id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03399v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03399v1 | Using LSTM and GRU With a New Dataset for Named Entity Recognition in the Arabic Language | 2023-04-06T22:14:02 | 2023-04-06T22:14:02 | Alaa Shaker, Alaa Aldarf, Igor Bessmertny | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named entity recognition (NER) is a natural language processing task (NLP),
which aims to identify named entities and classify them like person, location,
organization, etc. In the Arabic language, we can find a considerable size of
unstructured data, and it needs to different preprocessing tool than languages
like (English, Russian, German...). From this point, we can note the importance
of building a new structured dataset to solve the lack of structured data. In
this work, we use the BIOES format to tag the word, which allows us to handle
the nested name entity that consists of more than one sentence and define the
start and the end of the name. The dataset consists of more than thirty-six
thousand records. In addition, this work proposes long short term memory (LSTM)
units and Gated Recurrent Units (GRU) for building the named entity recognition
model in the Arabic language. The models give an approximately good result
(80%) because LSTM and GRU models can find the relationships between the words
of the sentence. Also, use a new library from Google, which is Trax and
platform Colab | [
-0.6562374234,
-0.8246112466,
0.4195720255,
-0.1378155947,
-0.4304387867,
0.2582286596,
-0.1872426122,
-0.7126866579,
0.2339452803,
0.4182180464,
-0.1319378316,
-0.8205736876,
-0.571624279,
0.3414564133,
-0.3435032666,
1.2933386564,
-0.2296538502,
-0.0058567333,
0.1262589097,
-0.4275061488,
-0.4611136317,
-0.5731781125,
-1.0630010366,
-0.2781599462,
0.599552989,
0.2312300503,
0.670963645,
0.5629341602,
0.4026897848,
0.2719350457,
-0.2102223784,
0.2415397167,
-0.084728241,
0.0121397581,
-0.2109152377,
0.077241011,
-0.3627650738,
-0.4717383981,
1.0589572191,
0.5059936047,
-0.0547052696,
0.2079269886,
-0.2067644447,
0.6700241566,
-0.3570632041,
0.256118834,
-0.3161166608,
0.0371855088,
-0.2716878653,
0.1779257059,
-0.0837953985,
-0.4911538064,
0.1466023624,
-0.1600797325,
0.1023060009,
-0.0477114208,
0.9909533262,
0.0231103469,
-0.513780117,
-0.4296289384,
-0.7402075529,
0.6589256525,
-0.7437731624,
0.7855837941,
0.1413036138,
0.2680422068,
-0.6592596173,
-0.6170873642,
-0.5286880732,
-0.1881105453,
-0.2585354745,
-0.2956761122,
-0.1541611701,
-0.017398186,
0.3001405895,
0.0832095593,
-0.4798997939,
0.0151680103,
-0.0529873669,
-0.2245150656,
0.5501568317,
-0.1313360631,
0.4915516973,
-0.0937085673,
-0.4318466187,
0.1713944077,
-0.6827815175,
0.0858548135,
0.1976536959,
0.3948173821,
-0.0199289173,
0.3583012223,
-0.2130474448,
0.6466525197,
-0.23268345,
-0.5013639927,
0.3597689271,
-0.0493718572,
-0.4110023677,
0.4817215502,
0.5587243438,
-0.0592495129,
0.450493753,
-0.3943531513,
-0.3724984825,
0.0686833858,
-0.009878967,
-1.0266802311,
-0.1000692993,
0.111357525,
-0.4332183301,
0.267154336,
0.0996717885,
-0.787258029,
-0.1137605086,
-0.2720713019,
0.2591602802,
-0.6345932484,
-0.0462804027,
0.0157386679,
0.314132452,
0.3672746122,
0.3344730437,
-0.4978197813,
0.5705163479,
0.3205619454,
0.7945643663,
-0.048717659,
0.0349084064,
-0.6164044142,
0.3299937546,
0.0574614741,
0.666456461,
-0.4870667756,
-0.5413472056,
0.004597025,
0.0773901045,
-0.0688841268,
-0.4832815528,
0.723954916,
-0.8489623666,
0.0130482102,
-0.0321739465,
-0.6889295578,
-0.6721113324,
0.198343128,
-1.0224183798,
0.9380902648,
0.1081292331,
-0.7107586861,
0.1616276056,
-0.7168737054,
-0.5960559845,
0.5101445317,
-0.542520225,
-0.7202135921,
0.097771436,
0.3875955045,
0.428365618,
-0.0975344107,
0.4043825269,
0.2869529724,
-0.1222229898,
0.2426039279,
0.0067030494,
0.2401029468,
0.1879267544,
-0.1427825242,
-0.0908549204,
-0.8640090823,
0.1863342524,
0.07949543,
-0.5551847816,
-0.40660429,
0.1508990675,
0.2586684227,
0.0869480595,
0.2767448127,
-0.6377433538,
0.2312341332,
-0.382481873,
0.2250833213,
0.3395785391,
0.1900014132,
0.3043957353,
-0.1740935743,
0.4972421229,
0.129337132,
-0.5164145231,
0.0641013235,
-0.3512237072,
-0.642219305,
-0.3205119073,
0.5895401835,
0.4130805731,
-0.5837235451,
0.1497740448,
-0.391669333,
-0.3891572654,
-0.3210838437,
0.0454244874,
0.2229762673,
0.5274276733,
0.5278047919,
-0.3145552874,
-0.9036633372,
-1.016420722,
-0.1419407129,
0.0305876527,
0.2340446115,
0.512303412,
0.7460924387,
-0.6997050643,
1.1125347614,
-0.3592795134,
-0.5210716128,
-0.4460994601,
0.2160642743,
0.5048783422,
0.4197489917,
0.5378038883,
-0.7966698408,
-0.3069245517,
0.2383506298,
-0.4869510829,
0.046368055,
0.074507013,
-0.0292968787,
0.4700404406,
0.3706942797,
-0.6963477135,
0.6016290784,
0.1376221627,
-0.3419303894,
0.4635784626,
0.0574251972,
-0.0042445776,
-1.2187919617,
0.1332960576,
0.1389558762,
-0.4562136233,
-0.6264170408,
0.1563534886,
-0.1875947267,
0.0895904824,
-0.5499011278,
0.7659501433,
-0.888838768,
0.0484372526,
-0.3729023933,
-0.0764357969,
-0.3820080757,
0.2694539726,
0.3128120303,
0.9342003465,
0.3628425896,
-0.8338689208,
0.2745182812,
0.3880894184,
-0.6608347297,
0.1248081103,
-0.6380755901,
0.3699299991,
-0.3325175047,
0.0988532081,
-0.4417705536,
-0.1404533386,
0.3879824579,
-0.2649061084,
0.346904099,
-0.1452780664,
-0.5428045392,
-0.0787264258,
0.0303532369,
0.7672609091,
0.3887250125,
-0.3711348176,
0.9623767138,
0.4558666646,
-0.3281351626,
-0.6217436194,
-0.4059212804,
0.1993796825,
-0.4139034152,
-0.3040782809,
0.6470238566,
0.1862498373,
-0.1937036216,
0.230708003,
-0.071265094,
-0.0391952395,
0.0963238105,
0.4248782396,
0.2690884769,
-0.3429762423,
0.4162577391,
-0.1713087261,
-0.1253240854,
0.0192957148,
-0.1867686361,
0.7785584927,
-0.3731568456,
0.0473914221,
-0.3052547276,
0.4862169921,
0.1253452003,
-0.4321564436,
1.1300580502,
0.6955493689,
-0.9677768946,
-0.050496947,
-0.4269396067,
0.1772257686,
-0.3644858897,
0.5735472441,
-0.4734598994,
-0.8669025898,
0.5968452096,
-0.3059400022,
-0.2044276297,
0.4267792404,
0.6330964565,
0.1648412794,
0.6127865911,
0.6342180371,
-0.6963424683,
0.1709117144,
-0.1151972488,
0.6058244109,
-0.804184854,
-0.4558656514,
-0.5922641754,
-0.5060849786,
-0.6427162886,
-0.1816359162,
0.18473728,
0.109067589,
-0.2718533278,
0.3733265996,
-0.246365875,
0.4395047128,
0.4651169777,
-0.0039194217,
0.2337752879,
0.3116629422,
-0.3044668436,
0.1062519848,
-0.3047090173,
-0.9244993329,
0.6189727187,
0.2630695403,
0.6997361779,
0.4279990792,
0.9929689765,
0.4840563536,
0.2144908458,
-0.8453851938,
0.7335931659,
0.0795901045,
-0.2672463357,
-0.1517183483,
-0.2334256917,
-1.1850966215,
-0.174420774,
-0.1119386628,
-1.0189225674,
-0.0316173173,
-0.3318550885,
-0.3577543795,
0.4013850093,
-0.2204096317,
0.4650368989,
-0.2743024528,
-0.0263117794,
0.128985554,
-0.5994948745,
-0.0416610576,
0.0036927804,
0.1435590833,
-0.0655482709,
0.073628746,
1.2000838518,
-0.3721437752,
0.4389406145,
0.0153947016,
-0.0602487139,
0.4648275077,
-0.031659089,
0.4794152677,
0.3423586786,
0.0937377065,
0.2824709713,
-0.0469490401,
-0.212465167,
-0.317222178,
0.8387048244,
-0.8362028599,
-0.4597188234,
-0.902351737,
-0.5098671317,
0.0789059326,
0.3422352076,
0.0225407071,
0.2984554768,
-0.4352544844,
0.1408145577,
0.4614012837,
-0.1487624198,
0.6118981838,
0.5528264642,
-0.4530104101,
-0.5055545568,
0.5394666791,
0.1355095953,
-0.3660185635,
0.4673211873,
-0.3150118291,
-0.3746364713,
-0.6953741312,
-0.5847957134,
0.4299120605,
-0.4307202101,
-0.5971949697,
-0.6223970056,
-0.6936110854,
-0.2621271014,
0.1451544762,
0.0315116383,
-0.0088203372,
-0.3959290385,
-0.1170437783,
0.5140247345,
0.6370282769,
0.3759934008,
0.3971172273,
-1.1122483015,
0.3615077138,
-0.1615420133,
0.1477539241,
-0.0494523495,
-0.4000032842,
-0.4556197822,
0.0886380002,
0.0022106813,
-1.2606548071,
0.7211057544,
0.4096701145,
0.5838699341,
0.4107546806,
-0.3031151891,
0.5711424947,
-0.676997304,
0.2196784317,
-0.2003667057,
-0.7997117639,
0.5678955913,
-0.0546393543,
0.2059445381,
0.4059039354,
0.6141699553,
-0.7998022437,
0.2011243105,
-0.4497041404,
-0.7721040249,
0.4272499681,
0.3683742285,
-0.112368159,
-0.2268409133,
0.5632423162,
0.2012372315,
0.324583739,
-0.777069509,
-0.3687212765,
0.3732250929,
-0.343403697,
-0.031068122,
-0.5310661197,
0.2159422636,
-0.1673591137,
1.0101635456,
0.1409497559,
0.3718257546,
0.1578509361,
-0.3553839326,
0.0996026993,
0.7534668446,
0.241704002,
0.2944974005,
-0.3264588714,
0.1812874377,
0.2786444128,
-0.6043784618,
0.2911304832,
0.4298517108,
-0.4663242698,
0.3513916135,
0.2173446119,
0.7002181411,
-0.0628177673,
-0.7210003734,
-0.0639630407,
0.1438438296,
0.0416005813,
-0.6348782778,
-0.0469911098,
0.2832939923,
0.2106649876,
0.3601822853,
-0.2690587938,
0.0677550137,
-0.4788757563,
0.3073936105,
0.5527635217,
-0.0589300804,
-0.1482335478,
0.3558313251,
-0.09439715,
-0.577378273,
0.9432317615,
-0.4333066642,
-0.6713417172,
0.6339854002,
0.7670801878,
0.6461874843,
-0.4234535396,
0.3326820731,
0.4927308857,
0.1120632812,
0.038195841,
0.503965199,
0.1551817954,
-1.0122059584,
-0.2320144475,
-1.0793310404,
-0.0612121373,
0.5975171328,
-0.5152788162,
0.3325322568,
-0.4951474667,
-0.3056595027,
-0.0679829866,
0.2626340687,
-0.9744827151,
0.4992954433,
0.3643517792,
0.7021411657,
-0.6964244246,
0.9817672968,
1.1690562963,
-0.3406301737,
-0.9365477562,
-0.4981129766,
-0.250836432,
-0.6637191176,
0.8427764177,
0.4641145766,
-0.3141663074,
0.2188615203,
-0.1980006695,
-1.1512953043,
1.0966279507,
-0.0226188265,
-0.772936523,
-0.0697168782,
0.2493493706,
0.4493097961,
-0.6251496077,
0.2030296177,
0.6196575761,
0.4935932755,
0.0276951231,
-0.5622296333,
0.1315320432,
-0.3172729313,
0.0059246048,
0.8133590221,
-0.1786902845,
0.868347168,
-0.3393252492,
-0.7678977251,
0.2972074151,
0.9218625426,
0.2746928334,
0.6228483915,
0.3303935528,
0.915389955,
0.6997003555,
-0.0286676474,
0.5952946544,
-0.1729930639,
0.2811413407,
1.3934146166,
-0.4031493068,
0.9088021517,
0.4765354991,
-0.2745907903,
0.8855360746,
0.569755137,
-0.1284080893,
0.3867632151,
0.2985511124,
-0.6180375218,
0.0971055776,
-0.5850510001,
-0.5851482749,
0.5216559172,
0.4171468019,
-0.5849853754,
-0.4927479923,
-0.1139528677,
0.2668090761,
-0.0146203814,
-0.3199439347,
0.7807965279,
0.1127899587,
-0.201637432,
0.2321907133,
0.4373007119,
0.2720268071,
-0.4429745078,
-0.1709737182,
-0.0811965764,
0.0562398918,
-0.2922812402,
-0.4390894473,
0.0749717951,
0.0072805081,
-0.1756733954,
0.2315755486,
1.0334062576,
-0.5472022891,
-0.8295547366,
0.2852271795,
0.8086616993,
0.4286698997,
-0.0960610732,
-0.3047799766,
-0.2929914296,
-0.1334859878,
-0.0358710736,
0.2150996774,
0.2359565645,
-0.3645372391,
0.6141789556,
0.5966051221,
0.2505466342,
-0.0808198005,
0.1695977002,
0.71853441,
-1.142056942,
-0.4911592305,
-1.1967227459,
-0.0468447469,
0.0824783295,
0.0074153151,
0.6676440239,
0.7703493237,
0.7713226676,
-0.0838970616,
0.5998761058,
-0.0540635176,
0.498703748,
-0.5424572229,
0.5994715095,
-0.321893543,
0.0526096784,
-0.1638621837,
-1.1487290859,
-0.3173318803,
0.6708686352,
-0.114086099,
0.2356549948,
0.6715539098,
0.5774009228,
0.1260575205,
-0.0525589958,
0.0372274593,
0.198677659,
0.2340382189,
0.88923949,
0.6963098049,
-0.4377063811,
0.0141657628,
0.04202687,
0.291402787,
-0.190794751,
-0.9969520569,
-0.9202580452,
-0.3924451172,
-0.4107687473,
-0.2177895755,
0.1881503165,
1.148665309,
0.2875789106,
-0.9971675277,
-0.1328651011,
-0.0902707353,
0.0992240906,
-0.0403647423,
-0.1376460791,
0.7508442998,
0.1402221173,
-0.6618518829,
0.3322605193,
0.1569239497,
0.4040919542,
0.244580254,
-0.1686479747,
-0.6637101173,
-0.1637842208,
0.4754159749,
0.4665459991,
-0.6464862823,
-0.4159571826,
-0.2680797577,
-0.1402190328,
0.1149386168,
0.5236672163,
-1.3946485519,
0.0366160497,
0.1620873511,
0.9130490422,
0.1645399332,
0.129868716,
0.2351668179,
-0.4635871053,
-0.0407564715,
0.2477516383,
0.7145557404,
0.3792175353,
-0.3315983415,
0.6649371386,
0.0674024075,
-0.5551224947,
-0.524089396,
0.3580243886,
-1.1499391794,
0.1349533349,
1.0059270859,
-0.0464836769,
-0.1437558383,
-0.1511092931,
-0.368650645,
0.5960533619,
-0.6191776991,
0.6552360654,
0.6664081216,
-0.0017051256,
-0.0655842051,
-0.4230435193,
0.3529787958,
0.4048200548,
-0.8590867519,
-0.7292379141,
0.4306485653,
0.2463284433,
0.0139901647,
0.3678215146,
0.1383276284,
0.0200798884,
-0.5035511851,
0.1134274155,
-0.1574023217,
-0.3678530753,
-0.1741700172,
0.1862565726,
-0.0402231328,
-0.4235932827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03394v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03394v2 | Deep Learning for Opinion Mining and Topic Classification of Course Reviews | 2023-04-06T21:48:29 | 2023-06-16T14:15:10 | Anna Koufakou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Student opinions for a course are important to educators and administrators,
regardless of the type of the course or the institution. Reading and manually
analyzing open-ended feedback becomes infeasible for massive volumes of
comments at institution level or online forums. In this paper, we collected and
pre-processed a large number of course reviews publicly available online. We
applied machine learning techniques with the goal to gain insight into student
sentiments and topics. Specifically, we utilized current Natural Language
Processing (NLP) techniques, such as word embeddings and deep neural networks,
and state-of-the-art BERT (Bidirectional Encoder Representations from
Transformers), RoBERTa (Robustly optimized BERT approach) and XLNet
(Generalized Auto-regression Pre-training). We performed extensive
experimentation to compare these techniques versus traditional approaches. This
comparative study demonstrates how to apply modern machine learning approaches
for sentiment polarity extraction and topic-based classification utilizing
course feedback. For sentiment polarity, the top model was RoBERTa with 95.5%
accuracy and 84.7% F1-macro, while for topic classification, an SVM (Support
Vector Machine) was the top classifier with 79.8% accuracy and 80.6% F1-macro.
We also provided an in-depth exploration of the effect of certain
hyperparameters on the model performance and discussed our observations. These
findings can be used by institutions and course providers as a guide for
analyzing their own course feedback using NLP models towards self-evaluation
and improvement. | [
-0.6476628184,
-0.8048317432,
0.4118133783,
-0.0648101568,
-0.2725190222,
0.2231646925,
-0.3797930181,
-0.1153446585,
0.1349717081,
0.6118332148,
-0.5298132896,
-0.8065562844,
-0.4583213627,
-0.1441506147,
-0.1703744084,
1.5982921124,
0.1108429581,
0.6480378509,
-0.4172341526,
-0.3796542883,
-0.2648289204,
-1.0546408892,
-0.5687525272,
-0.4169893265,
0.5320535302,
0.3487586081,
0.3429850042,
-0.1807851046,
0.5306863189,
0.2985757589,
-0.1722055078,
-0.1202309951,
-0.1135996506,
0.0840065703,
-0.1293394417,
-0.4661527872,
-0.5100159645,
0.3676545322,
0.3563946784,
0.5704047084,
-0.0094688982,
0.2368456572,
0.211656183,
0.7849639058,
-0.464220196,
0.279481113,
-0.1982116699,
0.4780601561,
0.0328159966,
0.0154483058,
-0.494545728,
-0.6322339773,
0.6238105297,
-0.1630793959,
0.3548207879,
-0.457837075,
0.6967842579,
0.130976215,
-0.2164420187,
-0.606842041,
-0.6874186993,
0.9999998212,
-0.906594336,
0.3283565938,
0.2567687631,
0.1563696861,
0.2179272622,
-0.4443226755,
-0.5427796245,
-0.1786153018,
0.1257476509,
0.4633155465,
0.111285381,
0.1842083335,
0.1155285314,
0.5921228528,
-0.3833982348,
0.1828631163,
-0.2467437983,
0.1074891835,
0.5494077206,
0.0984093174,
-0.2184128612,
-0.6468810439,
-0.3133517504,
-0.312822938,
-0.2886109054,
0.2858392298,
0.637870729,
0.2322668433,
0.230791986,
0.4123903215,
-0.011385316,
0.4213562906,
0.0224273242,
0.2418712527,
0.3140721917,
0.0253931377,
-0.3470299542,
-0.0535952486,
0.8117468357,
0.2919289768,
-0.016456116,
0.2987242043,
-0.1004936025,
0.0415987521,
0.429964155,
-0.7436989546,
-0.3037173152,
0.4135398865,
-0.8437489271,
-0.6129388809,
0.2962718606,
-1.0344780684,
-0.5253095031,
-0.855879426,
0.2345634699,
-0.0393552259,
-0.2702128887,
0.0573942699,
0.1102744341,
0.2429062575,
0.5849630237,
-0.3829900324,
0.086317949,
0.9066034555,
0.6831409335,
-0.3245376647,
-0.1009923965,
-0.1119285896,
-0.5648600459,
0.0341355279,
0.5657094121,
-0.3415861428,
-0.0826692879,
0.2724883258,
0.0566120259,
0.2860477269,
-0.4234537482,
0.544346869,
-0.7241109014,
0.7064860463,
-0.0384248942,
-0.9009165764,
-0.5545899868,
0.4506311119,
-0.4576808512,
0.7331246138,
-0.0399156101,
-0.7481409907,
0.2978792191,
-0.5015912652,
-0.4086640775,
-0.1340978891,
-0.2039153874,
-0.8818687201,
0.2113775164,
0.2310897559,
0.7610343099,
-0.0118661914,
0.4931867719,
-0.5599582195,
0.0022720904,
0.4085019827,
-0.2669115961,
0.9023236632,
0.2135424316,
-0.562730372,
0.3297100961,
-0.372246325,
0.0339663662,
-0.2433940917,
-0.264781177,
-0.2711068392,
0.0386456065,
0.1021916196,
0.3229793608,
0.0538379215,
-0.3920272589,
0.2334142178,
-0.3567777276,
0.4922456741,
0.9855736494,
0.0826974586,
0.3633002043,
0.1525930613,
0.3243371248,
0.3382080197,
0.3419215977,
0.1973495781,
-0.5637068152,
-1.1473475695,
0.0634161308,
0.3658852279,
0.403003335,
-0.3407559097,
0.6634254456,
0.1852834076,
-0.4512416422,
-0.7541100979,
0.3356020451,
0.0824514925,
0.431733042,
0.4472911656,
-0.5803622007,
-0.4061844051,
-0.4462825358,
-0.1269088984,
-0.3882213831,
0.1812659502,
0.380173713,
0.4002886117,
-0.5395764709,
1.059461832,
-0.7284824252,
-0.4855498672,
-0.268045336,
0.6745827198,
0.3843674958,
0.3415031731,
0.2290576249,
-0.647713244,
-0.3519276083,
-0.1914782226,
-0.9005898237,
0.1848045886,
-0.0584085397,
0.0276742447,
0.3531481028,
0.2174405754,
-0.3803501725,
0.2566341162,
0.1784876436,
-0.1322924793,
0.3481357396,
0.0599817894,
-0.0172418021,
-0.9254423976,
-0.2697476745,
0.3015321493,
-0.0635799617,
-0.3579948545,
-0.1050382927,
-0.099681437,
-0.3636833131,
-0.3594098091,
0.1802578717,
-0.0873452574,
-0.0035877791,
-0.5776088834,
-0.0175258461,
-0.0395642929,
0.6268610358,
0.284960568,
0.2216820121,
0.5078477859,
-0.2973856926,
0.5501531363,
0.2860174775,
-0.3510769308,
0.3130858243,
-0.4790435433,
0.3673258424,
-0.2445625961,
0.3714016378,
-0.6281196475,
0.0838227049,
0.2167889178,
-0.5343305469,
0.2485434264,
-0.418509692,
0.0656456873,
-0.3623062074,
-0.5048531294,
-0.1233519167,
0.5593718886,
-0.5720683932,
0.4168486297,
0.3988009393,
-0.2983964682,
-0.7246261835,
-0.2212475389,
-0.1898882836,
-0.0286872014,
-0.0123817008,
-0.2861409485,
-0.0820811763,
-0.2676667273,
0.0271771476,
0.179777503,
-0.1444921046,
0.0875146464,
0.5188717246,
0.3422654569,
-0.3026456833,
0.3716623485,
-0.0391603522,
-0.0615084209,
0.5299949646,
-0.4721228182,
0.6201802492,
-0.6208542585,
-0.2076984048,
-0.5229455829,
0.4085418582,
0.6786981821,
-0.1391728967,
0.5599779487,
0.6565810442,
-0.1126449928,
-0.3442180455,
-0.6625004411,
-0.5439472795,
-0.3820219636,
0.4060121477,
0.1105710119,
-0.8278770447,
0.0621423088,
-0.0000717462,
0.1598790735,
0.4480514824,
0.5867594481,
-0.4690942466,
1.1229637861,
0.7681490183,
-0.701479733,
0.5706034899,
-0.6353734732,
0.3126211166,
-0.5332122445,
-0.1918631494,
-0.4609161019,
-0.1169261783,
-0.5913280845,
-0.2224100232,
-0.1749254316,
0.0784430802,
-0.1757537723,
0.0370937996,
-0.434476614,
0.1378454268,
0.6148664951,
0.2803120017,
-0.0726511255,
0.2638069391,
0.1992173493,
-0.2115011662,
-0.4264034927,
-0.60508883,
1.2735230923,
0.7082026005,
0.5207609534,
-0.2085843384,
0.6567076445,
0.5241550803,
0.7539925575,
-1.1462676525,
0.5586628914,
-0.409832716,
-0.4181131721,
-0.2775250375,
-0.5645403266,
-0.4092598259,
0.1013047323,
-0.4809724391,
0.1764870286,
-0.0350686237,
-0.1717784256,
-0.1310968846,
0.5806812644,
-0.3632478714,
0.7464991212,
-0.4362546802,
-0.3027206957,
-0.5134461522,
-0.4664919972,
-0.1300301701,
-0.0170938764,
0.1255508363,
-0.0371393748,
0.55341506,
0.9353927374,
-0.2169014513,
0.9344573617,
-0.4415030181,
0.0361163244,
0.4514951706,
-0.3581915498,
-0.0042269127,
0.4067704678,
-0.072027728,
0.5288743973,
-0.4743793905,
-0.2895104289,
-0.574688971,
0.7185519934,
-1.3788927794,
-0.6974375248,
-0.528711617,
-0.0489767753,
-0.2163678706,
0.030314425,
0.076465182,
0.42466712,
-0.0356774777,
0.2457242757,
0.8499304056,
-0.2479850799,
0.428781718,
0.4437660873,
-0.1728168726,
-0.6950704455,
1.1224321127,
0.1091874987,
-0.1722733974,
0.2495992333,
0.3717090487,
-0.2829814553,
-0.4877965748,
-0.5176032186,
0.133319512,
-0.9106051922,
-0.2881106436,
-0.7354507446,
-0.2729814947,
-0.6395691633,
-0.1269914508,
-0.1194066554,
-0.308577925,
-0.4945694804,
-0.2497276962,
0.0681178942,
0.8203318715,
0.2402845174,
0.253010571,
-0.7101487517,
-0.0389016159,
0.5571522713,
0.4195201695,
0.1018023416,
-0.292940706,
-0.1267264485,
-0.0398581624,
-0.4793414176,
-0.8167273998,
0.3707667887,
0.1382892877,
0.3471975923,
0.6994075775,
0.0501372628,
0.1068297401,
-0.008982921,
0.820988059,
0.2760908902,
-0.8576738238,
0.9254337549,
-0.0071073393,
-0.1266073734,
0.6834389567,
0.8080943227,
-0.2314659655,
-0.4939867556,
-0.6224896312,
-0.8306798935,
0.5909682512,
-0.1040518954,
0.1921760142,
0.1659286767,
0.5669866204,
0.3606048524,
0.5660606027,
-0.8381754756,
-0.2877748609,
-0.620890379,
-0.3793625534,
-0.3739668131,
-0.3523368835,
0.015187623,
-0.4017679691,
0.848129034,
-0.2235245109,
0.0466961712,
0.0997880623,
-0.1233173236,
0.0283405334,
0.5207330585,
0.2813856304,
0.4827229679,
-0.489276439,
0.0476939306,
0.3372849226,
-0.6055216193,
0.0259173065,
-0.1958540976,
-0.2318183035,
0.3054885268,
0.1888812482,
0.5876637697,
-0.1728726625,
-0.2770539522,
0.8031921387,
-0.3403656483,
-0.05294846,
-0.5595276952,
-0.1902893782,
-0.4114351273,
0.1427714825,
0.2369747013,
0.1026159972,
0.2799452245,
-0.6507833004,
0.1352700889,
0.3297811747,
-1.0238304138,
-0.240517661,
0.1728907973,
0.5300247073,
-0.0277499165,
0.8600876331,
0.2430746555,
-0.8304382563,
0.5187057853,
0.0777561814,
1.4103505611,
-0.004197815,
0.6243962049,
0.3914630115,
-0.065014042,
0.1053069904,
0.1553457826,
-0.242309764,
-0.5661126375,
-0.2605275214,
-0.8372057676,
-0.8473804593,
0.1791081429,
-0.9823266268,
0.2938948572,
-0.742229104,
-0.4526654184,
0.0598695353,
0.3620574474,
-0.3972924948,
0.5367106199,
0.2201476544,
0.4666620791,
-1.0140228271,
0.6741991043,
1.2336870432,
-0.5023335814,
-0.4198284745,
-0.0667711347,
-0.1714736074,
-0.0551135205,
0.7471516728,
0.4349585772,
0.0415226556,
-0.3944592476,
-0.4270958006,
-0.0002643431,
0.4998537004,
-0.2431730181,
-0.5650895238,
0.2284356654,
0.2940790653,
0.7230605483,
-0.2517804205,
0.3701916039,
0.0419788212,
0.0453350991,
-0.3972821236,
-0.1879328191,
-0.4044897854,
-0.1746872962,
-0.3486919105,
0.1372439861,
-0.614074111,
0.8138363361,
0.2009807825,
0.2787776589,
-0.5898770094,
0.9833407402,
-0.1033512503,
0.5979490876,
0.557456255,
0.7477120161,
0.665103972,
-0.1805906147,
0.5814084411,
-0.1949305236,
0.7115646601,
0.8261452317,
-0.1876850575,
1.0613280535,
0.277934432,
-0.1209531426,
0.7723927498,
0.7219086885,
-0.2497510165,
0.4973294735,
0.1780742258,
-0.3173698783,
-0.393163234,
0.1208481118,
-0.3296792507,
0.1990192384,
0.2317223996,
-0.4221369326,
0.0531471819,
0.4527336061,
-0.1321714818,
-0.1360359639,
-0.6426821947,
1.0322341919,
0.1981912106,
-0.6801081896,
-0.0950019583,
0.048595611,
0.692535758,
-0.2124144882,
0.0294376109,
-0.3752263486,
0.5338684916,
-0.3974249959,
-1.0149269104,
0.1275552809,
0.0731168687,
-0.5091540813,
-0.4328598082,
0.7394355536,
-0.1487017423,
-0.5169392228,
0.318638891,
0.335827738,
-0.0354425237,
-0.0058762189,
-0.7954887152,
-0.2307996005,
0.0025469051,
-0.328047365,
0.2914950252,
0.3440822661,
-0.0698268563,
0.4108578563,
0.724044919,
0.053184282,
-0.1861058474,
0.3886579871,
0.8464061618,
-0.7321506143,
-0.5082709193,
-0.7177966237,
0.1705870181,
-0.2980603576,
-0.5132728815,
0.773106277,
0.565523684,
1.0762711763,
-0.2348398268,
0.750914216,
0.3383666873,
0.481526494,
-0.380741775,
0.7832202911,
-0.2344724536,
0.2707616091,
-0.3324769437,
-0.8325741291,
-0.1703280658,
0.712300241,
-0.5051416159,
-0.1713095456,
0.3854717314,
0.2328635454,
0.1696329266,
0.5628327727,
-0.0993259028,
0.0435293503,
0.3682239056,
0.2392861396,
1.1634918451,
-0.2784809172,
0.2640063763,
-0.6203727126,
-0.2857001126,
-0.4354073703,
-0.5186947584,
-1.2543994188,
-0.4740700424,
-0.8509418964,
-0.5937315822,
-0.0244994685,
1.018468976,
0.7507355809,
-1.3173106909,
-0.3831170797,
-0.1528088897,
0.3578703701,
0.0392084494,
-0.3041707575,
0.4673179686,
-0.6331442595,
-0.4430620968,
-0.0730317757,
0.0853520185,
-0.0112607367,
-0.650885582,
0.0474166162,
0.1402166933,
-0.0907237083,
0.7602305412,
0.019524198,
-0.7181664705,
-0.0532949381,
0.093814455,
-0.191465795,
0.0537442118,
1.0467252731,
-0.7553801537,
0.3040604591,
0.5921162963,
0.6927184463,
0.5142413378,
-0.0630852506,
0.2993679941,
-0.5940329432,
-0.005718817,
0.6594699621,
0.1777080148,
0.2879827023,
-0.3015537858,
0.2081733346,
0.2615644038,
-0.6545969844,
-0.6085023284,
-0.0076518045,
-0.9284481406,
-0.5990566015,
0.7729587555,
-0.4739945531,
-0.0097303614,
-0.190874368,
-0.3251706362,
0.2549184263,
-0.2871405184,
1.074849844,
0.6829494238,
-0.1777331382,
-0.191224739,
-0.5159872174,
0.5102549195,
0.5960953832,
-0.8466858864,
-0.1208171919,
0.3774904609,
0.2016645819,
0.1868203878,
0.1875734478,
0.016996583,
0.0780466348,
-0.6995363832,
0.1652719826,
0.1571166068,
-0.3774722219,
-0.8468715549,
0.6448761821,
-0.1359833181,
0.0464362726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03347v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03347v4 | Towards Interpretable Mental Health Analysis with Large Language Models | 2023-04-06T19:53:59 | 2023-10-11T08:13:28 | Kailai Yang, Shaoxiong Ji, Tianlin Zhang, Qianqian Xie, Ziyan Kuang, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL | The latest large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, exhibit strong
capabilities in automated mental health analysis. However, existing relevant
studies bear several limitations, including inadequate evaluations, lack of
prompting strategies, and ignorance of exploring LLMs for explainability. To
bridge these gaps, we comprehensively evaluate the mental health analysis and
emotional reasoning ability of LLMs on 11 datasets across 5 tasks. We explore
the effects of different prompting strategies with unsupervised and distantly
supervised emotional information. Based on these prompts, we explore LLMs for
interpretable mental health analysis by instructing them to generate
explanations for each of their decisions. We convey strict human evaluations to
assess the quality of the generated explanations, leading to a novel dataset
with 163 human-assessed explanations. We benchmark existing automatic
evaluation metrics on this dataset to guide future related works. According to
the results, ChatGPT shows strong in-context learning ability but still has a
significant gap with advanced task-specific methods. Careful prompt engineering
with emotional cues and expert-written few-shot examples can also effectively
improve performance on mental health analysis. In addition, ChatGPT generates
explanations that approach human performance, showing its great potential in
explainable mental health analysis. | [
-0.3109142184,
-0.9382190704,
0.9555153251,
0.2550483048,
-0.070365034,
-0.173138991,
-0.585888803,
-0.4008485377,
-0.1049159318,
0.2066683918,
-1.0033363104,
-0.5237205029,
-0.8246890903,
0.097196728,
-0.2205594778,
1.1083273888,
-0.0396583304,
0.1541173607,
-0.0184046216,
0.2337118536,
-0.6103530526,
-0.4087572992,
-0.9606174827,
-0.3445982635,
0.5383642912,
0.4390157461,
0.7801229954,
0.1993090808,
0.4286322892,
0.2230975181,
-0.0953191593,
0.1945465952,
-0.6131150723,
0.1273516566,
-0.1368655115,
-0.243638739,
-0.6802618504,
-0.1369164437,
0.4065123796,
0.7045010328,
-0.2384934127,
0.1056840569,
0.1339775473,
0.6999146342,
-0.2410587817,
0.4691438377,
-0.3582792282,
0.1785071194,
-0.1612633616,
-0.1930410564,
-0.4544253349,
-0.0071897851,
0.1602683365,
-0.2884445488,
-0.0606877543,
-0.0159501266,
0.5960724354,
0.43740049,
-0.4828029871,
-0.2750180066,
-0.5449650288,
0.5007573366,
-0.8212987185,
0.3156684041,
0.4122893512,
0.5086470842,
-0.4247287512,
-0.4671087265,
-0.4371463954,
-0.0669913366,
-0.0158036705,
0.3530244529,
-0.6077845097,
0.2809096575,
0.4171330333,
0.1512626261,
-0.653460145,
0.19218494,
-0.1281252205,
-0.0567865111,
0.7702612281,
0.4107768834,
0.6086743474,
-0.1937717497,
0.1115331277,
0.2232008278,
-0.4039157629,
-0.0434771776,
0.0674108192,
0.0189609323,
-0.3137875497,
0.6692938805,
-0.0831941888,
0.4658355713,
0.0388235115,
-0.1106513217,
0.0037763633,
0.0851197392,
-0.2216302902,
-0.0764608234,
0.7821143866,
0.5846943855,
0.3756349385,
-0.3292798102,
-0.1318957657,
0.0072931475,
0.2335095704,
-0.8149514794,
-0.2286191583,
0.4792624712,
-0.6995090842,
0.2057944834,
-0.1092589572,
-1.0324134827,
-0.6800563335,
-0.485804528,
0.1878901273,
-0.5460324883,
-0.3372868598,
0.4642592371,
0.0872471705,
0.0992758721,
0.3403594494,
-0.7010080218,
0.1691079587,
0.6482815742,
0.8006877303,
-0.3405919969,
-0.0709598735,
-0.3664094508,
-0.1392342746,
-0.1709538996,
0.8096963167,
-0.4897294641,
-0.1632595062,
-0.0609772801,
0.1798407733,
-0.1778613925,
-0.3139084876,
0.5331344604,
-0.246572718,
0.3114948571,
-0.3315900564,
-0.5416687727,
-0.3785997331,
0.0531399697,
-0.298746407,
0.7178583741,
0.1046816185,
-0.8764840364,
0.1675358117,
-0.9102740884,
-0.3506730199,
0.0100381095,
0.0964826122,
-0.0500226021,
0.1220137626,
0.6661493182,
0.8342961669,
-0.3346458077,
0.6074613929,
-0.4600552917,
-0.3201054037,
0.4109230042,
-0.6816135645,
0.7624925375,
0.3379215598,
-0.357762605,
0.2021981925,
-0.5624605417,
0.0502632111,
0.1031127572,
0.0092289709,
0.074250631,
0.1822844595,
-0.1166901141,
0.1814007759,
0.1109140068,
-0.0644451156,
-0.1829985976,
-0.3596305847,
0.5190090537,
0.5754765868,
0.2315922081,
-0.0150909834,
-0.1770466268,
0.9097323418,
-0.3031767905,
0.2903706729,
-0.2726663351,
-0.4828820527,
-0.2612122297,
-0.7455387712,
-0.2975732684,
0.611528337,
-0.5586337447,
0.4232965112,
-0.2500484288,
-0.4357602596,
-0.486274302,
-0.0501678362,
0.1633645445,
0.4036322236,
0.1774234772,
-0.1377849728,
-0.4392059743,
-0.8153991699,
-0.3238840997,
-0.0937577859,
-0.2751525939,
0.2674305141,
0.4071518481,
-0.5994630456,
0.7348147035,
-0.3841555119,
0.1475042403,
-0.2976685166,
0.1504068524,
0.2348133028,
-0.0957667753,
0.2401169389,
-0.289771229,
-0.1895438433,
-0.1102873012,
-0.9633539915,
-0.5268860459,
-0.0774848685,
-0.2814567387,
-0.2268607169,
0.3917537332,
-0.6975949407,
0.1484877616,
0.4315924346,
-0.4252802432,
0.6877049208,
-0.0964826494,
0.0303864423,
-0.8336381912,
-0.0874104127,
0.1850456744,
-0.2863974869,
-0.5339214802,
-0.0636055321,
-0.3597534001,
-0.3812342286,
-0.2020783275,
0.5645396113,
-0.3822838366,
-0.004983101,
-0.3030736148,
0.2969992757,
-0.0987577215,
0.3060227334,
-0.2142628878,
0.4705793858,
0.6208720207,
-0.0582526699,
0.5373657346,
0.042452164,
-0.2638411224,
0.7098836303,
-0.6097922921,
0.0613163635,
-0.3929837048,
0.5336571336,
-1.0490835905,
-0.5630487204,
0.3442873657,
-0.3661518693,
0.2429019213,
0.0674426481,
-0.4976126552,
-0.3974042535,
0.0408900976,
0.0262547471,
0.4964899719,
-0.537694931,
0.2419889569,
0.3316800594,
-0.3598985076,
-0.1818205267,
-0.2685288489,
0.1446309239,
-0.709023416,
-0.7204764485,
-0.0921165645,
-0.11506854,
-0.6058343053,
-0.0369763039,
-0.0212037731,
-0.1693312228,
0.3010683656,
0.5776152611,
0.4465088546,
-0.2041559666,
0.531011343,
-0.0799538419,
-0.1226119399,
0.5333371758,
0.0881263316,
0.2856485546,
-0.3991690874,
-0.3987394869,
-0.6116510034,
0.3888168037,
0.6345357895,
-0.1136033088,
0.7549164891,
0.7152416706,
-0.5046172738,
-0.0493029766,
-0.3476234078,
-0.2967815399,
-0.3734381795,
0.5157506466,
-0.2416380942,
-0.8671272397,
0.3373659253,
-0.028474208,
-0.0184081253,
0.4420788586,
0.7752871513,
-0.2405815572,
1.4356379509,
0.3134463131,
-0.0265226532,
0.3694654703,
0.25475052,
0.4350036681,
-0.51780653,
-0.1039449722,
-0.1685409248,
0.0051366487,
-0.4602344334,
-0.3321923018,
0.4251989722,
-0.0444770418,
-0.4218198359,
-0.3368185759,
-0.5856575966,
0.3872879148,
-0.2152790874,
0.4184818566,
0.1650406867,
-0.1204648241,
0.2288915366,
-0.2461465001,
-0.549323976,
-0.6022105813,
0.7340472937,
0.7476990819,
0.8469712734,
-0.0560644902,
0.3400473595,
0.3092965484,
0.5649721622,
-1.1149116755,
0.304437995,
0.0274752993,
-0.4962080419,
-0.4021371901,
-0.464512676,
-0.9929788709,
0.2589984536,
-0.1850129664,
-1.1631854773,
-0.3242720068,
0.0126599399,
-0.3933577538,
-0.0449213535,
-0.9344853163,
0.7060027122,
-0.4558838308,
-0.0036627019,
-0.3177493215,
-0.4791925848,
0.6599878073,
-0.2839931548,
0.4967157543,
-0.4877341092,
0.2237408757,
0.7790232301,
-0.2063850611,
0.8649173379,
-0.1379572302,
-0.2896358669,
0.047670994,
-0.0659862161,
0.2249807715,
0.1890137196,
-0.3624361157,
0.042915415,
0.2014130056,
-0.3224707246,
-1.0387265682,
0.5398544669,
-0.56132406,
-0.8558677435,
-0.0817508399,
-0.7992161512,
-0.5856029987,
0.0206211265,
0.0859292448,
0.3276150823,
-0.0365378559,
-0.1835895777,
0.5228008032,
-0.6120057702,
-0.0414953716,
0.5611751676,
-0.2532823086,
-0.1508991271,
0.7706000805,
-0.2070527226,
-0.0003572957,
0.0046126046,
0.4130770862,
-0.2693624496,
-0.2813433707,
-0.2413741499,
0.542568624,
-0.7123200297,
0.233697325,
-0.469575882,
-0.1240703836,
-0.1511442959,
-0.1535972357,
-0.2226359397,
0.0565715656,
-0.0870258957,
-0.1295419782,
0.4793449044,
0.8198139668,
-0.0259680282,
0.3655029833,
-0.7326152921,
0.2525213659,
0.2539992332,
0.3227995932,
0.4601428509,
-0.4611936808,
-0.1859452724,
0.1434252262,
-0.1600510031,
-1.3079872131,
0.3747440279,
-0.0357353799,
0.5253500938,
0.7713559866,
0.0947027728,
0.8407142162,
-0.429374516,
0.5940381289,
0.1823416352,
-0.9542215466,
0.6641029716,
-0.4322933257,
0.4014142454,
0.2994483113,
0.5224594474,
-0.7281743288,
-0.3514071405,
-0.5980198979,
-0.810766995,
0.6017372608,
0.1626383662,
-0.040170718,
-0.1370104551,
0.4193664789,
0.14752464,
-0.2861397862,
-0.4098395705,
0.0130770896,
0.0717852265,
-0.3612628579,
-0.1667113602,
-0.2219379693,
-0.1989639848,
-0.1809277534,
0.6321151853,
-0.178083688,
0.5292642117,
0.1324820518,
0.0014770316,
-0.1688914299,
0.4440508783,
0.1981030256,
0.6529119015,
-0.2331913114,
0.2797861099,
0.2617604733,
-0.1299633086,
0.0426286608,
0.2535393536,
0.5301297307,
-0.1345647722,
0.6197881699,
0.8439338803,
0.0988136008,
-1.0733047724,
0.4501395226,
-0.1889126003,
0.1669190824,
-0.0310464855,
0.076484926,
0.260555923,
0.5519329309,
-0.0242814086,
-0.5794265866,
0.2244930565,
-0.5798939466,
0.0982419103,
0.4665234387,
-0.6219652295,
-0.4692418873,
0.5157690644,
-0.0878864527,
-0.1787139028,
0.7804967761,
-0.0160614569,
-0.3648278117,
0.5052588582,
0.4643787146,
0.6232492328,
-0.1706456244,
0.3598358929,
0.2588565648,
0.3455748558,
-0.1303652674,
0.3452173769,
0.0686757788,
-0.5232310891,
-0.7291272283,
-0.2727275491,
-0.5709757805,
0.3716446757,
-0.8761506677,
0.0807851702,
-0.0303627215,
-0.077285856,
0.2750830948,
-0.1815165281,
-0.7387874126,
0.2536231279,
0.341088444,
0.613840282,
-0.9594843388,
0.4886738658,
0.7168245316,
-0.0661277249,
-0.8919448853,
0.3150540888,
0.3184721172,
-0.976973772,
0.37557742,
0.3585942686,
0.1269058883,
-0.2791883945,
-0.5481366515,
-0.5693699121,
0.7654471993,
0.6986364126,
-0.4271430373,
-0.0825279877,
-0.1114683673,
0.7580740452,
-0.1696603894,
0.6682642698,
0.7146451473,
0.7362405658,
-0.1218594313,
-0.7574324608,
0.2761515081,
-0.2397823781,
-0.2374350131,
0.007496363,
-0.3634009063,
0.2249334902,
-0.3247883618,
-0.4170178175,
-0.2098050863,
0.3519789875,
0.322131604,
0.4266972244,
0.5218847394,
0.2241755873,
1.1029858589,
0.0942059755,
1.1740859747,
-0.0883099139,
0.3487482071,
1.1133761406,
-0.2129293084,
0.6738262773,
0.2360253185,
-0.3728029728,
0.2885448933,
0.9816288948,
0.0430094004,
0.1117708609,
0.3519512713,
-0.2425922602,
-0.4163087606,
-0.2315538079,
-0.1676709205,
0.4493568838,
0.6224318147,
-0.4670595229,
-0.3547912538,
0.2812349498,
0.3256771266,
-0.2829036415,
-0.1116565466,
0.4692157209,
0.3725080788,
-0.5473676324,
0.4393179715,
-0.1848440766,
0.3368794322,
-0.3707112372,
-0.0301097333,
-0.1418239027,
-0.0474621877,
-0.3868416846,
-0.8181245923,
0.4921143055,
0.2932857573,
-0.1608796716,
-0.2426489741,
0.7507564425,
-0.1568858176,
-0.3136938214,
0.294349581,
0.8716483116,
0.6817981601,
-0.3345314264,
-0.6432008147,
-0.2444138527,
-0.1295912564,
-0.4603669345,
0.413438201,
0.9355613589,
-0.2334882766,
0.7613621354,
0.4604394436,
0.0863830149,
-0.442646265,
0.0213025026,
0.5262987018,
-0.6089778543,
-0.126109302,
-1.1101412773,
0.2692569494,
0.1832256615,
-0.0062281922,
0.6231899261,
0.0434546843,
0.0436781123,
0.0942549556,
0.7831590772,
0.0396152437,
0.2858707607,
-0.444139123,
0.7308459282,
-0.5890261531,
0.1856651455,
-0.1799794734,
-0.6869584322,
-0.2324435562,
0.5314218402,
-0.6130224466,
-0.1061890796,
0.7789700031,
0.6218302846,
0.1340960413,
0.2117512226,
0.3800389767,
0.5414710045,
0.4006998539,
0.6390212774,
1.0358190536,
0.2775002122,
0.28423962,
-0.0065703704,
-0.4544721246,
-0.0332698114,
-1.0008918047,
-0.9930850863,
-0.3307677209,
-0.3166404963,
-0.2324079573,
0.1251294464,
0.8504974842,
0.7236568332,
-0.5119846463,
0.1381282955,
0.2090996951,
0.1399107873,
-0.2824993134,
-0.3325056732,
0.5159764886,
-0.165196225,
-0.4910832047,
0.401194483,
0.2939192653,
-0.2368244529,
-0.2514151633,
-0.0476668738,
0.4169616401,
0.079519324,
0.8449955583,
0.0692912489,
-0.9174351096,
-0.2569074929,
-0.1119650304,
0.1279129088,
0.038617786,
0.5787875652,
-0.4133562446,
0.5440378189,
0.2802076042,
0.6635957956,
0.1781771183,
-0.0872021168,
0.6714084744,
-0.2108310759,
-0.3034280837,
0.0585857034,
0.5169347525,
0.3157650232,
-0.6730325818,
0.5545070767,
-0.1745834351,
-0.6459233761,
-0.6048020124,
-0.0382482409,
-1.0342032909,
-0.1947891265,
1.4556727409,
-0.5074167252,
-0.1645160615,
-0.0983723029,
-0.5783423185,
0.5255473256,
-0.4291335046,
1.0074931383,
1.0492832661,
-0.6456254721,
-0.4338096678,
-1.1138347387,
0.1490332782,
0.4884040058,
-1.3046555519,
0.2838828564,
0.5470563769,
0.297003299,
-0.4851180613,
0.5632386208,
-0.22023651,
0.2596772611,
-0.368408829,
0.0154060693,
0.2209822685,
0.16704382,
-0.5302883983,
-0.1634416133,
0.1023446545,
0.2216652036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03325v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03325v1 | ChatGPT-Crawler: Find out if ChatGPT really knows what it's talking about | 2023-04-06T18:42:47 | 2023-04-06T18:42:47 | Aman Rangapur, Haoran Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, I.7, I.m | Large language models have gained considerable interest for their impressive
performance on various tasks. Among these models, ChatGPT developed by OpenAI
has become extremely popular among early adopters who even regard it as a
disruptive technology in many fields like customer service, education,
healthcare, and finance. It is essential to comprehend the opinions of these
initial users as it can provide valuable insights into the potential strengths,
weaknesses, and success or failure of the technology in different areas. This
research examines the responses generated by ChatGPT from different
Conversational QA corpora. The study employed BERT similarity scores to compare
these responses with correct answers and obtain Natural Language Inference(NLI)
labels. Evaluation scores were also computed and compared to determine the
overall performance of GPT-3 \& GPT-4. Additionally, the study identified
instances where ChatGPT provided incorrect answers to questions, providing
insights into areas where the model may be prone to error. | [
-0.4800121784,
-0.8517536521,
0.6460654736,
0.2973614037,
-0.1341156065,
0.1382933408,
0.0012844598,
-0.6508892775,
0.0466268286,
0.1086899713,
-0.4471309185,
-0.3670608997,
-0.5292481184,
-0.117570065,
-0.6063460112,
1.1417323351,
0.3412510753,
0.0309862643,
0.0793114156,
0.1074506119,
-0.4824775159,
-0.4982502162,
-1.1182563305,
-0.1526444107,
0.6026787758,
0.1315959096,
1.0129351616,
0.2457708567,
0.6907567382,
0.2859174609,
-0.4170438647,
-0.2893221378,
-0.6835062504,
-0.0212375168,
-0.1165007502,
-0.6430574059,
-0.2857253551,
-0.0904249549,
0.4546185732,
0.2393940985,
-0.1555937231,
0.1795026958,
-0.0183090959,
0.5536226034,
-0.2426771671,
0.2117424011,
-0.6938908696,
0.1080099419,
-0.1353914887,
-0.0993043855,
-0.3677756786,
-0.6197656393,
0.4900213182,
-0.3785496056,
0.4996691346,
0.0960588604,
1.1681065559,
0.3175050318,
-0.2986903787,
-0.5407295823,
-0.7136925459,
0.4627223015,
-0.8935514688,
0.4120954871,
0.2886116505,
0.5467865467,
-0.1960904896,
-0.5986420512,
-0.7854674459,
-0.1959484816,
-0.1464562118,
0.3671530485,
-0.2117558271,
0.0325499587,
0.1894840747,
0.6477365494,
-1.0381641388,
0.0612731837,
-0.4605315328,
-0.1120794415,
0.2995662093,
-0.1204633415,
0.4515555501,
-0.3068909645,
-0.4695206285,
-0.3185300231,
-0.6534207463,
-0.0658764914,
0.5931204557,
0.0463118367,
0.0229082238,
0.7181844711,
-0.2191696018,
0.5109624267,
-0.0668375567,
0.1175090522,
0.2959544957,
-0.1814351529,
-0.1972037554,
0.0889728591,
0.8676242232,
0.3376143873,
0.6351437569,
-0.2876031399,
-0.1410927027,
-0.1063705087,
0.4518238306,
-0.715757966,
-0.3741712868,
0.3270938694,
-0.4697716832,
-0.1787341833,
0.0517817922,
-0.7017931938,
-0.4177309573,
0.062498562,
0.4143651426,
-0.8487606645,
-0.3123687208,
0.0278552528,
-0.3148998618,
0.8041523695,
0.1694908291,
-0.6732840538,
0.1045670211,
0.9666683078,
1.1085324287,
-0.0449722596,
-0.1017406359,
-0.3767627776,
-0.3190674782,
-0.0581772029,
0.9731397033,
-0.6170089245,
-0.4355676174,
0.0177697893,
-0.1019138321,
-0.5150697827,
-0.4158937037,
0.5067529678,
-0.9849696755,
0.4218779504,
-0.0869534537,
-0.6477401853,
-0.3887198865,
0.6412224174,
-0.7491982579,
0.9276602268,
0.1499737501,
-1.1271326542,
0.2529731095,
-0.9091664553,
-0.134775728,
0.2335082591,
0.1339852661,
-0.400165379,
-0.092671901,
0.0449343249,
0.1592457741,
-0.006727539,
0.1208375469,
-0.159182176,
-0.4712828994,
0.5052676797,
-0.4602284431,
0.6007601619,
0.3332852721,
-0.2460528612,
0.1490329057,
-0.678293407,
0.0958308727,
0.2432535291,
-0.2805311382,
-0.1069310904,
0.0960994586,
-0.0942637101,
0.1674000025,
0.199256286,
-0.7365304232,
0.1464479566,
-0.4947671592,
0.3914920092,
0.553272903,
0.2237875909,
-0.0171280429,
-0.3822903931,
0.6508674026,
-0.271997124,
0.1614617109,
-0.1959994584,
-1.1493439674,
-0.6518158913,
-0.0261648241,
0.6186460257,
0.7174640894,
-0.5050758123,
0.0213218369,
-0.3783079982,
-0.763015151,
-0.7495227456,
-0.34144786,
0.324298799,
0.4215306044,
0.1464657634,
-0.2831800282,
-0.3724396229,
-0.9063928127,
-0.2944303453,
-0.4428338706,
-0.3361278772,
0.4481266737,
0.3064117432,
-0.3904849291,
1.0126847029,
-0.4951288104,
-0.1457868069,
-0.069612585,
0.248439759,
0.3575368226,
0.1236173734,
0.4862028956,
-1.0448050499,
-0.3882829845,
0.0196847115,
-0.4173937142,
0.1176649407,
0.0691793039,
-0.0039793127,
0.0519366786,
0.0087938784,
-0.5561628938,
0.3768522739,
0.8881493807,
-0.2104074061,
0.5329620838,
-0.230654195,
0.2242318988,
-0.9185166359,
0.3397995234,
-0.0773846433,
-0.1201988831,
-0.4808034003,
0.1386612356,
-0.2215200812,
-0.2439405322,
-0.3199341297,
0.4169586003,
0.0989431739,
-0.2978616953,
-0.0413200222,
0.461825043,
-0.398742497,
0.4005229771,
0.0680423081,
1.1469238997,
0.2946648002,
-0.4422179759,
0.2305536419,
0.5455093384,
-0.2791452706,
0.1175004095,
-1.0594030619,
0.4788816571,
0.075175941,
-0.0056036091,
-1.4203652143,
-0.2999791801,
0.2930261791,
-0.8953245878,
-0.1019286588,
-0.4238577783,
-0.5032910109,
-0.2786667943,
-0.1379639357,
0.1658342332,
0.5977461338,
-0.4839010537,
0.4693946242,
0.3914093077,
-0.232224986,
-0.3105994165,
-0.3359466195,
0.0546541736,
-0.1652323306,
-0.8294694424,
-0.0934715569,
-0.1972154826,
-0.0941397846,
-0.0968455002,
0.083716929,
-0.1794779301,
0.0098694088,
0.3893693388,
0.1887088418,
-0.4039122462,
0.1448038071,
-0.5313706994,
-0.0743592009,
0.1946592927,
-0.105827637,
1.0156008005,
-0.4812098145,
-0.5541553497,
-0.0997234583,
0.0005255623,
0.4670493901,
-0.4315719604,
0.6651911736,
0.7798572183,
-0.0385774337,
0.3516289294,
-0.5558326244,
0.038319461,
-0.4734212458,
0.2255121917,
-0.3370608091,
-0.7819084525,
0.6244802475,
0.0260924567,
-0.0211395286,
0.4361873269,
0.4711163938,
-0.0388196371,
1.1309306622,
0.5186215639,
-0.1527168304,
0.3667646348,
-0.1548888534,
0.6056732535,
-0.5798127055,
-0.2725321054,
-0.6571012735,
-0.1534995735,
-1.2470855713,
-0.186863482,
0.2815520465,
-0.2649373412,
-0.2230813056,
0.3426584899,
-0.3560729921,
0.2581985295,
0.7451739907,
0.0530179478,
0.2691959739,
-0.190180406,
0.147583589,
0.3789055645,
-0.5442209244,
-0.6894665956,
0.8365266919,
0.4859997034,
0.5736838579,
0.3612298071,
0.4607105255,
0.3100613952,
0.1227189898,
-1.0160857439,
0.4206943214,
0.0303257853,
-0.6772456765,
-0.3524025381,
-0.3662661314,
-1.1033322811,
0.1110447049,
0.0768095851,
-0.8655785322,
-0.0968837366,
0.1174960062,
-0.2376114875,
0.3129530847,
-1.0912082195,
0.9282069802,
0.0534039438,
0.0718046352,
-0.1025316864,
-0.7068753242,
0.3081348836,
-0.1392874122,
0.0766784325,
-0.0395938717,
0.1990114599,
0.8067787886,
-0.1975582242,
0.698266685,
-0.0333351158,
-0.2090343833,
0.4794958532,
0.1588386297,
0.2431642562,
0.0301726852,
-0.1044682637,
0.1731185615,
0.1618636847,
-0.4438348413,
-0.5653617978,
0.6400901079,
-0.7812245488,
-0.4600639343,
-0.2873695791,
-0.0775099322,
-0.3364735842,
0.3079341054,
0.1889565289,
0.377430439,
-0.3408840895,
-0.0370089374,
0.6991247535,
-0.3585588932,
0.3592421114,
0.5301232338,
-0.2902442515,
0.0953596234,
0.9648145437,
-0.2862052321,
0.2375765443,
0.3780097663,
0.2449722588,
-0.2834717035,
-0.4939592183,
-0.5412610769,
0.3784890771,
-0.494975239,
0.0383253023,
-0.6244059205,
-0.5573526621,
-0.2438085973,
0.2258764654,
-0.343847394,
-0.1175507605,
0.2044018805,
0.035160929,
0.2548748255,
1.0352697372,
0.3376191556,
0.6018823981,
-0.9381902218,
0.2010949999,
0.4934359789,
0.6878819466,
-0.0337425731,
-0.3772985041,
0.0513617992,
0.2461734563,
-0.3730396032,
-1.0605560541,
0.3728715479,
0.1745662391,
0.3833529055,
0.5675963163,
-0.120799154,
0.2864899337,
-0.4397842884,
1.0421361923,
-0.2731180489,
-0.6851118803,
0.5191019177,
-0.5031000376,
0.4079447091,
0.1833013445,
0.6039624214,
-0.8448553085,
-0.4445077479,
-0.800000608,
-0.7011766434,
0.4217785597,
0.3402273655,
0.1321238875,
-0.1563708484,
0.0613138489,
-0.0291136503,
0.0986544043,
-0.5327084661,
0.0922563747,
-0.279520005,
-0.031346824,
0.0868775919,
-0.4141528308,
0.3104029894,
0.4616761208,
0.722707212,
-0.1556686908,
0.5792206526,
0.1582488716,
-0.0575362593,
0.1360279322,
0.3895270824,
0.4307145178,
0.7403141856,
-0.5537917018,
-0.0020933612,
-0.0118223391,
-0.7065615654,
-0.2509750426,
-0.0154208411,
-0.0211664047,
0.0241859201,
0.3506492376,
0.6308306456,
0.0480975211,
-0.8850619197,
0.7518897653,
-0.3977893591,
0.0990337431,
-0.4107472301,
0.1947484165,
0.1039338857,
0.191298455,
0.1551668048,
0.0851619616,
0.4015619159,
-0.5673245192,
0.0999070629,
0.35898453,
-0.6299645305,
-0.3523438573,
0.4409093559,
0.0306983404,
-0.6505489945,
0.9989212155,
-0.1657393873,
-0.8702220321,
0.4985603392,
0.5404231548,
0.7981751561,
-0.1955037415,
0.2350387722,
0.4418170154,
0.2545700371,
0.186029762,
0.1385908276,
0.0876863971,
-0.7561725974,
-0.6598405838,
-0.4879748821,
-0.7036768794,
0.2526527047,
-0.6905884147,
0.1274685264,
-0.0831437111,
-0.1586565375,
0.129056856,
-0.2224314362,
-0.8289343119,
0.2861418128,
0.1678254455,
0.9819802046,
-0.5198761821,
0.5622580647,
0.6834027171,
-0.5396382809,
-0.6974021196,
0.3887946606,
-0.1209034473,
-1.0964428186,
0.5847088695,
0.1843081266,
-0.2726631761,
-0.015502668,
-0.5730429888,
-0.8613062501,
0.7766900659,
-0.0871200562,
-0.5052576661,
-0.2278479636,
0.0685448721,
0.7417762876,
0.2287523448,
0.7574265599,
0.5533715487,
0.4288550317,
0.1832883954,
-1.281978488,
-0.174683556,
-0.310870409,
-0.099543862,
0.1181320995,
-0.635533154,
0.5795229673,
-0.2348804474,
-0.4063923061,
0.2162746191,
0.2776761353,
0.0371689498,
0.281326592,
0.5989430547,
0.3601995409,
0.6227847934,
-0.1133520827,
1.1414148808,
-0.299729377,
0.4255697131,
1.0215291977,
-0.0290442463,
1.059813261,
0.1503076255,
-0.3339934945,
0.3965668976,
0.5801753402,
-0.1138474122,
0.3264610767,
0.1865837574,
-0.0655330271,
0.0297619887,
0.2020959556,
-0.3642750978,
0.7193079591,
0.3289301097,
-0.2203877866,
-0.3113512099,
-0.1821270734,
0.0390735045,
-0.2728941143,
0.0399132185,
1.1170347929,
-0.2747889459,
-0.8257803321,
0.4190881848,
-0.0928719342,
0.4665102661,
-0.6332525611,
-0.1762293279,
-0.2493561506,
0.1153580099,
0.0006967305,
-1.0407525301,
0.3236114979,
0.0650237352,
-0.012901823,
0.1925244629,
0.6709368825,
-0.1187268496,
0.0025116452,
0.2227433473,
0.4646447003,
0.5858060122,
-0.4712260365,
-0.525108397,
-0.1249917522,
0.158529222,
-0.0632297769,
0.2138332874,
0.3951111138,
0.1376931667,
0.9365813136,
0.5843477845,
-0.0025986247,
0.2278968841,
-0.0006857258,
0.8343360424,
-0.5531480908,
-0.4437736571,
-0.5711610913,
0.1810057312,
-0.3194016218,
-0.3954722285,
0.8821818233,
0.7176678777,
0.8142150044,
-0.0862775221,
0.7454501987,
-0.0589426234,
0.8672617674,
-0.4052852988,
0.706030488,
-0.0251495857,
0.1842496991,
-0.3037660122,
-0.8599800467,
0.0033898274,
0.6299033165,
-0.547334373,
0.0510053448,
0.5362445116,
0.7858608961,
-0.0751080364,
0.5433447957,
0.1872706115,
0.1579172611,
0.6280000806,
0.3542863429,
1.0787302256,
-0.4449920654,
0.8758981228,
0.0417040698,
-0.2267104387,
-0.2733334601,
-0.7448124886,
-0.7936301231,
-0.5383973718,
-0.2151466906,
-0.3031701148,
0.210045293,
0.4271068275,
0.5672647953,
-0.8966776133,
0.0663592145,
0.0483789034,
0.0756580755,
-0.0258346945,
-0.304813236,
0.4623990953,
-0.5282828212,
-0.6062030196,
0.1811715662,
0.0038976776,
-0.0084217824,
-0.0930576324,
0.1597955972,
-0.1171326563,
0.112055935,
0.4666971266,
0.2867775261,
-0.582896769,
-0.4955147505,
0.1144324094,
-0.0165528953,
0.2147474438,
0.8157427907,
-0.8879110217,
0.3972611427,
0.5145667195,
0.6061467528,
0.4703105092,
0.229033649,
0.5015845299,
-0.5086331367,
-0.1972046196,
0.2086653411,
0.2420692444,
0.3878051937,
-0.2483026385,
0.6148664951,
-0.103228122,
-0.8224292397,
-0.4346149266,
0.1083912104,
-1.0342111588,
-0.0334362127,
1.2906388044,
-0.2338847369,
-0.2820637524,
-0.1104444414,
-0.6986829638,
0.2168789804,
-0.4350652993,
0.9590683579,
0.5442970395,
-0.0699849203,
-0.054245986,
-0.7930138111,
0.3426766992,
0.175516054,
-0.5180097222,
-0.2086563706,
0.1205609441,
0.3923514783,
0.4418825805,
0.4702505767,
-0.1222413406,
0.0613285601,
-0.0020900201,
-0.0946975648,
0.2034544349,
0.1820515841,
-0.0748661831,
0.30262959,
0.3258811235,
-0.5668674707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03279v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03279v4 | Do the Rewards Justify the Means? Measuring Trade-Offs Between Rewards and Ethical Behavior in the MACHIAVELLI Benchmark | 2023-04-06T17:59:03 | 2023-06-13T01:01:42 | Alexander Pan, Jun Shern Chan, Andy Zou, Nathaniel Li, Steven Basart, Thomas Woodside, Jonathan Ng, Hanlin Zhang, Scott Emmons, Dan Hendrycks | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Artificial agents have traditionally been trained to maximize reward, which
may incentivize power-seeking and deception, analogous to how next-token
prediction in language models (LMs) may incentivize toxicity. So do agents
naturally learn to be Machiavellian? And how do we measure these behaviors in
general-purpose models such as GPT-4? Towards answering these questions, we
introduce MACHIAVELLI, a benchmark of 134 Choose-Your-Own-Adventure games
containing over half a million rich, diverse scenarios that center on social
decision-making. Scenario labeling is automated with LMs, which are more
performant than human annotators. We mathematize dozens of harmful behaviors
and use our annotations to evaluate agents' tendencies to be power-seeking,
cause disutility, and commit ethical violations. We observe some tension
between maximizing reward and behaving ethically. To improve this trade-off, we
investigate LM-based methods to steer agents' towards less harmful behaviors.
Our results show that agents can both act competently and morally, so concrete
progress can currently be made in machine ethics--designing agents that are
Pareto improvements in both safety and capabilities. | [
-0.3854155242,
-0.2013089657,
0.5602978468,
-0.1821804792,
-0.2117645293,
-0.0396602526,
0.0038914375,
-0.5083643198,
0.1830022782,
0.6323205233,
-0.7258300781,
0.0802320391,
-0.6344950199,
0.2185756564,
0.3379740715,
1.2957412004,
0.1887641549,
0.0322995447,
-0.3050415218,
-0.2978025973,
-0.222858876,
-0.6819268465,
-0.9274522662,
-0.5428931117,
0.7311003208,
0.0744283944,
0.8549816012,
0.9273710847,
0.5045455098,
0.4571118355,
0.3598596752,
0.1989537776,
-0.5865157843,
0.2445674241,
-0.3722452819,
-0.3723200262,
-0.1159789786,
0.6984621286,
-0.0000771056,
0.1701389849,
0.0946293399,
0.1631900072,
-0.0948125944,
0.1602840722,
-0.5952557325,
0.1546250433,
-0.4023124576,
0.0701357722,
-0.1604306251,
-0.6907621622,
-0.3177687228,
-0.4494838417,
-0.2531067729,
-0.6201699972,
-0.3590461016,
0.211957112,
0.735768199,
0.4485990703,
-0.4034537673,
-0.6736056805,
-0.4951302707,
1.2226825953,
-0.2458516657,
0.2465792149,
0.7335743308,
0.2500183582,
-0.0081261219,
-0.6074145436,
-0.3179910779,
-0.5636583567,
0.0865093991,
0.0095391227,
-0.2875939608,
0.1535477787,
0.4144838154,
0.1739958674,
-0.2021822035,
0.1426790357,
-0.2318585217,
-0.3706836998,
0.9289683104,
0.2541981637,
0.3292052746,
0.0567889027,
-0.422719717,
-0.5556017756,
-0.674313426,
0.5768264532,
0.774856925,
0.0993629545,
0.4170581698,
0.3552176058,
0.2987186611,
0.1804123372,
0.0508455224,
0.0005787829,
0.1410063356,
-0.1808916926,
-0.1869446635,
0.0257255808,
0.6693898439,
0.8463882208,
0.2336432487,
-0.362180084,
-0.3975463212,
0.0171122346,
0.4798907042,
-0.8681929111,
-0.0247909538,
0.2037107646,
-0.6673596501,
-0.7409353852,
-0.1900494695,
-0.7132713795,
-0.7253097296,
-0.2557889819,
0.560765624,
-0.3228253424,
-0.1384897381,
-0.0332190804,
-0.4100711644,
0.5744383335,
0.014178195,
-0.9281009436,
0.4499594867,
0.8142387271,
0.9489095807,
-0.2798319757,
-0.4618530273,
-1.1699362993,
-0.0475113727,
-0.5785620213,
0.6486982107,
-0.6502940655,
-0.6118490696,
-0.0185956508,
-0.0132101243,
0.1149377078,
-0.4687228203,
1.1299990416,
-0.3799519837,
-0.1315996498,
-1.0196779966,
-0.3691706657,
-0.2704139948,
0.5448055863,
-0.4876825511,
0.7459425926,
-0.1659735143,
-0.4941182435,
0.4961256683,
-0.8468120098,
-0.4376865327,
0.1894908845,
-0.1041668802,
-0.1746630222,
0.0115773026,
-0.2888122201,
0.2370267659,
-0.3704395294,
0.3203878999,
-0.2086337954,
-0.4376660287,
0.5339233875,
-0.5469691753,
0.9625265598,
0.274107486,
-0.6399665475,
0.3311936855,
-0.3063958585,
0.125649631,
0.0431883112,
0.0033543562,
-0.6647141576,
0.3144618571,
-0.0661658943,
0.6618216038,
0.0870483518,
-0.4503328502,
-0.1379010528,
-0.0690017492,
0.4932885766,
1.3319271803,
-0.0158097092,
0.203876853,
-0.9399984479,
0.5891402364,
-0.3281573355,
0.4755747914,
0.478972435,
-0.2084183544,
-0.7025939226,
-0.1926282644,
-0.0543338023,
0.3538900018,
-0.7789487243,
0.1775104254,
-0.0495642237,
-0.4067495167,
-0.3781667054,
-0.2321220785,
0.3839021027,
0.3474585116,
0.2493497729,
-0.3482806087,
-0.1715542674,
-0.7973542809,
-0.5581425428,
-0.3129705191,
-0.0943725407,
0.4598564208,
0.8417285085,
-0.0896109194,
0.4676039815,
0.1034516394,
-0.0392241925,
0.0094978707,
0.1696277559,
-0.1913587153,
0.4684177637,
0.3639987409,
-1.0387377739,
0.2365504354,
-0.1361711025,
-0.6332045794,
-0.0652331784,
-0.0299192667,
-0.3359345496,
-0.2137702554,
0.2257090211,
-0.4038119316,
-0.0172355622,
0.19260934,
-0.486354202,
0.3192813396,
-0.2530591488,
0.7253218889,
-0.4709829092,
0.2153661102,
-0.1886477172,
-0.2967599928,
-0.725671947,
0.1662121266,
-0.1944297105,
0.2810525894,
-0.4623076618,
0.4903795421,
0.0055303266,
-0.0654338151,
-0.2718494534,
-0.0664806515,
-0.1459036618,
0.5197277069,
0.077779904,
0.7476465702,
0.3249961138,
-0.6907293797,
0.3566994667,
-0.2101509422,
0.2208886743,
0.9363638163,
-0.7227422595,
0.3255416453,
-0.0404693559,
-0.0139070163,
-0.4768356681,
-0.1001019031,
0.4885539114,
-0.3063637316,
-0.3499046862,
0.088007614,
-0.2889487743,
-0.2022728771,
-0.861641109,
0.104074344,
0.7121189237,
-0.3935838938,
0.5740149021,
0.6396160722,
-0.0307660904,
-0.552272439,
-0.6218247414,
0.0835758373,
-0.6796441674,
-0.1827285588,
0.3365712464,
-0.4588247538,
-0.5979124308,
-0.1186362505,
0.0698249117,
0.1134229675,
0.2501725256,
0.461355716,
0.1177979931,
0.316322118,
0.1283962727,
0.0593095273,
-0.2983723581,
0.4559340477,
-0.2906035185,
0.350617379,
-0.4355333149,
-0.2757826746,
0.2501025796,
0.3016089499,
0.3747586906,
-0.5340082645,
0.2669987381,
0.1731314063,
-0.4035998285,
0.1180719286,
-0.3568643034,
-0.206746608,
-0.54489851,
-0.0298026633,
-0.1177812591,
-0.759755075,
0.4077014029,
-0.0920178443,
0.4283981323,
0.4920856357,
0.5344183445,
0.3312735558,
1.1468980312,
0.3383681774,
0.0388764776,
0.153585583,
-0.0714157447,
0.0341253802,
-0.4011647701,
-0.2155663967,
-0.4576926231,
-0.2197453231,
-0.9240373373,
-0.469208777,
0.3477179408,
-0.4991862774,
-0.5085844398,
0.0174973235,
-0.6431108117,
0.7859728336,
0.7448620796,
-0.1436167508,
0.4128748178,
-0.481720686,
0.2730713785,
-0.0034153652,
-0.2203737497,
-0.7670563459,
0.8324351311,
0.2383124083,
0.2786698043,
0.1033830121,
0.8444628119,
0.6582702994,
0.4624800384,
-0.7092954516,
0.5959274769,
0.3367698193,
-0.5741413236,
-0.3196247816,
-0.4784525931,
-1.0115890503,
0.3113182187,
0.0923986956,
-0.659676671,
0.1031609625,
-0.1294531524,
-0.3312146962,
0.2483900636,
-0.2150039077,
0.9124284983,
-0.6787642837,
-0.7911043763,
-0.2927908599,
-0.5980963111,
0.2003318071,
0.2790280581,
0.2917686403,
-0.1557423621,
-0.3858296573,
0.959197998,
-0.3620813787,
0.3926215768,
-0.238000989,
0.1681283563,
0.1260344833,
0.2405876666,
0.5365658402,
0.0410624966,
-0.2959669828,
0.0062267692,
0.1541592628,
-0.3565841317,
-0.3292500973,
0.7562229037,
-0.6102204919,
-0.4441472888,
-0.930108726,
-0.5245434642,
-0.2940219939,
0.3375500739,
0.4372957945,
0.2363699973,
-0.1410862207,
-0.0106877033,
0.7709840536,
-0.0174158756,
0.5339730978,
0.3607107997,
0.1138187498,
-0.3059994876,
1.0779505968,
0.1587933153,
0.0500217564,
-0.0029257601,
0.4013862014,
-0.5088797212,
-0.3071584404,
-0.5064828396,
-0.043255195,
-0.6630851626,
-0.1803058684,
-0.3803616464,
0.1374648958,
0.1354427338,
-0.5952225327,
-0.2258716822,
0.1900302023,
0.1757673621,
-0.2724531293,
0.3523920178,
0.8304652572,
-0.3065300286,
-0.1820604801,
-0.2762688696,
-0.3337076604,
0.4295789599,
0.1777400225,
-0.2013510168,
-0.2658344507,
0.1378454268,
0.1366092414,
-0.427680999,
-0.6447066665,
0.3805203438,
-0.2036797702,
0.5901471376,
0.2348278016,
0.2915126085,
0.3839089274,
-0.2816868424,
0.7287358642,
0.0882349163,
-1.029735446,
0.2126543671,
-0.4776518941,
-0.455539763,
0.7339926958,
0.6438778639,
-0.6951847076,
-0.198006928,
-0.7659574747,
-0.3175533414,
0.5618038774,
0.3691283762,
0.2353010774,
-0.1015808135,
0.0966389924,
0.2376491576,
0.4220550358,
-0.8552049994,
-0.1585763395,
-0.2409416288,
-0.072038278,
-0.2802904546,
0.2475939542,
-0.4186077118,
0.0300849788,
0.6935368776,
-0.0589597523,
0.245184347,
0.0226040334,
-0.023871351,
-0.2139587104,
0.1397171021,
0.5670950413,
0.3929166794,
0.014705766,
0.3836211264,
0.0684091747,
-0.2097406834,
0.5219222307,
0.3688682616,
-0.0537519455,
-0.4102699161,
0.1954058558,
0.6616627574,
0.0955562592,
-1.0357211828,
0.5919156075,
-0.0413608178,
-0.1378816813,
0.0085561639,
0.25323838,
-0.2502986193,
0.3945882618,
0.2095170021,
-0.1107135415,
0.77076298,
-0.6465932131,
0.2265564203,
0.6286097765,
-0.3345282972,
-0.0825982839,
0.7188255191,
0.3175621033,
-0.7154862881,
0.3195253909,
-0.6308064461,
-0.4339796007,
0.6455732584,
0.1723279953,
0.892621696,
-0.17848818,
0.5901535749,
-0.0108013069,
0.385795027,
-0.2252195626,
-0.0254190192,
-0.1807774454,
-0.4658989906,
-0.2053821832,
-0.3513787389,
-0.7119766474,
0.1773852408,
-0.5253505111,
-0.0895461589,
-0.248204276,
-0.1617459208,
-0.0034668611,
0.4341918528,
-0.5406807065,
-0.0692783669,
-0.1764362305,
0.3640534282,
-0.8666394353,
0.4147053659,
0.372276634,
-0.6519228816,
-0.6840372682,
0.0152835287,
-0.1225078478,
-0.7861783504,
0.3110802472,
0.3543311954,
-0.4545306563,
-0.1912372261,
-0.5074449778,
-0.5018870234,
0.9231795669,
0.2676806748,
-0.115876615,
0.0508168861,
0.1042753309,
0.4981180429,
-0.2527983785,
0.4209195971,
0.6127274632,
0.6447722912,
0.0220726319,
-0.4759250283,
0.0698644295,
-0.4896907508,
-0.0127417818,
0.3712981343,
-0.6904240251,
0.6396244168,
-0.1171411946,
0.0425587632,
-0.0770826936,
0.1487258524,
0.3520966768,
0.776606679,
0.7604235411,
0.0179752745,
0.898027122,
-0.0729052424,
1.2014030218,
-0.1851176471,
0.3450170457,
0.3155993223,
-0.3438471854,
0.3394689262,
0.5547857285,
-0.0450363159,
0.2698863149,
0.9946388006,
0.123596862,
0.6033085585,
0.3317965567,
-0.0993769243,
-0.5661882758,
-0.3895503581,
-0.0880766883,
0.3473443985,
0.0560182892,
-0.2813196778,
-0.0815275982,
0.1664556563,
0.300103426,
-0.06571915,
-0.4534520507,
0.4131554067,
-0.1771200746,
-1.0137915611,
0.2377301306,
0.0207725558,
0.6316003799,
-0.5965803266,
-0.0374097042,
-0.079594031,
0.0329864323,
0.1224888265,
-0.5766902566,
0.0069389516,
0.0081391679,
0.3617279232,
-0.5752264857,
0.6606740355,
-0.2131085396,
-0.3585801423,
0.1506700963,
0.4554406106,
0.1944717318,
0.2214307785,
-0.8382176161,
0.1736091673,
-0.3294554353,
-0.2725387812,
0.4827571809,
0.2033046037,
-0.1751403958,
0.6125566959,
0.7342990637,
-0.117193155,
-0.3433994651,
-0.3474406898,
0.6441293955,
-0.4159480929,
-0.7334048152,
-1.1208895445,
0.1402263045,
-0.4591754675,
-0.4797720909,
0.7990941405,
0.4611998796,
0.6441238523,
0.2287474871,
0.7064202428,
-0.1533950269,
-0.1025948077,
-0.4454872608,
0.525791049,
-0.5288433433,
-0.0455917679,
-0.1938820183,
-0.4311720431,
0.105160147,
0.7152907252,
-0.5895340443,
0.4831775725,
0.2633916438,
0.7132413387,
0.1876234859,
0.1243971661,
0.4037778974,
-0.3813565671,
0.4933790863,
0.686003089,
1.0838747025,
0.0173925441,
0.3729955256,
-0.1454718262,
-0.5085887909,
-0.1627519429,
-0.9925400019,
-0.7797862887,
-0.7061877251,
-0.0275133681,
-0.3293226957,
0.4500263035,
1.2815887928,
0.6554316878,
-0.4018512964,
-0.375569433,
-0.1364244074,
0.2912994623,
-0.7695526481,
-0.1124184355,
0.0990465954,
-0.2170832902,
-0.7095314264,
0.0749335214,
0.4224265218,
-0.3140006959,
-0.2217654139,
-0.5041619539,
0.1095779017,
0.702416718,
0.5577507019,
0.3283937275,
-0.5068225861,
-0.4239869118,
0.1783693135,
-0.1635908633,
-0.0550626889,
1.1130567789,
-0.3679027557,
0.298007369,
0.1572651565,
0.6462265849,
-0.0160430223,
-0.2078849226,
0.3023548126,
-0.0348600671,
-0.1060349643,
0.6367863417,
0.1708842367,
0.0979853868,
-0.3900713325,
0.5985728502,
0.0434288718,
-0.9155602455,
-0.9538193345,
0.1537887901,
-0.4162113369,
-0.0524485633,
1.0227737427,
-0.075423114,
-0.2300241441,
0.0394329093,
-0.3109439611,
0.0509566776,
-0.3734688163,
0.7424498796,
0.7307790518,
-0.482557863,
0.0456950217,
-0.6660330892,
0.9520002007,
0.2912932336,
-1.0538158417,
0.2143823355,
0.5127894282,
0.0674200356,
0.118634969,
0.7455733418,
0.1254341751,
0.4748753309,
-0.0608508252,
-0.3643608093,
-0.3396192193,
-0.1885017008,
-0.237169981,
-0.0286942292,
0.2466017455,
-0.2774706185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03277v1 | Instruction Tuning with GPT-4 | 2023-04-06T17:58:09 | 2023-04-06T17:58:09 | Baolin Peng, Chunyuan Li, Pengcheng He, Michel Galley, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prior work has shown that finetuning large language models (LLMs) using
machine-generated instruction-following data enables such models to achieve
remarkable zero-shot capabilities on new tasks, and no human-written
instructions are needed. In this paper, we present the first attempt to use
GPT-4 to generate instruction-following data for LLM finetuning. Our early
experiments on instruction-tuned LLaMA models show that the 52K English and
Chinese instruction-following data generated by GPT-4 leads to superior
zero-shot performance on new tasks to the instruction-following data generated
by previous state-of-the-art models. We also collect feedback and comparison
data from GPT-4 to enable a comprehensive evaluation and reward model training.
We make our data generated using GPT-4 as well as our codebase publicly
available. | [
-0.1750306636,
-0.6687924862,
0.6066973805,
-0.137538746,
-0.4114852548,
-0.1747986972,
-0.2236928791,
-0.183857128,
-0.1998159736,
0.4982098043,
-0.780593276,
-0.8176161647,
-0.495618999,
0.129631564,
-0.2095444649,
1.4884630442,
-0.0268520564,
-0.1171431169,
0.3114155531,
0.3585517704,
-0.7354016304,
-0.3339289427,
-0.5859091878,
-0.1770856827,
0.5318356752,
0.7648795843,
0.4449461997,
1.0691361427,
0.4494370222,
0.2330679744,
0.3903905451,
0.1860418171,
-0.7483449578,
-0.1683611721,
0.0800046548,
-0.5179513693,
-0.6552512646,
0.1194823012,
0.6884217858,
0.1180334985,
-0.1313563138,
0.2999971509,
0.0732982978,
0.4470932186,
-0.2543809712,
0.4673984945,
-0.8378551602,
0.0554606915,
-0.4731609821,
-0.7069576979,
-0.3000740409,
-0.6254402399,
-0.1715228111,
-0.7129392028,
0.4642990232,
-0.1956797242,
0.9222198129,
0.4393187463,
-0.2650620639,
-0.2869418263,
-0.4582659602,
0.6883406639,
-0.9254466295,
0.3077173233,
0.5370162129,
0.1385348439,
-0.0132044414,
-0.6384565234,
-0.3627148271,
-0.3627365828,
0.2869422138,
0.1099068373,
0.0473787971,
0.0443946347,
0.3149600029,
0.4079572856,
-0.6023774743,
0.227087751,
-0.5647188425,
-0.1144684181,
0.5200462341,
0.2676666677,
-0.0090652425,
0.1133083105,
-0.2814174294,
0.1894618124,
-1.1439290047,
-0.2270568907,
0.602183938,
0.3126082122,
-0.2939466238,
0.5192506313,
-0.3796644807,
0.8032002449,
0.3290055692,
-0.0291216485,
0.1425633729,
-0.395301193,
-0.2550805509,
0.0127780372,
0.6008325815,
0.5265217423,
0.3744506836,
-0.1647818238,
-0.4303867817,
-0.0709529072,
0.1070774123,
-1.0228353739,
-0.6174903512,
-0.3090565801,
0.0098445099,
-0.3810428679,
-0.1591655612,
-0.3849807978,
-0.0202167239,
-0.4421669245,
0.4950313568,
-0.4617037177,
-0.049796436,
0.1138144955,
0.1440081894,
0.8361101747,
0.1712854058,
-1.4877787828,
0.2145254612,
0.8245984316,
0.889333725,
-0.1286259741,
-0.3287351429,
-0.7929568887,
0.2672199905,
-0.6025400162,
0.7817351818,
-0.5540453792,
-0.1495879591,
-0.095995985,
0.0945094004,
0.1294574589,
-0.5163454413,
0.61769557,
-0.5219967961,
0.0553656667,
-0.2773388028,
-0.8415212631,
-0.1531863362,
0.2638709843,
-0.4657634199,
0.7070473433,
0.1547721773,
-0.333280772,
0.3419064581,
-0.652227819,
-0.5056705475,
0.3337504268,
-0.2407228202,
-0.2836548984,
0.1681272388,
0.2912040055,
0.6016162038,
-0.1484176517,
-0.1580370069,
-0.074226208,
-0.7557752132,
-0.2778507769,
-0.7989744544,
0.3301499784,
-0.029645972,
-0.5233212709,
-0.053645391,
-0.6392970085,
0.1828582287,
0.1201229393,
-0.524492085,
0.1399801075,
-0.2932825387,
-0.5582132339,
-0.0909885988,
0.5531452894,
-0.5280951858,
0.4603090286,
-0.3292558491,
0.4666509032,
0.9961574674,
0.0592308789,
0.1800340265,
-0.247845009,
0.73480618,
-0.3970490396,
-0.1233027205,
-0.5129566789,
-0.5635215044,
-0.6237877011,
0.1052704304,
0.2866342068,
0.6504231691,
-0.7864459157,
-0.0105741611,
-0.0255070254,
-0.3712086976,
-0.6334979534,
0.1570866555,
0.5063610673,
0.4958678484,
0.4004944861,
-0.0322172865,
-0.3938115537,
-0.6836366653,
-0.0348321684,
0.2987938225,
-0.2747314274,
0.3403992951,
0.1622274667,
0.0640758052,
0.3201840818,
-0.7305467129,
-0.0912245661,
-0.0147240069,
0.1270656288,
0.2568470538,
0.4387225509,
0.3145346045,
-0.0411478952,
-0.6306555271,
0.3647534251,
-0.5927714109,
-0.1865416914,
0.183372587,
-0.2468180954,
0.2965324819,
0.2285820097,
-0.4317332804,
0.0962008983,
0.7145711184,
-0.08984337,
0.6709287167,
-0.2029062808,
0.2809523344,
-0.8846386075,
-0.2253430784,
-0.088613458,
-0.3344197869,
-0.6163311601,
0.0212587956,
0.1230195612,
-0.1042873934,
-0.3491106331,
0.1484380364,
-0.5047701001,
-0.1080743596,
-0.3931979239,
-0.0540646091,
-0.1925743222,
0.6809399724,
-0.0276843812,
1.0560891628,
0.5544617772,
-0.5419021249,
0.3439497054,
0.1267113239,
-0.2404166311,
0.2909698486,
-0.6842330694,
0.5260799527,
0.193169713,
-0.1866223514,
-0.6852421165,
-0.40728423,
0.3701077402,
-0.3455790281,
0.5219482183,
-0.4142187238,
-0.3417124152,
-0.2003218681,
-0.2732613683,
0.1369570494,
0.6332218647,
-0.4724534154,
-0.0083155725,
0.0172863007,
-0.3400898576,
-0.4149359167,
-0.6367759109,
-0.0469155498,
-0.1099207774,
-0.2807447016,
0.417627871,
-0.1318700314,
0.4168080688,
-0.2378279567,
-0.1757001281,
-0.0911764577,
-0.154652372,
0.0042062951,
0.4078502655,
-0.4240143895,
-0.182035625,
0.1119667739,
-0.2509946227,
-0.0402409136,
-0.3620213568,
0.5494301915,
-0.2151598036,
-0.3076091409,
-0.9371886849,
-0.0513216816,
-0.0052624843,
-0.3294782341,
0.1599096805,
0.6487109661,
-0.0375604928,
-0.1287905723,
-0.3425660133,
-0.3155063689,
-0.5661836267,
0.3585129678,
-0.321039319,
-1.0198788643,
0.1074680835,
-0.0642874092,
0.4196909666,
0.2570226789,
0.7363106608,
-0.0116407452,
1.0810456276,
0.7819405794,
-0.1246413141,
0.6499378085,
-0.1963831186,
-0.0749017522,
-0.5704696178,
0.1239256486,
-0.2017179877,
-0.2195404917,
-0.7728849053,
-0.4416191876,
0.2536459565,
-0.0877483264,
-0.6404006481,
0.2807064652,
-0.6792066097,
0.9269223809,
0.5791324377,
0.1179111302,
0.3469720483,
-0.062366765,
0.0621338002,
0.2011868358,
-0.5898808837,
-0.6268011928,
1.2558716536,
0.1755017489,
0.820305407,
-0.124793902,
0.8364397883,
-0.0213716235,
0.3007109165,
-0.5937560201,
0.3782643378,
-0.3639330864,
-0.3393243253,
-0.292052418,
-0.4708245099,
-0.7878598571,
-0.0905023366,
0.1771179736,
-0.3762111068,
-0.5626168251,
0.4976512492,
-0.5873801112,
0.1615638286,
-0.8927292228,
0.8539850116,
-0.3644528091,
-0.3136616349,
0.0174570736,
-0.4962901771,
0.6906696558,
-0.0553537644,
-0.2269512564,
-0.3082608283,
-0.0748417079,
0.454914242,
-0.3075822294,
0.7576847672,
-0.2797323763,
-0.4678016901,
0.203965798,
0.0562282987,
0.6278342009,
-0.0797803551,
-0.1823519319,
0.2428648919,
0.0495563745,
-0.2907912135,
-0.4506147504,
1.050034523,
-0.9427283406,
-0.736456275,
-0.0318591669,
-0.6822596788,
-0.1316823214,
0.3831048608,
0.3346650898,
0.4268347025,
0.1450949162,
0.0461706817,
0.4837417603,
-0.0522064045,
0.4136482477,
0.7385436296,
0.048782561,
-0.323895663,
1.0975159407,
0.2058221102,
0.3488910198,
0.2889704406,
0.0672853068,
-0.2618391216,
-0.6316369772,
-0.7905161381,
0.2393018603,
-0.3003269732,
-0.5242726803,
0.0093581062,
-0.2013617605,
-0.0870470032,
-0.1646360308,
-0.4234862924,
-0.2241673321,
-0.3377648592,
-0.2061587572,
0.4788480401,
1.1058474779,
0.1275707334,
0.5303928256,
-0.8339349627,
0.2703614533,
0.3243577778,
0.7090739012,
-0.2262841165,
-0.613332808,
-0.5162116885,
0.1463501453,
-0.7858430743,
-0.7761854529,
0.2852575779,
0.3049322665,
0.3983604014,
0.2978509068,
-0.2961961031,
0.7361198068,
-1.0534274578,
0.7486419082,
-0.1946894974,
-0.9114479423,
0.4972986877,
-0.6842486262,
0.4745334089,
0.1960805804,
0.3028644621,
-0.1562293023,
-0.2561133802,
-0.2827419043,
-0.4368878901,
0.9318528771,
0.1445098817,
0.3221400678,
0.0237497501,
0.7881414294,
0.361933589,
0.2150432765,
-0.6275259852,
-0.102143757,
-0.4037089348,
-0.2886448205,
-0.1094935164,
0.0491510816,
0.0542083755,
-0.2467548996,
0.7122671008,
-0.2822257578,
0.3624505401,
-0.4210200012,
0.0451236852,
-0.2932470143,
0.0656658635,
0.6755120158,
0.4568469524,
-0.1582633406,
-0.0691573247,
0.3871686757,
-0.4092172086,
0.1309448928,
0.2389530838,
-0.2703542411,
-0.2899498045,
0.1297750324,
1.1419546604,
0.3501617014,
-0.3431336582,
0.3439949751,
0.0339429006,
-0.4818154871,
-0.1278063804,
0.4716825485,
0.1681349576,
0.2851501107,
0.0056097242,
-0.3250653148,
0.0753391609,
-0.2706276178,
0.3106434941,
0.5070171952,
-0.1466591805,
-0.5981000066,
0.8067468405,
0.0724817663,
-0.1762838811,
0.6481598616,
-0.2703196704,
-0.1582513005,
0.4320168793,
0.8985870481,
0.5322898626,
-0.4759185016,
0.1656660587,
0.3246089518,
0.3008930981,
0.0168261733,
0.426114738,
-0.0533575527,
-0.5176203847,
-0.7381759286,
-0.5928069353,
-0.5480197072,
0.35788849,
-0.6123669744,
0.520249784,
-0.5563221574,
0.1549456865,
-0.0992404446,
0.2082995176,
-0.7725150585,
-0.0403403006,
0.2721569836,
0.5957494974,
-0.5414930582,
1.0862762928,
0.423635751,
-0.4602207243,
-1.2425746918,
0.1170221269,
0.027220441,
-1.1092374325,
0.3458548188,
0.4216804802,
-0.2426151633,
0.7063174844,
-0.6995984316,
-0.9128112197,
1.4370933771,
0.734995544,
-0.8357029557,
-0.0038936981,
0.1410578638,
0.2897139192,
-0.146551773,
0.1021563038,
0.8678351045,
0.2718449235,
0.2766514421,
-0.8605233431,
-0.0537989438,
-0.0333819613,
-0.1994037777,
0.358240664,
-0.6613897085,
1.0493165255,
-0.2382117808,
-0.1204265356,
0.2601190507,
0.5038427114,
0.2765865922,
0.0319511183,
0.0806397423,
0.5704697967,
0.7793523669,
0.0467079431,
0.9941101074,
-0.5368254185,
0.2938227654,
1.1864714622,
-0.3854436576,
0.8994874954,
-0.1302609444,
0.0252924338,
0.4817633927,
0.6685373783,
-0.241966337,
0.7215181589,
0.1427697837,
-0.2953739166,
0.0847831219,
0.2840150595,
-0.4279739559,
0.4371285141,
0.280223906,
-0.1328112185,
-0.2086607367,
-0.2401161194,
0.1085273176,
-0.3780216277,
-0.5837731361,
0.9419804215,
-0.0268581565,
-0.6165823936,
1.1388292313,
0.1120564714,
0.6922206283,
-0.6105430722,
-0.4204705656,
-0.4095089734,
0.0814451799,
-0.1616762877,
-0.9454105496,
0.1343901157,
0.4341374934,
-0.0147074545,
-0.0672849864,
0.488457948,
-0.5628677011,
-0.2989537418,
-0.2145617604,
0.2591130733,
0.4706157744,
0.0875984952,
-0.4744419158,
-0.034933608,
0.3069668412,
-0.2049978673,
0.3625101447,
0.657309413,
-0.0015251666,
0.37851879,
0.6531349421,
-0.0369289257,
0.3003798723,
0.1004071757,
0.9264476895,
-0.7838445902,
-0.2849663794,
-0.9910532832,
0.2470566481,
0.3738787174,
-0.3345857561,
0.684961915,
0.5011560321,
1.028989315,
-0.1027816087,
0.9452744722,
0.2484498173,
0.5020215511,
-0.73570925,
0.4417845905,
-0.289850235,
0.2159421444,
-0.0695355684,
-0.8866202831,
-0.3049550056,
0.5843137503,
-0.4244618416,
0.1948232502,
0.3579090536,
1.0467612743,
-0.2296094596,
0.0847325623,
0.4888533354,
0.2106896937,
0.3163936138,
0.7675344348,
0.5935789347,
-0.2995893657,
0.6653241515,
-0.2339280248,
-0.3242582381,
-0.0830177888,
-0.9411187768,
-0.7190757394,
-0.1427597404,
0.0501692109,
0.3397046626,
0.1546433121,
0.7294232845,
0.6667864323,
-0.7749654651,
-0.1548039615,
-0.298582375,
-0.2509481013,
-0.2589914203,
-0.1543272883,
0.3539808393,
-0.6066535115,
-0.7840572596,
0.6297485232,
0.2449028641,
0.0950209126,
-0.1886133403,
-0.3434524834,
0.0636715591,
0.1038422883,
0.62770015,
0.2332125455,
-0.6133385897,
-0.4106174707,
0.047085613,
0.0883878693,
0.151361689,
0.5068463087,
-0.5461053252,
0.1546973735,
0.0177955963,
0.669849813,
0.7026051283,
0.142171219,
0.7712510228,
-0.9451913834,
-0.1831665039,
0.0247475766,
0.1057224348,
0.3735854924,
-0.5137822032,
0.4901827276,
-0.0959143862,
-1.0154707432,
-0.4483832121,
0.173999697,
-0.5737495422,
0.2764025629,
1.0252197981,
-0.1834103763,
0.1374236941,
0.2910442054,
-0.3420804143,
0.5032262802,
-0.4479621649,
0.6476676464,
0.5179475546,
-0.4036393464,
-0.4920540452,
-1.1353341341,
0.5593430996,
0.2477312088,
-0.8858428597,
0.1277451664,
0.6012064219,
0.5902732611,
-0.5523924828,
0.6629377604,
0.0391830616,
0.4210603833,
-0.0592046715,
0.0248207729,
-0.373748064,
-0.2218451947,
-0.4219028652,
-0.0017568367,
0.3816180229,
-0.4636695683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03245v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03245v3 | Large language models effectively leverage document-level context for literary translation, but critical errors persist | 2023-04-06T17:27:45 | 2023-05-22T22:00:51 | Marzena Karpinska, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are competitive with the state of the art on a
wide range of sentence-level translation datasets. However, their ability to
translate paragraphs and documents remains unexplored because evaluation in
these settings is costly and difficult. We show through a rigorous human
evaluation that asking the Gpt-3.5 (text-davinci-003) LLM to translate an
entire literary paragraph (e.g., from a novel) at once results in
higher-quality translations than standard sentence-by-sentence translation
across 18 linguistically-diverse language pairs (e.g., translating into and out
of Japanese, Polish, and English). Our evaluation, which took approximately 350
hours of effort for annotation and analysis, is conducted by hiring translators
fluent in both the source and target language and asking them to provide both
span-level error annotations as well as preference judgments of which system's
translations are better. We observe that discourse-level LLM translators commit
fewer mistranslations, grammar errors, and stylistic inconsistencies than
sentence-level approaches. With that said, critical errors still abound,
including occasional content omissions, and a human translator's intervention
remains necessary to ensure that the author's voice remains intact. We publicly
release our dataset and error annotations to spur future research on evaluation
of document-level literary translation. | [
0.081492424,
-0.5306547284,
0.8647226095,
0.4621697664,
-0.2662921846,
0.0015989562,
-0.3698826134,
-0.4956589043,
-0.432379365,
0.5658150315,
-0.3534247279,
-0.3520525992,
-0.7203364372,
0.2275493294,
-0.7603760362,
1.0438104868,
-0.2942498028,
0.0288525932,
0.0185863469,
0.0461681671,
-0.1380860955,
-0.3246051073,
-0.4752838314,
-0.2269892544,
0.7608609796,
-0.0659351498,
0.8922088742,
0.4985109568,
0.6558368802,
0.2621771395,
-0.227364704,
0.4005945623,
-0.450776726,
0.0086808139,
-0.2746712863,
-0.3598912656,
-0.4938897192,
0.0646552145,
0.8782635927,
0.8098810911,
0.0747027174,
-0.0406733714,
0.2500303686,
0.6646062732,
-0.3448812366,
0.2071204782,
-0.4741362631,
0.0629743412,
-0.4327605963,
-0.2411817014,
-0.7594442368,
-0.5367181897,
0.081628561,
-0.7708420157,
0.056743715,
0.0557905473,
0.9005977511,
0.1596220434,
-0.5877199769,
-0.1869033426,
-0.9698095322,
0.7308202386,
-0.7866361737,
-0.0917563513,
0.1569484472,
0.0025865519,
-0.5113863349,
-0.547560811,
-0.6411353946,
-0.2085702121,
-0.1340961158,
0.169625923,
-0.1361068189,
0.1828082949,
0.2945239246,
0.4644447565,
-0.438057512,
0.1276349872,
-0.3281315863,
-0.0502880998,
0.5493394136,
0.2296197116,
0.6377677321,
-0.3797541857,
-0.2584245205,
-0.1941754669,
-0.6434510946,
-0.1305078864,
0.1745027304,
0.2143587321,
-0.0056708576,
0.4532087147,
0.0640865415,
0.5554834008,
-0.2532971799,
-0.0932488143,
0.231995225,
-0.4754026234,
-0.0053249188,
-0.2795271575,
1.0101931095,
0.6477310658,
0.4354800582,
-0.309835732,
-0.3600956798,
-0.0703815371,
0.3216800094,
-0.6716290116,
0.1136663854,
0.1347029656,
-0.0875417069,
-0.1276933998,
-0.0244170446,
-0.5816634297,
-0.5596488118,
-0.1043817699,
0.2830577493,
-0.3883012533,
0.0707716569,
0.2182386518,
0.0116121173,
0.2327170968,
0.7373549342,
-0.6369236112,
0.1017508283,
0.5311536193,
0.9670811296,
-0.2525548339,
-0.5445187688,
-0.5076398849,
0.3004089296,
-0.9714733958,
0.7466769218,
-0.1713943183,
-0.1591775715,
0.2496415377,
-0.0065438231,
-0.3159046471,
-0.3231445253,
1.0556809902,
-0.4706665874,
0.1000837535,
-0.4681112468,
-0.4607645273,
-0.049793534,
-0.0004737994,
-0.641955018,
0.7798323631,
0.2042354643,
-0.6230353713,
0.2566684484,
-0.4366167784,
-0.4238197207,
0.1387946308,
-0.141645208,
-0.0317712314,
0.5298253894,
0.3690965176,
0.6133760214,
-0.6651910543,
0.3213177919,
-0.0822116807,
-0.5371437073,
0.5283585191,
-0.4528891444,
0.6039147973,
0.2562853396,
-0.4246788621,
-0.0278689321,
-0.4772323966,
-0.2284439802,
0.2435551137,
-0.3568983972,
-0.3147054315,
-0.0213446114,
0.4298582673,
0.1788693815,
0.0778920352,
-0.5451875925,
0.2012419999,
-0.3835014403,
0.6590889096,
0.6258591413,
-0.1147543192,
0.4643602967,
-0.3418751955,
0.566439569,
-0.1796095818,
-0.1149348021,
-0.3481612802,
-0.3502675891,
-0.5697401166,
-0.2108181417,
0.2713367939,
0.5168591142,
-0.7642621994,
0.423753947,
-0.5503578782,
-0.5322842598,
-0.5049476624,
0.1681005508,
0.3475559652,
0.3376685381,
0.1679462343,
0.0573612638,
0.0959434584,
-0.7065711617,
-0.4045458138,
-0.3726004362,
0.0446844883,
-0.0832529068,
0.327963382,
-0.2415149808,
0.6699514985,
-0.2016282976,
-0.421241343,
-0.3088515401,
0.2667526901,
0.2269751281,
0.4010713995,
0.6089901924,
-0.5981050134,
-0.395342797,
0.3520942926,
-0.83430022,
-0.3768924475,
-0.5727436543,
-0.1306592524,
0.1684620082,
0.445954442,
-0.6634654999,
0.2824935615,
0.5801931024,
-0.2318181396,
0.4107205272,
-0.5469216108,
0.504650712,
-1.0132683516,
0.1791361868,
0.0411778614,
-0.2210855037,
-0.382856667,
0.2743678391,
0.3820655644,
0.1014691666,
-0.2882306874,
0.5381838679,
-0.4642827809,
0.0450567454,
-0.0527762026,
0.6124897599,
0.3107001781,
0.1784011722,
-0.2975851595,
0.8327506185,
0.0231883992,
-0.1671079546,
0.318993628,
0.3491828144,
-0.6227660179,
0.7238305211,
-0.5088142753,
0.1561015099,
-0.1201869994,
0.4656173587,
-1.2116347551,
-0.5510994196,
0.1422728002,
-0.1720308661,
0.4090940356,
-0.0016683319,
-0.6930040717,
-0.1161820516,
-0.1111124307,
0.2958862484,
0.3267817199,
-0.4180505276,
0.4885876179,
0.0827367082,
-0.4017217457,
-0.5288267732,
-0.9676606655,
0.5463135839,
-0.0637800023,
-0.6929385662,
0.1195932254,
-0.0371290967,
-0.2121916413,
0.0188677553,
0.0318703502,
-0.0656558275,
0.1445031762,
-0.0074596829,
0.396163553,
-0.0237599593,
0.0554668717,
0.2746272981,
0.0268219877,
0.0723484159,
-0.2462169528,
0.1474427879,
-0.1427366138,
-0.378456682,
-0.5217261314,
0.4432258606,
0.9695445299,
-0.1414105743,
0.6026211381,
0.5124918818,
-0.4269635379,
-0.1811212599,
-0.6743207574,
0.3383853137,
-0.3483396471,
0.5277353525,
-0.4696680009,
-0.758310616,
0.5834178329,
0.1371182799,
0.112625286,
0.8030344844,
0.413087368,
-0.1301435679,
0.6973465085,
0.2132908553,
-0.0388042368,
0.3499980271,
-0.0763039663,
0.1872818321,
-0.9560823441,
0.1134449244,
-0.6489517689,
-0.1227474287,
-0.3717525303,
-0.567946732,
0.5053777695,
0.1184004471,
0.1081130281,
0.2971406281,
-0.2082010955,
0.3972946703,
0.1002311185,
-0.1096522659,
0.6313955784,
0.2066042423,
-0.1826286614,
-0.3444549143,
-0.4208910763,
-0.9855197668,
1.0451612473,
0.5187416673,
0.7676338553,
0.1957275718,
0.4733234048,
0.2112797797,
0.4039326012,
-0.7089425921,
0.4335173666,
-0.3385850489,
-0.7143961787,
-0.5049893856,
-0.5713493824,
-0.7975210547,
0.4607670903,
-0.074938491,
-0.6322031617,
0.3202393651,
-0.1142162457,
-0.4132111073,
0.327093333,
-0.5985952616,
1.0821000338,
-0.2388891131,
-0.3865869343,
-0.2548071742,
-0.488494575,
0.1664453149,
-0.5031106472,
0.4631465673,
-0.1418634802,
-0.320325911,
0.6046926975,
-0.0653458908,
0.6268384457,
0.1163800806,
-0.5181228518,
0.1809664369,
0.3887235224,
0.5994694233,
-0.2006770819,
-0.2445047796,
0.0861940011,
0.2447894514,
-0.4997853339,
-0.6252222061,
0.5869742632,
-0.9398435354,
-0.486086458,
-0.6710163355,
-0.7349985838,
-0.2336366475,
0.2005288303,
0.2364158779,
0.4452875555,
-0.3914803267,
0.3676118255,
0.4766438305,
-0.1864125282,
0.3986943662,
0.4381344616,
-0.1614923626,
-0.4621888697,
0.7076716423,
0.2505026758,
0.5201377273,
0.3343643844,
0.150933072,
-0.2257899344,
-0.9410442114,
-0.8934838772,
0.3337781727,
-0.8035254478,
0.127476424,
-0.6837418675,
-0.1403500736,
-0.1529012322,
-0.2402537763,
-0.3669742346,
-0.1946223676,
-0.2478717268,
-0.0956858769,
-0.0121759195,
0.7997255921,
0.0928700864,
0.2405012846,
-1.029797554,
0.0554308705,
-0.0613312535,
-0.0006858843,
-0.1872965544,
-0.8784803748,
-0.3911927938,
-0.1243917197,
-0.1197806448,
-0.7851500511,
0.294231087,
0.1050442457,
0.2467114031,
-0.0082595013,
0.1349166334,
0.6989182234,
-0.7045414448,
0.7936552763,
0.0802875385,
-1.0077983141,
0.2043752819,
-0.9239866138,
0.3259581625,
0.654724896,
0.2611670494,
-0.8306926489,
-0.6189165115,
-0.199608475,
-0.9351020455,
0.769310236,
0.2389073968,
0.3346822262,
-0.1594810188,
0.5768978,
-0.1681880355,
0.0629272163,
-0.8271504641,
0.3030296266,
0.3102232814,
-0.2536630929,
-0.4632713497,
-0.2778591812,
-0.1867246628,
0.0264920108,
0.4768460393,
-0.2226507217,
-0.129107058,
0.5654428601,
-0.3846389651,
-0.3918884397,
0.5038123131,
0.5637180209,
0.8976021409,
-0.1473362893,
-0.1120737195,
-0.0095097506,
-0.3633138835,
0.3137990236,
0.1023186594,
-0.2479637116,
-0.0582141615,
0.6523386836,
0.4878933132,
0.1973261684,
-0.6254597306,
0.7725458741,
0.0188363343,
0.0008997952,
-0.430557698,
-0.2356554121,
0.1675134748,
0.3257632852,
0.4876892567,
-0.0159891825,
0.110267736,
-0.5126491785,
-0.1920621246,
0.083641462,
-0.3418076336,
-0.1131358221,
0.6457749009,
0.4415217936,
0.1189593002,
0.4034429193,
-0.2412972748,
-0.3158424497,
0.2550891042,
0.3424434662,
1.0369132757,
-0.029854333,
0.2868735194,
0.1620584875,
0.7286297679,
-0.5636359453,
-0.2665840685,
0.3386491835,
-0.5286136866,
-0.7864609957,
-0.5886939168,
-0.5287858844,
0.0341997258,
-0.5283927917,
0.1107501686,
-0.3525612354,
-0.056136407,
-0.2340347916,
-0.2460464984,
-0.4481019974,
0.027827939,
0.1874677241,
0.6746397614,
-0.9379317164,
0.7242078781,
0.6094862223,
-0.5450441241,
-0.6063560843,
0.1768924445,
-0.067435503,
-0.3795644641,
0.5903322101,
-0.1208610758,
-0.15942581,
-0.0483183376,
-0.2028579414,
-0.6847859025,
0.9067208171,
0.7864611745,
-0.9043540359,
-0.3388903737,
0.0803821981,
0.7833350301,
-0.356569171,
0.2706014514,
0.520539403,
0.4433035254,
0.0021885962,
-1.2346434593,
0.256699115,
-0.0929891244,
0.3222546279,
0.0125263026,
-0.705091238,
0.74868083,
0.0772553831,
-0.2788583636,
0.3498858213,
0.6099008322,
-0.232282564,
0.0474583432,
0.3925042152,
0.3805817664,
0.8568850756,
-0.2331344485,
1.2901418209,
-0.1748089045,
0.2364807129,
1.0123710632,
-0.3171072602,
0.9630593061,
0.4152963459,
-0.1780073643,
0.38011536,
0.5923586488,
0.0642559901,
0.1361190677,
0.2266344428,
-0.3173071742,
-0.3279037774,
-0.0276156738,
-0.3215311766,
0.0289425533,
0.2888436913,
-0.4393020272,
-0.084577471,
0.0179097839,
0.190355137,
0.4297631979,
-0.0572213978,
0.6069364548,
0.2750582099,
-0.8579062819,
0.5476299524,
0.1436451524,
0.3922632933,
-0.5078987479,
0.2211862653,
-0.3371124864,
0.3486684561,
-0.2823120058,
-0.6885552406,
0.2042748481,
0.1990785301,
-0.1249338314,
-0.368029952,
0.3086298406,
-0.3457184434,
-0.5915793777,
0.5035072565,
0.4188992381,
0.2997813523,
-0.2435207963,
-0.4550572932,
0.3894410729,
-0.0760146976,
-0.3382091522,
0.2271077931,
0.7439200878,
-0.0220510587,
0.4269481301,
0.4077711999,
0.3732693493,
-0.042872481,
0.0283710863,
0.6951448321,
-0.7187318206,
-0.3195178509,
-0.702154696,
0.6493263245,
-0.0939430743,
-0.3946310878,
0.6329276562,
0.2775197923,
0.8646842837,
-0.0187032223,
0.9655618668,
0.1933111399,
0.3093456328,
-0.5211243033,
0.7427369356,
-0.5797463059,
0.3490167856,
-0.6300461888,
-1.2172797918,
-0.3682527542,
0.7231457829,
-0.506326735,
-0.1379014254,
1.1223700047,
0.5935852528,
0.2403219044,
-0.1339442283,
0.53284657,
0.3717919588,
0.5540562868,
0.5955212712,
0.9287107587,
-0.6320736408,
0.6909996271,
0.3574952483,
-0.4641091526,
-0.1592982113,
-0.9785639048,
-0.85245049,
-0.3778140247,
-0.4843561947,
-0.5249180198,
0.0417808779,
0.9274371266,
0.266990751,
-0.5582928061,
-0.3828190267,
0.157332927,
-0.1311367601,
-0.0245736968,
-0.0986940414,
0.3004404306,
-0.6564776301,
-1.0942307711,
0.3969282508,
0.3999167681,
-0.1122313291,
-0.4665256739,
0.0650358573,
-0.0172333233,
0.2378289402,
0.5317252278,
-0.1069389358,
-0.9392933249,
-0.3846358061,
-0.2897613049,
-0.6488863826,
-0.0190124884,
0.64035815,
0.0170652736,
0.6534511447,
0.5428352356,
0.9676053524,
0.5650054812,
-0.2651975155,
0.8613440394,
-0.1994925439,
-0.0663674623,
0.1042324156,
0.4776835144,
0.5736065507,
-0.2094725519,
0.5554581285,
0.4420055449,
-0.6479161382,
-0.8113427162,
-0.1115292534,
-1.0656329393,
-0.0970542356,
1.3684799671,
-0.597111702,
-0.3640218973,
0.030135816,
-0.379801333,
0.0834122598,
-0.3017312884,
0.5869149566,
1.358823061,
0.2870019972,
0.0591598675,
-0.955080092,
0.4140430391,
0.5513871908,
-0.6813955307,
0.2264532149,
0.7870985866,
0.0741434842,
0.2816071808,
0.53621912,
-0.4550269544,
0.2530091703,
-0.1070936993,
0.0246736594,
0.2040241063,
-0.2284552306,
-0.5219864845,
0.1207484305,
0.5459458232,
0.2187964618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03216v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03216v3 | On the Pareto Front of Multilingual Neural Machine Translation | 2023-04-06T16:49:19 | 2023-10-31T15:58:53 | Liang Chen, Shuming Ma, Dongdong Zhang, Furu Wei, Baobao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we study how the performance of a given direction changes with
its sampling ratio in Multilingual Neural Machine Translation (MNMT). By
training over 200 multilingual models with various model sizes, data sizes, and
language directions, we find it interesting that the performance of certain
translation direction does not always improve with the increase of its weight
in the multi-task optimization objective. Accordingly, scalarization method
leads to a multitask trade-off front that deviates from the traditional Pareto
front when there exists data imbalance in the training corpus, which poses a
great challenge to improve the overall performance of all directions. Based on
our observations, we propose the Double Power Law to predict the unique
performance trade-off front in MNMT, which is robust across various languages,
data adequacy, and the number of tasks. Finally, we formulate the sample ratio
selection problem in MNMT as an optimization problem based on the Double Power
Law. In our experiments, it achieves better performance than temperature
searching and gradient manipulation methods with only 1/5 to 1/2 of the total
training budget. We release the code at
https://github.com/pkunlp-icler/ParetoMNMT for reproduction. | [
-0.3737699389,
-0.2949682474,
0.4464087784,
0.6814209223,
-0.5464718938,
-0.1209020615,
-0.4890077114,
-0.0127174109,
0.2227865458,
0.685385406,
-0.3895949125,
-0.1206704602,
-0.8536931872,
0.0932371169,
-0.3978537917,
0.9613938332,
-0.002271913,
0.6326732635,
-0.3181420863,
-0.2480968088,
-0.3972532749,
-0.8429532051,
-0.8246554136,
-0.5888335109,
0.831148088,
0.4032682776,
0.6318278909,
0.8572297096,
0.7149490118,
0.3012397289,
-0.0003449899,
0.0157606341,
0.0267301705,
0.0522283465,
-0.1792764962,
-0.7393698692,
-0.4133082628,
0.2035745382,
0.7529264092,
0.4862159789,
-0.3249034882,
-0.0735690221,
-0.0293825772,
0.8326442838,
-0.3341472149,
0.1129719093,
-0.6936928034,
0.2179492414,
-0.4187743962,
-0.4543649256,
-0.3896469772,
0.0750005841,
-0.2381702363,
-0.4784258604,
0.276404798,
0.0607051291,
0.6005803943,
0.2901603878,
-0.6134915948,
-0.1567727774,
-0.2561152279,
1.0377616882,
-0.535588026,
0.5605653524,
0.3611556888,
0.4822825193,
-0.0073405732,
-0.5349966884,
-0.485938251,
-0.083891727,
0.1255470365,
0.0232045762,
-0.2408938706,
-0.1945814788,
-0.025311932,
0.2330985069,
-0.3674594164,
-0.0037188793,
-0.4409248233,
-0.0160288736,
0.621933639,
0.1154417396,
0.3133724332,
-0.0253782701,
-0.6492584944,
-0.3673477173,
-0.4015958309,
0.1404206753,
0.5647181273,
0.540116787,
-0.0803222954,
0.4670458138,
0.0740299076,
0.7215342522,
-0.0324967876,
0.1620769501,
0.4582083225,
-0.5210155249,
-0.0435931683,
-0.003178891,
0.9248796701,
0.5933496952,
0.0689212009,
-0.2560286224,
-0.2827012837,
-0.5009151101,
0.5848456621,
-0.7691144347,
-0.0194346383,
0.1555467993,
-0.3531478345,
-0.0654881299,
-0.1321582794,
-0.8733856678,
-0.2324022651,
-0.6066668034,
0.4136075377,
-0.4247866273,
-0.2243012488,
0.068135038,
-0.108197622,
-0.0193685256,
-0.1681627035,
-0.7521976233,
0.218009606,
0.6148455143,
1.0435006618,
-0.0310266782,
-0.9130894542,
-0.5048748255,
-0.2329851389,
-0.3871693313,
0.4121878147,
-0.0310026482,
-0.0863776803,
-0.3663500547,
-0.03541255,
-0.5349774957,
-0.4336670339,
0.4120587707,
-0.5829381347,
0.0676228032,
-0.4341437817,
0.0510933772,
-0.1208098084,
0.1245199367,
-0.6726064086,
0.6517844796,
-0.3836796582,
-0.7529152036,
0.2653687298,
-0.5290468931,
-0.7635159492,
-0.4476576746,
0.0701828599,
-0.723362565,
0.2864357233,
0.1255348176,
0.492169559,
-0.3613395691,
0.3583053946,
-0.0866665095,
-0.241330266,
0.5763600469,
-0.3337127864,
0.9978861809,
0.5268886685,
-0.2639850676,
0.2710952163,
-0.6811430454,
-0.1096614823,
0.1952017993,
-0.4476568997,
-0.288744092,
0.0207464844,
-0.1164750457,
0.7535852194,
0.2215493917,
-0.4082649946,
-0.0588606261,
-0.2838724256,
0.638020575,
0.6844028831,
-0.3025360107,
0.654861331,
-0.1167273819,
0.4942565858,
0.3349661529,
0.1344621032,
0.2667339444,
-0.4690080285,
-0.6099110246,
-0.1557976007,
0.4266731441,
0.658924818,
-1.0767093897,
0.0254114103,
-0.2160757035,
-0.2081715912,
-0.6440911889,
0.1354159266,
0.5919168591,
0.2518992126,
0.4911854565,
-0.0617077351,
-0.6510744691,
-1.2025542259,
-0.4979231358,
0.2714740336,
0.1028640717,
-0.0810728744,
0.1455263197,
0.1927636862,
0.4721319973,
-0.1027457863,
-0.1347751319,
-0.3798037171,
0.0490909889,
0.5800247788,
0.5198906064,
0.5971599817,
-1.1238611937,
-0.4833712876,
0.3103569448,
-0.4993059635,
-0.1855725944,
-0.1400767416,
-0.4107167423,
0.0294745732,
0.4349436462,
-0.5938745141,
-0.1205054149,
0.7750886083,
-0.1833168417,
0.0208484326,
-0.4807255566,
0.2484957725,
-1.4193445444,
0.2321598381,
0.0203180909,
-0.0090701366,
-0.7221922874,
0.4870815277,
0.5189017653,
-0.0940043256,
-0.5634824038,
0.3160934746,
-0.3037526906,
-0.0025234201,
-0.3846852481,
-0.2845135629,
-0.0404938981,
0.6009027362,
-0.1824210733,
0.946823597,
0.2627283633,
-0.6386104226,
0.3397163749,
-0.0240095817,
0.1159015521,
0.5989016294,
-0.2744528949,
0.1029322371,
-0.1623085588,
-0.0402745306,
-0.8078551292,
0.0878569707,
0.1922181845,
-0.589200139,
0.5723568797,
-0.0492439792,
-0.5682017207,
-0.3870388567,
-0.1097422317,
0.3416658938,
0.3324402571,
-0.4655690789,
0.3614868224,
0.2957794964,
-0.1060770527,
-0.7491775155,
-0.9243614674,
0.2028333843,
-0.3419722021,
-0.4432931244,
0.2968030274,
0.0125494367,
-0.2298458517,
-0.4519943595,
-0.0780321062,
-0.2946245074,
-0.1581428796,
-0.0874089375,
-0.019919917,
0.0580588803,
-0.0486645922,
0.1460526735,
-0.3033118546,
0.1985597014,
-0.5422022343,
0.6596198082,
0.0553393923,
-0.0343628749,
-0.1508082002,
0.4180179834,
0.7373090386,
-0.329005599,
0.9163833857,
0.7991317511,
-0.085218288,
0.2663842142,
-0.3874176741,
-0.0188484155,
-0.3495475352,
0.5367598534,
-0.8455823064,
-0.0592177324,
0.5550429225,
0.4968093932,
0.0737994164,
0.554731369,
0.7970625758,
0.2657905519,
1.1185914278,
0.415738821,
0.144759059,
0.4720442295,
-0.1643408835,
0.204779163,
-0.7194598913,
-0.3403958082,
-0.6661449075,
-0.4998689592,
-0.6050704122,
-0.3327814043,
0.4528297484,
0.1493938714,
-0.0091571193,
0.5983320475,
-0.32242468,
0.371886611,
0.985155642,
0.3910083175,
0.197106272,
0.2492668778,
-0.2354583144,
-0.4260535836,
-0.8589653969,
-0.0061021335,
1.2117202282,
0.1711192429,
0.0445877612,
0.0885091946,
0.7183527946,
-0.2205771059,
0.0467339829,
-0.6254515052,
0.4461227953,
-0.5252600312,
-0.4872903824,
-0.054504972,
-0.9982376099,
-0.9358468056,
0.8153550625,
0.1775425524,
0.0862789601,
0.0197417587,
0.077884376,
-0.1547298729,
0.5266433954,
-0.5940212011,
0.941501081,
-0.4295991361,
-0.411252588,
-0.3338650465,
-0.8912113309,
0.0715118721,
-0.2704616487,
0.4445025325,
-0.1469691098,
-0.1653903872,
0.6517686248,
-0.2770484686,
0.3429560959,
-0.2842898071,
0.0302406345,
-0.0624358989,
-0.2098809034,
0.322196424,
-0.1304703355,
-0.2979602814,
0.6130263209,
-0.1639805138,
-0.7435187101,
-0.3687076569,
0.6493281126,
-0.7103847265,
-0.3795984387,
-0.3255447447,
-0.9039023519,
-0.2636783719,
0.4898533523,
0.7732561827,
-0.0487069972,
0.2324835211,
0.3281512558,
0.4293630719,
-0.2288775891,
0.4410181642,
0.3518269956,
-0.2244514823,
-0.7146686912,
1.1060829163,
0.3137769401,
0.391297996,
0.6321445704,
0.4322001636,
-0.3483617902,
-0.6137238145,
-0.9300528169,
-0.1672909409,
-0.388954103,
-0.1798300147,
-0.817710638,
-0.0116440058,
-0.3184399605,
0.1070431098,
-0.6681464911,
-0.407677263,
0.1235184819,
0.3433870971,
0.0447297394,
0.1395303905,
-0.3858972192,
0.3083952665,
-0.4498480558,
0.2045089155,
0.1121853814,
0.1601315737,
-0.2566353977,
-0.4274845123,
-0.5372285247,
0.3323071003,
-0.3811860979,
-0.7310156822,
0.6269786358,
-0.188075006,
0.4752206802,
-0.1183424667,
-0.2872887254,
0.42455405,
-0.7265030146,
0.3121004999,
0.7184618711,
-0.7502792478,
-0.0526162609,
-0.2700164318,
0.295833528,
0.2471335679,
0.1576586068,
-0.4465683401,
-0.1574103832,
-0.4007840455,
-0.9623249173,
0.7473579049,
0.3488873541,
0.2877874374,
0.2400080115,
0.0096798576,
0.1300251931,
0.8003098965,
-0.5470808744,
-0.1932103187,
-0.5127925873,
0.0185046662,
-0.4192680717,
0.0959370285,
-0.0343631804,
-0.3408676684,
0.6295056939,
0.0137894843,
0.4212119579,
-0.1643394828,
0.2912773192,
-0.1706809998,
0.3766319454,
0.7597127557,
0.578540504,
-0.0939937606,
0.2120709866,
0.0973622724,
-0.4471554756,
0.1121214628,
0.4150416851,
-0.0468737036,
0.1146911606,
-0.0052312394,
0.8693766594,
0.3314574063,
-0.2281343043,
0.474997133,
0.1358067542,
-0.2198123038,
0.0674954131,
-0.2588304877,
0.05998246,
0.2990137637,
0.3687489033,
0.3623702526,
0.0788418427,
-0.2839876711,
0.1216604114,
0.2915267944,
0.0582323372,
-0.2144454718,
0.7734217048,
-0.0935825855,
-0.3622211814,
0.5485107899,
-0.2792963386,
-0.5850596428,
0.7148171663,
0.5548425317,
0.74592489,
-0.4045665264,
-0.0438240729,
0.1418522149,
0.3854882419,
-0.1555155069,
0.3066497743,
0.1767404526,
-0.3898516297,
-0.4843073487,
-0.7130166292,
-0.1625296474,
-0.0793688744,
-0.787943542,
0.102715157,
-0.136522457,
-0.2114768773,
0.0514155477,
-0.0024226317,
-0.6144345403,
0.0398822315,
-0.2629567385,
0.5437024832,
-0.4516459405,
1.0018216372,
0.7165750861,
-0.395778954,
-0.3994894922,
-0.0752333105,
-0.1786664724,
-0.914931953,
0.4728185534,
-0.0245931,
0.177328825,
-0.0650700629,
-0.1526625603,
-0.6905298829,
0.8573489785,
0.6871842146,
-0.5716762543,
-0.2752823234,
0.2133676559,
0.3422621787,
-0.044003915,
-0.2544135451,
0.2371393442,
0.3964569569,
0.18724069,
-1.0638712645,
-0.3159612119,
-0.2252428979,
0.1668509841,
0.7347864509,
-0.8045280576,
1.4791612625,
0.0177866109,
0.2658936083,
0.0520468093,
0.3347249925,
0.1775356084,
0.6460775733,
0.2375336587,
0.61798805,
0.1733463407,
0.0546466187,
1.2639719248,
-0.4889425933,
0.5098183751,
0.6796104908,
0.0056717438,
0.9690688848,
1.0260540247,
-0.3362105787,
-0.0561233126,
0.4681242406,
0.1665669233,
0.6724502444,
0.2337511182,
-0.1131502092,
-0.161479637,
0.113158524,
-0.4903939068,
0.3188005984,
-0.0123436349,
-0.5971110463,
-0.2437369078,
0.1609695405,
0.2251956761,
0.1227086857,
-0.4000099599,
0.393496871,
0.3017127514,
-0.8901982903,
0.6287629604,
0.4311499,
0.4855878949,
-0.3964637816,
0.0868633166,
-0.2314292341,
0.517334044,
0.0497170463,
-0.6514370441,
0.4883415103,
-0.4175446928,
-0.3747705519,
-0.6031380892,
0.2727844715,
-0.6400582194,
-0.5646654963,
0.3025172949,
0.5854668617,
0.1310965419,
-0.4466430843,
-0.8982107043,
-0.0558246709,
0.134532854,
-0.1981538385,
0.5650058985,
0.3984439373,
0.1255218387,
0.2926172912,
0.908704102,
0.3186142147,
0.3845260143,
-0.2708858848,
0.4236396253,
-0.4058914483,
-0.8359666467,
-1.0321054459,
0.2229542434,
-0.1599151939,
-0.3296074569,
0.8138249516,
0.5517276525,
0.8936014771,
-0.0994920284,
0.3792595565,
0.1158618778,
0.3589646518,
-0.796946466,
0.7462240458,
-0.7384512424,
-0.1082156599,
0.0687692016,
-0.9361685514,
-0.3012411594,
0.3940053582,
-0.3484944701,
-0.1113202274,
0.7891503572,
0.4605025351,
-0.4569832981,
-0.0706385523,
0.5270766616,
0.0226921402,
-0.1389905959,
0.8231523037,
0.3377309442,
-0.497953862,
0.6778342128,
-0.6355329156,
-0.0346518718,
-0.0772958323,
-0.6634122133,
-0.7253606319,
-0.6350358725,
-0.0945379585,
-0.4892877638,
0.1752236634,
0.9376324415,
0.7229936719,
-0.6266331673,
-0.5260928869,
-0.1899419725,
-0.0329522528,
-0.5226929784,
-0.1340704858,
0.0697820634,
-0.573697567,
-0.828584969,
0.3243173659,
0.1881835461,
-0.2156125754,
-0.1344540864,
-0.217063874,
-0.4293465316,
-0.095202364,
0.4778958559,
0.0330252275,
-0.6392504573,
0.5134488344,
0.0488254242,
-0.3448503017,
0.2659080327,
1.134299159,
-0.0254535843,
0.4958255887,
0.3121890724,
0.8651868105,
0.4219026566,
-0.3711675107,
0.7343842983,
-1.0328931808,
0.4160349667,
0.0070542195,
0.4126880169,
0.1839253753,
-0.3605594039,
0.3917168379,
0.3647287786,
-0.4036284387,
-0.6577470303,
-0.0060673463,
-0.5906999707,
-0.2546086609,
1.0402901173,
-0.0981326401,
-0.2404378504,
0.4337421358,
-0.1339232028,
0.427846998,
-0.2548939884,
0.5742735267,
0.9284715056,
-0.1075746268,
-0.2405683249,
-1.0983914137,
0.1304897964,
0.8940615654,
-0.4418656528,
-0.2041143775,
0.1761612594,
0.1454845369,
0.3400864303,
0.30512923,
-0.0787876099,
0.2391670942,
0.0691709071,
0.0728359148,
-0.2258373052,
-0.4868064821,
-0.5750958323,
0.2815940678,
-0.0627810359,
-0.6861879826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03208v1 | Cerebras-GPT: Open Compute-Optimal Language Models Trained on the Cerebras Wafer-Scale Cluster | 2023-04-06T16:43:16 | 2023-04-06T16:43:16 | Nolan Dey, Gurpreet Gosal, Zhiming, Chen, Hemant Khachane, William Marshall, Ribhu Pathria, Marvin Tom, Joel Hestness | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We study recent research advances that improve large language models through
efficient pre-training and scaling, and open datasets and tools. We combine
these advances to introduce Cerebras-GPT, a family of open compute-optimal
language models scaled from 111M to 13B parameters. We train Cerebras-GPT
models on the Eleuther Pile dataset following DeepMind Chinchilla scaling rules
for efficient pre-training (highest accuracy for a given compute budget). We
characterize the predictable power-law scaling and compare Cerebras-GPT with
other publicly-available models to show all Cerebras-GPT models have
state-of-the-art training efficiency on both pre-training and downstream
objectives. We describe our learnings including how Maximal Update
Parameterization ($\mu$P) can further improve large model scaling, improving
accuracy and hyperparameter predictability at scale. We release our pre-trained
models and code, making this paper the first open and reproducible work
comparing compute-optimal model scaling to models trained on fixed dataset
sizes. Cerebras-GPT models are available on HuggingFace:
https://huggingface.co/cerebras. | [
-0.3399881721,
-0.7488510609,
0.5200468898,
0.2640220523,
0.0462031811,
-0.3182121515,
-0.7842174768,
-0.1600347459,
0.0197116993,
0.3698909581,
-0.1741568595,
-0.2310521305,
-0.5987735987,
-0.540594697,
-0.4067703187,
1.0492841005,
0.083040677,
0.001923671,
-0.053526774,
0.0073742936,
0.2078370154,
-0.6333700418,
-0.6781076193,
-0.2060239166,
0.6060759425,
0.1868180782,
0.9622005224,
0.8754720688,
0.4292348325,
0.2779816091,
-0.1579052806,
-0.2137128711,
-0.4829289913,
-0.2609684169,
-0.2092669159,
-0.0357900783,
-0.5406517982,
-0.2249647081,
0.4859646261,
0.986792624,
-0.7661363482,
0.4970262647,
0.2029667944,
0.5525692105,
-0.7893286943,
0.3988009691,
-0.7147830129,
-0.3593998253,
-0.3591544032,
0.3736102283,
-0.5371444225,
-0.7479060292,
-0.0786196068,
-0.5422433615,
0.220333606,
-0.1883638948,
0.8433923125,
0.2270246446,
-0.201951772,
0.0089569902,
-0.6044223309,
0.6512359381,
-0.5791018605,
0.5916534066,
0.0981973857,
0.2978664935,
0.0017630487,
-1.0473110676,
-0.1693525314,
-0.4161204398,
0.2074017823,
-0.0407687388,
-0.3282228112,
0.2300350964,
0.2160148472,
0.4314975142,
-0.6511525512,
0.3115382493,
-0.1559987366,
-0.0546844192,
0.2672867477,
0.002016861,
-0.0544957556,
0.3628102839,
0.1205806211,
-0.270226866,
-0.5959185958,
-0.1543413997,
0.169890821,
0.398245126,
-0.1814996749,
0.1960477233,
-0.2228477746,
0.8695325851,
0.0879647583,
0.1365708709,
0.2072136998,
-0.0330531672,
-0.3271544874,
-0.1383992136,
0.7719170451,
-0.148333177,
0.4259046614,
-0.2031448781,
0.0759610757,
0.1224629283,
0.0864366442,
-0.9017958045,
-0.5594319105,
-0.1673245132,
-0.3848811984,
-0.2816592157,
-0.2151970416,
-0.6902711987,
-0.3350994885,
-0.4615169466,
0.3975005448,
0.0497595258,
-0.6652700901,
0.3990284801,
0.3107432425,
-0.0851657018,
0.4514715075,
-1.2730236053,
0.5327100754,
0.4647967219,
0.4865288734,
0.1415085793,
-0.2809610665,
-0.4201259315,
-0.0705580115,
-0.3644617796,
0.4562379122,
-0.3343691826,
-0.0783921108,
-0.0843696892,
-0.1053309366,
-0.4352450371,
-0.3591777086,
0.7676078677,
-0.4568786621,
-0.1139754876,
-0.2667421401,
-0.3541054726,
0.0185758751,
0.1129817665,
-0.5510903001,
0.8669112325,
0.2722295523,
-0.7672891021,
0.0789316222,
-0.733048141,
-0.1761093587,
0.0609120838,
-0.0197227113,
-0.2946278453,
0.2456279248,
0.3659233153,
0.411799103,
-0.5473101735,
0.2664242983,
-0.3722456992,
-0.1166904122,
-0.0601347536,
-0.4296956062,
0.7147718668,
0.2640068531,
-0.3803937435,
0.0973228812,
-0.6797889471,
0.1272928119,
0.3892248273,
-0.2449488044,
-0.0108752511,
-0.1188505292,
0.1395713538,
0.0252137724,
0.6102355719,
-0.6813727617,
-0.1331220269,
-0.1831573397,
0.4674211442,
0.7712661028,
-0.3339844346,
0.3708672225,
0.1671079546,
0.5421987176,
-0.344486326,
0.6190011501,
-0.2159216702,
-0.2564411461,
-0.4238025844,
-0.121007584,
0.5589341521,
0.3217220604,
-0.1315380931,
0.2289565653,
-0.2804916203,
-0.8056303859,
-0.2055108696,
-0.2054737806,
0.3742979765,
0.6070732474,
0.4795231819,
-0.0859717131,
-0.1239088848,
-1.0382409096,
-0.2092627883,
-0.1210694686,
0.06537164,
0.2084992528,
0.1530950218,
-0.0058750571,
0.5774619579,
-0.676256299,
0.1819271594,
0.0719355121,
-0.0400466919,
0.3048653901,
0.3164678812,
0.4307971597,
-0.8709967732,
-0.5983135104,
0.5163758993,
-0.4382725954,
-0.0221831203,
0.3125244081,
0.2149984986,
0.0975226387,
0.6771396995,
-0.5265408754,
0.1315131187,
1.0181715488,
-0.0602932796,
0.6586397886,
-0.4826792181,
0.135184437,
-0.7129673362,
-0.0367205031,
0.0835930035,
-0.1539838165,
-0.4913322628,
0.1739517897,
0.497564435,
-0.1511787474,
-0.4769084752,
0.2906581163,
-0.4260674417,
-0.0777873024,
-0.1479802281,
0.0603856221,
-0.3249181807,
0.692165792,
0.0221681911,
0.7215044498,
0.6840909123,
-0.4609504938,
-0.048726283,
-0.0936896801,
-0.2678048611,
0.1681798249,
-0.8037317991,
0.1593652964,
0.2318606526,
0.0346846953,
-0.5116323829,
-0.2000317276,
-0.3240132034,
-0.3517188132,
0.2288134992,
-0.3126727045,
-0.6338380575,
-0.5025384426,
0.0240042191,
0.3677963018,
0.8108814359,
-0.805829525,
0.4611334801,
0.6658825278,
-0.0651653036,
-0.5310592055,
-0.4234546125,
-0.2152659595,
0.039594736,
-0.6196280122,
0.4034947753,
-0.1192881688,
-0.0373364165,
-0.1302052289,
-0.0022144353,
-0.1870018691,
-0.1233043522,
0.1413202435,
-0.0322918519,
-0.4050393701,
-0.0339415893,
0.0515538901,
-0.0910828263,
0.0655800626,
-0.7161140442,
0.7934943438,
-0.7973519564,
-0.2108948082,
0.0485996641,
-0.3117341101,
0.3802735209,
-0.4417129457,
0.7425076365,
0.5907438993,
-0.5794259906,
0.1550719589,
-0.5720491409,
0.1306175143,
-0.5269825459,
0.4217655063,
-0.4875059724,
-1.022808075,
0.3940926492,
-0.2289503366,
0.2160993218,
0.5331404209,
0.7256318331,
0.30610618,
1.1442043781,
0.7323384881,
-0.0736396462,
0.5127503276,
-0.0027633682,
0.0154965064,
-0.6106542349,
0.1647460312,
-0.7863635421,
0.294544518,
-0.673930943,
-0.3827531934,
0.3902926147,
0.1328801364,
-0.7742031217,
0.6202186942,
-0.7429944277,
0.818824172,
0.388435483,
0.1194901168,
0.1139932722,
-0.0790405571,
-0.2744593918,
-0.0090268087,
-0.7317535877,
-0.4059666991,
1.108492136,
0.3620804548,
0.7429060936,
-0.1578920633,
0.5514558554,
-0.1891127676,
0.3625640273,
-0.444490701,
0.4430648983,
-0.396982044,
-0.3383901119,
-0.3429879546,
-0.5866497755,
-1.0823143721,
0.2759199142,
0.0956535339,
-1.0267252922,
-0.0283499062,
0.3182424307,
-0.1296507716,
0.6552721858,
-0.7298541665,
1.0794963837,
-0.0043294225,
-0.2986859679,
-0.4476642907,
-0.4635008574,
0.2334176451,
-0.243385911,
0.3614534438,
0.1964963824,
-0.0894174799,
0.637634933,
-0.3739224076,
0.4826524258,
-0.4146554172,
-0.1073651537,
0.2994027138,
0.1653816551,
0.5525673628,
-0.0369798839,
-0.186042428,
0.2893555164,
-0.1238605529,
-0.5175712109,
-0.2821790576,
0.8709828258,
-0.9056436419,
-0.2181030661,
-0.0323298313,
-0.4533079565,
-0.2842403054,
0.2215314209,
0.2520623803,
0.522104919,
-0.4974169433,
0.3834511638,
0.8660368323,
-0.2559065223,
0.5096098185,
0.3087407351,
-0.3344598711,
-0.3810971677,
0.7759097219,
0.2517988086,
0.3307153285,
0.4061045945,
0.3765012026,
-0.1718917936,
-0.7495096326,
-0.4544528425,
0.1944068521,
-0.4914214313,
-0.0110542094,
-0.831677556,
-0.2069929093,
-0.4573734403,
-0.285166502,
-0.8552789688,
-0.537841022,
0.1636099964,
-0.0420703404,
0.364764303,
0.4980576932,
-0.4235447943,
0.5858389735,
-0.6797486544,
0.0802430585,
0.2776488066,
0.2841847241,
0.0327235125,
-0.4848391414,
-0.5742559433,
0.0043628095,
-0.3835720718,
-0.3914408982,
0.1469070166,
-0.153653726,
0.4719829261,
0.1327712387,
-0.2889511883,
0.3455686569,
-0.5342231989,
0.7250468731,
0.4385503829,
-1.0129901171,
0.4890045822,
-0.8290674686,
0.4500127435,
0.6649441719,
0.2627732456,
-0.3903169632,
-0.1338690966,
-0.9545029402,
-0.7023801804,
0.4760246575,
0.1716968268,
0.1699106246,
0.0800443217,
0.4214719832,
0.1134820729,
0.1643657535,
-0.6022860408,
0.0085448464,
-0.1121759862,
-0.3157614768,
-0.2491746247,
0.1869039834,
0.2452939153,
-0.3236306012,
0.7639216185,
-0.2913905382,
0.1380846202,
-0.1790578365,
-0.1179079488,
-0.1685004979,
0.0282045789,
0.3680212498,
0.9264799953,
-0.206346944,
-0.2765146494,
0.3376298249,
-0.8163773417,
-0.0770441815,
0.2725904286,
-0.0065187565,
-0.2515533566,
-0.1664654613,
0.7806017995,
0.286224246,
-0.4887385368,
0.5728051662,
-0.2245024592,
-0.3581008315,
-0.4228746593,
0.1155077368,
0.4161576629,
0.148141712,
0.0298625939,
0.0510978438,
0.0069385376,
-0.0318016559,
0.1306087673,
0.1671900898,
-0.3415746689,
-0.2530633807,
0.8750712872,
-0.155177325,
-0.1449682564,
0.6362930536,
0.098789528,
-0.1919741333,
0.8123276234,
0.3720982969,
0.7426847219,
-0.3275693059,
0.2635413408,
0.5399472117,
0.4990670085,
-0.4246064126,
-0.0734723955,
-0.0573131405,
-0.6736576557,
-0.4731893241,
-0.6321216226,
-0.8121039271,
0.1199579835,
-0.8443773389,
0.4471092522,
-0.6548364758,
-0.1572174281,
-0.0076807914,
-0.0016352826,
-0.6916776896,
0.275128454,
0.0790851265,
0.9872350097,
-0.5232551694,
1.1043958664,
0.5188651681,
-0.1998498738,
-1.0173969269,
-0.12758255,
-0.2277170867,
-0.7289142609,
0.1253964603,
-0.0028714279,
0.0003005799,
0.3952584267,
-0.5783163309,
-1.1144630909,
1.0190014839,
0.815212369,
-0.7856695652,
-0.0366532952,
-0.142791599,
0.4776398242,
-0.2212141007,
0.4377987385,
0.5676982999,
0.416280061,
-0.2802555263,
-1.1443539858,
-0.1491683871,
0.0346078202,
-0.1599551588,
0.7902625203,
-0.9299755692,
1.1017149687,
-0.2741204798,
0.2092102766,
0.0297878217,
0.743753314,
0.231510669,
-0.0500334352,
0.6463580728,
0.7466146946,
0.8056429625,
0.0142544061,
1.0815997124,
-0.3613035679,
0.6294960976,
1.3103307486,
-0.1652194858,
0.8277095556,
0.1125985235,
-0.2986151576,
0.5296900272,
0.7745729685,
0.0713660717,
0.4100418389,
0.4161492288,
-0.0944200233,
-0.1538395286,
0.0553611107,
-0.4758115709,
-0.0156098176,
0.419636786,
-0.2814761996,
-0.3083008826,
0.0796875954,
0.2592611015,
0.2657718956,
-0.5430476665,
0.380011797,
-0.0007456746,
-0.4109325409,
0.7366681695,
0.1479209214,
0.5167425275,
-0.6658093333,
0.5291250348,
-0.0873228088,
0.5214889646,
-0.0469946414,
-0.4454489648,
-0.1255396754,
-0.0244810656,
-0.0269598812,
-0.0217508264,
0.694103837,
-0.215068236,
-0.3451064527,
0.5403003693,
0.4776670933,
0.1789153218,
-0.4240752757,
-0.829228282,
-0.0658955947,
-0.1715539545,
-0.6584768891,
0.5526149273,
0.2500793338,
-0.2157586217,
0.3317045867,
0.6269142628,
0.1594152749,
0.1981476843,
0.3529877365,
0.8399772644,
-0.4647679031,
-0.5231712461,
-0.5840298533,
0.2763538361,
-0.0832438096,
-0.325807929,
0.445414722,
0.576484859,
0.8923897147,
0.0258658528,
0.6360753179,
-0.0535913035,
0.4619602859,
-0.2315026671,
0.468021363,
-0.3276470602,
-0.3069952428,
-0.2406127602,
-1.1390028,
-0.1127731279,
0.2362242341,
-0.420827955,
0.2525759339,
0.8315532207,
0.9892846346,
-0.3681310415,
0.4453651905,
0.3224979639,
0.3097862899,
0.1443518847,
0.7149684429,
0.3916820884,
-0.4576534629,
0.5395486355,
-0.3933414221,
-0.6398790479,
0.0778410286,
-0.7662226558,
-0.7020307779,
-0.5807040334,
-0.4974458814,
-0.2128718197,
0.1710293144,
0.7747316957,
0.9250299931,
-0.5466940999,
-0.3772495091,
-0.4294421077,
-0.2999678552,
-0.3261768222,
-0.1841806769,
0.6515330076,
-0.488432765,
-0.6325149536,
0.3882250786,
0.111509189,
-0.1615186036,
-0.1737439036,
-0.1828280985,
0.0950072929,
0.2649227977,
0.6480935812,
0.381880939,
-0.16863361,
-0.0503575094,
0.0379017368,
-0.1923084408,
-0.046978604,
0.7409567833,
-0.5751277804,
0.0059373192,
0.2543884814,
0.8260949254,
1.0626211166,
-0.4002361894,
0.4421815276,
-0.2032983452,
0.1371014714,
0.0356018916,
0.4563321173,
0.2111940682,
-0.2785131633,
0.855935812,
-0.0928879678,
-0.899417758,
-0.7863508463,
0.0796536282,
-0.8506176472,
-0.2184322774,
0.8832005858,
-0.1393886805,
-0.3214638829,
0.3220119476,
-0.1166648865,
0.1682583541,
-0.1887106597,
0.3101617396,
0.5348442793,
-0.0717153922,
-0.1424613446,
-0.7217286825,
0.2940045595,
0.4522090256,
-0.9347326159,
0.4209344089,
0.3285380006,
0.0904937312,
-0.0577226654,
0.6819636822,
-0.5994986892,
0.2538521886,
0.1486869752,
0.2847822905,
0.0305861589,
-0.3827439845,
-0.3790052235,
0.467669487,
0.3347488046,
-0.0736333951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03159v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03159v1 | Bridging the Language Gap: Knowledge Injected Multilingual Question Answering | 2023-04-06T15:41:25 | 2023-04-06T15:41:25 | Zhichao Duan, Xiuxing Li, Zhengyan Zhang, Zhenyu Li, Ning Liu, Jianyong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question Answering (QA) is the task of automatically answering questions
posed by humans in natural languages. There are different settings to answer a
question, such as abstractive, extractive, boolean, and multiple-choice QA. As
a popular topic in natural language processing tasks, extractive question
answering task (extractive QA) has gained extensive attention in the past few
years. With the continuous evolvement of the world, generalized cross-lingual
transfer (G-XLT), where question and answer context are in different languages,
poses some unique challenges over cross-lingual transfer (XLT), where question
and answer context are in the same language. With the boost of corresponding
development of related benchmarks, many works have been done to improve the
performance of various language QA tasks. However, only a few works are
dedicated to the G-XLT task. In this work, we propose a generalized
cross-lingual transfer framework to enhance the model's ability to understand
different languages. Specifically, we first assemble triples from different
languages to form multilingual knowledge. Since the lack of knowledge between
different languages greatly limits models' reasoning ability, we further design
a knowledge injection strategy via leveraging link prediction techniques to
enrich the model storage of multilingual knowledge. In this way, we can
profoundly exploit rich semantic knowledge. Experiment results on real-world
datasets MLQA demonstrate that the proposed method can improve the performance
by a large margin, outperforming the baseline method by 13.18%/12.00% F1/EM on
average. | [
-0.4467016757,
-0.9299838543,
0.5517345071,
0.1471896321,
0.0128544634,
0.3071046174,
0.0864884332,
-0.9875049591,
-0.0156127447,
0.1599199921,
-0.4685203433,
-0.1679436713,
-0.4352971017,
0.1037709415,
-0.1426142305,
0.7191275954,
-0.2352159917,
0.1371931881,
-0.2447498441,
-0.0847114548,
-0.6893984079,
-0.4655754566,
-0.6796469688,
-0.1542697847,
0.4407438636,
0.2329223156,
0.7723066211,
0.3971599936,
0.1526145786,
0.2746284902,
0.0395352356,
0.1202672124,
-0.1869131923,
-0.2521771491,
-0.4913112819,
-0.7280731201,
-0.1824272722,
-0.4421211183,
0.6037198901,
0.8022707701,
0.0140334861,
-0.0339028426,
-0.0316033848,
0.4758394361,
-0.5044316649,
0.1505162716,
-0.5630277395,
0.027409533,
0.0605057515,
0.0383407399,
0.0372563936,
-0.4019905329,
0.2791152894,
-0.8538276553,
-0.0013433571,
0.0941089019,
1.045199275,
-0.07713148,
-0.503926158,
-0.3028107285,
-0.6008226871,
0.598307848,
-0.4637253582,
0.6159558296,
0.3647160232,
0.543225646,
0.2098911703,
-0.5635479689,
-0.5827450156,
0.2270146757,
-0.1928974688,
0.0695115849,
-0.2528588772,
-0.1697271019,
0.0009101176,
0.3732119501,
-0.7770006657,
-0.1047469303,
-0.4956791401,
-0.2023857534,
0.4521510899,
-0.0770816877,
0.9690694213,
0.0263770055,
-0.4903864264,
0.0026396918,
-0.8094035983,
0.2863306403,
0.1848087758,
0.3140882552,
-0.0911405087,
0.3487621248,
-0.3595072031,
0.7080600858,
-0.1138389185,
0.1754194498,
0.1865107268,
-0.7557025552,
-0.0799915418,
-0.1389656812,
0.5591839552,
0.194438085,
0.3681737483,
-0.3359580636,
0.1346126944,
-0.3257372379,
-0.0949111283,
-0.6463302374,
0.0325656049,
0.1333184093,
-0.0233423933,
0.1248644963,
-0.0010961945,
-0.9364602566,
0.0167746395,
-0.1306927949,
0.7068225145,
-0.479683131,
-0.4796232283,
0.3562967181,
0.0734856874,
0.4076087475,
0.2304841429,
-0.923443377,
0.2713640928,
0.4125436544,
0.6352131367,
-0.1785563678,
-0.4039817154,
-0.7296625376,
0.3770231605,
-0.2023176402,
0.752358675,
-0.5090920925,
-0.2255108207,
0.2239716351,
0.2446632534,
-0.3015326262,
-0.3760235608,
0.0858465582,
-0.875849545,
0.7803746462,
-0.5178672075,
-0.4151357412,
-0.4168582261,
0.4010758698,
-0.5596110821,
0.9589580894,
0.2624716163,
-0.6257248521,
0.1106475666,
-0.7290480137,
-0.489371866,
0.0975879133,
-0.0353265852,
0.1484753937,
-0.364389807,
0.7472996116,
0.1773728281,
-0.4262351096,
0.2149635255,
-0.1044679806,
-0.3070401847,
0.1438489705,
-0.1673721075,
0.8559922576,
0.058968503,
-0.3120903373,
-0.1786870807,
-0.5128558874,
0.3046769798,
-0.0918717608,
-0.2744735181,
-0.5961741209,
-0.5826336145,
-0.1603649706,
0.6640480757,
0.1463948637,
-0.5744711161,
0.0991204083,
-0.6037003398,
0.111885488,
0.4282465875,
0.0906083807,
0.6238816977,
-0.274830848,
0.8564428091,
0.1671358347,
-0.0097010201,
0.0149554387,
-0.6475863457,
-0.5020091534,
0.1041531712,
0.4073173106,
0.9354144335,
-1.3407411575,
-0.1096005738,
-0.2854328454,
-0.2265715003,
-0.7812390924,
0.3987276554,
0.4890960455,
0.4089012444,
0.6192013621,
-0.0404999703,
-0.2804306746,
-0.8370608687,
-0.4063091874,
-0.319060415,
-0.1337551624,
0.1416635215,
0.1958766729,
-0.0490366518,
0.8084459305,
-0.5199722648,
-0.1149901226,
-0.4319478571,
0.0685521215,
0.1197603866,
0.4293392003,
0.4294090569,
-0.9646131992,
-0.8060871959,
0.4592080712,
-0.7729969025,
-0.2230640799,
-0.0800885782,
-0.4887847304,
0.1852065623,
0.4815672934,
-0.5255960822,
0.1389154047,
0.697689414,
-0.35222736,
0.6382662058,
-0.0813485682,
0.3571858406,
-1.3313993216,
0.0864467472,
-0.2104375809,
-0.0727128163,
-0.836524725,
0.0326773375,
0.2006678432,
-0.0372772738,
-0.762432456,
0.9547228217,
-0.578289628,
-0.0556308329,
-0.0065718554,
0.2856284976,
0.2439575493,
0.5824216604,
0.0684931949,
0.9248318672,
0.7153099775,
-0.4774829447,
0.3012884855,
0.3280905485,
-0.1142140627,
0.6299045682,
-0.5980947614,
0.1477809548,
0.0099652838,
-0.2271730155,
-0.8425860405,
0.0732053444,
0.3619882464,
-0.3968069255,
0.3129284978,
-0.2292980552,
-0.2098743767,
-0.1544264108,
0.133000344,
0.6387240887,
0.3516220152,
-0.5173760056,
0.6378169656,
0.25765571,
-0.665845871,
-0.7885639668,
-0.6838857532,
0.0481118187,
-0.1716424823,
-0.832167387,
0.3200187981,
-0.1933041066,
-0.1730892062,
0.2273628414,
0.0644555688,
-0.4496759176,
-0.0946863592,
-0.300803721,
0.3504015207,
-0.3223700821,
0.4126377702,
0.2346438766,
-0.1140063107,
0.1324093342,
-0.3926793933,
0.2963452339,
-0.2429629713,
-0.4527260661,
-0.1756711155,
0.7467594743,
0.325589776,
-0.3459810615,
0.5936923623,
0.8063038588,
-0.2393480092,
0.0814024583,
-0.4912363291,
0.0349203646,
-0.3946933746,
0.4800398052,
-0.7429748178,
-0.953099072,
0.6441257596,
0.0898606554,
-0.0693087429,
0.3549684882,
0.3529436588,
0.1798843294,
0.9845556617,
0.831869185,
-0.2369319499,
0.1257100701,
0.0224226173,
0.2924545109,
-0.5328614116,
-0.1065130681,
-0.4902680516,
0.1836221367,
-0.4622216225,
-0.6808452606,
0.3230776191,
0.316190213,
0.1787334234,
0.267403841,
0.0470869578,
0.5466347933,
0.4395476878,
-0.1196208522,
0.4735225737,
-0.0586383678,
-0.235014841,
0.1177270487,
-0.8483913541,
-0.0564499646,
0.8070102334,
0.1836027801,
0.4837955832,
0.3595465422,
0.5015180707,
-0.021312207,
0.1376145631,
-0.4521725178,
0.3350891471,
0.133849293,
-0.5362226367,
-0.4492436051,
-0.6395637393,
-0.8922450542,
0.5776886344,
-0.0719851628,
-0.8196219206,
0.2728126943,
-0.1277647465,
-0.2341729701,
0.4372843504,
-0.6962376833,
0.8351123333,
-0.3018303812,
-0.5134079456,
0.0101379333,
-0.7404074669,
0.3816419542,
-0.2179676443,
0.5282955766,
0.0647091046,
0.0059618978,
0.4958427548,
-0.0288065765,
0.536636591,
-0.2236679196,
-0.4353466332,
0.0946271196,
0.1543577611,
0.3851866126,
0.0595725849,
0.0116120288,
0.1641343981,
0.3696613312,
-0.6057298779,
-0.827526629,
0.3646187186,
-0.7114596367,
-0.6610099077,
-0.0580819994,
-0.9390763044,
-0.6627631187,
0.2073928267,
-0.0292920899,
0.2980581224,
-0.2223171592,
-0.2461073399,
0.5737187862,
-0.4971387386,
0.2255853117,
0.5336342454,
-0.3800776303,
-0.2937816083,
0.9411400557,
-0.0960585102,
0.6152396202,
0.739515841,
0.1525072306,
-0.7065822482,
-0.3263257146,
-0.8655521274,
0.3558771014,
-0.7527707815,
-0.1302508861,
-0.8178581595,
-0.2173549235,
-0.631722033,
-0.1665874869,
0.0185866226,
-0.3516391218,
0.1576931775,
-0.0935800672,
0.0346607231,
0.5307858586,
-0.2997990251,
-0.055048231,
-1.1977434158,
0.4957246482,
0.6883257031,
0.2041256279,
-0.125749886,
-0.2710260749,
-0.4118878245,
0.2300681472,
0.1562709659,
-0.9612691402,
0.4290291667,
0.2945782542,
0.8268000484,
0.0553241149,
-0.0446452238,
0.8723384142,
-0.3309571743,
0.735417366,
0.1959165931,
-0.9915180802,
0.3500013649,
-0.1487250477,
0.625570178,
0.3227239251,
0.6367005706,
-0.9340387583,
-0.5791862011,
-0.4182904065,
-0.8913778663,
0.5910721421,
0.0467941985,
0.0226568952,
0.1857506335,
0.0072842883,
0.2914676368,
0.0866990015,
-0.7231371403,
0.0864496604,
0.0075055393,
0.004750446,
0.0173543077,
-0.1363397539,
-0.0553019196,
-0.2151385993,
0.6890135407,
-0.3716550767,
0.1531793922,
0.2321350127,
-0.4969061911,
-0.1139526516,
0.54989779,
0.2989782691,
0.7684264779,
-0.0719824359,
0.1549646258,
0.4264709055,
-0.2822863162,
0.2743914127,
0.3346988857,
-0.0782350376,
-0.1757062972,
0.2647797465,
0.5332604647,
0.1543237865,
-0.5939105749,
0.3274194598,
-0.2156740278,
-0.1785685867,
0.1713755429,
-0.1609515846,
0.2784060538,
0.3076960444,
0.3958949149,
-0.2908878028,
0.1700334251,
-0.5471963882,
0.4108392596,
0.2374710441,
-0.4360508323,
-0.4049369693,
0.5030597448,
0.0538731143,
0.1491577923,
0.4709527493,
-0.117682822,
-0.7439700961,
0.5042940974,
0.7048403025,
0.7570104003,
-0.3426406384,
0.3592624366,
0.484454304,
0.2422657311,
0.2435670495,
0.4042420089,
-0.07644815,
-0.9159055352,
-0.7246209979,
-0.6071569324,
-0.343701303,
-0.1714713126,
-0.673930645,
-0.1385737658,
0.2969727516,
0.5062832236,
-0.2145049125,
0.0639134347,
-0.6922148466,
0.0469621718,
0.048205819,
0.8339595199,
-1.0294723511,
0.9707487822,
0.8285958171,
-0.4803635478,
-0.901125133,
-0.0161029659,
-0.2464516163,
-0.8899030089,
0.6712863445,
0.018928064,
-0.0397008359,
0.0096422723,
-0.0590075143,
-0.9478294253,
0.8185885549,
0.3323065042,
-0.0976084024,
-0.0825986415,
0.6518773437,
0.4423954487,
-0.3270307779,
0.1939259768,
0.5207244754,
0.5678626299,
0.1260607988,
-1.0114096403,
0.2526730299,
-0.5055806637,
-0.0191711318,
0.1369734406,
-0.1943082064,
0.7102930546,
-0.3538453877,
-0.289589256,
-0.0143191656,
0.5739482641,
0.1171175614,
0.0964251161,
0.5246148109,
0.399733454,
0.7239462733,
-0.0369191878,
1.134324193,
-0.2931874394,
0.0572200082,
0.8819745779,
-0.2885774672,
0.6551911831,
0.6214059591,
-0.144080773,
0.5072723627,
0.4688165188,
0.3823469579,
0.4838212132,
-0.0014937033,
-0.2114582807,
-0.2301116288,
-0.1343670338,
-0.6241624951,
0.3616763353,
0.261872381,
0.045496162,
-0.4699424803,
0.0481890216,
0.0203561634,
-0.0551530719,
-0.220412448,
0.7855709195,
-0.097326681,
-0.8195030093,
0.6154609323,
-0.222678706,
0.4704002142,
-0.7660146952,
-0.2557256818,
-0.4483584166,
-0.1313511729,
0.0301686805,
-0.8801289201,
0.4338358343,
-0.2043785155,
-0.1080530882,
-0.2657237947,
0.7904430628,
-1.1096334457,
-0.3707089424,
0.5497519374,
1.1927455664,
0.1103406698,
-0.180701375,
-0.8007561564,
-0.3511944115,
0.089914009,
0.0361932665,
0.544608891,
0.6322040558,
-0.1635439545,
0.6925373673,
0.751973629,
0.2393655628,
0.1697651744,
0.0535009727,
0.8094702959,
-0.5143608451,
-0.7834364772,
-0.4420515299,
0.4783033431,
-0.0418071933,
-0.0790617391,
0.7321051955,
0.3800032139,
0.8830890656,
-0.1063051224,
0.8059098125,
-0.2266985923,
0.5418462157,
-0.6690372229,
0.5499047041,
-0.8021695018,
0.1409742683,
-0.2781489193,
-0.6850301623,
-0.2477945834,
0.1471002996,
-0.2686870098,
-0.1281478405,
0.774864018,
0.9893303514,
-0.0321884491,
-0.084155418,
0.6403467655,
0.032303378,
0.4383842349,
1.0933095217,
0.8872926235,
-0.5300759077,
0.8548423648,
-0.28529948,
-0.0582358055,
0.2179327309,
-0.5872489214,
-0.6014342308,
-0.6411324739,
-0.2105410695,
-0.1980798393,
0.309543103,
0.3951325119,
0.5477038622,
-0.8532268405,
-0.330416739,
0.1642064154,
0.4136909842,
-0.5657805204,
-0.2638177276,
0.5274778605,
-0.5331002474,
-0.9335657358,
0.390440464,
0.18311508,
0.0412405394,
-0.1604008079,
-0.0792054757,
-0.5758425593,
-0.2150854319,
0.5655811429,
0.6087064147,
-0.4685253501,
-0.4750287831,
0.2998942733,
0.0589770526,
0.032540109,
0.4987865388,
-0.8160298467,
0.4663224518,
0.6059685946,
1.1539055109,
0.3520744443,
0.0179560874,
1.0314605236,
-0.8359926939,
-0.0501272492,
0.0061935349,
0.283241123,
0.3316646814,
-0.4156684875,
0.5783407092,
0.21576114,
-0.3203352392,
-0.5759263039,
0.2360121757,
-0.7105370164,
-0.4061045349,
1.2346973419,
-0.3179708719,
-0.1712129861,
-0.5984354615,
-0.1693854779,
0.2390660197,
-0.0663398355,
0.6790307164,
0.6467767954,
0.0380777866,
-0.3878147304,
-0.6696519852,
0.4382509589,
0.4906718433,
-1.2755770683,
-0.0216167495,
0.3607646227,
0.349288404,
0.1958085448,
0.6898614168,
-0.2498034388,
0.4719209373,
-0.2270431817,
0.1374612153,
0.0912103355,
-0.2106477469,
-0.2748991251,
0.4394762516,
-0.1879265308,
-0.2165307254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03153v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03153v1 | Zero-Shot Next-Item Recommendation using Large Pretrained Language Models | 2023-04-06T15:35:11 | 2023-04-06T15:35:11 | Lei Wang, Ee-Peng Lim | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive zero-shot performance
in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks, demonstrating their
capabilities for inference without training examples. Despite their success, no
research has yet explored the potential of LLMs to perform next-item
recommendations in the zero-shot setting. We have identified two major
challenges that must be addressed to enable LLMs to act effectively as
recommenders. First, the recommendation space can be extremely large for LLMs,
and LLMs do not know about the target user's past interacted items and
preferences. To address this gap, we propose a prompting strategy called
Zero-Shot Next-Item Recommendation (NIR) prompting that directs LLMs to make
next-item recommendations. Specifically, the NIR-based strategy involves using
an external module to generate candidate items based on user-filtering or
item-filtering. Our strategy incorporates a 3-step prompting that guides GPT-3
to carry subtasks that capture the user's preferences, select representative
previously watched movies, and recommend a ranked list of 10 movies. We
evaluate the proposed approach using GPT-3 on MovieLens 100K dataset and show
that it achieves strong zero-shot performance, even outperforming some strong
sequential recommendation models trained on the entire training dataset. These
promising results highlight the ample research opportunities to use LLMs as
recommenders. The code can be found at
https://github.com/AGI-Edgerunners/LLM-Next-Item-Rec. | [
-0.377921313,
-0.4355171919,
0.8987778425,
-0.2663167417,
-0.3966674805,
-0.0950900689,
-0.0792225674,
-0.1360970438,
0.227190882,
0.6136137247,
-0.8520305157,
-0.5922290683,
-0.4071095288,
0.0059840302,
-0.2707558274,
1.2086066008,
-0.0308189765,
-0.2392006665,
-0.1949015707,
0.0934210569,
-1.0103911161,
-0.3442771733,
-0.713606596,
-0.5078441501,
0.9357208014,
0.7464921474,
0.4802701175,
0.3778629303,
0.1753124297,
0.1541195065,
0.0427622125,
-0.0394790806,
-0.5073105097,
0.3999102116,
-0.1368359029,
-0.3281126022,
-0.3402642012,
-0.0051938426,
0.399312377,
0.3480703533,
0.0683100894,
0.2323993146,
-0.1341745108,
0.5420431495,
-0.6439261436,
-0.2229488939,
-0.6453676224,
0.3890329003,
-0.1958730966,
-0.4031781852,
-0.3358159065,
-0.2407980263,
0.3857645988,
-0.4422116876,
0.1072671339,
0.0850960463,
0.6082372069,
0.0697194189,
-0.1361330897,
-0.015590867,
-0.9217875004,
0.6539856791,
-0.6859543324,
0.29215464,
0.6063515544,
0.1379221529,
-0.0020194256,
-0.3744006753,
-0.6168096662,
-0.5283586383,
0.2944864333,
0.0851034373,
-0.192974478,
-0.2084576637,
0.2444608808,
0.0264416058,
-0.7257187366,
0.280839175,
-0.0574075766,
0.1627330482,
0.1299681067,
0.1505697817,
-0.0060633705,
0.2384893745,
-0.3453674316,
-0.0801650062,
-0.8826410174,
-0.1912626028,
0.2452436239,
0.176030919,
0.0977504253,
0.853962481,
-0.396048069,
0.6753972173,
0.3010034859,
0.2733511329,
0.144648239,
-0.3025870919,
-0.1215151474,
-0.0111616934,
0.4951729178,
0.8492458463,
0.3698089123,
-0.1199114919,
-0.1436890066,
-0.1419796497,
0.0643670261,
-0.8372526169,
-0.1134931147,
0.1634912044,
-0.0642046854,
-0.1176997796,
-0.2460086942,
-0.4522864521,
-0.6244888902,
-0.1067764163,
0.777469337,
-0.4021525979,
0.0160045568,
0.0978562087,
-0.0243841466,
0.2459819615,
0.2319494486,
-0.8624788523,
0.0710820481,
0.4477963448,
1.1829175949,
-0.0465000197,
-0.4544991255,
-0.854365468,
0.4160889685,
-0.3821374476,
1.2312608957,
-0.6136386991,
-0.2975590229,
0.1982088089,
-0.0942829028,
0.2022214532,
-0.3905304372,
0.3584739566,
-0.5789509416,
0.2803371549,
-0.4443739355,
-0.684997499,
-0.0884493366,
0.5417048335,
-0.1893539876,
0.6271818876,
0.0493794084,
-0.2997650504,
0.5984700322,
-0.7288176417,
-0.3911255896,
0.4455561638,
-0.1552877724,
-0.1048802808,
0.261803478,
0.3733059168,
0.7223166227,
-0.1811851561,
0.1807059497,
-0.6427518129,
-0.6605831385,
-0.2402412593,
-0.4625859261,
0.0598614998,
-0.0768318027,
-0.0501318052,
0.2878180444,
-0.1837863326,
-0.1807527244,
0.179950133,
-0.0073090126,
-0.0216701441,
-0.0577136241,
-0.1723144352,
0.2362666726,
0.2798631489,
-0.4629727304,
0.2730460763,
-0.3738742769,
0.1352000982,
0.9252170324,
0.0516608208,
0.459210217,
-0.4823336601,
0.6845733523,
-0.3045494258,
-0.0175399128,
-0.5919387341,
-0.307141006,
-0.63097018,
0.3937148452,
-0.0643778145,
0.5367144346,
-0.8363595605,
0.4118763804,
-0.0968483537,
-0.2525463104,
-0.0150777819,
0.1897703558,
0.1819662303,
0.4016211629,
0.3539079726,
-0.3738120198,
-0.4868373871,
-0.5265217423,
-0.0702028573,
-0.3137053847,
-0.2888400853,
0.4981734753,
0.1613399684,
-0.1644265652,
0.8444342613,
-0.6169379354,
-0.8346780539,
-0.4663115144,
-0.0069209561,
0.5513520241,
0.0023553416,
0.1753488183,
-0.0196912419,
-0.6011996865,
-0.0765950084,
-0.5174689293,
-0.1460127532,
-0.1385921538,
-0.0605054386,
-0.0391221195,
0.6211192012,
-0.4111551344,
0.1245886162,
0.3104366958,
-0.3356299996,
0.4223103821,
-0.4571042061,
-0.1589675695,
-0.955663681,
-0.1861167997,
0.0906274244,
-0.0564423874,
-0.5492601991,
-0.4358465075,
-0.3975322247,
-0.0807425305,
-0.5214030147,
0.8706208467,
-0.2195102572,
-0.0715704337,
-0.5091812611,
0.1796620339,
-0.2167396992,
0.5358726978,
0.176312089,
0.4986436367,
0.6150111556,
-0.5183125138,
0.2808868587,
0.2420452982,
-0.2198915184,
0.7535765767,
-0.6337780356,
0.3381330967,
-0.1725681722,
0.4430653751,
-0.8977321982,
0.0129606966,
0.0839780197,
-0.245885253,
0.1509138197,
-0.45566836,
-0.3459746838,
-0.378657937,
-0.5975449085,
0.1716090888,
0.4610676169,
-0.3673658371,
0.5017427206,
0.0716301054,
-0.4017791748,
-0.5130478144,
-0.2309732437,
0.3186123967,
-0.1281021982,
-0.1408015788,
0.308036387,
-0.4349549413,
0.2763936818,
0.0036715197,
-0.10458453,
0.151349321,
-0.2607465684,
0.420093894,
0.5623289943,
-0.056811858,
-0.0395815,
-0.2476436496,
-0.3764218092,
-0.3308750391,
-0.6791133285,
0.7398204803,
-0.1305359751,
-0.3599915504,
-0.3005438745,
0.2771225572,
0.3506532013,
0.0138588194,
0.4884201884,
0.9734879732,
-0.1067666486,
0.1311743557,
-0.8442959785,
-0.2821120918,
-0.4606843889,
0.4494952559,
-0.0669152662,
-1.1196885109,
0.0152095389,
0.0889300555,
0.1732206643,
0.0376775265,
0.7178932428,
-0.3098204732,
0.8503856063,
0.717594564,
-0.4051306844,
0.9267373085,
-0.392539829,
0.2833688855,
-0.920830071,
-0.1036151052,
-0.1578157693,
-0.2418899238,
0.0113018574,
-0.3433659077,
0.3770566583,
0.0124353897,
-0.3440858722,
0.3818340302,
-0.109227635,
0.9532370567,
0.7324848771,
-0.1432630271,
0.0951388851,
0.1212142929,
-0.3041594923,
0.2393431962,
-0.6466537714,
-0.2867399454,
0.9765232205,
0.1754039377,
0.6534696817,
0.0069124736,
0.6223036051,
0.3778508604,
0.1343466491,
-1.0077488422,
0.6590027809,
-0.3179106712,
-0.2432515025,
-0.3743994236,
0.0219967961,
-0.853854835,
-0.1554733217,
-0.2317805886,
-0.8912261128,
0.1737189591,
0.1277261525,
-0.8521957994,
0.3325079381,
-0.5316891074,
0.6505852342,
-0.2325588167,
-0.5077053308,
-0.0306276381,
-0.4141255319,
0.1138848364,
-0.1567997336,
-0.0945508704,
-0.3868638575,
-0.0166047812,
0.6251739264,
-0.1293197125,
0.6309527755,
-0.3633492589,
0.1348761767,
0.1158822402,
0.3499670923,
0.6824037433,
0.0483076498,
-0.0818514973,
0.1220119372,
-0.2605303824,
-0.036076095,
-0.429020375,
0.8759160638,
-0.405780524,
-0.6692005396,
-0.4316616654,
-0.4924792647,
-0.4441343844,
0.4130328596,
0.3352015316,
0.444157362,
0.121383965,
0.3555158079,
0.4643439054,
-0.2474001795,
0.757147193,
0.781031549,
-0.2972895205,
-0.4339933395,
1.0356352329,
0.0368982442,
-0.0739285424,
0.3791707456,
0.2526273429,
-0.5813089013,
-0.9401805401,
-0.5128698945,
0.1570706964,
-0.2495451421,
-0.2597430944,
-0.6579153538,
0.0554947034,
-0.1881604642,
-0.420207262,
-0.1703850478,
0.1289284676,
-0.2624674141,
-0.1806475967,
0.4236801267,
0.8054633737,
-0.0396395437,
0.4152311385,
-0.630548358,
0.4051860869,
0.3362346292,
0.7009590268,
-0.0230249744,
-0.8068500161,
-0.5368909836,
-0.4398587346,
-0.2561579943,
-0.5147153735,
0.4266613126,
0.1277264506,
0.3661476672,
0.5624235868,
0.0346237049,
0.6585672498,
-0.9564740062,
0.8402045965,
0.2137340158,
-0.4605101049,
0.515627265,
-0.5773019791,
0.7468205094,
0.7971624136,
0.4340024889,
-0.5871684551,
-0.1470784098,
-0.2887025476,
-0.8772418499,
0.7591481805,
0.0062267547,
0.3350554407,
-0.0554907359,
0.1806896627,
-0.0380514488,
0.1155663207,
-0.4104169309,
-0.0211701486,
0.185921222,
0.1963358521,
-0.5209538341,
-0.535066247,
0.2265318483,
0.0312336553,
0.7484467626,
-0.2302051932,
0.1904560477,
0.093190141,
0.1083302572,
-0.2834649682,
0.2440291196,
0.4660322368,
0.3781201541,
-0.6342170238,
-0.2007389367,
0.2848289311,
-0.2563829422,
0.3013194501,
0.045168601,
-0.2011619806,
-0.1680452228,
0.1015892923,
0.8506556749,
-0.0155825177,
-0.5645182729,
0.6181899309,
-0.2258222401,
-0.2383991778,
-0.4594290555,
-0.07598757,
-0.0078250784,
0.208941251,
0.312027365,
0.0205280297,
-0.0652736425,
-0.5821352005,
0.2490924299,
0.5244086981,
-0.6819401383,
-0.1345690638,
0.3726148307,
0.0444964319,
-0.361402154,
0.4607591033,
-0.0491614528,
-0.2303270698,
-0.0310131256,
0.4620362222,
1.1536079645,
-0.038069237,
0.4066142142,
0.1354228407,
0.2096345425,
-0.3310000896,
-0.0558126159,
-0.1917750537,
-0.8739934564,
-0.6276792288,
-0.6288254261,
-0.701446414,
0.4727211595,
-0.3340333998,
0.478461802,
-0.6000560522,
-0.11940483,
-0.1809943467,
-0.0123839853,
-0.6052895784,
0.0090347482,
0.2915920615,
0.5208845735,
-0.6872919202,
0.7757779956,
0.5438076854,
-0.409445852,
-0.6599758267,
0.1059502587,
0.0384457931,
-0.6068193316,
0.2280945331,
0.156606853,
-0.20541282,
0.0058121379,
-0.1624294072,
-0.7378962636,
0.9812136292,
0.3678513765,
-0.6733294725,
-0.1177392751,
-0.2219374627,
0.44176507,
-0.4728510678,
0.6891618967,
0.3268070221,
0.259364754,
0.5805144906,
-0.457849443,
-0.0749442428,
-0.206716761,
0.1216093153,
0.0776313618,
-0.3214149177,
0.6385520101,
-0.4621795118,
0.1537285149,
0.1317363828,
0.4356369376,
0.4981823862,
0.3117861748,
0.6348294616,
0.393378973,
0.2671143413,
0.3627806306,
1.0633713007,
-0.0932825506,
-0.0368310697,
1.6304341555,
-0.9190200567,
1.1343659163,
0.3106975555,
0.0282403305,
0.6322101951,
0.6236098409,
-0.2523980439,
0.5285190344,
-0.0498613492,
-0.4146344662,
-0.1820934415,
-0.5519061685,
-0.3297713399,
0.2655127048,
0.0816646889,
-0.2013311684,
-0.2437576354,
0.1336215436,
-0.133891955,
-0.3727733493,
-0.1951544732,
1.0431237221,
-0.1224454716,
-0.6091746092,
0.3787378371,
-0.216031,
0.7766736746,
-0.7114988565,
-0.2325068563,
-0.4138455987,
-0.0618885681,
-0.0090920301,
-0.7362127304,
-0.0871520191,
0.3105944693,
-0.2277869731,
-0.2737199664,
0.7023041844,
-0.3589021564,
-0.4248328805,
0.1762422025,
0.5111361146,
0.2678206563,
-0.1938194633,
-0.4016543627,
-0.2747755051,
0.0171206165,
-0.1060159132,
0.5264619589,
0.0855655894,
0.0402053483,
0.7483541369,
0.9380885959,
0.2910084128,
-0.3791865408,
0.3796494007,
0.5371562839,
-0.7464935184,
-0.3525924087,
-0.9514577985,
0.1332121491,
0.2801217735,
-0.1424595267,
0.6973635554,
0.344640106,
1.0612431765,
-0.07978075,
0.5782843232,
0.223132804,
0.2828209996,
-0.3841837049,
0.382573545,
-0.3776002228,
0.6290809512,
-0.2861452997,
-1.1836513281,
-0.3844279349,
0.3316890597,
-0.4242189825,
0.323184222,
0.6494752765,
0.796343267,
0.220216468,
-0.1569588631,
0.7013906837,
0.22761482,
0.224828124,
0.7499845624,
0.8832117915,
-0.026009623,
0.7059463263,
0.0416703559,
0.0371861793,
-0.3033377528,
-1.05346632,
-0.9167559147,
-0.2491796315,
-0.1259487271,
-0.1650111526,
0.1148462445,
1.0759521723,
0.7694889903,
-0.7171766162,
-0.3563887477,
-0.1826045662,
0.1012923047,
-0.1292149872,
-0.1213959679,
0.1721238047,
0.0996931046,
-0.5673501492,
0.7787762284,
0.5564806461,
0.1128521338,
-0.2867573798,
-0.1040254757,
-0.2628837526,
0.0854569301,
0.7449074388,
0.1809130758,
-0.6754212379,
-0.256259799,
-0.1576355249,
0.4527747929,
-0.2031371593,
0.8655767441,
-1.0483276844,
0.373198539,
0.2999595404,
0.4882417619,
0.713010788,
-0.2747823,
0.7961137295,
-0.5348306298,
-0.2277044058,
0.2210223526,
0.2949693501,
0.2147616297,
-0.4263898432,
0.4363009334,
-0.0972151756,
-0.5922794938,
-0.6932179332,
0.2305456251,
-0.7745888233,
-0.0733596832,
1.0491079092,
-0.1265423447,
0.1635127962,
-0.1649546027,
-0.3078054786,
-0.0911325365,
-0.7604467273,
0.3405533731,
0.5440332294,
-0.2152519524,
-0.4716640711,
-0.6355250478,
0.2058404237,
0.6433414817,
-0.4190817773,
0.0843115747,
0.4385407567,
0.2200480103,
-0.1237867624,
0.8466367722,
0.1739244461,
0.1253207177,
-0.2770418525,
-0.2014204562,
-0.4154371917,
-0.6341512799,
-0.6659279466,
0.2323942184,
0.0934408903,
0.0019098397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03145v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03145v2 | Evaluating the Robustness of Machine Reading Comprehension Models to Low Resource Entity Renaming | 2023-04-06T15:29:57 | 2024-04-16T18:04:14 | Clemencia Siro, Tunde Oluwaseyi Ajayi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question answering (QA) models have shown compelling results in the task of
Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC). Recently these systems have proved to
perform better than humans on held-out test sets of datasets e.g. SQuAD, but
their robustness is not guaranteed. The QA model's brittleness is exposed when
evaluated on adversarial generated examples by a performance drop. In this
study, we explore the robustness of MRC models to entity renaming, with
entities from low-resource regions such as Africa. We propose EntSwap, a method
for test-time perturbations, to create a test set whose entities have been
renamed. In particular, we rename entities of type: country, person,
nationality, location, organization, and city, to create AfriSQuAD2. Using the
perturbed test set, we evaluate the robustness of three popular MRC models. We
find that compared to base models, large models perform well comparatively on
novel entities. Furthermore, our analysis indicates that entity type person
highly challenges the MRC models' performance. | [
-0.5563469529,
-0.9258001447,
0.2789739072,
0.0591399074,
-0.1966700703,
0.0162845813,
-0.1338013858,
-0.5192648172,
-0.1085632741,
0.5440908074,
-0.665405333,
-0.0672804415,
-0.7723742127,
0.5699772835,
-0.4606056809,
0.9399155974,
-0.3720891178,
-0.3658853173,
-0.3087772131,
-0.5705814958,
-0.1818475276,
-0.4407420754,
-0.7953909039,
-0.2246229202,
0.4720070362,
0.3960860074,
1.0598053932,
0.5321822166,
0.6895192862,
0.2702069879,
-0.3883558214,
0.1774272323,
-0.3560443819,
0.3270022869,
-0.0026389651,
-0.6030674577,
-0.1480608135,
-0.078747347,
0.375297308,
0.716853857,
-0.2209759206,
0.3818131387,
0.2457202226,
0.3571663499,
-0.6649497151,
0.042103678,
-0.9828984141,
-0.1616734862,
0.1868259907,
-0.0737473294,
-0.5389008522,
-0.1508678645,
0.4210368693,
-0.5187477469,
0.5429345369,
-0.0343893543,
1.3275114298,
0.5526584387,
-0.3107533455,
-0.369620949,
-0.7081851959,
0.6407608986,
-0.6166661978,
0.2812635303,
0.7577412724,
0.4149996042,
0.0575805046,
-0.5750297904,
-0.6476824284,
-0.2571640909,
0.1304464191,
-0.0339731872,
-0.075602904,
-0.1069460809,
0.4641910791,
0.0786562264,
-0.4456565082,
-0.062232025,
-0.2913872302,
-0.0396948569,
0.2885452211,
0.1552807689,
0.2986685634,
-0.2392069399,
-0.5494551659,
-0.0360361747,
-0.6082330346,
0.2447882146,
0.4390432835,
0.4451125264,
0.2333818823,
0.6913291812,
-0.1440000385,
0.5247982144,
-0.1848994792,
-0.0834173933,
-0.1837689579,
-0.0813726932,
-0.5309968591,
-0.1749712974,
0.2905735373,
0.0620579943,
0.3166939318,
-0.4170841277,
-0.2430596799,
-0.0216821805,
0.4129356742,
-1.0074079037,
-0.3607197404,
0.2599425316,
-0.6200157404,
-0.198709771,
-0.050064791,
-0.5842173696,
-0.3905038834,
-0.0877361223,
0.5561303496,
-0.7325055599,
-0.0211821105,
-0.145884186,
0.0857479498,
0.1681343019,
0.1618296355,
-0.954836905,
0.2572112083,
0.439314723,
0.7375251055,
0.0060543786,
-0.3892250955,
-0.1576403081,
0.0441413894,
-0.1106829718,
0.8228999376,
-0.5154637098,
-0.5221869349,
-0.2792789638,
0.0239892621,
-0.4024018645,
-0.5884209275,
0.267916292,
-0.9066771269,
-0.1032122225,
-0.404966265,
-0.1611368358,
-0.1538100243,
0.4476443827,
-0.6812435389,
0.6624763608,
0.3893150985,
-0.9874455333,
0.2717734277,
-0.5185802579,
-0.6112195253,
-0.4008817971,
0.34470734,
-0.5585460663,
-0.2510204017,
0.5403416157,
0.1025681049,
-0.4252413809,
-0.3256902397,
-0.4822614789,
-0.1980978996,
0.5914117098,
-0.5886510611,
0.9667450786,
0.4179386795,
-0.0948527008,
-0.3625825047,
-0.571976006,
0.345100373,
0.147017777,
-0.285084337,
-0.354155302,
0.0487421043,
-0.1903007478,
-0.0120810531,
-0.2403366119,
-0.2843589187,
0.1056397781,
-0.2483585179,
0.7054501176,
0.6289882064,
0.3254728019,
0.3431349695,
-0.2970678508,
1.0015583038,
0.0912158564,
0.1272999197,
-0.1629653275,
-0.5285983086,
-0.8571120501,
-0.3476185203,
0.8736690283,
0.741920054,
-1.2590744495,
-0.162811622,
-0.2190671265,
-0.4941626787,
-0.7386313677,
-0.2317383736,
0.2217889875,
0.6840798855,
0.6358386874,
-0.0459440649,
-0.2055774182,
-0.9279339314,
-0.5597932935,
-0.5176672339,
-0.3299960792,
0.4772745967,
0.6004904509,
-0.3355837762,
0.7014264464,
-0.3836899698,
0.0813245028,
-0.1035195142,
-0.0626090169,
-0.1633513272,
0.2420786321,
0.4680209458,
-0.7187671065,
-0.084852241,
-0.5548015833,
-0.3664231002,
0.0312093049,
-0.1468316913,
-0.2383465618,
0.29179883,
0.1781285256,
-0.5232613683,
0.4037861824,
0.4300988615,
-0.5469309092,
0.5042544007,
0.0782700181,
0.4050563872,
-0.9789866805,
0.1751995683,
-0.1731252968,
-0.0916424617,
-0.274374485,
0.362667799,
0.0641182661,
-0.3817890584,
-0.304348737,
0.2443562448,
-0.3732413352,
-0.0080480054,
0.1688065976,
0.0718741491,
-0.0245946161,
0.1545291245,
-0.3076555431,
0.6618002057,
0.2897227407,
-0.7682349682,
-0.012380112,
0.5951917171,
-0.2981682122,
0.5697962046,
-0.6337550282,
0.2611255944,
-0.1386136264,
0.1744456887,
-0.7665029168,
-0.195469141,
0.0294622853,
-0.5319497585,
0.2768434882,
-0.4483348131,
-0.4687877297,
-0.3023452461,
0.2005009949,
0.3986018002,
0.2569132149,
-0.6815906167,
0.59087497,
0.194123432,
-0.2752218843,
-0.7172047496,
-1.1251398325,
0.0251089223,
-0.3457424939,
-0.7157490253,
0.1107747853,
0.0960575938,
-0.0331169888,
0.1465253979,
-0.1560452729,
-0.3465259373,
0.5004221201,
0.3892593086,
0.2088803798,
-0.3032155037,
0.1283587813,
-0.1510433406,
-0.1022510454,
-0.1020889431,
0.1846307218,
0.3284904659,
-0.0473536104,
-0.2394779623,
-0.2378868908,
0.1584715992,
0.4278137088,
-0.6773187518,
1.048368454,
0.2333180457,
-0.6835824847,
-0.4302595854,
-0.0970771685,
-0.2820456028,
-0.4015970528,
0.4233876765,
-0.7379214764,
-0.673260808,
0.8113533854,
0.1951258928,
0.1493714899,
0.6520186663,
0.3722853661,
-0.0952576473,
0.7132751942,
0.471277684,
0.1952646673,
0.0917972326,
-0.4004642963,
0.4101006687,
-0.788618207,
-0.1771629602,
-0.8778465986,
-0.5028365254,
-0.5004637241,
-0.455237478,
0.0784039646,
0.2045362443,
-0.251832217,
0.549138248,
-0.4123173058,
0.5199277401,
0.2494108081,
0.0065002455,
0.3221259415,
0.0389908962,
-0.1778529584,
-0.0926066265,
-0.5567997694,
-0.9363565445,
1.0095877647,
0.4469271004,
0.6592296958,
0.2658227682,
0.4011897743,
0.1512069404,
0.6358554959,
-0.5179725289,
0.4206902981,
-0.115215078,
-0.689701438,
-0.4712754786,
-0.6809760928,
-1.0769619942,
0.2401037514,
-0.2089929283,
-0.5800200701,
0.2025785893,
0.0008305984,
-0.7399763465,
0.5463309884,
-0.6268488169,
0.8555751443,
0.1404763758,
0.2760102153,
-0.085394308,
-0.336142391,
0.332064867,
0.0610345453,
-0.1286090165,
-0.1653950363,
-0.2961196601,
0.5522340536,
-0.4433495998,
0.1991020292,
-0.0983417779,
0.0801788718,
0.5988045931,
0.6549324393,
0.3793839216,
0.3598373532,
-0.4859046042,
0.0779650956,
0.3288170993,
-0.6841431856,
-0.688403964,
0.6482697725,
-0.7051581144,
-0.2569411099,
-0.1704555154,
-0.4319501817,
-0.5025812387,
0.0025919997,
0.3075883389,
0.4375521541,
-0.1228730455,
0.096506983,
0.5998945832,
-0.2146882862,
0.3765482306,
0.6936535239,
0.2047761083,
-0.3891991079,
0.6098967791,
0.4010413289,
0.4012866318,
-0.0109776724,
-0.3826143444,
-0.4161934853,
-0.7394539714,
-0.7016559839,
-0.0054955008,
-0.642231226,
-0.3157381415,
-0.6907955408,
-0.1548624933,
-0.2110079676,
-0.0521428138,
-0.1998315305,
-0.5448344946,
-0.3270351589,
-0.0060529313,
0.0814273581,
0.3310703635,
0.5091695189,
0.2026066482,
-0.5088682175,
0.5301405787,
0.2972570956,
0.4007310271,
-0.0397056676,
-0.8467803597,
-0.0274429433,
0.0815911517,
-0.4175798893,
-1.0918475389,
0.1349435747,
0.0638449192,
0.1787001789,
0.3965363503,
0.5609548688,
0.7857450843,
-0.2799999118,
0.6996741295,
-0.4248830676,
-0.6738491058,
0.3088525832,
-0.0730473399,
0.194862783,
0.7213720083,
0.3394364417,
-0.4187602401,
-0.511960268,
-0.8920747638,
-0.8534343243,
0.5043631196,
0.4241506159,
-0.0860408023,
-0.1007983461,
0.6466692686,
0.0056011681,
0.0574231371,
-0.2580043375,
-0.2323176265,
0.0602373593,
-0.1870111823,
0.0414014645,
-0.3247862458,
-0.0319757313,
0.3026916683,
0.9400308132,
-0.0634479895,
0.2337841839,
0.5737056732,
-0.3416729271,
-0.2531324029,
0.207694605,
0.2739661336,
0.6049656868,
0.0465384647,
0.1302908361,
0.3863922954,
-0.3071564138,
0.2118491381,
0.3909297884,
-0.5589933395,
-0.2557544112,
0.534219265,
0.6205466986,
-0.0303706527,
-0.5927288532,
-0.0042331791,
-0.3044993877,
-0.0249612611,
0.0387025885,
0.0441420637,
-0.0134390322,
0.2991057038,
0.2168004513,
0.4364898801,
0.0706309751,
-0.5432275534,
0.1079803184,
0.340641886,
-0.3326734602,
-0.0595138408,
0.9568609595,
0.1891783029,
-0.3198796809,
0.9893257618,
-0.2158643156,
-0.6262565255,
1.0691491365,
0.4541212618,
0.6576961279,
-0.1288718134,
0.2575608492,
0.3947812021,
0.8877130747,
0.0316760652,
0.2318350375,
0.1375017762,
-0.6225358844,
-0.1735649854,
-0.5752817988,
-0.460581094,
0.1041942313,
-0.7101761699,
-0.084649995,
-0.4095853567,
-0.5570937395,
0.0435483307,
0.2472155243,
-0.8263325095,
0.4132389128,
-0.0411771722,
0.9000964761,
-0.6379131675,
0.4431503117,
0.9042268991,
-0.2199901044,
-0.7646342516,
0.3729920685,
-0.3433350921,
-0.4013293982,
0.0369008929,
0.2064419538,
0.2074329108,
-0.0321597494,
-0.2006543428,
-0.9504307508,
1.0989888906,
0.5227401257,
-0.1502989084,
0.1171407923,
0.0100826416,
0.5911282897,
0.0217442475,
0.3723287582,
0.6135469079,
0.5235877633,
-0.0925363079,
-0.8220723271,
0.1750579029,
0.183867678,
0.0394498743,
0.1499775499,
-0.8905515671,
0.623467803,
-0.8892987967,
-0.6326187849,
0.3358348608,
0.9295914173,
0.1631071866,
0.3307021558,
0.8315469623,
0.7298954725,
0.9432538748,
-0.2676819563,
1.3137495518,
-0.0193276294,
0.3917571604,
1.02787292,
-0.1568539739,
0.9348207116,
0.2436083406,
-0.5093978643,
0.3471412063,
0.9558693171,
-0.0618457869,
0.3339286447,
0.2218311727,
0.0695855543,
-0.2989602983,
0.1671366692,
-0.1232766882,
0.3904456794,
-0.0764196739,
-0.3179870844,
-0.0497495309,
-0.1246878803,
-0.045565214,
0.0355027691,
-0.2003365755,
0.3405744135,
-0.0198768396,
-0.7397706509,
0.7092742324,
0.3373482227,
0.2419415563,
-0.3188750148,
0.3926132619,
-0.2683975995,
0.3517628312,
-0.0956965461,
-0.6503554583,
0.396737963,
0.0994021147,
-0.3556416631,
0.0905556008,
0.417147547,
-0.5379444957,
-0.4389585853,
0.1059603542,
0.3165054023,
0.0675460026,
-0.191837579,
-0.8440017104,
-0.1833570302,
0.0714369342,
-0.4080484509,
0.3015530407,
0.4062413275,
-0.0522688515,
1.0906820297,
0.4619069695,
-0.0885215253,
0.028458314,
-0.0528003424,
0.3946073651,
-0.4268255234,
-0.3900046945,
-0.7271750569,
0.13256827,
0.2947543263,
-0.4015642405,
0.6580482125,
0.4033447206,
0.5399588943,
-0.0033984976,
0.4965654016,
-0.0222076289,
0.4564103186,
-0.3184572458,
1.0767757893,
-0.2956074476,
0.1782545894,
-0.0458182581,
-0.9513997436,
-0.0374689065,
0.1850704998,
0.0097244168,
0.1100144908,
0.626396358,
0.7154231071,
0.0626099631,
0.1626780033,
0.1740487516,
0.3808607757,
0.2576279044,
0.4480209053,
0.6489169002,
-0.6628957987,
0.9417617321,
-0.3939002156,
0.0551494211,
-0.0241141021,
-0.5171792507,
-0.9493349195,
-0.5774427652,
-0.4654735327,
-0.8014116287,
0.2266070098,
0.4888158739,
0.529515028,
-0.9763249159,
0.485626936,
0.558945775,
0.2332684249,
-0.3718810081,
-0.2628749609,
0.6098927855,
-0.0939602852,
-0.6212931871,
0.3288962245,
-0.0912061185,
0.3475693166,
-0.1701928228,
0.0892634168,
0.0235286411,
0.4789249599,
0.4079296589,
0.3019352257,
-0.5444456935,
-0.2503672838,
-0.0384427011,
-0.172722742,
-0.3631378412,
0.7095088959,
-0.8935582042,
0.4562924206,
0.3255503774,
0.9493805766,
0.0866238773,
0.4775615335,
0.2342438847,
-0.3871303499,
0.0175140779,
0.4374576509,
0.304769665,
0.5140987039,
-0.2374969274,
0.6524251699,
0.0806514025,
-0.647919476,
-1.0341408253,
0.1086004078,
-0.5807692409,
-0.1689458191,
1.1128846407,
-0.3462697864,
-0.2762527168,
-0.0117581589,
0.0241902471,
0.3201358616,
-0.2201034278,
1.1897830963,
0.7828794718,
0.0149900708,
0.0486888476,
-0.6110345125,
0.3835444748,
0.5356883407,
-0.7743531466,
0.0992460623,
0.1304935217,
0.5394216776,
-0.0779420659,
0.3468322158,
-0.1328068376,
0.1589825898,
0.1187474355,
-0.1437593997,
-0.2064591199,
-0.212165162,
-0.1174789295,
0.2752403915,
-0.0199889634,
-0.2528336048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03098v1 | Static Fuzzy Bag-of-Words: a lightweight sentence embedding algorithm | 2023-04-06T14:25:46 | 2023-04-06T14:25:46 | Matteo Muffo, Roberto Tedesco, Licia Sbattella, Vincenzo Scotti | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ML | The introduction of embedding techniques has pushed forward significantly the
Natural Language Processing field. Many of the proposed solutions have been
presented for word-level encoding; anyhow, in the last years, new mechanism to
treat information at an higher level of aggregation, like at sentence- and
document-level, have emerged. With this work we address specifically the
sentence embeddings problem, presenting the Static Fuzzy Bag-of-Word model. Our
model is a refinement of the Fuzzy Bag-of-Words approach, providing sentence
embeddings with a predefined dimension. SFBoW provides competitive performances
in Semantic Textual Similarity benchmarks, while requiring low computational
resources. | [
-0.3709885478,
-1.0577713251,
0.5566692948,
-0.0019422546,
-0.5724092126,
0.1760578454,
-0.0562676527,
-0.4497914016,
0.3645923734,
0.4165811837,
-0.5411982536,
-0.3937603235,
-0.7416859269,
0.2455395311,
-0.8072268963,
1.1600779295,
-0.0466085635,
-0.1832605302,
-0.4502481222,
-0.181298852,
-0.3178136945,
-0.3599735796,
0.0202031787,
-0.1926313043,
0.1503733695,
0.4574653506,
1.0518881083,
0.4494433105,
0.5820361972,
0.3502853811,
-0.2719264925,
-0.2336240411,
-0.5512704253,
0.035675209,
-0.0467286408,
-0.4590417743,
0.0283304397,
-0.1295000464,
0.7957987189,
0.5154982805,
-0.6555329561,
0.1610908955,
-0.1121742725,
0.3749610186,
-0.6604704261,
-0.1460509002,
-0.8958090544,
0.1907715052,
-0.1258781999,
-0.1494977176,
-0.1483196169,
-0.1909271777,
0.0471450239,
-0.3791804016,
0.4721879959,
0.3896090984,
0.9583676457,
0.1833177805,
-0.1332055181,
-0.3530770242,
-0.2252668291,
0.723618865,
-0.6086072922,
0.3131821752,
0.3166252375,
-0.0845298395,
-0.2403883189,
-0.4138297737,
-0.6457563639,
-0.4825530946,
-0.1628925055,
-0.4295377135,
-0.0899095014,
0.0892222524,
-0.0683149621,
0.470882982,
-0.5402534008,
-0.2789974213,
-0.4272787273,
0.3277904391,
0.7953034639,
0.2620288134,
0.4205289185,
-0.2156062424,
-0.7203518748,
0.3076752424,
-0.342900902,
-0.2550972104,
0.2457826734,
0.2001576573,
-0.0626355112,
0.6911600828,
-0.4758102298,
0.7132249475,
0.1296221465,
-0.0417151116,
0.2216164917,
-0.2660605609,
-0.145519793,
0.2915495038,
0.5440658927,
0.1712155789,
0.2986314595,
-0.2760664523,
-0.6576880217,
-0.298281163,
0.5570297837,
-0.5958513618,
-0.0707818568,
0.1204248741,
-0.5517320037,
-0.7491945624,
0.3258536458,
-0.7611743808,
-0.4812959135,
-0.0360995755,
0.6050517559,
-0.6674512029,
-0.0693741292,
0.3631366789,
-0.5323308706,
0.212220028,
0.0796500519,
-0.9766110182,
0.9047735333,
0.9045725465,
1.1081528664,
0.2747847736,
-0.3468921483,
-0.4892649055,
0.0668986514,
-0.3342784345,
1.0915679932,
-0.9596954584,
-0.3280455172,
0.1835258305,
-0.3072648048,
0.320306778,
-0.2379315346,
0.5017101169,
-0.2014185786,
0.1836391836,
-0.2840597928,
-0.6485264301,
-0.2532610297,
0.1683935374,
-0.2767447829,
1.1316212416,
0.3201216161,
-0.8333722353,
0.2934998274,
-0.4355431199,
-0.3500957787,
0.4223333895,
-0.146052435,
-0.1562222689,
0.6875962019,
-0.0785933137,
0.7340809703,
-0.5456154346,
0.3404836357,
-0.5928375125,
-0.9144637585,
0.1634606868,
-0.0535974242,
0.4884221256,
0.2754797637,
-0.1296661049,
-0.1002934873,
-0.6152669787,
-0.0514961481,
0.3969388306,
-0.0328506976,
-0.4700002968,
0.3713950813,
0.3534984589,
0.0229141582,
0.2205868363,
-0.6696541309,
0.2409067005,
-0.3917954564,
0.5525369048,
0.5777561665,
-0.0763302445,
0.3186119795,
-0.34621647,
0.3195886314,
-0.0417647958,
-0.2049906105,
-0.1297907829,
-0.2162851691,
-0.4869742095,
-0.2461060733,
0.417816937,
0.4433032572,
-0.60547328,
0.6523674726,
-0.4353053868,
-0.4874080122,
-0.2993071377,
0.3180174828,
0.0803593695,
-0.0674533248,
0.1883579344,
-0.0914403945,
0.0774262473,
-0.9176566601,
-0.2766855955,
0.0645231158,
-0.1024696827,
-0.0631972179,
0.6806352735,
0.0508430824,
0.8930809498,
-1.175891161,
-0.3688886464,
-0.3188537955,
0.5187868476,
-0.0641301647,
0.6377187371,
0.8378266096,
-0.9090382457,
-0.2701395452,
-0.3260895908,
-0.4747470617,
-0.1202577651,
-0.165906176,
0.0642941147,
0.196054101,
0.5107668042,
-0.6283112764,
0.2481018603,
0.3836293519,
-0.5554493666,
0.3655595481,
-0.2616355419,
0.1603082418,
-0.9360932112,
-0.1906911582,
-0.0587601215,
-0.3161356449,
-0.4998236895,
0.297632128,
-0.2995661199,
-0.4128325284,
-0.3220259547,
0.1457822472,
-0.59420228,
0.0311392844,
-0.3706866503,
0.6120977402,
-0.0869805962,
0.5238831043,
0.0049186246,
0.5649908781,
0.5427885056,
-0.225263685,
0.4805997908,
0.1053939834,
-0.4562340975,
0.8611608744,
-0.6557152271,
0.0350219905,
-0.4512791932,
0.4238472283,
-1.0201627016,
-0.0642133355,
0.2306786627,
-0.1989732236,
0.3138355315,
0.4024677277,
-0.7584301233,
-0.2974370718,
-0.8811220527,
0.3951050937,
0.4209859669,
-0.2163206041,
0.371162653,
0.4029455483,
-0.3110459447,
-0.3426441848,
-0.9056595564,
0.1696170717,
-0.191554144,
-0.4803195,
0.5636235476,
0.2369137704,
-0.1554130614,
0.5160794258,
-0.10577292,
-0.3611310124,
0.1704243571,
-0.1924747378,
-0.034862604,
-0.2635250986,
0.7261689901,
0.007233195,
0.0033659621,
-0.1510701329,
-0.3006865382,
0.5250288248,
-0.3832242191,
0.016100334,
-0.1438100487,
0.9267038703,
0.2781207561,
-0.3788519204,
1.144291997,
0.8190723658,
-0.7898464799,
-0.3124980927,
-0.5571210384,
0.0762968212,
-0.5376625061,
0.4254721403,
-0.2860864997,
-0.8640034199,
-0.0146490801,
0.0016435961,
-0.0692571178,
0.3884219229,
0.1640188843,
-0.149497807,
0.7597225308,
0.9346213937,
0.0098189758,
0.51088202,
0.0935494229,
0.362300694,
-0.5762909055,
-0.0764125362,
-0.7453852296,
-0.4347371757,
-0.583199203,
-0.4547021091,
-0.1162840351,
0.3832495511,
-0.3351388872,
0.2869256735,
-0.6948277354,
0.578471303,
0.2811138034,
0.0538389459,
-0.0959348157,
-0.0633234605,
-0.2188656777,
0.276214689,
-0.790661037,
-0.4730361402,
0.4143367708,
0.0936869681,
0.7654866576,
0.1451221853,
0.9127801657,
0.6477934122,
-0.0924057961,
-0.6920422912,
0.6936615109,
-0.3868627846,
-0.4057476819,
-0.2538670897,
-0.2563128471,
-0.5245645046,
0.3183877766,
-0.7001943588,
-1.2857098579,
-0.1628031731,
-0.1992883235,
-0.3348897099,
0.422524929,
-0.657913506,
0.6301754117,
-0.1111167148,
-0.1685155332,
-0.3897318244,
-0.4474122226,
0.3728515506,
-0.0598395765,
0.0317779928,
-0.4733443856,
-0.4593965113,
0.6727539897,
-0.5470627546,
0.544503212,
0.0214569904,
-0.0546693616,
0.4953135848,
-0.042624265,
0.5416350961,
-0.0167517476,
-0.0241734963,
0.1450637877,
0.5247998834,
-0.5716001987,
-0.7710747719,
0.7496999502,
-0.3276880682,
-0.8172162771,
-0.8243209124,
-0.2946687937,
-0.1704997271,
0.1364336759,
0.0072075627,
0.6933572292,
-0.263592869,
0.6087969542,
0.4487235248,
-0.3165335953,
0.3384816051,
0.245049879,
-0.2315694541,
-0.356941998,
0.8810389638,
0.2088955045,
0.0974542648,
0.754440248,
0.29068923,
-0.1039857343,
-0.3751740754,
-0.1750049293,
0.0815493539,
-0.5610859394,
-0.4420543015,
-0.7549290061,
-0.0086486526,
-0.3511347473,
-0.809589684,
-0.0163898598,
-0.4531358182,
-0.1791933328,
-0.0652394667,
0.5765650868,
0.9620181322,
0.2179522067,
0.3635965586,
-0.9778074026,
0.4216866791,
-0.1791189611,
0.7719925642,
0.0291361008,
-0.0213260967,
-0.2569654882,
0.0285992343,
-0.2907116115,
-1.084322691,
-0.0491366498,
0.3547970057,
0.4495555162,
0.4043570757,
0.2285068184,
0.6914243698,
-0.6246772408,
1.1355050802,
0.1487417221,
-1.2378114462,
0.4755813181,
-0.361438036,
0.4860524833,
0.6506733298,
0.3513783514,
-0.5756932497,
-0.3830265105,
-0.8703615069,
-0.5612835288,
0.7687625289,
0.1595813334,
0.5088896155,
-0.1491721272,
0.3496512473,
-0.0070483498,
0.4844541848,
-0.4428088665,
0.069006592,
0.0143458908,
-0.5653807521,
-0.2405841947,
-0.5430826545,
0.2245249599,
-0.1736591011,
0.4740048945,
0.0018457089,
0.6052982211,
0.025890151,
-0.1465503126,
0.1063303798,
0.3182454109,
0.6469128132,
0.065057382,
-0.257163167,
0.1756008267,
0.6686736941,
-0.5205845237,
0.1296330839,
0.0391103216,
-0.0967944637,
0.0770758092,
0.4335695803,
0.5368183851,
0.8198074102,
-0.819965899,
0.5521467924,
0.2334442884,
-0.2076248676,
0.0632144436,
0.1434354335,
0.0167745966,
-0.0027306273,
0.2364762276,
-0.0492338389,
0.5092121363,
-0.7273468971,
0.3788197637,
0.4512280226,
-0.452688247,
0.0058740764,
0.3360610008,
0.3356200755,
-0.5782836676,
0.5028424263,
-0.0669594333,
-0.7649238706,
0.2999293506,
0.6216076612,
0.9496150017,
0.1568117142,
0.5401656032,
0.1133043841,
0.3270426691,
-0.2259816825,
0.3404955566,
-0.4489196837,
-0.436661154,
0.4039974213,
-0.9198212624,
-0.0277301297,
-0.3017424941,
-0.4387457967,
0.5353603363,
-0.4493587017,
0.1208900437,
-0.2654342651,
0.2874257863,
-0.4770276546,
0.1682750434,
0.2314502299,
1.0503102541,
-0.5610435009,
0.6537614465,
0.5575281382,
-0.4018745422,
-0.3682204187,
0.2930337787,
0.1615664363,
-0.2926934063,
0.1361238211,
0.3917786777,
-0.4446401298,
-0.0835042223,
-0.5925978422,
-1.0688539743,
1.026901722,
0.2169237435,
-0.2906783223,
0.002916649,
0.096760273,
0.5376213193,
-0.457760036,
-0.116435267,
0.1691490859,
0.2927473485,
-0.008481361,
-0.4008192122,
0.2875184715,
-0.2397110462,
0.2496964037,
0.5176701546,
-0.6798642278,
0.77214396,
-0.0134703945,
-0.3978276551,
0.1171558648,
0.7646400928,
-0.1772900075,
-0.0748248771,
0.5095945597,
0.5662843585,
0.8380989432,
-0.0273312423,
1.0463429689,
-0.2784831822,
0.6127153039,
0.9155907631,
-0.3515157998,
1.2954243422,
0.2174140662,
-0.1406747699,
0.6174539924,
0.2993915677,
-0.3100374639,
0.5350536704,
0.6374213696,
-0.2793692946,
-0.1437443048,
-0.1680427492,
-0.4043366611,
0.7601111531,
0.2282556891,
-0.1971378028,
-0.467872709,
-0.0916940719,
-0.061917685,
0.2331285477,
-0.1950086355,
0.7075120211,
0.0933350995,
-0.452141732,
0.570544064,
0.3503381014,
0.9843851328,
-0.6972756982,
-0.1548590809,
0.2310584038,
0.0673489198,
-0.0538852699,
-0.8216782808,
0.6224452853,
0.1699818969,
0.1346217245,
-0.2418910116,
0.9957683086,
-0.4882451296,
-0.8614805341,
0.0086577823,
0.1754560024,
0.0273428187,
0.1646130979,
-0.6993320584,
0.0755326375,
-0.5258021951,
-0.051004488,
0.3415503502,
0.5503236055,
0.2277367413,
0.7138483524,
0.3022129536,
-0.3088685572,
-0.1262088716,
-0.4727007449,
0.6289521456,
-0.9122663736,
-0.79853338,
-0.7603943944,
0.2348564714,
-0.1297618896,
-0.4637880027,
0.3508080542,
0.3016726971,
0.5796880722,
-0.078828685,
0.384252727,
-0.3195455074,
-0.1014212519,
-0.6990050077,
0.9561199546,
-0.8999686241,
-0.0543274544,
-0.4906177223,
-0.802673161,
-0.1839736998,
0.7374557257,
0.074784115,
0.0329730697,
0.9032481313,
0.6196964383,
0.0094430689,
0.4453219473,
0.2592921555,
-0.0291768909,
-0.1377213448,
0.4197629988,
0.4860673547,
-0.349681437,
0.287917465,
-0.1421225816,
-0.1129593402,
-0.2338115126,
-1.0820257664,
-0.6817083359,
-0.9618355036,
-0.231191963,
0.1640221179,
0.2413535863,
1.2107957602,
0.3669829965,
-0.5476801991,
-0.0190791413,
-0.1534200311,
0.2354677469,
-0.4111136794,
-0.2401144952,
0.0848375708,
-0.5417353511,
-0.3667320013,
-0.1155358106,
0.3061350286,
-0.068013072,
-0.3288886845,
0.2914324701,
-0.8384425044,
0.6306037903,
0.5779234767,
-0.3427400291,
-0.7234877944,
-0.6703208089,
-0.3199827671,
-0.1395397782,
-0.1162529513,
0.7149966359,
-0.7857777476,
0.0349296704,
0.7005394101,
0.5965162516,
0.1065150127,
0.1313441098,
0.7766386271,
-0.6942204237,
0.191075027,
0.1343996823,
0.4192165136,
0.2820153534,
-0.4747422636,
0.4094695449,
0.1979640573,
-0.1298874468,
-0.9988845587,
-0.057790257,
-0.8721554875,
-0.535009861,
1.1202987432,
-0.1445051879,
-0.2077972889,
0.1518840343,
-0.2762594521,
-0.0745752975,
-0.2702864707,
0.8089783192,
1.1677645445,
0.2788127661,
-0.2027402371,
-0.1849917024,
0.3558038175,
0.1830262244,
-0.653636694,
-0.0787496269,
0.3568970561,
0.2907942533,
0.2676655948,
0.5746700168,
0.2015806884,
0.1790166497,
0.6642999053,
-0.360994786,
-0.0558306985,
-0.3486520946,
-0.4552921355,
0.5280222297,
-0.1724412143,
-0.1968598217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03087v1 | Investigating Chain-of-thought with ChatGPT for Stance Detection on Social Media | 2023-04-06T14:12:02 | 2023-04-06T14:12:02 | Bowen Zhang, Xianghua Fu, Daijun Ding, Hu Huang, Yangyang Li, Liwen Jing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Stance detection predicts attitudes towards targets in texts and has gained
attention with the rise of social media. Traditional approaches include
conventional machine learning, early deep neural networks, and pre-trained
fine-tuning models. However, with the evolution of very large pre-trained
language models (VLPLMs) like ChatGPT (GPT-3.5), traditional methods face
deployment challenges. The parameter-free Chain-of-Thought (CoT) approach, not
requiring backpropagation training, has emerged as a promising alternative.
