0.5833514333,
-0.5833284855,
-0.5783497095,
0.0431428403,
0.4797253609,
-0.0476060435,
0.0510498509,
0.1126198098,
-0.3927884698,
-0.5681176782,
-0.4321250319,
-0.0669577718,
0.0172800478,
0.4553159177,
0.4575480819,
-0.4810799062,
0.6786734462,
-0.2154765129,
-0.4774602056,
-0.2592226863,
0.0536230467,
-0.0026004894,
0.3041613996,
0.5980703831,
-1.1673253775,
-0.7246803045,
0.4150138497,
-0.6530769467,
0.2783505619,
-0.1975744516,
0.2314799726,
0.5972678661,
0.0411016271,
-0.0202510729,
0.0327001736,
0.9655939341,
-0.2934208214,
0.0857721791,
0.1037515253,
0.3765976429,
-1.4088102579,
0.0123671638,
-0.0744093284,
-0.2523780167,
-1.0157837868,
0.3104646206,
0.1970481128,
-0.3767395318,
-0.5750964284,
0.5397468805,
-0.4418638647,
0.0588744767,
0.0346850827,
-0.20498164,
-0.2876148224,
0.5250428915,
-0.1082446575,
0.5878110528,
0.5214948654,
0.1278111041,
0.3286174536,
0.2590710223,
-0.0715333,
0.3848958015,
-0.2622544467,
0.1235650033,
0.1939853728,
0.2202442586,
-0.8562477231,
-0.505125761,
0.3005084097,
-0.5913760066,
0.5534723401,
-0.1647305787,
-0.7111919522,
-0.1751711667,
-0.0897376314,
0.1698183417,
0.2742743492,
-1.1293998957,
0.6248863935,
0.6092092395,
0.2477142215,
-0.9735597372,
-0.8461702466,
0.0347817354,
-0.1611063778,
-0.7692964077,
-0.2308013439,
0.2387064695,
0.0078502083,
-0.3145207763,
0.3031109273,
-0.3199126124,
0.4972202182,
0.7281297445,
0.0647496283,
0.0774898306,
0.2051416487,
0.0954841524,
-0.040557377,
-0.0370814614,
-0.0117171789,
0.3964623213,
-0.4407141805,
-0.3321869969,
-0.3469333947,
0.3945708871,
0.4369741678,
-0.3778500557,
1.2673158646,
0.9597165585,
-0.4024011791,
-0.1922202408,
-0.6371704936,
-0.2603157461,
-0.4645649791,
0.0837907195,
-0.3907870054,
-1.1647330523,
0.6839339733,
-0.1120511591,
0.2282163054,
0.1932902336,
0.4989837408,
0.0717062429,
0.9448881745,
0.8591066599,
-0.2874935269,
0.681261301,
-0.2053528428,
0.4639011025,
-0.0571810938,
-0.3011215925,
-0.2367385179,
-0.1722080857,
-1.1729652882,
0.025356384,
0.1069011912,
-0.2943628132,
-0.1659828722,
0.3709724247,
-0.2009778321,
0.497474581,
0.2439834028,
0.3032107353,
0.0335625187,
0.5153960586,
-0.3638680279,
0.15659675,
-0.6398619413,
-0.059612263,
1.0177359581,
0.5518215299,
0.6326990128,
0.0318133458,
1.1716250181,
0.0841404274,
0.6963695884,
-0.6223888993,
0.1233394593,
-0.1360539049,
-0.4963847697,
-0.2914675772,
-0.6618382931,
-0.8440528512,
0.1567061245,
-0.5282775164,
-0.6294335127,
0.0695103854,
-0.127930522,
0.0511545315,
0.547540307,
-0.7324903607,
0.7428029776,
-0.0086016934,
-0.0648246035,
-0.0151623664,
-0.9236378074,
0.3002241552,
-0.2996139824,
0.4064458907,
0.0366919264,
0.3670876026,
0.6939871311,
-0.2443847656,
1.1284917593,
-0.2513992488,
0.1951354444,
-0.0353828482,
-0.2043979615,
0.4819338322,
0.2214266062,
-0.0959717706,
0.7941958904,
-0.3482634723,
-0.3438334167,
-0.5611752272,
0.8282034397,
-0.8847663403,
-0.3476194441,
-0.2487424612,
-0.3034143746,
-0.0657404512,
0.3242812157,
0.1801655591,
0.2561202347,
-0.3487400115,
0.2621425986,
0.2955051363,
-0.0069090105,
0.5284985304,
0.5481564999,
-0.0795327947,
-0.7341963649,
0.8096317053,
-0.0282213464,
0.1447286308,
0.7468819022,
0.1428408623,
-0.2226778567,
0.0321802869,
-0.547729671,
0.1802628189,
-0.8596307039,
-0.4514164329,
-0.8220445514,
-0.1602117121,
-0.4609064162,
-0.2942397892,
-0.4317690432,
-0.3920325339,
-0.1116942689,
-0.2213617712,
0.5753301382,
0.4413507283,
-0.1056605577,
0.1794608831,
-0.8548893929,
-0.2511608899,
-0.0245497227,
0.6382265091,
-0.1063456833,
0.0212947782,
-0.5023332834,
0.4419699013,
-0.2040955126,
-0.8631256223,
0.5299879909,
0.3460602164,
0.4646192491,
0.7953178287,
0.2085511535,
0.3617998064,
-0.6801251769,
0.3153208494,
0.4802492857,
-0.6287617683,
0.4436525404,
-0.1370003372,
-0.098869279,
0.5485692024,
0.4916042984,
-0.7420909405,
-0.7458340526,
-0.6301399469,
-0.3822310269,
0.6289792657,
0.3526311517,
0.2720725834,
0.0784001276,
0.1686685681,
0.5245611668,
0.2075865865,
-0.800459981,
-0.5639939308,
-0.4905097187,
-0.125557676,
-0.3032947779,
0.1646800488,
-0.1668235958,
-0.1169511005,
0.4744004905,
-0.1888799369,
0.5509863496,
-0.4092214704,
-0.0007266452,
-0.2386337668,
0.3918017149,
0.0673986897,
0.0835086107,
0.0636395663,
-0.0897459909,
0.0312824473,
-0.5085378289,
0.1442146748,
0.281034112,
-0.0446423367,
0.0701330602,
0.3662374616,
1.0615340471,
0.2622759044,
-0.4158267677,
0.9258542657,
-0.3293741941,
-0.0185774453,
-0.3589917123,
-0.1367950737,
-0.1520109028,
0.2972101569,
0.154194966,
0.4149020016,
-0.035572473,
-0.5088664293,
0.4707734585,
0.4280306995,
-0.4915547967,
-0.5677182674,
0.454995513,
0.2796375155,
-0.0893567428,
0.7561417818,
0.0636007488,
-0.7379852533,
0.3680603206,
0.6635879278,
1.0413489342,
-0.599155426,
0.4926228821,
0.2048819661,
0.3112124801,
0.1741103828,
0.1718908846,
-0.2654181719,
-0.9005869627,
-0.1248110607,
-0.5496087074,
-0.4292922914,
-0.2674193978,
-0.4914494455,
0.1514717638,
-0.3756893277,
0.11512997,
0.0766942278,
0.1858355403,
-0.9238880277,
0.3154731989,
0.3180086315,
0.5483344197,
-1.5669466257,
0.842756927,
0.8337109089,
-0.3793676496,
-0.9421687126,
-0.1122091636,
-0.1034165993,
-0.8113457561,
0.4569925368,
0.6737248302,
0.3319565356,
-0.3219431937,
-0.4659638703,
-0.8025873303,
1.0110781193,
0.2810395062,
-0.318857342,
0.5684274435,
0.4831849337,
0.7587261796,
-0.4514525235,
0.3702428639,
0.1220195293,
0.296846807,
0.1786326468,
-0.8118329048,
0.1034339964,
-0.3260559738,
-0.2855594456,
0.3569874763,
-0.6458443403,
0.8241710663,
-0.3890094757,
-0.6012819409,
-0.3338683248,
0.704808712,
-0.0996613428,
0.5431366563,
0.4282289743,
0.4118210077,
0.7285448909,
-0.199958533,
1.1494860649,
-0.2507495284,
0.6344881058,
0.7384621501,
-0.1626675874,
0.9709779024,
0.3898843229,
0.1860084832,
0.3359342515,
0.5406813025,
-0.2690531015,
0.6691845059,
-0.4150567353,
-0.1419148892,
0.0229522474,
-0.0118487105,
-0.1044165716,
0.6538323164,
0.2313467413,
-0.4745656848,
-0.159072414,
0.6046732664,
0.1729352176,
-0.0020270674,
-0.0383982509,
0.9042291045,
-0.057456322,
-0.401201725,
0.5918677449,
0.0541087314,
0.5562485456,
0.0521084182,
0.1377868801,
-0.3052159846,
0.2846178114,
-0.361559391,
-0.7570724487,
0.2521184087,
-0.1692619473,
0.0052869623,
-0.4006156027,
0.9002414346,
-0.4389487803,
-0.6625019908,
0.4075980186,
0.3964301944,
-0.045048099,
0.0429728553,
-0.8071145415,
-0.2096370459,
0.0988299847,
-0.2108624578,
0.5732322335,
0.4746258259,
0.1449908912,
0.8988469839,
0.4761208594,
-0.3059557378,
-0.0183610301,
0.1558562666,
0.9369535446,
-0.0178921726,
-0.8173317313,
-0.6561878324,
0.2145499438,
-0.1750762165,
0.1970673501,
1.0905483961,
0.2905012369,
1.025464654,
-0.2758823633,
0.6259521842,
0.080124259,
0.4184131026,
-0.3698375523,
1.2316815853,
-0.5057173967,
-0.0152902426,
-0.2710326314,
-0.5938802958,
-0.507133007,
0.1831388324,
-0.3123803735,
0.1063065454,
0.3711331189,
0.5931452513,
-0.1281138957,
0.5887885094,
0.4247393608,
0.1725662798,
0.2099540383,
0.3433105648,
0.5429233909,
-0.5444846749,
0.0984260216,
-0.9240760207,
-0.155835852,
-0.3817034364,
-0.4448896646,
-1.199105382,
-0.7227957845,
-0.1940847039,
0.0021794722,
0.0041838917,
0.6914438605,
0.374055326,
-1.1030510664,
0.1835530251,
0.0927668735,
0.255638957,
-0.3779916167,
-0.2393349409,
0.3005121052,
-0.3327875137,
-0.5945550799,
0.1632420719,
0.0413256623,
-0.0764485747,
-0.105832994,
0.0874931887,
-0.1234423816,
-0.2025682926,
0.3698964715,
0.1642727852,
-0.659496069,
-0.3613636792,
-0.0830545425,
-0.108745262,
0.0102895852,
0.5054715872,
-0.677760601,
0.7735217214,
0.3777700961,
0.6672349572,
-0.1037170067,
-0.034471672,
0.3614052832,
-1.1790987253,
0.2311752439,
0.116733402,
0.6159080863,
0.5725951791,
-0.7131396532,
0.3034611642,
0.0561098456,
-0.4843232036,
-0.6062864661,
-0.0721602142,
-0.5465426445,
-0.1521699876,
1.1207224131,
-0.726998508,
-0.3994177282,
0.076816991,
0.3153697252,
0.441924274,
-0.5196253657,
0.7529039383,
0.1299327165,
0.4375565052,
-0.1076167449,
-0.0342749692,
0.2931552827,
0.0840818658,
-0.6477428079,
0.0721032917,
0.3762982786,
0.2599483132,
0.2643105686,
0.1340462714,
0.1642426103,
0.2794006765,
0.043117892,
0.1296866536,
-0.2468671948,
-0.5902573466,
-0.5240322351,
0.4626672268,
-0.5774633884,
-0.2903816402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17408v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17408v3 | P-Transformer: A Prompt-based Multimodal Transformer Architecture For Medical Tabular Data | 2023-03-30T14:25:44 | 2024-01-09T10:28:00 | Yucheng Ruan, Xiang Lan, Daniel J. Tan, Hairil Rizal Abdullah, Mengling Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Medical tabular data, abundant in Electronic Health Records (EHRs), is a
valuable resource for diverse medical tasks such as risk prediction. While deep
learning approaches, particularly transformer-based models, have shown
remarkable performance in tabular data prediction, there are still problems
remained for existing work to be effectively adapted into medical domain, such
as under-utilization of unstructured free-texts, limited exploration of textual
information in structured data, and data corruption. To address these issues,
we propose P-Transformer, a Prompt-based multimodal Transformer architecture
designed specifically for medical tabular data. This framework consists two
critical components: a tabular cell embedding generator and a tabular
transformer. The former efficiently encodes diverse modalities from both
structured and unstructured tabular data into a harmonized language semantic
space with the help of pre-trained sentence encoder and medical prompts. The
latter integrates cell representations to generate patient embeddings for
various medical tasks. In comprehensive experiments on two real-world datasets
for three medical tasks, P-Transformer demonstrated the improvements with
10.9%/11.0% on RMSE/MAE, 0.5%/2.2% on RMSE/MAE, and 1.6%/0.8% on BACC/AUROC
compared to state-of-the-art (SOTA) baselines in predictability. Notably, the
model exhibited strong resilience to data corruption in the structured data,
particularly when the corruption rates are high. | [
0.1407413781,
-0.8627424836,
0.7507158518,
0.2546652853,
-0.1049743146,
-0.0751197636,
0.0532433651,
0.0686881989,
0.0766282827,
0.2691206336,
-0.4027828574,
-0.3089711666,
-0.4915089607,
0.1181791425,
-0.009330946,
1.1651839018,
-0.2021234035,
0.2148120701,
-0.303114593,
0.3185836971,
-0.9657710791,
-0.2723793387,
-0.1239311919,
-0.2273129076,
0.5549741983,
0.6069610119,
0.8568526506,
0.552697897,
0.6762353778,
0.2746082246,
0.4807448685,
-0.0288872272,
-0.1490056515,
0.4837992191,
0.1007952914,
-0.353782624,
-0.4939821362,
-0.5179032683,
0.4456751347,
0.492447108,
-0.4113926589,
-0.0577409305,
-0.0713488683,
0.6643662453,
-0.3118310869,
0.4873324037,
-0.6298264861,
0.3560481966,
-0.1559603512,
-0.3089876175,
-0.6833184958,
-0.3246667385,
0.2386606038,
-0.6408245564,
0.1427460164,
0.1702942103,
0.6453028321,
0.4525208175,
-0.6389549971,
-0.1573280245,
-0.5318574905,
0.4108896852,
-0.1203836054,
0.5921977758,
0.0525438525,
0.8647707105,
-0.1934647113,
-1.0685710907,
-0.6467914581,
-0.2790181935,
-0.3463642597,
0.3370910883,
-0.2921850681,
0.0277365781,
0.102310203,
0.3550361097,
-0.8322614431,
-0.0212016758,
-0.3083355725,
-0.1210600212,
0.1601850986,
0.541631043,
0.5812295079,
-0.3031129837,
-0.478223443,
-0.2478274107,
-0.4461641014,
0.2235820144,
-0.3215931356,
0.1645030528,
-0.189844057,
0.4290910661,
0.0200874154,
0.4512643218,
0.2182738483,
-0.3725810349,
0.809433043,
-0.2591992319,
-0.3857021332,
0.1579526663,
0.9164118171,
0.3850154281,
-0.2047445774,
-0.1961864233,
-0.0588960685,
0.1848680824,
0.7251692414,
-1.0342721939,
-0.6489187479,
0.3160498738,
-0.6965879798,
-0.1952126324,
0.1819895357,
-1.2025910616,
-0.7721655965,
-0.1092583537,
0.352496773,
-0.5610678792,
0.1582718492,
0.1718883216,
0.2850858271,
0.0001618151,
0.5577927232,
-0.4965542853,
-0.1172982156,
0.3131300807,
0.7267631888,
-0.1779363751,
-0.2636764348,
-0.7161898017,
-0.0842297748,
-0.193097055,
0.8385365009,
-0.4061368406,
-0.3169481456,
0.0751307756,
0.4162510335,
-0.361825794,
-0.5337695479,
1.1263897419,
-0.1048693061,
0.0358661115,
-0.0669716299,
-0.1784513891,
-0.0090388628,
0.1425750703,
-0.8971955776,
0.5310764313,
0.18457295,
-0.6243929267,
0.7409709692,
-0.6138877869,
-0.4707587957,
0.2824013233,
-0.4928432703,
-1.2064470053,
0.0336741582,
0.5976221561,
0.7419881225,
-0.4941566885,
0.8217589855,
-0.0372364856,
-0.0428383574,
0.5671742558,
-0.5493524671,
0.165053457,
0.0471114106,
-0.1334184408,
0.3513831794,
-0.6774004102,
-0.2306477129,
0.2372653633,
-0.3459638059,
0.356623143,
-0.031960655,
0.3204551339,
0.5528463721,
-0.1616490632,
-0.6461072564,
0.2886409163,
-0.1870662719,
0.2781495154,
0.4156107306,
0.1633292884,
0.4361280501,
-0.7433438897,
0.5928244591,
0.4497258067,
0.2794478238,
-0.465642333,
-0.713563621,
-0.1505235434,
-0.4060963094,
-0.0102269854,
0.9000853896,
-1.0305064917,
0.3231241703,
-0.6022362709,
-0.6682226062,
-0.605063796,
-0.1553444266,
0.2042506188,
1.1193079948,
0.749802053,
0.1211514398,
-0.5102332234,
-1.0745999813,
-0.028083235,
0.0498621799,
-0.2222432643,
0.4704008996,
0.4135329127,
-0.5275810957,
0.7454507351,
-0.4442249238,
-0.565805614,
-0.5266210437,
-0.0213272106,
0.5645201206,
0.6539250612,
0.2240058929,
-0.9930256009,
-0.6855587959,
-0.0293158926,
-0.6880422235,
-0.0498392805,
-0.5659278631,
0.1895683855,
-0.1290186197,
0.0050149271,
-0.6531587839,
0.4718900025,
0.3661981821,
-0.6127765775,
0.4600366056,
-0.3838708103,
0.248671636,
-1.2154434919,
0.1067266986,
-0.0031900839,
0.0603469387,
-1.0951150656,
-0.51407969,
0.5476244688,
-0.5816435218,
-0.456576705,
0.2934387922,
-0.1566425413,
0.3403600454,
0.0450332575,
-0.3479941189,
0.0913101807,
0.2963124216,
0.0046685413,
0.70458287,
0.6920333505,
-0.3918956816,
0.368290633,
0.8170327544,
-0.4309488833,
0.7391702533,
-0.7347072363,
-0.1277559102,
-0.414029032,
0.5002889633,
-0.7282786965,
-0.3890596926,
0.385720104,
-0.3981763721,
0.4423707724,
-0.1056105196,
-0.2690014839,
-0.5675273538,
-0.1773230582,
0.3561557233,
0.4665058851,
-0.4959250093,
0.9069490433,
0.2079649419,
-0.3024661243,
-0.5039539933,
-0.7533178329,
0.1239589974,
0.0034168242,
-0.6674262285,
0.7405319214,
0.003232616,
0.1023801491,
-0.0487496443,
-0.0015839443,
-0.0767430365,
-0.2271857709,
0.7993929386,
0.6571130753,
-0.1155807078,
0.3662854731,
0.1336685568,
-0.4359022081,
0.0207361244,
-0.1900223345,
0.5903500319,
-0.0309253819,
-0.3796060085,
-0.7880295515,
0.2869724929,
0.7466932535,
-0.2952629626,
0.834916234,
0.5893673301,
-0.4408057928,
0.0034940897,
-0.4785426557,
-0.1021895409,
-0.4243287742,
0.622643292,
-0.3474394083,
-0.5298162103,
0.3551212251,
-0.0718558729,
-0.1273947805,
0.3630215824,
0.8525217772,
-0.2169235796,
0.7808035016,
0.0885863602,
0.1262788475,
0.3141783178,
-0.0504452772,
0.1253074706,
-0.5838330984,
-0.7962293029,
-0.3511832952,
-0.4258703887,
-0.453091532,
-0.5371162295,
0.9143166542,
-0.3442550898,
-0.3854264915,
0.1692441702,
-0.6072725654,
-0.1335882396,
0.2194385231,
0.5970142484,
-0.0156871639,
-0.1637903899,
0.0865071192,
-0.2501253188,
-0.6668485999,
-0.2732192576,
1.0968735218,
0.5499070287,
0.9485161304,
-0.1493417323,
0.3656797409,
0.0879939198,
0.2493169308,
-0.7744646668,
-0.0056406916,
-0.1756214499,
-0.2079295814,
-0.068347916,
-0.3991378844,
-1.0567501783,
0.1381643116,
-0.7017611861,
-0.3809525371,
0.3967977464,
0.3294462264,
-0.5191864371,
0.3739507496,
-0.5827220082,
1.2419197559,
-0.2193385363,
-0.2037063092,
0.2871997654,
-0.7031363845,
-0.0565421507,
-0.1733709276,
0.0878344104,
0.2085137814,
0.0600473732,
0.4672516882,
-0.2421155721,
0.6607326269,
-0.5062866807,
0.1981887966,
0.003725335,
0.1611485183,
0.7082971334,
0.5179459453,
0.1930789202,
-0.1340062618,
-0.2451978922,
-0.1833809465,
-0.7066876888,
0.3857716918,
-0.5356565118,
-0.1386417001,
-0.2513531446,
-0.7012920976,
-0.3436288536,
-0.0182917416,
0.2129169554,
0.611030519,
0.1032269225,
0.6246574521,
0.6633782983,
-0.6351721883,
0.3240891993,
0.2268302888,
0.1145499125,
-0.7051853538,
0.8314571977,
-0.0359805487,
-0.2527211607,
0.8521358371,
0.3552467823,
-0.2837330699,
-0.327239722,
-0.7770132422,
-0.1020752415,
-0.330353111,
-0.6757254601,
-1.0159722567,
0.0662540868,
-0.1188791394,
-0.3549195528,
-0.1851909757,
0.1178916097,
-0.2013643086,
-0.164526239,
0.2848303318,
0.3187143505,
0.4882974029,
0.3407122195,
-1.0663102865,
0.5273460746,
0.2682289183,
0.3295038342,
-0.4484885037,
-0.3980685771,
0.108267419,
-0.2848336697,
-0.3286874294,
-1.3056770563,
0.6067844033,
0.088481836,
0.5321409106,
0.2126693726,
0.0293138623,
0.5013599396,
-0.8523642421,
0.5627764463,
0.4066077471,
-0.6648760438,
0.5746176243,
-0.1683535427,
0.1072277501,
0.6077468395,
0.224623695,
-0.4875962138,
0.1768519878,
-0.3213646114,
-0.6690794826,
0.5046927333,
-0.0860639736,
-0.1046207398,
0.2220466137,
0.1992894262,
0.4388956428,
0.1777883768,
-0.7848212719,
-0.2121789753,
-0.6275103688,
-0.4913169146,
-0.0222994592,
-0.2876155674,
0.30885306,
-0.0877915993,
0.3457564116,
-0.3170529902,
0.5349135995,
0.4460998476,
-0.384595722,
-0.0375225097,
0.6758747697,
0.3913215399,
0.382609576,
0.021302877,
0.0652742237,
0.1157111898,
-0.7106208205,
0.2264457792,
0.3907295763,
-0.0914609581,
0.0262533594,
0.201433599,
1.0830843449,
0.1857090592,
-0.7190355659,
0.7502915859,
-0.0756021142,
-0.0764232725,
-0.2260236889,
-0.4022111893,
-0.2615309954,
0.1845898926,
0.4468540847,
0.2428312302,
0.3025366664,
-0.353892684,
0.6526994109,
0.0942570567,
-0.3631376624,
-0.27668643,
0.8274937868,
-0.0927101597,
-0.2083217353,
0.6940099597,
-0.0351593271,
-0.4145016074,
0.3915500641,
0.858874917,
0.4809031785,
-0.5719786882,
0.3933872879,
0.2302855551,
0.1780008674,
0.1904609203,
0.4866763949,
0.1955619007,
-0.506734848,
-0.3882296383,
-0.5039561391,
-0.1690830588,
0.019002961,
-0.4845758975,
0.3135623634,
-0.1768558919,
-0.1194927022,
-0.0253934972,
-0.2318470329,
-0.8574891686,
0.2949826121,
0.0402743407,
0.7740584612,
-0.8245147467,
0.7067313194,
0.8246795535,
-0.400698781,
-0.9351400733,
-0.132383123,
-0.0926163718,
-0.8120113611,
0.5797331929,
0.2232408077,
0.5973190665,
-0.4349473119,
0.2253757566,
-0.3226152658,
1.2970362902,
0.421208173,
-0.8197599649,
-0.3242256343,
0.433178544,
0.3230324388,
-0.1723961085,
0.2997137308,
0.3384975791,
0.5364117026,
-0.0861816928,
-1.099791646,
0.354282707,
-0.3317162097,
-0.1564701051,
0.3711157441,
-0.0924138278,
1.1674022675,
-0.2022518069,
-0.028687641,
-0.312636435,
0.3428300321,
0.0468268245,
0.3753227592,
0.3106341958,
0.5117990375,
0.6586634517,
-0.2920568883,
1.0314218998,
-0.2813330293,
0.1764664501,
0.8430598974,
-0.3141912222,
0.4125350714,
0.3805555403,
-0.1291627884,
0.6378783584,
-0.0487181246,
-0.294454962,
0.3938447237,
-0.1571437269,
-0.1074919328,
-0.0683713555,
-0.0406721905,
-0.414376229,
0.4215255976,
0.4826282561,
-0.6805407405,
-0.2022448033,
0.4679473937,
-0.1567813307,
-0.0187617093,
-0.3033441603,
0.7826033235,
-0.126825735,
-0.424333632,
0.0496823266,
-0.2034443915,
0.4681253731,
-0.3222459257,
-0.215367049,
0.0313141868,
0.2904551923,
-0.3928019702,
-0.8233692646,
0.1858329773,
-0.4173686504,
-0.2230066657,
-0.512527287,
0.9646794796,
-0.3412581682,
-0.4700196087,
-0.164524436,
0.7022140622,
-0.3320337832,
-0.0564789362,
-0.6810007095,
-0.042030815,
-0.239936918,
-0.083629854,
0.3018997908,
0.5551003814,
0.0990809649,
0.7992126942,
0.6142875552,
0.0738923624,
-0.0721057281,
0.0165622644,
1.0135462284,
-0.5155465603,
-0.7350993752,
-0.8313026428,
0.8128817081,
0.1490289569,
-0.1293672919,
0.3611452878,
0.6184493303,
0.218851909,
-0.4991603196,
0.4941640794,
-0.1076634303,
0.5358026624,
-0.4433671832,
0.8805900812,
-0.2101886868,
-0.2286662012,
-0.2633769512,
-0.3703771532,
-0.54783988,
0.6225543022,
-0.2503980994,
-0.1926851124,
0.7875976562,
0.6565762162,
0.0081853559,
-0.0577924401,
0.3347710073,
0.1768103093,
0.4034405649,
0.7997258306,
0.6640072465,
-0.3989685178,
0.6219815016,
-0.2602552474,
-0.340136528,
-0.1953123957,
-0.5693555474,
-0.731698215,
-0.7897180319,
-0.0381654166,
-0.3139310181,
-0.0940507129,
1.0440708399,
0.6450767517,
-0.8925948739,
0.339545995,
-0.1601877511,
-0.261682421,
-0.0422442704,
-0.2398278713,
0.5470529795,
-0.4216064215,
-0.2175516933,
0.5784217715,
0.3847610652,
-0.0739780813,
0.1807206422,
0.0343674272,
0.4021246433,
-0.5130509734,
0.4414362311,
-0.0542162694,
-0.5175984502,
-0.0335153118,
0.2856733501,
-0.0799610838,
0.5289558172,
1.0796978474,
-1.0355806351,
0.5482751131,
0.2787760496,
0.9822942019,
0.0697018728,
0.0674021691,
0.3261244595,
-0.3591649532,
-0.0141145531,
0.5730792284,
0.7751178145,
0.2143555582,
-0.6824865341,
-0.1433677673,
0.1428622156,
-0.7763589025,
-0.7146531343,
0.186585784,
-1.0376694202,
-0.0084166322,
0.7085075378,
-0.0077291955,
-0.1276876777,
-0.2412095964,
-0.5125307441,
0.3592531383,
-0.7377236485,
0.8071283102,
-0.1632104516,
-0.3433731794,
-0.2655524015,
-0.5884147882,
0.4994463027,
0.2431275249,
-1.1996021271,
-0.0859113261,
0.5033891797,
0.0905517414,
0.3109533191,
0.361753732,
-0.3746715784,
0.6061071157,
-0.0496307574,
-0.0841855183,
-0.4475663006,
-0.7700459361,
-0.3685261905,
0.6305225492,
-0.3654124737,
-0.2365587503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17395v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17395v1 | WavCaps: A ChatGPT-Assisted Weakly-Labelled Audio Captioning Dataset for Audio-Language Multimodal Research | 2023-03-30T14:07:47 | 2023-03-30T14:07:47 | Xinhao Mei, Chutong Meng, Haohe Liu, Qiuqiang Kong, Tom Ko, Chengqi Zhao, Mark D. Plumbley, Yuexian Zou, Wenwu Wang | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD | The advancement of audio-language (AL) multimodal learning tasks has been
significant in recent years. However, researchers face challenges due to the
costly and time-consuming collection process of existing audio-language
datasets, which are limited in size. To address this data scarcity issue, we
introduce WavCaps, the first large-scale weakly-labelled audio captioning
dataset, comprising approximately 400k audio clips with paired captions. We
sourced audio clips and their raw descriptions from web sources and a sound
event detection dataset. However, the online-harvested raw descriptions are
highly noisy and unsuitable for direct use in tasks such as automated audio
captioning. To overcome this issue, we propose a three-stage processing
pipeline for filtering noisy data and generating high-quality captions, where
ChatGPT, a large language model, is leveraged to filter and transform raw
descriptions automatically. We conduct a comprehensive analysis of the
characteristics of WavCaps dataset and evaluate it on multiple downstream
audio-language multimodal learning tasks. The systems trained on WavCaps
outperform previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) models by a significant margin. Our
aspiration is for the WavCaps dataset we have proposed to facilitate research
in audio-language multimodal learning and demonstrate the potential of
utilizing ChatGPT to enhance academic research. Our dataset and codes are
available at https://github.com/XinhaoMei/WavCaps. | [
-0.4529594481,
-0.5335054398,
0.2492648661,
0.2242915332,
-0.3130337,
0.0026337774,
-0.3760176897,
-0.4049582481,
0.1998919696,
0.2651549578,
-0.6463779807,
-0.3668921292,
-0.5542436838,
0.0358760357,
-0.4843485653,
1.2456166744,
0.151133731,
0.1986001134,
-0.1376518905,
-0.3427132964,
-0.4437463582,
-0.1989535093,
-0.5033742785,
0.1023120582,
0.7358785272,
0.5028373003,
0.4499628842,
0.2515595257,
0.6210108995,
0.1971944571,
0.1394043416,
0.3399472237,
-0.1084788069,
0.1235126257,
0.3301615417,
-0.2547317147,
-0.3244898021,
-0.2111936361,
0.5670312047,
0.5590671897,
-0.2719094157,
0.3988228738,
0.0490655303,
0.3003509939,
-0.5249836445,
0.6862739921,
-0.5150278807,
0.2128515542,
-0.3017570376,
-0.4199279547,
-0.3172327876,
-0.0977908149,
0.3051482737,
-0.5802767873,
0.1569460928,
0.2051968873,
0.6019217372,
0.3549070358,
-0.2226647288,
-0.2033660114,
-0.5654804111,
0.9990316033,
-0.7153561711,
0.3167493641,
0.4649769068,
0.3509819806,
0.0358721428,
-0.6917651892,
-0.593993783,
-0.041415073,
0.3208599389,
0.1375926286,
-0.2463134825,
0.0743988454,
0.1223402172,
0.4051738381,
-0.6105216742,
0.1860730648,
-0.8112452626,
-0.5432775021,
0.4271826446,
-0.0165576432,
0.3765097558,
-0.2001967728,
-0.4823864698,
-0.1149584651,
-0.4820545018,
-0.003329312,
0.2921957374,
0.6373909712,
-0.3074349463,
0.7706081271,
-0.1931131035,
0.3633289039,
-0.5399746895,
-0.4581376612,
0.5338677168,
-0.3354688287,
-0.0429764353,
0.0832112804,
0.9970924854,
0.1471939832,
0.1041014344,
-0.1655026376,
-0.2095634043,
0.188194856,
-0.0272218399,
-0.5939750075,
-0.4705683589,
0.3431596458,
-0.4481743574,
-0.19294025,
-0.322181493,
-0.8289174438,
-0.4894583821,
-0.5083556175,
0.5362864137,
-0.2808688283,
-0.1631730199,
-0.0157864671,
-0.0450353883,
0.0675134286,
0.1232765168,
-0.7717705965,
0.429090023,
0.2854657769,
0.9144653082,
-0.3327754736,
-0.3686309457,
-0.7690008879,
0.0511511303,
0.0246831384,
0.9097156525,
-0.4308111966,
-0.0195471011,
0.0548466146,
-0.1089247316,
0.2286254764,
-0.2301348001,
0.6711475253,
-0.2354174703,
0.0916780233,
0.0681192502,
-0.2601958811,
-0.0001419255,
0.008678766,
-0.701629281,
0.7965189815,
-0.3985781074,
-0.7663676143,
0.2455202639,
-0.5993096828,
-0.5235390663,
0.1183995903,
-0.3288538754,
-0.5781111121,
-0.2044652253,
0.5623781085,
0.6824756265,
-0.2452171147,
0.2326279432,
-0.1493989825,
-0.4143731296,
0.4003888369,
-0.871086061,
0.4421657324,
0.2768103778,
-0.1177637577,
0.1887187809,
-0.7902825475,
-0.1603019536,
0.0794426277,
-0.2279474884,
-0.0180354267,
0.3003855944,
0.4409491122,
0.134714067,
-0.050889045,
-0.6540027857,
0.1248054355,
0.0329852067,
0.8004825115,
0.5651159286,
-0.0255043954,
0.2686088979,
-0.34913221,
0.4645040333,
-0.1906549633,
0.2485300153,
-0.3954968452,
-0.7081495523,
-0.3606489897,
-0.6377259493,
0.217741847,
0.2710829079,
-0.8303438425,
0.0444608219,
-0.2777460814,
-0.2598177195,
-0.6721479297,
0.3153634965,
0.1417480707,
0.1407404095,
0.5902459621,
-0.443431735,
-0.6480984688,
-0.8320074677,
0.3663929999,
-0.127483964,
-0.1545987725,
0.2261409312,
0.1514072865,
-0.1021912321,
0.7248718739,
-0.4286175072,
-0.805793941,
-0.1320952177,
0.5406326652,
-0.0492490046,
0.3600008488,
0.1328318566,
-0.8581997752,
-0.0013005992,
-0.2829116881,
-0.4331049323,
-0.0669581145,
-0.0451332927,
0.1682537049,
-0.2010034919,
0.5865841508,
-0.6922252774,
-0.1241810173,
0.8460525274,
0.20288755,
0.6447429061,
0.1093345061,
0.1170955673,
-0.6835871339,
-0.0126088737,
-0.0683575571,
-0.0319218412,
-0.2059129775,
-0.2984764576,
-0.307711035,
-0.3591445982,
-0.660875082,
0.2450029999,
-0.4404872358,
-0.0406516418,
-0.1422513723,
0.3557831049,
-0.1293785125,
0.9144061804,
0.1763436496,
0.5632132888,
0.8468413353,
-0.3154116869,
0.4552786052,
0.2900947928,
-0.4638680816,
0.3511548638,
-0.2611983716,
0.0208131894,
-0.066249676,
0.3192494512,
-1.2235732079,
-0.4251739383,
0.0700969771,
-0.4378316104,
0.1671388745,
-0.5468583703,
-0.5547407269,
-0.1699625105,
-0.1786096692,
0.5068654418,
0.3301447034,
-0.4227099717,
0.3149745166,
0.6385037899,
-0.6911952496,
-0.5092251897,
-0.6665703058,
0.1027487442,
-0.2889185548,
-0.1602687091,
-0.0550993122,
-0.115714401,
0.1208483428,
-0.1802777052,
-0.2574122548,
-0.3791472614,
-0.4094849527,
0.4260816872,
0.4032804966,
-0.2186910212,
0.3540231586,
-0.0288734324,
0.0569205061,
0.0472918712,
-0.2839130461,
0.3692090809,
-0.2403080314,
-0.2823129594,
-0.5481744409,
0.1911853403,
0.7090077996,
-0.4977000058,
0.191948995,
1.0387272835,
-0.1107171103,
-0.1840237975,
-0.4247828424,
-0.153130278,
-0.4191021919,
0.422942847,
-0.1511175185,
-0.7872421145,
0.146882534,
0.0446225852,
0.2884587348,
0.1612809002,
0.3609311283,
-0.3737868667,
1.0063277483,
0.1847070158,
-0.1482797414,
0.6323512197,
-0.2139739543,
0.0366237648,
-0.5561557412,
-0.1735970974,
-0.4692091644,
-0.2402068973,
-0.5572772622,
-0.5485634804,
0.2621227205,
-0.460321784,
0.0990177393,
0.1584947258,
-0.492472589,
0.4261412024,
0.3764147162,
0.1540726125,
0.2593771219,
0.2423448712,
0.3256784976,
-0.0847657993,
-0.6781791449,
-0.3024973571,
1.2119410038,
0.4395984113,
0.8991781473,
0.1254330128,
0.4558745921,
0.640304625,
-0.0237490181,
-0.9659907222,
0.394719094,
0.0064176652,
-0.5131344795,
-0.4543572366,
-0.4982176423,
-1.0256277323,
0.3070961833,
-0.306266278,
-0.5499680042,
0.0039516711,
0.0248781331,
-0.1936182827,
0.2840275466,
-0.737985611,
0.7061983347,
-0.1421361715,
-0.4346185625,
0.0042177015,
-0.7271020412,
0.2820858657,
0.1198451668,
0.7492513657,
-0.3184888661,
0.1213876083,
0.9973484874,
-0.0405558683,
0.8592275977,
-0.2690246999,
-0.195796445,
0.6531784534,
0.0575753264,
0.3278182447,
0.0960686281,
0.4957366586,
0.1428326219,
0.2983552814,
-0.5069590211,
-0.2435607016,
0.6465636492,
-0.5701813102,
-0.0049220943,
-0.3303223252,
-0.7510001659,
-0.3421888053,
0.1723332554,
-0.0476992056,
0.9004663229,
0.0642833412,
0.3190117478,
0.6321130991,
-0.2653184235,
0.4694763422,
0.2815107405,
-0.1705344766,
-0.3203346133,
1.4847019911,
-0.0534626916,
0.1475369036,
0.3078256249,
0.1748754382,
-0.2472486943,
-0.7630894184,
-0.3504129648,
0.0100310873,
-0.5176132321,
-0.2916105688,
-0.5938154459,
0.0941922441,
-0.2309527099,
0.1239743978,
-0.7178921103,
-0.6328439713,
0.0964828208,
-0.0042300369,
0.2543565631,
0.4350504577,
-0.2090268135,
0.1583940387,
-0.7020199299,
0.8216406107,
0.4465981722,
0.2621380389,
-0.1725473553,
-0.3893464804,
-0.3005765676,
-0.0002403308,
-0.2260605693,
-0.5344833732,
0.373575747,
0.3243628144,
0.3463787735,
0.3977667093,
0.1004674435,
0.5178576708,
-0.435320735,
0.8507637382,
0.2701375186,
-0.561185658,
0.3585515618,
-0.469332695,
0.259106487,
0.5298502445,
0.2155496329,
-0.3171495497,
-0.5715537667,
-0.4468896985,
-1.1782048941,
0.6487978697,
0.453529954,
0.2511215806,
0.202187866,
-0.3221007884,
0.4137849808,
0.3578803837,
-0.901339829,
-0.2438987195,
-0.2609605193,
-0.314768225,
-0.0935709774,
0.0503650792,
-0.2154633701,
-0.1458981037,
0.7259052396,
-0.3787099123,
0.3937400281,
0.0040859384,
-0.2116407901,
0.0654505864,
0.7319033742,
0.3360592425,
0.3024888337,
-0.4185357988,
0.3410164714,
-0.0595782436,
-0.6209905148,
0.0193374921,
0.2077003568,
0.258574456,
0.0457137451,
0.4880904853,
0.619063139,
0.4785915017,
-1.176451683,
0.6790109277,
-0.1158138961,
0.026641706,
-0.2139224112,
-0.2261795551,
-0.0946796983,
0.0358942635,
0.5464354753,
0.3114663064,
0.4998062849,
-0.584646523,
0.2181703895,
0.02927058,
-0.5087735653,
-0.1539073437,
0.5691224337,
0.2392541915,
0.1201805025,
0.499645859,
0.0094856471,
-0.1361436397,
0.4501841366,
0.079780072,
0.490716517,
0.182872206,
0.3402884007,
0.2020661235,
0.2878716886,
-0.1749073416,
0.1719639152,
-0.614985764,
-0.322180748,
-0.5299931169,
-0.7630372643,
-0.6664245725,
0.2005241811,
-0.8028514385,
0.2630367577,
-0.2157613635,
-0.1188076288,
0.1354373395,
-0.2712137401,
-0.612867713,
0.170386374,
0.5080740452,
0.4187383056,
-0.9977830648,
0.6617555618,
0.3821063042,
-0.686313808,
-0.5936090946,
-0.2122289538,
0.0992845967,
-0.4645529687,
0.3232914209,
0.0662624016,
-0.1247106791,
-0.0723963752,
-0.8174225688,
-0.6709037423,
0.8495274186,
0.198624149,
-0.648835063,
-0.0139692482,
0.0225807521,
0.4401967227,
-0.0148293208,
0.1596434861,
0.2764764428,
0.3124527037,
0.166251868,
-0.8642172813,
-0.3670203686,
-0.148164764,
-0.6067878008,
-0.064254716,
-0.5424442887,
0.6060450673,
-0.1536854655,
-0.0191593897,
0.114624247,
0.654531002,
0.2004685402,
0.2709365487,
0.4064486027,
0.0301066879,
0.6160730124,
-0.1003521234,
0.9074802995,
0.3072317839,
0.2123045474,
1.3176314831,
0.001179439,
1.0287953615,
0.7502871156,
-0.3552978039,
0.3206369579,
0.4144794941,
-0.2218193859,
0.7067970634,
0.1632796228,
-0.2217482328,
-0.2537026405,
-0.4042851627,
-0.1963299364,
0.5912047625,
0.3412801027,
-0.0109835286,
0.0778419822,
0.5405614376,
-0.2848102748,
-0.2217193395,
-0.1795919389,
0.7267978191,
0.1900714934,
-0.2748361528,
0.276540637,
-0.2876733541,
0.8201236725,
-0.7068151236,
-0.1201713979,
-0.0872872397,
-0.1337342411,
-0.3199257255,
-0.7767851949,
-0.1054711193,
0.1009716615,
0.0253948905,
-0.1637340486,
0.421369493,
-0.6010167003,
-0.3267516792,
0.1480314583,
0.3908140659,
0.3813777268,
0.0624699742,
-0.4120330811,
0.3062363267,
-0.2481056899,
-0.1500121504,
0.251449883,
0.3266009688,
-0.0549607947,
0.6879987717,
0.6183575392,
0.2647476196,
0.2598074079,
0.4195944965,
0.630299747,
-0.2282592058,
-0.4785244763,
-0.3093385994,
0.4277432263,
0.380253762,
-0.0448165275,
0.5802530646,
0.6784169674,
0.7914185524,
-0.0786014795,
0.9535508156,
-0.3028345704,
0.3122103512,
-0.6814867258,
0.5801352262,
-0.5556986928,
0.2435217053,
-0.4888471365,
-0.8500248194,
-0.3506828249,
0.2943201065,
0.0511081293,
-0.2640024126,
0.4993697703,
0.6918640137,
-0.3680249453,
0.122811012,
0.2244332731,
0.2777681053,
0.2803010345,
0.4534718692,
1.0141581297,
-0.5924678445,
1.1379928589,
-0.3722830415,
-0.0290643517,
0.0713240281,
-0.5191275477,
-0.8037184477,
-0.7940466404,
-0.550470531,
0.0892323032,
-0.0128962025,
0.890468657,
0.8061028719,
-0.9517243505,
-0.1867272407,
0.185238421,
-0.0897995979,
-0.423658967,
-0.2393374592,
0.5085391998,
-0.4169861972,
-0.7496984005,
0.7395531535,
0.09269429,
-0.1218301579,
-0.2588574588,
-0.139296189,
-0.244910717,
-0.0504897609,
0.6164336205,
0.4613926709,
-0.5724608302,
-0.130997926,
-0.3954410851,
-0.0223446116,
0.2289553583,
0.7147075534,
-0.4699535966,
0.7188587189,
0.2673645914,
0.4413685203,
0.7578160763,
-0.2640246153,
0.2859459817,
-1.0099090338,
0.3072872162,
0.2092710286,
0.3735101819,
0.4670530856,
0.1678017825,
0.3349767327,
0.1382217854,
-0.4066829681,
-0.9563103914,
-0.2339757681,
-1.5440077782,
-0.209656015,
1.2529289722,
-0.053317029,
0.0833341852,
-0.4273772836,
-0.687795341,
0.2895519137,
-0.6674445868,
0.7405712605,
0.5878487229,
-0.0793822333,
-0.366589874,
-0.9127752185,
0.4982589781,
0.2055798918,
-0.6302056313,
0.2643722892,
0.6664998531,
0.1118429601,
0.1504184604,
0.4581421912,
-0.2581593394,
0.4414295554,
0.1900379956,
0.3576360047,
-0.3374449313,
-0.4602283835,
-0.1443368196,
0.5226672888,
0.0292380638,
-0.5395672321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17367v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17367v1 | A BERT-based Unsupervised Grammatical Error Correction Framework | 2023-03-30T13:29:49 | 2023-03-30T13:29:49 | Nankai Lin, Hongbin Zhang, Menglan Shen, Yu Wang, Shengyi Jiang, Aimin Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grammatical error correction (GEC) is a challenging task of natural language
processing techniques. While more attempts are being made in this approach for
universal languages like English or Chinese, relatively little work has been
done for low-resource languages for the lack of large annotated corpora. In
low-resource languages, the current unsupervised GEC based on language model
scoring performs well. However, the pre-trained language model is still to be
explored in this context. This study proposes a BERT-based unsupervised GEC
framework, where GEC is viewed as multi-class classification task. The
framework contains three modules: data flow construction module, sentence
perplexity scoring module, and error detecting and correcting module. We
propose a novel scoring method for pseudo-perplexity to evaluate a sentence's
probable correctness and construct a Tagalog corpus for Tagalog GEC research.
It obtains competitive performance on the Tagalog corpus we construct and
open-source Indonesian corpus and it demonstrates that our framework is
complementary to baseline method for low-resource GEC task. | [
-0.1335127503,
-0.8976501226,
0.29751876,
0.2509069443,
-0.0831471309,
-0.0550311804,
-0.4433041215,
-0.1464205384,
0.1469066739,
0.1713225842,
-0.4749346972,
-0.7011127472,
-0.275367558,
0.2661291063,
-0.1458124369,
1.0686596632,
0.0748179033,
0.0822769627,
-0.1310061961,
0.0364897884,
-0.0931993574,
-0.8211190104,
-0.1679215133,
-0.1505663693,
0.348465085,
0.6784191132,
0.4685119689,
0.0425636619,
0.4053730071,
0.3968695998,
-0.1342047006,
0.247885406,
-0.2024040818,
-0.3995574415,
-0.4058269262,
-0.5475100875,
-0.5766160488,
-0.0828116387,
0.6252411604,
0.8049995899,
-0.3568710983,
-0.142430082,
0.1635366231,
0.5069352984,
-0.4915598631,
0.2365254462,
-0.7734174728,
-0.0048933923,
-0.39632985,
0.21302405,
-0.4280719757,
-0.2427548468,
0.1047082245,
-0.446098268,
0.4149257839,
-0.3263610899,
1.0023884773,
0.0630009621,
-0.1026600823,
-0.3612890244,
-0.3992177248,
0.607604146,
-0.9283941984,
-0.0977203622,
0.2746683061,
-0.0162182227,
-0.2962087989,
-0.3343248963,
-0.6895997524,
-0.0136504583,
-0.1243492067,
0.2272713929,
-0.0793330967,
0.4242802262,
0.1006372273,
0.2668594122,
-0.621532321,
0.1776577383,
0.035134498,
-0.2088060677,
0.4813013971,
-0.3436271548,
0.2241691202,
-0.746037662,
-0.3706128895,
0.0117308702,
-0.4695951343,
0.1396082491,
0.7123157382,
0.5640848875,
0.0221511796,
0.4862089753,
0.0825358853,
0.6276140809,
-0.1228705123,
-0.0504378937,
0.3539593816,
-0.0772631466,
-0.3838445544,
0.1843213588,
0.5703306794,
0.1823130548,
0.3270510435,
0.0958976746,
-0.2682829201,
0.3917687833,
0.3647660613,
-0.1002946198,
-0.5126294494,
-0.1016489714,
-0.3195669353,
-0.1273426712,
0.3109158278,
-0.975158155,
-0.038658563,
-0.0044547082,
0.3696736097,
-0.371427387,
-0.1936478317,
-0.0248530824,
0.3930614591,
-0.1094551533,
0.3553676009,
-0.7911398411,
-0.0171472337,
0.2591349781,
0.7003831267,
0.2820300758,
-0.4269774556,
-0.1351312101,
-0.1523611397,
-0.4378935397,
0.9821277261,
-0.3573645353,
-0.4662529528,
0.387201339,
0.060964141,
-0.4886474907,
-0.2780677378,
0.7076835036,
-0.2655304074,
0.3479751647,
-0.2538911998,
-0.7843548656,
-0.3198324442,
0.1324380189,
-0.4146080613,
1.2189046144,
0.150945127,
-0.9108795524,
0.2640985548,
-0.9116874933,
-0.6999816298,
0.2835842073,
-0.0746464655,
-0.3488747478,
0.0889199674,
0.3872220218,
0.5277895331,
0.092199482,
0.4031795859,
-0.0642528608,
-0.4793960452,
-0.0076867063,
-0.2736344635,
0.5733468533,
0.1847300231,
-0.3942327499,
0.3215371072,
-0.8850371838,
0.3265797496,
-0.0497859158,
-0.4884726703,
-0.4262610674,
-0.0466625243,
0.0614739843,
0.0867263824,
0.1906887442,
-0.6394443512,
0.2133596689,
-0.3794243634,
0.2349631339,
0.8346298933,
-0.3164223731,
0.2776956558,
-0.0547007956,
0.261687696,
-0.2633543611,
0.0147261377,
-0.1119602546,
-0.6231717467,
-0.9721529484,
-0.2265839577,
0.595426023,
0.980746448,
-1.0200508833,
1.043651104,
-0.1285669059,
-0.3256644011,
-0.700458169,
0.249632135,
0.6495374441,
0.4768651724,
0.3400085568,
-0.2344304472,
-0.7307879925,
-0.6509999633,
-0.001673016,
-0.6412093639,
-0.0731587261,
0.2508864999,
0.4487674832,
-0.2519692779,
0.822309494,
-0.3494367599,
-0.618942976,
-0.4710499942,
0.6518367529,
0.4219974577,
0.5012514591,
0.6137952805,
-0.5446449518,
-0.3141379356,
0.0335036777,
-0.6888037324,
-0.3575405777,
-0.0034606804,
-0.0285880584,
0.665448904,
0.4009302855,
-0.3125146329,
0.532608211,
0.5070495605,
-0.1754552871,
0.5739759803,
-0.6653433442,
0.3144604862,
-0.6978773475,
0.2540279031,
0.059734121,
-0.0500232093,
-0.4189066887,
-0.1181929559,
0.0932854488,
0.1370600313,
-0.2009103447,
-0.0455169603,
-0.097818464,
0.0589296669,
-0.201642558,
-0.0836894661,
-0.4645082355,
0.5821914673,
-0.0240782537,
0.6520164609,
0.34724015,
-0.3629109561,
0.4510838091,
0.1710953265,
-0.3781174719,
0.592586875,
-0.2913934588,
0.1873279959,
-0.2227434218,
0.0601433516,
-1.1824783087,
-0.3799203634,
-0.1322332323,
-0.4916626513,
0.3469949961,
-0.1685255021,
-0.6732347608,
-0.4548796713,
-0.2213585228,
-0.0465757772,
0.3499529064,
-0.7564859986,
0.4933616817,
0.1641502529,
-0.29804793,
-0.5966261625,
-0.7878388166,
0.0806997269,
0.322688967,
-0.7925384641,
0.2908514142,
0.0882408246,
0.037583597,
0.1281361282,
0.0545056351,
0.1089850515,
-0.054606095,
0.1060589328,
0.4851971865,
-0.2490936965,
0.4254330695,
0.0351230949,
0.0283934362,
-0.1976823807,
-0.2602334023,
0.4099149704,
-0.3353699446,
-0.3733669221,
-0.1757082939,
0.4569399953,
0.0984813496,
-0.037907362,
0.5225329995,
0.3022200763,
-0.4749647677,
-0.3101172149,
-0.676456809,
0.1786560863,
-0.3848304749,
0.4307785034,
-0.3160857558,
-0.8149060607,
0.5967940092,
-0.1297313273,
-0.1042757705,
0.5365496874,
0.5354669094,
-0.3324626088,
0.5160922408,
0.8369876146,
-0.3185605407,
0.3227416277,
0.1307909936,
0.4403440058,
-0.1514044255,
-0.2769602537,
-0.6318959594,
-0.2280051708,
-0.6017079949,
-0.2541949451,
0.3173204362,
0.3303383887,
-0.0669871345,
0.2700707614,
-0.3486582339,
0.5003626347,
0.6753522158,
-0.1176974773,
0.1901240051,
0.110800609,
-0.7387242913,
-0.1631079614,
-0.807410121,
-0.6837824583,
0.8970018029,
0.0365097448,
0.6825113297,
0.1712063849,
0.5861043334,
0.2616084218,
0.2404176295,
-0.414999187,
0.6181557775,
-0.8074375987,
-0.5889186263,
-0.4081415534,
-0.5298553705,
-0.4687862396,
0.2799396515,
-0.2997793853,
-0.9657067657,
-0.0221251659,
0.1125519276,
-0.3627197146,
0.6314878464,
-1.1590883732,
1.1188992262,
-0.2532797456,
-0.2233948112,
0.1494811326,
-0.9497668147,
0.1235472858,
0.091920346,
0.2247681022,
0.1311414689,
0.3470048606,
0.5716163516,
-0.4534416795,
0.9065830112,
-0.3964646757,
-0.2240468562,
0.4019803405,
-0.1841766089,
0.3399337828,
0.0450156294,
-0.0624760054,
0.2490139306,
-0.3911099732,
-0.3634323478,
-0.4075607955,
0.6453315616,
-0.6865478754,
-0.3888906837,
-0.602178812,
-0.3175852001,
-0.3473321199,
0.0728106201,
0.4387863874,
-0.257121712,
-0.272544533,
-0.2428609878,
0.5953205228,
-0.1103833392,
0.5479801297,
0.5592750311,
-0.0508301891,
-0.2232745439,
0.7849994898,
0.1283046305,
-0.178205654,
0.4577506483,
-0.0882427543,
-0.3997687697,
-0.3967022598,
-0.6727039218,
0.2134207338,
-0.6667994857,
-0.225177303,
-0.3707361221,
-0.1921852678,
-0.4729699194,
-0.242284134,
-0.3748945296,
0.0728032738,
-0.3253874183,
-0.2095998079,
0.2061061561,
0.5697678328,
-0.2147981673,
0.4326063097,
-0.742816627,
-0.2231860161,
0.2124297172,
0.3713009655,
-0.2241536528,
-0.493072927,
0.0924655423,
-0.1371097565,
0.0458027348,
-0.6460792422,
0.1924243569,
0.2484323531,
0.4437968433,
0.2705636919,
-0.0784808472,
0.8339945674,
-0.5255860686,
0.8506529927,
0.3485600054,
-1.4247243404,
0.8137874603,
-0.1444723308,
0.0937563926,
0.4065413773,
0.1634479016,
-0.509963274,
-0.0132464599,
-0.6764544249,
-0.8425557613,
0.8390601277,
0.2074520439,
-0.0036846718,
0.074107796,
0.4459781051,
0.0308857094,
0.1287347972,
-0.7803778052,
-0.0496262535,
-0.3920172751,
-0.3863509297,
-0.2545337379,
-0.5011976361,
0.1112473309,
-0.1777884513,
0.822398603,
-0.3735614121,
0.2176152915,
0.3979739547,
-0.1454563737,
-0.2638026178,
0.7298359275,
0.3944329619,
0.3069898486,
-0.3896572888,
0.193712905,
0.2187829912,
-0.3124650419,
0.1163758263,
0.4124171436,
-0.0340368189,
0.2345164865,
0.614808023,
0.4426979125,
0.2903467119,
-0.7284826636,
0.6359863281,
0.1930810064,
-0.2020886689,
-0.082101427,
-0.2234126478,
-0.0213902108,
0.0079272306,
0.2748584747,
0.1786444932,
-0.2154010832,
-0.436267972,
0.1937934607,
0.0421254225,
-0.0742480978,
-0.2512922883,
0.2679792345,
0.3517532349,
0.2651697993,
0.6649664044,
-0.7539579868,
-0.8596724868,
0.3539065421,
0.4602553248,
0.4306913912,
-0.6139944792,
0.4488916099,
0.2850384414,
0.4287011921,
-0.2088497132,
0.5390512943,
0.2959852815,
-0.7633644938,
-0.5421806574,
-0.4903977215,
-0.1781469285,
0.1113047153,
-0.3663782477,
0.1543064713,
-0.5887591243,
-0.0669501796,
-0.0303073153,
-0.0593920462,
-0.1822947115,
0.3298850954,
0.1647226363,
0.4242161512,
-0.9605691433,
1.0587112904,
1.4018306732,
-0.27624771,
-0.8750966191,
-0.0258312393,
0.2499707788,
-0.4943467677,
0.5041134953,
0.0213841368,
-0.2148904204,
-0.3946851194,
-0.3182662427,
-0.5152922273,
0.5201756954,
0.5299857855,
-0.7494729161,
-0.1868220717,
0.0779438466,
0.8403238654,
-0.1944785565,
0.1839612424,
0.496609956,
0.4228624105,
0.2941050828,
-1.1273872852,
-0.2901578844,
-0.5174100399,
0.2793202102,
0.1568909734,
-0.3604932725,
1.1326830387,
-0.1838806123,
-0.2476055473,
0.3436030149,
0.4869879484,
-0.167008087,
0.0271731019,
0.5640623569,
0.862683475,
0.9688743949,
-0.3498471677,
0.704262495,
0.330232352,
0.7117279768,
0.9216201305,
-0.5515328646,
0.831015408,
0.2813525498,
-0.4988261759,
0.5868765712,
0.4327301383,
-0.0370420218,
0.4710329771,
0.4087364376,
-0.2066359669,
-0.3574391305,
-0.088452816,
-0.1682904512,
0.6052755713,
0.3060316741,
-0.1574992239,
-0.4908373654,
0.0246131886,
0.0832529217,
0.5660203099,
-0.4050172269,
0.581427753,
-0.2816944122,
-0.5580298305,
0.4075087905,
0.4037626982,
1.0892882347,
-0.7041234374,
-0.1271122396,
-0.2821435034,
0.6026445031,
-0.4604884088,
-0.6947648525,
0.1352128983,
0.5433174968,
-0.2559148967,
0.1417711228,
0.8543002605,
-0.5322681069,
-0.5104076862,
0.4153609574,
0.4534116089,
0.0520181879,
-0.0379144549,
-0.5837291479,
-0.0993950367,
0.1354867965,
0.3788322508,
0.1646121591,
0.5687701702,
-0.0918404758,
0.1834085584,
0.5989512205,
0.0221805647,
0.0829123482,
0.421114862,
0.6577212214,
-0.5305352807,
-0.7511072755,
-0.5312015414,
0.352396071,
-0.0988437012,
-0.4856202304,
0.5636969209,
0.340181917,
1.2681485415,
-0.3198516965,
0.8124544024,
-0.2338790596,
0.7100089192,
-0.6589773893,
0.7194566131,
-0.4540748894,
0.3383673131,
-0.7844828963,
-0.6799020171,
-0.7772586942,
1.0680185556,
-0.2724981308,
-0.0059097866,
0.7967731357,
0.8089583516,
0.2759069502,
0.466930002,
0.3069978654,
0.0905053616,
0.159854278,
0.813153863,
0.7438359857,
-0.2088884413,
0.3666939437,
-0.2323587835,
-0.5254479647,
-0.3660115004,
-0.7731941342,
-1.0297352076,
-0.476487726,
-0.2674971521,
-0.1116962284,
0.3346746564,
1.0630246401,
0.4117003679,
-1.0910599232,
-0.1812616289,
-0.1466494203,
0.1175416335,
-0.3102517426,
-0.2390966117,
0.6578224301,
-0.664388299,
-0.6333187222,
0.1734264344,
0.3054262698,
0.0242879223,
0.1510950029,
0.1280595958,
-0.8319544196,
-0.2209044546,
0.4610302746,
0.2286478132,
-0.8912549615,
-0.4602207541,
-0.1630938947,
-0.130735755,
0.18453978,
0.9041141868,
-0.482747525,
0.6563225985,
0.2587460279,
0.6937218904,
-0.0485955663,
-0.052318491,
0.1688904464,
-1.1656893492,
0.2188111246,
0.1975816935,
0.5573260784,
0.4443701208,
-0.3683542609,
0.5405165553,
0.6296198964,
-0.3165200055,
-0.4652118385,
-0.1093424335,
-0.8576259613,
-0.432849586,
0.8029844761,
-0.6563901305,
-0.1839269996,
-0.186993435,
-0.3511591256,
0.2017355114,
-0.472176224,
0.7860857844,
1.0633493662,
-0.0780210346,
0.1059671864,
-0.104055278,
0.3265765905,
0.7424462438,
-0.9797167182,
-0.057072971,
0.4026907086,
0.1260680407,
0.4584395587,
0.335771203,
-0.2575234473,
0.3198435903,
-0.0724860951,
0.3234883845,
0.2763642371,
-0.3627746403,
-0.322035104,
0.17916587,
-0.2168467194,
-0.3255947828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.18062v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.18062v2 | Solving morphological analogies: from retrieval to generation | 2023-03-30T12:36:46 | 2024-04-17T15:23:12 | Esteban Marquer, Miguel Couceiro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Analogical inference is a remarkable capability of human reasoning, and has
been used to solve hard reasoning tasks. Analogy based reasoning (AR) has
gained increasing interest from the artificial intelligence community and has
shown its potential in multiple machine learning tasks such as classification,
decision making and recommendation with competitive results. We propose a deep
learning (DL) framework to address and tackle two key tasks in AR: analogy
detection and solving. The framework is thoroughly tested on the Siganalogies
dataset of morphological analogical proportions (APs) between words, and shown
to outperform symbolic approaches in many languages. Previous work have
explored the behavior of the Analogy Neural Network for classification (ANNc)
on analogy detection and of the Analogy Neural Network for retrieval (ANNr) on
analogy solving by retrieval, as well as the potential of an autoencoder (AE)
for analogy solving by generating the solution word. In this article we
summarize these findings and we extend them by combining ANNr and the AE
embedding model, and checking the performance of ANNc as an retrieval method.
The combination of ANNr and AE outperforms the other approaches in almost all
cases, and ANNc as a retrieval method achieves competitive or better
performance than 3CosMul. We conclude with general guidelines on using our
framework to tackle APs with DL. | [
-0.376388371,
-0.6984527707,
0.8122666478,
-0.1510879099,
-0.3287215233,
-0.2697523832,
-0.1686166525,
-0.3565715849,
0.261315167,
0.1413373202,
-0.3241494298,
-0.303032428,
-0.5722245574,
0.2568576336,
-0.2909785509,
0.3288880587,
-0.0914263055,
0.4360387623,
-0.3305599988,
-0.4014507532,
-0.4477512836,
-0.5086809397,
-1.0398221016,
-0.4955806434,
0.3138543963,
0.0860797092,
0.6120471358,
1.2022407055,
0.429962039,
0.5056505203,
-0.0429616012,
0.1843244433,
0.0234755799,
0.2903129756,
-0.2839209437,
-0.6756367683,
-0.068942219,
-0.1963380128,
0.3507367373,
0.8782830238,
-0.2091041505,
0.0195323471,
-0.0139914975,
0.5450415611,
-0.7340420485,
0.3303760886,
-1.0231070518,
0.4298788011,
0.3854849637,
-0.1307488829,
-0.1201333553,
-0.178801164,
0.072221905,
-0.7952546477,
0.0952518433,
-0.0085522979,
0.5627851486,
0.5506102443,
-0.0942962319,
-0.5562731028,
-0.4348498285,
0.726772666,
-0.9234426618,
0.3118492961,
0.1847418845,
0.402672261,
-0.0903820246,
-0.8904293776,
-0.8298916817,
-0.1394968033,
-0.0392811708,
0.0748589337,
-0.1967993677,
0.0025033981,
0.0741944313,
0.3420143425,
-0.5023508072,
0.2644637227,
-0.3954433203,
-0.0096742352,
0.4671279788,
0.1572280824,
0.3055168092,
-0.0082471594,
-0.3794669211,
-0.2834422886,
-0.678473711,
-0.298323065,
0.4396066964,
0.0876355171,
0.2203734666,
0.3655765057,
-0.0131949019,
0.6407500505,
0.1165663823,
0.2080571353,
0.4047553539,
-0.1737644374,
-0.2281530946,
0.349583298,
0.6565760374,
0.4528692663,
0.5743342042,
-0.0609715767,
-0.2372605354,
0.2349502295,
0.2676517069,
-0.8747259974,
-0.2208122313,
-0.0871475264,
-0.6572081447,
-0.1911965311,
-0.0669295266,
-0.4972785711,
-0.1843162626,
-0.8065440655,
0.6869231462,
-0.6014356017,
-0.1629843414,
0.2890601158,
-0.0867269337,
0.2229701132,
0.2420815229,
-0.7723317146,
0.4899478555,
0.9294329882,
0.7705494761,
-0.1430960894,
-0.3815853596,
-0.2465157509,
-0.1199591905,
-0.5831423402,
0.7122352719,
-0.3581181765,
-0.0996852517,
-0.0864442363,
-0.3589113653,
-0.1986934841,
-1.0068283081,
0.2608136237,
-0.2804173827,
0.0120778903,
0.1944729388,
-0.9706628919,
-0.3862208426,
0.3717643023,
-0.7274964452,
0.5431785583,
-0.1718010902,
-0.3282916248,
0.1682335883,
-0.3605840206,
-0.2010710686,
-0.0542142577,
-0.5315033197,
-0.1883727312,
0.1251279265,
0.2677386105,
0.334707588,
-0.3248695433,
0.2034491003,
-0.5077810884,
-0.4628967345,
0.0866787359,
-0.4565930068,
0.6579366922,
0.5018161535,
-0.3057378829,
0.1384628713,
-0.4792571366,
0.1905195266,
0.0959049091,
0.3038119674,
-0.51996696,
-0.0682939738,
-0.5226612687,
0.229781732,
0.0192012247,
-0.5629380941,
-0.0999775752,
-0.6887597442,
0.7498033643,
0.6271489263,
0.1317669004,
0.390253067,
-0.1377520263,
0.1548076272,
0.2887555063,
-0.1643454432,
-0.2943615615,
-0.4189601839,
-0.8931154013,
0.0499866046,
0.3071777523,
0.3284547329,
-0.8919540644,
0.717656374,
-0.4356112182,
-0.2688530684,
-0.7518922091,
-0.046878498,
0.3833190203,
0.7378691435,
0.5323066711,
-0.2245593816,
-0.4744868577,
-1.0973192453,
-0.2496582717,
-0.3203972876,
-0.2449644357,
0.4908864498,
0.5258140564,
0.0202014297,
0.7330229282,
-0.3629206717,
-0.3722586036,
0.13265872,
0.17338866,
0.2747570872,
0.4863200188,
0.5254349113,
-1.051145792,
-0.254799962,
-0.0834108964,
-1.0754742622,
-0.033048328,
-0.093190603,
0.2096771896,
-0.1280978322,
0.9225172997,
-0.364410609,
0.3981791735,
0.0231696367,
-0.0427848585,
0.374288857,
-0.3788760602,
0.1255476326,
-1.0531688929,
-0.0014900874,
0.0831404775,
0.0815620795,
-0.3727510571,
0.4394763112,
-0.1288060546,
-0.0859055743,
-0.6365456581,
0.7580704093,
-0.1458483785,
-0.043669343,
-0.2388541102,
-0.1306218058,
0.1016762778,
0.4018913805,
0.2187330425,
1.0087794065,
0.3694755733,
-0.647315979,
0.5927320123,
0.097641468,
-0.314041853,
0.4861742258,
-0.7726522088,
0.0229767524,
-0.2281610817,
0.1858676672,
-0.578992784,
0.1297916174,
0.1668884605,
-0.4327965379,
-0.0168925188,
-0.017344052,
-0.6148673296,
-0.306365639,
-0.318223983,
0.7856329679,
0.6741953492,
-0.7729058266,
0.7401455045,
0.118302688,
0.0458807945,
-0.3751678169,
-0.6056665778,
0.0841979161,
-0.4469335675,
-0.2236155719,
0.4126235843,
0.0027748612,
-0.3636744022,
0.3943092525,
-0.0927183926,
-0.2699999511,
0.1701288074,
-0.0116072083,
-0.1303228438,
-0.5635912418,
0.0833999589,
0.1629677564,
-0.3190409839,
0.3519105315,
-0.5085560679,
0.4962673187,
-0.2139557898,
-0.6667543054,
-0.3263891041,
0.4031735957,
0.4756576717,
-0.1451746821,
0.5893477798,
0.3412494063,
-0.5188726783,
-0.2344592959,
-0.4079201221,
-0.3790027499,
-0.4476088881,
0.3822351694,
-0.6017301083,
-0.3101366758,
0.4984630346,
-0.2663339078,
-0.3118190765,
0.5484508276,
0.6525279284,
-0.1015179157,
0.8792864084,
0.0207066163,
0.1061769798,
0.0663003027,
-0.4516849816,
0.3170241416,
-0.6984315515,
-0.3338329494,
-0.2636170089,
-0.4620198905,
-0.2696040273,
-0.3528957665,
0.3345226943,
0.2757522464,
-0.4447611272,
0.5214864016,
-0.5516498089,
0.4931668341,
0.5201633573,
0.2246297449,
0.2308676988,
0.1198985204,
-0.4456782341,
0.0649478063,
-0.7440900803,
-0.2741079628,
0.9272106886,
0.2514910996,
0.5151364207,
-0.0627385303,
0.7362216115,
0.0888034478,
0.1287786067,
-0.9405123591,
0.7250375152,
-0.4188447893,
-0.2764393389,
-0.1101383194,
-0.4706006944,
-0.9134864807,
0.4438194036,
-0.0652203113,
-0.6415492296,
0.3049257696,
0.136181578,
-0.1915933043,
0.4943843186,
-0.6848435998,
0.6341920495,
-0.1666545421,
-0.0608682707,
-0.5685901046,
-0.7775328159,
0.0727925673,
-0.020429654,
-0.0755980313,
-0.0690356046,
-0.0442059077,
0.3752422035,
-0.4458945394,
0.4862219691,
0.1131695658,
0.1140081286,
0.3554987311,
0.2340635955,
0.0451484099,
-0.2782854438,
-0.5989669561,
0.2215216458,
0.0930669084,
-0.0863011554,
-1.2677793503,
0.8788084388,
-0.544303,
-0.6534483433,
-0.313352406,
-0.5324184299,
0.1071099266,
0.0300262533,
0.0622956641,
0.2653452158,
0.0059582917,
0.4096784592,
0.5844789147,
0.0238301493,
0.39106071,
0.0464322791,
0.109351851,
-0.4685706794,
1.0301113129,
0.0024653564,
0.0376897641,
0.3779958487,
0.3515850306,
-0.4419414401,
-0.5060745478,
-0.7655583024,
-0.0401681997,
-0.8488047123,
-0.4588076472,
-0.5059708953,
-0.6433873773,
-0.0788075477,
0.0473418534,
-0.2554137409,
-0.2869131863,
-0.259400934,
-0.0328686722,
0.1521343142,
0.3251835704,
-0.0945733264,
-0.022618698,
-0.5201033354,
0.4804154634,
0.286241889,
0.1484289318,
0.476336658,
-0.2923945785,
0.0891184583,
0.2863304019,
-0.0867236108,
-0.6714562774,
0.2770182788,
0.3596714139,
0.5999673605,
0.4536321759,
-0.164767161,
0.6117773652,
-0.8865285516,
0.536211133,
0.1747314185,
-0.7740539312,
0.2094394714,
0.1055164784,
-0.1178858355,
0.594658196,
0.4624150991,
-0.2208092958,
0.0851856768,
-0.7607190013,
-0.9187648892,
0.1088017598,
0.4884574413,
0.1772457212,
-0.2592262924,
0.6752275825,
0.1543481201,
0.3042107522,
-0.3567384183,
-0.4575235248,
-0.2210643888,
-0.6569299102,
0.1646105647,
0.1046073809,
0.0833201036,
-0.5069534183,
0.4940412939,
-0.1901761293,
0.2543421388,
0.0982766002,
-0.2027202696,
0.3147283792,
-0.0205045026,
0.2095288187,
0.5137118101,
0.0931615904,
0.4610317647,
0.3239928782,
-0.0222942252,
0.3617090583,
0.1497637779,
-0.1804692447,
0.0373739488,
0.5615718961,
0.5773506761,
0.0346811265,
-0.659162581,
0.4561057091,
0.1565221101,
-0.2415569127,
-0.3971968293,
0.2393193841,
0.088091895,
0.1329206973,
0.3951453269,
-0.0082778269,
0.5465627909,
-0.5334284306,
0.5193147063,
0.3753122091,
-0.2513352931,
-0.0231247451,
0.5416904688,
0.0360543616,
-0.5093943477,
0.7201882005,
-0.0390287228,
-0.6388975978,
1.2245197296,
0.7426187396,
0.7896543145,
-0.0853941292,
-0.1676224619,
0.4625487626,
-0.2146978527,
0.0637966096,
-0.0215207729,
-0.1880020499,
-0.8428700566,
-0.2879383266,
-0.5925271511,
-0.1690002382,
0.3060052693,
-0.7136237025,
0.0534001999,
-0.3711023629,
0.1913703084,
0.333154887,
-0.3248393834,
-0.6901971698,
0.3680917323,
0.2551854551,
0.9433910847,
-0.9245306849,
0.6737137437,
0.644598186,
-0.4986361265,
-0.8059891462,
0.0587715916,
-0.038335111,
-0.9200686216,
0.9496599436,
0.2935693264,
-0.3051773608,
0.0152606489,
-0.2610580623,
-0.6246045828,
0.9967272878,
0.4633412063,
-0.2862239182,
-0.0426417179,
0.0259208418,
0.8602518439,
-0.6894418001,
0.3980313838,
0.4905266166,
0.2276780903,
0.1037345231,
-0.7567036152,
0.0117567321,
-0.3952479661,
0.2074321508,
-0.0260824449,
-0.149106428,
0.7379721999,
0.000745939,
-0.0191837028,
0.4939022064,
0.771376133,
0.4104239643,
0.3309520483,
0.7520803213,
0.9574971199,
0.1662466377,
0.1350924969,
0.9377635121,
-0.1713382602,
0.1977114826,
1.1671953201,
-0.281496793,
0.7834252119,
0.7144945264,
-0.0276442748,
0.499792099,
0.6301558018,
-0.1664645672,
0.6042152643,
0.4588994384,
-0.3185952008,
-0.2426462919,
-0.3390003145,
-0.4270989299,
0.3696196675,
0.5884489417,
-0.6350495815,
-0.5360077024,
-0.0895848349,
-0.3885956407,
0.5800144076,
-0.3351606429,
0.9939382672,
0.3822008371,
-0.5869269967,
0.3971066773,
-0.101418376,
0.3277117014,
-0.3446635604,
-0.7675498724,
-0.1015730128,
0.4680407345,
0.1162254289,
-0.8866409659,
0.3524140418,
-0.5426786542,
-0.1718061417,
0.1041584313,
0.4818015695,
-0.5259842277,
-0.5970846415,
0.5482416749,
0.5506128669,
0.2647621334,
0.0752126649,
-0.8926660419,
-0.1848856658,
-0.2817275822,
0.2387788147,
0.2329879105,
0.6809842587,
-0.056161765,
0.9516354799,
0.5954700708,
0.1586050689,
-0.0486798324,
0.043741215,
0.8231696486,
-0.1874397099,
-0.5139433146,
-0.9885914922,
-0.1703775674,
-0.1669924706,
-0.1005251035,
0.4121157825,
0.608635366,
1.0204863548,
-0.1568998098,
0.3599217832,
0.1353041977,
0.2018650621,
-0.7131147385,
0.5819070339,
-0.6072052121,
0.2009576261,
0.0533271283,
-1.0281623602,
-0.4539349079,
1.0437216759,
-0.2474811673,
0.0528455302,
0.7957600355,
0.7955502868,
-0.598377049,
-0.1113420725,
0.3283031881,
0.0402889885,
0.0571633317,
0.6206482053,
0.644965589,
-0.569473803,
0.3365113139,
-0.2898539603,
0.2138704062,
-0.0557589158,
-0.9487882853,
-0.6315432191,
-0.7219932079,
-0.1868069023,
-0.3248490691,
0.4085650444,
1.1988360882,
0.6980822682,
-0.9059964418,
-0.0605237149,
-0.4728411436,
0.1763993353,
-0.2979423702,
-0.1699946821,
0.6265426874,
-0.3510991037,
-0.7552285194,
0.3728764355,
0.113001667,
-0.0773005784,
-0.2289351821,
-0.1005144268,
-0.2966517806,
-0.0441757962,
0.3243709505,
0.2428298891,
-1.0084071159,
-0.2773742974,
-0.3088354468,
-0.0597508326,
0.2436439544,
0.888417244,
-1.1377133131,
0.4487775266,
0.4855694175,
1.1383962631,
0.3857254684,
0.0313751139,
0.7809004784,
-0.4741583169,
0.422006011,
0.48998487,
0.6094691157,
0.2914277315,
-0.2291863114,
0.6149197817,
0.0524052233,
-0.0148914196,
-0.5433137417,
0.3782352209,
-0.4870280325,
-0.6976544261,
1.0013837814,
-0.345192641,
-0.2391545177,
0.123528257,
0.0577522293,
0.2792150378,
-0.186871171,
0.7836462855,
0.3910367787,
-0.1511891931,
-0.0838312283,
-0.2022895813,
0.2177338451,
0.7502168417,
-0.6095398664,
-0.4469385743,
0.1690855622,
0.1842789799,
0.3368194401,
-0.049524989,
-0.1186111122,
0.1461391151,
0.0105593251,
-0.1833411157,
-0.407464087,
-0.4125679433,
-0.4780548215,
0.1312651932,
-0.2628405392,
-0.4070211053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17324v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17324v1 | Topics in the Haystack: Extracting and Evaluating Topics beyond Coherence | 2023-03-30T12:24:25 | 2023-03-30T12:24:25 | Anton Thielmann, Quentin Seifert, Arik Reuter, Elisabeth Bergherr, Benjamin Säfken | cs.CL | cs.CL | Extracting and identifying latent topics in large text corpora has gained
increasing importance in Natural Language Processing (NLP). Most models,
whether probabilistic models similar to Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) or
neural topic models, follow the same underlying approach of topic
interpretability and topic extraction. We propose a method that incorporates a
deeper understanding of both sentence and document themes, and goes beyond
simply analyzing word frequencies in the data. This allows our model to detect
latent topics that may include uncommon words or neologisms, as well as words
not present in the documents themselves. Additionally, we propose several new
evaluation metrics based on intruder words and similarity measures in the
semantic space. We present correlation coefficients with human identification
of intruder words and achieve near-human level results at the word-intrusion
task. We demonstrate the competitive performance of our method with a large
benchmark study, and achieve superior results compared to state-of-the-art
topic modeling and document clustering models. | [
-0.3599458337,
-1.1321927309,
0.7433941364,
-0.0676754415,
-0.295442909,
0.3908112943,
-0.0635968968,
-0.4595382512,
0.594297111,
0.5470672846,
-0.4282758534,
-0.4450509846,
-0.6643104553,
-0.1129480451,
-0.8092918396,
0.9446959496,
0.2530068755,
-0.3174078763,
-0.4401385188,
0.2999276519,
-0.7155746818,
-0.505448401,
-0.1099236086,
0.0427289084,
0.2707242966,
0.3008709252,
0.3843119442,
0.1991865635,
0.7543943524,
0.2262617499,
-0.4894782603,
-0.0346338972,
-0.4422647357,
0.1222147867,
-0.6678467989,
-0.413400501,
-0.1368662566,
0.2306254059,
0.4857781827,
0.8694332242,
-0.1709292382,
-0.1765500903,
-0.034750849,
0.3299067616,
-0.5740029812,
-0.1782993823,
-0.9659500718,
-0.0921836719,
-0.5626699924,
-0.3909142315,
-0.1927403212,
-0.0647377968,
0.5268739462,
-0.3560957611,
0.592115581,
-0.0887931809,
1.0061767101,
-0.1049259081,
-0.1111621633,
-0.4911470413,
-0.3230245709,
0.9661899805,
-0.3161650896,
0.4263347387,
0.6724206805,
-0.2156293988,
-0.3212064803,
-0.6370003223,
-0.4735132158,
-0.0617273077,
-0.0074444865,
0.0125571359,
-0.4649448097,
-0.3005796969,
-0.2929426432,
0.5307908654,
-0.7636064291,
0.0004238543,
-0.1767369807,
-0.2914445996,
0.5129502416,
0.2251736671,
0.3958951533,
-0.4615155756,
-0.1672493368,
0.2115032077,
-0.2921117842,
-0.1821662188,
0.3929801583,
0.2381131649,
-0.0076931044,
0.3597775996,
-0.1771344095,
0.5786383152,
0.1653670967,
0.1799368262,
0.0354991369,
-0.5867532492,
0.2614646256,
-0.0109526953,
0.1849146187,
0.0958920643,
-0.5183060169,
-0.7434161901,
-0.0933045074,
0.1805265546,
0.5266441703,
-0.628543973,
-0.2002316415,
0.3369729817,
-0.50407511,
-0.276094228,
0.376098454,
-1.0587663651,
-0.3779621124,
-0.0811369121,
0.3922431171,
-0.334492445,
-0.4795068204,
0.0815735236,
-0.5962428451,
0.2489014417,
0.2404479533,
-0.9501794577,
0.470739156,
1.4057428837,
1.0886623859,
-0.6408647895,
-0.1501253545,
-0.6786549687,
-0.1249565706,
-0.5227490067,
0.9643179774,
-0.9615984559,
-0.3648024797,
-0.1676979214,
0.154569909,
-0.020056,
-0.58045578,
0.4180615544,
-0.9534636736,
0.5213724375,
-0.1078367084,
-0.7196059227,
-0.0804867297,
0.2315605432,
-0.4864535332,
0.7058286071,
0.2088440657,
-0.9536679387,
0.3503046632,
-0.8156654239,
-0.1125438362,
0.1740800291,
-0.2440726906,
0.0009457294,
0.4102440476,
-0.0982869193,
0.4665534198,
-0.514021337,
0.5108087659,
-0.1400558949,
-0.2712710798,
0.2981309593,
-0.2454115897,
0.5945219398,
0.2752997279,
0.0148163745,
0.1226031706,
-0.595010519,
-0.3710246384,
0.0006580498,
0.1175557449,
-0.7508282661,
0.1296393722,
0.1112629622,
-0.1428700686,
0.4416641593,
-0.4870374203,
-0.3383596539,
-0.8883405328,
0.3997636735,
0.6377115846,
0.4786196649,
0.525480032,
-0.1411771625,
0.4576718807,
0.0982543305,
-0.3506413698,
-0.1945017576,
-0.5635721087,
-0.3402174115,
-0.4524240196,
0.3349291086,
0.4242072403,
-0.5251204371,
0.9466055632,
-0.1478931606,
-0.6284815669,
-0.2556541264,
-0.0703530237,
0.1933842003,
0.4168688655,
0.173617363,
-0.7269038558,
-0.2523507774,
-0.6887851357,
-0.4354588985,
-0.0299685728,
-0.1353122592,
0.0870885402,
0.5336313844,
-0.3347153366,
1.2585650682,
-0.8859859705,
-0.0809451118,
0.1562458426,
0.6794397831,
0.5353258848,
0.4314584136,
0.2354719043,
-1.0461390018,
-0.1802015305,
-0.0636872426,
-0.5743535757,
-0.0670226291,
-0.0961018205,
-0.186289832,
-0.0577736087,
0.7029482722,
-0.3076196611,
0.387773484,
0.3361095488,
-0.6499298215,
0.3858904243,
-0.0006154587,
-0.2255846709,
-1.1851080656,
0.0402811915,
0.0391681604,
-0.0489322431,
-0.5244543552,
0.3191170096,
-0.3250952959,
-0.4436445236,
-0.1012810916,
0.4716601372,
-0.3435334861,
-0.1056338549,
-0.5096789002,
0.4064770639,
0.3065763414,
-0.010299678,
0.1805689484,
0.7599534392,
0.4944347441,
-0.3960052729,
0.3044151068,
0.2770110965,
-0.4600404501,
0.501175344,
-0.4865836501,
0.3530068099,
-0.1274306029,
-0.0064626788,
-0.9514533877,
-0.0936499909,
-0.0055201296,
-0.3814804256,
0.358145535,
0.1007369682,
-0.2094162703,
0.2417362928,
-0.5221360922,
-0.0427723452,
0.2028030455,
-0.3964977264,
0.2293266654,
0.7019976974,
-0.3070608974,
-0.4515153766,
-0.2514987886,
0.4706273079,
-0.5039708614,
-0.4593190253,
0.6301881075,
0.1218139231,
-0.6412628889,
0.2035086155,
-0.1093486771,
-0.6132793427,
0.6165243983,
0.0262185782,
0.1330593377,
-0.3029834032,
0.4162766039,
-0.0943249688,
-0.3418001533,
-0.0862828419,
-0.2025601864,
0.72747612,
-0.2413497567,
-0.0750597641,
-0.3246653676,
0.7062253356,
0.0520514846,
-0.4248957634,
0.705437541,
0.6288484335,
-0.5045208335,
0.1661173552,
-0.2955712974,
-0.4392952919,
-0.3722870648,
0.8008036017,
-0.3759442568,
-0.7094019651,
0.3222818375,
-0.0560790524,
-0.1270001233,
0.7444081306,
0.4427072406,
-0.1094240919,
0.2023481131,
1.0015307665,
0.0409156643,
0.6275199652,
-0.1180038378,
0.3027988374,
-0.8535206914,
0.0351178609,
-0.7356378436,
0.2442068011,
-0.6089178324,
-0.7120840549,
0.0827946812,
0.3129946291,
0.6325516701,
0.3997235298,
-0.4345882535,
0.3842839003,
0.1880544126,
-0.0523298793,
0.2107679546,
0.1079576388,
0.3101543486,
-0.247956112,
-0.3463274837,
-0.7173051834,
0.8359910846,
0.4553737342,
0.3940453231,
0.1825737357,
0.8194103837,
0.5078040361,
0.0098443376,
-0.7753569484,
0.3368791938,
-0.4743772447,
-0.8518350124,
-0.5405109525,
-0.137718752,
-1.0948928595,
0.4829061031,
-0.4058087468,
-1.1629918814,
0.6678500175,
-0.482796073,
-0.3425919116,
0.0018669285,
-0.5641083121,
0.7223101854,
0.0735390931,
-0.4638950825,
-0.5568597913,
-0.3333156109,
0.1651121676,
-0.6370202899,
0.1197049916,
-0.1740566343,
-0.4468910694,
1.0732736588,
-0.1531933397,
0.6130424738,
0.1840133965,
-0.3403970003,
0.2628918886,
-0.1344596595,
0.1263862997,
0.202550143,
-0.3756541014,
0.5656499267,
0.2955369949,
-0.2976934314,
-0.488158673,
0.4882904589,
-0.4838951826,
-0.7145236731,
-0.6164581776,
-0.3954749107,
-0.133261621,
0.2444586605,
0.1561789364,
0.525333643,
-0.6711786985,
0.4140566289,
0.5628347397,
-0.3293524086,
0.2965595722,
0.4969711006,
-0.1572054029,
-0.1348694116,
1.3524650335,
0.0485734195,
-0.1281864643,
0.6832582355,
0.5341356397,
-0.1685225219,
-0.5810937881,
-0.1238254905,
-0.0287699513,
-0.5433838367,
0.1612550914,
-0.921600759,
-0.1604052931,
-0.2832575142,
-0.2289486527,
-0.0917622074,
-0.1543096602,
-0.6427692175,
0.276683867,
0.2245599329,
0.4257847965,
-0.1089104712,
0.3771834075,
-0.8765130639,
0.5617771745,
0.2692935169,
0.0864231437,
-0.0848879591,
-0.7450888753,
-0.1369207203,
-0.4199303687,
-0.2322190702,
-1.1066792011,
0.3392782807,
0.2102126181,
0.580365777,
0.5450573564,
-0.0744978935,
0.4117562771,
-0.2700579464,
0.8817231655,
0.1739056855,
-1.061555028,
0.5396773815,
-0.3384627402,
0.0033552421,
0.6237148046,
0.3947366178,
-0.6505038738,
-0.315620482,
-0.8485021591,
-0.8961595893,
0.6423789263,
0.2829347551,
0.2488834113,
-0.1401987225,
0.3954462111,
0.3170880377,
0.2120827585,
-0.1015419215,
0.3388950229,
0.0995763466,
-0.1256913096,
-0.2629847527,
-0.3922522962,
0.0065592099,
0.0804347321,
0.3866007626,
-0.0284496676,
0.1992207468,
0.1546794027,
-0.2314860523,
-0.0547421016,
0.2759158909,
0.3485003412,
0.9499623775,
-0.5613976121,
0.289752394,
0.143360436,
-0.6931021214,
-0.0988203883,
0.1274230331,
0.0118006179,
0.2593693733,
0.7953901291,
0.1242447048,
0.0628308654,
-0.6596536636,
0.5272459984,
-0.1781207472,
0.0717944652,
-0.1344397217,
0.1556320488,
0.0914143026,
0.2339112461,
0.4061232805,
-0.2246002406,
0.4393539131,
-1.0022270679,
0.5626093745,
0.6133272052,
-0.6011503339,
-0.4360513091,
0.0860046297,
0.22533831,
-0.5143128633,
0.329536885,
-0.1906814873,
-0.4792954922,
0.7340074182,
0.5008380413,
1.1071361303,
0.1501837373,
0.1243526638,
0.1100705266,
0.230812937,
0.2416134626,
0.1794059873,
-0.1802353263,
-0.6284071803,
-0.1802428812,
-0.7038354874,
-0.302082181,
0.1966412961,
-0.7190371156,
0.1226161197,
-0.1195208579,
-0.0512615815,
0.5960519314,
0.4838624895,
-0.1116319969,
0.0548299626,
-0.085710749,
0.720169425,
-0.9136352539,
0.649946034,
0.6320675611,
-0.2134193331,
0.1142719463,
0.7128672004,
-0.2660497725,
-0.3354642093,
0.5254953504,
0.0847240016,
-0.128720969,
-0.1730227768,
-0.5025740266,
-0.8721323609,
0.6724846363,
0.0185070299,
-0.4780468047,
0.0579595827,
-0.3050460815,
0.5742910504,
-0.141261071,
0.0320611224,
0.5152618289,
0.2315007597,
-0.0844065547,
-0.5681652427,
-0.1778476387,
-0.0483056307,
-0.0940931141,
0.2112990171,
-0.4349762797,
0.883218646,
0.1789347827,
-0.2675055861,
0.0885587931,
0.8038054109,
0.1269839406,
0.5537952185,
0.554107964,
0.1958179176,
1.0437768698,
0.1611285359,
0.6773825288,
-0.1178171113,
0.3673496246,
1.0184674263,
-0.207036674,
0.830679059,
0.6327323318,
-0.1918515861,
0.5003244877,
0.688462019,
0.0833922327,
0.7140166759,
0.3561241329,
0.0001921168,
-0.192410782,
-0.4118421376,
-0.4181523323,
0.917832911,
0.6393538713,
-0.0465317033,
-0.3231562972,
-0.2539305091,
-0.1860022098,
0.3956914842,
0.0810775906,
0.9598427415,
0.2179510146,
-0.4430398345,
0.1386023462,
0.4001648128,
0.7188977599,
-0.4872574508,
-0.2579078376,
-0.1065368131,
-0.0081198765,
-0.0739833117,
-0.6037256718,
0.6993738413,
0.1650914103,
-0.4338760972,
0.1574075818,
0.9120436907,
-0.1667603403,
-0.417224735,
0.206461519,
0.5382951498,
0.4781699479,
-0.1475812495,
-0.5633413792,
-0.1734518409,
-0.3524951637,
0.033485774,
0.3042033911,
0.5593897104,
-0.2860688567,
0.0046061142,
0.7068287134,
0.1820106357,
-0.3002710044,
-0.2505630255,
0.7205358744,
-0.888052702,
-0.8914197087,
-0.8534619808,
-0.0732477978,
-0.3002371788,
-0.4858870804,
0.7651991844,
0.5445340872,
0.3542442024,
0.2374007106,
0.3864084184,
-0.0415281355,
0.7825961113,
-0.5793153048,
0.6571978331,
-0.7049016356,
0.2776383758,
-0.5557687283,
-0.739513576,
0.1020257175,
0.629983902,
-0.4574308097,
-0.3571302593,
0.7254439592,
0.7171320915,
-0.1225192249,
0.2038929909,
0.412876755,
-0.1074962392,
0.3650377989,
0.3408752084,
1.1825200319,
-0.2824516296,
-0.0020215642,
-0.0720828697,
-0.2887937725,
-0.4833916426,
-0.835191071,
-0.7556723952,
-0.7607163191,
-0.4084110856,
-0.2350001484,
0.040078029,
0.5300912857,
0.6926828623,
-0.7869368792,
-0.0953593329,
-0.1428004056,
0.5332893133,
-0.1121551916,
-0.2765705884,
0.6570369005,
-0.4029044509,
-0.5008621216,
0.5277872086,
0.3523947001,
-0.3524542153,
-0.5120313764,
0.2254071087,
-0.5916909575,
0.2658102512,
0.4314708114,
-0.0999507979,
-0.6012599468,
-0.1218223721,
-0.028683763,
0.0537918583,
-0.0213307291,
0.676558435,
-0.5402871966,
0.547144413,
0.6129363179,
0.744828701,
0.3242327273,
0.1146263182,
0.4707265794,
-0.6330317855,
0.4188297391,
0.3727419972,
-0.0634912327,
0.1435672045,
-0.5866552591,
0.4706048965,
0.4699788392,
-0.0370189697,
-1.0647468567,
0.1417127252,
-0.5966604352,
-0.6832066178,
0.7762177587,
0.0125543233,
-0.2750431895,
-0.6404722929,
0.1357586682,
0.0041631367,
-0.2797287703,
0.9024586678,
0.8437996507,
0.0902235135,
0.1788091809,
-0.4718751907,
0.2023406625,
0.4598562419,
-0.9587856531,
-0.1146149263,
0.3460659385,
0.0618655682,
0.742890358,
0.5660161376,
-0.1839157343,
0.2127867788,
0.2119614631,
-0.2190276682,
0.4958191812,
-0.4807281792,
-0.734136641,
0.2285155207,
0.0507210419,
-0.2629711032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17322v1 | Yes but.. Can ChatGPT Identify Entities in Historical Documents? | 2023-03-30T12:23:39 | 2023-03-30T12:23:39 | Carlos-Emiliano González-Gallardo, Emanuela Boros, Nancy Girdhar, Ahmed Hamdi, Jose G. Moreno, Antoine Doucet | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) have been leveraged for several years now,
obtaining state-of-the-art performance in recognizing entities from modern
documents. For the last few months, the conversational agent ChatGPT has
"prompted" a lot of interest in the scientific community and public due to its
capacity of generating plausible-sounding answers. In this paper, we explore
this ability by probing it in the named entity recognition and classification
(NERC) task in primary sources (e.g., historical newspapers and classical
commentaries) in a zero-shot manner and by comparing it with state-of-the-art
LM-based systems. Our findings indicate several shortcomings in identifying
entities in historical text that range from the consistency of entity
annotation guidelines, entity complexity, and code-switching, to the
specificity of prompting. Moreover, as expected, the inaccessibility of
historical archives to the public (and thus on the Internet) also impacts its
performance. | [
-0.6000216007,
-1.0533702374,
0.7607198358,
-0.2696986198,
-0.3156588078,
0.0730116144,
-0.4705979526,
-0.7022976279,
0.2758848369,
0.5617672205,
-0.521283567,
-0.2897916734,
-0.6513856053,
0.264129281,
-0.828058362,
1.2075264454,
-0.0573967956,
-0.247962147,
-0.069276154,
-0.0908271298,
-0.0768063292,
-0.8058437705,
-0.8499436378,
-0.1481935531,
0.631939292,
0.3822645247,
0.584395647,
0.580675602,
0.7035424113,
0.2481867671,
-0.2793053687,
0.1999442875,
-0.5905276537,
0.4002550542,
-0.156635657,
-0.4361171722,
-0.3324586451,
-0.0681285933,
0.8310480118,
0.234763965,
0.0277682655,
0.0829492882,
0.0526990853,
0.3617640436,
-0.4227518439,
0.3787163198,
-0.8824442029,
-0.1945369244,
-0.4088379443,
-0.6313901544,
-0.6533616781,
-0.3159862459,
0.3222491741,
-0.5055875182,
0.5537483692,
0.1670477539,
1.2624862194,
0.0163460262,
-0.3813098669,
-0.7708281279,
-0.950719595,
0.6637978554,
-0.6263381243,
0.415479064,
0.1383245885,
0.2987461686,
-0.3940379024,
-0.7265217304,
-0.6082909703,
-0.5674805045,
-0.1026818007,
-0.1821361333,
-0.3495895863,
-0.1797754616,
0.6283710599,
0.1768312752,
-0.6132911444,
0.2683062255,
-0.2059258372,
-0.4406068921,
0.0324026085,
0.1708638519,
0.5019186139,
-0.3076149821,
-0.4754211009,
0.0560227223,
-0.8901931047,
-0.2908333242,
0.2795177698,
0.4323753715,
0.0545386076,
0.4984224737,
-0.0697363168,
0.3658134341,
0.0192712676,
-0.2549843192,
-0.1097328886,
0.0196842607,
-0.3471208513,
0.1810560822,
0.6902685761,
0.0916564465,
0.4255130589,
-0.3063258231,
-0.0623870715,
-0.1763334125,
0.0491192564,
-0.8314058781,
-0.2384701222,
-0.2685030699,
-0.106332399,
0.0631947145,
-0.0598371774,
-0.7496416569,
-0.4096540511,
-0.2122430652,
0.1746598631,
-0.4129599333,
-0.2155163437,
-0.3187080026,
-0.1731766015,
0.5171021223,
0.8670677543,
-0.7694983482,
0.452131927,
0.8716510534,
1.0660426617,
-0.0114994226,
-0.1133920178,
-0.4444700778,
0.1268372387,
-0.2088748962,
1.0924762487,
-0.5143234134,
-0.3719828129,
-0.0689856336,
0.274636358,
0.1021385863,
-0.4158661664,
0.6298115253,
-0.8716855645,
0.1725215316,
-0.2834267914,
-0.7206277251,
-0.1995043606,
0.3856438398,
-0.7745832205,
0.8073664904,
-0.1619798541,
-0.9258174896,
0.3853267431,
-0.2190762907,
-0.1281169057,
0.3432153761,
-0.4326141775,
-0.4283010662,
-0.1637694538,
0.2029450387,
0.3795505166,
-0.4110814929,
0.3798017502,
-0.2102968842,
-0.3676401973,
0.2756538987,
-0.7389709353,
0.5662987232,
0.0230439268,
-0.4281412959,
-0.4417915642,
-0.4430384934,
-0.3151505291,
0.0998344943,
-0.4429816306,
-0.2944299281,
0.0690356418,
-0.0154684456,
-0.1256982237,
0.1426122934,
-0.2983504534,
0.5357635617,
-0.1040114462,
0.4645488262,
0.5657390952,
0.2271001041,
0.4376902282,
-0.2839183211,
0.5278012753,
-0.1592617929,
-0.4966025651,
-0.4360847175,
-0.5838187337,
-0.9962055087,
-0.2218113244,
0.3323058486,
0.5021238327,
-0.5884578824,
-0.0211958792,
-0.5977897048,
-0.5560979247,
0.1621541679,
-0.2647423744,
0.062928319,
0.6683259606,
0.1735570282,
-0.1840497702,
-0.5814003944,
-0.909527421,
-0.0756394118,
-0.6718297601,
0.084586814,
0.6365771294,
0.5924428105,
0.0978004858,
0.8461168408,
-0.0989672244,
-0.0385570042,
0.181749627,
0.3803807199,
0.2815006673,
0.1105726361,
0.2723664939,
-0.7082082033,
-0.2527259886,
0.1740840077,
-0.7912226915,
-0.0792514086,
-0.2514923811,
0.0799493939,
0.3058463335,
0.6796478629,
-0.5962953568,
0.3146007955,
0.219187513,
-0.0185220819,
0.3581874073,
-0.2039142102,
0.286785543,
-0.6373189092,
0.1288806498,
-0.0406695791,
-0.3406930864,
-0.7394493818,
-0.1985570788,
0.3489858806,
-0.1835408062,
-0.4948915541,
0.6963765621,
-0.8287775517,
-0.0224350151,
-0.3618136346,
0.5184187889,
-0.4943671227,
0.3817504644,
0.4047535956,
0.4764887393,
0.4680367708,
-0.6524365544,
0.1078774929,
0.1218290776,
-0.2529979348,
0.7987084389,
-0.2839722633,
0.5095735788,
-0.4537369609,
0.3282754719,
-0.6574425697,
-0.2242599279,
0.4269135892,
-0.5291475654,
0.6313815713,
-0.6697517037,
-0.5399227142,
0.110898383,
0.1248531342,
-0.0245398786,
0.2943581641,
-0.2941530049,
0.6367323995,
0.3975842595,
-0.3252820075,
-0.6862990856,
-0.5097370744,
0.4733780622,
-0.2483827472,
-0.6190974712,
-0.1129536107,
0.2236883044,
-0.1341298521,
0.1867954284,
-0.270549655,
-0.2708065808,
0.1353662908,
0.4395987093,
0.4546641409,
-0.5980525613,
0.4664040208,
-0.3589098155,
-0.0642659739,
-0.2540620863,
-0.0572161786,
0.4822428524,
-0.1833778024,
-0.4888677001,
-0.3513393104,
0.0882283822,
0.5434841514,
0.0040233522,
0.6083949208,
0.2164713144,
-0.4518057108,
-0.0730502605,
-0.8979581594,
-0.0920829922,
-0.3656883538,
0.3351248503,
-0.0342678092,
-1.2622419596,
0.4211895466,
0.0262722988,
0.025716234,
0.5966529846,
0.6194696426,
0.1347809285,
0.2140883207,
0.0659811199,
-0.3553655744,
0.5807564855,
0.0762648135,
0.1969361007,
-0.7722433209,
-0.0574037097,
-0.8560490608,
-0.1825174391,
-0.8761974573,
-0.1968548298,
0.2503127754,
0.0246655494,
-0.3577723205,
0.4726128876,
-0.3714651167,
0.3985573053,
0.3728238046,
-0.1140886992,
0.5532740951,
-0.1467525959,
0.3338108361,
0.139912203,
-0.3544113934,
-1.1375182867,
0.8522010446,
0.4180487096,
0.7506635189,
0.0780597255,
0.8495083451,
0.2504303157,
0.5660150647,
-0.7564979196,
0.7961055636,
0.1533509642,
-0.9246492386,
-0.3964783847,
-0.4256795645,
-1.1839091778,
0.0957560837,
-0.217062816,
-0.9875759482,
0.3576596081,
-0.0828107521,
-0.2422351688,
0.3841933906,
-0.6344276667,
0.6304882169,
-0.1700033695,
0.0619287156,
0.2437556535,
-0.3088897169,
0.0262851305,
-0.0756808221,
0.1804772168,
-0.4773181975,
-0.1550706029,
0.6072672009,
0.0396204665,
0.6125948429,
-0.0779867843,
0.2872854173,
0.3794522583,
0.4206512272,
0.8504137993,
0.0965332091,
0.1958598495,
0.1455466747,
-0.0868225768,
-0.1274295896,
-0.6443155408,
0.8398299813,
-0.589104712,
-0.809925139,
-0.5669712424,
-0.2311440706,
0.1269173324,
0.3269946277,
0.1608221233,
0.5641038418,
-0.5233265162,
0.4335876703,
0.6068127751,
-0.0251916405,
0.598831594,
0.8705829382,
0.0267484076,
0.104600355,
0.7443028688,
0.3918799162,
-0.0169574153,
0.5328623652,
-0.1928113997,
0.1230952069,
-0.8430184722,
-0.5261991024,
0.2971142232,
-0.8062121272,
-0.0571959876,
-0.7219800949,
-0.2406277657,
-0.1430447102,
0.07755851,
-0.0585271157,
-0.1965118945,
-0.6923345327,
-0.0954088271,
0.124578312,
0.7988793254,
0.3179037273,
0.1377507895,
-0.6952309608,
0.0768974796,
0.216413185,
0.1003239006,
0.0213357862,
-0.4968582094,
0.0590200648,
-0.1703266352,
-0.1265842021,
-1.2945103645,
0.4400782883,
0.0491464958,
0.7370141149,
0.3461108804,
-0.0801728442,
0.4275150895,
-0.7058956027,
0.700797379,
-0.3409659266,
-0.6458541155,
0.2381450236,
-0.4155488014,
-0.0013150807,
0.2506824136,
0.5897118449,
-0.7782729864,
-0.5749001503,
-0.7017588019,
-0.7582273483,
0.7365167141,
0.2757744193,
0.1594753712,
-0.376565516,
0.3863756955,
-0.1408251524,
0.0817975402,
-0.7045511603,
-0.0749122873,
0.1643496752,
0.34407565,
0.0966718122,
-0.2730985284,
0.2683432102,
0.4669421017,
0.8023375869,
0.017793864,
0.32265082,
0.457451731,
-0.4130088091,
0.0086794365,
0.6222795844,
0.562790215,
0.6001347303,
-0.1424694657,
0.2884982824,
0.248930797,
-0.4584365785,
0.0090835933,
0.0769826472,
-0.2542176843,
0.2531319261,
0.5407588482,
0.846426487,
0.4406053126,
-0.4369203746,
0.5116521716,
-0.0807727501,
0.027291812,
-0.7266512513,
0.0232374445,
0.1557634473,
0.5495242476,
0.5992953181,
-0.2367376536,
-0.0386682823,
-0.6953400373,
-0.0456416383,
0.6315527558,
-0.3603075743,
-0.1137506366,
0.4240382016,
-0.0275614373,
-0.5950703621,
0.9323676825,
-0.1839715242,
-0.4058910906,
0.6332685947,
0.2269000709,
0.7542925477,
0.0521692932,
0.1478682458,
0.2734076381,
0.4845815897,
-0.352352947,
-0.3280178308,
-0.0915366337,
-0.8720791936,
-0.2501695752,
-0.3730750084,
-0.6529310942,
0.1090839878,
-0.5304443836,
0.51380229,
-0.2196350843,
-0.330632776,
0.4670155644,
-0.1336760074,
-0.8974907398,
-0.0911978111,
0.513592422,
0.6982952356,
-0.6632019877,
0.7956213951,
0.3718187809,
-0.5085707903,
-0.5854825974,
-0.0767877549,
0.2837148905,
-0.6255639195,
0.9265609384,
-0.0646464452,
-0.0065823845,
-0.0706520602,
-0.6818894148,
-0.8648669124,
1.1190010309,
0.5481699109,
-0.716982007,
-0.5728641748,
-0.1247849539,
0.7093434334,
-0.1152574047,
0.8329346776,
0.2098380923,
0.5531172752,
0.0722039565,
-1.2866452932,
-0.0499167554,
-0.0873715207,
-0.3076211214,
0.6432557106,
-0.3655413687,
0.8868008852,
0.0933743492,
-0.9634149671,
0.1262577325,
0.5636751652,
-0.1184242889,
0.4378728569,
0.288757056,
0.3584424555,
0.9629125595,
-0.2941716015,
1.0954520702,
-0.0960072577,
0.5612951517,
1.1967115402,
-0.2706641555,
0.8329518437,
0.2840431035,
-0.147987932,
0.5681637526,
0.549087882,
-0.2376760244,
0.3028944135,
0.0047701071,
-0.3443444669,
-0.1271303296,
0.0127279488,
-0.2701571286,
0.1431680173,
0.4052878916,
-0.5229308009,
-0.5116732121,
-0.3605491519,
0.3235501647,
-0.4192283154,
-0.3227224052,
0.8548771143,
0.1332498193,
-0.5011236668,
0.2818673551,
-0.2557608485,
0.4755559862,
-0.4683978558,
-0.0681474507,
-0.0822680742,
-0.2720505893,
-0.0680294484,
-0.7174754143,
0.0320819393,
-0.023293918,
0.0884841159,
0.0112395231,
0.9213501811,
-0.2190771103,
-0.060009893,
0.0465652794,
0.7722753286,
0.5963033438,
-0.1850490868,
-0.1187624261,
-0.1876920313,
-0.2196454108,
-0.3809706867,
0.3072149754,
0.8017753959,
-0.3033081293,
0.5517600775,
0.5337780714,
0.0801279098,
-0.0411354154,
-0.2378173172,
0.7411120534,
-0.789026618,
-0.1679921299,
-1.1988142729,
-0.0706981793,
-0.0201134272,
-0.1939746886,
0.8104890585,
0.5823140144,
0.9478035569,
0.2084999233,
0.6118947268,
0.0747199133,
0.7223157883,
-0.3982898593,
0.5087918639,
-0.0891191214,
0.2570882142,
-0.3917588592,
-0.81361866,
-0.1601799428,
0.2999832928,
-0.4775351286,
-0.1638810188,
0.8216223717,
0.8442816734,
0.0539506227,
0.3130958676,
0.292704016,
0.1653944254,
0.3569929004,
0.4104923606,
1.2229384184,
0.0987926051,
0.7300982475,
0.1192658693,
0.1116832346,
-0.3283995986,
-1.1091163158,
-0.9239909053,
-0.6398360729,
-0.2056416869,
-0.1548865885,
0.427588284,
0.8564918637,
0.3858270347,
-0.6585224867,
-0.0353290029,
0.1765186936,
0.0644414276,
0.3783694506,
-0.1582696438,
0.5096487999,
0.0526760556,
-0.8333166242,
0.2413803339,
0.461479038,
0.0901623592,
-0.122315757,
0.15797773,
-0.0472765453,
-0.1254242808,
0.1518353224,
0.6186292768,
-0.8245337009,
-0.6176096797,
0.1499370784,
-0.3088871837,
0.3915525973,
1.1027185917,
-0.6529527903,
0.3275843263,
0.5198816657,
0.5960186124,
0.8704931736,
-0.0525330305,
0.0612795912,
-0.3366648555,
0.0265585911,
0.5747878551,
0.5614690781,
0.3015950322,
-0.3593631983,
0.3802421987,
0.1624350101,
-1.040081501,
-0.6196339726,
-0.006499406,
-1.1697839499,
-0.0107351318,
1.3230676651,
-0.2813495994,
-0.305868715,
-0.3639166951,
-0.3579530418,
0.2671314776,
-0.7258973718,
0.5140519142,
1.0085760355,
-0.210843876,
-0.4537347257,
-1.0294777155,
0.1161004901,
-0.125634864,
-0.6380498409,
-0.1859345734,
0.7655053139,
0.3551280499,
0.3309764564,
0.9265491366,
-0.0831160769,
0.1425873637,
-0.2223630399,
-0.099397704,
-0.0417709574,
-0.0333728716,
-0.1162120476,
0.2921061218,
0.2799120545,
0.2402253449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17276v1 | Humans in Humans Out: On GPT Converging Toward Common Sense in both Success and Failure | 2023-03-30T10:32:18 | 2023-03-30T10:32:18 | Philipp Koralus, Vincent Wang-Maścianica | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, 00, 68, I.2.0; I.2.6 | Increase in computational scale and fine-tuning has seen a dramatic
improvement in the quality of outputs of large language models (LLMs) like GPT.
Given that both GPT-3 and GPT-4 were trained on large quantities of
human-generated text, we might ask to what extent their outputs reflect
patterns of human thinking, both for correct and incorrect cases. The Erotetic
Theory of Reason (ETR) provides a symbolic generative model of both human
success and failure in thinking, across propositional, quantified, and
probabilistic reasoning, as well as decision-making. We presented GPT-3,
GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 with 61 central inference and judgment problems from a
recent book-length presentation of ETR, consisting of experimentally verified
data-points on human judgment and extrapolated data-points predicted by ETR,
with correct inference patterns as well as fallacies and framing effects (the
ETR61 benchmark). ETR61 includes classics like Wason's card task, illusory
inferences, the decoy effect, and opportunity-cost neglect, among others. GPT-3
showed evidence of ETR-predicted outputs for 59% of these examples, rising to
77% in GPT-3.5 and 75% in GPT-4. Remarkably, the production of human-like
fallacious judgments increased from 18% in GPT-3 to 33% in GPT-3.5 and 34% in
GPT-4. This suggests that larger and more advanced LLMs may develop a tendency
toward more human-like mistakes, as relevant thought patterns are inherent in
human-produced training data. According to ETR, the same fundamental patterns
are involved both in successful and unsuccessful ordinary reasoning, so that
the "bad" cases could paradoxically be learned from the "good" cases. We
further present preliminary evidence that ETR-inspired prompt engineering could
reduce instances of these mistakes. | [
-0.4782557189,
-0.7810831666,
0.890951097,
-0.1973640621,
-0.029118523,
-0.0597464032,
-0.2516510189,
-0.4786987305,
-0.1361860633,
0.1475282609,
-0.2134151161,
-0.2148323208,
-0.4784317315,
0.2148831487,
-0.1478037685,
0.8756822348,
0.0114256022,
0.0906721205,
0.1222554147,
0.0217757951,
-0.5455625057,
-1.0481055975,
-0.8913873434,
-0.7907940149,
0.5243846774,
0.5034710169,
0.6430753469,
0.3862497807,
0.4215030372,
0.2418141514,
-0.0474656671,
-0.014947189,
-0.4817631841,
-0.2422536016,
-0.1969875097,
-0.5924185514,
-0.2249278426,
0.2489535362,
0.3370314837,
0.7445946336,
-0.4921196997,
-0.4765459597,
0.2370758653,
1.0030384064,
-0.0320344344,
-0.1063792855,
-0.4528292716,
0.1308282316,
-0.0616784804,
-0.260628134,
-0.5121982694,
-0.4204968214,
0.2215320319,
-0.6060394645,
0.6390609741,
0.2120771259,
0.8528925776,
0.2260030806,
-0.2430098355,
-0.215461731,
-0.6153986454,
0.8958873153,
-0.4667369127,
0.2946373522,
0.4751497209,
0.2545846105,
-0.5432041883,
-0.660405159,
-0.7142772079,
-0.2932438552,
-0.0360284299,
0.2806616724,
-0.0491185039,
0.2464694828,
0.4922379553,
0.0332570747,
-0.4586841166,
-0.3347995877,
-0.6171732545,
-0.0485359207,
0.5694794059,
0.0600219443,
0.3552745581,
-0.069606863,
-0.3086603582,
-0.0638837889,
-0.9619657993,
-0.0482982434,
0.2692532837,
0.068299979,
0.2187268287,
0.4615483582,
-0.2013583034,
0.6070629954,
-0.0201706849,
0.3467929661,
-0.0834890157,
-0.2158022076,
-0.2197532356,
0.0932605341,
0.5739472508,
0.5859953761,
0.5967744589,
-0.0051928079,
-0.2333222479,
0.4789744616,
0.3776222169,
-0.4723483026,
-0.5724511743,
-0.1206499413,
-0.4718964398,
-0.0380968377,
0.2537032068,
-0.4612942338,
-0.3185682893,
-0.6431062222,
0.2493604571,
-0.6418532729,
-0.1576412767,
0.426119864,
-0.3290288448,
0.4542039931,
0.571470201,
-0.7987644076,
0.4248352051,
0.7947458029,
0.8192352057,
-0.2411511689,
-0.550399363,
-0.2943855226,
-0.0277533066,
-0.4801726341,
0.9381384254,
-0.2706333697,
-0.2414671332,
-0.3063448668,
-0.2572146952,
-0.1627943814,
-0.5125212073,
0.9559907317,
-0.3161773682,
0.2021202892,
-0.5712556243,
-0.544796586,
-0.6457415223,
0.368516326,
-0.4899405837,
0.7391290665,
-0.0774826258,
-0.659193933,
0.6904569864,
-0.9465034604,
-0.4419921339,
0.0139132431,
-0.4744467735,
-0.1026688144,
0.1811021864,
-0.1022669747,
0.3676710427,
-0.6411374807,
0.3988624513,
-0.4218851924,
-0.4465284646,
0.4260132313,
-0.409735322,
0.6960151196,
0.2461313307,
-0.4481777251,
-0.1570280939,
-0.3949741125,
0.0641349852,
0.1961895227,
-0.5684392452,
-0.3364959359,
0.3118645251,
-0.0620327182,
0.2967172265,
-0.4182523191,
-0.4868541658,
-0.039557457,
-0.254643172,
0.8748696446,
0.7329781651,
0.1068970263,
0.110545896,
-0.55509758,
0.1327935457,
0.0253036488,
0.07628043,
0.0841263384,
-0.8480634093,
-0.7701462507,
0.0671905652,
-0.1894181371,
0.4761459231,
-0.4315303266,
0.1634500027,
0.0181425158,
-0.3266767561,
-0.1471042931,
-0.0607868135,
0.3490101099,
0.5509839058,
0.2888239622,
-0.4962078631,
-0.4521167874,
-0.7475744486,
-0.7965345979,
-0.3431298733,
-0.1417759806,
0.1248247325,
0.5660731196,
-0.0340551026,
1.0911961794,
-0.4142966568,
-0.0631297678,
-0.4074433148,
0.3653323352,
0.4833466113,
0.5477781296,
0.134688288,
-0.8437282443,
-0.3069503009,
0.1078804731,
-0.6694803834,
0.1959678382,
-0.0120263202,
-0.081281215,
0.3599252403,
0.2324535102,
-0.7549481392,
0.4493059814,
-0.1237365156,
-0.7439024448,
0.5362112522,
-0.4058778286,
0.1949294209,
-0.9127690792,
-0.1521808803,
0.2445333302,
-0.1099304184,
-0.6484152079,
-0.3037149608,
-0.1655295491,
0.1784735769,
-0.2275100052,
0.2572511733,
-0.3948255181,
0.0482418239,
0.0394072682,
0.1839102656,
-0.1390965879,
0.4474408925,
0.0386860035,
0.5477914214,
0.2577711046,
-0.6015438437,
0.2615708113,
0.0175034348,
-0.1375352144,
0.7934212089,
-0.920606792,
0.4014938176,
-0.2850524187,
0.0350457653,
-0.902833581,
-0.6721268892,
0.3609736562,
-0.5903276205,
0.1941457391,
0.0634476766,
-0.3989751339,
-0.4249657691,
-0.2650581002,
0.1760801375,
0.6180003285,
-0.4885515571,
0.6736278534,
0.2449839264,
-0.243357718,
-0.3230134249,
-0.8253961205,
0.1622481346,
-0.4113975465,
-0.6948076487,
0.051174555,
-0.0696643516,
-0.5684818625,
-0.1404911876,
0.0241967607,
-0.04086712,
-0.1134228185,
0.0885979459,
0.3031992018,
0.0694519803,
0.1808750182,
-0.3216618598,
-0.2155640125,
0.2832498848,
-0.1472016126,
0.2518529594,
-0.4632287323,
-0.6482878923,
-0.2588431537,
0.4209973216,
0.4463892281,
0.342697084,
0.3221875429,
0.0805598348,
-0.3921399117,
0.0693896785,
-0.6931781173,
-0.4595752358,
-0.3545010388,
0.495731771,
-0.3980729282,
-0.7104278207,
0.4132095277,
-0.0156947486,
-0.0650421456,
0.5754026771,
0.3998458087,
-0.2167307585,
1.076918602,
0.5291392207,
0.032508608,
0.2704907954,
-0.1326496303,
0.186898753,
-0.5907551646,
-0.00468178,
-0.3898037076,
-0.2787990272,
-0.5595727563,
-0.3719078898,
0.2712751329,
0.2310274839,
-0.6620231271,
-0.0149146952,
-0.7094836235,
0.7844692469,
0.7686858773,
0.2503643632,
0.5167669654,
0.035716936,
0.025029853,
-0.1366130114,
-0.8508607149,
-0.7681311369,
1.1408759356,
0.3635026515,
0.7215764523,
0.0814703256,
0.6568255424,
0.3683768213,
0.6671400666,
-0.6710622907,
0.4580146968,
0.2227391452,
-0.7319794893,
-0.301741153,
-0.3960193992,
-0.7636486292,
0.193331033,
0.2203965932,
-0.5691886544,
0.325025171,
0.2891772389,
-0.2153885514,
0.2453480363,
-1.0750806332,
0.8300276995,
-0.2323627621,
-0.2716242075,
-0.3984166086,
-0.9061114788,
0.4597354829,
-0.0602227673,
0.0301317815,
0.0844229385,
0.1032155901,
0.9628053904,
-0.2921932042,
0.9899427295,
-0.1151148751,
0.2789303362,
0.5507023931,
-0.1931772679,
0.7650808692,
-0.0944503248,
0.0580006354,
0.106538482,
-0.306163013,
-0.4199205935,
-0.477850467,
0.2714662552,
-0.9257670045,
-0.4194432795,
-0.5692114234,
-0.2244243771,
0.0277585946,
0.0826743543,
0.6487525105,
0.3236681223,
-0.3601362407,
-0.0091607617,
0.6718705893,
0.0317733027,
0.4811127484,
0.3337903321,
0.0357039161,
-0.6599005461,
0.6506668329,
0.0064608338,
0.357968837,
0.0146540618,
0.1406412721,
-0.3928351104,
-0.3653834462,
-0.2300183624,
0.3368538916,
-1.0144274235,
-0.0903760269,
-0.4514561892,
0.0876576453,
0.1219061837,
-0.3496418893,
-0.1299029887,
-0.1838216931,
-0.202104196,
-0.1383841783,
0.3657444119,
1.2203811407,
-0.2040740699,
0.073185198,
-0.5907546282,
0.1560055763,
0.501949966,
0.2646484077,
-0.0089012589,
-0.4960542023,
-0.066962406,
-0.0156587716,
-0.619936645,
-0.8973388672,
0.2057110369,
0.0495219715,
0.4893754125,
0.4515144825,
-0.0383893363,
0.4711298048,
-0.3781330884,
0.5999186635,
0.546841383,
-0.7583494782,
0.3936726153,
-0.5830278397,
-0.1656461656,
0.3853033483,
0.2094327956,
-0.8327378631,
-0.2751429677,
-0.7483686209,
-0.6950055361,
0.8409998417,
0.068245925,
-0.1410658658,
-0.3199799657,
0.39773947,
0.0404999219,
-0.1837336123,
-0.7950773835,
-0.064511396,
-0.2429203838,
0.0641832203,
-0.124119699,
-0.1752540767,
-0.2657481432,
-0.3576240242,
0.5420809388,
-0.1690147221,
0.3971148431,
0.6576856375,
-0.0190781634,
-0.2040462345,
0.6461549997,
0.793155551,
0.8579285741,
-0.1005880237,
0.1823120713,
0.1155036464,
-0.5065771937,
0.3625920415,
0.1423810422,
-0.20334813,
-0.2879223824,
0.218606025,
0.5618447065,
0.0007377974,
-0.4315186143,
0.2256293595,
-0.1262544543,
-0.3920689523,
-0.4363344014,
0.0275791977,
0.0097044483,
0.299139142,
0.6636965871,
0.5128070712,
0.0837869048,
-0.6890194416,
0.1573527753,
0.106495373,
-0.330128938,
-0.5663756132,
0.7056837678,
0.2642967403,
-0.4228715897,
0.7108275294,
-0.3280960023,
-0.7305538058,
0.4716874659,
0.5475434661,
1.0150061846,
-0.0022491545,
0.0108147422,
0.369197458,
0.4612480104,
-0.6971039772,
0.5487132072,
0.1321567893,
-1.0053999424,
-0.8194712996,
-0.2564828098,
-0.5055801272,
-0.1337414533,
-0.3835334778,
0.0907892361,
-0.2848894298,
-0.293322891,
-0.3917616606,
-0.1762751341,
-0.59743011,
0.112773411,
-0.0458811484,
0.7246580124,
-0.8519749045,
0.508140564,
1.0329951048,
-0.5820178986,
-1.0960693359,
0.0204965957,
0.0324926302,
-0.4488531947,
0.7519462705,
0.3387428224,
-0.0977132544,
0.1782610565,
-0.5953574777,
-0.6119440198,
0.8975165486,
0.4210392535,
-0.7194097042,
-0.024811266,
-0.0429306179,
0.3280012906,
-0.2176202983,
0.1754607409,
0.9357556701,
0.6810313463,
0.0993715823,
-0.7867245078,
0.2111357749,
-0.0990389064,
-0.0693935379,
0.4442438185,
-0.4324361384,
0.8675630093,
-0.774509728,
-0.2667885125,
-0.2368020415,
0.4166254103,
0.6385589242,
0.5046449304,
0.3183092475,
0.8405913115,
0.8418884277,
-0.2980221212,
1.2216806412,
0.155160442,
0.4406604171,
0.7559499145,
-0.1401272565,
0.7744355798,
0.6619731784,
-0.6327567697,
0.2339256704,
0.7084115148,
0.3550010026,
0.3520818055,
0.3196466863,
-0.158042416,
-0.3670504689,
0.4116588235,
-0.3645336032,
0.1456240416,
0.2640988827,
-0.3084104359,
-0.0210888404,
-0.2537170947,
-0.0150683858,
0.0069444482,
-0.3009178042,
0.7219789624,
0.3788314462,
-0.8293319345,
0.49580881,
-0.3002998531,
0.6623585224,
-0.0587540492,
-0.2590992153,
-0.1335403472,
0.341929853,
-0.1325176656,
-0.8379933238,
0.2717678249,
-0.1609246433,
-0.346380651,
-0.0811982974,
0.9462716579,
-0.0390483923,
-0.2349986434,
0.1667257994,
0.6538390517,
0.5112957358,
-0.3119695783,
-0.4822956026,
-0.254581511,
0.1325185299,
-0.4791131318,
0.1586544663,
0.7553550005,
-0.0197205916,
0.5774415135,
0.5975352526,
0.2597432137,
-0.0345929898,
0.0884016231,
0.7863910198,
-1.215441227,
-0.5009657145,
-1.0508357286,
0.44107005,
-0.1980494857,
-0.2056826055,
0.3168598115,
0.2876325846,
0.7988139987,
-0.0164929107,
0.9214012027,
-0.2169986963,
0.6887221932,
-0.3230080605,
0.7467142344,
-0.1673857421,
0.098720558,
-0.3917860985,
-0.9966398478,
-0.3383818269,
0.7361570001,
-0.5746841431,
0.3782226741,
0.9068486691,
0.4561941922,
0.1129448116,
0.3370610476,
0.3666196465,
0.2005707622,
0.3859104216,
0.7085834146,
1.2534664869,
-0.1824927479,
0.5827070475,
0.1695143282,
-0.4045844376,
-0.2020099014,
-0.8513313532,
-0.7214107513,
-0.4989407957,
-0.0951610431,
-0.1782472134,
0.1455059797,
0.8756223321,
0.4412882328,
-0.5429666638,
-0.0884316638,
-0.8395140171,
0.111972481,
-0.251175046,
-0.2580363154,
0.1887198836,
-0.3838693798,
-0.2891840041,
0.1013581082,
0.2920515537,
0.1548924595,
0.1534575671,
-0.5074077249,
0.1168260723,
-0.0980125666,
0.6833475232,
0.3952116966,
-0.9618914723,
-0.4810328186,
-0.1592567414,
0.0169436838,
0.2206261158,
0.9253939986,
-0.7653909922,
0.2423619479,
0.4014702439,
0.3411290646,
0.0922190249,
0.0532276928,
0.837608397,
-0.2031795233,
-0.1766569763,
0.3060308397,
0.5527137518,
0.5177752972,
-0.1260912865,
0.8855186105,
0.5677523017,
-1.0139123201,
-0.6744346023,
0.3204384148,
-0.5899662375,
0.0003994937,
0.8251793385,
0.0608679652,
-0.1133597344,
-0.5633741617,
-0.4273698628,
0.2710956037,
-0.6903026104,
1.0729016066,
0.9381149411,
-0.5913929939,
-0.0962764174,
-0.8108810782,
0.5386894345,
0.5579081178,
-0.9044477344,
0.2983199954,
0.6758439541,
0.19062756,
0.2551010251,
0.8038425446,
-0.0013891436,
0.5837512612,
-0.090033628,
0.2235769182,
0.2746498287,
-0.1347742081,
-0.2289142609,
0.014988563,
0.4522792697,
0.0503722616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17183v1 | The Nordic Pile: A 1.2TB Nordic Dataset for Language Modeling | 2023-03-30T06:42:22 | 2023-03-30T06:42:22 | Joey Öhman, Severine Verlinden, Ariel Ekgren, Amaru Cuba Gyllensten, Tim Isbister, Evangelia Gogoulou, Fredrik Carlsson, Magnus Sahlgren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-training Large Language Models (LLMs) require massive amounts of text
data, and the performance of the LLMs typically correlates with the scale and
quality of the datasets. This means that it may be challenging to build LLMs
for smaller languages such as Nordic ones, where the availability of text
corpora is limited. In order to facilitate the development of the LLMS in the
Nordic languages, we curate a high-quality dataset consisting of 1.2TB of text,
in all of the major North Germanic languages (Danish, Icelandic, Norwegian, and
Swedish), as well as some high-quality English data. This paper details our
considerations and processes for collecting, cleaning, and filtering the
dataset. | [
-0.6242150664,
-0.323944509,
0.236055389,
0.0347519442,
-0.6498924494,
0.0395501591,
-0.0197393391,
-0.5080488324,
0.2050946653,
1.0848662853,
-0.2263018489,
-0.664162159,
-0.5723154545,
0.2954567075,
-0.6803879142,
1.0762765408,
-0.0592839718,
0.0085029891,
-0.2678790092,
-0.0923247933,
-0.4066339433,
-0.5944376588,
-0.5013407469,
-0.3092047572,
0.4830849469,
0.557420671,
0.7386754751,
0.8819107413,
0.4542765915,
0.1974009871,
-0.2854241431,
-0.0246132035,
-0.996571064,
0.3054437637,
-0.2093655914,
-0.4630782008,
-0.3874546587,
0.0608089417,
0.7658976316,
0.4889554679,
-0.1271205992,
0.3238294721,
-0.1415042579,
0.5876758099,
-0.2133966833,
-0.1706362218,
-0.4942416847,
0.0607586019,
-0.6050541997,
0.005815546,
-0.2860206962,
-0.2675245106,
-0.1279721111,
-0.576666832,
0.3585402071,
0.4313033819,
0.7986787558,
0.2097928673,
-0.4077909589,
-0.3133751452,
-0.5613588691,
0.9524265528,
-0.5818530917,
0.5018734336,
0.860819757,
0.0132054165,
-0.2376783192,
-0.4366802275,
-0.1971674711,
0.1692493856,
-0.3303830624,
-0.1670398712,
0.3250532448,
-0.2923864126,
-0.1302668452,
0.5694851279,
-0.8657271266,
0.6454126835,
-0.7066257596,
0.1021972373,
0.9094932675,
0.2714141011,
0.0236161146,
-0.2270798981,
-0.1813278943,
-0.2231718004,
-1.0457235575,
-0.3275684416,
0.6028370857,
0.5237748623,
-0.0690394416,
0.6957470775,
-0.0057980916,
0.6338503957,
-0.3576106131,
-0.1051473767,
0.1233604029,
-0.4593558908,
-0.1012737006,
-0.0547851846,
0.4503697753,
0.0111601725,
0.0865349993,
-0.1057707965,
-0.6243499517,
-0.1692100614,
0.3058886826,
-0.5985363126,
-0.3439054787,
0.5986886621,
-0.5566832423,
-0.2069824636,
-0.1856449395,
-0.6064614654,
-0.3615828753,
-0.6199846864,
-0.0167633966,
-0.1002029404,
-0.6842985749,
0.3404807448,
-0.080518879,
0.1025674194,
0.2204045206,
-0.6452710629,
0.25712201,
0.8260774016,
0.4893966913,
-0.4163814783,
-0.0364876352,
-0.4227746725,
-0.0190340057,
-0.63537395,
0.8834405541,
-0.4122472405,
-0.4505899847,
0.2175973654,
0.0643749461,
0.3018336892,
-0.6691647172,
0.6378475428,
-0.743778348,
0.4319362938,
-0.0597486831,
-0.7090349197,
-0.0400104746,
0.1765505224,
-0.9776463509,
1.3167629242,
0.3414331377,
-0.736887753,
0.2303912491,
-0.3628292084,
-0.4387099147,
0.5691897273,
-0.0555265732,
-0.0464913659,
0.3096240163,
-0.0299480297,
0.7650620341,
-0.5728039742,
0.5188506246,
0.0486190021,
-0.3343063295,
-0.2622451186,
0.0429097861,
0.8674886823,
0.5088349581,
0.1837093085,
-0.2936981022,
-0.8072348237,
-0.2162679732,
-0.0626361221,
-0.6406092644,
-0.5280060172,
0.0894861147,
0.4138740897,
0.374783963,
0.3755667508,
-0.4397071302,
0.057478372,
-0.2031156272,
0.0035531593,
0.7169514894,
-0.3518354297,
0.3166412413,
-0.377592057,
0.7229197621,
0.018279219,
-0.0409136266,
-0.0657224804,
-0.3167832792,
-0.5167537332,
-0.4719944894,
0.5830671787,
0.4891326427,
-0.9292022586,
0.4815778434,
-0.4640482366,
-0.5681027174,
-0.6355243325,
0.3939588666,
0.2874749601,
-0.1673920155,
-0.0411818735,
0.0072043026,
-0.6125753522,
-0.8248867393,
0.2309525311,
-0.1494283378,
-0.3285462558,
0.1520040333,
0.5242362618,
0.0375509933,
1.0342671871,
-0.2685911059,
-0.2561786175,
-0.2718360424,
0.0753812194,
0.6701715589,
0.5343288183,
0.4696434736,
-0.9429715276,
-0.4186348319,
0.060563311,
-0.6471374631,
-0.117028445,
0.2781150639,
-0.1951047182,
0.2855820656,
0.8401866555,
-0.5015005469,
0.1341060996,
1.0544042587,
-0.5053712726,
0.7044072151,
-0.1142378673,
-0.1049374193,
-1.1928441525,
0.2510245144,
-0.2131597549,
-0.3828120828,
-0.6259046793,
-0.0375609696,
-0.3287120163,
0.0390106291,
-0.8606351614,
1.0148478746,
-0.5641409755,
-0.1773750633,
-0.0947172567,
0.1915888339,
-0.0205995031,
0.2194790244,
0.1099455357,
0.5473046899,
0.3466767073,
-0.8201702237,
0.2443902045,
0.5853296518,
-0.6045976281,
0.7270359993,
-0.4490511417,
-0.0015708915,
-0.4585920274,
0.068016924,
-0.8204107285,
-0.109497644,
-0.2578729093,
-0.1733095497,
0.4715711772,
-0.235490635,
-0.9717355967,
-0.3052490652,
-0.0881140083,
0.2822170258,
0.4970667362,
-0.6700783372,
0.4745907485,
0.7691646814,
-0.6713347435,
-0.4064683616,
-0.2648612559,
0.1289470196,
-0.2407416403,
-0.4109156132,
-0.1683891267,
0.0677287877,
-0.3973772526,
0.1069186106,
0.1183167845,
-0.0749500543,
0.1264893711,
0.1022709459,
0.0622981302,
-0.138596639,
0.433607012,
-0.2027564198,
-0.0564831086,
-0.1139238104,
-0.167170614,
0.7272211313,
0.2520372868,
0.0104016,
0.0023140507,
0.5046920776,
0.5659822226,
0.0447451249,
0.6652943492,
0.2179614753,
-0.3537422121,
-0.2096306384,
-0.5273361802,
-0.1136091202,
-0.4504140615,
0.3872867525,
-0.422421813,
-1.0565814972,
0.4219937921,
0.2721815407,
0.687297821,
0.5429622531,
0.4204076827,
-0.4577795565,
0.8135254383,
0.7273124456,
-0.2195459306,
0.2544235587,
-0.1501623988,
0.0325907134,
-0.6608365178,
-0.0253726281,
-1.0284340382,
-0.3789665997,
-0.5926077962,
-0.5482128263,
0.0160434395,
0.0263117235,
-0.3768320978,
0.3370859027,
-0.3364347219,
0.5878647566,
0.5087526441,
-0.313039273,
0.3939813375,
0.2974177003,
-0.1180247143,
0.1834828407,
-0.9643099904,
-0.861856401,
0.9153010249,
0.4775983691,
0.7730097175,
-0.059634123,
0.4800245166,
0.1181022152,
0.40704602,
-0.4114794731,
0.5515753627,
-0.9512888193,
-1.1690045595,
-0.6184090376,
-0.4261092544,
-1.2548599243,
0.4483605027,
-0.1816753447,
-0.3070456684,
0.0322511196,
0.0855635554,
0.1025214642,
0.446800977,
-0.2755239606,
0.5353752375,
-0.2120798975,
0.0665791705,
-0.2184119523,
-0.4787664413,
0.2977343798,
-0.4676792026,
0.5120277405,
-0.3617548645,
0.0681410953,
1.0631017685,
-0.2406536788,
0.7694966197,
-0.0728604123,
-0.5391454697,
0.1862810254,
0.3877415955,
0.4913805127,
-0.1967356503,
-0.2067544162,
0.4260264039,
0.1711619943,
-0.4866966307,
0.0612934306,
0.4113667309,
-0.6317317486,
-0.3060441613,
-0.2876597047,
-0.5149124265,
-0.0767763928,
0.2481673062,
0.2255923599,
0.3982575536,
-0.3709618449,
0.5856633782,
0.7836231589,
-0.4504158199,
0.2626697421,
0.5308525562,
-0.5168280005,
-0.2737626731,
0.7797920108,
0.1561641991,
0.0744304657,
0.3529359996,
0.0220357515,
-0.4276431799,
-0.8385875821,
-0.176319629,
0.5793072581,
-0.5507888794,
-0.3345632851,
-0.8077344894,
-0.0188797545,
-0.2541526854,
-0.0725049153,
-0.5049304962,
-0.4502978325,
-0.4628119469,
-0.1623925865,
0.5854768157,
1.0860717297,
0.0779239684,
0.7111966014,
-1.107278347,
0.381506592,
-0.1244142577,
0.7098401189,
-0.3921984732,
-0.5572240949,
-0.5161385536,
0.0661463588,
0.3367514312,
-0.093329072,
0.6261298656,
-0.107445702,
0.5214931369,
0.2090332061,
-0.0186353475,
0.1482075751,
-0.4847373366,
0.9117776752,
-0.0473665148,
-0.3343791068,
0.1291649491,
-0.5276350379,
0.408647269,
0.6456225514,
0.5661645532,
-0.579038322,
-0.5771597624,
-0.7100858688,
-0.8444153666,
0.9146649241,
0.0564582609,
0.068728812,
0.0709522143,
0.1933116317,
0.4168164432,
0.4385746121,
-0.238312453,
0.0231744796,
0.2238932103,
-0.3250339031,
-0.7235742807,
-0.4626891613,
-0.1368041337,
0.0453743562,
0.9233643413,
0.0338749364,
-0.147908017,
-0.4744646549,
-0.2132743597,
0.0464449972,
0.0125438292,
0.3213061988,
0.57361269,
-0.1723607183,
0.138391763,
0.0175746232,
-0.7803109288,
0.2090450227,
-0.2360169142,
-0.0450114943,
0.225992173,
0.2883563936,
0.6620594859,
0.0674298331,
-0.7918646336,
0.137959376,
-0.105970487,
-0.3620840609,
-0.2392479926,
-0.3068825305,
0.3438940644,
-0.2071574032,
0.293035984,
-0.6395635605,
-0.2526562214,
-0.1296313852,
0.3412898183,
0.1210526675,
-0.0129303588,
-0.1850742251,
0.1997447163,
0.2048745453,
-0.1212192923,
1.2505563498,
0.1076147333,
-0.436799556,
0.4618813097,
0.2940783501,
0.4291655123,
-0.2990730703,
0.3588635921,
0.3821510375,
0.4376721382,
-0.4497349858,
0.4656691849,
0.4122454226,
-0.7859277129,
-0.6666650772,
-1.1447041035,
-0.3398308158,
0.1974041909,
-0.4462895989,
0.426417321,
-0.2038599104,
0.0219111964,
-0.3038511574,
0.1155394837,
-0.8939116001,
0.4384687841,
0.0472622365,
1.1495711803,
-1.2017626762,
0.5747198462,
0.5859304667,
0.2370146364,
-0.4740123749,
-0.7969970703,
-0.128527537,
-0.6913422942,
0.8097788095,
-0.1899344325,
0.2521080971,
0.015577645,
-0.6934934258,
-1.1440044641,
0.5214984417,
0.1064726338,
-0.6453080773,
-0.0111784413,
0.2634553611,
0.7046025991,
-0.2607999742,
-0.1813743114,
0.7201140523,
0.4693506062,
0.2052835673,
-0.8408629894,
-0.26054582,
-0.3350809813,
-0.0060342527,
0.4511980414,
-0.2896577418,
0.9416511059,
0.557926476,
-0.3536316156,
-0.0628933609,
0.4473274052,
0.4198690951,
-0.2313450575,
0.5731037855,
0.7991681099,
0.7463684082,
-0.1447198838,
1.2485218048,
-0.1068307534,
-0.0021445579,
1.2450742722,
-0.4817293882,
1.0266999006,
0.5457966924,
-0.1084572077,
-0.0049648201,
0.9350289702,
0.0090357438,
0.305752188,
0.43016693,
-0.0207074378,
-0.2164436877,
-0.2888435423,
-0.0690979883,
0.3972574472,
0.6025587916,
0.0666922256,
-0.3679510057,
0.0531870686,
0.017621398,
-0.1913583428,
-0.2322332412,
0.8518656492,
0.0460676588,
-0.6787198186,
0.6744008064,
-0.3556639552,
0.5561673045,
-0.2650955915,
0.0249456652,
-0.3361484706,
-0.0530113019,
-0.1265481561,
-0.9699555635,
0.3622613251,
0.0256681759,
-0.1755015552,
-0.6472238302,
0.3387719989,
-0.591293335,
-0.5504592061,
0.0813638642,
0.6087911725,
0.8606881499,
0.1740089208,
-0.2979012132,
0.2313332856,
-0.2951583266,
-0.5390892625,
0.4133444726,
0.4689675868,
-0.2132932395,
0.5333869457,
0.8324429393,
0.4304661453,
0.0876144096,
-0.0094554964,
0.7165623903,
-0.4404998124,
-0.5231747031,
-0.3165750206,
0.7093291879,
0.0004797938,
-0.3258858323,
0.46560359,
0.8272007108,
0.9106692076,
-0.0617177822,
0.682190299,
-0.1907750517,
0.9835986495,
-0.5027464032,
0.654042542,
-0.4971915483,
0.0831519216,
0.2053260058,
-1.134577632,
-0.3833711445,
0.5051293373,
0.1782429516,
-0.2051784694,
0.5243200064,
0.7190640569,
0.0782549828,
0.0970342457,
0.510124445,
0.4983743429,
0.361074239,
0.125805378,
0.6793507338,
-0.2061518133,
0.2883961201,
0.1031753868,
-0.0159064289,
-0.1094020009,
-1.1219270229,
-0.9132880569,
-0.6556514502,
-0.1525254548,
-0.24647668,
-0.1639143825,
0.7795060277,
0.8196080327,
-0.9292845726,
-0.6512639523,
0.2483355105,
0.1093831062,
-0.033119034,
-0.1046525091,
0.4073292315,
-0.3067856729,
-0.675109148,
0.3912469447,
-0.0731645226,
0.2480996251,
-0.4344929159,
-0.0691266209,
-0.4909911156,
-0.1452184469,
0.6506106257,
0.0524394773,
-0.2441662103,
-0.0734088421,
-0.0590292662,
-0.3247840106,
0.0486845821,
0.6640481353,
-0.5289955139,
0.2435839325,
0.7521309257,
0.5294665694,
0.7386282086,
-0.0459984802,
0.8553451896,
-0.9629950523,
0.1809003502,
0.5091628432,
0.2583065033,
0.5238006115,
-0.3735825121,
0.7114432454,
-0.3687918782,
-0.5904288292,
-1.1136710644,
-0.1297754049,
-0.5366440415,
-0.4223101437,
1.1655070782,
0.0852982104,
-0.1430102885,
-0.5784014463,
-0.2351499051,
-0.0769838244,
0.0074826255,
0.3987262249,
1.1981672049,
0.3056702316,
-0.1493764967,
-0.916854322,
0.6593422294,
0.1307554543,
-0.786970675,
0.372557193,
0.5775713921,
0.2092125714,
0.1236243099,
0.634077251,
-0.2801893651,
-0.1141954288,
-0.1039904952,
0.3023626506,
0.209162131,
-0.6846246123,
-0.503482759,
0.2019040436,
-0.0791911855,
0.2170567364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03287v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03287v1 | Synthesis of Mathematical programs from Natural Language Specifications | 2023-03-30T06:10:00 | 2023-03-30T06:10:00 | Ganesh Prasath, Shirish Karande | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Several decision problems that are encountered in various business domains
can be modeled as mathematical programs, i.e. optimization problems. The
process of conducting such modeling often requires the involvement of experts
trained in operations research and advanced algorithms. Surprisingly, despite
the significant advances in the methods for program and code synthesis, AutoML,
learning to optimize etc., there has been little or no attention paid to
automating the task of synthesizing mathematical programs. We imagine a
scenario where the specifications for modeling, i.e. the objective and
constraints are expressed in an unstructured form in natural language (NL) and
the mathematical program has to be synthesized from such an NL specification.
In this work we evaluate the efficacy of employing CodeT5 with data
augmentation and post-processing of beams. We utilize GPT-3 with back
translation for generation of synthetic examples. Further we apply rules of
linear programming to score beams and correct beams based on common error
patterns. We observe that with these enhancements CodeT5 base gives an
execution accuracy of 0.73 which is significantly better than zero-shot
execution accuracy of 0.41 by ChatGPT and 0.36 by Codex. | [
-0.4058482647,
-0.8722552657,
0.4845618904,
0.608612299,
0.0690001622,
0.2730405927,
-0.1120428219,
-0.5561807752,
-0.1750308573,
0.476844728,
-0.5066494346,
-0.7271975279,
0.0032042623,
0.2816395462,
-0.2420540005,
1.0207372904,
-0.5692237616,
0.0458433069,
0.0333869494,
0.1893261969,
-0.7332757711,
-0.4206709862,
-0.2918315232,
-0.4152775705,
-0.4272304177,
-0.0265326723,
0.6654340625,
0.515730083,
0.6401512623,
0.3903439939,
0.3832816482,
0.2719124258,
-0.3810211122,
-0.2114062756,
-0.2009806037,
-0.1579190195,
-0.5576002598,
-0.0052411077,
0.481429249,
0.8358768225,
-0.1367405653,
0.0004557435,
0.0699832812,
0.7827395201,
-0.4703216553,
0.5748249888,
-0.5902683139,
0.2184709311,
0.3769345284,
-0.412517339,
-0.2942822278,
-0.7512460947,
0.133710444,
-0.597880125,
0.5808657408,
-0.0526116528,
0.7250763774,
0.3305478394,
0.0243786648,
-0.6077821851,
-0.8640376925,
0.915158093,
-0.8528160453,
0.0469777137,
0.1325122863,
0.3876843452,
-0.4265456498,
-0.6336733103,
-0.0887692496,
-0.1627929211,
-0.2575108111,
0.1283894926,
-0.2878338099,
0.619161725,
0.5082243681,
0.2069937289,
-0.7304337025,
-0.4116617441,
-0.7214264274,
-0.2649415731,
0.9115980864,
0.3868425488,
0.1590320766,
-0.2983142734,
-0.1893719137,
0.0415323339,
-0.4917123318,
-0.1898258626,
0.3640026748,
0.1719279587,
0.1051019281,
0.746665895,
-0.4765345752,
0.7625104189,
-0.142093882,
0.1342432946,
0.2233354449,
-0.5883376002,
-0.7012012005,
0.0033408031,
0.5727074146,
0.3953728974,
0.3180699348,
-0.0438532718,
-0.4404566884,
0.4043457508,
0.40727368,
-0.6028661132,
-0.5049098134,
0.0912441537,
-0.2932355702,
-0.3929512203,
-0.1169966608,
-0.4790361524,
0.2937228382,
-0.6564198136,
0.5128170252,
-0.6589303017,
0.3572333157,
0.4579662979,
0.1537827998,
0.1306361407,
0.1891059875,
-0.7282888293,
0.3192934692,
0.5592207313,
0.6555020809,
0.1290287822,
0.0913016871,
-0.2640083432,
0.2056637257,
-0.6587534547,
0.454143852,
-0.510214448,
-0.6340677738,
-0.2333108187,
-0.5930588245,
-0.0458527468,
-0.5894344449,
0.6165312529,
-0.3357197344,
0.3118745089,
0.3323054016,
-0.6358707547,
-0.3367203474,
0.026045166,
-0.34923473,
0.9697131515,
0.4455120265,
-0.158314392,
0.175811559,
-1.1166952848,
-0.6004903316,
-0.0570238233,
-0.1953600198,
-0.4937310219,
0.4195000529,
0.481123507,
0.0880290419,
-0.2258862853,
0.3576028645,
-0.2001156956,
-0.1663580388,
0.1942061037,
-0.3957999945,
0.6059190631,
0.3852235675,
-0.3664388061,
0.0887720063,
-0.9148350954,
0.5680122972,
-0.1905783415,
-0.4011972547,
0.1098575741,
-0.0295288544,
-0.191423893,
0.0672850311,
0.2650286257,
-0.2528900504,
0.2602948546,
-0.9505618811,
0.3123472333,
0.5498546362,
0.1609253287,
0.3138094544,
-0.0934273079,
0.7188348174,
-0.5779351592,
0.267698437,
0.0382689908,
-0.4918230474,
-0.5337514877,
0.0385706052,
0.0460946299,
0.4576915205,
-0.8183251619,
0.3348728716,
-0.0601331182,
-0.3549320996,
-0.2091270834,
0.1269387901,
0.6334626079,
0.3681637049,
0.3902598321,
-0.0529646426,
-1.1810786724,
-0.9531180859,
-0.3243791461,
0.0191950165,
-0.150451988,
0.1305479556,
0.3855155706,
-0.057469666,
1.1585123539,
-0.9653329253,
-0.3050145507,
-0.2558215559,
0.362233758,
0.7488692403,
0.5833294392,
0.63761729,
-0.4784619212,
-0.6878129244,
-0.0192822292,
-0.8172146082,
-0.3460818231,
-0.157651484,
-0.0898669288,
0.334427774,
0.2963014245,
-0.4775706828,
0.7074275017,
0.3806799352,
0.1154857203,
0.6893656254,
-0.490341723,
0.0654044226,
-0.8957893252,
0.2743018568,
-0.1394396424,
-0.0123344399,
-0.6573944092,
0.1498365849,
-0.257766664,
-0.4263400137,
-0.1952610463,
-0.0453022085,
-0.5133544207,
-0.3989525139,
-0.1338758767,
-0.2174316794,
0.162910521,
0.6064209342,
0.0028679208,
0.8575882316,
0.4631803036,
-0.711402595,
0.5447315574,
0.1905804425,
-0.3572225273,
0.3075443208,
-0.9801511168,
0.1486470252,
0.0578797609,
-0.035401132,
-0.7285138965,
-0.2402466983,
0.2234192789,
-0.5194525123,
0.10348171,
-0.2086866796,
-0.330630362,
-0.4068769217,
-0.3084900975,
0.1801709384,
0.6059821844,
-0.0264158715,
0.5121542811,
0.1041967571,
0.0329039618,
-0.1307048351,
-0.5696790814,
0.0614050217,
0.1369909495,
-0.6522517204,
0.634988904,
-0.318862319,
-0.1283889413,
0.0261049904,
-0.049176354,
-0.1099826545,
-0.1310955286,
-0.0598564222,
0.586173594,
-0.249843657,
-0.3423039615,
0.0097710798,
-0.393375963,
0.108393386,
-0.5192587972,
0.4047943652,
-0.2163499892,
-0.4926220775,
-0.2228182703,
0.2733680904,
0.2889981568,
-0.1518905312,
0.1956774294,
0.3137672544,
-0.5064911842,
-0.2573037446,
-0.2217727304,
-0.0434898697,
-0.5444394946,
0.3057027757,
-0.5981673598,
-0.2977200747,
0.1274969727,
0.1828698516,
0.2123238891,
0.1990064085,
0.5866090059,
0.1470877379,
1.4734992981,
0.3074190915,
0.2557480931,
0.2607986033,
-0.3675976992,
0.5525512099,
-0.5369852185,
0.0035170563,
-0.498334229,
-0.3887488246,
-0.453696847,
-0.4027745128,
0.8329726458,
0.0259566065,
0.1822594404,
0.6776970625,
-0.7503821254,
0.6840206385,
0.4258076251,
-0.1325120628,
0.23030141,
0.2716150582,
-0.2789046764,
-0.327808708,
-0.5818673968,
-0.3767733574,
1.1397739649,
-0.04259561,
0.8410258889,
-0.0224524196,
0.7936659455,
0.1959759891,
0.3044153452,
-0.6023238897,
0.4016864002,
-0.0508052669,
-0.5956863165,
-0.0394319519,
-0.6510829329,
-0.7375836968,
-0.0491946936,
0.0143774692,
-0.5220013261,
-0.2234557867,
0.2426574826,
-0.4831883907,
-0.1690692306,
-0.9786208272,
0.8510327935,
-0.2665916979,
-0.2930288613,
-0.3659615517,
-0.4176205695,
0.2793423831,
-0.0156514496,
0.279863894,
0.0014030166,
0.3682544827,
0.3038201928,
-0.5319027305,
0.5146679878,
-0.1234429777,
-0.1791126132,
0.4502797127,
0.2805918753,
0.4317518473,
-0.0686892942,
-0.2346067876,
-0.2087840289,
0.0690588579,
-0.3145407438,
-0.861782968,
0.52535671,
-0.5000295043,
-0.4653273821,
-0.0827750638,
-0.7297255993,
-0.3965159953,
0.2473142743,
0.0233227704,
0.7080213428,
-0.1408084035,
0.1004351825,
0.1078025997,
-0.3596880734,
0.5473201871,
0.3813991249,
-0.3681077957,
-0.5778110027,
0.8778506517,
-0.0436457284,
0.2758112252,
0.5269869566,
-0.0007592921,
-0.5149402022,
-0.8286845088,
-0.2298104912,
0.04484424,
-0.6472966075,
-0.4204209447,
-0.0289746467,
-0.2761073709,
-0.6167141199,
-0.5643995404,
-0.3848161101,
-0.3918868303,
-0.0616614521,
-0.059698157,
0.0458817519,
0.8729076982,
-0.1908226609,
-0.0814007446,
-1.0151633024,
0.3302010894,
-0.0731883571,
0.5764939189,
-0.4073358178,
0.0135667613,
-0.3893022537,
0.3314931393,
-0.4042611718,
-0.5693615675,
0.730220139,
0.1359188706,
0.5243116617,
-0.0477464274,
0.0677914768,
0.8120555878,
-0.3209528327,
0.3023921847,
0.1020088419,
-1.197830081,
0.7157386541,
-0.3112734556,
0.1561410278,
0.2929064929,
-0.0116313836,
0.0693088397,
-0.3341599107,
-0.6528992653,
-0.5635215044,
0.9682007432,
0.7398658395,
0.0310080014,
0.2079514265,
0.2240020633,
-0.0900617838,
0.402394712,
-0.4468100667,
-0.0722473115,
-0.1755590141,
-0.448058784,
0.1578108221,
0.0686972216,
0.1406247914,
-0.2778285742,
0.6975366473,
-0.1907264441,
0.2667338848,
0.1887599379,
-0.0100172833,
0.0679614544,
-0.0382507853,
0.7330883741,
1.013274312,
-0.3580355346,
-0.1350893378,
0.0815842226,
-0.334228307,
-0.1173819005,
0.1875884384,
-0.3049007654,
0.2954774797,
0.2408145368,
0.6062843204,
0.223749876,
-0.718834579,
-0.0892826989,
0.2019833177,
-0.3274275064,
-0.2016411275,
0.198339954,
-0.2003485113,
0.0774898455,
0.2201671153,
0.235856548,
0.3716076314,
-0.3025523126,
0.3106304705,
0.3213524222,
0.0197953563,
-0.3204176724,
0.6305468678,
0.1552369148,
-0.146915406,
0.3888502717,
-0.3200735152,
-0.5894244909,
0.5198814869,
0.6096022725,
0.7344917655,
-0.0285936091,
0.1952213496,
0.4922313094,
0.2286606878,
0.3679252863,
0.4167770147,
0.0171610992,
-0.6868178248,
-0.7124804854,
-0.8626494408,
-0.2946498394,
-0.2721377015,
-0.4313707948,
0.4261553884,
-0.7237375975,
-0.0056473371,
0.0131960204,
0.0998426974,
-0.585755825,
0.2220444232,
-0.1239389181,
0.2874463499,
-0.4191986024,
0.6700518727,
0.6816469431,
-0.5438837409,
-1.0341089964,
-0.5617520809,
-0.166112408,
-0.8551381826,
0.6425333023,
-0.1573467106,
-0.0529593378,
0.4002313912,
-0.3551902175,
-0.6933037043,
0.7115750909,
0.4790374637,
-0.1663054526,
-0.1697997302,
0.5494742393,
0.6779018044,
-0.2634484768,
0.221375823,
0.566607058,
0.4777577221,
0.345241636,
-0.9932605028,
-0.0438139662,
-0.236006856,
0.3845371306,
0.3786423802,
0.0702756047,
0.7656422257,
-0.1723395884,
-0.2185173333,
0.0483558364,
0.5147101283,
0.2997137308,
0.1646568924,
-0.1066971347,
0.3733842075,
0.2911072969,
-0.0577725694,
1.0552350283,
-0.3734447062,
0.6954498291,
0.8029603362,
-0.3424357176,
0.3785841167,
0.3634400368,
-0.774058342,
0.1868538857,
0.281468451,
-0.3471688926,
0.3883347809,
0.1908711493,
-0.1381774098,
0.1449696124,
0.1503102481,
-0.3378173709,
0.4122625291,
0.5904925466,
-0.3391396999,
-0.5742275715,
-0.3644711077,
-0.0104916003,
0.1294822544,
-0.059446644,
0.6384830475,
0.0387557968,
-0.8649485111,
0.9505573511,
0.5795136094,
0.2519077063,
-0.5004869103,
-0.2493187189,
-0.1262361258,
0.4716919065,
-0.3974896967,
-0.646851778,
0.8728929162,
-0.0339702815,
-0.0161190685,
-0.4788196087,
0.5256980062,
-0.321644485,
-0.7446314692,
-0.2588468492,
0.1971961409,
0.1339601427,
-0.0932152122,
-0.798433125,
-0.0111270519,
0.4131579101,
0.1834644824,
-0.1555185914,
0.1990737468,
0.1109233797,
0.5343350768,
0.9809514284,
0.1252185851,
0.1144719273,
0.0900752991,
0.6969879866,
-0.4478503466,
-0.4180718958,
-0.9725288153,
0.2473765463,
-0.0415836982,
-0.1623685658,
0.7243663669,
0.8086723685,
0.8137164116,
-0.3918581903,
0.9115242958,
-0.2106427997,
0.300006479,
-1.0345134735,
0.2761670649,
-0.1016258672,
0.5009965897,
-0.5259072781,
-1.2351276875,
-0.5614449382,
0.8014528751,
-0.4593111575,
0.0734192654,
0.7535347342,
0.9365519881,
-0.0170021635,
0.0389150567,
0.2622630298,
0.0677929744,
0.7119790316,
1.0075310469,
0.4565805793,
-0.4387162328,
0.7404873371,
-0.2499137372,
0.0331200324,
-0.3369303942,
-0.7725309134,
-0.6766754389,
-0.1333414614,
-0.3520732522,
-0.2513656318,
-0.1006816998,
1.1036684513,
0.4624673426,
-0.9250136614,
-0.426183641,
-0.6645878553,
0.0176619906,
-0.0658862889,
-0.2945044935,
0.3745789826,
-0.6647952795,
-0.9244500995,
0.4852894545,
0.5250832438,
0.2147236913,
-0.2426871657,
-0.157959044,
0.0413823687,
0.0009853735,
0.526787281,
0.1046323106,
-0.4261949956,
-0.3383753002,
0.2177658528,
0.0197085794,
0.1370719671,
0.8988249302,
-0.8106033206,
0.5465323329,
0.592861712,
0.5975544453,
0.4745383263,
0.2090967447,
1.2120950222,
-0.899756372,
-0.0514902361,
0.3131690919,
0.3442784548,
0.2828475535,
-0.0066551687,
0.737236321,
0.4636135399,
-0.1891983598,
-0.6103928089,
0.3457327783,
-0.515422225,
-0.0472240075,
0.7789283395,
0.1469579637,
-0.0872191787,
-0.2250956446,
-0.6254974604,
0.2199860364,
-0.2275592983,
0.8100271225,
0.5696442723,
-0.551546514,
0.3402757347,
-0.6650132537,
0.6034655571,
0.4822369516,
-0.9488271475,
-0.2752317786,
0.7718268037,
-0.0246266592,
0.1577930301,
0.3902288377,
-0.2685653567,
0.2016409487,
0.0259643383,
0.0331810229,
-0.1979856789,
0.1167325601,
0.0882897303,
0.2757556736,
-0.0534608737,
-0.1787246168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17161v1 | TreePiece: Faster Semantic Parsing via Tree Tokenization | 2023-03-30T05:44:44 | 2023-03-30T05:44:44 | Sid Wang, Akshat Shrivastava, Sasha Livshits | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Autoregressive (AR) encoder-decoder neural networks have proved successful in
many NLP problems, including Semantic Parsing -- a task that translates natural
language to machine-readable parse trees. However, the sequential prediction
process of AR models can be slow. To accelerate AR for semantic parsing, we
introduce a new technique called TreePiece that tokenizes a parse tree into
subtrees and generates one subtree per decoding step. On TopV2 benchmark,
TreePiece shows 4.6 times faster decoding speed than standard AR, and
comparable speed but significantly higher accuracy compared to
Non-Autoregressive (NAR). | [
-0.0930263177,
-0.8896189928,
0.0785807967,
0.1540808976,
-0.668281734,
0.0535784066,
0.1883891076,
-0.7508965135,
0.2143944651,
0.3899068534,
-0.3756922185,
-0.3079301417,
-0.8534938097,
0.1947487295,
-0.8343709111,
0.6005870104,
0.2434567511,
-0.0382338911,
-0.0696102902,
-0.0405635722,
-0.3842289746,
-0.4089407623,
-1.0300643444,
-0.3047353625,
0.4603112042,
0.134422943,
0.7990620136,
1.3933310509,
0.7575169206,
0.4015183747,
-0.2866686583,
-0.1592299938,
0.2234493643,
0.4697686434,
-0.1472132057,
-0.307723254,
-0.5147174597,
-0.3609703779,
0.5998194814,
0.685798347,
0.0283052661,
0.2566508949,
-0.004597825,
0.6657575965,
-0.6307917833,
0.3069161475,
-0.7701978087,
0.3795651793,
-0.3906081021,
-0.4113663137,
-0.3995443881,
-0.2362969518,
0.046859026,
-0.5046547055,
0.2622452676,
0.0728154853,
0.7704083323,
0.6107015014,
-0.3273272812,
-0.0982486382,
-0.5352491736,
0.4992872775,
-0.6246794462,
0.520590961,
0.3734676242,
0.3779337704,
-0.0421921387,
-1.2033987045,
-0.3108842075,
0.2335900664,
-0.2277861983,
-0.1146535426,
-0.3531032503,
0.1379640549,
0.1635558009,
0.4085505903,
-0.5851726532,
-0.0349296294,
0.2411230206,
-0.271817863,
0.2641511261,
0.2657727003,
0.2517300844,
-0.4350343943,
-0.2315253168,
-0.4176234305,
-0.3020292819,
0.2483039796,
0.0288556162,
0.1262288243,
0.5100821853,
0.3747806847,
-0.4822793603,
0.9520601034,
-0.0169538185,
-0.3302223384,
0.2529838979,
-0.5628983378,
-0.4196857214,
0.4228819907,
0.4116134048,
0.1839945614,
-0.111810647,
-0.2268875688,
-0.1408573091,
0.2552532554,
-0.2595002055,
-1.1288673878,
-0.5849639177,
0.1364986449,
-0.8018581867,
-0.2335134745,
-0.1542597413,
-0.5564852357,
0.0147916768,
-0.0928306058,
0.2307196409,
-0.4766425192,
-0.3323643506,
0.3598755002,
-0.3279306889,
0.3972721994,
0.4247435629,
-0.8736009002,
0.5033106804,
0.8730609417,
0.9665592909,
-0.0261871386,
-0.241588667,
-0.9478827715,
0.0191465672,
-0.4184844494,
1.0689190626,
-0.6598630548,
-0.1955627054,
-0.3720985353,
0.2184865624,
-0.1290206164,
-0.4408325553,
0.6042957902,
-0.533434689,
0.004871896,
-0.1118088663,
-0.3559978604,
-0.3208376169,
0.4432287812,
-0.5517585874,
0.9673045278,
0.1454740316,
-0.8711596727,
0.7711037397,
-0.6941897273,
-0.5499958992,
0.272246927,
0.0706387088,
-0.2227535397,
-0.0411030874,
0.5565131903,
0.1771023571,
0.0231041908,
0.147371456,
0.184401989,
-0.0317970216,
-0.1371655315,
-0.5334694982,
0.8463823795,
0.3500874937,
-0.4514409602,
0.0965523124,
-0.6512447596,
0.1727422029,
0.1230929494,
-0.3023129702,
-0.3071700037,
0.262622565,
-0.1416397542,
0.2102669924,
0.1538282335,
-0.8762567043,
0.0623604022,
-0.9182394147,
0.5415163636,
0.5435316563,
-0.0815499127,
0.2338181585,
-0.0317952484,
0.2070066184,
0.2461234182,
0.0686120763,
-0.6634060144,
-0.5692216754,
-0.8908336163,
-0.0388541445,
0.6998802423,
0.5978395343,
-0.5556763411,
0.509118855,
-0.2127266228,
-0.2369636595,
-0.4377282858,
-0.0763193294,
0.4853064418,
0.5648882389,
0.4281812608,
-0.7702860832,
-0.7039497495,
-0.7858585119,
-0.4861095548,
-0.2347503603,
0.0855733082,
-0.0195043106,
0.355119586,
-0.2190127373,
1.0138831139,
-0.2198578566,
-0.4576714635,
-0.0593601689,
0.4220887125,
0.0349709913,
0.7103580832,
0.2191579491,
-0.4893746972,
-0.5016118884,
-0.0065662395,
-0.4504089355,
0.0326887816,
0.1204977855,
-0.0671138242,
0.3299889565,
0.755662322,
-0.5384824872,
0.5961353779,
0.3142835796,
-0.7898027301,
-0.1127642244,
0.0018127596,
-0.0435921364,
-1.0742044449,
-0.0045971046,
-0.5300946832,
-0.6870790124,
-0.2491522431,
-0.1648869663,
-0.1000111029,
0.1624106616,
-0.4800567627,
0.1661985517,
-0.4931985736,
-0.5602054596,
-0.4153702557,
-0.0721066967,
0.1996000409,
0.2256584466,
0.2606343925,
0.7159729004,
0.4844460189,
-0.4726019502,
0.3316538334,
0.451965332,
-0.1227666065,
0.3249319792,
-0.7554149032,
0.0392956026,
-0.208529368,
0.4870145619,
-0.745284915,
-0.0786138177,
0.0724174008,
-0.6112894416,
0.022376284,
-0.4281873405,
-0.5955809355,
-0.1806497276,
-0.0699717551,
0.687396884,
0.4114154875,
-0.6271154284,
0.5628876686,
0.3467163444,
0.0591770075,
-0.519225359,
-0.9623383284,
0.3600927591,
0.0583685338,
-0.7207182646,
0.5891338587,
0.4723895788,
-0.0207780655,
0.5279842019,
-0.0855653733,
0.1348257065,
0.1739714444,
0.0201505311,
-0.2836330235,
-0.4002866745,
0.1332884729,
-0.119996585,
-0.5727378726,
0.2072569728,
-0.5279018283,
0.7351740599,
-0.4087245166,
-0.3779267371,
-0.684401989,
0.3360442519,
0.3934169114,
-0.5357816815,
0.3851573169,
0.577376008,
-0.4695438147,
-0.034370292,
-0.216771096,
-0.1913391203,
-0.4799677134,
0.3268495798,
-0.4157008231,
-0.7613850832,
0.2462483644,
-0.1574931145,
0.0432012267,
0.6197321415,
0.2770683467,
0.2653505802,
1.4829170704,
0.4204421639,
-0.0445427299,
0.5302096009,
-0.4174380302,
0.0957162678,
-0.8078392744,
-0.2653935254,
-0.6397784948,
-0.3289016485,
-0.5137292147,
-0.4882177114,
0.1050401554,
0.1300201714,
-0.2360663116,
0.5161299109,
-0.8844131827,
0.590462029,
0.8336079121,
-0.2193153948,
0.5728564858,
-0.07244654,
-0.2085859776,
0.1750870049,
-0.9215849638,
-0.2282848805,
0.7165395617,
0.5145770907,
0.4884337485,
-0.0756476521,
0.5292505026,
0.2128380239,
-0.1422151029,
-1.0493057966,
0.5830067396,
-0.3849471211,
-0.3280265927,
-0.3460254073,
0.0016132141,
-1.239773035,
0.3044225574,
-0.0902059674,
-0.5582707524,
0.2319619954,
0.3098558486,
-0.2539590895,
0.5456632972,
-0.4250254929,
1.1410261393,
-0.1265604645,
0.016165996,
-0.0117472839,
-0.7514207363,
-0.0200961456,
0.388310194,
-0.1268345714,
-0.1714238226,
-0.0533180721,
0.9137034416,
-0.626914978,
0.5838361979,
-0.5051217079,
0.4619956315,
0.393170625,
0.4343481064,
0.8152822852,
-0.0232838504,
0.2593010962,
0.0652124509,
0.2762485445,
-0.2993758321,
-0.4874829948,
0.3262161911,
-0.5796581507,
-0.4196898043,
-0.7242892385,
-0.2928882837,
-0.0452785753,
0.1729989201,
0.1753583103,
0.6174602509,
0.0311841462,
0.4780638516,
0.4008011818,
0.292927295,
1.067361474,
0.1779575795,
-0.1864229143,
-0.4460228384,
0.6634844542,
0.1407180578,
-0.0998711661,
0.3783518076,
0.3335071504,
-0.3243962526,
-0.705041945,
-0.6582363844,
-0.2487060875,
-0.6664028764,
-0.6748967171,
-1.0168886185,
-0.5349845886,
-0.2710181475,
-0.0448202975,
-0.5202290416,
-0.7671760321,
-0.0121868653,
-0.047769174,
0.6100150943,
0.6222116351,
-0.0793159455,
0.6043202281,
-0.9148214459,
0.080581978,
0.5964635611,
0.296068728,
-0.0708666965,
-0.4954744577,
-0.0875452086,
-0.2533895671,
-0.007072228,
-0.5056315064,
0.5785745978,
0.3061436415,
0.2722661197,
0.3361661732,
-0.1010908484,
1.0602287054,
-0.5861366391,
0.7589223981,
0.0570975281,
-1.1073629856,
0.6883066297,
0.0107476832,
0.602620542,
0.6556702852,
-0.1143214554,
-0.7418365479,
-0.1508876383,
-0.5056799054,
-0.9298227429,
0.894318223,
0.1828178018,
-0.0294401702,
-0.2596009374,
0.0105997268,
0.0351837873,
-0.0282563604,
-0.5436671376,
0.0795459002,
-0.6045945883,
-0.1610385776,
0.1898109913,
-0.5028125048,
0.1366322041,
-0.4393012226,
0.5704361796,
-0.1232807562,
0.4799907506,
0.7281676531,
-0.2449176759,
-0.3437142074,
0.0357551575,
0.2396596223,
0.4606838822,
-0.2763089836,
0.4474667907,
0.2175997496,
-0.5344697833,
0.041699782,
0.1193502843,
-0.2532957494,
0.2616875768,
0.5413370728,
0.7884684801,
-0.1592710912,
-0.2960397601,
0.5591728687,
-0.2151310295,
-0.2432653606,
-0.4277845919,
0.0417097248,
-0.0862186253,
0.2709534168,
0.2572672367,
0.2336069196,
0.427000314,
-0.3589993715,
0.5147879124,
0.4377665222,
-0.2774400413,
-0.2250816673,
0.7670399547,
0.2795408368,
-0.7207654715,
0.538168788,
-0.2247019559,
-0.4986341,
0.525901258,
0.8201738,
1.2319896221,
-0.2094626874,
0.0539884083,
0.4558934271,
0.2594692707,
0.138521865,
0.0532979853,
-0.3654798865,
-0.6336947083,
-0.8682975173,
-1.0386283398,
-0.254865557,
-0.205351755,
-0.4661408961,
-0.105938457,
-0.2791130543,
-0.0864510387,
-0.0072877174,
-0.2534974813,
-0.4659104049,
0.3838657141,
-0.1072777659,
1.1969600916,
-0.6349250674,
1.1153788567,
0.491864413,
0.0699841008,
-0.7317557931,
0.0204395112,
-0.2159157097,
-0.7167220712,
0.9323167205,
0.3097457886,
-0.27272892,
0.2212814838,
-0.0404084027,
-1.2119386196,
1.1625677347,
0.0002480582,
-0.3698848486,
-0.2097764909,
0.3286512196,
0.4053530097,
-0.4663386047,
0.2456647605,
0.6869273186,
0.4329448938,
0.2278140485,
-0.8367820978,
0.000633634,
-0.2453224808,
0.3163195252,
0.4885735512,
-0.3513142169,
0.9058658481,
0.5943243504,
-0.2712819576,
-0.1693783849,
0.6965976357,
-0.2329431921,
0.2844275236,
0.9161932468,
1.1427454948,
0.3910046518,
-0.1775802225,
0.7235739827,
-0.6625440717,
0.0276942775,
1.0972616673,
0.1859948635,
0.9876434803,
0.4200901091,
-0.0659355,
0.657110095,
0.7668269873,
0.379845202,
0.605137229,
-0.2474872321,
-0.3229910731,
-0.3049841821,
-0.2081922442,
-0.3429096043,
0.8889672756,
0.2596927881,
-0.5193445683,
-0.6207570434,
0.0337696634,
0.127796948,
-0.0953326523,
-0.4992190003,
1.0588035583,
-0.1058932394,
-0.8003044724,
0.3515907824,
0.3044818342,
0.4210526645,
-0.4708892703,
-0.2340229005,
-0.0616437867,
0.2046776712,
-0.2585277259,
-0.6218421459,
0.8794434071,
-0.1767988503,
0.1281680316,
-0.4525182843,
0.844720006,
-0.2654708028,
-0.5184146166,
0.2957404256,
0.5272941589,
0.1550400406,
-0.0342784971,
-0.8138804436,
-0.0145325316,
-0.350685358,
-0.3352269828,
0.0683378428,
0.3724521399,
-0.0659544915,
0.3929059505,
0.7728793621,
-0.1288325042,
0.2720172405,
-0.1659247279,
0.9269484878,
-0.8275529742,
-0.4130655527,
-1.0350283384,
0.3967615664,
-0.0643656328,
-0.3322078586,
0.8283503652,
0.7340199351,
1.1208274364,
0.2789467871,
0.2876972258,
-0.2632546127,
0.516746223,
-0.5994049907,
0.3055411577,
-0.3232674897,
0.0107756723,
-0.0658217147,
-0.843196094,
-0.5704378486,
0.793898046,
-0.0648412779,
-0.3038170934,
0.9621915221,
0.6274528503,
-0.0308531653,
-0.0536304563,
0.1627143025,
-0.0177202877,
0.17845653,
0.4487267733,
0.6063511968,
-0.5771383643,
0.57786268,
-0.5837629437,
-0.0132009657,
-0.1054839492,
-0.9784735441,
-0.8462187052,
-0.5235711932,
-0.228982389,
-0.4200645983,
0.1388543248,
0.8924763203,
0.9075202942,
-0.8341537118,
-0.0639344156,
-0.9262456894,
0.0455286577,
-0.1417355686,
-0.245675981,
0.5570572615,
-0.6931890249,
-0.6165741682,
0.3931291997,
0.6082188487,
-0.1280976087,
-0.1383211315,
0.0964208767,
-0.2558318675,
0.0134484377,
0.6975281835,
0.0331863016,
-0.7028477192,
-0.456332773,
-0.0730413049,
0.1400195062,
0.4955121279,
0.8805470467,
-1.2214509249,
0.6204198599,
0.8392282128,
0.7965513468,
0.7859598994,
0.3335676491,
0.2446974218,
-0.4408799112,
0.3992934525,
0.4849561751,
0.4371190369,
0.1983676106,
-0.3063746989,
0.631577909,
0.4817913771,
-0.6413430572,
-0.6295358539,
0.3751651943,
-0.7091072202,
-0.3152132332,
0.7936846018,
-0.0293581318,
-0.8001881242,
-0.2306346297,
-0.2043695301,
0.2821798027,
-0.1977977604,
0.2322990596,
0.2779206038,
-0.4128090441,
-0.3352642059,
-0.1762609184,
0.8085106611,
0.5936915874,
-0.6880318522,
-0.0085276281,
0.2635247409,
0.1155459732,
0.1460290849,
0.6603904963,
-0.3822245002,
0.4087366462,
0.4585695863,
-0.1247480661,
-0.4021087885,
-0.4816927314,
-0.2953886986,
0.2504311502,
0.3141092658,
-0.5346701741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06034v1 | Social Biases through the Text-to-Image Generation Lens | 2023-03-30T05:29:13 | 2023-03-30T05:29:13 | Ranjita Naik, Besmira Nushi | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Text-to-Image (T2I) generation is enabling new applications that support
creators, designers, and general end users of productivity software by
generating illustrative content with high photorealism starting from a given
descriptive text as a prompt. Such models are however trained on massive
amounts of web data, which surfaces the peril of potential harmful biases that
may leak in the generation process itself. In this paper, we take a
multi-dimensional approach to studying and quantifying common social biases as
reflected in the generated images, by focusing on how occupations, personality
traits, and everyday situations are depicted across representations of
(perceived) gender, age, race, and geographical location. Through an extensive
set of both automated and human evaluation experiments we present findings for
two popular T2I models: DALLE-v2 and Stable Diffusion. Our results reveal that
there exist severe occupational biases of neutral prompts majorly excluding
groups of people from results for both models. Such biases can get mitigated by
increasing the amount of specification in the prompt itself, although the
prompting mitigation will not address discrepancies in image quality or other
usages of the model or its representations in other scenarios. Further, we
observe personality traits being associated with only a limited set of people
at the intersection of race, gender, and age. Finally, an analysis of
geographical location representations on everyday situations (e.g., park, food,
weddings) shows that for most situations, images generated through default
location-neutral prompts are closer and more similar to images generated for
locations of United States and Germany. | [
-0.4900748432,
-0.5549256802,
0.7819993496,
0.3714583814,
-0.1846464276,
-0.1377212554,
-0.0047248937,
-0.680927217,
0.0553280748,
0.303011477,
-0.6498753428,
-0.4431700706,
-0.7076833248,
-0.0402649343,
-0.0220784936,
0.7821952105,
0.0990238935,
0.0216184072,
-0.3471720517,
-0.1653036177,
-0.6174585223,
-0.2240697742,
-0.7508763671,
-0.3117014766,
0.5387489796,
0.5136591196,
0.7375415564,
0.3854732811,
-0.0298989173,
0.1131689698,
0.1334086657,
-0.0388707705,
-0.6642398238,
0.092312701,
-0.3284391165,
-0.4017385244,
0.0905195996,
0.2454828173,
0.3216040432,
0.6609953046,
0.4765433371,
0.4993483424,
0.0729720518,
0.7869215608,
-0.6618744135,
-0.0328533165,
-0.3497569263,
0.2230786979,
-0.3889222145,
-0.1275334954,
-0.4584752023,
-0.6005396843,
0.1459723562,
-0.4349380434,
0.6061976552,
-0.1014290228,
0.8131117821,
0.1527127326,
-0.9814917445,
-0.0856859088,
-0.8802708983,
0.8623343706,
-0.0487374626,
0.1301065832,
0.3211404979,
0.2548817098,
0.0919647068,
-0.0088370638,
-0.3212551773,
0.2169922292,
-0.0048775147,
0.1609923393,
-0.0989880413,
-0.3854579329,
0.4030355811,
-0.3155150414,
-0.4014361501,
0.0868867189,
-0.5368577242,
0.0631946102,
0.7667642236,
0.1234639958,
0.5764417052,
-0.1822190136,
-0.1453630775,
-0.2216830701,
-0.8159006238,
0.049167268,
0.6447409391,
-0.295637846,
-0.3727019131,
0.6610440612,
0.0688126311,
0.3125755191,
0.2329178154,
0.0207180474,
0.2347702384,
-0.2447285652,
0.2880500257,
-0.1721706986,
0.734899044,
1.1459981203,
0.625867188,
-0.1169412211,
0.0142630767,
0.3286951482,
0.2396358103,
-0.7284118533,
0.104940705,
0.2466692626,
-0.7545868158,
-0.7174601555,
-0.0079604853,
-1.2903653383,
-0.7444501519,
-0.1528648436,
-0.1331422031,
-0.1015277654,
-0.3103888035,
-0.5310243964,
-0.7228374481,
0.227328822,
0.2408091724,
-0.78271842,
-0.1660833955,
0.2875096202,
0.7935771346,
-0.2385348827,
-0.0512001067,
-0.1393063962,
0.362413168,
-0.4786979258,
1.0069196224,
-0.566455543,
-0.6283015609,
0.302752912,
-0.2350697517,
0.2455210686,
-0.5239058733,
0.3281231225,
-0.4550246894,
0.2518097758,
-0.6921836138,
0.0800518841,
0.1427518278,
-0.0091693653,
-0.7017006278,
0.9408544302,
0.2104311287,
-0.9602549672,
0.8135569692,
-0.7191883922,
-0.4158734679,
-0.2415292561,
-0.5261842608,
-0.483730793,
0.3165152967,
0.1442455798,
0.2967042327,
-0.3033331335,
0.2509022355,
-0.6522551775,
-0.1786502004,
0.1990184039,
-0.3053673506,
0.9361221194,
0.179377839,
-0.6271214485,
-0.1680978686,
-0.5376339555,
-0.2800065279,
0.3552325964,
-0.0352710262,
-0.4787907898,
0.0844724476,
0.2562069893,
0.512458086,
0.1049140021,
-0.6942785978,
-0.0640019551,
0.1581772566,
0.3362108469,
0.8322415352,
0.2836960852,
0.7364339828,
-0.3400731087,
0.2375776172,
0.4427819848,
0.2321543247,
-0.0989251584,
-0.5812497735,
-0.3290379047,
0.1958109587,
-0.2328188717,
0.5416052938,
-0.8632459641,
0.0568857267,
-0.4180905521,
-0.5093048811,
-0.065732114,
-0.0435193926,
0.3545137346,
0.3773241937,
-0.0019870396,
-0.2108703256,
-0.0879422501,
-1.1357735395,
-0.4747242928,
-0.0701934025,
-0.3772687912,
0.6916609406,
0.2989681661,
-0.3367435038,
0.9404343963,
-0.5883373022,
-0.1679819971,
0.0641778782,
0.339561075,
-0.1927445829,
0.3420622349,
0.8857607245,
-0.8624976873,
-0.4324207008,
-0.3631040156,
-0.9496117234,
-0.4552206397,
-0.180739969,
-0.4059850276,
0.4077833593,
0.2560910881,
-0.5327453613,
0.6178346872,
0.2775436342,
-0.7147601843,
0.5597443581,
0.0546940267,
0.0908875167,
-1.0761860609,
0.1414948255,
0.7475788593,
-0.0245229453,
-0.4913678467,
-0.0907319859,
0.0454896763,
-0.4185166359,
-0.2484634072,
0.7242531776,
-0.585030973,
-0.3678272665,
0.0128465528,
0.0629093125,
0.2661665082,
0.1544014812,
0.2019041181,
0.8300356269,
0.4586530924,
-0.4188452661,
-0.0817987919,
0.1608188152,
-0.346267283,
0.8617987633,
-0.6974689364,
0.4880155921,
-0.6532070041,
0.3931004405,
-0.9679822922,
-0.3948096931,
0.1007357761,
-0.3168845475,
0.0189633276,
0.1187529191,
-0.5544992089,
-0.4124550521,
-0.4955469668,
0.6266040802,
0.6874924302,
-0.4561317861,
0.555059135,
0.3522231579,
-0.111529924,
-0.2571504414,
-0.9447035789,
0.1094598696,
-0.2973943949,
-0.9945161343,
0.3509962559,
0.1846350878,
-0.5021588802,
-0.096702449,
0.3152629733,
-0.1668455601,
-0.3776006699,
0.4859258235,
0.339744091,
0.2318893224,
-0.0919131339,
0.2144712806,
0.1150742918,
0.2382007688,
0.0143647827,
0.3330526352,
0.4891430438,
-0.1282165051,
-0.4293503761,
0.6554219723,
0.6158300042,
-0.0636578798,
0.6410289407,
0.7139598131,
-0.175832659,
0.0207161531,
-0.7137612104,
-0.0691048279,
-0.4416003525,
0.230410099,
-0.0832186863,
-0.4134166837,
0.7006781101,
-0.1446914971,
0.230512619,
0.4234460592,
0.4454592466,
-0.1218639165,
1.2427829504,
0.4942747653,
0.162200883,
0.7250708938,
-0.1372070611,
0.0860049054,
-0.7347432971,
-0.4442515373,
-0.4129560292,
-0.376650095,
-0.6371302605,
-0.3514970243,
0.5940892696,
-0.3532741368,
-0.3679062724,
-0.2134297192,
-0.501504004,
0.6201997995,
0.6044229865,
0.3961030543,
-0.2658545077,
0.2871339023,
-0.0390918776,
-0.1920899451,
-0.3465951681,
-0.612844646,
1.2135350704,
0.2900810242,
0.5469097495,
0.1038083211,
0.547095716,
0.6161126494,
0.3578822017,
-0.298342675,
0.4735223651,
-0.3573571146,
-0.766184032,
-0.0491395406,
-0.2508589327,
-0.7286624312,
-0.0886092857,
-0.3718556166,
-0.8498497605,
0.66841048,
0.280449152,
-0.2449838817,
0.1271978468,
-1.1033649445,
0.7474946976,
-0.1377253979,
-0.9636225104,
-0.1738282591,
-0.6368063688,
0.415107429,
0.004667514,
0.3683589697,
-0.1021748334,
0.1816006005,
0.4196391106,
-0.0222980287,
1.0557335615,
-0.5685607791,
0.1283185631,
0.0860948563,
0.0637245029,
0.4703386724,
-0.0261806976,
-0.3111573756,
0.4292536676,
-0.0485630482,
-0.5760428905,
-0.4839691818,
0.5136896968,
-1.1607863903,
-0.2692233622,
-0.1524529308,
-0.37745139,
-0.1065043136,
0.1148934588,
0.7800729871,
0.6043633819,
-0.3372936845,
-0.2613929212,
0.4925022125,
-0.777749002,
0.1441100687,
-0.1182370931,
-0.0430674031,
-0.1810922474,
0.7686930299,
0.2544088364,
0.2990086675,
-0.1603631079,
0.085216105,
-0.2893960476,
0.0291525517,
-0.4436821938,
0.2276055366,
-0.6866036654,
0.0826957524,
-0.3892248869,
0.1307679415,
-0.466825366,
-0.4099036455,
-0.1097456813,
-0.2469813526,
-0.5952315331,
0.0591010936,
-0.0059410632,
1.0038350821,
0.1599938422,
0.1725204587,
-0.340567559,
0.4668350518,
0.3263327777,
0.2780633569,
0.2153138518,
0.0515793897,
0.0063046776,
0.0703433231,
-0.7720583677,
-1.0703933239,
0.2435328364,
0.0206605066,
0.1881848574,
0.7000375986,
0.0615697205,
0.3320356309,
-0.5530129671,
1.1760957241,
0.26718539,
-0.5473111868,
0.6786636114,
-0.6743699908,
0.3672576547,
0.4109805822,
0.2456008494,
-0.5100752711,
-0.4736700058,
-0.5430594683,
-0.7954933643,
0.5556996465,
0.1037400737,
0.3035077751,
-0.1483027786,
0.6123606563,
0.1153788939,
-0.0106063038,
-0.8181372285,
-0.3360569477,
-0.4804732502,
-0.1711944491,
0.1953447759,
-0.6308614612,
-0.1748971343,
-0.0200419165,
0.2872400284,
0.1252721101,
0.5959544182,
0.2410576791,
0.128933236,
-0.379363656,
0.1198216677,
0.5381435156,
0.5702105761,
-0.0349321812,
0.2885996997,
-0.1188987345,
-0.226622507,
0.2390832752,
-0.2792679667,
-0.6344956756,
0.0332149863,
0.1401959956,
0.8618320823,
-0.2850339413,
-0.2585194409,
0.6158454418,
-0.0034124632,
-0.259231925,
-0.6275442243,
0.0739903599,
-0.1801114678,
0.3012591302,
0.486001879,
0.3052724302,
0.2488293499,
-0.6888783574,
-0.3447040617,
0.5553513169,
-0.3316720128,
-0.5386738777,
0.9600377083,
0.4890429378,
-0.3053840399,
0.5976543427,
-0.3550021648,
-0.2718596458,
0.7619207501,
0.543530643,
0.9177425504,
0.1128179803,
0.5196516514,
0.4982350171,
0.2464068681,
0.0214151554,
0.1534850597,
0.215966776,
-0.8023561835,
0.0808304995,
-0.0877530873,
0.0043480755,
0.0995275974,
-0.4946617186,
0.3084131181,
-0.4072741866,
-0.6371241808,
0.2009940743,
-0.4405747056,
-0.9170640111,
0.188247472,
0.3294616938,
0.5912868977,
-1.2566269636,
0.3927944899,
0.8197824359,
-0.2473067492,
-0.4465485513,
0.3693444431,
0.3382066786,
-0.5566734672,
0.8557427526,
0.4200450182,
0.0561370514,
-0.326533705,
-0.7755790353,
-0.7180423141,
1.031162262,
0.3559018672,
-0.1912848353,
-0.2904095948,
0.4319670796,
0.4223706722,
-0.4523447752,
0.3184657395,
0.4352313578,
0.4265451729,
-0.0715641528,
-0.3948839605,
0.1210721806,
-0.4236529469,
0.7543811798,
-0.0855390355,
-0.8271937966,
0.527428925,
-0.3452595472,
-0.3414573669,
-0.3038317561,
0.1161527485,
0.469080925,
0.6174026728,
0.6250767708,
0.3116135299,
0.3589765728,
-0.0938955247,
1.2674942017,
-0.2909652293,
0.0357809365,
0.7314543128,
-0.3403092623,
0.3519281745,
0.6006457806,
0.0874935538,
0.6450116038,
0.7034292817,
-0.2345118523,
0.5690762997,
-0.1940529048,
-0.32570225,
0.1004757062,
-0.576033175,
-0.1623003632,
0.1379996389,
0.1685782224,
-0.7024880052,
-0.1940871179,
0.0490998924,
-0.064651683,
-0.0022223953,
-0.0869027227,
0.6833142638,
-0.0856198594,
-0.7889415026,
0.0315402485,
-0.0310554281,
0.6544505358,
-0.1315835863,
-0.0488263853,
-0.2370727956,
-0.1508498341,
-0.3701268435,
-0.9979375005,
0.4517271221,
0.0462721102,
-0.5263211727,
-0.4611250758,
0.9815735817,
-0.1503760666,
-0.5423090458,
0.316988349,
0.2473750412,
0.1131418496,
-0.0102739371,
-0.403095901,
0.0147812134,
0.1028687581,
-0.2503796816,
0.1927746832,
0.4705016017,
-0.2244818658,
0.2699145973,
0.3465412259,
0.02948975,
0.1223790199,
0.2181744576,
0.5676054358,
-0.4429291189,
-0.5952399969,
-0.8086905479,
0.5390732288,
-0.4496529698,
-0.253059566,
0.4863154292,
0.4469725192,
0.5262516141,
-0.2784591615,
1.0468639135,
0.0239558425,
0.2054376751,
-0.2088508904,
0.6873928905,
-0.4776892662,
-0.1087685898,
-0.3815059066,
-1.0782686472,
0.1418359727,
0.3732677698,
-0.7130100727,
0.3416767716,
0.3433926105,
0.6577481627,
-0.0148548726,
-0.1317948103,
-0.0027180226,
-0.0652461052,
0.2857725322,
0.3894476295,
0.6292875409,
-0.1565482914,
0.1371101886,
-0.2722217739,
-0.4224251211,
-0.1322358996,
-0.8724491,
-0.8721106648,
-0.4599902928,
-0.3456704617,
-0.5446772575,
-0.0888794437,
0.6389396787,
0.680585146,
-0.2690108418,
-0.1446701139,
-0.1057425514,
0.0380618125,
0.1478251666,
-0.3313471675,
0.0833857656,
0.085311465,
-0.5589338541,
-0.5103790164,
0.1505607516,
0.2206727415,
-0.4994014502,
0.2188149542,
0.297183007,
0.0948205888,
0.7723480463,
0.0408434942,
-0.5121013522,
-0.3808269799,
-0.065648891,
-0.0667093247,
0.1127770916,
0.6237854958,
-0.4199989736,
0.3748229146,
0.4302446544,
0.0690901652,
0.4338956475,
0.1535685956,
0.7359160185,
-1.0353517532,
0.2655243278,
-0.1803228706,
0.1377986819,
0.5266942978,
-0.740960598,
0.4634850323,
0.3720121682,
-0.5368133187,
-0.5559202433,
0.3937160671,
-0.6844409704,
-0.2446354628,
1.5179835558,
0.309582293,
-0.2433283478,
-0.0345930941,
-0.2234796435,
0.3497757912,
-0.5976583958,
1.2647367716,
0.7379441857,
-0.0467051268,
-0.2281727046,
-0.8378421664,
0.2703567445,
0.2683362663,
-0.7945241332,
-0.0552171357,
0.9520329237,
0.5057057738,
0.3685671389,
0.7389873862,
-0.2679695785,
0.2256213576,
-0.0271984935,
0.2558597028,
0.2024859786,
-0.1327707171,
-0.0277036987,
0.1306975633,
0.0462379381,
0.0514490008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17119v1 | TLAG: An Informative Trigger and Label-Aware Knowledge Guided Model for Dialogue-based Relation Extraction | 2023-03-30T03:10:28 | 2023-03-30T03:10:28 | Hao An, Dongsheng Chen, Weiyuan Xu, Zhihong Zhu, Yuexian Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue-based Relation Extraction (DRE) aims to predict the relation type of
argument pairs that are mentioned in dialogue. The latest trigger-enhanced
methods propose trigger prediction tasks to promote DRE. However, these methods
are not able to fully leverage the trigger information and even bring noise to
relation extraction. To solve these problems, we propose TLAG, which fully
leverages the trigger and label-aware knowledge to guide the relation
extraction. First, we design an adaptive trigger fusion module to fully
leverage the trigger information. Then, we introduce label-aware knowledge to
further promote our model's performance. Experimental results on the DialogRE
dataset show that our TLAG outperforms the baseline models, and detailed
analyses demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach. | [
-0.2691237032,
-0.6108397841,
0.3138949573,
-0.2064453661,
-0.3411679268,
-0.101694569,
0.0511687361,
-0.5987974405,
-0.0266190451,
0.5076762438,
-0.6372722983,
-0.543379426,
-0.6828548312,
-0.1593949497,
-0.1253892928,
1.1313899755,
0.363753885,
-0.1700129211,
0.1681261063,
-0.1109924838,
-0.6277084351,
-0.2021710426,
-0.7341910601,
-0.3986916244,
0.6783895493,
0.1952808052,
0.4364406168,
0.5604760051,
0.1339549124,
0.1054240912,
-0.2414848059,
0.1108511314,
-0.6735519171,
0.3587813973,
-0.2149545699,
-0.3016319573,
-0.4811362028,
-0.0696916282,
0.3743001223,
0.4582950473,
-0.1640360504,
0.0403036512,
-0.3323606849,
0.4380023181,
-0.5781516433,
0.4073494971,
-0.6916103959,
0.0906711742,
0.0361014605,
-0.0381462835,
-0.7135468721,
-0.4494358003,
0.3782188892,
-0.7325926423,
0.0652113259,
0.200518176,
0.8267487288,
0.3989004493,
-0.494297415,
-0.2046170235,
-0.6781771183,
0.5747309923,
-0.8507416844,
0.7455015779,
0.2247689366,
0.22682181,
-0.2774868309,
-0.8671584129,
-0.1954807788,
-0.1425209492,
-0.2783210278,
0.0635386854,
-0.0019552773,
0.2675926089,
0.6859247088,
0.2583528757,
-0.3203952312,
0.0315853879,
-0.3441112041,
-0.2553846836,
0.4924378693,
-0.0455139875,
0.1672096699,
-0.2394503504,
-0.6903778315,
0.3319474459,
-0.6492091417,
0.0382837653,
-0.024690222,
0.2035930306,
0.0005338764,
0.3222384751,
0.1468248516,
1.2687939405,
0.3495767415,
-0.4486065209,
-0.1839133501,
-0.2014821768,
-0.390606761,
0.2640256882,
1.1018360853,
0.3973847628,
0.2922850549,
-0.3081930876,
-0.113002494,
-0.1392011642,
0.0865536556,
-0.7801876664,
-0.5369945168,
0.1663610041,
-0.3686839044,
-0.6377056837,
-0.256685555,
-1.0972361565,
-0.4954536557,
-0.063119173,
0.3241466582,
-0.3957640529,
-0.6793296337,
-0.1704740077,
-0.5059133768,
0.0787859857,
0.3699498177,
-0.8000107408,
0.0572933778,
0.5173095465,
0.5166348219,
-0.052050449,
0.3842011392,
-0.7657269239,
0.5044799447,
-0.1670998782,
0.869699657,
-0.8870930076,
-0.5206500292,
0.089142561,
-0.2702204287,
-0.1653181911,
-0.6191035509,
0.4661778808,
-0.8811801672,
0.5396091342,
-0.3127684593,
-0.9522720575,
-0.2593251169,
0.2153004557,
-0.8923876286,
0.9262016416,
0.2993385792,
-0.7163959146,
0.5309173465,
-0.8503765464,
-0.1517729312,
0.2675359845,
-0.1513115615,
-0.2719300687,
-0.2357106954,
0.2348081619,
0.1413329393,
-0.3815321624,
0.9045192599,
-0.3500748873,
0.1574947238,
0.0574704707,
0.0276556499,
0.9425212145,
0.2064946443,
-0.1451186091,
0.225614965,
-0.7166402936,
-0.1345762908,
-0.2564586401,
-0.1543985158,
-0.1555843204,
-0.1076583415,
-0.4838132262,
0.3789822757,
-0.0182768498,
-0.5926965475,
0.4731446207,
-0.4002537429,
0.0784322396,
0.5509101748,
0.6259558797,
0.5144708753,
-0.1249993891,
0.4863400459,
0.0623950176,
0.0275498033,
-0.1147875488,
-0.4665561914,
-0.7399967313,
-0.3279495537,
0.6921647787,
0.6665738821,
-1.1079826355,
0.4115724266,
0.0241877232,
-0.3385449648,
-0.4238561094,
0.310898304,
0.524001956,
0.9809378386,
0.1488148868,
-0.158599332,
-0.676019609,
-0.7528049946,
-0.3375121057,
-0.586152792,
-0.0184134804,
0.3489173055,
-0.1110303178,
0.0510309041,
1.4096095562,
-0.8539837599,
-0.3454539776,
-0.4096435905,
0.2968404889,
0.1202124655,
0.1494375616,
0.4919269681,
-0.9829676747,
-0.4483516216,
-0.0230066888,
-1.2101361752,
-0.4816231132,
0.1550608128,
-0.2087370753,
0.1171630323,
0.4162445962,
-0.5138367414,
0.5057145357,
0.1672246903,
-0.2599459589,
0.626796484,
0.4492261112,
-0.1667548716,
-1.3032505512,
0.0205930341,
0.2020013928,
-0.3383939564,
-1.1224581003,
-0.5083018541,
0.0406370871,
-0.2544206083,
-0.4063696265,
0.6723042727,
-0.1574165672,
0.0170667358,
-0.1992352158,
0.0584814698,
0.0739594549,
0.535831511,
0.3479061425,
0.5978299975,
0.3332009614,
-0.755058825,
0.5498912334,
0.4612946212,
-0.3036935329,
0.2356777042,
-0.2820493877,
0.1217325181,
0.0208859444,
0.15668571,
-0.8031573296,
-0.2931246758,
0.5884771943,
-0.2736887336,
0.8366042972,
-0.3575454652,
-0.1244078651,
-0.0425139144,
0.0887760222,
0.4080302715,
0.411265552,
-0.6842026711,
0.752768755,
0.6177883744,
-0.2475030124,
-0.6624212861,
0.0514308549,
-0.0022552283,
-0.4533779025,
-0.4403376877,
-0.025049936,
-0.0262672901,
-0.3722410202,
0.045017615,
-0.184597522,
-0.3517137468,
-0.1540823579,
0.2256477177,
0.3279252648,
-0.0814675167,
0.7806534767,
-0.2810898423,
-0.2998925149,
0.0422763079,
-0.3101027906,
0.194904685,
0.2990942895,
0.3767772615,
-0.356986165,
0.2963243127,
0.3659456372,
-0.18500714,
0.6750486493,
0.5869463086,
-0.2178186029,
-0.1030147374,
-0.8368099928,
-0.3384723067,
-0.4538683891,
0.1250845194,
-0.3847686648,
-0.8523135781,
0.4363504052,
-0.6756235957,
0.1595597267,
0.3831242621,
0.1940312386,
-0.0498666428,
0.402338922,
0.9131974578,
-0.269682616,
0.7610118389,
-0.0182124656,
0.4646801651,
-0.9053629637,
-0.4639215171,
-0.197893694,
0.0522099808,
-0.1849550307,
-0.1528281718,
0.4590419829,
0.247876972,
-0.0672848225,
0.5242241025,
-0.4038287699,
-0.0153466025,
0.3771235943,
-0.0135626793,
0.4658831954,
-0.1588170677,
0.1878240705,
-0.1161454543,
-1.0037106276,
-0.2778303325,
0.6903176308,
0.1580199301,
0.8338884115,
-0.0271807164,
0.5169247985,
0.4646666944,
0.3926991522,
-0.9243346453,
0.5601884723,
0.3253249824,
-0.8646647334,
-0.2862722874,
-0.4664106667,
-0.7348678708,
0.0127573451,
-0.1565655917,
-1.2257490158,
0.4589133561,
0.1431719661,
-0.1985926181,
0.4295921326,
-0.895976007,
0.7438400388,
0.0318575017,
-0.1954486072,
0.3128104508,
-0.8131010532,
0.593912065,
-0.1749511212,
0.2002729923,
-0.3267127872,
0.0703570247,
1.0120037794,
-0.2345899343,
0.996150732,
-0.3658729196,
-0.3139016926,
0.4230546653,
0.185552597,
0.4244083166,
-0.0895154327,
-0.524808228,
-0.0269945841,
-0.2541929781,
-0.0231693089,
-0.8269876242,
0.3542547226,
-0.373906374,
-0.817310214,
-0.208135888,
-0.8745401502,
-0.3041487336,
0.1775613278,
0.3626129031,
0.7031280994,
-0.263610363,
-0.3319755495,
0.6293958426,
-0.1720133573,
0.515478611,
0.6962853074,
-0.4105894566,
-0.5808619261,
0.8107640147,
-0.0245272592,
0.4512116909,
0.4052131772,
0.1712490767,
-0.3450405896,
0.091880478,
-0.5006021261,
0.1911830306,
-0.7289598584,
-0.5942035317,
-0.7767336369,
-0.3101089597,
-0.3775801957,
0.0926438794,
-0.1163693145,
-0.6021466255,
-0.3449073434,
-0.2819198072,
0.6186472774,
0.9708684087,
-0.0885961056,
0.2908942401,
-0.952716589,
0.4645806253,
0.4054008126,
0.2795114815,
-0.2376407683,
-0.3666315973,
-0.0305400304,
-0.2021749616,
-0.3917360008,
-1.278544426,
0.4480088353,
0.4729279578,
0.4406383038,
0.6629757285,
0.5617328286,
0.4456563592,
-0.2294065952,
0.8163750172,
0.3492332399,
-0.6634491086,
0.9002694488,
-0.4218363762,
0.1856650412,
0.2475126386,
0.3490978181,
-0.2175836712,
-0.4379290044,
-0.9549127221,
-0.3866285086,
0.8258200288,
0.1540835351,
-0.5077034831,
0.3792746961,
0.4095930457,
0.2951631248,
0.4298467636,
-0.7992215157,
-0.1980959624,
0.1721335948,
0.0150254322,
0.1039255932,
-0.6683915854,
-0.2154618651,
-0.1505609453,
0.7266967893,
0.1300804913,
0.3498029113,
0.0855625719,
0.0136771705,
-0.4045487642,
0.3590417206,
0.2797243297,
0.5974660516,
-0.5943624973,
-0.1755666137,
0.115874961,
-0.0216322392,
0.1412324309,
0.198490873,
-0.2403230816,
0.2943463027,
0.5441699028,
1.0386836529,
0.2191157788,
-0.2632409334,
0.3255238235,
-0.060879346,
-0.1583355814,
-0.0452988036,
0.235160321,
0.0300759748,
0.3212680817,
0.197356239,
-0.0761369392,
0.2877885401,
-0.4169763923,
0.4210101664,
0.2525999248,
-0.7537222505,
-0.1560623944,
0.3190265,
0.4533490539,
-0.6032072306,
0.4731684327,
-0.1694347709,
-0.8172854781,
0.3208757043,
0.5820322037,
0.7304003239,
-0.5128469467,
0.1886393428,
0.6956902146,
-0.0922723413,
0.409116447,
-0.0098454254,
-0.3932691514,
-0.8074896932,
-0.4038491547,
-0.5480514765,
-0.3655760288,
0.1358524859,
-0.8630973697,
0.3174003065,
-0.0864179358,
-0.1802666038,
0.1605454087,
0.0150813889,
-0.197660014,
0.2209306508,
-0.1274123341,
1.0467139482,
-0.8204446435,
1.1296451092,
0.343842566,
-0.0259233974,
-0.8648200035,
-0.1638568044,
0.0049586878,
-0.425804168,
0.7914248705,
0.1073088348,
0.0518456176,
0.0520341545,
-0.57479316,
-0.5326718688,
0.8591862917,
0.4115046859,
-0.5045981407,
-0.0456432253,
-0.2080799788,
0.2637496591,
-0.7193867564,
0.1013133973,
0.7797495723,
0.432915777,
0.5975257754,
-1.0648167133,
-0.0427840464,
-0.2457434088,
-0.1855942756,
0.6818899512,
-0.2835112214,
0.119424209,
-0.1871160567,
-0.3355818689,
-0.186237812,
0.3839382827,
-0.0377393402,
0.5244565606,
0.6223089099,
0.4998060763,
0.6784165502,
-0.126907438,
0.8891324401,
-0.1054433808,
0.1873019934,
1.4951261282,
-0.3819811046,
0.6341904998,
0.2549538314,
0.1560654789,
0.6909802556,
0.6220979095,
0.094179064,
0.792450726,
-0.2646947503,
-0.7698129416,
-0.49760288,
-0.7200717926,
-0.3197262585,
0.2775683403,
0.780465126,
-0.6886864901,
-0.3466975391,
-0.0439604372,
-0.1077425182,
-0.3349968493,
-0.1897875667,
1.6978651285,
0.3795097172,
-0.9354263544,
0.6305571198,
-0.7241194248,
-0.0207023639,
-0.6217056513,
-0.2981700599,
0.2832161486,
-0.0419136509,
-0.1896569729,
-0.7415339351,
0.0936442986,
0.0314050913,
-0.2938991487,
0.014836004,
1.4600330591,
-0.8809051514,
-0.2486941516,
0.5141413212,
0.5279730558,
-0.0381561406,
0.2675731182,
-0.5158546567,
0.169661507,
0.6014379859,
-0.0899699405,
0.2171515971,
0.41060552,
0.2821471691,
0.7072677612,
0.5015717745,
0.0173530448,
-0.0424051844,
-0.1489534974,
1.2670310736,
-0.6413588524,
-0.0235303547,
-0.7199170589,
0.6730101109,
-0.5159870982,
0.0577542409,
0.3623665571,
0.317640841,
0.192739442,
-0.0517503358,
0.8709585071,
-0.1500536352,
0.6158736348,
-0.2733786702,
0.2758102715,
-0.239067629,
0.2015932053,
-0.1487239152,
-0.9437231421,
-0.2858469784,
0.2833348513,
-0.4715848863,
-0.2251601666,
0.5692822933,
0.9463737011,
0.0584696792,
0.3086442649,
0.4458891749,
0.2903967798,
0.6345293522,
0.7460933328,
0.6856706738,
-0.4569492638,
0.649684608,
-0.212988928,
-0.30033952,
-0.1452427059,
-1.1397012472,
-1.1355527639,
-0.4935718477,
-0.5523543358,
-0.2888621688,
0.1298852712,
0.7336061597,
0.8164278269,
-0.6936548948,
-0.0960130021,
0.1103335842,
0.3421921134,
0.1846923828,
-0.2179215252,
0.1299453974,
-0.5061118603,
-0.3937330544,
0.5202535391,
0.326946646,
-0.0430903062,
0.4314575195,
-0.0321999788,
-0.3728794754,
-0.2576067448,
0.4655414522,
0.5545470715,
-0.7428514361,
-0.2006497234,
-0.5107849836,
0.1272915304,
0.1782495379,
0.6581015587,
-0.9948958755,
1.0047715902,
0.3155297339,
0.1705138981,
0.5802786946,
0.2864018679,
1.3201137781,
-0.8460611105,
0.3223005235,
0.2686474919,
0.1642907858,
0.2547269464,
-0.5452418923,
0.785918951,
0.0721338019,
-0.6393685937,
-0.727196157,
0.6010503769,
-1.1128491163,
-0.0151359951,
1.3146612644,
-0.5206398964,
0.0177930985,
-0.4219883084,
-0.5054357648,
0.6106745601,
-0.773742497,
0.6387952566,
0.6384999752,
-0.1587302983,
-0.5520634651,
-0.4643330276,
0.9995902181,
0.0319097936,
-0.6455870867,
0.2726641297,
0.542658627,
0.1415781081,
0.3564634919,
0.4562290609,
0.1588196009,
0.2763802409,
-0.0921204537,
-0.0631194711,
-0.18837744,
-0.1947921067,
-0.0499452874,
0.3875270784,
0.2725867033,
-0.0017157183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17612v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17612v3 | oBERTa: Improving Sparse Transfer Learning via improved initialization, distillation, and pruning regimes | 2023-03-30T01:37:19 | 2023-06-06T16:30:09 | Daniel Campos, Alexandre Marques, Mark Kurtz, ChengXiang Zhai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we introduce the range of oBERTa language models, an
easy-to-use set of language models which allows Natural Language Processing
(NLP) practitioners to obtain between 3.8 and 24.3 times faster models without
expertise in model compression. Specifically, oBERTa extends existing work on
pruning, knowledge distillation, and quantization and leverages frozen
embeddings improves distillation and model initialization to deliver higher
accuracy on a broad range of transfer tasks. In generating oBERTa, we explore
how the highly optimized RoBERTa differs from the BERT for pruning during
pre-training and finetuning. We find it less amenable to compression during
fine-tuning. We explore the use of oBERTa on seven representative NLP tasks and
find that the improved compression techniques allow a pruned oBERTa model to
match the performance of BERTbase and exceed the performance of Prune OFA Large
on the SQUAD V1.1 Question Answering dataset, despite being 8x and 2x,
respectively faster in inference. We release our code, training regimes, and
associated model for broad usage to encourage usage and experimentation | [
-0.4376394153,
-0.7190594673,
0.2643733025,
0.3400491178,
-0.1234935895,
-0.1518336385,
-0.4755681455,
-0.5460457206,
-0.2552951574,
0.3297822773,
-0.2905263007,
0.0041523641,
-0.806211412,
0.3104985654,
-0.2320672125,
1.2205626965,
0.0902860984,
-0.1494498402,
0.0239058305,
-0.1271335334,
-0.5101261139,
-0.4407460988,
-0.6674682498,
-0.2397708446,
0.3292944431,
0.1752831042,
0.5953263044,
0.5245339274,
0.337202698,
0.3088166118,
-0.4720989168,
0.1468368769,
-0.8473969698,
0.2020757049,
0.1141360924,
-0.331476599,
-0.1829379201,
-0.3002685606,
0.6845568419,
0.7884247303,
-0.4252094924,
0.267387718,
0.4911305904,
0.7056639194,
-0.5075801611,
0.1859015226,
-0.8723573089,
-0.4132378697,
0.0814467967,
0.0380493738,
-0.3905639648,
-0.5022131205,
0.3362754285,
-0.6190971136,
0.422775805,
0.1488237232,
0.9521023035,
0.516761601,
-0.1318469346,
-0.3101878166,
-0.6907277107,
0.6617047787,
-0.3762669563,
0.4384226799,
0.4675833285,
0.1834958047,
0.0628590658,
-0.692404151,
-0.4149791896,
-0.3179087639,
0.0404226147,
-0.4016155601,
-0.449126333,
0.1199534312,
-0.0348112434,
0.2628591061,
-0.475549072,
0.0244770329,
-0.6882191896,
0.0583480336,
0.258641541,
-0.1555692106,
-0.179758966,
0.0345770493,
-0.3668546081,
-0.2782568038,
-0.808907032,
-0.1629288644,
0.2741775513,
0.4428077638,
0.1627878994,
0.3724528849,
0.0075162393,
0.9949458241,
0.0591273457,
0.1660322994,
-0.063562572,
-0.0848755315,
-0.4235035181,
-0.0063253981,
0.5746594667,
-0.1342360228,
0.2319473922,
-0.3901407719,
0.0008788301,
-0.195954442,
0.1993685812,
-1.0190429688,
-0.7411452532,
0.0792849585,
-0.3882750273,
-0.0847050697,
-0.2606084347,
-0.5398483276,
-0.2007185668,
-0.3752578199,
0.3268740475,
-0.7289364934,
-0.0339760035,
0.3371165693,
0.0125001818,
-0.1210331246,
0.5215993524,
-0.8649272919,
0.5124186873,
0.5176930428,
0.7877467275,
-0.125229463,
-0.1264666617,
-0.5330258608,
0.2384585291,
-0.0221975837,
0.9724942446,
-0.1933709085,
-0.270249635,
-0.2074552625,
-0.169334203,
-0.0368600264,
-0.6411175132,
0.5812280178,
-0.3651665747,
-0.0161990263,
-0.0638511628,
-0.3904137611,
-0.2692447305,
0.0916395485,
-0.8121911883,
1.125161767,
0.002134413,
-0.528621912,
0.1242595389,
-0.5207885504,
-0.5657548308,
-0.0765682459,
0.2715492845,
-0.3109663427,
0.1748847961,
0.4056299031,
0.4914802909,
-0.390812546,
0.0620259345,
-0.1755065173,
-0.2888961732,
-0.0095471526,
-0.2983425856,
1.0426524878,
0.4036235511,
0.0814279616,
-0.1882685125,
-0.6812484264,
-0.0637530088,
0.0211268794,
-0.6557952762,
-0.6230392456,
-0.4378473759,
0.1443733871,
-0.2362819165,
0.2379327565,
-0.3183688819,
0.4124903977,
-0.3392429948,
0.4929067194,
0.818443656,
-0.1674425602,
0.4750361145,
-0.3474338055,
0.307100445,
-0.376835227,
0.1180400401,
0.1295316666,
-0.4544408917,
-0.6475084424,
-0.6032559276,
0.6945443749,
0.5519711375,
-0.6326668262,
0.3834239841,
-0.3401864171,
-0.3102949858,
-0.9289159775,
0.476365,
0.3695611358,
0.4860492945,
0.3783009052,
0.0657292157,
-0.7362273932,
-0.6528645158,
0.0298811328,
-0.4762390256,
-0.0973009765,
0.0929781273,
0.2916910052,
0.2410487235,
0.7791445851,
-0.606713891,
-0.4478638768,
-0.3771192729,
0.382398814,
0.114945896,
0.5450318456,
0.6657608151,
-0.844953239,
-0.5969436169,
-0.0397402048,
-0.2851225138,
-0.0768637359,
0.1395875067,
-0.0928031281,
-0.0364624262,
0.3842313588,
-0.5754434466,
0.2059913725,
0.7461452484,
-0.0268972553,
0.3239562213,
-0.338999182,
0.0922252834,
-1.1713398695,
0.2983421087,
-0.0886273012,
-0.3841250539,
-0.5847577453,
-0.0548092909,
-0.0275172349,
0.0340927318,
-0.5289442539,
0.3909438848,
-0.7137836218,
0.1954999268,
-0.1204545349,
-0.0499111041,
0.0921971127,
0.7374454737,
0.1020354331,
0.9178879857,
0.4149790108,
-0.8060203791,
0.1722685546,
0.6470359564,
-0.4915795028,
0.2637968063,
-0.929576695,
0.2389233559,
-0.316824764,
0.0638055503,
-1.0414868593,
0.4424757659,
-0.0092443153,
-0.3515753448,
0.5337170959,
-0.5957823396,
-0.4523277879,
-0.0106543489,
-0.0540174618,
0.2582774758,
0.821081996,
-0.4121887088,
0.3636251688,
0.326929003,
-0.3314506114,
-0.5409285426,
-0.5420589447,
-0.1409487277,
-0.4522513449,
-0.3254469037,
0.4644058645,
-0.2044296861,
-0.172468245,
0.2526603639,
0.0331593528,
-0.5607034564,
0.26532498,
-0.007987204,
0.3183229864,
-0.1431614906,
0.1845179796,
-0.0341269821,
0.1302802116,
-0.4641875923,
-0.1862545907,
0.2696408331,
-0.2465913892,
0.084129639,
-0.3127364516,
0.1998879164,
0.2097213864,
-0.1987707317,
1.0605795383,
0.4534571767,
-0.2747949064,
-0.2419027686,
-0.426697284,
-0.1704536229,
-0.4025949836,
0.4238380492,
-0.5719177723,
-0.9682972431,
0.3201887012,
-0.1338189393,
0.3031170666,
0.1955716014,
0.4152250588,
-0.0313874446,
0.866402626,
1.1182249784,
-0.0879955515,
0.7044392824,
-0.3911251426,
-0.0363525152,
-1.0929933786,
-0.0589008667,
-1.0688380003,
-0.0666814819,
-0.1100282073,
-0.4715298116,
0.274618119,
0.4658282101,
-0.1440617889,
0.6360644102,
-0.6652798057,
0.4497299194,
0.2239389867,
0.0189711042,
0.3082077205,
0.2094497681,
0.0881072655,
0.0675129667,
-1.1492618322,
-0.3456900716,
1.025020957,
0.3436791599,
1.0598891973,
0.3757661879,
0.4713695049,
0.3407666683,
0.7532470226,
-0.688126564,
0.2869109511,
-0.3725970387,
-0.5618156195,
-0.3554382026,
-0.5834584236,
-1.2010718584,
0.3733089864,
-0.2302945703,
-0.7419773936,
0.2036225796,
0.2020857632,
-0.6165969968,
0.2221775204,
-0.84947294,
0.5313409567,
0.1248011962,
-0.2996443808,
0.0531864017,
-0.5597395301,
0.4086731672,
0.0633928329,
-0.0981106982,
-0.233884424,
0.0172983706,
0.6779527664,
-0.3870618045,
0.7546897531,
-0.0320664383,
-0.1386977136,
0.3155813217,
0.40739429,
0.4790634513,
-0.1680062711,
-0.1074579805,
0.1655865908,
0.1072332114,
-0.2020371556,
-0.5778397918,
0.5931705236,
-0.7652542591,
-0.4001143873,
-0.1022294983,
-0.5731882453,
-0.2973422408,
-0.0196720567,
0.0872403085,
0.4340547621,
-0.3382229209,
0.4543222785,
1.063698411,
0.1101454496,
0.0551107116,
0.4650012255,
0.1132681668,
-0.3044293821,
0.5968772173,
-0.0459434539,
0.1839188188,
0.5915036798,
0.1250979453,
-0.5679417253,
-0.7645352483,
-0.4601389468,
0.21551992,
-0.5432630181,
-0.567258656,
-0.5894006491,
-0.0340149365,
-0.7930064201,
0.1281259358,
-0.4537083805,
-0.6849853396,
-0.2969945669,
0.1481208205,
0.6281920075,
0.7713920474,
-0.0759695694,
0.4083560407,
-0.8764626384,
0.4203050435,
0.2496005148,
0.0931463093,
-0.0177310966,
-0.8057777882,
-0.2550047338,
-0.0406039767,
-0.0896638408,
-0.9269748926,
0.4318457246,
0.631878674,
0.5443115234,
0.0431236513,
0.1162652671,
1.1324225664,
-0.5835493803,
0.3902653158,
0.1331905127,
-0.8130580783,
0.3795463443,
0.0859043449,
0.0780294538,
0.7418493629,
0.4661121666,
-0.0873517692,
-0.1844366491,
-0.4575302601,
-0.7936673164,
0.6154633164,
0.3504057229,
-0.127079621,
0.1037468538,
0.3554619551,
0.1787493676,
0.2521877289,
-0.4895438552,
-0.231724605,
0.0435658842,
-0.3369740248,
-0.0846598297,
-0.0795205235,
-0.141782701,
-0.2690322101,
0.8284533024,
-0.1838413328,
0.2264655828,
0.443657428,
-0.3339145184,
0.0765654072,
0.1148286238,
0.3268152773,
0.3828009367,
-0.3866853714,
0.1579429656,
0.26653108,
-0.4929319024,
0.1601950824,
0.4550135732,
0.0363957472,
0.00279973,
0.1533623934,
0.8878222108,
0.1650230736,
-0.6900110245,
0.1748663634,
-0.3340878785,
-0.2046354711,
0.0291831326,
-0.110502094,
-0.1507129669,
0.0745023489,
0.2420486808,
0.179100737,
0.2310655117,
-0.318651557,
0.1218703166,
0.3137616515,
-0.2513559163,
-0.2871617973,
0.808643043,
0.1989915669,
0.0154567128,
0.7996953726,
0.1414572448,
-0.1841703802,
0.3223795295,
0.556400001,
0.7751690149,
-0.336574167,
0.0492167622,
0.3217659593,
0.437289983,
-0.2446084619,
-0.0831022263,
-0.4381538928,
-0.651043117,
-0.7949296832,
-0.8446236849,
-0.0729058683,
0.0686126277,
-0.7589170933,
0.1004007384,
-0.2746393681,
-0.1319850832,
-0.051320415,
0.0067453077,
-0.8450264335,
-0.3275243342,
-0.0356950983,
1.1069209576,
-0.8755556941,
1.0394850969,
0.9131659269,
-0.3532699049,
-0.7875763178,
-0.2454029769,
-0.4299019575,
-0.6951445937,
0.7664326429,
-0.2063952833,
-0.002200084,
0.2105546892,
-0.3724035919,
-0.7434788346,
0.780772984,
0.7470034361,
-0.4336928725,
-0.2177880406,
-0.2986692488,
0.5251820683,
-0.0743353665,
0.039977584,
0.5148221254,
0.2653267682,
0.311325103,
-1.1499797106,
-0.0653334707,
-0.09732645,
0.115404129,
0.2458154112,
-0.4826217592,
0.8495880365,
-0.1581923515,
-0.1395460814,
0.5336867571,
0.7581749558,
0.1888985336,
-0.3635434806,
0.4941695035,
0.729432106,
0.7178032398,
-0.0194144659,
1.0298471451,
-0.0658031926,
0.2801362872,
1.1963070631,
-0.3473983407,
1.0071082115,
0.639844358,
-0.3043106794,
0.4087050259,
0.2654580474,
0.2835436463,
0.7505556941,
0.1896033883,
-0.1541807652,
-0.2560589612,
-0.1437790841,
-0.2293850183,
0.2438563555,
0.3459595442,
-0.0296190381,
-0.356248796,
0.2355019152,
0.1704687625,
0.1694712192,
-0.1218321398,
0.9425883293,
-0.0554294549,
-0.7405592799,
1.1176121235,
-0.0395406224,
0.6106170416,
-0.7625319362,
-0.3071351945,
-0.1260246485,
0.2006090134,
0.1674601138,
-0.6617226601,
0.3738764822,
0.051652018,
-0.0695147067,
-0.6125480533,
0.7470638752,
-0.6122102141,
-0.2645778358,
-0.1650212258,
0.5441679955,
0.4420330822,
-0.0820852742,
-0.9257459044,
0.106996201,
0.1211911365,
-0.2831664383,
0.368960917,
0.5762901902,
0.1117865071,
0.7238493562,
0.7558435798,
0.3752306402,
0.3400820494,
-0.1592712104,
0.9685840607,
-0.0827087834,
-0.4260748029,
-0.5420388579,
0.2605373561,
0.0457972959,
-0.310229212,
0.6850462556,
0.4979306757,
0.6214735508,
-0.0979263783,
0.6434285641,
-0.5010114908,
0.6194251776,
-0.6040517688,
0.5743139386,
-0.2929916084,
0.3314658403,
0.1203681529,
-0.8871226907,
-0.1559087038,
0.8788005114,
-0.0060857562,
-0.074615784,
0.436822325,
0.6448395848,
-0.1592791378,
-0.3471670151,
0.2722087204,
0.3333415985,
0.1725982875,
0.7822506428,
0.7466493249,
-0.5795980096,
0.9280330539,
-0.2378714979,
-0.1678065062,
-0.1224514917,
-0.8560984731,
-0.9004984498,
-0.8638961315,
-0.3169396818,
-0.3268237412,
0.4348593056,
0.6811015606,
1.0732980967,
-0.5400849581,
-0.2146648616,
-0.0797712877,
0.0667648315,
-0.4767484665,
-0.1941246688,
0.4720391035,
-0.276983887,
-0.9499085546,
0.3604469597,
-0.1678707153,
0.1948738545,
-0.1600697488,
-0.1385735273,
-0.3097310662,
-0.0818379447,
0.4090718925,
0.5241174102,
-0.3830827475,
-0.0162339397,
-0.1867927164,
0.0585078597,
0.0047777798,
0.7733335495,
-1.1069331169,
0.1904285997,
0.5569570661,
0.654833138,
0.4511968791,
0.1435777545,
0.5300525427,
-0.9924558401,
0.512906909,
0.3773362637,
0.2556291521,
0.3651604652,
-0.2484876215,
0.5079168677,
-0.0447961986,
-0.5394976735,
-1.1069946289,
-0.0200611707,
-0.8014832139,
-0.5374126434,
1.1091483831,
-0.3048088551,
-0.447696209,
-0.1990952641,
-0.4945851862,
0.3466242552,
-0.3187589645,
0.7572767735,
0.3306997418,
-0.1817373782,
-0.1512696445,
-0.5657083392,
0.8195787668,
0.5138258934,
-0.7557404041,
0.2621960938,
0.4774407446,
0.4370705485,
-0.0436965078,
0.541985929,
-0.0385438576,
0.0525778979,
-0.137537986,
0.1130846217,
-0.362990737,
-0.5641699433,
-0.4058897495,
0.2714701295,
0.3102864623,
-0.1913328767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01003v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01003v1 | QUADRo: Dataset and Models for QUestion-Answer Database Retrieval | 2023-03-30T00:42:07 | 2023-03-30T00:42:07 | Stefano Campese, Ivano Lauriola, Alessandro Moschitti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | An effective paradigm for building Automated Question Answering systems is
the re-use of previously answered questions, e.g., for FAQs or forum
applications. Given a database (DB) of question/answer (q/a) pairs, it is
possible to answer a target question by scanning the DB for similar questions.
In this paper, we scale this approach to open domain, making it competitive
with other standard methods, e.g., unstructured document or graph based. For
this purpose, we (i) build a large scale DB of 6.3M q/a pairs, using public
questions, (ii) design a new system based on neural IR and a q/a pair reranker,
and (iii) construct training and test data to perform comparative experiments
with our models. We demonstrate that Transformer-based models using (q,a) pairs
outperform models only based on question representation, for both neural search
and reranking. Additionally, we show that our DB-based approach is competitive
with Web-based methods, i.e., a QA system built on top the BING search engine,
demonstrating the challenge of finding relevant information. Finally, we make
our data and models available for future research. | [
-0.6275366545,
-0.6625313759,
0.4556836486,
-0.1614871472,
0.0998141095,
0.1978216469,
0.1459710151,
-0.3365447223,
0.4201991856,
0.6234321594,
-0.1898412555,
-0.3108820021,
-0.1178461388,
0.2461239547,
-0.6696502566,
0.6904987693,
0.1745533645,
0.1635392755,
-0.7275060415,
-0.4743446708,
-0.2605465055,
-0.7475198507,
-0.6381912231,
-0.1679052263,
0.6739662886,
0.5489566326,
0.9977077842,
0.4653478861,
0.6317157745,
0.2132697999,
-0.0002885246,
0.1082563624,
-0.4710383415,
0.2208041549,
-0.1761223078,
-0.6253761053,
-0.4082870483,
0.0398736969,
0.4682004452,
0.6955894828,
-0.1306640655,
0.3479282558,
-0.4844063222,
0.5722640157,
-0.380425781,
-0.0216126163,
-0.5846493244,
-0.1483411491,
0.0995952114,
-0.0206826851,
-0.3247986138,
-0.9804180264,
0.0981668532,
-0.7604674697,
0.2841128409,
0.3875157237,
0.8094828725,
0.0567262769,
-0.5192648768,
-0.151988253,
-0.6975395083,
0.4665179551,
-0.4777464569,
0.4900263548,
0.2321216464,
0.7286000252,
0.1214932278,
-0.7894864678,
-0.6273609996,
0.0346014462,
-0.235716179,
-0.2264666855,
-0.222582534,
-0.1281395257,
0.1885094941,
0.5245902538,
-0.6877658963,
-0.2044189423,
-0.462225467,
0.2225704491,
0.6569757462,
0.3472588658,
0.2609636784,
-0.2204056531,
-0.2065701038,
-0.1497698128,
-0.791416049,
0.0183762535,
0.1287631691,
0.0776799098,
0.5079997778,
0.8355499506,
-0.3802869618,
0.6527606845,
0.138349846,
0.5047530532,
0.1169592589,
-0.3702383637,
-0.0666423962,
-0.440256983,
0.6727311015,
0.3960110843,
0.2369321585,
-0.631500423,
-0.2726217806,
-0.1441181153,
0.4939491153,
-0.775552392,
-0.242292434,
0.3678516448,
-0.4270979166,
-0.268977195,
-0.1201001555,
-0.9531243443,
-0.2419458032,
-0.3136338294,
0.9365726709,
-0.2930178642,
-0.3571234941,
0.082275264,
-0.175048098,
0.5530833602,
0.0056203953,
-0.621607244,
0.747089386,
0.6332606077,
0.7225123644,
0.0289463513,
0.1070518047,
-0.3815065324,
-0.2633149326,
-0.274184227,
0.8778146505,
-0.3891806304,
-0.3022987545,
0.1093906388,
-0.0474508405,
-0.0820482969,
-0.7441408038,
0.4442661107,
-1.4522634745,
0.3759801984,
-0.4247732162,
-0.5170211196,
-0.2156508267,
0.345046103,
-0.9575259089,
0.922280252,
0.3107450306,
-0.7422742248,
0.0226114448,
-0.6359599829,
-0.2229111046,
0.0975425169,
-0.1514577121,
-0.4701109827,
-0.0328487568,
0.2460618168,
0.1013412625,
-0.7929522991,
-0.027505219,
-0.1879251301,
-0.5798265934,
0.2610340416,
0.1151910499,
0.8900846243,
0.0289075132,
0.0670362711,
-0.066666536,
-0.5787861347,
0.4551228583,
0.2042448819,
-0.2422565967,
-0.5475566387,
-0.0236073956,
-0.2738217711,
0.2258260697,
0.3498300314,
-0.8647384644,
0.3272664249,
-0.3013237417,
0.3643973768,
0.269434154,
0.1389320046,
0.4215661287,
-0.5679918528,
0.7219141126,
-0.1029617414,
0.4274367988,
0.0693161488,
-0.3434146345,
-0.6758435369,
0.0799028277,
0.5127132535,
0.5147475004,
-0.7390047312,
0.2066641152,
-0.4561162293,
-0.4930404127,
-0.9678348303,
-0.2645541728,
0.2456880063,
0.5606608987,
0.6059425473,
-0.1507292539,
-0.4630208611,
-1.1003377438,
0.003769828,
-0.0895431936,
-0.2559924722,
0.6716563702,
0.4248895347,
0.1588683575,
1.0719857216,
-0.8767876029,
-0.0267730244,
0.0531638414,
0.0638183728,
0.2518140972,
-0.0058089467,
0.5029187799,
-1.2979513407,
-0.4517913759,
-0.2652931511,
-0.9453204274,
0.0463536829,
0.4906569719,
-0.2040427029,
-0.0319856852,
0.3135365844,
-0.5643838048,
0.2055951953,
0.1281277835,
-0.1147592217,
0.3657796681,
-0.1833225489,
0.5911890268,
-1.0502836704,
0.3599837124,
-0.1125112996,
-0.14348194,
-0.6602061391,
0.1331221163,
0.2432403862,
-0.3294442296,
-0.2518815994,
0.252348721,
-0.3130865693,
-0.3590014279,
-0.1504621506,
0.2639878094,
0.1185538769,
0.5331785083,
-0.0914121047,
1.0211840868,
0.2249711901,
-0.4435421824,
0.643945694,
0.5838761926,
-0.1197487488,
0.6487206817,
-1.1851956844,
0.4485832453,
-0.3476659954,
-0.0017962662,
-1.154494524,
-0.0194449332,
-0.1177117005,
-0.7963460684,
-0.0841460228,
-0.2274101675,
-0.5700656176,
-0.6646600962,
-0.270450294,
0.5633984804,
0.5124880075,
-0.6480264664,
0.5888860226,
0.5551542044,
-0.1579603702,
-0.5147990584,
-0.140528217,
-0.0558076166,
-0.0751965418,
-0.890078187,
0.2999558449,
-0.0816588178,
-0.2910339534,
0.3185191751,
-0.0227357708,
-0.5882086158,
-0.0525526814,
0.0605791919,
0.3303160965,
-0.5735269189,
0.2773593664,
-0.1258323193,
0.0319882147,
0.2809182703,
-0.1593196988,
0.4595591724,
-0.1861479729,
-0.0297742076,
-0.0608878434,
0.7852724195,
0.9010383487,
-0.7224892974,
0.7687930465,
-0.1896059066,
-0.4348574281,
0.0521103106,
-0.484351635,
-0.2332046777,
-0.4466477334,
0.0116536096,
-0.396738261,
-0.8246102333,
0.5972015858,
0.0794299692,
0.1181491688,
0.3295261562,
0.4111085832,
-0.1805043966,
1.1758545637,
0.6062366962,
-0.0923816562,
0.2390973419,
-0.3812372088,
0.2442616224,
-0.774087131,
-0.3334564865,
-0.8551266789,
-0.3512502909,
-0.4236863256,
-0.269936502,
0.6472343802,
-0.1308250278,
-0.3911684155,
0.4311608672,
-0.5481492281,
0.4809476137,
0.8593024611,
0.1365295053,
0.5103200674,
-0.1364526004,
0.0915991664,
0.2414889485,
-0.6446185112,
-0.3303999901,
1.4130767584,
-0.0629715472,
0.6613516212,
0.1845077276,
0.4554284215,
0.2972619534,
0.2371498942,
-0.6400611997,
0.4964966178,
-0.0313320085,
-0.8977127075,
-0.5461833477,
-0.4766875207,
-0.8423004746,
0.3874969482,
-0.2715477943,
-0.2563555241,
0.3093456328,
-0.219874382,
-0.5139940977,
0.2988683879,
-0.6100130081,
0.7448329329,
-0.0912489817,
-0.226930216,
-0.1256754845,
-0.780169785,
0.1041119173,
-0.0993554443,
-0.0189828668,
0.2447936684,
-0.0137446299,
0.7839096785,
-0.2613024712,
0.2749673724,
-0.1254810244,
0.2722153664,
0.4361252785,
-0.0454924144,
0.1107403934,
0.1399009824,
-0.3129447103,
-0.1601474732,
0.2809920907,
-0.470459789,
-1.0437731743,
0.6877753139,
-1.0476483107,
-0.6460852623,
-0.2614963949,
-0.5091311932,
-0.3224214315,
0.3332085013,
-0.0219481438,
0.5096712112,
-0.2724659145,
0.5383042097,
0.9895502925,
0.0165547282,
-0.0960354283,
0.7725645304,
-0.157994777,
-0.5625253916,
0.5879551172,
0.1824093759,
0.1567204148,
0.6916879416,
-0.0319092236,
-0.4983696342,
-0.3400086761,
-0.3805651367,
0.4535347819,
-0.3230047524,
-0.4945600331,
-0.6703057885,
-0.2673325837,
-0.5070739388,
0.0765060112,
-0.1623715758,
-0.6140941978,
-0.0145066297,
-0.0206570402,
0.3887307942,
0.7341120243,
0.1586258411,
0.0547244549,
-0.6461926103,
0.5010041595,
0.4959123433,
0.5197617412,
-0.056883812,
-0.2845553458,
-0.2653388977,
0.1823203713,
-0.1811927557,
-1.0706912279,
0.2347078323,
-0.1386891603,
0.5461401939,
-0.3266738057,
0.3501229584,
0.1121498048,
-0.3073065877,
0.4568563402,
-0.2563473582,
-0.5196400881,
0.5302223563,
-0.3550557494,
-0.0440454818,
0.7498898506,
0.9022733569,
-0.7280570865,
-0.0518522151,
-0.6246766448,
-0.7733465433,
0.5411913991,
0.0773530975,
-0.0748768374,
0.0524757989,
0.8000843525,
-0.2129798234,
0.3838869631,
-0.3731960356,
-0.297162056,
-0.1889645308,
-0.2470277697,
0.100938879,
-0.0181734227,
-0.0951532423,
-0.1156175882,
0.5365687013,
-0.196948126,
0.457788825,
0.2269976288,
-0.0185343437,
-0.164131999,
0.1526378989,
-0.0606673993,
0.4495098889,
-0.4004129767,
-0.0434203818,
0.0336134806,
-0.3039732277,
0.355294168,
0.1560828984,
-0.4850836098,
-0.0847855657,
-0.2681634128,
0.3438373208,
0.0641227737,
-0.5629315376,
0.579290092,
-0.2995590568,
-0.1965299696,
-0.2861617208,
-0.0609052926,
0.2109928876,
0.2917524278,
0.5149129033,
-0.3507766128,
0.2178965807,
-0.4640560746,
0.5423123837,
0.3642836809,
-0.311624974,
-0.2094023228,
0.7525761724,
0.1769344658,
-0.622878015,
1.0175554752,
0.1267369986,
-0.4707337022,
0.8351401091,
0.3908427656,
0.4583648443,
-0.2098204494,
0.3318117261,
0.3904180825,
0.080715619,
0.0298668966,
0.5706401467,
0.0530776605,
-0.6084310412,
-0.0025012409,
-0.336454004,
-0.6721340418,
-0.0788943917,
-0.8562403917,
0.1614132971,
-0.4694746137,
-0.0474039875,
0.1767918169,
0.3048829138,
-0.5684964061,
0.4112776816,
-0.4078569412,
0.9043052197,
-0.6626240015,
0.6910646558,
0.8798788786,
-0.9511732459,
-0.5978059769,
-0.2513119578,
-0.4062015712,
-0.6761040092,
0.5520957708,
-0.2702088058,
-0.0777370781,
0.2125291824,
-0.4262557328,
-1.1111347675,
1.2944384813,
-0.058410801,
-0.2077543437,
-0.5089788437,
0.2107669264,
0.8089985251,
-0.293048054,
0.418851763,
0.431330353,
0.1396637857,
0.2266835272,
-0.7242075205,
0.0035099252,
-0.2224186063,
-0.2390038818,
0.5497261882,
-0.8201752305,
0.9015173912,
-0.2312348634,
-0.1005936041,
0.2160724849,
0.7852057219,
-0.024605142,
0.2243908495,
0.4580206573,
0.4498017728,
0.7171176076,
0.0125462357,
0.8009071946,
-0.3983925283,
0.4593189955,
0.9675704837,
-0.3407976031,
1.1511745453,
0.2649781704,
-0.1044901311,
0.4677239954,
0.3478172421,
-0.064493522,
0.4223070741,
0.3977959752,
-0.3780920208,
-0.343755275,
-0.1346016079,
-0.2111991644,
0.2304855734,
0.19535999,
-0.2178630084,
-0.2597235441,
-0.1978408992,
-0.227891311,
0.2857730985,
-0.1603277624,
0.5786256194,
-0.0770212933,
-0.6890103221,
0.5422894359,
-0.0385202095,
0.367738694,
-0.2808205187,
0.0200061612,
-0.6411387324,
0.1027875319,
-0.0520584285,
-0.8645553589,
0.3750527501,
-0.0150617547,
-0.3056618571,
0.0700652525,
0.5882617235,
-0.3453377783,
-0.3321405053,
0.17456761,
0.8217515349,
-0.0726070628,
-0.0802604184,
-0.4511455595,
-0.4288794696,
-0.2897658646,
-0.1872460246,
0.2240274101,
0.4336849153,
-0.1676554084,
0.7267546654,
0.3407076597,
-0.2990919352,
0.1565302163,
-0.0925844163,
1.0968264341,
-0.69262743,
-0.1964881867,
-0.0439460278,
0.0535483323,
-0.2810046077,
-0.1080213189,
0.6157598495,
0.9232183695,
0.6349082589,
0.2600323856,
0.6034892201,
-0.1282424033,
0.9955791235,
0.0530653521,
0.6681439281,
-0.717400074,
-0.0401944332,
0.1429422647,
-0.7451938987,
-0.3082849085,
0.3928503096,
-0.2547912598,
-0.0723547637,
0.5166684985,
0.9078471065,
0.0067233429,
0.3549434841,
0.2480883449,
0.181471467,
0.370829165,
0.7302615047,
0.7224898934,
-0.7057477236,
0.8559629321,
-0.0903119743,
-0.2696787715,
-0.1932552308,
-0.1423989236,
-0.6684286594,
-0.6085032821,
-0.1502875537,
-0.3643470407,
0.2918711305,
0.5989248157,
0.5054126382,
-0.6126018167,
-0.31429106,
0.2660272419,
0.2699503303,
-0.1198221371,
-0.1776727587,
0.407784909,
-0.1590078771,
-0.5046868324,
0.2175304592,
-0.104188554,
-0.1303453147,
-0.3490434885,
0.3858931363,
-0.4223383069,
0.3211738467,
0.4980319142,
0.424107492,
-0.1044954509,
-0.4728437662,
0.8875638247,
-0.2650281787,
0.3511196375,
0.8720408082,
-1.0393849611,
0.1572745442,
0.9144323468,
0.6781196594,
0.5394083858,
0.2741958499,
0.7103189826,
-0.3694898188,
-0.6060569882,
0.5339153409,
0.0763928816,
0.2139823437,
-0.3055762351,
0.5810284615,
0.0935804695,
-0.7995460629,
-0.5282974839,
0.1474440992,
-0.8060339093,
-0.2752621472,
0.8824887276,
0.0358760767,
-0.2798606455,
-0.3268771768,
-0.1661438197,
0.1709455401,
-0.213402465,
0.8605630994,
0.4192883372,
-0.2836304903,
0.0021832716,
-0.3090793788,
0.191194132,
0.1788041294,
-0.8468598723,
0.1079818681,
0.6433160305,
0.4750960767,
0.250665307,
0.6863091588,
-0.3813044727,
0.4283897281,
-0.0487949513,
0.0392288826,
-0.1324298382,
-0.5256437063,
-0.3868695498,
0.7185793519,
0.0439543612,
-0.3246747255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17071v1 | DERA: Enhancing Large Language Model Completions with Dialog-Enabled Resolving Agents | 2023-03-30T00:30:19 | 2023-03-30T00:30:19 | Varun Nair, Elliot Schumacher, Geoffrey Tso, Anitha Kannan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as valuable tools for many natural
language understanding tasks. In safety-critical applications such as
healthcare, the utility of these models is governed by their ability to
generate outputs that are factually accurate and complete. In this work, we
present dialog-enabled resolving agents (DERA). DERA is a paradigm made
possible by the increased conversational abilities of LLMs, namely GPT-4. It
provides a simple, interpretable forum for models to communicate feedback and
iteratively improve output. We frame our dialog as a discussion between two
agent types - a Researcher, who processes information and identifies crucial
problem components, and a Decider, who has the autonomy to integrate the
Researcher's information and makes judgments on the final output.
We test DERA against three clinically-focused tasks. For medical conversation
summarization and care plan generation, DERA shows significant improvement over
the base GPT-4 performance in both human expert preference evaluations and
quantitative metrics. In a new finding, we also show that GPT-4's performance
(70%) on an open-ended version of the MedQA question-answering (QA) dataset
(Jin et al. 2021, USMLE) is well above the passing level (60%), with DERA
showing similar performance. We release the open-ended MEDQA dataset at
https://github.com/curai/curai-research/tree/main/DERA. | [
-0.2282718122,
-0.6719992757,
1.0570939779,
-0.305934608,
-0.1458078921,
0.3027277887,
-0.2280240506,
-0.625202477,
0.2617585957,
0.5491467714,
-0.2555782199,
-0.6103014946,
-0.5831395388,
0.2526160777,
-0.0946548283,
0.9413678646,
0.0166823361,
0.0465582572,
-0.2047044486,
-0.1732022464,
-0.5638420582,
-0.6380183101,
-0.965613544,
-0.4356260896,
0.6996887326,
0.2905543149,
0.8671478033,
0.5087858438,
0.5978783965,
0.4581986964,
0.0222419724,
0.3007796705,
-0.3428842425,
0.4698070884,
-0.1850885153,
-0.5176214576,
-1.0021592379,
-0.0193673633,
0.42357108,
0.6104453206,
-0.2942315638,
-0.0207681824,
-0.1715775728,
0.7637261152,
-0.1847891062,
0.3804138601,
-0.5866689086,
-0.0521858186,
-0.0100670997,
-0.3418896496,
-0.4891741574,
-0.3604706526,
0.4004287422,
-0.5417960286,
0.1767692417,
-0.332986623,
0.8760482669,
0.4910078049,
-0.6083315611,
-0.3261983395,
-0.7025719881,
0.3200513124,
-1.0899145603,
0.1687494665,
0.4013491869,
0.4114930332,
-0.1902321875,
-0.7702143192,
-0.39901492,
-0.3208568096,
-0.1179350168,
0.2672134936,
-0.1897521019,
0.4700532556,
0.3462339044,
0.3335887492,
-0.4848804474,
0.0012169334,
-0.2398384809,
-0.2582322955,
0.3197182417,
0.2371405959,
0.1658702791,
0.1059751213,
0.247716099,
0.3005826473,
-0.6787790656,
-0.2927741408,
-0.223430559,
0.2611823976,
-0.0802048594,
0.3865899444,
-0.2806633413,
0.8220123053,
0.1501092911,
-0.2278247178,
0.3607484698,
-0.3106127381,
-0.215559572,
-0.2511261404,
0.5964591503,
0.5038406849,
0.0772796348,
-0.1819720119,
-0.1957333237,
-0.0263081733,
0.4580447376,
-0.8809527755,
-0.216417402,
0.3930755556,
-0.2308665961,
-0.2868824005,
-0.4940418899,
-0.6113625765,
-0.4690963626,
-0.5156510472,
0.2863707244,
-0.1562631577,
-0.2122559696,
0.0291133989,
0.288731128,
0.0975857154,
0.7111300826,
-0.6706901193,
0.3877762258,
0.4843661487,
0.8955757022,
0.1821064949,
0.1462860554,
-0.8502979875,
0.1106381044,
-0.4506624341,
0.8231444359,
-0.5200806856,
-0.2038852274,
0.0399701037,
-0.1612551212,
-0.1714500636,
-0.6411068439,
0.5084952712,
-0.6455467939,
0.4255675673,
-0.4052810967,
-0.4110604525,
-0.3385980725,
0.5215791464,
-0.6732956767,
0.5505980253,
0.1657040119,
-0.5417810678,
0.2231993675,
-0.8031120896,
-0.1103131026,
0.1707552075,
-0.3630906641,
-0.2284644991,
-0.0721973926,
0.214347586,
0.4507496059,
-0.5148881674,
0.3989360332,
0.0124963932,
-0.0935673267,
0.2047341764,
-0.3062871993,
0.0884664059,
0.1163369045,
-0.373762697,
0.4536376894,
-0.5797846317,
-0.0557143725,
0.043904271,
-0.3588573933,
-0.0580634475,
-0.1746531874,
-0.3752394617,
0.3856970072,
0.3896690309,
-0.3609544337,
0.1130939499,
-0.4074979722,
0.55557549,
0.7117618918,
-0.0759365037,
0.2257728875,
-0.5787427425,
0.5933327675,
-0.0478747003,
0.1200837493,
0.0381865092,
-0.6844030619,
-0.7013767958,
-0.2885945439,
0.350690186,
0.4098418951,
-0.9059045911,
0.0673462972,
-0.3641268015,
-0.2792912722,
-0.5269126296,
-0.135595426,
0.3767661154,
0.864338398,
0.2823936045,
-0.3610904217,
-0.2582757473,
-0.7050594687,
0.0842836872,
-0.4984929562,
-0.2020950317,
0.5827139616,
0.0454935767,
-0.396794647,
0.8141876459,
-0.4598138332,
-0.4255937934,
-0.2685884535,
0.0879890397,
0.2757233083,
0.1153782234,
0.4379401505,
-0.6489123106,
-0.5189297199,
0.1684232503,
-0.7555914521,
-0.2341747284,
0.040178474,
0.004782042,
0.3546321094,
0.0849238113,
-0.8021993637,
0.3996815681,
0.5791302919,
-0.42722857,
0.4913205802,
-0.4829883873,
0.4215598404,
-1.1791855097,
0.188333869,
-0.1572678387,
-0.5826753378,
-0.9034820795,
-0.1463178992,
-0.2220306695,
-0.0264418032,
-0.11178606,
0.3781662881,
-0.273006022,
0.0077614198,
-0.3465273976,
0.4012553692,
0.0612799935,
0.4537797272,
0.0201128609,
0.9047111273,
0.3637358248,
-0.345523119,
0.3191187084,
0.4580057859,
0.1975803524,
0.4010084867,
-0.7393038869,
0.4061704278,
0.0935167819,
0.3337442577,
-0.7260754108,
-0.4419514239,
0.3474926353,
-0.4194351733,
0.3871752322,
-0.1671303809,
-0.3395119905,
-0.2143731415,
-0.107381165,
0.463185221,
0.4738651812,
-0.2109854519,
0.9098305106,
0.4852343202,
-0.515605092,
-0.4299340546,
-0.3137219548,
0.4359259903,
-0.1010413617,
-0.499794364,
0.2061992586,
-0.1847098619,
-0.2859277725,
-0.125915274,
-0.123609826,
-0.2534980774,
-0.1614524722,
0.1600643992,
0.3632239997,
-0.2550384104,
0.2109159827,
-0.0472855717,
-0.2254236042,
0.1632829607,
0.1194983125,
0.4694314003,
-0.2669404447,
-0.3622509241,
-0.5368571877,
0.2961646914,
0.888499558,
-0.2592504621,
0.5119863153,
0.2157462388,
-0.357059747,
0.2932421863,
-0.8041710258,
-0.4574008882,
-0.4546481967,
0.1764725894,
-0.5461514592,
-1.0447384119,
0.7914446592,
-0.1385710537,
0.313500315,
0.4228011072,
0.7176519036,
0.1945219487,
1.0112694502,
0.3885192275,
-0.02692095,
0.1653619856,
-0.122717768,
0.2482496947,
-0.7042683959,
-0.1238938272,
-0.4932934046,
0.1138375923,
-0.4811404645,
-0.5772873163,
0.5710313916,
-0.3937093019,
-0.0681193769,
0.0627739504,
-0.5476247072,
0.220523864,
0.4010741115,
0.2461236119,
0.6398953199,
-0.3156755567,
0.0364341103,
0.1163192093,
-0.5842900872,
-0.7028381228,
1.051907897,
0.6040018201,
0.4652975798,
0.2168136239,
0.5437940359,
0.258693248,
0.5042303205,
-0.7941784859,
0.5423700809,
0.0078203436,
-0.3425736725,
-0.2574575245,
-0.6667116284,
-0.8482977748,
0.3354741633,
0.0907989368,
-0.559856832,
-0.0651208609,
0.1570102423,
-0.5849999785,
0.1969599426,
-0.5519834757,
0.7552867532,
0.0831135362,
-0.1005773321,
-0.448066324,
-0.7094351053,
0.1901434064,
-0.2062542737,
-0.0447785668,
-0.3381851614,
-0.057794407,
0.6600323319,
-0.5121144056,
0.9522451162,
-0.1704628617,
-0.4474328756,
0.113522321,
0.0178344324,
0.5263963342,
0.0697510093,
-0.1058145091,
0.1882570088,
0.0960412174,
-0.3343834579,
-0.6854214072,
0.6135081649,
-0.6587091088,
-0.7986490726,
-0.4590385556,
-0.7794476151,
-0.4080929756,
0.1649319679,
-0.1371902376,
0.9400704503,
-0.0565147176,
-0.3411931992,
0.5669155717,
-0.1472388804,
0.0168149285,
0.896412313,
-0.1494220346,
-0.3154791594,
0.6043831706,
0.1303275973,
0.4493804276,
0.2763124108,
0.058439482,
-0.3570952415,
-0.8305982947,
-0.5633051991,
0.5820777416,
-0.7888784409,
-0.4552267194,
-0.7021894455,
-0.451777488,
-0.2232687324,
-0.044703126,
-0.1768018305,
-0.4234741032,
-0.226648584,
-0.1557735056,
0.4659426212,
1.1361474991,
-0.0327824801,
0.1168512478,
-0.9285950661,
0.3083337545,
0.4342653155,
0.2623476684,
-0.1470120102,
-0.5776940584,
-0.2285303026,
0.161809206,
-0.3334139884,
-0.8627247214,
0.3561259806,
0.0364995971,
0.2675893307,
0.3813892007,
0.1598391384,
0.4677065611,
-0.6319274902,
0.6518033743,
0.1040173471,
-0.7293788195,
0.4375733733,
-0.6296674013,
0.319938153,
0.5959559679,
0.0076711243,
-0.5652126074,
-0.7771490216,
-0.4404440522,
-0.6183966398,
0.5250192881,
0.2919641137,
-0.0589436479,
0.0262432918,
0.4028657079,
-0.0064546852,
0.1291031539,
-0.3176645041,
-0.0907234177,
0.1481478214,
-0.2572450042,
0.1063112766,
-0.4472990632,
-0.4782864153,
0.0051688976,
0.6169716716,
-0.3569495976,
0.2577611506,
0.4380619228,
0.1143282503,
-0.1498484462,
0.4794092178,
0.5808451176,
1.0215101242,
-0.3865406811,
0.1341277659,
0.1597677022,
-0.496437043,
0.1852851957,
0.3945028782,
-0.0183227621,
0.0566982962,
0.3086278439,
0.4397813082,
-0.1116230264,
-0.7080945373,
0.3825026751,
-0.4323711991,
-0.1490779966,
-0.0633639097,
-0.0779952779,
0.0021003759,
0.2992953956,
0.2012514174,
0.0860297605,
0.4145977199,
-0.3682129383,
0.3472878933,
0.2244951129,
-0.4398008883,
-0.4258295298,
0.5495420694,
0.5849738121,
-0.1510058492,
0.5341630578,
-0.126173988,
-0.5676583648,
0.5270295143,
0.3154388964,
0.8499984145,
-0.2386891097,
0.4386968315,
0.1944188923,
0.0568953268,
0.1209504753,
0.343108803,
0.0474845581,
-0.7087723017,
-0.8945581317,
-0.1761116832,
-0.7967686057,
0.1426829547,
-0.496884048,
-0.2416059077,
-0.2492531538,
-0.4822987318,
0.008974879,
0.2180465609,
-0.5495251417,
0.0076922774,
-0.1048912108,
0.7067403793,
-0.4752072394,
0.7114782333,
0.6242366433,
-0.4513029456,
-0.9369942546,
0.028835319,
0.0458218381,
-0.5319147706,
0.4537693858,
0.2077081054,
-0.1465467066,
-0.0909717754,
-0.1000734717,
-0.7307412028,
1.0431661606,
0.5985441208,
-0.5682153106,
-0.2064762264,
0.2522355318,
0.7645634413,
-0.3455674946,
0.5804200768,
0.7366155982,
0.3473828435,
0.1407720298,
-1.4812047482,
0.4075567722,
-0.2118398845,
-0.2936934233,
0.1425334215,
-0.5721162558,
0.3906432688,
-0.4174718857,
-0.0751731917,
0.2373430878,
0.3996779621,
0.2626441121,
0.4002480507,
0.482317239,
0.570012629,
0.9291417003,
-0.1504385322,
0.9393758774,
-0.3003470302,
0.1117971465,
1.1253570318,
-0.4075790346,
0.515604198,
0.0683446229,
-0.1159233823,
0.4906976223,
0.5733195543,
0.5096287727,
0.2844868004,
-0.017003879,
-0.6663445234,
-0.1901130378,
-0.4732846916,
-0.4391157627,
0.2986025214,
0.4006541967,
-0.298006475,
-0.2224870175,
-0.1349282265,
0.2411579788,
0.0068933209,
-0.1487439722,
1.1483315229,
0.1067719832,
-0.703995049,
0.6381849051,
-0.3836161494,
0.1008277833,
-0.5311037898,
-0.382068336,
-0.2639213204,
0.0508865528,
-0.1457498372,
-0.6158983707,
0.2723101974,
0.0313117541,
-0.3173506856,
-0.0722224936,
0.5886372328,
-0.5803874731,
-0.0637510493,
0.2941558361,
0.6436254382,
0.280828476,
-0.1273072064,
-0.7109562755,
-0.0136111844,
-0.0420025624,
-0.1789539158,
0.2318142802,
0.4828450382,
0.051078923,
0.7957602143,
0.4705792964,
0.2830605209,
-0.2465545684,
0.4683457613,
1.1842881441,
-0.4918292761,
-0.1627300233,
-0.5102592707,
0.2846900523,
-0.1656121314,
0.0698438361,
0.3456538916,
0.3967063427,
0.2994301617,
0.2104965001,
0.7696321011,
0.0434829965,
0.7575418353,
-0.4053258598,
0.6876382232,
-0.2338436395,
0.2803622782,
-0.0242390763,
-0.6012942195,
-0.2935555577,
0.3873158693,
-0.4492875636,
0.141373232,
0.6856366396,
0.7646735907,
0.3019857109,
-0.1973812431,
0.6100305319,
0.519133389,
0.8696312904,
0.6825736165,
0.7092167139,
-0.1831506491,
0.3470040262,
-0.1015155837,
-0.4774270952,
-0.0051690801,
-0.5965265632,
-1.0012431145,
-0.5447360873,
-0.3762043118,
-0.3914714158,
0.120654352,
0.8492926955,
0.7574297786,
-0.7406893373,
0.1014875174,
0.1452409029,
0.0666094348,
0.0530214496,
-0.1997314095,
0.4692031145,
-0.5876922011,
-0.6488012671,
0.4309103489,
0.4445387423,
-0.0404470414,
-0.1287627816,
-0.1290308535,
0.0692468882,
0.2037522346,
0.5563104749,
0.1915801615,
-0.7807902098,
-0.2801339626,
-0.1945735812,
-0.1112656295,
0.2559643388,
0.7568360567,
-0.8938676715,
0.6106452346,
0.2707448304,
0.7950963378,
0.3107081652,
0.1530466825,
0.9126967192,
-0.3371031582,
-0.2189245671,
0.4159161747,
0.3283038437,
0.3892978132,
-0.5608958602,
0.7358658314,
-0.0473233052,
-0.9492270947,
-0.5719048977,
0.1060829982,
-1.0373826027,
0.0445934236,
0.9576304555,
-0.2744813263,
0.1190270633,
-0.4099097848,
-0.5423879027,
0.3864954412,
-0.7261377573,
0.9151937962,
0.4072208107,
-0.2498040944,
-0.1040289477,
-0.7839817405,
0.7466748953,
0.4175109267,
-1.1792441607,
0.1410461068,
0.8081344366,
0.2112961113,
0.2116960734,
1.1668074131,
-0.1373240948,
0.3644837439,
-0.551589489,
-0.1187651828,
0.0313581899,
-0.2746216953,
-0.253426075,
0.1144974232,
0.3708061576,
-0.0943422392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17006v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17006v1 | How do decoding algorithms distribute information in dialogue responses? | 2023-03-29T20:21:45 | 2023-03-29T20:21:45 | Saranya Venkatraman, He He, David Reitter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans tend to follow the Uniform Information Density (UID) principle by
distributing information evenly in utterances. We study if decoding algorithms
implicitly follow this UID principle, and under what conditions adherence to
UID might be desirable for dialogue generation. We generate responses using
different decoding algorithms with GPT-2 on the Persona-Chat dataset and
collect human judgments on their quality using Amazon Mechanical Turk. We find
that (i) surprisingly, model-generated responses follow the UID principle to a
greater extent than human responses, and (ii) decoding algorithms that promote
UID do not generate higher-quality responses. Instead, when we control for
surprisal, non-uniformity of information density correlates with the quality of
responses with very low/high surprisal. Our findings indicate that encouraging
non-uniform responses is a potential solution to the ``likelihood trap''
problem (quality degradation in very high-likelihood text). Our dataset
containing multiple candidate responses per dialog history along with
human-annotated quality ratings is available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/saranya132/dialog_uid_gpt2. | [
-0.397957921,
-0.5883617401,
0.5020283461,
0.2142429352,
-0.3875458837,
-0.0991343111,
0.1462238878,
-0.2770264149,
0.1451238841,
0.6849899292,
-0.4690571129,
-0.3807223141,
-0.3922224343,
0.1373569518,
-0.3429479301,
1.1478797197,
0.3078279793,
0.2625963688,
-0.0887288302,
-0.1900227368,
-0.477026403,
-0.9934365153,
-0.4941037595,
-0.1016123816,
0.3215568662,
0.2909596264,
0.8101783395,
0.5351729989,
0.3020712137,
0.1839398295,
0.208047986,
0.1005062908,
-0.7619728446,
0.0575331673,
0.0271546356,
-0.5585286021,
0.007244572,
-0.0564206727,
0.6064812541,
0.910128653,
-0.410325855,
-0.0843764693,
0.5846969485,
0.6247110963,
-0.4379459023,
0.0559548214,
-0.2478301972,
-0.0233744103,
-0.1102652326,
-0.5854230523,
-0.7528087497,
-0.48823753,
0.1095846295,
-0.6102921963,
0.5254870057,
0.2388676256,
0.5737643838,
0.0446058512,
-0.3292542696,
-0.4780042768,
-0.8052862287,
0.645133853,
-0.457408607,
-0.0176699758,
0.7014394999,
-0.0604913682,
-0.5039809942,
-0.0482314453,
-0.4358786047,
-0.0499590151,
-0.149871096,
0.1342172474,
-0.0702826902,
0.3558576107,
0.1619540304,
0.2572990954,
-0.6794932485,
-0.1136444211,
-0.2477021962,
-0.0935250968,
0.7505094409,
0.372444272,
0.1456472576,
-0.0918375477,
-0.0479451604,
-0.4229230881,
-0.4315090477,
0.283739686,
0.5557928085,
0.001914957,
-0.0948721319,
0.6080738902,
-0.1457017511,
0.398955524,
0.208235845,
0.1492817253,
0.0091127045,
-0.4895563126,
-0.1208771914,
-0.0758313164,
0.8926614523,
0.5107412338,
0.1446145326,
-0.0690583065,
-0.1672903746,
0.0522279739,
0.3748302758,
-0.4838557541,
-0.2843369246,
0.077674523,
-0.7525767684,
-0.2546586394,
0.2898980975,
-0.7205460668,
-0.4469052255,
-0.1303022355,
0.2735741735,
-0.3609526455,
-0.2808303535,
0.170229122,
-0.3243658841,
0.2955422401,
0.2375195473,
-1.0689661503,
0.5227441788,
0.4698035121,
0.6155214906,
0.0906952918,
0.0974014327,
-0.4878277779,
-0.1439136714,
-0.6997260451,
0.7900308371,
-0.5752080679,
-0.5622336268,
0.0597242787,
-0.2195330262,
-0.087313287,
-0.5222684741,
0.6526580453,
-0.4410594106,
0.2015832365,
-0.5709139705,
-0.6007467508,
-0.0731539056,
-0.3004440367,
-0.6465989351,
0.6465162039,
0.2793011069,
-0.9066102505,
0.3390960991,
-0.4862572253,
-0.2166535258,
0.0408411548,
-0.3438505828,
-0.1774578094,
0.5814756751,
0.0321782902,
0.2402647883,
-0.2941923738,
0.0397166312,
-0.3711920083,
-0.6481865644,
0.6111774445,
-0.7506518364,
0.6533765197,
0.4694902301,
-0.2464652359,
-0.3801012337,
-0.332463026,
0.1336387396,
0.1511040479,
-0.3166536093,
-0.1837155521,
0.2553949654,
0.0394132063,
-0.1450461447,
-0.1701337695,
-0.398031503,
0.2395498157,
-0.2920018733,
0.3705488443,
0.9304773211,
0.2921857536,
0.4290472567,
-0.6393786669,
0.2942686081,
0.1519063264,
-0.0004823075,
-0.0778801963,
-0.6047210693,
-0.6049426198,
0.0783337951,
0.1918598711,
0.548663795,
-0.6690101027,
0.4140265882,
-0.2006135881,
-0.0643095151,
-0.7033277154,
0.1646868587,
0.6268547773,
0.2660978734,
0.0645419508,
-0.6288689971,
-0.3282541931,
-0.7798724174,
-0.2198991328,
-0.4795971513,
-0.2846630514,
0.4954018891,
0.0660753474,
-0.1547961682,
1.0032168627,
-0.2501803339,
0.0871185437,
-0.2497587353,
0.5002223849,
0.2166843414,
0.3564923704,
0.5330348611,
-0.7462108731,
-0.3747407198,
-0.2027223557,
-0.8327359557,
-0.1057555974,
-0.1641140282,
-0.3058948219,
0.459531337,
0.0829405189,
-0.6660029292,
0.6054838896,
0.4857758284,
-0.3064569235,
0.4895497859,
-0.2926555872,
0.4150621891,
-1.0331066847,
-0.1375956833,
0.0724110529,
-0.1700883061,
-0.6714023352,
-0.2853284478,
-0.3826086223,
0.1211346462,
0.0719485506,
0.2921684384,
-0.2174006701,
-0.2359733284,
-0.2153952718,
-0.2083167434,
0.1082298607,
0.6219589114,
0.1585023999,
0.9204668403,
0.0223346204,
-0.5891498327,
0.2600675225,
0.4310585856,
-0.4915714264,
0.8317081928,
-0.8346702456,
0.4367827177,
-0.5300210714,
0.6548970342,
-1.3500554562,
-0.5687057972,
0.3017428815,
-0.6042706966,
-0.0319012888,
-0.1413027495,
-0.6027846336,
-0.1434705555,
-0.3868925869,
0.5014419556,
0.8373612761,
-0.5227562785,
0.1406019181,
0.3369497955,
-0.3474532366,
-0.4053591192,
-0.5475178361,
-0.0405912176,
-0.0985488594,
-0.6777456403,
-0.086983107,
-0.5200593472,
-0.2534250617,
-0.1501959413,
0.0079722265,
-0.1980373114,
-0.2788475156,
0.2011310905,
0.0690985024,
-0.0628377944,
-0.0474835671,
0.0856075734,
-0.0240861773,
0.134699747,
-0.3739034235,
0.6133369207,
0.1397428811,
-0.3735133111,
-0.933714509,
0.733518362,
0.3833760321,
0.4073257744,
0.7263868451,
0.39555794,
-0.0044011888,
0.2041737735,
-0.6684984565,
-0.4232335687,
-0.4418341517,
0.0516367182,
-0.4975194931,
-0.6759557724,
0.5278906226,
0.2615229189,
0.1077495143,
0.2482993752,
0.4720280468,
-0.8223023415,
1.617770195,
0.4717723429,
-0.1936726719,
0.3548083305,
-0.1393817216,
0.014359951,
-0.7498919964,
-0.1263795793,
-0.6225405931,
-0.2172710896,
-0.6702582836,
-0.173446551,
0.3729175329,
0.3588825166,
-0.161292538,
-0.0035070276,
-0.6734222174,
0.3855440319,
0.8652108312,
0.172996521,
0.1750646085,
0.3075218797,
0.087835744,
-0.1373149902,
-0.7953614593,
-0.4624699056,
1.0870162249,
0.3197994232,
1.1172536612,
0.1507966816,
0.7733799815,
0.7096083164,
0.0323807113,
-0.2737747729,
0.3337984979,
-0.0084402235,
-0.178085655,
-0.3178718984,
-0.7882121205,
-1.209580183,
0.0707379505,
0.0212640669,
-0.7504329085,
0.3891846836,
0.1787817329,
-0.262201637,
-0.0532647446,
-0.8062422276,
0.5044611096,
0.1449157447,
0.0565157384,
-0.0589841567,
-0.7667661309,
0.2002103925,
0.2044138461,
0.2341996282,
-0.0413660631,
0.4238376915,
0.6186410785,
-0.4686574936,
0.7384272814,
-0.3258614242,
-0.1067949235,
0.5121331811,
0.1105128229,
0.6251357794,
0.3603796065,
0.1367835552,
0.1090617999,
0.2103221118,
-0.708799243,
-0.7421050072,
0.3061463535,
-1.2080276012,
-0.394166559,
-0.3021092415,
-0.4309713542,
0.0709088668,
-0.2726077437,
0.9296277761,
0.6155459881,
-0.1698290855,
0.2684169412,
1.0608532429,
-0.1637069732,
0.0733877942,
0.117516458,
0.3654851913,
-0.3227400184,
0.8967841268,
0.0215586498,
0.3464556038,
0.3811964691,
-0.0274353456,
-0.5674783587,
-0.3547445834,
-0.4569225013,
0.0213819109,
-0.5953478217,
-0.1591211557,
-0.5070159435,
-0.3055466413,
-0.4804822206,
-0.0720075294,
-0.0671819448,
-0.0959268957,
-0.1508170962,
0.0873880014,
0.2096573859,
0.8353886604,
-0.082540147,
0.2838729024,
-0.6343420744,
0.673844099,
0.2874760032,
0.2491729409,
-0.3788157403,
-0.5695053339,
-0.0409798473,
0.7278163433,
-0.0477649122,
-0.8560147882,
0.2574114501,
0.1617134362,
0.5256484747,
0.4331309497,
0.4661019444,
0.4025145173,
-0.2367951274,
0.7720344663,
0.1018392891,
-0.5976236463,
0.383882761,
-0.5579571128,
0.4023654759,
0.5683916807,
0.0103380196,
-0.767868042,
-0.6384730339,
-0.4799661934,
-0.3615147173,
0.9303024411,
0.4484013915,
0.6801640987,
-0.1732826084,
0.4716105461,
0.2093669027,
0.1435815394,
-0.512267828,
-0.1745195091,
-0.4555668831,
-0.3867928088,
-0.0060231639,
-0.5631074905,
-0.3629669249,
0.2228428125,
0.2179377824,
-0.0735775828,
0.9262139201,
0.2485910207,
0.0072718738,
-0.0248012394,
0.37000525,
0.600533843,
0.2461851537,
-0.2950170338,
-0.1420603096,
-0.2954684198,
-0.5273855329,
0.314756304,
-0.1959279925,
-0.21027641,
0.0181705505,
0.1534109712,
0.7771341801,
-0.1357378215,
-0.5730726719,
0.5729181767,
-0.5629897118,
-0.4300012589,
-0.1487787217,
0.3426010609,
-0.5035561323,
0.0315524824,
0.6926965714,
0.068670027,
0.4499568045,
-0.5828570127,
0.0220533889,
0.5143178105,
-0.0406870916,
-0.2804206312,
0.4855569005,
0.2423193455,
-0.3131934404,
1.141253233,
-0.3620890677,
-0.0542247854,
0.3734575808,
0.4434400201,
0.7284194827,
-0.2610773146,
0.5900485516,
0.220367223,
0.0654665902,
-0.3274260759,
0.3120168149,
-0.2230414301,
-0.6812312603,
-0.4035204947,
-0.5211376548,
-0.394423455,
0.1335055083,
-0.8582493663,
-0.2212888449,
-0.5320491195,
-0.1446740627,
-0.27560848,
-0.1076234728,
-0.6735036969,
-0.0084096137,
-0.0506813936,
0.3557083905,
-0.554756999,
0.4618518054,
0.14012523,
-0.3263290823,
-0.609503448,
0.1336071044,
0.03602878,
-0.572183609,
0.159986645,
0.1470625252,
-0.0696805641,
0.0408011451,
-0.7691531777,
-0.7601293325,
0.6523382068,
0.5015649199,
-0.3544132113,
-0.0190861486,
0.3678523004,
0.4440629184,
-0.3450049758,
0.3625875711,
0.6624599099,
0.1540364623,
0.1794802994,
-1.001919508,
-0.2722679377,
-0.5580094457,
0.3695154488,
0.051787734,
-0.4346576929,
0.4866013229,
-0.2305334806,
-0.4810244739,
0.5899781585,
0.3355155289,
0.3224009871,
0.2992218435,
0.1640757322,
0.4255383909,
0.5804144144,
-0.2061139792,
1.3293002844,
-0.1488257647,
0.2649424076,
0.7623793483,
-0.0489268675,
0.67810148,
0.1167829633,
-0.099922955,
0.5902978778,
0.8098816276,
0.1422224641,
0.6703857183,
0.1247098222,
-0.3323436379,
-0.0532392412,
-0.2411646843,
-0.3465671241,
0.2194108218,
0.3789994121,
-0.2083294541,
0.0643936247,
0.141384989,
-0.3815976679,
0.0053148344,
-0.0715767443,
1.1770284176,
-0.1710815132,
-0.872296989,
0.9335172176,
0.0719086751,
0.4496797323,
-0.3032694757,
-0.1510303169,
-0.6518101096,
-0.152974233,
-0.1393949091,
-0.880518496,
-0.0833855197,
-0.2414420843,
-0.481829375,
-0.0410158858,
0.171043098,
-0.4175177217,
-0.2551912665,
-0.1416374594,
0.1759695113,
0.4689935446,
0.0529949553,
-0.5168702602,
0.1948078424,
-0.0732015371,
-0.1559109837,
0.4159762859,
0.3265357912,
-0.0244318098,
0.5550295115,
0.6927765608,
-0.3110450208,
0.063484408,
0.1919720322,
0.6491252184,
-0.4191212654,
-0.6301646233,
-0.5603116751,
0.3924255371,
-0.0921852961,
-0.0009459321,
0.5329698324,
0.3511992097,
0.6664417982,
-0.0017960796,
0.9842406511,
0.1297074258,
0.5094051957,
-0.5698131919,
0.3351402879,
-0.0467661582,
0.2047608346,
-0.3122311234,
-1.1912287474,
0.1483605653,
0.8412927389,
0.129043892,
0.3513216972,
0.4827095568,
0.619985044,
0.1807907075,
0.142036438,
0.2756425738,
0.0606508292,
0.3455967307,
0.6432945132,
0.815290451,
-0.3626142442,
0.7324734926,
0.215341568,
-0.3521576524,
-0.5569006801,
-0.1552585512,
-0.7083159089,
-0.7144383192,
-0.0323305503,
-0.5574681163,
0.1619789302,
0.6991277933,
0.9018999338,
-0.4497493804,
-0.3083179295,
-0.4657255113,
-0.0679522455,
-0.2076310068,
-0.2803388834,
0.1449437886,
-0.488001138,
-0.6772612929,
0.0677255169,
0.3337388039,
0.2740466595,
-0.1263644844,
-0.4317141473,
0.4699186385,
0.4388515949,
0.3166064918,
0.5395514369,
-0.7040926218,
-0.2255153805,
0.0646396056,
-0.5186779499,
0.1996452361,
0.8474817276,
-0.6411086917,
0.5289093256,
0.3970014155,
0.4748975337,
0.2978619635,
0.4173998237,
0.8179626465,
-0.8942034245,
0.1414378285,
0.1872962862,
0.0195583403,
0.0885556862,
-0.6382542253,
0.3151607811,
0.1490358412,
-0.7060360312,
-0.7493396401,
0.3119893372,
-0.843824029,
-0.0285431296,
1.148445487,
-0.0658339411,
-0.0541439578,
-0.4386956394,
-0.4119124115,
-0.2523732483,
-0.744020462,
0.9650122523,
0.8090196848,
-0.5070971251,
-0.4071030915,
-0.5049108863,
0.6714265943,
0.44234249,
-0.6405642629,
0.1763837188,
0.6457775235,
0.1853971332,
0.0912814066,
1.2450904846,
0.0262819286,
0.7158157229,
0.1598888338,
-0.4025944769,
0.5423660278,
-0.2468622327,
-0.2758114934,
0.112582393,
0.1521266997,
-0.1481870562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17003v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17003v1 | Evaluating GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 Models on Brazilian University Admission Exams | 2023-03-29T20:10:13 | 2023-03-29T20:10:13 | Desnes Nunes, Ricardo Primi, Ramon Pires, Roberto Lotufo, Rodrigo Nogueira | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The present study aims to explore the capabilities of Language Models (LMs)
in tackling high-stakes multiple-choice tests, represented here by the Exame
Nacional do Ensino M\'edio (ENEM), a multidisciplinary entrance examination
widely adopted by Brazilian universities. This exam poses challenging tasks for
LMs, since its questions may span into multiple fields of knowledge, requiring
understanding of information from diverse domains. For instance, a question may
require comprehension of both statistics and biology to be solved. This work
analyzed responses generated by GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 models for questions
presented in the 2009-2017 exams, as well as for questions of the 2022 exam,
which were made public after the training of the models was completed.
Furthermore, different prompt strategies were tested, including the use of
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompts to generate explanations for answers. On the
2022 edition, the best-performing model, GPT-4 with CoT, achieved an accuracy
of 87%, largely surpassing GPT-3.5 by 11 points. The code and data used on
experiments are available at https://github.com/piresramon/gpt-4-enem. | [
-0.5769395232,
-1.1753377914,
0.8424367309,
0.3089282215,
0.054614827,
-0.0140681909,
-0.1098930687,
-0.4968015254,
-0.3559959829,
0.3106441796,
-0.2334895283,
-0.2590940595,
-0.2946638167,
0.4640471041,
-0.1919033378,
1.0450206995,
-0.6663188338,
0.1716480404,
-0.3530617058,
0.0227752589,
-0.6035321951,
-0.565695107,
-0.7948883176,
-0.2853482366,
0.4359193444,
0.0216844641,
0.5752357841,
0.1233753636,
0.5986828804,
0.1920476854,
-0.049275253,
-0.2336056978,
-0.2559177279,
-0.1500059217,
-0.2411860228,
-0.1894826889,
-0.5734319091,
0.5412123799,
0.7801668644,
0.6482910514,
-0.1221635416,
0.1802596748,
0.3316524029,
0.3905606568,
-0.3362593949,
0.1994617581,
-0.2964111567,
-0.3012886345,
0.0793331191,
-0.1915775985,
-0.5801695585,
-0.5698599815,
0.2663501203,
-0.3696191907,
0.0512044281,
-0.2450203151,
0.9925890565,
-0.0094217295,
-0.4156515002,
-0.421045661,
-0.586160481,
0.5880199075,
-0.429587543,
0.3744852245,
0.2141417563,
0.4193567038,
-0.2223509699,
-0.3618641496,
-0.2919266522,
-0.4225441813,
0.0930483192,
0.1897972673,
-0.0744924769,
0.2878890634,
0.2177890837,
0.2409275472,
-0.9775278568,
-0.003169586,
-0.6352262497,
-0.0547121502,
0.3085863888,
0.0304884836,
0.1115797013,
0.2610777617,
-0.4344074726,
-0.0790688321,
-0.7028292418,
0.0225907508,
0.5976980925,
0.2535762787,
0.0698363483,
0.3341870904,
-0.0874611959,
1.3305066824,
-0.4228578806,
0.0690411031,
-0.0994077623,
-0.5151554942,
-0.4707492292,
-0.3496598899,
0.8037680984,
0.0632433742,
0.239961341,
0.1056090966,
-0.2570348382,
0.0542067438,
0.1286187172,
-0.8082139492,
0.066054754,
0.5762966275,
-0.0689863935,
-0.291896075,
-0.1540505737,
-0.922863543,
-0.0765643865,
-0.318277359,
0.7176890373,
-0.4746694863,
-0.0584275909,
0.2399469316,
0.1277675778,
0.6051983833,
0.6183816195,
-0.4536046684,
0.4852769077,
0.4310056865,
0.7984796762,
-0.3307582438,
-0.4077353776,
-0.1564250588,
-0.2483918518,
-0.3046322167,
0.6495885849,
-0.7695031166,
-0.3992601037,
-0.1085207313,
-0.2134666294,
-0.4435228407,
-0.1874155104,
0.8145620227,
-0.7028294802,
0.6327975988,
-0.2826187313,
-0.4815243483,
-0.3837876916,
0.6179861426,
-0.5514129996,
0.9630055428,
0.407279253,
-0.3087934852,
0.0546905547,
-1.0778537989,
0.0439682528,
-0.0336466581,
-0.4119624496,
-0.2347478569,
-0.2928403616,
0.2147172987,
0.2960076332,
-0.5064847469,
0.297718823,
-0.2647418082,
-0.4781433642,
0.3301937878,
-0.6154085994,
0.8103125095,
0.1235658377,
-0.2046384364,
-0.0209530387,
-0.5591734648,
-0.0731945261,
0.4037828743,
-0.4434681535,
0.0503152423,
-0.3413106203,
-0.1058824956,
0.4151498675,
0.1209489256,
-0.5037785769,
0.5479533672,
-0.1303109974,
0.2087863386,
0.8332193494,
-0.0068460405,
0.1488179862,
-0.1556397527,
0.9639925361,
-0.0831119344,
0.2722735405,
0.0052836374,
-1.029198885,
-0.4345163107,
0.1144693345,
0.5866231322,
0.4439428747,
-0.5241644979,
-0.1879278123,
0.0500012413,
-0.7106360793,
-0.5276945829,
-0.1925778836,
0.2544656694,
0.3629148602,
0.35915187,
-0.0468112975,
-0.2084631622,
-0.5944381356,
-0.4992806911,
-0.1632069945,
0.1645376384,
0.2717017233,
1.0495523214,
-0.1384341568,
0.8103524446,
-0.4923101068,
0.1493017823,
-0.1682652831,
0.0465719551,
0.454352051,
0.4200438857,
0.747849524,
-0.7097730041,
-0.4179995656,
-0.1379229426,
-0.7127568722,
-0.1127053276,
0.0453246497,
0.1109306812,
0.0591592528,
-0.1630152464,
-0.5340624452,
0.2633307874,
0.7077335715,
-0.5344856381,
0.9113271832,
-0.3253023922,
0.4649431407,
-0.6152669191,
-0.1935575455,
0.2812666595,
-0.0461540557,
-0.6991090775,
0.4093997777,
-0.0229346324,
-0.3765778542,
-0.4290644825,
0.7956954241,
-0.6466573477,
-0.1533323228,
-0.1141651869,
0.2378684431,
0.1615132689,
0.2869070172,
-0.0776828527,
0.9460635781,
0.7886652946,
-0.7364573479,
0.2236173749,
0.0016416617,
-0.1243469343,
0.4466188848,
-0.498282671,
0.4141314328,
-0.084393397,
0.4118154943,
-0.8887553215,
-0.3387984335,
0.2108159512,
-0.389665097,
0.1277946532,
-0.227740705,
-0.217990607,
-0.6318762302,
-0.1602552682,
0.4249709845,
0.1728027463,
-0.3676913679,
0.7106115818,
0.1012413353,
-0.2175759077,
-0.54831177,
-0.2537305951,
-0.0383430682,
-0.3633109033,
-0.4276025295,
0.1162824258,
-0.198305741,
-0.2752468884,
-0.3201949894,
0.2705596685,
-0.0078066648,
0.1485323161,
-0.2189366221,
0.5232532024,
-0.4236287773,
0.0212293845,
-0.1498087645,
0.1220883727,
0.1974014491,
-0.4222511351,
0.7111654878,
-0.5350642204,
-0.2992550731,
-0.1764376312,
0.2938157022,
0.7766744494,
-0.3027083576,
0.6692371964,
0.4790504575,
-0.5333683491,
0.1539222151,
-0.5635481477,
-0.1708871275,
-0.4080457687,
0.2722869515,
-0.813380301,
-0.6365886331,
0.5155295134,
0.2089577019,
0.0153318588,
0.2617571652,
0.5642487407,
0.0185387209,
0.7601207495,
0.2970135808,
0.0109202955,
0.2327474207,
-0.2073694915,
0.1799380183,
-0.793593049,
0.0064133699,
-0.7093376517,
0.0099072829,
-0.8360660672,
-0.6812164783,
0.4258835614,
0.0972338244,
-0.1721473783,
0.3521296084,
-0.4429699183,
0.4612903297,
0.4827210009,
-0.0317644887,
0.2012237459,
-0.2504925132,
-0.111919418,
0.1304003745,
-0.5431547165,
-0.8575717211,
1.4454555511,
0.5268880725,
0.5461264253,
0.2513492405,
0.4859817922,
-0.1987458169,
0.562692225,
-0.6707652807,
0.5955450535,
0.5231827497,
-0.9245446324,
-0.4309547246,
-0.4469705522,
-0.8843516707,
0.6818746924,
0.0773251727,
-0.942058742,
0.1257275939,
-0.0144238006,
-0.5691735744,
0.246835947,
-0.6061387062,
0.9883241653,
-0.302934736,
-0.5675877333,
0.2231756002,
-0.4127757251,
0.3303834796,
-0.4797617495,
0.4081858397,
-0.0857362896,
0.0030091067,
0.9279770851,
0.2977073193,
0.4200108051,
-0.1486422122,
-0.2614960074,
0.6289656758,
0.166452378,
0.6311869025,
0.0587896295,
-0.5684486628,
0.243284151,
0.1661406606,
-0.4162153006,
-0.5950626731,
0.6031242609,
-0.7883960009,
-0.6207318902,
-0.704203248,
-0.5332556367,
-0.3633160889,
0.149499163,
0.0205473416,
0.4547358155,
-0.6144586802,
-0.234308362,
0.3886665702,
-0.4402492642,
0.3963697553,
0.6152513623,
-0.3123039901,
-0.3581105471,
0.7393424511,
0.2332275212,
0.4810895324,
0.198397547,
0.4295430481,
-0.6244961023,
-0.5645497441,
-0.7055547237,
0.4635156989,
-0.7492940426,
0.0721856505,
-0.786239922,
-0.1353444308,
-0.6373540163,
-0.0564000718,
-0.1498887837,
0.0278461333,
-0.0726958588,
-0.246290192,
0.0414753556,
0.8245406151,
0.2557021379,
0.3655599058,
-0.5112335682,
-0.0361267552,
0.1366160065,
0.3122183681,
-0.5961087346,
-0.6145434976,
0.0489914156,
0.0310631339,
-0.7248040438,
-1.4058206081,
0.163208887,
-0.0620538108,
0.5289741755,
0.2206890732,
-0.3292833567,
0.4369559586,
-0.3414126635,
0.8749767542,
-0.1795363873,
-0.8011458516,
0.652108252,
-0.8736650348,
-0.032802958,
0.4568855166,
0.6980569363,
-0.1901911497,
-0.3299201727,
-0.7300390005,
-0.3745035529,
0.6710990071,
0.4614354372,
-0.1003538817,
0.3061214387,
0.4223766029,
0.090402551,
0.2043023407,
-1.1469525099,
-0.030623313,
0.1520050615,
-0.0661222786,
-0.1709463745,
-0.1280627698,
0.012846712,
-0.2436145842,
0.7858175635,
-0.1118200049,
0.3969856501,
0.1181938499,
0.1740277857,
0.1401298791,
0.8415673375,
0.8514547944,
0.8673334122,
-0.5402535796,
-0.1292212903,
0.300940752,
-0.4635343552,
0.3852703571,
0.2240041345,
-0.1841242462,
0.0444349051,
-0.0884010196,
0.6758356094,
-0.3031274676,
-0.3078902066,
0.4883317351,
-0.062338762,
-0.1812390089,
-0.1607246995,
-0.1389825642,
-0.1768164039,
-0.1898101866,
0.1826062649,
-0.1041988507,
0.2589574158,
-0.8303236961,
-0.0406491458,
0.1818495542,
-0.5268832445,
-0.3784897327,
0.7123862505,
0.299344629,
-0.2114718109,
0.2934366763,
-0.1505117118,
-0.4406169653,
0.5953228474,
0.9089906812,
0.6108542085,
-0.6487348676,
0.3070492744,
0.540854156,
0.5434666276,
-0.1479344964,
0.4447458088,
0.293774724,
-0.8370319605,
-0.2641513646,
-0.820468843,
-0.8249486685,
0.5377331376,
-0.5264508128,
0.4101776481,
-0.0225491058,
-0.3031109869,
-0.4271349907,
-0.0423666053,
-0.8619974256,
0.5434532762,
0.058731176,
0.8853268027,
-1.0718694925,
0.6305968761,
0.9084666967,
-0.6627591252,
-0.7617712021,
-0.1771212518,
-0.0258003063,
-0.5249828696,
0.0473838374,
0.2674626708,
0.0339516588,
0.1937342584,
-0.1477865279,
-0.9131660461,
0.737231195,
0.4057070911,
-0.380484134,
-0.3002564609,
0.3539780676,
0.3537100255,
-0.3775166571,
0.8918792009,
1.0391281843,
0.6683516502,
-0.3282078207,
-1.0509444475,
-0.0926306024,
-0.0818466768,
-0.2549547255,
0.1724419147,
-0.5058410764,
1.0062483549,
-0.2559556663,
0.2028255314,
-0.2335585207,
0.5356957912,
0.7504445314,
0.2141663581,
0.3977695405,
0.2283055633,
0.7721484303,
-0.5358508825,
1.1324480772,
-0.2828129828,
0.522175312,
0.9863924384,
-0.4119063914,
0.7274676561,
0.6054089665,
-0.5194732547,
0.5641051531,
1.0582376719,
0.1001131088,
0.16687949,
0.3302949667,
-0.1387224197,
-0.0039622262,
0.1417302191,
-0.6399407387,
0.697219491,
0.5183681846,
-0.1528026611,
-0.2090923935,
0.2611774504,
-0.0931021944,
-0.2121265084,
-0.3133515418,
0.3530463576,
0.0831840709,
-0.9422330856,
0.4498274028,
0.0218641814,
0.2391277254,
-0.4284374416,
-0.0221737754,
-0.1629063934,
0.1907504499,
0.136547938,
-0.9503509998,
-0.0409823619,
0.1915262938,
0.3903390169,
-0.2592962384,
0.4460969567,
-0.2995824516,
-0.6239757538,
0.3798769414,
0.5636258721,
0.6507624388,
-0.3472394943,
-0.7971864343,
0.0561847836,
-0.2711472809,
-0.3795953393,
0.188374117,
0.2537242472,
-0.0224067699,
0.5835443139,
0.3791273832,
0.2444196194,
0.0935502872,
0.2441916764,
0.6395731568,
-0.5359018445,
-0.5513553619,
-0.9301128983,
0.3332523108,
0.0636138469,
-0.3410882056,
0.6313796043,
0.7064934969,
0.9706908464,
-0.1248310581,
0.9035439491,
0.1835543215,
0.1983898133,
-0.4271960855,
0.4008528888,
-0.3961637616,
0.1494651288,
-0.6394507289,
-1.0338695049,
0.0843210667,
0.4711760283,
-0.6292530298,
0.5398116112,
0.8983902335,
0.6775872707,
0.2040274143,
0.1246801987,
0.4939695895,
-0.1124414429,
0.4606355131,
0.6839632988,
0.9957942963,
-0.7843368053,
0.5525083542,
0.0245606415,
-0.4535343051,
-0.2133604586,
-0.5697392225,
-0.7461689711,
-0.3332678676,
-0.4034297168,
-0.5489448309,
0.1714064181,
0.8036432862,
0.173089385,
-0.8099491596,
-0.490305841,
-0.0671562031,
-0.000288977,
-0.3001969159,
-0.2323830724,
0.274274379,
-0.064407602,
-0.8122777939,
0.515763998,
0.1987266243,
0.3436429501,
-0.2752054334,
-0.0331139229,
-0.1302390844,
0.3339747787,
0.4713267684,
-0.1202816144,
-0.7740570307,
-0.3103606403,
0.1167526543,
-0.1889721453,
0.2957751453,
0.671067059,
-0.5313270092,
0.3292793036,
0.4891059399,
0.2942689657,
0.2320389301,
0.0642917976,
0.6999056935,
-0.2308440655,
-0.0061116931,
0.3613191545,
0.690104723,
0.2012270987,
-0.2080038637,
0.7455353141,
0.2328695953,
-0.5951516628,
-0.9367302656,
0.1089739427,
-0.9269920588,
-0.2201113403,
1.3877618313,
-0.0101410346,
-0.0564537235,
-0.2187412232,
-0.1708148718,
0.2766193748,
-0.2489857227,
0.3760762811,
0.9790769219,
-0.3169787228,
-0.0190183986,
-1.1004434824,
0.4777500629,
0.2135271877,
-0.9886713624,
-0.0071881125,
0.1713615805,
0.3218576312,
0.0168809872,
0.9542871118,
-0.3295305073,
0.3005141616,
-0.0584429614,
0.1650292724,
0.155575037,
-0.4517731071,
-0.4872462749,
0.4024689794,
0.0072586178,
-0.1706588566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16992v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16992v2 | ContraSim -- A Similarity Measure Based on Contrastive Learning | 2023-03-29T19:43:26 | 2023-05-30T09:47:33 | Adir Rahamim, Yonatan Belinkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has compared neural network representations via similarity-based
analyses to improve model interpretation. The quality of a similarity measure
is typically evaluated by its success in assigning a high score to
representations that are expected to be matched. However, existing similarity
measures perform mediocrely on standard benchmarks. In this work, we develop a
new similarity measure, dubbed ContraSim, based on contrastive learning. In
contrast to common closed-form similarity measures, ContraSim learns a
parameterized measure by using both similar and dissimilar examples. We perform
an extensive experimental evaluation of our method, with both language and
vision models, on the standard layer prediction benchmark and two new
benchmarks that we introduce: the multilingual benchmark and the image-caption
benchmark. In all cases, ContraSim achieves much higher accuracy than previous
similarity measures, even when presented with challenging examples. Finally,
ContraSim is more suitable for the analysis of neural networks, revealing new
insights not captured by previous measures. | [
-0.5671312809,
-0.0323224254,
0.1942880303,
-0.1462830156,
-0.5224283934,
-0.3508434892,
-0.0332074091,
-0.1858111769,
0.4493422508,
0.6187420487,
-0.5805617571,
-0.5361731648,
-0.4636356235,
-0.1091645062,
-0.2658492029,
0.8887960315,
-0.2051459998,
0.5462113023,
-0.7115198374,
-0.7430565357,
-0.2584880888,
-0.2927542329,
-0.5347259045,
-0.5657225847,
0.7459014058,
0.1870297343,
0.5592369437,
0.5379278064,
0.7664063573,
0.3812904358,
0.2787240148,
0.0365359671,
-0.3243885338,
-0.2273866832,
-0.3941505253,
-0.5890619755,
-0.0869031847,
0.5270910859,
0.7243179679,
1.0995233059,
0.1277591735,
0.2890663147,
0.3818883002,
0.7412214279,
-0.7100490332,
0.0992245227,
-0.4791420698,
0.1496919096,
0.039738901,
-0.2053444088,
0.1395864636,
-0.243081823,
0.2776827216,
-0.4999170005,
0.3330900073,
0.0928319469,
0.8162022233,
0.3621604145,
-0.2816331089,
-0.2233117372,
-0.3626331687,
1.0829353333,
-0.7222918868,
0.4390397668,
-0.0779354647,
0.632430315,
0.1295647472,
-0.7805305719,
-0.5737086535,
-0.553234756,
-0.0044213287,
0.3741827905,
-0.2594524026,
-0.3635904789,
0.067672953,
0.1645810455,
-0.6575854421,
0.2106025964,
-0.2651117146,
0.0774084926,
0.463529706,
0.361281395,
0.0997919664,
-0.0096767917,
-1.074805975,
-0.2245052904,
-0.7755740285,
-0.10582228,
0.4867387414,
0.1168295518,
-0.2660193145,
0.0363404006,
-0.1879771501,
0.4275873601,
-0.3582997322,
0.4597616494,
0.4419007897,
-0.0948664099,
-0.4803521931,
-0.1803485006,
0.790066421,
0.8454110026,
0.4249501824,
-0.1718727648,
-0.1330382824,
-0.1013604254,
0.0410599336,
-0.8336141706,
-0.5941599011,
-0.4424558878,
-0.769588232,
-0.2151824683,
0.4461061954,
-0.6758406162,
-0.2323992252,
-0.656067431,
0.4958934486,
-0.3995777369,
-0.1161727458,
-0.1608767807,
-0.1016389206,
0.3438627124,
0.1049640104,
-0.4512628019,
0.8946982622,
0.7310708761,
0.9143268466,
-0.4574149251,
-0.469095856,
-0.4247945249,
-0.3609787226,
-0.6550828815,
0.64294523,
-0.3131971955,
-0.0199986827,
-0.2797662914,
-0.1241520569,
-0.0480045266,
-0.8752324581,
0.1464892924,
-0.5284884572,
0.325581491,
-0.318187207,
-0.6423788667,
-0.7172266841,
0.4775851071,
-0.763307333,
0.4736338556,
-0.1075807139,
-0.6985096931,
0.6224425435,
-0.3682616949,
0.0750519037,
0.0962391943,
-0.3330908418,
-0.7829709649,
0.1284028143,
-0.206691891,
0.601797998,
-0.5306298733,
-0.0581752919,
-0.4961090982,
-0.7418097258,
0.4850294888,
-0.4749971628,
0.7119975686,
0.1202227697,
-0.2095344961,
0.0584872141,
-0.5135757327,
0.0520914793,
-0.093554318,
0.1592538804,
-0.7426802516,
-0.0096025933,
-0.0312571414,
0.1423304379,
0.1740092784,
-0.4335806072,
-0.4085362852,
-0.4877601266,
0.0395604298,
0.6222451925,
-0.1795211285,
0.296787709,
-0.6334361434,
0.3575343192,
0.3036296368,
-0.1142289042,
0.0329275988,
-0.0614838079,
-0.8139158487,
-0.3621119559,
0.519593358,
0.4604899287,
-0.5161547065,
0.2170691341,
-0.2490601093,
-0.5221872926,
-0.0338837765,
0.30082497,
0.7618511319,
0.6252925396,
0.6061768532,
-0.8436983228,
-0.5919029713,
-1.0824095011,
-0.4441349506,
0.0392197706,
0.0418029986,
0.5046746731,
0.6068392396,
-0.1310403347,
0.2582786977,
-0.355717361,
-0.6155499816,
-0.0007559077,
0.338437438,
0.3925543427,
0.6202207208,
0.8737621307,
-0.8825822473,
-0.5439502597,
-0.2239212543,
-0.7523696423,
-0.043180719,
-0.0102795204,
0.3589133918,
-0.254419446,
1.0075428486,
0.0693813264,
0.1355493963,
0.499597013,
0.013725874,
0.4581120908,
-0.2460205853,
0.3459356129,
-1.1903355122,
0.2138233036,
0.168475166,
-0.1963443905,
-0.2976465225,
0.0463612601,
-0.0655590072,
0.0785539299,
-0.9733501673,
0.4638148546,
-0.5069139004,
-0.3163279891,
-0.2587861121,
0.2414240092,
-0.267816633,
0.5108673573,
-0.1175814345,
0.5950508714,
0.7298244834,
-0.452396363,
0.6428380609,
-0.0038346031,
-0.5623521209,
0.9785045981,
-0.5207095146,
0.0428222381,
-0.195584029,
-0.168284893,
-1.1193290949,
0.2022954524,
0.1991382837,
-0.3708275557,
0.1872250885,
0.1841488928,
0.0215331931,
-0.1634746194,
-0.5537495017,
0.4537743032,
0.494250983,
-0.6318179369,
0.5940932631,
-0.2183835804,
0.1144804209,
-0.7959160209,
-0.9655929208,
-0.0239693038,
-0.5378091335,
0.0022990876,
0.5339909792,
0.0749329031,
-0.2161688805,
0.3701568246,
-0.0679248571,
-0.0653133839,
0.2065799087,
0.3945994377,
0.1982192695,
-0.7336113453,
-0.0833149329,
-0.2752594948,
-0.2845155597,
0.1677686125,
-0.3289127648,
0.337036401,
-0.2481961399,
-0.510514617,
-0.4817200303,
0.124343425,
0.2757639587,
-0.0835430846,
0.4486737847,
0.3924311697,
-0.3379797637,
-0.3146181107,
-0.3678353131,
-0.073309876,
-0.4039491117,
0.5366594791,
-0.6685948968,
-0.3214665949,
0.5608420372,
-0.4120308459,
-0.3837032914,
0.426918298,
0.1092025563,
-0.4118385017,
0.6996908188,
0.5827662945,
-0.1887972355,
0.4894722998,
-0.3938035071,
-0.2505908608,
-0.7027574778,
-0.4894450903,
-0.5284505486,
-0.7908157706,
-0.6773175001,
-0.2518016994,
-0.0404239148,
0.2128128856,
-0.2153062969,
0.6020032167,
0.0745215118,
0.59940207,
0.6383059621,
0.2262120396,
0.0692741945,
-0.1676276773,
-0.4521728456,
-0.3132449389,
-0.5512499213,
-0.4816170335,
1.0174491405,
-0.1662108302,
0.708085537,
0.1056781784,
0.8374208808,
0.1698709726,
0.5108633041,
-0.6343432665,
0.6765291095,
-0.9338881969,
0.0035181111,
0.0924701169,
-0.6278544664,
-0.9716820717,
0.2460049242,
-0.3290245235,
-0.3454948068,
0.2530595958,
0.1224423572,
-0.1748795509,
0.3655828238,
-0.3851216733,
0.8747418523,
-0.3198679686,
-0.3042212129,
-0.3806041479,
-0.5153476,
0.1275997013,
0.0279907212,
-0.2345276624,
-0.0753486902,
-0.2872942686,
0.9299138784,
-0.2278893739,
0.8372972012,
-0.1673862338,
0.5901970267,
0.023303939,
0.1854480058,
-0.3871340454,
-0.2031148672,
-0.2012496442,
0.4222206473,
0.1647367179,
-0.4582869112,
-0.9028788805,
1.2141282558,
-0.7089685798,
-0.5538264513,
-0.4626957774,
-0.4618053138,
-0.0307849571,
0.2582226396,
0.1473144144,
0.4459862709,
-0.7027879357,
0.3315472007,
0.4371581972,
-0.2328448743,
0.4677729011,
0.6023192406,
0.0796040595,
-0.3970181644,
0.761079371,
0.1132248342,
0.1411033273,
0.6367411017,
0.404633224,
-0.3661061823,
-0.5473689437,
-0.1871670932,
0.0302516017,
-0.6952190399,
-0.3301767707,
-0.1147550046,
-0.3337625265,
-0.0899059251,
-0.0484406464,
-0.256698668,
-0.1115178838,
-0.2980813384,
0.2436443716,
-0.1567894071,
0.5871100426,
-0.2319300026,
0.0637454018,
-0.2887276113,
0.4187903106,
0.4847935736,
0.4900393784,
-0.1586410552,
-0.4904040396,
0.0047716955,
-0.1287451237,
-0.3406996131,
-0.6924779415,
0.2077671289,
0.4715996385,
0.9044041038,
0.5714513659,
-0.1669189483,
0.5070996284,
-0.3719607592,
0.6001653075,
0.6061958671,
-0.9595044255,
0.2286592126,
0.3391034901,
0.1669896096,
0.6837823987,
0.6968297362,
-0.3242786825,
0.1180259436,
-0.5844480991,
-0.1439244449,
0.3930325806,
-0.1079541966,
0.5201478601,
0.2586869001,
0.3171506226,
0.4193116724,
0.0691050515,
-0.6332477331,
-0.2311614454,
-0.4281430244,
-0.51713866,
-0.5495757461,
0.0523540191,
0.2151576579,
0.0113364467,
0.4635645747,
-0.0914587751,
0.0079783695,
0.029334059,
0.0242637079,
0.2100158781,
0.0104789855,
0.3399548531,
0.3624276519,
-0.0389824845,
0.8353943825,
0.6553777456,
-0.3630333841,
-0.0561698116,
0.2805444598,
-0.1054336429,
0.0306418948,
0.5268790722,
0.6783224344,
0.2576645613,
-0.5465604067,
0.8540495634,
0.1340524107,
-0.4547741115,
-0.238373816,
0.1543627083,
-0.0025442399,
0.4592806697,
-0.0547356643,
0.4441577196,
0.2750803232,
-0.6637614369,
0.523686111,
0.6940184832,
-1.1765831709,
-0.2898512185,
0.5299938917,
-0.0472053476,
-0.291850239,
0.4177041054,
-0.0534732491,
-0.6263115406,
0.9181969166,
0.3817753792,
0.724198997,
-0.4620374739,
0.1356425136,
0.3465919793,
0.0914876834,
0.0133273555,
0.3264365196,
-0.1421057582,
-0.7244375944,
-0.0499255881,
-0.2546540797,
-0.2650914788,
0.317902118,
-0.6504227519,
0.5971103907,
-0.6223350763,
0.1724921167,
0.0876128078,
0.2176398933,
-0.8071694374,
0.6495044231,
0.0158431996,
0.6865754724,
-1.1296709776,
0.7883290052,
0.6825050116,
-0.6860422492,
-0.5763602257,
0.0123749766,
-0.0494791493,
-0.593857646,
0.7846679688,
0.4071525335,
-0.4433651865,
-0.3921073079,
-0.3509293199,
-0.5350584388,
1.1165407896,
0.5905272365,
-0.7073149085,
0.4184729457,
0.3938425779,
0.6998152733,
-0.6556938291,
0.377867043,
0.1746058613,
-0.0196886323,
-0.0330023095,
-0.5102308989,
0.1691457182,
-0.2401151955,
-0.0098602781,
0.0200844817,
-0.63333112,
0.9217247367,
-0.1280924976,
-0.1715249717,
0.5274239779,
0.6507513523,
-0.0892555788,
0.6432605386,
0.6057236195,
0.5789136291,
0.3902354836,
0.0594504625,
0.77347368,
0.0330331251,
0.326053232,
1.4076325893,
-0.3673383594,
0.9320462346,
0.6279981732,
0.1444515735,
0.8098305464,
0.2867944241,
-0.4566881955,
0.7860006094,
0.6154607534,
0.1906767339,
-0.399653405,
-0.0559437163,
-0.1770985574,
0.6053445935,
-0.0694977492,
-0.7507945299,
-0.3640030324,
0.0593889505,
-0.4583471119,
0.882643044,
-0.4328451157,
0.903459847,
0.549628377,
-0.444722712,
0.6140599847,
-0.1303426176,
0.5884819627,
-0.2329122126,
-0.2163958102,
-0.3482673466,
0.3831751943,
0.0450914055,
-0.7716983557,
0.5797967315,
-0.298063755,
0.0733420253,
0.0478522964,
0.3856746852,
-0.3461111486,
-0.4205607176,
0.7042116523,
0.4204551876,
0.3925777376,
0.1422381699,
-0.889015317,
-0.3707553446,
-0.3840441108,
0.2673209906,
-0.091753915,
0.2109950632,
-0.1514535844,
0.5476247072,
0.2467076629,
0.2972712219,
-0.0795447454,
0.3444215655,
0.5593372583,
-0.6274463534,
-0.396830231,
-0.9444075823,
-0.0264160354,
-0.2217070311,
-0.4680738151,
0.687438786,
0.785102129,
1.1447969675,
-0.172313109,
0.277375102,
0.5470835567,
0.5667743683,
-0.7315823436,
0.6736684442,
-0.8754479289,
0.1627877355,
-0.3858417869,
-1.2861702442,
-0.4770554602,
0.2748306096,
-0.5088531971,
0.0239443909,
0.7053483725,
0.9151419997,
-0.7547833323,
-0.101531744,
0.6180845499,
-0.0592207164,
-0.3606286943,
0.9320493937,
1.1101858616,
-0.6267479062,
0.5083709359,
-0.0865170956,
-0.1697487086,
0.0398296081,
-0.8949941397,
-1.3087240458,
-0.8298000097,
-0.5176341534,
0.0918850079,
0.2117058635,
0.5402179956,
0.9363086224,
-1.0346808434,
-0.1470704675,
-0.2215458304,
-0.0890781507,
-0.6538463235,
-0.0778570622,
0.4908247292,
-0.1074016169,
-0.5958972573,
0.0827988386,
0.0709700957,
0.0263805687,
-0.3215717971,
-0.2761698961,
-0.0160354059,
0.3664730787,
0.0270528644,
0.0333202928,
-0.6965344548,
-0.2563317418,
-0.2868182957,
-0.1508075893,
0.1761814505,
0.8921570778,
-0.7438934445,
0.2785329223,
0.7210874557,
0.7478975654,
0.8267611265,
-0.1581421196,
0.317910403,
-0.5980552435,
0.2150861323,
0.1194262356,
0.511339128,
0.6806920767,
-0.0170498006,
0.0879845098,
0.1622475833,
0.0136657441,
-0.2712345123,
0.4762268066,
-0.9273940921,
-0.4288998842,
0.5920240879,
-0.5518544912,
-0.1504562348,
0.1450968832,
0.1184156612,
0.4221050441,
0.205778107,
0.6556758285,
0.0917125642,
0.146287784,
-0.253120631,
-0.0261196867,
0.3285341561,
0.7779814601,
-0.6635523438,
-0.5187031627,
0.1129265577,
0.6167166829,
0.2858761549,
0.0218564868,
-0.3340812325,
0.4091553688,
-0.0322097354,
-0.1455643624,
-0.2734019756,
-0.340094775,
-0.4714909494,
0.2535647452,
-0.3028791845,
-0.6297148466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16985v1 | Adapting to the Low-Resource Double-Bind: Investigating Low-Compute Methods on Low-Resource African Languages | 2023-03-29T19:25:43 | 2023-03-29T19:25:43 | Colin Leong, Herumb Shandilya, Bonaventure F. P. Dossou, Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Joel Mathew, Abdul-Hakeem Omotayo, Oreen Yousuf, Zainab Akinjobi, Chris Chinenye Emezue, Shamsudeen Muhammad, Steven Kolawole, Younwoo Choi, Tosin Adewumi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Many natural language processing (NLP) tasks make use of massively
pre-trained language models, which are computationally expensive. However,
access to high computational resources added to the issue of data scarcity of
African languages constitutes a real barrier to research experiments on these
languages. In this work, we explore the applicability of low-compute approaches
such as language adapters in the context of this low-resource double-bind. We
intend to answer the following question: do language adapters allow those who
are doubly bound by data and compute to practically build useful models?
Through fine-tuning experiments on African languages, we evaluate their
effectiveness as cost-effective approaches to low-resource African NLP. Using
solely free compute resources, our results show that language adapters achieve
comparable performances to massive pre-trained language models which are heavy
on computational resources. This opens the door to further experimentation and
exploration on full-extent of language adapters capacities. | [
-0.681556344,
-0.4212577939,
0.230701372,
0.0478956737,
-0.0227358118,
-0.1207569242,
-0.6633399725,
-0.6543750167,
0.2392079383,
0.6177220941,
-0.4104357362,
0.2636334896,
-0.7273897529,
0.0451314449,
0.1192585006,
0.7926974297,
-0.0996152759,
-0.3418027163,
-0.110350877,
-0.4210338593,
-0.5559174418,
-0.607519269,
-0.5540953279,
-0.1297516078,
0.4783773124,
0.7366890907,
1.1142958403,
0.3113780916,
0.3043348491,
0.1957110316,
0.0095699485,
0.1685352623,
-0.6303268671,
-0.208397761,
-0.3602454364,
-0.5042147636,
-0.2010236979,
0.0323254764,
0.1815702319,
0.8491667509,
-0.040908806,
0.3225963116,
0.2021613419,
0.8037246466,
-0.8773978949,
-0.0858218744,
-0.822465539,
-0.1423052847,
-0.4223861396,
0.088317208,
-0.3820244968,
-0.0471775196,
-0.2523810863,
-0.5489383936,
0.4192364216,
-0.1535446495,
0.5508597493,
0.4922530651,
-0.2468555719,
-0.4142034352,
-0.792689383,
0.7646187544,
-0.7709710002,
0.0964678228,
0.7333283424,
0.3233627677,
-0.3251489103,
-0.4444946945,
-0.5948867798,
0.0251047537,
-0.1275883019,
-0.1430271715,
-0.3092228174,
0.0842668712,
0.4302320778,
0.419985652,
-0.0954669639,
0.3608831465,
-0.3175963759,
-0.1966968477,
0.6769713163,
-0.1745843589,
0.5549539924,
0.1199809015,
0.3010012209,
0.0480075665,
-0.3870691657,
-0.0287166871,
0.4354573488,
0.8145747781,
-0.3363011777,
0.5725055337,
0.0423397832,
1.0977022648,
-0.1711116433,
0.1601432115,
-0.2372319251,
-0.2534458935,
-0.0355626047,
-0.0104156081,
0.5792781711,
0.0836515948,
0.4676470459,
-0.2359256595,
0.0267780814,
0.1755203009,
0.4709035754,
-0.7868819237,
-0.4293008149,
-0.0708739832,
-0.3138181269,
-0.0849407166,
-0.6046414971,
-0.9857605696,
-0.5296404362,
0.0013120146,
0.5717056394,
-0.2015083134,
-0.0595536381,
0.0410495251,
0.02360522,
-0.0878246948,
0.2396333516,
-1.3300267458,
0.7159671783,
0.2764552534,
1.1431827545,
0.2028369904,
-0.1219841316,
-0.4412323236,
-0.2344634831,
-0.1322649568,
0.5026171207,
-0.4114094079,
-0.3850807548,
0.0136925615,
-0.0935999081,
-0.0839831755,
-0.5082730055,
0.7634307146,
-0.5839787126,
-0.3405358791,
-0.4676332474,
-0.1826334,
-0.0745830834,
-0.2578639388,
-0.9034728408,
0.77110219,
0.342790395,
-0.4667499363,
0.0938678905,
-0.8174834251,
-0.6111994386,
-0.1779187322,
0.2163814604,
-0.0812569708,
0.4870696664,
0.275449425,
-0.1281041354,
-0.6790190339,
-0.3998075724,
-0.4227585196,
-0.4006995559,
0.2245204598,
-0.4951396585,
1.0033785105,
0.1308162808,
-0.3206692338,
-0.4985490739,
-0.7720249295,
0.0186252911,
0.2459495515,
-0.1742601693,
-0.3691505492,
-0.0854449123,
0.0841973796,
0.5292019248,
0.0307467412,
-0.4856876135,
0.463437885,
-0.4490147233,
0.4105757177,
0.5268542171,
-0.4891287088,
0.578697741,
-0.0624566041,
0.5955379605,
-0.2415541261,
-0.1650535762,
0.3954991996,
-0.3615254164,
-1.0896285772,
-0.1293658465,
0.5767996907,
0.4747022092,
-0.8980373144,
0.06009176,
-0.0551586114,
-0.526052773,
-1.1261628866,
0.4328405261,
0.1033915579,
0.4063296914,
0.4990136325,
-0.2739248276,
-0.5461395383,
-1.0444674492,
-0.5114423037,
0.0842944533,
-0.0742795914,
0.6289630532,
0.3964844346,
-0.1278781891,
0.5922585726,
-0.5288954973,
-0.2991245091,
-0.1173671782,
-0.0255708732,
0.4025959671,
0.2726480365,
1.0045859814,
-0.6508151293,
-0.4411141574,
-0.0917356536,
-0.6111884713,
-0.1093632579,
0.0576973483,
-0.1310222745,
0.2167278975,
0.1461351365,
-0.1263941079,
0.6139193177,
1.1008789539,
-0.2836996615,
0.2363341898,
-0.5164143443,
-0.17323865,
-0.6809071898,
0.0749199316,
-0.3675022423,
-0.1423694342,
-0.9003044367,
-0.0311829336,
-0.0990355313,
-0.3705907464,
-0.1956902593,
0.5913966298,
-0.5829882026,
-0.2102172673,
-0.7595734,
0.1215956137,
-0.1851508468,
0.3325782418,
0.0161612947,
1.3036373854,
0.2930774093,
-0.8175644875,
0.0446617752,
0.3245251179,
-0.3844659626,
0.2428144366,
-0.5802832246,
0.5405595303,
0.1481984705,
-0.022684861,
-0.6087344289,
-0.0326908529,
0.0258516558,
-0.0887515098,
0.1993049681,
-0.6057318449,
-0.3324314654,
-0.4723964334,
-0.1113668159,
0.7603135705,
0.5308052301,
-0.8006543517,
0.4780030847,
0.6705668569,
-0.3161106706,
-0.6392210722,
-1.0581873655,
0.2732988,
0.2151204795,
-0.5720880032,
0.1390204877,
-0.127724871,
-0.053404469,
-0.1177355722,
0.0395450927,
-0.3192975819,
0.4626131654,
0.3031527698,
-0.0498712845,
-0.2238176316,
-0.1384295076,
0.0647491515,
0.0628482625,
-0.2001126558,
-0.5388808846,
0.5606213212,
-0.0797847807,
-0.1983261108,
-0.1575329602,
0.2703559399,
0.3459329307,
-0.0215502046,
1.2128875256,
0.2126932889,
-0.5139843225,
-0.1318068206,
-0.471573025,
0.1618391275,
-0.436537236,
0.1606856734,
-0.3609544933,
-0.782945931,
0.4871718585,
-0.0987631306,
-0.0570422746,
0.2901519239,
0.683826983,
-0.0366686545,
0.4313568473,
0.8851084709,
-0.0832348764,
0.3208327889,
-0.2553909719,
0.2959286869,
-0.9189003706,
0.4634708166,
-0.8051832914,
-0.7030776143,
-0.8074716926,
-0.630934,
0.0686529353,
0.4781666398,
0.1936142892,
0.5275024772,
-0.2065302879,
0.4760638773,
0.5361968279,
0.0810463503,
-0.0291872844,
-0.0411276631,
0.1121162549,
-0.0596119463,
-1.0324568748,
-0.4289998412,
1.0558531284,
-0.2631371021,
0.5099647045,
0.3885987699,
0.5138295293,
0.216654852,
0.2088362724,
-0.8873265386,
0.0939641669,
-0.5320513248,
-0.50990206,
-0.343813777,
-0.3332264423,
-0.9958637357,
0.2508651614,
-0.3730001748,
-0.7363174558,
0.6492812634,
0.6497033238,
-0.1561796367,
0.4588145018,
-0.6922028065,
0.8269073963,
-0.2652286291,
-0.4617559612,
-0.2682082355,
-0.2866637707,
0.1089071184,
-0.3992879689,
0.7288139462,
-0.0220005624,
0.0186921619,
0.8771497011,
-0.724460721,
0.6875824928,
-0.3922704756,
-0.0169645194,
0.4224927425,
0.2346866429,
0.4315418005,
0.0051311259,
-0.4825254679,
0.4856868982,
-0.3186723888,
-0.9606810212,
-0.4444490969,
0.8077827692,
-1.007818222,
-0.4028038383,
-0.3040383756,
-0.8323543668,
-0.4118927717,
0.3787216544,
0.1557110399,
0.161921218,
-0.327051878,
-0.2312583178,
0.2575583458,
-0.2285896242,
0.5290097594,
0.5001555681,
0.2119766027,
-0.3300173283,
0.8150259852,
0.2766280472,
0.5262987614,
0.0817390531,
0.1925278604,
0.1924895942,
-0.6947307587,
-0.7117015719,
0.2436742783,
-0.1527270973,
-0.2158187628,
-0.5325962901,
-0.0312056933,
-0.2644583285,
-0.4601297081,
-0.4015146196,
-0.925001204,
-0.3016463518,
0.2020795494,
0.4557895958,
0.3836090863,
-0.514410615,
0.5567643642,
-0.6855296493,
0.6822670698,
0.4669335783,
0.4377524853,
0.0955019146,
-0.7462482452,
-0.678306818,
0.4507917464,
-0.0767617822,
-0.6703686118,
0.2609815001,
0.4399209917,
0.2547971904,
-0.1468095481,
0.2622841001,
0.6467196345,
-0.710786581,
0.6192831397,
0.0026794632,
-0.9386211038,
0.4395803511,
-0.0742011145,
0.3256130219,
0.9746575356,
0.2866550684,
-0.4265391827,
-0.0131102512,
-0.3017354906,
-0.7120980024,
1.1235839128,
0.3534207642,
0.1896252036,
0.3065090179,
0.5467303395,
0.087986283,
0.1087477803,
-0.2806099653,
-0.4417816103,
-0.2729277015,
0.0418122523,
-0.3859983981,
-0.5364658237,
-0.1762875468,
0.119212307,
0.74331671,
-0.361522615,
0.2024857849,
-0.1318838298,
-0.4999836683,
-0.197231099,
0.5180051327,
0.2699199021,
0.4330783486,
-0.251251936,
0.1328865439,
0.283723712,
-0.6727266908,
0.3664361238,
0.3712184429,
-0.4309288263,
-0.165107742,
0.2062006295,
0.8665863872,
0.0501479395,
-0.3640105724,
0.2916400135,
-0.3956248462,
0.0882924497,
0.0546697378,
0.0813844129,
0.3135237098,
-0.2138742208,
-0.2508163154,
0.3727742732,
0.0444425046,
-0.5855068564,
-0.1101101786,
0.472548604,
-0.4950755537,
-0.452308774,
0.4616199434,
0.465875566,
-0.5338594913,
0.7401511073,
0.0988166779,
-0.2755016088,
0.3693806231,
0.8649180532,
0.6469199657,
-0.1864417046,
-0.1194555163,
0.0917834193,
0.4735870957,
0.0445054211,
0.428073734,
-0.178365171,
-0.8928311467,
-0.5650030971,
-0.6070719361,
-0.3337552845,
-0.0635672659,
-0.881555438,
0.3358062804,
-0.3705776334,
-0.1898528188,
0.2559456825,
0.0574869849,
-0.9654778242,
-0.0124948286,
0.2626895607,
1.1186900139,
-0.825380981,
0.9097647667,
0.6747182012,
-0.1484737247,
-0.2740558386,
-0.1239877343,
0.0655704811,
-0.7935173512,
0.3475168347,
-0.1517108679,
-0.2975963652,
-0.1337569505,
-0.1245788559,
-0.7448909879,
0.5012290478,
0.8247512579,
-0.6591107249,
0.0857222155,
0.2147936821,
0.5630129576,
0.2339029461,
0.231710881,
0.7081325054,
0.4230724871,
-0.2730642855,
-0.995280683,
-0.0425793864,
-0.1488417685,
-0.0653792918,
0.656832397,
-0.8065938354,
0.4405534565,
-0.3447176516,
-0.0597763509,
0.0295857433,
0.753757596,
-0.211048007,
0.1532488614,
0.5661863089,
0.4845877886,
0.8473174572,
0.1544515043,
1.0165679455,
-0.4836486578,
0.3130704463,
1.2264128923,
-0.3480165005,
0.6814169288,
0.4216203988,
-0.4922183752,
0.4541684985,
-0.0935311988,
0.4777214825,
0.3287984431,
0.3107806444,
-0.2595454156,
-0.2286420017,
-0.4604642689,
-0.1024113968,
0.3327335715,
0.4313858151,
0.2022521794,
0.0013485088,
-0.0226334054,
0.0754945725,
0.2635473907,
-0.4173663557,
0.7892323732,
0.2867273092,
-0.2528371215,
0.8329491019,
-0.1387497485,
0.7183715105,
-0.5878404975,
0.1447207928,
-0.0399154983,
0.1572719216,
-0.1319225281,
-0.4692393839,
0.4752967656,
0.2800730169,
-0.5233357549,
-0.0038537895,
0.8949070573,
-0.1790234894,
-0.5488952994,
0.5107921958,
0.3830818832,
-0.1163414344,
0.0927586034,
-0.4174107909,
-0.1182531267,
-0.0004327121,
0.1137954742,
0.6789873838,
0.3097381294,
0.0406809039,
0.3508437872,
0.7284044623,
0.519135654,
-0.1412402838,
-0.087385565,
0.8315846324,
-0.6701077819,
-0.4001089036,
-0.7373970747,
0.0368244126,
0.0924868584,
-0.1508906633,
0.6238720417,
0.5079748631,
0.8082823753,
-0.0177462138,
1.0546336174,
-0.2539647222,
0.2547069192,
-0.4566097856,
0.7303260565,
-0.4966032505,
-0.0578640997,
-0.1117155626,
-0.6997215152,
-0.1354421824,
0.3627476394,
-0.2148173004,
-0.3276749253,
0.3412173986,
0.4933144748,
-0.2804653049,
0.1049655527,
0.219665274,
0.3372876942,
0.2584658265,
0.6690972447,
0.4047438204,
-0.5978026986,
0.5413046479,
-0.7362478971,
-0.4857898653,
-0.3247482181,
-0.8698264956,
-0.9195731282,
-0.158346191,
0.0686542541,
-0.529519558,
0.1379857659,
0.8420851827,
0.5471174717,
-1.0448448658,
-0.39928931,
0.1639411896,
0.0629799962,
-0.4320590496,
-0.1200369969,
0.438631624,
-0.1474509388,
-0.5721030235,
0.6811404824,
0.145180136,
-0.038887877,
0.1770155579,
0.0735243931,
-0.3080628216,
0.2573876679,
0.5037222505,
0.8097371459,
-0.2920862436,
-0.1534445137,
-0.3001024425,
0.133829087,
-0.0457985066,
1.1502408981,
-0.907800734,
0.7366012931,
0.3077176511,
0.9382329583,
0.491384387,
-0.2367230505,
0.7771286964,
-0.585703373,
0.7645870447,
0.3109154105,
0.3479314744,
0.3022128344,
-0.3000248075,
0.5219852328,
-0.1010011658,
-0.6681129932,
-0.8803557158,
0.488197118,
-0.8283734918,
-0.004399132,
0.7599938512,
-0.0033227524,
-0.2031041235,
-0.1797680706,
-0.1416855007,
0.3205388784,
-0.2170965523,
0.7101624012,
0.5584749579,
-0.2391826957,
0.1808522493,
-0.6999624968,
0.5832980275,
0.4494287074,
-0.7628909349,
0.3138895333,
0.2712492347,
0.0026621642,
0.2927531302,
0.5838909149,
0.2806160748,
0.2133001089,
0.1006373838,
-0.0079125278,
-0.0595810264,
-0.0684101135,
-0.6096066236,
-0.1417734772,
0.5364744663,
0.0661370307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16974v1 | BEVERS: A General, Simple, and Performant Framework for Automatic Fact Verification | 2023-03-29T19:16:19 | 2023-03-29T19:16:19 | Mitchell DeHaven, Stephen Scott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic fact verification has become an increasingly popular topic in
recent years and among datasets the Fact Extraction and VERification (FEVER)
dataset is one of the most popular. In this work we present BEVERS, a tuned
baseline system for the FEVER dataset. Our pipeline uses standard approaches
for document retrieval, sentence selection, and final claim classification,
however, we spend considerable effort ensuring optimal performance for each
component. The results are that BEVERS achieves the highest FEVER score and
label accuracy among all systems, published or unpublished. We also apply this
pipeline to another fact verification dataset, Scifact, and achieve the highest
label accuracy among all systems on that dataset as well. We also make our full
code available. | [
-0.0724713206,
-0.5345609784,
0.3011601269,
0.1194991171,
-0.354485929,
0.0589232966,
-0.1598398983,
-0.3270304203,
0.3710545301,
0.4691875279,
-0.3464747071,
-0.6037757397,
-0.9301819205,
0.4497833252,
-0.8243977427,
1.2502969503,
0.1560999453,
-0.4698699415,
-0.4645937085,
-0.2210642248,
0.2579180002,
-0.3422775865,
-0.4685031474,
-0.6502023935,
-0.0777562484,
0.7371962667,
0.8550125957,
0.8255845308,
0.6654869914,
0.4545367956,
0.1240927279,
0.5790105462,
-0.55009377,
0.5597737432,
-0.3747984767,
0.0485540852,
-0.2793599069,
-0.1301268637,
0.2521819472,
0.3658768833,
0.162884295,
0.451497227,
0.0214134399,
0.6940562725,
-0.9391562343,
0.096360594,
-0.2649553716,
-0.203554824,
-0.3455815315,
-0.3272840381,
-0.4141075909,
-0.5486439466,
0.1368655264,
-0.674285531,
0.5258495808,
0.4366018772,
1.2132260799,
0.6725827456,
-0.836286664,
-0.4221486449,
-0.6149237752,
0.4841330349,
-0.0148287108,
0.3787223101,
0.2398046851,
0.3359515369,
-0.3186506927,
-1.0362282991,
-0.3558912575,
0.0926473811,
-0.2275698185,
-0.0633121282,
-0.6439506412,
-0.2701275945,
0.6284019351,
0.5462778807,
-0.7803975344,
-0.4851158857,
-0.2478509247,
-0.7035459876,
0.6873797774,
-0.0423425175,
0.0011438866,
-0.3756870925,
-0.3558096886,
0.0192396268,
-0.750207603,
0.3972139657,
-0.2579613924,
0.1191750988,
-0.3518239856,
0.6297265887,
-0.8958516717,
0.9166579843,
-0.0121673895,
-0.3277570009,
0.4472561777,
-0.3570874929,
-0.5908846259,
0.0977318212,
0.8073737025,
0.2451931983,
0.2066200972,
-0.2756410837,
-0.2872234881,
0.0020085296,
0.119551219,
-0.8580977917,
-0.3848464787,
0.1301636547,
-0.271589011,
-0.4699368477,
0.3189160824,
-0.6144835949,
-0.4113785326,
-0.2841279805,
0.5344355106,
-0.3755460083,
0.2261021286,
0.0613657311,
-0.2824346423,
0.0525276363,
0.2326948643,
-0.5665765405,
0.4379699528,
0.6835715175,
0.9252503514,
0.0843055844,
0.0687988773,
-0.9395294189,
-0.0783519149,
-0.5003327131,
1.0445145369,
-0.5770036578,
-0.2546414137,
-0.2693998814,
0.1911252141,
0.5336469412,
-0.1474493593,
0.705163002,
-0.5328905582,
0.0424493775,
-0.5903727412,
-0.443372041,
0.0511445552,
0.4106873274,
-0.4040245414,
0.6803731322,
0.1295266002,
-0.7940473557,
0.5026623011,
-0.342721045,
-0.8549184203,
-0.0337390043,
0.0221954677,
-0.4994237125,
-0.1427811235,
0.1915263832,
0.2003850192,
-0.8165559769,
0.0028502564,
-0.0103604086,
-0.1712695807,
0.5329048634,
-0.1858515888,
0.8270112872,
0.6109334826,
-0.2307009846,
-0.0804667026,
-1.044470787,
0.1113777384,
-0.1929977983,
-0.4820826948,
-0.0901716053,
0.1099944934,
-0.4429607987,
-0.3071294129,
0.2888199091,
-1.0985149145,
0.046614036,
-0.067840077,
0.2115451694,
0.0910615996,
0.2810096145,
0.1169365942,
-0.5015099049,
0.0754205659,
-0.0294046607,
0.1859638989,
-0.0492631756,
-0.292444557,
-0.7755257487,
-0.6533936262,
0.5030021667,
0.7161321044,
-0.8457243443,
0.7208002806,
-0.2852637172,
-0.4867219627,
0.1104525104,
0.1275020093,
0.5515050292,
1.0069403648,
0.3807725608,
-0.0543065369,
-0.9075940847,
-0.8336549401,
-0.0603354722,
-0.237778917,
-0.1799969375,
-0.1594358683,
0.3234704137,
-0.1632751673,
1.1539574862,
-0.7991707921,
-0.0792179853,
0.1730122268,
0.0228451416,
0.5811722279,
0.4500633478,
0.426086694,
-0.6913840175,
-0.4080479741,
-0.040258687,
-1.0218868256,
-0.3359360993,
0.4968669713,
-0.0716612712,
0.141823113,
0.7199127674,
-0.345174849,
0.4724746943,
0.3483991921,
-0.6281309128,
0.3342403173,
-0.3420459628,
0.6699512005,
-0.8042663932,
0.4099918604,
0.1865566969,
-0.866504848,
-0.6012638211,
-0.2097695917,
0.1713186502,
0.1755020618,
-0.3362440467,
0.1421789825,
-0.277377516,
0.1141313463,
-0.1516466886,
-0.1288461536,
0.4143998623,
-0.1851941496,
-0.2959916294,
0.570623219,
0.9137935042,
-0.9854391813,
0.9535678625,
0.149306953,
-0.4489037097,
0.8391928077,
-0.737914741,
-0.0708781481,
-0.2346609384,
0.2206012011,
-0.8567964435,
-0.5611766577,
0.346668303,
-0.4804869294,
0.137519002,
-0.354210794,
-0.3961135149,
-0.4394743443,
-0.0222756453,
-0.2425062805,
0.7643738985,
-0.5888729692,
0.4095004797,
0.6337977052,
-0.0056205657,
-0.9237677455,
-0.1260856241,
-0.0559939817,
0.1882392913,
-0.4573553205,
0.1728338152,
0.1324525177,
-0.4745726287,
-0.0565224849,
-0.1768475473,
-0.0358054861,
0.0649745092,
0.3994718492,
0.2049363703,
-0.3799848258,
0.2526082695,
0.1204758584,
-0.3338720798,
-0.2289102823,
-0.4713665545,
0.0285909083,
-0.3849563599,
-0.3201742768,
0.1338107586,
-0.066425845,
0.6327732205,
-0.0949270949,
0.2391283214,
-0.022669591,
-0.5949002504,
-0.1116815209,
-0.5410887003,
0.2000834793,
-0.4782526493,
-0.0357894786,
-0.4276324809,
-0.5144376755,
0.2955019176,
-0.0762304589,
0.3672653437,
0.5378983021,
0.3121284246,
-0.0544700958,
0.652808845,
0.4853725433,
0.02876449,
-0.3320046961,
-0.0373010971,
0.0726865977,
-0.2499971092,
-0.4982998967,
-0.9966468811,
-0.1181597114,
-0.2429445088,
-0.4200955927,
0.6134697199,
-0.1413167119,
-0.3529336154,
0.1306412667,
-0.5827327371,
0.9557119012,
0.2785346806,
0.1736113131,
0.5509093404,
-0.062065199,
-0.0222963374,
0.4349510372,
-0.3505512774,
-0.6350120902,
0.9982612133,
0.1379581541,
0.7961736321,
0.4090802372,
0.6124632359,
0.7475404739,
0.3250202239,
-0.3942583203,
0.3178479075,
-0.7688930631,
-0.6424331069,
-0.6578733921,
-0.212718308,
-0.8696521521,
0.1019008905,
-0.3934875727,
-0.5562187433,
0.2716163397,
0.4706314504,
-0.6360926628,
-0.1286709607,
-0.5656269193,
0.4000200331,
-0.0634953231,
-0.4976961911,
0.1074355766,
-0.5984777212,
0.2403630465,
0.1472922713,
0.2687009573,
-0.3231082559,
-0.0069599706,
0.5537565947,
-0.8789226413,
0.4572561681,
-0.0626684055,
0.4177105725,
0.3469773233,
0.1454195976,
0.3754938543,
0.4042427242,
-0.4247750938,
-0.1021672934,
0.3859472573,
-0.3394990861,
-0.3098073304,
0.5924395919,
-0.823943913,
-0.4682642221,
-0.7399348021,
-0.1202815101,
-0.0995420814,
0.4430776536,
0.5964331031,
0.9771198034,
-0.5947862267,
0.3692625463,
0.9967432022,
0.1681349874,
0.22201626,
0.92153579,
-0.1809831262,
-0.3873920143,
0.9407521486,
-0.0211769063,
-0.4376582205,
0.363135457,
0.329962194,
-0.2836908996,
-0.2841826975,
-0.5974323153,
-0.0130879339,
-0.9008777738,
-0.8549808264,
-0.7490161657,
-0.366063714,
-0.9136500359,
-0.1760530323,
-0.4138654768,
-0.4176743627,
0.0702802464,
-0.0000966962,
0.6736362576,
1.1231608391,
-0.7133563757,
0.2053021044,
-0.5334591866,
0.6837483644,
0.2731672525,
0.429169625,
-0.9352479577,
-0.4640567005,
-0.1466935873,
0.0301811062,
-0.2517943978,
-0.7365171909,
0.1961446553,
0.4767144322,
0.4984711409,
0.684209764,
0.4921184778,
0.1642882228,
-0.2566867173,
0.5087229013,
0.0390973724,
-1.1224558353,
0.6782516837,
0.095961377,
0.1595931053,
0.8025245667,
0.4554285109,
-0.4263577759,
-0.287876606,
-0.7870857716,
-0.5066906214,
0.6683885455,
0.1390810609,
-0.4378301203,
0.0007759602,
0.3695506752,
0.3795801997,
0.1879274845,
-0.0503935702,
-0.4669542611,
-0.4578670263,
-0.3138394654,
-0.4537912607,
-0.1701543182,
-0.3621231616,
0.0449742302,
0.9870681763,
-0.1701594144,
-0.1842751652,
0.5405461788,
-0.5012142658,
-0.2367160171,
0.0490937345,
0.461860925,
0.6479274035,
-0.3760684729,
0.6495994329,
0.1014357507,
-0.37589553,
0.5057361722,
-0.0214581843,
-0.4647156298,
0.3101676702,
0.3688471615,
0.4762858748,
0.1963877082,
-0.2110001445,
0.5554543138,
-0.1424714923,
-0.195977509,
-0.1080059856,
0.4470119476,
-0.3227815032,
0.1002637669,
0.2280714661,
0.432864964,
0.4349518418,
-0.2704843283,
0.6935073137,
0.2498442978,
-0.1227916777,
-0.0540836044,
0.2581474483,
0.4174478948,
-0.2435922921,
0.685924232,
-0.2628048658,
-0.5501767397,
0.7474031448,
0.2246273309,
0.3701244593,
-0.1575977206,
0.4670004547,
0.5687835217,
0.3663825095,
-0.2043510973,
0.1809688658,
-0.1567706615,
-0.7617701888,
-0.1822689176,
-0.7330811024,
-0.7908998728,
-0.112885803,
-0.5143327713,
0.6194546819,
-0.5782936811,
-0.2044499815,
0.3532685637,
0.0292302836,
-0.7468545437,
0.5325090289,
0.200926438,
1.2028081417,
-1.2639063597,
0.6922112703,
0.8196936846,
-0.1579422653,
-0.3951001167,
-0.2542570233,
0.5047684908,
-0.6365867257,
0.652721405,
-0.1017496064,
-0.3725493252,
0.0198382754,
-0.7733482718,
-1.5733326674,
0.6938374043,
0.465359807,
-0.1751916856,
0.4420842528,
-0.1265140325,
0.4343819022,
-0.5529467463,
0.2992679179,
0.7363324165,
0.3918053806,
0.6775887609,
-0.7746130824,
0.0686741024,
-0.4023781717,
-0.63169837,
-0.1851073653,
-0.726121068,
0.5599281192,
-0.3101712763,
-0.0971727967,
-0.2730270326,
0.9291911125,
0.2036912292,
0.6195751429,
0.5819776654,
0.2814209759,
1.2860481739,
-0.3810980618,
0.9962005615,
-0.4343468845,
0.2400932312,
0.7617506385,
-0.3326835036,
0.3592363596,
0.0817549452,
-0.0759270936,
0.5378513932,
0.6142600775,
0.0450319126,
0.4694231451,
0.2828282118,
-0.1165168807,
-0.5301755667,
-0.0244069044,
-0.2460942566,
0.5996191502,
0.5878790021,
0.0895309225,
-0.4479257464,
-0.0204721168,
0.309384197,
-0.2364919931,
-0.1184527203,
0.6919206977,
-0.3061110675,
-1.1919888258,
0.5677445531,
0.0864936635,
0.3145615757,
-0.643907249,
0.1407095045,
-0.1665721536,
0.1620084792,
-0.4330844283,
-0.7330743074,
0.3942846358,
0.29771927,
-0.5378118753,
-0.1057816595,
1.0686914921,
-0.1232731864,
-0.3891881108,
-0.552218914,
0.3432032168,
0.4428083897,
0.3216181993,
-0.3230835199,
0.2082851976,
0.0738870054,
-0.1222243458,
-0.2939125001,
0.5741459727,
0.1548543125,
0.7663615346,
0.565778017,
0.2718121111,
-0.1569019109,
-0.1733812243,
0.7249465585,
-0.2037495822,
-0.5119687915,
-0.7509731054,
0.4196403325,
-0.5641919374,
-0.3400357068,
0.4686872363,
0.8695824146,
0.3494527638,
0.2047410607,
1.0046973228,
-0.5611129403,
0.9067625403,
-0.494961381,
0.6818460822,
-0.1408741325,
0.1471633017,
0.1443821937,
-0.5051721931,
-0.300912708,
0.7353708148,
-0.091551967,
-0.4745818377,
0.8608319163,
0.9324762225,
-0.0552067757,
0.2882151306,
0.2509099543,
0.2905590832,
0.4088088572,
0.2692112923,
0.5535272956,
-0.3752841949,
0.2392281145,
-0.5464335084,
-0.7682390809,
-0.3887932599,
-1.1407244205,
-0.6822034717,
-0.564933002,
-0.81461519,
-0.7382737994,
0.4796127677,
1.1070832014,
0.7688845396,
-1.1236171722,
-0.0988647193,
0.4176463485,
0.4165661931,
-0.0152659444,
-0.0090895947,
0.2289599478,
-0.6063341498,
-0.3631110191,
0.4250099361,
0.4111848176,
-0.0162764993,
0.2577343583,
-0.0729770213,
-0.0092375334,
0.2199227363,
0.5080789924,
0.7257770896,
-0.0601502843,
-0.4697507024,
-0.0737967864,
-0.4729630947,
-0.116255261,
1.0691230297,
-0.9955911636,
0.2796474993,
0.7340047359,
0.3563337624,
0.0830330849,
0.0938606411,
0.5173502564,
-0.8716496825,
-0.0365115106,
-0.1800131351,
0.580688715,
0.4811534286,
-0.4931791723,
0.6143971086,
0.452673018,
-0.5763318539,
-0.902951479,
-0.0330942497,
-0.7102091908,
-0.043109417,
1.0707315207,
-0.1719566137,
-0.4560671449,
-0.6741921902,
0.3417304158,
0.4664688706,
-0.1771229953,
0.6634033322,
0.4955217242,
-0.2553997934,
0.3543252349,
0.1237694845,
0.8003956079,
0.0957845151,
-0.737087965,
0.1282441914,
0.6700770855,
0.592381835,
0.2454619706,
0.7231898308,
-0.0117901415,
0.3243308067,
-0.0103182327,
-0.0380809605,
-0.3035735488,
-0.5333467126,
0.1538001299,
0.2829302847,
0.1405539364,
-0.2410164773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16894v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16894v4 | ViewRefer: Grasp the Multi-view Knowledge for 3D Visual Grounding with GPT and Prototype Guidance | 2023-03-29T17:59:10 | 2023-12-05T05:34:18 | Zoey Guo, Yiwen Tang, Ray Zhang, Dong Wang, Zhigang Wang, Bin Zhao, Xuelong Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Understanding 3D scenes from multi-view inputs has been proven to alleviate
the view discrepancy issue in 3D visual grounding. However, existing methods
normally neglect the view cues embedded in the text modality and fail to weigh
the relative importance of different views. In this paper, we propose
ViewRefer, a multi-view framework for 3D visual grounding exploring how to
grasp the view knowledge from both text and 3D modalities. For the text branch,
ViewRefer leverages the diverse linguistic knowledge of large-scale language
models, e.g., GPT, to expand a single grounding text to multiple
geometry-consistent descriptions. Meanwhile, in the 3D modality, a transformer
fusion module with inter-view attention is introduced to boost the interaction
of objects across views. On top of that, we further present a set of learnable
multi-view prototypes, which memorize scene-agnostic knowledge for different
views, and enhance the framework from two perspectives: a view-guided attention
module for more robust text features, and a view-guided scoring strategy during
the final prediction. With our designed paradigm, ViewRefer achieves superior
performance on three benchmarks and surpasses the second-best by +2.8%, +1.5%,
and +1.35% on Sr3D, Nr3D, and ScanRefer. Code is released at
https://github.com/Ivan-Tang-3D/ViewRefer3D. | [
-0.5659881234,
-0.3658814132,
0.8132173419,
0.4048489034,
-0.3525687158,
-0.2267951667,
0.4168452621,
-0.3962897658,
0.0771446228,
0.589754343,
-0.34661448,
-0.3347840905,
-0.6370701194,
-0.0974122509,
-0.2868531346,
0.6255021095,
-0.1725227088,
0.0485702418,
-0.513489902,
-0.0971286148,
-0.1945446283,
-0.6153686047,
-0.0171829592,
-0.3509349823,
0.3928929567,
0.4754349291,
0.4722909331,
0.4701159894,
0.5974078774,
0.2471212894,
-0.1050387397,
0.2945786119,
-0.3721727133,
-0.3317747116,
-0.1565124243,
-0.1841992736,
-0.3312869668,
0.0372788645,
0.3695951104,
0.6816294193,
0.0682531148,
-0.2881270349,
0.1995866448,
0.9988598228,
-0.7731557488,
-0.0144052757,
0.0053740293,
0.1706484407,
0.2681861818,
-0.0416345932,
-0.309495002,
-0.2679508924,
0.5016536713,
-0.7895377874,
0.5332451463,
0.3067778647,
0.7857887149,
0.3277458549,
-0.2767127156,
0.6279321313,
-0.3232481182,
0.4537944198,
-0.2312746793,
0.8019499183,
0.3463948071,
0.4656090438,
0.097398065,
-0.6255660057,
-0.3207577765,
0.0241664182,
-0.240898177,
0.622484684,
0.3740963936,
0.2828819454,
0.159744516,
0.8701715469,
-0.4587350786,
-0.4818561673,
-0.1992788017,
-0.2517587543,
-0.1238476783,
-0.2538944185,
0.027389599,
-0.5674738884,
-0.7775979638,
-0.3592143357,
-0.4310441315,
0.0310274977,
-0.0005936506,
-0.0309849437,
-0.6009314656,
0.6517643929,
-0.3384564519,
0.8738358617,
0.187873587,
-0.0804860145,
0.2199683189,
-0.2625720203,
-0.5193982124,
-0.0805860758,
0.6107754111,
0.7952969074,
-0.0142800603,
-0.0799152628,
0.0936185718,
-0.259005785,
0.5428615808,
-0.6250912547,
-0.5162112117,
-0.0182863642,
-0.5397954583,
-0.1184954047,
0.4398889244,
-1.0681233406,
-1.0739840269,
-0.1305347532,
0.3334903717,
-0.4863388538,
-0.4537871182,
0.4097405076,
-0.5328766704,
0.3922612369,
0.7846462727,
-0.7342452407,
0.0615316294,
0.3389609754,
0.8387228251,
-0.0569754764,
-0.4911992252,
-0.381565541,
0.4694530368,
-0.3379236162,
1.0294206142,
-0.1940804422,
-0.4153845012,
-0.2112790197,
-0.0394729674,
-0.2062374949,
-0.2953334749,
0.0512709692,
-0.14076671,
0.6989160776,
-0.2873333395,
-0.020067174,
-0.7807998061,
0.7966083884,
-0.9353196025,
0.6730303168,
0.1764301658,
-1.0642793179,
0.6467050314,
-0.2645351887,
-0.4215964973,
-0.1006689221,
-0.601505518,
0.028232554,
0.2575408518,
0.5917952657,
0.4435011446,
-0.3939763308,
0.0037400473,
-0.1053763628,
-0.1443908066,
-0.5757693648,
-0.2697676718,
-0.0770033523,
-0.2709764838,
-0.266230315,
0.3052975237,
-0.7734863758,
-0.1152367145,
-0.0780801475,
-0.256904453,
-0.1743835509,
0.004793793,
0.255439043,
0.2934936881,
-0.1813796759,
-0.1578955799,
-0.1400935501,
-0.6471044421,
0.062451791,
0.2325430959,
0.0833029523,
0.5643206835,
-0.2885399461,
0.2727754712,
0.2226971537,
0.0645954013,
-0.6839933991,
-0.4608238637,
-0.7026777267,
-0.1171801537,
-0.2349704653,
0.4808217585,
-0.9118328691,
0.0114709735,
-0.21213682,
-0.2461891472,
-0.1671556383,
-0.0738409236,
0.7122433782,
0.5598827004,
0.5600828528,
-0.098824732,
-0.5366674066,
-1.1704772711,
-0.0862481892,
-0.3062996566,
-0.1967954636,
0.1494652033,
0.1645852774,
0.185822323,
0.7076926231,
-0.4183316827,
-0.6512641311,
-0.4687280357,
-0.1368748695,
0.0604099222,
0.5448729396,
0.5635411739,
-1.233194232,
-0.0077714291,
0.3256850541,
-0.8440659642,
0.5075409412,
-0.0322738364,
-0.1825358272,
-0.0851694867,
0.6641030908,
-0.1963966936,
0.4064884186,
0.6202107072,
-0.409588784,
0.1937439889,
-0.185138315,
0.5083115697,
-1.1417415142,
0.0004991213,
0.2653305531,
-0.2508193552,
-0.3294250667,
-0.0290214792,
0.2601884305,
0.2057380974,
-0.8533923626,
0.5441577435,
-0.4762573242,
0.0614464767,
-0.1687055975,
0.4510721862,
0.6613170505,
0.6242570877,
0.4275735021,
0.6371338367,
0.2997214794,
-0.6956110001,
0.2672843933,
0.4296129048,
-0.4870463312,
0.5702893138,
-0.4441751242,
-0.0217377506,
-0.1047546491,
0.030199226,
-1.1008956432,
-0.3795145154,
0.0657120422,
-0.3783304989,
-0.136717543,
-0.3716383278,
-0.4315536022,
-0.2604893744,
-0.1259725839,
0.3864063621,
0.0318270586,
-0.8239991069,
1.1072951555,
0.1769864559,
0.352470994,
-0.5165680647,
-0.4965274036,
0.0613856055,
-0.1221528575,
-0.6831290722,
0.3999620676,
0.0978050008,
-0.1113637239,
-0.2178629786,
-0.4698606133,
0.1657957286,
-0.2409466654,
0.5451773405,
0.0348847806,
-0.0280198492,
-0.354817301,
-0.1060741618,
-0.3908323944,
-0.0308795534,
-0.3592881858,
0.3635350466,
-0.3098977506,
-0.5712623,
-0.1910492927,
0.2301540226,
0.8566876054,
-0.0614841916,
0.2897876799,
0.3434736133,
-0.5643284917,
0.3525629938,
-0.9068066478,
-0.0164694395,
-0.4150193036,
0.5662589669,
-0.7661643028,
-0.6082198024,
0.3910076022,
-0.3131795824,
0.0235674568,
0.3159039617,
0.1256146878,
0.1480653733,
1.2004122734,
1.2877663374,
0.0347847492,
0.3473000228,
-0.3817511797,
-0.0288981218,
-1.1112034321,
-0.7976800799,
-0.2128402144,
-0.1037478298,
0.2592608631,
-0.5955184698,
0.1569578499,
0.4338701367,
-0.1625255346,
0.1721886396,
-0.3917723596,
0.5879203677,
0.4627238214,
0.0633234978,
0.5196790695,
-0.0557517186,
-0.5518109798,
-0.3552643657,
-0.5980849862,
-0.2667160034,
0.2210461944,
0.1168030724,
0.6285123825,
0.0820039287,
0.1300575137,
-0.0935134217,
-0.0059195925,
-0.7414671779,
0.3013021946,
-0.1216006801,
-0.2515546083,
0.2866081297,
-0.0868508145,
0.0615675449,
0.8570359945,
-0.2948771715,
-0.6104657054,
0.2722952068,
0.2893612981,
-0.3601800501,
0.42804268,
-0.7580450177,
0.9542708397,
-0.2630075514,
-0.5604904294,
-0.0290952139,
-0.6948156953,
0.4452268779,
0.1416622549,
0.2278664708,
0.1180698425,
0.1632267833,
0.4840630293,
-0.1387756169,
0.7447012663,
-0.1759300679,
-0.3175927401,
-0.1983927637,
0.2290852815,
0.0072963275,
0.6084162593,
0.1255281419,
-0.023190761,
-0.0620376654,
0.0462136902,
-0.4949886501,
0.3758114278,
-0.6781996489,
-0.6841145754,
-0.3004204333,
-0.2193944454,
-0.4374499321,
0.6950550675,
0.5823091865,
0.414752692,
-0.3275517821,
0.2244788855,
0.7871720791,
-0.2224548906,
0.2207025141,
0.1657031476,
-0.6575935483,
-0.7838260531,
0.5129255056,
-0.8370628953,
0.3237820268,
0.9724744558,
0.0040603387,
-0.389801681,
-0.3198792338,
-0.7073571086,
0.0864054635,
-0.8320545554,
-0.355350405,
-0.8412995338,
-0.2238906175,
-0.328674376,
-0.5993186831,
-0.6396135092,
-0.1756912172,
0.1164138913,
-0.4274381995,
0.3729949296,
0.6767664552,
-0.0066940757,
0.4568833411,
-0.7890433073,
0.9048463702,
0.3100066781,
0.6766500473,
-0.1978362352,
-0.2722692788,
-0.0909853876,
0.0001330632,
0.1088001281,
-0.4157810211,
0.1268998384,
-0.0538408719,
0.6085461378,
0.5367721915,
-0.0756834447,
1.0027104616,
-0.433883667,
0.7315022945,
0.763625145,
-0.7532405853,
0.6879128218,
-0.3224039674,
0.5874236226,
0.6486113071,
-0.2181487828,
-0.7806093097,
-0.3029054999,
-0.296071142,
-0.8397690654,
0.9462246299,
0.0418774225,
-0.1117159873,
0.2290146649,
0.2867527604,
0.1696118265,
0.1358011812,
-0.4814039767,
-0.1465087235,
-0.7709822059,
0.2238417119,
-0.1333232969,
-0.1796660274,
-0.3950429261,
-0.0792759359,
0.0565302558,
-0.3416118622,
0.081191808,
0.5195880532,
-0.1581448466,
0.1925398111,
-0.2832726538,
0.5105269551,
0.697711587,
-0.2503809631,
0.4008699059,
-0.0075569935,
-0.9783463478,
-0.1616583765,
0.1116805077,
0.1363602579,
-0.3107910752,
0.2493773401,
0.786486268,
0.4861815274,
-0.353992939,
0.5109032989,
-0.263774246,
-0.7550814748,
-0.1654199213,
-0.1004998609,
-0.1655677557,
0.2755126655,
0.2669119835,
0.5380803347,
0.2320758551,
0.2016102374,
0.3407736719,
-0.0410986431,
-0.8384472728,
-0.1538813412,
1.0755133629,
0.488679558,
0.2568268478,
0.4866881669,
0.4270671904,
-0.6830483079,
0.6514986157,
0.3913596869,
0.8192880154,
0.1226575896,
0.1423436999,
0.4682834744,
0.1745838672,
-0.4938202798,
0.0988472104,
0.0268097427,
-0.7816090584,
-0.4903180599,
-0.3048775792,
-0.3853387535,
0.073397629,
-0.5859637856,
0.3405609429,
-0.6934611797,
0.3007389903,
-0.4071847498,
-0.2591862679,
-0.5511223674,
0.4950356185,
0.3066569269,
0.9093399644,
-0.4328924119,
0.4901207387,
1.308224678,
-0.3076209724,
-0.3506079316,
0.0635276213,
0.4196943045,
-0.6779459119,
0.292262882,
0.5449922085,
-0.8109480143,
0.0870635882,
-0.0934554189,
-0.8082599044,
0.8433638215,
0.0606347881,
-0.1209290773,
0.0439073853,
-0.1816392392,
-0.0119382897,
-0.1965042502,
0.1979459077,
0.182648778,
0.5162232518,
0.572681427,
-0.7368683815,
-0.1595428735,
-0.5366539955,
0.0101786982,
0.1987407655,
-0.5964628458,
0.4405119717,
-0.446911484,
-0.0137442332,
-0.0735375211,
0.7890331745,
0.4794614911,
0.0126229841,
0.5364843607,
0.498901546,
0.1886451244,
-0.064898707,
0.8760045767,
-0.1492333412,
0.0356739089,
1.0465819836,
-0.2187362462,
0.4020681083,
0.5477350354,
0.2120420337,
0.1594024003,
0.5586666465,
0.1553849429,
0.9360520244,
-0.3156766891,
0.1803795099,
-0.5864226222,
0.3194320798,
-0.6044923067,
0.3169003129,
0.3242540061,
-0.0406942964,
-0.4517899454,
0.3118864298,
-0.1174149811,
0.3422702849,
-0.1424444169,
0.8552765846,
0.1264249235,
-0.4316710532,
0.1605121344,
-0.0307193417,
0.5752418041,
-0.5243699551,
-0.3927769661,
-0.3903189898,
0.5640406609,
-0.2134995759,
-0.7661280036,
-0.0661889985,
-0.4752852917,
-0.6532937884,
-0.5273120999,
0.4571233988,
-0.0953048393,
-0.3521347642,
0.4999716282,
0.6496785879,
-0.1646456271,
-0.461573869,
-0.2598536313,
-0.1605861187,
0.2205737829,
-0.2017071545,
0.2725315094,
0.496216327,
0.023637943,
0.5182040334,
0.3576189578,
-0.2847610414,
-0.1270679981,
0.458308965,
0.8220486045,
-0.7756664157,
-0.5984413624,
-0.5968099833,
0.6462279558,
-0.1862998009,
-0.3692690134,
0.7747609615,
0.8565604687,
0.9040950537,
-0.0876399279,
0.8806084991,
-0.1664703041,
0.4971169233,
-0.7211740017,
0.6958121061,
-0.7334552407,
0.0763856843,
-0.4764430523,
-1.1840121746,
-0.8561773896,
0.9516373873,
-0.0804455653,
0.102376096,
1.016076684,
0.2762707174,
-0.2094177753,
0.0570587032,
0.4511299431,
-0.2474448532,
0.5453504324,
0.4309861362,
0.8317301869,
-0.6005733013,
0.6545467377,
-0.5059789419,
-0.2754923999,
-0.024584556,
-0.9150474668,
-0.9849932194,
-0.601451993,
-0.1380828023,
-0.181782648,
-0.1642431319,
0.246986255,
0.9410654902,
-0.4690132439,
-0.0371301435,
-0.1231504604,
0.1719062626,
-0.5188643336,
-0.1214363575,
0.4139607847,
0.1021416783,
-0.6972794533,
0.3969865143,
0.4139531553,
0.2297117114,
0.0638045669,
0.0769112706,
-0.0907234624,
-0.685392499,
0.8089153767,
0.1103577912,
-0.7324504256,
-0.4106376171,
0.2436876595,
-0.0271297116,
0.1701024473,
0.9963244796,
-1.1806087494,
0.4796857238,
0.4300647676,
0.3935536146,
0.4290325046,
0.4328309596,
0.8610491753,
-0.6087313294,
0.5397489667,
-0.1101211831,
0.4950776696,
0.4678597152,
-0.3475851119,
0.5307049751,
0.1841649711,
-0.0394104086,
-0.1892940551,
0.3232598007,
-0.9296246767,
-0.027666267,
0.9719663262,
0.1994662583,
-0.0711145326,
-0.312671721,
-0.5283049345,
-0.1591132283,
-0.2032541335,
0.5498130322,
0.6101992726,
0.0174470935,
-0.7026933432,
-0.6133288145,
0.6265322566,
0.1809053719,
-0.6725127697,
0.2625048459,
0.9023802876,
-0.0203027539,
0.3662848771,
0.4600431323,
-0.4507277906,
0.2887021303,
0.1272450238,
0.2348580658,
-0.1749626696,
-0.8049875498,
-0.0909644216,
0.2657184601,
-0.2485051006,
-0.3351470828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16886v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16886v1 | End-to-End $n$-ary Relation Extraction for Combination Drug Therapies | 2023-03-29T17:55:50 | 2023-03-29T17:55:50 | Yuhang Jiang, Ramakanth Kavuluru | cs.CL | cs.CL | Combination drug therapies are treatment regimens that involve two or more
drugs, administered more commonly for patients with cancer, HIV, malaria, or
tuberculosis. Currently there are over 350K articles in PubMed that use the
"combination drug therapy" MeSH heading with at least 10K articles published
per year over the past two decades. Extracting combination therapies from
scientific literature inherently constitutes an $n$-ary relation extraction
problem. Unlike in the general $n$-ary setting where $n$ is fixed (e.g.,
drug-gene-mutation relations where $n=3$), extracting combination therapies is
a special setting where $n \geq 2$ is dynamic, depending on each instance.