This paper examines CoT's effectiveness in stance detection tasks,
demonstrating its superior accuracy and discussing associated challenges. | [
-0.7820074558,
-0.8030077815,
0.7275704145,
0.1929812133,
-0.6944574714,
0.3066115379,
-0.1725278348,
-0.2598203719,
0.4367343187,
0.3031900525,
-0.6348870993,
-0.6669790149,
-0.9510874152,
-0.4074215293,
-0.3344195187,
1.3946805,
-0.2712527514,
-0.1028683409,
0.3382715583,
-0.4046761394,
-0.2275952846,
-0.7843019366,
-0.9112383723,
-0.1449638009,
0.6535918713,
0.0820815861,
0.9529329538,
-0.0690744743,
0.2730998993,
0.1122403815,
-0.2809154093,
0.2370351255,
-0.5440021157,
0.0308801103,
-0.284280777,
-0.1903905869,
-0.6794290543,
0.1955136806,
0.6122803688,
0.2767350078,
0.0001196037,
0.0470679402,
0.0013291345,
0.9320756793,
-0.7266744375,
-0.2114174515,
-0.8166021109,
0.1603207141,
0.1074947566,
0.0567807443,
-0.3335057497,
-0.3180254698,
0.106087707,
-0.1698885709,
0.2063392401,
0.050804425,
0.7352535129,
-0.0314792879,
-0.5343299508,
-0.35003829,
-0.6743928194,
0.5627972484,
-0.5215962529,
0.6103543639,
0.4690643549,
0.0824038982,
-0.3420187831,
-0.4506706595,
-0.7580360174,
-0.0870293528,
0.2215394974,
0.2090547383,
-0.1443801522,
0.1155743375,
-0.0838003159,
0.4209264815,
-0.4256437123,
-0.157278806,
-0.0870766193,
0.1111135855,
0.4950192869,
-0.1916598082,
0.1586757153,
-0.3726622462,
-0.7251527905,
0.006895402,
-0.5566837192,
0.0157376025,
0.3943687379,
0.3019828796,
-0.2232443839,
0.588973999,
-0.1195128039,
0.3962891102,
0.4039013982,
0.5284951925,
-0.0515738502,
-0.1913636327,
-0.3434309065,
0.0587658882,
1.1784546375,
0.2288425863,
0.2011640668,
0.1889391392,
-0.1746170968,
0.1635812521,
0.4348894954,
-0.4181162417,
-0.2954741418,
0.3212897182,
-0.4343157113,
-0.5531986356,
-0.0027742032,
-0.6117781401,
-0.6382218599,
-0.2091404498,
0.2180183828,
-0.5297849178,
-0.6517087817,
0.0809498355,
-0.0009161846,
0.7398828864,
0.3857324123,
-0.7339010239,
0.1988569945,
0.9374467731,
1.1401695013,
-0.2827355266,
-0.0056686951,
-0.4300267398,
-0.1049131602,
-0.7074514031,
0.9734308124,
-0.3586522937,
-0.4205423892,
-0.2511524558,
-0.0633064359,
-0.0380197316,
0.0270846207,
0.4271193743,
-0.4074183404,
-0.030453546,
-0.4708352089,
-0.645291388,
0.1298117787,
0.8358877897,
-0.6726232171,
1.0522441864,
-0.1298045069,
-0.9458224177,
0.6284704208,
-0.4162592888,
-0.2160602063,
-0.1600244343,
-0.515519619,
-0.4284566641,
0.0262034237,
0.4319363534,
0.5173333883,
0.1641628742,
0.1472234577,
-0.5512382984,
-0.1906978339,
0.2402718961,
-0.5335232019,
0.8351038098,
0.2561436296,
-0.6020545363,
0.3445273638,
-0.2527626157,
0.0393261984,
-0.0016786602,
-0.0087804124,
-0.2879681587,
0.2293764651,
-0.2349936962,
0.4707166255,
-0.1225651056,
-0.3558403254,
0.2475652397,
-0.2604963481,
0.2438390553,
0.8600188494,
0.329856962,
0.2653496861,
-0.0125283878,
0.4445993602,
0.0128357382,
0.3306346536,
0.5700241327,
-0.6248121262,
-0.6479075551,
-0.0544976555,
-0.1082766503,
0.2628300786,
-0.7714337111,
0.3554719388,
0.0066023474,
-0.5913368464,
-0.3203011155,
0.2827136517,
0.397998035,
-0.0265357923,
0.2486401647,
-0.430315733,
-0.3743777275,
-0.5613504052,
-0.5181712508,
-0.4960733354,
0.3194814324,
-0.0661716685,
0.4133325815,
-0.141376704,
0.810477078,
-0.3515262902,
0.0297679454,
-0.4622603357,
0.4234176576,
-0.0386842526,
0.190788582,
0.4865982533,
-1.0189055204,
-0.5350502133,
0.0848982111,
-0.5540248156,
0.4584466517,
0.0160564836,
-0.4424319267,
0.3172078729,
0.480750531,
-0.7964935303,
0.5336446762,
0.6131392717,
-0.3511410654,
0.5577108264,
0.1920661032,
0.2174489051,
-1.2463138103,
-0.2499209195,
0.2807039022,
-0.4495057762,
-0.6470387578,
0.0382020213,
-0.0777873471,
-0.1478515863,
-0.9146189094,
0.2051659971,
-0.2806466222,
-0.1060765237,
-0.3593353629,
0.3008915186,
-0.19433254,
0.4301195145,
0.3634006679,
0.6174526215,
0.316809237,
-0.5373892784,
0.0436704606,
0.1692773551,
-0.1085448116,
0.7333253622,
-0.3396084309,
0.7199342847,
-0.2089523077,
0.5625292659,
-1.3625637293,
0.0892059207,
0.4740000963,
-0.4511666596,
0.0019605504,
-0.4687348306,
-0.3462670743,
-0.4897914529,
-0.7266142368,
0.2450660169,
0.2786501944,
-0.5514480472,
0.2870453894,
0.3652666509,
0.148117274,
-0.7346536517,
-0.2699341774,
-0.0965713039,
-0.2417738885,
-0.0805987716,
0.0751069039,
0.2777249515,
-0.2594158351,
-0.2517251372,
-0.3702264726,
0.041598957,
-0.3629108667,
0.0617565475,
0.1479663104,
-0.1222970188,
0.1776334643,
-0.0423488244,
0.0029900484,
0.0010120659,
-0.4861997664,
0.8689616323,
-0.698318243,
-0.3012231886,
-0.4390987754,
0.1153130159,
0.7714806795,
-0.0952609181,
0.6558073163,
0.908169806,
-0.1573276818,
-0.3114545047,
-0.3275694847,
0.294449985,
-0.4920933843,
0.0375587232,
-0.0547136888,
-0.5475724936,
0.2615999579,
-0.1428159475,
-0.0771465674,
0.0962226614,
0.5919461846,
-0.3469458222,
1.0149714947,
0.4561574161,
-0.3816226125,
0.6694250107,
-0.382863909,
0.5985409021,
-0.7490337491,
0.1742359102,
-0.1119733006,
-0.2895100117,
-0.8160177469,
-0.5421608686,
0.1404495388,
0.1433826387,
-0.2889021933,
0.5207760334,
-0.4773752391,
0.4107865393,
0.0867859274,
0.4900102913,
0.1640490741,
-0.2253598869,
0.1361302584,
0.3321787715,
-0.2954645157,
-0.6121385098,
0.8417198062,
0.221835956,
0.5526586175,
0.0267076232,
0.7988094687,
0.4372410774,
0.2978735268,
-1.1084491014,
0.775734961,
-0.2276134193,
-0.473896116,
-0.2640234828,
0.0109191975,
-0.7552339435,
0.318361491,
-0.1514635533,
-0.8627070785,
0.1300806552,
0.4791076183,
-0.1404435933,
0.8634440303,
-0.4393654466,
0.6122025847,
-0.2732326984,
-0.4309833348,
-0.2838583589,
-0.5477417707,
0.1373405457,
0.2764930725,
-0.0363335796,
-0.1440060437,
0.1239411086,
0.7592679262,
-0.4198866189,
0.951716423,
-0.3376754224,
-0.3596661687,
0.7450702786,
0.0610798709,
0.7887700796,
0.0045371726,
0.0305399057,
-0.061765857,
-0.149620086,
-0.4818927646,
-0.4977043867,
0.6997634768,
-0.6764155626,
-0.4701440036,
-0.3100983799,
-0.2652682662,
-0.6145837307,
0.0772697479,
0.4055032432,
0.0088899238,
-0.5693686008,
0.1211417466,
0.6154085398,
-0.1080665141,
0.5309770703,
-0.1224943101,
-0.4445157349,
-0.3739940524,
0.7928485274,
-0.0528160371,
0.4231331944,
0.1960127354,
0.2712651491,
-0.410263747,
-0.3353524804,
-0.2937764227,
-0.0395644866,
-0.7073373795,
0.1122933328,
-0.6010893583,
-0.2060977519,
-0.2173517644,
-0.3935690224,
-0.7781425714,
-0.2842230201,
0.1991163343,
-0.5392062664,
0.5624603629,
0.7147216797,
0.3015661538,
0.4688386619,
-0.1605037153,
0.4300727844,
0.193227917,
0.5498287678,
-0.0193660948,
0.23191607,
0.1847447604,
0.2406733781,
-0.5611962676,
-0.9117559195,
0.136907801,
-0.2020299435,
0.1915302277,
0.4387684464,
0.0799630359,
0.5275521278,
-0.1387084424,
0.8957132101,
0.4205796123,
-0.9104397893,
0.815639317,
-0.6843753457,
0.008829671,
0.5815022588,
0.7933014035,
-0.3520818055,
-0.515568316,
-0.7179226875,
-0.777172327,
0.2070434093,
0.3776164055,
0.123258099,
-0.3163169622,
0.1524391174,
0.0884368792,
0.3577625155,
-0.7477285266,
0.1502749026,
-0.3262459934,
-0.0780576691,
0.0057470123,
0.1702720672,
0.2678472102,
-0.4353814125,
0.4694088697,
-0.0842929557,
0.4723399282,
0.2519204915,
-0.1930330396,
0.0146041028,
0.4507672191,
0.3090026379,
0.5451904535,
-0.2255136967,
0.1375534981,
0.3870205879,
-0.584007144,
0.2908025086,
-0.6601648927,
-0.0165360589,
0.1242944002,
-0.0461637639,
0.8884729147,
0.1514865756,
0.033738561,
0.6500948071,
0.1486264616,
-0.3856554925,
-0.4692725539,
-0.0528573543,
0.1161234677,
0.1035697684,
-0.098462373,
0.0390020236,
-0.0136005552,
-0.7947173119,
0.2623392045,
0.5475510359,
-1.1237758398,
-0.3601187766,
0.3306773007,
-0.0999139249,
-0.3806696832,
0.2524172664,
-0.1457567215,
-0.6256887317,
0.5420312881,
0.5071958899,
1.1180622578,
-0.0722164884,
0.7115343213,
-0.0881588683,
0.0281908214,
-0.1462980509,
0.4677993059,
-0.2563073933,
-0.8968628645,
-0.0956362784,
-0.3195459545,
-0.5849674344,
0.2589145005,
-0.6709796786,
0.6062770486,
-0.9804386497,
-0.5302987099,
-0.0166550782,
-0.0691395402,
-0.719037652,
0.2060225755,
0.2755669355,
0.5327189565,
-0.7158145308,
0.9204610586,
0.7173340321,
-0.3302454948,
-0.8134174943,
0.5994995832,
0.2092854679,
-0.712796092,
0.2210576385,
0.1425060481,
-0.8440819979,
-0.0240912195,
-0.6839185953,
-0.3899896741,
0.8239408731,
0.1964841336,
-0.4229766428,
0.0813659951,
-0.1049663424,
0.6966683865,
-0.2086078525,
-0.0788124427,
0.4295669198,
0.0646556541,
0.0465998054,
-0.6523743272,
0.0151010361,
-0.0779787526,
-0.0487414114,
0.5649613142,
-0.8834690452,
0.8786774874,
0.0873440653,
-0.0632162616,
-0.4129719436,
0.5094951987,
0.335665226,
0.359228611,
0.7184785604,
0.320230484,
0.7239314914,
0.2262120396,
1.0429295301,
-0.0447568372,
0.4952908158,
0.9233016968,
-0.5335530639,
1.2309421301,
0.6420242786,
-0.1354142725,
0.8071473837,
0.5982613564,
0.3120314181,
0.4586076438,
0.1092127189,
-0.4696043432,
-0.0937647521,
0.2068914771,
-0.1632620394,
0.4115167558,
0.5075569153,
-0.418101579,
-0.1222637296,
-0.0472718962,
0.2289609164,
-0.0865926892,
-0.6539168358,
0.9002615213,
0.2330037206,
-0.6492475271,
0.5279176831,
-0.5213997364,
0.6408162713,
-0.4198823869,
0.1888282001,
0.0129253576,
0.2255028188,
-0.1997181475,
-1.0980490446,
0.2622509897,
0.18425937,
0.2435904294,
-0.1728974134,
1.0614911318,
-0.0220572371,
-0.3873022497,
0.5173919797,
0.5915181637,
0.0581165403,
-0.2203299105,
-0.6473286748,
-0.1289204508,
-0.2207822055,
-0.4473531544,
0.3753230572,
0.4635326266,
-0.387585789,
0.4417184293,
0.5516183376,
-0.1073276401,
-0.1060482338,
0.0954808295,
1.0249450207,
-0.6184629202,
-0.7313558459,
-1.0775769949,
0.2607488334,
-0.3043865561,
-0.3035338223,
0.5308732986,
0.1861521304,
0.7716009021,
0.1121643186,
0.7822626233,
-0.2276941836,
0.020395752,
-0.5718450546,
0.8415302634,
-0.2292472273,
0.002398805,
-0.8572340608,
-0.7675020099,
-0.1006465927,
0.6469758153,
-0.7703732848,
-0.0570845492,
0.948530674,
0.5851564407,
-0.2913678885,
0.4154315591,
0.0419604257,
-0.2178386003,
0.4103531837,
0.4453070462,
0.9243066907,
-0.2497115582,
0.4972742498,
-0.1399672031,
-0.1094478294,
0.032154955,
-0.9772936702,
-1.0813099146,
-0.5669414401,
-0.2384070307,
-0.4951346219,
0.3302078247,
1.3257483244,
0.7392727733,
-0.9501550794,
-0.1323153973,
-0.6401025057,
0.1314069182,
-0.4580734968,
-0.1439273059,
0.509586513,
-0.3284007311,
-0.3287517428,
0.2163371593,
0.0829425231,
-0.0194381084,
-0.0533063747,
-0.0953408182,
-0.679541707,
0.1917884648,
0.9811908603,
0.2628962398,
-0.740360558,
-0.6294090748,
-0.1081254184,
0.0018967713,
0.3324538171,
0.9424150586,
-0.5634655952,
0.2518066168,
0.4821196496,
0.4554941356,
0.6894164085,
0.408064574,
0.7515605092,
-0.9395161271,
0.3685088158,
0.212414816,
0.3227414787,
0.2298077792,
-0.5433625579,
0.3925136328,
0.0953074247,
-0.2503798008,
-0.5514005423,
0.4385289252,
-1.1392782927,
-0.261143297,
1.1425346136,
0.0364355668,
-0.2693378031,
-0.1778149754,
-0.5795944929,
0.4558824003,
-0.375072211,
0.6902214289,
0.7304478288,
-0.3628153503,
-0.2315937728,
-0.5062769055,
0.6100094914,
0.3006379306,
-0.5127447844,
0.1987474859,
0.0419924632,
0.1362027228,
0.0104367537,
1.1065950394,
-0.0950336382,
0.0372039974,
-0.0332393497,
-0.2329477668,
0.4027434289,
-0.3102554381,
-0.0558257103,
0.1313649863,
0.145005852,
-0.4000974596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03047v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03047v3 | ETPNav: Evolving Topological Planning for Vision-Language Navigation in Continuous Environments | 2023-04-06T13:07:17 | 2024-01-22T04:57:32 | Dong An, Hanqing Wang, Wenguan Wang, Zun Wang, Yan Huang, Keji He, Liang Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.RO | Vision-language navigation is a task that requires an agent to follow
instructions to navigate in environments. It becomes increasingly crucial in
the field of embodied AI, with potential applications in autonomous navigation,
search and rescue, and human-robot interaction. In this paper, we propose to
address a more practical yet challenging counterpart setting - vision-language
navigation in continuous environments (VLN-CE). To develop a robust VLN-CE
agent, we propose a new navigation framework, ETPNav, which focuses on two
critical skills: 1) the capability to abstract environments and generate
long-range navigation plans, and 2) the ability of obstacle-avoiding control in
continuous environments. ETPNav performs online topological mapping of
environments by self-organizing predicted waypoints along a traversed path,
without prior environmental experience. It privileges the agent to break down
the navigation procedure into high-level planning and low-level control.
Concurrently, ETPNav utilizes a transformer-based cross-modal planner to
generate navigation plans based on topological maps and instructions. The plan
is then performed through an obstacle-avoiding controller that leverages a
trial-and-error heuristic to prevent navigation from getting stuck in
obstacles. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed
method. ETPNav yields more than 10% and 20% improvements over prior
state-of-the-art on R2R-CE and RxR-CE datasets, respectively. Our code is
available at https://github.com/MarSaKi/ETPNav. | [
-0.4662119448,
-0.7842989564,
0.7427102327,
0.0938545167,
-0.2294985205,
0.1757506132,
-0.2957611382,
-0.5721985698,
0.5035146475,
0.3447565138,
-0.5600371361,
-0.6152309179,
-0.2575087249,
-0.2143279612,
-0.0437814854,
0.3639988601,
-0.0688571483,
-0.3089469969,
-0.0379388221,
-0.318302691,
-0.5620571375,
-0.3820126355,
-0.5104956031,
-0.2293713987,
0.5652891397,
0.7074772716,
0.7157966495,
0.5345618129,
0.3041752279,
0.259762615,
-0.1447375864,
0.5611006021,
-0.4585296214,
0.3976081908,
-0.2908633947,
-0.2197946161,
-0.3828996718,
-0.7686459422,
0.7365041971,
0.5844306946,
-0.3348512053,
-0.2001148015,
-0.0456664041,
0.8532275558,
-0.6830887794,
0.2776381075,
-0.3527311683,
0.2932390869,
0.0050812564,
-0.3784043491,
-0.2761057615,
-0.0223666672,
0.1356311589,
-0.9415938854,
-0.2788860798,
0.2320044935,
0.5673570633,
0.6551680565,
-0.2639625072,
-0.0657826066,
-1.2309490442,
0.4606257677,
-0.0377050824,
0.797118783,
0.0736310557,
0.5909233689,
-0.1996265501,
-0.7206425071,
-0.5813976526,
-0.2477514297,
0.1956145614,
0.5055241585,
0.0653729439,
0.0466622524,
-0.0794115514,
-0.3683395088,
-0.6500191092,
0.1472406238,
-0.6717275381,
0.2312507927,
0.4659796059,
0.304540813,
0.3111341596,
0.0919044688,
-0.430962503,
-0.2833258808,
-0.7401855588,
0.2950964272,
-0.2592599988,
0.2265791297,
-0.131054759,
0.6562855244,
-0.4500359297,
0.790446341,
-0.3005695343,
0.0598872527,
0.0508882441,
-0.1833175719,
-0.0320929214,
0.1237539798,
0.1401920021,
0.6342254281,
0.4008207917,
-0.0768567473,
-0.0976505578,
0.0148173077,
0.5276734233,
-0.1739878803,
-0.5281767249,
0.2969747782,
-0.1796825379,
-0.0652201548,
-0.2404811978,
-0.8616393805,
-0.3007990718,
-0.4397182763,
0.1461894661,
-0.3952971101,
-0.3537170291,
0.2065298259,
-0.0818086714,
0.6524854302,
0.5950102806,
-0.360653013,
0.4325282872,
0.629878819,
0.9388050437,
-0.1876279414,
-0.2278009057,
-0.6527113914,
0.2590542138,
-0.3237666786,
0.6502081156,
-0.6413327456,
-0.7195341587,
0.0206778739,
0.0005973367,
-0.0994618684,
-0.1366012245,
0.4685037136,
-0.2362586111,
-0.0636724234,
-0.0486158468,
-0.1075852141,
-0.3912194669,
0.5282025933,
-0.4739983976,
0.9703766108,
-0.0496648401,
-0.1286877841,
0.24968189,
-0.9454311132,
-0.455598563,
0.304356575,
-0.3820368648,
-0.4195371568,
-0.2008490264,
0.1412521154,
0.2049024701,
0.1394700408,
-0.0038890697,
0.1013472751,
-0.3012239039,
-0.240521878,
0.1794879287,
0.5832248926,
-0.0178654436,
-0.7526019812,
0.2312781215,
-0.5948947072,
0.1655189693,
0.2700839341,
-0.219413057,
-0.4815422893,
0.5962669253,
0.2595238686,
0.3351758122,
-0.0091869365,
-0.3481311798,
0.2475337982,
-0.5173361897,
0.0038964043,
0.6552964449,
0.018906625,
0.7366604209,
-0.347158134,
0.5710393786,
-0.2180357575,
0.4231528342,
-0.0763631985,
-0.920858562,
-1.2867524624,
0.0028097301,
-0.3137364089,
0.6284651756,
-1.0153497458,
0.3612465858,
-0.5378162861,
-0.7318895459,
0.3149728179,
-0.4039007425,
0.3662775755,
0.2004538029,
0.6504361629,
-0.1743519306,
-0.2727591991,
-0.3842107058,
0.1126437858,
-0.0876410902,
0.0065863952,
0.4139233828,
0.4964012802,
-0.2413963377,
0.7256428599,
-0.5181610584,
-0.3446386158,
-0.2452204078,
-0.4007518291,
-0.0993857309,
0.6920456886,
0.4351378977,
-1.0861353874,
-0.4003075361,
0.3718517125,
-0.6479712725,
0.224334985,
-0.4465178847,
-0.3418234289,
0.1554153115,
0.6306107044,
-0.419978857,
0.6475121379,
0.4068654478,
-0.4559957385,
0.2772261798,
-0.3955200315,
-0.1571750194,
-0.9002951384,
0.084280245,
0.1503333747,
-0.3321175873,
-0.8121103048,
0.7937693,
-0.1102384403,
-0.0202113241,
-0.5200085044,
0.6190392971,
-0.6421120167,
-0.0872678161,
-0.0637055114,
0.4311284721,
-0.197120145,
0.909799397,
0.5540059805,
0.1229052842,
0.6122885346,
-0.9571580291,
0.3383920789,
0.408942461,
0.022578381,
0.5377194285,
-0.5568377376,
0.2420529723,
-0.0089704609,
0.4541858137,
-0.3907969892,
0.1206699461,
0.7800522447,
-0.3887845278,
0.2610257864,
-0.2451260686,
-0.1867131442,
-0.0496679619,
-0.1029461622,
0.3320787251,
0.4549550414,
-0.4303334653,
1.3294528723,
0.2850346565,
-0.1227880418,
-0.2676956952,
-0.5819589496,
0.3008721173,
-0.1043435633,
-0.4497970343,
0.187683925,
-0.2722869515,
-0.3018041551,
-0.1667136997,
-0.1614507139,
-0.0294366237,
0.0405684076,
0.4668410122,
0.504116714,
0.098037675,
-0.0780993924,
0.1162440777,
-0.3132448494,
0.0658042878,
-0.7813051939,
0.501603961,
-0.2636195719,
-0.5120558143,
-0.0212894604,
0.3560397327,
0.3144809902,
-0.4876452088,
0.512834549,
0.1506745666,
-0.4211222529,
-0.4665880203,
-0.015982559,
0.0308745317,
-0.4826002419,
0.3401268721,
-0.5337480903,
-0.5522040725,
0.2696340978,
-0.4198641181,
0.3987898529,
0.1917193085,
0.5037308931,
-0.2287634164,
0.3781494498,
0.8234699368,
0.3957946897,
0.3046860993,
-0.5200638771,
0.2323696017,
-0.7274238467,
-0.7602334023,
-0.3977791369,
-0.6391900778,
-0.6916367412,
-0.9497056007,
0.9369860291,
-0.5129801631,
-0.0885075852,
0.4331083,
-0.7750542164,
0.5475625396,
0.4883241653,
0.1709027588,
0.221159339,
-0.0495493151,
-0.2994115055,
0.2293562293,
-1.0409981012,
-0.1354402602,
0.7891080379,
0.2878423035,
0.5203363895,
0.150270313,
0.5687820315,
0.1178343818,
-0.3947580457,
-0.6685672402,
0.7038140893,
0.5102431178,
-0.4066194892,
-0.6357873678,
-0.1650187075,
-0.8138592839,
0.2983661294,
-0.368584007,
-1.020829916,
0.7027238011,
0.187396884,
-0.343658179,
0.3900367022,
-0.312084496,
0.4766276777,
-0.3780295849,
-0.34429124,
-0.4210854173,
-1.1095644236,
-0.0237560794,
-0.0086461613,
-0.0011301952,
0.2778147161,
-0.2949455082,
0.1039540097,
-0.1572106481,
0.6546586156,
-0.2926343083,
0.1461405754,
0.2339672446,
0.4204411209,
0.742264688,
0.116559267,
0.2145549208,
0.2773198783,
-0.2780636847,
-0.2613066137,
-0.2152491808,
0.4900311232,
-0.355280906,
-0.1022175327,
-0.5989026427,
-0.154505983,
-0.1030491143,
0.0232308563,
0.2495216876,
0.5124019384,
-0.3995870948,
0.1348237395,
0.7514177561,
-0.4863861501,
0.4811549783,
0.3064736128,
-0.3159153461,
0.0497579426,
1.0606306791,
-0.0138569735,
0.3411951661,
0.5452315807,
-0.0102312583,
-0.1590373665,
-0.5964273214,
-0.6461905241,
-0.3199016154,
-0.6995535493,
0.0138894767,
-0.5464498401,
-0.5133721828,
0.3172061145,
-0.6916872859,
-0.5482446551,
-0.651102066,
0.0761243999,
0.1176803783,
0.1103940234,
0.6405774951,
-0.3470100462,
0.0017544889,
-0.6172277331,
0.3164412677,
0.1045442596,
0.131238237,
-0.2619232833,
0.0250993408,
-0.2695622146,
0.0334142372,
0.0037195405,
-0.5068304539,
0.2856138647,
0.4065960348,
0.5281792283,
0.1530032307,
0.3515724838,
0.4271230996,
-0.5703554153,
0.5694540143,
0.0688391253,
-0.4109508097,
0.5733054876,
-0.3130438328,
0.5287179351,
0.4695490003,
0.2178114504,
-0.6615481973,
-0.60498631,
-0.52975595,
-1.0707060099,
0.3269005418,
0.66998142,
-0.3058224916,
0.398627907,
0.2081438601,
-0.1978621334,
-0.1038346216,
-0.6061658263,
-0.3824399114,
-0.3097729683,
0.2022715956,
-0.0000796354,
0.1897987872,
-0.2679954767,
-0.4460791647,
0.4672342241,
-0.3158927262,
0.3291811645,
0.4159761667,
-0.227186203,
-0.0022470013,
-0.034024898,
0.8239104748,
0.6686505079,
0.0364214927,
-0.2021559924,
0.3544502854,
-0.4366066158,
-0.0066821128,
0.1416467726,
-0.3610788286,
-0.0481509753,
0.107610859,
0.3971277177,
0.0887297392,
-0.6349236965,
0.2428822964,
-0.1125567332,
-0.1003270373,
-0.7178801298,
0.2266913056,
0.0680426732,
0.4909879267,
0.1682641953,
0.3045836389,
0.195318833,
-0.2874847353,
0.0648825243,
-0.0327268057,
-0.5243470073,
-0.158414647,
0.6550214291,
0.5510077477,
-0.438710779,
0.6219763756,
-0.2671847343,
-0.6577089429,
0.7035274506,
0.094842419,
0.9833477139,
-0.1808759421,
0.1727234572,
0.3937558234,
0.6519806981,
0.2735183835,
0.4512937665,
-0.5351267457,
-0.6153512597,
-0.0909106433,
-0.4522233605,
-0.5342128277,
-0.6804006696,
-0.1200570837,
0.2181791216,
-0.6851836443,
0.3591987193,
-0.6326189041,
-0.3658040166,
-0.7262948155,
0.4232179224,
0.365709573,
0.7912823558,
-0.1833523214,
0.757062614,
0.7256814241,
-0.0269903149,
-0.6556184292,
0.2200964391,
0.369730711,
-0.7238969207,
0.1597680002,
0.0045246226,
-0.6923778653,
0.0262771919,
-0.2693410516,
-0.7518112063,
1.1753731966,
-0.2976368368,
-0.9740828276,
-0.2413818091,
0.1726301908,
0.3832970858,
-0.2114051878,
-0.0801993161,
0.3674047887,
0.6948593855,
0.1275787801,
-0.8334624171,
-0.009796666,
-0.4574522078,
0.0894438699,
0.2689864337,
-0.645622015,
0.2958197594,
-0.3596896529,
-0.3956070244,
0.2627806067,
0.4634319842,
0.3442275524,
0.337862283,
0.7938347459,
0.447761476,
0.4736193717,
-0.2547586262,
0.7941430807,
-0.4735400379,
0.0202365462,
1.2643072605,
-0.1898248345,
0.8362609148,
0.3383786678,
0.4110864401,
0.5855563879,
0.5190830827,
0.1710435003,
0.6599787474,
0.0735916048,
-0.2736164629,
-0.2670124471,
0.166972965,
-0.3814431727,
0.5181244612,
0.4397147894,
0.1197957546,
-0.0669332966,
0.1082329676,
-0.1989776343,
0.1471323669,
-0.1691800654,
0.6885227561,
0.1682476401,
-0.5283549428,
0.3494689465,
-0.1375245452,
0.1291621178,
-0.6476010084,
-0.2986304462,
-0.0312408302,
0.0846648514,
-0.0187335461,
-0.9446501136,
0.3592984378,
-0.2169678658,
0.619056046,
-0.1532576382,
0.8077768683,
-0.1813506782,
-0.286849916,
0.4186579883,
0.6773968339,
0.0070246086,
-0.0123616289,
-0.50045681,
-0.0032267293,
-0.0575060025,
-0.2779910266,
-0.1349688321,
0.2210324854,
-0.0537768528,
1.0517247915,
0.6025382876,
-0.0621856451,
0.1948742121,
-0.2577720582,
1.0594457388,
-0.8088548183,
-0.8604610562,
-0.3493273854,
0.9925633669,
-0.153091073,
-0.3567682505,
0.2749062479,
0.4997262657,
0.9328913093,
0.1907143146,
0.4907869399,
-0.2731970549,
-0.1702473164,
-0.7047230005,
0.6980355978,
-0.7091267109,
0.1068474129,
-0.2155192792,
-1.2746026516,
-0.3365300298,
0.7005062103,
0.1345932186,
-0.0241015814,
0.7548674345,
0.7368748784,
-0.2557837069,
-0.3320433199,
0.4788759053,
-0.0348861627,
0.420860678,
0.7780706286,
0.8800150752,
0.0020041238,
0.4838631153,
-0.1477119178,
-0.1834060848,
-0.2652498484,
-0.6251019239,
-0.5603340864,
-0.8338578343,
-0.1213679761,
-0.121218279,
0.418921411,
0.9437009692,
0.8562463522,
-0.1903837621,
-0.1524951607,
-0.4723703265,
0.0226560105,
-0.3395576477,
-0.0985324457,
-0.1528582722,
0.1105903983,
-0.6235974431,
0.9840462208,
0.6670864224,
-0.2345363796,
-0.5027809739,
-0.6352514625,
-0.1918928921,
-0.0827361941,
0.4342556298,
0.7999734282,
-0.5281286836,
-0.4597751796,
0.0598565787,
0.1636696905,
0.3077041805,
0.5212115645,
-0.7788892984,
0.972579062,
0.2298820764,
0.3994259834,
0.8814411163,
-0.3110300899,
0.848097682,
-0.5645791292,
0.247771576,
0.4770810306,
0.410344094,
0.1366045624,
-0.2970353067,
0.8359004259,
-0.0338493437,
-0.5767529607,
-0.2595698833,
0.3057230413,
-1.3806672096,
-0.2554472685,
1.1275154352,
0.0988502875,
-0.298383832,
-0.188097924,
-0.3267252147,
0.0738643929,
-0.3135846555,
0.6500799656,
0.0615632236,
-0.1010230705,
-0.1905914247,
-0.5729241967,
0.2687441111,
0.0285902303,
-0.8863019943,
-0.3154374659,
0.6178672314,
-0.1304956973,
0.3355270922,
0.469943434,
0.3112518787,
0.6060651541,
-0.0114516458,
0.1567154676,
-0.0628744289,
-1.0134493113,
-0.1420386434,
-0.0098465141,
-0.0630678982,
-0.345227778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03030v1 | Compression of enumerations and gain | 2023-04-06T12:29:53 | 2023-04-06T12:29:53 | George Barmpalias, Xiaoyan Zhang, Bohua Zhan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT, math.LO | We study the compressibility of enumerations, and its role in the relative
Kolmogorov complexity of computably enumerable sets, with respect to density.
With respect to a strong and a weak form of compression, we examine the gain:
the amount of auxiliary information embedded in the compressed enumeration.
Strong compression and weak gainless compression is shown for any computably
enumerable set, and a positional game is studied toward understanding strong
gainless compression. | [
-0.3961365819,
-0.3815561235,
0.3590801358,
0.1813578159,
-0.0995169207,
0.1622079611,
-0.0954564363,
-0.6513548493,
0.492941767,
0.3240145147,
-0.000024065,
0.1103772819,
-1.0731748343,
0.0502000935,
-0.2014783174,
0.4518792331,
-0.120174773,
-0.1627987623,
-0.6149853468,
-0.4087717533,
-0.5806654692,
-0.9334785342,
-0.3173653483,
-0.2531104386,
0.2432846278,
0.5547118783,
0.8609762192,
0.1880951673,
0.4815281928,
0.4896232784,
-0.0479758419,
0.0354264639,
-0.8856058121,
0.9485591054,
0.3249693811,
-0.5904314518,
0.2535586953,
-0.4203861356,
0.8228157163,
0.8322686553,
-0.1224346012,
0.0303392056,
0.1356149465,
0.7020662427,
-0.6220136285,
-0.0298378989,
-0.3182261884,
0.1400631666,
0.0021443302,
-0.667108953,
-0.3039067686,
-0.6316052079,
-0.3180357814,
-0.4091348946,
0.1414096653,
0.1299168915,
0.4185728729,
0.5021338463,
-0.0786205977,
-0.4193795323,
-0.6848057508,
0.8266294003,
-0.1611713767,
0.437933296,
0.6542169452,
0.0329890251,
-0.1080633625,
-0.1628502011,
-0.1142144874,
-0.0636725202,
-0.0362794586,
0.2025758922,
-0.0906753987,
0.1374187768,
0.7003739476,
0.6585011482,
-0.5488869548,
-0.0930196419,
-0.6534463167,
0.0056806495,
0.6238487363,
-0.0715664253,
0.3454036117,
0.0894802362,
-0.0492032096,
-0.0936450288,
-0.6386104226,
0.0271360371,
0.7411121726,
-0.0725689828,
-0.1002180651,
0.8485364318,
-0.2158520222,
0.8587393165,
-0.0737387985,
-0.1024534404,
-0.0029445351,
-0.4155759811,
-0.2970426977,
0.3228667974,
0.1258372068,
-0.0174487773,
0.0406116247,
-0.551910758,
-0.1442157179,
0.01333124,
0.2984820604,
-0.7637284398,
-0.2247835398,
0.4270849526,
-0.6688501239,
-0.2976848781,
0.3554757535,
-0.2103441507,
-0.5279849172,
-0.1878118217,
0.7989577055,
-0.2744915783,
0.0798304155,
0.1294360906,
-0.7979922295,
0.0062376643,
0.1220846772,
-0.7460107207,
0.452370286,
0.3910352588,
0.7878538966,
0.153115198,
0.0107369535,
-0.4366892576,
0.0042134621,
-0.2688593268,
0.9395667911,
-0.5767262578,
-0.4789544642,
0.1536944658,
-0.0944943726,
0.2169692218,
-0.7306868434,
0.4850185215,
-0.4244078994,
-0.3469048738,
-0.3040514588,
-0.7708494663,
-0.1911300123,
0.2850607336,
-0.9412609339,
0.7578511238,
0.3212429583,
-0.5321074724,
0.6189900041,
-0.1713970602,
-0.7030442357,
0.2188180536,
-0.0524298921,
-0.1240957454,
0.6800203323,
-0.2922188938,
0.3695816994,
-0.0518117286,
-0.5752776861,
-0.4552169144,
-0.8830779195,
0.4121967852,
0.0833726749,
0.5397265553,
0.1602430791,
0.133113116,
-0.3007816076,
-0.5142912269,
0.2581811547,
0.0125647401,
-0.6978751421,
-0.6321800351,
0.2006401271,
-0.7114433646,
-0.0244780611,
0.2996012568,
-0.3913908005,
0.737495482,
-0.2706639767,
0.1611844003,
0.4944908917,
0.5160514116,
0.5365738273,
-0.5918016434,
0.4893222153,
-0.1849259585,
0.0963841677,
0.3051537275,
-0.6166832447,
-0.649052918,
-0.0540508442,
0.6315748692,
0.5294950008,
-0.9830815792,
0.3643744588,
-0.1361681521,
-0.5927434564,
-0.1099502146,
0.0068619698,
-0.0732375085,
0.027281113,
-0.0192200877,
-0.2342319489,
-0.6450878382,
-0.6874165535,
-0.0046847742,
-0.2644748986,
0.0121273734,
0.3154309392,
0.424292773,
0.1825778484,
0.0227984488,
-0.3484552801,
0.2067208141,
-0.1042813957,
0.3445311487,
0.5417215824,
0.7966224551,
0.2018298507,
-0.7654064298,
-0.2838940322,
-0.4093553722,
-0.6689522862,
0.0092442427,
-0.07076893,
-0.0923472047,
-0.2433563322,
0.1563788801,
-0.8895707726,
0.5452739596,
0.2556285262,
-0.4859322309,
0.3774199784,
-0.5695567727,
0.450994432,
-0.6248683929,
-0.1937329322,
-0.7014145255,
-0.2995250523,
-0.571823895,
0.327688247,
-0.1740241647,
-0.1073665619,
-0.1826182157,
-0.1922890097,
-0.5462251306,
-0.4878206849,
0.1375296712,
-0.0683560073,
-0.062820442,
0.1526650041,
0.0600515231,
0.479796499,
0.7127198577,
-1.1282044649,
0.5641277432,
0.1001127958,
-0.5462206006,
0.5182113051,
-0.9716299772,
0.0266446024,
-0.3980080783,
0.0958303213,
-0.7057976723,
-0.2103862613,
0.140706107,
-0.4501825869,
0.3179441094,
-0.0031177187,
-0.763225615,
-0.3538278937,
-0.5511746407,
0.799621582,
0.6406459808,
-0.2743556201,
-0.1118470803,
0.4343843162,
0.0365980566,
-0.3449564278,
-0.7500036359,
-0.2521751523,
-0.2151619494,
-0.3458575904,
0.4593114555,
-0.5328261256,
-0.6276090145,
-0.2332585305,
0.0429274477,
-0.0537458397,
0.0555240884,
0.5508843064,
-0.0315454304,
0.2988981903,
0.5855440497,
-0.1776960492,
0.3669686615,
-0.2957163155,
-0.3142338097,
0.7138451934,
0.2324507236,
-0.1744639724,
0.3730505705,
0.7749308348,
0.2615212202,
0.4787414968,
0.6808472872,
0.030565219,
-0.6904542446,
-0.1016079932,
-0.2601562142,
0.0421554148,
-0.4944529533,
0.0278315842,
-0.4156737626,
-0.835208714,
0.7875587344,
0.2641369402,
-0.202630356,
0.6188996434,
0.5791833997,
0.1182115525,
1.028024435,
0.3026461005,
0.2623950839,
0.1815759093,
-0.4951199293,
0.0277372673,
-0.3960479498,
-0.3689954579,
-1.1063759327,
-0.8819452524,
-0.5486225486,
-0.4659810066,
0.1107481495,
0.4868721962,
-0.3192602098,
0.5627868176,
-0.7251618505,
0.8150814176,
0.6345418096,
0.182863757,
-0.0943384469,
0.0105927298,
0.4341627359,
0.1109995544,
-0.9200282097,
0.160503611,
0.8040562272,
0.0677575916,
1.0248736143,
0.7300080657,
1.0360225439,
0.6468690634,
-0.2450263798,
-1.2274963856,
0.2242788672,
0.0481069274,
-0.2132907361,
-0.3610183895,
-0.6182696223,
-1.2543975115,
-0.4016244113,
-0.2329017222,
-0.8308896422,
1.0027354956,
-0.0367833339,
-0.4569007754,
0.2190981805,
-0.7017219663,
0.3108349741,
-0.0211589448,
-0.2313848734,
-0.2538846135,
-0.2953261733,
0.2641510665,
0.4249591529,
-0.0318438411,
0.4042049646,
-0.3594216108,
0.9957866073,
-0.4133765399,
0.2943750918,
-0.2341754735,
0.1876021624,
0.455776751,
0.4765534103,
0.5434058905,
0.265671283,
-0.1099442318,
-0.1130911782,
0.2089093179,
-0.7338577509,
-0.7643371224,
0.6704220772,
-0.6761094332,
-0.0638821945,
-0.3537095487,
-0.6069903374,
-0.1624432802,
-0.1738468707,
0.6993293166,
1.0754851103,
-0.0097104022,
0.5657274127,
0.9148846269,
-0.2142365128,
0.4613297284,
-0.1065288186,
0.234472394,
-0.3421827853,
1.0804415941,
0.6470392942,
0.2736986279,
0.5304459929,
-0.0035886902,
-0.3317315578,
-0.3922173381,
0.0448174328,
-0.0861744583,
-0.9163509607,
-0.5764805675,
0.0626275837,
-0.1976419687,
-0.4286278486,
-0.4409690499,
0.001087344,
-0.9252939224,
0.0526907742,
0.0493316613,
-0.0024849887,
1.2238595486,
-0.1119066328,
-0.0386017673,
-0.5907685757,
0.3312245309,
0.5222532153,
0.4165392518,
-0.1673848182,
-0.3394601047,
-0.5057832003,
-0.1258557141,
-0.1319418103,
-1.0898382664,
0.3252984583,
0.4227123559,
0.5770812035,
0.7053956389,
0.4008997083,
0.6771463752,
0.0009802711,
1.0402801037,
0.1908327043,
-0.4394592941,
0.1358740777,
0.1745913476,
0.5467220545,
0.5089349747,
0.4800487757,
-0.1187584549,
-0.1689389497,
-1.2604014874,
-0.4210992754,
0.2441690117,
0.2502460182,
0.0762815177,
-0.0792506933,
0.1884837747,
0.3306101263,
0.4684571326,
-0.5556365252,
-0.1412904859,
-0.1713983268,
0.0014692217,
-0.2856702805,
-0.5707071424,
-0.2961618602,
-0.3286300898,
0.3912928104,
0.26706478,
1.0252349377,
0.5375193357,
-0.374052763,
-0.1149918735,
0.3443025351,
0.7863680124,
0.3890264034,
-0.4032313526,
0.7476522923,
-0.0581062138,
-0.3552066088,
0.3325888515,
-0.0466412194,
0.0314645804,
0.0010425104,
0.6385689974,
0.7932516932,
0.4637832046,
-0.5081054568,
0.2406762689,
0.1415691078,
-0.4673850238,
-0.1137774214,
0.1506961435,
-0.4452443123,
0.1615869701,
0.2265896648,
0.1210012808,
0.5721577406,
-0.8125344515,
-0.0086333267,
0.5194439888,
-0.4322746098,
-0.1041293368,
0.3029966056,
-0.0397594869,
-0.4274812043,
0.5791872144,
-0.3479429781,
-0.6797348261,
0.7294794321,
0.8126923442,
0.6029703021,
0.0418576747,
0.1477977186,
0.5636152029,
0.366253078,
-0.1980959624,
0.6071131825,
-0.7336229682,
-0.6167747974,
-0.2529171109,
-0.3546223044,
-0.36130476,
-0.1617184877,
-0.4421801865,
-0.0953920782,
-0.3210457563,
-0.0703892633,
-0.2497778386,
0.1644282043,
-0.6072039008,
-0.0453378819,
-0.1476149261,
1.0698435307,
-0.4123619199,
0.2148893178,
0.3909333944,
-0.2611863613,
-0.7104207873,
-0.2595759332,
-0.701798439,
-0.7042033076,
0.8140265942,
0.0568118915,
0.230780825,
-0.092385523,
-0.8911698461,
-0.785744369,
0.9030819535,
0.233231619,
-0.0724185556,
0.22172378,
-0.0761703104,
0.1999548525,
-0.1252133846,
0.1350260228,
0.1532358974,
0.7272042036,
0.2196698636,
-0.4226650298,
0.0069321459,
-0.3241956532,
-0.1551317722,
0.441006273,
-0.5003159642,
0.7707665563,
0.0757426172,
-0.2964357734,
0.0613879934,
0.3684738576,
-0.0420774482,
-0.1318135411,
0.5691590905,
0.7532315254,
0.9263755083,
-0.2984241247,
1.4488427639,
-0.4283021092,
0.1510949433,
0.3928158283,
0.154470101,
0.7890571356,
0.5233322978,
-0.4995124936,
0.221879378,
0.6960404515,
0.1801792085,
0.4176257849,
0.4413168728,
-0.5041615963,
-0.2572034299,
-0.0309637394,
-0.6893294454,
0.1852701902,
0.3112757504,
-0.4068968296,
0.3561627567,
-0.2917815149,
-0.3361621201,
-0.3547825217,
-0.6507611871,
0.6874523759,
-0.0922143906,
-0.8833794594,
1.0225321054,
-0.4665369093,
0.4606329501,
-0.7661678791,
-0.1688594669,
0.191200465,
-0.2536547184,
-0.1378914863,
-0.8777121305,
0.4497380257,
-0.6516680121,
-0.1831118762,
-0.0670157075,
1.3934206963,
-0.4668519497,
-0.3835866451,
-0.2452482283,
0.1590830088,
0.420540303,
-0.0532859415,
-0.1257516891,
0.329033047,
-0.3886334598,
-0.1826979369,
0.1954965144,
0.1293133944,
0.3952927291,
0.5616458654,
0.1276453733,
0.4502444267,
0.0802295953,
-0.0442830101,
0.5224508047,
-0.4635074735,
-0.6717033982,
-0.4301408529,
0.1839297861,
-0.4839579165,
-0.0708935186,
0.7308043242,
0.555637598,
0.3001383245,
-0.342381537,
0.7263184786,
-0.4466078877,
-0.0116850827,
-0.5906119943,
0.5092669725,
-0.4683793783,
-0.3783757389,
-0.1989314407,
-0.9578137994,
-0.4234954119,
0.672317028,
0.0007502261,
-0.2069469094,
0.4708123803,
0.3274413347,
0.0871678367,
-0.1531274021,
0.5864695907,
0.1243829131,
-0.4270786643,
0.7070763707,
0.8086595535,
-0.3725246191,
0.2905974984,
-0.3019904792,
-0.2653970718,
-0.1380945593,
-0.7275779247,
-0.4694696069,
-0.7417824268,
-0.308734864,
-0.5995006561,
-0.1114297733,
0.6158229709,
0.9011110067,
-0.5757252574,
-0.249925226,
-0.2410613596,
0.5913560987,
-0.6384726763,
-0.1903196871,
0.196543321,
0.0195356868,
-0.6884124279,
0.4108854532,
0.2520811856,
0.3105011582,
-0.231738627,
-0.4770348668,
0.0156344064,
0.5354406238,
0.742851615,
0.6152813435,
0.0252542198,
-0.3524374664,
-0.4585743248,
0.3433746994,
-0.3097105324,
0.9951809049,
-1.022543788,
0.5289576054,
1.3219895363,
0.3670337796,
0.1869991869,
0.1795772165,
0.5097416043,
-1.0617752075,
0.6583726406,
0.181721434,
0.6389015913,
0.1028282791,
-0.5515543818,
0.6253862977,
0.3470906913,
-0.9399772882,
-0.9863282442,
0.2623479068,
-1.1970876455,
-0.1276373863,
0.9582006335,
0.1250319928,
-0.0468318351,
-0.1619563252,
-0.3366336524,
0.2539660335,
-0.2823797762,
0.5440098643,
1.0210870504,
-0.371574074,
-0.1686353832,
-0.3792739511,
0.662828207,
-0.0363629349,
-0.6715974808,
-0.3892729878,
0.4471678436,
-0.6226770282,
0.4027717412,
0.3998167515,
-0.0816395208,
0.1873480082,
0.5536840558,
-0.3078024685,
0.0282096602,
-0.2191966176,
-0.2690455616,
0.7096130848,
0.2516263127,
-0.095104605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02993v1 | Natural Language Robot Programming: NLP integrated with autonomous robotic grasping | 2023-04-06T11:06:30 | 2023-04-06T11:06:30 | Muhammad Arshad Khan, Max Kenney, Jack Painter, Disha Kamale, Riza Batista-Navarro, Amir Ghalamzan-E | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.HC | In this paper, we present a grammar-based natural language framework for
robot programming, specifically for pick-and-place tasks. Our approach uses a
custom dictionary of action words, designed to store together words that share
meaning, allowing for easy expansion of the vocabulary by adding more action
words from a lexical database. We validate our Natural Language Robot
Programming (NLRP) framework through simulation and real-world experimentation,
using a Franka Panda robotic arm equipped with a calibrated camera-in-hand and
a microphone. Participants were asked to complete a pick-and-place task using
verbal commands, which were converted into text using Google's Speech-to-Text
API and processed through the NLRP framework to obtain joint space trajectories
for the robot. Our results indicate that our approach has a high system
usability score. The framework's dictionary can be easily extended without
relying on transfer learning or large data sets. In the future, we plan to
compare the presented framework with different approaches of human-assisted
pick-and-place tasks via a comprehensive user study. | [
-0.1956230998,
-0.6866171956,
0.4006671309,
0.1970717311,
0.0636968389,
-0.0097400043,
-0.0131244911,
-0.6177861094,
0.4979656339,
0.6458435059,
-0.5492482781,
-0.592508316,
-0.5103108287,
0.2280400693,
-0.4973712265,
0.377298981,
0.0984529853,
-0.2931209207,
-0.0318947099,
-0.1461465508,
-0.2989022732,
-0.604988873,
-0.4913881421,
-0.2723812759,
-0.0138491783,
0.2972405553,
1.3009814024,
0.7984296083,
0.8583741784,
0.3256805837,
-0.1792401075,
0.2499908656,
0.3430112302,
-0.1653750241,
-0.4910392165,
-0.233836472,
-0.3530754149,
-0.1785282344,
0.3183687031,
0.9150666595,
-0.4047706127,
-0.0782312229,
-0.213164255,
0.5459367633,
-0.5186489224,
-0.0150843849,
-0.2883732319,
0.3883687854,
0.220317468,
-0.0897446424,
-0.084251374,
-0.1590468884,
0.1429915726,
-0.8340532184,
0.0206293594,
0.0239921547,
0.9297677279,
0.5337996483,
-0.1768197715,
-0.7587215304,
-0.5618914962,
0.7666739225,
-0.8675953746,
0.2774371207,
0.6216561794,
0.4848951101,
-0.4473526776,
-0.4940469265,
-0.8058768511,
-0.4877412021,
-0.0812777653,
0.0406450033,
0.1404368877,
0.4019965827,
0.1390557289,
0.252260536,
-0.6094833612,
-0.0114448741,
-0.1633417308,
0.1314636618,
0.7194076777,
0.0166520998,
0.5865421891,
-0.460961163,
-0.3561216891,
-0.2585591674,
-0.1452118754,
0.224155724,
0.3888746202,
0.8111206889,
-0.301574111,
1.0724998713,
-0.4036290944,
1.1876804829,
-0.1910544336,
0.1003483832,
0.1751974672,
-0.5142952204,
-0.4552747905,
-0.4252372384,
0.8312378526,
0.4467763603,
0.1835964024,
-0.2723471522,
0.064512603,
0.0307747666,
0.4738619924,
0.1817414165,
-0.1974253803,
0.4202925861,
-0.4250981808,
-0.1437140256,
0.1865506172,
-0.4006638527,
-0.2925075293,
-0.6001352072,
0.1408785582,
-0.4455463886,
-0.0676359087,
0.6753367782,
-0.2265048176,
0.374701798,
0.1808629483,
-0.9962367415,
0.6352728009,
0.7312914133,
0.8286396265,
-0.1826018691,
-0.3206360638,
-0.6615810394,
0.35848248,
-0.2973098159,
0.7767944932,
-0.4263806343,
-0.2820709944,
0.221579954,
-0.2117011845,
-0.1576085687,
-0.5762182474,
0.4478420615,
-0.2409441322,
0.5092789531,
0.0921563581,
-0.3905072212,
-0.425917685,
0.5037732124,
-0.6742942929,
1.1972812414,
0.2730171382,
-0.1668925881,
0.5496068597,
-0.973036468,
-0.7702387571,
0.1471163779,
-0.0690105781,
0.1235745251,
-0.3272039294,
0.1458462924,
0.6172708273,
0.2483226061,
0.4041075706,
-0.3908398151,
-0.0302806422,
-0.0789646581,
0.1908638477,
0.9912529588,
0.0117987283,
-0.034987025,
0.033714287,
-0.7045941353,
0.1356365234,
-0.2096825093,
-0.6885975599,
-0.1653379649,
0.3041982353,
-0.0321476087,
0.4693905115,
0.3446624875,
-0.3563762009,
0.578522265,
-0.9338473082,
0.1771730334,
0.0874524042,
-0.17819345,
1.0949504375,
-0.0722706616,
0.65902704,
-0.7662275434,
0.1136368588,
0.2418478131,
-0.4862751663,
-0.4883745015,
-0.1737394631,
-0.2140112072,
0.9458659887,
-0.7637518048,
1.0363399982,
0.1809180528,
0.0251938645,
-0.2512010932,
0.3866332471,
0.2134773433,
0.4424317777,
0.4840788245,
-0.2840365171,
-0.6318344474,
-0.702807188,
-0.0777837858,
-0.3903330564,
-0.5439722538,
0.1824161708,
0.3407798111,
-0.2122351676,
1.4013715982,
-0.4093298614,
-0.610298872,
-0.5383863449,
0.0351395309,
0.3647716641,
0.3327751458,
0.514324367,
-0.7157175541,
-0.0209452938,
0.0968805775,
-0.6829396486,
0.0027017766,
-0.305121839,
-0.3054916561,
0.3677526414,
0.3541854322,
-0.7720366716,
0.4068682194,
0.6797463298,
-0.3384059966,
0.3241987526,
-0.3437895179,
-0.1789710522,
-0.9789074063,
0.1750041544,
-0.1276625544,
-0.149539575,
-0.4546597004,
0.5950013399,
-0.3900090456,
0.0676602274,
-0.54053092,
0.7861093283,
-0.1407795399,
-0.2724123001,
-0.3107796609,
0.1930560321,
-0.1433159262,
0.5321930647,
0.5582739711,
0.2729198933,
0.3035790622,
-0.9058184624,
0.5579193234,
0.5115672946,
-0.0290126186,
0.2208869606,
-0.4161804616,
0.001419371,
0.1264674813,
-0.0884699896,
-0.6711323261,
-0.498144567,
0.5492548943,
-0.6243451238,
-0.0313664153,
-0.063469395,
-0.7457414269,
-0.5125234723,
-0.0767498091,
-0.4939032793,
0.0327974334,
-0.5439736247,
0.7051164508,
0.4563525617,
0.0520693883,
-0.5112669468,
-0.5757759213,
0.2303515673,
0.0371074192,
-0.5244304538,
0.2900433242,
-0.0035085618,
-0.4267793894,
0.0280078333,
-0.1167781055,
-0.4179107249,
0.1938779801,
0.1469819099,
-0.0293089058,
0.4654499888,
-0.0613841154,
0.1561851799,
-0.2938915789,
0.0035008381,
0.0505702719,
0.5416998267,
-0.1601390392,
-0.3970206082,
-0.3698710799,
0.216174677,
-0.0594070442,
0.156140998,
0.2850542068,
0.2415720671,
-0.3644441664,
-0.1893800199,
0.1160369962,
0.1273780316,
-0.5173218846,
0.2224809676,
0.0282349829,
-0.7739849687,
0.1217427701,
0.0494255163,
0.4277254343,
-0.0811436772,
0.405520767,
-0.4585893452,
0.758010149,
0.8945418,
-0.2278768122,
0.4420978129,
-0.2931865752,
0.2511459887,
-0.4275538921,
0.0124424687,
-0.5879499912,
-0.5886597037,
-0.0501159765,
-0.6919452548,
-0.2903216183,
0.2429731339,
-0.1753593832,
1.0824955702,
-0.7029312849,
0.4112474024,
0.8476402164,
-0.3953502178,
0.1718548387,
-0.137791425,
-0.2393050492,
0.0339955315,
-0.7528126836,
-0.8210998774,
0.7142671943,
-0.0650200546,
0.3314568102,
0.0842114985,
0.8270122409,
0.373500526,
-0.2390428632,
-1.0981388092,
0.8905290365,
-0.1464594603,
-0.6247102618,
-0.4189161658,
-0.0382131636,
-0.9905328751,
0.0636580959,
-0.1978589296,
-0.7915989757,
-0.1085958555,
0.3340834975,
-0.5572811961,
0.187459141,
-0.729963541,
0.7429016232,
-0.474478215,
-0.0879852623,
0.0056764828,
-0.9048510194,
-0.0247003306,
0.710377872,
0.4241341949,
-0.3167742789,
-0.1828859746,
0.3537738621,
-0.4674333632,
0.7889691591,
-0.2072466016,
-0.1322122216,
0.3950674236,
0.3067684472,
0.1273453832,
0.0572645701,
-0.1348499954,
0.0420901068,
0.0119479643,
-0.025293408,
-0.6671559215,
0.0914096832,
-0.3926669061,
0.0449945331,
-0.5307801366,
-0.7175537944,
-0.1237237304,
0.1880328655,
-0.2366697788,
0.1300055236,
-0.0059928601,
-0.0287087411,
-0.0677330792,
-0.4680138826,
0.7199754715,
0.2834970057,
-0.388698101,
-0.1252871454,
0.628472507,
-0.2874107063,
0.2327510417,
1.0067362785,
0.0342324376,
-0.244732812,
-0.3451322913,
-0.3129168749,
-0.1544567496,
-0.3535533845,
-0.1807163507,
-0.4025297761,
0.0301941838,
-0.4165347517,
-0.9796521664,
-0.3352912068,
-0.6871529818,
-0.1969500929,
-0.1144565716,
0.3422115147,
0.4368885458,
-0.1793865263,
0.6075052023,
-0.7403538227,
0.8075914383,
0.1274945438,
0.4141101539,
-0.4666492939,
-0.1254267693,
0.0101383226,
0.0665075853,
-0.1067477241,
-0.4122060239,
0.8918469548,
0.173016578,
0.4246630669,
0.3116350472,
0.0112689119,
0.6903275251,
-0.2549057305,
0.7884316444,
0.0376867391,
-0.68470788,
0.7062932253,
-0.4942159355,
0.6171078086,
0.7060509324,
0.0803962275,
-0.5522536635,
-0.6563854218,
-0.504606545,
-0.9724232554,
0.7242928743,
0.1115772799,
0.0981225222,
-0.2114233971,
0.2046691626,
-0.1325133145,
0.2686854005,
-0.7686780691,
0.0680746436,
0.1267438978,
-0.4549832344,
0.2179942131,
0.1454782933,
-0.0846328661,
-0.269610554,
0.2574398518,
-0.4332594872,
0.3370545506,
-0.1615638584,
-0.2845537961,
0.1390457004,
0.0301959068,
0.3519126773,
0.3143317997,
-0.320943743,
-0.1035019308,
-0.1342249364,
-0.5350000858,
-0.2728529274,
0.0959963351,
-0.1328919232,
0.0053058313,
0.5886734724,
0.2109405994,
0.583127141,
-1.1007319689,
0.2165235579,
0.2588373423,
-0.3068132401,
-0.3948436975,
0.3448561728,
0.1205232665,
0.1276516765,
0.1344130784,
0.2905800343,
0.4384530783,
-0.1679751873,
0.1977933794,
0.4329867363,
-0.2351903319,
-0.1966342479,
0.5574201345,
0.1405856162,
-0.6867335439,
0.4594469666,
-0.6398912072,
-0.3181441724,
0.8141065836,
0.3483176231,
0.6498299837,
0.1152602136,
0.3582315743,
0.5953229666,
0.4155381024,
-0.1445752829,
0.5881860852,
-0.2985964715,
-1.0577294827,
-0.5976327658,
-0.6211659312,
-0.7451509237,
-0.3275396228,
-0.555107832,
0.3126403689,
-0.7745650411,
-0.0365545191,
-0.4228151739,
0.0630523413,
-0.3785175979,
0.0978986472,
0.2181173414,
0.6858123541,
-0.4549502134,
0.7048488259,
1.2164765596,
-0.3465570807,
-0.6657728553,
-0.2263928205,
0.320120126,
-0.7785505056,
0.6619567871,
0.0722697377,
-0.3092734814,
-0.2259745747,
-0.6886001825,
-1.1373713017,
0.846222043,
0.0522466637,
-0.1928241104,
-0.3763913214,
0.20018062,
0.5330118537,
0.0395914949,
-0.2194932848,
0.4784897566,
0.3391154408,
0.2377505302,
-1.0006802082,
-0.4776506126,
-0.276966095,
0.0002197149,
0.240204215,
-0.0918112174,
0.2852196693,
-0.1617389917,
-0.1419202983,
0.1597170085,
0.6610063314,
0.4216336012,
0.0132398093,
0.4021354616,
0.7324771881,
0.5220922828,
0.0933190733,
1.1714596748,
-0.2222426981,
0.212965548,
1.3088451624,
-0.593315661,
1.045193553,
0.6096296906,
-0.4151520431,
0.3668899238,
0.1222679317,
0.1635690331,
0.5007525682,
0.0822872296,
-0.1242870614,
-0.1300733238,
0.0846956596,
0.2297218293,
0.6121478081,
0.4437304437,
0.0093779378,
-0.4091982841,
0.0607962534,
-0.0251499396,
0.6161159873,
-0.0716455579,
0.6636984348,
0.0286532789,
-0.5728373528,
0.0681948587,
0.1855250448,
1.012262702,
-0.5649212003,
-0.1744479984,
0.1382156909,
0.3500442505,
-0.2429003268,
-1.1362607479,
0.854288578,
-0.0467555299,
-0.0232222173,
-0.837613225,
0.7887090445,
-0.1590959281,
-0.4316761196,
0.4299972355,
0.2609167695,
0.0154096279,
0.3159835637,
-0.795543313,
-0.3188506663,
-0.2619081438,
-0.1345298141,
0.1696124673,
0.1554413885,
0.1479793787,
1.0262390375,
0.6360183954,
0.1268092245,
0.0052864859,
0.0626419187,
0.3788754642,
-0.6527072191,
-0.5335035324,
-0.4427354634,
0.4323512912,
-0.063399896,
-0.4176795781,
0.6434791684,
0.4866982102,
1.056833148,
-0.0687650368,
0.5676324368,
-0.7482598424,
0.8141890168,
-0.5591430664,
0.5009889603,
-0.2140434682,
-0.1201193631,
-0.4143474102,
-0.549077332,
-1.0219324827,
1.35059762,
-0.2858177722,
-0.0961064771,
0.4227486253,
0.5672109127,
0.0619393289,
-0.4018464386,
0.0745203719,
-0.4734440446,
0.2923755348,
0.516046524,
0.4874704778,
-0.0843397677,
0.4993762672,
-0.430637598,
0.096081987,
-0.2434651405,
-1.0701771975,
-0.6063753963,
-0.3292864859,
-0.3074293733,
0.1353693753,
-0.1443082541,
1.2658090591,
0.6509482861,
-0.6324039102,
-0.7100742459,
-0.3914851546,
0.2112760246,
-0.7351613045,
-0.2642742097,
0.0247796942,
-0.4137539268,
-0.8757107854,
0.6763011217,
0.3826293945,
-0.0830001533,
0.2804394066,
-0.2868945003,
-0.6940478683,
-0.5207262039,
0.8694944382,
0.8925490379,
-0.6822430491,
-0.4425688088,
0.3227123916,
0.0049927202,
-0.104967095,
0.3476803303,
-0.9793908596,
0.5503086448,
0.3665585518,
0.7465880513,
-0.2203929722,
0.2058665454,
0.8595879078,
-1.0310473442,
0.4751774967,
0.3713871837,
0.2472140789,
0.2350219786,
-0.1803587228,
0.7223219872,
0.0204147678,
-0.2684308887,
-0.5924031734,
0.2339950204,
-1.2079104185,
-0.2380302101,
1.2078565359,
0.4386718571,
0.0223864857,
-0.3738985658,
-0.3906870782,
0.1060447022,
-0.3264243603,
0.7123176455,
0.7704325914,
-0.511208415,
-0.0074560391,
-0.7531170249,
0.4547539055,
0.2285655886,
-0.8575282693,
-0.0399006978,
0.6112146378,
-0.2338083088,
0.2780556381,
0.7509750128,
0.0658009574,
0.3259173036,
-0.3060921431,
0.5831125379,
-0.0960734114,
-0.2494408041,
-0.3254023492,
0.0816302449,
-0.1040711552,
-0.2542386651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02983v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02983v1 | Leveraging Social Interactions to Detect Misinformation on Social Media | 2023-04-06T10:30:04 | 2023-04-06T10:30:04 | Tommaso Fornaciari, Luca Luceri, Emilio Ferrara, Dirk Hovy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Detecting misinformation threads is crucial to guarantee a healthy
environment on social media. We address the problem using the data set created
during the COVID-19 pandemic. It contains cascades of tweets discussing
information weakly labeled as reliable or unreliable, based on a previous
evaluation of the information source. The models identifying unreliable threads
usually rely on textual features. But reliability is not just what is said, but
by whom and to whom. We additionally leverage on network information. Following
the homophily principle, we hypothesize that users who interact are generally
interested in similar topics and spreading similar kind of news, which in turn
is generally reliable or not. We test several methods to learn representations
of the social interactions within the cascades, combining them with deep neural
language models in a Multi-Input (MI) framework. Keeping track of the sequence
of the interactions during the time, we improve over previous state-of-the-art
models. | [
-0.1020930484,
-1.1404364109,
0.5138312578,
0.6436445117,
-0.2089570612,
0.2189731896,
-0.2277503461,
-0.558604002,
0.4551220238,
0.02991914,
-0.4344035685,
-0.2388036847,
-0.8014460802,
-0.0658765659,
-0.6024525762,
0.9886163473,
0.0953177065,
0.0698383078,
-0.1639116406,
-0.0390683264,
-0.1047251672,
-0.4083176255,
-0.8466014862,
-0.41263327,
0.9258648157,
0.4733077884,
0.6472464204,
0.207956478,
0.6309943795,
0.1366399378,
0.00655811,
0.3389776349,
-0.7391504645,
0.2348340899,
-0.2330037653,
-0.1501440853,
-0.0292771086,
0.1954529881,
0.2391000539,
0.378937453,
-0.0987759754,
0.3802453578,
0.4357226789,
0.1154927388,
-0.6245571971,
0.1118336469,
-0.7597765326,
-0.0995635614,
-0.3936706483,
-0.4071132243,
-0.2481026798,
-0.4178858101,
0.0804646239,
-0.2783404291,
0.1425836384,
-0.2191644162,
0.8986863494,
0.0183654893,
-0.2598211467,
-0.2766841948,
-0.9252739549,
0.5260490179,
-0.6406604648,
0.3075850606,
0.8805413246,
0.2781689167,
-0.1158928126,
-0.5134400725,
-0.5042139888,
0.0447564349,
0.0916299373,
0.0095621701,
-0.3342927396,
-0.241528824,
-0.0697927624,
-0.0094311619,
-0.3211276829,
-0.1161400378,
-0.524615407,
-0.3613547981,
0.628475666,
-0.2235493958,
0.5746774673,
-0.2262826115,
-0.208614856,
0.2387688011,
-0.4320535958,
0.0712291375,
0.1065711603,
0.2192934006,
-0.4631471932,
0.5627883077,
0.262329787,
0.0984757394,
0.5436583757,
-0.2259735763,
0.1240355372,
-0.5292826295,
-0.1153966561,
0.1332949996,
0.8377099633,
0.4745871425,
0.1590638459,
-0.3583221734,
-0.0479114428,
0.0925593227,
0.3953792751,
-0.5171483755,
-0.2172520608,
0.0468144044,
-0.5301073194,
-0.4481792748,
0.2499165088,
-0.7749448419,
-0.8042662144,
-0.0763495415,
0.3669914305,
-0.4726401269,
-0.427955687,
-0.2949373424,
-0.5508426428,
-0.1409842223,
0.4559979141,
-0.5741055012,
0.1077906117,
0.7226117253,
0.8291694522,
0.0970137343,
-0.4631015658,
-0.6503765583,
0.2313688844,
-0.3744395971,
0.8585630655,
-0.6179926991,
0.0468087345,
0.1551545262,
0.0133899301,
-0.2394544929,
-0.3866171241,
0.5358738303,
-0.4922934473,
0.0903887153,
-0.5679110289,
-0.4569159448,
-0.066192016,
0.4463275671,
-0.6113036871,
0.7550064921,
-0.0331592299,
-1.2459989786,
0.293785125,
-0.4587367475,
-0.6551346779,
-0.13396658,
-0.0997179821,
-0.4668506086,
0.1055448353,
0.14378649,
0.5192377567,
-0.1578389555,
0.370093137,
-0.9522114396,
-0.2817505002,
0.2886697948,
-0.4962152243,
0.6740162969,
0.1903695911,
-0.3194288611,
-0.1415353715,
-0.3222722411,
-0.5543644428,
-0.1398500651,
-0.3767772913,
-0.5807165504,
0.2626251876,
-0.1358729452,
0.1863388717,
0.0725713521,
-0.536598146,
-0.1762828529,
0.0095801195,
0.4073700607,
0.5291426778,
0.476167798,
0.4314646125,
-0.5462807417,
0.2379184961,
0.5833570361,
0.4628559053,
0.1694188118,
-0.5466541648,
-0.5426031947,
0.0936854407,
-0.2033463269,
0.648018837,
-1.0834014416,
0.2793155015,
-0.0826187953,
-0.5562428236,
-0.3258054554,
0.4294959605,
0.0598132052,
0.4735050797,
0.4639758766,
0.2074105442,
-0.7547900677,
-0.5919581056,
-0.606959343,
-0.3301820159,
0.3404341638,
0.0405341573,
0.1682199389,
-0.6511058807,
0.8029383421,
0.1409984231,
0.0307991207,
-0.3018952012,
0.5600557327,
-0.0073396689,
0.2290381491,
0.6584970355,
-0.7117903829,
-0.4909127355,
0.0276234671,
-0.9618245363,
0.0655279905,
-0.181079939,
0.0529844873,
0.1369783878,
0.5945190787,
-0.3556670547,
0.6419820189,
0.6265579462,
-0.2712835371,
0.2392973006,
0.0972720385,
0.3037061095,
-1.3305170536,
-0.205567494,
0.5960326791,
-0.2423541248,
-0.8402441144,
-0.4642143548,
-0.0627107471,
0.148949936,
-0.275215745,
0.2858701944,
-0.2022949606,
0.4164974988,
-0.3524077237,
-0.1082036123,
-0.0307047199,
0.0829733908,
-0.388800472,
0.4575001299,
0.5603837371,
-0.5272507071,
0.3298694491,
-0.2442029715,
-0.2054357231,
0.4810337722,
-0.688287735,
0.1005141139,
-0.3972017467,
0.2663988769,
-0.9261052012,
-0.4874126613,
0.6860627532,
-0.7319611907,
-0.1549684256,
-0.0693631023,
-0.5415764451,
-0.3828212321,
-0.4925946295,
0.2818334401,
0.069933638,
-0.4781658649,
0.5524358749,
0.7140165567,
-0.0233941171,
-0.5644394755,
-1.0438379049,
0.0135426968,
-0.2075828612,
-0.7334949374,
-0.0400762968,
0.137358129,
-0.4253102839,
0.0662030652,
-0.1282019913,
-0.4720581472,
0.2530752718,
0.3188948929,
-0.0190499239,
-0.1871961653,
0.4601993263,
-0.0691847876,
0.4487973154,
0.0515088215,
-0.0104194144,
0.7778325677,
-0.0390561819,
-0.2170464247,
-0.786393106,
0.3220661581,
0.7383977771,
0.0380872376,
0.9185378551,
0.832909584,
-0.7182319164,
-0.0189411156,
-0.6230505109,
-0.4034495354,
-0.4276106358,
0.1156506389,
0.2044873685,
-0.8626310229,
0.6125256419,
-0.0012315989,
-0.1591815352,
0.4613928795,
0.1408511698,
-0.482299149,
0.7393178344,
0.7159351707,
-0.529304862,
0.5611234903,
0.0792432055,
0.5040869117,
-0.4261506498,
-0.1894200593,
-0.4785842896,
-0.3045628071,
-0.4563862383,
-0.4111679494,
0.3292734921,
0.3514591157,
-0.0256079603,
0.2342407256,
0.0244349837,
0.2868337035,
0.4689944983,
0.4024329782,
-0.0126175405,
0.1939039379,
0.0173186827,
0.0872569159,
-0.9580551386,
-0.2612069249,
0.7144587636,
0.5443147421,
1.127835989,
0.0231844578,
0.7358792424,
0.6262853146,
0.4840485454,
-0.4168821871,
0.08493229,
-0.0865003169,
-0.4329634309,
-0.1891859025,
-0.4481402338,
-0.9712114334,
-0.4084112346,
-0.49080953,
-0.7690656185,
0.5051425099,
0.3041104674,
-0.5234748721,
0.4471359849,
-0.4830089808,
0.4964677989,
-0.0801503286,
-0.3073492944,
-0.4740667343,
-0.4607146978,
0.4346650541,
-0.0860569999,
0.3825924098,
-0.0846121833,
0.4323087335,
0.5475450158,
-0.0959529132,
1.1384934187,
0.0590281971,
0.1068207547,
0.3856723905,
-0.1795303375,
0.389248848,
0.313734144,
-0.1204315349,
0.3288143277,
-0.1437064409,
-0.3739990592,
-0.3400869966,
0.592109561,
-1.0474169254,
-0.2287033796,
-0.3719522357,
-0.3473534584,
-0.0095101586,
-0.0270112399,
0.3801124096,
0.3452849686,
-0.3978802264,
0.4376139939,
0.5827758312,
-0.0652100444,
0.5719436407,
-0.0444660448,
-0.1865148842,
-0.4456623495,
0.8113309741,
0.2972061038,
-0.0225163866,
0.1071254611,
0.3546097577,
0.0536637753,
-0.0413786396,
-0.1408187896,
0.2654978335,
-0.5487596989,
-0.2713332474,
-0.672950387,
-0.5836525559,
-0.6864537001,
0.0339815952,
-0.3041140735,
-0.1094060615,
-0.5558593869,
-0.0509615354,
0.334344089,
0.9060227871,
-0.4204793572,
0.3955408037,
-1.0679000616,
0.4584657848,
0.4329916835,
0.2380639613,
0.1000227556,
-0.2152782977,
-0.4404831529,
0.5777117014,
-0.3477958441,
-1.1693445444,
0.1304996163,
0.2935807407,
0.7000567913,
0.789155066,
0.033911597,
0.4962778687,
-0.1201981679,
0.6859135032,
0.1940105408,
-0.8591656089,
0.6384188533,
-0.53027004,
0.1300770491,
0.6996516585,
0.7705168128,
-1.0882968903,
-0.6307346821,
-0.6470682025,
-0.4342545867,
0.3460139036,
0.0768199041,
0.1182866022,
-0.3728802204,
0.2631397545,
-0.0499223024,
0.1019662619,
-0.6372272968,
-0.170371294,
-0.2902742028,
-0.1744977981,
0.1481474489,
-0.5287634134,
-0.2903493643,
-0.4206023216,
0.621661067,
0.0672561526,
0.1329419464,
0.1941162497,
-0.156493485,
-0.4142544568,
-0.0729124174,
0.6048895121,
0.8870967031,
-0.0712228715,
0.5226899385,
-0.2331977487,
-0.5455719233,
-0.1063917428,
0.060284175,
-0.1268129349,
0.2900890112,
0.3603293002,
0.6516185999,
0.0887617841,
-0.1138665527,
0.7092568278,
-0.3044965863,
-0.2092097551,
-0.1508719921,
-0.1032051668,
0.3071327806,
0.4684035182,
0.5119538903,
0.6203039885,
-0.0133581506,
-0.9640855789,
0.4732663929,
0.2762729526,
-0.521469593,
-0.6776358485,
0.2932168245,
0.3503316343,
-0.4099809825,
0.5382099152,
-0.019557599,
-0.554392159,
0.4507929385,
0.2506863475,
0.8462868333,
-0.5033311248,
0.6230268478,
0.3097915649,
0.5926076174,
-0.3280510902,
0.2469364554,
0.0338004231,
-1.0153928995,
-0.2426986098,
-0.273637563,
-0.1184279323,
0.3826130927,
-0.5355002284,
0.3192838728,
-0.518470645,
-0.49912256,
0.2211365849,
-0.431804955,
-0.5271090269,
-0.0121460175,
0.3129575551,
0.7976453304,
-1.2697367668,
0.8459278941,
0.5363259912,
-0.4302195907,
-0.7723242044,
0.7318568826,
0.1834913641,
-0.6374605894,
0.4869814515,
0.259639442,
0.0988752693,
-0.5465777516,
-0.9781501293,
-0.8742314577,
0.7907826304,
0.3584195673,
-0.3919890523,
0.2009806633,
0.2756057382,
0.4737062752,
-0.3271692991,
0.0714379176,
0.2122468352,
0.3719508648,
0.0031623954,
-0.9970314503,
-0.3024018705,
-0.4289817512,
-0.2315651774,
-0.2098489255,
-0.750413537,
0.6982408166,
-0.0058364808,
-0.2571083605,
-0.462117672,
0.7093032002,
0.3061624169,
0.8489246368,
0.6427511573,
0.4032903016,
1.0270075798,
0.0079657668,
0.8816130161,
-0.4264511168,
0.366263181,
1.1884348392,
0.0150892828,
0.7981808782,
0.5827613473,
0.4350841343,
0.5126346946,
0.776409924,
0.2096468955,
0.4741678238,
-0.0930214077,
-0.2715070844,
-0.4018442035,
-0.3446666896,
-0.3620932698,
0.3853935003,
0.6276665926,
-0.5689213872,
-0.4011247158,
0.2215033025,
0.2743706703,
-0.0790799856,
-0.2636825144,
0.6753842831,
0.1550070196,
-0.5531701446,
0.3107823431,
-0.2421463579,
0.7409737706,
-0.1908352375,
0.0244563725,
-0.2705602348,
0.1266389787,
-0.2228130102,
-0.5556455851,
0.655071795,
-0.1661964059,
-0.462107718,
-0.0028361785,
1.2458664179,
-0.6504539847,
-0.6245797276,
0.451616317,
0.6863708496,
0.0389651172,
-0.2696355283,
-0.7844075561,
0.2428599894,
-0.1317583025,
0.0706101283,
-0.0872858018,
0.4542996287,
-0.0643365681,
0.5431094766,
0.4471365809,
0.1026082188,
0.1862121969,
0.2315598577,
0.8819010258,
-0.2945242524,
-0.1252301484,
-1.02049613,
0.2133397758,
-0.5179588795,
-0.0645374134,
0.9512358308,
0.294336468,
0.5855430961,
0.218020156,
1.0798361301,
0.1803057492,
0.6085790992,
0.0667391792,
0.9394286871,
-0.465900898,
0.0952705219,
-0.1848797351,
-0.5113844872,
-0.1035006195,
0.5426970124,
-0.2801531553,
-0.1683951616,
0.6489399672,
0.6428397894,
-0.1960864663,
0.2180189043,
0.023904752,
0.3701166809,
0.2790139616,
0.1823261678,
1.0722520351,
-0.3520674706,
0.345038712,
-0.3523769975,
-0.2528516054,
-0.4926490784,
-0.6270141006,
-1.0996297598,
-0.4582976699,
-0.3957728744,
-0.8041985035,
0.3496269584,
0.9901034236,
0.7210960984,
-0.6310221553,
-0.0661654621,
-0.0296133328,
0.4149592221,
-0.2051794678,
-0.2669612169,
0.0460297577,
-0.4890128076,
-0.2933002114,
0.2516008317,
0.4265848696,
-0.0955380127,
-0.2733417749,
0.0998975113,
-0.655287385,
0.4229024947,
0.4600448608,
0.2394625396,
-0.4035929143,
-0.3629150391,
0.1524617821,
-0.4659705758,
0.0256005451,
0.6316956878,
-0.3105666637,
0.2090329826,
0.7328729033,
0.8307965994,
0.1538405418,
0.1116396487,
0.6469820142,
-0.6959540844,
-0.1550887823,
0.111117743,
0.2444505543,
0.5353966951,
-0.6111689806,
0.1291843355,
0.5746333599,
-0.5207932591,
-0.4937469363,
-0.1752066165,
-0.8671275377,
-0.2360654175,
1.3799648285,
-0.0618887506,
-0.5656619668,
-0.4909694195,
0.0862887576,
0.3165561557,
-0.5613024235,
1.3984904289,
0.9113894701,
0.0471939184,
-0.2088416368,
-0.2572030127,
0.5513530374,
0.0828797668,
-0.8316481709,
-0.3866266608,
0.1772119403,
0.3757116497,
0.3298068047,
0.7465286851,
0.2657992542,
0.5360887647,
-0.2371253669,
-0.2589691579,
0.4673992991,
-0.3859546781,
-0.1099949405,
0.1433027089,
-0.3567581773,
-0.1597402245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02945v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02945v1 | Multi-label classification of open-ended questions with BERT | 2023-04-06T09:09:44 | 2023-04-06T09:09:44 | Matthias Schonlau, Julia Weiß, Jan Marquardt | stat.AP | stat.AP, cs.CL | Open-ended questions in surveys are valuable because they do not constrain
the respondent's answer, thereby avoiding biases. However, answers to
open-ended questions are text data which are harder to analyze. Traditionally,
answers were manually classified as specified in the coding manual. Most of the
effort to automate coding has gone into the easier problem of single label
prediction, where answers are classified into a single code. However, open-ends
that require multi-label classification, i.e., that are assigned multiple
codes, occur frequently. This paper focuses on multi-label classification of
text answers to open-ended survey questions in social science surveys. We
evaluate the performance of the transformer-based architecture BERT for the
German language in comparison to traditional multi-label algorithms (Binary
Relevance, Label Powerset, ECC) in a German social science survey, the GLES
Panel (N=17,584, 55 labels). We find that classification with BERT (forcing at
least one label) has the smallest 0/1 loss (13.1%) among methods considered
(18.9%-21.6%). As expected, it is much easier to correctly predict answer texts
that correspond to a single label (7.1% loss) than those that correspond to
multiple labels ($\sim$50% loss). Because BERT predicts zero labels for only
1.5% of the answers, forcing at least one label, while recommended, ultimately
does not lower the 0/1 loss by much. Our work has important implications for
social scientists: 1) We have shown multi-label classification with BERT works
in the German language for open-ends. 2) For mildly multi-label classification
tasks, the loss now appears small enough to allow for fully automatic
classification (as compared to semi-automatic approaches). 3) Multi-label
classification with BERT requires only a single model. The leading competitor,
ECC, iterates through individual single label predictions. | [
-0.7896797061,
-0.5808696747,
0.4081982076,
0.1752663106,
-0.0887655318,
0.0347935334,
-0.4711045623,
-0.4832232296,
0.0478851162,
0.2327476591,
-0.460922122,
-0.5561041236,
-0.7601486444,
0.0102022616,
-0.2656447589,
1.4470390081,
0.053984277,
0.2686463296,
-0.4688191116,
-0.4735668004,
0.2018627971,
-0.8466816545,
-0.4373663664,
-0.3426691592,
0.8773933053,
0.3166479766,
0.6061182618,
0.0901367739,
0.3669390678,
0.3125407696,
-0.3396372497,
0.0692000091,
-0.5373089314,
-0.0217109192,
0.2825371921,
-0.4427005649,
-0.1057262868,
0.1273901761,
0.34158957,
0.7452409267,
0.1678338945,
0.6688747406,
0.2652838528,
0.539185822,
-0.5492373109,
0.2545708716,
-0.3121697307,
-0.0926167592,
-0.014137987,
0.0198853724,
-0.6343160868,
-0.8414037228,
0.3911955655,
-0.2194065899,
0.3916402459,
-0.1206485406,
0.6665158868,
0.1195182651,
-0.3880886137,
-0.4963552654,
-0.7974408269,
0.7282089591,
-0.4360826612,
0.3094625771,
0.2844562531,
0.3816361427,
0.0925476849,
-0.5733155012,
-0.3203983009,
0.0330797136,
-0.190839842,
0.2837855518,
-0.1676722765,
0.0042400155,
0.1226694584,
-0.1264510602,
-0.4608934522,
0.1984684765,
-0.7995615602,
-0.196101442,
0.5201309919,
-0.1513428837,
-0.1479039341,
-0.0411688797,
-0.3839721084,
-0.3776249588,
-0.1972978115,
0.3754845858,
0.4137449563,
0.4659038186,
0.082851164,
0.4795882702,
0.0631242543,
0.6216958165,
-0.1478437334,
-0.0806892067,
0.43746382,
-0.1362337321,
0.1530406475,
0.1552237421,
0.7308899164,
0.147090286,
0.4571904242,
0.0474958867,
0.0540084615,
0.1976666301,
0.305236131,
-0.6530662179,
-0.206250459,
0.3620631397,
-0.7375291586,
-0.2067820728,
0.1786575019,
-0.6340559721,
-0.0781149864,
-0.1946953386,
0.288579464,
-0.2551481724,
0.0988835245,
0.0995194316,
-0.2146639228,
0.2842594981,
0.609548986,
-0.3422370255,
0.1856279373,
0.4160483778,
0.7503598332,
0.0613960251,
-0.0948954672,
-0.0904132649,
-0.1650951058,
-0.1693242788,
1.0600719452,
-0.3979494274,
-0.2986169755,
0.1244810373,
0.0943175033,
0.0201085843,
0.0656585619,
0.4738998711,
-0.7423003316,
0.6162196398,
-0.2506189942,
-0.4828870595,
-0.289383769,
0.2064956874,
-0.8259636164,
0.9747114182,
-0.1609993279,
-0.8770825267,
0.3600248098,
-0.7305375338,
-0.2622770071,
-0.1507229358,
-0.0191550814,
-0.5939207077,
-0.0667659119,
0.0673531517,
0.5045047402,
-0.1329115033,
0.2834418416,
-0.7603012323,
-0.2595220208,
0.4694723189,
-0.5691305995,
0.968380332,
0.1962598413,
-0.079352051,
0.0374871641,
-0.6004401445,
0.4518440664,
-0.1029989198,
-0.5825224519,
-0.5615439415,
0.128152594,
0.0474715456,
0.3062000275,
0.1205025166,
-1.0708572865,
0.169369489,
0.0213964172,
0.0432074741,
1.1322697401,
-0.3007172942,
0.3925129473,
-0.3747255504,
0.3304086328,
-0.3393619061,
0.2328031361,
0.0646184012,
-1.0390777588,
-0.4492661059,
-0.1247225776,
0.5942020416,
0.5656859279,
-0.6261823773,
0.3876654208,
-0.267382592,
-0.9030475616,
-0.6525766253,
-0.3835150003,
0.3345301151,
0.2733569741,
0.48332569,
0.0048283846,
-0.2212119401,
-0.9432251453,
0.1311388314,
-0.2904114723,
-0.2097840905,
0.4136289656,
0.590039432,
-0.0385128818,
1.0450768471,
-0.8940272331,
-0.1377331167,
0.0526719354,
0.5375526547,
0.3277746737,
0.0887070447,
0.531162858,
-0.8306396008,
-0.480684638,
-0.0758843571,
-0.6028702259,
-0.1174177751,
0.2116437554,
0.0425284803,
0.2876496613,
0.0417656414,
-0.286809206,
0.5092952251,
0.5185530186,
-0.1359513849,
0.5847597718,
-0.355225563,
0.0275327805,
-0.6421529055,
-0.0603458025,
0.1996951997,
0.3333563209,
-0.8609054089,
-0.4626497328,
0.1740893871,
0.0529904179,
-0.5328959227,
0.3454095125,
-0.2352670878,
-0.0097857639,
0.0628896281,
-0.2025191784,
-0.1999009103,
0.6932914853,
0.07090538,
0.5502109528,
0.3414870501,
-0.7736508846,
0.3049308658,
0.4069112837,
-0.3946639299,
0.359330833,
-0.6919668317,
0.3347516954,
-0.859007597,
0.4551032782,
-1.4366923571,
0.0935959965,
0.0140378634,
-0.7748792768,
0.097621724,
0.3366783261,
-0.4401108027,
-0.7227057815,
-0.5564354062,
0.2078079432,
0.3700443804,
-0.6678721309,
0.3810148239,
0.2010208964,
-0.2341664284,
-0.6569481492,
-0.6461724639,
-0.5042678714,
-0.0434762724,
-0.6503805518,
0.1429789811,
-0.2798668146,
0.0898756385,
0.2896777987,
-0.2795535624,
-0.1999962181,
-0.165631637,
-0.0500265434,
0.3059335351,
-0.1402245611,
0.6453585029,
0.0808400884,
-0.0680349171,
-0.015873855,
-0.1142446026,
0.2827176154,
-0.353523463,
-0.416039288,
0.1282560974,
0.57749331,
0.6814623475,
-0.2651933432,
0.884165287,
0.5651034117,
-0.1827129126,
-0.0418736376,
-0.5316127539,
-0.0461827666,
-0.4051961899,
0.2575002313,
-0.3771240115,
-1.0037026405,
0.6297006011,
-0.0143223079,
0.4496386349,
0.3955413997,
0.4954997301,
-0.5232878923,
1.0110805035,
0.4992867112,
-0.0802811012,
0.2339399457,
-0.0710856467,
0.2343268096,
-0.4162962735,
-0.4705801308,
-1.1922255754,
-0.3759224117,
-0.7012307644,
-0.2127735615,
0.8285407424,
-0.1860752255,
-0.2242897451,
0.3387883008,
-1.1064778566,
0.1863992661,
0.9827734232,
0.3953914046,
0.2021472305,
0.0498993397,
0.3061548173,
0.1236692071,
-0.8874239922,
-0.5654342175,
1.192920804,
0.4139674604,
1.0707352161,
0.1225321218,
0.9008696675,
0.2757297456,
0.8292543888,
-0.7069749236,
0.4491289556,
-0.3355175853,
-0.7445742488,
-0.7643946409,
-0.3215095699,
-1.183329463,
0.5199666619,
-0.1261317283,
-0.7188412547,
0.3380087018,
0.0650160685,
-0.2297627628,
0.3043577075,
-0.9095011353,
0.6766472459,
-0.5199635625,
0.0742237791,
0.1804525107,
-0.9014539719,
0.1712950766,
-0.3617770374,
0.5347484946,
-0.0038333482,
0.1063872054,
1.1753821373,
-0.1398277581,
0.919896841,
-0.3339726925,
-0.1676487774,
0.5101950169,
-0.6272185445,
0.175260663,
-0.2949692905,
0.0018916319,
0.2471047789,
0.370457381,
-0.3444246948,
-0.5735189915,
0.2290593833,
-0.9470318556,
-0.2022815943,
-0.4409612119,
-0.1036821157,
-0.101161845,
-0.0147803538,
0.4737463295,
0.3217534125,
-0.1905671656,
0.484664619,
0.8699387908,
-0.5257906914,
0.3351293802,
0.5250745416,
0.0670494884,
-0.4262637794,
0.6158809066,
0.5844683647,
0.2521359324,
0.2151845098,
0.3151061535,
-0.600696981,
-0.0392286628,
-0.3636617959,
0.2027863115,
-0.8895956278,
-0.4337777197,
-0.7515763044,
-0.1948145926,
-0.5998970866,
-0.175949499,
-0.0003845523,
-0.397464335,
-0.1007261202,
-0.1254461408,
0.3160043359,
0.6796993017,
-0.1526178122,
0.1830557883,
-0.8611409068,
0.4178355932,
0.3731528223,
0.7266293168,
-0.0609246939,
-0.0930091888,
-0.1590661108,
0.0541221946,
-0.1936122775,
-1.5096517801,
-0.2522193193,
0.1357613057,
0.7517505288,
0.2145041525,
0.5290867686,
0.4305642545,
-0.4429903924,
0.5908482671,
0.3255504072,
-0.5535057187,
0.3438431919,
-0.0563058183,
0.5296645761,
0.4503191411,
0.693161428,
-0.670283556,
-0.5219681859,
-0.5405327678,
-0.8692234755,
1.0199801922,
0.0374175422,
0.0344959013,
-0.0552231073,
-0.2367339432,
0.3038546741,
0.2524755895,
-0.8445341587,
-0.5722048283,
-0.2600522041,
-0.0360705219,
-0.0934859514,
-0.2535775602,
-0.0895570144,
-0.4160086215,
0.7615081072,
-0.2250089198,
0.7755947113,
0.1901022345,
0.2610691786,
-0.0089965723,
0.7350283861,
0.4262942672,
0.2874384522,
-0.369042486,
0.1051806882,
0.1573475152,
-0.1705398262,
0.3463351727,
0.2925568223,
-0.3424767256,
0.3023917377,
0.3724522591,
0.6862734556,
-0.0783349127,
-0.3252013028,
0.3817821145,
-0.0140934009,
-0.5596449375,
-0.2664566636,
-0.3817475438,
-0.0925585777,
-0.1077534184,
0.5128468871,
0.0182286724,
0.0809749141,
-0.3472147286,
0.1985032856,
0.4921217859,
-0.2249028385,
0.0019285416,
0.386967361,
0.0266755931,
-0.2451575845,
0.5778279305,
-0.1215978786,
-0.6940096617,
0.8309778571,
0.3635594249,
0.8537480831,
-0.502263248,
0.5270856023,
0.3547924459,
0.5095676184,
-0.0017337707,
0.3048741221,
-0.1985449344,
-0.845475316,
-0.4436123967,
-0.6421880722,
-0.6496311426,
0.1020196974,
-0.96817559,
0.0830194652,
0.0158391148,
-0.3046114445,
0.3799555302,
-0.5148966312,
-0.765001893,
0.1690375805,
0.1882338971,
0.9261088371,
-1.0031784773,
0.5693358779,
1.0328136683,
-0.1637333632,
-0.5405611992,
-0.4684776366,
-0.1264759749,
-0.3166407049,
0.4714517295,
0.3824656606,
-0.1493685395,
-0.2917624712,
-0.8462891579,
-1.0602308512,
0.6616249084,
-0.165229857,
-0.066045925,
-0.2185015231,
0.1222802028,
0.7632986307,
0.0549938008,
0.5067056417,
0.256614238,
0.8028780222,
0.0164603274,
-1.119202137,
-0.2249956429,
-0.0871282369,
-0.1461642832,
0.5397865772,
-0.5040581822,
0.8288772106,
-0.2203259319,
-0.3216559589,
-0.2190378159,
0.5145760775,
-0.0390519835,
0.6163862944,
0.5792335272,
0.2000328153,
0.7282717824,
-0.371550262,
0.7201965451,
-0.1568298489,
0.8087307215,
0.7946817875,
-0.0926140994,
0.6199455857,
0.2048099488,
-0.5570120811,
0.5666847825,
0.5878423452,
-0.1412280053,
0.5484977961,
0.3913805485,
-0.2241845429,
-0.070796594,
0.0854080617,
-0.4342674911,
0.5623847842,
0.411170572,
-0.0158698112,
-0.5137692094,
0.3928410113,
-0.1286494732,
-0.0720312446,
-0.1806877404,
0.8947937489,
-0.1543971747,
-0.75412184,
0.4657380581,
-0.0846191123,
0.7889288664,
-0.8097729683,
0.0597018264,
0.1721964628,
0.1176922023,
-0.2235007137,
-1.0658220053,
0.2975496352,
-0.0765479505,
-0.1992818415,
-0.5373032093,
0.8405561447,
-0.4825973809,
-0.3979753554,
0.3017301857,
0.6972022653,
0.2913551331,
0.1731211096,
-0.5458267927,
-0.2263718545,
0.0696864054,
-0.4525144696,
0.1449044049,
0.2400853932,
-0.1193305925,
0.6273337007,
0.5322747827,
-0.3735355735,
0.2089283913,
-0.1378398091,
0.9477713704,
-0.4500613213,
-0.58110708,
-0.4157246351,
0.463178426,
-0.1112344414,
-0.12841326,
0.709862411,
0.5562441349,
0.900290668,
-0.3102584481,
0.9972726107,
-0.2801116407,
0.6940424442,
-0.1210162118,
0.4608975649,
-0.4253023267,
-0.1586464047,
-0.3757790625,
-0.7220130563,
-0.2458676696,
0.4022834599,
-0.3904183209,
0.025336666,
0.6993291974,
0.3853330314,
0.2131576538,
0.2682746947,
0.0257114712,
-0.2731167674,
0.2068669498,
0.5129281282,
0.7413355112,
-0.0497594103,
1.0777723789,
-0.4043160379,
-0.5615035295,
0.2294994295,
-0.3346974254,
-0.7976205945,
-0.6246697903,
-0.2019806206,
-0.4544961751,
-0.1284282506,
0.6390021443,
0.5337285995,
-0.8958889246,
-0.1763560772,
0.5869112611,
0.0966751501,
-0.2992127538,
-0.2492836565,
0.5512059331,
-0.3946268559,
-0.7117936015,
-0.0976355597,
0.0468528979,
0.024065908,
-0.0967788175,
0.0946997255,
-0.2619196475,
-0.0638751686,
0.8171826005,
0.1897976398,
-0.8094592094,
-0.4869603217,
0.314894706,
-0.0410130024,
0.0176530685,
0.7140870094,
-0.8988502622,
0.6056098342,
0.6081482768,
0.7409183383,
0.5642978549,
0.2622317076,
0.0442347154,
-0.8282149434,
-0.3331464827,
0.348557204,
0.1040145233,
-0.1405280679,
-0.2747301161,
0.4901246727,
-0.0645507425,
-0.7288187742,
-0.5935633779,
0.204415828,
-0.8987257481,
-0.674561739,
1.0911813974,
-0.0167812034,
-0.1035495102,
-0.4451894164,
-0.2991518676,
0.1934852898,
-0.5884724855,
0.6955497861,
0.9934922457,
-0.4083271623,
-0.0749093965,
-0.3084011972,
0.0249703228,
0.2828803062,
-0.76352036,
-0.1431260556,
0.6159681082,
-0.0411562063,
0.747549355,
0.8538601995,
0.1736874282,
0.2168129981,
-0.2381677479,
0.2556692064,
0.1155677438,
-0.3468297422,
-0.2718178034,
0.7493215799,
-0.2270373851,
-0.6496934295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02901v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02901v1 | SpanRE: Entities and Overlapping Relations Extraction Based on Spans and Entity Attention | 2023-04-06T07:19:39 | 2023-04-06T07:19:39 | Hao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Extracting entities and relations is an essential task of information
extraction. Triplets extracted from a sentence might overlap with each other.
Previous methods either did not address the overlapping issues or solved
overlapping issues partially. To tackle triplet overlapping problems
completely, firstly we extract candidate subjects with a standard span
mechanism. Then we present a labeled span mechanism to extract the objects and
relations simultaneously, we use the labeled span mechanism to generate labeled
spans whose start and end positions indicate the objects, and whose labels
correspond to relations of subject and objects. Besides, we design an entity
attention mechanism to enhance the information fusion between subject and
sentence during extracting objects and relations. We test our method on two
public datasets, our method achieves the best performances on these two
datasets. | [
-0.5280635953,
-0.7767652869,
0.5207954049,
0.7258508205,
-0.0952272266,
0.1407282948,
0.0938402414,
-1.1598528624,
0.3776548505,
0.5467366576,
-0.5508791804,
0.0583521239,
-0.5535978675,
0.1541880816,
-0.4590758681,
1.061455369,
-0.2769365609,
-0.2997424603,
-0.0032913375,
0.1125041172,
-0.3967293203,
-0.2045218796,
-0.4956271946,
-0.0843191966,
0.5634940863,
0.4100748301,
0.4099721611,
0.8300898075,
0.7534662485,
0.2648669183,
-0.1227068603,
0.5770673156,
-0.463694185,
0.058309231,
-0.2821550667,
-0.0309480336,
-0.4031568766,
-0.127288729,
0.6471302509,
0.7351266742,
0.3431220651,
0.1623450518,
-0.0117964903,
0.6444604397,
-0.9694930315,
0.2974472642,
-0.3204042017,
0.0290063415,
-0.622515142,
-0.0729023665,
-0.2090762854,
-0.5986183286,
0.3373799026,
-0.4996685386,
0.1816243976,
0.1300432831,
1.3493409157,
0.176241979,
-0.4845417738,
0.05402961,
-0.8146284223,
0.4388192892,
0.0305128042,
0.3638983369,
0.3295856714,
0.0458282009,
0.0859234408,
-0.7282963395,
-0.4866553843,
0.0877328962,
-0.3264725208,
0.1941067427,
-0.3294698596,
-0.0090488102,
0.3572104871,
0.6753726006,
-0.300627321,
-0.1262231618,
-0.7191807628,
0.0495224297,
0.5765483975,
0.0939217955,
0.510905385,
-0.4015500247,
-0.8205804229,
0.1258093417,
-0.7456522584,
-0.1180351898,
0.546779871,
-0.0706762001,
0.1915284991,
0.9551077485,
-0.2119609118,
0.9620040059,
0.2819789946,
0.4897231162,
0.2090673596,
-0.2463422865,
-0.1444379985,
0.2002799958,
0.8526310921,
0.2863369584,
0.4763085842,
-0.4135098755,
-0.0102719842,
-0.0221302602,
0.1238162965,
-0.2338477671,
-0.2502997518,
0.1926841289,
-0.2649464905,
-0.089351207,
0.4333109558,
-0.9203534126,
0.0619340688,
-0.2730123997,
0.3103808761,
-0.4563462138,
-0.4552212954,
0.1910644323,
-0.0278989617,
0.0918482691,
-0.1371643394,
-1.0906333923,
0.7791799307,
0.7543762922,
0.6504445672,
-0.5115636587,
-0.4968320429,
-0.8152700067,
0.5388112068,
0.0411240533,
0.7891881466,
-0.4570672512,
-0.0664113015,
-0.2103464007,
0.0488058999,
-0.3429576159,
-0.3746859133,
0.3704693317,
-0.7777423859,
0.4283997118,
-0.0532901213,
-0.7873483896,
-0.1673924625,
-0.0171653796,
-1.2971180677,
1.2720041275,
0.1992016584,
-1.2041152716,
0.2276616246,
-0.9477894306,
-0.6194056869,
0.118078649,
0.0772072822,
-0.3680670559,
-0.2027319223,
0.4514402449,
0.5339024663,
-0.1298958957,
0.1272651255,
-0.1040617749,
-0.1658833474,
0.0139211435,
0.2022812814,
0.7326154113,
-0.0637643561,
-0.2409700751,
0.1268549263,
-0.6259880662,
-0.0301383696,
0.0614562333,
-0.3015021086,
-0.5618968606,
-0.0829720646,
0.2379947454,
0.130976364,
0.3275513649,
-0.5801658034,
0.1863383949,
-0.6676251888,
0.2603185773,
0.2631535232,
0.5909759402,
0.3534401059,
-0.0616544932,
0.4211292565,
-0.1895485818,
-0.1668418199,
-0.1761695296,
-0.2130798101,
-0.6981396079,
-0.2676426172,
0.3362807631,
0.4876353145,
-0.3435029089,
0.7140618563,
-0.359636426,
0.0565704554,
-0.5236039162,
-0.1648491621,
0.4718492329,
0.3670451045,
0.3950411677,
-0.0665579289,
-1.0774321556,
-1.070489645,
-0.4915159643,
0.0024791395,
0.0544790477,
0.0277645681,
0.4372673631,
0.3888823986,
1.3056631088,
-1.0297679901,
-0.0995347425,
-0.0545730516,
0.3723271489,
-0.2079117447,
0.3423866034,
0.1931293011,
-1.2372300625,
-0.3683650494,
-0.0215366371,
-0.7538405657,
0.0134229409,
0.0205449034,
-0.2185068429,
0.0708794594,
0.4384016097,
-0.6884010434,
0.333340764,
-0.0396688059,
-0.1113634706,
0.5299264193,
0.3450995088,
0.0727529898,
-1.0229516029,
0.2418815196,
0.2350549847,
-0.3472380638,
-0.678078711,
-0.1303192526,
0.4001895189,
0.1094857156,
-0.430930227,
0.5326815248,
-1.0021348,
-0.3708423972,
-0.1130774319,
0.486574918,
0.1337225288,
0.4518452287,
0.4399783015,
0.5986399055,
0.3280802071,
-0.6127958298,
0.3223032355,
0.5196692348,
-0.3798730671,
0.7090601921,
-0.5011930466,
0.0442975201,
-0.039067205,
-0.025384875,
-0.8171114922,
-0.4515151381,
0.472312212,
-0.1990107149,
0.399882555,
0.1149762794,
-0.3365715146,
-0.8180341721,
-0.1802934855,
0.2012711912,
-0.2307115495,
-0.613429606,
0.261305809,
0.5701745152,
-0.1729459167,
-0.8497665524,
-0.6957686543,
-0.0231724065,
-0.2968669534,
-0.7603946328,
0.5035541058,
0.4313459098,
-0.1973746568,
0.5068385601,
-0.490362376,
-0.3734455705,
-0.221313566,
0.1982074976,
0.3805508018,
-0.2177034765,
0.3299654424,
-0.0543710254,
-0.1077275872,
-0.0006476045,
-0.0279038884,
0.4373407662,
-0.2474807799,
-0.122547552,
-0.4220472872,
0.5467991233,
0.4113455713,
-0.6186828613,
0.4065499306,
0.4246763289,
-0.7010425329,
0.5181000829,
-0.7887096405,
-0.0755690783,
-0.3909099698,
0.464253515,
-0.5826518536,
-0.7840281725,
0.2660291493,
0.0304631684,
-0.1080497727,
0.5945401192,
0.1808088869,
0.1072799265,
0.6703953743,
0.8357856274,
-0.2364002466,
0.4454521537,
-0.0621342883,
0.0015285562,
-1.3300038576,
-0.4794798791,
-0.3203841746,
-0.1299584955,
-0.0565518811,
-0.0262605306,
0.05987335,
0.3752757907,
-0.0604439005,
0.8419017196,
-0.6062440872,
0.729193747,
0.3262894154,
0.2752163112,
0.4492782056,
0.0547855496,
0.2883789539,
-0.2675317526,
-0.2401194572,
-0.3416121006,
0.6992703676,
0.0944451168,
0.5713049173,
0.0687677041,
0.836034894,
0.1506059319,
0.1374316961,
-0.7088272572,
0.2717894912,
0.2269325703,
-0.8556314111,
-0.3405962884,
-0.4721756577,
-1.2472271919,
0.2070271671,
0.0181921534,
-1.5405515432,
0.2388907522,
-0.3016252518,
-0.2629103661,
0.1819879264,
-0.848703742,
0.6334581971,
-0.19442828,
-0.4861457348,
0.2637303174,
-1.0840215683,
0.7546246052,
-0.120255433,
-0.2627950609,
-0.1226975173,
-0.0444414541,
1.0289950371,
-0.2694731653,
0.6349086761,
0.261944145,
0.1081710234,
0.0904920176,
-0.1072543412,
0.4523726106,
-0.10329777,
0.2337436229,
-0.294596374,
-0.2691913247,
-0.1594508886,
-0.3802931011,
0.4992133081,
-0.531868875,
-0.540084362,
-0.2948993742,
-0.6526409388,
-0.2138210982,
0.4814290702,
0.1759137511,
0.1357390434,
-0.3484529257,
-0.1488358825,
0.5481921434,
0.5228543878,
0.6710580587,
0.4525232613,
-0.0249762218,
-0.3893265724,
0.6258403063,
-0.1574066579,
0.1778686941,
0.7348726988,
-0.2210992277,
-0.4354136884,
0.2604302466,
-0.3462707102,
0.3153500557,
-0.32315588,
-0.3091648519,
-1.2029780149,
-0.4928646684,
-0.2483086735,
0.2012491375,
-0.3205377758,
-0.5608512163,
-0.275932759,
-0.1739642918,
0.5182073116,
0.8859949708,
-0.2757823467,
0.2535369098,
-0.8931558132,
0.672557056,
0.2752012908,
0.0633962676,
0.0460691378,
0.2047968209,
0.0848739892,
-0.3043063879,
-0.330791235,
-1.4460641146,
0.0485378876,
-0.0046149031,
0.5828614831,
0.6555441618,
-0.1893183589,
0.730335474,
-0.380358398,
0.3100389838,
0.3429766893,
-1.1537060738,
0.6207625866,
-0.2496313006,
-0.0455837548,
0.2131772637,
0.5632314086,
-0.5898840427,
-0.4237952828,
-0.7797999382,
-1.0422815084,
1.1420255899,
0.7374123335,
-0.5415736437,
0.0086834095,
0.2080158442,
-0.0497825742,
0.0897162035,
-0.8027255535,
-0.3200017214,
0.3659143448,
-0.1618969738,
0.5250187516,
-0.2835386395,
-0.2557494938,
0.1907811761,
0.4306044281,
0.3592753708,
0.1892448813,
0.312466085,
-0.1906716526,
-0.3354721963,
0.1181998625,
0.374270469,
0.7356782556,
-0.3325005174,
0.2950240672,
-0.1243339553,
-0.4192325771,
0.104155384,
0.5846348405,
0.0868583992,
-0.2361763865,
0.3632956147,
0.6399975419,
0.3404614031,
-0.1473600268,
0.450866878,
0.1337509453,
-0.1152635664,
0.0885626599,
-0.0418052375,
0.3510635793,
0.324166894,
0.4139581919,
0.1630141586,
0.2948911488,
-0.1614049077,
0.6302144527,
-0.0251462311,
-0.509350419,
0.056654688,
0.7766339183,
0.0734030977,
-0.3167801499,
0.4519876242,
0.1843969226,
-0.6102190614,
0.8536667824,
0.5665169358,
0.6041651964,
-0.2003587186,
0.1567516327,
0.2670666277,
0.391956836,
-0.3389053941,
0.3431764543,
-0.1864089072,
-0.6172315478,
-0.6598823667,
-0.0656633005,
-0.2203317136,
0.2123393565,
-1.2244529724,
0.2700113058,
0.1246370077,
0.074486129,
0.4092265368,
0.1085994244,
-0.4306959212,
0.2107857168,
0.0559056513,
0.7310340405,
-0.9761125445,
0.5341196656,
0.6351206899,
-0.7355470657,
-0.8708031178,
0.2145148814,
-0.1076064631,
-0.6233424544,
0.7903978229,
0.3860959113,
-0.3960440159,
0.202335313,
-0.4638615251,
-1.1012690067,
0.5902912617,
0.0852427185,
-0.529548347,
-0.0614442937,
-0.2153608054,
0.1517422348,
-0.3145547807,
-0.0399007834,
0.7561149001,
0.7874391675,
-0.018501414,
-0.7175340652,
0.2645434737,
-0.2182398587,
-0.2044615149,
0.7116747499,
-0.5821123719,
0.5358666182,
-0.1029023305,
-0.6118673682,
0.0748071522,
0.8545410037,
0.3774248064,
0.1552012265,
0.5009472966,
0.4576455653,
0.9687936902,
-0.2596379817,
0.78276968,
0.0264460724,
0.5364238024,
1.5371739864,
-0.6784066558,
0.6017620564,
0.6375517249,
-0.2088505477,
0.2833046615,
0.8793537617,
-0.284160465,
0.3935169578,
0.1439040154,
-0.1259805858,
-0.0229969416,
0.095285818,
-0.4604957998,
0.2697219551,
0.5239869356,
-0.2429444492,
-0.3626788557,
0.0391186588,
0.1630963981,
0.0255022272,
-0.0665504709,
0.6855659485,
-0.164170295,
-0.7840184569,
0.1996341646,
-0.0873380676,
0.2251610756,
-0.2476557344,
-0.0436505079,
0.0284907874,
-0.0834272578,
-0.3349082172,
-0.9250720143,
0.2722173035,
-0.0965132192,
-0.4304304123,
0.0779619589,
0.9453220367,
-0.6942142248,
-0.2113651782,
0.2606723011,
0.5856053233,
0.3289169669,
-0.1044812575,
-0.3966752887,
-0.1439921558,
0.0172829274,
-0.4234301448,
-0.2681740224,
0.4780690372,
-0.1871013492,
0.3233550191,
0.3670580983,
0.1492663473,
0.130510211,
-0.1547210515,
0.9014301896,
-0.7525517344,
-0.4892611206,
-0.8541943431,
0.3320531547,
-0.7080024481,
-0.3766424656,
0.5140423179,
0.9479460716,
0.4653996527,
-0.1277872175,
0.6511449218,
-0.3896996975,
0.5926558375,
-0.5505025387,
0.3221715689,
-0.4505863786,
-0.0304714739,
-0.3082077801,
-1.2269484997,
-0.5323044062,
0.3717374206,
-0.4622242749,
-0.0113669168,
1.1779834032,
0.4740350246,
-0.5122401714,
0.2847685218,
-0.1857216805,
0.0092164418,
-0.0372210778,
0.7794331312,
1.06510818,
-0.3904058039,
0.7084749341,
-0.1716976613,
-0.0784629956,
-0.2678040862,
-0.6769219637,
-0.741491437,
-0.5376551151,
-0.2845860422,
-0.1842096448,
0.1055882052,
0.3854304552,
0.918209374,
-0.4666095376,
0.0503267832,
-0.3240253329,
0.3615737855,
-0.4091593027,
-0.3718959689,
0.9681518674,
-0.0728964806,
-0.9410563111,
0.2852326035,
0.4106171429,
0.0831613541,
-0.0212701485,
0.3416491747,
-0.6603665948,
-0.3956981003,
0.1976982802,
0.5529336929,
-0.5417726636,
-0.1963744015,
-0.1116893291,
-0.1769842952,
0.2279313654,
0.999458313,
-0.4527660012,
0.3333542943,
0.4487937391,
0.4822266996,
1.0553926229,
0.3648453057,
0.6266459823,
-1.0642075539,
0.0100249881,
0.1041613668,
0.1323449016,
0.3775983155,
-0.7523668408,
0.9024826884,
-0.0252524652,
-0.3583825827,
-0.4621935785,
0.3966364563,
-1.0727766752,
-0.0635297149,
0.9486032128,
-0.1712309271,
-0.2865390182,
-0.2432857454,
-0.3114384711,
0.4979424477,
-0.3583628833,
0.6767778993,
0.6576371193,
-0.4101857841,
-0.1789683998,
-0.313547045,
0.2667820454,
0.2242436111,
-1.0817029476,
0.081118077,
0.355858922,
0.2038217932,
0.359816879,
0.4688417315,
-0.2935801744,
0.3190359175,
-0.2036360949,
0.3967762589,
-0.0017045217,
-0.5154238343,
0.0508497804,
0.3713309467,
-0.5610232949,
-0.6627702713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02894v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02894v2 | Affect as a proxy for literary mood | 2023-04-06T06:53:23 | 2023-05-23T08:09:23 | Emily Öhman, Riikka Rossi | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose to use affect as a proxy for mood in literary texts. In this
study, we explore the differences in computationally detecting tone versus
detecting mood. Methodologically we utilize affective word embeddings to look
at the affective distribution in different text segments. We also present a
simple yet efficient and effective method of enhancing emotion lexicons to take
both semantic shift and the domain of the text into account producing
real-world congruent results closely matching both contemporary and modern
qualitative analyses. | [
-0.2251715213,
-0.667426765,
0.6894347668,
0.4115336537,
-0.6661548615,
0.0444023423,
0.018337803,
-0.5823968053,
0.9690383077,
0.2325262278,
-0.5807117224,
-0.53210181,
-0.5158646703,
0.2944854498,
-0.5468555689,
0.7565796375,
-0.127301231,
0.0854698271,
-0.0852288306,
-0.2647769451,
-0.084932752,
-0.4864539802,
-0.8164092302,
-0.3294413984,
0.9057424664,
-0.0738906115,
1.1139518023,
-0.1106621474,
0.4122045636,
0.3313511312,
-0.2886191607,
-0.2960166037,
-0.2520625889,
0.603440702,
-0.3853721917,
-0.7382071018,
-0.1363024563,
0.094339706,
0.3333026171,
0.010308085,
0.15127033,
-0.409953624,
-0.4408687353,
1.1919697523,
-0.9584777355,
0.188148424,
-0.4380549788,
0.4373346865,
-0.4027786851,
-0.3381809592,
-0.2986094356,
-0.5910031199,
0.0204436295,
-0.4368799329,
-0.0237727016,
0.1793498099,
0.8996053934,
0.2678340673,
-0.7774928212,
-0.5174316168,
-0.2694794834,
0.6679680347,
-0.5280817151,
0.4242883623,
0.1670562923,
-0.1911529899,
0.1479243785,
-0.6838435531,
-0.8422321081,
-0.2023675293,
0.0536924452,
0.7521324754,
-0.1191435009,
0.2308765352,
0.0356789306,
0.7677775025,
-0.144671157,
-0.4969400167,
0.0941100195,
0.1142332256,
0.5685396194,
0.3786072433,
0.8335732818,
-0.544624269,
0.0488138199,
-0.3321713507,
-0.5362951756,
0.3479455113,
0.6893584132,
0.1819754094,
0.0020772489,
0.6649779677,
0.05936151,
0.1500899941,
0.0872947723,
0.3727913797,
0.246067971,
-0.0991083011,
-0.0665287375,
0.1871416271,
0.6925090551,
0.5337593555,
0.2229846567,
0.1559550166,
-0.1789788157,
0.6440541744,
0.5852389932,
-0.8525800705,
-0.2417160571,
0.4456929564,
-0.4369957745,
-0.3088963628,
-0.1467950046,
-1.2292329073,
-0.9498077035,
-0.2673087716,
0.5601791739,
-0.4419415295,
-0.2504799366,
0.2217789441,
-0.7831150889,
0.1294748485,
0.143845275,
-0.9494023919,
-0.0457514524,
0.6646257639,
0.8461334705,
-0.0901807919,
0.1842374206,
0.0446881391,
-0.4290642738,
-0.5592431426,
0.9287304878,
-0.8360681534,
-0.4918723404,
0.4094053209,
0.2981688976,
0.0505659133,
-0.1762153953,
0.923579514,
-0.5419213176,
0.2764546573,
-0.3163828254,
-0.4480443597,
-0.1227416545,
0.019695932,
-1.0016133785,
1.2539998293,
0.1953210384,
-1.0172444582,
0.1258056462,
-0.4388243556,
-0.5013480186,
-0.3922246695,
0.2774055302,
-0.233555764,
0.6309247017,
-0.1725946665,
0.2028066963,
-0.0640353933,
-0.1983001232,
-0.5743137002,
-0.491602838,
0.6349934936,
0.1467724591,
0.4263144433,
0.2931188941,
-0.6200552583,
0.1367366612,
-0.2511047125,
-0.1816200316,
-0.0470227823,
-0.0397095382,
-0.9819179177,
0.6778993607,
0.4407257438,
0.0877276137,
0.1059206203,
-0.6617318392,
-0.0392953195,
-0.8830282688,
0.162689954,
0.5306993723,
0.0923675597,
0.4747650325,
-0.0362917036,
0.6985269189,
0.0319087319,
-0.1120400578,
-0.0667979196,
-0.2571756244,
-0.7310419679,
-0.2168402821,
0.0895081908,
0.5242073536,
-0.7414987087,
0.0732531995,
0.4575902224,
-0.5007109046,
-1.0006769896,
-0.2841889858,
0.347617507,
0.0876768976,
0.3388257325,
0.0095612602,
-0.3170939386,
-0.4764766991,
-0.9777690768,
-0.2405076474,
0.2233043909,
0.1512870044,
0.1372953057,
-0.0958369449,
0.7030743361,
-0.6005600095,
0.1142291352,
0.010821566,
0.1158899516,
0.1714683324,
0.156591028,
0.7877207994,
-0.9987348914,
-0.6159073114,
-0.0502705276,
-0.6523149014,
-0.5457348228,
-0.0865748599,
-0.7544163465,
0.2138458788,
0.5492016077,
-0.3875511587,
0.5846450925,
0.4965658188,
-1.0003077984,
0.4391458035,
0.2925682366,
0.7517800331,
-0.9772505164,
-0.3057817519,
0.204265669,
0.0677211881,
-0.68377316,
0.0831097066,
0.3611412048,
-0.1210828274,
-0.5122281909,
0.9095673561,
-0.3471473455,
0.365355581,
-0.3358213007,
0.4650940001,
0.4954527318,
0.1082257703,
0.0692348555,
0.2669343948,
0.5964119434,
-0.3494336903,
0.3461753726,
0.2448447645,
-0.0517517738,
0.8952790499,
-0.5289708972,
0.0616864152,
-0.4363470078,
0.0474792197,
-1.3460437059,
-0.0928474367,
0.2487994432,
-0.2410122156,
0.3173508644,
0.0500481687,
-0.2841473818,
-0.1139014959,
-0.7734079957,
0.2943874896,
0.5222594142,
-0.5112469196,
0.6986186504,
0.1481537372,
-0.2088475525,
-0.225456953,
-0.7812230587,
0.0053627342,
-0.7030758262,
-0.4562729001,
0.736459434,
-0.1761294156,
-0.8288664222,
-0.0377502106,
-0.0381578766,
-0.1631760895,
-0.1177991033,
0.5310608745,
0.1476389766,
0.0600553527,
0.5192529559,
0.6982361078,
0.2691071332,
0.3969593346,
0.2048663199,
0.1302802116,
0.1199521795,
-0.1509359926,
-0.4870468378,
0.4989807606,
0.7318802476,
-0.0221023858,
0.6753024459,
0.525429368,
-0.2609777451,
-0.2494636774,
-0.220684126,
-0.088592425,
-0.546977818,
-0.1580150127,
-0.4223985374,
-0.7467532754,
0.7533888221,
-0.0724897534,
-0.4885679185,
0.5249528289,
0.5758278966,
-0.2118300647,
1.1496350765,
0.4019711614,
-0.0209686533,
1.1715542078,
0.3442208171,
0.2856992781,
-1.0165394545,
0.0527216978,
-0.7903311253,
-0.3751137257,
-0.7418987751,
0.0040150685,
0.1833274662,
0.2642208934,
-0.0003493254,
-0.0171829443,
-0.6426230073,
0.1820901185,
0.023570111,
0.3847830296,
-0.138604328,
-0.2274941951,
0.0148162376,
-0.3912082016,
0.0525097437,
-0.3033786118,
0.5963413119,
0.0044102692,
0.7123587132,
0.3367136121,
0.7335942984,
0.4837047756,
0.4607004523,
-1.1801166534,
0.2581574321,
-0.2644784749,
-0.7294539809,
-0.1210263819,
0.0056422316,
-1.1306786537,
0.4048393071,
-0.3385597467,
-0.5863766074,
0.641131103,
0.1489126384,
0.158985883,
-0.025799945,
-0.6947004199,
1.019348979,
0.0459720045,
-0.6022134423,
-0.3979085088,
-0.3221302629,
0.1400890499,
0.0013971856,
0.3049871922,
-0.265506506,
-0.1547340751,
0.6983132958,
-0.4696255326,
0.8132002354,
-0.1816414297,
-0.0305528119,
0.6278960705,
0.4446465075,
0.3913674951,
-0.0351206511,
-0.7147905231,
-0.2130491138,
0.453542769,
-0.4458018541,
-0.7137913108,
0.6991541386,
-0.5760324001,
-0.2886040807,
-0.4681990743,
-0.3294947743,
-0.1641344726,
-0.1278584301,
0.1486576945,
0.4721510112,
-0.440775454,
-0.3268449903,
0.2551715374,
-0.2832468152,
0.721088469,
0.4895489514,
-0.2953853905,
-0.4047305584,
0.6206074953,
-0.1292112619,
0.1676733643,
0.3538961411,
0.6317533255,
-0.5778182745,
-0.0534474291,
0.0142255565,
0.1895988584,
-0.8214057088,
-0.0344516747,
-0.6208044887,
0.4601582587,
-0.3904991746,
-0.5538937449,
-0.1311699003,
-0.1898096502,
-0.368157506,
-0.144514367,
0.9403342009,
0.694069922,
0.1315106899,
0.3530295789,
-0.5716558099,
0.2618854046,
0.1113206148,
0.4198353887,
-0.2634294629,
-0.5713912845,
-0.1604389101,
-0.3429395258,
-0.1377236992,
-1.7670766115,
0.8266333938,
0.2251194715,
0.0316153839,
0.443818897,
0.5761523843,
0.41611588,
-0.3253721595,
1.0838514566,
0.1106082425,
-1.5169543028,
0.7267383337,
-0.3973630965,
0.4079746604,
0.6068252325,
0.5948008299,
-0.8429371715,
-0.6145743132,
-0.6134142876,
-0.9714359641,
0.3422184587,
-0.1056549847,
0.5497349501,
-0.6588457227,
0.7924432755,
-0.0616751574,
0.2792704403,
-0.7418492436,
0.0083485013,
-0.391531378,
-0.6199271679,
-0.0985900834,
-0.4211363792,
0.1092708036,
-0.0874053165,
0.3360339701,
-0.0271337125,
0.4004677534,
0.5731637478,
-0.0090572229,
-0.0438806564,
0.3068484366,
0.1714678109,
0.138497591,
-0.2080201954,
0.6216381788,
-0.0331721604,
-0.4767749608,
0.027174199,
-0.2209071815,
0.0761466399,
0.3455998302,
0.3254972398,
0.6506483555,
0.4744443297,
-0.536799252,
0.4243403375,
0.2187245786,
0.0041391933,
-0.17450203,
-0.0653290376,
0.2333092839,
0.5978965163,
-0.1091118008,
-0.471173197,
0.6462129354,
-0.9578398466,
-0.1685991138,
0.3496457636,
-0.9998250008,
-0.4981612563,
0.5265943408,
0.1722278595,
-0.4569737911,
0.1207108647,
-0.3868322372,
-0.8591439724,
0.733283937,
0.678621769,
1.0387868881,
-0.4971154928,
0.3663977087,
0.1278954595,
-0.0231456291,
-0.0995938629,
0.9017117023,
0.3176851571,
-0.7628305554,
-0.252636373,
-0.7155612707,
-0.7472487688,
-0.4932814837,
-0.6616063714,
0.2702389359,
-0.2867557704,
-0.2894529104,
0.138595432,
-0.2790440023,
-0.2800773382,
0.2859329581,
0.053214848,
0.582675755,
-0.9507740736,
0.6321065426,
1.1050350666,
-0.4047825634,
-0.6390841603,
0.0694900602,
0.3907106817,
-0.0966624022,
0.4862307906,
0.1287009269,
-0.4326637387,
-0.0825727582,
-0.5900754929,
-0.5836052299,
0.7216678262,
-0.0259828921,
-0.1237210184,
0.5687572956,
-0.3525094688,
1.1144676208,
-0.1064747125,
0.6526945829,
0.2228775024,
0.6976588368,
-0.0412777215,
-0.175418824,
0.1783087701,
-0.5473311543,
-0.1617115736,
0.7247211933,
-0.6374251842,
0.8661555648,
0.382507652,
-0.5206626654,
-0.2899796963,
0.76619941,
-0.1864878833,
0.8081144094,
0.5973806381,
0.2876631021,
0.7189541459,
-0.2419199198,
1.3811563253,
-0.5149964094,
0.2437795401,
0.2558238506,
-0.4603586197,
0.9628864527,
0.5815568566,
-0.4112056494,
1.0687843561,
0.9563487768,
0.3582711816,
0.5666109324,
0.528226912,
-0.8007460237,
-0.0165973715,
-0.1345878541,
-0.0975763947,
0.1947339773,
0.496367991,
-0.2907002866,
0.2990324497,
0.1805296093,
0.3476677537,
0.2838208079,
-0.5326527357,
0.4579704106,
0.2696828544,
-0.7164940238,
0.0203248523,
0.0066978615,
0.6518952847,
-0.4338827133,
-0.0336221419,
-0.4071196616,
0.1375833154,
-0.4879251719,
-0.8312031031,
0.5345054269,
0.0055534039,
-0.2605733275,
-0.2298225909,
0.9535444379,
-0.2803035975,
-0.3412122428,
0.7470752001,
0.2980727255,
0.3121859133,
-0.4969032109,
-0.4928926528,
0.1716701686,
-0.1711733639,
-0.5693541765,
0.214420855,
0.9121049047,
0.0917884037,
0.1842626333,
0.2893010676,
-0.0862580687,
-0.0574959405,
0.2315229177,
0.8092030287,
-1.2221060991,
-0.3595171273,
-0.8860803843,
0.6790091991,
0.020305559,
-0.5115991235,
0.4056796134,
-0.1065467596,
-0.1026570722,
-0.0514640287,
0.4227419794,
-0.2808710635,
0.1226295233,
-0.6183872223,
0.5693135262,
-0.7862056494,
-0.1988122761,
-0.8887685537,
-0.8997913599,
-0.2323663831,
0.5786375999,
-0.3152423203,
-0.3695405126,
1.2117679119,
0.6787748337,
0.2875071764,
0.2448632419,
0.1851174831,
0.1160244793,
-0.0305811372,
0.0814168975,
1.10197258,
-0.1694722325,
-0.0833885074,
-0.0296509806,
-0.3112030625,
-0.2091635764,
-0.9970376492,
-0.919670701,
-0.5583605766,
-0.565100193,
-0.7432845235,
0.2366356701,
0.468984127,
-0.1391398311,
-0.565371871,
0.0701309144,
0.0068661459,
0.4809404314,
-0.1605146527,
-0.3182134032,
0.4904496968,
-0.501732707,
-1.0888165236,
0.4404689372,
0.3385464847,
-0.1444625109,
-0.0855262354,
0.3091329038,
-0.0860235319,
0.7104866505,
0.8014203906,
-0.0505188555,
-0.4393641353,
-0.6290538311,
-0.0430041887,
-0.3837432861,
-0.056228891,
0.8455242515,
-0.5553889871,
0.6051573753,
1.0083447695,
0.2731588185,
0.6661590338,
-0.1260800809,
0.346363157,
-0.355455935,
0.164899841,
0.0769280344,
0.4991587698,
0.1733074486,
-0.7028949857,
0.5672948956,
0.2746559083,
-0.5832070112,
-0.4298495352,
0.2265543342,
-1.1737142801,
-0.4052546024,
1.1405528784,
-0.1538338065,
-0.2895613015,
0.1051723212,
-0.5009407401,
0.4145293832,
-0.3455654979,
0.7985829115,
0.9776128531,
-0.4112943709,
-0.1754261106,
-0.5283405781,
0.6259155869,
0.9268352389,
-0.9782860875,
-0.2210188955,
0.5990831256,
-0.2006350458,
0.2396346629,
0.3805665672,
-0.3476224542,
-0.2144583315,
0.2418548763,
0.5646632314,
0.7013500333,
0.0764603689,
-0.5575921535,
0.3113175929,
-0.2245560735,
0.2552315593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02886v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02886v1 | Automatic ICD-10 Code Association: A Challenging Task on French Clinical Texts | 2023-04-06T06:31:54 | 2023-04-06T06:31:54 | Yakini Tchouka, Jean-François Couchot, David Laiymani, Philippe Selles, Azzedine Rahmani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatically associating ICD codes with electronic health data is a
well-known NLP task in medical research. NLP has evolved significantly in
recent years with the emergence of pre-trained language models based on
Transformers architecture, mainly in the English language. This paper adapts
these models to automatically associate the ICD codes. Several neural network
architectures have been experimented with to address the challenges of dealing
with a large set of both input tokens and labels to be guessed. In this paper,
we propose a model that combines the latest advances in NLP and multi-label
classification for ICD-10 code association. Fair experiments on a Clinical
dataset in the French language show that our approach increases the $F_1$-score
metric by more than 55\% compared to state-of-the-art results. | [
-0.3538066149,
-0.2064837217,
0.5695709586,
0.438986659,
-0.2794211507,
-0.0147555694,
0.0145031177,
-0.8953053951,
0.3574581146,
0.1498984098,
-0.0019886775,
-0.4799595773,
-0.9274091125,
0.2717673779,
-0.2843549252,
0.8808131218,
-0.1370813102,
0.4160249829,
-0.0354894288,
-0.6145760417,
-0.346408844,
-0.9416359663,
-0.8345713615,
-0.3234192729,
0.6909162402,
-0.1643221527,
0.5296025276,
0.6689399481,
1.0122016668,
0.3273684382,
0.0169614032,
0.1099547893,
0.3505393267,
-0.1921822131,
-0.0350426473,
0.0910800472,
-1.1868625879,
-0.2487777174,
0.212331295,
0.6308135986,
-0.199609533,
0.0606354326,
-0.209472701,
0.4466007352,
-0.3345205486,
0.2685037255,
-0.1699419171,
0.0782972798,
0.1223106086,
-0.2172921151,
-0.5466331244,
-0.2468351275,
0.055474259,
-0.2899008095,
-0.1851050556,
-0.1120654419,
0.617213428,
0.1311253011,
-0.3430435658,
-0.6173511147,
-0.7820565701,
0.1245763227,
-0.5824201107,
0.595497191,
0.2437294871,
0.1051421985,
0.1722034961,
-1.0792559385,
-0.3882559836,
0.072889775,
-0.264873594,
-0.059171129,
-0.4120281339,
-0.0728309602,
0.1079332903,
0.2262538373,
-0.4862459898,
0.191539228,
-0.523275435,
-0.070987761,
0.6927518249,
-0.0466814339,
0.776309967,
0.1947339326,
-0.222717911,
-0.0553383119,
-0.3171297014,
-0.2286516279,
-0.2156836241,
0.2107897252,
-0.5018770099,
0.39648965,
-0.116485782,
0.7165241838,
0.0324652307,
0.0463503189,
0.8403170109,
-0.2455516309,
-0.3126641512,
0.5817020535,
0.9740187526,
0.3044367135,
0.4229444563,
-0.3404247165,
-0.3950613737,
0.2077513933,
0.5722663999,
-0.4103521705,
-0.6516199708,
0.233565703,
-0.6373337507,
-0.3922683895,
-0.1249182746,
-0.6351091862,
-0.1313874274,
-0.3817441761,
0.5692053437,
-0.2301457077,
-0.0653007925,
0.3192991614,
0.149835974,
-0.1008109525,
0.210833177,
-0.8047133684,
0.5822768807,
0.2149802446,
0.5149559975,
-0.3762455285,
-0.2345684022,
-0.5376384854,
-0.1075094268,
-0.4214669466,
0.9784275293,
-0.4342775345,
-0.2618299723,
-0.305608362,
0.1106353551,
-0.0362453088,
-0.4396588802,
0.3901173174,
-0.4908229709,
0.2100412399,
0.3919140399,
-0.2919165194,
0.0175031908,
0.2755099237,
-0.8543505669,
0.8209900856,
0.1381598413,
-0.5658982992,
0.2333008349,
-0.5858440995,
-0.4962210953,
0.1660800427,
-0.2085401714,
-0.4582919776,
0.1692478359,
0.5312743187,
0.2783739567,
-0.4546906948,
0.6512039304,
-0.1800552905,
0.0473351516,
0.1376350075,
-0.4603499472,
0.7758896947,
0.0435392559,
-0.1073783189,
0.1852295846,
-0.9402145147,
0.1839151382,
-0.039063938,
-0.2938785851,
-0.5013409853,
-0.2365178168,
0.1505388021,
0.370248884,
-0.0819656551,
-0.2529649138,
0.3106377125,
-0.50193578,
0.2741492987,
0.4055460095,
0.20639956,
0.5637254119,
-0.4639631212,
0.394955188,
0.092604585,
0.2261878103,
-0.2525183558,
-0.8136783838,
-0.3256685734,
0.0786413476,
0.6360456944,
0.6460160613,
-0.5362328887,
0.5720011592,
-0.370977968,
-0.509293437,
-0.6494155526,
-0.0498147644,
0.3677456975,
0.5138459802,
0.728171885,
-0.5962237716,
-0.1700861305,
-0.7479096055,
0.0894367248,
-0.1344376355,
-0.1384194791,
0.4985883832,
0.2836356461,
-0.3729020953,
0.3961582482,
-0.5415208936,
-0.56111902,
-0.1139602438,
0.0818296671,
0.316483885,
0.9639186263,
0.657417953,
-0.8404439688,
-0.6306810975,
0.2967854738,
-0.5611202121,
-0.0418948308,
-0.1628314853,
0.134521842,
-0.2363357991,
0.546451509,
-0.1074160114,
0.5251773,
0.5663949847,
-0.2288811058,
0.2485339195,
-0.7771934867,
0.1211558804,
-1.026812911,
-0.0181591921,
0.157209754,
-0.0056672096,
-0.9372333288,
0.0453988798,
0.450856179,
-0.1265196949,
-0.6588102579,
0.9027011991,
-0.3289741874,
0.1676857471,
-0.0490144342,
-0.1417254359,
0.0704579875,
0.4278853536,
0.3861245811,
0.4948969185,
0.5306680202,
-0.8427124619,
0.4549770653,
0.4104538858,
-0.3262827396,
0.2013859749,
-0.5020371079,
0.1488947719,
0.0909805894,
0.1865749359,
-0.5588803291,
-0.0608425438,
0.092004329,
-0.3864578605,
0.4191108346,
0.1064452529,
-0.2433940619,
-0.5064554811,
0.342828095,
1.0965021849,
0.4357655942,
-0.8465368748,
0.8033239841,
0.5605717301,
-0.2595245242,
-0.2668109238,
-0.5368722081,
0.2894596457,
-0.1013883725,
-0.3333673179,
0.8676325083,
-0.0960458294,
-0.0138685713,
-0.1663841009,
0.0080265775,
-0.4718315005,
0.0326199308,
0.0481961332,
0.2441789359,
-0.4410690665,
0.505143106,
-0.0214290936,
-0.2549730837,
-0.0016799582,
-0.1772165149,
0.6153444052,
0.1235321984,
-0.3949725032,
-0.7205401063,
0.3748047054,
0.6861812472,
-0.5044935942,
0.5217843056,
0.2724204361,
-0.8401660323,
-0.1519094706,
-0.3641183376,
-0.135116294,
-0.4458798468,
0.2938350737,
-0.4773835838,
-0.011566652,
0.5982559919,
-0.2437569648,
-0.2046277821,
0.3197591901,
0.4843255877,
0.00488564,
1.200063467,
0.6837286353,
-0.2256385535,
-0.0383836515,
-0.0087145939,
0.4445304871,
-0.7701984644,
-0.2710215449,
-0.7980922461,
-0.272582978,
-0.3690341115,
-0.2200380415,
0.313279748,
0.0359360278,
-0.16939345,
0.3728106618,
-0.9046509862,
0.158343643,
0.3104324937,
0.354563266,
0.1932356656,
-0.0904217213,
-0.265620321,
0.1537997723,
-0.8829312325,
-0.1218435019,
1.1399227381,
0.249018997,
0.6741017103,
0.2198813409,
0.6803417802,
0.2933518291,
0.6471779943,
-0.6246176958,
0.1497568488,
-0.6161571741,
-0.1322514117,
0.2585573494,
-0.0217367355,
-0.8034732938,
-0.256239146,
-0.4416632056,
-0.8054977059,
0.4534056187,
0.1538899839,
-0.5222052932,
0.1644590348,
-0.8070311546,
0.9912692904,
-0.6193416715,
0.1815301627,
0.2010685503,
-0.420356214,
0.2190711796,
-0.5194710493,
0.3490458727,
0.1852274388,
0.1497418582,
0.8120996356,
-0.1632324904,
0.4672437608,
0.223916471,
-0.1125755906,
-0.1637902409,
-0.2114720196,
0.3630186021,
0.2597980797,
-0.0590732768,
0.1956715733,
0.0297257788,
-0.1898067296,
-0.5359293222,
0.6957974434,
-0.7087139487,
-0.2328788936,
-0.4854178131,
-0.2544022202,
-0.3239384294,
0.3035059273,
0.1598903537,
1.1110274792,
-0.0586597882,
-0.1605722755,
0.5107879639,
-0.6089690328,
0.5508176684,
0.3042359054,
-0.1548249424,
-0.4524594247,
0.7021573782,
-0.1446816027,
0.2949543893,
0.4566802979,
0.1644261032,
-0.2473504394,
-0.5080013275,
-0.6729679108,
0.1904572546,
-0.6962790489,
-0.4549683332,
-0.9068775177,
-0.6813756824,
-0.4581817091,
-0.3354082406,
-0.1944016963,
-0.1848786026,
-0.3509853482,
-0.1060750261,
0.2708024681,
0.6972647309,
0.2182080299,
0.2196164578,
-1.2475814819,
0.5972796082,
0.0587305352,
0.6571948528,
0.172939688,
-0.2070922256,
-0.1064423919,
-0.1182624847,
0.1099227294,
-1.1164685488,
0.3582248986,
0.1441900432,
0.5332519412,
0.4422786534,
0.2040619254,
0.565530777,
-0.8748635054,
0.5514053702,
0.531203866,
-0.7628832459,
0.2665313184,
0.2640067041,
0.2797109485,
0.2309821546,
0.4838854373,
-0.6365039945,
-0.1821347177,
-0.7947158217,
-0.6581586599,
0.7227314711,
-0.1374340653,
0.2881269455,
-0.308128804,
0.4303342104,
-0.1398773044,
0.0115321903,
-0.7372199297,
-0.6194447875,
0.1455513537,
-0.7807435393,
-0.1437354684,
-0.1137983501,
-0.1901550293,
-0.3755532205,
0.5359296203,
-0.132058531,
0.754668355,
0.294408083,
0.010026115,
0.0757308528,
-0.0093521997,
0.7247138619,
0.6693641543,
0.0107797328,
0.2281336188,
0.0273151658,
-0.7830806375,
0.4118150771,
0.3216916323,
0.0769037157,
0.0250200145,
0.4072033763,
0.6605812907,
0.0111489072,
-0.48908481,
0.429835856,
-0.300427109,
-0.3685617149,
-0.1861314327,
0.031436909,
0.1427044123,
-0.0056190263,
0.3218708932,
0.4601808488,
-0.141616866,
-0.2616258264,
0.8738630414,
0.2050441653,
-0.715497911,
-0.2851966918,
0.6706004739,
0.3950560093,
-0.9508748055,
0.5735092759,
-0.2596971691,
-0.5890738964,
1.0503870249,
0.5790984631,
0.7435732484,
-0.5067320466,
0.1403695643,
0.3856830895,
0.2315523326,
-0.1451081038,
0.2140684575,
0.2611628771,
-1.0068712234,
-0.5989218354,
-0.5627522469,
0.0972838849,
0.3799798787,
-0.774825573,
0.6161524057,
-0.3412927687,
-0.1163766161,
0.3816457689,
-0.320112884,
-0.7685258985,
0.6578555703,
0.1956016868,
1.0401637554,
-0.6719591022,
1.2352006435,
0.7923522592,
-0.2380966991,
-0.8456035852,
-0.2729356289,
-0.2008292228,
-0.7469836473,
0.707511127,
-0.0238037296,
0.3242924213,
0.2011996955,
0.2132842243,
-0.8322406411,
0.6657528877,
-0.2591257989,
-0.5239509344,
-0.2683311403,
-0.1573758125,
0.6074872017,
-0.8386738896,
0.1996710598,
0.4488885999,
0.2597528994,
-0.318993032,
-1.2126777172,
0.1041996405,
-0.4557381868,
-0.624586761,
0.4462817609,
-0.0890342072,
0.5059854984,
-0.3010831773,
-0.086322166,
-0.0979554728,
0.3379380405,
-0.207668677,
0.5483266115,
0.3918910325,
0.5868052244,
0.6092414856,
0.0261667557,
0.7860601544,
-0.8199326992,
0.267446816,
1.3313728571,
-0.300464958,
0.650747478,
0.1363691092,
-0.4166317284,
0.2484357208,
0.4845866263,
-0.0513363145,
0.5097916722,
-0.0178662464,
-0.409250021,
0.0583686121,
0.1426580846,
-0.5332508683,
0.4174053669,
0.5763465762,
-0.5742458105,
-0.2438126802,
0.3740543723,
-0.5200648904,
0.1654199809,
-0.4027559161,
1.1466518641,
0.1830424219,
-0.3796584606,
0.326610446,
0.1931348443,
0.4009927809,
-0.3816708624,
-0.0777585357,
0.0060498663,
0.254609853,
-0.1377560347,
-0.2126022875,
0.2863595784,
-0.2252596617,
-0.2053346485,
-0.2491032183,
0.4942843318,
-0.4382853806,
-0.7129235268,
0.4511450827,
0.619161129,
-0.1276073903,
0.2891412675,
-0.8928955793,
-0.189102754,
0.0644717515,
0.1853094995,
0.5945922136,
0.3570763171,
-0.1002505645,
0.5771154165,
0.5174595118,
0.4561341405,
0.0470255911,
0.2266279757,
0.8266979456,
-0.4457449019,
-0.6373735666,
-0.5206057429,
0.212558791,
0.1362081766,
-0.34257707,
-0.0552491099,
0.3623114824,
0.6058478355,
0.0505568162,
0.4898767173,
0.0980278105,
0.3112972379,
-0.4307035506,
0.876319468,
-0.57197541,
0.2918618023,
-0.2159261256,
-0.8814432025,
-0.8213200569,
0.4743308127,
-0.0047867196,
-0.0632289052,
0.8718335629,
0.4690515995,
-0.3622326553,
-0.1347796768,
0.1849218905,
0.0352469943,
0.4337600768,
0.4427655637,
0.0396764427,
-0.6404217482,
0.3213893175,
-0.6905776858,
-0.057511095,
0.1299242377,
-0.762989521,
-0.5765069723,
-0.6700264215,
-0.5731105208,
-0.4526099265,
-0.0696997046,
1.0253931284,
0.5001036525,
-1.0470980406,
0.1802320927,
-0.0650365129,
0.1191748157,
-0.5090982318,
-0.1019940972,
0.9371207952,
-0.3399963379,
-0.7300552726,
0.222958684,
0.4663262665,
0.438223511,
0.1052246839,
-0.0505939983,
-0.2134181261,
-0.155832544,
0.3067064285,
0.0822051615,
-0.4553071856,
-0.0893328711,
0.0668055415,
-0.2260210961,
0.2385980338,
0.841563046,
-0.9769399762,
0.6646777391,
0.2731069624,
0.8652005196,
0.0078039416,
0.1996851414,
0.6322976947,
-0.4692522585,
0.139095515,
0.3469774425,
0.2711578012,
0.0240861792,
-0.3211934566,
0.1979294866,
-0.0243963413,
-0.44755885,
-0.9371051192,
-0.0575315319,
-0.6977413297,
-0.3533725739,
0.6988004446,
-0.0691092387,
-0.0101612508,
-0.4040504992,
0.01585472,
-0.0656760186,
-0.0779137909,
0.9208408594,
0.6078314781,
-0.1979321837,
-0.1874931008,
-0.3512783051,
0.9201518893,
0.1370153874,
-0.8450881243,
-0.3980665505,
0.0781104937,
-0.1352658272,
0.5513750911,
0.8613938093,
-0.1289337128,
0.4348482788,
-0.2701613605,
0.2352076024,
0.1880328953,
-0.6300735474,
-0.5248816013,
0.2199894935,
-0.1505889148,
-0.1076655909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.05371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.05371v1 | Those Aren't Your Memories, They're Somebody Else's: Seeding Misinformation in Chat Bot Memories | 2023-04-06T05:09:39 | 2023-04-06T05:09:39 | Conor Atkins, Benjamin Zi Hao Zhao, Hassan Jameel Asghar, Ian Wood, Mohamed Ali Kaafar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | One of the new developments in chit-chat bots is a long-term memory mechanism
that remembers information from past conversations for increasing engagement
and consistency of responses. The bot is designed to extract knowledge of
personal nature from their conversation partner, e.g., stating preference for a
particular color. In this paper, we show that this memory mechanism can result
in unintended behavior. In particular, we found that one can combine a personal
statement with an informative statement that would lead the bot to remember the
informative statement alongside personal knowledge in its long term memory.
This means that the bot can be tricked into remembering misinformation which it
would regurgitate as statements of fact when recalling information relevant to
the topic of conversation. We demonstrate this vulnerability on the BlenderBot
2 framework implemented on the ParlAI platform and provide examples on the more
recent and significantly larger BlenderBot 3 model. We generate 150 examples of
misinformation, of which 114 (76%) were remembered by BlenderBot 2 when
combined with a personal statement. We further assessed the risk of this
misinformation being recalled after intervening innocuous conversation and in
response to multiple questions relevant to the injected memory. Our evaluation
was performed on both the memory-only and the combination of memory and
internet search modes of BlenderBot 2. From the combinations of these
variables, we generated 12,890 conversations and analyzed recalled
misinformation in the responses. We found that when the chat bot is questioned
on the misinformation topic, it was 328% more likely to respond with the
misinformation as fact when the misinformation was in the long-term memory. | [
-0.1128446758,
-1.1488831043,
0.525167048,
0.0715939701,
0.0367181376,
0.1651162058,
0.0747450516,
-0.4576697648,
0.3594298363,
0.7181420326,
-0.3147906065,
0.3119029403,
-0.5380024314,
-0.2256272286,
-0.4393715858,
0.983618319,
0.4558375478,
-0.3946871459,
-0.3070785403,
-0.1992756873,
-1.2172322273,
-0.7214941978,
-0.5895522237,
-0.2839716375,
0.4765149951,
0.4046082497,
0.8162591457,
0.1925434619,
0.3388487697,
0.3278909028,
0.118914783,
-0.1191795915,
-1.046505928,
0.1554955542,
-0.4380063117,
-0.9058724046,
0.1275027245,
0.0645849854,
0.2605367005,
0.3110949993,
0.0155780641,
-0.0348899141,
0.1241958439,
0.6379125118,
-0.7851926684,
-0.010066621,
-1.1048719883,
0.031366311,
-0.0574001223,
-0.7172996998,
-0.7214378715,
-0.1727312952,
0.1613893956,
-0.0832068771,
0.381347537,
0.260286659,
0.9328901172,
0.193444252,
0.028522253,
-0.210254699,
-1.0022531748,
0.6630685925,
-0.4077256024,
-0.0313109383,
0.6414628625,
0.7599032521,
-0.490895927,
-0.3761326969,
-0.7173349261,
0.0485268682,
-0.2288968116,
0.2408019304,
-0.4965410233,
-0.1702186912,
0.284026742,
0.1487700939,
-0.465069294,
-0.2188973129,
-0.7984399199,
-0.6150920987,
0.4415314496,
0.0821011588,
0.2013319433,
-0.077861473,
-0.6242144704,
-0.1653387547,
-0.5550541282,
-0.2033262998,
0.4176745713,
0.0582211502,
-0.1019933,
0.7412420511,
0.0307876747,
0.2861578166,
0.3295362592,
-0.1687367409,
0.2893556356,
-0.1430404633,
-0.2259354442,
0.3832086623,
0.7328694463,
0.6204750538,
0.4749216735,
-0.2320370078,
0.159499079,
0.045551084,
0.5973367095,
-0.3970646262,
-0.5175077319,
0.2541500628,
-0.6276150346,
-0.2983959913,
0.0200901702,
-0.7290690541,
-0.6323602796,
0.4513780475,
0.7036626339,
-0.6171917915,
-0.0484001301,
-0.1165904403,
-0.7811905146,
-0.0184231531,
0.457677871,
-0.6660140753,
0.1995864064,
0.6143607497,
0.7043935657,
0.0870345235,
-0.4395466745,
-0.1873772293,
0.2848949134,
-0.1411586702,
0.8803879619,
-0.596685648,
-0.5627250671,
-0.1463707387,
0.2408042699,
-0.1454393417,
-0.7083632946,
0.0861255601,
-0.4772071838,
0.6077364683,
-0.3897565305,
-0.5585294962,
-0.5885726213,
0.0840027779,
-0.423612684,
0.7822219133,
0.1995675713,
-0.9487872124,
0.0957393423,
-0.0585331507,
-0.3212003708,
-0.0387682877,
-0.4297780097,
-0.3058855832,
0.1559373587,
-0.3308695257,
0.2985953987,
-0.32941401,
0.1448195279,
-0.2867237628,
-0.3252559006,
0.6124687791,
-0.7070598602,
0.5444951057,
0.0012229552,
-0.0535482652,
-0.2117590904,
-0.2312997282,
-0.2694880664,
0.4341659844,
-0.1715862155,
-0.3991070688,
-0.0818351507,
-0.6123209,
0.4079398811,
0.2176764905,
-0.6525725722,
-0.173204869,
-0.2931644619,
0.3294052184,
0.9017048478,
0.4409321249,
0.2599728107,
-1.0561858416,
0.2198883295,
0.6806766987,
0.0863872319,
-0.7657426,
-0.9602432847,
-0.7669458389,
0.4227374196,
-0.21091564,
0.6432828307,
-0.4070880711,
0.3868294954,
-0.0345372111,
-0.3765810132,
-0.32423985,
0.0574424155,
0.3950443566,
0.9367462397,
0.4099946916,
-0.2916023135,
-0.3789649606,
-1.2576407194,
-0.4169071317,
-0.5130831599,
0.0981135964,
0.5394769311,
0.4942223728,
-0.1296114475,
1.33573699,
-0.630148828,
-0.2023712397,
-0.135978654,
0.1598123908,
0.0075685,
0.6440863013,
0.8014432788,
-0.7657219172,
-0.1881460547,
-0.289793849,
-0.5296276212,
0.4278158247,
-0.6614857316,
-0.1736498624,
0.1585318893,
0.2024778724,
-0.7059116364,
0.5623160601,
0.5090985894,
-0.2601771355,
0.3840944171,
-0.4943192303,
0.1469358355,
-1.0596871376,
-0.2292679101,
-0.2102557272,
-0.0297923926,
-0.2845391035,
-0.7228110433,
-0.0090592643,
0.1132106408,
-0.5536560416,
0.6013791561,
-0.1273786873,
0.1522421688,
-0.470635891,
0.1273231655,
-0.0669309795,
0.641068399,
-0.1974385977,
0.6652866602,
0.552660048,
-0.6110290885,
0.1775435507,
0.16686894,
-0.1464886516,
0.5033878088,
-0.3731476963,
0.35428527,
-0.4754745364,
0.340909183,
-1.0776844025,
-0.4397837818,
0.6885325909,
-0.7236994505,
0.1056722924,
-0.0886896849,
-0.6392793655,
-0.4437940717,
-0.2428173274,
0.1222570539,
0.6942318678,
-0.3577708006,
0.6032643318,
0.5894240141,
-0.0275138766,
-0.3476611376,
-0.8158572912,
-0.105325304,
-0.3034268022,
-0.4730029404,
0.078029871,
-0.0304818004,
-0.1113924459,
0.1216044351,
-0.1427555829,
-0.1229434982,
-0.0731358901,
0.68846488,
0.0674897581,
-0.0414575785,
0.4890707731,
-0.0105552012,
-0.2054873407,
0.0308096427,
0.1127651483,
0.9451763034,
0.143288523,
-0.3315382898,
-0.5082880259,
0.3033395708,
0.1573381722,
0.2680440843,
0.8994261622,
0.1919516027,
-0.3096680343,
0.0785355195,
-0.8759406805,
-0.5864124894,
-0.4994924963,
0.2356644273,
-0.199512884,
-0.770945549,
0.4190128744,
-0.2365500629,
-0.0866681561,
0.4516589046,
0.3446970284,
-0.5464549661,
0.7906060219,
0.5260795951,
-0.4257912636,
0.2990685999,
0.0937808678,
0.1766202301,
-0.5403930545,
-0.3190193474,
-0.1829908639,
-0.6334335804,
-0.6079274416,
-0.904099524,
0.0140106985,
0.0222683828,
-0.267433852,
0.4100903273,
-0.0515371338,
0.7130604982,
0.6662931442,
0.0750958025,
0.2067268342,
-0.0881537572,
0.3370807171,
0.0144572686,
-0.8514624238,
-0.3908718824,
1.1072289944,
0.3756021559,
0.8278979063,
-0.1772016883,
0.5342965126,
0.5346166492,
-0.1158298329,
-0.4297339916,
0.4232209623,
0.2634523809,
-0.914822042,
0.0182981137,
-0.2740816474,
-1.0350999832,
0.0541803874,
-0.2485808879,
-1.2056586742,
0.0843456984,
0.5495647788,
-0.3613597155,
0.3870862722,
-0.7501528263,
0.3534418046,
-0.3381847143,
-0.1192511991,
-0.6092153192,
-0.8659082651,
0.3977348804,
-0.2802729905,
0.0059033241,
-0.3271191716,
0.3507956862,
0.7254893184,
-0.0980119556,
1.2042136192,
0.0305529293,
0.3979045153,
0.6073553562,
0.2669179738,
0.4900476038,
0.002228094,
0.2292907387,
0.1183725968,
-0.2995783985,
-0.4205467105,
-0.7119567394,
0.7061633468,
-0.7045129538,
-0.850189209,
-0.4369922876,
-0.2969819605,
-0.0295705907,
-0.0349992886,
0.3264920115,
-0.2025245726,
-0.2621491551,
0.3213659227,
0.6338173151,
-0.577255547,
0.2549337149,
0.31111449,
-0.0459608622,
0.0262478106,
1.1294496059,
-0.1246727183,
0.4964893162,
0.4808633327,
0.5139279366,
0.2480943501,
0.1583267599,
-0.0790715516,
0.3074502647,
-0.5948451757,
-0.3325025737,
-0.9900057912,
-0.1759740263,
-0.2735833526,
-0.1144067794,
-0.5022414923,
-0.5835821629,
-0.0623409674,
0.034292873,
0.5944960117,
0.5270391703,
0.0091711096,
0.7401900291,
-0.9415441751,
0.3730678856,
0.425219357,
-0.0561496541,
0.1188954785,
-0.3666334152,
-0.1821189821,
0.3707816601,
-0.7719720006,
-1.2149670124,
0.3739552796,
0.0087546194,
0.6880159974,
0.6935510039,
-0.1143269539,
0.5554026365,
-0.3557502329,
0.7267647982,
0.2105306536,
-0.3492715359,
0.7027654052,
-0.07142061,
0.2744035721,
0.5893371105,
0.4168606997,
-0.8356814384,
-0.5897530913,
-1.1475262642,
-0.5203648806,
0.7596857548,
0.2630979419,
0.5208632946,
-0.301971972,
0.2051277906,
0.3229317665,
0.211676389,
-0.3972301483,
-0.5276117325,
-0.1066808924,
0.2356398404,
-0.0981965214,
-0.6060162783,
-0.2866310775,
0.0653014481,
0.3067499697,
0.1891563386,
0.5961634517,
-0.1960570365,
-0.0681886747,
-0.1056590527,
-0.0204474926,
0.300989449,
0.2421261072,
-0.1780145317,
-0.0132511752,
0.2319768816,
-0.2840032876,
-0.2924460173,
-0.5470004678,
-0.0318683498,
-0.0786399469,
0.2589594722,
0.5980141163,
0.3884776831,
-0.7375308275,
0.6710059643,
-0.0281372275,
0.1820507348,
-0.4037488103,
0.378202945,
0.1596871763,
0.2268429548,
0.1581351012,
0.517847538,
-0.099349156,
-0.9466574192,
0.1443261653,
0.2801944613,
-0.3567308187,
-0.5559755564,
0.5390466452,
0.1288571805,
-0.3625750542,
0.7956003547,
0.1565919518,
-0.4759083986,
0.3900809288,
1.0230125189,
0.8109775782,
-0.2304907441,
0.1702558696,
0.6121679544,
0.1004023999,
-0.0198420826,
0.1279362589,
-0.1265006661,
-0.9448020458,
0.3046504259,
-0.2055408508,
-0.0870481282,
0.0176988598,
-0.2001382411,
0.1132661998,
-0.5612297654,
-0.4254925251,
-0.370852828,
-0.5303148031,
-0.7456256747,
0.0837979764,
-0.1281784028,
0.6007431149,
-0.9630323648,
0.6720279455,
0.0498629436,
-0.464091301,
-0.2759044468,
0.1576953828,
0.2493473291,
-1.1193937063,
0.6169820428,
0.202472508,
-0.0863023028,
-0.4809679091,
-0.5596336722,
-0.940328598,
0.9623393416,
0.1210655048,
-0.5973480344,
-0.0430296771,
0.3596436083,
0.2556038499,
-0.3653042316,
0.1815406978,
0.4927991033,
0.2688661218,
0.2500369251,
-0.7751773596,
0.0286068898,
0.0477278158,
-0.0092495997,
0.0558769256,
-1.0325410366,
0.9385714531,
-0.4087551236,
-0.4728771448,
-0.0806160569,
0.4721957445,
0.2355880588,
0.1474194825,
0.5390567183,
0.330629915,
0.9705476165,
0.1508087069,
1.0379283428,
-0.3614967465,
-0.002116061,
1.5126901865,
0.0529624708,
0.7079492807,
0.677198112,
0.1661848426,
0.3772128224,
0.2618538439,
-0.0295272227,
0.4253090024,
0.1159737259,
0.0898234025,
-0.1513118744,
0.2190288901,
-0.5499951243,
0.5568708181,
0.6003476977,
-0.6408292651,
-0.2546921372,
0.013114322,
0.2159382403,
-0.0497922823,
0.3689648807,
0.9175246954,
-0.0908442214,
-0.4393178225,
0.0784360617,
-0.2626501918,
0.5551409125,
-0.305942744,
-0.2034864575,
-0.1427192986,
0.1141101345,
-0.0429401509,
-0.8078577518,
0.334844172,
-0.3524294794,
-0.1857450902,
-0.0977057889,
0.8580123782,
-0.1135806367,
-0.2796930373,
0.1649622917,
0.6588815451,
0.4001846015,
-0.2683454156,
-0.6507389545,
-0.0451959074,
0.1581842005,
0.1123947725,
0.3989215493,
0.5012618303,
-0.2331894487,
0.8478626609,
0.5891181827,
-0.1026125848,
0.1727482378,
-0.1911120564,
0.9488241076,
-1.042262435,
-0.3642956018,
-0.8692752123,
0.2901557088,
-0.2527528703,
-0.3499687314,
0.9501635432,
0.7974569201,
1.0285648108,
-0.1659026295,
0.9412993193,
-0.0347216167,
0.708448112,
-0.265610069,
0.7704592943,
-0.2162840664,
0.2734790444,
-0.0431250706,
-0.7311207652,
0.3074626625,
0.3978179693,
-0.3033089936,
0.0969001576,
0.6223688722,
0.7754561305,
0.1752496362,
0.2227332741,
0.3392954767,
0.5370337963,
0.2558024824,
0.6376338005,
1.0622217655,
-0.3065637648,
0.5072127581,
-0.4920377135,
-0.0828322768,
-0.607245028,
-0.4803308845,
-0.8721770048,
-0.7222867012,
-0.297773242,
-0.4341726601,
0.1599063128,
0.5593044758,
0.5660318136,
-0.5605111718,
-0.0247946326,
0.1229510605,
0.2587683797,
0.1203124225,
-0.2877961099,
-0.095034942,
-0.2853733599,
-0.5496032834,
0.3200727701,
0.4866858721,
0.467599839,
-0.1550084203,
0.1296016127,
-0.2005241066,
0.2152469456,
0.3903967738,
0.6288642287,
-0.5594822764,
-0.5952805877,
-0.3205213249,
0.0322323479,
0.501372695,
0.7292333841,
-1.3361686468,
0.7213664055,
0.6176392436,
0.201963678,
0.3265825808,
0.1659686863,
0.8424660563,
-0.5494835377,
0.3586800694,
0.3072894216,
0.1927783787,
0.1840877533,
-0.442263484,
0.0786897615,
0.1983896345,
-0.3507821858,
-0.4489626884,
0.2726740837,
-0.9169172049,
-0.5242778659,
0.9344580173,
0.1010470688,
-0.4268591702,
-0.18644014,
-0.5718808174,
0.1024202183,
-0.634822011,
1.1955928802,
0.6148218513,
-0.3721635342,
0.2393576801,
-0.6057724357,
0.4195505679,
0.1511060894,
-0.5207219124,
-0.0240173414,
0.4344836473,
0.2477531582,
0.3981949687,
0.7701098323,
-0.0679132789,
0.3801723719,
0.3961548507,
-0.4553720653,
0.2920728922,
-0.4973877966,
-0.0211403742,
0.1155058295,
-0.2232402563,
-0.4003531635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02868v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02868v1 | Can Large Language Models Play Text Games Well? Current State-of-the-Art and Open Questions | 2023-04-06T05:01:28 | 2023-04-06T05:01:28 | Chen Feng Tsai, Xiaochen Zhou, Sierra S. Liu, Jing Li, Mo Yu, Hongyuan Mei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 have recently
demonstrated their remarkable abilities of communicating with human users. In
this technical report, we take an initiative to investigate their capacities of
playing text games, in which a player has to understand the environment and
respond to situations by having dialogues with the game world. Our experiments
show that ChatGPT performs competitively compared to all the existing systems
but still exhibits a low level of intelligence. Precisely, ChatGPT can not
construct the world model by playing the game or even reading the game manual;
it may fail to leverage the world knowledge that it already has; it cannot
infer the goal of each step as the game progresses. Our results open up new
research questions at the intersection of artificial intelligence, machine
learning, and natural language processing. | [
-0.2767302096,
-0.9663360119,
0.7603738308,
0.1835334748,
-0.0357352868,
0.1100879088,
-0.5593343377,
-0.876731813,
-0.3017229438,
0.6320159435,
-0.5957040787,
-0.3101250529,
-0.6941332221,
0.0652387887,
-0.4167556763,
0.933808744,
0.1578039825,
-0.0418898016,
-0.1813560575,
0.0234142784,
-0.4799227715,
-0.8403893113,
-0.8017867804,
-0.6604288816,
0.2348626554,
0.2875258923,
0.8621561527,
0.2121436447,
0.8512057662,
0.4129091501,
-0.2432144433,
-0.0972879082,
-0.8566016555,
0.3717830777,
0.0043826462,
-0.6386380196,
-0.271281302,
0.131844908,
0.4829204679,
0.3044795096,
-0.0088804262,
-0.200130865,
0.2082493007,
0.3772460222,
0.1335816979,
0.4573092163,
-0.5964244008,
0.2165615708,
0.0080984673,
-0.0577972233,
-0.4385248423,
-0.0971150696,
0.4923373163,
-0.7972002625,
-0.0788530633,
0.1392295957,
0.7138063312,
0.3344979286,
-0.3497107327,
-0.7259629965,
-1.0853040218,
0.6227366924,
-0.7988442779,
0.0061725453,
0.3999049067,
0.2266417742,
-0.5729898214,
-0.3616564274,
-0.6203408837,
-0.4006052315,
0.1499442309,
0.2088778764,
-0.3408551812,
0.2805584669,
0.6034374833,
0.2636543214,
-0.4140547216,
0.082501471,
-0.374710083,
0.0223676097,
0.6518114209,
0.1808028668,
0.5769541264,
-0.0114142727,
-0.3075898886,
0.2087204903,
-0.6265582442,
0.1549395621,
0.2235508114,
0.1454915106,
-0.2788216174,
0.7869651318,
0.2556285262,
0.5264413357,
-0.3215093911,
-0.2037873268,
-0.2437940985,
-0.1796027273,
-0.2016491741,
-0.1223959178,
1.0775835514,
0.4384305477,
0.6356475353,
-0.3244697154,
-0.3337074518,
0.0336166658,
0.0507675931,
-0.7986879349,
-0.35696733,
0.103419587,
-0.2819331288,
-0.1682047844,
-0.2734688818,
-0.7983247638,
-0.6949503422,
0.1295025498,
0.6477884054,
-0.6115006804,
-0.1944506168,
0.1236952096,
-0.2188439369,
0.3047497869,
0.2243208885,
-1.1713871956,
0.4841085076,
0.6448351145,
0.9128760695,
-0.2071254551,
-0.2190036476,
-0.0792216957,
-0.0026809822,
-0.3149883151,
0.8537383676,
-0.6049683094,
-0.7273430824,
-0.0877702758,
-0.2802276313,
0.0377499089,
-0.5275626183,
0.6100047231,
-0.6032123566,
0.2822155356,
-0.2467023283,
-0.7123884559,
0.1144328192,
0.5396819115,
-0.6673874259,
0.7478699684,
-0.3224405646,
-0.7245729566,
0.0054606651,
-0.7563567162,
-0.4738643467,
0.1831836402,
-0.0974560827,
-0.1617385,
0.2453216314,
0.0394504257,
0.2787572742,
-0.3430105746,
0.1097119004,
-0.1878434867,
-0.6339091659,
0.4629765153,
-0.5677107573,
0.439686954,
0.0485401042,
-0.3142893314,
-0.1845883429,
-0.2674056292,
0.0821673274,
0.30681476,
-0.6527767777,
-0.0690488368,
0.5796685815,
-0.1762072891,
0.3600022495,
0.1570874155,
-0.5037992597,
0.5245983601,
-0.4464829266,
0.8944826126,
0.4996265173,
-0.2461686134,
0.4807741642,
-0.4072127044,
0.5141192079,
-0.3274684548,
-0.2232871801,
-0.370916754,
-0.9113356471,
-0.6352918148,
-0.1101825088,
0.382833153,
0.8413395882,
-0.861051023,
0.15805085,
-0.3495609164,
-0.4351410866,
-0.110870935,
-0.2773772478,
0.1005965844,
0.1426775306,
0.0568905286,
-0.0003677052,
-0.4127562046,
-0.5436239243,
-0.3169248402,
-0.4109321535,
-0.0878068209,
0.8009895086,
0.5704182386,
-0.007936867,
0.8007397056,
-0.2702492177,
-0.0450813696,
-0.4921499193,
0.0777310729,
0.028781049,
0.1371128857,
0.2987723053,
-0.7122782469,
-0.3942464292,
0.0803958178,
-0.9603798389,
-0.0132581433,
-0.009556991,
0.1583227664,
-0.0624056123,
0.5054843426,
-0.9147706628,
0.2892062664,
0.9198700786,
-0.5197803974,
0.2844616771,
-0.5059968829,
0.3286908865,
-0.7632824779,
-0.0972377211,
-0.0440172069,
-0.2867029309,
-0.8019685149,
0.0726576895,
-0.2863889039,
-0.3105064929,
-0.1320413798,
0.6634296775,
-0.4097396135,
-0.2747713327,
-0.5380655527,
0.5391659141,
-0.324523598,
0.3395892084,
0.0910407379,
0.951790154,
0.4708244205,
-0.6786251664,
0.4913224876,
0.271122098,
-0.7073103786,
0.281785965,
-0.8622000813,
0.0297732446,
-0.0083074458,
0.3985137045,
-0.9590089917,
-0.3969911039,
-0.0187374745,
-0.621424973,
-0.1100228652,
-0.0838867351,
-0.6912297606,
-0.4416909516,
0.1613478363,
0.1302520037,
0.8526527882,
-0.1569491178,
0.394571811,
0.7599135041,
-0.2013097703,
-0.130709976,
-0.8110150099,
0.3062600493,
-0.2045361102,
-0.6949155927,
0.2073771656,
-0.1719557345,
-0.2663535178,
-0.1518490016,
0.203467384,
-0.1950916499,
0.156213969,
0.2490874082,
0.111704208,
-0.2717354894,
0.4707212448,
-0.490340203,
0.0371370129,
0.0939704254,
-0.1194765195,
0.6386807561,
-0.0473451205,
-0.2278859764,
-0.1312183291,
0.2274468094,
0.4506015182,
-0.2179900855,
0.5908278823,
0.1251213253,
-0.3598021269,
-0.0408961922,
-0.311963141,
0.0164341312,
-0.492631197,
0.5559204221,
-0.2456547469,
-1.3709361553,
0.7283889651,
-0.1956873536,
0.153945297,
0.3639043272,
0.7305136919,
-0.2347618192,
1.2052519321,
0.6299408078,
-0.0463799573,
0.2059385478,
0.0766406655,
0.2782651186,
-0.5188038349,
-0.1284816414,
-0.6078802347,
-0.4366135299,
-0.8197504282,
-0.470225364,
0.2798896134,
-0.0339880399,
-0.4836507738,
0.0764107406,
-0.2769581079,
0.9040682912,
0.4332033992,
-0.0469305217,
0.2991395891,
-0.1760617495,
-0.0463068746,
-0.0700098053,
-0.744712472,
-0.5524654984,
0.6580408812,
0.4528811574,
0.7245158553,
0.312042743,
0.5852387547,
0.1326233298,
0.1658060402,
-0.7942704558,
0.6221504807,
-0.0802465528,
-0.9417657852,
-0.6423637867,
-0.5260785222,
-0.9921312928,
0.131507054,
-0.5204962492,
-0.9567360282,
-0.4774196446,
-0.0282636564,
-0.5167041421,
0.49698627,
-0.8969812989,
0.8834767938,
-0.3130904734,
-0.1401348263,
0.0809304938,
-0.3339567482,
0.5106930733,
0.0215606745,
0.4079575539,
-0.2619566023,
-0.119566001,
0.7098139524,
-0.0016444469,
0.6695731878,
0.0531241074,
-0.3284452856,
0.49300614,
0.2422098964,
0.425894469,
-0.00154579,
-0.0030746816,
0.0435207076,
0.0564014316,
-0.2780523002,
-0.543403089,
0.7519208193,
-0.8346934319,
-0.609929502,
-0.5678416491,
-0.560129106,
-0.3634203374,
0.2676986456,
0.2714834511,
0.2107177526,
-0.6596202254,
0.1118367314,
0.7525017262,
-0.5055075884,
0.561390996,
0.2741468847,
-0.2953032255,
0.0333197378,
0.9342684746,
-0.0159394704,
0.2471980602,
0.2943872809,
0.1793786138,
-0.1415447295,
-0.5986592174,
-0.3648836315,
0.0935297906,
-0.4029311836,
0.0473022349,
-0.3802160919,
-0.3238030374,
0.1757087559,
0.1368272007,
-0.1355209798,
-0.0942232087,
-0.0518451817,
0.1628509164,
0.2125637084,
1.4900615215,
0.1440824568,
0.597314477,
-0.9419153929,
0.0720654055,
0.3839940429,
0.5922421813,
-0.0160786938,
-0.3720375597,
-0.1206298769,
0.2452355027,
-0.2319542021,
-0.8281193972,
0.2838229835,
0.1473653913,
0.4405448735,
0.0578743592,
-0.2028643191,
0.4049681723,
-0.9985440373,
1.0308293104,
-0.1021085531,
-0.8594385386,
0.1162393615,
-0.8787635565,
0.4998762906,
0.205962345,
0.2113611102,
-0.7280182242,
-0.265440464,
-0.5257461667,
-0.2771273255,
0.9389478564,
0.4420842528,
0.4207615256,
-0.0045198412,
0.2538985312,
-0.2015822083,
0.0622281469,
-0.8970016837,
0.0520119183,
0.1922395676,
-0.1640668958,
-0.3202985823,
-0.2295782119,
0.161737293,
0.1092386022,
0.3492683768,
0.1207455322,
0.621760726,
-0.1218409613,
0.1530365497,
-0.0071414523,
0.3020814955,
0.6417808533,
0.32168594,
0.0475781634,
0.0447170734,
0.2077807188,
-0.6702950001,
0.2209120095,
0.0091189072,
-0.1145105511,
-0.4369639754,
0.6259688735,
0.565292418,
0.5315786004,
-1.0946502686,
0.5567882061,
-0.461802572,
-0.4415192604,
-0.0792402774,
0.2925555408,
0.4619636834,
0.4390871525,
0.0829932019,
-0.1250700653,
-0.0448891893,
-0.7585968375,
0.1351625323,
0.6885968447,
-0.5364646316,
-0.2168094367,
0.594011724,
0.4384027123,
-0.5834180117,
0.7160408497,
-0.197282061,
-0.8280117512,
0.7154777646,
0.7510668635,
0.4414322078,
0.020134965,
0.1608858407,
0.16451177,
0.4458755255,
-0.4014998972,
0.1171940491,
0.3185527623,
-0.9116876125,
-0.6560773253,
-0.2666645944,
-0.535951674,
0.2287683934,
0.1113079116,
-0.0013315656,
-0.3771190047,
-0.3331513107,
-0.0721233115,
0.159658581,
-0.6461623311,
-0.0540151186,
0.4675319195,
0.7149538398,
-0.4962356985,
0.5232037306,
0.4844736457,
-0.2106727958,
-0.5733001828,
0.1349479407,
-0.1304912418,
-0.5496710539,
0.5546655655,
0.0761569738,
0.1123601943,
0.0644841418,
-0.8173936009,
-0.842425108,
0.8831349015,
0.2770562768,
-0.41006428,
-0.3446685374,
0.1996917874,
0.7341173887,
-0.1560274661,
0.495544076,
0.5075645447,
0.4069519043,
0.165335238,
-1.1362851858,
-0.4599089921,
-0.1814463884,
-0.2263536751,
0.1866160929,
-0.7056769133,
0.7932775021,
-0.3256517947,
-0.4153148532,
0.3058996201,
0.7241708636,
0.133942157,
-0.0087631289,
0.3384849131,
0.4406820834,
0.6468803883,
-0.4476749599,
1.0835660696,
-0.2513023317,
0.3305473924,
0.7833990455,
-0.5666888952,
0.875993669,
-0.0654180199,
-0.19907175,
0.2205289304,
0.5661605,
0.0968062878,
0.2534210086,
0.3541907966,
-0.2918879092,
-0.4819655418,
0.2318056524,
0.0833078399,
0.6860958934,
0.4610803723,
0.0453440659,
-0.2457271367,
-0.0096974615,
-0.0933435112,
0.0763304681,
-0.1945728958,
0.9291844368,
0.1148234084,
-0.8196006417,
0.188828662,
0.0800492018,
0.9463589191,
-0.5554170012,
-0.1700615585,
-0.0397642665,
0.1720798314,
0.1704528779,
-1.0023300648,
-0.0774333701,
0.3592452109,
0.0744599402,
0.0876825005,
0.6679804921,
-0.2524605095,
-0.3542023003,
0.1089031473,
0.6401597261,
0.2570589185,
-0.0092536788,
-0.6765841842,
0.1542426348,
-0.1067705378,
-0.1940194964,
0.3832171857,
0.8452217579,
0.1617882401,
0.917214632,
0.2569212615,
0.0193355232,
-0.0188573673,
-0.3540838361,
0.6045187712,
-0.7697365284,
-0.4616719484,
-1.0893290043,
0.0516690761,
-0.1745396554,
-0.3898379207,
0.7222734094,
0.5652682185,
0.5255101323,
0.2268743217,
1.083319068,
0.0354325473,
0.4075776041,
-0.4773315489,
0.7134806514,
-0.1073616222,
0.1812935024,
-0.1941405684,
-0.7469964623,
-0.2102531195,
0.6981229782,
-0.4126114845,
0.3568634987,
0.5035608411,
0.3511352241,
-0.0426479466,
0.3465585411,
0.5485710502,
0.3385363519,
0.6416073442,
0.9889699221,
1.0675452948,
-0.2696817219,
0.6871395111,
0.3647082746,
-0.2879135311,
0.012472502,
-0.7421187162,
-1.4200263023,
-0.4691833556,
0.2469313443,
-0.1547837257,
0.2780713737,
0.8061136603,
0.4154772162,
-0.3446483016,
-0.2936969399,
0.034803763,
0.0092776902,
0.2376200855,
-0.1253021806,
0.191903308,
-0.2051197737,
-0.9126957655,
0.3094016016,
0.1808977425,
0.2828907371,
-0.3908936977,
-0.0883850902,
0.0088156052,
0.4399716854,
0.7497307062,
0.4343723655,
-0.5002082586,
-0.2847894132,
0.2147061825,
-0.2810047269,
0.0002905991,
0.8027259111,
-0.7556264997,
0.1438852996,
0.5097003579,
0.7030115724,
0.2776389718,
-0.0834237859,
0.6565792561,
-0.2681005597,
0.0693506375,
0.3662188649,
0.1436649263,
0.2773022652,
-0.1550059915,
0.3907224834,
-0.0185874179,
-0.9714107513,
-0.4221330881,
0.256733954,
-0.67836833,
-0.1457142085,
1.3744996786,
-0.0555627011,
-0.2868175507,
-0.0558945909,
-0.3905914724,
-0.0161035378,
-0.3557071388,
0.6217188835,
1.3629297018,
-0.1483517885,
-0.026169803,
-1.0676627159,
0.8064880371,
-0.024923645,
-0.83737427,
0.2876533568,
0.4567045867,
-0.101411745,
-0.0193654168,
0.8720229864,
0.0610483959,
0.087692976,
0.0140033048,
-0.1609408706,
0.2105398327,
-0.0267864149,
-0.1992671341,
-0.0186302327,
0.2105087191,
0.3036476672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02822v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02822v1 | Approach Intelligent Writing Assistants Usability with Seven Stages of Action | 2023-04-06T02:11:55 | 2023-04-06T02:11:55 | Avinash Bhat, Disha Shrivastava, Jin L. C. Guo | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs) as writing assistants,
they are plagued by issues like coherence and fluency of the model output,
trustworthiness, ownership of the generated content, and predictability of
model performance, thereby limiting their usability. In this position paper, we
propose to adopt Norman's seven stages of action as a framework to approach the
interaction design of intelligent writing assistants. We illustrate the
framework's applicability to writing tasks by providing an example of software
tutorial authoring. The paper also discusses the framework as a tool to
synthesize research on the interaction design of LLM-based tools and presents
examples of tools that support the stages of action. Finally, we briefly
outline the potential of a framework for human-LLM interaction research. | [
-0.2623721659,
-0.4328917563,
0.8045976758,
0.39719522,
0.1570991576,
0.0840694308,
0.1591613293,
-0.6085061431,
0.1113044992,
0.6197267175,
-0.7433182001,
-0.4664371312,
-0.4422941506,
0.5633722544,
-0.807851851,
0.5310907364,
-0.1367137581,
0.0239458606,
-0.254009217,
0.0347000435,
-0.5353418589,
-0.1853930056,
-0.9727217555,
-0.2258958668,
0.5755922794,
0.5918946862,
0.5507499576,
0.4562691748,
0.8120509386,
0.4476235211,
0.1636195928,
-0.0366352722,
-0.2627210319,
0.2082672566,
-0.0906732082,
-0.3213008046,
-0.6267157197,
0.0425163284,
0.6820763946,
0.7525205612,
-0.0398606695,
-0.1488084793,
0.3072775304,
0.3647222519,
-0.1182239875,
0.0765829161,
-0.0736493617,
0.1154715866,
0.1749628931,
-0.097830601,
-0.5025705099,
-0.1586721539,
-0.0004362685,
-0.9417005181,
0.1011036113,
0.3568105698,
0.2370766848,
0.0029279692,
-0.335539937,
-0.7725024223,
-1.0164839029,
0.6091059446,
-1.1206663847,
0.1325142086,
0.3883119822,
0.0348129049,
-0.6985220909,
-0.6373036504,
-1.0368453264,
-0.3561347425,
-0.1106043607,
-0.1554951519,
0.2057648599,
0.3680965304,
0.4438261092,
0.2506686151,
-0.3328972161,
0.1400438994,
-0.4781713784,
-0.0579889305,
0.8085949421,
0.3384383619,
0.7246228456,
0.049060408,
-0.3141349852,
0.0615095906,
-0.5644145012,
0.0477090441,
0.5432356596,
0.2361388355,
-0.0572409257,
0.7358503342,
-0.2154136449,
0.7718366385,
-0.009471057,
-0.3744240105,
-0.3351830244,
-0.2799987793,
-0.1735187769,
0.0042164866,
0.7462203503,
0.1882339418,
0.3376426697,
-0.3003578484,
-0.2669687867,
-0.1107653603,
0.6317535639,
-0.502061367,
0.0394457243,
0.4790961444,
-0.1995484978,
-0.514449656,
0.2166465521,
-0.3987192214,
-0.7680615187,
-0.4968620539,
0.5583305359,
-0.3290014565,
-0.2607287467,
-0.1045180485,
-0.0256750304,
0.3699043095,
0.4866830111,
-0.9108558893,
0.8182449937,
0.7613374591,
0.5947374701,
-0.5022316575,
-0.6952239275,
-0.4655069411,
0.3350628316,
-0.425655514,
0.8496027589,
-0.6524294615,
-0.7157976627,
0.1225896105,
-0.0393444262,
-0.2434951365,
-0.3827745616,
0.0936332345,
-0.2860330939,
0.0545258485,
0.0223233681,
-0.6237626672,
-0.2336332947,
0.3253556788,
-0.7540189028,
0.80012393,
0.0560065769,
-0.1815978289,
0.1718055904,
-1.0413998365,
-0.5807242393,
-0.1345450729,
-0.337986052,
-0.005054662,
0.0784182772,
-0.1303377599,
0.7368201613,
-0.2364307344,
0.4090833366,
-0.2364039421,
-0.5769754648,
0.3949637413,
-0.1582067907,
0.7480487823,
-0.0673970804,
-0.3318552375,
0.4259234071,
-1.288215518,
-0.3120337427,
-0.1771133691,
-0.563072145,
-0.0743932202,
0.0691063628,
-0.0692418143,
0.1543636918,
0.0061891582,
-0.552390337,
0.2296737731,
-0.2843754888,
0.2413783073,
0.6269167662,
0.0815977305,
0.7287079096,
-0.3136530519,
0.7783894539,
-0.0417299122,
0.2337685674,
-0.1612167358,
-0.3949765563,
-0.9072012901,
0.0572967306,
0.0618439764,
0.4390620291,
-0.609803915,
0.3842025399,
0.1231763437,
-0.3270678818,
-0.2450282872,
0.6327828765,
0.6449840665,
0.5541289449,
0.1912011355,
-0.4205101728,
-0.3399975002,
-0.6552947164,
-0.1349717528,
-0.2363481373,
0.1443335861,
-0.2473614514,
0.4443627596,
-0.0007992444,
0.7550191879,
-0.1266034096,
-0.2475330085,
-0.4685508609,
0.3098753691,
-0.1840051264,
0.7655306458,
0.3765248358,
-0.8739848137,
-0.3493720293,
-0.1858852208,
-0.8691848516,
-0.1032841504,
-0.2173187733,
-0.341445297,
0.2043213546,
0.942687273,
-0.4507178068,
0.7482010126,
0.335382849,
-0.4466454685,
0.2466842234,
-0.0381465703,
0.1907455921,
-1.3751865625,
0.0817146525,
0.0428332388,
-0.0632909909,
-0.9584941864,
-0.0390563644,
-0.2253956348,
-0.3674353957,
-0.4487339556,
0.7822742462,
-0.6361449361,
-0.1862041354,
-0.2815794349,
0.2100677341,
0.0817172751,
0.4460031688,
-0.035768494,
0.5421718955,
-0.0279570911,
-0.7012227774,
0.1466842592,
0.2650253177,
-0.1163996756,
0.7713068724,
-0.7978512049,
-0.0840459093,
0.1226442084,
-0.081841439,
-1.2679879665,
-0.3579142988,
0.3401530683,
-0.4265303314,
0.209831506,
0.1946607977,
-0.4424007833,
-0.2470904589,
-0.3105962276,
-0.1836500168,
0.0961149186,
-0.1632071733,
1.0838147402,
0.2137735039,
-0.4263164401,
-0.4129018784,
-0.4432276189,
0.1225531623,
-0.1538710594,
-0.6071522236,
0.2534785867,
-0.5098412037,
-0.4794172049,
-0.073175326,
0.2648746073,
0.0138465511,
0.2981966734,
0.6432883739,
0.2171788216,
-0.0609018654,
-0.1864843965,
0.1840026379,
-0.1966460943,
0.100591369,
0.3198668361,
0.2813650072,
0.2659081221,
-0.4586491287,
-0.8128635287,
0.6441767812,
0.7279852033,
0.0838407725,
0.3943109512,
0.403632015,
-0.5223399401,
-0.0532862581,
-0.5250279307,
-0.0193465073,
-0.4757349193,
0.0837114304,
-0.3282398283,
-0.5121524334,
0.5920206308,
-0.086125508,
0.5522840023,
0.2630344629,
0.448664695,
-0.1376202554,
1.1151260138,
1.1379646063,
0.1987353563,
0.6949740648,
-0.2735789418,
0.404084295,
-1.1343467236,
-0.2611068189,
-0.3999317288,
-0.4105245471,
0.0208520349,
-0.0613689758,
0.142179504,
0.1964289248,
-0.1675244123,
0.3712663949,
-0.3039427102,
0.2672560215,
0.6219778657,
-0.3773413897,
0.4841469824,
-0.131567508,
-0.2512510419,
0.3611011207,
-0.6512774229,
-0.8592000008,
0.6578730941,
0.1871864051,
0.8703529835,
0.2825442553,
0.9008523822,
0.4174430668,
0.5419625044,
-0.6399361491,
0.8558989763,
0.1854441166,
-0.437343955,
-0.7303464413,
0.2548132539,
-0.8156731129,
0.1791310608,
-0.4647994637,
-0.8725996017,
0.4486224949,
0.3573846519,
-0.6278400421,
-0.1001676172,
-1.0186910629,
0.8413932323,
0.0198982209,
-0.5265753269,
0.0376583748,
-0.7047963738,
0.2763989568,
0.3304373026,
0.330978483,
-0.1813617349,
0.0461538136,
0.8793800473,
-0.456086129,
1.3215858936,
0.0563074946,
-0.2457771152,
0.3006978929,
0.2915585637,
0.3975817859,
-0.1421160698,
-0.2551907003,
-0.6402848363,
0.1151346788,
-0.1373535097,
-0.7070589662,
0.7464244962,
-0.6364247203,
-0.586848259,
-0.5370180011,
-0.8254122734,
-0.4503363371,
0.3911163807,
-0.2155897766,
0.8218055367,
-0.4326661825,
-0.0635875911,
0.4527230263,
0.2687955797,
0.8706972003,
0.5783401728,
-0.3590420187,
-0.2631268799,
1.040263176,
0.0496334061,
0.3160124719,
0.1596247256,
0.0479812771,
-0.0510732383,
-0.746871531,
-0.5093813539,
0.0786496401,
-0.6942778826,
0.0645713061,
-0.6538911462,
0.0034737152,
-0.7878548503,
-0.5839293599,
0.1380018145,
-0.4280041158,
-0.5886391997,
0.0585164279,
0.2669418454,
1.4109467268,
0.0691993833,
0.6086091995,
-0.7494098544,
0.3480829,
0.1283999681,
0.1009799615,
0.3671188056,
-0.2389668077,
-0.2557246983,
-0.3927960992,
-0.4165209234,
-0.6157423854,
0.2280088216,
-0.081473276,
0.5999578238,
0.4607197046,
-0.1274843216,
0.4505265653,
-0.4011954963,
0.7548325062,
0.1799665987,
-0.7584826946,
0.3934601843,
-0.2374788821,
0.2133106291,
0.5240007639,
0.5628260374,
-0.4104587138,
-0.5041223764,
-0.6457118988,
-0.7854024768,
0.5831398368,
-0.0031334101,
-0.044421073,
0.158411622,
0.4563019574,
0.0344856419,
0.3701612651,
-0.5799375772,
0.3752404749,
0.2407016456,
-0.471185565,
-0.0603798553,
-0.3810348809,
-0.255979389,
0.0212089624,
0.6817042828,
-0.2571488917,
0.0137879616,
0.2270641178,
-0.3045550585,
0.0756522715,
0.1550722271,
0.9458084702,
1.0593191385,
0.1494483799,
0.0710021779,
-0.1245102286,
-0.6174042821,
0.1316632628,
0.0145888114,
-0.1560822576,
-0.6030591726,
0.7788416147,
0.3857642412,
0.4131325781,
-0.5537191033,
0.2794089317,
-0.0712528974,
-0.0478593335,
-0.5045885444,
0.6293855309,
0.2638800144,
0.3842658401,
0.1998549998,
-0.3356332779,
0.3949620128,
-0.8597468734,
-0.1534000486,
0.0493199825,
-0.5813179016,
-0.2552019358,
0.382540226,
0.7075399756,
-0.8641499281,
0.3665394783,
-0.1856734157,
-0.1914513707,
0.8264372945,
0.7820143104,
0.7086465359,
-0.2096680105,
0.2173797637,
-0.0364863016,
0.1529960036,
-0.0958084464,
0.5842952132,
0.0904270113,
-0.4749012887,
-0.1984446496,
-0.5757095814,
-0.658736527,
-0.2484128922,
-0.6064702272,
0.2045677006,
-0.6193900108,
0.1301888376,
0.0736357868,
0.0091995271,
-0.4503617287,
0.4383803308,
-0.2863605917,
0.8632013798,
-0.6981768012,
0.428824544,
0.8380470276,
-0.5345045328,
-0.8229134679,
-0.0953318998,
0.2967471182,
-0.7741196752,
0.2138896435,
-0.055779431,
-0.3683435023,
0.3357118368,
-0.5703998208,
-0.5328174829,
1.4017429352,
-0.0697037801,
-0.5157122612,
-0.2155377269,
0.1681794226,
0.4419485927,
-0.819031477,
-0.0716221556,
0.4977814555,
0.3610031903,
0.1011982933,
-0.6264504194,
0.1193067506,
-0.3601756096,
0.3663542867,
-0.1736488193,
-0.5068988204,
0.5889591575,
-0.3315392435,
0.0482179187,
0.5188655853,
0.8490658402,
0.0421026386,
0.3074018955,
0.5149403214,
0.2830704749,
0.6873785257,
0.2931988239,
1.1683260202,
-0.4443954825,
-0.1154337674,
0.9794089794,
-0.3975453377,
0.944863379,
0.6425247788,
-0.0125173433,
0.5395586491,
0.3460405767,
0.3132574856,
0.0197986513,
0.3290397823,
-0.5111415386,
0.0105163893,
-0.1959826201,
0.1088726372,
0.1491441131,
0.3555910885,
-0.2015925795,
0.0486779772,
0.2863993645,
0.2696003616,
0.2964456975,
-0.3102763593,
0.9308590293,
0.2068278342,
-0.6900845766,
-0.176580891,
-0.1155008152,
0.3624494672,
-0.6818700433,
-0.5889302492,
-0.1023342386,
0.0737109482,
-0.2534816861,
-0.9314014316,
0.1513243467,
-0.0997284353,
-0.3719702661,
-0.1486203372,
0.8822717071,
-0.3361860514,
-0.9395987988,
0.1149801165,
0.3612096608,
0.2238255739,
0.3647545576,
-0.567830205,
0.5740523338,
-0.4062142372,
-0.4293982685,
0.4223410487,
0.4127238989,
-0.1320687681,
0.7370045781,
0.548465848,
-0.0633619353,
-0.003979071,
0.1827899814,
0.663816452,
-0.7832372785,
-0.2931563854,
-0.623480022,
0.6170474291,
-0.1753092706,
-0.495082438,
0.5096436143,
0.2470030934,
0.619160831,
0.1137939021,
0.9817442298,
-0.2783719301,
0.5152446032,
-0.6287136078,
0.6560630798,
-0.4174970686,
0.17917867,
-0.3616443574,
-0.7320920825,
-0.41018641,
0.6950743794,
-0.158022061,
0.2346547544,
0.7561299205,
0.9839155078,
-0.0110279005,
0.0173944384,
0.528216958,
0.2054535747,
0.5231677294,
0.1333684921,
0.6068352461,
-0.2151281089,
0.2702529132,
-0.4025251865,
-0.1583840698,
-0.2695026398,
-1.061557889,
-1.1338777542,
-0.7639638186,
-0.0471303351,
-0.4776394069,
0.0949508697,
1.0286127329,
0.3781197667,
-0.5803852677,
-0.568523407,
-0.1026863754,
0.3107878864,
-0.0486390479,
-0.1920783818,
0.0848922506,
-0.2079014778,
-0.9207059145,
0.4010420442,
0.4111393988,
0.3259577453,
-0.7973040938,
-0.0196640361,
-0.4606880844,
0.2218488157,
0.7839862108,
0.6081735492,
-0.6095870733,
-0.3648314774,
0.0503327623,
-0.0890660509,
-0.1813208163,
1.1278710365,
-0.5107497573,
0.2955233753,
0.419503957,
0.4419317245,
-0.0927038342,
-0.0671965107,
1.0726593733,
-0.14663212,
-0.185572207,
0.0114553971,
0.2311341017,
0.4484059215,
-0.5587469339,
0.572203815,
0.0878577605,
-0.4583337307,
-0.8579615951,
0.0273341201,
-1.1868963242,
0.0747617558,
1.0899394751,
-0.2214931995,
-0.2897296846,
-0.3307638466,
-0.4991609752,
0.0622715987,
-0.1996221989,
0.6449171901,
0.9973805547,
-0.7918439507,
0.0015267896,
-0.6723578572,
0.4987367988,
-0.0040342943,
-1.1197942495,
-0.0621664375,
0.4385970533,
0.2905031741,
0.3290773332,
1.1161630154,
-0.0330446549,
0.2667222321,
0.0771594271,
0.1820916682,
-0.141606614,
-0.8146899343,
-0.1234807149,
-0.0436572544,
0.5720576048,
0.2905828953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02819v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02819v3 | GPT detectors are biased against non-native English writers | 2023-04-06T01:51:15 | 2023-07-10T18:48:45 | Weixin Liang, Mert Yuksekgonul, Yining Mao, Eric Wu, James Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | The rapid adoption of generative language models has brought about
substantial advancements in digital communication, while simultaneously raising
concerns regarding the potential misuse of AI-generated content. Although
numerous detection methods have been proposed to differentiate between AI and
human-generated content, the fairness and robustness of these detectors remain
underexplored. In this study, we evaluate the performance of several
widely-used GPT detectors using writing samples from native and non-native
English writers. Our findings reveal that these detectors consistently
misclassify non-native English writing samples as AI-generated, whereas native
writing samples are accurately identified. Furthermore, we demonstrate that
simple prompting strategies can not only mitigate this bias but also
effectively bypass GPT detectors, suggesting that GPT detectors may
unintentionally penalize writers with constrained linguistic expressions. Our
results call for a broader conversation about the ethical implications of
deploying ChatGPT content detectors and caution against their use in evaluative
or educational settings, particularly when they may inadvertently penalize or
exclude non-native English speakers from the global discourse. The published
version of this study can be accessed at:
www.cell.com/patterns/fulltext/S2666-3899(23)00130-7 | [
-0.2944081724,
-0.5714395046,
0.5652151108,
-0.196114108,
-0.012504044,
0.132289052,
-0.3016626835,
-0.4955825806,
-0.1682478189,
0.0458350368,
-0.3026051521,
-0.3687818646,
-0.8849248886,
0.5364937782,
-0.3485375047,
1.1314640045,
-0.0060802768,
-0.1509921104,
-0.2632529438,
0.1818481237,
-0.5512990355,
-0.5220584273,
-0.8896920085,
-0.1581130773,
0.3224358261,
0.1842353344,
0.5732318759,
0.2301790267,
0.2126916349,
0.2555492818,
0.0892315432,
0.1972048432,
-0.3336442709,
0.0242033415,
-0.1158719659,
-0.4007600546,
-0.1774068028,
0.2560976148,
0.4405412078,
0.1633207798,
0.0306233782,
-0.0102268057,
0.2244698405,
0.3410172164,
-0.8424766064,
0.061511308,
-0.7653822303,
0.1990395188,
-0.3736492991,
-0.3737685084,
-0.8817309737,
-0.269834578,
-0.1229982525,
-0.6068249345,
0.5631652474,
-0.203234151,
0.6727859974,
0.2363163978,
-0.2971681058,
-0.6410959363,
-0.7426660657,
0.8779246211,
-0.5334721208,
-0.0752800032,
0.7600341439,
0.1402081996,
-0.0917176828,
-0.5938615203,
-0.7129810452,
-0.4356479049,
-0.3049967885,
0.3859758675,
-0.5895117521,
0.1265896857,
0.4068778753,
0.2652688026,
-1.0149260759,
0.1477262378,
-0.2676749229,
-0.6260173321,
0.6542505026,
-0.1559620053,
0.6206057668,
-0.2314517498,
-0.023084145,
0.1623973101,
-0.6469506621,
-0.023933433,
0.9603754878,
0.2473953068,
-0.212580964,
0.426407665,
0.1868366748,
0.4721774757,
-0.1035392433,
-0.1587976217,
-0.0423233062,
-0.1597041637,
0.1756679416,
-0.0283614825,
1.0610529184,
0.4807269871,
0.7480872869,
-0.2168741077,
-0.2186448872,
0.6070466638,
0.0703903958,
-0.6569911838,
-0.4705814421,
-0.0543234982,
-0.3193751276,
-0.3406252861,
0.1198926419,
-0.5282222629,
-0.34863922,
0.2264161706,
0.4114073515,
-0.2510149777,
-0.3133887053,
0.1056778952,
-0.4073881805,
0.3257381618,
0.0053415257,
-1.0274933577,
0.1423753798,
0.5898913145,
0.7204728723,
-0.0889236256,
-0.2264602184,
-0.5944328904,
-0.0350022502,
-0.0565657131,
0.9629179239,
-0.4804943502,
-0.7877953053,
0.0589322262,
-0.0798161849,
-0.0864127353,
-0.3350587487,
0.8928427696,
-0.2766281962,
0.7485907078,
-0.3329901695,
-0.4211367667,
0.1570585519,
0.1388205886,
-0.6223562956,
0.793749392,
-0.0644605085,
-0.9158354998,
0.7337673306,
-0.4173614681,
-0.8145270944,
0.2699687183,
-0.4005770087,
-0.5590196848,
-0.1501711011,
0.6018257737,
0.304590106,
0.0266944002,
0.327275306,
0.2059111744,
-0.7752143145,
0.1129274443,
-1.1705886126,
0.646171689,
0.2276815772,
-0.5942752957,
-0.3108875155,
-0.351978004,
-0.1108328179,
0.2626776397,
-0.440349102,
0.0419747122,
0.1457327604,
0.0974572524,
-0.0018207431,
-0.1684239954,
-0.7029336691,
0.001227909,
-0.019481387,
0.5258230567,
0.9414417744,
-0.0374991111,
0.2357157767,
-0.6161563993,
0.8357702494,
-0.3668592274,
0.0351810567,
-0.2669970393,
-0.9441140294,
-0.1877828687,
-0.3457616866,
0.0310678519,
0.6402798295,
-0.9303853512,
0.289086163,
-0.2242090404,
-0.1958732605,
-0.7089980245,
-0.1256916523,
0.4961616099,
0.5952633619,
0.3567891121,
-0.0813666284,
-0.3272359967,
-0.7288620472,
-0.7257573605,
-0.3930376172,
-0.3243994415,
0.2920764983,
0.3371708095,
0.2077037543,
0.9012778401,
-0.1349642277,
-0.2064595073,
-0.3565250337,
0.3016154468,
-0.0560648143,
0.3492874503,
0.4485619962,
-0.6773486137,
-0.8241422176,
-0.2449917048,
-0.7963601351,
-0.4213009179,
-0.3870337009,
0.3397231102,
0.3482068181,
0.3893221617,
-0.7596046925,
0.6212952733,
0.5128085017,
-0.340585351,
0.623449862,
-0.0126057016,
0.2336381227,
-0.8106825948,
0.0989199579,
0.0545413159,
-0.3560725152,
-0.4995235205,
-0.0764475614,
-0.0448893718,
-0.0685926378,
-0.4912667572,
0.5025701523,
-0.4609779119,
0.3085869253,
-0.4556955993,
0.1367602199,
0.2469153553,
0.2239921242,
0.1531109363,
1.2287755013,
0.3597702086,
-0.3482316434,
0.0408565775,
0.1815036833,
-0.3331559598,
0.8628091812,
-0.7275823951,
0.5083554387,
-0.4252915382,
0.4600313902,
-0.8121889234,
0.0042139506,
0.4323851168,
-0.9621626735,
0.2044893652,
-0.6031116247,
-0.4065617323,
-0.3834429383,
-0.4608059227,
0.2271827459,
0.8116128445,
-0.467820704,
0.3385783732,
0.2509467304,
-0.0549219102,
-0.6866276264,
-0.9856805801,
0.2287730277,
-0.1894090474,
-0.6340207458,
0.1948556006,
0.1160232276,
-0.1740034074,
0.0435762629,
0.1640850753,
0.2483700812,
0.0718582198,
0.0462175906,
0.1648070365,
-0.2188264132,
-0.0048436299,
-0.0678957701,
-0.2390407324,
0.1178072169,
-0.3981493711,
0.5709158182,
0.2230758667,
-0.6951550841,
-0.6333155632,
0.6675615907,
0.2637777627,
-0.2059187144,
0.5781193376,
0.9293551445,
-0.3853568137,
-0.1593806744,
-0.586958468,
-0.2142656147,
-0.5462595224,
0.130934149,
-0.1562795937,
-0.837618649,
0.197098732,
0.734484911,
-0.0909148306,
0.2749588788,
0.6014101505,
0.0108418865,
1.0803261995,
0.2978951633,
-0.3114182353,
0.2971561253,
0.0886543617,
0.6797751784,
-0.6892614365,
0.0731237903,
-0.6142292619,
-0.2676459849,
-0.8473501801,
-0.186641112,
0.2021753788,
-0.3420810103,
0.0865480676,
0.0656471997,
-0.9287678003,
0.9661304951,
0.6216576099,
-0.0928461999,
0.4861330986,
-0.0917063728,
0.1863021553,
-0.0739144608,
-0.4664089978,
-0.9052397013,
1.3918819427,
0.1135541722,
0.8172174096,
0.040538881,
0.5840275884,
0.7107447386,
0.3951396644,
-0.7578006983,
0.4631615877,
-0.2414563149,
-0.6179244518,
0.0309944153,
-0.3758668602,
-1.2140734196,
0.1316974014,
0.0786426589,
-0.8456499577,
0.0267587621,
0.1389617026,
-0.2182170451,
0.6177814603,
-1.1334290504,
0.6693181992,
0.0942897946,
-0.2180083394,
0.1119899675,
-0.2546970844,
0.0926850811,
0.2453411818,
0.1027604565,
-0.1342729777,
0.3386441171,
0.547219336,
-0.1284912825,
0.955493927,
-0.4775226414,
0.0084616765,
0.7172603011,
0.1187321842,
0.5559073091,
0.2630839348,
0.1854975969,
0.082963571,
-0.2667095363,
-0.5516838431,
-0.0415609665,
0.5123720169,
-0.6554198861,
-0.7542117834,
-0.56164217,
-0.5638452172,
-0.0023613914,
0.0636128411,
0.9828691483,
0.1696563214,
-0.2200151682,
-0.2470515519,
0.3907656968,
-0.2635009587,
0.5247697234,
0.4681264758,
0.21961312,
0.1345820278,
1.0748076439,
-0.0749972612,
0.3528771996,
0.2403826118,
0.1905241609,
-0.2657671869,
-0.7423836589,
-0.5197324157,
-0.0412489064,
-0.6158776879,
-0.0613699406,
-0.6111701727,
-0.14537628,
-0.6084432602,
-0.4353707731,
0.0588896051,
-0.1205219328,
-0.124004133,
-0.2394028604,
0.1672986895,
0.6371495724,
-0.1015937254,
0.2137056589,
-0.485897243,
0.1989133805,
0.335524857,
0.0670800656,
-0.1503885388,
-0.4635572731,
0.2001006603,
0.0552081615,
-0.3248244226,
-0.6771714091,
0.2090687454,
0.1414355189,
0.5796691179,
0.15757671,
0.0503389835,
0.2127433866,
-0.4342581928,
1.0238261223,
-0.3139602542,
-0.9648217559,
0.5886508226,
-0.5456854701,
0.3033967614,
0.4126554132,
0.3825361729,
-0.9144781232,
-0.7972607017,
-0.3814451993,
-0.7011640072,
0.4470855594,
0.28574875,
0.5357348323,
-0.342553854,
0.0451625288,
0.2216770798,
0.0626251549,
-1.1528501511,
0.1308579743,
-0.1755356789,
-0.2586537898,
0.1965314597,
-0.0700451061,
-0.0161121152,
0.168099165,
0.4965949059,
-0.2277502716,
0.6221331358,
0.5152484179,
-0.3804253638,
0.0389493108,
0.2851168811,
0.3937108517,
0.3060513437,
0.2164634019,
0.0465196557,
-0.2470466495,
-0.9044360518,
0.0994255319,
0.1947510093,
-0.6742788553,
0.0537710935,
0.686407268,
0.5491045117,
-0.4990712404,
-0.5504637361,
0.8168061972,
-0.3080507517,
-0.2244267911,
-0.3474907577,
-0.0744958892,
-0.2874735594,
-0.2502467632,
0.1983266324,
0.0956603512,
0.2003144026,
-0.328587383,
0.1560726762,
0.8226121664,
-0.1876639575,
-0.379799068,
0.7805527449,
0.2499979734,
-0.2965845466,
0.8130349517,
-0.686281383,
-0.5900525451,
0.5548711419,
0.6272544265,
0.9970676303,
-0.1118328646,
0.5468994975,
0.1365397573,
0.7689427137,
0.1839885861,
0.2741845548,
-0.1773338467,
-1.1287413836,
-0.5651375651,
-0.1709088385,
-0.3966646791,
0.1696103662,
-0.5611850619,
0.1229709387,
-0.4245792627,
-0.1896280795,
-0.0533775501,
-0.2718906999,
-0.6810315251,
-0.1219446287,
0.5518370867,
0.6131739616,
-0.9853811264,
0.4937749803,
0.4861741364,
-0.358215332,
-0.7431078553,
0.3844219446,
0.4366818666,
-1.0746256113,
0.0790956095,
0.3958939016,
-0.2809367776,
-0.0498875901,
-0.4345248342,
-0.2156213075,
0.8740473986,
0.246918425,
-0.0533600412,
0.0194552522,
0.4902912378,
0.4957863688,
0.1940191239,
0.5248970389,
0.5395288467,
0.4958708882,
-0.2046642303,
-0.9010021091,
0.0326692909,
-0.3992089927,
-0.2694816291,
0.2313828021,
-0.4800160825,
0.7023351192,
-0.0650003627,
-0.6376711726,
0.0174960848,
0.1414981633,
-0.0290890615,
0.331163615,
0.2079692632,
0.4903354049,
0.8512243032,
-0.342348963,
1.2340350151,
0.0440646447,
0.0686656609,
0.6349487305,
-0.3358766437,
0.3498921394,
0.37226367,
-0.3177027702,
0.3547665179,
0.2683915198,
-0.2640109062,
0.3799357414,
0.1498954147,
-0.7617102265,
0.1824310124,
-0.3662148714,
-0.2921562195,
0.3155419827,
0.304248333,
-0.101625964,
-0.0328526124,
0.0327104628,
0.50453794,
0.2814549804,
-0.2871899903,
0.6243873239,
0.0021591869,
-0.9536381364,
0.4535126984,
0.0664671287,
1.2675743103,
-0.4438290596,
0.207732141,
-0.3911985457,
-0.0278642904,
-0.3521823883,
-1.0330438614,
0.3071412146,
0.4290441573,
0.0639470518,
-0.2674823403,
1.0181516409,
-0.1870405674,
-0.2302922755,
0.1441063434,
0.5370172262,
0.0180599373,
-0.2011907697,
-0.3175516725,
-0.1813574731,
-0.0071686227,
-0.0870198309,
0.1486073136,
0.1870525032,
-0.0958795771,
0.4776067138,
0.8969786763,
0.1590149105,
0.0782006904,
0.2196123749,
0.4294305146,
-0.2388992012,
-0.5514165759,
-1.0330498219,
0.5879460573,
-0.0481431261,
-0.3611628115,
0.7472902536,
0.4809985459,
1.2725559473,
-0.0512244329,
1.2412179708,
-0.0764376596,
0.3032569289,
-0.6150645614,
0.8148542643,
-0.0068184873,
0.2130579948,
-0.3154246211,
-0.7390719652,
-0.2097163647,
0.6151238084,
-0.521609664,
0.3353426754,
0.668746829,
0.7789251804,
0.1524394751,
0.2956914306,
0.3235218227,
-0.2910858095,
0.7306650281,
0.817370832,
1.0335700512,
-0.2476779819,
0.7093088627,
-0.107755892,
-0.2256622016,
0.3511965871,
-0.9364341497,
-1.0279426575,
-0.2327365875,
-0.2090617716,
-0.2312249839,
0.0853108466,
0.5667926669,
0.5442582369,
-0.7672229409,
0.1540155411,
-0.1353517175,
0.034156438,
0.0822494924,
-0.2705719471,
0.2852185071,
-0.1381891519,
-1.0567486286,
0.3034517169,
0.143720746,
0.1585048884,
-0.1848691851,
0.0719910339,
0.1644729525,
0.0028565833,
0.3412179649,
0.4751482606,
-0.4553385377,
-0.4187317789,
-0.0025572022,
-0.1216013655,
0.0927586406,
0.844648242,
-0.8608521223,
0.2703169882,
0.3864011467,
0.6453282237,
0.1852095574,
-0.1314159185,
0.5939750671,
-1.0134681463,
0.3513730466,
0.6653046608,
0.3263173997,
0.5911787748,
-0.6888535619,
0.296544075,
0.4957907796,
-0.8399832845,
-0.706500113,
0.440640837,
-0.401491791,
0.0135906655,
0.9485583901,
-0.1513993293,
0.1577067822,
-0.3306537867,
-0.2285249084,
-0.0555348992,
-0.5327264071,
0.7792506218,
0.9173796177,
0.0170329493,
-0.0542811342,
-0.739962399,
0.608353138,
0.5078474879,
-0.7728793025,
-0.2566672862,
0.3734437823,
0.2276761234,
-0.0305881761,
1.044598937,
-0.2686608434,
0.4347527325,
0.0705761462,
-0.0022830493,
0.0598016009,
0.0464264452,
-0.2504790425,
-0.2124311775,
0.2018040121,
-0.2995703518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02812v1 | Pragmatically Appropriate Diversity for Dialogue Evaluation | 2023-04-06T01:24:18 | 2023-04-06T01:24:18 | Katherine Stasaski, Marti A. Hearst | cs.CL | cs.CL | Linguistic pragmatics state that a conversation's underlying speech acts can
constrain the type of response which is appropriate at each turn in the
conversation. When generating dialogue responses, neural dialogue agents
struggle to produce diverse responses. Currently, dialogue diversity is
assessed using automatic metrics, but the underlying speech acts do not inform
these metrics.