Recently, Tiktinsky et al. (NAACL 2022) introduced a first of its kind dataset,
CombDrugExt, for extracting such therapies from literature. Here, we use a
sequence-to-sequence style end-to-end extraction method to achieve an F1-Score
of $66.7\%$ on the CombDrugExt test set for positive (or effective)
combinations. This is an absolute $\approx 5\%$ F1-score improvement even over
the prior best relation classification score with spotted drug entities (hence,
not end-to-end). Thus our effort introduces a state-of-the-art first model for
end-to-end extraction that is already superior to the best prior non end-to-end
model for this task. Our model seamlessly extracts all drug entities and
relations in a single pass and is highly suitable for dynamic $n$-ary
extraction scenarios. | [
-0.6099750996,
-0.6800205112,
0.3048982024,
0.0702964813,
-0.5741062164,
0.2223920673,
0.0033077986,
-0.5708485246,
0.527495265,
0.6031852365,
-0.5023351908,
-0.2145924121,
-0.8257423043,
0.3422473967,
-0.6302248836,
1.2821469307,
-0.0551975779,
0.1291862577,
-0.2330528349,
-0.2538378537,
-0.1733963042,
-0.1548432559,
-0.467037946,
-0.6031464338,
0.9658702016,
0.0968665332,
0.6868761182,
0.2951411009,
0.6956404448,
0.1332936883,
-0.2052054703,
0.0178083628,
-0.6060758829,
0.3799000978,
-0.3593615294,
-0.1320109367,
-0.4173267484,
0.0057798927,
0.2229600102,
0.8788868189,
-0.1233441234,
-0.0600365177,
-0.2499907017,
0.6741411686,
-0.5904768109,
-0.4047130644,
-0.2194787264,
0.1275940835,
-0.3771181405,
-0.2257486731,
-0.2040584534,
-0.0881035328,
0.3463859558,
-0.6430807114,
-0.1275544167,
-0.0290672183,
1.0180338621,
-0.0935227424,
-0.7248602509,
-0.4473516047,
-0.5031956434,
0.6046358943,
-0.6616774797,
0.4275046885,
0.1200322658,
0.3704755008,
-0.7540103793,
-0.9335111976,
-0.4383190572,
-0.2818416953,
-0.144163996,
0.2394153625,
-0.0860798061,
0.0888817832,
0.0858545974,
0.8199645877,
-0.4931771159,
0.2076631188,
-0.700001061,
-0.1025890484,
0.3494190276,
0.1979040354,
0.5142043233,
-0.2764776051,
-0.7937081456,
0.2016615719,
-0.7065261602,
0.0289076269,
-0.0560855567,
-0.0328620039,
0.203516677,
0.5298253894,
0.0571290515,
0.8258165717,
0.121681504,
-0.2936807275,
-0.0776975974,
-0.7886866331,
-0.2979626656,
-0.0756679997,
1.1014287472,
0.3621451259,
0.1515037566,
-0.6307001114,
-0.0797415897,
-0.308247894,
0.1428558528,
-0.8278090358,
-0.4246698022,
0.475648731,
-0.5326476693,
-0.4583525658,
0.0522919595,
-1.1003303528,
-0.0724647045,
-0.1526658237,
0.6809179783,
-0.6759036183,
-0.6079051495,
0.0643695667,
-0.3366729915,
0.5473482609,
0.1295918524,
-0.5258406401,
0.7180729508,
0.622990191,
1.0359869003,
-0.5569899082,
-0.1894981563,
-0.8982585669,
0.209802568,
-0.3049476147,
1.141458869,
-0.4958031178,
-0.4853600562,
-0.243661359,
-0.1890184134,
-0.1692110151,
-0.3827037215,
0.378644079,
-0.5184012055,
0.4515404999,
-0.3397966921,
-0.8275991082,
0.0186839681,
-0.0035997087,
-0.9550427198,
0.4772358835,
0.3593750894,
-0.6625851989,
0.2049823254,
-0.666826129,
-0.5269821882,
0.0603410043,
-0.0316376649,
-0.3321743906,
-0.0351969339,
0.2123268545,
0.0244167931,
-0.512712121,
0.4392254949,
-0.4207310379,
-0.2473077774,
0.4728465974,
-0.1465583891,
1.1026412249,
0.4259422719,
0.1027618945,
-0.0355300121,
-0.7548834682,
-0.179190591,
0.0588380061,
-0.2269015163,
-0.3716034293,
-0.7269074321,
0.0488655642,
0.6122031808,
0.1545996517,
-0.7697516084,
0.2733112574,
-0.2873897851,
0.396528542,
0.5212677717,
0.6418167949,
0.2850182056,
-0.502840817,
0.5339704156,
-0.0000915261,
0.0959927514,
-0.2392426431,
-0.519139111,
-0.3568306565,
-0.2700456083,
0.8864561319,
0.4038233459,
-0.8605040908,
0.2092474401,
-0.1420422941,
-0.3032765687,
-0.0106486343,
0.0867640749,
0.5373840332,
0.2874396145,
0.39173612,
-0.4767022133,
-0.4749155045,
-0.6828650236,
-0.1610554308,
0.2046726644,
0.3399215043,
-0.0489319488,
0.6443905234,
0.1902694553,
1.0127973557,
-0.4952504337,
-0.5323904157,
-0.182203874,
0.2424999326,
0.3858320713,
0.1852841526,
0.4300020635,
-0.8353536129,
-0.6037735939,
0.1447474062,
-0.523370564,
-0.1800357699,
-0.0489892066,
-0.6067019701,
-0.2042970955,
0.3981886208,
-0.553219974,
0.3677992225,
0.2144967318,
-0.1634075046,
0.3668953776,
-0.4847466648,
-0.0804748833,
-1.1696357727,
0.1709603816,
0.1723950058,
-0.2055692077,
-0.9293835759,
-0.0378055461,
-0.1279823631,
0.2724126577,
-0.3201197684,
0.3291312754,
-0.6907075644,
-0.1184467226,
-0.165666014,
-0.2045010626,
0.2660651505,
0.4409457445,
-0.0953914449,
0.5542603135,
0.1896446645,
-0.471855402,
0.427881211,
0.3055596352,
0.1328312755,
0.5840700865,
-0.4707882702,
0.0395034403,
0.2494603693,
0.4127743542,
-0.8213708997,
-0.2661106288,
0.2914718091,
-0.3230707645,
0.478236407,
-0.0757089481,
-0.3653536141,
-0.199743554,
-0.3461760581,
0.1110742539,
0.3875512779,
-0.4243114293,
0.5159316659,
0.5124174953,
-0.2886153162,
-0.5769042373,
-0.4170177877,
0.3133464158,
-0.1478363872,
-0.3579806387,
0.6604532599,
0.0459671132,
-0.1758317202,
0.2572862506,
-0.2074336708,
-0.440906316,
-0.2182380408,
0.0075429468,
0.2565093935,
0.2333241403,
-0.0500654131,
0.154236719,
-0.4038302898,
-0.0955557376,
0.0331528522,
0.5071428418,
0.2743868828,
-0.1968623698,
0.0045181867,
0.902551949,
0.7247049212,
-0.6038469672,
0.6511045098,
0.4680490196,
-0.5193237066,
0.1268135756,
-0.093948707,
-0.0689518973,
-0.3608766794,
0.2366142124,
-0.3731141388,
-0.3690740466,
0.5942140818,
-0.1326801181,
0.1936001033,
0.3107925057,
0.6313163638,
0.1713616997,
0.5697309971,
0.3255474269,
0.1746492684,
0.4082809687,
-0.1875735968,
0.5482192039,
-0.9415063858,
-0.5344452262,
-0.1068239585,
-0.3039641082,
-0.3302290738,
-0.100753434,
0.701394558,
0.177626878,
0.0055909026,
0.5249444842,
-0.3168936074,
0.0550169088,
0.6511135101,
0.4953363836,
0.5054249763,
-0.0484794378,
-0.0071079433,
-0.0046237251,
-0.5101071596,
0.0927147716,
1.5506010056,
0.0047373767,
0.139562428,
0.4072042406,
1.0686317682,
0.0334001668,
0.4011874199,
-0.5984580517,
0.3800060153,
-0.2812651694,
-0.6750044823,
-0.0681658164,
-0.3332647085,
-1.2092849016,
0.1447729021,
-0.3086227179,
-0.7655002475,
0.598223567,
-0.3531514108,
-0.6720833182,
0.2572629452,
-0.4467388093,
0.6392998695,
-0.3221737742,
-0.638850987,
0.2384630442,
-0.8939539194,
0.6568485498,
-0.4525586367,
0.2915265858,
0.189888224,
-0.0349796191,
0.8566717505,
-0.8295060396,
0.1688461453,
-0.0358393975,
0.0476406105,
-0.0790591314,
-0.0039955769,
0.4726267159,
-0.2127534598,
0.1313932389,
0.0520542152,
0.3309865296,
-0.2609373927,
-0.7375722528,
0.6531043053,
-0.5048771501,
-0.0567342155,
-0.5153348446,
-0.5488857031,
0.0790307075,
0.3501681387,
0.5140894055,
0.8351367116,
0.1048916429,
-0.0134252189,
0.551530242,
-0.3371658027,
0.2843839824,
0.4930528998,
-0.5320945382,
-0.7291437984,
1.0567903519,
0.4352767766,
0.419495821,
0.461060822,
0.1506994665,
-0.4541035891,
-0.7227355838,
-0.100417845,
0.1511072516,
-0.3185618222,
-0.3315914869,
-0.7895614505,
-0.4460250437,
-0.3430530131,
0.0038909665,
-0.3073599935,
-0.3974629641,
-0.1266453862,
0.1431542337,
0.5865784287,
0.5693208575,
-0.4648756683,
0.0281406939,
-0.8020634651,
0.7222725749,
0.0867324769,
0.3307248354,
-0.2032597512,
-0.4974620044,
-0.023116488,
-0.0437686779,
-0.2654286325,
-1.340411067,
0.650365591,
0.5274012089,
0.6872118711,
0.457690984,
0.1328938901,
0.7933663726,
-0.1666190177,
0.4710355401,
0.5228139162,
-0.4936232865,
0.3844324648,
-0.3465261161,
-0.2024987638,
0.3627261221,
0.2807530761,
-0.4920638502,
-0.1190549359,
-0.7148308754,
-1.1025134325,
0.5227972269,
0.490832001,
-0.5990641713,
0.2214053273,
0.3865939379,
0.2772832513,
0.0962334648,
-0.40081352,
-0.5113295913,
0.0736998916,
-0.2293759733,
0.1350916475,
-0.2433251292,
-0.3652000427,
-0.2276601195,
0.556555748,
0.2503544688,
0.4246792793,
0.3016526997,
-0.2544014454,
-0.3510167301,
0.2131843269,
0.3450706601,
0.8173670173,
-0.7332244515,
0.0358069241,
-0.3585645854,
-0.4649458528,
0.091524221,
0.5544394255,
0.0596235879,
-0.0977381542,
0.6117284298,
0.2850145102,
0.4236340523,
-0.5942077041,
0.5378187895,
-0.0747308061,
-0.2684138119,
-0.3017022312,
0.0060614278,
-0.1616086215,
0.3793792725,
0.4330298305,
0.0452027582,
0.4883361459,
-0.4986742437,
0.9371373653,
0.4925805628,
-0.386589855,
-0.0476597361,
0.4797007442,
-0.085828349,
-0.5409205556,
0.4136877954,
-0.2158800215,
-0.3655028939,
0.5672855377,
0.6233560443,
0.5875428915,
0.0421149991,
0.321290642,
0.4139539003,
-0.0870148018,
0.0513752252,
0.1126552001,
0.0854551047,
-0.4903583527,
-0.3650763035,
-0.6172187924,
-0.5924232006,
0.169117853,
-0.9954584241,
0.2766661346,
-0.1759684682,
0.1661076695,
0.3806783855,
0.3584504128,
-0.1049632803,
-0.0627263039,
0.0026199096,
0.7753832936,
-0.7765772939,
0.9323622584,
0.716512382,
-0.5817496777,
-0.5565235019,
-0.2464657873,
-0.0684368983,
-0.4023514688,
0.1769865006,
0.0000303435,
0.3846265078,
-0.0687138066,
-0.349507004,
-0.9999061823,
1.3845981359,
0.1820192039,
-0.5748436451,
0.120935671,
0.0599242896,
0.5525262952,
-0.4715626836,
0.3751387894,
0.8201733232,
0.360773772,
0.5915828347,
-0.9410765171,
-0.069408372,
-0.5210800767,
-0.3651621044,
0.600708425,
-0.3465174437,
1.0876569748,
-0.1649446636,
-0.0595388375,
0.1578088552,
0.2491801232,
0.3862612247,
0.5758340359,
0.3983416259,
0.5737008452,
0.6981492043,
-0.0853715166,
0.9434779286,
-0.4572714865,
0.3514212072,
0.9632088542,
-0.1336642206,
0.6781942844,
0.643560946,
-0.6285820603,
0.3374705911,
0.844514668,
0.0682305619,
0.9197063446,
-0.1194138452,
-0.1385954171,
-0.2157925367,
-0.0573844425,
-0.413092047,
0.1556304395,
0.5227110386,
-0.3143591881,
-0.6106092334,
0.1014403477,
0.1823336482,
-0.22913073,
-0.0079788966,
0.8010718822,
0.3630676568,
-0.685320735,
0.5085518956,
-0.3628791869,
0.3019508421,
-0.5469200015,
-0.260232538,
-0.3282750249,
0.0441941582,
-0.1593157351,
-0.8339161873,
0.1361273676,
-0.2512455285,
-0.235254392,
0.3263567388,
0.6823322177,
-0.7149889469,
-0.5534411669,
0.4299108982,
0.5150158405,
0.0689781681,
0.1877354085,
-0.5873787403,
0.0175289735,
0.1339166164,
-0.1793862879,
0.6644551754,
0.2816614807,
0.0908313692,
0.4446666837,
0.9905661345,
0.3252807856,
0.001362533,
-0.4281948805,
1.0798755884,
-0.4039924443,
-0.196283415,
-0.7338714004,
0.3982098699,
-0.4237331748,
-0.4976815879,
0.3204723895,
0.3469373286,
-0.0840446949,
0.5975164175,
0.5504430532,
-0.0603743978,
0.4740074277,
-0.4406878948,
0.2049474865,
-0.5040161014,
0.2982861698,
-0.1638681293,
-0.8266357183,
-0.4569628239,
0.3023332357,
-0.2437581569,
-0.1030356139,
0.8577020764,
0.3864066601,
0.0431476422,
0.4486614466,
0.0670158565,
0.3608551919,
0.823348105,
0.9873431325,
0.3573684096,
-0.6156555414,
0.4698086381,
-0.495659858,
-0.5833230019,
-0.1264071167,
-0.7304855585,
-0.5040850043,
-0.3799126148,
-0.0376139283,
-0.6531944871,
0.2235898226,
1.0531299114,
0.3595584333,
-0.6907399893,
0.0271892231,
-0.2045696974,
0.2172534466,
-0.5526083708,
-0.1899687499,
0.4351894259,
0.0215354245,
-0.3746754527,
0.1913374364,
0.5061320662,
-0.1693655849,
-0.3877359629,
-0.2279780805,
-0.6777829528,
-0.1532525271,
0.3806931973,
0.4300897717,
-0.3320478499,
0.2476658076,
0.1554708332,
0.172136873,
0.1868521422,
0.6946263313,
-0.7708081603,
0.734257102,
0.3278343678,
0.4337899983,
0.5885136127,
-0.0364486724,
0.8356674314,
-0.0307757929,
-0.1368386,
0.0610134937,
0.3035506904,
0.0500964373,
-0.2868764699,
0.369443804,
0.2735607326,
-0.5391806364,
-1.0316410065,
0.0856492072,
-1.2407040596,
-0.3905532062,
1.1366990805,
-0.3095341325,
-0.3652409017,
-0.5263228416,
-0.1742109656,
0.3205741346,
-0.4009192288,
0.53119874,
0.4002279043,
-0.4491705298,
-0.4948818684,
-0.5945814848,
0.1190985069,
0.0239643212,
-0.7330095172,
-0.2495491803,
0.2947428524,
0.2050313056,
0.1177655905,
0.6878045797,
-0.3085345924,
0.1673383862,
-0.043648161,
-0.2367144227,
-0.3228347003,
-0.1643109173,
-0.1594566107,
0.4461555481,
-0.3894056678,
-0.1850974411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16857v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16857v3 | Did You Mean...? Confidence-based Trade-offs in Semantic Parsing | 2023-03-29T17:07:26 | 2023-10-20T12:54:30 | Elias Stengel-Eskin, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL | We illustrate how a calibrated model can help balance common trade-offs in
task-oriented parsing. In a simulated annotator-in-the-loop experiment, we show
that well-calibrated confidence scores allow us to balance cost with annotator
load, improving accuracy with a small number of interactions. We then examine
how confidence scores can help optimize the trade-off between usability and
safety. We show that confidence-based thresholding can substantially reduce the
number of incorrect low-confidence programs executed; however, this comes at a
cost to usability. We propose the DidYouMean system which better balances
usability and safety. | [
-0.2463870347,
-0.3152848184,
0.9380870461,
0.2189729661,
-0.3225908875,
-0.2555200458,
-0.0282734446,
-0.748762548,
0.3635773659,
0.5368090868,
-0.2386254072,
-0.4049690366,
-0.5134941339,
-0.1557337344,
-0.3002955019,
0.7588838339,
0.1529612839,
0.1874660552,
-0.3599269986,
0.1686704606,
-0.7389476299,
-0.5254530311,
-0.6262789965,
-0.6320466399,
0.5367481709,
0.5534527898,
1.0452921391,
0.5349955559,
0.8883721828,
0.2710780501,
-0.0608575828,
-0.1899578422,
-0.2199338526,
0.1292892992,
-0.5567303896,
-0.5437780023,
-0.6670078635,
0.3020334244,
0.1264130026,
0.9596915841,
-0.0358555801,
0.0035945864,
0.0960814506,
0.3377171159,
-1.0872039795,
0.0859262049,
-0.6476895213,
-0.0344919451,
0.1192977726,
-0.4104986787,
-0.4030552506,
-0.1631738096,
-0.025159495,
-0.9239880443,
-0.0780200139,
0.0359133556,
0.7774522901,
0.5981891155,
-0.1634453982,
-0.2012934983,
-0.3813664317,
1.2688369751,
-0.645590663,
0.1028268039,
0.6377997994,
0.3019084334,
-0.3129295409,
-0.9920746088,
-0.4648410976,
-0.0181049295,
-0.1564971507,
0.2751992643,
-0.1145233512,
0.2163695991,
0.3057025373,
0.2850057781,
-0.249554947,
-0.1538490206,
-0.1471966058,
-0.4170762599,
0.6683126092,
-0.0237277709,
0.3100824356,
-0.174011007,
-0.4698290229,
-0.491463989,
-0.3270429373,
0.3928109705,
0.1157711446,
0.3280149102,
0.3789989054,
0.8037362695,
-0.7148697972,
0.7634940147,
0.032428775,
-0.2594473064,
0.1185736135,
-0.2213322371,
-0.2627671659,
0.1662151515,
0.4926057458,
1.0894333124,
0.5482718349,
-0.0638897121,
-0.2548728287,
0.41622895,
0.5304463506,
-0.3963520825,
-0.3999308646,
0.1471730024,
-0.4211152792,
-0.493964076,
0.1629736423,
-0.6215971708,
-0.0279576872,
-0.3146210313,
0.6857602,
-0.4217297435,
0.1611986607,
0.6087328792,
-0.4457535446,
0.1971869469,
0.5084506273,
-0.7083007693,
0.5428398252,
0.8913476467,
0.8116406202,
0.0513175316,
-0.194155395,
-0.8109360933,
0.08865273,
-0.2171247751,
0.6084271669,
-0.5622346997,
-0.6766247153,
-0.3400834501,
-0.2587369382,
-0.3442681134,
-0.2701623142,
0.8287584186,
-0.4342572689,
-0.1368432343,
-0.5883033872,
-0.5667265654,
-0.1596788019,
0.4717047215,
-0.5175602436,
0.998852253,
-0.0013160813,
-0.9770828485,
0.5471995473,
-0.2430628091,
-0.4686904252,
0.119054772,
-0.1363449693,
-0.0274199527,
0.1576862037,
-0.1187584102,
0.3257004917,
-0.1227462813,
0.1353467703,
-0.3257912099,
-0.6957163215,
0.6117029786,
-0.1272790432,
0.8777439594,
0.3906720579,
-0.405583322,
-0.0932713896,
-0.9152122736,
0.5555554628,
-0.4202066958,
-0.4042703211,
-0.8325103521,
0.0699802414,
-0.0509956814,
0.5655520558,
0.3367148638,
-0.8830538988,
-0.2692156136,
-0.3453389108,
-0.0114216367,
0.4220795333,
0.0463704467,
0.2888413668,
-0.4387819469,
0.278748244,
-0.0634238049,
0.2220147252,
0.3185730875,
-0.8371658325,
-1.1071175337,
-0.2888103426,
0.2113856226,
0.8565855026,
-0.5410423279,
0.6534939408,
-0.0736601204,
-0.2519624531,
-0.4180859923,
0.1441859752,
0.6842565536,
0.6883071661,
0.4460490644,
-0.6650832295,
-0.2869765759,
-0.9365214705,
-0.4609479606,
-0.411290139,
-0.3126941025,
-0.1754806936,
0.2696544826,
0.1879872829,
1.2706170082,
-0.7267030478,
-0.2196017951,
-0.0837143511,
0.1238740906,
-0.2156671882,
0.7624534369,
0.3089390695,
-0.9912995696,
-0.3565686941,
-0.0740541145,
-0.2963854373,
-0.3346270025,
-0.0619012155,
-0.378372103,
-0.3062935472,
0.5651849508,
-0.7847242355,
0.6622924209,
0.1987537891,
-0.453869611,
0.0776420161,
-0.2982588708,
0.3637568057,
-1.0441390276,
0.0573761836,
0.0165330563,
-0.4768892825,
-0.4402106404,
0.1418284476,
0.2120215148,
0.0962576419,
-0.6075430512,
0.2437131405,
0.1740866005,
-0.0634592623,
-0.3704067171,
0.0307486486,
0.5334008336,
0.2152696699,
0.1291470379,
0.6975924969,
0.3180610538,
-0.4656035602,
0.0722944215,
0.26797387,
-0.0306199789,
1.0475569963,
-0.5901928544,
-0.041637104,
0.1661076099,
0.0003300424,
-1.113719821,
-0.3191882372,
0.3346011043,
-0.4699729979,
0.120448187,
-0.1561154872,
-0.3733669221,
-0.2014045864,
-0.5994356871,
0.0916774943,
0.49644804,
-0.5348477364,
0.2737178802,
0.3409937322,
-0.0465332195,
-0.3795956373,
-0.9828062654,
0.189361006,
-0.1536435038,
-0.5985198021,
0.5402337313,
-0.1438361704,
-0.806025207,
0.1534974277,
0.0272950325,
-0.1176384389,
0.2858480513,
0.4840267897,
0.3289886117,
0.0348690562,
0.0396589041,
0.1702423394,
-0.5334362388,
0.2197971791,
-0.0999637768,
0.1367926747,
-0.3253077567,
-0.5082198381,
-0.578687191,
0.4715903401,
0.2462153286,
0.0189785585,
0.6946281195,
-0.0377387851,
-0.3234397173,
0.2599336207,
-0.6338564754,
-0.0806581378,
-0.4546997845,
-0.0321131907,
-0.4318399727,
-0.8285964727,
0.2481794655,
-0.1175969169,
0.0757424012,
0.5519073009,
0.4653978646,
-0.331829071,
1.1540397406,
0.5128292441,
0.2568787932,
0.0159096569,
0.4262158871,
0.270244807,
-0.4421103895,
0.0465028845,
-0.5568000674,
-0.3759954274,
-0.6896802187,
-0.4225125313,
0.1065895632,
0.0208157245,
-0.0280658044,
0.3500157893,
-0.3151971996,
0.7227435708,
0.9014580846,
0.1647978127,
0.532033205,
-0.3778582215,
0.0115132025,
0.107316874,
-0.3732079864,
-0.5485396981,
0.8668146133,
0.1650019288,
0.9385191798,
-0.1554434896,
0.8265098929,
0.2785213888,
0.0437678136,
-0.8390982151,
0.6986677647,
-0.0897446871,
-0.5780879259,
-0.2557565272,
-0.4492753744,
-0.5512066483,
0.3397216201,
-0.1622055918,
-0.9650448561,
0.3615866899,
0.3609386981,
-0.4144583046,
0.1273681372,
-1.0190982819,
0.9335307479,
-0.0796205699,
-0.1637455523,
-0.2261045426,
-1.0030418634,
0.2554486692,
0.0107110897,
0.0951705575,
-0.2690435648,
-0.0531344302,
0.7413642406,
-0.6259638667,
1.0707092285,
0.0378079005,
0.3087850809,
0.4138793051,
-0.0293470286,
0.1548239887,
-0.0661281347,
-0.2245322913,
0.1288113445,
0.4552355111,
-0.4906896055,
-0.5784735084,
0.9960264564,
-0.4254395068,
-0.454877317,
-0.5919694304,
-0.6903048158,
-0.2738673985,
0.1486216784,
0.2461558878,
0.0451762676,
-0.14192307,
0.1052569821,
0.5688670874,
0.2845903039,
0.536740005,
0.1514222026,
0.2073397934,
-0.2383158952,
0.7295637131,
-0.0526508875,
0.4696083069,
0.3958395422,
0.3233377039,
-0.078992255,
0.0233173072,
-0.2722776234,
-0.1300556511,
-1.1149636507,
-0.1947160214,
-0.4088822901,
-0.0920769125,
-0.2792922854,
-0.5637732148,
-0.4006815553,
-0.8547167778,
-0.1997562051,
-0.2285689265,
0.2796727121,
0.2694764137,
-0.1134406328,
0.6617245078,
-0.599834919,
-0.0368424058,
0.4027163982,
0.4636983573,
-0.3469790518,
-0.218642965,
-0.2577780485,
-0.0875956193,
-0.2358796597,
-0.7090415955,
0.2869176269,
-0.0500683971,
0.4784033,
0.1483306587,
0.4283072054,
0.4652552605,
-0.2288101912,
0.62142694,
0.5535029173,
-1.0724499226,
0.2973434925,
0.1600009501,
0.1454541832,
1.1254241467,
0.2984495461,
-0.5373495221,
-0.334625572,
-0.4660854936,
-0.7308624983,
0.5178812742,
0.4246629477,
0.1853868514,
-0.2399478853,
0.3089872003,
0.0387695432,
0.0163475312,
-0.6244692802,
0.0703757852,
-0.3862287998,
-0.4862354994,
0.029646121,
-0.426643759,
-0.3572109938,
-0.0572501943,
0.6876782179,
-0.1177668199,
-0.3180330098,
0.2205061316,
-0.3016571999,
-0.1032354981,
0.7298179865,
0.2423622161,
0.643912375,
-0.4019734859,
0.5085856915,
0.1177854687,
-0.6555275917,
0.0405830219,
0.0814639032,
-0.4828386605,
-0.1708389968,
0.1164244488,
0.532230854,
0.6650226116,
-0.8391779661,
0.6776925921,
-0.2261904478,
-0.223869592,
0.0435759053,
0.4032303393,
0.0309611764,
0.1062771082,
-0.099055931,
0.0359723046,
0.462600261,
-0.2148311883,
0.4230700731,
0.3500068486,
-0.5125585198,
0.0341780446,
0.5058148503,
0.3705915213,
-0.3998346329,
0.2581726611,
0.0710806102,
-0.3206375241,
0.3681921959,
0.3638894856,
0.7575512528,
-0.1071920991,
0.1253299415,
0.1062423736,
0.3125565052,
-0.2486357987,
0.4418787956,
-0.1284051239,
-0.7058337331,
-0.5008164048,
-0.707654655,
-0.7808569074,
-0.4047858417,
-1.040517211,
0.2105282694,
-0.3144691288,
-0.5428606868,
-0.0245660488,
-0.0344690494,
-0.6076896787,
0.7114706635,
-0.0120311147,
0.9162716866,
-1.0176753998,
0.5715460181,
0.6384087801,
-0.5033459067,
-0.8337442279,
0.1732235998,
-0.0448839366,
-0.5273253322,
0.4751789272,
0.4386945367,
-0.4094257355,
-0.1119720042,
-0.310441494,
-0.8308277726,
0.8757095337,
-0.0677756295,
-0.5788921714,
0.0539733879,
0.2199180126,
0.3591786623,
-0.0768372342,
0.0103223193,
0.8721389771,
0.3362671435,
0.3703931272,
-0.8244841099,
0.0332596339,
-0.2629906237,
-0.0553898886,
0.1337438971,
-0.3003810346,
0.8367921114,
0.1435459554,
0.0958820209,
0.1837103963,
0.4526222348,
-0.0134905363,
0.7786983252,
0.7920023799,
0.941660583,
0.5966416597,
0.1797547191,
1.2139896154,
-0.1625574231,
0.2250246853,
1.1879993677,
-0.4584982395,
1.0739444494,
0.9221901298,
-0.1539579481,
0.3219791055,
0.6482596993,
0.5892560482,
0.4878721833,
-0.0049827844,
-0.3279086351,
-0.7441590428,
-0.1318257004,
-0.0454598702,
0.421610117,
0.2622136474,
-0.1396510601,
-0.4390134215,
-0.1855745614,
0.0493258014,
0.0475718118,
-0.1736069024,
0.6448763609,
0.3444212377,
-0.813429594,
-0.1237498075,
0.0697702616,
0.534142077,
-0.6078648567,
-0.1501830071,
0.1366161406,
0.1441832036,
-0.1452958137,
-1.1096817255,
0.2472008169,
-0.0566905215,
-0.2240246534,
-0.2544257343,
1.0337831974,
-0.2777135372,
-0.7063999772,
0.4375272989,
0.4664597213,
0.1641679853,
-0.1046583503,
-0.4935387373,
-0.0355589762,
-0.3711950779,
-0.2511019707,
0.5198810101,
0.1379838288,
-0.2231113464,
0.3882312179,
0.8852002025,
-0.0925683528,
-0.0035296143,
0.2700484693,
0.9071365595,
-0.6121894121,
-0.7690466046,
-0.6802654266,
0.4010999203,
-0.3638499081,
-0.1932396889,
0.7148739696,
0.394102037,
0.9575265646,
0.1210059375,
0.5232006311,
-0.0311772525,
0.7953177691,
-0.5391445756,
0.6405020356,
-0.638815105,
0.2616566718,
-0.4846501946,
-0.7314392328,
-0.6367652416,
0.7998421788,
-0.6169967651,
-0.1282676756,
0.571231246,
0.7306395769,
-0.0911864713,
0.0148691107,
0.7041198611,
-0.4337410629,
0.1255274564,
0.4286950827,
0.7326287627,
-0.0681825578,
0.3609241545,
-0.7555978298,
-0.5083286762,
-0.3328989446,
-0.9551208615,
-0.706964612,
-0.1377001554,
-0.3170142174,
-0.4429017603,
0.1752432585,
0.8447633386,
0.6700639725,
-0.7589042783,
-0.0884379521,
-0.1135739312,
-0.0819607228,
-0.1305295527,
-0.1893902719,
0.0855644941,
-0.5315645933,
-0.3477905989,
0.1994906664,
0.2652718723,
0.0040889191,
0.2825684547,
-0.0373561829,
-0.2317793667,
0.4228408039,
0.3847075403,
0.2173621058,
-0.6450566053,
-0.8306087852,
-0.0133771393,
-0.3791152537,
0.0219241343,
0.8506669402,
-0.6139350533,
0.5641917586,
0.472838968,
0.6533372998,
0.2087339759,
0.202452898,
0.5520266891,
-0.6816515326,
0.3046792448,
0.0453272127,
0.4999144077,
0.4699401855,
-0.592965126,
0.4757566154,
0.2317485511,
-0.4255669415,
-0.4130005538,
0.1196163893,
-1.3581588268,
-0.1787099838,
0.8270115852,
-0.3748457432,
-0.252695322,
-0.2582833767,
-0.2844673693,
0.1090461537,
-0.0930000171,
0.7878621221,
0.7873942256,
-0.2081278265,
0.116159685,
-0.2607673705,
0.3761625886,
0.7684155703,
-0.9208825827,
-0.2885237634,
0.4893065095,
0.3056507707,
0.5493978262,
0.4935925901,
0.1156316176,
0.7055712938,
0.1051073596,
0.0582570285,
0.3779173493,
-0.1314925402,
-0.1043359935,
-0.1193546429,
0.3396268487,
-0.6776609421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16854v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16854v2 | AnnoLLM: Making Large Language Models to Be Better Crowdsourced Annotators | 2023-03-29T17:03:21 | 2024-04-05T15:19:19 | Xingwei He, Zhenghao Lin, Yeyun Gong, A-Long Jin, Hang Zhang, Chen Lin, Jian Jiao, Siu Ming Yiu, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many natural language processing (NLP) tasks rely on labeled data to train
machine learning models with high performance. However, data annotation is
time-consuming and expensive, especially when the task involves a large amount
of data or requires specialized domains. Recently, GPT-3.5 series models have
demonstrated remarkable few-shot and zero-shot ability across various NLP
tasks. In this paper, we first claim that large language models (LLMs), such as
GPT-3.5, can serve as an excellent crowdsourced annotator when provided with
sufficient guidance and demonstrated examples. Accordingly, we propose AnnoLLM,
an annotation system powered by LLMs, which adopts a two-step approach,
explain-then-annotate. Concretely, we first prompt LLMs to provide explanations
for why the specific ground truth answer/label was assigned for a given
example. Then, we construct the few-shot chain-of-thought prompt with the
self-generated explanation and employ it to annotate the unlabeled data with
LLMs. Our experiment results on three tasks, including user input and keyword
relevance assessment, BoolQ, and WiC, demonstrate that AnnoLLM surpasses or
performs on par with crowdsourced annotators. Furthermore, we build the first
conversation-based information retrieval dataset employing AnnoLLM. This
dataset is designed to facilitate the development of retrieval models capable
of retrieving pertinent documents for conversational text. Human evaluation has
validated the dataset's high quality. | [
-0.3899497688,
-0.6841478944,
0.5948617458,
0.1160305962,
-0.3410747349,
-0.0457549356,
-0.4480985105,
-0.6534260511,
0.1885096431,
0.7960096002,
-0.3993175924,
-0.519524157,
-0.6630498171,
0.2890811861,
-0.5143694878,
1.0767538548,
0.1402257234,
-0.2761989832,
-0.2708057463,
-0.1992991716,
-0.0352071188,
-0.787537694,
-0.5405099392,
-0.3423290551,
0.6340571642,
0.3013258874,
0.8647005558,
0.7087113261,
0.4944891334,
0.263484925,
0.0050583137,
0.3154680431,
-0.5041738153,
0.2055154592,
-0.1699112505,
-0.3956682086,
-0.2458111048,
0.2269706279,
0.3111522496,
0.6564369202,
0.0012685064,
0.3885237575,
-0.0677135736,
0.5856861472,
-0.4157155752,
0.2317225635,
-0.7849095464,
-0.13543953,
-0.4392874539,
-0.0422379896,
-0.3527172506,
-0.5040883422,
0.0242599808,
-0.7338408828,
0.1402924061,
0.2062207758,
0.6942528486,
0.3426640928,
0.0312792137,
-0.3092597425,
-0.6350093484,
0.7061356902,
-0.8333563805,
0.1289915591,
0.8129624724,
0.1991672665,
-0.2400971353,
-0.6474764943,
-0.7247132659,
-0.2819507718,
-0.1596959382,
-0.0686950982,
-0.008146855,
0.0309952665,
0.3811801076,
0.1723050773,
-0.5313918591,
0.3283163011,
-0.3480067849,
-0.1576644629,
0.7010084987,
-0.0027334215,
-0.0306169018,
-0.4120738506,
-0.3299981058,
0.2845809758,
-0.5459331274,
-0.4435275793,
0.2848166227,
0.36429286,
0.1707325131,
0.7511901259,
-0.4320801795,
0.8368396163,
-0.2204435915,
0.0000193586,
0.1652020216,
-0.1340181679,
-0.1578668356,
-0.0753624886,
0.867022872,
0.3153190613,
0.4061768353,
-0.2021916509,
-0.0721202567,
-0.3742131889,
-0.036666017,
-0.8671893477,
-0.3564153016,
0.3095124364,
-0.4228681624,
-0.0954446644,
-0.0059790034,
-0.5955096483,
-0.5542348623,
-0.5571712852,
0.443629086,
-0.2308395505,
-0.1067220569,
-0.0066469302,
0.2137039751,
-0.1675822735,
0.5594776273,
-0.8711826205,
0.2638255954,
0.9112393856,
1.0859390497,
-0.0433830209,
-0.1095834896,
-0.7700862885,
0.138729617,
-0.1766644716,
0.8424664736,
-0.5839779377,
-0.0969679058,
0.0671222806,
-0.0813593417,
0.1613481641,
-0.5640965104,
0.372623235,
-0.6089465022,
0.4856838286,
-0.1632559747,
-0.8078875542,
-0.4062201977,
0.2827215195,
-0.7134506702,
1.0779089928,
-0.0435476564,
-0.7656679153,
0.2159731388,
-0.9019295573,
-0.2565623522,
0.468816936,
-0.0070676031,
-0.1982430816,
0.1040568128,
0.480112493,
0.7843405008,
-0.3401732445,
0.3703433573,
-0.4273728132,
-0.2294005752,
0.4026604295,
-0.4363062084,
0.7538288236,
0.1948871911,
-0.1486954838,
-0.0763834268,
-0.5716260672,
-0.0330054462,
0.0175186992,
-0.1888328493,
-0.3041911423,
-0.0074666869,
0.1425840408,
0.1977670193,
0.1743165553,
-0.4504089653,
0.1759321541,
-0.2719966471,
0.4796191156,
0.7002544999,
0.0084195537,
0.1124100909,
-0.2614636421,
0.3207972646,
-0.4623627365,
0.0081045888,
-0.3917150795,
-0.4632101357,
-0.7301006913,
-0.3586837947,
0.3649556935,
0.4774940014,
-0.6079651713,
0.3038312197,
-0.1359160393,
-0.4113539457,
-0.8165836334,
0.3533288538,
0.0680770203,
0.3956009746,
0.4783134162,
-0.0815178901,
-0.513698101,
-0.8488348126,
-0.318389684,
-0.4687554538,
-0.3108503222,
0.1886805892,
0.4496707022,
0.006178495,
1.1197596788,
-0.3751380742,
-0.3739340305,
-0.1261852831,
0.515609622,
0.1771751791,
0.2018570453,
0.0159311835,
-0.6548538804,
-0.2190091312,
-0.1652308702,
-0.6358796954,
-0.3788293004,
-0.1147688925,
-0.1100570038,
0.2019404769,
0.457968384,
-0.5972105861,
0.2637825608,
0.4267314076,
0.1267173439,
0.2217613608,
-0.0959480032,
0.0307545904,
-1.000074029,
0.1988037229,
0.0378648899,
-0.5934692025,
-0.4325415194,
-0.2268595994,
-0.2343253046,
-0.1568724215,
-0.3085589409,
0.6494490504,
-0.3225382864,
0.007129746,
-0.5106415153,
0.5986615419,
-0.072275795,
0.2767747045,
0.2226253152,
0.4716845155,
0.1823893189,
-0.4969915152,
0.5113040209,
0.2483828366,
-0.3370681107,
0.3760929704,
-0.6315429211,
0.5015268326,
-0.2552190721,
0.1948456764,
-0.8741367459,
-0.5218061209,
0.1845103204,
-0.3876621723,
-0.00545215,
-0.2775662541,
-1.0143306255,
-0.4478248358,
-0.0770681575,
0.0630975738,
0.3629264235,
-0.760648787,
0.2375054657,
0.5040646791,
-0.4758265913,
-0.0135605643,
-0.6019804478,
0.3366360962,
-0.1646420509,
-0.4405089319,
-0.0146526759,
0.1599380523,
-0.3245304823,
-0.0623671934,
0.3389826417,
-0.0759629384,
0.1202012002,
0.4099886715,
0.2160478979,
0.0720103011,
0.6513851881,
-0.3738973439,
-0.354668498,
-0.0322885476,
-0.3321562707,
0.3773962557,
0.0613210909,
-0.5616775155,
-0.3512603045,
0.2563442588,
0.2090681642,
-0.4059922993,
0.6287145615,
0.8005151749,
-0.5198177099,
0.1560660452,
-0.9686832428,
-0.1982858628,
-0.3839375973,
0.4358985424,
0.0853806287,
-1.2106353045,
0.2841237187,
-0.1261979789,
0.2748682201,
0.3623168766,
0.6185235977,
-0.0816768482,
0.8000342846,
0.3961292207,
-0.3664972484,
0.2796319425,
0.0620484538,
0.2396312505,
-0.6374812722,
-0.2220578492,
-0.5361515284,
-0.2587614357,
-0.5710038543,
-0.7652668953,
0.1422007382,
0.2227392197,
-0.0385011248,
0.1124933362,
-0.5664971471,
0.5937560797,
0.6968422532,
-0.1043661013,
0.5040848255,
0.0417548046,
0.5403838158,
-0.0991541743,
-0.5364729762,
-0.968352735,
0.9951766133,
0.4227229655,
0.6791747808,
-0.0751993805,
0.7691181302,
0.1484369487,
0.7735344172,
-0.6318159699,
0.5133017302,
-0.1106794402,
-0.8108115196,
-0.3358592093,
-0.2721714973,
-0.6830794811,
0.2456622422,
-0.1941230297,
-0.976701498,
-0.2407223433,
0.1711988151,
-0.4669571817,
0.3033179939,
-0.5136609077,
0.7091018558,
-0.2913070619,
-0.4116226435,
-0.0082789557,
-0.5723136067,
0.2678132355,
-0.176721558,
0.3965583444,
-0.5499464273,
-0.1176609695,
0.9899401069,
-0.5878136754,
0.8576412201,
-0.2705789208,
0.1495289654,
0.5852092505,
0.0168786459,
0.6380126476,
0.164867416,
-0.3505162001,
0.2754613757,
-0.2689523399,
-0.2359696776,
-0.6113291383,
0.5836068988,
-0.3622960448,
-0.721958518,
-0.1690169573,
-0.4747843146,
-0.0997353494,
0.0810941756,
0.0330459289,
0.3058607876,
0.0448542833,
0.1724855453,
0.4100662172,
0.0392031707,
0.5282749534,
0.4483926296,
-0.5062302351,
-0.4236038029,
0.7849011421,
0.1583254784,
0.2001975477,
0.4169084728,
0.1808712631,
-0.4040254354,
-0.4359144568,
-0.3591952324,
0.1726199389,
-0.5255756974,
-0.3779808283,
-0.852814436,
0.0417361557,
-0.238338232,
0.0531611033,
-0.2497221231,
-0.6324451566,
-0.3675458729,
-0.3369993269,
0.8848045468,
0.7510722876,
-0.28524369,
0.307607621,
-0.7265969515,
0.311594516,
0.4086090326,
0.1741706133,
-0.0991284028,
-0.4864054024,
-0.2861482203,
0.1921160668,
-0.1179122925,
-0.7225906849,
0.2778153419,
0.1402859837,
0.2230256796,
0.2889883816,
0.0482632034,
0.7085107565,
-0.3344749808,
0.8129758835,
0.0161698274,
-0.8264818788,
0.4884525239,
-0.1974537075,
0.2174252719,
0.7483297586,
0.3897357583,
-0.8394389749,
-0.5551286936,
-0.4759368002,
-0.9615071416,
0.6624438763,
0.2464451194,
0.230633691,
-0.3077613413,
0.4157438278,
0.390804857,
0.2291573435,
-0.6513795257,
-0.0540292971,
-0.1042342708,
-0.2687453032,
-0.0782857761,
-0.3480275571,
0.1135861576,
0.0486658514,
0.75582546,
-0.2186522037,
-0.0212928224,
0.248922199,
-0.2481557429,
-0.0389363877,
0.341445744,
0.3228087723,
0.5996677876,
-0.1344430894,
0.2830976844,
0.1127660647,
-0.1945251971,
-0.0784741491,
0.597915709,
-0.2364539504,
0.249663949,
0.5316574574,
0.708458364,
-0.0081783747,
-0.647542119,
0.4374602139,
0.2944732904,
-0.0031131702,
-0.2318799496,
-0.1200495958,
0.2949835658,
0.3000077307,
0.6110674143,
-0.3912345469,
0.1283928752,
-0.1835419089,
0.1565614939,
0.3580058217,
-0.334595561,
-0.1634047925,
0.6765863895,
0.3193987608,
-0.4603789151,
0.7632344365,
-0.3366121948,
-0.6268238425,
0.1923726201,
0.2488529086,
0.7610836029,
-0.090466179,
0.4027113914,
0.32510975,
0.3976227939,
-0.3264436424,
0.0161733273,
-0.0709831268,
-0.3787354529,
-0.7963757515,
-0.5208004713,
-0.4877347052,
0.3143542111,
-0.4880338907,
0.0432290919,
-0.3116428554,
-0.1830074638,
0.0549936406,
0.0982571542,
-0.7792342305,
0.0824167207,
0.225946039,
0.6387114525,
-0.748854816,
0.4516635537,
0.4851697087,
-0.4385223687,
-0.6324532628,
-0.0858338252,
-0.0624254309,
-0.858138144,
0.8211948276,
0.387496233,
0.2374502271,
0.0378023125,
-0.7676181197,
-0.6770370603,
0.8267382383,
0.2761734128,
-0.8454381227,
0.2142641842,
0.3093837798,
0.4981624186,
-0.2296830118,
0.4731270373,
0.1819293797,
0.6332693696,
-0.0231692716,
-0.8955304623,
0.087355122,
0.1090966389,
0.0164644849,
0.2532947063,
-0.5456605554,
0.4869484603,
-0.4495411813,
-0.1036040783,
0.1435148865,
0.8956586123,
0.1955435276,
0.2742989659,
0.3852941394,
0.4498746097,
1.0616850853,
-0.0156432949,
0.9810862541,
-0.0106406258,
0.3819015324,
1.3907504082,
-0.2357447147,
1.0095450878,
0.546936512,
-0.2224576473,
0.1408583075,
0.6632582545,
-0.0690333247,
0.1835115254,
0.5274710059,
-0.3236006498,
-0.4706141651,
-0.398288697,
-0.0609912202,
0.2977686226,
0.2402204573,
-0.394577831,
-0.1932836622,
0.1716617495,
0.1535425633,
0.1323623061,
-0.2858689129,
0.9237911701,
0.1532693952,
-0.4014478624,
0.229014039,
-0.0281825196,
0.5093906522,
-0.2421875894,
-0.1237837002,
-0.2075089067,
-0.099920243,
-0.2969475389,
-0.6958856583,
0.0462331064,
0.2263804376,
-0.1217780337,
-0.1652422845,
0.6808815002,
-0.7608303428,
-0.7123482227,
-0.0483745374,
0.4229989648,
0.547270596,
-0.4342695177,
-0.5655534863,
0.1103442758,
-0.073766306,
-0.3443239033,
0.0075614089,
0.5421825051,
-0.0750014633,
0.6576173902,
0.7107450962,
0.0925814733,
-0.0732036605,
0.2319120169,
0.6800504327,
-0.6002944708,
-0.0583442785,
-1.0318449736,
0.3597661555,
-0.2958052158,
-0.1307191104,
0.6707469821,
0.6589389443,
0.7701532841,
0.251718998,
1.0487569571,
0.0535545237,
0.9509334564,
-0.5826219916,
0.501098752,
-0.1848132759,
0.2338038236,
-0.0833862871,
-0.9685786963,
-0.4808938503,
0.7453696132,
-0.5304279923,
0.1635041088,
0.3684045374,
0.7374568582,
0.111148566,
0.2532968223,
0.0981505066,
0.2453920692,
0.4653658569,
0.3813063502,
0.8132299185,
-0.3065303862,
0.4856110811,
-0.3073214591,
-0.1030929089,
-0.3905840814,
-1.0074347258,
-1.1124085188,
-0.4884289205,
-0.5856522322,
-0.1400904208,
0.0698845759,
1.1969211102,
0.8268440366,
-0.6445470452,
0.0131497048,
0.0693835244,
0.1076902896,
0.1962445378,
-0.2489534765,
0.3753980994,
-0.3416562378,
-0.6686379313,
0.117326729,
0.4094048738,
-0.0413449928,
-0.4339244366,
0.0777175725,
-0.1734817922,
-0.1953949332,
0.6182007194,
0.1864097118,
-0.808303237,
-0.4469796717,
-0.2182592005,
0.0463804714,
-0.1590495408,
0.7921085358,
-0.856405437,
0.5706816316,
0.0965684801,
0.7717382312,
0.6188670397,
0.2529613972,
0.4219878316,
-0.5233289599,
0.0550553948,
0.4155258238,
-0.0020955014,
0.7547447085,
-0.2364913821,
0.590960741,
-0.0432272963,
-0.6329589486,
-0.6532619596,
-0.054232128,
-0.6075473428,
0.0146351708,
1.306935668,
-0.1743163168,
-0.1717726141,
-0.2873260379,
-0.3084789515,
0.0833083838,
-0.5084946156,
0.8801496029,
0.8250162005,
-0.0935346112,
-0.1426772922,
-0.7157560587,
0.4083777666,
0.2273155302,
-1.0192953348,
0.4816097617,
0.5123203397,
0.0257484931,
0.2373317182,
0.755723536,
-0.0781994611,
-0.1575857848,
-0.4442723989,
0.0725340322,
-0.3624867201,
0.0456402935,
-0.0720865875,
0.1711539924,
0.3198575974,
-0.2320450842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16839v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16839v3 | MaMMUT: A Simple Architecture for Joint Learning for MultiModal Tasks | 2023-03-29T16:42:30 | 2023-08-09T05:39:34 | Weicheng Kuo, AJ Piergiovanni, Dahun Kim, Xiyang Luo, Ben Caine, Wei Li, Abhijit Ogale, Luowei Zhou, Andrew Dai, Zhifeng Chen, Claire Cui, Anelia Angelova | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | The development of language models have moved from encoder-decoder to
decoder-only designs. In addition, we observe that the two most popular
multimodal tasks, the generative and contrastive tasks, are nontrivial to
accommodate in one architecture, and further need adaptations for downstream
tasks. We propose a novel paradigm of training with a decoder-only model for
multimodal tasks, which is surprisingly effective in jointly learning of these
disparate vision-language tasks. This is done with a simple model, called
MaMMUT. It consists of a single vision encoder and a text decoder, and is able
to accommodate contrastive and generative learning by a novel two-pass approach
on the text decoder. We demonstrate that joint learning of these diverse
objectives is simple, effective, and maximizes the weight-sharing of the model
across these tasks. Furthermore, the same architecture enables straightforward
extensions to open-vocabulary object detection and video-language tasks. The
model tackles a diverse range of tasks, while being modest in capacity. Our
model achieves the state of the art on image-text and text-image retrieval,
video question answering and open-vocabulary detection tasks, outperforming
much larger and more extensively trained foundational models. It shows very
competitive results on VQA and Video Captioning, especially considering its
capacity. Ablations confirm the flexibility and advantages of our approach. | [
-0.2078068405,
-0.5396844745,
0.3422068059,
-0.1968125105,
-0.4784763455,
-0.1639744192,
-0.0276495237,
-0.108205609,
0.1359515041,
0.3953781426,
-0.558881402,
-0.5130364895,
-0.9196445346,
-0.1197211072,
-0.0953760967,
0.734293282,
-0.1700904667,
0.1438426971,
-0.3508091271,
-0.636233151,
-0.380399406,
-0.2779992819,
-0.3915161192,
-0.2370611131,
0.604182899,
0.4610808194,
0.4586693347,
0.5885286927,
0.7097181082,
0.3387568891,
0.3523719609,
0.3810050488,
-0.201932624,
0.0754472986,
-0.0919864029,
-0.477782011,
-0.1812407374,
-0.2146843523,
0.6311722994,
0.9169853926,
-0.047268834,
0.0967104509,
0.2621848285,
0.6476731896,
-1.0249291658,
0.3439950943,
-0.4988323152,
0.0516609512,
-0.0834090412,
-0.0815896019,
-0.3967808783,
0.3757609427,
-0.1842044443,
-0.7555103302,
0.0722698197,
-0.1693424582,
0.5049025416,
0.3925973177,
-0.6372174621,
-0.1974700689,
-0.4284859598,
0.9338257313,
0.004002179,
0.675305903,
0.3649207652,
0.3940367997,
0.3394964933,
-0.4347060323,
-0.4771741629,
-0.0325601287,
-0.0231738035,
0.3967422843,
-0.1188089699,
0.0817866847,
0.0446144864,
0.3253087699,
-0.6189007163,
-0.1972273439,
-0.5059940815,
-0.1220156103,
0.1432339847,
0.1542455405,
0.5636424422,
-0.215982154,
-0.8419066072,
-0.3961191475,
-0.2765567303,
0.0711039901,
0.1028520167,
0.2009760439,
-0.4906736016,
0.7944534421,
-0.4036566019,
0.6191920042,
-0.4561067522,
-0.3478481174,
0.2721371353,
-0.2852533758,
-0.3160625398,
-0.3937643766,
0.6376463771,
0.3412286639,
-0.1210151613,
-0.1704138517,
-0.353651017,
0.6003166437,
0.350723505,
-0.4435356557,
-0.4301142097,
-0.1815288961,
-0.5151942372,
-0.1368685961,
0.0138377491,
-0.7213154435,
-0.2234932631,
-0.3781678081,
1.0673830509,
-0.5278005004,
-0.5206524134,
0.2861017585,
-0.1044406742,
0.1498860568,
0.4194912314,
-1.0719760656,
0.4943099618,
0.5309502482,
0.9296049476,
-0.1965639889,
-0.6054238081,
-0.8470143676,
0.2120147943,
-0.190331012,
0.6489924192,
-0.5993458033,
-0.209706232,
0.0393396839,
-0.058182966,
-0.3355248272,
-0.2566153407,
0.1881621629,
-0.2528325319,
0.0466306321,
-0.1465855986,
-0.1125624925,
-0.4385536611,
0.4889366329,
-0.8389343023,
0.629681766,
0.0568362325,
-0.8794491887,
0.3843866587,
-0.7211794257,
-0.4437482655,
-0.0783995837,
-0.3221264184,
-0.3414197564,
0.0911340117,
0.2495301217,
0.4267962575,
-0.0983366892,
-0.1932730377,
-0.1526922584,
-0.2105776668,
-0.0163227413,
-0.5104966164,
0.6364100575,
0.1762840152,
0.0290408824,
0.1357779652,
-0.6089515686,
-0.4267850518,
0.2332614511,
-0.5693449974,
-0.467146337,
-0.2247206718,
0.0983233377,
0.2259427309,
0.160914883,
-0.5865136981,
0.1383852959,
-0.3456842601,
0.0863250196,
0.5233786106,
-0.3484870493,
0.9651760459,
-0.500803113,
0.4199053645,
0.3101065755,
0.1881818622,
-0.5870524049,
-0.5248713493,
-0.9258368015,
-0.5233780742,
-0.0048659677,
0.4948509037,
-1.3525137901,
-0.2379020452,
-0.2738482654,
-0.1431052834,
-0.6465702653,
0.4847688377,
0.6922041178,
0.2627136111,
0.294559896,
-0.6528220177,
-0.2564528584,
-0.9233814478,
0.0301288813,
0.0809838399,
0.1282384098,
-0.0817585364,
0.6232725978,
0.013930629,
0.3694303632,
-0.3615460396,
-0.4486914277,
-0.4213109314,
0.2701561153,
-0.1015431508,
0.4951730371,
0.3290816545,
-1.2176747322,
-0.3787777424,
0.17749919,
-0.8658503294,
0.2730101645,
0.0401700288,
-0.1111668497,
0.0722051859,
0.3470482528,
-0.7918674946,
0.1961931735,
0.6959319115,
0.0964654461,
0.189185977,
-0.3310968876,
0.2194969058,
-1.2916787863,
-0.0676617324,
-0.1783439368,
-0.2520501912,
-0.7383621335,
0.4597038329,
0.1731248796,
-0.2017780691,
-0.6997522712,
0.7313850522,
-0.5335060358,
-0.2408093214,
-0.3383364081,
-0.0023893239,
0.0544575639,
0.8810662031,
0.0897225142,
0.4764305949,
0.8848401308,
-0.6822324991,
0.2285339683,
0.3030049205,
-0.3385955095,
0.6436416507,
-0.1334616989,
0.0273547787,
-0.3972219229,
-0.1764800698,
-1.2463877201,
-0.4372763038,
0.4852443039,
-0.5610036254,
0.2641066611,
-0.2242643386,
-0.4319274426,
-0.0522204004,
-0.3060716987,
0.6735506654,
0.3892026544,
-0.7508679628,
1.0224435329,
0.3519538343,
-0.0429201014,
-0.8796890378,
-0.8540720344,
-0.1542754322,
0.0446926802,
-0.4723002613,
0.138450399,
0.028954057,
0.0206387863,
0.0967384279,
-0.3010676205,
-0.3028019369,
0.1125577018,
0.4461343884,
0.3232897222,
-0.1521934867,
0.37048316,
0.0560629107,
-0.3720702827,
-0.4243811369,
-0.2167368829,
0.3697080314,
0.2032895833,
-0.6173748374,
-0.3285759687,
0.745706141,
0.6332794428,
-0.6701898575,
0.4945448339,
0.8450951576,
-0.3013547957,
-0.167289257,
-0.3737007082,
-0.2244612724,
-0.4577673972,
0.5598990917,
-0.8160996437,
-0.8084232211,
0.0522477254,
-0.1424648166,
0.1896276474,
0.2044181079,
0.7151390314,
-0.0146012809,
0.943839252,
0.9226152897,
0.3232966065,
0.5567489266,
-0.2551619709,
-0.041373875,
-0.5254091024,
-0.3478071988,
0.016311422,
-0.2488735914,
-0.1760671735,
-0.6163426042,
0.3523676395,
-0.0205187518,
0.1494922042,
0.1948255897,
-0.2722527385,
0.5524394512,
0.646052897,
0.2786279917,
0.3679874837,
0.1531504393,
-0.4527431726,
0.0609219484,
-0.8003503084,
-0.3237106204,
1.0617113113,
0.0689513236,
0.7193974257,
0.3311590552,
0.7786329985,
0.055961255,
0.0762092024,
-0.8059616089,
0.566280663,
-0.5118144155,
-0.4584970474,
0.0677200556,
-0.2893795073,
-0.8448935151,
0.7981102467,
-0.3959961832,
-0.3932123482,
-0.0195532814,
0.066239208,
-0.0489276014,
0.6672241092,
-0.7647083998,
1.0873695612,
-0.0340072103,
-0.4124596715,
-0.460793376,
-0.7404559851,
0.607439816,
0.0722989962,
0.4008091986,
-0.072760947,
-0.2815041244,
0.583771348,
0.0858569294,
0.9898815155,
-0.199309811,
0.3284763396,
0.095334433,
0.3556623161,
0.058994323,
-0.1304999143,
0.3373209834,
-0.0901712179,
-0.0722538084,
-0.6217476726,
-0.6356657743,
0.3554503024,
-0.7048141956,
-0.4355335236,
-0.4195216,
-0.7183599472,
-0.0155786406,
0.2165112495,
-0.0770944729,
0.6462931037,
-0.1461645961,
0.2183489799,
0.5400409102,
-0.0340951681,
0.4566751719,
0.2823671699,
-0.3045866191,
-0.381136924,
0.9181464911,
-0.4042705894,
0.4794025421,
0.8513687253,
0.0127426283,
-0.06109735,
-0.3250290155,
-0.4698358774,
0.1821594685,
-1.0557055473,
0.0013027558,
-0.9399935603,
-0.0486503243,
-0.0755399093,
-0.1488728076,
-0.483047843,
-0.319681704,
-0.0845805034,
0.0723527744,
-0.0086450931,
0.6229020953,
-0.1604594886,
0.3814235926,
-0.8754171729,
0.7200770378,
0.7456143498,
0.1057249084,
-0.0484986603,
-0.2205993533,
-0.3719753325,
-0.0908740461,
-0.3895439804,
-0.6187150478,
0.3082676232,
0.2620939016,
0.5361801386,
0.2799756527,
-0.0009641905,
0.1962625384,
-0.5064411163,
0.5252440572,
0.7173908949,
-0.697145164,
0.2877430916,
-0.1099973917,
0.556198895,
0.5824031234,
0.4444331825,
-0.396914959,
0.0166543778,
-0.1304737329,
-0.3835445344,
0.6962696314,
0.2252636552,
0.3254993558,
0.1285685152,
-0.0562786087,
0.5222437978,
0.0751746595,
-0.8473162651,
0.1151021197,
-0.3792340755,
-0.4436126053,
-0.105334498,
-0.1047370881,
-0.2812347412,
-0.1543471068,
0.0976272151,
-0.2756678164,
0.3818810284,
-0.0256367158,
-0.5442607403,
0.1423502862,
0.3830397427,
0.47242257,
0.3644462526,
0.0578198098,
0.4606484175,
0.192633301,
-0.4437846839,
0.1562127024,
-0.0690589324,
0.2121107876,
0.0783826634,
0.3557811677,
0.9564542174,
0.4924033582,
-0.5752164721,
0.8509342074,
0.0339961722,
-0.5998597741,
0.0649362728,
0.0937022939,
0.0107183456,
0.4873609245,
0.101189822,
0.4721941054,
0.117506139,
-0.5445433855,
0.2758488953,
0.4160423875,
-0.3474195302,
-0.4204611182,
0.6336723566,
0.1814779192,
-0.2499869913,
0.1428468376,
-0.319016993,
-0.3945327401,
0.2941090167,
0.3314012587,
0.6535971761,
-0.3034490943,
0.3475942314,
0.2103040069,
0.2218883187,
-0.1611610651,
0.4103706777,
-0.5676311851,
-0.8107179403,
-0.3340548277,
-0.8048147559,
-0.4101463854,
-0.3610162437,
-0.5160691738,
0.2994568646,
-0.2902680039,
0.0931378603,
0.0460274145,
-0.3533217609,
-0.7214789391,
0.2422248721,
0.2454762906,
0.3755425811,
-0.8801465034,
1.1581686735,
0.9735950232,
-0.6155814528,
-0.3192949593,
-0.3648037016,
0.2335860282,
-0.9253756404,
0.7697383165,
0.3784968555,
-0.2491306514,
-0.1696004421,
-0.056857802,
-0.5492706299,
1.0630996227,
0.2202335,
-0.427154094,
-0.2604611516,
0.0679301918,
-0.1019167528,
-0.3699489534,
-0.0507132262,
-0.095288299,
0.1181275472,
0.3691498637,
-0.7520163059,
-0.2236997336,
-0.2574661374,
-0.1820676476,
0.4158782363,
-0.6144545674,
1.083558321,
-0.1676723957,
-0.322738111,
0.2339761704,
0.3765763938,
-0.052459918,
0.3385166824,
0.6589423418,
0.6734281182,
0.3010956645,
0.0830666125,
1.1645406485,
0.024673501,
0.2399863899,
0.9175291657,
-0.0320395976,
1.0210140944,
0.6041125059,
0.080167152,
0.1563914716,
0.1643444449,
0.2270755321,
0.990031898,
-0.3115472198,
-0.5018906593,
-0.6678454876,
-0.0456922427,
0.0850853026,
0.7746694684,
0.2972384393,
-0.0734787956,
-0.4934091568,
0.6753134131,
-0.3660053015,
0.1766346395,
-0.3659806848,
0.8277139664,
0.3713177145,
-0.3260760903,
0.2717013061,
-0.0248353109,
0.9048444033,
-0.7038685679,
-0.1701031625,
0.0376314148,
0.3263786137,
0.0505281463,
-0.539618969,
0.3264137208,
-0.3598445654,
-0.1136351824,
-0.1280038506,
0.7807247043,
-0.6152732968,
-0.4985841811,
0.3723430634,
0.7483518124,
0.0400761552,
-0.0139474263,
-0.6198688745,
0.0936537385,
-0.2515413761,
0.1945678443,
0.3701790869,
0.1495591402,
0.2487638444,
0.581110239,
0.5695412755,
-0.1964707375,
0.1704127192,
0.0999009833,
0.8058999777,
-0.4546765089,
-0.5107561946,
-0.7140976787,
0.70423913,
0.1972895116,
-0.0567772202,
0.576495707,
0.3661155403,
1.0048578978,
-0.1490634531,
0.6023568511,
0.2210604399,
0.2410188764,
-0.8743866682,
0.5895903111,
-1.201619029,
-0.220476836,
-0.0701146796,
-1.0766490698,
-0.5981001258,
0.4927377105,
-0.1554939002,
-0.0876909345,
0.9282987714,
0.7237055898,
-0.5835590363,
-0.1616753936,
0.742195785,
-0.2363563478,
-0.0215870943,
0.8590677381,
0.8547422886,
-0.4740440547,
0.8404884338,
-0.296036005,
-0.246557653,
-0.1730847061,
-0.3375946879,
-1.1086277962,
-0.8804135919,
-0.2485879064,
0.2004051656,
0.2123134881,
0.7724250555,
0.9520698786,
-0.3686586022,
-0.2007778138,
0.1151218563,
-0.1036472246,
-0.2375621945,
-0.0611296892,
0.1780707836,
-0.4569011033,
-0.8349595666,
0.2990469933,
0.6818845868,
-0.1154958457,
-0.1270988882,
-0.1907593906,
-0.4291096628,
-0.0515472665,
0.7778027654,
0.1466392577,
-0.7926478982,
-0.1199338585,
-0.1024215668,
-0.2341671884,
0.3213320673,
0.72745502,
-0.4926948249,
0.9667235017,
0.4083328843,
1.026042223,
0.7691243887,
-0.2882770598,
0.2135594189,
-0.7591283917,
0.5468485951,
-0.1131148338,
0.5387591124,
0.4613437951,
0.2145773768,
0.2837560475,
0.2642113566,
-0.1991559714,
-0.4519022405,
0.4803757966,
-1.2823522091,
-0.4133632183,
0.844645679,
-0.1588598043,
-0.4743263423,
-0.128915444,
-0.3692711592,
0.3257890046,
-0.1260220855,
0.4369363189,
0.6263452768,
0.3588782549,
-0.7701035142,
-0.6889872551,
0.0800836459,
0.6607966423,
-0.5297816992,
-0.2556579113,
0.2541716397,
0.2036520988,
0.1834902316,
0.5857642889,
0.000966496,
0.6841444373,
0.493830055,
0.2328297794,
-0.3024433255,
-0.6009206176,
-0.4388024807,
0.3945198953,
0.1019517779,
-0.8190147877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16835v1 | Zero-shot Entailment of Leaderboards for Empirical AI Research | 2023-03-29T16:28:43 | 2023-03-29T16:28:43 | Salomon Kabongo, Jennifer D'Souza, Sören Auer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We present a large-scale empirical investigation of the zero-shot learning
phenomena in a specific recognizing textual entailment (RTE) task category,
i.e. the automated mining of leaderboards for Empirical AI Research. The prior
reported state-of-the-art models for leaderboards extraction formulated as an
RTE task, in a non-zero-shot setting, are promising with above 90% reported
performances. However, a central research question remains unexamined: did the
models actually learn entailment? Thus, for the experiments in this paper, two
prior reported state-of-the-art models are tested out-of-the-box for their
ability to generalize or their capacity for entailment, given leaderboard
labels that were unseen during training. We hypothesize that if the models
learned entailment, their zero-shot performances can be expected to be
moderately high as well--perhaps, concretely, better than chance. As a result
of this work, a zero-shot labeled dataset is created via distant labeling
formulating the leaderboard extraction RTE task. | [
0.0466964878,
-1.3257994652,
0.7570884824,
-0.0089971637,
-0.0716351792,
-0.2206241935,
-0.2899298966,
-0.680018127,
0.3596001267,
0.4836385846,
-0.4203516841,
-0.9574258327,
-0.8801087737,
0.0320636183,
-0.5087916851,
1.1527956724,
-0.213850826,
-0.5288869143,
-0.4268833101,
0.1382227987,
-0.8378087282,
-0.2234418541,
-0.3255089521,
-0.4090510607,
0.4038413465,
0.6002123952,
0.3215800822,
0.9238387346,
0.6491581202,
0.1665304601,
0.2976457477,
-0.0276039168,
-0.5867942572,
0.3564231992,
-0.0036552658,
-0.5361193419,
-0.8904621005,
0.3879122436,
0.5472689271,
0.6080158353,
-0.1357755214,
0.4940518737,
0.0803795233,
0.2596186399,
-0.9181243777,
0.3763261735,
-0.8705201745,
0.1956246644,
-0.1635157168,
-0.3384436965,
-0.6741341949,
-0.1062898785,
0.1801138818,
-0.8034290671,
0.3419860899,
0.0349423029,
1.0410116911,
0.1943414062,
-0.3250769377,
-0.377920419,
-0.8203988671,
0.8457579017,
-0.3583731651,
0.1461719126,
0.9110871553,
0.3825779855,
0.1942152977,
-0.6121944189,
-0.3573637605,
-0.252622515,
0.1440400481,
0.3565827012,
-0.3473248184,
0.0939524695,
0.177646935,
0.3190905154,
-0.6240401864,
0.4319061935,
-0.3726392686,
0.1064741164,
0.7330347896,
0.225955084,
0.0224042144,
0.144608885,
-0.2971967757,
0.1810493022,
-0.7733650208,
0.0180744026,
0.1148121655,
0.2128710449,
-0.0789865479,
0.8399757147,
-0.7014483809,
0.7497820258,
-0.0107003991,
0.186041832,
0.1278482229,
-0.2618884742,
-0.5779231787,
0.4433118105,
0.6619179249,
0.3090970814,
0.3667530417,
-0.5807124972,
-0.1102177948,
0.0712575465,
0.2882685959,
-0.9117501378,
-0.3133910298,
0.3736389875,
-0.2553818822,
-0.474853158,
0.0257670395,
-0.4592508078,
-0.0704939663,
-0.2624444962,
0.9505315423,
-0.3417723477,
-0.2178442925,
0.0541642494,
-0.440054208,
0.3820818663,
0.4628339112,
-0.6137477756,
-0.0723828003,
0.9247099757,
0.8010274768,
-0.1515982151,
-0.3553298414,
-0.6210717559,
0.1420784891,
-0.656914115,
0.9815536737,
-0.8594794869,
-0.310377419,
0.0534635,
-0.1226211563,
-0.1958666444,
-0.6365329027,
0.386000365,
-0.4033656418,
0.1243995801,
0.0494071916,
-0.9903959036,
-0.0927669778,
0.6841453314,
-0.2710396051,
0.7589868307,
-0.4984149337,
-0.3109208345,
0.6525818706,
-0.7269765139,
-0.3339933753,
0.2152278125,
-0.3260549009,
-0.4117381275,
0.0566545539,
0.0638709739,
0.6986805201,
-0.1331028342,
0.3654317856,
-0.2338271588,
-0.5680195093,
0.1039199978,
-0.6223035455,
0.7145274878,
-0.2431496233,
-0.4974451065,
-0.0297886357,
-0.7451561689,
-0.0199911464,
-0.0252380837,
0.0116200605,
-0.3462550342,
0.0329744183,
-0.5827724338,
-0.1422560066,
0.3399206698,
-0.9128587246,
-0.0893042907,
-0.1678894311,
0.055957932,
0.7941646576,
0.1574606746,
0.4889606535,
-0.2973738015,
0.3341951966,
-0.135656938,
0.043633841,
-0.5503699183,
-0.8781217933,
-0.6229931712,
-0.470239073,
0.3785030246,
0.4517506957,
-0.5944965482,
0.565587461,
-0.0754800886,
-0.5975695252,
-0.5272177458,
-0.2520114779,
0.5495738983,
0.7786645293,
0.5039498806,
-0.1679553688,
-0.1783130318,
-0.9996274114,
-0.1934927106,
-0.2974686325,
-0.1617298126,
0.2984586954,
0.6873149872,
0.0757594258,
1.1072564125,
-0.9045646191,
-0.6168336272,
0.1317087263,
0.5552621484,
0.1602765471,
0.5257828236,
0.4343368411,
-0.4277700484,
-0.5893551111,
0.0923312977,
-1.4436299801,
0.1424690187,
-0.0216187518,
-0.3303445876,
-0.0431851037,
0.506470561,
-0.5485268831,
0.9426596165,
0.0151139861,
-0.2509970665,
0.6990425587,
-0.1934505105,
0.1032819077,
-0.5866802931,
0.0082030185,
0.2127422392,
0.0844064429,
-0.7949898839,
0.1778421402,
-0.04107593,
0.0761001632,
-0.203524977,
0.4171836972,
-0.3488946855,
0.1640575975,
-0.3246988058,
0.0325809531,
-0.0522297584,
0.6377328038,
0.3269376159,
0.3840382993,
0.8765690327,
-0.5565752387,
0.0480744131,
0.2059395909,
-0.1427515149,
0.6442604065,
-0.7171157002,
0.0546497367,
-0.3271911442,
0.0024098079,
-0.9282357693,
-0.3412770927,
0.1028839722,
-0.6848949194,
0.035045024,
-0.0289118458,
-0.3037643731,
0.1324189305,
-0.2178698182,
0.192595616,
0.8342031837,
-0.3414224386,
0.1745677888,
0.3402785659,
0.1024796739,
-0.3721491098,
-0.5122057199,
0.0064096791,
-0.2462956458,
-0.0024352989,
0.3405195773,
0.023494089,
-0.2827751338,
0.1178899705,
0.0871823728,
-0.4936680794,
0.1097414866,
0.5456213355,
0.2766100466,
-0.3654592633,
0.2731132507,
-0.1012712196,
0.1272808909,
0.1855266988,
-0.1038178578,
0.0324705616,
0.1500322372,
-0.4253058136,
-0.5699026585,
0.1294346303,
0.1902985573,
-0.3380566537,
0.7700412273,
0.4535004795,
-0.5534934998,
-0.5386734009,
-0.3719743788,
-0.221972242,
-0.4379366934,
0.3464416862,
-0.1591580361,
-0.746837616,
0.3823775351,
0.1794593334,
0.3168071806,
0.6963973641,
0.2459383309,
-0.2163209915,
0.6912764311,
0.7304233909,
0.2833065093,
0.1655097455,
-0.4281100035,
-0.0005689184,
-0.6700314879,
-0.5136376023,
-0.5807107687,
-0.3863836825,
-0.5834443569,
-0.1317001432,
0.3245967031,
-0.0328829661,
-0.3982432783,
0.3050808012,
-0.6142776608,
0.6870447993,
0.5065071583,
0.2532736361,
0.3995140791,
0.1500614583,
0.296097815,
0.0442891456,
-0.4941033721,
-0.3436762989,
1.5000418425,
0.1574828476,
0.3391427398,
-0.1573125869,
0.9433717132,
0.471209079,
0.3948927522,
-0.9039543271,
0.6132898927,
-0.0584688783,
-0.6885394454,
-0.542347312,
-0.2426875085,
-1.0634616613,
0.1570925564,
-0.3452040851,
-0.6831961274,
0.2060580552,
-0.0652489439,
-0.3371849954,
0.2408747077,
-0.4925331175,
0.8392876387,
-0.0053581446,
-0.3296051025,
-0.0904544368,
-0.3078418076,
0.5010303855,
-0.295232892,
0.0027524063,
-0.150015831,
0.2266159058,
0.9443867803,
-0.0937079713,
0.9648100734,
-0.2139846832,
-0.1544276625,
0.5340897441,
0.2051244676,
0.1947723031,
-0.1466969848,
-0.1723425239,
0.4683276415,
-0.4111339748,
-0.490435034,
-0.5870501399,
0.3523479402,
-0.6625491381,
-0.5744873285,
-0.3817392886,
-0.3576990068,
0.0257897172,
0.0978719741,
0.305426091,
0.5320590734,
-0.412646085,
0.4282960594,
0.5380275846,
-0.062657997,
0.4754576385,
0.6687237024,
0.0646630675,
0.0139782187,
1.1044596434,
0.5052452683,
-0.0484086424,
0.3935315311,
-0.1606760472,
-0.0142314173,
-0.6632826924,
-0.3579436243,
0.0082411421,
-0.4527209401,
-0.1557290107,
-0.4295797944,
-0.4684241712,
-0.2521261573,
-0.1616998613,
-0.3764776587,
-0.581224978,
-0.4192586839,
-0.2957950532,
0.1666941494,
0.9822863936,
0.1243693382,
0.1531073302,
-0.5071900487,
0.1985803545,
0.3458039463,
0.3217101693,
0.2312233448,
-0.7175337672,
-0.4458025098,
0.2391036898,
-0.5612604618,
-0.6813682318,
0.249299705,
0.4562461972,
0.6545133591,
0.5664424896,
0.3326026201,
0.7231806517,
-0.7953900695,
0.8621976972,
-0.0031025927,
-0.5459445119,
0.6998767853,
-0.3074945211,
-0.0032719036,
0.386641115,
0.6217119098,
-0.0059547564,
-0.5360540748,
-0.7618348598,
-0.6669566035,
0.5978389382,
0.538618505,
-0.0308658481,
-0.2022180259,
0.4915548861,
0.393614769,
0.2968135178,
-0.2295027226,
-0.0813455507,
0.0344158672,
-0.0581713393,
-0.1514782161,
0.1006244272,
0.0355918817,
-0.1358089149,
0.4885163903,
0.0738875791,
0.4312630892,
0.2191030383,
-0.2264285237,
-0.0497503206,
0.1672898233,
0.350384146,
0.7623156905,
-0.5650259852,
0.1946558952,
-0.0255243499,
-0.4441384673,
-0.0211931579,
-0.0632793382,
-0.4007506669,
0.0310597196,
0.8970850706,
0.806558311,
0.00043631,
-0.5507953763,
0.5020984411,
0.2335653901,
-0.4640741348,
-0.3101787567,
0.2191952616,
-0.4723492563,
0.0951167867,
0.6043396592,
-0.1035294309,
0.325748384,
-0.7258689404,
0.5319593549,
0.5652253628,
-0.636562407,
-0.6207039952,
0.7311688662,
-0.0442053415,
-0.4424900711,
0.7028462887,
-0.2018288225,
-0.1730986089,
1.1747709513,
0.4003369212,
1.1041405201,
0.0171344317,
0.6331938505,
0.4710978866,
0.3033555448,
-0.1121584848,
-0.2668046653,
-0.376920104,
-0.6486572027,
-0.3085074723,
-0.5473729372,
-0.7249058485,
-0.123393856,
-0.9305352569,
0.0942201242,
-0.2534879148,
-0.0818585083,
0.3956037462,
-0.2143614143,
-0.6247469783,
0.2160134315,
0.0049657314,
0.5901125669,
-0.8852615952,
0.7005255222,
0.5697416663,
-0.6005781293,
-0.4058787525,
0.2063811868,
-0.2255164832,
-0.8253612518,
0.8496732712,
0.2654886544,
0.1498437524,
0.0784441084,
-0.8665688038,
-0.4235404432,
1.1815451384,
0.0856702402,
-0.0541048124,
-0.0192373302,
0.2192600518,
0.5456939936,
-0.4230349362,
0.5744044185,
0.3528554738,
0.1485636681,
0.1446594596,
-1.0385683775,
-0.0977495536,
-0.1542379409,
-0.5946524143,
-0.1197742447,
-0.5191428661,
1.0850275755,
-0.0576800518,
-0.1094700471,
-0.1915734857,
0.6010910869,
0.4146042168,
0.867410779,
-0.0331285447,
0.584934175,
0.5911120772,
0.0807066113,
0.8260854483,
0.0554677173,
0.3805621564,
1.1255600452,
-0.7073605061,
1.2320678234,
-0.0380017683,
0.0293211825,
0.6098073721,
0.5404258966,
0.0585333034,
0.5452613831,
-0.2633254528,
-0.0262527466,
-0.4679808915,
-0.2448634654,
-0.3186997175,
0.8228146434,
0.244790554,
-0.2880245745,
-0.5723046064,
-0.1461802125,
-0.0451119132,
-0.0193256345,
-0.4120978713,
0.9642449617,
-0.0948728248,
-0.8150371313,
0.6788781285,
-0.0106358575,
0.5647344589,
-0.456440419,
-0.5400518179,
-0.3043016493,
0.165028885,
-0.0688985139,
-0.9651409388,
0.2605922818,
0.2589222789,
0.002011172,
-0.2083815187,
0.601418674,
-0.5194584131,
-0.4934944212,
0.1047662571,
0.5828649998,
0.4950038791,
-0.1928468198,
-0.2838921547,
-0.3430463076,
-0.2518371046,
-0.0067220377,
0.5221844912,
0.6735832095,
-0.1348751336,
0.3418616056,
0.4908039868,
0.0780835003,
0.0811927393,
-0.4955916703,
0.571420908,
-0.5096188188,
-0.5025978684,
-1.1315168142,
0.4137944579,
-0.216468811,
-0.1733040065,
1.0464485884,
0.817828238,
0.8006931543,
0.0061421446,
0.6424761415,
0.0948513225,
0.1319292635,
-0.4632434249,
0.8800267577,
-0.6473029852,
-0.0612730123,
0.0285634529,
-0.7578026056,
-0.398083508,
0.5731022954,
-0.3943906128,
-0.2634427547,
0.6465463638,
0.5976457,
-0.0771409348,
0.2724033296,
0.5675544739,
0.2484072,
0.2792757154,
0.4807808101,
0.5226687193,
-0.4464194477,
0.2775156796,
-0.1723742038,
-0.420914799,
0.0472831726,
-0.7783293128,
-0.9924196601,
-0.4404896498,
-0.5935572386,
0.019352816,
0.371173352,
0.5596302152,
0.5594571829,
-0.8331441283,
-0.2946845889,
-0.0724056512,
0.1136215627,
-0.2448246479,
-0.2316520363,
0.605846405,
-0.3830825686,
-0.6265116334,
0.3944344521,
0.3010659516,
-0.3151057363,
0.0236173868,
-0.0351059251,
-0.3161736429,
0.1810309291,
0.7348843813,
0.251430124,
-0.5157564878,
-0.2717165351,
0.1479760557,
0.1697847396,
0.0934214443,
0.402818948,
-0.8787085414,
0.5389608145,
0.344266057,
0.6295108795,
0.4702848494,
0.1804560721,
0.2067817003,
-1.0547468662,
0.093053259,
0.0051690699,
-0.0469959825,
-0.1392367631,
-0.3944441378,
0.6520685554,
0.374735266,
-0.6699382067,
-1.1056083441,
0.0037035088,
-0.5494597554,
-0.3065902591,
1.0075887442,
-0.2899136543,
-0.3462016881,
0.0064466726,
0.1874366552,
0.2380661368,
-0.2911361754,
0.7935699224,
0.6438731551,
-0.3491317928,
0.1615449339,
-0.9339696169,
0.2381203026,
0.1397212297,
-0.7220904827,
0.0413287096,
0.4676540494,
0.1305705756,
0.1891864687,
0.8100117445,
0.1140663773,
0.2822532654,
0.2089247704,
0.0508829392,
-0.315860182,
-0.6556935906,
-0.1587490886,
0.5273422003,
-0.2462192178,
-0.6206716895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16742v1 | Evaluating NLG systems: A brief introduction | 2023-03-29T14:49:29 | 2023-03-29T14:49:29 | Emiel van Miltenburg | cs.CL | cs.CL | This year the International Conference on Natural Language Generation (INLG)
will feature an award for the paper with the best evaluation. The purpose of
this award is to provide an incentive for NLG researchers to pay more attention
to the way they assess the output of their systems. This essay provides a short
introduction to evaluation in NLG, explaining key terms and distinctions. | [
-0.4309969544,
-0.5815537572,
0.4183400869,
0.4305014014,
-0.4056022167,
0.2508040071,
-0.2758538425,
-0.794903636,
-0.1089363992,
0.0587823465,
-0.5422106981,
-0.3212785125,
-0.7354468107,
0.601121366,
-0.6567124128,
1.2162778378,
0.3643795252,
0.0957672969,
-0.5394204259,
0.0243955217,
-0.4154495001,
-0.4612042904,
-1.1803283691,
-0.8818569183,
0.0433178209,
0.170618847,
0.6055639386,
0.1786416769,
0.6794142127,
0.2781783938,
-0.341203481,
0.0721180141,
-0.5070046782,
-0.0868389383,
-0.2370301932,
-0.1466885656,
-0.1140440777,
0.1442459226,
0.7002745271,
0.7245844603,
0.0271277763,
0.556673646,
0.4210238755,
0.7119753957,
-0.5316073298,
0.0512055233,
-0.3131332099,
0.3112073541,
-0.123703137,
-0.5282253027,
-0.4990648925,
-1.0104259253,
0.20379439,
-0.1725721955,
0.1381002665,
0.0753827319,
0.8429003358,
0.122049056,
-0.1233855411,
-0.7277489305,
-0.5635207891,
0.9589220881,
-0.9799974561,
0.18916969,
0.0507325046,
0.1377275288,
-0.4067064524,
-0.7956035137,
-0.4696627259,
-0.4140831232,
-0.2101047188,
0.4052194059,
-0.2918615341,
0.2824151516,
-0.0873971581,
0.6503233314,
-0.8690218329,
-0.083110489,
-0.2776280046,
-0.0204630233,
0.9052491188,
0.2121574581,
0.4163981974,
-0.3551168144,
-0.4336728454,
0.2159595191,
-0.5442184806,
-0.1527619809,
0.5348188281,
0.327980727,
0.0875220671,
0.3508088589,
0.0319747403,
0.8098160625,
0.1044088453,
-0.1669664085,
-0.0478081256,
-0.8504675627,
-0.4302735627,
0.517439723,
0.7892339826,
0.5404169559,
-0.074867405,
-0.5446366668,
-0.5252629519,
0.1336710751,
0.1259116828,
-0.53189677,
0.1345277429,
-0.098987326,
-1.0290219784,
-0.6081026196,
0.2456309646,
-0.8882974982,
-0.3784125745,
-0.2982013226,
0.6044535637,
0.0390599035,
-0.0605808422,
0.1460226625,
-0.4317145646,
0.2697248161,
0.0122972075,
-0.8075566292,
0.5784353018,
0.7302859426,
0.6373187304,
-0.3921888471,
-0.0540151186,
-0.5747795105,
-0.2086638659,
-0.3474263549,
0.7892610431,
-0.3606078327,
-0.5084373355,
0.093104884,
-0.2268853635,
0.1017352864,
-0.9686825275,
1.0745267868,
-0.3178004622,
0.6206157804,
-0.1909545064,
-0.7657470703,
-0.0135215661,
-0.063288413,
-0.202954635,
1.0486210585,
0.2493510544,
-0.7709983587,
0.8987771869,
-1.2388440371,
-0.1204615086,
0.5680317283,
0.1168911606,
0.2054560333,
0.3342969716,
-0.1657390594,
0.0831811428,
-0.7137365937,
0.3762946427,
0.0281921364,
-0.3116370738,
0.0103856605,
-0.0603958257,
1.1343488693,
0.428524524,
-0.3410186768,
0.3765035272,
-0.9975050092,
0.3850024939,
0.0633788258,
-0.7818478942,
-0.0890184566,
0.048737254,
0.1649738103,
-0.367780447,
0.2953589857,
-0.7576117516,
0.1616589874,
-0.8103223443,
0.353020072,
0.3706247509,
0.2166033238,
0.6607218385,
-0.0034225853,
0.8146916628,
-0.748723805,
0.3036673963,
0.1147869006,
-0.4377709329,
-0.8305060863,
0.4219301343,
0.7013306618,
0.3926840425,
-0.7406474352,
0.628750205,
0.0640705675,
-0.3240674436,
-0.4995499253,
0.3414551914,
0.5317620635,
0.1174947843,
-0.2382417023,
-0.5455263257,
-0.7950426936,
-0.9489569664,
-0.4354313314,
-0.2036070079,
-0.205885157,
-0.1482342482,
0.1894846559,
-0.046348989,
0.7730015516,
-0.147351712,
-0.1017206386,
-0.5394929647,
0.5518938899,
0.4081575274,
0.1863555312,
0.5678049326,
-0.2337559313,
-0.6103343964,
0.1680507958,
-0.8797929883,
-0.3947325349,
0.0576780848,
-0.0964450836,
-0.0473424681,
0.8080538511,
-0.2265570015,
0.3719753027,
0.4676208496,
-0.487659812,
0.7093369365,
-0.185244441,
-0.1055363566,
-0.2260702699,
-0.0473747514,
-0.1163872629,
-0.3840189576,
-0.6569045186,
0.2902628481,
-0.3550747931,
-0.0566988885,
-0.309938699,
0.7256633639,
-0.2692126632,
-0.1157011986,
-0.5512465239,
0.3616251945,
-0.0056923502,
0.1427658796,
-0.6122227907,
0.5599751472,
0.2974781394,
-0.8308388591,
0.3923745751,
0.1220683604,
-0.7898383141,
0.5437043309,
-0.631827116,
0.346576333,
-0.0349977538,
-0.0700057819,
-0.7049845457,
-0.059955854,
0.2309978306,
-0.594263196,
0.2936635613,
0.1279608458,
-0.6854950786,
-0.487898469,
-0.0288671255,
0.0206739679,
0.3187842071,
-0.7855462432,
-0.0287057068,
0.4340994358,
0.1550870687,
-0.2955225408,
-0.6126698256,
0.46460253,
-0.5093253255,
-0.5742541552,
0.1168214008,
-0.1728038043,
-0.7589178085,
0.1551504433,
0.1391566247,
0.2529421449,
0.1931983829,
-0.1204158887,
-0.2904523313,
-0.2799270153,
0.3099707961,
-0.2147283107,
-0.1410585344,
0.3241658807,
-0.3825563788,
0.3386085331,
-0.6255891919,
-0.1356837451,
-0.0622295886,
0.374635458,
-0.134206742,
-0.0418572538,
0.388353765,
0.4104526043,
-0.3149005473,
-0.2789044082,
-0.0071163601,
-0.0125803668,
-0.4723931849,
0.0304778125,
0.1691186577,
-0.6398684978,
0.2332058698,
-0.0221434385,
0.1015205234,
0.7911239862,
0.4893194735,
-0.1330046356,
0.8665413857,
1.0535188913,
0.3856354654,
0.2821132541,
0.0662994981,
0.5507472157,
-0.5926667452,
-0.1656044722,
-0.7088850141,
-0.3335368335,
-0.434843868,
0.0869239718,
0.2873322666,
0.6829100847,
0.0166412145,
0.1314915717,
-1.1385819912,
0.6767630577,
0.3868300021,
-0.2636955678,
0.2848364711,
-0.4806849957,
-0.0554422773,
0.0006705189,
-0.9556574225,
-0.9293247461,
0.8061472774,
0.2403634787,
0.6359109282,
-0.0797551349,
0.9949278831,
0.6592004895,
0.5643137693,
-1.0013360977,
0.6159361005,
-0.3210980594,
-0.508318603,
-0.4383465052,
-0.0500140861,
-1.2635524273,
0.1760523021,
-0.0684548691,
-0.8322769403,
0.1160849631,
-0.0524967164,
-0.4182389677,
0.1997835487,
-0.8109070659,
0.5957229137,
-0.4919576049,
0.0756848454,
-0.1504699886,
-0.5073915124,
0.5802208781,
0.1953983307,
0.0760255679,
-0.0011955961,
0.3009628654,
1.1908369064,
-0.1504113078,
0.2942631543,
-0.3310824931,
0.0890361592,
0.7683299184,
0.0019651779,
-0.0824680254,
-0.2182684392,
-0.1269551814,
0.0007308104,
-0.0665562078,
0.1156693399,
-0.5807113647,
0.5984553695,
-0.413921088,
-0.4414120615,
-0.3660939932,
-0.2130229175,
-0.0982340053,
0.1947847158,
0.4341406226,
0.3133197129,
-0.5633152127,
0.2341635078,
0.4374986291,
-0.6896868944,
0.9294375181,
-0.0926011428,
-0.875184536,
-0.4152781665,
0.8733187318,
-0.0852887779,
0.356751889,
0.2981399298,
0.6483758688,
-0.538708806,
-0.4978174865,
-0.6633794308,
-0.0191241745,
-1.0911220312,
-0.2251520157,
-0.3029772043,
-0.2657381892,
-0.0342690907,
-0.0584020428,
0.0394150726,
-0.5343359709,
-0.2407395989,
-0.0365363397,
0.1016094685,
1.5292812586,
-0.119944483,
0.6551926732,
-0.5512987971,
0.0457731821,
0.3586438894,
0.652767837,
0.0728215352,
-0.37387532,
-0.7132984996,
-0.3774877191,
-0.6185319424,
-0.7943631411,
0.3719270229,
0.3487221897,
0.800783813,
0.4365186691,
-0.4080967307,
0.4958224595,
-0.1841173321,
1.1770775318,
0.5122863054,
-1.2404892445,
0.705490768,
-0.3300764561,
0.6822369099,
0.5214694738,
-0.0279721413,
-0.5736010671,
-0.2952910364,
-0.793366313,
-0.9379802942,
0.6639276147,
0.0336309671,
-0.1220468581,
-0.0418536328,
0.4963009357,
0.2382374555,
0.3812716007,
-0.9560748339,
-0.3077683151,
-0.0149123836,
0.0834895819,
0.185191974,
-0.4415432215,
-0.4479264319,
0.0675219893,
0.5587090254,
-0.230276227,
0.4438365698,
0.3301123977,
-0.1857154667,
-0.2738748193,
0.4088104367,
0.6163387895,
1.0336363316,
-0.2088156492,
0.0136849014,
0.3377627134,
0.0732371435,
0.1108180657,
-0.5193862915,
-0.0172949545,
0.3057179153,
0.5895812511,
0.8834400177,
0.1581633091,
-0.5185419917,
0.370354414,
-0.3013251126,
-0.3528262973,
0.0213796999,
-0.0097375885,
-0.021687841,
-0.0512210652,
0.5341430902,
-0.0173916649,
0.4389225543,
-0.6628620028,
0.1450054497,
0.4638226032,
-0.5093610883,
-0.1593129039,
0.5497897863,
0.1188303977,
-0.7835099101,
0.199925065,
-0.5606842041,
-0.5540881753,
0.6547930241,
0.6698136926,
1.4374533892,
0.0430730134,
-0.0885561332,
0.5330071449,
0.5090959668,
0.2131708264,
0.4958728254,
0.130887717,
-0.4326918125,
-0.4984939098,
-1.2357447147,
-0.2773255706,
0.3118257225,
-0.4407874942,
0.2448348105,
-0.4979377985,
-0.3425108194,
-0.0722006485,
0.0045298566,
-0.6810657978,
0.2804465294,
0.5198794007,
0.9037516713,
-0.5128548741,
0.3851008713,
0.5390586853,
-0.0721828789,
-0.4070189893,
-0.1544330418,
-0.2101107091,
-0.1773295254,
0.9915226698,
-0.1390904784,
-0.3328714967,
-0.3943831623,
-0.75473243,
-0.868833065,
0.3911298215,
0.2556087971,
-0.113647528,
0.3161424994,
0.102903001,
0.8301860094,
-0.4798133373,
0.3361385763,
0.8379157186,
0.9894015193,
-0.5857450366,
-1.2756117582,
-0.4231812954,
-0.2645430267,
0.0484252423,
0.2331617922,
-0.5685578585,
0.4480904043,
0.0391319916,
-0.7076190114,
0.0551940501,
0.8004386425,
-0.0324510336,
0.41869241,
0.5300964117,
0.4012388587,
0.7043841481,
-0.4385505915,
1.4440484047,
-0.1641391516,
0.2110688388,
1.2346090078,
0.1984730065,
0.3060749471,
0.4537310004,
-0.5173317194,
0.2252492458,
0.8436689973,
-0.0594453812,
0.5483759642,
0.5967614055,
-0.2026443779,
0.2676717043,
-0.3748836517,
-0.1750628203,
0.628839016,
0.2095943391,
-0.2863808572,
-0.5373484492,
0.0443854928,
-0.4732188582,
0.1727184802,
-0.5185818672,
1.0025148392,
0.2179175317,
-0.7595661879,
0.5898675323,
0.0992258638,
0.7289037108,
-0.8077189326,
0.003496615,
-0.0963987634,
0.075329259,
-0.6114553809,
-0.7615580559,
0.7341472507,
0.0637988821,
-0.1192441583,
-0.5663968921,
0.9309683442,
-0.1965249181,
-0.3078595698,
0.6350676417,
0.2600149512,
0.2907191813,
0.4142994583,
-0.6497237682,
-0.042150192,
0.0721184313,
-0.2224721164,
0.1927766502,
0.4178183377,
-0.084197484,
0.5766554475,
0.4452238083,
0.1433542371,
0.4279929996,
0.3564987779,
0.2986143529,
-0.6412840486,
-0.3838818371,
-0.8944262266,
0.2895381153,
0.1527956873,
-0.4905937612,
1.1100773811,
0.7362385988,
0.7979401946,
0.0058569424,
1.0664929152,
-0.4198593795,
0.3987603486,
-0.1714108884,
0.6668715477,
-0.4339224398,
-0.113568604,
-0.2427416146,
-0.9068265557,
-0.2577968836,
0.4511172771,
-0.1255072951,
-0.2270103246,
0.6857514977,
0.2975066602,
0.3190978467,
0.2937222421,
0.4193247855,
-0.1291815042,
0.471508652,
0.1819490939,
1.2818353176,
-0.3657225966,
0.3703179955,
-0.0189629998,
-0.2583689392,
-0.1595901102,
-1.1837251186,
-0.3933591843,
-0.3644878864,
-0.0693906844,
-0.3222568035,
-0.0665786639,
1.0538934469,
0.4329638183,
-0.8836007714,
-0.7623124123,
0.0040708836,
0.3790959716,
-0.1753913909,
-0.2769308686,
0.2848605216,
-0.5393676162,
-0.7019866109,
0.685819149,
0.6622554064,
-0.3017543256,
-0.390923351,
-0.1792915016,
-0.1707234383,
0.181097284,
0.808281064,
0.0976019725,
-0.7470287085,
-0.3719089627,
-0.5434032679,
0.0028265645,
0.1362241954,
0.842687428,
-0.7729039788,
0.6327063441,
0.8247306347,
0.599039197,
0.2536271811,
-0.1744341105,
0.7183419466,
-0.490326196,
-0.0164518468,
0.4354465902,
0.1861819923,
0.3523232937,
-0.5877919197,
0.788308382,
-0.1975591332,
-1.0329340696,
-1.0041977167,
0.1970749795,
-0.55628407,
-0.023496449,
0.9914127588,
0.1634827107,
0.0617465526,
-0.1500468999,
-0.204615429,
0.3067919016,
-0.0884175971,
0.7230995297,
1.0885617733,
-0.7627347112,
0.027827641,
-0.6468600035,
1.0025978088,
0.3419950604,
-1.0270909071,
-0.344171375,
-0.0603631735,
-0.2004442215,
0.444719404,
0.307297647,
-0.3669069111,
0.1468987018,
-0.0791747794,
0.3367641568,
0.6482946277,
-0.1655473113,
-0.6649278998,
0.3075993955,
0.4501834214,
0.0929509029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16726v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16726v1 | Text revision in Scientific Writing Assistance: An Overview | 2023-03-29T14:25:30 | 2023-03-29T14:25:30 | Léane Jourdan, Florian Boudin, Richard Dufour, Nicolas Hernandez | cs.CL | cs.CL | Writing a scientific article is a challenging task as it is a highly codified
genre. Good writing skills are essential to properly convey ideas and results
of research work. Since the majority of scientific articles are currently
written in English, this exercise is all the more difficult for non-native
English speakers as they additionally have to face language issues. This
article aims to provide an overview of text revision in writing assistance in
the scientific domain.
We will examine the specificities of scientific writing, including the format
and conventions commonly used in research articles.
Additionally, this overview will explore the various types of writing
assistance tools available for text revision. Despite the evolution of the
technology behind these tools through the years, from rule-based approaches to
deep neural-based ones, challenges still exist (tools' accessibility, limited
consideration of the context, inexplicit use of discursive information, etc.) | [
0.1613389701,
-0.770806551,
0.6628174186,
0.4259830713,
-0.1409319043,
0.1711741835,
-0.2421790063,
-0.7432664633,
0.3708634079,
0.4821400642,
-0.4062089026,
-0.279324621,
-0.4267250299,
0.9602544904,
-0.1448696405,
1.1913903952,
-0.5664806962,
0.3483191729,
-0.5100832582,
-0.0619969107,
-0.5001267791,
-0.559854269,
-0.8928700686,
-0.1581040025,
0.7850285172,
0.3398686945,
0.1670539528,
0.52104491,
0.8180603385,
0.4641982913,
-0.3438366354,
0.0606027246,
-0.2489089221,
0.3716696203,
-0.1997365803,
-0.6075015664,
-0.5376989245,
-0.160057202,
0.6531838179,
0.8662679195,
0.1729510427,
-0.2644961476,
-0.0761897415,
0.8553655148,
-0.2382278889,
0.013477454,
-0.6207100749,
0.056968499,
-0.2182055712,
-0.2849349678,
-0.4019037485,
-0.496581763,
0.2296930999,
-1.0941473246,
0.6285846233,
0.0923779011,
0.3651228845,
0.3868122399,
-0.324753046,
-0.5595037937,
-0.8008275628,
0.6344717741,
-0.914018333,
0.1152408347,
0.5420659781,
-0.016129436,
-0.2485729158,
-1.0088882446,
-0.3116567433,
-0.4819878936,
-0.1245587841,
-0.0119905286,
0.1679711491,
0.1572099924,
0.2247909307,
0.2864413857,
-0.3559695482,
-0.1570938081,
-0.7112733722,
-0.1674849838,
0.8558780551,
-0.0888232887,
0.2301951796,
0.0500516891,
0.2039671391,
-0.1113412678,
-0.7471393943,
-0.2599116564,
0.4235292077,
0.0514498428,
0.3522048295,
0.725338757,
-0.0642330945,
0.5618069768,
-0.0326410197,
-0.0942438692,
0.0389842428,
-0.6178269982,
-0.1189025789,
0.2089749277,
0.4159927666,
0.4174950719,
0.0431239419,
-0.0821345747,
-0.1847416312,
-0.3724195659,
0.349306494,
-0.4088993669,
-0.0781750903,
-0.0337056927,
-0.3091833591,
-0.0715120286,
0.0265593398,
-0.5877913833,
-0.7345109582,
-0.2488172352,
0.3316048384,
-0.3112339973,
0.0720754787,
0.1755360961,
-0.2923430502,
-0.2857453227,
0.83185184,
-0.8206606507,
0.2884034216,
0.4738367498,
0.7142368555,
0.0959988162,
-0.4291471839,
0.268453151,
0.0764049366,
-0.2737478912,
0.8185719252,
-0.4051116109,
-0.520452261,
-0.1862270981,
0.2604578435,
0.0226342138,
-0.1947063506,
0.5105866194,
-0.3593032658,
0.436044991,
-0.2468549162,
-0.5166273713,
-0.1365782619,
-0.0438217185,
-0.706510365,
0.8617665172,
0.0877760425,
-0.9503445625,
0.2982174158,
-0.5093697309,
-0.7416808009,
-0.1991377324,
0.2662163079,
-0.548869729,
0.1657966822,
-0.0175743047,
0.1084472016,
0.0453958064,
0.040879678,
0.0090469578,
-0.0644708648,
0.1837947816,
-0.0979813039,
0.2578045726,
0.0611634739,
-0.2978520095,
0.3289354742,
-0.8157578707,
-0.2311208844,
-0.1806341112,
-0.1908566356,
-0.5879426003,
0.2365919203,
0.235226661,
-0.3236243129,
0.3511941135,
-0.8085696697,
0.7043122649,
-0.2366825044,
0.6917558908,
0.3553362787,
0.5586667061,
0.3953220546,
-0.2095395625,
0.5942232013,
-0.3712515533,
0.097122401,
-0.2316552997,
-0.8607133627,
-0.3699482977,
0.1268933862,
0.5919228792,
0.520645082,
-0.7207972407,
0.1325323284,
0.3505871892,
-0.6037425399,
-0.8389420509,
0.0256589912,
0.5506275892,
0.5505483747,
0.6031093001,
0.0790633261,
-0.9292827249,
-0.8090243936,
-0.4126874208,
-0.0441351272,
0.1884864867,
0.0188904069,
0.6423903108,
0.0209278353,
0.6056171656,
-0.4732945263,
-0.4778367579,
-0.0924293101,
0.4209480882,
-0.0693735927,
0.6147924066,
0.2345805019,
-0.8952365518,
-0.5260031223,
0.2326136529,
-0.6614137292,
-0.325740248,
-0.3877455294,
0.4726023078,
0.4981441498,
1.1056969166,
-0.3631932437,
0.2979932427,
0.4597406983,
-0.4059404731,
0.5422667861,
-0.6206315756,
0.418248266,
-0.9637902379,
0.3321380317,
0.1619284749,
0.0114107924,
-0.6261313558,
-0.078410618,
-0.0435467288,
0.1152614504,
-0.1779143363,
0.3652686179,
-0.6654507518,
0.3725504279,
-0.3461566567,
0.0431672707,
0.1544077098,
-0.1984106004,
0.3272951245,
0.7364677787,
0.0698970631,
-0.3307529688,
0.2871387303,
0.163590923,
-0.0053263614,
0.2669131458,
-0.8729596138,
0.3228395581,
-0.4408539534,
0.3406684399,
-0.5715315938,
-0.1384697556,
-0.0543893278,
-0.3536514938,
0.4757169187,
0.1608191729,
-0.2027540207,
-0.0524372719,
-0.3977411687,
0.2987748682,
-0.0071030254,
0.2224341482,
0.2320171595,
-0.0826463923,
-0.7013062835,
-0.7599219084,
-0.5965343118,
0.3877276778,
0.0637869835,
-0.3922612369,
0.5422641635,
-0.3445893824,
-0.4805607796,
0.2243312299,
0.1227338463,
-0.3042158782,
-0.1092390865,
-0.0286304429,
0.1234666556,
-0.1097417027,
0.0723317936,
0.2402328253,
0.1956680119,
-0.0613989644,
0.1848543733,
0.0224306919,
0.1790893376,
-0.0809558555,
-0.2016039044,
0.7811274529,
0.486179769,
-0.0244513135,
0.2932670116,
-0.0121894777,
-0.4675091803,
0.064337112,
-0.436860919,
-0.2973181009,
-0.4218186438,
0.6590148807,
-0.1503161043,
-0.6082541943,
0.319804728,
0.3113082945,
0.0151679991,
0.6230096817,
0.2503985167,
-0.1793125272,
0.7590042949,
0.8786116242,
0.3803182244,
0.3417946994,
0.1747721136,
0.2048323154,
-0.6987125278,
-0.6057203412,
-0.9423892498,
-0.2465012521,
-0.4855684936,
-0.0714329779,
0.0674363673,
0.1519163996,
0.2870519459,
0.4073905051,
-0.8199443221,
0.3756834865,
0.5607976317,
-0.1189678311,
0.5064540505,
-0.1908417344,
0.0530927107,
-0.518225193,
-0.6265536547,
-0.6905087829,
0.773896873,
0.285780251,
0.7825199366,
-0.3348501027,
0.4931890965,
0.2016076744,
0.4129440486,
-0.7955641747,
0.3907908797,
0.0085081281,
-0.4764754772,
-0.3596866429,
-0.2186169475,
-0.9408024549,
-0.1631464213,
-0.301217854,
-0.230536893,
0.3547134101,
0.1402895749,
0.012645903,
0.2926104963,
-1.017807126,
0.5856202841,
0.149969101,
-0.202470392,
0.0882408693,
-0.6512992382,
-0.1449174434,
-0.4087208211,
0.1141804308,
0.4080382586,
-0.0995374918,
0.8774685264,
-0.2382200509,
0.9455443025,
-0.0801088661,
-0.1558321565,
0.1549083143,
0.0042287987,
0.2637875974,
0.2503077388,
-0.1207455397,
-0.1843570471,
0.4597210288,
-0.1451382935,
-0.5094044805,
0.6365936399,
-0.680777669,
-0.6621587276,
-0.6557456255,
-0.8070691824,
-0.1606908292,
0.2250732929,
0.4817426503,
0.2161368877,
-0.3092547953,
0.1686317474,
0.5375523567,
0.0166572668,
0.4543547034,
0.3948471546,
-0.0189113487,
-0.5306260586,
0.624977529,
0.2760953009,
-0.1231207848,
0.5805926323,
0.0050369515,
-0.2639248371,
-0.958247602,
-0.2870540321,
0.3704359233,
-0.5874813199,
-0.1782219261,
-0.5209017396,
-0.0457143188,
-0.5934821367,
-0.6129453182,
-0.0224429537,
-0.8366064429,
-0.5597627759,
-0.169658646,
0.5836443901,
1.4469721317,
-0.11190065,
-0.0444874652,
-0.5668328404,
0.2053234726,
0.0339269452,
0.314480722,
-0.205441907,
-0.1850537062,
-0.2159458399,
-0.1062678173,
-0.2004870921,
-1.0633181334,
0.1914785057,
0.3019200563,
0.1344280541,
0.0362402387,
-0.20887658,
0.4257922173,
-0.8722539544,
1.0806083679,
0.128022939,
-0.7491933703,
0.6100102067,
-0.1108615622,
0.1427849531,
0.6065978408,
0.5889462829,
-0.9971868396,
-0.59983325,
-0.4012689292,
-0.9580360055,
0.0942218751,
-0.099528335,
0.0492694676,
0.1020740047,
0.8072838187,
0.2484234571,
0.3043087423,
-0.7807239294,
0.0695734471,
-0.5621617436,
-0.2509917021,
-0.1798345,
-0.103199169,
-0.2846783102,
-0.4497861564,
0.7761551738,
0.0623675808,
-0.0423683189,
1.0898673534,
-0.0107852668,
-0.0742493346,
0.529125452,
1.2274285555,
0.8636690378,
-0.1806148142,
0.0468952805,
0.0423469692,
-0.9059866667,
0.1621115804,
0.1323811114,
-0.5355420113,
0.1865199655,
0.604245007,
0.4710311592,
0.0997377187,
-0.3326167762,
0.0939254388,
-0.0476331376,
-0.6602011323,
-0.0988999605,
-0.2450773418,
0.051840838,
-0.1619981527,
0.692966342,
0.2405240685,
0.1152386665,
-0.3901631236,
-0.1807856113,
0.1904225647,
-0.3519077301,
-0.668520391,
0.641230762,
0.1450717002,
-0.5646072626,
0.0826858133,
-0.0580904409,
-0.2675499916,
0.499528259,
0.8350518346,
0.7770202756,
-0.4390715659,
0.2038373947,
0.1090432256,
0.4730260968,
0.0368977711,
0.6018916965,
0.4572711587,
-0.219852224,
-0.6353328228,
-0.1965027899,
-0.7262763977,
-0.0126696769,
-0.3509300649,
-0.008038193,
-0.6995862722,
-0.1891483516,
0.3392529488,
0.0365652665,
-0.1088498607,
0.1551656723,
-0.4700245857,
1.122328043,
-0.6311214566,
0.5398519039,
1.5006452799,
-0.4116047919,
-0.3705516458,
-0.4730889201,
-0.1159719974,
-0.0255474597,
0.4604435563,
-0.2965563536,
-0.2606643736,
0.0981468558,
-0.8380416036,
-0.6045625806,
0.7375864387,
0.111632809,
-0.3134788573,
-0.3152562678,
-0.0683711693,
1.0691584349,
-0.2023254484,
0.0324494541,
0.1124412566,
0.9226098657,
-0.3626101315,
-0.9981322885,
-0.0408190899,
-0.4415071607,
0.0473384447,
0.0835594311,
-0.3119546473,
0.7878566384,
-0.2868017256,
0.1773966849,
0.2387465686,
0.649107337,
0.0038603197,
0.4454130828,
0.1549091786,
0.1151840538,
0.7235146165,
-0.1417566389,
0.8761727214,
-0.0174318943,
0.0335997082,
0.7121981382,
-0.4275031388,
0.8354668021,
0.9418667555,
-0.0325501114,
0.692425251,
0.5066106319,
-0.1029175371,
0.3192504942,
0.1522937417,
-0.2946716249,
0.4963833392,
-0.2347388715,
-0.5874643326,
0.0835732743,
0.0988340825,
-0.3671792746,
0.1281177551,
0.0897264034,
0.396699965,
0.4961394966,
-0.3909511566,
0.8083060384,
0.0816381127,
-0.7759004831,
0.0887887925,
0.3095254302,
0.6254187822,
-0.8099110126,
-0.4232527316,
-0.1312272102,
-0.0032613289,
-0.5449720025,
-0.7623945475,
0.6620979905,
0.0420733653,
-0.5873000622,
-0.2500897348,
0.5702981949,
-0.4296920896,
-0.3788842559,
-0.1243583858,
0.0907898992,
-0.0585282631,
0.1014827341,
-0.3470023274,
0.0318704955,
0.0282733329,
-0.392400831,
0.0504312776,
0.3860163093,
-0.0920371413,
0.4736559689,
0.5212516189,
0.5896483064,
0.1836626232,
-0.0732295886,
0.5469726324,
-0.7424428463,
-0.1196400672,
-0.427292347,
0.3579490781,
-0.1879177839,
-0.5982109904,
0.8599075079,
0.5114667416,
0.6169186831,
-0.41369766,
0.8821775913,
-0.1064942181,
0.3504722714,
-0.6180052161,
0.8465276361,
-0.3855514824,
-0.2561830282,
-0.4486345649,
-0.794750452,
-0.7478480935,
0.496001631,
-0.128713429,
-0.0471233986,
1.3015595675,
0.4655924737,
0.2199873328,
0.1734213829,
-0.1045360267,
0.3490334153,
0.1364413947,
0.0290370267,
0.427033931,
-0.3222884834,
0.20786798,
-0.400634408,
-0.1614171565,
0.0777224302,
-1.174929142,
-0.395742029,
-0.9243311882,
-0.5925958753,
-0.3721239865,
0.1773356348,
0.7206608057,
0.30315274,
-0.803404808,
-0.0189715549,
-0.101100415,
0.1212656572,
-0.4377195835,
-0.2047380656,
0.4842196405,
-0.2552235425,
-0.8294125795,
0.5758092403,
0.2925449312,
0.3469268084,
-0.2480995506,
0.3273664117,
-0.3227613866,
0.1791760921,
0.5059221983,
0.7240027189,
-0.3528851271,
-0.322166115,
0.2134848684,
-0.1468604803,
0.0133237485,
1.2402579784,
-0.4247947633,
0.512081027,
0.6623096466,
0.5341352224,
0.3333662152,
-0.1109953448,
0.7057980895,
-0.9278687835,
0.1953958124,
0.5559337139,
0.4996612668,
0.7146691084,
-0.5528339148,
0.3513816893,
0.3353858292,
-0.8278671503,
-0.7950697541,
0.0716596097,
-0.9470264912,
-0.4039591253,
1.1115814447,
-0.088751778,
-0.1745757908,
-0.4371461868,
-0.9093265533,
0.1890069097,
-0.196158573,
0.8013371825,
1.021432519,
-0.1352311373,
-0.2575623393,
-0.3734008968,
0.8964295387,
0.4159387648,
-0.869779408,
0.0398741476,
0.3514806032,
0.2022334337,
0.220916912,
0.7114727497,
-0.0899841264,
0.2040652931,
-0.1861921847,
0.2638657391,
-0.054970026,
-0.2609941363,
-0.4204078913,
-0.0035578483,
0.3807831109,
0.5785988569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16694v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16694v1 | Using Semantic Similarity and Text Embedding to Measure the Social Media Echo of Strategic Communications | 2023-03-29T13:46:07 | 2023-03-29T13:46:07 | Tristan J. B. Cann, Ben Dennes, Travis Coan, Saffron O'Neill, Hywel T. P. Williams | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL | Online discourse covers a wide range of topics and many actors tailor their
content to impact online discussions through carefully crafted messages and
targeted campaigns. Yet the scale and diversity of online media content make it
difficult to evaluate the impact of a particular message. In this paper, we
present a new technique that leverages semantic similarity to quantify the
change in the discussion after a particular message has been published. We use
a set of press releases from environmental organisations and tweets from the
climate change debate to show that our novel approach reveals a heavy-tailed
distribution of response in online discourse to strategic communications. | [
-0.6492074728,
-0.7524430752,
0.6743655205,
0.3556275666,
-0.5968549848,
0.3981261849,
-0.2797742784,
-0.3748001456,
0.994761467,
0.4692494273,
-0.5299972892,
-0.5532278419,
-0.9577736855,
-0.063175112,
-0.4871996641,
0.7128243446,
0.1710025668,
0.0318607651,
0.2078121006,
-0.4757887125,
-0.2372651696,
-0.02934427,
-0.5971422195,
-0.0009910737,
0.7559984922,
-0.1138536632,
0.6589906812,
0.3329676092,
0.6457609534,
0.3560350537,
-0.4314617515,
0.074772574,
-0.9592145085,
0.1102558747,
-0.6730830073,
-0.2288075536,
0.1731017679,
0.1418545246,
1.115490675,
0.5598326325,
-0.1551227123,
0.3962433934,
0.6511796117,
0.2846080065,
-0.722243011,
0.2130805999,
-1.0465706587,
-0.1591472179,
0.1266365945,
-0.5390140414,
-0.1952473968,
-0.1656002104,
0.1893596798,
-0.921359539,
-0.2921577096,
0.0950936526,
1.1308472157,
0.1558778435,
-0.5518153906,
-0.641700387,
-0.8700102568,
1.0338845253,
-0.6242976785,
0.2374257594,
0.0425689481,
0.1223710924,
0.0055137975,
-0.7270889878,
-0.5977698565,
0.3333241343,
0.0561769158,
0.3014508486,
-0.3850061297,
-0.0703951046,
-0.2774749398,
0.0163054112,
0.0562253892,
-0.2309582233,
-0.247931242,
0.0097533697,
0.5346950293,
0.0798903108,
0.0338432305,
-0.3494523466,
-0.5378406644,
-0.3982268274,
-0.2830371857,
-0.2386117578,
0.5600515008,
0.3139370978,
-0.195608288,
0.2910133898,
0.1667172164,
0.2729556262,
0.2387098372,
0.0565607585,
0.0004636319,
-0.6106953025,
0.0152958985,
0.2024766356,
0.6877114177,
0.913226068,
-0.1306363195,
0.298668921,
0.139826104,
0.1064611822,
0.2979016304,
-0.6107852459,
0.0179667249,
-0.2057206333,
-0.7580398321,
-0.1606240869,
0.5469516516,
-0.8417269588,
-0.4003938138,
-0.1815772355,
0.2549492419,
0.1738369316,
-0.4722864628,
0.0244068988,
-0.6102046371,
0.5668441653,
0.2499166876,
-0.3654338121,
0.3929444551,
1.2338788509,
0.8999171853,
0.0106621394,
0.1738771647,
-0.128826946,
0.4197756946,
-0.5989531875,
0.9793859124,
-0.8474457264,
-0.3139317632,
0.2290842384,
-0.0987742469,
0.1580190212,
-0.5351867676,
0.5567919016,
-0.5355859399,
0.0907726139,
-0.418456167,
-0.7193739414,
-0.2370460331,
0.3534566462,
-0.8209781051,
0.7760458589,
-0.1713451594,
-1.0393661261,
0.5895449519,
-0.2720059156,
-0.0909892172,
0.0211751349,
-0.14923051,
-0.565293014,
-0.0540211126,
-0.0734753981,
0.3866640627,
-0.4275523722,
-0.0578320436,
-0.7144262791,
-0.2603058815,
0.3924329579,
-0.0537553169,
0.6100153327,
0.3169472218,
-0.4889897108,
0.1050675735,
-0.4111192822,
0.3139120042,
-0.0299095586,
-0.1352545321,
-0.701459825,
0.1732229441,
0.1561882645,
0.190607667,
0.1086727232,
-0.696493268,
-0.1239088029,
-0.3001011312,
0.7612143159,
0.723261714,
0.5815720558,
0.4336733818,
-0.6183029413,
0.0593662597,
-0.0864022002,
0.0405401252,
0.1341875941,
-0.6999996305,
-0.5460899472,
-0.1453368962,
0.063436985,
0.3539379239,
-0.4268357158,
0.1934936345,
-0.7269815207,
-0.7549940944,
-0.9289360046,
0.0943109319,
0.1413742155,
-0.2770510614,
0.1275902241,
-0.1531800926,
-0.4207798243,
-0.8391968608,
-0.8908320069,
-0.3559303582,
-0.2040941566,
0.5336068869,
0.2390044332,
-0.1288095862,
0.8693301082,
-0.5686432719,
-0.3355950713,
-0.2219071984,
0.6604355574,
-0.160025686,
-0.0260288231,
0.4358400106,
-0.9262378812,
-0.5973314643,
-0.1765341908,
-0.406719476,
-0.0287741255,
-0.4638184011,
-0.1534494013,
-0.1525374353,
0.5692434311,
-0.4472673535,
0.0971694067,
0.5743973851,
-0.3282110989,
-0.2804046869,
-0.1100807637,
0.7811207175,
-1.3183484077,
-0.2033569664,
0.0503417924,
0.1876280606,
-0.2719834745,
0.1582072228,
-0.3166240156,
-0.0860858858,
-0.670879364,
0.4102785885,
-0.265458554,
-0.1877741367,
-0.1008266509,
0.4746744335,
0.0650706962,
-0.0036524159,
-0.0516038164,
0.0938370004,
0.1307874769,
-0.4102223217,
0.1988622248,
0.3628826439,
-0.4824149013,
0.9110007286,
-0.5640420318,
0.1593369246,
-0.3250201941,
0.5116273761,
-1.3442462683,
0.1255658567,
0.0961844549,
-0.5434100628,
-0.3818899393,
-0.0476246513,
-0.6460720301,
-0.1108793542,
-0.8043033481,
0.2064727098,
0.3951702416,
-0.2452747822,
0.727625072,
0.5716099739,
-0.2645460665,
0.1501718611,
-0.8644471765,
0.31251809,
-0.5522843003,
-0.7222515941,
0.4543257356,
0.2261995971,
-0.6913199425,
0.3401380479,
0.1615429819,
-0.0250797626,
0.1139279678,
0.1943413168,
-0.3391853571,
-0.3018998206,
0.2038962394,
-0.1265419275,
0.0932661891,
0.39929986,
-0.3404983282,
0.4796644747,
0.0098689981,
-0.2507224679,
-0.3936969042,
0.779959321,
0.1457134187,
-0.0427421108,
1.0127527714,
0.5770772696,
-0.1490115076,
-0.2946048677,
-0.5002502799,
-0.3799287975,
-0.5238285065,
0.0476406775,
0.1843590587,
-0.6710370183,
0.4531513453,
-0.4415815771,
-0.0411095731,
0.7350696921,
0.2949030399,
-0.3317026198,
0.8690135479,
0.6183668375,
0.2621391416,
0.4996675253,
-0.272631526,
0.4411646426,
-0.4563747942,
-0.3267729282,
-0.3506163359,
-0.6417682767,
-0.8471201658,
-0.4554394484,
0.0313765183,
-0.0246651769,
-0.1934943944,
0.2859888673,
-0.5535876155,
0.1807035804,
0.3675178885,
-0.0122793987,
0.1033976898,
-0.0492068119,
0.2379631549,
-0.3514745533,
-0.4514084756,
-0.5389250517,
0.5482194424,
0.1541872025,
0.8126736283,
0.378998369,
0.6933304071,
0.5719564557,
0.3460039198,
-0.8038145304,
0.7366455793,
0.2047712803,
-0.2446350306,
-0.1419754624,
-0.4835767448,
-1.342664957,
0.1570581943,
-0.690564692,
-0.423735708,
-0.1911020428,
-0.2700417638,
-0.1373302937,
0.6258587837,
-0.2983695865,
0.513728261,
-0.0548192933,
-0.0904019251,
-0.7188052535,
-0.4776105583,
-0.3958254158,
-0.1363388449,
0.454159528,
-0.1537627131,
-0.5334619284,
1.1406985521,
-0.1638564467,
0.9209025502,
0.2151218653,
-0.1700931937,
0.6669129729,
-0.1942180991,
0.3821362257,
-0.3206521571,
0.3330299258,
0.153038606,
-0.0654504895,
-0.4647661746,
-0.7496862411,
0.9187663794,
-0.7461463213,
-0.6042503715,
-0.3294531405,
-0.0709569901,
0.0694276541,
0.0841058642,
0.0388732813,
0.1901505142,
-0.5458905101,
0.3426214457,
0.4646418095,
-0.1097192988,
0.4475651979,
0.4410377443,
0.1579520106,
-0.5838702321,
0.9088386297,
0.2850316167,
0.5227283239,
0.4665658772,
0.5603756905,
-0.355009973,
0.0051483219,
0.0541077852,
0.2004943937,
-0.9301704168,
-0.1521832198,
-0.652907908,
0.0117682274,
-0.2997267544,
-0.4502031505,
-0.2900784612,
-0.2636499405,
-0.1536802799,
-0.1295606345,
0.5082505345,
1.443281889,
-0.0093781892,
0.4558839798,
-0.7640635967,
-0.2388793826,
0.293902576,
0.2637821436,
0.0528593548,
-0.3420677185,
-0.0541563928,
0.3078318834,
-0.6502545476,
-1.152238965,
0.245231986,
0.3428041935,
0.4922138453,
0.478953898,
0.1686289757,
0.4297953844,
-0.2964699864,
1.1736946106,
0.1609882116,
-1.0203613043,
0.6013298035,
-0.6574525237,
0.2160483003,
0.2591026723,
0.7535048723,
-0.4041003585,
-0.6205989122,
-1.1561861038,
-0.9281045794,
-0.0564464629,
0.1774216592,
0.4083614051,
-0.3366128504,
-0.2657546401,
-0.4317703247,
0.2251535207,
-0.1423616409,
-0.1872655153,
-0.069988206,
-0.0155570908,
0.0309439637,
-0.1333524585,
-0.2586386204,
0.0954348519,
0.1974583417,
0.1400428414,
0.3831974268,
0.0692657605,
0.2227250189,
0.000921389,
0.4197984636,
0.4359597266,
0.427193284,
-0.0911969617,
0.2959800363,
0.3554191589,
-0.3380463719,
-0.0906633139,
-0.4020659029,
-0.0449905321,
0.4116536677,
0.5388413668,
0.3815317154,
0.9300180078,
-0.3322153687,
0.579358995,
0.1221296042,
-0.4764181077,
-0.0635750517,
-0.6018596292,
0.5510551929,
0.1311549842,
0.4733965695,
-0.0380576216,
0.3504086137,
-1.0103465319,
0.5367816687,
0.3647423685,
-0.5826354623,
-0.1704632789,
0.5759595037,
0.3941698372,
-0.4155899882,
0.2082976401,
-0.0784727186,
-0.7199621201,
0.5901122689,
0.4271298051,
0.7071046233,
-0.0835920721,
0.5364646912,
0.2903825939,
0.1459758878,
0.0847651735,
0.3380182385,
0.1993166208,
-0.5060850978,
-0.2090413421,
-0.2205225527,
-0.3590133488,
-0.1560597718,
-0.8098572493,
0.2382216007,
-0.8812353611,
-0.5508677363,
0.3944959939,
0.0277962256,
-0.6597781777,
-0.2144194394,
0.1474512964,
0.6313447952,
-0.922508657,
0.1797689348,
0.5522550941,
-0.2110489905,
-0.7620930076,
0.3399448991,
0.3112578094,
-0.5090667009,
0.6940432191,
0.2126973569,
-0.3928737342,
-0.1456469744,
-0.4734737575,
-1.0718250275,
0.9457819462,
0.3358077109,
-0.1907636821,
0.4980229735,
0.4316147566,
0.6454921365,
-0.3966007233,
0.3377595842,
0.0301437024,
0.4899329245,
0.202935338,
-0.9596700072,
0.1519713104,
-0.1295097172,
0.090985857,
0.5539008975,
-0.9843516946,
0.6060413718,
0.053692665,
-0.7740752697,
-0.2224307656,
0.6602329016,
-0.302128464,
0.2049777508,
0.5256288648,
0.4470462203,
0.5426724553,
-0.001725042,
1.0013215542,
-0.4169309437,
0.7165733576,
0.8303197026,
-0.0882041156,
1.4102243185,
0.5409421325,
0.089444764,
0.6389691234,
0.3148081899,
0.0251734648,
0.7543800473,
0.625942111,
-0.1660576463,
-0.205422923,
-0.7190063,
-0.1787379533,
0.2958699763,
0.6266404986,
-0.3235016465,
-0.3655642569,
-0.056990888,
0.0534745865,
0.7028177977,
-0.4307276011,
1.2611503601,
0.3450637162,
-0.5905833244,
0.4416225851,
-0.0827949867,
0.7684546709,
-0.392780602,
-0.3066114485,
0.3134950995,
0.2564342618,
-0.0812759921,
-1.4961047173,
0.8142828345,
-0.5445654392,
0.2544949949,
-0.495913595,
0.4541679919,
-0.6085150242,
-0.3369915187,
0.8875916004,
0.3180676103,
-0.0153124975,
0.1108940914,
-0.933187902,
0.6480013728,
-0.3616979122,
0.0001042716,
0.118928954,
0.5582808852,
0.1667932868,
0.5043529868,
0.4758186042,
-0.0321166366,
0.0546906963,
-0.0661692321,
0.9061838984,
-0.410002619,
-0.6422504783,
-0.758846283,
-0.0056675314,
-0.6619538665,
-0.6687508225,
0.9817126393,
0.3370367587,
0.9997714758,
0.1911605,
0.5720347166,
0.1878393888,
0.4839335978,
-0.2460669577,
0.7315827608,
-0.3999940157,
0.086366415,
-0.4792653024,
-1.0172733068,
-0.0272052716,
0.6420972943,
-0.3530964851,
-0.2173639536,
0.6366890073,
0.7385321856,
-0.1627344489,
0.1941252947,
0.0478693061,
0.2440661192,
0.1022340357,
0.2465437949,
1.0216186047,
-0.2535753548,
0.7360684872,
0.2171651721,
0.069066599,
-0.0389887057,
-1.0122287273,
-0.889575541,
-0.9226711988,
-0.3790849447,
-0.5352216959,
0.3355434537,
0.996450603,
0.455984354,
-0.4916707575,
0.0442201495,
0.2555490434,
-0.0832250565,
-0.1750527769,
-0.251722306,
0.4425106049,
0.2544794977,
-0.3430601358,
-0.2693555951,
0.2685766816,
-0.17688407,
-0.3625967205,
0.1142276525,
-0.449141115,
0.8182552457,
0.5494565964,
-0.0786860138,
-0.874787569,
-0.7219059467,
-0.2236863524,
-0.2121126205,
0.0433351956,
0.7763184309,
-0.429485172,
0.0014824659,
0.7881168723,
0.9498106241,
0.4872903824,
-0.0217362456,
0.4325222373,
-0.5162866712,
0.04284532,
0.3051326275,
0.0326056443,
0.6697697639,
-0.248247683,
0.2413459271,
0.1630172133,
-0.289054811,
-0.2940790355,
0.1445523798,
-1.1339884996,
-0.2931943238,
1.3493657112,
-0.2085492015,
-0.1601662785,
-0.0267761797,
-0.1843120456,
0.0237827301,
-0.6710625887,
0.7659903169,
0.8265571594,
0.5042222142,
-0.1819396168,
-0.2165407538,
0.2882412076,
0.4687905908,
-0.7195701003,
-0.3094603121,
-0.0531488545,
0.361992836,
0.4234977663,
0.4995815456,
0.2673873305,
-0.3125837743,
0.4376601577,
-0.6787788868,
0.7267084122,
0.0553360023,
0.1542739421,
0.1103184447,
-0.3099960685,
-0.1003900096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16657v1 | Summarizing Indian Languages using Multilingual Transformers based Models | 2023-03-29T13:05:17 | 2023-03-29T13:05:17 | Dhaval Taunk, Vasudeva Varma | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the advent of multilingual models like mBART, mT5, IndicBART etc.,
summarization in low resource Indian languages is getting a lot of attention
now a days. But still the number of datasets is low in number. In this work, we
(Team HakunaMatata) study how these multilingual models perform on the datasets
which have Indian languages as source and target text while performing
summarization. We experimented with IndicBART and mT5 models to perform the
experiments and report the ROUGE-1, ROUGE-2, ROUGE-3 and ROUGE-4 scores as a
performance metric. | [
-0.4338887334,
-0.4210759699,
-0.0059811464,
0.4111298621,
-0.3068278432,
0.4507289529,
-0.2144789845,
-0.3767336309,
0.4755164385,
0.5043113232,
-0.2866930068,
-0.1795829535,
-0.4696400762,
0.4391198158,
-0.6502710581,
1.1415681839,
0.0782145709,
0.0800816044,
0.1239781231,
-0.6315444112,
-0.8035725355,
-0.6057887673,
-0.2580952048,
-0.3488709629,
0.1457299143,
0.619766891,
0.6655839682,
0.3790857494,
0.8313457966,
0.2675046027,
0.0848819017,
0.077434279,
-0.3776004314,
0.1891441345,
-0.0473913923,
-0.716766715,
-0.4346674383,
0.0178926997,
0.6022335887,
0.5542424917,
-0.3688932359,
0.5331648588,
0.0328602344,
0.4963251948,
-0.4557141066,
0.3216820657,
-0.2730192244,
0.0138894692,
-0.2739299238,
-0.1706478,
-0.6984501481,
-0.4104720354,
-0.294544667,
-0.1244937256,
0.3256501257,
-0.1154317483,
0.5141916275,
0.2621048093,
-0.4880993366,
-0.1092155278,
-1.1536457539,
0.8291271329,
-0.8990336061,
0.2720411122,
0.387388587,
0.5917807817,
0.6492524743,
-0.6027023196,
-0.474205792,
-0.0048218449,
-0.5848718882,
0.4585756958,
0.0030147128,
-0.4831600189,
0.1786646992,
0.6424810886,
-0.4632732272,
-0.0604738295,
-0.6687753201,
-0.0008206544,
0.6078084111,
0.5398951173,
0.312762022,
-0.402793318,
-0.2496620119,
-0.1143292487,
-0.633790493,
0.0483017862,
0.3379433751,
0.7746340632,
-0.5199111104,
0.802161634,
-0.0345140398,
0.6824810505,
-0.1115115136,
-0.3397811055,
0.2842368186,
-0.6399537325,
-0.1216030121,
0.0230419207,
0.7510277629,
0.2079595029,
0.6799064875,
-0.1014259309,
-0.1579859853,
0.10000135,
0.0897444561,
-0.7148767114,
-0.0043843375,
-0.0562827252,
-0.6877996325,
-0.1681294143,
-0.3018941581,
-0.902656734,
-0.3306311667,
-0.3511737585,
0.1934595853,
-0.5366224051,
-0.6667987108,
-0.3293771446,
-0.0228634942,
0.4197017848,
0.1301567107,
-1.0949413776,
0.4335792065,
0.2210409343,
1.0514752865,
-0.3222974539,
-0.5288116932,
-0.2897719443,
0.1743930727,
-0.2656185031,
0.946208775,
-0.6132238507,
-0.6972208619,
-0.0408420302,
-0.1102671251,
-0.3373713195,
-0.4629043341,
0.5418601036,
-0.326923728,
0.0667137355,
-0.1315463781,
-0.1957619339,
-0.4107045233,
0.4252761006,
-0.7734052539,
1.0843058825,
0.1217196733,
-0.8301481009,
0.24183397,
-0.7404433489,
-0.9146299362,
-0.1219033003,
0.0382967144,
-0.2005140632,
0.2118769735,
0.4514714181,
0.5262026191,
-0.2898782194,
-0.098368302,
0.1656724811,
-0.4607776999,
0.1228761673,
-0.5067929626,
0.7585397959,
0.152305454,
-0.0681106001,
0.1200703382,
-0.8636758924,
-0.1040741429,
-0.0007873081,
-0.2237413228,
-0.4227962792,
-0.0903352499,
0.3192285001,
0.4268032908,
-0.1942067593,
-0.305531621,
0.2263140827,
-0.3367719352,
0.1624486297,
0.3727971017,
-0.0073420866,
0.3768721819,
-0.1104356125,
0.8693695068,
0.1583361626,
0.0887415782,
-0.6048100591,
-0.5766882896,
-0.8955460787,
-0.3998798728,
0.5811616778,
0.7212792635,
-0.7500950694,
-0.4504311979,
-0.5548063517,
-0.7137678266,
-0.9073801637,
-0.0403130874,
0.1983081996,
0.3504566252,
0.5633303523,
-0.0650377348,
-0.3740771413,
-1.2977004051,
-0.3405840099,
0.0292280558,
0.0766484365,
-0.3336625397,
0.4792571068,
0.0316626839,
1.0504022837,
-0.4774037898,
-0.2984566689,
-0.9842941761,
0.1550883502,
0.3760509193,
0.1149972603,
0.6801503301,
-0.8203926682,
-0.9927176237,
-0.0884540826,
-0.6484413147,
0.096145086,
0.095945552,
0.327932924,
0.3262182772,
0.4037654698,
-0.6904242039,
0.6045388579,
0.6421062946,
0.0348319411,
0.4452135265,
-0.1309902072,
0.4429917634,
-1.6094968319,
0.2233769745,
-0.2645412683,
-0.3169599473,
-0.9269650578,
0.0162558556,
0.1332877874,
-0.2162202299,
-0.4384132624,
0.5417491794,
-0.4394231141,
-0.1228483319,
-0.2548190951,
0.1100350991,
-0.2447703034,
0.7666413784,
0.0597151928,
0.8493801951,
0.1491260231,
-0.6011229753,
0.1335033029,
0.3164221346,
-0.183062315,
0.4584354758,
-0.5833415389,
-0.3643956184,
-0.0138913896,
-0.0520587079,
-1.1341972351,
-0.1546872109,
0.0099450676,
-0.5483830571,
0.4311887026,
-0.2653572261,
-0.733406961,
-0.1258971244,
-0.2010965049,
0.4778689742,
0.518437624,
-0.3393544257,
0.805234611,
0.4504955411,
-0.2995149493,
-0.6053830981,
-0.9837862253,
-0.0618942603,
-0.3122432232,
-0.2677719593,
0.0343683362,
0.024022609,
-0.4059714675,
-0.1687740833,
0.2486303449,
0.061157845,
-0.2695262432,
0.2506388128,
0.2120004594,
-0.0606978275,
0.0277626067,
-0.1526823938,
-0.3593371511,
-0.327910006,
0.5245280862,
0.6992508173,
-0.1785072088,
-0.4448286891,
-0.2222869396,
0.4842787981,
0.7367627025,
-0.7952290177,
0.9024742842,
0.7320386171,
-0.2385823578,
0.0252177399,
-0.3812051117,
-0.1367303133,
-0.3460868895,
0.1943108886,
-0.3746140599,
-0.3622615337,
0.9205647111,
0.0767339095,
0.0099385437,
0.7676110268,
0.9952350259,
0.2620436549,
1.0831947327,
0.8315016031,
-0.1981686056,
0.181813553,
-0.2756267488,
0.5339133739,
-0.7152355313,
-0.0466375463,
-0.5231238604,
-0.114204675,
-0.9797945023,
-0.1189306602,
0.3984307349,
-0.1058227867,
0.3759353757,
0.5633077621,
-0.3796146512,
0.4479881525,
0.5205182433,
-0.4390170574,
0.6957281232,
0.0008994997,
-0.1712659299,
-0.1376407295,
-0.7442575693,
-0.4886594713,
0.963835001,
0.1608195901,
0.9113804698,
0.4321787953,
0.3143860102,
0.3102234006,
0.7021638751,
-0.598946929,
0.3457024693,
-0.039515458,
-0.8411065936,
-0.2443213016,
-0.1825310439,
-0.6842743158,
0.6338706017,
0.0037852707,
-0.2978237271,
0.12626715,
0.013246377,
-0.3144810796,
0.2290928364,
-0.919162035,
0.6025773287,
0.0145794218,
-0.1243501231,
-0.3560450077,
-0.7059110403,
0.7286754251,
-0.0907147899,
0.4537277222,
-0.0258186162,
0.3061031699,
0.5751547813,
-0.1990982592,
0.8251034617,
0.0514977872,
0.0454140343,
0.3662890196,
0.0578681901,
0.2168599963,
0.0410062782,
-0.0561220758,
0.2033319771,
-0.0387865081,
-0.3306880891,
-0.4283308089,
0.4829268456,
-0.4638004899,
-0.1581360996,
-0.5220869184,
-0.6153200865,
-0.2167633176,
0.2083130479,
0.3386378884,
0.7057352662,
-0.074431397,
-0.0072065252,
0.2066452056,
-0.3175156415,
0.9495437145,
0.7281039357,
-0.5609105229,
-0.296241343,
0.8113742471,
0.3963831961,
0.3629140556,
0.4410122037,
-0.0633663014,
-0.2997695208,
-0.2248332053,
-0.6522558331,
0.2385223806,
-0.8486754298,
-0.3466474414,
-0.6743161082,
-0.3592666984,
-0.32340464,
0.2446622103,
-0.5900592208,
-0.7636024952,
0.3403888345,
-0.146646291,
0.3090738654,
0.9155415893,
-0.0457051694,
0.4910613,
-0.9624615312,
0.317576319,
-0.0162269063,
0.5007364154,
0.1199843138,
-0.6353356838,
-0.8150265813,
-0.0386996642,
-0.2542375624,
-0.8045480251,
0.650105536,
0.0394082218,
0.5145376325,
0.1232929379,
-0.1254232824,
0.6129345298,
-0.6179915667,
0.7067088485,
-0.0768470764,
-0.814612329,
0.3398405015,
-0.4343017936,
0.56079036,
0.5311208367,
0.2847777307,
-0.7295835614,
-0.5357052684,
-0.3579647243,
-0.6036692858,
0.6574003696,
0.5399726033,
0.1501880139,
0.1512686759,
0.0046457276,
0.2782285511,
0.1637853384,
-0.6966784596,
-0.5503610373,
-0.4159220457,
-0.1835878789,
-0.4695259929,
-0.166107744,
0.1857034415,
-0.2423560172,
0.4752810597,
0.0683573931,
0.1433419436,
-0.1966490299,
-0.4136487544,
0.0806517601,
0.3787034452,
1.0635823011,
0.6485013962,
-0.2246139646,
-0.021561902,
0.2749857903,
-0.6524415016,
0.1620771736,
-0.0590491556,
-0.1163329855,
0.2405209988,
0.94913131,
0.6564905047,
0.0249312501,
-0.5285257101,
0.2854351401,
-0.3232420087,
0.3950812817,
-0.3102657199,
-0.1600125134,
0.2067978084,
-0.0028864387,
0.3416902721,
0.3582431674,
0.1750779599,
-0.5243912935,
-0.0704702213,
0.0500893332,
-0.2763348222,
-0.5958296657,
0.5959210992,
0.2413197011,
-0.3341111243,
0.8723416924,
0.0072357678,
-0.5469281673,
0.4472671747,
0.5224948525,
0.6199659109,
-0.8147745132,
0.0738555789,
0.557898283,
0.7391299605,
0.0018600073,
-0.0007058913,
0.1942859143,
-0.4818204343,
-0.8662487864,
-0.5393388867,
-0.4318563044,
-0.1031540707,
-0.7419298291,
0.4805437028,
0.2448610663,
-0.1908241659,
-0.1303763092,
-0.2258481979,
-0.5562069416,
0.1425777972,
-0.3233325183,
0.7992079258,
-1.1245748997,
0.8014327288,
0.4471708834,
-0.9250622392,
-0.7354555726,
-0.0816140398,
-0.2179220766,
-0.592297852,
0.6076148748,
0.1278766841,
-0.1052476913,
0.0531269908,
-0.0458352827,
-0.8697309494,
0.8175076842,
0.1938994527,
-0.1484135687,
0.1608376056,
0.551586926,
0.8757668734,
-0.2969475687,
0.576012373,
0.5838253498,
0.5337794423,
-0.1727182716,
-1.140406251,
-0.4511870444,
-0.5799919367,
-0.2993510962,
0.378459841,
-0.8700709939,
1.1359943151,
-0.2325427085,
-0.2104008794,
-0.2754842341,
0.4423742592,
-0.0836292431,
-0.0568831563,
0.0593680553,
0.4179065228,
0.1722774208,
-0.056433212,
1.4895654917,
-0.3565835953,
0.4694620967,
1.2319003344,
-0.1903624982,
0.8798370361,
0.3857387602,
-0.2454179227,
0.345307678,
0.5840108991,
-0.0096276049,
0.4762175381,
-0.1719104648,
0.1721426547,
-0.0242290199,
-0.037875317,
-0.4037505388,
0.8536645174,
0.21302028,
-0.0423227251,
-0.3153809309,
0.2025534958,
-0.028575629,
0.0483072251,
-0.1827850789,
0.574475646,
0.0164699871,
-0.7534146309,
0.5884130001,
0.3311781287,
0.3991550803,
-0.4462126195,
-0.1041856185,
-0.7502812743,
0.4291416407,
-0.0831804797,
-0.6060743332,
0.7951036692,
0.1403555423,
-0.4023865759,
-0.1280335933,
0.5139497519,
-0.6053377986,
-0.8990035057,
0.303910166,
0.7084665895,
0.0504667237,
0.1249147654,
-0.180453822,
-0.1263782978,
-0.1853874773,
-0.1304628998,
0.1551562101,
0.0936685577,
-0.2778439522,
0.7595623136,
0.21169734,
-0.0961290523,
0.128390491,
0.2100409716,
0.3828692436,
-0.547560215,
-0.499919951,
-1.098344326,
0.616753161,
-0.0296327416,
-0.1777229756,
1.2028292418,
1.0164648294,
0.5973370671,
-0.3558350503,
0.8510652781,
-0.0055492665,
1.0496120453,
-0.3286674023,
0.9383543134,
-0.4703643322,
0.1800076663,
-0.3071784079,
-1.061917305,
-0.3546863794,
0.267560184,
-0.080034472,
0.1940616518,
0.5847607255,
0.5664163828,
-0.380987823,
-0.0302895755,
0.341793716,
0.208694309,
0.3136763573,
0.0193006247,
0.8374553919,
-0.4913083613,
0.6025285721,
-0.2226123512,
0.0040896698,
-0.2385305464,
-0.5794013143,
-1.1074888706,
-0.6805559397,
0.2012667805,
0.0236626696,
-0.445876658,
0.5779599547,
0.603625536,
-0.9140873551,
-0.5909717679,
0.5658777356,
0.0778976455,
-0.2607823312,
-0.2292229384,
0.6965630054,
-0.1678597033,
-0.8495634198,
0.2632138431,
0.3735284507,
0.0325764008,
-0.4289772511,
0.1023990735,
-0.4989215136,
0.1391767412,
0.8761293292,
-0.0565539189,
-0.4251275361,
0.2254076302,
0.0435031801,
-0.0452810042,
0.2278453708,
0.9945314527,
-0.7384950519,
0.2291374952,
0.5290024877,
0.1931273639,
0.632175684,
0.2360343933,
0.5229375958,
-0.8936002851,
0.3106594086,
-0.1075694337,
0.2428937852,
0.6999775171,
-0.0041612894,
0.8648312688,
0.0423150733,
-0.2511591911,
-0.938567102,
0.0165096801,
-0.6388166547,
-0.0090180151,
0.8269423246,
0.2519485652,
0.0733250156,
0.0101082725,
-0.117126219,
0.4182429314,
0.0062613385,
0.6673657298,
0.8325645924,
-0.2375683635,
-0.2968841195,
-0.8494699597,
0.471328944,
0.1571330875,
-0.9210699797,
0.1716126651,
0.0112938546,
0.1918311119,
0.5312569737,
0.6186683774,
-0.1616315693,
-0.0376108773,
0.0871596411,
0.153838709,
0.086764276,
-0.3689793348,
-0.2697214782,
0.213738814,
-0.1028438807,
-0.0832146108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16634v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16634v3 | G-Eval: NLG Evaluation using GPT-4 with Better Human Alignment | 2023-03-29T12:46:54 | 2023-05-23T22:12:16 | Yang Liu, Dan Iter, Yichong Xu, Shuohang Wang, Ruochen Xu, Chenguang Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The quality of texts generated by natural language generation (NLG) systems
is hard to measure automatically. Conventional reference-based metrics, such as
BLEU and ROUGE, have been shown to have relatively low correlation with human
judgments, especially for tasks that require creativity and diversity. Recent
studies suggest using large language models (LLMs) as reference-free metrics
for NLG evaluation, which have the benefit of being applicable to new tasks
that lack human references. However, these LLM-based evaluators still have
lower human correspondence than medium-size neural evaluators. In this work, we
present G-Eval, a framework of using large language models with
chain-of-thoughts (CoT) and a form-filling paradigm, to assess the quality of
NLG outputs. We experiment with two generation tasks, text summarization and
dialogue generation. We show that G-Eval with GPT-4 as the backbone model
achieves a Spearman correlation of 0.514 with human on summarization task,
outperforming all previous methods by a large margin. We also propose
preliminary analysis on the behavior of LLM-based evaluators, and highlight the
potential issue of LLM-based evaluators having a bias towards the LLM-generated
texts. The code is at https://github.com/nlpyang/geval | [
-0.433755815,
-0.7956684828,
0.5929131508,
-0.0721976683,
-0.2700906694,
0.3333856165,
-0.4480307698,
-0.5517970324,
0.06843514,
0.3452044129,
-0.2302359194,
-0.5358395576,
-0.4929422438,
0.2288374752,
-0.3184855282,
1.385264039,
-0.0658528432,
-0.0588718876,
-0.3405122161,
0.0131961619,
-0.3489303589,
-0.6062877178,
-0.5770411491,
-0.5614683032,
0.3013439476,
-0.1214167774,
0.8389081359,
0.192524597,
0.4692549109,
0.2843573093,
-0.144687742,
0.1814756393,
-0.4684740901,
0.015729079,
-0.2291531265,
-0.2394836545,
-0.7837435007,
0.1660927087,
0.5413677096,
0.3564657569,
-0.2647145092,
0.2068508416,
0.3966223598,
0.5809535384,
-0.5612885356,
-0.000374305,
-0.5306707621,
-0.0385501385,
0.0160070881,
-0.005540187,
-0.3254397511,
-0.6155140996,
0.2076375782,
-0.4522252977,
0.5188460946,
0.1038506478,
1.0175609589,
0.1927110851,
-0.1527523398,
-0.4792055488,
-0.5920848846,
0.7945505977,
-0.9890688658,
0.2261914611,
0.3199334443,
0.1749002635,
-0.0672733784,
-0.5294579268,
-0.7279629111,
-0.4525126219,
-0.0878146812,
0.3287817836,
-0.3191177547,
0.1395282745,
0.1545389593,
0.5342794061,
-0.8056256175,
-0.0062325136,
-0.3094566166,
-0.1391774863,
0.7863532901,
0.1728657633,
0.2892347872,
-0.3151076734,
-0.4753390849,
0.0194370579,
-0.6378128529,
-0.1483668685,
0.7229422331,
-0.0200362802,
-0.1208140031,
0.4885477126,
0.0139779635,
0.769643724,
0.1576718092,
0.0668389499,
0.3025245667,
-0.7357328534,
-0.3117060363,
-0.1543785781,
1.1748794317,
0.610162437,
0.1767261475,
-0.1556486934,
-0.2660988569,
0.2802929878,
0.4858172834,
-0.6313768625,
-0.1839065552,
0.0355912559,
-0.2460664511,
-0.4290829897,
0.0270111915,
-0.7471936345,
-0.2588016689,
-0.455508709,
0.4247154593,
-0.3718714416,
0.032798145,
0.0529621802,
0.0070596463,
0.2970175147,
0.3949857354,
-0.9187426567,
0.4269120991,
0.7328950763,
0.7864192724,
-0.3971438706,
-0.2241313905,
-0.7201004624,
-0.1610299349,
-0.4070847929,
0.743622303,
-0.391926825,
-0.2506516278,
-0.08504875,
-0.3633143604,
0.0113993436,
-0.5077331066,
0.7206840515,
-0.3478710949,
0.7099233866,
-0.0311678294,
-0.6862962246,
-0.1412844807,
0.2758131623,
-0.5549554229,
1.1127843857,
0.2784402966,
-0.5089651942,
0.3101216257,
-0.5319853425,
-0.1205591634,
0.3097374439,
-0.433618784,
-0.3999485672,
0.2486293763,
0.3141804338,
0.3813740015,
-0.7536255717,
0.6302818656,
-0.0624674037,
-0.4512554705,
0.2030528039,
-0.6211454272,
0.4414306879,
0.129927054,
-0.2907465398,
0.2200848162,
-0.6222951412,
0.2555792034,
-0.2538056374,
-0.3796057701,
-0.1468923092,
-0.2038448304,
-0.0324113853,
0.2637967765,
0.1602889001,
-0.2647629678,
0.224079743,
-0.5043056011,
0.2140785903,
0.5305463076,
0.0681884214,
0.3546078205,
-0.349514246,
0.8199147582,
-0.4783731997,
-0.0903953165,
0.0839272067,
-0.5599337816,
-0.5291654468,
0.1038688198,
0.4402127266,
0.3522428274,
-0.796659708,
0.7221212387,
-0.2510436773,
-0.4165953696,
-0.5617003441,
0.4692640603,
0.637368381,
0.3974457383,
0.244892031,
-0.4633270502,
-0.385553509,
-0.8564950824,
-0.2254570872,
-0.3512914777,
-0.5122967958,
0.10136915,
0.372943908,
-0.2214098126,
0.9657264352,
-0.4335541129,
-0.1775022745,
-0.4719699621,
0.3582804501,
0.2317701578,
0.1368954033,
0.4932768643,
-0.3821061254,
-0.3967790306,
-0.0215310026,
-0.7705164552,
-0.4084715247,
-0.0981031209,
-0.2225541472,
0.2306956649,
0.239401862,
-0.5905406475,
0.1585765928,
0.8800852299,
-0.3518408239,
0.8401122093,
-0.2929747999,
0.0173308998,
-1.0846431255,
0.1895001382,
0.2378422767,
-0.1056049466,
-0.7539148927,
-0.0151171759,
-0.0064653121,
0.0286892168,
-0.2460410744,
0.5452163815,
-0.3578417301,
0.0126439705,
-0.2344216108,
0.5085045695,
0.3165822625,
0.5208641291,
-0.2162158787,
0.9707700014,
0.0381826423,
-0.3048828542,
0.2735806108,
0.2301007211,
-0.3681609035,
0.5806530714,
-0.652936995,
0.4704722762,
0.0184133481,
0.2914038301,
-0.9719246626,
-0.3012966812,
0.134848699,
-0.3744856417,
0.2378727049,
0.1049316302,
-0.2737998664,
-0.3385128081,
-0.5402780771,
0.4442688525,
0.6311234832,
-0.4161599576,
0.5025708079,
0.2595437169,
-0.3607085347,
-0.4807119966,
-0.4798192084,
0.3001436293,
-0.4293392599,
-0.517757833,
0.2992869318,
-0.0620157607,
-0.2357245684,
-0.071216777,
0.0161520429,
0.0872388184,
-0.1595742702,
-0.0264569093,
0.5906794071,
-0.2178759724,
0.097691454,
-0.1838268191,
-0.0887793079,
0.145493716,
-0.1703916639,
0.5455644131,
-0.3935682476,
-0.3082115054,
-0.192178458,
0.0819333494,
0.3277091682,
-0.1559278965,
0.1805122495,
0.693117857,
-0.1398293078,
-0.1006188989,
-0.7085308433,
0.2454319596,
-0.4389109612,
0.405739665,
0.0206313282,
-0.8755223155,
0.3251127303,
0.1933490783,
-0.1530928463,
0.549810648,
0.7165303826,
0.0520998947,
0.7748696208,
0.3137529492,
-0.2339821011,
0.1947604865,
-0.2033829987,
0.3179017603,
-1.2846922874,
0.1583331376,
-0.2686096132,
-0.2642890215,
-0.3745747209,
-0.4568455815,
0.2373304963,
0.4711670876,
-0.0722923726,
0.2838177979,
-0.5901439786,
0.6564583182,
0.2881501615,
-0.1675747335,
0.3997061551,
-0.2561233044,
-0.1480468661,
0.0754998997,
-0.5201597214,
-0.894272089,
1.1763433218,
0.2273155153,
0.7468714714,
0.09799584,
0.6891758442,
0.3403224051,
0.6621198654,
-0.6721025109,
0.4845533073,
-0.1244558096,
-0.1451484263,
-0.3154650927,
-0.4432569444,
-0.9584996104,
0.4371846616,
-0.1477288008,
-0.9737224579,
-0.330240041,
0.2358701527,
-0.5820334554,
0.1620117128,
-0.7017534971,
0.7267814875,
-0.412663877,
-0.4104533195,
0.0270895567,
-0.3171801865,
0.63262707,
-0.2977357805,
0.0841281787,
-0.0553252287,
0.151286155,
0.7095689774,
-0.3670118153,
0.5721036196,
0.0087729273,
-0.4031841457,
0.5971170068,
-0.0589845367,
0.5246346593,
-0.0401796699,
0.0545261875,
0.2520118952,
-0.4274708033,
0.0210875869,
-0.8185901642,
0.6449628472,
-0.6882324815,
-0.5734733939,
-0.2853424847,
-0.4239183664,
-0.2310897261,
-0.0623506345,
0.4097806513,
0.3234402537,
-0.330478251,
0.1430939585,
0.0791312903,
-0.3680802882,
0.3543819189,
0.0314584374,
-0.4797431827,
-0.7949054837,
0.7972419262,
-0.1421569586,
0.5845323205,
0.0440991484,
0.3001439869,
-0.470846504,
-0.4300479293,
-0.6173178554,
0.1157087311,
-0.4543967247,
-0.259023428,
-0.4153062105,
-0.2381367236,
-0.1321395189,
-0.1911702305,
-0.0464282669,
-0.209549889,
0.01970548,
-0.0882387981,
0.080563195,
0.8681234717,
0.2356161028,
0.2101255059,
-0.6213106513,
0.3699996769,
0.325645119,
0.3155633807,
0.0407378562,
-0.4410202503,
-0.3043758869,
0.0142799979,
-0.6671808362,
-0.7350398302,
0.4371550977,
0.1138056293,
0.3272095323,
0.2431338429,
-0.349244684,
0.5348693728,
-0.5186715126,
1.1084252596,
0.4659025967,
-1.1461455822,
0.2554446161,
-0.4584497511,
0.3958717585,
0.5184621215,
-0.056280721,
-0.6103817821,
-0.6986925602,
-0.688567996,
-0.9140270352,
0.4275830984,
0.4783712327,
-0.0635924786,
-0.069126375,
0.1944254786,
0.1176574752,
0.321310401,
-0.5300343037,
0.2028859258,
-0.0826281682,
-0.2519213557,
-0.3041329384,
-0.0912273154,
-0.0014830061,
-0.0617686473,
0.4835034311,
-0.2594031394,
0.2963582575,
0.1270177364,
-0.0075003738,
-0.0628396869,
0.5347325802,
0.7409428358,
0.6406512856,
-0.0716557652,
0.1425955594,
0.519208014,
-0.4901658893,
0.2998510897,
-0.0511429086,
-0.1516692489,
0.1079331711,
0.4152145088,
0.824450016,
0.199851796,
-0.5027049184,
0.5638682842,
-0.0889269486,
-0.327424705,
-0.1737284213,
0.2633591592,
0.1172224581,
0.101697363,
0.2748920619,
0.0042200433,
0.1158408523,
-0.2898660302,
0.207411781,
0.4566932023,
-0.1958776861,
-0.5183678269,
0.7785460949,
0.2156274915,
-0.5399522185,
0.4622073472,
-0.532994628,
-0.477892071,
0.4809650779,
0.5141483545,
1.2942857742,
-0.1722759306,
0.2180594802,
0.36809811,
0.0464044474,
-0.1673163474,
0.0447907634,
0.1154445335,
-0.7759589553,
-0.8964549899,
-0.7847281694,
-0.6318845153,
0.4897925258,
-0.6010250449,
0.2702471912,
-0.1112818196,
-0.2802697718,
-0.1878457218,
-0.059653461,
-0.8640190959,
0.0154868476,
0.1802939177,
0.3379577994,
-0.7034873366,
0.676412344,
0.5024564266,
-0.3491718173,
-0.8867245913,
0.1504880786,
0.0361784324,
-0.4176580906,
0.4573807418,
0.1583822072,
-0.1832598001,
-0.1708125919,
-0.1635284871,
-0.7962043285,
1.0421712399,
0.3960018456,
-0.5834981799,
-0.3123646975,
0.1318059266,
0.9392411113,
-0.2657813132,
0.485817492,
0.628621757,
0.2814067006,
-0.1389543861,
-1.0848345757,
0.0242206864,
-0.3259721696,
0.2292233407,
0.3545441628,
-0.5186211467,
0.7363905907,
0.0126329362,
-0.2118065208,
0.1206945926,
0.4130250216,
0.4468511343,
0.1774757504,
0.3416754603,
0.5976812243,
0.8791963458,
-0.043556504,
1.2337936163,
-0.3787553608,
0.6684933901,
1.2327539921,
-0.4471548498,
0.7208600044,
0.2646684647,
-0.3444458246,
0.4545699656,
0.0366570391,
-0.106836088,
0.1785883009,
0.483605057,
-0.2910734117,
0.0858288705,
0.2155403197,
-0.0997404978,
0.4316726625,
0.1552616507,
-0.3253042996,
-0.4028332829,
-0.1751461923,
-0.1064412072,
0.0887787342,
-0.054521434,
0.831798017,
0.0755404755,
-0.9058018923,
0.6883636713,
-0.2287225574,
0.6954263449,
-0.455004096,
-0.1017782241,
-0.024648251,
0.0474345461,
-0.1438600868,
-0.8611295223,
0.2540889382,
0.373714298,
0.1264279038,
-0.1528957784,
0.7412452102,
-0.5726343989,
-0.3771523833,
0.2436948419,
0.6772407293,
0.2219011188,
0.0964181125,
-0.500695765,
-0.0881850272,
0.0041136821,
-0.4422936738,
0.3692549467,
0.2979911268,
-0.1504625231,
0.2730560899,
0.7066466808,
0.2123859227,
-0.2186216563,
0.3306777775,
0.5616412759,
-0.6787153482,
-0.4121081233,
-1.1787294149,
0.4261794388,
-0.1546159834,
-0.5565282106,
0.6715164781,
0.7339211702,
0.7713642716,
0.029995162,
0.9877718091,
0.1260925233,
0.219083935,
-0.6737915874,
0.6894603968,
-0.1284364164,
0.2052946538,
-0.6102781296,
-1.3206737041,
-0.2225667834,
0.6672127247,
-0.3762022257,
0.0982447341,
0.7902703285,
0.5894829631,
0.126350075,
0.0911555067,
0.3868841827,
-0.1141588464,
0.647225976,
0.7271148562,
1.0527629852,
-0.3795267344,
0.356828481,
0.2645017803,
-0.0977597684,
0.007261388,
-0.9074138999,
-0.7909209728,
-0.3643346727,
-0.1799721867,
-0.2753303945,
-0.0732683018,
1.0119879246,
0.1834155619,
-0.5113043189,
-0.2818338275,
-0.2767938375,
-0.2365736961,
-0.1036774442,
-0.2633313537,
0.4603697658,
-0.4849400222,
-0.7477673888,
0.3046689034,
0.3790855408,
-0.073649697,
-0.4081668556,
-0.3311701119,
0.1015124395,
0.0379865542,
0.6132395267,
-0.1129646897,
-0.9795844555,
-0.6338613629,
-0.2348600626,
-0.1792419255,
0.2389943153,
0.6027264595,
-0.8320252895,
0.4321545362,
0.4283002615,
0.7088146806,
0.3190344572,
0.514733851,
0.8256261945,
-0.8388970494,
-0.4509205818,
0.3223539591,
0.388286531,
0.3207820356,
-0.3001654148,
0.7024303675,
-0.1106277332,
-0.9123815894,
-0.5485543013,
0.0625719652,
-0.8850472569,
0.203333199,
1.3508138657,
0.0124144135,
-0.0533155948,
0.1183579713,
-0.4364948273,
0.1208590418,
-0.3962080479,
0.9366195202,
1.0481152534,
-0.3956464529,
0.1472574621,
-0.7141626477,
0.5801482797,
0.4360957742,
-1.0405037403,
0.0975947455,
0.526235342,
0.0529122539,
0.4450495839,
0.7267199159,
0.0101852482,
0.1775071621,
-0.2489333451,
0.3436447382,
0.135178715,
0.022398008,
-0.5528786182,
0.1609915197,
0.0075958963,
0.1100200266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16621v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16621v2 | AraSpot: Arabic Spoken Command Spotting | 2023-03-29T12:22:17 | 2024-05-05T12:38:04 | Mahmoud Salhab, Haidar Harmanani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spoken keyword spotting (KWS) is the task of identifying a keyword in an
audio stream and is widely used in smart devices at the edge in order to
activate voice assistants and perform hands-free tasks. The task is daunting as
there is a need, on the one hand, to achieve high accuracy while at the same
time ensuring that such systems continue to run efficiently on low power and
possibly limited computational capabilities devices. This work presents AraSpot
for Arabic keyword spotting trained on 40 Arabic keywords, using different
online data augmentation, and introducing ConformerGRU model architecture.
Finally, we further improve the performance of the model by training a
text-to-speech model for synthetic data generation. AraSpot achieved a
State-of-the-Art SOTA 99.59% result outperforming previous approaches. | [
-0.6180473566,
-0.6124788523,
0.3371530175,
-0.0689723417,
-0.6656368375,
0.2415352762,
0.0942147672,
-0.500274837,
0.2697515786,
0.5772325993,
-0.6135945916,
-0.9726370573,
-1.1235195398,
-0.1052531973,
-0.5292027593,
1.0123114586,
0.2432399839,
-0.0900423676,
0.2687913775,
-0.5164639354,
-0.2883730233,
-0.5421419144,
-0.6553289294,
0.0203245524,
0.0177948233,
0.834241271,
0.8369761109,
0.4459213614,
0.213004753,
0.2360006869,
-0.2540738583,
0.2602303624,
-0.0883770064,
0.2898118794,
0.1641664207,
-0.414239645,
-0.341055274,
-0.1989207417,
0.6055690646,
0.3039844632,
-0.4809470177,
0.1280634552,
-0.197707504,
0.8115609884,
-0.8123371005,
0.1061999202,
-0.5718522072,
-0.1900986284,
-0.2293587774,
0.2886625528,
0.0532686301,
-0.5258100033,
0.2307094485,
-0.6523324251,
0.2222943753,
-0.381829232,
0.8695565462,
0.3525055051,
-0.3641171753,
-0.7646936178,
-0.8627557755,
0.484294951,
-0.8843328953,
0.6387607455,
0.7488163114,
0.62918365,
-0.115978092,
-1.0170402527,
-0.956707418,
-0.3096596003,
0.2485373616,
0.0821285322,
-0.3517408669,
-0.0011659065,
-0.019657474,
-0.0028040949,
-0.2440094203,
-0.3136651218,
-0.3574310839,
-0.2481086552,
0.5552263856,
-0.2211118191,
0.1727208793,
0.1127524525,
-0.025180921,
-0.1086350828,
-0.7954607606,
0.0090548256,
0.3917893469,
0.4629153609,
-0.4107641876,
0.353184253,
-0.4181223512,
0.9133265018,
0.1874575615,
-0.2053732723,
0.1053964794,
-0.015498328,
-0.0659209713,
0.5134501457,
0.4910620749,
-0.0778766498,
0.2002788335,
-0.0250936151,
-0.0869977325,
0.2449924648,
0.2276965529,
-0.6532700062,
-0.4063090384,
0.1100339815,
-0.1597175151,
-0.4202452302,
-0.1912353337,
-0.3881637454,
-0.4582171142,
-0.0145453392,
0.255777657,
-0.693860352,
-0.2783468068,
0.0501194894,
-0.2056509554,
0.1775826365,
0.3705586195,
-0.724860847,
0.2490098923,
0.4716654718,
1.0126230717,
-0.0120382868,
0.1794801056,
-0.5607557297,
0.3650973737,
-0.3462291658,
0.9203276038,
-0.7732564807,
-0.780610323,
-0.2293618172,
-0.3835096657,
-0.0157147907,
-0.6475875378,
0.7955608368,
-0.6394245028,
-0.244705826,
0.0626763403,
-0.7813514471,
-0.6034242511,
0.0121153239,
-0.7094738483,
1.0771679878,
0.0139622595,
-0.5608738661,
0.4098377824,
-0.8092169166,
-0.408967495,
0.4432431459,
-0.4607834518,
-0.666351676,
-0.0825519636,
0.4946283996,
0.2327065021,
0.0792559832,
-0.030350145,
0.2037639916,
-0.2754912674,
0.1766421795,
0.0292906817,
0.260812968,
0.4835843742,
-0.5278586149,
0.017534947,
-1.0583662987,
0.030703174,
-0.1340967864,
-0.1843383312,
-0.2798933089,
0.3578076065,
0.3052655756,
-0.0206466224,
0.1514295638,
-0.7162494659,
-0.0345951729,
-0.5039328337,
0.3107386827,
0.3521310389,
-0.1323908567,
0.186060667,
0.0288581569,
0.8906528354,
-0.0407969393,
-0.234564051,
0.1352951378,
-0.7125912905,
-0.4572131038,
-0.6129271984,
0.4920862019,
0.4910395145,
-0.6678953171,
0.5023750067,
-0.2564620972,
-1.0442905426,
-0.7168658972,
0.0272223987,
0.2684073448,
0.2243951708,
0.0412875637,
-0.0657942295,
-0.4095658958,
-0.8511484265,
-0.5181697011,
0.1611917466,
-0.1109624803,
0.3811554611,
0.2527749836,
-0.2424863428,
1.2058172226,
-0.5334866047,
-0.6849467158,
-0.5597566962,
0.2826550603,
0.0851851255,
0.2741167843,
0.532584846,
-1.0153278112,
-0.8330911398,
0.2554284036,
-0.2851321399,
-0.1677110344,
0.3849007785,
0.4771718383,
-0.0043165586,
0.7614534497,
-0.4949822724,
0.6028972864,
0.8373591304,
-0.3413252831,
0.2297325134,
0.1578528881,
0.0086685531,
-1.2537677288,
0.21474199,
-0.1096887663,
-0.448466897,
-0.8848214746,
0.2742229998,
-0.0797626898,
-0.4503854513,
-0.5616666675,
0.2262651771,
-0.2752393782,
-0.0549364984,
-0.7939952612,
0.1960624456,
-0.2109967768,
0.1435057074,
0.1115118489,
1.347407341,
0.644330442,
-0.6835030913,
0.3014117479,
0.3746202886,
-0.6821636558,
0.1760758609,
-0.4747314453,
0.5016875863,
-0.085151881,
0.3541034758,
-1.4002146721,
0.0177182034,
0.0105726337,
-0.6723926067,
0.0453511104,
-0.3297499716,
-0.4812897146,
0.1234080866,
0.1691994369,
0.3578791022,
0.5646939278,
-0.3381264806,
0.8397844434,
0.7137908936,
-0.3702114224,
-0.2877527773,
-0.0087940916,
0.0145451669,
-0.1540340632,
-0.3646302819,
0.1633463651,
0.5778348446,
0.0717332065,
-0.303824991,
-0.1685510427,
-0.099497892,
0.003312675,
0.4485296905,
-0.1022844538,
0.0310068335,
0.0746582523,
0.1669352204,
-0.1122869477,
-0.230271697,
-0.1110562831,
0.8301343322,
-0.0122130597,
-0.1555308551,
-0.690293014,
0.4918548167,
0.6458957791,
-0.3676711023,
0.5468381643,
0.7129096389,
-0.3163046539,
0.1740590185,
-0.2928337753,
-0.099083364,
-0.6242271662,
0.5115974545,
-0.4981110096,
-0.7300533652,
0.4215267301,
-0.529058516,
0.1040088013,
0.5585856438,
0.3955557644,
-0.2826234698,
1.4223226309,
0.7757849097,
-0.2442649454,
0.3034306467,
-0.258161962,
0.2164631337,
-0.6447255611,
-0.0639973655,
-0.7744012475,
-0.3025134504,
-0.5849247575,
-0.1542361677,
0.8294650316,
0.3376323283,
0.0902714953,
0.2921757698,
-0.7160057425,
0.0841250494,
0.6424657106,
0.1558824927,
0.0185051505,
0.2297331244,
-0.0927262828,
-0.0112493178,
-0.5745959878,
-0.4900013208,
1.1063429117,
0.1809296906,
0.6670817137,
0.0442911796,
0.5898954272,
0.5793030858,
0.1438805163,
-0.8326961398,
0.6432569623,
-0.1667639911,
-0.4375777841,
-0.4338408113,
0.1614858955,
-0.9916450381,
-0.1258268058,
0.0466677956,
-0.7414990067,
0.1272495389,
0.3183825612,
-0.3763072491,
0.1374304146,
-0.6874207854,
0.4442266226,
0.3764049709,
0.3768804073,
-0.5395054221,
-0.7006006837,
-0.1140934676,
0.0297219809,
0.254745096,
-0.262133956,
-0.0300564822,
1.2812668085,
-0.7238886356,
0.8397410512,
-0.5402455926,
-0.1918857694,
0.5509275794,
-0.0334054567,
0.8841350675,
-0.4463275969,
0.1879654527,
0.3390449584,
0.070947364,
-0.2519472241,
-0.477119118,
0.4883798361,
-0.9144389629,
-0.3049271405,
-0.5301074982,
-0.532412529,
-0.359602809,
0.0400229953,
0.4252915382,
0.2825944424,
-0.0625316128,
0.0418426655,
0.3782765269,
-0.1531503648,
0.1034824774,
0.6336895227,
-0.0663434565,
-0.5095071197,
0.9298735261,
0.0458816066,
0.2215679288,
0.0972356722,
0.1755227298,
-0.5816175938,
-0.6463207006,
-0.7415049672,
0.0338361226,
-0.6713350415,
-0.1482207775,
-0.6533777118,
-0.3699803948,
-0.6466189623,
-0.0739381537,
-0.3180215061,
-0.5775028467,
-0.2055624723,
-0.0808747485,
1.0364658833,
0.6556220651,
0.0847347379,
1.2716858387,
-0.9697543383,
0.5043999553,
0.2310049534,
0.0315513909,
-0.1720542908,
-0.7009818554,
-0.4664744437,
0.1944447905,
-0.6770889759,
-1.1290707588,
0.6247516274,
0.5465969443,
0.2910786271,
0.5546642542,
-0.1226588786,
0.69751513,
-0.5469374061,
0.6995185018,
0.0343763083,
-0.9550577998,
0.7799195051,
-0.4204700291,
0.7160140872,
0.6181208491,
0.4380880892,
-0.775835216,
-0.6095794439,
-0.7711176872,
-0.7499504685,
0.76037395,
0.454575628,
-0.1639932096,
0.115450345,
0.2945902348,
0.0236984622,
0.4231142104,
-0.0670627952,
-0.5638784766,
-0.2487350404,
-0.4890033305,
-0.0358130708,
-0.086749956,
0.0575325973,
-0.3362440169,
0.735717535,
0.0197637882,
0.3486289978,
0.1710276753,
-0.0254658889,
-0.0375751443,
0.1986488849,
0.906201303,
0.4983558059,
-0.2664479911,
-0.1878399104,
0.1910582185,
-1.2669551373,
0.0646044686,
0.1709115058,
-0.2666711807,
0.5097866654,
0.0743321776,
0.8629344106,
-0.2229651958,
-0.89972651,
0.2264751196,
0.2286314368,
-0.134451285,
-0.5680675507,
0.0773147121,
0.3412329555,
0.1211751327,
0.7164986134,
-0.0317770168,
0.3922473788,
-0.34018749,
0.3998046219,
0.5192432404,
-0.401057303,
-0.066513449,
0.5152290463,
0.1774392873,
-0.712623775,
0.4700035453,
0.0020983259,
-0.9005969763,
0.7661528587,
0.5048641562,
0.89627707,
-0.7515489459,
0.0457586162,
0.0217659902,
-0.0594282001,
0.5954015255,
0.7701027393,
-0.3609285653,
-0.7708271742,
-0.1714063287,
-0.5489667058,
-0.5677829385,
0.3327067196,
-0.75443995,
0.2300427109,
-0.463204056,
-0.335785836,
0.3232474327,
-0.142804876,
-0.4179049134,
0.5144826174,
0.1040741205,
0.9544110894,
-0.7839972377,
1.0304746628,
0.801774323,
0.2428440005,
-0.8851431012,
-0.0509443842,
-0.143436417,
-1.2433507442,
0.8036115766,
0.1037770435,
-0.4611023962,
0.4965620339,
-0.6849513054,
-1.0017094612,
0.8581110239,
-0.125483647,
-0.8206933737,
0.177693516,
0.3908380866,
0.3252757788,
-0.0497813709,
0.0730313808,
0.7335093617,
0.3523934782,
0.2386777699,
-1.0644364357,
-0.2653182745,
0.0494771712,
-0.3028222024,
0.5237147212,
-0.3230644464,
0.4146670699,
0.1192640737,
-0.2652785778,
0.0916262046,
0.7376025915,
0.5532363057,
0.3131617904,
0.6953308582,
0.8220545053,
0.2436774671,
0.0985749438,
0.7185533643,
-0.4100962877,
0.1057669744,
0.8702035546,
-0.2978084683,
1.0343301296,
0.3059378862,
-0.3142952025,
0.6366072893,
0.3847709596,
0.2832454443,
1.1383607388,
-0.0337938555,
-0.722877562,
-0.1847784668,
-0.0953956544,
-0.3632438481,
0.8624898195,
0.9344370961,
-0.1611965299,
-0.6680640578,
0.420280993,
-0.0939458832,
0.1000478789,
-0.2423116118,
1.0979460478,
0.0019319213,
-0.3669488132,
0.7457715869,
0.4712569416,
0.5057521462,
-1.0310207605,
-0.3225577772,
0.0163824335,
0.274698019,
0.0657380745,
-0.5269501209,
0.3620169461,
-0.004450622,
0.1686609387,
0.2939631641,
0.8203292489,
-0.1550985426,
-0.6870803237,
-0.171561569,
0.2366229594,
0.4340467751,
-0.4310650527,
-0.6626621485,
0.0563253462,
0.0816057473,
0.1318319887,
0.1264462769,
0.2039079517,
-0.0915539414,
0.7488580346,
0.7423052192,
0.3519108593,
0.1536644101,
-0.0000385391,
0.7725943327,
-0.6515956521,
-1.1243708134,
-0.7410332561,
-0.1500370502,
-0.0483565815,
-0.3283009231,
0.8313375115,
0.73155123,
0.5636515617,
-0.1044567525,
1.0729185343,
0.0210218187,
1.0797703266,
-0.1024510339,
0.8905911446,
-0.2297986597,
-0.1043076664,
-0.1767872423,
-0.509175539,
0.0949661136,
0.7948142886,
-0.2167676538,
-0.2643082142,
0.1760007143,
0.7930732965,
-0.0987347886,
0.307397157,
0.3367573917,
-0.140720889,
0.3848824501,
0.1554475427,
0.6315659285,
-0.5972103477,
0.3698062599,
-0.026559731,
-0.1707091331,
-0.2467374057,
-0.4639420509,
-0.6380845308,
-0.6130540371,
-0.2618843913,
-0.1839577109,
0.2935970128,
0.6771218777,
0.8552606106,
-1.0223069191,
-0.3503429592,
-0.4000244141,
-0.2463683635,
-0.4274617136,
-0.1965949535,
0.7777331471,
0.1213304475,
-0.6975975633,
0.4362114668,
0.0439951643,
0.2418400049,
-0.0113826133,
-0.0173036512,
-0.3860558569,
0.1332564801,
0.3604450226,
0.4560524225,
-0.7287700772,
-0.2027872652,
-0.1975356787,
0.0322236456,
0.1053299904,
0.7589173317,
-1.2088844776,
0.4195929766,
0.3016856313,
0.6262903214,
0.7418527007,
0.3079739511,
0.5626851916,
-1.0404800177,
0.4808793962,
0.4053554833,
-0.0218424108,
0.2427266836,
-0.262209177,
0.0225168578,
0.0905198827,
-0.3914858401,
-0.6788509488,
0.3324579,
-0.9006970525,
-0.1631486565,
1.1043483019,
0.1177171767,
0.1790323108,
-0.5805445313,
-0.4149945378,
0.5657899976,
-0.4567218125,
0.9388045073,
0.6471114159,
-0.0163024683,
-0.2254541516,
-0.5079807639,
0.9212263823,
0.5981339216,
-0.4977975786,
-0.2509167194,
0.0377147533,
0.3328268528,
0.2882064879,
0.6700105667,
0.212301746,
0.5805768371,
-0.1072786674,
0.1046256572,
0.0184418652,
-0.0698166117,
-0.0717526674,
-0.0178877935,
0.1598474532,
-0.9972649217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16618v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16618v3 | Reference-less Analysis of Context Specificity in Translation with Personalised Language Models | 2023-03-29T12:19:23 | 2024-03-05T08:51:30 | Sebastian Vincent, Alice Dowek, Rowanne Sumner, Charlotte Blundell, Emily Preston, Chris Bayliss, Chris Oakley, Carolina Scarton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Sensitising language models (LMs) to external context helps them to more
effectively capture the speaking patterns of individuals with specific
characteristics or in particular environments. This work investigates to what
extent rich character and film annotations can be leveraged to personalise LMs
in a scalable manner. We then explore the use of such models in evaluating
context specificity in machine translation. We build LMs which leverage rich
contextual information to reduce perplexity by up to 6.5% compared to a
non-contextual model, and generalise well to a scenario with no
speaker-specific data, relying on combinations of demographic characteristics
expressed via metadata. Our findings are consistent across two corpora, one of
which (Cornell-rich) is also a contribution of this paper. We then use our
personalised LMs to measure the co-occurrence of extra-textual context and
translation hypotheses in a machine translation setting. Our results suggest
that the degree to which professional translations in our domain are
context-specific can be preserved to a better extent by a contextual machine
translation model than a non-contextual model, which is also reflected in the
contextual model's superior reference-based scores. | [
-0.6527125239,
-0.5331113338,
0.3091327846,
-0.1031333655,
-0.1670629829,
-0.425737381,
-0.4637352228,
-0.5514621139,
0.2608812749,
0.8474773765,
-0.3476544321,
-0.3896647394,
-0.4727042019,
0.5698552132,
-0.419306308,
0.8643014431,
-0.0167581588,
-0.099881418,
-0.1551314294,
-0.6785314083,
-0.6090837121,
-1.0089164972,
-0.0469583645,
-0.1021171883,
0.5714436769,
0.334982425,
0.8616037369,
0.690425396,
0.659091413,
0.2239186913,
-0.2675673962,
0.1429552436,
-0.262855351,
0.3805574179,
-0.5064940453,
-0.4149840176,
-0.3204299808,
-0.0434768312,
0.5704040527,
0.9339634776,
0.5856556892,
0.2931734025,
-0.0963271633,
0.2421562225,
-0.6070023775,
-0.1800698191,
-0.6745812297,
0.1994336247,
-0.0936036482,
-0.4763281345,
-0.5615937114,
0.2091022581,
0.1912036985,
-0.4376588464,
0.3891515136,
-0.0055025811,
0.6480730176,
0.3896199465,
-0.6929661632,
-0.0968715027,
-0.9223361015,
0.7416141033,
-0.6593580842,
0.1932929456,
0.5170390606,
0.4249776006,
0.3077477813,
-0.6193644404,
-0.4397418797,
-0.3641621172,
-0.4176437557,
-0.1053847373,
0.0558924116,
-0.2370501459,
0.3725795448,
0.3763491511,
-0.2402913421,
0.0372840241,
0.0023943724,
-0.2814610004,
0.5933064818,
0.1417742372,
0.1854152679,
-0.2473167032,
-0.3398801088,
-0.0845369473,
-0.6785519719,
-0.0253033936,
0.2556635737,
0.4333768487,
-0.2401118428,
0.4511597753,
-0.2881461084,
0.5723317862,
0.1408517361,
0.0083476296,
0.2052661479,
-0.4948973656,
-0.0431660526,
-0.0421374589,
0.5765248537,
0.1869548112,
0.5935921669,
-0.2233322859,
-0.1992850155,
-0.2818196416,
-0.0472856872,
-0.6896517277,
0.0466418341,
0.043770358,
-0.1098628566,
-0.0418371074,
-0.0968628526,
-0.15948084,
-0.4393518567,
-0.2884448469,
0.0136309983,
-0.1456948966,
-0.0716972798,
-0.3944700062,
0.1095734388,
0.0684224218,
0.3588702083,
-0.8861832023,
-0.0712404922,
0.3206120133,
0.6180647016,
-0.2795594633,
-0.1485208273,
-0.6220274568,
0.5474694371,
-0.3954868913,
0.7206748128,
-0.7650111318,
-0.3017062843,
0.2914434969,
0.1370630413,
-0.0550069846,
-0.7450760007,
0.7142300606,
-0.5590800643,
0.2205486149,
-0.4035597146,
-0.4069131017,
-0.1405424774,
0.1428055614,
-0.7299113274,
0.5940952897,
0.2602238059,
-0.7748654485,
0.39182356,
-0.3814494312,
-0.4017292559,
0.1604464054,
-0.2787922919,
-0.0714906678,
0.2668738067,
0.0914121494,
0.6172529459,
-0.1310755759,
0.7036251426,
-0.3079514205,
-0.3245759308,
0.7038897872,
-0.3389532864,
0.1274318099,
0.3575843871,
-0.2844541669,
0.3758965135,
-0.5119942427,
-0.285636574,
-0.050342273,
-0.3170982301,
-0.4724776447,
-0.2073628753,
0.40680179,
0.5164077878,
0.292658478,
-0.0679996982,
0.1482613832,
-0.2411038429,
0.4062994719,
0.3804809153,
-0.048200272,
0.6090574265,
-0.1712273508,
0.4774495363,
0.183602035,
-0.3101303279,
-0.4523281455,
-0.444401443,
-0.5439321995,
-0.3566605747,
0.2355071902,
0.522973299,
-0.3810197413,
0.5301597118,
-0.4164088666,
0.1606037617,
-0.5546153784,
0.2204276472,
0.3720416725,
0.6495808959,
0.329654783,
-0.5773510933,
-0.530603528,
-1.2203130722,
-0.4908195734,
0.2025307864,
-0.3030556142,
0.5927099586,
0.3886717558,
-0.6167291403,
1.0845096111,
-0.2372911423,
-0.3888763189,
-0.3263165653,
-0.2893752158,
0.1235760078,
0.4253350794,
0.463532269,
-1.075884819,
-0.6152847409,
0.2502194047,
-0.9543613791,
-0.3563486636,
-0.1376199573,
0.0944797471,
0.0432280712,
0.5124207735,
-0.3604795933,
0.1844348609,
0.5250261426,
-0.6172626615,
0.2937560081,
-0.3200757802,
0.1320621818,
-1.1693161726,
0.7620987892,
-0.0394414254,
-0.599567771,
-0.8596442938,
0.3440263569,
-0.0994382426,
-0.1873192936,
-0.4175652266,
0.8403817415,
-0.1664939374,
-0.0905588791,
-0.1001441181,
0.6652736068,
0.0102296295,
0.3890935183,
0.2212294042,
0.7649312615,
-0.1569617838,
-0.5021113157,
-0.1154120937,
0.3898334205,
-0.2416597009,
0.6585406065,
-0.3597603738,
0.2888944149,
-0.0770952478,
0.1218822896,
-0.9883799553,
-0.553186655,
0.1151121184,
-0.3192457259,
0.3835105896,
0.0156079615,
-0.2640960813,
0.2486311495,
0.0375383534,
0.2531128824,
0.269945085,
-0.0590134934,
0.3122214973,
0.323713094,
-0.2826828063,
-0.20725739,
-0.7991816998,
0.3685496747,
-0.5144435763,
-0.6557604074,
0.4972633123,
-0.348796159,
-0.3943077624,
-0.1523230523,
-0.0124523593,
-0.3218295872,
0.3832581639,
0.1432552487,
-0.1881946623,
-0.3404785693,
0.0436356254,
-0.0467480607,
-0.2179483026,
-0.381155014,
0.0354682654,
0.3108996451,
-0.0526268259,
0.0780536458,
-0.5838341117,
0.6921572685,
0.5618042946,
-0.2000523657,
0.8754874468,
0.7672629952,
-0.1485560685,
0.1296470314,
-0.6109287739,
-0.196579203,
-0.3988130093,
0.508628428,
-0.8127368689,
-1.0161834955,
0.8583026528,
0.0433933474,
-0.3136309087,
0.6058688164,
0.6237939,
0.0193047766,
0.9216367006,
0.8256484866,
-0.044832956,
0.6694913507,
-0.0627429709,
0.0997355506,
-1.0932028294,
-0.0039444077,
-0.3108423054,
-0.2198816687,
-0.6091921329,
-0.3797945976,
0.2003773302,
0.2329014391,
-0.1462851614,
0.5273640752,
-0.3673118651,
0.1908651441,
0.26255849,
-0.3763285875,
0.5251686573,
0.0113121634,
-0.190360412,
-0.2709476054,
-0.6539009213,
-0.9500476122,
0.8382455707,
0.3717597127,
0.0956405997,
0.2793624401,
0.2944371104,
0.3852716684,
0.725096643,
-0.4582729638,
0.3890167177,
-0.1993845403,
-0.8837468624,
-0.2618869841,
-0.422934413,
-0.8463871479,
0.4702952206,
-0.100127995,
-0.7409753799,
0.1852136105,
0.1839534491,
-0.2608829737,
-0.1059974208,
-0.8088232875,
1.0021315813,
-0.0909988731,
-0.5240575671,
0.0009093074,
-0.7187569141,
0.2877377272,
-0.4221724868,
0.4277245402,
-0.2012275308,
-0.2197936624,
0.5003117323,
-0.0568966903,
0.948894918,
0.0554275773,
-0.1614660621,
0.2559753954,
0.3135505915,
0.3049307168,
-0.0444933884,
-0.2757803202,
0.1122286394,
0.277081728,
-0.2500905097,
-0.401042074,
0.8509140611,
-0.7990463972,
-0.8221356273,
-0.0400378481,
-0.8926627636,
-0.1855708361,
0.2953744531,
0.1705432534,
0.1501872987,
-0.0856047943,
0.3975738287,
0.4563018084,
-0.2491266578,
0.2931640744,
0.6968917847,
0.0951496884,
-0.4476203918,
0.6875857115,
0.2680341303,
0.4089593887,
0.6827142835,
0.3985162079,
-0.0912627876,
-0.2921034992,
-0.4278113246,
0.1904577166,
-1.0706534386,
0.0772204772,
-0.5952789783,
0.132182762,
-0.661013782,
-0.3124751449,
-0.1363790184,
-0.4233544469,
-0.2287569642,
0.1332438439,
-0.0270122848,
0.5226272941,
0.3292137384,
0.4049307406,
-0.6774737835,
0.0360884108,
-0.008540391,
0.0577802397,
-0.3658061624,
-0.9991770983,
-0.4481346607,
-0.219894588,
-0.2290815413,
-0.9658652544,
0.642326057,
0.2226995379,
0.5742377639,
0.5530015826,
0.1304422766,
0.447442472,
-0.2788895965,
0.7853286266,
-0.1998745799,
-0.9910973907,
0.3115038574,
-0.5384007096,
0.5883742571,
0.7243708372,
0.4640487432,
-0.8605010509,
-0.15186432,
-0.4801159203,
-0.9268519282,
0.4589117467,
0.1558169723,
0.2212372422,
0.1416241527,
0.5462055802,
0.163944155,
0.3153955638,
-0.7812595963,
-0.037889123,
0.2344706804,
-0.2444560975,
-0.5783321261,
-0.425670892,
-0.236477375,
0.0122267716,
0.3051197827,
-0.2533997893,
-0.0068061464,
0.5129620433,
-0.3689385653,
0.1048120782,
0.3940611482,
0.8374812007,
0.4766891003,
-0.3563476801,
0.3228184879,
0.3636749387,
-0.1245673448,
-0.0659761205,
-0.2098237276,
-0.3471156061,
0.2336230576,
0.7577024102,
0.7540289164,
0.3594657779,
-0.6327621341,
0.4004758596,
0.2031230778,
0.3645247519,
-0.306150943,
-0.1913799345,
0.0840767026,
0.0140958475,
0.1345554143,
0.0424634479,
-0.0404705815,
-0.6737428308,
0.1796288639,
0.1939755082,
-0.6150416136,
-0.690337956,
0.6720407009,
0.4847007096,
-0.4942598939,
0.0655823946,
-0.0621308163,
-0.3483730853,
0.3845889568,
0.6074767113,
1.0567393303,
-0.368531853,
-0.2757649422,
0.1990544945,
0.136587128,
0.2193104178,
-0.3825550377,
-0.4474053383,
-0.7223434448,
-0.3293364346,
-0.4060437083,
-0.575535953,
0.1227666661,
-0.5294563174,
0.2439982146,
-0.087472342,
-0.3572172225,
-0.1538543403,
-0.0957326069,
-0.8914771676,
0.2930569649,
0.2741841376,
0.738060236,
-0.9649215937,
0.9940311909,
0.816706121,
-0.5348961949,
-0.3785594404,
0.0446989164,
-0.3334387839,
-0.2959321439,
0.8639083505,
0.2721878588,
-0.0439027436,
-0.1861748099,
-0.111119464,
-0.9376186132,
0.9533727169,
0.659121573,
-0.5292877555,
0.0620090365,
0.2773620486,
0.6953674555,
-0.7774038911,
0.3088491261,
0.5715938807,
0.3634432554,
-0.0531244352,
-1.0204142332,
0.1944203228,
-0.1977757961,
0.0706774145,
-0.2623120248,
-0.4862025976,
0.5535075068,
-0.0435145646,
-0.1989465207,
0.0400719345,
0.4064340889,
-0.1130965948,
0.3789472878,
0.174530372,
-0.0117166601,
0.6726972461,
0.3005710542,
1.2719739676,
-0.6732138991,
0.2144123614,
1.2210611105,
-0.3610835671,
0.9374967813,
0.7296409011,
0.1591223329,
0.3651859164,
0.334264189,
0.3134769797,
0.4465608597,
0.013777378,
-0.3189321756,
-0.3341419101,
-0.4902583957,
-0.3970084488,
0.3027428389,
0.1876965761,
-0.6695178747,
0.1826999485,
-0.0301742218,
-0.0163905695,
0.4478037059,
0.0353127606,
0.5918772221,
0.299095124,
-0.8215367198,
0.7173517346,
0.3376294076,
0.5355576873,
-0.6063534617,
0.3962731659,
-0.4935806096,
0.3596731722,
-0.299208194,
-0.4307649136,
0.6132858992,
0.1317440569,
-0.3527594209,
-0.3751464188,
0.4842751324,
-0.5203198195,
-0.1639701277,
0.2337423861,
0.4198487997,
0.339187324,
-0.1448938251,
-0.1361117959,
0.0883799419,
-0.0333336145,
-0.3398471177,
0.4910809696,
0.4794558883,
-0.4102302194,
0.5873984098,
0.385428369,
-0.055029545,
-0.1817461252,
0.1004727259,
0.5693640113,
-0.8961969018,
-0.3554780483,
-0.7569482923,
0.5164915323,
-0.0384167656,
-0.5789319277,
0.9898110032,
0.4538987279,
0.9884829521,
-0.3816428483,
0.7608534098,
0.3392809331,
0.1060745418,
-0.1403620988,
0.5426469445,
-0.2745946646,
0.3911245167,
-0.3224337399,
-0.8472946882,
-0.479190141,
0.497502923,
-0.7588900924,
0.0204928871,
0.5800736547,
0.5993243456,
-0.0062912637,
-0.3821276426,
0.8295622468,
0.0250503905,
0.309387058,
0.4378804862,
0.6587511301,
-0.2913251817,
0.4060189128,
-0.0736996755,
-0.0430899635,
-0.5084497929,
-0.894497335,
-0.9572990537,
-0.5970454216,
-0.523622334,
-0.0921009555,
-0.2309230715,
0.8127691746,
0.7606002688,
-0.9036328197,
-0.2559012771,
0.2948137522,
-0.0637379661,
-0.0096802888,
-0.1930837035,
0.2422585934,
-0.1876523942,
-0.7290015221,
0.4604299068,
0.2486569881,
-0.0795354769,
-0.3355926871,
-0.0893985406,
-0.0482230112,
0.3069940209,
0.7375448942,
0.1221057698,
-0.7869504094,
-0.4989284277,
-0.0590274893,
-0.2627094984,
0.1499535292,
0.8643272519,
-0.72231704,
0.586751163,
0.4839803278,
0.5612445474,
0.477865696,
0.1163562909,
0.6187720895,
-0.8377063274,
0.5064041018,
0.2080539316,
0.3336263001,
0.7295907736,
-0.4616392851,
0.4233861864,
0.4124160409,
-0.3600105345,
-0.7781286836,
0.4904368818,
-0.8781188726,
-0.1135514602,
1.2444477081,
-0.4769986272,
0.0344405919,
-0.0177589431,
-0.2313247025,
0.26338166,
-0.1073125377,
0.6128242016,
0.5989094973,
0.1024338156,
0.1191956401,
-0.7927580476,
0.326287955,
0.7496480346,
-0.4728577137,
0.0108902641,
0.2139085084,
0.4176801145,
0.3358156085,
0.4391466081,
0.0357710123,
-0.1536954343,
-0.199236095,
0.0023095589,
-0.1547770798,
-0.1929016262,
-0.5931121111,
0.4943601489,
0.2815595865,
0.2213080972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.06148v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.06148v1 | A semi-automatic method for document classification in the shipping industry | 2023-03-29T10:00:43 | 2023-03-29T10:00:43 | Narayanan Arvind | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In the shipping industry, document classification plays a crucial role in
ensuring that the necessary documents are properly identified and processed for
customs clearance. OCR technology is being used to automate the process of
document classification, which involves identifying important documents such as
Commercial Invoices, Packing Lists, Export/Import Customs Declarations, Bills
of Lading, Sea Waybills, Certificates, Air or Rail Waybills, Arrival Notices,
Certificate of Origin, Importer Security Filings, and Letters of Credit. By
using OCR technology, the shipping industry can improve accuracy and efficiency
in document classification and streamline the customs clearance process. The
aim of this study is to build a robust document classification system based on
keyword frequencies. The research is carried out by analyzing Contract-Breach
law documents available with IN-D. The documents were collected by scraping the
Singapore Government Judiciary website. The database developed has 250
Contract-Breach documents. These documents are splitted to generate 200
training documents and 50 test documents. A semi-automatic approach is used to
select keyword vectors for document classification. The accuracy of the
reported model is 92.00 %. | [
-0.2889049947,
-0.2423358411,
0.3902801275,
-0.166456297,
-0.681271553,
0.1056114957,
0.2243879586,
-0.6185017824,
-0.1522155851,
0.8641141653,
-0.2179832757,
-0.5879994035,
-0.4861842096,
0.2920644581,
-0.6470691562,
0.5564149022,
-0.1059621796,
-0.1561567187,
0.1109976843,
-0.0779466629,
-0.4288387895,
-0.6156811714,
-0.4175894856,
0.2233454287,
-0.425529182,
0.3723231852,
0.3959395289,
0.5624817014,
0.7641995549,
0.5409016013,
-0.2150826305,
0.2803195417,
0.0189451259,
0.1274478436,
-0.2116399854,
-0.7482027411,
-0.5273768306,
0.0044087037,
0.3503957093,
-0.0859916136,
-0.2838566601,
0.0046487674,
0.0398591906,
0.6022050381,
-0.3106426001,
0.5971655846,
-0.3799339235,
0.0963144079,
-0.5600484014,
-0.4428033233,
-0.4378478527,
-0.280595392,
-0.1726502925,
-0.5139963031,
0.4233328998,
0.2885619998,
1.2704590559,
0.3543909788,
-0.6486424208,
-0.8558261991,
-0.5392770171,
0.4942134917,
-0.5808588266,
0.5873445272,
0.5676365495,
0.4625281394,
-0.2188305259,
-0.8822769523,
-0.503508687,
-0.0449532606,
-0.3669214249,
0.3101691902,
0.2057973146,
0.2881952822,
0.2216259986,
0.4774778485,
-0.5902460217,
0.2076454759,
-0.5914646983,
-0.4093839824,
0.7579548955,
0.1593338549,
0.5271844268,
-0.2877563536,
-0.3735487759,
-0.1693177074,
-0.1304613352,
0.0377671942,
0.4102352858,
0.1731355786,
-0.0462908857,
0.4460552037,
-0.0576259345,
0.6841632724,
0.1374418885,
-0.5788676143,
0.2979538143,
-0.3745034635,
-0.3842252493,
0.4538745582,
0.6344583631,
0.3099552095,
-0.2839001417,
0.0928417519,
-0.5292735696,
0.0800302699,
0.6425110102,
-0.2821023464,
0.1613184363,
-0.0084730117,
-0.5838567615,
-0.5624163747,
0.434109658,
-0.8178115487,
-0.3461536467,
-0.1068848595,
-0.0092861447,
-0.194342494,
0.1648372263,
0.1317800283,
-0.6415561438,
0.170678854,
0.4919059575,
-0.2603855133,
-0.1745250672,
0.4751064479,
0.8754121661,
0.3109958768,
0.3388379812,
-0.2823968828,
0.1905562133,
-0.1264838278,
1.0242558718,
-0.228073433,
-0.527762711,
0.3813555241,
0.2030617893,
0.0862628743,
-0.3962869048,
1.1456323862,
-0.9696781635,
0.2054026574,
0.2818346918,
-0.6144690514,
-0.4666154087,
0.4046960771,
-0.7808101177,
0.8480188847,
0.5080072284,
-0.5080292225,
0.8429939747,
-0.3447259963,
-0.5915760398,
0.740948379,
-0.3128373921,
-0.7506772876,
-0.1616522223,
-0.2750898898,
0.5956959128,
-0.3506974876,
0.0218296647,
-0.0291554481,
-0.3916505277,
-0.1376969516,
-0.0014685777,
0.7320541739,
0.7181653976,
-0.2755590081,
-0.4824774265,
-0.6961386204,
-0.158802554,
-0.2683568299,
-0.9003384113,
-0.678861618,
-0.2708998919,
0.0632397979,
0.3157696724,
0.1625936329,
-0.6005942225,
0.2725929916,
-0.4239100814,
0.5373696685,
0.2862841189,
0.1751800478,
0.5395532846,
-0.4590290785,
0.5413441062,
0.1532031149,
0.1786849499,
0.0893703923,
-0.5376135707,
-0.4020917714,
-0.4978532791,
0.5693165064,
0.5843885541,
-0.7332237363,
0.7720829844,
-0.4992432892,
-0.859064877,
-0.1073224843,
0.0676738024,
0.1664472222,
0.2921461165,
0.0992614999,
-0.5333854556,
-0.6072791219,
-0.3147417307,
-0.0753657743,
-0.5066351295,
0.1537781209,
-0.0505630411,
0.3045344651,
-0.0799836814,
0.6327812076,
-0.3815349638,
-0.975910604,
0.0111934859,
0.5948123336,
0.3115777373,
0.2782289088,
0.5929781795,
-1.0420854092,
-0.6977035999,
-0.0713440925,
-0.7423217893,
0.0809861347,
-0.4806421697,
-0.1705069989,
0.536193192,
0.9567237496,
-0.4152399898,
0.7790642381,
-0.2777301967,
-0.3337952197,
0.117570065,
-0.6269740462,
0.0754360929,
-0.6903550625,
-0.0356104821,
0.2254443616,
-0.2024175227,
-0.6289774179,
0.0967637822,
0.7655383945,
-0.167375356,
-0.3627111912,
0.1465253681,
-0.7380385995,
0.0254700091,
-0.2234410048,
-0.0427818038,
0.0612133704,
0.1041430011,
0.3715704978,
0.60118258,
0.1623839438,
-0.8655571938,
0.3725710213,
0.6593168974,
-0.5992646813,
0.6878415942,
0.1208383888,
-0.0387317203,
-0.3153009713,
0.2494644523,
-1.0217216015,
0.3067567647,
0.320302397,
-0.0862950385,
0.685071826,
-0.5254639387,
-0.8338732123,
-0.6060827971,
-0.232896626,
-0.294092536,
0.5509386063,
-0.2367077917,
0.8368749022,
0.503649652,
0.0177119914,
-0.2835379839,
-0.7399576306,
0.0334040523,
-0.2919109762,
-0.3876148462,
0.3980354071,
0.1232632846,
0.2237775177,
-0.115712896,
-0.3960958123,
-0.1144357249,
0.1445016712,
0.378767848,
0.1853510886,
0.1183708459,
-0.0229722429,
0.072032094,
-0.0843847021,
-0.0298476983,
-0.4222487211,
0.4247546196,
0.2862876058,
-0.0886561349,
-0.32529217,
-0.1025426313,
0.9192643166,
-0.3469211757,
0.4519341588,
0.3739691079,
-0.0645688325,
-0.5407147408,
-0.3678165674,
0.418695271,
-0.5297320485,
-0.0634412244,
-0.5718855858,
-0.220754981,
0.2747964263,
-0.2346366644,
-0.0722328871,
0.6744425297,
0.1864943802,
-0.2778284252,
0.4175867736,
0.9564723969,
-0.2807229161,
0.3399211764,
-0.4462473989,
0.4368748963,
-0.2509292364,
-0.2752792239,
-0.9554892182,
-0.1292382032,
-0.5254115462,
-0.1638719589,
0.4054965079,
-0.1083517149,
0.0640784949,
0.8200044036,
-0.7370001674,
0.1533336937,
0.398798883,
0.0278554354,
0.4013246298,
0.0442075878,
-0.2047361732,
0.4906659722,
-0.2717018425,
-0.6475549936,
0.9172122478,
0.1818560511,
0.8184716702,
-0.0181120187,
0.6932197809,
0.8026022315,
0.0579948016,
-0.8086396456,
0.6500401497,
-0.3092851937,
-0.6621893048,
-0.2905834019,
-0.2630123496,
-0.9245797992,
-0.3835026324,
0.0461176783,
-0.3085801303,
0.7299035788,
-0.6218159199,
-0.4869619906,
0.320700407,
-0.2989118695,
0.427182883,
-0.3649401665,
0.5076280236,
-0.0812784731,
-0.5882467031,
0.1098758578,
-0.7165536284,
0.3276606798,
0.1392851919,
-0.3120487928,
0.8357492089,
-0.8365824819,
0.5048007369,
-0.1246643513,
-0.2731566131,
0.3776744008,
0.1258042306,
0.2877487242,
-0.1812703758,
-0.3689475954,
0.3900181055,
0.2707234621,
0.1438840628,
-0.3556217551,
-0.0322602205,
-0.6348058581,
-0.0052033509,
-0.8642362356,
-0.353217721,
0.2134475112,
0.5120840073,
0.5609380603,
0.2392314523,
0.2526673973,
-0.2107375264,
0.4281705916,
-0.1262059212,
0.5952300429,
1.0343979597,
0.3968005776,
-0.1652400345,
0.6441529989,
0.7385158539,
-0.3331798315,
0.6872961521,
-0.0799697712,
-0.6452316642,
-0.6677501202,
-0.4755806923,
0.2031446248,
-1.0349230766,
-0.6161353588,
-0.455965519,
-0.4651305079,
-0.4763453603,
-0.2837169468,
0.2649294436,
-0.2836277783,
-0.2702741921,
0.0751390979,
0.0018838891,
0.8026511669,
0.343572706,
0.2496784329,
-1.3745083809,
0.3115610778,
0.0097773457,
0.4048926234,
-0.4338564873,
-0.738653779,
-0.2407473624,
-0.2784319818,
-0.3844177723,
-1.1324756145,
0.4961731732,
0.1836624891,
0.8711212873,
0.7607753277,
0.6546419263,
0.383251518,
-0.0493185595,
0.6795701981,
-0.2013703287,
-0.9615532756,
0.5119758248,
-0.1458136886,
-0.1681351513,
0.5252764225,
0.7288243175,
-0.3172413111,
-0.486882925,
-1.0386881828,
-0.7705101371,
1.1311450005,
0.1581003517,
-0.3820559382,
0.1884512752,
0.3810772896,
-0.2084988058,
0.4975478649,
-0.023463022,
0.0980680734,
0.153285116,
-0.2522993982,
-0.1372257173,
-0.2403834015,
0.0981621444,
0.1012995392,
0.9489150643,
0.1513082236,
0.3011308014,
0.1409591734,
-0.4485666752,
-0.1710950732,
0.0774944872,
0.5222156644,
0.1713803411,
-0.4473281205,
-0.0016222355,
-0.0999820009,
-0.9408656359,
0.5404260159,
0.1328868121,
-0.2934933007,
0.377391398,
0.1325077415,
0.0110427011,
-0.3931547403,
-0.4408172965,
0.5934502482,
-0.3035119772,
-0.2478551418,
-0.5506932139,
-0.0430724546,
-0.4200981259,
0.1135780811,
0.0656430274,
0.3455540538,
0.3929855525,
-0.6271270514,
0.2875887156,
0.0920151323,
-0.2543747723,
0.4319558442,
0.443707794,
0.2020443678,
-0.2338515073,
0.8682695031,
-0.6477846503,
-0.7453217506,
0.7881717086,
0.0801548138,
0.7842149734,
-0.1925078928,
0.0975051597,
0.2627197206,
0.5529361367,
-0.514087081,
0.6503033638,
-0.4086793661,
-0.635299325,
0.2890891135,
-0.793931365,
-0.2020077556,
-0.0669157207,
-0.5315730572,
0.7665500045,
-0.614865005,
-0.3827771544,
0.001417928,
0.1425663829,
-0.5849671364,
0.2946329713,
0.3987899423,
1.1116310358,
-0.8067091107,
0.8641116619,
1.0473241806,
-0.8393973112,
-0.8267800212,
0.1044910252,
0.1523404419,
-0.4800283909,
0.9195304513,
0.1556028277,
0.2035287917,
-0.1901353449,
-0.0113791497,
-0.7337856889,
1.053943634,
-0.3102185726,
-0.6030589342,
-0.042841021,
0.6275488734,
0.5766304731,
0.1618169397,
0.589012444,
0.5944644809,
0.6693152785,
-0.1814322323,
-1.0522093773,
0.2060960531,
-0.4828632474,
0.1291760653,
0.5515354872,
-0.7259259224,
0.3713277876,
0.7057067156,
-0.4835816026,
-0.0745220184,
0.3635957539,
-0.2465891689,
0.423255682,
0.9569072723,
0.8033697009,
0.9739207029,
-0.2711617947,
0.7163013816,
-0.3607191145,
0.3041814268,
0.3079037666,
-0.3807375431,
0.5556174517,
-0.142658174,
-0.2307360023,
0.4302096367,
0.6407387853,
-0.6018981934,
0.4858480692,
0.2384747416,
0.0549298376,
0.0688536912,
0.0973678231,
-0.1341714114,
0.6559199691,
0.5155112743,
-0.4491511881,
-0.4624585807,
0.2980929315,
-0.0896470398,
-0.0603168495,
-0.2900850773,
1.1370135546,
0.0783323199,
-0.4397282302,
0.4758333564,
0.477753371,
0.6134761572,
-0.6235873699,
0.1451964825,
-0.176518023,
0.2269700021,
-0.4202865064,
-0.9301746488,
0.3786894381,
0.0900023133,
0.0334604532,
-0.5976681113,
1.0286216736,
-0.3305971026,
-0.1682247519,
0.0455576666,
0.0085915262,
0.3653258085,
-0.4074647725,
-0.5947167873,
-0.1765636355,
-0.2661103904,
0.160997346,
0.3718407154,
0.7093006372,
-0.3547523022,
0.4078254402,
0.4448411465,
0.0884878784,
0.0170038957,
-0.172037676,
0.6728548408,
-0.6610500813,
-1.3040246964,
-0.3784592748,
0.4853832126,
-0.2697054744,
-0.0156274214,
0.5690494776,
0.7246117592,
0.7761625051,
-0.327788353,
0.9300274253,
-0.2421345115,
0.3305999637,
-0.4356211722,
1.0919476748,
-0.6291665435,
0.3530526161,
-0.4130201638,
-0.6957943439,
-0.1768641174,
0.2573086619,
-0.1091517434,
-0.3892742097,
0.8908364773,
0.8432987332,
-0.0396436304,
0.29857108,
0.2510706186,
-0.0477591492,
0.1922406256,
0.1955526322,
0.8808938265,
-0.8741889596,
0.9380150437,
-0.3832302392,
-0.0476081856,
-0.4539272785,
-0.7486567497,
-0.6680808663,
-0.6409603357,
-0.5988095999,
-0.3490026891,
-0.2447247505,
0.4670393169,
0.5672528148,
-0.5388772488,
-0.4428212047,
0.0026106248,
-0.1160076261,
-0.3946992457,
-0.2060051262,
0.399195224,
-0.4878703952,
-0.5477690697,
0.3000036776,
0.3761258125,
0.2075065076,
0.2949261963,
0.1338376701,
-0.1269646585,
-0.0179989468,
0.1856731027,
0.2342830598,
-0.2292116135,
0.3986367285,
-0.5078564286,
-0.43141523,
-0.1147012711,
0.6060088873,
-0.3266144991,
0.3734688461,
1.0417919159,
0.5109339356,
0.3307570815,
0.2308952808,
0.2482051402,
-0.6343219876,
0.1974989027,
0.1018763557,
0.474681288,
-0.1754835844,
-0.9356715083,
0.7533988357,
0.4432660341,
-0.5368037224,
-0.6590415835,
-0.2926775813,
-1.2285635471,
-0.3891969919,
0.6660116315,
-0.2015800625,
-0.4470677376,
-0.7781679034,
-0.2646945417,
0.4954634607,
-0.4193047881,
0.6779275537,
0.6749433875,
0.2726638913,
0.1720023602,
-0.456440419,
0.5576828718,
-0.0151304575,
-0.7687668204,
-0.4101926386,
0.2206159234,
0.0420125015,
0.5114295483,
0.6365495324,
-0.4075493515,
0.1977325678,
-0.0594018437,
0.0624101721,
-0.0556516573,
-0.2242180109,
-0.4300633371,
0.3696220219,
-0.1295935512,
-0.2236560285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16537v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16537v2 | LMExplainer: a Knowledge-Enhanced Explainer for Language Models | 2023-03-29T08:59:44 | 2023-08-03T23:23:43 | Zichen Chen, Ambuj K Singh, Misha Sra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 are very powerful and can process
different kinds of natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, it can be
difficult to interpret the results due to the multi-layer nonlinear model
structure and millions of parameters. A lack of clarity and understanding of
how the language models (LMs) work can make them unreliable, difficult to
trust, and potentially dangerous for use in real-world scenarios. Most recent
works exploit attention weights to provide explanations for LM predictions.
However, pure attention-based explanations are unable to support the growing
complexity of LMs, and cannot reason about their decision-making processes. We
propose LMExplainer, a knowledge-enhanced explainer for LMs that can provide
human-understandable explanations. We use a knowledge graph (KG) and a graph
attention neural network to extract the key decision signals of the LM. We
further explore whether interpretation can also help the AI understand the task
better. Our experimental results show that LMExplainer outperforms existing
LM+KG methods on CommonsenseQA and OpenBookQA. We compare the explanation
results with generated explanation methods and human-annotated results. The
comparison shows our method can provide more comprehensive and clearer
explanations. LMExplainer demonstrates the potential to enhance model
performance and furnish explanations for the LM reasoning process in natural
language. | [
-0.4224305153,
-0.6492732763,
0.9205290079,
-0.0916929767,
-0.2863602042,
0.0919465646,
-0.3088055253,
-0.5053504705,
-0.1899012029,
0.4407227635,
-0.6342765093,
-0.2962289155,
-0.6317042112,
0.0603148341,
-0.2771239877,
0.7617928386,
-0.1788192689,
-0.0998793319,
-0.3026487529,
0.0115790507,
-0.390845269,
-0.3402020037,
-1.0271451473,
-0.7146281004,
0.7430131435,
-0.0691990033,
0.8836643696,
0.6966076493,
0.0882368833,
0.3563030362,
-0.1876689196,
0.1046478301,
-0.4202367663,
-0.1261256039,
-0.1256979257,
-0.6118252277,
-0.3459444344,
-0.3544038236,
0.4394076467,
0.7966868877,
0.0198549796,
-0.1401600838,
0.0633237883,
0.407982856,
-0.2916527092,
0.361205101,
-0.3518404067,
0.0208792575,
0.1093121991,
-0.2035112828,
-0.2176285982,
-0.3500918448,
0.1860176474,
-0.5607684851,
0.1821142137,
0.1678741872,
0.6236819625,
0.4665421247,
-0.3134092093,
-0.1383297592,
-0.6502233148,
0.711063683,
-0.7995135188,
0.5693957806,
0.0612890273,
0.4110959768,
-0.0956952721,
-0.7854044437,
-0.8225269318,
-0.1117680445,
-0.2699465752,
0.1711104065,
-0.2302909046,
0.1606542915,
0.208491236,
0.3358899057,
-0.646903038,
0.1907476485,
-0.1830573976,
-0.4059099853,
0.3106354177,
0.0803877264,
0.3888186812,
-0.2100425363,
-0.3818948567,
0.1903922111,
-0.5118484497,
0.1435734928,
0.1168810204,
0.0012921613,
0.1061624214,
0.3256926835,
0.000830014,
0.6597232223,
-0.0714742169,
-0.1367721111,
0.0521169193,
0.1930044442,
-0.2202180177,
0.2772971094,
0.7242777944,
0.3606964052,
0.219217971,
-0.4199134707,
-0.1966845244,
-0.0351506174,
0.089865312,
-0.8511669636,
-0.1151450723,
0.5614503026,
-0.4731718004,
-0.1913326532,
-0.3349464238,
-0.7185105085,
-0.4838267863,
-0.5881462097,
0.5369145274,
-0.4936444461,
-0.4422726631,
0.2907392085,
-0.1950630695,
0.0561358333,
0.4369926453,
-0.5344309211,
0.3250383139,
0.6883559227,
0.6622558832,
-0.2397048771,
-0.1685433686,
-0.3459967077,
0.1728760302,
0.031483639,
0.6731458306,
-0.5393929482,
0.0193048529,
-0.2776539028,
0.0598091744,
-0.1376702785,
-0.452462405,
0.7574495673,
-0.644138515,
0.3058821857,
-0.1608929932,
-0.794350028,
-0.5353548527,
0.061337769,
-0.6776348948,
0.8034502864,
0.0499889478,
-0.784543097,
0.0872226283,
-0.9726961851,
-0.1120996699,
0.1890081614,
-0.179274857,
-0.188340649,
0.125257805,
0.6386615634,
0.5318587422,
-0.2523180246,
0.3123444617,
-0.0866847187,
-0.2191022784,
0.303380847,
-0.5867270827,
0.7376114726,
0.2993603945,
-0.4560824931,
0.307164818,
-0.6722519398,
0.0628346801,
0.3966570497,
-0.2957072258,
-0.3811386526,
-0.0480576642,
-0.2780655026,
0.2389944792,
0.223687768,
-0.3307934999,
-0.3139187396,
-0.4227102697,
0.481875807,
0.8239365816,
-0.1402298063,
0.4411464036,
-0.1292502433,
0.8161046505,
-0.0626973957,
-0.0580001213,
-0.3455878198,
-0.4373913407,
-0.5690191984,
-0.2783614993,
0.1860226393,
0.3032789528,
-0.6246546507,
0.206636101,
-0.5218989253,
-0.1065610573,
-0.6963768005,
0.1575642824,
0.3710762262,
0.5840166807,
0.2501984239,
0.259202987,
-0.3757340312,
-0.8226121664,
-0.5654752254,
0.2601866424,
-0.2600561976,
0.4387963414,
0.2612701058,
-0.2851220667,
0.864079237,
-0.39178738,
0.1547642499,
-0.6585564017,
0.0705326051,
0.218114078,
0.0535874777,
0.306776017,
-0.6693649292,
-0.1695674658,
0.1714754403,
-0.6586175561,
-0.3068872392,
-0.2113530338,
-0.0599618144,
-0.1195058078,
0.5318171382,
-0.737385273,
0.1141401231,
0.4521738589,
-0.330961138,
0.5241769552,
-0.229007706,
-0.2847775519,
-0.8684096932,
-0.0669156387,
-0.1225873381,
-0.656488359,
-0.592156589,
0.2701984942,
0.0353542641,
-0.1909475327,
-0.2152563184,
0.7338666916,
-0.5160768032,
-0.0391875282,
-0.2993243337,
0.6154897809,
0.2140727043,
0.5618329048,
0.0851322934,
0.5103874207,
0.5361968279,
-0.5462367535,
0.4690048993,
0.1697901785,
-0.3371848762,
0.0466710292,
-0.712854147,
0.2916092277,
-0.3938788772,
0.2127031684,
-0.8797888756,
-0.1728565097,
0.2110976875,
-0.2837567031,
0.3164379001,
-0.1227074191,
-0.4170169532,
-0.5617495775,
-0.1110748574,
0.1877280325,
0.3820604384,
-0.9258268476,
0.867328763,
0.0141292512,
-0.3552259505,
-0.4043825865,
-0.3169864416,
0.174847886,
-0.5213646293,
-0.6387848258,
0.1595416963,
-0.2879535258,
-0.460011512,
0.0095958011,
-0.3055520356,
0.0902790353,
0.1897925436,
0.2703154087,
0.0339629203,
-0.3667774498,
0.3194537163,
-0.0748867616,
-0.3777996898,
0.4388258755,
-0.488807112,
0.5050932169,
0.0404813811,
-0.2815723717,
-0.5729551315,
0.2649579048,
0.6579020619,
-0.1775029898,
0.7566585541,
0.7012012005,
-0.2402963638,
-0.2799464762,
-0.4746240377,
-0.3226649761,
-0.4560757875,
0.3473688364,
-0.4548406005,
-1.0177474022,
0.5075687766,
-0.4332712591,
-0.1395443231,
0.3281700611,
0.4556483626,
0.081693545,
1.3424748182,
0.4575403333,
-0.281613946,
0.1832769215,
0.1007530317,
0.4997235537,
-0.7691493034,
-0.1258715838,
-0.3159984648,
-0.357509762,
-0.1965001523,
-0.3098930418,
0.22782287,
0.0714750662,
-0.0542451143,
-0.0060598082,
-0.4497442544,
0.6610347033,
0.3217321336,
0.0864398181,
0.2678560019,
0.0313287713,
-0.1260708869,
-0.0048280577,
-0.6948158145,
-0.4801425636,
0.7060607076,
0.5959061384,
0.7385956049,
0.160479635,
0.5028607249,
0.0880218521,
0.1430120021,
-0.8393625021,
0.4229083061,
0.204799667,
-0.416675508,
-0.3864718676,
-0.5706808567,
-0.8259779811,
0.5134112239,
0.0764870048,
-0.8552920222,
-0.0790187642,
0.1426481158,
-0.4365748167,
0.2448364794,
-0.7915459871,
0.9504311681,
-0.5476598144,
-0.3579572439,
-0.1493388861,
-0.5159519315,
0.5515466332,
-0.1982729286,
0.5970622301,
0.0713861957,
0.0584127717,
0.677928865,
-0.700053215,
0.8322665095,
-0.4094308317,
-0.4772792161,
0.0183744188,
0.0851024091,
0.8467921615,
-0.0703595877,
-0.2870358527,
-0.0933208168,
-0.2942602038,
-0.1633492708,
-0.8567855358,
0.8001291752,
-0.7741653323,
-0.8060235381,
0.1677299291,
-0.8360088468,
-0.076444678,
0.2206840366,
0.1128057241,
0.4111712277,
0.352715373,
0.0430030227,
0.7179359198,
-0.3842889071,
0.2548164725,
0.3698421717,
-0.4333840907,
-0.1181975603,
0.8710759282,
-0.1597435325,
0.18772237,
0.4330923557,
0.5278597474,
-0.4045473337,
-0.6187238097,
-0.1664581597,
0.1896937042,
-0.8420341015,
0.1589028239,
-0.8398015499,
-0.0739345774,
0.0081509799,
0.0154083939,
0.0249331649,
-0.5656492114,
-0.09305989,
-0.3331732154,
0.3486948311,
0.6532125473,
0.1382337809,
0.5176006556,
-0.5270394087,
0.5870629549,
0.4828626812,
0.2111751884,
0.1313325465,
-0.5820249915,
-0.1969717741,
0.0544456467,
0.0740621239,
-0.8499462605,
0.3945062757,
0.0297373384,
0.7652000785,
0.8312460184,
0.039710287,
0.5853896737,
-0.3479298949,
0.5956789255,
-0.0800151601,
-0.9185926914,
0.4707727134,
-0.3423835039,
0.4136875272,
-0.1448037624,
0.2469351143,
-0.2319717705,
-0.4494807124,
-0.4969475269,
-0.8967251182,
0.7502682805,
0.3392159343,
-0.0580918975,
0.185020566,
0.6278172135,
0.2210007459,
0.0581699982,
-0.9646087885,
-0.1918897778,
-0.209748283,
-0.1772700846,
-0.2456371933,
-0.3757848442,
-0.0608653203,
-0.2022747546,
0.5994644761,
-0.2235884815,
0.3392246962,
0.188376978,
-0.3666101992,
-0.2489548475,
0.4464555085,
0.7169336081,
0.7474621534,
-0.1751677692,
0.5440433621,
0.2757734358,
-0.1521556228,
-0.1933948398,
0.3769709468,
0.1498309821,
-0.0045903521,
0.5851890445,
1.0098631382,
0.1323643923,
-0.6206408143,
0.3653963208,
-0.1867893934,
-0.1489179581,
-0.206600979,
0.1231690943,
0.5301204324,
0.4185328186,
0.2154363841,
-0.1107353568,
0.0884466842,
-0.2407764345,
-0.1329082698,
0.3976240754,
-0.4842282236,
-0.3586097062,
0.9090822339,
0.0945862532,
-0.1151166856,
0.2536811233,
-0.0762725845,
-0.85226053,
0.6040479541,
0.6532207727,
0.7126392126,
-0.2895188034,
0.0879573599,
0.0689389855,
0.3451817334,
0.1634530872,
0.2307151109,
-0.2217109501,
-0.889139533,
-0.6965125203,
-0.6223248839,
-0.1907664984,
0.6036942601,
-0.5288020968,
-0.2192528099,
-0.2326318771,
0.1658752263,
0.3070966303,
-0.4392216802,
-0.6533058882,
0.189277783,
0.1867597401,
0.8758107424,
-0.6773650646,
0.5986148119,
0.5342493057,
-0.1764130592,
-0.9576728344,
0.1168427244,
0.1186469048,
-0.9999899864,
0.7314807177,
0.2133801877,
-0.2391848266,
0.2188222706,
-0.5245408416,
-0.5419435501,
1.1147918701,
0.5787321329,
-0.6502924562,
0.1764071137,
0.1752214134,
0.5106771588,
-0.2066525072,
0.3615445495,
0.5428299904,
0.8025019169,
-0.1755549759,
-0.5732600689,
0.3094349504,
-0.0897843018,
-0.1487360299,
0.1592773646,
-0.2451457083,
0.6585088372,
-0.4293379486,
-0.0628824458,
-0.1291579604,
0.367431581,
0.1098458096,
0.3225878179,
0.6071189046,
0.4871970117,
0.8969172239,
-0.0348488949,
1.4436671734,
-0.2776032984,
0.0818957686,
1.1809359789,
-0.1554053426,
0.543535769,
0.4459951818,
-0.2056147307,
0.5498777032,
0.5533449054,
0.3893922567,
0.3136614263,
0.2440590262,
-0.3875511587,
-0.4844611883,
-0.0543135852,
-0.1475897282,
0.2032098919,
0.4415709376,
-0.6069888473,
-0.2904746234,
0.1447338462,
0.1132647917,
-0.1991138458,
-0.4341581762,
0.8532735109,
0.2334489375,
-0.4363285303,
0.6233484745,
-0.2216410935,
0.2016792297,
-0.4906826317,
0.038636256,
-0.0505848937,
0.4592142105,
-0.2237569094,
-0.7608678341,
0.0205098912,
-0.2487651408,
-0.2585974038,
-0.3112052083,
0.8345976472,
-0.3517671824,
-0.4132347107,
0.6047616601,
0.6192984581,
0.3925392628,
-0.4580022991,
-0.6415677667,
-0.0471487157,
0.1763840467,
-0.3689769804,
0.1327321529,
0.7662765384,
-0.0988120511,
0.9765617251,
0.6169663668,
0.0206472818,
-0.0361684561,
0.395235002,
0.8266173601,
-0.5867727995,
-0.3772284985,
-0.9121764898,
0.5243064761,
0.0067851553,
0.4097865224,
0.7059224844,
0.3737428486,
0.2380853146,
-0.1790167689,
1.1592178345,
0.3163096011,
0.7222963572,
-0.6533880234,
0.7199462652,
-0.5433970094,
0.5672299266,
-0.0439057164,
-0.8395991921,
-0.1913596988,
0.4681078196,
-0.3143447638,
0.1572157294,
0.8611426353,
0.6798589826,
-0.2930821478,
0.0118959909,
0.4208150804,
0.8358686566,
0.267218411,
0.430221498,
1.048464179,
0.0308752153,
0.8163132071,
-0.0761590153,
-0.1513661444,
-0.0853771791,
-0.9048522115,
-1.1412194967,
-0.1821831465,
-0.3209100664,
0.0194160081,
0.1052410156,
0.5941019058,
0.5712191463,
-0.7314653993,
0.1909377128,
-0.3259533942,
0.351829052,
-0.2727498412,
-0.2780139148,
0.5977622867,
-0.2412386537,
-0.610640645,
0.6815422773,
0.1815785468,
-0.1224145368,
-0.2125721872,
-0.3714455068,
0.2558511794,
-0.0207126569,
0.5803082585,
0.079295367,
-1.116055727,
-0.3848366737,
-0.2707470357,
0.4317898154,
-0.0555725582,
0.7340775132,
-0.977370739,
0.5177028179,
0.2973710895,
0.5205911398,
0.3772879541,
-0.0664346144,
0.8381986618,
-0.6127409339,
-0.1657197922,
-0.1704513729,
0.674515903,
0.3287193477,
-0.5652352571,
0.3286667466,
-0.1216318607,
-0.6035638452,
-0.5812171102,
0.1447274685,
-0.9559758306,
-0.4126820564,
1.1987843513,
-0.1540739536,
-0.1567111909,
-0.4277998209,
-0.5658280253,
0.2359189838,
-0.5377207994,
0.6529459357,
0.5223289728,
-0.1728589982,
-0.8500620127,
-0.8851132393,
0.5053778291,
0.284475565,
-0.9423317909,
0.3375383317,
0.3308285475,
0.375377506,
0.2525544763,
0.1627383232,
0.0431170091,
0.0843929723,
-0.3703396618,
0.1265086681,
-0.237945959,
0.1231478676,
-0.4342379272,
0.1438882053,
0.1432039291,
0.0966320485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16528v1 | Building a Knowledge Graph of Distributed Ledger Technologies | 2023-03-29T08:34:01 | 2023-03-29T08:34:01 | Lukas König, Sebastian Neumaier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | Distributed ledger systems have become more prominent and successful in
recent years, with a focus on blockchains and cryptocurrency. This has led to
various misunderstandings about both the technology itself and its
capabilities, as in many cases blockchain and cryptocurrency is used
synonymously and other applications are often overlooked. Therefore, as a
whole, the view of distributed ledger technology beyond blockchains and
cryptocurrencies is very limited. Existing vocabularies and ontologies often
focus on single aspects of the technology, or in some cases even just on one
product. This potentially leads to other types of distributed ledgers and their
possible use cases being neglected. In this paper, we present a knowledge graph
and an ontology for distributed ledger technologies, which includes security
considerations to model aspects such as threats and vulnerabilities,
application domains, as well as relevant standards and regulations. Such a
knowledge graph improves the overall understanding of distributed ledgers,
reveals their strengths, and supports the work of security personnel, i.e.
analysts and system architects. We discuss potential uses and follow semantic
web best practices to evaluate and publish the ontology and knowledge graph. | [
-0.5388271809,
-0.5760776401,
0.5878431201,
-0.2512612641,
-0.3408134878,
0.3632564247,
0.3941845894,
-0.7081664205,
0.5256337523,
0.9591114521,
-0.488927424,
-0.9184402227,
-0.5698922873,
-0.1815216988,
-0.4245420694,
0.9970188141,
0.0093357535,
-0.3119836152,
-0.175529629,
0.079891488,
-0.450732708,
-0.5729089379,
-0.358152777,
-0.4788462222,
0.3762300313,
0.3173560798,
0.5388985276,
0.7430279255,
0.7110427618,
0.2827312052,
-0.0203201137,
-0.1037670746,
-0.1624856591,
0.1957378238,
-0.2508413196,
0.0310783461,
-0.7923610806,
-0.0152592547,
0.1832262576,
0.6611148715,
-0.0282562003,
0.1426213533,
-0.2775292397,
0.5872687697,
-0.6040098071,
0.4456620514,
-0.3975647986,
0.1188493744,
-0.6680074334,
-0.1895020902,
0.1086863801,
-0.1048791632,
0.4512911141,
-0.9665138721,
-0.0586318746,
0.2083771825,
0.2322391123,
-0.2890797555,
-0.4866644442,
-0.3081439137,
-0.5313241482,
0.2840113342,
-0.0632731244,
0.5213458538,
0.4265442491,
0.7690043449,
-0.1017630696,
-1.2311816216,
-0.380284369,
-0.0674567446,
-0.0434041172,
0.0930295214,
-0.0985236168,
0.160125494,
0.1220700517,
0.1902039051,
-0.3430565894,
0.200351879,
-0.1017637476,
-0.473708421,
0.4358439445,
0.3693957627,
0.0943158567,
-0.0623116381,
-0.7104914188,
-0.3123989701,
-0.6210271716,
-0.1536294669,
0.6164121628,
0.4073014855,
-0.0113388933,
0.4592624009,
-0.3289048076,
0.7862794995,
-0.3536996543,
-0.5189494491,
0.0857733935,
-0.4815964401,
0.2365456671,
0.1401186883,
0.1983164549,
0.4495018125,
-0.2438802868,
-0.4019206166,
-0.372374624,
-0.140860945,
0.3318840563,
-0.4759114087,
-0.1869554371,
0.4363258183,
-0.4102098644,
-0.2372089028,
0.2565562725,
-0.8099289536,
-1.0188508034,
0.0116442852,
0.2664951384,
-0.1219605953,
-0.4498159587,
-0.0486827418,
-1.076595664,
-0.2536994219,
0.3119555116,
-0.63277179,
0.7294495106,
0.9548953772,
0.702043891,
0.2368641198,
-0.2153057158,
-0.2372558415,
0.552264452,
0.0589923598,
0.603051126,
-0.0087705124,
-0.4228732288,
0.1587279737,
-0.3480615616,
0.3886517882,
-0.1244876683,
0.102364257,
-0.9847716689,
-0.4190595746,
-0.3643716574,
-0.7897341847,
-0.3209032714,
0.5354869366,
-1.040266037,
0.2829973102,
0.1041562036,
-1.1659084558,
0.6546397805,
-0.7258136868,
-0.4140310585,
0.286487639,
-0.0411897711,
-0.0412825011,
-0.4433460236,
-0.2950069904,
0.3477156162,
-0.483651191,
-0.1132661551,
-0.299356699,
-0.0203174818,
0.3410721719,
0.3595905304,
0.5086647868,
0.3257937729,
-0.1328699291,
-0.0139693171,
-0.7784593105,
-0.1791843921,
-0.0469610803,
0.3497369587,
-0.6096023917,
-0.0181816705,
-0.175888896,
-0.0927439183,
0.6608782411,
-0.7017082572,
-0.0150655257,
-0.3048997223,
0.7001335025,
0.7381691337,
0.3017933667,
0.2040515244,
-0.3262171745,
0.2544618845,
0.0833261833,
0.5776510835,
0.1333620101,
-0.4304637909,
-0.3132598698,
-0.2700062692,
0.2982679605,
0.5590564609,
-0.7226650715,
0.371466279,
-0.189449504,
-0.6545805931,
0.0295183565,
-0.0877140015,
-0.0033735626,
0.6216276288,
0.1138495505,
-0.534712553,
-0.716219008,
-0.6137978435,
-0.0190280546,
-0.6533381939,
0.4018270075,
0.1180766225,
0.5833066106,
-0.2396460772,
1.177621603,
-0.8376224041,
-0.4877560139,
-0.0381693318,
-0.3449557424,
-0.0067147561,
0.2413661778,
0.1339243054,
-1.0599894524,
0.2518677413,
0.5257515907,
-0.5833975673,
0.476344049,
0.023874633,
-0.1478352845,
-0.1917067468,
0.2499345839,
-0.4162365496,
0.4618699551,
0.1696869284,
-0.4270932674,
0.5026717782,
-0.3275657296,
0.0240658596,
-0.8852697611,
0.3113751411,
-0.0854552686,
-0.487452656,
-0.8075023293,
0.2398243845,
-0.0348737314,
-0.3112119436,
-0.2131119072,
0.6993533373,
0.0327183269,
-0.3948541582,
-0.0211684983,
0.6766389608,
0.1378164142,
-0.2455753237,
0.0003377257,
0.2875850201,
0.7520755529,
-0.7106112838,
0.9360675216,
0.2352949232,
-0.28136006,
0.3830880225,
-0.5669323802,
-0.0339538082,
0.4053165913,
0.0615835078,
-0.4158152044,
-0.0462918431,
0.3163262308,
-0.1883330196,
0.1112736836,
0.1168605238,
-0.7366933823,
-0.7938222885,
-0.3247350156,
0.1065285429,
0.2845740318,
-0.4385463893,
0.462012291,
0.8955588937,
0.3007801473,
-0.7605878711,
-0.6745193601,
0.1761200279,
-0.2793412805,
-0.8719201684,
0.432249248,
0.3147714138,
-0.6701618433,
0.1829746366,
-0.1706518829,
-0.2815669179,
0.3997943103,
0.485467881,
0.2008772641,
0.1784866452,
0.4368180633,
-0.3654018939,
-0.4423805773,
-0.1326827407,
-0.9294919968,
0.2218532711,
0.1031742916,
-0.5084326267,
-0.4058121443,
0.1174929589,
0.3949205279,
-0.1071423143,
0.86319381,
0.1507595927,
-0.2530899346,
-0.192118153,
-0.3387893438,
-0.2518151999,
-0.4619847238,
0.1491398364,
-0.490128547,
-0.8586486578,
1.2218333483,
-0.315603286,
0.142604202,
0.6077417731,
0.4303735793,
0.0875657648,
0.5851455927,
0.8418395519,
0.2090533227,
0.6708114147,
-0.4033271074,
0.3640964925,
-0.5074347854,
-0.5739824772,
-0.3553541601,
0.3190340102,
-0.746784389,
-0.0912691206,
0.3862767518,
-0.0699492171,
-0.3603743315,
0.570176959,
-0.3578920364,
0.0140064899,
0.3599507511,
0.0608972162,
0.6482641697,
-0.1252575517,
-0.1386937052,
0.4817748964,
-0.6987270117,
-0.5311564803,
1.0138874054,
0.4078101218,
0.7930037975,
-0.0503340177,
0.9089887142,
0.7355487347,
0.0345612802,
-0.4151955843,
0.4124991298,
-0.204300046,
-0.823522985,
-0.4345229566,
-0.6187759042,
-1.0893878937,
-0.1251873076,
-0.0421603359,
-0.508623898,
0.1326238513,
-0.0542813279,
-0.2030176073,
0.5628820658,
-0.460545063,
0.794898808,
0.1893229634,
0.1477036327,
-0.3386383057,
-0.6737887263,
0.194385916,
-0.0708622783,
0.5046017766,
0.1208942682,
-0.1197856218,
0.56171453,
-1.1160060167,
0.9198305607,
-0.0988429934,
-0.1557648182,
0.7379192114,
-0.2463895977,
0.4616216719,
0.1923523247,
-0.0767690986,
0.1701824367,
0.0627936348,
-0.1882208437,
-0.4747981131,
0.6192819476,
-0.8375898004,
-0.6796320081,
-0.1877256185,
-0.2657110989,
0.0009872215,
0.5590892434,
-0.0803747848,
0.5053496361,
-0.2823933065,
-0.3484336436,
0.3932498097,
0.3615265489,
0.1112082452,
0.1631878316,
-0.1261519939,
-0.5403810143,
0.8365672231,
0.6299171448,
0.3482642174,
0.2701115906,
0.222122103,
-0.4199106097,
-0.3236498833,
-0.3378445506,
0.0565100834,
-1.1905325651,
-0.2693714499,
-0.3879262507,
-0.198024556,
-0.9121652842,
-0.1116389111,
-0.1942036599,
-0.7853685021,
-0.097237505,
-0.2429022193,
1.2532562017,
0.9082117677,
-0.16596587,
0.0646634027,
-0.6501077414,
0.2536114752,
0.5959573388,
0.6436032057,
0.2529557943,
0.2358957976,
-0.3751128316,
-0.025174452,
0.0147355683,
-0.7495988607,
-0.1171789691,
-0.2042695284,
0.860940814,
0.3345091939,
0.4241635799,
0.4133857787,
0.013223039,
0.58905828,
0.5355471373,
-0.9803419113,
0.6195572019,
-0.1281104088,
-0.3693345487,
0.4779402018,
0.0955979526,
-0.7160716057,
-0.4347700477,
-0.7754260302,
-0.7455689311,
0.2960840464,
0.1989068687,
-0.1796835512,
0.2419860512,
0.4255639613,
0.4652143717,
0.3119981587,
-0.4048480988,
-0.4914417267,
-0.780338645,
0.0117895426,
0.3149340451,
0.2299488783,
-0.7124086618,
0.3759122789,
0.5717881918,
0.0694130436,
-0.279699415,
0.0879076645,
0.0843848139,
0.1684098393,
-0.0435248613,
-0.0726356208,
0.7845180631,
-0.0802870169,
0.5195741057,
0.0792704076,
-0.7269374132,
-0.0386204533,
0.2106755823,
-0.3157572448,
-0.458422482,
0.4680187702,
0.8375487924,
-0.3930869997,
-0.5637530684,
0.4578335583,
0.0337856598,
-0.0778826177,
-0.4460654557,
0.1431803852,
-0.0146097951,
0.4676267803,
0.2325594425,
-0.0538609549,
0.0857592821,
-0.7578018904,
0.301840812,
0.1340375096,
-0.5208847523,
-0.0143828662,
0.2998380959,
0.2633107603,
-0.1624280959,
0.3825354576,
-0.3175544143,
-0.5842481256,
0.6207028627,
0.3839969337,
0.6090358496,
0.3418430388,
0.1862019897,
-0.2084281445,
0.4271588922,
0.0226063915,
0.4119449556,
-0.2918777168,
-0.7282602787,
-0.0044725374,
-0.1450197697,
-0.5701260567,
-0.5938190222,
-0.3982041478,
0.2960485816,
-0.7533245683,
-0.8237944245,
0.0430123657,
0.4967318475,
-0.5517789125,
0.0731782466,
-0.0511237681,
0.9928916097,
-0.7462711334,
0.4932807386,
0.874623239,
-0.408355087,
-0.2419537157,
-0.4171344042,
-0.0994379297,
-0.7587245703,
0.6672828197,
-0.2612950504,
-0.1475521028,
-0.0757116675,
0.0138681801,
-0.6859267354,
1.343691349,
-0.131421268,
-0.162948817,
0.422901988,
0.1668649167,
0.482152611,
-0.347017765,
-0.2510689795,
0.4084168077,
0.8128650188,
0.2317861021,
-0.5271202326,
0.1737376153,
0.1060490087,
-0.015748078,
0.2936641276,
-0.6062275767,
0.9459358454,
-0.1298841238,
-0.3099805117,
-0.1479488611,
0.4877843261,
0.1845821142,
0.5681977868,
0.5185334086,
0.5546221733,
0.9415096641,
0.1711883694,
1.0512337685,
-0.3627555966,
0.2878267765,
0.5635993481,
-0.3796778321,
0.2367399037,
0.4155667126,
-0.1045195833,
0.5798968673,
0.7624672055,
0.1153815538,
0.4278157949,
0.3472907245,
-0.1324855983,
-0.4632750452,
-0.4188197553,
-0.4258012176,
0.1743020564,
0.3646653891,
-0.0909324437,
-0.1680398285,
-0.0042770742,
-0.2862754762,
-0.17564933,
-0.5540979505,
0.7371893525,
0.2538170516,
0.0644535199,
-0.2264916301,
0.0870128646,
-0.0265953112,
-0.5780088305,
0.0204289667,
0.2581016123,
-0.1716412157,
-0.2890093029,
-1.0936070681,
0.2432245463,
-0.0329960361,
-0.1402878165,
-0.3144716024,
1.1186282635,
0.2972000837,
-0.1934633106,
0.5916685462,
0.5140014291,
-0.0702299997,
0.2550109029,
-0.3161580563,
-0.289024502,
-0.5230178237,
-0.1685582399,
0.2618947923,
0.835043788,
-0.2691661417,
0.8382576704,
0.5948293805,
0.1178564206,
-0.2740282416,
0.2294759303,
1.0144453049,
-0.6344656944,
-0.9654407501,
-0.693862617,
0.2110834718,
-0.4308463931,
-0.4282937944,
0.9499869347,
0.2056154907,
0.7082980871,
0.4947889149,
0.743948698,
-0.0157620013,
0.2789313495,
-0.3849415779,
0.8047849536,
-0.436938256,
0.4051830769,
-0.2905412316,
-0.5463801026,
-0.4793325663,
0.2456726879,
-0.2213801146,
-0.1350212693,
0.4279620945,
0.3960545957,
0.5140081644,
0.2243208736,
0.294407934,
-0.1024940833,
0.3009173274,
-0.1282282919,
0.7724362016,
-0.2854536176,
0.4824104011,
-0.4237737954,
-0.1504494399,
-0.3972649276,
-0.854911983,
-0.594265759,
-0.6284402013,
-0.1781416535,
-0.3391918838,
-0.07919202,
0.3450322151,
0.6880538464,
-0.4890026152,
-0.2989855409,
-0.0971250609,
0.8762294054,
-0.2634989917,
-0.0821456164,
0.3580821753,
0.0907164589,
0.2003403604,
-0.0717507824,
0.441527307,
0.2701093256,
-0.4819669425,
0.0301702246,
0.36855492,
-0.2852537334,
0.2397906482,
0.3169879317,
-0.2402871698,
-0.514808476,
0.0577253811,
-0.1501488984,
-0.3777253032,
0.9828110337,
-0.5801576376,
0.7009789944,
0.7365065813,
0.2669332623,
0.546125412,
-0.1456098706,
0.3248547912,
-0.4532123804,
0.1045538783,
0.2093135417,
0.2752517164,
0.1642470807,
-0.4499563277,
0.2315015048,
0.5189525485,
-0.3482375443,
-0.5673456788,
0.4303464293,
-0.7931259274,
-0.5553864837,
0.4691030383,
-0.2573182583,
-0.3676365018,
-0.6192553639,
0.2955563068,
0.496679455,
-0.3227097094,
0.6604033113,
0.5324524641,
-0.1363246888,
0.4878074229,
-0.3529378772,
0.2742076814,
-0.3417882025,
-0.7483232021,
0.2169937193,
0.1064111069,
-0.0152129745,
0.4044374526,
0.5968449712,
-0.0342704505,
0.1512940526,
0.6954808235,
0.2146319151,
-0.2355236113,
-0.4581058025,
0.1830483228,
0.2181200087,
0.245800823,
0.0055592526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16445v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16445v3 | Larger Probes Tell a Different Story: Extending Psycholinguistic Datasets Via In-Context Learning | 2023-03-29T04:00:53 | 2023-11-14T17:24:28 | Namrata Shivagunde, Vladislav Lialin, Anna Rumshisky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language model probing is often used to test specific capabilities of models.
However, conclusions from such studies may be limited when the probing
benchmarks are small and lack statistical power. In this work, we introduce
new, larger datasets for negation (NEG-1500-SIMP) and role reversal (ROLE-1500)
inspired by psycholinguistic studies. We dramatically extend existing NEG-136
and ROLE-88 benchmarks using GPT3, increasing their size from 18 and 44
sentence pairs to 750 each. We also create another version of extended negation
dataset (NEG-1500-SIMP-TEMP), created using template-based generation. It
consists of 770 sentence pairs. We evaluate 22 models on the extended datasets,
seeing model performance dip 20-57% compared to the original smaller
benchmarks. We observe high levels of negation sensitivity in models like BERT
and ALBERT demonstrating that previous findings might have been skewed due to
smaller test sets. Finally, we observe that while GPT3 has generated all the
examples in ROLE-1500 is only able to solve 24.6% of them during probing. The
datasets and code are available on
$\href{https://github.com/text-machine-lab/extending_psycholinguistic_dataset}{Github}$. | [
-0.6157508492,
-0.757070303,
0.4244605601,
0.1025547758,
-0.0006751528,
-0.4445040822,
-0.4375766814,
-0.319801271,
-0.1254400611,
0.4473811686,
-0.4813007414,
-0.2376689911,
-0.5462837219,
0.2572267056,
-0.3281147182,
1.0035072565,
0.3476020992,
0.2546591759,
0.0573678762,
-0.1361671686,
-0.5625758767,
-0.4805707037,
-0.8339011073,
-0.4382407665,
0.4694516063,
0.4955931604,
0.5618480444,
0.3331791461,
0.250991255,
0.0939504653,
0.1303199083,
-0.1070820391,
-0.4848291576,
0.0086933691,
-0.08465112,
-0.3891648352,
-0.5692285895,
0.1581050158,
0.7496675849,
0.8935261965,
-0.114051193,
0.0381011143,
0.1916218251,
0.4509516656,
-0.5917174816,
0.2066764235,
-0.57959795,
-0.1865722835,
-0.0640766472,
0.0230707526,
-0.7204658389,
-0.084277533,
0.3187257349,
-0.5076515079,
0.3735308349,
-0.1077487692,
0.8586158752,
-0.0047296896,
-0.8770757914,
-0.0611393191,
-0.5362095237,
0.7700418234,
-1.0253820419,
0.4901315868,
0.5269669294,
0.3750353456,
-0.0976161733,
-0.51911515,
-0.5844424367,
-0.3387093246,
-0.2240149826,
-0.005329614,
-0.3257820308,
-0.0924107432,
0.5477312803,
0.0564979948,
-0.8143076897,
0.2935631275,
-0.4810165167,
-0.0518888868,
0.6636163592,
0.1927832067,
0.0445130579,
-0.3184171021,
-0.1703743935,
-0.5201849937,
-1.0237163305,
-0.1986635029,
0.526173532,
0.4899059236,
-0.1628467143,
0.3807647228,
0.1540814042,
0.8918994069,
0.056087207,
0.3089029789,
0.3928262293,
-0.2279297709,
-0.3215240538,
-0.0447804108,
0.6264007092,
0.352217406,
0.430765152,
0.0339238346,
-0.0757206976,
-0.1309426427,
0.1770684719,
-0.7611142993,
-0.3309871256,
-0.1385406256,
-0.2379908562,
0.0553249754,
-0.0103985919,
-0.6520891786,
-0.5130365491,
-0.3804721236,
0.5986067057,
-0.751416862,
-0.3774273396,
0.3400684595,
-0.1450653821,
0.7086294293,
0.0451106876,
-0.7104662061,
0.6512040496,
0.813822031,
0.6429035068,
-0.0241707657,
-0.4541324377,
-0.6332390904,
-0.0473927185,
-0.6147556901,
0.4753584564,
-0.7987962961,
-0.3375404477,
-0.3432734311,
0.2680665851,
-0.2845599651,
-0.6729818583,
0.4173894227,
-0.2117317319,
0.7271345854,
-0.4364736378,
-0.4889684916,
-0.4242488444,
0.2817233205,
-0.7071057558,
0.9409323335,
0.0502295233,
-0.5581569672,
0.5670366883,
-0.6101917624,
-0.4872922301,
-0.0595102236,
-0.3958497345,
-0.2250729352,
0.1887671947,
0.3536856771,
0.4718593657,
-0.4531890452,
0.5206054449,
-0.3725709021,
-0.7336933613,
-0.0066365427,
-0.4504005015,
0.9308400154,
-0.1729604006,
-0.4650824666,
-0.1214558333,
-0.5243097544,
-0.0926464573,
-0.0914885774,
-0.0390952826,
-0.4637162685,
-0.1264957637,
0.0081013925,
0.2952075899,
-0.3593381047,
-0.5388320684,
0.0293240491,
-0.4088489115,
0.3989980221,
0.5335993767,
-0.0222469531,
0.3250383437,
-0.371019721,
0.7425684929,
-0.1403257996,
-0.1637395322,
-0.0305373855,
-0.4626133144,
-0.7258155346,
-0.3923257589,
0.2162706405,
0.4086080492,
-0.4482885599,
0.4749706089,
-0.5119382143,
-0.4848303497,
-0.4420986176,
-0.2506745458,
0.5107727051,
0.6096317172,
0.5711444616,
-0.1797287911,
-0.607380569,
-1.2477321625,
-0.5547274947,
-0.1039471999,
-0.3281566799,
0.4237018526,
0.6110094786,
0.0150126107,
0.714327991,
-0.4073236585,
-0.3149671555,
-0.2406261861,
0.0709371343,
0.4861240387,
0.4056442082,
0.5167912841,
-0.6940792203,
-0.3775330186,
-0.2657412589,
-0.4502399266,
-0.1004425734,
-0.0366055146,
0.28767851,
0.2386524528,
0.9459612966,
-0.3575486541,
0.2186004519,
0.5691183209,
-0.3837581575,
0.560233891,
0.0321859531,
-0.0347313695,
-1.1149234772,
0.1303450614,
0.0311018862,
-0.1018668637,
-0.6655320525,
0.1114805341,
0.1429058313,
-0.0215408597,
-0.1788308024,
0.7341479063,
-0.6224643588,
-0.181444779,
-0.1402402222,
0.1594661176,
-0.117785655,
0.3037503362,
-0.0316127129,
0.6676516533,
0.5498121977,
-0.6683030128,
-0.0351134837,
0.0134308152,
-0.3697682321,
0.4409641922,
-0.6190074682,
0.1073585823,
-0.1137625575,
0.4876841605,
-1.0767341852,
-0.242417708,
-0.0581191331,
-0.4698503911,
0.3779600561,
-0.2639208436,
-0.5006434321,
-0.0882151276,
-0.3490814269,
0.4189164639,
0.7104888558,
-0.628448844,
0.3854020238,
0.0854621083,
-0.2228506058,
-0.5617824793,
-0.6647225022,
0.1703651845,
-0.7465084791,
-0.1794705391,
0.1653375179,
0.1037820429,
-0.4062229991,
-0.1900311559,
0.0345975496,
0.2531357408,
-0.1070318967,
0.1219697893,
0.092221126,
-0.3817338347,
0.4497279227,
-0.1321615726,
-0.0164378509,
0.1499758214,
0.0442590192,
0.741341114,
-0.4151661694,
-0.2547096312,
0.0434543341,
0.1804573387,
0.3347460032,
-0.0603215322,
0.502810657,
0.6463131905,
-0.4520153105,
-0.1446731687,
-0.5423487425,
-0.7081724405,
-0.4752192795,
0.5350193381,
-0.560983479,
-0.9409521222,
0.4209956229,
0.2192581594,
-0.1856267303,
0.435466677,
0.2506285608,
0.3403627872,
1.0953569412,
0.3688705862,
-0.0356253348,
0.3458594978,
-0.1027586684,
0.3992125392,
-1.107993722,
0.162037313,
-0.2661051154,
-0.344540298,
-0.8333148956,
-0.41102314,
0.4604241848,
0.0428579971,
-0.3280877769,
0.5410528779,
-0.2257523537,
0.4790933132,
0.1912380606,
0.0331408232,
0.1818818599,
-0.062177293,
0.0228733141,
-0.3413714468,
-0.6789424419,
-0.4713413715,
1.2452653646,
0.1354117543,
0.4306223989,
0.2877899408,
0.3921205401,
-0.1381866187,
0.3278760016,
-0.7143365741,
0.7830932736,
-0.1705256402,
-0.8680707812,
-0.4282093048,
-0.4143342674,
-1.0473389626,
0.500086844,
0.1346319318,
-0.878834784,
0.3505358398,
-0.0537149012,
-0.180880174,
0.1743129641,
-0.9847759604,
0.6794093847,
0.2072527856,
-0.5764250755,
-0.2428897619,
-0.5566322207,
0.5655764341,
-0.0825520307,
0.056143146,
-0.0408045352,
-0.0164081361,
0.7602181435,
-0.0506374352,
0.9331227541,
-0.2151725739,
-0.4622462392,
-0.0330568291,
0.3244608343,
0.2510778606,
0.2418640107,
-0.4978196025,
-0.212264657,
0.0366440453,
-0.4694958329,
-0.5889492631,
0.9433637857,
-0.2325604409,
-0.6415880322,
-0.3996001482,
-0.5041406751,
-0.5339936018,
0.3493232727,
0.2026143819,
0.647344768,
-0.1780241281,
0.54588449,
0.3439490795,
-0.3238680363,
0.3808351457,
0.8706339598,
-0.143453598,
0.0225964636,
0.6949600577,
0.232331425,
0.3164039552,
0.2383708954,
0.3238993585,
-0.210734725,
-0.2999421656,
-0.0754480883,
0.3027722239,
-0.4748238027,
-0.0081923679,
-0.5485936403,
-0.0177734736,
-0.7903948426,
-0.041956611,
-0.1429501325,
-0.4064005017,
0.1228420958,
-0.398360014,
0.5246345997,
0.6344814897,
-0.423905611,
0.2940110266,
-0.1975626498,
0.1842219979,
0.179524973,
0.2864325941,
0.1069359258,
-0.6084800363,
0.064406395,
-0.0263827406,
-0.1254136711,
-0.9600002766,
0.4851904511,
0.1676637679,
0.3094548285,
0.3671436906,
-0.0944220126,
0.8333898783,
-0.3834039569,
0.7593292594,
-0.2556829453,
-0.9887862802,
0.2318343073,
-0.7790100574,
0.3890944421,
0.5831148028,
0.4651743174,
-0.6123654842,
-0.1521989554,
-0.8223821521,
-0.9804551005,
0.701225698,
-0.0176659375,
0.1106380001,
-0.1309832335,
0.4543325007,
0.4312870502,
-0.018373346,
-0.5622112751,
0.0523764789,
0.2124219388,
0.1120574623,
-0.8508090973,
-0.0070301238,
-0.193594709,
-0.4749494791,
0.7533947229,
-0.360042125,
0.2588072419,
0.2099565864,
-0.0850902721,
0.4741309881,
0.4020527899,
0.4569503963,
0.600064218,
-0.4627768993,
0.2426970601,
0.5167870522,
-0.3794494867,
-0.0231993645,
0.2398732901,
0.1580711156,
-0.1910070479,
0.7452972531,
0.6751841307,
0.2423445731,
-0.6154392362,
0.4723473191,
0.043340262,
-0.370850414,
-0.3471677601,
0.0157584008,
0.1153118238,
0.0369220302,
0.2056079656,
-0.4572849274,
0.3671959341,
-0.6599548459,
0.3952777386,
0.3564939499,
-0.629391253,
-0.3950587213,
0.2155025601,
-0.239858523,
-0.2480545491,
0.7355762124,
-0.2435326874,
-0.2397122383,
0.6981405616,
0.7748586535,
0.6337960958,
-0.185358867,
0.1945623755,
0.5713945627,
0.4187291861,
-0.0856383443,
0.5400027037,
-0.0331343785,
-0.6966614723,
-0.2814508677,
0.0887844563,
-0.3147261739,
0.7249170542,
-1.0823904276,
0.3820351958,
-0.2546085119,
-0.0923012421,
-0.1611071676,
0.0276148673,
-0.6238770485,
0.2253531665,
-0.1986318529,
0.8234939575,
-0.9471126199,
0.7558477521,
0.6804742217,
-0.0521844327,
-0.7322407961,
0.2000922859,
-0.0232049283,
-0.6870443225,
0.3466372788,
0.3807235658,
-0.074909091,
0.0449432768,
-0.5637513399,
-0.6386995912,
0.9718322754,
0.5042917132,
-0.4581817687,
-0.1243102029,
-0.1100015864,
0.699993968,
-0.4408721924,
0.4366137981,
0.7789217234,
0.5409241319,
-0.5007687807,
-1.0295120478,
0.3130774796,
-0.3553275764,
-0.3894431591,
0.1215021759,
-0.5475859642,
1.0922731161,
-0.1263454556,
-0.1503719091,
-0.1633843184,
0.0832848027,
0.4660542011,
0.1614451855,
0.7062518597,
0.341956228,
0.498164922,
-0.0211739745,
1.044079423,
0.1968554854,
0.1327036023,
1.7177019119,
-0.5247327685,
0.9326204062,
0.765044868,
0.2249705642,
0.5326439738,
0.5329512358,
-0.1288655698,
0.218483597,
0.5578442216,
0.0704590827,
-0.3444391489,
-0.0160840098,
-0.564584136,
0.4951195419,
0.5246442556,
-0.3952863514,
-0.2398312688,
0.0459893681,
0.3166893721,
0.0765376091,
0.2219860703,
0.4911399782,
0.1292414963,
-0.7262759209,
0.6437914371,
-0.051456634,
0.639469564,
-0.547996223,
-0.1006285548,
-0.3069702089,
0.4722913504,
0.0378249064,
-0.5944831967,
0.0206598807,
-0.2271166891,
0.2493172437,
-0.3717168868,
0.446507901,
-0.2013785392,
-0.3200106323,
0.6259889007,
0.5983268023,
0.2568300664,
0.0608063042,
-0.2902911901,
-0.2785963714,
-0.2017713338,
-0.3806785643,
0.3405305445,
0.2117100954,
-0.3315891922,
0.5989689827,
0.2863805592,
0.0662451833,
0.0430529527,
0.2562450171,
0.6917330623,
-0.6834411621,
-0.3599220216,
-0.7687634826,
0.0848003402,
-0.1444362551,
-0.5561673641,
1.0647751093,
0.8707046509,
1.1136730909,
0.0029189328,
0.7151315808,
0.075131014,
0.5395906568,
-0.4696784914,
0.4819860458,
-0.5442221761,
0.1849065274,
-0.4268889129,
-0.7695150971,
-0.2683646977,
0.6197859645,
-0.7620130777,
0.3381476104,
0.7951959372,
1.0909593105,
-0.4161185324,
0.142008841,
0.349924922,
0.3362070918,
0.5878828168,
0.8250395656,
0.7819339633,
-0.7191608548,
0.2076393962,
-0.0453980379,
-0.1286577135,
-0.1055125445,
-0.991383791,
-1.020080924,
-0.7386022806,
-0.2008006424,
-0.2892099023,
0.0859904289,
0.6529914737,
0.8236461282,
-0.5187408924,
-0.4122747481,
-0.191187337,
-0.3046025336,
-0.3271173239,
-0.342759043,
0.3634074926,
0.0465695933,
-0.5999166369,
0.8525698781,
-0.2240117788,
-0.0093395552,
-0.1026578248,
-0.0740280226,
-0.374548912,
0.1872423887,
0.44577384,
0.2047901899,
-0.4747478962,
-0.3708182573,
0.1343149692,
0.2097099572,
-0.2826739252,
0.9590972066,
-0.9109583497,
0.1902543902,
0.5375878811,
0.3188930452,
0.6234986782,
-0.2775620818,
1.0027862787,
-0.6740263104,
0.2214029282,
0.2098188102,
0.2451277226,
0.4273435771,
-0.1419711262,
0.699208796,
-0.1670488864,
-0.17388542,
-1.1595996618,
0.4802459776,
-0.6047568321,
-0.2702514529,
1.2321856022,
0.1464691013,
0.1682245731,
0.0940882787,
-0.1420337707,
0.1478256881,
-0.231841743,
0.5998602509,
0.9411709309,
-0.3800874949,
-0.1378897578,
-0.7903921008,
0.5580115914,
0.9937422872,
-0.6257208586,
0.3441188037,
0.4677617848,
0.398606509,
-0.0280020703,
0.6221454144,
-0.4360774159,
0.1552328467,
-0.0527562201,
-0.2302074134,
0.0481788218,
-0.3937834799,
-0.8745492697,
0.0778793171,
-0.2147790194,
0.0748341456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.17579v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.17579v2 | Multimodal Image-Text Matching Improves Retrieval-based Chest X-Ray Report Generation | 2023-03-29T04:00:47 | 2023-05-02T21:03:40 | Jaehwan Jeong, Katherine Tian, Andrew Li, Sina Hartung, Fardad Behzadi, Juan Calle, David Osayande, Michael Pohlen, Subathra Adithan, Pranav Rajpurkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Automated generation of clinically accurate radiology reports can improve
patient care. Previous report generation methods that rely on image captioning
models often generate incoherent and incorrect text due to their lack of
relevant domain knowledge, while retrieval-based attempts frequently retrieve
reports that are irrelevant to the input image. In this work, we propose
Contrastive X-Ray REport Match (X-REM), a novel retrieval-based radiology
report generation module that uses an image-text matching score to measure the
similarity of a chest X-ray image and radiology report for report retrieval. We
observe that computing the image-text matching score with a language-image
model can effectively capture the fine-grained interaction between image and
text that is often lost when using cosine similarity. X-REM outperforms
multiple prior radiology report generation modules in terms of both natural
language and clinical metrics. Human evaluation of the generated reports
suggests that X-REM increased the number of zero-error reports and decreased
the average error severity compared to the baseline retrieval approach. Our
code is available at: https://github.com/rajpurkarlab/X-REM | [
-0.1665323675,
-0.2112637609,
0.6325138211,
0.0310867969,
-0.4715705216,
0.0105613619,
0.1546467841,
-0.5708086491,
0.3160882294,
0.6832227707,
-0.3255170286,
-0.5211753845,
-0.4238753617,
0.229506135,
-0.3603120148,
0.6914793849,
-0.0886183083,
-0.081431888,
-0.4234680533,
-0.3146340847,
-0.6311634779,
-0.2275662869,
-0.8269045949,
-0.392475605,
0.6296764016,
0.1737427711,
0.9627684355,
0.8129549623,
0.9253414869,
0.2858177125,
0.5838317871,
0.3389428854,
-0.1871686876,
0.2024871856,
-0.0030035877,
-0.4139285684,
-0.2810339034,
-0.1268053055,
0.4162493646,
0.0133638959,
-0.0917274505,
-0.1316955984,
-0.4205875695,
0.861541152,
-0.5442703962,
0.20313631,
-0.268909961,
0.1493715197,
-0.0455016196,
-1.1019620895,
-0.5143395066,
-0.2628142238,
0.2515905499,
-0.4939440191,
0.338937372,
0.3344869614,
0.943336308,
-0.0480323657,
-0.5262703896,
-0.5490234494,
-0.1787969321,
0.7301875949,
-0.5446460247,
0.366483897,
0.3417215347,
0.4640280306,
0.2832010686,
-0.8489786983,
-0.2674864233,
-0.1388821602,
-0.6077179313,
0.461260587,
-0.4523776174,
-0.0775268003,
-0.2346473336,
0.5511497855,
-0.8873272538,
-0.1701783389,
-0.1179679483,
-0.1021681577,
0.552638948,
0.4655171037,
0.5026323795,
-0.5344901085,
-0.6117860079,
-0.4374434352,
-0.5082891583,
-0.5558202863,
-0.3982611299,
0.4239969552,
-0.2175801545,
0.2018238157,
-0.2295205295,
0.6795839667,
-0.0608308092,
-0.3434375525,
0.7576746941,
-0.5568911433,
-0.3237865865,
0.3145704865,
0.7213375568,
0.836383462,
-0.1740187407,
-0.0670723096,
-0.1229115874,
0.2102456689,
0.2872015834,
-0.8057505488,
-0.1539622098,
0.0012452006,
-0.9041534662,
-0.6947230101,
0.0925555751,
-0.5003147721,
-0.1912683696,
-0.088914156,
0.52423805,
-0.5295143723,
0.0352674983,
0.1007104442,
-0.2279760242,
0.2314926237,
0.3142462969,
-0.1810365766,
0.2617890537,
0.1145448312,
0.8885966539,
0.0098970942,
0.120032452,
-1.0124076605,
0.1323201209,
-0.262796104,
1.0003905296,
-0.4980020523,
-0.4994645417,
0.010036665,
-0.2037719488,
0.0317293666,
-0.7825830579,
0.589902997,
-0.5694906116,
0.4461096525,
0.0674800128,
-0.2351202518,
-0.1039259806,
0.5771739483,
-0.7343152761,
0.7056729198,
0.2015257329,
-0.6581203341,
0.3165649176,
-0.2799767256,
-0.4441282451,
0.1412480474,
-0.6134087443,
-0.7561030984,
0.1175730452,
0.3292697966,
0.4613178372,
-0.6199117899,
-0.1585641056,
0.2501061559,
-0.3988826573,
0.3683813512,
-0.1280562133,
0.1492685378,
0.1714342088,
-0.2371482104,
0.0345481224,
-0.6716390848,
0.572696209,
0.1993113011,
-0.2511224747,
-0.2042529136,
-0.0665045828,
0.1302131712,
0.5602567196,
-0.2022113949,
-0.6442332268,
-0.3617043793,
-0.0239799861,
-0.0366456993,
0.2842927873,
-0.0320023596,
0.0451607667,
-1.2352255583,
0.6542956233,
-0.031293992,
-0.1653589308,
-0.8138919473,
-0.3396493196,
-0.2674141228,
-0.7020044327,
0.093938455,
0.5654470921,
-0.7772548199,
0.031401176,
-0.3375734091,
-0.6062484384,
-0.7105595469,
-0.1553979665,
0.8831692934,
0.7792421579,
0.4726160169,
-0.5190917253,
-0.7481477857,
-0.9540358186,
-0.002261214,
0.0218052063,
-0.0085259052,
0.9555043578,
-0.0473732837,
-0.2858062088,
0.4914008081,
-0.8761662245,
-0.943906486,
-0.0602579117,
0.2548679411,
0.1168296859,
0.2666737735,
0.571262598,
-0.8016284704,
-0.875092864,
0.3324434757,
-0.9279447198,
-0.2653010488,
-0.1663537025,
-0.0662636831,
0.4652224481,
0.724406898,
-0.1828826517,
0.392475009,
0.5420544147,
-0.1671904474,
0.3739275634,
-0.5649001002,
0.9579926729,
-1.0362261534,
0.2270308137,
0.0213904791,
-0.648555696,
-0.1570016891,
0.3056328893,
0.1686609238,
-0.3566310108,
-0.3750653863,
0.4700980484,
-0.6578529477,
0.2908443213,
-0.3201595545,
0.5031454563,
0.2591890693,
-0.0565145016,
0.304410547,
0.40572384,
0.4605549872,
-0.1070126295,
0.1966374367,
0.3423321545,
-0.1489156038,
0.8562112451,
-0.5620741844,
0.2300571501,
-0.0456731059,
0.218148157,
-1.1768814325,
-0.154842332,
-0.1299847811,
-0.4401836991,
0.5837500691,
0.1774870306,
-0.4365864396,
-0.0976232812,
-0.734752059,
0.5592660904,
0.5317277312,
-0.4031299353,
0.6004542112,
-0.1491668075,
-0.375126034,
-0.2815310061,
-0.9955052137,
0.2894021273,
0.2320153117,
-0.6898661852,
0.8083088994,
-0.1161817759,
0.1501335651,
0.1776684374,
-0.0315783918,
-0.151710853,
-0.3463972509,
0.2082304955,
0.3470746577,
-0.3853096068,
0.0022452592,
-0.1298772693,
-0.2676758468,
-0.0000458699,
0.1875338554,
0.4028664827,
0.0184544306,
-0.2947618961,
-0.5836145282,
0.6096971631,
0.460760057,
0.0497469231,
0.3670142591,
0.3992703557,
-0.2088666409,
0.2502836585,
-0.6701499224,
0.0010023493,
-0.3622906208,
0.4863463044,
-0.298366487,
-0.601749599,
0.1721227616,
0.2456024438,
-0.2414827049,
0.1451889575,
0.5057862401,
-0.1640095413,
0.9032875896,
0.335021019,
0.2636847794,
0.1327286363,
0.321197629,
0.0617100559,
-0.7054132819,
-0.3988695145,
-0.6200777888,
-0.1528334618,
-0.6611429453,
-0.4079914391,
0.3312278688,
-0.7082013488,
0.4038977325,
-0.0767146647,
-0.7110303044,
0.4332743585,
0.239160195,
0.5214953423,
0.5824267864,
0.2363140285,
0.1918789446,
-0.3921531737,
-0.6843131781,
-0.3530923724,
0.9553989172,
-0.2906953096,
0.8776316643,
0.2804412246,
1.0213932991,
0.4660509825,
0.4017969966,
-0.5056867599,
0.3332492709,
-0.6118364334,
-0.2591853142,
0.2279143929,
-0.5362426639,
-1.2477930784,
0.2513074875,
-0.5042709112,
-0.0453008786,
-0.2416529953,
0.2417876869,
-0.3656950891,
-0.0101217078,
-0.5771922469,
0.5535536408,
-0.2653249502,
-0.2359090149,
-0.3005821705,
-0.7405146956,
0.1832048893,
-0.3074428737,
0.3510394394,
0.154736042,
-0.1486611515,
0.6175009608,
-0.3197727799,
0.60876441,
0.2417119592,
0.0696947947,
-0.0634211451,
0.2354425043,
-0.0243687406,
0.1480900049,
-0.0920473412,
-0.1893148571,
0.1187476069,
-0.3189427853,
-0.5823367834,
0.9771863222,
-0.5910512209,
-0.3259564042,
-0.6329882145,
-0.7669867277,
0.2165914029,
0.3574747443,
0.3588638902,
0.8471065164,
-0.2773809433,
0.161732167,
0.6293165684,
-0.4171027541,
0.0331056975,
0.6967791319,
-0.3151182234,
-0.7971320152,
0.9803996682,
0.0237187911,
0.2573950589,
0.9342700839,
0.137590006,
-0.1135002449,
-0.1680763811,
-0.0741376653,
0.4128691256,
-0.6327755451,
-0.7122324109,
-0.3526006341,
-0.0413411856,
-0.1706362665,
-0.6335299611,
0.0283924472,
-0.0394929536,
-0.0169360843,
0.358173728,
0.1110199615,
0.4984411895,
-0.0117876744,
0.0288947541,
-1.1225589514,
0.3302873373,
0.1398627311,
0.3011940718,
-0.1434619129,
-0.5248439908,
-0.1521755457,
-0.5208569765,
-0.2522914708,
-0.6916909218,
0.4420718849,
0.2859015465,
0.445255965,
-0.0232009292,
0.1749862731,
0.5855779052,
-0.3228711188,
0.3566001654,
0.5039793849,
-0.6952116489,
0.6447503567,
-0.0745484754,
0.7093110085,
0.3475848138,
0.0997681022,
-0.5212712288,
-0.3332878053,
-0.5436344743,
-0.832798779,
0.6540467739,
0.2875504792,
0.0994204581,
-0.4259261787,
0.3505952954,
0.1491090953,
-0.0037396536,
-0.5036029816,
-0.1935709715,
-0.0492947064,
-0.4955165088,
0.0459028631,
-0.400971055,
-0.1195386276,
0.3038524389,
0.6562632918,
-0.2098608911,
0.5359136462,
0.5475501418,
-0.2790322602,
-0.3048876822,
0.2436814308,
0.6271274686,
0.3640507162,
-0.4071943462,
0.4246837497,
-0.1958208978,
-0.3439711928,
0.1586634964,
0.131878525,
0.1777888238,
0.223421827,
0.5404059291,
0.23865363,
0.4868491888,
-0.9175109863,
0.5100211501,
-0.5132905245,
-0.3470666707,
-0.0980877876,
-0.0647220612,
0.0804092959,
0.1765082926,
0.2292718738,
0.3447392881,
0.125876382,
-0.4895752668,
0.5510826111,
0.2956846952,
-0.6531732678,
0.0498207696,
0.4438681006,
0.2979576886,
-0.2020820379,
0.9169275761,
0.0272126906,
-0.0168455467,
0.4913758039,
0.7230532765,
0.5239445567,
-0.1045119092,
0.2627016604,
0.2175329477,
0.0748576224,
0.1867189854,
0.4194535315,
0.1549113393,
-0.5383749604,
-0.3515686095,
0.0837122798,
-0.2151377201,
-0.2455726564,
-0.9725168347,
0.3695668876,
-0.2848563492,
-0.0053347186,
-0.0698645189,
0.022614941,
-0.4304858744,
0.625369966,
0.2946893573,
0.9218096137,
-0.5735417008,
0.6151601672,
0.7264432311,
-0.4568015635,
-0.6150126457,
-0.1803265512,
0.0826499835,
-0.840123117,
0.5110024214,
0.4740445018,
-0.1068435982,
-0.1751191616,
0.0706623122,
-0.6238721013,
1.4238705635,
0.3049951494,
-0.4595118463,
0.3666961491,
-0.1300130039,
0.4160786569,
-0.6130620837,
0.423463285,
0.3003449738,
0.0177463833,
0.0513954051,
-0.8811847568,
0.7225763202,
-0.3717171848,
-0.0463007465,
0.4300687015,
-0.6668662429,
0.5314220786,
-0.3199481666,
-0.0955113247,
0.4280858636,
0.4462348521,
0.4704675078,
0.5340497494,
0.3385630548,
0.6227081418,
0.5933367014,
0.0102503477,
1.3234363794,
-0.1454249769,
0.1930198073,
1.112790823,
-0.5473325849,
0.8237127066,
0.3991101682,
0.1954875886,
0.6525464654,
0.0893010348,
-0.0777375996,
0.6515415907,
-0.067853488,
-0.1826310903,
-0.2353981584,
-0.1843194962,
-0.4084369242,
0.2799554765,
-0.0064702816,
-0.7535595894,
-0.384732604,
-0.0542499572,
-0.0044353679,
0.3294170797,
-0.0438344814,
0.7082407475,
-0.0017193808,
-0.3981379569,
0.6632534266,
-0.1813081652,
0.5991101265,
-0.6921290159,
-0.1279373169,
-0.1255490929,
0.2929053605,
-0.5062994957,
-0.8353110552,
0.530956924,
-0.2863374352,
-0.6480511427,
0.0382445455,
0.7031787634,
-0.4922054112,
-0.1379832476,
0.3431665003,
0.3719696105,
-0.0407686383,
-0.0351530798,
-0.6792952418,
0.281260252,
0.0838249102,
0.1370744258,
0.5999228954,
0.18208839,
-0.1027525216,
0.5426216722,
0.3347587585,
-0.1382448375,
-0.3107406795,
-0.0355206951,
0.698368609,
-0.4922930598,
-0.4064927101,
-0.5224794745,
0.2253450304,
-0.0868307352,
-0.2161078453,
0.2686529756,
0.7211287022,
0.5505974293,
-0.1418502629,
0.7993144393,
-0.1004919857,
0.3780019879,
-0.5139369965,
0.6100084186,
-0.817805469,
0.0286602192,
-0.409632057,
-0.3792689443,
-0.9028378725,
0.4392309785,
0.1448374689,
0.0077034151,
0.9671452045,
1.0589675903,
-0.0375149325,
-0.4027484655,
0.6239099503,
0.0540858507,
0.3848654032,
0.5236312747,
0.3374790549,
-0.7693295479,
1.1055393219,
-0.0855265111,
-0.3982905746,
-0.3482286334,
-0.9217784405,
-0.5474897027,
-0.3377096951,
-0.8593848944,
-0.5749082565,
0.0782073364,
0.6563314795,
0.8372110128,
-0.4028036594,
-0.1369248331,
0.376051873,
-0.2359928191,
-0.2267799228,
-0.2671098411,
0.5428242087,
-0.3711721003,
-0.3191030324,
0.1072056368,
0.6802559495,
-0.2517086864,
0.264778018,
-0.3083392084,
-0.2538876235,
0.1565357596,
0.6686777472,
0.0988995209,
-0.4364295304,
-0.1797833145,
0.1383000612,
-0.4320500195,
0.4166863263,
0.8357174993,
-1.0104861259,
0.7802838683,
0.4888706803,
0.5445805788,
0.481933862,
-0.2760400176,
0.4352567792,
-0.985009551,
-0.1423950195,
-0.0650737211,
0.3601777852,
0.5932430029,
-0.4633364677,
0.398991555,
0.2214156836,
-0.6133330464,
-0.6591628194,
0.1392793208,
-1.2944113016,
-0.1182846949,
0.4941966236,
-0.2346201539,
-0.1602680683,
0.0977869257,
-0.5884657502,
-0.0035757211,
-0.3937094808,
0.8657912016,
0.0967988148,
-0.3968243003,
-0.5138306618,
0.0591302589,
0.0779405087,
0.5430262685,
-0.8125403523,
-0.4889916778,
0.2543080449,
0.3629763126,
0.4115050733,
0.8059232831,
-0.5198218822,
1.016605854,
-0.1315413564,
-0.0176356398,
-0.2032494545,
0.3770478964,
-0.0652606413,
0.3303534985,
0.1203347594,
-0.3764404058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16434v1 | TaskMatrix.AI: Completing Tasks by Connecting Foundation Models with Millions of APIs | 2023-03-29T03:30:38 | 2023-03-29T03:30:38 | Yaobo Liang, Chenfei Wu, Ting Song, Wenshan Wu, Yan Xia, Yu Liu, Yang Ou, Shuai Lu, Lei Ji, Shaoguang Mao, Yun Wang, Linjun Shou, Ming Gong, Nan Duan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Artificial Intelligence (AI) has made incredible progress recently. On the
one hand, advanced foundation models like ChatGPT can offer powerful
conversation, in-context learning and code generation abilities on a broad
range of open-domain tasks. They can also generate high-level solution outlines
for domain-specific tasks based on the common sense knowledge they have
acquired. However, they still face difficulties with some specialized tasks
because they lack enough domain-specific data during pre-training or they often
have errors in their neural network computations on those tasks that need
accurate executions. On the other hand, there are also many existing models and
systems (symbolic-based or neural-based) that can do some domain-specific tasks
very well. However, due to the different implementation or working mechanisms,
they are not easily accessible or compatible with foundation models. Therefore,
there is a clear and pressing need for a mechanism that can leverage foundation
models to propose task solution outlines and then automatically match some of
the sub-tasks in the outlines to the off-the-shelf models and systems with
special functionalities to complete them. Inspired by this, we introduce
TaskMatrix.AI as a new AI ecosystem that connects foundation models with
millions of APIs for task completion. Unlike most previous work that aimed to
improve a single AI model, TaskMatrix.AI focuses more on using existing
foundation models (as a brain-like central system) and APIs of other AI models
and systems (as sub-task solvers) to achieve diversified tasks in both digital
and physical domains. As a position paper, we will present our vision of how to
build such an ecosystem, explain each key component, and use study cases to
illustrate both the feasibility of this vision and the main challenges we need
to address next. | [
-0.5686306357,
-0.4735629559,
0.2878599763,
0.2202358395,
0.0608947054,
0.3107424378,
0.0701531991,
-0.4490667582,
0.2244342864,
0.502820313,
-0.8243613243,
-0.3961279988,
-0.7137399316,
-0.0129248686,
-0.4509423077,
0.991173327,
-0.1961462051,
-0.211475119,
-0.7420355082,
0.0357535668,
-0.8960444331,
-0.4056096077,
-0.4365237951,
-0.563978672,
0.2082412541,
0.3806321621,
0.4511861503,
0.6014025211,
0.6965254545,
0.3718421161,
0.3759016097,
0.0448246039,
-0.4029488564,
0.0617555119,
-0.1782415956,
-0.6125826836,
-0.6604371667,
0.0423132814,
0.0950076878,
1.0227838755,
-0.1846553683,
0.4260674715,
0.1842542291,
0.6307293177,
-0.6323727965,
0.5548308492,
-0.3525834978,
0.1740223765,
-0.0377564095,
-0.0521607511,
-0.1314035803,
0.1457993537,
0.2111449391,
-0.8648566604,
-0.01729233,
-0.1139715984,
0.5842398405,
0.7239575386,
-0.21517542,
-0.161823988,
-0.8848749995,
0.6737138033,
-0.2747480571,
0.137382552,
0.461076498,
0.6114417911,
-0.1644561589,
-0.9728211164,
-0.3245815039,
-0.151359275,
-0.0298917443,
-0.0348987803,
-0.5924068093,
-0.0637151152,
0.1520714164,
0.0168939531,
-0.5307361484,
-0.3579379916,
-0.2596952915,
-0.0640376881,
0.4388618171,
0.4388309717,
0.3363339305,
0.1303172112,
-0.1903835088,
0.1932701766,
-0.7869557142,
0.096499376,
0.1779823005,
0.4599215388,
-0.049367249,
0.5997598767,
-0.5436662436,
0.7422003746,
0.0371706858,
0.2195496559,
0.1186370552,
-0.25018543,
-0.3146721423,
-0.2743944526,
0.4472407997,
0.0275823213,
0.0793883353,
-0.5176095963,
-0.3229984045,
0.5012473464,
0.6902700067,
-0.603795588,
-0.3445509374,
0.4528794885,
-0.5018184185,
-0.0719686151,
-0.3865653574,
-0.2447770238,
-0.2992951572,
-0.8670727015,
0.6956137419,
-0.2264575958,
-0.2820130885,
0.0489863828,
-0.0320519879,
-0.3052703142,
0.5771046281,
-0.5939290524,
0.549185276,
1.027605772,
0.7022634149,
-0.2027664036,
-0.2618012726,
-0.4788554013,
-0.043073792,
-0.066759266,
0.7628792524,
-0.7014824748,
-0.3486609757,
-0.1694031954,
-0.2876115441,
-0.1850870699,
-0.4644832015,
0.0651734099,
-0.4601572156,
-0.2924146652,
-0.3061133325,
-0.4199893475,
-0.2884817421,
0.5319262743,
-0.6059960127,
0.6824381351,
0.1199135929,
-0.4378848374,
0.2214116156,
-0.9760733247,
-0.3559686542,
0.2410029322,
-0.1813823432,
-0.1240770072,
-0.1178564355,
0.0442937203,
0.5962793827,
-0.4394140542,
0.3598460555,
-0.2041920573,
-0.3133304715,
-0.1254667193,
0.2546412647,
0.7333298922,
0.2202093303,
-0.7260113955,
0.3627878428,
-0.4864939749,
-0.15412727,
-0.1791766137,
-0.1601768732,
-0.0604823902,
0.1114404798,
0.3198148906,
0.3084225357,
0.4389377534,
-0.4693067074,
0.1963873655,
-0.057611268,
0.8223781586,
0.57590729,
-0.4814078808,
0.5578095317,
-0.7440515757,
0.7954537868,
-0.1707772613,
0.1177754104,
-0.1213542894,
-0.6471791863,
-0.7121895552,
-0.3967832923,
0.3989029229,
0.6767883897,
-0.3863535821,
0.1784880757,
-0.4972030818,
-0.739297688,
-0.2546138167,
0.0588478595,
0.3326390088,
0.5432742834,
0.287139982,
-0.3995258808,
-0.6991989613,
-0.934412539,
0.2650972009,
-0.016921442,
0.0892704874,
0.7057809234,
0.9680296183,
-0.3180465102,
1.4547913074,
-0.2127223313,
-0.6503286958,
-0.137130186,
0.1905014068,
0.1385789812,
0.702168107,
0.4546129704,
-1.2263349295,
-0.4834634662,
0.0838086382,
-1.0020008087,
0.1662802696,
0.2136598974,
-0.2745326757,
-0.2772092223,
0.3107431233,
-1.1399140358,
0.3641641438,
0.2639122009,
-0.1591262221,
0.3398526907,
0.0901087821,
0.0616254136,
-1.2486418486,
0.6286386847,
-0.198586911,
-0.1267068833,
-0.5987357497,
0.2558570504,
-0.3395905197,
-0.5149888396,
-0.2878068089,
0.5300917625,
-0.2182644904,
-0.2203090787,
-0.3497054577,
-0.1397370547,
-0.3007667959,
0.8350333571,
-0.1353310943,
0.6914077997,
0.6820542812,
-0.4126943648,
0.4513849616,
0.7173451185,
-0.0686731786,
0.6766200066,
-0.6731849909,
0.0006980159,
-0.0884766504,
0.4737924039,
-0.7848608494,
-0.2773128748,
0.2587067783,
-0.5095774531,
-0.0090886382,
-0.1955553591,
-0.1775479168,
-0.3258259296,
0.3053513169,
0.5795136094,
0.5807353258,
-0.3016123176,
1.1936320066,
0.7466768622,
-0.2012854815,
-1.0610009432,
-0.4707142711,
0.4752292335,
0.0507517941,
-0.7703077793,
0.4930258095,
-0.1452382356,
-0.1501055211,
0.3883426189,
-0.1078192443,
0.005886062,
0.4397774339,
0.9153257012,
0.0465866104,
-0.2211003155,
-0.2507497668,
-0.1388087869,
-0.4134930074,
0.2104576826,
-0.5414783359,
0.5371699929,
-0.1635780782,
-0.5346102715,
-0.5319034457,
0.6173014045,
0.7639268637,
-0.6267598271,
0.2271495014,
0.2618267834,
-0.9251660705,
-0.4097114205,
-0.2806448042,
-0.1154428795,
-0.4310596883,
0.252674073,
-0.6243058443,
-0.8881292343,
0.5820000172,
-0.2567914128,
0.3274530768,
0.3594994843,
0.6399568915,
-0.0309122819,
1.1462134123,
0.9267303348,
-0.0699369907,
0.2680251598,
-0.6671373844,
0.1977936178,
-0.6646034718,
-0.3887059689,
-0.4987419546,
-0.7308078408,
0.0019495303,
-0.2413514853,
0.0561389923,
0.025483815,
-0.3027615845,
0.7127792835,
-0.6763339043,
0.1640613377,
0.8878165483,
0.1051313505,
0.1110484451,
-0.0732674599,
0.0139058148,
0.3249770999,
-0.7221015692,
-0.5488173962,
1.1570180655,
0.0524855666,
0.4670782983,
0.004083083,
0.5695620179,
0.7057034373,
0.6498616338,
-0.5011462569,
0.7013390064,
-0.0569532514,
-0.7308856845,
-0.0023171485,
-0.1674271077,
-0.9929329157,
-0.0391609222,
-0.3817583025,
-0.7564205527,
0.3377028406,
0.2451248765,
-0.6214734316,
0.0636454076,
-0.373893708,
1.20421803,
0.3515628576,
-0.1047281921,
-0.4718562961,
-0.5867159367,
0.1383967549,
-0.0154223815,
-0.0170907602,
-0.2661637366,
-0.0365077481,
0.5816076398,
-0.5487700105,
1.0961397886,
-0.0749036372,
0.2755922377,
0.2653163373,
0.154942587,
0.418746978,
0.0077467873,
0.2168989629,
0.1043449119,
-0.2198686451,
-0.4159370065,
-0.4639076293,
0.6481842995,
-0.7744989991,
-0.5826758742,
-0.2252465487,
-0.8755615354,
-0.2931362391,
0.1409802288,
-0.0402415469,
0.607237339,
-0.3081388474,
0.1118514687,
0.2925184667,
0.4022816122,
0.3872315586,
0.1780152321,
0.1528315097,
-0.0610928386,
1.0042752028,
-0.1398920715,
-0.3771282136,
0.5204157233,
-0.4090097547,
-0.0308992211,
-0.8047043681,
-0.4937986732,
-0.2763034999,
-0.7336912155,
-0.4288654923,
-0.9685515165,
-0.1215722263,
-0.2086907625,
-0.4319907725,
-0.2774189115,
-0.358204335,
-0.2918999195,
0.218533203,
0.1893547773,
0.8765845299,
-0.0931947902,
0.2915372252,
-0.8030148745,
0.1357820034,
0.5367894769,
0.1327159405,
0.1827488244,
0.2169744074,
-0.3019432127,
0.3222077489,
-0.1655979007,
-0.4439436793,
0.2898383439,
0.1766245514,
0.6215704083,
0.0946858525,
-0.1007301807,
0.5212177038,
-0.584179759,
0.4843356907,
0.0081478488,
-0.9852181077,
0.5569795966,
-0.5374835134,
-0.0461402759,
0.510081768,
0.3817004263,
-0.3683129549,
-0.3193664253,
-0.545715034,
-0.6918340921,
0.7801380157,
0.6694853306,
0.0421619043,
0.1884693205,
0.2721138,
0.0672140494,
0.4128825366,
-0.1430088282,
-0.1339242309,
-0.2310087085,
-0.5156098008,
0.0023047994,
0.423338145,
-0.537543118,
0.1354681998,
0.6161384583,
-0.1842612773,
0.3898957968,
-0.0920032114,
-0.4426204562,
-0.1059305593,
-0.1885972023,
0.5250355005,
0.9718405604,
0.0009939992,
-0.1396730989,
-0.0531344898,
-0.5666773915,
0.0921960846,
0.537858665,
-0.1208320931,
-0.2942031026,
0.2883594036,
0.7585141063,
0.0855786353,
-0.9618031383,
0.4731286764,
-0.050235942,
-0.2602469027,
-0.4127761126,
0.2459838092,
0.2449808419,
0.6538032889,
0.5487385988,
0.784172833,
0.1468292177,
-0.3858673871,
0.5351531506,
0.5072757006,
-0.4853342772,
-0.3460423648,
1.0817511082,
0.4825415015,
-0.6080136895,
0.6597703695,
-0.0463671722,
-0.5006430745,
1.190725565,
0.2971535325,
0.688393414,
0.0514330938,
0.1940635741,
0.0833206251,
0.0756524578,
-0.1196488217,
0.3676513731,
-0.2823517621,
-0.6605297327,
-0.6797118187,
-0.68368572,
-0.4295789301,
-0.2370978445,
-0.3659623265,
-0.0403368436,
-0.4794100821,
-0.310946703,
0.0834087431,
-0.0445220396,
-0.8448624611,
0.3263520002,
0.2122913599,
0.8531548381,
-0.7712595463,
0.4558600783,
0.9977862835,
-0.4657076895,
-0.6463862062,
-0.6771286726,
-0.1416017711,
-0.7938446999,
0.9919018745,
0.2730379701,
0.0607982539,
0.3594110906,
-0.2200403661,
-0.8966859579,
1.1877880096,
0.5061614513,
-0.349037081,
-0.3424276412,
0.2437249571,
0.3517375886,
-0.7323675156,
0.0414183512,
0.2592512965,
0.4818875194,
-0.0147109972,
-1.0258197784,
0.1614140868,
-0.8138666749,
-0.2152762115,
0.3767222464,
-0.1933337003,
0.9655451775,
-0.1567920595,
-0.0685483292,
0.23401618,
0.5555593371,
0.1178352162,
0.2598999739,
0.571677506,
1.0262724161,
0.4733232856,
-0.1947067678,
0.856163919,
-0.5983827114,
0.3788917661,
0.7379529476,
-0.2189966291,
0.871764183,
0.0957260057,
-0.1080035567,
0.3138245344,
0.7942963839,
-0.1763308942,
0.4591835141,
0.1706800312,
-0.3166569173,
-0.5904750228,
-0.339797318,
-0.1987545639,
0.4614030719,
0.3167844713,
0.0576215126,
-0.3576329648,
0.4745948017,
-0.390083164,
-0.0726765841,
-0.4143164158,
0.4249546826,
0.1037188694,
-0.7687932253,
0.1069791242,
-0.1780782938,
0.4490166903,
-0.3626863062,
-0.4202880561,
-0.0323409103,
0.2170071006,
-0.2508354783,
-0.3411289752,
0.3953213692,
-0.221753642,
-0.2804983556,
-0.5368630886,
0.5954514146,
-0.0964893326,
-0.2827459574,
0.1485556364,
0.8246917129,
-0.0467982478,
-0.2353785336,
-0.793161869,
-0.3338877261,
-0.4274818599,
-0.1263930649,
0.2517535686,
-0.0026044573,
-0.1242972836,
1.0734474659,
0.8381381035,
-0.3501829505,
-0.1620649397,
-0.3639430702,
0.8520771265,
-0.2771803737,
-0.7297312617,
-0.4972415268,
0.5526827574,
0.1105027273,
-0.4599153996,
0.3433203995,
0.5909414291,
0.745595932,
-0.042579744,
0.8640528917,
-0.5164710879,
0.1639701277,
0.0707378238,
0.9029199481,
-0.7406576872,
-0.0603252202,
0.0122210514,
-1.0554933548,
-0.2606181502,
0.5618032813,
-0.1310647428,
0.0442824997,
0.4583067596,
0.6919539571,
-0.4176707864,
0.0579905696,
0.0723543987,
-0.0315369554,
0.0829971433,
0.8151617646,
0.7779113054,
-0.2050411105,
0.7299832106,
-0.1860997379,
-0.1922723204,
-0.2749344409,
-0.630287528,
-0.8420389295,
-0.8812237978,
-0.4494352639,
-0.2662183046,
0.2149062455,
0.8815317154,
1.1466571093,
-0.8032384515,
-0.2818359435,
-0.490735054,
-0.0822077468,
-0.4605129659,
-0.0483442619,
0.3143728375,
-0.3099916279,
-0.7346891165,
0.3646962345,
0.3291344345,
-0.2685946822,
-0.1668502837,
-0.0288449917,
0.0187645741,
-0.0591856427,
0.2633321881,
0.4681655169,
-0.5874046087,
-0.004955621,
0.2065909803,
-0.2145465463,
0.0503844358,
0.8845670819,
-1.0876967907,
0.0865684375,
0.5652902126,
1.1653487682,
0.4377205372,
-0.2350956798,
0.7687904239,
-0.3798102736,
-0.0692557469,
0.4275926054,
0.5985184312,
0.199793011,
-0.1802457273,
0.6028095484,
0.2591199279,
-0.410319984,
-0.7486300468,
0.2593967319,
-1.1157099009,
-0.2278045714,
0.5140128136,
-0.2233753204,
-0.3614104688,
-0.3491200507,
-0.0978971794,
0.2273552716,
-0.2779812813,
0.7962301373,
0.5502915978,
-0.2103407979,
0.1670516431,
-0.6346363425,
0.5360122919,
0.5823603272,
-0.9830158949,
0.0321628712,
0.2766942084,
0.2221922129,
0.5817835331,
0.6498606205,
0.3674764931,
0.5683512092,
0.1327167749,
0.1762006432,
-0.4339275658,
-0.4393855035,
0.0675413534,
0.594901979,
-0.3297694325,
-0.2316295803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16421v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16421v3 | ChatGPT is a Knowledgeable but Inexperienced Solver: An Investigation of Commonsense Problem in Large Language Models | 2023-03-29T03:05:43 | 2024-04-19T04:57:37 | Ning Bian, Xianpei Han, Le Sun, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Ben He, Shanshan Jiang, Bin Dong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have made significant progress in NLP. However,
their ability to memorize, represent, and leverage commonsense knowledge has
been a well-known pain point. In this paper, we specifically focus on ChatGPT,
a widely used and easily accessible LLM, and ask the following questions: (1)
Can ChatGPT effectively answer commonsense questions? (2) Is ChatGPT aware of
the underlying commonsense knowledge for answering a specific question? (3) Is
ChatGPT knowledgeable in commonsense? (4) Can ChatGPT effectively leverage
commonsense for answering questions? We conduct a series of experiments on 11
datasets to evaluate ChatGPT's commonsense abilities, including answering
commonsense questions, identifying necessary knowledge, generating knowledge
descriptions, and using knowledge descriptions to answer questions again.
Experimental results show that: (1) ChatGPT can achieve good QA accuracies in
commonsense tasks, while still struggling with certain domains of datasets. (2)
ChatGPT is knowledgeable, and can accurately generate most of the commonsense
knowledge using knowledge prompts. (3) Despite its knowledge, ChatGPT is an
inexperienced commonsense problem solver, which cannot precisely identify the
needed commonsense for answering a specific question. These findings raise the
need to explore improved mechanisms for effectively incorporating commonsense
into LLMs like ChatGPT, such as better instruction following and commonsense
guidance. | [
-0.3662530482,
-0.9237990975,
0.5869911313,
0.2260587066,
-0.1519479007,
0.059711054,
-0.2936983705,
-0.1980098635,
-0.2729662657,
0.2181957066,
-0.3608827889,
-0.1465478837,
-0.7147147655,
0.0431509651,
-0.3310770988,
1.0072159767,
0.2416442037,
-0.1472783089,
-0.211440593,
0.1214032397,
-0.6416658759,
-0.4124272168,
-1.2113987207,
-0.1979421526,
0.5887970328,
0.4981740117,
0.6338160038,
0.1404063553,
0.473885864,
0.3610671759,
-0.5448548794,
0.184578836,
-0.7717764974,
-0.1100575924,
-0.177021265,
-0.441452831,
-0.2882753313,
-0.2281632572,
0.4198377132,
0.6063462496,
-0.3394475281,
-0.0140116913,
0.274875164,
0.5357563496,
-0.2579375207,
0.3619965911,
-1.0028078556,
-0.0397119001,
-0.1087414026,
-0.1563575864,
-0.2206268311,
-0.1913288385,
0.3322648108,
-0.7329260707,
0.2472420484,
0.2149128467,
0.552308619,
0.3382181823,
-0.4435880184,
-0.4463986158,
-0.4089567661,
0.7273747325,
-0.8473529816,
0.1723631918,
0.2182804346,
0.4268724918,
-0.235464111,
-0.6947134137,
-0.805605948,
-0.2848309278,
-0.2153848261,
0.2263088524,
-0.2428051084,
0.0010461252,
0.3773510158,
0.4097162187,
-0.5600499511,
0.1358305961,
-0.5573602915,
-0.217641741,
0.4249130189,
0.0195171405,
0.3784246445,
-0.2208852321,
-0.5615288615,
0.2557899654,
-0.6060870886,
-0.0352838337,
0.1560683697,
0.150949508,
-0.0551523231,
0.5575235486,
-0.1496419758,
0.7293840051,
-0.2773871124,
-0.0285704453,
-0.1657915264,
0.1598518491,
-0.000249331,
-0.1399371475,
0.6565699577,
0.2561655939,
0.5880536437,
-0.0667936876,
-0.3049375713,
-0.4956797659,
0.1752539575,
-0.5151873827,
-0.5028650761,
0.3365178108,
-0.0761789382,
-0.2238149047,
-0.4129679501,
-0.7706667185,
-0.5192111135,
-0.2034736127,
0.5988972187,
-0.4571932554,
-0.5391072631,
0.1919612736,
-0.2063413411,
0.4527212679,
0.5775573254,
-0.8051723838,
0.2568821013,
0.9151083231,
0.836322546,
-0.2820018828,
-0.2306777835,
-0.3773009777,
-0.1846003681,
-0.1285092682,
0.8420254588,
-0.2896798253,
-0.2695015371,
-0.1866062433,
-0.1958967745,
-0.3168913126,
-0.480419457,
0.3986499012,
-0.7703645825,
0.0204695109,
-0.4101298451,
-0.781250596,
-0.0424482301,
0.5737972856,
-0.5937145948,
0.7523164749,
-0.1147424579,
-0.9906206131,
0.0269693416,
-0.6460638642,
0.0288874488,
0.3175837696,
0.1026036069,
-0.0397533588,
-0.2219688892,
0.3133083582,
0.5990954638,
-0.0148035847,
0.2215206772,
-0.0352838226,
-0.3101172447,
0.6564348936,
-0.8027603626,
0.5881416798,
0.2029955387,
0.1433909386,
-0.4299019873,
-0.4327773154,
-0.0910233706,
0.2706116438,
-0.2982351184,
-0.0619049594,
-0.0884794891,
-0.1015382111,
-0.0542043261,
0.2796626687,
-0.4407856166,
0.1497746855,
-0.1537829638,
0.5524861813,
0.846388936,
0.2339803129,
0.0735831261,
-0.5138437152,
0.2911112905,
-0.2489159107,
-0.1603087485,
0.1055599675,
-0.7675299048,
-0.6467769742,
0.0058270376,
-0.0037056711,
0.6355655789,
-0.8201140165,
-0.2450010926,
-0.1383490413,
-0.5235533118,
-0.1994987577,
0.2611858249,
0.533537209,
0.755567193,
0.3203259408,
0.1226575151,
-0.0852669179,
-0.850387454,
-0.5046993494,
-0.1587954462,
0.0164526887,
0.5535572171,
0.5161747932,
0.3698808551,
0.7261720896,
-0.7459020019,
-0.1765702069,
-0.3591644168,
0.1715786606,
0.3189571202,
0.4022208154,
-0.0387523957,
-0.9304056764,
-0.4154198766,
0.1217538789,
-0.5679088831,
0.0526566356,
0.0257897582,
0.2293214947,
-0.1194469631,
0.6434450746,
-0.7626392245,
-0.1635271758,
0.4745714664,
-0.0826132819,
0.7472817302,
-0.3463391662,
0.0165091045,
-0.9673402309,
0.1180484816,
-0.1666515321,
-0.0339971967,
-0.7359805703,
0.0589074902,
-0.067361787,
-0.3418416679,
-0.7331712246,
0.7358039021,
-0.2314703763,
0.0273953434,
-0.0304149967,
0.5321890116,
-0.2727587819,
0.7714024782,
0.2763582766,
1.0129045248,
0.3338571787,
-0.5382719636,
0.4565275609,
0.2607540488,
-0.3225623667,
0.5996103883,
-0.9375376105,
0.249925226,
-0.2635052502,
-0.1480076313,
-1.2060234547,
-0.2935243845,
0.0286144949,
-0.6022670865,
0.189354822,
-0.5912289023,
-0.4751475155,
-0.2286367416,
0.3561927974,
0.3801649511,
0.5441882014,
-0.5066199303,
0.3274796009,
0.2218104005,
-0.4568782449,
-0.7683808804,
-0.4474078715,
-0.0603075959,
-0.3433688283,
-0.619463563,
-0.2144442797,
0.0790197849,
-0.2730767429,
-0.0196650755,
-0.0583287366,
-0.351146996,
0.0948695987,
-0.1928949952,
0.1134933308,
-0.2160617709,
0.5584485531,
-0.4055666327,
-0.3031803966,
0.0592139065,
0.0121628707,
0.6534855962,
-0.5917019844,
-0.5253389478,
-0.1921325326,
0.1316964924,
0.2523643076,
-0.3453446031,
0.4322480261,
0.5704478025,
-0.0816371068,
-0.3080515563,
-0.7564404607,
-0.1742819697,
-0.4943999648,
0.5780268908,
-0.2412178963,
-1.067258954,
0.537155509,
-0.049039904,
0.2819059789,
0.2402204871,
0.4240959585,
-0.314619869,
0.4366470277,
0.1373181492,
0.1306360066,
-0.0331546441,
-0.0856514797,
0.2443812639,
-0.8041020036,
-0.1950825751,
-0.4257874191,
-0.2398092151,
-0.5707509518,
-0.5530016422,
0.480209291,
-0.0569658652,
-0.3279754817,
0.1221653596,
-0.3044061363,
0.6875559092,
0.455471307,
0.2276153564,
0.5439137816,
-0.3493688405,
0.3707536459,
0.0813429356,
-0.9591171741,
-0.4881144464,
0.9064392447,
0.3486895263,
0.7089216113,
0.2380809486,
0.5518946648,
0.0051909154,
0.0959805772,
-0.8622819185,
0.6058177352,
-0.1304630786,
-0.6881478429,
-0.4892498851,
-0.5487985611,
-0.7975897789,
0.2274662703,
-0.1609457433,
-0.7611742616,
-0.2530940175,
0.5349885225,
-0.3631751835,
0.5201668143,
-0.9598537683,
0.9495440125,
-0.1351196766,
-0.3214896917,
-0.0690741315,
-0.473516196,
0.5786629319,
0.0458165854,
0.2404315323,
-0.1751099676,
-0.0857307836,
0.8467721939,
-0.1536949277,
1.0299015045,
-0.1420806199,
-0.1693155318,
0.3253151178,
0.1642203927,
0.650333941,
0.2169259638,
0.1847749799,
-0.1278992742,
0.1357428581,
-0.5696194172,
-0.9681320786,
0.6386659741,
-0.7475103736,
-0.8859927654,
-0.2919899821,
-0.5718584061,
-0.5130426288,
0.0986095518,
0.0114318756,
0.4488974512,
-0.1969335228,
0.0953600407,
1.1771377325,
-0.4237701297,
0.2349143177,
0.3861223161,
-0.0608201697,
-0.1300601363,
1.0370758772,
0.0034416951,
0.618819356,
0.39021945,
0.4651926756,
-0.2275939584,
-0.6012619734,
-0.3255767524,
0.2222469151,
-0.7008484006,
-0.0806558877,
-0.7108906507,
-0.5169690847,
-0.0089713372,
-0.1351366788,
-0.4718696773,
-0.5015181899,
0.012480149,
-0.0315910913,
0.6056989431,
0.5687192082,
0.0491976887,
0.4028798044,
-0.6902282238,
0.3122947514,
0.9819096923,
0.2417821735,
0.150119707,
-0.4444347024,
0.2494712919,
0.0243805461,
-0.0229216516,
-0.8009976149,
0.1582078934,
-0.0079310164,
0.6803955436,
0.3701379299,
0.2334132195,
0.4415145814,
-0.3012520075,
0.9020416141,
-0.1069590673,
-0.5131784081,
0.191935569,
-0.6159239411,
0.2655212581,
0.3611195087,
0.414552629,
-0.844040215,
-0.4628479779,
-0.7765446901,
-0.631898582,
0.4013548791,
0.3560084105,
0.4396918118,
0.0043771421,
0.1706784815,
0.0186885465,
0.1229255646,
-0.8324627876,
-0.0657564625,
-0.0904066339,
0.181656003,
0.0458832681,
-0.3772211671,
-0.2237753719,
0.2307822406,
0.6992048025,
0.0404615775,
0.356302619,
0.1049959138,
-0.0737588406,
0.4913598299,
0.7153574228,
0.4521609545,
0.5343213677,
-0.3301531374,
0.280269444,
0.5731867552,
-0.4294618964,
-0.2194446474,
0.0354542956,
0.0080872001,
-0.3270307779,
0.4523533881,
0.4361494482,
0.3022832572,
-0.8020517826,
0.7503839135,
0.0696040243,
-0.3714915812,
-0.341361016,
0.1732400805,
0.5580225587,
0.2917196155,
0.3019931018,
-0.0354072526,
-0.0763218924,
-0.1879448444,
0.1837144792,
0.5464048386,
-0.2505279779,
0.1996085644,
0.337169528,
0.2860803902,
-0.3214682341,
0.9261434674,
-0.0755434483,
-0.7518443465,
0.6929806471,
0.5915827751,
0.2490338683,
0.0801291168,
0.2460960448,
0.4473239183,
0.2376781702,
-0.0496097542,
0.0577121228,
-0.0540471859,
-1.045996666,
-0.5191373825,
-0.2028935552,
-0.6767308116,
0.1197077557,
-0.4860162139,
0.1243977547,
-0.2262494117,
0.2977749109,
-0.1271577179,
0.0336328186,
-0.6573628783,
0.0565191358,
-0.2465985417,
0.988062501,
-0.7097028494,
0.438829422,
0.406992197,
-0.2798958123,
-1.0622001886,
-0.1470355093,
0.1511570662,
-1.3022631407,
0.589810431,
-0.1320928037,
0.1727529019,
0.2606025338,
-0.6875962019,
-0.6646704674,
1.136072278,
-0.0029368727,
-0.521336019,
-0.0184674077,
0.0945561677,
0.4048971236,
0.3065557182,
0.3131480813,
0.425118953,
0.4615925252,
0.5758658648,
-1.1299220324,
-0.0723173246,
-0.2319881916,
-0.2481212765,
0.0246242378,
-0.816916883,
0.6627031565,
-0.3821288943,
-0.1395794898,
-0.0798656419,
0.5335034132,
0.457641691,
0.3043978214,
0.5033625364,
0.4498898983,
0.829144299,
-0.0539092198,
0.7653638124,
0.030617198,
0.3329776824,
1.1498688459,
0.1603436619,
0.9142293334,
0.5529559255,
-0.2606089115,
-0.1231929958,
0.355830282,
-0.0048051164,
0.2871214151,
0.3256275356,
-0.4644233882,
-0.4437168241,
0.18865183,
-0.4351694882,
0.3685768545,
0.3157718778,
0.0780981705,
-0.4499968588,
-0.0631463677,
0.3042906821,
-0.0740351602,
-0.3464231193,
0.9124977589,
0.2764137089,
-0.6694325805,
0.3995836079,
-0.3141371012,
0.514544487,
-0.5687103868,
-0.1124901846,
-0.4030931294,
0.0070803263,
-0.097494632,
-1.1670091152,
0.2358095646,
0.0099458685,
0.3591789901,
-0.1310061514,
0.8505854607,
-0.3580798805,
-0.3074949384,
-0.3192774653,
0.7949126959,
0.5059443116,
-0.1634807289,
-0.4986267686,
-0.360735178,
-0.0891894475,
-0.1347548217,
0.2694391906,
0.8167430758,
0.2616076171,
1.2307078838,
0.6141843796,
0.0855964422,
0.033747118,
-0.3141702414,
0.9781253338,
-0.3643082678,
-0.1367344111,
-0.578664124,
0.572706759,
-0.1526292562,
-0.3853870034,
0.6862202287,
0.3468543291,
0.6829092503,
-0.1571224779,
0.7311252356,
-0.163850531,
0.6096895337,
-0.7929159999,
0.7282416224,
-0.3512832522,
0.4867772758,
-0.1966506839,
-0.6160084009,
-0.167328313,
0.5717440844,
-0.6451539993,
0.0168118291,
0.4996042252,
1.1238195896,
-0.1241801232,
0.2173719406,
0.491709739,
0.1543722898,
0.3034882545,
0.8286796212,
1.1802601814,
-0.017603606,
0.9267115593,
-0.2645697594,
-0.140891403,
0.0631770641,
-0.922752738,
-0.9668704271,
-0.492774725,
-0.1493353099,
-0.148685649,
0.345043689,
0.8118904233,
0.3782866001,
-0.5854377747,
-0.0299570952,
-0.0485121198,
0.2941559553,
-0.2559025586,
-0.2509514093,
0.5871224999,
-0.6476043463,
-0.6715427041,
0.0195997022,
-0.17917867,
-0.0081963753,
0.012175505,
0.056949202,
0.0404514372,
-0.1704381704,
0.4936924875,
0.3892684877,
-0.4872342646,
-0.3401053846,
0.1281169206,
0.1508927941,
-0.0089721102,
0.834900856,
-0.4015223384,
0.2999035716,
0.3238402307,
0.7283116579,
0.3677019477,
0.1327427626,
0.5104831457,
-0.6000517607,
-0.1721686274,
0.4063909352,
0.2116689682,
0.2374735326,
-0.2858282626,
0.3844899237,
0.0933267847,
-0.7451473475,
-0.3630430698,
0.2715927064,
-1.24657166,
-0.2205989659,
1.5216519833,
-0.1968378723,
0.0924573839,
-0.4942590892,
-0.6019269824,
-0.1335877627,
-0.5105482936,
0.7741485834,
0.8042129874,
-0.0673537552,
-0.7100870013,
-0.9175124168,
0.6404836774,
0.2830457687,
-0.6309096217,
0.3306405544,
0.3206644654,
0.4717479348,
-0.0765048712,
0.8464953303,
-0.0502048768,
0.1997469813,
0.0767181516,
-0.3698410094,
-0.3983076513,
0.2598344982,
0.1345998645,
0.261154294,
0.4124644399,
-0.0231453553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16416v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16416v3 | Improving Large Language Models for Clinical Named Entity Recognition via Prompt Engineering | 2023-03-29T02:46:18 | 2024-01-25T04:02:23 | Yan Hu, Qingyu Chen, Jingcheng Du, Xueqing Peng, Vipina Kuttichi Keloth, Xu Zuo, Yujia Zhou, Zehan Li, Xiaoqian Jiang, Zhiyong Lu, Kirk Roberts, Hua Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Objective: This study quantifies the capabilities of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 for
clinical named entity recognition (NER) tasks and proposes task-specific
prompts to improve their performance. Materials and Methods: We evaluated these
models on two clinical NER tasks: (1) to extract medical problems, treatments,
and tests from clinical notes in the MTSamples corpus, following the 2010 i2b2
concept extraction shared task, and (2) identifying nervous system
disorder-related adverse events from safety reports in the vaccine adverse
event reporting system (VAERS). To improve the GPT models' performance, we
developed a clinical task-specific prompt framework that includes (1) baseline
prompts with task description and format specification, (2) annotation
guideline-based prompts, (3) error analysis-based instructions, and (4)
annotated samples for few-shot learning. We assessed each prompt's
effectiveness and compared the models to BioClinicalBERT. Results: Using
baseline prompts, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 achieved relaxed F1 scores of 0.634, 0.804
for MTSamples, and 0.301, 0.593 for VAERS. Additional prompt components
consistently improved model performance. When all four components were used,
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 achieved relaxed F1 socres of 0.794, 0.861 for MTSamples and
0.676, 0.736 for VAERS, demonstrating the effectiveness of our prompt
framework. Although these results trail BioClinicalBERT (F1 of 0.901 for the
MTSamples dataset and 0.802 for the VAERS), it is very promising considering
few training samples are needed. Conclusion: While direct application of GPT
models to clinical NER tasks falls short of optimal performance, our
task-specific prompt framework, incorporating medical knowledge and training
samples, significantly enhances GPT models' feasibility for potential clinical
applications. | [
-0.0953932554,
-0.616016686,
0.94890517,
0.2011528462,
-0.149046734,
-0.1843330562,
-0.1053021476,
-0.576133728,
0.0505598448,
0.3285079896,
-0.3421540856,
-0.5765995979,
-0.6617327929,
0.5699531436,
0.0719355494,
1.1367175579,
-0.1428477615,
0.4343551099,
0.0375488922,
0.1799983382,
-0.7875873446,
-0.5408322215,
-1.1430143118,
-0.1107019261,
0.6788698435,
0.2482489944,
0.1271582544,
0.4071961641,
0.9211171269,
0.2115128189,
-0.2166202068,
-0.1454190463,
-0.095738709,
0.2050854564,
-0.1615115553,
-0.106642969,
-0.6814962029,
0.0038188321,
0.4386310577,
0.5327791572,
-0.1692955196,
0.0173914544,
0.1006733626,
0.1498560011,
-0.3611097932,
0.3553032279,
-0.2603552639,
0.12053179,
-0.1328543574,
-0.3156968355,
-0.5475148559,
-0.1056208909,
0.4369356036,
-0.9246367812,
0.4547370374,
0.0015582233,
0.8367735744,
0.0326139294,
-0.400796324,
-0.3657843173,
-0.3372322619,
0.4777653515,
-0.7537929416,
0.1789317876,
0.4484979808,
0.4180557728,
-0.2768928409,
-0.8266413212,
-0.4102931619,
-0.4659639001,
-0.0847643241,
0.0919533595,
-0.3146270216,
0.5130434036,
0.8548827171,
-0.0029945374,
-0.8145850301,
0.3737127185,
-0.4936376214,
-0.3901295066,
0.2546905875,
0.5897403359,
0.354388833,
-0.3069618642,
-0.2990731299,
0.2514310777,
-0.6702963114,
0.2595127225,
-0.2135064006,
0.3436859846,
0.0559785031,
0.4506885707,
-0.3037872612,
0.5813253522,
0.1170860678,
-0.2431841046,
0.3607915044,
-0.2884930372,
-0.2984726429,
0.0213907082,
0.8224207163,
0.3564982712,
-0.0836239457,
-0.0328359567,
-0.2051933259,
-0.0376627557,
0.1777797192,
-1.1027971506,
-0.4499017894,
0.2604182363,
-0.4781521857,
-0.2406332046,
-0.3251285851,
-0.7182150483,
-0.617946744,
-0.4123039246,
0.3964446485,
-0.712059319,
-0.0498155653,
0.0357489027,
-0.2398310006,
0.2503625154,
0.692553401,
-0.8736987114,
0.2387892306,
0.5132256746,
0.8975263834,
-0.3293319046,
0.0453515127,
-0.7498599887,
0.0393678099,
-0.134171322,
0.8638857007,
-0.4838675857,
-0.5860168934,
-0.2361201793,
0.3137552142,
-0.3658738136,
-0.4988483787,
0.5149927139,
-0.303286612,
0.2002072781,
-0.5776020288,
-0.4906838536,
-0.1119433045,
0.3068374693,
-0.5906094909,
0.5723406672,
-0.0258528832,
-0.7081778049,
0.3573469818,
-0.8765339851,
-0.26417768,
0.4519921243,
-0.363548398,
-0.1721664667,
0.0410953164,
0.3562913835,
0.5898076892,
-0.5631850958,
0.4649969041,
-0.0258779861,
-0.1975530535,
0.0733787045,
-0.2518896461,
0.6256760955,
-0.0120969955,
-0.3734192848,
0.2248778939,
-0.8177685738,
-0.0027849879,
0.145085007,
-0.1618624032,
-0.0885534212,
-0.3717684746,
-0.0089588333,
0.3447783291,
-0.0704122931,
-0.5370967388,
0.2808207273,
-0.2581283152,
0.3558726907,
0.5554412007,
0.4111414254,
0.1110653132,
-0.1938203275,
0.9212011695,
0.1767265797,
0.0625767112,
-0.2419329584,
-0.6700252891,
-0.4613555372,
-0.602286458,
0.3236917853,
0.7836609483,
-0.8560106158,
-0.0071911211,
-0.1217713803,
-0.4155980945,
-0.3190897107,
-0.4536440969,
0.5299460292,
1.1644154787,
0.6835696101,
-0.1242077351,
-0.4211941659,
-0.8839673996,
-0.0715098828,
-0.0955308229,
-0.197518155,
0.1341622025,
0.6327671409,
-0.1742281318,
0.6695910692,
-0.4018341601,
-0.192519471,
-0.2906276882,
0.3005429804,
0.5013335943,
0.5897971392,
0.278737098,
-0.528529644,
-0.4080410004,
-0.0195246674,
-0.7314826846,
-0.1084254012,
0.039280612,
0.3779769838,
0.0084604369,
0.4134292006,
-0.83183676,
0.635887146,
0.02087529,
-0.3651696444,
0.688769877,
-0.2201290578,
0.3669424057,
-1.0239537954,
0.3375819027,
0.0350157842,
-0.1431087852,
-0.8588336706,
-0.2610456645,
0.0666811839,
-0.2698705494,
-0.5875508189,
0.7530678511,
-0.5622774959,
0.3788140714,
-0.2488615513,
-0.1853478402,
0.0219554678,
0.2736247182,
0.2436287999,
0.7337073088,
0.7112065554,
-0.6438629031,
0.1445378512,
0.2983829081,
-0.0941370949,
0.6260131001,
-0.9476789832,
0.0091320621,
-0.1760396361,
0.1855202168,
-0.7633085251,
-0.4698044658,
0.5371106267,
-0.4470916986,
0.5709442496,
-0.1559818834,
-0.3296828866,
-0.4298601151,
0.0190605,
0.3085022271,
0.4844424725,
-0.2447052002,
0.4929657578,
0.1387265772,
-0.6761716008,
-0.4268897772,
-0.4368612766,
0.132956624,
-0.2963452935,
-0.2366260439,
0.5235068798,
0.1008282453,
0.104859896,
-0.2342500836,
-0.0275971871,
-0.0275571104,
-0.0722331777,
0.2748056352,
0.4744230807,
-0.2450650036,
0.3291509449,
0.0320906825,
-0.3092809618,
0.064480558,
0.0118069015,
0.3096408844,
-0.0635880455,
-0.227607891,
-0.7893651724,
0.4596668184,
0.332650274,
-0.3294995129,
0.5197061896,
0.6503368616,
-0.7822251916,
0.2028643489,
-0.6084414721,
-0.3280843198,
-0.3895532489,
0.3683913052,
-0.5675802231,
-0.9524772763,
0.6031427383,
0.0629586354,
-0.2418855131,
0.5217678547,
0.4430007637,
-0.0268606003,
1.1549814939,
0.5205207467,
0.343172729,
0.3359321058,
-0.0363718718,
0.1086242571,
-0.9630571008,
-0.2637780607,
-0.4375334978,
-0.0225078054,
-0.363365829,
-0.4055930972,
0.6043809056,
0.0412952267,
-0.3133818209,
0.1698684841,
-0.6920323968,
0.3123969734,
0.3898925185,
0.2521088123,
0.0553511195,
-0.126865685,
-0.3489431143,
-0.2157195956,
-0.6522709131,
-0.6061271429,
1.0303634405,
0.4217213094,
0.2530887425,
-0.0205927286,
0.6337603927,
0.0071567618,
0.4837935269,
-0.717972219,
0.5718880892,
0.0995219275,
-0.4771678746,
-0.0804286152,
-0.3667953908,
-1.0407290459,
0.1395109147,
-0.0800828189,
-1.053357482,
0.4197798967,
0.1114713028,
-0.9623225927,
-0.0273043029,
-0.5760755539,
1.1457688808,
-0.0983188972,
-0.1279508621,
0.208741188,
-0.7760789394,
0.2102078944,
-0.0557859987,
-0.0623726621,
-0.161716029,
-0.1518219411,
0.7689114213,
-0.4099290967,
0.8373057842,
-0.3140899837,
0.162102446,
0.1965579242,
-0.1746463776,
0.6100960374,
0.3330445588,
-0.0425797738,
0.1847727895,
0.1808981746,
-0.2118038386,
-0.544542551,
0.5177404881,
-0.4227999747,
-0.715523243,
-0.7572125196,
-0.4045711756,
-0.2496635616,
0.2565763295,
0.5450626016,
0.733728528,
-0.1571923047,
-0.1626670808,
0.7645558715,
-0.4239645004,
0.4188650846,
0.8491222262,
0.0783195198,
-0.6278757453,
0.6906296611,
0.0183789451,
0.0566973723,
0.355997622,
-0.0738782808,
-0.2005347013,
-0.8200988173,
-0.3570803702,
0.3956102729,
-0.6247550249,
-0.4984025657,
-1.0155261755,
-0.1700230986,
-0.6695967913,
0.1327714771,
0.0467598997,
-0.2742660344,
-0.6357588172,
-0.2338802814,
0.4448642433,
0.5783817768,
0.0384781659,
0.3953600526,
-0.9314696193,
0.2047914118,
-0.1488735825,
0.1298094094,
-0.2897822559,
-0.5921260118,
0.0426387712,
-0.2313953638,
-0.2354401648,
-1.1901105642,
0.537997663,
-0.0150703844,
0.5196216106,
0.2336155772,
-0.2419407666,
0.7894803286,
-0.8464486599,
0.7982761264,
0.3386809528,
-0.7893341184,
0.8419215679,
-0.5465167761,
0.206396699,
0.6715012193,
0.6947106123,
-0.4759075344,
-0.0154849328,
-0.6127134562,
-0.7965894341,
0.7532149553,
0.111616388,
-0.4036591351,
-0.4697548151,
0.5260531306,
0.0688159838,
0.1443077475,
-0.5327730179,
0.0269649215,
0.2256650031,
-0.2029878348,
-0.1204546317,
-0.1784200221,
-0.0109621873,
-0.2154983133,
0.5302662849,
-0.2099267393,
0.5221887827,
0.5687915087,
0.1238499507,
0.169171527,
0.3878440261,
0.5694183707,
0.4867898822,
-0.0954963118,
-0.1039710566,
0.1921190768,
-0.68244946,
0.2114778906,
0.6603848934,
-0.1123059317,
0.247150287,
0.2608232498,
0.9214559197,
-0.0166159477,
-0.7042310238,
0.5280541778,
-0.1742578149,
-0.0816202462,
-0.1808822006,
0.0279304516,
-0.1846087575,
0.3179139197,
0.0263808146,
0.0024023284,
0.5453155637,
-0.0485791564,
0.2130273134,
0.2631568611,
-0.53108567,
-0.5124616027,
0.7700401545,
-0.0640460402,
-0.0567841269,
0.7412406802,
-0.4000920355,
-0.3133153617,
0.7610726953,
0.7034202218,
0.8102747202,
-0.5500092506,
0.3182312548,
0.6310373545,
0.0980507731,
-0.308442235,
0.5174142122,
0.1697695553,
-0.2961025238,
-0.3679812551,
-0.4229013324,
-0.3841871321,
0.2427587658,
-0.6854841113,
0.5859566331,
-0.543462038,
-0.6330982447,
0.2269560099,
-0.2417914867,
-0.8811053038,
0.3107223809,
0.0313272737,
0.829934597,
-0.5674163103,
0.5974536538,
0.927033484,
-0.7337142825,
-1.0303953886,
-0.3307129443,
0.1877908409,
-0.5140952468,
0.759944737,
0.4718755186,
0.613704741,
0.1549419016,
-0.215426445,
-0.9544953704,
1.2897167206,
0.180346027,
-0.6924786568,
-0.4498861134,
0.046342589,
0.6356327534,
-0.3406469524,
0.5556000471,
0.476982981,
0.2474337816,
0.0877092928,
-1.2369936705,
0.3357763886,
-0.405919075,
-0.0523277819,
0.2334030271,
-0.0062537212,
0.7456338406,
-0.5593631268,
-0.2227599025,
0.2902847826,
0.3360255659,
0.7191439271,
0.6494978666,
0.1072088331,
0.4101502597,
1.0097372532,
-0.1812175363,
1.129488945,
-0.1280914843,
0.1079954058,
1.0235513449,
-0.448377192,
0.6864255071,
0.4793495536,
-0.0263449643,
0.2798334658,
0.7159038186,
-0.0106908623,
0.4383223951,
0.266125679,
-0.3393532634,
-0.1523553431,
-0.3330667615,
-0.5999009013,
0.0115420446,
0.5419750214,
-0.5624272227,
-0.0830399469,
0.4969875813,
0.105110839,
-0.5702198148,
-0.2938349247,
0.8510789275,
0.2300020605,
-0.6824896336,
0.4743047953,
-0.1050631851,
0.1956294179,
-0.5514839292,
-0.2358158678,
0.0081684003,
0.1055979878,
0.0040619909,
-0.4021705091,
-0.0621157289,
0.1612315178,
-0.2860611677,
-0.058949437,
0.6191756725,
-0.2258825451,
-0.4133327901,
0.0290991347,
0.3748656809,
0.245239377,
-0.1476721466,
-0.6947025657,
-0.0871883556,
-0.1788102388,
-0.2769863904,
0.2460765839,
0.5236917138,
-0.2164643109,
0.4766109586,
0.5567023158,
0.2715459168,
-0.2044895738,
0.0923201144,
0.8499942422,
-0.8369453549,
-0.4149498641,
-0.7544775605,
0.6117649078,
-0.0891083479,
-0.4047698975,
0.5157259107,
0.3851108551,
0.3151391745,
-0.2499028295,
0.6732373238,
0.0267901514,
0.735625267,
-0.5647429228,
0.5002172589,
-0.1579352617,
0.2428524196,
-0.3096712828,
-0.6289144158,
-0.6146233082,
0.3411131203,
-0.6194753647,
0.0846799016,
0.9142118096,
0.8085933328,
0.1560476124,
0.1279700547,
0.1494491845,
0.2299509495,
0.5672678351,
0.8434407115,
0.7924028039,
-0.4405915141,
0.0993491933,
-0.1175008044,
-0.3070294559,
-0.0815042183,
-0.8463684916,
-0.9919760823,
-0.2855164707,
-0.5898147821,
-0.4182952642,
0.4074622989,
1.1053251028,
0.4157162905,
-0.9504879713,
0.3972912431,
-0.0927053764,
-0.3612768054,
-0.2224167734,
-0.1870480925,
0.5582863688,
-0.4601048231,
-0.4088246524,
0.5362777114,
0.3114855886,
0.3615635633,
0.393120259,
0.1003527418,
0.0958397165,
-0.3404915333,
0.5528490543,
0.3716349602,
-0.8008226752,
-0.0460452624,
0.2814581692,
-0.3366784453,
-0.0264050104,
0.7601491809,
-0.7787148952,
0.3998508453,
0.4170015454,
0.5817860961,
0.148835808,
-0.0553415567,
0.4829664826,
-0.2645647228,
-0.1035565138,
0.5900140405,
0.5377547741,
0.3379281163,
-0.4315314889,
0.4437873363,
0.4017282724,
-0.6674183011,
-0.7874461412,
0.00604707,
-1.099752903,
0.0899133235,
1.2068016529,
-0.2418742478,
-0.0436803475,
-0.2836894095,
-0.459318459,
0.1610958874,
-0.4729305506,
0.4023579061,
0.4963565171,
-0.4882246852,
-0.1986592114,
-1.0400072336,
0.7819540501,
0.3144044578,
-0.9048723578,
-0.3290533721,
0.6338849664,
0.3696788549,
-0.0450577103,
0.9519057274,
-0.2574789524,
0.6158277988,
-0.3025244772,
0.1977289021,
-0.082642667,
-0.261793524,
-0.7518984675,
0.1185170561,
-0.0821413174,
-0.1043132767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16406v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16406v1 | Hierarchical Video-Moment Retrieval and Step-Captioning | 2023-03-29T02:33:54 | 2023-03-29T02:33:54 | Abhay Zala, Jaemin Cho, Satwik Kottur, Xilun Chen, Barlas Oğuz, Yasher Mehdad, Mohit Bansal | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | There is growing interest in searching for information from large video
corpora. Prior works have studied relevant tasks, such as text-based video
retrieval, moment retrieval, video summarization, and video captioning in
isolation, without an end-to-end setup that can jointly search from video
corpora and generate summaries. Such an end-to-end setup would allow for many
interesting applications, e.g., a text-based search that finds a relevant video
from a video corpus, extracts the most relevant moment from that video, and
segments the moment into important steps with captions. To address this, we
present the HiREST (HIerarchical REtrieval and STep-captioning) dataset and
propose a new benchmark that covers hierarchical information retrieval and
visual/textual stepwise summarization from an instructional video corpus.
HiREST consists of 3.4K text-video pairs from an instructional video dataset,
where 1.1K videos have annotations of moment spans relevant to text query and
breakdown of each moment into key instruction steps with caption and timestamps
(totaling 8.6K step captions). Our hierarchical benchmark consists of video
retrieval, moment retrieval, and two novel moment segmentation and step
captioning tasks. In moment segmentation, models break down a video moment into
instruction steps and identify start-end boundaries. In step captioning, models
generate a textual summary for each step. We also present starting point
task-specific and end-to-end joint baseline models for our new benchmark. While
the baseline models show some promising results, there still exists large room
for future improvement by the community. Project website:
https://hirest-cvpr2023.github.io | [
-0.1481921971,
-0.6715701818,
0.4828876853,
0.1340564638,
-0.3516887724,
0.1318445355,
0.1331606209,
0.1232605577,
0.0345920473,
0.0711011142,
-0.5487627983,
-0.703933835,
-0.6856268048,
-0.1133992672,
-0.7679530382,
0.7566629648,
0.0842055753,
0.0332867131,
-0.3099287152,
-0.3194861114,
-0.4958848059,
-0.2509665787,
-0.37955001,
-0.0305583216,
0.4422760904,
0.6974127293,
0.7666463256,
0.8997215629,
0.8350743651,
0.2332786769,
-0.2308200151,
-0.120563373,
-0.1445932686,
0.031709902,
-0.057919953,
-0.0461420752,
-0.2465188801,
-0.1402273029,
0.9325375557,
0.7098044753,
-0.0434469357,
0.3891531229,
-0.1593922973,
0.8549248576,
-0.7985450029,
0.3021746576,
-0.4489756823,
0.390701741,
-0.0469723195,
-0.6846445799,
-0.1232304722,
-0.3325836957,
0.2154277414,
-0.4767256677,
0.6502421498,
-0.0382812358,
0.8928980827,
0.4815528989,
-0.3107991517,
-0.0291290898,
-0.2885258496,
0.6099129915,
-0.4017965794,
0.6457725167,
0.3127824664,
0.3730536997,
0.3389484584,
-0.544431448,
-0.2357652336,
-0.0624649785,
0.1262399554,
0.2214498222,
-0.2073414624,
-0.0026247662,
0.2787278891,
0.5602319241,
-0.7182485461,
0.0870129019,
-0.4481858313,
0.1769341081,
0.1106859371,
0.2575303614,
0.3152020276,
-0.7475105524,
-0.4432366788,
-0.4908806384,
-0.5865151882,
0.119972989,
0.1547393948,
0.3366575837,
-0.026441209,
0.9615881443,
-0.3583182395,
0.1972645968,
-0.0200482756,
-0.134688288,
0.2977385521,
-0.3000732958,
-0.5544007421,
-0.0251334589,
0.6652767658,
0.5714738965,
0.0451856554,
-0.1048138142,
-0.1387708038,
-0.2096886486,
0.3873175979,
-0.9012210369,
-0.2735953629,
0.0351507962,
-0.4303261936,
-0.2020591199,
0.1442910582,
-0.6073135138,
-0.1809072196,
-0.6476336718,
0.6483533382,
-0.5833670497,
0.1076750308,
-0.3741818368,
-0.2099602371,
0.5320692062,
0.2880572379,
-0.7523659468,
0.5393271446,
0.722330749,
1.2130576372,
-0.465084672,
-0.3987005651,
-1.0004512072,
-0.0594350398,
-0.446819514,
0.5709269047,
-0.2534904182,
-0.2104630172,
0.3528873324,
0.1276156455,
-0.2101461142,
-0.5865138769,
0.2148091346,
-0.6580398083,
-0.145100534,
-0.421754539,
-0.4683436453,
0.0673170611,
0.5602549314,
-0.8354978561,
1.3581899405,
-0.0324178897,
-0.9493842721,
0.4329319,
-0.5155643225,
-0.494710505,
-0.0750261769,
-0.5068519115,
-0.5066011548,
-0.0033388382,
0.4011298716,
0.4594447017,
-0.3115669489,
0.1965400726,
0.113809891,
-0.4409140944,
-0.0873857141,
-0.5696200728,
0.4822889566,
-0.0205118638,
-0.3485176563,
0.0927587748,
-0.5931403637,
-0.3497971594,
-0.2395099998,
-0.1520943642,
-0.1102321222,
0.1495399177,
-0.0115048802,
0.1562470794,
0.1516383737,
-0.2910099626,
-0.0814537108,
0.3013582826,
0.0987880155,
0.6033502221,
0.1002542302,
0.4360812306,
-0.0851830915,
0.6069555283,
0.16742374,
0.3226565123,
-0.6362984776,
-0.1204668134,
-0.4166615605,
-0.2114304751,
-0.1524613202,
0.4938049316,
-0.7140749693,
0.1189862266,
-0.4401749671,
-0.2960553765,
-0.4495437443,
-0.0781809166,
0.5087040663,
0.5886061192,
0.635848403,
-0.3020577729,
-0.4230845869,
-0.9822405577,
0.1172069982,
-0.2967844903,
-0.2446063459,
0.074663274,
0.5211040378,
0.1043532714,
0.8540501595,
-0.5086926818,
-0.3360410929,
0.0971015692,
0.4829826355,
0.1287045479,
0.1687889546,
0.1650375128,
-1.1616060734,
-0.4138685465,
0.0779990628,
-0.7111586332,
0.2003777623,
-0.0708860084,
0.1738961786,
-0.2391538322,
0.9058301449,
-0.3800012171,
0.3475078642,
0.3787126243,
-0.0544843972,
0.6660684347,
-0.2873786986,
0.7852162719,
-1.0674110651,
0.1037813798,
-0.0293618422,
-0.1821758002,
-0.1422218233,
-0.0391824469,
0.2051778436,
-0.1597107053,
-0.5614072084,
0.044999592,
-0.494060874,
-0.7971410751,
-0.0587129407,
0.3546852767,
-0.454841882,
0.6630465984,
0.2629276216,
0.9605574012,
0.6428610682,
-0.5059888959,
0.1171886325,
0.4672222435,
-0.2567431033,
0.9287122488,
-0.7379943132,
-0.2844911814,
-0.1413275003,
-0.1767451018,
-1.0160068274,
-0.4713807702,
-0.3596189618,
-0.6223086715,
0.0998805389,
-0.5828787684,
-0.621647656,
-0.0466892719,
-0.7445810437,
0.4967375696,
0.371989876,
-0.6592130065,
0.2312937528,
0.2889149785,
-0.5012316704,
-0.8569219708,
-0.3431370258,
0.0988991186,
-0.2352976799,
-0.4681907296,
0.6454472542,
-0.0609628819,
0.0581249632,
-0.0235112254,
-0.3940788805,
-0.2252136022,
-0.4834525585,
0.2380885035,
0.2628837526,
-0.0911682099,
-0.03263399,
0.1544777453,
0.0627272353,
0.0419616774,
-0.0888915882,
0.1389690489,
-0.1732555926,
-0.3752829134,
-0.1635071337,
0.4280817509,
0.7472269535,
-0.1306016147,
0.4331614375,
0.8918951154,
-0.4346783161,
0.1421194226,
-0.5265877843,
0.1574147344,
-0.3815184236,
0.6339903474,
-0.1141221896,
-0.7997230291,
0.3773910701,
0.1949601471,
0.1731543392,
0.3286111951,
0.4097526073,
-0.4085943401,
0.7027398944,
0.5240495205,
-0.0200004224,
0.8692556024,
-0.4439860284,
-0.2272088379,
-0.8071846962,
-0.2542024255,
-0.4565572441,
-0.0976097509,
-0.604711473,
-0.7757362127,
0.6954477429,
0.0767795295,
-0.3555589914,
0.7279719114,
-0.1713821888,
0.6020467281,
0.5775296092,
0.1383240223,
0.2596319616,
0.0563861802,
-0.0968850851,
-0.2882448137,
-0.4837875962,
-0.2939789891,
0.6933454871,
0.2563991547,
0.5261150002,
0.2204431891,
0.5668010116,
0.5563717484,
-0.2004441172,
-0.8616110086,
0.7006646991,
-0.4024956822,
-0.1940749288,
-0.563261807,
-0.5105159879,
-0.8357329369,
0.2598159611,
0.164286837,
-0.5900247693,
-0.1006965339,
0.0889748335,
-0.08229886,
0.2778259516,
-0.3156740367,
1.115591526,
0.1034863591,
-0.3760894239,
-0.1283876598,
-0.9507842064,
0.0283356197,
0.1729699522,
0.3616063297,
0.0792191699,
0.0032932865,
0.9312255383,
-0.4941393435,
0.6542662978,
-0.0159029495,
0.1681486964,
0.3602174819,
0.1052205712,
0.3194436729,
-0.097845152,
0.3618292809,
-0.3274406493,
0.0788544789,
-0.3888378441,
-0.3847007155,
0.48829934,
-0.6194575429,
-0.1408232749,
-0.2617051005,
-0.406591624,
-0.049633231,
0.0651684701,
0.2956115305,
0.6237847805,
-0.387175113,
0.5599932075,
0.9303328395,
-0.1054073572,
0.6103272438,
0.3002987206,
0.1352030337,
-0.7193281054,
0.8216446638,
-0.0917118639,
0.2185003459,
0.9048176408,
-0.0620346926,
-0.2960811853,
-0.6651206017,
-0.4444966614,
-0.0400506109,
-0.7786272168,
-0.4200633168,
-0.3299383521,
-0.2005705684,
-0.4134655297,
-0.2082664371,
-0.6972603798,
-0.2204431742,
-0.0030002221,
-0.4006699324,
0.213476792,
0.3778811693,
-0.020008944,
0.2958146036,
-0.8995945454,
0.6438509226,
0.3962433636,
0.3430366516,
-0.1971541643,
-0.7261051536,
-0.579251349,
-0.6357047558,
-0.44711712,
-0.8319396377,
0.4570694864,
0.0559949018,
0.3577675521,
0.1887775362,
-0.1836851388,
0.8824571371,
-0.7072492242,
0.8690799475,
0.3799951673,
-0.6890432239,
0.6224928498,
-0.4977609515,
0.5393972397,
0.7561821342,
0.6756834388,
-0.5870073438,
-0.1331314147,
-0.5418660045,
-1.1605656147,
0.6033530235,
0.6444921494,
-0.1390952766,
-0.172004655,
-0.0899854004,
-0.0365868136,
0.0897550732,
-0.4845018089,
-0.0313228592,
0.1147247553,
-0.1588012129,
0.2051254809,
0.052604109,
0.0669444427,
-0.0821724534,
0.5691317916,
-0.2103327811,
0.1542567313,
0.3035693169,
-0.4248908162,
-0.2848898172,
0.27529791,
-0.0460021123,
0.3618720174,
-0.4085211456,
0.0743534714,
0.2130451798,
-0.6176201105,
-0.0229656138,
0.3246098161,
-0.1461677104,
0.1469743997,
0.5849814415,
0.5466026068,
0.9523531199,
-0.7878834009,
0.8693585992,
0.2595467865,
-0.1994129568,
-0.5872591138,
-0.3332355022,
-0.2315609008,
0.5032857656,
0.6333559752,
-0.1709372997,
0.4971999526,
-0.6471503377,
0.4180060625,
0.1122011021,
-0.4543843567,
-0.4237765372,
0.6868611574,
-0.1792157888,
-0.3446407318,
0.645034194,
-0.0726210624,
-0.330255419,
0.6301928163,
-0.0435096771,
0.8675569892,
-0.191064015,
0.5333800912,
0.7553340793,
0.1256654263,
-0.3892099261,
0.0995004848,
-0.5239319801,
-0.170143351,
-0.4787373841,
-0.5306078792,
-0.6904370785,
-0.2038519979,
-1.018930316,
0.4456197023,
0.0521245785,
0.0501337573,
-0.0487379618,
-0.0605171062,
-0.7082842588,
0.4222472608,
0.0656595752,
0.7270524502,
-0.9412748218,
0.6007017493,
0.5673081875,
-0.6918486953,
-0.4759596288,
-0.1901674867,
0.0439851135,
-0.3539572954,
0.4733941853,
0.2103158832,
-0.095328778,
-0.4850320816,
-0.2951501012,
-0.7147746682,
1.5936006308,
0.0858153552,
-0.6074786186,
-0.6471320987,
0.1682176739,
0.4924735427,
-0.1202349812,
0.2722039521,
0.7291840315,
-0.0194434151,
0.5934568048,
-0.8179007173,
-0.3892592788,
-0.2056944817,
-0.1005631313,
0.2379184961,
-0.3171232939,
0.8666797876,
-0.2045157105,
0.049578283,
-0.0507072173,
0.7931723595,
0.3294169903,
0.713303566,
0.5248864889,
0.3573199213,
0.3136940002,
0.2219354808,
0.7449403405,
0.1641732156,
0.3655413687,
1.3746283054,
0.2900481224,
1.182564497,
0.6119276285,
-0.3389146626,
0.2766863406,
0.6026977301,
0.1002119035,
0.4256411195,
-0.1615419835,
-0.0997655839,
-0.077843383,
0.1226033866,
0.0868592262,
0.1517476588,
0.1598451436,
-0.3648043275,
-0.1530849189,
-0.109863326,
-0.1271886379,
0.090357244,
-0.346849829,
0.7839007378,
-0.1001217887,
-0.6296889186,
0.0698521212,
-0.3263654113,
0.3304145038,
-0.4100188315,
-0.06930466,
-0.3432415724,
-0.0819346458,
-0.1377217323,
-0.8245700598,
0.1395186484,
0.5874769688,
-0.1089832857,
-0.1578522772,
0.145200327,
-0.5264190435,
-0.3379701674,
0.2116900384,
0.3402869999,
0.3784734011,
-0.1535698026,
-0.4934763908,
0.0056978478,
-0.2612307668,
-0.2679868937,
0.2986950278,
0.6168612838,
-0.2143891603,
0.310452491,
0.1554022878,
-0.3057093322,
0.140696764,
0.4918951094,
0.7524940372,
-0.9245337248,
-0.3849720061,
-0.6164200902,
0.6133657098,
-0.1085709706,
-0.1814695895,
0.5622922182,
0.9539673328,
0.8853610158,
-0.0970621258,
0.3716742694,
-0.2242888212,
0.232935816,
-0.5721923113,
0.0195738003,
-0.6948328018,
0.0966828838,
-0.8532788754,
-1.1194432974,
-0.2300072908,
0.222819671,
-0.0655892193,
-0.0791101903,
0.8500630856,
0.7254408598,
-0.3867262304,
-0.08463718,
0.4621487558,
-0.0619509369,
0.3464106917,
0.2725474238,
0.544311285,
-0.7496983409,
1.0883682966,
-0.1740877479,
-0.2338401973,
-0.3026750684,
-0.899805963,
-0.7207705975,
-0.8060488105,
-0.6177712083,
0.1136068031,
0.2524893284,
1.0758792162,
0.7054213285,
-0.5398877263,
-0.3060937226,
-0.0553708225,
-0.2053684592,
-0.5057203174,
-0.2137192488,
0.7316100001,
-0.3825827539,
-0.6872597933,
0.5339028239,
0.3416253924,
-0.1479906291,
-0.0318947397,
-0.1263499558,
-0.1441453844,
-0.0540372021,
0.9504953623,
0.3516956866,
-0.3020108044,
-0.3468036354,
0.2806544006,
-0.0225514937,
0.364817977,
1.0446028709,
-0.5156129599,
0.3213656545,
0.5677863955,
0.5719469786,
1.0857787132,
0.1202380657,
0.1486977339,
-1.1584944725,
-0.2511440217,
0.1161084473,
0.4291132689,
0.5679486394,
0.0317358375,
0.7522260547,
0.0821172968,
-0.5402230024,
-0.6052838564,
-0.0776775107,
-1.3833739758,
0.0403863937,
0.8947098851,
-0.0808309913,
-0.0943098664,
0.3535395563,
-0.1633774787,
0.5183101892,
-0.2829251885,
0.7521418929,
0.5164656043,
-0.0390962809,
-0.3445674777,
-0.609965086,
0.1616057903,
0.3504118323,
-0.815664053,
0.3660863936,
0.728605628,
0.117665112,
0.0045312326,
0.597982049,
-0.4922437966,
0.7351242304,
0.0987251252,
-0.1742424518,
-0.0002478808,
-0.7078179717,
-0.2184706181,
0.3845998645,
-0.1217837036,
-0.4349152148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16352v1 | ChatGPT or academic scientist? Distinguishing authorship with over 99% accuracy using off-the-shelf machine learning tools | 2023-03-28T23:16:00 | 2023-03-28T23:16:00 | Heather Desaire, Aleesa E. Chua, Madeline Isom, Romana Jarosova, David Hua | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | ChatGPT has enabled access to AI-generated writing for the masses, and within
just a few months, this product has disrupted the knowledge economy, initiating
a culture shift in the way people work, learn, and write. The need to
discriminate human writing from AI is now both critical and urgent,
particularly in domains like higher education and academic writing, where AI
had not been a significant threat or contributor to authorship. Addressing this
need, we developed a method for discriminating text generated by ChatGPT from
(human) academic scientists, relying on prevalent and accessible supervised
classification methods. We focused on how a particular group of humans,
academic scientists, write differently than ChatGPT, and this targeted approach
led to the discovery of new features for discriminating (these) humans from AI;
as examples, scientists write long paragraphs and have a penchant for equivocal
language, frequently using words like but, however, and although. With a set of
20 features, including the aforementioned ones and others, we built a model
that assigned the author, as human or AI, at well over 99% accuracy, resulting
in 20 times fewer misclassified documents compared to the field-leading
approach. This strategy for discriminating a particular set of humans writing
from AI could be further adapted and developed by others with basic skills in
supervised classification, enabling access to many highly accurate and targeted
models for detecting AI usage in academic writing and beyond. | [
-0.0250451509,
-0.6770266294,
0.5489932895,
-0.0756496638,
0.1997603178,
0.6226489544,
-0.2985943258,
-0.7879348993,
0.0284864791,
0.4442324638,
-0.0931851715,
-0.5151733756,
-0.8582148552,
0.3521125317,
-0.4860014319,
1.2104182243,
0.2257226855,
0.1040299609,
-0.5653910637,
-0.0617760941,
0.0111988271,
-0.3580592871,
-0.6021960974,
-0.3175193667,
0.6226151586,
0.3641262054,
0.4198586047,
0.6622992754,
0.7875415683,
0.3498774767,
-0.0071174605,
0.1555166394,
-0.556080997,
-0.0933975056,
0.2939621508,
-0.5947551131,
-0.5043142438,
0.2958209813,
0.321324259,
0.65616256,
0.0021940786,
0.2458808422,
0.1686794013,
0.5859716535,
-0.5837355256,
0.4089602232,
-0.6422945261,
0.0673546121,
-0.3034751117,
-0.224237591,
-0.81549263,
-0.5351442099,
0.1204566807,
-0.8856985569,
0.650737524,
0.2399589568,
0.6431426406,
0.2424936742,
-0.2446332574,
-0.4267389774,
-0.6822344661,
0.658200562,
-0.4217838645,
0.1423747092,
0.2761065066,
0.0889658704,
-0.1300657988,
-0.9834063053,
-0.6461321115,
-0.4801185727,
0.0072117629,
0.1975548714,
-0.0920991153,
-0.0314912423,
0.3432728648,
-0.0129938098,
-0.7219980359,
0.2343474776,
-0.6463900208,
-0.2938117981,
0.8192260861,
-0.1639016867,
0.3804647923,
0.0849299654,
-0.1155052185,
-0.2583582699,
-0.7599462271,
0.1036896631,
0.4883988798,
0.2726082504,
0.3657186627,
0.5095973611,
-0.0943886861,
0.4827818573,
-0.036228247,
0.1143911034,
0.0764032528,
0.1790175289,
0.062138591,
0.385477066,
1.1411668062,
0.1426423192,
0.5046146512,
-0.1985383034,
0.0475225374,
0.1320871264,
0.3545046449,
-0.7169308662,
-0.7624253631,
-0.1314872056,
-0.3746179938,
-0.5035428405,
0.2436567992,
-0.5242795348,
-0.9483471513,
-0.0916174874,
0.2586005628,
-0.2816687524,
-0.0421490781,
-0.2544373572,
-0.3254291117,
0.0940411165,
0.3961355686,
-0.8839853406,
0.1592193693,
0.9173939824,
0.9338774681,
-0.2268181741,
-0.4604082704,
-0.4404916763,
-0.0867053568,
-0.3557158709,
0.8957563639,
-0.5497323871,
-0.4169438779,
-0.1514219493,
-0.4533577561,
-0.0792568177,
-0.3371137083,
0.4475797117,
-0.4800828695,
0.6442860365,
-0.0842674077,
-0.6655028462,
-0.0120484345,
-0.0447149202,
-0.4825338125,
0.8589808345,
0.1470194906,
-0.6735964417,
0.7433167696,
-1.0480908155,
-0.3528325558,
0.3847458363,
-0.1696337312,
-0.7776879072,
-0.1557975411,
0.1232591569,
0.4797041416,
-0.0672193542,
0.2806510925,
-0.3399293423,
-0.304521054,
0.5759484172,
-0.2599419355,
0.9385946393,
0.1866761595,
-0.2872430086,
0.1536082029,
-0.7380176187,
-0.057966955,
0.0972328261,
-0.2165981978,
-0.2044607401,
0.1754171848,
0.2371182293,
-0.0819881335,
0.1638432145,
-0.9138168097,
0.1480676979,
-0.104704313,
0.6280368567,
0.6896167994,
-0.1876168996,
0.3379716575,
-0.4408386648,
0.4089338183,
-0.5802279115,
-0.0658733249,
0.0291621238,
-0.8445023298,
-0.3262839019,
-0.6637548208,
0.489855051,
0.7485376596,
-0.2799061239,
0.6113028526,
-0.2803066671,
-0.7495287657,
-0.813775599,
0.0850667208,
0.4662682116,
0.7209393382,
0.3437919319,
-0.2364903092,
-0.2635010183,
-0.6956370473,
-0.5919474363,
-0.5254215002,
-0.3544248343,
0.0705612823,
0.5633137822,
-0.0731869191,
1.0027085543,
-0.7541790009,
-0.3156064153,
-0.1867751479,
0.5661132932,
-0.1650490612,
0.4639545679,
0.3114338517,
-0.8588168621,
-0.8331632018,
0.1823888719,
-0.8621422648,
-0.3497416973,
-0.2108502239,
-0.0376960672,
0.294385463,
0.6569616199,
-0.6991250515,
0.5569579601,
-0.0763170868,
-0.3818462789,
0.5486066341,
-0.196566537,
0.1489308923,
-0.786606431,
0.4826538563,
0.1737513095,
-0.2276242971,
-0.6214419007,
-0.0216357,
0.023769496,
-0.2112044543,
-0.0684365183,
0.3473255932,
-0.3421002328,
0.3529421687,
-0.3631983995,
0.0475390144,
-0.0842478499,
0.3193375766,
0.0807575136,
0.6775904894,
0.2297013402,
-0.1260695457,
0.136627093,
0.6206040382,
-0.2829928994,
0.7095558047,
-0.6801389456,
0.3612456322,
-0.0567761958,
0.3627644479,
-0.9702733755,
-0.3768093288,
0.2248110622,
-0.8669460416,
0.2401994765,
-0.0317891799,
-0.487262845,
-0.2119699866,
-0.169231683,
-0.0012793683,
0.6924715638,
-0.2152604759,
0.5505796075,
0.3545479476,
-0.5922985673,
-0.3834868073,
-0.4539336264,
0.3198105991,
-0.2163791955,
-0.5456368923,
0.3321936727,
0.0237441249,
-0.3061950207,
0.0500817224,
0.1496116817,
-0.3359403014,
0.3317202628,
0.3916597664,
0.361795783,
-0.1784318984,
-0.0098121148,
-0.1075032279,
-0.1785942167,
0.2077887654,
-0.0189513173,
0.2343535274,
0.0343137532,
-0.2810646296,
-0.5935544372,
0.3032974601,
0.6399348378,
-0.2222542614,
0.6972879171,
0.9128607512,
-0.0150182722,
-0.1726860851,
-0.321403712,
-0.2913277745,
-0.459280163,
0.5213771462,
0.1450339556,
-0.8294851184,
0.4060325921,
0.0821620375,
0.2140363306,
0.6270383596,
0.1725747436,
-0.3226843178,
0.8687351942,
0.8372612596,
-0.2835839689,
0.4718408287,
-0.0104409838,
0.4687390924,
-0.5376325846,
-0.239791289,
-0.8533306122,
-0.3013369441,
-0.8439428806,
0.1603792012,
0.4004818499,
-0.3313445151,
-0.2232692987,
0.1983060986,
-1.0614567995,
0.5936811566,
1.1011911631,
0.0887003094,
0.2180577517,
-0.1061534807,
0.4566988945,
0.0346992277,
-0.5458963513,
-0.8306897879,
1.3681226969,
0.1774391532,
0.416649133,
-0.1581003666,
0.668128252,
0.9617584944,
0.5326138139,
-0.5269428492,
0.6179032326,
-0.0617130734,
-0.6122217178,
-0.319418937,
-0.3980497718,
-0.8936693072,
-0.0018251967,
-0.4030593336,
-0.8162979484,
-0.0664433837,
0.1949132532,
-0.2568637431,
0.2843614221,
-0.8540220857,
1.0189785957,
-0.0947907493,
-0.1989756823,
-0.0615741424,
-0.9482893348,
-0.031836018,
-0.3169479072,
-0.0754206032,
0.0111167226,
0.2181236297,
1.0196216106,
-0.272993654,
1.0349951982,
-0.2196875811,
0.236742124,
0.3839551508,
-0.0181666836,
0.2827533185,
-0.1469893306,
-0.0942394063,
0.2774891853,
-0.0039770971,
-0.3787915111,
-0.3147242069,
0.3700868487,
-0.8918202519,
-0.4050136507,
-0.648345232,
-0.4478956759,
0.126429975,
0.3555705845,
0.5661153197,
0.1868011504,
-0.514323771,
0.3036260307,
0.4152292013,
0.0775645152,
0.3339799941,
0.3793286383,
0.1228689849,
-0.2676711977,
1.2291152477,
0.0177125856,
-0.0261815041,
0.4411715269,
0.165057376,
-0.1706738919,
-0.6684342027,
-0.3911632597,
0.0026312172,
-0.4924849868,
0.1263664812,
-0.7598963976,
-0.2600069046,
-0.6285024285,
-0.512283206,
-0.0521620885,
-0.4365782142,
-0.5457664132,
0.2115650177,
0.2282523513,
0.7516652942,
0.028559953,
0.541256249,
-0.6054064631,
0.1671500504,
0.1601623297,
-0.0513012819,
-0.3346582949,
-0.4402063489,
-0.014560245,
-0.0291885603,
-0.6001287699,
-0.5624650717,
0.4233244956,
0.4677852094,
0.3823101521,
0.417933166,
0.1415401995,
0.2424267083,
-0.4306688607,
0.6624721289,
-0.0344952233,
-0.8848791718,
0.2551687956,
-0.2575607896,
-0.0454196632,
0.6025364995,
0.4218964279,
-0.7367863655,
-0.6418955326,
-0.6688964963,
-0.8170927763,
0.5603423119,
0.3567974865,
-0.1583359838,
0.2478753924,
0.1938509345,
0.5286851525,
0.3072435856,
-0.7514265776,
0.2550944984,
-0.1398091763,
-0.5110294223,
-0.2187552154,
0.1104474217,
-0.0733375177,
-0.0568964668,
0.7863546014,
-0.1737867743,
0.4336494803,
0.2072906196,
-0.1537397206,
0.1792661548,
0.0968955383,
0.419350177,
0.6968349218,
-0.1840411276,
-0.0898356512,
-0.1378437579,
-0.8019068241,
-0.227816537,
0.4722861052,
-0.4795158207,
-0.2175996304,
0.8079102039,
0.4125521779,
-0.4152600467,
-0.6194900274,
0.5432356596,
0.085666731,
-0.3527576327,
-0.4218437076,
0.423478514,
-0.1555272192,
0.0791247413,
0.4967096448,
0.5115746856,
0.2811120749,
-0.2485548109,
0.1012472063,
0.4195681512,
-0.435949862,
-0.3826283216,
0.8380060792,
0.300067693,
-0.5432840586,
0.8015818596,
-0.2111049592,
-0.5481315255,
0.8131540418,
0.2935169339,
1.0542771816,
0.0140507994,
0.4374067783,
0.0410453044,
0.1463010609,
-0.147762686,
-0.0907922313,
-0.2123516351,
-0.5922152996,
-0.2067349255,
-0.26052019,
-0.776676774,
-0.2811440825,
-0.5597211719,
0.1935370266,
-0.5567876697,
-0.1426834762,
0.583881259,
0.0094644399,
-0.3441870809,
-0.0266430378,
-0.0220591556,
0.4071331024,
-1.0861833096,
0.3993111849,
0.7441034317,
-0.2202947736,
-0.2396398038,
0.0343341753,
0.2321461439,
-0.6455023885,
0.4340251684,
0.3886966705,
-0.1456502527,
0.2188304067,
-1.0717982054,
-0.3632301986,
0.8891995549,
0.1027692705,
-0.3353755176,
0.2735265791,
0.1665543467,
0.893196106,
-0.2803820074,
0.3116914332,
0.2440657616,
0.3258627355,
-0.0512072034,
-0.8385528326,
-0.1904855669,
-0.415907532,
-0.491709888,
0.2317924351,
-0.5849945545,
0.5593017936,
-0.2149125785,
-0.1687228233,
-0.003781548,
0.6293477416,
0.1629757285,
0.8377105594,
0.1622117758,
0.255330354,
1.2417603731,
-0.0424777046,
0.7977384925,
-0.1356379092,
0.1229237765,
0.9173120856,
-0.5672852397,
0.7382904291,
0.2549447715,
-0.261657536,
0.565156579,
0.442600131,
-0.4109471142,
0.3368908763,
0.1215753332,
-0.4695509076,
-0.1033260748,
-0.2215103507,
-0.2267210633,
0.632715404,
0.0932614282,
-0.395650059,
0.4261905253,
-0.0281245075,
0.3309676647,
0.3424130976,
0.0268401913,
0.8946193457,
-0.070418857,
-0.7868052721,
0.0587710328,
-0.1546859443,
0.4916090667,
-0.4155634046,
0.0135340616,
0.1496189982,
0.2820769548,
-0.2968830466,
-0.9566277266,
0.1425411701,
0.3042675257,
-0.1864703298,
-0.4063027501,
0.6749612689,
-0.3455496132,
-0.6793446541,
-0.268648684,
0.447103709,
0.2573661506,
-0.1779757589,
-0.3760894537,
-0.4604697824,
0.0473937206,
-0.0359068438,
0.0801360607,
0.3638600409,
-0.1221982315,
0.7393705845,
0.8918164372,
0.1421152949,
-0.1330125928,
-0.2172652632,
0.4975369871,
-0.5287210345,
-0.6164764166,
-0.9308982491,
0.3242893815,
-0.5535254478,
-0.6151553392,
0.6407366395,
0.7756118178,
0.7978605628,
-0.1463730633,
1.127482295,
-0.3502038717,
0.5244888067,
-0.1728090793,
1.259141922,
-0.2037906945,
-0.039474465,
-0.3347082734,
-0.835616529,
-0.6880467534,
0.5024969578,
-0.3813043535,
0.1172746271,
0.6691110134,
0.6718062162,
0.0778017342,
0.1886451989,
-0.001899785,
0.0380645394,
0.6556822658,
0.2662140131,
0.7771738172,
-0.0431942791,
0.6056844592,
-0.1438714564,
-0.3965443373,
-0.2248997986,
-0.8815581203,
-1.0176292658,
-0.5265350342,
-0.8109480739,
-0.1098454073,
-0.0169988777,
0.8406468034,
0.5912559032,
-0.8453070521,
-0.0160450805,
-0.16729711,
-0.0256533287,
-0.2069642842,
-0.1720239818,
0.6334395409,
0.0523471609,
-0.6060354114,
0.1433461159,
0.1877496094,
-0.228038609,
-0.0450809337,
0.0335106142,
0.032889884,
-0.1512350291,
0.3782280982,
0.5657197237,
-0.5115389228,
-0.2273606956,
0.157037437,
-0.2954517603,
0.1892377287,
0.6566398144,
-0.5227439404,
0.507314086,
0.58687222,
0.6799541712,
0.1866449118,
0.0987570509,
0.405832082,
-0.4330067337,
-0.1883097738,
0.443267107,
0.0955766737,
0.4943276644,
-0.57222718,
0.570094943,
0.4928000867,
-1.1781284809,
-0.7548058033,
-0.1469742656,
-1.0543355942,
-0.2204947919,
0.692311883,
-0.2475645244,
-0.2158637941,
-0.2359116822,
-0.5308611989,
0.3365117908,
-0.6795837879,
1.5081598759,
0.5241647363,
-0.315975368,
0.1287182868,
-0.3714019358,
0.5083311796,
0.2568461299,
-0.9324250221,
-0.012599933,
0.5976905227,
0.020430848,
0.338957727,
0.5640567541,
0.0909222662,
0.3620523214,
0.0099272905,
0.4514523745,
-0.2239745557,
-0.36870718,
0.1259959489,
0.4183571637,
0.1471808553,
-0.21235843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16342v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16342v2 | Language-Guided Audio-Visual Source Separation via Trimodal Consistency | 2023-03-28T22:45:40 | 2023-09-23T15:05:33 | Reuben Tan, Arijit Ray, Andrea Burns, Bryan A. Plummer, Justin Salamon, Oriol Nieto, Bryan Russell, Kate Saenko | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | We propose a self-supervised approach for learning to perform audio source
separation in videos based on natural language queries, using only unlabeled
video and audio pairs as training data. A key challenge in this task is
learning to associate the linguistic description of a sound-emitting object to
its visual features and the corresponding components of the audio waveform, all
without access to annotations during training. To overcome this challenge, we
adapt off-the-shelf vision-language foundation models to provide pseudo-target
supervision via two novel loss functions and encourage a stronger alignment
between the audio, visual and natural language modalities. During inference,
our approach can separate sounds given text, video and audio input, or given
text and audio input alone. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our
self-supervised approach on three audio-visual separation datasets, including
MUSIC, SOLOS and AudioSet, where we outperform state-of-the-art strongly
supervised approaches despite not using object detectors or text labels during
training. | [
-0.5179620981,
-0.6421866417,
0.4493155777,
0.101206392,
-0.2538827658,
-0.0413411222,
-0.4926478267,
-0.395344764,
0.3518675268,
0.7670751214,
-0.9019545317,
-0.5255445242,
-0.4254932106,
0.0453983657,
-0.6471349001,
0.9212308526,
-0.0408605672,
0.0347696096,
-0.073700048,
-0.2448892146,
-0.5804874301,
-0.292512387,
-0.2449863851,
0.177374512,
0.1454354376,
0.4233747721,
0.4213009477,
1.1001924276,
0.6895256042,
0.2587767243,
0.0264642853,
0.1728780866,
-0.0791907907,
0.0507617258,
-0.2284845114,
-0.0939122513,
0.1592580974,
0.2006788105,
0.5866840482,
0.6304087639,
-0.4869382679,
0.1369319558,
0.1480282843,
0.3925584853,
-0.6577274799,
0.0766563043,
-0.4785474837,
0.0605629571,
-0.2988756299,
-0.118442744,
-0.2295648605,
-0.0429994315,
0.1979208142,
-0.7720602751,
0.3064806461,
-0.2465848774,
0.9616125226,
0.6746988297,
-0.1210887358,
-0.2253775746,
-0.7639732957,
0.7846179605,
-0.2659098506,
0.7901709676,
0.8028919697,
0.4892597198,
0.1997180879,
-0.671820879,
-0.2922396362,
0.0335522704,
0.0602599755,
0.0921416506,
-0.1382007301,
0.2559453845,
0.0528597794,
0.3483656347,
-0.557620883,
-0.0356150642,
-0.5399717093,
-0.5269731283,
0.5561718941,
-0.387801975,
0.5171126127,
-0.4122166038,
-0.5293245912,
-0.1768550575,
-0.560598731,
-0.1681864113,
0.3452303112,
0.2952094972,
-0.2137913406,
0.5515269041,
-0.2218035609,
0.534183085,
0.2052360475,
-0.4745514989,
0.2048267871,
-0.5287809372,
-0.2422999293,
0.5469039083,
0.9693115354,
0.1252045929,
0.3216942847,
-0.1081458256,
-0.005678785,
0.0368970744,
0.0689835027,
-0.3742014766,
-0.7207195759,
-0.1734042913,
-0.4258806407,
0.0054400973,
0.0278002322,
-0.4310153723,
0.0321242735,
-0.6009753346,
0.5732376575,
-0.5073766708,
-0.3661895394,
-0.1684835255,
0.026788177,
0.1135907397,
0.003691412,
-1.1860399246,
0.4109129906,
0.1970341057,
0.7647752762,
-0.2452529967,
-0.1938616037,
-0.8561885357,
0.5969336033,
-0.3351081014,
0.6482442617,
-0.3456932902,
-0.1681920439,
-0.0237869509,
-0.1455172598,
0.1150236204,
-0.7750964165,
0.3813777864,
-0.0248526018,
0.4665875435,
-0.1825014949,
-0.5241267085,
-0.0968788117,
-0.1266795546,
-0.7351109385,
0.9454331994,
-0.063651301,
-0.4246392548,
0.5584267974,
-0.3109765947,
-0.5029588342,
-0.0950487852,
-0.6348105669,
-0.3299649954,
-0.1287080348,
0.64219594,
0.0389139019,
0.0012316183,
0.4853164256,
-0.3617649376,
-0.1423513144,
-0.20267573,
-0.6378811002,
0.6307043433,
0.2242844254,
-0.4454777241,
0.1562366933,
-1.104184866,
-0.2079684287,
-0.2774400413,
-0.0598933734,
-0.3165738285,
0.1228784993,
0.2419032007,
0.2172728628,
-0.0886135772,
-0.6217516065,
-0.0089611532,
-0.3558025658,
0.3051016927,
0.6008149981,
0.0950815827,
0.6214176416,
0.3590431213,
0.5172168612,
-0.1775145382,
0.1950974166,
-0.3317869604,
-0.0764112994,
-0.5445275903,
-0.8532592058,
0.0712477341,
0.4281961024,
-0.7232862115,
0.5608608723,
0.2829968631,
0.0809646547,
-0.6748675108,
0.7783570886,
0.5411986113,
0.8450514078,
0.6853203773,
-0.3916775584,
-0.8589884043,
-1.1083080769,
-0.003660972,
-0.1928524375,
-0.1016415507,
0.1624908149,
-0.1271467507,
0.034434896,
1.2125308514,
-0.579761982,
-1.03431952,
-0.1612240225,
0.0836648718,
0.0624959208,
0.5005002022,
0.5133216977,
-0.9599804878,
-0.3084216714,
-0.2065969706,
-0.9178450704,
-0.5063055754,
-0.0008685404,
-0.2019042224,
-0.2129564732,
0.9441747665,
-0.3832490444,
0.3798454404,
0.4129861891,
0.1411076337,
0.3629879355,
0.1706102043,
-0.1393561959,
-0.8361551166,
-0.3365345895,
0.2891764939,
-0.3299491107,
-0.4573111832,
-0.6415184736,
-0.0648088083,
0.1414820552,
-0.751383841,
0.2856161594,
-0.5487027168,
-0.1471683085,
-0.4044826925,
0.16288203,
0.1409719884,
0.4436071813,
0.6985058188,
0.5927039981,
0.9111722112,
-0.365065217,
0.3639252782,
0.3889164329,
-0.2419321686,
0.6432430148,
-0.4695541859,
-0.1637102664,
0.1590699404,
-0.0807927474,
-1.0431696177,
-0.2665880322,
0.4497452676,
-0.2323258072,
0.2869920135,
-0.4325287938,
-0.3062767982,
0.1201036051,
0.2126594335,
0.6483108401,
0.431830585,
-0.852909565,
0.4117922783,
0.3273035884,
-0.0289921872,
-0.2935837507,
-0.8682675362,
0.0381334201,
-0.4694106281,
-0.4992994964,
0.2071744353,
0.085865058,
-0.2038851231,
0.125308916,
-0.521618247,
-0.6206999421,
-0.2129041553,
0.2850724757,
0.2884557247,
-0.2050766498,
0.1959809065,
-0.0478444621,
0.0439484939,
0.1068242416,
-0.4685430229,
-0.0581800714,
0.1458999664,
-0.5503089428,
-0.5916438699,
0.3850360513,
-0.023868233,
-0.5103343725,
0.2549339533,
0.7443427444,
-0.2045489401,
-0.206246078,
-0.6888683438,
-0.2406934947,
-0.5393143892,
0.3219819963,
-0.2788530886,
-0.8705034256,
0.3425571024,
0.212648347,
-0.2568102777,
0.2643022239,
0.3381352723,
-0.6616157293,
0.9025626183,
0.799675405,
0.1004272625,
0.8650694489,
-0.255710125,
0.0344609246,
-0.5938008428,
-0.341928333,
-0.1168709323,
0.0671814159,
-0.3827482164,
-0.1712458879,
0.1290920228,
0.1816095859,
0.206035465,
0.4765002429,
-0.654622972,
0.6303198338,
0.7500149608,
0.0127031663,
0.2215045989,
0.2795253694,
0.0985522196,
-0.3353745341,
-0.5186406374,
-0.0903113857,
0.7619459033,
0.2648844719,
0.9113564491,
0.060148187,
1.045050025,
0.438698858,
-0.1142878756,
-0.7142303586,
0.3880621493,
-0.0985203162,
-0.6491203904,
-0.3988770247,
-0.5349342823,
-0.663425386,
0.3498884141,
0.1066009849,
-0.8304219842,
0.3143943548,
0.254160732,
-0.0746073574,
0.2110258937,
-0.7515182495,
0.9772117138,
-0.4509795308,
-0.3784130514,
0.1372849047,
-0.6818563342,
0.4077887833,
-0.0030771927,
0.4216557145,
-0.2055848539,
0.3070411086,
0.8072308898,
-0.5055894852,
0.6843930483,
-0.1110256687,
-0.0225268248,
0.7506286502,
0.113739185,
-0.2064348012,
-0.0506354235,
0.7740525603,
0.2598589361,
0.1406737864,
-0.1725815833,
-0.459962219,
0.3042898774,
-0.5982931256,
-0.5572589636,
-0.1795442402,
-0.4029797614,
-0.247247979,
0.4690627456,
0.2668970227,
0.5792769194,
-0.0834178403,
0.406269908,
0.6301856041,
0.1409650445,
0.7779520154,
0.425776422,
-0.2837462723,
-0.6644009948,
0.9702775478,
-0.0444776267,
0.2521742284,
0.2760646045,
0.1164700165,
-0.6536177397,
-0.4847834408,
-0.4378926456,
0.1018910259,
-0.7345264554,
0.0824726969,
-0.1669674814,
-0.0119600417,
-0.3190444112,
0.1386190355,
-0.7848243713,
-0.2081580609,
-0.4301966131,
-0.2757973373,
0.1108089462,
0.2970368862,
-0.2904213369,
0.3074732423,
-0.8530435562,
0.7792136669,
0.3859481812,
0.3580496907,
-0.7757450938,
-0.689066112,
-0.4133070409,
-0.212632373,
0.011803085,
-1.0383154154,
0.3993678987,
0.4587393701,
0.7046693563,
0.7147090435,
-0.0958975852,
0.7836347818,
-0.5413560271,
0.6107283235,
0.638143003,
-1.0385444164,
0.9123683572,
-0.4344366491,
0.1152060777,
0.6919789314,
0.0161309466,
-0.3364365995,
-0.3793374896,
-0.4676818848,
-0.6922729611,
0.7227998972,
0.4326413274,
-0.275478214,
-0.0951193273,
0.0891310573,
-0.1105730608,
0.1223555729,
-0.8049530983,
-0.1888185292,
-0.7060201764,
-0.4753727317,
0.0051944531,
0.0271771383,
-0.3701370656,
-0.1476584822,
0.3714713752,
-0.1993962526,
-0.5084443688,
0.3974121213,
-0.371480912,
-0.112319991,
0.1132191122,
0.202208057,
0.37879017,
-0.2528429627,
0.316390425,
-0.2757845819,
-0.5065870881,
0.4695616066,
0.0123712495,
-0.0752090663,
0.0996901616,
0.5334700346,
0.5361891389,
0.3662894368,
-0.8330488801,
0.5103245378,
0.1209552959,
-0.4923115373,
-0.3059014082,
0.0381972231,
-0.1120399162,
0.1178671718,
0.4463796318,
0.0477943234,
0.4436244071,
-0.2997428775,
0.6534433365,
0.1657082289,
-0.6714525223,
-0.1394970119,
0.76838094,
-0.0383901522,
-0.0614948869,
0.5083311796,
0.0092690857,
-0.030709926,
0.5021499395,
0.1956298649,
1.0741275549,
-0.1882972419,
0.2228837162,
0.0191612504,
0.4099368751,
-0.19331716,
-0.0253751818,
-0.5639560819,
-0.5167284608,
-0.734980762,
-0.4992103577,
-0.3698351681,
-0.0039100684,
-1.017418623,
0.2560818493,
-0.4291743934,
0.0440785773,
0.0197954085,
-0.5371869206,
-0.3635344207,
0.567691505,
0.6212133169,
0.5336587429,
-1.083080411,
0.9282035828,
0.4591941833,
-0.7873729467,
-1.0661902428,
-0.0643493459,
0.2028230131,
-0.2794969976,
0.6719247699,
0.1297392547,
-0.3754812181,
-0.4071853757,
-0.6113395095,
-1.2250560522,
0.5099916458,
0.6877521873,
-0.5417875648,
0.067629911,
0.0531024821,
0.4642443657,
-0.174101606,
-0.0545072481,
0.5890806913,
0.3151431978,
0.4714615345,
-0.8869073987,
-0.5454374552,
-0.0480291508,
-0.3771491349,
0.1238403469,
-0.4392501712,
0.322884649,
0.2414640039,
-0.2007447034,
-0.1764894724,
1.1582020521,
0.2460427135,
0.388695389,
0.6352776885,
0.5282737613,
0.2825756967,
-0.1566754431,
0.6697586179,
0.0731021687,
0.3001055419,
1.4797465801,
-0.0845386684,
0.5772693753,
0.747676909,
-0.1092914045,
0.3600835204,
0.6145492792,
-0.2456379235,
1.0282917023,
-0.1509650201,
0.0705009401,
-0.5761709809,
-0.4539428651,
-0.0780910775,
1.0722123384,
-0.095362328,
-0.3084501028,
-0.1795555651,
0.2992220819,
-0.4367508292,
0.422524482,
-0.1927851588,
0.8938908577,
0.0983518437,
-0.6099530458,
0.3879429102,
-0.5384221077,
0.402579397,
-0.6706842184,
-0.2355735898,
-0.0904546753,
0.0018423641,
-0.3964405954,
-0.6826941967,
0.4865998626,
0.0222806763,
-0.2572758496,
-0.3621280789,
0.5537597537,
-0.86956954,
-0.5336358547,
0.4104608595,
0.3665486276,
0.1043653488,
-0.06258028,
-0.3595900536,
0.0867159218,
0.1473302543,
-0.1232367307,
0.1796976775,
0.3051311076,
-0.050590761,
0.4400624931,
0.5380058885,
0.264744401,
0.3203122914,
0.3562270701,
0.4624502361,
-0.468010366,
-0.7213932872,
-0.7999838591,
0.0974253565,
0.039496284,
-0.0091924611,
0.7935544252,
0.6249756813,
1.0263712406,
0.1451519728,
0.5692227483,
0.1804793626,
0.4113512933,
-0.7560018301,
0.1997441798,
-0.5745499134,
0.2677847147,
-0.5611398816,
-1.1079977751,
-0.1957961172,
0.5649027228,
-0.2243538797,
0.0138881532,
0.5108006001,
0.5338064432,
-0.3253536522,
-0.0616163462,
0.4111971855,
-0.0962486789,
0.465688318,
0.2158253938,
1.0176924467,
0.0098975301,
1.1409761906,
-0.5811333656,
0.0783699751,
0.1642076969,
-0.6605206728,
-0.8185232282,
-0.4369126856,
-0.6162216067,
0.0755955055,
-0.0197640508,
0.6883339882,
1.2142819166,
-0.7617794871,
-0.229920432,
-0.1967880279,
0.038656503,
-0.3461073339,
-0.2372820824,
0.589328289,
0.0125569524,
-0.7086173296,
0.9821124673,
0.5942745805,
-0.0608246103,
-0.4053461254,
-0.0528412126,
-0.2095487416,
-0.1507116109,
0.0925700814,
0.6720793843,
-1.0755300522,
-0.3045072258,
-0.1101852432,
-0.0040487498,
0.426762104,
0.5082236528,
-0.6015619636,
0.8246275187,
0.2566073537,
0.4150378704,
0.7847371697,
0.2563664615,
0.4134452045,
-1.1543480158,
0.3783735931,
0.0717636123,
0.4298652709,
0.6668358445,
-0.1507882625,
0.5357539654,
0.396530509,
-0.1582514346,
-0.708725512,
0.2191831768,
-1.1701027155,
-0.1531363577,
1.1361573935,
-0.0051793023,
-0.2162733078,
0.0018715197,
-0.3859147131,
0.4596901536,
-0.3294187486,
0.4574981034,
0.6041277647,
-0.1852868795,
-0.6327697635,
-0.3628025353,
0.6567768455,
0.5404416919,
-0.5353524089,
-0.0443091132,
0.9178195,
0.4124370515,
0.1261966377,
0.4447183907,
-0.1228482276,
0.5013984442,
-0.177017957,
0.2282423824,
-0.1969617605,
-0.7045827508,
-0.4143770635,
0.3029067218,
-0.214115873,
-0.7658827305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16281v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16281v3 | A "Perspectival" Mirror of the Elephant: Investigating Language Bias on Google, ChatGPT, YouTube, and Wikipedia | 2023-03-28T19:49:58 | 2024-03-08T00:15:02 | Queenie Luo, Michael J. Puett, Michael D. Smith | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | Contrary to Google Search's mission of delivering information from "many
angles so you can form your own understanding of the world," we find that
Google and its most prominent returned results - Wikipedia and YouTube - simply
reflect a narrow set of culturally dominant views tied to the search language
for complex topics like "Buddhism," "Liberalism," "colonization," "Iran" and
"America." Simply stated, they present, to varying degrees, distinct
information across the same search in different languages, a phenomenon we call
language bias. This paper presents evidence and analysis of language bias and
discusses its larger social implications. We find that our online searches and
emerging tools like ChatGPT turn us into the proverbial blind person touching a
small portion of an elephant, ignorant of the existence of other cultural
perspectives. Language bias sets a strong yet invisible cultural barrier
online, where each language group thinks they can see other groups through
searches, but in fact, what they see is their own reflection. | [
-0.8946584463,
-0.714002192,
0.4339534938,
0.5592368841,
-0.1342492998,
0.1537437588,
-0.3043072522,
-0.5408841372,
0.7500303388,
0.4780238271,
-0.614669323,
-0.0063320361,
-0.9233917594,
0.0374592021,
-0.4841795862,
0.9445521832,
0.1422712058,
0.3197802603,
0.3811359107,
-0.335998863,
0.0985711589,
-0.410223037,
-0.2683370411,
-0.2277957946,
0.5280293226,
0.334983319,
0.9392072558,
0.4350395799,
0.247834906,
0.184595868,
0.1491672844,
-0.1484605521,
-0.642369628,
-0.2391241193,
-0.2508701682,
-0.3364216089,
0.1561558545,
0.4016485214,
0.526049614,
0.8318761587,
-0.0234223418,
0.2812563777,
0.3476605415,
0.5337978601,
-0.6020585895,
0.0172355045,
-0.8076502681,
0.1711605191,
-0.3348209262,
0.0611269102,
0.0634091571,
-0.4614563286,
0.3109475672,
-0.8081944585,
0.5891125202,
-0.2147386521,
1.1937687397,
0.1868472695,
-0.5723773241,
-0.3677467704,
-0.4145314693,
0.898342073,
-0.1569751352,
0.5686400533,
0.5197997093,
0.2590631247,
0.0644779131,
-0.4060618579,
-0.8009371161,
-0.0576735549,
0.0838614106,
0.1660594791,
0.1040331647,
-0.2399712503,
0.1299230754,
0.2969523668,
-0.4874977469,
-0.2940246165,
-0.2244005352,
-0.1935202181,
0.5552414656,
-0.511775136,
0.9277460575,
-0.1697749794,
-0.1709060669,
-0.0655976534,
-1.0504556894,
-0.4098615646,
0.5409982204,
0.0979559794,
0.2388856262,
0.402051419,
-0.0987868384,
0.2362817824,
-0.0119812042,
0.0868751481,
0.0589838922,
0.2347532064,
0.1555128843,
0.4201081991,
0.6498507857,
0.6325372458,
0.466047436,
0.0231409799,
0.0948724449,
0.3091992736,
0.27983886,
-0.5465830564,
-0.1236530244,
-0.3910201192,
-0.5964552164,
0.0219020508,
0.1171594262,
-0.8302242756,
-0.9448192716,
0.2159410417,
0.4150209129,
-0.0303428788,
-0.5035477877,
0.028887216,
-0.127062127,
0.2871279418,
0.3856694698,
-0.9619349241,
0.3582807481,
0.7785030007,
0.7175197601,
0.058380682,
-0.5879013538,
-0.2628038824,
0.0105005195,
-0.342284888,
0.7962660193,
-0.7763514519,
-0.5610567331,
0.3905490041,
0.1578303277,
0.4288725853,
-0.5278788209,
0.543815136,
-0.4909973145,
0.4837804437,
-0.7922901511,
0.0476041064,
-0.4044545293,
0.0382065326,
-0.6300062537,
0.5977912545,
-0.4826649129,
-0.8914443851,
0.8754931092,
-0.4966131449,
-0.489203155,
0.0610586144,
-0.6677549481,
-0.0728244632,
-0.059528973,
0.5244209766,
-0.059172444,
-0.1267165095,
-0.199185878,
-0.4423660636,
-0.3691867292,
0.0454407409,
-0.3423995972,
0.9757267833,
0.264718622,
-0.7699615359,
-0.6238296032,
-0.5012039542,
-0.5485972762,
0.3303393126,
-0.5798197389,
-0.8317534924,
0.3699062765,
0.0353082754,
0.1962278485,
0.3750609756,
-0.759919405,
0.1051922366,
-0.1785561293,
0.2378643602,
0.9022432566,
-0.1806503981,
0.4773922563,
-0.1100295112,
0.2828936279,
-0.0666551739,
0.1969360858,
0.2175334245,
-0.6921744347,
-0.854042232,
0.2514564991,
-0.125965029,
0.2313448191,
-0.4789139032,
-0.0623991676,
-0.1763670295,
-0.2841421068,
-1.05831182,
0.3087186515,
0.2742498219,
0.3546266854,
0.1056479886,
-0.7448269129,
-0.4678969383,
-1.2917555571,
-0.7929020524,
-0.1711844653,
-0.4133546948,
0.4064382911,
0.1736999005,
-0.1103331074,
0.5108490586,
-0.4888364077,
-0.6589860916,
0.1535500139,
0.0797533914,
0.1508352309,
0.1833781153,
0.3575854599,
-0.9693562984,
-0.6659326553,
0.0324762873,
-0.6843124628,
-0.4127522409,
0.0754961222,
-0.2267613113,
-0.0905006155,
0.1117314398,
-0.1484721452,
0.2042470723,
0.7351570129,
-0.254001826,
0.0245961174,
0.0600852333,
0.1052682027,
-0.7719900012,
-0.2185841054,
0.1612244397,
0.1724594533,
-0.251357466,
-0.079728052,
-0.2802865207,
0.155411467,
-0.2919770777,
0.4802955985,
-0.562163651,
-0.2424542457,
-0.3361924887,
0.4697958529,
-0.0999978334,
0.0765650272,
0.3250466287,
0.823584199,
0.4625449181,
-0.2463680953,
0.0073394417,
0.2389182597,
-0.5509955287,
0.3955073357,
-0.1972182691,
0.3250155151,
-0.2385395765,
0.3839318752,
-0.8705821037,
-0.158059746,
0.1249724478,
-0.4238887429,
0.0070415749,
-0.0982963815,
-0.3398679495,
-0.0452373847,
-0.3825149238,
0.3785363734,
0.4506776035,
-0.7852754593,
0.3199490905,
1.0795853138,
-0.3206973672,
-0.8416900039,
-0.8248520494,
0.2890284061,
-0.062002521,
-0.6259795427,
-0.0222871751,
0.2064087391,
-0.5956843495,
0.0406660177,
-0.2242245823,
-0.2762314081,
-0.1858303249,
0.2740143538,
-0.0622534342,
-0.125796631,
-0.0687882826,
-0.0776587799,
0.1954737306,
0.1318137199,
-0.4186929166,
0.5134807229,
0.0094860308,
-0.4978920221,
0.0441027246,
0.7020407319,
0.2252717167,
-0.1256602108,
0.3536990583,
0.3736338913,
-0.1718010455,
-0.0624754317,
-0.9480804801,
-0.4197729528,
-0.4761026502,
0.3891268969,
-0.1586069167,
-0.8595603108,
0.4357823431,
0.2649644315,
0.0353780724,
0.3656077683,
0.5974410772,
0.0661556423,
1.3995757103,
0.6780441403,
-0.3063223064,
0.6404342055,
0.0410239473,
0.3388618231,
-0.6206824183,
-0.0480636396,
-0.4886388183,
-0.3632778525,
-1.0997433662,
-0.0645659417,
0.3573840857,
-0.4754248857,
-0.4029951096,
-0.0452229418,
-0.858686924,
0.5427803993,
0.801242888,
-0.004830522,
0.4993073642,
0.0927212834,
-0.0855644345,
-0.44996804,
-0.5481808186,
-0.8214407563,
0.9580252767,
0.1698690951,
0.823599875,
0.0125902006,
0.4106760025,
0.1482986808,
0.5019664168,
-0.2542230785,
0.5242866874,
-0.0856409892,
-1.0382564068,
-0.164108187,
0.0712207183,
-1.0969244242,
0.5696026087,
0.2107650787,
-0.6603279114,
0.3142813444,
-0.0499835163,
0.3015852571,
0.3447638154,
-0.7436653972,
0.657800436,
-0.3970023096,
-0.6023426652,
-0.460175842,
-0.6397711635,
0.4327157736,
0.0116062304,
0.4944607317,
-0.1163989007,
-0.1846099943,
0.6946653724,
-0.3595045209,
0.6756827831,
-0.1518304497,
-0.1496927589,
0.2103093863,
0.2496186644,
0.1144992784,
0.1554370672,
0.270316273,
0.3533310294,
-0.1417649388,
-0.7489571571,
-0.2067787647,
0.9982957244,
-1.0814965963,
-0.8671233654,
-0.5633347034,
-0.1193222627,
-0.1808183193,
0.3404182792,
0.3531440496,
-0.2761970162,
-0.3442701995,
-0.3045421243,
0.6103090048,
-0.4180646241,
0.2115417272,
0.5361782312,
-0.4932794869,
0.0942269191,
0.9957488179,
0.3916555941,
-0.0268414803,
0.2018966675,
0.1345803738,
-0.291292578,
0.0585900694,
-0.2385672033,
0.5069274306,
-0.6572913527,
0.6090965867,
-0.4202073812,
0.1818284392,
-0.3019140959,
-0.1754397601,
-0.3768829107,
-0.1064564884,
0.1944076121,
-0.0396002084,
-0.1341539323,
0.9574543834,
-0.1775570512,
0.2564808726,
-0.3140222728,
0.1009057537,
0.947816968,
0.5329023004,
-0.1407929361,
-0.026422793,
-0.0520672835,
0.1392219365,
-0.4934866428,
-1.007404089,
0.1699015051,
0.105024673,
0.3773006499,
0.6965844035,
-0.2645654976,
0.5236711502,
-0.7702027559,
0.9578667283,
-0.0154302251,
-0.7038483024,
0.3837094307,
-0.3495251536,
0.1801829338,
0.3441301882,
0.5859012008,
-0.9903777242,
-0.7558039427,
-0.6470186114,
-0.722641468,
0.4711556435,
-0.0112032034,
0.515231967,
-0.0847731382,
-0.3260598779,
0.31859532,
0.3067393005,
-0.9174484611,
-0.1963148415,
-0.7726877332,
0.4687147141,
0.0961740166,
-0.1006057262,
-0.2542851865,
-0.114622578,
0.5959441662,
-0.0513377488,
0.1585315466,
0.352243185,
-0.2769644856,
-0.3700529337,
0.121492371,
0.4500717521,
0.782946527,
-0.0821553692,
0.4522340894,
0.2387209982,
-1.017685771,
-0.1828791052,
-0.1273725629,
-0.2411307096,
0.3918869197,
0.1333577782,
0.4614671171,
-0.1929901838,
-0.6661065817,
0.6170992851,
-0.0768014714,
0.0123094572,
-0.5255924463,
-0.345279783,
0.1105813831,
0.1589656472,
0.7522809505,
-0.4203623533,
0.2675777078,
-0.7356024384,
-0.0493649133,
0.6466872692,
-0.3267036378,
-0.5318750143,
0.9605345726,
0.1471278667,
-0.1486176848,
0.4077214897,
-0.0075326553,
-0.871719718,
0.2605590224,
0.2117021829,
0.9945414066,
-0.2963567972,
0.1594441235,
0.0600612909,
0.5061870217,
0.0554887913,
0.2686799169,
-0.1233312264,
-0.8757215142,
-0.4621443152,
-0.565658927,
-0.3043037355,
0.2840583622,
-0.2981645465,
0.2136622071,
-0.3661530614,
0.08269196,
0.0274006613,
0.0129830781,
-0.5765523314,
0.207522437,
0.334937036,
0.7498655319,
-0.9297949076,
0.745239079,
0.8276231289,
-0.5936622024,
-0.4685430229,
0.4940595925,
0.2914869785,
-1.2071013451,
0.8684731126,
0.0311647709,
-0.2980634272,
-0.4065469801,
-0.6986457705,
-0.642095089,
0.3369926214,
0.4351368248,
-0.1686079204,
-0.1717250943,
0.3035012782,
0.4599304795,
-0.126525268,
0.2029794753,
0.4489082992,
0.5724271536,
-0.5142409801,
-1.1419327259,
-0.0400204286,
-0.0052370247,
-0.019818414,
0.1787698567,
-1.0454326868,
0.6054540277,
0.1835176945,
-0.1818775088,
-0.6381579041,
0.1668019295,
-0.1698782891,
0.1656295806,
0.4575824738,
0.1336294562,
0.3282996416,
-0.0386208966,
0.9500592351,
-0.3101452291,
0.3105588257,
0.6456648111,
-0.2168780863,
0.6424739361,
0.7614398003,
-0.2981676161,
0.3848503232,
0.5043607354,
0.203889221,
0.7277271152,
0.2200476229,
-0.4071495235,
-0.094830364,
-0.3996193707,
-0.29045102,
0.3966307342,
0.2634220421,
-0.4048960805,
-0.3309966028,
0.0836514384,
0.4086304307,
0.2810589075,
-0.3151341975,
0.6415890455,
0.1972603947,
-0.7834203243,
0.4269904792,
-0.532240808,
0.7188441753,
-0.3100043237,
-0.0652583539,
-0.3045218289,
-0.008793232,
-0.3286966681,
-0.8997070193,
0.1294251829,
-0.0884440392,
0.1826909631,
-0.4230853617,
0.6678854227,
-0.2569490075,
-0.1100950316,
0.407458663,
0.4154246747,
0.3720883131,
-0.2527901828,
-0.549808979,
0.1223209575,
0.0933128223,
-0.3211199641,
0.5437533259,
0.4327039421,
-0.1423829943,
0.5444999933,
0.3266047239,
0.4050453007,
0.4361549616,
-0.1440643072,
0.6797311902,
-0.4267320037,
-0.3510968983,
-0.7460092306,
-0.0938896835,
-0.2098760009,
-0.2525789738,
0.9653141499,
0.7460131049,
1.2650623322,
0.1305559874,
1.2393529415,
0.0138648804,
0.716892004,
-0.0436165184,
1.2905813456,
-0.8356654644,
0.0990392566,
-0.5154256225,
-1.046733737,
-0.1833848804,
0.9872432351,
-0.5957064629,
-0.056564685,
0.5439372659,
0.6990642548,
-0.251591146,
0.0835377723,
0.1419756114,
0.4628496766,
0.178852573,
0.2888878584,
1.1237728596,
0.1199341938,
0.7782930136,
-0.2668646574,
-0.39860183,
-0.3263277709,
-0.647411406,
-0.4966454506,
-0.830783546,
-0.0901401341,
-0.4996085763,
0.0119316401,
0.7175930142,
0.5415346026,
-0.4840564728,
-0.5079647303,
0.1774070859,
0.2658778131,
-0.0779120326,
-0.1909637451,
0.4456110299,
-0.1942845583,
-1.105181694,
-0.1679809988,
0.3753932416,
-0.3527524471,
-0.7533652186,
0.0403298289,
-0.1854608357,
0.2043802738,
0.3681922853,
0.5283784866,
-0.8897131681,
-0.6089699268,
0.0229140259,
-0.2069774121,
0.3561111093,
0.7559019923,
-0.5511885881,
0.8726266623,
0.3876650929,
0.4374167919,
0.6693646312,
-0.254460752,
0.6301478744,
-0.3090628982,
0.1746935695,
0.3013971448,
0.2011373937,
0.4977164268,
0.0214452632,
0.4049586356,
0.2374658287,
-0.8216763735,
-0.7198585272,
0.4520229399,
-0.5258122683,
-0.2192672938,
1.0265059471,
0.2615819871,
-0.3255926669,
-0.1122644618,
-0.6574954391,
0.3922016919,
-0.4956356883,
1.5554893017,
1.0663247108,
-0.0010908537,
0.0274692737,
-0.9464896321,
0.6063352227,
0.6968929768,
-0.2237809449,
-0.4747417271,
0.4272132218,
0.5542265773,
0.3592891991,
0.4863949716,
-0.0247281659,
0.2053115964,
-0.0023054106,
0.1070856825,
0.846336484,
0.2087270617,
-0.205519706,
0.1011252552,
0.352085501,
-0.4123291969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16275v1 | Writing Assistants Should Model Social Factors of Language | 2023-03-28T19:38:57 | 2023-03-28T19:38:57 | Vivek Kulkarni, Vipul Raheja | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, I.2.7; K.4.2; H.5.0 | Intelligent writing assistants powered by large language models (LLMs) are
more popular today than ever before, but their further widespread adoption is
precluded by sub-optimal performance. In this position paper, we argue that a
major reason for this sub-optimal performance and adoption is a singular focus
on the information content of language while ignoring its social aspects. We
analyze the different dimensions of these social factors in the context of
writing assistants and propose their incorporation into building smarter, more
effective, and truly personalized writing assistants that would enrich the user
experience and contribute to increased user adoption. | [
-0.2321751565,
-0.6490104198,
1.027078867,
0.6046513915,
-0.0608287044,
0.4795943797,
-0.277422756,
-0.6476407051,
0.4962697327,
0.4861039221,
-0.3549457192,
-0.3619352579,
-0.8685445786,
0.4801609814,
-0.328700155,
0.7637553215,
0.2462246567,
-0.0609195754,
-0.6899843216,
-0.0394854806,
0.0886177719,
-0.704714179,
-0.7048006058,
-0.5863500834,
0.8137990236,
0.6204058528,
0.7838722467,
0.645344615,
0.4665096104,
0.4295011759,
0.0550769009,
0.2773602903,
-0.4027283192,
-0.0782117099,
0.0017741196,
-0.3858820796,
-0.7767755985,
0.0527064465,
0.5302630663,
0.8566132188,
0.1688646972,
0.0957217067,
0.0881808251,
0.6617250443,
-0.4086430073,
0.0928247422,
-0.2731830776,
-0.1795551926,
-0.0761627257,
-0.3335499167,
-0.4999696314,
-0.7561768293,
0.1851216704,
-0.827883184,
0.0826593116,
0.0979319811,
0.4710530043,
-0.0525397994,
-0.2761762142,
-0.5637344122,
-1.1423823833,
0.5350029469,
-0.5304662585,
0.2378197014,
0.5245631337,
-0.2000328451,
-0.1468946785,
-0.3813858628,
-0.7516146898,
-0.2301481664,
-0.0046277014,
-0.1736531556,
0.0019333325,
0.2929667532,
0.1807511151,
0.2512242198,
-0.1776632518,
0.2652552724,
-0.4055345654,
0.2983029187,
0.8777080178,
0.3637503684,
0.6788370013,
0.2234586626,
0.2641459703,
0.3586907089,
-0.6271567941,
0.1707327515,
0.7718343735,
0.1974907219,
-0.1446232051,
0.5482709408,
-0.2764464319,
0.3588005602,
-0.0533740968,
-0.3829862475,
0.1557555348,
-0.2929752171,
-0.0767892674,
0.0059359125,
0.6215025783,
0.2008719146,
0.8920297623,
-0.2060509622,
-0.2814763784,
0.0098164016,
0.3104147315,
-0.3940068185,
0.0387699939,
-0.0268258452,
-0.296869427,
-0.5719769001,
0.0358432494,
-0.4299348295,
-0.7573158145,
-0.5572026372,
0.1137242615,
0.0174321048,
-0.0920600742,
-0.0610422529,
-0.0965579003,
0.0100264326,
0.2833005786,
-1.1447179317,
0.6757430434,
0.8141402006,
0.7050172687,
-0.1603304595,
-0.4165939093,
-0.1106128097,
0.1838601381,
-0.4867539406,
0.9792535305,
-0.9027952552,
-0.6688395143,
0.3210428059,
-0.0543918237,
-0.0070784963,
-0.3760713041,
0.1642715782,
-0.3467055857,
0.0807846487,
-0.6467453837,
-0.5321844816,
0.0336602069,
-0.3312678039,
-0.4672759175,
0.7922837734,
0.1325184405,
-0.2077980936,
0.5141043663,
-0.8039173484,
-0.822794795,
0.1601834297,
0.0483135916,
-0.2733153105,
0.3368580937,
-0.0915277302,
0.7573879361,
-0.3099575639,
0.1679442972,
-0.5397326946,
-0.5592532158,
0.3389037848,
-0.1176374033,
0.5943214893,
-0.0353540331,
-0.1906316727,
0.1485122889,
-0.8965523243,
-0.5049828291,
0.1668401361,
-0.6125372648,
-0.3428737223,
0.0862416327,
-0.0512275733,
-0.2467116714,
0.3675602973,
-0.5262801051,
0.007317313,
-0.1811109036,
0.2088604271,
0.9840439558,
-0.1288775951,
0.8332899213,
-0.3620487452,
0.8196555376,
-0.3927473128,
0.3115537763,
0.3056945801,
-0.4029459655,
-0.6320442557,
-0.2606441379,
-0.0434881598,
0.4787823558,
-0.3293133974,
0.2733048499,
-0.1367237419,
-0.5170893669,
-0.5481203198,
0.8251184821,
0.4414555132,
0.2243593484,
-0.0674281344,
0.0076939338,
-0.4569505453,
-0.8712539077,
-0.5014841557,
-0.1920004338,
0.4073655903,
0.4020330608,
-0.0103642894,
-0.2590292096,
0.5842888355,
-0.4637268782,
-0.3206990659,
-1.0357540846,
-0.1230490506,
0.0533467531,
0.2158664465,
0.7017531395,
-0.6504516602,
-0.7376711369,
0.0115311444,
-0.8710484505,
-0.5966373086,
-0.1488119513,
0.0194423776,
0.3108329773,
0.5818679333,
-0.4950644076,
0.4064199626,
0.5941496491,
-0.3213713765,
0.4311648905,
-0.3315384388,
-0.1662296951,
-0.9928981662,
-0.057355769,
0.2924459279,
-0.1380873621,
-0.7028654814,
-0.1822946668,
-0.0922717005,
-0.1087100431,
-0.2823359072,
0.6108088493,
-0.7129178643,
-0.4121510386,
-0.221810326,
0.4810909629,
0.0805255845,
0.3922313452,
-0.2314036787,
0.7372635007,
0.2178173512,
-0.5586383343,
0.164578259,
-0.0379887372,
-0.1990782917,
0.476110816,
-1.0838624239,
0.12437547,
-0.3342013061,
-0.098623544,
-1.0476771593,
-0.4279738665,
-0.0962539166,
-0.3307930529,
0.3908883631,
0.5011057258,
-0.590020597,
-0.0647728071,
-0.4239520431,
-0.2237199247,
0.4520736337,
-0.1733132005,
0.8198847771,
0.6633743048,
-0.3723776639,
-0.3901410997,
-0.431186229,
0.0334624015,
0.1029107124,
-0.670789361,
0.0002054591,
-0.1586889178,
-0.5557310581,
0.1662531346,
0.4182472527,
0.2134566456,
0.1924384385,
0.4361796975,
0.3201815486,
-0.2904522121,
0.0857346877,
0.0977873206,
-0.1342726648,
-0.0421448536,
0.1991958022,
0.3383095562,
-0.0537533127,
-0.0814666003,
-0.5138233304,
0.415874213,
0.8052656651,
-0.0749469697,
0.896456182,
0.1848392934,
-0.1283181757,
-0.0556950495,
-0.7562730312,
0.1014817581,
-0.5184037685,
0.4602876306,
-0.2551306486,
-0.7300867438,
0.5586425662,
0.1378335357,
0.2160999924,
-0.0115316268,
0.3338790238,
-0.1735351384,
1.1265907288,
1.121250391,
-0.0873882547,
0.8882356286,
-0.0185300428,
0.4730303288,
-0.9841386676,
-0.3078738153,
-0.517506063,
-0.2450376153,
-0.4176011682,
0.0855461881,
0.0799219459,
-0.1939195991,
0.1072805971,
0.1203375086,
-0.3054155409,
0.4980298877,
0.5700468421,
-0.0513079539,
0.3352963328,
-0.1251539737,
-0.0555096753,
0.1777134836,
-0.5570511818,
-0.939406991,
0.971532166,
0.4500027001,
0.9509643912,
0.0002344898,
0.7043510675,
0.2979518771,
0.4013479352,
-0.5057201385,
0.8673274517,
-0.5485655665,
-0.2680143416,
-0.3890345693,
0.0814694688,
-0.7487185001,
0.0621025972,
-0.3222723603,
-0.7599086165,
0.3145014942,
0.2885742784,
-0.3942964673,
0.0428873226,
-1.1075335741,
0.6314699054,
0.0215235353,
-0.4161303639,
-0.0909558535,
-0.2329242676,
0.0647696033,
0.0793814287,
0.2601035535,
-0.2384804636,
-0.1844073087,
0.4911360145,
-0.3240352273,
1.0393218994,
0.0270241443,
0.2650903463,
0.115103282,
-0.0060552219,
0.6263440847,
-0.2056569606,
-0.2019940466,
-0.1483416259,
-0.2334512174,
-0.3636657596,
-0.7103731632,
0.7786269188,
-1.0156821012,
-0.8967460394,
-0.1610975564,
-0.4326122105,
-0.2847959995,
0.0219234135,
0.0342602395,
0.5164669752,
-0.1974315792,
0.4812256694,
0.6101115346,
-0.0885189399,
0.5055022836,
0.3904639482,
-0.1456548423,
-0.0324332006,
0.9203577638,
0.3756743073,
0.4632815123,
0.365486443,
0.3780936897,
-0.2978563011,
-0.4776180685,
-0.2810026109,
0.5782250762,
-0.8347327113,
0.3974452615,
-1.2773727179,
-0.0127507569,
-0.8278448582,
-0.7444903851,
0.0408041328,
-0.3036000729,
-0.8527265787,
-0.3548964858,
0.2514255345,
1.1331295967,
-0.1767013669,
0.5959904194,
-0.4922011495,
0.3597425818,
0.2329279035,
0.2718521953,
0.0288402215,
-0.2688287199,
-0.0754768625,
-0.5338028073,
0.008494365,
-0.6817244887,
-0.0491719283,
0.1716782004,
0.8677097559,
0.29100582,
-0.3046035171,
0.3677875102,
-0.1489151716,
0.5668278933,
-0.2146327645,
-0.7942738533,
0.363286674,
-0.2311316878,
0.266269505,
0.5757060051,
0.5743424892,
-0.4928665459,
-0.5591931939,
-0.4564804435,
-0.7363892794,
0.7059838176,
-0.130951494,
0.461571455,
0.1023788303,
0.4269662797,
0.0295516793,
0.2466371059,
-0.851680994,
-0.0610370003,
0.3205888569,
-0.3533506989,
-0.2944569588,
-0.7254265547,
0.4175335765,
-0.0927851498,
0.7395936251,
-0.106847994,
0.1704932451,
0.2651928067,
0.0642185435,
-0.2493947148,
-0.0095511889,
0.7794975042,
0.9897529483,
0.0673405975,
0.0246860217,
0.0158850085,
-0.7352048755,
0.0173080545,
-0.2921815813,
-0.4153147936,
-0.197994709,
0.5786361098,
0.5626351833,
0.2875183523,
-0.2497813404,
0.4312724769,
-0.0943344906,
-0.1447732449,
-0.5362343192,
0.5118729472,
0.3774214387,
0.1251621395,
0.2506524622,
0.0233975966,
0.0541587025,
-0.8573338389,
-0.3446442783,
0.4861760736,
-0.4169469476,
-0.4046076834,
0.3977831006,
0.5204116702,
-0.8357667923,
0.026421316,
-0.0901131555,
-0.5241822004,
0.5995803475,
0.4924142063,
1.0362868309,
-0.1969056427,
0.4104295373,
-0.1450371295,
0.5406198502,
0.0267277136,
0.4868964553,
-0.0809017494,
-0.567135334,
-0.011339359,
-0.6629654169,
-0.367790103,
-0.0835791752,
-0.2692260146,
0.3361907899,
-0.8757537603,
-0.0413867533,
0.246780023,
0.0711797997,
-0.7093652487,
0.3060359061,
-0.3635215461,
0.5696028471,
-0.7560490966,
0.5719026923,
0.7500606179,
-0.3403879702,
-0.5680627227,
-0.2166962773,
-0.0222531948,
-0.8865189552,
0.4023921788,
-0.244611606,
-0.4692412317,
-0.1034753025,
-0.4160726368,
-0.756560266,
0.7836300135,
0.2219842672,
-0.3880988955,
-0.1425401717,
0.3127068281,
0.7456752658,
-0.7868248224,
0.0909829959,
0.3495317101,
0.3429650664,
-0.0845315903,
-0.4123430848,
0.1541903764,
-0.2105575055,
0.3440797627,
-0.1326940954,
-0.7801148891,
0.4417336583,
-0.4774865508,
-0.0317624733,
-0.0057692463,
0.4321499467,
-0.0193411242,
0.4674062133,
0.2387616783,
-0.139791131,
0.5828905702,
0.1634297967,
1.3728836775,
-0.280864954,
-0.4227341115,
0.9474571943,
-0.3309730589,
0.6626724601,
0.4621331394,
-0.0437120534,
0.5993178487,
0.3020886481,
0.3859742582,
0.1825851351,
-0.0375633352,
-0.4857667685,
-0.1563484222,
-0.422563225,
0.0307837427,
0.3338795006,
0.3702419698,
-0.8046338558,
0.425098747,
-0.1982645392,
0.0878324583,
0.5345009565,
-0.0183182936,
1.0449718237,
0.1511456668,
-0.6338924766,
-0.2310579121,
-0.0884546936,
0.465213418,
-0.5840813518,
-0.038545154,
-0.3105596006,
0.0937966257,
-0.3722625971,
-0.7769680023,
0.274079144,
-0.0881649703,
-0.3107426167,
-0.4171846509,
1.1441344023,
-0.0251471195,
-0.6749128103,
0.4240054488,
0.4759124517,
0.0849195868,
0.2046927512,
-0.2958133221,
0.1957452148,
-0.2865295708,
-0.4266878963,
0.3042645156,
0.6472074389,
0.1782950461,
0.7138589025,
0.9474574327,
0.3080814481,
0.1015302539,
0.2679194212,
0.6429533362,
-0.4960515499,
-0.4888578951,
-0.9240025878,
0.3122763038,
-0.1936027259,
-0.7482671142,
0.7155999541,
0.2841966748,
0.4058477581,
0.0307506304,
0.8872523308,
0.18760176,
0.5120072365,
-0.1613852531,
0.7922942042,
-0.6787258983,
0.21623528,
-0.7312521338,
-1.1196177006,
-0.0688045472,
0.3956340253,
-0.479929179,
0.3581523597,
0.4985632002,
0.7843924761,
0.2288927734,
0.2441744804,
0.7636118531,
-0.0139533039,
0.3063160479,
0.2271899581,
0.7481375933,
0.0034804861,
0.2657207847,
-0.4750676751,
-0.4351086318,
-0.4990456104,
-0.8940604925,
-1.2156211138,
-0.58167243,
-0.1722752154,
-0.2328330129,
0.1541315466,
1.0346617699,
0.5292300582,
-0.3883537054,
-0.3926275671,
-0.0479729883,
0.578489542,
0.2915000319,
-0.2188793421,
-0.2565467358,
-0.2518133223,
-0.8318638802,
-0.0184457134,
0.8058871627,
0.1863600165,
-0.7032424212,
-0.0564120673,
-0.2430774719,
0.608645618,
0.8166341782,
0.2922190726,
-0.5206380486,
-0.1034961194,
0.4065077603,
-0.4325744212,
-0.2622272074,
0.8616985679,
-0.2884283066,
0.2469782084,
0.6233340502,
0.636928916,
0.0181376468,
-0.1391985416,
0.7847661376,
-0.4112919569,
-0.1473428905,
0.0164168775,
0.3533140719,
0.4781840742,
-1.0111840963,
0.5606434345,
0.4373633265,
-0.6368583441,
-0.7353653908,
-0.1270836294,
-0.5161408186,
-0.0620175339,
1.4027241468,
-0.0794131979,
-0.5522611141,
-0.3874962926,
-0.2047150433,
0.0364461392,
-0.5802051425,
0.8053981662,
0.822655201,
-0.3949088156,
-0.1729521304,
-0.402310133,
0.4883102179,
0.3855831027,
-0.8574079871,
-0.1089328378,
0.2802499831,
0.2387067527,
0.1991725564,
1.1966688633,
0.0907031223,
0.3756394088,
0.0814077109,
-0.1472882628,
-0.150084272,
-0.5891996026,
-0.0336682051,
0.0940751657,
0.4700577557,
0.3116838038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16256v1 | Scalable handwritten text recognition system for lexicographic sources of under-resourced languages and alphabets | 2023-03-28T19:06:27 | 2023-03-28T19:06:27 | Jan Idziak, Artjoms Šeļa, Michał Woźniak, Albert Leśniak, Joanna Byszuk, Maciej Eder | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | The paper discusses an approach to decipher large collections of handwritten
index cards of historical dictionaries. Our study provides a working solution
that reads the cards, and links their lemmas to a searchable list of dictionary
entries, for a large historical dictionary entitled the Dictionary of the 17th-
and 18th-century Polish, which comprizes 2.8 million index cards. We apply a
tailored handwritten text recognition (HTR) solution that involves (1) an
optimized detection model; (2) a recognition model to decipher the handwritten
content, designed as a spatial transformer network (STN) followed by
convolutional neural network (RCNN) with a connectionist temporal
classification layer (CTC), trained using a synthetic set of 500,000 generated
Polish words of different length; (3) a post-processing step using constrained
Word Beam Search (WBC): the predictions were matched against a list of
dictionary entries known in advance. Our model achieved the accuracy of 0.881
on the word level, which outperforms the base RCNN model. Within this study we
produced a set of 20,000 manually annotated index cards that can be used for
future benchmarks and transfer learning HTR applications. | [
-0.1972230077,
-0.3649360836,
0.650177002,
-0.0559390597,
-0.4705206752,
0.2676351666,
-0.2570874989,
-0.5669448376,
0.3925128281,
0.6349260807,
-0.4929798841,
-0.4171911776,
-0.6871542335,
0.3739847541,
-0.3340326548,
0.6932149529,
-0.1049323529,
-0.3293854892,
0.0580181777,
-0.205005005,
-0.0499763228,
-0.5217998028,
-0.1643502116,
-0.2979565263,
0.2420590669,
0.534948051,
0.5660980344,
0.8874694109,
0.9286587834,
0.4330985844,
-0.2485751957,
0.3770991564,
-0.1871248782,
0.0101539325,
-0.0758333281,
-0.1763844788,
-0.3257156312,
-0.0530429594,
0.5808233023,
0.4051838815,
-0.1819910109,
0.2438774109,
-0.0193401799,
0.6840109229,
-0.5430088043,
0.2612102628,
-0.7557252049,
0.1094083041,
-0.6666844487,
-0.2794663012,
-0.3849782646,
0.0419719517,
0.1063619554,
-0.7274814248,
0.3317893147,
0.0408515036,
0.60518682,
0.0966812819,
0.0620169677,
-0.8268840313,
-0.7035547495,
0.5682063699,
-0.4077611864,
0.1550663114,
0.5266295671,
0.4880340695,
-0.0062747621,
-0.8793568611,
-0.6492407918,
-0.1497150213,
-0.0960412249,
0.1550084651,
-0.0458817258,
-0.1748987138,
0.6269739866,
0.4528021216,
-0.4464791417,
-0.0066490741,
-0.3807236254,
-0.3261755109,
0.4229508638,
0.3302386701,
0.2637238801,
-0.2507246435,
-0.1860160083,
-0.1997598708,
-0.3021043539,
-0.15491952,
0.2956638336,
0.3704275489,
0.0120958053,
0.4425641894,
-0.0340183601,
0.6880449653,
-0.0179143082,
-0.2720967829,
0.376473546,
-0.6273584962,
-0.017522065,
-0.0233500637,
0.8405852318,
0.0281568207,
0.3081724346,
-0.0137799084,
-0.2755135,
-0.2083934247,
0.2702448368,
-0.6938286424,
-0.1838814169,
-0.3650892675,
-0.7591318488,
-0.1690129787,
0.0212431625,
-0.8658099174,
-0.3622863591,
-0.1425751895,
0.3503201008,
-0.1696723253,
-0.0550568476,
0.0240197144,
-0.2987294197,
-0.1068897098,
0.3324693143,
-1.2857669592,
0.1772564054,
0.3319218457,
1.0416514874,
-0.0078728674,
0.018041702,
-0.2582559884,
-0.0387168713,
-0.2275011092,
0.6688730121,
-0.393710196,
-0.6379355192,
0.059367016,
0.0062831389,
0.2212313414,
-0.4913770556,
0.5934268832,
-0.4120502174,
-0.1099862307,
-0.2288593799,
-0.2359289676,
0.3917398155,
0.3068053424,
-1.0611702204,
1.0222474337,
0.140198648,
-0.8461752534,
0.2346006334,
-0.2777499557,
-0.3786337674,
0.524379611,
-0.0982929692,
-0.5168364048,
0.1530796885,
0.2896514833,
0.4135913551,
-0.3173407018,
-0.1571992934,
-0.1573444903,
-0.58799541,
0.0065504177,
-0.508967936,
0.7663584948,
0.4607237577,
-0.3438669145,
-0.3269076943,
-1.3005517721,
-0.0318890512,
-0.0726360679,
-0.6786510944,
-0.6527771354,
0.0615933612,
0.4249917567,
0.2174307555,
0.6201387048,
-0.86130023,
0.2569844127,
-0.3839487433,
0.5584439039,
0.3438543081,
-0.3111985922,
0.3279434443,
-0.0344854705,
0.1270621419,
-0.0655872673,
0.0412728004,
-0.1004957408,
-0.0972412899,
-0.5635302663,
-0.2342844754,
0.1541558355,
0.4929125607,
-0.9479436278,
0.646756947,
-0.3799109161,
-0.7124380469,
-0.2273493558,
0.0901409239,
0.1607513428,
0.5214754939,
0.5008708239,
-0.0615725294,
-0.6056908965,
-0.9470566511,
-0.0231294353,
-0.193966046,
-0.1479302645,
0.3720159531,
0.5445769429,
-0.2074445337,
0.5196802616,
-0.3037833273,
-0.5036058426,
-0.0541335233,
0.2088995576,
0.4625919461,
0.2233060002,
0.2896576524,
-0.5367794037,
-0.8141799569,
0.3505418003,
-0.3717363775,
-0.1219320074,
-0.0829288587,
-0.0154933864,
0.092812188,
0.8762029409,
-0.0648870468,
0.3449809849,
0.3301915228,
-0.3007927239,
0.0801101029,
-0.7068714499,
-0.1641916633,
-1.0688381195,
0.220610112,
-0.1391420215,
-0.0126297101,
-0.3302913606,
-0.216656372,
0.4420939386,
-0.0365877151,
-0.1222871989,
0.4183560014,
-0.7776173353,
0.0370738767,
-0.3463687897,
0.0504001528,
-0.3414883912,
0.3500263989,
0.3726747036,
0.7281793952,
0.0460785404,
-0.0171540678,
0.3889588714,
0.1813115925,
-0.5752055645,
0.7187077403,
-0.391022563,
0.0888036937,
-0.1813140213,
-0.1853071153,
-1.0077632666,
0.2437603474,
-0.0945684165,
-0.1991846412,
0.386903435,
0.0959239304,
-0.5283710957,
-0.64221102,
0.0047885962,
0.1601835638,
0.617947638,
-0.740796864,
0.805252254,
0.4189593792,
0.2159799933,
-0.6105700731,
-0.7028725743,
0.1818959415,
0.0895414725,
-0.2604173422,
0.3981126249,
0.017369533,
-0.031050181,
-0.1038283706,
-0.0452011563,
-0.2262814045,
0.1070412174,
0.3022720516,
0.2758372426,
0.0895275623,
0.0877339765,
-0.1954931766,
-0.1209032983,
-0.1056877822,
-0.2633339167,
0.3511983454,
-0.1546984613,
0.0956510305,
-0.173595801,
0.1771294773,
0.8684298992,
-0.2011856139,
0.3638857603,
0.6380568147,
-0.3465275764,
-0.3019859493,
-0.4936551452,
0.2544422746,
-0.4851275086,
0.2525727153,
-0.362580061,
-0.75204283,
0.7288739085,
-0.0194551088,
-0.1834370941,
0.6081407666,
0.5913547277,
-0.1582076997,
0.4237886369,
0.5146329403,
-0.2489599138,
0.7202863097,
-0.2415704429,
-0.0327486098,
-0.6816475391,
-0.0099667311,
-0.6700362563,
-0.4045642614,
-0.749478519,
-0.1476822793,
0.325017035,
-0.2533763945,
0.1077869907,
0.4278210402,
-0.6513646841,
0.6335136294,
0.6576857567,
0.16834943,
0.286196053,
0.1480092853,
-0.3368165791,
0.1159876436,
-0.3993166387,
-0.4528000057,
1.2159472704,
0.2509607375,
0.6938260198,
-0.1077072546,
0.7890686393,
0.3072324693,
0.41664958,
-0.574565351,
0.4878119528,
-0.5617544055,
-0.5954199433,
-0.6423910856,
-0.16152668,
-0.7321993113,
0.1900071204,
-0.4311256707,
-0.4662765563,
0.4555503428,
0.0392954424,
-0.3056716323,
0.3498700857,
-0.2327230424,
0.6327640414,
-0.1599973589,
-0.3057170808,
-0.1709310114,
-0.6849675179,
-0.160236448,
-0.2242343575,
0.1986286193,
0.1117465496,
0.0463972911,
0.7360607386,
-0.8899375796,
0.5732049942,
-0.0898906663,
0.091197975,
0.3727391958,
-0.1251694709,
0.5669977069,
-0.386947751,
-0.1178958043,
0.4444634914,
0.2455734909,
-0.0557691976,
-0.35320279,
0.4079910517,
-0.6228312254,
-0.1077070832,
-0.444050014,
-0.512467742,
0.1693128794,
0.4985050857,
0.5686871409,
0.6575584412,
-0.2660051584,
0.2206613123,
0.3173233569,
0.1098108217,
0.8430302143,
0.4568520486,
0.4149985909,
-0.6144528985,
0.6550427079,
0.5597997308,
-0.0697432607,
0.5083693266,
0.2397167087,
-0.2816962898,
-0.7925329208,
-0.5941491127,
0.2570690513,
-0.5418115854,
-0.0881414711,
-0.182057336,
-0.1857854128,
0.0644991472,
-0.2087129951,
-0.1274883896,
-0.2099869102,
-0.5769555569,
0.1967374384,
0.1926106513,
0.6237978935,
-0.1181135252,
0.4111928642,
-0.8237441182,
0.116453886,
0.284155935,
0.5216926932,
0.1678870171,
-0.3084618449,
-0.4128484726,
-0.2374005467,
0.0684570521,
-0.6374697685,
0.5405262113,
0.1290894896,
0.3631071448,
0.2511606812,
0.0505439676,
0.48595348,
-0.8711563945,
0.300993979,
0.1072651744,
-0.9187495708,
0.2366664708,
-0.4786060452,
0.368766427,
0.8410137892,
0.3306839168,
-0.6453819275,
-0.1485997736,
-0.5168800354,
-0.5364364982,
0.6744499207,
-0.2218344957,
0.0468313023,
-0.3561055064,
0.5166902542,
-0.0937132463,
0.0835743546,
-0.4248047769,
-0.0140491938,
-0.1265760213,
-0.7494952083,
-0.1233602092,
-0.6474902034,
0.316845268,
-0.0780067965,
0.282874465,
-0.0229787901,
-0.0144994427,
0.2831019163,
-0.1959154159,
-0.072960861,
0.1580514908,
0.6003168821,
0.519171536,
-0.2835157216,
0.2340372503,
0.0282088723,
-1.2640858889,
0.2256664187,
-0.0092463614,
-0.308986187,
0.1266899109,
0.6731312275,
0.6357030272,
-0.0411094241,
-0.652133286,
0.5385833979,
-0.0571688935,
-0.3962226808,
-0.64780128,
-0.2684717774,
-0.1160365194,
0.3160897791,
0.4372783005,
-0.1013187617,
0.1790263653,
-0.3995571733,
0.0429034047,
0.6806122065,
-0.2449176311,
-0.0437218025,
0.34058249,
0.2391755879,
-0.6200774908,
0.8432292938,
0.027476253,
-0.4308995605,
0.5748072267,
0.464664489,
0.6066256166,
-0.2159847468,
-0.0154006165,
0.6612735987,
0.5154378414,
-0.4264419675,
0.3135966957,
-0.5996828675,
-0.7825865149,
-0.0402265936,
-0.4845793247,
-0.4690060019,
0.0506246313,
-0.6451381445,
0.137557894,
-0.630373776,
-0.2098928243,
0.002006612,
0.1738575101,
-0.722699821,
-0.0524916202,
0.0837617517,
0.7806913853,
-0.8386671543,
0.8580541611,
0.1432021707,
-0.3483662605,
-0.5795164704,
-0.2369337678,
-0.2728901803,
-0.8788635135,
1.1297880411,
-0.0368481576,
-0.0370558873,
0.1223017275,
-0.226722911,
-1.1286087036,
0.9881388545,
-0.2911052406,
-1.0996669531,
-0.0788609833,
0.2060122043,
0.9423143268,
0.03480893,
0.376380533,
0.5336764455,
0.3189370632,
0.2446374297,
-1.1610372066,
-0.1342256665,
-0.3320118785,
0.1352470368,
0.4880440831,
-0.3807747066,
0.7876880765,
0.101451613,
-0.4848324955,
0.2049143463,
0.4091678262,
-0.1307261288,
0.1670787632,
0.3799876869,
0.7345367074,
0.8047050238,
-0.0752875656,
0.676006794,
-0.1339043081,
0.2495595217,
0.6553925872,
-0.2210926861,
0.9623309374,
0.442774713,
-0.2803919315,
0.5205475092,
0.2278249264,
-0.2454068065,
0.614004612,
0.4645260274,
-0.2461322695,
-0.228335768,
0.1936279088,
0.0156524647,
0.413718015,
0.3676067889,
-0.5975794196,
-0.4266085029,
0.1796470284,
-0.3541691303,
0.2326963395,
-0.6761658192,
0.8240605593,
-0.1978394985,
-0.4643153846,
0.561553061,
-0.1370170861,
0.8684847951,
-0.4884843826,
-0.0144119412,
0.0057477462,
0.4293422401,
-0.1348386705,
-0.6889353991,
0.2826223075,
-0.1820361018,
-0.2483671457,
-0.3092971742,
0.7780834436,
-0.702665925,
-0.7719599009,
0.0158936419,
0.4032796919,
0.1737878174,
0.298012048,
-0.3851000667,
0.1380083561,
-0.257081598,
-0.0168100391,
0.14777942,
0.5899343491,
-0.1255380511,
0.2235735208,
0.4737573862,
0.3739572167,
-0.2717417777,
-0.1119136959,
0.4511271715,
-0.5371545553,
-0.8033723235,
-0.9020470977,
0.1100287065,
-0.2059328407,
-0.1879298687,
0.7346669436,
0.4260430932,
0.7314555645,
-0.2361938804,
0.5999651551,
0.3320587277,
0.8180239797,
-0.4217086434,
0.9187892675,
-0.396373719,
-0.0032864108,
-0.5027087331,
-0.6651147604,
-0.5042543411,
1.0478175879,
-0.2552615702,
-0.2486719787,
0.6765478849,
0.5342496037,
0.1160999611,
-0.2362123877,
0.2443750203,
-0.1840380877,
0.1969433129,
0.5967415571,
0.6158673167,
-0.3571241796,
0.4678399861,
-0.1869162321,
-0.169832021,
-0.273414135,
-0.9777379632,
-1.0032894611,
-0.9560293555,
0.0496319644,
-0.3182221651,
-0.1336124837,
0.694758296,
0.2124802023,
-0.4711701274,
-0.3397862911,
0.0033345041,
-0.0872979164,
-0.0925458148,
-0.0857533216,
0.6479619741,
0.0909070373,
-0.5831773877,
0.1208041012,
0.3988691866,
0.2345457673,
-0.1936666518,
0.2994648516,
0.0192820113,
-0.1561739445,
0.4732544124,
0.430198729,
-0.3435055614,
-0.3103137612,
0.0276200771,
-0.2788602114,
0.0678870082,
0.9066036344,
-0.6296705008,
0.5679425001,
0.7336235046,
0.6219667196,
0.6863241792,
-0.1530607194,
-0.1157209948,
-0.5103883147,
0.2950133979,
0.2155694962,
0.5875670314,
0.1490738988,
-0.4137851,
0.4212516546,
0.4499878883,
-0.4277310073,
-0.5386090875,
-0.0336628892,
-1.0076054335,
-0.1987750083,
0.735614121,
0.1526161581,
-0.5253508091,
-0.2641660571,
-0.2265220582,
-0.0798800513,
-0.0348048843,
0.7124595642,
1.0018984079,
0.1497961283,
-0.096037887,
-0.046936959,
0.4575381577,
-0.1869955063,
-0.6150599122,
0.3099424541,
0.7935958505,
0.2856124341,
0.5592757463,
1.0960685015,
-0.2985207438,
0.2146808803,
0.0846842751,
0.3244282603,
-0.5247926712,
-0.3152012229,
-0.3478836119,
0.2306604534,
0.0141470246,
-0.0812537521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16252v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16252v1 | Zero-Shot Generalizable End-to-End Task-Oriented Dialog System using Context Summarization and Domain Schema | 2023-03-28T18:56:31 | 2023-03-28T18:56:31 | Adib Mosharrof, M. H. Maqbool, A. B. Siddique | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Task-oriented dialog systems empower users to accomplish their goals by
facilitating intuitive and expressive natural language interactions.