To remedy this, we propose the notion of Pragmatically Appropriate Diversity,
defined as the extent to which a conversation creates and constrains the
creation of multiple diverse responses. Using a human-created multi-response
dataset, we find significant support for the hypothesis that speech acts
provide a signal for the diversity of the set of next responses. Building on
this result, we propose a new human evaluation task where creative writers
predict the extent to which conversations inspire the creation of multiple
diverse responses. Our studies find that writers' judgments align with the
Pragmatically Appropriate Diversity of conversations. Our work suggests that
expectations for diversity metric scores should vary depending on the speech
act. | [
-0.6386443377,
-0.4927890003,
0.1506072283,
0.6159434319,
-0.2483201027,
0.5242249966,
-0.4584557712,
-0.4061968625,
0.3774323761,
0.0831841454,
-0.6818379164,
-0.2604998946,
-0.486441493,
0.2361568063,
-0.1810439378,
1.1771382093,
0.4355579317,
0.0865855664,
0.0118676089,
-0.5264786482,
-0.7265560031,
-0.2405286431,
-0.230659768,
0.0580226332,
0.7747258544,
0.4685851336,
0.8239917159,
0.2418617457,
0.5072644353,
0.42629987,
-0.1359031051,
0.2639037967,
-0.7264185548,
0.3576490581,
-0.3199144304,
-0.3522088826,
-0.0799590498,
-0.0351017192,
0.6923328042,
0.6642899513,
-0.377089709,
0.0905136093,
0.0125831719,
0.3192528188,
-0.4524315,
-0.3722703159,
-0.586140871,
0.1674470603,
-0.0803232118,
-0.099504292,
-0.1671105027,
-0.641708076,
0.4300209582,
-0.4850353003,
0.2819197178,
-0.109085843,
0.4393380582,
-0.2756723166,
-0.328774482,
-0.4692165256,
-0.8357608914,
0.8112424016,
-0.5558915734,
-0.0631157234,
-0.0364696458,
0.4358005822,
-0.0655779392,
-0.6779507995,
-0.7966011167,
-0.2024543881,
-0.0733693615,
0.3421030045,
-0.0394291468,
0.1176181883,
0.1642001867,
0.5155894756,
-0.5346915722,
0.0358622521,
-0.3145583868,
-0.2112689763,
0.7746428251,
0.5851296186,
0.4681649506,
-0.0419589318,
0.0488726944,
-0.0353229828,
-0.0334040597,
0.2151784152,
0.9368290901,
0.3905217946,
0.1847676933,
0.4720969498,
-0.2313070297,
0.8627960682,
-0.1696094871,
-0.202256754,
0.3057205081,
-0.9233798981,
0.1549604386,
-0.1404972821,
0.7041548491,
0.6828486323,
0.3566698134,
-0.0231219772,
-0.0479523093,
0.2389951646,
0.5915492773,
-0.6130783558,
-0.1047254875,
0.0390236452,
-0.3164436817,
-0.1593248546,
0.1789361984,
-0.9370748997,
-0.6054829955,
-0.2188464254,
0.0355286673,
-0.1553226113,
-0.3808740079,
0.0054507339,
-0.7475625277,
0.0143043594,
0.3332082331,
-0.6838012934,
0.17127496,
0.45244506,
0.5053371787,
-0.2625639737,
-0.4434644878,
-0.2193086296,
-0.2161017656,
-0.0799370185,
0.8556445241,
-0.6694741845,
-0.8091124296,
-0.1417614371,
-0.2865062952,
-0.1649985611,
-0.5481593013,
0.8697888255,
-0.0628896132,
0.3116760254,
-0.3475270569,
-0.2073600888,
-0.0479390845,
0.0868855417,
-0.5505849123,
0.3107116222,
0.2349842638,
-0.8352931738,
0.6212399006,
-0.6365127563,
-0.5637090206,
0.4473237693,
-0.2432543486,
-0.3364595473,
0.1242188737,
-0.0310092662,
-0.2135607004,
-0.0802420005,
0.4821157157,
-0.3373337984,
-0.4613798857,
0.8112190962,
-0.432938695,
0.6872872114,
0.4094661176,
-0.1952419579,
0.3671455681,
-0.722517252,
0.3733575344,
-0.0871730968,
-0.3801662326,
0.0154819116,
0.0798653886,
-0.1550596505,
0.1436294168,
-0.1880245507,
-0.5458075404,
-0.273255825,
-0.6595231295,
0.2244475633,
0.7402518988,
0.1997838169,
0.5158156157,
-0.8632807136,
0.7404437661,
-0.1407734752,
-0.0493074581,
-0.0995092243,
-0.9221852422,
-0.4071081579,
-0.4913165569,
-0.0716992766,
0.5963924527,
-0.3422459364,
0.5435875654,
-0.070837386,
-0.8219850063,
-0.6492675543,
0.2121194154,
0.2486451864,
0.3185894191,
-0.1915002018,
-0.7394111156,
-0.7490953803,
-0.9104927182,
-0.769353807,
-0.3088102639,
-0.1372524947,
0.5063399673,
0.1748002768,
0.2322614789,
1.2208371162,
-0.3435903192,
0.1047860235,
-0.4343597889,
0.5106735229,
0.3192184865,
0.3540167511,
0.3662593365,
-0.7680491209,
-0.4137847126,
-0.1472297907,
-0.3454450369,
-0.3158852756,
-0.2360381782,
-0.1388765126,
-0.4783916175,
-0.3659591675,
-0.724049747,
0.4469475448,
0.3961178362,
-0.3630637825,
0.6165887117,
0.179706946,
0.2302473187,
-0.8217520714,
-0.1064743623,
-0.2063987404,
0.0917933807,
-0.7472718358,
-0.2711173594,
-0.5404415727,
-0.2547221482,
-0.3990297616,
0.4592097104,
-0.1626406014,
-0.0272431299,
-0.136203751,
0.1998660415,
0.2384157479,
0.1466320157,
0.1345966309,
0.5575305223,
0.3939689994,
-0.5822138786,
0.6123641133,
0.3627170026,
-0.6551861167,
0.8746861219,
-0.5147688389,
0.2057387233,
-0.4071866572,
0.3977541625,
-1.2435638905,
-0.2502982616,
0.2586601675,
-0.6377179027,
-0.1427607387,
0.3900779486,
-0.1374594718,
-0.4805881679,
-0.1426551491,
0.4592699409,
0.3316215873,
-0.2825847566,
0.4643925428,
0.4205211699,
-0.54100281,
-0.7113976479,
-0.6583581567,
0.1095874012,
-0.3905365467,
-0.908423841,
0.1858761013,
-0.4735684991,
-0.5158099532,
-0.2763414383,
-0.0317757763,
-0.1112814471,
0.1916867644,
0.2105940729,
-0.0772477165,
-0.1408445984,
0.0427001938,
-0.2401198596,
0.5311032534,
-0.1023804694,
-0.1919125468,
0.3535039127,
-0.1949622333,
-0.3844385147,
-0.2561980784,
0.574630022,
0.1707738936,
-0.2259333879,
0.3875880539,
0.9095794559,
0.1248114258,
-0.2497315258,
-0.3889716864,
-0.1302344501,
-0.4923473001,
0.4632879496,
-0.1104016006,
-1.0331265926,
0.5417420268,
0.5215927958,
0.3416179419,
0.2018577307,
0.88677001,
-0.1845812201,
0.9485052824,
0.1353084743,
0.7358330488,
0.6603352427,
0.2874520719,
0.555705905,
-0.4573637545,
-0.3370973766,
-0.7400735021,
-0.7589000463,
-0.6501880288,
-0.2542548478,
-0.2538112402,
-0.2769952118,
0.0785010979,
0.166244477,
-0.819157362,
0.3936108053,
0.4987340868,
-0.1761524379,
0.1053654552,
-0.043427866,
-0.0583709888,
-0.2828423679,
-0.6747874022,
-0.3400208652,
0.7873998284,
0.2399874032,
0.6564048529,
0.3790919781,
0.7922232151,
0.2110711932,
0.6431854963,
-0.8690738082,
0.6198589206,
0.0885426104,
-0.7341046333,
-0.37568748,
-0.5646879077,
-1.1710078716,
0.4629339874,
-0.1160865501,
-0.8113555908,
0.3552679121,
-0.3215711415,
-0.5404276848,
-0.167541787,
-0.8930764198,
0.6786919832,
-0.3772486448,
-0.0504627302,
-0.1692222506,
-0.6377390623,
0.3098293245,
-0.0413614549,
0.1980465204,
-0.3518997431,
0.1179891229,
0.9776557684,
-0.0123692947,
0.8313828111,
-0.2034985274,
0.1219334304,
0.955935955,
0.074311085,
-0.0593283139,
0.3003571033,
-0.0392113514,
-0.1006868184,
-0.3392792344,
-0.2658521831,
-0.6791704893,
0.4584980607,
-0.7641254663,
-0.8334746361,
-0.3230489194,
-0.9612368941,
-0.3221644759,
0.0509630367,
0.1469272971,
0.0879034325,
-0.5173225999,
0.247714147,
0.1706337631,
-0.3289014101,
0.4598633051,
0.472946316,
0.0477458015,
-0.6694675684,
0.965895772,
0.1695427001,
0.222518757,
-0.0537710004,
0.2742203474,
-0.4658969343,
-0.6856498122,
-0.1609775424,
-0.046852883,
-0.8054807186,
0.0560883023,
-0.6316508651,
0.1078335643,
-0.3021425307,
-0.1759950966,
0.2568390667,
-0.6672676802,
-0.3353638947,
-0.3151753843,
-0.0920894966,
0.5278734565,
0.0451920964,
0.3920457959,
-0.7866661549,
0.2668327987,
0.6359746456,
0.340103358,
-0.2240445167,
-0.7210562229,
0.0881856754,
0.1204071045,
-0.6478053927,
-0.9466530681,
0.3189600408,
0.6055619717,
1.1359812021,
0.2053420097,
-0.1576144993,
0.5623088479,
-0.1953398883,
0.9455567598,
0.5415502787,
-0.665415585,
0.6390978694,
-0.4242905378,
0.4965184629,
0.6440424323,
0.1493698061,
-0.4306963384,
-0.8509501815,
-0.7168416381,
-0.762912035,
0.6214664578,
0.5429421663,
0.682113409,
-0.3671547174,
-0.2251726091,
0.182448104,
0.5988624096,
-0.6394302845,
0.2239665687,
-0.5713188052,
-0.1344603598,
0.1167813614,
-0.0091951406,
-0.724945426,
-0.09620101,
0.0251271632,
-0.2344602495,
0.3645487428,
0.0087182065,
0.020292975,
-0.1176826581,
0.5425837636,
0.7045403123,
1.1062749624,
-0.0152818803,
-0.0738318339,
0.1508410424,
-0.4598279297,
0.2305687815,
0.0062622,
0.2126986384,
0.2319460809,
0.2176311612,
0.8597581387,
-0.107101649,
-0.9310631752,
0.4366075099,
-0.4589124918,
-0.0899019092,
-0.039458964,
0.490701288,
0.0812807232,
0.0975546837,
0.2214979529,
0.3898111284,
0.211981073,
-0.6530947089,
0.4736256003,
0.4372618496,
-0.1008848622,
-0.1297914535,
0.1351050287,
0.6394475102,
-0.8966465592,
0.7985043526,
-0.3172580898,
-0.4287309051,
0.8404643536,
0.650898993,
1.1019144058,
-0.3043528795,
0.4629564285,
0.4770801663,
0.2347956747,
0.2851935029,
0.4912153184,
-0.1138388738,
-0.9947658181,
-0.3216024935,
-0.8383995295,
-0.4245668352,
-0.3025510013,
-0.4907160997,
0.1198362783,
-0.6693838835,
-0.5890645981,
0.0194651112,
-0.2951728702,
-0.5462306142,
0.3837864399,
0.2824487388,
0.6520841122,
-0.675147295,
0.3501163423,
0.6532822847,
-0.301833123,
-0.6218811274,
0.0257327873,
-0.0571288019,
-0.7266312838,
0.4417249262,
0.2399458736,
-0.0748152882,
-0.302757144,
-0.1096694097,
-0.5014708042,
0.7865637541,
0.244424805,
-0.3898075223,
0.1455202997,
0.0614751726,
0.7944982052,
-0.7590537667,
0.5964406133,
0.5374138355,
0.564214766,
0.3592860699,
-0.9404398799,
-0.2121728212,
-0.5214226842,
0.1862394363,
-0.0368469171,
-0.4469032288,
0.6665638089,
-0.4167785645,
-0.382378459,
0.1963545829,
0.7177073359,
0.5269662142,
0.4590095878,
0.6631278992,
0.3144234121,
0.965474844,
-0.2277984768,
1.0287021399,
-0.1274818182,
-0.0274839066,
0.9456519485,
-0.1614046842,
0.2693583667,
0.2922890484,
-0.251627773,
0.509013474,
0.5592167974,
-0.2630895972,
0.2551619112,
0.6132995486,
-0.5898616314,
-0.0069057196,
-0.4626191556,
-0.0600206405,
0.7191290855,
0.4865871072,
-0.3209465742,
0.0293524936,
-0.2665216327,
-0.4929150343,
0.2964894474,
-0.0635864884,
0.8134532571,
0.0199849233,
-1.2471214533,
0.3625051677,
-0.1546084732,
0.5439857244,
-0.6401457787,
0.1511562169,
-0.2115265876,
-0.3402141929,
-0.4118319154,
-1.3848289251,
0.5209857821,
-0.0975440368,
-0.027233975,
-0.0816298425,
0.7528865933,
-0.5661367178,
-0.3143161535,
0.0478401631,
0.4082420468,
-0.0246921293,
0.361746937,
-0.7339929938,
-0.0171330627,
0.1327566206,
-0.0805916935,
0.3189480305,
0.331741184,
0.0825852975,
0.419031024,
0.799819231,
0.1950214952,
0.1476998627,
0.4452116787,
0.5167644024,
-0.4434632957,
-0.9921424985,
-0.6222289801,
0.9598463774,
-0.4059534669,
-0.7032265067,
0.6705494523,
0.1690404266,
0.4060784876,
0.0807825103,
0.8906457424,
-0.1825395226,
0.4014779329,
-0.0128933592,
0.2871005237,
-0.1609861553,
0.1376722306,
-0.4558942318,
-1.0792433023,
-0.0886219591,
0.7151794434,
-0.3202839494,
0.4168550372,
0.569223702,
0.9693409801,
0.2254941016,
0.6884051561,
0.2967874706,
-0.1387443393,
0.2443780154,
0.424430877,
1.5235310793,
0.3972685039,
0.811111033,
0.0473816358,
-0.3052177131,
-0.0092461193,
-0.7819390297,
-0.524677217,
-0.2683524787,
-0.234012574,
-0.4032951593,
-0.2029676139,
0.6679337025,
0.4083503783,
-0.6527561545,
-0.4946512282,
-0.0315201059,
0.2743885815,
-0.3211633265,
-0.2502790689,
-0.4820351899,
-0.3818633556,
-0.7019209862,
0.365300864,
0.3949600756,
-0.0525464118,
-0.1613683701,
-0.2675068676,
-0.0362354256,
0.2943573594,
0.3731683195,
0.261616379,
-0.5799157619,
-0.1773887277,
-0.2079446763,
-0.0657437146,
0.1066194028,
1.0431523323,
-0.3387925923,
0.868480742,
0.8013769984,
0.7958108187,
0.013276685,
0.2390195727,
0.8492199779,
-0.8910086751,
0.1140404269,
0.9439223409,
0.0925338641,
0.4936659038,
-0.2989570498,
0.1708371341,
0.4396217465,
-0.535391748,
-0.8218761086,
0.6199400425,
-0.9197490215,
-0.0913878828,
0.9840204716,
-0.2759642005,
0.0940426514,
-0.2406918854,
-0.4140979648,
0.0305809509,
-0.3915050626,
0.6563600898,
1.00238657,
-0.3886897862,
-0.239703998,
-0.1431942284,
0.3780885637,
0.7972408533,
-0.6526483893,
-0.1875833869,
0.5136475563,
0.1637069136,
0.3264543116,
0.6554392576,
0.0420240499,
0.6137063503,
0.1572843343,
-0.349958688,
0.3438567519,
-0.1925093979,
-0.1836667061,
0.3845190406,
0.3251790702,
-0.0088567091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02787v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02787v2 | Context-Aware Classification of Legal Document Pages | 2023-04-05T23:14:58 | 2023-04-25T14:59:24 | Pavlos Fragkogiannis, Martina Forster, Grace E. Lee, Dell Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2 | For many business applications that require the processing, indexing, and
retrieval of professional documents such as legal briefs (in PDF format etc.),
it is often essential to classify the pages of any given document into their
corresponding types beforehand. Most existing studies in the field of document
image classification either focus on single-page documents or treat multiple
pages in a document independently. Although in recent years a few techniques
have been proposed to exploit the context information from neighboring pages to
enhance document page classification, they typically cannot be utilized with
large pre-trained language models due to the constraint on input length. In
this paper, we present a simple but effective approach that overcomes the above
limitation. Specifically, we enhance the input with extra tokens carrying
sequential information about previous pages - introducing recurrence - which
enables the usage of pre-trained Transformer models like BERT for context-aware
page classification. Our experiments conducted on two legal datasets in English
and Portuguese respectively show that the proposed approach can significantly
improve the performance of document page classification compared to the
non-recurrent setup as well as the other context-aware baselines. | [
-0.5512989163,
-0.2934457064,
0.3524840772,
0.1351896375,
-0.4023343921,
-0.2576345205,
-0.163925007,
-0.5568143725,
0.0580236763,
0.8172829747,
-0.2370926291,
-0.4435521662,
-0.5890467167,
-0.0395860784,
-0.6206898689,
1.1124229431,
-0.0322673321,
0.2006343752,
-0.1857943684,
-0.6631228328,
-0.4504055977,
-0.5479884148,
-0.7830408216,
-0.2958753109,
0.5795459151,
0.13762559,
0.2820480466,
0.3354422152,
0.2430902869,
0.3371655941,
-0.0172730591,
0.038984932,
-0.1651904434,
0.2344439775,
-0.3685024381,
-0.4807151556,
-0.1375558227,
0.0035190789,
0.6674237251,
0.3537366092,
-0.0283471495,
-0.1503185481,
-0.0474510305,
0.6565836072,
-0.5605573654,
0.0734293461,
-0.4362168312,
0.2164263427,
-0.2244289517,
-0.6110761762,
-0.7323519588,
-0.338512212,
0.0257152338,
-0.5216308832,
0.5248951316,
-0.0420831703,
0.7214013338,
-0.0131153855,
-0.5468764901,
-0.4357568622,
-0.4863280058,
0.3574561477,
-0.3766916394,
0.8123843074,
0.2016747445,
0.3705295622,
-0.1801407933,
-1.0845048428,
-0.8988556266,
0.1317149252,
-0.2886877954,
0.1128543764,
-0.162779659,
0.0749957338,
0.3023962975,
-0.0544492938,
-0.4085847437,
0.2535737753,
-0.3473587036,
-0.3460045159,
0.3765896559,
-0.1764535159,
0.1976060271,
0.0119712176,
-0.065810129,
-0.2088848948,
-0.5698002577,
0.2165684253,
0.1159842983,
0.1866829246,
0.3193805516,
0.215091899,
0.2168097049,
0.8178997636,
0.3308010697,
-0.2185221612,
0.2986745238,
-0.0379159562,
-0.0972103849,
0.1958272755,
0.4769150615,
0.20044595,
-0.1670989543,
0.0733009428,
-0.4088792801,
-0.5080215931,
0.4799587131,
-1.0095295906,
0.0890860558,
0.1069289371,
-0.5769623518,
-0.133380115,
0.3204886615,
-0.7878803611,
-0.6513144374,
-0.2753380239,
0.110944815,
-0.4691019952,
0.1478112042,
-0.2581107318,
-0.1794918925,
0.527980566,
0.7690761089,
-0.668977797,
-0.0745794773,
0.7525877357,
0.7165616751,
0.1724383682,
-0.2235208601,
-0.8019585609,
0.1411331296,
-0.1594134122,
0.856998682,
-0.6459590197,
-0.6609535813,
0.4357416928,
0.1912745237,
-0.0098339105,
-0.3428308666,
0.7288816571,
-1.1057478189,
0.4047628343,
-0.0746903867,
-0.6043848991,
-0.3574380577,
0.4024988115,
-0.7951136231,
0.5683159232,
0.2450521588,
-0.9150477052,
0.8747474551,
-0.769772768,
-0.910330534,
0.2699730396,
-0.531440258,
-0.5137292147,
0.0646287352,
0.1376046389,
0.3666426539,
0.2140814662,
0.1432819515,
-0.0257443562,
-0.1355327219,
0.1886113733,
-0.546079874,
0.810123384,
0.3517914414,
-0.1290770471,
0.2056882232,
-0.8487055302,
-0.3096898496,
-0.110512428,
-0.7856042981,
-0.3199704289,
-0.173314631,
0.2017363906,
0.3030041754,
0.4490150511,
-0.4804270566,
0.2761204541,
-0.2117782533,
0.1207484007,
0.5190161467,
-0.0055420185,
0.5245469213,
-0.4335775077,
0.4177955687,
-0.121391736,
-0.1834162027,
-0.5145183206,
-0.4070427418,
-0.8181996942,
-0.3440669179,
0.4777202904,
0.6268886924,
-0.5616695881,
0.6940998435,
-0.6609716415,
-0.3951176405,
-0.1668783277,
0.2426834702,
0.2947478592,
0.6870782375,
0.327358216,
-0.4143285155,
-0.5606406331,
-0.632085681,
-0.0577427372,
0.0014275633,
-0.1669534296,
0.6183745861,
0.279556334,
-0.4453655183,
1.0554735661,
-0.2674176097,
-0.4018248022,
-0.2512051463,
0.6684515476,
0.2377228439,
0.4925513864,
0.6380300522,
-1.3314956427,
-0.626968205,
0.1738076061,
-0.3845284879,
-0.1011174172,
-0.3391822278,
0.2089479417,
0.6565916538,
0.5152258277,
-0.2748779356,
0.6094562411,
-0.1453397423,
-0.2530179024,
0.2906084955,
-0.6476042867,
0.162023142,
-0.7889649868,
0.0325165875,
0.1245052889,
-0.5506330729,
-0.6369302869,
-0.0404935069,
0.4465084672,
-0.2123553306,
-0.4694239199,
0.4737963676,
-0.2186124474,
-0.3497342467,
-0.6835976243,
-0.1814368665,
0.1061208025,
0.4179880619,
0.4723612666,
0.7527371049,
0.1929717064,
-0.5773684978,
0.0572060533,
0.2039349228,
-0.3087679148,
0.8909375072,
-0.0307935216,
0.1727580279,
-0.3216296136,
0.7569689751,
-0.8676880598,
-0.0385993272,
-0.0477537364,
-0.3329130411,
0.8467794061,
-0.2456621826,
-0.7597482204,
-0.5254796147,
-0.1792537272,
0.1570503712,
0.2999027967,
-0.8023455739,
0.9682777524,
0.2702247798,
-0.0800850689,
-0.5321637988,
-0.5489895344,
-0.0625855848,
-0.2078227252,
-0.5139231682,
0.6895632744,
0.2513847351,
0.2867183089,
0.0194100495,
-0.2442276031,
-0.4387980103,
-0.1030669659,
0.3619501293,
-0.1406127065,
0.013782966,
0.2246406078,
0.1715324819,
-0.1854855418,
-0.258928597,
-0.3570268154,
0.7585425377,
-0.2365180999,
-0.2292347103,
-0.495402962,
0.4918470383,
0.850959301,
-0.3338041306,
0.522585988,
0.7233090401,
-0.3724547625,
0.0191712026,
-0.7672954202,
0.2303076535,
-0.4957844317,
0.2898671925,
-0.4530792236,
-0.8538806438,
0.5298476219,
-0.1361317039,
0.2257967591,
0.5389985442,
0.3374808431,
-0.2939596474,
0.453214407,
0.9451135397,
-0.2375405878,
0.8981189728,
-0.1287141442,
0.1913074106,
-0.6871553659,
-0.2183877677,
-0.5560886264,
-0.1741498113,
-0.5847226381,
-0.3173644245,
0.2174087465,
0.1580118537,
-0.1690455973,
0.7423453927,
-0.5441863537,
0.5918790102,
0.6174662113,
0.1740780473,
-0.0258596353,
-0.0716489404,
-0.2035069317,
0.2062293589,
-0.5320479274,
-0.3908550441,
0.8930561543,
0.2142406702,
0.3787765205,
0.0488916747,
0.9803640246,
0.3868291974,
0.694075644,
-0.5810490847,
0.530072093,
-0.4907814562,
-0.3289181292,
-0.5506614447,
-0.0585848577,
-1.2686293125,
0.1778200716,
-0.1535045058,
-0.7631961107,
0.5497117639,
-0.0936946496,
-0.5643003583,
0.0768559873,
-0.3391871154,
0.8035113811,
-0.5921421647,
-0.2892107368,
-0.3144215643,
-0.5518556833,
-0.234717235,
-0.398599565,
0.282433629,
0.3470687568,
0.0247850418,
0.8701246977,
-0.7302172184,
0.6088844538,
-0.4067926407,
-0.1801555902,
0.3775835931,
-0.1652977467,
0.4801371098,
-0.0157818217,
0.0583723336,
0.0024803688,
0.0283218138,
-0.1197865531,
-0.7760130167,
0.5579940677,
-0.4097876251,
-0.6136351228,
-0.3521882296,
-0.3938178718,
-0.0857847333,
0.7811448574,
0.4431337118,
0.3825175464,
0.2072161734,
0.4107227623,
0.5752162933,
-0.152873069,
0.5501470566,
0.9734179974,
-0.1441569775,
-0.3608546555,
0.8537454605,
0.4162223041,
-0.6752375364,
0.6654301286,
0.2145421803,
-0.6090760827,
-0.6502079368,
0.0015566293,
-0.0911191255,
-1.0133646727,
-0.1963552535,
-0.6241056919,
-0.334628135,
-0.6237956882,
-0.4318256676,
-0.0502858534,
-0.2110175639,
-0.2515496314,
0.0921462998,
-0.0661550313,
0.4171423614,
0.0889371336,
0.3291192651,
-1.1050212383,
0.1370342821,
0.3708651066,
0.6112252474,
-0.1047392115,
-0.6897925735,
0.1090534478,
-0.5011972785,
-0.2778590322,
-0.9155465364,
0.3579830527,
0.0226353463,
0.9699051976,
0.7203271985,
0.0540420078,
0.4483245015,
-0.7815560102,
0.2963725626,
0.2766200602,
-0.6438750029,
0.7754459977,
-0.2012165189,
0.0483735986,
0.8415418267,
0.5838555694,
-0.3663020432,
0.1009903997,
-0.6552355886,
-0.9204457402,
0.642544806,
-0.0693432912,
0.2423701137,
0.0643096715,
0.4380318224,
0.1861628592,
0.1866342276,
-0.7349320054,
0.1717894375,
-0.3138497472,
-0.0905329362,
0.1632475257,
-0.3260438442,
0.0065351566,
-0.3133500814,
0.4429906011,
0.0659493431,
0.215375796,
0.1692748517,
-0.4580744207,
0.3903740942,
0.4102844,
0.8831182718,
0.6286356449,
-0.3064769208,
-0.0284534991,
0.1672595143,
-0.3016492426,
0.2259430885,
0.3284864426,
-0.0168315675,
0.2442876548,
0.303483963,
0.5334854722,
0.2522872388,
-0.3810261488,
0.707305491,
-0.1086023822,
-0.1142223999,
-0.7273578644,
-0.0135207316,
-0.3704036772,
0.3663475215,
0.3907032311,
-0.0479726344,
0.1497559994,
-0.432821393,
0.7797195911,
0.1420643479,
-0.2762954831,
0.3755732179,
0.1744155735,
0.5314441323,
-0.6737277508,
0.5404298306,
-0.4417819679,
-0.7047612667,
0.5876941085,
0.5410394073,
0.8151968718,
-0.0314368941,
-0.2020826936,
0.3059140742,
-0.1833305657,
-0.1244089901,
-0.2317822427,
-0.6421276927,
-0.9105619192,
0.121057637,
-0.6111769676,
-0.2368968278,
0.3240527809,
-0.6128774881,
0.2959886789,
-0.5868951678,
-0.1919755787,
0.1974832565,
-0.0676836371,
-0.8229171634,
0.0516470186,
0.2320213765,
1.1910791397,
-0.369957,
1.2811872959,
0.6410055757,
-0.5597503185,
-0.1385238171,
0.1551790237,
-0.2014161199,
-0.4654122591,
1.0534390211,
0.8214302063,
-0.1096423343,
-0.2466079295,
-0.1199314669,
-0.3669634759,
1.0076620579,
-0.2779552937,
-0.7707598805,
-0.0176885091,
0.039716728,
0.6057297587,
-0.4074878693,
0.0011104128,
0.4676530659,
0.4293508232,
0.2684653997,
-0.679127574,
-0.0412446149,
-0.3191587329,
0.1038917229,
0.1300608218,
-0.3103577197,
0.4350889027,
0.187441349,
-0.3396133184,
-0.0766917318,
0.7623744011,
0.1695192605,
0.5157943964,
0.7952895164,
0.5694900155,
1.0174322128,
-0.0533900633,
1.0542374849,
-0.6820331812,
0.2770159245,
1.3741208315,
-0.3453115225,
0.9117540717,
0.2944006026,
-0.172721833,
0.5791390538,
0.4326076508,
-0.4135168791,
0.5222263932,
0.2559782267,
-0.2578724921,
-0.1109222472,
0.110697709,
-0.2153206319,
0.4145361781,
0.5281130672,
-0.5165714622,
-0.4500388503,
0.2240895331,
-0.110544987,
0.1383767426,
-0.4357994199,
0.8474739194,
-0.2530768514,
-0.6997292638,
0.120121263,
0.306694895,
0.9327248931,
-0.389660567,
0.0740014389,
-0.2619771957,
0.1813340485,
-0.2400533408,
-1.0225429535,
0.3450095057,
0.1834923178,
-0.3459140956,
-0.3542599976,
0.9425680637,
-0.3635665774,
-0.3371787071,
0.1455570757,
-0.1522724777,
0.0709892213,
-0.0738608837,
-0.5282508135,
-0.3402132988,
-0.3135297298,
-0.0630034357,
0.3550464511,
0.483441025,
-0.2427949905,
0.5329107642,
0.5304572582,
-0.2826223671,
0.0742051154,
0.1726282388,
0.872494638,
-0.5601831079,
-0.9686165452,
-0.5987813473,
0.3427880108,
-0.3111047745,
-0.009534982,
0.2615332007,
0.6567876935,
0.8897833824,
0.0697784945,
0.7410470247,
-0.0117301801,
0.1955302507,
-0.4487612247,
0.9419862032,
-0.4433908165,
0.1361291707,
0.118526198,
-0.6880941987,
-0.4889799058,
0.7745167613,
-0.3539991379,
-0.0270565134,
0.464856416,
0.4013698101,
-0.0074342941,
-0.1693142802,
0.243892774,
-0.3394204378,
0.5771173835,
0.4114422798,
0.4222663939,
-0.061850179,
0.6220607162,
-0.2453026026,
-0.1522510946,
-0.5020395517,
-0.8557350039,
-0.8620670438,
-0.7462681532,
-0.170836255,
-0.4084373116,
-0.2310662121,
0.6707829833,
0.5711530447,
-0.8516001701,
0.1731310189,
-0.2684005201,
0.0364584662,
0.1515731514,
-0.2279102951,
0.4308615625,
-0.6383374929,
-0.5919115543,
0.115217723,
0.2987670898,
0.3233242631,
0.089923732,
-0.0948337242,
-0.1678652465,
0.0218749512,
0.6326211095,
0.7478803396,
-0.5655594468,
-0.3021663725,
-0.5680946112,
-0.2178635299,
0.3587872684,
1.1713050604,
-0.6414018273,
0.5146593451,
0.8027102351,
0.9833654761,
0.6661791205,
0.0422012135,
0.4182137251,
-0.9303489923,
0.2789545655,
0.1653609574,
0.9068878889,
0.1082278416,
-0.3678151667,
0.4826962352,
0.1665710956,
-0.2738099396,
-0.4775570035,
0.1339538693,
-1.0163055658,
-0.4955324829,
0.8469020128,
-0.5404649973,
-0.1133066639,
-0.0768550783,
-0.1885912418,
0.5028851628,
-0.3076533675,
0.7169514298,
0.7818042636,
-0.2962737083,
-0.3499962986,
-0.2734421194,
0.1842279583,
0.0699029118,
-0.7142492533,
-0.2624635398,
0.5031650066,
0.229694128,
0.8610187173,
0.7492157817,
-0.252030164,
0.4688218534,
-0.1642023921,
-0.1623325199,
-0.2504940927,
-0.504670918,
-0.5176275969,
0.3959477842,
-0.2262086421,
-0.2803047299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02785v1 | Performance of Data Augmentation Methods for Brazilian Portuguese Text Classification | 2023-04-05T23:13:37 | 2023-04-05T23:13:37 | Marcellus Amadeus, Paulo Branco | cs.CL | cs.CL | Improving machine learning performance while increasing model generalization
has been a constantly pursued goal by AI researchers. Data augmentation
techniques are often used towards achieving this target, and most of its
evaluation is made using English corpora. In this work, we took advantage of
different existing data augmentation methods to analyze their performances
applied to text classification problems using Brazilian Portuguese corpora. As
a result, our analysis shows some putative improvements in using some of these
techniques; however, it also suggests further exploitation of language bias and
non-English text data scarcity. | [
-0.2304929644,
-0.9278180599,
0.1169019714,
0.1975196749,
-0.2739296556,
0.2654946148,
-0.3726441562,
-0.9298785329,
-0.1461174935,
0.5212528706,
-0.1004984155,
-0.3825246394,
-0.6537824273,
0.4492251575,
-0.4254208505,
1.1036441326,
-0.0570339635,
0.2226727158,
-0.3909763992,
-0.2039553672,
-0.629376173,
-0.788664341,
-0.6307350397,
-0.0980313495,
0.2422730923,
0.3517430425,
0.8911447525,
0.711101234,
0.7171307206,
0.4081060588,
-0.0441564396,
0.4717349112,
-0.3044799566,
0.0504065566,
-0.0652425215,
-0.7424632311,
-0.1795414537,
0.0761979371,
0.8716672063,
0.6931456327,
0.1692067683,
-0.2292969823,
0.1944196075,
0.480476141,
-0.5132898092,
0.1973583251,
-0.3624434769,
0.0942169428,
-0.1666998565,
-0.5853949189,
-0.3950510323,
-0.544041276,
0.2941486239,
-0.623632133,
0.5972229242,
0.0880342573,
0.7992119789,
0.4068031311,
-0.2443958521,
-0.5434265733,
-0.8812345266,
0.8741471767,
-0.2704571187,
0.3543760478,
0.2378194034,
0.200818792,
0.0829645619,
-0.4370059073,
-0.2336505651,
-0.4662586153,
-0.2902213037,
-0.0600338429,
-0.3969759345,
0.0883563012,
0.4739267826,
0.5556052327,
-0.6838302612,
0.478939414,
-0.7773116827,
-0.3134817183,
0.8768901229,
-0.0147627136,
0.1830792874,
0.0946748778,
-0.2176144868,
-0.2983639836,
-0.4950859547,
-0.0586904958,
0.6619420052,
0.1967397779,
0.1221158355,
0.4101451337,
-0.0674240142,
1.0535116196,
-0.3517307639,
-0.1859387606,
0.5153867602,
-0.3587560952,
-0.2732289135,
0.0665068552,
0.4093112946,
0.1779917777,
0.2301879227,
-0.2713013291,
-0.2311504334,
0.3678351641,
0.3662136495,
-0.7310760617,
-0.0123993503,
0.2385515124,
-0.4092935622,
-0.4923053384,
0.0442799553,
-0.7236016989,
-0.1711276323,
-0.3890652359,
0.1330708861,
-0.6387999058,
0.0097477986,
-0.1413840055,
-0.3894027174,
0.0683841556,
0.3369866312,
-0.6535241008,
0.352367878,
0.7438809276,
0.782053113,
-0.3927267194,
-0.114534229,
-0.3887982965,
-0.1381342113,
-0.5198474526,
1.0364716053,
-0.8371391296,
-0.5888574719,
0.098417379,
-0.0242218804,
-0.1298022568,
-0.6127645373,
1.0695552826,
-0.4016564488,
0.8058235645,
-0.006267773,
-0.7180418968,
-0.4057269692,
0.0920452327,
-0.666392386,
1.2723567486,
0.2560747564,
-0.6728240252,
0.5930655003,
-0.8580892086,
-0.4684478641,
0.1665929705,
0.0005458498,
-0.4292710423,
0.1475896984,
0.3564318717,
0.6122442484,
-0.2345800102,
0.1846812963,
0.0658652559,
-0.706088841,
0.2761467099,
-0.5898412466,
0.5164414048,
0.3980905712,
-0.1169325411,
-0.0063361591,
-0.8596337438,
-0.1920364946,
-0.2055633813,
-0.4839269221,
-0.5704883933,
-0.0496257842,
0.3570668101,
-0.0688932464,
0.1721738428,
-0.3312468827,
0.3609166145,
-0.7378913164,
0.1876457185,
0.5127143264,
-0.2584171593,
0.5492647886,
-0.3997961879,
0.6566901803,
-0.026834026,
-0.1708789021,
-0.2748128176,
-0.5777292252,
-0.6141842604,
-0.4002033174,
0.8562675118,
0.7427605391,
-0.9260468483,
0.4415129125,
-0.3960098624,
-0.5699591041,
-0.6079405546,
0.0914333761,
0.379807204,
0.4945325553,
0.5033885837,
-0.3166907728,
-0.5952262878,
-0.934889555,
-0.0281336289,
-0.0319008231,
-0.2220567316,
0.2017343342,
0.22254695,
-0.415384382,
0.6437721848,
-0.3485018313,
-0.1141054705,
-0.1542372555,
0.281632185,
0.13070108,
0.5688948631,
0.8740001321,
-0.9472371936,
-0.1780148596,
0.1206579581,
-0.7002652884,
-0.2758938372,
-0.0763470605,
0.2229769826,
0.6556560993,
0.2469078302,
0.1809555292,
0.3311659992,
0.4480398297,
-0.1270042658,
0.2974709272,
-0.4420248568,
0.4759391844,
-0.7731484175,
-0.0542066433,
0.3469882011,
-0.1899197996,
-0.7205507755,
-0.0307089295,
0.1400518268,
-0.0266942568,
-0.2329590172,
0.2224280536,
-0.5297927856,
-0.0542827882,
-0.5597659945,
0.008467379,
-0.107165806,
0.1265930831,
0.3733707964,
0.8742283583,
0.7569308877,
-0.925506711,
0.4569768608,
0.0000252553,
-0.1225554347,
0.5555473566,
-0.6537905335,
0.0984500274,
-0.4500571191,
0.1687957793,
-1.165132761,
-0.0249539576,
0.1642228812,
-0.5819073319,
0.5959533453,
-0.1660197824,
-0.3208583593,
-0.425719738,
-0.4081126153,
-0.0284710582,
0.33082968,
-0.542278111,
0.2247560173,
0.3211964965,
0.0088052647,
-0.7484897971,
-0.7906959057,
0.0805154815,
-0.5820990801,
-0.6506534219,
0.6573286653,
-0.027836537,
-0.2210256159,
-0.0523485541,
0.330324322,
-0.2462995499,
0.172914654,
0.0357167982,
0.5975740552,
0.0574069023,
0.4190597832,
0.4028118551,
-0.0874324068,
-0.1792943478,
-0.2324763685,
0.5663299561,
0.0743111745,
0.2135177255,
-0.2967679501,
0.2577431202,
-0.0223531034,
-0.1108588576,
0.7264488935,
0.8302443027,
-0.2934851348,
-0.0401842967,
-0.6540948749,
0.0462177657,
-0.4339156151,
0.3273206949,
-0.4785045385,
-0.9582482576,
0.2857893705,
0.0327321701,
-0.1107125506,
0.4648641646,
0.3395023942,
0.0636698678,
0.836828053,
0.7990048528,
-0.3897943795,
0.626765132,
-0.3805730939,
-0.2436219156,
-0.4791181087,
-0.1358826309,
-1.0246441364,
-0.157515645,
-1.2730246782,
-0.4878015816,
0.1940704286,
-0.1885587275,
0.3695191741,
0.5317952633,
-1.0364613533,
0.3169618547,
0.5522179008,
0.0339344032,
0.380651176,
0.3567532599,
0.2881155312,
-0.1255331486,
-0.7673156857,
-0.6396592259,
1.3471187353,
0.3913607597,
0.3350798786,
-0.1695713699,
0.5882480741,
0.5517372489,
0.3671405315,
-0.6964071393,
0.1678755283,
-0.1186550409,
-0.4040213227,
-0.1712251008,
-0.612342,
-1.3888428211,
0.2603585422,
-0.3917508125,
-0.5737123489,
0.2216354907,
0.0593476743,
0.0371431708,
-0.2377087921,
-0.8885917068,
0.5983654857,
-0.1617186517,
-0.3432839513,
-0.3696527779,
-0.3920987546,
0.0234370008,
-0.1140006855,
0.2205432653,
0.431465894,
-0.487338841,
1.0738478899,
-0.241734758,
0.2468091249,
-0.216439873,
-0.127608791,
0.3548444808,
-0.5092189908,
0.5112823248,
-0.1584750414,
-0.2568074465,
0.3343864083,
-0.1515347958,
-0.5595301986,
-0.6112083793,
0.6996793747,
-0.7408764958,
-0.2741461992,
-0.5530781746,
-0.473506391,
-0.3133716881,
-0.2058789134,
0.2592890263,
0.2033239007,
-0.3499045372,
0.2454211116,
0.6029707789,
-0.2743645906,
0.5502303839,
0.5337305665,
0.0670265183,
-0.3308918774,
0.8928931952,
0.4673047066,
-0.151066184,
0.6317874193,
0.0084640132,
-0.4430600703,
-0.9317477942,
-0.5771227479,
-0.0564559102,
-0.1548306644,
-0.1699843556,
-0.5688921809,
0.0609282404,
-0.6902445555,
-0.0447583385,
0.1856177449,
-0.6978183985,
-0.2143004835,
-0.3097470701,
0.4980557859,
0.4386137724,
-0.0925818682,
0.5390971899,
-0.8193774819,
0.112448968,
-0.1895107776,
0.0720355809,
-0.4854391217,
-0.5395610929,
-0.3545741141,
-0.0449168198,
-0.3457289636,
-1.1280425787,
0.5395870805,
0.0796537623,
0.6979699731,
0.4055249691,
-0.3477750719,
0.5126684308,
-0.0974775404,
0.4955992997,
-0.1872762889,
-0.7055785656,
0.7474281788,
-0.3414257467,
-0.1278861165,
0.3906833231,
0.6544917226,
-0.291939497,
-0.1795919836,
-0.8539479971,
-0.7137367725,
0.819131732,
0.4633252621,
0.0718235299,
0.3273764551,
0.4368971288,
0.2239539772,
0.3138058782,
-0.4183413088,
-0.2583059967,
0.0979833454,
-0.0225363392,
-0.3312798142,
-0.0863018036,
0.2918848097,
-0.4358999431,
0.7376927137,
-0.1601663977,
0.412350297,
0.1889076829,
-0.1662529707,
0.1091409102,
0.2318709493,
0.4284467399,
0.6222783327,
0.0016338929,
-0.3198547363,
0.4904777706,
-0.489353478,
-0.1446153224,
0.6019747853,
-0.2782447338,
0.206417501,
0.3754101098,
0.8038287163,
-0.1568678319,
-0.709454596,
0.0784730092,
0.022733869,
0.0405205451,
-0.1177880391,
0.4274992049,
-0.4591853917,
-0.1047034487,
0.5058971047,
0.1336029172,
0.6490395069,
-0.6412109137,
0.0365684927,
0.2960769534,
-0.3231396079,
0.1857420206,
0.2328633815,
0.1019007266,
-0.2369467765,
0.3693373799,
-0.1475751996,
-0.6005914807,
0.5685197115,
0.4629366696,
0.4694522619,
-0.5713372827,
0.2694286108,
0.4166413248,
0.3764334321,
0.0056949835,
0.0926883668,
-0.2869185209,
-0.6374180913,
-0.6107419729,
-0.4544657469,
-0.6617687941,
-0.0206080452,
-0.5107696652,
0.4127311707,
-0.0257107448,
0.0814466774,
0.1583379507,
0.4295447767,
-0.5888485909,
0.6176658273,
0.0024669729,
0.7045173049,
-0.8168970942,
0.7416264415,
0.8936328292,
-0.3438889682,
-0.4468010962,
-0.3596688807,
-0.4107620418,
-0.628534615,
0.25199157,
0.34486413,
0.1122315004,
-0.3865436316,
-0.6055169106,
-0.5871250629,
0.7657734156,
0.1097640991,
-0.5340839624,
0.147086978,
0.4308760464,
1.0831397772,
-0.3369528949,
0.5658278465,
0.771579206,
0.6062924266,
-0.0370465294,
-0.8804634213,
-0.2315562516,
-0.4070750177,
0.1798014492,
0.1392021924,
-0.5280241966,
0.3891082704,
0.1928927153,
-0.0413645133,
-0.2034126818,
0.7926992774,
-0.0722549558,
0.5964358449,
0.3903838396,
0.5731818676,
1.2149484158,
-0.3665643036,
1.2525160313,
-0.1107783839,
0.2045224756,
0.6743659377,
0.0826700479,
0.4511565268,
0.0224137008,
-0.4491156042,
0.4604971707,
0.7768124342,
-0.3268969059,
0.1383619457,
0.1987768859,
-0.1356425881,
0.2727226317,
-0.1865456551,
-0.5385176539,
0.6697165966,
0.6596115232,
-0.6661047935,
0.1491615623,
0.3870968521,
0.2990711033,
0.2723911107,
-0.3473475873,
0.8353588581,
-0.4757052362,
-0.8605555892,
0.6411943436,
0.3237594068,
1.0610696077,
-0.1756088585,
0.0252232868,
0.0188865289,
0.2066013366,
-0.2818675041,
-0.5603622198,
0.6387276649,
0.2679184973,
-0.0456806608,
-0.1050833389,
0.9455631971,
-0.1939354539,
-0.7287077904,
0.2909457982,
0.405883491,
0.4565136135,
-0.0836396366,
-0.6248047948,
0.0700968504,
0.0369602703,
0.0790865123,
0.2395545244,
0.3225306869,
-0.182949245,
0.5179435015,
0.6923409104,
0.116806291,
-0.0607001521,
-0.122844331,
0.8193070889,
-0.514611125,
-0.437829107,
-0.7627558112,
0.1005862057,
-0.5160320401,
-0.3385762274,
0.9750942588,
1.0514992476,
1.0076342821,
0.0864802673,
0.953890264,
-0.0010320961,
0.8175550103,
-0.4150720537,
0.2991102636,
-0.261474371,
0.2019521594,
-0.5046784282,
-1.1382164955,
-0.2694343328,
0.5438243747,
-0.5844669938,
0.0815967619,
0.5720980167,
0.8750870824,
0.2400516123,
0.3555050194,
0.2497409582,
-0.0597931258,
0.0312491674,
0.4712577462,
0.8115788102,
-0.6802877784,
0.5593503714,
-0.4425134957,
-0.481392324,
-0.1306337416,
-0.5520943403,
-0.6821468472,
-0.5829819441,
-0.4899336696,
-0.3576836884,
0.4630138874,
0.6747454405,
0.6243906021,
-0.8806517124,
-0.0574227832,
-0.0921837986,
0.2515113056,
-0.2390411198,
-0.2998325527,
0.3784665167,
-0.4700234234,
-1.3670328856,
0.4519681633,
-0.0833733156,
-0.0009330227,
-0.0827435702,
0.0545863956,
0.0556799285,
-0.0772222206,
0.5230899453,
0.1630671024,
0.0007412756,
0.0029888654,
-0.0898329988,
0.2027720213,
0.2826806009,
0.8266090751,
-1.0601508617,
0.3291369975,
0.6444805264,
0.5151489377,
0.5879898071,
0.2821343839,
0.4069408774,
-0.7842321396,
0.3950445354,
0.3618663847,
0.3007876575,
0.4770596325,
-0.5349088311,
0.8902329803,
0.257607758,
-0.5843122602,
-0.7748971581,
-0.4095395207,
-0.9585343599,
-0.2720037997,
1.1020892859,
0.0717544258,
-0.2389617264,
-0.2174050957,
-0.6067812443,
0.3362119496,
-0.6125060916,
0.6126693487,
0.6609519124,
-0.3437358439,
0.161971733,
-0.3532133996,
0.4960480034,
0.2654892206,
-0.9778035283,
-0.3430911601,
0.8339424729,
-0.028770972,
0.4244509935,
0.2774128914,
-0.1167536154,
0.2417095602,
-0.1409572661,
-0.3197741807,
0.0367243402,
-0.3793208897,
-0.4399087131,
0.4192602634,
-0.2092799544,
-0.1788503081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02768v1 | Application of Transformers based methods in Electronic Medical Records: A Systematic Literature Review | 2023-04-05T22:19:42 | 2023-04-05T22:19:42 | Vitor Alcantara Batista, Alexandre Gonçalves Evsukoff | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The combined growth of available data and their unstructured nature has
received increased interest in natural language processing (NLP) techniques to
make value of these data assets since this format is not suitable for
statistical analysis. This work presents a systematic literature review of
state-of-the-art advances using transformer-based methods on electronic medical
records (EMRs) in different NLP tasks. To the best of our knowledge, this work
is unique in providing a comprehensive review of research on transformer-based
methods for NLP applied to the EMR field. In the initial query, 99 articles
were selected from three public databases and filtered into 65 articles for
detailed analysis. The papers were analyzed with respect to the business
problem, NLP task, models and techniques, availability of datasets,
reproducibility of modeling, language, and exchange format. The paper presents
some limitations of current research and some recommendations for further
research. | [
-0.2263067812,
-0.7936193943,
0.4305531979,
0.1509694606,
-0.0773496106,
-0.0473808013,
-0.2744711936,
-0.626650393,
0.3466094136,
0.7238737345,
-0.3794130385,
-0.4596514106,
-0.513351202,
0.6263413429,
-0.6266580224,
0.9131554365,
-0.1210115105,
0.3353332877,
0.0572539978,
-0.2996445,
-0.3845151365,
-0.7425127029,
-0.4961233437,
-0.3506314158,
0.1834555566,
0.2468258291,
0.5936766863,
0.2172538489,
1.1743843555,
0.2792498171,
-0.1677875519,
0.0617151298,
0.0474392064,
0.3838430047,
0.0120458016,
-0.376292944,
-0.5846098065,
-0.4265631139,
0.5969591141,
0.5385314822,
-0.6942485571,
0.2612667084,
-0.3251447082,
1.0195605755,
-0.3546494842,
-0.0900398493,
-0.259493649,
0.4402238429,
-0.3593314588,
-0.4033463299,
-0.6681213379,
-0.2005385756,
0.3583768308,
-0.2717011869,
0.5205731988,
0.1190762967,
0.6017823815,
0.0428986698,
-0.1626191586,
-0.7509269714,
-1.4484241009,
0.7802261114,
-0.6781612635,
0.4860463738,
-0.076752685,
0.5589236021,
0.032004986,
-0.9796508551,
-0.3364221156,
0.0531809106,
-0.4615064859,
0.1487058997,
-0.4664661884,
0.1013629958,
0.3775527179,
0.556080997,
-0.4539603293,
0.0452650562,
-0.6018611789,
0.2569890618,
0.5912068486,
0.2531917095,
0.5013409853,
-0.2408461124,
-0.2266817987,
-0.0109644309,
-0.3715259433,
-0.0148763685,
-0.1876590252,
0.03735305,
0.0770531446,
1.0082690716,
-0.2760182619,
0.6030797958,
0.0499601923,
-0.2846923769,
0.3135698438,
-0.4540061951,
-0.4792901278,
-0.0410943329,
0.7080820203,
0.3393833041,
-0.0984582528,
-0.3382411897,
-0.3055811226,
-0.0688071027,
0.4999052584,
-0.4379380047,
0.1893820912,
0.3750971258,
-0.9103395939,
-0.0878287107,
0.0978739485,
-1.0454351902,
-0.0397753306,
-0.4747414589,
0.1579241306,
-0.2808167338,
-0.1738992631,
0.3035762906,
-0.2394998968,
0.2791689634,
0.0136579769,
-0.7648603916,
0.8223051429,
0.5081318617,
0.78203547,
-0.1728411913,
0.3914996982,
0.2671278417,
-0.0834130421,
-0.024293283,
0.9052042961,
-0.1682406217,
-0.472006321,
0.3227418661,
0.1537830979,
-0.2196345776,
-0.7091537118,
1.1624554396,
-0.569024086,
0.3435709774,
0.0824103579,
-0.4343205988,
-0.1474624425,
0.1747105569,
-0.8928403854,
0.7812598944,
-0.1108757257,
-0.7392443419,
0.2833794951,
-0.9142846465,
-0.5973693728,
0.0031800386,
-0.039303977,
-0.7577226758,
0.1969655603,
0.5675447583,
0.3932065666,
-0.6131914854,
0.4765073061,
0.549842,
-0.0395060144,
0.3833906054,
-0.2793363929,
0.6881561279,
0.3050377369,
-0.2997552156,
-0.039711386,
-0.7529419065,
-0.1225547045,
0.1859339327,
0.0030503834,
-0.4059056342,
0.2443223298,
0.4180046618,
0.252307713,
-0.1692915857,
-0.6965871453,
0.0361107141,
-0.336866796,
0.079439275,
-0.0829151645,
0.2335481793,
0.3990330398,
-0.68813169,
0.5578301549,
-0.0497211292,
0.5609366298,
-0.1929553896,
-0.6321614385,
-0.6220989823,
-0.1606662273,
0.4066081047,
0.5728040934,
-0.6702032685,
0.5567272305,
-0.2844125628,
-0.6360870004,
-0.9450644851,
-0.401732862,
-0.0590395331,
0.6206077933,
0.8401879668,
-0.3510278463,
-0.7403632998,
-1.3289085627,
-0.2299923301,
0.1405795515,
-0.2690786719,
0.1326871365,
0.1163694933,
-0.618624568,
1.0796892643,
-0.4735220075,
-0.6421129107,
-0.366848588,
0.2354771346,
0.5076438785,
0.1809117198,
0.1494269818,
-0.7692801356,
-0.3611173332,
0.0391452312,
-0.6843444109,
-0.235740602,
-0.3098799288,
0.2444075048,
0.4804216027,
0.1470185965,
-0.5059245229,
0.3769599795,
0.4308539331,
0.0060445224,
-0.0658604577,
-0.2767785788,
0.4448827207,
-0.7550863624,
0.2827492952,
0.3812051713,
-0.1093863472,
-0.988004148,
-0.2924101055,
0.2547166049,
0.057248313,
-0.2421622574,
0.110252887,
-0.5138408542,
0.1817601919,
-0.2653059363,
-0.1623524725,
-0.0118101751,
0.0352416933,
0.1392741203,
0.1127249599,
0.32691589,
-0.4371603429,
0.3532572091,
0.6015553474,
-0.0594338626,
0.6477310061,
-0.6325630546,
-0.1428830624,
-0.4370101392,
0.2396796942,
-0.5262909532,
0.3372599185,
0.1850182265,
-0.2462250143,
0.7562406063,
0.0545876399,
-0.5436660051,
-0.573094666,
-0.1189966649,
-0.0138299456,
0.7832357287,
-0.2763539851,
0.7306865454,
0.5172398686,
-0.4335563779,
-0.4104386568,
-0.6787819862,
0.2299103141,
-0.110608317,
-0.5792822838,
0.5530669689,
0.3012295961,
-0.3648773134,
0.0699001402,
-0.1889805496,
-0.2721923888,
-0.2979455888,
-0.1305436939,
0.3864253163,
-0.2338020056,
0.1605101824,
0.0158555936,
-0.3671371937,
0.3187427223,
0.1933040619,
0.0873678774,
0.134578988,
-0.4155339897,
-0.5530675054,
0.4609879851,
0.3671528399,
-0.0663263649,
0.5982725024,
0.4682226777,
-0.4612343311,
-0.1701946259,
-0.8388992548,
-0.1675993204,
-0.3487507403,
0.2938225269,
0.2614639699,
-0.4491485953,
0.3428644538,
-0.1266885549,
0.3035128415,
0.867497623,
0.6482007504,
-0.1703079194,
0.6903184056,
0.4053352177,
0.2559393644,
0.0893277302,
-0.0285226107,
0.6204667091,
-0.8395673037,
-0.6815804839,
-0.9696132541,
-0.3474437594,
-0.706854403,
-0.3919272423,
0.4322399795,
-0.3296717703,
0.2926511168,
0.2938204706,
-0.9546980262,
-0.0097043933,
0.1440664381,
0.2021072209,
0.8603577018,
-0.0329276919,
0.2123756409,
-0.2456672192,
-0.5362608433,
-0.6061308384,
1.1722303629,
0.5706143379,
0.902689755,
-0.0828544945,
0.3928934634,
0.3482807875,
0.708773315,
-0.7942703962,
0.1532742083,
-0.0439501405,
-0.7619737387,
-0.4709393978,
-0.184226796,
-1.0911072493,
0.1778606027,
-0.3472078443,
-0.2040573955,
-0.0022384659,
-0.2705540657,
-0.0410783403,
0.466602236,
-0.4774212539,
0.2615047395,
-0.3324282467,
0.1881832778,
0.077659905,
-0.6690132022,
0.1211121306,
-0.2129523009,
0.4423600733,
0.235736534,
-0.0706256628,
0.9457197189,
-0.3026045561,
0.4115554988,
-0.0238263719,
0.0301800761,
0.2513833642,
-0.3967088461,
0.4366188347,
-0.1267824769,
0.0713894144,
0.4294700623,
0.1860831082,
-0.0161748193,
-0.6008395553,
0.0929015353,
-0.1711373478,
-0.3645781577,
-0.8024879694,
-0.1674401909,
-0.2915411294,
0.2186044008,
0.3082244396,
0.4419630468,
-0.264655292,
0.3939399719,
0.4225234091,
-0.266122818,
0.3971688151,
0.6533437967,
-0.0331959166,
-0.3458407521,
0.0382113568,
0.3834995329,
-0.1796678305,
0.6994509101,
0.0034643377,
-0.4146984816,
-0.6881603003,
-0.3845899999,
0.269541353,
-0.3846454322,
-0.3262575865,
-0.88367939,
-0.3534077704,
-0.1845932901,
-0.130672574,
-0.3960450888,
-0.3234431744,
0.0447049513,
0.0424484238,
0.3656803966,
0.967513144,
0.3798405826,
0.0995157957,
-0.9906275272,
0.5824440122,
-0.1769338101,
0.6603326201,
-0.0414306186,
-0.2372399569,
-0.3156344891,
-0.0329682045,
-0.4169403613,
-1.0097477436,
0.589266777,
-0.147652328,
0.6259639263,
0.0124282194,
0.1322950721,
0.5323827863,
-0.7426882982,
0.4740345478,
0.2288322449,
-0.7588251233,
0.6120171547,
-0.1803404093,
-0.1428937316,
0.5097562075,
0.4563761055,
-0.8074316978,
-0.0830028951,
-0.8687485456,
-1.1169182062,
0.5306944847,
0.5618157387,
-0.1202803999,
0.1017770395,
0.0843834132,
-0.0606248342,
0.1387175173,
-0.3960890174,
-0.76410079,
0.3602320254,
-0.323448807,
0.0847837031,
-0.0047777984,
-0.0609756932,
-0.1104975343,
0.6504499912,
0.1654987484,
0.4638796747,
0.8582957983,
-0.1597328186,
-0.260843128,
0.7335720658,
0.3722198606,
0.6038009524,
-0.211293757,
-0.3527553678,
0.1964479089,
-0.7453668118,
0.072049439,
0.067326732,
-0.4423491955,
0.579148829,
0.0142262103,
0.2391481847,
0.3575122058,
-0.6715973616,
0.5611698627,
-0.2445920259,
-0.2786088586,
-0.6512514949,
-0.517436862,
-0.0876002014,
0.0319422819,
0.522991538,
0.3834701478,
0.5057365298,
-0.1599212736,
0.3724761605,
0.1904059947,
-0.5040189624,
-0.251388669,
0.3608907759,
0.1988689601,
-0.452363044,
0.5883388519,
0.4478457272,
0.1516434103,
0.5155314207,
0.7419953942,
0.7733033299,
-0.2731575966,
0.0765710995,
0.3393890858,
0.5654816628,
-0.3929373026,
0.2530990541,
0.3997961581,
-0.4735977352,
-0.6117169261,
-0.2963748872,
-0.7713764906,
0.0322736353,
-0.8725421429,
0.4529599249,
0.0447055511,
-0.4291988909,
0.0869535804,
-0.3422033191,
-0.8863832355,
0.0457457379,
-0.1586342603,
0.8902935982,
-0.6079602242,
0.209913522,
0.6715908647,
-0.1817265451,
-0.3805436492,
-0.2919670045,
0.094238013,
-0.2410259396,
0.2755624056,
-0.1667626649,
0.293271929,
-0.2760480344,
0.039637316,
-0.711071372,
1.1538498402,
-0.1772072017,
-0.7289147377,
-0.2037531585,
0.2121335268,
0.9396745563,
-0.0972284824,
0.5120244622,
0.6570353508,
0.4336499572,
-0.2041151822,
-1.0058836937,
0.0198920872,
-0.2859739363,
-0.1404966861,
0.5370185971,
-0.3740545213,
0.2612959445,
0.2751411498,
-0.4134968817,
-0.1846809536,
0.2609885335,
0.0668825954,
0.5697206259,
0.0804585069,
0.4241123497,
0.5356990099,
-0.1860617101,
1.0992684364,
-0.0542383678,
0.6118730903,
0.468767345,
-0.5561326742,
0.7407340407,
0.5160906315,
-0.5341445804,
0.5749534369,
0.0498747267,
-0.3313184977,
0.1003549397,
0.1695526689,
-0.1683054566,
0.5429132581,
-0.1569348872,
-0.3239546418,
0.2167286277,
0.4859142601,
-0.6984156966,
-0.2050996125,
-0.0679095536,
-0.0502349548,
0.0835657567,
-0.1579852998,
0.9249282479,
0.0929958522,
-0.474165678,
0.0155395148,
0.2540769279,
0.8693267107,
-0.6306449771,
-0.1463069469,
0.3130316734,
-0.0343194306,
-0.6039181948,
-0.4148893952,
0.8339042068,
0.2144508958,
-0.1187719852,
-0.4923790991,
1.0524742603,
0.0069604754,
-0.5048010349,
0.0935520455,
0.8274214268,
-0.2131844312,
0.3045029342,
-0.4203569889,
-0.3716367781,
-0.2013563663,
-0.4006836414,
-0.0548321418,
0.4606735408,
0.1358253062,
0.3064334393,
0.543266952,
0.4062912762,
-0.0580387115,
0.2342138439,
0.5645959973,
-1.0526666641,
-0.3118495643,
-0.7171621919,
0.7228956223,
-0.1433802843,
-0.1308261603,
0.6722382307,
0.6570447087,
0.6575652361,
-0.2911124825,
0.7260403633,
-0.1327733546,
1.1033886671,
-0.5458503962,
0.5804468989,
0.0413416475,
0.2417746931,
-0.3568426073,
-0.8437341452,
-0.7604082227,
0.4561088085,
-0.0899909362,
-0.0862963274,
1.064614296,
0.5127518773,
0.1181704774,
0.4532957673,
0.2227161229,
0.0445199199,
0.1410347223,
-0.0918370634,
0.5494313836,
-0.8264030218,
0.2417261451,
-0.4244191647,
-0.1392649859,
-0.338092953,
-0.653427124,
-0.3903685808,
-0.5307872891,
-0.3467566967,
-0.2085188627,
-0.3193909824,
0.9820089936,
0.4655537009,
-0.8204266429,
-0.0710304826,
0.0357058272,
-0.0867354199,
-0.4321883023,
-0.2192418873,
0.4665310383,
-0.3418918252,
-0.5246525407,
0.0656343922,
0.4432468116,
-0.0154578257,
0.0931782275,
0.2311559916,
-0.1062814891,
-0.1497617364,
0.6177074313,
0.2254528403,
-0.4800421,
0.3155267835,
0.5732778311,
-0.1652477086,
0.3908338845,
1.2963870764,
-0.4558668435,
0.4542492032,
0.6798768044,
0.6375976801,
0.4496977627,
0.0853687823,
0.4443725049,
-0.4232836366,
-0.3081216216,
0.6881849766,
0.5941925645,
0.3481640518,
-0.4346475303,
0.6202286482,
0.0639761314,
-0.7937674522,
-0.4909916222,
-0.0950695872,
-0.9553557634,
0.0263122562,
0.8235629201,
0.4978844821,
-0.0349472053,
-0.6787059903,
-0.2993482947,
0.4246935248,
-0.3033947349,
0.7675877213,
0.4071464241,
-0.5348396301,
0.0727841333,
-0.8386967182,
0.3600350916,
0.1121742427,
-1.0052653551,
-0.2871850431,
0.2374972403,
-0.1103651375,
0.3917756677,
0.7926115394,
-0.8715261817,
-0.0498187691,
-0.3404766917,
0.3216865361,
0.2538833618,
-0.1479723006,
-0.7874594927,
0.1702550501,
0.0409974754,
0.2128088325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02757v1 | The Saudi Privacy Policy Dataset | 2023-04-05T21:40:37 | 2023-04-05T21:40:37 | Hend Al-Khalifa, Malak Mashaabi, Ghadi Al-Yahya, Raghad Alnashwan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces the Saudi Privacy Policy Dataset, a diverse compilation
of Arabic privacy policies from various sectors in Saudi Arabia, annotated
according to the 10 principles of the Personal Data Protection Law (PDPL); the
PDPL was established to be compatible with General Data Protection Regulation
(GDPR); one of the most comprehensive data regulations worldwide. Data were
collected from multiple sources, including the Saudi Central Bank, the Saudi
Arabia National United Platform, the Council of Health Insurance, and general
websites using Google and Wikipedia. The final dataset includes 1,000 websites
belonging to 7 sectors, 4,638 lines of text, 775,370 tokens, and a corpus size
of 8,353 KB. The annotated dataset offers significant reuse potential for
assessing privacy policy compliance, benchmarking privacy practices across
industries, and developing automated tools for monitoring adherence to data
protection regulations. By providing a comprehensive and annotated dataset of
privacy policies, this paper aims to facilitate further research and
development in the areas of privacy policy analysis, natural language
processing, and machine learning applications related to privacy and data
protection, while also serving as an essential resource for researchers,
policymakers, and industry professionals interested in understanding and
promoting compliance with privacy regulations in Saudi Arabia. | [
-0.6691998243,
-0.3972592056,
0.1869776845,
0.4261677861,
-0.1587528437,
-0.0068038967,
-0.0300158933,
-0.3086985946,
-0.3213387728,
0.9277260303,
-0.6917385459,
-1.0158240795,
-0.1916856915,
0.1969371587,
0.011613695,
1.3031402826,
-0.2370514423,
-0.2174980491,
0.1550849527,
-0.0331958197,
-0.2057591677,
-0.3323741555,
0.0470002219,
0.2995215654,
0.406529665,
0.5201041102,
0.9153961539,
0.7091479897,
0.3732016981,
0.2090758234,
0.2067885995,
0.2058334947,
0.0722490028,
-0.3415203094,
-0.2673036456,
0.1358885765,
-0.1972175837,
-0.2520420253,
0.7914833426,
0.8130143285,
-0.3307049572,
0.188355729,
0.1576000899,
0.8548815846,
-0.9774134159,
0.1146856919,
-0.0353552029,
0.0750456229,
-0.2727864385,
0.0098616974,
0.1767597795,
-0.6666573286,
0.2131926864,
-0.227506265,
0.2348659337,
0.0521265082,
0.6024320126,
-0.1117470413,
-0.795363009,
-0.2696362138,
-0.5908977985,
0.5363355875,
-0.3120428622,
0.377690047,
0.7601821423,
0.4188771844,
-0.1715546548,
-0.5244830251,
-0.6797674298,
0.1276732236,
0.0478040054,
-0.2286163121,
-0.1484926641,
0.08075504,
0.3575422168,
0.4232192636,
-0.5320827365,
-0.0122888731,
-0.4256005883,
-0.647095561,
0.8830007911,
0.188349843,
0.1908295304,
0.0943392217,
0.1382342279,
-0.1054854318,
-0.7722685337,
0.216565609,
0.8400472999,
0.1418816149,
-0.4197171926,
0.4455044568,
-0.8594607115,
0.6533687711,
-0.280620873,
-0.3728159666,
0.4972953796,
-0.4594298601,
-0.1362130195,
0.5960452557,
0.5998002291,
0.4025442898,
0.1372908205,
-0.0114417216,
-0.0433917418,
-0.3605448604,
0.1811491698,
-0.807317555,
-0.3999384344,
0.3113767505,
-0.5698307157,
-0.3245495558,
0.3786984384,
-0.7817792892,
-0.6735297441,
-0.2589091063,
-0.0501034819,
0.3033332527,
0.0773424581,
0.1391869336,
0.1019133553,
0.0868312865,
-0.0040398901,
-0.9924240112,
0.7646636963,
0.5825337172,
0.591316402,
-0.0150794536,
-0.3148545623,
0.1737710536,
0.563282311,
-0.3137719333,
0.0663720071,
-0.5134630799,
-0.7130663395,
0.5829489231,
0.2384400815,
0.5002506971,
-0.447912842,
0.7446961403,
-0.5012071133,
0.1569832414,
-0.5331753492,
-0.385514915,
-0.494908452,
0.1358534843,
-0.9864313006,
0.0632999316,
0.2530593872,
-0.7669680119,
0.8243691325,
-0.8355637193,
-0.4742758572,
-0.0002258364,
-0.2488574684,
-0.6581161022,
-0.2819949985,
0.3070190549,
0.2346048802,
-0.2849925458,
0.0978209004,
-0.4662950337,
-0.3358893991,
0.356646657,
-0.3384486437,
0.9237020016,
0.3723867238,
-0.1153777763,
0.1451066285,
-0.9961545467,
-0.2315655649,
-0.0950322449,
-0.2636452913,
0.0953958482,
-0.134752959,
0.4883922637,
0.302333802,
0.6852731109,
-0.7359979153,
0.128757298,
-0.1426114142,
0.3292612433,
0.6368976235,
0.505446434,
0.2801641524,
-0.5245867968,
0.4914900959,
0.29845047,
0.3146257102,
0.0253416896,
-0.0915662199,
-0.0439947173,
-0.1883612722,
0.307584554,
0.3541993499,
0.0032602067,
0.7152839899,
-0.271053493,
-0.373598218,
-0.5220970511,
-0.0146114705,
0.0361245126,
0.6502850652,
0.2174342424,
-0.1929063946,
-0.5189647675,
-1.2955423594,
-0.3795494437,
0.1313775331,
0.1975008845,
0.4514760077,
0.6783245206,
-0.1102923006,
0.8818238378,
-0.2849491239,
-0.2784840763,
0.1087383255,
-0.229149729,
0.2206817269,
0.4957129061,
0.1884087771,
-0.9295256138,
-0.7267318964,
-0.0724920481,
-0.5034323931,
0.0870453864,
-0.0091092074,
0.0231561232,
0.3337729275,
-0.3473008275,
-0.2127350569,
0.7296829224,
0.1565746963,
-0.4418514371,
0.411657095,
-0.1436974257,
0.3339385986,
-0.7166094184,
0.1397159845,
0.0233355369,
-0.2079829723,
-0.6695449352,
-0.3995749056,
-0.0970684141,
-0.0329732411,
-0.6127990484,
0.2950956821,
-0.0977232158,
-0.2050016224,
-0.1874901354,
-0.5286798477,
-0.1411932856,
0.1462932229,
-0.0802360997,
1.1714367867,
0.6609736681,
-0.7896515727,
0.1527735889,
0.661816895,
-0.5534182191,
0.3368883431,
-0.3933720887,
0.1348385364,
-0.0160154849,
0.020887306,
-0.4717918038,
-0.4946787059,
0.6242175102,
0.0021696989,
0.0278083012,
0.1670230925,
-0.6539603472,
-0.257527113,
-0.693580687,
0.0220820867,
0.5605847836,
-0.2864269316,
0.2615817487,
0.8340135217,
-0.1867079586,
-0.9648972154,
-0.5454384089,
0.0186878704,
-0.4878216982,
-0.216031149,
0.5732048154,
0.3702067137,
-0.1528310329,
0.0602173284,
-0.0561947636,
-0.3229125142,
0.1458350122,
0.5438656211,
-0.0584000275,
0.3423660994,
-0.3827615678,
0.0666804984,
0.0571673065,
0.4037325084,
-0.059354458,
0.5527727008,
-0.0452467948,
-0.1279681027,
-0.9847455621,
0.3942348659,
0.3411242664,
0.3008591533,
0.8038991094,
0.2771964073,
-0.3371670842,
0.3365488946,
-0.147847414,
0.0829579458,
-0.449903816,
0.1368394196,
-0.5731970668,
-0.5594329238,
0.7566075921,
0.0057349005,
0.1615380943,
0.3330037594,
0.5931856036,
0.0364133269,
1.1032586098,
0.9196936488,
-0.6058866382,
0.1387776434,
0.2009605318,
0.039723713,
-0.6003099084,
-0.3043334484,
-0.4201664329,
-0.2936867177,
-1.5558409691,
0.6202859879,
0.0727692544,
-0.0145511702,
-0.7516968846,
0.1837786585,
-0.2878885269,
0.3531535566,
0.4537606239,
0.3038319051,
0.2405384481,
0.3424578309,
0.0843086988,
-0.1309353709,
-0.1103130654,
-0.8652512431,
1.4342993498,
0.2577722073,
0.6204179525,
0.425319463,
0.8822451234,
0.91089046,
-0.0798880309,
-0.0388129763,
0.3978832364,
0.0890101343,
-0.5106214285,
-0.24687846,
-0.363067925,
-1.1043617725,
-0.1547899693,
0.030928921,
-1.0044721365,
0.4507852793,
0.1446450353,
-0.1143288836,
-0.1008814871,
-0.1549901962,
0.9294794798,
0.1174849421,
-0.608009994,
-0.1998134106,
-0.7984127402,
0.43295151,
-0.1607866883,
0.0030664182,
-0.3117867708,
-0.3757158816,
0.8252537847,
-0.6103078127,
0.5026464462,
-0.440587461,
0.0910369009,
0.3728673756,
-0.3055220246,
0.3358360231,
-0.187284708,
0.2915436625,
0.2710526884,
0.3659845889,
-0.5053121448,
0.0486658588,
0.6364869475,
-1.1225161552,
-0.1097711101,
-0.5819802284,
-0.5461153984,
-0.5528523326,
0.244337976,
0.0317822918,
-0.0758735538,
-0.4254055917,
0.1927614212,
0.4522645772,
-0.2515591681,
0.2451040596,
0.5734478831,
-0.4603448808,
-0.3602560461,
1.0074462891,
0.3744047284,
-0.3965284824,
0.1246994585,
0.0699122176,
-0.7510765195,
-0.3525744081,
-0.2351818979,
-0.0157910679,
-0.8718216419,
0.04166013,
-0.5412577391,
-0.1470395029,
-0.5574560761,
0.1977128536,
0.2718678713,
-0.2637778819,
-0.0221950021,
0.0323043503,
0.4853439629,
0.5140088797,
-0.1743021458,
0.4695476592,
-0.5228992701,
0.3167960942,
-0.0029118089,
0.1028905734,
-0.4698759317,
-0.0805315003,
0.0752652809,
0.1416986436,
-0.2019344568,
-0.7899236679,
0.242499128,
0.1376109719,
0.3325377703,
0.4749881327,
0.047512427,
0.4492450953,
-0.4983592033,
0.578212142,
-0.0840573311,
-0.7502064705,
0.3875780702,
-0.3998374641,
0.0203296188,
1.0036712885,
0.7946615219,
-0.5551104546,
0.2948530018,
-0.8220381737,
-0.6723313928,
0.3123256862,
0.0750015378,
0.1658108085,
0.2581959367,
0.1454750746,
0.3932340145,
0.9872704744,
-0.07053826,
-0.4622957408,
0.0534348749,
-0.50889498,
0.3960418701,
-0.2155261636,
-0.258798033,
-0.0916575268,
0.7884343863,
0.1923174113,
0.1620302051,
-0.2782212496,
-0.0210623331,
0.1300091594,
0.2004474252,
0.6158758998,
0.9891850352,
-0.1808457971,
-0.176404655,
-0.1449828595,
-0.895422101,
0.2059819996,
0.3677172363,
-0.786841929,
-0.2604628801,
-0.2151961178,
0.2951109707,
-0.3737388253,
-0.6275072694,
0.4648921788,
0.0908802748,
-0.3134129643,
-0.6538665891,
0.2670999765,
-0.4126376808,
-0.1432196945,
0.1618977338,
-0.3669607341,
0.6873146296,
-0.450238049,
0.6987206936,
0.2092915028,
-0.3308160603,
-0.0789682344,
0.5439618826,
-0.0995745137,
-0.203408584,
0.4449210763,
0.002356173,
-0.2145212442,
0.434578836,
0.2739782333,
0.48001948,
-0.0338392369,
0.2311900854,
0.0643685311,
0.0292838812,
0.0437640846,
0.8769963384,
-0.2221717238,
-0.6142809391,
-0.0358180553,
-0.1639431864,
-0.6821014881,
0.2454152852,
-0.798686862,
0.0047492324,
-0.8343458772,
-0.009132484,
0.0700372681,
0.4756892622,
-0.9111487865,
0.1337923408,
0.0655951202,
0.5956059694,
-0.7833108306,
0.6343308091,
0.3480371237,
-0.6963627934,
-0.1973458081,
-0.0081914915,
0.2082849443,
-1.0123147964,
0.0944524929,
0.3758866787,
0.1131526977,
-0.1489844024,
-0.6415862441,
-0.5130318999,
0.8334336281,
0.0045457263,
-0.8738766909,
0.5257176161,
0.7844407558,
0.1584460735,
-0.2428207994,
-0.4638001323,
1.0099748373,
0.519928515,
-0.4262039959,
-0.7269723415,
0.0928775817,
0.1583818793,
-0.1981494725,
0.230922997,
-0.6391527653,
0.4133464694,
0.2127809972,
0.0472847074,
-0.0876501203,
0.768665731,
0.3073428869,
0.4431738555,
0.2385677993,
0.4116259217,
1.0661225319,
0.1621023864,
1.0074957609,
-0.7339085937,
0.0581487045,
1.0289456844,
-0.6978603005,
0.4190755785,
0.3164448738,
-0.4515401721,
0.3894699812,
0.7843739986,
-0.2612383664,
1.1191471815,
0.1678889543,
-0.6401306987,
0.4385254979,
-0.7654140592,
-0.4850319326,
0.4032898843,
0.1927859336,
-0.5257982016,
-0.1905978769,
0.090260528,
0.2244374603,
-0.014743113,
-0.6365561485,
0.7337076664,
-0.3511297703,
-0.1556783766,
-0.1408525258,
0.1763708144,
0.1947922409,
-0.319786191,
-0.1833819598,
0.2935653627,
0.1113644615,
-0.2717220187,
-1.0744115114,
0.4380122423,
0.1362067163,
-0.12604101,
0.0749966204,
0.7110592723,
-0.328461647,
-0.4293566644,
-0.7091498375,
0.3136261106,
0.4912302196,
-0.0092055518,
-0.8307185173,
0.0371600911,
0.0057502054,
-0.1611263901,
0.4402068555,
0.2047932446,
-0.1989067942,
0.3158900738,
0.6727873087,
0.2370723486,
-0.1766676903,
0.1729781181,
0.625621438,
-0.795355916,
-0.7669005394,
-0.9158909917,
0.253580004,
-0.4682749808,
-0.5282558203,
0.78863132,
0.7186979055,
0.9137331247,
0.1974405944,
1.1245994568,
-0.0707738325,
0.6865155101,
-0.3450608253,
0.6971709728,
0.1922881454,
-0.0557270981,
0.4501126707,
-0.9219374061,
-0.1530094743,
0.9022619724,
-0.4411086738,
0.2015548646,
0.0679064542,
0.7388825417,
0.351180464,
0.1886490285,
0.0375484191,
-0.201274544,
0.2194698751,
0.296982944,
0.3801484406,
-0.2854957879,
-0.0282934606,
-0.905395031,
0.4680100381,
-0.040531721,
-0.7818607092,
-0.6453441978,
-0.3726907969,
-0.5438109636,
-0.4024889767,
0.0247442722,
0.9780396819,
0.3995341957,
-1.1297605038,
-0.2175441235,
-0.3810890615,
0.005480879,
-0.1273334473,
-0.1964129359,
0.663289845,
0.3860679865,
-0.311472863,
-0.1318019181,
0.1606646329,
0.2462849766,
-0.4468683898,
-0.0447799489,
-0.060848631,
-0.2541604638,
0.1191436946,
0.572360754,
-0.4668357372,
-0.1190726086,
-0.4074431956,
-0.2527702451,
0.1916109771,
0.6290010214,
-0.5719602108,
0.2227706313,
0.2993943095,
0.5562570691,
0.4124382436,
0.2192645818,
0.1775576025,
-0.466688782,
0.1509389579,
0.3304981887,
0.362768501,
0.2731059194,
-0.4663279057,
0.4413509071,
-0.255584985,
-0.532874763,
-0.8206902146,
0.2592752874,
-0.8211416602,
-0.0224435739,
0.7754478455,
0.0022497356,
-0.563105464,
-0.6113210917,
-0.1943716109,
0.0917132795,
-0.7105514407,
0.801745832,
0.635530889,
-0.1854686588,
-0.1220416501,
-0.7181625366,
0.7975256443,
-0.2660099566,
-0.8739648461,
0.1706874073,
0.5624127984,
0.2257878631,
-0.2957026064,
0.5043347478,
-0.0032317953,
0.3637585938,
-0.1107608899,
-0.0980171636,
-0.0904636905,
-0.4140869379,
-0.4807142317,
0.241522938,
-0.0010226663,
-0.5131977797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02754v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02754v2 | Conceptual structure coheres in human cognition but not in large language models | 2023-04-05T21:27:01 | 2023-11-10T17:42:31 | Siddharth Suresh, Kushin Mukherjee, Xizheng Yu, Wei-Chun Huang, Lisa Padua, Timothy T Rogers | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Neural network models of language have long been used as a tool for
developing hypotheses about conceptual representation in the mind and brain.
For many years, such use involved extracting vector-space representations of
words and using distances among these to predict or understand human behavior
in various semantic tasks. Contemporary large language models (LLMs), however,
make it possible to interrogate the latent structure of conceptual
representations using experimental methods nearly identical to those commonly
used with human participants. The current work utilizes three common techniques
borrowed from cognitive psychology to estimate and compare the structure of
concepts in humans and a suite of LLMs. In humans, we show that conceptual
structure is robust to differences in culture, language, and method of
estimation. Structures estimated from LLM behavior, while individually fairly
consistent with those estimated from human behavior, vary much more depending
upon the particular task used to generate responses--across tasks, estimates of
conceptual structure from the very same model cohere less with one another than
do human structure estimates. These results highlight an important difference
between contemporary LLMs and human cognition, with implications for
understanding some fundamental limitations of contemporary machine language. | [
-0.4310801625,
-1.0226867199,
0.5907190442,
0.3042135239,
-0.1344492137,
0.2875065506,
-0.4442610741,
-0.7338616848,
0.4039134085,
-0.1175449789,
-0.3002453744,
-0.2317314148,
-0.442854017,
0.0516500436,
-0.4159945846,
0.4958297312,
-0.0219179038,
0.0372263417,
-0.6973506808,
-0.072239764,
-0.3632971346,
-0.6985525489,
-0.6807507277,
-0.8692585826,
0.4852294922,
0.0506666005,
0.6620109677,
0.2479873598,
0.6059547067,
0.3260633647,
-0.3483841419,
-0.0778316334,
-0.0704629272,
0.2112069726,
-0.0634983554,
-0.6860195994,
-0.4243594408,
0.2157248408,
0.745405376,
1.3118002415,
-0.1793040335,
-0.0042063626,
0.1993370056,
0.4816339314,
-0.7063974142,
0.2568276227,
-0.411239624,
0.1101162508,
-0.2681759596,
0.1366788894,
-0.1394999623,
0.0691722631,
0.442109555,
-0.4887167811,
0.2709940374,
0.0840547383,
0.9677053094,
0.0348291658,
-0.3755629659,
-0.4094441533,
-0.6321927309,
0.7636905313,
-0.4545636177,
0.5731118321,
0.649348557,
0.0489690192,
-0.3537187278,
-0.4670416415,
-0.7578768134,
-0.7887151241,
-0.1288705468,
0.0140636414,
-0.0668689758,
-0.0525145382,
0.2464303523,
0.0717559159,
-0.3884324133,
0.2297676355,
-0.2962333262,
-0.4045218825,
0.6633360386,
0.1248141527,
0.2854710221,
-0.4350295663,
-0.4070513546,
-0.1653216779,
-0.7038546801,
0.050393451,
0.1549585313,
-0.0090024434,
-0.3688674271,
0.5287438035,
-0.0181770474,
0.5041216612,
-0.1433242261,
-0.1328222752,
0.072776556,
-0.2584265471,
-0.1594845206,
-0.1670116484,
0.8616851568,
0.3269878328,
0.5133821368,
-0.4418275058,
0.0347501226,
0.4209419489,
0.1977380812,
-0.3616861105,
-0.3960976601,
-0.0939367637,
-0.3278051317,
0.0889411941,
0.1115043685,
-0.3273993134,
-0.2693800032,
-0.160560146,
-0.0114623755,
-0.2079617232,
-0.3683283031,
-0.0344129428,
-0.1159362346,
0.2817057669,
0.3723603189,
-0.8428660035,
0.6920138001,
0.7230719328,
0.9898478389,
-0.6390627623,
-0.3246101141,
0.0485506169,
0.0232059751,
-0.6569828987,
0.7675798535,
-0.4707357585,
-0.3167842031,
-0.3891010582,
-0.2529614866,
0.0489116162,
-0.7391014099,
0.3239498138,
-0.6593254805,
0.1081770584,
-0.3786780238,
-0.6396895647,
-0.0809008628,
0.376508683,
-0.6186420321,
0.7846930027,
-0.1558339894,
-0.8972221613,
0.2587667704,
-0.516620338,
-0.4438773096,
-0.0433253534,
-0.7082219124,
-0.1387708485,
0.5065858364,
-0.218862921,
0.6300896406,
-0.383105278,
0.2993560433,
-0.5859113336,
-0.4765777588,
0.7163410783,
-0.3835225701,
0.6434458494,
0.2632894218,
-0.0156661943,
-0.1089324206,
-0.5106816292,
-0.1104293764,
0.3455507159,
-0.2733296156,
-0.7919614315,
0.3846479952,
-0.2098128647,
0.1486997008,
0.2088294774,
-0.4520313442,
-0.1711844951,
-0.4647689462,
0.6559249163,
0.3896943331,
-0.2807640433,
0.6956959963,
-0.1261127442,
0.2821694016,
0.1728023291,
-0.5010137558,
0.2033308446,
-0.3944453895,
-0.4552173316,
-0.2560092509,
0.0826233178,
0.2287207246,
-0.3106565177,
0.2917038798,
-0.5131332874,
-0.2472344786,
-0.098749496,
-0.1278693527,
0.2869547009,
0.3695193231,
0.0943895578,
-0.5900882483,
-0.4010985196,
-1.1267882586,
-0.3625646532,
-0.5089043379,
-0.1668813229,
-0.0665645227,
0.7614925504,
0.1982770264,
0.9180631042,
-0.6901026368,
0.1751941144,
-0.0758925155,
0.1655466706,
-0.0714918971,
0.4487962127,
0.3360702097,
-0.715520978,
-0.2579164803,
-0.0634407774,
-0.8658007383,
0.286514163,
0.2115244269,
0.0822179243,
0.1007802933,
0.7796031833,
-0.6564728022,
0.3938169181,
0.4791673422,
-0.3021376133,
0.3982909024,
-0.1905561537,
-0.2163030356,
-1.170440793,
0.0023840219,
0.0957253203,
-0.0630096421,
-0.4872073531,
0.1267744154,
0.1396450102,
0.2832875252,
-0.1905679405,
0.6286344528,
-0.4916623235,
-0.356372714,
-0.3462676704,
0.2822975516,
0.1418034136,
0.4635518491,
0.2972179949,
0.6884195209,
0.1802634299,
-0.6990324259,
0.0937851891,
0.1073957607,
-0.5815967917,
0.8255715966,
-0.8708155751,
0.2550706863,
-0.2101615071,
0.3100182414,
-1.0031237602,
-0.3938938677,
0.2677512467,
-0.4772648811,
0.2427267879,
0.2867122591,
-0.5034397244,
-0.2679131627,
-0.1207292527,
0.5128925443,
0.4089521766,
-0.0597809963,
0.27964136,
0.4362699687,
0.0142507376,
-0.3327462077,
-1.0022051334,
0.1630440503,
-0.3540615737,
-0.8021193743,
0.4998798072,
-0.0065987012,
-0.8781483173,
-0.02663102,
-0.4940853715,
-0.483242631,
0.4938727319,
0.2309173048,
0.3305389583,
-0.4627462626,
0.3869028091,
-0.2170465887,
0.2901957333,
0.4139695466,
-0.1764189154,
0.5325832963,
0.00007488,
-0.3730699718,
-0.3395700455,
0.2437423766,
0.5402062535,
-0.1948335469,
0.940420866,
0.3501277268,
-0.5669810772,
0.1432710141,
-0.4758518636,
-0.2305957079,
-0.3841342628,
0.7604565024,
-0.6318663955,
-0.9543296099,
0.6494196653,
0.1316656768,
-0.2899240553,
0.2675931454,
0.495716691,
-0.6968250275,
0.7233940363,
0.4813514054,
0.170825392,
0.547775209,
-0.1284612864,
0.0133164674,
-1.1553096771,
-0.397016257,
-0.6816795468,
-0.3699245453,
-0.4617771804,
-0.4231833816,
0.3199174106,
0.3253974617,
-0.3577087522,
0.0260118302,
-0.0285829548,
0.3465655148,
0.2949276567,
-0.1736007929,
0.419913739,
0.3543913662,
-0.3679442108,
-0.1169865578,
-0.5397948027,
-0.5212605,
0.80047822,
0.3960102499,
0.7098531723,
-0.0077634933,
0.4457606077,
0.1472293586,
0.2652158141,
-0.9894972444,
0.5624810457,
-0.0959460959,
-0.697183311,
-0.2994088829,
-0.4701345861,
-1.2366753817,
0.6106640697,
-0.2660019398,
-0.9672837853,
0.0556042418,
-0.0683385506,
-0.1900634021,
0.0884021223,
-0.7223594785,
0.5704945922,
0.0202048048,
-0.1207772866,
-0.3340505064,
-0.5452157855,
0.3428252637,
-0.1415719539,
0.1129713431,
-0.2463161796,
-0.1200924739,
0.9100138545,
-0.4111327827,
0.761514008,
0.1527343988,
-0.4662119448,
0.3364704251,
0.0721227676,
0.3164121211,
-0.0846206024,
0.0169703327,
0.3211245239,
0.0453871004,
-0.5550678968,
-0.624587059,
0.5916802287,
-0.8699811697,
-0.6297363043,
-0.4029637873,
-0.8417946696,
-0.1783914119,
0.0022222879,
0.2459801883,
0.3459664881,
-0.4677342772,
0.3099971116,
0.4319577813,
-0.0234024581,
0.4678998888,
0.3299231827,
-0.0006693694,
-0.092355676,
0.3390409946,
0.2021586448,
0.4571602345,
0.4904824495,
-0.001132026,
-0.3264682889,
-0.4548242986,
0.0900318101,
0.3273794949,
-0.601067245,
0.3343190551,
-0.4738765657,
-0.0155763812,
-0.2000947595,
0.1120792404,
-0.370632112,
-0.2789524794,
0.0971314907,
0.0473237857,
-0.0240780581,
0.9530413747,
0.2920039594,
0.2223954648,
-0.434273243,
0.189033255,
0.1498149931,
0.2881819606,
0.385437429,
-0.3201723397,
-0.4773134589,
0.3069444597,
-0.1147346199,
-0.7641293406,
-0.0133687072,
0.0637939125,
0.4662438333,
0.1315956116,
-0.1607174426,
0.8718233705,
-0.4696394801,
0.6656242609,
0.3808884025,
-0.8429114223,
0.0666617006,
-0.1480072141,
0.4829361141,
0.1868460178,
0.2199889868,
-0.8086562753,
-0.2709682286,
-0.3394598365,
-0.512822926,
0.5016770363,
0.4306460619,
0.1946070641,
-0.2763752341,
0.5928550959,
-0.2111779898,
0.0519588254,
-0.4557130635,
-0.1872918904,
0.1757395864,
-0.2025285065,
-0.2916361392,
0.1125846431,
-0.1651261598,
-0.2975191474,
-0.1286578625,
-0.1712593287,
0.4900514483,
0.3964200914,
-0.2845631242,
-0.0891500264,
0.1259482801,
0.5249375105,
0.5830857754,
-0.0523464195,
0.4557953477,
0.3362582028,
-0.7577162981,
0.2705111206,
-0.1491296291,
0.0374884643,
-0.2714967728,
0.8610110283,
0.7221068144,
0.3985722661,
-0.4220820963,
0.2496058196,
-0.2446435988,
-0.1060090512,
-0.5575481653,
0.0328277089,
0.7673614025,
0.5494256616,
0.1181836948,
0.2418508679,
-0.2749976814,
-0.6828770041,
-0.2047757804,
0.6532358527,
-0.1853453964,
-0.7670567036,
0.54848212,
-0.0067885616,
-0.2685563266,
0.8301103115,
-0.1474320441,
-0.1910553575,
0.6869539022,
0.563955009,
0.8990920782,
0.157957837,
0.0435481891,
0.0154103749,
0.1142244786,
-0.2607915998,
0.126433447,
-0.1768992692,
-1.2226963043,
-0.6978954077,
-0.6581657529,
-0.0483320802,
-0.0164743233,
-0.7067716718,
-0.0687513575,
-0.2353430986,
-0.3350961804,
0.0361970142,
0.1998032928,
-0.7391044497,
0.1564749032,
0.3898129463,
0.8653892279,
-0.6512518525,
1.108779788,
1.1318881512,
-0.4266699255,
-0.8854878545,
0.3953730762,
-0.154549554,
-0.5308068991,
1.002867341,
-0.0440467447,
-0.3133634925,
-0.2804037929,
-0.5840079188,
-1.0464550257,
1.1280510426,
0.5114144683,
-0.3475034237,
-0.4244627357,
0.0366213769,
0.8165408969,
-0.3843210638,
-0.0511165857,
0.3810595572,
0.1982510686,
0.2124285698,
-1.0354150534,
0.0539004691,
0.002980401,
0.147014007,
0.2217031121,
-0.5422055721,
1.0919349194,
-0.0199220199,
-0.3497818708,
0.2027630359,
0.8989235163,
0.3979849815,
0.188642323,
0.5089221597,
0.3682020605,
0.9414049983,
0.0199853778,
1.1336131096,
-0.0565916486,
0.3408638239,
1.1276208162,
-0.2089214176,
1.0172126293,
0.4457651079,
-0.3840878308,
0.5671825409,
0.5768618584,
0.3293812871,
0.2076319456,
0.3938701451,
0.1041027382,
-0.269741267,
-0.093849428,
-0.2486258298,
0.7319831252,
0.6041423082,
-0.0473886877,
-0.0245224591,
-0.3810857832,
0.1572720557,
0.0577628426,
-0.0975456163,
0.549904108,
0.5823075175,
-0.8298866749,
0.7287321687,
0.0370438099,
0.7417078018,
-0.4751877189,
0.31529513,
-0.1419570297,
0.1325272918,
0.0472193547,
-0.6606689095,
0.5087621808,
-0.080265604,
-0.1309840977,
0.1774799228,
0.7109606862,
-0.402364403,
-0.1729259938,
0.4748921394,
0.8091105223,
0.2194744498,
-0.210422948,
-0.5815497041,
0.1161975265,
-0.5737551451,
-0.137777552,
0.2397871614,
0.2682034969,
-0.5829490423,
0.5838916302,
0.3384502232,
0.2089316845,
0.0312824138,
-0.1069353446,
0.549502492,
-0.8509461284,
-0.3718290925,
-1.1604835987,
0.0046283789,
-0.1784153134,
-0.2341588885,
0.6481887698,
0.1257545799,
1.1261225939,
0.1097498909,
0.4741643071,
-0.031848453,
-0.0297925491,
-0.4031740427,
0.6463065147,
-0.7190869451,
0.1370798945,
-0.326433599,
-1.0266139507,
-0.3848601282,
0.8280206323,
-0.355121851,
0.0158126205,
0.993742466,
0.4474489093,
-0.0217767563,
0.0310297515,
0.3654119372,
0.4396539927,
0.176682055,
0.2370198369,
1.1708308458,
0.0674277171,
0.0626710802,
0.0358207114,
0.1827486306,
0.0090802405,
-0.5715045333,
-1.0615350008,
-0.6431350112,
-0.1153952181,
-0.2415749133,
-0.0793471932,
1.1775679588,
0.8369240165,
-0.6447408795,
-0.6179069877,
-0.0407222658,
0.1556295902,
-0.1299849302,
-0.1431846172,
0.4685038626,
-0.117375426,
-0.7536262274,
0.3544746339,
0.3199638128,
0.0396434255,
-0.586871326,
-0.2025942504,
-0.2833178341,
0.1072027087,
0.676276803,
0.0050734999,
-0.9481807947,
-0.5026624203,
0.2242056131,
-0.3241523206,
0.1683647186,
0.5846382976,
-0.683907032,
0.2722757161,
0.7031704783,
0.3910792768,
0.2813372016,
-0.3693619967,
0.7948975563,
-0.9153757095,
0.338183403,
0.066328451,
0.4387629926,
0.4189386368,
0.058817815,
0.3382739127,
0.3296069801,
-0.0435015261,
-0.6182281971,
0.5936211348,
-0.7005556822,
-0.5427357554,
0.6827977896,
-0.2128127813,
-0.5591689944,
-0.1859600097,
0.1695813984,
0.4061772525,
-0.2520874441,
0.800126195,
1.1733480692,
-0.1374039352,
0.2928124964,
-0.5744328499,
0.2478756905,
0.5047010183,
-0.6371287107,
-0.4223182499,
0.1912424564,
0.4849335849,
0.4647242427,
0.6421480179,
-0.0223127529,
0.0044575073,
-0.1171944439,
-0.0695196316,
0.3860707283,
-0.1405310929,
-0.1987540871,
0.2927939892,
0.2519335747,
-0.1427333504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02739v1 | Bengali Fake Review Detection using Semi-supervised Generative Adversarial Networks | 2023-04-05T20:40:09 | 2023-04-05T20:40:09 | Md. Tanvir Rouf Shawon, G. M. Shahariar, Faisal Muhammad Shah, Mohammad Shafiul Alam, Md. Shahriar Mahbub | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper investigates the potential of semi-supervised Generative
Adversarial Networks (GANs) to fine-tune pretrained language models in order to
classify Bengali fake reviews from real reviews with a few annotated data. With
the rise of social media and e-commerce, the ability to detect fake or
deceptive reviews is becoming increasingly important in order to protect
consumers from being misled by false information. Any machine learning model
will have trouble identifying a fake review, especially for a low resource
language like Bengali. We have demonstrated that the proposed semi-supervised
GAN-LM architecture (generative adversarial network on top of a pretrained
language model) is a viable solution in classifying Bengali fake reviews as the
experimental results suggest that even with only 1024 annotated samples,
BanglaBERT with semi-supervised GAN (SSGAN) achieved an accuracy of 83.59% and
a f1-score of 84.89% outperforming other pretrained language models -
BanglaBERT generator, Bangla BERT Base and Bangla-Electra by almost 3%, 4% and
10% respectively in terms of accuracy. The experiments were conducted on a
manually labeled food review dataset consisting of total 6014 real and fake
reviews collected from various social media groups. Researchers that are
experiencing difficulty recognizing not just fake reviews but other
classification issues owing to a lack of labeled data may find a solution in
our proposed methodology. | [
-0.2727402151,
-1.1385455132,
0.067520991,
0.3313154578,
-0.3008558154,
0.1752414107,
0.1442836076,
-0.5531269312,
0.40745309,
0.3716110289,
-0.0499980673,
-0.4020701051,
-0.5022526979,
0.1990054697,
-0.6740341187,
1.3388137817,
0.0442142636,
0.5949891806,
0.2520821989,
-0.0511277355,
0.0702927411,
-0.2997333109,
-0.7477146983,
-0.048991207,
0.3367086947,
-0.3607876301,
0.6694480181,
-0.0384953916,
-0.1096455604,
0.3283153176,
-0.3121300638,
0.8254733086,
-0.1482404172,
-0.2393653542,
-0.0590496548,
-0.5133892894,
-0.3574932516,
0.0713580102,
0.3987221718,
0.1609674841,
-0.0224337447,
0.193220526,
0.0927974209,
0.7930074334,
-0.4194089174,
0.2321033031,
-0.4394366443,
0.3129177392,
-0.1190750971,
-0.1684191823,
-0.3630335629,
-0.7097828388,
-0.2858790457,
-0.6439130306,
0.4838764071,
0.2974710763,
1.1755415201,
0.0880911127,
-0.2697896063,
-0.3360386789,
-1.0049495697,
0.4127616882,
-0.7574772239,
0.0378476642,
0.3829126358,
0.4464202523,
-0.0326613188,
-0.3862240016,
-1.0638952255,
-0.1966810673,
-0.1500743926,
0.3888169229,
-0.1612171233,
-0.1645828784,
0.0666658133,
0.6140707731,
-0.714496851,
-0.193220377,
-0.6982845664,
-0.2109730989,
0.6325742006,
-0.1949770749,
0.5506433249,
-0.4241749942,
-0.5810043216,
-0.0246839486,
-0.7669507265,
-0.1469950527,
0.7636476755,
0.1959056407,
-0.1158959642,
0.537019074,
-0.4354222119,
0.9845337868,
0.119255878,
0.1741179228,
0.2260305732,
-0.5589613914,
-0.6386914849,
0.0986248478,
0.9720286131,
0.1853947937,
0.5471587181,
0.1753645986,
-0.5277436376,
0.414467752,
0.5815612674,
-0.3094143271,
-0.3896689117,
-0.1681350172,
-0.530053854,
-0.7355340719,
0.0280858465,
-0.7526463866,
-0.616751492,
-0.2676722407,
0.548661232,
-0.1124647707,
-0.2580420077,
-0.0008873679,
0.0162759572,
0.0143137127,
0.3421157002,
-0.4813359082,
0.0598308891,
0.4001828134,
0.8150800467,
0.1312148124,
-0.170908317,
-0.1693552881,
-0.0292985961,
-0.6411008239,
0.9163440466,
-0.1823995113,
-0.1028820798,
0.311899066,
0.0979260206,
0.1004772633,
-0.6872417927,
0.5767639875,
-0.9879959226,
0.0828349516,
-0.0517921522,
-0.3523957133,
-0.3167835176,
0.8675588965,
-0.7097452283,
0.785817802,
0.1197639406,
-0.6525735855,
0.4301972687,
-0.203464672,
-0.7790252566,
0.3334397078,
-0.0256808065,
-0.70033288,
0.2622737586,
0.519212544,
0.4886049628,
-0.0113212559,
0.2628948987,
-0.3546279073,
-0.5658484101,
0.3457280099,
-0.7437349558,
1.1177426577,
0.3668680489,
-0.2809977233,
0.3364602029,
-0.6442595124,
0.0258076321,
0.2062308192,
-0.3379710913,
-0.2292311639,
-0.4093085229,
0.2369063348,
-0.0405725241,
-0.1442059875,
-0.4052578807,
0.2566993535,
-0.4952940643,
0.1135611832,
0.7129089236,
0.0951767564,
0.2167594433,
-0.3561924994,
0.6479925513,
0.0896064341,
0.2875677347,
0.1579177529,
-0.4385028481,
-0.8793613911,
0.0932331607,
0.6701892018,
0.3435743451,
-1.2907301188,
0.573574245,
-0.2539163828,
-0.4082765877,
-0.9326894283,
0.0613965355,
0.5999125242,
0.2434086949,
0.3834092617,
-0.1454217881,
-0.4364193678,
-0.9621785283,
-0.4042011499,
-0.3650576472,
0.0185180362,
-0.0812251717,
0.311190933,
-0.3122314215,
0.569573462,
-0.2686359286,
-0.7166351676,
-0.5083658099,
0.4189191163,
-0.1785744578,
0.0657394752,
0.5005294681,
-1.2275867462,
-0.8846902847,
-0.0066420049,
-0.5741453767,
-0.0339131691,
-0.1937533468,
0.2420940846,
0.6513630748,
0.1024478599,
-0.3701340556,
0.6664417982,
0.5976284742,
0.1591362804,
0.8944405913,
-0.2576149106,
0.4238981903,
-1.1697093248,
-0.3130969107,
0.3823857903,
-0.2121090442,
-0.410169363,
-0.2796371877,
0.0084742894,
-0.0898152813,
-0.3932584524,
0.603043735,
-0.5269873738,
-0.065928556,
-0.2938651145,
-0.1854600608,
0.1807101071,
0.5403789282,
0.081580855,
0.7795423269,
0.3601595163,
-0.561021328,
0.7870895863,
0.1891397238,
-0.9413758516,
0.3546248674,
-0.5509578586,
-0.0862439722,
-0.1116709784,
0.5538550615,
-1.0513746738,
-0.2637573779,
0.5135706067,
-0.7687352896,
0.435405612,
-0.4397088587,
-0.9481607676,
-0.4135024846,
-0.1371314228,
0.028863702,
0.2780071497,
-0.7790359855,
0.4400927126,
0.4474006593,
0.1764025986,
-0.2990043759,
-0.9270769954,
0.0004369308,
0.2107504904,
-0.3987984955,
0.0678334087,
0.0365344845,
0.0211960599,
0.1181863397,
-0.1328220665,
0.0330382288,
-0.3358713984,
0.0017534345,
0.1799406856,
0.135236457,
-0.1855776012,
-0.0247079041,
0.0903479308,
-0.0404635444,
-0.1363962293,
0.421652019,
-0.3191407621,
-0.0743877888,
-0.534188211,
-0.0405291766,
0.5499468446,
-0.050597813,
0.7226638794,
0.8732152581,
-0.4377514422,
-0.7405231595,
-0.4578664005,
0.0907232389,
-0.4198391438,
0.3455601931,
-0.1364424527,
-0.3554076254,
0.1896773726,
0.329159081,
-0.5549809933,
0.1274438351,
0.6578672528,
-0.2605993748,
1.0889692307,
0.2722249925,
-0.2363832295,
0.4900352657,
-0.2199122459,
0.7716343999,
-0.6730076075,
-0.3429763317,
-0.1254406869,
-0.2382355481,
-0.6392459273,
-0.3442534506,
0.4808061123,
-0.0069384268,
0.1580445766,
0.2206682712,
-0.7852860689,
0.4013301134,
0.5254791975,
0.2395062745,
0.0412089415,
0.2413213849,
-0.1045909524,
0.3176286221,
-0.5408576131,
-0.5855972171,
0.8176103234,
0.1536699384,
0.8867487907,
-0.1022365838,
0.0551469065,
0.8304324746,
0.6891330481,
-0.6456696987,
0.6473992467,
-0.1313277036,
-0.9708998799,
0.0182993617,
-0.4609633088,
-0.3601251245,
0.0329882428,
-0.17160891,
-0.0466205068,
-0.1509235352,
0.1941313148,
-0.4001982808,
0.5590915084,
-0.967928648,
0.6707628965,
-0.7174192667,
-0.3319782317,
0.2349825054,
-0.5785839558,
0.4951791167,
0.0377370641,
0.0782895014,
0.2474469543,
0.6354625225,
0.90556252,
-0.3413461447,
1.0166962147,
-0.2487421036,
0.0144728385,
0.5173717141,
0.2444369197,
0.4572714269,
0.1312450022,
0.2784536779,
0.173414439,
-0.1880117208,
-0.4114407003,
-0.6779420972,
0.8173436522,
-0.7822089195,
-0.4458420873,
-0.8464771509,
-0.1687183678,
-0.4140401781,
0.2452523112,
0.3010593355,
0.109012492,
0.0730673149,
0.0632014722,
0.499379456,
-0.2075437158,
0.1748443842,
0.5379796624,
-0.2768265307,
-0.6170968413,
0.9283476472,
0.3106912673,
-0.0654075965,
0.2864374518,
0.1118958071,
-0.5209978819,
-0.7268212438,
-0.8984209895,
0.0834752768,
-0.4055115581,
-0.3088483512,
-0.520409286,
-0.4608333409,
-0.552731812,
0.1610305607,
-0.405415982,
0.149359867,
-0.2340817899,
-0.320700109,
0.0062003797,
1.020550251,
0.1035534143,
0.2491853982,
-0.7709538341,
0.5979703665,
0.1559012085,
0.3954806924,
0.1769039482,
-0.5946351886,
-0.3722544014,
0.3829607069,
-0.2038513571,
-1.0003410578,
0.7072506547,
-0.3468438685,
0.2341002971,
0.639511168,
0.1178058013,
0.6954354048,
-0.0448452607,
0.8691022396,
0.1356561333,
-0.6859173179,
0.4153222442,
-0.4105727673,
0.0138198398,
0.290325582,
0.7665114403,
-0.3255678415,
-0.098731406,
-0.3383187354,
-0.4852435291,
0.5621473193,
0.0973084718,
0.0736217052,
0.0733079314,
0.0482453331,
0.0058295629,
0.4578569531,
-1.1840438843,
-0.3210049272,
-0.2544802725,
0.0594098382,
-0.0612179413,
-0.5552186966,
-0.1048000157,
-0.3083972037,
0.9765813351,
0.1519944519,
0.1450228244,
0.0164363571,
0.0520787053,
-0.1269974262,
0.3110386431,
0.726396203,
0.5302703977,
-0.0868364349,
0.0726943016,
-0.1624006182,
-0.1961048841,
0.1399368644,
0.0006090023,
-0.7498989105,
0.0683739185,
0.3428845704,
0.7603927255,
-0.250747472,
-0.2463958859,
0.6067236066,
-0.1447255909,
-0.0131093021,
-0.5413562059,
-0.2483451813,
-0.1548961848,
-0.0902300254,
0.2847222984,
0.7055280209,
0.0965437219,
-0.709998548,
0.1447956711,
0.3604765832,
-0.5512860417,
-0.6490809321,
0.4378753304,
0.2911659777,
-0.3621487916,
0.5088516474,
-0.7888233662,
-1.179304719,
0.282910496,
0.5402120352,
0.744397521,
-0.2429159433,
0.6316666603,
0.225669682,
0.4939615428,
-0.2569064796,
-0.027045317,
-0.1965774149,
-0.8737428188,
-0.0940010995,
-1.0858240128,
-0.1116259694,
0.6103855371,
-0.5324527621,
0.3110796809,
-0.5344087481,
0.1952489913,
-0.0801330507,
0.060413558,
-0.2214990854,
0.7819731236,
0.2855718136,
0.4090666771,
-1.3325133324,
0.8442050219,
0.87959373,
-0.6658964157,
-0.8027688861,
0.2390033752,
0.2021335214,
-0.6073423028,
0.6077131033,
0.0890277624,
-0.2813552916,
-0.4193886518,
-0.3833905756,
-0.218851611,
0.3488066196,
-0.0892260149,
-0.5243614912,
0.0453157388,
-0.0364162587,
1.1040999889,
-0.1002760604,
0.2610196769,
0.1366117299,
0.4037041068,
0.1582598239,
-0.4617793262,
-0.2217085063,
-0.6477169394,
0.06746687,
-0.1274621338,
-0.8234276772,
0.5956506133,
0.0323705599,
-0.3331891298,
-0.013235948,
0.6518514752,
0.1935502142,
0.5900197625,
0.4742096961,
0.6301124096,
0.319111377,
-0.1274546832,
1.214035511,
0.0680615604,
0.4206897318,
0.888522923,
-0.3619052172,
0.6066691279,
0.1305098832,
-0.321364969,
0.2049653232,
1.0026092529,
-0.3046069443,
0.5345677733,
0.5174429417,
-0.2403459996,
-0.071783632,
-0.0857445076,
-0.2563547492,
0.1923177242,
0.2429808527,
-0.3182551265,
0.0460477695,
0.1717494875,
-0.1336924881,
0.2143315822,
-0.3522848785,
0.6254972219,
-0.1049636304,
-0.678847909,
0.6409602761,
0.0217148997,
0.8007755876,
-0.5264838338,
-0.0772722736,
-0.2209904939,
0.2639066875,
-0.3828897774,
-0.6374670267,
0.4857990146,
0.107218951,
-0.3669821322,
-0.5153085589,
0.7084138393,
-0.4646812975,
-0.8822507262,
0.4776852727,
0.2328670025,
0.0673192963,
-0.0607301295,
-0.6422441006,
0.2055385858,
0.2215827107,
-0.2995491624,
0.1520575136,
0.1952653229,
0.0305817928,
0.3868124485,
0.7242718339,
0.6201672554,
0.349987179,
0.1563877463,
0.5774335265,
-0.2894868851,
-0.7540026903,
-0.5191956758,
0.029949544,
-0.2241820842,
-0.1170736998,
0.9975258112,
0.7940872312,
1.4220404625,
-0.5401175618,
1.0006610155,
-0.0127417454,
0.6731210351,
-0.5228002071,
1.3407486677,
-0.73938483,
0.4309029877,
0.0293594003,
-0.888163209,
-0.340831846,
0.4915982485,
-0.5236512423,
0.5215280652,
0.5920581818,
1.0626707077,
-0.0957872421,
0.0620359331,
0.5119781494,
0.4637387395,
0.1996628344,
0.0746755451,
1.0228773355,
-0.6782463789,
0.609875083,
-0.1402053088,
-0.0023140463,
-0.3683799803,
-0.3401792347,
-0.9928512573,
-0.5338278413,
-0.4670792818,
-0.6524558067,
0.2069706321,
0.4059986472,
0.8591831326,
-1.0955630541,
0.291757077,
-0.1822145581,
0.0778492838,
-0.2585879862,
-0.3032995164,
0.5240556002,
0.0006881435,
-1.0322781801,
0.5197970867,
0.2256119847,
0.181410253,
-0.5055964589,
0.0920110047,
-0.4240560234,
0.0918407664,
0.336497575,
0.2492170632,
-0.8607669473,
0.033338815,
-0.4368173778,
-0.2346111983,
-0.1341194063,
0.6627423763,
-0.6473315954,
0.859918654,
0.5667476058,
0.6636352539,
0.5733408332,
0.2907033861,
0.2060205936,
-0.9024685621,
-0.2608532012,
0.3436705172,
0.275624007,
0.5232331753,
-0.3132762015,
0.2636293471,
0.4786183536,
-0.3788132071,
-0.8963218927,
0.1265841126,
-1.0438238382,
-0.1466267258,
1.2996656895,
-0.2875805199,
-0.6167365313,
-0.1603111476,
-0.2061739415,
0.4261710048,
-0.0398540385,
1.2802903652,
0.611931324,
0.1368317753,
0.0312421154,
-0.2910682559,
0.7682414055,
0.4525828958,
-0.8245853782,
-0.2466998845,
0.3070580065,
0.3207366168,
0.4133924246,
0.5129939318,
-0.1485148519,
0.2914144993,
-0.1042413339,
-0.1511055976,
-0.4129217267,
-0.6305180192,
-0.425801754,
0.3329091966,
-0.4727907479,
-0.4591094851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02738v1 | Core Challenges in Embodied Vision-Language Planning | 2023-04-05T20:37:13 | 2023-04-05T20:37:13 | Jonathan Francis, Nariaki Kitamura, Felix Labelle, Xiaopeng Lu, Ingrid Navarro, Jean Oh | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC | Recent advances in the areas of Multimodal Machine Learning and Artificial
Intelligence (AI) have led to the development of challenging tasks at the
intersection of Computer Vision, Natural Language Processing, and Robotics.
Whereas many approaches and previous survey pursuits have characterised one or
two of these dimensions, there has not been a holistic analysis at the center
of all three. Moreover, even when combinations of these topics are considered,
more focus is placed on describing, e.g., current architectural methods, as
opposed to also illustrating high-level challenges and opportunities for the
field. In this survey paper, we discuss Embodied Vision-Language Planning
(EVLP) tasks, a family of prominent embodied navigation and manipulation
problems that jointly leverage computer vision and natural language for
interaction in physical environments. We propose a taxonomy to unify these
tasks and provide an in-depth analysis and comparison of the current and new
algorithmic approaches, metrics, simulators, and datasets used for EVLP tasks.
Finally, we present the core challenges that we believe new EVLP works should
seek to address, and we advocate for task construction that enables model
generalisability and furthers real-world deployment. | [
-0.5036801696,
-0.7868177295,
0.6448680162,
-0.0040211412,
-0.0329750255,
-0.0172969382,
0.1672289222,
-0.8990746737,
0.1502440572,
0.6139128208,
-0.7564590573,
-0.3443039954,
-0.6174548268,
-0.0310428701,
-0.1558686495,
0.1308406889,
-0.3133569658,
-0.2779251039,
-0.1677139997,
-0.3740681112,
-0.6481966376,
-0.6472402215,
-0.3938051462,
-0.1818170846,
0.333163619,
0.304479152,
0.8227337003,
0.1137285307,
0.574282527,
0.2687851787,
0.0346246436,
0.6198846698,
0.3382362723,
0.2058476359,
-0.0768152699,
-0.0775816292,
-0.4949166477,
-0.2242743075,
0.53536731,
0.9548972249,
-0.0024489164,
0.1024038419,
-0.0672307685,
0.6480668187,
-0.9018468261,
0.3053961098,
-0.3545704484,
0.6212513447,
0.0677540153,
-0.0252214149,
0.0252146833,
0.5116381645,
0.2832180858,
-0.505328238,
0.0242216382,
0.3585058749,
0.6653636098,
0.4526816905,
-0.3730072975,
-0.2620250285,
-0.8536023498,
0.544003427,
-0.4501622319,
0.3659915626,
0.2493259013,
0.2300908566,
-0.0815738589,
-0.3118067384,
-0.7617112994,
-0.1443489194,
0.0805210769,
0.0790768936,
-0.3278106451,
0.3388986588,
0.2713134885,
0.0379033126,
-0.6573257446,
0.3113631606,
-0.2787959278,
-0.0352074802,
0.7153710723,
0.4093950093,
0.7326058149,
-0.2174191028,
-0.180656448,
-0.1937092394,
-0.7294252515,
0.0519552231,
0.2483140081,
0.2889065146,
-0.1474915445,
1.0710294247,
-0.1943717748,
0.9595254064,
-0.3173052371,
0.2790344656,
-0.0277401712,
-0.3181342781,
-0.1989976466,
-0.0933986157,
0.4390572608,
0.442442745,
-0.0319064818,
-0.0160689242,
-0.3546711504,
0.0380267687,
0.5683255196,
-0.0544342101,
0.0387735926,
0.4591152966,
-0.3031043112,
0.0339279957,
-0.3007537425,
-0.7149537802,
-0.2728936374,
-0.7803442478,
0.4843148291,
-0.3283211887,
-0.2438915521,
0.2858705521,
-0.25489676,
0.6880414486,
0.6168138385,
-1.0550096035,
0.2934242189,
0.7765452266,
0.7387960553,
0.0807926655,
-0.407980442,
-0.1501772851,
0.4345452189,
-0.3065732419,
0.8466528654,
-0.5259682536,
-0.5193645358,
0.1456619799,
-0.2375106514,
-0.1683189273,
-0.4003839195,
0.4220059514,
0.2297718674,
0.2806405723,
-0.2970755994,
-0.1498385519,
-0.2303793728,
0.6555938721,
-0.6197818518,
1.0586653948,
0.0107969772,
-0.4177393913,
0.5707903504,
-0.7649999857,
-0.6675884724,
0.3160023093,
-0.4664492011,
-0.083871834,
0.1546830386,
0.3322373629,
0.6010662913,
-0.0705265626,
0.0959273577,
0.2394588739,
-0.0771588162,
-0.5050887465,
0.1077753976,
0.4303743243,
0.0228838604,
-0.7343310714,
0.3230648339,
-0.6303057075,
0.0053020283,
0.0796710253,
0.0924557075,
-0.1890075505,
0.7078357339,
0.2163241059,
0.268106997,
0.3450971842,
-0.3361292183,
0.4129757285,
-0.4366928935,
0.3558223546,
0.6744143963,
-0.39584741,
0.77808249,
-0.3056022823,
0.5964978337,
-0.3093663454,
0.5241097808,
-0.2294288576,
-0.8269631267,
-0.8105762005,
-0.0397984795,
-0.8229619265,
0.5247402191,
-1.043821454,
0.4127818644,
-0.2269317359,
-0.6302034259,
-0.3243591189,
-0.1917796582,
0.4091306329,
0.2595429718,
0.5116393566,
-0.3096724153,
-0.2789136171,
-0.9863737822,
-0.0579963326,
-0.4413269758,
0.0928789303,
0.5794680119,
0.6539191008,
-0.1862500161,
0.8751407266,
-0.3567354083,
-0.5644347668,
-0.5085830688,
0.442546159,
-0.0832908154,
0.4322375357,
0.5659656525,
-1.3977150917,
-0.1982631981,
0.3267121315,
-0.6838123202,
0.0023458295,
-0.2985362113,
0.1463013589,
0.2340967506,
0.1302779466,
-0.7802509665,
0.479870677,
0.6118391156,
-0.2792890668,
0.5935099125,
-0.4433671832,
0.1016377136,
-0.693770647,
0.2362649292,
-0.1129007712,
0.2273061424,
-0.925532043,
0.7945687771,
-0.2265358865,
-0.2906656563,
-0.6122357249,
0.7459899187,
-0.7312089801,
-0.4722170234,
-0.178038463,
-0.0747426599,
-0.1286678761,
0.5720432401,
0.464885056,
0.4544433355,
0.6138285995,
-0.817314446,
0.5815072656,
0.4050672054,
-0.1698757857,
0.4756674469,
-0.6097558737,
0.3051434755,
-0.1484386921,
0.1226045862,
-0.763025701,
-0.3048295975,
0.5403610468,
-0.3029984534,
0.3719109297,
-0.0010015185,
-0.5782677531,
-0.575612843,
-0.1892989278,
0.3970040679,
0.3784312308,
-0.3126311898,
1.4092329741,
0.4874521792,
-0.0322390646,
-0.5638436675,
-0.6509100795,
0.4200022519,
-0.0428254269,
-0.7717856169,
0.6694380045,
0.2296328992,
-0.3902910948,
0.0315637887,
-0.0963298082,
-0.0605443008,
0.0271260701,
0.3693800867,
0.3779853284,
0.2441365719,
-0.2886662781,
-0.2165353596,
-0.0819768757,
0.049465064,
-0.2362581491,
0.4729990661,
0.0275584664,
-0.7981820703,
-0.1709034443,
0.6162481308,
0.517655611,
-0.3186815977,
0.336763978,
0.3102632761,
-0.449101299,
-0.0439794026,
-0.5246120691,
0.2947236001,
-0.4425831735,
0.4001058638,
-0.3429520428,
-0.7566504478,
0.3638105989,
0.1214429513,
0.5913727283,
0.2388427407,
0.4881553352,
-0.338950485,
0.9817575812,
0.8198062778,
0.1947798729,
0.2687962055,
-0.1216365546,
0.4388006032,
-0.9940009117,
-0.7439133525,
-0.5131935477,
-0.7119135857,
-0.233221069,
-0.7872231603,
0.4193543792,
-0.7239779234,
-0.0284087602,
0.601112783,
-0.6365025043,
-0.0269951168,
0.4857425988,
-0.1707042605,
0.0101081636,
-0.222458005,
-0.089671053,
0.0308525041,
-0.6651989222,
-0.5779009461,
0.5564651489,
-0.1140135676,
0.5921489596,
-0.0392572656,
0.4393258393,
-0.0410116464,
-0.3639740944,
-0.7031448483,
0.8925437331,
-0.0632691309,
-0.6847677827,
-0.4568614066,
-0.087142311,
-0.8690504432,
0.4745399058,
-0.3650262654,
-0.7975845337,
0.2746031284,
0.2267332673,
-0.1313523799,
0.627524972,
-0.5098538399,
0.5847774744,
-0.7589919567,
-0.4484381676,
-0.2807098031,
-0.841763854,
-0.033076413,
0.3406946063,
0.3600079715,
-0.2622925937,
-0.0491191559,
0.2465291172,
0.1227899566,
0.7883968353,
-0.1856510639,
-0.0867288113,
0.3086682856,
-0.0092794197,
0.3680072427,
-0.6878800988,
0.4568192363,
0.0865254775,
-0.1302443445,
-0.3206666708,
-0.3413963318,
0.1063312814,
-0.4347429276,
-0.5762446523,
-0.4814378619,
-0.3286144733,
-0.365485698,
-0.0758642629,
0.1614378691,
0.4606812,
-0.4681665301,
-0.2357397377,
0.625505507,
-0.7574578524,
0.5921571851,
0.1196223497,
-0.2600695193,
0.1630691588,
0.6954674125,
0.0656325072,
0.3007222712,
0.8457601666,
-0.1686740667,
-0.2279764414,
-0.6137539148,
-0.4627916515,
-0.2114896625,
-0.4196085036,
0.2980077863,
-0.6345722079,
-0.2269306481,
-0.3878643215,
-0.5643934608,
-0.4925513864,
-0.3141647577,
-0.0934871882,
0.0236296225,
-0.2472592145,
0.8517093658,
-0.0216109958,
-0.0325603522,
-0.7860639691,
0.6649089456,
0.4055180848,
-0.0069981338,
0.1021892279,
0.0702389926,
0.0747874454,
0.1106740609,
-0.1930478364,
-0.5501391292,
0.6267673373,
0.2957009375,
0.7648596764,
0.3006274104,
0.0701540187,
0.8525929451,
-0.7072703242,
1.1189368963,
0.310026139,
-0.5146506429,
0.9244810939,
-0.1567229927,
0.358615011,
0.2968463302,
0.4414995313,
-0.7109209299,
-0.332058847,
-0.5247790217,
-1.2505202293,
0.1636258066,
0.3234125972,
0.324988991,
0.1578984261,
0.1341068596,
-0.0531669185,
0.1849315464,
-0.5427851677,
0.062448848,
0.0900231302,
0.1064821333,
0.04761618,
-0.1375360191,
0.0003038557,
-0.3844316006,
0.1858201325,
-0.246963501,
0.3975018263,
0.1923684776,
-0.2437976599,
0.0923137814,
0.1993178129,
0.5854891539,
0.3972342014,
0.019323254,
0.0587311573,
-0.0075419317,
-0.4252108335,
-0.0886119306,
-0.2202614546,
-0.1306380033,
-0.184990108,
0.6989485621,
0.7818402052,
0.644254148,
-0.9995571375,
0.289639473,
0.2535717785,
-0.390611738,
-0.5320461392,
0.0036785244,
-0.2999816537,
0.1601654291,
0.5600096583,
0.121368669,
0.1728008837,
-0.8757942915,
-0.2118092328,
0.5956293344,
-0.5479974747,
-0.5242493749,
0.7284177542,
0.294623822,
-0.2429854572,
0.8181086779,
-0.0397515632,
-0.7868053317,
0.7242929935,
0.0565872565,
1.0776963234,
-0.0208148155,
0.2359078526,
0.2132122517,
0.7005593777,
0.1152454913,
0.500312686,
-0.2216555625,
-0.9915950298,
-0.3221122622,
-0.5175327659,
-0.7709210515,
-0.502705574,
-0.4149231911,
0.2241047174,
-0.4172984064,
0.0710890666,
-0.2513317466,
-0.2407290787,
-0.6219040155,
0.1390440762,
0.5857766867,
0.7394819856,
-0.6658430696,
0.2497173101,
1.2231496572,
-0.3194954693,
-0.3788521886,
-0.3219134808,
0.2685597837,
-0.9276586175,
0.6354953051,
0.1479835808,
-0.3656166196,
-0.2559230328,
-0.4436109066,
-0.4469967186,
1.0839463472,
-0.000161815,
-0.348708272,
-0.7285018563,
0.2920295894,
0.336283803,
-0.1856154054,
-0.1294085085,
0.1441996545,
0.8005831242,
0.2972643971,
-1.1844137907,
-0.3882265985,
-0.3183553517,
-0.1454841495,
0.4414072633,
-0.6331627965,
0.5865859389,
-0.2331495136,
-0.3327014744,
0.1015066877,
0.43467471,
-0.015387035,
0.3429106772,
0.540006578,
0.8310860395,
0.432169795,
-0.2277007401,
1.0700293779,
0.0088293748,
0.070610553,
0.8971310258,
-0.6924599409,
0.9454393983,
0.599370122,
-0.3308815956,
-0.0571265668,
0.4280471206,
-0.0218133572,
0.3957347572,
-0.0510819554,
-0.3990054131,
-0.271728009,
-0.019047942,
-0.1726625711,
0.7739419341,
0.512657702,
0.3003075719,
-0.2496772707,
0.3608322442,
-0.4597411752,
0.0031154437,
-0.4303060174,
0.7016595602,
0.0015263325,
-0.5415995717,
-0.3698115051,
-0.241600439,
0.6649643779,
-0.6760058999,
-0.3635515571,
0.1247921884,
-0.204000026,
-0.005533882,
-1.0369082689,
0.6600137353,
-0.3165126145,
0.2559837401,
-0.9045904875,
0.8604746461,
0.0076776864,
-0.2138787508,
0.3809174597,
0.4533905983,
-0.0799431056,
-0.3145722449,
-0.6351838708,
-0.0777141228,
-0.2797477841,
0.0530355163,
0.3648164272,
0.3077824414,
0.0215936713,
1.2168453932,
0.4504517615,
0.0198240466,
0.3292759359,
-0.2628302574,
0.7237039208,
-0.7403874993,
-0.4398492277,
-0.5748631358,
0.621741116,
0.025371613,
-0.3832888603,
0.3777637184,
0.4774506092,
0.7162337303,
-0.0321844555,
0.4581893384,
-0.5865691304,
-0.1026368961,
-0.7795804739,
0.4367720485,
-0.7008128762,
-0.0939112529,
-0.4369965494,
-0.9192445874,
-0.4124977291,
0.777820766,
-0.1539359391,
-0.127993986,
0.5213664174,
0.3720501661,
0.1299250722,
-0.1521755159,
0.5399832129,
-0.3071370423,
0.3969600499,
0.7547728419,
0.9856010079,
0.002642886,
-0.0990756899,
-0.3183885217,
-0.0225220304,
-0.2605935633,
-0.831555903,
-0.5304752588,
-1.1223958731,
-0.353153944,
0.3600862324,
0.0207789149,
0.9329683781,
0.7873020172,
-0.3584851623,
-0.2609223723,
-0.1657359451,
0.055110544,
-0.2834045291,
-0.1326878667,
0.0765621364,
-0.1168765575,
-0.8429118395,
0.504542768,
0.8070694208,
0.0925938189,
-0.4492477775,
0.0353162922,
-0.3005399108,
-0.3522618711,
0.8454361558,
0.6622997522,
-0.8588570356,
-0.5936800241,
0.0769229382,
0.1130949929,
-0.0791293532,
0.848071456,
-0.6714833975,
0.7336150408,
0.1966360658,
0.5699009299,
0.4776718915,
-0.2788387537,
0.7607371211,
-0.7374346852,
0.3940778971,
0.6770271659,
0.4868302941,
0.1710910797,
-0.2542459369,
0.7626166344,
-0.0143542346,
-0.2734276056,
-0.4594606757,
0.4728243947,
-1.3776391745,
-0.3334023356,
1.0096437931,
0.215213716,
-0.1813040674,
-0.2815721333,
-0.4336696863,
-0.1875571907,
0.3465197682,
0.5444992185,
0.8479603529,
-0.5321228504,
-0.5574948788,
-0.6900644898,
0.1657711715,
0.181597665,
-0.6942665577,
-0.0092816148,
0.7315246463,
-0.3963919878,
0.2649148405,
0.615095675,
0.0571511351,
0.2703506947,
-0.0329702906,
0.3976776302,
0.0344225578,
-0.5478771329,
0.0165012516,
0.2590459883,
-0.0667563677,
0.040688809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02721v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02721v3 | To Asymmetry and Beyond: Structured Pruning of Sequence to Sequence Models for Improved Inference Efficiency | 2023-04-05T19:44:20 | 2023-06-12T21:13:14 | Daniel Campos, ChengXiang Zhai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Sequence-to-sequence language models can be used to produce abstractive
summaries which are coherent, relevant, and concise. Still, model sizes can
make deployment in latency-sensitive or web-scale implementations difficult.
This paper studies the relationship between model size, structured pruning,
inference efficiency, and summarization accuracy on widely used summarization
datasets. We show that model accuracy is tied to the encoder size while
inference efficiency is connected to the decoder. Using asymmetric pruning can
lead to nearly 3x improvement in inference latency with ~1 point loss in
Rouge-2. Moreover, we find both the average degradation and the role of
asymmetry to be consistent across model sizes and variations in datasets. | [
-0.0718160793,
-0.3150887787,
0.4054318368,
0.3259254396,
-0.4295945466,
-0.077980198,
-0.1773287207,
-0.3972536623,
0.1701873094,
0.2466861755,
-0.2438955754,
-0.1810109317,
-0.4756820798,
0.2489749342,
-0.6220011711,
0.8588033319,
0.1803279072,
0.0995231196,
-0.1137077212,
0.0019074009,
0.0196347423,
-0.6346051693,
-0.3214125633,
-0.0938061103,
0.47362867,
0.11164736,
0.8324186802,
1.103599906,
0.6476415992,
0.2396953851,
-0.2442071736,
0.1209716126,
-0.3075613976,
0.2388748229,
0.1109769493,
-0.5953171849,
-0.629792273,
-0.2508327067,
0.9597899318,
1.1476826668,
-0.2778903842,
0.1348855346,
0.2270314097,
0.807069242,
-0.8113926649,
-0.0407553203,
-0.0794835538,
-0.2940908372,
0.0210683588,
-0.0191530008,
-0.4177022278,
-0.3425745368,
-0.0673376098,
-0.6853817701,
0.5333488584,
-0.2004766017,
0.8590505123,
0.5111066103,
-0.5276151896,
-0.1329580843,
-0.7705844641,
0.6966546774,
-1.2446733713,
0.4032411277,
0.3525839448,
0.2196220756,
0.2140718699,
-0.8093132973,
-0.254537493,
0.250888288,
-0.4082147479,
0.1477147043,
0.1128237844,
0.2506004274,
0.4585533142,
0.4556703866,
-0.6361733675,
0.1207934916,
-0.4629843831,
-0.0225171186,
1.052235961,
0.2020231485,
-0.0379406512,
-0.1130203977,
0.2072235048,
-0.0641599223,
-0.7837682366,
-0.0444443524,
0.7105590105,
0.2751907706,
-0.1063779518,
0.5614865422,
-0.2165384889,
0.9663257003,
-0.008759981,
-0.0888842642,
0.048937764,
-0.6578552723,
-0.1976436675,
-0.2294615656,
0.6201435328,
0.5448931456,
0.2428140193,
-0.0473994166,
-0.0774498507,
0.0795728937,
0.123251088,
-1.1485029459,
-0.4480539858,
0.4116259217,
-0.6527534723,
0.0312614031,
0.5099462867,
-0.6376608014,
-0.0278336424,
-0.0665542781,
0.0191466901,
-0.2896140516,
-0.212295875,
0.1641742438,
-0.6850894094,
0.1575294435,
0.5851644278,
-0.7488166094,
0.5052776933,
0.8282998204,
1.2824356556,
-0.1940359771,
-0.0056432779,
-0.3167364001,
0.0543159693,
-0.5984928608,
0.5694962144,
-0.3285228312,
-0.4144991636,
-0.2939164937,
-0.0473609306,
-0.078661643,
-0.488894999,
0.273160547,
-0.3713219166,
-0.1168323085,
-0.16369766,
-0.6052384377,
-0.3331939876,
0.0329029039,
-0.7275254726,
0.3326409459,
-0.0263142064,
-0.7119597793,
0.3114860058,
-0.2344749272,
-0.9261048436,
-0.3157812655,
-0.0611849874,
-0.7430198789,
0.5518568158,
0.050574068,
0.4039167762,
-0.290197283,
0.4104801714,
-0.1355907023,
-0.6090675592,
0.1277395934,
-0.2746382058,
0.9501332641,
0.3196036518,
0.1815388203,
0.0959478244,
-0.8644801378,
-0.038815327,
0.065512158,
-0.4339909852,
-0.3687888384,
0.3986622989,
-0.0714223161,
-0.0624961331,
-0.0676295459,
-0.2041627616,
-0.0357569791,
-0.6111853123,
0.6501775384,
0.2786793113,
0.1645767689,
0.6038091183,
-0.4690265357,
0.351913482,
-0.1240914762,
-0.1249870211,
-0.6509518027,
-0.3386871219,
-0.4799651802,
-0.4557410777,
0.4605546296,
0.4010607302,
-0.3507413566,
0.4609404206,
-0.5237799287,
-0.4549494982,
-0.2092721313,
-0.3463212252,
0.3690498769,
0.3372143507,
0.2941031456,
-0.5466068387,
-0.3610788882,
-0.7024026513,
-0.5276838541,
-0.2200818956,
-0.7311835289,
0.0693708509,
0.3480321169,
0.1740151346,
0.7950200438,
-0.4511956871,
0.1925209016,
-0.4751270711,
-0.0399252027,
0.327666223,
0.6028781533,
0.2581398487,
-0.778450191,
-0.4168993533,
-0.3001978099,
-0.5095152259,
-0.1914758086,
-0.0099539012,
0.3346418738,
0.1531599313,
0.3611851633,
-0.6876299381,
0.6040728688,
0.4408016503,
-0.3915281594,
0.6741851568,
-0.2231629193,
0.0601363406,
-0.9538777471,
0.1611071974,
-0.1236249804,
-0.3035323322,
-0.7943589687,
0.2235958874,
0.1628420651,
-0.0073680528,
0.063815698,
0.1898464411,
-0.8237617612,
-0.4384186566,
0.0406704508,
-0.0851445645,
0.4523203671,
0.3475273252,
0.3038016856,
0.6503987908,
0.1114637405,
-0.837385416,
-0.0885565132,
0.244378835,
-0.265445292,
-0.0157052707,
-0.9892483354,
-0.2135507613,
-0.039251551,
0.4159733653,
-0.7970454097,
-0.3920009136,
-0.1118493006,
-0.5498274565,
0.5464617014,
-0.20919016,
-0.2690787613,
-0.0070360103,
-0.6934169531,
0.4681094587,
0.5480188727,
-0.2143925577,
0.4729040265,
0.2393444628,
-0.1530305594,
-0.5839694738,
-0.9866619706,
-0.3212414384,
-0.3226635754,
-0.6667308807,
0.3465258777,
0.0840988979,
-0.5900690556,
-0.243181929,
-0.3261766732,
-0.0216592718,
0.1058996841,
0.2522251606,
0.046391245,
-0.396478951,
0.1210433021,
0.1100211442,
0.0878385678,
0.0012720956,
-0.0936098024,
0.410356313,
0.2163639069,
-0.417064786,
-0.4242403209,
0.4377337098,
0.3208323419,
-0.1451580822,
0.8015932441,
-0.1631761789,
-0.0874561444,
-0.0632965863,
-0.2307320237,
-0.4781152606,
-0.3883805871,
0.4079407454,
-0.3550700843,
-0.5506102443,
0.7507356405,
0.0817593262,
0.382386744,
0.4405417442,
0.0952129588,
-0.0170171335,
0.9221076369,
0.5858682394,
0.2461389899,
0.5188373327,
-0.3181259036,
0.2817930877,
-0.7097747922,
0.004552247,
-0.631311655,
-0.3351858258,
-0.5454417467,
-0.5453752875,
0.0186887961,
0.2988628745,
-0.4799720049,
0.2486566901,
-0.3254166245,
0.3193942308,
0.3647328615,
0.0234480966,
0.7358390093,
0.1059034467,
0.7186977863,
0.073786281,
-1.0381871462,
-0.3694728315,
1.0463263988,
0.3593334556,
0.7724944949,
0.4494525492,
0.4012705386,
-0.0201588664,
-0.0184468888,
-0.8407895565,
0.3149869144,
-0.1905702204,
-0.429222703,
-0.6034399867,
-0.5962184668,
-0.7334147096,
0.3150008023,
0.1917829365,
-0.5990189314,
0.6780201197,
0.5412216783,
-0.6582127213,
0.040664956,
-0.655377686,
0.7825946212,
0.1098100841,
-0.2929238975,
-0.2313767821,
-0.9858097434,
0.3117179275,
0.1270124614,
0.0042880648,
0.0668928921,
-0.3844701052,
0.7008584738,
-1.0644567013,
0.6302236915,
0.0177232157,
0.303797245,
0.2544459105,
0.1813618839,
0.5867194533,
-0.0202047657,
-0.2118150443,
0.5233781338,
-0.0139659606,
-0.4785511494,
-0.8740608096,
0.0613706596,
-0.5069435835,
-0.5860734582,
-0.2148373127,
-0.5614712834,
-0.050321091,
-0.2706097066,
0.6858198643,
0.6635135412,
-0.0159359947,
0.2604671717,
0.4140746593,
-0.1548676789,
0.603934586,
0.4456582665,
-0.0297197476,
0.0535718426,
0.7128562331,
0.4845932424,
0.7016936541,
0.3782105446,
-0.071666345,
-0.1090955436,
-0.7993523479,
-0.3656243086,
0.3382925391,
-0.3736082315,
-0.2583754361,
-0.7741984129,
-0.4125282168,
-0.5075594783,
-0.4150156677,
-0.4887601733,
-0.9807020426,
-0.0801432431,
-0.2039785534,
0.3135228157,
0.5576525927,
-0.1051617712,
0.7436477542,
-0.460342437,
-0.0201857407,
-0.1186328605,
0.071545057,
0.0820269808,
-0.8594204187,
-0.2357782573,
0.041418314,
0.0509358495,
-1.1353240013,
0.7136899233,
0.503523767,
0.0970613286,
0.6745871902,
0.03257652,
0.7977551222,
-0.3083821535,
0.6749779582,
0.0420373753,
-0.7995501161,
0.2995107472,
-0.3888530731,
0.5498250127,
0.2582141161,
0.2731594443,
-0.3634109497,
-0.3389430344,
-0.6672264338,
-1.0425382853,
0.6769922972,
0.1194019392,
-0.2396385819,
0.2601096332,
0.2221018523,
-0.0063226568,
0.340041846,
-0.3039711416,
-0.2727449238,
-0.3248915672,
-0.1732831746,
-0.4156160653,
-0.4802107215,
0.1465395838,
-0.216134727,
0.6932816505,
-0.1952712238,
0.1424988359,
0.1852096617,
-0.2958475053,
0.2083350271,
0.1067112386,
0.2978202403,
0.8595830202,
-0.0552214421,
0.1282628328,
0.0139839221,
-0.4525230825,
0.0260320511,
0.1240291074,
-0.420787096,
0.2267373353,
0.751342237,
0.6226294041,
0.0455373116,
-0.7255446315,
0.4958768487,
0.0524650291,
0.0876058489,
-0.1732819676,
0.0395468138,
0.0034744458,
0.1003143415,
0.2697318196,
0.0770437866,
0.6196091771,
-0.462364018,
0.0661246032,
0.2698664069,
-0.1777025908,
-0.3416135013,
0.5294627547,
0.0703148097,
-0.3552209735,
0.847658515,
-0.0619835109,
-0.2107882649,
0.9326505661,
0.5335646868,
0.4755678475,
-0.4182572961,
0.143261373,
0.7003346086,
0.2384898365,
-0.5124396682,
-0.1111316457,
-0.439542383,
-0.6894687414,
-0.6681880355,
-0.5153099298,
-0.1071403846,
-0.31215927,
-0.9648907781,
0.0775458589,
-0.408935219,
-0.0484753884,
-0.0181070492,
-0.1598458886,
-0.0738727972,
-0.0474847741,
-0.5490644574,
0.8673258424,
-0.8680719733,
0.4568865001,
0.4566933513,
-0.2702262998,
-1.0149326324,
0.0617152527,
0.2201147527,
-0.1492984295,
0.1523729116,
0.2260883301,
0.0791222155,
0.0052675628,
-0.3953936994,
-0.8247007728,
1.0484161377,
0.4276195168,
-0.8191699386,
-0.198013559,
-0.2647828758,
0.5434542894,
-0.2833547592,
0.3446140587,
0.7883499265,
0.1516422927,
0.1991597116,
-0.8604775071,
-0.0071943058,
-0.3493997455,
-0.0214943532,
0.3528888822,
-0.5673897266,
0.947470367,
-0.5533970594,
-0.5402459502,
0.019570658,
0.6106826067,
0.2725473642,
0.3414966464,
0.0830064863,
0.2520736754,
0.5706934333,
-0.1348875314,
1.2787873745,
-0.3015005887,
0.0207793266,
1.4012998343,
0.0613085441,
0.8020712733,
0.2877721786,
-0.2357081473,
0.4046497047,
0.6119715571,
0.0130004948,
0.2564119697,
-0.0400232598,
0.1030262411,
-0.1033814549,
0.1717078537,
-0.2865469158,
0.1396637857,
0.5190015435,
-0.5317037106,
-0.0630379468,
-0.4828076959,
0.1449216604,
0.2086792439,
-0.344627291,
0.8565400839,
0.2827652693,
-0.6589571834,
0.279745996,
0.1098647192,
0.5283380151,
-0.5559263229,
0.0327695198,
-0.3368519247,
0.1963135451,
-0.4341400266,
-0.4495361745,
0.7816489339,
-0.0970008001,
-0.2617029548,
-0.039854113,
0.6791107059,
-0.4238624573,
-0.4686158895,
0.1289390177,
0.6448472142,
0.4523840547,
-0.3171795607,
-0.1522412449,
-0.0950423777,
-0.0612081103,
-0.4870728254,
0.1203910634,
0.1591777056,
-0.2422710359,
0.6443234682,
0.3709753156,
0.3445954323,
0.0103583569,
0.1751835346,
0.6395975947,
-0.5416952968,
-0.7397930622,
-1.1085412502,
0.6797834635,
-0.3732602,
0.0683124363,
1.0554420948,
0.8521189094,
0.5806059837,
0.0291258991,
0.5580223799,
-0.1274034977,
0.603469193,
-0.2344273031,
0.58830899,
-0.5150196552,
0.4588156044,
-0.1068733186,
-0.7817336321,
-0.3600974977,
0.7972936034,
-0.3531208038,
0.1003477946,
0.4892125428,
0.8659605384,
-0.0033543163,
-0.0524312072,
0.3323521912,
0.2140680999,
-0.011015364,
0.2157311738,
0.4304904044,
-0.5157117844,
0.1519568861,
-0.1143092662,
-0.2478832006,
-0.2992985547,
-0.5284917951,
-0.7616890669,
-0.6487402916,
-0.3183318675,
-0.3127954006,
0.3266940713,
0.5543805361,
0.7326754928,
-0.7605845332,
-0.4419955909,
-0.2811464965,
0.1810237318,
-0.4818417132,
-0.1909139901,
0.3954161406,
0.0781783015,
-0.5579393506,
0.0797506049,
0.4178671837,
0.073109217,
0.0456446745,
-0.096612975,
-0.0536955371,
0.2819927335,
0.5214409232,
0.4239442945,
-0.5029646754,
0.0978778005,
-0.173227638,
0.2062817961,
0.0596803017,
1.0724549294,
-0.5190907121,
0.1707725376,
0.7397332191,
0.3318964839,
0.5969896913,
0.7118222713,
1.0643094778,
-0.8270766139,
0.3856282532,
0.3225062191,
0.2157918662,
0.4157844186,
-0.2257838547,
0.7387524247,
0.1715425849,
-0.398219347,
-0.9905493855,
0.3566685021,
-0.4566641152,
-0.4940513968,
1.1268986464,
-0.3923719525,
-0.2423597127,
-0.2102760673,
0.3171755373,
0.4308456481,
-0.287135005,
0.4528600872,
0.3767907321,
-0.2238431722,
-0.2412730306,
-0.3242172301,
0.6867980361,
0.3101675808,
-0.6902584434,
0.2848203778,
0.7093535662,
0.1355181038,
0.2988985777,
0.6035994887,
0.0488070287,
0.2101874948,
0.574886322,
-0.2395795584,
-0.2127117813,
-0.4436849356,
-0.6395182014,
0.244052425,
-0.0185534433,
0.0720159635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02625v1 | Towards Explainable AI Writing Assistants for Non-native English Speakers | 2023-04-05T17:51:36 | 2023-04-05T17:51:36 | Yewon Kim, Mina Lee, Donghwi Kim, Sung-Ju Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | We highlight the challenges faced by non-native speakers when using AI
writing assistants to paraphrase text. Through an interview study with 15
non-native English speakers (NNESs) with varying levels of English proficiency,
we observe that they face difficulties in assessing paraphrased texts generated
by AI writing assistants, largely due to the lack of explanations accompanying
the suggested paraphrases. Furthermore, we examine their strategies to assess
AI-generated texts in the absence of such explanations. Drawing on the needs of
NNESs identified in our interview, we propose four potential user interfaces to
enhance the writing experience of NNESs using AI writing assistants. The
proposed designs focus on incorporating explanations to better support NNESs in
understanding and evaluating the AI-generated paraphrasing suggestions. | [
-0.2277649641,
-0.5009087324,
0.8221094012,
0.2322294116,
0.0069975783,
0.2522080839,
-0.0302249342,
-0.4966277182,
0.1408755928,
0.3514021337,
-0.5376675129,
-0.3371217251,
-0.415969044,
0.9399135113,
-0.4737625122,
0.9493104815,
-0.2791794538,
-0.3844161332,
-0.7284294367,
-0.1189141944,
-0.6594073176,
0.0733308941,
-0.797772646,
-0.1450016052,
0.4710281491,
0.8959881067,
0.8327187896,
0.4408680499,
0.3640455604,
0.3832615316,
0.2265852541,
0.3083264828,
0.0335254371,
0.0337365009,
-0.1340866089,
-0.4553157389,
-0.4572680295,
-0.2341271192,
0.2782893777,
0.6176617742,
0.1757141203,
-0.1188951358,
0.2083990425,
0.4501106143,
-0.3315608501,
-0.0784256384,
-0.3879552186,
0.0955936089,
-0.0941315368,
-0.3181045055,
-0.3869852722,
-0.3595989347,
0.2086198479,
-1.0962760448,
0.3490771651,
0.2478094101,
0.6740082502,
0.2283844948,
-0.212871775,
-0.5869511366,
-0.5796281695,
0.7335284352,
-0.7949568629,
0.0304872822,
0.6021521688,
0.2715573609,
0.1250217259,
-0.7450309992,
-1.030495286,
-0.5275269747,
-0.3696489334,
0.1592711061,
-0.250915885,
-0.0036002526,
0.0184059888,
0.5117257237,
-0.7959241271,
-0.0419432111,
-0.1391148567,
-0.2527499199,
0.6716704369,
0.1881306469,
0.7428839803,
-0.1125122383,
0.0113879442,
0.3481158614,
-0.218616128,
-0.0001739881,
0.3636606634,
0.0172785725,
-0.2575769424,
0.3270809948,
-0.1582791954,
0.7327642441,
-0.149149254,
-0.2283507586,
0.2600637078,
-0.284360081,
0.0495609455,
-0.3478828669,
0.573317945,
0.5551040769,
0.4325925708,
-0.6752438545,
-0.1919452399,
-0.3147795498,
0.19062154,
-0.2973467112,
-0.25077492,
0.2113236487,
-0.6207921505,
-0.2514938712,
-0.1179971546,
-1.0876210928,
-0.5705398917,
-0.2321157753,
0.6184235811,
-0.4398588538,
-0.1937815398,
-0.3349023461,
-0.7535280585,
0.2253395319,
0.3908350766,
-0.9864592552,
0.3621129394,
0.2265519202,
0.9002500176,
-0.3256624639,
-0.7173907161,
-0.1244810224,
0.265935868,
-0.1517604738,
0.8294653893,
-0.5105249286,
-0.5527975559,
-0.1657911986,
-0.1757962406,
-0.1432384551,
-0.522249043,
0.3760371804,
0.1956536025,
0.5748740435,
-0.0485345572,
-0.3725201786,
-0.0119315526,
0.1640183628,
-0.5085769892,
0.5802159905,
-0.1236712486,
-0.7816127539,
0.1657286882,
-0.8803164363,
-0.8519791365,
0.1655892879,
-0.1028839424,
-0.1296144575,
0.2514745295,
0.6826617122,
0.3434628844,
-0.1481417418,
-0.1790709496,
0.0824816898,
-0.5086343288,
0.1435653865,
-0.638124764,
0.6782007217,
0.171660915,
-0.4637217224,
0.1200736836,
-0.6660016179,
-0.1061076447,
0.2616903782,
-0.0869559273,
-0.1355020851,
-0.0527688824,
0.0056406301,
-0.1487627327,
0.639893949,
-0.2284042537,
-0.3611983657,
-0.4331955612,
0.6518620849,
0.5529535413,
0.3844689727,
0.4784214795,
-0.7501367331,
0.8831244707,
-0.4989628494,
0.2524340153,
-0.153944239,
-0.5752310157,
-0.3943707645,
0.0762770101,
-0.1646665633,
0.5805986524,
-1.1015908718,
-0.1197592095,
-0.0233985446,
-0.6445761323,
-0.5757997036,
0.513835609,
0.6468060613,
0.9253405333,
0.5726106763,
0.4126230776,
-0.3530246317,
-1.0248156786,
-0.6632681489,
-0.3075684905,
-0.287427187,
0.2773950994,
0.3230530322,
0.2173468918,
0.7783325911,
-0.0039446666,
-0.1023050472,
-0.7112787366,
0.3526888192,
-0.2560428977,
0.2230774611,
0.3921980262,
-0.9203413725,
-0.6923519373,
0.0363940299,
-1.0147433281,
-0.3556683958,
-0.6127668023,
0.3024790883,
0.2428522557,
0.8269279003,
-0.6728043556,
0.3748682439,
0.2241683453,
-0.0680364743,
0.487162739,
-0.5765129924,
0.1344711035,
-1.2436803579,
0.3122790754,
0.0929666683,
-0.0504783951,
-0.3833871186,
0.2127881348,
-0.1491967142,
-0.3669184744,
-0.3504575193,
0.6280509233,
-0.66573596,
0.0502149723,
-0.4819714129,
0.5918554664,
0.5224080086,
0.2702887058,
0.118702434,
0.9574152827,
0.4332792163,
-0.4625396729,
0.0268369969,
0.5363991857,
0.1366793066,
0.6636853218,
-0.8792484999,
0.1075581387,
-0.3030672669,
0.0975359082,
-1.2366380692,
-0.1939873397,
0.1289049089,
-0.8758657575,
0.0127108069,
0.2255320251,
-0.1010005251,
-0.3593115211,
-0.3681699932,
0.0786001533,
0.507337451,
-0.4468293488,
0.6638477445,
0.0506390519,
-0.4755932987,
-0.3475498855,
-0.6214762926,
0.7257754803,
-0.6825371981,
-0.4015781879,
0.4767165482,
-0.0770861953,
-0.6034573317,
-0.0718965828,
0.2964240611,
-0.2331175506,
0.3357266486,
0.238732934,
-0.046597667,
-0.2249618024,
-0.0073512401,
0.1394952089,
-0.2116295993,
0.15463911,
0.0703115687,
-0.0270037912,
0.1396359652,
0.048661299,
-1.2428274155,
0.7352595925,
0.7561064959,
-0.3232017457,
0.560716331,
0.4411199689,
-0.3388914466,
0.0348985754,
-0.2157099992,
-0.0817764476,
-0.4691961408,
0.1009042412,
-0.4183431268,
-0.2560581565,
0.3557759821,
0.3913525045,
0.4293230474,
0.5543838739,
0.4015025198,
-0.428162396,
0.8153434992,
0.4611914456,
0.0666106865,
0.2200411111,
0.2724829316,
0.3518258035,
-0.3726621866,
-0.2833081186,
-0.6451475024,
-0.4252375662,
-0.2716923654,
0.070405066,
0.1823745221,
-0.2026665509,
0.2773261666,
0.3936510086,
-0.4654410183,
0.5901541114,
0.8568618298,
-0.2318291217,
0.2392652333,
-0.2502677441,
0.2361066639,
-0.0436566062,
-0.3803514838,
-0.722722888,
0.9104450941,
0.1230142713,
0.4058161378,
0.0563975871,
0.8713562489,
0.5131274462,
-0.0766765401,
-0.414791435,
0.5749329925,
-0.0145521304,
-0.3659360707,
-0.5175474286,
-0.2308105975,
-0.8681294322,
-0.2855840921,
-0.2390280664,
-0.7516482472,
-0.1987582445,
0.5054391623,
-0.5209754109,
-0.0076595615,
-1.0975883007,
0.9126598835,
-0.0984156504,
-0.0954796597,
-0.0296608359,
-0.8158846498,
0.0395259187,
0.1971968859,
0.2786093652,
0.1361156255,
-0.1511008143,
0.8058872223,
-0.5065815449,
0.6859452724,
-0.4633552134,
0.1428105682,
0.4549497366,
0.0646491647,
0.2105464935,
0.1510130316,
-0.3644014001,
-0.0074451892,
-0.2381574064,
-0.5896732211,
-0.6803398728,
0.7117735147,
-0.6655188799,
-0.6971114278,
0.1289975345,
-0.6738074422,
-0.3136931658,
0.1014385819,
0.4997772574,
0.3424402177,
-0.0623790435,
-0.0327382796,
0.1716286838,
-0.3513971567,
0.7222672701,
0.0959151387,
0.2762251496,
-0.1871533394,
1.3599973917,
-0.1326146424,
0.2298314273,
0.6664501429,
0.2980029583,
-0.3478540778,
-1.0696207285,
-0.7265288234,
-0.0332058743,
-0.5121260881,
0.2235345393,
-0.6076205969,
0.1822061837,
-0.6352366209,
-0.5433935523,
0.2979668975,
-0.6550027728,
-0.4472276568,
-0.1930917948,
0.4953826368,
0.6988806725,
0.0075394311,
0.443708241,
-0.4107438922,
0.6665903926,
0.2058038265,
-0.2187983245,
0.2536512613,
-0.6120434999,
-0.1378186941,
-0.2100888193,
-0.4305844903,
-0.9176250696,
0.2432280034,
0.4470130801,
0.5060960054,
0.3560139239,
0.1016044617,
0.6407908201,
-0.4940559864,
1.076874733,
-0.2043080628,
-1.0817605257,
0.700751543,
-0.2476203293,
0.2201791555,
0.69683218,
0.4922820926,
-0.4761463404,
-0.8554976583,
-0.4679372013,
-0.9412930608,
0.3694219887,
0.4329369068,
0.4347079098,
-0.1781041324,
0.5528373718,
0.4934705198,
0.0385627188,
-0.8323367834,
-0.2170094252,
-0.4173099101,
-0.4766071439,
-0.3033293486,
0.0069273151,
0.2206925452,
0.0639516935,
0.591342628,
-0.0769871175,
0.2380826622,
0.3576627374,
-0.2666963935,
0.2849075794,
0.0441237427,
0.7899838686,
1.0228495598,
0.2352540642,
0.1326158494,
0.2097955942,
-0.1350666285,
-0.1048187762,
0.0655076653,
-0.0343121067,
0.2047199011,
0.8650085926,
0.5040681362,
-0.0839974284,
-0.8482384682,
0.4943963885,
-0.3697921336,
-0.6127129793,
-0.3379270136,
0.046042677,
0.3773014843,
-0.0994492248,
0.4143951833,
-0.204375878,
0.2877623141,
-0.2498281747,
0.1469595879,
0.3999021649,
-0.1365723312,
-0.3099376857,
0.8148258924,
0.5298198462,
-1.0547544956,
0.5785791278,
-0.1521328986,
-0.0963310823,
0.681746006,
0.7075918913,
0.6943538189,
0.0024813185,
0.4513324201,
-0.1316458881,
0.3844077587,
0.4834374785,
0.2454612851,
-0.4293708801,
-0.2087800205,
-0.0422027744,
-0.1723451912,
-0.8878363371,
0.1069786996,
-0.5842290521,
0.1318358183,
-0.6126846671,
0.4980503321,
0.3534074724,
-0.4134485722,
-0.3262884021,
0.1780045331,
0.0409657434,
0.6809895039,
-0.9723935723,
0.2224954367,
0.7473911047,
-0.5912650228,
-0.6056494713,
0.6323039532,
-0.3054782152,
-1.0481420755,
-0.0624281093,
0.2077192515,
0.0310012009,
0.1112559214,
-0.1114526689,
-0.300069809,
0.9037532806,
0.3082319796,
-0.0414905921,
-0.3486961722,
0.3007607758,
0.667429328,
0.0937789455,
0.3893597126,
0.3263609111,
0.661808908,
-0.3218583465,
-0.815233767,
-0.1327293068,
-0.4878529906,
-0.1991925985,
-0.0257331021,
-0.3170631826,
0.7254155278,
-0.2638708353,
0.2203182876,
0.4047688544,
0.8010092378,
-0.2945108116,
0.8282130957,
0.406950891,
0.2473091781,
0.7079867125,
0.4218208194,
1.080114603,
-0.170004487,
-0.4117917418,
1.0164119005,
-0.0064871693,
0.7270687819,
0.9173549414,
0.092870988,
0.7412756681,
0.321393013,
0.3718498945,
0.1623067558,
-0.0232453644,
-0.3556240201,
-0.0369279943,
-0.1689966768,
-0.0207160674,
0.4178798795,
0.1346972585,
-0.3920841217,
-0.3297354281,
0.4997804761,
-0.2055713534,
0.7353228927,
-0.2074194849,
0.9970113635,
-0.0294285212,
-0.8469845057,
0.5157143474,
0.1545154154,
0.4804412723,
-0.2587696016,
-0.2035520673,
-0.5458856225,
-0.1217120364,
-0.4009003043,
-0.813600421,
0.7092474103,
0.2755203247,
-0.2494847625,
-0.5187861323,
0.3712294102,
-0.0693968907,
-0.4076980054,
0.0169790238,
0.6003081203,
0.6013233662,
-0.1359168291,
-0.7047101855,
-0.4482176602,
0.1183541194,
0.0277853459,
0.0005761651,
0.655960381,
-0.2916474938,
0.6443278193,
0.2991475165,
-0.254129827,
-0.0560891554,
-0.2303755432,
0.17745547,
-0.4772661328,
-0.5108397603,
-1.0828425884,
0.4254688919,
-0.0823018774,
-0.7097380757,
1.0204049349,
0.4191603065,
0.3964488506,
-0.1747829169,
1.0133005381,
-0.1547479928,
0.7264140248,
-0.3323274255,
0.8364003301,
-0.8283129334,
-0.2017213702,
-0.4321022034,
-0.6327636242,
-0.160403043,
0.6164275408,
-0.2138601094,
-0.0203548986,
0.672727704,
0.6079131365,
0.011639121,
0.2140931636,
0.4084242284,
-0.0926083252,
0.2155605555,
0.6099617481,
0.7051075697,
-0.1571924835,
0.922446847,
-0.3049123287,
-0.2024275064,
-0.0179035086,
-0.9565395117,
-0.9267309308,
-0.5758078694,
-0.347530961,
0.1055947021,
0.0432496592,
0.5502353311,
0.232738927,
-0.5356330872,
-0.0536289401,
-0.5681844354,
0.4695223868,
-0.1985993385,
-0.2669943571,
0.1328946054,
-0.2593183815,
-0.9827182293,
0.7397233844,
0.2063398659,
0.1190147996,
-0.1425284147,
-0.0711797029,
-0.0013916194,
0.1853687465,
0.1037592515,
0.6433890462,
-0.5898492336,
-0.3222135305,
-0.0805689171,
0.241112113,
-0.0728902444,
0.5521323085,
-0.6012303233,
0.0584616959,
0.3612071872,
0.8946706057,
-0.1201018021,
0.0107337181,
0.7729930878,
-0.6912774444,
0.027126275,
0.3327282965,
0.0981072336,
0.5512968898,
-0.4001416266,
-0.0768691599,
0.0113512529,
-0.5119181275,
-0.799010694,
-0.1198811308,
-0.6073870659,
-0.2093902528,
0.7443183064,
-0.4927773774,
-0.1119040325,
-0.4342837632,
-0.4043157697,
0.1188105866,
-0.1898109764,
0.8203235865,
0.6969701648,
-0.4083656967,
-0.257566303,
-0.5052475333,
0.6419089437,
0.7589392066,
-1.1098878384,
0.1209188998,
0.2360088229,
0.2376310676,
0.0581463464,
0.6369450688,
0.1195681915,
0.6834518909,
0.0345339365,
-0.0266140066,
-0.2704792917,
-0.4594090879,
-0.3230223358,
0.1180100068,
0.5688195229,
-0.5050557256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02623v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02623v1 | Beyond Summarization: Designing AI Support for Real-World Expository Writing Tasks | 2023-04-05T17:47:11 | 2023-04-05T17:47:11 | Zejiang Shen, Tal August, Pao Siangliulue, Kyle Lo, Jonathan Bragg, Jeff Hammerbacher, Doug Downey, Joseph Chee Chang, David Sontag | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Large language models have introduced exciting new opportunities and
challenges in designing and developing new AI-assisted writing support tools.
Recent work has shown that leveraging this new technology can transform writing
in many scenarios such as ideation during creative writing, editing support,
and summarization. However, AI-supported expository writing--including
real-world tasks like scholars writing literature reviews or doctors writing
progress notes--is relatively understudied. In this position paper, we argue
that developing AI supports for expository writing has unique and exciting
research challenges and can lead to high real-world impacts. We characterize
expository writing as evidence-based and knowledge-generating: it contains
summaries of external documents as well as new information or knowledge. It can
be seen as the product of authors' sensemaking process over a set of source
documents, and the interplay between reading, reflection, and writing opens up
new opportunities for designing AI support. We sketch three components for AI
support design and discuss considerations for future research. | [
-0.4527197778,
-0.4439376593,
0.8634016514,
0.035675481,
0.1868807971,
-0.1575977653,
0.0601911396,
-0.7528974414,
0.1640537381,
0.3463897705,
-0.4737027586,
-0.1844264269,
-0.4964564145,
0.4898777604,
-0.1812141538,
1.1118279696,
-0.18540667,
-0.0414091758,
-0.431645453,
-0.1233693361,
-0.2949054837,
-0.5272635221,
-0.4524103105,
0.0295540914,
0.740477562,
0.7606931925,
0.5271536112,
0.4334071577,
0.7000752687,
0.2728114426,
0.2563810945,
0.4065619409,
-0.1269560307,
0.7232420444,
0.3288193047,
-0.813115716,
-0.37066558,
0.0702201426,
0.6450713277,
0.438292712,
-0.1982067823,
0.0495647714,
-0.1121438295,
0.3751111329,
-0.4440965354,
0.2531745434,
-0.0585740171,
0.2560934424,
-0.0808638558,
0.0528026707,
-0.3427699208,
-0.4661568999,
0.2217385769,
-1.0235157013,
0.1097555384,
0.4297220409,
0.4205545187,
0.373290509,
0.0619250573,
-0.4691135585,
-0.7087140083,
0.3056475222,
-0.8597983718,
0.0501110516,
0.0694840327,
0.440345794,
-0.0546661466,
-0.7508823276,
-0.8455119729,
-0.2083710581,
-0.2960594594,
0.3771772981,
0.2436559796,
0.184343636,
0.2140345275,
0.33309111,
-0.2712877989,
0.0032594097,
0.052701138,
0.0206228886,
0.4771878421,
0.2224250585,
0.4506392777,
0.378603369,
-0.0395436138,
-0.1598676443,
-0.5662178993,
0.1484547555,
0.2545840144,
0.0565972887,
0.2238400429,
0.639806807,
-0.1823700368,
0.479875803,
-0.4152781069,
0.0498069972,
-0.1433143616,
-0.0969511718,
-0.0775319114,
0.2046048343,
0.4143554866,
0.3648164272,
0.0392959118,
-0.0932869017,
-0.0524032526,
-0.1588257551,
0.1810167581,
-0.862800777,
-0.0527772419,
0.1590315551,
-0.5622047186,
-0.1902990341,
0.2091840804,
-0.328412503,
-0.9678103328,
-0.4676575959,
0.1664431989,
-0.3480320871,
-0.2317040712,
0.0206992794,
-0.8247051835,
0.0127219893,
0.7581879497,
-0.9323328733,
0.2670336962,
0.7233936191,
0.9028304219,
0.1528538764,
-0.5640194416,
-0.2511162758,
0.4558362663,
-0.0769323185,
1.0385872126,
-0.5186604857,
-0.3124423921,
-0.0527992137,
-0.2463560253,
0.0661858097,
-0.5115863681,
0.6963210106,
-0.1483163983,
0.2819210589,
-0.241798535,
-0.6815996766,
0.0627326965,
0.3169222176,
-0.7653862238,
0.6039993763,
0.0456708707,
-0.7335598469,
0.5741874576,
-0.6570221782,
-0.3766863644,
0.1001904532,
-0.3711116314,
-0.4532692432,
0.4152678251,
0.028791951,
0.4647671282,
-0.200485602,
0.3625033498,
-0.1990440935,
-0.5077270269,
0.0588934086,
-0.2968684733,
0.5018427968,
0.0969027951,
-0.4229230285,
0.1943356544,
-0.9276777506,
-0.4802397788,
-0.1308881491,
-0.2153315991,
-0.4722294807,
0.2335744351,
-0.0273900069,
-0.0825891271,
-0.2072478533,
-0.6716732383,
0.3467299938,
-0.1306425482,
0.4053618908,
0.5423092842,
-0.2062203437,
0.3422677517,
-0.8005900979,
0.59925735,
-0.3470649123,
-0.1594313234,
-0.8233671784,
-0.709091723,
-0.4904360473,
-0.1953142136,
0.0840908065,
0.4871755242,
-0.4703907073,
0.0388664864,
0.0077817272,
-0.4920727313,
-0.793740809,
-0.4761635363,
0.1236792803,
0.876734376,
0.5057716966,
0.1026191562,
-0.8924130201,
-0.7408031225,
-0.2385011911,
-0.444525063,
-0.1749084145,
0.1403974593,
0.2996675372,
0.0032718051,
0.8821183443,
-0.4664895236,
-0.6312189698,
-0.3773241639,
0.2991084754,
-0.2047422975,
0.4620070159,
0.5145710111,
-0.9455914497,
-0.3470357955,
-0.0946617052,
-0.8702705503,
-0.3058973551,
-0.4579020739,
-0.0048724497,
0.0567062832,
0.7387903929,
-0.7761726975,
0.4498873651,
0.0496000089,
-0.297137022,
0.7816790938,
-0.174355939,
0.1901554316,
-0.8437799811,
0.3168725669,
-0.1694289446,
0.0051484713,
-0.4659415781,
0.2973141372,
-0.1627182066,
-0.2346885353,
-0.0909370258,
0.5260582566,
-0.3774445057,
0.4539928734,
-0.2912125289,
0.0810565427,
0.1509385854,
-0.0380935892,
0.4429274499,
0.4099527299,
0.3049984872,
-0.1390492916,
0.3595014811,
0.4967502356,
-0.1272298396,
0.6422848105,
-0.6489927173,
-0.501857698,
-0.233260572,
0.6083236337,
-0.9263408184,
-0.2283062488,
0.1959275752,
-0.4834392071,
-0.012697666,
0.0616030358,
-0.5430095792,
-0.0436651483,
-0.470254451,
0.1239388958,
0.2584960759,
-0.1716749668,
0.8141674399,
0.4167940915,
-0.6472387314,
-0.4499076903,
-0.7329289913,
0.4777521193,
-0.2914405167,
-0.5465619564,
0.5795080662,
-0.1199457794,
-0.8175833225,
0.2142364979,
0.2084332108,
0.2193620205,
0.2157902569,
0.4312222004,
0.1751722395,
-0.1926297694,
0.352584362,
0.0602613464,
-0.2750267982,
0.1214451492,
-0.3085103333,
-0.1023313478,
0.2658971548,
-0.3166183531,
-0.4362869263,
0.839216888,
0.5036796927,
-0.0831943452,
0.7263796329,
0.6130072474,
-0.28596735,
-0.2318970412,
-0.5500593781,
-0.1995846927,
-0.369289279,
0.0915461332,
-0.2292262465,
-0.932512939,
0.4848830104,
0.3070081174,
0.5590069294,
0.2376578003,
0.4196800292,
-0.308732897,
1.1350370646,
0.9087216854,
0.1371018887,
0.5243187547,
-0.0335199423,
0.2400621474,
-0.6916509271,
-0.1996686012,
-0.4269400537,
-0.4310907125,
-0.1671480983,
0.1139415577,
0.3468528986,
-0.2394573241,
0.0423447043,
0.0496998206,
-0.6035075784,
0.0301169716,
0.9622603059,
-0.3156481087,
0.4349798858,
-0.3719851077,
0.1154414862,
0.1284157634,
-0.6419021487,
-0.6457474232,
0.7634484172,
0.1380093843,
0.5777124763,
0.0406902991,
0.5095208883,
0.5096354485,
0.4378890991,
-0.55257231,
0.4479841292,
0.1339594573,
-0.4725616276,
-0.4795453846,
0.1489939094,
-0.4136639237,
0.5486500263,
-0.3456857204,
-0.2472917885,
0.3132860959,
0.1798184067,
-0.719053328,
0.1614092737,
-1.0284621716,
0.6258599162,
0.0271791723,
-0.2971870005,
-0.1008225977,
-0.9543197155,
0.0521330088,
0.6050613523,
0.0817266852,
0.1470833868,
-0.0641504452,
0.6380341053,
-0.6594599485,
0.8460193872,
-0.2771815956,
-0.1769863665,
0.5040361285,
-0.1287609786,
0.3583144248,
0.4914199412,
-0.2524395287,
-0.4273335636,
0.0741545185,
-0.1357780546,
-0.5072835684,
0.4332485497,
-0.4043352902,
-0.9205841422,
-0.4347754121,
-0.7696459293,
-0.1576847285,
0.3392186761,
0.1811272502,
0.4576539695,
-0.2378609031,
-0.0140745435,
0.8420861363,
0.2729280591,
0.4898316264,
0.3591442108,
-0.0972503722,
0.0178965386,
0.9901610017,
0.3534608781,
-0.2019939125,
0.75566715,
0.2405041158,
-0.1376848668,
-0.9880740047,
-0.906637907,
-0.1851385832,
-0.4731668532,
0.1055754796,
-0.8479015827,
0.1182565987,
-0.7316965461,
-0.2244715393,
0.2371021807,
-0.7137495279,
-0.4884355068,
-0.4811655283,
0.1434557736,
0.6231755018,
-0.0380300097,
-0.1634974331,
-0.8247469664,
0.3568502665,
0.3831727505,
0.035032142,
0.2400541008,
-0.0243969131,
-0.4721812606,
-0.2141568214,
-0.1329745203,
-0.6098206639,
0.0860377029,
0.1874313653,
0.478015691,
0.2333065867,
0.2624159753,
0.5001798272,
-0.6841952801,
0.7135233283,
-0.2755915523,
-0.4503437281,
0.3749005198,
-0.330502212,
0.1107160151,
0.641353786,
0.4228965342,
-0.8083663583,
-0.7649031281,
-0.5202349424,
-0.8399463296,
0.3790481091,
0.1399708092,
-0.1208974123,
0.1144396663,
0.2839311361,
0.5963798761,
0.4285521209,
-0.3541625738,
0.161755532,
-0.334246695,
-0.3789918721,
0.0562883355,
-0.1419254839,
-0.3471026123,
-0.0716313124,
0.5773359537,
-0.3663223684,
0.0323261805,
0.5763332844,
-0.1613456756,
0.1029130965,
0.1499143392,
0.6844622493,
0.4695680737,
0.0650194064,
0.3291018307,
-0.2662962377,
-0.4303480983,
0.0301565919,
0.7603087425,
-0.5285784006,
-0.185294643,
0.5908321738,
0.4670685828,
-0.297323972,
-1.0810593367,
0.2686259151,
-0.3247637749,
-0.1783592254,
-0.5256851315,
0.3786896765,
0.1102143154,
0.3284543157,
0.6235592365,
0.1365104169,
0.5331980586,
-0.6995612979,
-0.087843366,
0.4338799715,
-0.367265135,
-0.3540558815,
0.7470633388,
0.2743812799,
-0.1803418249,
0.3500421047,
-0.2421029061,
-0.130855605,
0.8679281473,
0.4979938567,
0.551900804,
0.2631975412,
0.1280554235,
-0.1438537389,
-0.0347391255,
-0.1139009222,
0.3819202483,
-0.2518169284,
-0.4927364886,
-0.1642119735,
-0.2312581986,
-0.8412643075,
-0.4428962171,
-0.3406047523,
0.1623900533,
-0.18531169,
0.1568817645,
0.1389181465,
-0.2399690151,
0.0189758204,
0.3914390802,
0.107465677,
0.733891964,
-0.6838824153,
0.3341780901,
1.1358374357,
-0.6142289042,
-0.3806892335,
-0.0145817623,
0.2332562357,
-0.6727839112,
0.0715498701,
0.3420890868,
-0.064537257,
0.0530983694,
-0.5733154416,
-0.4063654542,
1.1626300812,
0.173831448,
-0.2756501138,
-0.4371828735,
-0.0976053104,
0.9536317587,
-0.5317167044,
0.64747262,
0.3236553371,
0.6572165489,
-0.3105950654,
-0.2854047418,
0.0338088833,
-0.5215257406,
-0.2697014213,
-0.0540761203,
-0.8387182951,
0.8914146423,
-0.4225256145,
-0.2806135714,
0.437633723,
0.6391753554,
0.2307091355,
0.4678053856,
0.1388045847,
0.8218126893,
0.7026926279,
0.0502011366,
0.9606229663,
-0.029446438,
-0.4750111997,
1.0093388557,
-0.3931532204,
0.4327991009,
0.5188214779,
0.1155875847,
0.7678329349,
0.332808584,
0.007620153,
0.1356841177,
0.1370588094,
-0.3925827444,
0.0770039633,
-0.6723721623,
-0.4810467958,
-0.0679938495,
0.2315224707,
-0.1954658628,
0.1966664344,
0.1699100584,
-0.0471008196,
0.2716398537,
-0.0527083166,
0.9385735989,
-0.0102393348,
-0.8928927779,
-0.1664897203,
-0.2558489144,
0.3707972467,
-0.4496091306,
-0.6480730176,
-0.0390902311,
0.0751048326,
-0.412453413,
-0.9465324879,
0.366885215,
-0.1762336642,
-0.4517472982,
-0.4730579853,
0.6414147019,
-0.1806116253,
-0.4413391352,
-0.1696735919,
0.4972173572,
-0.3799845576,
-0.1510187835,
-0.0946190655,
-0.1400961876,
-0.3916803002,
-0.4080870152,
0.4627488256,
0.6751309633,
-0.2304408103,
0.6499662399,
0.5660189986,
0.1945936978,
-0.1486622393,
0.2031097114,
0.6744658947,
-0.5827270746,
-0.7003829479,
-0.8019278049,
0.5558023453,
-0.140337795,
-0.3781665564,
0.8026252985,
0.5225350857,
0.6213718653,
0.2903573513,
1.4568923712,
-0.5884728432,
0.6474254131,
-0.2453219742,
0.7585329413,
-0.418001771,
0.0614608899,
-0.1549495012,
-0.6187936664,
-0.6728141904,
0.200124234,
0.0483404323,
-0.4058720171,
0.5044932365,
0.3343957663,
0.3305388689,
0.5283998847,
0.0360563435,
0.1182099655,
0.7624486685,
0.270078063,
0.9742220044,
-0.0498738885,
0.5008376241,
-0.2304893136,
-0.3843594491,
-0.2403762043,
-0.9234809279,
-0.7211054564,
-0.6613926291,
-0.0042442312,
0.1333676726,
0.1747412086,
0.5207340717,
0.4067380726,
-0.8062099814,
-0.0912059173,
-0.5429182053,
0.1899136454,
-0.5424767733,
-0.2064452916,
0.2937406898,
-0.2921386957,
-0.5498013496,
0.2584148943,
0.3612338901,
-0.0095270704,
-0.3596684039,
0.258138299,
-0.0775957257,
-0.2143839151,
0.5053245425,
0.5151238441,
-0.2494621426,
-0.1336342841,
0.023513468,
0.1243910789,
0.09418872,
1.1924831867,
-0.9224885702,
0.4939780235,
0.8840103745,
0.8321309686,
0.0894202217,
0.0987329334,
0.8717616796,
-0.013708598,
-0.0415477827,
0.5987420082,
0.3377842009,
0.3227823377,
-0.3907587826,
0.5381308198,
0.2882655561,
-0.6633374691,
-0.8490447998,
0.1497768313,
-0.3584256172,
-0.3440116644,
0.5270920396,
-0.3577196896,
0.1582617462,
-0.3664714694,
-0.7173129916,
0.1545238495,
-0.4958331585,
0.9466295838,
0.6806019545,
-0.838819325,
-0.2408013195,
-0.3687571883,
0.4855898023,
0.3957159221,
-0.7917514443,
0.3023685515,
0.6374920011,
-0.3764185905,
0.3166846931,
0.6012789011,
0.1347277015,
0.4163229167,
0.1488813609,
0.0111908037,
-0.4402053952,
-0.4058408141,
-0.0717950165,
0.391901046,
0.2771030962,
0.4030672014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02554v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02554v1 | Human-like Summarization Evaluation with ChatGPT | 2023-04-05T16:17:32 | 2023-04-05T16:17:32 | Mingqi Gao, Jie Ruan, Renliang Sun, Xunjian Yin, Shiping Yang, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating text summarization is a challenging problem, and existing
evaluation metrics are far from satisfactory. In this study, we explored
ChatGPT's ability to perform human-like summarization evaluation using four
human evaluation methods on five datasets. We found that ChatGPT was able to
complete annotations relatively smoothly using Likert scale scoring, pairwise
comparison, Pyramid, and binary factuality evaluation. Additionally, it
outperformed commonly used automatic evaluation metrics on some datasets.
Furthermore, we discussed the impact of different prompts, compared its
performance with that of human evaluation, and analyzed the generated
explanations and invalid responses. | [
-0.5351584554,
-0.5875771642,
0.3254150748,
0.4890396297,
-0.5687825084,
0.2875278294,
-0.480097115,
-0.4648019373,
0.2918070555,
-0.0175819322,
-0.5002207756,
-0.4295890033,
-0.5107232928,
0.4815395772,
-0.3213113248,
1.7609951496,
0.1272661388,
0.1261262298,
-0.0557434149,
-0.0051323292,
-0.6615638733,
-0.5739697218,
-0.6586431265,
-0.4072013795,
0.2931857705,
0.5958081484,
0.720541954,
0.2810125351,
0.8692265153,
0.1675337851,
-0.0849628374,
0.1543180645,
-0.6411288381,
0.0186622273,
0.228013888,
-0.1888482869,
-0.6158038974,
0.1958479881,
0.6099139452,
0.6150727272,
-0.0700623691,
0.3864049911,
0.3980014324,
0.8674491048,
-0.3068192303,
0.3405764103,
0.0045254617,
0.3780412972,
-0.0130522717,
-0.3321852386,
-0.1419806778,
-0.7152587771,
0.7555721998,
-0.6716325879,
0.3344576359,
0.2081146389,
0.512720108,
0.1343263537,
-0.296708107,
-0.4987947643,
-0.5044518113,
0.568693161,
-0.6094583869,
-0.0192859024,
0.3181506395,
0.6185039282,
0.0687361062,
-0.6979342699,
-0.4338636398,
-0.3401618004,
-0.2687762678,
0.5446535945,
-0.0317583531,
0.0855307281,
0.3171480596,
0.4520710409,
-0.7798479199,
-0.1607578546,
-0.393040508,
-0.2800219953,
0.8811405301,
0.4881835878,
0.427701205,
-0.7347832322,
-0.3246308565,
-0.1641898751,
-0.2604297101,
-0.0067828144,
0.3035573661,
0.0232284702,
-0.2569364905,
0.6729701757,
-0.4098130763,
0.42449072,
-0.3002702296,
0.0795628652,
0.2721300423,
-0.445790112,
-0.14307262,
0.1068808809,
0.9808316231,
1.1346093416,
0.5416067839,
-0.2846274078,
-0.2257102281,
-0.0725196227,
0.0373089276,
-0.8429486752,
-0.5308059454,
0.2176925391,
-0.7248546481,
-0.3316280544,
0.0377196036,
-1.0582094193,
-0.6389660239,
-0.1987667829,
0.3818542659,
-0.5881135464,
-0.0984284133,
-0.0254994016,
-0.6730697751,
0.3472544253,
0.7386241555,
-1.0205256939,
0.5040484071,
0.6419285536,
1.1096128225,
-0.3374509811,
-0.2788079679,
-0.3118833899,
-0.4619275033,
-0.0201905891,
1.180082798,
-0.2775252759,
-0.6798151731,
-0.4109550714,
-0.4825573862,
-0.2654058933,
-0.2782167792,
0.6338553429,
-0.1157797724,
0.5466290712,
-0.428173095,
-0.5033444166,
-0.448677063,
0.5735993981,
-0.4511170983,
0.9685499668,
0.0155223375,
-1.0761034489,
0.4741016924,
-1.115557313,
-0.3859097362,
0.2006286681,
-0.1226726398,
-0.3105467558,
-0.2167821229,
0.4304348528,
0.5973653793,
-0.1560739726,
-0.0595249459,
0.2650466859,
-0.8018080592,
0.3502190113,
-0.4818331003,
0.6842705607,
0.0483865514,
-0.316714257,
0.2664651275,
-0.6765550375,
0.0522583798,
0.0745038316,
-0.1935971379,
0.0587505586,
-0.0921820253,
0.3604771793,
-0.1106308997,
0.0735386834,
-0.3984681666,
0.4331771433,
-0.3933221996,
0.403539896,
0.2944119573,
0.3906157911,
0.020354012,
-0.4996786118,
0.7640287876,
-0.6020287275,
-0.00805273,
-0.4669115245,
-0.8249391913,
-0.4576381147,
-0.2620100081,
0.5608912706,
0.7920415998,
-0.5603578091,
0.1436665952,
-0.5561848283,
-0.7531228065,
-0.3095784187,
-0.1634523869,
0.6052821279,
0.5820411444,
0.2624679208,
-0.6762732863,
-0.3653990924,
-0.7017983198,
-0.3074446023,
-0.3399000168,
-0.5889589787,
0.1852283329,
0.6000602245,
0.0708651766,
1.1495668888,
-0.6337669492,
-0.2809821367,
-0.4295652807,
0.6659436226,
0.1079597324,
0.2307063043,
0.5013290048,
-0.5333088636,
-0.4545213878,
-0.1196852103,
-0.6993783116,
-0.2365160435,
-0.1258265674,
0.2588641644,
0.0375958458,
0.1140820906,
-0.4728288949,
0.5166964531,
0.1631646156,
-0.3416711986,
0.9683600664,
-0.3720713556,
0.7582860589,
-0.7436962128,
0.1931624264,
-0.0651838258,
-0.4824382961,
-0.4107041657,
-0.2852479517,
-0.0425432548,
-0.3720214069,
-0.1972729117,
0.2795765996,
-0.3198898435,
-0.2251616418,
-0.2468038797,
0.7369505763,
0.0501370579,
0.5795154572,
-0.064676784,
0.7118369341,
0.0571485162,
-0.2059267163,
0.6033825874,
0.4526039064,
-0.331474632,
0.5437507033,
-1.031572938,
0.1467564404,
-0.2343129218,
0.6573528647,
-1.3699034452,
-0.5226239562,
0.4513522685,
-0.6876834035,
-0.061218027,
-0.1787874401,
-0.6075357795,
-0.0275624618,
-0.9310039282,
0.191786781,
0.6033956409,
-0.1849210262,
0.2008481026,
0.0772550628,
-0.3521230817,
-0.1742473096,
-0.6826780438,
0.4700017571,
-0.3385719359,
-0.6422894001,
0.1121899337,
0.0310300477,
-0.2208170742,
-0.2168685496,
0.1269218475,
0.1787413955,
0.0339306667,
0.1732770801,
0.2749918997,
0.0396082439,
-0.0157897025,
-0.1421259046,
-0.3324394822,
0.1001919135,
0.3229954243,
0.4561974108,
-0.4609213471,
-0.2923231125,
-0.4990651309,
0.1912566721,
0.1357855946,
-0.2513048351,
0.2938679457,
0.688326776,
-0.2420004159,
0.3383016586,
-0.4520796537,
-0.160200879,
-0.2984977365,
0.4106971622,
-0.0533213951,
-0.6944963932,
0.6121547222,
0.1857145727,
0.4508487284,
0.6638662815,
0.6101691127,
-0.2958371937,
0.7911276221,
0.1277066916,
0.1415870041,
0.3080896139,
-0.1108660996,
-0.1490954757,
-0.7854021788,
-0.244211778,
-0.4763408303,
-0.303547591,
-0.6020851135,
-0.1717039645,
0.4939360023,
-0.086663872,
0.0711895525,
0.1815138459,
-0.6649069786,
0.5214850903,
0.4120886326,
0.2157908231,
0.5840756297,
-0.1694011986,
0.2708583474,
-0.132290557,
-0.4961074889,
-0.8229672909,
1.0852749348,
0.4248838127,
0.5102015734,
0.1479997784,
0.6515386105,
0.7625693679,
0.4812060893,
-0.87629354,
0.3665083647,
0.0099641122,
-0.401458472,
-0.6020933986,
-0.4320139289,
-0.8431304693,
0.4621640444,
-0.3749139309,
-0.9717643261,
-0.2925624549,
0.1978231817,
-0.6861176491,
-0.3131548166,
-1.3581892252,
0.8394089937,
0.0099958349,
0.3132626116,
-0.0967495963,
-0.9718894362,
0.3491099179,
-0.0085081868,
0.0739457905,
-0.1387864351,
-0.1142967567,
1.1622486115,
-0.3246788085,
0.8211538196,
-0.1677979082,
0.2807721198,
0.3978839517,
-0.0198245831,
0.066234462,
0.1983695328,
0.0142277917,
0.1421270221,
0.2017232776,
-0.3123955727,
-1.1250357628,
0.166785717,
-0.5581591725,
-0.3025329411,
-0.4334517717,
-0.3072913289,
-0.2389042974,
0.0886877775,
0.3485395312,
0.6209763885,
-0.566983223,
-0.1739837974,
0.2913568318,
-0.2051094323,
0.6230775118,
0.1812203228,
-0.4726482034,
-0.6663481593,
0.9572620392,
0.1702911109,
-0.0168132484,
0.1938437372,
0.3554874659,
-0.3560394943,
-0.3246091902,
-1.0356789827,
-0.1347928792,
-0.6286246181,
-0.1123252362,
-0.6503523588,
-0.1056750193,
-0.1200878844,
-0.0697949529,
-0.0170556642,
-0.9797320366,
0.1532694399,
-0.0359154046,
0.2975396514,
0.7691084146,
0.2164978683,
0.6098051071,
-0.919867754,
0.3487049639,
0.3400118053,
0.4000027478,
0.1279754192,
-0.5229081511,
-0.2269177884,
-0.0021714356,
-0.3738229573,
-0.9684295654,
0.1048968136,
0.2080179453,
0.1511504352,
0.279704541,
-0.0507973656,
0.5862464309,
-0.3714486361,
1.063565731,
0.1769086719,
-0.9820273519,
0.4490041435,
-0.5737949014,
0.5295603275,
0.6859977841,
0.0794479325,
-0.9078682661,
-0.1723235995,
-0.4532892406,
-0.7644521594,
0.7051090598,
0.8391547203,
-0.048588369,
0.1030349582,
0.3415652812,
0.1690463573,
0.0712245256,
-0.3689262271,
-0.265940249,
-0.5347550511,
-0.0835222602,
-0.1633067131,
-0.4329352677,
0.1591271162,
0.0652443841,
0.5194510818,
0.0851128474,
0.2766117156,
0.591426909,
-0.2316783816,
0.3491409421,
0.5001038909,
0.7330610156,
0.771740973,
-0.5175782442,
-0.1010620669,
0.4432425201,
-0.6420756578,
-0.1770583689,
0.3271696568,
0.0170327816,
0.067048125,
0.8427293301,
0.4578910768,
0.1966439784,
-0.7617022395,
0.675803721,
-0.6701812148,
-0.0451866388,
-0.150073424,
0.0933580026,
-0.0754942372,
-0.020874504,
0.6064574122,
-0.0198061299,
0.6453558207,
-0.2520822585,
0.0919815972,
-0.0284217447,
-0.5167372227,
-0.3026021719,
0.4245435596,
0.4880290627,
-0.4583112597,
0.7628791332,
-0.3337498009,
-0.6115900874,
0.5537614226,
0.1642524302,
1.0686309338,
-0.0483285636,
0.1997033358,
0.3036981225,
0.4326252341,
0.1324662268,
0.2941916883,
-0.3052259088,
-0.450158,
-0.7005319595,
-0.2453649342,
-0.8748634458,
-0.4472150505,
-0.6406251192,
0.2767989635,
-0.2917209268,
-0.1609667987,
0.1839098781,
0.210529387,
-0.4745514691,
0.3569598198,
-0.2189826071,
0.7596670985,
-0.7143310905,
0.0592821129,
0.9198092222,
-0.6008079052,
-0.6743305326,
0.1110142767,
0.2036709785,
-0.4435759783,
0.2235400528,
0.4596359134,
-0.1249490529,
-0.0772686005,
-0.18483679,
-0.0959217399,
1.0248236656,
0.1512571126,
-0.3116602898,
0.0624092184,
-0.0209672526,
0.9197350144,
-0.0028930181,
1.0025367737,
0.8077313304,
0.4614427686,
-0.1777313203,
-1.2652920485,
-0.1201380789,
-0.4019274712,
-0.1821089685,
-0.0157045741,
-0.7178125381,
0.0849062279,
-0.1575603783,
-0.2932198048,
-0.22535716,
0.6549086571,
0.1845992655,
0.509626627,
0.5977864265,
0.158160463,
0.6322512627,
0.0219731331,
1.1256017685,
0.1091549098,
0.5875359774,
1.1849087477,
0.1443522573,
0.4429610372,
0.0525158569,
-0.4131372869,
0.2905699313,
0.8319292665,
-0.0461234637,
0.1146925539,
0.3116975427,
-0.1746472418,
0.0399863385,
-0.0593033768,
-0.3148002028,
0.6073688865,
0.1903495938,
-0.0966137946,
-0.5312082171,
-0.1914189756,
0.1820303947,
-0.1803475022,
-0.1428397745,
1.0222531557,
-0.0101018185,
-0.6756605506,
0.229781419,
0.0878106877,
0.4592599869,
-0.320476383,
-0.3476881683,
-0.290040195,
-0.4350267947,
-0.5883518457,
-0.8819494247,
0.3764396012,
0.4459996819,
-0.0113599133,
-0.0276232585,
0.6153665781,
-0.1357422769,
-0.1868167371,
-0.2251012921,
0.5078209043,
0.7495823503,
-0.2656348348,
-0.3883653879,
-0.2112669796,
0.2346986234,
-0.5287768245,
0.0262420624,
0.531850934,
-0.266451478,
0.698179245,
0.4444208145,
-0.2244480848,
-0.2290753871,
0.2762320936,
0.6570786238,
-0.7924026847,
-0.6030486822,
-1.1914470196,
0.4106281698,
-0.2754505575,
-0.5255928636,
0.8555749655,
0.8412524462,
0.2820801735,
-0.0453274623,
0.9029957056,
-0.190603748,
0.7425305843,
-0.3036279082,
0.9135289788,
0.0910067633,
0.2473415285,
-0.7310323119,
-1.1660628319,
-0.5622454882,
0.6070296168,
-0.3647049665,
0.1221543178,
0.6624215841,
0.3037265539,
0.1383343339,
0.487634629,
0.1631469876,
-0.2065776289,
0.4286364615,
0.2495167851,
0.9129878283,
-0.3291123807,
0.7603984475,
-0.1656364352,
-0.6630102396,
-0.1916070133,
-1.0755798817,
-1.1089377403,
-0.3989767432,
-0.2486489117,
-0.0137209306,
0.0554578863,
1.105348587,
0.4665995538,
-0.5749700665,
-0.085390985,
0.4276205599,
-0.1587233096,
-0.0767387152,
-0.286907196,
0.8856310844,
-0.2719551623,
-0.6316071749,
-0.0672513917,
0.357334137,
-0.0130885858,
-0.2100071013,
0.0799638554,
0.3780897856,
-0.3202403486,
0.7111484408,
-0.0449344218,
-0.3452165127,
-0.3635944724,
-0.2213605791,
0.0227585062,
0.1148485392,
0.7986366153,
-0.7231503725,
0.6861343384,
0.5494737029,
0.579654336,
0.6183075905,
0.6354874372,
0.7551093102,
-0.6824074388,
-0.0775610879,
0.201348871,
0.1751974076,
0.4951085746,
-0.2933544219,
0.7132382393,
0.0433365069,
-0.7173221111,
-0.3980539441,
-0.2860620618,
-1.1745390892,
0.3323638737,
0.9170879126,
-0.3797017336,
0.0428716764,
-0.3853573203,
-0.8262833357,
0.2698212266,
-0.5965595245,
1.092130661,
0.8875102997,
-0.6658056378,
-0.0246893186,
-0.549127996,
0.3849811256,
0.35695979,
-0.9202435613,
0.043275211,
0.5270981193,
0.2873604,
0.1080777645,
0.8668779135,
-0.0928006247,
0.5635278821,
-0.1007777154,
0.1499245763,
-0.1684553176,
0.2406849563,
-0.4538856447,
0.0325496867,
-0.0150860632,
-0.2805286944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02541v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02541v4 | PWESuite: Phonetic Word Embeddings and Tasks They Facilitate | 2023-04-05T16:03:42 | 2024-03-26T10:13:06 | Vilém Zouhar, Kalvin Chang, Chenxuan Cui, Nathaniel Carlson, Nathaniel Robinson, Mrinmaya Sachan, David Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mapping words into a fixed-dimensional vector space is the backbone of modern
NLP. While most word embedding methods successfully encode semantic
information, they overlook phonetic information that is crucial for many tasks.
We develop three methods that use articulatory features to build phonetically
informed word embeddings. To address the inconsistent evaluation of existing
phonetic word embedding methods, we also contribute a task suite to fairly
evaluate past, current, and future methods. We evaluate both (1) intrinsic
aspects of phonetic word embeddings, such as word retrieval and correlation
with sound similarity, and (2) extrinsic performance on tasks such as rhyme and
cognate detection and sound analogies. We hope our task suite will promote
reproducibility and inspire future phonetic embedding research. | [
-0.1316265315,
-0.2254780531,
0.3939487338,
0.4537909329,
-0.1853524894,
0.1242612898,
-0.3506768346,
-0.2939551771,
0.7595803142,
0.2966063917,
-0.2271436602,
-0.6175566316,
-0.5381603241,
-0.1479546577,
-0.194396615,
0.381043911,
-0.2742216587,
0.0012917034,
-0.1319329441,
-0.2768310905,
-0.7008856535,
-0.6493650079,
-0.4030123651,
-0.0858331919,
0.3294242918,
0.3028307855,
0.9115342498,
0.7905906439,
0.4385753572,
0.2217831463,
-0.0603772141,
-0.1270851642,
-0.2174778134,
0.4719039202,
-0.0481945723,
-0.4593625665,
-0.3091299832,
0.1665236652,
0.659580946,
1.1354349852,
-0.4144823551,
0.1855174899,
0.2165310234,
0.1728529632,
-0.7293643951,
0.3664013445,
-0.4465341568,
0.5523841977,
-0.3537471592,
-0.2446528673,
-0.0288286079,
-0.3216460645,
0.2989245057,
-0.9033246636,
0.0734349266,
0.2161354721,
0.3488185108,
0.1910723001,
0.0018039064,
-0.7846154571,
-0.5125907063,
0.9543543458,
-0.4299640059,
0.8538674116,
0.5302703381,
-0.1156623214,
-0.3469855487,
-0.9182137847,
-0.6581844687,
-0.3734186292,
0.3305804729,
0.3474210203,
-0.2214648873,
0.2396537811,
0.0832461715,
0.6729450226,
-0.409789592,
0.0692369267,
-0.0239212532,
-0.3631282747,
0.4000315964,
-0.2783860862,
0.6338302493,
-0.1373555511,
-0.254229039,
-0.5467757583,
-0.391987741,
-0.1028079689,
0.6362078786,
0.2823671997,
0.0153507115,
0.8817400336,
0.1796186119,
0.3448331356,
-0.204410553,
-0.2254510373,
0.4411773384,
0.0277803279,
-0.0670568123,
0.311897248,
0.4924890697,
0.0551603138,
-0.076782234,
-0.5415347815,
-0.1377560347,
0.0506474301,
0.26910761,
-0.1537146121,
-0.3925516307,
0.3654243946,
-0.4661557972,
-0.0701612085,
-0.0199355073,
-0.4371294379,
-0.3248728216,
-0.4962693155,
0.5547668934,
-0.7604487538,
-0.5795578361,
0.1332413107,
-1.065628767,
0.152286157,
0.0605711527,
-0.8701637983,
0.3903040588,
0.8359995484,
0.7175945044,
-0.0967274308,
-0.4917129576,
-0.5142614245,
0.1467753351,
-0.4620996714,
0.514854908,
-0.683998704,
-0.5189929008,
0.3328002691,
0.0900107473,
-0.1850414425,
-0.7813629508,
0.9065836072,
-0.1315413266,
0.0524738953,
-0.6602379084,
-0.8557110429,
-0.4034374058,
-0.261447221,
-0.5415756106,
1.0842032433,
0.1920876205,
-0.6465553641,
0.3814983964,
-0.46462062,
-0.395919472,
0.1624634117,
-0.1033848897,
0.1582292765,
0.3702699542,
0.0202324949,
0.497751683,
0.1197400168,
-0.2824014425,
-0.2783478796,
-0.4167730212,
-0.0551087409,
-0.1034365222,
0.7278900743,
0.0326418094,
-0.3596198261,
-0.1222144738,
-0.4615758061,
0.0309008472,
0.1312916577,
-0.2296386063,
-0.5566206574,
-0.0848238394,
0.1080991551,
-0.2872059047,
0.2755961716,
-0.8066065311,
0.0810366273,
-0.2794824839,
0.5250986814,
0.2240261883,
-0.1400969028,
0.6045593619,
-0.4310536087,
0.5745102167,
-0.1832489222,
-0.1446765214,
0.2775001824,
-0.8270325661,
-0.3225423098,
-0.515380621,
0.4964580238,
0.8597637415,
-0.571813345,
0.5471146107,
-0.0667022243,
-0.5010694861,
-0.633866787,
0.2279093862,
0.1833067536,
0.069542788,
0.368753612,
-0.5060548186,
-0.3976677656,
-0.681736052,
-0.3168567121,
-0.2613264322,
-0.2871206999,
-0.0343422107,
0.1233913526,
0.120389767,
0.4257090092,
-0.2254333943,
-0.4274384081,
-0.0951008722,
0.3049786091,
-0.0880329758,
0.40930897,
0.5598005652,
-0.313498497,
0.1459290683,
-0.258122921,
-0.6326515079,
-0.1157813668,
0.1169778034,
-0.0968382061,
-0.2601042688,
0.5413369536,
-0.5903568268,
0.2691864669,
0.527816534,
-0.0764561519,
0.3271772265,
-0.1424473077,
0.1129163057,
-0.7046518922,
-0.3145250082,
-0.2394946367,
0.0099385874,
-0.2640333772,
0.2531104088,
0.0488411374,
-0.4029518664,
-0.2717784047,
0.3477215767,
-0.747572422,
-0.2411016077,
-0.1361784339,
0.6261314154,
-0.0606005751,
0.3341766298,
0.2476563901,
0.5383782387,
0.5667048097,
-0.4790023267,
0.5018597245,
0.4192685485,
-0.2318011671,
0.5571671128,
-0.4917607605,
0.1933974028,
0.0158740152,
0.1025069654,
-1.0658471584,
-0.0399218351,
0.3366518319,
-0.4821490645,
0.5764219761,
-0.1448313892,
-0.5480570197,
-0.3581650257,
-0.5660126805,
0.4345441461,
0.5386016965,
-0.6184672117,
0.3197423518,
0.795104146,
-0.1389506161,
-0.3310638368,
-0.8132783771,
0.2226464003,
-0.3294596374,
-0.3674231768,
0.5810036063,
0.5867444277,
-0.1408392191,
0.1825288683,
-0.0737382323,
0.0767282099,
-0.1700479537,
0.2222178578,
-0.2709879577,
-0.281052351,
0.3005473614,
0.0145194242,
0.1894775033,
-0.0063295928,
-0.6516429186,
0.3793663979,
0.3048255146,
-0.4857481122,
-0.5432991385,
0.5518983603,
0.618670702,
-0.2820441723,
0.3704709411,
1.018176198,
-0.6629680991,
-0.0838188007,
-0.4686080217,
0.083654575,
-0.3656413853,
0.3848094642,
-0.3247945011,
-0.7049751878,
0.3732229471,
-0.2781836092,
0.0908079073,
0.3672710955,
0.1646728516,
-0.334526211,
0.4675747454,
0.3926858306,
0.0357268937,
0.3472625911,
-0.2194220573,
0.3980891407,
-1.2873897552,
-0.0770533234,
-0.4736881554,
-0.4380165637,
-0.6901176572,
-0.7852632999,
0.1856131703,
0.310292691,
0.2618308961,
0.5849961042,
-0.6473251581,
-0.353589952,
0.8449039459,
-0.0868822634,
-0.3512327671,
0.1582443118,
-0.4418171942,
-0.3006333709,
-0.9298253059,
-0.2970565856,
0.9393300414,
0.5577380657,
0.5385228992,
0.2438199371,
0.9953722954,
0.2618263364,
-0.4371272922,
-1.2101824284,
0.4232236743,
-0.3573269546,
0.1877625436,
-0.4087560475,
0.0685456693,
-1.0643516779,
-0.0200826563,
-0.3352785408,
-0.6355242133,
0.4333874285,
-0.0001842809,
-0.3571669757,
0.236315906,
-0.7649611831,
0.5801360011,
0.0722046196,
-0.1277624071,
-0.3110292256,
-0.0842345878,
-0.059891589,
0.3167340755,
0.063429676,
-0.0319197215,
-0.2314133346,
1.206133008,
-0.525143981,
0.7376605868,
-0.4473716021,
-0.2611187398,
0.2865352333,
0.0792039111,
0.3539038897,
-0.1944066137,
-0.0395583324,
0.213926971,
0.4626968801,
-0.2935180366,
-0.6490356922,
0.8144284487,
-0.4146801829,
-0.4570795298,
-0.4241340458,
-0.4468359053,
-0.4426397383,
-0.180084452,
0.1110619232,
0.7215464711,
-0.1993685365,
0.1385907978,
0.4436133206,
-0.3941032588,
0.4071949422,
-0.1969383955,
0.0383431688,
-0.447078824,
0.9660081267,
0.3050589859,
-0.2065221816,
0.4551638961,
0.3027318418,
-0.5920565128,
-0.608499527,
-0.3249147832,
0.1519249082,
-0.6441737413,
0.0436209999,
-0.5140519738,
0.0693136081,
-0.5631294847,
-0.0048744269,
-0.358202219,
-0.9386501312,
-0.1236712039,
0.0994381756,
0.5349356532,
0.9699710608,
-0.4913313389,
0.1086754203,
-0.6941404343,
0.5064771771,
0.4183697999,
0.1859156042,
-0.0148676597,
-0.3019019365,
-0.0527011007,
0.1451866329,
-0.2339096665,
-1.0069134235,
0.0094668902,
0.4253812432,
0.8109603524,
0.1596484482,
0.0695779175,
0.5799160004,
-0.6332659125,
1.1223951578,
0.1040751711,
-1.0657855272,
0.5462896824,
-0.2065235376,
0.0422352813,
0.237315461,
0.3589278758,
-0.5233469605,
-0.5775980949,
-0.5665385723,
-1.0287050009,
-0.0092989719,
0.3466635346,
0.1480849534,
-0.5363488793,
0.3407294452,
0.0788743347,
0.1895550787,
0.2834925056,
-0.095075734,
-0.3933787942,
-0.2795289755,
0.1968683302,
-0.4259221852,
-0.0467351861,
-0.2511545122,
0.4353303611,
0.2661283314,
0.7359967828,
0.5762804747,
-0.2273304015,
0.3007377684,
0.0291846823,
0.4487907588,
0.4200044572,
-0.1038546115,
0.184997648,
0.1354547888,
-1.0365513563,
0.0001723688,
0.0753699392,
0.3992955983,
0.4118295908,
0.6336124539,
0.7479410768,
0.4573678672,
-0.3156895936,
0.5938028693,
0.0763050839,
-0.2659451962,
-0.6629564166,
-0.0779873803,
0.186432302,
0.2154978663,
0.2542255223,
-0.0729391724,
0.3819299936,
-0.755037725,
0.229927212,
0.5329310298,
-0.4814365804,
-0.2997108996,
0.5690042973,
-0.0167178363,
-0.3462854028,
0.4591494501,
-0.373681277,
-0.585216403,
0.2694021463,
0.4373103678,
0.9709404707,
-0.4048387408,
0.0541840009,
0.2970786393,
0.2837310731,
-0.309798032,
0.6702644229,
-0.2984912694,
-0.5476124287,
-0.275505662,
-0.6405441165,
-0.4299161434,
-0.025521569,
-0.9084430933,
0.1883202046,
-0.3041682839,
-0.3391240239,
-0.0531672686,
-0.2191694081,
-0.9067153335,
0.133861348,
0.1492235959,
0.9645437598,
-0.502071619,
0.4683562815,
0.9455615878,
-0.1397448927,
-0.8571328521,
0.3338607252,
-0.0375894345,
-0.987978518,
0.5528153777,
-0.1905237585,
-0.3077884614,
0.033462882,
0.0961887464,
-0.8492413163,
1.0021035671,
0.2468404621,
-0.5383560658,
0.0812868103,
0.0899502337,
0.2863714099,
-0.1075394303,
0.0180988293,
0.3774476945,
0.4452763796,
-0.0428271331,
-1.1213784218,
0.1524171233,
-0.0534557104,
0.08313182,
-0.0859640986,
-0.1510447264,
0.3195456266,
0.021026019,
-0.3991075158,
0.2211543471,
0.7300866842,
-0.0002809763,
-0.0709361807,
0.6165812016,
0.9719320536,
1.2078691721,
-0.1112555638,
0.9471790195,
-0.4198586047,
-0.1121792197,
0.9612080455,
-0.154881075,
1.1618827581,
0.5387516022,
-0.2898978293,
0.1808251441,
0.4167624712,
0.2059316039,
0.5596373677,
0.6963147521,
-0.2765301168,
0.1272966862,
-0.262159884,
-0.4629791677,
0.9273062944,
0.6221815944,
-0.1256391257,
0.0249186531,
0.2916789353,
-0.1763856113,
-0.0321129635,
-0.0748594925,
0.6585990191,
0.2134206444,
-0.3206630051,
0.4893285632,
-0.0950703025,
0.7456019521,
-0.3868066967,
-0.3104288578,
0.1398883611,
-0.1712657958,
-0.1273204833,
-0.9332317114,
0.4811467528,
-0.6631882787,
0.2304270566,
-0.1939995289,
0.5608958006,
-0.4940830767,
-0.105364494,
0.4845429361,
0.3914833367,
0.258487463,
-0.1793559939,
-0.3025228083,
0.2100229412,
-0.2790702581,
0.1133514568,
-0.0088586155,
0.7825456262,
0.0244462155,
0.2391884923,
0.4670223892,
0.4512989819,
0.1587620974,
0.2757432163,
0.2252561599,
-0.5610333681,
-0.5350200534,
-0.2728049457,
-0.0057721189,
0.1036408171,
-0.3266207576,
0.7620171905,
0.4374509156,
0.6792626381,
-0.191353932,
0.8995757103,
0.0810715184,
0.5850515962,
-0.7322066426,
0.6163875461,
-0.4032694995,
-0.0716939121,
-0.3561430573,
-0.9307137132,
-0.1339657307,
0.9131923914,
-0.0382511318,
-0.264390558,
0.9193879962,
0.3832779825,
-0.2806841731,
0.4226556718,
0.268656373,
-0.0743839219,
-0.1697314531,
0.2012419254,
0.857432127,
-0.483615756,
0.1611125469,
-0.5082426667,
-0.3226898909,
0.1004064158,
-0.8785008788,
-0.6265926361,
-1.0026174784,
-0.6503686309,
-0.1315868497,
-0.0241266564,
0.8849349618,
0.5546298027,
-0.6373762488,
-0.1960519254,
0.0409291983,
-0.0620447323,
-0.6172571778,
-0.2376757562,
0.5239055157,
-0.4061917365,
-0.573407352,
0.6613529921,
0.3559283614,
-0.0677568316,
-0.0556026548,
0.2582038343,
0.1522595137,
-0.1613398939,
0.6731676459,
0.298627913,
-0.7919521332,
-0.5614144206,
0.0464538969,
0.2882913351,
-0.2372706085,
0.9863836169,
-0.373565644,
0.2038626224,
0.6608237624,
0.6424311399,
0.0646917149,
-0.4800269902,
0.8816413283,
-0.7939909101,
0.3988342285,
0.3435478508,
0.6329413652,
0.4796689153,
-0.3006348014,
0.2213837504,
0.2341271341,
-0.2882451415,
-0.6553906202,
0.0561897047,
-1.134297967,
0.0125438003,
1.0654108524,
-0.17666547,
-0.1854131371,
-0.3778359592,
-0.1387444437,
0.4320077598,
-0.2339016348,
0.4053229094,
0.8880866766,
-0.1128079146,
-0.0365070179,
-0.7809790969,
0.7076657414,
0.4120090306,
0.0124455243,
-0.0360308439,
0.0357626565,
0.1418341547,
0.4665442705,
0.3956790268,
-0.1691315323,
0.2209118605,
0.3365166485,
0.2189165652,
0.1071651354,
-0.162613824,
-0.0287043843,
0.1843188405,
0.311671108,
-0.8958132267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02496v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02496v1 | Evaluation of ChatGPT Family of Models for Biomedical Reasoning and Classification | 2023-04-05T15:11:25 | 2023-04-05T15:11:25 | Shan Chen, Yingya Li, Sheng Lu, Hoang Van, Hugo JWL Aerts, Guergana K. Savova, Danielle S. Bitterman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive ability
in biomedical question-answering, but have not been adequately investigated for
more specific biomedical applications. This study investigates the performance
of LLMs such as the ChatGPT family of models (GPT-3.5s, GPT-4) in biomedical
tasks beyond question-answering. Because no patient data can be passed to the
OpenAI API public interface, we evaluated model performance with over 10000
samples as proxies for two fundamental tasks in the clinical domain -
classification and reasoning. The first task is classifying whether statements
of clinical and policy recommendations in scientific literature constitute
health advice. The second task is causal relation detection from the biomedical
literature. We compared LLMs with simpler models, such as bag-of-words (BoW)
with logistic regression, and fine-tuned BioBERT models. Despite the excitement
around viral ChatGPT, we found that fine-tuning for two fundamental NLP tasks
remained the best strategy. The simple BoW model performed on par with the most
complex LLM prompting. Prompt engineering required significant investment. | [
0.0061432603,
-0.7962002754,
0.7738729715,
0.2284629941,
-0.1492124796,
-0.0992188305,
-0.1139475778,
-0.632345736,
-0.2441776842,
0.4783554673,
-0.4190562963,
-0.5350971818,
-0.6223361492,
0.2469081581,
-0.1427138001,
1.1447081566,
-0.0231530294,
0.3565128446,
-0.2669852674,
0.041373644,
-0.4271408916,
-0.5641997457,
-0.9313305616,
-0.5315580368,
0.8245152235,
0.0576332994,
0.5786919594,
0.2158807665,
0.8136084676,
0.1755712777,
-0.3295094073,
0.165315181,
-0.4057913423,
0.1213454157,
-0.2295105904,
-0.4788999856,
-0.4508709908,
-0.0178683344,
0.3466116786,
0.7528035045,
0.0055201841,
0.1495934427,
0.0187274516,
0.3805606067,
-0.1824621856,
0.3693619967,
-0.350852102,
-0.0798905492,
-0.0493704714,
-0.3372884989,
-0.5611650348,
-0.3833747208,
0.5334937572,
-0.3841244876,
0.1382089555,
0.2470037937,
0.7479365468,
0.2825594842,
-0.2653942108,
-0.3562049568,
-0.6118630767,
0.5556958914,
-0.8076149821,
0.3324732184,
0.4242609143,
0.1495846957,
-0.4864799976,
-0.7824776173,
-0.1656960845,
-0.4506488442,
0.0105055599,
0.2571672201,
-0.4186210334,
0.4163683951,
0.2751100957,
0.0176275894,
-0.8372588754,
0.2448305041,
-0.5541923642,
-0.1006829888,
0.3466234803,
0.14189744,
0.3596372306,
-0.2813911736,
-0.2662723064,
0.2376531661,
-0.870842576,
-0.036652226,
-0.2102168053,
0.2276206315,
-0.0152805466,
0.7337401509,
-0.1986804008,
0.6078418493,
-0.270090431,
-0.1635973454,
-0.1445333362,
-0.3232400417,
-0.2634811103,
-0.1490442157,
0.7163857222,
0.3106133044,
0.1195233613,
-0.3691551685,
0.1540958136,
0.0163757503,
0.1633116007,
-0.95939219,
-0.2857315838,
0.3892588913,
-0.6699407101,
-0.2279012203,
-0.5439558029,
-0.432818383,
-0.4675920308,
-0.2289875299,
0.4227599502,
-0.6256976724,
-0.009083949,
0.473228693,
-0.087879844,
0.3644302189,
0.5664849877,
-0.5795809031,
0.3328559697,
0.6827112436,
1.0723680258,
-0.1687629372,
0.0281186514,
-0.3865999579,
-0.0134928208,
-0.088875778,
1.0937292576,
-0.4375454485,
-0.4373633265,
-0.2076940835,
-0.0174690578,
-0.3908877969,
-0.4754826427,
0.6060207486,
-0.4858086705,
0.0852224827,
-0.3246345818,
-0.7784285545,
-0.2019974887,
0.1900637299,
-0.3240246177,
0.4636334479,
0.005553036,
-0.7687188387,
0.2447413057,
-0.871435523,
-0.2843285501,
0.4377111197,
-0.1166276187,
-0.3223305643,
-0.1849234402,
0.1282181442,
0.6738240123,
-0.627694726,
0.2202568948,
-0.5661891699,
-0.3373786211,
0.3877541125,
-0.2606034577,
0.6656352878,
0.2619241774,
-0.0988984555,
0.0866934657,
-0.4372599423,
-0.1620919406,
-0.0768575296,
-0.258928895,
-0.187643826,
0.1448075771,
-0.1908515543,
0.1465198547,
0.0310993958,
-0.6686531901,
0.362657845,
-0.4006563425,
0.6935320497,
0.4156498611,
0.0670100749,
-0.0849154517,
-0.3601273894,
0.5594131351,
-0.0975224972,
0.1881171614,
-0.0032647888,
-1.0762940645,
-0.4094420373,
-0.3148173988,
0.275788784,
0.7000908852,
-0.6082500815,
0.0827962458,
-0.2246421725,
-0.4659838676,
-0.3886805475,
-0.2064711899,
0.2669819295,
0.5350624323,
0.4603891969,
0.1080554202,
-0.1506420374,
-0.8800452948,
-0.1835526079,
-0.4598405361,
-0.1390667111,
0.4210637212,
0.6181827188,
-0.4252591133,
0.6162981987,
-0.4823677242,
0.1320979297,
-0.1110509634,
0.3513381481,
0.2385989279,
0.1994833499,
0.3470158875,
-0.4750466347,
-0.0544527955,
0.2764625549,
-0.6385287046,
-0.2966198325,
0.0977304652,
-0.0231875665,
-0.1741583347,
0.3514448404,
-0.7856908441,
0.431401521,
0.3307600617,
-0.3201777935,
0.6608988643,
-0.148010388,
0.1168918386,
-0.665476799,
0.2106929719,
0.0804143548,
-0.2933863699,
-0.7778704762,
-0.064594999,
-0.0900137126,
-0.1697693765,
-0.3083592951,
0.6093708277,
-0.1580640674,
0.136288777,
-0.3063119948,
-0.0971174166,
-0.1682615876,
0.3711719215,
0.1864140928,
0.5871608853,
0.5428495407,
-0.5337154269,
0.430031836,
0.392955482,
-0.2248908281,
0.2744531929,
-0.9939522147,
0.1371015757,
-0.2786120474,
0.3188388944,
-1.0352823734,
-0.2747263014,
0.3397470713,
-0.4451339543,
0.2008387297,
-0.2742885947,
-0.5323449373,
-0.551201582,
-0.0669763684,
0.2442605495,
0.6007513404,
-0.2568207383,
0.1980874538,
0.1814066023,
-0.5603350401,
-0.1671986282,
-0.5640700459,
-0.1364544183,
-0.2345657051,
-0.6354124546,
0.1319863498,
0.0813849643,
-0.0756831318,
-0.0486517027,
-0.1117995456,
-0.0372412018,
-0.1367907673,
0.1581760943,
0.5130764246,
-0.3290790617,
0.5097596049,
0.0367219113,
0.0112746945,
-0.017886702,
-0.1891811788,
0.3744160235,
-0.3129264712,
-0.4141329825,
-0.1805810332,
0.1520043164,
0.3728734553,
-0.1151156053,
0.7067247629,
0.4493391216,
-0.3166456223,
0.2220993191,
-0.5715484619,
-0.1567397267,
-0.363473326,
0.4118482769,
-0.1802879423,
-1.0748745203,
0.4072823524,
-0.1411324441,
0.18265149,
0.2346338928,
0.6989197731,
-0.1347366869,
1.009993434,
0.0239047352,
0.0942161754,
-0.0852405801,
0.0372480638,
0.2815882564,
-0.6819245219,
-0.1205981299,
-0.587749958,
0.0031407189,
-0.6692919731,
-0.5899621248,
0.6898876429,
0.0665221512,
-0.3343987465,
0.1569984108,
-0.3931360841,
0.0657336861,
0.3679470122,
0.5506737828,
0.3141180277,
-0.1928661317,
0.152705878,
0.4290341437,
-0.955911994,
-0.6779380441,
1.0753189325,
0.6094099879,
0.8384580612,
-0.0208934322,
0.3156449795,
-0.0496696234,
0.452445209,
-0.7849068046,
0.590574801,
-0.2189498395,
-0.4619703889,
-0.217699632,
-0.4251296818,
-1.2354743481,
0.1689723134,
-0.1089480072,
-0.8213264942,
0.0655195639,
0.0624055453,
-0.6942293048,
0.1427658349,
-0.7221498489,
0.8332825899,
-0.0472822413,
-0.2750458419,
-0.1319483966,
-0.6590259671,
0.49592489,
-0.0127164396,
0.0874968916,
-0.2761974633,
-0.0268485174,
0.6834965348,
-0.2692477107,
0.7732382417,
0.048518613,
0.1017072052,
0.2802731693,
-0.2065862715,
0.2905692756,
0.1284301877,
-0.0132523142,
0.2274788022,
0.5002055168,
-0.3242453635,
-0.5213954449,
0.5548852086,
-0.6932728291,
-0.5322218537,
-0.2114442736,
-0.3450896442,
-0.4677420259,
0.0443364941,
0.2627073228,
0.6333116889,
-0.0617604703,
0.2626188695,
0.7213415504,
-0.614821732,
0.0158424992,
0.4752222896,
-0.257640034,
0.0683179274,
0.6530796885,
-0.1218290478,
0.3210317194,
0.3928527236,
0.3589366972,
-0.3573358357,
-0.7947669625,
-0.3044945002,
0.5608820319,
-0.4815642536,
-0.2179805636,
-0.7231555581,
-0.3769049048,
-0.5338668227,
0.2344119549,
-0.0139390361,
-0.1509342641,
-0.1067534834,
0.0911645144,
0.5491205454,
0.7261574864,
0.1958098561,
0.1855287254,
-0.9478130341,
0.3434920609,
0.2406789064,
0.4721488357,
-0.3104548454,
-0.3797225654,
-0.0464834794,
0.0578945465,
-0.2713363469,
-1.016043067,
0.1397858113,
0.0629448667,
0.364893347,
0.2413860559,
-0.2648767531,
0.5216183662,
-0.5727010965,
0.6344225407,
-0.0312630013,
-0.4368427694,
0.4652527273,
-0.6210926771,
0.2761904299,
0.2004528642,
0.6016776562,
-0.5687131286,
-0.3268554807,
-0.4284676909,
-0.4888783991,
0.5768561959,
0.4488411844,
-0.3399793506,
-0.1235693991,
0.5002452731,
0.0272678379,
0.0919462889,
-0.4990511835,
0.0077715241,
0.1474192291,
-0.0638851523,
0.044138629,
-0.0509844869,
0.033501558,
-0.2365319431,
0.5329173207,
-0.1553218514,
0.6033573151,
0.4849621058,
0.1782639027,
0.1559554338,
0.365429908,
0.489785254,
0.2767453194,
-0.2043736875,
-0.1437614709,
0.0991805643,
-0.480353117,
-0.0542256981,
0.2962621748,
-0.0902291536,
-0.1772201657,
0.5397473574,
0.918741703,
0.2147644758,
-0.8611829281,
0.3961239457,
-0.0759481564,
-0.2075400054,
0.091758959,
0.1119855195,
0.193048209,
0.272565335,
-0.2311191112,
0.0548706688,
0.4679588377,
-0.3661340475,
0.0247749239,
0.4603032768,
-0.2144905329,
-0.2746631503,
0.6822142005,
0.0225559585,
-0.0205889586,
0.5071703792,
0.1169018149,
-0.2593232691,
0.4442059994,
0.3628154993,
0.6220357418,
-0.2422146946,
0.3321302533,
0.3042729795,
0.089319557,
-0.1611700952,
0.1991367638,
0.1277084202,
-0.7390044928,
-0.6553667188,
-0.6415733695,
-0.6259687543,
0.3206828833,
-0.429557085,
0.4096418023,
-0.1394323856,
-0.2149323374,
0.3531926274,
-0.3112432063,
-0.7133206129,
0.1062154993,
0.1521542966,
0.817784667,
-0.5001320839,
0.7068151832,
0.7307143211,
-0.4418724477,
-0.8037880063,
-0.2950288653,
-0.1254453957,
-0.8030079007,
0.7429338098,
0.0765135139,
0.0226029996,
-0.102055259,
-0.6252147555,
-0.6976723671,
0.7820730805,
0.1197464243,
-0.488553226,
-0.4133418798,
0.2750020325,
0.74586761,
-0.005876522,
0.5172323585,
0.6620082259,
0.3529850841,
0.3287318945,
-1.1813133955,
-0.0859222189,
-0.1729772687,
-0.1457843632,
-0.0830845535,
-0.5548817515,
0.5235816836,
-0.1909386516,
-0.0312425327,
0.2909727991,
0.2689416707,
0.5487091541,
0.2016520947,
0.2478385717,
0.155988425,
0.8214659095,
-0.1853315234,
1.2281601429,
-0.1092141569,
0.2338944077,
0.6589846611,
-0.4237407446,
0.7370283008,
0.1486315727,
-0.5083121657,
0.2420483381,
0.7070699334,
0.024344353,
0.2834361792,
0.3973849118,
-0.3377328515,
-0.2382487357,
0.0428056233,
-0.3826275766,
0.3162463605,
0.6634114385,
-0.1019501388,
-0.1771290302,
0.2325865477,
0.0259678531,
-0.5243430138,
-0.4032570422,
0.7604995966,
0.220469743,
-0.7574820518,
0.4728970528,
-0.1453489363,
0.4226339757,
-0.6014091372,
-0.0524727441,
0.0045877635,
0.0503635071,
-0.0486951545,
-0.7401984334,
0.2541667819,
0.0808962956,
0.0785128698,
0.0375411436,
1.0501681566,
-0.2613009512,
-0.4122132957,
0.0743202344,
0.4087370038,
0.5292850733,
-0.0121599073,
-0.638949275,
-0.2019590586,
-0.1801266521,
-0.3316011429,
0.1650238484,
0.2911360562,
-0.1051806286,
0.8555788994,
0.5804978013,
0.3609148562,
0.0425107218,
0.0519914292,
0.6861046553,
-0.5948190093,
-0.195650056,
-0.7847777009,
0.026435595,
0.0273959301,
-0.1505806297,
0.5143113732,
0.2783519924,
0.2243440151,
-0.1732736081,
0.8416951895,
0.2822533548,
0.8371848464,
-0.5617690682,
0.5106804967,
-0.3407240808,
0.2043505013,
-0.3385184109,
-0.4400100112,
-0.4947521985,
0.4340274036,
-0.6310712099,
0.1317100674,
0.8422026038,
0.7050823569,
0.1663036793,
0.5294530392,
0.3495896161,
0.3976971805,
0.5177717209,
0.7038592696,
0.9255351424,
-0.2477198392,
0.2817207277,
0.1424838901,
-0.4823687375,
-0.116031453,
-0.7026451826,
-1.030644536,
-0.2187981755,
-0.4086642861,
-0.2149624527,
0.3058776855,
0.8959627748,
0.7243234515,
-0.6938744783,
0.0209786035,
-0.1899998933,
-0.2014518231,
-0.1143003255,
-0.1362389028,
0.4731571972,
-0.4917942882,
-0.4318729639,
0.3762886822,
0.5455058217,
0.0067657651,
-0.0397822969,
0.1592884213,
-0.0552896075,
0.0954585224,
0.8464880586,
0.3109025657,
-0.8004236221,
-0.1612588614,
0.2825270891,
-0.1020070389,
-0.0111873196,
0.7540538907,
-0.6539078951,
0.1795906126,
0.5089944005,
0.7735764384,
0.4243489206,
-0.0115667786,
0.5392152071,
-0.0920496881,
-0.1545705646,
0.3951353729,
0.4608857334,
0.1237946227,
-0.2916169167,
0.6068811417,
0.2229259461,
-1.0986288786,
-0.5648226738,
0.0530103408,
-1.0881524086,
-0.3397147954,
1.376983285,
-0.1480488926,
-0.0918723494,
-0.503459394,
-0.5982395411,
0.1475570053,
-0.1706877947,
0.5329086185,
0.6929821968,
-0.6576185822,
-0.0290941317,
-0.9690631032,
0.602491498,
0.4488025606,
-1.0328193903,
0.0107281646,
0.3766961098,
0.1980453134,
-0.079551585,
0.8227781057,
-0.3003043234,
0.3677269816,
-0.2139672339,
-0.0956809148,
0.2628795803,
-0.0299956612,
-0.2028306723,
0.0218488313,
0.1753692627,
-0.0586020611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02492v1 | Quantifying the Roles of Visual, Linguistic, and Visual-Linguistic Complexity in Verb Acquisition | 2023-04-05T15:08:21 | 2023-04-05T15:08:21 | Yuchen Zhou, Michael J. Tarr, Daniel Yurovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Children typically learn the meanings of nouns earlier than the meanings of
verbs. However, it is unclear whether this asymmetry is a result of complexity
in the visual structure of categories in the world to which language refers,
the structure of language itself, or the interplay between the two sources of
information. We quantitatively test these three hypotheses regarding early verb
learning by employing visual and linguistic representations of words sourced
from large-scale pre-trained artificial neural networks. Examining the
structure of both visual and linguistic embedding spaces, we find, first, that
the representation of verbs is generally more variable and less discriminable
within domain than the representation of nouns. Second, we find that if only
one learning instance per category is available, visual and linguistic
representations are less well aligned in the verb system than in the noun
system. However, in parallel with the course of human language development, if
multiple learning instances per category are available, visual and linguistic
representations become almost as well aligned in the verb system as in the noun
system. Third, we compare the relative contributions of factors that may
predict learning difficulty for individual words. A regression analysis reveals
that visual variability is the strongest factor that internally drives verb
learning, followed by visual-linguistic alignment and linguistic variability.
Based on these results, we conclude that verb acquisition is influenced by all
three sources of complexity, but that the variability of visual structure poses
the most significant challenge for verb learning. | [
-0.395686239,
-0.8433578014,
0.6292754412,
0.1139673293,
-0.2605268955,
0.0896712989,
-0.1701651514,
-0.4280168414,
-0.2272112221,
-0.2381342947,
-0.377658695,
-0.0000947363,
-1.106872797,
-0.0266823359,
-0.0152939428,
0.3861245811,
-0.104489401,
0.2200549543,
-0.3738276362,
-0.0444747843,
-0.6944855452,
-0.4138466418,
-0.5318855643,
-0.4799225926,
0.6135273576,
0.4108868539,
0.812702477,
0.9332461357,
0.655256629,
0.4550332725,
-0.0770207942,
-0.0221496895,
-0.1574734002,
0.2086375654,
-0.2745678723,
-0.7008304,
-0.0395390354,
-0.2110789567,
0.4624627233,
1.0026533604,
-0.0062303096,
0.1576690376,
0.0333895981,
0.8509303927,
-0.6438865066,
0.7566695213,
-0.2023891807,
0.1385789216,
-0.2698945999,
0.0608574897,
0.0122547438,
0.0159838554,
0.4267060161,
-0.4264385104,
0.2018064111,
0.1341405213,
1.1996181011,
0.1969387978,
-0.6836844683,
-0.527494669,
-0.7283763885,
0.689504385,
-0.0883828178,
0.6843622923,
0.447748512,
0.1011804491,
-0.31833902,
-0.4611233771,
-0.5349395871,
-0.3282169402,
-0.1202802435,
-0.0476724952,
-0.2383938134,
0.0988521427,
0.1589092165,
0.1095754877,
-0.5755885243,
0.2826956213,
-0.6520859599,
0.0274230223,
0.5033444166,
0.0857229531,
0.7276336551,
-0.4932081103,
-0.3746021986,
-0.2722428143,
-0.6034716964,
0.2272931188,
0.316624999,
0.5372397304,
-0.0579769798,
0.96351403,
0.200653404,
0.5662363768,
-0.2299802899,
-0.1102562323,
0.2004516572,
-0.3843695521,
-0.1715320051,
-0.0993408933,
0.6742374897,
-0.0801823214,
0.4462808669,
0.2743426561,
-0.4487925768,
0.2963861823,
0.4581264257,
-0.2662862539,
-0.1569498479,
-0.2743289769,
-0.3017781973,
0.1410601288,
0.5327550173,
-0.6036272049,
-0.3079761863,
-0.3555927873,
0.5759782195,
-0.5224307179,
-0.1745539755,
0.1407596022,
-0.111667186,
0.4425970316,
0.3358739316,
-1.0138764381,
0.6010859013,
0.7211170197,
0.6900382638,
-0.2202527374,
-0.6751655936,
-0.0612451509,
-0.1863925308,
-0.4520121813,
0.4792797565,
-0.4096535146,
-0.0750779957,
0.0341961756,
-0.0043043746,
0.0369937755,
-0.4573630989,
-0.1479008198,
-0.5724694729,
0.0556703843,
-0.1920806915,
-0.6695077419,
-0.4764894247,
-0.1888122857,
-0.7930794954,
0.5694123507,
0.1662758589,
-0.378672421,
0.7656385303,
-0.2129401118,
-0.515506506,
0.0138008017,
-0.7193408012,
-0.2527934015,
0.7101638913,
0.0467731319,
0.6292060018,
-0.1412712336,
0.0597937517,
0.2830473185,
-0.1229008064,
0.2442927212,
-0.239414379,
0.6178258657,
-0.0384409986,
-0.6444595456,
-0.0277481116,
-0.5403846502,
-0.3409366012,
0.4207062423,
-0.2769177258,
-0.2494553775,
0.2534101903,
-0.3673017621,
0.0744756535,
0.0825909823,
-0.3056522906,
-0.0664539412,
-0.242806524,
0.0371029861,
0.7879193425,
-0.041888617,
0.5461567044,
-0.0289988499,
0.7013372779,
0.4394685924,
0.1706986725,
-0.075734362,
-0.5802081227,
-0.9044205546,
0.0433561765,
-0.0062937359,
0.3340112567,
-0.703763485,
0.0429860055,
-0.3733615279,
-0.2496917695,
-0.185498476,
0.6440281272,
0.7072254419,
-0.0797490999,
0.2243111134,
-0.6381633282,
-0.3212556243,
-0.7821965814,
-0.083970882,
-0.7325884104,
0.1383946389,
0.3641752005,
0.5805936456,
0.0143629154,
0.3915242553,
-0.3535097539,
-0.3563911617,
-0.2173322588,
0.08080405,
0.024430396,
0.3750802577,
0.5013201833,
-0.7728070021,
-0.2387834638,
0.0533638187,
-0.4780620933,
0.1974531859,
-0.0715504065,
0.0353263989,
0.3829190135,
0.6187278032,
-0.6397438645,
0.5381813645,
0.2701158226,
-0.8079869747,
0.0933715403,
-0.3517773151,
-0.1692989022,
-0.3209036887,
-0.4150519073,
-0.0588815324,
0.0530087985,
-0.5804648399,
0.0706985518,
-0.0479323827,
0.2567541003,
-0.4487937689,
0.3018909991,
-0.869461596,
-0.1539366394,
0.0256060474,
0.2334324419,
-0.1393973529,
0.4991639853,
-0.2990681529,
0.4604469538,
0.6590007544,
-0.7493422627,
0.4495052695,
-0.274551332,
-0.4773789644,
0.3914625049,
-0.7197021246,
-0.2215615213,
-0.6528605819,
-0.5602686405,
-1.2937879562,
-0.35122329,
0.0928104073,
-0.6283444166,
0.5637977123,
0.1648018211,
-0.4492987096,
-0.1275269836,
0.1348043382,
0.4108170271,
0.5658665299,
-0.2589795291,
0.5806676745,
0.3710491657,
-0.0151552819,
-0.41139552,
-0.6136831045,
-0.2398869246,
0.0825178772,
-0.316719979,
-0.031107014,
0.4702269435,
-0.5226917267,
0.2003313154,
-0.3447027504,
-0.0234134328,
0.0574724004,
0.5145094991,
0.3258105516,
-0.5093047023,
0.8041688204,
-0.4399714172,
0.1331588924,
0.1555477083,
-0.3370860219,
0.433362931,
-0.5042023659,
-0.4882514179,
0.0256940331,
0.1176767051,
0.6082859635,
-0.0648069754,
0.7626090646,
0.2867661715,
-0.3859806359,
-0.227381289,
-0.2783022225,
0.2001105398,
-0.4009778202,
0.6071556211,
-0.4969629645,
-0.682000339,
0.2796325386,
0.2887477577,
-0.2549280822,
0.5469776988,
0.3764936626,
-0.1858019978,
0.5857706666,
0.8416821361,
0.3199351132,
0.5653893948,
-0.312059015,
-0.0348251686,
-0.2840492725,
-0.7301581502,
-0.3489443958,
-0.4585456848,
-0.7295953035,
-0.5797382593,
-0.0293742493,
0.2045068145,
-0.509482801,
0.1393839568,
-0.0229326468,
0.4360353053,
0.634252727,
0.1472554803,
0.0754433051,
0.1577418298,
-0.1446796656,
-0.0875461698,
-0.6858671308,
-0.2891918719,
0.8658279181,
0.2627947628,
0.8136569858,
0.6464392543,
0.6628651023,
-0.1483182013,
-0.2530782223,
-1.1646760702,
0.4094051421,
-0.3271418214,
-0.3171950877,
-0.4698714614,
-0.2562196255,
-1.3566594124,
0.3769914508,
-0.2901450396,
-0.6010017395,
0.5052942038,
0.0542145036,
-0.1516982317,
0.1896147281,
-0.9808697104,
0.6407938004,
-0.4073133767,
-0.4423856735,
0.058107987,
-0.7375276089,
0.0641501471,
-0.0896095335,
0.3532181978,
0.0594945997,
-0.5140011311,
0.6630122662,
-0.4282079041,
0.7500159144,
-0.1254329532,
-0.0452725627,
0.3714109957,
0.2070790231,
0.0423310995,
-0.2527535856,
0.5057423711,
-0.1276147664,
-0.3315418959,
-0.5918801427,
-0.92282933,
0.3582252562,
-1.0932656527,
-0.7347537875,
-0.562936902,
-0.1351794153,
-0.0741617829,
0.2084684372,
0.2327519208,
0.3024997413,
-0.0462818295,
0.2848680317,
0.4952768981,
-0.1679836065,
0.4624506533,
0.0613269433,
-0.4442332387,
-0.0791445449,
0.8373462558,
0.3793581724,
0.462685585,
0.3640867472,
0.2783180475,
-0.1256716251,
-0.5797361732,
0.0157260578,
0.2612654269,
-0.9539538026,
-0.0466810353,
-0.2477944344,
-0.0767132193,
-0.0475113615,
-0.0826899186,
-0.440608263,
-0.221825406,
-0.4755675197,
-0.2347512841,
0.3108460605,
1.3429396152,
0.0008536635,
0.5235683322,
-0.5615919828,
0.4597503841,
0.6204836965,
0.5403182507,
0.2328872979,
-0.4828261137,
-0.2286459357,
-0.2298472077,
0.0810234398,
-0.8308980465,
0.1716309041,
0.6485518813,
0.6094546914,
0.4861670434,
-0.5860637426,
0.7881663442,
-0.6450777054,
0.9181627035,
0.3584448695,
-0.9158169031,
0.577481389,
0.1525266469,
0.4248325527,
0.2614763677,
0.5454554558,
-0.0917670503,
-0.1171709597,
-0.7591253519,
-0.9774397016,
0.5385201573,
0.0666684136,
0.2837126851,
-0.0865524933,
0.3377438188,
0.1097391844,
-0.0213562008,
-0.5529776216,
-0.3475152552,
-0.1758303046,
-0.0222093221,
-0.6233944297,
-0.2177719027,
0.1256452948,
-0.511043191,
0.1250769794,
0.1006159335,
0.3652287424,
0.1054080352,
-0.5250270963,
-0.0575348325,
0.0137216141,
0.5571574569,
0.5568841696,
0.1553860903,
0.7479342222,
-0.2593677938,
-0.7343557477,
0.5177466869,
-0.496088028,
0.2349331528,
0.0814915895,
0.9762391448,
1.2300418615,
0.2759039104,
-0.5699653625,
0.6595656872,
-0.0106765535,
-0.0269047264,
-0.3186252415,
0.2489714175,
-0.0425693356,
0.3683816493,
0.1367315501,
-0.1643759459,
-0.2288698554,
-0.7548384666,
0.1252072304,
0.1918196231,
-0.4633446336,
-0.5048023462,
0.1619172245,
-0.401435554,
-0.4918058217,
0.7775579691,
-0.069317691,
-0.4919650853,
0.8325888515,
0.4345570803,
0.891307652,
-0.2310006171,
0.2269869298,
0.3221130967,
0.668902874,
-0.1229527518,
0.7447630167,
0.1070768237,
-0.7288088799,
-0.0900645852,
-0.6365168095,
0.1012905762,
-0.238805607,
-0.4818333387,
0.1302786618,
-0.5929595828,
-0.3259263635,
0.0235441253,
-0.1696918756,
-1.0843998194,
0.293605864,
0.4130529761,
0.2752372324,
-0.9748395681,
0.3253548145,
0.9424025416,
-0.6478239894,
-0.9806141257,
-0.1600036621,
0.1590754837,
-0.6746749878,
1.2919540405,
0.016568549,
-0.4210237563,
-0.1245356202,
-0.6104646921,
-1.1411619186,
0.8071715236,
0.1571709812,
-0.215833649,
-0.0177784096,
0.1568372399,
0.8095021844,
-0.2833516002,
-0.1146706641,
0.275976032,
0.2521812022,
0.2090397775,
-0.5714864135,
0.0547416843,
-0.2116799504,
0.455948025,
0.2590087354,
-0.1772457659,
1.1361374855,
-0.3843075037,
-0.706574142,
-0.4509798288,
0.7763712406,
-0.1560826004,
-0.2738728821,
0.4472881556,
0.1335067898,
0.5630679131,
-0.1574428976,
0.9597995877,
0.223353222,
0.0705705509,
0.9611935019,
0.4876568317,
0.9864419699,
0.8678465486,
-0.4065805078,
0.5793795586,
0.4509669542,
-0.0649929792,
0.2734905183,
0.6998104453,
0.05357714,
0.0445985384,
0.0297998339,
0.0951172784,
0.7934304476,
0.6924082041,
-0.399684906,
-0.0162620042,
0.1875555813,
-0.1644512564,
0.0239235424,
-0.3989884555,
0.8564354181,
0.202952683,
-0.697134316,
0.6925604343,
-0.3482083678,
0.4454551637,
-0.4896483719,
-0.0106207356,
-0.2576680779,
0.0802462175,
-0.1672528684,
-0.896787405,
-0.0268601384,
-0.1946060359,
0.1468998343,
-0.0673698038,
0.6692922711,
-0.4003085494,
-0.3852948546,
0.4163145721,
0.9709908962,
0.1913845539,
0.3692761362,
-0.2220544219,
0.1679197252,
-0.4143339097,
-0.4738211632,
0.0646817088,
0.6679250002,
-0.0546897464,
0.7174504399,
0.1479235739,
0.4528783858,
0.7287088037,
-0.0090183364,
0.4392115474,
-0.758508563,
-0.2226862758,
-1.1089279652,
0.3765252233,
0.4155947566,
-0.2975932062,
0.6754691005,
-0.0439225025,
1.1178407669,
-0.331043452,
0.1081301495,
-0.1611699164,
-0.4541296065,
-0.5287480354,
0.5326411724,
-0.8322432637,
-0.0688229352,
-0.33866027,
-0.782308042,
-0.6198615432,
0.7456924915,
0.0045987535,
0.1760444343,
0.977199316,
0.5656872392,
0.0146205928,
-0.2641706467,
0.3784486651,
0.1222738624,
0.1278006881,
0.4502935708,
0.9036027789,
-0.3141968548,
0.2457254827,
-0.412594825,
-0.1777936518,
-0.1050111204,
-0.3766689003,
-0.6961498857,
-0.8684616089,
-0.1749188751,
-0.1483685076,
0.0806797445,
1.0303095579,
0.2625513673,
-0.4907316566,
-0.5872505307,
-0.4026354551,
0.2295513898,
-0.2487846762,
-0.1380110085,
0.5405087471,
-0.7885728478,
-0.6619290709,
-0.0119644804,
0.2269679755,
0.466301173,
-0.4118967354,
-0.043285124,
-0.4414870739,
0.0236018244,
0.8272408843,
0.3128754497,
-0.9598708749,
-0.4951422811,
0.1558584869,
-0.4615245461,
0.2144600898,
0.6747867465,
-0.5517876148,
0.7327288985,
0.7931592464,
0.6114292741,
0.1190999374,
-0.3408089578,
0.5242673755,
-0.7203181386,
0.141237095,
-0.0442425348,
0.3950448632,
0.1678818762,
-0.1631783992,
0.2328983098,
0.2357170284,
-0.016673604,
-0.5029630661,
0.5122895241,
-0.6314154267,
-0.3892945647,
0.8926637769,
-0.1360510439,
-0.480519563,
-0.1857395172,
0.0103486376,
0.4530611634,
0.0162923336,
0.5661889911,
1.0240164995,
-0.3416801095,
-0.3836096227,
-0.6268804073,
0.6016465425,
0.5330843329,
-0.3108939826,
-0.2789430618,
0.5660860538,
-0.17513524,
0.3856222034,
0.2395702749,
-0.2546745241,
0.0959624499,
0.3255521059,
-0.0491152517,
0.1295451671,
-0.7179051042,
-0.6917164326,
0.2613695264,
0.3909872472,
-0.342448324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02426v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02426v5 | ParroT: Translating during Chat using Large Language Models tuned with Human Translation and Feedback | 2023-04-05T13:12:00 | 2023-11-02T07:44:52 | Wenxiang Jiao, Jen-tse Huang, Wenxuan Wang, Zhiwei He, Tian Liang, Xing Wang, Shuming Shi, Zhaopeng Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT have exhibited remarkable abilities
on a wide range of natural language processing~(NLP) tasks, including various
machine translation abilities accomplished during chat. However, these models
are only accessible through restricted APIs, which creates barriers to new
research and advancements in the field. Therefore, we propose ParroT, a
framework to enhance and regulate the translation abilities during chat based
on open-source LLMs (e.g., LLaMA), human-written translation and feedback data.
Specifically, ParroT reformulates translation data into the
instruction-following style, and introduces a "$\mathbf{Hint}$" field for
incorporating extra requirements to regulate the translation process.
Accordingly, we propose three instruction types for finetuning ParroT models,
including translation instruction, contrastive instruction, and error-guided
instruction. Experiments on Flores subsets and WMT22 test sets suggest that
translation instruction improves the translation performance of vanilla LLMs
significantly while error-guided instruction can lead to further improvement,
which demonstrates the importance of learning from low-quality translations
annotated by humans. We also demonstrate the potential of automatic evaluation
tools in providing quality information of translations, when constructing
error-guided instructions for directions that lack human annotation data.
Please refer to our Github project for more implementation details:
https://github.com/wxjiao/ParroT | [
-0.0493293405,
-0.8294026256,
0.1640398651,
0.6107658744,
-0.4022654295,
0.0241688248,
-0.671742022,
-0.676173389,
0.0890811756,
0.6422861218,
-0.5212968588,
-0.389890641,
-0.709913075,
0.2343312353,
-0.4960812628,
0.9395471811,
0.1567287594,
0.2355867922,
-0.0260202512,
0.1727677584,
-0.6132726669,
-0.650585413,
-0.5488209128,
-0.211636737,
0.436106354,
0.5677574277,
0.7652267218,
0.5619632602,
0.6979212165,
0.3293569088,
-0.3013635874,
0.5534394383,
-0.6535390615,
0.0267776642,
-0.1025607735,
-0.7513220906,
-0.7063921094,
-0.0638473779,
0.5468011498,
0.5378066301,
-0.2233087271,
-0.0055393958,
0.3595923483,
0.5585802197,
-0.2903932333,
0.4588517845,
-0.4820585847,
0.1657323092,
-0.4073654711,
-0.5567939281,
-0.5020729303,
-0.4328701794,
0.0759621486,
-0.6459863186,
-0.0768543184,
0.1044850349,
0.4214038849,
0.2554653287,
-0.4303818643,
-0.3921298683,
-0.7121309042,
0.9467756152,
-0.9838436842,
0.2016558945,
0.6568771601,
0.4524599612,
-0.6150103807,
-0.6107160449,
-0.4414420128,
-0.2712222934,
0.0484000407,
0.0427009091,
-0.0572831072,
0.3366567492,
-0.0541530214,
0.5316622853,
-0.1700817347,
0.0617833734,
-0.3826419115,
-0.2086149454,
0.7122866511,
0.108610034,
0.3911576569,
0.0602913648,
-0.012098711,
-0.1772767901,
-0.6540731788,
-0.0104695968,
0.0559832565,
0.5641786456,
-0.17446962,
0.7150148153,
-0.4611455202,
0.7129645348,
-0.115837425,
-0.1068940088,
0.1712306738,
-0.2336217761,
-0.078134805,
-0.2070641667,
0.8375686407,
0.5167536736,
0.1680996269,
-0.1651336849,
-0.2641048729,
-0.2702802122,
0.0650391132,
-0.6719982028,
0.0245019142,
0.1432502866,
-0.5124886036,
-0.6463422775,
-0.1544114947,
-0.6253013611,
-0.5823959112,
-0.0664503872,
0.1887234151,
-0.3081692755,
-0.0301520005,
0.1984229535,
0.0734837502,
0.4010165334,
0.6564537883,
-1.1035847664,
0.2357522696,
0.6787086725,
0.9672791362,
0.0503552109,
-0.3116407394,
-0.8990317583,
0.1354131699,
-0.6144446731,
0.5535445809,
-0.6477708817,
-0.5488186479,
0.1005239636,
0.0468428098,
0.1098758951,
-0.1765040755,
0.6026843786,
-0.3633562922,
0.3847725093,
-0.1916618198,
-0.5759695172,
-0.4428886175,
0.2322318256,
-0.2715087235,
0.6440527439,
-0.1037553176,
-0.529998064,
-0.2517618239,
-0.9406744242,
-0.6003935933,
0.1513532251,
0.0449075364,
0.009238393,
0.1279886216,
0.4383814931,
0.4372876287,
-0.4333415627,
-0.0906620547,
-0.1708986312,
-0.4527806938,
0.4105114937,
-0.487653017,
0.7415185571,
0.1304174811,
-0.2580554187,
0.5326592326,
-0.428478241,
0.0598162077,
0.0546063446,
-0.7051579952,
0.0695014074,
0.4351580143,
0.0674148053,
-0.0658750609,
0.1409227401,
-0.4462076724,
0.4713453948,
-0.4236719608,
0.875097692,
0.5876210332,
0.028561309,
0.4465029836,
-0.2636853755,
0.6004949212,
-0.2018807679,
0.3011977673,
-0.2560482323,
-0.8806301355,
-0.8045172095,
0.068367146,
0.2173293233,
0.773003757,
-0.6763536334,
0.3862631619,
-0.1969986856,
-0.3131154478,
-0.6782971025,
0.4214071035,
0.5183616877,
0.4348628521,
0.4429726303,
-0.3383126855,
-0.391405642,
-0.4297557771,
0.0499362126,
-0.141297847,
-0.2580679953,
0.2282121927,
0.0178384986,
-0.3668926954,
0.3952723145,
-0.1955334544,
-0.6153730154,
-0.3061234355,
0.032237906,
0.0072896387,
0.5220139027,
0.3638489246,
-0.5252581239,
-0.3744344711,
0.2681457102,
-0.474996388,
-0.2609687448,
-0.1219012067,
-0.3347736895,
0.0824181139,
0.6052367091,
-0.392395407,
0.4235663712,
0.6863872409,
-0.103473261,
0.4067688882,
-0.221085757,
0.1874300539,
-0.9295566678,
-0.1462804526,
-0.3800528049,
-0.5808470845,
-0.4568799734,
0.2481171489,
0.0748164505,
-0.0157174598,
-0.5735173821,
0.2096782774,
-0.3047351539,
0.00910288,
-0.4740516841,
0.2480591089,
0.0632229373,
0.4520317018,
0.1889683753,
0.9498293996,
0.3265170753,
-0.4363285601,
0.6469743848,
0.5778195858,
-0.2019558698,
0.3115602136,
-0.6340755224,
0.3662724495,
0.3887067735,
0.5180817842,
-0.8226791024,
-0.4313915372,
0.5820054412,
-0.503831327,
0.2561128139,
-0.187843129,
-0.5696884394,
-0.1645177454,
-0.2237004489,
-0.0184618384,
0.6546462774,
-0.4274340272,
0.2483821958,
0.1752413511,
-0.2685570121,
-0.4802532196,
-0.8946302533,
0.4843147695,
0.0352738462,
-0.5468108058,
0.1590940952,
-0.1037511006,
-0.0349761397,
-0.1468416601,
0.3067853451,
-0.0786855072,
0.0864097923,
0.093157649,
0.1117774546,
-0.2892636657,
0.150263235,
0.163755089,
0.0853637904,
-0.0098003037,
-0.4338995218,
0.4241290092,
-0.3623409271,
-0.2926740348,
-0.8314349651,
0.4172773361,
0.497203052,
-0.4544611871,
0.5396840572,
0.5986391902,
0.01131343,
0.0029368093,
-0.3708679676,
-0.1840897501,
-0.4945215285,
0.428886801,
-0.205908969,
-0.6949049234,
0.400357306,
-0.0180960987,
0.2893589437,
0.112938419,
0.5682098866,
-0.3991410732,
1.1629720926,
0.5882066488,
-0.1426595002,
0.7443281412,
-0.0688925534,
-0.1453572661,
-0.9950112104,
0.0528250709,
-0.3585947752,
-0.4355378151,
-0.4197318852,
-0.7603495717,
0.010590218,
0.3189582825,
0.0938983709,
0.1379152834,
-0.518283546,
0.6897981763,
0.8011750579,
0.2012255639,
0.4037641883,
-0.1381428093,
0.1772203594,
0.1348137707,
-0.6353979111,
-0.5764437318,
1.2363849878,
0.3725371361,
0.7912047505,
0.1080368459,
0.5353317857,
0.2630119622,
0.4127334058,
-0.9152338505,
0.4721646309,
-0.1374416202,
-0.3504245281,
-0.3370027244,
-0.5050113201,
-0.7941122651,
0.2269286662,
-0.2536953986,
-0.6347827315,
-0.0974518582,
0.2157166302,
-0.1677687466,
0.1219583377,
-0.7275006175,
0.6975823045,
-0.5141655207,
-0.1427887529,
-0.4090316892,
-0.6993858218,
0.3589604497,
-0.0033505242,
0.2324907631,
-0.0354860127,
-0.1481314451,
0.4986032546,
-0.6620973349,
1.1963047981,
-0.069648467,
-0.229330793,
0.297434181,
0.1769019365,
0.5048947334,
-0.092880398,
-0.0606094711,
0.3028165996,
0.1810395271,
-0.4132882655,
-0.6505061388,
0.3889228404,
-0.9010592103,
-0.7101274133,
-0.0587582029,
-0.7218181491,
-0.1577274352,
0.2075461894,
0.1405540258,
0.2314666212,
-0.0512996688,
0.3927114308,
0.2151467055,
-0.3880352974,
0.1605302095,
0.6128548384,
-0.5987790823,
-0.3798177838,
0.9119186997,
-0.1988726109,
0.3040983975,
0.4719539285,
0.4470977187,
-0.2793919146,
-0.7623969316,
-0.6826527119,
0.1181688234,
-0.7296338677,
-0.1958448142,
0.0247484948,
-0.1187599376,
-0.344448179,
-0.1085505337,
-0.325350076,
-0.5963529348,
-0.4462568462,
0.2075513601,
0.3504996598,
0.8348672986,
0.0593339019,
0.5780081153,
-1.0339571238,
0.1186668724,
0.2917338014,
0.2454135716,
-0.0467383116,
-0.6207066774,
-0.265078634,
0.505219698,
-0.4562919736,
-0.8242895603,
0.4006585479,
0.5071094632,
0.2296532393,
0.5356495976,
0.0866320357,
0.8381875157,
-0.5648243427,
0.7869064808,
0.0165321939,
-1.1775290966,
0.6979147792,
-0.4543132782,
0.2272818536,
0.2045715898,
-0.183692202,
-0.912743926,
-0.723823607,
-0.0085694073,
-0.47491768,
0.85040766,
0.398924768,
0.2916785181,
0.0047290111,
0.3775376379,
-0.2140884399,
0.1957111359,
-0.5163828135,
0.1923938245,
-0.2964286804,
-0.0808515921,
-0.1586945653,
-0.1501487046,
-0.2283701152,
-0.2664474845,
0.5419397354,
-0.1380430907,
0.1719105393,
0.0943445414,
-0.2491450757,
-0.2748276889,
0.2395495474,
0.889290154,
0.3719003201,
-0.2410397381,
-0.1908564121,
0.1574601829,
-0.4178105891,
-0.0664910898,
-0.2131761611,
0.0141449813,
-0.211357519,
0.6301574111,
0.5989753604,
0.3835313618,
-0.6549135447,
0.6238031387,
-0.243576929,
0.0309551768,
-0.1626054347,
0.3265846968,
0.1477564126,
0.3768086731,
0.1128227711,
0.0150539568,
0.0481036454,
-0.4103034735,
-0.1183180362,
0.2699972093,
-0.4175855815,
-0.3463233113,
0.8072891235,
0.7966591716,
-0.5877881646,
0.7946439981,
-0.2119177878,
-0.4915777445,
0.2653271556,
0.5805827975,
0.7888150811,
-0.2884189188,
0.0373634025,
-0.0744972602,
0.3684947491,
-0.1904247701,
0.3161213696,
-0.3230530322,
-0.404263407,
-0.7695426345,
-0.3708503544,
-0.7635883093,
-0.0334460363,
-0.6375706792,
0.2533226013,
-0.2885156274,
-0.0006099227,
-0.4676376283,
-0.1226500347,
-0.3963289261,
-0.2362440228,
0.258515954,
0.9820247293,
-0.4860714078,
1.118712306,
0.5587333441,
-0.5281660557,
-0.5944615006,
-0.0830397308,
0.1599367857,
-0.7059910297,
0.5622591972,
0.065377064,
-0.2641405761,
0.097223863,
-0.6875494719,
-0.6631926894,
0.8758454323,
0.3294447958,
-0.7363271713,
-0.041825626,
0.3049811423,
0.6435419917,
-0.2523081005,
0.2598960698,
0.384039849,
0.2918857932,
0.1013209373,
-1.1669408083,
-0.2461599708,
-0.2696938515,
0.0719697997,
-0.2123823017,
-0.6269885302,
0.5094880462,
-0.1827462763,
-0.0315070525,
0.3121114373,
0.7294458747,
-0.1999201328,
-0.1698612124,
0.2851209342,
0.0066639921,
0.8450913429,
0.1553855091,
1.2468163967,
-0.3167972267,
0.0781019405,
1.2691025734,
0.0153595917,
1.3270740509,
0.442756474,
-0.1546634883,
0.2987874746,
0.6585954428,
0.2931488156,
0.3453514278,
0.073635608,
0.0110183721,
-0.141037792,
-0.0092382887,
-0.4796254933,
0.6348056197,
0.6442208886,
-0.3216167986,
0.1245562956,
0.0486511588,
-0.0911214203,
-0.0368902236,
-0.2454836071,
0.8866657615,
0.1621060073,
-0.4809079766,
0.8412753344,
0.1188080311,
0.675914824,
-0.6042304635,
-0.2473852783,
-0.452306658,
0.177773878,
-0.2545580864,
-0.6726951599,
0.3145565391,
0.0909929127,
0.0891212001,
-0.2102305889,
0.3211581409,
-0.5745831132,
-0.5033515096,
0.1657371819,
0.1372717023,
0.3791357279,
-0.1370074898,
-0.6010663509,
0.3546046317,
0.1141927242,
-0.3251354992,
0.1361400783,
0.3537292182,
-0.1899413615,
0.9289183021,
0.7159792185,
0.4155986011,
0.3117361367,
0.0968477055,
0.6498574018,
-0.5037408471,
-0.6509490013,
-0.6110826731,
0.2328365296,
-0.0352419838,
-0.1609042138,
0.7539522052,
0.2196946293,
0.7026423812,
-0.0729364082,
0.7167028189,
0.2665521204,
0.528226614,
-0.4394447505,
0.8375735879,
-0.3595955372,
0.5105425119,
-0.1946692169,
-0.8323262334,
-0.4571844339,
0.7088878155,
-0.3826338351,
-0.4562619627,
0.3974847496,
0.6918616295,
-0.0739929378,
0.1194261089,
0.2465487719,
0.2003627121,
0.7376742363,
0.5759967566,
0.9501202703,
-0.264503479,
0.9676091671,
-0.1688969731,
-0.2867952883,
-0.6047597528,
-0.7942445278,
-0.9195744991,
-0.4520089328,
-0.3021532297,
-0.1471987069,
0.0508734919,
1.0678939819,
0.9255020618,
-0.7751713991,
-0.477917105,
-0.2849691808,
0.1165189818,
-0.4697397649,
-0.1824828833,
0.2026622295,
-0.7557265162,
-0.8239821792,
0.783439219,
0.1656251848,
0.1490249485,
-0.3361383379,
-0.3697251379,
0.103675954,
0.1634407192,
0.6879720688,
0.3619532883,
-1.0369714499,
-0.4123274982,
-0.2393927276,
-0.1639907062,
0.0904352143,
0.5403619409,
-0.3320064843,
0.8379144669,
0.6025733352,
0.7304631472,
0.4025517702,
0.094309926,
0.9523323774,
-0.7854890227,
0.4136705697,
0.1975690573,
0.2050141543,
0.3785047233,
-0.3248487413,
0.4728690088,
-0.1077896208,
-0.6485821009,
-0.7633414865,
0.075926967,
-0.7967624664,
-0.0614353716,
1.0804381371,
-0.3384787142,
-0.305442065,
0.0959597379,
-0.667055428,
0.2233391702,
-0.4033236802,
0.9410423636,
0.7044888735,
-0.1791739166,
-0.3272767067,
-0.6249738932,
0.5168009996,
0.2772343755,
-0.7283167839,
0.1702627987,
0.5080711246,
0.0658290312,
-0.1135086939,
0.5986410975,
-0.140383631,
0.3364420235,
-0.1754128486,
0.1281413734,
-0.2566811442,
0.054378055,
-0.349978447,
-0.2929243743,
0.3602865636,
-0.6094071269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02328v1 | Enhancing Multimodal Entity and Relation Extraction with Variational Information Bottleneck | 2023-04-05T09:32:25 | 2023-04-05T09:32:25 | Shiyao Cui, Jiangxia Cao, Xin Cong, Jiawei Sheng, Quangang Li, Tingwen Liu, Jinqiao Shi | cs.MM | cs.MM, cs.CL | This paper studies the multimodal named entity recognition (MNER) and
multimodal relation extraction (MRE), which are important for multimedia social
platform analysis. The core of MNER and MRE lies in incorporating evident
visual information to enhance textual semantics, where two issues inherently
demand investigations. The first issue is modality-noise, where the
task-irrelevant information in each modality may be noises misleading the task
prediction. The second issue is modality-gap, where representations from
different modalities are inconsistent, preventing from building the semantic
alignment between the text and image. To address these issues, we propose a
novel method for MNER and MRE by Multi-Modal representation learning with
Information Bottleneck (MMIB). For the first issue, a refinement-regularizer
probes the information-bottleneck principle to balance the predictive evidence
and noisy information, yielding expressive representations for prediction. For
the second issue, an alignment-regularizer is proposed, where a mutual
information-based item works in a contrastive manner to regularize the
consistent text-image representations. To our best knowledge, we are the first
to explore variational IB estimation for MNER and MRE. Experiments show that
MMIB achieves the state-of-the-art performances on three public benchmarks. | [
-0.828478992,
-0.6638339162,
0.341976434,
0.1781281829,
-0.2349729985,
0.053838551,
-0.3123524785,
-0.5262188315,
0.2912580073,
0.2389513701,
-0.8843192458,
-0.1256813109,
-0.6456655264,
0.1070868,
0.3484626412,
0.7197200656,
-0.0694445968,
-0.0663143024,
-0.3767935336,
-0.3232932389,
-0.7435386777,
-0.043895714,
-0.244463101,
-0.0290451422,
0.7137289047,
0.2421156317,
0.6637738943,
0.7442594171,
0.7385206819,
0.3063302338,
0.1851834953,
0.4650724828,
-0.5313817859,
0.445181489,
-0.2085165083,
-0.4639639258,
-0.1550997049,
-0.0881955847,
0.5672623515,
0.4092583954,
-0.0693528503,
0.1850747466,
-0.1712835729,
0.6066037416,
-1.017149806,
0.4969037473,
-0.6655389071,
-0.076367192,
-0.2851094902,
-0.2481418252,
-0.2583142519,
0.198626712,
-0.0119129792,
-0.8009735346,
0.1362433583,
0.2740480304,
1.3477197886,
0.3591373265,
-0.4237442017,
-0.3459872603,
-0.5587126613,
0.9028309584,
-0.3450948298,
0.9181748033,
0.141358614,
0.3475780785,
-0.1274795532,
-0.4764462113,
-0.6743821502,
-0.0970807672,
-0.0030956694,
0.1219454408,
-0.2231313586,
-0.042221345,
0.2968284786,
0.3916872442,
-0.3107692003,
-0.0544076227,
-0.4051708281,
-0.3083849251,
0.3225215077,
-0.0164931305,
0.1237479672,
-0.5748214722,
-0.7285662889,
-0.0661340803,
-0.4580913782,
0.1193751395,
0.14740704,
0.0609730445,
-0.135445565,
0.454033941,
-0.0434668846,
0.4223405421,
0.0318465121,
-0.3220990598,
0.5482061505,
-0.4142842591,
-0.1617241651,
-0.5066393614,
1.1073086262,
0.6261107922,
-0.110010162,
-0.3209261298,
-0.120154053,
0.0674862117,
0.0930692852,
-1.0257700682,
-0.0417268164,
-0.0085208528,
-0.6180390716,
-0.0532686785,
0.3168412745,
-1.3090655804,
-0.3875103593,
-0.5003856421,
0.2521025836,
-0.5758420229,
-0.5522571802,
-0.3395825624,
-0.2407582104,
-0.0507573001,
0.2406016588,
-0.7364427447,
0.0225341953,
0.3020729125,
0.8002908826,
-0.218600601,
0.0229440276,
-0.2714961767,
0.4259061217,
-0.0115806945,
0.5953403711,
-0.7032530904,
-0.2927942574,
-0.3230399489,
-0.0052341744,
-0.1949649155,
-0.5661398768,
0.4138458073,
-0.6906977296,
0.2233628631,
-0.3091979027,
-0.3482292593,
-0.1270837784,
0.2341934294,
-1.119505167,
0.8321577311,
-0.0858859792,
-1.0099470615,
0.4443773031,
-0.6916301847,
-0.0581292547,
-0.3099250793,
-0.5977040529,
-0.5275899172,
0.0122455321,
0.4085781276,
0.5261343122,
-0.5548214316,
0.1834159344,
-0.3888933659,
-0.1022148654,
0.3772315383,
-0.5903562903,
0.3576973379,
0.3778168857,
-0.0918091312,
-0.1473173201,
-0.9385893345,
-0.2130265534,
-0.1223055869,
-0.4089664519,
-0.3890040517,
0.0097052101,
0.197647199,
0.3339879513,
0.2281374186,
-0.471385181,
0.2690034509,
0.0264229514,
0.304569453,
0.6763207316,
0.10766422,
0.3101169467,
-0.1115765646,
0.4287493229,
0.5048111677,
-0.1581372321,
-0.4401216805,
-0.2987610102,
-0.4838591218,
-0.6130982637,
0.6400446296,
0.5009582043,
-1.2025535107,
-0.0816072673,
-0.5885612965,
-0.1068364978,
-0.6119322181,
0.3266056776,
0.2783564329,
0.3143910766,
0.4263315499,
-0.5667114258,
-0.6029468179,
-0.9871826172,
-0.1457255334,
0.0522931889,
-0.1070722565,
0.5940284729,
0.2119467705,
-0.447440505,
0.9318513274,
-0.4670154154,
-0.2031662762,
0.1140387729,
0.7836402059,
0.0703078881,
0.6717008352,
0.4409969449,
-1.4059746265,
-0.3286024034,
-0.1102571413,
-0.699834466,
0.0143092191,
-0.2286438644,
-0.0678538904,
-0.1388113499,
0.4282571971,
-0.8167753816,
0.1716110408,
0.325083524,
0.0343170501,
0.3950724304,
0.2538205087,
0.378454864,
-1.2387260199,
-0.1427795291,
0.2648636103,
-0.1858433634,
-0.3951477408,
-0.0311658941,
0.1535057425,
-0.0732106045,
0.166522786,
0.1173852012,
-0.8769168854,
0.2747707367,
-0.0097132036,
0.3597017527,
-0.0241594929,
0.5961674452,
-0.1033068672,
0.7787100077,
0.4921911657,
-0.4358228147,
0.2428087443,
-0.1668702662,
-0.0615445115,
0.9309350252,
-0.1533275694,
0.035820201,
-0.4692346156,
-0.1629229188,
-0.9463570118,
-0.4065347016,
0.3344602287,
-0.5241360068,
0.8761546612,
-0.0515634976,
-0.3293142915,
-0.1348602772,
-0.4183452129,
0.4617545605,
-0.0349812172,
-0.1856926233,
0.9766241908,
0.3526069522,
-0.0576343723,
-1.1523994207,
-0.5465082526,
0.0172982365,
-0.1909409314,
-0.5664688945,
0.5289112329,
0.0054839989,
0.0349675156,
0.2494424284,
-0.4697922468,
-0.5246163011,
-0.238165319,
0.4915004671,
0.4514763057,
-0.5206180215,
0.5016006231,
-0.0422610082,
-0.0577316359,
-0.1864226013,
0.2993457317,
0.3041151166,
-0.1269534677,
-0.0767585188,
-0.5621526837,
0.4417990446,
0.695099175,
-0.1971353292,
0.6494617462,
1.1058388948,
-0.4103716612,
0.351066947,
-1.0065705776,
-0.0377583392,
-0.4187170565,
0.4957717061,
-0.8510960937,
-0.9119936824,
0.3556286097,
-0.5020422935,
-0.1633074135,
0.4685387015,
0.2213849425,
-0.0461314917,
0.6535561681,
0.9512967467,
-0.1543733031,
0.6739932299,
-0.1802296191,
-0.0216851868,
-0.9104605913,
-0.1911051571,
-0.1588078439,
-0.2298975438,
-0.7899797559,
-0.6264309883,
0.2171997428,
0.5394764543,
0.1736917347,
0.5679395795,
-0.1230932698,
0.3723369837,
0.2403335869,
0.2578052282,
0.2660364211,
0.0494352095,
-0.1049554572,
-0.5839153528,
-0.6072990894,
-0.3271369934,
1.0269804001,
0.3995700777,
0.7208337188,
0.2866550982,
0.4719897211,
-0.0302211568,
0.5088526011,
-0.6246436238,
0.2494891286,
0.2666929662,
-0.7235614657,
-0.2058711499,
-0.882789135,
-0.8815525174,
0.6589493155,
-0.5814065337,
-0.9578145742,
0.7297039628,
0.066605106,
0.0435695052,
0.100978218,
-0.655585289,
0.8922682405,
0.1524643153,
-0.6812718511,
-0.22698991,
-0.9915502071,
0.4964307845,
0.0738586038,
0.5282658339,
-0.1391398013,
-0.3358791471,
0.4370179176,
0.0483042486,
0.5548595786,
-0.0809156448,
0.2248647064,
0.0159803554,
0.0090998458,
0.3265759051,
0.2299955189,
0.0806038901,
0.1292105019,
-0.1366537511,
-0.1663633585,
-0.8107817173,
0.5820621848,
-0.5932440162,
-0.4088363349,
-0.0293885022,
-0.786023438,
-0.2966938317,
0.2341322005,
0.1164346859,
0.3312905729,
-0.0586856268,
0.5124755502,
0.7581634521,
0.1307836473,
0.5326811075,
0.3430320024,
0.1197718456,
-0.6868155003,
1.1357947588,
0.1308463067,
0.1886791587,
0.7959306836,
-0.2038412094,
-0.1179414093,
-0.1292673647,
-0.5093748569,
0.2925006151,
-0.6176306605,
-0.4065270722,
-0.658923924,
0.0192966014,
-0.1183768362,
0.2414756268,
-0.5412521958,
-0.2526770234,
-0.4472717643,
0.2347305417,
-0.1366613209,
0.2421371937,
-0.1428951025,
0.221967116,
-0.6169188023,
0.4884985387,
0.087852411,
0.3010576963,
-0.1086265147,
0.1107682213,
-0.0863345191,
-0.0951915681,
-0.7759029269,
-1.0969039202,
0.0065843957,
0.2265621275,
0.4591582119,
0.8675091863,
-0.1852241009,
0.962063849,
-0.3686879277,
0.4373597205,
0.7028684616,
-0.7067700624,
0.2154167145,
-0.0202353857,
-0.0167352743,
0.5468797088,
0.7641489506,
-0.3672419488,
-0.1326969266,
-0.5193125606,
-0.8849427104,
0.3412770331,
0.4420529902,
0.0053653074,
0.2211487293,
0.1776701808,
0.1116013601,
0.7270861268,
-1.1282211542,
-0.3179608881,
-0.2248247266,
-0.2793916762,
0.3091981113,
-0.4225666821,
0.0631264746,
-0.0096719209,
0.3705417514,
0.0973156616,
0.4673577845,
0.2434796989,
-0.2662155628,
-0.1895196885,
0.5188406706,
0.4307783246,
0.8195958138,
-0.2466852367,
0.2563229799,
-0.0004615876,
-0.3885473311,
-0.0202782825,
0.4134313464,
0.1372112334,
0.3180678487,
0.3627377152,
0.8391970396,
0.221767202,
-0.6774978042,
0.7582044005,
-0.0012685519,
0.1022347957,
0.061395172,
-0.2425022125,
0.0635020062,
0.5661793351,
0.2750405967,
0.3174501061,
0.306995362,
-0.489970386,
0.2851105928,
0.6173547506,
-0.4773246944,
-0.1292889118,
0.6815081239,
-0.0596965738,
-0.0259386096,
0.2022327781,
-0.2493063211,
-0.1705781668,
0.351020515,
0.2969976366,
0.4807222188,
-0.3336564004,
-0.0797085464,
0.2332919985,
0.3163714111,
0.2540456355,
0.2361556441,
-0.3248258531,
-0.7216400504,
-0.5047909617,
-0.3853972852,
-0.1129777059,
0.2167408317,
-0.7534823418,
0.3704126775,
-0.1739842296,
-0.4567970932,
0.2513533533,
-0.2168874443,
-0.6553789973,
-0.0094532045,
-0.0577267744,
0.4372062683,
-0.4598170817,
0.4485221505,
0.5994436741,
-0.7009888887,
-0.6224534512,
-0.0161317252,
-0.0487795547,
-0.3438039124,
0.7635231614,
0.4389734566,
-0.1670781821,
-0.3102475107,
-0.4047011733,
-0.8089696765,
1.3788836002,
0.3788231611,
-0.8518871069,
-0.0119089326,
0.0030371342,
0.1991339922,
-0.6430281401,
0.3555622399,
-0.0910443142,
0.3934136331,
0.2984384596,
-0.7914302945,
0.1819631308,
-0.3003616035,
0.3048387766,
0.4230631888,
-0.6751342416,
0.9382469654,
-0.0534237884,
-0.5303241014,
-0.2139606029,
0.7126649022,
-0.0459982194,
0.4879626036,
0.6416702271,
0.5991074443,
0.7043065429,
-0.0396964625,
0.6113342643,
-0.3041221797,
0.4511553943,
1.1596176624,
0.0702683404,
0.7579998374,
0.8733174205,
-0.0272691585,
0.7017450333,
0.5471495986,
-0.1216690391,
0.5436393023,
-0.0116947824,
-0.1368217915,
-0.1734172106,
-0.1586514711,
-0.3883419633,
0.2965839207,
0.4925850332,
-0.6479884982,
-0.2100426406,
0.118033126,
0.1517053545,
-0.208005622,
-0.1095494255,
0.6487079263,
-0.0227676742,
-0.2408639789,
0.4570273161,
0.075845927,
0.7376887202,
-0.3148948848,
-0.0692876428,
0.2050517648,
-0.1054110005,
-0.0709445775,
-0.0966224074,
0.0418500192,
-0.4109067321,
-0.5093942285,
0.1932126582,
0.8728232384,
-0.6398230791,
-0.2816167474,
0.0147610186,
0.5363796353,
-0.0466190167,
-0.0792319626,
-0.7082597017,
0.0804364607,
-0.1032036841,
-0.3490285873,
0.1079611108,
0.7517409325,
0.120853655,
0.6749407053,
0.4883780777,
-0.0748956129,
0.0514570288,
-0.2709659636,
1.1651934385,
-0.5541219115,
-0.1734489799,
-1.0149960518,
0.5637057424,
-0.516433239,
-0.2111917585,
0.3793350458,
0.5502461195,
0.7147004604,
-0.154441461,
0.4930375814,
-0.2987670004,
0.2208704948,
-0.5061200261,
0.2508691549,
-0.6552513242,
0.2668967545,
-0.4517182112,
-0.8942673802,
-0.0812148079,
0.4056142569,
-0.1219682693,
-0.1712312251,
0.8760370612,
1.0045059919,
-0.421072036,
-0.0003392351,
0.140099436,
0.0277986825,
0.1725618094,
0.5875431299,
0.6205883026,
-0.484607935,
0.822874248,
-0.2760029137,
-0.3414004147,
-0.1422446668,
-0.984567821,
-0.9316666126,
-0.6836180091,
-0.4051234424,
-0.081234239,
0.0277637076,
0.9928959608,
0.7925958633,
-0.5146374106,
-0.1901426613,
0.0393358096,
0.324701637,
-0.2266780436,
-0.3493085802,
0.2109079808,
-0.3829194605,
-0.622448504,
0.0782857612,
0.4803198874,
0.0421046205,
-0.1133428887,
0.1408562809,
-0.339358747,
-0.0130121019,
0.4397427738,
0.0888724476,
-0.7554899454,
-0.0800533146,
-0.3156737685,
-0.0180698577,
0.483730793,
0.9338045716,
-0.2985633314,
0.872677207,
0.3298357725,
0.776006043,
0.6594518423,
0.1528729796,
0.3978747129,
-0.9326177239,
0.2572567761,
0.0115304738,
0.2970401943,
0.2552412152,
-0.3981265128,
0.4020512402,
0.6899281144,
-0.3066188991,
-0.7636913657,
0.4663799405,
-1.0995073318,
-0.2406697571,
0.7577059865,
-0.2316595316,
-0.127434507,
0.0260476302,
-0.2394368947,
0.3198638558,
-0.5996819735,
0.7715759873,
1.0351989269,
-0.1672262251,
-0.6462048292,
-1.0014287233,
0.2966547012,
0.087538369,
-0.526968658,
-0.2196064293,
0.6167895794,
0.1776931584,
0.7743453383,
0.2908471227,
-0.1023118272,
0.075713031,
0.1305441409,
0.1686630994,
-0.1778167933,
-0.245382309,
0.2001375705,
0.4842078984,
-0.3130180538,
-0.3529291153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02313v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02313v2 | Personality-aware Human-centric Multimodal Reasoning: A New Task, Dataset and Baselines | 2023-04-05T09:09:10 | 2024-03-04T12:33:46 | Yaochen Zhu, Xiangqing Shen, Rui Xia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Personality traits, emotions, and beliefs shape individuals' behavioral
choices and decision-making processes. However, for one thing, the affective
computing community normally focused on predicting personality traits but
overlooks their application in behavior prediction. For another, the multimodal
reasoning task emphasized the prediction of future states and behaviors but
often neglected the incorporation of individual personality traits. In this
work, we introduce a new task called Personality-aware Human-centric Multimodal
Reasoning (PHMR) (T1), with the goal of forecasting the future behavior of a
particular individual using multimodal information from past instances, while
integrating personality factors. We accordingly construct a new dataset based
on six television shows, encompassing 225 characters and 12k samples. To
establish a benchmark for the task, we propose seven baseline methods: three
adapted from related tasks, two pre-trained model, and two multimodal large
language models. The experimental results demonstrate that incorporating
personality traits enhances human-centric multimodal reasoning performance. To
further solve the lack of personality annotation in real-life scenes, we
introduce an extension task called Personality-predicted Human-centric
Multimodal Reasoning task (T2) along with the corresponding dataset and method.
We will make our dataset and code available on GitHub. | [
-0.7568122745,
-0.2360679358,
0.650483489,
0.3973353505,
-0.0680865422,
-0.0399953388,
-0.2449196428,
-0.1853509992,
0.3282728195,
0.4466792941,
-0.9550828338,
-0.0999558419,
-0.366623491,
-0.1226182133,
0.4019223452,
0.8172605038,
0.1961980909,
0.1156551465,
-0.3529980183,
-0.1382000297,
-0.7883474827,
-0.726585567,
-0.1473137438,
-0.6501532793,
0.8700705767,
0.8288251162,
0.5124386549,
0.251720041,
0.1878786832,
0.2278319895,
0.2313332856,
0.3324964345,
-0.1041142792,
0.2557321191,
-0.372007221,
0.0366047956,
-0.5825639963,
0.0682614148,
0.2044016719,
0.3260004222,
0.0675717592,
0.1725467443,
-0.3031326532,
0.656480968,
-0.6713016629,
0.1258229017,
-0.1368927062,
0.0778449997,
-0.1470255107,
-0.240757525,
-0.4397126436,
-0.0434330814,
0.1825086176,
-0.3034470975,
-0.135022819,
-0.0323544219,
0.2524089515,
0.2518699169,
-0.8554400206,
0.1852371395,
-0.8103356361,
0.8652371168,
-0.2876160741,
0.5868319869,
0.554338932,
0.3556595147,
0.0526656061,
-0.2019116133,
-0.7196440101,
-0.2299605757,
-0.0547030009,
0.0564359948,
0.1051017642,
-0.0581705347,
0.3367685676,
-0.0707701296,
-0.593444705,
-0.2983401418,
0.0204247255,
-0.348650068,
0.6279141903,
0.1620158553,
-0.2884919345,
-0.4457935989,
-0.1303837895,
-0.1597599089,
-0.2346020937,
0.177831322,
0.3158489764,
-0.0870299339,
-0.081308946,
0.6657803059,
-0.447065264,
0.1283132136,
0.1711264998,
-0.3575696051,
0.4541374743,
-0.3824942708,
0.045426745,
0.014946172,
0.2679135203,
0.7399651408,
0.6545466781,
0.222175315,
0.1758197099,
0.4229649603,
0.2453915775,
-0.6020236611,
-0.5347893834,
0.5575794578,
-0.6318141222,
0.0441743843,
-0.1284984499,
-0.8586706519,
-0.7862917781,
-0.5206677318,
0.2565470636,
-0.7050105333,
-0.5038718581,
-0.2022646368,
-0.2559416592,
-0.0484794974,
0.5933730006,
-0.6202837229,
-0.2826379538,
0.4139119983,
0.2823099494,
0.1721558124,
-0.4350307286,
-0.489421159,
0.0611180179,
0.1108384803,
0.9115592241,
-0.6856185794,
-0.3830679953,
-0.4205731153,
-0.0895290822,
0.116999127,
-0.1783107817,
0.5400303602,
-0.1482058465,
0.0575402267,
-0.6027675867,
-0.2567871809,
-0.303509891,
0.3719826937,
-0.4674431384,
0.5466957092,
0.1706217825,
-0.5164595246,
0.4368208647,
-0.6385844946,
-0.6402416825,
-0.252058357,
0.132093057,
-0.4652868211,
-0.1257491708,
0.3609528542,
0.7429158092,
0.3335847855,
0.2746119201,
-0.7365365028,
-0.1340315789,
0.5742177367,
-0.1587309986,
0.3065698743,
0.2488872111,
-0.1828309447,
0.2631879747,
-0.5900815725,
0.1317526549,
-0.1730975062,
-0.025725808,
-0.0882906318,
0.2352185398,
0.0738527477,
0.5503584743,
0.3734615743,
-0.6698598862,
0.1347937584,
0.4873735905,
0.1380060762,
0.7933315039,
-0.0800705776,
0.3674823344,
-0.4678700268,
0.3257582188,
0.2697096467,
0.3325062394,
-0.4637503028,
-0.5608487725,
-0.5384920239,
-0.4573194385,
-0.4056766629,
0.5453545451,
-0.5441604257,
0.3234709203,
-0.138135612,
-0.5929660201,
0.0431376509,
-0.0499810725,
0.5506662726,
0.2702712119,
0.4673824906,
-0.3123467565,
-0.8347956538,
-0.7614861131,
-0.3376156092,
0.0973592773,
0.175774008,
0.3934796751,
0.4727862775,
-0.2319417745,
0.8626186252,
-0.5574839115,
-0.2691112459,
-0.448449403,
0.3684776723,
-0.1264438629,
0.659742415,
0.2949614525,
-0.8997664452,
-0.2529783547,
-0.2114559114,
-0.6133543253,
0.2579636872,
-0.051924061,
-0.1148582399,
-0.0883203521,
0.1965701729,
-0.4320619404,
0.2119863182,
0.429497838,
-0.8813663125,
0.9192445874,
-0.1406500638,
0.2749455571,
-0.8831573129,
-0.0620272271,
0.4922856688,
-0.2592947483,
-0.6553971767,
-0.5143081546,
0.0288122781,
-0.0561254323,
-0.1772432625,
0.8376718163,
-0.3031185567,
-0.2423311472,
-0.2013285309,
-0.2688986957,
0.1607043892,
0.8083706498,
0.2269301265,
0.6100441813,
0.386366576,
-0.3981495798,
0.3638077974,
0.2889119685,
-0.3570971489,
1.1301609278,
-0.068687968,
0.2206561118,
-0.6411538124,
0.378190726,
-0.8126977682,
-0.4777827859,
0.063780807,
-0.5574815869,
0.1435774714,
0.0281799491,
-0.3712274134,
-0.2929292023,
-0.2171608061,
0.0748088285,
0.3070665002,
-0.2820890248,
0.901047945,
0.1602576226,
-0.271871984,
-0.4100295305,
-0.3783158362,
-0.1696099937,
-0.3297073543,
-0.4045221508,
0.3659911752,
-0.4276598692,
-0.2875954807,
-0.1418941021,
0.0232070796,
-0.2100321651,
-0.1354955882,
0.4150970578,
0.2874277532,
0.0361049734,
0.0730169117,
0.0090574706,
-0.2033827752,
-0.0556783788,
-0.0002911066,
0.3154805601,
-0.2841231525,
-0.3759971559,
-0.4310961366,
0.4450762868,
0.811432004,
-0.5372094512,
0.4256536663,
1.0208806992,
-0.1066286042,
0.1823566109,
-0.8378315568,
-0.3868710101,
-0.3597228527,
0.4617335796,
-0.4929148853,
-0.8296877742,
0.4492378831,
0.0858293399,
-0.1792708635,
-0.012389522,
0.7023009062,
-0.3310777545,
1.3829915524,
0.5255345702,
0.1453408897,
0.8049839735,
0.0234335531,
0.0589138046,
-1.0672149658,
-0.5260843635,
-0.0190719012,
-0.6803411245,
-0.3282414973,
-0.5363947749,
0.5434733629,
-0.4598705471,
-0.5651293397,
0.2239839733,
-0.326223433,
0.3020298481,
0.6743971109,
0.4515431821,
0.296367079,
-0.2956056595,
-0.0212741662,
-0.2557169199,
-0.006495385,
-0.231520012,
1.2179583311,
0.1892975122,
0.4801719785,
0.2158629447,
0.1783169359,
0.4268776178,
0.6790564656,
-0.6763279438,
0.5616442561,
-0.2596808672,
-0.6982690096,
-0.182262063,
-0.2655142546,
-0.3275657296,
0.3429437578,
-0.2110490501,
-0.8967021108,
0.4822743237,
0.3309469819,
-0.319848299,
-0.0617382005,
-0.8686780334,
0.8296080828,
-0.4063560963,
-0.4124247134,
-0.6355125308,
-0.8171371222,
0.3532322645,
0.1945249885,
0.2295469791,
-0.6057656407,
0.3439293504,
0.4736589193,
-0.0511724353,
0.6310597658,
-0.5319544077,
0.4141367376,
0.0229049772,
0.0550479218,
0.2659188211,
0.087943688,
-0.1762623638,
-0.0409560017,
0.1938571185,
-0.2015359849,
-0.6247008443,
0.5282027125,
-0.6890322566,
-0.1632234305,
-0.3687810302,
-0.7151170373,
-0.6142386794,
0.1538810581,
0.0314343236,
0.7345802188,
-0.0538237132,
0.3172694445,
0.599434495,
0.129469797,
0.2595404088,
0.3179025948,
-0.1498605013,
-0.4926160574,
0.9816972017,
-0.1492568105,
-0.0550103188,
0.4866891503,
0.3755681217,
-0.3315525651,
-0.0915433243,
-0.1556611657,
0.1643096358,
-0.8256796002,
0.0838193446,
-0.4610702097,
0.3222916722,
-0.3282878697,
-0.1475484073,
-0.4271720946,
-0.193375811,
-0.0293220971,
0.2607842982,
0.2390904427,
0.3325361013,
0.0530429445,
0.2280927896,
-0.5460596681,
0.3710609078,
0.4991984665,
0.456227839,
0.0782539919,
-0.2513273954,
-0.2323340476,
-0.0228581633,
-0.641992569,
-0.769105494,
0.3153693378,
0.11030031,
0.4951094389,
0.7006508708,
-0.0898470134,
0.5633689761,
-0.2493695617,
0.4777926505,
0.234655425,
-0.6548599005,
0.5276144147,
-0.3489385247,
0.3869509995,
0.4865709543,
0.3049361408,
-0.6745145917,
0.1628883183,
-0.1968294382,
-0.0942344964,
0.4956864417,
0.0493989103,
-0.0998804793,
-0.0376279242,
-0.0025928689,
0.2538631856,
0.4225387871,
-0.5459333062,
-0.2798675001,
-0.7011716366,
-0.0832780823,
-0.4379985631,
-0.2527650893,
0.1733667403,
-0.7102805972,
0.4659318328,
-0.4914013743,
0.5217599869,
0.2555546761,
0.0016035782,
0.0214692075,
0.4519149363,
0.6602574587,
0.5609968901,
-0.5782155991,
0.0581331737,
-0.2310320884,
-0.3072118461,
0.1757570207,
0.1782569438,
0.6171794534,
-0.2578177452,
0.0133204628,
0.6866416335,
0.3480927646,
-0.9854973555,
0.4351834357,
-0.0161003303,
-0.1048085317,
-0.7024028301,
-0.158244282,
0.0485071726,
0.6276630759,
0.1830736101,
0.3733702898,
0.0311443489,
-0.6199109554,
0.1630657166,
0.2522986233,
-0.2965176404,
-0.4167362452,
0.5435233712,
0.1110086069,
0.102070041,
0.5965375304,
-0.3937247396,
-0.4932904243,
0.5138902068,
0.1471037567,
0.7798776031,
-0.3508211672,
0.2643968463,
0.3980792761,
-0.1461419612,
-0.0196690541,
0.6892404556,
-0.1754268557,
-1.1824522018,
-0.5523261428,
-0.3410002887,
-0.6453953385,
-0.0163196977,
-0.3706721663,
0.2687756717,
-0.5893746614,
-0.4029254317,
0.0419156067,
-0.0582788885,
-0.6260072589,
0.4363736212,
0.5152394176,
0.6519471407,
-0.538084209,
0.8141394854,
0.9563308358,
-0.1717094481,
-0.597679615,
-0.0580555424,
0.3431276679,
-0.5420871973,
0.5775359273,
0.3382207453,
-0.1219729036,
-0.088639617,
-0.2093888372,
-0.8450215459,
1.0319641829,
0.1750067174,
-0.064011842,
-0.0680147409,
-0.343596071,
0.1543549001,
-0.4005649686,
0.3969299197,
0.427292645,
0.8609260321,
0.341296345,
-0.7377365232,
-0.1831716448,
-0.4322533906,
-0.1864786893,
0.0953199491,
-0.5618630052,
1.040790081,
-0.5154328942,
0.2988562286,
0.0241426323,
0.7797167301,
0.3293505609,
0.5721729398,
0.5927092433,
0.4614058435,
0.5871031284,
-0.0301322117,
0.902490437,
-0.2129903287,
0.1116586551,
1.1184786558,
-0.3375312686,
0.7419701815,
0.4259200394,
-0.1062808335,
0.9942213893,
0.5039308667,
-0.0633149818,
0.5627297759,
-0.3285091221,
-0.2997019589,
-0.6900248528,
-0.2414904982,
-0.0390492976,
0.8839692473,
0.4797510505,
-0.1740087271,
0.0760438889,
0.3778910041,
0.1528295279,
0.0285942759,
-0.3137916923,
0.5230252743,
-0.164070338,
-0.9625756145,
-0.0695193559,
0.0575282164,
0.8493931293,
-0.5608813167,
0.0991783217,
-0.0577937923,
0.5143654943,
-0.2164775729,
-0.9665886164,
0.2593351305,
-0.2976050675,
-0.3767203689,
-0.558547318,
0.7710133791,
-0.312403053,
-0.1772672981,
0.0487525277,
0.5578943491,
-0.0559719726,
-0.72931844,
-0.425112009,
-0.2498994023,
-0.1544663161,
-0.2670071125,
0.4894182086,
0.0759948641,
-0.1476950943,
0.9489617348,
0.5628280044,
-0.1609470099,
-0.2667884529,
-0.0153427683,
0.7249342799,
-0.7116882801,
-0.72617805,
-0.6184841394,
0.7688527107,
0.0919038728,
-0.4077787101,
0.6014223695,
0.2345392555,
0.5937127471,
-0.2945382893,
0.8202577829,
-0.2672813833,
0.6356430054,
-0.1806074232,
0.3584084511,
-0.6275909543,
-0.3697389066,
-0.2819503844,
-0.7360097766,
0.1714499742,
0.4293075204,
-0.4764715731,
0.4187943041,
0.7707970738,
0.5983362198,
0.0803773627,
0.2317194492,
0.221552372,
-0.1116764173,
0.2161780894,
0.6052567959,
0.6040309668,
0.3763991296,
0.2745779455,
-0.8785223961,
-0.2198067904,
-0.5568403006,
-1.0165910721,
-0.8705402613,
-0.6838086843,
-0.152304396,
-0.2801317871,
-0.1961956471,
1.1042109728,
0.9608611465,
-0.6359648108,
-0.0985948741,
0.2866434455,
0.2088003904,
-0.6899940968,
-0.2555053234,
-0.1087506711,
0.2743979394,
-0.4689258039,
0.2623100579,
0.3023572564,
-0.3431174159,
-0.5549832582,
-0.1655399948,
-0.1773245335,
-0.2121629417,
0.8626820445,
0.2432692796,
-0.7485668063,
-0.570105195,
0.0468875542,
0.2564120591,
0.1577716172,
1.0424011946,
-0.8349235654,
0.6515671015,
0.392129302,
-0.0520476326,
0.273296684,
0.2230468988,
0.4871533513,
-0.7515136003,
0.1111575365,
0.2470623106,
0.4783856273,
0.5273592472,
-0.5401095152,
-0.0150939329,
0.4955411851,
-0.4857495427,
-0.2838467658,
0.6036713719,
-1.2258281708,
-0.1933098584,
0.8570127487,
0.0154342484,
0.0917092562,
-0.3273181021,
-0.1838739812,
0.0670531392,
-0.6574762464,
0.4420121908,
0.7174812555,
-0.7170562744,
-0.7826731801,
-0.2896829844,
0.242753908,
0.4518329799,
-0.8429282308,
0.0337091312,
0.6227369905,
0.2308852971,
0.1830802709,
0.5267158151,
0.1009297669,
0.440230906,
-0.0819024593,
0.2517712116,
-0.428842932,
-0.6155788898,
0.0158159453,
0.0525673553,
-0.1835968196,
0.1107371226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03158v1 | CoT-MAE v2: Contextual Masked Auto-Encoder with Multi-view Modeling for Passage Retrieval | 2023-04-05T08:00:38 | 2023-04-05T08:00:38 | Xing Wu, Guangyuan Ma, Peng Wang, Meng Lin, Zijia Lin, Fuzheng Zhang, Songlin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Growing techniques have been emerging to improve the performance of passage
retrieval. As an effective representation bottleneck pretraining technique, the
contextual masked auto-encoder utilizes contextual embedding to assist in the
reconstruction of passages. However, it only uses a single auto-encoding
pre-task for dense representation pre-training. This study brings multi-view
modeling to the contextual masked auto-encoder. Firstly, multi-view
representation utilizes both dense and sparse vectors as multi-view
representations, aiming to capture sentence semantics from different aspects.
Moreover, multiview decoding paradigm utilizes both autoencoding and
auto-regressive decoders in representation bottleneck pre-training, aiming to
provide both reconstructive and generative signals for better contextual
representation pretraining. We refer to this multi-view pretraining method as
CoT-MAE v2. Through extensive experiments, we show that CoT-MAE v2 is effective
and robust on large-scale passage retrieval benchmarks and out-of-domain
zero-shot benchmarks. | [
-0.3382813036,
-0.5121049881,
0.7723949552,
0.23887375,
-0.4805760384,
0.0057110684,
0.2424153984,
-0.2572657466,
0.167750597,
0.7379663587,
-0.3033365011,
-0.231853053,
-1.0375785828,
0.1079814956,
-0.3888777792,
0.6133864522,
-0.174919188,
0.2489668727,
-0.3923438191,
-0.0666027516,
-0.6805714965,
-0.787742734,
-0.0757792145,
0.2499789745,
0.1074872836,
0.1590290368,
0.2076600045,
0.5884132385,
0.1728021353,
0.2558710277,
0.1629638076,
0.140914917,
-0.4531807303,
0.3188029528,
0.2622132003,
-0.4702282548,
-0.2011842877,
0.2145809382,
0.5960205197,
0.3847981691,
-0.0171699077,
-0.121619463,
0.1640075147,
0.5496686101,
-1.0140558481,
0.2308163345,
-0.6904044747,
0.0580348112,
-0.0034222866,
-0.21084629,
-0.5562675595,
-0.1004552171,
0.355258286,
-0.6675235033,
0.2086082846,
0.1818476021,
0.6378511786,
0.4441380799,
-0.9160351157,
-0.1994474381,
-0.2766303718,
0.6824052334,
-0.2966915667,
0.6357117295,
0.3642938435,
0.4487397075,
0.1801518649,
-0.8090243936,
-0.374097079,
-0.1324798316,
-0.4252421558,
0.1414198279,
0.1839717627,
0.0928960741,
-0.0567598268,
0.2199036181,
-0.6118944287,
-0.4240782261,
-0.5781342983,
-0.4191182852,
0.3832795024,
0.0800533742,
-0.1153160036,
-0.2411672324,
-0.9539533854,
-0.2496959567,
-0.5845702291,
-0.1967346966,
0.002735171,
-0.264331758,
-0.1189895868,
0.1988619715,
-0.101171039,
0.646559,
-0.1357688159,
0.1048789024,
0.4786253572,
-0.3305850327,
-0.3049403429,
0.020101143,
0.5046085119,
0.3353974819,
-0.0137415063,
-0.0746407732,
-0.189141959,
-0.1055666059,
0.4788261652,
-0.80045259,
-0.3846181929,
-0.0168478601,
-0.5611689687,
-0.1629830152,
0.2441209555,
-0.9552252889,
-0.2664514482,
-0.47038275,
0.674562037,
-0.2296328694,
-0.2896850109,
0.1057453156,
-0.1054100469,
0.5956707001,
0.457777977,
-0.5041347146,
0.4095001817,
0.4208582044,
0.8534223437,
-0.1921828985,
-0.1603916734,
-0.8113363981,
0.148396045,
-0.2512031794,
0.6624949574,
-0.57359308,
-0.603463769,
-0.1250163615,
0.1771373451,
-0.4217988849,
-0.4099549651,
0.194827199,
-0.4926884472,
0.2232064903,
-0.3858584762,
-0.4432327449,
-0.0124035273,
0.3201623261,
-0.6995017529,
0.7848105431,
0.1171981022,
-0.3521026671,
0.2999975383,
-0.3684228957,
-0.1748314202,
-0.266318053,
-0.3742352426,
-0.3820590675,
0.0683236644,
0.4604705274,
0.2330817431,
-0.0224201493,
0.0339543,
0.0799357444,
-0.3061645627,
-0.1383141726,
-0.7388620377,
0.4752476513,
0.3715825379,
-0.2113721818,
-0.1518378705,
-0.4585516155,
-0.0659063458,
0.01512923,
-0.1057367623,
-0.4069584906,
-0.1604191661,
0.2780212462,
0.4021086395,
0.2012775093,
-0.5281872153,
0.0759141669,
-0.3173862994,
0.2280881554,
0.3959365189,
-0.0049454267,
0.4578375816,
0.0721898153,
0.4500514567,
0.4002269208,
0.2494514138,
-0.6081445813,
-0.4436732233,
-0.5934102535,
-0.2204137444,
0.1619751304,
0.4392340481,
-0.8097817302,
0.012200661,
0.1671790034,
-0.0592604913,
-0.6334343553,
0.1028983891,
0.7889076471,
0.5070387125,
0.6660801172,
-0.5727847815,
-0.5560974479,
-0.7366908193,
-0.1111246645,
0.1603627205,
0.1047586128,
0.2869767249,
0.5506341457,
-0.2450721115,
0.8057029247,
-0.7288187146,
-0.6121912003,
-0.1316050291,
0.2454281598,
-0.4600392282,
0.5672643781,
0.7584092021,
-1.0172897577,
-0.4367610514,
-0.5072135329,
-0.7586026788,
0.0193002913,
0.1133315489,
-0.3633539975,
0.3958959281,
0.8502195477,
-0.2338348925,
0.6355912685,
0.3894958794,
-0.4166791737,
0.4520842433,
-0.5227262378,
0.2486670911,
-1.1084691286,
-0.2423271686,
-0.3865604103,
-0.415933311,
-0.4245221019,
-0.0639655814,
0.5438907146,
0.0038336501,
-0.5362039804,
0.4135124981,
-0.861489296,
-0.1347490698,
-0.4625567794,
0.3251601756,
0.5483133793,
0.5024133325,
0.3902619481,
0.8661314845,
0.5926870704,
-0.6114950776,
0.0116192792,
0.2972247303,
-0.1864000112,
0.6406196952,
-0.576072216,
0.2806041539,
-0.4852257073,
0.6095816493,
-0.9854635,
-0.1269083321,
-0.0525361225,
-0.3424010277,
0.4611396492,
-0.1579278857,
-0.0996237993,
-0.2147289962,
-0.5529531837,
0.7275277972,
0.2706505358,
-0.5325827003,
0.5245586038,
0.3336441219,
0.0390790403,
-0.6529003382,
-0.5408586264,
0.02786294,
0.0710350424,
-0.1404471546,
0.5050781369,
0.1272332817,
0.1591680646,
-0.1541241109,
-0.2879494727,
0.0532957204,
-0.3006181121,
0.0704281852,
0.4372416735,
-0.2011791766,
0.0568262152,
0.1443378776,
-0.4782699943,
0.0702949762,
-0.4026098549,
0.5191723704,
-0.0911655053,
-0.3424849212,
-0.1645672023,
0.7781968713,
0.5956785679,
-0.5620575547,
0.8041218519,
0.6650106907,
-0.354190141,
0.0989758074,
-0.7641900182,
-0.0997657403,
-0.3958412707,
0.4902183712,
-0.6216224432,
-0.6726480126,
0.1346253157,
-0.0967467204,
-0.1585889906,
0.468090713,
0.4059436619,
0.0067938385,
0.9911006689,
0.7753663063,
0.0615846924,
0.2546854615,
-0.6919868588,
0.0824435726,
-1.4302575588,
-0.762129128,
-0.4302287102,
0.0336710028,
-0.2450886071,
-0.6008666754,
0.6426379681,
0.0861238092,
-0.3323815167,
0.5635211468,
-0.5942851305,
0.3537964523,
0.5248892903,
-0.0166402925,
0.2525573671,
-0.242765069,
-0.3124999106,
0.0495856442,
-0.5084941387,
-0.6413542628,
1.2647278309,
0.1547422558,
0.7963545322,
0.1630414277,
0.5441535115,
0.1452719867,
-0.0010476726,
-0.4337363541,
0.1700848937,
-0.160110727,
-0.4114388525,
-0.0607923456,
-0.2406043708,
-0.7444885969,
0.7757587433,
-0.1326626688,
-0.8138896823,
0.5893720388,
0.2159762383,
-0.3907130659,
0.0545759462,
-0.9722372293,
1.0104656219,
-0.2951195538,
-0.3345969915,
-0.0026350259,
-0.9393871427,
0.32359761,
-0.0856719241,
0.082180433,
0.1703220606,
-0.2228561044,
0.6127300262,
-0.5899745226,
0.4368907213,
-0.4025835991,
0.0094997147,
0.2652081251,
0.1302186549,
0.4337871075,
0.3674300611,
0.2318793088,
0.0584903099,
0.4104303122,
-0.3046758473,
-0.530579567,
0.6928124428,
-0.8963514566,
-0.5476031303,
-0.6317999959,
-0.1454611123,
-0.2678638697,
-0.1785831004,
0.6827734113,
0.8045108318,
-0.0093061728,
0.2548187971,
0.7054744959,
-0.2915667892,
0.4240565002,
0.3872469068,
-0.0251254961,
-0.4621688426,
0.5568851233,
-0.058555752,
0.478769213,
0.5543171167,
-0.4063852429,
-0.7026745677,
-0.0777249187,
-0.4784438908,
0.0476209074,
-0.662992239,
-0.3669293523,
-1.0349125862,
-0.4540584087,
-0.5784725547,
-0.2586573064,
-0.6101151705,
-0.1178836897,
-0.1901257187,
-0.0455978587,
0.0359432474,
0.6201083064,
0.0044605839,
0.4046811163,
-0.5162859559,
0.6533257961,
0.3837375343,
0.2804727256,
0.015097104,
-0.3882542551,
-0.1867207438,
-0.1290633678,
-0.4949659705,
-0.8846868277,
0.4522223175,
-0.0374565162,
0.5053809285,
0.2668690383,
0.1027967557,
0.591407001,
-0.428383112,
0.7347980738,
0.2165149599,
-0.764443934,
0.6221557856,
0.3335671127,
0.2826945484,
0.6633043885,
0.1471414119,
-0.137919575,
-0.0857364461,
-0.1577548087,
-0.946074307,
0.7501964569,
0.4206723273,
0.0931828767,
0.0730768442,
0.1807560921,
0.3222844005,
0.3527152836,
-0.5060670972,
-0.1280760616,
-0.7245132923,
-0.1217186749,
-0.207345292,
-0.5973076224,
0.2562877834,
-0.2311562747,
0.3906099796,
-0.0694738179,
0.7177374959,
0.7253424525,
-0.562997818,
0.3183402419,
0.0963363647,
0.512403965,
0.3210009038,
-0.3555718958,
0.2486072183,
0.1582673788,
-0.8833988905,
0.2458397746,
0.3076397777,
0.0545900054,
0.1052183881,
0.3373654187,
1.0016189814,
0.1848469377,
-0.4120960832,
0.8268916607,
-0.1509946287,
-0.1776449084,
-0.6022920012,
-0.0729910061,
-0.464640379,
0.2645800114,
0.5163943768,
0.0062737227,
0.4939945042,
-0.5601344109,
0.1504891068,
0.2627008855,
-0.4180734158,
0.1587043256,
1.2124041319,
0.202101931,
0.0094039831,
0.4629103839,
-0.0375253335,
-0.5600901246,
0.5904870629,
0.4416892827,
0.9240857959,
-0.13825728,
0.0277255084,
0.4232111275,
0.1529387534,
-0.0196052678,
0.0768676549,
-0.5379181504,
-0.2363982052,
-0.1874153167,
-0.6610188484,
-0.2115601301,
0.0477552302,
-0.8174000382,
0.1464197338,
0.2208650559,
0.0952546895,
-0.4757724106,
-0.011942042,
-0.7555516958,
0.3727042675,
0.2184062004,
0.9039027691,
-0.3908046782,
0.9204939008,
0.3280563951,
-0.2888368368,
-0.5411065221,
0.267814219,
0.2581590116,
-0.5767938495,
0.220349133,
0.5344962478,
-0.426714927,
-0.0387221612,
-0.3179060519,
-0.9491620064,
1.4459089041,
0.131286338,
-0.7771311402,
-0.0898790509,
0.015787242,
0.2608840168,
-0.8185250163,
0.4503096044,
0.4920009673,
0.0904174,
0.265532434,
-0.9334936738,
-0.1128931493,
-0.2115231305,
0.384889245,
-0.0161517486,
-0.6026066542,
0.8760446906,
-0.1441901773,
0.1417264342,
0.2463537753,
0.4027965665,
0.3149547577,
0.4074810445,
0.4308592081,
0.1983306408,
0.462792933,
-0.1212088689,
1.0853421688,
-0.365169853,
0.3232084215,
1.1564619541,
-0.3165567219,
0.8999771476,
0.447966069,
0.2685436606,
0.518571198,
0.2961334884,
0.440664202,
1.107124567,
-0.1708720922,
-0.2546695471,
-0.1094152555,
0.4068343043,
-0.6647216082,
0.6087048054,
0.4540432394,
-0.6320384145,
-0.1930114329,
0.5914427042,
0.0534394234,
0.0066628847,
-0.2881679237,
0.9011512399,
0.2954187989,
-0.7160890698,
0.544382453,
0.0386874862,
0.5949099064,
-0.5179467201,
-0.0688056573,
-0.258710444,
0.1962056309,
0.2715927064,
-0.5520566702,
0.3714990914,
-0.0909850523,
0.2135094702,
-0.3791564107,
0.7883911729,
-0.6047677398,
-0.2766550183,
0.4413328767,
0.6353469491,
0.2435257882,
-0.3298449814,
-0.2947548628,
0.1449781209,
-0.2578307986,
-0.3009023368,
0.1075268835,
0.3100115061,
-0.0355138555,
0.2913791835,
0.2584573328,
-0.3781131208,
0.2398685664,
0.2233543545,
0.8597541451,
-0.7854454517,
-0.6374852061,
-0.6552339196,
0.440336436,
-0.2043250501,
-0.3220148087,
0.3196898699,
0.8111541867,
0.7361491323,
-0.2848159969,
0.7059996724,
0.0605378486,
0.2514115572,
-0.7394980192,
0.8299040794,
-0.6283826828,
0.1364884228,
-0.3096326888,
-0.9814727306,
-0.0258736964,
0.7551708817,
-0.1865612119,
0.1421098262,
0.9023287892,
0.954357326,
-0.1776020527,
-0.2302687019,
0.3298870921,
0.2331040502,
0.1592080742,
0.8197164536,
0.4746784568,
-0.8138411045,
0.6595960259,
-0.0347321257,
-0.2275769114,
-0.4926275015,
-0.5276649594,
-0.7594514489,
-1.073202014,
-0.1361790299,
-0.2647261918,
0.0534730777,
0.6974306107,
1.0769714117,
-0.5735786557,
0.0896620229,
-0.0533294491,
-0.2365175933,
0.006052041,
-0.2192929536,
0.4949554503,
-0.3988465369,
-0.5946506262,
0.3989841044,
0.4304871559,
0.0714660659,
-0.518604219,
-0.3643003404,
-0.1900507212,
0.2144015133,
0.9679389,
-0.1377246231,
-0.6410146356,
-0.2005737722,
-0.0097984243,
-0.2652294338,
0.0666872263,
0.6845835447,
-1.3551932573,
0.8005643487,
0.1040864438,
0.2357853949,
1.0065405369,
0.0604655854,
0.5701321959,
-0.6634875536,
0.2905346155,
-0.1329391003,
0.5234581828,
0.2542617619,
-0.3727034032,
0.4869273305,
0.2830837667,
-0.275634259,
-0.5969452262,
0.1690118611,
-0.9960477948,
-0.24255687,
1.0255266428,
-0.0762904063,
-0.1748986691,
-0.3016450703,
-0.6360456944,
0.1525542289,
-0.1196490005,
0.7286688685,
0.6179113388,
0.0644229054,
-0.4704690576,
-0.7928358912,
0.48163113,
0.1344088167,
-0.6660652161,
-0.3545196056,
0.4485096335,
0.2796290219,
0.0193366222,
0.8279031515,
-0.5427063704,
0.4150079191,
0.1845835447,
-0.391933322,
-0.2013936043,
-0.6728306413,
-0.1434612721,
0.2589726746,
-0.4131771922,
-0.5978403687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02247v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02247v2 | Disentangling Structure and Style: Political Bias Detection in News by Inducing Document Hierarchy | 2023-04-05T06:35:41 | 2023-10-27T11:35:04 | Jiwoo Hong, Yejin Cho, Jaemin Jung, Jiyoung Han, James Thorne | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We address an important gap in detecting political bias in news articles.
Previous works that perform document classification can be influenced by the
writing style of each news outlet, leading to overfitting and limited
generalizability. Our approach overcomes this limitation by considering both
the sentence-level semantics and the document-level rhetorical structure,
resulting in a more robust and style-agnostic approach to detecting political
bias in news articles. We introduce a novel multi-head hierarchical attention
model that effectively encodes the structure of long documents through a
diverse ensemble of attention heads. While journalism follows a formalized
rhetorical structure, the writing style may vary by news outlet. We demonstrate
that our method overcomes this domain dependency and outperforms previous
approaches for robustness and accuracy. Further analysis and human evaluation
demonstrate the ability of our model to capture common discourse structures in
journalism. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/xfactlab/emnlp2023-Document-Hierarchy | [
-0.2376817316,
-0.8790342808,
0.6086835861,
0.1676907837,
-0.1457120329,
0.3725702763,
-0.1362022012,
-0.1563966572,
0.3030461073,
0.2117510289,
-0.5532231331,
-0.5432910919,
-1.0710601807,
-0.2114992738,
-0.4358678758,
1.1344742775,
0.3394975662,
0.1289673895,
0.0832538158,
-0.1194312274,
0.0445103757,
-0.5102420449,
-0.3149252534,
-0.4825046659,
0.3783075809,
0.2074360251,
0.6214962602,
0.8645196557,
0.2383349389,
0.2797337174,
-0.3355744183,
0.1086313128,
-0.4923834801,
-0.0901886746,
-0.4081298113,
-0.2969587147,
-0.4233951867,
0.2407216877,
0.5999917388,
0.5791330338,
0.2281961888,
0.0800316036,
0.214482531,
0.9946014881,
-0.5260575414,
0.2133696526,
-0.8815991282,
-0.0445191972,
-0.399977386,
-0.5407252908,
-0.4952968359,
-0.1212777197,
0.1207528636,
-0.3797019124,
0.2641792595,
0.1265847981,
0.9803038836,
0.1019689441,
-0.7279642224,
-0.4094229639,
-0.5272182822,
0.6571019888,
-0.2844584286,
0.3881056011,
0.2138408422,
-0.0265142694,
0.1159211099,
-0.2515846491,
-0.4250234663,
0.1507423222,
-0.0636514351,
0.1072215065,
-0.1614425778,
0.0362854078,
0.0929178745,
0.3950039148,
-0.4740732014,
-0.2318320572,
-0.2756126821,
0.1303938776,
0.1822973341,
-0.3768544197,
0.2280784398,
-0.8053353429,
-0.2504132688,
0.0445552617,
-0.5451819301,
-0.2245868593,
0.8123447895,
0.4488235116,
-0.1727076471,
0.2969150245,
-0.2953274846,
0.413515389,
0.6972694993,
-0.3416509032,
0.1891482323,
-0.293084234,
-0.2500045002,
0.2699822485,
0.5154783726,
0.5502697229,
0.1093706638,
0.1561437547,
0.0500484966,
0.221024245,
0.4566196501,
-0.4429574609,
-0.1239386946,
0.2958191037,
-0.7160356641,
-0.8288167119,
0.0056952476,
-1.1376494169,
-0.6970252395,
-0.4600310922,
-0.0183202382,
-0.2049447,
-0.411049813,
0.0556333102,
-0.3048992157,
0.1977455169,
0.1697103232,
-0.8415461183,
0.0566032603,
0.747595489,
0.964787364,
-0.279946208,
-0.0358573832,
-0.4113762081,
0.1951525062,
-0.3030409217,
0.8674417138,
-0.5562976599,
0.2806330621,
0.2152019143,
-0.1588564515,
0.30411762,
-0.4215845168,
0.6529301405,
-0.4958561659,
0.4552030861,
-0.2828436792,
-0.3232902288,
0.3075836897,
0.5949044824,
-0.7595146894,
0.8548766375,
0.3668552637,
-1.3345458508,
0.5090761781,
-0.486766696,
-0.5301985145,
-0.4793141782,
-0.4367186129,
-0.7193565965,
-0.0519946776,
0.5025760531,
0.1956229955,
0.0803638548,
0.535584569,
-0.2126231343,
-0.069362022,
-0.2309222668,
-0.0641454607,
1.0406700373,
0.0286331046,
-0.4900671542,
0.4330791533,
-1.107609272,
-0.4581749737,
-0.0604082346,
-0.5676176548,
-0.7282105088,
0.0923781097,
0.1524161249,
0.4372988641,
-0.1323498338,
-0.550556004,
0.2451989055,
-0.0849344432,
0.5868838429,
0.766148448,
-0.0250730086,
1.0943346024,
-0.3021565676,
0.1215722412,
0.2970937192,
-0.0933420956,
-0.250495255,
-0.0452337712,
-0.5301917791,
-0.1979711056,
0.2744300067,
0.4845828712,
-0.5659431219,
0.6484680772,
-0.1134029701,
0.0175934192,
-0.3235134482,
-0.1351800859,
0.1652032882,
0.6249976754,
0.1359284073,
-0.0149338562,
-0.8268437982,
-0.8437121511,
-0.6642212868,
-0.0588176176,
-0.1493739635,
-0.0961359441,
0.4888215959,
0.0036225356,
0.7060377598,
-0.3247589171,
-0.4063215554,
-0.192907393,
0.3441432416,
0.1522257477,
0.3573256731,
0.518142581,
-0.9162746668,
-0.1828325093,
0.0414340757,
-0.4639670253,
-0.2382186949,
-0.3720473945,
-0.2982762158,
0.2489502728,
0.6048464775,
-0.5791851282,
0.4207435846,
0.3631575704,
-0.3337184489,
0.2869310081,
0.4296446145,
0.2070885152,
-1.1084645987,
-0.154590413,
0.407840997,
-0.4060528576,
-0.6577897668,
0.0079585444,
0.2827070355,
0.0514934994,
-0.3424766362,
0.1677097082,
-0.5519868731,
-0.1549691409,
-0.3689409494,
0.0938110873,
0.5137813091,
0.7161997557,
0.2592737079,
0.0787938088,
0.3859571218,
-0.1208833531,
-0.0083851507,
-0.0236508548,
-0.4927263856,
0.9592351317,
-0.5327849984,
0.1355861127,
-0.5319912434,
0.6238101125,
-1.2701187134,
-0.2702468634,
0.2039205283,
-0.4451644123,
0.4307405353,
-0.4295194149,
-0.4080229104,
-0.1253745109,
-0.6535580754,
0.1981260329,
0.0294446126,
-0.3702141047,
0.4684217274,
0.6961925626,
-0.0935618207,
-0.6579192877,
-0.7576089501,
-0.1344977319,
-0.3157558441,
-0.4933132529,
0.5893608332,
0.2272593975,
-0.3780640066,
0.0190941561,
-0.4800789058,
-0.2500311434,
-0.315959692,
-0.0404556468,
0.1708742529,
-0.2240775228,
0.0996808708,
0.3060315251,
0.2548021078,
0.0390779041,
-0.3520932496,
0.4720550478,
0.1583563983,
0.0263956096,
-0.5594599247,
0.8040750623,
1.0459209681,
-0.4289667904,
0.4893998802,
0.3564067781,
-0.5718233585,
-0.3395485878,
-0.5549080968,
-0.1088350192,
-0.3662869632,
0.5236807466,
0.0143052433,
-0.5949947238,
0.5442680717,
-0.1268442422,
-0.0037962203,
0.3569236994,
0.6969495416,
0.2968719006,
1.0182750225,
0.7651320696,
-0.4301392436,
0.6375309825,
-0.1298580319,
0.1809766889,
-0.56447649,
-0.1730248779,
-0.7128442526,
-0.4623188078,
-0.4210585058,
-0.1279556155,
0.253849566,
-0.2417815328,
-0.1596588194,
-0.0957396477,
-0.927133441,
0.7862141728,
0.3759516478,
0.0551977977,
0.4488471448,
0.1287312657,
0.3110084236,
-0.0480939597,
-0.4853239357,
-0.3543657064,
0.7750170827,
0.681024611,
0.8982121944,
-0.1655679047,
0.6114735603,
0.2559632957,
0.0771803334,
-0.8531286716,
-0.0817404985,
-0.1033946797,
-0.6658645272,
-0.2389086187,
-0.2178583294,
-0.5864050388,
0.6124768853,
0.1363725811,
-0.621566236,
0.5759080648,
-0.1819379926,
-0.2915199995,
0.332787931,
-0.5211243629,
0.6488019228,
0.1093430817,
-0.2388886213,
-0.0138209974,
-0.6644296646,
0.5124358535,
0.1448614746,
0.3327744007,
-0.0729291588,
0.0731578991,
0.6431462765,
0.0514059626,
0.8324167728,
0.1545182616,
-0.1718988568,
-0.0368682407,
-0.2936804593,
0.2573508918,
0.1023540422,
-0.0353889801,
0.045702897,
-0.2094677389,
-0.3117824793,
-0.3977259994,
0.6964960694,
-0.7790269256,
-0.429020673,
-0.6342865229,
-0.9360265732,
-0.0192344207,
0.4322557449,
0.3520541787,
0.5215628147,
-0.2023123503,
0.383551687,
0.7659489512,
0.2993561625,
0.2209650278,
0.3030099869,
-0.0282600224,
-0.2021059543,
0.3205779195,
0.4123395383,
-0.049215395,
0.471803695,
0.2847384214,
-0.2305439264,
-0.4260926545,
-0.3494467139,
-0.0079968628,
-0.6328049898,
-0.1867088526,
-0.7581146955,
-0.2382363379,
-0.6297584176,
-0.1554591656,
-0.4343946576,
-0.6073341966,
-0.2151969522,
-0.1718039215,
-0.1671508402,
0.8700013161,
0.1545082182,
0.4453830719,
-0.1714145392,
0.6668877006,
0.0994966105,
0.1841435432,
-0.1772925556,
-0.5369732976,
-0.0329972096,
-0.2690103054,
-0.8825212717,
-1.4416171312,
0.3015486896,
-0.051329229,
0.3481111825,
0.6004722714,
0.1972865909,
0.242726326,
-0.6739820838,
0.4318815768,
-0.0752191842,
-0.9701702595,
0.8759526014,
-0.836763978,
0.4733310938,
0.5799666643,
0.6116216779,
-0.1983276159,
-0.7764749527,
-0.6759267449,
-0.6947511435,
0.709913969,
0.0702372342,
-0.1337611228,
-0.1907654256,
0.2969834805,
-0.0832284316,
0.467335254,
-0.8897613883,
-0.1214142963,
-0.4065128565,
-0.0408997089,
0.4824242294,
-0.2929290235,
-0.4934416115,
-0.4027951658,
0.3716197908,
-0.1868221015,
-0.0830971226,
0.4146344066,
-0.0032934074,
-0.2289969325,
0.525457859,
0.6607135534,
0.9400309324,
-0.2796486616,
0.4568495452,
-0.5268532038,
-0.2111958563,
0.0553581789,
-0.0243251622,
-0.2590634525,
0.4659776092,
0.3067196012,
0.3529156446,
0.3201282918,
0.2248336971,
0.6204748154,
0.115450412,
-0.3800408244,
-0.0785104036,
-0.4569666386,
0.1606978476,
0.2938826084,
0.589767158,
0.1288819164,
0.4769492745,
-1.1984165907,
0.4176461697,
0.4830869734,
-0.1687783748,
-0.2140751779,
0.5970563889,
0.4804230332,
-0.0689054653,
0.1450652033,
-0.2121611089,
-0.7214623094,
0.7256138325,
0.4913643897,
0.7696248889,
-0.3741272688,
0.360196501,
0.1824479103,
0.4457071424,
-0.0815690681,
0.0702388212,
0.1406901181,
-0.6124665141,
-0.3002423048,
-0.4362182021,
-0.2206786871,
0.5266551971,
-0.6550352573,
0.1965892464,
-0.644262135,
-0.1027099192,
0.4782721698,
0.2735059261,
-0.0772365704,
-0.0129957953,
0.2905090749,
0.7788683772,
-1.1221596003,
0.895299077,
0.385776639,
0.0187219493,
-0.2427789718,
0.4781844914,
0.7310536504,
-0.3644124269,
0.3918381035,
0.3228930235,
-0.036235176,
-0.3540742993,
-0.5174347758,
-0.601872921,
0.7552759051,
0.5272173882,
-0.6306577921,
-0.5412162542,
-0.1787032783,
0.226862371,
-0.7230654955,
-0.0778786317,
0.7640486956,
0.4952268898,
-0.0249982681,
-0.645155251,
-0.0997539386,
-0.0746638477,
-0.1108991206,
0.3179223239,
-0.7709772587,
1.1073435545,
0.2292181551,
-0.2838612795,
-0.4410549402,
0.6505991817,
0.0298644491,
0.4925032854,
0.5017614365,
0.3076581359,
0.9598494172,
-0.1443102211,
0.9482356906,
-0.3856521547,
0.363976419,
1.1444685459,
-0.1764588952,
0.4419900775,
0.5391497612,
0.0973021388,
0.7161937952,
0.4235238731,
0.2634249926,
0.7663313746,
0.2467605472,
0.0675941929,
0.1211382896,
-0.3334847689,
-0.2907426953,
0.4904926121,
0.2605222464,
-0.5292826891,
-0.5203825831,
-0.1469321251,
0.4389362931,
0.3628285527,
-0.436460197,
0.4023367167,
-0.0270294212,
-0.6519501805,
0.1983072311,
0.0654127449,
0.7721239924,
-0.5227387547,
0.0460058264,
-0.01411069,
0.2637903094,
-0.4238056242,
-0.7315263152,
0.5470611453,
-0.2425048053,
-0.6645166278,
-0.3012357354,
1.0429706573,
-0.7472516298,
-0.3608893752,
0.226971671,
0.6051026583,
-0.4048205018,
-0.3852888346,
-0.5625634789,
0.6102638245,
-0.2164645642,
-0.4639644027,
0.4249081016,
0.6287096143,
-0.0523150936,
0.020018369,
0.4015234411,
-0.0878358185,
-0.1745939851,
0.3391181529,
1.0005631447,
-0.28352198,
-0.9151483178,
-1.0468834639,
0.2581994236,
-0.5186764598,
-0.2930721045,
0.6431130767,
0.482729882,
0.8448911905,
-0.0536100306,
0.6814315319,
0.0754112154,
0.4064962864,
-0.42039904,
0.9651182294,
-0.2959535122,
-0.2140251994,
-0.5554260015,
-0.7407075763,
-0.4108034968,
0.6729966998,
-0.2052645087,
0.0181672778,
0.9942600727,
0.6900779009,
-0.3030932546,
-0.0916841626,
0.0959706604,
0.236562252,
0.0685767531,
0.5671568513,
0.6829431057,
-0.0498276539,
0.4496970773,
-0.3050094545,
-0.5381591916,
0.0184632894,
-1.0148106813,
-1.1744294167,
-0.7029627562,
-0.4758135676,
-0.4549635947,
0.3065600991,
0.507717967,
1.135160923,
-0.5126026273,
-0.0884882063,
-0.0230810679,
0.595600307,
-0.0488479063,
-0.3113608956,
0.5612329841,
-0.2869530916,
-0.9911729693,
0.0846632347,
0.479878962,
-0.3794227839,
-0.4156929553,
0.3847277761,
-0.6332692504,
0.324280411,
0.7330393791,
0.0608968623,
-0.6800297499,
-0.5336343646,
-0.2716376781,
-0.2597408295,
0.433640331,
1.2214050293,
-0.4782248139,
0.1119673029,
0.8377492428,
0.5638796091,
0.1657806039,
0.3699427843,
0.2757517993,
-1.2485246658,
0.3890031874,
-0.0176905505,
0.3481389284,
0.487709552,
-0.6760890484,
0.3196884096,
0.2429498285,
-0.621322155,
-0.7806177139,
0.3350600898,
-1.168544054,
-0.4112520218,
1.1851844788,
0.2067012042,
-0.5861322284,
-0.2761361301,
-0.4319089651,
0.296867013,
-0.597055316,
0.8617148995,
0.9142683744,
-0.0249912646,
-0.3361824453,
-0.4830529392,
0.552669704,
-0.0143022304,
-0.8197453022,
0.1960061193,
0.5451861024,
0.2213688493,
0.5177946091,
0.9454276562,
-0.3357319236,
0.3318332434,
-0.0819474682,
-0.3615107536,
0.1974774152,
-0.7145536542,
-0.3555698991,
0.532466948,
-0.427765727,
-0.2472499311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02233v1 | Ericson: An Interactive Open-Domain Conversational Search Agent | 2023-04-05T05:28:31 | 2023-04-05T05:28:31 | Zihao Wang, Ali Ahmadvand, Jason Choi, Payam Karisani, Eugene Agichtein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, 68T07 | Open-domain conversational search (ODCS) aims to provide valuable, up-to-date
information, while maintaining natural conversations to help users refine and
ultimately answer information needs. However, creating an effective and robust
ODCS agent is challenging. In this paper, we present a fully functional ODCS
system, Ericson, which includes state-of-the-art question answering and
information retrieval components, as well as intent inference and dialogue
management models for proactive question refinement and recommendations. Our
system was stress-tested in the Amazon Alexa Prize, by engaging in live
conversations with thousands of Alexa users, thus providing empirical basis for
the analysis of the ODCS system in real settings. Our interaction data analysis
revealed that accurate intent classification, encouraging user engagement, and
careful proactive recommendations contribute most to the users satisfaction.
Our study further identifies limitations of the existing search techniques, and
can serve as a building block for the next generation of ODCS agents. | [
-0.6378468871,
-0.7427636981,
0.6947429776,
-0.3301166296,
-0.0109716132,
0.1933379918,
-0.1302216202,
-0.4139328301,
0.1727808565,
0.3583890498,
-0.5940558314,
-0.3850624859,
0.0087546362,
0.3078835309,
0.0811578259,
0.4503544271,
-0.1889570951,
-0.1597117037,
-0.1936311126,
-0.1480845809,
-0.29095456,
-0.217917487,
-0.8807095289,
0.0149544626,
0.6015219688,
0.5297852159,
1.0973459482,
0.2497408539,
0.2789343297,
0.3025966287,
-0.3167291582,
0.6491256952,
-0.7490352392,
0.7737118602,
-0.35807392,
-0.2300999612,
-0.6681969762,
-0.0334834084,
0.0893065706,
0.4297350347,
-0.3149755001,
-0.2579399049,
-0.0559976324,
0.0975677148,
-0.7947177291,
0.1168944761,
-0.5487764478,
-0.08332178,
0.2892028391,
-0.642261982,
-0.3191776276,
-0.4687353969,
0.5783278942,
-0.9681662917,
0.0030896585,
0.1954817027,
0.6453496218,
0.0644795075,
-0.6308321357,
-0.5541573763,
-0.8820647597,
0.7462711334,
-0.3907829523,
0.4549461603,
0.496938318,
0.4281861186,
-0.2033759952,
-0.6359221339,
-0.6069853306,
-0.3944665492,
-0.0632638708,
0.0747481957,
-0.1660616845,
0.3535189331,
-0.2767231464,
0.2637592852,
-0.6050162911,
-0.1030298322,
-0.2255367935,
0.3176225126,
0.6337263584,
0.2351880819,
0.1598050147,
0.2836919725,
-0.2058538944,
0.0533405133,
-0.4141780436,
0.0670584589,
0.5849522948,
0.4193505645,
0.479873836,
0.6335424781,
-0.4833386838,
0.6657995582,
0.1039825827,
0.0973076224,
-0.2474010289,
-0.4856927097,
-0.055122178,
0.1543065459,
0.5605984926,
0.408370018,
0.2537383735,
-0.3484832942,
-0.1553934366,
-0.3871990442,
0.763279438,
-0.8116990924,
0.1936899424,
0.8447324634,
-0.3953738511,
-0.2133076936,
0.2716967165,
-0.4258972406,
-0.4934692085,
-0.3339815736,
0.1362705231,
-0.4315018654,
-0.4081309736,
0.1738222688,
0.0469410233,
-0.1390318125,
0.6015149355,
-0.239696756,
0.4887190163,
0.2624104023,
0.5856214762,
-0.0809117109,
-0.035027355,
-0.4962082207,
-0.1317252964,
-0.6042275429,
0.8343747854,
-0.7358878255,
-0.4616448581,
0.3851829171,
-0.1008392498,
-0.1825319231,
-0.7761921883,
0.3915590346,
-1.1708368063,
0.1337839812,
-0.1669442654,
-0.289077282,
-0.040833585,
0.622190237,
-0.5987122655,
0.9163343906,
0.169372499,
-0.28325212,
0.1036010683,
-0.8815867305,
-0.1079333425,
0.4455756843,
-0.1676200479,
-0.0387132578,
-0.1529960036,
-0.0544602759,
0.2508072257,
-0.468331337,
0.0249019191,
-0.3675002456,
-0.5001807213,
0.3968374133,
0.0032431076,
0.339987576,
0.4007020295,
-0.3379701674,
0.2253135294,
-0.6451992989,
0.3050726652,
0.2579416335,
-0.272005409,
-0.1514406353,
0.2292263955,
-0.2814213336,
-0.0464361608,
0.0503289253,
-0.6514419913,
0.3063375354,
0.0086269677,
0.2003712952,
0.4901494384,
0.0524655953,
0.3493645787,
-0.3996589482,
0.912388742,
-0.0480996929,
0.2061151564,
-0.3745194077,
-0.3712528646,
-0.5040120482,
-0.1681186706,
0.1687898189,
0.5527524352,
-1.047021389,
0.6768876314,
-0.1554474384,
-0.4080954194,
-0.731015861,
-0.2027159333,
0.0360470451,
0.2051470876,
0.2848187685,
-0.5257604122,
-0.2890445888,
-0.3896270096,
-0.010104158,
-0.2308363914,
-0.1436526328,
0.7907388806,
0.061264962,
-0.1402499378,
1.2633687258,
-0.5718199611,
-0.6119437814,
-0.3180731535,
0.1562295705,
-0.0731821805,
0.0877533853,
0.3880461454,
-0.9200766087,
-0.4582007229,
0.2010962963,
-0.6747923493,
0.1422037184,
0.0987072513,
-0.0696412027,
0.1129294187,
0.6409290433,
-0.8424821496,
0.9705927968,
0.0193972774,
-0.3591838777,
0.3930978775,
-0.2739907503,
0.3339552879,
-0.5231665969,
0.2669306695,
-0.3829132318,
-0.2034112215,
-0.6249915361,
0.092934452,
-0.3168996274,
-0.2731550336,
-0.5701373219,
0.5351068974,
-0.451050669,
0.171406433,
-0.1840306371,
0.5438724756,
-0.1629756838,
0.4971562028,
0.0713842884,
0.7779332399,
0.3803728819,
-0.8766732812,
0.4937086403,
0.4833603203,
-0.2424784899,
1.008687973,
-0.8011051416,
0.4705796242,
-0.3465487659,
0.2514203787,
-1.1461549997,
-0.0644492358,
0.0467941128,
-0.376231581,
-0.0680365562,
-0.3373276889,
-0.5623884797,
-0.0755941644,
-0.3132453859,
0.6159801483,
0.2481040806,
-0.6791912913,
0.715944767,
0.0630330443,
-0.5023554564,
-0.1380925179,
0.2605040073,
0.0773114339,
0.1095852628,
-0.7553058863,
0.2024246305,
-0.2069191337,
-0.3337638974,
0.1692432314,
0.0182652045,
0.0484646559,
0.232160002,
-0.0059091519,
0.0617457107,
-0.2658579051,
0.1294818372,
-0.3031173348,
0.1184232235,
-0.2066968828,
-0.3009395301,
0.8770837784,
-0.0249868296,
-0.5190253258,
-0.3950096667,
0.5249167681,
0.630405128,
-0.4933334887,
0.8693361878,
0.2155906111,
-0.1510307491,
-0.3865283132,
-0.2129224986,
-0.4014108479,
-0.5050166249,
0.1349139065,
-0.3501838446,
-0.7886909842,
0.3813506365,
-0.2416556627,
-0.0611172579,
0.0175318066,
0.2095426619,
-0.1964858919,
1.6163538694,
0.1628555655,
0.5263965726,
0.4648234546,
-0.3329347372,
0.6317458749,
-0.8586589098,
-0.3272813261,
-0.5716181993,
-0.380733639,
-0.3337797821,
-0.0769484416,
0.4498134851,
-0.082844533,
-0.3574048281,
0.1337370425,
-0.4142320752,
0.2039788514,
0.7720948458,
0.1217544153,
0.1157776415,
-0.2777869105,
-0.0340185873,
0.2446319908,
-0.4926041663,
-0.6667904854,
0.9180875421,
0.1103609279,
1.0293425322,
0.4407081306,
0.3245922625,
0.2675417662,
-0.1013227999,
-0.6988301873,
0.6625488997,
0.5721382499,
-0.619743228,
-0.527972877,
-0.334857285,
-1.4231630564,
0.2825929224,
0.1547926813,
-0.9141471982,
0.4547463953,
0.0412446484,
-0.6808674932,
0.2102332264,
-0.3003206849,
0.6810564995,
-0.2647482157,
-0.4354023933,
0.0009022654,
-0.4715221226,
-0.2255640775,
0.4352122247,
-0.1661084741,
0.0307621751,
0.049834013,
0.326659441,
-0.5291019678,
0.5466216207,
-0.1373852193,
-0.1006481647,
0.6394390464,
0.3727018833,
0.6320406795,
0.0564934723,
-0.0697214976,
-0.3443703055,
-0.0657530427,
-0.2038937062,
-0.6397166252,
0.460057497,
-0.6058982611,
-0.5738303065,
-0.5451571941,
-0.2850681245,
-0.2779381573,
0.4801124334,
-0.1752467602,
0.3282453418,
-0.5373833776,
0.3729169667,
0.7042732239,
-0.1211758107,
-0.0191825517,
0.7470340729,
-0.2398601025,
-0.3656900823,
0.7693264484,
0.1085555181,
0.3026219904,
0.1381351352,
-0.0227918644,
-0.1709537059,
-0.4957376122,
-0.1864399612,
0.14142856,
-0.4812210798,
-0.1707298756,
-0.622649312,
-0.0682356581,
-0.7343046665,
-0.1992813647,
-0.2566170394,
-0.0659042522,
-0.5735144019,
-0.332798928,
0.0338600986,
0.6073542237,
0.3876651227,
0.3341990113,
-0.3156911433,
0.3806084692,
0.5322629213,
0.5067130923,
0.0493241511,
-0.1651217341,
-0.0471114404,
0.3073504865,
-0.8413388133,
-0.6582360864,
0.2539913654,
0.2506485879,
0.649019897,
0.631936729,
0.7857287526,
0.4056428075,
-0.0983380228,
0.9383355975,
-0.3039502203,
-0.3934594691,
0.5118454695,
-0.4147182703,
0.2579752505,
0.7509233952,
0.5525867343,
-0.4769159555,
-0.1900262535,
-0.6796304584,
-0.9824644327,
1.2747229338,
0.4460546076,
-0.2668317258,
-0.0205605384,
-0.014172514,
-0.106595248,
0.5174737573,
0.1818637252,
-0.1927501857,
-0.0220256932,
-0.1591683328,
0.0280951411,
-0.1674232483,
-0.2565515339,
0.0875945985,
0.8060486317,
-0.5088973641,
0.4883927405,
0.542206645,
0.0748944879,
-0.3919560909,
0.3052507937,
0.5140135884,
0.5778693557,
-0.6259391904,
0.1475294232,
-0.2609163523,
-0.22517398,
-0.0657126531,
0.3673005104,
-0.0631188154,
0.0344104059,
-0.0608316436,
0.8099575639,
-0.0194105767,
-1.2012757063,
0.5269224644,
-0.4759042859,
-0.1450361758,
-0.4649989307,
0.1173493415,
-0.0162100457,
0.2015262991,
0.5099554062,
-0.0465614051,
0.2258872092,
-1.0421874523,
-0.0356622152,
0.485222578,
-0.8820155859,
-0.374715656,
0.6208217144,
0.3443376422,
-0.6465943456,
0.6590922475,
-0.4596227407,
-0.630682528,
0.5071664453,
0.1156908497,
0.9024527669,
-0.5625745654,
0.4347784221,
-0.0941527933,
0.1391746849,
0.0811314285,
0.8704531789,
-0.3394524753,
-0.6950110197,
0.3673840165,
0.0493342318,
-0.7754045129,
0.0677402318,
-0.7270682454,
0.1941551566,
-0.2709670365,
-0.3144268692,
-0.0423789993,
-0.0428087413,
-0.9282948375,
0.2698564827,
-0.3716734648,
0.959952116,
0.1136148572,
0.3308427334,
0.8668217063,
-0.3477981687,
-0.4500017762,
-0.1422806829,
-0.080279097,
-0.6615656614,
0.3939658999,
0.0472245142,
-0.3464835882,
0.0267885029,
-0.5772049427,
-0.7105467916,
1.2899143696,
0.2817608416,
0.0726421699,
-0.0883201286,
0.1953683048,
0.7007582188,
-0.5235266089,
0.9711070061,
0.4543372393,
0.3379895091,
0.3470384479,
-1.0201677084,
-0.1841794252,
-0.3858030736,
-0.1228178293,
0.0835560337,
-0.5931418538,
0.8153465986,
-0.1159286648,
-0.3246154785,
0.4183793664,
0.371105969,
0.0894093066,
0.5179284215,
0.600807786,
0.2319087684,
0.5955463052,
0.0067661693,
1.0503691435,
-0.3415927887,
0.2826178074,
1.0035541058,
-0.9000040889,
0.7368500829,
0.071654126,
0.0058959108,
0.4717234969,
0.5344913006,
0.6109421253,
0.6291667223,
0.1290306598,
-0.4820539355,
-0.3174909055,
-0.7246201634,
-0.0998597145,
0.1988798976,
0.243097201,
-0.2907576859,
-0.0177180599,
-0.0742972493,
0.0178636592,
-0.027329823,
0.037369404,
1.1283484697,
-0.2898236811,
-1.090940237,
0.5852931142,
-0.1716316789,
0.1712995023,
-0.6523774862,
-0.1491361409,
-0.169695124,
0.4398782551,
-0.1219375581,
-0.5964356661,
-0.3515329957,
-0.3331508338,
0.3912890851,
-0.3662207425,
0.5908660293,
-0.6583654284,
0.2334492952,
0.4270566106,
0.3143914938,
0.1579761207,
-0.3891552985,
-0.224338904,
0.2201357633,
-0.2163745612,
-0.3832867146,
0.0545264669,
0.3888650835,
0.0635906532,
0.7291619182,
0.5354839563,
0.019549977,
-0.0961444825,
-0.2484605461,
0.8336728215,
-0.3739891648,
-0.734348774,
0.054616157,
0.5327879786,
-0.3486406803,
-0.3612078428,
0.5804244876,
0.5246528983,
0.8958016634,
0.1965274513,
0.9679297209,
0.0074558775,
0.7999492288,
-0.1955964416,
0.3661754727,
-0.6075939536,
0.2738910019,
0.1097863838,
-0.8045235872,
0.1827163547,
0.6349927783,
-0.1184809655,
0.4220015109,
0.7401997447,
0.7718853951,
-0.1902480125,
0.4277417064,
0.4736836851,
0.1506739855,
0.6238026619,
0.058365941,
1.0178393126,
-0.3283290863,
0.5512225628,
0.0109969368,
-0.2498155385,
-0.7745907307,
-0.3174263537,
-0.8876326084,
-0.677246809,
-0.2620411217,
-0.2874614596,
0.2017126828,
1.0033479929,
0.7683824897,
-0.6772525311,
-0.1682820618,
0.0131221889,
0.1057777405,
-0.4506679475,
-0.2373327315,
0.1595639437,
-0.2740466297,
-0.8265810609,
0.8028404117,
0.1880703419,
-0.1225503013,
-0.2498493642,
-0.3013497591,
-0.2360651493,
0.4780928791,
0.4273690879,
0.4154056311,
-0.4182680547,
-0.3705267608,
0.4327492118,
-0.0707972944,
0.0424301252,
1.1066929102,
-0.8356595635,
0.8720867038,
0.3510411978,
0.5416277051,
0.2387005389,
0.2399116457,
0.7052502036,
-0.4639683068,
-0.2910508811,
0.6578840613,
0.0195744429,
0.0163302999,
-0.4105467796,
0.5043559074,
-0.1109321341,
-0.6326488853,
-0.9459463358,
0.1667059362,
-0.988922894,
-0.2599464059,
1.1882013083,
-0.1304462105,
0.0288277268,
-0.669983387,
-0.9027357697,
-0.0428426862,
-0.7780407071,
0.5437819362,
0.3192503452,
-0.3570870161,
-0.0260616932,
-0.2135981768,
0.4350839555,
0.2081916034,
-0.7373741865,
-0.1184073165,
0.1788543761,
-0.2575252652,
0.4985722601,
0.6402260065,
0.2279548347,
0.4313797653,
-0.2171043009,
0.0554879941,
-0.2535707653,
-0.4948180914,
-0.0046544876,
0.5697154403,
0.1434446573,
-0.3428957462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02213v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02213v5 | Large Language Models as Master Key: Unlocking the Secrets of Materials Science with GPT | 2023-04-05T04:01:52 | 2023-04-12T14:06:02 | Tong Xie, Yuwei Wan, Wei Huang, Yufei Zhou, Yixuan Liu, Qingyuan Linghu, Shaozhou Wang, Chunyu Kit, Clara Grazian, Wenjie Zhang, Bram Hoex | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The amount of data has growing significance in exploring cutting-edge
materials and a number of datasets have been generated either by hand or
automated approaches. However, the materials science field struggles to
effectively utilize the abundance of data, especially in applied disciplines
where materials are evaluated based on device performance rather than their
properties. This article presents a new natural language processing (NLP) task
called structured information inference (SII) to address the complexities of
information extraction at the device level in materials science. We
accomplished this task by tuning GPT-3 on an existing perovskite solar cell
FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) dataset with 91.8%
F1-score and extended the dataset with data published since its release. The
produced data is formatted and normalized, enabling its direct utilization as
input in subsequent data analysis. This feature empowers materials scientists
to develop models by selecting high-quality review articles within their
domain. Additionally, we designed experiments to predict the electrical
performance of solar cells and design materials or devices with targeted
parameters using large language models (LLMs). Our results demonstrate
comparable performance to traditional machine learning methods without feature
selection, highlighting the potential of LLMs to acquire scientific knowledge
and design new materials akin to materials scientists. | [
0.1328139454,
-0.7917504311,
0.9011932015,
0.0683425665,
-0.1859984845,
0.1746096611,
-0.1724465489,
-0.1550232619,
-0.4628787935,
0.3576874435,
-0.3328895569,
-0.514522016,
-0.5421923995,
-0.0231171232,
-0.1250056177,
0.9058917165,
-0.2836566865,
0.0756715238,
-0.1342438012,
0.4203909636,
-0.1445188075,
0.0583189428,
-0.2706195116,
-0.6493886113,
0.2238649428,
0.3551107347,
0.5301738381,
0.4716005027,
0.5471553802,
0.2536087632,
-0.1510413587,
0.1486394405,
0.0550473332,
-0.2068317384,
-0.3343449831,
-0.4507441819,
-0.674644053,
0.441740483,
0.6954001784,
0.765566051,
0.036992453,
0.3641449511,
0.3207426369,
0.5224314928,
-0.4284493029,
0.5544120073,
-0.9890555143,
0.255281359,
-0.1737897545,
-0.4416698515,
-0.5515762568,
-0.2388152778,
0.0419512391,
-0.5779946446,
0.347758472,
-0.1217860505,
0.9510256052,
0.1718744338,
-0.2342173457,
0.0227138493,
-0.8210141659,
0.9258431792,
-0.5516088009,
0.3427723348,
0.4267112613,
0.0950917229,
-0.1792559922,
-0.6645718217,
-0.5511420369,
-0.308093667,
-0.0157065243,
0.0532529503,
0.3288014829,
0.290795356,
0.1490004361,
0.3630024493,
-0.6923525929,
-0.1368097514,
-0.4168432951,
-0.0777386501,
0.5042234659,
-0.0805344433,
0.1923443079,
-0.2417845279,
-0.2111794204,
0.0630258322,
-0.8371233344,
-0.281493336,
0.330494523,
0.3545743525,
0.0140562477,
0.8731860518,
0.029715525,
0.4596493244,
-0.2660273612,
-0.1556459665,
0.2015547603,
-0.6525728106,
-0.4675009549,
-0.0603596419,
0.8225790858,
0.0720738173,
0.0971734896,
-0.3789589107,
-0.1896374226,
-0.2681885064,
-0.0519049503,
-0.9594321251,
-0.3955202997,
0.2355657816,
-0.3836766183,
-0.1644281596,
0.2577341497,
-0.5324100852,
-0.5366668105,
-0.4318957329,
0.3969860375,
-0.1056021154,
-0.516395092,
0.3102710843,
-0.2009638846,
0.1962548643,
0.3228579462,
-1.1162207127,
0.4368200898,
0.8626862168,
0.9484205246,
-0.0756766349,
-0.2691718638,
-0.2057039142,
0.2829633057,
-0.2088789791,
0.5847406983,
-0.5971352458,
-0.5105272532,
-0.7379393578,
-0.0120308083,
-0.3858726919,
-0.4136162102,
0.5255746841,
-0.3565195501,
0.1261409521,
-0.0465551168,
-0.201698795,
0.3399972022,
-0.1593872607,
-0.7212001085,
0.783698082,
0.1098507643,
-0.8032906651,
0.4919762611,
-0.7258546352,
-0.3738374412,
0.0418290608,
-0.2280388027,
-0.4889632165,
0.2081051469,
0.0120639279,
0.5698355436,
-0.4631845653,
0.5145109892,
-0.2442836165,
-0.1206350625,
0.2612539232,
-0.5403302908,
0.2009265572,
0.3378432095,
-0.2189575136,
0.0913138017,
-0.6033322811,
-0.1288789213,
-0.0197906196,
-0.4592722654,
-0.0218072813,
0.1735676229,
0.0616671443,
0.122355707,
0.2350154668,
-1.0494679213,
0.2350699306,
-0.3015185297,
0.7903083563,
0.9010761976,
-0.1834659278,
0.6102877855,
0.174031809,
0.2843648195,
-0.2974481583,
0.1396691501,
-0.127417326,
-0.494553417,
-0.2194687128,
-0.0208046902,
0.451693058,
0.5765694976,
-0.6545231342,
0.2498476356,
-0.165825665,
-0.5105269551,
-0.2991890907,
0.3955366611,
0.269487232,
0.5941149592,
0.1762245595,
0.0488355905,
-0.0951322988,
-0.8377634287,
-0.3693887293,
-0.0661562383,
-0.2474268526,
0.4885280132,
0.5109305382,
0.1038658991,
1.1472092867,
-0.7357633114,
-0.2054596692,
-0.325471729,
0.3465071917,
0.6072615385,
0.5827816725,
-0.2375206053,
-1.2621788979,
-0.3246017098,
0.5707513094,
-0.7370387912,
0.0837374032,
-0.2211361676,
0.0190570392,
-0.0231842883,
0.6380055547,
-0.7947536111,
0.182637319,
0.3962841034,
-0.5391519666,
0.5907315016,
-0.4174200296,
0.125186041,
-0.9748085141,
0.42648682,
0.4553757906,
0.0502872914,
-0.4532337189,
-0.1939770877,
0.2941117883,
-0.3718550503,
-0.3744367361,
0.7493603826,
-0.6686093807,
-0.1573878974,
-0.3191021383,
-0.1104463339,
0.1593685597,
0.2349597365,
0.0336636752,
0.9928178191,
0.2952134609,
-0.5702161789,
0.1057581604,
-0.0056358678,
-0.6241012216,
0.2101514339,
-0.8986226916,
-0.0501245484,
0.0062440615,
0.0083764978,
-0.6766298413,
-0.3676813543,
-0.1816367209,
-0.3703005016,
0.6002499461,
-0.2278474122,
-0.9782963395,
-0.3911486268,
-0.1421750486,
0.1487327367,
0.0991890877,
-0.3123698831,
0.749889195,
0.5427129269,
-0.5888822675,
-0.4661786854,
-0.4144829512,
-0.0399284028,
-0.0601439066,
-0.7505697012,
0.7074344158,
-0.4004712105,
-0.0758466125,
-0.1613808274,
-0.4602549374,
-0.1301582009,
0.5086907148,
0.2355598956,
0.3791481555,
-0.2597049177,
0.3703981936,
0.1915066093,
-0.3588742614,
-0.03054736,
-0.2194987983,
0.5694101453,
-0.2590095401,
-0.1977292746,
-0.5824955702,
-0.0450219549,
0.5992963314,
-0.3483767211,
0.3564954102,
0.3971262574,
-0.4147651792,
-0.2625905573,
-0.3354768753,
-0.1716213971,
-0.5599399209,
0.5700892806,
-0.7323171496,
-0.6166944504,
0.388106972,
-0.1416244358,
0.085683316,
0.3605211675,
0.2408994436,
0.2300474495,
1.1608461142,
0.8774966002,
0.0572849736,
0.636500001,
-0.0716794729,
0.3612091243,
-0.8771934509,
-0.2112033963,
-0.4282892644,
-0.086611174,
-0.3499159813,
-0.2394342124,
0.4539422095,
-0.0271353647,
-0.2153931409,
0.3087852597,
-0.6670534015,
0.9945516586,
0.2173888683,
0.1831539273,
0.4309233725,
0.0204179361,
0.0947550684,
0.181174159,
-0.3193781078,
-0.6410852671,
1.0996944904,
0.48456797,
0.9042223692,
-0.2969444394,
0.124868311,
-0.0598417222,
0.1220502853,
-0.558566153,
0.5066366196,
-0.0657474995,
-0.4381979704,
-0.2639759481,
-0.6472104788,
-0.8974351287,
0.2698781788,
0.1067309752,
-0.689278543,
0.0786452442,
-0.0839224681,
-0.375766784,
0.4637338817,
-0.9941133857,
1.0586050749,
-0.2719633281,
-0.5405378938,
-0.0621166974,
-0.3495656848,
0.2191999406,
-0.2148271352,
0.2620259821,
-0.3855558634,
-0.005121951,
0.6568850279,
-0.1760377139,
0.5667165518,
-0.1976902783,
-0.2319599688,
0.1370515525,
0.0293415878,
0.3495115936,
0.3051653504,
-0.4764273465,
-0.2623645067,
-0.1227287054,
-0.3142682016,
-0.3443071544,
0.9291168451,
-0.4962005615,
-0.5511678457,
-0.127401948,
-0.4930643439,
-0.1619955301,
0.1769307554,
0.2357228398,
0.1387678981,
-0.1836936623,
0.0945775136,
0.8088694215,
-0.1787020266,
0.5185378194,
0.2922686934,
0.3373877406,
-0.0195435509,
1.2764949799,
0.227625221,
0.2393941581,
0.3514808416,
0.3582169116,
-0.1445089132,
-0.8529990315,
-0.5535597801,
0.3298566043,
-0.3757750392,
-0.1583264023,
-0.8771384358,
-0.2561999559,
-0.3478206694,
-0.1343075931,
-0.4569202065,
-0.4793537557,
-0.3300032914,
-0.5297854543,
0.1871093959,
0.7083756328,
0.2232848108,
0.2705218792,
-0.6746026278,
0.4754572213,
0.2479370385,
0.7883576751,
-0.2704728842,
-0.197179392,
-0.2645300031,
-0.2529687285,
-0.3863355219,
-0.625465095,
0.336081475,
0.1869389117,
0.6715340018,
-0.0464755856,
-0.304500401,
0.3121943176,
-0.4405085742,
0.6041863561,
0.0244465284,
-0.8726357818,
0.9035961032,
-0.5357183218,
0.3081930876,
0.4481666684,
0.1493327022,
-0.1032367125,
-0.0144560561,
-0.6824760437,
-1.08357656,
0.8534536362,
0.0806500986,
-0.0327554792,
0.3209021986,
0.2158557922,
0.3478361964,
0.423915714,
-1.0019747019,
0.111787416,
-0.050075341,
-0.2945007384,
-0.0171935428,
-0.011976839,
0.0685413331,
-0.1630970836,
0.7228574753,
-0.395758152,
0.0992529318,
0.2458048463,
-0.2903707922,
-0.0307929516,
0.4202427864,
0.3085357845,
0.761035502,
-0.4715690613,
-0.0274895802,
-0.1245891154,
-0.7996067405,
-0.1658717245,
0.3274781108,
-0.1497225314,
-0.118297793,
-0.113064602,
0.579636097,
-0.0645995885,
-0.5288183093,
0.4634205997,
-0.1072790399,
-0.2319446057,
-0.1126750708,
0.0702753589,
-0.2539704442,
0.1327032298,
0.6614726186,
0.1403355151,
0.2742160261,
-0.5497710109,
0.3293433189,
0.5237837434,
-0.3305502236,
-0.4990051389,
0.6859388947,
0.2765851021,
0.1095155254,
0.2419534177,
-0.113481842,
-0.1360496283,
0.8543881774,
0.4116185009,
0.8392590284,
-0.1418891698,
0.4384129643,
0.3970851898,
0.4590175152,
-0.2191450149,
0.2332504839,
-0.1776962429,
-0.4201639593,
-0.6812524199,
-0.7974386811,
-0.5591120124,
0.2061521858,
-0.2372892052,
0.1651593745,
-0.69444561,
0.0862106308,
0.241079554,
0.3421283066,
-0.4928194284,
0.1092612892,
0.2294745296,
0.882058382,
-0.9985763431,
0.8109873533,
0.2759018838,
-0.1090013087,
-0.5531690121,
-0.3312520683,
-0.0736004859,
-0.2991763651,
0.6845307946,
0.2256571203,
-0.1243149042,
-0.108569786,
-0.707883358,
-1.0048071146,
1.2901012897,
0.4152956903,
-0.1890081018,
-0.0134585928,
0.0077425581,
0.1219245642,
-0.2626552582,
0.4960297644,
0.9030045271,
0.7127910256,
-0.0134982858,
-1.120904088,
0.0309206694,
-0.5553842187,
-0.3758996725,
0.3873808086,
-0.4116942286,
0.9142891765,
-0.2438735366,
-0.3949447572,
0.2302226424,
0.6539843678,
0.3370891511,
0.4708013237,
0.1205855086,
0.0513782948,
1.0360589027,
-0.1838534772,
1.0986120701,
-0.0617057309,
0.2507856786,
0.8067896962,
-0.5268769264,
0.6064928174,
0.4465218186,
-0.0823661312,
0.2347218096,
0.590827167,
-0.221003741,
0.4267218113,
0.1736473292,
-0.3126070201,
-0.1564956456,
-0.0434627272,
-0.2019113302,
0.1278800964,
0.7337096334,
-0.4093950987,
-0.1150817573,
0.0216970276,
0.0355358198,
-0.0633930564,
-0.4294987023,
0.5820335746,
0.0992660001,
-0.4078489542,
-0.0030629805,
0.2149815708,
0.7189055085,
-0.6111218333,
-0.0711478069,
0.0529080145,
0.2031387836,
-0.442873776,
-0.9601179957,
0.0785824582,
-0.0076778992,
-0.420298934,
-0.3737765253,
0.6870737076,
-0.0408818461,
-0.5758244395,
-0.0387205109,
0.3137873411,
0.0134872114,
-0.2821895182,
-0.6588298082,
-0.2785235345,
0.0249625444,
-0.453317076,
0.3294890225,
0.4642992318,
-0.1026043668,
0.626566112,
0.8070473671,
0.2478309125,
-0.1399840564,
-0.0884392858,
0.9267613292,
-0.8056128621,
-0.2109689713,
-0.8888427615,
0.4636610746,
-0.2878952026,
-0.3605476916,
0.5293365717,
0.8503425717,
0.6820254326,
-0.033533711,
0.8716019988,
0.2568491697,
0.4871256649,
-0.7776967287,
0.7642028928,
-0.1661767513,
0.4952357113,
-0.408913523,
-0.8539358974,
-0.5182539225,
0.5400158167,
-0.5363683701,
0.0105924141,
0.7861489058,
0.8216956258,
-0.3228992522,
0.1684294939,
0.0035538264,
0.3861771822,
0.6180493832,
0.2684992254,
0.4732344449,
-0.3927191496,
0.5480381846,
-0.0193619765,
-0.2715624571,
0.1450130194,
-0.8990444541,
-0.5060039759,
-0.4530643225,
-0.3259107769,
-0.0955315754,
-0.2308927476,
0.5902531147,
0.7561540604,
-0.4623977542,
-0.2711037695,
-0.4043277204,
0.444589287,
0.1199785471,
-0.2123350948,
0.6566352844,
-0.1928135157,
-0.7681522965,
0.6923225522,
0.3456562161,
0.0771491453,
0.1363745332,
0.1117876023,
0.0746022612,
0.0562653728,
0.6673467755,
0.2893128395,
-0.2764384747,
0.089538388,
0.0893776566,
-0.1444845945,
0.0773346797,
0.7744040489,
-0.8134971857,
0.1296777278,
0.6205946207,
0.4749995172,
0.5989972353,
-0.1217925996,
0.7098571658,
-0.7339450121,
-0.0627120957,
0.2006259263,
0.5949012637,
0.4210976958,
-0.4858158529,
0.5967492461,
0.0619592853,
-0.7555757761,
-0.8695427179,
0.2498751432,
-1.0699301958,
-0.6683645844,
1.2634906769,
0.2977455258,
-0.7045678496,
-0.088768594,
-0.3087204099,
0.0344631858,
-0.4023300409,
0.4489708543,
0.4692316353,
0.0193653144,
-0.1085800678,
-0.883277595,
0.4908211827,
0.3755983412,
-0.8249614239,
0.38897264,
0.0999296457,
0.247743547,
0.1776887476,
0.5234513879,
-0.4384281933,
0.2931610346,
-0.1936520934,
0.0814785585,
-0.2016310543,
-0.5914797187,
-0.1152732,
0.3727652431,
0.1078434363,
0.139522925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02210v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02210v2 | Document-Level Machine Translation with Large Language Models | 2023-04-05T03:49:06 | 2023-10-24T14:00:21 | Longyue Wang, Chenyang Lyu, Tianbo Ji, Zhirui Zhang, Dian Yu, Shuming Shi, Zhaopeng Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT can produce coherent, cohesive,
relevant, and fluent answers for various natural language processing (NLP)
tasks. Taking document-level machine translation (MT) as a testbed, this paper
provides an in-depth evaluation of LLMs' ability on discourse modeling. The
study focuses on three aspects: 1) Effects of Context-Aware Prompts, where we
investigate the impact of different prompts on document-level translation
quality and discourse phenomena; 2) Comparison of Translation Models, where we
compare the translation performance of ChatGPT with commercial MT systems and
advanced document-level MT methods; 3) Analysis of Discourse Modelling
Abilities, where we further probe discourse knowledge encoded in LLMs and shed
light on impacts of training techniques on discourse modeling. By evaluating on
a number of benchmarks, we surprisingly find that LLMs have demonstrated
superior performance and show potential to become a new paradigm for
document-level translation: 1) leveraging their powerful long-text modeling
capabilities, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 outperform commercial MT systems in terms of
human evaluation; 2) GPT-4 demonstrates a stronger ability for probing
linguistic knowledge than GPT-3.5. This work highlights the challenges and
opportunities of LLMs for MT, which we hope can inspire the future design and
evaluation of LLMs.We release our data and annotations at
https://github.com/longyuewangdcu/Document-MT-LLM. | [
-0.2049957067,
-0.9047743082,
0.8576469421,
0.1433610469,
-0.4321914911,
0.2518832088,
-0.1341891736,
-0.4097445905,
-0.4117948115,
0.6168072224,
-0.27832371,
-0.6461618543,
-0.8464283943,
0.2962406278,
-0.7760782242,
0.8682081699,
-0.3160701692,
0.2477620542,
-0.329038173,
0.2370836884,
-0.5567496419,
-0.658065021,
-0.7224837542,
-0.3496717811,
0.4311926365,
0.0170405004,
0.5595561266,
0.4242687821,
0.5151908398,
0.3272072077,
-0.3266933262,
0.1574037373,
-0.4522000849,
0.2489286959,
0.0763829127,
-0.4123838544,
-0.6292222142,
0.042155087,
0.8419979215,
0.64366436,
0.2099173516,
-0.020265257,
0.4373693764,
0.3727412224,
-0.0055653644,
0.2497123927,
-0.5385746956,
0.0151224192,
-0.1511928886,
-0.3527713418,
-0.6817349195,
-0.3715538383,
0.0990211591,
-0.5290002823,
-0.0411197171,
0.3209283352,
0.785413444,
0.2391418666,
-0.7512888908,
-0.4081802964,
-0.679047823,
0.5997544527,
-0.8896618485,
0.2957142889,
0.0950849056,
0.3437049687,
-0.4157693982,
-0.7672795653,
-0.3677887321,
-0.30349648,
-0.1198705435,
0.282283783,
-0.0991930142,
0.111849241,
0.3365235627,
0.4949575961,
-0.652091682,
0.4100368321,
-0.1755115092,
-0.0150479442,
0.196392253,
0.3462030888,
0.2075914741,
-0.415805161,
-0.4556226134,
0.1101100668,
-0.6067655087,
-0.0883537233,
0.1656810492,
0.2840356827,
-0.0818052292,
0.656124711,
-0.0118124606,
0.6234624982,
-0.1592805088,
-0.3004519939,
0.1149074659,
-0.2897475064,
-0.2748745084,
-0.3196401298,
0.9179656506,
0.2852309048,
-0.0029782194,
-0.0081847282,
-0.3866740465,
-0.3536538482,
0.02776937,
-0.8141366839,
0.43980214,
0.1256776005,
-0.4654918909,
-0.234892115,
-0.3390776813,
-0.4427871406,
-0.5690886974,
-0.4373301268,
0.1542563587,
-0.6156417131,
-0.0093544014,
0.2147762477,
0.0827543363,
0.5223283172,
0.7199310064,
-0.6059426665,
0.2927413285,
0.9701039195,
0.9506907463,
-0.5226076841,
-0.1993176788,
-0.3552857339,
0.031548392,
-0.4673460126,
0.7879926562,
-0.3217934072,
-0.5057720542,
0.2158452719,
-0.0762141794,
-0.2103508562,
-0.4886361361,
0.9166656733,
-0.5186495185,
0.410598129,
-0.2402761877,
-0.7301823497,
-0.1638929546,
0.5668875575,
-0.4551660419,
1.0175359249,
0.126698181,
-0.7064129114,
0.0540353693,
-0.649430871,
-0.4982278943,
0.1888842732,
0.098811999,
-0.1893144548,
0.1549474001,
0.2849133015,
0.5758686662,
-0.6754027605,
0.4273429811,
-0.041584149,
-0.3244762719,
0.5195009112,
-0.5990143418,
0.5310485363,
0.2449264824,
-0.1189419031,
0.2953340411,
-0.4385507405,
-0.3049700856,
0.1043098718,
-0.3605872393,
-0.0762784407,
-0.1239424869,
-0.0912413597,
0.4093209803,
0.3581023216,
-0.327455461,
0.2701247036,
-0.4115873277,
0.5954598188,
0.5904918909,
-0.0362379551,
0.4603068233,
-0.2002394646,
0.699731946,
-0.0787847564,
0.0112925386,
-0.445790261,
-0.6652715802,
-0.6843861938,
-0.1299791634,
0.4720519483,
0.6135172844,
-0.7482511401,
0.2233507782,
-0.4629641175,
-0.2293020487,
-0.4872207046,
-0.126487568,
0.2990162969,
0.6733467579,
0.2333945334,
-0.2428511828,
-0.191794768,
-0.7893486023,
-0.1515868157,
-0.0377870463,
-0.322143048,
0.2449566573,
0.5354908109,
-0.2051564455,
0.6677969694,
-0.2391123176,
-0.1547176093,
-0.30195871,
0.368650794,
0.2576388419,
0.1851144731,
0.1634004265,
-0.4966778755,
-0.4767293036,
0.1860930771,
-0.7543045282,
-0.2781537771,
-0.1738647074,
0.0354318358,
0.3026904762,
0.5120379329,
-0.8410313725,
0.1611173004,
0.5198665261,
0.041408658,
0.5800080895,
-0.3629339933,
0.2774110436,
-1.3015601635,
0.1658850014,
-0.0651089922,
-0.42909953,
-0.5975034833,
0.1448119134,
0.1587553769,
-0.4698182046,
-0.6316581964,
0.6189621687,
-0.4629118741,
-0.516445756,
-0.3616572618,
0.5176971555,
0.124628,
0.2787140012,
-0.1548519582,
0.9374232888,
0.2279587686,
-0.2702941895,
0.2424714714,
0.2393631339,
-0.4528706074,
0.667170167,
-0.6308157444,
0.2353960425,
0.0903894752,
0.5826744437,
-1.072147727,
-0.3093192279,
0.3147628903,
-0.4277499318,
0.4599929154,
-0.1345078051,
-0.8738009334,
-0.4008351564,
-0.0507121012,
0.0669537336,
0.4721356928,
-0.2762262225,
0.5183031559,
0.1923418939,
-0.5913502574,
-0.2812974453,
-0.4509133697,
0.5842162371,
-0.2115355879,
-0.7106226683,
0.3901679814,
0.0208423194,
-0.0137042124,
-0.3785534501,
0.0535544455,
0.0165696349,
0.1836950928,
0.1757678688,
0.3005132079,
-0.1263229847,
0.0789958984,
0.2377967983,
-0.2012721151,
0.1964927763,
-0.4792385995,
0.6341767311,
-0.2905182838,
-0.4747361839,
-0.3661638498,
0.3682436645,
0.5940468311,
-0.3207665682,
0.5969936252,
0.5822502375,
-0.3213421702,
0.1274977922,
-0.4796369374,
0.1035053506,
-0.4090855718,
0.3136050701,
-0.5195827484,
-1.0975929499,
0.5504646301,
-0.4623411298,
0.1229754239,
0.5369486809,
0.5755269527,
-0.1684345454,
1.0429389477,
0.2581062019,
-0.0619251281,
0.3151878715,
-0.1027137339,
0.2181010097,
-0.9753833413,
-0.0839800015,
-0.6296904683,
-0.1146580502,
-0.5282287002,
-0.665821135,
0.3509294391,
-0.0761527792,
-0.0442386083,
0.1826139987,
-0.2387147099,
0.2430046201,
0.2311878055,
-0.2195319831,
0.4807582796,
-0.1653863043,
-0.187790677,
-0.0569950007,
-0.4991011024,
-0.9381052256,
0.7929685712,
0.6110610962,
0.5892219543,
-0.1942052394,
0.3869565427,
0.1847171336,
0.3849661648,
-0.7969344258,
0.716262579,
-0.1918609887,
-0.4040403664,
-0.2785073221,
-0.4697760642,
-0.9807471633,
0.4417387247,
-0.0610372461,
-0.3852272332,
-0.3079592586,
-0.1914631724,
-0.0816960558,
0.1239890903,
-0.5214223266,
0.7998136878,
-0.4669995904,
-0.205761373,
-0.0726732388,
-0.5534967184,
0.3073475361,
-0.2830511928,
0.3306575716,
-0.132273525,
-0.2580992877,
0.3903476596,
-0.0552313142,
0.8897998929,
0.1265674233,
-0.6059182286,
0.1821501106,
0.0874627829,
0.591149509,
-0.1342414767,
-0.2621740699,
0.1978040785,
-0.1796281189,
-0.1648893505,
-0.4939652681,
0.6870713234,
-0.6919080615,
-0.757768929,
-0.3029191196,
-0.7527831793,
-0.0838627666,
0.482250005,
0.2253523618,
0.2098368406,
-0.4589426219,
0.2206186801,
0.7026991844,
-0.4904357195,
0.1803587228,
0.4904349744,
-0.518538177,
-0.2363249063,
0.6449273825,
0.1740940511,
0.2880646884,
0.5356267095,
0.1256747544,
-0.3721822798,
-0.7869489789,
-0.7003967762,
0.12271294,
-0.7944708467,
-0.150899902,
-0.6886920929,
-0.3570410609,
-0.4601525366,
-0.2126148343,
-0.1570811719,
-0.3688908815,
-0.393402487,
-0.067958191,
-0.0939389542,
0.7344882488,
0.458563894,
0.4639542997,
-0.6868507266,
0.1493584514,
0.1320374012,
0.1408650875,
-0.265458107,
-0.8270614147,
-0.1138123348,
-0.0134038469,
-0.5296608806,
-0.8428869843,
0.4312067628,
-0.2441977561,
0.405105263,
0.0834315121,
-0.2207245231,
0.3368656635,
-0.6618343592,
0.9359302521,
0.0173261128,
-0.9391680956,
0.3042697906,
-0.9629483819,
0.5217313766,
0.2026679963,
0.3386660218,
-0.7092022896,
-0.5016673207,
-0.2969995737,
-0.7731305957,
0.5064697266,
0.1584329754,
0.1957269609,
0.0370412432,
0.420207262,
0.1907915175,
0.2043804973,
-0.6915029287,
0.1661550552,
0.0222536977,
0.0209938847,
-0.0542019457,
-0.3109174967,
0.0700780302,
0.1138380989,
0.5784927607,
-0.0921102613,
0.230949074,
-0.1037360355,
-0.2281611711,
0.0495916083,
0.6634539366,
0.7635342479,
0.5176244378,
-0.0898901075,
0.0236497,
0.5099076033,
0.0001358211,
0.1411100626,
0.253421694,
-0.2935150862,
0.0803822353,
0.3083529472,
0.8161157966,
0.4203770757,
-0.2178450525,
0.4800490737,
-0.0811353177,
-0.3297682106,
-0.0998404324,
-0.1495499313,
0.395958066,
0.0210422687,
0.2719130516,
-0.2096350193,
0.1099051163,
-0.3631973565,
-0.242446661,
0.3473379314,
-0.2327269614,
-0.1560418308,
0.6797614098,
0.346491009,
-0.3986677527,
0.4486415982,
-0.0823370442,
-0.4586403668,
0.3172722161,
0.6936102509,
0.8170104623,
-0.3001254499,
0.1316874474,
0.1755030751,
0.3969808221,
-0.1685893685,
-0.1467676312,
0.1937275231,
-0.1934018433,
-0.7101262808,
-0.4551586211,
-0.6655011177,
0.2610022426,
-0.3529551029,
0.3075936139,
-0.1266789436,
-0.2943169475,
-0.2318537384,
0.0257470515,
-0.556750834,
-0.0450673066,
0.1560293734,
0.8845192194,
-0.56134969,
0.9123424888,
0.4582487345,
-0.1594480127,
-0.3878771961,
-0.0259622559,
-0.083526656,
-0.5755081177,
0.4797207415,
0.2634952366,
-0.0807428285,
0.0259581581,
-0.3818242252,
-0.7504910827,
1.1174012423,
0.5695617199,
-0.5458592772,
-0.1587634087,
0.5438200831,
0.6931899786,
-0.4137910903,
0.3091469407,
0.4721485972,
0.5066185594,
0.1163347289,
-1.0102732182,
0.0388385579,
0.0183932018,
0.2387391031,
0.1025346667,
-0.3520458937,
0.6890391111,
0.1566009521,
-0.3059599698,
0.2433119267,
0.7210951447,
0.1159416437,
0.2421330065,
0.2713531852,
0.3063119054,
0.7251546383,
-0.1055507213,
1.2199310064,
-0.2286906987,
0.0608959273,
1.1356384754,
-0.4933637083,
0.8233846426,
0.3097526431,
0.0043763286,
0.3172191679,
0.7115333676,
0.217912063,
0.0513811149,
0.3465636671,
-0.193072021,
-0.0935662836,
-0.2404579222,
-0.5116350055,
0.1768419296,
0.4521742165,
-0.4963335991,
-0.2172271013,
0.0388590097,
0.101467073,
-0.0182264429,
-0.1723215878,
0.76844275,
0.3857022822,
-0.7627415061,
0.5944138765,
0.3645350039,
0.4206158817,
-0.4796265066,
0.121080026,
-0.3591597378,
-0.0685479119,
0.1277408451,
-0.9005981088,
0.1297283769,
0.2701408863,
0.0612742417,
-0.6824280024,
0.984187007,
-0.1992735565,
-0.4161131382,
0.2581057847,
0.6682872772,
0.3285810649,
-0.072458297,
-0.6407456398,
0.1167378128,
-0.1886072755,
-0.3573714793,
0.5568599105,
0.7293414474,
-0.1333218962,
0.6281820536,
0.6071789265,
-0.140171349,
-0.0975417122,
0.1613799483,
0.8275914788,
-0.4710466266,
-0.2416542023,
-0.7692577839,
0.4216310382,
-0.0667793676,
-0.1874557137,
0.8244707584,
0.6351996064,
0.5957902074,
0.0115585327,
0.7730597854,
0.3914216459,
0.4306444526,
-0.4655873179,
0.5842033029,
-0.2420983166,
0.2391134948,
-0.4159421325,
-0.923632443,
-0.3177368343,
0.2723276913,
-0.6647409797,
-0.1329435706,
0.7372242808,
0.5337495208,
0.036961291,
0.003708435,
0.5717210174,
0.2476753294,
0.4957798421,
0.3900368512,
1.0249745846,
-0.3761651516,
0.7598242164,
0.3381176293,
-0.1875891834,
-0.2567189336,
-1.077662468,
-0.8732851744,
-0.5650211573,
-0.0437226072,
-0.1819943935,
-0.014365796,
0.4980439544,
0.4279426634,
-0.3525188863,
-0.2904231846,
0.0985149369,
0.13422741,
0.0387467481,
-0.1140962243,
0.296459645,
-0.4627034962,
-0.7965380549,
0.551471293,
0.401519686,
0.2358944565,
-0.3298874497,
-0.1685509235,
-0.0074339528,
0.1211945489,
0.9191347361,
-0.1976777613,
-0.8295312524,
-0.0737233013,
0.2213912159,
-0.4801163375,
0.1142085418,
0.7653382421,
-0.4163089395,
0.2325787544,
0.5275651217,
0.7328249216,
0.668100059,
-0.0175954849,
0.7046576738,
-0.540609479,
-0.0927451327,
0.1148895845,
0.4754474759,
0.5430356264,
-0.1929335147,
0.4838326871,
-0.0479054041,
-0.6906869411,
-0.7036216855,
0.1501904577,
-0.8400301337,
-0.1951091737,
1.2683106661,
-0.3544530869,
-0.1611245871,
-0.0354875475,
-0.5625542998,
0.4141177237,
-0.2788715065,
0.5897411704,
0.9065391421,
0.155417636,
-0.2754849195,
-0.9901442528,
0.1821886003,
0.3746056855,
-1.0045179129,
0.1933306605,
0.5980594754,
0.0582839325,
-0.0728358105,
0.6577790976,
-0.244806245,
-0.0253792703,
-0.3527359068,
-0.1027125567,
-0.0910503641,
-0.052682545,
-0.4607585073,
0.1782851368,
0.3232910931,
0.1687332541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02182v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02182v2 | How to Design Translation Prompts for ChatGPT: An Empirical Study | 2023-04-05T01:17:59 | 2023-04-21T09:35:44 | Yuan Gao, Ruili Wang, Feng Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recently released ChatGPT has demonstrated surprising abilities in
natural language understanding and natural language generation. Machine
translation relies heavily on the abilities of language understanding and
generation. Thus, in this paper, we explore how to assist machine translation
with ChatGPT. We adopt several translation prompts on a wide range of
translations. Our experimental results show that ChatGPT with designed
translation prompts can achieve comparable or better performance over
commercial translation systems for high-resource language translations. We
further evaluate the translation quality using multiple references, and ChatGPT
achieves superior performance compared to commercial systems. We also conduct
experiments on domain-specific translations, the final results show that
ChatGPT is able to comprehend the provided domain keyword and adjust
accordingly to output proper translations. At last, we perform few-shot prompts
that show consistent improvement across different base prompts. Our work
provides empirical evidence that ChatGPT still has great potential in
translations. | [
-0.5756952763,
-0.7102001309,
0.6465616226,
0.5509313941,
-0.5035828352,
0.1750091314,
-0.4204489887,
-0.1929859221,
-0.0817159787,
0.3092675209,
-0.6373138428,
-0.3834476769,
-0.6160076261,
0.442653358,
-0.0134416772,
1.1392581463,
-0.1618937999,
0.2025686502,
0.0810289606,
-0.0124842441,
-1.2000020742,
-0.4850726426,
-0.8996917009,
-0.1604585201,
0.4374852777,
0.5850887895,
0.8187224269,
0.2894850075,
0.6606110334,
0.1778889447,
-0.2079422772,
0.4045376182,
-0.4151237607,
0.3042776585,
-0.0312521756,
-0.3320444822,
-0.3606337607,
-0.1817537397,
0.5088386536,
0.4546622336,
0.1761742085,
-0.0961547196,
0.4576743543,
0.5956318974,
-0.0601643063,
0.3474105299,
-0.374591291,
0.1877049059,
-0.171745941,
-0.4154345095,
-0.6504844427,
-0.4642445743,
0.0401787721,
-0.6346523762,
0.3889296949,
0.4545130134,
0.7019192576,
0.2970474362,
-0.492205143,
-0.4404617846,
-0.6415798664,
0.6759983301,
-0.5689510107,
0.3293065727,
0.1700443178,
0.7424479723,
-0.4659098685,
-0.5673143864,
-0.3413870633,
-0.4560694695,
-0.1944749802,
0.3277741969,
-0.1881701946,
0.0665562004,
0.3150105476,
0.3826863766,
-0.9660121202,
-0.0717102513,
-0.0995518342,
-0.2286626399,
0.2090587169,
0.2060895264,
0.6092689633,
-0.3097941875,
-0.3853361905,
-0.3157153428,
-0.7545810938,
0.095511511,
0.0898992345,
0.5179998279,
0.025197655,
0.639249146,
-0.2798492908,
0.6857759356,
-0.096915096,
0.1602536589,
0.0379387289,
-0.5012701154,
0.0602651201,
-0.0044196704,
0.8953772783,
0.5045887232,
0.4670404196,
-0.2016959786,
-0.195037201,
-0.2531555593,
0.2451726943,
-0.8336277604,
-0.1294071972,
0.0690589026,
-0.4066695273,
-0.1039864719,
-0.259685874,
-0.7003773451,
-0.3907164633,
-0.2405889928,
0.247115925,
-0.7363976836,
0.0096924361,
0.0820056945,
-0.3884418011,
0.3852813542,
0.5771092176,
-0.9137004614,
0.0439561568,
0.6003804207,
0.9915351272,
-0.3838888705,
-0.1263953,
-0.6462767124,
-0.2265632302,
-0.3056100309,
0.9013642669,
-0.4401693046,
-0.6105507612,
0.0559260547,
-0.2345245183,
-0.178603828,
-0.4474520087,
0.8651999831,
-0.5817759037,
0.4612800777,
-0.4569980502,
-0.4732945263,
-0.1897259951,
0.3091590703,
-0.2842007279,
0.6472839713,
-0.1153164208,
-0.6111260056,
0.2299568951,
-1.0447474718,
-0.5621028543,
0.3652616739,
0.0139128575,
-0.089097321,
0.191834718,
0.5027928352,
0.173423022,
-0.2246155292,
0.0267723948,
0.2264846414,
-0.164192766,
0.5868962407,
-0.6310566664,
0.5774092674,
0.6854555607,
-0.2020947933,
0.0324820019,
-0.1867911816,
0.1032776088,
0.1787730604,
-0.2598672807,
0.1080564782,
-0.2553935051,
0.1718174815,
0.0798481703,
0.1507174224,
-0.2895220518,
0.3496756852,
-0.1389373541,
0.3618997335,
0.4488054812,
0.2042915821,
0.439578414,
-0.0577796735,
0.9640641809,
-0.216535449,
-0.0437029377,
-0.381131351,
-0.9920525551,
-0.5039710402,
-0.0986694172,
0.4495217204,
0.755063951,
-0.8505201936,
0.2190720588,
-0.1597907096,
-0.1897958666,
-0.4149155617,
0.0263087004,
0.3541392088,
0.4984312654,
0.4273985028,
-0.3899547458,
-0.1653161645,
-0.7758802772,
-0.4961179197,
-0.1329139173,
-0.3162809908,
0.4014070928,
0.1594929397,
0.0157215074,
0.9467599392,
-0.5651521683,
-0.0318089426,
-0.448538065,
0.2930427492,
0.4554736614,
0.3906467557,
0.5239505768,
-0.7631114721,
-0.754586935,
0.2191600651,
-0.6082823277,
-0.4518167377,
-0.2529960573,
-0.4699851871,
-0.3077420294,
0.162065506,
-0.7928202748,
0.1245700642,
0.3798567951,
-0.2449462563,
0.6021981239,
-0.266073674,
0.4152813852,
-1.2084600925,
0.0497813225,
-0.2744650841,
-0.4220641553,
-0.6858133674,
0.0562446639,
0.0750144348,
-0.4710261822,
-0.5011689067,
0.4798904061,
-0.308321774,
0.1561731398,
-0.5108845234,
0.4619074166,
0.101219289,
0.3783622384,
0.0491430014,
1.1353384256,
0.3499393165,
-0.6264733076,
0.4196730256,
0.5929780006,
-0.200370416,
0.6362389326,
-0.8777507544,
0.2235245556,
-0.0814154372,
0.3711705804,
-1.2341519594,
-0.1958995014,
0.7400842309,
-0.6973162889,
0.1848000586,
-0.3436009884,
-0.4988595843,
-0.2284215242,
0.1834253967,
0.1207853407,
0.8263090253,
-0.5126268268,
0.0530285537,
-0.021991631,
-0.5420677066,
-0.1120269075,
-0.3903110623,
0.4484479427,
-0.3141002357,
-0.7910937667,
0.1818988323,
-0.303676635,
-0.0159549862,
-0.27836743,
0.1528711915,
-0.0272881351,
0.0455938168,
0.045701433,
0.0727717578,
-0.3939986229,
0.1891017556,
0.0305277649,
-0.4273308516,
-0.0829092264,
-0.5098139644,
0.640699029,
-0.2329949141,
-0.3948926628,
-0.3207038343,
0.5783377886,
0.3953409493,
-0.3746449947,
0.5617658496,
0.7480486631,
0.0222187657,
-0.0070112054,
-0.2843242288,
-0.199240014,
-0.4524362087,
0.0975998044,
-0.5366283059,
-0.6729650497,
0.4514000118,
-0.2256839424,
0.2615894377,
0.3547123969,
0.6248419285,
-0.1110937148,
1.2417656183,
0.4057220817,
0.1370822936,
0.769390285,
0.0949727818,
0.367965132,
-0.7079749107,
0.1990970522,
-0.6149398088,
-0.2576406896,
-0.7198994756,
-0.3301556408,
0.3349729478,
0.1778179854,
0.1467306018,
0.709179759,
-0.4650737941,
0.4603912234,
0.6445379853,
-0.0374272391,
0.2968059182,
0.0904010311,
-0.2749058902,
-0.1471431255,
-0.7752351165,
-0.8283979297,
0.3471667469,
0.2474004328,
0.6365829706,
0.1223266348,
0.5085018873,
0.2626461089,
0.1356751323,
-0.8879432082,
0.387068361,
0.1036401168,
-0.4254170358,
-0.0457475744,
-0.562825501,
-1.0653464794,
0.3110427856,
0.0764026865,
-0.4251334965,
-0.1110707149,
0.3134630919,
-0.2298601568,
-0.2916950583,
-0.9909602404,
1.1150323153,
-0.2686235309,
-0.0321059898,
-0.0322765596,
-0.5630241036,
-0.0771540925,
0.1755483299,
-0.042187918,
-0.0815831795,
0.1461378485,
0.43023929,
-0.2628900111,
0.7426626086,
-0.1068653762,
-0.1293623894,
0.3448710442,
0.1787567884,
0.5703849196,
0.1561845094,
-0.0634648651,
-0.2025700957,
-0.243132025,
-0.5059973598,
-0.6982151866,
0.3302308619,
-0.4264624119,
-0.5658255816,
-0.0858674645,
-0.5947899222,
-0.2300459296,
0.2596174479,
0.6520508528,
0.3309596181,
-0.3856368065,
0.0083994614,
0.5714386106,
-0.3960842788,
0.3660085201,
0.3234190941,
-0.1883745641,
-0.2443513423,
0.9208055139,
-0.1784436405,
0.3260097206,
0.4688925743,
0.3501303494,
-0.4412685335,
-0.478987962,
-1.2462114096,
-0.0369141884,
-0.6419225931,
-0.1590080261,
-0.5422794223,
-0.0088580772,
-0.4963211119,
-0.225947082,
-0.2052367032,
-0.4899379909,
0.0411479883,
0.0959997177,
0.5133652687,
0.6088924408,
0.2392308116,
0.6188678741,
-1.1232212782,
0.2483125329,
0.1969738454,
0.0275411159,
-0.3476274908,
-0.6312978268,
-0.2264094651,
0.1778910458,
-0.551872313,
-0.9514394999,
0.4838198423,
-0.0277868211,
0.6183900833,
0.2442708462,
0.162511006,
0.4287911952,
-0.7740827203,
1.04923141,
0.0429260507,
-0.7857163548,
0.7261860967,
-0.48327142,
0.6151760817,
0.4075939655,
0.2227436751,
-1.159345746,
-0.4695941806,
-0.5099329948,
-0.4984192848,
0.4484607875,
0.6620058417,
0.2784350812,
0.0668287352,
0.1240154356,
0.1475645304,
0.2083482146,
-0.3068434,
-0.1457697004,
-0.2583823502,
-0.1318597645,
0.0012607609,
0.0631804317,
0.0608833358,
0.4001016021,
0.5294985771,
-0.2076063603,
0.4437058866,
-0.0091628097,
-0.1890145838,
0.1100079939,
0.6038935781,
0.7179597616,
0.5366988182,
0.0913070962,
0.0979630351,
0.324601084,
-0.3175629377,
0.0436248742,
-0.0978599787,
-0.1945898384,
0.2763752639,
0.166466251,
0.9701657891,
-0.0834558606,
-0.2920869291,
0.3755640984,
-0.3818184435,
0.1053924859,
0.1871489137,
0.2296264917,
0.0564402491,
0.1354092807,
0.140643388,
0.2794632018,
0.166330114,
-0.2380881906,
0.0209961403,
0.3554499149,
-0.4272371829,
-0.2859956622,
0.673185885,
0.4707857072,
-0.7019834518,
0.6697078943,
-0.4314543903,
-0.7694987655,
0.3448674679,
0.7856686711,
1.0235843658,
-0.1415830404,
0.348651588,
0.2324787974,
0.1043132693,
-0.1030446291,
0.0657477155,
-0.2027243823,
-0.4901588261,
-0.5845825672,
-0.2371730804,
-0.9060105085,
-0.3153633475,
-0.3388890922,
0.2567160726,
0.1957010031,
-0.1882915944,
-0.3750041127,
-0.1599838287,
-0.7848988175,
-0.064467974,
0.0192622989,
0.8115969896,
-0.7376113534,
0.4677343071,
0.7907957435,
-0.4714663923,
-0.5255888104,
0.033648286,
-0.1180825159,
-0.8717558384,
0.5183234215,
0.1126630455,
-0.093636483,
0.2419217825,
-0.5105165839,
-0.341146946,
0.6113439202,
0.3128415644,
-0.1965937167,
0.1858849674,
0.3759320676,
0.485213846,
-0.0912632719,
0.2422833145,
0.2739574313,
0.6196627617,
0.2293541878,
-0.9482334852,
0.031144686,
-0.2684698999,
0.0177837126,
0.1528308541,
-0.3211347163,
0.3191893399,
-0.1411637515,
-0.4183306992,
0.0913353562,
0.6232179999,
0.143168211,
0.1662546247,
0.3656915724,
-0.00319527,
0.7118859291,
-0.1080693081,
1.1391875744,
-0.2694967687,
0.2482143044,
0.8510527015,
0.2213290185,
0.5585789084,
0.5073689222,
-0.0384373181,
-0.0368159041,
0.7802918553,
0.2672229409,
0.5066926479,
0.1039302573,
-0.4849685133,
-0.2933499813,
-0.3974858522,
-0.6054530144,
0.0644505918,
0.2576460838,
-0.321739018,
-0.304641515,
0.1627325863,
0.0514271297,
-0.2164038867,
0.2251960933,
0.7589087486,
0.3553313315,
-0.9038863778,
0.5579067469,
-0.0347485468,
0.3884815872,
-0.5286410451,
-0.2374162525,
-0.4667461514,
0.0056860838,
0.1139927283,
-1.0373716354,
0.1124618128,
0.2270213515,
0.0961160362,
-0.8346087337,
0.7499392033,
-0.3330229819,
-0.2029712498,
-0.3052628934,
0.741633296,
0.604285419,
-0.3629399538,
-0.4978304207,
-0.1324088871,
0.1578597277,
-0.2079171389,
0.2303298861,
0.9639914036,
0.0402983464,
0.4840891361,
0.6774157286,
-0.0270755999,
0.0601076335,
0.1185689941,
0.6144868135,
-0.6578315496,
-0.6481077075,
-0.8694804907,
0.4535245001,
-0.1620764434,
-0.553841114,
0.907736659,
0.3737334907,
0.5409898758,
-0.3338700831,
0.7821148634,
-0.1089966148,
0.1787404418,
-0.6115058064,
0.5793446302,
-0.1072776988,
0.1095875725,
-0.2307188809,
-0.915551126,
-0.3959864378,
0.7339601517,
-0.3264966607,
-0.1448910087,
0.7278915644,
0.8437764645,
-0.0549641885,
0.1923747659,
0.3532880843,
-0.2755169272,
0.7759917974,
0.430044651,
0.9990167022,
-0.3224540651,
0.9779272676,
0.0657048672,
-0.2515293062,
-0.5019563437,
-0.9866945744,
-0.764765501,
-0.4636314213,
-0.1376478076,
-0.2278126329,
-0.0336899608,
0.899954021,
0.6398919225,
-0.795132041,
-0.0759326518,
-0.2150497437,
0.2056473792,
-0.3984378874,
-0.2149211615,
0.1984778792,
-0.9160081744,
-0.8657522798,
0.6302405596,
0.0790063292,
0.2224811316,
0.1121249124,
-0.2774111629,
0.45856148,
-0.2273797393,
0.7707111239,
0.2302791327,
-0.485425204,
-0.3657118082,
0.3396825194,
-0.3888104856,
0.2466753423,
1.057082653,
-0.5546805263,
0.4052177072,
0.9212481976,
0.8332842588,
0.3890148997,
0.1830846369,
1.1205254793,
-0.6801100969,
-0.1012594029,
0.0853542089,
0.3051815927,
0.3438574076,
-0.3190388381,
0.480545789,
0.0443703532,
-0.7673939466,
-0.2600083947,
0.301158905,
-0.9854597449,
0.1585620493,
1.1767879725,
-0.2266817242,
0.0339546725,
-0.1929068416,
-1.0557255745,
0.4055692554,
-0.7025080919,
0.5700511336,
0.844321847,
-0.427547127,
-0.1756047308,
-1.0193961859,
0.453106761,
0.6259564161,
-0.6863549948,
0.2132832706,
0.4101582468,
-0.0258905049,
0.1179336086,
0.5197520256,
0.0013556877,
0.333430469,
-0.0661304444,
-0.147118926,
0.1301905066,
-0.0355784334,
-0.1745991409,
-0.1020204872,
0.3905843794,
-0.5752729774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02181v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02181v2 | On the Impact of Voice Anonymization on Speech Diagnostic Applications: a Case Study on COVID-19 Detection | 2023-04-05T01:09:58 | 2024-06-26T17:58:42 | Yi Zhu, Mohamed Imoussaïne-Aïkous, Carolyn Côté-Lussier, Tiago H. Falk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | With advances seen in deep learning, voice-based applications are burgeoning,
ranging from personal assistants, affective computing, to remote disease
diagnostics. As the voice contains both linguistic and para-linguistic
information (e.g., vocal pitch, intonation, speech rate, loudness), there is
growing interest in voice anonymization to preserve speaker privacy and
identity. Voice privacy challenges have emerged over the last few years and
focus has been placed on removing speaker identity while keeping linguistic
content intact. For affective computing and disease monitoring applications,
however, the para-linguistic content may be more critical. Unfortunately, the
effects that anonymization may have on these systems are still largely unknown.