State-of-the-art approaches in task-oriented dialog systems formulate the
problem as a conditional sequence generation task and fine-tune pre-trained
causal language models in the supervised setting. This requires labeled
training data for each new domain or task, and acquiring such data is
prohibitively laborious and expensive, thus making it a bottleneck for scaling
systems to a wide range of domains. To overcome this challenge, we introduce a
novel Zero-Shot generalizable end-to-end Task-oriented Dialog system, ZS-ToD,
that leverages domain schemas to allow for robust generalization to unseen
domains and exploits effective summarization of the dialog history. We employ
GPT-2 as a backbone model and introduce a two-step training process where the
goal of the first step is to learn the general structure of the dialog data and
the second step optimizes the response generation as well as intermediate
outputs, such as dialog state and system actions. As opposed to
state-of-the-art systems that are trained to fulfill certain intents in the
given domains and memorize task-specific conversational patterns, ZS-ToD learns
generic task-completion skills by comprehending domain semantics via domain
schemas and generalizing to unseen domains seamlessly. We conduct an extensive
experimental evaluation on SGD and SGD-X datasets that span up to 20 unique
domains and ZS-ToD outperforms state-of-the-art systems on key metrics, with an
improvement of +17% on joint goal accuracy and +5 on inform. Additionally, we
present a detailed ablation study to demonstrate the effectiveness of the
proposed components and training mechanism | [
-0.1630731374,
-0.9524483681,
0.586332202,
-0.3286671638,
-0.431592375,
-0.0144995851,
-0.2950663865,
-0.2261485904,
0.1047350392,
0.4698603749,
-0.7300333977,
-0.6749374866,
-0.4896008968,
-0.0148346229,
-0.1277214736,
1.443903923,
0.1653695703,
-0.2620669901,
-0.2378108501,
0.0245040972,
-0.4828700125,
-0.4654475749,
-0.6564259529,
-0.2814433873,
0.279396534,
0.4531566799,
0.3825537562,
0.3475241661,
0.2187953591,
0.193633616,
0.187671721,
0.0230971146,
-0.5290806293,
0.5300367475,
-0.2230517417,
-0.3082957268,
-0.7828384638,
-0.3849422634,
0.0828428566,
0.7299847603,
-0.1897767931,
0.1956339329,
0.0005494368,
0.297532022,
-0.5263869762,
0.3607132137,
-0.5428719521,
-0.0392873473,
-0.0844460726,
-0.5141308904,
-0.3613063395,
0.1425326914,
0.4886077344,
-0.7198411822,
0.3036984503,
-0.2863556445,
0.6881791949,
0.1155552119,
-0.6749404073,
-0.2813239098,
-0.6497540474,
0.8478932977,
-0.6779839396,
0.2512745559,
0.1533311605,
0.5124718547,
-0.0895855576,
-0.3858533204,
-0.4144771397,
0.1423313022,
0.1962942779,
0.3917325735,
-0.2502533197,
0.4065284431,
0.1306897551,
0.3459463418,
-0.9769462943,
-0.142542854,
-0.2509230077,
-0.2016471475,
0.2459082305,
0.3847182989,
0.3359970748,
0.0492043644,
-0.3356452286,
0.2816238105,
-0.6599189043,
0.0068469238,
-0.02585393,
0.5624455214,
-0.0766090602,
0.5247119069,
-0.8451370597,
1.0265151262,
0.1160557121,
-0.1984641701,
0.1270055324,
-0.4320466518,
-0.7261919975,
-0.255264461,
0.589502573,
0.6036533117,
0.1843452454,
-0.5579943061,
-0.0150332404,
0.1538609564,
0.283770293,
-0.8824692369,
0.2947209179,
0.4055150449,
-0.0752372965,
-0.2251663655,
-0.4104221165,
-0.3101148605,
0.2367832661,
-0.4947078228,
0.3266937435,
-0.3951125145,
-0.0267935097,
0.2159194946,
-0.1786317974,
0.1111619473,
0.7573060393,
-0.9643386006,
0.3568024933,
0.5908431411,
0.9044405222,
-0.1659271866,
-0.0366405845,
-0.5243958235,
0.5755722523,
-0.3483697772,
0.7094134092,
-0.5160713792,
-0.5165702105,
0.0596009977,
-0.0959657803,
-0.1100551561,
-0.2744401395,
0.3253946304,
-0.4449356496,
0.4373430908,
0.0110713979,
-0.5935811996,
-0.1855466813,
0.5050193667,
0.2093689293,
0.6403471231,
0.4437704682,
-0.3126502037,
0.3622792661,
-0.6998654008,
-0.4316577315,
0.24067837,
-0.2945024967,
-0.054794576,
0.1883629262,
-0.1199558154,
0.634914279,
-0.5259416103,
0.5006557703,
-0.0686908215,
-0.3176295459,
-0.3649712503,
-0.241823256,
0.6248198748,
0.0878255665,
-0.5186725259,
0.1681150943,
-0.5760529637,
0.0964874476,
0.0842204243,
-0.0582627654,
-0.2775108516,
-0.4102517068,
-0.3375191689,
0.3850514591,
0.2500552237,
-0.8254710436,
0.3619223833,
-0.1193779334,
0.2726546824,
0.4469091892,
0.1082092747,
0.4502769709,
-0.1583996266,
0.4331016839,
0.1212785691,
0.1807675213,
-0.6310332417,
-0.5345743895,
-0.6614621878,
-0.2009538412,
-0.1321047693,
0.6848865151,
-1.0060379505,
0.4999133348,
-0.4286836684,
-0.260363996,
0.2718179822,
-0.0636044219,
0.659725666,
0.8115673065,
0.227223143,
-0.5794096589,
-0.1657571048,
-0.828759253,
0.1147587672,
-0.0795451477,
-0.4947004914,
0.5692147017,
0.4012672603,
-0.0034632406,
1.1640768051,
-0.7321563363,
-0.6290338039,
-0.3731155396,
0.1757941395,
0.0282754097,
0.2656633854,
0.5738005042,
-0.3033605516,
-0.7312555909,
0.2203071266,
-0.8882585168,
-0.0442209616,
-0.068399325,
-0.0942689553,
0.2713917196,
0.1235311031,
-0.907998085,
0.6163552403,
0.0968943536,
-0.5389051437,
0.5750326514,
-0.1280747801,
0.0752335191,
-0.9716736674,
0.099579677,
-0.0646710768,
-0.2386829704,
-1.1685262918,
-0.2718578577,
-0.1451597661,
-0.2084529698,
-0.3474823236,
0.5376928449,
-0.3252555728,
-0.1483690739,
-0.3756587207,
0.1696153432,
0.0241292417,
1.2650331259,
0.1364773959,
0.718044579,
0.6623196006,
-0.5525584221,
0.180676952,
0.3536146581,
-0.0981400236,
1.064434886,
-0.6473842859,
0.1350767761,
-0.0966079235,
0.5039774776,
-0.8426737189,
-0.2702195048,
0.3809606433,
-0.6611841917,
0.2831703424,
-0.2437274754,
-0.0855835453,
-0.1052941829,
-0.0655103624,
0.1589813828,
0.4602163732,
0.0349037759,
0.5299924016,
0.1715268195,
-0.5078940988,
-0.6387987137,
-0.3040278256,
0.2536257803,
0.0201245937,
-0.3634583354,
0.2065175325,
-0.1094764173,
0.141528666,
-0.1519425511,
-0.3619606793,
-0.1610549241,
-0.1268884093,
0.3132540882,
0.2796015739,
-0.0053816889,
-0.0412017852,
0.2878676057,
-0.2321828604,
-0.1342991292,
-0.6610030532,
0.6435067654,
0.0346734487,
-0.3154796362,
-0.5330457091,
0.4923282564,
0.8747065663,
0.0743820593,
0.3494388759,
0.2273640484,
-0.3379044235,
-0.1763809025,
-0.2943322957,
-0.0669416562,
-0.3979224265,
0.3704832792,
-0.4720490575,
-0.9969684482,
0.4044340849,
-0.1639844328,
0.3969332874,
0.3014509678,
0.5728160143,
0.0525370017,
0.7804334164,
0.6766449809,
0.0145011451,
0.3759299517,
-0.3946584761,
0.3305378258,
-0.9229471087,
-0.21915856,
-0.2084223032,
0.0342425667,
0.2743991017,
-0.4695324302,
0.275197506,
0.0470259637,
-0.4225917757,
0.4628777206,
-0.3802192807,
0.2534833848,
0.5980226398,
-0.0075627649,
0.3663269281,
0.0577331707,
-0.0916526392,
0.1639766544,
-0.4691338539,
-0.3532729149,
1.3671532869,
0.0415681936,
0.189727053,
0.1219091117,
0.6151788831,
0.5328991413,
0.2900822163,
-0.8842132092,
0.5829051733,
-0.0586672984,
-0.4010684192,
-0.7455788255,
-0.2292876393,
-0.5325909853,
0.3485179842,
0.3150994778,
-1.054679513,
0.1306848377,
0.1465704143,
-0.5608497262,
0.2948498428,
-0.5347245336,
0.680942595,
0.0188766848,
-0.2694900334,
-0.0544488169,
-0.8123494983,
0.19431445,
0.0573360957,
-0.1401386708,
-0.3116343021,
0.1274756491,
0.4476807714,
-0.6479579806,
1.0547401905,
-0.4454186261,
-0.2958497703,
0.3685261607,
0.1274644434,
0.5370989442,
-0.1841901988,
0.2802940309,
0.3316041827,
-0.2249597758,
-0.4318199456,
-0.9204511642,
0.4270648062,
-0.3864365518,
-0.6867123246,
-0.1417541057,
-0.7196091413,
-0.5094320774,
0.3191455007,
0.2254647911,
0.7682021856,
-0.2952849567,
0.0802735165,
0.4514615536,
-0.0280027371,
0.2688221931,
0.820749402,
0.0610185005,
-0.3008458018,
1.0657894611,
0.0712001398,
0.6420667171,
0.3793305159,
-0.3840664327,
-0.1379773617,
-0.5455818176,
-0.9123387337,
-0.0740359649,
-0.3730199039,
-0.5641765594,
-0.889796555,
-0.1373588294,
-0.4560121894,
-0.439204514,
-0.0474403463,
-0.6081784964,
-0.1499144435,
-0.0900557861,
0.1349503994,
0.4808735251,
0.1721626371,
0.5823467374,
-0.6050707102,
0.3341935277,
0.4476232827,
0.4654490948,
0.0272199772,
-0.5730829835,
-0.2969144285,
0.282282114,
-0.4128112793,
-0.6432235837,
0.3773610592,
0.3270277679,
0.352519691,
0.6730927229,
0.078685917,
0.5418560505,
-0.7190577388,
0.9447284341,
0.4832597971,
-0.9110887051,
0.5759472847,
-0.8797729015,
0.4033833444,
0.4230070114,
0.0735478029,
-0.8675384521,
-0.4959927201,
-0.5279809833,
-0.7091103196,
0.9271107912,
0.2766231894,
0.1244813576,
-0.1802869886,
0.3364565969,
0.2988548577,
0.4068935812,
-0.0544430315,
-0.2854787707,
-0.248041302,
-0.1780501157,
0.0169246253,
-0.1882112622,
-0.305657059,
0.1312603951,
0.67139256,
-0.4472371042,
0.4315311015,
0.175079152,
-0.1714322269,
-0.0830465853,
0.535918951,
0.7497475147,
0.632989645,
-0.4020247459,
-0.3115977645,
-0.032597851,
-0.3892911673,
0.164866671,
-0.2335082889,
-0.379651159,
0.0689281374,
-0.0691870302,
0.9593505263,
0.136648193,
-0.7522293329,
0.6487900019,
0.0057364316,
-0.4487951994,
0.0086251078,
0.1024167612,
-0.1670960635,
0.179949984,
0.5714203119,
-0.0334184207,
0.3901205659,
-0.5097821355,
0.2208870947,
0.5244550705,
-0.4493017793,
-0.5263749957,
0.5701736808,
0.4468147159,
-0.2547370195,
0.3383390307,
-0.2587364316,
-0.3547405601,
0.541721046,
0.6659012437,
1.0036615133,
-0.1440649331,
0.6375092268,
0.0858230889,
-0.0649831146,
0.2453321964,
0.2556038201,
-0.7720021009,
-0.5792967081,
-0.4497078061,
-0.3180142939,
-0.7300473452,
0.0174216554,
-0.7707592249,
-0.1592395306,
-0.3095178902,
-0.2406003922,
-0.2733604908,
-0.139057681,
-0.5493370295,
0.4237766564,
-0.2792887688,
0.6100763083,
-0.7531980872,
0.6349421144,
0.4226734936,
-0.2122412771,
-0.1999132335,
-0.1803531647,
0.2103345394,
-0.6660907865,
0.7161599994,
0.0506409109,
-0.1331418753,
-0.0390262417,
-0.2030055076,
-0.822093606,
1.3641887903,
0.1526788771,
-0.5961608291,
-0.1636400372,
0.2446438968,
0.6353299022,
-0.5346295238,
0.2872600257,
0.5034654737,
-0.0376385003,
0.2932693064,
-1.1233016253,
0.0999788642,
-0.3875061274,
-0.0940664187,
0.2741978168,
-0.6424676776,
0.5710544586,
-0.299202323,
-0.4028317332,
0.0336832851,
0.4535939097,
0.0309392605,
0.5340245962,
0.3522587121,
0.659960568,
0.4443549216,
-0.2204942852,
0.7809944749,
-0.5686269999,
0.3186735809,
1.3756560087,
-0.4727753997,
0.4200998545,
0.2537921369,
0.0689083338,
0.2604844868,
0.3448815644,
0.2976981103,
0.6808426976,
0.0427868329,
-0.6037435532,
-0.1425914168,
-0.4773673713,
-0.2284719497,
0.2542356551,
0.6522061229,
-0.0421134308,
-0.5876713991,
0.1140787899,
0.0801570639,
-0.4374126792,
-0.0506199822,
0.907086134,
-0.1930302382,
-0.6005847454,
0.412997812,
-0.2437565029,
0.6805288792,
-0.8584086299,
-0.035783533,
-0.3119223118,
-0.1508471519,
0.0053656511,
-0.4798458517,
0.1920894235,
0.1583241224,
-0.1401202083,
-0.4088935554,
0.6542623639,
-0.5396872759,
0.0068818112,
0.0655891746,
0.7468563914,
0.2199067175,
-0.108322233,
-0.2351399809,
-0.2853583395,
0.172554329,
-0.3313229978,
0.4436049163,
0.4490139782,
-0.2087511271,
0.7094214559,
0.6783884764,
-0.0614943057,
-0.3345303833,
0.1876683235,
0.842171669,
-0.5637030602,
-0.559507668,
-0.3083498478,
0.4608151317,
-0.1977372915,
-0.4174130857,
0.5632799864,
0.5744400024,
0.839415133,
0.0424605459,
1.1716282368,
-0.0664314032,
0.6529161334,
-0.0643775091,
0.4125011861,
-0.3857918978,
0.0295285843,
-0.1344315261,
-0.7751733065,
-0.3763165772,
0.2189204246,
-0.1660377085,
0.0880139843,
0.3850353658,
0.4418472052,
0.1375333369,
-0.0300257094,
0.7151657939,
0.001385659,
0.5095341802,
0.6778025031,
0.3155269921,
-0.2829990983,
0.4371612966,
-0.0718039572,
-0.4679697156,
-0.2520236075,
-0.4101817608,
-0.8433431983,
-0.5316855907,
-0.1822021157,
0.0351956896,
0.4101829231,
0.5475432873,
0.6097803116,
-0.6432667375,
-0.1765993237,
-0.0830029175,
-0.2503445148,
-0.1725606471,
-0.2648355365,
0.2986359,
-0.5396530628,
-0.7833409309,
0.3282579482,
0.9773162007,
0.1332887262,
-0.0184544642,
-0.0331686288,
0.2783510685,
0.2086497992,
0.8677249551,
0.5595487356,
-0.762696147,
-0.3653021455,
0.2433661968,
-0.0394781083,
-0.0334351137,
1.0248100758,
-0.7170758247,
0.3982816041,
0.1648468971,
0.5041461587,
0.3839741647,
0.0055652987,
0.8005468249,
-0.7171595693,
-0.0084371725,
0.0180042386,
0.198665306,
0.0521056876,
-0.4495072067,
0.6355937719,
0.121247761,
-0.3673068583,
-0.6179552078,
0.3543706238,
-1.1287286282,
-0.2818296254,
0.7941743731,
-0.3768345118,
0.073569648,
-0.5599089265,
-0.1988973469,
0.2627252936,
-0.6639609337,
0.6769503355,
0.4521135986,
-0.4098966122,
0.2007949203,
-0.5131786466,
0.3994321823,
0.4363027215,
-0.8928154707,
0.3413587213,
0.7721387148,
0.3532019854,
0.1624990851,
1.089810729,
0.0324356928,
0.3221518397,
-0.1539355963,
0.0197585039,
-0.3058973849,
-0.5031536818,
-0.0935001671,
0.1007929593,
-0.7346610427,
-0.3263402283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16199v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16199v2 | LLaMA-Adapter: Efficient Fine-tuning of Language Models with Zero-init Attention | 2023-03-28T17:59:12 | 2023-06-14T17:31:32 | Renrui Zhang, Jiaming Han, Chris Liu, Peng Gao, Aojun Zhou, Xiangfei Hu, Shilin Yan, Pan Lu, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | We present LLaMA-Adapter, a lightweight adaption method to efficiently
fine-tune LLaMA into an instruction-following model. Using 52K self-instruct
demonstrations, LLaMA-Adapter only introduces 1.2M learnable parameters upon
the frozen LLaMA 7B model, and costs less than one hour for fine-tuning on 8
A100 GPUs. Specifically, we adopt a set of learnable adaption prompts, and
prepend them to the word tokens at higher transformer layers. Then, a
zero-initialized attention mechanism with zero gating is proposed, which
adaptively injects the new instructional cues into LLaMA, while effectively
preserves its pre-trained knowledge. With our efficient training, LLaMA-Adapter
can generate high-quality responses, comparable to Alpaca with fully fine-tuned
7B parameters. Besides language commands, our approach can be simply extended
to multi-modal instructions for learning image-conditioned LLaMA model, which
achieves superior reasoning performance on ScienceQA and COCO Caption
benchmarks. Furthermore, we also evaluate the zero-initialized attention
mechanism for fine-tuning other pre-trained models (ViT, RoBERTa) on
traditional vision and language tasks, demonstrating the superior
generalization capacity of our approach. Code is released at
https://github.com/OpenGVLab/LLaMA-Adapter. | [
-0.239997521,
-0.8104858398,
0.4757313132,
0.1797642708,
-0.5678730011,
-0.0358587019,
-0.2876876593,
-0.4184614122,
0.0488315374,
0.3794587255,
-0.4498634338,
-0.3207510412,
-0.5510571599,
-0.135663107,
-0.085597299,
1.0007596016,
0.0197672769,
-0.3090809286,
-0.141518712,
-0.2133367509,
-0.721771121,
-0.013048254,
-0.6020593047,
-0.1272509396,
0.4906430244,
0.8280623555,
0.4309802651,
0.8957427144,
0.3093987405,
0.203799963,
0.0210501887,
0.1026914418,
-0.826241672,
-0.1904674619,
-0.1344431043,
-0.5404112339,
-0.4836355746,
-0.1799157113,
0.3504443765,
0.3702547252,
-0.0744183064,
0.6555278301,
-0.0596332625,
0.4457921684,
-0.819863677,
0.2680903077,
-1.0094003677,
-0.1695837379,
0.0306720678,
-0.2897755802,
-0.345985949,
-0.1467111111,
-0.0908618867,
-0.8294765949,
0.2403001636,
0.0646228567,
0.8379858732,
0.8637278676,
0.114634037,
-0.0151611371,
-0.5177058578,
0.8211764097,
-0.7577303052,
0.3130743206,
0.1067536846,
0.250916779,
-0.0969407335,
-0.543933332,
-0.6270226836,
-0.437220186,
0.2423759997,
0.200320065,
-0.3099811375,
0.1343697757,
0.3098038435,
0.4565773606,
-0.2897937894,
0.2457761914,
-0.2630154788,
0.1373730451,
0.2494535148,
-0.0758233368,
0.3000819683,
0.2960567176,
-0.2913852632,
0.0463670567,
-0.8902483582,
0.1140320897,
0.1640957445,
0.1672021151,
-0.2927362919,
0.5104365349,
-0.5690484643,
0.9241538048,
0.5098742843,
-0.1123752147,
0.0213684775,
-0.1618100703,
-0.3369837999,
0.225446254,
0.5264453888,
0.3218196332,
0.3087222576,
-0.3171660006,
-0.132333234,
0.1736788154,
0.4156612456,
-0.9671387076,
-0.2079160362,
-0.1186181083,
-0.3686456382,
-0.3098424971,
-0.557071507,
-0.6093629599,
-0.1304794252,
-0.2083264738,
0.6236465573,
-0.1776863635,
0.1346800178,
0.3937686086,
0.3549956679,
0.5997007489,
0.5589210987,
-1.1530674696,
0.2969647944,
0.3102594316,
0.7922125459,
0.0252143331,
-0.2262375951,
-0.7032426,
0.2487273812,
-0.2449837178,
0.9712514281,
-0.5947856307,
-0.0781839415,
-0.507278502,
0.0296152253,
-0.140707925,
-0.3677840233,
0.4026687145,
-0.4406245351,
0.0707304701,
0.0619859286,
-0.2903242707,
-0.5071553588,
0.2471331805,
-0.3631154299,
0.8734657764,
0.0753242746,
-0.4916322231,
0.1270462722,
-0.9800118804,
-0.3394957185,
0.1851813346,
0.1922780573,
-0.1911023855,
0.2728864551,
0.5527645946,
0.473477155,
-0.4351436496,
-0.1653173119,
-0.3922685385,
-0.6606448889,
-0.1403115243,
-0.3675752282,
0.4451360404,
0.061288964,
-0.3748248219,
0.3544099331,
-1.0260156393,
-0.1598373801,
0.3633973897,
-0.2758323848,
-0.1231145933,
0.0471751504,
-0.2325693369,
-0.0692767873,
0.5455525517,
-0.5525864363,
0.3349808156,
-0.4965207875,
0.4942605197,
0.7586128712,
-0.147165969,
0.5091402531,
0.0771533325,
0.467287451,
-0.1538508683,
0.3151435852,
-0.5252630711,
-0.3553594947,
-1.2534576654,
-0.225837484,
0.1784050912,
0.5767399073,
-0.5446765423,
0.2194345295,
-0.2327738255,
-0.4474452138,
-0.9215849042,
0.3531532884,
0.4117082059,
0.7886175513,
0.4174462855,
-0.4105685353,
-0.1740816683,
-0.698849082,
0.0253437497,
-0.0166956224,
0.0125202173,
0.4213759899,
0.247131303,
-0.2012512237,
0.4747488499,
-0.5767018795,
-0.2572482824,
-0.1629558951,
-0.2737127542,
0.3331314623,
0.1790254861,
0.8393548727,
-0.1598065943,
-0.473829627,
0.3750026226,
-0.6245177984,
-0.0935167223,
-0.0787045136,
-0.1649089307,
0.0448813364,
0.559703052,
-0.3715774715,
0.1867236197,
0.6257102489,
-0.1368922144,
0.1645957232,
-0.2693343461,
-0.1849648058,
-0.9560228586,
0.0352213122,
-0.1133734733,
-0.1538838148,
-0.7082192302,
0.2177845687,
0.1644759625,
0.0271145049,
-0.4683190882,
0.5801309347,
-0.4221090078,
0.1136701033,
-0.5606827736,
0.028771786,
-0.2036875188,
0.888271451,
-0.1123234257,
0.935141325,
0.7592164874,
-0.6124689579,
0.1958906502,
0.1052207574,
-0.2464827746,
0.4051568806,
-0.9323483706,
0.5506336093,
-0.2415571362,
-0.063270174,
-0.9625628591,
-0.1664125472,
0.6178863049,
-0.221475333,
0.2418669909,
-0.3004436195,
-0.1845779866,
-0.1436005831,
-0.3736062646,
0.5248060226,
0.4243883193,
-0.8583682179,
0.6294938326,
0.0606547557,
-0.1926053911,
-0.584679544,
-0.327485621,
0.0913240016,
-0.1505978703,
-0.1016513482,
0.0545520149,
-0.418671459,
0.2138255835,
0.050418511,
-0.1374152601,
0.0838651434,
0.3029568493,
0.2602545023,
0.3896169662,
-0.407441169,
-0.1541414708,
0.1884917766,
-0.0899299458,
-0.3273302019,
-0.3392176926,
0.464037776,
-0.2690328062,
-0.2531872094,
-0.4989814758,
-0.1244326532,
0.7386960983,
-0.4273400307,
0.5215269923,
0.4337737858,
-0.2838277519,
-0.0364974625,
-0.6135632396,
-0.1015699804,
-0.48998034,
0.4190366566,
-0.2542117536,
-0.9008646011,
0.344697088,
-0.0473134033,
0.1025634632,
0.1783700138,
0.6675863266,
0.0620951019,
0.8001086712,
1.0473511219,
-0.414329648,
0.8402568698,
0.0051847366,
0.2303193659,
-0.8437869549,
-0.0916131064,
-0.2887233794,
-0.3493350148,
-0.2997416556,
-0.4386874139,
0.0913232341,
0.1712591648,
-0.2061505616,
0.338092804,
-0.711471498,
0.7431769967,
0.4279846251,
0.1907148659,
0.1182076782,
-0.094036907,
0.3177453876,
0.2294471115,
-0.7699628472,
-0.4221459925,
1.1480152607,
0.2845441699,
0.984916389,
-0.1741724759,
0.4362925291,
-0.0238727368,
0.4899184704,
-0.9213718176,
0.4694758654,
-0.0817418024,
-0.0440480374,
-0.2018665224,
-0.0833541825,
-0.6349481344,
0.1491381675,
-0.0652476475,
-0.8079286218,
0.1446786225,
0.4106763899,
-0.5547678471,
0.1752531826,
-0.8519738317,
0.8119633794,
-0.4536435008,
-0.2540223598,
-0.3029631674,
-0.5375233293,
0.382042557,
-0.1832739562,
0.0322835296,
-0.3005024791,
-0.2091306001,
0.5111438036,
0.192669332,
1.1229149103,
-0.1809121221,
-0.2909159958,
0.1515793204,
-0.017965652,
0.4085109234,
0.1057891846,
0.1415295899,
0.1456981301,
-0.272868067,
-0.4949343801,
-0.5727444887,
0.6905391812,
-1.0101613998,
-0.6443228722,
-0.0347125269,
-0.8169073462,
-0.0347228572,
0.3013943732,
-0.0927239582,
0.0367934443,
-0.1657527983,
0.0306665506,
0.795073092,
-0.2286236584,
0.4700716138,
0.8024159074,
0.0920397192,
-0.4400979578,
1.1563463211,
-0.1424683183,
0.3066938818,
0.5955574512,
0.0973547176,
0.0626355559,
-0.5993314385,
-0.8122672439,
0.339524895,
-0.5574384332,
-0.4884401858,
-0.4839257002,
-0.0544410236,
-0.0515155867,
-0.15382649,
-0.4914526045,
-0.3758520186,
-0.7209768295,
0.0311849825,
0.640706718,
0.5993533134,
0.3367069364,
0.7174666524,
-0.4545224607,
0.6235154867,
0.4798593521,
0.5193291903,
0.1509814411,
-1.0186749697,
-0.383446008,
-0.0736603364,
-0.3943160176,
-0.5608356595,
0.0990678594,
0.6065495014,
0.6155353785,
0.666572094,
-0.0986666977,
0.8875914216,
-0.6500330567,
0.5023037195,
0.0837808177,
-0.9975610971,
0.6559533477,
-0.2346463352,
0.5010931492,
0.4114819765,
0.0989121199,
-0.2406738549,
-0.2614627182,
-0.2411233187,
-0.6972234845,
0.7721575499,
-0.2895941436,
0.4486745894,
0.1364686042,
0.7229291201,
0.1989792138,
0.0389560238,
-0.7605829239,
-0.1059732586,
-0.4813309014,
-0.2662022412,
-0.274391979,
-0.3565537632,
-0.0294480752,
-0.3755467236,
0.4932840466,
-0.6700305343,
0.217164129,
-0.1278873682,
-0.3625948131,
-0.3363639116,
0.1532354951,
0.8748073578,
0.3503465354,
-0.1659709364,
0.0292558242,
0.7309206128,
-0.5649505854,
0.1058132872,
0.1276028156,
-0.3785835505,
-0.4999502003,
0.1172177419,
1.21667099,
0.5359780192,
-0.5222719908,
0.2840854526,
-0.2579366863,
-0.0338762328,
0.2586357892,
0.3506214619,
0.1194797233,
0.2865542173,
0.073633045,
0.1538132727,
-0.0369404107,
-0.3186888695,
-0.2344483137,
0.4986759126,
-0.3432299793,
-0.5523579121,
0.9750213027,
0.0583654754,
-0.1203879416,
0.2368855923,
0.0262354352,
-0.2241075486,
0.472916007,
0.8262156844,
0.8237064481,
-0.3147190809,
0.071066007,
0.2711821496,
0.4216586053,
0.0398113653,
0.2383787483,
-0.3178842664,
-0.6512995362,
-0.6086528897,
-0.665091455,
-0.5292080045,
0.0572779775,
-0.4984520078,
0.3006040156,
-0.7230163217,
0.2872397006,
-0.1938279271,
-0.1935176551,
-0.6848831177,
0.1471431553,
0.2595125735,
0.8807335496,
-0.6858468056,
0.906450212,
0.75559026,
-0.4004533291,
-0.5960912108,
-0.0429155044,
-0.4662989974,
-1.1822913885,
0.2192004025,
0.27568385,
-0.398032248,
0.334805727,
-0.8923948407,
-1.0436595678,
1.1907198429,
0.8321854472,
-0.8495628238,
0.1902234405,
-0.1008876488,
0.4067298174,
-0.3160161674,
0.3148426116,
0.5478882194,
0.1497541368,
0.0514620505,
-0.764973402,
0.1261825114,
-0.2123886198,
-0.0736685097,
-0.0620265752,
-0.992317915,
0.5832391977,
-0.5551757812,
-0.0898874328,
0.1913314611,
0.887491405,
0.0490857214,
0.0697449893,
0.5258184075,
0.7200577855,
0.600361824,
0.2082366496,
0.8861085773,
-0.5451478362,
0.1616410315,
0.993016541,
-0.2247218788,
0.8173622489,
0.5296421051,
0.1017520577,
0.3104070425,
0.482912302,
-0.0003248632,
0.8338227272,
0.1420282423,
-0.2026184797,
-0.2486678064,
-0.2863821685,
-0.2289482206,
0.409214884,
0.3203214705,
0.0642635077,
-0.2165077031,
0.0378562212,
-0.1975501925,
-0.2021006048,
-0.5211082697,
0.991997838,
0.0386670604,
-0.398267597,
0.8231900334,
-0.0800383538,
0.6976786852,
-0.506557703,
-0.2145728171,
-0.3458722234,
0.270763427,
-0.096764192,
-0.3860823214,
-0.1380419433,
0.162974,
-0.3479506373,
0.2060134113,
0.759386301,
-0.3383469284,
-0.5869925618,
0.2888349891,
0.2763625085,
0.0991730392,
-0.0029637152,
-0.3976767063,
0.138395682,
-0.0173885915,
-0.2023824304,
0.4171319902,
0.3340264559,
-0.1401698142,
0.7748925686,
0.726580441,
-0.0450479239,
0.2580228746,
0.1467961073,
1.1682530642,
-0.3800272048,
-0.1768351495,
-0.7464749217,
0.2679871917,
0.4379083216,
-0.2282625437,
0.4784929752,
0.2516015172,
0.9385244846,
-0.3236373365,
0.653006196,
0.1617247015,
0.0441937819,
-0.4552176297,
0.6824959517,
-0.5757979155,
0.1017881855,
-0.1417706907,
-0.981403172,
-0.3663167357,
0.6851824522,
-0.277043432,
-0.185046345,
0.2665826976,
0.8508491516,
-0.371239692,
-0.3245414197,
0.4345963597,
0.139479965,
0.1846861392,
0.6319388747,
0.6323652864,
-0.4753330052,
0.6118991375,
-0.23840864,
-0.3432371914,
-0.2317183018,
-0.9434585571,
-1.0012315512,
-0.0216001906,
-0.2405271232,
0.2545377314,
0.2957540452,
0.7726635337,
0.6167826056,
-0.7566006184,
-0.127266109,
-0.0656399652,
0.060689006,
-0.1957384497,
-0.1515833437,
0.2992125154,
-0.4935005009,
-0.6733163595,
0.5533457994,
0.4433785677,
0.0346963629,
-0.0394973233,
-0.1381597817,
0.078491196,
0.2388282865,
0.7046922445,
0.5197108984,
-0.7871753573,
-0.4776586592,
0.1071006581,
0.1857254058,
0.2680231035,
0.3968791366,
-0.8032528758,
0.4835814834,
-0.0054232501,
0.8076471686,
0.5909478664,
-0.047283601,
0.2950810194,
-0.5355212688,
0.4225093722,
-0.0997041166,
0.2133619636,
0.3667291403,
-0.4273051918,
0.2872264981,
-0.0700680017,
-0.5907450914,
-0.7489011884,
0.0882208645,
-1.2311496735,
0.1917029023,
0.8167046905,
-0.0350149609,
-0.5160152912,
0.2740239799,
-0.6056603193,
0.299934864,
-0.460054189,
1.0879268646,
0.2258535326,
0.0096371658,
-0.6218286753,
-0.626216352,
0.1011708304,
0.3322289586,
-0.9236589074,
-0.0533267334,
0.2370317131,
0.5915634632,
-0.0053079347,
0.4637744427,
0.2292009741,
0.5093950629,
-0.2138274312,
0.3929006457,
-0.2307898253,
-0.4150591791,
-0.4980327487,
-0.1357126683,
0.3341275752,
-0.6389616132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16173v1 | Towards Countering Essentialism through Social Bias Reasoning | 2023-03-28T17:34:59 | 2023-03-28T17:34:59 | Emily Allaway, Nina Taneja, Sarah-Jane Leslie, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL | Essentialist beliefs (i.e., believing that members of the same group are
fundamentally alike) play a central role in social stereotypes and can lead to
harm when left unchallenged. In our work, we conduct exploratory studies into
the task of countering essentialist beliefs (e.g., ``liberals are stupid'').
Drawing on prior work from psychology and NLP, we construct five types of
counterstatements and conduct human studies on the effectiveness of these
different strategies. Our studies also investigate the role in choosing a
counterstatement of the level of explicitness with which an essentialist belief
is conveyed. We find that statements that broaden the scope of a stereotype
(e.g., to other groups, as in ``conservatives can also be stupid'') are the
most popular countering strategy. We conclude with a discussion of challenges
and open questions for future work in this area (e.g., improving factuality,
studying community-specific variation) and we emphasize the importance of work
at the intersection of NLP and psychology. | [
-0.7565591931,
-0.7833856344,
0.718939364,
0.1126464605,
-0.2015625089,
0.0586378798,
-0.0438112207,
-0.2137916237,
0.9635286331,
0.554897368,
-0.2172412276,
-0.1441361159,
-0.6317499876,
0.1301190257,
-0.1976308376,
0.7222652435,
0.2791185677,
0.0692337826,
0.1947262138,
-0.613273561,
-0.3128604293,
-0.5986642838,
-0.4710483253,
-0.2890317142,
0.5005550385,
0.5003650784,
0.8147735,
0.1574563831,
-0.1393972188,
0.1261097193,
-0.3421018422,
-0.1640433222,
-0.571824789,
0.0797082335,
-0.6396394372,
-0.6716678143,
-0.0322393179,
-0.1075953767,
0.3233196735,
0.8033289909,
0.2584820986,
0.2315557748,
0.0183209963,
0.7307257652,
-0.5531285405,
-0.1707589924,
-0.8793661594,
0.0831574202,
-0.1602618843,
0.0648383647,
-0.1790149063,
-0.6661353707,
0.1322302222,
-0.4762784541,
0.4207979739,
0.0357652083,
0.7463747859,
0.1079420894,
-0.8225210905,
0.0261727758,
-0.509796977,
0.7122122049,
-0.8282621503,
0.0050941901,
0.3705954254,
-0.1163580269,
-0.1360612661,
-0.1947815865,
-0.7660925388,
0.3218530416,
-0.0387357064,
0.1534791738,
0.03655627,
0.2886752784,
0.8053426743,
0.1187784746,
-0.4074674547,
-0.3998122513,
-0.584872365,
-0.061590936,
0.4079547524,
-0.1978081018,
0.4148243964,
-0.1602222472,
-0.110381119,
0.3742641807,
-1.0727808475,
0.0497615673,
0.3923205435,
-0.1547145098,
0.3851258755,
0.2737961113,
-0.3491339386,
0.2957558334,
0.0800962821,
0.5074178576,
0.1659920663,
-0.092334412,
0.1305033416,
0.3410631716,
0.2171327919,
0.7730275393,
0.6786652207,
-0.097358413,
-0.0671257898,
0.5783097744,
0.2637237608,
-0.4485174417,
-0.0363544971,
0.204466179,
-0.2915435433,
-0.3403854072,
-0.2349687517,
-0.3747168779,
-0.2469191104,
-0.390973866,
0.1959814131,
-0.3322794437,
-0.4210249782,
0.1023524851,
-0.6365474463,
0.3085933626,
0.2173411399,
-0.8030427098,
0.3862497807,
0.7209984064,
0.9373676777,
0.2678155303,
0.0449558012,
-0.2588628829,
0.4078000188,
-0.6429976225,
1.1222121716,
-0.5936413407,
-0.4375866055,
0.0503783748,
0.3801700473,
0.3069330156,
-0.5389635563,
0.6431807876,
-0.1329011023,
-0.0857040286,
-1.2769162655,
-0.4843455553,
-0.4960137606,
0.4253898561,
-0.4675031304,
0.5822643042,
-0.2399668097,
-0.8840684295,
0.5552675724,
-0.4517003894,
-0.4926234186,
0.0650239289,
-0.4679165184,
-0.0443593487,
0.429918468,
-0.0775625259,
-0.0106606605,
-0.1864975691,
0.1896504164,
-0.8164298534,
-0.4305249155,
0.1685428917,
-0.0995433852,
1.1143352985,
0.0444487482,
-0.9198633432,
0.2616124749,
-0.2983484268,
0.0729343891,
0.0813478082,
0.1581719071,
-0.9031127095,
0.4425184429,
0.0108645074,
0.2965978682,
-0.2360381633,
-0.6625494957,
0.0544406548,
-0.6060494781,
0.4197600186,
1.0229676962,
0.1141701788,
0.277887553,
-0.7277575731,
0.0063203177,
-0.1021854058,
0.3392733037,
0.3358929157,
-0.7237927318,
-0.8162246943,
0.3772445321,
0.037865907,
0.5770713687,
-0.7638738751,
0.4420925677,
0.1728052944,
-0.1825880706,
-0.1368266791,
0.1683342755,
0.3717119694,
0.4304462671,
0.5989254713,
-0.4778798223,
-0.6041482687,
-1.3798048496,
-0.771389544,
-0.259780407,
-0.0672087744,
-0.0943774879,
0.4978726506,
-0.0457238182,
0.9183038473,
-0.7253689766,
-0.1337278783,
-0.1363228112,
0.1800763309,
0.2029060274,
0.4221440256,
0.7793800831,
-0.7520008683,
-0.5549122095,
-0.3440805972,
-0.6741970778,
-0.3424482346,
0.1998442262,
-0.2425917983,
-0.0733282641,
0.5092886686,
-0.4264686406,
0.638614893,
-0.0829208791,
-0.5427749753,
0.5271366835,
0.3735896945,
-0.0085944831,
-0.8708799481,
-0.222492978,
0.1993482411,
-0.1724980325,
-0.8405234814,
0.0372368135,
-0.1564977318,
0.2385997325,
-0.4530206621,
0.3671787381,
-0.213669613,
0.2427907437,
-0.2165063918,
-0.1519014239,
0.0294023398,
0.0765761584,
0.2659212351,
0.2112729847,
0.273914814,
-0.5362779498,
-0.0539490804,
-0.1250691116,
-0.1326630861,
0.8139403462,
-0.9572528005,
0.0853075832,
-0.47745049,
0.42906335,
-0.7782834768,
-0.0411716104,
0.2828513384,
-0.2932518125,
-0.3267947733,
-0.1802455485,
-0.4458352029,
-0.2062682956,
-0.4161768258,
0.2486909032,
0.5088680387,
-0.2653005123,
0.4204028249,
0.5060064793,
-0.1300762743,
-0.6168122888,
-0.3507637084,
-0.1138377115,
-0.4415250719,
-0.4353017211,
0.3470430672,
-0.1165037155,
-0.8944610953,
0.0571302921,
-0.4002797604,
0.0488747992,
-0.1065486297,
0.1349918693,
0.0433730558,
-0.0719224736,
0.1416891366,
0.354736656,
-0.1029341444,
0.3214948177,
-0.0683264583,
0.3372585475,
-0.3326981962,
-0.3296568692,
0.1629054695,
0.6815094352,
0.2070748508,
0.3440869451,
0.6615259051,
0.392983079,
-0.5793135762,
-0.0707781538,
-0.9770205617,
-0.4258775115,
-0.4019357264,
0.1131423861,
0.1119074598,
-0.4993356466,
0.4358455837,
0.1014212966,
0.4984314144,
0.3210370243,
0.2107068747,
-0.1143653393,
0.9358540177,
0.2696703374,
0.1075806394,
0.2530435026,
-0.0565187521,
0.2172650248,
-0.6040917039,
0.3868953586,
-0.2211925834,
-0.3236405849,
-0.0220568161,
-0.4549573064,
0.3826346397,
0.0737919584,
-0.3463685811,
0.1863187999,
-0.7599583864,
0.7552999258,
0.1560435593,
0.1804127991,
0.0868716463,
-0.1209500656,
0.2101741433,
-0.2923755944,
-0.3942354321,
-0.7089630961,
1.1298888922,
0.2640945613,
0.4087876081,
0.5318488479,
0.4583417475,
0.4137320817,
0.8136252165,
-0.5584017634,
0.6506080031,
0.166184485,
-1.260633707,
-0.1767003089,
-0.0788212717,
-0.3873271346,
0.7542241216,
-0.3374746144,
-0.5710504055,
0.4402018785,
0.411970228,
-0.1897646636,
0.5689241886,
-0.7053346038,
0.6598849297,
-0.201503858,
-0.5224658847,
-0.4196258187,
-0.6712250113,
0.4939517379,
0.1610659212,
0.3933843076,
-0.2941876352,
0.1050753072,
0.8880677819,
-0.1504594237,
0.9991096258,
-0.3659238219,
0.2934902012,
0.2703876793,
0.0117758419,
0.190241456,
0.1470050514,
0.0541028529,
0.3218924999,
0.381329149,
-0.7223941088,
-0.381726265,
0.6415121555,
-0.5583989024,
-1.0290292501,
-0.4903018773,
-0.4523668885,
-0.0785786286,
0.3168068826,
0.2452030629,
0.3074434102,
-0.6166012883,
0.2803430259,
1.3144888878,
-0.1772623956,
-0.0033335849,
0.4859039783,
-0.284838438,
-0.2170715928,
0.6757906675,
0.679009378,
0.7087455988,
-0.0615001097,
0.2834608853,
-0.1732940376,
-0.2559470832,
-0.0555896275,
0.1561316252,
-1.0243066549,
0.2394521832,
-1.0827381611,
0.2497314662,
-0.7451856732,
-0.6369319558,
-0.2729928493,
-0.3644804955,
0.0569547154,
-0.088928923,
0.2140486836,
0.77361691,
-0.4659535885,
0.2512038946,
-0.1987578273,
0.581263721,
0.5992826819,
-0.0518279597,
0.0556520708,
-0.1336263865,
0.371488601,
-0.1052428484,
-0.5181258321,
-1.3001557589,
0.0405817106,
-0.3312782943,
0.6929071546,
0.8746080995,
0.5059057474,
0.3446933031,
-0.4705704451,
0.437771678,
0.3887747526,
-0.8988509178,
0.433435142,
-0.293728143,
0.0030766323,
0.7567574382,
0.7116941214,
-0.8441102505,
-0.4656296074,
-0.9707915187,
-1.1432301998,
0.1534930021,
0.1586970836,
-0.0745952874,
-0.462703228,
-0.0620802492,
-0.118040584,
0.1191904619,
-0.9615625143,
-0.5454667211,
-0.6695326567,
0.1293421537,
0.202972576,
-0.2563674152,
-0.8253474236,
-0.2964960635,
0.6617693901,
-0.3350531757,
-0.3069425523,
0.4785750806,
-0.0534849726,
0.105404079,
0.6637768149,
0.359890759,
0.9528105855,
-0.3868632615,
0.4130770564,
0.6454203129,
-0.1955297589,
0.3701568246,
-0.2869868875,
-0.5164589882,
0.3358591199,
0.1399933398,
0.1688660532,
0.2220667005,
-0.316085577,
0.6058000922,
0.16960904,
-0.25050807,
-0.9576927423,
-0.1564379334,
0.3483130336,
-0.0333816446,
0.3228580356,
0.2896052897,
0.3463024795,
-1.0265733004,
0.017496692,
0.7527316213,
-0.6539893746,
-0.4401210845,
0.5274174809,
0.2524429262,
-0.332154423,
-0.0570097715,
-0.2783539593,
-0.8122074604,
0.963488996,
0.558126986,
0.7216829062,
-0.1409602314,
0.1814542711,
0.4860975444,
0.8279461265,
-0.1250866205,
0.1198407561,
0.0582300238,
-0.9608861804,
-0.1208534911,
-0.2207889855,
-0.4517412782,
0.0906965807,
-0.6316956282,
0.1051227897,
-0.7982977033,
-0.3076816201,
-0.0520799682,
-0.4942735136,
-0.4379293323,
-0.0525877103,
-0.049086839,
0.9261432886,
-1.2112158537,
0.4484564662,
0.5126181841,
-0.4053188264,
-0.3880665302,
0.4413295686,
0.5186721087,
-0.4832442701,
0.816798687,
0.3535641134,
-0.1896501482,
-0.4101342857,
-0.6479521394,
-0.7876413465,
0.4538782835,
-0.1410133839,
-0.5297673941,
-0.1356856078,
-0.1526434869,
0.1553070843,
-0.2860093713,
0.3974296451,
0.5770173073,
0.6780505776,
-0.2037362605,
-0.4255262911,
0.4109504223,
-0.2179540098,
-0.0355811529,
-0.0133607462,
-0.6354821324,
0.7623475194,
0.0031396283,
-0.1518134475,
-0.5961161852,
0.3893224895,
0.286503911,
0.3176261485,
0.9994226694,
0.3115831614,
0.304818511,
0.032339558,
0.512789607,
-0.2750809491,
-0.0291447267,
0.8645082116,
-0.4891763628,
0.3368211985,
0.6486108899,
-0.049023319,
0.271768719,
0.2160381526,
0.4068569243,
0.3666053414,
0.3235246837,
-0.4440855086,
-0.3201748431,
-0.228491053,
-0.7732996345,
-0.0522278734,
0.8637148738,
-0.1508262455,
-0.2165831029,
-0.523903966,
0.1898394674,
0.2849002481,
-0.3587598205,
0.5422086716,
0.2495498359,
-0.5581264496,
0.4360567927,
-0.2807253599,
0.9607599974,
-0.4579696655,
-0.0557268932,
0.0051801247,
0.0748596191,
-0.5538271666,
-0.6434155107,
0.7085877061,
-0.3924241066,
-0.4230226576,
-0.0872022808,
0.8405159712,
-0.0318354331,
-0.3080364168,
0.323427856,
0.2315067202,
0.1364174634,
-0.0787802786,
-0.6494854689,
-0.2116568536,
0.1837980747,
-0.0969450548,
0.2098635584,
0.2344697267,
-0.0624279678,
0.4408441782,
0.7419356704,
0.4729090631,
-0.2280997932,
0.0493757166,
0.9254834652,
-0.8518408537,
-0.6233882904,
-0.7549688816,
0.1862249076,
-0.733602047,
-0.3242706954,
0.7918787003,
0.386610657,
0.814165175,
0.0581842624,
1.0561331511,
-0.0972038358,
0.7873651385,
-0.3815642893,
0.7760846615,
-0.3930330873,
0.086455293,
-0.6041481495,
-0.9543193579,
-0.0406522602,
0.6879832149,
-0.8033788204,
-0.3050599098,
0.7651531696,
0.7332937121,
-0.0815259591,
0.4040507972,
0.232370615,
0.3009604514,
0.6230184436,
0.3438532948,
0.8473744988,
-0.098242186,
0.3998859227,
-0.2220157385,
-0.3996205032,
-0.0101840254,
-0.602422595,
-1.0231342316,
-0.2635926306,
-0.2520277798,
-0.7809934616,
-0.0188160576,
0.9701780677,
0.3709664047,
-0.676402986,
-0.145147115,
0.0160582308,
0.6182888746,
-0.2450976521,
-0.2867771983,
-0.1709309965,
-0.0128998132,
-0.3699833155,
-0.1068497375,
0.3510639668,
-0.2987904251,
-0.3447710872,
0.2754364014,
-0.410887152,
0.5019796491,
0.7342056036,
0.7470622063,
-1.0290920734,
-0.589627564,
-0.4470446408,
0.1396112293,
-0.1593810767,
0.933827579,
-0.5344974399,
0.2591947019,
0.5268275738,
0.2284428775,
-0.0993037969,
-0.0583836325,
0.5234304667,
-0.2238772511,
0.3523101807,
0.3915587962,
0.5781936049,
0.1695889235,
-0.2998573184,
0.5927518606,
0.6608406305,
-0.5436456203,
-0.8877255917,
0.7937372327,
-0.5551383495,
-0.5334068537,
1.0165973902,
0.1535399407,
-0.2175612748,
-0.952001214,
-0.3152670562,
0.0205305144,
-0.5333423018,
0.817276001,
0.6075721383,
0.1580692977,
0.1245579496,
-0.7351836562,
0.5649330616,
0.6427925229,
-0.6358483434,
-0.2052295208,
0.3035952449,
0.7932600379,
0.3919615746,
1.1113485098,
0.0947291553,
0.2110529691,
0.1246227399,
0.2868337333,
0.5187648535,
0.0325468257,
0.2375608981,
0.1275585443,
-0.0025437009,
0.4393966794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16166v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16166v4 | When Good and Reproducible Results are a Giant with Feet of Clay: The Importance of Software Quality in NLP | 2023-03-28T17:28:52 | 2023-08-15T21:53:56 | Sara Papi, Marco Gaido, Andrea Pilzer, Matteo Negri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite its crucial role in research experiments, code correctness is often
presumed only on the basis of the perceived quality of results. This assumption
comes with the risk of erroneous outcomes and potentially misleading findings.
To address this issue, we posit that the current focus on reproducibility
should go hand in hand with the emphasis on software quality. We present a case
study in which we identify and fix three bugs in widely used implementations of
the state-of-the-art Conformer architecture. Through experiments on speech
recognition and translation in various languages, we demonstrate that the
presence of bugs does not prevent the achievement of good and reproducible
results, which however can lead to incorrect conclusions that potentially
misguide future research. As a countermeasure, we propose a Code-quality
Checklist and release pangoliNN, a library dedicated to testing neural models,
with the goal of promoting coding best practices and improving research
software quality within the NLP community. | [
-0.0570199266,
-0.1896628439,
0.302570194,
0.6541773677,
-0.2364802063,
-0.1661841571,
-0.1883910298,
-0.6785122156,
0.2596024573,
0.6395357847,
0.2533301711,
-0.5674059987,
-0.8323836923,
0.0878019407,
-0.9042928219,
0.9253801107,
-0.0962978005,
-0.0398457944,
-0.0478931144,
-0.4730263054,
-0.3117232621,
-0.5200001597,
-0.506591022,
-0.2873889208,
0.4796926975,
0.0713817924,
1.0410096645,
0.7462319732,
0.5124073029,
0.1896971017,
-0.204822734,
0.0472076759,
-0.2859073579,
-0.1143963784,
-0.102738522,
-0.7372276187,
-0.4115464091,
0.0573556125,
0.3990223408,
0.4113421142,
-0.2252809703,
0.1358203143,
0.2931000888,
0.6816099882,
-0.2007809132,
0.2192807347,
-0.0937122628,
0.122059986,
-0.2496373355,
-0.1705826074,
-0.5898811221,
-0.7852945328,
-0.1413758844,
-0.3945077658,
0.5135062337,
0.0216519814,
1.1162680387,
0.6521542072,
0.029078817,
-0.6188951731,
-0.4611167312,
0.6284806728,
-1.2588820457,
0.4001891017,
0.3382047415,
0.3190784156,
-0.6464791894,
-0.6240262985,
-0.5230324864,
-0.3066082895,
-0.1974600554,
-0.0309644863,
0.0633023307,
-0.2311722785,
0.097102128,
0.56879884,
-0.7468035817,
-0.0049514468,
-0.4677705169,
-0.2812088132,
0.5595786572,
-0.3888584673,
0.4201810658,
0.005117761,
0.2231649458,
-0.1708505601,
-0.8492725492,
-0.0795607194,
0.42362836,
0.2188903391,
0.1726909578,
0.6582328081,
0.360632062,
0.9489453435,
-0.1015457958,
-0.1149193719,
0.2678128183,
-0.2508461177,
0.0197687801,
0.0452101007,
0.3725953698,
0.2532939315,
0.0843973309,
-0.4487041235,
-0.460398674,
0.2013370693,
0.5929201245,
-0.3161934614,
-0.624445796,
0.734881103,
-0.6026742458,
-0.3199159503,
0.0878408328,
-0.7632545233,
-0.4895538986,
-0.2668676674,
0.3926130533,
-0.4923362434,
-0.6341728568,
0.105694145,
-0.3674687147,
0.0866527483,
0.2367231101,
-0.7756677866,
0.1204818115,
1.0205186605,
0.873396039,
-0.1847231984,
-0.5971454382,
-0.4909587801,
-0.2231714278,
-0.7942782044,
0.4551528096,
-0.1731981933,
-0.3737412691,
-0.0459160991,
-0.0249416847,
0.1969045848,
-1.1066515446,
0.3603637516,
-0.3018086851,
-0.0585745126,
-0.0818635002,
-0.552710712,
-0.0731611401,
0.2030284554,
-0.5537199974,
0.9857828617,
0.4843506813,
-0.4923333228,
0.349326849,
-0.2765437365,
-0.2844342887,
-0.1123617664,
-0.1834801584,
-0.2513641715,
0.2989353836,
-0.2997254431,
0.1068568677,
0.0936888084,
0.2811675668,
0.1322634667,
-0.4748190343,
0.1057454795,
0.1041982323,
0.8457137346,
0.0079543823,
-0.7226686478,
0.1764396429,
-0.7404143214,
0.1438637823,
-0.0111153116,
-0.7518698573,
-0.2985805571,
0.1019532606,
-0.0141498027,
0.3172058463,
-0.0601286553,
-0.518673718,
0.2208618224,
-0.4772009254,
0.2976149023,
0.6700398922,
-0.2973680794,
0.2471059859,
-0.4950698018,
0.2211215347,
0.1644541919,
0.3551822603,
0.1959600449,
-0.6224919558,
-0.7395930886,
0.0501422286,
0.5556563139,
0.3725256622,
-0.7931576371,
0.4617241919,
-0.083578825,
-0.8081896901,
-0.6699421406,
0.3961279392,
0.471773386,
0.2676073611,
0.1675927192,
-0.4177420735,
-0.2102296352,
-0.642121017,
-0.2524533868,
-0.548171699,
-0.3442048728,
0.1642832607,
0.4366655648,
-0.2689827979,
0.9367830753,
-0.322419405,
-0.2975395322,
-0.06629619,
0.3368363976,
0.3156037033,
0.9068771005,
0.865007937,
-0.9478707314,
0.1392735988,
-0.316215843,
-0.6313869357,
0.0161126889,
-0.0604711473,
-0.0265871864,
0.3855703771,
0.3338829577,
-0.3583833277,
0.1251953989,
1.0591765642,
-0.1878905445,
0.7117156982,
-0.4411683679,
0.290502727,
-0.8380126953,
-0.0293914713,
0.1091388389,
-0.104664512,
-0.2876117229,
0.3068600297,
0.2116468996,
0.0674265698,
-0.2994934618,
0.0402768664,
0.008856114,
-0.2235357165,
-0.2957674563,
0.2460599989,
0.0567813888,
0.078738451,
-0.2160233855,
0.9705343843,
0.2390987724,
-0.8265507817,
0.3896510899,
0.2717961371,
-0.3369249701,
0.4459026456,
-1.0365976095,
-0.1315655708,
-0.0546025224,
0.022536125,
-0.8244184852,
-0.2433787137,
0.285366565,
-0.7871562243,
0.3975845873,
-0.1044450626,
-0.7076420188,
-0.4735399485,
-0.1203391179,
0.0311746597,
0.5812810063,
-0.8215993047,
0.236233294,
0.4390394092,
0.1269143373,
-0.5932971239,
-0.9911310673,
-0.0454347022,
0.1818248034,
-0.5913491249,
-0.211954996,
-0.0132608367,
-0.1148832068,
0.1532803327,
-0.3522410691,
-0.2356230915,
0.0700824112,
0.2661569118,
0.0219214968,
-0.3615460396,
0.1179577112,
-0.3642858565,
-0.2953792214,
0.1768063456,
-0.3272500336,
0.3004072011,
-0.3896241784,
-0.5525795817,
0.1420116723,
-0.0004700341,
0.699159801,
-0.2864697278,
0.5135602355,
0.4267621338,
-0.2501821518,
-0.2604272664,
-0.4770891666,
-0.172423169,
-0.4063225389,
0.2267662287,
0.1041443497,
-0.6153821349,
0.5080471039,
-0.3287336826,
0.4865581095,
0.3147450686,
-0.0435825847,
0.0236879587,
0.7816061974,
0.8688796163,
0.0467925966,
0.1083587781,
-0.1784858853,
0.6112830639,
-0.8435074091,
-0.1322675049,
-0.8973584175,
-0.1391596198,
-0.6054866314,
-0.3537645638,
0.0512312353,
0.3164714575,
0.0869489834,
0.8047116995,
-0.8860839009,
0.4493138492,
0.6744529605,
-0.0187885985,
0.2338213772,
-0.5775530338,
0.0089420695,
-0.1499712169,
-0.7829145193,
-0.7465049624,
0.6570550203,
0.15655303,
0.6615240574,
0.1640099585,
0.8233801723,
0.3725002706,
0.4634743631,
-0.5300526619,
0.2572721839,
-0.1563898325,
-0.609452188,
-0.3536411226,
-0.4515811503,
-0.9622147679,
0.0936388895,
0.1662625521,
-0.586371839,
0.3335139453,
0.6139085889,
-0.1601604372,
0.2755378187,
-0.5094767809,
1.1280499697,
-0.049837146,
-0.1006655619,
-0.0701391175,
-0.7057387233,
0.3552606404,
-0.0144565869,
0.1521805376,
-0.1060661077,
0.2825786769,
0.7051048875,
-0.2879445553,
0.5449322462,
-0.0426766872,
-0.2077474743,
0.2606833875,
0.4041846395,
0.4381704032,
-0.0922821611,
-0.0602245666,
0.3436481953,
0.2456114292,
-0.6107136011,
-0.6049590707,
0.8257758617,
-0.6747410297,
-0.6459320188,
-0.4511461556,
-0.2460411787,
-0.0055677467,
0.1784438789,
0.2097530663,
0.4268800616,
0.1800028086,
0.0300657842,
0.9127647281,
-0.4535008371,
0.2728049457,
0.3615356088,
-0.4738345444,
-0.2555927932,
1.2331459522,
0.2713588476,
0.3650355935,
-0.321138829,
-0.0281944051,
0.1586951017,
-0.7431614399,
-0.5341649055,
0.3606843352,
-0.7302757502,
-0.0614714064,
-0.2407246828,
-0.2575578392,
-0.3323350549,
-0.3650662601,
-0.7984333634,
-0.1870585084,
-0.1039396748,
-0.001113117,
0.0797967464,
0.9207594991,
-0.1520988941,
-0.0427717566,
-1.0012564659,
0.3623022735,
-0.1561571956,
0.4449136853,
-0.0250522457,
-0.3002506793,
-0.2975317836,
0.0874152109,
-0.0695954487,
-0.5722774267,
0.3894536197,
-0.1954002976,
0.5654588342,
-0.0421722457,
0.0326178595,
0.4393280447,
-0.3854492605,
1.0924017429,
0.006913329,
-0.7991788387,
0.8885535002,
0.0051041194,
0.2126095146,
0.5089233518,
0.3515565693,
-0.6214945316,
-0.9928953052,
-0.822075069,
-1.0336773396,
0.2517917454,
0.1643274575,
0.0054884963,
-0.1351947337,
0.4004699588,
0.2263781279,
0.4163764715,
-0.3571823537,
-0.3098805845,
-0.5502625704,
-0.0778476968,
-0.1444702446,
-0.3069676161,
-0.2382405102,
0.0026095922,
0.8438445926,
-0.0083149392,
-0.0705551803,
0.4378433526,
-0.1483765692,
0.0240195766,
0.252207011,
0.7904089689,
1.2492023706,
-0.3051735461,
0.2381332964,
-0.4249044061,
-0.5826275349,
0.0917841271,
-0.3125455081,
-0.2767702639,
0.5123291612,
0.1351705939,
-0.054586865,
0.1855439991,
-0.6620835662,
0.4738963246,
0.1890972555,
0.0390149131,
-0.3855092525,
0.2264838368,
0.0086114937,
0.1798232943,
0.3137285113,
0.5386248231,
0.092254363,
-0.3550666273,
0.4459115565,
-0.2505013943,
-0.3769266605,
-0.2443447709,
0.6280856133,
0.1346924156,
-0.4462832212,
0.9520173669,
-0.1765195876,
-0.2751247585,
0.7557778358,
0.5687059164,
0.4409845769,
-0.2360110879,
0.3210346997,
0.3451001346,
0.6973056197,
-0.6037994027,
0.1929475963,
0.4978954792,
-0.5415198207,
-0.5299537182,
-0.377438277,
-0.5305020213,
-0.1047177911,
-0.6374554038,
-0.0364834741,
-0.3392530084,
-0.1799971014,
0.0404618531,
-0.5196181536,
0.0398241431,
-0.0434702784,
-0.243557781,
1.2105847597,
-0.8158171773,
0.6900738478,
0.3520988524,
-0.5548005104,
-0.8923385739,
-0.0389174335,
0.1574786752,
-0.2988636494,
0.5597123504,
-0.056549862,
0.0938121304,
-0.073763676,
-0.6910564899,
-0.6497166157,
0.8448328972,
0.5694372654,
-0.316935122,
0.4064954519,
-0.0640376285,
0.6799134016,
0.109929435,
-0.2348197699,
0.5098487735,
0.5092073083,
-0.0377159715,
-1.1861569881,
-0.101863876,
-0.2985534966,
0.2133308649,
0.2967612147,
-0.508995831,
0.5002328753,
-0.2157582641,
0.042327933,
0.0359720662,
0.5739679933,
0.3775679469,
0.0470674075,
0.2245716155,
0.5348044634,
0.8997192383,
-0.5995440483,
1.31080091,
-0.364084959,
0.2285661399,
1.1229097843,
-0.0802805573,
0.9350652099,
0.7035381794,
-0.0642055273,
0.2098386884,
0.5642096996,
-0.2082180232,
0.3278733492,
0.6013505459,
0.0458543785,
-0.0397108942,
0.0008410857,
-0.3713778555,
-0.09578906,
0.1036619693,
-0.3379176855,
-0.1956192106,
0.1092483476,
0.030718334,
0.1874487996,
-0.0405343734,
0.4684870541,
0.0391595475,
-0.5805777907,
0.5502616763,
-0.2786314189,
0.7323743105,
-0.314512223,
-0.4901311398,
-0.2034636587,
0.3500718474,
-0.4994447529,
-0.8276802897,
0.738399446,
-0.3649310172,
-0.271964252,
-0.0256955903,
0.3547592759,
-0.143076703,
-0.0470991433,
0.3605947196,
0.2936125696,
0.5843653083,
-0.067980513,
-0.4508396089,
0.3449698091,
-0.1409393102,
-0.0460223816,
0.2118414491,
0.3560480177,
0.3852376938,
0.7628978491,
0.6499652863,
0.3426130414,
0.2851798832,
-0.0144292237,
0.8588013053,
-0.402320534,
-0.0887386799,
-0.60211128,
0.4962378442,
-0.0905278549,
-0.4923647642,
0.8530371189,
0.554713428,
0.9445127845,
-0.1004666314,
0.4326099455,
-0.2004336864,
0.2481284291,
-0.2282926142,
0.7702199221,
-0.1796301752,
0.2931138575,
-0.0566270649,
-0.7670964003,
-0.6052824259,
0.6571780443,
0.1316497624,
-0.185467422,
0.6800491214,
0.8466012478,
0.1132625788,
-0.0151471328,
0.3894456029,
0.3897471726,
0.5041270256,
0.2759277225,
0.4352563322,
-0.643894136,
0.5293428898,
-0.2413583696,
-0.2232916206,
-0.2996230423,
-0.6480449438,
-0.4253308773,
-0.7028239965,
-0.5987334251,
-1.0712826252,
0.3699445426,
0.689013958,
0.5538864732,
-1.0254266262,
-0.0797805488,
-0.1875540912,
0.2756413817,
-0.7105390429,
-0.2143537998,
0.3039385676,
-0.4497225583,
-0.3694096506,
0.119016245,
0.3418937922,
0.1240023598,
-0.1906817853,
-0.2619955838,
0.0610571913,
-0.2524278164,
0.2504385412,
0.5991049409,
-0.7782050967,
-0.620716095,
0.0185929816,
-0.4191499352,
0.1229203865,
0.7871121168,
-0.502951622,
0.3176611066,
0.4059704542,
0.7805349231,
0.0673864186,
-0.2532575428,
0.8426056504,
-0.4493340552,
-0.0601847135,
0.5291187763,
0.428722024,
0.3142475188,
-0.3211240768,
0.9071985483,
-0.1374311298,
-1.0297449827,
-0.8473741412,
0.0392837524,
-0.823985815,
-0.1434981823,
1.0348953009,
-0.6746183038,
-0.4736590087,
-0.2757866383,
-0.3247041702,
0.1363525242,
0.1192350537,
1.2646291256,
1.1132969856,
-0.2287586182,
-0.1479447633,
-0.7302564979,
0.6168733239,
0.2834747434,
-0.5981750488,
0.1928217709,
0.4610451758,
0.3556704521,
0.8286479115,
0.1871727407,
-0.5005452037,
0.5527744293,
0.3705640137,
0.2830658555,
-0.0323572494,
-0.2255895138,
-0.2504734099,
-0.0155405402,
0.4194390178,
0.0342222862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16755v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16755v3 | Training Language Models with Language Feedback at Scale | 2023-03-28T17:04:15 | 2024-02-22T22:29:10 | Jérémy Scheurer, Jon Ander Campos, Tomasz Korbak, Jun Shern Chan, Angelica Chen, Kyunghyun Cho, Ethan Perez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Pretrained language models often generate outputs that are not in line with
human preferences, such as harmful text or factually incorrect summaries.
Recent work approaches the above issues by learning from a simple form of human
feedback: comparisons between pairs of model-generated outputs. However,
comparison feedback only conveys limited information about human preferences.
In this paper, we introduce Imitation learning from Language Feedback (ILF), a
new approach that utilizes more informative language feedback. ILF consists of
three steps that are applied iteratively: first, conditioning the language
model on the input, an initial LM output, and feedback to generate refinements.
Second, selecting the refinement incorporating the most feedback. Third,
finetuning the language model to maximize the likelihood of the chosen
refinement given the input. We show theoretically that ILF can be viewed as
Bayesian Inference, similar to Reinforcement Learning from human feedback. We
evaluate ILF's effectiveness on a carefully-controlled toy task and a realistic
summarization task. Our experiments demonstrate that large language models
accurately incorporate feedback and that finetuning with ILF scales well with
the dataset size, even outperforming finetuning on human summaries. Learning
from both language and comparison feedback outperforms learning from each
alone, achieving human-level summarization performance. | [
-0.2421326488,
-0.7140465379,
0.2123413682,
0.1895047575,
-0.0849691555,
0.0438116007,
-0.37940377,
-0.2785031497,
0.1357531548,
0.6770086884,
-0.5233325958,
-0.1947186887,
-0.4651165903,
0.0684506893,
-0.3187319338,
1.2424058914,
0.104070276,
0.2609885037,
-0.0868098587,
-0.1050186455,
-0.0311550628,
-0.4378885925,
-0.9257925153,
-0.5978374481,
0.6403273344,
0.5661494732,
0.3579898775,
0.4354503155,
0.2421888411,
0.329151839,
0.3165493906,
0.21144104,
-0.6568912864,
-0.1723660082,
-0.1592893153,
-0.6647247672,
-0.0727137402,
0.2661525905,
0.8630133867,
0.9212029576,
-0.4015933275,
0.0661117509,
0.2981048524,
0.8438981175,
-0.5854913592,
0.5467693806,
-0.2952284515,
-0.0758208185,
0.3614500761,
0.149448663,
-0.5929353237,
-0.6014160514,
0.0779388472,
-0.3920407295,
0.1298166513,
0.0377312005,
0.6270506978,
0.0914549455,
-0.1014064178,
-0.2387915105,
-0.987554431,
0.7721329927,
-1.0670744181,
0.1460327506,
0.559020102,
0.1858775914,
-0.1165047884,
-0.4754093885,
-0.4823419154,
-0.7540418506,
-0.2876451612,
0.1146077067,
0.0020507141,
0.1554748565,
0.1874146014,
0.3018619716,
-0.3343367577,
0.1765238792,
-0.4478737712,
0.0241592936,
0.6705787778,
-0.1860094815,
0.0533979982,
0.1542963982,
-0.0833505914,
-0.469868511,
-0.7079637647,
0.2557913959,
0.4103198647,
0.463450253,
0.0493153632,
0.3345446289,
-0.3866422176,
0.7524639368,
0.3438170552,
-0.3890565038,
0.1934512258,
-0.0206823628,
-0.0302596018,
-0.0792106837,
0.7987602353,
0.3764081597,
0.3375296593,
-0.2818622291,
-0.5035982728,
-0.0866393223,
0.2488450259,
-0.9036772847,
-0.201675877,
-0.0810045153,
-0.4585112333,
-0.375900209,
0.3399974406,
-0.6061714888,
-0.2231281847,
-0.476225853,
0.7889882326,
-0.3765215874,
-0.3839483559,
0.0371578857,
0.1158758327,
0.1020334512,
0.4300743341,
-1.0942815542,
0.5226932764,
0.4631225169,
0.6299660206,
0.0097256126,
-0.5991069078,
-0.8504700065,
-0.0958208144,
-0.5929738283,
0.8774701953,
-0.331669271,
-0.4385676384,
-0.1052345783,
-0.0188859794,
0.0473437048,
-0.9199746251,
-0.1507912725,
-0.2635577023,
0.2779747248,
0.0541208945,
-0.4970276952,
-0.2849109471,
0.1696598679,
-0.5934616327,
0.9332758784,
0.3570156991,
-0.6247752905,
0.5619858503,
-0.4311743081,
-0.5644973516,
-0.2147231847,
-0.1002375707,
-0.3937309682,
0.3172003031,
0.1375866681,
0.5141477585,
-0.0311583132,
0.0136135612,
-0.3789154887,
-0.3720375299,
0.2131481916,
-0.2353917509,
0.186029166,
0.1053102016,
-0.3463304043,
0.249078244,
-0.8834797144,
0.1294418722,
-0.0846439302,
-0.4784465432,
-0.2952846885,
0.0297657978,
-0.2662502229,
-0.0976814851,
0.0105532575,
-0.3046233952,
0.2160390913,
-0.6494448185,
0.2199866623,
0.5246272683,
0.1542436182,
0.5824152827,
-0.7263088226,
0.5330038071,
-0.2408198565,
-0.0413795263,
-0.1926245689,
0.0873460025,
-0.6856563091,
-0.0166396908,
0.3999217451,
0.2865673006,
-0.653547585,
0.2463997006,
-0.1271302104,
-0.4282382429,
-0.5778522491,
0.2396809757,
0.5006723404,
0.2657089233,
0.1290861368,
-0.5228577852,
-0.3658694327,
-0.7473728061,
-0.1862237453,
-0.563193202,
-0.1937423497,
-0.0464402586,
0.2849985063,
0.0751477778,
0.7041959167,
-0.1557737738,
-0.2391300946,
-0.6546733975,
0.6940230131,
0.1808056831,
0.584675014,
0.3828369677,
-0.3989456892,
-0.2823921442,
0.0454906225,
-0.234741956,
-0.1455943882,
-0.2704728842,
0.2705180943,
0.0599798001,
0.7063534856,
-0.138207987,
0.1348538101,
0.5321988463,
-0.0034601057,
0.5320932865,
-0.5645885468,
0.1556666791,
-0.944193542,
0.0109090097,
-0.2627783716,
-0.4774823189,
-0.4140045345,
0.0517500713,
-0.0927909538,
0.2168195695,
-0.1274142712,
0.5173305273,
-0.4395341873,
-0.049982246,
-0.5579338074,
0.0665289536,
-0.248531878,
0.616844058,
0.2903926373,
0.5128980875,
0.085683383,
-0.6140088439,
0.1655716896,
-0.2290755808,
-0.6476222277,
0.2700791955,
-0.5837144852,
0.0589433201,
-0.3758075535,
0.2081663311,
-0.919934988,
-0.3728252351,
0.0579069629,
-0.5019631386,
0.3902220726,
-0.118287988,
-0.5520185232,
-0.1193299741,
-0.2622713745,
-0.0920149237,
0.6152155399,
-0.4985594451,
0.4909775555,
0.317625016,
-0.2211988717,
-0.6602351069,
-0.555242002,
-0.4249366522,
0.0034802968,
0.1190926209,
-0.1461021602,
-0.158533752,
-0.3880362213,
-0.2581122518,
-0.0141458092,
-0.0015660456,
0.1119958013,
0.2845182717,
-0.0797965527,
-0.1808505207,
0.1662794501,
-0.0359082744,
0.030932067,
0.0742668509,
-0.2025372833,
0.4415500164,
-0.1843136549,
-0.2503593862,
-0.4065963626,
0.2844097614,
0.4975287616,
-0.1633387357,
0.5862896442,
0.4725517035,
-0.1996447891,
-0.5115880966,
-0.5114246011,
-0.5232031345,
-0.3596045971,
0.5563773513,
-0.310287863,
-0.8210923076,
0.1723993123,
-0.2427593768,
0.3459566832,
0.184901163,
0.3811457753,
-0.1715425402,
1.2752945423,
0.948908627,
-0.2693727016,
0.6832616925,
-0.3370229602,
-0.0401669852,
-0.3720490932,
0.0070313811,
-0.4880922735,
-0.2630231678,
-0.4531382024,
-0.2700381875,
0.0505744293,
0.5403544307,
-0.216266498,
0.2059194744,
0.0314578712,
0.8997517824,
0.7013040185,
0.3302202523,
0.3423065245,
0.0594859719,
-0.0972980037,
0.0456088595,
-0.7786887884,
-0.4102481902,
0.9070578814,
0.1690296978,
1.1947523355,
0.0602343939,
0.8839756846,
0.0855253935,
0.9406895041,
-0.7373278737,
0.261459738,
-0.1599423587,
-0.1390828937,
-0.4870105684,
-0.6448212862,
-0.6551690102,
0.2186297029,
-0.2265478373,
-0.7620356679,
-0.1646555513,
0.5237623453,
-0.4877425134,
0.2159558386,
-0.8233100176,
0.5890998244,
-0.0814821273,
-0.3946242929,
-0.4938427508,
-0.6320075393,
0.214421317,
0.0756727308,
0.4555759728,
0.0711746067,
0.3222298026,
0.5751541257,
-0.439155966,
1.1136568785,
-0.1704413146,
-0.0895440578,
0.1611601263,
0.280806005,
0.4458673894,
0.222019434,
0.0690827891,
-0.3998698294,
0.0317224525,
-0.3141939044,
-0.9137160778,
0.5325711966,
-0.826703012,
-0.5725589395,
-0.2052143514,
-0.3451038003,
-0.3594040275,
0.230512023,
0.2802807391,
0.4316298366,
-0.3040972948,
0.1336940229,
0.632705152,
-0.1287225038,
0.3905697763,
0.7339621782,
-0.7845575213,
-0.4147287309,
0.9012297392,
-0.1326872706,
0.6132887602,
0.7805815935,
0.280370295,
-0.2447381914,
-0.29150635,
-0.528146565,
0.4381139576,
-0.5684197545,
0.0135876788,
-0.3350097835,
-0.1204906628,
-0.3291608393,
0.0548521616,
-0.4924928844,
-0.3855443597,
-0.0062596635,
-0.1666247845,
-0.0134531762,
1.2443258762,
-0.34969154,
0.4083701372,
-0.6603342891,
0.0568066314,
0.5523480177,
0.3637179136,
0.2399123311,
-0.5287377834,
-0.3746054471,
0.1430607587,
-0.1114908308,
-0.6551609039,
0.2352559865,
0.358320266,
0.4872269034,
0.671046257,
-0.0043598213,
0.4335204065,
-0.4735343754,
0.5993052721,
0.1514720023,
-0.7775334716,
0.3939066231,
-0.0559433289,
0.7070329785,
0.6181029081,
0.3499163687,
-0.5500990152,
-0.655413568,
-0.5162918568,
-0.4866913855,
0.7540269494,
-0.2168149203,
0.2632392049,
0.0598749779,
0.4904445708,
0.3441097736,
0.2672308981,
-0.9632805586,
0.1045103669,
-0.0670446083,
-0.126431644,
-0.5085327625,
-0.1277285814,
0.0246389247,
-0.1622526199,
0.7623912096,
-0.2886762023,
0.1608721167,
0.0670394599,
-0.3405308127,
-0.1588046402,
0.175151214,
0.5736393332,
0.7576230764,
-0.2053637803,
0.3194603622,
0.163348794,
-0.1529500484,
0.1410025209,
-0.1149056256,
-0.0318396427,
0.041527573,
0.6160931587,
0.7059922218,
0.2888611853,
-0.8225648999,
0.4679492414,
-0.1942048967,
-0.2885680497,
-0.2866185009,
0.3390257359,
0.0382343568,
0.2844246328,
0.006394682,
-0.0270940643,
0.0769931525,
-0.6405088305,
0.275904268,
0.2254801542,
-0.5784279704,
-0.4457643032,
0.5561085939,
-0.0453656688,
-0.2305713445,
0.5345979333,
-0.1695855707,
-0.4217570722,
0.3968794346,
0.6059824228,
0.5539255738,
-0.4625788927,
0.4914947152,
0.677588284,
0.3013906777,
-0.4800203443,
0.1322238445,
-0.4528156221,
-0.690998435,
-0.656983614,
-0.6468877792,
-0.5978850126,
0.3163048029,
-0.8108794689,
0.1689737141,
-0.7416902781,
0.1472859383,
-0.0723313019,
-0.2239737511,
-0.206496194,
0.2177546471,
-0.1188030764,
0.5697132349,
-0.7638547421,
0.8734122515,
0.6883588433,
-0.6842207909,
-0.9006640911,
0.1660878062,
-0.2683716416,
-0.7252834439,
0.6092408895,
0.3595999181,
-0.2950582802,
0.1217585281,
-0.6404300928,
-0.5973160267,
0.5005739331,
0.3659408987,
-0.4789364338,
-0.0526131578,
-0.0036517768,
0.6674252152,
-0.4472202361,
0.467446506,
0.6385697126,
0.077256538,
-0.149289757,
-0.7741385102,
-0.2553922534,
-0.1802900136,
0.1435289234,
0.1233356372,
-0.6817324758,
0.5858486295,
-0.608148694,
-0.0314540043,
0.2763724327,
0.7309484482,
0.0320089348,
-0.1733292341,
0.7986284494,
0.3540390432,
0.435413152,
0.118434988,
0.9937537909,
-0.1081326157,
0.331277281,
1.5154817104,
-0.0628324896,
1.0841300488,
0.3842727244,
-0.1974888146,
0.6060574651,
0.6100543141,
0.2694389522,
0.6871029735,
0.6033812165,
-0.281889379,
-0.1279235929,
0.0965668485,
0.0319187976,
0.21446383,
0.2974173725,
-0.41353935,
-0.2132103294,
0.2039485872,
0.0626691207,
0.2618940771,
-0.3091298938,
1.1778753996,
-0.033852756,
-0.9064809084,
0.5216892362,
-0.0464661457,
0.4946867228,
-0.6859571338,
-0.4108003378,
-0.511008203,
0.4318399429,
-0.0112771522,
-0.2067268342,
0.1181171313,
-0.2086851597,
-0.3636841774,
-0.3181021214,
0.1258071363,
-0.814117074,
-0.3330391347,
0.269038707,
0.2152399123,
0.1771749556,
0.0532975793,
-0.3797155023,
-0.3762648106,
0.1123098135,
-0.167731598,
0.4086136222,
0.2172982097,
-0.0485716239,
0.6739423275,
0.375289917,
0.3761649728,
-0.0998726562,
0.2783294618,
0.3774691224,
-0.329703629,
-0.5415269136,
-0.648408711,
0.1867889911,
-0.0615712963,
-0.2285739779,
0.408361733,
0.3129645288,
1.3489500284,
-0.3204976618,
0.8818036914,
0.1658316851,
0.9254335165,
-0.614385426,
0.7334976792,
-0.5514245629,
0.1950027347,
-0.1327667236,
-0.7750887275,
-0.2966556549,
0.8704932928,
-0.2157461196,
0.1655301303,
0.6685815454,
1.021056056,
0.0262258034,
-0.0328599997,
0.3993723392,
0.3985193074,
0.0919315964,
0.2294003367,
0.8619817495,
-0.0469047017,
0.3563818336,
-0.5315387845,
-0.5513164997,
-0.1684931666,
-0.6213622093,
-0.9714592695,
-0.6391128898,
-0.2791038156,
-0.3349800706,
0.0830984488,
1.2442355156,
0.8974096179,
-1.0125986338,
-0.7359981537,
-0.2213830203,
0.0491851717,
-0.5398595929,
-0.2331166267,
0.2371028364,
-0.6192569733,
-0.9268903136,
0.2510496974,
0.1675722301,
0.1291950494,
-0.3816158772,
-0.071656011,
0.0707362443,
-0.0136031117,
0.4757924676,
0.3971332908,
-0.6819577217,
-0.2767057717,
-0.3588173985,
0.061398901,
-0.0794634745,
1.0185835361,
-0.6975536346,
0.6071171761,
0.3496604562,
0.6365771294,
0.5237773061,
-0.1569541842,
0.9709384441,
-0.8323326111,
0.1270258278,
0.0037892982,
0.1992172897,
0.2477653921,
-0.1705486923,
0.3193699419,
-0.0588785075,
-0.3954467773,
-0.5418447256,
0.1775155216,
-0.4043602645,
-0.3129320145,
0.9811137915,
-0.3753654063,
-0.1796353906,
0.2732155621,
-0.4370799065,
0.1787517667,
-0.4204308987,
1.0298162699,
0.7420184016,
-0.2608386874,
-0.3972982466,
-0.3241325617,
0.662062645,
0.5027419329,
-0.8068704605,
0.1501686573,
0.4435303807,
0.4018354118,
-0.0107085137,
0.6045752168,
-0.0916010663,
0.3530107439,
-0.0804564357,
0.1517986506,
0.3063982427,
-0.2925842702,
-0.5511465073,
0.0199590605,
0.6172500849,
0.0836795047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16133v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16133v2 | Exposing and Addressing Cross-Task Inconsistency in Unified Vision-Language Models | 2023-03-28T16:57:12 | 2024-02-21T22:53:33 | Adyasha Maharana, Amita Kamath, Christopher Clark, Mohit Bansal, Aniruddha Kembhavi | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | As general purpose vision models get increasingly effective at a wide set of
tasks, it is imperative that they be consistent across the tasks they support.
Inconsistent AI models are considered brittle and untrustworthy by human users
and are more challenging to incorporate into larger systems that take
dependencies on their outputs. Measuring consistency between very heterogeneous
tasks that might include outputs in different modalities is challenging since
it is difficult to determine if the predictions are consistent with one
another. As a solution, we introduce a benchmark dataset, CocoCon, where we
create contrast sets by modifying test instances for multiple tasks in small
but semantically meaningful ways to change the gold label and outline metrics
for measuring if a model is consistent by ranking the original and perturbed
instances across tasks. We find that state-of-the-art vision-language models
suffer from a surprisingly high degree of inconsistent behavior across tasks,
especially for more heterogeneous tasks. To alleviate this issue, we propose a
rank correlation-based auxiliary training objective, computed over large
automatically created cross-task contrast sets, that improves the multi-task
consistency of large unified models while retaining their original accuracy on
downstream tasks. | [
-0.1176736206,
-0.4597017765,
0.4350555837,
0.3921461105,
0.0081549073,
-0.0188736469,
-0.258785665,
-0.7612571716,
0.1092915908,
0.3524048924,
-0.2624185681,
-0.4062489867,
-0.870290637,
0.0931536555,
-0.4104278088,
0.7549917698,
-0.2873744369,
0.0067486577,
-0.5822217464,
-0.5575392246,
-0.588999629,
-0.3820497692,
-0.5768607855,
-0.1459907889,
0.4697573185,
0.5629525185,
0.9471296072,
0.5247548819,
0.7259104848,
0.3014548719,
0.3472565114,
0.471457392,
-0.3414984345,
-0.014453711,
-0.3732001185,
-0.235687241,
-0.3839473724,
-0.0402670205,
0.4658205509,
0.8819075823,
0.0092233717,
-0.1132546514,
0.6371707916,
0.2189758122,
-1.0633299351,
0.4225096107,
-0.8650243282,
-0.009157775,
-0.1300714314,
-0.0644975156,
-0.2669821084,
0.3657614291,
-0.0510644466,
-0.8359154463,
0.5178229213,
0.0586871803,
1.1545921564,
0.5264091492,
-0.1438641399,
0.0924794748,
-0.6464014053,
0.9243704081,
-0.5156276226,
0.484382689,
0.4181880057,
0.1096843109,
0.0746507198,
-0.6023074389,
-0.3734043837,
-0.4437161684,
-0.2794824243,
0.3033160269,
-0.0482529514,
-0.0088375174,
-0.0021432927,
0.1654227972,
-0.465115726,
0.1483467221,
0.0189615488,
-0.2082901895,
0.6761535406,
0.440644592,
0.274749279,
0.1967259049,
-0.2970849574,
-0.2503125072,
-0.6631637216,
0.1973985136,
0.3013425767,
0.3128076196,
-0.4632136226,
0.6422630548,
-0.4896600842,
0.8302345276,
0.0951861292,
0.087238878,
0.1575123966,
-0.5053222775,
-0.3848490715,
-0.1093173325,
0.7037838697,
0.3081591725,
-0.0306867901,
-0.4614582956,
0.0141798826,
0.5171978474,
0.4584784806,
-0.296120882,
-0.5439400673,
0.1923884749,
-0.0304446332,
-0.1971219778,
0.1220774055,
-0.4381563365,
-0.3776001334,
-0.5830776691,
0.4590943158,
-0.1570971161,
0.0949754864,
-0.1920492053,
0.2072887719,
-0.0372330099,
0.4710631967,
-1.1146483421,
0.291796416,
0.5536632538,
0.5577042699,
-0.5486807823,
-0.7840647697,
-0.4603484273,
0.1724921763,
-0.546071887,
0.7748064399,
-0.709824264,
-0.2600533366,
-0.0833591521,
0.2431007177,
-0.5137836933,
-0.5362263322,
0.435013026,
0.1156852245,
-0.1059599668,
-0.2807706296,
-0.322307229,
0.1873609722,
0.4827705324,
-0.3351678848,
1.1831469536,
0.0410262235,
-0.8247836828,
0.4606399834,
-0.202655673,
-0.2240730971,
-0.0669317096,
-0.7580957413,
-0.5315786004,
0.2550952435,
0.3079003394,
0.3390675187,
-0.377815783,
0.2373770475,
-0.4182884097,
-0.5528850555,
0.0207820293,
-0.4597961903,
0.7167194486,
-0.1880518943,
-0.5607376099,
0.2544640899,
-0.6368279457,
-0.0704427809,
-0.0164666921,
-0.1336584985,
-0.4504483938,
0.0767111331,
0.0394657664,
0.0535617322,
0.3836862147,
-0.6656141877,
0.0239562746,
0.2417518198,
-0.0178849548,
0.7288920879,
-0.3431946933,
0.2366512418,
-0.4065150917,
0.0997426659,
0.4301115572,
0.410208106,
0.0429928936,
-0.5972258449,
-1.1608870029,
-0.2344786972,
-0.0621890873,
0.4015540481,
-0.5667689443,
0.3131077886,
-0.364489913,
-0.4546379149,
-0.4783727825,
0.3656595349,
0.4773786664,
0.6656715274,
0.555898428,
-0.6614342928,
-0.5504678488,
-1.0785928965,
-0.320805341,
0.0208505709,
0.1442576945,
0.4305313528,
0.3341004252,
-0.4508256912,
0.7283297777,
-0.3352195919,
-0.3629680872,
0.133078441,
0.2785287797,
-0.1636433303,
0.9537975788,
0.2395378053,
-0.9835009575,
-0.6595342159,
0.2516035736,
-0.899974823,
0.0493938252,
-0.0068776868,
-0.1601142138,
0.2862865329,
0.7009730339,
-0.0611779504,
0.5852181911,
0.8891529441,
-0.2152221352,
0.5374104977,
-0.4404569268,
0.4927172065,
-0.7278968096,
0.2663526237,
0.1603108346,
0.0519474186,
-0.3951489031,
-0.0220612176,
0.1162950173,
0.0608383641,
-0.3503900766,
0.4123430848,
-0.3160127103,
-0.1873225272,
-0.0586499646,
-0.094044596,
0.248557508,
0.6586951017,
0.1877522469,
0.7000041008,
0.8894903064,
-0.5124377012,
0.3247687221,
0.2573500872,
-0.3068962991,
0.994130373,
-0.66591084,
-0.0439258255,
0.0456348546,
0.009285694,
-1.0295860767,
-0.3406777382,
0.2916407585,
-0.1470240653,
0.2059250176,
-0.0085653812,
-0.3519589901,
0.0152341565,
0.087052919,
0.6418834925,
0.193590343,
-0.5815025568,
0.8145016432,
0.2060538232,
0.0810902417,
-0.9806488752,
-0.6454844475,
0.0517171845,
0.0799433738,
-0.4761648178,
0.5839538574,
-0.1445608735,
-0.1440747976,
0.0639230162,
-0.345423907,
-0.3213262856,
0.0459617898,
0.7063055038,
0.535141468,
-0.1613529921,
-0.1516564786,
-0.2612707913,
0.2527155876,
-0.2906344533,
0.0595876724,
0.1752566248,
-0.1705658287,
-0.6539162397,
-0.387090385,
0.2747347355,
0.6213291883,
-0.3103570342,
0.5310928822,
0.4797847569,
-0.2568348646,
0.0585587248,
-0.6612405777,
0.0804238096,
-0.4200313389,
0.3683589101,
-0.6407421827,
-0.6239594817,
0.672604382,
0.3064763248,
0.2479512095,
0.3809945881,
0.1372352093,
-0.1987594664,
1.2118233442,
0.9743332863,
0.0165352654,
0.4724416137,
-0.1018324047,
-0.055930078,
-0.9840810299,
-0.5088285804,
-0.5511956811,
-0.1408391595,
-0.3428237736,
-0.3905636072,
0.3147539496,
0.0962272435,
-0.2308136225,
0.5428515673,
-0.3797825277,
0.3088135123,
0.499199152,
0.1535220146,
0.446269691,
0.1463697553,
-0.2401777506,
0.1383236349,
-0.9677472115,
-0.1491851509,
1.0032820702,
-0.1233513877,
0.9122571945,
-0.2144845277,
0.4736927152,
0.3053635359,
0.4202602506,
-0.1850975305,
0.2586709261,
-0.576508522,
-0.3419840932,
-0.2661875188,
-0.3909808695,
-0.9653949738,
0.5350605249,
-0.380454123,
-1.0783971548,
0.5031028986,
0.5262178183,
-0.0743038356,
0.2669824958,
-0.4304579794,
1.4276374578,
-0.1985624135,
-0.7579075694,
-0.0068145115,
-0.6661881208,
0.5161493421,
0.1626616418,
-0.0774222463,
-0.3086113334,
0.1651050001,
0.3039439917,
-0.2575494051,
0.8937293887,
0.5044606924,
0.0242095497,
0.1518656909,
-0.0641254783,
0.4573947191,
-0.0938948393,
0.233960852,
0.5402142406,
-0.2125013769,
-0.7314423323,
-0.4706095457,
0.944601655,
-0.9036113024,
-0.5475901365,
-0.410921514,
-1.0099709034,
-0.497746259,
-0.2205216289,
0.4984301329,
0.737039566,
-0.3072030246,
0.055280827,
0.4992800653,
0.0459679402,
0.2850193381,
0.2880757749,
0.2546559572,
-0.0179280601,
0.9552949667,
-0.2497445345,
0.4142130017,
0.4187607467,
-0.2491751015,
-0.2024757117,
-0.2857344747,
-0.5230246186,
-0.1128167361,
-0.7150982022,
0.0336993635,
-0.5656971335,
-0.1039173454,
-0.5336292982,
-0.3527750373,
-0.6355429888,
-0.0802830905,
-0.2897796333,
0.5072274208,
-0.1849073172,
0.5708678365,
-0.1401718259,
0.0644533336,
-0.6303149462,
0.4444698691,
0.4353946149,
0.2883907855,
-0.1289238632,
-0.4570345581,
-0.3473701477,
0.1026639342,
-0.2666209936,
-0.3005199432,
-0.0732859001,
0.1291663349,
0.7753852606,
0.4453246295,
-0.1063905954,
0.8582635522,
-0.3507052958,
0.6844348907,
0.494584769,
-1.0826101303,
0.2544983327,
-0.0304174796,
0.3781760037,
0.7021951675,
0.2614338696,
-0.5257623196,
-0.8425229788,
-0.7929592729,
-0.7871214151,
0.5890681744,
0.3431919813,
-0.1828595102,
0.1567833722,
-0.2507205009,
-0.0021150559,
0.1311787069,
-0.455524832,
-0.2461235076,
-0.4321821928,
-0.4037557244,
-0.424952507,
0.0811586529,
-0.4386149347,
-0.0797135383,
0.5575354695,
-0.3116206527,
-0.1238837764,
0.2549540401,
-0.2802918851,
0.0065156408,
0.1753053963,
0.6189756393,
1.0490636826,
-0.0519004762,
0.5036618114,
0.1335337609,
-0.4576831162,
0.0031670416,
0.2720922828,
-0.1030502394,
0.0095090531,
0.3868142962,
0.7578408122,
0.546692729,
-0.7062494755,
0.4724687338,
0.0492011346,
0.1255617738,
-0.0628311336,
0.2786014378,
-0.1958649755,
0.0439615324,
0.1988278031,
0.4774000645,
-0.0662370622,
-0.8045182228,
0.1620609164,
0.5610734224,
-0.719012022,
-0.0305832811,
0.8308552504,
0.2385829538,
0.0968488902,
0.5807416439,
0.2653891444,
-0.3639590144,
0.8958311677,
0.1291131675,
0.6756309271,
-0.2147752345,
0.2163624167,
0.1698542535,
0.3895923495,
-0.4024677873,
0.0428116545,
-0.1872169971,
-0.9720512033,
-0.1495723277,
-0.3665059209,
-0.6863211393,
-0.0583251379,
-0.7011777163,
-0.023297241,
-0.246840179,
0.0077145891,
-0.0059040394,
-0.3734996319,
-0.9006575346,
0.5668103099,
0.041433569,
0.4588731527,
-1.0025146008,
0.88830477,
0.6427643299,
-0.6537271142,
-0.7446241379,
-0.1265885532,
-0.19079566,
-0.7428535819,
0.5426681042,
0.057166446,
-0.1069292203,
-0.3794680238,
-0.45383358,
-0.7136482,
0.9809075594,
0.3386459947,
-0.5929620266,
0.0691800863,
0.3177365661,
0.3042921424,
-0.7179102898,
0.1339354813,
0.4689393044,
0.4326234162,
-0.0729399472,
-1.1428198814,
-0.0249444582,
-0.0931375921,
0.2095666528,
0.0098389657,
-0.5753889084,
0.9754589796,
-0.2624418437,
-0.1243387908,
0.2560717762,
0.5845609903,
0.3133279085,
0.3481218219,
0.5257050991,
0.7139974833,
0.5029796958,
-0.1728108674,
1.0883497,
-0.345869422,
0.354760915,
1.6270413399,
-0.356962204,
0.6936231852,
0.5995557308,
0.1254406869,
0.3539693356,
0.389108777,
-0.284565866,
0.4137237072,
-0.0716239512,
-0.1610963643,
-0.5891427994,
-0.3364638388,
-0.2531263828,
0.5273663998,
-0.0356844515,
-0.3045112491,
-0.2031546533,
-0.0703913867,
-0.3482831419,
0.1980037093,
-0.4666692615,
0.2881492376,
-0.1233382151,
-0.9408271909,
0.5792027712,
-0.1884094179,
0.643879354,
-0.6220483184,
-0.1777497828,
-0.31988585,
0.4194431901,
-0.2245414853,
-0.53777951,
0.2428688258,
-0.15185754,
-0.1794122756,
0.1737259924,
0.3455992341,
-0.6638152599,
-0.6570852399,
0.2847530246,
0.364166975,
0.0246025752,
-0.0098486235,
-0.7473332882,
0.5703716874,
-0.1415308118,
0.2712445557,
0.3069072962,
-0.0421503708,
-0.1605042815,
0.4665232897,
0.4520439506,
-0.1174273938,
0.141026035,
0.0221091285,
0.5092046261,
-0.2028250098,
-0.4507010877,
-0.4857583642,
0.5929641724,
-0.2801829576,
-0.6425153017,
0.9070109725,
0.6481589079,
1.144408226,
0.0012527029,
0.5555145741,
-0.0655356422,
-0.0042391419,
-0.4287241995,
0.4231002629,
-0.9073966742,
0.0895384848,
-0.2488591969,
-0.999358356,
-0.2288951129,
0.3579874337,
-0.0550951213,
-0.0874163359,
0.8534311056,
0.8629599214,
-0.5229939222,
-0.3252505064,
0.6684547663,
0.1258012354,
-0.0205249768,
0.8085603714,
0.6186509728,
-0.5616796017,
0.6758754253,
-0.4409468472,
-0.0323915035,
-0.2742823958,
-0.7124211788,
-0.6868955493,
-0.5959832668,
-0.7985064387,
-0.3588844538,
0.4785602689,
0.4435154796,
0.9295204878,
-1.0910005569,
-0.4231655896,
-0.2795479,
0.0397785977,
-0.7022322416,
-0.1890719533,
0.4254204035,
-0.4136769176,
-0.9796330929,
0.2889050245,
0.4011467695,
0.0137723321,
-0.2352188081,
-0.1247395277,
-0.0288381856,
0.1192593873,
0.185842067,
0.6359910369,
-0.9567381144,
-0.4956294596,
-0.2530200481,
-0.5806596279,
0.2805554271,
0.8023919463,
-0.435087204,
0.5714149475,
0.2525490522,
0.7903836966,
0.4056198001,
0.0535082296,
0.4939182699,
-0.7823482752,
0.2029250264,
0.0012991969,
0.7783893347,
0.6869744062,
-0.2241314352,
0.7224884033,
0.2582286,
-0.3667651415,
-0.5653846264,
0.3215600848,
-1.3437628746,
-0.3642531037,
0.7951170802,
-0.5494864583,
-0.0343896747,
-0.1656090319,
0.0380655676,
0.1050768718,
0.0057755597,
0.9252002239,
0.550358057,
-0.3218250275,
-0.0964388028,
-0.2031666338,
0.4881235659,
0.7536606789,
-0.961124897,
-0.0383853912,
0.4588136673,
0.3719082177,
0.3594442308,
0.3909524679,
-0.0431529507,
0.4339482784,
0.3906531036,
0.1271131039,
0.0576221794,
-0.6233182549,
-0.0879289582,
0.1555486917,
-0.2096661627,
-0.4320874214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16104v1 | Hallucinations in Large Multilingual Translation Models | 2023-03-28T16:17:59 | 2023-03-28T16:17:59 | Nuno M. Guerreiro, Duarte Alves, Jonas Waldendorf, Barry Haddow, Alexandra Birch, Pierre Colombo, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale multilingual machine translation systems have demonstrated
remarkable ability to translate directly between numerous languages, making
them increasingly appealing for real-world applications. However, when deployed
in the wild, these models may generate hallucinated translations which have the
potential to severely undermine user trust and raise safety concerns. Existing
research on hallucinations has primarily focused on small bilingual models
trained on high-resource languages, leaving a gap in our understanding of
hallucinations in massively multilingual models across diverse translation
scenarios. In this work, we fill this gap by conducting a comprehensive
analysis on both the M2M family of conventional neural machine translation
models and ChatGPT, a general-purpose large language model~(LLM) that can be
prompted for translation. Our investigation covers a broad spectrum of
conditions, spanning over 100 translation directions across various resource
levels and going beyond English-centric language pairs. We provide key insights
regarding the prevalence, properties, and mitigation of hallucinations, paving
the way towards more responsible and reliable machine translation systems. | [
-0.3378532231,
-0.7631670237,
0.5216789842,
0.4141519964,
-0.1598702371,
-0.2332230359,
-0.3322369456,
-0.7167198062,
0.1653450578,
0.8880731463,
-0.6262180805,
-0.3500027359,
-0.8503857255,
0.2922558486,
-0.6829613447,
1.1071503162,
0.1479089111,
0.3280864656,
0.3853577077,
-0.0733790174,
-0.6845092773,
-1.1022975445,
-0.5883226395,
-0.250156492,
0.6165302992,
-0.2143944651,
1.0453398228,
-0.0028637904,
0.7186493874,
0.1948033124,
0.0148683386,
0.3691012561,
-0.5590181947,
0.3242461979,
0.1498120874,
-0.3956528604,
-0.5686427355,
-0.1966624707,
0.4085297883,
0.6940031648,
-0.2822902501,
-0.3454665542,
0.1354301572,
0.3574983776,
-0.1979849935,
0.1687038094,
-0.9345318675,
0.5355445743,
0.0903909653,
-0.368209362,
-0.8331234455,
-0.2179825604,
0.0617068335,
-0.3267237842,
0.145716697,
0.3377944231,
0.544405818,
0.3085775077,
-0.6200022101,
-0.5329911709,
-0.8427556753,
0.5419051051,
-0.5276924372,
0.6147577167,
0.3098008335,
0.3800814748,
-0.423536092,
-0.5223681927,
-0.5665379167,
-0.4391601384,
-0.1692693532,
-0.0098812291,
-0.2287067324,
-0.0323672853,
0.2258255333,
0.1918901503,
-0.7717625499,
0.1500426531,
-0.3268558085,
-0.3893553019,
0.3723050058,
0.3110494018,
0.5954591036,
-0.4113866687,
-0.2303162962,
-0.0922189951,
-0.4627854824,
-0.5076726675,
0.4316189885,
0.414914161,
-0.0222468134,
0.7343478799,
0.300593555,
0.4590340555,
-0.4461684525,
0.019686535,
0.203618601,
-0.2257074118,
-0.0810642466,
0.2085608989,
1.0448865891,
0.5638800859,
0.5102412701,
-0.7955362797,
-0.2762214839,
-0.0455678627,
0.5724406838,
-0.8164863586,
-0.1006073654,
0.4286887944,
-0.4307924211,
-0.2548632026,
-0.1295164078,
-0.8527284861,
-0.6938614845,
-0.2753933966,
0.4667401016,
-0.6295793056,
-0.3968918025,
0.406904012,
0.1809745133,
0.2031998187,
0.2017468363,
-0.8371608257,
0.0033842819,
0.6160475612,
1.0022382736,
-0.4307868183,
-0.7111395001,
-0.2742243111,
0.0816233531,
-0.5383755565,
0.5138308406,
-0.2836970389,
-0.3952178955,
0.1684979498,
0.2614412308,
-0.2546911836,
-0.6681792736,
0.4167285562,
-0.4953546226,
0.1028803736,
-0.0729541332,
0.0640386641,
-0.3012383878,
0.3095678389,
-0.5489595532,
0.5662820339,
-0.2988650203,
-0.5037540197,
0.0622273162,
-0.3303960264,
-0.5244296193,
-0.2607024312,
-0.1470830292,
-0.2850711942,
0.4208423197,
0.1516233385,
0.6321617365,
-0.2216821909,
0.3606971204,
-0.0472533219,
-0.2664874494,
0.640681684,
-0.6470233202,
0.6103852391,
0.3556308448,
-0.3518882096,
0.269872874,
-0.3261080086,
-0.2149844319,
0.1669923216,
0.1896302849,
-0.0674806088,
-0.1559931338,
0.2494809926,
0.4252339303,
-0.0285774544,
0.034047164,
0.1613915265,
-0.1637333184,
0.4496787786,
0.588776052,
0.0803715661,
0.1918957233,
-0.0713616088,
0.5604667664,
0.4200973213,
0.2072165161,
-0.2550601363,
-0.7069327235,
-0.6087324023,
-0.0801912323,
-0.138168484,
0.5155006051,
-0.5804262161,
0.2731356323,
-0.3299146891,
-0.1423212737,
-0.6383992434,
-0.1043587402,
0.1403482556,
0.0558764674,
0.4777239561,
-0.0717146322,
-0.2809574008,
-0.9312362075,
-0.0936982855,
0.1423388571,
-0.0518350564,
0.2304977924,
0.468836844,
-0.8826853037,
0.0783636943,
-0.209187597,
-0.6685082316,
-0.1654776484,
0.1651523858,
0.0564834774,
0.3622672558,
0.4548386335,
-0.8599020839,
-0.2790023386,
0.5352506042,
-0.9617767334,
0.2049778104,
-0.5388498306,
-0.0756712109,
0.4966543615,
0.5465202332,
-0.8362089992,
0.3294509649,
0.9479647875,
-0.1848882139,
0.7176019549,
-0.4478686154,
0.4622241259,
-1.3060882092,
0.0089695361,
-0.4389802516,
0.0055621378,
-0.5494374037,
0.3080666959,
-0.0604921132,
-0.2556631565,
-0.2563458681,
0.0224327911,
-0.4284566045,
-0.1838938594,
-0.2095178515,
0.3213764429,
-0.3327435553,
0.3566212356,
-0.0412364192,
0.8450345397,
0.4840885699,
-0.4135579467,
0.3105161488,
0.2017674297,
-0.2985109687,
0.1773443222,
-0.3202473223,
0.2409604043,
0.0205003265,
0.1368475705,
-0.826331079,
-0.5354366899,
0.3872046471,
-0.5629452467,
0.2468405366,
-0.0149693293,
-0.9277448654,
-0.0824172646,
0.1841586381,
0.2450588942,
0.509830296,
-0.4508045614,
0.5133811235,
0.2821958363,
-0.0225068722,
-0.2762115598,
-0.9634684324,
0.554485321,
-0.3137832582,
-0.6065984368,
0.0546374656,
0.0468367487,
-0.2670645118,
-0.297062546,
0.0116721587,
-0.0603417121,
-0.0051273643,
0.3401019275,
0.1058214456,
-0.1704386175,
-0.0535126925,
-0.0326567851,
-0.1920222193,
0.3135670125,
-0.2977606654,
0.9222841859,
-0.2136839777,
-0.5461955667,
-0.1929369569,
0.5006662607,
0.9214692116,
-0.1580566317,
1.1215077639,
0.8950932026,
-0.5246300101,
-0.2822261155,
-0.5829173326,
-0.4614568353,
-0.3580382168,
0.7045944333,
-0.6427630186,
-0.7227237225,
0.9470489621,
0.1242985725,
-0.2201599628,
0.3150426149,
0.8670588136,
0.1639997214,
1.4800025225,
0.4096251428,
-0.0642209724,
0.0226505753,
-0.051810611,
0.567905128,
-0.710318625,
-0.469679445,
-0.3849108219,
-0.1255452633,
-0.7734168172,
-0.6578065157,
0.4475950599,
-0.0368976034,
0.3417671323,
0.3019048572,
-0.4480288327,
0.4155242741,
0.0689630881,
-0.0769801289,
0.4210915267,
0.2484613359,
-0.176663056,
-0.3086016774,
-0.5403714776,
-0.5937714577,
0.9230928421,
0.1660163254,
0.4822176993,
0.2519825697,
0.3979011774,
0.1765407622,
-0.0043244041,
-0.9249482155,
0.4738326967,
-0.1519196481,
-0.7178817987,
-0.2238049656,
-0.5271832347,
-1.0451294184,
0.7175078392,
-0.1288769096,
-0.8531500697,
-0.0814999267,
-0.2232288718,
-0.1239917427,
0.5067436099,
-0.6477352977,
0.8709407449,
-0.4523401558,
-0.0786094591,
-0.4103924334,
-0.5183493495,
0.5979151726,
-0.4482947588,
0.2468070537,
0.0202676877,
0.214710325,
0.2142122537,
0.1019070521,
0.7043048143,
0.3070365191,
-0.581154108,
-0.0656848401,
0.5878195763,
0.535692215,
0.0290747751,
-0.0731547773,
0.5851032138,
-0.1279532462,
-0.200379476,
-0.4822762907,
0.7946427464,
-0.8671431541,
-0.5831381083,
-0.4289536774,
-0.9470647573,
-0.2446784675,
0.1590036005,
0.4980501831,
-0.0254691709,
-0.1319268048,
0.1884000003,
0.8085556626,
-0.4203187823,
0.1517073214,
0.2293965667,
-0.9339848757,
-0.3238640726,
1.0747845173,
0.2136870176,
0.2914885879,
-0.0282732993,
-0.1155106723,
-0.0002136551,
-0.8002619147,
-0.4847698808,
0.2227270901,
-0.6346598864,
0.2194664031,
-0.9497616887,
-0.3579620123,
-0.5160824656,
-0.0296385176,
-0.5063624978,
-0.1037053913,
-0.2016910315,
0.0184895284,
0.0269366577,
0.6117824912,
0.1539278179,
0.1691098064,
-0.8311421275,
0.5193755031,
0.0129001364,
0.1133359075,
0.0303413887,
-0.6850870848,
-0.2237364054,
0.1510546207,
-0.1749907583,
-0.8629526496,
0.7525470257,
-0.2783082426,
0.4348068535,
0.4946326613,
-0.0327429846,
0.7198638916,
-0.6527035236,
0.7607059479,
0.3152394593,
-0.5787401199,
0.120520249,
-0.5229410529,
0.0381469503,
0.1319305152,
0.5899279118,
-0.9620393515,
-0.5145653486,
-0.1904977411,
-0.7523180842,
0.426497817,
0.3574757576,
0.3789815605,
0.0049464884,
0.1293769479,
0.5814310908,
0.0893974826,
-0.9739871025,
0.0225460064,
-0.058999382,
0.1899622828,
-0.3047250509,
-0.1274029613,
-0.0720081925,
-0.068018809,
0.4501555562,
-0.0643664151,
0.3950657547,
-0.0021405451,
-0.3158272505,
-0.1226299405,
0.2039596885,
0.8735324144,
0.509950459,
-0.2441980392,
0.2705002725,
0.1638372838,
-0.482350409,
-0.0200594813,
-0.0438496284,
-0.0425078832,
0.0267565772,
0.2603313029,
0.96298033,
0.1305274218,
-0.4897084832,
0.2812437117,
-0.0249651428,
-0.1961398274,
-0.4534912705,
-0.2058153749,
0.1223387197,
0.247888431,
0.2984586656,
0.2865967453,
0.1136912331,
-0.6297796369,
-0.0010540202,
0.3633189499,
-0.6012423635,
-0.6528257132,
0.6987425089,
-0.083436802,
-0.5237716436,
0.7788968682,
-0.0683557242,
-0.7291966081,
0.3051426709,
0.6774020195,
1.278996706,
-0.187260136,
0.177317664,
0.160142228,
0.8430066109,
-0.1560914665,
-0.1440759897,
0.3209181428,
-0.6924300194,
-0.2687219381,
-0.5327339172,
-0.3330959082,
0.3405863643,
-0.5668851137,
0.2384401113,
0.0408222601,
-0.2066227198,
-0.3006491661,
-0.547688961,
-0.4946647286,
-0.1990502179,
0.3923224807,
0.3840164244,
-0.6588464379,
1.0213327408,
0.3827980161,
-0.3816773891,
-0.3864545226,
0.3572622836,
-0.0463673621,
-0.6832436919,
0.4898279309,
0.3382067382,
-0.3223101795,
0.0952670574,
-0.21471183,
-0.3826855421,
0.7407876849,
0.386757195,
-0.5381676555,
-0.267234832,
0.7427449822,
0.727399528,
-0.2921077013,
-0.0598729402,
0.510215342,
0.4490434825,
-0.0315784439,
-1.0124646425,
0.0623313747,
0.0502911694,
-0.0893008858,
0.1928468645,
-0.5622553229,
0.674372673,
-0.2717546821,
-0.1320423484,
-0.1061575338,
0.220145151,
0.0986625999,
0.1557490379,
0.1249000579,
0.3254547715,
0.5945762992,
-0.0480293557,
1.1297235489,
-0.4382172227,
0.0279731154,
0.9877550602,
-0.4079789519,
0.823661685,
0.8112969398,
0.0976108685,
-0.0696454346,
0.524939239,
-0.0654435754,
0.3978835642,
0.117871888,
-0.0736562759,
-0.3574642241,
0.0025064426,
-0.7327361107,
0.2233798057,
0.4678393304,
-0.457279563,
0.1171722785,
0.3611066341,
0.1319913864,
-0.2680754066,
0.0519482493,
0.6736955643,
0.4210426211,
-0.8171787858,
0.626480937,
-0.0780260265,
0.6215583086,
-0.5445178747,
0.0877986923,
-0.3912758231,
0.3191047013,
-0.0935669765,
-0.4570319951,
0.5486776829,
-0.1252085418,
0.0074087549,
-0.2848972678,
0.4203384519,
-0.3747250736,
-0.4080475271,
0.8174474239,
0.5326945782,
0.4951428771,
-0.4753643572,
-0.4833977818,
0.289957583,
0.0196576081,
-0.3357833624,
0.4850283265,
0.8487340808,
-0.0943061411,
0.8280606866,
0.7170560956,
0.2324459255,
0.4400840402,
0.0682657659,
0.566755712,
-0.6891818047,
-0.2607513368,
-0.8945719004,
0.3864262402,
0.2630250156,
-0.2370986193,
1.0534024239,
0.5034242868,
0.8598622084,
-0.3655744493,
0.6274967194,
0.3076648712,
-0.2092210501,
-0.5173787475,
1.2829070091,
-0.5328298211,
0.2617635429,
-0.2105632424,
-1.1890138388,
-0.5490968823,
0.4997547567,
-0.2148139924,
-0.1235139892,
1.0031306744,
0.9682161212,
0.0018276228,
0.0244999137,
0.8546159267,
0.4527288079,
0.258951515,
0.450162977,
0.9154519439,
-0.4760689437,
0.9495353103,
-0.1384050846,
0.2425084859,
-0.404556483,
-0.6168680787,
-1.0401533842,
-0.6728367805,
-0.2475617975,
-0.4540068507,
0.024747692,
0.7235743999,
0.5257480741,
-1.059555769,
-0.4390804768,
0.0134224631,
-0.0356744006,
-0.129368335,
-0.1649909019,
0.185989067,
-0.5252058506,
-0.762475729,
0.2872454822,
0.3012399673,
0.2985993028,
-0.6279318333,
-0.3527473807,
0.1578472406,
0.0748492256,
0.7706003785,
-0.3322325349,
-1.1272879839,
-0.1783989072,
0.3252105117,
-0.4759044945,
0.0394229889,
0.7854630947,
-0.2446716428,
0.5415015817,
0.264395386,
0.5420030951,
0.4200875461,
-0.5284750462,
0.6170694828,
-0.2815005779,
0.4297969043,
0.2727160156,
0.1970597953,
0.1821017712,
-0.2861305773,
0.5754546523,
0.1451001465,
-0.4762701988,
-1.1404616833,
0.2042743415,
-0.9178391695,
-0.3392491937,
1.1542725563,
0.0428203642,
-0.0511720851,
0.0176130645,
-0.4615761042,
0.2917608023,
0.0549147315,
1.3527463675,
1.0039970875,
0.1438080966,
-0.1703601182,
-1.0782831907,
0.4267120957,
0.5115627646,
-0.6361545324,
0.322958082,
0.5388006568,
-0.2657227218,
0.2794333398,
0.0590210296,
-0.2664812207,
0.038811285,
0.1950234771,
0.2305496782,
0.0796793401,
-0.4252537489,
-0.3954985738,
0.3247558475,
-0.0669441968,
0.0925495103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16749v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16749v2 | Improving Code Generation by Training with Natural Language Feedback | 2023-03-28T16:15:31 | 2024-02-22T22:30:31 | Angelica Chen, Jérémy Scheurer, Tomasz Korbak, Jon Ander Campos, Jun Shern Chan, Samuel R. Bowman, Kyunghyun Cho, Ethan Perez | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The potential for pre-trained large language models (LLMs) to use natural
language feedback at inference time has been an exciting recent development. We
build upon this observation by formalizing an algorithm for learning from
natural language feedback at training time instead, which we call Imitation
learning from Language Feedback (ILF). ILF requires only a small amount of
human-written feedback during training and does not require the same feedback
at test time, making it both user-friendly and sample-efficient. We further
show that ILF can be seen as a form of minimizing the KL divergence to the
ground truth distribution and demonstrate a proof-of-concept on a neural
program synthesis task. We use ILF to improve a Codegen-Mono 6.1B model's
pass@1 rate by 38% relative (and 10% absolute) on the Mostly Basic Python
Problems (MBPP) benchmark, outperforming both fine-tuning on MBPP and
fine-tuning on repaired programs written by humans. Overall, our results
suggest that learning from human-written natural language feedback is both more
effective and sample-efficient than training exclusively on demonstrations for
improving an LLM's performance on code generation tasks. | [
-0.2911101282,
-0.6776112318,
0.270273298,
0.3526936173,
-0.1122722179,
0.2380927652,
-0.4853239059,
-0.6129477024,
-0.0360939465,
0.4135466218,
-0.5939757228,
-0.4874996543,
-0.2581617534,
0.2208200246,
-0.2229583412,
0.9975773692,
0.0437222458,
0.2145736665,
-0.1784130931,
0.0820780173,
0.0430032909,
-0.6477345228,
-0.7513254285,
-0.5267125368,
0.443343699,
0.3661045134,
0.1969096959,
0.4525391161,
0.1519643813,
0.2362519056,
0.1858785599,
0.3270388842,
-0.370921284,
-0.3357791007,
0.0725124478,
-0.6937762499,
-0.1316300929,
0.1812468618,
0.5184808373,
0.762022078,
-0.2555881739,
0.0714295432,
0.2486192584,
1.0156704187,
-0.4928982854,
0.2791530192,
-0.4921525419,
0.2004237175,
0.3330873251,
-0.2596652806,
-0.6499282718,
-0.7248697877,
0.0336844213,
-0.4435804486,
0.3159712553,
-0.0096386913,
0.5839270353,
0.2390540391,
0.083303079,
-0.5022550821,
-0.8578960896,
0.7971144319,
-1.0634009838,
0.0995221287,
0.3093478978,
0.0131176012,
-0.3621787429,
-0.5436521769,
-0.5467630029,
-0.8360539675,
-0.0194130912,
-0.0478241406,
0.1781842411,
0.1662680507,
0.385963589,
0.3181557655,
-0.1940035075,
-0.0125525957,
-0.4209520519,
-0.3398791552,
0.6975209713,
-0.081841439,
0.1738939434,
-0.0164612457,
-0.1010459512,
-0.0966614187,
-0.9338952899,
0.2169336975,
0.6461495757,
0.28815642,
-0.0310755726,
0.2624024153,
-0.2155118138,
0.8755374551,
-0.0018841561,
-0.2077461034,
0.2023159862,
-0.4781063795,
-0.0367188789,
0.0296291485,
0.6451781988,
0.2153953165,
0.3649817109,
-0.3035183847,
-0.3086954057,
0.1490782499,
0.279818058,
-0.859239161,
-0.3164879382,
-0.1508589536,
-0.4128359258,
-0.4960210919,
0.2775595188,
-0.6051032543,
-0.1636386514,
-0.6885079741,
0.3315467834,
-0.4956694543,
-0.1543042064,
0.113087073,
-0.0349587984,
0.3637517393,
0.2800934911,
-0.7458640933,
0.3098394573,
0.5469161868,
0.618116796,
0.0609100908,
-0.4814205766,
-0.8200438023,
-0.1772929579,
-0.6302070618,
0.7546897531,
-0.2474443167,
-0.3461498618,
0.0100979758,
-0.3617790043,
0.055192709,
-0.9102791548,
0.024498852,
-0.226540789,
0.146029368,
0.0444013961,
-0.5869383812,
-0.0076486119,
0.1846997887,
-0.416649729,
1.0160210133,
0.2418338805,
-0.6916100383,
0.5639273524,
-0.8256459236,
-0.6980217695,
-0.20352979,
-0.0967790559,
-0.2209495157,
0.2454285026,
0.3186882138,
0.239685148,
-0.0167223383,
-0.0183824878,
-0.3037227988,
-0.4388312697,
0.201023683,
-0.2617284954,
0.313405484,
0.1661744118,
-0.5691711903,
-0.078374885,
-0.9942851663,
0.4257787764,
-0.0569404662,
-0.7884668708,
-0.1763273478,
0.1501478255,
-0.2762989104,
-0.0854310244,
-0.118663691,
-0.3748193383,
0.418410778,
-1.0114245415,
0.3371624649,
0.6139753461,
0.251000315,
0.6188191772,
-0.5274305344,
0.5660902858,
-0.1577073336,
-0.0831440985,
-0.2820866704,
-0.1199365258,
-0.8685398698,
-0.1065754443,
0.3948680162,
0.3149285614,
-0.760604322,
0.4448375106,
-0.0307572205,
-0.251018852,
-0.6469236612,
0.6477207541,
0.519118011,
0.3690436184,
0.2278958857,
-0.3488281071,
-0.8405644298,
-0.6866329312,
-0.2753231823,
-0.3864077628,
0.0102876117,
0.0356660895,
0.2963245809,
-0.150880754,
0.9697800875,
-0.2379361093,
-0.0745791495,
-0.5876635909,
0.4896293581,
0.3520458639,
0.5927709341,
0.3950867057,
-0.2972344458,
-0.5297229886,
-0.1244593486,
-0.3961934447,
-0.2743472457,
-0.1986583918,
-0.0158602204,
0.598138392,
0.6620309353,
-0.2849160731,
0.4164630473,
0.443292439,
0.0180902109,
0.5756468773,
-0.3799515069,
-0.0711265355,
-0.9434492588,
0.004776421,
-0.3670754135,
-0.2413305193,
-0.5147348642,
0.1987590343,
-0.1538681984,
0.1257185489,
-0.3429013193,
0.3806677163,
-0.6741458774,
0.1211977378,
-0.4453258812,
-0.2628239095,
-0.1703039855,
0.547876358,
0.0690046027,
0.7048433423,
0.2781750262,
-0.8243093491,
0.1332868338,
-0.2018951923,
-0.6206878424,
0.1098333076,
-0.5382092595,
0.5590488911,
-0.1663695127,
0.1720186323,
-0.5821109414,
-0.2172292471,
0.2050132304,
-0.4555636048,
0.2974063754,
-0.2976508141,
-0.6266700625,
-0.30014956,
-0.2377253771,
-0.1533760279,
0.7748243213,
-0.8281545639,
0.4165776968,
-0.0446213521,
0.097379826,
-0.5080618858,
-0.6436698437,
-0.0801320523,
0.1890388876,
-0.4489516616,
0.0914912894,
-0.3729166687,
-0.278816551,
-0.2008955777,
-0.0415244922,
0.0341352001,
0.1867628694,
0.0995295569,
0.0401136242,
-0.2872602344,
0.1570881456,
-0.1798538566,
-0.0487369671,
0.1132511199,
-0.5057362914,
0.4965639114,
-0.2779422402,
-0.389611274,
-0.2904241383,
0.2860031128,
0.3548706174,
-0.1555405557,
0.4884008169,
0.3655246198,
-0.1580665261,
-0.7947190404,
-0.3812892735,
-0.3223365843,
-0.3982336223,
0.2554289699,
-0.0415653437,
-0.5771294832,
0.0708427131,
-0.0398716144,
0.2469459176,
-0.1270306855,
0.4567266703,
-0.1035906076,
1.0370751619,
0.7665382624,
-0.2584599853,
0.5163351893,
-0.4757914841,
0.1990935951,
-0.3733888566,
0.0705102831,
-0.4812684953,
-0.1807186902,
-0.1851740777,
-0.4064563811,
-0.0294793062,
0.5022828579,
0.0859992206,
0.1595649868,
-0.3170245588,
0.7771416903,
0.9339966774,
0.2706435323,
0.3072759509,
0.1183623597,
-0.1926211715,
-0.0700642318,
-0.8385192752,
-0.4221528471,
1.0208864212,
0.0458347909,
1.0326956511,
-0.1763295978,
1.2186273336,
0.1548347622,
0.8429734111,
-0.6886672974,
0.4167990983,
-0.0248863101,
-0.2245951891,
-0.0291595925,
-0.6293555498,
-0.5002149343,
-0.1198211536,
-0.0330318063,
-0.4451657832,
-0.3171365857,
0.6567904949,
-0.415366292,
0.1977876574,
-1.1051161289,
0.5318055153,
-0.1121618599,
-0.2556985617,
-0.2409081608,
-0.435590446,
0.2291018069,
0.1168645695,
0.2398351431,
0.1056572348,
0.3716441691,
0.4726376832,
-0.6878551841,
1.0170412064,
-0.4573742151,
-0.1127966344,
0.5667402744,
0.0898701251,
0.5207646489,
0.2281813473,
-0.0617481507,
-0.3330975473,
-0.2588731349,
-0.3381694257,
-0.767754674,
0.4127843976,
-0.6418479085,
-0.4741584063,
-0.1324917227,
-0.4400724471,
-0.2699829042,
0.0113366349,
0.5261534452,
0.6198028326,
-0.1258281171,
0.1384060979,
0.5930529833,
-0.2601310015,
0.5914623737,
0.4534336329,
-0.4702756405,
-0.3999532163,
0.826666832,
-0.1729281098,
0.5561062694,
0.5201218128,
0.2691418529,
-0.1558277458,
-0.4828184843,
-0.4372365475,
0.1673302203,
-0.7271565795,
-0.1705816835,
-0.3234343231,
-0.242759496,
-0.3786779344,
-0.1272880286,
-0.448261261,
-0.2118303329,
-0.2603294253,
-0.1369708478,
0.0537404418,
0.9708738327,
-0.1887352169,
0.1348696798,
-0.8806653619,
0.1633184999,
0.3299942315,
0.4655330181,
0.0693935454,
-0.3702303171,
-0.3019789159,
0.2815834582,
-0.1372419149,
-0.6980730891,
0.2200298905,
0.4898944795,
0.5877945423,
0.2614408731,
0.0485240929,
0.61944139,
-0.3700733185,
0.6990010738,
0.1722619385,
-0.886208117,
0.4833118021,
0.0853425339,
0.5940175653,
0.5847301483,
0.0632862821,
-0.3209487498,
-0.6522151828,
-0.3892140687,
-0.4896647632,
0.7801765203,
0.0685542971,
0.4685748518,
-0.0117313229,
0.3638185561,
0.1341599375,
0.2412597388,
-1.0194865465,
-0.0260619372,
-0.1622793674,
-0.2477493584,
-0.081152685,
-0.0122557823,
0.0329283476,
-0.4043819606,
0.7774439454,
-0.4690667689,
0.3816363811,
0.4005847275,
-0.3550854027,
-0.1193082556,
0.3072198927,
0.7888880372,
0.6953121424,
-0.1516349614,
0.2351542115,
0.0853496641,
-0.3497411907,
0.2115508169,
-0.1141930297,
-0.2777615488,
0.1410218626,
0.5785717368,
0.7401491404,
0.0739157796,
-0.7438812852,
0.4768154919,
-0.1060435548,
-0.529125452,
-0.3595803976,
0.4698742628,
0.2292715907,
0.0982239395,
0.278914392,
0.2874910533,
-0.0946119428,
-0.4986147285,
0.269002974,
0.2233920693,
-0.4367721379,
-0.4045825303,
0.3428911269,
0.1386439651,
-0.4979914129,
0.6362563968,
-0.444329679,
-0.7013350129,
0.7063410282,
0.6053091288,
0.7969343662,
-0.0252076052,
0.2918252945,
0.6128877401,
0.3905320168,
-0.2197478414,
0.2226932347,
-0.2577375174,
-0.5917104483,
-0.7874493599,
-0.7343698144,
-0.3174949586,
0.1873367727,
-0.5112347603,
0.2775125504,
-0.8603429794,
0.1305255443,
-0.2243939936,
-0.1910215765,
-0.4239132106,
0.0096747028,
0.1764890552,
0.9738361239,
-0.4602122605,
0.9373998046,
0.7285445929,
-0.4914628565,
-1.0384782553,
0.230457738,
-0.3994410634,
-0.571747005,
0.7438360453,
0.5178881288,
-0.2391591817,
0.1081608161,
-1.0520613194,
-0.4802309275,
0.4958567917,
0.5430089831,
-0.4054602981,
-0.0750245005,
0.0396046489,
0.7238821983,
-0.4923116863,
0.1041182429,
0.5116733909,
0.20217444,
-0.1712410748,
-0.5947076678,
-0.2809637189,
-0.3865426481,
0.128418982,
0.1692230999,
-0.2649253607,
0.3299567699,
-0.6197625399,
-0.1497197151,
0.2547974885,
0.8383951187,
0.2009725273,
0.0557119027,
0.7160232663,
0.3876652718,
0.4608205259,
0.1265454739,
1.2356398106,
-0.2092219293,
0.2008533031,
1.3445791006,
-0.0842403024,
0.8071375489,
0.7319973111,
-0.2655295134,
0.7054616809,
0.3247082233,
0.1079602242,
0.6106793284,
0.7006679177,
-0.278691411,
-0.2426961213,
0.2877214253,
-0.2146523893,
0.1194792837,
0.0502997451,
-0.4012443125,
-0.1996509582,
0.0227678958,
-0.1438957006,
0.2854710817,
-0.0770496279,
0.9573306441,
0.1468577683,
-1.13494277,
0.7624213696,
-0.0318007693,
0.7742210627,
-0.6988729835,
-0.4461446702,
-0.5353245139,
0.367323488,
-0.0602543727,
-0.1632023156,
0.2900123894,
-0.0061322646,
-0.4094623029,
-0.2801128924,
0.3879444301,
-0.50588274,
-0.4167661071,
0.382440269,
0.0848675892,
-0.1193396002,
0.0645230636,
-0.489579916,
-0.2909092903,
0.291141659,
-0.2373435497,
0.235909164,
-0.0640811622,
0.3417713344,
0.6429793835,
0.9237989187,
0.231839627,
0.4958545268,
0.182966128,
0.5439069867,
-0.4762545228,
-0.5673374534,
-0.7345858812,
0.2996890545,
-0.0990348309,
-0.3173244298,
0.3384840786,
0.290695399,
1.0528624058,
-0.4037433565,
1.0517815351,
-0.1746694595,
0.7699855566,
-0.8861826062,
0.546215713,
-0.342402488,
0.4233326018,
-0.1439781338,
-0.8862187266,
-0.2593156397,
0.7173706889,
-0.0160595961,
0.0348748416,
0.7395679951,
1.1758021116,
0.0903221294,
-0.0469592884,
0.1555326283,
0.1654766649,
0.3388857841,
0.5682519674,
1.1418181658,
-0.2768837512,
0.6950398684,
-0.5772153139,
-0.1070862859,
-0.0416472889,
-0.9892205596,
-0.9701443315,
-0.2808427215,
-0.3395460546,
-0.5041563511,
-0.0060506496,
1.4362345934,
0.9333239794,
-0.9399654865,
-0.3736500144,
-0.600188911,
0.0402145907,
-0.4079262018,
-0.2161252499,
0.0483704619,
-0.8682796359,
-0.7851302624,
0.5365024805,
0.1354430616,
0.1061539873,
-0.3358391225,
-0.5535804629,
-0.0618172586,
0.0653597042,
0.3852181137,
0.4115032256,
-0.5848644972,
-0.3140530288,
0.105152458,
-0.1754131913,
0.2057751566,
1.0189005136,
-0.6656429768,
0.5780729651,
0.4562732875,
0.8222007751,
0.2544314861,
-0.0729591399,
0.9356567264,
-0.9786228538,
0.2242161483,
0.1452433765,
0.2625218928,
0.4284074008,
-0.2066586465,
0.4196032882,
0.3503503501,
-0.2762768865,
-0.7165161967,
0.259108007,
-0.3635531664,
-0.1778345406,
1.1634557247,
-0.2077851892,
-0.3188280761,
-0.0086925039,
-0.3824056685,
0.1273014098,
-0.320432663,
0.8521561027,
0.719491303,
-0.1119240075,
-0.14624843,
-0.2924934626,
0.6985728741,
0.5407442451,
-1.0197976828,
-0.0525562353,
0.3925101459,
0.4038914442,
0.1014478952,
0.8160071373,
-0.0283471923,
0.5150839686,
-0.0504329205,
0.3449550569,
-0.0599784777,
-0.3582907319,
-0.3610391617,
-0.024245128,
0.5629066229,
0.1078524888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16098v1 | Carolina: a General Corpus of Contemporary Brazilian Portuguese with Provenance, Typology and Versioning Information | 2023-03-28T16:09:40 | 2023-03-28T16:09:40 | Maria Clara Ramos Morales Crespo, Maria Lina de Souza Jeannine Rocha, Mariana Lourenço Sturzeneker, Felipe Ribas Serras, Guilherme Lamartine de Mello, Aline Silva Costa, Mayara Feliciano Palma, Renata Morais Mesquita, Raquel de Paula Guets, Mariana Marques da Silva, Marcelo Finger, Maria Clara Paixão de Sousa, Cristiane Namiuti, Vanessa Martins do Monte | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | This paper presents the first publicly available version of the Carolina
Corpus and discusses its future directions. Carolina is a large open corpus of
Brazilian Portuguese texts under construction using web-as-corpus methodology
enhanced with provenance, typology, versioning, and text integrality. The
corpus aims at being used both as a reliable source for research in Linguistics
and as an important resource for Computer Science research on language models,
contributing towards removing Portuguese from the set of low-resource
languages. Here we present the construction of the corpus methodology,
comparing it with other existing methodologies, as well as the corpus current
state: Carolina's first public version has $653,322,577$ tokens, distributed
over $7$ broad types. Each text is annotated with several different metadata
categories in its header, which we developed using TEI annotation standards. We
also present ongoing derivative works and invite NLP researchers to contribute
with their own. | [
-0.404741168,
-0.4247861505,
0.3124565184,
0.4092084169,
-0.3079811037,
0.3899743259,
-0.7992129922,
-0.829580009,
0.681640029,
0.6378573179,
0.1649141759,
-0.6838009357,
-0.3482544124,
0.160347715,
-0.6384196281,
0.9337607622,
0.1418103576,
-0.0059795948,
-0.2404821217,
-0.1769813299,
-0.0732382014,
-0.6062738895,
-0.7046842575,
0.3298583627,
0.9555897713,
0.2677997649,
0.9459082484,
0.9954855442,
0.2132539451,
0.2833519578,
-0.4623730481,
-0.3195546865,
-0.6456210613,
-0.0238248371,
-0.550037086,
-0.2831071019,
-0.4096788764,
-0.110041678,
0.8453876972,
0.5579658151,
-0.0355579816,
0.1018820181,
0.3432474434,
0.406689018,
-0.8834403753,
0.2799524069,
-0.4278984666,
-0.4357041419,
-0.6076759696,
-0.2081911117,
-0.4942594171,
-0.6799568534,
0.2255111337,
-0.7265809178,
0.1840153933,
-0.1816783994,
0.828025341,
-0.0192042682,
-0.3496865332,
-0.4058785141,
-0.7764074802,
0.9003999233,
-0.0996233001,
0.2960973978,
0.5371692777,
0.6082977057,
0.0675724968,
-0.6647472978,
-0.2357285619,
-0.4258581996,
-0.1187744513,
-0.0755879134,
-0.564055264,
0.0348371044,
-0.1756653786,
0.4298964739,
-0.4442571402,
-0.0131551661,
-0.7496902347,
-0.3022750318,
0.603494525,
-0.4103575349,
0.1698395163,
0.044227723,
-0.0819513276,
0.0232724249,
-0.9334244728,
-0.4646992087,
0.5761857033,
0.6089728475,
-0.2510564327,
0.4265643954,
-0.058556959,
0.6537923217,
-0.2861313224,
0.1299049407,
-0.082228601,
-0.1446880102,
-0.1487974972,
0.0930448622,
0.4898032844,
-0.0832798481,
0.1800456345,
-0.3092957139,
0.0541896112,
-0.122093074,
0.4170827568,
-0.1690007746,
-0.1023222581,
0.4967518151,
-0.305112958,
-0.3881759644,
0.1388789564,
-0.663975358,
-0.4622733295,
-0.559170723,
-0.3055028021,
-0.6445797086,
-0.4424818456,
-0.4132810831,
0.0136445723,
0.2460966706,
0.5395715833,
-0.5059766769,
0.2716625333,
0.7645154595,
0.771995306,
-0.4390555322,
-0.0362476818,
-0.1140056774,
0.081676349,
-0.4639031589,
1.0720155239,
-0.442247957,
-0.6025928855,
0.3569087088,
0.2654594779,
0.5273358226,
-0.3848646581,
0.9674333334,
-0.5350808501,
0.114720583,
-0.5282749534,
-0.0211713444,
-0.3962604702,
0.1819633394,
-0.9396300316,
0.7342720628,
0.5730077624,
-0.8027758002,
0.0445742533,
-0.4353994131,
-0.153203398,
0.5740787983,
-0.2135788947,
0.1763308644,
0.0163125191,
-0.2004723549,
-0.1682726741,
-0.5946125984,
0.3262716234,
-0.4080603719,
-0.4648180008,
0.0989415273,
-0.2695688903,
1.1445821524,
0.7909952402,
0.3773037195,
0.0581518672,
-0.8957432508,
-0.0394250751,
0.0937603638,
-0.5102884769,
-0.2934884131,
0.1058139279,
0.4983769953,
-0.1631515473,
0.5076963305,
-0.5316277146,
0.2307876498,
-0.2376682311,
0.4379445016,
0.3950359523,
-0.2230258137,
0.5442244411,
-0.2473030388,
0.9707989693,
-0.2551887333,
0.1539032012,
-0.0556745976,
-0.1630538106,
-0.4457907975,
-0.4348272979,
0.9393641353,
0.5387297273,
-0.6050813198,
0.0151686445,
-0.3519078195,
-0.7049179077,
-0.3958024085,
-0.5376421213,
0.4424827099,
0.0238785874,
0.5411781669,
-0.112050727,
-0.7345693707,
-0.9748372436,
-0.079391174,
-0.0778593421,
-0.1303290576,
-0.0263563003,
0.2299923599,
0.1065240279,
1.1842443943,
-0.4172872305,
-0.1162100285,
-0.1783815473,
0.1163393557,
0.0426340103,
0.5232884884,
1.028192997,
-0.6093195081,
-0.2391712815,
0.1103820428,
-0.5663567185,
-0.1503302455,
0.3255997896,
-0.1036259905,
0.6677052975,
0.2799298167,
0.2146115452,
0.3279166222,
0.8147881031,
-0.1199979931,
0.6684331894,
-0.1555205435,
0.1924092323,
-0.9164912701,
0.3554680347,
-0.0733753964,
-0.1926353425,
-0.1707441807,
0.3957973719,
-0.0921143293,
-0.1677209437,
-0.8423495889,
0.4205718637,
-0.7734419107,
-0.158509627,
-0.4750422239,
0.079882957,
-0.2742375433,
0.1605322361,
0.3357081115,
0.7513490319,
0.4649429321,
-0.6087152958,
0.1718462855,
0.0079458794,
0.1680526733,
0.6482780576,
-0.6371187568,
0.2818451226,
-0.2072986662,
0.2689317465,
-0.5678159595,
-0.0684947744,
0.2531738579,
-0.6102218032,
0.3136538267,
-0.7512538433,
-0.0034354413,
-0.3996270895,
-0.252810359,
0.2923965156,
0.1833607703,
-0.4227995574,
0.5787891746,
0.7681612372,
-0.4377318025,
-0.7041751742,
-0.9247024655,
0.4486549199,
0.003376201,
-0.5852520466,
0.3475976288,
0.0302832648,
-0.5421782732,
0.0751486719,
0.1834604442,
-0.6531856656,
-0.0212884825,
0.0768756568,
0.2215277404,
-0.2885451317,
0.2186291367,
0.3903762102,
-0.1437306255,
-0.135808453,
-0.4981998503,
0.5930370092,
-0.2489025444,
0.0322358347,
0.0357567668,
0.6559665799,
-0.0358258486,
-0.3321929276,
0.7316083908,
0.0097810254,
-0.507260561,
-0.0550059043,
-0.2624177933,
0.3962928057,
-0.3865629137,
-0.0727785975,
-0.2454714626,
-0.9478115439,
0.4745218158,
0.1566770971,
0.0732698515,
0.5449923277,
0.2818905413,
0.1228740737,
0.2282107323,
0.7447400689,
0.0002185407,
0.4895141423,
-0.2723909318,
-0.1649607718,
-0.2677757144,
-0.032722421,
-1.2034809589,
0.0523219854,
-0.9547816515,
-0.5437522531,
0.0897130147,
0.272739768,
-0.241674006,
0.9254278541,
-0.7643896341,
0.5909652114,
0.7528942227,
-0.028939547,
0.646081686,
-0.1445263177,
0.190869987,
0.1204190776,
-0.3456909955,
-0.9312300682,
1.2351784706,
0.005580287,
0.2470136732,
0.2898839414,
0.7794836164,
0.5431601405,
0.2555384636,
-0.4052666724,
0.3577839434,
0.0117123928,
-0.5678542852,
-0.1508825719,
0.0224383399,
-1.2488662004,
0.1986513436,
-0.6170410514,
-0.6220102906,
0.1571961641,
0.3894373775,
-0.1364654899,
-0.1737686992,
-0.6480942965,
0.7186723948,
0.0050798389,
-0.6409879327,
-0.2915394604,
-0.6361973882,
0.2892475724,
0.0269333385,
0.2568567991,
0.4141011536,
-0.0726718828,
0.4743784964,
-0.4049283266,
0.3206699491,
0.0835355297,
-0.2592434883,
1.0919697285,
0.4329832494,
0.2948993444,
0.3439240754,
-0.063492313,
0.4867160022,
0.5319452882,
-0.7092916369,
0.0564094186,
0.7115849853,
-0.5404510498,
-0.2333285213,
-0.9940731525,
0.0729144067,
0.0727383122,
0.3165946901,
0.2931414545,
0.2380724698,
-0.8338404298,
0.1632819474,
0.3580670655,
-0.5083066821,
0.3830167353,
0.5164933801,
-0.3528651297,
-0.4702883065,
0.9691815376,
0.0724889636,
-0.0182768535,
0.5364089608,
0.0737827718,
-0.1042820662,
-0.9015555978,
-0.1615640521,
0.220421046,
-0.4315712154,
-0.032468453,
-0.5131915808,
0.110251151,
-0.7257772684,
-0.429572463,
-0.4676675498,
-0.6608284116,
-0.3559999466,
-0.1936998218,
0.307254374,
0.7582571507,
-0.3135713339,
0.4102783799,
-0.6669786572,
-0.2213330418,
-0.1443406343,
0.197418496,
-0.3423351347,
-0.0010617509,
-0.207821995,
0.2950373888,
-0.4428367615,
-0.9903404117,
0.4458935559,
-0.3686244786,
0.2625862956,
0.5341265202,
0.1014383882,
0.2163840979,
0.1803602427,
0.929921031,
0.0854939669,
-0.9668517113,
0.4182272553,
-1.0076215267,
0.1270206869,
0.7112667561,
0.3935494125,
-0.5952274799,
-0.3055672646,
-0.6339182854,
-0.7236037254,
0.4643419683,
0.0177931786,
-0.2819906175,
-0.2941970229,
0.0526234917,
0.1227280274,
0.1532259583,
-0.429207921,
0.0727181286,
-0.234914124,
0.1446521133,
-0.0643735155,
-0.2216490209,
0.0804497078,
-0.2540664971,
0.5618317723,
-0.3612981141,
0.4022470713,
-0.0129458914,
-0.1356528401,
0.2439448386,
0.5914750695,
0.57774055,
1.0679894686,
-0.0761813223,
-0.0533315651,
0.2112194449,
-0.4431197345,
-0.5083081722,
0.0262128301,
-0.3258857429,
0.009740755,
0.1861262918,
0.148115322,
0.2002991289,
-0.6342574954,
0.5182451606,
0.2798872292,
0.1670797318,
-1.0229572058,
-0.4024770856,
0.2825855613,
-0.0400468521,
0.1697157025,
-0.26109761,
0.1691401899,
-0.6264637709,
-0.1274950057,
0.1119458005,
-0.5729939342,
-0.4236979187,
0.6337006688,
0.2724638879,
-0.0542191043,
0.3847105503,
-0.3840096593,
-0.213562265,
0.3716274202,
0.3325740397,
0.7304017544,
-0.0599597506,
0.4716595709,
0.627294004,
0.0076566841,
-0.2053279281,
0.5526674986,
-0.0405172668,
-0.18114537,
-0.3451481164,
-0.7385991812,
-0.5841510296,
-0.2991208136,
-0.6241905689,
0.93726933,
-0.3945479095,
0.027372878,
-0.2503220141,
-0.1717623472,
-0.4486429095,
0.1291087866,
0.20297876,
0.8907838464,
-0.3221047223,
0.9929254055,
0.4681987464,
-0.878341794,
-0.4152262211,
-0.4646627605,
0.1025172099,
-0.5438882113,
0.0080975527,
-0.4895126224,
-0.402104944,
-0.2125762701,
-1.0742647648,
-1.1549965143,
0.9503525496,
0.812987268,
-0.6260477901,
-0.2068828046,
0.0178248975,
0.8485965133,
-0.1466870159,
0.48276034,
0.4142403901,
0.6443721652,
0.2761050463,
-0.8030936122,
-0.1924689114,
-0.0191792957,
0.045418784,
0.2327732891,
-0.4926294684,
0.9964314103,
-0.1212378144,
-0.6978248954,
0.3391405046,
1.0899809599,
0.0284416378,
0.0673454404,
0.1362952292,
0.2623792589,
0.8313287497,
-0.2633672059,
1.0726468563,
-0.4680565894,
0.2345081866,
1.3673526049,
-0.0070888591,
0.7468329668,
0.3441648185,
-0.3705821633,
0.6152150631,
0.5275951028,
0.1424209327,
0.0229475573,
0.6354930401,
-0.2912786603,
0.0588909499,
-0.4084383547,
-0.5311653018,
0.6553115249,
0.1081850603,
-0.5268553495,
-0.2463611215,
-0.1694113165,
0.6952624321,
0.7024666071,
-0.2689152956,
0.4372504652,
-0.0480229706,
-0.9078089595,
0.5030683279,
0.0656300634,
0.4270573556,
-0.5795125961,
0.01254352,
0.0451676697,
0.1311192513,
-0.2947808206,
-0.7060543895,
0.7580162883,
0.0755215436,
0.1746690273,
-0.2787666321,
0.4270259142,
-0.2317747623,
-0.2680644393,
0.4140377343,
0.3713177741,
0.4145848751,
-0.4957740903,
-0.136188522,
0.1267013699,
-0.3293735385,
0.0581852458,
0.4044380784,
0.0754474401,
-0.3804082572,
0.2964833975,
0.6004377007,
0.2147856951,
-0.1309290975,
-0.1550366729,
0.7943645716,
-0.9349492192,
-0.7731941938,
-0.3331739008,
0.089964807,
-0.1062199771,
-0.7533349991,
0.5506424308,
0.8943247795,
0.8201904297,
0.0513586067,
0.9953685999,
-0.4207274616,
0.6977325082,
-0.0786272138,
0.8474330902,
-0.1843672246,
-0.12010061,
-0.1964950562,
-0.9818053842,
-0.1007662416,
0.1986025572,
0.0457483791,
-0.2868429124,
1.0219956636,
0.4359278679,
0.4014829397,
0.6966465116,
-0.0658353865,
0.1431688517,
0.0565422103,
0.4691959918,
0.6319000125,
0.1226783469,
0.7335675955,
-0.2021965683,
-0.4020498097,
0.0200031381,
-1.1519055367,
-0.1909034252,
-0.857878983,
-0.2759293914,
-0.8171418309,
0.2652974427,
1.0542708635,
0.3464657068,
-0.9982078671,
-0.3236002624,
0.0255750772,
0.0441732705,
-0.4038732946,
-0.1573023945,
0.2331854552,
0.1758189201,
-0.8509940505,
0.4636518657,
-0.0331535228,
-0.0945430323,
-0.4214458168,
0.1743227094,
-0.1584496498,
-0.039020624,
0.6568057537,
0.9171316028,
-0.3161192536,
-0.5370762944,
-0.1239056289,
-0.1121909246,
0.2725497484,
0.9378548265,
-0.8278955221,
0.2140275836,
0.5858587623,
0.0717978254,
0.6748839617,
0.0140339257,
0.6038861275,
-0.2821124494,
0.3498324156,
0.7543011308,
0.2997504175,
0.1288009137,
-0.0082958732,
0.6869727969,
0.2757197917,
-0.4137326181,
-0.5371772051,
0.1249802113,
-1.7514671087,
-0.4602361619,
1.2792625427,
0.0045213671,
-0.6350075006,
-0.3462609947,
-0.5265911818,
0.432810694,
-0.7628210783,
0.4206421077,
0.6385076642,
0.3835610747,
0.2177441716,
-0.2510482073,
0.2544907331,
-0.4357827306,
-0.7122923732,
0.1648435444,
0.845559001,
0.0807781667,
0.3113448918,
0.6920758486,
-0.5340568423,
0.1579359472,
0.1104580387,
0.4675732255,
-0.0862608552,
-0.5208706856,
-0.4391767979,
0.5769343376,
0.0071940166,
-0.0346450508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16028v1 | Synthetically generated text for supervised text analysis | 2023-03-28T14:55:13 | 2023-03-28T14:55:13 | Andrew Halterman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Supervised text models are a valuable tool for political scientists but
present several obstacles to their use, including the expense of hand-labeling
documents, the difficulty of retrieving rare relevant documents for annotation,
and copyright and privacy concerns involved in sharing annotated documents.