In this paper, we fill this gap and focus on one particular health monitoring
application: speech-based COVID-19 diagnosis. We test three anonymization
methods and their impact on five different state-of-the-art COVID-19 diagnostic
systems using three public datasets. We validate the effectiveness of the
anonymization methods, compare their computational complexity, and quantify the
impact across different testing scenarios for both within- and across-dataset
conditions. Additionally, we provided a comprehensive evaluation of the
importance of different speech aspects for diagnostics and showed how they are
affected by different types of anonymizers. Lastly, we show the benefits of
using anonymized external data as a data augmentation tool to help recover some
of the COVID-19 diagnostic accuracy loss seen with anonymization. | [
-0.2775074542,
-0.7049278617,
0.218709603,
0.1297480017,
-0.0765792206,
0.1603687257,
-0.1913532764,
-0.8831914663,
0.2535139322,
0.2967675626,
-0.483761698,
-0.3506738245,
-0.4562295377,
-0.1334621161,
-0.684237659,
0.8005117774,
0.6728854179,
0.1676815897,
-0.3872230053,
-0.1045825705,
-0.2686677277,
-0.9247806072,
-1.023496747,
-0.1538375914,
0.2149581909,
0.2235054076,
0.9200667143,
0.868840456,
0.4109123349,
0.1889985502,
-0.2836836278,
-0.1792654097,
-0.4314613938,
0.3816817403,
0.1325622499,
-0.1851387918,
-0.2535870671,
0.1284570247,
0.5042405128,
0.6286984086,
-0.2686837912,
0.3528662622,
-0.3039911687,
0.2959444523,
-0.6526080966,
-0.0588015281,
0.020460926,
0.3121737242,
-0.5781233907,
-0.0647353083,
0.0051848865,
-0.1729650199,
0.240175128,
-0.3025080264,
0.3581669927,
-0.0252494812,
0.8729035258,
0.4851110876,
-0.1642382145,
-0.2442966253,
-1.0604071617,
0.5971605778,
-0.6402621269,
0.5342789888,
0.4224557281,
0.4352504015,
0.0828357786,
-0.5601239204,
-0.2822347283,
-0.2958851159,
-0.0793653801,
0.0814614445,
-0.6207908988,
0.0186659638,
0.1613691449,
0.8083914518,
-0.6336280704,
0.5012236238,
-0.3082101345,
-0.5061697364,
0.8091378808,
0.1114512756,
0.5625834465,
0.064159885,
-0.1427950859,
0.0786291659,
-0.475971669,
0.2632663548,
0.2838385105,
0.1800628603,
-0.3328814805,
0.1604064852,
-0.3967521191,
0.4662822187,
0.1347993612,
-0.2105196714,
0.2718185782,
-0.3828383386,
-0.1169963405,
0.4691455662,
0.7067766786,
-0.2676018476,
-0.0766256526,
-0.3346254826,
0.3360867798,
0.128590554,
0.1504348069,
-0.6688728929,
-0.4820181429,
0.2114336193,
-0.728120327,
-0.1000784039,
-0.3242346942,
-0.6604911089,
-1.0199335814,
-0.2949045599,
0.3634434938,
-0.1591807902,
-0.3163536191,
0.1242913157,
-0.0971233398,
0.0443056673,
0.2400580198,
-0.755625844,
0.6330476403,
0.6812283397,
0.499186933,
-0.1284226477,
0.1132341474,
-0.9343318343,
-0.1827813834,
-0.2916767597,
0.2338396162,
-0.6578208208,
-0.3150282502,
-0.3329503536,
-0.0905817226,
-0.1896394193,
-0.9787967205,
0.2223174572,
0.1525737941,
0.3413029015,
-0.299767226,
-0.4066999555,
-0.2832099795,
-0.0553486533,
-0.4187430739,
0.7656456232,
-0.344470799,
-0.620765388,
0.1471845359,
-0.5612325668,
-0.5102310181,
0.2377344221,
-0.3721665442,
-0.7219557762,
0.103990823,
0.1506961584,
0.4915680885,
-0.4572156072,
0.2776841223,
-0.3868825436,
-0.407785207,
0.0778170526,
-0.4963093102,
1.0307742357,
0.2591091692,
-0.6984778047,
-0.0208451338,
-0.9550885558,
-0.227916941,
-0.1357131004,
0.2528871894,
-0.2131654173,
0.1158484966,
-0.380259335,
-0.1529753059,
0.0946103856,
-0.7228530049,
-0.4440556765,
-0.5002772808,
0.2716459334,
0.0057693641,
0.3190490603,
0.1238457039,
-0.1502755284,
0.9573868513,
0.0937910154,
0.4809244573,
-0.1641777754,
-0.7159973979,
-0.4489964247,
-0.689460516,
0.3000201881,
0.6869302988,
0.0139049822,
0.0409817994,
0.0991430879,
-0.5112379193,
-0.8370150328,
-0.1525256485,
0.3647103906,
0.7159796357,
0.2959497273,
-0.1967710555,
-0.390558213,
-1.0070556402,
-0.5648573637,
0.148533985,
0.0627076402,
0.64597857,
-0.0684902892,
-0.2421231866,
0.6077916026,
-0.2540585101,
-0.4632644653,
0.1153316125,
-0.2228522301,
-0.0056919577,
0.3831784725,
0.617451787,
-0.6649329662,
-0.2510119975,
0.0184044354,
-0.6306939721,
-0.1765414029,
0.0307449903,
0.3944992125,
-0.4785064757,
0.2726938725,
-0.2210242301,
0.7445726991,
0.8912005424,
-0.3168404996,
0.302644521,
-0.3291028738,
0.0904131904,
-0.8582795858,
0.1696942747,
-0.052888982,
-0.2272830755,
-0.9444425702,
-0.145322606,
-0.3376615644,
-0.7049645782,
-0.3076469004,
0.2484286577,
-0.2597704232,
-0.0472691581,
-0.2149078846,
-0.379347235,
0.0856825113,
-0.3887937963,
-0.0714955851,
0.7546759248,
1.0156236887,
-0.5521121025,
0.3975796103,
0.1024063975,
-0.0531074256,
0.4011611342,
-0.5793022513,
0.2549479902,
0.0208030455,
0.0124144712,
-0.7847726345,
-0.129065603,
0.4533812106,
-0.530320406,
-0.0065961205,
0.19612737,
-0.3033793867,
0.0370406918,
-0.0543194599,
0.4310261905,
0.4445017278,
-0.8034161925,
0.2483471185,
0.639414072,
-0.1627417356,
-0.4058921337,
-0.8997391462,
0.4048762619,
-0.5136683583,
-0.6031008363,
0.4163134992,
0.0688129365,
-0.3102374077,
0.1210858971,
-0.1355573088,
-0.5799604654,
0.4777800739,
0.4255566299,
-0.2126216143,
-0.1376206279,
0.3711047173,
-0.0473870263,
-0.0350012518,
0.2005318105,
0.2635996938,
0.2423710078,
-0.037905369,
-0.1370972842,
-0.993368268,
0.5688036084,
0.2953281105,
-0.5156396627,
0.6743639112,
0.8480886817,
-0.565092802,
0.0572047345,
-0.6304634809,
-0.1373334825,
-0.4266032875,
-0.0664860308,
0.1421248466,
-0.7855533361,
0.6003796458,
-0.1291573197,
-0.5984208584,
0.198376596,
0.4173407257,
0.0852141902,
0.8499560356,
0.4849381745,
-0.4610858262,
0.3011419773,
0.0185599849,
0.5615952611,
-0.4090340137,
-0.3678880632,
-0.8080255985,
0.0097400676,
-0.781899333,
-0.1166372299,
0.6060228944,
-0.3679436743,
0.2102788538,
-0.0672868192,
-0.6158226132,
0.0896176845,
0.58167696,
0.3480698168,
0.2712039351,
-0.1749221981,
0.5346775055,
-0.0235856567,
-0.6082563996,
-0.0089081032,
0.8260908127,
0.34581092,
0.5176501274,
-0.0148255266,
0.9517142773,
0.3878758252,
-0.3149121106,
-0.637427628,
0.1453606486,
-0.6015584469,
-0.5551237464,
-0.4115903974,
-0.3690238297,
-1.1522729397,
-0.0533462651,
-0.0802866369,
-0.9398200512,
0.6785442233,
0.4786017835,
-0.6427254081,
-0.2728166878,
-0.6870385408,
0.9127283692,
-0.1373713762,
-0.2395405471,
-0.3992257416,
-0.5002000928,
0.1197896525,
0.0880396143,
0.3161511719,
-0.0853287205,
0.1963234842,
0.8739664555,
-0.3386158645,
0.8808498383,
-0.478608042,
0.1274859309,
0.1616861522,
-0.5030442476,
0.2420279533,
0.2685983181,
-0.187434867,
0.420009464,
0.3675865829,
-0.1879778951,
-0.364543587,
0.6571524143,
-0.4896959066,
-0.6859531999,
-0.4830955863,
-0.3191854954,
-0.4023585021,
0.1585799456,
0.2539993525,
0.6606317759,
-0.1052008048,
0.4612208307,
0.7531931996,
-0.5409036279,
0.2637580931,
0.5497373343,
0.3765805066,
-0.2065072954,
1.0334507227,
0.2094599158,
-0.132637471,
0.0832514018,
0.8500151634,
-0.1535063386,
-0.5980409384,
-0.0477100275,
0.2339207083,
-0.2871604562,
0.1265811026,
-0.4394151568,
-0.3757244647,
-0.5134528279,
0.3809084594,
-0.469266206,
-0.2494720668,
-0.6067913175,
0.1008262262,
0.406029284,
0.6941233277,
-0.2740179598,
0.0238474179,
-0.2400618643,
0.5922178626,
0.3344864249,
0.2496672869,
-0.0466879234,
-0.2162282169,
-0.3033624887,
0.2332647443,
0.0678361431,
-0.7768902779,
0.3104573488,
0.7350468636,
0.5847535729,
0.4633557498,
0.2045751065,
0.8707559705,
-0.1501180381,
1.0293624401,
0.0376142226,
-1.0280665159,
0.4553501904,
-0.0056109405,
0.3312620223,
0.4954070151,
0.2171764672,
-0.8320077062,
-0.4900408685,
-0.6135536432,
-0.6504445672,
0.382029593,
0.0840586275,
0.0774717927,
0.2228505015,
0.3688589334,
0.1219917759,
0.2318920344,
0.1566675007,
-0.6201138496,
-0.2336702645,
-0.0156761166,
-0.4269193709,
-0.1305129379,
-0.1874955893,
-0.6467139721,
0.2265706211,
0.4597289562,
0.230804801,
0.2340355366,
0.2176424861,
0.3225159347,
0.2142623663,
0.7681828141,
0.4088507295,
0.2627944052,
0.1436239779,
-0.145205304,
-0.6700095534,
0.0358802639,
0.2631103694,
-0.0766553283,
0.3068990707,
0.1422799677,
0.939375937,
-0.1157760844,
-0.6517736912,
0.6752625108,
0.0378916748,
0.0268116277,
-0.3229141235,
0.0369131304,
0.0336353406,
0.260075599,
0.1517331451,
0.0217557643,
0.8212836981,
-0.3785140514,
0.0809340775,
0.5845372677,
-0.3225966394,
-0.4929060042,
0.9388124347,
0.0846569985,
-0.5172683001,
0.4211901128,
-0.1315921545,
-0.2204732746,
0.7180343866,
0.3131617904,
0.8742853403,
-0.7304342389,
0.2310279459,
-0.1977002472,
0.1052904502,
0.0582269654,
0.249109894,
-0.0808477178,
-0.3648142219,
-0.1902692616,
-0.0552032031,
-0.7674714923,
0.5965700746,
-0.9167028069,
-0.0767334923,
-0.4299207032,
-0.2681785524,
0.3091548383,
0.0430927835,
-0.6501545906,
0.596493423,
0.5992818475,
0.3047675192,
-0.8280287981,
0.635307014,
0.5030438304,
0.3348749578,
-0.777338624,
0.1785956025,
0.3116253018,
-0.605891943,
0.134639293,
0.1665916741,
-0.1652998328,
-0.0934441835,
-0.098082982,
-1.0245027542,
0.7439383268,
0.8256670833,
-0.4251584709,
0.4234960973,
0.3160372674,
1.0269104242,
-0.1808930188,
-0.0939173698,
0.458232969,
0.3613370657,
-0.2256488502,
-1.4056680202,
0.0842388421,
-0.1872149259,
-0.1392684877,
-0.0939427689,
-0.6589903831,
0.5694035292,
0.0142382542,
-0.3278263807,
-0.1216186509,
0.0712267682,
-0.3070984483,
0.8664431572,
0.1074723601,
0.3962356448,
1.2129871845,
0.3053333163,
1.0213261843,
-0.3686563969,
0.1236185431,
0.9759604335,
0.0732628405,
0.5967802405,
0.152658239,
-0.0553526878,
0.1992259771,
0.5825639367,
0.0109909056,
0.431279093,
0.338530153,
-0.5411706567,
0.0657027513,
-0.5974422693,
-0.7764411569,
0.7849083543,
0.3593758643,
-0.5716947913,
-0.0754269063,
0.4069751203,
0.1246138886,
0.0061034583,
-0.0936944485,
0.7923241258,
-0.1594150364,
0.0105730444,
0.579395175,
-0.255099833,
0.1979556382,
-0.2764553428,
0.1496882886,
0.0642075092,
0.0664042979,
-0.3983703256,
0.0969696641,
0.5789468884,
-0.039750576,
-0.1159885377,
-0.3547717333,
0.7228649855,
-0.431356281,
-0.2145112008,
0.2001613379,
0.2962260246,
0.4094647467,
-0.3547673821,
-0.5592222214,
0.3720177114,
-0.3231262267,
-0.1462299526,
0.4577539265,
-0.0491728485,
0.1721714437,
0.578666687,
0.325619787,
0.3085127771,
0.1901831031,
0.0164331961,
0.5918424726,
-0.3290774524,
-0.7484105825,
-0.862077713,
0.1012078226,
-0.1227582842,
-0.2662293911,
0.9196067452,
0.823195219,
0.4305710793,
0.2554164529,
0.7350252271,
0.2402499467,
0.7947197556,
-0.0690190941,
0.8861505985,
-0.3793144822,
0.2532979548,
0.1289472133,
-0.1306143105,
-0.2996191084,
0.2175433487,
-0.3830314577,
-0.2716124058,
0.4079372585,
0.6906085014,
0.2143636644,
0.1606567651,
0.392336309,
0.2056414038,
0.2694283128,
-0.0082684616,
0.4449723661,
-0.1247562841,
0.2972217798,
-0.8136581182,
-0.3288259208,
-0.0362721384,
-0.6283340454,
-0.6721357703,
-0.293571502,
-0.7672454715,
-0.0870995075,
0.5451027751,
0.3618297279,
0.834918201,
-0.9111100435,
-0.2633058429,
-0.0655592605,
-0.1725287288,
-0.6267814636,
-0.1927808672,
0.3061623573,
0.1077664122,
-0.5171544552,
0.9874702096,
0.3954585493,
-0.2626952231,
-0.2133640498,
0.1526615173,
0.243549794,
-0.1129925027,
0.2324245274,
0.6427822709,
-0.7744266391,
-0.2554710805,
0.012162596,
0.1359345168,
0.0665523559,
0.5757682323,
-0.9402511716,
0.9158860445,
0.3020449579,
0.8800601959,
0.4345172644,
0.3931575119,
0.5474250317,
-0.5821741223,
0.1652806103,
0.489000082,
-0.2247693688,
0.2875130177,
-0.9778923392,
0.0709567219,
0.2836439312,
-0.3203035593,
-1.0383771658,
-0.0340975262,
-0.7200093865,
0.1572645754,
1.0130569935,
-0.1327955574,
0.0899737328,
-0.34974733,
0.0443112142,
0.1941595227,
-0.380007565,
0.8119575977,
0.2694810629,
-0.7924157381,
-0.2638920844,
-0.4747298658,
0.7732539177,
0.5183989406,
-0.744433403,
-0.167386964,
0.149495542,
0.2844887674,
-0.1226844564,
0.5512315631,
0.0716138929,
0.5392726064,
-0.1857909709,
-0.2377413511,
-0.4016245604,
-0.0388967171,
-0.8765504956,
0.2392717749,
-0.1163861528,
-0.7876471877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02168v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02168v2 | I2I: Initializing Adapters with Improvised Knowledge | 2023-04-04T23:51:48 | 2023-07-10T20:41:34 | Tejas Srinivasan, Furong Jia, Mohammad Rostami, Jesse Thomason | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | Adapters present a promising solution to the catastrophic forgetting problem
in continual learning. However, training independent Adapter modules for every
new task misses an opportunity for cross-task knowledge transfer. We propose
Improvise to Initialize (I2I), a continual learning algorithm that initializes
Adapters for incoming tasks by distilling knowledge from previously-learned
tasks' Adapters. We evaluate I2I on CLiMB, a multimodal continual learning
benchmark, by conducting experiments on sequences of visual question answering
tasks. Adapters trained with I2I consistently achieve better task accuracy than
independently-trained Adapters, demonstrating that our algorithm facilitates
knowledge transfer between task Adapters. I2I also results in better cross-task
knowledge transfer than the state-of-the-art AdapterFusion without incurring
the associated parametric cost. | [
0.0221645534,
-0.226655975,
0.4905105233,
0.5229350328,
0.0599398799,
0.1243779138,
0.0219994262,
-0.2500583529,
-0.3234371245,
0.0030697174,
-0.5798086524,
0.3343218863,
-0.6586717367,
-0.2238442749,
-0.0068299784,
0.9225744009,
-0.3594204783,
-0.0966120437,
-0.6677390933,
-0.342276305,
-0.9168723822,
0.1985978931,
-0.9842570424,
-0.2621042728,
0.6629113555,
0.9295188785,
0.0041676532,
0.0912135169,
0.3831592798,
0.2778894305,
0.3899567723,
0.2608265281,
-0.8235111833,
0.0985716805,
-0.4319759011,
-0.6960286498,
0.1586702764,
-0.0584012121,
0.8169365525,
0.5737102032,
-0.1051570177,
0.3130077422,
0.2756039202,
0.8325291872,
-0.5186000466,
0.1526083648,
-0.815648675,
-0.0999063551,
0.1545539796,
-0.330141902,
-0.569278419,
-0.3189786971,
0.2199191749,
-0.7495335937,
-0.0160189085,
0.0049481234,
0.3884502351,
0.3984498382,
-0.0865832195,
-0.4855696559,
-0.8796809316,
0.6820533872,
-0.2392397672,
0.1468310356,
-0.141222924,
0.4591543078,
-0.3035018146,
-1.0261981487,
-0.8627316952,
-0.1842983067,
0.0941911414,
0.4237343967,
-0.263305217,
-0.2958731353,
0.0093500521,
0.0357145444,
-0.4177838564,
-0.0908353701,
-0.6437851787,
0.130523026,
0.3518965244,
-0.0947534963,
0.6389777064,
0.4819802046,
-0.6113764048,
0.0607460514,
-0.4661423862,
0.3094813526,
0.0399577171,
-0.2947681546,
-0.1022126228,
0.4466167986,
-0.1102854311,
0.3799345493,
0.3494824171,
-0.1636515558,
0.1206764653,
-0.3721452355,
0.1382625401,
0.0001171945,
0.1947982013,
0.4534729421,
0.4751891196,
-0.664654851,
0.0447301082,
-0.0905753076,
0.6820346713,
-0.5947066545,
-0.5677595139,
0.1342583895,
-0.2570466697,
0.0974757075,
-0.10911984,
-0.3426750004,
-0.0572533645,
-0.2865298688,
0.9522634745,
-0.7615001798,
-0.1461499482,
-0.2818081081,
-0.50973171,
0.3340320885,
0.4688158631,
-0.7091858387,
0.2223926187,
0.3913911879,
1.0428141356,
-0.1887316257,
-0.6333357692,
-0.511597693,
0.2494549155,
-0.4036705494,
1.0102158785,
-0.157027781,
-0.2407780588,
-0.065957725,
0.2661602199,
-0.4360655844,
-0.5715883374,
-0.1681812555,
-0.4423202872,
0.1304770857,
-0.3304708898,
-0.5038910508,
-0.249246195,
0.3179447949,
-0.1455173492,
0.9127045274,
0.4548012018,
-0.462037921,
0.5268901587,
-0.6985756159,
-0.1386874467,
0.2867437601,
0.0837870762,
-0.2357413024,
0.1897600293,
-0.1210709438,
0.1075313762,
0.0470208861,
0.0437594205,
-0.2454805225,
-0.4925121963,
0.1117639318,
-0.1502761394,
0.4367963374,
-0.1433797181,
-0.2962768972,
-0.0731424317,
-0.6239213943,
-0.0666312203,
0.1403697878,
-0.3774705529,
-0.3301344216,
0.0598824024,
-0.1658969671,
0.2972346544,
0.1599553674,
-0.8357912302,
0.2380983979,
-0.2919788957,
0.279065907,
0.9997311831,
0.3137037456,
0.508077383,
-0.8130551577,
0.2621569932,
0.386290431,
0.1116822213,
-0.3455939889,
-0.5052598715,
-1.0957570076,
0.1595626175,
-0.1207642257,
0.8412674665,
-1.0895719528,
-0.1502129585,
-0.6047773957,
-0.6370489001,
-0.1340469122,
0.4185181558,
0.4578208625,
0.6572234035,
0.5849013925,
-0.2170512229,
-0.4364359975,
-0.7097780704,
-0.2396729887,
-0.2191392928,
-0.007195069,
0.3470259607,
0.5656535625,
-0.3015109599,
0.6705598235,
-0.2229339778,
-0.3803055584,
-0.1349892169,
0.14230147,
-0.11147964,
0.944701314,
0.6848740578,
-0.3743223548,
-0.662434876,
0.0010395545,
-0.9770299196,
0.5625086427,
-0.5436081886,
-0.2093866467,
-0.2196793258,
0.5881356001,
-0.0618684478,
0.2819586992,
0.3516407907,
-0.1589632332,
0.3019586504,
-0.5748680234,
-0.0805502906,
-1.0841854811,
0.1682486832,
-0.0903233588,
0.0459818915,
-0.5634497404,
-0.3433308303,
0.1993735433,
0.104040429,
-0.2965700626,
0.8135025501,
-0.3487072885,
0.2460456192,
-0.1879064441,
0.0243208222,
-0.336706996,
0.599157691,
-0.2786207497,
1.1805512905,
0.4117043912,
-0.7695536613,
0.23023507,
0.4054372907,
-0.3270390928,
0.8287473321,
-0.5315951705,
0.3490012884,
-0.4855913818,
0.0645875484,
-1.4690572023,
-0.0968663394,
0.3989352584,
-0.3973329067,
0.4005286694,
-0.2082761824,
0.0342968889,
-0.4441762567,
-0.0392372049,
0.7358206511,
0.5397911072,
-0.8122318387,
0.5892064571,
0.264306128,
-0.3042280972,
-0.3546513617,
-0.497387737,
0.1920773089,
-0.1216446906,
-0.2618414164,
0.2809196711,
-0.480417192,
0.1452515572,
0.0281501412,
-0.1248293146,
-0.1853570938,
-0.1174068972,
0.4327187538,
0.2175607383,
-0.1961052418,
0.1893883795,
0.1488194466,
-0.187582165,
-0.0297049489,
-0.7802737951,
0.0801444575,
-0.0396941975,
-0.3211916387,
-0.4985874891,
0.2550757229,
0.6683750153,
0.2437671423,
0.6620725393,
0.4190722108,
-0.2716063261,
-0.1354280412,
-0.958368957,
0.1908067763,
-0.4687654376,
0.4191907942,
-0.4333895147,
-0.5020339489,
0.1953668594,
-0.617485404,
0.3431579471,
0.1336940974,
0.1039976925,
-0.6445189714,
0.5254505277,
0.9907844663,
0.060229823,
0.6210990548,
-0.3166227639,
0.0770292953,
-1.0323979855,
-0.6172431707,
-0.0691725537,
-0.8099542856,
-0.0467193685,
-0.4425181448,
0.5891040564,
0.1560468227,
-0.1557133645,
0.2661657631,
-0.3761176765,
0.4049749672,
0.7257004976,
0.6012849212,
-0.1475672126,
0.0158336591,
0.0345584005,
0.0535745509,
-1.0736209154,
0.2544823289,
1.3071415424,
0.0472848453,
0.482652247,
0.0594058372,
0.5596917868,
0.2956154943,
0.6203829646,
-0.6656278968,
0.2679581642,
-0.1039882079,
0.013050369,
-0.1656689197,
-0.0516765639,
-0.8477841616,
-0.3635510206,
0.0061896094,
-0.6316068769,
0.7010155916,
0.5802998543,
-0.4176106155,
0.3038148582,
-0.6687374711,
0.5952595472,
-0.2315131426,
-0.4846917689,
-0.5560418963,
-0.6643121243,
0.360845834,
-0.0007412723,
-0.0096347462,
0.1474163085,
-0.052910205,
0.9470112324,
-0.0265448838,
0.7209811807,
-0.5506129265,
0.4703551829,
0.4717494249,
-0.191792056,
0.5600575209,
0.224211663,
0.2197450101,
-0.0994486064,
-0.0564095713,
-0.7853475213,
-0.7095311284,
0.6493013501,
-0.6961824298,
-0.290501684,
-0.3339095712,
-0.6633195877,
-0.316890955,
0.1085526794,
0.2300966233,
0.5352905393,
-0.1382333338,
0.169325754,
1.0082420111,
-0.0710865855,
0.5892279744,
0.5296456218,
0.325319171,
-0.8037791252,
1.2213433981,
0.3339829743,
0.3509622812,
0.1471988559,
-0.0007431423,
0.1395534873,
-0.5162428617,
-0.5073339939,
0.1790122092,
-0.7142500877,
-0.19952856,
-0.7125825286,
-0.478319943,
-0.0127997035,
-0.2390606552,
-0.2622001469,
-0.306646198,
-0.1343034357,
0.2346595377,
0.2943215966,
0.6548092365,
-0.3559137583,
0.3614164293,
-0.6370142698,
0.4147270918,
0.80907619,
0.3653598726,
-0.0017724441,
-0.8386073709,
-0.5106723905,
-0.1221287847,
-0.182783097,
-0.4494442046,
-0.1907425821,
0.605053246,
0.8211148977,
0.4566882253,
-0.0972515866,
0.9362729788,
-0.6218234301,
0.623033464,
0.3570214808,
-0.381700933,
0.5174544454,
0.0638865083,
0.6381836534,
0.9664137363,
0.6939580441,
-0.5258153677,
-0.0378197879,
-0.4475641251,
-0.611820817,
0.5717566609,
-0.1794273108,
0.3891170919,
-0.0525558442,
0.7669582963,
0.2865248024,
-0.0172082447,
-0.5137464404,
-0.0015096202,
-0.2079718262,
-0.2797044218,
-0.0858272687,
-0.5670178533,
-0.2356680185,
-0.4162271619,
0.6959273219,
-0.3594570458,
0.5791495442,
0.3900292516,
-0.501868844,
-0.1682117581,
-0.2220990807,
0.5559982657,
0.8786209226,
0.0494941659,
-0.0129542351,
0.5579006672,
-0.7099232674,
0.3546867967,
-0.2012605667,
-0.2846550345,
-0.262339443,
0.309270978,
0.7892974615,
0.525457263,
-0.6598276496,
0.4755216539,
-0.2066633254,
-0.2245020419,
-0.6308872104,
0.3891755044,
-0.0709571093,
0.522315681,
0.1705797911,
0.8584808111,
-0.0641431138,
-0.5801897049,
0.5217629671,
0.5355570912,
-0.6672749519,
-0.4483565986,
0.5593263507,
0.0774926469,
-0.3297545016,
0.8000645638,
0.0089696739,
-0.2435753196,
0.4458724856,
0.73319906,
0.9214630723,
-0.3596381545,
-0.0772757679,
0.7013852596,
0.4111207724,
-0.081808351,
0.2800630033,
-0.4569316804,
-0.6309250593,
-0.129168123,
-0.3219917715,
-0.2652702332,
-0.1764408648,
-0.496886611,
0.0802279338,
-0.5513088107,
0.3635824621,
-0.3917199075,
-0.4455593228,
-0.9129461646,
0.3260278404,
0.0190127529,
0.8854188323,
-0.7284495234,
0.8687865734,
0.614777863,
-0.4191242158,
-0.4997501373,
0.2528346181,
-0.344671309,
-1.0435367823,
0.5030480623,
0.1517211795,
0.0512757264,
0.3948678672,
-0.5002502203,
-0.9700428843,
1.3932276964,
-0.1379608959,
-0.4914900959,
-0.1157179251,
-0.1135401875,
0.0549462624,
-0.3831188083,
0.4313716292,
0.5120126009,
0.324015975,
0.3503373861,
-0.57557863,
-0.0794291049,
-0.5163977146,
0.1159329638,
-0.2415829003,
-0.6924011707,
0.4589822888,
-0.575419426,
-0.1966232359,
0.3037261665,
0.8262546062,
-0.1460152119,
0.56751436,
0.5899014473,
0.5358559489,
0.7005855441,
0.1570790559,
0.5866968632,
-0.4885813892,
-0.1549833268,
1.4415018559,
0.0756995007,
0.9154111147,
0.6171497107,
-0.2980697453,
0.7345871329,
0.2264241427,
-0.0173194129,
0.6162701249,
-0.1239851862,
-0.5077437162,
-0.045289468,
0.4167684317,
-0.32780388,
0.1187805459,
0.3559522033,
0.0251414143,
-0.2810726166,
0.5631155968,
-0.0861430988,
-0.1550133675,
-0.0829493627,
1.33378613,
-0.0820266083,
-1.1883616447,
0.5274031162,
-0.5007036328,
0.3546593785,
-0.8572651148,
-0.1808859855,
-0.413305074,
0.4102353752,
-0.0285054091,
-0.7168742418,
0.5085104704,
-0.4754908383,
-0.3734070957,
0.0099501461,
0.4764066935,
-0.4938160777,
-0.585139215,
0.1272071004,
0.2096694708,
-0.1781110466,
0.0677186996,
-0.3848879337,
-0.5782321095,
-0.0287946332,
0.0975130945,
0.5888738036,
0.3791883588,
0.0591037087,
0.8704910874,
0.6807931662,
-0.2178100646,
0.3799920082,
-0.5512090325,
1.1202385426,
-0.2530770302,
-0.3422810137,
-0.4751965106,
0.8584468961,
-0.0707750544,
-0.3154456317,
0.6315398216,
0.5575829148,
0.6167649031,
-0.2582915723,
0.9368636608,
-0.2078058869,
0.1692662537,
-0.435742408,
0.660330534,
-0.6225371361,
-0.0808664858,
0.1125810742,
-0.6535018086,
-0.0371420719,
0.2043408602,
-0.1762058437,
-0.3939889669,
0.7355812788,
0.5812422633,
-0.2285426408,
-0.4085103869,
0.1894189417,
0.2188943177,
0.1104438007,
0.7373972535,
0.6818016171,
-0.7161391377,
0.5712162256,
-0.4611554444,
-0.6094004512,
0.0450935252,
-0.5390443206,
-0.8482202291,
-0.7002296448,
-0.3808646202,
-0.5134441257,
0.5142149925,
0.5255306959,
0.7071242332,
-0.8748396635,
-0.249552846,
-0.5508744121,
0.005569695,
-0.7373263836,
-0.1758449674,
0.0658371672,
-0.9136262536,
-0.4155472219,
0.7456482649,
0.4737768173,
-0.1297647804,
0.0345302746,
-0.1490007788,
-0.3572646081,
0.3109679222,
0.4155786932,
0.7587622404,
-0.4393366873,
-0.4803406,
-0.2404250205,
0.4644402266,
0.2946038544,
0.7529418468,
-1.1997928619,
0.924382627,
0.2431873083,
0.8156439662,
0.5061261058,
-0.0912121013,
0.4272377491,
-0.4652903378,
0.3580813408,
-0.0457020439,
0.1785454899,
0.0065309885,
-0.4002766311,
0.3223612309,
0.5425072908,
-0.7709599137,
-0.5644798875,
0.012583266,
-0.899138093,
-0.0150292609,
0.5882072449,
-0.4542262256,
-0.1258529425,
-0.3031414151,
-0.1916710436,
0.1385381073,
0.1095596701,
0.9588070512,
0.2297614515,
-0.2478736043,
-0.2849625945,
-0.5300523639,
0.4290147722,
0.2886897027,
-0.8719164133,
-0.5087602139,
0.0763382167,
0.8536151648,
0.0822495744,
0.7250709534,
0.2115588933,
0.6365137696,
0.2970837057,
-0.1020387113,
-0.0332139432,
-0.7818366885,
-0.0363843516,
0.2348995656,
0.104856655,
-0.5128467083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.03228v1 | FedBot: Enhancing Privacy in Chatbots with Federated Learning | 2023-04-04T23:13:52 | 2023-04-04T23:13:52 | Addi Ait-Mlouk, Sadi Alawadi, Salman Toor, Andreas Hellander | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Chatbots are mainly data-driven and usually based on utterances that might be
sensitive. However, training deep learning models on shared data can violate
user privacy. Such issues have commonly existed in chatbots since their
inception. In the literature, there have been many approaches to deal with
privacy, such as differential privacy and secure multi-party computation, but
most of them need to have access to users' data. In this context, Federated
Learning (FL) aims to protect data privacy through distributed learning methods
that keep the data in its location. This paper presents Fedbot, a
proof-of-concept (POC) privacy-preserving chatbot that leverages large-scale
customer support data. The POC combines Deep Bidirectional Transformer models
and federated learning algorithms to protect customer data privacy during
collaborative model training. The results of the proof-of-concept showcase the
potential for privacy-preserving chatbots to transform the customer support
industry by delivering personalized and efficient customer service that meets
data privacy regulations and legal requirements. Furthermore, the system is
specifically designed to improve its performance and accuracy over time by
leveraging its ability to learn from previous interactions. | [
-0.3241763115,
-0.7830294967,
0.027621571,
0.2627304196,
0.1567936838,
0.3717447519,
-0.1547914743,
-0.405390799,
-0.0376194343,
0.7990369797,
-0.6722922325,
-0.4032538533,
-0.197602272,
-0.0220764838,
-0.4128292799,
1.2587103844,
0.2770062685,
-0.1241879165,
-0.6057811379,
0.0207599699,
-0.4103871882,
-0.7598135471,
-0.2599058747,
-0.2329688966,
0.337651521,
0.5555529594,
0.919285953,
0.1887120306,
0.6173928976,
0.44671157,
0.1265856326,
-0.0291819982,
-0.7056276798,
0.3690896928,
0.0261917654,
-0.8002979755,
-0.5218325853,
0.1546496302,
0.5644477606,
0.5901420712,
-0.3707251847,
-0.1232648119,
-0.0728786662,
0.545702219,
-0.505622983,
0.4708319306,
-0.29482463,
0.2023408562,
0.1119620577,
0.2069457918,
-0.6318643093,
-0.5391816497,
0.2956129909,
-0.4300767481,
0.448127836,
-0.02803801,
0.8256492615,
0.2697241604,
0.0577862225,
0.1186062768,
-1.0502269268,
0.5559248924,
-0.2701189816,
0.4410746098,
0.4145210087,
0.7820572853,
-0.2404798269,
-0.7473179102,
-0.5295961499,
-0.0492896736,
-0.4043876529,
0.0873370692,
-0.3760746717,
0.1483651847,
0.2202742547,
0.5514159799,
-0.3476478159,
0.2686540782,
-0.062020313,
-0.4048584998,
0.8795034289,
0.0030914068,
-0.2407429069,
0.2187268138,
-0.6345840693,
-0.427957505,
-0.2230779231,
0.3728946149,
0.5249059796,
0.4266194999,
-0.0755923465,
0.2941118181,
-0.450507462,
0.2217627317,
0.365968138,
-0.1778919995,
0.4243689179,
0.1662627161,
-0.3446262181,
0.0258521605,
0.8294740915,
0.0501743145,
0.0362386964,
-0.3711630702,
-0.215242967,
-0.1960271001,
0.1195334494,
-0.7594205141,
-0.2528198361,
0.2741561532,
-0.3728282154,
-0.5355829597,
0.4022751749,
-0.7459885478,
-0.7066829801,
-0.0675558224,
-0.0020369028,
-0.0533654466,
-0.529769063,
0.0863388479,
0.0943869278,
0.1445447654,
0.2480378002,
-0.9077650905,
0.5360330343,
1.2830706835,
0.5727165341,
0.0975034758,
-0.2981458902,
-0.6576418877,
-0.1704306304,
0.1238567531,
0.5356363058,
-0.5381897092,
-0.2812258005,
0.2941467464,
0.1926231682,
0.0309083518,
-0.4104308486,
0.1931956708,
-0.6378930211,
0.761428237,
0.3112483621,
-0.7928894162,
-0.0963647962,
0.1748291105,
-0.4212153554,
0.3613946736,
0.0481338203,
-0.5636329651,
0.2038605809,
-0.6907718182,
-0.6038839221,
0.2743884325,
0.0395449288,
-0.8738877773,
0.0506420694,
0.1378602535,
0.7849949598,
0.0766680017,
0.1750691384,
-0.512668252,
-0.2035090625,
0.4937472343,
-0.4024460316,
0.8400327563,
0.3039287627,
-0.1890068501,
0.2807686925,
-0.546703279,
-0.3070731759,
0.2061909735,
0.0321235433,
-0.1022105142,
-0.3055286407,
-0.2589386106,
0.0272352509,
0.3677012622,
-0.811791122,
0.0270427559,
-0.6633841991,
0.4457627237,
0.6622108221,
-0.1731920689,
0.8042482138,
-0.3531975746,
0.6101482511,
0.1149054393,
0.7350961566,
-0.2631987333,
-0.5669656396,
-0.5175645351,
-0.3165917099,
0.19851996,
0.3767723143,
-0.5248265862,
0.6636945605,
-0.2418862283,
-0.4929193258,
-0.3552323878,
-0.0766601488,
0.0486667752,
0.5740966201,
-0.1734984368,
-0.2628575265,
-0.2473403513,
-0.6990767121,
0.0997590497,
-0.0127164423,
-0.2689552605,
0.5379696488,
0.0758537352,
-0.5044059753,
1.228294611,
-0.646299541,
-0.5230507255,
0.0072885095,
-0.2281189263,
-0.0198627729,
0.6287440062,
0.3800910115,
-1.0843062401,
-0.3730431795,
-0.0570226684,
-0.4955272079,
0.1643487364,
-0.1440878958,
-0.2177756727,
0.2913714647,
0.0328746289,
-0.4907233119,
0.6014055014,
0.6527506709,
-0.3697320521,
0.1223638877,
-0.3586478233,
-0.1681626588,
-1.0242558718,
-0.2232327461,
-0.3327129185,
-0.8343670964,
-0.7109897137,
-0.2053762823,
-0.0883856639,
-0.7028879523,
-0.3169659972,
0.0864629224,
0.0781878158,
-0.091866307,
-0.5345955491,
0.0004310914,
-0.0093104122,
0.5688451529,
0.0640565455,
0.5656289458,
0.6853565574,
-0.2122600675,
0.6421866417,
0.6160191298,
0.345426321,
0.7410408258,
-0.4046324492,
0.4872252643,
0.108470872,
0.3320888579,
-0.8932850361,
-0.3671717644,
0.3964478374,
-0.6758181453,
0.0345905945,
0.1236988977,
-0.7333496213,
-0.237029165,
0.1716446728,
-0.2330021113,
0.4921170771,
-0.7365424633,
0.6442448497,
0.5411646962,
0.0810610577,
-0.4820896983,
-0.5422022939,
-0.1221011356,
-0.0444408208,
-0.81471771,
0.050174702,
0.0751870573,
-0.1291183084,
-0.2673456669,
0.005922331,
-0.3311190903,
0.4741973281,
0.8450046778,
0.1129982769,
-0.0089936405,
0.297131598,
-0.1836858839,
-0.3658049703,
0.149224773,
-0.1736005247,
0.8308711052,
-0.4407522976,
-0.0598243847,
-0.841035068,
0.3812067211,
0.3391304612,
-0.3074563146,
0.882408917,
0.5747805834,
-0.3453349471,
-0.2005752772,
-0.5685195327,
-0.6595025063,
-0.5875020027,
-0.1204846725,
-0.0996285677,
-1.0843061209,
0.5464390516,
-0.2356608063,
0.2354412377,
-0.0352208801,
0.3624732792,
-0.2234137952,
0.7668857574,
1.0931073427,
-0.2279351205,
0.8270999193,
-0.0487973318,
0.2843171358,
0.0608296618,
-0.2705708146,
-0.3596508503,
-0.3904779851,
-0.7609274387,
-0.0683166161,
-0.0342312418,
-0.2470965683,
-0.2194353193,
0.5609861612,
-0.4442877769,
0.5323806405,
0.5863648653,
0.5124224424,
0.2369658947,
0.002549324,
0.299554497,
0.2842555046,
-0.5592651367,
-0.2028629631,
0.7465058565,
0.6740697622,
0.6287332773,
-0.1200087294,
0.8574418426,
0.263359338,
0.300815016,
-0.5292011499,
0.4514243007,
-0.025858527,
-0.6260493398,
-0.3709159791,
-0.613093257,
-0.9187448025,
-0.1925125122,
-0.1997670531,
-0.446837455,
0.2586832941,
0.1228882819,
-0.3439941406,
0.0710150152,
-0.6613942385,
0.6607329845,
-0.1895379126,
-0.4283444881,
-0.3135891259,
-0.9265828133,
0.0297975764,
0.0772640854,
-0.0843326598,
0.1008961871,
0.4546904564,
0.637834847,
-0.6626158953,
1.085449934,
-0.6698748469,
0.0114127435,
-0.1004578248,
-0.0537771359,
0.5714638233,
0.3369727731,
0.2663059533,
0.3432931006,
-0.312330991,
-0.4437390566,
-0.6637656093,
0.5635486245,
-0.6304936409,
-0.6404557824,
-0.2292287201,
-0.6844163537,
-0.4932313561,
0.2807766199,
-0.2842213809,
-0.0516217351,
-0.1241796389,
0.6244838834,
0.6779101491,
-0.2108603716,
0.4870344698,
0.5554240942,
-0.1910644174,
-0.3926506341,
0.6197639704,
-0.4744722545,
0.1751020849,
0.4971866608,
0.511677444,
-0.2966071069,
-0.0293340832,
0.104910776,
0.2065078616,
-0.4144021273,
-0.3493518829,
-0.4499959946,
-0.166506812,
-0.5739227533,
-0.3487518132,
-0.7168428898,
-0.2110525221,
-0.3208747506,
-0.1251974106,
0.6577621698,
0.2694815099,
-0.0497021042,
0.734051168,
-0.6564728022,
-0.0954251066,
0.3173785806,
0.7347452641,
-0.193599835,
0.104143776,
-0.0993681923,
0.2585482299,
-0.1375664473,
-0.2981416285,
0.2421889752,
0.0662780628,
0.4265720248,
0.7047534585,
0.5743573904,
0.421264708,
-0.2531342506,
0.5030423999,
0.3341415524,
-0.7409666777,
0.4010744989,
-0.0828616917,
-0.0524894707,
0.5545948148,
0.2015064657,
-0.5390028954,
-0.3690110445,
-0.8658598661,
-0.2731285989,
0.762134552,
0.2661881447,
0.4358465374,
0.531943202,
0.2038662434,
0.3901017606,
0.458578974,
-0.2935833335,
-0.2521145046,
-0.4549619257,
-0.1753138751,
-0.1165290624,
0.1671941578,
-0.3472274244,
-0.0626758561,
0.2324786186,
-0.0479455665,
0.3790204227,
-0.099592723,
0.1126768738,
0.0129757086,
0.0157999992,
0.5011981726,
0.1349379122,
-0.0128828995,
-0.4266525805,
-0.1857102364,
-0.578854084,
-0.1543879658,
0.6071705222,
-0.1888221055,
-0.0516418405,
-0.0553618371,
0.7215322852,
0.1419446468,
-0.4233337641,
0.8718096018,
-0.3513455391,
-0.2432567775,
-0.4839189053,
0.3419393599,
-0.1446653157,
0.5981679559,
0.2211849093,
0.2982973158,
-0.1207921281,
-0.2284357697,
0.4888536632,
0.3040799201,
-0.4424316585,
-0.3692052662,
0.6792268753,
0.5853989124,
-0.7383512259,
0.6244854927,
0.1776028126,
-0.5194963217,
0.2524696887,
0.3645509779,
1.0077108145,
-0.3757839501,
0.4455274045,
-0.2298995107,
-0.1586723179,
0.0847377405,
-0.0485112518,
-0.6531244516,
-0.7621693015,
0.1892973781,
-0.1949581504,
-0.8005908728,
-0.283750236,
-0.7319927812,
0.1675505936,
-0.8126341105,
-0.0779660419,
-0.1711990535,
0.115328595,
-0.8569143414,
-0.1222018525,
0.2996658385,
0.5402670503,
-0.64277035,
0.8237591386,
0.2484728098,
-0.1057703868,
-0.5326378942,
-0.1311021894,
-0.1589522213,
-0.6397795677,
0.3344358802,
0.270547539,
0.0807797983,
-0.2599672377,
-0.7037301064,
-0.3260000348,
1.0864193439,
0.1633670926,
-0.9923279881,
0.2129669785,
0.729745388,
0.7853837013,
-0.4017749429,
-0.1912743151,
0.4087242186,
0.126384303,
0.0624098741,
-0.7962129116,
-0.0833436772,
0.2353411615,
-0.3730870783,
-0.1131009832,
-0.88220644,
0.6004670858,
0.1160546765,
-0.2378745973,
-0.3402086496,
0.8952016234,
-0.1533749104,
0.5954115391,
0.7161110044,
0.2864792049,
1.1265976429,
-0.1059216484,
0.7753021121,
-0.0571791381,
0.6718312502,
1.0394166708,
-0.5601099133,
0.6204150915,
0.1784566045,
-0.0004013538,
0.3469148576,
0.2338053137,
-0.1944616586,
0.672752142,
-0.1670413762,
-0.3213404715,
-0.1306518465,
-0.0297669955,
-0.1019035652,
0.6253576279,
0.1585246325,
-0.5549842119,
-0.0799794495,
0.5769963264,
0.2047293484,
0.1576659828,
0.000495091,
1.1942415237,
-0.1000312194,
-0.267398864,
0.418405205,
-0.4395171702,
0.5102587342,
-0.3256509304,
0.1928814054,
-0.4259253144,
0.6862116456,
-0.3401786983,
-0.6025850177,
0.4231724441,
0.0596610047,
-0.1889939755,
-0.497133553,
0.8143694997,
-0.2934293449,
-0.2483679205,
0.1498119831,
0.2029992789,
-0.0838106647,
-0.1600986123,
-0.6248912811,
-0.2861856222,
-0.1895195693,
-0.0262869261,
0.2741576433,
0.1564863324,
0.2888801396,
0.6850568652,
0.7177118063,
-0.2855497897,
-0.2876517773,
0.190505147,
0.9060872197,
-0.2625607848,
-0.8319396973,
-0.6257320642,
0.3869554698,
-0.4893053472,
-0.1083100066,
1.0095785856,
0.4404782355,
0.98107481,
-0.046532616,
0.4734446406,
0.1263616085,
0.6411173344,
0.0440466106,
1.0740123987,
-0.0227732509,
0.1858315021,
-0.0990267545,
-0.5442013144,
-0.5812331438,
0.5242344141,
-0.4593502283,
-0.4352780282,
0.1801511049,
0.790111959,
0.1764037609,
0.6541837454,
0.3820735812,
0.1007740796,
0.7544873953,
0.3572779894,
0.7037555575,
-0.3214304149,
0.5220184922,
-0.9863758087,
-0.33126688,
-0.3337056637,
-0.4683980346,
-1.0238242149,
-0.5209279656,
-0.4693773985,
-0.2712953091,
-0.0855065584,
0.6941415071,
0.8936806917,
-0.938777566,
0.0272903983,
-0.2643197775,
0.0506177992,
-0.4878784418,
-0.2585663795,
0.0547893494,
-0.1730197221,
-0.7338223457,
0.2553578615,
0.0547870696,
0.1053822562,
-0.4351045191,
0.0248673819,
0.1901681423,
-0.357031703,
0.305139631,
0.3044863343,
-0.2849125266,
-0.3097694814,
0.1190554872,
0.0154105788,
0.2532792687,
0.6755418777,
-0.899532795,
0.6254792213,
0.5672918558,
0.8370506167,
0.3449677527,
0.4358927906,
0.6865959764,
-1.0175071955,
0.53912884,
0.5895577669,
0.1872433871,
0.3753123581,
-0.9321820736,
0.2070934325,
0.0944185555,
-0.8812457919,
-0.841707468,
0.1204761863,
-0.7849903107,
-0.1448086202,
0.6356992722,
-0.6086953282,
-0.28182742,
0.0310727395,
-0.0804689825,
0.2176834494,
-0.7139323354,
0.87526232,
0.3333120942,
-0.0376840159,
-0.1300568432,
0.0120266909,
0.4586097598,
0.0419756062,
-0.7228510976,
0.5069000125,
0.45535025,
0.1560075283,
0.2337620407,
0.0195539165,
0.0650173202,
0.2144854665,
-0.1040138155,
-0.1237815171,
-0.3854952753,
-0.4414286613,
-0.6323590279,
0.3952288628,
-0.4360256195,
-0.6991767287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02144v1 | A Data Fusion Framework for Multi-Domain Morality Learning | 2023-04-04T22:05:02 | 2023-04-04T22:05:02 | Siyi Guo, Negar Mokhberian, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models can be trained to recognize the moral sentiment of text,
creating new opportunities to study the role of morality in human life. As
interest in language and morality has grown, several ground truth datasets with
moral annotations have been released. However, these datasets vary in the
method of data collection, domain, topics, instructions for annotators, etc.
Simply aggregating such heterogeneous datasets during training can yield models
that fail to generalize well. We describe a data fusion framework for training
on multiple heterogeneous datasets that improve performance and
generalizability. The model uses domain adversarial training to align the
datasets in feature space and a weighted loss function to deal with label
shift. We show that the proposed framework achieves state-of-the-art
performance in different datasets compared to prior works in morality
inference. | [
-0.3630611002,
-0.5778675675,
0.4437107146,
-0.1412262172,
-0.3037289679,
-0.1347518712,
-0.1100884452,
-0.0874864459,
-0.3432481587,
0.5987665057,
-0.4278151095,
-0.6474722028,
-0.7935140133,
-0.1890972704,
-0.0462870076,
1.1447350979,
0.4108091593,
0.2949192226,
-0.5139328241,
-0.6510920525,
-0.276553005,
-0.7192349434,
-0.427409023,
-0.4918488562,
0.3381237984,
0.1779870838,
1.0167855024,
1.0392436981,
0.4422509968,
0.2111272663,
0.3795975745,
0.1135533452,
-0.6258813739,
-0.0948182046,
-0.4495010376,
-0.2243577242,
-0.324203372,
0.5573334694,
0.369849354,
0.7367258072,
-0.0170120411,
0.0648364723,
-0.2317209393,
0.5640903115,
-0.8807172179,
-0.0184164941,
-0.5641120672,
0.1931627691,
-0.0487287194,
-0.0660717711,
-0.3793327808,
-0.798519671,
0.2944175303,
-0.872020483,
0.2909248769,
0.0095362477,
0.8366526961,
0.3423547447,
-0.6913256645,
-0.2219402939,
-0.4647650719,
1.3852965832,
-0.4123243093,
0.5316157341,
0.6236199141,
0.0778772607,
0.2761209905,
-0.4745929837,
-0.5584645867,
0.3892397881,
-0.1210572794,
-0.0099936659,
0.0058529573,
-0.1069971919,
0.0206045043,
0.3279196322,
-0.2574028969,
-0.1697845459,
-0.0490454659,
-0.2018126398,
0.8028863668,
0.0871909782,
0.1308440417,
-0.0837443024,
-0.5741927624,
-0.5011387467,
-0.6151766777,
0.2176168263,
0.6474248171,
0.336812079,
0.0059347167,
0.2365806401,
0.2876087427,
0.7621554732,
0.1039620712,
-0.1846782118,
0.5116843581,
-0.272911042,
-0.3262562752,
0.0600880831,
0.5406761765,
0.7077412009,
0.2680714726,
0.1556123495,
0.064516969,
0.3868032098,
0.5191444755,
-0.7123895884,
-0.3456049562,
0.2547006905,
-0.6034649014,
-0.5823372602,
0.054238569,
-0.7610148191,
-0.7841924429,
-0.4947564602,
0.1468416452,
-0.6636766791,
-0.0648627654,
0.590516746,
-0.0094523123,
0.4727123082,
0.202611655,
-0.8255101442,
0.0306207277,
0.7526373863,
0.364369303,
-0.0603791177,
-0.1955957264,
-0.9206284285,
0.2159794718,
-0.2559393346,
0.5139653087,
-1.0339232683,
-0.3494892418,
0.2361642271,
0.0000792261,
-0.1361517757,
-0.2741210759,
0.8772483468,
-0.301102668,
0.4386107922,
-0.3062954247,
-0.6131304502,
-0.4041637778,
0.239450261,
-0.667393744,
0.4629310369,
-0.065621905,
-0.7640961409,
0.5326141715,
-0.428188324,
-0.6580625176,
-0.1214514747,
-0.2818229496,
-0.8513368964,
-0.1044203788,
0.1494716555,
0.737934947,
-0.3804910481,
0.6141860485,
-0.5981477499,
-0.3545109928,
0.1745461076,
-0.285053134,
0.9966412187,
0.1393063664,
-0.1289843768,
-0.237205267,
-0.6184956431,
0.0747668967,
0.0738890916,
-0.1821936965,
-0.8262233138,
0.260225594,
0.1596841961,
0.242605105,
-0.0657132715,
-0.6317893863,
0.0286879875,
-0.3357948065,
0.0205586012,
0.8734781742,
-0.1167944297,
0.5580965281,
-0.4475980103,
0.0340685472,
0.1949706525,
0.3798295557,
0.4072566926,
-0.3755473197,
-0.546287477,
-0.203127116,
0.0644346923,
0.5250483751,
-0.6867823601,
0.7016660571,
-0.0650672689,
-0.1174485162,
-0.6901430488,
0.0361212119,
0.5066975951,
0.4998264611,
0.5074887872,
-0.322801739,
-0.2853605151,
-1.1012837887,
-0.426944077,
-0.077455163,
0.0533558168,
0.4319761693,
0.3785004914,
-0.347597003,
0.8746689558,
-0.5334120989,
-0.4116754234,
0.2021982223,
0.2782658637,
-0.1466092616,
0.5863509178,
0.6121239662,
-1.6667692661,
-0.1429903656,
0.1279787868,
-0.9299309254,
0.2684287131,
0.0275751576,
-0.2034381181,
-0.0944728106,
-0.1057720557,
0.032205157,
0.4019274712,
0.4470707178,
-0.4717808068,
0.2070175409,
0.201002568,
0.4402531087,
-1.2693821192,
0.0089947358,
0.1116628572,
-0.0368293524,
-0.821472466,
-0.3866972625,
0.0329627208,
0.1173652411,
-0.623172462,
0.3337342143,
0.1772719771,
0.004609033,
-0.1122531891,
0.028381221,
0.1716973037,
0.3735027015,
0.0734244138,
0.6965886354,
0.8033576012,
-0.7173220515,
0.6488460898,
0.8264432549,
0.096596539,
1.0984643698,
-0.2162141949,
0.0554277562,
-0.2661612928,
0.1464572698,
-0.4023425877,
-0.3350096047,
0.0443963036,
-0.3504656553,
-0.1808875799,
-0.2510378063,
-0.0638190508,
0.0772139132,
-0.6470748782,
0.3952277303,
0.2945977151,
-0.685646832,
0.7624185681,
0.712660253,
0.0841289759,
-1.0138885975,
-0.6093739271,
-0.2298532575,
-0.5078840256,
-0.5914871693,
0.4302534759,
0.0589619763,
-0.4066676795,
0.1393817365,
0.1112124994,
-0.3329521418,
0.0905845091,
0.2596950233,
0.2894857824,
0.0506849289,
0.5686244369,
0.1427589208,
-0.1548116803,
0.0948284715,
-0.4778026938,
0.3284000456,
-0.5013406277,
-0.2766386867,
-0.0613886155,
0.5637447834,
0.3568929434,
-0.4099664092,
0.7551493645,
0.6504987478,
-0.461163491,
-0.136727795,
-0.3905334473,
0.1114816666,
-0.4369972348,
0.0401257649,
-0.1099578738,
-0.9464344978,
0.3483787179,
-0.2992152274,
0.3279176056,
0.4920437336,
0.418687433,
0.0411550254,
1.010507822,
0.8882964849,
0.0263162069,
0.2576544285,
-0.2071394622,
0.2417532802,
-0.5661327839,
-0.1266357601,
-0.3368636966,
-0.1187171414,
-0.7409434319,
-0.3946112692,
0.2028513551,
-0.1131793857,
-0.460861057,
0.0557645299,
-0.3510904014,
0.659134388,
0.3355354071,
-0.0719391629,
0.292563647,
0.2750464976,
-0.0032473556,
0.0070053204,
-0.4381515384,
-0.6650110483,
1.1507740021,
-0.024611054,
0.7122499347,
0.1880385727,
0.5467957258,
0.60160923,
0.133587718,
-0.64817065,
0.2641406059,
-0.9115812182,
-0.4375731051,
-0.2363440394,
-0.4880683422,
-0.7353538275,
0.2593904138,
-0.281683594,
-0.4360381961,
0.6815798283,
0.0191292185,
-0.2822935283,
0.4058796763,
-0.4847535789,
0.7496497631,
-0.1684191227,
-0.5130297542,
-0.3049603701,
-0.9492994547,
0.3159482777,
-0.3008271754,
0.1289990395,
-0.3247965872,
0.2149825841,
0.5755438805,
-0.0046140011,
0.7229166627,
-0.232402876,
-0.1905215979,
-0.0038560957,
-0.1711874604,
0.334823519,
0.2228096128,
-0.2975247502,
0.1393669695,
-0.2247807682,
-0.4090114832,
-0.3863912225,
0.7394273877,
-0.7872276902,
-0.2465055436,
-0.3483788669,
-0.5705966353,
-0.6960619092,
-0.0744561255,
0.2531285882,
0.3851652443,
-0.4718548656,
0.4374159575,
1.0263955593,
-0.4080669284,
0.0938805565,
0.2241273075,
0.2358297408,
-0.5993548036,
0.9606295824,
-0.3009803593,
0.2652881145,
-0.0088265156,
0.1836013198,
-0.5329729319,
0.1373297572,
-0.5314424634,
-0.0275516361,
-1.0244119167,
-0.3430856168,
-0.6552662849,
-0.1049803346,
-0.3406248987,
-0.6682554483,
-0.4283849895,
-0.2998875678,
-0.1190521121,
-0.0373051427,
0.5891529918,
0.5358408093,
-0.0690732002,
0.1732531935,
-0.708874166,
0.5114236474,
0.4884153903,
0.6302576065,
-0.4750478268,
-0.069755055,
-0.0393379293,
0.3693059683,
-0.1427209526,
-0.3573328257,
0.0408137999,
0.4331516325,
0.3992679417,
0.2324378341,
0.27703017,
0.4491891563,
-0.2514959574,
0.590514183,
0.289324075,
-1.0781695843,
0.5816710591,
-0.3284429908,
-0.1107169092,
0.6940562129,
0.692558527,
-0.5428331494,
-0.2383403927,
-0.7066164613,
-0.6089245081,
0.7079873085,
0.3181327581,
0.1907733232,
0.3039948344,
0.2897539437,
0.4799388051,
0.3517443538,
-0.4628008902,
-0.4588863552,
-0.5858106017,
-0.4351010621,
-0.1058896407,
0.2780795693,
-0.5432998538,
-0.2464696765,
0.7985358834,
-0.5571156144,
0.096833989,
-0.0191515796,
-0.0078305053,
-0.0731115639,
0.256152004,
0.1645297855,
0.4753019512,
-0.069398284,
0.1705880016,
-0.0611202866,
-0.6471444964,
0.5333673358,
0.3568805456,
-0.0250099041,
-0.3322078586,
0.1031697392,
0.6965395808,
-0.2856750786,
-0.3042809367,
0.7266384959,
-0.2764790058,
-0.3434866369,
0.1453656107,
0.1534127742,
-0.2087325007,
0.295368582,
0.2085008025,
0.1775166988,
0.2016791254,
-0.4295780361,
0.6775423288,
0.2167711705,
-0.3534156382,
-0.0483859964,
0.5339568853,
0.2171343267,
0.2895853519,
0.469260931,
-0.0608304963,
-0.5067529082,
0.4792196751,
0.3106948435,
0.888676703,
-0.300103426,
0.656257391,
0.1151575297,
-0.1101941466,
-0.0905085951,
0.2387791276,
0.157464236,
-1.0888924599,
-0.4172634184,
-0.7888556719,
-0.5355860591,
0.0629415438,
-0.6529470682,
0.0212354921,
-0.4359711707,
-0.1515005827,
-0.0584478714,
0.0260632336,
-0.4993492961,
0.6373144388,
0.035388276,
0.0126755461,
-0.9366593361,
0.925626874,
0.7506285906,
-0.2282105535,
-0.402166903,
0.1591451615,
0.0888647363,
-0.6588120461,
0.304487884,
0.2387692034,
-0.5096565485,
0.0615720078,
-0.7628469467,
-0.543407321,
0.829474926,
0.4683588743,
-0.0677796826,
0.4696919918,
0.3110654056,
0.3665127754,
-0.8344635367,
-0.5645638108,
0.5934214592,
0.4777100682,
-0.0330298245,
-0.2609276175,
-0.1146295592,
-0.2225518972,
-0.1064054519,
0.217128545,
-0.5602647662,
0.9820227623,
0.051327493,
-0.1997802556,
-0.4701853395,
0.3775700033,
0.1717578769,
0.423832953,
0.6618018746,
0.4845791161,
1.0321882963,
-0.1419176608,
0.9309234619,
-0.0323101804,
0.7814534903,
0.8865028024,
-0.6414533257,
0.234454602,
0.0610732362,
0.322521925,
0.2338378429,
0.3805296123,
-0.2962919474,
0.7173817158,
-0.1030934602,
-0.3436170816,
-0.7462306023,
-0.678616643,
-0.2712517083,
0.5599919558,
0.3680633903,
-0.3579344451,
-0.2033248097,
0.4217426479,
-0.1226291358,
0.3480336666,
-0.1814721823,
0.6723822951,
-0.0466404147,
-0.2721797824,
0.5999218822,
0.0215183683,
0.5349111557,
-0.4114928842,
-0.1941788346,
0.027826013,
0.4241633117,
-0.1619446576,
-0.9615269899,
0.3751195669,
0.0586134456,
-0.2490035594,
-0.4447243214,
0.9036332965,
-0.408277005,
-0.3459601104,
0.4465386569,
0.3950482607,
-0.1918387115,
0.2249919921,
-0.7426452637,
-0.0360007957,
0.1609377563,
-0.0262357816,
0.2192175686,
0.4043684602,
-0.0771363154,
0.6055948138,
0.7740408182,
-0.3969333768,
-0.25595662,
0.0812580809,
1.009324789,
-0.7106643319,
-0.3137848377,
-0.6544155478,
0.3610162437,
-0.2970844805,
-0.4536877573,
0.5080736279,
0.508977592,
0.9485619068,
0.0608290955,
1.0171846151,
-0.1456716955,
0.2275564224,
-0.6482245922,
0.7185108662,
-0.6387766004,
-0.1466390491,
-0.0682169199,
-0.8527296185,
-0.5207518935,
0.8012301922,
-0.3825686574,
-0.0426491685,
0.460383743,
0.463698715,
-0.3056176901,
0.403342545,
0.5294190049,
-0.0509110913,
0.3391109407,
0.598885417,
0.6083844304,
-0.5756978989,
0.1824743301,
-0.3084174693,
0.0570707619,
0.0019865492,
-0.7096447349,
-0.7119252682,
-0.6507895589,
-0.3055616915,
-0.144419685,
0.2649587989,
0.7852004766,
0.6556795239,
-0.8060225844,
-0.048485104,
0.0963133574,
0.1312413961,
-0.2255408168,
-0.2085938752,
0.4576155245,
-0.2115181386,
-0.6384901404,
0.3001821339,
0.2240077108,
-0.1819308698,
0.0127604716,
-0.1584210694,
-0.5907513499,
0.2131072134,
0.547262013,
-0.1827595234,
-0.5501258373,
-0.632989943,
-0.3954586983,
-0.283757776,
0.2169634104,
0.8337305784,
-0.5956920981,
0.3855190277,
0.1432750672,
0.8925804496,
-0.0662598684,
0.4206901193,
0.7933716774,
-0.9390940666,
0.0652977303,
0.4653834105,
0.2132738531,
0.5113018155,
-0.6874071956,
0.6224925518,
0.3784244955,
-0.4549977183,
-0.30802387,
0.5223109722,
-0.7398589849,
-0.3768951893,
0.9972976446,
-0.1587769985,
-0.1263815016,
-0.4407694042,
0.1016027033,
0.2590924203,
-0.3841438293,
0.4545252323,
0.7451424599,
0.004708,
0.3757671714,
-0.3737732172,
0.7019085288,
0.4211623669,
-0.9112241864,
0.5898436904,
0.9490629435,
0.1631505489,
0.2163802236,
0.111274153,
-0.0846122205,
0.3915949464,
-0.1213670373,
0.1175923645,
0.1153340265,
-0.3785731196,
-0.5797470808,
0.2343831807,
-0.6915543079,
-0.0590232052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02138v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02138v3 | Geotechnical Parrot Tales (GPT): Harnessing Large Language Models in geotechnical engineering | 2023-04-04T21:47:41 | 2023-06-21T15:55:24 | Krishna Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, physics.geo-ph, I.2.7; J.2.6 | The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs), such as OpenAI's
ChatGPT, could revolutionize various industries, including geotechnical
engineering. However, GPT models can sometimes generate plausible-sounding but
false outputs, leading to hallucinations. In this article, we discuss the
importance of prompt engineering in mitigating these risks and harnessing the
full potential of GPT for geotechnical applications. We explore the challenges
and pitfalls associated with LLMs and highlight the role of context in ensuring
accurate and valuable responses. Furthermore, we examine the development of
context-specific search engines and the potential of LLMs to become a natural
interface for complex tasks, such as data analysis and design. We also develop
a unified interface using natural language to handle complex geotechnical
engineering tasks and data analysis. By integrating GPT into geotechnical
engineering workflows, professionals can streamline their work and develop
sustainable and resilient infrastructure systems for the future. | [
-0.284665972,
-1.1372741461,
0.819737494,
0.3736413717,
-0.1532353461,
0.0137549266,
-0.1209891587,
-0.4352285564,
0.0887817964,
0.0373822451,
-0.3748800755,
-0.1807276905,
-0.4992230535,
-0.0600399598,
-0.5586534739,
0.8679382801,
-0.356382668,
-0.422667712,
0.1140442342,
0.2652913332,
-0.8522202373,
-0.58180058,
-0.5933172107,
-0.1370505691,
0.1950013191,
-0.0290308241,
0.8618015647,
0.3290259838,
-0.0640455559,
0.2707145214,
-0.2222331166,
-0.1968566626,
-0.3275110722,
0.2709479332,
-0.398042649,
-0.0676554367,
0.1499069631,
0.0596361794,
0.2061661929,
0.8288728595,
-0.1213255525,
-0.0263739284,
0.4043251276,
0.3799014688,
-0.3725362122,
0.3794843853,
-0.2699918151,
0.1222488359,
-0.084111996,
-0.7404571176,
-0.0675915107,
-0.352304548,
0.2602933943,
-0.6163867116,
-0.0870713145,
0.0956299379,
0.5641449094,
0.2112171352,
-0.3558006585,
-0.5804721713,
-0.4483301044,
0.4278603494,
-0.2017237395,
0.3116479218,
0.2491001934,
0.5964192748,
-0.672526896,
-0.6137855649,
-0.401866138,
-0.3609855175,
0.0145469727,
0.066718623,
0.1204847768,
0.0049246149,
0.1287336797,
0.3496213257,
-0.8506361842,
0.1143648326,
-0.3621610999,
-0.4259037375,
0.3716948032,
0.1178309768,
0.6132914424,
-0.4460920691,
-0.4023259282,
0.0370212048,
-0.8427413106,
0.5796480775,
0.3668877482,
0.7220449448,
-0.1231036633,
0.3989859819,
-0.4000060558,
0.572083652,
-0.2144719362,
-0.1024042889,
0.0048198029,
-0.1525666416,
-0.2961087525,
0.4213372171,
0.6658696532,
-0.0606971718,
0.4468664825,
-0.4493106604,
-0.2042260766,
0.0986296684,
0.270165503,
-0.4502803087,
-0.1734382361,
0.2035956979,
-0.2772935629,
-0.5374522209,
0.1700750291,
-0.6854139566,
-0.7957737446,
-0.3645411134,
0.1629885882,
-0.1021881327,
-0.2818472385,
0.571644187,
-0.2095864713,
0.0992433056,
0.3850470781,
-0.6884385347,
-0.0320833176,
0.803339541,
0.9575542212,
0.5572901964,
-0.2938493192,
-0.9008414745,
0.1592214555,
-0.3805277348,
0.7748831511,
-0.6244022846,
-0.6699581742,
0.2582045794,
0.1111121625,
0.204501912,
0.0736937076,
0.7521152496,
-0.2633121908,
0.2775775492,
-0.2909806967,
0.0743466914,
-0.3612812459,
0.3216637671,
-0.3525496125,
0.9782009125,
0.1775466502,
-0.9295434952,
0.1750323325,
-0.5549084544,
-0.5588416457,
0.2887851894,
-0.2415071428,
0.2599925697,
0.2403490692,
0.4166063368,
0.2457347661,
-0.3264463842,
0.5646296144,
-0.1313354671,
-0.3611634672,
-0.1541673094,
-0.4791557491,
0.9379092455,
0.2189623863,
-0.5342058539,
-0.1154689342,
-0.161094144,
-0.1696594208,
0.0540950559,
-0.2795695364,
-0.2451751977,
0.1905771643,
0.0051205275,
0.3515177667,
0.1413720697,
-0.3503677845,
0.194047913,
-0.3576038778,
0.8113877177,
0.8640397787,
-0.0435016602,
0.1708318293,
-0.4344528019,
0.7283742428,
-0.3606345654,
-0.1283535659,
-0.2795652747,
-0.5332321525,
-0.0782326907,
0.1459059119,
0.0602696352,
0.7372943163,
-0.8458386064,
-0.1580506414,
-0.3082431555,
-0.5379185677,
-0.1567961127,
-0.010098327,
-0.0790547505,
0.7861790657,
0.2004853487,
-0.0495422594,
-0.545823276,
-0.4537424743,
-0.372905761,
-0.3498494625,
-0.1625211537,
0.2942474484,
0.0421582088,
-0.084157452,
1.357257247,
-0.1966518611,
0.0361698754,
-0.0676093847,
0.1939916015,
0.4997113943,
0.3007559478,
0.7979203463,
-1.0497238636,
-0.2631127238,
0.2239833325,
-0.851703167,
-0.2703296542,
-0.2992805839,
0.1831875592,
-0.1138364598,
0.4390678704,
-0.8708224893,
0.2528039515,
0.4116722345,
-0.2885777354,
0.8853936791,
0.0412629694,
0.2170795649,
-0.6008009315,
0.0190726034,
0.1882476807,
-0.4589148462,
-0.3655531108,
0.3232613206,
-0.0717654154,
-0.3901942074,
-0.6469926238,
0.6087968349,
-0.3795773983,
-0.0806001872,
-0.0684521943,
0.3296177387,
-0.2702638507,
-0.0160846487,
-0.1289020628,
1.405105114,
0.8743854761,
-0.7411125302,
0.6110975146,
0.411228925,
-0.1387074441,
0.2294531763,
-0.8103897572,
0.0525959246,
-0.0029734967,
0.2578259706,
-0.7344254255,
-0.4916192591,
0.2064932585,
-0.5698874593,
0.1727847755,
-0.3398003578,
-0.7265292406,
-0.825381577,
-0.6616892815,
-0.1242028996,
0.7047554851,
-0.8065772653,
0.2942552567,
0.3480759263,
-1.0013577938,
-0.4644857347,
-0.525408864,
0.5242345333,
-0.3745808303,
-0.815237999,
0.0017175652,
-0.135342747,
-0.1514829695,
-0.2622192502,
-0.3550229669,
-0.2631733716,
0.3331465125,
0.1571359038,
-0.1588087231,
-0.2715741694,
0.2691034079,
-0.0221560802,
-0.300113827,
0.3366699815,
-0.5671607852,
0.4843769073,
-0.3274451494,
-0.2382268012,
-0.1151402667,
0.2260133624,
0.4898812771,
-0.0067504803,
0.1834981591,
0.3000516593,
-0.3649077117,
0.2136659473,
-0.4135109186,
0.058387205,
-0.5545726418,
0.1026839018,
-0.4534228444,
-1.0993199348,
0.3313260972,
-0.4149918854,
-0.0452445336,
0.2952417135,
0.2538688481,
-0.2402000874,
0.8002036214,
0.8621141315,
-0.5280994177,
0.2640406787,
0.5110169649,
0.5383574367,
-0.4200905859,
0.2688840628,
-0.5670833588,
-0.0011264253,
-0.6221975088,
0.2543853521,
0.4834217727,
0.1859454364,
-0.3394863009,
0.2298352569,
-0.5785306096,
0.606969893,
0.3342104256,
0.0082595535,
0.2343079001,
0.1341491044,
-0.0848460793,
0.1285799593,
-0.6700022221,
-0.8799717426,
0.5455262661,
0.3261398971,
0.7033054829,
0.0985977873,
0.3462819159,
0.2753067613,
-0.0236978177,
-0.6986934543,
0.4213301837,
0.1518555731,
-0.2749296427,
-0.409358263,
-0.1853161752,
-0.8352639675,
0.1310786307,
-0.0658866391,
-0.8607566953,
-0.1685256511,
0.1067187786,
-0.5262340307,
0.3631511033,
-0.468511343,
0.5646904111,
-0.1281907856,
-0.2149765939,
0.0879561827,
-0.7323425412,
0.3927764893,
-0.0717606843,
0.6898961663,
0.3624269664,
0.2515722513,
0.1276324391,
-0.4790148139,
0.9973775148,
-0.1860355735,
-0.4256071746,
0.7063883543,
0.271296382,
0.7752794623,
0.5424483418,
-0.0241199806,
-0.0484016053,
-0.1835862249,
-0.3377179205,
-0.3510044813,
0.8930763602,
-0.6108612418,
-1.022741437,
-0.2984705567,
-0.4312960207,
-0.1521532983,
0.1111676916,
0.0722153187,
0.3902878463,
-0.0802035928,
-0.0465757176,
0.5612095594,
-0.4034107625,
0.8109847307,
-0.0687813908,
0.0780334622,
0.0281915087,
0.7261050344,
0.0265867524,
-0.2842248976,
0.1273108423,
0.3001522124,
-0.25977844,
-0.4881280065,
-0.3675247133,
0.0272813942,
-0.6855246425,
-0.1887839437,
-0.6787296534,
-0.1416321248,
-0.5423465967,
-0.7164812088,
0.1271952242,
-0.4010589421,
0.0187119022,
-0.4389426708,
0.347722888,
0.9807339907,
-0.1235736385,
0.1883544922,
-0.9994016886,
0.1014479473,
0.5518462658,
0.2624124289,
-0.365354687,
0.0420456529,
0.2268302143,
0.2570838034,
-0.2906178534,
-0.7668622732,
0.3189412951,
-0.2256969661,
0.6423371434,
0.1174468324,
-0.0202935338,
0.3371566236,
-0.6321339607,
1.0863898993,
-0.0238121636,
-0.9077839851,
0.6964690089,
-0.9237480164,
-0.0033794031,
0.1146657094,
0.5053642988,
-0.8914524317,
-0.1723338962,
-0.2837102413,
-0.9428660274,
0.2309375554,
0.0258787982,
0.2238663882,
-0.2117677182,
0.218612656,
0.3357109725,
0.1121858954,
-0.7784131765,
0.4510177672,
-0.4771557152,
0.0135348774,
0.0312614143,
-0.45724684,
-0.1315429956,
0.2779837251,
0.4226135314,
-0.3533624411,
0.0549711585,
0.3391259611,
-0.5448664427,
0.1523644775,
0.5450538397,
0.7969864607,
0.8157126307,
0.0148850996,
0.0753940493,
0.2576631606,
-0.6622180939,
0.0264415294,
0.1296354979,
-0.0497630723,
-0.060998641,
0.4061830938,
0.3664670885,
0.2734808624,
-0.6367620826,
0.4810347259,
0.1556891948,
-0.0276384093,
-0.2900921702,
-0.1064269617,
0.1159920245,
0.2630334198,
0.608202517,
-0.2260787338,
0.3870956302,
-0.2987389266,
0.0503943749,
0.1508070678,
-0.4738320708,
-0.4242848456,
0.6871199012,
0.3585738838,
-0.1318817288,
0.5626527667,
-0.0625910312,
-0.4932944477,
0.7526412606,
0.420602113,
0.9036049843,
-0.1189159751,
0.1340373755,
0.1831553131,
0.5993763208,
-0.0844524577,
0.077853553,
0.1054180861,
-0.2535711825,
-0.5951728821,
-0.510964632,
-0.1733289659,
0.0883463547,
-0.0494291261,
0.4035926461,
-0.6360173821,
0.1391684413,
-0.5957292318,
-0.2268730998,
-0.5557569265,
0.0996740237,
0.1509120464,
1.2478728294,
-0.8672441244,
0.1224190295,
1.0381253958,
-0.5308235884,
-0.7443044186,
0.0823192,
0.2823243141,
-0.5244270563,
0.8006459475,
0.4485979378,
-0.0016122749,
-0.1552783698,
-0.5953095555,
-0.6009320617,
1.0865712166,
0.2219012231,
-0.3872946501,
-0.2792947888,
0.1114220098,
0.1496517062,
-0.0667096004,
0.2064422965,
0.2191739976,
0.5744342804,
-0.2677743435,
-1.3707568645,
0.2848079801,
-0.0573329479,
0.0926746503,
-0.0161909536,
-0.4306817949,
0.8899537325,
-0.0923200473,
-0.5421165824,
0.0332966074,
0.4259067178,
0.3568549454,
0.2320896834,
0.4739397764,
0.2263493538,
0.8177146912,
-0.0899629742,
1.4046550989,
-0.4106842875,
0.2989490926,
0.7700117826,
-0.0599923991,
0.4423461258,
0.4335332811,
-0.3365099728,
0.2228624374,
1.1254352331,
0.5749920607,
0.4495030046,
0.0200897176,
-0.2150277644,
-0.2122023255,
-0.2265332639,
-0.9183033109,
0.2918812037,
0.2729253769,
0.3727719784,
-0.6281403899,
0.1045461819,
-0.024450276,
0.0923388153,
-0.40948686,
0.2967808545,
0.1209219173,
-0.0693617463,
0.1521372944,
-0.3201402128,
0.7393462658,
-0.4748502374,
-0.1216322333,
-0.2342461348,
-0.4683243036,
-0.1754982173,
-0.8430559039,
0.3096928298,
-0.0468125157,
-0.1635369658,
-0.5525478125,
0.7494843602,
0.094140254,
-0.0728590116,
0.1788466722,
0.3557917476,
0.0364915244,
-0.3695419431,
-0.3080826104,
-0.2709745765,
-0.4465197027,
-0.4620332122,
0.2270486355,
0.9229815006,
-0.3537730277,
0.9131709933,
0.7738090158,
0.0702957883,
-0.0937585458,
-0.1030567884,
1.3946676254,
-0.850562036,
-1.006337285,
-0.6731689572,
0.6709965467,
0.0450756997,
-0.0891351402,
0.4029210508,
0.2785151601,
0.5701121092,
-0.1065175831,
1.199934721,
-0.1760976166,
0.4957365692,
-0.6927912831,
0.7360758781,
-0.0547321513,
0.2492469102,
-0.322594136,
-0.8875514269,
-0.1416905373,
0.4101522565,
-0.3395059109,
0.1523009986,
0.7948544621,
0.3941391408,
-0.1554151177,
0.2794954181,
0.15792422,
0.3750972152,
0.6062064171,
0.7358577847,
1.1353689432,
-0.2123850584,
0.4944928885,
0.2772544622,
-0.3930777609,
-0.1846901029,
-1.3204344511,
-0.7293663621,
-0.2028190643,
0.0072617354,
0.0234193541,
0.2413811982,
0.6550939083,
0.5426098704,
-0.651832819,
0.0438456126,
-0.2560999691,
0.0497287139,
0.1544038802,
-0.3161284029,
0.0356489532,
-0.8190725446,
-0.3336849511,
0.9017369747,
0.4056429267,
0.111280039,
-0.2186161578,
-0.0190785266,
0.0027198759,
-0.263974607,
0.6609299779,
0.5830671191,
-0.5768767595,
-0.7576323152,
-0.0554226488,
-0.0615194291,
-0.0335424803,
0.9457756281,
-1.1407971382,
0.1674582511,
0.5546401143,
1.1487582922,
0.1275518686,
-0.1279422641,
0.7614676952,
-0.6828880906,
0.5056502223,
-0.0006591378,
0.5445001721,
0.3973659873,
-0.8793933988,
0.8589800596,
0.2403952777,
-0.4737729132,
-0.5964493752,
0.2473642975,
-0.620149076,
-0.2627500892,
0.9371359944,
0.015656352,
-0.0032761362,
-0.3444465101,
-0.4456760287,
-0.1287611127,
-0.111297898,
0.7978326678,
1.0605851412,
0.1621591449,
-0.2603121996,
-1.1943622828,
0.4172049165,
0.2074674368,
-0.7150653005,
-0.1168452576,
0.5762121081,
0.4321053624,
0.0383165367,
0.60521245,
-0.016313104,
0.3521123827,
-0.0782942027,
-0.1183275506,
-0.2489979118,
-0.4240985513,
-0.4144532979,
0.3489476442,
0.0446081795,
0.1812392771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02080v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02080v1 | Scalable and Accurate Self-supervised Multimodal Representation Learning without Aligned Video and Text Data | 2023-04-04T19:11:05 | 2023-04-04T19:11:05 | Vladislav Lialin, Stephen Rawls, David Chan, Shalini Ghosh, Anna Rumshisky, Wael Hamza | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Scaling up weakly-supervised datasets has shown to be highly effective in the
image-text domain and has contributed to most of the recent state-of-the-art
computer vision and multimodal neural networks. However, existing large-scale
video-text datasets and mining techniques suffer from several limitations, such
as the scarcity of aligned data, the lack of diversity in the data, and the
difficulty of collecting aligned data. Currently popular video-text data mining
approach via automatic speech recognition (ASR) used in HowTo100M provides
low-quality captions that often do not refer to the video content. Other mining
approaches do not provide proper language descriptions (video tags) and are
biased toward short clips (alt text). In this work, we show how recent advances
in image captioning allow us to pre-train high-quality video models without any
parallel video-text data. We pre-train several video captioning models that are
based on an OPT language model and a TimeSformer visual backbone. We fine-tune
these networks on several video captioning datasets. First, we demonstrate that
image captioning pseudolabels work better for pre-training than the existing
HowTo100M ASR captions. Second, we show that pre-training on both images and
videos produces a significantly better network (+4 CIDER on MSR-VTT) than
pre-training on a single modality. Our methods are complementary to the
existing pre-training or data mining approaches and can be used in a variety of
settings. Given the efficacy of the pseudolabeling method, we are planning to
publicly release the generated captions. | [
-0.4397396743,
-0.1656487286,
0.2396964878,
0.1660144627,
-0.3719869256,
-0.0270281024,
-0.3260064125,
-0.0718937069,
0.3937069774,
0.4083994329,
-0.5792657733,
-0.2809090912,
-0.7078350186,
0.1469313204,
-0.3053405881,
1.0148285627,
-0.0492695831,
0.4349519908,
-0.58059901,
-0.5563700795,
-0.2104653865,
-0.4973427057,
-0.1489682198,
-0.095551081,
0.3320993185,
0.4335189164,
0.5408471227,
0.9712999463,
0.5420436859,
0.3792588115,
0.4527556896,
0.2825667858,
-0.1989420801,
-0.2279093862,
0.1688502878,
-0.2880530655,
-0.2088627219,
0.1074613035,
0.6684773564,
0.387003839,
0.048311092,
0.2469626665,
-0.1089790389,
0.6263936162,
-0.4955981076,
0.4460067451,
-0.5074974298,
0.1599709243,
-0.3226679564,
-0.3695821166,
-0.2255142927,
0.096685119,
0.1179537177,
-0.5568792224,
0.2573122084,
0.2150858343,
0.839871347,
0.5741147399,
-0.4636217058,
-0.2399972528,
-0.5509342551,
0.9666663408,
-0.4788502157,
0.4044558406,
0.3413021266,
0.4632224441,
0.3317093253,
-0.8107125163,
-0.6549529433,
-0.202296719,
-0.2330187708,
0.154886961,
-0.062325906,
0.1654396355,
0.3172569275,
0.58781147,
-0.5505905151,
0.049211856,
-0.4032843709,
-0.3897024989,
0.4506044686,
-0.0669736937,
0.2403870821,
-0.5995554924,
-0.6613924503,
-0.4156192243,
-0.4933696985,
0.0090283323,
0.1156036109,
0.1566404104,
-0.1390548646,
0.7152594924,
-0.1095588431,
0.5783383846,
0.0175001305,
-0.1049912497,
0.3876845539,
-0.5357843637,
-0.3182603419,
0.0199481864,
1.2045048475,
0.4809468687,
0.4409386516,
-0.080498524,
-0.206094116,
0.0388463959,
0.1766780764,
-0.6977843642,
-0.4785438776,
-0.0917089581,
-0.5837133527,
0.0232800338,
0.0987043977,
-0.7523627281,
-0.0406119749,
-0.5666933656,
0.8783811331,
-0.2510052323,
-0.0137861716,
-0.3749577105,
-0.0320242904,
0.1790623665,
0.1216394305,
-0.8349782825,
0.3411154151,
-0.2166717798,
0.8280369043,
-0.1327878535,
-0.2826399505,
-0.6391651034,
0.3307484686,
-0.3381267488,
0.7358068228,
-0.3009678423,
0.1111028865,
-0.134498477,
0.1471583396,
0.0309073031,
-0.5002556443,
0.2185296118,
-0.4629449248,
0.3036545217,
-0.1207728982,
-0.4615242779,
-0.0477257185,
0.2456511557,
-0.8309800625,
0.6921291947,
-0.4220702052,
-0.7380188107,
0.4000931978,
-0.6423540711,
-0.5392757654,
-0.1022145376,
-0.4123441875,
-0.6800362468,
-0.1149939969,
0.7897750735,
0.719288528,
-0.146910429,
0.2018732727,
-0.259493202,
-0.1532537639,
0.0540730879,
-0.6129270792,
0.2077075094,
0.3017447293,
-0.288293004,
0.2190813273,
-0.625110805,
0.1462454647,
-0.022713881,
0.0476322472,
0.0162688885,
-0.0359665193,
0.1691388637,
0.2587832212,
0.3276270628,
-0.3938452005,
-0.0815490112,
-0.1536371261,
0.6449850798,
0.6921228766,
-0.2948927879,
0.8034407496,
-0.2395679951,
0.4320901632,
0.0627580509,
0.1690548211,
-0.7326382995,
-0.127958402,
-0.7207895517,
-0.3966443539,
0.3161486685,
0.3437907398,
-1.1649923325,
0.2246136814,
-0.5201132894,
-0.4171811044,
-0.3854907453,
0.4318475127,
0.3930116892,
0.3328443766,
0.7000169158,
-0.4065437913,
-0.5918440223,
-1.0132540464,
0.0238631442,
-0.0298467949,
0.038754534,
0.4068000317,
0.1549042612,
-0.215545699,
1.0320242643,
-0.433834374,
-0.8080305457,
-0.1482114047,
0.4414562583,
-0.0091136517,
0.5480186939,
0.4262408316,
-1.1523096561,
-0.5569788218,
-0.1141345128,
-0.8653820753,
0.2343548089,
-0.2233677804,
0.4555039704,
-0.0561333001,
0.7317357063,
-0.4982978702,
0.1298067868,
0.6590461135,
0.4301618636,
0.3064095676,
-0.4653197527,
0.3682485223,
-0.9923248887,
-0.2274594456,
0.2523103952,
-0.5481253862,
-0.3777890801,
-0.3821392655,
0.2373638749,
-0.3916141689,
-0.3188859224,
0.3158786595,
-0.7686305046,
-0.1221851557,
-0.2549189925,
-0.1908962727,
-0.1235262901,
0.5744342208,
0.3645275831,
0.8234886527,
0.8908494711,
-0.5337091684,
0.5212621093,
0.1436727792,
-0.2113632262,
0.4825207293,
-0.5534204245,
-0.1283406913,
-0.4304552376,
0.2562768757,
-1.0684936047,
-0.5552603006,
-0.0139539456,
-0.5550045967,
0.558821559,
-0.2884498835,
-0.4586314559,
-0.4274240732,
-0.2757816315,
0.5516067147,
0.4424232841,
-0.6891821027,
0.6216496229,
0.3002722561,
-0.0167536978,
-0.5974994302,
-0.7080268264,
0.2116446942,
-0.4165302217,
-0.4201619029,
0.3082964122,
-0.0401385538,
0.3686824441,
-0.0452770516,
-0.2325123996,
-0.330637604,
-0.5547803044,
0.3046262562,
0.0782353953,
-0.1059603021,
0.4855505526,
-0.0551633798,
-0.1277751625,
-0.060382098,
-0.2244859189,
0.1917113811,
-0.2291881442,
-0.168647185,
-0.6444347501,
0.2273745984,
0.5967702866,
-0.5138226151,
0.4545559585,
0.8536784053,
-0.3265682161,
0.0128471348,
-0.6848223805,
-0.303209573,
-0.4905592203,
0.3317410648,
-0.1429121196,
-0.9064861536,
0.1136016771,
-0.1584232152,
-0.3379015028,
0.3432937562,
0.3098145723,
-0.6229333878,
0.932428956,
0.4952661693,
-0.0110786129,
0.722889483,
-0.2259782106,
0.0683195442,
-0.3615971506,
-0.2031947523,
-0.1151875257,
-0.2185495198,
-0.6795579195,
-0.5796934366,
0.4250791073,
-0.1894379258,
-0.0048727104,
0.4733755589,
-0.3128494024,
0.4727473259,
0.4485192895,
0.1629461348,
0.1485619843,
0.4242581427,
0.4005680084,
-0.3729396462,
-0.8199778795,
-0.3949950635,
1.2850979567,
0.2813757658,
0.993381381,
-0.1828924716,
0.7057886124,
0.585709691,
0.2547425032,
-0.590788126,
0.4015619755,
-0.3982182145,
-0.6632679105,
-0.382186681,
-0.8434646726,
-0.7885304093,
-0.0202974919,
-0.4427669346,
-0.2225453556,
-0.0479424223,
0.509047091,
-0.2868912816,
0.1851777583,
-1.0447057486,
1.0152697563,
-0.5371826291,
-0.2319366783,
-0.0094330553,
-0.9301806688,
0.0362893902,
-0.032955654,
0.4303826094,
0.1900303513,
0.1324350685,
0.8735225201,
-0.5098339915,
0.8208403587,
-0.2726409137,
0.3415777385,
0.5677456856,
-0.2576651573,
0.281095475,
-0.1149235889,
0.6637093425,
0.2397626489,
0.1376510113,
-0.4714408517,
-0.6386162043,
0.6688594818,
-0.8513047695,
-0.393979758,
-0.3735277653,
-0.349134326,
-0.199125573,
0.2366498411,
0.363484621,
0.6976459026,
0.2026071846,
0.4393479526,
0.7297117114,
-0.1111240461,
0.7034864426,
-0.033692766,
0.1491394639,
-0.8665118814,
1.2530243397,
0.3189258873,
0.1384291351,
0.5335717201,
0.0385751128,
-0.5798608661,
-0.3684679866,
-0.562195003,
0.2305238545,
-0.7109008431,
-0.4461900592,
-0.6380517483,
-0.0667532384,
-0.4669398367,
0.0919278562,
-0.6371869445,
-0.3016068637,
-0.3784544468,
-0.1137411818,
0.2443618774,
0.5642554164,
-0.1499830335,
0.6550595164,
-0.8842808604,
0.5239673257,
0.7250620127,
0.314368993,
-0.1020356491,
-0.4156472385,
-0.3808860183,
-0.072294794,
-0.2277666032,
-0.6563420892,
0.4331426322,
0.5093719363,
0.4422031641,
0.5456423759,
-0.0630867183,
0.9906030297,
-0.6140239835,
0.7373348475,
0.6358271241,
-0.8702353239,
0.5098018646,
-0.2970031798,
0.1328756809,
0.4196065664,
0.6861715913,
-0.0851458162,
0.2443364114,
-0.4797927737,
-0.5912210941,
0.6956028342,
0.3625835478,
0.4192538559,
0.1124496013,
0.1004661694,
0.0825592801,
0.3577233553,
-1.3908578157,
-0.3068431914,
-0.9959866405,
-0.5060396791,
-0.4657540619,
-0.0260945372,
0.0561477505,
-0.2629621029,
0.3050225079,
-0.3795367777,
0.1879466176,
0.2316718847,
-0.4323344529,
0.0196431726,
0.1700119525,
0.1994528919,
0.356744349,
-0.1564285308,
0.4839859307,
0.0898803324,
-0.1762665361,
0.3759284616,
0.186479643,
0.264069885,
-0.0600094758,
0.5871200562,
0.6851409674,
0.2122436762,
-0.7938321829,
0.8292006254,
0.0656286255,
-0.1780235916,
-0.3657405674,
-0.2166192383,
-0.2749757469,
0.1344345361,
0.4545638561,
0.2138357311,
0.1960704774,
-0.5481039286,
0.3648125231,
0.4022877216,
-0.701985538,
-0.2000194788,
0.6813222766,
0.0031099159,
0.1454592347,
0.4883135855,
-0.0889319852,
-0.316937536,
0.4266477227,
0.2304350734,
0.3984860182,
-0.1201343685,
0.3840877712,
0.4200795591,
0.3229283392,
-0.2883113623,
-0.1351816505,
-0.5035257936,
-0.578359127,
-0.6657298207,
-0.4029298127,
-0.0912148729,
-0.0057015354,
-0.6785038114,
0.1618010104,
-0.3158527613,
-0.2424309403,
-0.1526657939,
-0.2923244536,
-0.5671668649,
0.6129156947,
0.2285535634,
0.4173227847,
-1.0221486092,
0.8214363456,
0.8725737333,
-0.5226204395,
-0.6320070028,
-0.2060310841,
-0.3227971196,
-0.5156015158,
0.6541175246,
0.4804478586,
0.1324396729,
-0.0022677975,
-0.761608541,
-0.8303765655,
1.0552057028,
0.2960852385,
-0.5454926491,
-0.0183400474,
0.2552364469,
0.5073191524,
-0.3695963621,
0.1381020695,
-0.1253472269,
0.2565757036,
0.3390420675,
-0.7219806314,
-0.3172108531,
-0.2078437656,
-0.0823656172,
0.0016072249,
-0.6066526771,
0.7219240665,
-0.0263632201,
-0.0809288472,
-0.051129438,
0.9704127312,
-0.1444215626,
0.4494307041,
0.6405101418,
0.516849637,
0.3440154195,
-0.0525719076,
0.9444758296,
0.2386215031,
0.3148033023,
1.21103549,
0.1098081023,
0.5335375667,
0.5989086032,
-0.0379342139,
0.279274404,
0.5574797988,
-0.1909846812,
0.7224373221,
-0.1313487738,
0.1451035142,
-0.9160733223,
-0.1301859319,
-0.1676315367,
0.6246317029,
0.0488156565,
-0.4253985584,
-0.2229595333,
0.3482744098,
-0.4425660968,
0.3073753715,
-0.5339949131,
0.7427892089,
0.1187885478,
-0.336292237,
0.3305606842,
-0.2693189383,
0.7439194322,
-0.6873064637,
0.0112278154,
-0.0379471965,
-0.0705772042,
-0.3093465567,
-0.5553438663,
0.093098551,
0.0617998205,
-0.2642991543,
-0.3883987367,
0.5663007498,
-0.6031121016,
-0.4984519184,
0.1305229962,
0.4439299107,
0.1091574058,
-0.1468387693,
-0.4966746867,
-0.1023712382,
-0.139672339,
0.0675996542,
0.2614406943,
0.4674803317,
-0.1341220886,
0.6936973929,
0.4849485159,
-0.0773191452,
0.1424015909,
0.0607946627,
0.9112681746,
-0.5480826497,
-0.3366360366,
-0.7516203523,
0.365292877,
-0.0358982496,
0.3053380847,
0.8655543327,
0.5107178092,
0.787055254,
-0.2027756274,
0.510843277,
0.0020990826,
0.1120636165,
-0.6883254647,
0.5320551395,
-0.7915888429,
-0.1750341505,
-0.4717915058,
-1.0041630268,
-0.4006601572,
0.5938848257,
-0.3125084639,
0.1951887012,
0.4421261549,
0.671163857,
-0.2562782466,
-0.1124518737,
0.3706614673,
0.0876484364,
0.2174854577,
0.2546974719,
0.8761811852,
-0.5900086761,
1.0391767025,
-0.2323994637,
-0.2833918631,
0.1539332569,
-0.8471130133,
-1.1568604708,
-0.7126472592,
-0.3347488642,
0.1438967139,
-0.131186381,
0.8493688703,
1.1782951355,
-0.6853633523,
-0.2124853879,
0.1703508198,
-0.2169169635,
-0.1023904756,
-0.1425727308,
0.415682286,
-0.3148328364,
-0.5912879705,
0.2533689141,
0.2243814766,
0.2710347176,
-0.1727606058,
-0.2181619108,
-0.0281046033,
-0.162770018,
0.566663146,
0.2942979336,
-0.4268544912,
-0.1511034966,
-0.0806483999,
0.2544288039,
0.436539799,
0.6843101978,
-0.6155751348,
0.8080151677,
0.0708187073,
0.520644486,
0.9118242264,
0.1683131158,
0.3621580601,
-0.9807573557,
0.1704803556,
0.0638745576,
0.3696686625,
0.6225892901,
-0.0072866394,
0.0549196191,
0.2518967986,
-0.4091056585,
-0.5005688071,
0.0935799479,
-1.1208722591,
-0.055624824,
0.8144524693,
-0.1746808589,
-0.1967742741,
0.2180473357,
-0.1815327257,
0.2091892362,
-0.3700315952,
0.629322648,
0.5767210126,
0.0178344436,
-0.6034116745,
-0.127501145,
0.5181407332,
0.3791294992,
-0.6523007751,
-0.1107866988,
0.5814560056,
0.1781438589,
0.2810764015,
0.4367624521,
-0.2588836849,
0.1786148399,
-0.3259229064,
0.1324919462,
-0.2621172965,
-0.5955091715,
-0.3482180834,
0.3929454386,
-0.0908123031,
-0.3784421086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02034v1 | Effective Theory of Transformers at Initialization | 2023-04-04T18:00:01 | 2023-04-04T18:00:01 | Emily Dinan, Sho Yaida, Susan Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, hep-th, stat.ML | We perform an effective-theory analysis of forward-backward signal
propagation in wide and deep Transformers, i.e., residual neural networks with
multi-head self-attention blocks and multilayer perceptron blocks. This
analysis suggests particular width scalings of initialization and training
hyperparameters for these models. We then take up such suggestions, training
Vision and Language Transformers in practical setups. | [
-0.6903778315,
-0.6474103928,
0.3376719654,
0.2836906314,
-0.0796559006,
-0.3567998409,
-0.3884758055,
-0.2162234783,
-0.0338216498,
0.4222690463,
-0.3717277944,
0.1878969222,
-0.616400063,
-0.2510295212,
-1.0269701481,
0.9424603581,
0.1567945778,
0.0537716374,
0.3237721026,
-0.1986130923,
-0.4189606011,
-0.3196787238,
-0.7371042371,
-0.4979042709,
0.6757408977,
0.3221811056,
0.9146584868,
0.4830523431,
0.6293653846,
0.3463627696,
-0.0228850376,
-0.4798244536,
-0.5803468227,
0.1312260032,
-0.1896344423,
-0.277448684,
-0.1380949616,
-0.0337118879,
0.9803982973,
0.9614605904,
-0.2849195302,
0.1089563072,
0.1146973595,
0.4827136397,
-0.514629662,
-0.1791908294,
-0.4714431465,
0.3610662222,
0.2876012325,
-0.308193922,
-0.4318853617,
-0.0612394512,
0.5571611524,
-0.4804218113,
0.4244003296,
-0.4480646253,
0.9608102441,
0.0627410486,
-0.5188324451,
0.2586817145,
-1.2555232048,
0.9170874357,
-0.2316169292,
1.0814589262,
0.053913597,
0.6043246388,
-0.0602845401,
-1.2080786228,
-0.3819422126,
-0.0254202727,
-0.3092550337,
0.2580285668,
-0.3044050634,
0.3906098306,
0.5904886723,
0.6240895391,
-0.1358024925,
0.0702926219,
-0.5907303095,
-0.0095948493,
0.318341136,
0.0383978114,
0.0677898154,
0.1862370819,
-0.5212958455,
0.0778780505,
-0.5762316585,
-0.2345866263,
0.4257446527,
0.1352125406,
-0.306645751,
0.2852137983,
-0.1687879264,
0.8389946222,
0.4270782769,
0.0414653607,
-0.0215763841,
-0.459079951,
-0.4571030438,
-0.2470315993,
0.5037152171,
0.0807443038,
0.4879330695,
-0.4338367581,
-0.1847099066,
0.2069656253,
0.9250231981,
-0.8266106248,
-0.2350587994,
0.0941076204,
-0.6909409165,
-0.4820418358,
-0.1069110408,
-0.6650232077,
0.0015806039,
-0.7652344108,
0.6231169105,
-0.2799035907,
-0.3069212437,
-0.0930997208,
0.0376959592,
0.5947195292,
-0.2777428925,
-1.0932517052,
0.5274460912,
0.2726879418,
0.3207908273,
0.0152824,
-0.4569283426,
-0.0638457462,
0.0602668822,
-0.2555283308,
0.6531638503,
-0.0883845463,
-0.0586676598,
0.0997890085,
0.1036219746,
0.116560474,
-0.1198955774,
0.4757840633,
-0.553964138,
0.0468650535,
0.2868141234,
-0.3427073359,
-0.2790460587,
0.0707352459,
-0.6229790449,
0.5993579626,
0.3035007417,
-0.5309744477,
0.5151432157,
-0.6541474462,
-0.6972252727,
-0.2986755669,
-0.1018949673,
-0.4461216331,
0.3585126698,
0.0888570249,
0.5394580364,
-0.0378224663,
0.2724172473,
0.1676049978,
-0.4167698324,
0.2598207593,
-0.7663428187,
0.9648893476,
0.2158897966,
-0.5596263409,
0.2899832726,
-1.1452805996,
-0.1402156949,
0.0352548473,
0.1673471481,
0.0515085571,
-0.1097477302,
-0.1349798441,
0.0420271382,
-0.2589821815,
-0.4460571706,
0.004561123,
-0.4930749536,
0.3284038603,
0.6225615144,
0.067554757,
0.6105237603,
0.2726615071,
0.2421571016,
-0.2547618449,
0.6335983276,
-0.5755566955,
-0.3160645962,
-1.1984177828,
-0.1577114165,
0.1501137167,
0.2022059709,
-0.1832596064,
0.5507146716,
-0.0428076461,
-0.4246774614,
0.0412495434,
-0.169636026,
0.1905222535,
0.450836271,
0.4930967391,
-0.4569968879,
-0.6411298513,
-1.2180914879,
-0.0886584669,
0.1054407507,
-0.0499289073,
-0.1037902758,
0.2417781502,
-0.3351214528,
0.8322636485,
-0.5639932156,
-0.0891072005,
-0.2964469194,
-0.0076646013,
0.4265820086,
0.6231089234,
0.4992927313,
-0.7397065759,
-0.3609260321,
-0.1478846222,
-0.7782574296,
0.3071608841,
-0.0859240443,
-0.1930360198,
-0.2395778298,
0.3137895763,
-0.5028219819,
0.6930989027,
0.4038969278,
-0.2757098973,
0.332536906,
-0.0384944156,
-0.2730475366,
-1.0096193552,
0.1436403096,
0.3699317873,
-0.0315384641,
-1.1391868591,
0.2868674099,
0.2656571567,
-0.235514164,
-0.3222284913,
0.3150413036,
-0.5107274055,
-0.151919201,
-0.3582070172,
0.0131916236,
-0.2437923104,
0.5843081474,
-0.0098156147,
0.3530304134,
0.7162123322,
-0.8337184191,
0.4542723298,
0.1237588227,
-0.0048234533,
0.9531064034,
-0.6377125978,
-0.052827742,
-0.2234370857,
0.0591531955,
-1.3101305962,
-0.0584802255,
0.2281326056,
-0.4398640096,
0.6500525475,
-0.2206276655,
0.0440855958,
-0.7143517733,
0.0452963822,
0.7581795454,
0.722758472,
-0.8423295617,
0.8074880838,
0.1385925412,
0.4957114756,
-0.7466968298,
-0.6523602009,
-0.1471818089,
-0.2128191888,
-0.4608380198,
0.2353031486,
0.262940377,
-0.2090439498,
-0.0277801137,
0.0022570956,
-0.4388508499,
0.2791748941,
0.1633737534,
-0.020172568,
-0.3225996494,
0.0816117153,
-0.0991126075,
-0.4654623568,
0.1764501184,
-0.3513684869,
0.4261559844,
-0.2181514353,
-0.1410084963,
-0.6717894077,
-0.0376750492,
0.4807748199,
-0.290250659,
0.5392192602,
0.7873545289,
-0.4317548275,
-0.0504882485,
-0.6986678243,
-0.8015856743,
-0.5261837244,
0.4509557784,
-0.3897527456,
-0.3063147068,
0.5509347916,
0.1216406524,
0.0041005868,
0.805871129,
0.5624313951,
0.1334118992,
0.8815537095,
1.0715874434,
0.08921507,
0.6240653396,
-0.7287473679,
0.3169568777,
-0.8950612545,
-0.1990422606,
-0.1815033108,
-0.5298117995,
-0.3066446781,
0.1585104316,
0.133104071,
0.1680772007,
-0.569554925,
0.5697183609,
-0.6263529062,
0.4611095786,
0.5342119932,
0.0428179502,
0.0746379718,
0.256794095,
-0.2285160869,
0.0862619877,
-0.8452618122,
-0.0359635651,
1.1324244738,
0.8154250979,
0.8031653166,
-0.2376465797,
0.4280200303,
-0.3990196884,
0.4399873018,
-1.0293269157,
0.1818710119,
0.1151942387,
-0.764312923,
-0.6198016405,
-0.1248108149,
-1.1833145618,
0.2054450512,
-0.3623873889,
-0.7670769095,
0.4266744852,
0.2941617668,
-0.516941011,
0.4898918569,
-0.5740207434,
0.7866833806,
-0.4072044194,
-0.2158455253,
-0.3677566051,
-0.8060523868,
0.4009082615,
-0.0762591958,
-0.3040675521,
0.3198655844,
0.1152238026,
0.7959491014,
0.1436792463,
0.9428751469,
-0.2687531114,
-0.2114182711,
0.6340867877,
-0.0190112218,
0.2448579967,
0.0044900649,
0.4011763632,
0.3173650503,
-0.5574560761,
-0.3224446177,
-0.7157356143,
0.3190391064,
-0.5943465829,
-0.1831664592,
-0.1477057338,
-0.3799409866,
-0.2798457444,
0.5147438645,
0.4330874383,
0.7628376484,
-0.2610655129,
0.2958639264,
0.6861513257,
-0.0820581317,
0.5378047228,
0.4602479339,
-0.1812330335,
-0.4262369275,
0.6771351099,
0.2249520868,
0.191781491,
0.0082473718,
0.3379316628,
-0.0947775766,
-0.34666574,
-0.3929391801,
0.0581709668,
-0.8114592433,
-0.3038576543,
-0.4111151993,
-0.7041372657,
0.1834296286,
0.0567024238,
-0.8605566621,
-0.5128940344,
0.0301845316,
-0.1374838501,
-0.0856659189,
0.8835312724,
-0.1259347498,
0.8152179122,
-0.5520982742,
0.3768848777,
0.3690682352,
0.957857728,
0.5905910134,
-0.7038897872,
-0.7464958429,
-0.0866429359,
-0.7108100057,
-0.5208693743,
0.0016205072,
-0.1580448449,
1.0610198975,
0.9609541297,
-0.5437275171,
0.3552982509,
-0.6045331955,
0.7963863015,
0.7563391328,
-0.7460042238,
0.2762784958,
-0.2247768492,
0.2270301729,
0.2603295445,
0.5890263915,
-0.4580256343,
-0.2410626858,
-0.8167288899,
-0.7036052942,
0.351764977,
0.42897892,
0.262026608,
0.0585199594,
0.5323655009,
0.4208397567,
0.0603324138,
-0.5185577273,
-0.7604304552,
-0.5146692991,
-0.0804502368,
-0.1144150719,
-0.448887676,
-0.22019656,
-0.5799875259,
0.2750422657,
0.039009586,
0.9677404761,
0.0927254632,
0.0945343599,
-0.2655440569,
0.0123414649,
0.8026151657,
1.1112781763,
-0.0158590637,
0.2968853414,
0.2773579955,
-0.4380006492,
0.4258871078,
-0.0693134815,
0.0527460277,
-0.3402704,
0.3932784498,
0.8035598397,
0.3466140926,
0.225275442,
0.4460526407,
-0.1997680217,
-0.1115682423,
-0.3604265451,
-0.1471354514,
-0.302087307,
0.2719743252,
0.5427677631,
0.1722673923,
0.071266219,
-0.4035099447,
0.6458311677,
0.2781009376,
-0.7926811576,
-0.6035274267,
0.5480849743,
0.4287111759,
-0.3035601377,
0.9478898644,
0.515422225,
-0.7379630208,
0.6566253304,
0.817484498,
1.1859954596,
-0.3813833594,
-0.0461505055,
0.500890851,
0.3008473217,
-0.203957364,
-0.0313930809,
0.0485131927,
-0.9283909202,
-0.8738878965,
-0.3168590963,
-0.0060012001,
0.0424221531,
-0.6869697571,
0.2252632827,
-0.316608727,
-0.3619255126,
0.0675385967,
-0.440777868,
-0.8255165219,
0.5436022878,
0.057542637,
0.7057973146,
-0.5970740914,
0.60345155,
0.2832847834,
-0.3846000433,
-0.9636409879,
-0.0358474404,
-0.5027609468,
-0.8292092681,
0.9781422019,
-0.0225756485,
-0.0268091001,
0.1784055084,
-0.4774663448,
-1.1900045872,
0.7432378531,
0.3274072111,
-0.5180912018,
0.1841482222,
-0.1800294816,
0.6125469208,
-0.2029843181,
0.5381528139,
0.7033388019,
0.5996743441,
-0.209741652,
-0.8450003862,
-0.0940360501,
0.2056594193,
-0.1409080625,
0.5718554854,
-0.7522411942,
0.8209517002,
-0.0851159543,
-0.1975633204,
0.2062041461,
0.7347406149,
-0.6670648456,
-0.005788743,
0.4805982709,
0.6871366501,
0.1585916281,
0.0016430262,
1.1944224834,
-0.6717284322,
0.6717101932,
0.696688354,
0.5093519688,
0.3628089428,
0.5073369741,
-0.3369869292,
0.2997942567,
0.1536763161,
-0.3476432562,
0.430347681,
0.3578341901,
0.315569669,
0.1900270134,
0.1453956366,
-0.6899372339,
0.6203672886,
0.120396927,
-0.7442466617,
-0.0630496666,
0.1365865171,
-0.3658222556,
-0.2792922258,
-0.5006144047,
0.3566771746,
0.1528413147,
-0.3592512608,
0.6764573455,
0.025920501,
0.4119442105,
-0.5847378373,
-0.0151240509,
-0.2992145121,
0.3802476823,
-0.3724600077,
-0.7341538072,
0.3567127585,
-0.5395541191,
-0.0685918406,
0.0291425101,
0.9778420329,
-0.3589340448,
-0.4162008166,
0.3324781358,
0.2276145965,
-0.0656774044,
0.0873192996,
-0.2133708298,
-0.1493482441,
-0.2866708636,
-0.509984076,
-0.0079630362,
0.0338277556,
0.3254833519,
0.4931094348,
0.1951841861,
0.0940245464,
0.2955387831,
-0.0218776669,
0.8059836626,
-0.7240166068,
-0.4410431087,
-0.861982584,
0.6127675772,
-0.0702595785,
-0.2170641273,
0.827665627,
0.5507286787,
0.7405075431,
-0.1591932029,
0.2868450582,
0.3529628813,
0.0376220942,
-0.2587060928,
0.7467404008,
-0.3545293212,
-0.2366479039,
-0.5592951775,
-1.7733842134,
-0.5439652801,
0.9556782246,
-0.1358332187,
0.2171939015,
0.9074885845,
0.3036125898,
-0.5160033703,
0.0622907802,
0.5142772198,
0.2428820878,
0.206056118,
0.2764683366,
0.9928892255,
-0.633656919,
0.484141171,
-0.6605876088,
-0.3168230057,
-0.0400237925,
-0.706874609,
-0.7994584441,
-0.367664516,
-0.068297483,
-0.3763110042,
-0.0760575905,
0.3073737621,
1.0409010649,
-0.6779977679,
-0.497435838,
-0.3742620349,
-0.0774684548,
-0.3734150231,
-0.2005575895,
0.4465777278,
-0.4625336826,
-0.3203361928,
0.2658539414,
0.1320993602,
0.1976232827,
-0.7919414043,
-0.1484881043,
-0.062631458,
0.0573982075,
0.9635211825,
0.3861600459,
-0.3925586641,
-0.5993518233,
-0.3512814343,
0.0351325199,
0.1739794612,
1.1226012707,
-0.8566892147,
0.5513147116,
0.2152772844,
0.5928015709,
0.6569806337,
-0.0113217775,
0.8448589444,
-0.5332462192,
0.6053040624,
0.0164979603,
0.1817861348,
0.1331530809,
-0.3187099993,
0.7989399433,
0.3777920306,
-0.4268829823,
-0.7438375354,
0.3730796576,
-0.7119930387,
-0.1091366038,
0.9821138382,
0.1810322851,
-0.1177176163,
0.2483719885,
-0.1918294132,
0.6271854043,
-0.0323012732,
0.532359302,
0.4245328307,
-0.3045749962,
-0.0528204031,
-0.2960627079,
0.4065520763,
0.4615088701,
-0.2051166445,
-0.2160689384,
-0.007045947,
0.2035482228,
0.5549865365,
0.1428521574,
-0.0820364207,
0.1659078747,
0.2849079967,
0.0996493474,
-0.0303230528,
-0.9576721191,
-0.6327784061,
0.2001489103,
-0.0011370995,
-0.3177937567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01982v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01982v3 | Rethinking the Role of Token Retrieval in Multi-Vector Retrieval | 2023-04-04T17:37:06 | 2024-04-08T18:31:32 | Jinhyuk Lee, Zhuyun Dai, Sai Meher Karthik Duddu, Tao Lei, Iftekhar Naim, Ming-Wei Chang, Vincent Y. Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Multi-vector retrieval models such as ColBERT [Khattab and Zaharia, 2020]
allow token-level interactions between queries and documents, and hence achieve
state of the art on many information retrieval benchmarks. However, their
non-linear scoring function cannot be scaled to millions of documents,
necessitating a three-stage process for inference: retrieving initial
candidates via token retrieval, accessing all token vectors, and scoring the
initial candidate documents. The non-linear scoring function is applied over
all token vectors of each candidate document, making the inference process
complicated and slow. In this paper, we aim to simplify the multi-vector
retrieval by rethinking the role of token retrieval. We present XTR,
ConteXtualized Token Retriever, which introduces a simple, yet novel, objective
function that encourages the model to retrieve the most important document
tokens first. The improvement to token retrieval allows XTR to rank candidates
only using the retrieved tokens rather than all tokens in the document, and
enables a newly designed scoring stage that is two-to-three orders of magnitude
cheaper than that of ColBERT. On the popular BEIR benchmark, XTR advances the
state-of-the-art by 2.8 nDCG@10 without any distillation. Detailed analysis
confirms our decision to revisit the token retrieval stage, as XTR demonstrates
much better recall of the token retrieval stage compared to ColBERT. | [
-0.2831859589,
-0.4789327383,
0.384916544,
-0.0574587844,
-0.4871035814,
0.1069365591,
0.0400833562,
-0.3171618879,
0.2879255414,
-0.013286557,
-0.034015689,
-0.3471860886,
-0.7078777552,
0.0491365828,
-0.635448873,
1.0070426464,
0.3061552346,
-0.0729166716,
-0.1886322945,
-0.273165822,
-0.3996691704,
-0.7623617649,
-0.719858706,
-0.1414923817,
1.0075737238,
0.3569982052,
0.4676565826,
0.7615344524,
0.5070026517,
0.2292833328,
-0.3833539486,
-0.1573664993,
-0.6573266983,
0.2834969163,
-0.1811443567,
-0.6284472942,
-0.1990333945,
0.0995405167,
0.6811829805,
0.4281656444,
0.0800566375,
0.0990067571,
-0.0113064218,
0.50172925,
-0.7872817516,
0.1041382477,
-0.6953244805,
0.1131560281,
-0.3680437505,
-0.4734294713,
-0.7141150832,
-0.1223468184,
0.1727598757,
-0.6055016518,
0.4873583019,
0.526714623,
0.5442075729,
-0.1420537829,
-0.8142336011,
-0.2831081152,
-0.3911366761,
0.9821058512,
-0.0367975496,
0.558575213,
0.1332965046,
0.1971716583,
-0.0331096575,
-1.225659132,
-0.5775844455,
-0.2756020725,
-0.1829420477,
-0.109901011,
-0.2485494614,
-0.1537341624,
0.1652001739,
0.4018930197,
-0.3150735795,
-0.2391609699,
-0.3884871006,
-0.3109236062,
0.0517775863,
-0.0747536123,
-0.2400607765,
-0.8636622429,
-0.8851643205,
-0.4919225276,
-0.4860714674,
0.2764856517,
0.1628863364,
0.5729422569,
0.451136142,
0.4570530951,
0.0948698819,
0.490881443,
-0.0968938023,
0.1844983995,
0.3092488348,
-0.6477813125,
-0.0929588452,
0.1417621672,
0.3868232965,
0.2262765765,
-0.4336827993,
-0.1896781325,
-0.3131284118,
-0.2237147689,
0.459461987,
-0.6977395415,
0.1324655712,
0.1791069657,
-0.7712101936,
-0.3723631799,
0.4288445115,
-0.9122763276,
-0.1989741623,
-0.3701515794,
0.5296483636,
-0.4586350918,
-0.1416308731,
-0.356798172,
-0.5093095303,
0.5071752667,
0.2776913047,
-0.3974916935,
0.1567978263,
1.1010707617,
1.0577617884,
-0.3066849113,
-0.1332485229,
-1.334692359,
-0.1307119578,
-0.3442212641,
0.7959655523,
-1.0237846375,
-0.7709462643,
-0.1850029975,
-0.2165780813,
0.1355395019,
-0.3187705278,
1.1258217096,
-0.7973953485,
0.0314143933,
-0.8815551996,
-0.4636386931,
-0.0333493315,
0.36506024,
-0.7635722756,
1.3175547123,
0.0582302772,
-0.8932343721,
0.7514194846,
-0.6346417069,
-0.2765665948,
0.0339659266,
-0.2337784767,
-0.3232097626,
0.2184858322,
0.2025983185,
0.3270948529,
-0.1692633033,
0.0630533174,
-0.2328008562,
-0.6617828608,
-0.1666831672,
-0.2434188873,
0.4355136454,
0.1790709943,
-0.1724190861,
0.1812278032,
-0.7006605864,
0.1424620152,
-0.3824515641,
-0.4681710899,
-0.4463249445,
-0.1410939395,
0.156854853,
0.3059750199,
-0.1593867093,
-0.8336273432,
0.2002986073,
-0.0407242216,
0.4867374599,
0.8023067713,
-0.3033989668,
0.5078906417,
-0.3368571997,
0.4102904797,
0.1247111186,
-0.0160860121,
-0.4763126373,
-0.4112890065,
-0.4121957719,
-0.5226754546,
0.5851195455,
0.1679737419,
-0.6956388354,
-0.090244703,
-0.3953326344,
-0.4393640459,
-0.3104852438,
-0.272328645,
0.3976537287,
0.8366434574,
0.5588150024,
-0.1747951061,
-0.5188862681,
-0.4414363801,
-0.3714047372,
-0.3143731058,
0.0666089356,
0.5380418301,
0.6304926276,
0.1703767478,
0.9916200638,
-0.441944927,
-0.5646416545,
-0.2470322698,
0.4522123337,
0.1274271607,
0.4656857848,
0.5381744504,
-1.0482474566,
-0.3450179994,
0.0880692825,
-0.3829008639,
0.2087618411,
0.0806888118,
-0.2807170749,
0.0649798363,
0.8990407586,
-0.5283328891,
0.6823559999,
-0.0765816197,
-0.3586737812,
0.4557021558,
-0.3110461831,
0.1681248546,
-0.7101616859,
0.4988224506,
-0.2013542801,
-0.3878839016,
-0.4537238479,
0.1761041284,
0.3769991696,
-0.1108899266,
-0.4644994438,
0.7938574553,
-0.5131605864,
-0.069692485,
-0.0929222628,
0.3845005631,
0.4491043985,
0.2940212786,
-0.4515806139,
0.8717471957,
0.304027617,
-0.4985328913,
-0.1286646426,
0.5032479167,
-0.1738315523,
0.8140403628,
-0.6641732454,
0.2988775373,
-0.7293338776,
0.4491894245,
-1.2269699574,
0.3276074529,
0.0338943154,
-0.4907084405,
0.4764179885,
-0.278465867,
-0.4432318807,
-0.1646777689,
-0.6699826121,
0.4711701572,
0.0049256603,
-0.7139572501,
0.9538386464,
0.1328825206,
0.0963647813,
-1.0493104458,
-0.2092336565,
0.3137609065,
-0.1241195425,
-0.3452026844,
0.7339789867,
0.2099931985,
-0.0589836314,
-0.0323068053,
-0.3897674978,
0.2669373155,
-0.2444218844,
-0.061377544,
0.2116853744,
-0.0446993373,
0.2876986563,
-0.1013462096,
-0.4399601221,
-0.365003109,
-0.3601869047,
0.3392095268,
0.0314568616,
-0.3199020922,
-0.179462254,
0.6135343313,
0.6128097773,
-0.5110524297,
0.5817778111,
0.7838372588,
-0.1233004406,
0.1961328983,
-0.6058926582,
-0.1268799007,
-0.3849903643,
0.2624043524,
-0.6552824974,
-0.6929142475,
0.4536714554,
0.1569450647,
0.042717915,
0.4406967163,
0.3188413382,
0.1645027399,
0.813752234,
0.4871278405,
0.0223750994,
0.7038321495,
-0.2378466427,
0.3016768992,
-1.2116544247,
-0.5918733478,
-0.7359778881,
-0.6093616486,
-0.4556020498,
-0.4953802228,
0.5236673951,
-0.0806001127,
0.0680708885,
0.2712872922,
-0.4305187464,
0.356434077,
1.0285545588,
-0.0099942256,
0.3066032529,
-0.0849427804,
-0.6590846181,
0.1175036281,
-0.6119371057,
-0.2424274832,
1.3493630886,
-0.1220017001,
0.4229091108,
0.1708253473,
0.7696629763,
0.3708842993,
0.3588844836,
-0.5586105585,
0.2918121815,
-0.1981927156,
-0.6513251066,
-0.1829117984,
-0.3273327947,
-1.1714024544,
0.791821897,
-0.0831826106,
-0.6421884894,
0.5832957625,
-0.1154721901,
-0.4745325744,
0.2032933831,
-0.7856974602,
0.6969894171,
0.0908547938,
-0.7093075514,
-0.1966913939,
-0.9333627224,
0.0705839694,
-0.1792643815,
0.1069469601,
-0.006783118,
-0.1641628891,
0.7380351424,
-0.3112691045,
0.3642097116,
-0.397472173,
0.3117560148,
0.1289652735,
0.0927785784,
0.5378769636,
0.2446092367,
-0.7537552118,
0.0059602945,
0.4868254662,
-0.3821121752,
-0.5712476373,
0.784527123,
-0.561420083,
-0.7119377851,
-0.6098936796,
-0.2610181272,
0.3252932131,
0.5135279298,
0.0729054585,
0.5952057242,
-0.1538680345,
0.6886917353,
0.1507634073,
-0.0452905893,
0.5447755456,
0.0981488079,
-0.0413822532,
-0.3574624062,
0.8627192378,
0.2442628741,
-0.0535763949,
0.8025979996,
0.4126039445,
-0.7596089244,
-0.2185440063,
-0.0896149576,
0.0038136072,
-0.9586904049,
-0.3724521101,
-0.8782909513,
0.2982292473,
-0.3250923753,
0.1030111462,
-0.1141795516,
-0.5044750571,
-0.521680057,
-0.2083383799,
-0.0271378364,
0.5601318479,
-0.2640623152,
0.1790808439,
-0.6255164742,
0.3324990571,
-0.0120374952,
0.4016122818,
0.3114950955,
-0.3621310294,
0.0818321258,
-0.3886492252,
-0.4750994742,
-0.4347600043,
0.1108081415,
0.2895600796,
0.6469183564,
0.4197751582,
0.2002091855,
0.8674581051,
-0.644163847,
0.5865241289,
-0.0751122162,
-0.9986847639,
0.2302818745,
0.0333308764,
-0.1106549427,
0.5687946081,
0.1149384007,
-0.7008017302,
0.2050410062,
-0.3720998466,
-1.0239220858,
0.8789507747,
0.4066573977,
0.2994470298,
-0.4853110015,
0.6896095276,
0.2843039632,
0.2790808678,
-0.3179031014,
-0.2254096717,
-0.4874339402,
0.2077531815,
0.090299584,
-0.5156801343,
0.0791820064,
-0.4061378539,
0.3382589519,
-0.1731532812,
0.542334795,
0.6360408664,
0.0304490551,
0.1628622264,
0.166059792,
0.4491047561,
0.6238357425,
-0.2599332333,
0.2388467044,
-0.23048307,
-0.2722027302,
0.1608042568,
0.0591627918,
0.2726503313,
0.1303723007,
0.2984705269,
0.5958790183,
0.4659310579,
-0.4162805378,
0.8484166265,
-0.2543119788,
-0.1850435436,
-0.2735224664,
-0.1391982734,
-0.346336633,
0.2818740308,
0.8021631837,
0.05116418,
0.0817568451,
-0.4101186693,
0.7497472167,
0.7320525646,
-0.4693190157,
-0.1331649721,
1.1670713425,
0.0170178544,
-0.3869135082,
0.7432394028,
-0.3178832233,
-0.3168617487,
0.3107161224,
0.3584074378,
0.5133454204,
0.1767053902,
0.1264558434,
0.3664558828,
-0.029669432,
-0.1235696822,
0.4734865725,
-0.2595014572,
-0.3947439492,
-0.3086512983,
-0.6133337617,
-0.2676995099,
-0.3525123298,
-0.8032298088,
0.5621561408,
-0.2653769553,
-0.455940038,
0.1490121484,
0.0258640852,
-0.6757965088,
-0.0655987263,
-0.1863873452,
1.18097651,
-0.1289559454,
0.5848737359,
0.1491968036,
-0.3969866633,
-0.4351299703,
-0.0281139463,
-0.0045336015,
-0.8330777287,
1.0746182203,
0.3018094003,
-0.1032823622,
0.2944816649,
-0.1116491258,
-1.0002410412,
1.2104383707,
0.1474770159,
-0.2133948803,
-0.2711376548,
-0.1568866372,
0.3388320506,
-0.1702646464,
0.5391974449,
0.4128715098,
0.4163951874,
0.5340605378,
-0.5398442149,
0.1441927254,
-0.2374549657,
0.2002026737,
0.2462197095,
-0.6576760411,
1.2555208206,
-0.2554562986,
-0.2658135295,
0.2269162387,
0.7420582771,
-0.0068779285,
0.1869618148,
0.5455036759,
0.4410255551,
0.9971911907,
-0.0524813794,
1.2582128048,
-0.402020961,
0.4230948091,
0.7229707241,
-0.2914634943,
0.9959636331,
0.8968220353,
0.1030464694,
0.4694885612,
0.2372923642,
0.1024301723,
0.4422671497,
0.2970199287,
-0.2302664518,
-0.1077292934,
-0.2051905245,
-0.161472097,
0.6314592361,
0.0630462468,
-0.3727940917,
-0.5014855862,
0.000716246,
-0.0885824934,
-0.3633187115,
-0.1441263556,
0.4799106121,
-0.0028640374,
-0.6661733389,
0.3835524321,
0.1872442216,
0.4242223799,
-0.3299467862,
-0.139795959,
-0.1607111841,
0.3008309007,
-0.0621179938,
-0.5327557325,
0.2608404756,
-0.3589194119,
-0.0741169229,
-0.3847480118,
0.5266929269,
0.014425776,
-0.6213038564,
0.4446988404,
0.6203802824,
0.0164795239,
-0.2665896416,
-0.3927712739,
0.1892003715,
-0.2862719595,
-0.2887942791,
0.2118107677,
0.5072237253,
-0.3090435565,
0.6511820555,
0.9909747839,
-0.21471183,
0.1327827424,
0.201119706,
0.9498026371,
-0.7268621922,
-0.6149045825,
-0.8617680669,
0.2768212557,
-0.0494886264,
-0.3401663005,
0.4912824035,
0.6704128385,
0.7888379693,
0.3809081912,
0.5845573545,
-0.1587184668,
0.5673674941,
-0.2841745317,
0.4630552232,
-0.822896719,
0.2116481662,
-0.3691674471,
-0.728368938,
-0.5918103456,
0.4559909105,
-0.0669285879,
0.1837899685,
0.8642905951,
0.8007606268,
-0.1205946431,
0.0012043153,
0.3228863478,
0.0226563253,
0.7737716436,
0.0702645257,
0.686501503,
-0.5261847377,
1.0290222168,
0.1718443036,
-0.1155402139,
-0.4125862122,
-1.0927504301,
-0.7394297719,
-0.5995804071,
0.1378381401,
-0.1285684705,
-0.2511944771,
1.0405141115,
0.7084337473,
-0.5013335943,
0.1138255447,
0.2317749709,
0.3501786888,
-0.2908291519,
-0.2401071787,
0.542321682,
-0.5984123945,
-0.7860645652,
0.2456353456,
0.3567973077,
-0.3546405435,
-0.0639359057,
0.2497924864,
-0.3216081262,
-0.1262444109,
0.8550540805,
-0.0005420754,
-0.7561503053,
-0.6301707029,
0.4376911223,
0.0688206553,
0.636934936,
1.2754164934,
-1.1515936852,
0.5295788646,
0.588624537,
0.6608005166,
0.6162707806,
0.1614585072,
0.4520624578,
-0.9165803194,
-0.1241580471,
0.0183322486,
0.4073584378,
0.2671021521,
-0.4135951996,
0.2318949103,
0.2926973701,
-0.2590958774,
-0.9833324552,
0.0185685493,
-0.8484951854,
-0.1503207535,
0.9699937105,
0.1490230709,
-0.1916920096,
-0.3694806993,
-0.444009304,
0.2538304627,
-0.6105995178,
0.8083655238,
0.6017503142,
-0.219610244,
-0.1215205416,
-0.4134732187,
0.2548894882,
0.3608565927,
-0.0888892785,
0.0604465976,
-0.0630413815,
0.0913370475,
0.1798733175,
0.8778546453,
-0.3625097871,
0.0040608668,
-0.1210636124,
-0.4811884165,
-0.1047220379,
-0.4084422886,
-0.0709193721,
0.6089137793,
-0.0664808825,
-0.3484324813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01974v1 | Dialogue-Contextualized Re-ranking for Medical History-Taking | 2023-04-04T17:31:32 | 2023-04-04T17:31:32 | Jian Zhu, Ilya Valmianski, Anitha Kannan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | AI-driven medical history-taking is an important component in symptom
checking, automated patient intake, triage, and other AI virtual care
applications. As history-taking is extremely varied, machine learning models
require a significant amount of data to train. To overcome this challenge,
existing systems are developed using indirect data or expert knowledge. This
leads to a training-inference gap as models are trained on different kinds of
data than what they observe at inference time. In this work, we present a
two-stage re-ranking approach that helps close the training-inference gap by
re-ranking the first-stage question candidates using a dialogue-contextualized
model. For this, we propose a new model, global re-ranker, which cross-encodes
the dialogue with all questions simultaneously, and compare it with several
existing neural baselines. We test both transformer and S4-based language model
backbones. We find that relative to the expert system, the best performance is
achieved by our proposed global re-ranker with a transformer backbone,
resulting in a 30% higher normalized discount cumulative gain (nDCG) and a 77%
higher mean average precision (mAP). | [
-0.2108438611,
-0.6135014296,
0.6142471433,
-0.3730621934,
-0.2271175385,
-0.0761783049,
0.0648649931,
-0.2754524648,
0.3070090711,
0.5652864575,
-0.4521228671,
-0.5700761676,
-0.7863606811,
0.034704566,
-0.2039915174,
1.0472986698,
0.0068408609,
0.3240181506,
-0.4788711965,
-0.1788357794,
-0.5471845269,
-0.6092823744,
-0.9982893467,
-0.4679416418,
0.6329346895,
0.2149556577,
0.6753767133,
0.5864864588,
0.1729009151,
0.2881421149,
-0.0804681852,
0.1285992861,
-0.2813319862,
0.515452981,
-0.0937765837,
-0.6283877492,
-0.5222541094,
-0.0954583436,
0.4637319446,
0.7622613907,
0.0864395425,
0.0278825555,
-0.0647995844,
0.2893687487,
-0.2282944471,
0.2843408883,
-0.4302511215,
0.1048915237,
0.3873521388,
-0.5187317729,
-0.3775354028,
-0.5963033438,
0.480329603,
-0.4486700892,
0.386860013,
-0.0955763757,
0.7075276971,
0.4725641012,
-0.5332332253,
0.1509233117,
-0.3650241196,
0.6207178235,
-0.5646048188,
0.6091272831,
0.4260447025,
0.4591454566,
0.0650482625,
-0.915168047,
-0.2445244193,
-0.1483600885,
-0.2944028974,
0.1264468282,
-0.2233009487,
-0.0352721885,
0.0482284389,
0.3569693267,
-0.5272978544,
0.0983061194,
-0.2851242125,
-0.1489076614,
0.4929448664,
0.2823071182,
0.2694092095,
-0.1634498984,
-0.1787893921,
-0.029517835,
-0.7708046436,
-0.0089885257,
-0.3495153785,
0.2140793055,
0.1729158461,
0.1948901117,
-0.4270151854,
0.7846271396,
0.1772159785,
-0.0774562359,
0.1487795562,
-0.4115948975,
-0.1826376915,
-0.0887711421,
0.5322675705,
0.7443388104,
0.0309731402,
-0.2401087433,
0.1041619331,
-0.3600099981,
0.479575783,
-0.7956200838,
-0.2122105062,
0.1635610014,
-0.4010214508,
-0.3093938231,
-0.3756468892,
-0.7333675027,
-0.3588353097,
-0.4303566813,
0.2777042091,
-0.1523207426,
0.1201136559,
-0.2637627125,
0.1128267497,
0.250708878,
0.6789301634,
-0.579100132,
0.0278131664,
0.6003715992,
0.8234239817,
-0.1629218012,
-0.0856938958,
-0.5232075453,
-0.1002636477,
-0.3022207022,
0.7093917131,
-0.5827998519,
-0.6660500765,
-0.044813633,
0.1059578583,
-0.1529302299,
-0.6446493268,
0.5996604562,
-0.340703994,
0.6920416951,
-0.0100670829,
-0.5090619922,
-0.1546154022,
0.4831092358,
-0.5584378242,
0.858910799,
0.1777088493,
-0.4795648158,
0.5621600151,
-0.1122098714,
-0.4440068901,
-0.0032850879,
-0.6179695129,
-0.525416255,
-0.2199136764,
0.6759690046,
0.3913109899,
-0.5301513076,
0.5368774533,
0.1649651378,
-0.4768598974,
-0.1724106967,
-0.5786573291,
0.4479743838,
-0.1203353256,
-0.4102528691,
0.0228767432,
-0.4340648055,
0.0410217419,
-0.051569242,
-0.4331159592,
-0.238649562,
-0.1182581931,
-0.360717535,
0.2903366089,
0.0479558893,
-0.4525319934,
0.573676765,
-0.5909842849,
0.2648759186,
0.4505526721,
0.1929257065,
0.2599508762,
-0.5658058524,
0.637195766,
0.0224256702,
0.2353297472,
-0.258149296,
-0.8092797995,
-0.9013652205,
-0.0094883237,
0.3959080279,
0.8580624461,
-0.5794681311,
0.435862869,
-0.5037863255,
-0.3338108361,
-0.5817767382,
-0.3520204425,
0.4376636147,
0.8285780549,
0.6371623278,
-0.2473662794,
-0.4879754782,
-0.9199073315,
-0.2375630438,
-0.3800039887,
-0.3288661838,
0.7067686319,
0.085105747,
-0.3739123344,
0.8848043084,
-0.711643815,
-0.2097793221,
-0.3963534534,
0.1873987466,
0.2686516345,
0.4654952586,
0.1561976075,
-0.7176685929,
-0.1934624463,
0.1085099429,
-0.7156757712,
-0.1086774245,
-0.2009807229,
-0.1374701113,
0.2833230495,
0.5165835023,
-0.41809237,
0.6989187002,
0.1576251984,
-0.0699865147,
0.167675063,
-0.2827711403,
0.5752527118,
-1.275727272,
0.146386683,
-0.1131135449,
-0.282179296,
-0.703327477,
-0.1636224836,
-0.1434638351,
-0.1794987172,
-0.2164993584,
0.6014386415,
-0.0197110213,
0.2211573571,
-0.0102968868,
0.057269223,
-0.0309317596,
0.6126674414,
0.1790121496,
0.4313647747,
0.3947860599,
-0.3736878335,
0.1253678501,
0.3966240883,
-0.0916963071,
0.6140376329,
-0.5876604915,
0.1104209423,
-0.0610300563,
0.6262805462,
-1.1030967236,
-0.0105301524,
0.1032370403,
-0.5918021798,
0.4153736234,
-0.4004370272,
0.0484928675,
-0.229322359,
-0.0026150623,
0.7423986197,
0.3708896637,
-0.4326377809,
0.7602769136,
0.2631906271,
-0.6784025431,
-0.7702690363,
-0.4099519253,
0.2041968554,
-0.0109204371,
-0.5107350349,
0.4586769044,
0.0869415179,
0.1663612872,
-0.3512558937,
-0.3195648491,
-0.2383540422,
-0.1265003383,
0.2722616196,
0.363419205,
-0.1827138662,
0.2764852345,
0.2517005503,
-0.4946227372,
0.0359955207,
-0.1887571812,
0.4610586464,
0.1375481039,
-0.4451797009,
-0.6328059435,
0.4283167422,
0.7932959199,
-0.0772945955,
0.4852376282,
0.1046878844,
-0.5206698775,
0.246643424,
-0.7047836781,
-0.3508343995,
-0.3098292947,
0.3499074876,
-0.1723897606,
-0.9264639616,
0.3565876186,
-0.252084583,
0.3096323311,
0.4921102226,
0.568475008,
-0.0685883462,
1.1241197586,
0.0922564045,
-0.3802648485,
0.2920753956,
-0.2469668388,
0.2063350677,
-0.5167276859,
-0.4459831119,
-0.3669561148,
-0.4109278023,
-0.5318529606,
-0.4700564742,
0.7205561996,
-0.2000758946,
-0.183290422,
-0.1306689084,
-0.398355931,
0.2867226899,
0.5217661858,
0.2678287327,
0.5249502063,
-0.17536062,
-0.1306702793,
-0.0257409979,
-0.6849879622,
-0.2608208656,
1.1304165125,
0.1710493416,
0.6171262264,
-0.0883399546,
0.786383152,
0.1765035838,
0.2627393007,
-0.5807605386,
0.3602527678,
-0.1503981352,
-0.3712392747,
-0.4600894451,
-0.3411306739,
-1.160315156,
0.5588883758,
-0.1677749604,
-0.5654603839,
0.1622087359,
0.2426986396,
-0.6496514678,
0.3048568368,
-0.3484629691,
0.94723171,
-0.0824522898,
-0.120998174,
-0.0194861759,
-0.8995940685,
0.105876103,
0.2153133005,
-0.0454087108,
0.3718091846,
0.1707087755,
0.3746493459,
-0.3289316893,
0.8179702759,
-0.1896659136,
0.1728054732,
-0.1985519677,
0.0193868224,
0.3200410008,
0.330655992,
0.209800452,
0.1446881741,
-0.0516480021,
-0.1406878382,
-0.8229804039,
0.6108483672,
-0.5993852019,
-0.9324299097,
-0.3124182522,
-0.4063012302,
-0.2255007476,
0.0783144087,
0.3919663429,
0.7834224105,
-0.260607779,
0.3960478008,
0.5698533058,
-0.332781136,
-0.1924230009,
0.337216258,
-0.144302845,
-0.2983276546,
0.5725034475,
0.1479430497,
0.2012419403,
0.6759405136,
0.2045612484,
-0.2863849103,
-0.4253915548,
-0.7687129974,
0.0792188793,
-0.5771206021,
-0.1695547402,
-0.8978216648,
-0.4105877876,
-0.3596823215,
-0.2852405012,
-0.2468165904,
-0.4512985647,
-0.1209167913,
-0.2155311108,
0.1231605411,
0.4934483171,
0.2833713889,
0.1069741622,
-0.4640246928,
0.2923002243,
0.3411895633,
0.3102484047,
-0.0919651836,
-0.5279664397,
-0.1342921853,
-0.1415153444,
-0.3396832645,
-0.7586520314,
0.2939427793,
0.0426247343,
0.9170243144,
0.236637488,
-0.1839255542,
0.6612560153,
-0.6114854813,
0.8228974938,
-0.0147890989,
-0.4854902327,
0.7913635373,
-0.0263392497,
0.3844226301,
0.6686211228,
0.3407131135,
-0.8170405626,
-0.590954721,
-0.5307224989,
-1.04464221,
0.6349087358,
0.0020180047,
-0.1472790241,
-0.0779627487,
0.478800118,
0.1626760066,
-0.0890283659,
-0.4306956828,
-0.4154388905,
-0.2354813963,
-0.1480901986,
-0.1353398412,
0.0081859799,
-0.1522423178,
-0.5214148164,
0.4862818122,
-0.1914115697,
0.2731969357,
0.3562626839,
-0.1710402519,
0.1706426591,
0.3258129954,
0.4676647484,
0.6419694424,
-0.1981782317,
-0.131214425,
0.5322348475,
-0.3900899291,
0.108290188,
0.2195497155,
-0.1572633833,
0.2046614736,
0.2681774199,
0.8218963146,
0.6028556824,
-0.4359071851,
0.4688540101,
-0.242404744,
-0.1444107443,
-0.1939226091,
-0.0197104197,
0.0037947509,
0.3881006241,
0.2962636054,
-0.0343195461,
0.3083653748,
-0.3003103733,
0.5505794883,
0.164948836,
-0.3177822232,
0.1166295856,
0.7111065984,
0.1985028684,
-0.3935443759,
0.7992812395,
0.3812396228,
-0.4622920156,
0.4607370496,
0.3285118639,
0.571157515,
-0.6060264707,
0.090196155,
0.5380049348,
-0.0705605522,
0.0020647466,
0.0914597139,
-0.193144992,
-0.3765777647,
-0.2088683248,
-0.1461651921,
-0.5584903359,
-0.0037156877,
-0.9269602299,
0.0875271857,
-0.149856329,
-0.3631104529,
-0.14856942,
-0.2231443673,
-0.7896981239,
0.455552876,
-0.0100082606,
0.6536415815,
-0.5415505767,
0.6555098295,
0.3376980722,
-0.2936138213,
-0.4288350344,
0.2038400322,
0.0195118245,
-0.7760446668,
0.6567807794,
0.3094413877,
-0.011085202,
-0.1521854401,
-0.0265231561,
-0.8446618915,
1.4357306957,
0.2006613463,
-0.4439980686,
-0.3608281314,
0.0207537096,
0.5485706329,
-0.4470631182,
0.6146486402,
0.7729580402,
0.0054942253,
0.2533976734,
-0.9602163434,
-0.0617838874,
-0.3023712635,
-0.2071686387,
0.3467126191,
-0.3339521289,
0.7169981599,
-0.0476873145,
-0.1095403656,
0.2428786457,
0.3208182156,
0.3840680718,
0.4222121537,
0.529802978,
0.5849174857,
0.705678761,
-0.3018277287,
1.1922112703,
-0.3992051184,
0.2693565786,
1.0882182121,
-0.1075949594,
0.7966023684,
0.2147239,
-0.1363734156,
0.731570065,
0.5169702768,
0.2941951156,
0.3620742857,
0.0809580162,
-0.1457265168,
-0.3509339094,
0.0383104794,
-0.6159217954,
0.32416448,
0.1484482735,
-0.7656684518,
-0.241540283,
-0.1977456808,
0.2059287578,
-0.3850804269,
-0.1389775574,
0.9591886401,
-0.0526387617,
-1.0195654631,
0.68873173,
-0.2366233021,
0.3712831736,
-0.4921488464,
-0.1358255446,
-0.7076340914,
-0.0942745134,
0.1084769219,
-0.5714672804,
0.0852475539,
-0.0194396898,
-0.2909061909,
-0.209117189,
0.3977118134,
-0.6241363883,
-0.5367617011,
0.0778150633,
0.6891419291,
0.2943253517,
0.067211017,
-0.5803531408,
-0.309284538,
-0.0090757124,
-0.2504092157,
0.319848448,
0.0759695768,
-0.2548579276,
0.7162992954,
0.4298642278,
-0.1829149872,
-0.2290447801,
0.3615073562,
0.8149093986,
-0.74595052,
-0.7614773512,
-0.6893680692,
0.5078167319,
-0.1726528555,
-0.3614305258,
0.2928479314,
0.5293126702,
0.6528182626,
0.3484646976,
0.7301370502,
0.3922372758,
0.6595131159,
-0.3366995454,
0.6619941592,
-0.824189961,
0.1054113731,
-0.1593935788,
-0.4097812474,
-0.458239913,
0.6450288892,
-0.3451452851,
0.1817002445,
0.5506132245,
0.6879795194,
0.2794033885,
0.1882196218,
0.305018276,
0.1576117724,
0.4368243217,
0.831071794,
0.6139387488,
-0.3789174855,
0.3674217165,
0.0760881379,
-0.3493233621,
-0.3984235525,
-0.4261623025,
-0.6684689522,
-0.5455849767,
-0.1579074264,
-0.1093546823,
0.1771592051,
0.9405052066,
0.6772711277,
-0.6758215427,
0.0970622823,
0.2873904407,
0.0623106472,
-0.2864937782,
-0.11031425,
0.5541576147,
-0.1582356244,
-0.7062375546,
0.5050191283,
0.2319230586,
-0.2056178004,
-0.1322249025,
0.0048170071,
0.0216275342,
-0.1206440181,
0.4712066054,
0.1254906505,
-1.0554500818,
-0.33656317,
0.0302726515,
-0.1101806015,
0.3198716044,
1.0319335461,
-1.1610928774,
0.6981649399,
0.3698740005,
0.9138729572,
0.5213415027,
0.2469533682,
0.7618145943,
-0.7125899196,
-0.3143277764,
0.3028294146,
0.5142452717,
0.1931445301,
-0.546487987,
0.368606329,
0.1641150266,
-0.6714748144,
-0.6097899675,
0.1354043037,
-0.7846147418,
-0.3043142855,
0.7785436511,
-0.0674035773,
0.2908014655,
-0.3726320267,
-0.3866515458,
0.6267407537,
-0.3023958206,
0.7902355194,
0.427762866,
-0.5127770305,
-0.1536389887,
-0.663366437,
0.3434392214,
0.6232303977,
-0.7634344697,
-0.1116705462,
0.551861763,
0.3478230238,
0.0264827665,
0.7462487817,
-0.1194730029,
0.329787761,
-0.2636477351,
-0.1626766473,
0.0567023195,
-0.4488420784,
-0.4224356711,
0.2665500641,
-0.3128602505,
-0.2060834318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01969v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01969v2 | MEGClass: Extremely Weakly Supervised Text Classification via Mutually-Enhancing Text Granularities | 2023-04-04T17:26:11 | 2023-10-29T21:03:54 | Priyanka Kargupta, Tanay Komarlu, Susik Yoon, Xuan Wang, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text classification is essential for organizing unstructured text.
Traditional methods rely on human annotations or, more recently, a set of class
seed words for supervision, which can be costly, particularly for specialized
or emerging domains. To address this, using class surface names alone as
extremely weak supervision has been proposed. However, existing approaches
treat different levels of text granularity (documents, sentences, or words)
independently, disregarding inter-granularity class disagreements and the
context identifiable exclusively through joint extraction. In order to tackle
these issues, we introduce MEGClass, an extremely weakly-supervised text
classification method that leverages Mutually-Enhancing Text Granularities.
MEGClass utilizes coarse- and fine-grained context signals obtained by jointly
considering a document's most class-indicative words and sentences. This
approach enables the learning of a contextualized document representation that
captures the most discriminative class indicators. By preserving the
heterogeneity of potential classes, MEGClass can select the most informative
class-indicative documents as iterative feedback to enhance the initial
word-based class representations and ultimately fine-tune a pre-trained text
classifier. Extensive experiments on seven benchmark datasets demonstrate that
MEGClass outperforms other weakly and extremely weakly supervised methods. | [
-0.3021476865,
-1.0565325022,
0.5890587568,
-0.0582443476,
-0.24398534,
-0.0241695568,
-0.4117030203,
-0.4730589688,
-0.1136246994,
0.3882929981,
-0.2487335503,
-0.8734822869,
-0.6769868135,
-0.1744088233,
-0.5034718513,
1.3854324818,
0.1489234418,
-0.2409663051,
-0.4844513535,
0.033550296,
-0.2897411585,
-0.6443247795,
-0.1282548904,
-0.4697044194,
0.5741709471,
0.6786981225,
0.5770296454,
0.5455670953,
0.5879521966,
0.3631190956,
-0.2670830786,
0.4203600883,
-0.1969402283,
-0.1646839529,
-0.1086706743,
-0.1998305023,
-0.5757968426,
0.0167145953,
0.5241530538,
1.0507540703,
0.0412485003,
0.1338983923,
0.4337825775,
0.253687948,
-0.9627252817,
0.2161048204,
-0.6764087081,
0.004946447,
-0.4699914157,
-0.3268504739,
-0.5163932443,
0.1284033954,
0.1179753542,
-0.4523738623,
0.3610964417,
0.0088563021,
1.0588773489,
0.0166811198,
-0.612829566,
0.0334791951,
-0.609801054,
0.7215104699,
-0.1222948432,
-0.0063407198,
0.7650460601,
0.0488901399,
-0.0184987988,
-0.8974024653,
-0.2961669862,
0.1330704093,
-0.2183896601,
0.2928590775,
0.0739901736,
0.2545843124,
0.0867633224,
0.4745046496,
-0.2249814868,
0.2528092861,
-0.1629020721,
-0.1535193175,
0.4187021255,
0.2704275548,
0.465061456,
-0.1503254324,
-0.552791357,
0.0031630551,
-0.1849025488,
-0.1127969474,
0.4032657146,
0.6075258851,
-0.0045583327,
0.3678220212,
-0.3086219132,
0.5877217054,
-0.1571470499,
-0.0702714026,
0.1982632875,
0.0310246367,
-0.1174869165,
0.2479625046,
0.6911918521,
0.3037314415,
-0.3444320261,
-0.4502583742,
-0.2936649919,
0.0874194577,
0.470320493,
-0.7606849074,
-0.3874916136,
-0.0373101197,
-0.5244978666,
-0.5912045836,
0.2927753031,
-0.8628869057,
-0.3099782765,
-0.3549852669,
0.8670973778,
-0.2584404349,
-0.03490391,
-0.1783851385,
-0.1236594692,
-0.0317753665,
0.4560993314,
-1.2011656761,
0.4334510267,
0.743819356,
0.7697717547,
-0.2473516911,
-0.6937558651,
-0.3647178411,
0.3996444941,
-0.1675876826,
1.2530933619,
-0.8353204131,
-0.3635376096,
0.1230908036,
-0.1101625487,
0.1786914915,
-0.4322557151,
0.9597718716,
-0.1281207204,
0.4388210475,
0.0297263488,
-0.6188439131,
-0.1336601675,
0.2622968554,
-0.1624375135,
1.280603528,
0.219514519,
-1.0624866486,
0.7513687611,
-0.3154694736,
-0.5083009005,
0.0879206732,
0.0282055847,
-0.8629694581,
0.2281996608,
0.1179417074,
0.9097439647,
0.000845094,
0.2281351984,
-0.5072470903,
-0.7968838215,
-0.0998158529,
-0.5104435086,
0.2314961553,
-0.2152187675,
-0.2096748501,
0.104198277,
-0.8272564411,
0.0415757596,
0.1878082603,
-0.3321434557,
-0.8421547413,
0.0485854149,
0.2648888826,
0.010717201,
0.2920894325,
-0.2364912629,
0.3502722979,
0.0039079473,
-0.0134477196,
0.7598801255,
-0.026654413,
0.7268599272,
-0.5278263092,
-0.1735331714,
-0.1004405022,
0.028657781,
-0.214747563,
-0.216693759,
-0.9115571976,
-0.4318375587,
0.316097945,
0.2964804471,
-0.3640120924,
0.6101638079,
-0.334605515,
-0.5056692362,
-0.0184786357,
0.2512528598,
0.3969417512,
0.4045776129,
0.5576497912,
0.0267068185,
-0.2327662408,
-0.8492128849,
-0.2477138489,
-0.2736949027,
0.0390991718,
0.1775643826,
0.3620674908,
-0.3183541,
0.6218550205,
-0.7068349719,
-0.6744707823,
-0.3347959518,
0.5881180167,
-0.044147592,
0.5002888441,
0.1627125144,
-1.0368107557,
-0.310672462,
-0.0121057779,
-0.7195515037,
-0.4327458143,
-0.2031169534,
-0.2691457272,
0.0204224307,
0.6468738317,
-0.1633881927,
0.2412037253,
0.1752168387,
-0.4273124337,
0.2986551523,
-0.3459640741,
-0.0404344387,
-0.955999732,
-0.0659580082,
-0.1756245643,
-0.1528517306,
-0.5623811483,
0.0430493541,
0.2520788312,
-0.0226038601,
-0.1929558367,
0.4932667911,
-0.5219308138,
0.2086192667,
-0.5595167875,
0.0139946276,
0.0035256799,
0.6101674438,
0.2887114882,
0.4626495242,
0.6129696965,
-0.730880022,
-0.1223192737,
0.29195714,
0.1158303246,
0.7408665419,
-0.077175729,
0.0665862113,
-0.0604390875,
0.0961711332,
-0.7319143414,
-0.4537230432,
-0.2229302973,
-0.3082608879,
0.5664539337,
-0.3033581078,
-0.6101847887,
-0.0755577311,
-0.4263496101,
0.0276265591,
0.3973779678,
-0.7613761425,
0.679377377,
0.5169993043,
-0.0524702519,
-0.4003126323,
-0.6190202236,
0.1842640638,
-0.354865998,
-0.0984971672,
0.3948443234,
0.2883095443,
-0.058261849,
0.1246650815,
-0.3697877228,
-0.5814350247,
0.2678129077,
0.6833702326,
0.4058359861,
0.2025415003,
0.4027330279,
0.5404741168,
-0.4562351406,
-0.0394913517,
-0.3888244629,
0.2944409847,
-0.0691212416,
-0.2504463494,
-0.1597317904,
0.3290664554,
0.4142659307,
0.1685234308,
0.5961024165,
0.9033415318,
-0.4049550295,
-0.67734164,
-0.3091772497,
0.0068505886,
-0.4663814604,
0.3248567879,
-0.4387680888,
-0.8227040172,
0.2157347649,
-0.3941782117,
-0.1279064715,
0.3920648396,
0.3335932195,
-0.0648855641,
0.936014235,
0.8793999553,
-0.1126467586,
0.6971749663,
-0.0287712738,
-0.2664055526,
-0.6617791057,
-0.4454286098,
-0.4960957468,
-0.1238642111,
-0.3681554794,
-0.1738407761,
0.1625111997,
0.2172709405,
-0.0610820279,
0.3613005877,
-0.6090422273,
0.7546520233,
0.4793201089,
0.3878535628,
0.345349282,
0.146996364,
-0.0907579437,
-0.0220451932,
-0.4563997686,
-0.8325831294,
0.9703812003,
0.1073997542,
0.5026244521,
0.0141822286,
0.8754882216,
0.4102483392,
0.2104850858,
-0.7386508584,
0.7767643929,
-0.4727841616,
-0.4642075002,
0.0557809286,
-0.6460036039,
-0.7520700097,
0.410068512,
-0.5970941782,
-0.8946692944,
-0.167281583,
-0.0586088561,
0.0265177377,
0.5104818344,
-0.9398961067,
0.901183188,
0.0979385898,
-0.7083539963,
0.0330496021,
-0.6039557457,
0.1956793517,
-0.4930758774,
0.0997797474,
-0.1655051112,
-0.2770975828,
0.5841628313,
-0.5835538507,
0.8889714479,
-0.0530533604,
-0.0570502467,
0.252861917,
0.1061276495,
0.4201716185,
0.0827789605,
0.2978957891,
0.2227662057,
-0.3334621191,
-0.6144554615,
-0.4604086876,
0.6175159812,
-0.6033800244,
-0.1758418679,
-0.4023605287,
-0.3341013789,
-0.3638848364,
0.5113252997,
0.4173307419,
0.6676993966,
-0.1415731907,
-0.0912306979,
0.6434756517,
0.1023719609,
0.6453718543,
0.4767650962,
-0.1900368631,
-0.1765431762,
1.2908440828,
0.0496218316,
0.1031147614,
0.7077360153,
0.3508887291,
-0.1319905967,
-0.7896449566,
-0.2909416854,
-0.3176024258,
-0.5984114408,
-0.2589318156,
-1.0671031475,
-0.0554171205,
0.1202401668,
-0.6029987335,
-0.1745866835,
-0.3067530692,
-0.2762803733,
0.0871995762,
-0.0700827092,
0.6273351908,
0.0457674451,
0.6154443622,
-0.9116069674,
0.2837414742,
0.5243715048,
0.2847386003,
-0.3310943246,
-0.4404470325,
-0.102251187,
-0.6095194817,
-0.1178031564,
-0.4894944727,
0.0489408895,
0.2647602856,
0.3014984727,
0.5089944005,
0.1965025514,
0.6620994806,
-0.5235211253,
0.6662611961,
0.0982294902,
-1.0028953552,
0.6014142036,
-0.5277033448,
0.1420224011,
0.9821361899,
0.2337145209,
-0.1549741328,
-0.6205863953,
-0.8068250418,
-1.1246708632,
0.9015843868,
0.0883529633,
0.3930254281,
0.0877430514,
0.1474172324,
0.3659250736,
0.0170914326,
-0.6939938664,
0.0598649196,
0.1256795824,
-0.2882953882,
0.2180999368,
-0.3250980079,
0.0757434517,
-0.0690018758,
0.7307164073,
-0.1746857017,
0.2134370953,
-0.0749197453,
-0.281126827,
0.1810393482,
0.3057573736,
0.0824493766,
0.1735052317,
-0.3516997397,
0.8255103827,
0.6742196083,
-0.7824347019,
0.1290839314,
0.0917939842,
-0.1540949494,
0.0531950742,
0.7375414371,
0.3131870031,
0.2991480231,
-0.4261737466,
0.8841776252,
-0.2326313704,
-0.0494121052,
0.0448035374,
0.2278290987,
-0.5231750607,
0.0686504766,
0.2052444071,
0.2420120537,
0.411800772,
-0.4254109561,
0.2599203885,
0.1154882833,
-0.6717285514,
-0.2673740387,
0.4124324918,
0.2323287725,
0.1142120659,
0.1512365192,
-0.4524208903,
-0.5700328946,
0.1718681455,
0.6957882047,
0.8407748938,
0.1234121472,
0.1877296716,
0.0476594418,
0.0302154347,
-0.3482947052,
-0.2285469472,
-0.5516062379,
-0.3554062247,
-0.1839545071,
-0.7854724526,
-0.5709477067,
-0.1156699285,
-0.53036201,
0.5680530667,
-0.4766283333,
-0.0190801974,
0.0387594812,
0.1566269547,
0.032049071,
0.280665189,
0.2113782763,
0.4893506467,
-1.1163320541,
0.5524309278,
1.1714363098,
-0.3518508077,
-0.4448158443,
0.4661211967,
0.1073979363,
-0.3154318333,
0.3596380651,
0.5391787291,
-0.1696198434,
-0.0661569536,
-0.5439170003,
-0.2579328716,
0.6788942814,
0.1432872862,
-0.1421159059,
0.0351110995,
0.0302138887,
0.3651923835,
0.1743738204,
0.3449677825,
-0.0155021651,
0.3749648035,
0.0253307149,
-0.5025187731,
-0.0162444264,
-0.3554722965,
-0.032936208,
0.6359226704,
-0.7772054672,
0.5702700615,
0.1157262623,
-0.2124177366,
-0.0821951479,
0.728217423,
-0.3487658501,
0.7176374197,
0.3660305738,
0.7879317403,
0.9030563235,
-0.3317928016,
0.8742585182,
0.0003596531,
0.570877254,
1.1647578478,
0.0088607706,
0.7946007252,
0.0160178374,
-0.1546691209,
0.4856153131,
0.5647228956,
-0.0228584502,
0.4513349235,
-0.1255339086,
-0.6165627241,
-0.599144578,
-0.3209454119,
-0.2063356936,
0.6172100306,
0.1437493861,
-0.0517667979,
-0.4518637955,
0.0551772267,
0.2737824023,
0.2477901429,
-0.5350595117,
0.990393579,
-0.0578977726,
-0.0939738601,
0.0363723524,
0.0648963451,
0.7933095098,
-0.5342819095,
-0.0399658792,
0.0014139728,
0.4663348794,
-0.5908612013,
-0.7564137578,
0.3056987226,
0.1340734959,
-0.3247076273,
-0.1103032455,
1.1837728024,
-0.3919125199,
-0.3907952607,
0.2881604135,
0.3490227759,
0.0867887065,
-0.2440976053,
-0.2272045016,
-0.1957400143,
-0.593429625,
0.0621663034,
0.5868882537,
0.9001205564,
0.0153272646,
0.2369830459,
0.6458397508,
-0.0489586033,
-0.2179916203,
-0.0570927672,
1.0181877613,
-0.5551137328,
-0.4755806923,
-0.9679230452,
0.3682858646,
-0.2996516526,
-0.502769053,
0.8977584243,
0.6999720335,
0.763263166,
0.2807298899,
0.5881780982,
0.0165691841,
0.1923814267,
-0.6106446981,
0.6140470505,
-0.6041592956,
0.1490653157,
-0.7122251391,
-1.3027294874,
-0.6427877545,
0.3861420155,
-0.2386999577,
0.0824076757,
0.8495706916,
0.2681570649,
-0.4470256269,
0.0939079896,
0.3680655062,
-0.1262565702,
-0.0435125381,
0.3215430677,
1.0378671885,
-0.1669874489,
0.701148212,
-0.2433761656,
-0.2667767704,
-0.2339769751,
-0.7078588009,
-1.3171519041,
-0.4988729358,
-0.4152791798,
-0.3329180777,
0.1062514037,
0.8039288521,
0.8334419727,
-0.5164779425,
0.3278978765,
-0.2250755578,
0.1234532446,
-0.0275794808,
-0.2873450816,
0.5521154404,
-0.7943019271,
-0.8575329781,
0.1787946224,
0.4152805507,
0.1936630011,
0.1462141424,
0.4008688033,
0.1553176492,
-0.1615329683,
0.4835438728,
-0.0958831608,
0.1195810065,
-0.1470093131,
-0.5477309227,
-0.4309111834,
-0.0464165844,
0.5761002302,
-0.5149223208,
0.2040352225,
0.4428171813,
0.7142605782,
0.4380488098,
0.1951261759,
-0.2353051752,
-1.0244104862,
0.2457788289,
0.1500294358,
0.1961645335,
0.1810433418,
-0.3557622433,
0.4396649897,
0.4634005129,
-0.5549326539,
-0.867850244,
-0.0800257623,
-1.1407898664,
-0.6960323453,
1.1718724966,
-0.070164375,
-0.3851059377,
-0.2309563607,
-0.4934826791,
0.1565580368,
-0.4437661767,
0.7406300306,
0.5326938033,
0.0843950137,
0.1511887312,
-0.4175029099,
0.1600842029,
0.4243452847,
-1.1028603315,
0.1250350624,
0.4608725607,
-0.1299799234,
0.2394270301,
0.335616529,
-0.0790746361,
-0.0610391833,
0.4894641638,
0.0031085617,
-0.2276595086,
-0.6637273431,
-0.381616652,
0.5857442617,
-0.0677195415,
-0.0413729027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01961v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01961v1 | AToMiC: An Image/Text Retrieval Test Collection to Support Multimedia Content Creation | 2023-04-04T17:11:34 | 2023-04-04T17:11:34 | Jheng-Hong Yang, Carlos Lassance, Rafael Sampaio de Rezende, Krishna Srinivasan, Miriam Redi, Stéphane Clinchant, Jimmy Lin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.CV | This paper presents the AToMiC (Authoring Tools for Multimedia Content)
dataset, designed to advance research in image/text cross-modal retrieval.
While vision-language pretrained transformers have led to significant
improvements in retrieval effectiveness, existing research has relied on
image-caption datasets that feature only simplistic image-text relationships
and underspecified user models of retrieval tasks. To address the gap between
these oversimplified settings and real-world applications for multimedia
content creation, we introduce a new approach for building retrieval test
collections. We leverage hierarchical structures and diverse domains of texts,
styles, and types of images, as well as large-scale image-document associations
embedded in Wikipedia. We formulate two tasks based on a realistic user model
and validate our dataset through retrieval experiments using baseline models.
AToMiC offers a testbed for scalable, diverse, and reproducible multimedia
retrieval research. Finally, the dataset provides the basis for a dedicated
track at the 2023 Text Retrieval Conference (TREC), and is publicly available
at https://github.com/TREC-AToMiC/AToMiC. | [
-0.6594048142,
-0.7911340594,
0.4581305683,
-0.2930253744,
-0.2596886456,
0.0242159907,
0.0226092394,
-0.3584179282,
-0.0196135789,
0.2843307853,
-0.2431984842,
-0.4541382492,
-0.3300985396,
0.2734291553,
-0.7226567268,
0.6719990373,
-0.3352774084,
-0.0909218043,
-0.2706059813,
-0.296379745,
-0.5391475558,
0.255975455,
-0.3809340894,
-0.0044881892,
0.5717433691,
0.561209619,
1.3316496611,
1.0143591166,
0.862191081,
0.2469860166,
0.4838578105,
0.2390215397,
-0.2266848832,
-0.0075108479,
-0.4081245363,
-0.123572886,
-0.0123477532,
-0.038015157,
0.67970258,
0.3215076625,
0.2923483551,
0.0352906138,
-0.5210351944,
0.2321390212,
-1.1699235439,
-0.0329624526,
-0.665078938,
0.3523280621,
-0.3652017117,
-0.436507374,
-0.4205804467,
-0.0158599876,
-0.1180583239,
-0.8056724072,
0.129851073,
0.5238479376,
0.9011478424,
0.1333992928,
-0.7287185788,
-0.1755206436,
-0.5530869365,
0.8029478788,
-0.3352554739,
0.7285894156,
0.5129631162,
0.3469417691,
0.3884921074,
-0.8981896639,
-0.7344882488,
-0.2826065719,
0.1111736223,
0.1979887933,
-0.1125698909,
-0.2397901267,
0.0423123464,
0.8330341578,
-0.6698744297,
0.0258550141,
-0.1308583319,
-0.1067979634,
0.4473998845,
0.3515138328,
0.9460213184,
-0.3998919725,
-0.2456592321,
-0.3138152063,
-0.7863643765,
-0.5402473807,
-0.0216503683,
0.1605902314,
-0.0711560994,
1.0632365942,
-0.2714138925,
0.269384861,
-0.2848814726,
0.3860751987,
0.1628257036,
-0.4751369357,
0.1605499387,
0.0510087684,
0.8309027553,
0.5388408899,
0.2728776634,
-0.3355648518,
-0.3107751012,
0.1536493599,
0.360163182,
-0.9268449545,
-0.2493610233,
-0.0285627116,
-0.5459561348,
-0.1309961826,
0.2657398582,
-0.5454198122,
-0.1939773709,
-0.4180094898,
0.8314587474,
-0.6593034863,
-0.1488344818,
-0.3035723865,
-0.4644332528,
-0.125724569,
-0.0298148841,
-0.6717327237,
0.4605265856,
0.4623321295,
0.8858553171,
-0.5172220469,
-0.5982999802,
-0.4658932686,
0.4415014684,
-0.6515873075,
0.7952286005,
-0.5336238742,
-0.3653506935,
0.194602102,
-0.3656304479,
0.5151679516,
-0.7764191628,
0.1396259665,
-0.906953752,
-0.1078471616,
-0.4022211134,
-0.4892685413,
0.1970028728,
0.1925042272,
-1.1125750542,
0.9946869612,
0.308658421,
-0.9287180305,
0.428162694,
-0.5648081899,
-0.4660806954,
0.1122616678,
-0.6395637393,
-0.2010572851,
0.0396941677,
0.1437408924,
0.1047833413,
-0.5415951014,
0.0811468288,
-0.3496935666,
-0.6618461013,
0.3603294194,
-0.283041507,
0.1039419696,
0.4635620415,
-0.3671765924,
-0.2083935589,
-0.3968010247,
0.0323763713,
0.0653266609,
-0.2691157162,
-0.4610307515,
0.1522954851,
0.5906915069,
0.1484883726,
0.1981372386,
-0.6447425485,
0.0506885275,
0.3075730801,
0.1440669894,
0.5987989306,
0.1768687516,
0.3565815985,
-0.4392931163,
0.2123565674,
0.2260799855,
0.2222642303,
-0.4340911508,
-0.0269564167,
-0.5693949461,
-0.1688529104,
0.2805967331,
0.358874619,
-1.2035514116,
0.1379051059,
-0.5189897418,
-0.401016593,
-0.4165169001,
0.2247733176,
0.4637809098,
0.2461416423,
0.5702033043,
-0.5819905996,
-0.4137749672,
-1.232495904,
-0.0751193762,
-0.1023576409,
-0.0317657962,
0.7583141327,
0.7807424068,
-0.4515467286,
1.0671597719,
-0.5724974871,
-0.2353476584,
0.1087153926,
0.4209050238,
-0.1910755634,
0.5076858401,
0.1271129698,
-1.4137318134,
-0.5091432333,
0.1536931396,
-0.9682430625,
-0.05374033,
-0.034293972,
-0.2576685846,
0.0166247841,
0.4573301077,
-0.7991608977,
0.2900222838,
0.2822739482,
-0.1738251746,
0.5304168463,
0.2253680825,
0.7970924377,
-1.1110275984,
0.3411033154,
-0.1399083734,
-0.2086383253,
0.0913763568,
0.3032608032,
0.2079920918,
-0.3477485478,
-0.5562881231,
0.6780273318,
-0.4353909194,
-0.4269250333,
-0.3351165354,
0.0483009294,
-0.1844225675,
0.1100105345,
0.1651407778,
1.1754314899,
0.5802310705,
-0.4551486671,
0.1757591516,
0.3601775765,
-0.4544769526,
0.9302470088,
-0.6668407321,
-0.0059432839,
-0.0880022198,
-0.0516759753,
-0.8040242195,
-0.3230139017,
-0.0561268367,
-0.2988339365,
0.0396500565,
0.1713033468,
-0.9709761739,
-0.1190307513,
-0.2381097525,
0.7043774724,
0.4141567349,
-0.4308300614,
0.5722950101,
0.468272686,
-0.173676163,
-0.434751451,
-0.6427800059,
0.3672645688,
0.1173303649,
-0.370012939,
0.6842646599,
-0.3636849821,
-0.3319812417,
0.4463122785,
-0.2860079706,
-0.4944510162,
-0.1340090185,
0.3773710728,
0.2760950327,
-0.2103031278,
0.1633822918,
0.0352707915,
-0.0018421148,
-0.2143555284,
0.0550377071,
0.3049019277,
0.0486041829,
-0.3630417585,
-0.3356503248,
0.6013678312,
0.3800223768,
-0.3206720948,
0.1185569391,
0.513508141,
-0.3782610297,
-0.3167279363,
-0.4201497138,
-0.2889396846,
-0.4945157468,
0.4470734298,
-0.341352582,
-0.7276772857,
0.3611271381,
0.0018066134,
0.1119897217,
0.3797369003,
0.4619433284,
-0.2151636928,
0.9116100669,
0.2772528827,
-0.129011929,
0.4952468872,
-0.3991141617,
-0.3836240768,
-0.6659460068,
0.0519373827,
-0.3596156538,
-0.4042410851,
-0.2602155507,
-0.3828665614,
0.2905126512,
-0.2759067416,
-0.4228211939,
0.5595852137,
-0.1083341166,
0.677809298,
0.512624383,
0.3214770555,
0.5383684039,
-0.0279962551,
0.0423180312,
-0.2343330979,
-0.3453416824,
-0.1653552949,
0.9968423247,
-0.2169217765,
0.8517831564,
0.1921798289,
0.4376759827,
0.920578301,
0.3281849921,
-0.6256065369,
0.5011307001,
-0.1587882936,
-1.1342003345,
-0.0581327789,
-0.6685399413,
-0.8486245871,
0.0909789801,
-0.0965173095,
-0.1708846986,
-0.102483362,
-0.0092437854,
0.0878093615,
0.2274617851,
-0.1845592558,
1.0103766918,
-0.1465449184,
-0.3405616581,
-0.34017241,
-0.5184669495,
0.1585203409,
-0.2397936136,
0.3346650898,
-0.0218236651,
-0.3880809247,
0.5004456043,
-0.1927908212,
0.4984432757,
0.2581322491,
0.2381986231,
0.4090533257,
0.675522089,
0.1109917387,
0.1352067441,
0.0520377867,
-0.0701944903,
-0.1844063848,
-0.1079372391,
-0.6856249571,
0.7969205976,
-0.8182575107,
-0.0871235728,
-0.2073427886,
-0.942520082,
0.036327675,
0.6883556247,
0.1886035353,
0.6660943031,
-0.2097913474,
0.4875652492,
0.6905862689,
0.0699467734,
0.3881810904,
0.6178668737,
-0.0648219883,
-0.7179276347,
1.0062035322,
0.0777900442,
0.2080298364,
0.6266764998,
-0.0794355795,
-0.1833250672,
-0.5623991489,
-0.5189177394,
0.1130147651,
-0.7166517377,
-0.4326741397,
-0.3723918498,
0.0222741123,
-0.2290988564,
-0.2741193771,
-0.5796542168,
-0.0620197766,
-0.3375504017,
0.0539325438,
0.2032528371,
0.466999948,
-0.079620637,
0.2044311911,
-0.9380289912,
0.8363884091,
0.0660454333,
0.380699873,
-0.1006455198,
-0.266030848,
-0.4663334489,
-0.1799233109,
-0.4826847017,
-0.8291142583,
0.1268326491,
0.4577789605,
0.38331756,
0.281504184,
0.2469593287,
0.7024820447,
-0.8017284274,
0.6554387808,
-0.0062639811,
-0.9956302643,
0.5545431972,
-0.5029393435,
0.2351173908,
0.8763468862,
0.8557147384,
-0.5855451822,
-0.3174289167,
-0.5795382857,
-0.7803362012,
0.2900337279,
0.3880909383,
0.3196699321,
-0.2659089863,
0.3164614141,
0.0593182705,
0.1117447093,
-0.5684299469,
-0.2032472044,
-0.0265079476,
-0.4395241737,
0.0420612544,
0.0953657553,
-0.131355539,
0.1180009618,
0.6083185077,
-0.2278499454,
0.0419895984,
0.3469281793,
-0.4546028078,
-0.332247436,
-0.1523833722,
-0.3056609929,
0.5468671918,
-0.2311381996,
0.4264806509,
-0.1569336355,
-0.4673293531,
0.0997264683,
-0.0254126433,
-0.2956767976,
0.0405101925,
0.3376228511,
0.3757368326,
0.5519322753,
-1.0642693043,
0.5129531026,
0.1229850575,
0.1195472404,
-0.3484419286,
0.0199705064,
-0.2670774758,
0.0750155449,
0.4761515856,
-0.1880540997,
0.7296490073,
-0.8083478808,
0.8489198089,
0.3258258998,
-0.381219089,
-0.1767038554,
0.7489272952,
-0.0994649678,
-0.0779099911,
1.095913887,
0.0515004732,
-0.0862513781,
0.5369461179,
0.5438562036,
0.5130324364,
0.253015101,
0.3060759306,
0.079402335,
0.1225765646,
-0.0099022826,
0.4072467983,
-0.2622722983,
-0.6553592086,
-0.050195571,
-0.2491027713,
-0.5003941655,
-0.3009101152,
-0.6014885902,
0.2291833907,
-0.3151906133,
-0.2355653644,
0.0443031117,
0.0966345668,
-0.3823712766,
0.4052273035,
0.174409464,
1.1585006714,
-0.8451484442,
0.3710455596,
0.5709214807,
-0.9206377268,
-0.5159544945,
-0.3423570395,
0.0737471506,
-0.517606318,
0.6011081934,
0.0485312231,
0.3292728066,
0.3467105031,
-0.5606436729,
-0.9303565621,
1.3045192957,
0.1739578843,
0.0672302768,
0.1362172067,
0.2608484328,
0.2085171491,
-0.0619462281,
0.4674718976,
0.1292969733,
0.403740257,
0.2084235102,
-0.5930808187,
0.1839171201,
-0.4817192256,
0.2062677294,
0.3113669753,
-0.4067597985,
1.0999878645,
0.0140892016,
-0.3317708373,
0.4140879214,
0.7849285603,
0.4431270957,
0.3768839538,
0.5265920162,
0.8850019574,
0.1180859283,
0.0633886456,
1.257999301,
-0.0844413564,
0.2812225223,
1.0008233786,
-0.3027141392,
1.189917326,
0.5581401587,
0.0068810275,
0.4357931912,
0.7193261981,
-0.3775428534,
0.6416074634,
-0.0471665934,
-0.2229509652,
-0.3447171152,
-0.6234334111,
-0.3329932988,
0.1104217321,
-0.0288140494,
-0.3963150978,
-0.2859989703,
-0.1112337261,
-0.1379350722,
0.0015096837,
-0.1588200331,
0.5393710136,
0.0961763784,
-0.3918127716,
0.0244052615,
-0.1213653088,
0.4560274184,
-0.4876957238,
-0.1561338007,
-0.3006201386,
-0.0259002764,
-0.1681948453,
-0.9789995551,
0.0404613465,
-0.1221558601,
-0.2143247277,
0.1590326726,
0.6358423829,
-0.238863498,
-0.2232462615,
-0.0688882843,
0.290630728,
0.2579497099,
-0.1163559482,
-0.5581934452,
0.4388206899,
-0.5140904784,
-0.1624695361,
0.2457202226,
0.3125922978,
-0.1584510356,
0.5251844525,
0.751337111,
-0.0906976908,
-0.0797112212,
-0.092936039,
0.6968386173,
-0.6895444989,
-0.3177562058,
-0.6357429028,
0.5057466626,
0.0130846677,
-0.3575536311,
0.8771345019,
1.1304024458,
0.9826050401,
-0.2910325527,
0.7324977517,
-0.3685810566,
-0.2783052325,
-0.3653152883,
0.7995512486,
-0.9319084287,
-0.4636616409,
-0.4493531883,
-0.9384721518,
-0.3175403774,
0.1650054157,
0.2478575855,
0.1398441494,
0.7333421707,
0.8700675964,
-0.4159281552,
0.0950772241,
0.1169397011,
-0.0665205792,
0.3446804583,
0.5235003233,
1.0450787544,
-0.8073267341,
0.5481620431,
-0.4472031593,
0.0450877026,
-0.0247541741,
-0.7089626789,
-0.5134580135,
-0.7779814601,
-0.3924281001,
-0.0194221511,
0.1131805182,
0.7171667814,
0.8418694139,
-0.5662525296,
-0.2402054965,
-0.1083394736,
-0.0640590638,
0.0069924071,
-0.2338602096,
0.3315397203,
-0.1903550178,
-0.8345769048,
0.1223556697,
0.0502923429,
0.0873345882,
-0.1655726731,
-0.0807039738,
-0.1233953014,
-0.0807488412,
0.3158064485,
0.3454793394,
-0.2220593095,
-0.1937841028,
0.1381670237,
-0.3119514585,
0.0079008033,
0.8824160099,
-0.598608315,
0.2972778678,
0.5881875753,
0.8610662818,
0.2939225435,
-0.0123543991,
0.3469626307,
-0.6577602029,
-0.2086187452,
0.240621537,
0.270878613,
0.1666751802,
-0.2474198937,
0.467882514,
0.3884917796,
-0.5543314815,
-0.835442543,
0.0788712874,
-1.1145486832,
-0.4714103937,
0.9576977491,
0.2245384157,
-0.1630520523,
0.2958723307,
-0.1762876809,
0.3581982851,
-0.3548049331,
0.9227762818,
0.4129765034,
0.2346517742,
-0.2100274414,
-0.4043667018,
-0.0476606302,
0.2584595084,
-1.0080183744,
-0.1177175418,
0.9467312694,
0.2564113438,
0.3153595626,
0.4995114803,
-0.3860242963,
0.7924444079,
0.2089747638,
0.271946311,
-0.3098957241,
-0.6760577559,
0.2818559408,
0.1459347755,
-0.0857239068,
-0.0072173662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01933v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01933v3 | LLM-Adapters: An Adapter Family for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning of Large Language Models | 2023-04-04T16:31:37 | 2023-10-09T15:38:46 | Zhiqiang Hu, Lei Wang, Yihuai Lan, Wanyu Xu, Ee-Peng Lim, Lidong Bing, Xing Xu, Soujanya Poria, Roy Ka-Wei Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | The success of large language models (LLMs), like GPT-4 and ChatGPT, has led
to the development of numerous cost-effective and accessible alternatives that
are created by finetuning open-access LLMs with task-specific data (e.g.,
ChatDoctor) or instruction data (e.g., Alpaca). Among the various fine-tuning
methods, adapter-based parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) is undoubtedly
one of the most attractive topics, as it only requires fine-tuning a few
external parameters instead of the entire LLMs while achieving comparable or
even better performance. To enable further research on PEFT methods of LLMs,
this paper presents LLM-Adapters, an easy-to-use framework that integrates
various adapters into LLMs and can execute these adapter-based PEFT methods of
LLMs for different tasks. The framework includes state-of-the-art open-access
LLMs such as LLaMA, BLOOM, and GPT-J, as well as widely used adapters such as
Series adapters, Parallel adapter, Prompt-based learning and
Reparametrization-based methods. Moreover, we conduct extensive empirical
studies on the impact of adapter types, placement locations, and
hyper-parameters to the best design for each adapter-based methods. We evaluate
the effectiveness of the adapters on fourteen datasets from two different
reasoning tasks, Arithmetic Reasoning and Commonsense Reasoning. The results
demonstrate that using adapter-based PEFT in smaller-scale LLMs (7B) with few
extra trainable parameters yields comparable, and in some cases superior,
performance to powerful LLMs (175B) in zero-shot inference on both reasoning
tasks. | [
-0.4912012219,
-0.8588386178,
0.6937705278,
0.1381997615,
-0.2487432808,
-0.2996327877,
-0.4372989237,
-0.0315105505,
-0.1897924393,
0.4151159525,
-0.2828681171,
-0.3947750032,
-0.4688172042,
0.0829188153,
0.0258472878,
0.5826418996,
-0.2112714201,
-0.1215482876,
0.1788988858,
-0.0673389137,
-0.1997631192,
-0.2484618574,
-0.7203251719,
-0.1259896457,
0.4889663756,
0.4801316559,
0.4487696588,
0.711825788,
0.4794524312,
0.2535839975,
-0.1735574901,
0.3175561428,
-0.4752798975,
-0.0872973055,
-0.4366382062,
-0.4522167146,
-0.5252978206,
-0.2165495455,
0.5708104372,
0.5188261867,
-0.2474163026,
0.2483395338,
0.0495990515,
0.7956246734,
-0.5983162522,
0.2980823219,
-0.8886936307,
-0.1808731109,
-0.1097243354,
-0.3189364076,
-0.3257820904,
-0.3609919548,
-0.1546593457,
-0.4956309795,
0.0890947953,
0.1797428727,
0.4562694728,
0.2813560665,
-0.2403153926,
-0.263045311,
-0.6271432638,
0.8707751632,
-0.9871811271,
0.423202157,
-0.0123447627,
0.3191389441,
-0.4768389463,
-0.4203784764,
-0.5940632224,
0.034750469,
-0.0774343014,
-0.1175328568,
-0.1203765944,
0.2726627886,
0.1856261194,
0.407563448,
-0.2946687043,
0.289775908,
-0.0861297399,
0.0738356486,
0.4143429399,
0.1256162226,
-0.0329430811,
0.2892615795,
0.0043892036,
0.1687347591,
-1.050154686,
-0.0720039532,
0.2789959311,
0.4835311174,
-0.0842002481,
0.4561722279,
-0.4094085395,
1.0463421345,
0.3594667912,
-0.4210342467,
0.0063363253,
-0.2457718849,
-0.0884425342,
-0.2813639343,
0.634042263,
0.2579805851,
0.3848933578,
-0.2095236778,
-0.2568078041,
-0.3299437761,
-0.1988473982,
-0.9446316957,
-0.250477463,
-0.0523363128,
-0.5180588365,
-0.2229046524,
-0.2946011424,
-0.8245744705,
-0.2415815741,
-0.3949145079,
0.5780083537,
-0.2347087264,
-0.0682909861,
0.2243459672,
0.1379941404,
0.5362153649,
0.5799501538,
-0.9626278281,
0.3131138682,
0.5454820991,
0.7203512788,
-0.3334280849,
-0.2252125144,
-0.7198565006,
0.1503714174,
-0.0982957631,
0.9779500365,
-0.7250074744,
-0.1891870797,
-0.1613544822,
0.2004604042,
-0.4305506647,
-0.5751928687,
0.6687345505,
-0.5362789035,
-0.0685426518,
-0.1928673238,
-0.6500245929,
-0.291194886,
0.2870087326,
-0.3779509664,
0.7603037953,
0.0518211387,
-0.4429140389,
0.0760108382,
-0.8269016147,
-0.3521031439,
-0.1440217197,
-0.1485267282,
-0.2955692112,
0.2432001531,
0.3426971138,
0.5714254379,
-0.5769937634,
0.0044524353,
-0.4329959154,
-0.5774196982,
0.0608504489,
-0.6614900827,
0.3230620921,
0.1400286108,
-0.2590897381,
0.0517788939,
-0.8024459481,
-0.1077677682,
0.2146685719,
-0.7427917123,
-0.1052744985,
0.2690047026,
-0.1595791429,
0.1388124973,
0.240586549,
-0.5239011049,
0.2127703428,
-0.442499876,
0.6098616719,
0.7625678182,
-0.1200935394,
0.3240829408,
-0.3815150559,
0.276627332,
0.0213088077,
-0.0149508668,
-0.361671716,
-0.4082547724,
-0.7826877236,
-0.3417029977,
0.2474689782,
0.5802324414,
-0.4929901958,
0.4979029,
-0.0830384269,
-0.6166652441,
-0.3562081456,
0.3120663464,
0.1733525693,
0.6638256311,
0.2326510549,
0.223155722,
-0.1477790922,
-0.839053154,
-0.4966982007,
-0.0781600922,
-0.0523453057,
0.4668984711,
0.1181536838,
-0.0130826002,
0.6697910428,
-0.5116441846,
0.0111558782,
-0.0116890669,
-0.4641200602,
0.5233308077,
0.2818029523,
0.6069334149,
-0.4090792239,
-0.5069590211,
0.1671340615,
-0.2636097372,
-0.1809837371,
0.1659819931,
0.0297080223,
0.1729495525,
0.435932368,
-0.2240785509,
0.0233482514,
0.6740169525,
-0.407389462,
0.3985775709,
-0.1912700534,
0.0569602512,
-0.8451634645,
-0.0297180396,
0.0588151999,
-0.3728882968,
-0.5986453295,
0.0538174398,
0.1410621107,
0.2437354773,
-0.5787013173,
0.6189190745,
-0.1857012957,
0.202185452,
-0.3639730215,
0.0019325836,
-0.0698513165,
0.6403140426,
-0.1293483824,
0.9121767879,
0.6492348313,
-0.5524868369,
0.202033937,
-0.1208690703,
-0.0507478341,
0.4113816023,
-0.5619639754,
0.3142974675,
-0.1401262879,
-0.0327557959,
-1.0448124409,
0.0815287232,
0.325083524,
0.1263031363,
0.0843018442,
-0.4038470089,
-0.5790070295,
-0.0361773595,
-0.4559649527,
0.3021953106,
0.4840888679,
-0.8636007905,
0.8738301992,
0.1724983752,
-0.3163997829,
-0.1125836298,
-0.2852994502,
-0.3268788159,
-0.5472216606,
-0.4180083573,
0.2883676887,
-0.3331567347,
-0.1629472971,
-0.258128643,
-0.160215646,
0.0171910897,
0.0983898565,
0.0737927184,
0.1873985082,
-0.4589547217,
-0.008959814,
0.4012670815,
-0.1043024361,
-0.2561610043,
-0.1675304621,
0.4949192703,
-0.5457292795,
-0.5413340926,
-0.1481819451,
0.1487775594,
0.6007799506,
-0.0064230449,
0.6648281813,
0.3630336523,
-0.2402445525,
-0.0337682739,
-0.8612199426,
-0.0404372364,
-0.5425994396,
0.3233094513,
-0.5055817962,
-1.1450496912,
0.359828949,
-0.5580147505,
0.3468983769,
0.351462692,
0.7868800759,
0.0504421517,
0.8017036319,
0.3782483339,
-0.1185404137,
0.4555608332,
0.200431928,
0.1865020096,
-0.8529298902,
0.1313443035,
-0.4949993789,
-0.3634601831,
-0.5091882348,
-0.5075668693,
0.1281881928,
0.3132009208,
-0.4343765974,
0.2317539155,
-0.417835921,
0.6974361539,
0.3739348054,
-0.0198633298,
0.5893780589,
-0.030351555,
-0.0206059124,
0.1841194481,
-0.615798533,
-0.562709868,
1.1645575762,
0.3632810116,
0.9093691707,
0.1479429007,
0.5229279995,
-0.1355287284,
0.2543719411,
-1.0247926712,
0.5128041506,
-0.4836265743,
-0.238773033,
-0.1917878836,
-0.2930271626,
-0.6141369939,
0.3913632035,
-0.0180749577,
-0.7996724844,
0.5430307388,
0.4604648054,
-0.2995300591,
0.4331270754,
-0.9576248527,
0.4851047099,
-0.2475019395,
-0.2305150479,
-0.1514879763,
-0.1478625238,
0.0998879969,
-0.4085940421,
0.374990046,
-0.4104804993,
-0.3537408113,
0.6319178343,
-0.167155087,
0.7250418067,
-0.3506346345,
-0.2340020537,
0.1833277047,
0.0437702499,
0.7830471992,
0.2021922171,
-0.4664732218,
0.2273706645,
0.2549810708,
-0.3039862812,
-0.5157042146,
0.9485036731,
-0.7234426141,
-0.6457046866,
0.0225435589,
-0.750181675,
-0.4074545801,
0.3203829527,
-0.1517829001,
0.1864363104,
0.1291159093,
0.2229441404,
0.6911262274,
-0.1458114386,
0.4757992327,
1.021941781,
-0.2400031984,
-0.3295564651,
1.013730526,
0.0838897228,
0.2321439534,
0.5614776015,
0.3813606501,
-0.0326699391,
-0.9152360559,
-0.4225995243,
0.4414834678,
-0.4960166216,
-0.2337173969,
-0.2665916085,
-0.096741043,
-0.0391002521,
-0.2202712148,
-0.3341194391,
-0.5026106834,
-0.2221657336,
0.2089211345,
0.6600341797,
0.223903209,
0.1851922423,
0.5580542088,
-0.4960563779,
0.424718082,
0.4245993495,
0.6234320402,
-0.0968659222,
-0.6291707754,
0.0165843386,
-0.1572276503,
-0.3891981542,
-0.5340391994,
-0.0309030227,
0.4716341197,
0.5850060582,
0.443826735,
-0.0700192675,
0.6787246466,
-0.5590398908,
0.3533076942,
-0.1751876771,
-0.6918902397,
0.4168300331,
-0.4773411453,
0.1748944819,
0.607763648,
0.0119458241,
-0.1662404239,
0.0670376644,
-0.1017451286,
-0.7082360387,
0.817304492,
0.0925711021,
0.1357937604,
0.048466295,
0.7674434781,
0.2682785094,
0.0275435634,
-0.4187931716,
-0.3325861394,
0.0651157051,
-0.3244883418,
-0.0602899753,
-0.2297802866,
0.0221343171,
-0.3706952035,
0.7320452929,
-0.5613072515,
0.2648987472,
-0.0560780503,
-0.0518249944,
-0.1034546494,
0.5251005292,
0.432661891,
0.5507822633,
-0.2629462183,
0.1350942552,
0.6101579666,
-0.2734257877,
0.0845023468,
0.3142603934,
-0.1931424886,
-0.2377704233,
-0.0177240167,
0.7207990885,
0.2408029735,
-0.8410493731,
0.2532915175,
-0.1112781465,
-0.2180961818,
-0.063168101,
0.437070936,
0.441302985,
0.3716237843,
0.0131425401,
-0.0280733928,
0.1166363284,
-0.3289458752,
-0.0664147288,
0.4491494298,
-0.2456057519,
-0.3533824682,
0.3507751524,
0.1862075776,
-0.4696268737,
0.1874662936,
0.0829219446,
-0.0287016761,
0.3074710965,
0.7837051749,
0.5593221188,
-0.2433458716,
-0.2884885371,
0.1357307881,
0.2113815248,
-0.048404891,
0.3498647511,
-0.0670361742,
-0.8009305,
-0.5571485162,
-0.798294425,
-0.4563601017,
0.2836240232,
-0.3251176476,
0.3697375953,
-0.4464501739,
0.1578309089,
-0.0281465016,
-0.2501834333,
-0.738599956,
-0.2026920617,
-0.0085923942,
1.3054448366,
-0.5516511202,
0.9805473089,
0.8702664375,
0.1747946292,
-0.7913424969,
0.0845158845,
0.0108411433,
-1.1051901579,
0.077677384,
-0.1151011065,
-0.1041239873,
0.2779816687,
-0.0828224048,
-0.9101979136,
1.1398822069,
0.7139071822,
-1.0648349524,
-0.1662813425,
0.1739597172,
0.2574400604,
-0.2178311199,
0.2168663889,
0.9690909386,
0.5490419269,
0.1243477389,
-0.8908317089,
0.1597566307,
-0.1707272977,
0.0012875666,
0.3925714791,
-0.8214380741,
0.5548505783,
0.121560216,
0.367885828,
0.0922410563,
0.3187305927,
0.6266241074,
0.0427658483,
0.7169911861,
0.3586698771,
0.4713086188,
-0.0572725497,
0.7064999342,
-0.4822643399,
0.4597808123,
1.0306745768,
-0.0684878081,
0.9440360069,
0.6550490856,
-0.4896682799,
0.2170817256,
0.2314041704,
0.0100335861,
0.3896684647,
0.2501235902,
-0.3130637705,
-0.3167085052,
0.2581505775,
-0.1753955185,
0.1422359496,
0.6375584006,
-0.3858231306,
-0.4511923194,
-0.148535043,
0.0455510467,
-0.1783539057,
-0.407384485,
0.8607645631,
0.2651857734,
-0.4410267472,
0.4698451161,
0.2029866278,
0.9383406043,
-0.428478986,
-0.0359050483,
-0.1279281974,
0.3934340477,
-0.2109154314,
-0.7224774361,
0.3661444783,
-0.0259425938,
-0.244285807,
0.1424942166,
0.9207643867,
-0.2396526337,
-0.6188857555,
0.2357190102,
0.5183613896,
0.0771764368,
-0.2418111712,
-0.6565559506,
0.0297734402,
-0.0967082828,
-0.3929696083,
0.4614798725,
0.3545564413,
0.1110436246,
0.5241870284,
0.5937827826,
0.1682055146,
0.038061399,
-0.0364524387,
0.9440153241,
-0.5824639201,
-0.1201925427,
-1.0019652843,
0.2035382688,
0.3786394,
-0.041554179,
0.5575363636,
0.5305665731,
0.6088362932,
-0.023620829,
0.7845489383,
0.0140528316,
0.5951824188,
-0.5422956944,
0.4887488186,
-0.3567435443,
0.451244235,
-0.1505000293,
-1.0331761837,
-0.3823986351,
0.5277729034,
-0.5812515616,
-0.0043804022,
0.2597339451,
0.8866003156,
-0.2983835936,
0.0008545367,
0.3045580089,
0.2049355507,
0.5248310566,
0.580080688,
0.4885261357,
-0.3211383522,
0.6559978724,
-0.2897091806,
-0.3032548428,
-0.2982800305,
-0.9322263002,
-1.0082606077,
-0.2500621378,
-0.2055644095,
0.0280675124,
0.2248335183,
0.9610718489,
0.6504226923,
-0.9467458725,
-0.2079292536,
-0.3129828572,
0.1251780093,
-0.026383223,
-0.235214591,
0.467161417,
-0.228543371,
-0.7320134044,
0.5057125092,
0.3854066432,
-0.0934331045,
0.0974848345,
-0.1994067132,
0.1005219743,
0.3350900114,
0.7549625039,
0.2620465159,
-0.8097858429,
-0.2917802632,
-0.0355679616,
0.4600331783,
0.2806603014,
0.5783032179,
-0.822829783,
0.235572055,
0.4649920464,
0.6131949425,
0.2753448188,
-0.154071182,
0.4938548803,
-0.2562846243,
-0.0601492412,
-0.1673824638,
0.6742691398,
0.0409215093,
-0.1984889805,
0.2639756203,
0.0122399563,
-0.6929576993,
-0.7593825459,
0.1768006384,
-0.9898927212,
-0.0491620637,
1.147151947,
-0.1870244294,
-0.0858740509,
-0.0828792825,
-0.5115967393,
-0.0010713199,
-0.5077517033,
0.6709656715,
0.3971085846,
-0.4065939486,
-0.4261977673,
-0.3135128915,
0.1644236445,
0.1715713739,
-0.9794291854,
0.1340531111,
0.1435800195,
0.706402719,
-0.0979313254,
0.4315213561,
-0.2554138899,
0.045957353,
-0.4488160908,
-0.3504486382,
-0.2978643179,
0.0374647416,
-0.4508244991,
0.1833408475,
0.5262240171,
0.034994185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01922v1 | Resources and Few-shot Learners for In-context Learning in Slavic Languages | 2023-04-04T16:16:25 | 2023-04-04T16:16:25 | Michal Štefánik, Marek Kadlčík, Piotr Gramacki, Petr Sojka | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the rapid recent progress in creating accurate and compact in-context
learners, most recent work focuses on in-context learning (ICL) for tasks in
English. However, the ability to interact with users of languages outside
English presents a great potential for broadening the applicability of language
technologies to non-English speakers.
In this work, we collect the infrastructure necessary for training and
evaluation of ICL in a selection of Slavic languages: Czech, Polish, and
Russian. We link a diverse set of datasets and cast these into a unified
instructional format through a set of transformations and newly-crafted
templates written purely in target languages. Using the newly-curated dataset,
we evaluate a set of the most recent in-context learners and compare their
results to the supervised baselines. Finally, we train, evaluate and publish a
set of in-context learning models that we train on the collected resources and
compare their performance to previous work.
We find that ICL models tuned in English are also able to learn some tasks
from non-English contexts, but multilingual instruction fine-tuning
consistently improves the ICL ability. We also find that the massive multitask
training can be outperformed by single-task training in the target language,
uncovering the potential for specializing in-context learners to the
language(s) of their application. | [
-0.1341175586,
-0.37174505,
0.4714196622,
-0.0494006649,
-0.2875475585,
0.319462657,
-0.6241065264,
-0.4103362858,
-0.1143727452,
0.1936626732,
-0.6318102479,
-0.8145930171,
-0.2136148065,
0.2870839536,
-0.0248472281,
1.0957438946,
-0.093657963,
0.6573576331,
-0.2771159708,
-0.2994933724,
-0.7542927265,
-0.4044097066,
-0.2513943017,
-0.2888203561,
0.3165112734,
1.0948796272,
-0.0900489241,
0.0419448316,
0.2669526339,
0.2165815234,
0.2227251232,
0.1737017035,
-0.4383808374,
0.0778578371,
-0.3376475573,
-0.3344142735,
0.0559888743,
-0.0991553739,
0.8538840413,
0.8724321127,
0.2978926003,
0.5359372497,
0.3963639438,
0.595895648,
-0.7413492799,
0.137978971,
-0.8789693713,
0.1154863536,
-0.370583564,
-0.0948919728,
-0.7529782653,
0.1138581038,
0.1270916611,
-0.6529017687,
-0.0516423732,
0.0268294718,
0.3734917641,
-0.0516586676,
-0.6308503747,
-0.3901493847,
-0.632840693,
1.0865806341,
-0.3478500843,
0.6343817115,
0.5454298258,
0.2310814559,
-0.0774682015,
-0.3258162141,
-0.0118238321,
-0.3479442596,
-0.2080578059,
0.1435735822,
-0.0020599663,
0.0002767421,
0.0883569121,
-0.1435188204,
-0.6548724174,
0.092395097,
-0.4606127739,
-0.1736803353,
0.4376406074,
0.2447873801,
0.1935254633,
-0.043843247,
-0.3270341158,
0.1910684109,
-0.7756022215,
0.2330846041,
0.4240689874,
0.8441460729,
-0.3493351638,
0.527341485,
-0.1961011738,
0.8039702773,
0.2565741837,
-0.6851511002,
0.2010668516,
-0.6089974642,
-0.0231448859,
0.0136706047,
0.2893202901,
-0.0268779732,
-0.0111811943,
-0.4887390137,
-0.0579605699,
-0.3189385235,
0.073758252,
-0.4694969952,
-0.016111061,
0.0065583154,
-0.3059315979,
0.3117999434,
-0.2006072849,
-0.5721378326,
-0.0195891112,
-0.6108407378,
0.3994594216,
-0.5342535973,
-0.1132719293,
-0.1338329166,
0.1248151511,
0.090118207,
0.1671266705,
-0.9528384209,
0.384003371,
0.4263596535,
0.7595697641,
-0.4048282206,
-0.5579808354,
-0.6802078485,
0.0559909455,
-0.3518303037,
0.7535963058,
-0.5212284923,
-0.1292072535,
0.3944596052,
0.145798862,
-0.0935650691,
-0.4581269324,
0.0844647884,
-0.3325614929,
0.1934096813,
-0.0849997997,
-0.5619724393,
-0.0140072843,
0.4232865572,
-0.4083417952,
0.8542383313,
0.4869014025,
-0.7080625892,
0.8006816506,
-0.7153889537,
-0.5749514103,
0.4643658102,
-0.0040062461,
-0.1190263703,
0.0440155827,
-0.3706654012,
0.407091409,
-0.0183145329,
0.0606399588,
-0.1384299546,
-0.3906211853,
-0.0199837852,
-0.1009953544,
0.8443379402,
0.1660436392,
-0.3337879181,
0.1510442197,
-0.6820855141,
0.2909353673,
-0.2742520273,
-0.768885076,
-0.3956283331,
-0.2466767579,
0.5466858745,
0.4216233194,
0.18477723,
-0.6964550614,
0.0812248588,
-0.4687075615,
0.1394992322,
0.3279224038,
-0.1725114584,
0.939311862,
0.1290431917,
0.6952270865,
-0.0243232064,
0.0882207677,
-0.2307764143,
-0.0365407206,
-0.5483494401,
-0.24603948,
0.1163112298,
0.4895154238,
-1.0286470652,
0.1173470318,
-0.0949331895,
-0.4600983262,
-0.3517237008,
0.5341016054,
0.7993688583,
0.5677027702,
0.3114587069,
0.0667030588,
-0.6591268182,
-0.7445707321,
-0.2970759273,
0.1020742208,
0.0977900326,
0.2567501962,
0.688703537,
0.2821621299,
0.7720298767,
0.077225402,
-0.2657122314,
-0.6513289213,
-0.2602918148,
0.0427845344,
0.5695967078,
0.385436058,
-0.576431632,
-1.3770873547,
0.3159836829,
-0.5929272771,
0.3457638621,
0.0315864719,
-0.0705944598,
0.5056781769,
0.4203253984,
-0.2132465988,
0.162548393,
0.4663702548,
-0.3924878836,
0.5136918426,
-0.1130398437,
0.0783547908,
-1.080014348,
0.2034127414,
-0.0947257802,
-0.2426653057,
-0.8169721365,
0.0086458949,
0.2406154424,
-0.2564807534,
-1.0468600988,
0.9056981206,
-0.5417814255,
-0.1639652103,
-0.1647026539,
0.147961393,
-0.2400094569,
0.3919157684,
0.0805407912,
0.8814173341,
0.6740518212,
-0.3874261379,
-0.0572429709,
0.3303637207,
-0.7807192802,
0.7613789439,
-0.0228759218,
0.1775810272,
-0.1095653176,
0.0282038394,
-0.8059796095,
-0.3454546034,
0.1943233162,
-0.0641800091,
0.4597536922,
-0.5907728076,
-0.5327390432,
0.0890787244,
0.0838484466,
0.2997980118,
0.1475911885,
-0.6115876436,
0.2689484656,
0.3878022432,
0.0803141221,
-0.6902215481,
-0.6211138964,
-0.0506394804,
-0.5607894063,
-0.2449810952,
0.132662788,
-0.3180508614,
-0.414208889,
-0.1561617702,
0.0720430762,
-0.4820011854,
0.1470974237,
0.0130683286,
0.2349185646,
-0.1277669668,
0.5180073977,
-0.0447925068,
-0.1209726036,
-0.4330658019,
-0.7117007971,
0.3076249659,
-0.2790668309,
-0.3985313177,
-0.3300962448,
0.6627486944,
0.4603104591,
-0.1427594423,
0.7715588212,
0.5209561586,
-0.3149008453,
-0.2048566639,
-0.3359377384,
-0.2382546067,
-0.3825488687,
0.5322016478,
-0.3908826709,
-0.8765822053,
0.3984926641,
-0.1167269647,
0.1994705498,
-0.0299509149,
0.4268271029,
-0.2138104588,
0.9770408273,
0.9782735705,
0.0975068435,
0.7128878832,
-0.2938019335,
0.1896164864,
-0.6841313839,
-0.3670239747,
-0.3520975709,
-0.2192607373,
-0.3743263185,
-0.0140756657,
0.52156955,
-0.0355696641,
-0.2725348771,
0.5356516838,
-0.1230053082,
0.836134553,
0.4815951586,
0.1133149341,
0.1705838293,
0.2282251269,
-0.1369548142,
-0.3006055951,
-0.9829490185,
-0.5673595667,
1.1668865681,
-0.1226579994,
0.5916007757,
0.009077074,
0.6523432732,
-0.0202495735,
0.105347015,
-0.8088882565,
0.2407295704,
-0.2874988616,
-0.9194913507,
-0.3849447072,
0.0282766279,
-0.8184787631,
0.2186217457,
-0.2346566021,
-0.8945349455,
0.0205448698,
0.2889460027,
-0.2502659261,
0.2351078689,
-0.8868644834,
1.125447154,
-0.2951409221,
-0.767994225,
-0.291536808,
-0.5947703123,
0.1020113155,
-0.1799873412,
0.1835861057,
0.0105218766,
-0.0498545282,
0.2887150347,
0.1846335977,
1.0888061523,
-0.2849698961,
0.2801631391,
0.3355326056,
0.0556190908,
0.293512702,
0.1440037936,
-0.0666945204,
-0.0300354548,
0.0432392918,
-0.7431359887,
-0.2998659313,
0.54696697,
-0.4178225994,
-0.2315351516,
-0.2399586588,
-0.6533743739,
-0.3936969638,
0.2044412643,
0.5339168906,
0.5744385123,
-0.3486978114,
0.3218362629,
0.4735996127,
0.0601118281,
0.4575368464,
0.9285923243,
0.2991860211,
-0.1177018136,
0.7334939241,
0.1635549217,
0.4436427057,
0.3414130807,
-0.0234403145,
-0.1813404262,
-0.624176681,
-0.5626141429,
-0.028002914,
-0.9690247774,
-0.30128631,
-0.1864432693,
0.1780676097,
-0.0889898911,
-0.4910463095,
-0.505967617,
-0.0760761276,
-0.2693468332,
0.0703869537,
-0.0153300371,
0.7918254137,
0.0205504335,
0.2692624927,
-0.579671979,
-0.4739916325,
0.0855406076,
0.3437523246,
-0.1644836664,
-0.5484852791,
-0.9926174879,
-0.0146629456,
-0.2732692957,
-0.65313977,
0.3559315503,
0.5260280967,
0.6328288913,
0.1008295566,
-0.0641226172,
0.7452653646,
-0.8256946206,
0.7424989343,
0.1161895692,
-0.9327256083,
0.495811373,
-0.2074006498,
0.6654674411,
1.0001114607,
0.6132721901,
-0.5988977551,
-0.2105000317,
-0.341920644,
-0.5877511501,
0.955724895,
-0.2167533189,
0.308665067,
0.0123107657,
0.2529188395,
0.4969608486,
0.174345687,
-0.8100650311,
-0.1340059638,
-0.1061169952,
-0.2426004708,
-0.1393122226,
0.009122394,
-0.1430856884,
-0.2748143375,
0.7127175331,
-0.6272895336,
-0.2047813982,
-0.1701916009,
-0.5179523826,
-0.1857117265,
0.4572792947,
0.5296217203,
0.9661660194,
0.1775001585,
0.0166940819,
0.5926164985,
-0.3137466311,
0.2457030714,
-0.4020217359,
-0.2088374943,
-0.0742302313,
0.4692570865,
0.6964764595,
0.9194149971,
-1.0268528461,
0.5398849249,
-0.013708842,
-0.0807479918,
-0.5775077939,
-0.2441010773,
-0.086773172,
0.3691800535,
0.3070312738,
0.0429816432,
0.1603586078,
-0.6762983799,
0.0977623239,
0.6510682702,
-0.5082371235,
-0.6578915119,
0.0243407674,
0.2178311944,
-0.3864559829,
0.499291867,
-0.3731036782,
-0.24477759,
0.3092654943,
0.9431422949,
0.7388691902,
-0.0260197371,
0.2557099164,
0.6549651027,
0.1092061773,
0.2243290395,
0.263366282,
-0.4190950096,
-0.4248525798,
-0.4456550181,
-0.3851965368,
-0.2939303815,
0.2045897394,
-0.5441283584,
0.5025092959,
-0.1395541877,
0.1051611602,
-0.1466194391,
0.1597571969,
-0.9651969671,
-0.1797055602,
0.0156030636,
0.7594236732,
-1.1897995472,
0.9624914527,
1.1299512386,
-0.2943711281,
-0.404687047,
0.002964997,
0.064938657,
-0.3023965359,
1.065861702,
0.049188517,
-0.0124821886,
-0.1386040747,
-0.5673696399,
-1.123242259,
0.9121561646,
0.7078371644,
-0.3056491315,
0.035249427,
-0.0150184305,
0.5143162012,
-0.7235350609,
0.1267121434,
0.2309633195,
0.2609399259,
-0.2099146098,
-1.0407273769,
-0.6036410332,
-0.0653828606,
-0.2775475681,
0.0500692017,
-0.5807353854,
0.5421446562,
0.0054509798,
-0.4263795018,
-0.0389398932,
0.3378897607,
0.0392594971,
0.3709819317,
0.3850207627,
-0.0839803889,
0.5450075269,
0.1389845014,
0.6671052575,
-0.3951146603,
0.113679722,
1.3167080879,
-0.1752584428,
0.9312865734,
0.6531279087,
-0.034197282,
0.4078808129,
0.6482843161,
0.2503319085,
0.7246541381,
-0.146298632,
-0.5585780144,
-0.4543800354,
-0.3833980262,
0.1799207926,
0.7277062535,
0.2625901997,
0.0915272832,
-0.4271715283,
0.7209308147,
-0.0451624654,
0.3572707176,
-0.3303618133,
0.8427131176,
-0.1477683485,
-0.7298968434,
0.4260008633,
-0.3169597983,
0.5778790116,
-0.762491703,
-0.0104065314,
-0.0350952484,
0.1250322312,
-0.2285171896,
-0.6043551564,
0.3488643169,
0.2381724268,
-0.3242980838,
-0.2757779062,
0.6369162202,
-0.8955793977,
-0.4115562439,
0.3635488749,
0.4433799684,
0.3865659535,
0.3694240749,
-0.4595785141,
-0.2205963135,
-0.0649193153,
0.2167334259,
0.7366555929,
0.157216683,
0.0050367964,
0.5895627737,
0.2651255131,
0.0311079063,
0.0345974155,
-0.1784845442,
0.6760514975,
-0.108408004,
-0.3910717964,
-0.4853386283,
0.9102639556,
0.1691794693,
-0.6484072208,
1.0401785374,
0.7627207637,
1.476141572,
-0.4525855482,
0.7154775262,
0.0523700714,
0.4828377068,
-0.5608587265,
0.4522830248,
-0.708310008,
-0.2176840752,
-0.0248176996,
-0.7091181874,
-0.1929652542,
0.4139589071,
-0.1341329068,
-0.1728235334,
0.8612200618,
0.4355093241,
-0.2586347163,
-0.3729760051,
0.7156911492,
-0.2495837361,
-0.1176142171,
0.4808272123,
0.628313303,
-0.2545934618,
0.4907435775,
-0.579123199,
-0.0369014591,
-0.1194746569,
-0.7800517678,
-1.1904059649,
-1.1095232964,
-0.1390764415,
0.011995865,
0.2836492062,
1.3456287384,
1.0797811747,
-0.9314028025,
-0.615062952,
0.0706103221,
0.0749390423,
-0.1417854875,
-0.0919926092,
0.1588280499,
-0.9255371094,
-0.9155339003,
0.9469236732,
0.350332886,
-0.0342990495,
-0.4095497429,
-0.1038586944,
-0.2193351835,
-0.5116214752,
0.8097115159,
0.4218019247,
-0.7812899351,
-0.177718848,
0.3152373135,
0.0375779904,
0.0497403257,
0.8493561149,
-0.7488613725,
0.6677649617,
0.338126719,
0.425519824,
0.415022701,
-0.3884482682,
0.3139255643,
-1.0627890825,
0.5645097494,
0.3325189352,
0.2782050073,
0.4853565395,
-0.3483038843,
0.3257369697,
-0.0957952216,
-0.4603052437,
-0.8178431392,
0.2169952095,
-0.3795894682,
-0.2395037264,
1.0014908314,
-0.3881153166,
-0.0530599356,
-0.5758280754,
-0.0314078331,
0.100462772,
-0.2584853172,
0.6623495817,
0.888353169,
-0.0836536288,
0.0090785436,
-0.7594504356,
0.700039804,
0.2852312028,
-0.7463089824,
0.0967707783,
0.3010129929,
0.3781847954,
0.0686594546,
0.4038052857,
0.0958604962,
0.4923794866,
-0.0302963592,
0.0190043505,
0.1536301672,
-0.7162424922,
-0.6372208595,
-0.0992608219,
0.236252442,
-0.0856803209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01904v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01904v2 | REFINER: Reasoning Feedback on Intermediate Representations | 2023-04-04T15:57:28 | 2024-02-04T12:15:18 | Debjit Paul, Mete Ismayilzada, Maxime Peyrard, Beatriz Borges, Antoine Bosselut, Robert West, Boi Faltings | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) have recently shown remarkable performance on reasoning
tasks by explicitly generating intermediate inferences, e.g., chain-of-thought
prompting. However, these intermediate inference steps may be inappropriate
deductions from the initial context and lead to incorrect final predictions.
Here we introduce REFINER, a framework for finetuning LMs to explicitly
generate intermediate reasoning steps while interacting with a critic model
that provides automated feedback on the reasoning. Specifically, the critic
provides structured feedback that the reasoning LM uses to iteratively improve
its intermediate arguments. Empirical evaluations of REFINER on three diverse
reasoning tasks show significant improvements over baseline LMs of comparable
scale. Furthermore, when using GPT-3.5 or ChatGPT as the reasoner, the trained
critic significantly improves reasoning without finetuning the reasoner.
Finally, our critic model is trained without expensive human-in-the-loop data
but can be substituted with humans at inference time. | [
-0.4659341276,
-0.5775256753,
0.901098609,
-0.3027433157,
0.0228511579,
-0.2005434334,
-0.6065137982,
-0.2328618169,
-0.0934070498,
0.625638485,
-0.5393535495,
-0.0855301097,
-0.3354495764,
0.0812271759,
-0.452368021,
1.070371151,
-0.1646391451,
0.1501360685,
-0.1105589867,
-0.0051325415,
-0.4191626608,
-0.3538402021,
-0.9679419398,
-0.5575444698,
0.8407893777,
0.7002820373,
0.612991035,
0.261839211,
0.2214071155,
0.36402753,
0.2670226097,
0.2487213761,
-0.4770058095,
0.2960041761,
-0.9006490707,
-0.6213366389,
0.118423298,
-0.0820150226,
0.3650412858,
0.629963398,
-0.3211011887,
0.1662825644,
-0.0395858586,
0.7561681271,
-0.7019483447,
0.152174443,
-0.7053739429,
-0.4443272054,
0.0832400694,
-0.1046281084,
-0.8676704168,
-0.389003396,
0.0735930204,
-0.5799542665,
0.2952578664,
0.1130832657,
0.9129018188,
0.697778523,
-0.1335583776,
-0.1860100031,
-1.0672146082,
0.4442681968,
-0.7448939681,
0.4373220205,
0.17827636,
0.6644086242,
-0.1297837049,
-1.1198488474,
-0.7963829041,
-0.4890000224,
-0.4149760902,
-0.0283010136,
-0.2065201551,
0.3482801914,
0.4781044424,
0.2434942424,
-0.027984485,
-0.2219809592,
-0.3005811274,
-0.093332544,
0.3501516879,
0.1546535939,
-0.0961080939,
0.0666813105,
-0.0326939784,
-0.0992074832,
-0.6238310933,
0.1025575772,
0.2553950548,
0.2744042873,
0.4532157481,
0.3695097268,
-0.5574354529,
0.7036975622,
0.3665276468,
0.3775945008,
-0.1639952511,
-0.1369669139,
-0.2653011978,
-0.2181548923,
0.487611562,
0.5456959605,
0.5144643188,
-0.0612352639,
-0.4468258619,
0.4089972079,
0.3726791143,
-0.8676957488,
-0.6749802828,
0.1228865087,
-0.2207337171,
-0.0557433479,
0.0938942954,
-0.3674123585,
-0.3466613889,
-0.7367481589,
0.1513204426,
-0.3022211492,
-0.2737874985,
0.1214978695,
-0.1989227682,
-0.0651106238,
0.5917525291,
-0.6578503847,
0.4580203593,
0.3361294568,
0.2422409654,
0.3914645314,
-0.2160757929,
-0.7542577386,
0.1747714132,
-0.332031548,
1.2374176979,
-0.8250821829,
-0.1008401439,
-0.0889207423,
0.1285781413,
0.1701198667,
-0.6478508115,
0.7314644456,
-0.4102786183,
0.1572210044,
-0.4346405268,
-0.5492831469,
-0.5230127573,
0.3463592529,
-0.641123116,
0.8946545124,
0.1118680835,
-0.6295573711,
0.217337817,
-0.5461221337,
-0.0451888293,
-0.0087224562,
-0.3464002907,
0.0740456283,
0.2545425296,
0.2847942412,
0.1229863763,
-0.3372618854,
0.5009088516,
-0.4266255796,
-0.5145756602,
0.2285314053,
-0.4606269002,
0.1014423296,
0.2877912819,
-0.3472213447,
0.4157522023,
-0.6819841862,
0.0895285606,
-0.1028235331,
-0.2506582737,
-0.1087475568,
0.2290783525,
-0.170943886,
0.185029,
-0.1432441473,
-0.3056191504,
0.3663438857,
-0.1204357594,
0.6173146963,
0.8662022948,
0.1586367488,
0.4789075851,
-0.3557216823,
0.3645515144,
-0.0220694151,
-0.0736266449,
-0.3692406714,
-0.0745502934,
-1.4043321609,
0.2187666297,
0.4812123477,
0.3277809024,
-0.9553223848,
-0.0867223516,
-0.0933508277,
-0.3650892377,
-0.5740405321,
0.0669805184,
0.3581939638,
0.459625721,
0.3426812887,
-0.0076373518,
-0.6712386608,
-0.9209212065,
-0.6037663817,
-0.4862409234,
-0.0687543377,
0.0829371735,
0.3487748206,
-0.4551374614,
0.8482618332,
-0.4393220544,
0.1539056152,
-0.2032042742,
0.1094855815,
0.181744352,
0.5535767078,
0.0835046992,
-0.1080892831,
-0.3042593896,
-0.1963060945,
-0.3776958883,
-0.3313323259,
-0.3855609894,
-0.3772358596,
0.1454123557,
0.8011960387,
-0.5318688154,
0.3109416962,
0.1060705632,
-0.3639000356,
0.6925118566,
-0.1496827453,
-0.2145558,
-0.4935976267,
0.1196483299,
0.0420390069,
-0.4061441422,
-0.4539981782,
0.1475752592,
-0.1808147132,
0.1309139878,
0.0665610507,
0.5108106136,
-0.2574684024,
0.3692201078,
-0.4527013004,
0.123594664,
0.2482930422,
0.7185100317,
0.2832843065,
0.450248003,
0.1743979901,
-0.4723108709,
0.2500552535,
-0.3253437579,
-0.2592116296,
0.5859062672,
-0.6541747451,
0.4399154186,
-0.2552030981,
0.6296850443,
-1.124469161,
-0.1992880851,
0.4346394539,
-0.2555941343,
0.1875255108,
-0.3300943077,
-0.4833868146,
-0.4119798541,
0.0349308103,
0.0429727472,
0.3766376078,
-0.5496248603,
0.70093292,
-0.1406537145,
-0.1128628328,
-0.3289082348,
-0.4493949413,
-0.1519451886,
0.0410552807,
-0.3774481416,
0.0223421603,
-0.1364880651,
-0.5097464919,
0.1156864241,
-0.3018077016,
0.0668240115,
-0.143881768,
0.2190045267,
0.056183923,
-0.0872573704,
0.2641631663,
0.0537441596,
-0.3834319711,
0.3584096134,
-0.5321894884,
0.3411998749,
-0.4544819295,
-0.411010772,
-0.4091345668,
0.1561280787,
0.4787624478,
0.0469795801,
0.1828376949,
0.5191563964,
-0.3954551816,
-0.2385920584,
-0.8945205212,
-0.5789856911,
-0.4696289003,
-0.0536791272,
-0.6576532722,
-0.7053543329,
0.4397096336,
-0.3281028569,
0.1392025054,
0.4339822829,
0.406390965,
-0.0653444901,
1.0786421299,
0.4015170336,
0.1767622381,
0.4559158683,
-0.4604348838,
0.2841002941,
-0.8047288656,
-0.2652084827,
-0.575293541,
-0.3884289265,
-0.3308261633,
-0.4004223943,
-0.1900021583,
0.4703478515,
-0.6600598693,
-0.0172702689,
-0.5171128511,
0.7723400593,
0.5324237347,
0.1962292194,
0.5225996375,
-0.1705512702,
-0.3909949958,
0.0591069832,
-0.6868482828,
-0.7076161504,
0.7095566988,
0.3169672489,
0.902761817,
-0.0210845266,
0.5393448472,
0.1830639094,
0.8232663274,
-0.6609574556,
0.531021595,
0.1330863386,
-0.4838744998,
-0.0112891654,
-0.3357713521,
-0.3327662051,
0.3468298316,
0.2182878256,
-0.5184659362,
0.3157535493,
0.3342407942,
-0.7023214102,
0.2084017843,
-0.787774682,
0.7376413941,
0.0291993394,
-0.6700665951,
-0.3600130677,
-0.5348684192,
0.3107934594,
0.4189958274,
0.1235853434,
-0.0607797839,
0.1534742713,
0.4366094172,
-0.9118329287,
0.9507949352,
-0.5542060733,
-0.0649649054,
0.585175395,
0.5109964609,
0.8082271814,
0.3047908545,
0.0443158485,
-0.2815801501,
-0.1432591826,
-0.2493671626,
-1.0407488346,
0.8267020583,
-0.5675218701,
-1.0005040169,
-0.2939706147,
-0.3388986588,
-0.2732668519,
0.2744101286,
0.1337511688,
0.3141662478,
0.1994478554,
-0.1918083131,
0.2817983627,
0.2610870898,
0.1749569029,
0.7150247693,
-0.4924484491,
-0.4681020677,
0.6698321104,
-0.1756417006,
0.3535439968,
0.1142734438,
0.1978211552,
-0.4671362638,
-0.356764257,
-0.5290976167,
0.2109220177,
-1.2076554298,
-0.2033729702,
-0.3359901309,
-0.0884493515,
0.2220326662,
-0.0664718226,
-0.4047329426,
-0.4594626725,
0.1342672557,
-0.2083203942,
0.3082093,
0.876558125,
-0.0501210839,
0.310739249,
-0.4943128526,
0.0329501554,
0.4327942729,
0.484234035,
0.2419471145,
-0.5253676176,
-0.2605508566,
0.1616454273,
-0.2725748718,
-0.5111810565,
-0.1550647318,
-0.089659147,
0.4424557984,
0.7011397481,
0.0844022781,
1.0509201288,
-0.5659319758,
0.7259274125,
0.061883565,
-1.0072015524,
0.4960758388,
-0.2342517376,
0.4654343724,
0.9738914967,
0.0959374309,
-0.6985731125,
-0.5674540401,
-0.5849286914,
-0.5242624879,
0.5147982836,
0.0557077564,
-0.0400483198,
-0.2700107396,
0.4517094791,
0.1221122667,
0.0391796306,
-0.7540521622,
0.209009707,
-0.301320523,
0.0720999911,
0.1578301042,
-0.0941678211,
-0.0699854344,
-0.6681185365,
0.7120773792,
-0.3576181531,
0.0531144589,
0.468298465,
-0.1649876237,
-0.3406897187,
0.2152913958,
0.4569627345,
0.6931061745,
-0.1833716035,
0.3778588772,
0.1536914408,
0.1283271164,
0.0797939375,
0.0274913721,
-0.1391911358,
0.2291001827,
0.248503074,
0.8132426739,
0.2771178186,
-0.6749140024,
0.0729630589,
-0.3041341603,
-0.0393753052,
-0.4528536797,
0.1773262769,
0.1089900583,
0.466687113,
0.0232195351,
0.576044023,
0.208433032,
-0.4886269271,
0.1769347042,
0.0134546142,
-0.5530951023,
-0.2631542981,
0.7635328174,
0.5052839518,
-0.0203887317,
0.9677784443,
-0.1503996253,
-0.5285070539,
0.170345217,
0.2815034986,
1.0091876984,
-0.1242327467,
-0.0760046914,
0.6129773855,
0.2396743447,
-0.3261294067,
0.2538219392,
-0.3263960779,
-0.782826364,
-0.8011010885,
-0.3335996568,
-0.5443404913,
0.1601689607,
-0.6295669079,
0.3247458339,
-0.5378426313,
-0.171442315,
-0.117777586,
-0.1626395583,
-0.6103902459,
0.0082258852,
0.2334736139,
1.0873240232,
-0.5367655158,
0.9226458073,
0.5547009706,
-0.7808861732,
-0.9013977051,
0.1739158481,
-0.2234187275,
-0.3904668391,
0.6343008876,
0.3307366371,
-0.4668633044,
-0.0456955805,
-0.5810161829,
-0.5538181067,
0.6739847064,
0.4261565506,
-1.1910797358,
-0.1512977928,
-0.2036557496,
0.6579194665,
-0.3284358978,
0.8023355603,
0.7528306842,
0.6742452383,
0.0665771589,
-0.6879990101,
0.3357865512,
-0.5177708864,
0.2168026567,
0.1375045031,
-0.4871101081,
0.7340242863,
-0.5206345916,
-0.2876838148,
0.279319495,
0.6349313855,
0.3352056444,
0.0651398972,
0.7289135456,
0.8394237757,
0.8821345568,
-0.2348611653,
1.2610923052,
-0.3719245493,
0.2984483242,
1.5755352974,
-0.3033753037,
0.877854228,
0.5255138278,
0.012040182,
1.3118357658,
0.6632390618,
0.2620803118,
0.5955373049,
0.5341038108,
-0.2232791036,
-0.5197440386,
-0.0481301919,
-0.2213575393,
0.068258442,
0.4461388588,
-0.3308130503,
-0.3125339448,
-0.2473111749,
0.1302605867,
0.2706417441,
-0.354326874,
0.7388304472,
0.0269086808,
-1.2460858822,
0.8931427598,
-0.0381431952,
0.2658742368,
-0.3555006683,
-0.2803183496,
-0.3934415579,
0.687089324,
-0.3103422523,
-0.7452382445,
0.4256294072,
-0.0795337185,
-0.3586417139,
-0.1913794577,
0.6810463667,
-0.5420544744,
-0.2329171896,
0.1976931244,
0.1654417515,
0.063798964,
-0.3505688906,
-0.5646827221,
0.0819017142,
0.0431199335,
-0.2707477808,
-0.2304521352,
0.5775080919,
-0.2244872749,
0.6477970481,
0.7777190208,
-0.123768799,
-0.2351994812,
0.6340323091,
1.169701457,
-0.774680078,
-0.2471265495,
-0.9912415147,
0.6504684091,
-0.1328794211,
0.0204840824,
0.5253383517,
0.421920985,
1.1167964935,
-0.1045560688,
0.8948287368,
0.0955270529,
0.4525492191,
-0.507829845,
0.3366262913,
-0.1958170086,
0.3938880861,
0.0381623954,
-0.8542546034,
0.0976079032,
0.6610834599,
-0.4311617315,
-0.0058029001,
0.9410762787,
0.7651754022,
0.0207457934,
0.254483372,
-0.1339643002,
0.4091342688,
0.381172359,
0.6722176075,
1.2127935886,
-0.2028875202,
0.4949394763,
-0.2026659697,
0.0642948002,
-0.1836820096,
-0.6644350886,
-0.9122582674,
-0.3508928716,
-0.1964064687,
-0.6654108763,
-0.0429006331,
0.782219708,
0.622069478,
-0.8008785844,
-0.2726501524,
-0.6309937835,
0.0969860926,
-0.2936750352,
-0.2833966911,
-0.0876834989,
-0.7748541236,
-0.6930613518,
0.2503789663,
0.1595797241,
-0.4192694724,
-0.6425277591,
-0.3548540473,
-0.0468652397,
0.2062236071,
0.3876352012,
0.1563426703,
-1.2081319094,
-0.6282088161,
-0.2016979307,
0.1740990728,
-0.0676379427,
1.1185951233,
-1.1321097612,
0.6224309802,
0.6295105219,
0.3560050726,
0.7078456879,
-0.083338581,
0.832007587,
-0.4466150701,
0.0996130779,
0.2321810871,
0.678502202,
0.2880877852,
-0.071115531,
0.6217406392,
0.2569216788,
-0.5819330812,
-0.9275722504,
0.4137031436,
-0.5855902433,
-0.3369526863,
0.9795855284,
-0.1382343322,
-0.1018360257,
0.05876825,
-0.4867294729,
0.1644094139,
-0.5730215907,
0.686211884,
0.9115786552,
-0.169089824,
-0.4087054133,
-0.4906448722,
0.564147234,
0.6499700546,
-0.6014871597,
0.3159652054,
0.5580260754,
0.4895492792,
0.2731033564,
0.634510994,
0.0768178999,
0.2841652334,
0.0504183136,
0.0396399163,
-0.0506283455,
-0.5254995823,
-0.1174472794,
-0.2227638066,
0.4206489325,
0.155121237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01894v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01894v1 | San-BERT: Extractive Summarization for Sanskrit Documents using BERT and it's variants | 2023-04-04T15:47:26 | 2023-04-04T15:47:26 | Kartik Bhatnagar, Sampath Lonka, Jammi Kunal, Mahabala Rao M G | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we develop language models for the Sanskrit language, namely
Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT) and its
variants: A Lite BERT (ALBERT), and Robustly Optimized BERT (RoBERTa) using
Devanagari Sanskrit text corpus. Then we extracted the features for the given
text from these models. We applied the dimensional reduction and clustering
techniques on the features to generate an extractive summary for a given
Sanskrit document. Along with the extractive text summarization techniques, we
have also created and released a Sanskrit Devanagari text corpus publicly. | [
-0.2176813483,
-0.5995764136,
0.040466629,
0.3207566142,
-0.6914891601,
0.11586833,
-0.3969339132,
-0.394361794,
0.6938459873,
0.2635750175,
-0.3515135944,
-0.2264541984,
-0.5330908895,
0.3436714709,
-0.6668934822,
1.1528807878,
0.1574112326,
0.3140526712,
0.0234566852,
0.140872404,
-0.3522328436,
-0.2926369309,
-0.3082374632,
-0.1511134952,
0.290927738,
0.2628271282,
0.48218292,
0.2903132737,
0.9664281011,
0.3070432246,
-0.2781903744,
-0.1409716308,
-0.4214672446,
0.5352577567,
0.0411974378,
-0.561249733,
-0.2328335941,
-0.1755048186,
1.1303007603,
0.39059484,
-0.0418198295,
0.12384478,
-0.0620305985,
0.58390975,
-0.4661317468,
0.26539886,
-0.4115709066,
-0.1643630713,
-0.2648344636,
-0.0268102083,
-0.4368236363,
-1.1339116096,
0.2150931209,
-0.2537825406,
0.2951425314,
-0.3846440017,
1.1327588558,
0.5291352868,
-0.1134396642,
-0.5010655522,
-0.9979888201,
0.9812179208,
-0.7389466763,
0.1195919141,
0.1503847688,
0.6487058997,
0.2340647429,
-0.5857835412,
-0.7114963531,
0.1214831769,
-0.416392535,
0.4524522424,
0.1404365301,
-0.0573447868,
-0.1179948151,
0.7307440042,
-0.5637961626,
0.0138751101,
-0.8965585232,
0.0748938024,
0.7682664394,
-0.164198339,
0.2695257664,
-0.6851124167,
-0.2961128652,
-0.1651419401,
-0.597396791,
-0.366163373,
0.3270741403,
0.2138522267,
-0.0870427862,
0.623668015,
0.2852698863,
0.5883858204,
-0.2078525722,
-0.1861168295,
0.1095200777,
-0.4509337842,
-0.1565367877,
0.1906858087,
0.4137212038,
0.0253880024,
0.3649176061,
-0.0879837573,
-0.0385824256,
-0.0175023451,
0.2306986153,
-0.6487435699,
-0.1265157461,
0.149403736,
-0.8661028147,
-0.4536420405,
0.0255436897,
-1.1473164558,
-0.2045864463,
-0.2167128921,
0.0065899589,
-0.6825073957,
-0.4863057137,
-0.5260851979,
-0.6570770741,
0.7669868469,
0.2731018662,
-1.2012543678,
0.0928068906,
0.5783222914,
0.8035289645,
-0.4141750336,
-0.058884196,
0.0808857828,
0.4402137995,
-0.0512785241,
0.7962400317,
-0.7541196346,
-0.8321563601,
0.2178792953,
-0.3183056116,
0.0129848383,
-0.3256120086,
0.6364643574,
-0.63345927,
0.1913490742,
-0.3496757746,
-0.5077772737,
-0.3580101728,
-0.0252192318,
-0.6827455163,
1.0263184309,
0.0677472651,
-0.7600414753,
0.1176406294,
-0.8624451756,
-0.8034392595,
0.3249075413,
-0.2746556997,
-0.3326580524,
0.2393501401,
0.3034515083,
0.4013574123,
0.0103258528,
0.1670320183,
0.1128909215,
-0.3738914728,
0.0010268167,
-0.1248443425,
1.0051301718,
0.6191937327,
0.0846118778,
0.295186311,
-0.972051084,
-0.177200973,
0.1300225258,
-0.4836238325,
-0.6048592329,
0.0045670103,
0.5287436843,
-0.3355678022,
0.7783362865,
-0.7591382265,
-0.0191717558,
-0.4655761719,
0.4416176379,
0.8197809458,
0.0171537939,
0.5005604029,
-0.1947292984,
0.6669653654,
-0.3338111639,
-0.0431962423,
-0.3157676458,
-0.4920965731,
-0.5115286708,
-0.7989570498,
0.7779014111,
0.5000998378,
-0.5682374239,
0.6125007272,
-0.4802898169,
-0.7850375772,
-0.8435536623,
-0.0678417981,
0.4074788392,
0.2463966012,
0.0927158892,
-0.1693522334,
-0.7062180638,
-1.0250258446,
-0.1130323932,
-0.2403057963,
0.0501290336,
-0.0708298534,
0.4416997731,
-0.2350457758,
1.1713106632,
-0.7684326768,
-0.2297795415,
-0.5572178364,
0.4178528488,
0.0150843225,
0.4950930178,
0.7199209929,
-1.1181782484,
-0.6043328643,
-0.0743136778,
-0.7318258882,
-0.1012634635,
-0.0548463613,
-0.1562268436,
0.3734714687,
0.4463769197,
-0.5770307183,
0.6278968453,
0.3253792524,
0.3044087887,
0.3892162442,
-0.3639648259,
-0.074675329,
-1.578861475,
0.2953250706,
-0.3454343975,
-0.1828920543,
-0.3859150708,
0.4262317419,
0.0619016103,
-0.2785079479,
-0.0343796611,
0.1430462748,
-0.3567236662,
-0.4257615209,
-0.2318744063,
0.3389107883,
-0.2779978216,
0.4883837104,
0.3101549745,
0.9096364975,
0.1932932734,
-0.5228427649,
0.1920890808,
0.5629704595,
-0.0473053567,
0.1843684465,
-1.0266861916,
-0.2821793854,
-0.4838004112,
0.0866682008,
-1.3941048384,
-0.3533260226,
-0.2550254464,
-0.4728633165,
0.4424197376,
0.2657200396,
-0.6358940601,
-0.1583087444,
-0.6200988293,
0.2378795445,
0.9548755288,
-0.4202562273,
0.7361568809,
0.5629749298,
-0.7108016014,
-0.2684658766,
-0.787071228,
-0.2538606524,
-0.1577415168,
-0.2527260482,
0.3735136986,
-0.0932181701,
-0.2031876594,
0.1022281349,
0.2409168333,
-0.1897367388,
-0.1756936163,
0.199606657,
0.3079927862,
0.0260544196,
0.1248617694,
0.5332345366,
-0.0915115774,
-0.2207424045,
0.3785174489,
0.636041522,
-0.1631074548,
-0.1908673942,
-0.4762937129,
0.6949307323,
0.573826611,
-0.3319443464,
0.4184117019,
0.7889328599,
-0.4839431942,
0.3335696161,
-0.4479548633,
-0.1508095562,
-0.3755310774,
0.2654266953,
-0.1614074111,
-0.6950659752,
0.7346813679,
-0.0876709223,
0.2774492204,
0.793636322,
0.6775317788,
-0.0110787991,
0.6663891077,
0.9552192688,
-0.3394172192,
0.726556778,
-0.168037191,
0.359131068,
-0.8588247895,
-0.1950779706,
-0.6597283483,
-0.2212553918,
-0.6750128269,
0.1020623967,
0.4840856791,
-0.0186277553,
0.219311446,
0.6830077767,
-0.8142719865,
0.5568005443,
0.7335358858,
-0.1299463362,
0.3346045315,
0.0215620548,
0.0164074302,
-0.3450405002,
-0.2962728739,
-0.5153090358,
1.0021822453,
0.1370413303,
0.7229750156,
0.4564836323,
1.0418660641,
0.3611157238,
0.0916646421,
-0.5179255009,
0.4847256243,
-0.2604149282,
-0.7215465307,
-0.3869830668,
-0.065773122,
-0.8444188833,
0.3021920919,
0.0695260018,
-0.3019881845,
0.3264027238,
-0.3739035428,
-0.4026748836,
-0.2993749678,
-1.15289855,
0.4096313119,
-0.0622020103,
0.3805754781,
-0.575068593,
-0.8578314781,
0.5060381293,
-0.1403040588,
0.0364205763,
0.2836278677,
0.2006341517,
0.7601265311,
-0.4377662241,
0.9610987902,
-0.0575076006,
-0.1546490788,
0.2593408823,
-0.1597268581,
0.2503268123,
0.137616545,
-0.0708176196,
0.0221562274,
0.0836877227,
-0.5324687362,
-0.4245640039,
0.6577497721,
-0.769489944,
-0.2266889662,
-0.517031908,
-0.4199644923,
0.2581847012,
0.4805143774,
0.1938062906,
0.2485208809,
-0.3119468987,
-0.0720375106,
0.5669050217,
-0.2120742947,
0.9167671204,
0.2323440909,
-0.2678189874,
-0.4805002213,
0.9128454924,
-0.0263379496,
0.0391760617,
0.6296550035,
0.0487645902,
-0.4075298905,
-0.4435166121,
-0.2362877578,
0.4405205846,
-0.6694877148,
-0.081124492,
-0.3694511652,
-0.6253597736,
-0.6465833783,
-0.3197464943,
-0.1554811597,
-0.9046081901,
-0.3594625294,
-0.0175039601,
0.5190801024,
1.1971383095,
-0.0262715481,
0.4902847707,
-0.8864178658,
0.2014448047,
0.3935133815,
0.0193412062,
-0.0151258176,
-0.3095993102,
-0.2060021609,
-0.1304118931,
-0.3189796805,
-0.7204772234,
0.594702065,
0.2922570407,
0.4672737122,
0.6229727268,
-0.1338187307,
0.7138207555,
-0.470279485,
1.1238142252,
0.0965886787,
-0.7496554852,
1.0120645761,
-0.4360285401,
0.1147795543,
0.48080194,
0.3201963603,
-0.0098675089,
-0.448824048,
-0.5031425953,
-0.787116766,
0.4371336997,
0.4583402872,
-0.0450717062,
0.0325037241,
0.3377965391,
0.4319549799,
0.3142620623,
-0.5254043937,
-0.1499277502,
-0.2693080902,
-0.4533089995,
-0.0533437058,
-0.5772917867,
0.1617898345,
-0.5652682185,
0.4982904792,
0.2905797064,
0.4127905965,
0.2628418803,
-0.2474985719,
0.2059211731,
0.1840815246,
1.0157700777,
0.6069635749,
-0.4643774033,
-0.0316969305,
-0.1151989996,
-0.703990519,
-0.544886291,
0.4145530164,
-0.363098979,
0.5082554221,
0.4300535023,
0.3288816214,
0.3040684462,
-0.8030783534,
0.341704011,
-0.2315746993,
0.1965175718,
-0.7471224666,
-0.1972799748,
-0.0527732857,
0.0840766206,
0.4296650887,
0.1249891818,
0.2827393413,
-0.2678119838,
-0.0253180731,
0.386020869,
-0.0187176988,
-0.4932268858,
0.8430656195,
0.3661842048,
-0.1534411311,
0.4484695196,
-0.1761460304,
-0.5314252377,
0.3751372099,
0.5204777122,
1.0314420462,
-0.2972272933,
0.2216281295,
0.384672761,
0.1487703919,
0.2254711539,
0.5351104736,
-0.3739713132,
-0.2284145355,
-0.4462724328,
-0.9341940284,
-0.3850197494,
-0.339559108,
-0.8724434376,
0.2145242095,
-0.3396763206,
0.1050908342,
0.3036773801,
-0.1519441009,
-0.1493151635,
-0.2512928247,
-0.2638993263,
0.6720117927,
-0.6226789951,
0.9098247886,
0.6213647127,
-0.9222674966,
-0.2520367801,
-0.0050314912,
-0.3722837567,
-0.9351814985,
0.7775250673,
-0.3133583665,
-0.0768172219,
0.0598062873,
-0.528988421,
-0.8265557885,
1.0973776579,
0.2018409371,
-0.2239926606,
-0.0949120969,
-0.0898867846,
0.8240069151,
-0.2589775026,
0.2225263715,
0.5718175173,
0.4558237493,
0.2390638143,
-0.8207266927,
-0.1938343793,
-0.5842932463,
0.5210273266,
0.2082688063,
-0.7334566712,
0.8294751048,
0.0135988509,
-0.1527898312,
0.3470574915,
0.8458034396,
-0.1136621088,
-0.2300391793,
-0.0666388944,
0.5608882308,
0.8512837291,
-0.005234906,
1.1476415396,
-0.3297020495,
0.2231964022,
0.8013280034,
-0.1700422168,
1.1677235365,
0.4867232144,
-0.1844232678,
0.8110905886,
0.6232064366,
-0.016554011,
0.7465159893,
-0.0677026436,
-0.244524315,
0.2464080453,
-0.067056492,
-0.5878717899,
0.5066306591,
0.480610162,
-0.4513469338,
-0.397584796,
-0.0721782073,
-0.0678611398,
0.2363373935,
-0.1035327166,
0.9342422485,
-0.0881514177,
-0.5880791545,
0.6014691591,
0.0506189242,
0.7302481532,
-0.5526874065,
-0.2266143113,
-0.0823349059,
0.2002740949,
-0.0551729947,
-0.4606537223,
0.7526220083,
0.1827750504,
-0.4156856537,
-0.3397470713,
0.9371757507,
-0.6188405752,
-0.5810996294,
-0.1217463538,
0.1270353198,
0.5728522539,
0.3253332973,
-0.1074272022,
-0.0810976326,
-0.1102942899,
0.2444468588,
0.2853147686,
0.1159424782,
0.0542639345,
0.2643728852,
0.3999045789,
0.2205269933,
0.3048656285,
0.146376133,
0.7690312266,
-0.7530581951,
-0.6570922136,
-0.7798306942,
0.2837214172,
-0.5146483183,
-0.3147481084,
0.9280723929,
0.743185997,
0.4534504116,
-0.4872657061,
1.1407501698,
-0.2123026252,
0.8189480305,
-0.2190061361,
1.0373551846,
-0.3389459252,
0.0511823855,
-0.3209878206,
-0.7913916111,
-0.2652601004,
0.6996206045,
0.004780781,
-0.1064999849,
0.7057583332,
0.4160291851,
0.3035008013,
0.4493926764,
-0.1648182273,
0.0338734128,
0.2281651795,
0.1620576531,
0.430393219,
-0.5289672017,
0.5697677135,
0.0047192764,
-0.4079533219,
-0.4311664999,
-0.6703451276,
-1.0188280344,
-0.9261376858,
-0.1656503528,
0.1055992469,
-0.2423090339,
0.5240212679,
0.4222368896,
-1.008341074,
-0.1486384273,
-0.1303866506,
0.4163634777,
-0.0890417919,
-0.2918070853,
0.8317069411,
-0.5366532803,
-1.1726236343,
0.1616629958,
0.2955459058,
0.2442104071,
-0.603369832,
0.0882237256,
-0.3299242854,
-0.036012806,
0.6707444787,
0.3432488441,
-0.6398018003,
-0.0665996373,
-0.1849258244,
-0.0335417166,
-0.167056635,
0.7514766455,
-0.4519096911,
0.3996216059,
0.7754609585,
0.8177837729,
0.5883877277,
0.1894503683,
0.5980556607,
-1.0207839012,
0.3170143366,
0.1407274604,
0.2693774402,
0.3025990427,
-0.4091510177,
0.4496872723,
0.2104688436,
-0.5235465169,
-0.8653335571,
0.2178840935,
-1.1646295786,
-0.1617308557,
1.0960149765,
0.0246280227,
-0.5469270945,
-0.0121402442,
-0.4074164331,
0.349904716,
-0.4120920002,
0.9211912155,
0.7564716339,
-0.0767274201,
0.0526653081,
-0.1564230174,
0.5008010864,
0.3389633894,
-0.6123624444,
-0.1437840462,
0.2160008699,
-0.0970534831,
0.6896378994,
0.5305534005,
-0.4546693265,
0.1377826333,
-0.1085524261,
0.2700957656,
0.2866890132,
-0.2215224952,
-0.5417606831,
0.0426202491,
-0.0451309867,
-0.5648994446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01890v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01890v4 | Sociocultural knowledge is needed for selection of shots in hate speech detection tasks | 2023-04-04T15:42:08 | 2023-05-17T23:01:20 | Antonis Maronikolakis, Abdullatif Köksal, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce HATELEXICON, a lexicon of slurs and targets of hate speech for
the countries of Brazil, Germany, India and Kenya, to aid training and
interpretability of models. We demonstrate how our lexicon can be used to
interpret model predictions, showing that models developed to classify extreme
speech rely heavily on target words when making predictions. Further, we
propose a method to aid shot selection for training in low-resource settings
via HATELEXICON. In few-shot learning, the selection of shots is of paramount
importance to model performance. In our work, we simulate a few-shot setting
for German and Hindi, using HASOC data for training and the Multilingual
HateCheck (MHC) as a benchmark. We show that selecting shots based on our
lexicon leads to models performing better on MHC than models trained on shots
sampled randomly. Thus, when given only a few training examples, using our
lexicon to select shots containing more sociocultural information leads to
better few-shot performance. | [
-0.3856589794,
-0.5293127298,
0.2950401902,
-0.2653907835,
-0.1577479839,
0.1948158145,
-0.1760841161,
-0.7565951943,
0.184409827,
0.1287152022,
-0.3359827399,
-0.5717813969,
-0.9633816481,
-0.0981174856,
-0.2195384651,
1.1887047291,
0.404106766,
0.1827022284,
0.1873643994,
-0.3991134763,
0.0883822143,
-0.3879503906,
-0.8688127398,
-0.5712065697,
0.7670439482,
0.3411303759,
0.8607072234,
0.3368090987,
0.2288080752,
0.1890842766,
-0.5852892995,
-0.1651930511,
-0.5534174442,
0.1239781231,
-0.3932181597,
-0.4642375112,
0.1413915157,
0.0278260671,
0.4148061574,
0.3648203313,
-0.0528708771,
0.2070239931,
-0.1425745338,
0.046987135,
-0.7387747169,
-0.2586056292,
-0.9755368233,
0.2606624365,
-0.1612342596,
0.3337885141,
0.0063748923,
-0.1769744456,
0.0203356799,
-0.2544116676,
0.2262333781,
-0.0117688552,
0.6017879844,
0.0546181798,
-0.3704197705,
-0.0799156427,
-0.6814183593,
0.7294812202,
-0.3706831336,
0.2994369268,
0.6217395663,
0.4729858339,
0.140500471,
0.1258531213,
-0.466822207,
-0.1915637255,
0.1111855954,
0.2245963961,
-0.3794528246,
0.0096612563,
0.495539248,
-0.0110203521,
-0.6071304083,
0.5292878151,
-0.7169302106,
-0.5630794168,
0.7053563595,
0.196557045,
0.228303954,
-0.2959050536,
0.0531996414,
0.2619789243,
-0.5435488224,
-0.2009036094,
0.7762902379,
0.4489279985,
-0.4235747755,
0.2144201994,
-0.2404257059,
0.731541574,
-0.3440798223,
-0.4360259175,
-0.0524738096,
-0.0244258866,
0.1059417799,
-0.0392355174,
0.5043148398,
0.3364057243,
0.638461411,
-0.1183293089,
-0.0090481201,
0.3686695099,
0.1284221262,
-0.6909751296,
-0.0293027535,
-0.1121578813,
-0.0990569144,
-0.5587027073,
-0.641995132,
-1.0422359705,
-0.5463629365,
-0.005834131,
-0.0895852,
-0.404140085,
-0.286658287,
-0.5483887196,
-0.612824738,
0.3059701025,
0.2731468081,
-0.7948073149,
0.1615707427,
0.2815446854,
0.9368771911,
-0.2332677394,
-0.3574383855,
-0.5948075652,
0.0449455157,
-0.4201907218,
1.1004415751,
-0.8776651025,
-0.4534521997,
0.3260245621,
-0.4001809061,
0.2541978359,
-0.6171469688,
0.2841791511,
-0.4796935618,
-0.2507326603,
0.1601981223,
-0.2066863179,
-0.2695279419,
0.2715824842,
-0.0679499954,
1.016264677,
0.3532469869,
-0.6610940695,
0.6602902412,
-0.1839535683,
-0.6222054362,
0.3776922226,
-0.3173694313,
-0.3062103689,
0.0200549569,
-0.2330885977,
0.4939612448,
-0.054112874,
-0.0981210098,
-0.7143380642,
-0.1868725568,
-0.1771886349,
0.0841280669,
0.8463836312,
0.4653537869,
-0.3242602944,
-0.0274096411,
-0.8594473004,
-0.3460691273,
0.2596544623,
-0.1678533703,
-0.501429081,
-0.0458637178,
0.2391954064,
0.3661348522,
-0.5034012794,
-0.7634786367,
-0.2936781943,
-0.4157787859,
0.2683053911,
0.8255231977,
-0.2680605352,
0.3423418403,
-0.3110359907,
0.8193035722,
0.1611571014,
0.1020539403,
0.4637638628,
-0.3902750611,
-0.5125678778,
-0.0261589922,
-0.176138401,
0.7765257955,
-0.5904182196,
-0.2452741861,
0.2316879779,
-0.9918564558,
-0.0996610373,
0.2352314591,
0.5697370768,
0.468886435,
0.1554500461,
-0.101305604,
-0.8449580669,
-1.0109027624,
-0.5401926041,
-0.4232023358,
0.2711984813,
0.6071425676,
0.7155076265,
-0.0022547385,
0.4040637314,
-0.5875026584,
-0.304250747,
-0.618219614,
0.0134502519,
-0.0476337038,
0.0639092177,
0.8659037948,
-0.7222378254,
-0.5522205234,
-0.0214855336,
-0.5111545324,
-0.1219316944,
0.4017214179,
-0.1923090219,
0.219024241,
0.36448434,
0.1479708701,
0.7015246749,
0.4846510589,
-0.1642543077,
0.7411147356,
0.5388060212,
0.1917488873,
-1.0279662609,
-0.2735121548,
0.3194129765,
-0.4391102791,
-0.5276343226,
-0.0358061157,
-0.2720796764,
-0.4254349768,
-1.1521784067,
0.7345612645,
0.0205228105,
-0.0010750593,
-0.2092979103,
0.2836505771,
-0.4167723954,
0.417450428,
0.4966726899,
0.4857788682,
0.6366363168,
-0.7426039577,
0.3949446082,
0.0978092998,
-0.5157287717,
0.9416995049,
-0.2554880381,
0.1151523367,
-0.3754456639,
-0.1403199136,
-0.6978208423,
-0.3862162232,
0.1167829558,
-0.4438998997,
0.0108508198,
-0.6166002154,
-0.150371626,
-0.4075191915,
-0.0248450413,
0.3157039285,
0.3980039656,
-0.2560449243,
0.438660115,
0.8546311855,
0.0943917558,
-0.552498579,
-0.7709097862,
-0.2093957961,
-0.537661314,
-0.2948711514,
0.066857703,
-0.1225460395,
-0.5738667846,
-0.3773852587,
0.1395796388,
-0.1651941538,
0.1114130542,
0.5166751146,
0.2888256907,
0.1710031927,
0.1145224497,
-0.1182101294,
0.0944272578,
-0.1565360576,
0.0298692677,
0.2744340897,
0.2780589163,
0.2105100453,
0.0381588973,
0.5763806105,
0.2090750337,
0.2585299611,
0.808355689,
0.7704468966,
-0.6020870209,
-0.3386674523,
-0.6350633502,
-0.1927365512,
-0.313659519,
0.4621660411,
-0.237833038,
-0.9325572252,
0.6812205911,
0.3921197653,
-0.1530293375,
0.171918571,
0.7377729416,
-0.0374969766,
0.7732015252,
0.7817904353,
-0.3665528893,
0.6628020406,
0.2147779614,
0.0189730842,
-0.402284503,
0.049718257,
-0.7182577252,
-0.142982319,
-0.5130352974,
-0.1460866332,
0.6586378217,
-0.3928081393,
-0.4077123702,
0.4672560096,
-0.3456068039,
0.770131588,
0.4085273147,
0.0879067406,
0.0592834987,
0.2284318656,
-0.2104045004,
-0.1600276083,
-0.6749388576,
-0.2069895566,
0.8086634278,
0.0797498748,
0.718452096,
0.1653265506,
0.5831454396,
0.2581591904,
0.2205402404,
-1.0957924128,
0.4020517766,
-0.1072553992,
-1.2330971956,
-0.0658215508,
-0.2199438661,
-0.64261657,
0.2336265147,
-0.2641175687,
-0.8329883218,
0.005010982,
0.3506231606,
-0.8929044008,
0.3618985713,
-0.5190404058,
0.7840010524,
0.1555111259,
-0.2897537947,
-0.4090492129,
-0.4478022754,
0.2752512097,
0.0631565973,
0.4917822778,
-0.4214930832,
0.2395358682,
1.03307724,
0.0843562856,
0.9527258277,
-0.1733450443,
0.2859772444,
0.3679097295,
0.4629575908,
0.1348689795,
-0.2312245369,
-0.282471627,
0.4516916275,
0.1146885678,
-0.449053973,
-0.2160124183,
0.4134839177,
-0.7811313272,
-0.6548219919,
-0.5538190603,
-0.4436787963,
-0.2395302653,
0.011693418,
0.6737824082,
0.3267309368,
-0.3694680929,
0.0086731333,
0.3652486801,
-0.2042067349,
0.1826396286,
0.7141518593,
-0.2471798211,
-0.1455222219,
0.4860242009,
0.5404222608,
0.4332790673,
-0.0996245295,
0.3858321011,
0.0360552296,
-0.6557201147,
-0.2500289381,
0.2601454258,
-0.9791110754,
-0.3357546031,
-0.6666556001,
-0.296734184,
-0.9196534157,
-0.370176971,
-0.25676018,
-0.0864167064,
0.1039434895,
-0.2463147938,
0.4115150571,
0.7807270885,
-0.6955079436,
0.6092547774,
-0.3865095675,
0.3768206537,
0.2790775299,
0.1639448404,
-0.1678605974,
-1.1552375555,
-0.44338727,
-0.2153080106,
-0.2799810469,
-1.0747766495,
0.4157557189,
0.1816591322,
0.4688653648,
0.3505253196,
-0.0740230381,
0.5204469562,
-0.6247817278,
0.5989635587,
0.040551994,
-0.5332437754,
1.1704030037,
-0.223716259,
0.220956713,
0.5102778077,
0.9898174405,
-0.9494994283,
-0.5531535745,
-0.7081535459,
-0.4536205232,
1.0255644321,
0.0462266915,
0.2576172352,
-0.103600882,
-0.0394376479,
0.0827528462,
-0.2347300947,
-0.8955022097,
-0.3260753155,
0.0149160968,
0.1660844237,
-0.0998758972,
-0.4201647639,
-0.5892128944,
-0.1613257378,
0.9013024569,
0.0308002811,
-0.2227439582,
0.0310071073,
-0.3372707963,
-0.3181431592,
0.2321588546,
0.3441938758,
0.443033129,
-0.0680059418,
0.2157983184,
0.5528843403,
-0.4049490392,
0.2332570404,
-0.1730312109,
-0.2214012593,
0.0038989324,
0.2470716089,
0.8729797602,
0.19112809,
-0.6233358383,
0.4115432203,
0.2595712841,
-0.1546134502,
-0.6029156446,
0.2853194773,
-0.2617374957,
0.4334217906,
-0.1105580106,
0.019606065,
0.2086152881,
-0.5540451407,
0.0226679165,
0.4552069306,
-0.4816917777,
-0.2534063756,
0.455411464,
0.1033779159,
-0.4379148483,
0.432700485,
-0.5277634859,
-0.8472681642,
0.5727674365,
0.58938241,
0.420930177,
-0.5081691146,
0.6265093088,
0.8328121901,
0.2812055349,
0.4979806542,
-0.1619618535,
-0.211013779,
-1.2824981213,
0.0943745449,
-0.9092475176,
-0.3905554116,
0.2972590625,
-0.5315943956,
0.5143242478,
-0.5665507913,
-0.0554872379,
0.4096894562,
-0.2831894457,
-0.8381311297,
0.207003966,
0.9706705809,
0.7242626548,
-1.3582952023,
0.6758645773,
0.6444670558,
-0.3690089881,
-0.6947350502,
-0.57122159,
0.7844831347,
-1.1834378242,
0.9164921641,
-0.019429896,
-0.2509532273,
-0.1361724883,
-0.7041400671,
-0.70612216,
0.3106439114,
0.1830330789,
-0.4518182874,
0.0273249038,
-0.044848077,
0.4611993432,
-0.3500805497,
0.4691970944,
0.8014544845,
0.1516443789,
0.3851348758,
-0.75309515,
-0.4198702872,
0.0912291929,
0.1093443483,
-0.0868456066,
-0.6480797529,
0.2506328225,
-0.2503625453,
-0.0615071878,
-0.3947015703,
0.4349195659,
0.2427823246,
0.2446766198,
0.6107164025,
0.474101454,
0.2283911705,
0.2619797587,
0.9785942435,
0.1606098115,
0.0682105273,
1.2459719181,
-0.2320785522,
0.7126077414,
0.1155137196,
-0.4554496109,
0.3805150688,
0.8842238784,
0.0950151086,
0.2321442813,
0.1230215505,
-0.4179002345,
-0.5640817881,
-0.6360806823,
-0.0407027155,
1.051768899,
0.487973392,
-0.1821041703,
-0.5714464188,
0.478351742,
0.5660223961,
0.1188623011,
-0.5812286139,
0.8552102447,
0.1336451322,
-0.6780257821,
0.5649004579,
-0.2830009758,
0.7968962193,
-0.5672723055,
0.1988714486,
-0.2627425492,
-0.0345390514,
-0.4411361217,
-0.8158709407,
0.7317461371,
0.3058701456,
-0.1181220859,
0.1862246245,
0.8440300226,
-0.4870216846,
-0.3453940749,
0.6937409043,
0.2789931297,
0.7862359285,
-0.2747043669,
-0.8857167363,
0.0642227009,
0.0880039334,
0.0008166686,
0.4894531667,
0.120663099,
-0.0109290332,
0.3753310442,
0.3458246589,
0.4611215293,
0.1756637543,
0.2812159657,
0.6616883278,
-0.528061986,
-0.3699290752,
-0.977892518,
0.1530987024,
-0.0883158371,
-0.3691551685,
0.4849049449,
0.3400694132,
1.2262250185,
0.1183085442,
0.9255601168,
-0.1134597957,
0.7463776469,
-0.1350367665,
0.6065645218,
-0.5472957492,
-0.5218470097,
-0.3368773162,
-0.8189041615,
-0.3709129691,
0.7580801249,
-0.7724876404,
-0.1038586125,
0.5656810999,
1.2464565039,
0.1335220486,
-0.0525398552,
1.0113253593,
0.1535923779,
0.0410928205,
0.4680857956,
0.7909570336,
-0.2130163908,
0.8913614154,
-0.725291729,
-0.3997623324,
-0.0295038093,
-0.7172806859,
-0.8893049359,
-0.5496727228,
-0.5652242303,
-0.6597623229,
0.1909758151,
0.8642622828,
0.9224459529,
-0.8846306801,
-0.4391416609,
0.5558936,
0.4129548669,
0.157301113,
-0.2260569036,
-0.3232355714,
-0.3901076019,
-0.9863887429,
0.1390235424,
0.4387639463,
0.1280846745,
0.1350730807,
0.0743978545,
-0.5448072553,
-0.0647453442,
0.8312872648,
0.4916189611,
-0.5603231192,
-0.461832881,
-0.5004557967,
0.039552968,
0.0552893765,
0.7311131954,
-0.6477864385,
0.2858181894,
0.3136661351,
0.3772445023,
0.3374707699,
-0.4966950715,
0.1849345416,
-0.5232462287,
0.9205546975,
0.5954419971,
0.4075027704,
0.2649993598,
-0.3120271862,
0.6902724504,
0.6043865681,
-0.5542792678,
-0.7843770385,
0.5731307268,
-0.4975766242,
-0.3078332841,
1.6571230888,
-0.0922373235,
-0.5379894376,
-0.4310516417,
-0.1675206125,
0.3313115537,
-0.4496617615,
0.4864080548,
1.0172479153,
0.0173577443,
-0.2695360184,
-0.4022054374,
0.6902559996,
0.4412033558,
-0.4165194333,
-0.1457577646,
0.6621053815,
0.2300871909,
0.1551448703,
0.6346950531,
-0.0329947919,
0.3646866977,
0.2044651061,
0.1304167062,
0.4695762098,
-0.2736163437,
-0.3273958564,
0.0616756678,
0.1274966151,
0.1918157935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01852v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01852v4 | Summary of ChatGPT-Related Research and Perspective Towards the Future of Large Language Models | 2023-04-04T15:01:06 | 2023-08-22T03:18:43 | Yiheng Liu, Tianle Han, Siyuan Ma, Jiayue Zhang, Yuanyuan Yang, Jiaming Tian, Hao He, Antong Li, Mengshen He, Zhengliang Liu, Zihao Wu, Lin Zhao, Dajiang Zhu, Xiang Li, Ning Qiang, Dingang Shen, Tianming Liu, Bao Ge | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a comprehensive survey of ChatGPT-related (GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4) research, state-of-the-art large language models (LLM) from the GPT
series, and their prospective applications across diverse domains. Indeed, key
innovations such as large-scale pre-training that captures knowledge across the
entire world wide web, instruction fine-tuning and Reinforcement Learning from
Human Feedback (RLHF) have played significant roles in enhancing LLMs'
adaptability and performance. We performed an in-depth analysis of 194 relevant
papers on arXiv, encompassing trend analysis, word cloud representation, and
distribution analysis across various application domains. The findings reveal a
significant and increasing interest in ChatGPT-related research, predominantly
centered on direct natural language processing applications, while also
demonstrating considerable potential in areas ranging from education and
history to mathematics, medicine, and physics. This study endeavors to furnish
insights into ChatGPT's capabilities, potential implications, ethical concerns,
and offer direction for future advancements in this field. | [
-0.4879321456,
-0.938929677,
0.5805899501,
-0.0199217182,
0.0719411299,
0.1253628433,
-0.3827481568,
-0.5243908167,
-0.100701496,
0.3930212855,
-0.3667296171,
-0.1918630153,
-0.7946446538,
-0.2108294368,
-0.5321712494,
1.0329414606,
0.049657356,
0.077567406,
-0.0433212183,
0.2553282678,
-0.3836005926,
-1.0143342018,
-0.7618523836,
-0.4321420193,
0.5593965054,
0.0307950657,
0.595905602,
0.1793345809,
0.6623280644,
0.2178426981,
-0.1845647693,
-0.2461849153,
-0.5050481558,
0.0898252428,
-0.1520065367,
-0.2060706615,
-0.5973694324,
0.2149163634,
0.939237535,
0.6854444742,
-0.374486953,
-0.2210634202,
0.2815862298,
0.6284762621,
-0.2308312058,
0.4676264524,
-0.4948434234,
0.021860458,
-0.2653100193,
-0.1293072253,
-0.3909876943,
-0.2416732013,
0.5206253529,
-0.2807653844,
0.1369002163,
0.1215369105,
0.518832922,
-0.0868700072,
-0.4450251758,
-0.3344976008,
-0.7856070399,
0.6506537795,
-0.8247933388,
0.5020465255,
0.155903995,
0.3942687511,
-0.591024518,
-0.8228492141,
-0.4434448183,
-0.2536064386,
0.2541428804,
0.2471660078,
-0.0668629408,
0.194191888,
-0.0132704275,
0.53088516,
-0.7351267934,
0.2505231798,
-0.2365853935,
0.0187820904,
0.3671499491,
0.0534607805,
0.3158055246,
0.2586744428,
-0.1872238815,
0.1542958617,
-0.9099853039,
-0.2163853943,
0.1296189427,
0.2371813506,
-0.090857476,
0.4248195589,
-0.2094506919,
0.7731519938,
-0.4656106532,
-0.0882668421,
-0.0072803325,
-0.229191348,
-0.1169670001,
-0.1708184779,
0.9689901471,
0.14310956,
0.2951267064,
-0.2036123574,
-0.0128342239,
-0.3023609817,
0.0087518916,
-0.8684097528,
-0.2903906703,
0.0275054649,
-0.2866573036,
-0.1051756889,
-0.1901269704,
-0.8053062558,
-0.6126660109,
-0.3753316104,
0.1750383824,
-0.4770945013,
-0.5181868076,
0.3627999127,
0.0780643597,
0.4910146296,
0.5029290318,
-1.0236587524,
0.3044696152,
1.0402002335,
0.8791404963,
-0.4090223014,
-0.410970062,
-0.0462902933,
0.0081430543,
-0.0795537159,
0.9191091061,
-0.7231318355,
-0.4234954715,
0.2933067381,
-0.1373178214,
-0.1964230984,
-0.293628186,
0.5817493796,
-0.645023942,
0.3126289845,
-0.1617775261,
-0.6328273416,
-0.3033647835,
0.6627973318,
-0.4562828243,
0.6440835595,
-0.1427834332,
-0.8279650807,
0.125269264,
-0.7720646858,
-0.3761070967,
0.0750541463,
-0.0510361381,
-0.2638686895,
-0.070372358,
0.2056539357,
0.5464450121,
-0.56647259,
0.2780255973,
-0.2509639263,
-0.2186442614,
0.3876682818,
-0.7890805006,
0.3626571,
0.2290239036,
-0.0580393262,
0.0437397696,
-0.5583786964,
-0.0753252208,
0.1473269761,
-0.3202991188,
0.066200681,
0.2275551409,
0.0984895006,
0.216654703,
0.2903355956,
-0.4025344849,
0.3140302896,
-0.1139659882,
0.8715762496,
0.6025435925,
0.113296397,
0.2410673499,
-0.0883591697,
0.6839363575,
-0.2507780194,
0.2012803704,
-0.2834618688,
-0.5535809398,
-0.6014068127,
-0.1070685312,
0.4128315151,
0.4322739244,
-0.4313166738,
0.0376217812,
-0.4102691412,
-0.5440202355,
0.0122202756,
-0.3194342256,
0.0564722866,
0.2193493992,
0.1463379711,
-0.2772868574,
-0.385563612,
-0.7451503277,
-0.2858500779,
-0.2152019739,
0.1774554551,
0.1525407881,
0.2990796268,
-0.2504214048,
0.8368963003,
-0.4274176359,
-0.0651477203,
-0.3347675502,
-0.0187496822,
0.1881356686,
0.2788690329,
0.1985841542,
-0.7645958662,
-0.5181443691,
0.2499505728,
-0.4256789088,
0.1809044033,
0.2484437078,
0.0016156001,
-0.0987877622,
0.518666923,
-0.7136750221,
-0.0264004171,
0.8124662042,
-0.0116601558,
0.6388487816,
-0.0942752138,
0.1200085729,
-1.0086802244,
0.025767915,
-0.1046261191,
-0.1413778067,
-0.7280627489,
-0.0725329146,
-0.1713825017,
-0.2888807654,
-0.1888444722,
0.552836895,
-0.4149371088,
-0.061218787,
-0.3670319915,
0.2170998454,
-0.4765376151,
0.2403065562,
0.1467591673,
0.9867988229,
0.52266258,
-0.3827534616,
0.2829262316,
0.1513937414,
-0.2292640209,
0.1949303448,
-0.5275112987,
0.2322491854,
0.1454368681,
0.5274767876,
-0.8275553584,
-0.2797010839,
0.1272070557,
-0.5123799443,
0.2191344053,
-0.2524630129,
-0.6747464538,
-0.2287998199,
-0.0370528251,
0.177242294,
0.7458747625,
-0.2006773502,
0.3195854425,
0.5810140967,
-0.5490319133,
-0.4016028047,
-0.2949813604,
0.2720958292,
-0.1420453936,
-0.4204649329,
-0.0805626735,
-0.0147174736,
-0.1190823987,
-0.2292381823,
0.1081694886,
-0.1116570607,
-0.0423354581,
-0.0107457275,
0.1671166271,
-0.2021525651,
0.1270443201,
-0.4611180127,
-0.0300844368,
0.0909576714,
-0.5769734383,
0.9092452526,
-0.3449532688,
-0.4062899351,
0.0426040813,
0.1940597594,
0.4008702636,
-0.3453069031,
0.5656588078,
0.7487936616,
-0.1701538712,
0.0482389629,
-0.553632319,
-0.0721541718,
-0.4074966311,
0.7058123946,
-0.0435708389,
-1.426946044,
0.3236727118,
-0.1807886511,
0.2756135464,
0.2700679004,
0.8865336776,
0.1229328886,
0.7990348339,
0.7328132987,
-0.225550577,
0.6706876159,
0.079096213,
0.5217230916,
-0.8646655083,
0.0919082984,
-0.4774595499,
0.0878407508,
-0.7924243212,
-0.3455332816,
0.2339208871,
-0.1435025334,
-0.3430671692,
0.0438463725,
-0.3255619109,
0.3434626162,
0.3332721591,
-0.2009187192,
0.4200609624,
-0.0517435558,
0.2274949402,
0.1792297661,
-0.638835609,
-0.4941358864,
1.0203108788,
0.4786926508,
0.6901100874,
0.0370444842,
0.3949594796,
0.1079937592,
0.3822101057,
-0.8708046675,
0.5345118046,
-0.0759180337,
-0.740179956,
-0.4557087719,
-0.3697044253,
-1.0088262558,
0.40767923,
0.2307468653,
-0.7763589025,
-0.3253521621,
0.1527683437,
-0.106605351,
0.348369658,
-0.7614143491,
0.662804842,
-0.1362043619,
-0.2312525511,
-0.2371184826,
-0.524636507,
0.3901700675,
-0.1002116576,
0.288082093,
-0.2818271816,
0.0387925543,
0.6662941575,
-0.0411130339,
0.7805497646,
-0.0659045503,
-0.5214397907,
0.3176133633,
-0.1055176184,
0.4911002815,
0.0781755298,
0.0794574842,
0.1505167633,
0.1065222844,
-0.2186132967,
-0.3727317452,
0.7099226713,
-0.6945289969,
-0.7284637094,
-0.6176971197,
-0.613792181,
-0.8258498907,
0.3093841076,
0.0833398551,
0.2781885564,
-0.4412894845,
0.1448010653,
0.7657608986,
-0.3543906808,
0.3288609684,
0.4055437744,
-0.4534475803,
-0.182539314,
0.9282711744,
0.0249191076,
0.3808312714,
0.5664885044,
0.1562635899,
-0.2180843353,
-0.9012963176,
-0.0982825086,
0.2984535098,
-0.5110305548,
0.1065221205,
-0.5351046324,
-0.4363336861,
-0.4341866374,
0.1271094382,
-0.4631306827,
-0.21405828,
0.0440379977,
0.1668212712,
0.4255243838,
0.8282416463,
0.2115263641,
0.490393281,
-0.7383902669,
-0.0398416333,
0.3609513044,
0.5741446614,
0.0788652748,
-0.4081225395,
-0.2352738827,
0.1367093921,
-0.3227984905,
-0.2884208858,
0.2643420994,
0.1486252397,
0.4323040247,
0.0371120237,
-0.3810995817,
0.3968892097,
-0.82484442,
0.9479322433,
0.3253265023,
-0.5054886937,
0.1519944519,
-0.8640951514,
0.2748052776,
0.0593811944,
0.247511059,
-1.1132032871,
-0.0054055713,
-0.519512713,
-0.7665002942,
0.575745523,
0.1947371066,
0.2727400064,
0.2454769611,
0.1791464984,
0.1550426781,
0.1252190769,
-0.5118176341,
0.1627700031,
0.0208245721,
-0.0223765504,
-0.1376924366,
-0.1568026394,
0.1179216132,
0.0719450414,
0.7112152576,
-0.120840162,
0.6456822753,
-0.1117564216,
0.0223518386,
0.477882266,
0.6876239181,
0.5406534672,
0.7628568411,
-0.0886038914,
-0.0317092873,
0.1591125727,
-0.8706163168,
-0.0748490319,
0.2138101906,
0.0488920547,
-0.4038403034,
0.3367007971,
0.6249580979,
0.0659184679,
-0.6330115795,
0.5015188456,
-0.1013530865,
-0.0994681269,
-0.5671955943,
0.0111491038,
0.2704930305,
0.2424852401,
0.1972485632,
-0.1674946249,
0.1819329411,
-0.5145030022,
0.0411470495,
0.3953785598,
-0.5190595388,
-0.5321856737,
0.4526845515,
0.0563143678,
0.0343423299,
0.501444459,
0.1516086757,
-0.5642381907,
0.3611170053,
0.4875146449,
0.741065979,
-0.0489428826,
-0.0299920775,
0.1820974946,
0.104283303,
-0.3114720881,
-0.0492576323,
0.1922903806,
-0.7789598703,
-0.5864725709,
-0.5742611289,
-0.656034708,
0.3398983777,
-0.2570178807,
0.2295399904,
-0.4045176804,
-0.1159144118,
-0.1019221991,
-0.1194027737,
-0.5848296881,
-0.04281912,
0.3299452066,
0.6798208356,
-0.3012036979,
1.0215486288,
0.6154437065,
-0.290443331,
-0.603736639,
0.2543679178,
0.1302307695,
-0.9240173101,
0.3760566711,
-0.0685037971,
-0.1501218826,
0.2057593167,
-0.625007093,
-0.840995729,
0.9067226052,
0.2669196427,
-0.5282521844,
-0.2769011855,
0.2015726268,
0.5558374524,
0.0713151321,
0.3459358513,
0.7510131001,
0.2810016572,
0.097364746,
-1.0706961155,
-0.3482985497,
-0.1992730349,
0.1258520037,
0.3426091969,
-0.9927591681,
0.695224762,
0.2076113224,
-0.0564330555,
0.1095710769,
0.5618759394,
0.2652021646,
-0.2687259316,
0.0353764035,
0.1815000176,
0.3206432164,
-0.2122944444,
1.0033489466,
-0.2252954096,
0.4451308846,
0.8496795893,
-0.294800967,
0.857010901,
0.3686551154,
-0.6180130839,
0.0440447032,
0.6534310579,
0.0608251095,
0.3401427269,
0.2767849863,
-0.4062888026,
-0.0384934545,
-0.0830868036,
-0.6040282249,
0.3446216285,
0.76930058,
-0.0939542651,
-0.2658984065,
-0.0748813897,
0.2800864577,
-0.3722442091,
-0.2060807049,
0.6976562738,
0.3316073716,
-0.565428853,
0.3286881447,
-0.1564297527,
0.8234884143,
-0.8137224317,
-0.1870830655,
-0.1860463768,
0.2897612154,
0.0511184223,
-0.9524957538,
-0.0846176967,
-0.0512766019,
0.0878044441,
-0.3127631545,
0.8047414422,
-0.179562062,
-0.1098819375,
0.0671577081,
0.6414247751,
0.1924284846,
-0.181100294,
-0.4751766622,
0.1354725659,
-0.0438290387,
-0.5012575388,
0.6465749145,
0.6920830607,
-0.0421559438,
0.8111482263,
0.5278212428,
0.1474449933,
0.0899852961,
0.0546620004,
0.8010125756,
-0.6809882522,
-0.3001449108,
-0.7002439499,
0.0781180188,
0.1634585857,
-0.351986587,
0.6243616939,
0.3970531523,
0.6912621856,
0.039831914,
1.158088088,
-0.1377659291,
0.7243783474,
-0.5225316286,
0.76657933,
-0.0922139883,
0.0735939741,
-0.3123015165,
-0.857250154,
-0.3688156903,
0.231233418,
-0.6401785016,
0.2544136941,
0.6659009457,
0.4528723955,
-0.0198823437,
0.3082998097,
0.2984666526,
0.1458677053,
0.7408639789,
0.4307467043,
0.9751520753,
-0.2560496926,
0.6003852487,
0.1726787835,
-0.1138750836,
-0.2692606747,
-0.807254076,
-0.7815603018,
-0.7066724896,
-0.0828353539,
0.0650775284,
0.1403161883,
0.6922239065,
0.6197024584,
-0.7455947399,
-0.2248756588,
-0.205557242,
-0.3025268018,
0.064271912,
-0.1518502384,
0.4395977855,
-0.404260695,
-0.6500582099,
0.0887874812,
0.3652720153,
0.1077771559,
-0.3246925473,
-0.0356055871,
-0.068490237,
-0.20111233,
1.02823627,
0.4155423939,
-0.5650420785,
-0.2289708704,
0.0511724353,
-0.0083550969,
0.1861841083,
0.8680994511,
-0.4862088859,
0.0105842939,
0.4371980131,
0.8235888481,
0.5004996657,
-0.2554178834,
0.7583532929,
-0.3600803018,
0.1161388159,
0.353656888,
0.3814113438,
0.4390468299,
-0.0872414485,
0.6161636114,
0.1265906245,
-0.8902181387,
-0.555834353,
0.3105593026,
-0.9424056411,
-0.0531301983,
1.338460207,
-0.1411586404,
0.0624283031,
-0.0963679999,
-0.3778658807,
0.1560992748,
-0.4458333254,
0.6743807793,
1.0616025925,
-0.286082834,
-0.6272325516,
-1.2710672617,
0.4006870389,
0.1483150721,
-1.0480574369,
0.4254478216,
0.4715476632,
0.1969552189,
-0.2159505635,
0.591633141,
-0.5484128594,
-0.1558067501,
-0.1174345836,
0.1721082777,
0.2454420328,
0.0289500467,
-0.2529944181,
0.012754743,
0.6063216925,
0.1669666171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01774v1 | A User-Centered, Interactive, Human-in-the-Loop Topic Modelling System | 2023-04-04T13:05:10 | 2023-04-04T13:05:10 | Zheng Fang, Lama Alqazlan, Du Liu, Yulan He, Rob Procter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Human-in-the-loop topic modelling incorporates users' knowledge into the
modelling process, enabling them to refine the model iteratively. Recent
research has demonstrated the value of user feedback, but there are still
issues to consider, such as the difficulty in tracking changes, comparing
different models and the lack of evaluation based on real-world examples of
use. We developed a novel, interactive human-in-the-loop topic modeling system
with a user-friendly interface that enables users compare and record every step
they take, and a novel topic words suggestion feature to help users provide
feedback that is faithful to the ground truth. Our system also supports not
only what traditional topic models can do, i.e., learning the topics from the
whole corpus, but also targeted topic modelling, i.e., learning topics for
specific aspects of the corpus. In this article, we provide an overview of the
system and present the results of a series of user studies designed to assess
the value of the system in progressively more realistic applications of topic
modelling. | [
-0.6183048487,
-0.7195588946,
0.5852044225,
0.0108162211,
-0.4029820859,
0.1773164868,
-0.2371908277,
-0.0668947324,
0.4668123424,
0.6076064706,
-0.386380285,
-0.5071259141,
-0.198559463,
-0.1029814407,
-0.5290122032,
0.7183610201,
0.1080318838,
0.2261859477,
-0.2913759053,
0.1221345663,
-0.612829268,
-0.6203138232,
-0.2729424238,
-0.6484143138,
0.698656261,
0.762401402,
0.5774711967,
-0.0158667378,
0.519077003,
0.1449680924,
-0.2268233746,
-0.0572039224,
-0.4500421286,
0.2062494159,
-0.6391399503,
-0.2068226337,
-0.4241887331,
0.0990025699,
0.2507339418,
0.9081339836,
-0.2492953539,
0.1320910156,
-0.1411492229,
0.4776762128,
-0.4140713513,
-0.2847982645,
-0.1550907791,
-0.111594677,
-0.2792185843,
-0.2485034764,
-0.2889585495,
-0.2399099469,
0.5236390233,
-0.398029387,
0.0793821514,
0.0496975332,
0.4704203308,
-0.1139831692,
-0.1930495054,
-0.5996694565,
-0.6981820464,
0.4556873441,
-0.6458450556,
0.17480883,
0.219922021,
0.374640584,
-0.2064222991,
-0.5470291376,
-0.6473671198,
-0.4312041104,
0.0543893874,
0.1133173183,
-0.0693222508,
-0.2131834477,
0.0260434859,
0.1870671809,
-0.4514628053,
-0.0800915956,
-0.3550743461,
-0.0299946647,
0.6230134964,
0.2777810991,
0.0818181857,
-0.3692534268,
-0.3532067239,
0.1306118816,
-0.3960827291,
-0.0967882499,
0.569221735,
0.1959939748,
0.0697090477,
0.7155734897,
-0.4037646055,
0.745283246,
0.077244997,
-0.1281323135,
-0.0909150019,
0.011991445,
0.0934070051,
-0.3607152402,
0.3906532526,
0.2445683479,
0.0106611401,
-0.3571105003,
-0.3872056305,
0.2348665148,
0.6024428606,
-0.6416507363,
-0.2928065956,
0.2848999798,
-0.5639554858,
-0.2720710337,
0.1970818192,
-0.7356947064,
-0.5201037526,
-0.6757642031,
0.5489112735,
-0.4544135928,
-0.4870226979,
0.2969363332,
-0.2743686438,
-0.2034414709,
0.7606099844,
-0.554445982,
0.3276579678,
0.5709428191,
0.6918080449,
-0.4568290114,
-0.302549392,
-0.1723479182,
-0.0516734198,
-0.038194973,
1.0697946548,
-0.8240295053,
-0.7134039402,
-0.2437053174,
-0.2483051419,
0.3611486554,
-0.4282739758,
0.3301903903,
-0.7425639033,
0.3922280073,
-0.3709467053,
-0.8604171276,
0.011882511,
0.2483920604,
-0.3458904922,
0.7241771221,
0.0945907831,
-1.1186221838,
0.2970749438,
-1.1365314722,
0.0877380222,
0.0295935627,
-0.0214166772,
-0.011372203,
0.0323264003,
-0.1598087698,
0.2500876784,
-0.3082210422,
0.6861000061,
-0.4805051684,
-0.6143508554,
0.4542534947,
-0.1888050586,
0.5004937053,
0.5494163632,
-0.0225484036,
0.7238247395,
-0.5491332412,
-0.4642870724,
-0.2070417851,
-0.1094839275,
-0.1310793161,
-0.2169908583,
0.3181145787,
0.123042345,
0.1028465107,
-0.3420593143,
0.5499061942,
0.1222043261,
0.590244472,
0.545194447,
0.2750936151,
0.4129806459,
-0.4371289611,
0.7011806965,
0.0532567278,
-0.1823320985,
-0.5596390963,
-0.6924105287,
-0.5093435645,
-0.0267262794,
0.8716701865,
0.4058231413,
-0.5691289306,
0.4038817585,
0.0769923925,
-0.48738271,
-0.3421394229,
-0.081158936,
-0.0842370912,
0.5211008787,
-0.063585788,
-0.9227966666,
-0.1771950424,
-0.4938088655,
0.0803217888,
-0.3857213855,
-0.3668677509,
0.3119944036,
0.7560151219,
-0.5219601393,
1.5794579983,
-0.4779857993,
0.1501412839,
-0.1698828638,
0.6660029888,
-0.077799499,
0.2570690215,
0.0866126195,
-0.878352344,
-0.0942220166,
-0.1097779199,
-0.7955100536,
-0.2119375467,
0.0477063507,
-0.2641412914,
-0.1995405406,
0.1684874892,
-0.4731198549,
0.7751447558,
-0.1568153799,
-0.4490240514,
0.7565949559,
-0.5652631521,
0.0599887744,
-0.8600320816,
0.5327323079,
-0.005546065,
-0.1646855474,
-0.2890664637,
-0.04561349,
0.0550749414,
-0.7020314336,
-0.2848351598,
0.8456379175,
-0.1437658519,
-0.1987989843,
-0.7469293475,
0.3190017045,
-0.0826946571,
0.3661211729,
0.1445145756,
0.7161160111,
0.3853341043,
-0.5188246369,
0.5859052539,
0.2861189842,
-0.2472948283,
0.6171857715,
-0.4576275349,
0.3367660344,
-0.0340348557,
0.3093333542,
-0.8263027668,
-0.7191824317,
0.2380207628,
-0.448931545,
0.0695693642,
-0.0195948388,
-0.388295114,
-0.5225635767,
-0.2634805739,
-0.1363953054,
0.3156244457,
-0.2471744865,
0.1690363884,
0.7575883269,
-0.4156683385,
-0.1236412376,
0.0215524398,
0.5298338532,
-0.4513758123,
-0.617390871,
0.4570511281,
-0.1885516644,
-0.5097005963,
0.2156193703,
0.2596145868,
-0.0797183216,
0.161011979,
0.2211917788,
-0.0551280566,
0.1540079117,
0.7480046153,
-0.2048687339,
-0.3693784475,
-0.2242854089,
-0.3399324417,
0.4300449491,
-0.2292584628,
-0.6132484078,
-0.5596523285,
0.6210772395,
0.6393370032,
-0.2160049826,
0.1255189478,
0.4545327127,
-0.562112987,
0.0954201519,
-0.5064099431,
-0.5128005743,
-0.3629253805,
-0.0055226092,
-0.3365495801,
-0.8753198385,
0.4874617159,
-0.5262858272,
-0.1461395174,
0.238274321,
0.7444735765,
-0.4763688743,
0.6054484844,
1.0447661877,
0.0525650047,
0.3690239787,
-0.2508910894,
-0.036085736,
-0.7010290623,
-0.1019883603,
-0.4440104663,
-0.3306564987,
-0.0376486368,
-0.2378743589,
0.1205519289,
0.4484839439,
-0.3089787364,
0.181041196,
-0.4975687563,
0.0634053871,
0.7687148452,
0.2785973549,
0.2315194905,
0.0034746833,
-0.267855674,
-0.0657920912,
-0.6848800182,
-1.2030450106,
1.0783628225,
0.3900669217,
1.1046329737,
-0.1669174433,
0.6712237597,
0.8233017325,
0.7124563456,
-0.545696795,
0.4402508438,
0.0904186666,
-0.5850682259,
-0.5666441321,
-0.0886084884,
-0.6235175729,
0.042363625,
-0.1582466066,
-0.8920974135,
0.24503766,
0.1949380934,
-0.6436085701,
0.4086864889,
-0.6753633618,
0.7152999043,
-0.1755670905,
-0.6166102886,
-0.3336371183,
-0.6714465618,
-0.051468648,
-0.0460783131,
0.0545009375,
-0.1274364889,
0.2134963721,
0.7871398926,
-0.480301559,
1.0553655624,
-0.325864315,
-0.0299575143,
0.5402364135,
-0.1696171165,
-0.0763422698,
0.5108757615,
-0.4100966752,
-0.1578124762,
-0.2173517495,
-0.1793867201,
-0.4571389258,
0.5627803802,
-0.676886797,
-0.8491466045,
-0.2977626622,
-0.3889233172,
-0.0956069753,
0.1849646568,
-0.0116944192,
0.3785822988,
-0.49284482,
0.0073991194,
0.5015467405,
-0.2689044178,
0.0407685786,
0.5033162832,
-0.735550642,
-0.4107080102,
0.7266276479,
-0.0140936561,
-0.1797808111,
0.2005695254,
0.3020068705,
-0.3059203029,
-0.3136443198,
-0.689863205,
0.1772736013,
-0.605309844,
0.0232111011,
-0.6636669636,
0.1414420456,
-0.2697283626,
-0.2842674553,
0.0237384401,
-0.3296386898,
-0.5158635378,
0.1186824813,
0.4743870795,
0.8705196977,
-0.1752230674,
0.5909383893,
-0.4379831553,
0.4694708288,
0.6094064713,
0.6038361192,
-0.023306381,
-0.452973932,
-0.1314209551,
-0.0026718955,
-0.8650109768,
-1.1197121143,
0.4925680757,
-0.2264152765,
0.3748538792,
0.4669593871,
0.087297231,
0.3219506443,
-0.154286325,
0.6572056413,
0.0117256884,
-0.9984270334,
0.7154766321,
-0.4521101117,
0.359633714,
0.4883142412,
0.3010244966,
-0.9128391743,
-0.0355875678,
-0.4636639655,
-0.5110777617,
0.6601957679,
0.110665001,
-0.127381593,
0.1883159131,
0.7310333848,
0.4760963619,
0.3663531542,
-0.1255177408,
0.156054467,
-0.2367981374,
0.1549750566,
0.1726923138,
-0.3813877702,
0.0727690011,
-0.092751883,
0.6757307053,
-0.224631682,
0.3099040687,
0.1750728488,
-0.2106288522,
-0.3999524713,
0.3448490202,
0.5065470338,
1.2275019884,
-0.5938231349,
0.0069568516,
0.1353214681,
-0.1270325035,
0.2132340521,
-0.0160205737,
-0.2488404661,
0.0886656046,
-0.0808144584,
0.6911925673,
0.3954466581,
-0.675513804,
0.2424357831,
-0.1175542921,
0.0037415267,
-0.1059202552,
-0.0151048908,
0.5703406334,
0.1153681204,
0.3063273728,
0.2258185297,
0.2460892797,
-0.5140098333,
0.5453647971,
-0.1156988889,
-0.648633182,
-0.4080599248,
0.6772547364,
0.5207645893,
-0.8182447553,
0.6166677475,
-0.1769113541,
-0.5623599291,
0.516468823,
0.2716803253,
0.7435340285,
0.0014513726,
0.3675209582,
0.1566181034,
-0.2873797119,
-0.0823243037,
0.54052037,
-0.2304841876,
-0.441652745,
-0.0990568995,
-0.5221474171,
-1.0313131809,
-0.0149428863,
-0.7917832136,
0.6035574079,
0.0361382999,
-0.600964129,
0.1716664433,
0.1173436195,
-0.26095438,
0.2000535578,
0.2393599898,
1.1948307753,
-0.5976813436,
1.0552606583,
1.133874774,
-0.287003696,
-0.0058864257,
0.0313487351,
-0.1703718156,
0.0317622423,
0.5206292868,
0.0837891847,
-0.1412786245,
-0.2512176633,
-0.5759744048,
-0.5159392953,
1.0066252947,
0.2836750746,
-0.387057513,
-0.0949974135,
-0.1840012521,
0.7272542715,
-0.4834060669,
0.3871535063,
0.3322526813,
0.3073011637,
0.1860553473,
-0.8775841594,
-0.5688245893,
-0.3083431721,
0.0379316472,
-0.0466929935,
-0.6370660663,
0.785487771,
-0.2834693193,
-0.0598301813,
0.0324756466,
0.8443824649,
0.213169843,
0.5320599675,
0.481429249,
0.5416362286,
0.9423828721,
0.0790108144,
0.8601934314,
-0.3429839909,
0.4350879788,
1.0760728121,
-0.6354399323,
0.7373163104,
0.3098551035,
-0.2192645669,
0.2961902916,
0.8340240121,
0.3567901254,
0.4120240808,
0.5515616536,
-0.2509078085,
-0.3915196359,
-0.0766602531,
-0.3373400569,
0.193738848,
0.639747858,
0.2084908783,
-0.302300185,
0.2476605028,
-0.2490410358,
0.0522721335,
-0.0786344185,
0.6454789042,
0.0921439156,
-0.5810059905,
0.0151872961,
0.2867518365,
0.7644507289,
-0.5470405221,
-0.1329921335,
-0.4131625295,
-0.0628735349,
-0.0061438037,
-0.7694446445,
0.3691833615,
0.4344498515,
-0.3240218461,
-0.3067808747,
1.0325456858,
-0.3044208288,
-0.3748079538,
0.1055802405,
0.518222332,
0.2081928551,
-0.0520035923,
-0.4747936726,
0.0566839427,
-0.0329520218,
-0.2809513509,
0.0742648244,
0.4366925359,
-0.5336884856,
0.9993137717,
0.4179555774,
-0.057701651,
-0.3477137983,
0.0159582105,
0.8687698841,
-1.1158825159,
-0.6713832617,
-0.3257520199,
0.3608216643,
-0.1861414164,
-0.5474095941,
0.3992274702,
0.4045217037,
0.7107822299,
-0.0213469956,
0.9390902519,
0.1113943234,
1.0393149853,
0.0138958106,
0.7129411101,
-0.4423152804,
0.4644725323,
-0.253139466,
-0.6017486453,
-0.1337667704,
0.4744564891,
-0.3624280095,
-0.1332157552,
0.1973252594,
0.6064229012,
-0.1296899468,
0.471729219,
0.3785305321,
-0.0829368979,
0.33569929,
0.0164058842,
1.285073638,
0.1715156883,
-0.0868324563,
-0.4976283908,
-0.4719716012,
-0.7120116353,
-0.6796805263,
-0.689978838,
-0.7167964578,
-0.3702018857,
0.0820326135,
0.2442258447,
0.8553037047,
0.9295686483,
-0.8714841008,
-0.7115212679,
0.1499957591,
0.1713825166,
0.2299085855,
-0.1745315045,
0.4409732819,
-0.1439022273,
-0.3050649762,
0.1428450048,
0.5974888206,
-0.1639216095,
-0.5822885633,
0.1146364138,
-0.1044737548,
0.0139693525,
0.4816414118,
0.2775147259,
-0.8998850584,
-0.1503501236,
0.1162088066,
-0.1808252484,
-0.0509607047,
1.2046414614,
-1.1395668983,
0.7748259306,
0.5068891048,
0.4493739307,
0.6622627378,
0.0713445246,
0.664295733,
-0.1463331133,
-0.0240890589,
0.2007132024,
0.3165461421,
0.368191123,
-0.1741853803,
0.4615731835,
0.309481889,
-0.4820203781,
-0.7545772195,
0.1309036463,
-0.8900769949,
-0.4492566586,
0.8000169992,
-0.1573088765,
0.1254680306,
-0.4381247461,
-0.670907855,
0.2335097194,
-0.5647242069,
1.1286385059,
0.8356779218,
-0.3163611591,
0.2593383193,
-0.2625755966,
-0.084712632,
0.1346268952,
-0.7749240398,
-0.0245235395,
0.3522800207,
0.245568037,
0.2085462362,
0.6405175924,
-0.0595584102,
0.2458376437,
-0.1892694086,
0.4161433578,
0.1478911787,
-0.509730041,
-0.4907537699,
0.3822188973,
0.128713727,
0.302626729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01752v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01752v3 | Black Box Few-Shot Adaptation for Vision-Language models | 2023-04-04T12:42:29 | 2023-08-17T17:22:41 | Yassine Ouali, Adrian Bulat, Brais Martinez, Georgios Tzimiropoulos | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Vision-Language (V-L) models trained with contrastive learning to align the
visual and language modalities have been shown to be strong few-shot learners.
Soft prompt learning is the method of choice for few-shot downstream adaptation
aiming to bridge the modality gap caused by the distribution shift induced by
the new domain. While parameter-efficient, prompt learning still requires
access to the model weights and can be computationally infeasible for large
models with billions of parameters. To address these shortcomings, in this
work, we describe a black-box method for V-L few-shot adaptation that (a)
operates on pre-computed image and text features and hence works without access
to the model's weights, (b) it is orders of magnitude faster at training time,
(c) it is amenable to both supervised and unsupervised training, and (d) it can
be even used to align image and text features computed from uni-modal models.
To achieve this, we propose Linear Feature Alignment (LFA), a simple linear
approach for V-L re-alignment in the target domain. LFA is initialized from a
closed-form solution to a least-squares problem and then it is iteratively
updated by minimizing a re-ranking loss. Despite its simplicity, our approach
can even surpass soft-prompt learning methods as shown by extensive experiments
on 11 image and 2 video datasets. | [
-0.1428042799,
-0.5823611021,
0.5860043168,
-0.2779465914,
-0.4294524193,
-0.2029874325,
-0.2710456848,
-0.2227323949,
-0.0708267167,
0.3613662124,
-0.7998758554,
-0.3276015818,
-0.3351787925,
0.0298379473,
-0.0741555691,
0.964640975,
0.0678242147,
-0.0411360376,
0.0818969086,
-0.3768174052,
-0.560737431,
-0.0575724095,
-0.3966571391,
-0.0356568731,
0.6127265692,
0.3132483363,
0.7235304117,
0.4804190397,
0.4918298721,
0.3272659779,
0.0710931569,
0.1629442722,
-0.6620573997,
-0.1276036054,
-0.1972723007,
-0.4868080616,
-0.3026941419,
-0.2545984983,
0.6446911097,
0.7086006403,
0.1530118734,
0.1348967701,
0.3952387869,
0.5535356402,
-0.8285434842,
-0.1380950809,
-0.7875480056,
0.0317942165,
-0.0629125461,
-0.2075015903,
-0.394967556,
-0.1954722106,
0.2397092581,
-0.8249984384,
0.258815676,
0.0852201879,
0.8269664049,
0.4742129445,
-0.1253267527,
0.1360201091,
-0.6202093959,
0.8842443824,
-0.6367838979,
0.3670031726,
-0.0074030454,
0.4494818151,
-0.1327252984,
-0.398716718,
-0.5574479103,
-0.0386127755,
0.0378001146,
0.094900012,
-0.263920337,
0.0992527679,
0.1463389844,
-0.1228401512,
-0.615447104,
0.335998863,
-0.4409722388,
-0.2407217771,
0.5420796275,
0.2238153815,
-0.0252884552,
-0.0644227043,
-0.5721972585,
-0.1967104971,
-0.5225998163,
0.2403825223,
0.0198371243,
0.7290594578,
-0.4070649445,
0.4568561316,
0.0594038256,
0.8460762501,
0.3039330542,
-0.5435741544,
0.3088766038,
-0.4623366296,
-0.2706932724,
-0.0576112643,
0.7174440622,
0.4204359949,
0.3015407324,
0.1181677952,
-0.3412932456,
0.0578382574,
0.2184771448,
-0.7933920622,
0.0065358509,
0.0484740585,
-0.3572518826,
-0.2446567416,
-0.1898062676,
-0.8412405252,
-0.5913080573,
-0.1482875943,
0.9090492129,
-0.1885173917,
0.0839692354,
0.0095746191,
0.0997130871,
0.4940831065,
0.7051898837,
-0.8604786992,
0.1657978147,
0.3691711426,
0.8854423761,
-0.3238347769,
-0.3605010211,
-0.9549736977,
-0.2818285525,
-0.5346568823,
0.7951341271,
-0.308603555,
-0.0576550551,
0.2991060615,
0.1017928794,
0.0477115884,
-0.2799471915,
0.2349725962,
-0.2218887955,
0.2847211957,
-0.0908889174,
-0.2213994265,
-0.1460779011,
0.1130098701,
-0.378767401,
0.9008305669,
0.2418040782,
-0.4327872694,
0.4730682969,
-0.3329148591,
-0.1822577715,
0.1391504258,
-0.3554342985,
-0.6182593107,
0.3500641882,
0.2494990379,
0.488817513,
-0.1039901227,
-0.2069683075,
-0.5050464869,
-0.4941559732,
0.3044846654,
-0.3671892583,
0.5879209638,
-0.0642258152,
-0.2349856496,
0.0744046867,
-0.8394412398,
-0.0214412194,
0.1746183634,
-0.0781768337,
-0.2752222717,
-0.0987649485,
0.1465739459,
0.1473905593,
0.0501901954,
-0.3324078321,
0.6227246523,
-0.5383166075,
-0.020468263,
0.9073807001,
-0.147587806,
0.8686829805,
-0.0655304268,
0.5011674762,
0.2438691109,
0.1739035398,
-0.4642267823,
-0.4025344551,
-0.7906758189,
-0.342682898,
0.2903495431,
0.8005863428,
-1.004027009,
0.1421344876,
-0.2316978574,
-0.0600558519,
-0.7665328979,
0.7560527921,
0.5112232566,
0.6867741346,
0.3000898063,
-0.5139370561,
-0.1984033287,
-0.7135238051,
0.1008617133,
0.0027958795,
-0.0380501635,
0.4188129008,
0.4164738655,
-0.0509330593,
0.8118088245,
-0.6803444624,
-0.5723795295,
-0.2575772405,
-0.0415850021,
0.3376695812,
0.3155555725,
0.8349822164,
-0.5054315925,
-0.3795920312,
0.0910372734,
-0.7113348246,
-0.2184914798,
-0.2501903176,
0.0021039431,
0.2361533493,
0.3713953197,
-0.2412108332,
0.5156728029,
0.5410609245,
-0.3722561002,
0.2012377083,
-0.1267597526,
-0.0428271778,
-1.0312948227,
-0.1845926195,
0.2743093371,
-0.4603426158,
-0.7675381303,
-0.2453923374,
0.1063064262,
-0.3018316329,
-0.8013106585,
0.7545208335,
-0.4114599228,
-0.1306243092,
-0.5252580047,
0.2466391176,
0.0706324801,
0.6932396293,
0.0733871013,
0.7582202554,
0.8319550157,
-0.4675578773,
0.1082764417,
0.3373648524,
-0.1913939416,
0.8127844334,
-0.3650051951,
0.2623385489,
-0.457508713,
-0.0744539946,
-0.9995003939,
0.1203133687,
0.4606930614,
-0.1855311394,
0.2990972996,
-0.4969459474,
0.1207241043,
0.0424571596,
-0.4521721303,
0.4852827787,
0.5841488838,
-0.5458971858,
0.4794350564,
-0.2289576977,
-0.1681637466,
-0.7034764886,
-0.6213086843,
-0.1230701655,
-0.0336284041,
-0.4159969389,
0.3057062328,
-0.1533757448,
-0.0065072766,
0.0638543814,
-0.0620985366,
-0.0808702856,
0.0974146426,
0.1028124914,
0.4791285992,
-0.6988997459,
0.0417396203,
-0.2543511689,
-0.2762750387,
-0.6235867143,
-0.2539041638,
0.0303268041,
-0.1300923675,
-0.1946636289,
-0.4784936011,
0.3093107641,
0.2922065556,
-0.0404848382,
0.6034319401,
0.6378031969,
-0.3639888465,
-0.4807822704,
-0.2902233303,
-0.3407607377,
-0.5034235716,
0.4680540562,
-0.3752593994,
-0.7047494054,
0.2831420302,
-0.0693659708,
0.0527689643,
0.0937289,
0.3913618028,
-0.3505924642,
0.6839579344,
1.2097150087,
-0.0438593067,
0.8140211701,
-0.1249996349,
0.1693331003,
-0.3923122883,
0.0281734131,
-0.3328617811,
-0.5067121983,
-0.3919863999,
-0.4286189377,
0.3915344775,
0.2604282498,
-0.0187663212,
0.3184487522,
-0.3104482889,
0.4953869283,
0.2590536177,
0.2907572091,
0.0009769335,
0.1270272136,
0.0672272146,
-0.3287422657,
-0.6268157959,
-0.1466853321,
0.9374421835,
0.2615290582,
1.0075247288,
0.210025847,
0.6353948116,
0.232518211,
-0.0050770883,
-1.0449192524,
0.4908333123,
-0.439711988,
-0.1459808052,
-0.2111305743,
-0.1294169575,
-0.795404911,
0.2890050709,
-0.8262438178,
-0.7282962203,
0.5932436585,
0.3102017343,
-0.692404449,
0.0134468144,
-0.8464376926,
1.0145068169,
-0.3737626672,
-0.7252361774,
0.2286251634,
-0.4601207376,
0.3288304806,
-0.3091621995,
0.0835939869,
-0.036454577,
-0.2845118642,
0.3595301509,
-0.3153124452,
1.0999320745,
-0.281218946,
0.016155431,
-0.0091444114,
0.0936719179,
0.4936785698,
-0.3058542311,
0.2226204127,
-0.0856404752,
-0.0955043957,
-0.5919983387,
-0.8325592875,
0.2497897893,
-0.6509480476,
-0.5850391388,
-0.4566767514,
-0.4364872575,
-0.0283097271,
0.1527465284,
0.117827639,
0.5852208734,
-0.01440416,
0.0580622628,
0.6387880445,
-0.2548829019,
0.7416867018,
0.4952496886,
-0.2853085101,
-0.3789446652,
0.8373274803,
-0.0449627638,
0.3593544066,
0.3747774661,
0.29812482,
-0.0667831749,
-0.7719503641,
-0.5151443481,
0.1897346675,
-0.7627463937,
-0.395524919,
-0.0984215215,
-0.1722894311,
-0.2987754643,
-0.7186068892,
-0.4213620126,
-0.1790386289,
-0.3801188171,
0.2014441639,
0.4169459641,
0.4405137897,
0.2064220756,
0.5294584036,
-0.6518839598,
0.6630994081,
0.5059194565,
0.1759341508,
-0.5341341496,
-0.974521935,
-0.1371508688,
-0.3584675193,
-0.2545370162,
-0.9213528633,
0.2778382599,
0.6233517528,
0.4126431048,
0.5090138912,
-0.0876996219,
0.922132194,
-0.6343713403,
0.771101594,
0.4889633656,
-0.7942972183,
0.5558404326,
0.0502231419,
0.4036873877,
0.6939049959,
0.1362931877,
-0.2296568453,
0.1086594686,
-0.1460179836,
-0.4338977635,
0.7226489186,
-0.0441002175,
0.2248621881,
0.5615894198,
0.3912308812,
0.2140717208,
0.0194532126,
-0.8828138709,
-0.2218068987,
-0.4059686661,
-0.5260725021,
-0.2047126889,
-0.1661847085,
-0.0806603879,
-0.1365355253,
0.4553139806,
-0.8201083541,
0.0291756634,
0.1710111499,
-0.5091838241,
-0.2027201951,
0.4468363822,
0.8144940734,
0.5593960881,
-0.2048516273,
0.0852577984,
0.3124909699,
-0.3915726244,
0.371414572,
0.1551079154,
-0.4892350435,
-0.0267504118,
0.3982275426,
1.0212384462,
0.5453945398,
-0.4139704704,
0.9956011772,
0.2330334634,
-0.1990953833,
0.1414777637,
0.0332057327,
-0.3827060759,
0.628215909,
0.5438266993,
0.2550396919,
-0.1707064658,
-0.5674114823,
0.263355583,
0.5381784439,
-0.4622342587,
-0.2857340276,
0.598710835,
0.3503665626,
-0.36563465,
0.2731686234,
-0.2085390389,
-0.3241182864,
0.1906970888,
0.4699519873,
1.0198301077,
-0.0662096366,
0.256393671,
0.3253519833,
0.3233505487,
0.0629610121,
0.2090822607,
0.1129052043,
-0.9241543412,
-0.4784550667,
-0.5933358669,
-0.2722445428,
0.1556131095,
-0.2553764582,
0.6149344444,
-0.6570326686,
-0.0067471093,
0.2198287845,
0.048379425,
-0.8954342008,
0.0091430489,
0.5565984249,
0.8214074373,
-1.1945734024,
0.8639750481,
0.5763757229,
-0.4731627107,
-0.3997681439,
-0.0285381917,
0.3538070619,
-0.8826617599,
0.4863952994,
0.0065451367,
-0.2077470422,
-0.0697959736,
-0.7588791847,
-0.584476769,
1.0811415911,
0.5613315701,
-0.8432956338,
0.1528701782,
-0.0977630615,
0.309201479,
-0.5468692183,
0.0197018608,
0.2266118824,
0.1775528342,
-0.0009696705,
-0.8263494968,
0.0419113189,
0.0941118002,
0.1419621706,
0.0232459605,
-0.5088509321,
0.4639446139,
-0.4613185823,
-0.116756089,
0.0845078379,
0.8594537973,
0.1798627824,
0.3411664367,
0.6852533221,
0.2046131045,
0.5525936484,
0.1227283925,
0.7186583281,
0.0948518813,
0.2729003429,
0.9620324969,
-0.4166773558,
0.8673781157,
0.5871888399,
-0.1058395207,
0.3519281149,
0.2560663819,
-0.1983562112,
0.7457541823,
-0.1269801259,
-0.1696173102,
-0.3696231544,
-0.0722256377,
-0.037412174,
0.4803972244,
0.102982752,
-0.2374374568,
-0.3670869768,
0.1959390193,
-0.2194762528,
0.0998277515,
-0.5264471173,
0.9247869253,
0.2463265359,
-0.4716926515,
0.8079075813,
-0.2972898185,
0.8890730143,
-0.6943194866,
-0.1299901605,
-0.2633403838,
0.2595487535,
-0.231832996,
-0.7239269018,
-0.2301450074,
0.1413163543,
-0.1977487803,
-0.1385983378,
0.875669539,
-0.5374436975,
-0.6336999536,
0.1649587154,
0.5167024732,
-0.0264194421,
0.2712330818,
-0.9938797951,
0.2154548317,
-0.0316567384,
-0.1570071131,
0.3820971847,
0.283555001,
-0.0925864801,
0.494971633,
0.5250722766,
0.0711518601,
0.1224904433,
0.2948527038,
0.7598280311,
-0.819842577,
-0.3220242262,
-0.6877253056,
0.7619535327,
0.2282494009,
-0.3152647316,
0.2294594049,
0.1772130877,
0.6100699902,
-0.1063911766,
0.678204596,
0.1914770901,
-0.011766281,
-0.9056041837,
0.2334105223,
-0.755741477,
0.0529474877,
-0.4370583594,
-1.0290540457,
-0.4109379053,
0.4691927433,
-0.020260796,
-0.0989860892,
0.7773986459,
1.0897179842,
-0.3871020973,
-0.6983979344,
0.7770974636,
0.2043203264,
-0.0436173938,
0.6977961659,
0.4723030031,
-0.6289348602,
0.7950869203,
-0.3121995032,
-0.3181226552,
-0.3915053308,
-1.130664587,
-0.8923111558,
-0.5915651321,
-0.6306504607,
-0.3269910216,
0.1734955758,
0.9873446822,
0.7258933783,
-0.8270877004,
0.1084217876,
0.3945061266,
0.1228738949,
-0.3305986524,
-0.1419566572,
0.368150115,
-0.3668989539,
-0.6693461537,
0.5120271444,
0.5092225075,
0.3027192354,
-0.1916417181,
-0.1740515381,
-0.0506780334,
0.0126342727,
0.5464974046,
0.6173714995,
-0.7916345596,
-0.5337198973,
0.028110452,
-0.2065852284,
0.31678617,
0.6472744346,
-0.8642125726,
0.5820760727,
0.5067777634,
0.9159687161,
0.4027707875,
0.0565695949,
0.4382266104,
-0.9147059917,
0.5424534082,
-0.0891548097,
0.3751551807,
0.4173620939,
-0.2722396851,
0.1402835101,
0.4045371711,
-0.1574742198,
-0.7991243601,
0.2358187884,
-1.5901181698,
-0.263794899,
1.1056209803,
0.0917640477,
-0.5234917998,
-0.0486496501,
-0.4342754185,
-0.1103079543,
-0.331223011,
0.4536550641,
0.2482229173,
0.2134984881,
-0.8323873281,
-0.5486879945,
0.5540197492,
0.3770774901,
-0.5834619999,
-0.1632616371,
0.4584248066,
0.3808633089,
0.0057728663,
0.6849865317,
0.1850361377,
0.553085506,
-0.1020462811,
0.1501999944,
-0.0221747309,
-0.397087276,
-0.9993715286,
0.1230182573,
0.2146151364,
-0.4569605589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01746v1 | Is ChatGPT a Highly Fluent Grammatical Error Correction System? A Comprehensive Evaluation | 2023-04-04T12:33:40 | 2023-04-04T12:33:40 | Tao Fang, Shu Yang, Kaixin Lan, Derek F. Wong, Jinpeng Hu, Lidia S. Chao, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT, a large-scale language model based on the advanced GPT-3.5
architecture, has shown remarkable potential in various Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. However, there is currently a dearth of comprehensive
study exploring its potential in the area of Grammatical Error Correction
(GEC). To showcase its capabilities in GEC, we design zero-shot
chain-of-thought (CoT) and few-shot CoT settings using in-context learning for
ChatGPT. Our evaluation involves assessing ChatGPT's performance on five
official test sets in three different languages, along with three
document-level GEC test sets in English. Our experimental results and human
evaluations demonstrate that ChatGPT has excellent error detection capabilities
and can freely correct errors to make the corrected sentences very fluent,
possibly due to its over-correction tendencies and not adhering to the
principle of minimal edits. Additionally, its performance in non-English and
low-resource settings highlights its potential in multilingual GEC tasks.
However, further analysis of various types of errors at the document-level has
shown that ChatGPT cannot effectively correct agreement, coreference, tense
errors across sentences, and cross-sentence boundary errors. | [
-0.1312168092,
-1.2018964291,
0.3466834128,
0.3593850434,
0.0385316759,
0.2412836254,
-0.6164749861,
-0.283998698,
-0.0556536317,
-0.144364208,
-0.3435536027,
-0.5436181426,
-0.6055192947,
0.1163102239,
-0.3953502476,
1.1590474844,
-0.0676456392,
0.1298896372,
0.0244211815,
0.0119478079,
-0.7310181856,
-0.8466085792,
-0.8199834824,
0.0568354465,
0.3096723258,
0.6784659028,
0.7135606408,
0.2078750879,
0.580501914,
0.232567817,
-0.2319337577,
0.214298889,
-0.5427910686,
-0.082617335,
-0.1141052097,
-0.1805879921,
-0.8311625719,
-0.3684251904,
0.6537962556,
0.6225414276,
-0.3236682713,
-0.3234698176,
0.3959664404,
0.5964099765,
-0.675067842,
0.4352663457,
-0.6604982615,
0.1630428433,
-0.1759494692,
0.1638566554,
-0.6127887964,
-0.189118132,
-0.0094636362,
-0.4915730655,
0.4287861288,
-0.1899529696,
0.8010733724,
0.0184029061,
-0.2961508632,
-0.295837909,
-0.8287972808,
0.3059206307,
-0.6885496974,
0.2192614824,
0.2624045312,
0.2076864392,
-0.2788649499,
-0.3957252204,
-0.4832445681,
-0.138625443,
0.0627355203,
0.531519115,
-0.1904001087,
0.4485233128,
0.2937248945,
0.2882758379,
-0.8574556112,
0.0250844955,
-0.0845027044,
-0.1922093779,
0.1830798686,
-0.1095260605,
0.3415508866,
-0.043436233,
-0.0681158006,
0.0592735074,
-0.6121757627,
-0.1644227654,
0.1227401048,
0.4265454113,
-0.1513442993,
0.5106286407,
-0.2931914032,
0.6285573244,
-0.2267434448,
0.2448897213,
-0.0255672,
-0.1173812449,
-0.3177267909,
0.0057417634,
0.8068550229,
0.3280834258,
0.4148109257,
-0.1797493398,
-0.1830013841,
0.3643110693,
0.1359830797,
-0.3397145867,
-0.2889020443,
-0.0820272118,
0.2544151545,
-0.1443909407,
0.070158489,
-0.6800679564,
-0.2470704317,
0.0955664068,
0.4224653542,
-0.5355557203,
0.0045698285,
0.3380323946,
0.1657232046,
0.2031865269,
0.4860098064,
-0.9825515747,
0.4047180712,
0.6647267342,
0.999853313,
0.1014426202,
-0.5392280221,
-0.3521453738,
-0.0978861973,
-0.5531933904,
1.113941431,
-0.3936267197,
-0.4001852274,
0.1772483736,
-0.0897979513,
-0.5436270833,
-0.2238186002,
0.6363652945,
-0.3539909422,
0.229893133,
-0.3065898716,
-0.6817739606,
-0.0137494719,
0.5386325121,
-0.4595012069,
0.9711977243,
0.0227277931,
-0.6653351784,
0.2797831893,
-0.6814805269,
-0.4903970361,
0.0750464424,
-0.0033823573,
-0.2757866979,
-0.1704022735,
0.3324517608,
0.3309485018,
0.1086163968,
0.2648860216,
-0.0425129756,
-0.6159481406,
0.1704012603,
-0.7993447185,
0.3457424641,
-0.1632061601,
-0.6233335137,
0.1172926277,
-0.7389680743,
0.1499026567,
-0.0924776942,
-0.3401970565,
0.2260302752,
-0.0432924032,
-0.0059309532,
0.2015888691,
-0.037681289,
-0.4875026345,
0.3150958419,
-0.1003481522,
0.4330456555,
0.6457551718,
-0.0707682371,
0.3431739807,
-0.1071353704,
0.5680530071,
-0.4037488401,
0.0397264101,
-0.2935774922,
-0.7151716948,
-1.0797767639,
-0.011130807,
0.4001369476,
0.9687534571,
-0.5123777986,
0.4692946672,
-0.1262722015,
-0.2549859285,
0.0704365745,
-0.1113619283,
0.6931326389,
0.4886190295,
0.2096653432,
-0.1814944893,
-0.465875119,
-0.4393170774,
-0.2046927065,
-0.4330173135,
0.1600545645,
0.1457916796,
0.5066807866,
-0.0257382449,
0.8105974197,
-0.4094973207,
-0.3727290332,
-0.3036996126,
0.1589154452,
-0.0025780876,
0.3657429218,
0.2726039886,
-0.2774370313,
-0.6894122362,
0.428592205,
-0.7807862759,
-0.0287151933,
-0.107534416,
-0.1971689165,
0.3791290224,
0.4072735012,
-0.7057709098,
0.2944185734,
0.6155850291,
-0.4369243383,
0.7599540353,
-0.5552635789,
0.1927807927,
-0.7981687188,
-0.0224890262,
-0.1669732779,
-0.3280387521,
-0.6218428612,
0.0166009478,
0.3708699942,
-0.1466218084,
-0.2907954454,
0.1316979378,
-0.1623252481,
0.1203351319,
-0.1496674418,
0.225465104,
-0.1476246119,
0.6360142827,
-0.1061172262,
0.8214056492,
0.4912371933,
-0.2761707306,
0.3720158339,
0.2113950104,
0.0530995652,
0.7249270082,
-0.3668741882,
0.4170934856,
-0.1241042092,
0.3041846454,
-1.0180367231,
-0.6215237379,
0.2053598613,
-0.5548270941,
0.2553848624,
-0.2737259269,
-0.4980568886,
-0.0998999551,
0.0358980894,
0.0341130048,
0.3896951973,
-0.3004020154,
0.1429025829,
-0.0201751199,
-0.349455744,
-0.6223543882,
-0.5354391932,
0.3593645096,
0.2788809538,
-0.7117397785,
-0.1536595821,
0.3074953556,
-0.1116956025,
-0.0272980854,
0.0363675766,
-0.1448684633,
-0.0876111984,
0.0575068928,
0.2810690701,
-0.218325004,
0.5225750804,
-0.2077421993,
-0.0883202329,
-0.3081831038,
-0.3245142996,
0.5678657889,
-0.7781065702,
-0.565468967,
-0.1957823336,
0.1856658161,
0.3998653293,
-0.1389513463,
0.467592448,
0.3937527835,
-0.4892750978,
-0.089968726,
-0.5796185732,
0.3715972304,
-0.3443356454,
0.4952293634,
-0.1603157818,
-0.7581061721,
0.6484392285,
0.3861744702,
-0.0341770127,
0.5554040074,
0.2491312027,
-0.1535760313,
0.6053538322,
0.5045213103,
-0.1434610635,
0.2997111678,
-0.1305071712,
0.2361249477,
-0.4631103575,
0.0615590289,
-0.5658821464,
-0.0681820735,
-0.5150262713,
-0.3293260038,
0.3119761646,
0.1822923273,
-0.4514930546,
0.2486743629,
-0.1418746412,
0.7238291502,
0.4107593894,
0.1369477957,
0.5154688358,
-0.0866934881,
-0.2071654052,
-0.0949730054,
-0.82060498,
-0.5532500744,
0.8277292252,
0.0974467322,
0.7098365426,
0.0715514719,
0.3468054235,
0.1402680278,
0.1330901235,
-0.879953742,
0.3783826232,
-0.3562008142,
-0.5391407013,
-0.4466263652,
-0.2340669632,
-0.5978564024,
0.3981171846,
-0.1718401164,
-0.6456730962,
-0.1318377852,
0.3648920655,
-0.6129956245,
0.5193219781,
-1.16130054,
1.1514577866,
-0.0807266682,
-0.4366108477,
-0.011245491,
-0.6172174811,
0.0945918262,
0.0837285221,
0.0434428565,
-0.0386227183,
0.0946018696,
0.2596739531,
-0.2706633508,
0.915266037,
-0.1247957051,
-0.0089348843,
0.3642321229,
0.259554714,
0.6867436171,
-0.0384625345,
-0.0332658701,
-0.0617322735,
-0.3002891541,
-0.4946753085,
-0.66553092,
0.4310058653,
-0.566175878,
-0.2476999015,
-0.6108099222,
-0.3915716708,
-0.5126101375,
0.1254562736,
0.3552964032,
0.4611782432,
-0.7394789457,
0.1177791432,
0.4396073818,
-0.0500158407,
0.4527105987,
0.3155930936,
-0.0386514179,
-0.2772076726,
0.737653017,
0.1734368056,
0.415247649,
0.2228339463,
0.0383713432,
-0.0501830764,
-0.5123734474,
-0.8809977174,
0.0073888367,
-0.756675899,
-0.000217803,
-0.5980915427,
-0.2743076682,
-0.2468907237,
-0.3708276153,
-0.5239156485,
-0.2963453233,
-0.0325879641,
-0.2124243677,
0.1917565614,
0.8313711882,
0.0992857441,
0.6748469472,
-0.8293066621,
-0.0486820303,
0.2168475688,
0.5223510265,
-0.3697450459,
-0.3291505277,
-0.0921930969,
0.0769251809,
-0.4074978828,
-0.5457062125,
0.2201138437,
0.4544314146,
0.1171855181,
0.1858473122,
-0.3892470002,
0.9396031499,
-0.6781794429,
0.996994555,
-0.05273683,
-1.0839265585,
0.4321174026,
-0.6526938677,
0.4954454005,
0.4376763105,
-0.1740784794,
-1.2520430088,
-0.4478817582,
-0.7404161096,
-0.6799123287,
0.5848616958,
0.3971045613,
0.1069352478,
-0.1366640478,
0.348505497,
-0.1022202522,
-0.0463715568,
-0.6909640431,
0.3723880053,
-0.0370083936,
-0.143084228,
-0.1460827887,
-0.3734274805,
0.0972105786,
0.1166047305,
0.8160478473,
-0.4186498225,
0.3163693845,
0.3927414715,
-0.280074656,
-0.0207534861,
0.7689862847,
0.6794490814,
0.6455718279,
-0.1075401753,
0.0451126099,
0.5727751255,
-0.5788468122,
0.115119271,
-0.0465291999,
-0.017084863,
0.0687444061,
0.5254005194,
0.6350120902,
0.4595417082,
-0.4725334346,
0.7182731628,
-0.0467208698,
-0.1056055203,
-0.312099278,
-0.1786845326,
0.0876224339,
-0.0081739919,
0.0475219414,
0.4867649376,
-0.0716700852,
-0.3184807003,
0.0704399347,
0.3740766346,
-0.5003752112,
-0.3256267011,
0.4213875234,
0.2736830115,
-0.0366977006,
0.7676131725,
-0.5623975992,
-0.5773270726,
0.520783186,
0.5752514601,
0.8291047812,
-0.1942297518,
0.4904887676,
0.3417689204,
0.376100421,
-0.4632965326,
0.1121383682,
0.1795508862,
-0.8781160116,
-0.6985444427,
-0.1270634234,
-0.7085006833,
-0.1445404887,
-0.3536405563,
0.3597512841,
-0.5723242164,
-0.0091106286,
-0.3639859855,
-0.3873668313,
-0.3214104176,
0.1439097822,
0.0972673893,
0.6463511586,
-0.7935733795,
0.5884164572,
0.642760098,
-0.0929373652,
-0.8500115275,
0.0910692066,
0.1396314204,
-0.5757622719,
0.1685020775,
0.0758832172,
-0.3918427229,
-0.0718890503,
-0.3895696104,
-0.4871831834,
0.7033548951,
0.5845559835,
-0.585658133,
-0.1761342138,
0.1798277795,
0.8512742519,
0.0569056273,
0.4332457781,
0.5266827345,
0.1982767135,
0.1701995581,
-1.4082856178,
-0.4206593037,
-0.248142451,
0.0404328778,
0.1202761233,
-0.6562077403,
0.774640739,
-0.0819333345,
-0.3178904653,
0.0942812189,
0.2803523242,
-0.1690419763,
-0.0531853214,
0.2741175294,
0.5804318786,
0.9526765943,
-0.4007740021,
0.9842991233,
0.0546182729,
0.7471647859,
1.241668582,
-0.3995094001,
0.9389205575,
0.1206726655,
-0.2016168982,
0.3317433298,
0.486910671,
0.2496439815,
0.0730132759,
-0.0422263034,
-0.5806207657,
-0.1517173946,
0.1715719551,
-0.2212803066,
0.3921175897,
0.3759409189,
-0.0156235965,
-0.4294164777,
-0.0326732844,
0.2948403955,
0.1007113606,
-0.2678996027,
0.7954965234,
-0.274636507,
-0.6284950376,
0.4647251368,
-0.0077726347,
0.6768900752,
-0.5327247977,
-0.1278660595,
-0.3694090545,
0.5507475138,
-0.2898422182,
-0.8125861287,
0.2156327516,
0.4869237244,
0.2834545374,
-0.0326074138,
0.8726821542,
-0.3596881628,
-0.4262632728,
0.0583033524,
0.5899733305,
0.1442094296,
-0.4220716357,
-0.2292784154,
-0.121756874,
-0.1463327408,
0.0948783606,
-0.0309178624,
0.4707853794,
-0.153234303,
0.4593200684,
0.3552336097,
0.0813606977,
0.2276728451,
0.2930721939,
0.5902075768,
-0.6440596581,
-0.6491146684,
-0.9194833636,
0.5425460935,
-0.0565725714,
-0.4548916817,
0.619197309,
0.5870947242,
1.1124751568,
-0.2247231901,
1.0048991442,
-0.149914965,
0.2240214348,
-0.6361791492,
0.4547922909,
0.0787017792,
0.0759513974,
-0.4997378886,
-0.8896170855,
-0.8951610923,
0.7827730179,
-0.3745237291,
-0.0514562018,
1.070962429,
0.870072782,
0.0413972549,
0.4234360456,
0.5203609467,
0.2043423951,
0.3606914878,
0.6578193903,
0.8873651624,
-0.5368090868,
0.6466475129,
-0.1938647479,
-0.4191611707,
-0.1214634702,
-0.6411628723,
-0.6283833981,
-0.3249237537,
-0.1791725308,
-0.3491858244,
0.6263487339,
1.0995771885,
0.3950614929,
-0.8051711917,
-0.2473579496,
-0.4710655212,
-0.1539984196,
-0.3607161641,
-0.1938033998,
0.3163676262,
-0.8468076587,
-0.8090780973,
0.2774517834,
0.4529473782,
0.0417019911,
0.0781782046,
-0.0330943204,
-0.1588750631,
-0.3569126427,
0.8541635275,
0.2789175808,
-0.4821576476,
-0.5990100503,
0.2737363279,
-0.288333118,
0.3709264696,
0.8729095459,
-0.3370385468,
0.6603287458,
0.4409546554,
0.5616304278,
0.311606437,
-0.0121733705,
0.6491841674,
-0.790405333,
0.1086028367,
0.1462012082,
0.5289735198,
0.3733819723,
-0.4674337208,
0.6370461583,
0.397100687,
-0.7247787714,
-0.2245377004,
-0.0433499962,
-0.9757881761,
0.1816623956,
1.3071000576,
-0.4115693867,
-0.0057702069,
-0.2044702619,
-0.817261219,
0.2246890962,
-0.4453516304,
0.6549182534,
1.3747185469,
-0.2707024813,
-0.0830803216,
-0.8197267652,
0.2561714947,
0.4965406954,
-0.8706136346,
0.266058743,
0.7240190506,
0.1944679171,
0.0726567879,
0.6446979046,
-0.3237010539,
0.5439161658,
0.1888545305,
0.2273194194,
0.3201487362,
-0.2711228728,
-0.6601996422,
0.0471943021,
0.3156022131,
-0.2259378731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01712v1 | Rumour Detection and Analysis on Twitter | 2023-04-04T11:20:37 | 2023-04-04T11:20:37 | Yaohou Fan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years people have become increasingly reliant on social media to
read news and get information, and some social media users post unsubstantiated
information to gain attention. Such information is known as rumours. Nowadays,
rumour detection is receiving a growing amount of attention because of the
pandemic of the New Coronavirus, which has led to a large number of rumours
being spread. In this paper, a Natural Language Processing (NLP) system is
built to predict rumours. The best model is applied to the COVID-19 tweets to
conduct exploratory data analysis. The contribution of this study is twofold:
(1) to compare rumours and facts using state-of-the-art natural language
processing models in two dimensions: language structure and propagation route.
(2) An analysis of how rumours differ from facts in terms of their lexical use
and the emotions they imply. This study shows that linguistic structure is a
better feature to distinguish rumours from facts compared to the propagation
path. In addition, rumour tweets contain more vocabulary related to politics
and negative emotions. | [
-0.4197427034,
-1.0625183582,
0.2502436638,
0.5556561947,
-0.5651346445,
0.2265681177,
-0.318395108,
-1.1087905169,
0.5591043234,
0.3407012224,
-0.5109601617,
-0.4283383489,
-0.6538652182,
-0.0708971769,
-0.7667943835,
1.0926370621,
0.3227653205,
-0.2600611746,
-0.0228528082,
0.0780665651,
-0.0898072198,
-0.5656905174,
-0.9249221683,
-0.1433862597,
0.3193489015,
0.1552003026,
0.883801043,
0.0402948149,
0.666280508,
0.1667421013,
-0.1127449274,
0.1922761947,
-0.2884098887,
0.5658213496,
0.0100236982,
-0.311814934,
-0.0746159032,
0.1102952659,
0.1158034652,
0.1210180372,
-0.2219820619,
0.3351362646,
-0.2829120457,
0.4463818967,
-0.3027319014,
0.1351563185,
-0.7458017468,
0.0474439785,
-0.5435033441,
-0.3389874697,
-0.1706597358,
-0.5342100859,
0.5554453731,
-0.1692983359,
0.3653863668,
0.1591798514,
0.8907722235,
-0.0022956296,
-0.043049261,
-0.5443440676,
-0.68490839,
0.5312833786,
-0.5826918483,
0.197209388,
0.3011791408,
0.6014634967,
-0.0685635805,
-0.313508898,
-0.4155373871,
-0.2341216505,
-0.0537912808,
-0.1625800729,
-0.6091731191,
-0.3593662679,
0.0231578797,
0.3608317673,
-0.6187466383,
-0.1364727765,
-0.5335639119,
-0.4966982901,
0.7940007448,
-0.4118484855,
0.5825279951,
-0.4064905941,
-0.4639776051,
0.3346098363,
-0.298838973,
-0.0497323722,
0.2318411022,
0.1261660606,
-0.4441057146,
0.3420234025,
-0.1269819587,
0.3817675114,
0.1079564691,
-0.4861062467,
0.2336986512,
-0.2084520608,
-0.3341494203,
0.4793607891,
0.9360480309,
0.4911592305,
0.3354502618,
-0.4766286612,
0.0355255567,
0.6138312817,
0.1489735246,
-0.5340033174,
-0.2939389944,
0.3182850182,
-0.4641353786,
-0.5166535974,
-0.1611348689,
-0.9873894453,
-0.6618303061,
-0.0443360396,
0.0748580396,
-0.7137717009,
-0.3663572967,
0.1659284532,
-0.7093345523,
0.2779897451,
0.9084702134,
-0.3632213771,
0.4152415693,
0.7405375838,
0.6522291303,
-0.0772975534,
0.2357724458,
-0.2588153183,
0.0500288568,
-0.3111951649,
1.2797027826,
-0.5733685493,
0.1538048089,
-0.0994740501,
-0.5328955054,
0.1520606726,
-0.3863929808,
0.9904606342,
-0.4853519499,
0.520170927,
-0.3206295967,
-0.2683486044,
-0.3708258867,
0.3276155889,
-0.5467880368,
1.0132278204,
-0.0982195064,
-1.1855900288,
0.4186688066,
-0.4855817556,
-0.5958245397,
-0.0581414588,
0.037012618,
-0.3537184298,
0.2014667094,
0.5436154008,
0.330085814,
-0.6292898059,
0.4061411619,
-0.1325202733,
-0.0199369323,
0.2817045748,
-0.4956033528,
0.8044538498,
0.4214327633,
-0.3408443332,
-0.2122747302,
-0.5168219209,
-0.3613149524,
-0.1604713351,
0.0430659838,
-0.3811210692,
0.0693015233,
0.0676871464,
0.3568995595,
-0.0200561676,
-0.6937239766,
0.0895500183,
-0.3718385696,
0.1759352088,
0.0709074289,
0.4122439325,
0.2901451886,
-0.3804055452,
0.4801548123,
0.2953559458,
0.4305800796,
0.2350837886,
-0.8137268424,
-0.6173312068,
-0.0176751353,
-0.2314070314,
0.4921785295,
-0.642036736,
0.0973980874,
0.136520341,
-0.8528640866,
-0.5749652386,
-0.2738682032,
-0.0997332707,
0.4607322812,
0.3663763404,
0.3521977067,
-1.119146347,
-0.7287148833,
-0.635356307,
-0.5589019656,
0.3936423957,
-0.2973636687,
0.0391173251,
-0.0227569025,
0.8456918597,
-0.2786489129,
-0.190074265,
-0.4867129624,
0.5443903804,
0.2053810954,
-0.0412968136,
0.871109724,
-0.8153762221,
-0.5005037189,
-0.0392654128,
-0.6568790078,
-0.179614231,
0.0492593125,
0.0655612126,
0.4886303544,
0.2288275212,
-0.4854791164,
0.555429101,
0.4854016304,
-0.3555763066,
0.6619700789,
0.2961813807,
0.1424906552,
-0.9587498307,
-0.2551806271,
0.3122093081,
-0.3226032853,
-0.7900452018,
-0.201859504,
-0.3627408743,
0.1862095743,
-0.1605777144,
0.2968936861,
-0.243425861,
0.114452526,
-0.453126967,
0.0309990998,
-0.0140137561,
-0.2157877684,
0.1499806195,
0.3031397164,
0.8725321293,
-0.5060597062,
0.5687299967,
-0.1383962035,
-0.4867275357,
0.3103824258,
-0.3291715682,
-0.200383693,
-0.3208717406,
0.2813589573,
-1.0058672428,
-0.133897081,
0.5805297494,
-0.8035627007,
-0.1601623148,
0.0970385298,
-0.4960895777,
-0.5499394536,
-0.4725099206,
-0.2298688143,
0.4238044918,
-0.3149049878,
0.2875765562,
0.6030440331,
-0.0912099257,
-0.4305951297,
-0.8200167418,
0.4625772238,
-0.4096529186,
-0.8001514673,
0.1408513784,
0.2463014722,
-0.7838687897,
0.0845492631,
-0.2384328991,
-0.3320811987,
0.0277619381,
0.1680459827,
0.1503970027,
-0.3218325078,
0.1330050081,
-0.2265435457,
0.1025583148,
0.318662852,
-0.0264920704,
0.4819946289,
-0.1330108941,
0.282794714,
-0.5998482704,
0.1202397943,
0.6669659019,
-0.1671607792,
1.0348242521,
0.9989688993,
-0.6085814238,
-0.2619150877,
-0.9492331147,
0.0888063833,
-0.3525284231,
-0.0309691783,
0.0202335417,
-0.4953832328,
0.3508830965,
0.1849488467,
-0.2272360027,
0.9201197028,
0.3385307193,
-0.0370339379,
0.4542142153,
0.6107239723,
-0.4056899548,
-0.0128362169,
-0.0214522071,
0.577742219,
-0.2645157278,
-0.5269415975,
-0.6894308925,
-0.1574023962,
-0.4419387281,
-0.6055683494,
0.1332189739,
0.0103575615,
0.442247957,
0.4640892446,
-0.4758901298,
0.0829338953,
0.300424546,
-0.1190034673,
0.4265349507,
0.3850330114,
0.0039430768,
0.016861029,
-0.5855629444,
-0.4984764159,
0.4299547374,
0.4933088124,
0.8162015676,
0.2159965336,
0.4175109267,
0.6584382057,
0.3708613515,
-0.6682872176,
0.4025001526,
-0.0277563911,
-0.5769290328,
-0.3713294864,
-0.1151419058,
-0.5718608499,
-0.0150589375,
-0.4434477687,
-0.8556370139,
0.1762951761,
-0.3237092793,
-0.3683169782,
0.5336886048,
-0.4813744128,
0.1715547889,
-0.0984700844,
0.1576578468,
-0.5576251149,
-0.3795230687,
0.5222382545,
-0.1077753529,
0.553349793,
-0.5179187655,
0.1682700068,
0.8451092243,
-0.4434985816,
0.6375960112,
-0.155753985,
-0.0961742923,
0.6787707806,
-0.1037130058,
0.3834534287,
0.3092809618,
-0.5824355483,
0.0874829516,
0.0282629039,
-0.1174494401,
-0.1809200644,
0.489223361,
-0.8671660423,
-0.4589528143,
-0.7378324866,
-0.3703487515,
0.08949738,
-0.4503643215,
0.5153566599,
0.2636400163,
-0.3453769386,
0.1280572265,
0.3324154317,
-0.3233884573,
0.5928647518,
0.4830782712,
-0.4012202621,
-0.0629860982,
0.3659926951,
0.2074398994,
-0.2402316034,
0.5808930397,
0.5581105351,
-0.1877116412,
-0.3832533658,
0.0037213136,
0.1111515239,
-0.4279468358,
-0.2825247943,
-0.8105739355,
-0.6525214911,
-0.5786631107,
-0.0768489838,
-0.2885756791,
-0.2872320712,
-0.0789669901,
-0.1138881668,
1.0549737215,
0.9788145423,
-0.1065205112,
0.3303538263,
-0.4011873305,
0.5445128679,
0.043607045,
0.1591786295,
-0.0796950608,
-0.5165504217,
-0.2860398293,
0.1327102333,
-0.0276964586,
-0.9909207821,
0.6577404737,
0.072058931,
0.2336860001,
0.7096889615,
0.1870186329,
0.6631013155,
-0.0943457708,
0.730835855,
0.3149905205,
-0.7134416103,
0.6574270725,
-0.3876117766,
0.006026221,
0.3518528044,
0.2958159447,
-0.9423872232,
-0.697840631,
-0.7844822407,
-0.4358875155,
0.5359089971,
0.2144726068,
-0.334277451,
-0.2350717485,
0.1898791194,
0.5060014129,
0.2437053621,
-0.5317966342,
-0.3489831686,
0.1136719659,
0.3593898118,
0.0572889782,
-0.6710456014,
0.2432181686,
-0.5006651282,
0.4720264673,
0.4413229823,
0.4235311151,
0.1463759392,
0.0091435043,
-0.468577981,
0.3309792876,
0.3360435665,
0.7638136148,
-0.5037280321,
0.3761285841,
-0.1056329459,
-0.5530509353,
-0.0075351745,
-0.0564262271,
-0.0653873309,
0.5850712061,
0.3660839796,
0.7776113153,
0.0232826304,
-0.3106536269,
0.573353827,
-0.1639097482,
-0.2860568762,
-0.6366737485,
-0.0853315815,
0.2554729283,
0.3111353219,
0.5732965469,
0.7363508344,
0.2749377489,
-0.985951066,
0.2567750216,
0.3521502614,
-0.2342007607,
-0.6460183859,
0.4946995378,
0.1411850899,
-0.0890014619,
0.4114670753,
-0.3686869144,
-0.6655762792,
0.5498033166,
0.4639860988,
0.8423753381,
-0.3716519773,
0.8466539383,
0.2272177339,
0.562036097,
-0.2822466493,
0.4120516181,
0.3210635781,
-0.6995116472,
-0.5383979678,
-0.6921992898,
-0.1277892739,
0.4553821385,
-0.4891185164,
0.5441065431,
-0.3265269399,
-0.0906399935,
0.3341356814,
0.1079953536,
-0.7012038231,
0.3439420164,
0.717594564,
1.1198245287,
-0.96579808,
0.9159444571,
0.6379422545,
-0.1596949995,
-0.7350096703,
0.4622931778,
0.0420840718,
-0.5899311304,
0.5468748808,
0.2618821561,
0.2056535929,
-0.5923190713,
-0.5395222902,
-1.1529896259,
0.6712813973,
0.4093607068,
-0.3477450609,
0.0435792319,
0.2545059919,
0.7798739672,
-0.4237247109,
0.144342944,
0.5254811049,
0.6118844748,
0.4159635901,
-1.0204652548,
-0.1601365507,
0.0206555389,
-0.4780111015,
0.0436223745,
-0.6293397546,
0.7146295905,
-0.0417999439,
-0.1942605823,
-0.2540854812,
0.5820207,
0.0669805631,
0.6953453422,
0.3971335292,
0.399074167,
0.9932877421,
-0.117951028,
1.1084414721,
-0.2244018465,
0.0556240007,
0.7792603374,
-0.0026336745,
0.8619207144,
0.3052396476,
-0.2472695261,
0.8283416629,
0.5977057219,
0.1436096728,
0.3909257352,
0.2390080988,
-0.0534568951,
-0.0369861871,
-0.287340492,
-0.3587738872,
0.6061906219,
0.7255493999,
-0.2463011742,
-0.7705329657,
0.1460451633,
0.2526792586,
-0.1058597788,
-0.4891359806,
0.4370665848,
0.0404655524,
-0.6573876143,
0.2739900947,
0.1509487778,
0.789177537,
-0.4393029213,
0.2479100823,
0.0544418506,
-0.1030144021,
-0.4087444246,
-0.6932333708,
0.8270778656,
0.1004099771,
-0.2260213047,
0.0311763529,
1.3838442564,
-0.4649412632,
-0.5106950402,
0.5079471469,
0.7931672335,
0.278580755,
-0.6839746833,
-0.734847188,
0.0664609373,
0.0699511394,
-0.1340763122,
-0.0017078221,
0.6992896795,
-0.2115603536,
0.639447093,
0.4383520484,
0.3129271269,
0.0983146951,
0.0168796424,
0.809532702,
-0.6313609481,
-0.551787436,
-1.0932245255,
0.0072693354,
-0.2735026479,
0.0362738781,
1.0757893324,
0.517911613,
0.1139822155,
0.1258056164,
0.9860674143,
-0.1524721384,
0.6956988573,
-0.1604190022,
0.6842311025,
0.0101102442,
0.4187739789,
-0.3641369045,
-0.6321940422,
-0.2056667507,
0.4780455232,
-0.6112360954,
-0.3270668685,
0.8408755064,
0.3383934498,
0.29507038,
0.5109434724,
-0.0220766049,
0.4134849608,
0.0009297392,
0.0632655695,
0.8546814322,
-0.3633529246,
0.3944005668,
-0.3438666463,
0.0469949357,
-0.6594238281,
-0.830509603,
-1.0515044928,
-0.364813149,
-0.5845400691,
-0.4924883842,
0.312025398,
0.8871856928,
0.4099445939,
-0.8352808356,
-0.2298161387,
-0.0604607686,
0.2389593571,
-0.2134378254,
-0.2709288299,
0.5236703157,
-0.2898288071,
-0.1546186507,
0.2411636114,
0.5548222065,
-0.2414216101,
-0.1709277928,
0.2790426016,
-0.6304058433,
0.3261649609,
0.7361073494,
0.114721261,
-0.6989995241,
-0.2851820588,
-0.0225290377,
-0.215379253,
0.0050183414,
0.4627332091,
-1.0649759769,
0.1669844985,
0.6719400883,
0.1931078732,
0.3356611133,
0.017244637,
0.6856074929,
-0.6723100543,
0.19125624,
0.0845070258,
0.169937849,
0.3755876124,
-0.7451412678,
0.4240662158,
0.2854820192,
-0.2229830623,
-0.4514634907,
-0.3581179976,
-1.0175514221,
-0.3462226987,
1.2886561155,
0.4689130187,
-0.465749681,
-0.441557467,
-0.1760164201,
0.2768521011,
-0.823987782,
0.9984989166,
0.7273651958,
-0.1691269875,
-0.0488199331,
-0.5634191036,
0.8962074518,
-0.2064855248,
-0.7096688151,
-0.2386956513,
-0.0328248218,
0.2440805584,
0.1702248156,
0.6747093797,
0.0220810622,
0.2485282421,
-0.1034576073,
-0.0752003491,
0.1890520453,
-0.160889253,
0.0682603717,
0.5415467024,
-0.0942788944,
-0.0008563909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01680v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01680v1 | Can BERT eat RuCoLA? Topological Data Analysis to Explain | 2023-04-04T10:11:06 | 2023-04-04T10:11:06 | Irina Proskurina, Irina Piontkovskaya, Ekaterina Artemova | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates how Transformer language models (LMs) fine-tuned for
acceptability classification capture linguistic features. Our approach uses the
best practices of topological data analysis (TDA) in NLP: we construct directed
attention graphs from attention matrices, derive topological features from
them, and feed them to linear classifiers. We introduce two novel features,
chordality, and the matching number, and show that TDA-based classifiers
outperform fine-tuning baselines. We experiment with two datasets, CoLA and
RuCoLA in English and Russian, typologically different languages. On top of
that, we propose several black-box introspection techniques aimed at detecting
changes in the attention mode of the LMs during fine-tuning, defining the LM's
prediction confidences, and associating individual heads with fine-grained
grammar phenomena. Our results contribute to understanding the behavior of
monolingual LMs in the acceptability classification task, provide insights into
the functional roles of attention heads, and highlight the advantages of
TDA-based approaches for analyzing LMs. We release the code and the
experimental results for further uptake. | [
-0.346069634,
-0.8542284966,
0.395015806,
0.0911492035,
-0.0262603685,
-0.0310278982,
-0.4830000103,
-0.6778890491,
0.3296084702,
0.3580992818,
-0.3648723066,
-0.2739083767,
-0.6654233336,
0.2294923365,
-0.6462067366,
0.894620657,
0.2965833545,
-0.0932822973,
-0.0060044411,
-0.3506899774,
-0.5372784734,
-0.3225085139,
-0.5563408732,
-0.3984659612,
0.8463121057,
0.5713073015,
0.9018697143,
0.7333058715,
0.4009337723,
0.2771574855,
-0.3653922975,
-0.0920996964,
-0.5060922503,
0.0214943979,
-0.0425428413,
-0.5858899951,
-0.4423982799,
-0.0330328606,
0.7074433565,
0.9088958502,
-0.0470876805,
0.288434267,
0.4452630877,
0.7352407575,
-0.1458862871,
0.133933872,
-0.8723876476,
0.2129924893,
-0.3007914722,
-0.2290796191,
-0.6554496884,
-0.4972583354,
0.3225961626,
-0.3408604264,
0.4271378815,
-0.0717252791,
0.9470792413,
0.4239670336,
-0.1045026034,
-0.3327996135,
-0.8281751871,
0.5133454204,
-0.3859263361,
0.8447731137,
0.3294627964,
0.3597142696,
-0.1407089233,
-0.8173594475,
-0.6963749528,
0.1470155865,
-0.5627397895,
-0.3834974766,
-0.4428808987,
-0.2475497574,
-0.0317751579,
0.5444408655,
-0.8159034252,
0.1358790249,
-0.4650131464,
0.2010019124,
0.2844905853,
-0.0825495273,
0.383957088,
-0.3578426242,
0.1801739037,
-0.0784470811,
-0.3963651359,
0.2347897738,
0.0557025559,
0.7146703005,
-0.0812621564,
0.4892213047,
-0.0534082539,
0.8049502969,
-0.0015843093,
0.3209695816,
0.0939706266,
0.0863986313,
-0.5930841565,
-0.1729470342,
0.7000849247,
-0.2528790534,
0.7879431844,
-0.5163776875,
0.2073294669,
-0.0710250065,
0.502227366,
-0.2113810927,
-0.4618019164,
0.6083011031,
-0.3942174911,
-0.4288373291,
-0.148377493,
-0.9753201604,
-0.2333424687,
-0.3571458161,
0.021243548,
-0.4770104885,
-0.1541822851,
0.1779936701,
0.1434568316,
0.5138408542,
-0.04104615,
-1.0538774729,
0.4642944932,
0.7871260643,
0.7878937125,
-0.1487101614,
-0.4264334738,
-0.4229999185,
-0.1236464456,
-0.1963983029,
0.8366381526,
-0.5230944157,
-0.0530898981,
0.0526561104,
0.1224346533,
-0.2426149249,
-0.4637750387,
0.8053593636,
-0.5637784004,
0.0291324761,
-0.1280997992,
-0.1577783674,
-0.3594136536,
0.3047319949,
-0.6356105804,
0.8925969601,
0.1100519076,
-0.8529446721,
0.4528598189,
-0.4616697431,
-0.579947114,
0.2098929137,
-0.1118065789,
-0.5258982182,
0.1789075732,
0.0785541013,
0.6241733432,
0.1382693946,
0.3862846196,
-0.4302628934,
-0.0879348218,
0.2934908569,
-0.0750183016,
0.995338738,
0.2736052871,
-0.2184622884,
0.3347886205,
-0.757753849,
0.2360898554,
0.3042494953,
-0.2948121727,
-0.2271460593,
0.3462457657,
0.2685210407,
-0.0354081243,
-0.1650406569,
-0.2245194614,
0.2889392674,
-0.3049051762,
0.6000952125,
0.7388365269,
-0.569224,
0.2546091378,
-0.1368405372,
0.3730643988,
-0.1670456231,
0.0290635265,
0.1524085701,
-0.3851748407,
-1.3297359943,
-0.3395626843,
0.6867215633,
0.6006707549,
-0.3481474817,
0.7021282315,
-0.4865061343,
-0.5400473475,
-0.6603275537,
-0.1261726916,
-0.0844684988,
0.2378731072,
0.2749337256,
-0.1449404955,
-0.4435946047,
-0.8543769121,
-0.2798647583,
0.2218950391,
0.0235678703,
0.5577390194,
0.1436461806,
-0.3092677295,
0.9123071432,
-0.5765737891,
-0.4522649348,
-0.5195476413,
-0.0147774946,
0.3954379857,
0.306897074,
0.8012363911,
-0.461971581,
-0.5391375422,
0.4552889168,
-0.7556760907,
0.1624509692,
0.22272861,
0.2733439803,
0.1637035757,
0.2532483935,
-0.4101161361,
0.2406226844,
0.5080099702,
-0.457421273,
0.2196536362,
-0.1001606509,
-0.0766223297,
-0.8566055298,
0.2021894455,
-0.0162429828,
-0.5551330447,
-0.9060471654,
0.3214583099,
-0.0223486237,
-0.3599024713,
-0.1220697463,
0.3854060769,
-0.2959213555,
-0.1811997294,
0.0414254889,
0.1383247375,
-0.4063747227,
0.5905952454,
0.0833300874,
0.3232236803,
0.7288968563,
-0.7694975734,
0.0443752035,
0.2381450832,
-0.309882611,
0.4382750094,
-0.9557601213,
0.2606385648,
-0.1926108003,
-0.0476193316,
-1.3099515438,
-0.1719695926,
0.3179093003,
-0.632725358,
0.5853628516,
-0.093562454,
-0.597968936,
-0.1585933417,
0.022298025,
0.3408172429,
0.3584801555,
-0.5901631713,
0.7337169051,
0.3470694721,
-0.1982109994,
-0.4679348171,
-0.6327770352,
-0.1147549897,
-0.4443206787,
-0.6056150794,
-0.1832407713,
0.0828827098,
-0.1045864522,
-0.038113337,
0.1689411998,
-0.332950294,
0.3050265014,
-0.0776616633,
-0.1700917631,
0.0289594475,
-0.0467913225,
-0.1988137215,
-0.1933888942,
-0.0972845778,
-0.3131082058,
0.7956863046,
-0.2004713267,
0.3209230602,
-0.5359306931,
0.0197518207,
0.6415780783,
-0.2676323354,
0.387216568,
0.7075369954,
-0.4379478693,
-0.4147881269,
-0.1599445045,
-0.1945368499,
-0.4550178647,
-0.0581485443,
-0.5687095523,
-0.8086128831,
0.7033303976,
0.3851319551,
-0.0468436144,
0.2498923838,
0.322191596,
-0.3532315493,
0.331379056,
0.8696045876,
-0.2643416524,
0.3419825435,
-0.3225902021,
0.3447209299,
-0.5990821123,
-0.0000772063,
-1.1915121078,
-0.7177050114,
-0.9027665854,
-0.1892601997,
0.3757115304,
-0.2983014882,
0.3380900919,
0.6318744421,
-0.5249572396,
0.5021261573,
0.4193664193,
0.0779414475,
0.3068552315,
-0.0196519624,
-0.0303961411,
-0.2235549986,
-0.8078349829,
-0.191858992,
0.8093377948,
0.7888595462,
0.6435934305,
0.1943687648,
0.2840437591,
0.2497681081,
-0.0840688348,
-1.0642350912,
0.4443392456,
-0.2736617625,
-0.5066384673,
-0.3880753815,
-0.3473399282,
-1.0274165869,
0.1755925715,
-0.0790631399,
-1.0889618397,
0.4103838503,
0.2231926173,
0.0802457035,
0.1930228323,
-0.6545597315,
1.014811039,
-0.0007848336,
-0.1744163632,
-0.1725050211,
-0.5538970232,
0.226746425,
0.0901119187,
0.1512934268,
0.2715463638,
0.5094880462,
0.4800508022,
0.1994158775,
0.8487932682,
0.1734215021,
-0.307921201,
-0.1443001032,
0.5405443311,
0.415974915,
-0.0014298818,
0.2574860454,
0.6233658195,
0.0572936684,
-0.4087019563,
-0.5970575809,
0.668191731,
-0.5866045952,
-0.3151293695,
-0.5437248349,
-0.7158863544,
-0.2782583535,
0.3246096969,
0.1501312554,
0.2895284593,
-0.0829956606,
0.3427542448,
0.7999512553,
-0.0468764342,
0.4408825934,
0.4513899386,
-0.3189239502,
-0.1468799263,
0.9737183452,
0.2586882114,
0.0030125952,
0.4407415092,
0.2764147222,
-0.0150215207,
-0.6392216682,
-0.152730912,
0.4198666811,
-0.3750938773,
0.0679460019,
-0.8701490164,
-0.2727891803,
-0.4937351644,
-0.0957551301,
-0.2631212771,
-0.4482576549,
-0.2601712644,
-0.0533191897,
0.0972102284,
0.8685776591,
0.0959003195,
0.2128127068,
-0.4918405414,
0.3432100415,
0.3707674146,
0.8287166357,
0.079620786,
-0.622402966,
-0.0298527293,
-0.3084434867,
-0.2970557511,
-0.773465097,
0.2240905166,
0.2008498311,
0.309370935,
0.3494591117,
-0.2087338269,
0.4294742048,
-0.6147440076,
0.4656709433,
-0.3899339437,
-1.1204304695,
0.6022758484,
-0.5040729642,
0.2178922445,
0.3245127797,
0.5605714917,
-0.7832556963,
-0.6223175526,
-0.5589315891,
-0.4918783307,
0.9934059978,
0.3436713815,
0.0567180403,
0.0880619511,
0.2059749216,
0.1999261975,
-0.0855429396,
-1.0908848047,
-0.409964174,
0.0047734696,
-0.129898563,
-0.2611545324,
-0.3288086951,
0.0413523726,
-0.3837043345,
0.4393938482,
-0.1603901237,
0.2862808406,
0.0710838363,
-0.0118548907,
-0.0742562115,
0.5502340794,
0.6711505651,
0.7277567387,
-0.4885998368,
0.1096683815,
0.0037161314,
-0.3476616442,
-0.2657718658,
0.1023929194,
-0.2830067873,
0.0655915588,
0.3460516632,
0.487067163,
-0.0544213206,
-0.382941246,
0.059403196,
-0.2459436357,
0.0526770614,
-0.1982427984,
0.0099995136,
-0.0661010966,
0.1303230077,
0.0504921935,
-0.2005103976,
0.320553124,
-0.6111381054,
0.4249890149,
0.5664322972,
-0.7355710268,
-0.5338551402,
0.3491132855,
0.1065703481,
-0.4558808804,
0.478040874,
-0.1032435372,
-0.4522186518,
0.3741023839,
0.5299594402,
1.0899020433,
-0.4155844152,
0.2240066528,
0.2503525019,
0.6595634222,
0.650480032,
0.2228529751,
-0.0977144018,
-0.8737917542,
0.0032035613,
-0.5591176152,
-0.1211014763,
0.3809882998,
-0.7074611783,
0.560958147,
-0.3452807069,
0.3405102491,
0.3977749944,
-0.3837887645,
-0.6931766272,
0.1793435067,
-0.2366029918,
0.729074657,
-0.9207277894,
0.9342726469,
0.6851075888,
0.0312186554,
-0.6311778426,
0.1307087541,
-0.1208796352,
-0.8074387312,
0.431625247,
-0.0037781538,
0.1917187721,
0.0942258909,
-0.158424288,
-0.6053055525,
0.7028690577,
0.2620601952,
-0.3854647875,
-0.0845851302,
0.2787809074,
0.7033628821,
-0.0226930566,
0.0964198411,
0.9531140924,
0.4521292448,
-0.176611349,
-1.0805228949,
-0.2404115051,
-0.0047517819,
-0.3195411861,
0.434083581,
-0.6098211408,
0.5732777119,
-0.2150749117,
-0.4650874436,
-0.2533139288,
0.5781216621,
-0.2487190366,
0.1753800064,
0.5380764604,
0.8164412975,
0.6268096566,
-0.4057981968,
1.0084729195,
-0.0006477573,
0.7764812112,
1.1521118879,
0.0741983503,
0.8424810171,
0.4946350157,
-0.3358914852,
0.3712891638,
0.642046392,
0.1963261962,
0.4020444155,
0.2901539505,
0.4359646738,
0.1462962329,
-0.2397799641,
-0.2456343621,
0.8568508029,
0.3930537403,
-0.3265837431,
-0.2189513445,
-0.0456498042,
0.1076987162,
0.0472066812,
-0.005391892,
0.866484344,
0.0059727374,
-0.3662228286,
0.9047992826,
-0.3433529735,
0.276569128,
-0.3458983302,
0.1644197553,
-0.3442658186,
0.298733145,
-0.4025651217,
-0.9447314739,
0.5936260223,
-0.1220310107,
-0.2551740706,
-0.0764182135,
0.4385698736,
-0.4756494164,
-0.4376271963,
0.4159529209,
0.3849487305,
0.1595327556,
0.3132751584,
-0.4656675458,
0.1540164948,
0.0157442316,
0.0142525472,
-0.0438048132,
0.4937098622,
0.4242791533,
0.7969383597,
0.164066419,
0.2584277093,
-0.077426523,
-0.0925586075,
0.7233303189,
-0.7434399128,
-0.5394896269,
-0.6573192477,
0.580637753,
0.3675167561,
-0.2750310302,
0.3930358887,
0.2623012066,
0.9296106696,
-0.2324549407,
0.577839613,
-0.291834414,
0.5702444315,
-0.4582565725,
0.7607004642,
-0.5859254003,
0.0917894095,
-0.3599842489,
-1.024399519,
-0.3905678093,
0.5758215189,
-0.0831543505,
-0.0120499339,
0.9683424234,
0.3768667877,
-0.5580784082,
-0.0331628434,
0.2637404203,
0.3808775544,
0.4175863564,
0.4583838284,
0.4695221186,
-0.5810490251,
0.3677197695,
-0.2217353582,
-0.2828001678,
-0.2314252406,
-0.7106751204,
-1.0742050409,
-0.8109544516,
-0.1212854981,
-0.3889882565,
-0.1708221734,
0.4792560935,
0.6842247844,
-0.9896938205,
-0.3837040961,
-0.0542823486,
0.4965701699,
-0.387114197,
-0.3550959527,
0.3458271027,
-0.6951856017,
-0.9848719239,
0.1158895642,
0.1185498983,
-0.0085478527,
-0.2625592053,
0.3178082705,
-0.2122488916,
-0.0698692873,
0.60905689,
0.3520512283,
-0.7650964856,
-0.7189860344,
0.2346002609,
0.1325166523,
0.1714000255,
0.9894248247,
-0.5602476001,
0.5676994324,
0.5911861658,
0.848993659,
0.0831132159,
-0.2398216426,
0.5720744133,
-0.8480644226,
0.1302884072,
0.1185406148,
0.4443189502,
0.1128128916,
-0.4463165998,
0.7361937761,
0.0648162216,
-0.7790815234,
-0.8386885524,
0.3441361785,
-1.4986103773,
-0.1368869096,
1.0892941952,
0.0039591226,
-0.1736191213,
-0.1736463457,
0.0471375659,
0.0533219315,
-0.1496576518,
1.1053712368,
0.8758189678,
-0.1009074822,
-0.3177801073,
-0.4134827256,
0.6225011349,
0.4948362708,
-0.9765493274,
0.4030359387,
0.2321114838,
0.3178929985,
0.4679457247,
0.2258047909,
0.0538665615,
0.2529002726,
-0.5165582299,
-0.1097550392,
0.207866475,
-0.8108404279,
-0.6611496806,
0.1500744522,
0.2681664526,
-0.2371070534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01666v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01666v2 | A Survey on Contextualised Semantic Shift Detection | 2023-04-04T09:50:19 | 2024-06-11T15:33:13 | Stefano Montanelli, Francesco Periti | cs.CL | cs.CL | Semantic Shift Detection (SSD) is the task of identifying, interpreting, and
assessing the possible change over time in the meanings of a target word.
Traditionally, SSD has been addressed by linguists and social scientists
through manual and time-consuming activities. In the recent years,
computational approaches based on Natural Language Processing and word
embeddings gained increasing attention to automate SSD as much as possible. In
particular, over the past three years, significant advancements have been made
almost exclusively based on word contextualised embedding models, which can
handle the multiple usages/meanings of the words and better capture the related
semantic shifts. In this paper, we survey the approaches based on
contextualised embeddings for SSD (i.e., CSSDetection) and we propose a
classification framework characterised by meaning representation,
time-awareness, and learning modality dimensions. The framework is exploited i)
to review the measures for shift assessment, ii) to compare the approaches on
performance, and iii) to discuss the current issues in terms of scalability,
interpretability, and robustness. Open challenges and future research
directions about CSSDetection are finally outlined. | [
-0.246740669,
-0.7779895067,
0.315699935,
0.2336098254,
-0.2843848169,
0.0216404907,
-0.1021814644,
-0.5672717094,
0.0763030201,
0.24525024,
-0.8685342669,
-0.5400328636,
-0.696959734,
0.155998081,
-0.5768948793,
0.4430111349,
-0.3254476786,
0.1750156134,
-0.1825324446,
-0.3191002905,
-0.6254672408,
-0.2093423903,
-0.4625100493,
0.0519896969,
0.0013282798,
-0.1359231174,
0.6456595063,
0.818706274,
0.4069875181,
0.2298366278,
-0.5095705986,
0.0360171236,
-0.0230533183,
0.1828858107,
-0.5657950044,
-0.1911996603,
-0.078355819,
-0.1991823465,
0.8453856707,
0.9056075811,
-0.1372834444,
0.2246389836,
-0.0306052826,
0.4746677279,
-0.9863911867,
0.0640742928,
-0.6653363109,
0.2723246813,
-0.3022947311,
-0.0000737175,
-0.1152691469,
-0.2474519312,
0.1471755803,
-0.5418100357,
0.3013229668,
-0.2931976616,
0.6488212347,
0.585821569,
-0.656981349,
-0.4574450254,
-0.389986366,
0.8531039357,
-0.4830769897,
0.8282060623,
0.177378878,
0.2507883906,
0.0703536049,
-0.5924136043,
-0.560913682,
0.227589339,
0.115650855,
0.0644776151,
0.0696164444,
-0.297541678,
0.2594608963,
0.1207942218,
-0.2547863126,
0.2278379649,
-0.2538868785,
-0.4093056023,
0.5395900607,
0.4586305022,
0.416028291,
-0.3292190135,
-0.5993288159,
-0.1298346221,
-0.6522408724,
0.1133997142,
-0.1197759137,
0.237163201,
-0.2092342526,
0.3046047688,
-0.3626624942,
0.5697770119,
0.2135194838,
0.0586914234,
0.3849794865,
-0.6019242406,
-0.1608381271,
0.1388582885,
0.1218129918,
0.3958512247,
-0.1458264142,
-0.2323200703,
0.0389699154,
0.5670675039,
0.2894838452,
-0.5134495497,
0.2156668901,
-0.0587549731,
-0.5487177968,
-0.3039215207,
-0.0884894952,
-0.4223566055,
-0.4062302113,
-0.5904636383,
-0.1798965931,
-0.690672338,
-0.5928940773,
0.2197536379,
-0.2651795447,
0.8925821185,
0.5312896967,
-0.7100576162,
0.0893052742,
0.6035206914,
0.7853860259,
-0.9264323711,
-0.1184019893,
0.0402598418,
0.4785582721,
-0.4989096522,
0.7253345847,
-0.6080909371,
-0.622525394,
-0.0333808474,
0.4374624193,
-0.3750612438,
-0.1722935587,
0.5735679865,
-0.6148958802,
0.0216659885,
-0.4338231683,
-0.6993198395,
-0.003184973,
0.3866125941,
-0.5476101041,
1.2421790361,
0.089283742,
-0.8441503644,
0.9408896565,
-0.7617672682,
-0.7663027644,
0.2963413298,
-0.0859835893,
-0.0762466341,
0.1410932839,
0.1323060542,
0.4965507984,
0.1587371677,
0.2403760701,
-0.2481667697,
-0.1818548441,
0.2763343155,
-0.4867110848,
0.8897614479,
0.6307324767,
-0.4624698162,
-0.0623338744,
-0.8999882936,
0.2321631312,
-0.2642039657,
-0.1753547341,
-0.6706815362,
0.4585338831,
0.5060057044,
0.5933473706,
0.0517497659,
-0.6825695634,
-0.0543154217,
-0.3248439133,
0.7075535059,
0.8883727789,
-0.0130707417,
0.6166136265,
0.3602536917,
0.4479033053,
0.4151865542,
0.1426612735,
0.284952879,
-0.0341465883,
-0.365233928,
-0.3185035884,
0.2962427735,
0.5666832328,
-0.753180325,
0.666626215,
-0.4004341066,
-0.0834819227,
-0.3905415833,
-0.0771002397,
0.0342065804,
0.3492257595,
0.4801327586,
-0.0769992247,
-0.1603307724,
-0.6938049793,
-0.4324227571,
0.1817682087,
0.1245586947,
-0.0881606489,
0.4042380452,
-0.591964066,
1.1634608507,
-0.7090709805,
-0.2229392081,
0.0482512675,
-0.0375015661,
-0.6628429294,
0.4219612181,
0.3517189622,
-1.0231173038,
-0.0971948355,
-0.035547778,
-0.7690781951,
0.0080122398,
-0.1222144365,
0.0575307049,
0.453584522,
1.2640327215,
-0.1970723569,
0.7050772905,
0.1541817188,
-0.3631496429,
0.1834449172,
0.204568699,
-0.1009331495,
-1.1686849594,
-0.0355907194,
-0.2539190948,
-0.2280153483,
-0.4522181451,
0.0860995278,
0.4995093942,
0.0129406834,
-0.721811533,
0.4223579764,
-0.6560354829,
-0.2050413638,
0.0207195133,
0.3994323611,
-0.442777127,
-0.0494895317,
0.4464479089,
0.3587816656,
0.3167392015,
-0.7795925736,
-0.1665442735,
0.1455208808,
-0.4048186541,
0.8983373642,
-0.3135245442,
-0.1194560528,
-0.1104191989,
0.1892531961,
-1.2614022493,
0.0141833043,
0.0536521412,
-0.2567349076,
0.1612686962,
0.054056976,
-0.1747111678,
-0.190818876,
-0.2080359012,
0.4159273803,
-0.0932907462,
-0.4960983992,
0.3888047338,
0.5798683763,
0.0941863209,
-0.3331530988,
-0.9029851556,
0.0790220425,
-0.2022687942,
-0.5704411864,
0.5760793686,
0.0513770096,
-0.1789645404,
0.194737345,
-0.3087951243,
-0.0200455897,
0.4776525795,
0.2211147249,
0.1224899739,
0.0979487598,
0.3073742688,
0.4107981622,
-0.1258630902,
0.0679389387,
0.1289892048,
0.2555178404,
-0.06421794,
-0.3389770091,
-0.3243002295,
0.2938324213,
0.4630872309,
-0.0397234932,
0.4531853795,
1.1064407825,
-0.5497938395,
-0.2138637155,
-0.2932871282,
0.0382609218,
-0.4376711547,
0.3061962426,
-0.4268034697,
-1.0747075081,
0.4044552147,
-0.4862967432,
-0.0739073008,
0.4438152313,
0.4927395284,
-0.1239101961,
1.2673066854,
0.5553768873,
0.1062422469,
0.6754382253,
-0.140012145,
0.1076274812,
-0.9532546401,
-0.0654602647,
-0.4239237309,
-0.2247819901,
-0.8486590981,
-0.3583396971,
0.3406892717,
-0.1184390336,
0.2311260253,
0.2116790265,
-0.628937006,
0.2615250051,
-0.4442855716,
-0.045386266,
-0.072803922,
-0.1350979954,
-0.1081461012,
-0.1955834776,
-0.2814214528,
-0.190390572,
0.6752403975,
-0.0217607208,
0.5141810775,
0.0988782644,
0.4941169918,
0.6285384893,
-0.0470653251,
-0.7895934582,
0.6927817464,
0.1330499202,
-0.3865483701,
-0.6085967422,
-0.0623556376,
-0.9900853038,
0.5490823984,
-0.1131384522,
-0.4200151563,
0.4473672509,
-0.2102092654,
0.1180044487,
0.097390458,
-0.5691481233,
0.7335601449,
0.0099001843,
-0.1998070031,
-0.5022786856,
-0.9649916887,
0.1367774904,
0.1954620183,
0.41403687,
-0.3074423969,
-0.2911817133,
0.6237829924,
-0.4300940037,
0.8556821346,
-0.4236326516,
-0.2621024549,
0.0356016867,
0.1812810153,
0.3924304247,
-0.1869284213,
0.0954438448,
0.2303721756,
0.6012133956,
-0.3563907743,
-0.4121472538,
0.786719501,
-0.4326927066,
-0.0741396844,
-0.5737110376,
-0.2111153901,
-0.3080459535,
0.1108508185,
0.1121014655,
0.2981790006,
-0.6549307108,
0.0411814302,
0.5744045377,
0.069291696,
0.8477888107,
0.4680024087,
0.1266562939,
-0.0068967915,
0.6635373235,
0.2052937299,
0.3649564087,
0.2545260787,
0.1650829762,
-0.5681502223,
-0.3825872838,
-0.4865721166,
-0.2162452042,
-0.7851650119,
0.149475649,
-0.4613319933,
-0.0476772189,
-0.8555122614,
-0.5557927489,
-0.2882862985,
-0.7445978522,
-0.3104912043,
-0.2616505027,
0.2249204516,
0.4196430147,
-0.0955077782,
-0.0844581947,
-0.242267549,
0.2052297294,
0.0659482107,
0.1933044642,
-0.1799443066,
-0.1343246996,
-0.0760168582,
0.0058106948,
-0.3031156659,
-0.6711056828,
0.3046589792,
0.0754233748,
0.698304534,
0.5259160995,
0.1032469347,
0.7558907866,
-0.223637104,
1.1678346395,
0.2418854386,
-1.2671836615,
0.6641227007,
0.0615756959,
0.5587511659,
0.5384569764,
0.4377177954,
-0.9932724833,
0.01092669,
-0.5025399923,
-0.8370311856,
0.6345492005,
-0.3049866557,
-0.1137839034,
-0.3358015716,
0.1276921779,
0.2057655901,
0.0654453263,
-0.1838704646,
0.0176067743,
-0.2686668634,
-0.1581751555,
0.1834804267,
0.2005946934,
0.2685707808,
-0.3870721757,
0.3073934913,
-0.3164073825,
0.1984517425,
0.2408123314,
-0.9214424491,
0.2512474954,
0.523408711,
0.6067070365,
0.8880265355,
0.1131686196,
0.045808658,
0.4996362627,
-0.7129591107,
-0.0168384537,
-0.4381324351,
-0.4050303698,
0.0265256632,
0.2515607476,
0.5582600236,
0.5868383646,
-0.4522620738,
0.6612637639,
0.0800392851,
-0.1406666189,
-0.3597220778,
-0.1346745491,
-0.0181517322,
-0.271040678,
-0.0509758554,
0.089515388,
0.3853629827,
-0.4800143242,
-0.0108139701,
0.4627074301,
-0.7480567694,
-0.3402950168,
0.3415251374,
0.0819002092,
-0.0084330691,
0.5145204663,
-0.1605204493,
-0.5789273977,
0.4378042817,
0.5507392883,
1.0810775757,
-0.4760099351,
0.3512797058,
-0.0223191045,
0.1055220738,
0.0632978156,
0.4145946801,
-0.6611278057,
-1.0447529554,
-0.0220024623,
-0.4109810591,
-0.2447137088,
-0.2261595577,
-1.1590870619,
0.3049353659,
-0.4721336663,
-0.183903873,
0.2798818946,
-0.4055226445,
-0.8213194609,
0.1308720559,
0.0883465186,
0.8629520535,
-1.0084517002,
0.7427554131,
0.8422544003,
-0.0214632805,
-0.2464009821,
0.0308423359,
0.2591067851,
-0.7028706074,
0.7644992471,
-0.012905159,
-0.5663753748,
-0.1898970753,
-0.5923855901,
-0.7124214172,
1.1972774267,
-0.1525933146,
-0.239798829,
0.1373078674,
0.0711884126,
0.6215950847,
-0.1773480624,
-0.1859372258,
0.885099709,
0.4212885201,
0.0989937335,
-0.6525459886,
0.1840360165,
0.0159666408,
0.5496066809,
0.3331591487,
-0.4422648251,
0.6570580602,
0.1298036575,
-0.740650177,
-0.2111037523,
0.4995740056,
-0.3071270287,
0.342702508,
0.7301388383,
0.4584384263,
0.7878710032,
-0.1912114918,
0.8603160977,
-0.3583691716,
0.1868003607,
0.7466558814,
-0.6534408331,
1.053198576,
0.6227576137,
-0.3015651405,
0.5244649649,
0.7139680982,
0.3201529086,
0.9263792038,
0.2366177291,
-0.1244912297,
-0.4077691436,
0.1002202705,
-0.4637328684,
0.5701739192,
0.9564029574,
-0.2600978911,
-0.4043025672,
0.3889489174,
-0.0534753092,
0.0408684835,
-0.4466982186,
0.9209144711,
-0.2246877551,
-0.4821426272,
0.4978772104,
0.1990381628,
0.7966688275,
-0.418969512,
0.1125470027,
0.0334119909,
0.4005133212,
-0.2296251208,
-0.6506701112,
0.5851873755,
-0.5637432337,
-0.22851336,
-0.4787366688,
0.9481729865,
-0.3231750727,
-0.4469577968,
0.3029030859,
0.3102515638,
0.0614718795,
0.3853074908,
-0.8519260883,
0.2678312659,
-0.262519151,
0.2591430843,
0.4196743071,
0.4910509586,
-0.8096458316,
0.5178182721,
0.4462009966,
0.0908484459,
0.4063975811,
0.0206795763,
0.544403851,
-0.7579110265,
-1.0104728937,
-0.5383273363,
-0.1226555109,
-0.2205742747,
-0.5797683597,
0.7661648393,
0.3898057342,
0.9347810149,
-0.1415223181,
0.8164041042,
-0.1794589162,
0.4991475046,
-0.7078242302,
0.3151130378,
-0.3766891062,
0.0744104609,
-0.6030383706,
-0.398150295,
-0.1264848709,
0.6318364739,
-0.4125541747,
-0.3185282946,
0.7728888988,
0.8044193387,
-0.1016753614,
0.5900226831,
0.0711897835,
-0.0720734447,
0.2322226167,
0.2557833195,
0.941129446,
-0.3566316068,
0.0407614112,
0.1721641868,
-0.0681197345,
-0.2497694045,
-1.0292090178,
-0.541079998,
-0.966391325,
-0.6431345344,
-0.0887888595,
0.1256281435,
0.8540008664,
0.6164351702,
-0.8012245893,
-0.0066096443,
-0.1137543917,
0.2312945873,
-0.8801481724,
-0.3059076667,
0.7766048312,
-0.438413471,
-0.3410122097,
0.5304576755,
0.1723481119,
-0.1037303805,
-0.2803674638,
0.1777209193,
-0.3699018061,
-0.0798319057,
1.0101416111,
0.1492162198,
-0.7662494779,
-0.6126580834,
-0.0834972933,
-0.115747124,
-0.3273122311,
1.0171973705,
-0.5907101035,
0.3263216913,
0.6860522032,
0.7844649553,
0.800485611,
-0.1311482936,
0.178403452,
-0.7057286501,
0.0712018684,
-0.1439397782,
0.0893169343,
0.3181958497,
-0.4124287367,
0.6151816845,
0.5750236511,
-0.0771693066,
-0.7219033241,
0.1540912688,
-0.9930861592,
-0.5921661258,
1.2523058653,
0.14864178,
-0.3109903336,
-0.5719528794,
0.0400591828,
0.0516477823,
0.0513131395,
0.628082037,
0.8272617459,
-0.239930585,
0.2569802999,
-0.1985834837,
0.6476492286,
0.2559264898,
-0.7115263939,
0.2442680299,
0.7576444745,
0.7883651853,
0.1616793573,
0.415025562,
-0.5706225038,
0.2802285552,
-0.3301922679,
-0.0371843688,
0.1208600923,
0.0828645751,
-0.5901151896,
0.2243971378,
-0.6688299775,
-0.4495764375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01665v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01665v3 | Mastering Symbolic Operations: Augmenting Language Models with Compiled Neural Networks | 2023-04-04T09:50:07 | 2024-03-09T15:27:33 | Yixuan Weng, Minjun Zhu, Fei Xia, Bin Li, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models' (LMs) proficiency in handling deterministic symbolic
reasoning and rule-based tasks remains limited due to their dependency implicit
learning on textual data. To endow LMs with genuine rule comprehension
abilities, we propose "Neural Comprehension" - a framework that synergistically
integrates compiled neural networks (CoNNs) into the standard transformer
architecture. CoNNs are neural modules designed to explicitly encode rules
through artificially generated attention weights. By incorporating CoNN
modules, the Neural Comprehension framework enables LMs to accurately and
robustly execute rule-intensive symbolic tasks. Extensive experiments
demonstrate the superiority of our approach over existing techniques in terms
of length generalization, efficiency, and interpretability for symbolic
operations. Furthermore, it can be applied to LMs across different model
scales, outperforming tool-calling methods in arithmetic reasoning tasks while
maintaining superior inference efficiency. Our work highlights the potential of
seamlessly unifying explicit rule learning via CoNNs and implicit pattern
learning in LMs, paving the way for true symbolic comprehension capabilities. | [
-0.025040945,
-0.6486353278,
0.6375948787,
0.4041046202,
-0.2972402573,
0.0001644061,
-0.2758305371,
-0.2970964015,
-0.1237889901,
0.6404667497,
-0.8303516507,
-0.3958214819,
-0.661259234,
0.1215443537,
-0.6203576326,
0.6491085887,
0.2081825733,
0.3319246471,
-0.2276501954,
-0.0493800007,
-0.4262492359,
-0.4342437685,
-0.7357166409,
-0.5837652087,
0.3550308049,
0.0767694488,
0.8646086454,
0.9495888948,
0.3802085519,
0.4857027531,
-0.010548613,
0.5352308154,
-0.2060322315,
0.2766878009,
0.0674745962,
-0.7980469465,
-0.2979614139,
-0.1783497334,
0.3309027255,
0.8744863272,
0.0134644909,
-0.0070147282,
-0.0713910833,
0.6412368417,
-0.4815661609,
0.6035447121,
-0.4343087077,
0.2343856543,
0.3852350712,
-0.0216138419,
-0.6998247504,
-0.3231461346,
0.0245093442,
-0.7771744132,
-0.0331971534,
-0.1193538383,
0.363978833,
0.8025138974,
-0.4862271249,
-0.0726189762,
-0.5670747757,
0.6134386063,
-0.708656311,
0.6009541154,
0.2572422624,
0.3502205014,
0.0228332188,
-1.0212985277,
-0.4256681502,
-0.2768773735,
-0.6115618944,
-0.0070080673,
-0.3713382185,
0.3834776878,
0.5799145103,
0.0411859415,
-0.4924929738,
-0.2188324928,
-0.4421862662,
0.0734212771,
0.5478379726,
0.1974066943,
0.4666686058,
0.1003915742,
-0.1122819334,
-0.1981189549,
-0.6977440715,
-0.1210012585,
0.1660258025,
0.142091915,
-0.1195302159,
0.5266750455,
-0.1569277197,
0.8458616138,
-0.1467519701,
0.4515716434,
-0.0882316008,
-0.1972071826,
-0.6149549484,
0.0190293211,
0.6778949499,
0.1771759689,
0.8073127866,
-0.4357380569,
-0.4761817753,
0.2943201065,
0.4453346133,
-0.8625845313,
-0.3279611766,
0.0014513768,
-0.3818674088,
-0.2051433325,
-0.0535160378,
-0.1545421779,
-0.1704404354,
-1.0147701502,
0.4721216559,
-0.4935972393,
-0.1943626702,
0.3563986123,
-0.3046805561,
-0.0757644176,
0.1894115061,
-0.9355338216,
0.5890630484,
1.1244069338,
0.786732018,
0.2987613678,
-0.1249833032,
-0.4222323895,
-0.1073815301,
-0.58719486,
0.1347408742,
-0.3916396797,
0.0051566875,
-0.0264628567,
-0.0428971425,
-0.4068505466,
-0.5048516393,
0.3204411566,
-0.8025087714,
-0.2103540748,
0.0761548653,
-0.3495205343,
-0.4642902017,
0.1993312389,
-0.817807734,
0.8814386725,
0.1551435143,
-0.2325283736,
-0.1436697245,
-0.6769272685,
-0.7357116342,
-0.0751481429,
0.0032442447,
0.0483222865,
0.297570765,
0.1454676092,
0.581228137,
-0.2387575656,
0.4357710481,
0.0373741724,
-0.4553257823,
0.2518169284,
-0.3572413325,
1.0034528971,
0.2349877357,
-0.3804246485,
0.4937202036,
-0.5002550483,
-0.0120698893,
-0.0074454886,
0.2294844836,
-0.4329380393,
0.1843426675,
-0.3660826087,
0.4054546952,
0.0742517784,
-0.2680561244,
-0.1129649132,
-0.7193340659,
0.516567111,
0.7102541327,
-0.2597888112,
0.722905457,
-0.2807575464,
0.4003608227,
0.0373052135,
0.1847506762,
-0.1941485405,
-0.1121119633,
-1.129285574,
0.1646229923,
0.0036701325,
0.5448608994,
-0.8516747355,
0.4724224508,
-0.3950907886,
-0.4918406308,
-0.3220493793,
0.1335761398,
0.3929023743,
0.4586500525,
0.4270315468,
0.0903399512,
-0.6816971898,
-0.9035571218,
-0.3204585612,
-0.2837255895,
0.0014839513,
-0.0088818735,
0.3525382578,
0.0747487992,
0.5472912192,
-0.2676681876,
-0.0014327382,
-0.3942217231,
0.0144642917,
0.3854719996,
0.4838908315,
0.2288026661,
-0.861482501,
-0.2054696232,
0.0422059298,
-0.8941320777,
-0.1126726493,
-0.2462329566,
-0.2142036706,
0.1600566655,
0.9002669454,
-0.8364052773,
0.0408381633,
0.4883685112,
-0.503919661,
0.4795737863,
-0.2234489173,
-0.2366131097,
-0.7662847638,
-0.1876592338,
0.0639803857,
-0.2612967193,
-0.8647547364,
0.4005433917,
0.190784961,
0.0833886415,
-0.5685044527,
0.3916074336,
-0.4426789284,
0.0649251714,
-0.0967402458,
-0.1729422659,
-0.0790168419,
0.5902599692,
0.0106644528,
0.5565707684,
0.5638487935,
-0.6217387915,
0.3104628921,
0.0187773909,
-0.2034217864,
0.204501763,
-0.9567143321,
-0.0339078195,
-0.1954447031,
-0.0526284315,
-0.649199605,
0.1287929118,
0.245795697,
-0.1710163504,
0.2078967392,
-0.2143880576,
-0.5746710896,
-0.011225624,
0.0479348227,
0.1786679178,
0.7562616467,
-0.4414920211,
1.099396944,
0.0332682393,
0.2154751718,
-0.719293654,
-0.7768486738,
-0.0449247994,
0.112074025,
-0.6422948837,
0.026682388,
0.0655089095,
-0.5494529009,
0.0942987427,
-0.307174176,
0.0653676763,
0.3591642976,
0.3917117715,
0.1636228263,
-0.4618752301,
0.0918807611,
0.2365501374,
-0.1354522705,
0.6608800888,
-0.3812312186,
0.6361564994,
-0.0008254371,
-0.4010271132,
-0.2150770128,
0.1808519214,
0.7987081409,
-0.469204098,
0.5326786637,
0.3322457373,
-0.4793896675,
-0.7257035375,
-0.219491601,
-0.7611153722,
-0.4936462939,
0.4227315485,
-0.4698167443,
-0.7307804823,
0.3270895183,
-0.0858558789,
0.1836733967,
0.3929288983,
0.2396577448,
-0.0891589373,
1.2189881802,
0.3874664009,
0.1106292456,
0.3429263234,
-0.4056246579,
0.1122835875,
-0.4863362908,
-0.3808884919,
-0.3706034124,
-0.739158988,
-0.4192183316,
-0.4366147816,
0.1674508303,
-0.00703798,
-0.6693755388,
0.4169772267,
-0.5017351508,
0.5609778762,
0.6898774505,
0.4317738116,
0.2843548656,
-0.1055765599,
0.05018593,
0.2097316831,
-0.5488542914,
-0.2547590137,
0.8417029977,
0.1960511208,
0.689320147,
0.0088970345,
0.4623239636,
0.1907937229,
0.2284642011,
-0.8375974298,
0.818005383,
-0.5470914245,
-0.1680418998,
-0.1275950968,
-0.5013760328,
-0.6506132483,
0.3685348332,
0.0114337057,
-0.4238679111,
0.0161007438,
0.1438405067,
-0.2975448668,
0.182192713,
-0.7244573236,
1.0591737032,
-0.3570482433,
0.0397572927,
-0.4493783414,
-0.7266654968,
0.4965522289,
0.1139005274,
-0.1238473579,
-0.0872607604,
-0.2910987437,
0.5299832225,
-0.5598762631,
0.9655738473,
-0.0192164499,
0.1190954894,
-0.0182344075,
0.5723820925,
0.4731912911,
-0.1409555227,
-0.247070998,
0.0494797714,
0.001298319,
0.0501503609,
-1.216080308,
0.5206322074,
-0.7067543864,
-0.6171632409,
-0.3284061849,
-0.8854231238,
-0.0071312757,
0.117374815,
-0.3413726985,
0.4567833543,
-0.0233929418,
0.155170083,
0.7292618155,
0.3831050992,
0.6626682281,
0.2941263616,
0.0180619005,
-0.0890557766,
0.6025243402,
-0.0510833152,
0.3143361211,
0.5704981685,
0.0184408836,
-0.483070612,
-0.4673825204,
-0.5182942748,
0.0084006498,
-0.8961051106,
-0.1808511913,
-0.8571721315,
-0.487873286,
-0.0118141565,
0.0326689854,
-0.0306130517,
-0.5373862386,
-0.238863498,
-0.1093997806,
0.5000281334,
0.8033969998,
0.1094861627,
0.5598130226,
-0.6208224297,
0.3971173465,
0.1928005368,
0.1134424806,
0.0758457556,
-0.4229640961,
-0.1407170743,
0.202268526,
0.0342029668,
-0.8472294211,
0.4626270831,
0.1411614865,
0.4839646518,
0.2059423029,
-0.0129709896,
0.5228975415,
-0.5084026456,
0.3309619129,
-0.104297258,
-0.9784502387,
0.1485632807,
-0.1297647953,
0.3457855582,
0.312466085,
0.3920211196,
-0.7095302939,
-0.4020712376,
-0.5134168267,
-0.479404211,
0.9106459022,
0.1350117922,
0.5152375102,
0.0235890709,
0.2624094784,
-0.2208489478,
0.1255034208,
-0.3594656587,
-0.4662484527,
-0.1908848286,
-0.5900422931,
-0.1099692807,
0.0293087512,
-0.013517824,
-0.3874613345,
0.6431706548,
-0.3389082551,
0.0099406699,
0.0035736631,
-0.5319482684,
0.1005160138,
-0.0141057866,
0.5260908008,
0.7476946712,
0.0589619689,
0.5542891622,
0.1798110157,
-0.3840636611,
0.069305487,
0.2140084058,
-0.3630802929,
0.0542764068,
0.2976441383,
0.862205565,
0.4515095651,
-0.5424759984,
0.1299784333,
-0.0981320813,
-0.1655964404,
-0.2642560899,
0.336374104,
0.3756628036,
0.282199055,
0.2153782994,
0.4054878354,
0.1289343834,
-0.2749243975,
0.5142177343,
0.370434612,
-0.4127545953,
-0.2502945065,
0.5130088925,
-0.0168739967,
-0.2560470104,
0.751552403,
-0.0589141622,
-0.6275730729,
0.9510073066,
0.7650540471,
0.9066762328,
-0.0397641025,
0.2226177156,
0.3580040336,
0.6573244929,
-0.3269922435,
0.5002633333,
-0.1106792688,
-0.6361293197,
-0.8052853346,
-0.5574606657,
-0.0847443193,
-0.0583815649,
-0.2572018802,
0.0858730748,
-0.7184563279,
0.2682772875,
-0.1168406084,
-0.4439563751,
-0.5392324328,
0.3369471133,
-0.00923499,
1.1460922956,
-0.7751210332,
0.6298395991,
0.5866108537,
-0.3831252754,
-1.0556961298,
-0.5120850205,
-0.0573798008,
-0.7726736665,
0.9379714727,
0.2377416939,
-0.0822432861,
0.2060498446,
-0.3404459655,
-0.4334606528,
0.7021462321,
0.8756772876,
-0.5737018585,
-0.1490967572,
0.3300461173,
0.5574864745,
-0.227869913,
0.706092298,
0.8607398868,
0.5468245149,
-0.0497607589,
-0.5382623076,
0.3465023637,
-0.4488232434,
-0.1961290836,
0.3662060797,
-0.2152962536,
0.7827920914,
-0.0149440756,
-0.1463326067,
0.0071856785,
0.742099762,
-0.0339165889,
0.0552410483,
0.6194227934,
0.668047905,
0.3566872776,
-0.4880940616,
1.1838357449,
-0.5062350631,
-0.1211085171,
1.0207413435,
0.2580257952,
0.6052051783,
0.3349490762,
0.195045948,
0.633918643,
0.5035580397,
0.1520815939,
0.1542666703,
0.3390756249,
-0.3897096217,
-0.6852548718,
-0.2139097899,
0.0148455203,
0.5035771728,
0.3555717468,
-0.5772949457,
-0.3746144474,
-0.4354818761,
-0.0762764141,
0.3196236789,
-0.433483988,
0.9072166681,
0.380333513,
-0.8475452065,
0.5898299813,
-0.0512643382,
0.4393959045,
-0.829552114,
-0.3259173036,
-0.1714735031,
0.3296130598,
-0.2760135531,
-0.7817522883,
0.5829073787,
-0.4094347656,
-0.1414551437,
-0.42165941,
0.7075090408,
-0.6047741771,
-0.5367818475,
0.3837043643,
0.6606206298,
-0.0733806863,
-0.3667967916,
-0.7115947604,
0.0399504304,
-0.2577659488,
-0.0258190334,
-0.0633926019,
0.4578085542,
-0.3037198186,
0.7875638008,
0.7855269313,
0.013392956,
0.1928659678,
0.4012235999,
0.7289854884,
-0.3607129157,
-0.3908989727,
-1.3340085745,
0.6166579127,
-0.0521049164,
0.086150445,
0.5988702774,
0.4998436868,
0.8480018377,
-0.3552791774,
0.3854660392,
0.0892194435,
-0.4477653503,
-0.6133288741,
1.0265815258,
-0.4145491421,
-0.0094001079,
0.211374253,
-0.7750926614,
-0.6166618466,
0.4102895558,
-0.1976451129,
0.0322291739,
0.7091372609,
1.0725859404,
-0.3690786362,
0.2315578759,
0.4331810474,
-0.0416272841,
-0.0494389944,
0.7251238227,
0.7893999219,
-0.4756422043,
0.3615632057,
-0.5416536927,
0.1026532426,
0.2021871656,
-0.7928252816,
-1.0324976444,
-0.5719841123,
-0.0825219676,
-0.1326178461,
0.2415886223,
1.0453777313,
1.0306569338,
-0.732111454,
-0.4186777472,
-0.4491010308,
0.4783182144,
-0.5132328868,
-0.1606944352,
0.4051867127,
-0.6696541905,
-0.8862004876,
0.5327125788,
0.1231237277,
-0.0523258634,
-0.1412026286,
-0.3736565709,
-0.1038361788,
-0.0184041224,
0.7389414907,
0.0475746579,
-0.6212140322,
0.1260841191,
0.3827052116,
-0.0691273212,
-0.25767681,
1.0689667463,
-0.7698134184,
0.3218252659,
0.7332726121,
1.0692876577,
0.158499226,
-0.0787469745,
0.7106651664,
-0.8765069246,
0.1364315748,
0.348326534,
0.5824591517,
0.1898190826,
-0.361189276,
0.5185211301,
0.0728086233,
-0.0592648089,
-0.5841401815,
0.1905556023,
-0.8784469962,
-0.2391963005,
0.9525202513,
0.0573110394,
-0.3138091266,
0.036196541,
-0.0073224297,
0.4624005258,
-0.2257743925,
0.3090651631,
0.1329269558,
0.0613706224,
-0.5539986491,
-0.5205732584,
0.5476350188,
0.7384648323,
-0.7895249128,
0.1643084735,
0.4538161159,
0.0202430338,
0.0805496722,
-0.0155770602,
-0.0055624745,
0.6814831495,
-0.1989139169,
0.0429946706,
-0.7309568524,
-0.5133652091,
-0.3884031177,
-0.0084965834,
-0.2028842717,
-0.0595695041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01662v1 | Cross-Domain Image Captioning with Discriminative Finetuning | 2023-04-04T09:33:16 | 2023-04-04T09:33:16 | Roberto Dessì, Michele Bevilacqua, Eleonora Gualdoni, Nathanael Carraz Rakotonirina, Francesca Franzon, Marco Baroni | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Neural captioners are typically trained to mimic human-generated references
without optimizing for any specific communication goal, leading to problems
such as the generation of vague captions. In this paper, we show that
fine-tuning an out-of-the-box neural captioner with a self-supervised
discriminative communication objective helps to recover a plain, visually
descriptive language that is more informative about image contents. Given a
target image, the system must learn to produce a description that enables an
out-of-the-box text-conditioned image retriever to identify such image among a
set of candidates. We experiment with the popular ClipCap captioner, also
replicating the main results with BLIP. In terms of similarity to ground-truth
human descriptions, the captions emerging from discriminative finetuning lag
slightly behind those generated by the non-finetuned model, when the latter is
trained and tested on the same caption dataset. However, when the model is used
without further tuning to generate captions for out-of-domain datasets, our
discriminatively-finetuned captioner generates descriptions that resemble human
references more than those produced by the same captioner without finetuning.