This article proposes a partial solution to these three issues, in the form of
controlled generation of synthetic text with large language models. I provide a
conceptual overview of text generation, guidance on when researchers should
prefer different techniques for generating synthetic text, a discussion of
ethics, and a simple technique for improving the quality of synthetic text. I
demonstrate the usefulness of synthetic text with three applications:
generating synthetic tweets describing the fighting in Ukraine, synthetic news
articles describing specified political events for training an event detection
system, and a multilingual corpus of populist manifesto statements for training
a sentence-level populism classifier. | [
-0.1913193315,
-0.8961464167,
0.7860656977,
0.2127843201,
-0.2904826403,
0.421871841,
-0.3862495124,
-0.4428844154,
0.2352352589,
0.7637603879,
-0.3498798907,
-0.3079845905,
-0.6236476898,
0.3396499753,
-0.6770694256,
1.1524134874,
-0.0077758087,
0.1070488766,
0.0298708715,
0.0633982122,
0.0521667935,
-0.8481444716,
-0.4748998284,
-0.2656327188,
0.4281820655,
0.1653680652,
0.6202617288,
0.5932046175,
0.4609418809,
0.3784541786,
0.016825499,
0.3102911413,
-0.4237602651,
0.2275870889,
-0.3277647197,
-0.3412567079,
-0.2064660937,
0.5074522495,
0.7845811248,
0.4120581746,
0.2010355145,
-0.2320806235,
-0.1265815794,
0.5583872199,
-0.4917006791,
-0.0622594021,
-0.7740904093,
0.0514656268,
-0.411772877,
-0.3080039918,
-0.4697220623,
-0.5861151218,
0.0297711678,
-0.6021930575,
0.435973227,
0.0046347906,
0.5993775129,
-0.1269953549,
-0.4763779044,
-0.6688212156,
-0.8402947783,
0.8559849262,
-0.4475999475,
0.1113737375,
0.2252001762,
0.2682014108,
-0.434223175,
-0.9344075322,
-0.746049881,
-0.3634001017,
-0.1452385336,
0.287080884,
0.0276948549,
-0.0081749531,
0.0926289409,
0.2468915284,
-0.2911044359,
-0.0594085008,
-0.5177528262,
-0.2443684787,
1.0144158602,
0.0900138691,
0.2788605094,
-0.6784068346,
-0.0744235814,
-0.1706958413,
-0.5431680083,
-0.3275216222,
1.0172352791,
0.4165046811,
0.1528470665,
0.9184732437,
-0.0850960165,
0.580055356,
-0.035791941,
0.0004059387,
-0.0662210435,
-0.6485803723,
0.0771640763,
0.0335174277,
1.0439276695,
0.192305997,
0.4546296,
0.0968036428,
-0.1958047301,
0.1732508987,
0.4444124997,
-0.7847990394,
-0.4089120626,
0.4586991072,
-0.4982394278,
-0.7311729193,
0.323921442,
-0.9209270477,
-0.4789235294,
-0.5115602016,
-0.0619223453,
-0.197354883,
-0.3234806955,
-0.0818432048,
-0.3712897599,
-0.3728539646,
0.1880547702,
-0.7923535109,
0.1732236296,
0.547886312,
0.6834691167,
-0.3116466403,
0.1444640756,
-0.4722911716,
0.0806417689,
-0.5025190711,
0.5469899178,
-0.6356238723,
-0.6112523675,
0.2928698361,
0.0139614334,
0.174534753,
-0.4049594402,
0.2754617929,
-0.3283027709,
0.5206953883,
0.1587861329,
-0.6374301314,
0.2387428433,
-0.0144018596,
-0.7367113829,
1.0152390003,
-0.0356629975,
-0.7847294211,
0.3145118952,
-0.7561851144,
-0.5314058065,
0.0581861511,
-0.2086903453,
-0.439329803,
0.1856413931,
-0.1010755822,
0.5593886375,
0.0846472457,
0.678109169,
0.1885380745,
0.1018310562,
0.5400758982,
-0.1350739747,
0.8002709746,
0.2502484024,
-0.1626202464,
0.3566533029,
-1.0326480865,
0.0062003774,
0.0157848112,
-0.4822986424,
-0.3284216523,
0.193214491,
0.6600446105,
0.0510089584,
0.3527104557,
-0.6023002267,
0.137974754,
-0.3019656539,
0.6349329352,
0.4730084538,
0.3120096028,
0.5469463468,
-0.1788064092,
0.405223012,
-0.1652458161,
-0.0596930571,
-0.085467346,
-0.4493011832,
-0.5429637432,
-0.0509887636,
0.4138976932,
0.5789994001,
-0.8883620501,
0.3292073607,
0.247732684,
-0.5678949356,
-0.3265939355,
-0.0947719961,
0.1713199168,
-0.0845648795,
0.1362710148,
0.4210398495,
-0.8601472378,
-1.1128886938,
-0.5609534979,
-0.0852584764,
-0.0964311734,
-0.0496875979,
0.8185269833,
-0.1356740296,
0.8919275999,
-0.4158581495,
-0.0042148824,
-0.3101646602,
0.5269239545,
-0.3356171846,
0.5739805698,
0.4640291631,
-1.1953171492,
-0.3379517496,
0.2940360904,
-0.5676084757,
-0.2040298879,
-0.4818495214,
-0.0765355676,
0.4947504997,
0.6393273473,
-0.5182531476,
0.2561789155,
0.5127617121,
-0.0310692694,
0.4215322137,
-0.189103812,
0.2707623839,
-1.5746566057,
0.1200165376,
0.1693695635,
-0.4885760546,
-0.7649430037,
0.0687312409,
-0.0602238923,
-0.20768179,
-0.4399544895,
0.5072892308,
-0.2019342482,
0.5109903216,
-0.6772710681,
0.2358468473,
-0.1186890453,
-0.2926919162,
0.2289035171,
0.6638015509,
0.0139304046,
-0.3849740326,
0.3355408013,
0.1616804451,
-0.1956264675,
0.3562296331,
-0.4610054791,
0.0253210999,
-0.1529612541,
0.2549666166,
-0.5472317338,
-0.7016103864,
0.1934177577,
-0.3590222895,
0.1958238333,
0.1817204356,
-0.6403907537,
-0.1433734894,
-0.209138006,
0.0048076403,
0.4671266675,
-0.2870438993,
0.4703151584,
0.6492765546,
-0.1366466135,
-0.2440449744,
-0.3763677776,
0.2131583989,
-0.1912235916,
-0.287109226,
0.4973657727,
0.1899469495,
-0.5545161366,
0.2021206766,
0.2407795489,
-0.130510062,
-0.0624508187,
0.2293583155,
-0.0605700128,
0.1978224963,
0.3043578267,
0.2637606561,
-0.078093566,
0.0565954857,
-0.2363124639,
0.3190086186,
0.2326865792,
0.2626982033,
-0.388948977,
0.8778166175,
0.4280110896,
-0.0586688705,
0.8268723488,
0.5116884708,
-0.5010153055,
-0.3541118503,
-0.4141792357,
-0.2682368159,
-0.4514353573,
0.2234751582,
0.0790063888,
-0.8656320572,
0.3237935007,
-0.1215603501,
0.0720738173,
0.7039234638,
0.7390148044,
-0.0971855968,
0.9219556451,
0.6952964664,
0.4046022892,
0.4562101364,
0.0604794286,
0.3014065623,
-0.2033696622,
-0.2628288269,
-0.8192045689,
0.108146064,
-1.2272953987,
-0.1505850852,
0.2319353819,
-0.2027235776,
-0.0424774513,
0.2554732561,
-0.8842784166,
0.5119131804,
0.8031195998,
-0.0877715945,
0.2355511338,
0.0252408739,
0.3997397125,
-0.1285209209,
-0.4588891566,
-1.020684123,
0.7653822899,
0.0645554513,
0.4283475876,
-0.3537123799,
0.8504999876,
0.3455815315,
0.4152510464,
-0.4870960712,
0.5523186326,
-0.2840883732,
-0.9112483263,
-0.0368575752,
-0.5162913203,
-0.8321486115,
0.1057547703,
-0.6549748182,
-0.5779368877,
-0.0969212353,
0.0270995442,
-0.0927297696,
0.2105994821,
-0.5103774071,
0.5321956873,
-0.010969975,
-0.203611359,
-0.1903536916,
-0.4640858769,
0.4120219648,
-0.5462941527,
0.1608286649,
0.1756482124,
0.0741323307,
0.9855704904,
-0.1769836247,
0.7944064736,
0.0855653137,
-0.0524403118,
0.4285523593,
-0.1051703319,
0.3095902801,
0.1049910709,
-0.078236796,
-0.033765588,
0.3611225188,
-0.327041626,
-0.2516479492,
0.7259232998,
-0.5180738568,
-0.7934938073,
-0.5852224231,
-0.7107976079,
0.2105748355,
0.32916224,
0.5397993922,
0.0496995673,
-0.3266243339,
0.5273726583,
0.1619232595,
-0.3722067177,
0.3382411003,
-0.0306881052,
-0.3110503256,
-0.4844520688,
0.9679902792,
0.442482084,
0.2019316852,
0.1770493686,
0.2667311728,
-0.1144968867,
-0.4961831868,
-0.2375480831,
-0.0059462897,
-0.4710920751,
-0.0742504969,
-0.8091641068,
-0.4200830162,
-0.128352195,
-0.3407956958,
-0.3725668788,
-0.7239417434,
-0.5959690809,
-0.125841558,
0.3620078266,
1.0585952997,
-0.1476714462,
0.6238217354,
-0.6603908539,
0.4562556148,
-0.1425851136,
-0.0253304709,
-0.597819984,
0.2996091247,
-0.091631718,
0.1836743802,
-0.5902854204,
-1.0861859322,
0.4555126727,
-0.0723209083,
0.145638302,
-0.0125147179,
0.3887304962,
-0.0214217529,
-0.6693719029,
0.9824058414,
0.0014128485,
-0.9658647776,
0.8172517419,
-0.7447849512,
-0.0861317813,
0.3459112048,
0.4237248898,
0.0049505616,
-0.8665090203,
-0.7353337407,
-0.6881684661,
0.3425097764,
0.689676404,
0.5725588202,
-0.2759555578,
0.4673504829,
0.286363095,
0.281768471,
-0.7415952086,
0.1398118734,
-0.3037988544,
-0.423838079,
0.1152556539,
-0.1363753825,
-0.366486311,
0.0048625176,
0.7254277468,
-0.0994669497,
-0.1519962698,
0.2229263335,
0.3555117548,
-0.1256061941,
0.2268376052,
0.6010273695,
0.6550099254,
-0.0372897349,
-0.0093305223,
-0.1508762389,
-0.4404018223,
0.1737360954,
0.0873588175,
-0.301710844,
0.1987191439,
0.1746725142,
0.2109257877,
-0.2615656555,
-0.4929680228,
0.2394878119,
0.1295078993,
-0.451577425,
-0.4797014594,
0.0886267424,
0.2102590203,
0.22354725,
0.4653537571,
-0.0720553473,
0.0985492095,
-0.7078455687,
0.227741003,
0.5765706897,
0.0557020679,
-0.3561505079,
0.7362457514,
0.4446688294,
-0.5724179745,
0.3473827243,
-0.1156751961,
-0.6316785216,
0.5814534426,
0.5631220937,
0.5859592557,
-0.1846771985,
0.5370633602,
0.2624822557,
0.3252800107,
-0.0710126683,
0.2893175483,
0.4120298624,
-0.4735617042,
-0.4487392902,
-0.4763271809,
-0.6424326301,
0.3517596126,
-0.4585933983,
0.1785868257,
-0.5663820505,
-0.4967743754,
0.5315651894,
0.21882312,
-0.1809007674,
0.192237094,
-0.201745078,
0.52557832,
-0.8413993716,
0.6109197736,
0.4279018342,
-0.2013354897,
-0.174294278,
-0.084478803,
0.0123051433,
-0.0073835202,
0.5451889038,
0.1302602738,
0.0391115546,
-0.1954670399,
-0.8296616673,
-0.2266209722,
0.416906625,
0.2751412392,
-0.3848033845,
0.0985530242,
0.2455626279,
0.6573028564,
-0.3991575241,
-0.4138048589,
0.5065316558,
0.6470227838,
-0.3776729405,
-0.5007436275,
0.083746776,
-0.3163907826,
-0.1307427287,
0.3541725278,
-0.3845999539,
0.9369511604,
0.2854251564,
-0.3705979288,
0.3080343008,
0.6170024872,
0.0636576712,
0.343416959,
0.0641890913,
-0.2175638527,
0.6624849439,
-0.236465618,
1.2426605225,
-0.2158069462,
0.1958484054,
0.765062511,
-0.2391495407,
0.6129860878,
0.5834978819,
0.2004413456,
0.1913834065,
0.6029469967,
-0.0318489596,
0.141444996,
0.4962725043,
-0.3721361756,
-0.2035210431,
-0.4270491004,
-0.2116072029,
0.3979907334,
0.5289517641,
-0.466352433,
0.0472976193,
0.1485607624,
-0.0213504434,
0.6921544671,
0.0621843375,
0.71324718,
0.122533299,
-0.5580378175,
-0.0141594689,
0.1023877189,
0.2520227134,
-0.3148049712,
-0.2638307214,
0.244332701,
0.120405972,
-0.2057956159,
-0.8684763312,
0.6208254695,
0.267827034,
-0.3604545891,
-0.3223520517,
0.6925565004,
-0.4652118981,
-0.7682250738,
0.0698383227,
0.6180016398,
0.008117741,
-0.018095199,
-0.3168663383,
0.0779834166,
-0.1363954842,
-0.5309714079,
0.1987897307,
0.3694455624,
-0.2976203859,
0.373588562,
1.0129439831,
0.3719235957,
-0.1075465232,
-0.0520525873,
0.7821287513,
-0.5867896676,
-0.2940770388,
-0.8841230869,
0.3572296798,
-0.4879896343,
-0.3034390509,
0.5721095204,
0.5545579791,
0.8332570195,
-0.128063038,
1.1416712999,
-0.1370738745,
0.5667207241,
-0.732771039,
1.0512809753,
-0.441929698,
-0.1994879544,
-0.0533188581,
-0.9474267364,
-0.608703196,
0.6986544728,
-0.1987910271,
-0.0462960489,
0.6239605546,
0.5419992805,
-0.096851252,
0.1091140434,
0.1053662151,
-0.0426960103,
0.5005354285,
-0.0126674725,
0.9912719727,
-0.1057361513,
0.3119796216,
-0.3242774308,
0.0450640544,
0.0038561244,
-1.0089097023,
-1.1012058258,
-0.9521325231,
-0.3684828579,
-0.4759316742,
0.0747995675,
0.9681732059,
0.7388364077,
-0.8059580922,
-0.1678363085,
-0.2961195707,
-0.0809026286,
0.368252486,
-0.3058375418,
0.4483467937,
-0.2467127293,
-1.1736006737,
0.2422650456,
0.0307030082,
0.3105555177,
-0.3287524879,
0.3371633291,
-0.2597999275,
0.498157382,
0.5571804643,
0.0435290448,
-0.6578436494,
-0.4932855666,
-0.246500358,
-0.1562155783,
-0.28791821,
1.0107966661,
-0.4307027757,
0.4233739078,
0.5938301682,
0.606090188,
0.2791222334,
0.1956448257,
0.7831984758,
-0.756236434,
0.3266184032,
0.4194171429,
0.1352056414,
0.5182525516,
-0.4564550221,
0.4292160869,
0.0520285666,
-0.4680843055,
-0.9608239532,
0.2717978954,
-0.9051142931,
-0.4844745398,
1.2601867914,
0.2003189027,
-0.2377156317,
-0.0278280694,
-0.625967741,
0.5023579001,
-0.3743517697,
0.7809150815,
0.7936985493,
0.1027618125,
-0.0950973779,
-0.861775279,
0.7059383988,
0.0139664244,
-1.0791528225,
0.1176967919,
0.5467834473,
-0.0462585203,
0.4285144508,
0.2739765942,
-0.094510451,
0.0447534658,
-0.0232783239,
-0.1767120808,
0.0294871386,
-0.4468556345,
0.0762682259,
0.2301436216,
-0.4958295226,
-0.075326927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15987v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15987v2 | Sentiment Analysis Dataset in Moroccan Dialect: Bridging the Gap Between Arabic and Latin Scripted dialect | 2023-03-28T14:02:42 | 2023-11-06T18:38:55 | Mouad Jbel, Imad Hafidi, Abdulmutallib Metrane | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis, the automated process of determining emotions or opinions
expressed in text, has seen extensive exploration in the field of natural
language processing. However, one aspect that has remained underrepresented is
the sentiment analysis of the Moroccan dialect, which boasts a unique
linguistic landscape and the coexistence of multiple scripts. Previous works in
sentiment analysis primarily targeted dialects employing Arabic script. While
these efforts provided valuable insights, they may not fully capture the
complexity of Moroccan web content, which features a blend of Arabic and Latin
script. As a result, our study emphasizes the importance of extending sentiment
analysis to encompass the entire spectrum of Moroccan linguistic diversity.
Central to our research is the creation of the largest public dataset for
Moroccan dialect sentiment analysis that incorporates not only Moroccan dialect
written in Arabic script but also in Latin letters. By assembling a diverse
range of textual data, we were able to construct a dataset with a range of 20
000 manually labeled text in Moroccan dialect and also publicly available lists
of stop words in Moroccan dialect. To dive into sentiment analysis, we
conducted a comparative study on multiple Machine learning models to assess
their compatibility with our dataset. Experiments were performed using both raw
and preprocessed data to show the importance of the preprocessing step. We were
able to achieve 92% accuracy in our model and to further prove its liability we
tested our model on smaller publicly available datasets of Moroccan dialect and
the results were favorable. | [
-0.8086503148,
-0.0371743031,
0.2079395652,
0.7629891038,
-0.268119067,
0.3382122219,
-0.360024631,
-0.4040741026,
0.4082174301,
0.3964780867,
-0.5681684613,
-1.0403103828,
-0.615311563,
0.2131090164,
-0.1890289038,
1.0522142649,
0.0966012701,
0.3603639305,
-0.0887544677,
-0.4716458321,
-0.1497711092,
-0.8519173861,
-0.4600607455,
-0.1860094368,
0.7423268557,
0.3516598344,
0.8597512841,
0.1559324265,
0.5848779678,
0.1896093935,
0.1327484101,
0.2552405894,
-0.2282081991,
0.0572110675,
-0.1738289744,
-0.2107348293,
-0.5075124502,
-0.1428825706,
0.2930824459,
0.7793468237,
-0.0624386333,
0.0047571012,
-0.1202303544,
0.9854824543,
-0.5463314652,
-0.0402041711,
-0.429006964,
0.1112914681,
-0.4431387484,
0.1383633465,
-0.105404295,
-0.6719819903,
0.0337527953,
0.1793928742,
0.3378832936,
-0.2384933531,
0.8079531193,
0.087597616,
-0.5466220379,
-0.3932544589,
-0.844391644,
0.8992442489,
-0.7144224644,
0.4609816074,
0.2346841395,
0.2183545977,
-0.0029517917,
-0.5527319908,
-0.66861552,
-0.1095968857,
0.32084921,
0.2756235301,
-0.2823745012,
-0.0124001903,
-0.0894179866,
0.4246697128,
-0.5694487095,
0.0619207025,
-0.2250742763,
-0.2206803858,
0.6819680333,
0.0257550012,
0.1927182525,
-0.1311451048,
-0.2055154741,
-0.2338216305,
-0.633780241,
0.1851003319,
0.7491513491,
0.4146102965,
0.1345446706,
0.3597227037,
-0.2208756953,
0.5120291114,
-0.5630598068,
0.4146451354,
0.4912365079,
-0.0685355142,
-0.1653788388,
0.0063068517,
0.9627928138,
0.5133832693,
0.5755056739,
0.0864795148,
-0.4277745187,
0.3373327851,
0.40220204,
-0.7102524042,
-0.2871985435,
0.4000118077,
-0.3835875094,
-0.2728051841,
0.3523747325,
-0.8831114173,
-0.4582792521,
-0.2871072292,
-0.1657202244,
-0.1499959975,
-0.2902606726,
0.2048294097,
0.0128369052,
0.230613485,
0.3161606491,
-0.4404046834,
0.5392411351,
0.5323718786,
0.9884963632,
-0.3558919728,
0.1987987012,
-0.039664086,
-0.5578801036,
-0.4407094419,
0.7853625417,
-0.6255260706,
-0.8036682606,
0.2149743736,
-0.1187375486,
0.0415388606,
-0.5230515599,
0.9489883184,
-0.8458395004,
0.155698061,
-0.4321844578,
-0.2571015656,
-0.5056968927,
0.2498583645,
-0.9218503237,
1.0740659237,
0.1150975451,
-0.6668912172,
0.1267980337,
-0.633925736,
-0.5967571139,
-0.281909734,
-0.0117799873,
-0.5417425632,
0.2970885932,
0.4538280666,
0.2354014963,
-0.3174439073,
-0.1005261764,
-0.4830395579,
-0.0315347314,
0.6734884977,
-0.3078748882,
0.6940122247,
0.2999223173,
-0.1427203715,
-0.0831661746,
-0.5994915962,
-0.0284493025,
-0.134993121,
0.0793616921,
-0.2275893092,
0.0276518241,
0.5215873718,
0.5546592474,
0.237921834,
-0.6883913875,
0.1481993049,
-0.7303733826,
0.0293329563,
0.5051632524,
0.1341870874,
0.1824299544,
-0.2764203846,
0.9223550558,
0.1309569925,
-0.10830006,
0.1372132599,
-0.4004352093,
-0.8780632019,
-0.3078030944,
0.5434087515,
0.6141124368,
-0.3899303377,
0.348377049,
-0.2389528751,
-0.5603422523,
-0.6611827016,
0.0027396679,
0.078107819,
0.2614453733,
0.4145617485,
-0.611743331,
-0.7547697425,
-0.9178141356,
-0.3705742955,
-0.0077070668,
0.0950324088,
0.0764637813,
0.434420377,
-0.4125472307,
1.0679485798,
-0.4285266697,
-0.3325643241,
-0.3812313378,
0.3143689632,
0.4612026215,
0.2537640929,
0.6541327238,
-0.8149829507,
-0.5449668765,
0.253926754,
-0.3985209763,
-0.3520431519,
0.2071534395,
0.0205552764,
0.1052616686,
0.1937879175,
-0.2665872872,
0.5874194503,
0.5579082966,
0.0275179427,
0.4099562764,
0.2332775891,
0.269644171,
-0.9767460823,
-0.0925255045,
0.1259028912,
-0.0853389204,
-0.7812792063,
-0.5220533013,
-0.1612097472,
0.0857722238,
-0.4767566621,
0.5210598111,
-0.1928207576,
-0.1070477888,
-0.3459059298,
-0.3146275282,
0.3169976771,
0.3667435348,
0.1949407458,
0.6537305117,
0.3647251725,
-0.3107113838,
0.4530505538,
0.1604602188,
-0.5506280661,
0.2603990138,
-0.7682660222,
0.2568057179,
-0.0662616193,
0.0265532359,
-1.2367302179,
-0.1368916035,
0.1705827564,
-0.6230090261,
0.0259395316,
-0.1218844429,
-0.1884766817,
-0.2214909047,
-0.2996136248,
0.2907008231,
0.3345782757,
-0.2104417533,
0.5721940994,
0.3567135036,
-0.6298077703,
-0.8234149218,
-0.5910161138,
0.1621635109,
-0.2395422459,
-0.6369238496,
0.1810615063,
0.2866177559,
-0.6546974182,
-0.1621115059,
0.0162151493,
-0.2275717109,
-0.09225519,
0.4983820915,
0.3654574156,
-0.2343382984,
0.3123850226,
0.3586508334,
0.1117208675,
0.1742598414,
-0.3189778328,
0.6820315123,
-0.307421267,
-0.3784812391,
-0.2774941027,
0.31173563,
0.7590861917,
-0.6283322573,
0.9455317855,
0.5733892918,
-0.2374989986,
-0.2837090194,
-0.3767466247,
0.2094652206,
-0.4041274488,
0.272639215,
-0.287425071,
-0.51210922,
0.5990228653,
-0.0928470343,
-0.0175385009,
0.5858787894,
0.6401921511,
-0.3724724352,
1.1594063044,
0.5031200051,
-0.6087475419,
0.2729781568,
-0.160355255,
0.0920875072,
-0.3516580164,
-0.0944355577,
-0.7551014423,
-0.3755427003,
-0.5464596152,
-0.3504277766,
0.3184996545,
-0.3375175297,
0.0608379543,
-0.009148051,
-0.0127065694,
0.272731483,
0.2899918258,
-0.1448073089,
0.1196501106,
0.2996553779,
-0.3592103422,
-0.2269205898,
-0.4473834038,
-0.8893122673,
1.1242095232,
0.3333758712,
0.4218914807,
0.1315155625,
0.6351095438,
0.9908347726,
0.2769336998,
-0.8011755347,
0.300881803,
-0.2682045698,
-0.16111058,
0.0135552026,
-0.2225150019,
-0.8344389796,
0.3023299873,
-0.2335331291,
-0.3341818154,
0.4212924242,
-0.1116935313,
-0.257247299,
-0.0045384564,
-0.2489675432,
0.8997633457,
-0.0674394593,
-0.2338071167,
-0.2260002941,
-0.6948547959,
0.1841123402,
-0.096810706,
0.5780128241,
-0.1847166717,
0.1173304692,
0.7962188125,
-0.6341475844,
0.6465697289,
-0.0807933435,
-0.1371082366,
0.2608690858,
0.1034947559,
0.0077317092,
-0.160206899,
-0.4338858724,
0.5824325681,
-0.0364715792,
-0.3420298696,
-0.5275529623,
0.7034198046,
-1.0390813351,
-0.0266218614,
-0.7188723683,
-0.2901974618,
-0.4505522251,
-0.1730839908,
0.286984235,
0.5874503255,
-0.6385827065,
0.0073952856,
0.5044515729,
-0.1675283909,
0.2402715981,
0.2151187211,
-0.3651760817,
-0.5527516603,
0.962738812,
-0.0664137006,
-0.0059578009,
0.1984652132,
-0.0449898653,
-0.5454300642,
-0.4964649379,
-0.4499410093,
0.1393530816,
-0.689335525,
-0.0962119102,
-0.6193758845,
-0.0487026386,
-0.428208679,
-0.1606036425,
-0.3189855814,
-0.4877168238,
-0.1611346155,
-0.1221200004,
0.298923105,
0.7840155363,
-0.0489441864,
0.6449627876,
-1.0908071995,
0.1367301196,
-0.0314663053,
-0.1318517923,
-0.167014569,
-0.2865368426,
-0.2185935676,
0.145565331,
-0.2064329833,
-1.1543081999,
0.9476844668,
0.3350309134,
0.0369983353,
0.6379854083,
0.1114298478,
0.3494338095,
-0.3000952303,
0.7236176729,
-0.0630492344,
-0.9780100584,
0.3823857307,
-0.2749501765,
0.1816358715,
0.6477822065,
0.6701334119,
-0.9112526178,
-0.350566417,
-0.3460568786,
-0.8077502251,
0.4077496231,
0.3264543414,
0.093720071,
-0.1316748708,
-0.0215560365,
0.3010036051,
0.4522254169,
-0.3453160822,
-0.0074320184,
-0.4261144102,
-0.7305982709,
-0.2503676713,
0.0572026893,
0.0192884188,
-0.2011210173,
0.6309016347,
0.0765129626,
0.1547128707,
0.0210300088,
-0.304739207,
0.0990045145,
0.3239962757,
0.3206992149,
0.4949937463,
-0.0851899385,
0.0529189967,
0.1685312688,
-0.6851996183,
0.0215007961,
-0.0412895307,
0.0481136069,
0.3009707034,
0.4309871495,
0.6493802667,
-0.3264991641,
-0.6514276266,
0.4984349012,
-0.1429151744,
-0.1194642633,
-0.4699195027,
-0.0902929157,
-0.0608867928,
0.1063824221,
0.2697153687,
0.3273146451,
0.2778701782,
-0.3959429264,
0.1049138978,
0.4336782694,
-0.6674306989,
-0.3866142929,
0.1458143145,
0.2038752437,
-0.0579415523,
0.7842013836,
-0.068351835,
-0.9390884042,
0.8221061826,
-0.0251898337,
0.8159425259,
-0.2345382422,
0.428353101,
0.1395186484,
0.1529878676,
0.012930505,
0.6010807157,
-0.0122235399,
-0.9709132314,
-0.3041181862,
-0.9226725698,
-0.6550892591,
-0.3081324995,
-0.8594229221,
0.1427831948,
-0.4813305438,
-0.4770302474,
-0.1786817759,
0.0011945734,
-0.6748285294,
0.7043617368,
0.1751429886,
0.8305914402,
-1.1294317245,
0.7964509726,
0.7228555083,
-0.2843001783,
-0.3077834547,
-0.0131261321,
-0.0384698845,
-0.5921182632,
0.7317245603,
0.310305804,
-0.7440155149,
-0.1597596109,
-0.490575254,
-0.3872085512,
0.4189700186,
-0.113579236,
-0.4499919713,
0.4185259938,
0.4297355115,
0.7828915715,
-0.5385963321,
0.2446309328,
0.6134285331,
0.3151096404,
0.2496562898,
-0.3435181975,
-0.4333409667,
-0.4751096368,
-0.072816357,
0.2892567515,
-0.315800041,
0.8615797758,
0.1946586668,
-0.153620556,
-0.0262781847,
1.0689241886,
-0.242927134,
0.4430195689,
0.4882233441,
0.5552143455,
0.7985463738,
-0.2009425163,
0.6650525928,
-0.3449772,
0.1276688725,
0.9602962136,
-0.6939139366,
0.8849599957,
0.1869489849,
-0.4262515306,
1.1164873838,
0.6575253606,
0.1620824337,
0.3313592374,
0.1958346218,
-0.7088260651,
-0.1726745665,
-0.3054830134,
-0.3510976434,
0.663082242,
0.6422091722,
-0.2745713592,
-0.0160165746,
0.1136746928,
0.0239785202,
0.177123487,
-0.3858374655,
0.5461991429,
0.1179578826,
-0.439642787,
0.0864529684,
0.1819902509,
0.2101205885,
-0.6763339639,
0.1017166451,
-0.324334085,
0.1674407572,
-0.3784185946,
-0.7364121675,
0.4187467396,
0.2642221153,
-0.1104237139,
-0.1026301235,
0.7421568036,
-0.2626193166,
-0.6528163552,
0.1820034534,
0.6399961114,
0.2791882455,
-0.2697280943,
-0.4668402076,
0.1681126356,
0.0805089548,
-0.1403245181,
0.0791865736,
0.3153974414,
-0.2322090566,
0.3299321532,
0.8822694421,
0.3991042078,
-0.0281941406,
0.4310630262,
0.9672039747,
-0.8206877112,
-0.521935761,
-1.0390789509,
0.4381707013,
-0.2474410236,
-0.2924169004,
0.9458382726,
0.5040751696,
0.6452332139,
-0.2029813677,
1.0851327181,
0.1845279336,
0.6133220196,
-0.3661694527,
0.728723228,
-0.3498131335,
0.1610570848,
-0.3039488792,
-1.0060399771,
-0.3927404284,
0.6599163413,
-0.5666593909,
0.04167239,
0.3473193944,
0.9028768539,
0.0347549133,
0.3128210306,
0.0333378986,
-0.0003868219,
0.0777418539,
0.312160939,
1.1026117802,
-0.1024549752,
0.0312679037,
-0.0889005288,
-0.139405787,
-0.1838062108,
-0.8779858351,
-0.8299431205,
-0.2542846799,
-0.1115981862,
-0.4877980947,
-0.093904078,
1.2804056406,
0.4031056464,
-1.1797411442,
-0.5308734775,
0.1228225678,
0.1053567752,
-0.0839226246,
-0.2076879144,
0.1910634935,
-0.2551297545,
-0.6595205665,
0.4033229947,
0.2666582167,
0.0410851501,
-0.3460667431,
-0.0637044534,
0.0615046583,
0.5422528386,
0.4781489372,
0.5069228411,
-0.212016955,
0.1578407288,
0.1993533224,
-0.1715280861,
0.2241465747,
0.8737724423,
-0.712919116,
0.6047015786,
0.4948552549,
0.5677328706,
0.3341651261,
0.1156887859,
0.7395620346,
-0.8260412812,
0.0926425755,
0.4889882505,
0.3255055845,
0.5222166777,
-0.0227466077,
0.2410355657,
0.0749911591,
-0.3665939867,
-0.5587401986,
0.4018161595,
-1.0725491047,
-0.0157824066,
0.9441894293,
-0.1446487755,
-0.0789436102,
-0.2861077189,
-0.4464522004,
0.2123975009,
-0.4689337909,
0.6145222783,
0.822907567,
-0.0138504934,
0.185681358,
-0.3875297606,
0.4560635984,
0.4014621973,
-0.6731464863,
-0.2945336103,
0.5223667622,
-0.0707668439,
-0.0505152009,
0.4092204571,
0.0780779123,
0.1785045415,
-0.3368351758,
0.3005925715,
0.2747004628,
-0.4416252673,
-0.744645834,
0.4627580941,
0.053021241,
-0.2435157746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15973v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15973v1 | Do Neural Topic Models Really Need Dropout? Analysis of the Effect of Dropout in Topic Modeling | 2023-03-28T13:45:39 | 2023-03-28T13:45:39 | Suman Adhya, Avishek Lahiri, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Dropout is a widely used regularization trick to resolve the overfitting
issue in large feedforward neural networks trained on a small dataset, which
performs poorly on the held-out test subset. Although the effectiveness of this
regularization trick has been extensively studied for convolutional neural
networks, there is a lack of analysis of it for unsupervised models and in
particular, VAE-based neural topic models. In this paper, we have analyzed the
consequences of dropout in the encoder as well as in the decoder of the VAE
architecture in three widely used neural topic models, namely, contextualized
topic model (CTM), ProdLDA, and embedded topic model (ETM) using four publicly
available datasets. We characterize the dropout effect on these models in terms
of the quality and predictive performance of the generated topics. | [
-0.7307393551,
-0.7069926262,
0.2930152118,
-0.1785572022,
-0.261911422,
-0.349173069,
-0.1514158845,
-0.0402635038,
0.2133717239,
0.5246978402,
-0.4818956852,
-0.3408383429,
-0.559771657,
-0.331122607,
-0.7155153751,
1.0833771229,
-0.0442106836,
0.0566933565,
-0.5414361954,
0.2809955776,
-1.1612600088,
-0.4717408121,
-0.4865342081,
-0.4122283757,
0.2553405762,
0.1090903357,
0.1726287454,
0.403103292,
0.5896075964,
0.1319863647,
-0.6211343408,
-0.2674556077,
-0.4731826484,
-0.1499779075,
-0.1231757328,
-0.4305220246,
0.0116154626,
0.2006912678,
0.6692852974,
0.9249311686,
-0.0592041574,
-0.312612921,
0.1503740251,
0.2220665365,
-0.688088119,
-0.2868690491,
-0.4031032622,
0.3279912472,
-0.1698991358,
-0.0158680603,
-0.4493176937,
-0.1674215794,
0.6022749543,
-0.2287996858,
0.5385887623,
-0.5769908428,
0.8369886279,
0.5427923203,
-0.4495949447,
-0.086199142,
-0.8220454454,
0.622729063,
-0.8884489536,
0.0874088332,
0.4263964891,
0.142123878,
-0.186746031,
-0.5321829319,
-0.3138358891,
-0.0286933668,
0.058056552,
0.2715676725,
-0.1018346176,
0.2335016578,
0.2062391043,
0.1810042411,
-0.1059943214,
0.2824998498,
-0.6597035527,
0.1355071366,
0.1882082969,
0.2055146843,
0.2352743596,
-0.3401697278,
-0.2898288667,
0.1650390178,
-0.7032648921,
-0.1198410317,
0.3966859877,
0.063323468,
-0.1891237646,
0.1381722987,
0.1612547338,
0.5933942795,
0.0067424984,
0.4011641741,
-0.2780614495,
-0.1711064577,
-0.2773445249,
0.0670284405,
0.2198620588,
0.2396579385,
0.006679723,
-0.1364245862,
-0.0075261937,
-0.1778006852,
0.5662794709,
-0.9733219743,
-0.2078829408,
0.3943976462,
-0.9897389412,
-0.2405042648,
0.1901414543,
-0.721807003,
-0.3017783463,
-0.279497683,
0.3463356197,
-0.2988556027,
-0.5908297896,
0.0942767113,
-0.4609635174,
0.1422384679,
0.4459005594,
-0.5711588264,
0.4547558725,
0.7740698457,
1.0142430067,
-0.5631421208,
-0.1746760309,
-0.2692582607,
-0.2668013573,
-0.5210119486,
0.4906404912,
-0.4332640469,
-0.5948777795,
0.0825202242,
0.0098550506,
-0.4094874859,
-0.4786354899,
0.2825782597,
-0.4898828268,
0.2328879833,
-0.4236996174,
-1.1413179636,
-0.3715257943,
0.0503448397,
-0.6571100354,
0.1989261359,
-0.4092505872,
-0.7701086998,
0.3673399091,
-0.6850916743,
-0.1233898774,
0.0060713035,
-0.3117434978,
-0.3272615969,
0.4763829112,
-0.155639872,
0.6735188961,
-0.2539888322,
0.6814472079,
0.0083995136,
-0.6507700086,
0.4499664307,
-0.6964851022,
0.5326532722,
0.0825134739,
-0.3482772112,
-0.1922637522,
-0.6726130843,
-0.147429198,
-0.2531226575,
-0.3034166694,
-0.490870297,
0.2008709311,
0.3861314654,
0.3208757639,
-0.2283788174,
-0.4986435473,
-0.0728668496,
-0.4731929302,
0.616451025,
0.6130828857,
0.4374000728,
0.3646426201,
-0.0177875906,
0.4978714883,
0.205841437,
0.0267707817,
-0.1892743558,
-0.6073461175,
-0.6796758175,
-0.2470146418,
0.8307911158,
0.2390293777,
-0.1813014597,
0.4430872202,
0.1938481629,
-0.3714575768,
-0.1311038733,
-0.5800271034,
0.4133507907,
0.4942546189,
0.0968065858,
-0.2400583178,
-0.0571353212,
-1.0296537876,
0.3805713356,
0.3550898731,
0.0466434173,
0.119771786,
0.7096431851,
-0.2252575308,
1.2184295654,
-0.3694142997,
-0.0955880582,
0.1307587177,
0.1843728572,
0.1398989111,
0.7469280362,
0.5659092069,
-0.877282083,
0.0399705321,
-0.2547476292,
-0.6360828876,
0.2372274548,
-0.2366385758,
-0.0235029291,
0.1197079271,
0.3820363283,
-0.8654219508,
0.9311121702,
0.333463788,
-0.2502001822,
0.5479757786,
-0.1557455957,
0.0867791995,
-1.2730419636,
0.2245531231,
0.0970743373,
0.1920120716,
-0.8015846014,
-0.2926661372,
0.1450295299,
-0.6078455448,
-0.6026011705,
0.4618149102,
-0.2758592665,
0.0045324285,
-0.526381135,
-0.1480446607,
0.0584952943,
0.0873870105,
0.5633672476,
0.5315451026,
0.5334861875,
-0.6174108982,
-0.196396336,
0.2089326829,
-0.012589219,
0.0035340236,
-0.9068800807,
0.0660269186,
-0.2354232222,
0.2595834434,
-0.7321472168,
-0.2793903351,
0.0376876369,
-0.2459335774,
0.5435647964,
-0.4107476175,
0.1261022091,
-0.1115746424,
-0.4035888314,
0.2471258491,
0.3596101403,
-0.5338298678,
0.1281213313,
0.1482073665,
0.0680154413,
-0.5905770063,
-0.7075735927,
-0.1015302837,
-0.2870253325,
-0.4550258517,
0.528791368,
-0.0787443742,
-0.0570287928,
0.3669372499,
-0.0484454297,
-0.2743216157,
0.1889888197,
0.4772624969,
-0.1371881813,
-0.2724047899,
0.3662528694,
0.1357567757,
-0.1389078796,
0.1425882578,
0.0850216448,
0.5817379951,
0.054360494,
-0.5492405891,
-0.6872966886,
0.5438545942,
0.3928128779,
-0.1813866794,
0.9013754725,
0.2284923494,
-0.8153672218,
-0.1470122784,
-0.3897639215,
-0.5232259631,
-0.3574462533,
0.6030094624,
-0.1013975367,
-0.5963496566,
0.7091445923,
-0.0137415566,
-0.2749183774,
0.5220548511,
0.3469741642,
-0.0595432557,
0.4285311997,
0.7402980924,
0.2802682817,
0.5918836594,
-0.8121481538,
0.2313152999,
-0.650410831,
-0.3570031226,
-0.3806946576,
-0.3019111753,
-0.7230148315,
-0.1530499458,
-0.0787603334,
0.2317182571,
0.1911151409,
-0.075821422,
-0.5942827463,
0.5595415235,
0.6807028055,
-0.1259575337,
-0.2173674405,
-0.0374575965,
0.3724811375,
-0.5462866426,
-0.753029108,
-0.3061986864,
0.9214052558,
0.3957334757,
0.4766690135,
-0.4023002684,
0.7912272811,
0.4553913474,
-0.0407422706,
-0.6950730085,
0.206664592,
-0.2915977836,
-0.3757590353,
-0.1449285597,
-0.2613028288,
-0.8414599299,
0.0610420667,
-0.1455480158,
-0.5628454685,
1.0096545219,
-0.1412387341,
-0.4754026532,
0.3001443148,
-0.533901751,
0.9638909698,
0.002279056,
-0.0392977297,
-0.278519839,
-0.376827538,
0.4749335945,
-0.2173074484,
-0.3069602847,
0.0323681347,
0.1632687598,
1.1863268614,
-0.6386428475,
0.8711239696,
-0.290489167,
0.0913989842,
0.4178595841,
-0.0792455897,
0.2621508539,
0.2614449561,
-0.1983993053,
0.6187495589,
-0.2197729051,
-0.1573678553,
-0.6922816634,
0.7551531196,
-0.9212329388,
-0.4396482408,
-0.4266293049,
-0.2293964475,
0.0685505271,
0.0322502889,
0.8915076256,
0.9555038214,
-0.0728553236,
0.3960711062,
0.6957474351,
-0.2217905074,
0.7358462811,
0.1839647889,
0.2864744067,
-0.6613672376,
0.8074358106,
0.6365407109,
0.0448156148,
-0.0522707254,
0.1980174184,
-0.0367271155,
-0.9636397958,
-0.2029151469,
0.0565958396,
-0.7866069674,
-0.0507403687,
-0.6622692943,
-0.6854066849,
-0.056935966,
-0.2228455395,
-0.6688668728,
-0.1651057601,
-0.687498033,
-0.1110651344,
0.2452523112,
0.763554275,
-0.0263316482,
0.4945437908,
-0.586831212,
-0.0973827168,
0.0795457214,
0.1663323343,
0.0556968115,
-0.621645391,
-0.4026735425,
-0.0468985811,
-0.3605124652,
-0.9374711514,
0.2888562381,
0.0685906112,
0.7636764646,
0.6662918329,
-0.0224160068,
0.2601841092,
-0.2656028569,
0.8657333255,
0.3854205608,
-0.8705441952,
0.8316789269,
-0.4278809726,
0.0926003903,
0.2978386581,
0.3746374249,
-0.5386096835,
-0.0309045576,
-0.6169373989,
-0.9683396816,
0.8410153389,
0.4328870475,
0.2782012224,
-0.3252831995,
0.7478485107,
0.4297223687,
0.4806693196,
-0.2789239585,
-0.2736362815,
-0.2641645372,
0.1269218773,
0.296642065,
-0.5580706596,
0.2385767251,
-0.0249718409,
0.3715890944,
0.1675812602,
0.3515033424,
-0.1046691239,
0.3379808068,
0.0278919395,
0.0377965309,
0.5331506133,
0.8422977328,
-0.4693990946,
-0.2314808071,
-0.0852016583,
-0.339207828,
0.0427615419,
0.086796537,
-0.6991482377,
0.1586431563,
0.3985598683,
1.0243080854,
0.0925741941,
-0.3339272738,
0.4904076755,
-0.3132350743,
-0.2304271311,
-0.096460931,
-0.1071037427,
-0.0240088999,
0.0661456957,
0.3540712893,
0.4449938536,
0.525490284,
-0.1289127916,
0.198919937,
0.267285645,
-0.541549325,
-0.2978304923,
0.5589248538,
0.4600549936,
-0.4408765435,
0.8623414636,
0.2835377753,
-0.3777925372,
1.2507488728,
0.6071107388,
1.075807333,
0.2017599046,
0.4579372108,
0.0225112159,
0.1555666625,
-0.1852594614,
-0.1700341105,
0.1469390392,
-0.4058959186,
-0.8014637828,
-0.3548397124,
-0.5040264726,
0.6013662815,
-0.866954565,
0.2028031051,
-0.2842314243,
-0.349203974,
-0.071360521,
0.0265495833,
-0.4893271923,
0.5028246045,
0.2148483545,
0.546988368,
-0.8674240708,
0.3590846956,
0.6867135763,
-0.3930937052,
-0.4509637952,
0.5253118873,
-0.2959222496,
0.3469244242,
0.8104546666,
0.3167118728,
0.1510040313,
-0.1116243228,
-0.3399690688,
-1.0351823568,
0.5533160567,
0.6408455968,
-0.5277243257,
0.1565203071,
-0.0634970441,
0.4521437287,
-0.2672522664,
0.3433901072,
0.3639425039,
0.009368822,
-0.196614027,
-0.5193884969,
-0.1782782674,
-0.2672506571,
0.3582315743,
0.3840371072,
-0.6819263697,
1.0183734894,
0.1267723292,
0.0747409984,
-0.3945505619,
0.3133198321,
0.0132166147,
0.5043770075,
-0.0297458842,
0.4761489332,
0.5011740327,
0.0074556284,
1.1429491043,
-0.0932433903,
0.4990508854,
0.8436704278,
-0.0790147483,
0.800745368,
0.2823571265,
0.1743841022,
-0.184276998,
1.1686458588,
0.1706584096,
0.8425400853,
0.26313743,
0.1544672996,
-0.3197535574,
-0.0843325406,
-0.704648912,
0.5737561584,
0.3891326785,
-0.2932602465,
-0.1998261064,
0.4009998441,
-0.1192253307,
0.0095523195,
-0.1360882074,
0.40955621,
0.2421066463,
-0.4073289335,
0.4857425392,
0.0295412112,
0.6370806694,
-0.165183723,
-0.2436021864,
-0.7671118379,
0.099346295,
-0.0456094071,
-0.4052956998,
0.379775852,
-0.1615325361,
-0.5780856013,
0.1091418564,
0.9972399473,
-0.2180221826,
-0.3531891406,
0.6265790462,
0.6487836838,
0.2347974926,
-0.1071647182,
-0.4383330941,
-0.0424871072,
-0.3804025948,
-0.4615280628,
0.466638118,
0.1824083179,
-0.2419936359,
0.378207624,
0.3737207949,
0.1464133114,
0.149194479,
0.3220452666,
0.8012562394,
-0.5947089195,
-0.6645457745,
-1.0654973984,
0.3975564539,
-0.1791580915,
-0.52806741,
0.7538510561,
0.3968944848,
0.5824396014,
-0.2126409262,
0.7512665391,
0.162177071,
0.1284025759,
-0.613737464,
1.0628290176,
-0.627928853,
0.2190047503,
-0.1760768443,
-0.9375495315,
-0.1105670556,
0.2281293273,
-0.5376284122,
0.1873412728,
0.6065253615,
0.3966706097,
-0.1620468795,
0.0114760613,
0.5935073495,
-0.2329907864,
0.2863776386,
0.2303070426,
0.9718717933,
-0.4174741805,
0.1768613011,
-0.406350404,
0.1649754494,
-0.5313922763,
-0.6091699004,
-1.0278463364,
-0.566342175,
-0.8616756201,
-0.0191938486,
0.4882882833,
0.4824354947,
0.979600668,
-0.9179557562,
0.1427418441,
-0.3633950949,
0.1625128984,
0.01229872,
-0.2183308005,
0.8165265322,
-0.0547079816,
-0.5873352289,
0.3394379616,
0.0902978778,
-0.045091141,
-0.1245604232,
0.1836711615,
-0.2060936987,
0.0592393503,
0.3355925679,
0.0178603288,
-0.6470838785,
-0.1292089522,
-0.2006204277,
0.0990692899,
-0.0440471694,
1.1002788544,
-0.6228482127,
0.3870767057,
0.460637629,
0.8703455925,
0.3942976594,
0.1184388921,
0.4823205173,
-0.7758604288,
0.217058599,
0.2693409026,
0.3603515327,
0.1274024695,
-0.6452627182,
0.2603835762,
0.3804721832,
-0.5138354897,
-0.8887785077,
-0.089053899,
-0.4041175842,
-0.4497257173,
1.0508209467,
-0.1400062293,
-0.2978286743,
-0.0722108856,
-0.1193123236,
0.3100524843,
-0.4066432118,
0.5697588325,
0.6998560429,
-0.0020002828,
-0.2204906642,
-0.8467627168,
0.4876222014,
0.4003853798,
-0.8534680605,
-0.0871186629,
0.6219496131,
0.3943021894,
0.2375475764,
0.3995810151,
0.3378489017,
0.4869494736,
0.2077448666,
0.4431105256,
-0.1565517336,
-0.5379627347,
-0.720333159,
0.2636054158,
-0.284155339,
-0.785775423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15870v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15870v1 | A Multi-Granularity Matching Attention Network for Query Intent Classification in E-commerce Retrieval | 2023-03-28T10:25:17 | 2023-03-28T10:25:17 | Chunyuan Yuan, Yiming Qiu, Mingming Li, Haiqing Hu, Songlin Wang, Sulong Xu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Query intent classification, which aims at assisting customers to find
desired products, has become an essential component of the e-commerce search.
Existing query intent classification models either design more exquisite models
to enhance the representation learning of queries or explore label-graph and
multi-task to facilitate models to learn external information. However, these
models cannot capture multi-granularity matching features from queries and
categories, which makes them hard to mitigate the gap in the expression between
informal queries and categories.
This paper proposes a Multi-granularity Matching Attention Network (MMAN),
which contains three modules: a self-matching module, a char-level matching
module, and a semantic-level matching module to comprehensively extract
features from the query and a query-category interaction matrix. In this way,
the model can eliminate the difference in expression between queries and
categories for query intent classification. We conduct extensive offline and
online A/B experiments, and the results show that the MMAN significantly
outperforms the strong baselines, which shows the superiority and effectiveness
of MMAN. MMAN has been deployed in production and brings great commercial value
for our company. | [
-0.4883979261,
-0.8457428217,
0.3082118034,
0.3976004124,
0.0564143434,
-0.4493371248,
0.1977151632,
-0.5237908363,
0.4854559302,
0.6003845334,
-0.6701047421,
-0.3079361916,
-0.2053452432,
-0.0312572904,
-0.3005238771,
0.5666044354,
0.2772243619,
-0.261962235,
-0.267277509,
-0.0390985273,
-0.3184105456,
-0.5311235189,
-0.9393372536,
0.2555806339,
0.8551493287,
0.1162287146,
0.2092841864,
0.3487716317,
0.8940103054,
0.3985349834,
0.1542512178,
0.7422103286,
-0.4479160011,
0.0860023573,
-0.0213722717,
-0.2924318016,
-0.7916657329,
-0.0677393451,
0.2048977911,
0.3329901695,
-0.4165596664,
0.3190907836,
0.0026331153,
0.7348106503,
-0.7556736469,
0.3481200635,
-0.6410814524,
0.2023131847,
-0.0289464686,
-0.3219194114,
-0.4904250205,
-0.0988688767,
-0.1804388314,
-0.6374974847,
0.1227081865,
0.4592932463,
0.9152874947,
0.181343466,
-0.6425985098,
-0.3013382852,
-0.3199787736,
0.3703271747,
-0.4329251051,
0.382040441,
0.6406901479,
0.4119525254,
0.056286674,
-0.9479678869,
-0.1992407739,
0.1774427295,
-0.4656813741,
0.3335990012,
0.0173983239,
0.1178142503,
0.0904493257,
0.2530025542,
-0.6460590959,
-0.3387185633,
-0.4018528759,
-0.0737516657,
0.600646615,
0.309111625,
0.1250793785,
-0.1477833837,
-0.5512673259,
0.3218880594,
-0.2219693065,
0.105021365,
0.1121800467,
0.4568556249,
0.4485364258,
0.4156735837,
-0.7193157077,
0.905208528,
0.3784637153,
-0.1714050323,
0.2125689983,
-0.5797614455,
-0.3290562332,
0.1758053899,
0.7920991778,
0.2520012856,
-0.2194319963,
-0.1371482462,
-0.0324278809,
-0.4440053701,
0.7484412193,
-0.8259518147,
-0.0463194288,
0.0702261776,
-0.5485357642,
0.0189456716,
0.2888996899,
-0.3254872561,
0.1405678391,
-0.3155157268,
0.4980264306,
0.0943830013,
-0.0718129352,
0.3398578167,
0.2703644335,
0.4138912559,
0.2935967147,
-0.768157959,
0.3187448084,
0.8423380256,
0.9750590324,
-0.0919410214,
-0.1195735261,
-0.2901268303,
0.3594618738,
-0.0268277768,
0.7993584871,
-0.6299247146,
0.0424462259,
-0.1654198766,
0.2107654661,
-0.5818619728,
-0.4367138743,
0.5722748637,
-1.0612530708,
-0.0359555259,
-0.0370518416,
-0.361576438,
-0.6436698437,
0.9294028282,
-0.8044421673,
0.8714650869,
-0.1507170349,
-0.6129619479,
0.2998099029,
-0.854878962,
-0.3266516626,
0.1718023717,
0.0956615359,
-0.7400740981,
0.0274951104,
0.0829832479,
0.5505093336,
0.0279194005,
0.0838525072,
-0.5999907255,
-0.357406348,
0.2502804697,
-0.2553336322,
0.3707218766,
0.2053999752,
-0.2420095354,
0.0018386532,
-0.4144706428,
0.324934721,
0.0155753475,
-0.4808478653,
-0.3110206723,
-0.3333066106,
-0.1383292079,
0.6951376796,
0.2543489933,
-0.2830413878,
0.2886658311,
-0.1213553324,
0.2146029025,
0.4243079126,
0.0722776055,
0.1851683557,
-0.2481462508,
0.339207679,
0.0231271815,
0.4581842124,
-0.0114146266,
-0.7358548641,
-0.5887647271,
-0.1648837477,
0.1193661988,
0.409386605,
-0.3398670554,
0.4466944933,
-0.4715797603,
-0.1643211395,
-0.538517952,
-0.0433988869,
0.3017605543,
0.3167825341,
0.2477773577,
-0.4626638889,
-0.1747527868,
-0.985298872,
-0.2475649714,
-0.0144382827,
0.0323978812,
1.2691659927,
0.0972994342,
-0.1635999084,
0.731882751,
-0.5647802949,
-1.1051172018,
-0.0607490987,
-0.1717042476,
0.0988419503,
0.1701747179,
0.3441734016,
-1.226646781,
-0.7301049829,
0.3187030256,
-0.4524557292,
0.0614650175,
0.228794083,
-0.6139785051,
-0.250659287,
0.3056641221,
-0.3895858526,
0.2840740681,
0.0864271224,
-0.1848217249,
0.1717304736,
-0.0443801135,
0.6635635495,
-1.183475852,
0.1896383315,
0.0029868376,
-0.2749043703,
-0.7093209028,
0.0184122492,
0.3586579561,
-0.115688242,
-0.8167929053,
0.3158244789,
-0.1735980809,
-0.154367879,
-0.0898693353,
0.2234468311,
0.5425337553,
0.7064752579,
-0.0785331801,
0.6700894237,
0.4843268394,
-1.1243829727,
0.4222729504,
0.4154956937,
-0.0165779479,
0.6929112673,
-0.3142201602,
0.1571377516,
0.0260658171,
0.2424461693,
-0.8428800702,
-0.4896531105,
0.2566669881,
-0.4734010696,
0.2834220231,
-0.4953267872,
-0.3219615221,
-0.4832115769,
-0.2694151998,
0.6490727067,
-0.0453113765,
-0.554769218,
1.0526616573,
0.1999522001,
-0.1113076061,
-0.6643639803,
-0.8551882505,
-0.0242411662,
-0.2902289927,
-0.7513977289,
0.2386109233,
0.0291737076,
0.5271986723,
-0.1105074361,
0.0493944362,
-0.34991768,
0.131366089,
0.0269481689,
-0.1202310175,
-0.2809318304,
0.2240763754,
-0.0668878406,
0.1410911977,
-0.0365932249,
-0.3995977938,
0.4436112344,
0.0171637852,
-0.6426489353,
-0.6113580465,
0.3522876203,
0.4150242209,
-0.4507617652,
0.5971343517,
0.8412703276,
-0.2251858115,
0.0503850393,
-0.6820328236,
-0.0686306059,
-0.5233752131,
0.3951582313,
-0.5560867786,
-0.7812905908,
0.2415580899,
-0.1420288086,
-0.3420189619,
0.2582347095,
0.2598777115,
0.0409397557,
1.2604347467,
0.3157734573,
0.2815017104,
0.3815676272,
-0.2111605406,
0.3423655331,
-1.2955284119,
-0.720371604,
-0.4118582308,
-0.5762370229,
-0.2560279369,
-0.2595431507,
0.18087928,
-0.0454300754,
-0.1411154419,
0.1983328611,
-0.4778220952,
0.401027441,
0.3563022614,
0.4362137616,
0.1429360509,
0.2711442411,
0.1072587371,
0.2741281688,
-0.51140517,
-0.0712109134,
0.908017993,
-0.124390997,
0.7245027423,
0.4904937148,
0.4016165435,
0.1525609642,
0.1304481328,
-1.0707259178,
0.5602775812,
-0.1902969778,
-0.9463123679,
-0.0516587198,
-0.8913149834,
-1.1161236763,
0.6306774616,
0.3245054483,
-0.6423150897,
0.2452759743,
-0.0531343296,
-0.4040619731,
0.1985143572,
-0.6624037027,
1.0669573545,
-0.4790040255,
-0.5134446025,
0.2466638684,
-0.4771694541,
0.4629107416,
-0.0143051567,
0.1776440144,
-0.1191047132,
-0.2054736912,
0.5632229447,
0.082724385,
0.5130541325,
0.0335888043,
0.1481309235,
0.2797142267,
0.1397972554,
0.4207183421,
0.0918034911,
0.0408086106,
-0.207150206,
-0.5842814445,
-0.4709731638,
-0.5439936519,
0.677959621,
-0.1711645126,
-0.525914371,
-0.1407488286,
-0.3152476251,
-0.2295518517,
0.3601796627,
-0.1131517589,
0.5245491862,
-0.1575797796,
0.5325360894,
0.83107692,
0.4898326993,
0.5268288255,
0.4434117973,
-0.3756024539,
-0.303686887,
0.9302884936,
-0.0853251219,
0.2634752393,
0.5973840952,
0.1153639033,
-0.6374018788,
-0.2500365973,
-0.4442855716,
-0.040888615,
-0.6321747303,
-0.4436582923,
-1.1117491722,
-0.2184729278,
-0.4033637047,
0.246848464,
-0.0450115055,
-0.1366216987,
-0.2642797828,
0.1950503588,
0.1309257895,
0.4252236784,
0.26632303,
0.3812329173,
-0.8646121621,
0.2827818096,
0.7216077447,
0.5065267086,
0.1743361205,
-0.4641010463,
-0.3092983365,
-0.1059950739,
-0.4885562062,
-0.4460464716,
0.2156946808,
0.7032827735,
0.4739865065,
0.8935124278,
-0.0170533992,
0.7788254619,
-0.2615311742,
0.4454321265,
0.095153451,
-0.4051572382,
0.4995835721,
-0.1565758139,
0.164922744,
0.7508588433,
0.7271474004,
-0.3829556108,
0.1136649549,
-0.4314275384,
-0.8230846524,
1.259444356,
0.2800130546,
0.0576167814,
-0.1067262217,
0.3919204473,
-0.0420574471,
0.497956872,
-0.6915040016,
-0.2995936275,
0.0392825343,
-0.1101524234,
0.3244086802,
0.0639802068,
0.1401637644,
0.0292369798,
0.616474092,
-0.3635869026,
0.3279777467,
0.1368712187,
-0.2164255679,
0.3444001377,
0.1356292069,
0.1637791991,
0.5272392631,
-0.0594056286,
0.0155092441,
-0.0293243136,
-0.6461855173,
0.0327315629,
-0.0216218196,
-0.1641841531,
-0.3774607778,
-0.269678086,
0.7403025627,
-0.0070196274,
-0.1580845863,
0.7931479216,
-0.5954549313,
-0.0363384113,
0.1047495455,
0.1285520941,
0.1345027238,
0.0607015081,
0.0715689734,
0.227092132,
0.9795873165,
-0.5745710135,
0.3256502151,
0.5470249653,
-0.7016096711,
0.0013792987,
0.3346719146,
0.0268849283,
-0.4213138819,
0.4297908247,
-0.6116594076,
-0.6640190482,
0.6139418483,
0.5294959545,
0.7530331016,
-0.4563621879,
0.2216738164,
0.4539829493,
0.0583776273,
-0.1692216396,
0.1951786876,
-0.323676765,
-0.3132173419,
-0.0791616589,
-0.7857227921,
-0.0569597445,
-0.0598878451,
-0.7018809915,
0.2944675088,
0.0070484942,
-0.2647386193,
-0.0240657032,
-0.0728813782,
-0.5880585909,
0.4141313136,
-0.1402346343,
0.2110431492,
-0.3790989816,
0.2835884988,
0.7394741774,
-0.4337665737,
-0.6637765169,
-0.08312089,
-0.2578774989,
-0.6314904094,
0.4850510657,
0.7078166604,
-0.1620112658,
0.0486793891,
-0.0977172554,
-0.9206701517,
1.1123497486,
-0.1834160835,
-0.4130139649,
0.0481505468,
0.0874757096,
0.0580940768,
-0.7427862287,
0.5186134577,
0.2526611984,
0.4431776106,
0.3163884282,
-0.730645895,
-0.0091766706,
-0.0792603791,
-0.1400610954,
0.3914031982,
-0.9053774476,
0.6178449988,
0.1475801468,
-0.1822970212,
-0.213188976,
0.1853932291,
0.0074298009,
0.6683912277,
0.2736060023,
0.7212756872,
0.572612524,
-0.2140628397,
0.7584462762,
-0.0315258913,
0.703222394,
0.8246709108,
-0.2287177891,
0.8532474637,
-0.0274971724,
-0.2781181037,
0.2264877409,
0.6863753796,
0.0953125432,
0.5094640255,
0.0877965018,
-0.0884512886,
-0.4866637886,
-0.2222235054,
-0.3784721792,
0.3433442712,
0.6249703169,
-0.2572546899,
-0.1116101816,
-0.0578902923,
-0.5059255362,
-0.4954489768,
-0.6338142157,
1.3280484676,
-0.0052764639,
-0.2311585397,
0.448533386,
-0.2075625062,
0.5454348326,
-0.5875338912,
0.2718589604,
-0.140328452,
0.3728887141,
-0.4980102181,
-0.4529718161,
0.1294693649,
-0.6151104569,
-0.179157719,
0.3305154741,
0.8871968389,
-0.4362731874,
-0.5429998636,
0.4203734994,
0.3532748222,
0.2405651808,
-0.5389600396,
-0.9898711443,
-0.2489088178,
-0.3075187504,
-0.3168462515,
0.4151053727,
0.740257442,
0.2730715275,
0.620978117,
0.5506871939,
-0.3641441464,
0.5375576615,
0.1747364551,
0.6506143808,
-0.4700995982,
-0.7487953901,
-0.4860726297,
0.0876763538,
-0.3832386136,
-0.1086537689,
0.4973108768,
0.9356547594,
0.4783736169,
0.0020588136,
0.3808920085,
0.1568935066,
-0.093590945,
-0.3836494684,
0.6442224979,
-1.0449005365,
-0.0687297732,
0.1120543256,
-1.1109257936,
-0.3904098272,
0.3897971213,
0.0504556559,
0.7352817655,
0.8432117105,
0.6986282468,
-0.9158359766,
-0.1889875233,
0.5619527698,
-0.0542570986,
0.0988007933,
0.5244270563,
0.5761510134,
-0.7125998139,
0.9388098121,
-0.0011434761,
-0.1231169403,
-0.8537712693,
-0.4821933508,
-0.7739366293,
-0.3011686504,
-0.2912104726,
-0.2096367329,
-0.1056246012,
0.5665999055,
0.9613429904,
-0.6014095545,
-0.011745776,
0.0152714765,
-0.0949900672,
-0.3420262039,
-0.2349141091,
0.5006300211,
-0.5506781936,
-0.4636363089,
0.098655805,
0.7745260596,
-0.0128265414,
0.0982464924,
0.1109594926,
-0.6785533428,
0.3572866917,
0.6135482192,
-0.1262903512,
-0.8041753769,
0.1653845906,
0.4550251663,
-0.1228587702,
0.3218533397,
0.8333432674,
-0.4284282029,
0.4425504804,
0.3511778414,
0.9416400194,
0.6110585928,
0.3156763017,
-0.1719978154,
-0.9706512094,
-0.3449370563,
0.2541570067,
0.3798777759,
0.2338820845,
-0.5757790208,
0.3659017682,
-0.1141666919,
-0.6393467188,
-0.3134363592,
0.3927857578,
-1.1120761633,
-0.0405608527,
1.1624494791,
-0.2519128025,
-0.5915572047,
-0.5557655692,
-0.4239815474,
-0.1039966345,
-0.5249434114,
0.858402133,
0.4814784527,
-0.3075498044,
0.0824084356,
-0.3315058351,
0.1090608463,
0.2382633239,
-0.8994031549,
0.026918659,
0.1379419714,
-0.0850988477,
0.4177401662,
0.4208046198,
-0.0718011409,
0.4650188982,
-0.2934307456,
-0.1974707097,
-0.3467234075,
-0.5010388494,
-0.0665153787,
0.5487281084,
-0.2089314759,
-0.3154793084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15846v1 | Soft-prompt tuning to predict lung cancer using primary care free-text Dutch medical notes | 2023-03-28T09:36:53 | 2023-03-28T09:36:53 | Auke Elfrink, Iacopo Vagliano, Ameen Abu-Hanna, Iacer Calixto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | We investigate different natural language processing (NLP) approaches based
on contextualised word representations for the problem of early prediction of
lung cancer using free-text patient medical notes of Dutch primary care
physicians. Because lung cancer has a low prevalence in primary care, we also
address the problem of classification under highly imbalanced classes.
Specifically, we use large Transformer-based pretrained language models (PLMs)
and investigate: 1) how \textit{soft prompt-tuning} -- an NLP technique used to
adapt PLMs using small amounts of training data -- compares to standard model
fine-tuning; 2) whether simpler static word embedding models (WEMs) can be more
robust compared to PLMs in highly imbalanced settings; and 3) how models fare
when trained on notes from a small number of patients. We find that 1)
soft-prompt tuning is an efficient alternative to standard model fine-tuning;
2) PLMs show better discrimination but worse calibration compared to simpler
static word embedding models as the classification problem becomes more
imbalanced; and 3) results when training models on small number of patients are
mixed and show no clear differences between PLMs and WEMs. All our code is
available open source in
\url{https://bitbucket.org/aumc-kik/prompt_tuning_cancer_prediction/}. | [
-0.1374603808,
-0.5722154379,
0.5897223949,
0.1454110295,
-0.4516757727,
-0.3249392509,
-0.3180065155,
-0.1531882137,
0.1369573623,
0.991871655,
-0.5948069096,
-0.7361697555,
-0.8205290437,
0.3239731491,
-0.060311079,
1.1749702692,
0.2892228663,
0.4300337732,
-0.0036047392,
-0.321313709,
-0.5788069367,
-0.3155037165,
-0.8603801131,
-0.3162988424,
0.8452970386,
0.7379205227,
0.6334058046,
0.4163819253,
0.4590791166,
0.2087692022,
-0.4940935373,
0.1799390167,
-0.1666872799,
0.3335013688,
-0.0353844576,
-0.4653620124,
-0.2637981772,
0.0661275908,
0.1613876522,
0.8864467144,
-0.1582136899,
-0.1554531753,
0.4034921527,
1.0016666651,
-0.4464487731,
-0.0641272515,
-0.7031328082,
0.2313768715,
-0.1265521795,
-0.4486301541,
-0.5008745193,
-0.2819253504,
0.2586225569,
-0.4989150167,
0.4725866318,
0.0009047432,
0.5580967069,
0.3893097043,
-0.6604248881,
-0.5268516541,
-0.6985319257,
0.4965189397,
-0.5513824224,
-0.065536499,
0.3935031295,
0.3085978031,
-0.3053379953,
-0.7210807204,
-0.0533602796,
-0.3459323645,
-0.1634489894,
0.3081301153,
0.0240255818,
0.5558487773,
0.4652452767,
0.6819646358,
-0.6550363302,
0.2224788219,
-0.2614707351,
-0.2369508743,
0.3945728242,
0.2011253685,
0.0771583766,
-0.2438781112,
-0.1731299311,
0.1158199683,
-0.6338026524,
0.0943204463,
0.0647733435,
0.6760015488,
0.1210855097,
0.7108280659,
-0.2318720371,
0.8295693994,
0.2434390634,
0.0449853167,
0.1803089529,
-0.2241155058,
-0.21353513,
0.3639532328,
0.7217203975,
0.3828816414,
0.2090166956,
0.1888221502,
0.17387788,
0.2161627561,
0.3149323761,
-0.7233682275,
-0.3895995617,
0.2214958519,
-0.7789942622,
-0.416919291,
-0.0682356358,
-0.6288499236,
-0.4636979997,
-0.0663487315,
0.3705542982,
-0.2217198759,
-0.0167973917,
0.4358389378,
-0.0137166567,
-0.2322759926,
0.2190016657,
-0.6340135336,
0.1961282641,
0.5705775023,
0.8913075328,
0.2134369016,
0.2204119563,
-0.8959797621,
-0.07804019,
0.0051382082,
0.794898212,
-0.4549535513,
-0.6859942675,
0.1266049892,
0.3731485903,
-0.1704108268,
-0.5457814336,
1.1860221624,
0.0920303538,
0.7563571334,
-0.3418674469,
-0.5152044892,
-0.1002817601,
0.0554427989,
-0.7824177742,
0.7855552435,
0.24209629,
-0.8996516466,
0.4646275342,
-0.6898674369,
-0.4624118805,
0.1720832139,
0.055109635,
-0.6105083227,
0.4216661751,
0.3802353144,
0.5714529157,
-0.2061532736,
0.1984396428,
-0.2500570416,
-0.1981175393,
0.0892210007,
-0.5179250836,
0.8994538784,
0.3570147455,
-0.2713731229,
0.3321054578,
-0.6579487324,
0.0282267407,
-0.0613630712,
-0.1460542083,
-0.3148555756,
0.1288248748,
-0.0172646958,
0.4368208349,
-0.0217873063,
-0.4854328334,
0.4458667934,
-0.8413612247,
0.2570313215,
0.4377191067,
0.1206386015,
0.1820985377,
-0.4823454916,
0.4964405,
0.2059866637,
0.3733869791,
-0.3263320029,
-0.9892593026,
-0.358245343,
-0.1335689127,
0.3992851079,
0.8212951422,
-0.6058875918,
0.6073845029,
0.0512892939,
-0.2677825093,
-0.5348829031,
0.3692648709,
0.267621696,
0.8819394708,
0.4092859626,
-0.5304856896,
-0.4381825626,
-0.9216751456,
-0.3171317279,
-0.1303247958,
-0.2891238332,
0.5701286197,
0.0513054952,
-0.2005473971,
0.6313878298,
-0.6119005084,
-0.5847414136,
-0.3519774377,
0.3921912313,
0.3728848696,
0.433201611,
0.2722503245,
-0.8264091611,
-0.5844417214,
-0.139053762,
-0.3443556726,
-0.5068767667,
0.0602007918,
0.0457585454,
0.0661389753,
0.4496236444,
-0.3573800027,
0.3709228337,
0.6679093242,
-0.4478456974,
0.1957835555,
-0.4566678703,
-0.0563503765,
-1.0402917862,
0.1260835379,
0.0835509822,
-0.2344857305,
-0.5109350681,
-0.4129783213,
-0.0597412623,
-0.3045627475,
-0.3577041328,
0.4552944899,
-0.1929572672,
0.3751081526,
-0.5498206019,
-0.2679226398,
0.1479848772,
0.112369135,
0.2251673192,
0.5503715277,
0.4066874385,
-0.559827745,
-0.1745928675,
0.1804949194,
-0.3705227673,
0.4916106462,
-0.695289433,
-0.0682597309,
-0.0526692197,
0.5095723867,
-0.9365675449,
-0.1469411999,
0.3025739491,
-0.3689597547,
0.2684117258,
-0.3424907029,
-0.3512476385,
-0.7055817842,
0.0544575602,
0.2793094814,
0.4186599255,
-0.1579459757,
0.3665623367,
0.0712501928,
-0.5098666549,
-0.2544620633,
-0.528676033,
-0.0610982999,
-0.2043954879,
-0.4618348777,
0.3605729043,
-0.1673861295,
0.1543441266,
-0.0429094546,
0.0899250954,
-0.0952221379,
0.2965794504,
0.4229993522,
0.0227018334,
-0.372422874,
0.1170914695,
0.1657316536,
-0.5022831559,
-0.119902119,
-0.4801914096,
0.3108795881,
-0.2260234505,
-0.2544365525,
-0.4656132162,
0.5718789697,
0.6771366596,
-0.03648654,
0.7710987926,
0.5948143005,
-0.3866797686,
0.0778956562,
-0.5134349465,
-0.304505527,
-0.442340374,
-0.0765764788,
0.14409931,
-0.979521513,
0.4455379546,
-0.2957476974,
-0.057154052,
0.7553706765,
0.7151073813,
-0.1876070946,
1.5472990274,
0.8015521765,
0.0406687632,
0.3882550597,
0.0093711829,
-0.2692864239,
-0.4994892776,
-0.0665906817,
-0.8183036447,
-0.34941414,
-0.9178167582,
-0.211368233,
0.7926005721,
-0.0417795293,
-0.1222685501,
-0.0602343678,
-1.0727069378,
0.2774943411,
0.5849141479,
0.3725306094,
0.1101205349,
-0.0284923688,
-0.279101789,
-0.2114942223,
-0.9338777065,
-0.3214918077,
1.2023450136,
0.2082238048,
0.3452304304,
-0.4053375721,
0.4939952195,
0.05516617,
0.4598864019,
-0.7591859698,
0.0881381854,
-0.8591142893,
-0.7044082284,
-0.0073104156,
-0.545989573,
-1.1978945732,
-0.0702092424,
-0.2742711604,
-0.3135834336,
0.018980749,
0.2943862677,
-0.6789693236,
0.2579694688,
-0.5186325312,
0.9604653716,
-0.4335760474,
-0.1453887075,
0.0765756145,
-0.8741047978,
0.1456516236,
0.3042104244,
0.0141274603,
-0.0917682871,
0.0695871562,
0.6917199492,
-0.4650687873,
0.793623805,
-0.5718992949,
-0.09703473,
0.3015910685,
-0.2168351263,
0.3925188482,
0.1637948006,
-0.2741950452,
-0.0991841406,
-0.0501237586,
-0.6342383623,
-0.4762375653,
0.5769851804,
-0.515130043,
-0.3935578763,
-0.461130023,
-0.2002603412,
-0.327244252,
0.1329881996,
0.749986887,
0.6519918442,
-0.1278588772,
0.4614406824,
0.7497470975,
-0.5034960508,
0.0239697695,
0.7177119851,
0.0455172621,
-0.4810168743,
0.5257048607,
0.1770947129,
-0.0545200445,
0.4735777676,
0.6856873035,
-0.0666416138,
-0.5197654366,
-0.296487987,
-0.011767149,
-0.3666275144,
-0.300453037,
-0.7627926469,
-0.3098883033,
-0.2373780906,
-0.2809026241,
-0.2509201765,
-0.3181132972,
-0.5012502074,
0.0516067408,
0.5083456039,
0.5674674511,
-0.0504866913,
0.6165028214,
-0.8670408726,
0.2017381787,
0.1591509581,
0.4718607068,
-0.5766829848,
-0.455966413,
-0.2394884825,
-0.1061943397,
-0.3349234462,
-0.8590662479,
0.4484676719,
0.2361325771,
0.3567699492,
0.489210099,
0.2226289213,
0.3268651962,
-0.4486126006,
0.8882530332,
0.2372410148,
-0.5698583126,
0.9094371796,
-0.5778025389,
0.5240228176,
1.1289098263,
0.288826406,
-0.6947543025,
-0.3070105016,
-0.7712279558,
-0.9868937135,
0.5939434767,
-0.1035295874,
-0.0079259891,
-0.1432914287,
0.5844792128,
0.4543352723,
0.222231552,
-0.5327538252,
-0.3329897225,
-0.3649598658,
-0.5023444891,
-0.408202529,
-0.490884006,
-0.3294758201,
-0.2609293759,
0.6147348285,
-0.3773893714,
0.4145170748,
0.3765280247,
-0.0008043123,
-0.4188658297,
0.2792294919,
0.8711829185,
0.1891311556,
-0.3671046197,
-0.067609705,
0.0745631754,
-0.4336065054,
0.0247889142,
0.1091836691,
-0.1717513651,
0.3631149828,
0.2651711106,
0.9193615913,
0.4590425193,
-0.445356667,
0.6922296882,
-0.2583347261,
-0.2624650598,
-0.1626580507,
0.0595673285,
-0.2480475307,
-0.1542657316,
0.3112492263,
0.1951865703,
0.1901732236,
-0.1509031951,
0.2289746553,
0.449400723,
-0.7339175344,
-0.1981231272,
0.5821349621,
0.4632426798,
-0.2725811005,
0.4835106432,
0.0626776293,
-0.5572320223,
0.634765327,
0.4321923852,
1.0664249659,
-0.2707286775,
0.3206268549,
0.3247126043,
0.3321709037,
-0.1842324734,
0.2495427579,
0.1278541237,
-0.2649093568,
-0.5896843076,
-0.353472054,
-0.6272229552,
0.4160677195,
-0.8049218655,
0.4155209959,
-0.5681727529,
-0.1609277427,
-0.0834231302,
0.5469713807,
-0.7223103642,
0.3768466711,
0.3077610433,
1.1292464733,
-0.9580174088,
0.6937671304,
0.7265946865,
-0.0027060034,
-0.7337935567,
0.1192713231,
0.0550684258,
-0.4956459999,
0.2760641277,
0.6433650851,
0.191615805,
-0.2702971697,
-0.4720272422,
-0.5975663066,
0.7860146165,
0.2830603123,
-0.7300208807,
-0.0489749834,
-0.1607417166,
0.5637821555,
-0.3434387743,
0.3020965457,
0.0814747065,
0.5120216608,
0.0140978554,
-1.0760085583,
-0.1282524914,
-0.2027431279,
-0.3685216606,
0.1332067698,
-0.4003868997,
0.7479590178,
0.160661757,
-0.1044593677,
0.2406548709,
0.4939929247,
-0.1375206411,
0.7947529554,
0.6767550111,
0.5996989608,
0.9358268976,
-0.0705330297,
1.1309771538,
-0.5584738255,
0.1653496027,
0.8462048769,
-0.3688992262,
0.5882650018,
0.2250273526,
0.0464893207,
0.6655507088,
0.5971241593,
0.2126231492,
0.5782965422,
-0.1022795737,
-0.3151548505,
-0.2757865787,
-0.0204320289,
-0.6446062326,
0.2996106148,
0.6712925434,
-0.5637627244,
-0.1785093546,
0.3740849495,
-0.1691968739,
0.0196027327,
-0.534104228,
1.0733414888,
0.2132924944,
-0.9207291007,
0.4709896445,
0.0726160631,
0.7460576296,
-0.7599081397,
0.2961631119,
-0.0241000298,
0.2671716809,
-0.2466125041,
-0.5336101055,
0.3914206028,
-0.1583433002,
-0.4214656055,
-0.3665914237,
0.97263062,
-0.4690228999,
-0.803379178,
0.2108900547,
0.5154837966,
-0.1627676785,
-0.1301386356,
-0.9638018608,
-0.324001044,
-0.0213116761,
-0.3109588027,
0.3633176982,
0.4846919477,
-0.0133359265,
0.3774584234,
0.6170151234,
0.322576344,
-0.4106194973,
-0.0378570557,
0.6714567542,
-0.6840662956,
-0.5895085335,
-0.6049363613,
0.34770751,
0.1554170698,
-0.6479635835,
0.4465167522,
0.3180674911,
0.4402145147,
0.0306929238,
0.5587330461,
0.3147338629,
0.9369632602,
-0.7299190164,
0.4980463684,
-0.5816240311,
0.0616591461,
-0.1715860367,
-0.5470142961,
-0.6010054946,
0.5710852146,
-0.4250354767,
-0.0259057898,
0.5904316306,
0.6868770719,
-0.0598054416,
0.2470630258,
0.0967482254,
0.3373096585,
0.1025580689,
0.4949787259,
0.3708554506,
-0.1376395375,
0.387606889,
-0.5230937004,
-0.1992559433,
-0.7101130486,
-0.9710139632,
-0.6169569492,
-0.463819474,
-0.4235796034,
-0.5033187866,
0.0131431129,
1.2217550278,
0.6567941308,
-0.9942566156,
0.1889089495,
-0.1606853902,
0.1201742813,
-0.2799661756,
-0.1641894877,
0.2643283904,
-0.1843586862,
-0.3349919021,
0.5841624737,
0.2821909189,
-0.1218420044,
-0.0419064797,
0.0119027738,
0.0680510774,
-0.1058244929,
0.4854723215,
0.412429601,
-0.5139042139,
-0.0281261988,
-0.0406447947,
-0.2943833172,
0.182905212,
1.2232995033,
-0.9958177805,
0.5324478149,
0.2491822392,
0.4069466591,
0.2552226484,
0.0344652273,
0.4839904308,
-0.8344498277,
0.327950865,
0.6008201838,
0.3502870798,
0.4688921273,
-0.5523937941,
0.207583189,
0.2604441047,
-0.7184676528,
-0.8341242075,
0.2335494608,
-1.04687953,
-0.4262050688,
1.0449410677,
0.004187129,
-0.2073299736,
-0.3512810469,
-0.5527644157,
0.3508056402,
-0.3464826047,
0.6294813752,
0.4360922873,
-0.1434354484,
-0.0610260181,
-0.5517042279,
0.605016768,
0.8593741059,
-0.392755717,
-0.1192610487,
0.3374274969,
0.1958052516,
0.0578020513,
0.7183051705,
-0.0664495453,
0.4291894436,
-0.4980454147,
-0.3535738289,
-0.1217614189,
-0.391901195,
-0.816301465,
0.4358043373,
0.0526530445,
0.0368280895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16757v1 | How can Deep Learning Retrieve the Write-Missing Additional Diagnosis from Chinese Electronic Medical Record For DRG | 2023-03-28T08:56:31 | 2023-03-28T08:56:31 | Shaohui Liu, Xien Liu, Ji Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The purpose of write-missing diagnosis detection is to find diseases that
have been clearly diagnosed from medical records but are missed in the
discharge diagnosis. Unlike the definition of missed diagnosis, the
write-missing diagnosis is clearly manifested in the medical record without
further reasoning. The write-missing diagnosis is a common problem, often
caused by physician negligence. The write-missing diagnosis will result in an
incomplete diagnosis of medical records. While under DRG grouping, the
write-missing diagnoses will miss important additional diagnoses (CC, MCC),
thus affecting the correct rate of DRG enrollment.
Under the circumstance that countries generally start to adopt DRG enrollment
and payment, the problem of write-missing diagnosis is a common and serious
problem. The current manual-based method is expensive due to the complex
content of the full medical record. We think this problem is suitable to be
solved as natural language processing. But to the best of our knowledge, no
researchers have conducted research on this problem based on natural language
processing methods.
We propose a framework for solving the problem of write-missing diagnosis,
which mainly includes three modules: disease recall module, disease context
logic judgment module, and disease relationship comparison module. Through this
framework, we verify that the problem of write-missing diagnosis can be solved
well, and the results are interpretable. At the same time, we propose advanced
solutions for the disease context logic judgment module and disease
relationship comparison module, which have obvious advantages compared with the
mainstream methods of the same type of problems. Finally, we verified the value
of our proposed framework under DRG medical insurance payment in a tertiary
hospital. | [
-0.0647182018,
-0.6673462391,
0.5948682427,
-0.3182297647,
-0.1237067655,
-0.2460186481,
-0.1724232584,
-0.7684784532,
0.0509783886,
0.5106816888,
-0.8892967105,
-0.7326779366,
-0.5536364317,
0.1374124885,
-0.023140993,
1.0349326134,
-0.0759460106,
0.0357628241,
-0.0433177352,
-0.0943077803,
-0.6033861637,
-0.3991000652,
-1.1647077799,
-0.4977557361,
0.4577126801,
0.4977363944,
0.5023975968,
0.9422119856,
0.7856191397,
0.122853227,
0.0002525557,
0.5306100249,
-0.0006283301,
-0.1238536537,
0.2795069814,
-0.4472500086,
-0.8652722836,
-0.1121784523,
0.7015327215,
0.8026567698,
-0.1698438525,
-0.3161216676,
0.0066191042,
1.1281946898,
-0.2089502662,
-0.0077242809,
-0.2467639893,
0.975440383,
0.002442721,
-0.338339448,
-0.4337083697,
-0.1293787807,
0.1354110092,
-0.4994939566,
0.7987862229,
-0.4325254261,
0.8893743753,
0.4252702892,
-0.493103385,
-0.5337979198,
-0.8851344585,
0.2454438657,
-0.9536143541,
0.0269903149,
0.3891143501,
0.3398246467,
-0.3474293947,
-0.7680417299,
-0.7488127947,
-0.4754754305,
-0.3444624841,
0.3650262356,
0.2993260622,
0.2950402796,
0.2879114449,
0.7725276351,
-0.8486266136,
0.2932070494,
-0.1061471477,
-0.2221943438,
0.8913046718,
0.4853349328,
0.5937719941,
-0.0679198876,
-0.4118117094,
-0.0874119326,
-0.6633495092,
0.0285939891,
-0.0427310131,
0.2561791837,
-0.1180201843,
0.0653112978,
-0.1181098819,
0.7757861018,
0.0351246372,
-0.1629328281,
0.5288810134,
-0.2594334185,
-0.3750797212,
0.4485807121,
0.7185254693,
0.0902349278,
-0.0408521704,
0.0694280341,
-0.3155668676,
-0.2052859962,
-0.0546393432,
-0.4598791301,
-0.607278645,
0.2533033192,
-0.8829836249,
-0.0318944044,
-0.2715810537,
-0.4602029622,
-0.8444725275,
-0.4889296293,
0.2165980935,
-0.4378049076,
-0.5527291894,
0.1783098578,
0.0516484194,
-0.0470017791,
0.2794287205,
-0.8289526105,
0.2130304724,
0.5543946624,
0.6251739264,
-0.0639827922,
-0.1185404807,
-0.4815935791,
0.0350635126,
-0.4483864903,
0.7388999462,
-0.2295452803,
-0.1631325483,
0.0082375752,
0.0087538678,
-0.4869965613,
-0.7575466633,
0.6414618492,
-0.1083050221,
0.3531635404,
-0.224238351,
-0.7749122381,
-0.3597777188,
0.2893612385,
-0.7694289088,
0.7153231502,
0.1238795593,
-0.5886533856,
0.8356225491,
-0.2786793709,
-0.5607728362,
0.3700191975,
-0.3309081495,
-0.7516370416,
-0.1321193427,
0.3477222621,
0.7979787588,
-0.1517636776,
0.6880409122,
-0.084644407,
-0.4866737723,
-0.1443000138,
-0.539398849,
0.9346624017,
0.0805348903,
-0.3036525249,
0.0205144957,
-1.1319608688,
-0.0367910154,
0.1832986176,
-0.5668522716,
-0.2215976119,
0.2462597042,
-0.2666506171,
0.1229426861,
-0.0434687436,
-0.3831016719,
0.614723444,
-0.5685904622,
0.0429590866,
0.4064648449,
0.1304840595,
0.1469780654,
-0.2395412922,
0.28266716,
0.3519201279,
0.1392067373,
-0.2961735725,
-0.4918107092,
-0.8253288269,
-0.4298331738,
0.1018294618,
0.6093242168,
-0.4281072319,
0.3622273207,
0.0226739664,
-0.2602706552,
-0.7865352035,
-0.0511043482,
0.2615751624,
0.9842382669,
0.5105871558,
0.0845887065,
-0.6133769751,
-0.8475785255,
-0.3280013502,
-0.059116032,
0.1720550805,
0.3893547356,
0.3655174077,
-0.5577220321,
0.4428719878,
-0.6810068488,
-0.956152916,
-0.2448373735,
0.1268374473,
0.551884532,
0.54387182,
0.536323607,
-0.6467449069,
-0.4770060778,
0.2926265001,
-1.1517425776,
0.2601875663,
-0.5198145509,
0.3631268442,
0.334364742,
0.3452772796,
-0.363943994,
0.6935560107,
0.1969417483,
-0.3705021441,
0.4278788567,
-0.7766905427,
0.1220817342,
-0.9225808978,
-0.0059728734,
-0.0315456018,
-0.1826256365,
-0.6010005474,
0.0171552524,
0.2487054765,
-0.0739967376,
0.1871252358,
0.1841835082,
-0.4965722859,
0.2954848707,
-0.4365153313,
0.1021637321,
0.196134761,
0.268144697,
0.2458481789,
0.2186052203,
0.6391785741,
-1.0989211798,
0.5098215342,
0.0734787583,
0.0564085692,
0.297441572,
-0.3174273074,
0.1343847066,
-0.4340015352,
0.1818636656,
-0.8517060876,
-0.0937273875,
0.5580160618,
-0.5502827764,
0.7597236633,
-0.1427280158,
-0.4659977257,
-0.687810123,
-0.1119473428,
0.1967091262,
0.2425825596,
-0.6547722816,
0.6484180689,
0.2137279212,
0.1114627421,
-0.745775938,
-1.0296424627,
0.232474789,
0.1395977885,
-0.5430610776,
0.3875415027,
0.1671264768,
0.21067442,
0.2984388471,
0.0598264597,
-0.2898971438,
0.2597694695,
-0.1673240066,
0.2424067259,
-0.6426093578,
0.552990973,
0.2577300668,
-0.3767509758,
0.0375539511,
-0.2646725178,
0.1277750283,
0.1068119854,
-0.4658162594,
-0.6152168512,
0.5541117787,
0.0680854097,
-0.122629486,
0.5081302524,
0.6827430129,
-0.9995045662,
-0.5204073191,
-0.3838863075,
-0.0463892557,
-0.4164110422,
0.3882744312,
-0.1341561377,
-0.567856431,
0.6848080158,
0.1349051595,
0.0197169613,
0.8756267428,
0.3559778035,
0.1132809743,
0.9683816433,
0.7351263165,
-0.0106020467,
-0.0548003316,
-0.1655858457,
0.4737642705,
-0.6898955703,
-0.5342286229,
-0.1889347285,
-0.1646371186,
-0.5175104737,
0.0981166139,
0.4767733514,
0.1254584938,
-0.0715354159,
0.1892654151,
-0.9873537421,
0.0574158914,
0.4887098968,
0.4092036784,
0.6795863509,
-0.2392176837,
-0.3606037199,
-0.1151659191,
-0.7998182774,
-0.1238705814,
0.8017879725,
0.1621654928,
0.4116251469,
-0.1305749565,
0.9618026018,
0.5959821939,
0.356338203,
-0.880217433,
0.2332934141,
-0.3652099967,
-0.303121388,
-0.0606940202,
-0.5087396502,
-0.9924117327,
0.2562434971,
-0.0229984354,
-0.4549477696,
0.3358648419,
0.5320549011,
-0.5362671018,
0.37414065,
-0.7186273336,
0.9912973642,
-0.2582275867,
0.1656911373,
-0.3407672048,
-0.6350464821,
0.6339541674,
0.2305807024,
-0.0273405798,
0.0303125195,
0.2836872637,
0.8994382024,
-0.4297594726,
0.8045045733,
-0.3769854009,
-0.1492908299,
0.2809374928,
-0.2185681313,
0.2488409728,
0.3358135819,
0.0020122472,
-0.171704039,
-0.1464845836,
-0.0095831081,
-0.3912594616,
0.6571522355,
-0.53871876,
-0.4554489255,
-0.7406303287,
-0.2911060452,
-0.1478106678,
0.442538321,
0.1955366582,
0.503282845,
-0.0157006178,
-0.4144156575,
0.9872552752,
-0.5463603735,
0.7611494064,
0.8040565252,
0.2124627829,
-0.0957300588,
0.8946766853,
0.2202721983,
-0.1481591016,
0.4609128833,
0.5195475817,
0.1080562696,
-0.6279335022,
-0.8419474959,
0.3099294603,
-0.8130418062,
-0.3827617466,
-0.9472156763,
-0.5268867612,
-0.4948065579,
0.0883949175,
-0.2663740814,
0.0315462798,
-0.6983990073,
-0.2365618646,
0.3835397065,
0.7564992905,
-0.2398739457,
-0.0585156046,
-1.1158479452,
0.6341379881,
-0.1961917728,
0.4781348705,
0.5321427584,
-0.4572053552,
-0.2719884515,
0.0960430279,
-0.0583454594,
-0.657548666,
0.3703461587,
0.3225216866,
0.6577082872,
0.7311553359,
0.0095360614,
0.9619375467,
-0.513828516,
0.457141161,
0.1659498215,
-0.6599143147,
0.7273085713,
-0.1151708513,
0.0088802818,
0.5299153328,
0.2275158614,
-0.9743365049,
0.0832844898,
-0.4770253301,
-0.88622123,
0.90997684,
-0.4896711111,
-0.2027685791,
-0.166338712,
0.6121358871,
0.205792591,
-0.1751437932,
-0.6162991524,
-0.7375679612,
0.1328682601,
-0.325257659,
0.0413914062,
-0.3270103633,
0.1215628907,
-0.512663126,
0.4623855054,
0.0131803844,
0.4238819182,
0.8061222434,
-0.0568317696,
-0.1038710773,
-0.0256780945,
0.5409517884,
0.3464983404,
0.0768683925,
-0.1894743592,
-0.2122479677,
-0.6407593489,
-0.1920333654,
0.3057088256,
-0.1444301754,
0.1232570708,
0.6014245749,
0.7719052434,
-0.2240511924,
-0.7442092299,
0.8021924496,
-0.0289473664,
-0.4216707349,
-0.7408258319,
0.0922344401,
0.15775837,
0.0574545935,
0.5215422511,
0.4086436033,
0.5416467786,
-0.5289974809,
0.5003965497,
0.299416393,
-0.6894205809,
-0.020010218,
0.4540584683,
0.0053356704,
-0.3585160077,
1.0633062124,
-0.2917362154,
-0.5750534534,
1.0430606604,
0.6686658859,
0.8701121807,
-0.0753575712,
0.2349402755,
0.3751508594,
0.4116635323,
-0.2515160739,
0.4457033277,
0.1670652777,
-0.5824978948,
-0.5214326978,
-0.0708273053,
-0.0688077807,
0.4112497568,
-0.6289616227,
0.3575209975,
-0.5020837784,
0.1353420019,
-0.2299075723,
0.1248292401,
-0.7653955221,
0.6808245778,
0.4517862797,
0.5026839375,
-0.689455092,
0.4643576741,
0.378967911,
-0.3807516694,
-1.1145153046,
-0.0502523482,
0.0083404193,
-0.9243290424,
0.411676228,
0.4550356269,
0.0501880646,
-0.2334944904,
-0.108475104,
-0.6478500962,
0.8529086113,
0.1522149593,
-0.5853258967,
0.0480289459,
-0.091333136,
0.7406164408,
-0.2640408576,
0.0714350045,
0.4961905181,
0.416838944,
-0.030230986,
-0.906915009,
0.4614947438,
-0.1956715882,
-0.5775019526,
0.3810923994,
-0.43251127,
0.9009680152,
-0.6153532863,
-0.2851409316,
-0.2309155762,
0.3509372473,
-0.2237898558,
0.7692878246,
-0.1443250328,
0.825545907,
1.3400914669,
0.200737223,
1.2918459177,
0.2563207448,
0.2572847009,
0.8890895844,
-0.3444492221,
0.3907998502,
-0.1252466738,
-0.1615826637,
0.3893812299,
0.6796147227,
-0.1885156631,
0.4627321661,
0.0785997063,
-0.6144785881,
-0.1618381143,
0.1671633571,
-0.7270817161,
0.2715643644,
0.4391674995,
-0.7843732238,
-0.1333087832,
0.2374271303,
0.0415020734,
0.1352418512,
-0.4452876747,
1.1756364107,
0.0966659933,
-0.594314158,
0.7009909749,
0.0173938088,
0.4992416501,
-0.4848794341,
-0.5028914809,
-0.1227477193,
0.6695757508,
-0.6141421795,
-0.3593128026,
0.3193189502,
-0.4566291273,
-0.3810039461,
0.0979873538,
0.8845113516,
-0.4321800768,
-0.5618003607,
0.2843789756,
0.4564122558,
0.0910400227,
0.0061953282,
-0.6920637488,
-0.4971981943,
0.0773041248,
-0.0522328839,
0.2439911067,
0.6485598087,
0.0641679689,
0.6701526046,
0.4476895928,
0.3281918466,
-0.0989736691,
0.3738429844,
0.7248586416,
-0.7220922112,
-0.4681290686,
-1.1331186295,
0.1427176148,
-0.1909445822,
-0.4448360503,
0.2564670444,
0.4702281654,
0.6396807432,
-0.1585801244,
1.0770983696,
0.0324338451,
0.595703125,
-0.506167829,
1.1115590334,
-0.5899320841,
0.1161060408,
-0.1960811764,
-0.1686230302,
-0.8054269552,
0.5145283937,
0.1058160737,
-0.1580992341,
1.0934708118,
0.3672999442,
0.1440585256,
-0.0262261648,
0.2317655236,
-0.0181034282,
0.3928189278,
1.0153399706,
0.2858980298,
-0.5675081611,
0.3387746811,
-0.0941108093,
-0.2541539669,
-0.2606418133,
-0.8138609529,
-1.0488141775,
-0.2503936887,
-0.5020511746,
-0.2876788974,
0.0961764455,
0.6627275944,
0.444398433,
-0.9086291194,
0.3224889338,
-0.2602877617,
0.3643814623,
-0.8313690424,
-0.2639319003,
0.8896405101,
-0.2399736494,
-0.3566301167,
0.2988840044,
0.2805982232,
-0.062975198,
0.2087279707,
0.1805229783,
-0.1134499311,
-0.6915653944,
0.3145055175,
0.2249800861,
-0.4933049977,
0.0188995153,
-0.0856348649,
-0.2916299105,
0.3826457858,
1.0696864128,
-0.9958873391,
0.4191845655,
0.3269851208,
1.0556023121,
0.3369861543,
-0.3825733066,
0.5305258036,
-0.3744523227,
-0.0417281799,
0.6369875073,
0.3425048292,
0.456204623,
-1.0718538761,
0.2289725989,
0.6062644124,
-0.4036753774,
-0.5197991729,
0.1862514317,
-0.8465470076,
-0.3315422535,
0.7697295547,
-0.3439150155,
0.1351265013,
-0.3601002395,
-0.1977328211,
0.5941943526,
-0.1557727605,
0.8198607564,
0.3148331344,
-0.4945134521,
-0.2578420937,
-0.4419565499,
0.7151785493,
0.2839705348,
-0.5622196794,
-0.0567204803,
0.2810848951,
0.2499115616,
-0.2255878597,
0.9541056156,
-0.1710022241,
0.4876075685,
0.0551340282,
-0.1198201627,
-0.4369542003,
-0.0883560479,
-0.3211018741,
-0.0138620809,
-0.1080823019,
-0.3058260083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16779v1 | Language Models Trained on Media Diets Can Predict Public Opinion | 2023-03-28T06:08:25 | 2023-03-28T06:08:25 | Eric Chu, Jacob Andreas, Stephen Ansolabehere, Deb Roy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Public opinion reflects and shapes societal behavior, but the traditional
survey-based tools to measure it are limited. We introduce a novel approach to
probe media diet models -- language models adapted to online news, TV
broadcast, or radio show content -- that can emulate the opinions of
subpopulations that have consumed a set of media. To validate this method, we
use as ground truth the opinions expressed in U.S. nationally representative
surveys on COVID-19 and consumer confidence. Our studies indicate that this
approach is (1) predictive of human judgements found in survey response
distributions and robust to phrasing and channels of media exposure, (2) more
accurate at modeling people who follow media more closely, and (3) aligned with
literature on which types of opinions are affected by media consumption.
Probing language models provides a powerful new method for investigating media
effects, has practical applications in supplementing polls and forecasting
public opinion, and suggests a need for further study of the surprising
fidelity with which neural language models can predict human responses. | [
-0.6702439785,
-0.5917370319,
0.1720123589,
0.1880716681,
-0.0784989819,
0.0560569391,
-0.259301275,
-0.0785335377,
0.4523485899,
0.4341129959,
-0.3640020192,
-0.1229411289,
-0.6709042788,
-0.2588529587,
-0.4354779124,
0.6531766653,
0.4591670036,
0.6814263463,
-0.0823395997,
-0.1087928638,
0.0306541212,
-0.552525878,
-0.3596175015,
-0.3627879024,
0.5560116172,
0.1408191472,
0.9234225154,
0.2755455971,
0.2415541857,
0.1618184,
-0.0077491459,
-0.0756355822,
-0.7344640493,
-0.3726258576,
-0.057917729,
-0.522013545,
-0.1239897162,
0.720087707,
0.1433334202,
0.8714014292,
-0.1878242046,
0.2961363792,
0.0760762393,
0.3248760402,
-0.4348055422,
-0.3916420937,
-0.6744347215,
-0.084764652,
0.2864917219,
-0.3817791939,
-0.5243322849,
-0.5293799639,
0.3992932737,
-0.4689486027,
0.2359231859,
-0.1526795626,
0.93121171,
0.196179986,
-0.8200550079,
-0.3044358194,
-1.021682024,
0.8216384649,
-0.7307591438,
0.785335958,
0.7398795485,
0.1726732701,
-0.0431001447,
-0.4241204858,
-0.584710896,
-0.338503927,
0.0900107548,
0.3223462701,
-0.1659901291,
-0.2624203563,
-0.155832991,
0.2628449798,
-0.4706583023,
-0.4600850344,
-0.4941097796,
0.1256408244,
0.5347605944,
-0.023468785,
0.5664848089,
-0.3154110312,
-0.3860653341,
0.0060070013,
-0.7046781182,
0.0924565792,
0.2806897163,
0.0091483966,
-0.1480712146,
0.5036157966,
-0.1010147631,
0.6428725719,
0.1002534181,
-0.1337206215,
-0.1885588616,
-0.2040559947,
-0.3173437715,
-0.0345348753,
0.5681343079,
0.845015347,
0.2972892821,
0.2054065466,
0.1402526647,
0.440155834,
0.2059098929,
-0.656442523,
-0.3356727362,
0.0940395519,
-0.4828575253,
-0.3773587346,
-0.0037844339,
-0.8904530406,
-0.8665778041,
-0.3304278553,
0.1663857698,
-0.031966269,
-0.5285436511,
0.3390714526,
-0.3851560354,
0.19883582,
0.3569449484,
-0.6816430092,
0.5720196962,
0.6861544847,
0.6886563301,
-0.0022265215,
0.1106722653,
-0.4006712437,
-0.0460704304,
-0.5890337229,
0.910351038,
-0.8687540293,
-0.339887023,
-0.1024645641,
-0.3183005452,
0.1017747447,
-0.4862406552,
0.1681868434,
-0.5618998408,
0.4809426963,
-0.7235962152,
-0.5859616399,
-0.3451797068,
0.5099112988,
-0.7961784601,
0.6725648046,
0.0694824457,
-0.7979184389,
0.5003005862,
-0.2367673963,
-0.2938622832,
-0.3122250736,
-0.1237125397,
-0.090849407,
0.3021236062,
0.530559659,
0.2405219227,
-0.371836096,
0.4591828883,
-0.7612879872,
-0.1638470739,
0.4182562828,
-0.5391790271,
0.8413886428,
0.5300050974,
-0.1652842611,
-0.2525815964,
-0.4485225379,
-0.1857799888,
-0.0544031784,
-0.5822275281,
-0.6722092032,
0.332079947,
0.2381175458,
0.0860589445,
-0.1875338107,
-0.7100459933,
0.1091218218,
-0.4307817817,
0.6868693233,
0.3930464685,
0.1724107862,
0.5380533934,
-0.385175854,
0.5542274117,
-0.1517127156,
0.2958883345,
0.0738035589,
-0.367375344,
-0.5676720142,
0.0079067927,
0.1176455617,
0.3419009447,
-0.1566899419,
-0.0788626745,
-0.3345134258,
-0.818174839,
-0.3629399538,
-0.1867057234,
0.0382306986,
0.4608060718,
0.0705365688,
-0.2878577411,
-0.6512898207,
-0.6286530495,
-0.695592165,
-0.1830762029,
0.001198545,
0.4522906542,
0.3124150932,
0.150308162,
0.8828551769,
-0.4388324618,
0.2621721327,
-0.3635866344,
0.5401892662,
0.0801433325,
0.0027567651,
0.4910939634,
-1.0705524683,
-0.2978370786,
-0.120802395,
-0.5062496662,
0.0272654593,
-0.0754894763,
0.4343081415,
-0.2794286311,
0.3193568587,
-0.2848167717,
0.2966501117,
0.9531654119,
-0.437520206,
0.1900030673,
0.2918587923,
0.2719738781,
-1.0792298317,
-0.1867533326,
0.5304659605,
-0.1289715767,
-0.6686646938,
-0.0914414153,
-0.2219211459,
-0.2983888686,
-0.6223912835,
0.7289565802,
-0.4177273214,
-0.2543652952,
-0.3232713938,
-0.2018313557,
0.4210895598,
-0.0695372075,
0.3232716918,
0.7701933384,
0.2864753604,
-0.6099066734,
0.2800258994,
0.0928664878,
-0.8759928942,
0.4183316231,
-0.6368255019,
0.0012453811,
-0.5085502267,
0.4982560277,
-1.2884505987,
-0.3549416065,
-0.0010453182,
-0.8445541263,
-0.2748833299,
0.0650209486,
0.0406116359,
-0.2251687944,
-0.0673461184,
0.0505244955,
0.3072215319,
-0.4471462667,
0.7406942844,
0.8348530531,
-0.2228997797,
-0.3340374827,
-0.6974274516,
0.1764014065,
-0.3309662938,
-0.4897645712,
-0.0597444437,
-0.1244689077,
-0.7370727658,
-0.1375121176,
-0.0902461559,
-0.3194387555,
0.1637499183,
0.0251515172,
-0.0264692828,
-0.2998991907,
0.0551838018,
-0.3474114537,
0.3848938942,
0.1368601918,
0.1284706891,
0.6309199929,
-0.1872700155,
-0.1729022861,
-0.2529655695,
0.4496266544,
0.7421776056,
-0.3962651193,
0.0618083701,
0.3010219336,
-0.4839363694,
0.0077058794,
-0.5764122605,
-0.5954592824,
-0.4306417406,
0.4646636248,
-0.0766887888,
-0.4680209756,
0.1135896966,
-0.1127374843,
-0.2414186001,
-0.1097345278,
0.6828234196,
-0.1722483039,
1.3453947306,
0.4384474158,
-0.2768522799,
0.4730679691,
-0.2065140605,
0.0482502244,
-0.5089509487,
0.0424570478,
-0.566331625,
-0.3461206853,
-0.236692816,
-0.2381696105,
0.4597344995,
-0.3080058396,
-0.20047912,
-0.0133033311,
-0.0761001557,
0.5803938508,
0.4694094956,
0.0935078263,
0.2083834857,
0.0916862264,
-0.0611371174,
-0.1066334695,
-0.479706347,
-0.5324773788,
0.7329261899,
0.4353977442,
1.0886868238,
-0.0815258026,
0.3556348085,
0.3689050674,
0.8034924865,
-0.9118505716,
0.3911194801,
-0.1472551078,
-1.1152251959,
-0.2541669011,
-0.1787233502,
-0.6345431805,
0.3433792591,
-0.1423277408,
-0.5616089702,
0.4312914312,
0.119453311,
-0.4526435435,
0.2309264392,
-0.8314199448,
0.5734242201,
-0.3924058676,
-0.2510332167,
-0.4392789602,
-0.3587017059,
0.3786467016,
0.248799935,
0.4733387232,
-0.3045670092,
0.1397679746,
0.8312911391,
-0.2409126461,
1.0916090012,
-0.0890551433,
0.072628662,
0.3185352981,
0.1407800615,
0.237819165,
0.1708947718,
-0.2686133683,
-0.2043887675,
0.0771338418,
-0.2305531353,
-0.7064548135,
0.5922877192,
-0.9932508469,
-0.6114258766,
-0.4620561004,
-0.4392675161,
-0.4936575592,
0.1870362014,
0.2390414476,
0.5622763634,
-0.5323406458,
0.2149147838,
0.6199487448,
-0.1549010277,
0.1468829066,
0.6203460097,
-0.3538386822,
-0.623667419,
0.7154271007,
0.1251462996,
0.2855364382,
0.4352192581,
0.8265755177,
-0.3271044195,
-0.0905697495,
-0.1685144603,
0.1083741933,
-0.6749964952,
0.2000780702,
-0.5168201923,
0.2572614849,
-0.3684262335,
-0.0442342348,
-0.4760506153,
-0.1166763902,
-0.1982861012,
-0.2417506725,
0.0570933782,
0.9423645139,
-0.050325565,
0.435448736,
-0.7661358714,
0.3204990029,
0.605373919,
0.2614941299,
-0.1127745062,
-0.3629429936,
-0.0144037884,
0.3991921544,
-0.2969838381,
-1.2982137203,
0.7052791119,
0.2860686481,
0.4041448236,
0.5013768673,
-0.0026156139,
0.5552425981,
-0.265768528,
0.8389161229,
0.099977918,
-0.7724724412,
0.2276290506,
-0.7559522986,
0.1593535691,
0.4995466769,
0.9123983383,
-1.0158033371,
-0.360771209,
-0.4287360907,
-0.082085453,
0.0484021269,
-0.394046396,
0.5136011839,
-0.3553518951,
-0.1688379645,
0.1816103756,
0.1936087757,
-0.5828648806,
0.1359553039,
-0.6330619454,
0.0547795668,
-0.2209484875,
-0.148387894,
-0.1113453358,
-0.4999665618,
0.4170341194,
0.142674461,
0.1631184667,
0.2198179066,
0.1529111713,
-0.426352948,
0.2574278712,
0.6620416641,
0.9510838389,
-0.5441698432,
0.4917041063,
-0.1733170599,
-0.5466969013,
0.2164193392,
-0.4080955088,
-0.3867136538,
0.2630231082,
-0.0378509238,
0.5101909041,
0.2272464782,
-0.4981465638,
0.676150918,
-0.3507983088,
-0.14567554,
-0.4150948226,
-0.4347789884,
0.5456591249,
0.0097955763,
0.2977340817,
0.2447922081,
0.119489342,
-0.8973544836,
0.3007759154,
0.5952429771,
-0.6552074552,
-0.4997493923,
0.8238132,
0.3892962933,
-0.1940407008,
0.3979820907,
0.0504298322,
-0.3542024195,
0.613860786,
0.6439117193,
0.6123491526,
-0.494279623,
0.5148057342,
0.3187566996,
0.2694823742,
-0.3879375458,
0.447596103,
0.5768523216,
-1.0249882936,
-0.5025858283,
-0.6331471205,
-0.353923142,
0.5609820485,
-0.766190052,
0.3067235053,
-0.5675358176,
-0.3882616162,
0.3054637313,
-0.1446506083,
-0.6489080191,
0.7503967285,
0.5263141394,
1.0808686018,
-1.2407443523,
0.8664374352,
0.7426363826,
-0.3896813989,
-0.9710288048,
0.3332569599,
0.1859618425,
-0.8490040302,
0.5104159713,
0.1077459753,
-0.0405863971,
-0.0110473298,
-0.7313411236,
-1.2266449928,
0.4237161577,
0.3612679839,
-0.3863604367,
-0.0285950005,
0.0334557332,
0.4096271992,
-0.4333591163,
0.3226110935,
0.4884797931,
0.5103895068,
0.0632511526,
-0.6090299487,
-0.239003256,
-0.262957871,
-0.171283856,
-0.0090203751,
-0.6041943431,
0.8477246165,
-0.1831503659,
-0.1929645836,
-0.1423100829,
0.8474998474,
-0.0156897139,
0.5295286775,
0.6755055785,
0.3481191099,
0.6527721882,
0.2314235717,
1.2637522221,
-0.3978213966,
0.3492082953,
1.0025980473,
-0.2371314764,
0.9757808447,
0.4891001582,
-0.1409599036,
0.4292981029,
0.7862576246,
0.0655467063,
0.7381576896,
0.3122089207,
-0.080318287,
-0.4887882471,
-0.5135279894,
-0.1572714001,
0.8269882798,
0.539078176,
-0.3007608652,
-0.249376446,
0.1286803782,
0.3160604239,
0.3787963986,
-0.2703988254,
0.4467895925,
0.1590114385,
-0.9507896304,
0.7411817908,
-0.0009428565,
0.4488618374,
-0.2737081945,
0.0577826537,
-0.3350084424,
-0.1189755276,
0.0018813313,
-0.4371733069,
0.4025528431,
-0.2851181328,
-0.0388950855,
-0.0324635133,
0.6690330505,
-0.3007521927,
-0.6009886265,
-0.0079656392,
0.739395678,
0.105556339,
-0.1861001253,
-0.4422792196,
0.0914463103,
-0.1378726214,
-0.676366806,
0.1900820285,
-0.2258639038,
0.0258860718,
0.500328362,
0.344125092,
0.2287611216,
0.260697186,
0.141751036,
0.5641279817,
-0.5147403479,
-0.5626532435,
-0.6965087652,
0.1300332248,
0.0009097799,
-0.3562716246,
0.6320155263,
0.5479918122,
0.8866952062,
-0.2788483799,
1.3393861055,
0.1649182439,
0.6251322627,
-0.1786532551,
0.8314876556,
-0.629724443,
-0.1840010732,
0.0002657371,
-0.6620625854,
-0.083685644,
0.5851653218,
-0.8790209293,
-0.0880665854,
0.6397681832,
1.058280468,
-0.1133681685,
0.4723692536,
0.1786567867,
0.283387959,
0.2474073619,
0.2310902923,
1.0875349045,
-0.0641153455,
0.4642075896,
-0.1519813538,
-0.1908318698,
-0.1788876057,
-0.8281393647,
-0.8674725294,
-0.5135595798,
-0.0278600771,
-0.3872082829,
0.0295091495,
1.0206614733,
0.8678843975,
-0.5640400648,
-0.4174199402,
0.0018921534,
-0.181426242,
-0.4285314977,
-0.1852259338,
0.0993407965,
0.2562428415,
-0.8290522099,
0.4814208448,
-0.0548835695,
-0.1067415476,
-0.6763455272,
0.0412295572,
-0.2464657277,
0.6549152136,
0.4119216502,
0.3515058458,
-0.9303480387,
-0.2780436277,
0.3273004293,
-0.2481844127,
0.1684599519,
1.1047743559,
-0.6421805024,
0.4436214566,
0.7614474893,
0.4232547283,
0.2918992043,
0.3189171255,
0.8525514007,
-0.6683824062,
-0.0971824974,
0.379054755,
0.3258031905,
0.6189329624,
-0.3413604796,
0.0953551754,
0.2087390423,
-0.3928580284,
-0.6512520313,
0.5141866803,
-0.8637238145,
-0.3770460486,
1.3979611397,
0.1689791381,
-0.489731729,
-0.0577508472,
-0.0542396754,
0.120775491,
-0.4560705423,
1.0833160877,
0.6275988221,
0.3151308894,
-0.3510357738,
-0.6602907777,
0.3660033643,
0.4078011513,
-0.6559073925,
-0.0233741626,
0.4156058729,
0.6656624079,
0.0301802121,
0.8090387583,
0.1475868523,
0.2572210133,
-0.1124235466,
-0.2456315458,
0.1131395474,
-0.369892031,
-0.1080158055,
0.114482224,
-0.0044427249,
0.1816578954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15727v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15727v1 | Evaluation of ChatGPT for NLP-based Mental Health Applications | 2023-03-28T04:47:43 | 2023-03-28T04:47:43 | Bishal Lamichhane | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLM) have been successful in several natural language
understanding tasks and could be relevant for natural language processing
(NLP)-based mental health application research. In this work, we report the
performance of LLM-based ChatGPT (with gpt-3.5-turbo backend) in three
text-based mental health classification tasks: stress detection (2-class
classification), depression detection (2-class classification), and suicidality
detection (5-class classification). We obtained annotated social media posts
for the three classification tasks from public datasets. Then ChatGPT API
classified the social media posts with an input prompt for classification. We
obtained F1 scores of 0.73, 0.86, and 0.37 for stress detection, depression
detection, and suicidality detection, respectively. A baseline model that
always predicted the dominant class resulted in F1 scores of 0.35, 0.60, and
0.19. The zero-shot classification accuracy obtained with ChatGPT indicates a
potential use of language models for mental health classification tasks. | [
-0.3222219646,
-0.9867475033,
0.7406816483,
0.7011339664,
-0.228000924,
-0.0472160578,
-0.5584846139,
-0.6461548805,
0.0181390159,
0.0107277213,
-0.4475500584,
-0.9212546945,
-0.8990069032,
0.1962556839,
-0.3772669137,
1.2821424007,
0.0781777948,
0.0881982744,
0.128686592,
0.3266358972,
-0.585190177,
-0.7517837286,
-1.2230358124,
-0.3550612926,
0.5451641083,
0.2366299182,
0.7331456542,
-0.1902251095,
0.8364287019,
0.1142611131,
-0.2726258337,
-0.0458426028,
-0.4872928858,
0.0311712977,
-0.1953166276,
-0.115283981,
-0.6305884123,
-0.0010360834,
0.293564111,
0.1062666327,
-0.3582326472,
0.2551964521,
0.2641470432,
0.3497896791,
-0.3556433022,
0.5367456079,
-0.554577291,
0.1766276509,
0.0082043596,
-0.1661833823,
-0.3703908622,
-0.2855574489,
0.0744742304,
-0.2985884249,
0.1124999598,
-0.0361102149,
0.5626936555,
0.4052833021,
-0.2872631252,
-0.325560838,
-0.61882025,
0.5065211654,
-0.929841876,
0.2249083221,
0.5268279314,
0.3764889538,
-0.0782814696,
-0.4259535968,
-0.4984578192,
0.0225963742,
0.0497947671,
0.3962109089,
-0.4058763087,
0.2935111225,
0.3563215137,
0.4787892997,
-0.9326187372,
0.2624498308,
-0.1114429384,
-0.0792533085,
0.7161377072,
0.2490319014,
0.4031913877,
-0.3889322281,
-0.0454319529,
0.1291876882,
-0.0668719858,
-0.1960406452,
-0.2364921421,
0.446526885,
-0.3258910477,
0.7459797859,
-0.1722328514,
0.4305146337,
-0.2881721258,
-0.428780973,
0.1553860158,
0.0491055287,
-0.3190214634,
-0.0507825464,
1.0503656864,
0.8388813138,
0.2126561254,
-0.1856777072,
-0.0958445817,
0.1402335167,
0.2875839472,
-0.8303410411,
-0.1800985485,
0.194970727,
-0.5414719582,
-0.2145631611,
-0.5963292122,
-0.6971255541,
-0.6310557723,
-0.0817019045,
0.3739737272,
-0.7675312161,
-0.3086526096,
0.4773155153,
0.0853711143,
0.2195071429,
0.5223037601,
-0.7862176299,
0.5308677554,
0.980574429,
1.3168672323,
-0.4524200559,
0.0415938534,
-0.1140046045,
-0.2597098649,
0.1423757374,
0.897459209,
-0.2199025154,
-0.2424548417,
0.027707193,
-0.1018348262,
-0.3923558295,
-0.1652224809,
1.1414189339,
-0.2314992696,
0.1704441607,
-0.057972841,
-0.7609891891,
-0.2647897005,
0.4502342939,
-0.3370869458,
1.0228763819,
-0.071938321,
-1.1444289684,
0.1348305792,
-0.7014063001,
-0.4220513701,
0.4041797519,
0.1726249754,
-0.3021544814,
-0.0175709296,
0.2871432006,
0.924207449,
-0.3878827393,
0.2704066038,
-0.5167249441,
-0.7002300024,
0.1761377454,
-0.6734505892,
0.4775102139,
0.1263485849,
-0.2104019523,
-0.0476690978,
-0.5236762762,
0.0889149979,
0.0320753269,
-0.2453418225,
-0.154488191,
0.1518488675,
0.5318546891,
0.4304047823,
-0.024301948,
-0.572398901,
0.0645475462,
-0.251634568,
0.2893492579,
0.3123674989,
0.1954412758,
-0.3098853827,
-0.2838811576,
0.5277184844,
-0.3757281601,
0.2074663937,
0.2952024639,
-1.0655189753,
-0.2802470624,
-0.6040249467,
0.0348786078,
1.0451036692,
-0.4899109006,
0.7650410533,
-0.3099234104,
-0.6906328201,
-0.2825490534,
-0.2769692838,
0.0921265036,
0.4451740384,
0.4909088016,
-0.0842725039,
-0.2561784685,
-0.778922677,
-0.3129444718,
-0.3697395623,
-0.2872263491,
0.2676754594,
0.5139830112,
-0.6949540973,
0.6005290151,
-0.7409187555,
-0.3074652553,
-0.2534671724,
0.4207892716,
0.2437565923,
0.0793629289,
0.2906374335,
-0.3166701496,
-0.4618460834,
-0.0003896283,
-0.5975400805,
-0.3502991796,
0.2626462579,
0.1000795513,
-0.0179134756,
-0.0785104781,
-0.8077449799,
0.4100483954,
0.5922427177,
-0.1996062398,
0.6205556989,
0.1094626188,
0.0069221496,
-1.1109554768,
0.0143845864,
0.3594559729,
-0.4329848886,
-0.6908712983,
-0.5326179266,
-0.1645009369,
-0.4562328458,
-0.2872597873,
0.3395982385,
0.2302570194,
0.1334235668,
-0.3833690286,
0.0885359719,
-0.2830216885,
0.4305083156,
0.2053959966,
0.5051981807,
0.4713122845,
-0.1436754018,
0.4187937677,
0.0598646626,
-0.2312527746,
0.5623185635,
-0.5969746709,
0.1678406894,
-0.0317087136,
0.3134665191,
-0.9779051542,
-0.3085988462,
0.3131204247,
-0.3687736988,
0.0068346667,
0.050701119,
-0.7546801567,
-0.4672225416,
-0.1703571826,
0.0527531467,
0.3032942116,
-0.1209857389,
0.1147249192,
0.3537801802,
-0.265933007,
-0.1267689317,
-0.6133052707,
0.0001358038,
-0.3813995421,
-0.3966231346,
0.2372470349,
0.0566876717,
-0.0322821923,
0.0202033464,
-0.0082170945,
-0.1365357786,
0.0490215644,
0.4551954567,
0.2077694386,
-0.1045673043,
0.6060634851,
-0.1645894945,
-0.0217420962,
0.0425839275,
0.1207752824,
0.6157235503,
-0.4135711193,
-0.3620094955,
-0.5424292684,
0.4463265538,
0.4606361985,
-0.0112706637,
0.8403867483,
0.9172130823,
-0.6288106441,
-0.1084238812,
-0.6069867611,
0.1288916171,
-0.3443440199,
0.4063628018,
0.0250635911,
-1.133079052,
0.4424735904,
0.1791884303,
-0.0888196081,
0.3791467845,
0.7361580133,
-0.0939749032,
1.1006850004,
0.3283234239,
-0.4110987186,
0.3561713398,
0.0688326731,
0.4545073807,
-0.5136604905,
0.2518410683,
-0.3375571072,
0.0295092706,
-0.6919246912,
-0.4502299726,
0.3883139193,
0.0689073652,
-0.3323682845,
0.1723338813,
-0.6230000257,
0.132261619,
0.0571519136,
0.4230212569,
0.4711924493,
-0.0113466792,
0.3682217002,
-0.2277201563,
-0.4430578947,
-0.6851338148,
0.9039060473,
0.7029960155,
0.7253316641,
0.0394234844,
0.5491464138,
0.4059581459,
0.8051384687,
-1.1552438736,
0.4779050946,
-0.2920849621,
-0.5157103539,
-0.2522414029,
-0.4756713212,
-0.6267875433,
0.1695545763,
-0.2023245543,
-1.1395645142,
-0.3683482111,
-0.1063400134,
-0.5968362093,
0.1405180246,
-0.8520858884,
0.9787091017,
-0.3245057762,
0.0727419183,
-0.3043066859,
-0.2486133873,
0.6156631708,
-0.2504216731,
0.1822786331,
-0.6740337014,
0.1936341673,
0.7929685116,
-0.03344585,
0.6479614973,
-0.0184507612,
-0.0805661604,
0.0452490039,
-0.2738639712,
0.1504505277,
0.4305897951,
-0.1724816561,
0.1598559618,
0.359749496,
0.0015786921,
-0.8455023766,
0.4789400697,
-0.6609407067,
-0.4887321591,
-0.4914678335,
-0.4646766186,
-0.538611412,
0.1711116284,
0.1279749125,
0.231933713,
-0.2178242654,
0.1092716008,
0.3940770924,
-0.4602366388,
0.1671108603,
0.6597986817,
-0.4971901178,
-0.3693393171,
0.8184037805,
-0.0595154092,
0.0570791773,
0.2157222182,
0.1665389985,
-0.2238460481,
-0.440081507,
0.0443328843,
0.3738381565,
-0.4716052711,
-0.3524944484,
-0.5896472335,
-0.5632455349,
-0.3913722932,
0.143345356,
-0.3997533023,
-0.139226228,
-0.1369418353,
-0.0859138817,
0.5650306344,
0.6773620844,
0.038674172,
0.4348249435,
-0.748265028,
0.3093382716,
0.1727632284,
0.7350370288,
-0.0760186985,
-0.2428080291,
-0.2421900481,
-0.0067977803,
-0.3759548068,
-1.1571573019,
0.4214871228,
0.1761588901,
0.2940731645,
0.325861156,
-0.002370924,
0.5887329578,
-0.3957077861,
0.5965557098,
0.1998996586,
-0.7510426044,
0.6496328712,
-0.529055059,
0.4103034437,
0.605494976,
0.6393407583,
-1.0981965065,
-0.4609220028,
-0.3946945369,
-0.5929282308,
0.6520085931,
0.6589432359,
-0.1299247295,
-0.2637915015,
0.3930313885,
-0.2135777175,
-0.0504373945,
-0.6589930654,
-0.1046526805,
-0.0525371768,
-0.3571119905,
-0.1721829176,
-0.271079272,
0.124624677,
-0.2447731942,
0.6585146189,
-0.0826599374,
0.7259956598,
0.2807539403,
0.1198145375,
0.1963919997,
0.5015407801,
0.2643578351,
0.2923949361,
-0.6337690353,
0.1084144711,
0.3077044487,
-0.7559974194,
0.0057102959,
0.4822989702,
0.0916637629,
0.0374769643,
0.4683936536,
0.6669930816,
0.1186620817,
-0.7046594024,
0.5425943136,
-0.5379744768,
0.076782614,
-0.1773103178,
0.0915775672,
0.149156183,
0.2988107502,
0.0804342106,
-0.2563030422,
0.4890324771,
-0.3181758821,
0.0749920681,
0.3046436608,
-0.4427090287,
-0.3846929669,
0.2672798932,
-0.1008009911,
-0.3740557432,
0.5383179188,
-0.3604243994,
-0.5857347846,
0.179360494,
0.651181221,
1.0047428608,
-0.2874186635,
0.3885729313,
0.3982934356,
0.282231003,
-0.2563644946,
0.4368146062,
0.0977594256,
-0.9200341105,
-0.5448818207,
-0.7571297288,
-0.5916498303,
0.5235232115,
-0.739161253,
0.274214983,
-0.2836531103,
-0.6822161078,
0.0712624639,
0.0772029534,
-0.6403002739,
0.4082454145,
0.5939582586,
0.7643629909,
-0.8298103809,
0.7023259997,
0.6276169419,
-0.1011113822,
-0.8862547278,
0.3529274762,
0.1687809378,
-0.3048765063,
0.3186865151,
0.5567896366,
-0.0724575296,
-0.0660023913,
-0.3718695045,
-0.7727735639,
0.8785784841,
0.3571541607,
-0.3753214777,
-0.0830541849,
0.3017075658,
1.014670372,
-0.0571960174,
0.5513050556,
0.5062457323,
0.2403195351,
0.0366446041,
-1.341684103,
-0.08421316,
-0.3316642046,
0.1344217062,
-0.164507851,
-0.5031408072,
0.3034794927,
0.3990623951,
-0.422944814,
-0.3709968925,
0.3524833024,
0.4429163635,
0.1699211001,
0.3939164579,
0.6649779081,
0.8174597621,
0.03573763,
0.9741218686,
-0.2601047158,
0.8319216967,
0.9868555069,
-0.3754701912,
1.0586680174,
-0.1114967614,
-0.4225910008,
0.1400983632,
0.7358053327,
0.1377519071,
0.3461961746,
0.1539183408,
-0.4334873557,
0.0127357962,
-0.0732061565,
-0.2659486234,
0.3539922237,
0.6517923474,
-0.1937394291,
-0.3594957292,
0.1475294679,
0.288130939,
-0.4754248857,
-0.2439375073,
0.6304562688,
0.3661728203,
-0.4454217255,
0.5507625937,
0.0880204812,
0.7243151665,
-0.3079653084,
0.0472504757,
0.0639794022,
0.2724344134,
-0.220685035,
-1.0162235498,
0.8018552065,
0.3689330518,
-0.0833677873,
-0.1804650873,
1.1990368366,
-0.0941013768,
-0.729336679,
0.4767667353,
0.3577889204,
0.3071665168,
-0.4994506836,
-0.7413586378,
0.0202607512,
-0.4594808519,
-0.4649121463,
0.162010923,
0.4475788772,
0.0616856441,
0.6474180818,
0.273555994,
0.0827638358,
-0.1510246545,
0.2006838471,
0.5801698565,
-0.6218568683,
-0.3593111932,
-0.9716601372,
0.1373730153,
-0.0823992044,
-0.3201848269,
0.6628704071,
0.48424384,
0.3298439682,
-0.0094576403,
0.7526190877,
-0.0992588922,
0.8305253983,
-0.2814730108,
0.7025465369,
-0.3019357622,
0.0189723205,
-0.4831626117,
-0.6502643824,
-0.7244147658,
0.626388371,
-0.8102129102,
-0.0612623245,
0.79778862,
0.6661112905,
0.1262017936,
0.4091193676,
0.2254824042,
0.070599176,
0.418366164,
0.7084130645,
0.8035438061,
-0.2034452707,
0.2040741742,
-0.2878770828,
-0.2601252496,
-0.0578418896,
-0.6284613609,
-1.0974777937,
-0.27947855,
-0.2503785193,
-0.1008842885,
0.1866467446,
0.9493939877,
0.5946136713,
-0.7624962926,
-0.0202309135,
0.0162302162,
-0.1107795164,
-0.213525489,
-0.3159814775,
0.3514209092,
-0.3332078457,
-0.2863779962,
0.1050487906,
0.4619328082,
-0.2194931954,
-0.0521976277,
0.2144974917,
-0.2295433581,
-0.2662340701,
0.9017677903,
-0.0517748818,
-0.7147576213,
-0.3490346372,
-0.075934656,
-0.3423368931,
0.0882785618,
0.4945658147,
-0.3645448387,
-0.0118520213,
0.4631497562,
0.6820170879,
0.5229941607,
0.2204423547,
0.3789997697,
-0.4925750494,
-0.0738408118,
0.3143206835,
0.2456613183,
0.4213747382,
-0.5721760392,
0.53689152,
0.2201744169,
-0.7763335705,
-0.5990656018,
-0.1100341976,
-1.1001650095,
0.0295009017,
1.2538490295,
-0.202512607,
-0.0435904413,
-0.2494490296,
-0.4584110081,
0.4885233939,
-0.5394442081,
0.8997430801,
0.9640071392,
-0.50457865,
-0.3133604825,
-1.1111592054,
0.4724832773,
0.2694954574,
-1.108088851,
-0.0149854729,
0.2017001063,
0.128932938,
0.0554796457,
0.9436897635,
-0.0555721447,
0.0716334432,
-0.5574295521,
0.2369210422,
0.4381721616,
0.2995921671,
-0.4660817385,
0.1034005433,
-0.0290493742,
0.0321163535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15714v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15714v4 | Explicit Planning Helps Language Models in Logical Reasoning | 2023-03-28T03:55:03 | 2023-11-07T18:12:20 | Hongyu Zhao, Kangrui Wang, Mo Yu, Hongyuan Mei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language models have been shown to perform remarkably well on a wide range of
natural language processing tasks. In this paper, we propose LEAP, a novel
system that uses language models to perform multi-step logical reasoning and
incorporates explicit planning into the inference procedure. Explicit planning
enables the system to make more informed reasoning decisions at each step by
looking ahead into their future effects. Moreover, we propose a training
strategy that safeguards the planning process from being led astray by spurious
features. Our full system significantly outperforms other competing methods on
multiple standard datasets. When using small T5 models as its core selection
and deduction components, our system performs competitively compared to GPT-3
despite having only about 1B parameters (i.e., 175 times smaller than GPT-3).
When using GPT-3.5, it significantly outperforms chain-of-thought prompting on
the challenging PrOntoQA dataset. We have conducted extensive empirical studies
to demonstrate that explicit planning plays a crucial role in the system's
performance. | [
-0.3434748054,
-0.6322774291,
0.8282641172,
0.2834089398,
0.1293437332,
-0.4060906768,
0.0957491696,
-0.4613242745,
-0.3408344984,
0.5327493548,
-0.6675101519,
-0.1784096807,
-0.3090250492,
0.1160654575,
-0.3101664484,
0.6102067232,
-0.0959449783,
-0.2041820139,
0.4058753252,
0.2001238316,
-0.4240951836,
-0.1791628301,
-0.6603497863,
-0.3833494782,
0.3338365853,
0.4369474053,
0.9128391743,
0.6425623894,
0.0340187773,
0.224537164,
-0.1248039454,
0.37178424,
-0.0700396448,
0.1754656732,
-0.3991279304,
-0.3214968741,
-0.5974764228,
-0.247944802,
0.5187158585,
0.5934883952,
-0.0196885616,
-0.2328057289,
-0.3646223247,
0.6765890718,
-0.8330757618,
0.4263443053,
-0.5488780141,
0.2158531696,
0.3000538945,
0.1794898957,
-0.5949512124,
-0.2923604548,
0.1479674727,
-0.7171620131,
0.1715038419,
-0.3018098474,
0.6040381193,
0.2033330202,
-0.4675901532,
0.0276647601,
-1.0498406887,
0.5767548084,
-0.6184569597,
0.7002461553,
0.3449684083,
0.3642074168,
-0.2782278657,
-0.4655723274,
-0.5583455563,
-0.0202794541,
0.0462705828,
-0.1391163319,
-0.0065159756,
0.3151347041,
0.6726844311,
-0.1567885876,
-0.5293274522,
-0.121649459,
-0.3579581976,
-0.0224612746,
0.8110459447,
0.1003350317,
0.0458940305,
0.1177774966,
-0.3055543602,
-0.1326944828,
-0.7522057891,
0.1702417582,
0.0689892992,
0.5930843353,
0.3519347906,
0.6107392907,
-0.6025176048,
0.7403838038,
-0.0797353983,
0.0197938662,
-0.0129852183,
-0.1826929152,
-0.4977832437,
0.108680442,
0.5134519935,
-0.0753677785,
0.7044636607,
0.1945523769,
-0.5050000548,
0.1585199535,
0.0717172772,
-0.6997212768,
-0.3986480534,
0.2502530515,
0.2509037256,
0.1135136858,
-0.3699888289,
-0.4563298821,
-0.2949034274,
-0.3460896015,
0.2891712785,
-0.8352051377,
-0.3742788732,
0.7006257772,
-0.0590171218,
0.1550988257,
0.5950376391,
-1.1361689568,
0.4334520102,
0.808498621,
0.3468599617,
0.3267762363,
-0.4242688417,
-0.6188150644,
0.5012255907,
-0.7132384181,
0.9296247959,
-0.6232563853,
-0.3707261086,
0.0928703621,
-0.3155404031,
-0.2347812951,
-0.2023994625,
0.9443620443,
-0.5145255923,
0.0856054574,
-0.1614648402,
-0.5923215747,
-0.2781097591,
0.406352818,
-0.7397770286,
0.8017686009,
-0.2548622191,
-0.5051678419,
0.9104349017,
-0.7312729359,
-0.4480021596,
-0.0382008813,
-0.4024575055,
-0.0032052763,
-0.2397029847,
0.7532514334,
0.5259674191,
0.1749568284,
0.2856141329,
-0.0131792771,
-0.2091958672,
-0.3164412379,
-0.2588116527,
0.554744184,
0.1183302402,
-0.3604167998,
0.115935944,
-0.5882117748,
0.3622407913,
0.1490918696,
-0.3762617111,
-0.1087512374,
0.3334812522,
-0.6565332413,
0.4932379723,
-0.1235603765,
-0.3068813384,
0.4641678035,
-0.6447820067,
0.0858368054,
0.5336510539,
0.0155096138,
0.723501265,
0.0413498618,
0.4960660934,
-0.0621325448,
0.2695159316,
-0.522839427,
-0.7415988445,
-0.7367002368,
-0.0351792313,
-0.0653870031,
0.7405953407,
-0.5072006583,
0.2274351716,
-0.1917073429,
-0.2015966922,
-0.030578753,
-0.2744640708,
0.3713508844,
0.3530006111,
0.4914530516,
0.1999563277,
-0.3716812432,
-0.78970927,
-0.5340653658,
-0.5026806593,
0.072643593,
-0.1448709667,
0.4586311579,
0.0740139261,
1.0823421478,
-0.6026953459,
0.0482787639,
-0.5918628573,
0.2157114446,
0.2374025583,
0.3344616592,
0.0730633885,
-0.8818063736,
-0.14635849,
0.0002368428,
-0.453144908,
0.0289604608,
-0.4765475094,
-0.2337009609,
0.09668044,
0.1798902154,
-0.9219081402,
0.6038944721,
0.0514734872,
-0.6068403721,
0.6950240135,
-0.210300073,
-0.1705802232,
-0.5213071108,
-0.1738052219,
0.1144469529,
-0.066738829,
-0.8076918125,
-0.0223742239,
0.3030062914,
0.0273787156,
-0.3984954655,
0.7189579606,
-0.3953356445,
0.0081680333,
-0.0473686084,
-0.1152901277,
0.2248751819,
0.3938371241,
0.6847912073,
0.5550330877,
0.3436997533,
-0.7941844463,
-0.1182146147,
0.4555328786,
-0.2495169044,
0.021834109,
-0.2692229152,
0.0049307668,
0.1065603495,
0.3839870095,
-0.5632401109,
-0.1503186077,
0.1840369999,
-0.3999657035,
0.1650916785,
-0.2576386034,
-0.2852499187,
-0.422021389,
0.0463509113,
0.0653105229,
0.2733605802,
-0.2205265611,
0.7344112992,
0.0967587307,
-0.1360801905,
-0.7161539197,
-0.7153004408,
-0.0001110676,
0.0091533288,
-0.669493854,
-0.0126965092,
0.1709574759,
-0.3077336848,
-0.2569598854,
-0.3046601415,
-0.2644179165,
-0.3410846889,
-0.0504054688,
0.1564901769,
-0.2679183483,
0.0929752365,
0.094673112,
-0.2826894224,
0.2026681602,
-0.5009596348,
0.244975239,
-0.0758823901,
-0.5385197997,
-0.2606794536,
0.191812709,
0.2247915119,
-0.3408636749,
0.268579334,
0.055178605,
-0.3677044511,
-0.6106658578,
-0.3405029774,
-0.0880549178,
-0.4372121692,
0.2884173095,
-0.6097565889,
-0.5310387611,
-0.0021297175,
-0.1830497533,
0.5536802411,
0.3620429039,
0.1181812361,
0.3220958114,
1.3503998518,
0.8505769968,
0.3435190618,
0.2356380075,
-0.2831031978,
0.4525434375,
-0.4562696815,
-0.3647806048,
-0.3924829364,
-0.042482283,
-0.2327824086,
-0.8190927505,
0.0783845335,
0.1709774882,
-0.7457621694,
0.2473365515,
-0.3452862799,
0.6829935312,
0.3131663203,
-0.2674680054,
0.4305671453,
-0.0703234747,
-0.5010395646,
-0.0432890654,
-0.7557057142,
-0.6879042983,
0.7455000281,
0.2089391202,
0.6854808927,
-0.1500245184,
0.6360285282,
-0.1424581856,
-0.0817704499,
-0.808893621,
0.9755133986,
0.1848757267,
-0.7931236625,
-0.6552097201,
-0.1826718152,
-0.8391917944,
0.5088453293,
-0.0883046165,
-0.6729409695,
0.4694022834,
0.1106232628,
-0.5112768412,
0.515732646,
-0.8789815903,
0.5084514618,
-0.3894882202,
-0.4211867154,
-0.0702591315,
-0.5475945473,
0.433204174,
0.0473756753,
0.2306023389,
-0.3487858176,
-0.2255516052,
0.5139769912,
-0.1267089099,
0.6140305996,
-0.3817243576,
0.0136853885,
0.2946387827,
0.6158030629,
0.681112051,
-0.1190939397,
-0.1947668642,
-0.2998540401,
-0.3821634054,
-0.3523956239,
-0.6173134446,
0.3860167563,
-0.3891612291,
-0.7295800447,
-0.5814685822,
-0.5634584427,
-0.6762559414,
0.4657053351,
-0.2746803463,
-0.0050498387,
-0.387819618,
-0.4397622049,
0.7170748115,
-0.1311274171,
0.5520268083,
0.5425947309,
-0.4780119359,
-0.1623727977,
0.3278420866,
0.0356005691,
0.4434533715,
0.5025988221,
0.2734436095,
-0.5143046975,
-0.6462025642,
-0.5569033027,
0.1567212045,
-0.8136125803,
0.1143143624,
-0.8716471791,
-0.2952965498,
-0.5738915801,
-0.2672561705,
-0.4261640608,
-0.7244383097,
0.4184891284,
-0.4014744461,
0.0879765004,
0.9456974864,
-0.1371359229,
0.0039958009,
-0.733291924,
0.3359256685,
0.5197862387,
0.0941538438,
-0.2819069326,
-0.1788145751,
-0.0887174159,
-0.0556130446,
-0.2513490617,
-0.7974354625,
0.5139687061,
0.1785118729,
0.7296853065,
0.5653770566,
0.0305623226,
0.7322647572,
-0.7124943137,
0.7908844948,
0.0142082656,
-0.6799761653,
0.9293037057,
-0.5766064525,
0.6536493897,
0.4884287417,
0.5399397016,
-0.3110575676,
-0.1851345152,
-0.86304456,
-0.9002138376,
0.8139284253,
0.2972355187,
-0.2508758008,
0.037045151,
0.0314429104,
-0.0255270805,
0.0515484884,
-0.6378415823,
0.3260633349,
0.0501202084,
0.464445591,
0.0278317183,
-0.0001251311,
-0.1055487543,
-0.5114569664,
0.6780112386,
-0.2723616064,
0.2626288235,
0.1812897027,
0.1226156577,
0.025807742,
0.358399272,
0.3889459968,
0.7716036439,
0.1107346788,
0.0897326767,
0.2497476488,
-0.348225832,
0.1339397281,
0.1995171607,
-0.1541258693,
-0.1098266989,
0.4149438739,
0.6746287346,
0.2058006823,
-0.6641086936,
0.2752317786,
-0.0213357527,
-0.3704051077,
-0.1015356183,
0.4839166105,
0.1174753383,
0.3699136674,
0.0709921718,
0.3004519939,
0.1120606363,
-0.2232567519,
0.1493517905,
-0.1716896892,
-0.1939657331,
-0.2033819705,
0.5929691195,
0.0300636943,
-0.2260790318,
0.6340125799,
-0.1294807792,
-0.4878802896,
0.5716516972,
0.6074192524,
0.9305260181,
-0.4556138813,
0.4270192087,
0.5041972995,
0.521981895,
-0.4749034047,
0.5800821185,
-0.1724043936,
-0.9221617579,
-0.780610919,
-0.5303494334,
-0.4234654605,
-0.0720287487,
0.0173906814,
0.4842520058,
-0.4924292266,
0.191349566,
-0.1786347181,
-0.0532471165,
-0.574295938,
0.658593297,
0.4570371807,
1.3416392803,
-0.9151618481,
0.8082746863,
0.6888446808,
-0.3284003735,
-1.3226211071,
0.0908174962,
0.0479377098,
-0.6868440509,
0.6778801084,
0.1733927578,
-0.4653760493,
-0.3452598751,
-0.3266932368,
-0.8048161864,
0.8037779331,
0.348695606,
-0.4781266153,
-0.3804000914,
0.2553456128,
0.2570340931,
-0.3346461058,
0.2631979287,
0.8291128278,
0.6806178689,
0.5551882386,
-0.8361384869,
-0.0834878311,
-0.1418907344,
-0.2819304466,
0.4402701557,
-0.1879963428,
0.8107442856,
-0.610306263,
-0.2676877081,
-0.2776194811,
0.586535871,
0.6282117963,
0.3129995465,
0.6538287997,
0.6029217839,
0.9250968099,
0.0436795391,
0.8509913087,
0.0705256686,
-0.1623319387,
1.23361063,
-0.4638604522,
1.1191786528,
0.140265733,
-0.1209622547,
0.4781278968,
0.5382835269,
0.5251988769,
0.4115439057,
-0.1682875007,
-0.417468369,
-0.5561692119,
0.4037986398,
-0.1908423603,
0.353818953,
0.7201865911,
-0.1356994957,
-0.4075170159,
-0.3637872338,
0.1648606807,
0.0295880903,
-0.3716873229,
0.5254102349,
0.0012818156,
-1.0396044254,
0.4006744921,
-0.267823875,
0.1940194964,
-0.8172417879,
-0.1344653219,
-0.132278651,
0.2904151678,
-0.2158249766,
-1.1989990473,
0.1872306466,
-0.0122494977,
0.1157671884,
-0.5968567729,
0.9712997079,
-0.1086702123,
-0.3823361695,
0.3244049847,
0.6841449738,
0.0278092716,
-0.2549215853,
-0.7210099697,
-0.4214464426,
0.0487657078,
-0.6318084598,
0.068533048,
0.9419269562,
-0.5622645617,
0.9470039606,
0.6335071921,
0.2543065846,
0.1590477526,
0.0299667362,
0.9337637424,
-0.8957914114,
-0.9375261068,
-0.6834487319,
0.6456439495,
-0.1539057493,
-0.2243152261,
0.4828915596,
0.7161481977,
0.7373095155,
0.1471670866,
0.8146865964,
0.085879527,
0.3063357174,
-0.4452084303,
0.1819007099,
-0.130065456,
0.2618429959,
-0.0967198461,
-0.8824025989,
-0.5101732612,
0.6473103166,
-0.8871766925,
0.036360871,
0.7155643702,
0.6729438305,
-0.1055531278,
0.3831649721,
0.4824858606,
0.0392953455,
0.5972431898,
0.7365797162,
0.9408074021,
0.0198820885,
0.4552778006,
-0.0609087832,
-0.145392552,
0.0539625734,
-0.9318659306,
-0.6096939445,
-0.306194365,
0.0377746709,
0.0690584555,
0.1976994425,
0.7564871907,
0.9444624782,
-0.5255599022,
-0.2269677371,
-0.3858082294,
0.0083374614,
-0.3591530323,
-0.1308792084,
0.0830796212,
-0.4767923057,
-0.4666260779,
0.8890651464,
0.3343987763,
-0.2132405192,
-0.1974905431,
-0.2795462012,
-0.6330192685,
0.3509848416,
0.5627505183,
0.5568643808,
-0.5208405852,
-0.1858093739,
-0.190001905,
0.1380687356,
0.0429728664,
0.9157845974,
-1.1347095966,
0.535192728,
0.698228538,
0.4152816236,
0.6701492667,
-0.114926666,
0.8906035423,
-0.5411429405,
0.2794279456,
0.7571582794,
0.24858509,
-0.0075072995,
-0.2889000773,
0.7024798989,
-0.1823064387,
-0.6845901012,
-0.3381809592,
0.4296382964,
-0.5083168149,
-0.3516642153,
1.2788155079,
-0.0313900337,
-0.1155696288,
-0.2876162231,
-0.340736866,
0.0895349905,
-0.5168114901,
0.3461898267,
0.6294767857,
-0.847594142,
-0.0864277259,
-0.8560628295,
0.7475420833,
0.4591473341,
-0.6959751844,
0.1795705557,
0.7562496662,
-0.0573331155,
0.0868878588,
0.9351281524,
0.0226899069,
0.27793172,
0.2394609004,
-0.071104832,
-0.0458989777,
-0.7459493876,
-0.2308441699,
0.1678973287,
0.1701264083,
0.0089227473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15708v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15708v2 | Bias or Diversity? Unraveling Fine-Grained Thematic Discrepancy in U.S. News Headlines | 2023-03-28T03:31:37 | 2023-05-06T03:57:30 | Jinsheng Pan, Weihong Qi, Zichen Wang, Hanjia Lyu, Jiebo Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL | There is a broad consensus that news media outlets incorporate ideological
biases in their news articles. However, prior studies on measuring the
discrepancies among media outlets and further dissecting the origins of
thematic differences suffer from small sample sizes and limited scope and
granularity. In this study, we use a large dataset of 1.8 million news
headlines from major U.S. media outlets spanning from 2014 to 2022 to
thoroughly track and dissect the fine-grained thematic discrepancy in U.S. news
media. We employ multiple correspondence analysis (MCA) to quantify the
fine-grained thematic discrepancy related to four prominent topics - domestic
politics, economic issues, social issues, and foreign affairs in order to
derive a more holistic analysis. Additionally, we compare the most frequent
$n$-grams in media headlines to provide further qualitative insights into our
analysis. Our findings indicate that on domestic politics and social issues,
the discrepancy can be attributed to a certain degree of media bias. Meanwhile,
the discrepancy in reporting foreign affairs is largely attributed to the
diversity in individual journalistic styles. Finally, U.S. media outlets show
consistency and high similarity in their coverage of economic issues. | [
-0.6078516245,
-0.6006665826,
0.4889076054,
0.549208343,
-0.2713707983,
0.5956829786,
-0.0926865041,
-0.401321888,
0.3819399178,
0.1813271046,
-0.5865631104,
-0.4442965686,
-1.0405359268,
-0.0686718076,
-0.3856302798,
1.2557461262,
0.2369317412,
0.1535539925,
0.3006384969,
-0.4308241308,
-0.3053427637,
-0.014309383,
-0.2934583127,
-0.1238082051,
0.7180751562,
0.3229908347,
0.7018555999,
0.6665877104,
0.688595295,
0.1748509556,
-0.2996962965,
0.1409563124,
-0.3036009371,
-0.3303164244,
-0.5366877317,
-0.4769048989,
-0.1168181524,
0.3712866008,
0.4554262757,
0.8165380955,
0.2577618957,
0.3744480014,
0.1970530003,
1.1473286152,
-0.647243619,
-0.258777529,
-0.8354554772,
0.1346378475,
-0.5177258253,
-0.0408041701,
-0.0521343164,
-0.4035466015,
0.1964119375,
-0.392021507,
0.2246143967,
-0.1586739868,
1.0992258787,
0.0237090718,
-0.974229753,
-0.30546543,
-0.770263195,
0.9483694434,
-0.1656969488,
0.3373737335,
0.1544309556,
0.1319219619,
-0.0422505401,
-0.2769013643,
-0.2092099488,
0.1867289394,
0.3705933988,
0.3164513707,
-0.4186065197,
-0.2522709072,
0.2437798828,
0.3258793652,
-0.4130559266,
-0.0316695645,
-0.4427858889,
-0.1050205901,
0.4736910462,
0.18664518,
0.3332116306,
-0.223916769,
-0.3662207127,
-0.1045423374,
-0.6277745366,
0.184876591,
0.8414477706,
0.2167918831,
-0.2743524313,
0.5519956946,
-0.5881409645,
0.4461312592,
0.306979984,
-0.4788062871,
0.1268634349,
-0.8349111676,
0.2046471983,
0.3445391357,
0.4673337936,
1.0221617222,
0.1527335644,
0.3825335801,
0.1865604222,
0.2426056862,
0.1631679386,
-0.5384759903,
0.3012295663,
-0.0120013077,
-0.7947663665,
-0.0664095879,
0.4010801613,
-1.2741322517,
-0.5023397207,
-0.2548834383,
-0.0305865072,
0.1725037098,
0.1027627513,
0.0142707322,
-0.5428355336,
0.0956275761,
0.3823976517,
-0.56688416,
0.0472927839,
0.4351912737,
0.7906877398,
-0.2288250774,
0.0666388273,
-0.0556326546,
0.0518702716,
-0.3732295036,
1.0437531471,
-0.6886045337,
-0.139483735,
-0.0123131424,
-0.218772918,
0.2636913359,
-0.3702476323,
0.464977622,
-0.1095324904,
0.1482755244,
-0.9383572936,
0.0413760245,
0.0854267329,
0.1949490011,
-0.5527616739,
0.7044686079,
0.2194809765,
-1.0128002167,
0.9125751257,
-0.053854581,
-0.2123554498,
-0.7483987808,
-0.4349085093,
-0.3507665992,
0.2881076336,
0.1867298931,
-0.1743704677,
-0.3677939773,
0.4587503076,
-0.328818202,
-0.3914422393,
0.1908441037,
-0.5736069679,
0.8530734181,
0.425014317,
-0.3080646098,
-0.2148934156,
-1.0914512873,
-0.6720589995,
-0.1119696125,
-0.2982592881,
-0.6897407174,
0.0775637776,
-0.0115488712,
0.3651665151,
0.1557292044,
-0.5881214738,
0.0592627227,
0.0808533505,
0.1865325868,
0.574798882,
0.1595184356,
0.7523362041,
-0.7142466307,
0.1855706871,
0.7140703201,
0.0646578744,
-0.3151041567,
-0.3177382052,
-0.5898892879,
-0.0337265246,
0.1042947099,
0.5298262835,
-0.290669173,
0.2496638745,
0.0548454598,
-0.3568419814,
-0.1938282847,
-0.2584364116,
-0.0284918081,
0.1094645485,
0.2610370815,
-0.5057346821,
-0.6012939215,
-1.0065778494,
-1.2272298336,
0.1529479325,
-0.0656936988,
0.0552119315,
0.3095918596,
-0.0888969004,
1.1876927614,
-0.548961401,
-0.3780565858,
-0.0723287687,
0.4785627127,
0.2754563391,
0.4136923254,
0.4042689204,
-0.5718812943,
-0.4470615387,
0.0912395492,
-0.4462040067,
-0.3752350509,
-0.3925181031,
0.0365075506,
-0.0022356003,
0.3047210276,
-0.41792503,
0.523044467,
0.3269221783,
-0.4170679748,
0.4086267352,
0.1898626983,
0.1889158785,
-0.9359074831,
-0.3971942961,
0.3362112045,
0.2004590034,
-0.4603101611,
-0.4697464705,
-0.17439574,
0.2754634619,
-0.1780943125,
0.3214488328,
-0.4067193866,
-0.3419641852,
-0.0703990608,
0.0697387159,
0.4104423225,
0.0078403968,
-0.3593736589,
0.3095358312,
0.3593788445,
-0.0858796537,
-0.1159653664,
-0.1785549819,
-0.3531568348,
0.8862947226,
-0.2619285285,
-0.181904912,
-0.5444298387,
0.7164095044,
-0.9340006709,
-0.1885309219,
0.0769529566,
-0.095578596,
-0.1057401896,
0.0197941195,
-0.1984059066,
-0.25361377,
-0.5465501547,
0.4455383122,
0.2188781053,
-0.1834057719,
0.1177255586,
0.4067392945,
-0.298230648,
-0.6108308434,
-0.7430435419,
0.0510725528,
-0.3858530521,
-0.4255976379,
0.2157194465,
0.1754678041,
-0.7435731888,
0.0089344895,
-0.7671177387,
-0.3033745885,
-0.0858026892,
-0.1765590161,
-0.2146371007,
-0.2224990427,
-0.1094651446,
0.2913002372,
-0.0044806683,
0.0936358422,
-0.1999862641,
0.2679331303,
-0.0556278899,
-0.3480430245,
-0.4096296728,
0.7163817286,
0.4368481338,
-0.4581539631,
0.3708600402,
0.4890061021,
-0.0788539499,
-0.0036480229,
-0.6357454062,
-0.2604798377,
-0.348466754,
0.265165627,
0.0640858337,
-0.5308648348,
0.7776750326,
0.0435576998,
0.1094132438,
0.5517597795,
0.0815164298,
0.1200049669,
0.9460113645,
0.3529490232,
-0.0354697444,
0.6279287934,
-0.17425403,
0.1769531965,
-0.4779781103,
-0.2786582708,
-0.8239030242,
-0.7636056542,
-0.6620403528,
-0.0735133067,
0.0913397819,
-0.2477319539,
-0.1666294187,
-0.2178359628,
-0.5244516134,
0.6677920222,
0.448797673,
-0.2284538001,
0.5668472648,
0.3805545866,
0.3037911952,
-0.270111233,
-0.3896978796,
-0.358186394,
0.863950789,
0.3250992,
0.9507537484,
-0.2303219587,
0.6684396267,
0.280143857,
0.1046569347,
-0.4716859162,
0.1325182021,
-0.3096049726,
-0.3244298995,
0.1407604069,
-0.3208119571,
-0.9728408456,
0.3432333171,
-0.149393037,
-0.7009043694,
0.7284901142,
-0.3209483325,
-0.0928462148,
0.2266041636,
-0.2476259619,
0.3757339418,
0.063084133,
-0.2395121753,
-0.1630289406,
-0.6714051366,
0.6396079063,
0.0574848354,
0.5282164216,
-0.5414661765,
0.1249246225,
0.6160480976,
0.0983701274,
0.5198933482,
0.1777321547,
-0.218052417,
0.1618881971,
-0.4831106961,
0.255066663,
0.2863371968,
0.4328891337,
0.3762952685,
-0.121120818,
-0.5305603743,
-0.1551911533,
0.5960334539,
-0.8455836773,
-0.6521024108,
-0.8617503047,
-1.0333225727,
0.0384917147,
0.0948577672,
0.4126868248,
0.6968942285,
-0.2655485272,
0.2777386308,
0.6087101102,
0.0626670048,
0.6980813742,
0.143020153,
0.032816492,
-0.2242857963,
0.7135451436,
0.7979896069,
0.0727078244,
0.1107158288,
0.0866828114,
0.2895698845,
-0.288556695,
-0.3630951047,
-0.0481695533,
-0.2740247548,
-0.10549023,
-0.5539858937,
-0.0683637187,
0.0314705893,
-0.3415894806,
-0.566000104,
-0.2286688834,
-0.3337827921,
0.3274080455,
0.0229030643,
0.6585210562,
0.1318981349,
0.5500943065,
-0.7717583179,
0.4773839712,
0.1774758995,
0.4449950457,
-0.426694572,
-0.3937850893,
-0.3858157992,
0.4863161743,
-1.0216042995,
-1.2142535448,
0.0079550883,
-0.0218292326,
0.2335004359,
0.8984417319,
-0.0523261875,
0.6400367022,
-0.5444743633,
0.9952522516,
0.1365357786,
-0.6716603041,
0.4114086032,
-0.9408811927,
0.6147805452,
0.7071814537,
0.2855296731,
-0.1405393332,
-0.9523183107,
-0.8816399574,
-0.6432378292,
0.6352365017,
0.0932310894,
0.2270704508,
-0.3243392408,
-0.1346281171,
0.2903188169,
0.3300714791,
-0.5044879913,
-0.4367886484,
-0.2433233112,
-0.1458072513,
0.1854918599,
-0.1815462559,
-0.4098576903,
-0.0412059948,
0.0939813182,
0.010786254,
0.075869754,
0.3872655332,
0.0768764019,
-0.2526240647,
0.6018708944,
1.0181839466,
1.1074645519,
-0.2810544968,
0.3689890504,
-0.2960273027,
-0.6533683538,
0.3511631787,
0.0663641915,
-0.1363088638,
0.5187730789,
0.1043196619,
0.4918580949,
0.2472991347,
-0.2869434059,
0.363373816,
0.0286438931,
-0.268559128,
-0.1830945164,
-0.2254753113,
0.0062155174,
0.491364181,
0.7756192088,
0.5828111172,
0.4198225141,
-1.0023264885,
0.0610753447,
0.7131080627,
-0.1503691226,
-0.2835742235,
0.6119080186,
0.2641818225,
0.0024776256,
0.0961992592,
-0.048202578,
-0.1059470549,
0.9543888569,
0.5086123347,
0.782042563,
-0.175624609,
0.4847721159,
-0.0404502377,
0.5110347271,
-0.2933295071,
0.1734385341,
0.356335938,
-0.6132515073,
-0.1414551139,
-0.4263941944,
0.0216902457,
0.0258145779,
-0.8542719483,
0.1620450616,
-0.4867060184,
-0.3059095144,
-0.006213746,
0.269718796,
-0.4753642082,
0.2060893923,
0.1429072171,
0.8812907934,
-1.2174677849,
0.5478587747,
0.587952137,
-0.2280962318,
-0.3226104975,
0.4585067928,
0.5806214213,
-0.2144930512,
0.5833271742,
0.2887137532,
0.2665407062,
-0.2999019325,
-0.1168513298,
-0.9346074462,
0.9638980031,
0.4404936433,
-0.5045543313,
0.0601179935,
0.4503960907,
0.0933671072,
-0.6703389883,
0.169597894,
0.9873252511,
0.6248844862,
0.0097266063,
-0.7167050838,
-0.3246649802,
0.1188509762,
0.1259580553,
0.5527428389,
-1.0903497934,
1.0511909723,
0.0858979002,
0.0500091016,
-0.582341373,
0.5548581481,
0.2310159802,
0.952187717,
0.3936032653,
0.373834908,
0.435660243,
-0.3054721355,
0.8063197732,
-0.3915590942,
0.2756284475,
0.6348078251,
-0.0759833604,
0.1937482506,
0.707704246,
-0.4437474012,
0.6341537833,
0.6023104191,
-0.0803718269,
0.632568419,
0.0690056756,
-0.2524296939,
0.2350957096,
-0.4532954395,
-0.4131705165,
0.6431064606,
0.4016560316,
-0.3134532273,
-0.9282306433,
-0.0985626653,
0.2371705025,
0.083798863,
-0.5075365305,
0.4964631498,
0.2669974566,
-0.5545130968,
-0.1460218281,
0.1289335191,
0.5201284289,
-0.5745218992,
0.007974402,
-0.6963467598,
-0.039299909,
-0.4068510532,
-0.6235023141,
0.6543157101,
-0.0448362678,
-0.4375725389,
-0.1268059164,
0.8178796172,
-0.6273533106,
-0.2903088033,
-0.1035488769,
0.5175588727,
-0.2312643975,
-0.1854810417,
-0.4455061257,
0.421815604,
0.0053118109,
-0.1372091621,
0.6430966258,
0.4300148487,
-0.2697795033,
0.2153602242,
0.6029105783,
0.0695578009,
-0.0060854033,
-0.0217720624,
0.7873208523,
-0.48679021,
-0.5733103156,
-0.9439885616,
0.6470153928,
-0.260417223,
-0.6772334576,
0.996837616,
0.4385953844,
0.5351189971,
-0.1724492013,
0.6054063439,
0.118659474,
0.116585359,
-0.5238856673,
0.5540213585,
-0.2941316962,
0.1486824453,
-0.3145373166,
-1.1899416447,
-0.2093584687,
0.6475496888,
-0.0994917154,
0.2207368016,
0.7292157412,
0.4714837074,
-0.2816746533,
0.1961351484,
-0.0150652807,
0.1702542752,
-0.0550643578,
0.1863907129,
0.8519185781,
-0.0212062262,
0.4165371954,
-0.2344857007,
-0.3068218231,
-0.3820160627,
-0.7934936881,
-0.6826207638,
-0.4230811596,
-0.3197130263,
-0.1996851116,
0.1898404211,
0.7894883156,
0.3619361818,
-0.3861787915,
-0.0997976512,
-0.1654912829,
0.640416801,
-0.2241251022,
-0.3178034425,
0.193651855,
-0.3688900769,
-0.8641504645,
-0.2913390696,
0.4874134362,
-0.152132839,
-0.2424488962,
0.7104563713,
-0.2563162148,
0.4584489167,
0.4156296253,
0.0826439261,
-0.9664281607,
-0.5792534947,
-0.0659794509,
-0.2047445774,
0.2929454148,
1.000723362,
-0.5523427129,
0.1806614697,
0.4131180048,
0.5809101462,
-0.0263321679,
0.1952268034,
0.3579174578,
-1.0413613319,
0.3703570664,
-0.4083792865,
0.1471154988,
0.202101633,
-0.3689839244,
0.1082414314,
0.3740144968,
-0.6594317555,
-0.7222646475,
0.3573378026,
-1.2893241644,
-0.1975369006,
1.1630856991,
0.203139171,
0.0786911026,
-0.3320204914,
-0.2361481041,
0.0144935148,
-0.5972611308,
0.8516199589,
0.9689031243,
-0.0388003141,
-0.2115121931,
-0.7138237953,
0.3984314799,
0.2044551671,
-0.8539149761,
-0.2781222463,
0.5311496854,
0.2548347414,
0.2758632004,
0.3482115865,
0.0312427804,
0.3814118505,
0.0206111129,
-0.2733050585,
0.4485526979,
-0.5628736615,
-0.163652122,
0.0553022698,
-0.3737403452,
-0.1371343881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15705v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15705v1 | Translate the Beauty in Songs: Jointly Learning to Align Melody and Translate Lyrics | 2023-03-28T03:17:59 | 2023-03-28T03:17:59 | Chengxi Li, Kai Fan, Jiajun Bu, Boxing Chen, Zhongqiang Huang, Zhi Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Song translation requires both translation of lyrics and alignment of music
notes so that the resulting verse can be sung to the accompanying melody, which
is a challenging problem that has attracted some interests in different aspects
of the translation process. In this paper, we propose Lyrics-Melody Translation
with Adaptive Grouping (LTAG), a holistic solution to automatic song
translation by jointly modeling lyrics translation and lyrics-melody alignment.
It is a novel encoder-decoder framework that can simultaneously translate the
source lyrics and determine the number of aligned notes at each decoding step
through an adaptive note grouping module. To address data scarcity, we
commissioned a small amount of training data annotated specifically for this
task and used large amounts of augmented data through back-translation.
Experiments conducted on an English-Chinese song translation data set show the
effectiveness of our model in both automatic and human evaluation. | [
-0.1154391691,
-0.3734499812,
0.1075649783,
0.6698814631,
-0.5090429783,
0.2619954348,
-0.2512209713,
-0.6145396829,
0.0338469036,
0.5441651344,
-0.6727519631,
-0.7277249694,
-0.4445689619,
0.1151517928,
-0.4489503205,
1.2078458071,
-0.1454970688,
0.2405030876,
-0.1089505702,
-0.3329282403,
-0.6806957722,
0.2950412631,
-0.2834346294,
-0.1093344241,
0.4552328587,
0.2233788818,
0.4758059382,
0.4725449383,
0.8502155542,
0.3103867471,
0.1268493235,
0.3669323623,
-0.2394379824,
0.0926273316,
-0.0094773406,
-0.5388188958,
-0.8605744243,
0.1563753784,
0.6606507897,
0.5932680964,
-0.2295481861,
0.4188707769,
0.1988568902,
0.7408411503,
0.169086203,
-0.1166457236,
-0.7422610521,
0.1852091104,
-0.1885213852,
-0.2400251031,
-0.1809585541,
-0.6913605332,
0.1365480721,
-0.7822258472,
0.1968351454,
0.2301244736,
0.8617107868,
0.4685201645,
-0.3636830151,
-0.4528241754,
-0.3837456107,
0.8193254471,
-0.4940407276,
0.0312413424,
0.0099360822,
0.2214681357,
-0.4059441984,
-0.2857456207,
-0.2891480029,
0.3646123707,
-0.2432587296,
0.4419510067,
0.1856155843,
-0.026693603,
-0.0852585658,
0.8073024154,
-0.7856126428,
-0.3113351464,
-0.261277765,
-0.0297922455,
1.1073513031,
-0.0484897941,
0.8809862137,
-0.1813048571,
-0.6006312966,
0.1756708026,
-0.2975709438,
0.1837001592,
0.1358337849,
0.7096763849,
-0.5190299749,
0.3073581159,
0.4246220589,
1.1501597166,
0.2864198387,
-0.463599205,
0.4742980003,
-0.4557441473,
-0.3011762798,
0.4606105983,
0.8763056397,
0.4181157351,
0.1373526305,
-0.4696965218,
-0.5041912794,
0.108722195,
0.0010804322,
-0.2008088827,
-0.0998661146,
0.2240740806,
-0.5813258886,
-0.2329393774,
-0.2861913741,
-0.7919839025,
-0.2113053501,
-0.4981757104,
0.734985292,
-0.3566799462,
-0.0415724516,
0.2311315089,
-0.118693985,
0.2000231445,
0.3871356547,
-0.9095723629,
-0.0463312976,
0.5654746294,
1.0783067942,
-0.166792497,
-0.503005743,
-0.5632817149,
0.263106823,
-0.3618618548,
0.7859228849,
-0.0551333986,
-0.1674652249,
-0.3075411618,
0.0152155403,
-0.4143423438,
-0.3166176677,
0.4923962355,
-0.2233375013,
0.3238344789,
-0.2667467296,
-0.4693845212,
-0.0375000201,
-0.2720402479,
-0.7414245605,
0.6298102736,
0.389059335,
-0.6204091311,
0.4010835886,
-0.5975159407,
-0.5831597447,
-0.0851671696,
0.111640349,
-0.5789737105,
0.5682732463,
0.4493807554,
0.1888994575,
-0.0667101294,
0.1982368082,
-0.0811246037,
-0.619536221,
0.3468261957,
-0.0426218621,
0.7824190855,
0.439071089,
0.152517125,
0.1452100724,
-0.6450942159,
-0.1332410276,
0.1892977804,
-0.5939614773,
-0.3380763233,
-0.1404126137,
0.5279752612,
0.2818391919,
0.4977638423,
-0.2586589158,
0.2724006772,
-0.5192682743,
0.295669049,
0.7631599307,
-0.1967228353,
0.899050355,
-0.5123657584,
0.4456432462,
-0.1419968158,
-0.048436366,
-0.0154339727,
-0.3427688181,
-0.2953640819,
-0.0235948432,
0.4223481715,
0.4049116969,
-0.4530376792,
0.5629972219,
-0.6361022592,
-0.1922067702,
-1.2241491079,
0.556131959,
0.2110047489,
0.3205028474,
0.4683524668,
-0.5305995345,
-0.4903685451,
-0.4193895757,
-0.4559984505,
0.0288342834,
0.0912893787,
-0.1152408347,
-0.0030706134,
0.2036613375,
0.6796558499,
-0.024650678,
-0.8685721159,
-0.2428456396,
0.1126678437,
0.4057207704,
0.8389380574,
0.7718221545,
-1.0095075369,
-0.7647970319,
0.3815303743,
-0.7094362974,
-0.3530332446,
-0.4880038798,
-0.5229032636,
0.1081398353,
-0.082748346,
-0.2711165547,
0.0336207785,
0.9916384816,
-0.353711158,
0.0078096725,
0.1128870472,
0.3079256713,
-1.2930860519,
-0.1454179585,
-0.1509767473,
-0.332695514,
-0.5896508098,
0.0079010306,
-0.0200454872,
0.0501527227,
0.047399193,
0.0919932202,
-0.6165499091,
-0.5029071569,
-0.3070264459,
0.3719119728,
0.2723302245,
0.3687310815,
-0.0125069516,
0.7044267654,
0.4410929382,
-0.1690578014,
0.5814444423,
0.4755997062,
-0.5301498175,
1.1331419945,
-0.2726961374,
0.1605569571,
-0.0366607681,
0.0741163492,
-1.0094487667,
-0.5276793838,
0.1503451318,
-0.7183635235,
0.476262033,
-0.1979902983,
-0.2113233656,
-0.2082341313,
0.3167905211,
0.3392662704,
0.5646332502,
-0.7457639575,
0.6318807602,
0.3619071543,
-0.1097499877,
-0.3892503083,
-0.7174093127,
0.2131702304,
-0.6349291205,
-0.7271329165,
0.6478050351,
0.0999087989,
-0.0151568437,
0.2268746644,
-0.4069651365,
0.103490822,
0.08895652,
-0.0467111468,
0.2197583318,
-0.2844022512,
0.6108638048,
0.1183236092,
0.1207409427,
-0.1666086167,
-0.7267385721,
0.3977300823,
-0.0023521204,
-0.0560743809,
-0.2885484993,
0.6982595921,
0.4934805036,
-0.5038198233,
0.4272631407,
0.8488473892,
-0.1478726417,
-0.3234397471,
-0.1655813158,
0.5933964849,
-0.4461709857,
0.2965179682,
-0.4618983269,
-0.6156489849,
0.7735311389,
-0.06922061,
0.3148073852,
0.4085435271,
0.1026052907,
-0.7197110653,
1.0937578678,
0.6689263582,
-0.2122543454,
0.5186241269,
-0.0416969433,
-0.0023090842,
-0.8387771249,
-0.1347272396,
-0.3024614155,
-0.7718804479,
-0.6488113999,
-0.2974630296,
0.371283412,
0.4417922795,
-0.0750562474,
0.4536160827,
-0.9400637746,
0.3165717423,
0.2413142323,
0.2207586318,
0.3474441469,
0.2126526386,
0.2685208023,
-0.0076900837,
-0.2198935151,
-0.0950021818,
0.9401515126,
0.0601654388,
0.8204285502,
0.5208603144,
1.0193721056,
0.0549787357,
0.1535674632,
-1.0085458755,
0.2751961648,
-0.5064449906,
-0.2904598713,
-0.3626258671,
-0.5974138379,
-0.5792884827,
0.0913251415,
-0.1602535993,
-0.4634442627,
-0.0159673523,
0.2429098189,
-0.1926102936,
0.2196614146,
-0.4459753036,
0.9306495786,
-0.8315894604,
-0.093277365,
0.1152026355,
-0.6721217632,
0.3120752573,
-0.3382937014,
0.343167454,
-0.299710542,
-0.0826023147,
0.7072600722,
-0.0475356802,
0.5156229138,
-0.2052436322,
-0.5823699236,
0.1104358137,
-0.2764076293,
0.5784182549,
-0.3767003417,
0.0680920631,
-0.045136638,
-0.371196717,
-0.6438199878,
-0.8378976583,
0.7309744358,
-0.6073735952,
-0.3837269843,
-0.2665489018,
-1.1229932308,
-0.0278965533,
0.1277012825,
0.4093052447,
0.0758458674,
0.1037498489,
-0.1058409438,
0.304457128,
0.0590885989,
0.6183456779,
0.183122173,
-0.5033453703,
-0.9447552562,
0.7733612657,
0.1728943884,
0.6524564028,
0.3898196518,
0.0136237517,
-0.4145590067,
-0.6760382652,
-0.8576323986,
0.2039439976,
-0.6333387494,
-0.1228198335,
-0.3548882902,
0.069929719,
-0.3329405189,
-0.348244518,
-0.1813233793,
-0.2667839229,
-0.1190022975,
0.2088261992,
0.8606173396,
0.5569694638,
-0.061364349,
0.3924009204,
-1.0929541588,
0.3368118703,
0.3220522106,
0.4077160358,
-0.4577778876,
-0.7638915181,
-0.6327719688,
-0.1278087199,
0.0637373999,
-1.0675960779,
0.4838577509,
0.384881705,
0.3107630908,
0.0654012188,
-0.1105508283,
1.306422472,
-0.4778207839,
0.5029606819,
0.3306147456,
-1.155990243,
0.6895951629,
-0.6779312491,
0.1094440818,
0.5960190296,
-0.1179049015,
-0.5924880505,
-0.0737388507,
-0.0037783266,
-0.5788616538,
0.625539422,
0.0520461723,
0.0315729529,
0.6036704183,
0.2456193715,
0.0264688171,
0.2197778523,
-0.8070769906,
-0.0905715749,
-0.5284714699,
-0.7627801299,
-0.4296351671,
0.6190637946,
-0.1953856051,
-0.2660498917,
0.4166390896,
-0.3385353982,
0.3315750957,
0.0719070584,
-0.0598807372,
-0.6662988067,
0.3550756872,
0.310852915,
0.2106069624,
-0.3604409993,
-0.2321544439,
0.0554756187,
-0.3697734773,
0.4965058863,
0.1711336672,
-0.155289039,
-0.0240952112,
0.325448513,
0.8976355791,
0.172785297,
-0.2369615436,
0.3708314598,
0.1610455364,
0.3134099543,
-0.2796826363,
0.0185564049,
0.2696638405,
0.0510297045,
0.2723894715,
0.5927856565,
0.0890800133,
-0.3580735624,
0.3230345249,
0.345567435,
-0.8162043691,
-0.2958530188,
0.6477069259,
0.145403713,
-0.3024762273,
0.1777877808,
-0.2392613143,
-0.3663405478,
0.6622269154,
0.7596222758,
1.0476182699,
-0.5941483378,
0.2100884169,
0.2155872583,
0.252648592,
-0.1812358052,
0.3722617328,
-0.1283607483,
-0.4082921147,
-0.786786139,
-1.0267901421,
0.1421864331,
-0.0050774538,
-0.9359126091,
0.1182560027,
0.2161530554,
0.1221401319,
-0.0778532252,
-0.2262699008,
-0.4196660817,
0.2480014563,
-0.0411449485,
0.5918027759,
-1.1973669529,
0.8599113822,
0.8520234823,
-0.4756520092,
-0.9658161402,
0.1682073325,
0.0589543693,
-0.5647658706,
0.35304299,
0.1656108648,
-0.0020203404,
0.339277178,
-0.6622718573,
-0.9440388083,
1.0704599619,
0.0991504714,
-0.610470593,
-0.1209410802,
0.1642192155,
0.5294553041,
-0.5950562358,
-0.6558816433,
0.6320950985,
0.3627660573,
0.2506627142,
-1.0388497114,
-0.3083395958,
-0.4764344394,
-0.0214736629,
0.350492537,
-0.7656183839,
1.0474690199,
-0.0285541676,
-0.3804892004,
0.4270356596,
0.6477839351,
0.1338469833,
0.4587084353,
0.3886971176,
0.7897366285,
0.511310339,
-0.3965869546,
0.6262359023,
0.0247306749,
0.4617306888,
1.2957097292,
-0.2031977326,
0.6474937797,
0.5036501884,
-0.3803676665,
0.2318449616,
0.7909242511,
-0.1171563566,
0.7882254124,
0.1121352017,
-0.4213544726,
-0.5449982285,
-0.2076957226,
-0.2911054492,
0.763568759,
0.3460815251,
-0.6808519363,
-0.0807338431,
0.125615418,
-0.2962469459,
0.4690421522,
-0.5708802938,
0.9904620647,
0.3522675931,
-0.8355702758,
0.4377579093,
-0.1939409226,
0.645955205,
-0.2782593668,
-0.1182629839,
-0.178864643,
0.0352650024,
-0.4477567971,
-0.7036191821,
0.1909994483,
-0.1080287695,
-0.0939668566,
-0.163746804,
0.4969682992,
-0.988478899,
-0.797591269,
0.4345057905,
0.1994626075,
0.0117526902,
0.3635259569,
-0.870228529,
-0.0446920954,
0.251252532,
0.2128776014,
0.2701744735,
0.5678458214,
0.1096656695,
0.351809442,
0.4525914192,
0.5011271238,
0.2703923583,
0.1305344701,
0.5317155123,
-0.5967972279,
-0.5589672327,
-0.5422008038,
0.7041815519,
-0.087593317,
0.1863594502,
0.7022618651,
0.4042906463,
0.7651512623,
-0.1139588207,
1.1118346453,
0.0732562542,
0.4622865319,
-0.739079833,
0.9271238446,
-0.7994718552,
0.2026377618,
-0.7101168633,
-0.939543426,
-0.4646499455,
0.7516483665,
-0.1289541125,
-0.0398714319,
0.227741614,
0.6143078208,
-0.2254675031,
0.0174121615,
0.1059311256,
-0.2088131458,
0.0506364927,
1.0802243948,
0.7954069376,
-0.9408637881,
0.5223380923,
-0.2595236003,
0.0509952083,
0.0556314178,
-0.6677626371,
-0.7047029138,
-0.5748405457,
-0.4045081735,
-0.1704299748,
-0.1452276558,
1.0099313259,
0.3108496964,
-0.9415169954,
-0.2045079917,
-0.1743821204,
0.2443957478,
-0.6070088744,
-0.2006615698,
0.6676305532,
-0.4776656926,
-0.9613289833,
0.4350626767,
0.3128373027,
0.5038740039,
-0.0609925911,
-0.2409909219,
-0.0293487553,
-0.0132952612,
0.07987158,
-0.1756211966,
-0.9632424712,
-0.435639143,
-0.0705978498,
-0.1578782797,
0.2527532578,
0.5118418932,
-0.2392597347,
0.7429248095,
0.6366553307,
0.3879697621,
-0.140028581,
0.5169112086,
0.5098555684,
-0.8450033069,
-0.1661911458,
-0.1657951325,
0.2778450251,
0.5095377564,
-0.3034830987,
0.4444144666,
0.2353900075,
-0.5785012841,
-0.7630601525,
0.1054848954,
-1.235145092,
0.1495308727,
0.5960042477,
-0.4327617586,
-0.2441612184,
-0.191614747,
-0.0688901842,
0.6022575498,
-0.2378544211,
0.6837878823,
0.5066732764,
0.0691698045,
-0.331735909,
-0.5051190257,
0.7032272816,
0.1444789171,
-0.6287233233,
-0.2271939814,
0.6363243461,
0.1408790499,
0.3892839849,
0.4174876213,
-0.2990982831,
0.5438708663,
-0.094099313,
0.3836897314,
0.0890294388,
-0.2199238539,
-0.5342379212,
0.1782538593,
-0.0547701865,
-0.6429538131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02468v1 | Comparative Analysis of CHATGPT and the evolution of language models | 2023-03-28T03:11:28 | 2023-03-28T03:11:28 | Oluwatosin Ogundare, Gustavo Quiros Araya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Interest in Large Language Models (LLMs) has increased drastically since the
emergence of ChatGPT and the outstanding positive societal response to the ease
with which it performs tasks in Natural Language Processing (NLP). The triumph
of ChatGPT, however, is how it seamlessly bridges the divide between language
generation and knowledge models. In some cases, it provides anecdotal evidence
of a framework for replicating human intuition over a knowledge domain. This
paper highlights the prevailing ideas in NLP, including machine translation,
machine summarization, question-answering, and language generation, and
compares the performance of ChatGPT with the major algorithms in each of these
categories using the Spontaneous Quality (SQ) score. A strategy for validating
the arguments and results of ChatGPT is presented summarily as an example of
safe, large-scale adoption of LLMs. | [
-0.3387911022,
-0.7401670218,
0.5916072726,
0.2979248464,
-0.1032626331,
0.3778178096,
-0.3101277053,
-0.400927484,
-0.1052891463,
0.2269082367,
-0.3044834435,
-0.2595105171,
-0.524179399,
0.0677729249,
-0.6604182124,
0.7587914467,
0.2735075653,
0.0576000512,
-0.1762212217,
0.1145260185,
-0.181496188,
-0.7303548455,
-0.9580769539,
-0.499024123,
0.3068774939,
-0.0687356442,
0.8252646923,
0.3471053541,
0.4909799695,
0.2508779168,
-0.2570934892,
0.1076845378,
-0.4093030393,
0.2107613683,
0.0557985492,
-0.5213854313,
-0.2623491287,
-0.0265067071,
0.6638095379,
0.6465893984,
-0.3073207736,
-0.137585476,
0.2724122405,
0.6597699523,
-0.0912607908,
0.1271309555,
-0.6708524823,
0.0129077984,
-0.0480392948,
-0.290686965,
-0.2277001292,
-0.6013673544,
0.3617459238,
-0.2339664847,
0.1420592666,
0.1836977899,
0.7049729228,
0.0027027999,
-0.3833871186,
-0.4745738804,
-0.7679539919,
0.6829392314,
-0.908614397,
0.5393723845,
0.057182543,
0.2703870535,
-0.3786701858,
-0.6522938609,
-0.6739370227,
-0.6086132526,
0.1443391293,
0.1351330578,
-0.2059319764,
0.0231982265,
0.1192280948,
0.5060847402,
-0.845808506,
0.2341267616,
-0.1414266825,
0.0234523248,
0.5307804942,
-0.0492713116,
0.5332969427,
-0.191414848,
-0.4303873181,
0.045428928,
-0.9615523219,
-0.0373862982,
0.3015211225,
0.0385136344,
0.0540030226,
0.7033417821,
-0.3767458498,
0.5713672042,
-0.3041990995,
-0.1498822272,
0.1513166875,
-0.2064893246,
-0.2528395057,
-0.1921646446,
0.9751242399,
0.4691150486,
0.4443785846,
-0.3150918186,
-0.2029443085,
0.2223653048,
-0.013463595,
-0.6105076075,
-0.1599109769,
0.0374487191,
-0.2940067351,
-0.3758005202,
-0.2144099027,
-0.6633303165,
-0.45518139,
-0.3050015569,
0.1422426105,
-0.3805582225,
-0.2736004591,
0.2658385038,
-0.0682299286,
0.5767817497,
0.4382645488,
-0.8086403012,
0.339050293,
1.1228181124,
0.8203703165,
-0.4844222665,
-0.1075080037,
-0.0093466472,
-0.3632537127,
-0.4209731221,
1.1248376369,
-0.2629582882,
-0.3002789319,
0.013060729,
-0.4574702978,
-0.0784916952,
-0.5268037319,
0.6338875294,
-0.736300528,
0.5299862623,
-0.2506783605,
-0.8078606129,
-0.3517221212,
0.5086195469,
-0.1939291507,
1.0717570782,
-0.0505619645,
-0.948025167,
0.5743632913,
-0.7044677734,
-0.2146088034,
0.363586098,
-0.1787954867,
-0.0875638053,
0.0917912498,
0.110963963,
0.3313931823,
-0.4411529601,
0.2779894471,
-0.309610188,
-0.0888006315,
0.489479214,
-0.6751019955,
0.8014985919,
0.3324767947,
-0.2124545872,
-0.220152244,
-0.6184032559,
0.0815492868,
0.1787019819,
-0.3992710412,
-0.1303916276,
0.2764390707,
-0.1720361859,
0.4500000775,
0.1503469795,
-0.1482799649,
0.2367484868,
-0.4220736027,
0.5958707929,
0.4377523661,
0.2563399971,
0.272360146,
-0.4223710299,
0.5232869387,
-0.2473048121,
0.1523592323,
-0.1591030359,
-0.7850719094,
-0.8587381244,
0.0553249978,
0.3251008093,
0.6725838184,
-0.4415978789,
0.3391473591,
-0.3468692899,
-0.607542634,
-0.3462719023,
0.1379140317,
-0.0127444081,
0.2088524252,
0.0940144584,
-0.3878751993,
-0.3325627744,
-0.7422140241,
-0.4002563357,
-0.3725436926,
-0.2674920261,
0.2483902425,
0.0922917426,
-0.2215832323,
0.9749860168,
-0.2104374319,
0.3180171847,
-0.5247078538,
0.1466888487,
0.2355645001,
0.3013534844,
0.4661864042,
-0.6768208742,
-0.397266537,
0.122085683,
-0.7633855939,
-0.2460377812,
0.0480247401,
-0.1074260175,
0.0328389555,
0.37296772,
-0.8397725224,
0.1364888698,
0.6085022092,
-0.2886039317,
0.707138598,
-0.0250098929,
0.3270075917,
-1.2023032904,
-0.061583437,
-0.2128022313,
-0.3527742922,
-0.7936655879,
0.100836888,
-0.2731465697,
0.0298861433,
-0.2413630784,
0.3779850602,
-0.3193743825,
-0.2803431749,
-0.2948192656,
0.5087368488,
-0.1622086167,
0.163630262,
0.0522353612,
0.5956087708,
0.4867844284,
-0.4466484785,
0.5339332223,
0.0115149813,
-0.6523070335,
0.2615368962,
-0.6909309626,
0.2709298134,
0.0315907598,
0.0204096362,
-1.0535296202,
-0.228737399,
-0.0972266942,
-0.5785132051,
0.0520345606,
-0.2913634479,
-0.7009926438,
-0.2836618721,
-0.172900185,
-0.0109529318,
0.8856182098,
-0.362403959,
0.2896103263,
0.2409175336,
-0.5852046609,
-0.4277046621,
-0.346619457,
0.376203686,
-0.4331341684,
-0.7820587158,
-0.2159170061,
-0.0324537195,
-0.5924230218,
-0.1743958741,
0.0293991435,
0.0232634526,
0.3852942586,
-0.0115498966,
0.2078223974,
-0.4894787371,
0.1130375713,
-0.1072101519,
-0.0198071431,
0.1212908924,
-0.4318695068,
0.8269553781,
-0.1284445226,
-0.3796907663,
-0.0799301118,
0.0630878583,
0.5526555777,
-0.0470865853,
0.6025301814,
0.3113457859,
-0.0720545948,
-0.2815301716,
-0.6989657879,
-0.1279774606,
-0.4019105732,
0.2408663332,
-0.061056789,
-0.9702622294,
0.3460423946,
-0.2021169811,
0.4027812481,
0.3791477382,
0.7132803798,
-0.0815826505,
0.9250895381,
0.523450613,
-0.1112156585,
0.5632032156,
0.1053702608,
0.4068667889,
-0.5053325891,
0.1494849771,
-0.5776603818,
0.0720833316,
-0.7539801598,
-0.4497976303,
0.1611775309,
0.3900739849,
-0.0864374563,
0.1526383907,
-0.0717431009,
0.4781773984,
0.3713818491,
-0.2777784765,
0.6716558337,
0.0000012812,
-0.080211103,
0.1017152295,
-0.9439606667,
-0.8279674053,
0.9625996351,
0.3679750264,
0.4956865311,
0.1841138303,
0.6157650352,
0.2736717761,
0.4685088992,
-0.732466042,
0.6269325018,
0.0693027601,
-0.3897277117,
-0.2634049952,
-0.52407974,
-0.8347325325,
0.57419312,
-0.344768554,
-0.8107993603,
-0.1627492905,
0.0436178371,
-0.1591434479,
0.0978630185,
-0.8043593764,
0.7552949786,
-0.2161094099,
-0.156613633,
-0.2018004358,
-0.3164721429,
0.6017251015,
-0.182329163,
0.2991113663,
-0.1877862215,
0.0772426128,
0.6006938815,
-0.1994610876,
0.6001402736,
0.1213037968,
-0.2411361337,
0.4033910632,
0.2739128172,
0.4415709376,
0.1027882621,
-0.0521562174,
-0.023542067,
-0.1813031584,
-0.2023336738,
-0.789745152,
0.6122786403,
-0.6050725579,
-0.5970432758,
-0.141552791,
-0.304074347,
-0.3769203722,
0.1191608235,
0.259290427,
0.3524595499,
-0.3461378813,
0.135049805,
0.582130909,
-0.2744119465,
0.4207971692,
0.379467696,
-0.600505054,
-0.1230747402,
0.6413692236,
-0.016737543,
0.6503161788,
0.3455988467,
0.4286482036,
-0.3911804855,
-0.5597635508,
-0.1999535412,
0.143113032,
-0.7465825081,
0.0108959088,
-0.6834968925,
-0.228074491,
-0.3056126535,
-0.1213083193,
-0.3511073887,
-0.4323323667,
0.2903581858,
-0.1364383996,
0.2816693783,
0.8508978486,
0.0027502065,
0.2115655988,
-0.666030407,
0.0016644741,
0.5153425336,
0.1428829134,
0.0442214683,
-0.5139420629,
0.0926097855,
0.1122474596,
-0.3190727234,
-0.7681002021,
0.3928112686,
0.0366863273,
0.4866625369,
0.457991153,
-0.3177344799,
0.2522397637,
-0.4017553329,
1.0034147501,
0.058780089,
-0.7562832236,
0.268586725,
-0.4703291953,
0.2592843771,
0.197728321,
0.4046024084,
-1.0112272501,
-0.5451604128,
-0.803501904,
-0.7432461977,
0.2004286498,
0.3149720728,
0.0881337225,
0.1166392192,
0.1226132736,
0.102722533,
0.2386714667,
-0.9074825048,
0.1122306734,
0.0059880959,
-0.0537173115,
-0.2064941376,
-0.2268686146,
0.1434844732,
0.0803263113,
0.5558425188,
0.0138886478,
0.3367579281,
-0.0063951844,
-0.2907759547,
0.2918757796,
0.6177530289,
0.5582057834,
0.6257477403,
0.1072910279,
0.2979321778,
0.2608729005,
-0.4105406106,
0.0157155916,
-0.2081887424,
-0.3095946908,
-0.0783585981,
0.5697160363,
0.7333686352,
0.2435728014,
-0.6180149317,
0.556140244,
-0.0684480518,
-0.1858546585,
-0.0988212004,
0.2476658225,
0.3583817184,
0.3828728497,
0.3151924908,
0.0219954941,
0.0677702054,
-0.4718025327,
0.1656010449,
0.4429528415,
-0.1316270083,
-0.3679431379,
0.2594788074,
0.0346661024,
-0.4237534702,
0.5649751425,
-0.3590093553,
-0.7082437873,
0.3420358896,
0.3750592768,
0.9111993313,
-0.0344877541,
0.1640975177,
0.1222394407,
0.4170588553,
-0.4140155911,
0.0617724806,
-0.204205811,
-0.969456315,
-0.6954468489,
-0.7708446383,
-0.3970282674,
0.0619025566,
-0.2568176091,
0.1720323861,
-0.2882755399,
0.0195241123,
-0.1178739667,
-0.0836692527,
-0.5965321064,
-0.0717435405,
0.1946145743,
0.8306456208,
-0.7670991421,
0.8178826571,
0.4223062694,
-0.1362713128,
-0.7113264203,
0.2372232974,
-0.1008495539,
-0.8850272894,
0.6592681408,
-0.0048253373,
0.0117954426,
0.112834461,
-0.4286215007,
-0.7162061334,
0.7414426208,
0.0152558982,
-0.6241832376,
-0.0379414707,
0.2340574116,
0.7467389703,
-0.1192306727,
0.2710652947,
0.6889651418,
0.2879005075,
-0.0324690305,
-0.9222310781,
-0.2574810088,
0.0873734504,
-0.0526865944,
0.1333182305,
-0.3453735411,
0.5627387762,
-0.2221840322,
-0.4049239457,
0.0134132672,
0.4198487103,
0.2490942031,
0.0077023669,
0.5201176405,
0.315353781,
0.5902849436,
-0.219408676,
0.9158706069,
-0.2471189946,
0.4804694653,
0.7950002551,
-0.2897110581,
0.9863932729,
0.2678702176,
-0.5290634036,
0.3164578378,
0.5000212193,
0.0632309392,
0.2062261105,
0.2911299765,
-0.3362575471,
-0.2177521139,
0.2924554944,
-0.2216505408,
0.5066412091,
0.3780388534,
-0.2030721605,
-0.3635725379,
-0.1738422662,
0.078716442,
-0.1859907508,
-0.1197136715,
1.0549869537,
0.2480416596,
-0.775497973,
0.4043578804,
-0.2591186464,
0.7130277753,
-0.4865682125,
0.1580620855,
-0.4301511347,
-0.0616982915,
-0.0729275569,
-0.8048080206,
0.1196806729,
0.1339644939,
0.1135801524,
-0.2241991311,
0.7258064151,
-0.2987499535,
-0.3070617318,
0.1194815785,
0.8268949986,
0.2684135735,
-0.0129901106,
-0.6855968237,
-0.0744248852,
-0.1023951396,
-0.5120123029,
0.3538717926,
0.5886488557,
0.0541042536,
0.9155008197,
0.7311844826,
0.188724041,
0.3231630325,
0.0772109404,
0.6132077575,
-0.6761869788,
-0.4354933798,
-1.0633747578,
0.2130939662,
-0.1064937487,
-0.2363688797,
0.8972741365,
0.4790594876,
0.491566658,
0.176404506,
0.8240848184,
0.0129508944,
0.6220056415,
-0.5832543373,
0.7676602602,
-0.1767613441,
0.3314138651,
-0.4654552341,
-1.0530011654,
-0.3592388034,
0.5592542291,
-0.3807350695,
0.0859627351,
0.6189412475,
0.7398942709,
0.0960093513,
0.1767097265,
0.431473732,
0.2468728572,
0.4721012414,
0.3206014931,
1.3857816458,
-0.0932725817,
0.3119429946,
0.1471617669,
-0.3892766833,
-0.2545829117,
-1.0759023428,
-0.7014988661,
-0.4808543921,
-0.1736041456,
-0.2434584349,
-0.0635292828,
0.9706578255,
0.5515107512,
-0.5524106622,
-0.3413132429,
-0.3352677226,
0.1669850945,
-0.2096516192,
-0.2688037753,
0.1374670863,
-0.610761106,
-0.5170125961,
0.4929644167,
0.430387646,
0.1964539438,
-0.3951807022,
-0.0508973263,
0.0873015448,
0.252397567,
0.9850524664,
0.2838153243,
-0.6224316359,
-0.1450143158,
0.0378255285,
-0.1112000719,
0.0880293772,
0.8485993743,
-0.580624938,
0.1127670109,
0.6656534076,
0.6229663491,
0.316949755,
-0.1030844674,
0.7703976035,
-0.330987066,
-0.0898503289,
0.2274722904,
0.4186120331,
0.5194839239,
0.1116228327,
0.4328047931,
0.3086717427,
-0.8009826541,
-0.8959988356,
0.213841483,
-0.9035228491,
-0.1212944463,
1.2827563286,
-0.0515993424,
-0.0190047007,
-0.2571482062,
-0.2450527847,
-0.0183218587,
-0.3469488919,
1.0221322775,
0.7798727155,
-0.125207752,
-0.27469787,
-0.8978767991,
0.7129616141,
0.280286938,
-0.9408516884,
0.2566801012,
0.1775866896,
0.4195942581,
0.0776837319,
0.471552521,
-0.2197023034,
0.1337981373,
-0.0095119514,
0.0575286709,
0.4086505175,
0.1031931043,
-0.2939152718,
0.2118013948,
0.6559360027,
0.2709938884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15697v1 | Model and Evaluation: Towards Fairness in Multilingual Text Classification | 2023-03-28T03:00:01 | 2023-03-28T03:00:01 | Nankai Lin, Junheng He, Zhenghang Tang, Dong Zhou, Aimin Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, more and more research has focused on addressing bias in text
classification models. However, existing research mainly focuses on the
fairness of monolingual text classification models, and research on fairness
for multilingual text classification is still very limited. In this paper, we
focus on the task of multilingual text classification and propose a debiasing
framework for multilingual text classification based on contrastive learning.