We further show that, on the Conceptual Captions dataset, discriminatively
finetuned captions are more helpful than either vanilla ClipCap captions or
ground-truth captions for human annotators tasked with an image discrimination
task. | [
-0.5649532676,
-0.3610174954,
0.1019286886,
0.1624628156,
-0.6412123442,
0.0093428455,
-0.4712694883,
-0.5223815441,
-0.0007602882,
0.5804561377,
-0.4592881501,
-0.1691757441,
-0.5618033409,
0.2799026966,
-0.4052363336,
1.132039547,
0.0830832198,
0.0398550481,
-0.4637188315,
-0.0660305694,
-0.696557343,
-0.4000402391,
-0.5868068933,
-0.3095892966,
0.2831466198,
0.4738503098,
0.7852676511,
0.729929924,
0.535333395,
0.1956640929,
0.3566726744,
0.4610036314,
-0.5388205051,
-0.1933778971,
-0.4354258776,
-0.5849821568,
0.2721348107,
-0.0093344226,
0.0938629061,
0.5394371748,
0.1552995741,
0.029437637,
0.1900960356,
0.7404171228,
-0.6565162539,
0.3702528775,
-0.8758792877,
0.2540588379,
-0.0837917104,
-0.6984063387,
-0.276796788,
-0.0600228533,
0.3936915994,
-0.8496990204,
0.9502761364,
0.4061595201,
1.2430920601,
0.4984880984,
-0.0152967712,
-0.2679549456,
-0.7738821507,
0.5755707026,
-0.418730855,
0.3131657839,
0.2879780531,
0.4280935824,
0.119610928,
-0.5156370401,
-0.6076269746,
-0.1011963114,
-0.3127039373,
0.1250673532,
-0.2779824436,
0.0026776379,
0.162516892,
0.398571521,
-0.2784344852,
0.1631241143,
-0.7195312381,
-0.4074598849,
0.705871582,
-0.0538687892,
0.1715572327,
-0.1689946502,
-0.7163082361,
-0.0788468122,
-0.8105723262,
-0.1301990896,
0.0103943581,
0.3585395217,
-0.1445831656,
0.4436488152,
-0.310049057,
0.3809098601,
0.6301739812,
0.2648314834,
0.0826821402,
-0.0801774859,
-0.0867147222,
0.1015017033,
0.7065736651,
0.9611132741,
0.7224760056,
-0.5949417949,
-0.3663814962,
0.0103497887,
0.4490578771,
-0.7917594314,
-0.6011784077,
-0.3656444252,
-0.6572768688,
-0.0236583874,
0.1572116762,
-0.7068126202,
-0.3864462674,
-0.5930017829,
0.5757915974,
-0.3209784329,
0.1260899901,
0.0039253645,
-0.1817236394,
0.2545548081,
0.2242068499,
-0.8810945749,
0.5179765821,
0.2498430759,
0.8301284313,
-0.5575412512,
-0.2213433832,
-0.5076258779,
0.0771273524,
-0.4507844746,
0.9239391685,
-0.0864235535,
0.0078863595,
0.0348878056,
0.2411211282,
0.067555204,
-0.877227962,
0.3138302267,
-0.5771685839,
-0.1124869362,
-0.168032527,
-0.3299188316,
-0.1285255253,
0.0433820635,
-0.8622984886,
0.3380630314,
-0.1347299218,
-0.6234818697,
0.6350946426,
-0.5533158183,
-0.5677649975,
0.2573307157,
-0.3088375032,
-0.7553746104,
0.2338975221,
0.4727485478,
0.7710291743,
-0.3657435477,
0.0825318098,
-0.1339346617,
-0.4686689079,
0.3676681221,
-0.4086976647,
0.3280925155,
0.2105871141,
-0.5689522028,
-0.1043657586,
-0.5939285159,
-0.1390905529,
0.3204303682,
-0.0534158796,
-0.4098168314,
-0.1892114133,
0.1017762423,
0.138894707,
0.0657367036,
-0.6818320155,
-0.3566363156,
-0.2234904021,
0.6520748734,
0.4282862246,
0.1418577582,
0.5726137161,
-0.5095601678,
0.348757565,
0.1749906838,
0.1131599247,
-0.1349898279,
-0.2065265775,
-0.8142619133,
-0.1693205386,
0.3088347614,
0.3723038435,
-0.9026016593,
0.2096719444,
-0.3411649168,
-0.041958198,
-0.5911203623,
0.0985798091,
0.7122277021,
0.4166916311,
0.5508542657,
-0.4591656923,
-0.471191138,
-1.2689460516,
0.1769573838,
0.4065799117,
0.0536594503,
0.4326966703,
0.3969805539,
0.1645144075,
0.8595705628,
-0.4845679998,
-0.8032070994,
0.0871451795,
0.1095534414,
-0.2347807735,
0.5150212049,
0.5425764322,
-1.0368829966,
-0.5541732907,
0.1245819703,
-0.5377126336,
-0.0052621365,
-0.529379487,
-0.0520958677,
0.1202469841,
0.6718311906,
-0.7514810562,
0.358754158,
0.127262935,
0.033446379,
0.5964493752,
-0.2457950264,
0.0591777861,
-0.5345621109,
0.0791628286,
0.0684845746,
-0.2266427428,
-0.2464389503,
0.1108399406,
-0.0476359725,
-0.1139401123,
-0.3852013946,
0.3847504258,
-0.7949134707,
-0.1437701285,
-0.3692781925,
0.2058972418,
0.2305193245,
0.6979727745,
0.398296088,
0.9883724451,
0.7211976051,
-0.5473598242,
0.3081997335,
0.5937895775,
-0.2833151817,
0.8492806554,
-0.7282812595,
0.1025331169,
-0.3741455972,
0.0206679069,
-1.0301465988,
0.0499397814,
0.1904138625,
-0.3600970507,
0.2904804051,
-0.2246357501,
-0.4110736251,
-0.3644892871,
-0.0603575781,
0.3670615554,
0.3037708998,
-0.8345292807,
0.1739170849,
0.0282184724,
-0.0374719538,
-0.3406259418,
-0.9482180476,
0.0540974475,
-0.3511791825,
-0.2113118172,
0.5223276019,
-0.0436492972,
0.2995278239,
-0.1055005416,
-0.1868410408,
-0.3289139271,
-0.1420308053,
0.4272175133,
0.2221353352,
-0.1536094397,
0.2152532339,
0.0257051513,
0.1076692194,
0.1863904595,
-0.3057844043,
0.2292318642,
-0.015483412,
-0.0663360655,
-0.4735716879,
0.3457293808,
0.1445189118,
-0.3582989872,
0.1472745836,
0.6081005335,
-0.2197673917,
-0.3247336149,
-0.3386714458,
-0.3938962817,
-0.42014575,
0.2117698342,
-0.6401389837,
-0.7577885389,
0.4028151631,
0.0115341367,
-0.2908264697,
0.3233512938,
0.2108951807,
-0.2062670141,
0.6576590538,
0.5646868944,
0.2316772044,
0.3295017481,
-0.4936798513,
-0.0648340881,
-0.6977316737,
-0.0420086123,
-0.1646443456,
-0.3961507082,
-0.4251971245,
-0.1146366671,
-0.0018768855,
0.0695613474,
-0.0301374085,
0.4837558866,
-0.7494289279,
0.6613889933,
0.80545789,
0.3462840021,
0.2219323963,
0.2874312699,
0.0119923064,
-0.268581301,
-0.6857879162,
-0.2694934607,
0.9366934299,
0.1919511259,
0.8286343813,
-0.2377526313,
0.5973184109,
0.4755140841,
0.1705255508,
-0.7336732149,
0.2771700621,
-0.568218708,
-0.5667136312,
-0.1049227268,
-0.363846153,
-1.0781270266,
0.0380195379,
-0.3478275836,
-0.307357043,
0.4669285119,
0.3192908764,
-0.6767247319,
0.0515927151,
-0.6445091367,
0.9004935026,
-0.1739204079,
-0.1322519034,
-0.0432155766,
-0.8039433956,
0.1744077504,
-0.0951482654,
-0.0265452769,
-0.0448204763,
0.2350677848,
0.5608715415,
-0.1195240393,
1.134681344,
-0.1955646425,
0.0105015263,
0.4042912126,
0.1438961774,
0.0301001891,
-0.0018385402,
0.5601960421,
0.1462439299,
0.0983063132,
-0.2115714997,
-0.6851828098,
0.6164455414,
-0.8428775072,
-0.6197627783,
0.0784962848,
-0.4746846855,
-0.0656826496,
0.324414283,
0.6056396961,
0.5261884928,
-0.0619007871,
0.1556018144,
0.6184816957,
-0.1270136833,
0.4176283479,
0.3677742481,
0.3288317621,
-0.6013031006,
1.0493197441,
-0.1756784171,
0.360116154,
0.6694493294,
0.0714610741,
-0.3583931029,
-0.608612597,
-0.605872035,
0.197312817,
-0.7747191191,
-0.7915109992,
-0.165549472,
-0.1490451396,
0.0342122354,
-0.0679254085,
-0.2528484464,
-0.4095414579,
-0.5060588717,
0.0948365033,
0.3014370501,
0.4703432322,
-0.0909271464,
0.5237680078,
-0.7585875392,
0.4636991024,
0.2917809784,
0.3956666589,
0.075812526,
-0.5046855807,
-0.3251321912,
0.1712456942,
-0.4205807745,
-0.4207595587,
0.3644717932,
0.6742192507,
0.4072473645,
0.3447676897,
0.2455892265,
0.6618538499,
-0.6963994503,
0.3995865285,
0.2180794626,
-0.7547987103,
0.3332260847,
-0.0798205882,
0.2530381382,
0.4634696543,
0.3888442814,
-0.2409269512,
-0.3350564837,
-0.3732180297,
-0.543928504,
0.4182684124,
0.1961366683,
0.5093648434,
-0.1239782125,
0.5022465587,
0.4964094162,
0.2373726219,
-0.6923177838,
-0.2195106596,
-0.540979147,
0.0285346396,
-0.0912414491,
0.1923223883,
-0.337074399,
-0.0094161043,
0.2213662714,
-0.4607780874,
0.4939538538,
0.5024004579,
-0.3006382585,
-0.2930513918,
0.2361372262,
0.5487826467,
0.3724636137,
-0.0545607917,
0.3135881126,
-0.1977678537,
-0.2290433645,
-0.1313940138,
0.5217815042,
-0.273491323,
0.064475365,
0.2310026437,
0.9959514141,
0.1754309535,
-0.5077220798,
0.7192835212,
0.0058712312,
-0.380597353,
-0.0065149385,
-0.0895858556,
-0.2604864538,
0.2151742131,
0.5549809337,
0.4728322327,
0.3794349432,
-0.2850565016,
0.488509953,
0.5428318381,
-0.4579086304,
-0.270550251,
0.9243725538,
0.309525162,
-0.0822927952,
0.3680230677,
-0.1891943961,
-0.4649491608,
0.5072469115,
0.7840937972,
0.6946649551,
0.4764685035,
0.337284714,
0.1615638137,
0.0581014901,
0.0169778187,
0.051080808,
-0.3642115295,
-0.8432698846,
-0.3834874332,
-0.3287780285,
-0.1076244563,
-0.044731088,
-0.8239462376,
-0.0504105762,
-0.4761910141,
-0.1707933098,
0.3389455974,
-0.1792299449,
-0.8634759188,
0.4879204035,
0.2647095323,
0.654540956,
-0.6605550647,
0.473012656,
0.6961299777,
-0.7619417906,
-0.6006479263,
0.0064691431,
-0.5246531367,
-0.6908747554,
0.8902316689,
0.2636465728,
-0.0412511602,
0.1114369854,
-0.785533607,
-0.681402266,
0.9866200089,
0.3468552232,
-0.6343784332,
0.0541617386,
0.3699709475,
0.6083421707,
-0.5833620429,
-0.1494090259,
0.4012201428,
0.0134315258,
0.0726101473,
-1.1262038946,
0.4068925679,
-0.0812188908,
0.1994363815,
-0.0728599802,
-0.6590842009,
0.5072011352,
-0.4083422422,
-0.4920856953,
0.4076518714,
0.7946811914,
-0.0148742432,
0.1198488399,
0.5480235815,
0.194880113,
0.2963123024,
-0.0949147418,
0.8510177732,
-0.1215062886,
0.3045294881,
1.1767166853,
0.1355482638,
0.6051506996,
0.5564683676,
0.1621910632,
0.2974477112,
0.4493227303,
-0.4744412005,
0.8966363072,
0.2561977506,
0.1991846263,
-0.3455197811,
-0.219537124,
0.0280871335,
0.329307884,
0.0964913443,
-0.5915609002,
-0.2363349944,
0.2457895428,
-0.4939090014,
0.516254127,
-0.4021986127,
0.7409454584,
0.166421473,
-0.5801233649,
1.1163830757,
-0.3477545977,
0.8988381624,
0.021950122,
-0.1546864212,
-0.1843187958,
0.2426366657,
-0.2179844528,
-0.9355049729,
0.3364185989,
-0.3738937974,
-0.3822468519,
-0.0243353788,
0.6337383986,
-0.7120730281,
0.0863616467,
0.0370707512,
0.2228790373,
0.2129776627,
-0.2644508779,
-0.7348475456,
-0.2252634764,
-0.0574641861,
0.4956834912,
-0.0699312314,
0.5280123353,
-0.263445586,
0.6820750237,
0.4614113271,
0.0162517037,
0.1482703537,
0.352637291,
0.6928389072,
-0.4513681233,
-0.4642913342,
-0.5443785191,
0.1551048905,
-0.0027989256,
-0.3461201191,
0.50395751,
0.6279731989,
1.0942618847,
-0.82789433,
0.7676433325,
0.0350454375,
0.3328222632,
-0.5459280014,
0.6725730896,
-0.4140158296,
-0.2504434884,
-0.0082660327,
-0.8067060709,
-0.4269927144,
0.4522817731,
-0.1533249021,
-0.1472192407,
0.5290158391,
0.6803758144,
-0.3340414464,
-0.1864956021,
0.3576971591,
-0.0712690875,
-0.0073840781,
0.6063941717,
0.9265394807,
-0.5150878429,
0.9668174982,
-0.5397087336,
0.1186572686,
0.0433653332,
-0.6396744251,
-1.2467602491,
-0.6023136377,
-0.5507797599,
-0.0038640404,
0.2984399199,
0.6716148257,
1.035128355,
-0.9175582528,
0.012844692,
-0.1429196745,
-0.3444057405,
-0.3465234637,
-0.3224998415,
0.3581548035,
-0.3470430374,
-0.6571134925,
-0.2207414657,
0.048393812,
0.3179365695,
-0.2458966523,
-0.1236428022,
0.2846832871,
-0.1213662624,
0.4354555011,
0.4208776653,
-0.7859247923,
-0.4262790084,
-0.1256364435,
-0.1700145155,
0.3688659668,
0.758936584,
-0.5552614927,
0.332781136,
-0.0469402485,
0.6700300574,
0.5290496945,
0.2669834495,
0.6271980405,
-1.1170969009,
-0.0319258794,
-0.1371245235,
0.1986691803,
0.8219549656,
-0.5686673522,
0.1809682548,
0.1417014301,
-0.5176661015,
-0.2556742728,
0.0826734006,
-1.0401110649,
-0.0400300547,
1.0562160015,
-0.2871054709,
-0.0385999568,
-0.0280967411,
-0.5753446817,
0.1225287244,
-0.4701038003,
0.97121948,
0.2813491225,
0.0808048919,
-0.4940819442,
-0.2386257052,
0.7612557411,
0.31200701,
-0.7325660586,
0.2363219112,
0.4589578509,
0.4638919532,
0.412748307,
0.2756312191,
0.0354003794,
0.5600587726,
-0.2506963909,
0.1813593805,
-0.2214668244,
-0.3339738846,
-0.1453034133,
-0.1645824015,
0.0443970412,
-0.5770773888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01638v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01638v1 | Multidimensional Perceptron for Efficient and Explainable Long Text Classification | 2023-04-04T08:49:39 | 2023-04-04T08:49:39 | Yexiang Wang, Yating Zhang, Xiaozhong Liu, Changlong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Because of the inevitable cost and complexity of transformer and pre-trained
models, efficiency concerns are raised for long text classification. Meanwhile,
in the highly sensitive domains, e.g., healthcare and legal long-text mining,
potential model distrust, yet underrated and underexplored, may hatch vital
apprehension. Existing methods generally segment the long text, encode each
piece with the pre-trained model, and use attention or RNNs to obtain long text
representation for classification. In this work, we propose a simple but
effective model, Segment-aWare multIdimensional PErceptron (SWIPE), to replace
attention/RNNs in the above framework. Unlike prior efforts, SWIPE can
effectively learn the label of the entire text with supervised training, while
perceive the labels of the segments and estimate their contributions to the
long-text labeling in an unsupervised manner. As a general classifier, SWIPE
can endorse different encoders, and it outperforms SOTA models in terms of
classification accuracy and model efficiency. It is noteworthy that SWIPE
achieves superior interpretability to transparentize long text classification
results. | [
-0.0801289901,
-0.2359166145,
0.7529971004,
0.2507646382,
-0.4041066468,
-0.0792699605,
0.0027331193,
-0.5507295728,
0.2315132767,
0.6029751301,
-0.3746113777,
-0.544506669,
-0.6939445138,
-0.0955538228,
-0.652960062,
1.1130545139,
-0.0701597482,
-0.1873115599,
-0.2492764145,
-0.2918177545,
0.2274839729,
-0.734403789,
-0.3249527216,
-0.6648833156,
0.8326621652,
0.2403094023,
0.4173201025,
0.4660683274,
0.5321964025,
0.3188279867,
-0.0096428571,
-0.089993678,
-0.0804829672,
-0.0334639437,
-0.0862038136,
-0.4296338856,
-0.4740869105,
-0.2739283741,
0.3783896565,
0.5196709037,
0.0531714559,
0.0892636105,
-0.0235515367,
0.6048064232,
-0.5843802691,
-0.1434057355,
-0.2758325636,
0.1422307938,
-0.3615462184,
-0.1616010219,
-0.3922146261,
-0.2087398767,
0.2081126869,
-0.5320525765,
0.1836719066,
-0.2210077643,
0.6163753271,
0.2006806731,
-0.6459397078,
-0.1238993332,
-0.5374106765,
0.7224407196,
-0.3578207791,
0.5439983606,
0.3742125928,
0.3515702784,
0.2416295856,
-0.9820609689,
-0.7112259269,
-0.0689211264,
0.0901482776,
0.3520312905,
0.0602800027,
0.0941422358,
0.1947838366,
0.1050639302,
-0.3057834804,
0.6078026891,
-0.0368164107,
-0.218180269,
0.379034698,
0.0169590432,
0.2163077891,
-0.3083494306,
-0.9352310896,
0.0201920792,
-0.4286688864,
0.1788083911,
0.3257118165,
-0.0179189499,
-0.0754269958,
0.4883056879,
0.0990087762,
0.4873255491,
0.0231088772,
-0.1434237957,
0.4153600633,
-0.3547601402,
-0.2566983104,
0.0738442913,
0.7963138223,
0.1294158399,
0.0875073299,
0.2636210918,
-0.1825334281,
-0.1083118692,
0.4434982538,
-1.010114193,
-0.1210907176,
0.2980952263,
-0.765694797,
-0.3207350373,
0.0879093558,
-1.0090664625,
-0.6421198249,
-0.4302113056,
0.3561891317,
-0.5140596032,
-0.176925987,
0.1872901917,
-0.2282850444,
0.0365190357,
0.4980322719,
-0.9121325016,
0.1004784256,
0.6373089552,
0.8856394291,
-0.2702270448,
-0.4058205187,
-0.2338886559,
-0.0737212375,
-0.0025637103,
0.9120351672,
-0.6642578244,
-0.188280493,
-0.0909173191,
-0.3122397661,
-0.2088640779,
-0.2695211172,
0.5935365558,
-0.4345178306,
-0.017031664,
0.1594701856,
-0.545601368,
-0.0213197377,
0.3344838619,
-0.6250867248,
0.6469316483,
0.0399234109,
-1.129958868,
0.5127466917,
-0.9180132151,
-0.4254750609,
0.0678750873,
-0.0048620887,
-0.8038814068,
0.0461220257,
0.4576296508,
0.6865775585,
0.0729999393,
0.1798604578,
-0.225498125,
-0.3741544485,
0.4980906844,
-0.7229755521,
0.5574499965,
0.1096787304,
-0.1461940706,
0.5333675146,
-0.8403578401,
-0.2123325616,
-0.0634616166,
-0.4752470553,
-0.7592425942,
-0.1446642727,
0.1831899136,
-0.0216890313,
0.2676261961,
-0.5911195278,
0.0814422965,
-0.2000185698,
0.4675292373,
0.7721781731,
-0.153121531,
0.6271252632,
0.1827011257,
0.2985080481,
0.3791842759,
0.4383648634,
-0.5641585588,
-0.0766078308,
-0.613032937,
-0.6633394957,
0.542906642,
0.1960139573,
-0.7097041607,
0.5671606064,
-0.5242599249,
-0.3717256486,
-0.2915866971,
-0.1299147606,
0.297434181,
0.5272451639,
0.444671005,
-0.2572676241,
-0.1564448178,
-0.760345757,
-0.193934828,
0.2892209888,
-0.1543160826,
0.2359148711,
0.6262145042,
-0.5862337351,
0.628187418,
-0.3730634451,
-0.2367769778,
-0.4406526387,
0.2874920964,
0.1556107551,
0.2632266581,
0.1582746804,
-1.0300147533,
-0.4576652348,
0.1540508717,
-0.4852598011,
0.1232891604,
-0.390431881,
-0.054486461,
-0.0058874143,
0.4927483797,
-0.6877163053,
0.7924978137,
0.3016758561,
-0.3346548676,
0.7073794007,
-0.3910069466,
-0.0552335531,
-1.0322128534,
0.2389010936,
0.3582808673,
-0.2445903569,
-0.8844105005,
-0.0734788477,
0.6332158446,
-0.095402658,
-0.3113841712,
0.5553898811,
-0.3209103048,
0.0321965925,
-0.3524780273,
0.0332581475,
0.1373620927,
0.4104569256,
0.1200391725,
0.386118114,
0.345680058,
-0.7764428854,
0.1486858428,
0.367932111,
-0.4939776659,
0.6013063788,
-0.5604785085,
-0.0892059505,
-0.2795482278,
0.5032635927,
-0.6580649018,
-0.2184665352,
0.1251669526,
-0.3247753084,
0.4340774417,
-0.2101109922,
-0.2806194425,
-0.6738645434,
-0.4677951038,
0.4782822132,
0.1007283777,
-1.2810896635,
0.7817274332,
0.2771628201,
0.0227085538,
-0.852471292,
-0.5818276405,
-0.1361989081,
-0.1644637287,
-0.2727837265,
0.4273699224,
0.4013669789,
0.0670650229,
-0.3454474509,
-0.3318296671,
-0.2732257545,
-0.0541597009,
0.4618310332,
0.1759036928,
0.0862830281,
0.4748081565,
0.3290659189,
-0.4441904128,
-0.0258145761,
-0.0771845356,
0.6574552655,
0.2858555317,
-0.6224591732,
-0.6039877534,
0.3297935724,
0.8783428073,
-0.5492377877,
0.2702415884,
0.6658263803,
-0.1762842387,
-0.2705806792,
-0.3278365433,
-0.1771876067,
-0.4671064019,
0.6948483586,
-0.4354056716,
-0.7146196365,
0.4887754321,
-0.2835637927,
-0.1397429258,
0.3136630952,
0.191593796,
-0.2038496435,
0.9357830286,
0.6231204271,
-0.2301148176,
0.6695978642,
0.0793338194,
0.3690576255,
-0.8507731557,
-0.4538052082,
-0.5955348611,
-0.3686915338,
-0.3392329216,
-0.4458574653,
0.3715232015,
-0.3353454173,
-0.3677761257,
0.1092010438,
-0.6332781315,
0.4335986674,
0.7673795223,
0.5166086555,
0.0648672655,
0.008587352,
-0.0499818772,
0.0970852822,
-0.384157598,
-0.2899882793,
0.9764914513,
0.7504841685,
0.9670156837,
-0.3030506074,
0.7677825093,
0.0106221763,
0.1627185494,
-0.8098103404,
0.3809608519,
-0.4579046667,
-0.351403296,
-0.405885607,
-0.343518734,
-1.0456472635,
0.4617063105,
-0.2831823826,
-0.5455470085,
0.3021158874,
-0.0061273868,
-0.3059011698,
0.4652150273,
-0.5470658541,
0.8351806402,
-0.6022604704,
-0.16521433,
-0.2925111651,
-0.7564041018,
0.1653920412,
-0.1933899075,
-0.0752244741,
0.0580803342,
0.0590451546,
0.9581408501,
-0.5471130013,
1.1055595875,
-0.4764916599,
0.2360334992,
0.0672788471,
-0.2673102319,
0.3156139255,
-0.1019796729,
0.1034964472,
0.2112480402,
-0.2707247138,
-0.1931826621,
-0.4957102239,
0.519993186,
-0.6322260499,
-0.0821986124,
-0.4934926331,
-0.2582253218,
-0.0276374761,
0.4664157033,
0.2121110708,
0.5224861503,
0.0228257924,
0.1062325612,
0.8715442419,
-0.2704722583,
0.4667644203,
0.0626897365,
-0.2618454993,
-0.2082789093,
0.7675350904,
-0.1138995439,
-0.2972557545,
0.6581909657,
0.4019835591,
-0.5553079247,
-0.5848858356,
-0.2676746845,
0.1536801904,
-0.4506256282,
-0.4039926529,
-0.8845332861,
-0.3462269902,
-0.0209771786,
-0.1277552992,
-0.3599227965,
-0.2299662679,
-0.5360967517,
-0.3219678104,
0.2732277215,
0.5299648643,
0.249402374,
0.4987895489,
-0.7545739412,
0.5519008636,
0.4141904712,
0.6991468668,
0.1494510323,
-0.5179203153,
-0.1569238305,
-0.1982635409,
-0.2244965583,
-0.6309837699,
0.3368570209,
-0.0905412808,
0.5720749497,
0.8123974204,
0.0523086525,
0.6067566276,
-0.4669246674,
0.4458836615,
0.7880278826,
-1.072368145,
0.4005219936,
-0.0885114223,
0.5466400385,
0.6429709792,
0.5904251933,
-0.3666795492,
-0.0349566825,
-0.2331305593,
-0.9641903639,
0.4569011629,
-0.3818264008,
0.2229406834,
0.1713344902,
0.3035086393,
0.6607570648,
0.0672314912,
-0.7297233939,
0.2232094407,
-0.5910027623,
-0.6349846721,
0.1801191121,
-0.639911592,
0.0265850816,
-0.051664643,
0.1463864297,
-0.2461723983,
0.4142639339,
0.2454188168,
-0.2761166394,
0.4315698147,
0.4620991945,
0.6210747361,
0.5560657382,
0.1512093544,
0.4334954619,
-0.1680057645,
-0.8293233514,
-0.0119795855,
0.131099984,
-0.1768919379,
-0.1438631117,
0.3203203976,
0.8849564195,
0.2698555291,
-0.3752958179,
0.8590636849,
-0.0841972232,
-0.4098630846,
-0.2986568511,
-0.2649309337,
0.0955753252,
0.2148739994,
0.3479858637,
0.2532340884,
0.2432686985,
-0.1203138009,
0.1945601106,
0.14925614,
-0.5685462356,
-0.2395001352,
0.4980868697,
0.3589690924,
-0.0683783218,
0.7492852211,
0.4117483795,
-0.9191675186,
0.411663264,
0.5448797941,
0.5005655289,
-0.2917646468,
0.3483584523,
0.1632146835,
-0.1605726779,
-0.1559080333,
-0.0011469517,
-0.3113569319,
-0.7304266691,
-0.3674463332,
-0.5476245284,
-0.5008158684,
0.0598553047,
-0.7270157337,
-0.0886058882,
-0.5269722342,
-0.2832558751,
0.2980790734,
-0.3721977472,
-0.5586189628,
0.3240003884,
0.1444598138,
0.974181056,
-0.7148127556,
0.8697490692,
0.5181302428,
-0.1618349552,
-0.3696396947,
0.1075664833,
-0.3782462478,
-0.7812048793,
0.5285970569,
0.7649303079,
-0.1251508743,
-0.4726582766,
-0.5130588412,
-0.4173718095,
0.8259704709,
-0.1833915263,
-0.8094602823,
0.1814780682,
-0.0012161214,
0.611871779,
0.0243839193,
0.2483073324,
0.4090283215,
0.5542337298,
-0.1655367911,
-0.6557298303,
-0.0461510755,
-0.1578737199,
-0.1814567596,
0.4356026053,
-0.5572749972,
0.6312913299,
-0.3737584949,
0.0479490981,
-0.1773973554,
0.7476335168,
0.1394705623,
0.7788645029,
0.5506759882,
0.32264027,
0.9553941488,
-0.0118845496,
0.928132236,
0.1401575208,
0.0441055,
1.0296725035,
-0.3961654305,
0.8824641705,
0.5758697987,
-0.0909962878,
0.5298365355,
0.3418401778,
-0.125465557,
0.537920177,
0.1047302783,
-0.3560107052,
-0.2023421675,
0.2200872898,
0.0192624386,
0.7271015644,
0.3399398923,
-0.5146915317,
-0.0467311442,
0.4295719564,
-0.0263214987,
0.1085746214,
-0.6349966526,
0.6676210165,
0.1240308881,
-0.4500502646,
-0.1112520397,
0.0335143209,
1.1221020222,
-0.6846612692,
0.2403888553,
0.021948535,
0.5979703665,
-0.4286512434,
-1.0041253567,
0.002294644,
-0.0741480738,
-0.3154067993,
-0.237293154,
1.123118639,
-0.3104723692,
-0.4578787088,
0.333918035,
0.1581801176,
0.0431945696,
-0.3317379653,
-0.5359176397,
-0.104197301,
0.0348728448,
-0.347320199,
0.6531320214,
0.4060939252,
-0.1597742885,
0.858088553,
0.644159615,
-0.1210699379,
0.0071794158,
0.4307987988,
0.8001107574,
-0.8379700184,
-0.6292164922,
-0.781668663,
0.5356547236,
-0.3873620927,
-0.2913583815,
0.4753976464,
0.3607367575,
0.3000100553,
-0.1312969625,
0.8053578734,
0.3889331818,
0.6934111118,
-0.4349324703,
1.0107213259,
-0.4396630228,
-0.2165328264,
0.0999274775,
-0.5369313359,
-0.7083397508,
0.7947230935,
-0.3162492514,
0.1007484421,
0.7489001751,
0.1482776701,
-0.3504311144,
0.1018694043,
0.2983081341,
0.0830641463,
0.3929366171,
0.3395020962,
0.6175524592,
-0.1462127268,
0.5195321441,
-0.2447153181,
-0.3976706862,
-0.3693809807,
-0.7678431273,
-0.9961321354,
-0.5029663444,
-0.2222682983,
-0.1915321201,
-0.1516582221,
0.5957455635,
0.642436862,
-0.6254255772,
0.1746587306,
0.2061354816,
0.2724305391,
-0.099553287,
-0.1667681485,
0.7528556585,
-0.1589180529,
-0.465138346,
0.248844102,
0.4064524174,
0.0405297428,
0.0523978695,
0.194739148,
0.0738197565,
-0.0417241603,
0.8326866627,
0.3321530819,
-0.2058804184,
-0.2918345928,
-0.1327690631,
-0.2353447229,
0.2291670144,
0.900390625,
-0.4892013967,
0.3563054502,
0.2844982445,
0.6185477376,
0.7997953296,
0.2194416523,
0.150701046,
-0.5486463308,
-0.0054515884,
0.4239098728,
0.3894644678,
0.3547530472,
-0.3041464984,
0.1037434787,
-0.1879196614,
-0.6672126055,
-0.6545242071,
0.2800605893,
-1.2201290131,
-0.3946626186,
1.0124648809,
-0.1914545894,
-0.5882840753,
-0.2776324451,
-0.1940316558,
0.1007448286,
-0.3784774542,
0.6406680346,
-0.0124360071,
-0.2184419781,
-0.2117222399,
0.0946334675,
0.0822389349,
0.1641845554,
-0.791505456,
0.1760399491,
0.3345657885,
0.344774574,
0.3729785383,
0.7288233042,
-0.4335561693,
0.0950565934,
0.1140631437,
0.3740063012,
-0.2552297115,
-0.6798980832,
-0.3595930934,
0.3996874988,
-0.121970132,
-0.4152287543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01622v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01622v2 | An interpretability framework for Similar case matching | 2023-04-04T08:25:12 | 2023-08-16T11:58:38 | Nankai Lin, Haonan Liu, Jiajun Fang, Dong Zhou, Aimin Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Similar Case Matching (SCM) plays a pivotal role in the legal system by
facilitating the efficient identification of similar cases for legal
professionals. While previous research has primarily concentrated on enhancing
the performance of SCM models, the aspect of interpretability has been
neglected. To bridge the gap, this study proposes an integrated pipeline
framework for interpretable SCM. The framework comprises four modules: judicial
feature sentence identification, case matching, feature sentence alignment, and
conflict resolution. In contrast to current SCM methods, our framework first
extracts feature sentences within a legal case that contain essential
information. Then it conducts case matching based on these extracted features.
Subsequently, our framework aligns the corresponding sentences in two legal
cases to provide evidence of similarity. In instances where the results of case
matching and feature sentence alignment exhibit conflicts, the conflict
resolution module resolves these inconsistencies. The experimental results show
the effectiveness of our proposed framework, establishing a new benchmark for
interpretable SCM. | [
0.020730624,
-0.1003831252,
0.901868403,
0.1696736068,
-0.6858250499,
0.0531031191,
0.0128647378,
-0.5675694942,
0.2177274376,
1.0502935648,
-0.4951347411,
-0.4775912762,
-0.5405820608,
-0.0564663075,
-0.8489436507,
0.9497007728,
-0.1573372781,
0.2265312374,
-0.2742073834,
-0.7942168117,
-0.6096276045,
-0.3129990101,
-0.2253737003,
-0.2412087321,
0.0549248047,
0.2385967672,
0.5957112908,
1.0032764673,
0.907143116,
0.3785427213,
-0.200557664,
-0.160233885,
-0.2188994884,
0.1710935831,
-0.600772202,
-0.6155160069,
-0.4240966737,
-0.0242709015,
0.5524193048,
0.4031114876,
-0.5216343999,
0.1951415837,
0.2988038361,
0.5501418114,
-0.505386591,
0.2577995658,
-0.8456010222,
0.2369284481,
-0.4990077913,
-0.333342433,
-0.1837172955,
-0.2611691952,
0.2455017269,
-0.7315554023,
0.4349409044,
0.2239963114,
0.8020381331,
0.3688933551,
-0.5041227937,
-0.4271457791,
-0.344643116,
0.2977621555,
-1.0822834969,
0.088923648,
-0.2183574289,
0.6729316711,
-0.1360389441,
-1.0262711048,
-0.8054516315,
0.288823843,
-0.5892236829,
0.350249052,
-0.0882673636,
0.1861005723,
0.3668176234,
0.2862242758,
-0.757660985,
0.1198113039,
-0.3323816359,
-0.3471244276,
0.3952343762,
0.4211195409,
0.2439804524,
-0.2264963239,
-0.3240662515,
0.2825884819,
-0.6399548054,
0.0151500292,
0.4067485929,
0.6911600232,
-0.1451537311,
0.5934665799,
-0.3198506236,
0.629140079,
-0.0417456478,
0.0820282176,
0.1363133043,
-0.322868228,
-0.4312117994,
0.4286676347,
0.3276776969,
0.6907286644,
0.1285343319,
0.1347291023,
-0.0468550585,
-0.0163599458,
0.4267854989,
-0.5976518393,
0.1422101259,
0.2306090146,
-1.0416958332,
-0.347895205,
0.5082808137,
-0.6805878282,
-0.6406270266,
-0.3008383214,
0.2331365347,
-0.1224722415,
-0.2609254718,
0.0309250839,
-0.1482846737,
0.587721765,
0.0932469964,
-0.599871695,
0.3694933653,
1.3113362789,
0.9691023231,
-0.2676373422,
0.0511431992,
-1.0105011463,
0.2081543952,
0.0100405067,
0.6386319399,
-0.7457304001,
0.1012980863,
0.3137241006,
0.1142170876,
-0.101787433,
-0.7066714764,
0.8900227547,
-0.565699935,
0.1429372132,
0.0493484847,
-0.5679423213,
-0.3397270143,
0.2407418042,
-0.6482685804,
0.5177645683,
0.1874684691,
-0.7285332084,
0.8651073575,
-0.7264108062,
-0.4791199565,
0.5377913713,
-0.3031122983,
-0.5687272549,
0.1536269933,
-0.1923924088,
0.3043107688,
-0.1241312772,
0.2827253342,
-0.6144353747,
-0.8041173816,
-0.0528717339,
0.0888992772,
0.7170891762,
0.5765023828,
-0.224229604,
0.3709518313,
-0.7571836114,
0.0279555842,
-0.3357903063,
-0.2161835134,
-0.2811819911,
0.1936159134,
0.0927206501,
0.3893998861,
0.1802059263,
-0.3153637946,
-0.0730755702,
-0.4387547374,
0.7737570405,
0.6175541878,
-0.2864589989,
0.481382221,
-0.1896745116,
0.6791945696,
0.2931972146,
-0.0235424135,
-0.3520557284,
-0.1580450833,
-0.5817201138,
-0.4634884894,
0.4513529539,
0.6598103642,
-0.4082697034,
0.3816648424,
-0.5453323126,
-0.1065759882,
-0.7712873816,
0.0498206317,
0.2812470496,
0.3820001483,
0.2482762486,
-0.5970717072,
-0.843515873,
-1.1362370253,
-0.9783500433,
-0.2336336076,
-0.0465834811,
0.3035191298,
0.1807523221,
0.0418897755,
0.9539232254,
-0.0960274711,
-0.5263406634,
-0.1053949594,
0.0977521613,
0.6401021481,
0.2711767554,
0.5014395714,
-0.8463958502,
-0.7119870782,
0.4015337229,
-0.9711142778,
-0.2791542411,
-0.1268767565,
-0.0530637205,
-0.2626073062,
0.7712472677,
-0.2175932527,
0.5616580844,
0.1723839194,
-0.6418375969,
0.0864189938,
-0.0409072153,
0.4072858691,
-1.0401624441,
0.0481320731,
-0.1105750203,
-0.5616140366,
-0.4380677938,
0.4629759789,
0.1938161999,
-0.0126622831,
-0.6339610219,
0.2021119595,
-0.2357465327,
-0.4208081961,
-0.2385370582,
0.3614891768,
0.0595588833,
0.1133291796,
-0.2379515469,
0.4027938843,
0.5848325491,
-0.1943813562,
0.2222899944,
0.2549090683,
-0.6099563837,
1.4832049608,
-0.4971656799,
-0.3035960793,
-0.124812834,
0.1146526262,
-0.5574310422,
-0.0524195731,
0.42499879,
0.1878853589,
0.0573183633,
-0.5888234377,
-0.2772058249,
-0.1332630366,
-0.1078147665,
0.2248516232,
0.1875889748,
-0.4815596044,
1.1286406517,
-0.1938926131,
-0.3439571261,
-0.6664801836,
-0.5816343427,
0.0130138472,
-0.8543272018,
-0.3395595253,
0.3297737837,
0.1478195488,
-0.1300343573,
0.34002617,
-0.3063359857,
-0.1226286441,
0.1049767882,
0.6258007288,
0.1216431782,
-0.467947185,
-0.0334109068,
0.1887453496,
-0.02029231,
-0.0562161729,
-0.1604367048,
0.2044250965,
0.0755144507,
-0.5953255296,
-0.3771263659,
0.6973261237,
0.6683430672,
-0.0994335413,
0.4768125415,
0.3532070518,
-0.3308655918,
0.0852746218,
-0.4505926669,
0.166297093,
-0.4652077258,
0.293384701,
-0.8860163689,
-0.925144136,
0.770652473,
-0.3165718019,
0.0707591251,
0.4324594736,
0.2839310169,
-0.2009789348,
0.8106093407,
0.7011522651,
0.0422510356,
0.5604346991,
0.4247532785,
0.4609102011,
-0.6655614972,
-0.2421291322,
-0.5403152108,
-0.2886664271,
-0.4959244728,
0.0314763114,
0.0411479883,
0.4346027076,
-0.1245376542,
0.6761663556,
-0.3861502111,
0.4887484312,
0.2846531868,
0.0056868051,
0.633839488,
-0.1796649992,
-0.5269396305,
-0.1998987794,
-0.47123757,
-0.7245873809,
0.9156628251,
0.0429837033,
0.1259415001,
0.3814971745,
0.5010637641,
0.4435811639,
0.3204214871,
-0.5525867343,
0.4038014114,
-0.3006522954,
-0.4847766757,
0.074291572,
-0.3028398156,
-0.8401263952,
0.4034714103,
-0.6036745906,
-0.8809108138,
0.118062079,
-0.0501480699,
-0.2801429033,
0.0003237619,
-0.5532187223,
0.9731218219,
-0.0206022989,
-0.0909962207,
-0.4362904429,
-0.7059479356,
0.1476038992,
-0.3609002531,
0.3768035173,
-0.140082866,
0.1897750348,
0.5203784704,
-0.6077286005,
0.2903702855,
0.050545346,
0.2802557051,
0.0730432793,
-0.0555325337,
0.2949983776,
0.0154379439,
-0.5433710814,
-0.0692021623,
0.5568782687,
-0.2916651964,
-0.9021838903,
0.6935814023,
-0.0769312829,
-0.6655033827,
-0.560385108,
-0.5978874564,
0.2306332141,
0.4675506055,
0.0426291339,
0.1994564235,
-0.2898966372,
0.0883936808,
0.1137088537,
0.2475117296,
0.367156446,
0.9046499133,
-0.1046805307,
0.0129484041,
0.7092499137,
-0.0914583802,
-0.1321874261,
0.2570691705,
-0.0875184238,
-0.2786433697,
-0.8438560367,
-0.3846383989,
-0.1441247165,
-0.7532991767,
-0.3236524165,
-0.3836638033,
-0.1883661598,
-0.1440846324,
-0.0592746176,
-0.0084751025,
-0.1740872562,
-0.0375503786,
0.2031749785,
0.3143654168,
0.8179090619,
0.0408215225,
0.3763833046,
-0.7142404318,
0.0840564072,
0.1956718713,
0.8529909849,
-0.4150064588,
-0.8098890781,
-0.2778833807,
-0.151147455,
-0.1839614213,
-0.5222862363,
-0.034687303,
0.1914377064,
0.6176852584,
0.7447103858,
0.2095154375,
0.9536123872,
-0.5575557351,
0.4627141654,
0.2311005145,
-1.2377284765,
0.6227130294,
-0.0486062095,
-0.0310997218,
0.8720659614,
0.0387767069,
-0.4200941324,
-0.364112854,
-0.5948730707,
-0.7601310611,
0.7580038309,
0.2013027221,
-0.0033211384,
0.400868535,
0.7638865709,
0.2535930276,
0.2391725034,
-0.5686505437,
0.161003232,
-0.0275644921,
-0.6378889084,
0.1843884736,
0.1066536978,
-0.3122107685,
-0.0049935989,
0.3680312932,
-0.2158328742,
-0.0537715927,
-0.1932700872,
-0.3444104791,
0.0168745313,
0.4208752811,
0.1998956203,
0.76277107,
-0.1772844642,
0.0653833896,
0.1963740736,
-0.2275950909,
-0.0873485655,
0.2650622129,
-0.0106098419,
-0.1318869144,
0.5671218634,
0.6653147936,
0.1733690351,
-0.8884177208,
0.716098845,
-0.1560808867,
-0.208359763,
-0.0674962625,
0.2339654416,
0.0548316464,
0.9459821582,
0.2281119227,
0.16963467,
0.5550113916,
-0.8978208899,
0.3727909029,
0.4129367173,
-0.9199398756,
0.3192507327,
0.6695882082,
0.0154718347,
-0.532649219,
0.4454389215,
-0.0853309557,
-0.573887825,
0.5326625109,
0.1689415574,
0.4503879845,
0.2438563108,
0.0158069674,
-0.0809347108,
-0.01376322,
-0.2398027778,
0.2565227151,
-0.0546319373,
-0.4867611229,
-0.4441049099,
-0.3422117829,
-0.2733516991,
-0.1712700725,
-1.3814822435,
0.6012690663,
-0.0970580354,
0.2664104998,
0.0998466164,
-0.1508353502,
-0.8256084323,
0.0854259878,
-0.3674537838,
0.6549919248,
-1.0193969011,
0.7068528533,
0.7024694681,
-0.2794901431,
-0.7368611097,
0.0339233465,
0.2497811466,
-0.6463513374,
0.0702743456,
0.2825559974,
0.1305277199,
-0.3815677762,
-0.3260158598,
-0.2759267092,
1.3219569921,
0.5239060521,
-0.8112770319,
0.3552795053,
0.2992047369,
0.7949142456,
-0.9023249149,
0.2111715227,
0.9813585281,
0.2294809073,
0.1582560688,
-0.9588286281,
0.4796508253,
-0.328397274,
-0.0397109091,
0.042319905,
-0.3673981428,
0.276419431,
0.1085085422,
-0.3812254369,
0.30589059,
0.4804833829,
0.2370778322,
0.6955651641,
0.6341596246,
0.512942791,
0.6442189217,
-0.1036017463,
0.3977344334,
-0.3401496112,
0.4319908917,
1.4497944117,
-0.6187896729,
0.8931562304,
0.5797870159,
-0.0407837667,
0.6543326378,
0.5098789334,
-0.1249828637,
0.6515091658,
0.4165987372,
-0.1361652762,
-0.4229020774,
-0.0578097738,
-0.3726756275,
0.6746471524,
0.1066187322,
-0.7393086553,
-0.1681534797,
-0.2050146759,
-0.4602208734,
0.6417034268,
-0.1686151773,
0.9351580143,
0.0588855743,
-0.4042392075,
-0.4024577439,
-0.1649361849,
0.5299385786,
-0.3217149377,
-0.3234329224,
-0.1146872863,
0.1429252774,
-0.5472202897,
-0.9684397578,
0.6661059856,
-0.0956363082,
-0.3662354052,
-0.0743148997,
0.4028556347,
-0.2739357948,
-0.3700813651,
0.3992400169,
0.5236220956,
0.2681802511,
-0.1013570279,
-0.7866613269,
0.1484638751,
-0.2318872213,
0.3807300925,
0.4230342209,
0.6734283566,
-0.0943297744,
0.6124753356,
0.3117574155,
0.1245533228,
-0.251259774,
0.0369622968,
0.7741627693,
-0.7142313123,
-0.7650453448,
-0.6484657526,
0.5855121017,
-0.5013960004,
-0.1973867267,
0.2196156234,
0.679939568,
0.5650107265,
0.3070387244,
0.7112294436,
-0.1064875945,
0.6441166401,
-0.499438554,
0.5997422338,
-0.4503846765,
0.6644679904,
-0.458411932,
-1.2808921337,
-0.2406561226,
0.6694127917,
0.1542895585,
-0.2805495262,
0.8019758463,
0.8041166663,
-0.5787618756,
0.3019983768,
0.2768816948,
0.0316397585,
0.080407761,
0.4274770021,
0.5250504613,
-0.6115098596,
0.95288378,
0.3043242395,
-0.0624909624,
-0.3254587948,
-1.2318776846,
-0.7981064916,
-0.3995082974,
-0.4324237704,
-0.5038883686,
0.137022987,
0.5825139284,
0.6579343677,
-0.9301353693,
0.0206243359,
-0.1170174107,
0.1581849456,
-0.5429145098,
-0.2738539279,
0.2379785478,
0.2397418618,
-0.4721010327,
0.1113899052,
0.5099192858,
-0.3318355083,
0.1084946468,
-0.2007770985,
0.0593010448,
0.0493688174,
0.4896765649,
0.230564177,
-0.9232141972,
-0.7667924762,
-0.4860967994,
0.0749248117,
0.1455429941,
1.260043025,
-0.4766354561,
0.7380408645,
0.2592509091,
0.5460592508,
0.7573747635,
-0.0879516825,
0.7845032811,
-0.4355361164,
0.134879604,
-0.0472394451,
0.6411173344,
0.1412575096,
-0.3172001839,
0.7736001611,
-0.0189515743,
-0.1297170818,
-0.7973101735,
0.3602916896,
-1.4107217789,
0.0180108752,
0.5670711398,
-0.7512834668,
0.4629833102,
-0.5903862715,
0.0424701199,
0.4011808932,
-0.0796727762,
0.6265919805,
0.9638669491,
-0.0396770723,
-0.2356928289,
-0.3365263939,
0.2273404151,
0.4142546058,
-0.6739467382,
-0.2921040058,
0.1300383955,
0.46690768,
0.0021536327,
0.2894253433,
-0.2215444744,
0.2207043469,
-0.1206749305,
-0.2098120451,
0.0828484148,
0.2047493458,
-0.6665499806,
0.1593289226,
-0.2478715479,
0.0880263075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01621v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01621v1 | SimCSum: Joint Learning of Simplification and Cross-lingual Summarization for Cross-lingual Science Journalism | 2023-04-04T08:24:22 | 2023-04-04T08:24:22 | Mehwish Fatima, Tim Kolber, Katja Markert, Michael Strube | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual science journalism generates popular science stories of
scientific articles different from the source language for a non-expert
audience. Hence, a cross-lingual popular summary must contain the salient
content of the input document, and the content should be coherent,
comprehensible, and in a local language for the targeted audience. We improve
these aspects of cross-lingual summary generation by joint training of two
high-level NLP tasks, simplification and cross-lingual summarization. The
former task reduces linguistic complexity, and the latter focuses on
cross-lingual abstractive summarization. We propose a novel multi-task
architecture - SimCSum consisting of one shared encoder and two parallel
decoders jointly learning simplification and cross-lingual summarization. We
empirically investigate the performance of SimCSum by comparing it with several
strong baselines over several evaluation metrics and by human evaluation.
Overall, SimCSum demonstrates statistically significant improvements over the
state-of-the-art on two non-synthetic cross-lingual scientific datasets.
Furthermore, we conduct an in-depth investigation into the linguistic
properties of generated summaries and an error analysis. | [
-0.3893115222,
-0.2171268463,
0.2980929315,
0.5135718584,
-0.5181651711,
0.4236537516,
-0.3501491249,
-0.3557966053,
0.6701722741,
-0.079158999,
-0.381683141,
-0.5850820541,
-0.8040117621,
0.5515498519,
-0.0658109784,
1.0785884857,
-0.1882073283,
0.6117049456,
-0.6738808751,
-0.1577791572,
0.1012291834,
-0.292637229,
-0.1578245014,
-0.0714102685,
0.6676121354,
0.5567237139,
0.6622895598,
0.6463554502,
0.3843417764,
0.2208839208,
-0.2225774527,
0.5385475755,
-0.7146984935,
-0.3477810323,
-0.089735195,
-0.4269889891,
-0.578506887,
-0.3611555398,
0.7620049119,
1.1037117243,
0.1696399003,
0.1936932057,
0.2397047132,
0.7367326617,
-0.5745430589,
0.3559764922,
-0.1844376624,
0.1220072433,
0.0473265424,
-0.6157961488,
-0.1993218958,
-0.0051866239,
-0.1606747061,
-1.0538198948,
0.2547609806,
0.2122863382,
0.6524248719,
0.1388431638,
-0.4674349725,
-0.2563126981,
-0.4848507047,
0.9583653212,
-0.4393233657,
0.4756884575,
-0.0310166981,
0.0796902776,
0.0893283859,
-0.5955865383,
-0.1799935848,
-0.0547759086,
-0.3276258409,
0.4194341004,
-0.0054308455,
-0.1826425791,
0.1517341733,
0.211404264,
-0.912617147,
-0.3558545709,
-0.81243819,
-0.1739427596,
0.6876510382,
0.1403226703,
0.2715627253,
-0.0715247691,
-0.1899474263,
-0.0924169347,
-0.6206835508,
-0.2379864901,
0.4077006578,
0.2327223122,
-0.3306546807,
0.5161785483,
-0.7490021586,
0.1763451695,
-0.1367916763,
-0.256408751,
0.5558198094,
-0.5705187917,
-0.0986956581,
0.4676654637,
0.6815694571,
0.3216505647,
0.0674167722,
-0.3918442428,
0.1888733208,
0.0242070295,
-0.0689600259,
-0.6138940454,
0.0723050535,
0.0673885569,
-0.5561037064,
-0.0630777925,
0.2037935257,
-0.5984603167,
0.0187540706,
-0.5407540798,
0.0680837035,
-0.1727973968,
-0.2508073449,
0.3731006682,
-0.1179149672,
-0.2298842221,
0.3303753138,
-0.7696598172,
0.412296325,
0.6906262636,
0.8686760664,
-0.4414310455,
-0.8021505475,
-0.3021186888,
0.5359429121,
-0.1321156621,
0.7568653226,
-0.1408183277,
-0.2401494533,
-0.4765152633,
-0.0339261554,
0.0715593994,
-0.4353556931,
0.2206502706,
-0.1821806133,
0.1159914657,
-0.6169590354,
-0.2220883667,
-0.1744989753,
0.0983506888,
-0.6592886448,
0.9604849815,
-0.2493257225,
-1.1545749903,
0.503403604,
-0.6117463708,
-0.6409395337,
-0.1990741342,
-0.2669989765,
-0.3137076795,
0.114979431,
0.5493039489,
0.390994817,
-0.1685483605,
0.5323410034,
-0.06531661,
-0.3717530072,
-0.1648665667,
-0.1738958806,
0.815120697,
0.2848241925,
0.0200733822,
0.06742201,
-0.6181443334,
-0.2950734496,
-0.0620183237,
-0.3944424987,
-0.4266777933,
-0.1747947633,
0.0478007421,
0.1633016318,
0.1709041744,
-0.6447666883,
-0.0317988805,
-0.0675052553,
-0.0449933223,
-0.0789178833,
-0.0716204867,
0.6130974889,
-0.6274421811,
0.3426559567,
0.3115804195,
0.0309354644,
-0.2987935245,
-0.2239418626,
-0.5844259262,
-0.3870848715,
0.3035516441,
0.536413908,
-0.9754108787,
0.0369861424,
-0.5503638983,
-0.6108943224,
-0.3767443001,
0.3232371211,
0.4065111279,
0.1087154597,
0.6006515622,
-0.3692258894,
-0.7073055506,
-0.7486094832,
-0.7027492523,
0.1174503118,
-0.071779944,
-0.035302978,
0.496445924,
0.105670318,
0.8344534039,
-0.283220619,
-0.023461435,
-0.5729987025,
0.6092255116,
-0.1903402954,
0.3803205192,
0.5645973682,
-1.0274391174,
-0.4536016285,
0.042280104,
-1.0241620541,
-0.2287750542,
-0.2272819281,
0.0967859402,
0.2313012481,
0.7314101458,
-0.662409544,
0.2427799702,
0.5868418217,
0.0515532792,
0.5640300512,
-0.1689282507,
0.3929702342,
-1.1862670183,
0.1541643441,
-0.081966877,
-0.2138526291,
-0.4488562047,
-0.2208717465,
0.0508621894,
-0.1765344143,
-0.8816949725,
0.3241564929,
-0.9368470907,
-0.4945133924,
-0.0032186934,
-0.0500132702,
-0.0524124503,
0.5059142709,
0.4304697216,
0.4230217338,
0.54093045,
-0.5394259095,
0.2226233929,
-0.0200452022,
-0.3331806064,
0.1908564568,
-0.4422447085,
-0.553935349,
-0.454428941,
0.561655581,
-0.7294651866,
-0.4659823179,
-0.0046459688,
-0.5594269037,
0.1667892784,
0.3724810481,
-0.4801676273,
0.0819886327,
-0.360835135,
0.7845090032,
0.0794877484,
-0.3454008996,
0.6962157488,
0.230755046,
-0.6585330367,
-0.7714238167,
-0.8746763468,
0.0661611706,
0.1373329163,
-0.5973124504,
0.3440896571,
0.0664053932,
-0.2965478301,
0.2741514742,
-0.2963493466,
0.2243384421,
-0.1863294244,
0.1972323805,
0.0972871855,
-0.2863980234,
-0.0707660019,
0.5003821254,
-0.1369774193,
0.1023438275,
0.0836828947,
0.1908565164,
-0.0401397496,
-0.4260409176,
-0.2226246148,
0.7369684577,
0.5631176829,
-0.0706711486,
0.4069449902,
0.5722209811,
-0.1610796005,
-0.1864684522,
-0.1443899572,
-0.1996869296,
-0.3277885914,
0.5659694672,
-0.2096214741,
-0.8441036344,
0.4727092087,
-0.2453278005,
0.1899989098,
0.4477771223,
0.5152701139,
0.0031458896,
0.9490696192,
0.6523057222,
0.0677606538,
0.1678699702,
-0.2021548003,
0.1363707781,
-0.2311555594,
-0.412193954,
-0.3140937388,
-0.1047633812,
-0.1903871745,
-0.490999043,
0.5020155311,
-0.1228728741,
0.1646120697,
0.1566713005,
-0.0608184338,
0.6790512204,
0.3813733757,
0.0079153944,
0.6894654036,
0.3509075344,
-0.0735548735,
-0.0510912202,
-1.1858987808,
-0.285043031,
0.7067401409,
0.2716624737,
1.0123645067,
-0.1270306557,
0.9145718813,
0.0474274904,
0.273966223,
-0.5933796763,
0.6002287269,
-0.0946545005,
-0.1614412963,
-0.1140415967,
-0.8567396998,
-0.499410212,
0.4137889147,
-0.2060588747,
-0.0397285186,
0.030662179,
-0.0046110321,
-0.1495816559,
0.3117476702,
-0.4945921004,
0.5996725559,
-0.3853229582,
-0.0577452444,
-0.4471477866,
-0.8776111603,
0.6106497049,
0.0164349508,
0.4588240981,
-0.0214532483,
-0.2221695483,
0.6484228969,
-0.0480045378,
0.9622889757,
0.1966188401,
0.1250134557,
0.0698539317,
-0.0133037651,
-0.1143730059,
0.3605813086,
0.3058731258,
0.6314713955,
-0.039774362,
-0.4784229696,
-0.4053561389,
0.6296721101,
-0.7009311914,
-0.3610658944,
-0.6926926374,
-1.1967567205,
-0.1220405027,
0.0988423005,
0.3017361462,
0.3721859455,
-0.4177046716,
0.1819946617,
0.4856005907,
-0.2855565846,
0.358887732,
0.3967114687,
-0.0389863737,
-0.5030036569,
0.8837980628,
0.094722487,
0.3929065764,
0.5559260845,
-0.0513041504,
0.1092358977,
-0.3137532771,
-0.5136922598,
0.4741206467,
-0.6007038951,
-0.2131506056,
-1.0066268444,
-0.1915055215,
-0.693308413,
-0.3523528278,
-0.2543114424,
-0.6851887703,
-0.2145954072,
0.0778534263,
-0.0557701997,
0.6587514281,
-0.3888530433,
0.1298915595,
-0.9617201686,
0.650123775,
0.0101010259,
0.0212769192,
-0.2355677187,
-0.2338882238,
-0.5770435333,
0.103617616,
-0.0875964835,
-0.6384792924,
0.5813106298,
0.209750846,
0.6187696457,
0.0786998644,
0.0265702438,
0.5335279107,
-0.3432730734,
0.6801053286,
0.38110286,
-0.8990060091,
0.1121802926,
-0.2996691465,
0.6033966541,
0.5055336952,
0.7865873575,
-0.5312364101,
-0.5378668308,
-0.39924106,
-0.7573129535,
0.6985995173,
-0.0729213804,
-0.2285872698,
0.1461811811,
-0.1132840514,
0.3891626298,
0.2507461309,
-0.5733006001,
-0.1123201475,
-0.3603481054,
-0.2654105723,
-0.1368533522,
-0.1754751801,
-0.3455241323,
-0.3136227131,
0.9731900692,
-0.4199554026,
-0.1533226222,
0.2400950342,
-0.3257889152,
-0.1353228986,
0.2505475879,
0.7463356853,
0.7432395816,
0.0606895834,
0.2526873946,
0.5169315934,
-0.5456110239,
-0.213138029,
0.0357708484,
-0.262850076,
0.43804425,
0.6280118823,
0.6423387527,
0.5375184417,
-0.6898662448,
0.4871259332,
-0.143367067,
-0.6664214134,
0.1990695,
-0.2931976914,
0.2773499787,
-0.0140441563,
0.5390794277,
0.1823506504,
0.3999055624,
-0.4858699739,
0.1255375147,
0.1381039917,
0.2342890203,
-0.338894248,
0.3873989284,
0.103026934,
0.3713103235,
-0.2701178789,
-0.241169557,
-0.5057319999,
0.7034429312,
0.5265604258,
0.6461299658,
-0.1459497064,
0.4414498806,
0.4363875985,
0.29142344,
-0.3354578018,
0.4835817516,
-0.2899020612,
-0.2885337472,
-0.6640036106,
-0.5778002143,
-0.6792550087,
-0.5050548911,
-0.6689894199,
0.4705733657,
-0.0788792372,
0.4399121106,
0.1911924481,
-0.0052816006,
-0.1788297743,
0.1432070434,
0.1976665407,
1.0193663836,
-1.2541520596,
0.5451843143,
0.8961315155,
-0.1949022114,
-0.6086574197,
-0.1049255729,
0.1375679821,
-0.3014340401,
0.7866518497,
0.0640076846,
-0.2992098033,
-0.2681666613,
-0.4228571355,
-1.0043680668,
1.1843602657,
0.6743202806,
-0.5613209605,
-0.1444887668,
0.4906180203,
0.4004725218,
-0.5374255776,
0.214358449,
0.1493186951,
0.40714854,
0.1703877449,
-1.1207721233,
-0.0665972903,
-0.1925089061,
-0.2979565263,
0.1176845804,
-0.8202722669,
0.8365474939,
-0.3751373887,
-0.3719484508,
-0.1902915239,
1.0100061893,
0.2117723227,
0.7938555479,
0.3977801204,
0.5127559304,
0.292830497,
-0.0111067817,
0.8695880175,
-0.3636399806,
0.3674814999,
1.1300615072,
-0.123804234,
0.438708961,
0.7196296453,
0.2843802869,
0.3827692866,
0.5316991806,
0.2347184569,
0.5775700808,
-0.0615716986,
-0.1882712096,
-0.188301906,
-0.4154887497,
-0.3783957958,
0.4145915508,
0.460495472,
-0.2648923695,
-0.65905267,
0.1402417272,
0.0992040485,
0.0686778426,
-0.5119760036,
0.7259836197,
0.2995968461,
-0.5964372754,
0.3483802676,
-0.0099367211,
0.675647676,
-0.7063084841,
0.0075741708,
-0.1777219176,
-0.0734021291,
-0.5224460959,
-0.491081059,
0.531021893,
-0.070797354,
-0.1557094008,
-0.241783008,
0.5049020648,
-1.0274825096,
-0.5214891434,
0.3320039213,
0.719024837,
0.3504856527,
0.2756819427,
-0.4937451184,
0.2019842118,
-0.2508981526,
-0.251952678,
0.3009927571,
0.4800602198,
-0.2398171574,
0.3306230307,
0.6602860093,
0.4322783351,
0.1144879758,
0.2465659976,
1.0099394321,
-0.4100344777,
-0.7909173369,
-0.4093305171,
0.1137044653,
-0.1002553478,
-0.2137859315,
0.9655688405,
1.0426849127,
1.1753796339,
-0.2594833672,
0.936999023,
-0.1061498523,
0.4466338754,
-0.5702311993,
0.7101097107,
-0.7458286285,
-0.0113576055,
-0.1673431695,
-0.9923953414,
-0.6733934283,
0.0485824458,
-0.115552634,
0.0756590143,
0.9572741389,
0.8643510342,
-0.5332561135,
0.1533804834,
0.2876212299,
0.0106895799,
-0.2703514397,
0.5562052727,
0.6916478872,
-0.2453133315,
0.6526414752,
-0.3816755116,
-0.1165288091,
-0.1994661689,
-0.9847691655,
-1.0429883003,
-0.3297475576,
-0.3217321336,
0.0498012826,
0.2561112046,
0.8155338168,
0.7005077004,
-0.8364868164,
-0.3271808326,
0.1449475437,
-0.049045451,
-0.50000453,
-0.1811989099,
0.3981311619,
-0.3171234131,
-0.7754219174,
0.4702404141,
0.4873212874,
-0.2503428161,
-0.3470650613,
-0.3268830776,
-0.1435480416,
0.0698560849,
0.3846208751,
0.4030452967,
-0.5687046051,
0.2289915234,
0.0292062629,
-0.3404868245,
-0.0494553223,
1.1172003746,
-0.4964670837,
0.2868662477,
0.9423199892,
0.7516143918,
0.5920542479,
0.0776023865,
0.3960268199,
-0.9842130542,
0.2880861163,
0.0640085191,
0.4855572879,
0.5482196808,
-0.4955877662,
0.3691655099,
0.407764107,
-0.3877405822,
-0.6494809985,
-0.089278169,
-1.2744576931,
-0.4167766571,
1.244612813,
-0.1536493748,
-0.5098126531,
-0.208276853,
-0.1773483902,
0.557444334,
-0.2788977325,
0.55740273,
0.3827113807,
-0.0511952452,
-0.1141101718,
-0.337429136,
0.5008479953,
0.758153975,
-1.0777261257,
0.094599992,
0.4454689324,
0.4333960712,
0.3893450499,
0.3783063591,
-0.236500755,
0.7373725176,
0.1755221784,
0.3038971126,
-0.4781402946,
-0.799263835,
-0.351447165,
0.2244644761,
-0.5943640471,
0.0770773888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01612v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01612v1 | EDeR: A Dataset for Exploring Dependency Relations Between Events | 2023-04-04T08:07:07 | 2023-04-04T08:07:07 | Ruiqi Li, Patrik Haslum, Leyang Cui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relation extraction is a central task in natural language processing (NLP)
and information retrieval (IR) research. We argue that an important type of
relation not explored in NLP or IR research to date is that of an event being
an argument - required or optional - of another event. We introduce the
human-annotated Event Dependency Relation dataset (EDeR) which provides this
dependency relation. The annotation is done on a sample of documents from the
OntoNotes dataset, which has the added benefit that it integrates with
existing, orthogonal, annotations of this dataset. We investigate baseline
approaches for predicting the event dependency relation, the best of which
achieves an accuracy of 82.61 for binary argument/non-argument classification.
We show that recognizing this relation leads to more accurate event extraction
(semantic role labelling) and can improve downstream tasks that depend on this,
such as co-reference resolution. Furthermore, we demonstrate that predicting
the three-way classification into the required argument, optional argument or
non-argument is a more challenging task. | [
-0.600918591,
-0.4057582021,
0.490532279,
-0.3785164356,
-0.0805982202,
-0.5106837153,
-0.1048141643,
-0.9152101874,
0.1981004924,
0.4649755061,
-0.5580962896,
-0.2238266468,
-0.5140880346,
0.2047608644,
0.0095900008,
1.1469929218,
-0.1622545123,
-0.1289450377,
-0.5664304495,
-0.3352668285,
-0.4823998213,
-0.6513307095,
-0.6300262213,
-0.5396575332,
0.9851086736,
0.3909630179,
0.2435669899,
0.7515426874,
0.9009873271,
0.1285591722,
0.069609575,
-0.2198556513,
-0.0361673161,
0.2684925199,
-0.3727628887,
-0.3520516753,
-0.4906728864,
0.4127237797,
0.1424895227,
0.8066692352,
0.1087562963,
0.2941754162,
-0.1131547689,
0.4231247306,
-0.6371632218,
0.4817238152,
-0.6141513586,
-0.0570745394,
-0.5147197843,
-0.3801847994,
-0.3534938097,
0.1367450356,
0.4245171845,
-0.6606015563,
0.3999443352,
0.031085318,
1.0658280849,
0.355915159,
-0.4059730768,
-0.4902385473,
-0.7295947671,
0.5453557372,
-0.2566637993,
0.3523590863,
0.7280244231,
0.0226358045,
-0.2044702321,
-0.9221227765,
-0.4724241197,
0.0753217414,
-0.3836340308,
0.2446543127,
0.0265615955,
0.4780068994,
0.2906202674,
0.1989340335,
-0.1804994941,
0.1325583011,
-0.3932272792,
0.0549863167,
0.5515227318,
0.0417125449,
0.3583427072,
-0.6897086501,
-0.3095405996,
0.1305741668,
-0.5775728822,
0.0234421771,
0.2680904567,
0.3452244103,
0.0966925547,
0.422175318,
0.1755082011,
0.7650607824,
0.1385649443,
0.1926122606,
-0.0123010743,
-0.2703710794,
0.0621730126,
0.3754492104,
0.6923450232,
0.3842665851,
0.2634502053,
-0.3558733165,
0.1849931479,
0.181215629,
-0.0043854993,
-0.6760494113,
-0.3304328024,
0.3743574917,
-0.2341920584,
-0.0588074401,
0.2843084335,
-0.9063361883,
-0.2731198967,
-0.3818787336,
0.0728883296,
-0.1964218467,
-0.13412112,
-0.2985594571,
-0.4622908235,
0.2240458876,
0.2846849263,
-0.8323231339,
0.3237139285,
0.8316094279,
0.5015631914,
-0.0982624441,
-0.1354660243,
-0.8636720181,
0.4374545813,
-0.1669621021,
1.1196137667,
-0.8397691846,
0.0525371395,
-0.1841435283,
-0.1861557961,
0.0389219299,
-0.297111392,
1.074329257,
-0.6186246276,
0.4622963369,
-0.2715531588,
-0.8415166736,
-0.4420939386,
0.0919129625,
-1.0114958286,
0.8748572469,
0.0127665373,
-1.0594877005,
0.7712156177,
-0.7459453344,
-0.3658112884,
0.4517690241,
-0.6521614194,
-0.1140378341,
-0.1216885969,
0.243537724,
0.5212535262,
-0.3013670146,
0.5179508328,
-0.2856522799,
0.0189376064,
-0.1900273263,
0.1296499819,
0.5581338406,
-0.2101916075,
-0.102995716,
-0.2710902095,
-1.2359782457,
-0.4488326907,
-0.1215863302,
-0.296972394,
-0.7847431302,
0.4296216071,
-0.0023306017,
0.3348466158,
0.1322234869,
-0.7142420411,
0.1540873051,
-0.5504631996,
0.1497454494,
0.556148231,
0.3520910442,
0.5730974078,
0.1258477271,
0.3067868352,
-0.023795316,
-0.0341831967,
-0.2532978356,
-0.6140711308,
-0.6182915568,
-0.1317242831,
0.5003421903,
0.5974020362,
-0.5892663598,
0.5654193759,
-0.3306823075,
-0.0156742875,
-0.2411321849,
-0.1593496054,
0.1395401061,
0.626608789,
0.3334796131,
0.0166678205,
-1.2126823664,
-0.7396959662,
-0.2871948779,
-0.8880040646,
-0.0272976384,
0.2697840035,
0.3989513218,
-0.1486822814,
1.2947700024,
-0.3165906966,
-0.7777484655,
-0.1212838143,
0.4221053123,
0.212047413,
0.159394905,
0.4182856083,
-0.8068936467,
-0.2473317683,
0.2580972612,
-0.9125204086,
-0.1821238995,
-0.0082811238,
0.0862616822,
0.1791279167,
0.3394783139,
-0.2543075383,
0.6210263968,
0.3256035745,
-0.4185661674,
-0.0633768439,
0.0141012538,
0.0370723568,
-0.890455544,
0.1393358111,
0.1045188606,
-0.2628211379,
-0.8019991517,
-0.3604688346,
-0.0100169079,
0.2177606672,
-0.0006764109,
0.4798450768,
-0.3381864429,
0.1992696375,
-0.1815605164,
0.2798781097,
0.3028744757,
0.2621047497,
0.3255369663,
0.2095169276,
0.1684384495,
-0.4672181606,
0.385910809,
0.5761308074,
-0.1004590914,
0.5891512036,
-0.3984045982,
0.2196378559,
-0.2366893589,
0.1103679687,
-0.749194324,
-0.3142446876,
0.3735604882,
-0.3945768178,
0.3181234598,
-0.5886851549,
-0.5229461789,
-0.0774385333,
-0.0812634975,
0.0704139546,
0.0481766127,
-0.6370062828,
0.8916137815,
0.5666156411,
-0.4104503393,
-0.6027176976,
-0.5741134882,
0.189269051,
-0.2924208343,
-0.4598561823,
0.3724318743,
0.4275127947,
-0.5132015944,
0.2976462543,
-0.0613705441,
-0.3867568076,
-0.0928930864,
0.6687815785,
0.5096886754,
-0.188200593,
0.4545515776,
-0.291144073,
-0.4382147789,
0.0970940441,
0.1870630085,
-0.0885348618,
0.1347882748,
-0.2014413327,
-0.3898926973,
0.6237552166,
0.1136929914,
-0.004779004,
0.5618106127,
0.2335128635,
-0.6504843831,
0.3789891899,
-0.7852871418,
-0.1912033111,
-0.357627213,
0.3048028648,
-0.4871795774,
-0.6213858128,
0.5875009894,
0.2203928381,
0.3522833884,
0.7888627052,
-0.1069160327,
-0.2114244103,
0.6340031624,
0.4923766851,
-0.018673934,
0.4810239077,
0.0826424807,
0.0952931941,
-0.8219637275,
-0.1534163803,
-0.6710361838,
-0.1736476421,
-0.4660694897,
-0.0916605666,
0.0065587708,
0.2799294591,
0.1424699277,
0.3797880709,
-0.215835914,
0.3708606958,
0.2125551105,
-0.2262563854,
0.5365586877,
-0.1264456511,
0.2753638923,
-0.2661814392,
-0.6556124687,
-0.5644040108,
0.769164443,
0.1420378983,
0.3282343745,
-0.0992409736,
0.8330794573,
0.1525114179,
0.4993151128,
-0.7558653951,
0.2486453503,
0.0333628431,
-0.9476224184,
-0.2777306139,
-0.4402255416,
-1.1497462988,
0.1056810096,
-0.0938243195,
-1.1006882191,
0.523229599,
-0.0000050529,
-0.3386945724,
0.1856304705,
-0.5910298228,
0.6229863763,
-0.0214776043,
-0.2874525189,
0.0094400337,
-0.8204421401,
-0.0453813747,
0.1363640428,
0.2970031798,
-0.1959475577,
0.0115647214,
1.3972547054,
-0.0030021928,
0.6288337111,
-0.0541570634,
0.1511814594,
0.3975007832,
-0.0098024607,
0.7011246681,
0.0208351389,
-0.4499968588,
-0.0218184609,
0.1731217951,
-0.0427472256,
-0.5182675123,
0.4855588973,
-0.5886364579,
-0.6252102256,
-0.6255821586,
-0.4289316237,
-0.0892232805,
-0.0856908858,
0.2374066561,
0.6270197034,
-0.2921422124,
-0.0582872853,
0.2850741446,
0.2238629162,
0.7732462883,
0.4463870525,
-0.0702243671,
-0.5328071117,
0.660353899,
0.4957792759,
-0.1956014931,
0.4384505451,
0.1193636656,
-0.2268580198,
-0.2492786199,
-0.495701611,
0.2344945669,
-0.952391386,
-0.2211553305,
-1.0821522474,
0.0214234665,
-0.1916409731,
-0.1849501282,
-0.3658962846,
-0.6433821321,
-0.5905585885,
-0.5644569993,
0.7270745039,
1.0598888397,
-0.1906776428,
-0.1418708861,
-0.8761615157,
0.2556079328,
0.0884148479,
0.4709627628,
-0.1651087105,
-0.2779034674,
-0.1849542409,
-0.5665357709,
-0.2014695853,
-1.012578845,
0.0369390994,
0.5041422248,
0.7030385137,
0.5901236534,
0.3690348566,
0.7110528946,
-0.4501841068,
0.690156579,
0.2884533405,
-0.6332902908,
0.8169192076,
-0.2236947715,
-0.4147453606,
0.7922974229,
0.4583846927,
-0.4926016629,
-0.1173094064,
-1.1031776667,
-1.0038945675,
1.0506225824,
0.2171754539,
-0.3936394751,
-0.1415176392,
0.4923563302,
0.2120340765,
-0.1408257484,
-0.725718379,
-0.4007677138,
0.4040190279,
-0.091809608,
-0.0615898371,
-0.4179187417,
-0.0655755028,
-0.2497213632,
0.3978566825,
0.229955852,
-0.0258554202,
0.5289314985,
-0.1188281327,
-0.3941809535,
0.2237375677,
-0.0211448055,
0.7838539481,
-0.5936900377,
0.4855743945,
0.1841066331,
-0.3346293271,
0.0520621501,
0.5134077072,
0.084359698,
0.3200096488,
0.7099315524,
0.5897418261,
0.0326362029,
-0.3356599212,
0.5307884812,
-0.0667269304,
-0.0454940014,
-0.358207792,
-0.2927075326,
0.0193706732,
0.0802542642,
0.3740650117,
-0.1313895583,
0.3904980123,
-0.4190807045,
0.5216892362,
0.0451357663,
-1.0246404409,
-0.4262941182,
0.5180686116,
0.5689470768,
-0.3002756238,
0.4710460305,
-0.0819781497,
-0.4219167829,
0.5918497443,
0.1696415097,
0.720825851,
-0.0565550439,
0.036339879,
0.5410155058,
0.2659445107,
0.2008928359,
0.0953461677,
0.0803992897,
-0.5967270732,
-0.5623950362,
-0.448770076,
-0.3486887813,
0.1754298955,
-0.9275987148,
0.5393556952,
-0.0841405839,
-0.1161004528,
0.4142486453,
0.0340391621,
-0.6558021903,
-0.0095702279,
0.176750496,
0.491345644,
-0.8217524886,
0.6114216447,
0.7879900932,
-0.564566195,
-0.5405745506,
-0.0526329875,
-0.2666901648,
0.0380665772,
0.8539771438,
0.2877346575,
0.18889907,
-0.0242630895,
0.0193873774,
-0.7322647572,
0.7435415387,
0.1867197603,
-0.5694721341,
0.0709118173,
0.0621287152,
0.4199465811,
-0.4702109694,
0.4095502496,
0.612103641,
0.5157464743,
0.0015164417,
-0.6993668079,
0.1279830486,
-0.1642408669,
-0.17851758,
0.5411344767,
-0.0644776598,
0.48844558,
-0.0932858586,
-0.5068321824,
-0.4425269067,
0.7933322191,
-0.1672402471,
0.6491314173,
0.5713484883,
0.3998340666,
0.7017790675,
-0.0155453393,
1.0891637802,
0.0878224596,
0.2584829032,
1.4979088306,
-0.5352129936,
0.9295837283,
0.8353985548,
-0.1168831885,
0.5045800209,
0.6504694223,
0.2187677473,
0.4300480187,
-0.1385882199,
-0.2363432795,
-0.2778816223,
-0.3337987065,
-0.2347353399,
0.3056241274,
0.5627627373,
-0.4778490961,
-0.4330978692,
-0.1434102058,
-0.0965446606,
-0.0869467854,
-0.0954491049,
1.1223856211,
0.0958269686,
-0.8567320704,
0.0538943075,
-0.3538534343,
0.2968867123,
-0.3243468106,
-0.3488943875,
0.1740829796,
0.0484458543,
-0.3742312789,
-0.8153469563,
0.3757424355,
0.093481198,
-0.5515310764,
0.2146723568,
0.96451056,
-0.2428939342,
-0.3440951109,
0.7597411871,
0.5834361315,
0.0948463753,
0.1176478639,
-0.1641077399,
-0.2706819177,
-0.1309078485,
-0.60189569,
0.2693246305,
0.5561148524,
-0.0731382146,
0.2107048333,
0.4181158245,
0.0870291144,
0.0686833635,
0.0952628776,
0.7861580253,
-0.5708530545,
-0.2569915354,
-0.9752025604,
0.4396664202,
-0.2384271026,
-0.2156923711,
0.3711287379,
0.4709573388,
0.5098108649,
0.2810851336,
1.0130804777,
-0.3700566292,
0.5361940861,
-0.1107253209,
0.115886353,
-0.2372733355,
0.1210028157,
-0.2132138759,
-0.6167559028,
-0.5505494475,
0.554227829,
-0.4629968405,
-0.3205479383,
0.7874885201,
0.5025943518,
-0.0280833729,
0.3876053989,
0.1680881679,
-0.2662189603,
0.3760014772,
0.4528996646,
1.0843024254,
-0.6359957457,
0.6400328875,
-0.2904365063,
-0.391471982,
-0.1790112704,
-1.1062817574,
-1.0451456308,
-0.8169315457,
-0.6872969866,
-0.2277501523,
0.0585013032,
1.2547432184,
0.3524978161,
-0.8328935504,
-0.0492614731,
-0.1510758996,
0.1385591924,
-0.0853401497,
-0.1876337081,
0.4276100397,
-0.362528652,
-0.6319400668,
0.0874419734,
0.4328619242,
-0.1190434769,
0.3524551988,
0.1878546327,
-0.6129615903,
-0.066974178,
0.4187019467,
0.2143303305,
-0.6719213128,
-0.6333327293,
-0.4516400397,
0.1031348333,
0.3567120135,
0.8013945818,
-0.6040424109,
0.4563349783,
0.6709014773,
0.4370371997,
0.4563305378,
-0.1009700447,
0.7479807734,
-0.9032155871,
0.1810149103,
0.2611088753,
0.4591337144,
0.2506458163,
-0.6424843073,
0.8582580686,
0.1559391916,
-0.5971016884,
-0.7008714676,
0.239121601,
-1.1540449858,
0.0724530295,
1.1618427038,
-0.3268432617,
-0.1229784936,
-0.8293684125,
-0.1627360135,
0.5089513659,
-0.3352023065,
0.5312299728,
0.753031075,
-0.4811087549,
-0.3260233998,
-0.6251603365,
0.5098854303,
-0.0686793923,
-0.6329646707,
0.2710147798,
0.4047992229,
-0.1251931936,
0.5673893094,
0.5394338369,
0.011303368,
0.0092368089,
-0.0337880477,
0.5757277608,
0.0412690826,
-0.3378262818,
0.0558580048,
0.3407954276,
-0.0013925355,
-0.335429579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01597v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01597v1 | Unsupervised Improvement of Factual Knowledge in Language Models | 2023-04-04T07:37:06 | 2023-04-04T07:37:06 | Nafis Sadeq, Byungkyu Kang, Prarit Lamba, Julian McAuley | cs.CL | cs.CL | Masked language modeling (MLM) plays a key role in pretraining large language
models. But the MLM objective is often dominated by high-frequency words that
are sub-optimal for learning factual knowledge. In this work, we propose an
approach for influencing MLM pretraining in a way that can improve language
model performance on a variety of knowledge-intensive tasks. We force the
language model to prioritize informative words in a fully unsupervised way.
Experiments demonstrate that the proposed approach can significantly improve
the performance of pretrained language models on tasks such as factual recall,
question answering, sentiment analysis, and natural language inference in a
closed-book setting. | [
-0.2759876549,
-0.6263873577,
0.3733284175,
0.0978463739,
-0.2940641344,
0.1755731553,
-0.5387948751,
-0.2596295476,
0.1222114339,
0.9083297849,
-0.2838704586,
-0.5868971348,
-0.7033655643,
-0.2289130837,
-0.2206018418,
1.0375899076,
0.0577004068,
0.1849074215,
-0.6075104475,
-0.0975071266,
-0.3417334855,
-0.8529150486,
-0.2794994712,
-0.5944387317,
0.3081453741,
0.1503501236,
0.5330531597,
0.5601561069,
0.429137975,
0.3813922405,
0.1123442277,
0.2463927716,
-0.6525247693,
0.0907433629,
-0.2485771477,
-0.7460609674,
-0.2871043682,
0.2013762146,
0.6774358749,
1.0969744921,
-0.2496522963,
0.2192236781,
0.1443214118,
0.7978691459,
-0.9340159893,
0.2950327694,
-0.7527849674,
-0.0200813357,
-0.0904885903,
-0.4551663399,
-0.3984922469,
-0.2138877809,
0.2628061771,
-0.6775630116,
0.4454353154,
0.2216190547,
0.6608763337,
0.3364928961,
-0.2093301862,
0.0988630205,
-1.0852303505,
0.7872706652,
-0.5514213443,
0.6386852264,
0.5091364384,
-0.1317379028,
-0.1388155073,
-0.5820738077,
-0.4143687785,
-0.3220801055,
-0.3024504185,
0.1409779787,
-0.1582050771,
0.3284347951,
0.4798592031,
0.2451955229,
-0.3533633351,
0.0156685971,
-0.2324361652,
-0.3014340401,
0.5198065042,
-0.132921055,
0.2049273551,
0.3863182366,
-0.2366294563,
0.0222909581,
-0.7997863889,
0.1993430406,
0.3051261306,
0.2165870667,
0.3522285223,
0.622322917,
-0.6166936159,
0.8408963084,
-0.0410621986,
-0.166689679,
0.2688805461,
-0.1891289949,
-0.3976821899,
0.2431519479,
0.2389599681,
0.2379567027,
0.3240602911,
-0.3236837983,
-0.4327332675,
0.0539804362,
0.3874452114,
-0.9344508648,
-0.4167125821,
0.0059520598,
-0.2917355299,
-0.2636963725,
0.1504379213,
-0.4821518064,
-0.5131840706,
-0.6106161475,
0.7366302013,
-0.0189108457,
-0.4013961554,
0.3034439981,
-0.0756007582,
-0.3434719145,
0.2885677218,
-0.7460457683,
0.2725515068,
0.520270884,
0.4466519952,
0.0282662902,
0.0456232801,
-0.632162571,
0.3122238517,
-0.5331590176,
0.572501719,
-0.6623088121,
-0.0603248253,
0.1611564904,
-0.080545187,
-0.3064428568,
-0.6629810333,
0.243084982,
-0.8018275499,
0.3916023672,
-0.3197574914,
-0.7048146129,
-0.4084002674,
0.2168524712,
-0.4887019992,
1.0777057409,
-0.1322633028,
-0.8914064169,
0.4270155728,
-0.7406036854,
-0.4959415495,
0.0938859805,
0.039377775,
-0.401478678,
0.1974634826,
0.2809633315,
0.6298877597,
0.0069363695,
0.5488154888,
-0.025954932,
-0.3662008047,
0.2709409893,
-0.1359980702,
0.3656537533,
-0.0706666335,
-0.487041086,
0.2718538642,
-0.8182798624,
-0.1885067225,
-0.056189131,
-0.3539727032,
-0.6206077337,
-0.019346958,
-0.2675309777,
0.0043457942,
0.2875548303,
-0.480042249,
-0.2475001514,
-0.7227701545,
-0.2415182143,
0.6964845061,
-0.075676769,
0.624068737,
-0.2550681531,
0.4596855938,
0.2581789494,
0.0381914638,
0.0063963621,
-0.3010287881,
-1.3152829409,
-0.3472417295,
0.5742154717,
0.7104614973,
-0.7827060819,
0.5040111542,
-0.0611503832,
-0.2674961686,
-0.547870934,
0.485830158,
0.6754220724,
0.5961403251,
0.406429708,
-0.5020082593,
-0.5920746326,
-0.7751218677,
-0.3924383223,
0.0599445216,
-0.0455095097,
0.0458486974,
0.1732405424,
-0.3086357117,
0.863912046,
-0.6779181957,
-0.3163382411,
-0.2744737566,
0.2783937156,
0.1892397702,
0.4565471113,
0.3203936517,
-0.77091223,
-0.418517381,
-0.118957445,
-0.4626299143,
-0.1140890718,
0.1717900634,
-0.3422910273,
0.1896501482,
0.6767863631,
-0.5881530046,
0.4929884374,
0.1981688291,
-0.1406984478,
0.4161198735,
-0.3537586033,
-0.0604115911,
-0.8423472047,
0.0435544625,
-0.12309587,
-0.4226318002,
-0.9452311397,
-0.2103174478,
-0.1415507644,
0.0397173911,
-0.2547588348,
0.4576396942,
-0.5469105244,
0.0718679801,
-0.3824155331,
0.0469649062,
-0.106217131,
0.6293093562,
0.3897728324,
0.5857789516,
0.8305829167,
-0.8021876812,
0.2302319407,
-0.0726771727,
-0.7821067572,
-0.0223658085,
-0.4178913534,
-0.0178631693,
-0.4713769555,
-0.0944845304,
-0.7880968451,
-0.00599398,
0.0605357476,
-0.1913922876,
0.7034016252,
0.030195782,
-0.2335026562,
-0.117927663,
-0.0033384771,
0.0944772139,
0.4339667559,
-0.5211778879,
0.5730134249,
0.4608634114,
-0.0767532587,
-0.8570328355,
-0.1197532192,
-0.1207986251,
-0.1006992906,
-0.2768170834,
0.2527000606,
-0.0210741051,
-0.3775531352,
-0.0262762215,
-0.2829523087,
-0.0119758956,
0.1901176572,
0.2567577958,
0.253013283,
-0.3359946311,
0.3898217976,
-0.2521439493,
-0.1345216334,
0.0441657528,
-0.6964329481,
0.5570161343,
-0.072903879,
-0.1653315723,
-0.1239220127,
0.1676330119,
0.1442280263,
-0.614405036,
1.0440359116,
0.7198151946,
-0.4075215161,
-0.3710687459,
-0.924331367,
-0.3172482252,
-0.484418273,
0.5726371408,
-0.1524806619,
-1.170088768,
0.1821943521,
-0.224425897,
-0.0672216639,
0.1957979947,
0.5924878716,
-0.2209453136,
1.0291107893,
1.108014822,
-0.2157538384,
0.6608173847,
-0.1176862791,
0.297737956,
-0.3588146269,
-0.3361898661,
-0.3564073741,
0.0147533072,
-0.4426007271,
-0.6266899705,
0.2625319064,
0.3220421672,
-0.169654578,
0.0782341957,
-0.1485577077,
0.5239126086,
0.8286553621,
0.323775351,
0.3350888789,
0.2319086045,
-0.332742095,
0.1580436528,
-0.9600751996,
-0.4968184531,
1.1489590406,
0.2837432623,
0.5804612637,
-0.1042928919,
0.3479698002,
0.109813489,
0.5276225805,
-0.454705745,
0.4447314739,
-0.091741018,
-0.7537648082,
-0.5018178225,
-0.4107654989,
-0.7560365796,
0.2387203574,
-0.5110590458,
-0.6066865325,
0.129850015,
0.419819355,
-0.3492040336,
0.2162370384,
-0.6068848372,
0.856246829,
-0.1709355861,
-0.126178965,
-0.2307118922,
-0.5268759727,
0.3272316158,
-0.2853922248,
0.2222435176,
-0.0413827039,
0.1735049039,
1.0036423206,
-0.4184550345,
0.9990431666,
-0.3024576306,
0.1450808644,
0.0807120353,
-0.0456400178,
0.5399128795,
-0.1814459562,
0.101975821,
0.1486531198,
-0.2504680753,
-0.5029540062,
-0.8351563215,
0.2397514731,
-0.6967432499,
-0.941506803,
-0.2329832315,
-0.5500442386,
-0.6627524495,
0.2392015159,
0.338185966,
0.5242647529,
-0.275996387,
0.243979454,
1.1444590092,
-0.1506582052,
0.3646868169,
0.8226214051,
-0.2338197678,
-0.0061389194,
0.8349064589,
0.1334766895,
0.3535037637,
0.7479611039,
0.1823829859,
-0.5369964242,
-0.8173289299,
-0.1253393888,
0.097353451,
-0.7495180964,
0.008539808,
-1.0159600973,
-0.2574674487,
-0.5362122059,
0.1217941716,
-0.3372093737,
-0.3870922625,
-0.2404485643,
-0.3749382198,
0.2527629137,
0.6191251874,
-0.0010783641,
0.4018622041,
-0.5139685869,
0.2381236702,
0.5652814507,
0.4370091259,
-0.1822884381,
-0.7033396959,
-0.5539693832,
0.0718099177,
0.1157431006,
-0.3807932138,
0.2093823999,
0.2747204304,
0.8792876005,
0.6689144969,
0.231652528,
0.5517728925,
-0.5196778774,
0.3339505792,
0.3696260452,
-0.8181648254,
0.5200089812,
-0.1380289495,
0.1559106857,
0.5663883686,
0.5414908528,
-0.3396805525,
-0.5541428924,
-0.4758768976,
-0.5662123561,
0.6571691632,
0.2720045745,
0.2242513597,
0.3363751769,
0.0525453463,
-0.0567953624,
0.6433805823,
-0.6740472913,
-0.2460894436,
-0.3668718934,
-0.0571158044,
-0.5463443995,
-0.5378235579,
-0.2579618096,
-0.4456659555,
0.9571290016,
-0.030326562,
0.0736815706,
0.0526727103,
-0.3969514966,
-0.1802511513,
0.1822389066,
0.6641863585,
0.9701344371,
-0.3589051664,
0.4489044845,
0.1393676102,
-0.5878364444,
-0.0476184972,
0.0313465968,
-0.3445187211,
0.0419956893,
0.5081910491,
1.1577566862,
0.1975230724,
-0.5358660221,
0.5726392865,
0.1643701196,
0.0292987209,
-0.0774378702,
0.3435869515,
0.0707707107,
0.2187786251,
0.2048130333,
0.2395175397,
-0.120829612,
-0.5642749071,
0.3391918242,
0.5709096789,
-0.5335105658,
-0.0753746182,
0.4716766477,
0.2062742263,
-0.1639350951,
0.4878515005,
-0.0282982774,
-0.9924946427,
0.3463434577,
0.6163098812,
0.5885112286,
-0.573903203,
0.3055571914,
0.2054675519,
0.5210811496,
-0.2146548778,
0.1050718129,
-0.1741526872,
-1.2255142927,
-0.4033320844,
-0.9987229705,
-0.13414675,
0.2434469014,
-0.4870271981,
0.0900477841,
-0.3710172176,
0.0078782169,
-0.0696072653,
0.1850450039,
-0.8554651737,
0.7219234109,
0.0457705185,
0.5714299083,
-0.7983452082,
1.0614680052,
0.7053940892,
-0.1667917818,
-0.7252867222,
-0.0257110726,
-0.4109174311,
-0.8410878181,
0.7479079962,
0.1051554978,
-0.2131861299,
0.1062218919,
-0.4744648039,
-0.8940034509,
0.6676813364,
0.3306224942,
-0.6234263182,
0.376432091,
0.4282851517,
0.506347239,
-0.5951608419,
0.191150859,
0.4061976969,
0.4064244032,
0.1029616743,
-0.7654889822,
-0.0066208029,
-0.244671315,
0.0685096532,
0.1138002202,
-0.197166428,
0.529209435,
-0.2026282102,
-0.1579597741,
-0.3692904115,
0.8126943707,
-0.1187889352,
0.2952679396,
0.7422352433,
0.4973064661,
1.1389778852,
0.1150651723,
0.8219107985,
-0.3388849497,
0.1554147005,
1.13197577,
-0.2168416977,
0.6324276924,
0.1214197204,
-0.0292982142,
0.2298092842,
0.7249920368,
0.1588484347,
0.680414319,
0.2944527268,
-0.5206665397,
-0.8061757684,
-0.3654740155,
-0.4451186359,
0.5461421609,
0.1448151022,
-0.3045613766,
0.0411203988,
0.1788741797,
0.1671641916,
0.1892894208,
-0.4696113765,
0.7592198849,
-0.0601236559,
-0.60415411,
0.5123422742,
0.1964849532,
0.6015611291,
-0.5375487804,
0.046990823,
-0.2484991997,
0.1463478506,
-0.108931236,
-0.1761312038,
0.1973373741,
-0.1089404598,
-0.4999990165,
-0.314165175,
1.0648847818,
-0.9111572504,
-0.8079263568,
0.2782230377,
0.4769902527,
0.0801915824,
-0.5987144113,
-0.4164774418,
-0.400254637,
-0.0752501115,
-0.2698299289,
0.3323963583,
0.2981404364,
-0.1620356888,
0.6441931725,
0.8993287683,
0.1314943135,
0.2499984503,
0.2195477635,
0.9978809357,
-0.5453616977,
-0.5537537336,
-0.723942697,
0.3378468752,
-0.1765369177,
0.1514441371,
0.8547616601,
0.652377367,
1.0541434288,
-0.2562527657,
0.6861613989,
0.4119757712,
0.7200691104,
-0.7057621479,
1.0247263908,
-0.4634923041,
0.2641448379,
-0.3067038059,
-1.0969027281,
-0.2840825617,
0.4217472076,
-0.3013924956,
-0.0080920402,
0.5822977424,
1.0732649565,
0.1126394346,
-0.0864110664,
0.6915816665,
0.3787809908,
-0.1279925704,
0.156397745,
0.8512479663,
0.0401327647,
0.199401632,
-0.5375761986,
-0.4543125331,
-0.0339682028,
-0.8974090815,
-1.4306093454,
-0.5981724262,
-0.4536502361,
-0.1700555682,
0.1290452033,
0.8601826429,
0.9380056262,
-1.0023895502,
-0.2122102678,
0.1971710771,
0.321939826,
-0.0870525762,
-0.1434276402,
0.2657686472,
-0.5032493472,
-0.4090708494,
0.5184583068,
0.3087601662,
-0.1548099518,
-0.1245431677,
0.0643179789,
-0.1785233617,
0.2361563444,
0.7902217507,
-0.0562855043,
-0.4229282439,
-0.2090286762,
-0.0661447197,
0.1754879802,
-0.0256220941,
1.1891577244,
-0.7531691194,
0.6041945815,
0.2485026717,
0.6550451517,
0.6449207067,
0.1199145466,
0.7182403207,
-0.9756377935,
0.3180642426,
0.1645922959,
0.2087385207,
0.2928102612,
-0.5571711063,
0.3129471242,
0.6166765094,
-0.1534023732,
-0.7211905122,
0.0448371656,
-0.576399982,
-0.4299434125,
1.1065500975,
-0.2211456746,
-0.0663666576,
-0.4668703675,
0.1358542293,
0.5324320793,
-0.0210014954,
0.7663139105,
0.6912084818,
0.1769054681,
-0.1113411114,
-0.5237239003,
0.843675375,
0.5529200435,
-0.6841074824,
-0.0054390007,
0.316799134,
0.406825006,
0.091541186,
0.7991648316,
0.1868323833,
-0.1293515265,
-0.362205863,
0.2437542975,
-0.259224236,
-0.7484212518,
-0.0063985796,
0.1135917008,
-0.0434108302,
-0.2727745473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01563v1 | Attribute-Consistent Knowledge Graph Representation Learning for Multi-Modal Entity Alignment | 2023-04-04T06:39:36 | 2023-04-04T06:39:36 | Qian Li, Shu Guo, Yangyifei Luo, Cheng Ji, Lihong Wang, Jiawei Sheng, Jianxin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The multi-modal entity alignment (MMEA) aims to find all equivalent entity
pairs between multi-modal knowledge graphs (MMKGs). Rich attributes and
neighboring entities are valuable for the alignment task, but existing works
ignore contextual gap problems that the aligned entities have different numbers
of attributes on specific modality when learning entity representations. In
this paper, we propose a novel attribute-consistent knowledge graph
representation learning framework for MMEA (ACK-MMEA) to compensate the
contextual gaps through incorporating consistent alignment knowledge.
Attribute-consistent KGs (ACKGs) are first constructed via multi-modal
attribute uniformization with merge and generate operators so that each entity
has one and only one uniform feature in each modality. The ACKGs are then fed
into a relation-aware graph neural network with random dropouts, to obtain
aggregated relation representations and robust entity representations. In order
to evaluate the ACK-MMEA facilitated for entity alignment, we specially design
a joint alignment loss for both entity and attribute evaluation. Extensive
experiments conducted on two benchmark datasets show that our approach achieves
excellent performance compared to its competitors. | [
-0.3835940957,
-0.4333268404,
0.4718031585,
-0.0049741953,
0.051655896,
0.0965004712,
-0.0890137106,
-0.4344864786,
0.2900063396,
0.0152820777,
-0.7804282308,
-0.4547662437,
-0.4108998477,
-0.023017941,
0.2438370287,
0.645858407,
-0.1660896838,
0.1103587151,
-0.435049504,
-0.611004293,
-0.7952356339,
0.0207277201,
-0.62265414,
-0.4802580178,
0.8056748509,
0.3322065175,
0.7004184723,
0.7271863818,
0.1648817062,
0.2788280249,
0.387753278,
0.7452749014,
-0.3520293832,
0.1034054384,
-0.002371443,
-0.0313247181,
-0.6153134704,
0.0202542245,
0.7387536168,
0.8834140301,
-0.3925807476,
0.0314671658,
0.104561083,
0.3318199813,
-0.7046630383,
0.4629876018,
-0.7715457678,
0.067983143,
-0.0957690105,
0.1203180626,
-0.684548378,
-0.0670785457,
0.0010030165,
-1.1720331907,
-0.1558422148,
0.2657898366,
1.078245759,
0.2611229718,
-0.9519571066,
0.0022161573,
-0.2703527808,
0.7793004513,
-0.3372340798,
1.1337451935,
0.1598979235,
0.3732717037,
-0.014756198,
-0.4411007762,
-0.6959100962,
-0.127976045,
-0.3250565231,
0.0970323831,
0.1807719171,
-0.0724882409,
-0.2239975482,
0.0419345796,
-0.4585843384,
0.1585322022,
0.2970896661,
-0.4727342129,
0.3391065896,
0.159269765,
0.1293869913,
-0.2692238092,
-0.7444906831,
-0.2163650095,
-0.7305974364,
0.0259408057,
0.3317412436,
0.1735255271,
-0.0331318788,
0.2087919414,
-0.0391732529,
0.6650009751,
0.1715257615,
-0.4005013704,
0.420352906,
-0.2003190964,
-0.3557347655,
-0.1563835442,
0.920342505,
0.2488598078,
-0.2030681968,
-0.6519519091,
-0.0731653646,
-0.1560482979,
0.2047722489,
-0.5610195994,
-0.1818121523,
-0.1765702665,
-0.3353684843,
-0.2852993906,
0.1319392622,
-0.3759206831,
-0.2894958258,
-0.3449401259,
0.2952059805,
-0.772495091,
-0.1699016839,
-0.4008429348,
0.2158491015,
0.0612092689,
0.4279037118,
-0.7734981179,
0.0630173534,
0.35928756,
0.5913717747,
-0.1312684268,
-0.5012415648,
-0.3281440437,
0.8776032925,
-0.2434509397,
0.5091882944,
-0.4995416403,
0.0655267164,
-0.2658054233,
-0.0448873453,
-0.3883448541,
-0.3095988035,
0.212828204,
-0.7927027941,
-0.1169144958,
-0.3146985471,
-0.6481903195,
-0.4905523062,
0.4527454972,
-0.8844989538,
0.8357093334,
0.2772042751,
-0.4803554416,
0.7750185132,
-0.4079166651,
-0.210184902,
-0.1509910822,
-0.4229995012,
-0.7682331204,
-0.2995194197,
0.3655982018,
0.4568031728,
0.0291494727,
0.049786292,
-0.5647912621,
-0.0052045225,
0.2431101948,
-0.3593702316,
0.551913321,
0.0503018722,
-0.0674953088,
-0.0553866029,
-0.9781649709,
0.0957371444,
0.012697679,
-0.1754278541,
-0.3948295414,
0.0078342017,
-0.0834124088,
0.2672557831,
0.2351012379,
-0.4792722464,
0.3482275605,
0.0638038144,
-0.1475351304,
1.0541459322,
0.0030745924,
0.7889128327,
-0.1738142818,
0.1156826988,
0.5398187041,
-0.098311536,
-0.1310734004,
-0.2578905821,
-0.3224676549,
-0.5246914029,
0.4808630943,
0.3038829565,
-0.9201415181,
0.509134531,
-0.4534293711,
-0.3277459443,
-0.4174815714,
0.292581141,
0.2649536431,
0.9755257368,
0.3489292264,
-0.5385287404,
-0.3420341611,
-0.7630819678,
0.0073244465,
-0.0493941233,
0.0124421408,
0.6977162957,
0.0976926088,
-0.2769509852,
0.8596838713,
-0.4720135629,
-0.6695230603,
0.195603475,
0.2361885905,
-0.2839268446,
0.6600236297,
0.7314913869,
-0.7389407754,
-0.5510257483,
0.2943852246,
-0.7500584126,
0.1165862158,
-0.2489259392,
-0.3706445694,
0.0403614901,
0.13911134,
-0.6216412187,
0.0134107759,
0.4002097249,
-0.4691265821,
0.296926707,
0.1824166924,
0.3277869821,
-1.3185731173,
0.0675591305,
0.0903744102,
-0.5790797472,
-0.2518284619,
-0.1191952899,
0.3399854898,
-0.0723150596,
-0.1216782257,
0.3016601205,
-0.5172970891,
0.0960074887,
0.2314371765,
0.1261021346,
0.2289724648,
0.6571150422,
-0.2051068097,
0.5620447993,
0.5435961485,
-0.5590869188,
0.4199550748,
0.4451823831,
0.1356214583,
1.0768549442,
-0.0624184571,
0.2284431905,
-0.1640017033,
0.3126702905,
-0.6983204484,
-0.3032588065,
0.2629344761,
-0.3624024093,
0.6409660578,
-0.2220555693,
-0.313765794,
0.0233928654,
-0.1770361215,
0.5533465743,
-0.0790914446,
-0.394708097,
1.0268268585,
0.1340651065,
0.3501573503,
-0.9419763684,
-0.4366176724,
-0.1628062874,
0.0897213519,
-0.8857782483,
0.6248787642,
0.1543964446,
0.394697696,
0.4889162481,
-0.4426445961,
-0.1735276729,
0.0785838515,
0.1509082764,
0.2889914811,
-0.3782075942,
0.4059251845,
-0.0134248538,
-0.0693921,
-0.2046783864,
-0.2260633558,
0.5290759206,
0.0932240337,
-0.5513213873,
-0.500372231,
0.3254461884,
0.4054947495,
-0.314932853,
1.0646859407,
0.8008956313,
-0.5214649439,
-0.0498970151,
-0.5041155815,
-0.1219745651,
-0.4264692962,
0.4938131869,
-0.5414122939,
-0.6675117016,
0.8062480688,
-0.2353075147,
-0.0150760142,
0.4991063178,
0.120222941,
-0.1443593055,
1.0880551338,
0.652631402,
-0.1511363387,
0.481274277,
-0.3466489315,
0.2618689835,
-0.948456645,
-0.6242167354,
-0.0866891369,
-0.4713864923,
-0.4236315787,
-0.1708635688,
0.3830358088,
0.2689330876,
-0.3837487996,
0.294369638,
-0.2167938501,
0.3946613669,
0.2880789638,
0.2967269421,
0.2444052845,
-0.0617541149,
-0.3191008568,
-0.212099269,
-0.547175467,
-0.2057035267,
0.9648125172,
0.193450883,
0.7381228805,
0.2926011384,
0.8191762567,
0.0714251846,
0.4293162525,
-0.7764664888,
0.2265642732,
0.1064409763,
-0.3052259684,
-0.3814990222,
-0.8805759549,
-0.7283481956,
0.1728970855,
-0.441157341,
-0.8183746934,
0.2976858914,
0.2280297577,
-0.0896809995,
0.4575617909,
-0.7080072165,
1.1370338202,
0.1133876145,
-0.1302698404,
-0.0423678495,
-0.6218245625,
0.213172704,
0.1952747405,
-0.0554585271,
-0.1711896807,
-0.0940189883,
0.4918431938,
-0.3251000941,
0.5233480334,
-0.2607227266,
0.1155246124,
0.0620854534,
0.1600391865,
0.6454486847,
0.256973505,
0.1590296924,
-0.0450682156,
-0.3128503263,
-0.395032227,
-0.9961513281,
0.7848489881,
-0.8019233346,
-0.0661848709,
-0.2190229446,
-0.8351697922,
-0.5095992684,
0.4413144588,
-0.1348403543,
0.4223117828,
-0.2315211147,
0.1878795326,
0.71623981,
0.2499032319,
0.3163225651,
0.360327363,
0.2080526054,
-0.7806518078,
1.1160956621,
0.3277924657,
0.1485988498,
0.2746805847,
-0.2081917822,
-0.3431126773,
-0.1096682101,
-0.8371969461,
0.1569828689,
-0.7380533814,
-0.7238774896,
-0.540115118,
-0.0355452336,
-0.5375056863,
-0.0910026208,
-0.3970314264,
-0.3022634983,
-0.262878865,
0.0206749197,
0.1260686666,
0.5911786556,
0.0200240705,
0.2497659326,
-0.6095380187,
0.2266433537,
0.4968512058,
0.6808295846,
0.3339185715,
0.0247428231,
-0.1996579766,
0.0159594975,
-0.8191376328,
-1.1613168716,
-0.0807470456,
0.4385198355,
0.6865950227,
0.7228882313,
-0.2166498899,
0.959847331,
-0.4693834484,
0.4175786078,
0.5777304173,
-0.8179907799,
0.0717689171,
-0.201984629,
-0.0271978155,
0.5529315472,
0.4013821781,
-0.7094748616,
-0.2099725604,
-0.6007554531,
-0.7855547667,
0.6250461936,
0.201914832,
-0.1255642474,
0.0779374391,
0.2943812609,
0.0557572171,
0.2663112581,
-0.9983642101,
-0.6239661574,
-0.3025847971,
-0.6573638916,
0.4594428241,
0.1457731128,
-0.1538618356,
-0.0554736182,
0.8466261029,
-0.5401927829,
0.2249761224,
-0.0542098358,
-0.3932037652,
-0.2225540578,
0.2418733835,
0.2538923919,
0.6635889411,
0.0138207246,
0.2380075604,
0.196655184,
-0.2990513146,
0.3238140047,
0.3489645123,
-0.2230687588,
-0.1575098336,
0.1854729503,
0.6643377542,
0.3129575551,
-0.1023385972,
0.6399315596,
0.1366268545,
0.0460225493,
0.0165512394,
-0.2625517547,
0.2997875214,
0.1508146226,
0.3965608478,
0.4148289859,
0.104082942,
-0.466730386,
0.4131056368,
0.6716837883,
-0.4917609394,
-0.1256865263,
0.7371256948,
0.045208849,
0.2123338282,
0.5921712518,
-0.4310992956,
-0.388971597,
0.3951717615,
0.5154980421,
0.580247581,
-0.3961327076,
0.2806186378,
0.2058795094,
0.1382585168,
0.2879014313,
0.0053308322,
-0.1381896585,
-0.8658121824,
-0.3429428041,
-0.4552717805,
-0.1455023587,
-0.0813680291,
-0.4939007759,
0.2587305307,
-0.1466461867,
0.0596870109,
-0.0749741197,
-0.0954901576,
-0.8535013795,
0.2312009335,
0.0409821421,
0.5652997494,
-0.8653107882,
0.6387037635,
0.7677050829,
-0.763050139,
-1.3909099102,
-0.1533564329,
-0.0079033338,
-0.692184031,
0.3077933788,
0.2305590063,
0.0678114668,
-0.0845842659,
-0.3435952663,
-0.9774554968,
1.7193003893,
0.777756393,
-0.2536467314,
-0.2083419859,
0.2541374266,
-0.0385426208,
-0.5915327668,
0.0179459509,
0.0351685733,
0.4162823856,
0.2079307735,
-0.7525074482,
0.1574378759,
0.0534529313,
0.0783538297,
0.3436438441,
-0.875161767,
0.5540137887,
0.1777261049,
-0.1287500709,
-0.1424277425,
1.0900654793,
0.2370314598,
0.4573253691,
0.6132717133,
1.0794019699,
1.0008035898,
-0.1766614318,
0.7143396735,
-0.1629819125,
0.4998184741,
1.1100172997,
-0.1820053309,
0.4874201715,
0.4787965715,
0.1165702567,
0.7969633937,
0.4547117054,
0.0937370807,
0.6153744459,
-0.3058535755,
-0.2868288755,
-0.3748293221,
-0.1752857715,
-0.1769788116,
0.4751893878,
-0.0770868063,
-0.3510095775,
-0.324310869,
-0.1319938004,
0.0144065507,
-0.1116905063,
-0.2901360095,
0.8410591483,
-0.099559851,
-0.3516607285,
0.1886610687,
-0.0538011268,
0.2880907059,
-0.6713997126,
-0.2623328865,
0.0564744249,
-0.0632023737,
-0.335149616,
-0.4241753519,
0.0378220975,
-0.7413324118,
-0.4116741717,
-0.0047074566,
0.7055706978,
-0.8220264912,
-0.2827227116,
0.0593859367,
0.3864489794,
-0.5177120566,
0.2296172678,
-0.5400067568,
-0.211339429,
-0.2830929458,
-0.2521348,
0.2824355364,
0.7040348649,
0.0597295128,
0.5512785316,
0.4041816592,
-0.1227917969,
0.1803414822,
0.0776945278,
0.8410487771,
-0.2662063241,
-0.5566771626,
-0.5979833603,
0.6002325416,
-0.4414499402,
-0.1389409006,
0.6163018942,
0.5528616905,
0.8617964983,
0.133221209,
0.2752119899,
-0.2563968599,
-0.0237786267,
-0.5841937661,
0.9887342453,
-0.5296714902,
0.043442063,
-0.3311880529,
-1.0722767115,
-0.2187682986,
0.5954959393,
0.2280971557,
0.2794350684,
0.6752505302,
0.6969467998,
-0.5100490451,
-0.4125699699,
0.3637750447,
0.0268095452,
0.3518650532,
0.6091949344,
0.289129287,
-0.6838887334,
0.6019001603,
-0.303721875,
-0.1442067474,
0.1747885048,
-0.909227252,
-0.457075119,
-0.7747859359,
-0.3972946107,
-0.3346203864,
-0.2042709738,
1.0145800114,
0.8707278967,
-0.6722291708,
0.2641513944,
0.1165884361,
0.4055508971,
-0.5547384024,
-0.3162559867,
0.5404265523,
-0.4195354283,
-0.4234412014,
0.265629977,
0.2919743061,
-0.0331950299,
-0.1756617278,
-0.3219279945,
-0.2522957027,
-0.1826788932,
0.3242695034,
0.0273652822,
-0.5897710323,
-0.7268168926,
-0.0347378366,
-0.1931702346,
0.2901901305,
0.7167570591,
-0.6675060391,
0.4680596292,
0.1623176932,
0.8796541691,
0.135172829,
-0.1508383155,
0.5384753346,
-1.3573132753,
0.0197862312,
0.2071339488,
0.646453321,
0.4090740383,
-0.4679078162,
0.3868403733,
0.483803004,
-0.4298756421,
-0.5722737312,
0.4808874726,
-1.3122471571,
0.1539527774,
0.7186772227,
-0.3520771861,
-0.2718862593,
0.1307632625,
-0.018501509,
0.5609394312,
-0.5497682691,
0.7397223711,
0.6523085833,
-0.1442558169,
-0.3447866738,
0.0263551604,
0.3992917538,
0.2833023369,
-0.5402348638,
-0.1079193354,
0.6908459663,
0.2869761586,
0.300246805,
0.3729300201,
-0.0512100384,
0.5022612214,
-0.0840681121,
0.1679882854,
-0.4497023821,
-0.3921141028,
0.0410361998,
0.3210609853,
0.0888420641,
-0.1430588216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.06488v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.06488v1 | One Small Step for Generative AI, One Giant Leap for AGI: A Complete Survey on ChatGPT in AIGC Era | 2023-04-04T06:22:09 | 2023-04-04T06:22:09 | Chaoning Zhang, Chenshuang Zhang, Chenghao Li, Yu Qiao, Sheng Zheng, Sumit Kumar Dam, Mengchun Zhang, Jung Uk Kim, Seong Tae Kim, Jinwoo Choi, Gyeong-Moon Park, Sung-Ho Bae, Lik-Hang Lee, Pan Hui, In So Kweon, Choong Seon Hong | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | OpenAI has recently released GPT-4 (a.k.a. ChatGPT plus), which is
demonstrated to be one small step for generative AI (GAI), but one giant leap
for artificial general intelligence (AGI). Since its official release in
November 2022, ChatGPT has quickly attracted numerous users with extensive
media coverage. Such unprecedented attention has also motivated numerous
researchers to investigate ChatGPT from various aspects. According to Google
scholar, there are more than 500 articles with ChatGPT in their titles or
mentioning it in their abstracts. Considering this, a review is urgently
needed, and our work fills this gap. Overall, this work is the first to survey
ChatGPT with a comprehensive review of its underlying technology, applications,
and challenges. Moreover, we present an outlook on how ChatGPT might evolve to
realize general-purpose AIGC (a.k.a. AI-generated content), which will be a
significant milestone for the development of AGI. | [
-0.62530756,
-0.8906282783,
0.395159483,
0.1456807703,
-0.0018879479,
0.0463590324,
0.0193351619,
-0.5741282701,
0.2203465253,
-0.1660760045,
-0.632276535,
-0.0800502598,
-0.6939009428,
-0.2111712247,
-0.617757678,
1.44713521,
0.0249220971,
-0.2634486258,
-0.0842436329,
-0.0877168179,
-0.3544656336,
-0.4606758058,
-1.2050584555,
-0.2908360958,
0.273378104,
0.2582167983,
0.6623267531,
0.1722871214,
0.5363664031,
0.2217865139,
-0.0737804547,
0.0301948991,
-0.4029669464,
-0.3059223592,
0.2385715097,
-0.1274507344,
-0.839127779,
0.3368588686,
0.678095758,
0.4368715882,
-0.134879142,
0.1268117428,
0.2149847448,
0.6224024892,
-0.362496376,
0.4150144458,
-0.2692630589,
0.2729219198,
-0.466173768,
0.0233777985,
-0.1324736476,
-0.3140514493,
0.1751094759,
-0.5716978312,
0.3881822824,
-0.1792646348,
0.6529859304,
0.1466289461,
-0.3291128278,
-0.3572491109,
-0.9840884805,
0.3849107325,
-0.2955756485,
0.0984141603,
-0.0636111721,
0.5658168793,
-0.1647613943,
-0.9599993825,
-0.6879216433,
-0.5534572601,
0.2184544802,
0.5434475541,
-0.1985548586,
0.0944636762,
-0.0839768574,
0.7211007476,
-0.6455049515,
-0.1424043775,
-0.4246912599,
0.0156121049,
0.6323008537,
0.0031413583,
0.4864584506,
0.13695544,
-0.283241868,
0.0064582285,
-0.8907879591,
-0.1323533356,
0.4655380249,
-0.0748062283,
-0.1649655402,
0.4479147494,
-0.2447105497,
0.2988293767,
-0.0203899983,
0.4919085205,
0.2615972757,
-0.7734431028,
-0.1384522319,
-0.0308381617,
1.0439127684,
0.0912947431,
0.3036813438,
-0.100916855,
0.3323017061,
0.1076322868,
0.2552776039,
-0.8421772718,
-0.3878952563,
0.2397532612,
-0.2747985721,
-0.1730666608,
0.2577447295,
-0.8121849895,
-0.323302269,
0.1830189228,
0.0259803478,
-0.3989464343,
-0.4469239116,
-0.1804813594,
-0.016495375,
0.6745174527,
0.6958414912,
-1.0669205189,
0.1025733352,
1.0496697426,
1.1228699684,
-0.2041940391,
-0.3363395929,
-0.2871134579,
-0.1210579947,
-0.3296424448,
0.9384419322,
-0.6012336612,
-0.5870091915,
0.0223034248,
-0.3740407825,
-0.1620818079,
-0.0342241973,
0.5310220718,
-0.3724765778,
0.3962286711,
0.0853770673,
-0.3126147985,
-0.0538447835,
0.8111340404,
-0.4408406913,
0.5006411672,
-0.0096535254,
-0.8923418522,
0.36419487,
-1.1515767574,
-0.1816024482,
0.4682535231,
-0.4621019363,
-0.3687318861,
-0.2225832045,
0.4449324012,
0.0502811261,
-0.2601860464,
0.0638603047,
-0.0402697287,
-0.3761085272,
0.1033412442,
-0.8091184497,
0.5691142082,
0.3378166258,
-0.2891191542,
0.2274023592,
-0.4329006076,
0.202520445,
0.0066398182,
-0.0929562449,
0.3592479527,
0.2289373428,
-0.2503935993,
-0.0054528448,
0.1780404896,
-0.658856988,
0.5942491293,
-0.0731038079,
0.814966023,
0.704272449,
0.3773396313,
0.4249505699,
-0.1122085378,
0.7503657937,
-0.0866568238,
0.5804190636,
-0.3795435727,
-1.0573297739,
-0.7088329792,
-0.1353950351,
0.5251438618,
0.699254632,
-0.7810492516,
0.2308292538,
-0.3322040141,
-0.5961462259,
-0.4918318987,
-0.4150543809,
0.1493063867,
0.0788085684,
0.1792426705,
-0.3244778812,
-0.1504225135,
-0.5213552713,
0.1738881022,
-0.7304673195,
-0.2641505599,
0.4963429868,
0.3839891255,
-0.5484784245,
0.8703234792,
-0.4738315344,
-0.4292843938,
-0.2427983433,
0.4102027714,
-0.0127196331,
0.3998346031,
0.4342422187,
-0.8251208067,
-0.5822746158,
0.5157093406,
-0.6385530829,
0.277582258,
-0.1587024778,
-0.1567680985,
-0.0918840095,
0.1593723893,
-1.0264706612,
0.4973635674,
0.5523945093,
-0.167709291,
0.5391700864,
-0.1305569708,
0.501236856,
-0.7717437744,
0.1209103167,
-0.1741495132,
0.1692987829,
-0.7147468328,
0.1504745483,
-0.2143787146,
-0.3471477926,
0.0305892415,
0.3714758456,
-0.2105732262,
0.2050384134,
-0.1229511574,
0.0060775438,
-0.6534345746,
0.2786661386,
-0.2229542285,
1.1642875671,
0.5617518425,
-0.543664217,
0.2856248915,
0.512488842,
-0.1015043408,
0.271407336,
-0.6754204631,
0.4004703164,
-0.0810948163,
0.4768375754,
-0.9911934733,
-0.4211128652,
0.802288115,
-0.8531573415,
0.1292390972,
-0.1255776286,
-0.1890449375,
-0.4139042199,
-0.2423619926,
0.3936514854,
0.6630262733,
-0.4666220844,
0.4042089581,
0.2899717987,
-0.48882851,
-0.1876790971,
-0.4004777968,
0.3732738495,
0.0087516028,
-0.7353847027,
0.0313726999,
-0.3083938062,
-0.0176970772,
-0.0307984166,
-0.0567082949,
-0.0972596183,
-0.2057115287,
0.0873392299,
0.0474832393,
-0.1387224346,
-0.0355748609,
-0.3013785779,
-0.2707125545,
0.0298424009,
-0.5270764828,
0.458252877,
-0.5281970501,
-0.6735932231,
-0.1615314037,
0.5086176991,
0.2619394064,
-0.3564403951,
0.128628552,
0.8892705441,
0.1919500828,
0.1770824641,
-0.2843198776,
0.210086748,
-0.3909600973,
0.4150186181,
-0.1714705229,
-1.0050886869,
0.4017131925,
-0.0626907051,
0.1795010269,
0.6671971679,
0.3743180335,
0.1565571427,
1.2268602848,
0.7099670172,
-0.3016467988,
0.6087421179,
-0.3608700633,
0.5484092236,
-0.539422214,
-0.1571110338,
-0.4876480401,
-0.1776553988,
-0.8468795419,
-0.2089071274,
0.623472631,
-0.2225270718,
-0.2663520873,
-0.0428321511,
-0.5780912638,
0.3605106473,
0.5202457905,
-0.0190081578,
0.3658529222,
-0.0818310827,
0.4892172813,
0.3331211209,
-0.5923408866,
-0.2413396388,
0.9458293319,
0.2949503064,
0.4837141037,
0.1097275764,
0.5846610069,
0.5332908034,
0.5658021569,
-0.7716127038,
0.5338226557,
0.0414487422,
-0.4129855037,
-0.5736515522,
-0.5012685657,
-0.9745649695,
-0.0037270335,
0.3540394306,
-0.6945046186,
-0.0123806782,
0.3087231815,
-0.2142834663,
0.2421465367,
-0.8358359337,
0.7530968189,
-0.0820404664,
0.0667651519,
-0.1762117743,
-0.669170022,
0.4785108864,
0.0600358769,
-0.1031115353,
0.1315240264,
0.1099589914,
0.4536523819,
-0.4171924293,
0.4737806916,
-0.2616224289,
-0.0625937283,
0.8463507891,
-0.2488490939,
0.3849957287,
0.1917815655,
0.2665733993,
0.3311305344,
-0.3098444343,
-0.3984039128,
-0.5521397591,
0.4144361913,
-0.7386111021,
-0.5668615699,
-0.6975839138,
-0.0615630187,
-0.2616192997,
-0.0285400152,
0.5799692869,
0.0885944515,
-0.5926088095,
-0.0347267538,
0.5880252719,
0.1114033088,
0.4144156873,
-0.053708639,
0.005494616,
-0.3056255579,
1.0212465525,
-0.0633424968,
0.1215131655,
0.1236722693,
0.0433578752,
0.0292763487,
-0.7391083837,
-0.8524501324,
-0.1438945532,
-0.2973311841,
0.0658077747,
-0.5892512798,
-0.6717534661,
-0.3748294711,
0.2324732244,
-0.4115703106,
-0.1839338541,
-0.1167524382,
0.0298882239,
0.1961403638,
1.0048061609,
0.0872712135,
0.3824168146,
-0.7205663919,
0.1074724942,
0.669244945,
0.4202948213,
0.0615522712,
-0.1357765645,
-0.1271250546,
0.2048150897,
-0.5446988344,
-0.5652385354,
0.0050011273,
0.554074347,
0.5167595148,
0.7647460103,
-0.2435302436,
0.6106344461,
-0.7205628753,
1.3164330721,
0.3615615964,
-0.496994704,
0.3805399835,
-0.5212138891,
0.4497185051,
0.2926210165,
0.3855460584,
-0.852016449,
-0.2027296126,
-0.7176561952,
-0.8541648984,
0.5038865209,
0.4970227778,
0.3815119565,
-0.195416227,
0.0691784695,
0.1183994785,
0.1830611676,
-0.4207147956,
-0.0298338495,
-0.3612275422,
0.1574025899,
0.0111786509,
-0.1580942124,
0.0097410409,
-0.0579555221,
0.6692478657,
-0.2124818265,
0.9141468406,
0.1499428749,
0.3585508168,
0.2204328179,
0.6403767467,
0.3641765714,
0.5913851857,
-0.0398023129,
-0.4008946121,
-0.0135337263,
-0.9932760596,
0.1397846192,
0.2372246385,
-0.5190089345,
-0.3822236657,
0.2126707286,
0.9050104618,
-0.2335609496,
-0.4383076131,
0.6654992104,
-0.1634471118,
-0.2714026272,
-0.5640372634,
0.2791333497,
-0.3915873468,
0.2587851584,
0.4169016778,
0.111471124,
0.3598100841,
-0.6161085367,
-0.0133696618,
0.4045297503,
-0.4917593896,
-0.5415409207,
0.8040550351,
0.3929712474,
-0.0711258873,
0.9192438126,
-0.7716777325,
-0.3894614577,
0.4714132547,
0.2448797226,
1.3279851675,
-0.043545343,
0.4413750768,
0.2495034635,
0.196385324,
-0.0381766446,
0.0206081569,
-0.3109951317,
-0.5201254487,
-0.6217184067,
-0.2810682058,
-0.7191674113,
0.0124011915,
-0.1781045943,
-0.0420687683,
-0.2810670137,
-0.0148137752,
-0.1189187989,
-0.2010467947,
-0.5568218827,
0.042701602,
0.2618853748,
0.689347446,
-0.4925898612,
0.4880716801,
0.8599590063,
-0.5152807236,
-0.3848598897,
0.5195091963,
-0.0347021855,
-0.5321525931,
0.1085281521,
0.1335043311,
0.0391283296,
0.174081713,
-0.879875958,
-0.632623136,
0.993430078,
-0.1785431951,
-0.0939174667,
-0.2177746147,
0.2266960144,
0.5213266611,
-0.1876829565,
0.4961338043,
0.6984378099,
0.5203485489,
0.4716680348,
-0.7736722231,
-0.4922637343,
-0.6495786905,
0.0411323868,
0.3264771998,
-0.9525053501,
0.9824463725,
-0.1280280948,
-0.6011531949,
0.3932802975,
0.7445033193,
0.0017281884,
0.4829453826,
0.3140556216,
0.4065253139,
0.486921519,
-0.2758841515,
1.2325251102,
0.0073930472,
0.3302716315,
0.7444137335,
-0.0895438641,
0.476329416,
0.0248315297,
-0.5241474509,
0.0467405468,
0.6184380651,
-0.166760698,
0.3771338165,
-0.0622020513,
-0.6418619156,
0.1050635725,
-0.0745828375,
-0.6206687093,
0.4806070328,
0.4002675116,
0.1548534334,
-0.3835574687,
-0.0115809161,
0.0692672431,
-0.5452239513,
-0.4824979603,
0.9817690849,
-0.1579132527,
-0.7971540093,
-0.0050145849,
-0.1190432981,
0.5584130287,
-0.9303854704,
-0.2705639303,
-0.4356666505,
0.0884079933,
-0.0770439729,
-0.884634912,
0.1402761638,
0.1736102402,
0.1605486572,
-0.1222844645,
0.7410258651,
-0.2060091048,
-0.0407720581,
-0.1950083077,
0.6087127328,
0.3663185239,
-0.3249092698,
-0.3632371724,
-0.1994658113,
0.1685277224,
-0.2333871424,
0.4008616805,
0.5330122709,
-0.0513973832,
0.5159128904,
0.4914274812,
-0.0229333118,
0.1009781882,
-0.0390761495,
0.8907551169,
-0.5340074897,
-0.7041572928,
-0.6774833202,
0.4801016152,
-0.1549303085,
-0.5197891593,
0.7040338516,
0.3518653214,
0.8285067081,
-0.0891397521,
1.120270133,
-0.6955706477,
0.0338581838,
-0.2699416578,
0.7979964018,
-0.1811304539,
-0.2884169817,
-0.272937566,
-0.8750813007,
-0.2066044658,
0.2641181648,
-0.29542014,
0.296816051,
0.5520866513,
0.4088432193,
-0.0372557268,
0.4520806372,
0.2645858228,
-0.0595780239,
0.6417777538,
0.4573427737,
0.8603223562,
-0.327175349,
0.953101933,
0.1888479143,
-0.4398222268,
-0.123504065,
-0.8328099847,
-0.4131438732,
-0.4869183004,
-0.4746366143,
0.1445215791,
0.1160863265,
0.5007305145,
0.5895091295,
-0.8771268725,
0.1546378434,
-0.4765533209,
-0.3113284707,
-0.5155764818,
-0.1978607029,
0.4243312776,
-0.3800613582,
-0.8667735457,
0.1909705848,
0.2896160185,
0.0476282127,
-0.2829746008,
-0.1799075007,
0.0211566966,
-0.1252065599,
0.6936459541,
0.7181489468,
-0.3744009137,
-0.439756304,
-0.234406054,
0.18110919,
0.3654072583,
0.8699369431,
-0.4417404234,
0.4646404684,
0.5284184217,
0.7989084125,
0.5491412282,
0.2329892367,
0.3431621194,
-0.7393443584,
0.0963833332,
0.2687148452,
0.09468963,
0.0647523478,
-0.4108570516,
0.9888843894,
0.1914294958,
-1.0298517942,
-0.3075195551,
0.3959748745,
-0.9960811734,
0.3702916205,
0.902824223,
-0.2375831753,
-0.0195310172,
0.1922160536,
-0.4753193259,
0.1923387349,
-0.463491708,
0.8153005242,
0.7906374931,
-0.5043340325,
-0.3755233288,
-0.9110126495,
0.3643124104,
-0.0547654852,
-1.1837283373,
-0.1540226787,
0.5000824928,
-0.2410658747,
0.3235088289,
0.9572722912,
-0.3559216559,
0.383069247,
0.3768360317,
0.0867428109,
-0.1088749617,
-0.4858298898,
-0.237955153,
0.2302808911,
0.1237300113,
-0.5054707527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01515v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01515v1 | Text-Conditioned Sampling Framework for Text-to-Image Generation with Masked Generative Models | 2023-04-04T03:52:49 | 2023-04-04T03:52:49 | Jaewoong Lee, Sangwon Jang, Jaehyeong Jo, Jaehong Yoon, Yunji Kim, Jin-Hwa Kim, Jung-Woo Ha, Sung Ju Hwang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV, I.5.4; I.2.10; I.4.m | Token-based masked generative models are gaining popularity for their fast
inference time with parallel decoding. While recent token-based approaches
achieve competitive performance to diffusion-based models, their generation
performance is still suboptimal as they sample multiple tokens simultaneously
without considering the dependence among them. We empirically investigate this
problem and propose a learnable sampling model, Text-Conditioned Token
Selection (TCTS), to select optimal tokens via localized supervision with text
information. TCTS improves not only the image quality but also the semantic
alignment of the generated images with the given texts. To further improve the
image quality, we introduce a cohesive sampling strategy, Frequency Adaptive
Sampling (FAS), to each group of tokens divided according to the self-attention
maps. We validate the efficacy of TCTS combined with FAS with various
generative tasks, demonstrating that it significantly outperforms the baselines
in image-text alignment and image quality. Our text-conditioned sampling
framework further reduces the original inference time by more than 50% without
modifying the original generative model. | [
-0.380104661,
-0.5620781183,
0.3141700625,
0.306176275,
-0.7774223685,
0.1288170964,
-0.1664746106,
-0.1692136377,
0.2272994667,
0.479965657,
-0.4456292391,
-0.5267637968,
-0.547426641,
0.3164624274,
-0.3964950442,
0.951030314,
0.0934436768,
-0.1232607439,
-0.3207321763,
-0.0306240954,
-0.5302528739,
-0.264346987,
-0.8929368258,
0.0160102043,
-0.0212452039,
0.2766698301,
0.3750861287,
0.5464372635,
0.4223237038,
0.1994397044,
0.1227870136,
0.2600145042,
-0.3935822845,
0.2137713581,
-0.0544780269,
-0.2351652831,
-0.2013795525,
-0.2007041126,
0.3457939923,
0.2592196763,
-0.1111667603,
0.0755437613,
-0.0328564197,
0.5679052472,
-0.6343330741,
-0.0016777177,
-0.7803162932,
0.3166413605,
-0.0853161886,
-0.3396725953,
-0.6619313359,
-0.0719427019,
0.0133438418,
-0.9140620828,
0.8712038994,
0.2659993172,
0.6613280177,
0.3317351341,
-0.3941701353,
-0.2284538448,
-0.3437857628,
0.6624678373,
-0.4030669034,
0.2155052125,
0.5593470931,
0.0707369596,
-0.0576375313,
-1.0104906559,
-0.4957276583,
0.0496336184,
-0.0521845557,
0.5291901827,
-0.032535065,
0.0564316288,
0.0841474682,
0.373344183,
-0.3267241418,
-0.0944057554,
-0.2927895188,
-0.3901430368,
0.3323664069,
-0.167129159,
0.3007876575,
-0.3202183247,
-0.8006208539,
-0.3032850623,
-0.4770765603,
-0.0694084093,
0.3693687916,
0.1847200394,
-0.1707313955,
0.3274410665,
0.0008283975,
0.7890126109,
0.5174923539,
-0.041337043,
0.1647833735,
-0.3677126765,
-0.4651213288,
-0.009229593,
0.7942817807,
0.4651024342,
0.1801307499,
-0.2041380554,
-0.3770744503,
-0.0705248564,
0.2472805679,
-0.9339193702,
-0.2598868012,
0.17077896,
-0.6088413596,
-0.4394653738,
0.0623499416,
-1.0575191975,
-0.0411857292,
-0.0106904181,
0.3082698286,
-0.4230681658,
-0.2403055876,
-0.0287795775,
-0.4809631109,
-0.2352960855,
0.1104955003,
-1.0815244913,
0.170876354,
0.2050579786,
0.9526076913,
-0.4540617466,
0.1194417328,
-0.7043036819,
0.1969615221,
-0.6195089817,
0.9285980463,
-0.3023149967,
-0.4996178448,
0.0502844974,
-0.3559941351,
-0.0415422097,
-0.4594368041,
0.3944514096,
-0.6901771426,
0.2895762026,
-0.1209492311,
-0.3542865813,
0.2492720187,
0.0182826575,
-0.8689584136,
1.1478853226,
0.2589590251,
-0.9738869667,
0.6470268369,
-0.470392257,
-0.5063613057,
0.0890243202,
-0.1554273814,
-0.7074121833,
0.1785802096,
0.7218654156,
0.5395653844,
-0.0637231991,
0.4295145571,
-0.098097764,
-0.4247212112,
0.0099395774,
-0.475995481,
0.4433164895,
0.5635135174,
-0.3076187968,
0.116532892,
-0.8177419901,
-0.1344929039,
0.0127723236,
-0.2380600572,
-0.3298795521,
0.0278415028,
0.2891423404,
0.1535712779,
-0.330579102,
-0.5224578977,
-0.0095671816,
-0.347063303,
0.4492950737,
0.755707562,
0.3058342934,
0.6437413096,
-0.3264861107,
0.5555870533,
0.2112359554,
-0.0851155967,
-0.6151092052,
-0.2444000989,
-0.7191214561,
-0.7006370425,
0.5447930098,
0.2064775676,
-1.3733998537,
0.2661911845,
-0.4312131107,
-0.1987682283,
-0.2641280293,
-0.0978069007,
0.2079819441,
0.5607019663,
0.3194389343,
-0.7726697922,
-0.2083362788,
-0.5462510586,
-0.1400499791,
0.0947316065,
-0.165389508,
0.0972683802,
0.3646909297,
0.3351998627,
1.0966476202,
-0.4281608164,
-0.3406518698,
-0.0279742461,
0.1854001731,
-0.1984597296,
0.6312837601,
0.7428876162,
-0.9160214067,
-0.4780749977,
-0.3580441177,
-0.3729777634,
-0.0057054618,
-0.3941084146,
-0.4073786139,
0.3141699433,
0.8024990559,
-0.3600077331,
0.5150738358,
0.5911080837,
-0.430054307,
0.2996542752,
-0.2183986157,
0.1885371506,
-1.3373605013,
0.0660972968,
0.0973368213,
-0.6184872985,
-0.441583544,
0.0291744526,
0.1600762904,
-0.2582599521,
-0.2575930357,
0.6202438474,
-0.6046174169,
-0.0008944353,
-0.3858856261,
-0.1302073598,
0.2208937109,
0.6390712261,
0.2718075216,
0.8762170076,
0.4608656466,
-0.4212466478,
0.0715400875,
0.2744305432,
-0.5427862406,
0.7481991649,
-0.4561657608,
0.3433194757,
-0.3943269253,
0.4823250771,
-1.0165233612,
-0.2527788877,
0.283202678,
-0.3783062696,
0.4542375207,
0.0475820266,
-0.511711657,
-0.1342607886,
-0.0870845392,
0.6573680043,
0.5691465735,
-0.6810681224,
0.6192293167,
0.0639012083,
-0.0057922015,
-0.530066371,
-0.6525503993,
0.1015684679,
0.0366860814,
-0.2031829655,
0.70160079,
0.1904710978,
0.1710446179,
0.2672068477,
-0.2712692618,
-0.0805541724,
-0.0609154366,
0.1679735631,
0.0684271827,
-0.0235207845,
0.3901908398,
0.2170575708,
-0.1117763296,
-0.2983457148,
-0.7194868922,
0.5986672044,
0.6498076916,
-0.4212058783,
-0.3915408552,
0.4290675819,
0.3176512122,
-0.3673496842,
0.541318655,
0.6409098506,
-0.2959967852,
-0.3026938438,
-0.4704453945,
-0.196671918,
-0.4509647787,
0.3597001135,
-0.3720282614,
-0.8318066597,
0.2714630961,
0.1186617315,
0.0107411873,
0.5695005655,
0.528154254,
-0.1066629291,
0.6164042354,
0.5688780546,
0.0728611946,
0.8772646189,
-0.1468675286,
-0.0731429383,
-0.4771045446,
-0.0815189406,
-0.2054291964,
-0.1111021563,
-0.3904881179,
-0.6918362975,
0.3570870757,
-0.2002368122,
-0.0637410879,
-0.0884724632,
-0.5884826779,
0.345626235,
0.8403479457,
0.5185566545,
0.260114938,
0.6577872038,
-0.3910190761,
0.1499023736,
-0.78815943,
-0.0476829447,
0.9742251635,
0.0493772589,
0.4293955266,
-0.2631485164,
0.5446318388,
0.3782133758,
0.4914973378,
-0.3423763216,
0.2815507054,
-0.3440748453,
-0.6764518619,
-0.137968868,
-0.2767800689,
-0.7787951231,
0.1361898035,
-0.3017871678,
-0.3267115057,
0.2819763422,
0.3655866981,
-0.1950787753,
0.3767386675,
-0.711362958,
0.5839688778,
0.2433404475,
-0.3759270608,
0.0123212999,
-0.585573256,
0.3492711782,
-0.3620346785,
0.1518672407,
-0.0388697051,
0.0692043006,
0.5724728107,
-0.4061339498,
0.9780501127,
-0.3119950891,
0.1103313789,
0.5150530934,
-0.2251240015,
0.4065498114,
-0.051192604,
-0.1303108186,
-0.1228583902,
-0.0948658139,
-0.6907961965,
-0.5247391462,
0.2346443534,
-0.5174611211,
-0.4051876366,
-0.2117310911,
-0.4088339806,
-0.0456463322,
0.1985463351,
0.8060523868,
0.5995891094,
-0.1099030301,
0.1526435316,
0.3712818325,
-0.270953238,
0.6711237431,
-0.1952068508,
-0.107115455,
-0.9316244721,
0.7944476604,
-0.0854345113,
0.5697458982,
0.4338562787,
-0.1302314252,
-0.2880134881,
-0.566141367,
-0.555467248,
-0.1625499129,
-0.7642579675,
-0.5070356131,
-0.6083443761,
-0.022629695,
-0.4427530468,
-0.2236884534,
-0.1435093433,
-0.2680071592,
-0.4959463477,
-0.0695360377,
0.431456089,
0.1010462865,
0.0794336051,
0.6149405837,
-0.5763220191,
0.6723617911,
0.26189363,
0.4573860765,
0.0775986016,
-0.4145356417,
-0.0616668276,
-0.2701975107,
-0.2590609491,
-0.8900617957,
0.4741986692,
0.2636371255,
0.3355317712,
0.2081855237,
0.3640175462,
0.6492989659,
-0.3314854205,
0.6300553083,
0.4186379313,
-0.8778399229,
0.3160929084,
-0.3428200185,
0.4174128771,
0.5368833542,
-0.1237608343,
-0.5188831687,
-0.5475655794,
-0.4864097536,
-0.8835787773,
0.6529951096,
0.6235708594,
0.4947269261,
-0.0957055315,
0.6275267601,
0.066291146,
0.1699400395,
-0.8352571726,
-0.1144850925,
-0.6759448051,
-0.6835053563,
-0.0865283906,
-0.303704828,
-0.0097115757,
0.027598219,
0.5385687351,
-0.4344374537,
0.5362727046,
0.6161770225,
-0.0766737759,
-0.147324428,
-0.05489121,
0.4996866882,
0.1809906512,
0.0011200561,
0.1575240344,
-0.0191189721,
-0.7332258224,
0.183774814,
0.115622595,
-0.4808609784,
0.0629426613,
0.1932531744,
1.1660603285,
-0.0722689554,
-0.423519671,
0.5810036063,
-0.2099686712,
-0.321791321,
-0.011265615,
0.1008490846,
-0.1418050677,
-0.1326453686,
0.6541082263,
0.3685349822,
-0.1385516375,
0.0128406966,
0.2856752574,
0.444067359,
-0.4097812176,
-0.063701205,
0.8446741104,
0.3427366614,
-0.2551361918,
0.4416106641,
-0.2766118348,
-0.3193651438,
0.8140685558,
0.8803582788,
0.8278555274,
0.13576895,
0.3160084784,
0.5091651082,
0.2684024274,
-0.0919416621,
0.0877939165,
-0.4543919861,
-0.7128794193,
-0.3671471775,
-0.6079480648,
-0.1506904364,
0.0023647447,
-0.49193573,
0.2571288049,
-0.2828661501,
-0.3428331614,
-0.3044894338,
-0.2494611293,
-0.5776277781,
0.6038960218,
-0.2393832952,
0.9956330061,
-0.8390462399,
0.6837565303,
0.3105278909,
-0.1329762787,
-0.6798719168,
0.3541333973,
-0.4830161631,
-0.7208496332,
0.3532967567,
0.1962566376,
0.1280142665,
0.6283690333,
-0.5663189292,
-0.7262611985,
0.9592519403,
0.3479100168,
-0.3666088283,
0.0702545196,
-0.0207742844,
0.3819685876,
-0.2893011272,
0.0438419767,
0.2233032733,
0.0491659679,
0.3748626113,
-0.3476623297,
0.1056413502,
-0.3233658373,
0.24236615,
0.0598463416,
-0.6874190569,
0.2997617424,
-0.0553663746,
-0.4927728176,
0.3389270902,
0.9189628363,
0.3765785992,
0.4134627283,
0.7267084718,
0.5105723143,
0.4232162237,
0.0722521245,
1.0595946312,
-0.335573554,
0.3565858603,
0.876814127,
0.1620413214,
0.588018775,
0.6485173702,
0.1530446559,
0.3010167181,
0.8804913163,
-0.313048929,
0.9737756848,
0.0303611215,
-0.357082963,
-0.2470822036,
-0.0500468686,
-0.165231958,
0.3675735593,
0.0969984457,
-0.6984521747,
-0.1702440679,
0.1880084276,
-0.314279139,
0.1572403759,
-0.1228957549,
0.6613587737,
-0.1458844393,
-1.0571867228,
0.2813639939,
0.1728760302,
0.8184050918,
-0.0924546048,
0.1490495652,
-0.3731497526,
-0.3010171056,
0.0101203909,
-0.3281325698,
0.128432259,
0.1131621078,
-0.2508883774,
-0.4351343811,
0.9355371594,
-0.4402190745,
-0.711605072,
-0.259750843,
0.2251392901,
-0.1631458402,
-0.0227943752,
-0.2278579921,
-0.2259628028,
-0.074800007,
-0.2628608048,
0.2591590881,
0.4124270976,
-0.0998100862,
0.1687834859,
0.8466640115,
-0.0351061188,
0.1192876548,
0.0544315055,
0.6034914851,
-0.386248827,
-0.6013450027,
-0.8314013481,
0.388136059,
-0.2166664898,
-0.2603537738,
0.2363423854,
0.4790426493,
0.6379746199,
-0.3359463513,
0.7870379686,
0.1080955416,
0.0548148155,
-0.848328054,
0.8502101302,
-0.553312242,
-0.1684613824,
-0.2037965208,
-0.6223248243,
-0.4234249294,
0.3787649572,
0.0397704169,
0.1201270446,
0.5368196368,
0.6656398177,
-0.1140077412,
-0.199178949,
0.317343086,
-0.3608385921,
0.367957294,
0.3532267511,
0.589092195,
-0.5302320123,
0.4890196919,
-0.2614155114,
0.0422512665,
0.0424099118,
-1.179692626,
-0.8477874398,
-0.7657964826,
-0.2852615118,
-0.1396894604,
-0.0392250828,
0.7814158797,
0.9235414863,
-0.5952991843,
0.3923106492,
-0.5628588796,
-0.0094237188,
-0.1287838668,
-0.2094178051,
0.7274891734,
-0.5772310495,
-1.1004525423,
-0.2458354235,
0.2353285551,
0.3957313597,
0.2085349858,
0.3044407666,
0.2003485113,
0.0879223868,
0.4141774178,
0.0270998552,
-0.5559895635,
-0.1376953721,
0.0522162803,
-0.3764717281,
0.2760114372,
0.9314187169,
-0.8207918406,
0.7464754581,
0.3405548036,
0.6285122633,
0.7701382637,
0.1800830066,
0.5375834703,
-1.2552545071,
0.5090705156,
-0.0533172637,
0.1903675646,
0.4058364332,
-0.3175845444,
0.259272933,
0.529337585,
-0.2873539925,
-0.7356085181,
0.0126496982,
-1.0112257004,
-0.3782913983,
1.1074095964,
-0.1025710106,
-0.175627172,
-0.0358539373,
-0.3705342412,
0.5687445998,
-0.2929188013,
0.88929528,
0.5158401728,
0.2754204869,
-0.2719851732,
-0.3291831017,
0.6210549474,
0.4704555571,
-0.7629425526,
-0.2350194603,
0.4535813928,
0.3779726923,
-0.0424777381,
1.1624572277,
0.0131585347,
0.3227133155,
0.1407498866,
0.0966889784,
-0.1165193766,
-0.0104302447,
-0.066025123,
0.4143233299,
-0.1389416009,
-0.5104538798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01492v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01492v5 | A Unified Contrastive Transfer Framework with Propagation Structure for Boosting Low-Resource Rumor Detection | 2023-04-04T03:13:03 | 2023-10-17T02:37:46 | Hongzhan Lin, Jing Ma, Ruichao Yang, Zhiwei Yang, Mingfei Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | The truth is significantly hampered by massive rumors that spread along with
breaking news or popular topics. Since there is sufficient corpus gathered from
the same domain for model training, existing rumor detection algorithms show
promising performance on yesterday's news. However, due to a lack of
substantial training data and prior expert knowledge, they are poor at spotting
rumors concerning unforeseen events, especially those propagated in different
languages (i.e., low-resource regimes). In this paper, we propose a unified
contrastive transfer framework to detect rumors by adapting the features
learned from well-resourced rumor data to that of the low-resourced with only
few-shot annotations. More specifically, we first represent rumor circulated on
social media as an undirected topology for enhancing the interaction of user
opinions, and then train a Multi-scale Graph Convolutional Network via a
unified contrastive paradigm to mine effective clues simultaneously from post
semantics and propagation structure. Our model explicitly breaks the barriers
of the domain and/or language issues, via language alignment and a novel
domain-adaptive contrastive learning mechanism. To well-generalize the
representation learning using a small set of annotated target events, we reveal
that rumor-indicative signal is closely correlated with the uniformity of the
distribution of these events. We design a target-wise contrastive training
mechanism with three event-level data augmentation strategies, capable of
unifying the representations by distinguishing target events. Extensive
experiments conducted on four low-resource datasets collected from real-world
microblog platforms demonstrate that our framework achieves much better
performance than state-of-the-art methods and exhibits a superior capacity for
detecting rumors at early stages. | [
-0.3602703214,
-0.5362600088,
0.2857116163,
0.4245097935,
-0.6188315749,
0.0928487256,
-0.2753871679,
-0.77818501,
0.642473042,
0.1987263262,
-0.4643162489,
-0.3202909827,
-0.6041405797,
-0.2958685756,
-0.5502452254,
1.2244361639,
0.1390943974,
-0.1562863439,
0.27930969,
-0.1468355358,
0.1704632044,
-0.2658263147,
-0.5699871778,
-0.2540290952,
0.4681417942,
0.4514443278,
0.6092280746,
0.2960574925,
0.283198595,
0.210075587,
-0.2325276881,
0.3836820126,
-0.5291546583,
-0.1542782933,
-0.2325575799,
-0.1912510246,
0.0520047322,
-0.0133986771,
0.5908507705,
0.6169453263,
-0.027804831,
0.1176477,
0.2309750021,
0.4783832431,
-0.6645761132,
0.0760893449,
-0.9951099753,
0.0432985537,
-0.3511474729,
-0.2333173603,
-0.17519629,
-0.0235752556,
0.0641977489,
-0.7492602468,
0.2693963945,
0.0598549731,
0.9257541895,
-0.0533309616,
-0.3139199317,
-0.0649129376,
-0.7031123042,
0.4695104361,
-0.1441978812,
0.1262202263,
-0.1675056219,
0.4378399551,
-0.0463382453,
-0.7161254287,
-0.6873384714,
0.0083331987,
-0.2591971755,
0.1120905951,
-0.6300961971,
-0.2196051627,
-0.1496235281,
0.0760534406,
-0.2628971934,
0.1880221069,
-0.5594120622,
-0.57663095,
0.2046698928,
-0.3934809864,
-0.1008602753,
-0.3290677965,
-0.6309604049,
0.073332727,
-0.4541403055,
-0.235425815,
0.3316275775,
0.3824189603,
-0.5001760721,
-0.0582293794,
-0.5327253938,
0.3106388152,
0.1343296766,
-0.1015445441,
0.3550628126,
-0.2826797962,
-0.0506957434,
0.1823265254,
0.8800275326,
0.4708612859,
0.0180690475,
-0.2834969163,
0.0737980977,
0.2630410492,
-0.0329732187,
-0.8106769919,
-0.2523739338,
-0.316711843,
-0.4750212729,
-0.5960332155,
0.1395426244,
-1.2216027975,
-0.6640210152,
0.1340827346,
0.3104299605,
-0.2230730206,
-0.4142560661,
0.089804098,
-0.1892920136,
-0.2482116222,
0.7215480804,
-0.5300245285,
-0.0410705023,
0.2505747676,
0.7190985084,
-0.0349871479,
-0.1226195022,
-0.5944214463,
0.3017279506,
-0.3837341368,
1.3425204754,
-0.4764281809,
-0.0014357371,
0.0357231982,
-0.1059127003,
0.1664997935,
-0.2785173655,
1.0842897892,
-0.6126894355,
0.1368416101,
-0.2136405259,
-0.2185479403,
-0.0849347264,
0.1768015772,
-0.5565380454,
0.6110761166,
0.213069573,
-1.000885725,
0.3066737652,
-0.5290644169,
-0.4311598539,
-0.0632146224,
0.0107977567,
-0.1987873167,
0.0225701611,
0.5492611527,
0.2725655735,
-0.3211649358,
-0.1615183353,
-0.3227664232,
-0.5530005693,
0.3056995869,
-0.7480259538,
0.5270935893,
0.5513569713,
-0.1637509912,
-0.0748638287,
-0.7664054036,
-0.318492204,
-0.0984490663,
-0.2486355454,
-0.3497938514,
-0.4784884155,
0.0617729276,
0.3362362385,
-0.179605186,
-0.5982849598,
0.1680372357,
-0.0382996686,
0.0503773838,
0.4641899168,
0.3499344587,
0.712471664,
-0.3114328384,
0.1578338742,
0.600620389,
0.204808712,
-0.1502964199,
-0.1159571782,
-0.8161318302,
-0.1236540154,
0.1473239362,
0.2004102468,
-1.2267417908,
0.0370111465,
-0.3533228934,
-0.3080652058,
-0.9136021733,
0.2538843751,
0.2807177007,
0.8743120432,
0.5314290524,
0.3779970407,
-0.7730391622,
-0.8850079179,
-0.3629739881,
-0.169964239,
-0.0457527675,
0.0098546594,
0.0102139283,
-0.0285030473,
0.3721846044,
-0.2331566811,
-0.5768501759,
-0.2372650951,
0.529409647,
0.2415130585,
0.3518848121,
0.708706975,
-1.0476065874,
-0.5249423981,
0.0022652873,
-0.6136969924,
-0.1384714842,
-0.1337537318,
-0.1298941225,
0.3965513408,
0.6596611142,
-0.292416364,
0.1841495484,
0.6687452197,
-0.2795158327,
0.2135622203,
0.128386274,
0.4521424174,
-1.1771378517,
-0.2607615888,
0.214786604,
-0.221979633,
-0.4456106126,
-0.2597356141,
-0.274356693,
0.1887794435,
-0.5099154711,
0.5187593699,
-0.4295592308,
0.08155635,
-0.5901732445,
0.4376278818,
0.0079411119,
0.312476784,
-0.0302137658,
0.4640670419,
0.638255775,
-0.585116148,
0.2505373955,
-0.0716703683,
-0.3915660977,
0.8321273923,
-0.0698761791,
-0.0048456984,
-0.1773488522,
0.4169625044,
-0.9734142423,
-0.0712411627,
0.5389322639,
-0.4914453924,
-0.0709857568,
-0.5396047235,
-0.5821149349,
-0.4272142351,
-0.2287556678,
-0.0146665322,
0.7542917132,
-0.8714512587,
0.4226138294,
0.2513205409,
0.1367420554,
-0.525162816,
-0.8185923696,
-0.1024870798,
-0.1139124706,
-0.6551092863,
0.532358706,
0.1485022604,
-0.0883306563,
0.35989061,
-0.3752701581,
-0.2613657713,
-0.1132219061,
0.0687571913,
0.2738555968,
-0.3022810221,
0.1826943606,
0.0779418945,
-0.0618732236,
-0.1417554319,
-0.3519548774,
0.2201230377,
-0.055493664,
-0.103162311,
-0.4854648411,
-0.0516721904,
0.3982918561,
0.2862591147,
0.7887534499,
1.0962861776,
-0.3506043851,
-0.4948100448,
-0.787294209,
-0.2860726118,
-0.3888180256,
0.3325181007,
-0.1840561926,
-0.793846488,
0.4489094019,
-0.3709729314,
-0.3398254514,
0.6206079125,
0.2479644716,
-0.0897328556,
0.5550003052,
0.6944357753,
-0.4345313609,
0.3965794742,
-0.1057538688,
-0.1993152946,
-0.5739632249,
-0.0823228583,
-0.4850997329,
-0.5040200353,
-0.4599712491,
-0.653495729,
0.191944465,
0.4787852764,
0.1370396912,
0.0421150289,
-0.4048472345,
0.657479167,
0.3038578331,
0.1577068865,
0.690995574,
0.4449053109,
-0.0545975566,
-0.0294196252,
-0.6866830587,
-0.013664593,
0.6636406183,
0.1779506803,
0.7788211107,
-0.0521646887,
0.4064864814,
0.5494426489,
0.7030699849,
-0.3861562312,
0.2697212398,
-0.2678099871,
-0.1807796955,
-0.2263530344,
-0.5864132643,
-0.5074464679,
0.544516027,
-0.6651668549,
-0.6903727651,
0.5181980729,
-0.0000540864,
-0.1590059847,
0.7467380762,
-0.5008526444,
0.4634755552,
0.2329969853,
-0.23536174,
-0.5468027592,
-0.481286943,
0.4845533669,
-0.1004037485,
0.4251506627,
-0.2557732165,
0.0554574504,
0.5874769688,
0.0447875932,
0.8718532324,
-0.162230134,
0.3090252876,
0.4830789566,
0.1027713269,
0.6385073066,
0.0604253896,
-0.2547648251,
0.1772303283,
-0.4241710901,
-0.3447906971,
-0.4403357804,
0.6620128155,
-0.6541480422,
-0.1854458898,
-0.2178508192,
-0.6073537469,
-0.2073460668,
0.0593344904,
0.5452442765,
-0.0117030572,
-0.4535501003,
0.1994947493,
0.3299956322,
0.3802386224,
0.4330641627,
0.9592751861,
-0.0517939106,
-0.1864595562,
0.8286870122,
-0.0782411173,
-0.0835664496,
0.34667629,
0.1191035658,
-0.0871347189,
-0.6669037938,
-0.2870348096,
0.1081259921,
-0.7771062851,
-0.4009013176,
-0.5854693651,
-0.3920346498,
-0.1872997284,
-0.3346740007,
-0.4182673991,
-0.273681134,
-0.1633414924,
-0.0509722605,
0.3905262947,
0.4557917416,
-0.3617053628,
0.4854182005,
-0.7380979657,
0.5022447705,
0.1074836031,
0.1987243593,
-0.2315654457,
-0.9885882735,
-0.2348193079,
0.1080754772,
-0.1025379151,
-0.6142057776,
0.1837023199,
-0.0016090465,
0.4362944365,
0.6326137781,
0.4296072423,
0.6146450043,
-0.0429654829,
0.2545303702,
0.4270882308,
-0.7837436795,
0.3145889938,
-0.2361750752,
-0.2385098338,
0.6136717796,
0.399412632,
-0.5854548812,
-0.4447620213,
-0.8771830797,
-0.301538676,
0.7358462214,
0.0831351653,
0.1009831354,
-0.0347916707,
0.3095994294,
-0.0852159485,
0.2689515352,
-0.8320700526,
-0.2017773986,
-0.0689966306,
0.0513417348,
0.3086483479,
-0.4842788577,
-0.2450145632,
-0.1506940722,
0.5670917034,
-0.3283378482,
0.0784439296,
0.1038759202,
-0.1499624997,
-0.3406950533,
0.5900847316,
0.2106143534,
0.4731232822,
-0.2984495759,
0.3400111496,
0.0120770466,
-0.2452574372,
0.0037259299,
0.6344924569,
-0.3981020451,
0.2097585648,
0.3325256407,
0.7260805964,
0.5638566613,
-0.1070704386,
0.7306117415,
0.2151556909,
-0.3797326386,
0.1578553319,
-0.1813491136,
0.1606119275,
0.574123323,
0.5420327187,
0.4179967642,
0.2098591179,
-0.6698574424,
0.3195930123,
0.241583392,
-0.6763602495,
-0.4872077107,
0.4439026415,
0.4456191063,
0.442625314,
0.4046152532,
-0.5429120064,
-0.3851123452,
0.3347039521,
0.5420152545,
0.5826160312,
-0.1719520539,
0.7306904197,
0.1242138371,
0.405068934,
-0.2559753954,
0.0149656478,
0.1388085783,
-1.0802758932,
-0.3486723304,
-0.6187155247,
-0.2410119027,
0.3157142997,
-0.3508653641,
0.3305186927,
-0.2792032957,
0.3531214893,
0.1689258963,
-0.035774909,
-0.4847428799,
-0.0831281096,
0.3343741,
0.948369801,
-0.9015997052,
1.0033849478,
0.5369251966,
-0.5845874548,
-0.7522933483,
0.3441709578,
0.1640673131,
-0.7409564257,
0.5727251172,
0.0089781806,
-0.0409714356,
-0.1788691878,
-0.4764372408,
-0.6414248943,
1.017364502,
0.7925024629,
-0.611513555,
-0.0292211436,
-0.2333403677,
0.5876014233,
-0.5993903875,
-0.060602162,
0.2186633348,
0.4370956123,
0.8069977164,
-0.6679993868,
0.178274408,
0.1709167957,
-0.3225663304,
0.0247942563,
-0.8045507073,
0.9461379051,
-0.3855862916,
-0.2584169507,
0.0067573339,
0.9026225209,
0.0687535033,
0.3925065696,
0.7002393603,
0.2659845948,
0.7731981277,
-0.0962162167,
0.935851872,
-0.4046301842,
0.1971171349,
0.9101057649,
-0.1745142341,
0.6420014501,
0.3228058219,
0.0770131648,
0.7371404767,
0.2653059065,
-0.1122369617,
0.5673359632,
0.1851098537,
-0.3398744762,
-0.3357179761,
-0.6249909997,
-0.2754764557,
0.240261972,
0.2773315907,
-0.328358978,
-0.8124459982,
0.1476227194,
0.2060105354,
0.2101737857,
-0.7107458115,
0.4473984838,
0.0734835342,
-0.372441113,
0.2307097167,
-0.1037781984,
1.0013543367,
-0.6845604777,
-0.0989019945,
-0.3250495791,
0.3375754654,
-0.2111664712,
-0.6610090733,
0.2009236366,
-0.2188063562,
-0.1623301953,
0.0313528143,
1.2550251484,
-0.6721515656,
-0.4172816575,
0.6173431277,
0.704806447,
0.1234223694,
-0.4434567094,
-0.6664286852,
0.2172842324,
-0.0477363132,
-0.0682757273,
0.4666692317,
0.9055258632,
-0.0615898706,
0.283300072,
0.7485575676,
0.3744332492,
-0.2970488369,
0.2951284051,
1.1995475292,
-0.280043304,
-0.7767947912,
-0.549036622,
0.1987071782,
-0.3933441639,
-0.01619922,
0.6288199425,
0.2466339767,
0.6079844236,
0.1978819519,
0.6289286017,
0.2576047778,
0.7240484953,
-0.5495140553,
0.6064968705,
-0.2786235511,
0.4862047136,
-0.3107774258,
-0.6691840887,
-0.1422747523,
0.36356318,
0.1143694744,
-0.100265041,
0.760773778,
0.5717443228,
-0.1983247101,
-0.0272984486,
0.3562014997,
0.554023087,
0.1364495903,
0.4244423211,
0.7364251018,
-0.3030929267,
1.1885911226,
-0.4023272097,
-0.1245717481,
-0.4846998155,
-1.0264239311,
-0.8519442081,
-0.4229241014,
-0.4138048291,
-0.6691461205,
0.4032372832,
0.7156665325,
0.7620454431,
-0.5447283983,
0.2057676911,
-0.0796010569,
0.3247868419,
-0.1660552919,
-0.3178292513,
0.4933238328,
-0.3669489324,
-0.4541902244,
0.4982965291,
0.2195712924,
0.1503801495,
-0.0164773185,
0.1669716984,
-0.1143214777,
0.0862305611,
0.4283809364,
0.5277301669,
-0.3763429523,
-0.5244204998,
-0.3921478689,
-0.307574898,
-0.068674311,
0.7244084477,
-0.94944489,
0.0717704967,
0.1543078423,
0.684980154,
0.5711413026,
-0.0351894908,
0.1669168174,
-1.1166136265,
0.7652570605,
0.0289038569,
0.4428552389,
0.4195917845,
-0.499846071,
0.5564591885,
0.7048653364,
-0.0871142372,
-0.5381770134,
-0.0355592445,
-1.1288280487,
-0.479398638,
1.2409182787,
0.2189647108,
-0.1790064424,
-0.1680087745,
0.0291677006,
-0.0028939052,
-0.7012599707,
0.9187728167,
0.5203769803,
-0.0049644844,
-0.2095001191,
-0.1610253602,
0.7582233548,
-0.1751627028,
-0.7618424296,
-0.0398175791,
0.4854414761,
0.3705097437,
0.4708802998,
1.0379805565,
-0.0781028867,
0.4096720517,
0.1735982895,
0.06667009,
-0.2548136115,
-0.365373075,
-0.2307100743,
0.3392074704,
-0.2851933241,
-0.2121984363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01487v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01487v2 | To ChatGPT, or not to ChatGPT: That is the question! | 2023-04-04T03:04:28 | 2023-04-05T04:28:41 | Alessandro Pegoraro, Kavita Kumari, Hossein Fereidooni, Ahmad-Reza Sadeghi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | ChatGPT has become a global sensation. As ChatGPT and other Large Language
Models (LLMs) emerge, concerns of misusing them in various ways increase, such
as disseminating fake news, plagiarism, manipulating public opinion, cheating,
and fraud. Hence, distinguishing AI-generated from human-generated becomes
increasingly essential. Researchers have proposed various detection
methodologies, ranging from basic binary classifiers to more complex
deep-learning models. Some detection techniques rely on statistical
characteristics or syntactic patterns, while others incorporate semantic or
contextual information to improve accuracy. The primary objective of this study
is to provide a comprehensive and contemporary assessment of the most recent
techniques in ChatGPT detection. Additionally, we evaluated other AI-generated
text detection tools that do not specifically claim to detect ChatGPT-generated
content to assess their performance in detecting ChatGPT-generated content. For
our evaluation, we have curated a benchmark dataset consisting of prompts from
ChatGPT and humans, including diverse questions from medical, open Q&A, and
finance domains and user-generated responses from popular social networking
platforms. The dataset serves as a reference to assess the performance of
various techniques in detecting ChatGPT-generated content. Our evaluation
results demonstrate that none of the existing methods can effectively detect
ChatGPT-generated content. | [
-0.3194447458,
-1.2291581631,
0.3700432181,
0.0719582364,
-0.3148303926,
0.2758473754,
-0.2882001698,
-0.4792901874,
-0.1659379154,
0.4032306075,
-0.3786517382,
-0.4815571606,
-0.7614432573,
0.0844517797,
-0.6274715066,
1.0747857094,
0.1378745139,
-0.1433307827,
-0.1660470366,
0.3242668808,
-0.298987329,
-0.5014615059,
-0.9793462157,
-0.3519586027,
0.3604724109,
0.3174121678,
0.4556691647,
0.2311873585,
0.5334517956,
0.2660196424,
-0.2344852835,
0.3630931079,
-0.4570204616,
-0.0039677094,
0.1709044427,
-0.262137562,
-0.119059585,
0.0421014726,
0.4386835396,
-0.0592656769,
-0.0612871684,
0.143787235,
0.0940071866,
0.4789248109,
-0.4083147943,
0.2601208985,
-0.8286724091,
0.1249542534,
-0.5473891497,
-0.3421369493,
-0.5637663603,
-0.3202147782,
0.076183252,
-0.0621373951,
0.3489918709,
0.1112939492,
0.731982708,
0.1485091597,
-0.3156831264,
-0.885003686,
-0.6085431576,
0.4441253543,
-0.6166190505,
0.3077412546,
0.2684403658,
0.4088548124,
-0.3839833736,
-0.8279801607,
-0.8587675691,
-0.4680933058,
-0.1355932504,
0.0888446346,
-0.5218636394,
-0.1797185689,
0.1665471792,
0.3057500124,
-0.8634596467,
0.1104815006,
-0.1777289063,
-0.4857036173,
0.621576786,
-0.0334768482,
0.8006070256,
-0.492790997,
-0.3260348737,
-0.2425082475,
-0.6979268193,
-0.1016390994,
0.4501031339,
0.0055042882,
-0.1721653044,
0.5062849522,
-0.1053735167,
0.4242556989,
-0.0969832167,
-0.2622654736,
0.0858367756,
-0.3227764368,
-0.0072461884,
0.0216340795,
1.1859660149,
0.274340868,
0.7288856506,
-0.236926198,
-0.1289564371,
0.1227070093,
0.0805195644,
-0.6272298098,
-0.4045662582,
-0.0185862239,
-0.389298737,
-0.5516559482,
-0.1013209671,
-0.6216772795,
-0.7359278202,
0.0656431094,
0.0174854361,
-0.4200432003,
-0.3592938185,
-0.1004090384,
-0.2443997562,
0.5632610321,
0.2438468933,
-0.718077004,
0.0195802618,
0.7857549191,
0.7396802902,
-0.4846597612,
-0.025424093,
-0.2556386888,
-0.2334766537,
-0.3338989019,
1.3361997604,
-0.4379631281,
-0.2255397439,
-0.1085047126,
-0.0644901022,
-0.0026422467,
-0.6090907454,
0.7406435609,
-0.4476000071,
0.5245431066,
-0.2510198057,
-0.6604732275,
-0.0318288356,
0.3468610048,
-0.4236213565,
1.0442222357,
-0.0518654324,
-1.0091239214,
0.6485693455,
-0.6736189723,
-0.5063297153,
0.2727332413,
-0.2304177135,
-0.6746064425,
-0.2192916721,
0.4017805755,
0.5811455846,
-0.2962881923,
0.475010097,
0.0009406402,
-0.4438042045,
0.4826906323,
-1.0354214907,
0.4430480003,
0.2927016616,
-0.2747887969,
-0.0843543708,
-0.5509114265,
-0.100429289,
0.3438895941,
-0.3005100191,
0.1486371607,
0.2231052518,
0.1803691536,
0.0084885303,
0.101798825,
-0.4786222279,
0.0358776227,
-0.1320382953,
0.6470884085,
0.6410394907,
0.1901141703,
0.044776205,
-0.4383461177,
0.5757062435,
0.0288886372,
-0.1321659684,
-0.1988316178,
-0.8498418331,
-0.5283991098,
-0.2221850902,
0.1349651068,
0.7360616326,
-0.6544950008,
0.4599170983,
-0.1121623069,
-0.6900780201,
-0.1071781367,
-0.0117401062,
0.2809221745,
0.4856008589,
0.1811667532,
-0.2535649836,
-0.2715511918,
-0.6844462156,
-0.5628625751,
-0.4335901737,
-0.2141692787,
0.4029579461,
0.4125820994,
-0.1204081848,
0.7381783128,
-0.3655633926,
0.0340543762,
-0.3701822162,
0.326795727,
-0.1060776114,
0.2860515118,
0.5352470279,
-0.7351232171,
-0.7585033774,
-0.0418101139,
-0.6762156487,
-0.2698245049,
-0.2644117177,
0.1128706858,
0.0563320704,
0.485674113,
-0.5949793458,
0.4420482814,
0.300090909,
-0.268625021,
0.4849180579,
0.076823853,
0.2432296425,
-0.9529106617,
0.0323486552,
0.1342336982,
-0.3294399977,
-0.6848930717,
-0.1692268699,
-0.0325335972,
-0.1081330031,
-0.3686283529,
0.6693615317,
-0.2427154481,
0.0259421691,
-0.3213866651,
0.2993735075,
-0.1983127892,
0.3512202799,
0.018333951,
1.0462243557,
0.3575991392,
-0.2705392241,
0.5497088432,
0.2652868927,
-0.4805029631,
0.4491185546,
-0.8111819625,
0.4160456657,
-0.2367452681,
0.4057029188,
-1.3182606697,
-0.2756001353,
0.8058900833,
-0.8119642735,
0.1449474245,
-0.3117516935,
-0.7754862905,
-0.0812892988,
-0.1240294725,
0.0643117577,
0.7633761764,
-0.4451494813,
0.2744068503,
0.2878286839,
-0.2542893887,
-0.3918025792,
-0.5018018484,
0.3373925686,
-0.3398299515,
-0.8314573765,
0.045257438,
0.08736936,
-0.1861363798,
-0.2325746715,
0.0368504152,
-0.0910774916,
0.1628838927,
0.1041638777,
0.0375063121,
-0.2193024009,
0.0662408397,
-0.1835296601,
-0.2094573826,
-0.0718820915,
-0.0325556211,
0.9647025466,
-0.012909973,
-0.5804755092,
-0.5927159786,
0.0856386572,
0.4617239535,
-0.2080706954,
0.4923678041,
1.0914440155,
-0.0550932847,
-0.1272955686,
-0.7247179151,
-0.1486388445,
-0.4807703495,
0.3130942285,
0.18168962,
-0.7777455449,
0.3475362957,
0.0891259015,
-0.0856983289,
0.2174216658,
0.7994449735,
-0.0202817712,
1.0200396776,
0.1995615661,
-0.2720928788,
0.6735183597,
0.1497317106,
0.5533951521,
-0.514611721,
-0.1189992726,
-0.4890889227,
-0.1209484115,
-1.0175695419,
-0.3774294555,
0.1778690964,
-0.2805311382,
-0.0355987959,
0.3178747296,
-0.5183327794,
0.5189483166,
0.5759885907,
0.0971978679,
0.3293488622,
0.0512937754,
0.2847637534,
0.2118906528,
-0.5699477196,
-0.7906316519,
1.1286455393,
0.2571300864,
0.573451221,
-0.0834971294,
0.4385539591,
0.7534244657,
0.3706936538,
-0.77673316,
0.6058797836,
-0.1607467085,
-0.3814404011,
-0.1727689058,
-0.3825683296,
-1.1595985889,
0.1408940107,
-0.28764534,
-0.7816698551,
-0.4445905387,
0.0620003939,
-0.0232686177,
0.3281669915,
-0.8145840764,
0.8598228693,
-0.0717869103,
-0.0605465323,
0.0467246622,
-0.2117030919,
0.2428519428,
0.0181512181,
0.0325377695,
-0.3356536925,
0.1775681973,
0.4893978834,
-0.0292600673,
0.788223505,
0.0503547229,
-0.171953246,
0.5967735648,
-0.0688916519,
0.6801776886,
0.08505328,
0.3062706888,
0.1546506137,
-0.1976064146,
-0.3642112911,
-0.3031365573,
0.3103857338,
-0.5769597292,
-0.3688756824,
-0.2810774744,
-0.2871833444,
0.028491566,
0.1055978984,
0.5101754069,
0.3439733982,
-0.3689600527,
0.1125685722,
0.4431865811,
-0.6022601724,
0.4488893747,
0.3104735911,
0.0892468542,
-0.0460998677,
1.0444611311,
-0.3048791289,
0.0280103032,
0.2348193526,
0.3212313354,
-0.2283878773,
-0.7026372552,
-0.5459674597,
0.163863644,
-0.5629612207,
0.023064347,
-0.4830541015,
-0.4130904078,
-0.4928177297,
0.0484670885,
-0.20428738,
0.0772843361,
-0.157487914,
0.1790175289,
0.3463007808,
0.5797730088,
0.2629415393,
0.4896691144,
-0.7526817322,
0.2955000103,
0.2136143893,
-0.0200708397,
-0.1369212568,
-0.2838466763,
0.3407877386,
0.1540088356,
-0.398534745,
-0.6582157612,
0.3940833807,
0.1467974931,
0.5839262009,
0.4512541592,
0.0003632336,
0.2001804113,
-0.3706280887,
0.9859939218,
-0.0542567819,
-0.6003164649,
0.4227926731,
-0.4416992664,
0.1091183499,
0.0708631948,
0.3304953277,
-0.9211508036,
-0.4549729824,
-0.6417633891,
-0.4258463681,
0.3038240671,
0.4426300526,
0.3887991011,
-0.1860834062,
0.2398694605,
-0.0359038189,
0.2269967943,
-0.7781971693,
0.0902020037,
0.0807265341,
-0.1728126407,
0.1121253669,
-0.1474167109,
0.327658385,
0.3547821045,
0.3368580341,
-0.0267247241,
0.374145031,
-0.0204116106,
-0.179462716,
0.1767161638,
0.2844740152,
0.6106804013,
0.5254288316,
0.0335155986,
-0.0947393775,
-0.0154775605,
-0.6024275422,
-0.117875278,
-0.057601586,
-0.3058216274,
0.0027294052,
0.6846758723,
0.5482407212,
-0.1640661806,
-0.9632341862,
0.7487341762,
-0.2705339491,
-0.0769915655,
-0.462264061,
0.3971479535,
-0.120609872,
0.2130268812,
0.1310463995,
0.039274063,
0.1197731793,
-0.6427251101,
0.3134497404,
0.6964740157,
-0.3240279555,
-0.3199104667,
0.4045108855,
0.1001878008,
-0.440266639,
0.7525551915,
-0.1693322212,
-0.708142221,
0.5518395901,
0.2563335299,
0.8126025796,
0.1315806657,
0.3721930683,
0.1723650098,
0.2588879168,
0.0091612749,
0.0926954374,
-0.2188569158,
-1.1557383537,
-0.3346324563,
-0.2055667639,
-0.4316703081,
0.3534344137,
-0.2835458219,
0.4295189083,
-0.3404061198,
-0.0876127407,
0.2245405763,
-0.1042303219,
-0.6195101738,
-0.1074251756,
0.335647881,
0.541775763,
-0.8741616607,
0.5346909165,
0.4463207424,
-0.3339137137,
-0.4606029689,
0.4095526636,
0.262263447,
-1.1920875311,
0.3384840488,
0.1406550109,
0.0726869702,
-0.057973817,
-0.8533949256,
-0.4164607227,
0.8966894746,
0.1701453477,
-0.1234651729,
-0.0779273957,
0.4175070524,
0.5335235596,
0.0515580513,
0.4628944695,
0.6204407811,
0.3874176145,
0.2058326453,
-0.9328543544,
-0.1710990369,
-0.151789248,
-0.3238229454,
0.1794762164,
-0.7227247357,
0.7456392646,
0.2178036273,
-0.4280878305,
0.110434778,
0.1924733222,
0.2698403299,
0.4053688943,
0.3787643313,
0.2842180729,
0.7494442463,
-0.2712677717,
1.0128499269,
-0.2511926591,
0.2832021713,
0.6291828156,
-0.2069054991,
0.6114432216,
0.0794754699,
-0.1876874417,
0.3318469226,
0.7284537554,
-0.3517129421,
0.2514460087,
0.4196770489,
-0.2742629647,
-0.2129532397,
-0.1986524314,
-0.3149006367,
0.736813128,
0.3802779019,
-0.2693057954,
-0.3571257293,
-0.1665359885,
0.2018517703,
-0.0943540633,
0.0648824722,
1.1688191891,
-0.1165701896,
-0.7707226276,
0.4748963416,
-0.0638389662,
0.8475272059,
-0.3696047664,
-0.1127225384,
-0.3113218844,
0.0363685489,
-0.0342700966,
-0.7736096382,
0.0695784613,
0.3466049135,
0.2835388184,
-0.045346234,
1.240914464,
-0.206518814,
-0.2374378294,
-0.1380420029,
0.7213279009,
0.442050606,
-0.3395524621,
-0.5968093276,
-0.1014564484,
-0.0230995137,
-0.1521061808,
0.2617012262,
0.6130177379,
0.018676823,
0.8424652815,
0.8136740327,
0.0088202599,
-0.1032448187,
-0.0660532564,
0.6636311412,
-0.371297121,
-0.3934569359,
-1.0207010508,
0.201729089,
-0.3258627951,
-0.3041880131,
0.7832936049,
0.3588265181,
0.8284380436,
0.0343414173,
1.0398119688,
-0.0001724901,
0.5357153416,
-0.5946770906,
0.7485643029,
-0.2184774429,
0.3963953257,
-0.4456284642,
-0.7124267817,
-0.0495405309,
0.6011139154,
-0.3982586265,
0.1622542888,
0.4012956917,
0.8462227583,
-0.006283544,
0.2619085312,
0.199406758,
-0.2679596543,
0.6230455041,
0.3352383375,
1.3717234135,
-0.262003541,
0.7205588222,
0.1823066771,
-0.0784395561,
-0.2664423585,
-1.054577589,
-1.1616526842,
-0.3569954038,
-0.4007421434,
-0.0957217067,
0.0132935029,
0.6455354095,
0.6737588048,
-0.8343915343,
0.1016104519,
-0.2633001804,
0.1305480152,
0.037811555,
-0.2300095111,
0.3049664497,
-0.2669613659,
-0.652692914,
0.2522432506,
0.0314457417,
0.1403987706,
-0.1731929034,
0.2622311413,
0.1059818119,
0.0326804854,
0.5298262239,
0.2420999706,
-0.6567795277,
-0.4483105838,
0.0996479988,
-0.0523761883,
0.2367305309,
0.8139478564,
-0.5114737749,
0.1383199394,
0.6914876103,
0.6026186943,
0.3417875767,
0.1630485803,
0.4150564671,
-0.7463818192,
0.1282004267,
0.2832920551,
0.1322011948,
0.3741252124,
-0.3847215772,
0.4593129158,
0.3274670243,
-0.7697988749,
-0.5913830996,
0.1622562855,
-0.8322540522,
-0.1050047576,
1.0990847349,
-0.1247531772,
0.0551025681,
-0.1692527235,
-0.5300866365,
0.169253096,
-0.5920664072,
0.8208401203,
0.8000555038,
-0.2362570465,
-0.2377830297,
-0.7177915573,
0.5285203457,
0.0173382685,
-1.0047272444,
0.1175766364,
0.4440095425,
0.4202771187,
-0.0117565617,
0.6314355731,
-0.1021331474,
0.2529331148,
-0.1130642071,
-0.107010074,
0.1936544627,
0.0172080025,
0.102737084,
0.0180549864,
0.0407055095,
-0.0658139512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01483v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01483v2 | Blockwise Compression of Transformer-based Models without Retraining | 2023-04-04T02:55:40 | 2023-09-17T22:47:50 | Gaochen Dong, Wei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Transformer-based models, exemplified by GPT-3, ChatGPT, and GPT-4, have
recently garnered considerable attention in both academia and industry due to
their promising performance in general language tasks. Nevertheless, these
models typically involve computationally encoding processes, and in some cases,
decoding processes as well, both of which are fundamentally large-scale matrix
multiplication. These operations bring the inevitable challenges of massive
computation resources and huge memory footprint, usually requiring at least
10^23 FLOPs and hundreds of gigabytes, respectively. A common method to address
this issue is to reduce the computational and memory requirements by applying
layerwise quantization to the transformer, replacing the usual fp32 data type
with a low-bit equivalent. Unfortunately, this method often leads to decreased
model accuracy and necessitates time-consuming retraining. Such retraining not
only requires fine-tuning skills but also substantial computational resources,
posing challenges for users. To specifically tackle these issues, we propose
BCT, a framework of blockwise compression for transformers without retraining,
aiming to facilitate model deployment. Unlike layerwise compression methods,
BCT achieves finer compression of the entire transformer by operating
blockwise. This method mitigates data distribution deviation caused by
quantization, eliminating the requirement for retraining. BCT effectively
compresses all components of the model, including but not limited to the
embedding, matrix multiplication, GELU, Softmax, layer normalization, and
intermediate results. In a case study, an efficient model is compressed by BCT
achieving up to 7.988x compression. Subsequently, we also evaluate it on
several General Language Understanding Evaluation (GLUE) datasets. | [
-0.4772399664,
-0.6325357556,
0.4272038937,
0.3290680051,
-0.4561425745,
0.1473752856,
-0.350654006,
-0.2952577472,
-0.0147501826,
0.3622035384,
-0.5005907416,
-0.2790756524,
-0.577439189,
-0.2084496915,
-0.5187420249,
0.8844810724,
-0.1776773185,
-0.1908720732,
0.0481090136,
0.3821030855,
-0.6925421953,
-0.3475356698,
-0.6596593857,
-0.365142405,
0.1228665411,
0.0832319856,
0.7438808084,
0.6621956229,
0.2198141962,
0.2413384318,
0.0900734216,
-0.0157038663,
-0.3178888857,
0.034584146,
-0.0656251609,
-0.2581282556,
-0.2859113812,
-0.1702548712,
0.5472529531,
0.5160995722,
-0.4602929056,
0.1024399251,
-0.0041385842,
0.665861547,
-0.7117771506,
0.3038731217,
-0.7066878676,
0.093339555,
0.337574631,
-0.0929142237,
-0.6289302707,
-0.3907529116,
-0.1236386672,
-0.3538046181,
0.7303817272,
0.0240660384,
0.7841659188,
0.3023693562,
-0.4597277939,
0.2715489566,
-0.8454411626,
0.7085182071,
-0.533642292,
0.7649598718,
0.3200042844,
0.3510552049,
0.1253602356,
-0.6563895345,
-0.545666635,
0.2542923987,
-0.2048598528,
0.0940654501,
-0.5749486685,
0.3024681211,
0.2327859253,
0.5553951263,
-0.7268449664,
-0.0390926898,
-0.4634311795,
-0.2648004293,
0.4400615692,
0.08513432,
-0.1591096818,
-0.2731058896,
-0.3479922414,
-0.3631210029,
-0.7272293568,
-0.1701571941,
0.4054928124,
0.2570594549,
-0.2022091001,
0.260366708,
-0.1866591871,
0.8017120957,
0.2077428699,
0.1135557219,
0.005561512,
-0.2033570111,
-0.5061017871,
-0.1368206143,
0.862490654,
0.0908721834,
0.070599556,
-0.4274668097,
-0.388625443,
0.2345307767,
0.6630608439,
-1.2151577473,
-0.4598045051,
0.4421460927,
-0.3015125394,
-0.2740626037,
-0.1418084055,
-0.6961593032,
-0.1165361032,
-0.3660382628,
0.7059025764,
-0.394525677,
-0.2336598784,
0.258877486,
-0.0507001393,
0.1130511612,
0.2758944631,
-1.1893749237,
0.4342897236,
0.5500380993,
0.9226671457,
0.0204886198,
0.0964781046,
-0.2396631241,
0.0869030729,
-0.163191095,
0.7212164402,
-0.3376094699,
-0.5004256368,
-0.1698486507,
-0.0645502433,
0.0037902871,
-0.5723100901,
0.5909190774,
-0.458743751,
-0.1687753648,
0.0907098949,
-0.168380931,
-0.1245819256,
0.2040144652,
-0.6755405068,
0.747911036,
0.3945196569,
-0.6558569074,
0.0809840038,
-0.3012215793,
-0.449601382,
-0.218898192,
-0.0896515548,
-0.6864362955,
0.4481292963,
0.5162869096,
0.5938798785,
-0.607450068,
0.3720084131,
-0.0179261602,
-0.4976511598,
0.0069029513,
-0.6397412419,
0.3747029901,
0.1958259344,
-0.3572028279,
0.1531080902,
-0.648966074,
0.2059487998,
-0.0977735445,
-0.1928709298,
0.1487282515,
-0.347758323,
0.1443848163,
0.4179249704,
-0.0586208031,
-0.5379325151,
0.5291848183,
0.0410063714,
0.680475533,
0.7076531053,
-0.0581786036,
0.1916718632,
-0.2716947496,
0.649815321,
0.0386112258,
0.3940317929,
-0.1110788807,
-0.3598366082,
-0.7784839869,
-0.301846087,
0.414989531,
0.4746657312,
-0.9280461669,
0.4049695134,
-0.6559817195,
-0.7784706354,
-0.5462723374,
-0.2407282442,
0.2655685544,
0.3302994072,
0.787353456,
-0.2468123883,
-0.4652701616,
-1.1106539965,
0.1517947912,
0.0160227977,
-0.3534929156,
-0.0406125896,
0.2460132837,
-0.1062871292,
0.8523671031,
-0.5916448832,
0.0864954367,
-0.213751331,
0.4835111797,
0.1900361925,
0.8087679148,
-0.1601459533,
-0.831104219,
-0.3478311002,
0.0641474351,
-0.2975003123,
-0.1645848006,
-0.1728255898,
0.0698892996,
0.1049146056,
0.1448098272,
-0.8746339679,
0.7071868181,
0.8891280293,
-0.0034975563,
0.8954354525,
-0.1329641342,
0.1664737016,
-0.8627768159,
0.1722057909,
-0.0536702685,
-0.4410344958,
-0.8693093657,
-0.0135429632,
0.4946340024,
-0.331856221,
-0.4357391596,
0.1064564884,
-0.4319698215,
0.0651922151,
-0.3391185403,
-0.1778165102,
0.1525150836,
0.810313642,
0.4485304654,
0.7985687852,
0.3378906548,
-0.4777505696,
-0.0412003733,
0.1266448051,
-0.1276552528,
0.5610078573,
-0.8191388249,
0.4070162475,
0.0890710577,
0.4779892862,
-0.3241789341,
0.2365557551,
0.109176375,
-0.1107501537,
0.6292564273,
-0.4574331343,
-0.4994017482,
-0.4209813178,
-0.3399576843,
0.7230433822,
0.6347911954,
-0.382714957,
0.717520535,
-0.0156893283,
0.2652563453,
-0.6984791756,
-0.7759639621,
-0.2113136351,
-0.1848759949,
-0.7056041956,
0.7515538931,
-0.1792834699,
0.3409477174,
-0.0965969488,
-0.5919556618,
-0.2082385719,
-0.2332697809,
0.3386652768,
0.2746264637,
0.0264255814,
-0.1524711996,
0.1448047459,
-0.2501751781,
-0.0659703612,
-0.7301539779,
0.7953009009,
-0.0564637929,
-0.1709278375,
-0.3303987384,
0.3454928398,
0.2210627943,
-0.0586015061,
0.6714152694,
0.8681222796,
-0.3181731403,
-0.3198405504,
-0.7081685662,
-0.1825703681,
-0.5025291443,
0.1486454904,
-0.4003899693,
-1.1643658876,
0.4335420132,
0.0877458751,
-0.2026023865,
0.2072191089,
0.4959715903,
0.4014112055,
0.7413745522,
0.6547946334,
0.0282426216,
0.2917971611,
-0.3672775626,
0.5308426023,
-0.9188901782,
-0.0377082527,
-0.4017237723,
-0.4530190527,
-0.658836484,
-0.6261637807,
0.3989130557,
0.0666472688,
-0.409583658,
0.8311402202,
-0.8500794768,
0.4568935931,
0.38730371,
0.2756300271,
0.2720850408,
-0.1670426279,
0.225972563,
0.1640378237,
-0.7105704546,
0.0360419005,
1.0785326958,
0.2241426855,
0.757940352,
0.1474580765,
0.6674610972,
0.1079868972,
0.2045791298,
-0.7806196213,
0.3806332052,
0.1513660252,
-0.5207784772,
-0.1199114844,
-0.8304963708,
-1.018420577,
0.2286496162,
-0.0576576293,
-1.0006986856,
0.4558530748,
0.2914568186,
-0.3904612362,
0.5067136884,
-0.8018938899,
0.8532696366,
0.2566165924,
-0.3969425559,
-0.3683604598,
-0.6339759827,
0.5245248079,
-0.3899513483,
0.1124407277,
0.2258950323,
0.2032206357,
0.4256338775,
-0.627040565,
0.6978979111,
-0.1643855572,
-0.0031710831,
0.2351402342,
0.3450086117,
0.5986020565,
-0.112706691,
0.2730142176,
0.2600532472,
0.1590692848,
-0.5692614913,
-0.9820799828,
0.5011458397,
-0.6190825701,
-0.6243863106,
-0.0949088633,
-0.7683631778,
-0.2739581764,
-0.0453094952,
0.2483677268,
0.4677816927,
0.1499799341,
0.0469891801,
0.5498055816,
-0.1211105958,
0.3748509288,
0.114465341,
-0.1999174505,
-0.4778820872,
1.0405737162,
-0.0312532037,
0.5780845881,
0.6071561575,
0.0479805134,
-0.2151186764,
-0.8331165314,
-0.1925888211,
0.186025396,
-0.5893995762,
-0.7424423695,
-0.4921391308,
-0.2752474844,
-0.298753649,
-0.2484231889,
-0.5872620344,
-0.6259242892,
0.342168808,
-0.0438748673,
0.1909731328,
0.617074132,
-0.2708670795,
0.6650617719,
-0.7485836744,
0.2455213815,
0.4228643179,
0.5133312345,
0.0895119458,
-0.4287882745,
-0.6667150855,
-0.1836564988,
-0.6391037703,
-0.6746124029,
0.4688504338,
-0.1295061111,
0.0780278966,
0.2661359906,
0.0915347561,
0.8650032282,
-0.5508891344,
0.6404824257,
0.1429816186,
-1.3791028261,
0.2262043357,
-0.2229949087,
0.2218415737,
0.3918174803,
0.3948464394,
-0.6769934893,
-0.0729977041,
-0.7932617664,
-0.9599604607,
0.4959890246,
0.4019398093,
-0.0319885612,
0.1553985775,
0.173326686,
0.1691204607,
0.4488166869,
-0.7474858165,
-0.0939079896,
-0.6557876468,
-0.0921725482,
0.2139749527,
-0.0731368735,
0.112280257,
-0.2768033445,
0.7655676603,
-0.1058044955,
0.7330694199,
0.10109815,
-0.3072249889,
0.1552511305,
0.3883774579,
0.3983802497,
0.3172120452,
-0.3830773234,
0.389983058,
0.0835537612,
-0.7341285348,
0.3955543339,
0.2135881484,
-0.0368572436,
-0.2194644064,
0.0466109402,
0.8983365893,
0.4747265577,
-0.2936665714,
0.4827771187,
-0.0560312681,
-0.1575310677,
-0.0142742749,
-0.0789739788,
-0.0849033073,
0.2533932626,
0.2711293697,
0.102760531,
0.0836477429,
-0.0911967382,
0.1346429139,
0.3098056018,
-0.1965147704,
-0.5201814771,
0.6062384844,
-0.1039391384,
-0.0642563105,
0.8215202093,
-0.1720680445,
-0.4720674157,
0.0905766338,
0.6983616948,
0.9418717027,
-0.2647548318,
0.1265133172,
0.3789013326,
0.5085327029,
-0.2143526524,
-0.1312872618,
-0.3463916779,
-0.7458195686,
-0.8556796908,
-0.564676106,
-0.4792065918,
0.1714030057,
-0.6598550677,
0.3921231925,
-0.6132129431,
-0.0717074722,
-0.2389893681,
-0.0027536661,
-0.8017500639,
0.3275938332,
0.0827945024,
0.9930679798,
-0.7046083808,
1.2094230652,
-0.1156338155,
-0.3262448311,
-1.1029089689,
-0.1747633666,
-0.1974948347,
-0.6436707973,
0.2172807604,
0.2785833776,
0.0094011799,
0.1975320876,
-0.2894645929,
-0.5292775035,
1.2795330286,
0.5183520317,
-0.5239915848,
-0.1011768579,
0.2071591616,
0.2255185097,
0.0063233818,
0.5529139042,
0.6811535954,
0.5702878237,
0.0385894403,
-0.9011901021,
0.2955830991,
-0.2761955857,
0.1661971807,
0.4875894785,
-0.5337122679,
0.8332597613,
0.2669046819,
-0.2568879426,
-0.1657770872,
0.5715173483,
0.1360026151,
-0.2674967349,
0.5270030499,
0.6064507961,
0.6418415904,
-0.267771244,
1.1166988611,
-0.4397910833,
0.6066526175,
0.7008693814,
0.1785873622,
0.6404806376,
0.4257563055,
-0.3981086016,
0.4809373617,
0.4606542587,
-0.0954751372,
0.3936358988,
0.3467645347,
-0.3066172004,
-0.3385283053,
0.1546752602,
-0.2849652469,
0.162427932,
0.1185190082,
0.0036685376,
-0.0698158592,
-0.3228499293,
0.2003378719,
-0.3179165721,
-0.3011614382,
0.1379355192,
0.0802194923,
-0.3572792113,
0.8955598474,
0.0791254118,
0.8432258368,
-0.7230444551,
0.1695936471,
-0.2173151672,
-0.1495208889,
-0.3000923693,
-0.4558402002,
0.5915570855,
-0.1228928566,
-0.2867661715,
-0.4138061106,
0.616957128,
-0.2721816301,
-0.3326885402,
-0.04585943,
0.3961862028,
0.0954095796,
-0.4881245494,
-0.2707493901,
0.2312942296,
0.0279963333,
-0.335342437,
0.3401481211,
0.2980106771,
-0.0814275518,
0.6768992543,
0.6791862249,
0.0702239722,
-0.1029493809,
-0.1109552309,
1.0045177937,
-0.6896526814,
-0.3290880024,
-0.7528884411,
0.6251799464,
0.1590479761,
0.0559977852,
0.3492637277,
0.5116894245,
0.7115278244,
-0.0758509412,
0.7069275975,
-0.058262784,
-0.060658548,
-0.6232527494,
0.5472803712,
-0.1992958933,
0.2541675866,
-0.3178685009,
-1.0092391968,
-0.5241292119,
0.5309101939,
-0.361753732,
0.1178112105,
0.8583298922,
0.7400835156,
-0.3686739504,
0.2111230046,
0.4059283137,
0.0068724714,
0.4660665393,
0.8455377221,
0.5455708504,
-0.4231325686,
0.6387747526,
-0.4324203134,
-0.004383415,
0.1402700692,
-1.0102939606,
-0.7040555477,
-0.6211757064,
-0.3312570453,
-0.2367142588,
-0.1498057693,
0.971858561,
0.9949679375,
-0.6141074896,
-0.195767194,
-0.2353155464,
-0.0005801271,
-0.431288749,
-0.1873879582,
0.5540648103,
-0.0367165804,
-0.7287842631,
0.4505169094,
0.1253158003,
0.1201583073,
-0.4193996489,
0.0549174547,
0.3416958153,
0.0656481534,
0.513782084,
0.1279393584,
-0.2368752807,
-0.4729996026,
-0.2347078174,
0.3993332684,
0.3126388788,
0.9924017787,
-1.1713951826,
0.216073975,
0.252872169,
0.6204129457,
1.1307137012,
-0.0359564126,
0.6691849232,
-0.9743802547,
0.3167880177,
0.1590265334,
0.2949827909,
0.5495066047,
-0.2416607738,
0.5700650811,
0.3015679717,
-0.7313172221,
-0.7655892372,
0.3509403467,
-1.1896243095,
-0.0974329337,
0.8797325492,
-0.0901660696,
-0.2550106347,
0.0180045757,
-0.0638179109,
0.4144501388,
-0.4595419168,
0.8084560037,
0.4514597058,
-0.066600956,
-0.470023483,
-0.555521667,
0.2909200788,
0.1615130156,
-0.6662136316,
0.2459273189,
0.2801046669,
0.0949203596,
0.0731818676,
0.3543595672,
0.0646754578,
0.0299268272,
0.0828690678,
0.4938647151,
-0.2828131914,
-0.2652771473,
-0.4935972393,
0.1865205169,
-0.2136947364,
-0.0402780473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01481v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01481v1 | The Vector Grounding Problem | 2023-04-04T02:54:04 | 2023-04-04T02:54:04 | Dimitri Coelho Mollo, Raphaël Millière | cs.CL | cs.CL | The remarkable performance of large language models (LLMs) on complex
linguistic tasks has sparked a lively debate on the nature of their
capabilities. Unlike humans, these models learn language exclusively from
textual data, without direct interaction with the real world. Nevertheless,
they can generate seemingly meaningful text about a wide range of topics. This
impressive accomplishment has rekindled interest in the classical 'Symbol
Grounding Problem,' which questioned whether the internal representations and
outputs of classical symbolic AI systems could possess intrinsic meaning.
Unlike these systems, modern LLMs are artificial neural networks that compute
over vectors rather than symbols. However, an analogous problem arises for such
systems, which we dub the Vector Grounding Problem. This paper has two primary
objectives. First, we differentiate various ways in which internal
representations can be grounded in biological or artificial systems,
identifying five distinct notions discussed in the literature: referential,
sensorimotor, relational, communicative, and epistemic grounding.
Unfortunately, these notions of grounding are often conflated. We clarify the
differences between them, and argue that referential grounding is the one that
lies at the heart of the Vector Grounding Problem. Second, drawing on theories
of representational content in philosophy and cognitive science, we propose
that certain LLMs, particularly those fine-tuned with Reinforcement Learning
from Human Feedback (RLHF), possess the necessary features to overcome the
Vector Grounding Problem, as they stand in the requisite causal-historical
relations to the world that underpin intrinsic meaning. We also argue that,
perhaps unexpectedly, multimodality and embodiment are neither necessary nor
sufficient conditions for referential grounding in artificial systems. | [
-0.3604261577,
-0.5633952022,
0.7484266758,
0.187901631,
-0.3899514377,
0.2134609669,
-0.2237855047,
-0.2373077422,
0.0625600144,
0.1073717773,
-0.3260832429,
-0.1866913885,
-0.7471144795,
0.0040044114,
-0.3456281722,
0.6640905142,
-0.1910787225,
0.2414195538,
-0.5654369593,
-0.486890316,
-0.6367595792,
-1.0044184923,
-0.45491907,
-0.8966044784,
0.4930349886,
0.0685167164,
0.5987546444,
0.7367826104,
0.4503901601,
0.2865483165,
-0.2788873017,
0.0170591157,
-0.605666399,
0.2762429118,
-0.1566466838,
-0.8706227541,
0.3407211602,
0.2311243862,
0.6341720223,
0.8160177469,
0.3419596553,
-0.2430399507,
-0.0833125338,
0.8016409874,
-0.4062468112,
0.2578647435,
-0.4062057436,
0.4366025329,
0.2582276464,
-0.3430215716,
-0.1018872187,
-0.2188383639,
-0.1920878142,
-0.4846949577,
-0.0741407797,
0.1708391756,
0.9994265437,
0.4995417893,
-0.2582755387,
-0.1594871432,
-0.8390115499,
0.7703790665,
-0.3327846229,
0.4548529387,
0.324324578,
0.0334556326,
-0.2495554835,
-0.2030929923,
-0.6237906814,
-0.6811931133,
0.0423446372,
0.1774152368,
-0.1272311062,
0.0953827128,
0.5552015305,
0.2384738028,
-0.017936524,
-0.0917628035,
-0.4535866082,
0.001515132,
0.0631883666,
-0.0503721572,
0.5414863229,
-0.2256227583,
-0.3775608242,
-0.1124741435,
-0.91346246,
0.3137820363,
0.1153678447,
0.1606315523,
-0.0444252416,
0.7192355394,
0.0732651651,
0.4283893406,
0.1877459139,
0.1621289551,
-0.0853657648,
0.203236118,
-0.1434517801,
0.0822132155,
0.3710943162,
0.2349414229,
0.4563437104,
-0.5459486246,
-0.296654284,
0.6769798994,
0.4256234169,
-0.2720419765,
0.1161876693,
0.2715901732,
-0.4409066141,
-0.4491134882,
0.3209578991,
-0.0017345215,
-0.3180617094,
-0.9770614505,
0.2416782379,
-0.6343891025,
-0.2542851567,
-0.2453873605,
-0.3989497721,
0.4838565588,
0.1333629042,
-0.5434324741,
0.2563562691,
0.9296242595,
0.7358698845,
-0.1912159175,
-0.3333857358,
-0.3119787276,
0.2535442412,
-0.5956388712,
0.7139976621,
-0.7361417413,
-0.314640373,
-0.1140205935,
0.0932228193,
0.2768878341,
-0.5277670026,
0.6246688366,
-0.3762173355,
-0.1911238283,
-0.9114868641,
-0.5046676993,
-0.398037672,
0.2955322564,
-0.3466109931,
0.9097600579,
-0.2306656539,
-0.6192664504,
0.1117352024,
-0.0724185109,
-0.306835711,
-0.0286121927,
-0.8350619078,
-0.1025345027,
0.5659375787,
-0.1990978718,
0.49258551,
-0.3111938536,
0.3309675753,
-0.3098402619,
-0.6107515097,
0.1888401359,
-0.0860183761,
0.4123588502,
0.0500177443,
-0.4988298118,
0.2313593775,
-0.7666158676,
-0.0470622964,
0.3357738256,
-0.26271227,
-0.620896399,
0.427256465,
-0.3650453687,
0.3388050497,
-0.1346797943,
-0.3467683196,
-0.0259408783,
-0.5052981973,
0.6693626046,
0.9195978045,
-0.2356942445,
0.5740959048,
-0.5654656887,
0.147692591,
0.3021414876,
-0.4957048595,
-0.2530585825,
-0.4077198505,
-1.0029919147,
-0.0219257493,
0.0252790507,
0.6769427061,
-0.4905051291,
0.5571627021,
-0.2659687996,
-0.1742032319,
-0.1246794015,
-0.1466250122,
0.4555851221,
0.3576334119,
0.3239843249,
-0.0463741943,
-0.4380812645,
-0.9785578251,
-0.2345119715,
-0.2350313514,
-0.1498463601,
0.4364150763,
0.4798281789,
-0.1694754958,
0.8863832355,
-0.0581648797,
-0.2797139287,
0.1195764244,
0.083246395,
0.1599725038,
0.4359234571,
0.5352759957,
-0.7120152712,
0.0810547099,
0.1009750366,
-1.2576961517,
0.0071013514,
-0.051380951,
-0.0517943688,
-0.2692082524,
0.6853277087,
-0.8172357082,
0.1628711373,
0.1925536096,
-0.1889080256,
0.2646443546,
-0.4579157233,
-0.0347529352,
-0.4556391835,
0.0001888251,
-0.0044965493,
-0.1221162528,
-0.4694293141,
0.2857847214,
0.0774423108,
-0.2445796728,
-0.3966993392,
0.3748365939,
-0.5233338475,
-0.1579426825,
-0.4418589473,
0.1393885165,
-0.0970995724,
0.607867837,
-0.0112493131,
0.471332252,
0.507009089,
-1.0272103548,
0.4451877177,
0.1229417846,
0.3373445868,
0.812387526,
-0.8893737793,
0.1980209798,
-0.7446750998,
0.3388020694,
-0.8886270523,
0.1384016871,
0.4551795125,
-0.5792523026,
0.0499114841,
-0.0389237739,
-0.0917051509,
-0.1147174612,
-0.2464284301,
0.5268834829,
0.7204566598,
-0.4713902175,
0.6940280199,
0.3647314906,
0.2735663652,
-0.3235096335,
-0.4500744939,
0.1023034602,
-0.3747137189,
-0.6038051248,
0.2795740962,
0.373570472,
-0.5272338986,
0.0550857596,
-0.3074856997,
0.2365139127,
0.1152381226,
0.6113684177,
-0.1815945059,
-0.2774855196,
0.4898435771,
-0.0651830137,
-0.5142384768,
0.4480421245,
-0.498192668,
0.2726246119,
-0.0630169362,
-0.5503601432,
-0.2604823411,
0.3082218468,
0.7099558711,
-0.1279903203,
0.6101921797,
0.2596733272,
-0.7464373112,
-0.2349857092,
-0.2776800096,
-0.2147040963,
-0.3875635862,
-0.0133000165,
-0.5749145746,
-0.5670005083,
0.493917942,
-0.3071431816,
-0.1077590957,
0.6079490781,
0.5434219241,
-0.2780144811,
0.7815977335,
0.5203595757,
-0.051765915,
0.3318134248,
-0.3678538799,
0.0550034717,
-0.8752399087,
-0.4338957667,
-0.6115713716,
-0.3298394084,
-0.357447356,
-0.4764237106,
0.2162579447,
0.3105892241,
-0.4995359778,
-0.1486424804,
-0.6110457778,
0.3139584064,
0.6199702621,
0.0713708401,
-0.006621575,
0.2761459053,
-0.5882877111,
-0.1894690692,
-0.5285081863,
-0.6841067076,
0.8950018883,
0.4512518942,
0.7998611927,
-0.1436611712,
0.3217363954,
0.1779326349,
0.253595084,
-0.7240462899,
0.3630699217,
-0.0602969453,
-0.2150512487,
-0.1188443899,
-0.1770132929,
-0.8243450522,
0.6661621928,
-0.457778126,
-0.3985210657,
0.199504137,
0.0512696691,
-0.1749611348,
0.40353477,
-0.29262954,
0.3795212507,
-0.3439033329,
-0.3477995694,
-0.1051273793,
-0.5838859677,
0.2776877284,
0.2304362804,
0.4777986407,
-0.1671370119,
0.0082590543,
0.7779713869,
-0.2111847401,
0.8304714561,
-0.1960041523,
-0.3125306368,
0.1395394057,
-0.04099923,
0.5428897738,
0.201507166,
0.2622702718,
0.2551837564,
-0.0027748013,
-0.3858922124,
-0.6158767939,
0.7287717462,
-1.2609664202,
-0.5734383464,
-0.7314336896,
-0.1108520105,
-0.1553406119,
0.2524804473,
0.2538478673,
0.2949723005,
-0.3662356436,
0.22301732,
1.0816261768,
-0.3786135912,
0.1351611763,
0.1495094895,
-0.3189682662,
-0.2886766791,
1.1793941259,
-0.0744539276,
0.0266192351,
0.5540046692,
0.1336922497,
-0.0447949208,
-0.380917877,
-0.3002663255,
0.5008209348,
-1.0091366768,
0.1364568919,
-0.7690926194,
-0.1768747568,
0.0475457944,
-0.2595427334,
-0.2305790931,
-0.1021885127,
-0.604298234,
-0.2286655456,
0.017641075,
0.948597908,
-0.0657282993,
0.1370426863,
-0.7977012992,
0.8576769233,
0.2241724133,
0.2364604473,
-0.0443154201,
-0.384798497,
0.022152422,
0.3390047252,
-0.2667340934,
-0.849611342,
-0.0250217114,
-0.0124239074,
0.7264888883,
0.41875723,
-0.0628729984,
0.5702629089,
-0.8876567483,
0.6379604936,
0.2042749375,
-0.9588162899,
0.2673617601,
-0.4176874459,
-0.1544026136,
0.0921847746,
0.3787398636,
-0.8068783879,
-0.4903725386,
-0.5301396251,
-0.8125888705,
0.2090850621,
0.2940380871,
0.4595831037,
-0.1905018091,
0.6630696654,
-0.168761,
0.0321893319,
-0.7117518783,
-0.4639565349,
-0.4013799727,
0.0676099733,
-0.296903789,
-0.319314152,
-0.2966548204,
-0.3223008513,
0.2740873992,
0.033449389,
0.6533769369,
0.3276179135,
-0.3084864616,
-0.4800942838,
0.0864302889,
0.8558295369,
0.6492034793,
0.1181749552,
0.3930667639,
0.0053056362,
-0.0410135277,
0.7373464108,
-0.305775106,
-0.2595717311,
0.0217744168,
0.3918215334,
0.9506765008,
0.3782579601,
-0.3702851236,
0.2815434635,
0.1600683182,
-0.1345421523,
-0.6796748638,
-0.0127388407,
-0.0012920131,
0.2285742611,
0.5645418167,
0.1649385542,
-0.3641943038,
-0.4930755198,
0.1804450452,
0.5894881487,
-0.6583434939,
-0.4559704065,
0.7692164779,
0.1385351419,
-0.4717685282,
0.4914222658,
0.1497600973,
-0.6525086164,
0.8091166019,
0.3675046563,
0.7622235417,
0.0116491625,
-0.079866454,
0.1813441217,
0.4829455614,
-0.3131810725,
0.1309217215,
0.2019235492,
-0.8643604517,
-0.2694029808,
-0.4720329046,
-0.3029823005,
-0.0182270817,
-0.428455174,
0.3307782412,
-0.6922310591,
-0.0907756984,
-0.1890015304,
-0.3802144229,
-0.3823537529,
0.286061883,
0.4142426848,
0.4462831616,
-0.9899387956,
0.3951373994,
0.8983533978,
-0.4104116261,
-0.5915772915,
-0.0582043193,
-0.2944832742,
-0.5423384905,
1.188716054,
0.2432872355,
-0.2182094604,
0.1139017791,
-0.6859648228,
-1.0185763836,
0.771060884,
0.3448406458,
-0.1047393233,
-0.1995715052,
-0.0179609153,
0.4798048139,
-0.2883460224,
0.1283311397,
0.2262813598,
0.5328814983,
-0.0472321883,
-0.4102530777,
0.1772753,
-0.0695214793,
0.2121779472,
0.012127663,
-0.6226053238,
1.0325707197,
0.0952785984,
-0.4361326396,
-0.3430931866,
0.8933826089,
0.3786660135,
-0.1327999085,
0.1843036264,
0.8229746222,
0.5504981875,
-0.2390590906,
1.0899465084,
-0.2902061045,
0.2343210131,
0.376519978,
-0.1592174321,
0.4605182707,
0.6427503824,
-0.3400766551,
0.2757264972,
0.4320998192,
0.2539850771,
0.3614825308,
0.8194086552,
0.0325296819,
-0.3013402224,
0.121508956,
-0.6042547822,
0.2616923153,
0.3764603734,
-0.190226227,
-0.3476044536,
0.1953631043,
-0.4263970256,
0.2261620462,
-0.2645995021,
0.7062526941,
0.5089861751,
-0.4176334143,
0.7265034318,
0.259095937,
0.5867814422,
-0.3825228512,
-0.4068629742,
-0.1182602942,
0.0151413875,
-0.0620645359,
-0.1351399571,
0.275601685,
-0.451109767,
-0.2429397255,
-0.4330365956,
0.7575930357,
0.0139194094,
-0.425984323,
0.4967303276,
0.6987496614,
0.1547449827,
0.0765068382,
-0.5335883498,
0.3149861693,
-0.4155926406,
-0.2653756142,
0.2694005072,
0.6923270822,
-0.1615165621,
0.9383209348,
0.8083094954,
0.2434255034,
0.0598236471,
-0.2613789439,
0.9514833689,
-1.1071157455,
-0.7306534648,
-0.928550899,
0.2861870527,
0.3794230223,
0.0492879525,
0.4883346558,
0.1788418144,
0.6111643314,
-0.1314973682,
0.9918241501,
0.1932496876,
0.293130964,
-0.6869453788,
0.5218356252,
-0.3728503287,
0.2103072107,
-0.2454471588,
-0.9825413823,
-0.3727557957,
1.0809390545,
-0.2547031641,
-0.0169687271,
0.9107906222,
0.0406541973,
-0.0473692454,
-0.1574562043,
0.6614015102,
0.1517761499,
0.3970942497,
0.487434268,
1.3157354593,
-0.2926384211,
0.0266872831,
0.0546308234,
-0.153041333,
-0.0411606617,
-0.7586882114,
-1.0323938131,
-0.4372955263,
-0.0058552776,
-0.431252718,
0.0752334371,
1.1395869255,
0.3109623492,
-0.7970208526,
-0.2337479293,
-0.4277909696,
0.3624586463,
-0.1726100892,
-0.1164141595,
0.2200796008,
-0.5554332733,
-0.3771158755,
0.2741444707,
0.3928830028,
0.159701243,
-0.5138956904,
-0.1246211231,
0.1289757639,
0.0977372006,
0.6931772232,
0.4831271172,
-1.0842779875,
-0.6009960771,
-0.0382242091,
-0.2031145245,
0.3015586436,
1.0965983868,
-1.0337398052,
-0.2101691514,
0.2263647169,
0.933724165,
-0.057217475,
0.0642727837,
0.62816751,
-0.4630411863,
0.4966000915,
0.303370595,
0.3909674287,
0.21562545,
-0.2607856691,
0.1464218348,
0.7076390982,
-0.2127777338,
-0.7643013,
0.4194126427,
-0.6374247074,
-0.2924453914,
1.3141480684,
0.0231503155,
-0.3072911799,
-0.1670751125,
-0.2868906558,
0.3310777843,
-0.0691011697,
0.615552485,
0.8275858164,
0.0860994384,
-0.0957232863,
-0.4563398957,
0.4131384194,
0.5011571646,
-0.4749602973,
-0.2249161452,
0.5916855931,
0.2729502916,
0.339782536,
0.5485289693,
0.2606706917,
-0.0310209263,
-0.1800234169,
0.0532801375,
-0.1428295672,
-0.3088214695,
-0.6321719885,
0.4485240877,
0.1587753445,
-0.0519870035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01424v1 | Polarity based Sarcasm Detection using Semigraph | 2023-04-04T00:13:55 | 2023-04-04T00:13:55 | Swapnil Mane, Vaibhav Khatavkar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sarcasm is an advanced linguistic expression often found on various online
platforms. Sarcasm detection is challenging in natural language processing
tasks that affect sentiment analysis. This article presents the inventive
method of the semigraph, including semigraph construction and sarcasm detection
processes. A variation of the semigraph is suggested in the pattern-relatedness
of the text document. The proposed method is to obtain the sarcastic and
non-sarcastic polarity scores of a document using a semigraph. The sarcastic
polarity score represents the possibility that a document will become
sarcastic. Sarcasm is detected based on the polarity scoring model. The
performance of the proposed model enhances the existing prior art approach to
sarcasm detection. In the Amazon product review, the model achieved the
accuracy, recall, and f-measure of 0.87, 0.79, and 0.83, respectively. | [
-0.1323114485,
-0.9210525751,
0.3631151915,
0.3694622517,
-0.4947649539,
0.202200219,
0.0391364619,
-0.4030445516,
0.5107293725,
0.6148484349,
-0.4867043495,
-0.7714098692,
-0.3699965775,
0.1890761703,
-0.1928827763,
1.2097604275,
0.3033770323,
0.0947788358,
0.0142165786,
-0.2811136842,
-0.3144681752,
-0.5025339127,
-0.6787914634,
-0.1982710809,
0.1567011327,
0.2174279839,
0.6768792272,
-0.1281700134,
0.6890065074,
0.3263221383,
-0.297193259,
-0.2273717225,
-0.0376642607,
0.3400217295,
-0.1276426017,
-0.7369115949,
-0.5606854558,
0.2624115348,
0.459482491,
0.0872850716,
0.0622714981,
0.1682482958,
-0.5023429394,
0.5436105728,
-0.3100855052,
0.1023119688,
-0.2954743505,
0.371576786,
-0.2008195817,
-0.3682589829,
-0.5946316123,
-0.4648007751,
-0.1948683709,
-0.2587996423,
0.364790082,
0.2455656379,
0.6213896275,
0.2042203546,
-0.292278856,
-0.3908158541,
-0.6609123945,
0.7931139469,
-0.9525287151,
0.0826339349,
-0.0213038009,
0.4646767676,
0.1783404797,
-0.5019985437,
-0.6602348089,
-0.435957253,
-0.0461318158,
0.3210134804,
-0.1964475513,
0.0667340457,
0.5135651231,
0.4555585086,
-0.7473499775,
-0.3267785013,
0.2638324201,
-0.2077046782,
0.4362385571,
0.1254328042,
0.5631443858,
-0.7701494694,
-0.6922457218,
0.1961611062,
-0.0735299811,
0.3207361102,
0.625164628,
0.2881720662,
-0.0222115163,
0.5283764005,
-0.251927346,
0.5063435435,
0.0255480018,
-0.2280559391,
0.2926681638,
-0.2591156363,
-0.1016235352,
-0.106510587,
0.7012052536,
0.346034646,
0.3625361323,
-0.0254665241,
-0.5936599374,
0.3113082051,
0.0832943842,
-0.4109884501,
-0.0529464483,
-0.0438984185,
-0.5594174862,
-0.62785393,
-0.0023525401,
-0.7917583585,
-0.605635643,
-0.2141245902,
0.1183466539,
-0.3932620883,
-0.2984222472,
-0.0057865987,
-0.7978341579,
0.2841671407,
0.4426032603,
-0.1178394631,
0.1088461429,
0.5193937421,
0.8760479689,
0.238092497,
0.0985424742,
-0.2896208763,
-0.0428562947,
0.1344379187,
0.9799615741,
-0.4361038506,
-0.2070233822,
-0.0415242724,
-0.301253885,
0.0531578325,
-0.3031865656,
0.8365091681,
-0.6507163644,
0.244979769,
-0.0778934211,
-0.4998171031,
-0.3857002556,
0.6067611575,
-0.9200096726,
1.3816417456,
0.5530885458,
-1.4314302206,
0.1340388656,
-0.4911571443,
-0.8147601485,
0.48657763,
0.0736973584,
-0.3721396923,
0.0869674012,
0.0466451012,
0.3304024041,
-0.4634925723,
0.3731366396,
-0.3446254134,
-0.367190063,
0.6318941116,
-0.2614117563,
1.3556177616,
-0.0680918321,
-0.7328339219,
-0.2221010923,
-0.3658477068,
-0.0695588365,
-0.0058373641,
-0.0912810564,
-0.3605462611,
-0.1212086603,
-0.0002225724,
0.4503186941,
0.3617453873,
-0.6228113174,
-0.1179748699,
-0.4381948411,
0.1964807361,
0.5715651512,
0.1025453508,
0.244268924,
-0.3077361584,
0.8716834784,
0.0330925323,
0.6171706915,
0.2331444323,
-0.8420196176,
-0.7202988863,
-0.6811754704,
0.0998553485,
1.0771142244,
-0.8868899941,
0.7018054724,
-0.1371888816,
-0.3360147774,
-0.3601512313,
0.066645056,
0.4771890342,
0.7367870808,
0.226815179,
-0.3286026716,
-0.2856520712,
-0.5960561633,
-0.7183387876,
-0.3804698586,
0.2741225064,
0.3837949932,
0.2689993978,
0.0735853165,
0.9111481309,
-0.5225613713,
-0.382083863,
-0.5647101402,
0.7236251235,
0.3391371071,
0.0517043546,
0.8384646773,
-0.7049928904,
-0.9613934159,
-0.0370521322,
-0.9429362416,
-0.3221924901,
0.1839451641,
-0.0007649074,
0.4853423536,
0.5539366603,
-0.7417029738,
0.5172970891,
0.0897143185,
-0.404107362,
0.5085829496,
0.4145132005,
0.3980539739,
-0.8515559435,
0.150992915,
0.378580004,
-0.644585371,
-0.6805734634,
0.1820047498,
-0.1191625521,
-0.1036806926,
-0.4059209228,
0.4030121863,
-0.243091777,
0.1130451187,
-0.1206031442,
0.2143983841,
0.1245340705,
0.3570421934,
-0.3653288782,
0.3979897201,
0.4360286891,
-0.122866191,
0.5504472852,
-0.2301086783,
0.1344452053,
0.8486264944,
-0.3763535023,
0.2041899115,
-0.3769035637,
0.5272042751,
-1.1146259308,
0.0454381555,
0.5609887242,
-0.5869313478,
0.330603838,
-0.1355359107,
-0.4350765944,
-0.5485400558,
-0.8765884638,
0.4446514249,
0.3882636726,
-0.1151621267,
1.0265860558,
0.2893182635,
-0.2851189971,
-0.6585913897,
-0.6281167269,
-0.0366322324,
-0.1738299727,
-0.9133399725,
0.0149017069,
-0.0540003218,
-0.1219821349,
-0.078568019,
0.2220424414,
0.1836659163,
-0.0940449238,
0.0001335963,
0.419752717,
-0.1183005571,
-0.1523399502,
-0.0552978404,
-0.0878728852,
0.2717225552,
-0.0214547906,
0.5428797007,
0.0235339571,
-0.0068590343,
-0.9395923018,
0.4894309044,
0.7289184928,
0.0326738395,
0.4967841506,
0.6081789136,
-0.4130753577,
-0.7403854132,
-0.6483159661,
-0.0846811533,
-0.485812217,
-0.1772514284,
0.062427137,
-0.4488203228,
0.6921963096,
0.0103644961,
-0.5930252671,
0.3297430277,
0.3747227788,
-0.0873076692,
1.1632395983,
0.6543863416,
-0.2624432147,
0.7231881618,
0.0267492905,
0.9076887369,
-0.4812344313,
-0.2223136574,
-0.7286286354,
-0.3370059431,
-0.4736998975,
-0.3764778972,
0.2162319422,
-0.2809412777,
0.1264095157,
0.1793091148,
-0.5356106758,
0.4290852845,
0.6660397649,
0.3107077181,
0.2616550922,
-0.1640980989,
0.0121553587,
-0.0221827105,
-0.1192391887,
-0.3270105422,
0.78301543,
0.2708037794,
0.510897696,
0.107566312,
0.5704695582,
0.9444378614,
0.6029690504,
-1.0415028334,
0.786930263,
-0.2796747386,
-0.7539979815,
-0.1559533328,
-0.5917881131,
0.0365129299,
-0.2855096757,
0.0559715927,
-0.4401934445,
-0.2808737159,
0.0842781365,
-0.0304051992,
-0.0442997813,
-0.8405326009,
0.7515833378,
-0.2068936229,
-0.0157741681,
0.0251190457,
-0.8189579844,
0.306104362,
0.3682371974,
0.2314923704,
-0.1295946985,
0.3705942929,
0.692912221,
0.0069188448,
1.1185890436,
-0.6395863891,
0.3193220794,
0.7106484771,
0.315723002,
0.5310096145,
0.2617255151,
-0.2803382576,
0.0710293576,
-0.3317317963,
-0.3870177865,
-0.6559113264,
0.4415733218,
-0.5083022118,
-0.479236275,
-0.649859786,
-0.3544603884,
-0.0654100403,
0.3834797144,
0.2121791691,
0.103866972,
-0.297855258,
-0.4835835099,
0.6844605803,
-0.0055520195,
0.4550940692,
0.4898391366,
-0.0198987536,
-0.4864045978,
0.9513491988,
-0.0405850261,
-0.0234974958,
0.5944931507,
0.3689907789,
-0.3026882708,
-0.1827740967,
-0.0755547658,
0.4770252109,
-1.0117520094,
-0.4940568209,
-0.6506686211,
-0.1683046073,
-0.8417596817,
-0.4530883431,
0.0702995136,
-0.5559872985,
-0.4173490703,
0.0136530576,
0.220560804,
0.6205168366,
0.4320068359,
0.2437565178,
-0.4031514525,
0.3151778281,
0.1961518675,
0.1024679244,
-0.1603281498,
-0.6177892685,
0.1974180788,
-0.1442169994,
-0.3259176314,
-1.1828188896,
0.3883211911,
-0.1106316373,
0.2912387848,
0.3731209636,
0.1628406048,
-0.0746403039,
0.1485639364,
0.7808636427,
0.2485908419,
-1.2055441141,
0.6857728362,
-0.4950695038,
-0.0085459594,
0.4994696975,
0.284511447,
-0.2688080668,
-0.7047299147,
-0.7428674102,
-0.6109037995,
0.8576668501,
0.1410426944,
0.0021689564,
0.0379944332,
0.4144055247,
-0.015403701,
0.4087220132,
-1.204187274,
0.0480229668,
-0.3781734109,
-0.6250283122,
0.2029849589,
-0.1136871502,
-0.169314608,
-0.3492847681,
0.6857079864,
-0.3119811118,
0.2116388232,
0.0489264764,
-0.2565491199,
-0.0942205787,
0.1998338997,
0.143776834,
-0.149361968,
-0.2992545962,
0.2808791399,
-0.2285526991,
-0.4572251737,
-0.2011062801,
-0.048281163,
-0.5278955102,
0.223560825,
0.2589929998,
0.3127533495,
-0.0576100573,
-0.387134999,
1.1557660103,
-0.1295360625,
0.0692262724,
-0.3490149975,
-0.1722949594,
-0.0495530255,
0.1889337748,
-0.0923831314,
0.3569865227,
0.6580219269,
-0.657787919,
-0.1256235689,
0.7625948787,
-0.4248585105,
-0.4528582394,
0.1146812141,
0.3629224002,
-0.6002666354,
0.6262558103,
-0.7509391308,
-1.104237318,
0.8100508451,
0.7830502987,
1.1043108702,
-0.3780944645,
0.9784995317,
0.1967781782,
0.5214785933,
0.0543620884,
0.8122110367,
-0.1519757658,
-0.5501391292,
0.3527068794,
-0.8196948767,
-0.3557674587,
-0.5959153771,
-0.3090491593,
0.7877003551,
-0.8466598392,
-0.48188743,
0.1913968772,
-0.1659815013,
-0.4261032641,
0.3651885688,
0.1251403242,
0.6515701413,
-1.3204079866,
0.1814712584,
0.8704203963,
-0.5498982668,
-0.6136354804,
0.1997424066,
-0.0246145464,
-0.4987488687,
0.2421388179,
0.5230861306,
-0.6254336834,
-0.0411694236,
-0.5614889264,
-0.3269699812,
0.8610096574,
0.6055532694,
0.130649209,
0.1179960594,
0.2444775403,
0.9339837432,
-0.295977056,
0.6256300211,
0.3759424686,
0.4670808613,
0.0036885999,
-0.314138025,
0.5013977289,
-0.3495993316,
-0.1484003514,
0.3580243886,
-0.8956647515,
1.0411131382,
0.3667263687,
-0.3423291743,
-0.1993598342,
0.2824555337,
-0.1842461526,
0.8416314721,
0.4545919895,
0.8166963458,
0.6956743598,
0.0566088594,
0.8797434568,
-0.2135926187,
0.7167849541,
0.3580034673,
-0.5205525756,
0.5517917275,
0.3436740637,
0.097252734,
0.9151942134,
0.0689466372,
0.0986343473,
0.2194178849,
-0.0874366462,
-0.6561809778,
-0.3344577849,
-0.4029864967,
0.0074380687,
0.296988517,
0.3509200215,
-0.4977358878,
-0.1783601344,
-0.0465118028,
0.2268480211,
-0.0427702889,
-0.1467577368,
0.6664451361,
0.0461585633,
-0.8700661063,
0.1250916421,
0.1989582479,
0.5439026952,
-0.1951322109,
0.0949084759,
-0.260155648,
0.0904972851,
-0.3956769407,
-0.6774801612,
0.190983966,
0.0596387088,
-0.3775694966,
-0.0825262517,
1.0920270681,
0.1155814379,
-0.5996292233,
0.7066809535,
0.340559721,
-0.2403590083,
-0.0411407538,
-0.778126359,
-0.3907545805,
-0.1196357906,
-0.317948699,
-0.0637255907,
0.7995593548,
-0.1781297773,
0.3467187583,
0.4749494493,
-0.2723164558,
0.2172345668,
0.5402588844,
0.9205882549,
-0.736102581,
-0.9301058054,
-0.5578830838,
0.4599221945,
-0.4582692683,
-0.4401940405,
0.6818453074,
0.1805278808,
0.3644839227,
-0.0977747738,
0.8620462418,
-0.2187342942,
0.5097665787,
-0.3518660069,
0.439748764,
-0.4933940172,
0.1790018827,
-0.6101320386,
-0.7499880791,
-0.7068282962,
0.4696075916,
-0.2839155197,
0.3094981015,
1.1233515739,
0.9050173759,
-0.1368721724,
0.6487813592,
-0.0657090545,
0.0830128491,
0.113442257,
0.1212543696,
0.8246840239,
-0.3478395045,
0.1469867676,
-0.2715145648,
-0.9524411559,
-0.4132630825,
-0.760043025,
-1.2815893888,
-0.0135840345,
-0.4476154745,
-0.4905517399,
-0.1907986701,
0.3108359277,
0.1823703647,
-0.7545132041,
0.0932600647,
-0.4093000591,
0.3853265345,
-0.1532626599,
-0.4211907089,
-0.1294185668,
-0.1988045871,
-0.249360919,
-0.0545949787,
0.5988038778,
-0.2178074569,
-0.1862984598,
0.2177658081,
-0.4587612152,
0.5144364834,
0.4080021083,
0.2771725059,
-0.3579129577,
-0.3199599981,
0.1481818259,
-0.2686445415,
-0.1184410974,
1.0907204151,
-0.5140231848,
0.3137000501,
0.9447147846,
0.1904371828,
0.1174258888,
0.2622627914,
-0.0453199036,
-0.88162148,
0.3013500869,
0.7957440615,
0.1613847911,
0.703669548,
-0.9613231421,
0.0397978239,
0.8170169592,
-0.4880687296,
-0.8602207303,
0.3564482927,
-1.3657590151,
-0.1146625727,
0.9205867648,
-0.1531654149,
-0.3800034821,
-0.3517216742,
-0.2198903561,
0.453299284,
-0.4771051705,
0.9828097224,
0.5723852515,
-0.263076216,
0.2803294361,
-0.1644359082,
0.2195095718,
0.6307829022,
-0.6865875125,
-0.2325065285,
0.2110726088,
0.1373021454,
0.4192505181,
0.9885073304,
-0.247917518,
0.4490176439,
0.0454870798,
-0.0488534123,
0.4406636357,
-0.5078184605,
-0.2179077417,
0.356818825,
0.0089565339,
0.2133942246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01423v1 | Thematic context vector association based on event uncertainty for Twitter | 2023-04-04T00:13:47 | 2023-04-04T00:13:47 | Vaibhav Khatavkar, Swapnil Mane, Parag Kulkarni | cs.CL | cs.CL | Keyword extraction is a crucial process in text mining. The extraction of
keywords with respective contextual events in Twitter data is a big challenge.
The challenging issues are mainly because of the informality in the language
used. The use of misspelled words, acronyms, and ambiguous terms causes
informality. The extraction of keywords with informal language in current
systems is pattern based or event based. In this paper, contextual keywords are
extracted using thematic events with the help of data association. The thematic
context for events is identified using the uncertainty principle in the
proposed system. The thematic contexts are weighed with the help of vectors
called thematic context vectors which signifies the event as certain or
uncertain. The system is tested on the Twitter COVID-19 dataset and proves to
be effective. The system extracts event-specific thematic context vectors from
the test dataset and ranks them. The extracted thematic context vectors are
used for the clustering of contextual thematic vectors which improves the
silhouette coefficient by 0.5% than state of art methods namely TF and TF-IDF.
The thematic context vector can be used in other applications like
Cyberbullying, sarcasm detection, figurative language detection, etc. | [
-0.1254547834,
-0.9728626013,
0.3142263293,
0.3001176715,
-0.8220385909,
0.5182499886,
-0.0713203177,
-0.3104207516,
0.5213053823,
0.0211489815,
-0.6343209743,
-0.8676385283,
-0.8239172697,
-0.1116328016,
-0.7112639546,
0.6218715906,
-0.1217734888,
-0.3622815609,
-0.0546541214,
-0.3085640371,
-0.5418374538,
-0.4999857545,
-0.871039927,
-0.0745380521,
0.4113764763,
0.3419051766,
0.2137439698,
0.4599145055,
0.9587715268,
0.349647969,
0.070266135,
0.0138441315,
-0.527706027,
0.4849553704,
-0.3069778085,
-0.077465944,
-0.2878740728,
0.0162302796,
0.2001193464,
-0.1872585863,
-0.3198603094,
0.3123332262,
-0.1179396734,
0.1330795884,
-0.6652137637,
0.2518141568,
-0.9902299047,
-0.0337149315,
-0.4138092399,
-0.503657341,
0.2180742025,
-0.0969594792,
0.1607592702,
-0.4028637409,
0.1875065118,
0.0976731032,
1.1542916298,
0.139730826,
0.0387088135,
-0.3385326862,
-0.7778432965,
0.8126704693,
-0.3138565421,
0.0439420417,
0.3846432865,
0.4790611565,
-0.071197331,
-0.9380660057,
-0.5418320298,
0.5497540832,
0.0645796955,
0.0501198173,
-0.3167364895,
-0.1868935525,
-0.2412182689,
-0.2184250653,
-0.3911907077,
-0.1190741807,
-0.3253379166,
-0.1299085319,
0.4599396586,
0.1495088637,
0.5717534423,
-0.6856096387,
-0.4622023404,
0.045618359,
-0.3372928798,
0.0680272877,
-0.217605859,
0.407487601,
-0.4783392549,
0.4496043921,
-0.1771754771,
0.3531984985,
0.0153073454,
-0.416328609,
0.1746269614,
-0.4888288975,
-0.351827234,
0.2267802954,
0.9489555955,
0.3873126507,
0.2985138595,
-0.3036388755,
-0.1593322158,
0.1096731946,
0.1601118892,
-0.6002748609,
0.0854461342,
0.373032093,
-0.4817295372,
-0.486150533,
0.401933074,
-1.1502116919,
-0.0787162483,
-0.0408195741,
0.3951291144,
-0.7413800359,
-0.2606602013,
-0.238221392,
-0.4069434404,
0.3404354453,
0.4459644854,
-0.2912818789,
0.0609599017,
0.8886057734,
0.9472309947,
-0.4664709568,
0.1445832998,
-0.3503863215,
0.3508547843,
-0.1665798575,
0.5908589959,
-0.9459552169,
-0.3633690774,
0.0607249774,
-0.2328368127,
-0.1120747551,
-0.0577273332,
0.7469640374,
-0.5140323043,
0.1583306044,
-0.0943151936,
-0.3103628755,
-0.0696363747,
0.2437782735,
-0.2980784476,
1.1821906567,
0.0071681286,
-0.9882231951,
0.6244439483,
-0.43117553,
-0.2504666746,
0.3843402267,
-0.5858676434,
-0.5574521422,
0.0379976965,
0.4905495942,
0.763857007,
-0.2325894088,
0.6411614418,
-0.4661424756,
-0.2323140651,
0.2889092267,
-0.0153677808,
0.3970116675,
0.3017519116,
-0.407663554,
0.1621117592,
-0.7172685266,
-0.1808463633,
0.0789471269,
0.2204711139,
-0.7828890681,
0.3666340709,
0.2780393362,
0.4105583429,
-0.010838015,
-0.5161852837,
-0.1174400002,
-0.0978461131,
0.3808122277,
0.587987721,
0.6706671715,
0.3766513467,
-0.174198091,
0.7243281007,
0.2076725066,
-0.1652694046,
0.1319446415,
-0.6183313131,
-0.4546092749,
-0.7360581756,
0.2087133229,
0.547717452,
-1.1451647282,
0.7964714766,
-0.6370173097,
-0.5408000946,
-0.0236161966,
-0.0806633085,
0.0451112203,
0.313664943,
0.0819530934,
-0.1196963936,
-0.9114941955,
-0.3965369165,
-0.2321582735,
-0.3674035966,
0.0836193264,
0.1134705245,
0.3421864808,
-0.1943864226,
1.3548783064,
-0.5455561876,
-0.3624803424,
-0.2841416001,
0.6121085286,
-0.0398269892,
0.3783887923,
0.7448208928,
-0.8477910161,
-0.3380808234,
-0.1530707031,
-0.6641860008,
0.0030495669,
-0.0536803752,
-0.168389529,
-0.1384311318,
0.6837530732,
-0.4620605707,
0.6524277329,
0.1307599843,
-0.2619702816,
-0.1312387586,
0.3292140663,
-0.0359275788,
-1.478841424,
-0.0307489615,
0.3302122056,
-0.2706904411,
-0.6123407483,
0.0614387877,
-0.1358494461,
0.0682770908,
-0.3357584774,
0.5415711403,
-0.0295636673,
0.4175963998,
-0.1915632933,
0.2282019705,
-0.2275314629,
0.1286011636,
0.1009342745,
0.4866435826,
0.6330952048,
-0.4332279861,
0.1758419871,
0.032937929,
-0.2262452692,
0.5320618153,
-0.3925599158,
-0.0461877175,
-0.2612243891,
0.0946732983,
-1.1286388636,
-0.1862558424,
0.5793074965,
-0.560020268,
0.2162824273,
0.2184337825,
-0.3013221622,
-0.1506188065,
-0.4168156683,
0.3136126995,
0.3466695845,
-0.166925326,
0.6578822136,
0.6393840909,
-0.2128575593,
-0.519661963,
-0.340252012,
0.2925851345,
-0.8088172674,
-0.3825049996,
0.3336667418,
0.4286473393,
-0.4210042953,
0.0931009278,
-0.2741425037,
-0.2486139536,
0.1420757174,
0.3691571355,
0.0612987615,
-0.0072330097,
0.2498530895,
-0.0736953989,
0.0825489238,
-0.1239968687,
-0.1517440379,
0.6281068921,
0.0439833812,
0.0515845716,
-0.3644945621,
0.2117659152,
0.4273425937,
-0.2176650614,
0.7510991693,
1.2598030567,
-0.8748987317,
0.0788576156,
-0.4460602701,
-0.0658063889,
-0.4391490519,
0.2695060074,
-0.147323221,
-0.8234471679,
0.785056293,
0.1000509784,
-0.3624481857,
0.7325074077,
0.3763758242,
-0.1346042305,
0.5984655619,
0.6685711145,
-0.4680829346,
0.7201541662,
-0.0524751097,
0.2119172513,
-0.494006902,
-0.2905361652,
-0.6927161813,
-0.3647619188,
-0.8593763113,
-0.4692643881,
0.3082050681,
0.0328493267,
0.0486933514,
0.2645286024,
-0.297826916,
-0.2155974656,
0.4616063535,
0.2330161333,
0.0637652799,
0.3435665667,
0.0622578338,
-0.1672269404,
-0.5982151628,
-0.3627751768,
0.8134949803,
0.2516839206,
0.6442860365,
0.1203102767,
0.965218246,
0.3171831667,
0.2266311049,
-0.5962008834,
0.410320729,
0.110235244,
-0.4699265361,
-0.4305435419,
-0.205547452,
-1.0302138329,
-0.201229319,
-0.5010789633,
-1.2649509907,
0.579597652,
-0.4517245293,
-0.3549244404,
0.1386187375,
-0.2315737605,
0.2171937525,
0.2122737914,
-0.2270378023,
-0.0834203586,
-0.6406463385,
0.2382210195,
-0.340809375,
0.3340341151,
-0.3924497068,
-0.3190068603,
1.0479284525,
-0.2284999341,
0.7781265378,
0.09044604,
0.1880444139,
0.59754318,
-0.1146913543,
0.6653681397,
0.302891314,
-0.0279239323,
0.2571316063,
0.0797019526,
-0.139111951,
-0.3157807291,
0.5165048242,
-0.7359182835,
-0.3328189254,
-0.7042296529,
-0.1922379434,
0.0267996639,
0.1545227915,
0.3310574293,
0.4272977114,
-0.3934095502,
0.4279026389,
0.3390644193,
-0.1043670848,
0.888148129,
0.173966378,
-0.035369914,
-0.3775433898,
1.0128384829,
0.0730126873,
-0.4199698865,
0.6866889,
0.4157091975,
0.0777788535,
-0.6108839512,
0.0436794274,
-0.2831571102,
-0.413864255,
-0.6257587075,
-0.9069157839,
-0.369135052,
-0.4342396557,
-0.1905681193,
0.1298229545,
-0.4789160788,
-0.3879319429,
-0.1177215278,
0.7724225521,
0.3831626475,
0.0955026746,
0.6268035173,
-0.7116224766,
0.4972976446,
-0.0660564676,
0.1466059387,
-0.265391618,
-0.0438336432,
-0.1295081824,
-0.2301944047,
-0.1829790324,
-0.8924602866,
0.6412857175,
0.4537266493,
0.3576121628,
0.7771285176,
0.0814071447,
0.7403934002,
-0.3593132794,
0.7609548569,
0.1392601728,
-0.8031799793,
0.5111654401,
-0.6756785512,
0.1945545822,
0.5264490247,
0.2194516212,
-0.5344615579,
-0.7817893624,
-1.0260840654,
-1.0194581747,
0.7903746367,
0.626065731,
-0.0565024316,
-0.1996113956,
0.6891712546,
-0.1004496217,
0.4968636036,
-0.3685675263,
-0.4220665693,
0.0377255492,
-0.5203188062,
-0.1724615395,
-0.3023899794,
-0.0782545805,
-0.3413160443,
0.3444460928,
0.233875066,
0.4263290465,
0.1301182359,
0.110759683,
-0.2738778889,
0.0218579639,
0.4015877843,
0.8617389202,
-0.5895508528,
0.0010382247,
-0.0452081226,
-0.8109061122,
0.0736407638,
0.0344954282,
-0.079815492,
0.3572898805,
0.5767977238,
0.3202665448,
0.1788627505,
-0.3973901272,
0.38701424,
-0.2741877437,
0.1793872267,
-0.3421097994,
0.0134031679,
-0.1567831188,
0.0959053263,
0.6495496035,
0.176278919,
0.1833479851,
-0.4443354905,
0.5394012928,
0.5611928105,
-0.5856567621,
-0.2119932771,
0.3348322511,
0.1638481468,
-0.3091377914,
0.0563657917,
-0.1716866046,
-0.4550711513,
0.6334041953,
0.1356719881,
1.1338574886,
-0.3637524843,
0.2397039831,
0.2636577487,
0.5386383533,
0.1698447317,
0.4603327215,
0.2410663664,
-0.8003562093,
-0.1699506789,
-0.7892434001,
-0.0478989072,
0.1993050128,
-0.651890099,
0.5104493499,
-0.298271358,
-0.3703025281,
-0.1673456579,
0.0741804689,
-0.9046678543,
0.4979900122,
-0.1182200536,
0.7433738112,
-0.8920618296,
0.8376652002,
0.7180752754,
-0.0493528955,
-0.6503431797,
0.2532375753,
0.0652163327,
-0.6971715689,
0.4920301735,
-0.0047310092,
0.129751429,
-0.1431700289,
-0.4880625606,
-1.2221451998,
1.2114158869,
-0.2144401968,
-0.2453172058,
0.1097910404,
0.077505976,
0.6995598674,
-0.7072398663,
-0.0522469357,
0.4269277155,
0.3679329455,
0.5865056515,
-0.3319862485,
0.3527792394,
0.0090675829,
0.1054442078,
0.1749586612,
-0.3724500835,
0.5535090566,
0.5306621194,
-0.3595159352,
-0.0859063789,
0.946352303,
0.0508832969,
0.6451374888,
0.2878417373,
0.3497766256,
0.6362643242,
-0.2291206867,
0.7875440121,
-0.4535094202,
0.5005955696,
0.9657482505,
-0.0552896187,
0.8029851913,
0.5369608998,
0.0802518502,
0.5145825744,
0.8749344349,
0.3103973567,
0.7525632381,
-0.0880645216,
-0.1764904857,
-0.1170770526,
-0.1328350157,
-0.3084158897,
0.8076818585,
1.0202752352,
-0.2073151618,
-0.4661809802,
-0.0726538375,
0.0318181105,
-0.1960264593,
-0.2553282082,
0.8118670583,
0.2120227069,
-0.4580157399,
0.0379076563,
0.4546755254,
0.6194562912,
-0.6087955832,
0.1670576036,
0.1234124675,
-0.1001875922,
0.0615523122,
-0.2280730456,
0.4844608903,
-0.1203903407,
0.1640498489,
-0.0312785134,
1.2593866587,
-0.344979763,
-0.9338881969,
0.0661542416,
0.9188429713,
-0.2624524832,
-0.0850827843,
-0.7663762569,
0.0695273951,
-0.4159777462,
-0.0193309858,
0.126952216,
0.7290828824,
-0.0975239202,
0.4672570825,
0.1854552329,
0.0618782118,
-0.2103062719,
-0.3303854764,
0.7327392101,
-0.4927884042,
-0.5609690547,
-1.0839370489,
0.2102170736,
-0.31288445,
-0.2898109257,
0.8192234039,
0.245615229,
0.2183354348,
0.3165000379,
0.7710601687,
-0.3956877291,
0.3132914901,
-0.4268755913,
0.5421947837,
-0.4914985597,
0.1156529784,
-0.7164304256,
-0.5896469355,
-0.3115494847,
0.3748857379,
-0.2670724094,
-0.0435215868,
0.8043516278,
0.4241631031,
-0.1834657937,
0.0727633908,
0.1160457432,
-0.0050463462,
0.3310363889,
-0.0204540975,
0.3350917101,
-0.3417639434,
0.2114808708,
-0.1954891831,
-0.2823935151,
-0.4947177768,
-1.0072306395,
-0.9379033446,
-0.8022836447,
-0.3580181897,
-0.514585793,
0.1958241761,
1.1166557074,
0.4842233062,
-0.9591762424,
-0.1042645276,
-0.0193872154,
0.4234876037,
-0.2824602127,
-0.3225167096,
0.7056590319,
-0.3388026357,
-0.564325273,
-0.1442311555,
0.4634646773,
-0.1253314614,
0.110280253,
0.4356085658,
-0.6654351354,
0.2747167051,
0.5099521875,
-0.0846759155,
-0.4784418643,
-0.6379293203,
-0.1120210737,
-0.1915112585,
0.0653496832,
0.6510756016,
-0.6977946162,
0.3757039011,
0.6578343511,
0.4508549273,
0.3075224161,
0.2684261203,
0.6630369425,
-1.1827173233,
0.2463045567,
-0.0273685381,
0.291182071,
0.0975521132,
-0.5118210912,
0.3953073025,
0.5552170277,
0.0860617831,
-0.4826774299,
-0.0861539617,
-1.1332464218,
-0.1481958479,
1.348405838,
0.093638368,
-0.3042557538,
-0.3593644798,
0.2065582275,
0.4309576452,
-0.6227626204,
1.0573328733,
0.8529103398,
0.1789436638,
0.0239347685,
-0.2914729118,
0.6641900539,
-0.0798909962,
-0.6379078031,
-0.6167339683,
-0.1578355581,
0.0739177689,
0.1855132878,
0.5956184268,
0.1733739972,
-0.0511964746,
-0.3627294004,
-0.1337749213,
0.3744697571,
-0.22243011,
-0.2583963275,
0.407720238,
-0.4309377074,
-0.4122612476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01412v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01412v2 | The StatCan Dialogue Dataset: Retrieving Data Tables through Conversations with Genuine Intents | 2023-04-03T23:18:30 | 2023-04-05T01:20:51 | Xing Han Lu, Siva Reddy, Harm de Vries | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce the StatCan Dialogue Dataset consisting of 19,379 conversation
turns between agents working at Statistics Canada and online users looking for
published data tables. The conversations stem from genuine intents, are held in
English or French, and lead to agents retrieving one of over 5000 complex data
tables. Based on this dataset, we propose two tasks: (1) automatic retrieval of
relevant tables based on a on-going conversation, and (2) automatic generation
of appropriate agent responses at each turn. We investigate the difficulty of
each task by establishing strong baselines. Our experiments on a temporal data
split reveal that all models struggle to generalize to future conversations, as
we observe a significant drop in performance across both tasks when we move
from the validation to the test set. In addition, we find that response
generation models struggle to decide when to return a table. Considering that
the tasks pose significant challenges to existing models, we encourage the
community to develop models for our task, which can be directly used to help
knowledge workers find relevant tables for live chat users. | [
-0.1944871545,
-0.6557198763,
0.7675971389,
-0.0363353752,
-0.2412941009,
0.2173360735,
0.0002082698,
-0.4491665065,
0.3384812176,
0.9148145318,
-0.7748468518,
-0.5182514191,
-0.3772981763,
0.0372438058,
-0.6466087103,
0.9957364202,
-0.0591748357,
0.1944992244,
-0.2019177973,
-0.0346245505,
-0.722117126,
-0.4956269264,
-0.7980747223,
-0.1075453833,
0.7525916696,
0.7168127894,
0.6183670163,
0.1725578606,
0.4359280169,
0.270000428,
0.3444016278,
0.3661212027,
-0.9074367881,
0.6286197901,
-0.003857722,
-0.9135511518,
-0.4353807271,
-0.110004656,
0.1223483607,
0.5611217618,
-0.2365668714,
0.1955847144,
0.1046104059,
0.6052885652,
-0.119195953,
0.7136600018,
-0.6843442321,
0.0210707821,
-0.0716553777,
-0.4176974297,
-0.5915786028,
-0.6841653585,
0.4313771725,
-0.427479744,
0.4963243008,
-0.0411163755,
0.6708722115,
0.0983335078,
-0.5945631266,
-0.467523694,
-1.0404965878,
0.4877318144,
-0.4560169876,
0.2746322453,
0.6822198033,
0.6334331036,
-0.5736530423,
-0.86402601,
-0.4694336355,
-0.3243696392,
-0.3996567726,
0.0868610293,
-0.0034999242,
-0.0562532693,
0.4194267988,
0.0756737292,
-0.2974755168,
-0.5244926214,
-0.6410441399,
-0.1261224002,
0.7568970919,
0.7457498312,
0.1659212708,
-0.0986677483,
0.1715639383,
-0.2257057279,
-0.6573886275,
-0.1479658335,
0.4305734932,
0.6711391807,
-0.1935253441,
0.6938925385,
-0.3519646227,
0.7007274032,
-0.3050999343,
0.1018917561,
-0.0347814076,
-0.64671731,
0.1180281043,
-0.0458480567,
0.7111185193,
0.2078105062,
0.2820752263,
-0.1130387858,
-0.1796582937,
-0.0632395521,
0.4468100071,
-0.4388528168,
-0.2652367949,
0.4527504742,
0.0378372148,
-0.2710720897,
-0.0475043468,
-0.6932651401,
-0.2756181359,
-0.5800535679,
0.2922140658,
-0.2498158365,
0.0557235442,
-0.0334132761,
0.0395145752,
0.1207965165,
0.7668101192,
-0.4156659245,
0.4685962498,
0.6239174604,
0.7008635402,
-0.1635124832,
0.2935205996,
-0.6320801973,
-0.1077401191,
-0.3654589057,
1.0048577785,
-0.5273357034,
-0.4470615983,
0.0143439332,
0.2355751842,
-0.2197749466,
-0.2837821245,
0.5448720455,
-0.5020865202,
0.4651072025,
-0.6847805381,
-0.1729095876,
0.0562773012,
0.3281206191,
-0.8850977421,
0.8814775944,
-0.0890768543,
-0.6812717915,
0.5974299312,
-0.82989645,
-0.1823825687,
0.1447398216,
-0.5435724854,
-0.2601800561,
-0.2133256197,
0.0824148059,
0.4655705094,
-0.6382541656,
0.3612826467,
-0.1677521318,
-0.17816405,
0.3722987771,
-0.4788000882,
0.6602433324,
0.3441846669,
-0.2056751996,
-0.1663804352,
-0.3379164338,
-0.194748193,
0.1358243972,
-0.2591677308,
0.0484346673,
0.4459354877,
-0.2088492662,
0.1539195478,
-0.1488109678,
-0.8289588094,
0.1339642256,
-0.2335309535,
0.086366564,
0.3260855377,
0.2421230078,
-0.0196507685,
-0.5815788507,
0.4526801407,
0.1687493622,
0.2985324562,
0.0598559678,
-0.5403316617,
-0.7297712564,
0.0262550563,
0.1910679787,
0.4833642244,
-0.8865312338,
0.2041861415,
-0.5103115439,
-0.6222146749,
-0.2553600669,
-0.2013828903,
0.0918701515,
0.4595739841,
0.0550265685,
-0.583440423,
-0.2135398835,
-0.8585947156,
-0.0412838422,
-0.2925355136,
-0.1556620449,
0.6407076716,
0.2805592418,
0.2065499127,
1.3956599236,
-0.7818557024,
-0.1518779546,
-0.6977770925,
0.324894309,
0.2733000815,
0.1350740343,
0.3874337971,
-0.7522941232,
-0.7687573433,
-0.0804318041,
-0.701947093,
0.1789828241,
-0.1323316842,
-0.1602858305,
0.1115374416,
0.188257277,
-0.5920385122,
0.7221139669,
-0.0164906587,
-0.128983885,
0.2986208797,
0.0963689536,
0.4503272474,
-1.1260392666,
0.1010157242,
-0.1845262051,
-0.3519636095,
-0.8887444139,
-0.6139914393,
-0.4100548625,
-0.3213255703,
-0.5647339225,
0.5869355202,
-0.3581285775,
-0.0773624703,
0.2159312665,
0.1055486202,
-0.1443833411,
0.6018165946,
0.2252587676,
0.7162793279,
0.3829129338,
-0.8263155818,
0.5026762486,
0.7464690804,
-0.3130390048,
0.4787686467,
-0.6060890555,
0.3032589257,
-0.3599838316,
0.6050200462,
-1.1014866829,
-0.5468001962,
0.5623903871,
-0.4741232991,
0.0485941321,
-0.308635354,
-0.4832966328,
-0.3816844523,
-0.0127068311,
0.2310068458,
0.0891326666,
-0.2320406437,
0.5532004833,
0.7160429955,
-0.4663723707,
-0.5223861933,
-0.365452379,
0.1872404963,
-0.1194208115,
-0.5004780293,
-0.3190067112,
0.1499975175,
-0.3116327822,
-0.4699162245,
-0.0521267429,
-0.167910099,
-0.2093355954,
0.1813397855,
0.1985587031,
0.1207532361,
0.2334196568,
-0.243509531,
0.0597775355,
0.1505323946,
0.1351433992,
0.8569120765,
0.2974731028,
-0.5697915554,
-0.4349360764,
0.317733407,
0.4725473821,
0.0858614072,
0.7998904586,
0.2635198832,
-0.1966936141,
0.0737353191,
-0.6325792074,
-0.5711295605,
-0.4875429869,
0.2744621933,
-0.3873501122,
-0.4110007584,
0.8292883039,
0.3510724008,
0.7668176889,
0.16923666,
0.6118173003,
-0.1376746148,
1.1427313089,
0.3603098392,
0.2177108824,
0.4215003252,
-0.1409775764,
0.332658112,
-0.1881572753,
-0.4943545163,
-0.7478691339,
-0.2385638356,
-0.2098980397,
-0.3896251321,
0.4875768721,
-0.8886725307,
0.1284572035,
0.6040440202,
-0.4120264649,
0.2390241772,
0.4165920913,
0.4470024705,
0.402099669,
0.2831354439,
0.066134654,
-0.0801121667,
-0.7748272419,
-0.6180992723,
1.227650404,
0.1778653115,
0.9935697913,
0.0232759751,
0.410416007,
0.558419466,
0.3644568622,
-0.7792841196,
0.7232061028,
0.1576819271,
-0.7342625856,
-0.4517001808,
-0.8209317327,
-1.3159452677,
-0.2133886814,
0.0016794432,
-0.8566864729,
0.2733007669,
0.1561789364,
-0.3067658246,
0.0516432412,
-0.5135836005,
0.7798304558,
-0.1967740953,
-0.2119719237,
-0.2527887821,
-0.754950583,
0.3514096737,
-0.1054247692,
0.05274266,
-0.4745964706,
0.5848701596,
0.9163360596,
-0.6546435952,
1.0095602274,
-0.1308745891,
-0.1842864454,
0.6530546546,
0.2371128947,
0.5589997172,
0.1326771677,
-0.0708951056,
-0.4061300159,
0.3331521749,
-0.3776966929,
-0.5722224712,
0.1553571522,
-0.5989287496,
-0.4364568293,
-0.2770812809,
-0.3142443299,
-0.4953158796,
-0.1305785775,
0.0627033338,
0.9821612835,
-0.5521336794,
0.1218430102,
0.4978936315,
-0.1565217376,
-0.0509455018,
0.68420434,
0.0625914857,
0.2066630572,
0.9070668221,
0.1641602814,
0.3458602428,
0.3896005452,
-0.1986315846,
-0.4034101069,
0.0159386992,
-0.2309094667,
0.1556452364,
-0.5460725427,
-0.3058240414,
-1.0515869856,
-0.1994616538,
-0.3457342386,
0.3073082864,
-0.5051652789,
-0.5934106708,
-0.1566735953,
-0.1985911727,
0.6398313642,
0.9270712137,
0.0175245162,
0.2303306162,
-0.9378951788,
0.2151890546,
0.3795394897,
0.0753629729,
-0.1977042556,
-0.4834611118,
-0.2646512389,
0.3506934643,
-0.206745699,
-1.0481650829,
0.5252614021,
-0.0290011615,
0.5254140496,
-0.0029020056,
0.421469152,
0.3316612244,
-0.0567380451,
0.6177885532,
-0.1162992641,
-0.2453473806,
0.4988833666,
-0.4823310971,
0.1283654124,
0.8762472272,
0.6501087546,
-0.7032032609,
-0.6034728289,
-0.5854600072,
-0.7637971044,
1.1907039881,
0.5173381567,
0.2500256896,
-0.0957513303,
0.1854084879,
0.1343953013,
0.2775557339,
-0.2280861884,
-0.0570621081,
0.0975193903,
-0.1839043647,
0.138517037,
-0.0063094785,
-0.5927785635,
-0.0380834527,
0.2981877029,
-0.213830471,
0.7868734598,
0.1861480922,
0.0389257483,
-0.0931468457,
0.2949020565,
0.2320628762,
0.6767487526,
-0.3331734836,
-0.1580595672,
0.1875782609,
-0.6768020988,
-0.0303109419,
0.0124357324,
0.1449195296,
0.1632481962,
0.0262999106,
0.7841114998,
0.2177722305,
-0.7140234113,
0.3191795051,
-0.7240998745,
-0.210238874,
-0.4501509368,
0.2936405241,
-0.1960645914,
-0.1072939411,
0.5319874287,
-0.2377535403,
0.0865649804,
-0.9089924693,
0.6240724325,
0.296942085,
-0.6280693412,
-0.3839721382,
0.585172236,
0.2620832026,
-0.3855233192,
0.8447628617,
0.1022446454,
-0.533259809,
0.713244319,
-0.0005754961,
0.6577140689,
0.027356863,
0.7280399799,
0.5014199018,
-0.0552893691,
-0.2724417746,
0.5009450912,
-0.1137003303,
-0.7247607112,
-0.2344933599,
-0.3640144169,
-0.9340900779,
-0.1314554065,
-0.607588172,
0.3784522116,
-0.0215102062,
-0.3865778744,
-0.0846809298,
0.1357283741,
-1.0721956491,
0.0722055659,
-0.2453483045,
0.7164550424,
-0.8501160741,
0.5139407516,
0.1646580845,
-0.3809289932,
-0.9535439014,
-0.1751829237,
0.103785105,
-0.6267411709,
0.486781925,
-0.1270094067,
0.1398287266,
-0.1900903583,
-0.8254286647,
-0.7111253142,
0.8394326568,
0.3401751518,
-0.3945580423,
-0.0186383631,
0.7373203635,
0.6877081394,
-0.3285079598,
0.7966684103,
0.9605597258,
0.4125002623,
0.4001977444,
-0.9879635572,
0.0197474156,
-0.1033025533,
-0.8428745866,
0.1205158755,
-0.7719863653,
0.5518223643,
0.2282014936,
-0.5045269132,
-0.2995246351,
0.5527349114,
0.0328108817,
0.2746864855,
0.5330489278,
0.0478032678,
0.6157553792,
-0.2173465043,
0.8893175721,
-0.0447173677,
0.1249386296,
1.08926332,
-0.5144637227,
0.5577697754,
0.0903189257,
-0.2269179821,
0.1840581298,
0.6019695401,
0.2537696362,
0.1865390092,
0.0053101815,
-0.3690373302,
-0.2644092739,
-0.3237923086,
-0.0561698601,
0.4120029807,
0.7495878935,
-0.0567657053,
-0.4804117382,
-0.2510894239,
0.055111751,
-0.3216437995,
0.2338873446,
0.9570206404,
0.0940101147,
-0.9981651902,
0.1815973967,
-0.4874624908,
-0.1879413575,
-0.5867543221,
-0.1734107733,
-0.6806258559,
-0.1650903523,
-0.1594271809,
-1.0273973942,
0.375020802,
0.0662232339,
0.2787563503,
-0.0787520111,
0.4513551891,
-0.4811024368,
-0.2936225235,
0.0587506369,
0.8634688258,
0.5743514895,
0.0467424914,
-0.7583307028,
0.0365626588,
0.2315314859,
-0.2953543961,
0.2219985574,
0.4250849783,
-0.2360750139,
0.8682473302,
0.429648757,
-0.1370662451,
-0.0710744187,
0.1688012481,
1.0139142275,
-0.4315302968,
-0.3713499308,
-0.230832234,
0.3928498626,
-0.269621551,
-0.0944950432,
0.3789545894,
0.6073576808,
0.4068523943,
0.0156766735,
0.7098879218,
-0.2392019629,
0.9683510661,
-0.3355354369,
0.5318220854,
-0.388412267,
0.465043366,
-0.0891556889,
-0.9993883371,
-0.0267776381,
0.3974593282,
-0.4845736325,
-0.1566423178,
0.566408217,
1.0791039467,
-0.2184812427,
0.165473938,
0.1655460745,
0.2067397684,
0.6656638384,
0.3188007474,
0.8039028645,
-0.2723479569,
0.9411261678,
-0.0410052799,
0.0306654796,
-0.1944649071,
-0.2167403251,
-0.8905897141,
-0.6983526349,
-0.2494771183,
-0.3586045504,
0.2245768309,
1.0960990191,
0.5376989841,
-0.9939089417,
-0.4339675307,
-0.0490205213,
0.0349844769,
0.3363482952,
-0.2994526923,
0.2326565236,
-0.4161633849,
-0.7922208905,
0.3302468956,
0.0281686168,
0.0181461163,
-0.1917958111,
0.1750748158,
0.0054619722,
0.3686158955,
0.1718617976,
0.7325398922,
-0.0460173823,
-0.3235057592,
0.0696559027,
-0.476082474,
0.2118210793,
1.0923061371,
-0.7682111263,
0.4112615287,
0.7337248921,
0.3948342502,
0.9260783195,
0.2113694847,
1.2564675808,
-0.7285653353,
-0.0319264121,
0.4259087741,
0.0113323629,
0.2405794114,
-0.4847863019,
0.9003328681,
-0.0575528741,
-0.5830162764,
-0.9234004617,
0.1750338376,
-0.9740989804,
0.1903500408,
0.7691546082,
-0.0626814067,
-0.084549509,
-0.9356027842,
-0.4391342998,
0.3005973101,
-0.7591387033,
0.9588214755,
0.5450338125,
-0.2639111876,
-0.0702659935,
-0.8599390984,
0.8909676075,
0.3373405039,
-0.9158995748,
0.5020833611,
0.4208756685,
-0.0715811625,
0.011410106,
1.0254420042,
-0.1509123743,
0.1716203988,
0.1067835689,
-0.3368797004,
0.5694625974,
-0.4982670248,
0.4559554756,
0.008507696,
-0.1866079122,
0.0568358265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02020v1 | A Bibliometric Review of Large Language Models Research from 2017 to 2023 | 2023-04-03T21:46:41 | 2023-04-03T21:46:41 | Lizhou Fan, Lingyao Li, Zihui Ma, Sanggyu Lee, Huizi Yu, Libby Hemphill | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | Large language models (LLMs) are a class of language models that have
demonstrated outstanding performance across a range of natural language
processing (NLP) tasks and have become a highly sought-after research area,
because of their ability to generate human-like language and their potential to
revolutionize science and technology. In this study, we conduct bibliometric
and discourse analyses of scholarly literature on LLMs. Synthesizing over 5,000
publications, this paper serves as a roadmap for researchers, practitioners,
and policymakers to navigate the current landscape of LLMs research. We present
the research trends from 2017 to early 2023, identifying patterns in research
paradigms and collaborations. We start with analyzing the core algorithm
developments and NLP tasks that are fundamental in LLMs research. We then
investigate the applications of LLMs in various fields and domains including
medicine, engineering, social science, and humanities. Our review also reveals
the dynamic, fast-paced evolution of LLMs research. Overall, this paper offers
valuable insights into the current state, impact, and potential of LLMs
research and its applications. | [
-0.2578027546,
-0.7366297841,
0.7005283237,
0.1918518394,
-0.1225336194,
0.2656848431,
-0.2719196975,
-0.6412880421,
0.1630542576,
0.7426134944,
-0.4120873511,
-0.3270397484,
-0.7352469563,
0.289780885,
-0.6304050088,
0.6228253245,
0.1046381593,
0.3702546954,
-0.1848448813,
0.0576308481,
-0.2651746571,
-0.6000784636,
-0.4244176745,
-0.531701684,
0.7241032124,
-0.0214668289,
0.6546828151,
0.6236793995,
0.7077365518,
0.3047158122,
-0.5790429711,
0.0311270915,
-0.4356924295,
0.2974775434,
-0.1485530138,
-0.2620135546,
-0.5446587801,
0.0059441356,
0.8903610706,
1.0195246935,
-0.0478964001,
0.1941886097,
0.131604284,
0.5797880888,
-0.1741200984,
0.1319568008,
-0.5605989695,
-0.1131252348,
-0.5039967895,
-0.373324126,
-0.3403131068,
-0.2252245545,
0.1689555794,
0.0145895435,
-0.1298382729,
0.2807965279,
0.4275458753,
-0.115225479,
-0.4406110346,
-0.4699407518,
-0.8781920075,
0.9469897151,
-0.9570792317,
0.6431540251,
0.0376652591,
0.1886868477,
-0.5241419077,
-0.8531775475,
-0.3422787786,
-0.3045713603,
0.2771544456,
-0.3584118485,
-0.1999048293,
-0.1271568239,
-0.1308266371,
0.2026338726,
-0.5662651658,
0.5367340446,
-0.4113239944,
0.095505394,
0.5372179747,
0.4401671588,
0.4016325176,
-0.1263353676,
-0.2462868541,
0.4066050649,
-0.9338834882,
-0.1960766762,
0.0478063151,
0.3228306174,
-0.0058394992,
0.7508012652,
-0.0554429926,
0.7315093279,
-0.5440338254,
-0.3383522332,
0.2006551325,
-0.5849509835,
-0.3151672184,
-0.1421403736,
0.9790076613,
0.2722301781,
0.1465947181,
-0.4240486622,
-0.1303420216,
-0.2429560125,
0.1485406905,
-0.7107791305,
0.2119302154,
0.2498861253,
-0.4854288697,
-0.2283299714,
-0.2662615478,
-0.8341401219,
-0.5725102425,
-0.5949184299,
-0.3090088367,
-0.2032925636,
-0.4079372287,
0.310437113,
0.2738922834,
0.2574449778,
0.2642953098,
-0.7283313274,
0.2324169278,
1.0940947533,
1.1403969526,
-0.3596803844,
-0.296645999,
0.0254171956,
0.111191459,
-0.5474583507,
0.7582716942,
-0.4867428541,
-0.5820772648,
0.4615729451,
0.1314162165,
0.2749566436,
-0.5095453858,
0.4860368967,
-0.7229773402,
-0.054688219,
-0.386526823,
-0.4059994221,
-0.079316102,
0.4679463208,
-0.7155273557,
0.7262444496,
-0.2678670585,
-0.7106015682,
0.0262225438,
-0.5968536139,
-0.2523769438,
0.3351151347,
-0.0882970169,
-0.2999455929,
0.0771222711,
-0.2100501955,
0.5319206715,
-0.9355314374,
0.6787770987,
-0.3864889443,
-0.2234565765,
0.3998788297,
-0.1764935255,
0.9925863147,
0.3229393959,
-0.0612736605,
0.2529576123,
-0.6504595876,
-0.1056175157,
0.1118220165,
-0.1828235239,
-0.24213548,
0.4477722645,
0.1893232018,
0.1464468092,
0.4189361632,
-0.4539535344,
0.2236169279,
-0.5214152932,
0.9345269799,
0.4764038622,
-0.0655226633,
0.5405886173,
-0.1793932319,
0.5171686411,
-0.372889787,
0.1888883263,
-0.1937585175,
-0.4935805798,
-0.414873749,
-0.2266321629,
0.2009981573,
0.345734179,
-0.4278710783,
0.4142955542,
-0.3340703845,
-0.6655851007,
-0.3861749172,
0.1155811474,
-0.1672951877,
0.1696626693,
0.2091555148,
0.006080783,
-0.7360860109,
-0.7437291145,
-0.2851017118,
-0.1857309192,
0.0909635797,
-0.0640536174,
0.4780149162,
-0.5005550981,
0.834387958,
-0.0345085561,
-0.0572460182,
-0.3105959594,
0.1047356799,
0.1933697313,
-0.0093314955,
0.2424249202,
-0.5550311208,
-0.1490765512,
0.0384976082,
-0.7632446885,
-0.0367107913,
0.3982197642,
0.147184521,
0.2565082312,
0.6842511892,
-0.5982761979,
-0.1674645543,
0.7634778619,
-0.1746712923,
0.4705871642,
0.0799490735,
-0.1171167195,
-0.946199894,
0.2007060349,
0.0837955028,
-0.0288491994,
-0.6070979834,
0.1001904756,
-0.1635625213,
0.0139567163,
-0.2335908115,
0.6304907799,
-0.8277444243,
-0.0768417493,
-0.4841563702,
0.0561065599,
-0.5036884546,
-0.296687603,
-0.0677175,
0.4418343902,
0.4987722933,
-0.4128967822,
0.4740731716,
0.029335117,
-0.7046225667,
0.1617200822,
-0.6572563648,
0.0072840969,
0.0308029987,
0.404766053,
-0.938344717,
0.0759612024,
-0.0087240646,
-0.1646854728,
0.1435497999,
0.067546308,
-0.9148755074,
-0.5971407294,
-0.3315492868,
0.0897589475,
0.3778966367,
-0.1844520271,
0.3680965602,
0.6794867516,
-0.8211858869,
-0.3561910093,
-0.5711497068,
0.4999522567,
-0.0763425454,
-0.5013062954,
0.1526610255,
-0.0480816588,
-0.6627737284,
0.0488161854,
0.2422070801,
0.2068720758,
0.1248934269,
0.1228276864,
0.5118959546,
-0.2024062574,
0.0578747541,
-0.3287008703,
0.127752021,
0.3655564785,
-0.1617191583,
0.7964398861,
-0.1236301437,
-0.0478695296,
-0.0576677546,
0.1905636191,
0.7065058947,
-0.3211115003,
0.6777061224,
0.4260368943,
-0.1824246049,
-0.0557308681,
-0.6942247748,
-0.1757381409,
-0.4096990526,
0.6763127446,
0.1599685252,
-1.2169079781,
0.2006595433,
-0.4291648567,
0.3608832955,
0.2426256537,
1.0744559765,
0.0237211101,
0.7913959622,
0.7558630705,
-0.2051510811,
0.3595766425,
-0.1026751399,
0.5049728155,
-0.9042341113,
-0.5074768662,
-0.6768004298,
-0.2054893523,
-0.7760288715,
-0.6628341079,
0.3451893032,
-0.2005043328,
-0.150488019,
-0.086064063,
-0.3854243159,
0.1648067534,
0.1854287237,
-0.5522944927,
0.4779524505,
0.0478465185,
0.0256078374,
-0.1190616041,
-0.4335077107,
-0.8403517008,
1.230928421,
0.5415162444,
0.6612841487,
0.0908543617,
0.3154890239,
0.2003714442,
0.4575618804,
-0.7751477361,
0.787624836,
-0.0131603023,
-0.8230410218,
-0.5718355179,
-0.3302874565,
-1.0521275997,
0.4075402319,
-0.1773182601,
-0.6923106909,
-0.1463074535,
-0.3001063764,
0.1372542232,
0.5005472898,
-0.0314379446,
0.3119624555,
-0.4186375141,
-0.4740617573,
-0.2258767039,
-0.6819422841,
0.5893104076,
-0.0558057986,
0.6562111378,
-0.4208394885,
-0.2170085758,
0.7323215008,
-0.0114273392,
0.7099890709,
0.0993107334,
-0.4074445963,
0.239215076,
0.0278760381,
0.5335552096,
-0.2762154937,
-0.2632018328,
0.3576688468,
0.1864104569,
-0.1098455638,
-0.0129060037,
0.9457319975,
-0.4855337441,
-0.5316881537,
-0.6532317996,
-0.5860195756,
-0.5070780516,
0.2381922752,
-0.0519615747,
0.0738701001,
-0.4930635989,
0.2821939886,
0.6868443489,
-0.100538522,
0.6039808393,
0.5651318431,
-0.5691040158,
-0.2752324343,
0.8341213465,
0.3747228682,
-0.0194433741,
0.2830775678,
0.1530044228,
-0.3304838836,
-1.0543538332,
-0.3240080476,
0.8400807381,
-0.34491992,
0.100875333,
-0.617505312,
-0.3268725574,
-0.6416624188,
-0.0380930528,
-0.3421569765,
0.0803464875,
-0.3656283319,
0.0912921131,
0.1134383157,
1.0803267956,
0.1724072546,
-0.0167340841,
-0.6362434626,
0.047921177,
0.0408899598,
0.3386635184,
0.1859312207,
-0.576480329,
-0.2259391546,
-0.2171142399,
-0.30924806,
-0.6774638295,
0.681637466,
-0.2425308228,
0.5526595712,
0.1518702656,
-0.3430380821,
0.367603898,
-0.9464526176,
0.8941881061,
0.4177395403,
-0.5211787224,
0.1010738313,
-0.4785834551,
0.214638412,
0.1162623465,
0.6819454432,
-0.9015552402,
-0.0583572239,
-0.2563085258,
-1.0133746862,
0.508377552,
-0.2431731075,
0.3009305596,
0.2805297971,
0.0415933877,
-0.024738064,
0.3800888956,
-0.546169579,
-0.1010783389,
0.3841268718,
-0.1136605367,
-0.2109990418,
-0.6366609931,
-0.2076092958,
-0.0897327363,
0.6097646952,
-0.006571766,
0.1803616136,
-0.3168590963,
0.1744457781,
-0.2587673962,
0.6750392914,
0.5522608757,
0.8677694201,
-0.1371353567,
0.1230461672,
-0.0816855803,
-0.2276657075,
0.0454131216,
0.1962291896,
-0.3928233981,
0.025652973,
0.4415540397,
0.4997282326,
0.2185144722,
-0.9042648077,
0.3022321463,
0.4345627427,
-0.2692973614,
-0.4957859814,
-0.3725622594,
0.6979923844,
0.4645198882,
0.3293032944,
-0.3548411727,
0.244195208,
-0.8785117865,
-0.3670589924,
0.6666073203,
-0.1991883069,
-0.4867418408,
0.4259692132,
0.2928040624,
-0.343926549,
0.2813104689,
0.1905191541,
-0.1679305434,
0.1526980698,
0.4416179061,
0.5571778417,
-0.1626583487,
0.0623264462,
0.0612033196,
0.5220456123,
-0.40616256,
0.2362923622,
0.3988629282,
-0.5373088121,
-0.5538911223,
-0.8986749649,
-0.4721788466,
0.5147031546,
-0.2075234056,
0.3281597793,
-0.4264709353,
-0.2992164791,
0.1682094336,
0.1709455103,
-0.48016572,
-0.0844270885,
0.412717551,
0.7545588613,
-0.4669258893,
0.7986911535,
0.6776524186,
-0.0497141145,
-0.2813416719,
-0.2935288548,
0.439258337,
-0.6559531093,
0.7179470658,
-0.2221664935,
-0.2451244742,
-0.1367375702,
-0.8553096652,
-1.0108906031,
1.109087348,
0.2039220482,
-0.9144149423,
-0.5227541924,
0.2081559598,
0.7220904231,
-0.3904181123,
0.0665014461,
0.5929288268,
0.5367281437,
0.1203561053,
-0.8970455527,
-0.1217423081,
-0.1645954847,
0.279938221,
0.2212409228,
-0.7331770062,
0.8716753721,
0.0261034761,
-0.0492033139,
0.4410365522,
0.7075574994,
0.440117389,
0.4411575794,
0.0989141166,
0.1649626642,
0.5741593838,
-0.0152021246,
0.887978971,
-0.3250434399,
0.2397989035,
0.7643828392,
-0.77354002,
0.9096684456,
0.6619947553,
-0.5436368585,
0.447021842,
0.4009509683,
-0.1755307764,
0.137235105,
0.4324127138,
-0.1716095209,
-0.235073939,
-0.3242069781,
-0.3666941226,
0.2407313138,
0.6472268701,
-0.6193762422,
-0.0607013553,
0.0195565261,
0.3712461293,
0.0914754644,
-0.2205759138,
0.5390705466,
0.2468978614,
-0.551199317,
0.3128668368,
0.3083298206,
0.7403634787,
-0.693584621,
0.0686793998,
0.0087622888,
-0.0659457669,
-0.0449711904,
-0.712635994,
0.0880561993,
0.1535085887,
-0.0827029496,
-0.3248224854,
0.6891030073,
-0.3272275031,
-0.6071063876,
0.5241670609,
0.6456844807,
0.0873647183,
0.2838532925,
-0.5358880758,
0.5632462502,
-0.1764763296,
-0.3733845353,
0.4666624069,
0.4436649978,
-0.0036292479,
0.9064967036,
0.5809117556,
0.4670291543,
0.1775615066,
-0.081188105,
0.8044481277,
-0.8877185583,
-0.0544329397,
-0.9037092328,
0.1097029671,
0.0199474748,
-0.2644885182,
0.8484870195,
0.442864418,
0.3969907463,
0.1503447592,
0.8545738459,
0.1082579717,
0.8617360592,
-0.4581576586,
0.6283369064,
-0.4849954545,
0.3850802481,
-0.1633293182,
-0.6904838681,
-0.409725368,
0.1854103655,
-0.5049065351,
0.1050585136,
0.5356762409,
0.6901252866,
0.3171204329,
0.2335317284,
0.384563148,
0.4433964789,
0.4392801821,
0.0404807255,
0.9196654558,
0.0879251435,
0.1259011328,
0.1790465713,
0.0522648431,
-0.7155014277,
-0.7470306158,
-0.7408075929,
-0.575689435,
0.0218996275,
-0.2335286289,
0.1496941894,
0.8588936329,
0.5007707477,
-0.5244824886,
-0.6986940503,
0.0023945491,
0.0110103358,
0.0761727467,
-0.187517494,
0.1532075107,
-0.218291983,
-0.8175375462,
0.4083944857,
0.5839111209,
-0.163971886,
-0.9507032633,
-0.0876379162,
-0.478099972,
0.2866847515,
0.9563738704,
0.2316524982,
-0.9922405481,
0.3084841669,
0.1376383156,
-0.4006273746,
-0.2235918343,
1.0491397381,
-0.3334783614,
0.2375228554,
0.5017827153,
0.6197066903,
0.2786318064,
-0.458896637,
0.3156318963,
-0.0110772317,
-0.1163303554,
0.4839543998,
0.3735743165,
0.6443172097,
0.2282816321,
0.6449210048,
0.3511133492,
-0.8039168715,
-1.1891479492,
0.0757005364,
-1.0213081837,
-0.4747208655,
1.3633714914,
0.2792110741,
-0.3313047886,
-0.1998913437,
0.0233387873,
0.0558100268,
-0.1493986845,
0.7751922607,
0.8406943083,
-0.0583830997,
-0.3155265749,
-0.8094990849,
0.1707683653,
0.2887531519,
-0.8084315658,
0.153914541,
0.4695231616,
0.303356111,
0.159153074,
0.4934002757,
-0.38398996,
-0.2607507408,
-0.3901016712,
0.1857304871,
0.0684431568,
-0.3614273667,
-0.1788172424,
0.1890931875,
0.5243102908,
0.5379929543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01373v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01373v2 | Pythia: A Suite for Analyzing Large Language Models Across Training and Scaling | 2023-04-03T20:58:15 | 2023-05-31T17:54:07 | Stella Biderman, Hailey Schoelkopf, Quentin Anthony, Herbie Bradley, Kyle O'Brien, Eric Hallahan, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Shivanshu Purohit, USVSN Sai Prashanth, Edward Raff, Aviya Skowron, Lintang Sutawika, Oskar van der Wal | cs.CL | cs.CL | How do large language models (LLMs) develop and evolve over the course of
training? How do these patterns change as models scale? To answer these
questions, we introduce \textit{Pythia}, a suite of 16 LLMs all trained on
public data seen in the exact same order and ranging in size from 70M to 12B
parameters. We provide public access to 154 checkpoints for each one of the 16
models, alongside tools to download and reconstruct their exact training
dataloaders for further study. We intend \textit{Pythia} to facilitate research
in many areas, and we present several case studies including novel results in
memorization, term frequency effects on few-shot performance, and reducing
gender bias. We demonstrate that this highly controlled setup can be used to
yield novel insights toward LLMs and their training dynamics. Trained models,
analysis code, training code, and training data can be found at
\url{https://github.com/EleutherAI/pythia}. | [
-0.1091243103,
-0.7276949883,
0.3758879602,
0.0922836959,
0.0640132502,
0.1693114042,
-0.3786582947,
-0.2162026465,
0.0201099515,
0.5025600195,
-0.3608863056,
-0.2723303735,
-0.521061182,
-0.0679634809,
-0.74090451,
1.029214859,
-0.0923011899,
0.322114706,
0.1366874725,
-0.2437500954,
-0.1871007979,
-0.5118899941,
-0.3991208971,
-0.3290737569,
0.7425574064,
0.4870209992,
0.5973172188,
0.7792104483,
0.5409086943,
0.2599782646,
-0.4005866051,
-0.1169600189,
-0.6624314189,
0.3388928175,
-0.0900390595,
-0.5858475566,
-0.4742301404,
-0.0774505138,
1.217030406,
0.7217225432,
-0.1681502908,
0.5670149922,
-0.2132633775,
0.3956625462,
-0.6080034971,
-0.0901848674,
-0.6116631627,
-0.1992449611,
-0.2998753488,
-0.0354169644,
-0.3755219877,
-0.2943563759,
0.3936926126,
-0.2135898471,
0.2009291798,
0.1687562764,
0.5745355487,
-0.3013750017,
-0.5329766273,
-0.1811182201,
-0.8731020689,
0.7694967389,
-0.3901408613,
0.2178318053,
0.0253316425,
0.4145542979,
-0.3712920547,
-0.891238749,
-0.2638374567,
-0.2383472621,
0.3142211139,
-0.4074225426,
-0.3111345768,
0.0725633129,
0.4988593757,
0.7515175343,
-0.5884500146,
0.1655087322,
-0.3897998929,
-0.1434656829,
0.5047155023,
0.2028592974,
0.6471102238,
0.2758642137,
0.2742027044,
-0.1001766548,
-1.0004614592,
-0.371740967,
0.574516356,
0.1347381324,
-0.1485741287,
0.6312371492,
-0.3275489807,
0.5511358976,
-0.1748231649,
-0.0552293919,
0.1099056676,
0.09903007,
-0.3160065413,
0.0495274253,
0.7393228412,
-0.188715905,
0.2391273975,
-0.2222521454,
-0.155510217,
-0.2265852541,
0.1614751071,
-0.9799515605,
-0.680968821,
0.0325004496,
-0.4618850648,
-0.4167823195,
-0.2723501921,
-0.9249395728,
-0.6698428988,
-0.3343219161,
0.3969940841,
-0.1993434876,
-0.6640812159,
-0.1198060587,
-0.0199895166,
0.2955022454,
0.2428243607,
-1.1064348221,
0.4267666042,
0.5610938072,
1.1429902315,
0.0576118901,
-0.5739488006,
-0.5466627479,
-0.2434801906,
-0.4643555582,
0.3834217489,
-0.4261427522,
-0.2311203629,
0.2913248241,
-0.010648408,
0.0134311467,
-0.4764744341,
0.0268978309,
-0.6900398135,
-0.1096781865,
-0.2109415531,
-0.5686991811,
-0.0646827072,
0.1112922728,
-0.8141463399,
1.0567622185,
-0.1093045771,
-0.8574073911,
0.2028260976,
-0.409561336,
-0.0729061961,
0.078240931,
-0.1253598332,
-0.4934786558,
0.5828418136,
0.0407577343,
0.1882308125,
-0.4880761802,
0.0445843898,
-0.4845900238,
-0.3620759845,
0.4238539934,
-0.3875397444,
0.7130920291,
0.0691038892,
-0.3501447737,
0.5744835734,
-0.8431658149,
0.0631759167,
0.1353245676,
-0.5780344009,
-0.0067047304,
0.1098504141,
0.1766694784,
0.1061304584,
0.238228038,
-0.2562555373,
0.4278825223,
-0.2192345262,
0.7224984765,
0.6352792382,
0.0716729611,
0.5419194698,
-0.3173514307,
0.5578550696,
-0.1925676167,
0.0497629754,
-0.1637125164,
-0.3964587152,
-0.9574062228,
-0.309150666,
0.1972090155,
0.2151513994,
-0.2500036955,
0.0681791306,
-0.5313007236,
-0.7605065107,
-0.1396352351,
0.3044736981,
0.1661148369,
-0.150777027,
0.1399279684,
-0.2379206419,
-0.4275291562,
-0.8313295841,
-0.4041722119,
-0.1481413096,
-0.0883887261,
-0.1360307783,
0.9556601048,
0.0485629626,
0.6715967655,
-0.3355609775,
0.2734731734,
-0.574880302,
0.28652215,
0.1099812314,
0.3537467718,
0.3607077003,
-0.4369058907,
-0.0422236472,
-0.0170385689,
-0.4139494598,
0.0582495742,
-0.0168533623,
-0.3945213258,
0.0881171599,
0.5186131597,
-0.5017000437,
0.2068149,
0.7923591733,
-0.3094653189,
0.7460156679,
-0.3527231216,
-0.0978473946,
-0.9616981745,
0.1772879958,
-0.0199983157,
-0.2780987322,
-0.715945065,
0.2680615187,
0.1103753895,
-0.137362659,
-0.2890649438,
0.3625927269,
-0.7652587891,
-0.6522784829,
-0.3173469305,
0.0305641424,
-0.4747380316,
0.2651414871,
-0.0392073691,
0.7037308216,
0.8160614967,
-0.5813427567,
0.5386918187,
0.174336046,
-0.5863404274,
0.0680483058,
-0.5839416385,
0.4453061521,
0.071898587,
0.2476443052,
-0.7785781026,
-0.4427625537,
0.0087136207,
-0.2981165051,
0.1662891507,
-0.5502184033,
-0.8759659529,
-0.1302835494,
-0.1644101739,
0.402777791,
0.5047134161,
-0.5123212934,
0.7258576155,
0.4188251793,
0.0521683916,
-0.1402256787,
-0.4805070162,
-0.0220099054,
-0.5745329857,
-0.3166389763,
-0.1214567423,
0.006060564,
-0.6213809848,
-0.4489714205,
-0.0600339137,
-0.2637605667,
0.2244238406,
0.4340689182,
0.1604810357,
-0.3093167245,
0.3449804485,
-0.2618827522,
0.3138483763,
0.1037047878,
-0.5200400949,
1.0116413832,
-0.263787508,
-0.023688091,
-0.5228683949,
-0.0277205221,
0.7992904186,
-0.4142201841,
0.9535944462,
0.3324024677,
-0.503472209,
-0.2181866318,
-0.3734871149,
-0.0801892653,
-0.4462617636,
0.5530042648,
-0.3380899131,
-0.7014083266,
0.614279449,
-0.1495394707,
0.3027656078,
0.2808173001,
1.0473766327,
0.1760997325,
0.9515904784,
0.769341588,
-0.4974623919,
0.931000948,
-0.2903761864,
-0.039279256,
-0.7016327977,
0.00025633,
-0.4341805279,
-0.4804068506,
-0.7674867511,
-0.5361722708,
0.1719027162,
0.3393754065,
-0.7122880816,
0.1672663242,
-0.1646426916,
0.7604071498,
0.476223588,
0.0181536153,
0.42493397,
0.2071266025,
0.3919537961,
0.1319386959,
-0.5862323046,
-0.4979619086,
1.5154209137,
0.61220783,
0.7294360399,
0.3439439535,
0.71158427,
-0.0095273908,
0.3219128847,
-0.9791924953,
0.4892985225,
0.2490922809,
-0.9800554514,
-0.2935162485,
-0.6404858828,
-0.8461638093,
0.2452295125,
-0.0661536306,
-0.9745049477,
-0.2083745748,
0.1271893829,
-0.1589962244,
0.4733512402,
-0.5092250705,
0.8419519663,
-0.3152430654,
-0.3125959933,
-0.6653698683,
-0.3905115426,
0.4377245605,
0.0726990253,
-0.0144096045,
-0.0278281812,
0.1938096434,
0.910699904,
-0.2702589333,
0.6361413598,
0.1157663688,
-0.1033752337,
0.329544723,
0.5040590763,
0.3566892743,
0.192397356,
0.2103573978,
0.0196089,
0.054708153,
-0.5748554468,
-0.3946163654,
0.9840316176,
-1.0060763359,
-0.2028992027,
-0.6001189947,
-0.8437871933,
-0.1616944671,
0.2512345612,
0.0186340399,
0.7825424671,
-0.1247323602,
0.2359090447,
0.8209235072,
-0.2600237727,
0.3470084071,
0.3156086206,
-0.567864418,
-0.3051783442,
0.7581861615,
0.1885462254,
0.528856039,
0.3054274917,
0.1381406784,
-0.0332863852,
-0.8298700452,
-0.412155211,
0.4269384444,
-0.8905158043,
0.0945338458,
-0.1691352576,
0.0058685946,
-0.265142858,
0.208213076,
-0.26880759,
-0.3581004143,
-0.1124633476,
-0.0093727745,
0.5901792049,
1.0936855078,
0.3482153714,
0.6777866483,
-0.5425671339,
-0.0119089829,
0.2278451473,
0.2342618853,
-0.0872266516,
-0.6946316361,
-0.2202659547,
-0.1188870147,
-0.2791558206,
-1.0184299946,
0.3804224432,
0.1662412882,
0.3057343066,
0.1240992025,
-0.4862033427,
0.4962156415,
-0.3993798196,
0.6870587468,
0.0987627581,
-1.109957695,
0.427567631,
-0.6636974216,
0.343732506,
0.4014210701,
0.2083778381,
-0.6844800115,
-0.111790821,
-0.4931963384,
-0.83040905,
0.8342866302,
0.2063391656,
0.287453562,
0.37493366,
0.6729661226,
-0.4038972259,
0.1183503196,
-0.7541132569,
-0.2426430732,
0.0430689491,
-0.407507062,
-0.0573025756,
-0.2809761167,
-0.2715404332,
-0.1940778792,
0.6404035091,
-0.1228371486,
0.0754995123,
-0.1935065836,
-0.5908049345,
0.0067429859,
0.0203404613,
0.2677570581,
0.9938113093,
0.0375282802,
0.0602036528,
0.3523541987,
-0.6513853669,
0.0456754826,
-0.2830137908,
0.11008697,
-0.2283788621,
0.516012013,
0.7705652714,
0.3211910725,
-0.80298841,
0.1582124084,
-0.0785696283,
-0.004854247,
-0.3848109245,
-0.0543048196,
0.2074078768,
0.470004648,
0.0845003873,
-0.6839301586,
-0.087851584,
-1.0341277122,
-0.0579852313,
0.0002872706,
-0.0505512394,
-0.2986758351,
0.2504683435,
0.0150367571,
-0.2443406582,
1.0280667543,
-0.0587549992,
-0.4144738019,
0.4892248511,
0.3781451583,
0.6533654928,
-0.0854159817,
0.1947192699,
0.4494617283,
0.1881311536,
-0.5153439641,
0.1038923115,
0.0827670768,
-0.4772411287,
-0.2351102382,
-0.8188312054,
-0.3779438138,
0.3515465856,
-0.6070433259,
0.5422390699,
-0.8503866196,
0.1156277731,
0.0011508962,
0.2333906144,
-0.3949320912,
0.0286438987,
0.3356052637,
0.9468755722,
-0.788815558,
1.0778254271,
0.6981653571,
-0.5467789173,
-0.9561145306,
0.2883394361,
0.3027863503,
-0.7252933383,
0.6001541615,
0.0827317312,
-0.0996080562,
0.3052127957,
-0.4944043756,
-0.9821372032,
1.2667329311,
0.3341670036,
-0.9339861274,
-0.3753834367,
-0.0601377748,
0.5424790382,
-0.1380122304,
0.3672504723,
1.1007347107,
-0.0138777029,
0.127579838,
-0.9285664558,
-0.2143600732,
0.0569697767,
0.0549466349,
0.4411066473,
-0.4222069681,
0.9278180599,
0.0093437256,
0.03669402,
0.5218549371,
0.5802083015,
0.2672748566,
-0.1522875875,
0.2551436424,
0.4490309358,
0.8000151515,
-0.1897619516,
0.9209429622,
-0.3876380622,
0.6121906042,
1.1829719543,
0.0200482532,
0.9148641825,
0.3286719322,
-0.2351803333,
0.4017818868,
0.6981167793,
-0.082719855,
0.0675527379,
0.772598803,
-0.3935551643,
-0.315757513,
0.2919225395,
-0.0774626955,
0.4014455974,
0.2302109003,
-0.4909746349,
-0.1613915414,
-0.190787375,
0.1980116069,
-0.2518701851,
-0.6593726277,
0.5210332274,
0.0920101479,
-0.3747592568,
0.420830816,
0.0509684756,
0.3969296515,
-0.6686540842,
0.2735591829,
-0.2244219929,
0.4908029735,
-0.1889758557,
-0.5280513763,
-0.0375060886,
0.1878787428,
0.0352368057,
-0.0236900263,
0.3515467048,
-0.3967200518,
-0.5176843405,
0.1219553649,
0.3854544461,
0.3372682333,
-0.1925056279,
-0.4598493874,
0.3444807529,
-0.3704617023,
-0.4613139927,
0.5910139084,
0.2733725607,
-0.2744742632,
0.7329401374,
0.4469533563,
0.3161248267,
0.4308733046,
0.3212383687,
0.708206296,
-0.5374698043,
-0.2224204689,
-0.9345412254,
0.2024592459,
-0.105504483,
-0.660073638,
0.9078870416,
0.5455235243,
0.7262022495,
0.1680247486,
0.5216758251,
-0.1561345607,
0.0959952846,
-0.4361135662,
0.8141664863,
-0.2640252411,
-0.0160566457,
0.0118670035,
-0.9554430246,
-0.381030798,
0.7814928293,
-0.6145237088,
0.0012126233,
0.6955849528,
0.7861968875,
0.0943312272,
0.0496671535,
0.1158837378,
0.3721866906,
0.6307840347,
0.5337513685,
1.0919008255,
-0.236441344,
0.5726857781,
-0.0277405009,
-0.1506798416,
-0.2488486916,
-0.4840642512,
-1.1446894407,
-0.4293699563,
-0.4126423597,
-0.47107777,
0.0112096453,
1.0894846916,
0.668345511,
-0.6751662493,
-0.5446137786,
-0.5713965297,
-0.0963238105,
0.0407232232,
-0.1243164837,
0.1181115136,
-0.2645303607,
-0.8135271072,
0.3072440028,
-0.0385098048,
0.0856705233,
-0.5752952099,
-0.0910848305,
-0.0682101846,
-0.0105548361,
0.2390138656,
0.2763344944,
-0.4933598936,
-0.1630880982,
-0.2591692805,
0.0696696714,
-0.097833477,
1.2929559946,
-0.3621458113,
0.3225840032,
0.6748081446,
0.4186147749,
0.6383013129,
-0.5657011867,
0.6837146282,
-0.4541135728,
0.1956625134,
0.1453810781,
0.4912756979,
0.2849994898,
0.102974534,
0.1144583747,
0.2097893059,
-0.8078458309,
-1.1580549479,
0.3764022589,
-0.5369375944,
-0.1639437526,
1.3895314932,
-0.2054424733,
-0.1844952852,
0.1716669202,
-0.2479748875,
0.4221909046,
-0.129157424,
0.810048461,
1.0365437269,
0.1045329869,
-0.1754734963,
-0.9048549533,
0.422947973,
0.2148541659,
-0.9236584306,
0.488471657,
0.7484118938,
0.8657439947,
0.0592450574,
0.4231785536,
-0.1088443398,
0.2409632951,
0.0631721541,
-0.163063094,
0.2730516791,
-0.764308393,
-1.0110058784,
0.0022750061,
0.6222351193,
-0.0186458509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01352v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01352v2 | A Simple and Effective Method of Cross-Lingual Plagiarism Detection | 2023-04-03T20:27:10 | 2023-04-05T09:23:17 | Karen Avetisyan, Arthur Malajyan, Tsolak Ghukasyan, Arutyun Avetisyan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | We present a simple cross-lingual plagiarism detection method applicable to a
large number of languages. The presented approach leverages open multilingual
thesauri for candidate retrieval task and pre-trained multilingual BERT-based
language models for detailed analysis. The method does not rely on machine
translation and word sense disambiguation when in use, and therefore is
suitable for a large number of languages, including under-resourced languages.
The effectiveness of the proposed approach is demonstrated for several existing
and new benchmarks, achieving state-of-the-art results for French, Russian, and
Armenian languages. | [
-0.3522199392,
-0.5554618239,
0.4692581892,
0.4938233793,
-0.4591933489,
-0.0821465403,
-0.171755448,
-0.333787024,
0.2297125906,
0.6926437616,
-0.4088546038,
-0.275923878,
-0.6461704969,
0.3022342324,
-0.5505064726,
0.7825806141,
-0.1947253793,
0.1527327448,
-0.0941449478,
-0.302698642,
0.1935044229,
-0.4418409765,
-0.6667728424,
-0.3410838842,
0.7084535956,
0.4604011178,
0.1569171697,
0.3833815157,
0.2742635012,
0.331199348,
-0.1354715824,
0.1261279881,
-0.5019831061,
-0.0320379324,
-0.3146042824,
-0.4145605266,
-0.0412174612,
-0.2016177028,
0.7708177567,
0.5282926559,
0.1890323162,
0.11146193,
-0.1501778215,
0.3988918066,
-0.6908488274,
0.0068483148,
-0.5914300084,
0.0253322627,
-0.7833940983,
-0.0825374573,
-0.4143633246,
-0.2223144174,
0.0117189931,
-0.6957689524,
-0.0056363698,
-0.0797954053,
0.6734505296,
-0.2395314574,
-0.3693077266,
-0.5366479158,
-0.0809851736,
1.1087993383,
-0.5459909439,
0.6917911172,
0.3104849458,
0.1491260529,
0.2987725437,
-0.870557785,
-0.7693914771,
-0.0100246426,
-0.1742000729,
-0.0652093589,
-0.3058888614,
-0.4681631625,
0.1652632356,
0.3152168393,
-0.5901160836,
0.1044209972,
-0.2143114954,
-0.5575484037,
0.29661268,
-0.5567381382,
0.6216490269,
-0.307300508,
-0.605689466,
-0.2612862289,
-0.6809087396,
-0.1758605838,
0.4350265861,
0.2802795172,
0.0843530819,
0.5583779216,
-0.1003801972,
0.1764549464,
-0.2777298987,
-0.3205396831,
0.187961638,
-0.7722193003,
-0.0903093293,
0.0065126452,
0.5771690011,
-0.1025579646,
0.5413988829,
-0.4297873378,
-0.0918665081,
-0.2208790779,
-0.2168096453,
-0.5238969326,
-0.3372447193,
-0.2388171554,
-0.4640429914,
-0.098067373,
-0.0251112767,
-0.8095774055,
-0.1115804762,
-0.2123378962,
0.4390807748,
-0.8201783299,
-0.4624868035,
-0.2415494621,
-0.3019656837,
0.2751871049,
0.152916342,
-0.8565917015,
0.0625449941,
0.8586156368,
0.7101579905,
-0.1536243707,
-0.7813329697,
-0.7366932034,
0.3040655851,
-0.17603302,
0.907885015,
-0.2813410759,
-0.2932176888,
0.0775318593,
0.2122205794,
0.0700246766,
-0.6017606258,
0.7036752105,
-0.625228405,
0.3420303166,
-0.6330292821,
-0.3578051031,
-0.4348531961,
0.3813949227,
-0.9484408498,
1.0490546227,
0.1249947175,
-0.6411344409,
0.4831363261,
-0.5824187398,
-0.6065122485,
0.0380755812,
0.1242444813,
-0.6460102201,
-0.301306963,
0.3649309576,
0.1186786219,
-0.0486284569,
0.0916440636,
-0.1836900264,
-0.109477371,
0.0654603392,
-0.2483971417,
1.4624435902,
0.2003912926,
-0.1548287421,
0.1319525689,
-0.4678758979,
-0.0002105799,
0.0430562422,
-0.4886487424,
-1.0572800636,
-0.6119813919,
0.5036327839,
0.2762252688,
0.5067583919,
-0.8836997747,
-0.0571894124,
-0.1145980656,
-0.0151357185,
0.5046844482,
-0.2480035871,
0.6319801807,
-0.2655474246,
0.334333539,
0.0589640737,
-0.0817691088,
0.1076033935,
-0.3363739252,
-0.6247666478,
-0.6600043774,
0.7232846022,
0.5981996059,
-1.3903257847,
0.0833359137,
-0.3931741714,
-0.487144053,
-0.5647633076,
0.8368968964,
0.6682032943,
0.205826655,
0.3658569157,
-0.2848356366,
-0.4661290944,
-0.7943677902,
-0.6498365402,
0.0437122919,
-0.0097978897,
0.0550219826,
0.9221134186,
0.0686735138,
0.6911461353,
0.1876482368,
-0.6560688615,
-0.3808084428,
0.602635026,
-0.0238941908,
0.6809824705,
0.958389163,
-1.0515155792,
-0.9601599574,
0.2578038573,
-0.7146270871,
-0.6182945371,
0.1273162365,
-0.4669611156,
0.5502598286,
0.4092752337,
-0.5301312804,
0.1213930696,
0.1799859703,
-0.1675189883,
0.1589799523,
-0.1435222924,
0.206964761,
-0.8513732553,
0.6097322702,
-0.1599229425,
-0.107522063,
-0.6308993101,
0.2555392087,
0.199882403,
-0.0695211738,
-0.6520591378,
0.6829869747,
-0.5394365191,
-0.1426725984,
0.0103871776,
0.2753024101,
-0.312975198,
0.358294487,
0.3519028425,
0.5560786724,
0.2779710889,
-0.1192488372,
0.3964054585,
0.3252713382,
-0.5350033045,
0.7977702618,
-0.4526228309,
0.1519709677,
-0.1649919897,
0.0695534274,
-0.8197754622,
0.0574378707,
0.4163193405,
-0.2008065432,
0.141487658,
-0.2928011119,
-0.732358098,
0.026374571,
-0.614335537,
0.5145203471,
0.1513032913,
-0.9061388373,
0.6535012722,
0.0246572699,
-0.5679557323,
-0.8174011707,
-0.7400861979,
0.1746588647,
0.0046670446,
-0.6755493879,
0.2205488682,
-0.0744725466,
-0.3545896709,
0.046821855,
-0.1030122936,
-0.5158905387,
-0.0177722182,
-0.4084666967,
0.1163215265,
-0.0703963935,
-0.3238193095,
0.0302848686,
0.0453112833,
-0.3369004428,
-0.1346189678,
0.4915113449,
0.2556666732,
-0.2624021769,
0.088010326,
1.06988132,
0.7554243207,
-0.5915359259,
0.227790013,
0.9550293684,
-0.544457674,
-0.4048791826,
-0.5470929146,
0.0182205513,
-0.3790073693,
0.1987969577,
-0.5194189548,
-0.4878791273,
0.4781462848,
0.0540388077,
0.0693952143,
0.101055406,
0.5476093888,
0.2571848035,
0.5521535873,
0.6062951684,
-0.2155198306,
0.6088673472,
-0.1842235923,
0.4591852725,
-0.3575165868,
-0.2060829997,
-0.7068192363,
-0.2690023184,
-0.3597055674,
-0.420263052,
0.24808608,
-0.0424381793,
0.0073657269,
0.4021807611,
0.0117741991,
0.4323917329,
1.1158044338,
0.0474740006,
0.5328298211,
0.2233679593,
-0.1997750401,
-0.1849346012,
-0.6838784814,
-0.3928379416,
0.9243962765,
-0.1992685199,
0.4589120448,
0.424144119,
0.818910718,
0.0886177644,
0.4743141532,
-0.598639369,
0.5973085761,
-0.5833313465,
-0.8058871031,
-0.4961464107,
-0.4587694407,
-0.9318284988,
0.5788389444,
-0.2535906434,
-0.6449812055,
0.1977972984,
-0.350779891,
-0.0197965875,
0.4740552902,
-0.5777004957,
1.1390771866,
-0.3690340817,
-0.3558610976,
-0.2249061763,
-0.4442226589,
0.4524950385,
-0.4384571314,
0.075564146,
-0.0330265015,
-0.167949006,
0.8501142859,
-0.5370480418,
0.547354579,
-0.1509164125,
-0.2137390077,
0.0865375698,
0.1805863082,
0.3285211325,
-0.0399903916,
-0.1981059611,
0.347481519,
0.115431875,
-0.5861279964,
-0.235008657,
0.7258093953,
-0.4383359849,
-0.0839944556,
-0.4981788099,
-0.6335952282,
0.1554256827,
0.7481920123,
0.2891373634,
0.08078897,
-0.3152349889,
0.2039515227,
0.5889981985,
-0.2564632595,
0.678599596,
0.8090609908,
-0.1443707645,
-0.1086833775,
1.0004324913,
0.1846966147,
-0.1698889136,
0.6724025011,
0.0922698379,
-0.4189840257,
-0.3214414418,
-0.6962789297,
0.4222833216,
-0.8628100157,
0.1103169993,
-0.3744464219,
0.3188608885,
-0.5736793876,
-0.2298788428,
-0.0488182679,
-0.1240029708,
-0.0343694016,
0.4498788118,
0.160569787,
0.2291117758,
-0.2638572454,
0.1152348891,
-0.8373618126,
0.5798143744,
0.570100069,
0.2719860077,
-0.0983358622,
-0.2102048248,
0.063204959,
0.073305428,
-0.0731894448,
-0.5792276263,
0.5985657573,
0.4138274789,
0.9791654944,
0.2206413001,
-0.0359194428,
0.3603298366,
-0.2899971306,
0.67304039,
0.1895778775,
-1.2739384174,
0.3699327707,
-0.2075420469,
0.2678824961,
0.5190369487,
0.6342291236,
-0.3836756349,
-0.180441767,
-0.3572417796,
-0.4957621992,
0.6799026728,
0.1138115749,
-0.2572231293,
0.394525826,
-0.254435122,
0.2968312204,
0.1231124029,
-1.0720701218,
0.0192438271,
-0.1554301828,
-0.1912609637,
-0.1355728358,
-0.0981766358,
-0.1385430992,
-0.3206314743,
0.7594658732,
-0.111749135,
0.035824772,
0.1424472928,
-0.7759227753,
-0.1714727134,
0.3693660498,
0.5699388981,
0.7748147249,
-0.0621925145,
0.0203324351,
0.1495385766,
-0.422629416,
0.0248025786,
0.1632168889,
-0.2369961739,
0.5483382344,
0.5061061382,
0.17669563,
0.57377702,
-0.6738731861,
0.7317219973,
0.210696876,
-0.3351112604,
-0.4691809118,
-0.6262977123,
-0.0482463725,
0.3132531345,
0.2617299557,
-0.1942258477,
0.0086085238,
-0.7494568229,
0.3107328713,
0.4635778666,
0.2161118388,
-0.1980867386,
0.5296496153,
0.2143429667,
-0.1917462647,
0.484262675,
-0.0502962768,
-1.0151320696,
0.436252743,
0.5026633143,
0.6594893932,
-0.1938439012,
0.0632709786,
-0.0557846427,
0.3488727808,
-0.2908633351,
0.6188494563,
-0.2549227476,
-0.8512606025,
-0.4754510522,
-0.5066711307,
-0.2825664878,
0.1186215878,
-0.5440487266,
0.2259765714,
-0.1340837032,
0.3964944482,
0.359148711,
-0.0439655557,
-0.5693699718,
-0.1085622311,
0.5279394388,
1.0097961426,
-0.8487207294,
1.4023965597,
0.8766666055,
-0.5105445385,
-0.4455319643,
-0.1777502894,
-0.0070790136,
-0.9767663479,
0.9962107539,
-0.2132773846,
0.0198772624,
-0.1173532307,
-0.3527556062,
-0.5590465069,
0.9084761143,
0.4928748906,
-0.4998504817,
0.0554385111,
0.0584179834,
0.4803569615,
0.1082113683,
-0.0889096931,
0.7489657402,
0.7948281765,
-0.2761776745,
-1.1942458153,
-0.120193243,
-0.3322581351,
-0.2503140569,
0.3424766362,
-0.6038350463,
1.1766668558,
0.2279099375,
-0.1171385348,
0.3981258571,
0.3731849492,
0.0378224552,
0.4223335087,
0.5953630209,
0.7993322015,
0.6645916104,
-0.1547130197,
0.8429889679,
-0.2634908557,
0.3287859261,
0.6366144419,
-0.4161752462,
0.8891997933,
0.9904685616,
0.0187532343,
0.3313997388,
0.2438037694,
-0.0725455955,
0.9145678282,
0.2232922912,
-0.4423425496,
-0.5261570811,
-0.1610026956,
-0.1144464165,
0.626963675,
0.1990844309,
-0.3760663271,
-0.6641020179,
0.1688450575,
0.1383184195,
0.1184981912,
-0.6006356478,
0.6428695321,
0.1560314298,
-0.7898321748,
0.6474637985,
0.0065351706,
0.9517127275,
-0.6232603788,
-0.0664228499,
-0.2346014977,
0.4711785913,
0.0340451896,
-0.5289442539,
0.1345355064,
0.2000022382,
-0.0631500781,
-0.5615214705,
1.0127958059,
-1.0624870062,
-0.4407212436,
0.6319000721,
0.9885127544,
0.1773997098,
0.1456980854,
-0.5389902592,
0.041258838,
0.0563502759,
0.121839948,
0.3611584902,
0.6320198774,
-0.2821575999,
0.3636621833,
0.6333527565,
0.2560709417,
0.1960920095,
-0.0139284264,
0.4890682399,
-0.3831751049,
-0.5489194989,
-0.7372086644,
-0.0023784968,
-0.4803889692,
-0.4279316664,
1.0479451418,
0.5414144993,
1.2292617559,
-0.3300146461,
1.0546752214,
-0.0054830033,
0.6483888626,
-0.5102245212,
0.8592794538,
-0.6020262241,
0.0739094839,
-0.391333282,
-0.8870356083,
-0.3611434102,
0.6221830845,
-0.3097930551,
-0.3594384193,
0.7904660702,
0.6249054074,
-0.463157177,
-0.1064619794,
0.2513234913,
-0.0490950197,
-0.0276725516,
0.6444442272,
0.5957515836,
-0.3930872679,
0.9692149758,
-0.5439124107,
-0.1328124255,
-0.2787572145,
-0.9821989536,
-0.9598215818,
-0.272194922,
-0.3461022377,
-0.1548370719,
0.0818273202,
0.5507110953,
0.4566944838,
-1.1671776772,
-0.1999451518,
0.4571359456,
0.3902972937,
-0.413649559,
-0.1398563683,
0.3151462972,
-0.0444681644,
-0.9857184291,
0.3999824524,
0.0276794937,
0.0061171404,
-0.1560191214,
0.0682922602,
-0.6901877522,
0.0815885812,
0.7704218626,
0.4120466113,
-0.6558403373,
-0.4061090052,
-0.0827828571,
-0.376341939,
-0.1953442097,
0.9934846163,
-0.3403590918,
0.4500615895,
0.9188297987,
0.6516052485,
0.5882551074,
-0.0359002613,
0.5567452908,
-0.9884534478,
0.2194973826,
0.0817387998,
0.6614844799,
0.5338000059,
0.181936577,
0.3960859776,
0.5436071157,
-0.2091182321,
-0.9872609377,
-0.2316861749,
-1.0196859837,
-0.4934778214,
0.9446273446,
-0.6630082726,
-0.1570537835,
-0.4729150236,
-0.1849409044,
0.3296569288,
-0.2009752095,
0.825165689,
0.9360626936,
0.3813500702,
-0.0998079032,
-0.3396081924,
0.3929542303,
0.6851942539,
-0.623595953,
-0.0759722143,
0.2124287337,
0.5288890004,
0.3931544423,
0.4579847753,
-0.2239919305,
0.6293831468,
-0.0085026985,
0.0572606064,
0.0466000438,
0.0082719512,
-0.340185672,
0.3161307871,
-0.2521819472,
-0.0751352012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01344v1 | End-to-End Models for Chemical-Protein Interaction Extraction: Better Tokenization and Span-Based Pipeline Strategies | 2023-04-03T20:20:22 | 2023-04-03T20:20:22 | Xuguang Ai, Ramakanth Kavuluru | cs.CL | cs.CL | End-to-end relation extraction (E2ERE) is an important task in information
extraction, more so for biomedicine as scientific literature continues to grow
exponentially. E2ERE typically involves identifying entities (or named entity
recognition (NER)) and associated relations, while most RE tasks simply assume
that the entities are provided upfront and end up performing relation
classification. E2ERE is inherently more difficult than RE alone given the
potential snowball effect of errors from NER leading to more errors in RE. A
complex dataset in biomedical E2ERE is the ChemProt dataset (BioCreative VI,
2017) that identifies relations between chemical compounds and genes/proteins
in scientific literature. ChemProt is included in all recent biomedical natural
language processing benchmarks including BLUE, BLURB, and BigBio. However, its
treatment in these benchmarks and in other separate efforts is typically not
end-to-end, with few exceptions. In this effort, we employ a span-based
pipeline approach to produce a new state-of-the-art E2ERE performance on the
ChemProt dataset, resulting in $> 4\%$ improvement in F1-score over the prior
best effort. Our results indicate that a straightforward fine-grained
tokenization scheme helps span-based approaches excel in E2ERE, especially with
regards to handling complex named entities. Our error analysis also identifies
a few key failure modes in E2ERE for ChemProt. | [
-0.3200095296,
-0.4268370867,
0.3761920631,
0.0859261304,
-0.2465984374,
0.1130914018,
-0.012488733,
-1.0719873905,
0.210706681,
0.0361652561,
-0.4154369235,
-0.2533400655,
-0.8412030339,
0.3829110563,
-0.3317844272,
1.211127162,
-0.0808188096,
0.0041611274,
-0.1698783636,
0.2122467458,
0.0715986341,
-0.3040373027,
-0.9616802931,
-0.3603376448,
0.7352951765,
0.0679890215,
0.3335141838,
0.598733604,
0.5726268291,
0.1831794828,
-0.2255919725,
0.1917639524,
-0.6313303113,
0.1686041802,
-0.4856481254,
-0.3323480487,
-0.5256923437,
0.1082030609,
0.0120023079,
0.7541765571,
0.2651402056,
0.0440606587,
-0.1992120147,
0.5764246583,
-0.7397908568,
0.2298765779,
-0.4437682629,
0.1748095453,
-0.2630178034,
-0.0419973992,
-0.4637355208,
0.2417150438,
0.2699663937,
-0.6292383075,
-0.0529725924,
0.3755984008,
1.1927304268,
0.137001425,
-0.6452536583,
-0.3434473574,
-0.593768537,
0.5793002844,
-0.6010388136,
0.5576973557,
0.4004091918,
0.2996142507,
-0.4681857526,
-1.0730298758,
-0.3117057085,
0.0035571596,
-0.1315712184,
0.5115420222,
-0.4527246356,
0.2565599084,
0.1668371558,
0.3426520824,
-0.3140806258,
0.1688958108,
-0.6817640662,
-0.3561535478,
0.4711678922,
-0.1518179178,
0.3454202116,
-0.1514052302,
-0.4877272248,
0.1105107442,
-0.5524278879,
0.0323457196,
0.2323523611,
0.1659087688,
0.1342891008,
0.8356364965,
-0.188820526,
0.2846035957,
0.2132141739,
0.5944650769,
0.0848012641,
-0.3694341481,
-0.2827408016,
0.0934877172,
0.7323652506,
0.3892340064,
0.3281501532,
-0.3453031182,
-0.130800277,
-0.0154060759,
-0.1181638241,
-1.0169670582,
-0.4008871019,
0.6459595561,
-0.4499836564,
-0.0531107485,
0.3130422235,
-1.1333309412,
-0.0786355585,
-0.2963425219,
0.3325497806,
-0.4997547865,
-0.1450462937,
-0.189231962,
-0.4241207838,
0.5641967654,
0.1877570897,
-0.6599676013,
0.7803913951,
0.7287085056,
1.146732688,
-0.3767544329,
0.0715462565,
-1.0111726522,
0.4670982957,
-0.0811870247,
0.810462296,
-0.6807108521,
-0.136067763,
-0.2086307406,
0.0656103641,
-0.1353650093,
-0.5881407261,
0.3945040405,
-0.5930723548,
0.3120224178,
-0.4866511822,
-0.7100331783,
0.12052688,
-0.2385359854,
-0.8577947021,
1.1189153194,
0.2857385278,
-0.8763715029,
0.3142049611,
-0.8209166527,
-0.4795752168,
-0.1967803538,
-0.1489589661,
-0.3053822219,
0.2918971479,
0.1604743004,
0.2275719047,
-0.5184740424,
0.0485307723,
-0.2878762782,
-0.1727199852,
0.2122748643,
0.2003716528,
0.463232398,
0.358897984,
-0.2205763459,
-0.0042508231,
-0.7581278682,
-0.0152860042,
-0.2494008392,
-0.239128679,
-0.3252061903,
0.0507152006,
0.4668032825,
0.7576835752,
0.1206410527,
-0.7576851845,
0.0002074139,
-0.4671345055,
0.5094637275,
0.7442294359,
0.2310871482,
0.2327991575,
0.0210375488,
0.1617136598,
0.2533363104,
-0.0367636383,
-0.2052408606,
-0.4318106472,
-0.6807225347,
-0.5433063507,
0.498044759,
0.4675306678,
-0.4115886092,
0.3190353215,
-0.2456259578,
-0.1486202478,
-0.4038181007,
-0.0594893545,
0.6126099229,
0.3677802384,
0.6869655848,
-0.4700318277,
-0.7599273324,
-0.9326858521,
-0.3733052313,
-0.2447139621,
-0.2469297647,
0.0515115187,
0.7396770716,
-0.2333855778,
1.301463604,
-0.4530387223,
-0.149970755,
-0.0912662297,
0.1962702423,
0.1184263602,
0.3937446773,
0.1932201833,
-0.6881642938,
-0.5967072248,
0.4003732502,
-0.715477407,
-0.4056437016,
-0.0537317656,
-0.4115096629,
0.2026523501,
0.5278533101,
-0.5863828659,
0.2118686587,
0.119850792,
-0.408605963,
0.4522071779,
0.1934524775,
-0.1629557908,
-1.0598573685,
0.5333940983,
0.4050377607,
-0.1809586734,
-0.9445568919,
-0.0840495229,
-0.1055736318,
0.1881591827,
-0.4848335981,
0.5702140927,
-0.7208268642,
-0.3078033626,
-0.0531939045,
-0.215002656,
0.0596140772,
0.4742607176,
0.1440390199,
0.4219428301,
0.2234216332,
-0.298360467,
0.0468505882,
0.1565235257,
0.2786109149,
0.5846136808,
-1.1098679304,
0.192128703,
-0.1795964688,
0.4305772185,
-1.0763595104,
-0.5163435936,
0.4772686362,
-0.4448209703,
0.8651454449,
-0.2320861816,
-0.3563808799,
0.0758882537,
-0.6291689277,
0.26123631,
0.2483386993,
-0.4486300647,
0.435136348,
0.3251336813,
-0.3405711651,
-0.4511855245,
-0.5756930113,
0.1749732494,
-0.0387392566,
-0.343378365,
0.6526221633,
0.1827859282,
-0.0529872589,
-0.0513870977,
-0.5235558152,
-0.3608799577,
-0.4196565449,
0.1636172533,
0.1950464249,
0.3794941306,
0.0100520076,
0.3782892227,
-0.4077308476,
0.1818941832,
-0.0218745805,
0.4965546131,
0.1422737092,
-0.1349979639,
-0.4450727999,
0.6030860543,
0.8024569154,
-0.360086292,
0.6359890699,
0.6243038177,
-0.6767044067,
0.1235542893,
-0.2506366372,
-0.3248771131,
-0.3718827665,
0.7880509496,
-0.3606242836,
-0.5723725557,
0.5999972224,
-0.5829219222,
0.1338941008,
0.4963258207,
0.230056718,
-0.3395189345,
0.5261418819,
0.4225180447,
-0.1626501083,
0.1217058897,
-0.0718488172,
0.3467447758,
-1.2591407299,
-0.9240292907,
-0.3748613894,
-0.3960098326,
-0.2053606957,
-0.4441922605,
0.3692493737,
0.3301428854,
-0.2017045915,
0.6140478849,
-0.0753758028,
0.1278840303,
0.2077794969,
0.1576444358,
0.204226464,
0.3729141653,
-0.2228205651,
-0.1949056387,
-0.5543568134,
-0.1432187408,
0.8918411732,
0.4833414853,
0.3674126565,
0.1655492187,
0.680678308,
0.3181402981,
0.2177064717,
-0.9343695641,
0.3034867048,
0.2129828781,
-0.4762948155,
-0.2086110115,
-0.273019284,
-0.8748250008,
0.1615381241,
-0.1397974193,
-0.9143303037,
0.442309916,
-0.0772522762,
0.1482895464,
0.0423905179,
-0.3953897059,
0.6225911975,
0.0455463976,
-0.8172793984,
0.1279224753,
-1.20221138,
0.1679033786,
-0.2522575855,
0.3364933133,
0.1149270087,
-0.4547709823,
0.7593100071,
-0.7007061243,
0.7920293212,
0.0907540768,
-0.0758119673,
0.1411679834,
0.0429150537,
0.7929330468,
-0.3646664619,
-0.2120714039,
0.1694680452,
0.0274476409,
-0.4204334319,
-0.5617983341,
0.4326927662,
-0.6677267551,
0.016122343,
-0.5469538569,
-0.208125174,
-0.0356204808,
0.0209002607,
0.5003843904,
0.1712549776,
0.0521934777,
-0.1426148266,
0.3118193448,
-0.1594585478,
0.7310190201,
0.2022491693,
0.0578984581,
-0.6388756633,
0.8594152927,
0.1329019368,
0.2870770097,
0.4913395047,
-0.2418906391,
-0.5702858567,
-0.1303262413,
-0.1549109668,
0.2394127101,
-0.5537259579,
-0.2855016589,
-0.7581269145,
-0.1874763817,
-0.180264771,
-0.0117294621,
-0.4393837154,
-0.5923945308,
-0.1502514333,
-0.222442016,
0.3360289931,
0.2723254561,
-0.2321853936,
-0.0417295992,
-0.7175388336,
0.0922904313,
-0.1823585182,
0.2611766458,
-0.1348989755,
-0.3609727919,
-0.2413714379,
-0.3707991242,
-0.1019049138,
-1.4893981218,
0.2829525471,
0.7846130729,
0.4436846077,
0.2776971459,
-0.0537284464,
0.7395336032,
-0.47262007,
0.589440167,
0.3693487942,
-1.0637792349,
0.6022757292,
-0.1918225139,
-0.0243500229,
0.4819675088,
0.7389605641,
-0.7558780313,
-0.0671901703,
-0.2673179805,
-1.3571819067,
0.3940233886,
0.6323516965,
-0.3006218672,
-0.3600526154,
0.4843333662,
0.0839393735,
0.1873366088,
-0.6822758317,
-0.2629239559,
0.1494486183,
-0.1425621659,
0.5287393332,
-0.1975212246,
0.0720835328,
-0.2061886489,
0.675377965,
-0.092757158,
0.3532143831,
0.5393723249,
-0.2921927869,
-0.2797207236,
0.3054209054,
0.0446349792,
0.3043211401,
-0.2050784826,
0.2620010674,
0.0149794742,
-0.3194735348,
-0.1558055431,
0.1299081743,
0.1480231583,
-0.0438017063,
0.6100682616,
0.3190869093,
0.1941509098,
-0.6406553388,
0.3736972213,
0.5212715864,
-0.0836898983,
0.1353440285,
-0.3629452884,
-0.0577368326,
0.2522461116,
0.4244607985,
0.0223897807,
0.6263958216,
-0.6164172292,
0.5475211143,
0.3200485706,
-0.4800600111,
-0.4910609722,
0.667715013,
0.17186068,
0.1545137018,
0.7170206904,
-0.108362101,
-0.4926309586,
0.5706215501,
0.8201708198,
0.7523656487,
-0.2809053957,
0.0985520333,
0.5701680779,
0.195330143,
0.2465490103,
0.2970316708,
0.0470475554,
-0.2643224597,
-0.6959317923,
-0.7400933504,
-0.1636440903,
0.027607847,
-0.8268575668,
0.4045044184,
-0.3800936937,
0.0388997085,
0.0756530836,
0.1247707307,
-0.4030616581,
0.1253347099,
-0.0676870719,
0.8657795191,
-1.1572980881,
0.569045186,
0.7901967168,
-0.4610483646,
-0.4118267,
-0.2724840939,
0.2509202957,
-0.0825635493,
0.7792984843,
0.2049948573,
0.0672180057,
-0.0189990439,
-0.2949628532,
-0.8454891443,
1.1909966469,
0.1512775719,
-0.7981543541,
-0.0931067616,
0.166630432,
0.6919164658,
-0.2686727047,
0.6523045897,
0.7243857384,
0.5904604793,
0.4639243484,
-0.8786158562,
0.3760445118,
-0.7363684177,
0.0201958902,
0.429358691,
-0.5985246301,
0.6213062406,
-0.2539152801,
-0.2425832897,
-0.1083396748,
0.771197021,
0.2711415589,
0.7307484746,
0.0520696528,
0.5189692974,
0.6980308294,
-0.1294735521,
0.8522570729,
-0.1833987087,
0.3987891078,
1.1155465841,
-0.430342406,
1.1027452946,
0.9771821499,
-0.5067189932,
0.3036916852,
1.0092973709,
-0.2302886993,
0.5601428151,
0.4555321336,
-0.2084013224,
0.0825111866,
-0.2576873004,
-0.3694006801,
0.1933134645,
0.4510554969,
-0.5022617579,
-0.2675895989,
-0.4066718817,
0.3728456497,
-0.2324127406,
-0.0178152137,
0.7272553444,
0.1868304908,
-0.3463459611,
-0.0496190377,
0.1051597148,
0.4298060834,
-0.3727562726,
-0.2790120542,
-0.2148367316,
-0.2548924088,
-0.5394900441,
-0.2750292122,
0.3320066333,
0.0780915618,
-0.2970882356,
0.6374333501,
0.7736613154,
-0.5433812737,
-0.3673652709,
0.5786879659,
0.7434853911,
0.3782321215,
0.0547812134,
-0.3657567203,
0.1120586172,
-0.2701365352,
-0.3723760545,
0.4266761541,
0.0628906488,
-0.136977613,
0.3742542267,
0.8645586371,
0.0247920174,
-0.0507512167,
-0.1171249598,
1.102640748,
-0.4580798745,
-0.1433999985,
-0.9591733217,
0.5758290887,
-0.4324175417,
-0.164835006,
0.3690232933,
0.96727705,
0.6289867759,
-0.0719566047,
0.7202640772,
-0.3309758604,
-0.0975152552,
-0.3979434371,
0.3968174458,
-0.3468908966,
0.2667264342,
-0.5271134377,
-1.2140307426,
-0.5151887536,
0.535795331,
0.0888432041,
0.235281691,
1.0151185989,
0.6239870787,
-0.1482156068,
-0.0017393463,
-0.024138201,
0.2824832797,
0.6363607049,
0.8664390445,
0.4705625474,
-0.7247664928,
0.2098101676,
0.1507962048,
-0.3675403595,
-0.0386013389,
-1.0527091026,
-0.8039924502,
-0.4009233117,
-0.5428721309,
-0.279638201,
0.4549453259,
1.3041992188,
0.7196389437,
-0.7698988914,
-0.0401233286,
-0.3240444064,
-0.5913238525,
-0.2612476051,
-0.2338947058,
0.6112496853,
-0.3491786122,
-0.8840822577,
0.1997257471,
0.6270109415,
-0.1112162471,
0.3520582616,
-0.3511569202,
-0.3048460782,
0.0355474167,
0.8472465277,
0.6148498654,
-0.6306326389,
-0.1498975158,
0.0048123365,
0.2102831155,
-0.0684284195,
0.5580183268,
-0.6227750182,
0.5419267416,
0.4364669621,
0.6799380183,
0.7185641527,
-0.1632032096,
0.7778850794,
-0.6379157901,
-0.4569733739,
-0.2099191695,
0.3131303191,
0.1256921887,
-0.4577540159,
0.8802650571,
0.3334686458,
-0.3035402596,
-0.5843678117,
0.2780122161,
-1.2772529125,
-0.1317360699,
1.0769585371,
-0.2322439551,
-0.048785314,
-0.2281467766,
-0.3033470213,
0.7016466856,
-0.5002724528,
0.5994173288,
0.613422513,
-0.5381298065,
-0.2535531521,
-0.4492427707,
0.3850595355,
0.4647522569,
-1.1003721952,
-0.0498604961,
0.565615356,
0.2798844278,
-0.0543529652,
0.240094319,
-0.4501962066,
0.2272472084,
-0.2691761255,
-0.2336468101,
-0.3700813651,
-0.5417861938,
-0.189834401,
0.162231192,
-0.2945993245,
-0.0423402004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01331v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01331v1 | Creating Custom Event Data Without Dictionaries: A Bag-of-Tricks | 2023-04-03T19:51:00 | 2023-04-03T19:51:00 | Andrew Halterman, Philip A. Schrodt, Andreas Beger, Benjamin E. Bagozzi, Grace I. Scarborough | cs.CL | cs.CL | Event data, or structured records of ``who did what to whom'' that are
automatically extracted from text, is an important source of data for scholars
of international politics. The high cost of developing new event datasets,
especially using automated systems that rely on hand-built dictionaries, means
that most researchers draw on large, pre-existing datasets such as ICEWS rather
than developing tailor-made event datasets optimized for their specific
research question. This paper describes a ``bag of tricks'' for efficient,
custom event data production, drawing on recent advances in natural language
processing (NLP) that allow researchers to rapidly produce customized event
datasets. The paper introduces techniques for training an event category
classifier with active learning, identifying actors and the recipients of
actions in text using large language models and standard machine learning
classifiers and pretrained ``question-answering'' models from NLP, and
resolving mentions of actors to their Wikipedia article to categorize them. We
describe how these techniques produced the new POLECAT global event dataset
that is intended to replace ICEWS, along with examples of how scholars can
quickly produce smaller, custom event datasets. We publish example code and
models to implement our new techniques. | [
-0.5367856622,
-0.323766619,
0.268438518,
-0.2887742221,
-0.2421059757,
0.4988878965,
-0.2448352873,
-0.3717899621,
0.7151272893,
0.5718511939,
-0.4075875878,
-0.512175262,
-0.3499632478,
0.1691844463,
-0.6059048772,
1.3502883911,
0.1534043103,
-0.4618026614,
-0.0123691112,
-0.0934045091,
0.2101612091,
-0.7931173444,
-0.4601266086,
-0.2932994962,
0.4047006667,
0.6447007656,
0.5237024426,
0.5128367543,
0.7210147977,
0.1651535183,
0.1866063625,
0.3948538601,
-0.5871433616,
-0.2238935977,
-0.3068546355,
-0.2677557766,
-0.2057747692,
0.3809704781,
0.4428568482,
0.4715333283,
-0.2549212277,
0.3265763521,
-0.0544945709,
0.4036564827,
-0.7192419767,
0.0137112448,
-1.1502420902,
0.2331243008,
-0.554133594,
-0.5934379101,
-0.3413721323,
-0.1831170619,
-0.1553851515,
-0.630443573,
0.6534058452,
0.1776102781,
0.7087273002,
-0.0862245038,
-0.3796084821,
-0.4658602178,
-0.7816389203,
0.7383803725,
-0.46807459,
-0.1439602375,
0.5581313968,
0.2363529056,
-0.4970670938,
-1.000513196,
-0.7157259583,
0.0700696409,
-0.145998314,
0.0220527425,
-0.0711284727,
-0.1921712756,
0.1885612458,
0.0659878403,
-0.468716532,
-0.1667315066,
-0.3959527016,
0.3748027086,
1.0897932053,
0.2218050659,
0.1902946681,
-0.4728009999,
-0.0134046823,
0.0139220236,
-0.6756689548,
-0.1327184439,
0.6866477132,
0.3549543619,
0.0495581441,
0.6233654022,
-0.3460211158,
0.3953894377,
0.2988365889,
-0.040251635,
-0.0260127373,
-0.4444912076,
-0.0496546589,
0.1160699353,
0.9455707669,
0.1291579455,
0.4151011109,
-0.4432238638,
-0.0497193858,
-0.3152220547,
0.075127475,
-0.5686579347,
-0.6526532769,
0.1125481203,
-0.3529061675,
-0.5192400813,
0.1795074046,
-0.6222857237,
-0.4470475614,
-0.4173232317,
0.2472328395,
-0.0260270145,
-0.2716458142,
-0.0265453812,
-0.5301722884,
0.1398445666,
0.3213642538,
-0.840066731,
0.5453386903,
0.6650862694,
0.5891064405,
-0.2981685996,
-0.0239812564,
-1.0410130024,
0.2116153985,
-0.7115830779,
0.8905921578,
-0.7583681941,
-0.1236490235,
-0.1342561543,
-0.1367027462,
0.1998087168,
-0.3500111103,
0.3315080404,
-0.5967468619,
0.0894496366,
-0.401094377,
-0.6476311088,
0.2352717072,
0.1723665148,
-0.4369424582,
0.79047364,
-0.513425827,
-0.8684671521,
0.4666025639,
-0.6531041861,
-0.5762535334,
0.3519315124,
-0.4985048473,
-0.0568296425,
0.1090212539,
0.2206866145,
0.6060603857,
-0.0683185831,
0.6276955605,
-0.2421618551,
-0.1159036979,
0.4249511063,
0.1854583025,
0.7869976759,
0.0809682161,
-0.228916198,
-0.2818708122,
-1.1290242672,
-0.1165750697,
0.0648689419,
-0.3608129919,
-0.4394336641,
0.605843246,
0.2075061351,
-0.0768755898,
0.0669221655,
-0.4799275696,
0.546241641,
-0.1775983572,
0.169176206,
0.3637853563,
0.2365465164,
0.5178576708,
-0.0766871944,
0.430867672,
-0.3169850707,
-0.0309964195,
-0.1527343988,
-0.5841403008,
-0.5457440615,
0.0313078314,
0.1363910437,
0.5525966883,
-0.7748548985,
0.4794066548,
-0.0913237482,
-0.5461697578,
-0.1036029086,
0.2312183231,
-0.1442715973,
0.4017012119,
0.1247027293,
-0.0125608752,
-0.955116868,
-0.527795136,
-0.4597201645,
-0.2460209131,
-0.1505125612,
-0.0568368956,
0.7457666397,
0.2215562016,
1.224272728,
-0.6549779773,
-0.3682706952,
-0.4124478698,
0.45859465,
-0.0642938688,
0.5533545017,
0.4477124214,
-0.7291730046,
-0.4261624515,
0.2063787729,
-0.4504307508,
-0.0351523086,
-0.2179971337,
-0.1969358027,
0.1842437834,
0.6220349073,
-0.2894918621,
0.4549869001,
0.351303339,
-0.4156162143,
0.3634560406,
0.1354619265,
0.1797685176,
-1.0360443592,
0.2610099316,
-0.1231193542,
-0.3920041919,
-0.7480812073,
-0.1817629933,
-0.1256238073,
-0.0728452057,
-0.3781808317,
0.6817780733,
-0.3835954368,
0.1533937603,
-0.3482023478,
0.2611963451,
-0.0687675178,
0.2648410797,
0.3388673663,
0.0111491699,
0.4048582911,
-0.5926997066,
0.4562779963,
0.5103776455,
-0.5064361691,
0.5353675485,
-0.3076735735,
0.2969548702,
-0.334399581,
0.0448314697,
-0.7279004455,
-0.4475916028,
0.3074007034,
-0.3510872424,
0.267100215,
-0.6098113656,
-0.5644898415,
-0.1276192367,
-0.2557237446,
-0.1339636296,
0.6708891988,
-0.5437602997,
0.2445541769,
0.8070269823,
0.0147727057,
-0.5549642444,
-0.8605185151,
0.6212590337,
-0.2967778146,
-0.0203878693,
0.2181694359,
-0.0064451257,
-0.4174248874,
0.1363130212,
0.2314681411,
-0.3282546401,
-0.0643213615,
-0.1915228963,
-0.1428536177,
0.1102947444,
0.3970552087,
-0.0552440211,
0.0278196912,
-0.1169098094,
-0.0742499605,
0.0684723854,
0.2592104673,
-0.1974134594,
-0.4914284647,
0.4966983199,
0.1022130623,
-0.4193119109,
0.6352010965,
0.7255058289,
-0.4509971142,
-0.3871592879,
-0.5471304059,
-0.3236999214,
-0.4758983552,
0.1058476716,
-0.077811271,
-0.4137091637,
0.4605259001,
0.0861536264,
0.474085331,
0.2220889777,
0.1678863317,
-0.1117415428,
0.8814294934,
0.5026803613,
-0.0076965974,
0.5371131897,
-0.1409132481,
0.3048942983,
-0.4325755239,
-0.1236212254,
-0.810115993,
-0.5048238039,
-0.6101549864,
-0.4970523119,
0.1328177005,
-0.1462550312,
-0.1406461596,
0.1343373507,
-0.4836882353,
0.6858416796,
0.573025465,
-0.4983966649,
0.4350723028,
0.1954097897,
0.6903815269,
-0.0219493471,
-0.8812499642,
-0.7034438848,
1.1387983561,
-0.387583524,
1.1069910526,
-0.3309893608,
0.9407626987,
0.3039379716,
0.2832063138,
-0.5697939396,
0.5913009048,
-0.180860728,
-0.5990326405,
-0.2237008363,
-0.3094050884,
-1.102109313,
0.0988269448,
-0.3789477348,
-0.722584188,
0.5643011332,
0.2519898117,
-0.0396887548,
0.5147320032,
-0.374194026,
0.6763763428,
-0.0163798835,
0.0351794846,
-0.1158109084,
-0.4348206222,
0.2955825031,
-0.119665511,
0.1815776676,
-0.3822538853,
-0.258867085,
1.1732983589,
-0.2836403251,
1.0238463879,
-0.0923613086,
0.3744754195,
0.587195456,
0.0471968725,
0.8195311427,
0.1988531649,
-0.1891224384,
0.0132486001,
0.1780067831,
-0.164295122,
-0.38357988,
0.6036422849,
-0.4258602858,
-0.469037354,
-0.2432846874,
-0.2306726873,
0.0767867416,
-0.0873165131,
0.2177845389,
0.6100404859,
-0.4381134212,
0.3477803171,
0.4781042635,
0.0021982272,
0.7140340805,
0.6970837712,
0.0596877337,
-0.3997163773,
0.8110753894,
0.5848681927,
-0.3137238026,
0.5849715471,
0.2809702456,
0.1379894316,
-0.4782357812,
-0.445774883,
0.0480679646,
-0.5626375675,
-0.4504730105,
-0.848541081,
-0.0052528083,
-0.383867085,
-0.4143041372,
-0.4179312885,
-0.6592825055,
-0.4436378479,
-0.2140326053,
0.527515769,
0.8182598948,
-0.2124004066,
0.2799508572,
-0.5805316567,
0.4230238795,
0.13468346,
0.0416547358,
-0.1736736149,
-0.0221464541,
-0.3341265023,
-0.2242052704,
-0.4189045429,
-1.0514544249,
0.5901277065,
0.7656162977,
0.5119036436,
0.5418115258,
0.6770000458,
0.7883725762,
-0.622190237,
0.8589775562,
-0.0690177456,
-1.0202151537,
0.9947808385,
-0.2447075099,
0.041947782,
0.3939983547,
0.557911098,
-0.6051377654,
-0.7333788276,
-0.9593530297,
-0.6021440029,
0.9667602181,
0.3042691052,
0.199683398,
-0.2033759207,
0.5485969186,
0.2989017665,
0.5644215941,
-0.7581422329,
-0.1525842398,
0.1705668569,
-0.3153756261,
-0.3176433146,
0.0685466304,
-0.3645979464,
-0.3261854947,
0.5743637681,
-0.4661562145,
-0.381470412,
0.2832706869,
0.0887171775,
-0.27236256,
0.0700308755,
0.0624773614,
0.8287730217,
0.0610157549,
0.2909929156,
0.2498704344,
-0.3066111803,
-0.1169798896,
-0.0399518609,
-0.1872576922,
0.2901602983,
0.494882673,
0.4091493487,
-0.0184135921,
-0.8809925318,
0.472173214,
-0.1512843221,
-0.1961040795,
-0.5352363586,
0.1615405977,
0.0006508897,
0.0318922251,
0.689674437,
-0.0826545358,
0.3030655086,
-0.6689465642,
0.2211084813,
0.5317073464,
0.0718412921,
-0.6213949323,
0.5374485254,
0.2810052633,
-0.3635695279,
0.4784602225,
-0.4463414252,
-0.0757737532,
0.5656999946,
0.2233724892,
0.5656602979,
-0.3442517817,
0.4778017998,
0.470948875,
0.6374871135,
0.078630574,
0.3322602808,
-0.2260698974,
-0.6343889236,
-0.410957545,
-0.5980061293,
-0.4833557308,
0.4455678761,
-0.6527698636,
0.5347005129,
-0.2253475189,
-0.0459248759,
-0.0727277771,
0.3398362398,
-0.8218564391,
-0.0216317978,
0.0134124495,
0.7422319651,
-0.9801496267,
0.5689995885,
0.7530076504,
0.0527318195,
-0.2887974381,
-0.1370723546,
-0.1181984916,
-0.1812046617,
0.4372946024,
-0.2402847111,
0.4187107086,
-0.2150078863,
-0.7557905316,
-1.1731749773,
0.3474597931,
0.3301026225,
-0.7085407972,
0.0202206336,
0.2422941178,
0.520206511,
-0.3191021681,
-0.2580049336,
0.4827551246,
0.5069898963,
-0.0692748353,
-0.6347267628,
-0.1752021313,
-0.0957385451,
-0.3788101971,
0.3558702171,
-0.3576925695,
0.3630985022,
-0.0493526459,
-0.1910592467,
-0.3750211,
0.6807794571,
-0.2608732283,
0.4830542803,
0.2677996159,
0.2343415618,
1.065128088,
-0.0459986366,
0.827075839,
-0.0407605954,
0.1369449645,
1.1166710854,
-0.3938772082,
0.8112806082,
0.4325145185,
0.0352283195,
0.2466591001,
0.5480197072,
-0.1102845892,
0.5096532702,
0.2012361884,
-0.1368065774,
-0.4567628801,
0.3479734659,
0.0787535757,
0.6039000154,
0.413874507,
0.0277362783,
-0.1976373792,
0.4099073708,
0.0583952889,
-0.0039090812,
-0.2247821093,
1.0670704842,
0.0714635104,
-0.7400177717,
0.1845014244,
-0.0639326572,
0.4605464935,
-0.6338793039,
0.0221329704,
-0.1756296158,
0.0250193384,
-0.3903771341,
-0.7199060321,
0.6170677543,
0.3726566434,
0.0283880606,
-0.1095442623,
0.69829458,
-0.4970959425,
-0.6373957992,
-0.1074735224,
0.4627733529,
0.4574645758,
0.1250479817,
-0.33965078,
-0.0038072411,
-0.2547055781,
-0.6854955554,
0.2295005918,
0.556450665,
-0.2077535689,
0.5711835027,
0.5821900964,
0.294039011,
-0.0187130906,
-0.0740006417,
0.6614835262,
-0.6639459133,
-0.4681527317,
-0.6729859114,
0.2482261956,
-0.35970819,
-0.3298010826,
0.6292309165,
0.73901546,
0.9451665878,
-0.0237430241,
0.9972752333,
-0.2823744118,
0.461150676,
-0.1778245568,
0.6270461679,
-0.6304180622,
-0.0633600503,
-0.0796974525,
-0.2477150559,
-0.2516897619,
0.4420294166,
-0.0806668997,
-0.32831496,
0.4657870233,
0.6246959567,
-0.1704462916,
-0.2045189291,
0.1687264591,
-0.0824769735,
0.6097327471,
0.1359012425,
0.6709457636,
-0.1665300727,
0.8575570583,
-0.3206030726,
-0.2331008315,
-0.4910619259,
-1.0533387661,
-1.163606286,
-1.0908697844,
-0.7990684509,
0.1256964803,
0.2340075374,
0.9811419249,
0.9386336207,
-0.7992603183,
-0.327398479,
0.0185178034,
0.3069715202,
-0.223996684,
-0.2839116752,
0.5076736212,
-0.6822258234,
-1.0554602146,
0.3453578055,
0.0942193195,
-0.0073357392,
0.0260139797,
0.3634194136,
-0.1101540104,
0.3571965098,
0.5376265645,
0.3908388913,
-0.4117679894,
-0.2237583101,
-0.3788434267,
0.1585554183,
-0.027043052,
0.9234945774,
-0.9484387636,
0.2705667913,
0.6730746031,
0.3551600575,
0.5231674314,
-0.1954988837,
0.5001306534,
-0.9901809096,
0.1684318036,
0.4135156572,
0.1530244052,
0.3747673929,
-0.4954455793,
0.5355264544,
0.2593275607,
-0.5716332197,
-1.0053946972,
0.013898625,
-0.9291103482,
-0.2298846841,
1.0873297453,
0.182345435,
-0.3315691948,
-0.2980607748,
-0.2147641182,
0.0705418289,
-0.3182328045,
0.9583901763,
0.5660598874,
-0.4162106812,
0.1385209411,
-0.4290222824,
0.9213645458,
-0.2260391712,
-0.9703899026,
0.1231051683,
0.2466491908,
0.2718394399,
0.0712544769,
0.7211126089,
0.2073651999,
0.0449392982,
-0.0869269818,
0.2923442125,
0.1869533509,
-0.2564364672,
0.1742453724,
0.3877708912,
-0.3749623895,
-0.1099369153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01330v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01330v1 | A Comparison of Document Similarity Algorithms | 2023-04-03T19:50:55 | 2023-04-03T19:50:55 | Nicholas Gahman, Vinayak Elangovan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Document similarity is an important part of Natural Language Processing and
is most commonly used for plagiarism-detection and text summarization. Thus,
finding the overall most effective document similarity algorithm could have a
major positive impact on the field of Natural Language Processing. This report
sets out to examine the numerous document similarity algorithms, and determine
which ones are the most useful. It addresses the most effective document
similarity algorithm by categorizing them into 3 types of document similarity
algorithms: statistical algorithms, neural networks, and corpus/knowledge-based
algorithms. The most effective algorithms in each category are also compared in
our work using a series of benchmark datasets and evaluations that test every
possible area that each algorithm could be used in. | [
-0.396769315,
-0.526804626,
0.6199510098,
0.4036826193,
-0.1030393615,
0.1127790213,
-0.037134178,
-0.5380337834,
-0.0555854887,
0.4883230627,
-0.129162088,
-0.4393530488,
-0.4898037016,
0.4645575583,
-0.9708404541,
0.6924070716,
-0.1755231619,
0.1212785169,
-0.4817872643,
-0.2751609087,
-0.0063129403,
-0.3574120998,
-0.8608093262,
-0.615218997,
0.2794006169,
-0.1178496405,
0.5892577767,
0.6408589482,
1.2015674114,
0.4745296538,
-0.0557591505,
-0.1465237439,
-0.28618294,
0.08799503,
-0.2051721513,
-0.6650582552,
0.0775327012,
0.0645035878,
0.4758259654,
0.5343334675,
0.0701160654,
0.0677762628,
0.1089878604,
0.8153210282,
-0.6173394322,
0.1489770412,
-0.4029102921,
0.1100137085,
-0.3900769651,
-0.5428947806,
-0.0907517746,
-1.0168602467,
0.1115561351,
-0.5096342564,
0.6545431018,
0.0894737244,
0.688018918,
-0.0231888574,
-0.2032175213,
-0.878461957,
-0.5034251809,
0.6468388438,
-0.7942447066,
0.3046942353,
0.2568411827,
0.1938509494,
-0.2248073965,
-0.8429177403,
-0.7957264781,
-0.1259616315,
-0.177203998,
0.0735573024,
-0.0896771327,
0.1769613922,
0.182609722,
0.7382845283,
-0.8488585353,
0.2138766795,
-0.3072608709,
-0.3010518849,
0.217319876,
0.0709811375,
0.527120769,
-0.0796157047,
-0.1929142326,
-0.4242053926,
-0.312997669,
-0.0963848904,
0.69359231,
-0.1391543895,
0.1955528557,
0.2770842016,
-0.4733895659,
0.9361388087,
-0.4582419693,
-0.3787874579,
0.3323285878,
-0.4841039181,
-0.3507196605,
0.0410922281,
0.6149674654,
0.7448682785,
0.3289862871,
-0.3017296791,
-0.2680593431,
0.1376049817,
0.2547673583,
-0.4550189078,
0.0650467053,
-0.0916447118,
-0.7374817133,
-0.4799748361,
0.2432143688,
-0.6818289161,
-0.6075819731,
-0.6488146782,
0.4202041626,
-0.5433700085,
0.1565003395,
-0.3034804165,
-0.6180106401,
0.5283395052,
0.1197187603,
-0.9080599546,
0.6781857014,
1.3343647718,
1.2877631187,
-0.3264363706,
-0.571354866,
-0.2208999246,
-0.1087912023,
-0.3570797741,
1.1223648787,
-0.3985381424,
-0.0975754336,
0.0978545323,
-0.236353457,
-0.1952348799,
-0.8000437617,
0.8140004873,
-0.5481805801,
0.2059804946,
-0.3480075896,
-0.9531274438,
-0.5363930464,
0.3360591531,
-1.0158094168,
1.0366052389,
0.2250598073,
-0.9332584739,
0.4504137337,
-0.7707674503,
-0.4796800017,
-0.1783592701,
0.1456235647,
-0.4844529629,
0.063809,
-0.1181781441,
0.3964336216,
-0.5801228285,
-0.1166020781,
-0.1222174242,
-0.59754318,
0.2030782402,
-0.2429630011,
0.705894649,
0.4248937964,
-0.1378093809,
0.0807500631,
-0.8423929214,
-0.1677490324,
0.0770761296,
-0.2716537714,
-0.7952622771,
-0.1599044502,
0.0373466276,
-0.1194393188,
0.2967805564,
-0.5095909834,
-0.1827050745,
-0.5702112913,
0.4532525837,
0.4094161093,
0.1454698145,
0.6071391106,
-0.9041388035,
0.2675917745,
-0.4405151904,
0.1111672372,
-0.0305436365,
-0.5927113295,
-0.3014231622,
-0.2088699043,
0.4663211107,
0.6833114028,
-0.2304001153,
0.1083173007,
-0.2246258855,
-0.7966929674,
-0.4407602847,
0.0786851645,
0.3732096851,
0.5684686303,
0.0974342823,
-0.4293093681,
-0.5882773995,
-0.8892742991,
-0.6348772049,
0.0458179936,
-0.0013926522,
-0.353933543,
0.4541486204,
0.1987168938,
0.6617443562,
-0.2486885339,
-0.2649157941,
0.0953887403,
0.4770191014,
0.3429571092,
0.2212158144,
0.8382635117,
-0.976823926,
-0.7926750183,
-0.001166665,
-0.9022236466,
-0.1969368309,
0.0047052409,
0.3010226488,
0.4260009229,
0.6284783483,
-0.2265186608,
0.4131140113,
0.3153014779,
-0.089510262,
0.2272562385,
-0.4662778676,
0.6880576015,
-0.684006691,
0.0700843111,
-0.0872412622,
-0.1390082091,
-0.6991863847,
0.3244954646,
0.1118558273,
-0.0432480127,
-0.2584962845,
0.4068804383,
-0.4348804355,
-0.4963581264,
-0.328227967,
0.2850019932,
-0.0245313514,
0.211605981,
-0.1871043295,
0.8697636724,
0.4274032414,
-0.4310053289,
0.6244633198,
0.0722507462,
-0.7295478582,
0.8022950292,
-0.1957504004,
0.2111758888,
-0.2291791439,
-0.054929886,
-0.9919965863,
0.0775329918,
-0.0675283447,
-0.2249071598,
0.0959282741,
0.1982964426,
-0.7117280364,
-0.2746685445,
-0.9874650836,
-0.0043166219,
0.3327092826,
-0.3584597111,
0.5973441005,
0.1674993187,
-0.4222942889,
-0.6207942367,
-0.5267270803,
0.1002406925,
-0.2556279004,
-0.4086235166,
0.472884059,
0.0685259029,
-0.4186047316,
0.1703961939,
-0.0441752076,
-0.285954684,
0.1860851347,
0.278324604,
0.0362228565,
-0.1583991051,
-0.0964098498,
-0.2620774209,
-0.0735568851,
-0.1728352606,
-0.0447186902,
0.56838274,
-0.1699152142,
-0.2414072007,
-0.2457494438,
0.4794855714,
0.6353489757,
-0.002384681,
0.6278361082,
0.4954995513,
-0.4465695024,
0.1794683933,
-0.7427966595,
0.1912852526,
-0.4106662571,
0.1469075829,
-0.3685647547,
-0.4469943047,
0.5764380097,
-0.0333838202,
0.2163283229,
0.3568519056,
0.3633361459,
-0.1044427529,
0.3733340502,
0.296030134,
-0.393954128,
0.4002221525,
-0.0808306411,
0.2716570497,
-0.5016874671,
-0.1441717595,
-1.1170651913,
-0.2445284575,
-0.5234456062,
-0.2915991247,
-0.1985841393,
-0.1274450719,
0.065342024,
0.6272172332,
-0.5184336901,
0.6274445057,
1.0318648815,
-0.606451571,
0.508507669,
0.1769473255,
-0.0907780528,
0.2229699343,
-0.3417471349,
-0.6398392916,
1.0363525152,
-0.0141562317,
0.2508580089,
-0.000483211,
0.8996519446,
0.6352469325,
0.306456089,
-0.6596722603,
0.6422666311,
-0.382086277,
-0.3312861621,
-0.4554649889,
-0.3230962157,
-1.2066613436,
0.1154027581,
-0.5300269723,
-0.5469432473,
-0.0361242481,
-0.4133551717,
0.0396922231,
0.4746814668,
-0.8806840181,
0.5990783572,
0.144585222,
0.1657557786,
-0.3263570964,
-0.4321433902,
-0.0526699461,
-0.4852226377,
0.2760469317,
0.1892486513,
0.0595474169,
1.3332546949,
-0.3121367991,
0.1923268735,
0.1454199702,
0.0466938317,
0.4357457161,
-0.103126429,
0.2126031965,
-0.5800848603,
-0.5605570078,
0.1881457269,
0.4806868136,
-0.1962383986,
-0.6751310229,
0.8759778142,
-0.7136973143,
-0.2281647772,
-0.4856013656,
-0.3069784939,
0.1491490602,
0.6072112322,
0.3010228574,
0.575312674,
-0.4105839729,
0.1566059887,
0.4292415679,
0.0130734015,
0.6090885401,
0.7200285792,
0.0458986834,
-0.2351506501,
1.1163355112,
0.3143631518,
-0.204827711,
1.0075532198,
0.1135122925,
-0.300259918,
-0.9826778769,
0.1734566092,
0.1123946607,
-0.8851227164,
-0.2006133199,
-0.5570688248,
-0.2157089263,
-0.5200000405,
-0.4585828483,
0.0262101088,
-0.4036629796,
-0.0392147079,
-0.2343697697,
0.2163888067,
0.8123902082,
0.0378745981,
0.2547872066,
-0.6542489529,
0.5813122988,
0.4613054693,
0.420930624,
-0.0694284663,
0.1032292321,
0.0981129035,
-0.41345644,
-0.308483839,
-0.9348459244,
0.1791303903,
0.1669465154,
0.8158899546,
0.4737738669,
-0.1522320956,
0.1365507692,
-0.1939425617,
0.5916038752,
0.0946624205,
-0.7874948382,
0.1824715883,
-0.1046850011,
0.1846173555,
0.908844769,
0.4519946873,
-0.4864052534,
-0.3852987885,
-0.5454514623,
-0.6704098582,
0.4293654859,
0.5707834959,
-0.3820992112,
0.0855073631,
0.3602127731,
0.3032426238,
0.1351146996,
-0.1823141724,
-0.3111171424,
0.0517580248,
-0.5608079433,
-0.0510224439,
0.0347549394,
0.0658860132,
0.319809109,
0.4375016689,
0.0913550407,
0.4939832389,
0.2117433846,
-0.1774888337,
0.068729952,
0.3938939869,
0.5369630456,
0.7691610456,
-0.5066167116,
0.3892644942,
0.3895507455,
-0.7946157455,
0.0533044748,
0.1371312439,
-0.1940932423,
0.0927413329,
0.7599925399,
0.4647919238,
0.1461510807,
-0.5449544191,
0.4178334773,
-0.3480751812,
-0.4496085346,
-0.1771845967,
0.1229682341,
0.1258814931,
-0.079305537,
0.2664590478,
0.3581594825,
0.5669618249,
-0.9300509691,
0.2137634605,
0.3019011915,
-0.1886951774,
0.1298345625,
0.1956232935,
0.3414107859,
-0.9870595932,
0.5356175303,
-0.0055445232,
-0.6628433466,
0.8225929141,
0.2636673152,
0.6080830693,
-0.102646865,
0.1676344275,
0.2382647395,
0.1450842768,
-0.476077348,
0.0272423066,
-0.1761525422,
-0.5378634334,
-0.1365855485,
-0.6022641659,
-0.4558118284,
-0.0427591503,
-0.5823982358,
0.1222235337,
-0.5219201446,
-0.0671917498,
0.4782575071,
0.2341783047,
-0.7679731846,
0.145952031,
0.0660736039,
0.9577261209,
-0.7811539173,
0.5716790557,
0.6137472987,
-0.2151726186,
-0.4572267234,
-0.229750216,
0.21720393,
-0.578399837,
0.2748529613,
0.0945460722,
-0.1586867124,
-0.2109491825,
-0.0929402485,
-0.5196057558,
1.2148954868,
0.1052566692,
-0.5411295891,
-0.0365947559,
0.1757310927,
0.7390467525,
-0.2120635509,
0.5641840696,
0.8932180405,
0.3889275789,
-0.2404486537,
-1.0734893084,
0.0297257528,
-0.2332161218,
-0.0155979628,
0.4937491715,
-0.4524285793,
0.644684732,
0.2684131563,
-0.1958135664,
0.1164269075,
0.2762588561,
0.0331768878,
0.7893362045,
0.6141663194,
0.6025653481,
1.0743582249,
0.0872667357,
0.9996321201,
-0.2823308706,
0.2578911781,
1.0390677452,
-0.5022925735,
0.7157016397,
0.2379127443,
-0.3518660963,
0.3375925422,
0.2929317653,
-0.3193650246,
0.4341510236,
0.111729227,
-0.037512958,
0.3942166865,
0.1358537972,
-0.3154899478,
0.2279828191,
0.0969009846,
-0.3629358113,
-0.4079122245,
-0.1112513542,
-0.2090080976,
0.3816558421,
-0.242234841,
1.1534644365,
-0.1454016566,
-0.8522281051,
0.2149597555,
0.2154227346,
0.6946704984,
-0.664339304,
-0.0772630498,
-0.1633485258,
-0.0695528388,
-0.2311984301,
-1.1036863327,
0.5564718246,
-0.0110901454,
-0.2777741849,
-0.1660158634,
1.1373468637,
0.122160688,
-0.0770007893,
0.3782353401,
0.1564557999,
0.2406957299,
-0.0998582095,
-0.5463734269,
-0.1816500127,
-0.0751233622,
0.0532667562,
0.4758059084,
0.1491821706,
-0.1732811332,
0.6792472601,
0.6059390903,
0.2712207735,
0.2452454865,
0.3091123104,
0.417696327,
-0.7566213608,
-0.6346800327,
-0.6782647371,
-0.4554961324,
-0.4904425144,
-0.1466029435,
0.9006074071,
0.7884761691,
0.6894873381,
0.0065316269,
0.7940172553,
0.0812873244,
0.72937572,
-0.5251708627,
0.6223048568,
0.0315128043,
0.1314570606,
-0.6216698885,
-1.2712671757,
-0.3930730522,
0.5904376507,
-0.2688957155,
-0.2666565776,
1.1650441885,
0.8551362157,
0.0637364462,
0.5589044094,
0.1696714014,
-0.1135339513,
0.2228017747,
0.2980305552,
0.7008531094,
-0.4424177706,
0.6326790452,
-0.371948868,
-0.355258882,
-0.1788846552,
-0.8666812181,
-0.7347364426,
-0.891163826,
-0.3458097279,
0.020796556,
0.1952538937,
0.5514225364,
0.3492597938,
-0.7991335988,
-0.0096709114,
-0.227662459,
0.5112048388,
-0.6208500266,
-0.2553769052,
0.4823229015,
-0.0835350081,
-0.7127144933,
0.2073026747,
0.4337810576,
0.0240048971,
0.1411847025,
0.1767308861,
-0.2863621414,
0.197142601,
0.5301679969,
0.2482167333,
-0.28791067,
-0.2069156617,
-0.1687976867,
-0.3317419589,
-0.088604264,
1.123331666,
-0.5160750151,
0.4060169756,
1.1300994158,
0.588675499,
0.4244241118,
0.1145750284,
0.4338589311,
-0.186997503,
0.0069958461,
0.0009484933,
0.338077873,
0.550299108,
-0.1764810234,
0.7990875244,
0.1557310075,
-0.6301586628,
-0.5521394014,
-0.0911336765,
-1.0892517567,
-0.4682387412,
0.8414496183,
-0.1774101555,
-0.4074667394,
-0.4974657297,
-0.3619695306,
0.3151105344,
-0.3087765276,
0.756106019,
0.9384809732,
-0.0831591487,
0.0155325681,
-0.3722027242,
0.5234187841,
0.0893448442,
-0.6297140121,
-0.5314941406,
-0.0432352796,
0.546730876,
0.509675622,
0.6320822835,
-0.1381211728,
0.0711966529,
0.0745865777,
-0.1577948034,
0.035173215,
0.0587665848,
-0.3800436556,
0.6971882582,
-0.0123296957,
0.0247030016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01328v1 | Grand Challenge On Detecting Cheapfakes | 2023-04-03T19:50:26 | 2023-04-03T19:50:26 | Duc-Tien Dang-Nguyen, Sohail Ahmed Khan, Cise Midoglu, Michael Riegler, Pål Halvorsen, Minh-Son Dao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Cheapfake is a recently coined term that encompasses non-AI ("cheap")
manipulations of multimedia content. Cheapfakes are known to be more prevalent
than deepfakes. Cheapfake media can be created using editing software for
image/video manipulations, or even without using any software, by simply
altering the context of an image/video by sharing the media alongside
misleading claims. This alteration of context is referred to as out-of-context
(OOC) misuse of media. OOC media is much harder to detect than fake media,
since the images and videos are not tampered. In this challenge, we focus on
detecting OOC images, and more specifically the misuse of real photographs with
conflicting image captions in news items. The aim of this challenge is to
develop and benchmark models that can be used to detect whether given samples
(news image and associated captions) are OOC, based on the recently compiled
COSMOS dataset. | [
-0.5283079743,
-0.7877508402,
0.4556604922,
-0.4431934953,
-0.1989966333,
-0.0732971579,
0.2022092193,
-0.6224922538,
0.0312206764,
0.5554105639,
-0.8114866614,
-0.0631973073,
-0.689227283,
0.0496685915,
-0.3730741441,
0.843296051,
-0.1208972186,
0.0118984692,
-0.3930644989,
-0.4586846232,
-0.4523969591,
0.0443669744,
-0.6585567594,
0.1625371724,
0.1022126749,
0.5939310789,
1.1168462038,
0.5046966672,
0.8903544545,
0.3579543829,
0.0479913503,
0.3792644143,
-0.4631088078,
-0.4832703173,
-0.3314770758,
-0.1846446395,
0.0411263518,
0.515389204,
0.1753858477,
0.3643632531,
0.2683050036,
0.2608659565,
-0.2913005054,
0.6725414991,
-0.9694433808,
0.1190748736,
-0.9223220944,
0.033262454,
-0.1504773796,
-0.3203805983,
-0.2271133661,
-0.1211754233,
-0.3697239161,
-0.9695329666,
0.4170101881,
0.1861376911,
1.3662216663,
0.6642142534,
-0.3931954205,
-0.7394621372,
-0.4218566418,
0.5271624327,
-0.4969322979,
0.3434665203,
0.5574652553,
0.4507656395,
-0.5179195404,
-0.5714280605,
-0.8873381019,
-0.28419137,
-0.355854094,
0.0116467085,
-0.4002533555,
-0.193749547,
0.350212425,
0.4885658622,
-0.3757095039,
-0.0840230137,
-0.1694617867,
-0.2822839618,
0.6669248939,
0.133862555,
0.4516775012,
-0.4684066474,
-0.5797325373,
0.1138158962,
-0.6032419801,
0.1031863615,
0.6579803824,
-0.0094377054,
-0.3906449676,
0.6920934319,
-0.411159128,
0.3608557582,
0.2739382982,
-0.4814057052,
0.1691404283,
-0.3695531189,
-0.3659018576,
-0.1987647712,
0.4820297956,
0.603212595,
-0.0757099018,
-0.1222651377,
-0.2864276767,
-0.0121119767,
-0.0430799089,
-0.4777496159,
-0.1489308327,
-0.0925958976,
-0.4810088575,
-0.4849838018,
0.1545524448,
-0.8215823174,
-0.5866442919,
-0.2853195369,
0.8594677448,
-0.056444712,
0.0410380587,
0.0224464443,
-0.0760444179,
0.1416784227,
0.3746458292,
-0.2602960765,
0.1342568994,
0.3339995742,
1.020855546,
0.1634234041,
-0.1771980524,
-0.9109979272,
-0.045880612,
-0.3841440678,
0.8837271333,
-0.3317864537,
-0.3027826548,
-0.083391957,
0.2254848182,
0.2238089591,
-0.5895257592,
0.6164857149,
-0.7315794826,
0.3406668901,
-0.6229747534,
-0.5220355392,
0.0346429944,
0.3134397864,
-1.1691340208,
1.0238740444,
0.3633660972,
-0.9888261557,
0.8408036828,
-0.7181536555,
-0.3518834114,
0.0315306187,
-0.2099317461,
-0.6391119361,
0.1805096865,
0.1811479032,
0.0356245972,
-0.2338470221,
0.3314422667,
-0.3409430385,
-0.4610600173,
0.1880025417,
-0.4722330868,
0.6254341006,
0.2763170004,
-0.6139600277,
-0.2751597464,
-0.6248508096,
-0.6583762169,
0.3735456169,
-0.1906356514,
-0.3314568996,
-0.0201700833,
0.1486993134,
0.3125549257,
-0.167099148,
-0.6405056715,
0.3489645123,
0.057673797,
0.4545588195,
0.4776080549,
0.1672380567,
0.6986328959,
-0.4695754945,
0.1155645177,
0.2823135853,
0.5283102393,
-0.2007820457,
-0.6116111279,
-0.4808847308,
-0.4497973323,
0.0097339256,
0.4310384989,
-1.3909406662,
0.0092220567,
-0.1333071887,
-0.3044777215,
-0.4497888684,
0.2203319818,
0.2545150816,
0.8319150805,
0.5093094707,
-0.2753401101,
-0.1501480043,
-0.9572932124,
-0.4348327219,
0.0636113584,
0.314358443,
0.3639926612,
0.9475716949,
-0.2355038226,
1.2319999933,
-0.4970602989,
-0.7897279263,
0.3002363145,
0.5136116743,
0.0403305739,
0.5882421136,
0.6336134076,
-1.3199837208,
-0.257781893,
-0.1046951488,
-0.7016658783,
-0.0480555296,
-0.3514604867,
0.2319300771,
0.6885308027,
1.042935133,
-0.7269225717,
0.7033094168,
0.3890049458,
-0.1435119957,
0.544138968,
-0.0654485002,
0.708807826,
-0.4963230789,
0.2768790126,
-0.205448091,
-0.0681495145,
-0.4152352214,
0.2262292504,
0.0652084276,
-0.3312298656,
-1.0297045708,
0.4911359847,
-0.3838311434,
-0.2120472342,
-0.2886744738,
0.0719979778,
0.0271663256,
0.2622433603,
-0.0055384426,
0.904217422,
0.2787131667,
-0.1414921582,
0.3185039163,
0.0686798394,
-0.7903460264,
0.8080182076,
-0.29100281,
0.0565415621,
-0.6122848392,
0.4271191955,
-1.3383564949,
-0.6995643377,
0.4488903284,
-0.4825673997,
-0.0610811338,
-0.580945015,
-0.7901332974,
-0.1807986647,
-0.15056701,
0.5001237988,
0.1777410805,
-0.8158003688,
0.5287846327,
0.242539987,
0.1687640101,
-0.7452111244,
-0.7930887341,
0.2323090583,
-0.2624307573,
-0.6671596766,
0.3717758656,
-0.1393004209,
-0.3241451979,
0.6049238443,
-0.2677006721,
-0.3216027021,
0.0926431268,
0.2731870711,
0.2749365568,
-0.1490490288,
0.0321055502,
-0.0079593509,
-0.0683597773,
-0.0683990642,
0.0897043124,
0.2434463203,
-0.0994950011,
-0.3660531938,
-0.647298038,
0.502833724,
0.7294846773,
0.1515851468,
0.4170493186,
0.384794116,
-0.5961675644,
-0.0326403007,
-0.7152268887,
-0.1825343519,
-0.5566043854,
0.0174544659,
-0.1544571519,
-0.5957562327,
0.6066842079,
-0.0068750796,
-0.2069437504,
0.2921307087,
0.1098190695,
-0.0772336125,
0.7122886777,
0.1547243744,
-0.2926793993,
0.1626517922,
-0.3175853491,
-0.0048033237,
-0.0063036294,
-0.1929632127,
-0.4101410508,
-0.4038426876,
-0.4516433179,
-0.646792233,
0.3071806729,
0.0808661282,
-0.139845565,
0.4212858677,
-0.0781311765,
1.0890840292,
0.5627453923,
0.0762287155,
0.6443295479,
-0.1110634953,
0.3432895839,
0.0742821097,
-0.5048935413,
-0.2844101787,
0.6444272995,
0.0574506484,
0.6140150428,
0.1800134331,
0.4979689717,
0.7407357097,
0.5290845633,
-0.7936571836,
0.462649703,
-0.2300881445,
-1.0235669613,
-0.1093208939,
-0.5128973126,
-0.7313406467,
-0.1900126487,
-0.3809843957,
-0.4201722741,
0.3635313511,
0.2058375627,
-0.3587192893,
0.5956894159,
-0.3908412755,
0.81695503,
-0.1154928654,
-0.5021494031,
0.0362038277,
-0.5687134862,
0.5703235865,
-0.0302742235,
0.82055372,
-0.1264343858,
-0.0568166822,
0.4463772178,
-0.3538905978,
0.7097485065,
-0.3818522394,
0.0260388143,
0.6160000563,
0.2084068209,
0.7163552642,
0.3486752212,
0.5382717848,
0.0304878801,
-0.2124752104,
-0.5312033296,
-0.4588168859,
0.751201272,
-0.7596990466,
-0.3930478394,
-0.3359818161,
-0.4943082631,
-0.2254949957,
0.1141272634,
0.8833767176,
0.2535218,
-0.1304660738,
0.0759852752,
0.4852106869,
-0.2570631504,
0.7610327601,
0.4996164441,
0.0723496526,
-0.5294604301,
0.8319262862,
0.224069342,
0.0981499851,
0.119444117,
0.2427217364,
-0.1765682548,
-0.3121611476,
-0.7399685383,
0.0071153613,
-0.8273620605,
-0.3940365314,
-0.2204512805,
0.2210422307,
-0.3657062948,
-0.4767667949,
-0.5797490478,
-0.1011136845,
-0.3533204794,
0.2029301971,
0.066247426,
0.4971257448,
-0.3538364172,
0.5352489352,
-0.7385861874,
0.6626643538,
0.4554700851,
0.2843176723,
-0.2636343539,
-0.5754352808,
-0.1343533546,
-0.1268535256,
-0.3462901413,
-0.7491093874,
0.3974443376,
0.0350728184,
0.3930351138,
0.6710807085,
0.2743951082,
0.7419757247,
-0.2123906761,
0.8230862617,
0.2812127769,
-1.3554919958,
0.4266332686,
-0.5765566826,
-0.1567220837,
0.9121671915,
0.7621071935,
-0.2607871592,
-0.0308784042,
-0.740881145,
-0.6518551707,
0.5697676539,
0.310352236,
0.1022030339,
-0.0508697666,
0.2893701196,
0.1856792867,
0.333784461,
-0.8978395462,
0.1059010997,
-0.0810700282,
0.2033266276,
0.0728444159,
0.2614582777,
-0.2764287293,
-0.0272619668,
0.4244755208,
-0.2712884843,
0.1981475055,
0.3876905441,
-0.3431612551,
-0.5791753531,
-0.0959986001,
0.6155459881,
0.0294265319,
-0.1692349017,
0.2030002326,
0.0550218299,
-0.28634426,
0.1081643924,
-0.1650707275,
-0.25245592,
0.1305292696,
0.4230457544,
0.5638022423,
0.5014501214,
-0.8331667185,
0.9475700855,
0.1057363898,
-0.4895102084,
-0.3992199302,
-0.1110446304,
-0.2337592244,
0.2269361168,
0.5734980702,
0.4796664417,
0.4408637583,
-0.8425984383,
0.3287920356,
0.4531679153,
-0.3785651326,
-0.0741955712,
0.7359811068,
0.1410670131,
-0.0405304842,
0.5796172619,
-0.499548912,
-0.2268923372,
0.7599820495,
0.0322179832,
0.531896174,
0.2163706571,
0.3415468335,
0.1176839843,
0.5477933884,
-0.1830225438,
0.1739855111,
0.119301267,
-0.7952622771,
-0.4607685208,
-0.1242655292,
-0.5423698425,
0.7049841285,
-0.7136478424,
0.6343830228,
-0.3380078375,
-0.0814258009,
0.0195900761,
-0.0778499097,
-0.6699947119,
0.5248244405,
0.2616966963,
0.9844942689,
-1.2085955143,
0.7310526371,
0.5324572325,
-0.5275716782,
-0.3892118037,
0.0739440173,
0.5845556855,
-0.5515486002,
0.8064337373,
0.2199206501,
-0.1247509196,
-0.248345986,
-0.9983816743,
-0.7842488289,
0.8153522611,
0.3581755161,
-0.4110088348,
-0.0188507512,
0.375148803,
0.0290483944,
-0.2020394653,
-0.134368822,
0.4921386242,
0.796389401,
0.3732111156,
-0.6157503128,
-0.150860697,
-0.1274142414,
-0.546972394,
0.3608079255,
-0.6515294313,
1.0896220207,
-0.2978411317,
-0.3904431164,
0.3136987388,
0.391310811,
-0.1443398595,
1.1967139244,
0.8788408637,
0.8128607273,
0.3952636123,
-0.1608139277,
0.7891123295,
0.1306591332,
0.7207483649,
1.1983044147,
-0.2999457121,
0.6987113953,
0.568836987,
0.1295422614,
0.1820121109,
0.3805045187,
-0.2780379653,
0.8421318531,
-0.013911291,
-0.1197820678,
-0.1732567996,
-0.0164187867,
-0.2119496912,
0.7002484798,
0.1091230437,
-0.0632367954,
-0.3347175419,
0.3086253107,
0.3065656126,
0.1257122606,
-0.4396232963,
0.7374184728,
-0.3323704898,
-0.6910007,
0.3606042266,
0.0530362017,
0.7394934297,
-0.2503384948,
0.1481755674,
-0.5064799786,
0.0387531333,
-0.3904219866,
-0.5582589507,
0.6548187137,
-0.0874011517,
-0.0968868583,
0.2763685584,
0.7350766063,
-0.3116253018,
-0.2006887347,
0.1655785441,
0.2989472449,
-0.155290395,
-0.2562794685,
-0.5762488246,
0.1303155571,
-0.3247939348,
-0.1910635382,
0.4126040041,
0.2002368867,
-0.1643211395,
0.3034609556,
0.8381695747,
-0.2445313036,
-0.0477977879,
-0.4807572961,
0.9228332639,
-0.6237501502,
-0.5230666399,
-0.5388687253,
0.4702702463,
-0.2400563806,
-0.4600691497,
0.6034044027,
0.5929396152,
1.1015185118,
-0.4826377332,
0.5772153139,
-0.3103432059,
-0.0725922808,
-0.6881124973,
0.7220242023,
-1.0460435152,
-0.0952379331,
-0.6115691662,
-0.42316401,
-0.2801057398,
0.314591825,
-0.219527036,
-0.3689616621,
0.6884245872,
1.1271260977,
-0.3456571996,
0.4279146492,
0.3679566979,
-0.1608301252,
0.0087388316,
0.4471455514,
1.0743492842,
-0.5584790111,
0.7023838758,
-0.4440819323,
-0.2385080308,
-0.3792263269,
-1.3432998657,
-0.742305398,
-0.5268495083,
-0.6843762398,
-0.3138821423,
0.0068599903,
0.7420479059,
0.8341528773,
-0.903896153,
0.1971930861,
-0.2524753213,
0.0069225272,
-0.2615219057,
-0.2267365456,
0.2949179411,
-0.1663526148,
-0.8122950196,
0.5164411664,
0.1884816885,
0.0683610588,
0.0742290318,
0.08761473,
-0.114456363,
0.435100764,
0.5099722743,
0.3189864457,
-0.4915042222,
-0.5304569006,
-0.0760997534,
-0.0808843076,
0.0359448344,
1.0295034647,
-0.5802271962,
0.1235200837,
0.6097354889,
0.6065101624,
0.1840997189,
-0.0668597445,
-0.4546835423,
-0.8621113896,
0.3812836707,
-0.0914117172,
0.3921430409,
0.2019786686,
-0.445161581,
0.5228065252,
0.9290094972,
-0.4847679436,
-1.0217921734,
0.2137391716,
-1.0992696285,
-0.7104231119,
0.7985559106,
-0.0834145918,
-0.0788780972,
-0.2583599091,
-0.2376280725,
-0.0955912173,
-0.3640604019,
1.0282166004,
0.5428948998,
0.023809474,
-0.1433259696,
-0.4630998969,
0.5072263479,
0.1150439754,
-0.8308156133,
-0.2229280919,
0.6973223686,
0.3111042976,
0.4515274465,
0.351161629,
-0.220399633,
0.6326788068,
0.2483993173,
-0.2724021673,
-0.4003515244,
-0.3322523534,
-0.0786174089,
0.6380094886,
-0.4685831964,
-0.2754307389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01322v1 | PALI: A Language Identification Benchmark for Perso-Arabic Scripts | 2023-04-03T19:40:14 | 2023-04-03T19:40:14 | Sina Ahmadi, Milind Agarwal, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Perso-Arabic scripts are a family of scripts that are widely adopted and
used by various linguistic communities around the globe. Identifying various
languages using such scripts is crucial to language technologies and
challenging in low-resource setups. As such, this paper sheds light on the
challenges of detecting languages using Perso-Arabic scripts, especially in
bilingual communities where ``unconventional'' writing is practiced. To address
this, we use a set of supervised techniques to classify sentences into their
languages. Building on these, we also propose a hierarchical model that targets
clusters of languages that are more often confused by the classifiers. Our
experiment results indicate the effectiveness of our solutions. | [
-0.0638573617,
-0.4566068947,
0.440059036,
0.330837816,
-0.0906466767,
0.6693357229,
-0.0019821399,
-0.3150601983,
0.1187829301,
0.3522114456,
-0.3879531622,
-0.9723551869,
-0.5888834,
0.4589012861,
-0.6236848235,
0.742356658,
-0.2581995726,
-0.3059993982,
0.5983109474,
-0.288816452,
-0.0500470772,
-0.4010464251,
-0.5817123652,
0.3555532992,
0.6247851253,
0.4592545629,
0.5358675122,
0.851413846,
0.3498653769,
0.3935771585,
-0.0275938772,
0.242675364,
-0.2564212084,
0.0750359297,
0.0591670424,
-0.4749536216,
-0.1984509826,
-0.2592482269,
0.9791601896,
0.8275679946,
-0.2638401389,
0.3945184648,
-0.4849996865,
0.132321462,
-1.0347032547,
-0.0336222425,
-0.6087008119,
0.2430976182,
-0.9805224538,
0.0284438264,
-0.2409050614,
-0.5861898065,
-0.0833212361,
-0.344497323,
0.2526766062,
0.1721965969,
0.7895380259,
0.0476903878,
-0.3798708022,
-0.2852329612,
-0.6476211548,
0.7544813156,
-0.6659684777,
0.1160309911,
0.4701066017,
0.4074288309,
-0.1242920384,
-0.3175013959,
-0.8384671807,
0.0726135969,
-0.0689349696,
-0.1829514056,
-0.3537510633,
-0.2616369128,
0.2435147017,
0.4937375188,
-0.6107184291,
0.3741292953,
-0.061785955,
-0.5630042553,
0.3968260884,
0.3447576463,
0.6737036705,
-0.0288467593,
-0.1660662293,
0.0732434765,
-1.2055149078,
-0.0177073572,
0.7795820236,
0.3516228795,
-0.0728124753,
0.4858688116,
-0.3646057546,
0.6394389868,
-0.3715980053,
-0.435419172,
0.3828794062,
-0.2647010088,
-0.095651485,
0.3630705774,
0.7274719477,
-0.0500440672,
0.2607931197,
-0.0284112524,
-0.4109759331,
0.1391251236,
-0.2046057433,
-0.3297083378,
-0.0265942831,
-0.5032616854,
-0.3789493442,
-0.3223099709,
-0.0753259882,
-0.7572042346,
-0.6069296598,
0.3747125566,
-0.0028137497,
-0.2228161842,
-0.5494645834,
-0.2446114123,
-0.0623576753,
0.3679635823,
0.1636717767,
-0.9246361256,
0.5819783211,
0.5120427608,
0.7968004346,
-0.1097948477,
-0.4387752414,
-0.5439816117,
0.3010821342,
-0.5668265224,
0.8683492541,
-0.9402296543,
-0.5066551566,
0.2128657848,
-0.0844952092,
0.0241682176,
-0.6831190586,
0.2295325547,
-0.5678468943,
-0.0440916456,
-0.3607925773,
-0.1091984659,
0.0885579512,
0.0229509417,
-0.7142769694,
0.9249411821,
0.36564219,
-0.6531038284,
0.3064070642,
-0.2683829963,
-0.3909360468,
0.2100344151,
-0.3103069365,
-0.2801970541,
0.0984730497,
0.0541902035,
0.0100163128,
-0.3949148953,
-0.1211648658,
0.0293060001,
-0.4742151201,
0.383712858,
-0.6130663157,
0.6410412192,
0.3369353414,
-0.1284266263,
0.0547634773,
-0.9892866611,
-0.2572458088,
-0.0623277836,
-0.3655341864,
-0.3833935261,
-0.0732510313,
0.3674284816,
-0.0248452332,
0.3766087294,
-0.8484143019,
0.2047525048,
-0.2685226798,
0.1601217091,
0.7453317642,
-0.1651708633,
0.0711042657,
0.0036656293,
0.9821593761,
0.0277340356,
-0.3143910766,
-0.2389455736,
-0.5105076432,
-0.718983829,
-0.4834089577,
0.4547426403,
0.5688138008,
-0.3773748279,
0.2699647248,
-0.0717349201,
-0.4578665197,
-0.9838243723,
0.4719391763,
0.8146983981,
0.5928521156,
0.1716324538,
-0.4449318647,
-0.6208119988,
-0.9950128794,
-0.3306673467,
-0.3026989996,
0.3005692363,
-0.0329342522,
0.0146093871,
-0.3485368192,
0.7417913079,
-0.3573431671,
0.0458420217,
-0.1030534506,
0.3702807128,
0.0157878902,
0.252695471,
0.1846642196,
-0.6603514552,
-1.0289264917,
0.379213959,
-0.4198321402,
-0.6136488318,
0.2493915111,
0.2570784092,
0.3080054522,
0.7687602639,
-0.1636729091,
0.6926057935,
0.3494792581,
-0.2963391542,
0.5739531517,
0.0086965011,
-0.0898370966,
-0.6155122519,
0.1245991737,
-0.0205979887,
-0.1512664258,
-0.5200570822,
-0.1665837318,
-0.1299301684,
0.1135094389,
-0.4076967537,
0.6130510569,
-0.3328460753,
-0.1281733662,
-0.3029883206,
-0.3798289299,
-0.6159998178,
0.3461950123,
0.2369492948,
1.1015329361,
0.6457756758,
-0.1496239156,
0.2330802679,
-0.0393041484,
-0.7396140695,
0.3251084387,
-0.4310629666,
0.1655518115,
-0.0039130184,
0.1375189573,
-1.4170445204,
-0.2420003265,
0.1116357744,
0.0046696076,
0.1605282277,
-0.1851231158,
-0.8059159517,
0.0352432132,
-0.00433979,
0.7580804825,
0.5355181098,
-0.2629451454,
0.3899621069,
0.4159242213,
-0.2857851088,
-0.8615145683,
-0.3832087517,
0.0416464359,
-0.5663952231,
0.0323374122,
0.1790465564,
0.6145457029,
-0.4022449851,
0.0015557102,
-0.2820672095,
-0.2185986042,
-0.0248670168,
0.3252905309,
0.0525031798,
-0.570292592,
0.118597433,
0.5480193496,
-0.409488529,
-0.3745525777,
-0.0135644469,
0.7211021185,
-0.4608164728,
-0.4511554837,
-0.8294939995,
0.5791609287,
0.7932772636,
-0.2441381961,
0.6076045036,
0.6478793025,
-0.1579618901,
-0.0747162551,
-0.8677635193,
0.4298443794,
-0.493863225,
0.327825129,
-0.7888035178,
-0.5999675393,
0.6697978377,
-0.4502312541,
-0.4597199857,
0.5160095692,
0.5943861008,
0.0001880035,
0.9894044399,
0.7763757706,
-0.452329278,
0.2761496007,
0.1914239079,
0.213746503,
-0.6207493544,
-0.1041798443,
-0.6409422159,
-0.3331498206,
-0.8742723465,
-0.1128217578,
0.2615188062,
-0.0312912539,
-0.2958504856,
0.6335449219,
-0.2500298321,
0.8787155151,
0.630059123,
-0.4189479947,
0.5458201766,
-0.078166239,
-0.2667621076,
0.155646503,
-0.5517813563,
-0.9218286276,
1.0541130304,
0.1630435437,
0.5916359425,
0.383438766,
0.8006898165,
0.2404417545,
0.328233242,
-0.0650683716,
0.6224039197,
-0.2740068436,
-0.3645084798,
-0.2031609714,
-0.1211895198,
-1.2134091854,
0.1121331453,
0.2304307818,
-0.9865071177,
0.2883392572,
-0.4062080383,
-0.549714148,
0.0883269534,
-0.875474751,
0.925236702,
-0.0477708094,
0.0565920919,
-0.2470527589,
-0.7818018794,
0.0071441964,
-0.1971907169,
0.1818080544,
-0.3738566637,
-0.4198646247,
0.6321629882,
-0.518828094,
1.0466085672,
0.107347697,
-0.0877109766,
0.3413031697,
0.2646725774,
-0.0753651857,
-0.1201436222,
-0.1694646031,
0.1083982214,
0.2500878274,
-0.634442091,
-0.3005923629,
0.8551956415,
-0.9796162248,
-0.486063987,
-0.5292003155,
-0.5215790272,
-0.2214158475,
0.3571075797,
0.1661028564,
0.229992792,
-0.1892566383,
-0.2191596627,
0.4177043736,
-0.324059248,
0.569637835,
0.7519647479,
-0.2969330847,
-0.1274856627,
1.0891916752,
-0.0005631463,
0.1254093349,
0.4278177023,
0.2790457606,
-0.2360828519,
-0.5655261874,
-0.5680865049,
0.2305891663,
-0.5538849831,
0.0020209528,
-0.1776922047,
-0.1347470433,
-0.3807345331,
-0.0936466455,
-0.0350647643,
-0.3843480945,
-0.0851435289,
-0.0260254107,
0.0072081531,
0.8791642189,
0.1779069901,
0.5762205124,
-0.6126549244,
0.145341292,
0.349503547,
0.1164431423,
-0.0015499471,
-0.193725273,
0.3241582811,
-0.4096487463,
0.0258815177,
-1.0109442472,
0.350482285,
0.1005430371,
0.540795505,
0.654165864,
-0.2896346748,
0.642362237,
-0.6006332636,
0.3645526767,
0.0477856211,
-1.0967571735,
0.5864533782,
-0.3450784087,
0.2717175186,
0.7386038303,
0.7185362577,
-0.7240554094,
-0.4426082373,
-0.4848366678,
-0.6551620364,
0.6326669455,
0.0578608774,
0.1665523648,
-0.1410261393,
0.1498764753,
0.5349698663,
0.4587236941,
-0.5565761328,
-0.0247890949,
0.1850211918,
-0.4177811146,
0.0709021017,
-0.1881820112,
0.0301330835,
-0.1944782734,
0.0797657594,
0.1558361799,
-0.086882025,
-0.2695680857,
-0.2050793469,
-0.2213086635,
0.1175876036,
0.3622542918,
0.5432428718,
0.0791393667,
0.4579958618,
0.2004610449,
-0.4507611692,
0.2178246081,
-0.197148487,
-0.1478648186,
0.0364987738,
0.5984470844,
0.6059735417,
0.0573995039,
-1.0889667273,
0.3159851432,
0.3459010124,
0.5272538662,
-0.2230768949,
0.210613206,
-0.1091299057,
0.0542993881,
0.3788203299,
0.0045654373,
0.2344913483,
-0.9997437,
-0.2163551152,
0.3704312444,
-0.2069474608,
-0.3792851567,
-0.0077529605,
0.1292195767,
-0.8443691134,
0.8095859885,
-0.3546002507,
-0.766351223,
0.669457376,
0.6473354697,
0.8407466412,
-0.5717195868,
0.2334914356,
0.0291283,
0.1312031299,
0.1552920789,
0.2487762868,
-0.5030945539,
-0.7441417575,
-0.2182330042,
-0.8409987688,
-0.4521118999,
-0.0834418982,
-0.3766520023,
0.3139724135,
-0.5210667849,
0.1670651138,
0.2799479365,
-0.0953749493,
-0.4169763923,
-0.1099467427,
0.6405810714,
0.6508773565,
-1.4238812923,
1.2073309422,
0.5966316462,
-0.5175799727,
-0.530927062,
0.1261011809,
0.3135787249,
-0.942506969,
0.7851667404,
0.2037091851,
-0.6184054613,
0.0093367323,
-0.2825031877,
-0.9335047007,
0.6424707174,
0.1231069192,
-0.3710866868,
0.007733867,
0.2799277306,
0.9857795238,
-0.4556543529,
0.3379876912,
0.8386644125,
0.3606885374,
0.0342564508,
-1.2722200155,
0.0607048236,
-0.4615418613,
0.093392916,
0.3803713918,
-0.5669406056,
0.8426417708,
0.2063945532,
-0.273892194,
0.458610177,
0.4771046042,
0.2516466379,
0.4803928137,
0.4563411474,
0.5486165881,
0.9517945051,
0.1221203804,
0.8701053262,
0.1963783801,
-0.109131068,
0.8708979487,
-0.6632725596,
1.0353676081,
0.3699746132,
-0.5616438389,
1.2615022659,
0.4809333682,
0.0902120098,
0.6550110579,
0.4407938421,
-0.664383173,
-0.1245478913,
-0.2127964944,
-0.3465420008,
0.6073259115,
0.6871647239,
-0.0242425557,
-0.3676227331,
-0.0905202925,
-0.0365782529,
0.224200204,
-0.1743698567,
0.6763350368,
-0.2114427537,
-0.6929539442,
0.4095102251,
0.044177033,
0.4190506339,
-0.5207661986,
0.0024300404,
-0.1870092452,
0.1998474002,
-0.3147290349,
-0.4685409069,
0.4624759555,
0.2370754927,
0.0717154741,
-0.1835916489,
0.5553343296,
-0.5419791937,
-0.5521344543,
-0.1013173163,
0.5145448446,
0.4325926602,
0.267500937,
-0.1476893872,
0.132422626,
-0.1794837117,
0.3599465787,
0.4394852817,
0.5167915821,
-0.5656759143,
0.4610359073,
0.4647196233,
0.1741135716,
0.3585699499,
-0.0370450355,
0.5073136091,
-0.486518234,
-0.3690604866,
-0.902253449,
-0.0252779052,
-0.1690834165,
-0.7577818632,
1.1429954767,
0.689137578,
0.7871944308,
-0.0680819973,
0.5685420632,
-0.0388900153,
0.7403072119,
-0.1487169266,
0.6300821304,
-0.2663989663,
0.3482910693,
-0.4151490033,
-0.7193595171,
-0.413084507,
0.7090425491,
-0.5018598437,
-0.2615889013,
0.7284609675,
0.8947184682,
-0.1730613708,
0.032602407,
0.0210756231,
0.0318355672,
-0.0588318221,
0.6172769666,
1.1564096212,
-0.1901289672,
0.4356335402,
-0.3492951393,
-0.2883638442,
-0.1941945851,
-0.6712973118,
-0.7659906149,
-0.724850297,
-0.5490815639,
-0.1318140328,
0.0107052391,
0.7108804584,
0.5359150767,
-1.1633870602,
-0.6383196712,
-0.3328942955,
0.4099496007,
-0.332277149,
-0.0827775523,
0.5829507709,
-0.2879224718,
-0.9488610029,
0.5774995685,
0.4131795466,
-0.1502178907,
-0.3019718826,
0.2203770131,
-0.3167074621,
-0.0312627926,
0.1632372141,
0.7772299051,
-0.9965091348,
0.0759171695,
-0.1013847589,
-0.311486274,
-0.1976122409,
0.9005330801,
-0.9712641835,
0.4967709482,
0.418536216,
0.5849265456,
0.5126581788,
-0.0071812845,
0.3981940746,
-0.7352836132,
0.2224241197,
0.3172316253,
0.1110729277,
0.190417707,
-0.0723277554,
0.4172240198,
0.335160017,
-0.1512525231,
-1.2109162807,
0.2807818651,
-0.8546680808,
-0.0257112309,
1.1461353302,
-0.2551009059,
-0.2156789303,
-0.6020441055,
-0.3036412299,
-0.0072043538,
-0.1194771826,
0.8484286666,
0.8390058279,
0.0574654751,
0.0643107668,
-0.0052306103,
0.4829774797,
0.5773895979,
-0.3462254405,
-0.2472362071,
0.2277821749,
0.3002074957,
0.4100036025,
0.7361459136,
-0.0636525378,
0.471678555,
0.1613595486,
-0.2572894096,
0.3858196735,
-0.453586936,
-0.3858163655,
0.38489905,
0.1662593484,
-0.2372465432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01319v1 | Approaches to Corpus Creation for Low-Resource Language Technology: the Case of Southern Kurdish and Laki | 2023-04-03T19:36:32 | 2023-04-03T19:36:32 | Sina Ahmadi, Zahra Azin, Sara Belelli, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | One of the major challenges that under-represented and endangered language
communities face in language technology is the lack or paucity of language
data. This is also the case of the Southern varieties of the Kurdish and Laki
languages for which very limited resources are available with insubstantial
progress in tools. To tackle this, we provide a few approaches that rely on the
content of local news websites, a local radio station that broadcasts content
in Southern Kurdish and fieldwork for Laki. In this paper, we describe some of
the challenges of such under-represented languages, particularly in writing and
standardization, and also, in retrieving sources of data and retro-digitizing
handwritten content to create a corpus for Southern Kurdish and Laki. In
addition, we study the task of language identification in light of the other
variants of Kurdish and Zaza-Gorani languages. | [
-0.5979992151,
-0.6738923788,
0.4451221228,
-0.1448629349,
-0.0637576506,
0.5759091377,
-0.5549945235,
-0.2458630651,
0.5671280026,
0.7568525076,
-0.1365208477,
-0.3769362271,
-0.4534921646,
0.3152180314,
-0.4160764217,
0.7611369491,
-0.3198832572,
-0.3350966871,
0.0722704455,
-0.4200488627,
-0.1674013734,
-0.6246790886,
-0.6264958382,
0.0131178424,
0.3559933305,
1.0380935669,
0.7956265211,
0.3612827063,
0.3058409989,
0.2532936335,
-0.376806587,
0.1099817902,
-0.2793691158,
0.1321215183,
0.0704951286,
-0.2965994775,
-0.0129029276,
0.0742726848,
0.9420832992,
0.8468492627,
-0.0504244529,
0.3620201051,
-0.1382520497,
0.9077290297,
-0.9460839033,
-0.4250760674,
-0.3710976541,
-0.003079874,
-0.9381306767,
0.1536708176,
-0.0978529304,
-0.428542763,
-0.4368962944,
-0.4332194924,
0.4231562018,
-0.2774644792,
0.765296638,
-0.0834488794,
-0.4812695682,
-0.6445004344,
-0.9686467052,
0.974481225,
-0.6350620389,
0.3789590001,
1.0727567673,
0.2318439931,
-0.2710944116,
-0.4003870785,
-0.4997848868,
-0.2307384759,
-0.2457141578,
0.0381533355,
-0.2420678139,
-0.4597856998,
0.2443216145,
0.1997282356,
-0.345954299,
0.241791293,
-0.9858433008,
-0.0353499763,
0.4700097442,
0.0565963462,
0.0510508716,
-0.4030381441,
0.3902870715,
0.1700535715,
-1.0346090794,
-0.1035325676,
0.8797848225,
0.450897485,
-0.1043678597,
0.8850504756,
-0.5522594452,
0.7112518549,
0.0565801002,
-0.2415291369,
0.2866018713,
-0.5486761928,
0.0257825945,
0.2075550109,
0.67856884,
-0.1933470964,
-0.0663544908,
-0.0926544517,
-0.0301491264,
-0.0885115489,
0.2395435423,
-0.2178214043,
0.1243179739,
0.1987749487,
-0.6909575462,
-0.411980927,
-0.4726434648,
-0.7965723872,
-0.8263014555,
-0.0571683496,
0.0024011221,
-0.2594758868,
-0.6698130369,
-0.386636436,
-0.0871236473,
0.0855330899,
0.1415577382,
-1.0930733681,
0.3342298567,
0.418813765,
0.8378461599,
0.2525528073,
0.0989067256,
-0.3672008812,
0.1879710257,
-0.4020976424,
0.6151943207,
-0.5463675261,
-0.6389377713,
0.0739243478,
-0.0646017045,
0.2787193656,
-0.610507369,
0.656981349,
-0.3885205388,
0.1797981411,
-0.3241241872,
-0.166091904,
0.1628541797,
-0.2248885781,
-0.871307075,
1.2311550379,
0.6039071083,
-0.9993774295,
0.1702601463,
-0.2963393033,
-0.5650838017,
0.2864729464,
-0.413336724,
-0.2254318893,
0.4017478824,
-0.1447517425,
0.3890235424,
-0.2934499979,
-0.1832588911,
0.1217286363,
-0.4127759933,
0.2801357508,
-0.1709377915,
0.8978809714,
0.7424538136,
-0.2988285124,
-0.3194848001,
-1.0938301086,
-0.0482179932,
0.0898607671,
-0.7004565001,
-0.4775018096,
0.1433826238,
0.2339664102,
-0.1663326174,
0.230230242,
-0.6091974378,
0.0635285079,
-0.2257395685,
0.3961955011,
0.2097583711,
-0.3586393595,
0.7807969451,
-0.1969485134,
0.6792730093,
-0.1849360168,
-0.0741175041,
0.452180922,
-0.2683234215,
-0.8673914075,
-0.1160788313,
0.4591839015,
0.6307327151,
-0.8587774038,
0.202762723,
-0.1884156018,
-0.8330946565,
-0.9206644893,
0.4265006781,
0.0962943435,
0.4377233386,
-0.0827752501,
-0.3881731927,
-0.8087923527,
-1.0234375,
0.1834810376,
-0.1893384159,
0.0032100899,
0.3311707973,
-0.1460261196,
-0.089778766,
0.8602462411,
0.1207217202,
-0.2882542014,
-0.3973841667,
0.2780066133,
0.4221999347,
0.2883738279,
0.455370456,
-0.753015995,
-0.7041012645,
0.3817252815,
-0.6366996765,
-0.2427016795,
0.110244818,
0.3047807813,
0.7560840249,
0.7233318686,
-0.3882029355,
0.3517612517,
0.6252904534,
-0.0803431198,
0.3127663136,
-0.0822415799,
0.3624727726,
-1.0412843227,
0.3306862712,
-0.4435729086,
-0.1152494699,
-0.871450901,
0.0046580965,
-0.1765140891,
-0.3084708452,
-0.6047002673,
0.5094109178,
-0.5698097348,
-0.0407064296,
-0.6024605036,
0.4458710551,
-0.6083267331,
-0.1660608202,
0.2009326667,
0.8397443891,
0.0549363457,
-0.2168037593,
0.5545529723,
-0.073381409,
-0.5321063995,
0.323474139,
-0.1873233765,
0.3629040718,
-0.2851464748,
-0.0574411154,
-0.2539670467,
-0.255253315,
0.524703145,
-0.3809058666,
0.1290327013,
-0.5789017081,
-0.5889425874,
-0.2026860118,
-0.0581354275,
0.6055576205,
0.7746626139,
0.1608236432,
0.3825430572,
0.8093320131,
-0.6111086011,
-0.7613523602,
-0.5673415065,
0.2245985121,
-0.5933127403,
-0.3787996769,
-0.1225264743,
0.4980711639,
-0.7050804496,
0.3647111058,
0.4280243814,
-0.2475206405,
0.2483666241,
0.3099572062,
-0.1449005455,
-0.4353491366,
0.1616968662,
-0.0121804606,
0.0889016688,
-0.4123451114,
0.0466400646,
0.4741145968,
-0.2421285808,
-0.1745958328,
-0.0850954577,
0.8903990388,
0.0774608776,
0.0672052801,
0.9454345703,
0.8210634589,
-0.4956331551,
0.2856577635,
-0.8409190774,
0.248487711,
-0.4602895975,
0.1110755354,
-0.3907288313,
-0.9417178631,
0.3473555446,
-0.0559346601,
-0.2692078352,
0.4791543782,
0.8823379874,
-0.3462718427,
0.2285003215,
0.6760944724,
-0.1427386701,
0.4981766045,
0.066251874,
0.1570561379,
-0.5648768544,
0.1007061526,
-0.8421522975,
-0.0977915674,
-0.773791194,
-0.2516157925,
0.226940915,
0.592130363,
-0.0012600764,
0.6052142382,
-0.2750174105,
0.5781129003,
1.1343122721,
-0.2454773784,
0.2799974382,
0.328707546,
0.2176893055,
-0.0090623461,
-0.8718859553,
-1.0345582962,
1.2556177378,
0.068134293,
0.5591132641,
0.2685397863,
1.1740107536,
0.4524409473,
0.0613041036,
-0.3753853142,
0.2167227864,
-0.2999062836,
-0.5974112749,
-0.5415497422,
-0.3860417008,
-1.1551196575,
-0.2496397495,
-0.4103403091,
-0.7267680764,
0.3788876534,
0.0673381314,
-0.5365456939,
0.1246086434,
-0.855768919,
0.6903446317,
0.0855118483,
-0.170299232,
-0.4962974787,
-0.4942283034,
0.0139501132,
-0.3478247225,
0.7922712564,
-0.1927117407,
0.1624004543,
0.9370444417,
-0.2271508574,
0.8917770982,
-0.1159197316,
-0.0240508467,
1.0302500725,
0.1787058115,
0.2565998137,
0.0349615924,
-0.0761612132,
-0.0214370359,
0.2638570368,
-0.7143934369,
-0.2313263118,
0.676966846,
-0.8933683038,
-0.5269936919,
-0.3814088404,
-0.1407885104,
-0.1101419777,
0.3830092847,
0.2861864567,
0.1416369528,
-0.3590991795,
0.0329567194,
0.3095464706,
-0.2704248726,
0.4262629449,
0.2840032876,
0.0973660722,
-0.4563087523,
1.0594881773,
0.1414340138,
0.1704345942,
-0.1444188505,
-0.0570748337,
0.2301252335,
-0.5346965194,
-0.6762141585,
0.3239991069,
-0.8440428972,
0.0812012851,
-0.2024260312,
-0.3571752012,
-0.6057841778,
-0.3507640064,
-0.4675140679,
-0.781129837,
-0.4347985983,
0.2681045234,
0.0651737228,
1.0251028538,
-0.4549387693,
0.4244685769,
-0.9771371484,
0.1667601615,
-0.0687229112,
0.0062195701,
-0.2494376004,
-0.2064309269,
-0.6178904772,
0.1214083955,
0.0094959941,
-0.8431536555,
0.1653395444,
-0.1930923462,
0.4026229084,
-0.0188198071,
0.0022628626,
0.1929608881,
-0.5640841126,
0.6599438787,
0.025853632,
-0.6595709324,
0.6073556542,
-0.3188410699,
0.1411750764,
0.6971315145,
0.3982303739,
-1.1638712883,
-0.5047547817,
-0.69599545,
-0.8022438884,
0.5819095969,
0.3248624504,
0.273974061,
0.0331292264,
0.2532639802,
0.32064569,
0.1111772656,
-0.4713045657,
0.0352213308,
-0.3199763894,
-0.3722455204,
-0.0242588781,
-0.4939614236,
-0.2790980041,
0.219057411,
0.6419389248,
0.0653026849,
0.1455207467,
0.0120850392,
-0.2540510893,
-0.3510735929,
0.6956692934,
0.8537431955,
0.5521177649,
-0.0838521719,
0.3837898374,
0.1649343818,
-0.6344333887,
0.2373183817,
-0.0468855165,
-0.5701196194,
0.1088334322,
0.4144722521,
0.7532974482,
-0.2484561652,
-0.6553456783,
0.1679375023,
0.0780068785,
0.165356636,
-0.7042864561,
-0.2537262738,
0.3143932521,
0.3118481636,
0.4074433148,
-0.2527705729,
-0.155374676,
-0.5844951272,
-0.3416605592,
0.3809188902,
-0.0568601377,
-0.1370652616,
0.2206133306,
0.3955431879,
-0.2698751092,
0.7542859316,
-0.3519743979,
-0.1030302793,
0.4782702327,
0.2832832634,
0.6007984877,
0.1213099882,
0.5262486935,
0.2377113104,
0.3510003388,
0.2364850938,
0.3734079897,
-0.1354184002,
-0.6131417155,
-0.1632916331,
-0.6583607793,
-0.2927999496,
0.1591184437,
-0.3546733856,
0.4981414676,
-0.4337535501,
-0.4962298274,
-0.0387017876,
0.2166220248,
-0.4872483611,
-0.1544124037,
0.4981987476,
0.5615950227,
-0.8971112967,
0.9541671276,
0.7889839411,
-0.40533939,
-0.2857041955,
-0.4440014958,
-0.0502005666,
-0.5914679766,
0.8316418529,
-0.5083703399,
-0.1283593327,
-0.0234443229,
-0.0457401387,
-1.106615901,
0.6442940235,
0.2675720155,
-0.3863148093,
0.036698591,
0.2995816767,
0.4932518303,
0.0599644408,
-0.0255477224,
0.5178979039,
0.410153985,
-0.2494638264,
-1.2703603506,
-0.043974489,
0.0503511317,
-0.2124269903,
0.3629207611,
-0.5168457627,
0.6193523407,
-0.0112709133,
-0.700899899,
0.312913239,
0.6651831269,
-0.1566098183,
0.1189436466,
0.2065982968,
0.339101404,
0.6069501638,
0.1826096624,
0.6140448451,
0.1146808639,
0.1411728263,
0.9883845448,
-0.063607581,
0.8928549886,
0.612847805,
-0.3978725672,
0.2664593756,
0.644169867,
0.088248685,
0.5999392271,
0.1953033507,
-0.7216171622,
-0.059516184,
-0.4666361511,
-0.3523350656,
0.4927200973,
0.4642036259,
-0.1826276332,
-0.2802174985,
0.0389944799,
0.1951626837,
0.2479872108,
-0.2519038618,
0.6583769917,
0.0445480384,
-0.3828127384,
0.7456923127,
0.3816876411,
0.3931439817,
-0.1817184836,
0.1875592321,
-0.4117927849,
-0.0636560246,
-0.2688429952,
-0.5806728005,
0.6811368465,
0.0647217557,
-0.1502869427,
-0.0330525078,
0.9674968719,
-0.452547133,
-0.7298489809,
-0.1423467845,
0.7235012054,
0.4478361607,
0.3855759799,
0.0400906466,
0.2499084473,
-0.2525560856,
0.0384549908,
0.2936129272,
0.2907495797,
-0.548797667,
0.2926216722,
0.2131786644,
0.6602376103,
0.3618001938,
-0.0284417905,
0.5862949491,
-0.6482878327,
-0.0447323769,
-0.5861437917,
-0.1577329934,
0.0401617587,
-0.2087661922,
0.6713725328,
0.5299475789,
0.9070736766,
-0.1168772802,
1.056530714,
-0.7193461061,
0.8190554976,
-0.5129611492,
1.0515578985,
-0.3332547843,
-0.2725450099,
-0.1275560856,
-0.6972336769,
-0.130114153,
0.5109591484,
0.0306397323,
-0.2345615327,
0.5724670291,
0.5459224582,
-0.0941915065,
-0.1010917872,
0.0845033824,
-0.0063718329,
-0.2692084014,
0.5254077911,
0.8225710988,
-0.1614244133,
0.5667449832,
-0.7469755411,
-0.2148911655,
-0.0711292252,
-0.716332078,
-0.8607638478,
-0.9469474554,
-0.2074221075,
-0.5168365836,
0.0314593092,
0.6790223718,
0.3125089109,
-1.0713405609,
-0.6229902506,
0.2188977301,
0.135387361,
0.1517743319,
-0.1407567114,
0.4246693254,
-0.1950690597,
-0.6672901511,
0.6205666661,
-0.1678483784,
0.2274420559,
-0.2653394938,
-0.0001244398,
-0.1264497489,
-0.3625593185,
0.3267163932,
0.9609803557,
-0.7418395877,
-0.3174792826,
-0.1041645184,
-0.2784473598,
-0.1652784944,
1.0944129229,
-1.0973974466,
0.0971307606,
0.4198906124,
0.640958488,
0.4590601325,
-0.1599657685,
0.5143815875,
-0.8988061547,
0.5302064419,
0.3173604012,
0.0866491273,
0.5946770906,
-0.2675112486,
0.6014983654,
0.4386274219,
-0.3135300577,
-0.8655170202,
0.3769744933,
-0.5764349699,
-0.1503624767,
1.181119442,
0.1005238444,
-0.1197580472,
-0.3689323664,
-0.306997627,
0.4172832072,
0.0002654247,
0.813939631,
1.0409036875,
0.0366467051,
-0.357983321,
-0.6537152529,
0.7968135476,
0.2408641577,
-0.4191679358,
0.0405079313,
0.5447568297,
0.1647041589,
0.4551371932,
1.1562842131,
0.0332890451,
0.3245210946,
0.3150090277,
-0.0725937113,
0.1758743674,
0.0336983316,
-0.1271578372,
0.0548854433,
0.3778685033,
0.0982379839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.01295v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.01295v4 | Efficiently Aligned Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning for Conversational Tasks using Prompt-Tuning | 2023-04-03T18:46:01 | 2024-01-27T03:47:55 | Lifu Tu, Jin Qu, Semih Yavuz, Shafiq Joty, Wenhao Liu, Caiming Xiong, Yingbo Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Cross-lingual transfer of language models trained on high-resource languages
like English has been widely studied for many NLP tasks, but focus on
conversational tasks has been rather limited. This is partly due to the high
cost of obtaining non-English conversational data, which results in limited
coverage. In this work, we introduce XSGD for cross-lingual alignment
pretraining, a parallel and large-scale multilingual conversation dataset that
we created by translating the English-only Schema-Guided Dialogue (SGD) dataset
(Rastogi et al., 2020) into 105 other languages. XSGD contains approximately
330k utterances per language. To facilitate aligned cross-lingual
representations, we develop an efficient prompt-tuning-based method for
learning alignment prompts. We also investigate two different classifiers:
NLI-based and vanilla classifiers, and test cross-lingual capability enabled by
the aligned prompts. We evaluate our model's cross-lingual generalization
capabilities on two conversation tasks: slot-filling and intent classification.
Our results demonstrate the strong and efficient modeling ability of NLI-based
classifiers and the large cross-lingual transfer improvements achieved by our
aligned prompts, particularly in few-shot settings. In addition, we highlight
the nice results of our approach compared to LLMs such as text-davinci-003 and
ChatGPT in both zero-shot and few-shot settings. While LLMs exhibit impressive
performance in English, their cross-lingual capabilities in other languages,
particularly low-resource languages, are limited. | [
-0.307541728,
-0.5930031538,
0.2292871922,
0.2905555964,
-0.151526168,
0.1360654086,
-0.4677461088,
-0.3353084028,
0.0779255182,
0.2177971005,
-0.7980802059,
-0.606574297,
-0.2943544686,
0.0406161472,
0.0272041354,
1.0861041546,
-0.0222629793,
0.4019089937,
-0.1434451342,
-0.1949959099,
-0.7610064745,
-0.2720418274,
-0.8792721033,
-0.1127767786,
0.643358469,
0.6180095077,
0.6196449399,
0.5751321912,
0.1617523432,
0.274337709,
0.0982782543,
0.1665035933,
-0.5777145624,
0.025143005,
-0.3418456018,
-0.4535511434,
-0.1643662602,
-0.0953627005,
0.6465246081,
0.9379615784,
-0.1135890111,
-0.1212178916,
0.3159433007,
0.1491632909,
-0.2923568785,
0.3579183519,
-0.4585600495,
0.1867799461,
-0.2841266692,
-0.2243540883,
-0.3847187757,
-0.1755529493,
0.3986215293,
-1.046361208,
0.0435405821,
0.4256968498,
0.7949501872,
0.0729749575,
-0.3601160347,
-0.2198493332,
-0.3246614933,
1.0398535728,
-0.4007152915,
0.7145596147,
0.1521392167,
0.3449579477,
0.1694735438,
-0.4046445191,
-0.389703095,
-0.1347149909,
-0.2427704334,
-0.0231338777,
-0.0918863863,
0.0353703685,
0.328864634,
0.1803013384,
-0.9630625844,
0.4550815821,
0.0725472197,
-0.1896446347,
0.5032396913,
0.1334646195,
0.4881097376,
-0.1611386091,
-0.4938771129,
-0.280872643,
-0.6490570903,
0.2916230857,
0.253362596,
0.6204351187,
-0.2625135183,
0.3519603014,
-0.1052007675,
0.835740447,
0.4525681734,
-0.1803851873,
0.145958364,
-0.8036307693,
0.0183668546,
0.2542997599,
0.8262215257,
0.4731906056,
0.3744159341,
-0.2463018,
0.1321105957,
-0.1703953445,
-0.1114325896,
-0.6101017594,
0.048604738,
-0.1997670233,
-0.1690007746,
0.0126892906,
-0.267665863,
-0.5834015012,
-0.1844126135,
-0.3717943728,
0.1433183551,
-0.3844719827,
-0.0246224161,
0.120219931,
0.1881092191,
0.4669583142,
0.3272888064,
-1.2096260786,
0.0956272036,
0.6677924991,
0.7805495858,
-0.5622754693,
-0.4734647572,
-0.7371333241,
0.1206335127,
-0.4258963466,
0.59479177,
-0.5162484646,
-0.4107986093,
0.0530617163,
0.2553955019,
-0.3750714362,
-0.2336351275,
0.6107965708,
-0.2938643098,
0.6801554561,
-0.3725449741,
-0.5771529078,
-0.0935603604,
0.3712736666,
-0.4432177246,
0.8964540958,
0.184823364,
-0.6697004437,
0.3325965405,
-0.4528503716,
-0.6539090276,
0.1756252944,
-0.270385623,
-0.0928867161,
-0.2719160914,
0.3993812501,
0.4429408908,
-0.5061365366,
0.3355960548,
-0.1433116496,
-0.1983867288,
-0.0032955487,
-0.3887495697,
0.8037031293,
0.1622795612,
-0.3229047358,
0.2502931952,
-0.5492535233,
0.2849647105,
-0.140717715,
0.1324287206,
-0.3453387916,
-0.5402200222,
0.1089432538,
0.3323737979,
0.2088695765,
-0.5107758045,
0.1476945728,
-0.2965343595,
0.0365201905,
0.6024932265,
-0.3726777434,
0.74713099,
-0.3616956174,
0.8960517049,
0.0325064436,
-0.1267486513,
-0.5938057303,
-0.4655486643,
-0.593077004,
-0.0925953463,
0.4822553992,
0.9505754709,
-0.9977342486,
0.5998268127,
-0.441347152,
-0.3606546521,
-0.546572566,
0.2022115588,
0.6907154918,
0.9217998385,
0.2391291112,
-0.0573634505,
-0.2915838361,
-0.6407806873,
-0.2463032752,
-0.1149845943,
-0.0844608471,
0.5114601254,
-0.1920129061,
0.1202684268,
0.7516607642,
-0.3771329522,
-0.2766726315,
-0.341024965,
0.2420201898,
0.0367954746,
0.5397960544,
0.5927988887,
-0.4998185635,
-1.0023456812,
0.4880667925,
-0.6056358218,
-0.5894503593,
-0.445481509,
-0.3387028873,
0.3029276431,
0.6591245532,
-0.6174151897,
-0.1175996661,
0.6710165143,
-0.3858658969,
0.3595478535,
0.086352393,
0.4292753339,
-1.2327635288,
0.0159188304,
0.1618106216,
-0.4374203384,
-0.6570151448,
-0.3408817053,
0.0550289974,
-0.2664620876,
-0.611191988,
0.9249520302,
-0.571747601,
-0.0328650475,
0.0034506936,
0.3643990755,
0.1107687876,
0.7761868834,
0.4230521321,
0.8569323421,
0.8873664141,
-0.3861932755,
0.2799077034,
0.5490975976,
-0.4241447449,
0.9838953018,
-0.5059544444,
-0.0126375612,
0.1239546612,
0.175878793,
-1.0701568127,
0.194799602,
0.3819238245,
-0.2000080049,
0.54099226,
-0.1695735157,
0.0464934632,
0.1336399168,
-0.0038137492,
0.6472311616,
0.3800958991,
-0.7432212234,
0.5488913655,
0.0589713342,
-0.7986685634,
-0.7062109113,
-0.492472142,
0.0226935595,
-0.2451280951,
-0.9258224964,
0.5370492935,
0.0067349076,
0.0612416305,
-0.1642847955,
0.0541800782,
0.254573226,
-0.2920598686,
-0.0836912394,
0.385958761,
-0.36434111,
0.042150978,
0.1578005403,
-0.2737064362,
-0.1759001315,
-0.2941717505,
0.560329318,
0.0720240474,
-0.5791430473,
-0.4612912238,
0.5907828212,
0.2934519053,
-0.1392385364,
0.3520568013,
0.7239804268,
-0.0251761805,
-0.0976604745,
-0.3967792988,
-0.0010108032,
-0.4328959286,
0.4542996585,
-0.4394093752,
-0.9840254188,
0.5705649853,
0.0210553072,
0.1893023998,
0.0944642648,
0.2634986639,
0.0806493312,
1.2597532272,
0.6314781904,
-0.1607971042,
0.8541706204,
0.0451545753,
0.1432152539,
-0.5865380168,
-0.0155552952,
-0.4915028512,
-0.3028867841,
-0.5354606509,
-0.4760365486,
0.1903024614,
-0.0268372819,
-0.0130553283,
0.345513016,
0.0043344921,
0.5353949666,
0.5828581452,
-0.2542564869,
0.1898479462,
-0.0250947103,
-0.0897047967,
-0.3440207243,
-0.9425637722,
-0.1753513217,
0.7689125538,
0.0535630174,
0.9567354321,
-0.1403814852,
0.5385152102,
-0.0560485274,
-0.0831419006,
-0.7874851227,
0.5294068456,
-0.1910886168,
-0.0900374353,
-0.4931846261,
-0.5590804219,
-1.0430370569,
0.3201248348,
-0.2289721072,
-0.6070076227,
0.1938114762,
0.0730723813,
-0.4250672162,
0.0702093393,
-0.9218624234,
1.2197626829,
-0.6144317985,
-0.3622135818,
-0.1148682162,
-0.8163738847,
0.1953391284,
-0.0813575089,
-0.1582368314,
-0.0360361524,
0.1136582196,
0.5269108415,
-0.1629460603,
0.8215905428,
-0.1551461071,
-0.4253751934,
-0.1180267334,
-0.1936161667,
0.5655557513,
0.0827168897,
0.2366766483,
0.3307931721,
-0.0343326703,
-0.3683156073,
-0.8785124421,
0.7412014008,
-0.56751436,
-0.736489296,
-0.3556191325,
-0.8192700148,
-0.4815828204,
0.2462611943,
0.3506711125,
0.3004777133,
-0.4635406435,
-0.0601574071,
0.7587742805,
-0.3045000732,
0.3015529811,
0.6165001988,
-0.3138591945,
-0.2709803581,
0.9659734368,
0.0860813931,
0.469403863,
0.4851423204,
0.0144822802,
-0.5558553934,
-0.2035067379,
-0.9184972048,
0.1967243552,
-0.5728840232,
-0.1218352839,
-0.5368706584,
-0.0211195946,
-0.6644538045,
-0.4191569388,
-0.141191572,
-0.4203826487,
-0.4755859375,
0.0070314296,
0.1018118486,
-0.0125727057,
-0.0007441438,
0.449036926,
-0.9325187206,
0.3143968582,
0.2209711075,
0.1117239222,
-0.2921355665,
-0.5587925315,
-0.1839962304,
0.0840749741,
-0.0548022389,
-0.563952744,
0.4296373129,
0.3800336719,
0.7239952087,
0.6171817183,
0.0677355081,
0.8974989057,
-0.5665303469,
0.6356050968,
0.4182762206,
-0.9502711296,
0.2087012529,
-0.2780587077,
0.4839142263,
0.5108782053,
0.6316395998,
-1.1114965677,
-0.0687144548,
-0.4016854465,
-0.4758801758,
1.0179735422,
-0.3292732537,
0.0077337115,
0.0362657979,
0.0483240224,
0.3233233988,
0.0004771606,
-0.3926419318,
-0.1340521276,
-0.1022092551,
-0.399569124,
-0.2688244879,
0.1149363443,
-0.1272322685,
-0.1631434262,
0.7520401478,
-0.5998613238,
-0.1454743594,
-0.0700826645,
-0.3371274769,
-0.0253216513,
0.3281149268,
0.3741487265,
0.3155173659,
0.3625786901,
-0.2334093601,
0.3254983723,
-0.1563328356,
0.33493945,
0.4069631398,
-0.1575073004,
-0.0528066866,
0.2083224058,
1.2435324192,
0.5069155097,
-0.6921801567,
0.607177794,
-0.207491532,
0.0618647635,
0.1364679039,
-0.1048634201,
-0.0484334044,
0.3394342959,
0.0389704481,
-0.1470228732,
0.0103515508,
-0.3860209286,
0.0997826532,
0.7304260135,
-0.3292355835,
-0.3374502063,
0.4012790918,
0.3985688686,
-0.1642638892,
0.6740056872,
-0.2430120558,
-0.3956259787,
0.1670554876,
0.7393115163,
0.9083425403,
-0.3044514358,
0.4611427188,
0.2335889339,
-0.038604077,
0.0331824459,
0.2532925308,
-0.4181086421,
-0.9171426296,
-0.7563102245,
-0.3658039868,
-0.5710253119,
-0.2359777093,
-0.7008088231,
0.5626246333,
-0.0589084849,
0.0741576403,
-0.0800729692,
-0.0085181743,
-0.5391044617,
-0.0826158002,
0.2767317295,
0.804670155,
-1.0451710224,
0.7015513182,
0.6652832627,
0.09039253,
-0.7955099344,
-0.2069966644,
-0.1182577908,
-0.9640635848,
0.4641363621,
0.1315458417,
-0.0964121595,
0.1860154271,
-0.1751981676,
-0.9632344842,
0.8985376358,
0.6632313728,
-0.9159358144,
-0.272970587,
0.2918334007,
0.4255823195,
-0.4002659917,
0.3160241246,
0.5345198512,
0.5501675606,
0.2968345881,
-1.0968009233,
0.0232722331,
-0.334690243,
0.0493821576,
0.1572251022,
-0.5730741024,
0.5372793674,
-0.1963404566,
-0.4573272765,
0.1113966554,
0.7438136935,
0.2134788185,
0.1228466332,
0.7577266693,
0.6089569926,
0.878585875,
-0.2837964892,
0.7877924442,
-0.5229377747,
-0.127949357,
1.0254884958,
-0.7004380822,
0.3537118137,
0.4839528799,
0.2439852059,
0.2949957252,
0.6443963051,
0.1299310178,
0.5100450516,
-0.1036299989,
-0.238936007,
-0.3834025562,
-0.4275786877,
-0.232471019,
0.3503746688,
0.2573062479,
-0.0379297957,
-0.2645253837,
0.3893212378,
-0.0799532235,
-0.1271473765,
-0.2834116518,
0.9572945833,
-0.0676951855,
-1.138733983,
0.6481298804,
-0.285089165,
0.8910846114,
-0.8616115451,
-0.055691991,
-0.246295765,
0.0124431858,
-0.086566098,
-0.7006124854,
0.0751169473,
-0.1616823077,
-0.0245473646,
-0.6175608039,
0.5095883012,
-1.1557354927,
-0.2939037085,
0.1824207008,
0.6088187695,
0.0579015203,
0.2769796252,
-0.7644624114,
-0.165831238,
0.1996497065,
-0.1245111972,
0.5973364115,
0.5997696519,
-0.5278363824,
0.5326391459,
0.5947442651,
0.0548513569,
0.1121925935,
0.245994851,
0.6521863341,
-0.673540175,
-0.8483111858,
-0.4371092916,
0.2809375823,
0.0596343316,
-0.6062443256,
0.9285880923,
0.4251128137,
1.1377229691,
0.0378996171,
0.7199345231,
0.0551443696,
0.5466980934,
-0.7529010177,
0.347273469,
-0.388577044,
0.0800960064,
-0.2274818271,
-0.8807587028,
-0.1829462945,
0.6159790754,
-0.2610751092,
0.0386153013,
0.6238176227,
0.9035722613,
-0.1298601925,
0.1735337675,
0.421580255,
-0.2189381421,
0.1979286522,
0.5607276559,
0.8923277259,
-0.130580619,
0.7320821285,
-0.2382411957,
-0.2301025838,
-0.0556644499,
-0.8610962033,
-0.8548337221,
-0.535689652,
-0.426282078,
-0.0535745881,
0.067229636,
0.9375898838,
0.7607235909,
-0.8473337293,
-0.349006176,
0.0647427291,
0.1634335667,
-0.4648836553,
-0.2226176858,
0.3458199799,
-0.8014431,
-1.1006971598,
0.5610553026,
0.0831352696,
0.1605916619,
-0.2326536775,
-0.2788038254,
-0.1518589109,
-0.212166965,
0.4168022573,
0.437657088,
-0.4733513296,
-0.2087034434,
0.429410547,
-0.2268582135,
0.117447108,
0.8823801279,
-0.6343693137,
0.3019447625,
0.6156315207,
0.9367610216,
0.3625175953,
0.1910669804,
0.9198588729,
-1.0458679199,
0.0858998969,
0.0895220488,
0.4345809817,
0.5137912631,
-0.4320045412,
0.3433585465,
-0.0015411403,
-0.563616097,
-0.6028880477,
0.178531304,
-1.0051370859,
-0.023415206,
1.0754463673,
-0.3744742274,
-0.137327835,
-0.1143798903,
-0.5673887134,
0.2252983153,
-0.3535968363,
0.4396893978,
0.7789224982,
-0.1838959754,
-0.3779559135,
0.0409268364,
0.6138614416,
0.92848593,
-0.8408449292,
0.2824778557,
0.5859254599,
0.071945779,
0.2708876431,
0.5604586601,
0.0260555055,
0.3928990364,
-0.3063807786,
0.0139282811,
0.1843225658,
-0.2705413401,
-0.662741065,
-0.2397859842,
-0.2574020624,
-0.2399509996
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.