Our proposed method does not rely on any external language resources and can be
extended to any other languages. The model contains four modules: multilingual
text representation module, language fusion module, text debiasing module, and
text classification module. The multilingual text representation module uses a
multilingual pre-trained language model to represent the text, the language
fusion module makes the semantic spaces of different languages tend to be
consistent through contrastive learning, and the text debiasing module uses
contrastive learning to make the model unable to identify sensitive attributes'
information. The text classification module completes the basic tasks of
multilingual text classification. In addition, the existing research on the
fairness of multilingual text classification is relatively simple in the
evaluation mode. The evaluation method of fairness is the same as the
monolingual equality difference evaluation method, that is, the evaluation is
performed on a single language. We propose a multi-dimensional fairness
evaluation framework for multilingual text classification, which evaluates the
model's monolingual equality difference, multilingual equality difference,
multilingual equality performance difference, and destructiveness of the
fairness strategy. We hope that our work can provide a more general debiasing
method and a more comprehensive evaluation framework for multilingual text
fairness tasks. | [
-0.2022763342,
-0.3111864626,
0.2781977654,
0.3963558674,
-0.1674955338,
-0.0974332839,
-0.17323865,
-0.4855321944,
-0.2352193743,
0.2421079874,
-0.3756875396,
-0.4023441672,
-0.7315145731,
0.2122640312,
-0.0122171603,
1.1232032776,
0.1059470847,
0.6831252575,
-0.2602363229,
-0.5752901435,
-0.5171599388,
-0.7284993529,
-0.6060304642,
-0.5982787609,
0.4227621555,
0.2703320384,
0.4228232801,
0.2387489974,
0.6665109396,
0.5598723888,
-0.2099063247,
-0.3790510297,
-0.2833601832,
-0.2046734095,
-0.348729223,
-0.4878432155,
-0.440628469,
0.2369299531,
0.597520709,
0.5124770999,
-0.2200230658,
0.0327220932,
0.1750525981,
0.5893344879,
-0.7852333784,
-0.0101619903,
-0.3691001236,
0.4309234321,
-0.1934289038,
0.1091641858,
-0.4202503264,
-0.4686778188,
-0.1270666867,
-0.2801943123,
0.0751850158,
-0.0896199122,
0.4925164282,
0.0123996241,
-0.6988592148,
-0.307831645,
-0.1889193207,
1.174369216,
-0.5836647749,
0.5239871144,
0.1808753312,
0.5674276352,
0.5377779603,
-0.4635505378,
-0.8035712242,
-0.1670664996,
-0.1832302809,
0.3572950363,
0.1012094468,
-0.0899793208,
0.0000781256,
0.4603778422,
-0.551520586,
0.3117596209,
-0.2318021357,
-0.2361541092,
0.5262119174,
-0.0132953664,
0.2926380932,
-0.4351338446,
-0.6398748159,
-0.0732673332,
0.0001501849,
-0.0256229062,
0.7181719542,
0.2865862548,
-0.4409533739,
0.1031397507,
-0.1869115084,
0.3720240295,
-0.1255236566,
-0.5182812214,
0.8351361752,
-0.2014991194,
-0.186425969,
0.0509381033,
0.6348221302,
0.6819765568,
0.1080582887,
-0.1715108603,
-0.2495646924,
0.3054298759,
-0.012657431,
-0.9050368667,
0.154631421,
-0.0458231308,
-0.9373272061,
-0.4275718331,
-0.0961004198,
-1.1607935429,
-0.4593380988,
-0.2640701532,
0.4491168261,
-0.1571967602,
-0.50684762,
0.3487305343,
-0.0304968581,
-0.0310994741,
0.1869458556,
-0.8035303354,
0.3830580115,
0.4006898105,
0.5123870969,
-0.2150294632,
-0.6132503748,
-0.4030676484,
-0.0916541144,
0.1754453033,
0.6581496596,
-0.6169686317,
-0.163758114,
0.0680821314,
0.0782854334,
-0.1523970515,
-0.2991859019,
0.7175843716,
-0.5555409789,
0.6292533278,
-0.0484580137,
-0.2989145815,
-0.5394747257,
0.4816254079,
-0.8770053983,
0.3804455996,
-0.1589585245,
-1.0688406229,
0.4653334022,
-0.742105484,
-0.3818177581,
-0.0128917908,
-0.1991856396,
-0.4817697704,
-0.3255998492,
-0.0025608898,
0.2466498315,
-0.3096525669,
0.3679828346,
-0.4404991567,
-0.4089435637,
0.2144191116,
-0.6492689252,
1.184773922,
0.4906084836,
-0.5698301792,
-0.0194448251,
-0.6085674167,
-0.0388835743,
-0.2144692242,
-0.4301825166,
-0.3433468342,
-0.2413969338,
0.4283306599,
0.6035810113,
0.2332953066,
-0.553078711,
-0.3320351839,
-0.4711041451,
-0.1696455181,
0.8494669199,
-0.4961915612,
0.6929478049,
-0.3243412971,
0.5115115643,
0.3125577867,
0.2970288396,
0.0161155257,
-0.2241560966,
-0.6494713426,
-0.3277268112,
0.6259335876,
0.7392341495,
-0.7165990472,
0.3762109876,
-0.1235916391,
-0.2070348859,
-0.5897365212,
0.0690181553,
0.8478633761,
0.3755314946,
0.2542736232,
-0.2439740151,
-0.2484685332,
-0.9957618117,
-0.312477231,
0.062380176,
0.2518556714,
0.1525662839,
0.5049489141,
-0.4618181288,
0.3160631061,
-0.309686482,
-0.3663984537,
-0.2052578479,
0.1291515529,
0.0709224567,
0.7259427309,
0.8928906918,
-1.3091102839,
-0.4584360123,
0.1152375862,
-0.8376838565,
-0.1388717145,
0.3457344472,
-0.0809562057,
0.2713275552,
0.2513215244,
-0.1196494773,
0.3586129546,
0.4649836123,
-0.4086141586,
0.2277618647,
-0.0789022893,
0.8325457573,
-0.8493548036,
0.0373826735,
-0.113808699,
-0.2103184462,
-0.4361276627,
0.4626330137,
0.0338208638,
0.0019207792,
-0.6490249038,
0.9272764325,
0.0608408973,
0.2306675464,
-0.2289071679,
0.3623595834,
0.1559278369,
0.4719277322,
-0.0219773259,
0.1187795326,
0.5184957385,
-0.5785269737,
0.1826487482,
0.0770318881,
-0.3529127836,
0.9738782644,
-0.1630282998,
-0.0556518473,
-0.4830573499,
-0.0398990661,
-0.847624898,
0.2736051381,
0.3554686904,
-0.31259197,
0.2351968884,
-0.0248470549,
-0.3187096715,
-0.0741856843,
-0.4576871991,
0.7511557937,
0.2929688096,
-0.8535031676,
0.3846654892,
0.5048581958,
-0.2932416201,
-0.942256093,
-0.782589674,
-0.346768111,
-0.3837231398,
-0.4321291149,
0.4916515052,
-0.4229662716,
-0.4433584809,
-0.0148189804,
0.0753805414,
-0.462554723,
0.2329346538,
-0.0978937596,
0.0113281654,
0.2532579005,
0.286147356,
0.3296300471,
-0.3533053398,
-0.2144737691,
0.1033301428,
0.2660479248,
-0.1504761726,
-0.3619147241,
-0.2498266697,
0.535155654,
0.0733481944,
-0.303832829,
0.4005490541,
0.9969893098,
-0.5304920077,
-0.0168950111,
-0.5649517179,
0.0520968698,
-0.4444395006,
0.4249660671,
-0.5048194528,
-0.837110281,
0.5071784258,
0.1890293062,
0.0075949705,
0.6482107639,
0.5390393734,
0.430462271,
0.9109610319,
0.8442456722,
-0.0410542041,
0.0870111585,
0.2263903171,
0.0318888612,
-0.1034130752,
-0.4110530615,
-0.9986132383,
-0.224067986,
-0.8382491469,
-0.1852145046,
-0.0182474926,
0.1289909333,
-0.3426094651,
-0.2225974798,
-0.4627875984,
0.6120430827,
0.3510633111,
0.2215680927,
0.4292760193,
0.1482595801,
-0.3887791932,
-0.346644938,
-0.3998921812,
-0.5588600636,
0.7999437451,
0.3014585376,
0.5579330921,
0.4588220119,
0.6686769724,
0.4865334332,
0.5585352182,
-0.4121797681,
0.2344707996,
-0.6287166476,
-0.6615661979,
-0.0730574727,
-0.8846840262,
-0.6576825976,
0.6930425167,
-0.2073612362,
-0.5192516446,
0.153597787,
-0.2491918355,
0.0876476541,
0.2998151779,
-0.7050443888,
1.1928596497,
-0.268173635,
-0.2327754796,
-0.561169982,
-0.4823747277,
0.4690734744,
-0.1505448073,
0.806286335,
-0.0611261576,
0.150426656,
0.9641385674,
0.0003263897,
0.6962639093,
-0.4239838123,
-0.1886107177,
-0.0811115354,
0.0339459516,
-0.2266049534,
0.2895737588,
-0.6226354241,
0.4832082093,
0.0124840979,
-0.3280116618,
-0.3531293869,
0.8502686024,
-0.6236620545,
-0.1915012151,
-0.5590213537,
-0.0713160783,
0.1199737266,
0.3472711444,
0.1532105803,
0.3807611465,
-0.4120785892,
-0.1810608357,
0.2734793127,
-0.5544347167,
0.6237140894,
0.7940703034,
-0.4490164816,
-0.4750452936,
0.9774506688,
-0.194144994,
-0.0838892087,
0.8177191019,
0.2452352345,
-0.5298566222,
-0.294003278,
-0.3252934813,
-0.1712025255,
-1.0813319683,
-0.3682136834,
-0.5624042749,
0.0203115493,
-0.3735699654,
-0.0262794178,
-0.1226019934,
-0.3686954975,
0.0964202955,
0.0965984613,
-0.0481753387,
0.6067252159,
-0.2936479747,
0.2581322193,
-0.5911484361,
0.5542100072,
0.3513856828,
0.8053806424,
0.1879359633,
-0.5293180943,
-0.3364191353,
-0.0347016007,
-0.6027065516,
-0.6043656468,
0.1890425533,
0.0451352634,
0.7596994638,
0.1850671619,
-0.0863689631,
0.3105486333,
-0.6668816805,
0.4174089432,
0.5789538622,
-1.241969347,
0.0826310143,
0.1885877699,
0.1850855052,
0.7491128445,
0.3421173394,
-0.4421232939,
-0.2345919162,
-0.3484810889,
-0.4532679915,
0.8723824024,
0.0815147907,
0.3407640457,
0.0053149522,
0.2050030082,
0.5319137573,
0.4175756276,
-1.5372935534,
-0.3513679504,
-0.4323348701,
-0.3650938272,
-0.1554179192,
-0.1787877828,
0.1835557073,
-0.2683034837,
0.4839066863,
0.0015237794,
0.0350846797,
-0.1132030934,
-0.3459524214,
0.165607512,
0.722445786,
0.3035850227,
0.5082798004,
-0.094840683,
0.1108302176,
0.2812960744,
-0.2384229153,
0.3161429465,
0.3824029267,
-0.0874043554,
0.0526296422,
0.2777482271,
0.5306877494,
0.2813338041,
-0.469043076,
0.8797116876,
-0.3185944557,
-0.0981412753,
0.0710919648,
-0.2165909708,
-0.146869421,
0.3093392253,
-0.0715604946,
0.1981191486,
0.6024531126,
-0.2423421741,
0.2253662497,
0.20980151,
-0.4492152035,
-0.0085580247,
0.5896868706,
0.4541765749,
-0.0977782458,
0.2844297886,
-0.7055826187,
-0.8039986491,
0.4822182357,
0.4388266206,
0.7585823536,
-0.8052411079,
0.3255564868,
0.3122704327,
0.2028806061,
0.1064785495,
0.2311194837,
0.120057568,
-0.7081149817,
-0.2708012462,
-0.9141339064,
-0.1430084556,
0.0137138311,
-0.4258882403,
0.358187288,
-0.2175812423,
-0.059667822,
0.016416898,
0.1876512319,
-0.7312378883,
0.5366098881,
0.0792692676,
0.7030194998,
-0.626316309,
0.5442613959,
0.5719380975,
-0.372066021,
-0.0323862061,
-0.1810851097,
-0.1043249443,
-0.3998062909,
0.8826967478,
0.671081841,
-0.2743600905,
-0.4748389721,
-0.0025473612,
-0.1880064905,
0.4924120009,
0.6389397383,
-0.6024249196,
0.4110823274,
0.1051454842,
0.4497451484,
-0.3457478583,
0.5587011576,
-0.0206864066,
0.6340687275,
-0.3728210926,
-0.9900301099,
-0.0137975458,
-0.5029729605,
-0.0734284967,
-0.1591210067,
-0.7129035592,
1.072810173,
0.0329671875,
-0.1280677915,
0.015670415,
0.1887206137,
-0.0900838375,
0.515984714,
0.6068727374,
0.5680663586,
0.8011265397,
0.0820295438,
0.9784438014,
0.0185126327,
0.5695992112,
0.9438009262,
-0.542724669,
0.5406864285,
0.1049620733,
-0.1882555485,
0.599439919,
0.4058228433,
0.0421991982,
0.7374269962,
0.3144135475,
-0.3502052426,
-0.1858715713,
-0.0517047606,
-0.4188812673,
0.5682095885,
-0.2512325644,
-0.1265736967,
-0.4898589849,
0.3936376274,
0.0134473192,
0.5889382362,
-0.4215678573,
0.6750381589,
0.0289304499,
-0.283477664,
0.2943078578,
0.7528949976,
1.0209611654,
-0.3875187337,
-0.0107895844,
-0.1450847387,
0.6247016788,
-0.2373324633,
-0.5600081682,
0.2229561955,
-0.0125866607,
-0.4861781597,
-0.131292671,
0.5016229153,
-0.5247719288,
-0.6901297569,
0.8984459639,
0.3468021154,
0.0487688668,
0.1710058749,
-1.0606960058,
-0.0084169973,
0.0466554947,
0.0456178002,
0.4856539965,
0.4011245966,
0.1705584526,
0.4207562208,
0.1699040979,
-0.2900797427,
-0.3055408895,
0.5830790401,
0.4359546602,
-0.7566531897,
-0.8254467249,
-1.0536395311,
0.4562933445,
-0.1737680882,
-0.2523427606,
0.6368678808,
0.588788271,
0.9656410813,
-0.1146590635,
0.7346612215,
0.0639831275,
0.5984637737,
-0.6306099892,
1.0300550461,
-0.7796596289,
0.148080349,
-0.6392583251,
-0.9144504666,
-0.4115070701,
0.7821137309,
-0.1526153982,
0.5561488867,
0.794911325,
0.41737023,
-0.1174569279,
0.2049062699,
0.3534199297,
-0.0883234292,
0.045445282,
0.5861006379,
0.6663565636,
-0.6995802522,
0.5071350932,
-0.1344324052,
-0.5033359528,
0.1320086569,
-0.9946399927,
-1.0693370104,
-0.5804569125,
-0.2489324808,
-0.1807501763,
0.0767076612,
0.7074973583,
0.632025063,
-0.686635077,
-0.3882755637,
0.4117199779,
0.6743651032,
0.0257121213,
-0.2737521827,
0.3132172823,
-0.6149682403,
-0.9565415978,
-0.0541321933,
0.1476793885,
-0.052323781,
-0.0502760597,
-0.3857106268,
-0.3141834736,
-0.2901428938,
0.7199841738,
-0.3521313965,
-0.3421961367,
0.0436232761,
-0.5843099356,
-0.2629588842,
0.0425968282,
0.5100994706,
-0.5672799349,
0.4098825455,
0.230423063,
0.5754806399,
0.3233721852,
-0.4254413545,
0.2375856638,
-0.6785668135,
0.5289598107,
0.0616795681,
0.452867955,
0.4558571875,
-0.25268507,
0.2718128562,
0.1750124842,
-0.3671436012,
-0.622107625,
0.2239938825,
-0.554843843,
-0.580627203,
0.7316581607,
-0.2225330174,
0.085629344,
-0.0531923324,
-0.193764016,
0.2002783567,
-0.2168646157,
0.7982483506,
0.6238105893,
0.3910027742,
0.0146171674,
-0.1799088418,
0.4288524687,
0.3648304939,
-0.8866869211,
-0.1233420223,
0.4319886267,
0.1406789571,
0.2638108432,
0.7748628259,
-0.5140327811,
0.3601917326,
-0.1389857829,
0.3380231857,
0.3285191059,
-0.3336948454,
-0.7037329674,
0.3468708992,
-0.1239013448,
0.0116537809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02746v1 | Sejarah dan Perkembangan Teknik Natural Language Processing (NLP) Bahasa Indonesia: Tinjauan tentang sejarah, perkembangan teknologi, dan aplikasi NLP dalam bahasa Indonesia | 2023-03-28T02:31:47 | 2023-03-28T02:31:47 | Mukhlis Amien | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | This study provides an overview of the history of the development of Natural
Language Processing (NLP) in the context of the Indonesian language, with a
focus on the basic technologies, methods, and practical applications that have
been developed. This review covers developments in basic NLP technologies such
as stemming, part-of-speech tagging, and related methods; practical
applications in cross-language information retrieval systems, information
extraction, and sentiment analysis; and methods and techniques used in
Indonesian language NLP research, such as machine learning, statistics-based
machine translation, and conflict-based approaches. This study also explores
the application of NLP in Indonesian language industry and research and
identifies challenges and opportunities in Indonesian language NLP research and
development. Recommendations for future Indonesian language NLP research and
development include developing more efficient methods and technologies,
expanding NLP applications, increasing sustainability, further research into
the potential of NLP, and promoting interdisciplinary collaboration. It is
hoped that this review will help researchers, practitioners, and the government
to understand the development of Indonesian language NLP and identify
opportunities for further research and development. | [
-0.5902521014,
-1.1739133596,
-0.0075897635,
0.6533159018,
-0.1468072087,
0.1758344918,
-0.4077832699,
-0.7531637549,
0.6462877393,
0.8947857022,
-0.3560353518,
-0.4145368636,
-0.4106193781,
0.8429387212,
-0.4474262595,
0.6758993268,
0.0489770733,
-0.3686904609,
0.1831360906,
-0.0423749313,
-0.613320291,
-0.7180452347,
-1.0754846334,
-0.0833947137,
0.1956431717,
0.1738903522,
0.4433422983,
0.1772083491,
0.6451847553,
0.3143819869,
-0.3396035433,
-0.2001066208,
0.2815017104,
0.3828802705,
-0.3454935551,
-0.4850123823,
-0.2300521135,
-0.212192744,
0.6739723682,
0.9356746078,
0.1262497753,
0.0402134508,
-0.0318995789,
1.1235640049,
-0.2813140154,
0.1862902343,
-0.0531033799,
0.3516547084,
-0.7880352139,
-0.5415044427,
-0.1163246483,
-0.4936710298,
0.2612249851,
-0.2820793688,
-0.0878414512,
-0.1678988636,
0.6311788559,
0.1764532179,
-0.3270256519,
-0.5656520724,
-0.6901324391,
0.6936030984,
-0.8817734122,
-0.0035284311,
0.4391107261,
0.4626376629,
-0.2842887044,
-0.5152581334,
-0.366050303,
0.014311213,
-0.0353219248,
-0.1531742513,
0.1607176363,
0.0178401768,
0.1041334793,
0.5175462961,
-0.6311429739,
0.0894238055,
-0.4717042148,
0.2396696955,
0.6263760924,
-0.172286123,
0.4468989968,
-0.482932806,
0.0297629833,
0.2412721962,
-0.5916104913,
-0.0429314859,
0.6339205503,
0.5109077692,
0.3305959702,
1.0190671682,
-0.5630684495,
0.7808576226,
-0.3179207146,
-0.2665560246,
0.2890889943,
-0.6969624758,
-0.3224138319,
0.078080073,
0.5080912709,
0.1562386304,
0.091372788,
0.1502045244,
0.0308548156,
0.1124370098,
0.1124062315,
-0.1849088222,
0.1844542027,
0.1801428497,
-0.5427613258,
-0.3477078378,
-0.1172899529,
-1.0004519224,
0.0221123323,
-0.3203882873,
-0.0660954192,
-0.2677073777,
-0.9185917377,
0.2659111023,
-0.2366598845,
0.3708369136,
-0.0528520979,
-1.0226535797,
0.5560563803,
0.8124884367,
0.7285672426,
-0.0803084224,
0.0026756139,
0.357776612,
-0.1038694009,
-0.1841419488,
0.806746006,
-0.57108742,
-0.3545506001,
0.3063922524,
-0.1699121594,
0.0950332806,
-0.5177730918,
0.8251612186,
-0.2889490724,
0.2160248905,
0.0669087544,
-0.4860482514,
-0.4893771112,
0.3122716248,
-0.6443431377,
1.2802554369,
-0.2476709336,
-1.2131941319,
0.3393854797,
-1.105158329,
-0.7983130813,
0.0952801332,
-0.0303729698,
-0.3310860395,
0.2637333572,
0.2293444723,
0.5566156507,
-0.0151015781,
0.3142291307,
0.2440006286,
-0.33112517,
0.0330618061,
-0.0401290394,
1.1457818747,
0.3543035984,
-0.2550391853,
-0.0057460852,
-0.9038799405,
-0.3561543524,
0.2397844344,
-0.5460658669,
-0.5980215073,
0.0723414123,
0.1548391134,
-0.0302973688,
0.342430979,
-0.3532373607,
0.3034226298,
-0.6918748617,
0.1339710206,
0.3287909031,
0.1794176996,
0.238220349,
0.0884414986,
0.5641904473,
-0.3714841604,
-0.0672305003,
-0.464802146,
-0.8403531313,
-0.6970565319,
0.2515132725,
0.5236507058,
0.5048772097,
-0.8172826171,
0.6560992599,
0.0492381081,
-0.1989980787,
-0.5040109158,
-0.1440014988,
-0.04519796,
0.2492488176,
0.3691312075,
-0.4793960154,
-1.1264834404,
-0.7369892001,
-0.5498411655,
-0.2281657904,
-0.0148883229,
-0.1522802263,
0.2881259918,
-0.1284474581,
1.0476344824,
-0.1035603061,
-0.3676140308,
-0.636564672,
0.4287222028,
0.5882633924,
0.499810189,
0.5835487247,
-0.7749432921,
-0.5378322601,
0.2833656669,
-0.615819037,
-0.2888489366,
0.2057096064,
0.2723311186,
0.6808534861,
0.405184418,
-0.2539021075,
0.6602550149,
0.5363832116,
-0.3695045114,
0.5394438505,
0.0178047605,
0.0772214085,
-1.0573079586,
0.3427113593,
0.123843357,
-0.1586622894,
-0.6391072273,
-0.0259367377,
-0.5768218637,
0.0247223657,
-0.27085495,
0.3448727727,
-0.1582920402,
-0.170137167,
-0.5208470225,
-0.1912002265,
-0.4360125363,
0.1967523992,
0.2622556388,
0.3998211324,
0.3419747055,
-0.805128336,
0.4064383805,
0.0896784514,
-0.23288697,
0.5624601841,
-0.3426216543,
-0.0186251756,
0.0483899526,
-0.0895015523,
-0.5787965059,
-0.0725568309,
0.3818662763,
-0.5545648932,
0.4566862285,
-0.0987276882,
-0.583996594,
-0.49281317,
-0.353821367,
0.0889271274,
0.4268096387,
-0.1007075086,
0.2226221412,
0.5547683835,
-0.7006735802,
-0.7771388888,
-0.9583063126,
0.4526582658,
-0.3291732669,
-0.500886023,
0.1224803403,
0.175397709,
-0.3676359355,
0.008699812,
-0.0895805135,
-0.2848674357,
0.3350140452,
-0.1589840353,
-0.1851195991,
-0.3261730373,
0.0255470518,
0.2565776408,
-0.3537496328,
0.2370947599,
-0.2201046646,
0.5598234534,
0.055341538,
0.1561608464,
-0.4634273946,
0.4300624728,
-0.3900988102,
0.2898139358,
0.4581489861,
0.4255173802,
-0.3880191743,
0.1267159134,
-0.6483487487,
0.2612622082,
-0.3752170205,
0.1721186638,
-0.3950141668,
-0.8480454683,
0.0033517177,
-0.4017228484,
0.2070811689,
0.8544516563,
0.3543505073,
-0.1006107107,
0.4716871083,
1.3016183376,
-0.1193924472,
0.545887053,
0.0716589317,
0.4268158376,
-0.675478518,
0.0454136021,
-0.908103466,
-0.1322620213,
-0.8079115748,
-0.1029407829,
-0.111018315,
0.0032059825,
0.3582089841,
0.5924346447,
-0.6337020397,
0.3479148149,
0.3443181813,
-0.5184078217,
0.6423991919,
0.1994698793,
-0.2689411938,
-0.266962111,
-0.4800131023,
-0.8620718718,
1.068921566,
0.4730210304,
0.5489407778,
-0.1951352209,
0.6989059448,
0.2920576036,
-0.0867360085,
-0.2731578052,
0.5858221054,
-0.1764713526,
-0.6716349721,
-0.3682598174,
-0.3094061017,
-1.0652139187,
-0.0037148944,
0.1107627377,
-0.511223495,
-0.1109057739,
-0.243395552,
-0.100691691,
0.2678894997,
-0.5697226524,
0.6567255855,
0.1194572598,
0.2455400229,
-0.3411329389,
-0.7748129964,
0.3542379439,
0.222895816,
0.1363277435,
-0.2028328627,
0.0418855026,
1.0441645384,
-0.1058690473,
0.5908094645,
-0.1355577558,
-0.1057412773,
0.498696506,
-0.1997082531,
-0.3463511765,
0.0678728521,
-0.139503181,
0.2618023157,
0.1318613738,
-0.3274448514,
-0.2527963221,
0.3149493039,
-0.3346664011,
-0.4680688381,
-0.7288336754,
0.0265254341,
-0.0182465632,
0.2829340696,
-0.1174013615,
-0.251914233,
-0.3624049723,
-0.0670347735,
0.3166181147,
-0.4928143322,
0.5347928405,
0.2470106333,
-0.748075068,
-0.0825339332,
0.754290998,
0.087216422,
-0.1992255747,
0.663572073,
0.2055188566,
-0.207908541,
-0.6931013465,
0.0311571509,
0.1356438994,
-0.5104038715,
-0.003513481,
-0.6156419516,
-0.2166524529,
-0.4028270245,
-0.0803856328,
-0.4977531731,
-0.7971590757,
-0.1391132474,
-0.0921942666,
0.269934237,
0.8820537925,
-0.2004160434,
0.0690371692,
-0.1431428939,
0.2908113301,
0.0776207075,
0.3407916725,
-0.2253190428,
-0.0179874692,
-0.1073168144,
-0.2060698122,
-0.1373219788,
-0.5195548534,
0.596555829,
-0.1445208341,
0.0714585036,
0.0422717892,
-0.2256474495,
0.3376047313,
-0.1826426536,
0.9527454972,
0.1454365104,
-0.7058504224,
0.9911419153,
-0.169222191,
0.3633842468,
0.5377649665,
0.2425326258,
-0.9110860825,
-0.3336988389,
-0.4945450127,
-1.0243051052,
0.6386976838,
0.2940665781,
-0.0534741618,
0.0557716712,
0.3745077848,
0.3588017821,
0.3646130264,
-0.868540287,
-0.2437528372,
-0.0919009298,
0.0958877578,
0.134942621,
-0.290330708,
0.2570648193,
-0.2177933007,
0.7015826702,
-0.1013813764,
0.4595595896,
0.3004286587,
-0.0891419351,
0.0092490967,
0.5280968547,
0.3038725555,
0.6772564054,
-0.2739573717,
0.1076150686,
0.1088856906,
-0.4069918692,
-0.1870781928,
0.1591738909,
-0.3691012263,
0.4635129571,
0.2460245043,
0.5914412141,
-0.0238677561,
-0.3976100981,
0.2179179788,
-0.2653340697,
0.0004110744,
-0.6512800455,
-0.2576458752,
0.0205322932,
-0.0216858983,
0.6021357775,
0.2160002738,
0.2112734169,
-0.518196404,
-0.023550218,
0.0385182388,
-0.1160172001,
-0.4125548303,
0.2738310397,
0.3416337073,
-0.3300344646,
0.3037079275,
-0.1710368544,
-0.3102082908,
0.5040158033,
0.5127469301,
0.9443696737,
-0.3901388943,
0.095366925,
0.4879226983,
0.515468657,
-0.0007993833,
0.5197539926,
-0.0782221407,
-0.2464877665,
-0.714779377,
-0.7491218448,
-0.3325781226,
0.0053800512,
-0.3290734291,
0.4671928883,
-0.5222665071,
-0.2923140526,
-0.0762936249,
0.5606163144,
-0.5465682149,
0.0148175796,
-0.0420469455,
0.9277048707,
-0.4856766164,
0.7698773742,
0.6857384443,
-0.4235658944,
0.1667336971,
-0.0820339099,
-0.002894978,
-0.2097044438,
0.6857430935,
0.3407021165,
0.1215872467,
-0.229112044,
-0.4013124704,
-0.7022964954,
0.5873576999,
-0.1039490625,
-0.2280592769,
-0.0368145593,
0.3140093386,
0.8131138086,
-0.0633611903,
0.1629843265,
0.9421013594,
0.7161116004,
-0.3028670847,
-0.9922187924,
-0.1497927904,
-0.4853212535,
0.3130277991,
0.0169935524,
-0.2282649577,
0.4193153977,
0.4513443112,
-0.5790288448,
0.3390954137,
0.8615583777,
-0.1253750622,
0.1449927241,
0.1267689466,
0.4002828896,
0.1962105483,
-0.2893271148,
0.9888424277,
0.1988918781,
-0.1903148592,
0.6146386266,
0.0090259602,
0.7665069103,
0.7494797707,
-0.6021729708,
0.3166879416,
0.5109226704,
0.3254838288,
0.1782859117,
0.2829360962,
-0.2598564625,
0.6635152698,
-0.4412995875,
-0.5388035178,
0.1048406959,
0.6684482694,
-0.0659962595,
0.0067166807,
-0.0635723472,
0.1113086194,
0.1431029737,
-0.1111856773,
0.7588842511,
0.1217613071,
-0.5569140911,
0.1583133489,
0.3297512531,
1.2528496981,
-0.6185298562,
-0.0376509652,
-0.0107315043,
-0.1916515529,
-0.3781293035,
-0.9187442064,
1.2279140949,
0.2470239252,
0.212515682,
-0.3795129657,
0.9145625234,
-0.1261365712,
-0.2900858521,
0.2099129707,
0.2610065937,
0.2427831441,
0.1386172473,
-0.5910633206,
0.3089102507,
-0.1856727749,
-0.4382535517,
0.124627918,
0.4152239263,
0.1269915998,
0.4287495613,
0.5019228458,
0.3444003463,
0.4441840351,
0.0331779718,
0.435397476,
-1.1115529537,
-0.4808741212,
-0.6366404891,
0.2796216905,
-0.2560326457,
-0.4207596183,
0.7338010669,
0.2518477738,
1.0877774954,
-0.0206202809,
0.9881439805,
-0.4664072394,
0.9565480947,
-0.4430360496,
0.2676126361,
-0.1093814746,
0.0331962854,
-0.6132004857,
-1.1136196852,
-1.0183917284,
0.8706889749,
-0.1000518501,
-0.1910130978,
0.7347680926,
0.0957575738,
0.3216055036,
0.363455236,
0.0000110579,
0.2320760638,
0.2758071423,
0.1136870608,
0.7153338194,
-0.4957161546,
0.1683792323,
-0.5433635712,
0.0276580323,
-0.3498340249,
-0.7850188613,
-0.8861441612,
-0.5715690255,
-0.3460280299,
0.0854953676,
0.092633307,
0.8925263286,
0.16669254,
-0.9118698835,
-0.651111424,
-0.3713581562,
0.4002464116,
-0.5993494391,
-0.3065236509,
0.3654365242,
-0.6659469604,
-0.8066631556,
0.4273998439,
0.8370424509,
-0.1394674629,
-0.4255775511,
0.2425248325,
-0.9621248245,
-0.2263546139,
0.7578145862,
0.7340326905,
-0.6848804951,
0.1735626757,
-0.2990316153,
0.0865155011,
0.259347856,
0.7458257079,
-0.6800993085,
0.6585097313,
0.7083768845,
0.8775604963,
0.4027848542,
-0.4581036866,
0.7309377789,
-0.8522922993,
0.2334457934,
0.3896079957,
0.254866749,
0.5603726506,
-0.1281909496,
1.112226367,
0.3567734063,
-0.4042495489,
-0.5521098375,
0.1462647617,
-0.6790216565,
-0.3076364994,
0.6324039102,
0.1809060425,
-0.2838927209,
-0.7480834723,
-0.6207041144,
0.3790729046,
-0.1569713801,
0.5726116896,
0.835595727,
-0.2048336864,
-0.1109701991,
-0.740822494,
0.7468432784,
0.4175311029,
-0.8260453939,
-0.2942789495,
-0.1803958863,
-0.1820478886,
0.4243254364,
0.8371418118,
-0.324550122,
-0.1181062758,
-0.1948785633,
0.1217922717,
0.5594456792,
-0.1548784077,
-0.5129916668,
0.1999035329,
0.0739685744,
0.1988071948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15682v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15682v1 | Pre-training Transformers for Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-03-28T02:10:37 | 2023-03-28T02:10:37 | Sanxing Chen, Hao Cheng, Xiaodong Liu, Jian Jiao, Yangfeng Ji, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Learning transferable representation of knowledge graphs (KGs) is challenging
due to the heterogeneous, multi-relational nature of graph structures. Inspired
by Transformer-based pretrained language models' success on learning
transferable representation for texts, we introduce a novel inductive KG
representation model (iHT) for KG completion by large-scale pre-training. iHT
consists of a entity encoder (e.g., BERT) and a neighbor-aware relational
scoring function both parameterized by Transformers. We first pre-train iHT on
a large KG dataset, Wikidata5M. Our approach achieves new state-of-the-art
results on matched evaluations, with a relative improvement of more than 25% in
mean reciprocal rank over previous SOTA models. When further fine-tuned on
smaller KGs with either entity and relational shifts, pre-trained iHT
representations are shown to be transferable, significantly improving the
performance on FB15K-237 and WN18RR. | [
-0.5073720813,
-0.113736704,
0.3661533892,
0.1184567958,
-0.1028550863,
0.2092324048,
-0.2797497213,
-0.4064266384,
0.317476511,
0.4395511746,
-0.4840358496,
-0.3797724843,
-0.9450194836,
0.2825596631,
-0.4242790937,
1.010234952,
-0.2533103824,
-0.0876730457,
-0.4151426852,
-0.1367420852,
-0.1421039701,
-0.2346887141,
-0.089129746,
-0.7829458117,
0.6160753369,
0.4272339344,
0.6827567816,
0.37224859,
0.432661593,
0.2422170788,
0.4637017846,
0.0331931747,
-0.759719789,
-0.2729501426,
-0.3251625896,
-0.2161557227,
-0.2317412049,
0.0687243864,
0.6918292642,
0.9352827072,
0.0309450869,
0.2596435845,
0.2162161767,
0.6624172926,
-0.426612556,
0.7239701748,
-0.6264156699,
0.177156359,
-0.1830023378,
-0.1886947751,
-0.8525428176,
-0.6822111607,
0.3272103667,
-0.9467534423,
-0.0637066662,
-0.0805968717,
1.0413643122,
0.1569334567,
-0.7739021778,
-0.1954085678,
-0.7133816481,
0.1347387135,
-0.2630695999,
0.7814241052,
0.3399564922,
0.5337433815,
0.0260211509,
-1.1956231594,
-0.6906737685,
-0.2841718495,
-0.5701370239,
0.1207481176,
0.0095024798,
-0.0412969105,
0.331805408,
0.1832772493,
-0.2281517833,
-0.0167326797,
-0.2707972825,
-0.2884349227,
0.3125492036,
-0.0554325692,
0.0984026939,
-0.2253347933,
-0.3603690267,
-0.3811780512,
-0.6326473355,
-0.0269371867,
0.3721256554,
0.3942341805,
0.2191394567,
0.4981850982,
-0.2691715062,
0.6090398431,
0.0512213819,
0.052211199,
0.3394266665,
-0.1663006097,
0.1109717786,
0.1562856287,
1.008266449,
0.1035273448,
0.634665668,
-0.5770144463,
0.0464663953,
-0.3244923353,
0.5186801553,
-1.0527991056,
-0.6875183582,
-0.3798110187,
-0.4436885715,
-0.071241416,
0.192589283,
-0.4007263184,
-0.1856305897,
-0.3507780135,
0.8220031857,
-0.6529988647,
-0.4735598266,
-0.0691479817,
0.2005489767,
0.0780865476,
0.1958356798,
-0.8592395782,
0.1052734405,
0.1307033598,
0.3589017093,
-0.0004294264,
-0.5096837878,
-0.1528681517,
0.5682939291,
-0.3270591497,
0.7104972601,
-0.4903616607,
-0.2181000561,
0.0009382321,
0.1062067673,
-0.2058717757,
-0.4267810881,
0.2050886601,
-0.9688023329,
0.1003312469,
-0.4219600558,
-0.7910584807,
-0.3230331242,
0.3940120637,
-0.8034350276,
1.0808088779,
0.7230186462,
-0.8738597631,
0.4166347682,
-0.6239650249,
-0.6686091423,
0.0935940295,
0.0681631938,
-0.4212628603,
-0.3988844454,
0.1118821725,
0.5894137025,
-0.2033807039,
0.0940000787,
-0.1626423597,
-0.2750819325,
-0.184510693,
-0.0092548942,
0.4297122955,
0.0050985641,
-0.0602836087,
0.0110035287,
-0.7841307521,
0.1423490644,
0.1748347878,
-0.3861539066,
-0.2817656696,
-0.4116550088,
-0.2122833282,
0.0891335756,
0.5270240903,
-0.4695515335,
0.4332615733,
-0.1344999224,
0.21028997,
0.5641058087,
-0.2186551988,
0.7183951735,
0.0624591522,
0.4275169075,
0.0817323253,
0.0026578882,
0.0153880054,
-0.29623276,
-0.4468398392,
-0.0536188185,
0.7336081862,
0.348519057,
-1.1749991179,
0.5121844411,
-1.0032866001,
-0.8121424913,
-0.3535300791,
-0.2055536956,
0.263035506,
0.6883288026,
0.574760437,
-0.2388118953,
-0.3234991729,
-0.7314074636,
-0.156945169,
-0.0848930851,
0.0517223626,
0.2220889479,
0.3637985885,
-0.4952614605,
1.0673817396,
-0.5698157549,
-0.6378791332,
-0.3273304701,
0.1037715226,
0.2312178314,
0.3444595933,
0.5731415153,
-0.7462011576,
-1.0778665543,
0.4268379509,
-0.8373603821,
0.1581036597,
0.3224234581,
-0.2278016359,
-0.3273634613,
0.7323518395,
-0.692286551,
0.2612813413,
0.4855473042,
-0.2855074704,
0.4874926805,
-0.1106988192,
0.3296951354,
-1.1921707392,
0.0080244374,
-0.4819063842,
-0.630669713,
-0.3391765654,
-0.0501999147,
0.2573345006,
-0.1261870712,
-0.0923691019,
0.3352603018,
-0.2901742458,
-0.0218683295,
0.2523143589,
-0.0285921451,
-0.0609499812,
0.4802825749,
-0.374135226,
0.6681193113,
0.3291032314,
-0.5889281034,
0.3185071945,
0.6356814504,
-0.4802913964,
0.4507492483,
-0.2921420336,
0.1285050064,
-0.2682724595,
0.4567722082,
-0.7588435411,
-0.3240467608,
0.2235157639,
-0.4113567173,
0.6592848301,
-0.3000618815,
-0.597910285,
-0.4721160531,
0.1102417633,
0.4725830555,
0.3946736753,
-0.7738271952,
1.2426655293,
0.0216028783,
0.1367384791,
-0.6738666296,
-0.2911345065,
-0.1864153147,
0.2029874921,
-0.552116096,
0.8124136925,
0.2624620199,
0.5694814324,
0.5283290148,
0.0253122579,
0.0640272722,
-0.1627893299,
0.1016723141,
-0.0462649129,
-0.1182825938,
0.2562320828,
-0.1003572643,
-0.3837566376,
0.0360553376,
-0.4643551707,
0.7428342104,
0.0713731572,
-0.4935359359,
-0.2368349135,
-0.0920031443,
0.4587733448,
-0.2950968444,
0.9246026874,
0.7086503506,
-0.3374740183,
0.0312135704,
-0.4309099317,
-0.2945794761,
-0.458374083,
0.6879913211,
-0.6986967921,
-0.8777721524,
0.4678292572,
-0.5090395212,
-0.2251506001,
0.5520667434,
0.2111792117,
-0.2256241143,
0.7297965288,
0.6588391662,
-0.1344179511,
0.5743569136,
-0.391312331,
0.4701440632,
-0.5880013704,
-0.5001418591,
-0.3992140293,
-0.3217754364,
-0.5016340017,
-0.2170378715,
0.4296137691,
0.2211286128,
-0.4025765359,
0.6373873353,
-0.4536412358,
0.5957128406,
0.4727240801,
0.1774254888,
0.4016771913,
0.1322674751,
-0.1936206669,
-0.1528533995,
-0.6983550191,
-0.1870543808,
1.2157894373,
0.1465108544,
0.6048742533,
0.0209273938,
0.7444514632,
0.3036301434,
0.910636127,
-0.6582788825,
0.3644331098,
-0.3924754858,
-0.2825406492,
-0.4472690821,
-0.7355965376,
-0.9780396223,
0.0275541153,
-0.3741901815,
-0.5803741813,
-0.2874834836,
-0.0633717105,
0.1463433206,
0.3886138797,
-0.6540874243,
1.0367629528,
0.2644854486,
0.1553329825,
-0.125055328,
-0.7411962748,
0.2101696432,
-0.0507365353,
-0.0583028868,
0.0512219407,
0.623812139,
0.7323924899,
-0.4304828942,
0.3629523218,
-0.402220577,
0.0160674006,
0.2114940286,
0.0982113332,
0.8626518846,
-0.2072870731,
-0.1234719902,
0.0752269253,
-0.0476925112,
-0.3051704764,
-0.8844462037,
0.2774148881,
-0.9337074161,
-0.3421735764,
-0.0433844998,
-0.4875530303,
-0.441116333,
0.5524539948,
0.5640383959,
0.3203285933,
-0.1140941232,
0.3335102797,
0.6577351689,
0.1881482452,
0.0417596325,
0.2281264067,
-0.4950540066,
-0.3434391022,
1.0560078621,
0.4684147835,
0.1860724092,
0.69967103,
0.0078171538,
-0.5591986775,
-0.3777100444,
-0.4214938879,
0.1497922391,
-1.1805810928,
-0.4165287614,
-0.9894962311,
-0.5890493393,
-0.4178045988,
0.0165528115,
-0.4801601171,
-0.2668425143,
-0.1394790709,
-0.3416802585,
0.3945585787,
1.0830789804,
0.1014169231,
0.4379266202,
-0.9294951558,
0.2774156034,
0.6292705536,
0.5472102761,
0.2606979907,
-0.4158467352,
-0.4763617218,
-0.2659540772,
-0.0954449326,
-0.7959259748,
-0.070406206,
0.1233629286,
0.5803575516,
0.143929407,
0.266541183,
0.5507518649,
-0.5705006123,
0.3418487906,
0.3239345849,
-0.8046005964,
0.0908830538,
-0.232895866,
0.0181288533,
0.8120051026,
0.8515915275,
-0.1966549009,
-0.0280221142,
-0.4172901809,
-0.6450299025,
0.6908735037,
0.0895450637,
0.2742953897,
0.1637895405,
0.4253385365,
0.1917331517,
0.0150020318,
-1.0757584572,
-0.1861523539,
-0.4659831226,
-0.6239549518,
0.1746691316,
-0.2376668751,
0.0680575967,
-0.5012251139,
0.8440461755,
-0.4141818285,
0.2997620106,
0.0753772706,
-0.4233110547,
0.078079097,
-0.057649266,
-0.2427249104,
0.5781033635,
-0.1173795834,
0.2202084959,
0.1852535754,
-0.6152002811,
0.2852210701,
0.4816338718,
-0.0739667267,
-0.0823829323,
0.5346214771,
0.5975183845,
0.2608123124,
-0.1431757957,
0.8151456118,
-0.0655946061,
-0.0884888321,
-0.1038192436,
-0.3102148771,
0.3302828372,
0.2213109881,
0.4146820903,
0.0727646872,
-0.0574660599,
-0.347497046,
0.2236784846,
0.1886338741,
-0.7528609037,
-0.2895600498,
0.5826932192,
0.0481725223,
0.0051840073,
0.9979140759,
-0.5124673843,
-0.7644902468,
0.3816513121,
0.6298092008,
0.4281952381,
-0.1813288927,
0.336925596,
0.5499712825,
0.3277531862,
-0.0176742394,
-0.0188918523,
-0.1478566974,
-1.0330699682,
-0.522742331,
-0.7108016014,
-0.2014159858,
-0.4029164612,
-0.7332006097,
0.366299808,
-0.1374489069,
-0.1040642858,
-0.1874847263,
-0.1643451303,
-1.0204355717,
0.1743727624,
-0.2822849154,
0.9030269384,
-0.6296950579,
1.0814665556,
0.5914137959,
-0.5381902456,
-1.2758247852,
0.044287201,
-0.8917176127,
-0.7688757181,
0.7502385974,
0.2981007397,
0.0288459864,
0.5627279282,
-0.2874233723,
-0.9122292995,
1.342297554,
0.7206286788,
-0.4653533101,
-0.3122434616,
0.5207942128,
0.2636700571,
-0.1934863925,
0.244720906,
0.4347482026,
0.5683922172,
0.0730385259,
-0.918995142,
0.1604160666,
-0.071803458,
-0.1528701037,
0.370904088,
-0.5483048558,
0.7060489655,
-0.053291779,
-0.1291234195,
-0.2101731002,
0.7837430239,
-0.0286817532,
0.0582251847,
0.5866879821,
0.8951617479,
0.8152905107,
-0.243152529,
1.2068434954,
-0.3390449286,
0.50924927,
1.0137511492,
-0.1668711156,
0.5982266068,
0.1191032752,
-0.4861011505,
0.9075538516,
0.3422864676,
0.181617558,
0.7322756648,
0.0954868197,
-0.0291894507,
-0.3458761275,
-0.1747814566,
-0.6758749485,
0.3710021377,
0.1477968544,
-0.39619416,
-0.2640110254,
0.1307249069,
-0.0247781631,
0.2112901062,
-0.2135478556,
0.8601228595,
-0.1015661284,
-0.5088513494,
0.2644844353,
-0.3717584312,
0.4288268983,
-0.9789010882,
-0.0897431895,
0.0783897415,
0.0372495353,
-0.2994200885,
-0.8402702808,
0.2452700138,
-0.610857904,
-0.4052638412,
-0.4061820805,
0.891536653,
-0.5187076926,
-0.3478890061,
0.7012023926,
0.3276605308,
-0.1582897455,
-0.2670228183,
-0.096331045,
-0.3945202827,
0.0288787764,
-0.2728880048,
0.31770432,
0.7715252638,
-0.0687984303,
0.6035920382,
0.5210463405,
-0.3570416868,
0.1788847595,
0.2302988321,
1.0506026745,
-0.427415669,
-0.4785823226,
-0.6070667505,
0.3001207709,
0.025509676,
0.008298181,
0.4572660029,
0.5487904549,
1.0302004814,
-0.2239343822,
0.6988098025,
-0.2393869609,
0.2462043315,
-0.530702889,
1.146645546,
-0.3000420332,
-0.2283440083,
-0.2057986408,
-1.2296863794,
-0.0469686352,
0.4909784794,
-0.1514591873,
0.0230541676,
0.664665699,
0.446600318,
-0.1753774434,
0.0134136109,
0.2094963044,
0.3100969195,
0.3371339738,
0.5312249064,
0.9630132914,
-0.5829175115,
0.9251616001,
-0.2651843727,
0.0002210297,
-0.0802071393,
-0.8781296611,
-0.7942666411,
-0.7847690582,
-0.1901783645,
-0.5973635912,
-0.2719918787,
0.9150111675,
0.7355210781,
-0.6136928797,
0.2667248249,
0.0943915248,
0.1785477102,
-0.0094825113,
-0.2527005374,
0.5546159148,
-0.2924567461,
-0.3924323618,
0.1153567582,
0.0698673576,
0.021897411,
-0.2763833702,
-0.1875644475,
-0.0694406107,
-0.3405593932,
0.6781111956,
-0.0419611596,
-0.2072417587,
-0.5672393441,
-0.1233784929,
-0.162604332,
0.168538034,
0.7227285504,
-1.0795407295,
0.4978940785,
0.3995937109,
0.9668569565,
0.9640241265,
-0.30333215,
0.4718730748,
-0.9672337174,
-0.0277665295,
0.2849899232,
0.3554718792,
0.5199992061,
-0.3575536013,
0.6738508344,
0.2300963402,
-0.2441939563,
-0.5403115749,
0.3217983246,
-0.796391964,
-0.0030728993,
0.7053850889,
-0.3045534194,
0.0192542542,
-0.0004085901,
0.1321253926,
0.6314566135,
-0.0123099685,
0.6485011578,
0.8339298368,
0.1803775579,
-0.0101410206,
-0.0472013988,
0.4515800774,
0.1040526107,
-0.8005953431,
-0.1489074081,
-0.109819524,
0.3352325857,
0.4002924562,
0.842024982,
-0.2588179111,
-0.037958499,
-0.0366512053,
0.2043981999,
-0.2404808402,
-0.4058026075,
0.4552589655,
0.3029030263,
0.0390025079,
0.1714053303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15662v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15662v3 | ChatGPT4PCG Competition: Character-like Level Generation for Science Birds | 2023-03-28T01:07:38 | 2024-03-21T01:42:43 | Pittawat Taveekitworachai, Febri Abdullah, Mury F. Dewantoro, Ruck Thawonmas, Julian Togelius, Jochen Renz | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2.8 | This paper presents the first ChatGPT4PCG Competition at the 2023 IEEE
Conference on Games. The objective of this competition is for participants to
create effective prompts for ChatGPT--enabling it to generate Science Birds
levels with high stability and character-like qualities--fully using their
creativity as well as prompt engineering skills. ChatGPT is a conversational
agent developed by OpenAI. Science Birds is selected as the competition
platform because designing an Angry Birds-like level is not a trivial task due
to the in-game gravity; the quality of the levels is determined by their
stability. To lower the entry barrier to the competition, we limit the task to
the generation of capitalized English alphabetical characters. We also allow
only a single prompt to be used for generating all the characters. Here, the
quality of the generated levels is determined by their stability and similarity
to the given characters. A sample prompt is provided to participants for their
reference. An experiment is conducted to determine the effectiveness of several
modified versions of this sample prompt on level stability and similarity by
testing them on several characters. To the best of our knowledge, we believe
that ChatGPT4PCG is the first competition of its kind and hope to inspire
enthusiasm for prompt engineering in procedural content generation. | [
-0.3942147493,
-0.5565722585,
0.2244169712,
0.6894133687,
-0.1436402798,
0.237693429,
0.1528433263,
-0.4838804007,
0.1670674682,
0.2041129023,
-0.6644970775,
-0.4076057673,
-0.2793633044,
0.6112545729,
-0.0651735738,
0.8945990801,
0.3051418662,
-0.2456417084,
-0.2046302408,
0.3740296364,
-0.5846013427,
-0.3277426362,
-1.320823431,
-0.1287455261,
0.7318221331,
0.3423016369,
0.4307070374,
0.5577586889,
0.6831820607,
0.3507077396,
-0.1230468228,
0.147976324,
-0.6270785332,
0.3403178453,
0.0028968507,
-0.4952038527,
-0.470227927,
0.416236788,
0.5243943334,
0.1614876539,
-0.061469838,
-0.1758584529,
0.1648962498,
0.3607632816,
-0.0722164139,
0.7812515497,
-0.5300577879,
0.5397543907,
-0.1784357578,
-0.7685703039,
-0.4381682575,
-0.4475091994,
-0.0902605876,
-0.8964979053,
0.3656834066,
0.5025270581,
0.8772544265,
-0.033457581,
-0.1345587671,
-0.5289449096,
-0.3048559427,
0.5511344671,
-0.6117020845,
-0.0060587702,
0.0478314795,
0.3695714474,
-0.7810005546,
-0.8703073859,
-0.577175498,
-0.4736801982,
0.4691977203,
0.510357976,
-0.2170224339,
0.2278188318,
0.2360427082,
0.0779278278,
-0.725092411,
-0.0350317322,
-0.5963631868,
-0.1610875577,
0.5574344993,
0.1230543405,
0.5165883899,
0.0309687983,
-0.1950409561,
-0.1782324165,
-0.7759085894,
0.5674110055,
0.5013688207,
0.6198393703,
0.1285915077,
0.664631784,
-0.1036861613,
0.1947778463,
0.3667279482,
-0.0754932612,
0.234025076,
-0.2980316281,
0.2924831212,
0.3591593504,
0.9792253971,
0.5184959173,
0.097154595,
0.1309942305,
0.0221464057,
-0.2341376841,
0.2102172077,
-0.8977355957,
-0.3398590088,
0.1228774637,
-0.5735383034,
-0.7974644303,
-0.117947787,
-0.6654989123,
-0.512137413,
0.3134691715,
0.2616028488,
-0.5053966045,
-0.3676802516,
0.0589512624,
-0.2069332153,
0.3110484481,
0.3580457568,
-0.8674505353,
-0.066065453,
0.8163561821,
1.0498161316,
-0.0155440969,
-0.5343361497,
-0.5823978186,
-0.0751421675,
-0.5368829966,
0.8223506212,
-0.6997498274,
-0.70744133,
-0.4036986828,
-0.1266428232,
0.3002165556,
-0.1670058072,
0.7502132058,
-0.4197618663,
0.5322063565,
-0.5554050803,
-0.3391126394,
0.0695358664,
0.5633848906,
-0.431535691,
0.6998514533,
-0.1784071624,
-0.8590464592,
0.5811550021,
-1.0112212896,
-0.176913783,
0.7405296564,
-0.3869099617,
-0.1642857492,
-0.1308818758,
0.0130826291,
0.1309289336,
-0.1063287631,
-0.3088787198,
-0.1784814745,
-0.2384846658,
0.0334714428,
-0.1202538535,
0.5665791631,
0.459173739,
-0.1780610234,
0.2421388924,
-0.5032506585,
0.1903069466,
0.2585089803,
-0.2826402783,
0.3751236796,
0.3853541017,
-0.4869322479,
0.3855392635,
0.2390236259,
-1.104005456,
0.3588395417,
-0.4515852332,
0.7568849921,
0.5616316795,
0.2967849076,
0.0429199561,
-0.6257163882,
0.8006138206,
-0.0686588213,
0.2415180206,
-0.1971031576,
-1.0054353476,
-0.2921974659,
-0.103648901,
0.162540257,
0.4343556762,
-0.8300794363,
0.2398115993,
0.0984696969,
-0.6811070442,
-0.1688211411,
-0.5315944552,
0.0840524882,
0.6444270015,
-0.0752808154,
-0.2711866796,
-0.4027420878,
-0.6097549796,
-0.0307223164,
-0.5071491003,
-0.070728533,
0.2654279768,
0.0874815062,
0.3017588556,
0.7649730444,
-0.1175689995,
-0.1788120419,
-0.2427519411,
0.3315214813,
0.3575722575,
0.6627932191,
0.7139849067,
-0.5255571008,
-0.5883175135,
0.0900778323,
-0.6404077411,
-0.2836106122,
0.0645827428,
-0.2444557101,
-0.0534446463,
0.4379323125,
-0.6600316167,
0.0404753089,
0.4042479992,
-0.4879730642,
0.7277027965,
-0.2917618752,
0.7643057704,
-0.8984362483,
-0.0107386215,
-0.1373145431,
-0.2045035362,
-0.5219564438,
0.2223636359,
-0.2121807933,
-0.8242672086,
-0.6379227042,
0.2635362744,
-0.2222495079,
0.2340321988,
-0.3532282114,
0.380181998,
-0.0370144844,
0.4723657668,
-0.0268416423,
0.9525560141,
0.6076171994,
-0.3347998261,
0.5894187093,
0.2537833452,
-0.0628505126,
0.4871835709,
-0.976123929,
0.2142217606,
0.0341983549,
0.3361835778,
-0.9671093822,
0.0569076352,
0.4207449555,
-0.8293117285,
0.017085094,
0.0724167898,
-0.3016432226,
-0.5770618916,
-0.2026415914,
0.3383160233,
0.8273499012,
-0.4159055352,
0.1020594761,
0.160848856,
-0.534190774,
-0.2154727578,
-0.4375627637,
0.2281872481,
-0.1486859024,
-0.9621521831,
0.0115149943,
-0.4578602612,
0.3033434153,
-0.1831280142,
0.0142331971,
0.2730570138,
-0.3122547269,
0.2349477261,
-0.2975904047,
-0.3726613522,
-0.2890500426,
-0.0633445606,
-0.0725694448,
0.3118512034,
-0.3719481826,
0.6191347837,
-0.3980167508,
-0.3613622487,
-0.4283789098,
0.3823593557,
0.259167105,
-0.3749993443,
0.2511820495,
0.257653743,
-0.1160373017,
-0.0719658062,
-0.2010721415,
-0.1379281282,
-0.6348296404,
0.3421500027,
-0.744199276,
-0.9720438719,
0.6698799133,
-0.0903792754,
0.4119181931,
0.3824736774,
0.4822445512,
-0.1617765874,
1.4734354019,
0.4089062512,
0.369685322,
0.2909063697,
0.3068013191,
0.2503439486,
-0.2705832422,
-0.5571004748,
-0.8685818911,
-0.4432377815,
-0.696095407,
-0.1579091102,
0.4650351703,
-0.04420783,
-0.3470411301,
0.0855026096,
-0.9808177352,
0.9013038278,
0.5456787944,
0.2015414536,
0.0268574841,
-0.0538894162,
0.0020697901,
-0.0715219378,
-0.8742513657,
-0.4231359065,
0.6017690897,
0.2568536997,
0.4063783884,
0.0193818975,
0.8830725551,
0.4753755331,
-0.2797411382,
-0.5641601086,
0.7579788566,
0.1160774752,
-0.3444618583,
-0.5132253766,
-0.5404090285,
-1.2803957462,
0.0451175906,
-0.0825701728,
-0.4896334708,
-0.0321911462,
0.0552971885,
-0.3464526236,
0.2438137531,
-0.3286040723,
0.737221837,
-0.0448527113,
-0.1210045815,
0.1339207888,
-0.6029458046,
0.3832480609,
0.0911824554,
0.0202550776,
-0.1018676981,
0.068215251,
0.6590542793,
-0.5869181156,
0.4657952785,
-0.1966746449,
-0.031614732,
0.7140501738,
0.3660918772,
0.5216982961,
0.0910460725,
-0.3259174824,
-0.0836198851,
0.2826349437,
-0.6879429221,
-0.4583903551,
0.6898095608,
-1.1367088556,
-0.7225715518,
-0.6514037251,
-0.3046838343,
0.0461671986,
0.477755338,
0.4192416072,
0.3954191506,
-0.2752117217,
0.2758576572,
0.5012026429,
-0.3200557232,
0.4330342114,
0.3612419963,
-0.2625808418,
-0.2813514769,
1.2412948608,
-0.1825451553,
0.1428131461,
0.2368366569,
0.4768701196,
-0.1408603787,
-0.7046312094,
-0.1434525996,
-0.229951039,
-0.498393327,
-0.099869512,
-0.4808367789,
-0.5770125985,
-0.3645898998,
-0.2100183964,
-0.2569859028,
-0.3016158342,
-0.3003697693,
0.3054255247,
0.0866480991,
0.8546108603,
-0.2506692708,
0.1967785507,
-0.6483045816,
-0.0638302788,
0.2570624948,
0.2315258384,
-0.3262254,
-0.2462781072,
0.1891141087,
0.1330036521,
-0.6128044128,
-0.7065245509,
0.449665457,
0.3366173208,
0.5692054629,
0.3861017823,
0.0396206044,
0.2570011616,
-0.6366938949,
1.4565063715,
0.5520282984,
-0.8263011575,
0.6870507598,
-0.8349040151,
0.2365737855,
0.3642716706,
0.2112593502,
-0.737909019,
-0.6381753683,
-0.5728276968,
-0.4505693018,
0.9423539639,
0.6206259131,
-0.0230450742,
-0.2369240224,
0.5853801966,
0.2696311474,
0.3129296899,
-0.6840070486,
0.095430322,
-0.7526800632,
-0.00368811,
0.3398492038,
-0.0719075203,
-0.0310166068,
0.2042693198,
0.6479726434,
-0.0266248491,
0.3933823109,
0.1584583372,
0.5879935026,
-0.2299193144,
-0.0078077405,
0.9611840844,
0.4081733823,
-0.3079174757,
0.0450117439,
-0.0988375321,
-0.8261654377,
0.2551888227,
-0.3032923937,
-0.1024178788,
-0.3424654305,
0.2452505231,
0.6187121272,
-0.1096395478,
-0.4126922488,
0.4857493043,
-0.447381109,
-0.5911322832,
-0.0182404742,
0.5264837742,
-0.2554089427,
0.4325086772,
0.3625808954,
-0.0102675371,
0.0320814811,
-0.4467125833,
0.147369355,
0.3391203582,
-0.1833637059,
-0.3033303022,
0.9599906802,
0.7115399837,
-0.7809123993,
0.6014565229,
-0.8534510136,
-0.3290222287,
0.9580451846,
0.767124474,
0.7735551596,
-0.1925638169,
0.3555684686,
0.5226768851,
0.2843130231,
-0.0738086402,
0.5896978378,
0.2316481173,
-0.4968856573,
-0.2096559405,
-0.4490906298,
-0.7463021874,
0.1902163923,
-0.1509186029,
0.5517604947,
-0.7251650095,
-0.0904341117,
-0.3230906129,
0.2948157489,
-0.3371456563,
-0.0981272161,
0.1089080125,
1.0045734644,
-0.30760625,
0.2670300901,
0.6737203598,
-0.570645988,
-0.8960000873,
-0.2189536691,
-0.0085283713,
-0.5467059016,
0.6691457033,
0.0035766065,
0.1097421423,
0.2680827081,
-0.9110062122,
-0.9336701035,
1.048050046,
0.0700821057,
-0.4510757923,
-0.2714416981,
0.3562468886,
0.4116415679,
-0.5360386968,
0.6732937694,
0.0794583708,
0.4647781849,
0.6650204062,
-0.907430768,
-0.0547722243,
-0.7476172447,
-0.1159500331,
-0.2007558048,
-1.0114737749,
0.9905151129,
0.112193808,
-0.3484799564,
0.3404967189,
1.0550539494,
0.8841545582,
0.2185391486,
0.4378069639,
0.0325200707,
0.6053009033,
-0.3318611383,
0.5886430144,
-0.6240458488,
0.1169830859,
0.7193980217,
-0.2695957124,
0.2852486968,
0.0256917942,
-0.0753939524,
0.2159921527,
1.0029802322,
-0.2567825019,
0.4963608682,
0.4132399857,
-0.2316847593,
-0.0294835139,
-0.0689936653,
-0.6603949666,
0.3599810898,
0.0878740028,
0.1823469102,
-0.4127326608,
0.1168548614,
-0.1220993325,
-0.2348672748,
-0.304954052,
0.5186305642,
-0.207455337,
-0.5350908637,
0.3952611685,
-0.1438276321,
0.6354396939,
-0.9188893437,
-0.1068341061,
-0.2889241576,
-0.2834306061,
-0.1577336192,
-0.9975606203,
-0.2802486718,
-0.0234835967,
0.0230072439,
-0.192697227,
0.6454778314,
-0.3242988586,
-0.2350870371,
-0.5109360814,
0.0339377671,
0.7227550149,
-0.0091721918,
-0.7894636393,
0.2207504809,
-0.0787795037,
-0.3802960813,
0.1180334166,
1.0024174452,
0.1648097783,
0.6099720001,
0.5173644423,
0.3437781334,
0.2370142937,
-0.0095257945,
0.6472942829,
-0.5182464123,
-1.0125415325,
-0.4723116755,
0.2451507598,
-0.0853996873,
-0.3765457571,
0.83183074,
0.6474193335,
0.3797819614,
0.0011416236,
0.9478464723,
-0.2859495282,
0.0528002568,
-0.1788712144,
0.874219656,
-0.3882283866,
-0.1447646618,
-0.3055272698,
-0.9274870157,
-0.0063327085,
0.4470340312,
0.2815220356,
0.2401176095,
0.6502797604,
0.6598851681,
0.0633585304,
0.5324146748,
0.448466301,
0.0802830756,
1.0855689049,
0.9205818772,
1.0592042208,
-0.1470295042,
0.680343926,
-0.0491954386,
-0.5734602213,
-0.0877575949,
-1.2081133127,
-1.1491193771,
-0.6226207018,
-0.4080817699,
-0.3626481593,
0.0909305364,
1.0282726288,
0.6123904586,
-0.5515078902,
-0.116339609,
-0.4837417901,
-0.2975927293,
-0.0820674673,
-0.2554078698,
0.1333358139,
-0.5611608624,
-0.7002265453,
0.6735717654,
0.362811774,
0.0837382078,
-0.2746663094,
-0.0846467987,
0.0595007725,
0.3001586497,
0.6282411814,
0.7545214891,
-0.4753846228,
-0.6477680206,
0.0459135436,
-0.1747658849,
0.1062118635,
0.7449271083,
-0.5516779423,
0.4224384129,
0.8765457869,
0.345422864,
0.347230047,
0.0041565774,
0.6596848369,
-0.763102293,
0.1955970675,
0.4768343866,
0.064376682,
-0.120433338,
-0.4881544709,
0.4333320558,
0.1921911687,
-1.208335638,
-0.7361025214,
0.3108801842,
-1.1890465021,
-0.0480298437,
1.1246389151,
-0.1595094502,
-0.2307247669,
0.1623023003,
-0.8355204463,
0.3945905864,
-0.6755599976,
0.899005115,
0.7696264386,
-0.7389836907,
-0.4194966257,
-0.2758482099,
0.7063508034,
0.1162327603,
-0.8970409036,
-0.2529730797,
0.2396324873,
0.0463407934,
0.3464469612,
0.5352320075,
-0.2306954414,
0.3293884695,
0.3582825363,
0.4107511342,
-0.6323394179,
-0.0859915614,
0.1263492405,
0.5803735256,
0.2364757806,
-0.3250236809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15655v1 | Joint embedding in Hierarchical distance and semantic representation learning for link prediction | 2023-03-28T00:42:29 | 2023-03-28T00:42:29 | Jin Liu, Jianye Chen, Chongfeng Fan, Fengyu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | The link prediction task aims to predict missing entities or relations in the
knowledge graph and is essential for the downstream application. Existing
well-known models deal with this task by mainly focusing on representing
knowledge graph triplets in the distance space or semantic space. However, they
can not fully capture the information of head and tail entities, nor even make
good use of hierarchical level information. Thus, in this paper, we propose a
novel knowledge graph embedding model for the link prediction task, namely,
HIE, which models each triplet (\textit{h}, \textit{r}, \textit{t}) into
distance measurement space and semantic measurement space, simultaneously.
Moreover, HIE is introduced into hierarchical-aware space to leverage rich
hierarchical information of entities and relations for better representation
learning. Specifically, we apply distance transformation operation on the head
entity in distance space to obtain the tail entity instead of translation-based
or rotation-based approaches. Experimental results of HIE on four real-world
datasets show that HIE outperforms several existing state-of-the-art knowledge
graph embedding methods on the link prediction task and deals with complex
relations accurately. | [
-0.4925507307,
-0.657998383,
0.62658149,
-0.3293273151,
-0.0606335551,
-0.0481903329,
0.1149287373,
-0.9513567686,
0.659229219,
0.2127588242,
-0.6352387071,
-0.7363336086,
-0.7464210391,
-0.2194985449,
0.186866641,
0.7589672208,
-0.193161279,
-0.1354999393,
-0.3427337408,
-0.2077421546,
-0.7400445938,
-0.0691477954,
-0.2152834684,
-0.1467602253,
0.7574738264,
0.1121070385,
0.8411286473,
1.0850006342,
0.4951989949,
0.1775586009,
0.2752677202,
0.2690306604,
-0.4274939001,
0.0606087595,
-0.2192655355,
-0.3328849077,
-0.5853648186,
-0.0815256238,
0.9451971054,
1.2821236849,
0.1939004362,
0.073634617,
0.1542946547,
0.5701415539,
-0.6906271577,
0.7696499825,
-0.5009714961,
0.1697541773,
-0.1848427653,
0.0615528449,
-0.1575293988,
-0.2690698802,
0.3701477647,
-1.0707335472,
-0.1774981618,
0.7124721408,
0.8958628774,
0.2018488199,
-0.6021918058,
0.1028359607,
-0.7128850222,
0.642903626,
-0.4075114131,
0.874334991,
0.1218177602,
0.4863191247,
-0.1643527448,
-0.3973737657,
-0.2750458419,
-0.0472307876,
-0.0502782054,
-0.0337308906,
-0.0799985453,
0.1554353684,
0.0975323692,
0.2141372412,
-0.1598281711,
0.0194391795,
-0.1703741997,
-0.1103969812,
0.1954130083,
0.101615347,
0.2134651691,
-0.2386455387,
-0.6836197972,
-0.1022294536,
-0.7841308117,
-0.3688527644,
0.2936856151,
0.3179466128,
-0.0902431458,
0.3679007292,
-0.1530433744,
0.5143155456,
0.0892869309,
-0.0860368907,
0.2598927915,
0.0573262163,
0.0318010338,
-0.0686414614,
0.6906402111,
0.339814961,
-0.0198822469,
-0.4419809282,
-0.0134020792,
-0.1127879769,
0.0482461564,
-0.5204414725,
-0.2487153113,
-0.2175815403,
-0.5158406496,
0.0393494777,
0.1296358109,
-0.6750409603,
-0.2044276744,
-0.1570242941,
0.5015726686,
-0.5671761632,
-0.4171047807,
0.0452579819,
0.0790773556,
-0.2935923636,
0.2793796659,
-0.7788773179,
0.4952691495,
0.4239608049,
0.6196600199,
-0.2846366763,
-0.795024395,
-0.6171340346,
0.8977602124,
-0.1152218655,
0.5193386674,
-0.5159804225,
-0.0629196614,
0.0801960304,
-0.0911243632,
-0.258394748,
-0.3030388951,
0.065597102,
-0.7711513638,
-0.1193623841,
-0.2173218727,
-0.9133699536,
-0.3680963516,
0.2723928988,
-1.0681090355,
0.8707198501,
0.284768194,
-1.1829091311,
0.4007974565,
-0.7104868293,
-0.1953105778,
0.0519246757,
-0.1244557127,
-0.4837464392,
-0.3304232955,
0.2425104678,
0.6627854109,
-0.1677598953,
0.0521252342,
-0.6868716478,
-0.278109163,
-0.5678605437,
0.1107476652,
0.3542006612,
-0.3351320922,
-0.198492378,
0.067742236,
-0.4778113961,
-0.2993264496,
0.1459085643,
-0.1076014638,
-0.791264832,
0.0971586555,
-0.4138158262,
0.3323619664,
0.4389424622,
-0.7655887008,
0.0893470421,
-0.4950969219,
-0.1925249994,
0.4791803658,
0.2553859949,
0.6191268563,
-0.2347888798,
0.3044849038,
0.4318594337,
0.0742277727,
0.3104557991,
-0.6780722141,
-0.2380360812,
0.2629128993,
0.2980525792,
0.2217236161,
-0.6488921046,
0.5420217514,
-0.6470453739,
-0.3303401172,
-0.3453862369,
-0.0746667683,
0.0663538054,
0.4708303213,
0.6975121498,
0.1120585278,
-0.5526080728,
-0.704423964,
-0.1903357357,
-0.3663930297,
-0.0149950134,
0.2055874914,
0.6998106837,
-0.3731870353,
0.9417254925,
-0.8185788989,
-0.5207479596,
-0.0846985355,
0.0758256391,
-0.1192314178,
0.5493180752,
0.2343256474,
-0.8158029914,
-0.3894115686,
-0.0437313616,
-0.882427156,
0.5195663571,
0.1847292334,
-0.3206878603,
-0.3045067489,
0.3673678339,
-0.5999072194,
0.557769537,
0.562635541,
-0.2558839917,
0.5200036764,
-0.0372583866,
0.0598464049,
-1.380230546,
-0.3084453344,
0.2554053366,
-0.2188622802,
-0.242953822,
-0.0954492241,
0.1306053251,
-0.1170357838,
-0.2450837791,
0.3545949757,
-0.5474922061,
-0.2883274257,
0.0878960788,
0.3347598016,
-0.1325683594,
0.6404640079,
0.1711769551,
0.2004636973,
0.6214566827,
-0.4958069324,
0.3014359176,
0.3240039945,
-0.1893312931,
0.5369271636,
-0.4058558643,
-0.0950879678,
0.0390116461,
0.3512247503,
-0.5218962431,
-0.1994644254,
0.1567308456,
-0.3695853651,
0.3743470907,
-0.242140457,
-0.6342012882,
-0.3864434958,
-0.2958641648,
0.7292585373,
0.3991199434,
-0.6854270101,
0.5619854331,
0.7381772399,
0.2414357662,
-0.43470487,
-0.320984602,
-0.1472480595,
-0.2414093614,
-0.8853719831,
0.8206219077,
0.2278715372,
0.2845028937,
0.4768314362,
-0.1390840113,
0.0220154449,
-0.0652950779,
0.4625663459,
0.3232197165,
-0.3113748133,
0.3088266253,
0.1478358954,
-0.3218005896,
0.3672474921,
-0.6925747991,
0.251534462,
-0.1081876978,
-0.6619715095,
-0.4238920212,
0.4564965367,
0.5073328614,
-0.2830852568,
0.9079413414,
0.7884268165,
-1.0056000948,
0.0471235737,
-0.4665548205,
-0.3461548984,
-0.3618452847,
0.5762650967,
-0.3884276748,
-0.9098700285,
0.4000973403,
-0.4460838735,
-0.2016372383,
0.6604523063,
-0.033931978,
-0.2252792418,
0.9922274947,
0.9237328768,
-0.2163806558,
0.2129275948,
-0.5765676498,
0.4726899564,
-1.0757166147,
-0.5779389143,
-0.300337404,
-0.2059004456,
-0.7984834313,
-0.490321368,
0.7968795896,
0.401837945,
-0.3450366557,
0.5310820341,
-0.0011399778,
0.2188650966,
0.4335978925,
0.2614393532,
0.1958121061,
0.2189915478,
-0.4195983708,
-0.2973249555,
-0.7619454861,
-0.1671039015,
0.6385540366,
0.7755298018,
0.6291178465,
-0.049749136,
1.0965830088,
-0.018660523,
-0.160368368,
-0.8456941247,
0.4575877786,
0.1193063036,
-0.1923601925,
-0.5291094184,
-0.4694401324,
-0.8901103139,
-0.0022309334,
-0.3736281991,
-0.8626155853,
0.193305999,
-0.1475804597,
-0.027181264,
1.068977356,
0.0200063288,
0.809678793,
0.3864487708,
-0.3196229339,
-0.3575397432,
-0.8072766662,
-0.0104649216,
0.0811167583,
0.2195098698,
-0.3263982832,
-0.0386196785,
1.2191925049,
-0.4221536815,
0.7553159595,
-0.3828463554,
0.0563726723,
0.2822437286,
0.3753467202,
0.8104633689,
-0.0600282624,
-0.0397247039,
0.3842683434,
-0.1205991283,
-0.4237243533,
-0.6200573444,
0.797893703,
-0.6547404528,
-0.4755115509,
-0.1377973109,
-0.7930229902,
-0.736607492,
0.3533442318,
-0.1011163518,
0.3557587564,
-0.0610736497,
0.1009404361,
0.4736415744,
0.0309910458,
0.1693162918,
-0.0334821381,
0.0007889188,
-0.413607806,
0.771140635,
-0.0403312072,
0.1501484066,
0.8144546151,
0.3671440184,
-0.6315613389,
-0.3536680341,
-0.4171271026,
0.4940336347,
-0.7978832126,
-0.3419178724,
-0.7403847575,
-0.1684803069,
-0.2918052375,
-0.1738115996,
-0.4505027831,
-0.2108076662,
-0.0126627618,
-0.0855517015,
0.266054213,
1.193469882,
-0.168100521,
0.0053808042,
-0.9169804454,
0.0522756577,
0.2887276113,
0.5827023983,
0.3507646322,
0.1318564862,
-0.7918711901,
0.267306,
-0.2643141747,
-1.0249824524,
0.1262460202,
-0.1285701096,
0.5001260638,
0.0420417935,
0.0125275766,
0.7947717309,
-0.5368542671,
0.5907605886,
0.5618103147,
-0.5906088352,
0.5515472889,
-0.486321032,
-0.036604099,
0.268950671,
0.8701416254,
-0.2723234892,
-0.2011038661,
-0.5872049332,
-0.5065891743,
0.3859485686,
0.1430327296,
-0.277972877,
-0.1071987599,
0.1377197951,
0.071177803,
0.0153607847,
-0.6144917607,
-0.3395827413,
0.1667792648,
-0.091573447,
0.6047537327,
-0.0488300957,
0.4193472564,
-0.3228317201,
0.6174276471,
-0.1701284051,
0.5537027121,
-0.1559789777,
0.0492411703,
-0.4996748269,
-0.1474473029,
-0.5973515511,
0.6464745402,
-0.419567734,
0.0321002081,
0.3862410784,
-0.2254040986,
-0.0048624175,
0.1279241294,
0.2654345036,
0.0850500092,
0.6638140082,
0.7251093388,
0.6135812402,
0.1175150052,
0.7889320254,
0.4219048917,
0.0261278674,
-0.0549711399,
-0.3662374318,
0.3982172012,
0.1258056909,
0.049753841,
0.1717397422,
0.3060275316,
-0.3889189363,
0.2189132422,
0.1234144717,
-0.5998492837,
-0.2415302247,
0.8070167899,
0.1161256284,
0.0724032521,
0.6478165984,
-0.1439432204,
-0.4963727295,
0.5349977612,
0.6839857101,
0.8143618107,
-0.3427779078,
0.1579774022,
0.6862892509,
-0.1651866287,
0.1411823183,
0.0392082967,
-0.0694577172,
-0.6396791935,
-0.2657808065,
-0.7847220302,
-0.1657059193,
-0.2724150121,
-0.7361767292,
0.2754234672,
-0.1862230599,
0.0684266686,
-0.1101936921,
0.1303690225,
-0.9182480574,
0.0829933807,
0.0564856268,
0.6977299452,
-0.7708804607,
1.0536922216,
0.7668276429,
-0.4524964094,
-0.9505966902,
0.2821180224,
-0.2799871862,
-0.5963231325,
0.8160718679,
0.279604584,
-0.4394201934,
0.0554079898,
0.0191834904,
-1.0709300041,
1.3899987936,
0.2175107896,
-0.4730278254,
-0.6689204574,
0.3041504025,
0.18659468,
-0.6911354065,
-0.0801337957,
0.1351942271,
0.2596597373,
0.0324827209,
-0.8673644662,
0.2216521204,
0.1012719795,
0.4331812263,
0.4496786594,
-0.240921855,
0.659432888,
-0.3445771039,
-0.1807750762,
-0.2582683861,
0.8290798068,
0.2018079013,
0.19378151,
0.7419814467,
0.5723054409,
0.6067928672,
0.094670482,
0.9430597425,
-0.3021112978,
0.5341534019,
1.0841338634,
-0.2354057431,
1.0277283192,
0.2207711637,
-0.1956799179,
0.9064541459,
0.4998432696,
0.2416188419,
0.4906374216,
-0.1218674853,
-0.0913471431,
-0.2405367792,
-0.3557443321,
-0.4075479209,
0.223012507,
0.5029745698,
-0.175695315,
-0.345972389,
-0.1101925671,
-0.1058502346,
0.048150558,
-0.2625030875,
0.6900427341,
0.0777654201,
-0.2520122826,
0.4589910805,
0.0329684801,
0.4516802132,
-0.4315507412,
-0.3522884846,
0.2851397097,
-0.1087016761,
-0.2402976602,
-0.8083106875,
0.4069927037,
-0.8067369461,
-0.212767601,
0.1067147329,
0.7806480527,
-0.5364003181,
-0.1648264825,
0.9428545833,
0.6617673039,
-0.1539915502,
-0.0984957367,
-0.6636901498,
-0.2376217544,
-0.2905400097,
0.08293809,
0.3697965443,
0.4681078792,
-0.1502598524,
0.5327469707,
0.2608900368,
0.0669215173,
0.0511226393,
-0.1119961962,
0.7296802998,
-0.7079591751,
-0.8250657916,
-0.5486790538,
0.2108336985,
-0.0492221341,
0.1502852589,
0.6522102356,
0.5204530358,
0.9030267596,
-0.1893843859,
0.55989784,
-0.0177459717,
0.3585778475,
-0.485046804,
0.4364621341,
-0.6449443102,
0.0767967775,
-0.4984372854,
-1.1934463978,
-0.2656542063,
0.2524971962,
-0.4467811286,
0.1935677975,
1.1438286304,
0.6917007565,
-0.3552395105,
0.1178650856,
0.493817389,
0.0042190775,
0.0866557732,
1.0750015974,
0.715665102,
-0.6610600352,
0.4075343013,
-0.7042599916,
-0.0013246125,
-0.0326081887,
-0.8111618757,
-0.8992757797,
-1.059043169,
-0.5593492985,
-0.2864729166,
0.1715779155,
0.9679869413,
1.0724829435,
-0.4334861934,
-0.1958949268,
-0.0481145568,
0.1926461756,
-0.2065888941,
-0.1697374731,
0.8220815659,
-0.0127838105,
-0.565115273,
0.2782833576,
0.4719493091,
0.1179398373,
-0.3187898397,
-0.3231101632,
-0.3603763878,
-0.5050012469,
0.4764642715,
-0.162890926,
-0.6934680939,
-0.6035634279,
-0.3877973855,
0.110849157,
0.2160174996,
0.4128145576,
-0.8052282929,
0.2627162933,
0.5322335362,
0.7770919204,
0.5423882008,
-0.2379624099,
0.4844609499,
-0.7605186105,
-0.2422597855,
0.2335155755,
0.7135887742,
0.2845039666,
-0.6098953485,
0.4556447566,
0.3822169304,
-0.2198996693,
-0.1697092056,
0.3041359186,
-0.7420771122,
-0.0364934132,
0.9481412172,
-0.4630059898,
-0.4160674214,
-0.0828744397,
0.2816320062,
0.6862100363,
-0.2080927789,
0.4620988965,
0.2754640877,
-0.0084517263,
0.2060470283,
-0.4764371812,
0.2373415381,
0.1071478948,
-0.7496628165,
-0.1429745257,
0.4425966442,
0.3187296987,
0.2685109675,
0.172051698,
-0.2573991418,
0.2280645669,
0.1525748521,
-0.0314731151,
-0.2581421137,
-0.6368162036,
0.1966875941,
0.3339178264,
0.1635699272,
-0.4010590613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15647v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15647v1 | Scaling Down to Scale Up: A Guide to Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning | 2023-03-28T00:06:38 | 2023-03-28T00:06:38 | Vladislav Lialin, Vijeta Deshpande, Anna Rumshisky | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a systematic overview and comparison of
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods covering over 40 papers published
between February 2019 and February 2023. These methods aim to resolve the
infeasibility and impracticality of fine-tuning large language models by only
training a small set of parameters. We provide a taxonomy that covers a broad
range of methods and present a detailed method comparison with a specific focus
on real-life efficiency and fine-tuning multibillion-scale language models. | [
-0.6896307468,
-0.7477472425,
0.3119115531,
-0.0115266768,
-0.2035469413,
-0.2685834765,
-0.6952523589,
-0.3421078622,
-0.2867241204,
0.4256715178,
-0.6493396163,
-0.2794736624,
-0.4585615695,
0.0562922135,
-0.1994397789,
0.8685072064,
0.1812451631,
0.0917949826,
0.1121680662,
-0.1790627837,
0.0232910831,
-0.1032861993,
-1.3080688715,
-0.2810619175,
0.6161335707,
0.6635371447,
0.6953188777,
0.9298103452,
0.6831392646,
0.2524706721,
-0.5209605694,
0.2612380087,
-0.7081150413,
-0.0809147656,
-0.1329310089,
-0.300599277,
-0.4551097751,
0.0035798724,
0.8813220263,
0.8012780547,
-0.2264748216,
0.6674844027,
0.0893737376,
0.9025609493,
-0.7456784248,
0.1457097679,
-0.6811951399,
-0.4225817025,
-0.1854776144,
-0.1315784454,
-0.4937993884,
-0.3671754599,
-0.3058879673,
-0.5133038163,
0.2425440401,
0.0143141029,
0.8851127028,
0.3394381404,
-0.1650747061,
-0.2768525183,
-0.6818366647,
1.0822650194,
-0.9753894806,
0.5628613234,
0.4289563,
0.3827012777,
0.2211673707,
-0.8034924269,
-0.2095230669,
-0.4447591603,
0.0322745293,
-0.3613990843,
-0.0392308757,
0.3677324653,
0.5575915575,
0.4530090988,
-0.2935643494,
0.3861855567,
-0.3155884147,
-0.0977699012,
0.6563362479,
0.2001587749,
0.1250157058,
0.1228221729,
0.2827397585,
-0.2399166375,
-0.7039333582,
-0.0410328992,
0.4225873649,
0.7485858202,
0.1111414656,
0.2430882007,
-0.3461279571,
1.1212149858,
0.2420892119,
-0.3976271451,
-0.3283138871,
-0.6982278228,
-0.3648993671,
-0.4503521621,
0.4054091871,
0.4482047856,
0.2394625396,
-0.3264223039,
-0.1110882238,
-0.315823257,
0.2911065519,
-1.0103986263,
-0.2563214898,
-0.1248615235,
-0.6520835757,
-0.2264225185,
-0.4780020118,
-0.7622376084,
-0.2876978219,
-0.5336849093,
0.393761456,
-0.0969119221,
-0.0730288178,
0.2011726499,
-0.1349514872,
0.1563979536,
0.4159909487,
-1.0765140057,
0.3060287535,
0.6190914512,
0.85881567,
0.2771095335,
-0.3016389608,
-0.5666858554,
-0.1628352255,
-0.3846550286,
0.5665499568,
-0.5847383142,
-0.0706504807,
-0.1442077756,
-0.1012211144,
-0.0297013652,
-0.675342977,
0.6737480164,
-0.4143961668,
-0.1838279963,
-0.4488224089,
-0.3713615239,
-0.3709058166,
0.0610046089,
-0.496006608,
1.0609853268,
0.0808247849,
-0.5403509736,
0.6943692565,
-0.5803126693,
-0.2482037991,
-0.3144627213,
0.2603352964,
-0.457524389,
0.1028505713,
0.1181798801,
0.6198813319,
-0.7481741309,
0.0017869626,
-0.5467158556,
-0.2198076546,
-0.5007956028,
-0.2955841124,
0.8623226881,
0.4769801497,
-0.1566649973,
0.2086398005,
-1.1738616228,
0.2916848361,
-0.1777804196,
-0.4162930548,
-0.453928262,
0.0325340517,
0.0410491191,
0.2070906013,
0.3476886749,
-0.3928843737,
0.358135879,
-0.4750550389,
0.9710327387,
0.3422064185,
-0.1452602446,
0.5495160222,
-0.3190372586,
0.3127973676,
-0.4052894711,
0.411138624,
-0.1864278466,
-0.1790208519,
-0.9258303046,
-0.3459919095,
0.6114766598,
0.1481412053,
-0.1362187117,
0.3737814426,
0.0055340338,
-0.9402390718,
-0.5700665712,
0.3234416842,
0.4516591132,
0.427099824,
0.4179045856,
0.1220555454,
-0.3669755757,
-0.9983284473,
-0.5204482079,
0.0040379642,
-0.0306410827,
0.2051918805,
0.3764019012,
0.024518488,
0.3283434808,
-0.3981803358,
0.0694426969,
-0.106042631,
0.3501381576,
-0.0345001295,
0.525408268,
0.6463480592,
-0.4562705755,
-0.6258071661,
0.2834400237,
-0.1491732895,
0.0940359235,
0.006716508,
0.0903510079,
-0.0202501938,
1.0369921923,
-0.1465412974,
0.0791057572,
0.5911499262,
-0.232934311,
0.203167811,
-0.6284154654,
0.2348794639,
-0.9965986013,
0.0962184146,
0.1192247644,
-0.2534011006,
-0.7542970181,
0.4579401314,
0.564481914,
-0.1514631212,
-0.3379331231,
0.5715546608,
-0.626164794,
0.2131921202,
-0.1043684185,
-0.0176423304,
-0.1908269227,
0.4441159964,
-0.3142291903,
0.7884307504,
0.5446000695,
-0.7441679835,
0.1262113154,
-0.1001060158,
-0.270316273,
0.336351186,
-0.5446289778,
0.0627532899,
-0.0541601107,
-0.1471493095,
-1.033348918,
0.018262716,
-0.0271018296,
-0.197250396,
0.6685624719,
-0.2519634366,
-0.74271667,
-0.2164148092,
-0.5007533431,
0.3503905237,
0.4977516234,
-0.6006416082,
0.4240297377,
0.3088945746,
-0.1819740832,
-0.2528882921,
-0.6087992191,
-0.0811684355,
-0.5759365559,
-0.5436317325,
0.1784736961,
-0.2385884225,
-0.2152713388,
-0.5622764826,
-0.0895877555,
-0.1311455965,
0.2838654816,
-0.2818550766,
-0.4718110263,
-0.2525312304,
0.2198589891,
0.2306772172,
-0.0511740223,
-0.1981237382,
-0.2034750581,
0.4333830178,
-0.3557615578,
-0.0760348588,
-0.3931370676,
0.2272888124,
0.537920773,
-0.2613848448,
0.6055153012,
0.4309207797,
-0.279392153,
-0.1028951928,
-0.5634203553,
-0.2711300254,
-0.5390123725,
0.4173945487,
-0.434130162,
-0.7412292361,
0.7354277372,
-0.4648465812,
0.2299840152,
0.6485906243,
0.6414009333,
0.2409925759,
1.3792666197,
0.936042428,
0.0935187489,
0.4919065833,
-0.259942174,
0.0886457115,
-0.7127296925,
0.1193661466,
-1.2840846777,
-0.4224342704,
-0.9980814457,
-0.2044704556,
0.001590313,
0.4842012525,
-0.5640484095,
0.5869527459,
-0.5888620615,
0.6911043525,
0.4611510932,
-0.0855184421,
0.4926182926,
-0.1812586337,
0.0082451263,
-0.0908018127,
-0.8509055972,
-0.4496481121,
1.0653949976,
0.3963585794,
0.8548282981,
-0.0132718161,
0.4926595986,
0.0293015279,
0.1336916238,
-0.9355267286,
0.4019883871,
-0.3529182076,
-0.8013753295,
-0.9200643301,
-0.387911886,
-0.6776753664,
0.1737778485,
0.1060391814,
-0.8705071807,
0.3788786232,
0.2933336794,
-0.3347902596,
0.6363803744,
-0.9617654681,
0.7931621075,
0.0380770229,
-0.1788934171,
-0.4781519175,
-0.5842899084,
-0.0080839107,
-0.2866977751,
0.1543512493,
-0.2371322811,
-0.3016394973,
0.7428975701,
-0.3556465507,
0.722922802,
-0.194929719,
-0.2683891058,
-0.1705280244,
-0.0207786486,
0.4324544072,
0.1413343102,
-0.3937210441,
0.2582389712,
0.282695055,
-0.6273549795,
-0.5893893838,
0.6967169642,
-0.6069552898,
-0.1582706124,
0.0493872948,
-0.5310254097,
-0.4005732834,
0.5757617354,
0.3389295042,
0.6165425777,
0.0179161616,
0.3395508826,
0.7257646918,
0.0472655557,
0.5735633969,
0.6326574087,
-0.0104919858,
-0.2941576242,
0.934992671,
0.490401268,
0.4426609278,
0.6727385521,
0.2939317822,
-0.2321068347,
-0.8435745835,
-0.534578979,
0.3622446358,
-0.6122963428,
-0.2249975801,
-0.2201537043,
0.1140274853,
-0.3919380009,
-0.3152751923,
-0.6681449413,
-0.5418414474,
-0.2837537527,
0.1554330885,
0.4755470753,
0.5411244035,
-0.1872966439,
0.5319563746,
-0.55337888,
0.233498916,
0.260930568,
0.7005109191,
0.09229967,
-0.8996406794,
-0.620677948,
0.0663713291,
-0.3241323829,
-0.4473804832,
0.2206765264,
0.601413846,
0.5729359388,
0.6357133985,
-0.0456643663,
0.9200246334,
-0.462339431,
0.7324796319,
-0.0263923202,
-1.0283486843,
0.7947478294,
-0.4569478929,
0.3875875771,
0.8726474047,
0.6021545529,
-0.2330634296,
-0.2641364038,
-0.6777681708,
-0.9477697015,
0.7355256081,
-0.1706978679,
0.0918431133,
0.4006083608,
0.7295223475,
0.2332201004,
0.1249975339,
-0.1880008429,
-0.4331409931,
0.3672879338,
0.0558597259,
-0.5373084545,
-0.3512726724,
-0.1992318034,
-0.7989753485,
0.7415287495,
-0.372336328,
-0.082182169,
-0.3345232904,
-0.0850430056,
-0.2414090186,
0.2474202812,
0.9225564003,
1.0386177301,
-0.4158826768,
-0.0688855648,
0.5600695014,
-0.381806761,
0.1014154553,
0.0693514422,
-0.217381373,
-0.2833019793,
0.1672865897,
0.855214715,
0.5440360308,
-0.3549789488,
-0.0125021534,
-0.2405406982,
-0.5533047318,
0.1268156469,
0.1702849567,
0.1758569479,
0.1718827337,
0.0080821598,
0.0512650125,
0.2820682526,
-0.3827942014,
0.0221450869,
0.3605422974,
-0.5262765288,
-0.1613727808,
0.5557994843,
0.2264022976,
-0.4410505295,
0.4645979404,
-0.1070885137,
0.4035860896,
0.4054495096,
0.2591343224,
0.7381750345,
-0.0494863838,
-0.041074004,
0.4707346261,
0.4665165246,
-0.4291317165,
0.2397395223,
-0.2383939475,
-0.3965954185,
-0.5866976976,
-0.6298661232,
-0.5941414833,
0.4774550498,
-0.9793359041,
0.3586519957,
-0.4354583025,
-0.2444573343,
0.50890553,
0.4561232328,
-0.5096162558,
0.2881121933,
-0.2211624682,
1.4290235043,
-0.7951763868,
0.7818642855,
1.0135015249,
-0.4128614068,
-0.9142692685,
0.1389100999,
-0.1400899589,
-0.6689700484,
0.335816592,
-0.1623216122,
-0.2377373278,
0.42643857,
-0.5111189485,
-0.7981596589,
0.976213634,
0.6520558596,
-0.6175009012,
-0.2767181993,
-0.1173214316,
0.6297119856,
-0.0285414942,
0.4900496602,
0.9562295079,
0.7996734977,
-0.1373618245,
-1.1656723022,
-0.068027176,
-0.0308903567,
0.2962830663,
0.478515029,
-1.0525510311,
0.7501966953,
-0.0295463633,
-0.0739795119,
0.089909181,
0.4706972837,
-0.2252286375,
0.1213478372,
0.4279457927,
0.6728768349,
0.8579527736,
-0.2136828154,
0.8413920403,
-0.5661444664,
0.6683567762,
0.8399752975,
0.3331773579,
0.8510591388,
0.4870949984,
-0.3739664853,
-0.043294955,
0.8039196134,
0.0867357776,
0.481687814,
0.402633667,
0.1576293111,
-0.4318219423,
0.2173083574,
-0.2841434479,
0.3013246357,
0.2955526114,
-0.2064669728,
-0.6737424731,
0.0327277742,
0.1149147823,
0.0207836255,
-0.7841638923,
0.9806835651,
-0.0084725292,
-0.5602099895,
1.0977600813,
0.194659695,
0.7131637335,
-0.4795837998,
0.2595527768,
-0.3160653412,
0.3526445627,
0.0334295668,
-0.3160366714,
0.3520543277,
-0.0834106058,
-0.3887895048,
-0.4085893333,
0.6418420076,
-0.2820059061,
-0.4753572941,
0.2232811004,
0.2988442481,
0.0293391328,
-0.1593589783,
-0.8886536956,
-0.1681104749,
-0.0119060995,
-0.3672096729,
0.4842854142,
0.4466903806,
0.1707585007,
0.8999184966,
0.2760925293,
0.3772465885,
-0.0242617484,
0.0870969146,
0.6815498471,
-0.7757601142,
-0.3906294703,
-0.7755784392,
0.4255936742,
0.0268543754,
-0.5660036206,
0.7363911271,
0.4628843069,
1.1220514774,
-0.0323745497,
0.5364742279,
0.1054310948,
0.767795682,
-0.4260000288,
0.758159101,
-0.9379512072,
0.1952296942,
-0.0634688064,
-0.5167192817,
-0.3950513601,
0.5036056638,
-0.3039355576,
0.2513687015,
0.5079377294,
1.0229029655,
-0.2048528641,
-0.0598599799,
0.5196037292,
0.1438693851,
0.1296855956,
-0.112344116,
0.4011365175,
-0.3720867634,
0.6198785901,
-0.3671087623,
-0.2830354869,
-0.5440517664,
-1.0665819645,
-0.8028342724,
-0.7437278628,
-0.3962394595,
-0.0696091875,
0.1804802269,
0.5375481844,
1.1483477354,
-0.9488830566,
-0.3138820529,
-0.3662086427,
0.0102556143,
-0.6145293117,
-0.1433655918,
0.2134142965,
-0.6837920547,
-0.8104465604,
0.1873783171,
0.2927833498,
-0.2777045667,
-0.5122693777,
0.0944971815,
-0.062856935,
0.3521695733,
0.5821301937,
0.444042325,
-0.4414063096,
-0.2371144891,
-0.1546158344,
0.0155286603,
0.0639171079,
0.8510314226,
-0.1997355372,
0.3168945611,
0.7176342607,
0.4174464047,
0.5502821207,
-0.2529121935,
0.4208158255,
-0.703992188,
0.003803063,
0.0490389951,
-0.0232227445,
0.1443072408,
-0.1732196808,
0.4779617786,
-0.2536566854,
-0.9222965837,
-0.9183330536,
0.2128464282,
-0.8930574656,
-0.3407637477,
1.0916187763,
0.0371105969,
0.0328181498,
0.0598929375,
-0.3099075258,
0.2653941214,
-0.3293442428,
0.8183450103,
0.6263440847,
-0.2897712588,
-0.257388711,
-0.6133950949,
0.9691392183,
0.3118290603,
-0.7263066769,
0.497610718,
0.1452894211,
0.284720391,
0.09510912,
0.3235738277,
0.0006752158,
0.0186615568,
0.1258277446,
-0.1968653053,
0.0348099247,
-0.3346005678,
-0.5624161959,
0.1114455611,
0.6569126844,
0.143562451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15621v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15621v2 | ChatGPT as a Factual Inconsistency Evaluator for Text Summarization | 2023-03-27T22:30:39 | 2023-04-13T10:59:39 | Zheheng Luo, Qianqian Xie, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL | The performance of text summarization has been greatly boosted by pre-trained
language models. A main concern of existing methods is that most generated
summaries are not factually inconsistent with their source documents. To
alleviate the problem, many efforts have focused on developing effective
factuality evaluation metrics based on natural language inference, question
answering, and syntactic dependency et al. However, these approaches are
limited by either their high computational complexity or the uncertainty
introduced by multi-component pipelines, resulting in only partial agreement
with human judgement. Most recently, large language models(LLMs) have shown
excellent performance in not only text generation but also language
comprehension. In this paper, we particularly explore ChatGPT's ability to
evaluate factual inconsistency under a zero-shot setting by examining it on
both coarse-grained and fine-grained evaluation tasks including binary
entailment inference, summary ranking, and consistency rating. Experimental
results indicate that ChatGPT generally outperforms previous evaluation metrics
across the three tasks, indicating its great potential for factual
inconsistency evaluation. However, a closer inspection of ChatGPT's output
reveals certain limitations including its preference for more lexically similar
candidates, false reasoning, and inadequate understanding of instructions. | [
-0.1819412261,
-0.9918372631,
0.6481195688,
0.2370306998,
-0.1595991254,
0.1997035593,
-0.2799516618,
-0.2359556407,
-0.0535868853,
0.0581054054,
-0.2601078749,
-0.3921153247,
-0.9326930642,
0.0990408361,
-0.438755095,
1.7533318996,
-0.0122920936,
-0.2357352823,
-0.1888543814,
-0.1854487956,
-0.5308733582,
-0.4435735941,
-0.4516023099,
-0.2693953216,
0.3169185519,
0.4461371303,
0.8007227778,
0.2211580127,
0.7274351716,
0.2321489155,
-0.0866903514,
0.1580286175,
-0.7100355029,
0.0914772376,
-0.0728282332,
-0.305919677,
-0.2882731855,
0.0109140277,
0.6436445117,
0.4505044818,
-0.1553604007,
0.1491978616,
0.1012992635,
0.6178067327,
-0.6941457391,
0.3947947323,
-0.8385981917,
0.2127557993,
0.0419827215,
-0.2128848583,
-0.2978928387,
-0.6144325733,
0.3643881679,
-0.177153334,
0.7269321084,
-0.0381748416,
1.0276321173,
0.3282020688,
-0.4731736481,
-0.4725939929,
-0.7770436406,
0.4506575763,
-1.0094535351,
0.2064983547,
0.104916431,
0.2369827777,
-0.0219830759,
-0.4999105632,
-0.7154151797,
-0.5199980736,
-0.2417449355,
0.5496599674,
-0.0647517219,
0.1866094321,
0.3526191413,
0.5564394593,
-0.8677627444,
-0.1557586938,
-0.260948211,
-0.3272762895,
0.4288884401,
0.1649091393,
0.3710201383,
-0.4640731514,
-0.3412189484,
0.0491482653,
-0.5618159771,
0.0845379382,
0.3775463402,
0.2096175849,
-0.4283999503,
1.0044188499,
-0.3683408201,
0.4549531639,
-0.0294757634,
-0.1808405071,
-0.0395029932,
-0.6006698608,
-0.3710927367,
0.2824496329,
0.8996136785,
0.3219918907,
0.1495677829,
-0.237259239,
0.0606415495,
0.1270324439,
0.1597260982,
-0.9246086478,
-0.4709390402,
0.4252258241,
-0.1041037217,
-0.2444643676,
0.0695696846,
-0.5363399982,
-0.3371981978,
-0.1978604198,
0.5621277094,
-0.7130502462,
-0.1458697021,
0.0327837355,
-0.3135365546,
0.2613114119,
0.5450237393,
-0.8867832422,
0.046397496,
0.7463462353,
0.879660964,
-0.0604111962,
-0.3248435855,
-0.482303232,
-0.1318203211,
-0.3185106218,
1.1894462109,
-0.3384034336,
-0.2460720837,
-0.2719134688,
-0.2595062852,
-0.4430685341,
-0.1571920514,
0.7778680921,
-0.2330662459,
0.3721862137,
-0.255779773,
-0.7814872861,
-0.2973041832,
0.597440362,
-0.2626956403,
0.9124463797,
-0.0213495977,
-1.0845086575,
0.5973409414,
-0.4473829865,
-0.3362986743,
-0.0231444072,
-0.2809017003,
-0.5607878566,
0.0603245944,
0.0350152589,
0.3859664798,
-0.0242547952,
0.3994091451,
-0.1133484021,
-0.6787360907,
0.3095601499,
-0.9604049325,
0.5356509686,
-0.0113789104,
-0.2726592124,
-0.021620864,
-0.6794429421,
-0.1405906826,
-0.043148499,
-0.4479334354,
0.1194179058,
-0.0150568215,
-0.3020869792,
-0.046859514,
0.1502021551,
-0.570204854,
-0.0227905475,
-0.4729732573,
0.0812921524,
0.3944472373,
0.362562418,
0.1281764358,
-0.5131398439,
0.370251894,
-0.1738512963,
-0.254668802,
-0.4869722724,
-0.5482659936,
-0.8372517824,
-0.264361918,
0.4108493328,
0.8167811036,
-0.7215764523,
0.2617743909,
-0.5015019774,
-0.6984639168,
-0.0793102607,
-0.183534801,
0.4996142685,
0.5684880018,
0.0977056846,
-0.1846306324,
-0.2970604599,
-0.7238169312,
-0.3867304027,
-0.4254714847,
-0.1478121132,
0.0459502228,
0.5951185226,
0.117468439,
1.0049312115,
-0.4082171321,
0.0025390231,
-0.2619334459,
0.5139063597,
0.3274652064,
0.3203580976,
0.4035058916,
-0.4227834046,
-0.4959669113,
0.0524407625,
-0.7719994187,
0.0540573075,
-0.3079695404,
0.1201655045,
0.3184873462,
0.1622340232,
-0.853536725,
0.6290105581,
0.4845746458,
-0.294960767,
1.0008045435,
-0.4453735948,
0.5095819235,
-0.6365007758,
0.0497702695,
-0.0349844359,
-0.2914623916,
-0.4953727722,
-0.0974608958,
0.0346284062,
-0.1273230612,
-0.2757969797,
0.2339803278,
-0.2210453302,
0.0583789609,
-0.1365893781,
0.5520535707,
0.0968209729,
0.5756552219,
-0.1365638822,
0.859744072,
0.1304269135,
-0.4769999683,
0.2810489237,
0.2892209888,
-0.3424183428,
0.6288489103,
-0.7981387377,
-0.0640010908,
-0.2648559809,
0.2833475769,
-1.495896697,
-0.4393893182,
0.3688857555,
-0.6111922264,
0.441742599,
-0.3709487617,
-0.4335199296,
0.1612711102,
-0.4360951781,
0.248549521,
0.3328378499,
-0.2628627121,
0.2037674636,
0.1047909856,
-0.3583586514,
-0.6132230163,
-0.5465216041,
0.25767079,
0.0335955247,
-0.6239010096,
-0.103453517,
0.0078538805,
-0.2468989193,
-0.0332428403,
-0.3843610287,
-0.0246416647,
-0.1883471608,
0.0828140154,
0.3463275731,
-0.3145442307,
0.2178164124,
-0.0972537398,
-0.013855136,
-0.123295784,
0.0972535536,
0.3009388447,
-0.235760659,
-0.6986144185,
-0.1932366788,
-0.0389740542,
0.3390664458,
-0.0802837163,
0.6274408698,
0.5196310878,
0.0710592493,
0.1284353882,
-0.7352082729,
0.1711507291,
-0.2946217954,
0.4461164474,
-0.1612162292,
-0.909275651,
0.4044232666,
0.3549045622,
0.2864658833,
0.5420095921,
0.509157598,
-0.0322089046,
0.5478130579,
0.360909164,
0.2166168541,
0.1162101999,
0.1606038511,
0.4659056067,
-0.5854198337,
-0.0146265356,
-0.5424326062,
0.0789347142,
-0.8304504156,
-0.3040875793,
0.5288324356,
-0.1866145432,
-0.2223688215,
0.1726202965,
-0.2241576016,
0.5269284844,
0.1684713215,
0.0226967651,
0.5462570786,
-0.0251061395,
-0.0280209128,
0.0405270793,
-0.793487668,
-0.5844345093,
0.9703524709,
0.2789115608,
0.5358117819,
0.2673684657,
0.2836313248,
0.4081799388,
0.2939467728,
-0.8784197569,
0.233008638,
-0.0909050256,
-0.5562978387,
-0.4392256439,
-0.5610090494,
-0.6680105925,
0.5712748766,
-0.3908999264,
-0.7349156737,
-0.1495836228,
0.1556797028,
-0.4151770771,
0.1796063185,
-1.0476241112,
0.9547061324,
0.1131892428,
-0.1967339665,
0.0635697916,
-0.5460177064,
0.8447090983,
-0.0545510575,
0.0277958345,
-0.3291705251,
0.1694279164,
0.3214070201,
-0.4176248908,
0.7348889112,
0.145286113,
-0.1305948645,
0.3184123635,
0.3049707115,
0.5259176493,
0.2260988802,
0.0676782504,
0.2787826955,
0.1779950708,
-0.4729273021,
-0.6598132253,
0.3691682816,
-0.4844370484,
-0.5045528412,
-0.6329641342,
-0.5358507633,
-0.4217362404,
-0.0368169472,
0.5517530441,
0.6462266445,
-0.458864361,
0.1053546965,
0.7367224097,
-0.3618339598,
0.4293240905,
0.4671865702,
-0.1922129989,
-0.1257915497,
0.9893596768,
0.1902914494,
0.4240201116,
0.4142301977,
0.0897024125,
-0.1401103288,
-0.5383253098,
-0.6471320391,
0.1675087065,
-0.5935705304,
-0.1040972471,
-0.6942875385,
-0.6380693316,
-0.2623518109,
0.0904465318,
-0.3591876924,
-0.6898466349,
0.2875299454,
-0.1744321734,
0.1550022066,
0.6957481503,
0.1365564167,
0.4023365974,
-0.891564846,
0.3301773071,
0.2822532356,
0.3423097432,
-0.1138296202,
-0.839347899,
-0.1907982379,
0.0622765571,
-0.3740157187,
-0.760956347,
0.0050626495,
0.1894127578,
0.3013065457,
0.3427157998,
0.0047020568,
0.4587935507,
-0.5493386388,
0.9902275205,
0.1500626951,
-0.8509336114,
0.2795424461,
-0.4934929907,
0.5227136016,
0.4752803743,
0.0035838941,
-0.6859390736,
-0.7544045448,
-0.8179426193,
-0.5843833089,
0.6737615466,
0.8107004762,
0.0940195248,
0.0243756436,
0.1729213893,
0.2411098927,
0.2792728245,
-0.4855293334,
-0.1783028841,
-0.2540072501,
-0.0605432466,
0.0333410986,
-0.5404154062,
0.0716216937,
0.1137347817,
0.8179212809,
-0.0600205511,
0.2476655692,
0.349717617,
-0.0821101815,
0.1882380843,
0.5297040343,
0.7010304332,
0.9306332469,
-0.4298303425,
0.2009972334,
0.4483675957,
-0.6551530361,
0.055482816,
0.1379971653,
-0.2525639832,
0.3559754491,
0.7526441813,
0.6909782887,
0.3509089351,
-0.6500968933,
0.8336024284,
-0.3087849021,
-0.132333383,
-0.1563398838,
0.1652431488,
-0.1102676094,
-0.026962135,
0.1219929755,
0.3744718432,
0.2171917707,
-0.4715305865,
0.135463208,
0.455150038,
-0.3836558461,
-0.2514774799,
0.4156094491,
-0.0715587959,
0.0905157775,
0.4652604759,
-0.411075443,
-0.4560332894,
0.6578395963,
0.1828617752,
0.8712086082,
-0.0277905408,
0.5196947455,
0.4141936004,
0.632737577,
0.0514205657,
-0.0083500613,
-0.1445289403,
-0.8478608727,
-0.7228566408,
-0.4236734807,
-0.8086869717,
-0.087958172,
-0.2457438856,
0.3141795993,
-0.293577373,
0.0529943369,
-0.0613822602,
-0.0862211436,
-0.4433833063,
0.2608192563,
-0.0868124813,
0.6604955196,
-0.6477538347,
0.3946425617,
0.3521790206,
-0.5863294601,
-0.7798292041,
0.3877762258,
0.0903472751,
-0.6698689461,
0.3063465655,
0.0173793714,
-0.1652018428,
-0.4010064006,
-0.4326100349,
-0.6785975099,
0.7523776889,
0.5763034821,
-0.3695467412,
0.0842014253,
0.1798437089,
0.5974730849,
0.1608119607,
0.7275936604,
0.6363426447,
0.3085761964,
0.3900546432,
-1.0979393721,
-0.0428323783,
-0.089139387,
-0.1183138192,
0.1152294725,
-0.7782096863,
0.6443277001,
-0.2417405844,
-0.4457933605,
-0.1797480285,
0.3791114688,
0.292875737,
0.3601667583,
0.1588884443,
0.4375929534,
0.7056778073,
-0.2070301324,
1.1190241575,
-0.169422999,
0.6642359495,
1.412749052,
-0.1802298427,
0.560371995,
0.0981374383,
-0.4409294724,
0.2177581191,
0.4216313064,
-0.0162899811,
0.1548609287,
-0.1306368709,
-0.4108787477,
0.0014283787,
0.0535692945,
-0.3087430298,
0.6227418184,
0.1465815604,
0.029671222,
-0.7743074298,
-0.4817326069,
0.3280318379,
-0.1091397107,
0.0811624154,
0.812882185,
-0.0798646361,
-0.7056623101,
0.3973647356,
0.0219625514,
0.3749181628,
-0.6493136287,
-0.2391715646,
-0.3623870015,
-0.0652751923,
-0.340500921,
-0.8774744868,
0.5134305358,
0.2866266072,
0.0167403538,
0.2827865779,
0.7914021015,
-0.3305040598,
-0.4030478001,
-0.3397710025,
0.5802804232,
0.4302740991,
-0.2782301903,
-0.3951827288,
-0.1426686496,
0.129479751,
-0.1044043079,
0.1473538578,
0.8910992742,
0.2624778748,
0.3745544851,
0.5903504491,
0.065664418,
-0.0528497063,
-0.0834408104,
0.4661404788,
-0.4442934692,
-0.3677922785,
-1.2141193151,
0.4868229628,
-0.0798428878,
-0.3775367737,
1.0618406534,
0.7813387513,
0.5522969365,
-0.0266097598,
1.0210118294,
-0.1503323913,
0.5295287967,
-0.633238852,
0.703754425,
0.012249222,
0.3386320472,
-0.3745143712,
-1.0089883804,
-0.2149067968,
0.4140474796,
-0.4358198047,
-0.0586283058,
0.9444617629,
0.6776814461,
-0.1254719943,
0.3492469788,
0.5015037656,
0.3542056382,
0.3288131356,
0.3392561972,
0.8560557961,
-0.5006543994,
0.7654123902,
-0.0054040286,
-0.3066343367,
-0.1475403458,
-1.1359037161,
-0.83554703,
-0.2571600378,
-0.4279174507,
-0.2566066682,
-0.0470351689,
0.7647072673,
0.4415233433,
-0.8848465085,
-0.0563892201,
-0.1310467869,
0.2852713764,
0.0947466791,
-0.2926057577,
0.4404714704,
-0.7287157178,
-0.6201128364,
0.0730742961,
0.6123310924,
-0.0258288011,
-0.0414076708,
0.2770803273,
-0.0704217404,
0.2906059325,
0.7179918885,
0.1654939651,
-0.5246453285,
-0.5928472877,
-0.3947840929,
-0.0724216327,
0.243443042,
0.5698984861,
-0.5298311114,
0.5274556279,
0.5378571153,
0.66549474,
0.5798069835,
0.2980332375,
0.4670286477,
-0.7716658115,
0.0377735719,
-0.0445067585,
0.2971546948,
0.3810365498,
-0.4282362163,
0.5569384694,
0.3229978383,
-0.7027055621,
-0.4925033152,
-0.0176583268,
-0.9822054505,
-0.0238710716,
1.0451649427,
-0.2561678588,
-0.019439416,
-0.1171181425,
-0.4932970107,
0.3401471376,
-0.4181717336,
0.9862439036,
1.0277920961,
-0.3789952099,
-0.0528293476,
-0.9099543095,
0.3485542238,
0.325399667,
-0.8125542998,
0.1053325236,
0.6289887428,
0.3656364381,
0.1520719975,
0.6424094439,
-0.0652188584,
0.2223304659,
0.2896176577,
-0.0923715234,
0.2096973211,
0.0443203598,
-0.0753048807,
0.211427778,
-0.0077014766,
-0.0933088288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15619v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15619v1 | Typhoon: Towards an Effective Task-Specific Masking Strategy for Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-03-27T22:27:23 | 2023-03-27T22:27:23 | Muhammed Shahir Abdurrahman, Hashem Elezabi, Bruce Changlong Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Through exploiting a high level of parallelism enabled by graphics processing
units, transformer architectures have enabled tremendous strides forward in the
field of natural language processing. In a traditional masked language model,
special MASK tokens are used to prompt our model to gather contextual
information from surrounding words to restore originally hidden information. In
this paper, we explore a task-specific masking framework for pre-trained large
language models that enables superior performance on particular downstream
tasks on the datasets in the GLUE benchmark. We develop our own masking
algorithm, Typhoon, based on token input gradients, and compare this with other
standard baselines. We find that Typhoon offers performance competitive with
whole-word masking on the MRPC dataset. Our implementation can be found in a
public Github Repository. | [
-0.5238950849,
-0.4425939023,
0.0540780611,
0.6183678508,
-0.3423340023,
0.1974896342,
-0.248016268,
-0.1936817467,
0.4023176134,
0.9670624137,
-0.4973293245,
-0.3841635883,
-0.8512299061,
0.116642043,
-0.2298747599,
0.7391583323,
-0.0598508231,
-0.3360134959,
-0.1521708518,
0.1014008597,
-0.405760169,
-0.5847094059,
-0.6552941799,
-0.2119814008,
0.4820542336,
0.299833715,
0.5698181391,
0.9038709998,
0.8463891745,
0.3387767375,
0.0497798696,
0.1640865505,
-0.5992586613,
0.1470619589,
-0.3421390057,
-0.4736757278,
-0.2290619463,
-0.0531951226,
0.5741438866,
0.3843081594,
-0.1251045167,
0.2345403582,
0.1234313771,
0.3724371493,
-1.1303976774,
0.2935478389,
-0.5854572058,
0.2932080626,
-0.7542459965,
-0.0788784847,
-0.554594934,
0.4495346248,
-0.0650801733,
-0.761449635,
0.2347000092,
0.0439222939,
0.9256613851,
0.4676915705,
-0.107635811,
0.1980670542,
-0.710138917,
0.7196043134,
-0.3384048343,
0.5304083824,
0.3353220224,
0.3948892951,
0.0049077021,
-1.3806763887,
-0.4270688891,
0.3069127798,
-0.2387530506,
0.2346040457,
-0.2605423033,
0.4366845489,
0.3695008457,
0.3887715638,
-0.4858570397,
0.1160467044,
-0.2890163958,
-0.3044936359,
0.3386212289,
0.1674702764,
0.2629955709,
-0.4145864546,
-0.4147019386,
-0.253598094,
-0.5807863474,
0.2708794177,
0.1582009494,
0.4614497721,
0.0456281677,
0.3194364607,
-0.377183646,
0.8902481794,
-0.0876702443,
-0.5374837518,
-0.0767870471,
-0.0996574834,
-0.4601489305,
-0.0833119527,
0.8075377941,
0.0408343971,
0.0990776643,
-0.2295681089,
-0.4163995385,
-0.0504618436,
0.3430939913,
-1.0285220146,
-0.4475891888,
-0.2977466583,
-0.249501586,
-0.4115325212,
0.2409653664,
-0.8026173711,
-0.341486454,
-0.3471664488,
0.3500020504,
0.2897901237,
-0.3159121871,
0.1052325442,
-0.1722429544,
-0.0817479864,
-0.1146444008,
-0.8428708911,
0.5091139674,
0.7329258919,
0.7201619744,
-0.3082311749,
-0.1963299066,
-0.8542895317,
0.2165638804,
-0.2899949849,
0.8805767894,
-0.9856994152,
-0.2165132612,
-0.1932643652,
0.0441990793,
-0.5286681652,
-0.6262882948,
0.4625248015,
-0.3321791887,
0.1913847476,
-0.1185092926,
-0.2157318592,
-0.0994319171,
0.0412871391,
-0.6780917048,
1.1801557541,
0.2258598357,
-0.7546359897,
0.1284004152,
-0.4607743323,
-0.33117643,
0.2990282178,
-0.0425501354,
-0.4185850024,
0.1164461449,
0.6241107583,
0.3945728242,
-0.4772862792,
0.6122438312,
-0.1056126356,
-0.5496307015,
-0.1688404232,
-0.4580215812,
0.7175818086,
0.2348283529,
-0.4930681288,
0.294811517,
-0.4735328257,
-0.0983256102,
-0.0888478905,
0.0033108522,
-0.1386057585,
-0.2046012878,
-0.0017842904,
0.381736964,
0.0623245016,
-0.4345620871,
0.1696085036,
-0.3719220161,
0.4637179673,
0.7130061388,
-0.1749016643,
0.3106806278,
-0.0458357483,
0.9802660942,
0.0982236043,
0.2019072026,
-0.7043102384,
-0.5175888538,
-0.8916398287,
-1.0175157785,
0.4045414329,
0.7818263769,
-1.0194151402,
0.1226327941,
-0.2762418985,
-0.6197385192,
-0.7019521594,
0.1765184551,
0.6691214442,
0.5410316586,
0.2322754562,
-0.5970455408,
-0.9771893024,
-0.8978210688,
-0.2290004492,
0.0885744914,
-0.2266295701,
0.419585675,
0.1851718128,
-0.2015512735,
0.9760295153,
-0.9204804897,
-0.5309821963,
-0.2885101736,
0.0301378202,
0.1810207516,
0.3592689931,
0.4650662243,
-0.9191857576,
-0.5369855165,
-0.178587079,
-0.6202198863,
-0.3505905569,
0.0890100822,
-0.0859423876,
-0.1793927401,
1.0289264917,
-0.61738199,
0.5847224593,
0.6702419519,
-0.2115752548,
0.5437469482,
-0.0088722492,
-0.0189530607,
-0.873555243,
0.2993375957,
-0.1881098449,
-0.5717200041,
-0.8035986423,
0.3718162775,
-0.2534924448,
-0.563637197,
-0.5897042155,
0.669603467,
-0.2317645699,
0.1497301608,
-0.435721755,
-0.0681556389,
0.1608262211,
0.5724122524,
0.2012403756,
0.7458449006,
0.8558331728,
-0.2950881422,
0.3454139531,
-0.1178819314,
-0.1508534104,
0.438673079,
-0.6301047802,
0.2588463128,
-0.3564150333,
0.317864567,
-0.8976130486,
-0.0518792309,
0.3523451686,
0.0233641453,
0.3343497813,
-0.0394837707,
-0.3305955231,
-0.7592571378,
-0.182585448,
0.5678597689,
0.4311897755,
-0.5066466331,
0.7711206675,
0.597305119,
-0.1381673664,
-0.7527528405,
-0.3001719415,
0.4247389436,
-0.3186742365,
-0.2660567462,
0.80566746,
0.1156007946,
0.1030551866,
-0.1409566104,
-0.1104522422,
-0.3856984377,
0.1434176117,
0.4747871161,
0.0676978678,
-0.5100925565,
-0.2444387227,
-0.3214003444,
-0.4390617013,
-0.1144134849,
-0.4158568084,
0.6084153056,
0.1267723888,
-0.1580343097,
-0.2912119627,
0.0924171358,
0.4316772819,
-0.5426331162,
0.8012610078,
0.8080718517,
-0.5219759345,
-0.0506428778,
-0.6365363002,
-0.1063435301,
-0.5870752335,
0.3638989031,
-0.6849156022,
-0.9238191843,
0.456633389,
0.0143537689,
-0.2722159922,
0.2737693489,
0.0720525384,
0.3419923782,
0.9274080992,
1.1002962589,
-0.5268628001,
0.4262227118,
0.0415177047,
0.6431331038,
-0.6458988786,
-0.110273838,
-0.6665614247,
-0.079017356,
-0.3914590776,
-0.8943023682,
0.0673779845,
0.6045284271,
-0.1750697196,
0.5681346059,
-0.6913745403,
0.8093457222,
0.6138865352,
0.0402444229,
0.1782218069,
-0.009315609,
-0.0558356196,
-0.2111933529,
-0.8159489632,
-0.3090073466,
0.7667903304,
0.131808117,
0.3723681569,
-0.4583352804,
0.5834908485,
0.0425476618,
0.5320660472,
-0.3057540059,
0.6554028392,
-0.5149025321,
-0.328466177,
-0.280176878,
-0.2156659067,
-0.7251111269,
0.5451492667,
-0.0174662508,
-0.7846060991,
-0.0646420568,
0.1088466421,
0.0098073808,
0.4988553524,
-0.4073058069,
1.075881362,
0.3106904328,
-0.0772087276,
-0.0126815615,
-0.5323148966,
0.3385817111,
-0.3400449455,
-0.0104783308,
-0.0598835163,
0.0462121554,
0.8260635734,
-0.2551967204,
0.846208334,
-0.3519277275,
0.2579972148,
0.3787963986,
-0.2100544721,
0.41087991,
-0.1669251621,
0.0458893552,
0.2188423574,
-0.366774261,
-0.3894922137,
-0.5611357093,
0.4497545063,
-0.4096234441,
-0.9480466247,
-0.1106031612,
-0.4303531647,
0.0634092912,
0.5020210147,
0.3983004689,
0.4864600599,
0.0239569154,
0.0436214767,
0.5381110311,
-0.2338363528,
0.5428949594,
0.4449810088,
-0.3813255131,
-0.4345682859,
1.2623519897,
-0.0088489885,
-0.0648962185,
0.7401688695,
0.0528045371,
0.0885655433,
-0.3028960824,
-0.3664819002,
0.180345118,
-0.6092969179,
-0.5018718243,
-0.6150009632,
-0.5268636942,
-0.4813385904,
-0.2372045368,
-0.5146300793,
-0.2845605314,
-0.1466365755,
-0.0013569791,
-0.3137694597,
0.7831524611,
0.2122206688,
0.3659917414,
-0.5799726844,
0.4979662299,
0.440715462,
0.3899260163,
-0.076338388,
-0.2509641647,
-0.1243960783,
-0.0654039085,
-0.4283077121,
-0.4896375835,
0.2959569395,
0.333638519,
0.5918773413,
0.5614538789,
0.1513705552,
1.1497594118,
-0.4048487246,
0.8240424991,
0.1000671908,
-1.2525011301,
0.5190179348,
-0.1903615892,
0.6584638953,
0.3727448285,
0.2491790652,
-0.6412915587,
-0.8340051174,
-0.5642579794,
-0.8165938258,
0.7162133455,
0.2378147542,
0.0224008244,
0.0573090613,
0.2126589566,
-0.2079330385,
0.3709460795,
-0.7522035241,
-0.2514032722,
-0.3395447433,
-0.1178574413,
-0.3569904864,
-0.3092419207,
0.2897388935,
-0.3206627369,
0.5273510218,
-0.1345838904,
0.2522633374,
0.1359032243,
-0.2610214353,
0.0484515876,
-0.1161440834,
0.7269659638,
0.4651355147,
0.2361330837,
0.35504058,
0.0944330841,
-0.7831586003,
-0.0394691937,
0.1282775998,
0.0288455915,
0.0405345745,
0.6128639579,
1.0283011198,
0.4176327288,
-0.7817863226,
0.7757777572,
-0.0279955994,
0.0957920104,
0.2809601128,
0.0485034473,
0.0006151983,
-0.0373841822,
0.2786794305,
0.2086936533,
0.0347241797,
0.0121315541,
0.2608049512,
0.1818971336,
-0.5992413163,
-0.5017300844,
0.7766880393,
0.0806153789,
-0.3110792339,
0.6745057702,
-0.1160860881,
-0.9443544745,
0.6850036979,
0.7920171618,
0.8303753734,
-0.7384753227,
0.2705488801,
0.3911572099,
0.3389530778,
-0.1028051823,
-0.1154850051,
-0.2813825607,
-0.5249797106,
-0.6241669059,
-0.6963486075,
-0.2175656259,
0.0859091952,
-0.5702988505,
0.4381605089,
-0.2271802872,
0.126160875,
0.0518770814,
-0.4619241655,
-0.8367439508,
0.2222501785,
0.3769173324,
1.0043627024,
-0.9547795057,
0.8329125643,
0.5004163384,
0.1245236248,
-0.8722094297,
-0.1854768991,
-0.2003934234,
-0.6597080827,
0.9075323939,
0.6494696736,
-0.0332657248,
-0.076307565,
-0.0802469477,
-1.0069293976,
0.5496537089,
0.670085609,
-0.4484252036,
-0.1821894795,
0.643476069,
0.4982543886,
-0.4934480786,
0.2812540829,
0.5139167905,
0.5063351989,
-0.0687819198,
-1.2356081009,
-0.0326955579,
-0.3672063053,
0.2455792576,
0.4410833418,
-0.3782247007,
0.7284567952,
0.1915062517,
-0.174236536,
-0.1721146852,
0.6877904534,
-0.0613398999,
0.2207365483,
0.5860013366,
0.770526886,
0.7826426029,
-0.182877183,
0.7811629772,
-0.2383050919,
0.2744296491,
0.8817891479,
-0.1679663509,
0.7497888803,
0.2722289562,
-0.0937723815,
0.5728964806,
0.1742783934,
0.0759062171,
0.751696527,
0.3691629767,
-0.3330322504,
-0.2019131631,
-0.5352058411,
0.0087207034,
0.7515296936,
0.1168524623,
-0.1758442223,
-0.1274684519,
0.6367791891,
0.2144844085,
-0.0175791979,
-0.540785253,
0.8006606698,
0.115727596,
-1.0694445372,
0.4465984106,
0.127052933,
0.6524204612,
-0.5902327299,
0.0843233913,
-0.1486808658,
0.3016520143,
-0.1982679069,
-0.4368675649,
0.4829125702,
-0.1436383724,
-0.2120104432,
-0.5283331275,
0.9604846239,
-0.4482695758,
-0.4330608845,
0.0703347251,
-0.0150086498,
-0.1008164957,
-0.3914152086,
-0.4182425737,
0.2142157406,
-0.0295773502,
-0.228097111,
0.2136632949,
0.1741520762,
-0.1507007033,
0.7903985381,
0.4440736771,
0.0601034835,
0.0433644466,
-0.0196887888,
0.9215850234,
-0.556743741,
-0.8572576642,
-0.8125624061,
0.4419964254,
-0.1285468638,
-0.2357828766,
0.8085659146,
0.6916937828,
0.7106878161,
-0.1383830607,
0.265555352,
0.2462573349,
0.222778365,
-0.3250704706,
0.3954507411,
0.0136982668,
0.1421110183,
-0.486628443,
-1.0720065832,
-0.530072093,
0.4720707536,
-0.0367961004,
-0.2866826653,
0.6498148441,
0.9651529789,
-0.1618693918,
0.0408466943,
0.2666331232,
-0.1067008525,
0.5838474035,
0.5738463998,
0.3636612892,
-0.4326195121,
0.3912786543,
-0.5266563892,
-0.1017016545,
0.1017604843,
-1.0236467123,
-1.1384956837,
-0.7420627475,
-0.4151967168,
0.0380521715,
0.0791315436,
0.4254542291,
1.1220883131,
-0.6333585382,
-0.1321394742,
-0.2185216695,
0.066322647,
-0.3244242966,
-0.2491905242,
0.3411098719,
-0.3817177415,
-0.5742932558,
0.407084167,
0.4873192608,
-0.2260062695,
-0.1975058317,
0.1341641247,
0.330080688,
0.0184069071,
0.5299453139,
0.1832891405,
-0.6796833873,
-0.179003194,
-0.0564453267,
-0.0759575963,
0.0047976808,
1.2785123587,
-1.1739281416,
0.592197001,
0.3549763262,
0.6818282604,
0.7012602091,
-0.2435213178,
0.6473898888,
-1.0086542368,
0.6760997176,
0.1174606383,
0.1693014503,
0.3727442324,
-0.3215402365,
0.4366304874,
0.3290504217,
-0.2330983579,
-1.1646332741,
0.0730817914,
-0.5137201548,
-0.2999633551,
0.5205988884,
-0.4484398365,
-0.1456979364,
-0.0342710093,
-0.1824076325,
0.0330009758,
0.1740949452,
0.552343905,
0.7270507812,
0.3692638874,
-0.3063843548,
-0.1960103512,
0.5962219834,
0.3379355669,
-0.8371582031,
0.0583250523,
-0.2112376392,
0.0886593834,
0.1805388778,
0.7098278403,
0.0524937026,
0.2062165439,
-0.0665855482,
-0.2648996711,
-0.2748206854,
-0.7422196865,
-0.1591826081,
0.4319004416,
-0.231774345,
-0.0676092505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.16777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.16777v1 | Not cool, calm or collected: Using emotional language to detect COVID-19 misinformation | 2023-03-27T22:24:05 | 2023-03-27T22:24:05 | Gabriel Asher, Phil Bohlman, Karsten Kleyensteuber | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI | COVID-19 misinformation on social media platforms such as twitter is a threat
to effective pandemic management. Prior works on tweet COVID-19 misinformation
negates the role of semantic features common to twitter such as charged
emotions. Thus, we present a novel COVID-19 misinformation model, which uses
both a tweet emotion encoder and COVID-19 misinformation encoder to predict
whether a tweet contains COVID-19 misinformation. Our emotion encoder was
fine-tuned on a novel annotated dataset and our COVID-19 misinformation encoder
was fine-tuned on a subset of the COVID-HeRA dataset. Experimental results show
superior results using the combination of emotion and misinformation encoders
as opposed to a misinformation classifier alone. Furthermore, extensive result
analysis was conducted, highlighting low quality labels and mismatched label
distributions as key limitations to our study. | [
-0.4527824521,
-0.7107334733,
0.0209089741,
0.3473594487,
-0.3424741328,
0.2285465002,
-0.2074705362,
-0.7233148813,
0.5856264234,
-0.1555446386,
-0.6668873429,
-0.4841998219,
-0.6363883615,
0.1992910206,
-0.4947860539,
0.9557037354,
0.254163295,
-0.1649310291,
-0.0422299691,
0.0245158356,
-0.0369152874,
-0.4901456535,
-0.6096204519,
-0.4614555836,
0.3692262471,
0.7906130552,
0.7718859911,
-0.1234979779,
0.6392855644,
-0.0049633575,
0.1310894191,
0.1441352665,
-0.7669914365,
0.0089560142,
-0.0492315739,
-0.2684975266,
-0.1257074177,
0.0429546237,
-0.2816066444,
-0.2879894674,
-0.1760654151,
0.2316728234,
-0.3630537391,
0.1483744085,
-0.8601947427,
-0.0228076521,
-0.4495147467,
0.2324500233,
-0.3307996094,
-0.3742865324,
-0.4531429112,
-0.1551517695,
-0.0108930282,
-0.3478638828,
0.2194114029,
-0.0748339891,
1.1654552221,
0.2629517615,
-0.2899543941,
-0.2853995264,
-0.8042478561,
0.5748190284,
-0.5196263194,
0.2413828075,
0.502332747,
0.3450197875,
0.2074157298,
-0.2098331004,
-0.7386543155,
0.386189878,
0.1782062948,
0.3308711946,
-0.776068449,
-0.3149525821,
-0.0412697643,
0.1589506269,
-0.651599288,
0.1682097316,
-0.4737432301,
-0.2064396143,
0.9659602642,
-0.1258077621,
0.5143431425,
-0.1744728237,
-0.4324847758,
-0.1186343133,
-0.2695268989,
0.2102353871,
-0.1068490893,
0.0566110201,
-0.800498724,
0.3642549217,
-0.0139204375,
-0.080006063,
0.6183568835,
-0.1431316137,
0.3865573108,
0.0989565924,
-0.4897872806,
0.3318895996,
0.8857986927,
0.5079709291,
0.1491020769,
-0.2593340874,
-0.3280918002,
0.3424876034,
0.2350260466,
-0.9262758493,
-0.463591814,
0.3624280691,
-0.5259901285,
-0.3888349235,
0.0865845531,
-1.0953155756,
-0.858741343,
0.1963545084,
0.1728693843,
-0.398447156,
-0.2934280038,
-0.1422794163,
-0.6255638003,
-0.0362307094,
0.4788536131,
-0.5034129024,
-0.0745658353,
0.4476446509,
0.5643963814,
0.0366409421,
0.2286039144,
-0.1146095544,
-0.1271015704,
-0.4069191813,
0.645150423,
-0.8273658156,
-0.1137714237,
0.1212032139,
-0.2151014954,
-0.0943788588,
-0.316188395,
0.6875197887,
-0.3989627063,
0.3088219166,
-0.4765777886,
-0.1581833661,
-0.2729476094,
0.2957800627,
-0.6730966568,
0.9318276048,
0.2735491693,
-1.243606329,
0.5317841172,
-0.4905605614,
-0.2739078701,
0.1381698251,
-0.2011767626,
-0.5319714546,
-0.0235897247,
0.291944474,
0.6050657034,
-0.3839768171,
0.4296299815,
-0.826528132,
-0.3037624657,
0.3103556335,
-0.1761638224,
0.5438982248,
0.568677485,
-0.304610312,
-0.2125067264,
-0.4083456397,
-0.3635675609,
0.0301135145,
-0.1239390001,
-0.3562469482,
-0.2295395732,
-0.0203888379,
0.6470515728,
0.4580292702,
-0.7938703299,
-0.0830041021,
0.2046801001,
0.3150527477,
0.1893167049,
0.2657545507,
0.4754053652,
-0.4230453372,
0.597874403,
0.5552194715,
0.4151717126,
0.3775336742,
-0.5808337331,
-0.4142491221,
-0.2351745069,
-0.7177885175,
1.0256739855,
-0.8938928843,
0.2726529539,
0.0832363069,
-0.8937401175,
-0.5928656459,
-0.0915459394,
0.0777382255,
0.6754529476,
0.5297618508,
0.1792213023,
-0.8741036057,
-0.6266874075,
-0.3962618411,
-0.1368109137,
0.4829960167,
0.1426154971,
0.3263276815,
-0.7711595297,
0.6584044099,
-0.0546715781,
0.2621558905,
-0.1250150651,
0.6670756936,
-0.0174628068,
0.1566990018,
0.7176100016,
-0.7624900937,
-0.3932584226,
0.112609379,
-0.9179815054,
-0.0689334348,
-0.1478937864,
0.1167122647,
0.0816505402,
0.5266548395,
-0.5597603321,
0.6611358523,
0.3930727541,
-0.3853613138,
0.175537467,
-0.0032655071,
0.3545357287,
-1.1623561382,
-0.1187770143,
0.2854562402,
0.0878944546,
-0.9808012247,
-0.2995534241,
0.1797161698,
-0.1621577144,
-0.2093234211,
0.2162675411,
-0.0143515216,
0.7929747105,
-0.326002419,
-0.1054193228,
0.1300226897,
0.0791119486,
-0.0806675702,
0.3315804899,
0.5372075438,
-0.333219558,
0.3627999425,
0.2026012093,
0.0066562551,
0.656039238,
-0.2490126342,
0.3462073505,
-0.6191888452,
0.376201123,
-0.814858079,
-0.5714734793,
0.6063505411,
-0.4510056376,
0.2191361189,
0.1719069034,
-0.2371341884,
-0.6500813961,
-0.4792380333,
0.3772762418,
0.3341747224,
-0.4057750404,
0.4820561111,
0.467341274,
-0.0291946828,
-0.557068646,
-1.2198741436,
0.1622853577,
-0.6098049879,
-0.6552715898,
0.095505707,
0.1351071447,
-0.4019656479,
0.0048579737,
-0.187963888,
-0.5327553153,
0.1651021391,
0.4417802989,
-0.060634248,
-0.1702272892,
0.5896343589,
-0.0247485321,
0.3579298258,
-0.0300715044,
0.0811372846,
0.5163938403,
-0.1062592939,
0.1030023545,
-0.8612561226,
0.4759652615,
0.4999247491,
-0.0358406827,
0.9016776681,
1.0872606039,
-0.8861395717,
-0.2704617977,
-0.5543408394,
-0.2045568079,
-0.3828454614,
0.2068227977,
-0.0699817091,
-0.8276079297,
0.6271195412,
0.0220951885,
-0.4276865721,
0.6275117993,
0.1182566807,
-0.2100757957,
0.6994627714,
0.8469983935,
-0.3860818148,
0.4093180001,
-0.0944143459,
0.7440214157,
0.0087103713,
-0.6233695149,
-0.8331839442,
-0.3638121486,
-0.7704408169,
-0.3899241388,
0.0695960224,
0.1146176532,
-0.3954027891,
0.14159742,
-0.2542390823,
0.1028450951,
0.2052064687,
0.1977507323,
-0.2560189664,
-0.0050044302,
0.4417828023,
0.0458486378,
-0.910928309,
-0.2944119871,
0.5623022914,
0.4186394811,
1.0575970411,
0.2228774726,
0.9196450114,
0.6198723912,
0.1422386616,
-0.542322278,
0.012919548,
-0.4225110114,
-0.3798900247,
-0.1214254722,
-0.2728552818,
-0.706274271,
-0.4914966524,
-0.4098261893,
-0.938028574,
0.8358155489,
-0.0710862279,
-0.4514120817,
0.2064617574,
-0.8371218443,
0.4642024934,
0.0072222096,
0.1529507786,
-0.3317012787,
-0.487706244,
0.354837954,
-0.3866220713,
0.4804750979,
-0.3647156656,
0.0687168315,
0.8939333558,
-0.3766117096,
0.9398007393,
-0.1168490574,
0.1481190324,
0.3979378343,
-0.0035645871,
0.4507108927,
0.0917704329,
-0.4428967535,
0.0851235017,
-0.1167287007,
-0.5759674311,
-0.3307151794,
0.6222678423,
-1.2205201387,
-0.1464453191,
-0.3355771005,
-0.4529118538,
-0.0181677379,
-0.1317071468,
0.7389605045,
0.1116783544,
-0.2091272622,
0.12024647,
0.5296420455,
-0.2536416352,
0.6341176033,
0.1344146729,
0.2474866956,
-0.2740814686,
0.7985823154,
0.1289262623,
-0.0779427364,
0.6591929793,
0.5180011392,
0.0830703154,
0.0427982993,
-0.0277101584,
-0.0773586184,
-0.8866330385,
-0.3592129648,
-0.5701960921,
-0.317305088,
-0.4714405239,
-0.3052644134,
-0.3018089533,
-0.1399144828,
-0.6126337051,
-0.2544173598,
0.9161837697,
1.1725319624,
-0.2468622178,
0.4408024251,
-0.6594970822,
0.2369502187,
0.074563235,
-0.1309852004,
-0.2132148147,
-0.4243879914,
-0.4881997705,
0.3650780022,
-0.1681234092,
-1.1638729572,
0.7869135737,
0.4203802347,
0.2418289483,
0.9724703431,
0.6170839071,
0.6621813178,
0.3028340638,
0.8382902741,
0.3299745023,
-0.8851119876,
0.6016610265,
-0.296333015,
0.3821042776,
0.5620843768,
0.6501728892,
-0.7472388148,
-0.4501147866,
-0.8790020943,
-0.6341272593,
0.6715889573,
-0.1493858397,
-0.0586948395,
-0.309705615,
0.0472229831,
0.1588301957,
0.2098325044,
-0.3061006069,
-0.2121068984,
-0.5299471021,
-0.2426757663,
-0.0522993356,
-0.4622806907,
-0.2320700884,
-0.0412654467,
0.4408254325,
0.3146001101,
0.4680537283,
0.2034778893,
0.1543700397,
-0.4673099816,
0.293068409,
0.5088781118,
0.2653848231,
-0.5348224044,
0.5477662086,
-0.0631931722,
-0.5581408143,
-0.1448440403,
0.0356226079,
-0.1001910642,
0.2262833416,
0.2713163793,
0.8427820802,
-0.1372252107,
-0.2784720957,
0.6784497499,
-0.160455212,
0.0252867918,
-0.1801489443,
-0.2579599619,
0.0012006144,
0.2762928307,
0.3494900167,
0.7135208845,
0.1368650198,
-0.6626296639,
0.2431370467,
0.1343625337,
-0.4747645855,
-0.6732310653,
0.3045085967,
0.339146167,
-0.2552742064,
0.4916190505,
-0.292419821,
-0.4479160905,
0.5658165216,
0.3052641451,
1.0333484411,
-0.4568594992,
0.5968842506,
0.2889891565,
0.4743155837,
-0.1066399664,
0.8895449042,
0.0810027719,
-0.8261032104,
-0.0006713736,
-0.1000080705,
-0.0932046175,
0.3358397186,
-0.8624890447,
0.3330754638,
-0.5606099963,
-0.4277250767,
-0.1801190525,
-0.2632859051,
-1.1621443033,
0.510083437,
0.5193650126,
1.0533890724,
-1.3049429655,
0.6772603393,
0.6277314425,
-0.3702835441,
-0.9148790836,
0.5071547031,
0.1589559466,
-0.5733250976,
0.3992787004,
0.3234182,
-0.1338872463,
-0.5908394456,
-0.9725936651,
-0.7863367796,
1.1506052017,
0.3889131248,
-0.5220285058,
0.416254133,
0.1200321093,
0.6071871519,
-0.5208489299,
0.3665808439,
0.3261013627,
0.359683007,
0.2173228711,
-0.9745593667,
-0.0489757173,
-0.667919457,
-0.413562268,
-0.1248360276,
-0.8044455647,
0.7607933879,
-0.0450823233,
-0.3441692889,
-0.4291867912,
0.5158841014,
-0.1660332382,
1.0315821171,
0.1307104081,
0.807608366,
1.4149599075,
-0.0848905668,
0.9356005192,
-0.2800358832,
0.2200807184,
1.0237158537,
-0.0340683982,
0.9233216047,
0.4364562035,
0.4922840297,
0.4773664176,
0.9124084711,
0.2842148244,
0.5309453607,
0.0077948528,
-0.5336598754,
-0.4356219769,
-0.6333230138,
-0.4407319129,
0.5174649954,
0.7600579858,
-0.2868954241,
-0.3662071526,
0.2285028249,
0.325974375,
-0.1799854636,
-0.3615511358,
0.612255156,
0.0718729198,
-0.2429519594,
0.660210073,
0.170996204,
0.8085677624,
0.0249757245,
0.3878695071,
-0.2924936712,
0.0070331218,
-0.6001031995,
-0.4987882972,
0.5683346987,
0.0430109464,
-0.191649422,
-0.1349138916,
1.0516196489,
-0.5462796092,
-0.2315741628,
0.302200526,
0.5358498693,
0.1043691635,
-0.3452228606,
-0.6048848629,
0.0952379927,
-0.0653125048,
0.1479235142,
-0.0964104459,
0.9517254829,
-0.3077585399,
0.7026796341,
0.1578319222,
-0.2553817332,
0.0241261721,
0.1543533802,
0.7782312036,
-0.6419474483,
-0.5535081625,
-0.7794069052,
0.366984725,
-0.1867478192,
-0.2885851562,
0.6647396684,
0.3472268879,
0.5870661736,
-0.145820424,
1.1735956669,
-0.0842059702,
0.3344685733,
0.1930099577,
0.6966338158,
-0.3548358977,
-0.0777138993,
-0.0288052429,
-0.0290422235,
-0.1908239871,
0.3503032625,
-0.6484553218,
-0.180545494,
0.4882797003,
0.6644394398,
0.1259215921,
0.4731343091,
0.1706359982,
0.3478430212,
0.1914765686,
0.4896952212,
0.7290925384,
-0.2621029615,
0.3006317317,
-0.6518239379,
-0.2115023285,
-0.8408495188,
-0.7595156431,
-1.0013250113,
-0.4849320054,
-0.5632480979,
-0.7030456066,
0.1040301621,
1.0673859119,
0.6206164956,
-0.9526685476,
0.081979163,
0.0559413545,
0.0289821476,
0.0767136961,
-0.2950209677,
0.0577250831,
0.0155100422,
-0.1360047758,
0.3804011643,
0.3085289598,
0.0207792018,
0.1756564677,
-0.1653703302,
-0.2942207754,
0.5140594244,
0.3996506631,
0.326562345,
-0.3580908775,
-0.1870530695,
0.1066038832,
-0.5032801628,
-0.0438442118,
0.3027435541,
-0.3874147236,
0.4965800047,
0.7750173211,
0.469520539,
0.302763015,
0.0933066085,
0.4580537975,
-0.6951275468,
0.2058588117,
0.3538130522,
0.2828298807,
0.578741014,
-0.8409402966,
0.0575892478,
0.3211373091,
-0.1838506758,
-0.5006871223,
-0.0811625868,
-1.2675142288,
-0.0045966734,
1.1758184433,
-0.0211127736,
-0.3153175712,
-0.3351168633,
-0.0109509109,
0.4386518002,
-1.1144241095,
1.2022054195,
0.5904000401,
-0.0597231276,
-0.2841162682,
-0.1472945511,
0.6449766159,
-0.0433137529,
-0.627866447,
-0.6020079851,
0.0467030816,
0.0250773393,
0.2493650764,
0.4040930867,
0.3126389384,
0.5956639051,
0.1520872861,
0.2003089637,
-0.0347196199,
-0.1361965835,
-0.3852198422,
0.2866503894,
-0.1614360511,
-0.2683159411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02017v10 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02017v10 | Unlocking the Potential of ChatGPT: A Comprehensive Exploration of its Applications, Advantages, Limitations, and Future Directions in Natural Language Processing | 2023-03-27T21:27:58 | 2024-04-17T20:50:41 | Walid Hariri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models have revolutionized the field of artificial
intelligence and have been used in various applications. Among these models,
ChatGPT (Chat Generative Pre-trained Transformer) has been developed by OpenAI,
it stands out as a powerful tool that has been widely adopted. ChatGPT has been
successfully applied in numerous areas, including chatbots, content generation,
language translation, personalized recommendations, and even medical diagnosis
and treatment. Its success in these applications can be attributed to its
ability to generate human-like responses, understand natural language, and
adapt to different contexts. Its versatility and accuracy make it a powerful
tool for natural language processing (NLP). However, there are also limitations
to ChatGPT, such as its tendency to produce biased responses and its potential
to perpetuate harmful language patterns. This article provides a comprehensive
overview of ChatGPT, its applications, advantages, and limitations.
Additionally, the paper emphasizes the importance of ethical considerations
when using this robust tool in real-world scenarios. Finally, This paper
contributes to ongoing discussions surrounding artificial intelligence and its
impact on vision and NLP domains by providing insights into prompt engineering
techniques. | [
-0.4510484934,
-0.8725119233,
0.4369613528,
0.4076205194,
-0.1108343229,
0.2365649045,
-0.3157052398,
-0.5087167025,
-0.2294705808,
0.4156900048,
-0.5097830296,
-0.0791886225,
-0.7741600275,
-0.0353417881,
-0.5795122385,
1.1268970966,
0.0956939608,
0.0171152502,
0.2038258314,
0.0337923355,
-0.7379512191,
-0.7518335581,
-1.0059067011,
-0.197797507,
0.1979492754,
0.2292880714,
0.9338332415,
0.2071729302,
0.8459260464,
0.3271522522,
0.0328860581,
-0.2106090933,
-0.4596785903,
0.1494254172,
0.0864666551,
-0.4394915402,
-0.341404438,
0.2867681086,
0.5503205657,
0.5433464646,
-0.1926838458,
-0.0845445991,
0.2190010995,
0.6152696609,
-0.3301788568,
0.3217706084,
-0.6109202504,
0.2636134326,
-0.4006344676,
-0.3419588804,
-0.2968480289,
-0.4627084434,
0.3514156044,
-0.5293597579,
0.2256200016,
0.0360344313,
0.9101855159,
0.5378178358,
-0.165635407,
-0.4409920573,
-0.8591602445,
0.7777965069,
-0.6157477498,
0.4301901162,
0.1494063437,
0.726105988,
-0.2770604491,
-1.0320949554,
-0.6329654455,
-0.4071960449,
-0.0670020282,
0.2273804694,
-0.2934336066,
0.3138878644,
0.28182742,
0.5946934819,
-0.746665597,
0.1247450411,
-0.1706181616,
-0.1369404346,
0.3062336743,
-0.0727052689,
0.7880762219,
-0.1029286087,
-0.297085166,
-0.1465274096,
-0.4766273499,
0.0049903654,
0.3491516709,
0.1941414475,
0.1351141185,
0.6391353011,
-0.1729307026,
0.6400008798,
-0.3051051795,
0.1736851037,
0.0316691734,
-0.3724074662,
-0.1984591037,
-0.0164526887,
1.0879900455,
0.1164312586,
0.5806494951,
-0.1559719741,
0.1927504092,
0.0925061256,
0.3986460865,
-0.8549314141,
-0.2291182578,
0.1807356328,
-0.4237303734,
-0.3425938487,
-0.0673245713,
-0.987564981,
-0.3484511971,
-0.1955287606,
0.0152723473,
-0.6069449186,
-0.2097039968,
0.2301912308,
-0.1545464694,
0.611602366,
0.2974392772,
-1.0431226492,
0.0945040062,
0.8224650025,
0.8945070505,
-0.0279549565,
-0.1678007841,
-0.3337285221,
-0.2768797874,
-0.1544761211,
0.7649978399,
-0.6858410239,
-0.3278226256,
-0.1023202389,
-0.457868576,
-0.0870700479,
-0.3818464279,
0.9774532914,
-0.515386045,
0.3122500181,
0.1062508225,
-0.2110529244,
-0.1117442921,
0.2920701504,
-0.5502189398,
0.7388105989,
-0.0485726409,
-0.8065844774,
0.2188053727,
-1.1452950239,
-0.4640766382,
0.4260413349,
-0.0733891204,
-0.3419331014,
-0.0622228757,
0.3503340483,
0.3514177501,
-0.2686197162,
0.360470593,
0.1730828881,
-0.0440682322,
0.3219673634,
-0.9264978766,
0.8502793908,
0.2935040891,
-0.1826293319,
0.2401144207,
-0.4671407342,
0.0229320191,
0.2166823745,
-0.153631404,
-0.0970389843,
0.1070018113,
0.1844456494,
0.1816299558,
0.1085660756,
-0.5384451151,
0.0663213804,
-0.4890318811,
0.8064928055,
0.7043994069,
-0.1157347113,
0.3569353223,
-0.0895333812,
0.6520206928,
-0.2427398115,
0.3525081277,
-0.4390824437,
-0.7649140358,
-0.6859802604,
-0.2015814036,
0.3675436676,
0.8723140359,
-0.7519272566,
0.4428236783,
-0.2578262389,
-0.5729430318,
-0.6759846807,
-0.1067008302,
0.0279986188,
0.4589431584,
0.3243694901,
-0.2952956855,
-0.504421711,
-0.8305076957,
-0.4943229258,
-0.1753537506,
-0.2382157594,
0.1364581734,
0.0366881005,
-0.1878875643,
1.1612372398,
-0.4518054724,
-0.3745343983,
-0.5268922448,
0.1920422316,
0.2696814537,
0.5271741748,
0.3441928029,
-1.1945898533,
-0.4945344627,
0.175736174,
-0.782196939,
-0.1430582851,
-0.4060349166,
-0.2828406394,
-0.2784505486,
0.3955152929,
-0.9181761146,
0.4512781799,
0.6246033907,
-0.2018869966,
0.4899222851,
-0.0384780876,
0.1825753003,
-1.0873067379,
0.075629741,
-0.0225927122,
-0.3273344338,
-0.914357245,
0.0502306372,
-0.2613112032,
-0.5574713349,
-0.3435041606,
0.357045114,
-0.1057721525,
0.2955734134,
-0.2913382649,
0.086243175,
-0.4346541464,
0.3137066662,
0.0340226963,
0.9094091058,
0.4614004195,
-0.4972378016,
0.4876240194,
0.534320116,
-0.1576508731,
0.3731368482,
-0.8134688139,
0.206562981,
-0.0976017788,
0.1187593266,
-0.6271441579,
-0.1834805012,
0.5263209939,
-0.6942507625,
0.1771026701,
0.0101524806,
-0.4604362249,
-0.2792611718,
-0.1216305643,
0.3885471523,
0.8696548343,
-0.440200597,
0.3988335431,
0.4730334282,
-0.3946966529,
-0.4720398188,
-0.4343805909,
0.4430523515,
-0.175980106,
-0.6399764419,
0.2448088229,
-0.141993627,
-0.1445954889,
-0.1975300759,
0.031668935,
-0.077992402,
0.1743093431,
0.1500257105,
0.2058973163,
-0.1457413286,
0.0405176692,
-0.2062137425,
-0.5386080146,
-0.0538064949,
-0.1974391639,
0.9534624219,
-0.3544307947,
-0.6022046208,
-0.4299882948,
0.4232823253,
0.3501140773,
-0.4740459919,
0.4790447652,
0.7162979841,
-0.1652071774,
0.0626088455,
-0.3591290116,
-0.2038298696,
-0.5117481351,
0.4953252375,
0.0712318495,
-0.9485186934,
0.174273178,
-0.1330308169,
0.2750309706,
0.3684618175,
0.5405279994,
0.0857301056,
1.0153609514,
0.8352223635,
-0.1455110908,
0.7653381824,
0.1830554008,
0.9026673436,
-0.6021878123,
0.1014243737,
-0.6621055007,
-0.1077215374,
-0.8963113427,
-0.1633967012,
0.3942559659,
-0.0116282031,
-0.0663107187,
0.3027977347,
-0.5850095153,
0.5768762231,
0.7806633115,
-0.1043732017,
0.4493633807,
-0.2445284128,
0.4668952823,
-0.0162720159,
-0.7663518786,
-0.7850000262,
0.6769529581,
0.4716605544,
0.5773817301,
-0.2207037956,
0.2418711185,
0.2699996829,
0.2462205738,
-1.0279626846,
0.6182686687,
-0.0451819785,
-0.5204944611,
-0.4451630116,
-0.3471556604,
-1.1145128012,
0.1587796062,
-0.029922422,
-0.6111362576,
-0.2631020844,
0.2002604753,
-0.2381419688,
0.273242265,
-0.9895247221,
0.9577322006,
-0.3161531687,
0.1004350036,
-0.0568133369,
-0.7577729821,
0.177232191,
-0.0449321494,
-0.097383216,
-0.1083925366,
0.2774710357,
0.6264564991,
-0.129339993,
0.84418118,
0.0844620541,
0.0829337314,
0.3252049387,
-0.1415330768,
0.233605355,
0.143342346,
0.2159402817,
0.3930604458,
-0.2011489719,
-0.3703683019,
-0.5366988182,
0.2920102179,
-0.5888277888,
-0.737375319,
-0.4874753654,
-0.4646897614,
-0.4204274416,
0.4299870431,
0.3764857352,
0.1655058712,
-0.4372631609,
0.0355165936,
0.5682362318,
-0.610722065,
0.6245800853,
0.0226013865,
-0.2230764776,
0.0481420904,
1.0179419518,
-0.2090288699,
0.2424720526,
0.3225526512,
0.252437681,
0.0411140881,
-0.6468101144,
-0.3938268125,
-0.0314609148,
-0.5298042893,
-0.0102518685,
-0.6543762684,
-0.6256135106,
-0.3768465519,
-0.1438895315,
-0.4579539597,
-0.1417464614,
-0.0004031296,
0.0243368912,
0.1462290585,
0.4944223762,
0.3104314506,
0.425704658,
-0.9209468365,
0.3285802603,
0.5029386282,
0.4710712433,
-0.1424921751,
0.0576189719,
0.1515165269,
0.2272012085,
-0.4715683162,
-0.7209194303,
0.5224607587,
0.1306151152,
0.6714134812,
0.2681694925,
0.0845934525,
0.3098316193,
-0.6430794001,
0.8891739845,
0.085197635,
-0.7986544371,
0.6484035254,
-0.3394363225,
0.3969539702,
0.3374691308,
0.4130688906,
-1.0759005547,
-0.425830543,
-0.5901914239,
-0.9360834956,
0.532994628,
0.7836734653,
0.4412711561,
0.2082820386,
0.0608953536,
0.1903494149,
0.1712583303,
-0.7226235867,
0.1008874178,
-0.4713489115,
-0.2311836332,
0.0039621661,
-0.0067877523,
0.0649564415,
0.0419508219,
0.656398356,
-0.0870389193,
0.5888447762,
0.1469572484,
-0.0764924511,
0.3302989304,
0.5297164917,
0.3805757463,
0.3130074143,
0.143124193,
-0.1619048864,
0.0323734283,
-0.8455346823,
-0.3023903668,
0.2247746885,
-0.1443556845,
-0.0695963055,
0.3842720091,
0.7815593481,
-0.1874380708,
-0.804233551,
0.5558456779,
-0.369094789,
0.2188833952,
-0.3949150443,
0.0432170741,
-0.1989590079,
0.1134632528,
0.2815305889,
0.4274531007,
0.1999748945,
-0.4556829631,
0.007867801,
0.5140867233,
-0.5862342119,
-0.2726424038,
0.575750649,
0.2478431761,
-0.5225220919,
0.8816281557,
0.0306607168,
-0.7681193352,
0.4423113167,
0.4094869494,
1.0362321138,
-0.1778683066,
0.2304943949,
0.0122595448,
0.3690823615,
0.140954107,
-0.1479378343,
-0.1656833589,
-0.9840930104,
-0.5589697957,
-0.638972342,
-0.582673192,
0.0341726355,
-0.2470059693,
0.2886416912,
-0.4075648785,
-0.0896840096,
0.0532326587,
-0.4029301405,
-0.6601521373,
-0.1268528253,
0.116673328,
0.7440431714,
-0.4679661095,
0.6304207444,
0.4864542484,
-0.4482770562,
-0.5717303157,
0.3557329178,
-0.1184132472,
-0.9252739549,
0.4520513713,
0.3606530428,
0.0257156976,
0.1788417548,
-0.6260356903,
-0.4581698179,
0.6032442451,
0.3365756571,
-0.3471889496,
-0.2004838884,
0.3802165985,
0.6275654435,
0.1619733572,
0.3964250982,
0.7081469297,
0.4799188375,
0.1405975521,
-1.1778969765,
-0.1336419284,
-0.3405422866,
0.0256956387,
0.3973971307,
-0.4869868755,
0.4987723231,
-0.0492218994,
-0.4972485304,
-0.0083013196,
0.5079433322,
-0.1233195588,
0.0118884295,
0.2194139361,
0.1822816133,
0.5086014867,
-0.3419007361,
1.1822090149,
-0.165766269,
0.1471586078,
0.6653577685,
-0.0073791882,
0.5372651219,
0.3489321768,
-0.213796556,
0.0396054015,
0.436294198,
0.0756031498,
0.2663805187,
-0.0618824475,
-0.3946284056,
-0.0617910624,
-0.2076161951,
-0.3807986975,
0.5931863189,
0.4452367425,
-0.1585974991,
-0.3573850393,
0.1861367971,
0.1313114017,
-0.1346974224,
-0.2397591174,
0.8186471462,
0.1882594079,
-0.5847876668,
0.0914628804,
-0.1530433893,
0.8158743978,
-0.7130300999,
-0.1495860964,
0.1070645154,
0.1782779247,
-0.0172896329,
-0.8915095329,
0.5719184279,
0.0558034815,
0.3066989481,
-0.6275487542,
1.0443592072,
-0.0384066813,
-0.1698540002,
-0.0613079593,
0.5123123527,
-0.0287511013,
-0.4377059042,
-0.6098840237,
-0.2619370818,
-0.0701845363,
-0.3366194367,
0.2546232343,
0.4833521843,
0.0162686259,
0.9349201918,
0.8747354746,
0.0061002662,
0.1461091787,
-0.019107312,
0.8988018632,
-0.5804400444,
-0.4975110292,
-1.0094858408,
0.4362778664,
-0.2298935801,
-0.4153368771,
0.7016353607,
0.2724968195,
0.7583168149,
0.0154852411,
0.9803046584,
-0.3235986531,
0.3490125537,
-0.5479842424,
0.8360501528,
0.1145121083,
0.0713836774,
-0.2330825776,
-0.7932494283,
-0.5762532353,
0.6083223224,
-0.4378760755,
0.0395849086,
0.6349127889,
0.4753835201,
0.1270328015,
0.4382574856,
0.3755193055,
0.0764545128,
0.7420209646,
0.4616682529,
0.9413942695,
-0.255089283,
0.8168712854,
-0.045641657,
-0.4025937617,
0.1041999236,
-0.8374149203,
-0.9188013077,
-0.6516811252,
-0.0329653025,
-0.0048454599,
0.02398072,
0.8579298258,
0.7056971192,
-0.7712930441,
0.0175416823,
-0.4275412261,
-0.0490008406,
-0.204447642,
-0.2632593215,
0.0811979324,
-0.6243390441,
-0.9157148004,
0.2661722302,
0.4553424418,
0.1691466719,
-0.1776264608,
0.1874397546,
-0.0320915245,
-0.1684746742,
0.769433856,
0.5199769139,
-0.3460861742,
-0.2550224066,
-0.0353284925,
0.0802380517,
0.3011114299,
1.0584381819,
-0.8594741821,
0.3135024309,
0.5984306335,
0.9734862447,
0.210239768,
-0.0191146247,
0.9956713915,
-0.4404606223,
0.2823205888,
0.7336546183,
0.1173197478,
0.363178283,
-0.4068027437,
0.5210340023,
0.0987557322,
-0.7607723475,
-0.5507285595,
0.5148915052,
-1.0650449991,
-0.0727803484,
0.9316443801,
0.0733093545,
0.052229248,
-0.3095060885,
-0.8042857647,
0.4121009409,
-0.4731939435,
0.7631734014,
0.6600597501,
-0.2562611997,
-0.3813520372,
-1.1269618273,
0.6831457615,
0.3835833669,
-1.0371416807,
0.0886480361,
0.0907249898,
-0.1975364685,
0.1661153585,
0.5298252106,
-0.2943283617,
-0.0669978783,
-0.1374492645,
0.0232428703,
0.17813541,
-0.0833232179,
-0.2125196904,
0.2734966874,
0.168567434,
-0.312241137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15587v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15587v1 | Linguistically Informed ChatGPT Prompts to Enhance Japanese-Chinese Machine Translation: A Case Study on Attributive Clauses | 2023-03-27T20:33:40 | 2023-03-27T20:33:40 | Wenshi Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the field of Japanese-Chinese translation linguistics, the issue of
correctly translating attributive clauses has persistently proven to be
challenging. Present-day machine translation tools often fail to accurately
translate attributive clauses from Japanese to Chinese. In light of this, this
paper investigates the linguistic problem underlying such difficulties, namely
how does the semantic role of the modified noun affect the selection of
translation patterns for attributive clauses, from a linguistic perspective. To
ad-dress these difficulties, a pre-edit scheme is proposed, which aims to
enhance the accuracy of translation. Furthermore, we propose a novel two-step
prompt strategy, which combines this pre-edit scheme with ChatGPT, currently
the most widely used large language model. This prompt strategy is capable of
optimizing translation input in zero-shot scenarios and has been demonstrated
to improve the average translation accuracy score by over 35%. | [
-0.2481219769,
-1.0444208384,
0.7019588351,
0.2477283776,
-0.5932019353,
0.136008963,
-0.4210243523,
-0.340033859,
0.245718956,
0.4377692044,
-0.69541502,
-0.2754825652,
-0.5423204899,
0.2494767457,
0.0222366005,
0.9715864062,
-0.1862055063,
-0.0486628488,
0.2650043666,
0.0990355387,
-0.6638192534,
-0.5177655816,
-0.8983174562,
-0.2489286512,
0.6068637967,
0.3503701985,
1.2879962921,
0.6406648159,
0.5118362308,
0.2230870575,
-0.0796075687,
0.3014869094,
0.0175769776,
0.1159549057,
0.1285277456,
-0.6870419383,
-0.4282690883,
0.0152986404,
0.587947011,
0.6362912059,
0.1134512499,
-0.2018833011,
-0.010760691,
0.5028424263,
-0.488455385,
0.4019703567,
-0.6622028351,
0.1081392542,
-0.4958780408,
-0.4260618985,
-0.3953629732,
-0.4151332378,
-0.213592276,
-0.9206402898,
0.1080485135,
-0.1332202852,
0.9979676008,
0.6390380859,
-0.3176108301,
-0.0946947411,
-0.3576407135,
0.4270611405,
-0.7825293541,
0.3088893294,
0.4187532961,
0.2159878612,
-0.5922306776,
-0.5600988865,
-0.4766418636,
-0.2475894392,
-0.3263953626,
0.3742023706,
0.0969134793,
0.2646578848,
0.4151520133,
0.0687891841,
-0.8057621717,
0.2754419446,
0.0039034153,
-0.1164479107,
0.3955098689,
-0.0332561433,
0.5223096013,
-0.6119894385,
-0.0972949341,
-0.087971136,
-0.8086089492,
0.0812337324,
0.3451204896,
0.5440517068,
0.3565395772,
0.67350775,
-0.434858948,
0.8626276851,
-0.0334387049,
0.227916941,
0.1145675182,
-0.4676320851,
0.1376791745,
0.3386308551,
0.899682641,
0.3992046714,
0.28653422,
0.0442264266,
-0.2841448486,
0.2235190421,
0.116583772,
-0.6688892245,
-0.3085790873,
0.1711606234,
-0.2452638298,
-0.3071000576,
0.0346619599,
-0.5202098489,
-0.3148427606,
-0.1524733156,
0.2371179312,
-0.4891323149,
-0.0466219261,
0.2812335491,
-0.032456819,
0.3271335363,
0.5563284159,
-0.5126361251,
-0.1994588971,
0.7259842753,
0.8020333648,
0.1542362571,
-0.2201987058,
-0.6567758918,
0.044672817,
-0.5413383842,
0.9482930303,
-0.5752537847,
-0.5398016572,
-0.123047024,
-0.1830950528,
-0.0858340412,
-0.2291490138,
0.6295449138,
-0.4400632083,
0.6409884095,
-0.2717667818,
-0.2572159171,
-0.0476795137,
0.1831794232,
-0.3647084236,
0.8334518671,
-0.0115673551,
-0.5865769386,
0.3701514304,
-0.9844022393,
-0.7284597754,
0.3163840771,
-0.0159804579,
-0.3809357285,
0.036376439,
0.7137402892,
0.2684894204,
-0.1403060108,
0.2402291894,
-0.0508522429,
-0.2085336596,
0.5000334978,
-0.4675166607,
0.9210831523,
0.3435873389,
-0.0576166138,
0.1643822044,
-0.479694128,
0.1263484359,
0.093262367,
-0.1061161906,
-0.2727754414,
-0.1167858765,
-0.2871060073,
0.2117591202,
0.1549120396,
-0.2712287605,
0.4670572281,
-0.4124639332,
0.4494262338,
0.5188151002,
0.1875890046,
0.3387618363,
-0.0414218158,
0.7123534083,
-0.0137691749,
0.2667149305,
-0.6123517752,
-0.7586018443,
-0.7251132727,
-0.1413455606,
0.4098115861,
0.9390978217,
-1.2749158144,
0.4330118001,
-0.1591686457,
-0.4547256827,
-0.8547888398,
-0.1629742533,
0.5119786263,
0.3059616983,
0.4523411691,
-0.2807648182,
-0.4291760027,
-0.593192935,
-0.4710721076,
-0.6798129082,
-0.0997449309,
0.155793041,
0.1543391496,
-0.1955114156,
0.8540082574,
-0.7275637388,
-0.2958145738,
-0.1728956997,
0.4283541441,
0.3927794099,
0.5333897471,
0.3626140654,
-0.7471815944,
-0.603577733,
0.2028881609,
-0.5671824217,
-0.5065857172,
-0.5203376412,
-0.3717720509,
0.0394875295,
0.6979067326,
-1.0030764341,
0.3138580918,
0.1149335131,
-0.4508554637,
0.7451310158,
-0.3426887393,
0.5575162768,
-1.1857687235,
-0.0443793014,
-0.2948733866,
-0.4155925512,
-0.6636624336,
0.3723866343,
0.2071321905,
-0.2391629815,
-0.3561628163,
0.1904385239,
-0.5828820467,
0.3043299913,
-0.2671322525,
0.4038135707,
0.0256508831,
0.3995426297,
0.0705641508,
0.7470648289,
0.3103492856,
-0.5341781974,
0.4964365363,
0.474699825,
-0.3394920826,
0.4486936629,
-0.605794847,
0.2282118946,
-0.1937721521,
0.3075683415,
-0.9574689865,
-0.1951165497,
0.7868143916,
-0.7613068223,
0.4515454471,
-0.174252674,
-0.6555230021,
-0.075198099,
-0.1387101412,
0.2953725755,
0.3923900425,
-0.2809513509,
0.1691925228,
0.0055760574,
-0.3477210701,
-0.4483463466,
-0.6624792218,
0.4436669648,
-0.2251157463,
-0.4215782881,
0.4860602915,
-0.0098530352,
-0.135540843,
-0.0689778402,
0.190438807,
-0.02914262,
0.3460371494,
-0.2002399564,
0.4610756338,
-0.3270734251,
-0.0504759327,
0.0810960159,
-0.396456331,
-0.0610169396,
-0.203080371,
0.4334690571,
0.2615432739,
-0.3658537567,
-0.4159312248,
0.290342629,
0.2328014225,
-0.4043481052,
0.4651755095,
0.5509610772,
-0.0635993183,
0.087793231,
-0.32368806,
-0.2620592713,
-0.4253362715,
0.4837716818,
-0.5878126025,
-0.5057954192,
0.4898306131,
0.128650859,
0.0970787331,
0.2402597517,
0.2413489372,
-0.0611568764,
1.1446703672,
0.1888735294,
0.060866341,
0.7685338259,
0.4952903986,
0.3287384808,
-0.6270925999,
0.2538716495,
-0.7698916197,
0.0242841486,
-0.8434497714,
-0.5856749415,
0.3630267382,
0.1390062422,
0.0194737054,
0.5989001393,
-0.1985383332,
0.6611450315,
0.250865072,
0.2603161037,
0.2723917663,
-0.260692358,
0.2210432738,
-0.2760004401,
-0.7295526266,
-0.2868611813,
0.419344902,
0.0565335751,
0.4079281688,
0.2396404892,
0.5072940588,
0.1125480458,
-0.0788815692,
-1.0111352205,
0.5539932847,
-0.2221276313,
-0.402748704,
-0.2118676901,
-0.5230580568,
-1.0251255035,
0.3589611053,
-0.1656555086,
-0.5261740088,
-0.1637011021,
0.0274987258,
-0.3948232234,
-0.1289223135,
-0.6389914155,
1.0719252825,
-0.3015888929,
-0.0868626758,
0.0222604964,
-0.7699565887,
0.0437152386,
-0.2707415223,
0.192825079,
0.0188588686,
-0.18094033,
0.495488137,
-0.4017010629,
0.6612305045,
-0.2048119307,
-0.1080590859,
0.1464945227,
0.1372207999,
0.7625191212,
0.0518117622,
-0.0063908705,
-0.1033272818,
-0.2898024023,
-0.3739169538,
-0.9933924079,
0.0740329921,
-0.5703763366,
-0.9845945835,
-0.3261369467,
-0.4197100103,
-0.4108986259,
0.3145802617,
0.4575970173,
0.2878314257,
-0.0586355738,
0.0843226761,
0.4639268816,
-0.4092225432,
0.3279960752,
0.4850822389,
-0.4601156414,
-0.1146118939,
0.6512134075,
0.0940731466,
0.381913662,
0.4745233059,
0.2423208356,
-0.2490989268,
-0.3640148342,
-0.6878416538,
0.2903339863,
-0.8058884144,
-0.1413455606,
-0.5779462457,
-0.0896410868,
-0.5490933061,
-0.3783474863,
-0.4567585289,
-0.5660299659,
-0.1695192009,
0.0486789942,
0.2742092311,
0.2587012649,
0.1996682882,
0.6218160391,
-0.9357920289,
0.4106660187,
-0.1850553453,
0.089340575,
-0.5266003013,
-0.8670369387,
-0.1284910887,
0.1416027695,
0.0209777374,
-0.9754508138,
0.3001621664,
0.172685802,
0.5932435393,
0.0443167612,
0.2554879785,
1.1590176821,
-0.5431171656,
0.947679162,
0.1559896171,
-1.0031164885,
0.9626808167,
-0.3466288149,
0.784627378,
0.3736388981,
0.2472098321,
-0.8795491457,
-0.7095560431,
-0.5916597247,
-0.7317526937,
0.7379662395,
0.25958094,
0.1152669191,
0.1061550155,
0.354493171,
-0.0053968886,
0.0719973594,
-0.6291915178,
-0.1554514468,
-0.260772258,
0.0866170749,
-0.2147916555,
-0.155650273,
0.4760935605,
-0.0371293537,
0.8976131678,
-0.1578960866,
0.168475464,
0.1199158654,
-0.3292265534,
0.1215912998,
0.3464248776,
0.3048245311,
0.3294987381,
0.0741805509,
-0.1953314096,
-0.032376796,
-0.3195389807,
-0.0311525315,
0.0990160704,
-0.544347167,
0.4310213029,
0.2127133459,
1.0343174934,
0.2560240924,
-0.1510913223,
0.3641783893,
-0.0408698916,
0.0716600195,
-0.077628836,
-0.0617120266,
-0.3629263639,
0.1360274255,
0.0322604962,
0.1801866889,
0.1997820139,
-0.5085070133,
0.0260358453,
0.2587243319,
-0.38793993,
-0.2449396104,
0.5087947845,
0.0474953912,
-0.2951774895,
0.6466293931,
-0.1380430758,
-0.9163216949,
0.1489855349,
0.4148851633,
0.9788433313,
-0.6200911403,
0.4226226807,
0.4158878922,
0.4786844254,
-0.1891382337,
-0.0452542007,
-0.1347936839,
-0.9141654372,
-0.5842311978,
-0.1785214394,
-0.4831129611,
-0.2237992287,
-0.5645021796,
0.6519761682,
-0.0975204334,
-0.2034328729,
0.0035897561,
-0.0975910202,
-0.1290223897,
0.0840542018,
0.0986318067,
0.3674528003,
-0.5814381838,
1.0468969345,
0.812676549,
-0.5008073449,
-0.8091834188,
0.1413530409,
-0.1336663365,
-0.543153882,
0.2978340387,
0.1705622673,
0.0503548086,
0.2016919106,
-0.3304014802,
-0.5942362547,
0.3479272127,
0.4581460059,
-0.2023640871,
0.0309110582,
0.3367005885,
0.4251391292,
0.1079024971,
0.2894855142,
0.6402465105,
0.6570726633,
0.1789547503,
-1.0445760489,
0.1958422661,
-0.3788273335,
0.0927047431,
0.3078190982,
-0.3313066661,
0.5698567629,
-0.1390507817,
-0.3671975732,
-0.0730072707,
0.6324473619,
0.0391006544,
-0.13158831,
0.5379402041,
-0.0625792369,
0.6700705886,
-0.2583849132,
0.9843273759,
-0.055899322,
0.0519783422,
1.1167322397,
0.0044340221,
0.694686234,
0.4557030201,
-0.2246190906,
0.3112317622,
0.8047469258,
0.0813527256,
0.5296480656,
-0.0635775849,
-0.2520430684,
-0.2924855947,
-0.2468490601,
-0.3543908596,
0.7163112164,
0.5101093054,
-0.1276836395,
-0.0886868164,
0.0814870745,
0.5290358663,
0.1164653525,
-0.2666433156,
0.9200380445,
0.0506747887,
-1.2102277279,
0.5336052775,
0.039425157,
0.64172858,
-0.7616521716,
0.0083655613,
-0.3568405807,
0.0195673071,
-0.3100266755,
-0.8567146659,
0.2816473544,
0.1685481071,
0.1183565408,
-0.4491729736,
0.7753078938,
-0.6515353322,
-0.3167207837,
-0.0749092326,
0.5600876212,
0.3415376842,
-0.4157936871,
-0.8372178078,
-0.0779376701,
0.2928960919,
-0.3698991239,
0.0960361883,
0.7109044194,
-0.1885926425,
0.3891363442,
0.6790497899,
0.2634241581,
-0.0387926735,
0.1228255406,
0.5504997373,
-0.6251773834,
-0.8219802976,
-0.9718424678,
0.6259909272,
-0.0255390648,
-0.1836342216,
0.7568051219,
0.1601305455,
0.8888747096,
-0.0119512044,
0.7755454183,
-0.121387437,
0.1780066043,
-0.7064011693,
0.6514592767,
-0.4607958496,
0.1609896272,
-0.4821446538,
-1.013920784,
-0.7719148397,
0.7065973878,
-0.3089209497,
-0.1465516537,
0.8318769336,
1.0511507988,
0.2396427691,
0.0745828077,
0.4038780928,
0.1256519556,
0.5508320332,
0.4994089007,
0.7886661887,
-0.6843329072,
0.5899047256,
-0.2588638663,
-0.1860900968,
-0.1078720912,
-0.9517323375,
-0.5220966339,
-0.50516361,
-0.7089193463,
-0.2144408226,
0.1272981763,
1.1428413391,
0.1792467684,
-0.6597225666,
-0.1065452695,
0.0349766426,
-0.0612276942,
-0.2476348877,
-0.1756555587,
0.283398211,
-0.842659831,
-0.8257775307,
0.4684906602,
0.1811123788,
0.050334923,
0.2093882561,
0.1010905206,
-0.1257699579,
-0.1825395674,
0.620147109,
0.0423102155,
-0.6280978918,
-0.3325478733,
-0.1430831403,
-0.2262521237,
0.1229516342,
0.9039546847,
-0.6704769135,
0.6395614147,
0.5098673701,
0.6479333043,
0.1841533631,
0.1641867906,
0.8536016345,
-0.7186487913,
0.4342827201,
0.0406101532,
0.3635028899,
0.5217407346,
-0.5907793641,
0.5154526234,
0.3909208775,
-0.3865417838,
-0.6776556969,
0.3171049356,
-0.7993026972,
-0.4642517269,
1.1538870335,
-0.3803352416,
-0.1773241758,
-0.214160651,
-0.5924963951,
0.6547549367,
-0.2398984134,
0.6839106679,
0.767382741,
0.1347571313,
-0.3402028084,
-0.5515277386,
0.6095443964,
0.6540575624,
-0.6503201127,
0.2669696212,
0.5400473475,
-0.3959366679,
0.0475419052,
0.3987864852,
-0.2059929222,
0.5033854246,
-0.0242427625,
-0.1612870842,
-0.1167385504,
0.0099950293,
-0.1546322703,
-0.2698225081,
0.4387524724,
-0.2481612414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.00008v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.00008v3 | On the Creativity of Large Language Models | 2023-03-27T18:00:01 | 2023-07-09T18:00:02 | Giorgio Franceschelli, Mirco Musolesi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs) are revolutionizing several areas of Artificial
Intelligence. One of the most remarkable applications is creative writing,
e.g., poetry or storytelling: the generated outputs are often of astonishing
quality. However, a natural question arises: can LLMs be really considered
creative? In this article we firstly analyze the development of LLMs under the
lens of creativity theories, investigating the key open questions and
challenges. In particular, we focus our discussion around the dimensions of
value, novelty and surprise as proposed by Margaret Boden in her work. Then, we
consider different classic perspectives, namely product, process, press and
person. We discuss a set of ``easy'' and ``hard'' problems in machine
creativity, presenting them in relation to LLMs. Finally, we examine the
societal impact of these technologies with a particular focus on the creative
industries, analyzing the opportunities offered by them, the challenges arising
by them and the potential associated risks, from both legal and ethical points
of view. | [
-0.3904180825,
-0.7321640253,
0.875248611,
0.0954098776,
-0.1016813889,
0.2756258845,
-0.4592325985,
-0.5742118955,
0.0399455987,
0.7188725471,
-0.7508907318,
-0.2591818869,
-0.6840314269,
0.1369263232,
-0.3653332293,
0.6551695466,
-0.0412002653,
-0.167616412,
-0.1289394945,
-0.1374683529,
-0.2045870721,
-0.5230904818,
-0.3989575505,
-0.0965563208,
1.0411686897,
0.2570969164,
0.709066689,
0.4365172386,
0.4629315734,
0.4751547277,
-0.4965957999,
0.1305822283,
-0.5517328978,
0.3649298549,
-0.3299353421,
-0.5818537474,
-0.0544857159,
0.2408483475,
0.5031325817,
0.9094537497,
0.0891585723,
0.0512926131,
-0.0072407327,
0.858617723,
-0.1228377819,
-0.246708259,
-0.6151903272,
0.2081091255,
-0.3185820878,
-0.1090920344,
-0.2871189117,
-0.4324257374,
0.0006226061,
-0.2964622974,
0.0621516183,
0.0006418139,
0.6857377887,
0.2860518694,
-0.3005825877,
-0.8342750669,
-1.1863029003,
0.8567039967,
-0.7523958683,
-0.0370027795,
-0.3730119169,
0.3782123923,
-0.4234748781,
-0.7695841193,
-0.8424034119,
-0.0541517958,
0.5074313879,
-0.0622162968,
-0.1886454672,
-0.4342998862,
0.4277418554,
0.7382568717,
-0.4146990776,
0.6513354778,
-0.2835856676,
0.2564772964,
0.947781682,
0.3379160464,
0.4724998772,
0.1317773759,
-0.0409094878,
0.1388459802,
-0.6833802462,
0.1994741708,
0.7642732263,
-0.0326896533,
0.0207201969,
0.8947411776,
-0.1514817774,
0.3739825189,
-0.3672273755,
-0.1786411554,
0.2786077261,
-0.1093388051,
-0.0442858413,
-0.2163562626,
0.8066594601,
-0.0443893,
0.5142676234,
-0.0711602196,
-0.3538751304,
-0.0608814657,
0.2940177619,
-0.5403344035,
0.1058398858,
0.4418344498,
-0.4067311287,
-0.4297913015,
0.1738074422,
-0.1953686476,
-0.688452363,
-0.3012411594,
0.3313979805,
-0.1834367067,
-0.2674974501,
0.3585183322,
-0.307602495,
-0.021248972,
0.2674606144,
-0.9079461098,
-0.2529098392,
0.9013366103,
0.4909948111,
-0.0541890785,
-0.1658146977,
-0.0653161332,
0.13328062,
-0.664013505,
0.5826564431,
-0.2123230547,
-0.2671706378,
-0.0315831117,
0.0083004786,
0.5187366605,
-0.5864101052,
0.3438500166,
-0.3627341688,
0.281784296,
-0.3828569055,
-0.4236211777,
-0.1878886223,
-0.0048551112,
-0.7874389291,
0.3907312453,
0.1042510569,
-0.5559316278,
0.2373626083,
-0.4198821783,
-0.505841732,
0.536911428,
-0.2729531527,
-0.1063887924,
0.5956132412,
-0.3148626685,
0.4371001124,
-0.5389456153,
0.42740646,
-0.3105843365,
-0.1863059402,
0.9664570093,
-0.6362848282,
0.8630204201,
0.4000114501,
-0.4226434529,
0.1078380197,
-0.8795784712,
0.2363646626,
0.329986155,
-0.4266343713,
-0.0500152037,
-0.1243506595,
-0.1332255751,
0.4653529227,
0.3990601599,
-0.6091176867,
0.2322334647,
-0.4949191511,
0.8548839092,
0.6859135628,
-0.0970342308,
0.4482565224,
-0.6135722399,
0.5908579826,
-0.1674741656,
0.1329248846,
-0.3078841567,
-0.7243406177,
-0.5225846767,
-0.3889681101,
0.1445558369,
0.4274623096,
-0.6923508644,
0.4421026111,
-0.088930048,
-0.9265583754,
-0.8634949923,
0.4707514942,
-0.1446697116,
0.0216967873,
-0.3983963728,
-0.2989526987,
-0.334321022,
-0.7648218274,
-0.48947981,
0.248204872,
-0.279607594,
0.3590755463,
0.3653404713,
-0.2930932939,
0.8063749671,
-0.2052744478,
-0.0454106294,
-0.5224874616,
0.3185787201,
0.6228545904,
0.3213973343,
0.3587870002,
-0.8112146854,
-0.2898042798,
0.0742943659,
-0.9353987575,
-0.3936258852,
-0.2266628891,
0.2489280552,
0.5125539303,
0.0432546027,
-1.023327589,
0.2531263232,
0.4317708015,
0.0535597727,
0.5261649489,
-0.2052570879,
-0.0466773324,
-0.8542292714,
0.0209485423,
-0.1910756826,
0.3603105843,
-0.5047417879,
0.0780833885,
-0.4113495648,
-0.2663814425,
-0.8200737834,
0.6139853001,
-0.4408904612,
-0.108698763,
-0.5209967494,
0.1524091214,
0.0149114542,
0.1721643806,
-0.1975715309,
0.2312682271,
0.5467434525,
-0.3794376552,
0.8805626035,
-0.131479308,
-0.6957784891,
0.2999088466,
-0.559319675,
0.3645882905,
-0.3971215785,
0.0693143532,
-1.0278584957,
-0.2830409408,
-0.108497262,
-0.3721343279,
-0.0543254651,
0.3331166208,
-0.9114030004,
-0.7726861238,
-0.1314062625,
0.1103445888,
0.7374566197,
-0.239503473,
0.4134817421,
0.3712312281,
-0.5192909241,
-0.1792363226,
-1.0212669373,
0.4071910977,
-0.4427106678,
-1.0308630466,
0.1767808944,
-0.4423529804,
-0.5671772957,
0.0493692569,
0.363682121,
0.2932782173,
0.2071438581,
0.3908581734,
-0.0053561456,
-0.1370787174,
-0.1514147669,
-0.2879002988,
-0.0960349739,
-0.0224544629,
-0.3806962073,
0.6741924882,
-0.1678397655,
-0.3037491441,
-0.376614362,
0.4767687321,
0.589933455,
-0.0846117958,
0.6195947528,
0.5071303844,
-0.3010216653,
-0.4716049731,
-0.6637239456,
0.3399266601,
-0.6111441851,
0.1516689658,
-0.1637497693,
-1.1646786928,
0.577049315,
0.0934991986,
-0.0563511215,
0.3979206383,
1.1047564745,
-0.2163276523,
0.8692030311,
0.7566189766,
0.3194161057,
0.2581778169,
-0.4010950625,
0.7192713618,
-0.5220846534,
-0.3681700528,
-0.3285961747,
-0.6786583662,
-0.7832083106,
-0.0954057053,
0.3137370348,
-0.098510392,
-0.3978615105,
-0.0865235999,
-0.4427418113,
0.490659982,
0.8413633704,
-0.3930903673,
0.2233311981,
-0.1839826703,
0.1318179518,
-0.0425687842,
-0.733137548,
-0.8194850087,
0.7931177616,
0.5928528309,
0.8669098616,
0.2666354179,
0.6747378707,
-0.0763658956,
0.1178376228,
-0.8515347838,
0.7039957047,
-0.1580563635,
-0.5037786961,
-0.4792387486,
-0.4292089045,
-0.8862161636,
-0.2633264661,
-0.1449465752,
-0.7827989459,
0.0212504715,
-0.2487154454,
-0.4707022607,
0.6365640163,
-0.5397239327,
0.5949209332,
-0.7257369757,
-0.4880158603,
-0.0843971074,
-0.5019942522,
0.4311870933,
-0.2639044225,
0.5537431836,
-0.0598959289,
0.0966273621,
0.5855768919,
-0.016841704,
0.6576767564,
0.261675626,
-0.473842144,
0.720887959,
0.3127128482,
0.1248929948,
-0.267723918,
-0.0638039038,
0.2084743828,
-0.2384396344,
-0.1360753179,
-0.6911195517,
0.8536534309,
-0.5305044055,
-0.9989772439,
-0.2545149326,
-1.0940504074,
-0.0380629078,
0.3380168378,
0.2716594636,
0.246188283,
0.0582851171,
0.413587749,
0.4536699951,
-0.7902598977,
0.7248157859,
0.356883198,
-0.263712734,
-0.3737884164,
0.8426495194,
0.5190050602,
0.3536321223,
0.0137058096,
0.2957487404,
-0.1859848499,
-0.44521451,
-0.2820268273,
0.3970727921,
-0.8026945591,
0.3803197443,
-0.4449124038,
-0.476265192,
-0.261698246,
-0.4305453002,
-0.183074072,
-0.4664621949,
-0.4036746025,
0.0808612853,
0.0935959369,
1.2459384203,
-0.0110728303,
0.0161552671,
-0.6596708894,
0.0825605914,
0.3583067358,
0.3842016459,
0.3136592507,
-0.3175149858,
-0.2390524298,
-0.0083329314,
-0.5861198902,
-0.4011857212,
0.394258827,
-0.4126113057,
0.4545062184,
0.4358576238,
-0.3252682388,
-0.0331913643,
-0.6020589471,
1.0356425047,
0.1745046526,
-0.5719227791,
0.1752875,
-0.3559619784,
0.3044651747,
-0.0358479433,
0.4710226953,
-0.6391777992,
-0.3590261936,
-0.8845786452,
-0.9033349156,
0.2418605536,
0.0367170908,
0.5717541575,
-0.0171978492,
0.1695384383,
0.402775228,
0.549849391,
-0.789193809,
0.0664592162,
0.1059487313,
-0.2400873005,
-0.1541738808,
-0.3400097489,
-0.0298780408,
-0.2082379907,
0.4563984871,
0.3586956263,
-0.0041052522,
-0.1601227224,
0.3508318961,
-0.3483086526,
0.5292315483,
0.5490578413,
0.7117576003,
0.3715884089,
0.2629286051,
-0.0800046697,
0.0310539547,
0.3287519813,
-0.4872409999,
-0.0141879749,
-0.1983202696,
0.3909884989,
0.8252258301,
-0.1284626275,
-1.0904499292,
0.3519801199,
0.4080350995,
-0.4054771066,
-0.5389091372,
0.3748793304,
0.515434444,
0.5755375028,
0.3365596831,
-0.0746340603,
-0.2098175138,
-1.1441113949,
-0.1609625667,
0.596322298,
-0.1208803207,
-0.3053480089,
0.753672719,
-0.0955297947,
-0.979115963,
0.2351091802,
-0.2532772124,
-0.5182964802,
0.703382194,
0.5525127649,
0.9958819747,
0.1026408076,
0.0588612445,
-0.3477682769,
0.3794101477,
-0.1053176299,
0.5014168024,
0.4213913679,
-0.7335895896,
-0.3255016208,
-0.6448954344,
-0.3980779946,
0.4706097841,
0.0805898309,
0.3047292233,
-0.5493089557,
-0.0560733713,
0.2654132247,
-0.1490120441,
-0.6418201327,
0.100947082,
0.5561563373,
0.6973767281,
-0.4904613197,
0.5345009565,
0.4849913716,
-0.3151504099,
-0.6831640601,
-0.3312750459,
0.0896114856,
-0.3872410655,
0.8091435432,
0.2986604869,
0.1270447969,
0.1507679075,
-0.7868047953,
-0.8797261119,
0.8326694965,
0.2396943122,
-0.6920599937,
-0.1310804337,
0.5228513479,
0.7821953893,
-0.53884238,
-0.2120322883,
0.3438870311,
0.5052412748,
0.3056141734,
-0.7225885391,
-0.2905902267,
-0.4258660674,
0.1809576005,
-0.0173810832,
-0.6193211675,
0.9913987517,
-0.3888226449,
-0.187661618,
0.3461781442,
0.527477622,
0.2105682045,
0.4151316881,
0.0394410677,
0.6283475757,
0.638720274,
0.0131524559,
1.1139672995,
-0.0939306542,
0.0444819219,
0.3822808564,
-0.5799127221,
0.6156974435,
0.2111879438,
-0.0428559296,
0.4787568152,
0.3812822402,
-0.3349192441,
0.1584352255,
0.704215169,
-0.3016714156,
0.0462021753,
-0.0850695372,
0.0173199885,
0.225150764,
0.2772405148,
-0.2885923684,
0.1850566566,
0.3587456048,
-0.0654230937,
0.2838134468,
-0.3120935857,
0.7414927483,
0.4350743592,
-0.6272867918,
0.3798006475,
0.0444344431,
0.6287032366,
-0.3267642558,
0.2767200768,
0.1901768893,
0.0263950396,
-0.14872168,
-1.2132006884,
0.2857837975,
0.0238211006,
-0.1423898041,
-0.2676050663,
0.5385718346,
-0.3914121389,
-0.6458148956,
-0.0518876277,
0.4704799056,
0.2393262982,
0.0335847475,
-0.3140308261,
0.3070486784,
-0.2990687191,
-0.3445718884,
0.0460654236,
1.1058783531,
0.0608943626,
0.9482834339,
0.5920179486,
0.3526370525,
-0.0609685779,
0.0453922935,
0.5430629253,
-0.9789253473,
-0.570802927,
-0.9546736479,
0.5897305012,
0.1833168417,
-0.3947528899,
0.6701890826,
0.4746947289,
0.7011157274,
-0.1527719498,
0.9027667642,
-0.0443874225,
0.4407068491,
-0.4752189517,
0.9723741412,
-0.5060327053,
0.3834549487,
-0.2919742763,
-0.9344791174,
-0.2596329153,
0.160671249,
-0.5121579766,
0.1617529094,
0.6670203209,
0.6142581105,
0.2328093946,
0.2030778676,
0.4482756555,
0.4458247125,
0.272382617,
0.676178813,
1.3461495638,
0.2308622897,
0.051788006,
-0.1882493049,
-0.2682947516,
-0.0722358301,
-0.9946141243,
-0.8119542003,
-0.6697550416,
-0.1098459736,
-0.1999185383,
-0.4770067632,
0.7674962878,
0.0290036798,
-0.3078112602,
-0.239134565,
0.0335086063,
0.0340810828,
0.1360438466,
-0.189156726,
0.0211497154,
-0.0356246866,
-0.796125412,
0.2570137382,
0.6302054524,
0.4231170416,
-0.7763418555,
0.1607564688,
0.273435384,
0.507912159,
0.7636796236,
0.0802352503,
-0.9326875806,
-0.3291736543,
-0.0656731203,
-0.2308184505,
-0.2244345397,
0.7281248569,
-0.533505559,
0.1403623968,
0.4449868798,
0.7172478437,
0.1038813367,
-0.2983938158,
0.3318661749,
-0.2751729488,
0.3252144456,
0.5562846661,
0.2769519687,
0.5113204718,
-0.3699935079,
0.2610737383,
0.4753327668,
-0.5473650098,
-0.9355689287,
0.6294526458,
-0.8612263203,
-0.4683559835,
1.1917490959,
0.2294408381,
-0.5316729546,
0.285069257,
-0.3191053271,
0.0937940031,
0.3339801431,
0.8867022991,
1.0750300884,
0.1133078039,
-0.2136484087,
-0.8332790136,
0.1636835337,
0.3075782955,
-0.4085513055,
-0.1817085892,
0.2468337268,
0.1717287898,
0.2019346654,
0.4860095084,
-0.1453932673,
0.0246728454,
-0.1827305108,
0.247425735,
-0.1624772698,
-0.3944323063,
-0.2844453156,
0.4556908011,
0.3242513537,
0.4301147759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15445v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15445v3 | IRFL: Image Recognition of Figurative Language | 2023-03-27T17:59:55 | 2023-11-25T22:07:55 | Ron Yosef, Yonatan Bitton, Dafna Shahaf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Figures of speech such as metaphors, similes, and idioms are integral parts
of human communication. They are ubiquitous in many forms of discourse,
allowing people to convey complex, abstract ideas and evoke emotion. As
figurative forms are often conveyed through multiple modalities (e.g., both
text and images), understanding multimodal figurative language is an important
AI challenge, weaving together profound vision, language, commonsense and
cultural knowledge. In this work, we develop the Image Recognition of
Figurative Language (IRFL) dataset. We leverage human annotation and an
automatic pipeline we created to generate a multimodal dataset, and introduce
two novel tasks as a benchmark for multimodal figurative language
understanding. We experimented with state-of-the-art vision and language models
and found that the best (22%) performed substantially worse than humans (97%).
We release our dataset, benchmark, and code, in hopes of driving the
development of models that can better understand figurative language. | [
-0.4744872451,
-0.5273964405,
0.0470932014,
0.25167346,
-0.4298232496,
0.1123721302,
-0.1506015956,
-0.9761176705,
-0.175968647,
0.2720939219,
-0.4964512289,
-0.1393865496,
-0.7051514983,
0.2210308015,
-0.4221557975,
0.6604742408,
0.1260923147,
0.1324438453,
-0.327032119,
-0.523812294,
-0.207822293,
-0.11098665,
-0.5663551688,
-0.3238708973,
0.3780682683,
0.2926270366,
0.8578417897,
0.5977435112,
0.7093288302,
0.3735743761,
0.2849264145,
0.2380657643,
-0.3347999752,
0.1472288668,
0.0179271922,
-0.1802247316,
0.4124218524,
0.1867440939,
0.6551161408,
0.3382451236,
0.1250749826,
0.0771954507,
-0.4794431925,
0.6497733593,
-0.5302706957,
0.6182237267,
-0.6836410165,
0.4027579725,
-0.2769919336,
-0.2683361173,
-0.5240567923,
-0.0005221247,
0.1110753119,
-0.4913452566,
0.1074098796,
0.2306144983,
0.9346639514,
0.5754071474,
-0.5591188073,
-0.2481521815,
-0.3284844756,
0.67279917,
-0.2797124088,
0.4706884027,
0.4494728148,
0.4959110618,
-0.078178525,
-0.7722002864,
-0.6619411111,
-0.6105787158,
-0.5363389254,
-0.1382543892,
-0.2843199074,
-0.2192667276,
0.120305039,
0.1832696199,
-0.6912564039,
-0.1943417788,
-0.4139600694,
-0.2932785153,
0.7002624273,
-0.0771115869,
0.3796359599,
-0.002509434,
-0.7446480393,
-0.3480342329,
-0.3301434517,
-0.2583225965,
-0.0811827779,
0.1932023615,
-0.1993390471,
0.3656362593,
0.017340187,
1.0117640495,
-0.6015755534,
-0.4147037268,
0.4830889404,
0.0268977117,
-0.2024753541,
-0.0291402843,
0.7420092225,
0.2172243595,
0.6222943664,
-0.027014168,
-0.3972143829,
0.2158411294,
0.025039643,
-0.5419986248,
-0.0623265766,
-0.0914702564,
-0.3712743521,
-0.315248847,
0.1292280555,
-0.3390511274,
-0.7195926309,
-0.3859949112,
0.3308453262,
-0.7163366079,
-0.2042005062,
0.0655425414,
-0.3767198324,
0.2702847719,
0.3570720255,
-0.3899677694,
0.0779762939,
0.4194547534,
0.7148438692,
0.198591888,
-0.5837461948,
-0.5655427575,
0.292968154,
-0.1045212969,
1.0792423487,
-0.5745557547,
-0.0147779575,
-0.1713933796,
-0.2434660196,
-0.1106614619,
-0.4918604493,
0.5672780275,
-0.1523443013,
0.2206546813,
0.3685646951,
-0.2981603742,
-0.4976952374,
0.3048149049,
-0.8861318231,
0.7862763405,
-0.0308087356,
-0.6973608136,
0.1455718726,
-0.7668518424,
-0.5958253145,
0.2209765613,
-0.6263338327,
-0.0958223715,
0.3685485423,
0.0520754941,
0.704621911,
-0.8376063704,
0.1955756396,
-0.076423265,
-0.2714178562,
0.6636710167,
-0.5736559629,
0.6858389378,
0.6413137913,
-0.3125004768,
-0.1171894893,
-0.6418024898,
0.0242604278,
0.279330045,
0.0613432378,
-0.306237787,
-0.1290957481,
0.8054838181,
0.526298821,
-0.0656173304,
-0.3277057111,
-0.0572682284,
0.284014672,
0.5581873655,
0.6750698686,
-0.4414560795,
-0.2003061324,
-0.3773159683,
0.3603495061,
0.3675512373,
0.0184056275,
-0.2161398828,
-0.3610497415,
-0.5746585727,
-0.7586394548,
0.1235702485,
0.3037467599,
-0.908303082,
-0.0683396459,
-0.1835616529,
-0.5844416618,
-0.581225872,
-0.0606991872,
0.6183405519,
0.6045067906,
0.1328539699,
-0.2933213115,
-0.1803238094,
-1.2422276735,
-0.2041262984,
-0.4719640315,
0.2982524037,
0.2547375858,
0.4762215912,
-0.2560446858,
0.801060617,
-0.4751623869,
-0.6930890083,
0.1619677246,
0.8137292266,
-0.193867445,
0.6357653737,
0.9385405183,
-1.1925017834,
-0.3832639456,
0.0712359771,
-0.8360980153,
0.0477890223,
-0.2440175414,
-0.0783137977,
0.2208893001,
0.5644499063,
-0.3241135776,
0.2505448163,
0.4494274855,
-0.7756784558,
0.3067271709,
-0.015003928,
0.3089197874,
-0.4599776566,
0.0677212402,
0.2963831723,
-0.264110446,
-0.5921143889,
0.2557618916,
0.0662083551,
-0.0440396294,
-0.8175443411,
0.7102206945,
-0.618452847,
0.0037419442,
-0.0287993383,
-0.1867336929,
-0.0844295099,
0.3518196642,
0.4676773846,
0.8079392314,
0.5928717256,
-0.0448400155,
0.3632885218,
-0.0762765706,
-0.6274269223,
0.6831236482,
-0.4067025483,
0.2230648398,
-0.6100195646,
0.0541813485,
-1.2115105391,
-0.3868631124,
0.1928626597,
-0.278565675,
0.240878731,
0.2775239348,
-0.7772484422,
-0.0155701973,
-0.0101762824,
0.6998258829,
0.316996783,
-0.4060400724,
0.8172207475,
0.4602500796,
0.3074031174,
-0.7681401968,
-0.8323235512,
0.0786498338,
-0.2475202084,
-0.6364884973,
0.1193300784,
0.0168003514,
-0.4181647003,
-0.0106459754,
0.250151068,
-0.4545518756,
-0.0621830299,
0.227330178,
0.0617279522,
-0.1872376055,
0.3801672459,
-0.3754577637,
-0.1387146711,
-0.0329365097,
0.1690689921,
0.4612779915,
-0.5661588311,
-0.3765306175,
-0.722376287,
0.382343173,
1.3245774508,
-0.2277655452,
0.5733540654,
1.0374548435,
-0.5881603956,
0.285885632,
-0.7120158076,
-0.0883881673,
-0.4010810256,
0.3366761208,
-0.6078408957,
-0.5099179149,
0.3587283194,
0.1581732035,
-0.0748021007,
0.3694916368,
0.3232609928,
-0.0699016899,
0.7216544747,
0.485670954,
-0.1997745186,
0.4204264879,
-0.0178561993,
-0.1342837363,
-0.2692204714,
-0.4288038015,
-0.6057734489,
-0.5256371498,
-0.2028096765,
-0.6202206612,
0.296467185,
-0.289470017,
-0.0613220222,
0.1823946089,
-0.3757719398,
0.5088673234,
0.486269325,
0.1181802377,
0.4956712425,
0.3000645041,
0.0481573679,
-0.1224524081,
-0.3505637944,
-0.3635857999,
0.3168514073,
0.4083006382,
0.8531843424,
0.1224970371,
0.2964207828,
0.6276606321,
0.5003184676,
-0.7907454371,
0.5303200483,
-0.2472642511,
-0.7537655234,
-0.0304490793,
-0.1863363087,
-0.4936908782,
0.5406706929,
-0.3374869525,
-0.454102397,
0.1247368827,
0.2812353373,
0.2197814733,
0.0107622966,
-0.910246551,
1.0086414814,
-0.4636161923,
-0.1169806942,
-0.2755318582,
-0.8463055491,
0.4136237204,
0.0738599971,
0.4878917336,
-0.3813949525,
-0.1662195474,
0.5706310272,
-0.1457315236,
0.7521262765,
-0.0215702876,
0.0807982832,
0.2330369353,
0.0678441226,
0.2408548594,
-0.0460261367,
-0.1214984506,
0.2376636863,
0.023254158,
-0.3612063229,
-0.5405936837,
0.3589596748,
-0.7280719876,
-0.1624125242,
-0.7740867734,
-0.9171378016,
-0.173522532,
0.0302206986,
0.0589003973,
0.44434762,
-0.1384935379,
0.1163440049,
0.2001872659,
-0.0506699793,
0.3783499599,
0.4183958769,
-0.0509316362,
-0.2410437018,
0.9276011586,
-0.1838310957,
0.1984262466,
0.3986332417,
0.2451774329,
-0.4606274366,
-0.1034176126,
-0.4061903954,
0.4998141825,
-0.9978637695,
-0.3893464804,
-0.4410406053,
-0.0800108165,
-0.2144586891,
-0.1168411821,
-0.1874043047,
-0.4850518107,
-0.3382771909,
0.2521499991,
0.779915154,
0.6864839196,
-0.0762283206,
0.0249988306,
-0.6197732091,
0.32586658,
0.2556603849,
0.1885258108,
0.0238939896,
-0.306003511,
0.1280590892,
-0.0831740201,
0.2546510398,
-0.6433746219,
0.3681828678,
0.6792777181,
0.3220208883,
0.7934505939,
0.1081122458,
1.0334607363,
-0.4271642268,
0.3821326196,
0.4715220034,
-0.8391731977,
0.3734660447,
-0.0799923986,
0.4255484343,
0.5553675294,
0.3949786425,
-0.7573569417,
-0.3888446987,
-0.4267202914,
-0.38829723,
0.7281218171,
0.2178346813,
0.1096953154,
-0.0737820864,
-0.0609434471,
0.1293006986,
0.3304696381,
-0.9562196732,
-0.282764256,
-0.2212235332,
-0.4586357772,
-0.1153505072,
0.0444371067,
-0.3921324909,
-0.4517255127,
0.44149369,
-0.293633163,
0.3996745646,
-0.0842788443,
-0.3844204247,
-0.0418476425,
-0.0338632911,
0.9266882539,
0.4602725804,
-0.0903983712,
0.5066305995,
-0.2896245718,
-0.6688718796,
0.0409329087,
0.2278131992,
0.1511774659,
0.1521576941,
0.6626387835,
0.8481943011,
-0.0381905809,
-1.397490859,
0.3550309539,
-0.2877563834,
-0.0412667319,
-0.5565046668,
-0.1027392,
-0.0751607418,
0.3159246445,
0.5625329018,
0.2504574358,
0.0822287798,
-0.6725253463,
0.20484972,
0.5929965377,
-0.5032243133,
0.0107510695,
0.4139441848,
0.0059239226,
-0.1783554852,
0.8252354264,
-0.0296973791,
-0.4072657228,
0.6581724882,
0.671862185,
0.654076159,
0.1769837886,
0.4375574887,
0.0645286813,
0.3553342819,
0.205878213,
0.2869422436,
0.0225189291,
-0.794172585,
-0.0563027374,
-0.4891906381,
-0.0652951747,
0.1589450985,
-0.5148769021,
0.3296090066,
-0.297003448,
0.1607370973,
0.1673526913,
-0.4889371693,
-0.7792993784,
0.3887315094,
0.3545449078,
0.8909038901,
-1.0691765547,
0.8089615107,
1.0333516598,
-0.5415052176,
-0.5562940836,
-0.2075067163,
0.2633084655,
-1.0774472952,
1.1104000807,
0.4383237064,
-0.3951328099,
-0.0299516972,
-0.6585818529,
-0.7099574804,
1.0110189915,
0.6264327168,
-0.1309754848,
0.2140040994,
0.2579979002,
0.5329537988,
-0.7030544877,
0.4943829179,
0.3902890384,
0.6683927178,
0.408146292,
-0.7904637456,
0.1025879532,
-0.3496929705,
0.1604237109,
0.0512957536,
-0.6218083501,
0.922927916,
-0.1602965742,
-0.2745124102,
-0.0372283049,
0.7669020295,
0.1638026536,
0.2029094398,
0.8425590992,
0.3809921741,
0.4594503045,
-0.2458000034,
0.826687932,
-0.132263124,
0.2177377939,
0.8907416463,
-0.0709237605,
0.7688663602,
0.7425826788,
0.1111411899,
0.2811547816,
0.4706248939,
0.1253820658,
0.5572843552,
0.1684487164,
-0.4711748362,
-0.2717619836,
-0.6112112403,
-0.3694628477,
0.8970218301,
0.4675600231,
-0.4116402268,
-0.3351548314,
0.3859528899,
-0.098122865,
0.0420375094,
0.0473528169,
0.5766723752,
-0.1839560866,
-0.4708892405,
0.8532137871,
-0.1998132169,
0.5515925884,
-0.4581023157,
-0.2803052068,
0.0249459036,
0.1242047995,
-0.1299261749,
-0.7518351078,
0.2403834462,
-0.2104656547,
0.0283805598,
-0.1325040311,
0.5843468308,
-0.6059727073,
-0.6023945808,
0.1121380776,
0.3728549778,
0.5271689892,
0.025452327,
-1.0749467611,
0.4883165061,
-0.0327046141,
0.0065735877,
0.1104901135,
0.4347315133,
-0.0523101762,
0.8521975279,
0.2350096405,
-0.2473013848,
-0.05054079,
0.1030545011,
0.6801337004,
-0.5456956625,
-0.1895508766,
-0.6088219285,
0.6850531697,
-0.0633686557,
-0.4103502631,
0.0990357697,
0.2433768511,
0.8621977568,
-0.6089493632,
0.4916578233,
-0.4990124404,
0.043221958,
-0.4723456502,
0.857558012,
-0.8986086845,
-0.2197517157,
-0.4679451287,
-0.5602248311,
-0.6817617416,
1.1446038485,
0.2331564426,
-0.1692079902,
0.7867182493,
0.7583560944,
-0.1459566355,
0.1469951272,
0.4063388705,
0.0007231584,
0.164176181,
0.3573049903,
0.9014562368,
-0.4394080341,
0.4247015417,
-0.507732749,
-0.1396692395,
-0.0179715808,
-1.1641846895,
-0.8017836809,
-1.1542575359,
-0.5139635801,
-0.0961148366,
-0.0294630509,
1.1481304169,
0.7503359914,
-0.6627576947,
-0.4977094531,
0.0832958296,
-0.0832599327,
-0.446583122,
-0.2458968908,
0.214228645,
-0.2367462367,
-0.8697600365,
0.0527076945,
0.2169190347,
0.236294508,
-0.3005921543,
-0.0828935951,
-0.691537559,
-0.2932666242,
0.7808718681,
0.3957906961,
-1.0142159462,
-0.4264390469,
-0.3448461294,
-0.136083439,
0.0174361989,
0.851472199,
-0.9307136536,
0.548936069,
0.3315754235,
0.5982419252,
0.0970907062,
-0.1245688349,
0.303211391,
-0.7340769768,
0.8002646565,
0.3561070859,
0.5699653625,
0.3808960915,
-0.2895692587,
0.8910388947,
0.3244472146,
-0.0717225149,
-0.931720078,
0.3190103769,
-0.9867173433,
-0.3992981613,
0.8095723391,
-0.1236351207,
-0.1475442499,
0.022395676,
-0.4199125767,
-0.031677492,
-0.4364370406,
0.6512150168,
0.6650739908,
-0.5223212242,
-0.5963845253,
-0.1820832342,
0.308334589,
0.4119488001,
-0.7895733714,
-0.0095618712,
0.98900491,
-0.0558845587,
0.3374029696,
0.5490475893,
-0.1436153203,
0.32228598,
-0.1541458219,
-0.1057270095,
-0.2315399349,
-0.5766839385,
-0.2416110486,
0.2947150767,
0.1296791732,
-0.2108812481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15441v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15441v1 | Zero-shot Model Diagnosis | 2023-03-27T17:59:33 | 2023-03-27T17:59:33 | Jinqi Luo, Zhaoning Wang, Chen Henry Wu, Dong Huang, Fernando De la Torre | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | When it comes to deploying deep vision models, the behavior of these systems
must be explicable to ensure confidence in their reliability and fairness. A
common approach to evaluate deep learning models is to build a labeled test set
with attributes of interest and assess how well it performs. However, creating
a balanced test set (i.e., one that is uniformly sampled over all the important
traits) is often time-consuming, expensive, and prone to mistakes. The question
we try to address is: can we evaluate the sensitivity of deep learning models
to arbitrary visual attributes without an annotated test set? This paper argues
the case that Zero-shot Model Diagnosis (ZOOM) is possible without the need for
a test set nor labeling. To avoid the need for test sets, our system relies on
a generative model and CLIP. The key idea is enabling the user to select a set
of prompts (relevant to the problem) and our system will automatically search
for semantic counterfactual images (i.e., synthesized images that flip the
prediction in the case of a binary classifier) using the generative model. We
evaluate several visual tasks (classification, key-point detection, and
segmentation) in multiple visual domains to demonstrate the viability of our
methodology. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method is capable of
producing counterfactual images and offering sensitivity analysis for model
diagnosis without the need for a test set. | [
-0.5532465577,
-0.6908662319,
0.4840478003,
-0.1312239766,
-0.2913815379,
-0.4131758809,
0.1092724279,
-0.4042731225,
-0.1763399541,
0.3354368508,
-0.8008301854,
-0.3480476141,
-0.5043849349,
-0.1187733561,
-0.5739806294,
0.7861949801,
0.1639750004,
-0.0043434626,
-0.4161505103,
-0.3228822351,
-0.7440089583,
-0.1027762666,
-0.5146914721,
-0.3265033662,
0.4104609787,
0.367759794,
0.9764971137,
0.3858377337,
0.6584122777,
0.2082727849,
-0.0028233025,
-0.0714071468,
-0.3749176562,
0.1064254642,
-0.0824339241,
-0.431245178,
-0.4446484447,
0.0421218239,
0.3555190563,
0.8420020938,
0.4467184842,
0.0426207557,
-0.1525066048,
0.2881006598,
-0.9379137754,
-0.1635442972,
-0.6117833257,
0.6175556183,
0.1007369831,
-0.1149031445,
-0.2735834718,
0.2353140861,
0.171609208,
-0.77995193,
0.7818772197,
-0.4632939696,
0.9918144345,
0.4365884066,
-0.2350839376,
0.2736028135,
-0.7514960766,
0.7373844385,
-0.4889672697,
0.1311942339,
0.0807216316,
0.4294021428,
0.0474613309,
-0.3668706417,
-0.6927469969,
-0.3203826845,
0.2444088161,
0.1616511792,
-0.4151037335,
0.0047075953,
0.5764300823,
0.4230058193,
-0.7310376167,
0.5121436119,
-0.2820234895,
-0.1955083311,
0.5721292496,
0.3618276715,
0.3483909369,
-0.0108663756,
-0.3344283402,
-0.2335522175,
-0.6084830165,
-0.0421000533,
-0.0193587746,
0.4219242632,
0.0218670461,
0.6979783773,
-0.3425883949,
0.7839689851,
0.2824013531,
0.2050737143,
0.1446894556,
-0.072632499,
-0.6079790592,
-0.1858039498,
0.7544744611,
0.7760500908,
0.5057774186,
-0.1211046875,
-0.2283488363,
0.575548768,
0.5836645961,
-0.9929041862,
-0.3874931335,
0.2022865713,
-0.2812094092,
-0.7268427014,
-0.4295146763,
-0.5940045714,
-0.3327811956,
-0.1748258322,
0.8858189583,
-0.4242001772,
-0.2077853233,
0.0622214228,
-0.3001983166,
0.2058989257,
0.3780771196,
-0.5862515569,
-0.2435144484,
0.396512568,
0.8359854817,
0.115793936,
-0.3781141937,
-0.4771104753,
-0.1826954186,
-0.8005675673,
0.7751463056,
-0.4824981093,
-0.587177515,
-0.1267502755,
0.1582336128,
0.0770112351,
-0.581951499,
0.1891549975,
-0.2198039144,
-0.229577437,
-0.3192812502,
-0.5226459503,
-0.1975134313,
0.5240511894,
-0.4282550812,
0.6835228205,
0.2282565087,
-0.3080476522,
0.8419710398,
-0.5764168501,
-0.3861234486,
0.4466400743,
-0.2817734182,
-0.6809495091,
0.2893562317,
0.3611834645,
0.6179995537,
0.1759574413,
0.2114864588,
-0.8071687222,
-0.4575275481,
0.1149624065,
-0.4341476262,
0.8867973685,
-0.0689348206,
-0.4967797101,
0.161580354,
-0.7760273814,
0.0869555771,
0.245218873,
0.3586094677,
-0.1084561497,
-0.2817618251,
-0.2455168962,
0.0549206361,
-0.1966946125,
-0.5218159556,
0.2540771961,
-0.181895867,
0.0660454482,
0.5002979636,
-0.0222304724,
0.2788367867,
-0.1829691976,
0.6018015742,
0.424130857,
0.5512498021,
-0.4723010063,
-0.7254171968,
-1.2911795378,
-0.307292074,
0.035763111,
0.4698458314,
-0.5888237357,
0.5660497546,
-0.1331747472,
-0.5511733294,
-0.4570939839,
-0.0459778011,
0.4544424415,
0.8197875023,
0.3923658431,
-0.578728497,
-0.1855193079,
-1.0303155184,
0.264000386,
0.1823375374,
-0.2651604712,
0.4432162046,
0.7614789605,
-0.1154583171,
0.6388962865,
-0.7070690393,
-0.3644108772,
0.027535025,
0.3332091868,
-0.1056638584,
0.415661633,
0.8149468899,
-0.7270810604,
-0.128282696,
-0.1419291496,
-1.106683135,
0.1536485851,
-0.0049844487,
0.1547576189,
-0.0480167307,
0.4660364091,
-0.6039013267,
1.1378958225,
0.0678602085,
-0.2348246127,
0.6607668996,
-0.1228867844,
0.1864926815,
-0.3390330076,
0.3222178221,
0.0857501402,
-0.1937791705,
-0.7175917029,
0.5077760816,
0.0177955199,
-0.5069884062,
-0.325597614,
0.3194380701,
0.0855039507,
-0.0965114683,
-0.3403121233,
-0.1300610602,
0.3499979973,
0.2750824988,
0.2281990647,
0.6895920634,
0.8208664656,
-0.8367989063,
0.390232265,
0.1812457144,
-0.2562596202,
1.0444425344,
-0.884345293,
-0.0772410929,
-0.1877072603,
-0.1934536844,
-0.8792251945,
-0.1278412938,
0.2876601517,
-0.5271792412,
0.3678578138,
-0.1537184417,
-0.0477403812,
-0.4091698527,
-0.2576015294,
0.4893881679,
0.5078375936,
-0.4557980299,
0.1206862405,
-0.157659173,
0.263995558,
-0.5455961823,
-0.8782061934,
0.0686306432,
-0.0310088787,
-0.463839978,
0.1909779906,
-0.166765511,
0.0125443246,
0.2357661873,
0.2796659172,
-0.2446119338,
0.4847420454,
0.5424235463,
0.5994427204,
-0.482793659,
0.3851365745,
-0.4335997105,
-0.2149552554,
-0.3594677448,
0.091649279,
0.1009777412,
-0.2181891501,
-0.5640618801,
-0.2159776837,
0.467184186,
0.5874072313,
-0.2190206051,
0.3727701604,
0.6403326392,
-0.3974367976,
-0.2795666754,
-0.2789995968,
-0.1349144429,
-0.4298955798,
0.3225230575,
-0.3200657666,
-0.6121825576,
0.5220044255,
0.1783140302,
-0.3116857111,
0.7556579709,
0.5911007524,
-0.1954958439,
0.895475328,
0.9490230083,
0.1880216599,
0.0145388106,
-0.4238977432,
0.581397593,
-0.5678316951,
-0.2734603286,
-0.2122639567,
-0.3715062737,
-0.3261305392,
-0.2697398961,
0.599606812,
0.0957323462,
-0.3868469596,
0.1763669252,
-0.8253359199,
0.5718092322,
0.5669549704,
0.3467534482,
0.1174029484,
-0.2365641892,
-0.0880272165,
-0.0640201643,
-0.6136015058,
-0.1845758706,
1.1497024298,
0.0636934116,
0.4397747517,
-0.3416788876,
0.1792749763,
0.3467537165,
0.2353864759,
-1.3567932844,
0.45748353,
-0.4113631845,
-0.7581272721,
-0.4365720451,
-0.1105271131,
-0.7495138645,
0.045236472,
-0.1477264613,
-0.5317032933,
0.6234586835,
0.3622177243,
-0.9580266476,
0.2830248177,
-0.6644308567,
1.1470060349,
-0.1911003292,
-0.2605950832,
0.0060964562,
-0.3973109126,
0.5964506269,
0.0005673424,
-0.3510703743,
-0.3174708486,
0.2600890398,
0.4003762305,
-0.4101430476,
1.0048720837,
-0.1684086174,
0.2882125676,
0.081389375,
0.4135662019,
-0.1918541789,
-0.2613258064,
0.1873774379,
0.3274402022,
-0.0272348076,
-0.3114458621,
-0.7586647272,
0.5226643682,
-0.5455831289,
-0.4005957246,
-0.353844583,
-0.5007956028,
-0.2301922888,
0.2426692098,
0.478630662,
0.4524624646,
-0.1269724071,
0.0172262229,
0.6847154498,
-0.306854248,
0.598287046,
0.4750051796,
-0.190361917,
0.1026280895,
0.9098094702,
0.1929591745,
0.2244059891,
-0.0031761366,
0.078973107,
0.2392487079,
-0.5101729631,
-0.6076048017,
-0.3084150255,
-0.686910212,
-0.5809692144,
-0.136192739,
-0.4855872691,
-0.2758098245,
-0.4984411597,
-0.6305806041,
-0.2284563929,
-0.5643798113,
-0.1240339875,
0.247312054,
0.4637097418,
-0.1348249018,
0.1637568921,
-0.3696646988,
0.5940645933,
0.6817686558,
0.4716775119,
0.1862587929,
-0.5137052536,
0.1464611292,
-0.0663659796,
-0.5750412941,
-0.5132704377,
0.3553009927,
0.3565343916,
0.2508839071,
0.7765112519,
0.1532303393,
0.9641123414,
-0.3755193353,
0.8850128651,
0.4668290615,
-0.9208943844,
0.8419154286,
-0.1024975628,
0.3308582902,
0.4387375116,
0.6116937399,
-0.2847435772,
-0.1768493652,
-0.5386075377,
-0.6015895009,
0.385073185,
-0.1274607182,
0.2312261611,
0.0183165688,
0.292869091,
0.1179128587,
-0.0127502214,
-0.537843585,
-0.116273962,
-0.5582492352,
0.1628100574,
-0.1860796809,
-0.3789528608,
-0.3652038872,
-0.5763747692,
0.3141867816,
-0.3183290064,
0.1256426275,
0.428088963,
-0.1782356948,
-0.2331150919,
0.0460049324,
0.4965050519,
0.5728886127,
-0.3612512648,
0.0605467446,
0.0288987271,
-0.1982740611,
0.1655513644,
-0.228062883,
-0.6771062016,
-0.0199255496,
0.5772169232,
1.1063276529,
0.3717329502,
-0.5839948654,
1.0773431063,
0.2319200486,
-0.4857701063,
-0.0560466945,
0.224395752,
-0.3279892206,
0.1913038939,
0.164675504,
0.2730717659,
0.3738251626,
-0.4997327924,
0.3471589983,
0.6949714422,
-0.8030094504,
-0.3532401919,
0.497418046,
0.2071104348,
-0.1560930461,
1.0871516466,
-0.3305249214,
-0.6251676083,
0.8908240199,
0.0828408077,
1.0113654137,
-0.0975445211,
0.6245478392,
0.3031058908,
0.3820637763,
0.2829150558,
0.058398813,
-0.0595594831,
-0.9863355756,
-0.2285748273,
-0.3984376192,
-0.3774581254,
0.5078454018,
-0.7287611961,
0.2728801072,
-0.6620266438,
-0.2448225617,
0.5831224322,
-0.3442418873,
-0.8899707794,
0.6227442622,
0.3524285853,
0.7892766595,
-1.1124209166,
0.3124161065,
0.1261176914,
-0.645023942,
-0.413590759,
-0.3402870297,
-0.1099426672,
-1.154435873,
0.7094400525,
0.5274255872,
0.1059165969,
-0.4208757579,
-0.8331170082,
-0.2021534294,
0.8327524066,
0.6382544637,
-0.4321765304,
0.2441695333,
-0.1134568825,
0.5383447409,
-0.2023255378,
0.3533023,
0.2951872647,
0.3120208383,
0.5136580467,
-0.9190303683,
0.0456904098,
-0.2499908954,
0.0396164693,
-0.0088852756,
-0.3764277995,
0.9340803623,
-0.6555742621,
-0.1555622369,
0.0788780376,
0.1214935556,
-0.2500914335,
0.5457364917,
0.3612394035,
1.0833077431,
0.4781367481,
0.0502902605,
1.1962707043,
0.0136605082,
0.3309110403,
1.0140999556,
-0.4087435901,
0.7520998716,
0.2629777193,
-0.2159280926,
0.0026515226,
0.5317099094,
-0.7942750454,
0.5803727508,
0.0942396373,
-0.2915616333,
-0.9387378693,
-0.3892932832,
-0.3906818628,
0.6688696146,
0.0244256016,
-0.3664728105,
-0.5124495029,
0.0773946047,
-0.3071204722,
-0.3079901636,
-0.4707674682,
0.549318552,
-0.0543932244,
-0.4504665434,
0.5363470316,
-0.3697681129,
0.5468138456,
-0.3364899755,
-0.1451007128,
-0.2540264726,
0.2566095293,
-0.3574078381,
-0.8217540383,
0.3901515007,
-0.078588903,
-0.401928097,
0.176525265,
0.7496500015,
0.0479307212,
-1.0432043076,
0.1584622115,
0.2384990901,
0.1818789393,
-0.440006882,
-0.3866819143,
-0.0850599557,
-0.3227289319,
0.0142650185,
0.2446053922,
0.2083619088,
0.1024090052,
0.8058131337,
0.3757865727,
-0.0623429567,
-0.0567313619,
0.2299352139,
0.8410372138,
-0.4731445312,
0.0290194787,
-0.9033774137,
0.5759915709,
-0.0226050373,
-0.4553382397,
0.4510082304,
0.1971415579,
0.8048791885,
-0.2671579123,
0.7112150788,
0.260645777,
0.0707940161,
-0.1168411523,
0.7219237685,
-0.7691832781,
-0.1899216175,
-0.0445566922,
-0.2700082064,
-0.7790548801,
0.5515729189,
-0.2650920749,
0.0458001569,
0.410084933,
0.887152195,
-0.2215247452,
-0.1805894226,
0.8568025231,
-0.0384383872,
0.1220656335,
0.6992240548,
0.6984098554,
-0.4524367452,
0.4763256013,
-0.433414638,
-0.3462152481,
-0.4531182349,
-1.0624194145,
-0.8751304746,
-0.296300739,
-0.710695684,
-0.0196917802,
-0.0175384339,
-0.0039004989,
1.0498789549,
-0.8177009225,
0.4418458045,
-0.15273045,
0.0444009528,
-0.1546176225,
-0.2129113078,
0.1154012159,
-0.3304064274,
-0.3380693793,
0.1906473637,
0.6216357946,
0.2608706355,
-0.4551320076,
0.2055140883,
0.2545835972,
-0.1947882175,
0.550986886,
0.4414400756,
-0.6228433847,
-0.444444865,
-0.044562906,
0.1879064739,
0.0803632736,
0.5975853205,
-0.8860013485,
0.8460491896,
0.0720692277,
0.4388045073,
0.4338321984,
-0.4684200585,
0.5557284951,
-0.4920143187,
0.1689397842,
0.4070780575,
0.1142296866,
0.4589913189,
-0.4801666141,
0.3931908607,
0.4184361398,
-0.354349494,
-0.8698288798,
0.3287339807,
-0.9075962901,
-0.3354755044,
0.6054843664,
-0.5100769401,
-0.1002309769,
0.1316804588,
0.2586283088,
0.0986502692,
0.1605897993,
0.7979077101,
0.4463060796,
-0.1749588549,
-0.2806881666,
-0.4716554284,
0.2245891541,
0.5661309958,
-0.2638195753,
-0.2591067255,
0.4101050496,
0.4234488904,
0.200492382,
0.2820724249,
0.0239555556,
0.587222755,
0.3853492439,
0.282058984,
-0.3973010182,
-0.3670934141,
-0.5574725866,
0.3271244168,
-0.1125412509,
-0.5810307264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15430v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15430v2 | TextMI: Textualize Multimodal Information for Integrating Non-verbal Cues in Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-03-27T17:54:32 | 2023-03-29T04:49:46 | Md Kamrul Hasan, Md Saiful Islam, Sangwu Lee, Wasifur Rahman, Iftekhar Naim, Mohammed Ibrahim Khan, Ehsan Hoque | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pre-trained large language models have recently achieved ground-breaking
performance in a wide variety of language understanding tasks. However, the
same model can not be applied to multimodal behavior understanding tasks (e.g.,
video sentiment/humor detection) unless non-verbal features (e.g., acoustic and
visual) can be integrated with language. Jointly modeling multiple modalities
significantly increases the model complexity, and makes the training process
data-hungry. While an enormous amount of text data is available via the web,
collecting large-scale multimodal behavioral video datasets is extremely
expensive, both in terms of time and money. In this paper, we investigate
whether large language models alone can successfully incorporate non-verbal
information when they are presented in textual form. We present a way to
convert the acoustic and visual information into corresponding textual
descriptions and concatenate them with the spoken text. We feed this augmented
input to a pre-trained BERT model and fine-tune it on three downstream
multimodal tasks: sentiment, humor, and sarcasm detection. Our approach,
TextMI, significantly reduces model complexity, adds interpretability to the
model's decision, and can be applied for a diverse set of tasks while achieving
superior (multimodal sarcasm detection) or near SOTA (multimodal sentiment
analysis and multimodal humor detection) performance. We propose TextMI as a
general, competitive baseline for multimodal behavioral analysis tasks,
particularly in a low-resource setting. | [
-0.428640455,
-0.8047215343,
0.4568324089,
0.5354431868,
-0.3122741282,
-0.1998858452,
-0.5825137496,
-0.4423940182,
0.1795358509,
0.3227654099,
-0.653593719,
-0.3409966528,
-0.6624233127,
0.0079819113,
-0.1924888045,
1.270318985,
0.126704976,
0.1954585165,
-0.5376601815,
-0.1111751795,
-0.2787013948,
-0.567327559,
-0.1754030138,
-0.054151129,
0.5793477893,
0.333959341,
0.5429676771,
0.1269238144,
0.5647346973,
0.3508736193,
0.2957143784,
0.4459170997,
-0.383471638,
-0.0126792332,
-0.0326196812,
-0.3056179285,
-0.5675716996,
0.1505497843,
0.6929273009,
0.4937652349,
0.1555438042,
0.2107395083,
-0.0515546054,
0.179456681,
-0.6569249034,
0.3495962322,
-0.3281672001,
-0.050913617,
-0.0920491144,
-0.5073277354,
-0.6809636354,
-0.1816567183,
0.2124718279,
-0.6862618327,
-0.1975803971,
-0.1827988774,
0.6726971865,
0.3170486391,
-0.5735403895,
-0.3551955521,
-0.7552675605,
1.0671393871,
-0.6150636673,
0.4487944245,
0.7348916531,
-0.0460150354,
0.1162827089,
-0.4044253826,
-0.7565752864,
-0.3721971214,
-0.1740122885,
0.150491491,
0.0242017414,
0.1101276278,
0.0321634598,
0.1014408395,
-0.5901941657,
-0.1633289456,
-0.0442593209,
-0.0886053294,
0.5448719859,
0.0103202593,
0.6034315825,
-0.4168093801,
-0.3972782493,
-0.2619694769,
0.010883159,
0.1103341207,
0.215978995,
0.3138704896,
-0.43913728,
0.6964717507,
0.1676238924,
0.5178674459,
-0.2430704385,
-0.4460065961,
0.3845483661,
-0.6342615485,
-0.2284304947,
-0.083877638,
0.9845077395,
0.4864166081,
0.386733532,
-0.0335175358,
-0.1857279092,
0.0306560472,
0.1648370624,
-0.7903121114,
-0.1859099418,
0.0276079215,
-0.6737979054,
-0.2321100086,
-0.119012177,
-1.0624986887,
-0.3836431801,
-0.3019734323,
0.5297707915,
-0.6782314181,
-0.4110569358,
-0.0269264709,
-0.1782837361,
0.2637292743,
0.2881645858,
-0.9689282775,
0.0919584408,
0.3734658062,
0.8703503609,
0.4329366386,
-0.2879445851,
-0.7149992585,
0.2466451377,
-0.1515597701,
0.7435281277,
-0.8188195229,
-0.4532113075,
-0.078341715,
-0.1424331516,
-0.2577595413,
-0.0832024366,
0.2774144709,
-0.2645782232,
0.4188703001,
0.0653325692,
-0.3316051364,
-0.1056447327,
0.4569405615,
-0.7614947557,
1.1242620945,
-0.3042848706,
-0.9162439704,
0.1715293676,
-0.8739550114,
-0.7006366253,
-0.1758616269,
-0.1235551015,
-0.3113972545,
0.2049172223,
0.4633838534,
0.4763734043,
-0.1412295997,
0.3842943311,
-0.4164575636,
-0.2713651061,
0.6188774705,
-0.5427427292,
0.4298685789,
0.1582012624,
-0.193699494,
0.0133152008,
-0.6189032793,
0.009488252,
-0.0633639619,
-0.3901357055,
-0.5141985416,
0.1458574235,
0.4060703516,
0.2362609953,
0.4022555947,
-0.3887158632,
0.0111393277,
-0.1521455795,
0.3721837401,
0.6126130819,
-0.3835453093,
0.5952875018,
-0.2237427384,
0.5007970333,
-0.0308144093,
0.282384634,
-0.4593559206,
-0.3932365179,
-0.7312108278,
-0.7477483153,
0.260073036,
0.6675628424,
-1.136870265,
0.1596159786,
-0.5020878315,
-0.3992105126,
-0.4555538297,
0.2025109679,
0.4596148431,
0.279858917,
0.3848092854,
0.0334142148,
-0.59464854,
-0.7129650116,
-0.3466136158,
-0.3628944755,
-0.0775978491,
0.3441853225,
0.528182447,
-0.2407723069,
0.913243711,
-0.2837467492,
-0.4092799425,
-0.4730736613,
0.8239597082,
-0.056616649,
0.3394332826,
0.5739268064,
-0.9302615523,
-0.2803616822,
0.0370785929,
-0.8027490973,
-0.0566654131,
-0.3230673969,
0.0279581323,
0.0788722038,
0.4689264894,
-0.5324772,
0.1716757715,
0.7270514965,
-0.1735425293,
0.2713133991,
-0.2371095419,
0.401562959,
-1.0126003027,
0.1936672181,
0.2541392446,
-0.3384870887,
-0.646443665,
-0.2963438928,
-0.0078738779,
-0.1980596781,
-0.392432034,
0.6448087096,
-0.3176493049,
0.0337753668,
-0.0883614421,
0.2130867392,
-0.0003520505,
0.7420653701,
0.3125706017,
0.6751473546,
0.2565881908,
-0.5790457129,
0.3002940714,
0.2610266805,
-0.4165505469,
0.682541132,
-0.2844030261,
-0.0124363648,
-0.4670231938,
0.3440473378,
-1.0630905628,
-0.3102972806,
0.0696355775,
-0.7400352359,
0.1155102402,
0.0867349729,
-0.6285784245,
0.1599147022,
-0.6156308055,
0.5068409443,
0.2363865077,
-0.371094048,
1.1229300499,
0.3730139136,
-0.4488837123,
-0.5568805337,
-0.923897922,
0.1261000484,
-0.0452549867,
-0.6411646605,
0.1296645403,
-0.1636645496,
0.0245075952,
-0.0588341691,
0.2497735769,
-0.3504510522,
-0.0983111486,
0.1090232059,
0.4928977191,
-0.210559532,
0.4973658621,
-0.0169259887,
-0.0340732038,
-0.0771453083,
-0.0188098047,
0.2939780951,
0.0883696824,
-0.1254114211,
-0.669473052,
0.5417973399,
0.7194871306,
-0.5343361497,
0.8041323423,
0.9164102674,
-0.3203935325,
0.0769574046,
-0.5222959518,
-0.0389886461,
-0.3987024724,
0.3904967308,
-0.3222387433,
-0.7632014751,
0.0402808003,
-0.0295072328,
0.0441346578,
-0.015313467,
0.3718402088,
-0.5591182709,
1.299546957,
0.7977979779,
0.0807573646,
1.0431388617,
0.0818321928,
0.2464041263,
-0.4271856248,
-0.4166663587,
-0.3837834299,
-0.4103511572,
-0.4876488447,
-0.6130137444,
0.2456467301,
-0.2558969557,
0.0571407042,
0.0008085734,
0.1400529593,
0.3853907287,
0.440783143,
0.3104263246,
0.3033396304,
-0.0241354965,
0.1338502765,
-0.2868303359,
-0.4926761091,
-0.5376569629,
0.87061584,
0.3598926663,
0.8782939911,
0.183653295,
0.3070501685,
0.2205770463,
0.4024412036,
-0.8214650154,
0.614500463,
-0.5761310458,
-0.4088568091,
-0.1817495674,
-0.6004266143,
-0.4911803305,
0.1978148222,
-0.5519323945,
-0.4580180049,
0.1691000909,
0.2496877909,
-0.1656513065,
0.0545395166,
-0.9690761566,
0.8464009762,
-0.3931597173,
-0.1143951416,
-0.2218489051,
-0.6824322939,
0.3805376589,
-0.1256639212,
0.6942865252,
-0.0438993722,
-0.1275432706,
0.7452482581,
-0.2257759422,
1.0451592207,
-0.2435524315,
-0.1490300149,
0.0974642336,
-0.1139091402,
0.4163739085,
0.015477635,
0.0961842388,
0.0409290083,
0.0772842169,
-0.2954046428,
-0.7365050912,
0.376116693,
-0.7356050611,
0.0032841295,
-0.2560667098,
-0.5842865109,
-0.3821069002,
-0.0122894058,
0.1104896218,
0.6462307572,
-0.2885549068,
0.3361587226,
0.8289187551,
-0.4535983503,
0.5066560507,
0.3838811219,
-0.0850450248,
-0.6001802683,
1.1405823231,
-0.224999696,
0.0923193321,
0.7513855696,
0.0166238658,
-0.5670595765,
-0.1134373546,
-0.1567156464,
0.2954713404,
-0.6639180183,
-0.004527824,
-0.9306980968,
0.0944059268,
-0.455411166,
-0.0089365421,
-0.3678816855,
-0.1184664741,
-0.3591621518,
0.0616457574,
0.3578718901,
0.3872696459,
-0.0754098669,
0.5940588713,
-1.0544184446,
0.5951060653,
0.3599785566,
0.3132054806,
-0.1193665788,
-0.2942571342,
-0.3953711987,
0.1523036808,
0.0382115394,
-0.7760371566,
0.3339322805,
0.4906738698,
0.2919205129,
0.3247688711,
-0.0846046656,
0.8354474902,
-0.4848358333,
0.6482457519,
0.466255635,
-1.2148913145,
0.6722197533,
-0.3832591474,
0.3270606995,
0.5289211869,
0.3402373493,
-0.5305129886,
-0.3192850053,
-0.0406343453,
-0.4881556034,
0.8665132523,
0.2236567885,
0.4642145932,
-0.0576201156,
-0.2354494631,
-0.1367890388,
0.2272933573,
-1.1030671597,
0.2274421901,
-0.4908046722,
-0.7172211409,
-0.3285427392,
-0.3541575074,
-0.0179156289,
-0.2227010131,
0.4345185459,
-0.2248485535,
0.3495535553,
-0.0072842604,
-0.7345194817,
0.3459462225,
0.3633374572,
0.7154697776,
0.245322302,
-0.1975206733,
0.2517450154,
-0.0721475706,
-0.5286502838,
0.0068168864,
0.0586706363,
0.4693712294,
0.2150652111,
0.6988246441,
0.7390246391,
0.5693870783,
-1.0174617767,
0.7787637115,
-0.2844212353,
-0.2849616706,
-0.0457754023,
-0.282353133,
-0.0713213161,
0.3344481289,
0.0892448425,
-0.1584832668,
0.122614421,
-0.6896646023,
0.1067679226,
0.4204556942,
-0.300604403,
-0.3810327351,
0.3861908019,
0.5804233551,
0.103632383,
0.5930169821,
-0.0394843146,
-0.4275225401,
0.4010139108,
0.3513114154,
0.6851152778,
-0.318405956,
0.5316843987,
0.1130033806,
0.4548614919,
0.0376113094,
0.4712337255,
-0.2578703165,
-0.6066259146,
-0.7330075502,
-0.5229886174,
-0.2343105376,
0.0415068455,
-0.5217720866,
0.483641386,
-0.4657672644,
-0.3394821584,
0.0396877341,
-0.4184220731,
-0.4426790476,
0.4604015946,
0.3620148897,
0.4920095801,
-0.9712879658,
0.7117952704,
0.8463764191,
-0.5450051427,
-0.3845175207,
0.0782167837,
-0.1384709626,
-0.6450632215,
0.8081604838,
0.2859728038,
-0.4084759057,
-0.1902965605,
-0.5131492019,
-0.5273794532,
0.6768493652,
0.5724629164,
-0.2463107705,
-0.1581618786,
0.1218732446,
0.476449132,
-0.1808035523,
0.5455710292,
0.1805769205,
0.6288084388,
0.214698419,
-0.9369382262,
-0.1981562376,
-0.5253795981,
-0.0085537322,
0.3200317621,
-0.3616092205,
0.8761470914,
-0.0780924261,
-0.2545968294,
-0.0755003244,
0.5719656348,
-0.1047378629,
0.3826268613,
0.6635397077,
0.2795291245,
0.6443352103,
0.1214133352,
0.7958691716,
-0.1046376899,
0.3122284114,
1.2164827585,
-0.0990675911,
0.9279288054,
0.50303334,
0.1589626223,
0.5233034492,
0.6050013304,
0.1497208625,
0.5727209449,
-0.2852007449,
-0.3979551196,
-0.5814445615,
-0.4057092667,
-0.2568284273,
0.8013081551,
0.36994645,
-0.3853939176,
-0.0879026875,
0.5195940733,
0.0497259721,
0.0022337032,
-0.1627286971,
0.9348121881,
-0.0784969255,
-0.4167519808,
0.1888048798,
0.0112339463,
0.9035513997,
-0.7552650571,
-0.0761737153,
-0.1245763227,
0.0837310478,
-0.2718117237,
-0.4863148928,
0.2843843699,
0.3526126742,
-0.3044370711,
-0.4650875628,
0.5317149758,
-0.6755057573,
-0.5705248117,
0.4212797284,
0.3991109729,
0.0877303928,
-0.0620278157,
-0.4369486868,
0.0695429593,
-0.1647151858,
-0.0752947852,
0.2197142988,
0.5586435199,
0.0583929755,
0.5483773351,
0.6700419784,
-0.2914081514,
-0.0602005534,
0.2150909305,
0.7836892605,
-0.7118474245,
-0.6928998232,
-1.0600652695,
0.64868927,
-0.0553736314,
-0.0805483982,
0.5377494097,
0.3110354543,
0.5972182155,
-0.1019971594,
0.8087365031,
0.0525981374,
0.1879626811,
-0.8295425773,
0.5714238286,
-0.9501517415,
-0.1613519341,
-0.4970592558,
-0.7744977474,
-0.1650434285,
0.7080520988,
-0.2334832847,
0.1786014736,
0.7827115655,
0.5221555829,
-0.1132703871,
0.1733178496,
0.2557786405,
0.0585696213,
0.2334781289,
0.4454610646,
0.9946436286,
-0.0603064075,
0.8790175319,
0.0803596824,
-0.4990255535,
-0.2550791502,
-0.9502944946,
-1.1230170727,
-0.4796529412,
-0.2246761322,
0.0820218101,
-0.2847046256,
0.8404898047,
0.8180404305,
-0.4038792551,
-0.2612941861,
0.4615362287,
0.0348518938,
0.0563159026,
-0.1981814355,
-0.101958707,
-0.3912431598,
-0.8953603506,
0.3858932555,
0.4292337894,
0.0376106873,
-0.108595334,
0.0375991762,
-0.5140513182,
0.4150389731,
0.8835345507,
-0.0527544506,
-0.4219503403,
-0.1251044869,
0.1442195773,
-0.0909468904,
-0.082742162,
0.9908681512,
-0.4692159891,
0.6959294677,
0.5650424361,
0.7850207686,
0.5110346079,
-0.1776940823,
0.674647212,
-1.0628751516,
0.3604933321,
0.0199481733,
0.2144896388,
0.3283829689,
-0.2369055301,
0.1681377739,
0.1102026701,
-0.1200152636,
-0.8631569147,
0.0593556799,
-0.9939433336,
-0.4381920695,
0.9511323571,
-0.1452052146,
-0.0852740034,
-0.0067874361,
-0.1669225246,
0.3017431796,
-0.3561614454,
0.4698028564,
1.0404033661,
-0.0928905234,
-0.4182946086,
-0.5906633735,
0.2565666139,
0.5100588202,
-1.0882165432,
-0.049704697,
0.5565766692,
-0.044025261,
0.1888829023,
0.8467465639,
-0.0425780267,
0.1848945469,
-0.1722340137,
0.1731900722,
0.1508630663,
-0.4084885418,
-0.2701011598,
-0.0889183655,
-0.2142730355,
-0.505869329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15422v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15422v4 | KPEval: Towards Fine-Grained Semantic-Based Keyphrase Evaluation | 2023-03-27T17:45:38 | 2024-06-04T10:00:56 | Di Wu, Da Yin, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the significant advancements in keyphrase extraction and keyphrase
generation methods, the predominant approach for evaluation mainly relies on
exact matching with human references. This scheme fails to recognize systems
that generate keyphrases semantically equivalent to the references or diverse
keyphrases that carry practical utility. To better assess the capability of
keyphrase systems, we propose KPEval, a comprehensive evaluation framework
consisting of four critical aspects: reference agreement, faithfulness,
diversity, and utility. For each aspect, we design semantic-based metrics to
reflect the evaluation objectives. Meta-evaluation studies demonstrate that our
evaluation strategy correlates better with human preferences compared to a
range of previously proposed metrics. Using KPEval, we re-evaluate 23 keyphrase
systems and discover that (1) established model comparison results have
blind-spots especially when considering reference-free evaluation; (2) large
language models are underestimated by prior evaluation works; and (3) there is
no single best model that can excel in all the aspects. | [
-0.0883225873,
-0.1608065069,
0.7915790677,
0.1734251827,
-0.3173433542,
0.0651604906,
-0.1361235678,
-0.4726238549,
-0.2079137713,
0.3664021492,
-0.2238328159,
-0.3616983891,
-0.5196871161,
0.2648678124,
-0.4315134287,
0.8473658562,
0.1866596937,
0.2953940332,
-0.1402902007,
-0.247092694,
-0.4417647719,
-0.4205392301,
0.0081049073,
-0.5552509427,
0.2804482877,
0.6537684798,
0.8495737314,
0.2184397876,
0.9445284605,
0.1780485064,
-0.2670403719,
0.0397318043,
-0.3672991097,
0.2492154092,
-0.668700397,
-0.2338377833,
-0.4141582847,
0.0563247316,
0.4634922445,
0.7465924025,
0.1217867285,
0.1518718749,
0.1044331267,
0.8156079054,
-1.0572257042,
-0.0359003507,
-0.8637515903,
0.0060823751,
-0.152543202,
-0.0389749855,
-0.1785288006,
-0.6161996126,
0.5461227298,
-0.3729143441,
0.1100332439,
-0.1361822486,
0.8299629688,
-0.114857167,
-0.4549816549,
-0.5315626264,
-0.4984278679,
0.8273528814,
-0.5620059967,
0.6445119977,
0.3778659999,
0.5171607137,
-0.2768079042,
-0.9280607104,
-0.3724265099,
-0.4615572989,
0.266597718,
0.0169139914,
0.1365560442,
0.2499133348,
-0.3316118121,
0.6248970628,
-0.3591841757,
-0.1330964714,
-0.4723835289,
-0.4045651257,
0.5696671009,
0.2204978913,
0.2491882145,
-0.521050334,
-0.2334914058,
-0.3351725042,
-0.3868058324,
0.1111072749,
0.0763441324,
0.2878486514,
0.2927262187,
0.6503388286,
-0.6432833076,
0.3784213662,
0.0475355759,
-0.2640172243,
0.4962050021,
-0.811860323,
-0.1831823587,
0.054257296,
0.7571893334,
0.7584972382,
0.2514337301,
-0.6107968688,
-0.1618069112,
0.243951723,
0.4234522879,
-1.0252548456,
-0.3223144114,
0.4280126393,
-0.7918077111,
-0.782874763,
0.0302966665,
-0.8705435395,
-0.2311061323,
0.1027735323,
0.8078795671,
-0.641056776,
0.1178956255,
0.4028874338,
-0.7822493911,
0.3610327542,
0.2588429749,
-0.6805961132,
0.2793003917,
0.8880364895,
0.5929170251,
-0.2091889083,
-0.4452573955,
-0.497441709,
-0.1677820534,
-0.2744647264,
0.8164868951,
-1.1386779547,
-0.6716507077,
-0.2070708573,
0.0518990383,
0.1094672456,
-0.6240817904,
1.3862171173,
-0.4932855964,
0.181652531,
-0.3983082771,
-0.8271170259,
-0.0725963041,
0.2367706895,
-0.4138315618,
0.8583626151,
0.0671625286,
-0.5320159197,
0.7229967117,
-0.6518995166,
-0.1692081243,
0.0902921632,
0.0443617515,
-0.3843034506,
0.3386047482,
-0.1088229343,
0.227982536,
-0.4996110797,
0.1631815583,
-0.6387317181,
-0.2997950912,
0.2307927012,
-0.3431333899,
0.5526933074,
0.4896260202,
-0.4106543958,
-0.1136409119,
-0.9372401237,
0.6515616179,
-0.1714063883,
-0.3025209904,
-0.7238093615,
-0.0065289689,
0.079865478,
0.1230860874,
0.2717036009,
-0.7972956896,
0.1480039358,
-0.609112978,
0.5901083946,
0.5257351995,
0.0854722187,
0.5572054386,
-0.0266617946,
0.2552976012,
-0.4127315283,
0.3155715764,
-0.0114263846,
-0.5104157329,
-0.2200912684,
-0.0476776995,
0.7725248337,
0.2803694308,
-0.2344371676,
0.5105745792,
-0.4433566332,
-0.8552413583,
-0.3371667862,
-0.0170230009,
0.5318157077,
0.323107332,
0.1856390983,
-0.6834151745,
-0.1080069765,
-0.8862659335,
-0.4694769681,
-0.3172085583,
-0.1922900379,
0.4005847871,
0.7424407005,
-0.1206894591,
0.8840876222,
-0.3756554723,
-0.058678247,
0.1049378887,
0.1302456856,
-0.0347878784,
0.2906525433,
0.3676066697,
-0.9042302966,
-0.3918710351,
0.0074345893,
-0.3384572566,
-0.3347532451,
0.3104268312,
-0.2052453011,
-0.5895760059,
0.4339390993,
-0.4711526334,
-0.0003824151,
0.1203275099,
-0.5860955715,
0.5527026653,
-0.1457333863,
0.4023266137,
-0.5360956192,
0.3448841572,
-0.5325363874,
-0.0116536422,
-0.4686267376,
0.5494599938,
0.5304275155,
-0.379909277,
-0.4021830261,
0.6853842735,
-0.1224765033,
-0.1216048524,
-0.278966248,
0.3275074959,
0.4125661254,
0.0386069939,
-0.1663209647,
0.5567688346,
0.1522127241,
-0.5488212705,
0.2279185802,
0.2801835537,
-0.5116761327,
0.7543442845,
-0.8707078099,
-0.064365536,
0.09099859,
0.1619008183,
-0.9073845744,
-0.1769582033,
0.1144225672,
-0.5627603531,
-0.2077487856,
0.1279666573,
-0.3086861372,
-0.3056324124,
-0.7357560396,
0.5161337852,
0.3759476542,
-0.2598073781,
0.1362249702,
0.2916307151,
-0.1225156486,
-0.3077636063,
-0.2106929868,
0.1573047191,
-0.0337663665,
-0.6217191219,
0.5312052965,
-0.0183577258,
-0.108424589,
0.2171664536,
-0.41356197,
-0.3292859197,
0.2800635099,
-0.0404716991,
-0.110031344,
0.0855050981,
0.2711808085,
-0.0367435999,
-0.1255318075,
-0.2640680969,
-0.3200770319,
0.4672271907,
-0.2595142424,
-0.4392316043,
-0.0904466063,
0.3052560091,
1.140920639,
-0.5869348645,
-0.0287898984,
0.4628015757,
-0.3018569052,
0.2654508054,
-0.3894331455,
-0.0810125023,
-0.406449616,
0.5231200457,
-0.4914293885,
-0.6362681389,
0.2135836184,
-0.1067234576,
0.0379416011,
0.5843445659,
0.6194267869,
0.0607286952,
0.8394418359,
0.4879178405,
0.080681704,
0.2216148227,
0.1294695139,
0.1982845813,
-0.8781467676,
-0.41499722,
-0.8913269043,
-0.3658524454,
-0.6094532013,
-0.391220361,
0.43611902,
0.4763816595,
-0.1884664297,
0.2958605289,
-0.6688693762,
0.3561010361,
0.4862436354,
0.0666255131,
0.2813797295,
-0.1104281694,
-0.5430638194,
-0.0895779282,
-0.4547377527,
-0.6715026498,
1.4900507927,
0.3453764021,
0.7159359455,
-0.1669750363,
0.7616097331,
0.4552843571,
-0.0198617745,
-0.9580472112,
0.36505723,
-0.0644131452,
-0.7723810077,
-0.4963718653,
-0.2237259299,
-1.1802504063,
0.572644949,
-0.1613355279,
-0.73097682,
0.4957900345,
-0.2872038186,
-0.697081387,
-0.2029026449,
-0.8072200418,
1.1349804401,
-0.2374954075,
-0.157678023,
-0.3489159942,
-0.5309615135,
0.272990942,
-0.219230786,
-0.0219876375,
-0.2652021348,
-0.1957159191,
0.5561285615,
-0.8168657422,
0.2463897616,
0.0644954666,
-0.0409834757,
0.2816114128,
-0.0751451254,
0.4208749235,
-0.1275102645,
-0.4125612378,
-0.0909337401,
0.483314544,
-0.3869108558,
-0.6870002747,
0.5227273703,
-0.4878526628,
-0.0852886587,
-0.2307574451,
-0.0778442845,
-0.3680559099,
0.429653585,
0.2947957516,
0.324557811,
-0.5209937096,
0.543489337,
0.4721638262,
-0.1769984514,
0.2767793238,
0.5303301215,
-0.101021491,
-0.6360193491,
0.8361285329,
-0.0275514964,
0.3433651924,
0.3271138072,
0.5136741996,
-0.2054193169,
-0.3444515765,
-0.2526367605,
-0.2107700855,
-0.5982607007,
-0.1874804646,
-0.6878385544,
0.0343301781,
-0.345171541,
-0.1383592337,
-0.5009022951,
-0.5074871182,
0.4219672382,
0.2691966593,
0.2824207246,
0.2400464118,
0.0491682589,
0.0570882857,
-1.1811356544,
0.5349494815,
0.5893061161,
0.6620327234,
-0.025462497,
-0.3809772432,
0.0101874908,
-0.012715592,
-0.5312344432,
-1.0328780413,
0.0146779744,
0.5666587353,
0.5527969599,
0.1224935949,
0.2444862574,
0.3797601461,
-0.852869153,
0.9583239555,
0.0061862972,
-1.0418953896,
0.4759509563,
0.0556444675,
0.302614212,
1.1376504898,
0.0976391733,
-0.6395994425,
-0.3396836519,
-0.8109539747,
-0.8603537083,
0.3070381582,
0.625667572,
0.0208361037,
-0.0781426728,
0.3130251169,
0.2656845748,
0.3864832819,
-0.3585836291,
0.0408165678,
-0.2433365583,
-0.1283756196,
0.1260517836,
-0.2998872399,
0.1567096263,
-0.096499294,
0.3858468533,
0.1222825497,
0.2225723565,
0.5011280179,
-0.2271649688,
0.1796081513,
0.6847152114,
0.4242405593,
0.4402959645,
-0.4237958193,
-0.009180624,
0.1446860582,
-0.7564035058,
0.4384838343,
-0.1409519017,
-0.2621822953,
0.3323123455,
0.3152632117,
0.3384114504,
0.5832154155,
-0.7873489261,
0.7984029651,
-0.0827618092,
-0.1942875087,
0.1462841481,
-0.0153987771,
-0.0523890369,
0.1673479825,
0.2422061861,
0.0827127472,
0.6017757058,
-0.806175828,
0.5152718425,
0.5888857245,
-0.5130605102,
-0.2185256183,
0.4174725413,
0.5057634711,
-0.361135602,
0.1476113796,
-0.3039055169,
-0.7489023209,
0.391966939,
0.0252745897,
1.231933713,
-0.2594222724,
0.0430888049,
0.1293324083,
0.348644942,
0.0499707609,
0.3969929218,
-0.4018760026,
-0.5911425352,
-0.0994312614,
-0.8492980003,
-0.5549512506,
0.175148949,
-0.4718092084,
0.2867665291,
-0.1621103585,
-0.1289134175,
0.2091390342,
0.2260193378,
-0.6600364447,
0.3099624813,
-0.1859630644,
1.0143603086,
-0.7427071929,
0.6009414792,
0.6285278201,
-0.4131802619,
-0.5389225483,
0.1529049277,
-0.3041828573,
-0.6755973697,
0.6768869162,
-0.050696522,
-0.0404737368,
-0.5288886428,
-0.1517747045,
-0.8949908614,
1.0329394341,
0.129726395,
-0.4209434092,
-0.1146704108,
0.0433805361,
0.6058593392,
-0.1173288152,
0.2799757123,
0.6716865897,
0.5613172054,
-0.0927753672,
-1.4223462343,
-0.2404654175,
-0.3148236275,
0.0006970406,
0.1203404069,
-0.5715495944,
0.5288363099,
0.2002445906,
-0.1280399114,
0.276196152,
0.2987624705,
0.1148044541,
0.2881387472,
0.3402758241,
0.5752156973,
0.7694169283,
0.1447124779,
1.0242087841,
-0.6103746295,
0.4856658578,
1.1148222685,
-0.4395035803,
1.0000981092,
0.3806421459,
-0.2265651226,
0.1782167852,
0.5277219415,
0.1205196828,
0.9805932045,
0.1532778442,
-0.0850906149,
-0.3988362849,
-0.0351538248,
-0.5076729655,
0.7106584311,
0.1658634543,
-0.5988646746,
-0.8619309664,
-0.0284809563,
-0.3792017102,
0.0033305653,
-0.3293702006,
0.6171139479,
0.1510540545,
-0.5538010001,
0.6160283685,
0.2540973425,
0.520160675,
-0.5902844071,
0.0800909325,
0.0975031033,
0.2484545708,
-0.159528017,
-0.739392221,
0.1523246616,
0.1139840037,
-0.1424083412,
0.0561184362,
1.0440328121,
-0.1635200083,
-0.4469032884,
0.1875390112,
0.3822297156,
0.3038964272,
-0.2569495738,
-0.702611804,
-0.0855195224,
-0.1702178568,
-0.0615983233,
0.2811991572,
0.6740378737,
-0.0991021693,
0.5348134041,
0.3318558037,
0.0490203761,
-0.1111728922,
-0.0523885414,
0.5834088326,
-0.5694829226,
-0.3209795952,
-0.9319499135,
0.3286339939,
-0.1662004292,
-0.5899736881,
0.8077652454,
0.5050038099,
0.7353085876,
0.0351052806,
0.8503181934,
0.1116847098,
0.4669592679,
-0.2228890508,
0.660341382,
-0.5779993534,
-0.0995560959,
-0.854257226,
-1.0513539314,
-0.0037978454,
0.5682126284,
-0.2218896598,
-0.1230265275,
0.6795174479,
0.5966820717,
-0.2775626779,
0.0593451485,
0.4672567844,
-0.2323720604,
0.255923748,
0.5167760849,
0.7270721793,
-0.8742795587,
0.7261840701,
-0.0859590024,
-0.2426521927,
-0.6542200446,
-0.9671174288,
-0.360466361,
-0.4889678359,
-0.0395274796,
-0.189570114,
0.1093396172,
0.8519985676,
0.4496171176,
-0.6319890618,
0.0015855638,
-0.0817690045,
0.2273251563,
-0.0826849043,
-0.2357367873,
0.2741430104,
-0.6803687215,
-0.5754981041,
0.3003058434,
0.579944253,
-0.3085329831,
-0.0513145588,
-0.1297802031,
0.2073138207,
0.2552454472,
0.8071276546,
0.1828374416,
-0.698182106,
-0.5822715759,
0.1853092909,
-0.4261282682,
-0.1469096988,
0.7438960671,
-0.6040127277,
0.6827319264,
0.7937147617,
0.7533102036,
0.034329515,
-0.1777239293,
0.7227470279,
-0.0302117728,
-0.2101706266,
0.3865650892,
0.3234001398,
-0.00938047,
-0.0334355123,
0.4537461996,
0.1099095419,
-0.6938856244,
-0.826800704,
0.2815282643,
-0.7272055149,
-0.3102899492,
1.1489775181,
-0.0889001116,
-0.2599333525,
-0.2200320065,
-0.2341524214,
-0.2149702162,
-0.2262665331,
0.7869767547,
0.8771098256,
0.1153898388,
0.6029514074,
-0.3169642389,
0.5354123712,
0.7603042722,
-0.2978677452,
0.066301018,
0.4143745005,
0.4597800374,
0.4317367077,
0.65453583,
-0.5902167559,
0.6946995258,
-0.0384790748,
0.1212546825,
0.3661371768,
-0.1379172802,
-0.3960457444,
0.4950622916,
0.4697003663,
-0.3502838314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15413v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15413v5 | Debiasing Scores and Prompts of 2D Diffusion for View-consistent Text-to-3D Generation | 2023-03-27T17:31:13 | 2023-12-19T22:03:12 | Susung Hong, Donghoon Ahn, Seungryong Kim | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG | Existing score-distilling text-to-3D generation techniques, despite their
considerable promise, often encounter the view inconsistency problem. One of
the most notable issues is the Janus problem, where the most canonical view of
an object (\textit{e.g}., face or head) appears in other views. In this work,
we explore existing frameworks for score-distilling text-to-3D generation and
identify the main causes of the view inconsistency problem -- the embedded bias
of 2D diffusion models. Based on these findings, we propose two approaches to
debias the score-distillation frameworks for view-consistent text-to-3D
generation. Our first approach, called score debiasing, involves cutting off
the score estimated by 2D diffusion models and gradually increasing the
truncation value throughout the optimization process. Our second approach,
called prompt debiasing, identifies conflicting words between user prompts and
view prompts using a language model, and adjusts the discrepancy between view
prompts and the viewing direction of an object. Our experimental results show
that our methods improve the realism of the generated 3D objects by
significantly reducing artifacts and achieve a good trade-off between
faithfulness to the 2D diffusion models and 3D consistency with little
overhead. Our project page is available
at~\url{https://susunghong.github.io/Debiased-Score-Distillation-Sampling/}. | [
-0.4839296937,
-1.0667688847,
1.1099294424,
0.394174248,
-0.292488277,
-0.1450340897,
0.1933589131,
-0.3434990048,
0.0439085625,
0.3625836074,
-0.2451046705,
-0.3971139491,
-0.7576477528,
0.1995176971,
-0.1525051594,
0.8828923106,
-0.1788451672,
-0.0082663912,
-0.6638518572,
0.0318270847,
-0.3777600229,
-0.1092900038,
-0.6157945991,
-0.1045190915,
0.5368120074,
0.4543162882,
0.6899664998,
0.6854532361,
0.371756196,
0.1759581268,
-0.3780892193,
0.2446148843,
-0.2748029828,
0.3787765801,
-0.1488619,
-0.1514950991,
-0.3997262716,
0.3613192737,
0.5149124861,
0.8836009502,
0.0970731825,
0.1809748858,
0.5996866822,
0.9519251585,
-0.5394466519,
-0.04501082,
-0.125134483,
0.0770545006,
-0.0193159785,
0.0252065621,
-0.2533366978,
-0.7142375112,
0.2849755883,
-0.6974600554,
0.4114920795,
-0.1274473667,
0.5469471812,
0.4516225755,
-0.3571899831,
-0.1241735369,
-0.7825554609,
0.8893316388,
-0.4677444696,
0.1352373958,
0.2857586443,
0.2027965635,
-0.0462136865,
-0.2263946086,
-0.5228267312,
-0.3268883526,
0.0356289223,
0.3260993958,
-0.030396305,
-0.13494955,
0.491691649,
0.2659251392,
-0.7013384104,
-0.0141730858,
-0.2901483476,
0.0756314024,
0.6697041392,
-0.0152475545,
0.0681926906,
-0.393194139,
-0.7546898723,
-0.4976690412,
-0.6105778217,
-0.051929228,
0.712849617,
0.092147693,
-0.272459507,
0.4405424893,
-0.1956269294,
0.731695652,
0.4139012694,
0.0922357365,
0.282415241,
-0.0638337284,
-0.1358128041,
0.0039689061,
0.764560163,
0.7826437354,
0.1267879307,
0.3136439025,
-0.0641601235,
-0.0615188666,
0.2637485266,
-0.74202317,
-0.5409198999,
0.4050547779,
-0.4888078272,
-0.5993133187,
-0.0688013211,
-1.2740495205,
-0.9058794975,
-0.1330779046,
0.3555451334,
-0.1310605109,
-0.4623632729,
0.0057719001,
-0.5771494508,
-0.3107455969,
0.7983183265,
-0.7862970233,
-0.1121177673,
0.282676965,
0.9311316013,
-0.3632177114,
0.1376891881,
-0.4656689465,
-0.1168038696,
-0.5261626244,
1.0281014442,
-0.5049986243,
-0.7690095305,
-0.1898205578,
-0.6728369594,
0.1249523312,
-0.7080207467,
0.2564229667,
-0.0805780888,
0.6965655684,
-0.4173458517,
-0.3836323321,
-0.1799767613,
0.6358511448,
-0.8377171755,
1.1665592194,
0.2340105623,
-0.756541431,
0.2597357631,
-0.4409117401,
-0.1698546708,
-0.1692281514,
-0.4903696477,
-0.2312185764,
0.3685233295,
0.3296872079,
0.3321480751,
-0.4044739306,
0.1347036958,
-0.3890916407,
-0.0362554081,
-0.1577730775,
-0.6440458298,
0.7834089398,
0.3095301688,
-0.3186503351,
-0.2259723842,
-0.6702326536,
-0.1814720035,
0.0980168656,
-0.1777169555,
-0.5687662363,
0.1813714504,
0.1355881989,
0.1381901354,
0.2203605473,
-0.4708939493,
0.2592362165,
-0.2413677126,
-0.1683623791,
0.7863923311,
0.1764509678,
0.6034582853,
-0.287586689,
0.4416679144,
0.4616841674,
0.1387202144,
-0.2998066247,
-0.7061766386,
-0.2085106373,
-0.1530283093,
0.0295866691,
0.4917624295,
-0.8205597997,
0.1190584898,
-0.1357631385,
-0.4096667469,
-0.0579120778,
0.0839955062,
0.1749344021,
0.8064163923,
0.434851855,
-0.0778877065,
-0.1559859812,
-0.9696826339,
-0.1481423974,
-0.4204550982,
-0.2141327262,
0.0834863335,
0.1859125942,
0.07895533,
1.021761775,
-0.7736426592,
-0.3072946668,
-0.131056875,
0.1327165216,
0.0703945607,
0.8248551488,
0.891373992,
-1.0497642756,
-0.648658216,
-0.2879052162,
-0.77032125,
-0.1736319661,
-0.174478218,
0.098232314,
0.1119456515,
0.593885839,
-0.2920084596,
0.454105556,
0.5878716707,
-0.2929353118,
0.4026310742,
-0.2011412233,
0.3440661132,
-1.2272669077,
0.0123073356,
0.5189198852,
-0.2045601606,
-0.4694915414,
-0.2013360411,
-0.3401569426,
0.1951721758,
-0.4196252525,
0.7248599529,
-0.409724772,
0.4540461004,
-0.2988862395,
0.7322391272,
0.7226222157,
0.3745829761,
0.1858841479,
0.3280966878,
0.3708509207,
-0.7106665373,
0.187245205,
0.2978161275,
-0.5729207993,
0.9372524023,
-0.6728982925,
0.0600716062,
-0.2872098684,
0.2616284192,
-1.3458914757,
0.0995575488,
0.4638423324,
-0.3278481066,
0.1994669586,
-0.1290089637,
-0.3513111472,
-0.1216601953,
-0.5517548919,
0.6384768486,
0.564502418,
-0.6107875705,
0.4192432165,
0.3754103482,
-0.0023839416,
-0.4974010289,
-0.5652288198,
-0.1912209541,
-0.3497223258,
-0.4529986382,
0.430090189,
-0.330408752,
-0.4920961857,
-0.0992965251,
-0.287332803,
0.2378388345,
0.1491740346,
0.1720246971,
0.3372509181,
0.0181606263,
-0.3979656994,
0.4908212423,
-0.2608537376,
0.2349833995,
-0.2459698617,
0.0329479389,
0.4619960785,
-0.356813252,
-0.4427981973,
0.5149248838,
0.6465853453,
0.3836236894,
0.2307432443,
0.3439095318,
-0.3869833648,
-0.1197512448,
-0.5449228287,
-0.0238220617,
-0.4472934902,
0.2279812843,
-0.469201982,
-0.5711988211,
0.4786733687,
-0.2776518166,
0.3229538202,
0.4781310856,
0.5370433927,
-0.2574306428,
1.5404759645,
0.5024492145,
0.2380539924,
0.5443475246,
-0.1983173639,
0.1129533947,
-1.1101480722,
-0.1931417882,
-0.5973584056,
-0.5468043685,
-0.4106652737,
-0.6425303221,
0.593687892,
0.4207841754,
0.0204601772,
0.0060263537,
-0.7057651281,
0.4363487959,
0.3912900686,
-0.1416761726,
0.2417572737,
0.1033787727,
-0.4492085576,
0.0127589004,
-0.431329906,
-0.6312669516,
0.5537991524,
0.2543135881,
0.6785802841,
0.1439823955,
0.747966826,
0.4634329081,
0.0122748436,
-0.3558885157,
0.3568819463,
-0.2582937479,
-0.5241072178,
-0.0235227104,
-0.5208597183,
-0.5266557932,
0.389816165,
-0.1640148908,
-0.921615243,
0.4623769522,
0.3624536395,
-0.6753320098,
0.2605799139,
-0.5642604828,
0.9810776114,
-0.0462793969,
-0.6786842942,
-0.0587614849,
-0.3816320598,
0.2827560604,
0.100274086,
0.2170603424,
-0.2881508172,
0.3261837363,
0.6351808906,
-0.0833958164,
0.7425274849,
-0.6296085119,
-0.6365681291,
0.417258203,
0.3824285567,
0.3377379775,
0.5756628513,
-0.210731253,
0.302506268,
0.2453150153,
-0.2291197926,
-0.6993708014,
0.8996377587,
-0.5152690411,
-0.8596500158,
-0.5496960878,
-0.3653949797,
-0.2326778322,
0.0397732481,
0.5066048503,
0.3584781885,
-0.4506726265,
-0.075898841,
0.8756288886,
-0.3367004097,
0.2709023952,
0.0897791535,
-0.5451362133,
-0.3390369415,
0.5894628167,
-0.2484347671,
0.3124603629,
0.4685896337,
0.4293836355,
-0.4034679234,
-0.4270308316,
-1.0923678875,
-0.2955145538,
-0.4156054854,
-0.2403628677,
-0.442694217,
0.0412151478,
-0.5238192081,
-0.1776592433,
-0.5342732072,
-0.5243732929,
-0.495564729,
-0.1262371689,
0.2368423939,
0.8017865419,
-0.402594775,
0.0792858675,
-0.8777878881,
0.6341010332,
0.0139431255,
0.2836163938,
0.0157221984,
-0.4980802834,
-0.2197039574,
0.3839996755,
-0.3134389818,
-0.7858321071,
0.0435311235,
-0.3089833558,
0.5047693253,
0.5659809709,
0.1073735654,
0.6606826782,
-0.4589575827,
1.1495747566,
0.3779665828,
-0.7830756307,
0.6704797745,
-0.3238596916,
0.3286269903,
0.7738831639,
0.1766325682,
-0.4782321155,
-0.5162770152,
-0.3734060526,
-0.7960820794,
0.7438645959,
0.2207072228,
0.2308447361,
-0.235862866,
0.4733406305,
0.4469060302,
-0.0890376642,
-0.3294061422,
-0.26739645,
-0.2412883937,
-0.3155135512,
-0.0073268982,
-0.3910696507,
-0.1688633412,
0.0091918008,
0.4633583426,
-0.0897786394,
-0.1169287041,
0.416066885,
0.0722192228,
-0.1965426058,
-0.2388228029,
0.6488753557,
0.5077927709,
-0.2258639038,
0.1004851609,
-0.204185307,
-0.7508299947,
0.1641858965,
0.04275373,
-0.4206395447,
0.0311906971,
-0.1199202389,
0.6667239666,
-0.1944511682,
-0.3159316778,
0.4976116419,
-0.1765719801,
-0.399725616,
-0.2926900089,
0.0676250234,
-0.3139020503,
0.3954654336,
0.3967320621,
0.42718786,
0.2342254519,
0.0203039441,
-0.0545368195,
0.4419151545,
-0.5296471119,
-0.2183234245,
1.0971224308,
0.4605183601,
0.1342758685,
0.5127959847,
-0.1633793265,
-0.2545762062,
0.5730231404,
0.2900818586,
1.1686573029,
-0.261598289,
0.5689126849,
0.6762843132,
0.0972938538,
-0.5982464552,
-0.0445979312,
-0.2780983746,
-0.6102873683,
-0.1287936866,
-0.6689386964,
-0.5063053966,
0.0050379504,
-0.7578927875,
0.3350012004,
-0.391191721,
-0.119168371,
-0.1192134321,
-0.0918475911,
-0.3895402849,
0.2927666008,
0.620359242,
0.6992273927,
-0.9068807364,
0.6856177449,
0.6953745484,
-0.4217233956,
-0.3640217781,
0.1433325857,
0.28254053,
-0.2304330617,
0.5077050328,
0.2110605538,
-0.3109570146,
-0.0513738878,
-0.2380221337,
-0.8556190133,
0.8025444746,
0.1867334992,
-0.5666712523,
-0.134480238,
0.1193294153,
0.317279458,
-0.3322492838,
0.3328557909,
0.4838523865,
0.5319356918,
0.1414252222,
-0.5514662862,
0.090098314,
-0.3221372664,
0.2129767537,
0.0579452105,
-0.5205149055,
0.742464602,
-0.2370412946,
-0.2253977656,
0.1141639203,
0.5275120735,
0.4885126948,
0.5582320094,
0.8336203694,
0.6276157498,
0.5521906614,
0.0407494642,
0.8432064652,
0.0087023163,
0.2650687099,
0.9638545513,
-0.6557540894,
0.4347985983,
0.670067668,
-0.0425806418,
0.7780898213,
0.5546231866,
0.0347068906,
0.6713349819,
0.0135190673,
0.0760412067,
-0.1595067382,
0.321631223,
-0.2721226811,
0.4305586815,
0.3057742119,
-0.2138804048,
-0.4712317288,
0.2679472566,
-0.0676205531,
0.3850814998,
0.1579208076,
0.7995398641,
0.089481011,
-0.7443664074,
0.3560271263,
-0.0905039907,
0.4505350888,
-0.3190717697,
-0.3270554543,
-0.4826475978,
0.2960149646,
-0.0826842934,
-0.7942108512,
0.28731668,
0.1789652109,
-0.5058921576,
-0.8048468828,
0.1368790418,
-0.3812941909,
-0.5547120571,
0.1987750381,
0.6793883443,
0.1078725234,
-0.2575066686,
-0.6070153117,
0.0860507041,
0.258964479,
-0.5535154343,
0.3839052618,
0.4222573042,
-0.1347697824,
-0.0327849053,
0.5272036195,
-0.1124463528,
-0.2641831636,
0.0701255426,
0.5888836384,
-0.4044162929,
-0.4552076459,
-1.0513944626,
0.6619907618,
-0.2496367246,
-0.5244500637,
0.9058111906,
0.7921872139,
0.6925793886,
-0.0450375155,
0.7692167759,
-0.2533376217,
0.6338785887,
-0.4348327816,
0.7705507278,
-0.9003530145,
0.4634750187,
-0.5143523216,
-1.4455381632,
-0.3553029299,
0.8121448755,
-0.1644864827,
0.0684243515,
0.6525195241,
0.516225338,
0.0568854176,
-0.1070531979,
0.2591538131,
-0.0749778152,
0.5358912945,
0.4034640491,
0.8269720078,
-0.541202724,
0.2986540794,
-0.4189403355,
-0.4265034497,
-0.2694956064,
-0.9804791808,
-0.7403532267,
-0.7809556127,
-0.8457651734,
-0.5888708234,
-0.3337772489,
0.5303415656,
0.4463930428,
-0.6660897732,
0.0585808754,
-0.0951706693,
0.3722629547,
-0.498427093,
-0.2511159778,
0.3195126355,
-0.0963192433,
-1.2764786482,
0.4212285876,
0.3167169988,
0.1419496089,
-0.4161321223,
0.28081882,
0.0316185504,
0.0542819053,
0.5537630916,
0.0735374168,
-0.4786656201,
-0.4436633885,
0.0478921011,
-0.288426429,
0.1350505948,
0.7148959637,
-1.0022560358,
0.6027358174,
0.7925204635,
0.0194242783,
0.3549289703,
0.3747225404,
0.6058058143,
-0.7316109538,
0.2151210159,
0.2126869559,
0.167792961,
0.3951634765,
-0.4525790215,
0.2515759468,
0.1991631389,
-0.4243777096,
-0.7814488411,
0.4023213685,
-1.1416245699,
-0.3317830265,
1.1349840164,
0.0474343821,
-0.2178901136,
-0.0354793668,
-0.2644897401,
0.0514064059,
-0.1265389621,
1.2139809132,
0.5018632412,
-0.1304549724,
0.2277087271,
-0.5180065036,
0.7456351519,
0.2658885717,
-0.4860820174,
0.2091246843,
0.9148570895,
0.204791978,
0.5458241105,
0.505751431,
-0.3133980334,
0.2371911108,
0.2552351058,
-0.1790311188,
-0.0835521594,
-0.4738417864,
-0.2704585791,
0.1491746157,
-0.3001422286,
-0.4554066062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15381v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15381v1 | Causal schema induction for knowledge discovery | 2023-03-27T16:55:49 | 2023-03-27T16:55:49 | Michael Regan, Jena D. Hwang, Keisuke Sakaguchi, James Pustejovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Making sense of familiar yet new situations typically involves making
generalizations about causal schemas, stories that help humans reason about
event sequences. Reasoning about events includes identifying cause and effect
relations shared across event instances, a process we refer to as causal schema
induction. Statistical schema induction systems may leverage structural
knowledge encoded in discourse or the causal graphs associated with event
meaning, however resources to study such causal structure are few in number and
limited in size. In this work, we investigate how to apply schema induction
models to the task of knowledge discovery for enhanced search of
English-language news texts. To tackle the problem of data scarcity, we present
Torquestra, a manually curated dataset of text-graph-schema units integrating
temporal, event, and causal structures. We benchmark our dataset on three
knowledge discovery tasks, building and evaluating models for each. Results
show that systems that harness causal structure are effective at identifying
texts sharing similar causal meaning components rather than relying on lexical
cues alone. We make our dataset and models available for research purposes. | [
0.0117081692,
-0.4269411266,
0.9411025643,
0.1986574084,
-0.1474543661,
-0.1836373657,
-0.0639724508,
-0.379882127,
0.3752165735,
0.2361932397,
-0.6580186486,
-0.7164426446,
-0.6432144642,
0.1357427388,
-0.806278348,
0.7325568795,
-0.2702852488,
0.0084755532,
-0.3719515204,
-0.2107556313,
-0.4104187489,
-0.1088235527,
-0.3951176405,
-0.2564608455,
0.7325420976,
0.4200459421,
0.700640142,
0.9008613229,
0.491093576,
0.168097198,
0.0028626306,
0.5317584872,
-0.4626444578,
0.362324208,
-0.7306872606,
-0.3262709081,
0.1203685552,
-0.0463638566,
0.5086095929,
0.9746330976,
-0.29063344,
0.0103173163,
-0.0584011115,
0.3983026445,
-0.5278337598,
0.5340625644,
-0.6914974451,
-0.2546053827,
-0.5018119216,
-0.5286402106,
-0.2485117018,
-0.5124352574,
0.0938435495,
-1.1584570408,
0.7162950635,
0.3071534336,
0.8872339725,
0.2250050455,
-0.6319768429,
-0.562066257,
-0.7625982761,
0.531216383,
-0.1171043217,
0.5638796687,
0.405533731,
0.0190521833,
-0.2410503775,
-0.6468293071,
-0.4927972257,
0.087844193,
-0.5098357201,
-0.0798859969,
0.0058312807,
-0.1784456074,
0.1418776065,
-0.121639818,
-0.6790803075,
0.0444307923,
-0.5714785457,
-0.3503492773,
0.5836749673,
0.5856432319,
0.3790501654,
-0.5196883678,
-0.1599949896,
0.0495529622,
-0.9757278562,
-0.343185693,
0.3629373014,
0.5430548787,
0.107700631,
0.6907414794,
-0.555794239,
0.6079236269,
-0.1942714453,
-0.0983115584,
0.1881423146,
-0.7075673938,
0.2194652408,
0.3621714115,
0.7048222423,
0.2694216073,
0.0107080089,
-0.5673719049,
0.1861174703,
0.3113621175,
0.0623075888,
-0.5797410011,
0.2283302099,
0.0195951425,
-0.3584930897,
-0.4156402051,
0.2043651491,
-0.4171833694,
-0.7044699788,
-0.3593251705,
0.2145281285,
-0.564637661,
-0.0548934676,
0.3349297345,
-0.7500891685,
0.0827472433,
0.303991586,
-0.7343992591,
0.1539300382,
0.5744362473,
0.6528894901,
-0.2057467997,
-0.538734138,
-0.3011133075,
0.5155089498,
-0.3922159672,
1.0402354002,
-0.4216481447,
0.021944467,
0.2249474972,
0.28271088,
0.0340713635,
-0.2330128103,
0.7432675958,
-0.6427748203,
0.1983467638,
-0.5718482137,
-0.6272956729,
-0.0016785661,
-0.2853705585,
-0.6117047668,
1.0999289751,
0.1913429648,
-1.0041379929,
0.9578377008,
-0.361344099,
-1.013653636,
0.0185843967,
-0.3019704819,
-0.0418299586,
0.0106331324,
0.0909413099,
0.5206557512,
-0.7992327809,
0.7637928724,
-0.2991249561,
-0.2765448391,
-0.1483073086,
0.0223702583,
0.7439238429,
0.0750787407,
-0.3426753879,
-0.1347187012,
-0.7710881829,
-0.6530147791,
0.2868987024,
-0.0588925853,
-0.883934617,
0.3615691662,
-0.3853800297,
0.0467014611,
-0.1038058624,
-0.484482795,
0.2916641235,
-0.2519718409,
0.1624908596,
0.4472155273,
0.2720848918,
0.8092259765,
-0.1530211121,
0.0905672014,
0.3023443818,
-0.061880935,
-0.198106721,
-0.3383343816,
-0.5636706948,
0.2263289392,
0.088062264,
0.3282245994,
-0.7531882524,
0.2205867916,
-0.4069749713,
-0.3938626051,
-0.4115315974,
0.1610711962,
-0.0965516567,
0.484315455,
0.2492215633,
0.0788078234,
-0.5399590731,
-0.6636523008,
-0.6092120409,
0.0299728755,
-0.1846935749,
0.3743211329,
0.3655561805,
0.0528942756,
0.8019458652,
-0.7889872789,
-0.3515741825,
-0.1071246266,
0.3992888033,
0.2228763402,
0.0367249511,
0.3559168875,
-0.5234203339,
-0.0612156577,
0.0150634954,
-1.2222903967,
-0.3012735546,
-0.3055595756,
-0.3090581,
-0.0766849518,
0.8553090692,
-0.7325020432,
0.485103637,
-0.1181717813,
-0.4174731076,
0.4319319427,
0.1848859638,
0.0333656259,
-0.9824743867,
-0.0571354479,
-0.0734995306,
0.0639156476,
-0.2419792712,
-0.1623719633,
0.1729114354,
-0.0349273942,
-0.2378217727,
0.5424361229,
-0.4064978063,
-0.040419247,
-0.1479126811,
0.6791547537,
0.1315850616,
0.214508146,
0.1562631279,
0.4237554967,
0.5692333579,
-0.7437521219,
0.3664710224,
0.385365665,
-0.52098912,
0.6496645212,
-0.4801608324,
-0.2859330773,
-0.5015287399,
0.0756321847,
-0.7719880939,
-0.5268725753,
0.0311028678,
-0.2338647246,
-0.0960955992,
0.0263007097,
-0.6803838611,
-0.4615241587,
-0.1059787869,
0.2651155889,
-0.2124855518,
-0.5932794809,
0.4114854038,
0.4189862907,
-0.1254858971,
-0.5393487811,
-0.1119152084,
-0.1087381914,
-0.0349116996,
-0.6441372037,
0.4603913128,
0.5215270519,
-0.3164078295,
0.2923482358,
-0.1423291415,
0.0700979158,
0.0929898024,
0.422193706,
-0.0085533317,
-0.1329718232,
0.8777592182,
0.5029157996,
-0.1332610399,
0.1243538186,
-0.6260099411,
0.4842685461,
0.3040373921,
-0.1722235531,
-0.4232796133,
0.4426293671,
0.6791670918,
-0.0088667721,
0.9283200502,
0.5457252264,
-0.4155217111,
-0.2081250995,
-0.3429941535,
-0.5223329067,
-0.3980511129,
0.2173589021,
0.0431558862,
-0.57433182,
0.3832397461,
-0.2950049639,
-0.2901017964,
0.6829437613,
0.3056529164,
-0.0247260146,
0.9410703778,
0.3216972351,
-0.2264418006,
0.2973987758,
0.0291165914,
0.241311878,
-0.3764373362,
-0.3932875991,
-0.6099547148,
-0.1000793204,
-0.3917756379,
-0.2583500743,
0.2896575332,
-0.1087715998,
-0.3916282952,
0.5762153864,
-0.3470378518,
0.3859147429,
0.7959696054,
0.2011347413,
0.5967831016,
-0.045347441,
-0.245507732,
0.1831385642,
-0.9534130096,
-0.0884328038,
1.0317825079,
-0.3370454013,
0.9235611558,
-0.2122939229,
0.6201569438,
0.0999885425,
0.1247342452,
-0.5021820068,
0.3750885427,
0.2958344221,
-0.8307197094,
-0.4409471154,
-0.4142169356,
-1.0943387747,
-0.2656071782,
-0.3803396225,
-0.5088219047,
0.3545350134,
-0.3400253356,
-0.1278369129,
-0.0894174501,
-0.3907298744,
0.4554607272,
-0.033097025,
-0.5564786792,
-0.4171690643,
-0.5282124281,
0.4064386785,
0.0264372658,
0.2920246422,
-0.0877732113,
0.3707248569,
0.957226336,
-0.4415771067,
0.8073817492,
0.0227485988,
0.095893614,
0.297301054,
-0.046775274,
0.975887537,
0.2268676013,
-0.0253220685,
0.0245224833,
-0.1777944863,
-0.2999648452,
-0.6346609592,
0.6208717227,
-0.5516454577,
-0.6183874607,
-0.4161963463,
-0.8199310899,
-0.1116856188,
0.4912573397,
0.2926035821,
0.3632723689,
0.004036753,
0.2155444175,
0.3800815642,
-0.0846933946,
0.1456109434,
0.7821853161,
-0.0186427031,
0.1088341027,
0.5396060944,
0.2660201788,
-0.3098401725,
0.3219951689,
0.2556463182,
-0.1327615827,
-0.1674091369,
-0.0566063784,
0.3393554688,
-0.5347660184,
-0.6846177578,
-0.729870379,
-0.1012163758,
-0.448641777,
-0.1944686323,
-0.1791077405,
-0.6722955704,
-0.3032812774,
-0.6134927273,
0.6395434141,
0.8269889951,
-0.1576348394,
0.3481938541,
-0.3462581336,
0.3564321399,
0.0788205788,
0.3429738879,
0.0244128145,
-0.0258189514,
-0.4884647131,
-0.2358887792,
-0.303732276,
-1.0728825331,
0.1986012459,
0.0179624092,
0.4829668403,
0.7305319905,
0.3010712266,
0.4512123466,
-0.5390042067,
0.398415029,
-0.0643287674,
-0.693117857,
0.7618855238,
-0.7461950779,
-0.0958293304,
0.275072366,
0.8877719641,
-0.6233564615,
-0.6290223002,
-0.8056715727,
-0.9219452739,
0.664332509,
0.1793895364,
-0.190283969,
-0.2995897532,
0.5261821747,
0.1346725672,
0.2599021494,
-0.2697958648,
-0.1668822169,
0.0230023358,
-0.1486957669,
0.1937042773,
-0.118023999,
-0.2769688666,
-0.2831790745,
0.5490294695,
-0.0094682211,
0.1069976687,
0.2464800328,
-0.3451438546,
-0.1771162897,
-0.1108441055,
0.2399302423,
0.5200157762,
0.0218567029,
0.2850436866,
0.1826198399,
-0.3308744431,
-0.0020234843,
0.2932406366,
-0.3431737721,
0.1948569119,
0.5514762402,
0.5547505021,
0.7265768647,
-0.4037644565,
0.533942461,
0.0622525699,
-0.2200083733,
0.0799286664,
-0.0031606571,
0.3273189068,
0.3091254234,
0.480281204,
-0.2067848593,
0.1900476962,
-0.5094270706,
0.4025059342,
0.3934011459,
-0.0392273664,
-0.3373481035,
0.8091671467,
0.0274985898,
0.0385090485,
0.6510324478,
-0.3582057655,
-0.3733794093,
0.4747865796,
0.578126967,
0.3602763116,
-0.1708126813,
0.5664766431,
0.3603064716,
0.4109424949,
-0.2028566599,
0.3214320838,
0.0647799745,
-1.0123895407,
-0.217916131,
-0.425570637,
-0.1927909553,
-0.0863747224,
-0.6137040854,
0.6294158101,
0.0123221185,
0.084531039,
0.3185053766,
-0.1313124001,
-0.9493326545,
-0.0141226603,
-0.2011309713,
0.8439130187,
-1.2504544258,
0.5959803462,
0.1308421046,
-0.5267308354,
-0.9213677049,
-0.2363124192,
0.1291033328,
-0.9277680516,
0.77238518,
-0.1766320318,
0.1682156473,
-0.1413217187,
-0.4428295195,
-1.0319125652,
1.3852819204,
0.2867031693,
-0.3881980479,
-0.2309591919,
0.2753002644,
0.4113203585,
-0.2486808002,
-0.1278033257,
0.6073491573,
0.4997451007,
-0.0832308158,
-0.3216978908,
0.4263660908,
0.1164752841,
-0.4756142497,
0.3710841238,
-0.3005424738,
0.6244549155,
-0.2828615308,
-0.3468624949,
-0.2032540441,
0.700842917,
0.0816462934,
0.6677237749,
0.1693571508,
0.3891556263,
1.3221796751,
-0.1556549817,
0.9836344719,
-0.6051954627,
0.3166621923,
0.972088635,
-0.5268575549,
0.3256103098,
0.3548892736,
-0.0280976072,
0.8065679073,
0.5140342116,
0.1521437913,
0.660492897,
0.0892858878,
-0.1694971025,
-0.2184976786,
-0.5039682984,
-0.1304470748,
0.3906317353,
0.4846716225,
-0.5632032156,
-0.4931329191,
0.0227199011,
0.3352826834,
-0.2198312879,
-0.2129656523,
0.6459957361,
-0.1214076355,
-0.6967206597,
0.0307388008,
-0.1614167988,
0.0488384776,
-0.558688581,
0.1982312202,
-0.4652708471,
-0.0337058417,
-0.1729281843,
-0.6149763465,
0.4085959494,
-0.3578901589,
-0.4276302755,
-0.0206564348,
1.1829047203,
-0.3411522806,
-0.5922248363,
0.3250300884,
0.6640172601,
-0.1876248866,
-0.1576240063,
0.1762129366,
-0.2729465663,
-0.4431894124,
-0.1003287658,
0.1386205107,
0.8501599431,
-0.430793494,
0.4999953806,
0.6471054554,
0.0472010933,
-0.1473426819,
0.0758839995,
0.9800833464,
-0.8540791273,
-0.343467176,
-0.6400201321,
-0.008336409,
-0.3770899773,
-0.2239222825,
0.9175639153,
0.6592037678,
0.6014467478,
0.0071706576,
0.964844048,
0.1171693727,
0.528793931,
-0.4202431738,
0.6929152608,
-0.3858448863,
0.2200804204,
-0.3518466353,
-0.4395994246,
-0.4130334854,
0.3335700035,
-0.3547298014,
-0.5320770741,
1.0392481089,
0.877325356,
-0.1100284159,
0.3288221359,
-0.1049089655,
0.3107676804,
-0.0847710297,
0.202957049,
0.8563671112,
-0.2407549471,
0.5749658942,
0.0193908177,
-0.1204571798,
-0.2876904011,
-0.7857972383,
-0.7078908086,
-1.0161765814,
-0.07705874,
-0.3920855224,
0.3848010302,
0.4512932599,
0.5037407875,
-0.5863966346,
0.0250584614,
-0.5386506915,
0.7610518932,
-0.3368265629,
-0.2900338173,
0.7104949951,
-0.6639969349,
-0.2172603458,
0.4425130188,
0.2445897013,
-0.4029510021,
0.1267782748,
0.2677048743,
-0.2222274095,
0.2647583187,
0.5690956712,
0.120603092,
-0.1256699711,
-0.4174340665,
0.355881542,
0.0466163419,
-0.3499994576,
1.2015941143,
-0.9529996514,
0.0460841209,
0.6505795121,
0.309769839,
0.5821945667,
-0.3420918882,
0.765622139,
-0.9703446627,
0.3040158451,
-0.1147110388,
0.5115666986,
0.1156000197,
-0.5493976474,
0.7564139366,
0.6342777014,
-0.3356063664,
-0.8661655784,
0.1657463312,
-0.6702068448,
-0.3273850083,
1.2766056061,
0.3477897346,
-0.0966507494,
-0.4139550924,
0.007482158,
0.3732199371,
-0.2231294215,
0.8969451785,
0.723454237,
-0.0454463102,
0.3385147452,
-0.2847689688,
0.7150945663,
0.0775004923,
-0.6225963235,
0.2812557518,
0.2343770266,
0.0898307264,
0.2136376798,
0.2734105587,
-0.0997925326,
0.3332587779,
0.1813028902,
-0.1846555024,
0.1187491864,
-0.5930269361,
0.3755502701,
0.1415069848,
-0.3900996447,
0.1425572783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15350v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15350v2 | Improving Neural Topic Models with Wasserstein Knowledge Distillation | 2023-03-27T16:07:44 | 2024-06-20T06:50:43 | Suman Adhya, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Topic modeling is a dominant method for exploring document collections on the
web and in digital libraries. Recent approaches to topic modeling use
pretrained contextualized language models and variational autoencoders.
However, large neural topic models have a considerable memory footprint. In
this paper, we propose a knowledge distillation framework to compress a
contextualized topic model without loss in topic quality. In particular, the
proposed distillation objective is to minimize the cross-entropy of the soft
labels produced by the teacher and the student models, as well as to minimize
the squared 2-Wasserstein distance between the latent distributions learned by
the two models. Experiments on two publicly available datasets show that the
student trained with knowledge distillation achieves topic coherence much
higher than that of the original student model, and even surpasses the teacher
while containing far fewer parameters than the teacher's. The distilled model
also outperforms several other competitive topic models on topic coherence. | [
-0.4212070405,
-0.5140719414,
0.642942369,
-0.2208049148,
-0.5469877124,
0.0085713286,
-0.4771911204,
0.2115690261,
0.340195477,
0.3085929155,
-0.2228306979,
-0.5114210844,
-0.8826310039,
-0.425070554,
-0.5977858305,
1.1732748747,
0.1688514948,
0.1661371589,
-0.4940787852,
0.1986630559,
-0.0767276362,
-0.4556417465,
-0.5200052857,
-0.8471823335,
0.3567460179,
0.1934547275,
0.2456068993,
0.5304285884,
0.4157713652,
0.3921430111,
-0.6628901362,
-0.201733321,
-0.6214142442,
0.5080009699,
-0.4003777206,
-0.6181303263,
-0.4002330899,
0.2221658081,
0.2429969758,
1.0459191799,
-0.3419823349,
-0.0971853212,
0.3826896548,
0.6029070616,
-0.6768057942,
-0.0840408728,
-0.6978543997,
0.1491489112,
-0.048471339,
-0.1428400725,
-0.1388082057,
0.0287204515,
0.7208358049,
-0.5743533373,
0.6555110216,
-0.2479198426,
0.7198569179,
0.5536910295,
-0.5151165724,
-0.032455992,
-0.5172944665,
0.6740971804,
-0.5303601027,
0.3088018596,
0.6558198333,
0.2064258754,
-0.0004734792,
-0.9652453065,
-0.4228954911,
0.129565388,
0.1045650691,
0.1487869471,
-0.3395210207,
-0.0622531846,
0.0959890112,
0.3636876643,
-0.508264482,
-0.2196123004,
-0.3585889637,
-0.061304979,
0.363011539,
-0.0753799826,
-0.1226225719,
-0.2725894451,
-0.2904039025,
-0.1056599915,
-0.3294160962,
-0.2871700823,
0.2829978168,
-0.0533586442,
0.2129328698,
0.3423218131,
-0.4060054421,
0.5068089962,
0.2976866066,
-0.2086607069,
-0.0476445593,
-0.209532842,
0.0277079232,
0.245853439,
0.2907480896,
0.4002321959,
0.0162823405,
-0.3541595638,
0.0010354818,
-0.184788242,
0.3327799737,
-1.1535215378,
-0.5716380477,
0.1208234057,
-0.7456194162,
-0.1008998677,
-0.0122983344,
-0.6896395683,
-0.4095424712,
-0.4801162779,
0.1838903874,
-0.1806734353,
-0.3866667151,
-0.0036919825,
-0.6709246635,
-0.3679809868,
0.5074068308,
-1.0042874813,
0.2800801694,
0.8482002616,
0.9225008488,
-0.3805063367,
-0.3004031181,
-0.1871641278,
0.1885332912,
-0.1135313064,
0.5345984697,
-0.2172962725,
-0.2548558712,
-0.3947165906,
-0.2628700435,
0.3723430336,
-0.5984889269,
0.1039920077,
-0.6912058592,
0.1869245917,
-0.3044163883,
-0.9812723994,
-0.2862803936,
0.4759304225,
-0.4664368331,
0.4237381518,
-0.0857494026,
-0.9232826829,
0.4432364106,
-0.4328759015,
-0.1303119808,
-0.2009412497,
-0.088890031,
-0.1749241799,
0.4493881166,
0.1190233603,
0.4971548319,
-0.4830524921,
1.0496293306,
-0.3128527999,
-0.2368588448,
0.2674163878,
-0.7284231782,
0.6860820651,
0.2579636574,
-0.2083868086,
-0.1222132668,
-0.7765626907,
-0.2340570539,
-0.1927680075,
-0.4927663505,
-0.7717826962,
-0.1877093911,
-0.2082179189,
-0.1206125394,
0.3187913597,
-0.3924712539,
0.1655773371,
-0.2771542668,
0.4722436368,
0.5341416597,
0.2256025076,
0.7696883082,
-0.2388806641,
0.0774457902,
0.4168384075,
-0.1915551275,
-0.0179921854,
-0.3730351925,
-0.9721726775,
-0.1600292325,
0.634424746,
0.1858015358,
-0.6895315647,
0.6600617766,
-0.2300668657,
-0.6248213649,
-0.0958778411,
0.0659634545,
0.0716420859,
0.7306596041,
0.3792339265,
-0.3500574529,
-0.1956353337,
-0.6237694025,
0.1089680046,
-0.0802304745,
-0.2074691355,
0.1117653027,
0.5090423822,
-0.0544392839,
1.0631144047,
-0.9439013004,
-0.1908501983,
0.1652740389,
0.6667321324,
0.4222945869,
0.7516476512,
0.3711488545,
-0.996204257,
-0.4729290307,
-0.3980795145,
-0.6775280833,
0.1013891399,
0.2828505635,
-0.1172130257,
-0.1053900868,
0.605884552,
-0.4234359264,
0.5171262026,
0.2152777165,
-0.4050536752,
0.1296816468,
-0.4863476455,
0.1311851889,
-1.4222730398,
0.0819455311,
-0.0017561662,
-0.1585963666,
-0.5640916824,
-0.229919374,
-0.0837681815,
-0.4976519644,
-0.3882420361,
0.3880248666,
-0.3387151659,
0.25101614,
-0.8106680512,
-0.0158300288,
0.3695683479,
0.4509781003,
0.4277639389,
0.4428719878,
0.7548761368,
-0.4475394487,
0.5791965127,
0.1955789924,
-0.3656350374,
0.655990243,
-0.8197886944,
0.1433196664,
-0.2554143965,
0.3645953238,
-0.830668807,
-0.0670732632,
-0.0702040344,
-0.2010740191,
0.6080665588,
-0.4808194637,
-0.1480889469,
-0.0335904509,
-0.0422200747,
0.1851255745,
0.4754778147,
-0.5769757628,
0.3322186172,
0.2543685734,
-0.2682493925,
-0.4807813168,
-0.7440719008,
0.2071475834,
-0.4769974053,
-0.7128284574,
0.8215816021,
-0.1220745593,
-0.1890397072,
0.4576093554,
-0.1776302308,
-0.5921940207,
0.2125622332,
0.1025081947,
-0.0723631755,
-0.1927232444,
0.5133140087,
0.3076941669,
-0.4115540385,
-0.1689821631,
-0.5835925937,
0.5450778604,
0.0844253823,
-0.2362578064,
-0.2360838503,
0.4379441738,
0.3930607736,
0.0469018668,
0.8876413703,
0.552754283,
-0.5047599077,
-0.0764918849,
-0.4367259741,
-0.6380283833,
-0.4639196992,
0.4091883898,
-0.2697787285,
-0.8466934562,
0.4039714336,
-0.3557795584,
-0.3774967194,
0.0451538041,
0.451405704,
-0.1524832398,
0.4425085783,
0.7697985172,
-0.0523544066,
0.4552375376,
-0.644287467,
-0.0244117789,
-0.6213952303,
-0.213113308,
-0.4976119697,
-0.483156532,
-0.3093114793,
-0.3594285846,
0.531624794,
0.1683224738,
0.0190268569,
0.0504306257,
-0.507804215,
0.5716813803,
0.965395391,
0.3518280089,
0.2092056274,
0.1957669556,
0.0343662016,
-0.0735925809,
-0.9159342647,
-0.3977463841,
1.0507516861,
0.3754943311,
0.8918891549,
-0.0209333915,
1.0571261644,
0.1653736085,
-0.1049004644,
-0.4696430564,
0.280010581,
-0.5017047524,
-0.7943854928,
-0.4405994117,
-0.4127418399,
-0.6663959026,
0.3909504712,
-0.1868731529,
-0.6094761491,
0.5226761699,
0.2658724785,
-0.4517755508,
0.2582668066,
-0.4413641095,
0.7494720221,
-0.0077040023,
-0.5655588508,
-0.3672087193,
-0.4552870095,
0.1671559811,
-0.1954948455,
-0.3509617746,
0.0320963487,
0.0407388173,
1.0814710855,
-0.830540061,
0.7085850835,
-0.372815907,
0.0375980362,
0.3362617195,
-0.2742829919,
0.3140883446,
0.1325484663,
-0.1863184571,
0.1318063587,
0.0044081626,
-0.3581511974,
-0.8337138891,
0.6231675744,
-0.7869329453,
-1.0568823814,
-0.3171833754,
-0.5731647015,
0.0302466564,
0.1133451387,
0.5216365457,
0.3756508231,
-0.1703843623,
0.6263234615,
0.9195901752,
-0.0704120845,
0.4888120294,
0.4263966978,
0.1108022779,
-0.4111002684,
0.8304216862,
0.4703908563,
-0.1050609946,
0.1307585388,
0.5443028808,
-0.3745882809,
-0.7082366943,
-0.1054559499,
-0.1513248533,
-0.9566159248,
-0.257550478,
-0.857370317,
-0.2648257911,
-0.6209598184,
-0.1709409058,
-0.5855988264,
-0.5412543416,
-0.8156555891,
0.1055162326,
0.3763751984,
0.3292454481,
-0.4120674431,
0.5586687922,
-0.6173247099,
0.2454273254,
0.5746233463,
0.1264422387,
0.2141813934,
-0.786560595,
-0.1403112411,
0.0943192467,
-0.2908136845,
-0.809628129,
0.5000274777,
0.3555660844,
0.5337614417,
0.5373259783,
0.4380190372,
0.4118954837,
-0.281111449,
0.5933547616,
0.467227608,
-1.0673686266,
0.6469064355,
-0.1040551886,
0.3417356312,
0.8116532564,
0.6121359468,
-0.3753482997,
-0.2402904928,
-0.6344996691,
-0.9107139111,
0.4755156338,
0.0892053768,
0.3762075305,
0.2193535119,
0.4111952782,
0.321106106,
0.449413389,
-0.5084595084,
-0.1969874948,
-0.5833790302,
-0.1058514714,
-0.14610672,
-0.4382117391,
-0.0950958356,
-0.3863031268,
0.7360909581,
0.0863764286,
-0.1477616578,
0.0618579797,
-0.1697989702,
0.047478281,
0.0726089925,
0.3802236617,
0.59046942,
-0.4614291191,
0.8376234174,
0.0157084931,
-0.525313437,
0.6353956461,
0.2787995636,
-0.2787986696,
0.0601218119,
0.1988137066,
0.7910433412,
-0.0153038288,
-0.0935518891,
0.4886672497,
-0.2404343486,
-0.2142289281,
0.0320112593,
0.3855936527,
0.3494260609,
0.6997716427,
0.4181186557,
-0.0287657175,
0.3297525346,
-0.3893171251,
0.5098727345,
0.0021634123,
-0.3231806159,
0.0025401039,
0.4922442734,
0.3463926315,
-0.0926987305,
0.8218943477,
-0.1624444574,
-0.6846743822,
0.6099177599,
0.5283266306,
0.6706110835,
0.0802716836,
0.1761220545,
0.3674937189,
-0.1121228337,
-0.2030745894,
-0.1221873835,
-0.4444490075,
-0.6342033744,
0.0941772163,
-0.6280450821,
-0.2880859673,
0.1546231657,
-0.6587346792,
0.1000406221,
-0.1766203493,
-0.4434094727,
0.2013390213,
0.2987926006,
-0.2213132679,
0.2362533659,
-0.2102005184,
0.8084418178,
-0.8657618165,
1.0289955139,
0.4894875884,
-0.2110518068,
-0.4195503294,
0.2563433051,
-0.2136706859,
-0.1223941818,
1.0503793955,
-0.1630106866,
0.3995239437,
0.1461932808,
-0.4399209917,
-0.9563689232,
1.2324177027,
0.4330135584,
-0.6703317165,
0.1488919556,
-0.0285611115,
0.512086153,
-0.1258448064,
-0.0727287084,
0.0843226463,
0.1962087601,
0.4986250699,
-0.3875503838,
-0.1387192905,
-0.262447089,
-0.0021625713,
-0.0823245645,
-0.3481218815,
0.9317179918,
0.1696397662,
0.1623349339,
-0.2208070755,
0.9810585976,
0.1876795143,
0.6117706895,
0.3740212917,
0.7869669795,
1.0263688564,
-0.0861366987,
0.5608541965,
-0.3728895485,
0.4918612838,
1.4156508446,
-0.1633725166,
0.4438877106,
0.7000442743,
0.0911404341,
-0.0536892079,
0.7185124159,
-0.0644398183,
1.0122517347,
0.53015095,
-0.2718256116,
-0.277608335,
-0.2603288889,
-0.5580631495,
0.57245332,
0.0828993544,
-0.3718148768,
-0.5393307209,
0.3281960785,
0.0330789611,
0.0154409371,
0.0203339346,
0.7550019622,
0.2823102474,
-0.9384481907,
0.6640145183,
0.0794354081,
0.7822384834,
-0.2322845757,
0.0693042651,
-0.4865864515,
0.0485627763,
0.2269322425,
-0.4610936344,
0.4924092889,
0.115328297,
-0.6934123039,
-0.3014148176,
1.0953754187,
-0.8999739885,
-0.24295789,
0.1026144177,
0.6158275008,
0.3100413978,
-0.2073265165,
-0.5779746175,
-0.026162738,
-0.2268700153,
-0.4189213812,
0.2142958939,
0.6251442432,
0.2728559971,
0.4415198863,
0.349555552,
0.0430046357,
-0.108919777,
-0.1468382031,
0.9301819801,
-0.2981266379,
-0.5777181983,
-0.9337520599,
0.2423415482,
-0.2263178527,
-0.1607325077,
0.4548175335,
0.4226079881,
0.5738601089,
-0.0010189912,
0.4702273607,
0.1298302114,
0.2006212473,
-0.555801332,
1.2836797237,
-0.748411417,
0.2100588232,
-0.0363630578,
-1.0371069908,
0.0141982995,
0.6465519667,
-0.3271123767,
0.044171311,
0.4199717641,
0.69331038,
-0.4285517335,
-0.0345277339,
0.6546046734,
-0.0691275597,
0.252592206,
0.349719286,
1.0562026501,
-0.2242572159,
0.0868859515,
-0.6914002299,
-0.2527459264,
-0.2260552049,
-1.099768877,
-1.1550104618,
-0.8534712195,
-0.7041308284,
-0.1706688404,
0.1594443768,
0.706264019,
1.1437009573,
-0.5374546647,
-0.0159927662,
-0.2923315763,
0.1657968163,
0.3149966002,
-0.1252472997,
0.4945249856,
-0.2521908581,
-0.6027323604,
0.1925759166,
0.0167576764,
0.421071887,
-0.2944716215,
0.0630171075,
-0.2774448097,
-0.0753901079,
0.2002932578,
-0.3225152791,
-0.3889509141,
0.0165218748,
-0.1228734255,
-0.0854005516,
-0.1070462093,
0.7990470529,
-0.3881779909,
0.3611781597,
0.7455686331,
0.5251480341,
0.9575120211,
-0.1717917174,
0.5259581208,
-0.9675050378,
0.395172596,
0.131292209,
0.3912369907,
0.2575157881,
-0.3592109382,
0.3948414624,
0.4549827874,
-0.3618566692,
-0.68097651,
-0.0408764854,
-0.5511744618,
-0.9180509448,
0.8336638808,
-0.6557615995,
-0.2610348165,
-0.0943818837,
0.0631783307,
0.7118139863,
-0.3210676312,
0.987013042,
0.6968473196,
0.2638416588,
-0.0194655247,
-0.1186573282,
0.2989035547,
0.3354486525,
-0.7067162991,
-0.0659648925,
0.3813633919,
0.3105464578,
0.3173764944,
0.4081664979,
0.3983471692,
0.1152000949,
0.2862275243,
-0.0701306015,
-0.1909015775,
-0.6549091935,
-0.2857756317,
0.3879699111,
-0.1233353391,
-0.0752995387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15265v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15265v1 | Bilex Rx: Lexical Data Augmentation for Massively Multilingual Machine Translation | 2023-03-27T14:54:43 | 2023-03-27T14:54:43 | Alex Jones, Isaac Caswell, Ishank Saxena, Orhan Firat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | Neural machine translation (NMT) has progressed rapidly over the past several
years, and modern models are able to achieve relatively high quality using only
monolingual text data, an approach dubbed Unsupervised Machine Translation
(UNMT). However, these models still struggle in a variety of ways, including
aspects of translation that for a human are the easiest - for instance,
correctly translating common nouns. This work explores a cheap and abundant
resource to combat this problem: bilingual lexica. We test the efficacy of
bilingual lexica in a real-world set-up, on 200-language translation models
trained on web-crawled text. We present several findings: (1) using lexical
data augmentation, we demonstrate sizable performance gains for unsupervised
translation; (2) we compare several families of data augmentation,
demonstrating that they yield similar improvements, and can be combined for
even greater improvements; (3) we demonstrate the importance of carefully
curated lexica over larger, noisier ones, especially with larger models; and
(4) we compare the efficacy of multilingual lexicon data versus
human-translated parallel data. Finally, we open-source GATITOS (available at
https://github.com/google-research/url-nlp/tree/main/gatitos), a new
multilingual lexicon for 26 low-resource languages, which had the highest
performance among lexica in our experiments. | [
-0.2744061351,
-0.427928865,
0.3855736852,
0.4376380742,
-0.4097944796,
0.3603779376,
-0.3073174655,
-0.5714984536,
0.388987571,
0.4502666891,
-0.3484753966,
-0.5283936858,
-0.4874399304,
0.4497881532,
-0.5518186688,
1.0560132265,
0.1989257783,
0.2300583273,
-0.1045096293,
-0.3601540327,
-0.2986419499,
-0.5934941173,
-0.4630094767,
-0.3199044466,
0.7415404916,
0.3378781676,
1.2825561762,
0.8030952811,
0.1616104543,
0.2912480235,
-0.1693760455,
0.4488625526,
-0.0898977742,
-0.039439261,
-0.2486923933,
-0.4138360023,
-0.5933631659,
-0.3708637655,
0.7248333693,
1.251811862,
-0.0295393504,
-0.1188095286,
0.0589687265,
0.700188756,
-0.529822588,
0.1345899105,
-0.6580376625,
0.162788868,
-0.2421225607,
-0.1228192747,
-0.2737227678,
-0.2106618881,
-0.1150607914,
-0.7642351985,
0.1418545246,
0.2143215686,
0.4089521766,
0.2850083113,
-0.7214950919,
-0.169505924,
-0.4716223478,
0.6819019318,
-0.6717633009,
0.6975593567,
0.205524534,
0.0220855623,
-0.1724386513,
-0.6349315643,
-0.3005873859,
-0.1118753552,
0.1544894278,
0.3487820029,
-0.2350907922,
-0.2169280201,
0.1018904597,
0.565747261,
-0.6915513277,
0.1940733343,
-0.1893995702,
-0.1712834686,
0.2593921721,
0.2484421879,
0.5900905728,
-0.0258609466,
-0.324457407,
-0.3115828633,
-0.5149666667,
-0.2053576708,
0.4986389279,
0.5777568221,
-0.0375507176,
0.8415967226,
-0.2612172663,
0.5473229289,
-0.377601862,
0.1333485246,
0.4093529284,
-0.6846660376,
0.0205872934,
0.2255879939,
0.7819489837,
0.0678855479,
0.2787607908,
-0.7115373611,
-0.2195664346,
0.0151110096,
0.2406977564,
-0.6293007731,
0.0307261366,
-0.0029834309,
-0.1307561845,
-0.1220199168,
-0.1065901518,
-0.8953049183,
-0.4454466999,
-0.4009977579,
0.0720751658,
-0.2379540205,
-0.3498711884,
0.2978167236,
-0.008652634,
-0.0949129462,
0.0815868825,
-0.9214676619,
0.5117900968,
0.5742755532,
1.0302846432,
-0.2484291792,
-0.5679011345,
-0.6103335619,
-0.1909469515,
-0.6740118861,
0.6828274131,
-0.3344020247,
-0.3569261432,
-0.0506213307,
0.0853184387,
-0.0352288298,
-0.5083028078,
0.5539436936,
-0.5414963365,
-0.1534710377,
-0.3507415652,
-0.1152038351,
-0.0993324816,
0.1942673624,
-0.7126674652,
0.9202230573,
0.084133327,
-0.8523694277,
0.1624150872,
-0.4886598289,
-0.6683387756,
-0.0954172611,
0.2421461791,
-0.0322065577,
0.3035698533,
0.4749038517,
0.0272525288,
-0.5572493672,
0.1290963292,
-0.3160938919,
0.0413219705,
0.3234137893,
-0.4513291121,
0.7925845981,
0.3555597961,
-0.238956362,
-0.0126955211,
-0.616333127,
-0.0461740755,
0.0396146923,
-0.4743750989,
-0.3674750924,
-0.1852521896,
0.2881251276,
0.2204894125,
0.1928841919,
-0.7678840756,
0.1410180032,
-0.7242213488,
0.2084442526,
0.42995736,
-0.5768232346,
0.6822618246,
-0.0164410714,
0.5180450678,
0.1638766527,
0.1036866903,
-0.0312260613,
-0.8048512936,
-0.6602377892,
-0.1247014105,
0.6380731463,
0.5007369518,
-0.9765546322,
0.1060740054,
-0.5515115261,
-0.2534780502,
-0.5899173021,
0.36179775,
0.3345832825,
0.4545890987,
0.6038748026,
-0.4206920266,
-0.4213060737,
-0.9305018187,
-0.2386793792,
0.1242632195,
0.1358064264,
0.0556719154,
0.1655845344,
-0.531442225,
0.6627114415,
-0.2126862705,
-0.0770979449,
-0.247469604,
0.3611485958,
0.1266456693,
0.3102941811,
0.4079114199,
-0.642111659,
-0.5458496213,
0.7428495884,
-0.6365587115,
-0.1440943778,
0.0558928922,
0.0283521768,
0.4570582509,
0.2490824163,
-0.3452640176,
0.3411141038,
0.659591794,
-0.1383622885,
0.5514881611,
-0.6795173883,
0.1787306368,
-1.1421102285,
0.2035165578,
-0.1965393573,
-0.4433858693,
-0.5428279042,
0.1433817297,
0.5202260613,
-0.2298674285,
-0.4621064663,
0.5634641647,
-0.5783655643,
-0.3782264888,
-0.3917636871,
0.0685465187,
-0.273794055,
0.4349886477,
-0.0529836342,
0.9072872996,
0.5097011924,
-0.4474416673,
0.437017411,
0.0640672743,
-0.317333281,
0.235929355,
-0.5021796227,
0.1894006431,
-0.1254288554,
0.1521165073,
-0.5943408012,
-0.1834692806,
0.0418699645,
-0.4936816394,
0.1607212573,
-0.1018021405,
-1.0210632086,
-0.1428774893,
-0.0903847367,
0.5925853848,
0.2388534844,
-0.9164553881,
0.4339067042,
0.3775514066,
-0.2576890886,
-0.6695523262,
-1.0062232018,
0.6669463515,
0.0404216833,
-0.5426635146,
0.297608763,
-0.0451840125,
-0.0109942993,
0.0493687131,
0.0391157195,
-0.2079490572,
0.0440983474,
-0.0824628174,
0.1137135401,
-0.0961079299,
0.132638514,
0.2749000788,
-0.1565524489,
-0.005804956,
-0.5420807004,
0.5143625736,
-0.3307116926,
-0.2763019204,
-0.1515277773,
0.5255297422,
0.7334135175,
-0.3056266308,
0.609269917,
0.7853766084,
-0.404109329,
-0.0010419621,
-0.3814483881,
-0.021315068,
-0.3521611989,
0.3348463178,
-0.325827688,
-0.5140411854,
0.6111680269,
0.1360702664,
0.0529612899,
0.3000462651,
0.5074055791,
0.2813238502,
1.5354822874,
0.4439538121,
-0.2102449089,
0.037578322,
-0.1331070364,
0.22527574,
-0.7726786137,
-0.1465566456,
-0.5213888884,
-0.2881925106,
-0.6966284513,
-0.5071469545,
0.4303299785,
-0.2916887105,
0.1299468875,
0.4879485071,
-0.2693378031,
0.3350415826,
0.6057075262,
0.0175154023,
0.5837097168,
0.1793430448,
-0.4110679328,
-0.1315720379,
-0.9038928747,
-0.0872721151,
1.2432502508,
0.1874939799,
0.7518570423,
0.2640130818,
0.3356602788,
0.1413081586,
0.0902087167,
-0.8466647863,
0.2864246964,
-0.3596916497,
-0.5440847278,
0.1354916096,
-0.7249475121,
-1.0958712101,
0.4432338476,
-0.3758714497,
-0.3638706207,
0.2321265042,
0.0027773248,
-0.1562597156,
0.4919320345,
-0.6831796765,
0.7571333647,
-0.6089388728,
-0.5012232661,
-0.2659523785,
-0.5712306499,
0.2385564297,
-0.3533640802,
0.4123509526,
0.2620790303,
-0.3809742928,
0.4643760324,
-0.6077980399,
0.6340492964,
0.2056719214,
-0.0590596125,
-0.1904053241,
0.1365848184,
0.5073073506,
0.2452122718,
0.1833696812,
0.2432990223,
0.1431444585,
-0.560554862,
-0.6171191931,
0.9324873686,
-0.6136143208,
-0.1681758612,
-0.5547631979,
-1.1156022549,
-0.469045043,
0.2881241441,
0.0347786173,
0.62152946,
0.0427144207,
0.4101281166,
0.4778465629,
-0.3804053664,
0.2921586633,
0.3602294624,
-0.3537817895,
-0.6946545839,
1.0968620777,
-0.0230904706,
0.2465363741,
0.3298634291,
0.3939404786,
-0.6322396398,
-0.4921757579,
-0.9847752452,
0.2847562134,
-0.4929607809,
-0.1496693939,
-0.8823003173,
0.1790675372,
-0.7172268033,
-0.031313166,
-0.6436616778,
-0.6322239637,
-0.1636212766,
0.1147892848,
0.1378174573,
0.6000032425,
-0.3579485118,
0.1413376629,
-0.7935056686,
0.3007827997,
0.2658442259,
-0.0124942837,
-0.0988643989,
-0.3411037028,
-0.3019255102,
0.4142768383,
-0.0270976312,
-0.8493745327,
0.8625816107,
-0.0960471109,
0.4138997197,
0.1302129775,
-0.1377098262,
0.6470940113,
-0.3358978331,
0.4074602723,
0.3324459791,
-0.7119537592,
0.1445451379,
-0.4027998149,
0.5899985433,
0.4221744835,
0.2548561096,
-0.809568584,
-0.2913027406,
-0.4571210146,
-0.8985767961,
0.6105350256,
0.1490968913,
0.1812088341,
-0.0130082862,
-0.0042142933,
0.104371585,
0.1443694681,
-0.5594403744,
-0.2386723906,
-0.3398727477,
-0.2001256347,
-0.318066597,
-0.0004766374,
0.0821280107,
-0.2954430878,
0.6567723155,
-0.3857695162,
-0.2119868547,
0.1448881477,
-0.4424867332,
0.1077497974,
0.3797034919,
0.4383507073,
0.5572806001,
-0.049917873,
0.2856130302,
0.346673578,
-0.4068340957,
-0.1323208958,
0.2460758388,
-0.1381081492,
0.0554603077,
0.029209068,
0.6146788597,
0.6053056717,
-0.7516285777,
0.3190018535,
-0.1092363298,
-0.2409046292,
0.1115622893,
-0.5196957588,
0.2163953334,
0.0208076201,
0.048645705,
0.1830238253,
0.2785213292,
-0.7285826206,
-0.0971465111,
0.4239053726,
-0.3063744307,
-0.4070117474,
0.6845695972,
0.1048533618,
-0.0672353879,
0.5659739971,
-0.2529817224,
-0.570106566,
0.4391054511,
0.7126747966,
0.6756032705,
0.0417291336,
0.2792576849,
0.4510029852,
0.5180498958,
-0.1324205995,
-0.0622990951,
-0.3568490446,
-0.5576871634,
-0.4263067842,
-0.5359356999,
-0.4604979455,
-0.2011081874,
-0.5557695627,
0.0696448311,
-0.1037515551,
0.067411162,
-0.0216550939,
0.0286409035,
-0.5085790753,
-0.0877163932,
0.0749768317,
0.9228595495,
-0.7729846239,
1.0196895599,
0.9341084957,
-0.3854139149,
-0.5407313108,
-0.3685773313,
-0.0142711084,
-0.7095721364,
0.5201918483,
-0.0819680467,
-0.1667521745,
0.2245996296,
0.0222095288,
-0.7531875968,
0.7685002685,
0.5662147403,
-0.3127097487,
0.044991225,
0.7050324678,
0.621363759,
-0.03666218,
0.1947908551,
0.5387555361,
0.5941497684,
-0.0630334169,
-1.0085998774,
-0.2627081871,
-0.3435098529,
0.0100036589,
0.2176282406,
-0.1741046757,
0.6997532248,
-0.1150337607,
-0.2543482482,
0.1182423458,
0.5403256416,
-0.1164516658,
0.2331406772,
0.6049793363,
0.900505662,
0.6656662822,
0.0346514061,
1.247199297,
-0.2374663502,
0.2639069557,
1.0309149027,
-0.0461309329,
0.5355674028,
0.484644264,
-0.0302727688,
0.0887214318,
0.535818994,
0.4768502712,
0.3453264534,
-0.0666272491,
-0.3499160707,
-0.3727918863,
-0.3814486265,
-0.4710099101,
0.4181815088,
0.2207027674,
-0.1406117976,
-0.5151478648,
0.1087076664,
0.212629348,
0.1767230183,
-0.1856511682,
0.6336987019,
-0.0370322503,
-0.7617492676,
0.6373580098,
0.0769629329,
0.6899969578,
-0.5482810736,
0.2741436362,
-0.597034514,
0.308464855,
-0.1167430878,
-0.6590738297,
0.4955588281,
0.2197305411,
-0.0997395143,
-0.3582000732,
0.5312356353,
-0.5477201343,
-0.6862812638,
0.5349475741,
0.6802169085,
0.2967050076,
-0.3259817958,
-0.722591877,
-0.0695832297,
-0.1382319182,
0.1425557137,
0.5713640451,
0.3196241558,
-0.1497160345,
0.5694355369,
0.9975417256,
0.4348598421,
0.4113511741,
0.2399330884,
0.83886379,
-0.4555469751,
-0.4970344007,
-0.3961306512,
0.1691394448,
-0.0569305122,
-0.3406433761,
0.7984384298,
0.8491843343,
0.9671401381,
-0.0341115929,
0.4952078462,
0.168509081,
0.3922231793,
-0.3576070964,
0.6850814223,
-0.9327546358,
-0.0407260247,
0.0328613594,
-0.939740479,
-0.5380948186,
0.0716216862,
-0.0073408638,
-0.2531795204,
0.8998066187,
1.0809209347,
-0.4098902047,
0.0868539736,
0.5060852766,
0.0141401663,
0.0798843205,
0.4539170265,
0.7192795873,
-0.5007994175,
0.7874355912,
-0.7680709362,
-0.2451357692,
0.0455084406,
-0.7041172981,
-0.6350038648,
-0.5899509192,
-0.117145434,
-0.1687569767,
0.1491799504,
0.8508232832,
0.6108554006,
-0.6711619496,
-0.3428820372,
-0.3038259447,
0.1637327522,
-0.3359211087,
-0.0623326451,
0.0523457266,
-0.7503698468,
-1.1008085012,
0.7782503366,
0.2689118087,
-0.2133500427,
-0.186066702,
-0.1041319966,
-0.3358063698,
-0.2650963068,
0.6088398695,
0.4639666975,
-0.5606773496,
0.1493833959,
0.2508312166,
-0.1108268797,
-0.0169795454,
0.924167037,
-0.7357127666,
0.8383044004,
0.6268925667,
1.1134546995,
0.4366317689,
-0.1023381054,
0.5167000294,
-0.5043407679,
0.2086797506,
0.1578811258,
0.5675132275,
0.5205203295,
-0.082697615,
0.5228146315,
0.3721223772,
-0.3860682249,
-0.7705059052,
-0.0649835542,
-1.0627971888,
-0.2661729753,
1.2390338182,
0.0660593882,
-0.3955256641,
-0.2919177413,
-0.1938405782,
0.1842016727,
-0.2368922681,
0.5624035597,
0.3883856237,
0.3719234467,
0.0100956308,
-0.7837501764,
0.054363735,
0.7712855339,
-0.8390769958,
0.0510343052,
0.5556784868,
0.0628135428,
0.1868752688,
0.2420787513,
-0.3857944906,
0.3782525659,
-0.1096451059,
0.1983570755,
-0.1869682074,
-0.4831834733,
-0.4140644073,
-0.0301202871,
-0.0898105949,
-0.1369519383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15247v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15247v2 | Zero-Shot Composed Image Retrieval with Textual Inversion | 2023-03-27T14:31:25 | 2023-08-19T14:04:41 | Alberto Baldrati, Lorenzo Agnolucci, Marco Bertini, Alberto Del Bimbo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR | Composed Image Retrieval (CIR) aims to retrieve a target image based on a
query composed of a reference image and a relative caption that describes the
difference between the two images. The high effort and cost required for
labeling datasets for CIR hamper the widespread usage of existing methods, as
they rely on supervised learning. In this work, we propose a new task,
Zero-Shot CIR (ZS-CIR), that aims to address CIR without requiring a labeled
training dataset. Our approach, named zero-Shot composEd imAge Retrieval with
textuaL invErsion (SEARLE), maps the visual features of the reference image
into a pseudo-word token in CLIP token embedding space and integrates it with
the relative caption. To support research on ZS-CIR, we introduce an
open-domain benchmarking dataset named Composed Image Retrieval on Common
Objects in context (CIRCO), which is the first dataset for CIR containing
multiple ground truths for each query. The experiments show that SEARLE
exhibits better performance than the baselines on the two main datasets for CIR
tasks, FashionIQ and CIRR, and on the proposed CIRCO. The dataset, the code and
the model are publicly available at https://github.com/miccunifi/SEARLE. | [
-0.1263514459,
-0.5320773721,
0.7166777849,
-0.2698863745,
-0.7596259117,
0.1516352296,
-0.2383405119,
-0.2756229043,
0.0958172977,
0.7225036621,
-0.2204685658,
-0.7244893909,
-0.278413415,
-0.0794392601,
-0.4603605568,
0.9793651104,
-0.0441549793,
0.0447525233,
-0.5120810866,
-0.5718384981,
-0.3988578916,
-0.5895154476,
-0.1269889772,
-0.1166680604,
0.5816780329,
0.5588565469,
0.4169986248,
0.7044876814,
0.6150033474,
0.2373851091,
0.1841098964,
-0.016345812,
-0.5161838531,
0.2296739072,
-0.3998499811,
-0.4190896451,
-0.0090861553,
-0.2464724928,
0.3592257798,
0.2456879765,
0.0857237726,
0.3937353194,
-0.1917594373,
0.9118083715,
-1.3887724876,
-0.0112115974,
-0.5665369034,
-0.0518227704,
-0.4937767088,
-0.4373355806,
-0.2145858556,
-0.1585307866,
0.0037190395,
-0.7664718628,
0.600614965,
0.0018594407,
0.5715654492,
0.2528051436,
-0.4005196095,
-0.1624063253,
-0.6429288387,
0.8591355681,
-0.2739976048,
0.2896676064,
-0.0432514586,
0.6091729403,
0.3191413283,
-0.7921187282,
-0.7459900379,
0.0782572925,
-0.0723631531,
0.5208604336,
-0.2457796335,
-0.1226745099,
-0.0053718868,
0.4523833096,
-0.6635291576,
-0.3116419613,
-0.7113227844,
0.0052697808,
0.4998716116,
0.1900820732,
0.14217785,
-0.0182760395,
-0.77569139,
-0.3145907223,
-0.6698367,
-0.076160647,
-0.0542825386,
0.2805173397,
0.0052714674,
0.7458906174,
-0.5176758766,
0.8320800662,
0.0312082898,
0.144336611,
0.4124940038,
-0.0541043803,
-0.3065207005,
0.4291662872,
0.6866225004,
0.6232638359,
0.0189853292,
-0.3618555963,
-0.3402921557,
0.215496555,
0.0694681033,
-0.8719220161,
-0.0911821499,
0.1324941069,
-0.2544015646,
-0.1725131422,
0.3997614384,
-0.5718635917,
-0.0662980452,
-0.4708538353,
0.734870553,
-0.4560063481,
0.1162448153,
0.1204055399,
-0.4069411755,
0.6036601663,
0.1145008281,
-0.1262280047,
0.2656530738,
0.5433578491,
0.9322528243,
-0.1152918786,
0.0714495853,
-0.751506865,
0.3597528338,
-0.450248003,
0.9962397814,
-0.5889208317,
-0.4255954325,
-0.0536963493,
0.2055431604,
-0.0847367123,
-0.4674060345,
0.7245127559,
-0.637596488,
0.172020793,
-0.5156651139,
-0.4873250425,
-0.1858583838,
0.3022019863,
-0.64529562,
0.9395867586,
-0.0121159405,
-0.860691011,
0.0065951617,
-0.6445653439,
-0.2961080372,
0.3605539501,
-0.4717793763,
-0.2883584499,
0.1267845482,
0.2999728322,
0.2783208489,
-0.4331358671,
0.1275389642,
-0.2652161121,
-0.9841929674,
0.2461128682,
-0.0850286633,
0.5305129886,
0.2435234189,
-0.3876161277,
-0.2001668811,
-0.7392272949,
0.4451778531,
0.1686024666,
0.162960574,
-0.8357092142,
-0.1198833808,
0.1595771909,
0.1026171222,
0.1855925918,
-0.7915446758,
-0.0211350396,
-0.0821484253,
0.0406042524,
0.2415026426,
0.2381783724,
0.5057764649,
-0.2942739427,
0.4923003614,
0.0515010878,
-0.1654860377,
-0.4239370227,
0.128894791,
-0.6365566254,
-0.6402769685,
0.2631727159,
0.5698032379,
-1.1797925234,
0.2638737261,
-0.4279361665,
-0.5097395778,
-0.5940554738,
-0.069406867,
0.8650771976,
0.7269231677,
0.613712132,
-0.4284477234,
-0.3277491629,
-0.9917542338,
-0.1314751655,
0.0485665761,
-0.3544875085,
0.3997191489,
0.3329131603,
0.3251729906,
1.0511147976,
-0.9310154915,
-0.6311655045,
-0.0002691896,
0.418761611,
0.0686616451,
0.3975595236,
0.6739857197,
-0.775296092,
-0.6344385147,
-0.0363589041,
-0.7848188281,
-0.2293286175,
-0.0942155421,
-0.3606737256,
0.0110116722,
0.4508728087,
-0.387015909,
0.5723381639,
0.0652961358,
0.0332909338,
0.3615250885,
-0.0503748283,
0.3300152421,
-0.8542411923,
0.5179201365,
0.0443076007,
-0.1314524859,
-0.6708562374,
0.2298553735,
0.3113121688,
0.0333460681,
-0.6226787567,
0.3836189508,
-0.632687211,
-0.1470273733,
-0.3627381921,
0.16959095,
0.3392612338,
0.508765161,
0.4140761495,
0.9792906642,
0.5745373368,
-0.3637953997,
0.0578313731,
0.1967508197,
-0.4628913701,
1.0251820087,
-1.0037959814,
0.6676187515,
-0.7192543149,
0.1110429987,
-0.7773271799,
0.0774735138,
0.3506959081,
-0.1685149968,
0.185041815,
-0.0656364709,
-0.3765756488,
-0.0825897381,
-0.5527514815,
0.6444238424,
0.0937640518,
-0.4590749145,
0.0807395652,
-0.0023490295,
0.1977441609,
-0.5655579567,
-0.6066023707,
-0.0238239095,
-0.1986247599,
0.0339640677,
0.8621855974,
-0.1770994514,
-0.0166017748,
0.0945323706,
-0.1261043549,
-0.3275818527,
-0.4539265931,
0.1969230324,
0.4931049049,
-0.3371738493,
0.0434049964,
-0.038339369,
-0.0229617395,
-0.2845636606,
-0.0542752221,
0.2347590327,
-0.2137220204,
-0.3704887927,
-0.1071288511,
0.2926121056,
0.5006116629,
-0.4113831222,
0.4794445336,
0.3697190583,
-0.0576683432,
0.0949689224,
-0.4377200902,
0.2979257703,
-0.4338968396,
-0.0427938364,
-0.3950147033,
-0.7154777646,
0.3109727204,
0.24645634,
-0.2759046555,
0.2889274061,
0.1553112566,
-0.2915039062,
0.4468984306,
0.4550763071,
-0.0555755422,
0.3538337648,
-0.5334163308,
0.0094862282,
-0.9717124701,
-0.3776435554,
-0.5384517908,
-0.3586497307,
-0.318495363,
-0.5722213984,
0.6546539664,
0.0815864354,
-0.4300818741,
0.4831473231,
-0.7032818794,
0.8729975224,
0.7129376531,
0.6682016253,
0.2939422131,
0.0367345661,
-0.1150853708,
-0.1048557982,
-0.4745051265,
-0.1877976209,
0.9240350127,
-0.4846271574,
0.4656685889,
0.0098465132,
0.6542745233,
0.3062953949,
0.185220331,
-0.8091577291,
0.5590792298,
-0.2461051494,
-0.6086532474,
-0.1197228432,
-0.1172721982,
-0.7604168057,
0.406368196,
-0.0286547579,
-0.3361891806,
0.5224099159,
-0.2609340847,
-0.3330190778,
0.0437977165,
-0.3578045368,
0.5407112241,
-0.4471942484,
-0.725476563,
0.1758777648,
-0.9680057764,
0.3316121995,
-0.1987333298,
0.1050500423,
-0.0656342879,
-0.1761374772,
0.4040563107,
-0.3632864952,
0.5984715223,
-0.3483736217,
0.3520512879,
0.5668231249,
-0.0207621548,
0.039510861,
-0.5118470192,
-0.2431492358,
0.2229504585,
0.301520437,
-0.3717828393,
-0.6453866959,
0.3910649717,
-0.4547990859,
-0.2161114514,
-0.5254715085,
-0.1524402052,
0.1427634805,
0.2954761684,
0.4386788905,
0.554510951,
-0.4185782671,
0.6412889957,
0.3366287947,
-0.2202600241,
0.5225892067,
0.6905477047,
0.2060534358,
-0.7943087816,
0.8063150048,
0.1819800735,
-0.0228503551,
0.6634159684,
-0.0752546489,
-0.2772664428,
-0.2076502144,
-0.5203698874,
0.0193431322,
-0.49827227,
-0.7965784073,
-0.2265471071,
-0.1787776053,
0.0143698845,
-0.3538168967,
-0.3971475959,
-0.3812222481,
-0.4028476775,
0.1243074685,
0.2806246281,
0.0686067641,
0.2234185636,
0.4486384094,
-0.8341190815,
0.4517125785,
-0.1129126847,
0.4211939275,
-0.1456409842,
-0.4532985687,
-0.1774809211,
0.005021587,
-0.3420189023,
-0.6963387728,
0.3825232387,
0.488609761,
0.5320093036,
0.6688420177,
0.7606394887,
1.083266139,
-0.4999553561,
0.623763442,
0.3376879692,
-0.9095103741,
0.4906891286,
-0.3498420417,
0.4547384083,
0.9089944363,
0.4298933446,
-0.3534011245,
-0.1031765044,
-0.3551455736,
-0.7917436957,
0.3857610226,
0.3467082679,
0.2425192595,
-0.1286796927,
0.3854224086,
0.089773275,
0.297428757,
-0.4356085658,
-0.1106800437,
-0.3720127046,
-0.1452670097,
0.0031746479,
-0.191434294,
-0.0898570046,
-0.2493277788,
0.3815214336,
-0.2970884144,
0.3989114761,
0.7416863441,
-0.3289818168,
-0.186379537,
0.3246383369,
0.2684158683,
0.2473215759,
-0.2972100079,
0.1960734874,
-0.2156238705,
-0.0794595182,
0.1382411867,
-0.0463245027,
-0.4821138084,
0.2230676264,
0.3168322444,
0.6440319419,
0.512850821,
-0.7397168875,
0.8674002886,
0.3025664091,
-0.4419428408,
-0.4089951813,
-0.0360492989,
-0.4162335396,
0.3002122045,
0.6316833496,
-0.2532922029,
0.4749001563,
-0.4297673404,
0.3274720311,
0.4838713109,
-0.5096773505,
-0.3199664354,
0.8159950972,
-0.3149150014,
0.1538155675,
0.5731089711,
0.0272734463,
-0.3958338797,
0.5479751229,
0.5282012224,
0.8409080505,
0.0599059388,
0.4810053706,
0.5360996127,
0.0266408119,
-0.0335764028,
0.3213217854,
-0.4134643078,
-0.62065804,
-0.096201323,
-0.3138400316,
-0.5048143864,
-0.0736593008,
-1.0584155321,
0.396961242,
-0.3227977455,
0.0730025545,
-0.0330451578,
-0.1566966772,
-0.6383861303,
0.359018296,
0.0199507829,
0.6623212695,
-0.7440576553,
0.7899699807,
0.6170962453,
-0.7548078895,
-0.2592406571,
0.0425637774,
-0.1395668685,
-0.4944299459,
0.4506237805,
0.3004916012,
-0.3758006096,
-0.0041776616,
-0.9189673662,
-0.70772475,
1.3787022829,
0.4162289798,
-0.5088086724,
0.4153501987,
0.133973226,
0.6127954125,
-0.4176319242,
0.307071507,
0.2235397398,
0.1160496995,
0.7880125046,
-0.3455525935,
0.0672286153,
-0.2788211405,
0.0659698099,
0.0627142116,
-0.8349887729,
0.681109786,
-0.0749879852,
-0.4484333396,
0.371386975,
0.5747018456,
0.3723416328,
0.9434633255,
0.4356546104,
0.4160886407,
0.418256104,
0.1330095232,
0.7654010057,
-0.2451613545,
0.2686048448,
1.4548209906,
-0.6776387691,
1.0689694881,
0.5689707994,
0.125358507,
0.5886321664,
0.1715538949,
-0.1298719645,
1.0700910091,
-0.0228973087,
-0.6086623669,
-0.0405822061,
-0.2440144271,
-0.2471360117,
0.6394507289,
0.0781345591,
-0.3988560736,
-0.3718420863,
-0.1685371548,
-0.2297868431,
0.2455572337,
-0.1957295686,
0.7798900604,
-0.1179398373,
-0.3678692579,
0.6586494446,
-0.030562304,
0.4162339568,
-0.2560120821,
-0.0905089006,
-0.3203468621,
0.0419347472,
-0.0447193496,
-0.6013131738,
0.382147938,
0.0602794513,
-0.0268704034,
0.0115399035,
0.8957561851,
-0.4093553722,
-0.7100429535,
0.082847409,
0.5143506527,
0.3314260244,
-0.332241714,
-0.3269425631,
-0.0165119395,
-0.2215575874,
-0.0500029586,
0.1509612501,
0.5140249729,
-0.2402662337,
0.2652542591,
0.5857254863,
-0.2074306309,
-0.1920528263,
-0.1589146405,
1.0246520042,
-0.8719517589,
-0.0988164097,
-0.6148047447,
0.5482296348,
-0.1683909893,
0.077830404,
0.3806474507,
1.0334905386,
0.7018035054,
-0.2847132385,
0.9146994352,
-0.074900344,
0.4392280877,
-0.4725423157,
0.5491745472,
-0.6816985011,
0.0089688934,
-0.4507988095,
-0.9073013067,
-0.6433392167,
0.4032724798,
-0.24529773,
-0.3278444111,
0.5715905428,
0.9395225048,
-0.3008121252,
-0.1712144613,
0.4278153479,
-0.310293138,
-0.1560384184,
0.3522043824,
0.5849301815,
-0.6948323846,
0.5512563586,
-0.4658448398,
0.0148189496,
-0.0078172097,
-0.9663576484,
-0.5825486183,
-0.5158569217,
-0.4385475516,
0.170373261,
0.284178406,
0.583775878,
0.4126525223,
-0.7481636405,
0.040760722,
-0.0463994034,
-0.2293583453,
-0.1649974287,
-0.2162985504,
0.4603303671,
-0.0080751432,
-0.716173172,
0.3783504963,
0.2788136899,
-0.0875255093,
0.2111435235,
0.1296872795,
-0.0310804565,
-0.0094613917,
0.5517469645,
0.3890962005,
-0.4318950772,
-0.2471845597,
0.2426947653,
-0.0508469939,
0.2596809268,
0.9869684577,
-0.9756238461,
0.4837837219,
0.3765097857,
0.4512263834,
0.8926857114,
0.3811759949,
0.2158010453,
-0.9397803545,
0.2286153734,
-0.012627597,
0.0661118031,
0.4982195795,
-0.2868714929,
0.705768168,
0.2725797296,
-0.240306735,
-0.5200786591,
-0.3128913641,
-1.2301622629,
-0.3174549341,
0.7387656569,
-0.1157431602,
-0.3164094687,
0.2566592097,
-0.2303842157,
0.3462891281,
-0.2114731222,
0.7116633058,
0.2919308841,
0.1006106883,
-0.4813547134,
-0.4512649179,
-0.2751075327,
0.0902350545,
-0.3795274496,
-0.2248297483,
0.8083335161,
0.3211730421,
-0.0758140534,
0.8342309594,
-0.3404830992,
0.1173785552,
-0.3314232528,
0.38381356,
-0.1881135851,
-0.2932047546,
-0.2078636289,
0.2856474817,
-0.4019446969,
-0.8353350759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.15230v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.15230v2 | Troika: Multi-Path Cross-Modal Traction for Compositional Zero-Shot Learning | 2023-03-27T14:10:26 | 2024-03-26T03:07:56 | Siteng Huang, Biao Gong, Yutong Feng, Min Zhang, Yiliang Lv, Donglin Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent compositional zero-shot learning (CZSL) methods adapt pre-trained
vision-language models (VLMs) by constructing trainable prompts only for
composed state-object pairs. Relying on learning the joint representation of
seen compositions, these methods ignore the explicit modeling of the state and
object, thus limiting the exploitation of pre-trained knowledge and
generalization to unseen compositions. With a particular focus on the
universality of the solution, in this work, we propose a novel paradigm for
CZSL models that establishes three identification branches (i.e., Multi-Path)
to jointly model the state, object, and composition. The presented Troika is
our implementation that aligns the branch-specific prompt representations with
decomposed visual features. To calibrate the bias between semantically similar
multi-modal representations, we further devise a Cross-Modal Traction module
into Troika that shifts the prompt representation towards the current visual
content. We conduct extensive experiments on three popular benchmarks, where
our method significantly outperforms existing methods in both closed-world and
open-world settings. The code will be available at
https://github.com/bighuang624/Troika. | [
0.046648819,
-0.5724850297,
0.7794472575,
0.2612238526,
-0.6905903816,
0.4220191836,
-0.2574400902,
-0.5552542806,
0.2027009279,
0.2683495283,
-0.8642144799,
-0.8680629134,
-0.2248847783,
-0.2593585253,
-0.2506335378,
0.8565706015,
-0.2321036607,
0.1171888262,
-0.1403996944,
-0.4486415684,
-0.6759423614,
-0.1641428024,
0.0201086253,
-0.1604505926,
0.7889163494,
0.4414557219,
0.2701459527,
0.3863330185,
0.1003979072,
0.1843952984,
0.253239125,
-0.04893668,
-0.1241187751,
0.5471229553,
-0.0659355521,
-0.4312240779,
0.130224973,
-0.0580588728,
0.7480133176,
0.4010065794,
-0.0541030355,
0.1260064244,
-0.1114425883,
0.2080643922,
-1.0690011978,
-0.0733325183,
-0.5954616666,
0.3877700269,
-0.2147768885,
-0.3662878275,
-0.5900921226,
0.0019636855,
0.2841408849,
-0.9403646588,
0.1822685152,
-0.2375149131,
0.5705044866,
0.0567253232,
-0.5390037894,
-0.1682789773,
-0.9060690403,
1.0110651255,
-0.264975816,
0.5350747108,
-0.3584119081,
0.5801216364,
0.2639500499,
-0.4211119413,
-0.2826506793,
-0.4609321356,
0.1863593012,
0.4108504057,
0.2644370496,
0.0026030326,
0.0430328213,
-0.0857916176,
-0.6875780225,
-0.151753664,
-0.468508482,
-0.4524475634,
0.2987733781,
0.4348000288,
0.4617168605,
0.1036271155,
-0.8654323816,
-0.4016564786,
-0.6604486108,
0.441470474,
0.0839809254,
0.4190560579,
-0.4743259251,
0.4844322503,
-0.1175133511,
1.1746031046,
-0.0865308419,
-0.2344475091,
0.3347209096,
-0.1838261038,
-0.1187739372,
0.1984757185,
0.986338377,
0.2366960645,
-0.2319132388,
-0.495413512,
0.0591092408,
0.2797822058,
0.2717092931,
-0.5076289773,
0.1396799088,
-0.1066299677,
0.1260097474,
-0.3837765455,
0.0788016915,
-0.6452912688,
-0.1200893149,
-0.4025153816,
0.6749258637,
-0.4576987922,
-0.1852682382,
-0.0290074851,
-0.115882732,
0.433295399,
0.4863501191,
-0.5459496975,
-0.1113104671,
0.4883719087,
1.1061710119,
-0.1291568577,
-0.6430948377,
-0.5919103622,
0.4776297808,
-0.6110672951,
0.7673513889,
-0.7024083734,
-0.2927548587,
0.0805596113,
0.0342604369,
0.1175993234,
-0.0157179758,
0.3225139976,
-0.3096170127,
0.3283797204,
-0.1740949005,
0.0219327994,
-0.205622822,
0.486392498,
-0.5321779847,
0.7799676657,
0.1701235026,
-0.4815200567,
0.5360070467,
-0.502438724,
-0.4568568468,
-0.0425154641,
-0.2883448899,
-0.2066184878,
0.1499528289,
-0.1692538857,
0.2112439871,
-0.096756354,
0.1977012008,
-0.4541248083,
-0.4891929924,
-0.016869789,
-0.1921259761,
0.7406191826,
-0.0609590858,
-0.3106098473,
0.5034317374,
-0.8386223912,
0.0095913168,
-0.1034835726,
-0.0786404014,
-0.6277681589,
-0.3989447057,
-0.0367247127,
0.6269971132,
0.0513181165,
-0.7142000198,
0.1063111648,
-0.4256823957,
0.1469320953,
0.7723894119,
0.0734293535,
0.6284537911,
-0.2079956234,
0.6910743713,
0.6236572266,
0.2222267538,
-0.3418012857,
-0.3258858621,
-0.6021872163,
-0.2308364064,
0.1708261669,
0.2766195834,
-1.0633829832,
0.1467193961,
-0.1968932301,
-0.6210458279,
-0.3638636768,
-0.0814269185,
0.4431911409,
0.6901125312,
0.4596874714,
-0.5304951072,
-0.3392635286,
-0.6445223689,
-0.0947563574,
0.2128146142,
-0.1069084778,
0.0612742081,
0.1282416284,
0.312897861,
0.9233449697,
-0.4159042239,
-0.4464682639,
-0.0980933383,
0.2282317281,
-0.1617781073,
0.4311675429,
0.661586225,
-0.4572507739,
-0.8232209086,
-0.1458499432,
-0.6410294175,
0.2197602987,
-0.2380127758,
-0.3133812845,
0.0562586114,
0.0157267544,
-0.7624475956,
0.2704660296,
0.5319055915,
-0.4644694626,
0.4610105455,
-0.1315236092,
0.0072447592,
-1.1138241291,
0.1824518144,
0.1599552184,
-0.309258014,
-0.6920131445,
0.2312123179,
-0.0680011809,
-0.2511526644,
-0.9104243517,
0.5466785431,
-0.4191708863,
-0.1752591133,
0.0142010087,
0.2381856889,
0.2378184795,
0.8511238694,
0.2672198117,
0.5162685513,
1.0422142744,
-0.625387609,
0.3751640022,
0.060289938,
-0.2043260634,
0.7499718666,
-0.5555024743,
0.2021100372,
-0.1983266026,
0.4259873331,
-0.6517718434,
0.0747601688,
0.8304620385,
-0.2815974355,
0.0896319821,
-0.1924549192,
-0.1098598391,
0.028816605,
-0.427610904,
0.6579694748,
0.3285527229,
-0.2211915553,
0.9490696192,
-0.0759709179,
0.4525028765,
-0.9783953428,
-0.6331760287,
-0.1168822125,
-0.1038679481,
-0.3344233036,
0.3609412611,
-0.3780755103,
0.2332915664,
-0.0628742501,
-0.2316355556,
-0.1156967729,
-0.0309010744,
0.412191391,
0.3405031562,
-0.1993362457,
0.1275078803,
-0.0085563362,
-0.0142671699,
-0.1850335002,
-0.4157960415,
0.6922599077,
0.024234144,
-0.3913765252,
-0.1963902712,
0.4051753283,
0.7073504329,
-0.5526762605,
0.5866186023,
0.7571667433,
-0.0031822303,
-0.2302181125,
-0.010565972,
0.018860653,
-0.4209451675,
0.0251902211,
-0.4967338443,
-0.8049498796,
0.5765421987,
0.1615254432,
0.0362658128,
0.1974230707,
0.4800165594,
-0.0057596136,
0.7177767754,
0.6184819341,
0.1881862134,
0.5361889005,
-0.522224009,
0.0949949175,
-0.8604061604,
-0.5906831622,
-0.2819426656,
-0.3771078885,
-0.3782843649,
-0.4634196758,
0.4076279998,
-0.1293653846,
-0.1934376061,
0.3117932975,
-0.4396811128,
0.4655389786,
0.6674302816,
0.5261009932,
0.3145317435,
-0.0411900096,
-0.5577383637,
0.0706378147,
-0.5813967586,
0.1150849909,
1.013831377,
-0.0746021122,
0.4917663932,
0.0431061201,
0.7461737394,
0.2174453884,
0.0895440057,
-0.9665060639,
0.6687133312,
-0.0026706262,
-0.6256023645,
-0.1945076436,
-0.3150306344,
-0.7328924537,
0.4397471547,
-0.4224228263,
-0.605959177,
0.2185076773,
0.2338974625,
-0.4416665435,
0.3490339518,
-0.3363621831,
1.0143746138,
-0.1832964867,
-0.6523856521,
-0.1762059033,
-0.963032186,
0.522397995,
0.0798860118,
-0.0944579914,
-0.0913876444,
-0.1214722991,
0.4454361796,
-0.148508504,
0.97929883,
-0.4434818029,
-0.1177386791,
0.5737707615,
0.257959187,
0.2653630674,
-0.0970073864,
0.4873728454,
0.1293465346,
0.1012967974,
-0.4607811868,
-0.6703794599,
0.6416606307,
-0.663980782,
-0.2629775703,
-0.6218130589,
-0.5270982981,
-0.3751942813,
0.2898324728,
0.1697445959,
0.8028042912,
-0.2842383385,
-0.0006231914,
0.3677228987,
-0.0344771333,
0.6021825671,
0.6583398581,
-0.0178529676,
-0.3689704835,
1.1222326756,
-0.1471866369,
0.2028724551,
0.4753246307,
0.1778173447,
-0.1797759235,
-0.2314562201,
-0.5779851079,
0.0852890834,
-0.6614766121,
-0.2778833807,
-0.4466945827,
0.0279405061,
-0.0747578442,
-0.0961237848,
-0.3613194823,
-0.4603112638,
-0.44028157,
0.0260801204,
0.0136727951,
0.6586623788,
-0.123927094,
0.4001324773,
-0.9534631371,
0.2498019487,
0.3667829037,
0.4605140686,
0.0982428491,
-0.2129363716,
-0.3452858031,
0.18529661,
-0.4946133196,
-0.910972178,
0.0720808059,
0.1175287738,
0.3873484135,
0.3296345174,
0.0950780585,
0.6419978738,
-0.4823046029,
0.9106958508,
0.7153971791,
-0.956348598,
0.4466970265,
-0.4132353961,
0.4620040357,
0.6248317361,
0.4376320243,
-0.6527885795,
-0.4598711133,
-0.491332233,
-0.5315790176,
0.7644667029,
-0.2054359466,
0.1729905009,
0.4318167269,
-0.0184431281,
0.2316345572,
0.2304874659,
-1.0613224506,
-0.0204172079,
-0.5375797153,
-0.4913830757,
0.0331468694,
-0.0079093706,
-0.3990871012,
-0.0818704218,
0.4525880218,
-0.3598435521,
0.0782828853,
0.2297139615,
-0.4433811009,
-0.3942563236,
0.3001621664,
1.1803780794,
0.7378596067,
-0.0193474386,
0.1861691773,
-0.2350800186,
-0.2892674208,
0.7668260932,
-0.4191752672,
-0.6408265829,
0.1507836282,
0.5284819007,
0.9813760519,
0.3592910767,
-0.4855583906,
0.7149478793,
0.0101980306,
-0.3087034225,
-0.1030821279,
0.176853314,
-0.3476946652,
0.2714770138,
0.2786853611,
0.4293096066,
-0.0020376679,
-0.6139509082,
0.0979414508,
0.4684641957,
-0.9297727346,
-0.8901727796,
0.3315904438,
0.1105288044,
-0.1408076286,
0.1719516218,
-0.0583892055,
-0.5015842319,
0.2778270841,
0.3272573054,
1.0509287119,
-0.3683046103,
0.7617834806,
0.3987872601,
0.1556965113,
0.1568015665,
0.1004090011,
-0.4309940338,
-0.6656783819,
-0.5150130987,
-0.3514577746,
-0.3600659966,
-0.1212485358,
-0.4414223135,
0.3392585218,
-0.5698081851,
0.1148439273,
-0.4728107452,
-0.3573465943,
-0.5741666555,
0.1375154853,
0.111310944,
0.6730235219,
-1.3562591076,
0.8214116693,
0.7258822322,
-0.5559691191,
-0.7346063852,
0.2711304128,
-0.2253408283,
-0.6305136085,
0.4883314669,
0.1714303493,
-0.3199003041,
-0.180397138,
-0.5742886662,
-0.6754487157,
1.2303490639,
0.4091174304,
-0.3679294586,
-0.1521236598,
0.302811414,
0.4870634377,
-0.5675470829,
0.337843895,
-0.0116574792,
0.273889631,
0.5231848359,
-0.5664002299,
0.0588047691,
0.1959519833,
-0.0170711353,
0.0725407973,
-1.0354565382,
0.6391196251,
-0.0037990033,
-0.2330388278,
-0.078854613,
0.4550030231,
0.4489626288,
0.3767028153,
0.5997737646,
0.6346336603,
0.1763509512,
0.0977630615,
0.5364202261,
-0.2670299411,
0.1802696735,
1.3029347658,
-0.372435838,
0.4472318292,
0.7174466252,
0.2646298707,
0.9385496378,
0.4795611799,
0.243378073,
1.1877394915,
-0.0590044409,
-0.5617223382,
-0.4747754931,
-0.3632721007,
-0.243916586,
0.656814158,
-0.0075613949,
-0.0510434844,
-0.5621693134,
0.2275190949,
-0.3837309182,
-0.235418722,
-0.1218889505,
0.6738500595,
-0.0020130393,
-0.6559630632,
0.4452881515,
-0.2291103005,
0.3078269064,
-0.8909834027,
-0.2932525873,
0.0202362966,
-0.1224095151,
0.0435155407,
-0.7156564593,
0.154212147,
-0.3536884189,
0.0805704147,
0.0392445698,
0.5326964855,
-0.6563435793,
-0.4307037592,
0.3912397921,
0.3695203662,
-0.3861890137,
0.1800697148,
-0.5654201508,
0.1442428231,
-0.1662160754,
-0.0182002243,
0.2130100727,
0.4955913723,
-0.014510395,
0.5812473297,
0.4186168611,
-0.055009786,
0.2207940668,
0.0949032605,
0.9647254944,
-0.7136307359,
-0.6156597137,
-0.6791201234,
0.9909340739,
0.1960931271,
-0.1793522686,
0.3987538218,
0.4553766549,
0.7336379886,
-0.2977004647,
0.6137555242,
-0.009679989,
0.21421507,
-0.7900089025,
0.2523520589,
-0.7310029268,
-0.0820076391,
-0.2235286981,
-1.1206723452,
-0.3410382271,
0.2720563412,
0.0906023458,
-0.122175619,
0.7769615054,
0.5761600733,
-0.3840443492,
-0.3529322445,
0.5533986688,
0.0295253117,
0.2154199183,
0.8342509866,
1.0643274784,
-0.4622389376,
0.6152327657,
-0.5538262129,
0.0261318833,
0.0614574179,
-0.9039382935,
-0.8194742203,
-0.712050736,
-0.1791104227,
-0.0736208037,
0.1725156754,
0.8168856502,
0.8922137022,
-0.6673955321,
-0.2556016147,
-0.1737719625,
0.0089671873,
-0.1229524836,
-0.190805465,
-0.0053405543,
-0.2546108365,
-0.3070215583,
0.5210467577,
0.4565584958,
0.1134019569,
-0.6616276503,
-0.2182760984,
-0.1399001032,
-0.2674158812,
0.5326892734,
0.2257681042,
-0.7036800385,
-0.4513305128,
0.1821165085,
0.1066310257,
0.40725559,
1.0748050213,
-0.9678567648,
0.5975689888,
0.5628308058,
0.1746143103,
0.7649277449,
-0.1255570054,
0.6086233258,
-1.1539977789,
0.5692899227,
0.2363555282,
0.2213073969,
0.3440695405,
-0.0873168483,
0.2258840054,
0.4153105319,
-0.0112478388,
-0.5169172287,
0.4704242945,
-1.3585869074,
-0.1132694706,
0.6856366396,
-0.141386047,
-0.5160855055,
0.1536819488,
-0.0709810928,
0.2802729309,
-0.4295065701,
0.5395650268,
0.4488505423,
0.2747185528,
-0.5252647996,
-0.0829114392,
0.1982016116,
0.1789628118,
-0.5425312519,
-0.1482548714,
0.5838046074,
0.3109756112,
0.3459700346,
0.5377758741,
0.0920736864,
0.4077097774,
-0.3174351752,
0.1686387658,
-0.175475046,
-0.956625402,
-0.4928358197,
0.258708477,
-0.0093847821,
-0.2758854926
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.