id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03772v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03772v1
|
Character-Level Chinese Dependency Parsing via Modeling Latent Intra-Word Structure
| 2024-06-06T06:23:02 | 2024-06-06T06:23:02 |
Yang Hou, Zhenghua Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Revealing the syntactic structure of sentences in Chinese poses significant
challenges for word-level parsers due to the absence of clear word boundaries.
To facilitate a transition from word-level to character-level Chinese
dependency parsing, this paper proposes modeling latent internal structures
within words. In this way, each word-level dependency tree is interpreted as a
forest of character-level trees. A constrained Eisner algorithm is implemented
to ensure the compatibility of character-level trees, guaranteeing a single
root for intra-word structures and establishing inter-word dependencies between
these roots. Experiments on Chinese treebanks demonstrate the superiority of
our method over both the pipeline framework and previous joint models. A
detailed analysis reveals that a coarse-to-fine parsing strategy empowers the
model to predict more linguistically plausible intra-word structures.
|
[
0.14652787148952484,
-0.5359055399894714,
0.5509474873542786,
0.08686737716197968,
-0.19256311655044556,
-0.11896197497844696,
0.2608836591243744,
-0.5210925340652466,
-0.012890588492155075,
0.2780205309391022,
-0.6349689960479736,
-0.36194026470184326,
-0.38166165351867676,
0.10532491654157639,
0.009602141566574574,
0.7520521879196167,
-0.09321372210979462,
0.06689785420894623,
-0.13833244144916534,
0.1838838905096054,
-0.39001357555389404,
-0.5849840641021729,
-0.5276307463645935,
-0.19831708073616028,
0.7030063271522522,
0.34137094020843506,
0.5364848375320435,
0.7293919920921326,
0.3888874650001526,
0.2910865843296051,
-0.4552021920681,
-0.2245868593454361,
-0.33310630917549133,
0.20840680599212646,
-0.03978639096021652,
-0.7542799711227417,
-0.31635934114456177,
-0.22104693949222565,
0.7282356023788452,
0.8563868999481201,
-0.0022516034077852964,
-0.17843395471572876,
0.35590076446533203,
0.25424280762672424,
-0.3371897041797638,
0.35712000727653503,
-0.7492006421089172,
0.25764456391334534,
-0.5968250632286072,
-0.23593807220458984,
-0.4830215275287628,
0.16189873218536377,
0.09379612654447556,
-0.32639384269714355,
0.30601316690444946,
0.01043308898806572,
1.251226782798767,
0.09941108524799347,
-0.2702035903930664,
0.10562648624181747,
-0.4689399302005768,
0.3603194057941437,
-1.0108603239059448,
0.36251288652420044,
0.4869641065597534,
0.13143198192119598,
-0.29116493463516235,
-0.6518924236297607,
-0.30276575684547424,
-0.6989905834197998,
-0.5426192283630371,
0.07020334154367447,
0.33742132782936096,
0.5344246625900269,
0.16352955996990204,
0.6385534405708313,
-0.4345049560070038,
0.20835909247398376,
-0.08035493642091751,
0.07399249821901321,
0.22747814655303955,
0.4298659861087799,
0.8611218333244324,
-0.5778688788414001,
-0.015508320182561874,
-0.14195804297924042,
-0.748622477054596,
0.6023498177528381,
0.2903827428817749,
0.965743362903595,
-0.009647628292441368,
0.6807736158370972,
0.16115732491016388,
0.3782810568809509,
0.12334629893302917,
-0.17343929409980774,
-0.16906097531318665,
-0.29273292422294617,
-0.26867106556892395,
0.1502790004014969,
0.4832018315792084,
0.014532229863107204,
-0.1570209562778473,
0.03336130082607269,
-0.42507755756378174,
0.07605438679456711,
-0.15934410691261292,
-0.9058395028114319,
-0.6540522575378418,
0.3896680176258087,
-0.6073952913284302,
-0.06728807091712952,
0.2404940128326416,
-0.44146478176116943,
-0.4857875406742096,
-0.056338611990213394,
0.009771227836608887,
-0.48209160566329956,
-0.42549607157707214,
-0.41568079590797424,
0.019317040219902992,
0.21070246398448944,
0.28863605856895447,
-0.9972285032272339,
0.2559562921524048,
0.7159081697463989,
1.1453708410263062,
0.2588058412075043,
-0.18682131171226501,
-0.7076378464698792,
0.4090549647808075,
-0.2628939151763916,
0.8403541445732117,
-0.7379207611083984,
-0.22469505667686462,
-0.13485008478164673,
0.24340002238750458,
-0.06521584838628769,
-0.39777183532714844,
0.5733606815338135,
-0.11115909367799759,
0.2338356226682663,
-0.34677502512931824,
-0.6720200181007385,
-0.23303134739398956,
0.46649491786956787,
-0.6795492768287659,
0.7812597155570984,
0.452833890914917,
-0.959301769733429,
0.25359871983528137,
-0.4364986717700958,
-0.44692692160606384,
0.38819804787635803,
-0.3034183979034424,
-0.1612093299627304,
0.25776830315589905,
0.3186970353126526,
0.3910922706127167,
-0.17259377241134644,
0.21981512010097504,
-0.35534167289733887,
-0.06693373620510101,
-0.4456952214241028,
-0.20602282881736755,
1.2091137170791626,
0.13941404223442078,
0.14642244577407837,
0.30090129375457764,
-0.6543550491333008,
-0.11793907731771469,
0.13087689876556396,
0.05620523914694786,
-0.6008009910583496,
0.4267055094242096,
0.13638663291931152,
0.34654292464256287,
0.29460206627845764,
-0.7388055920600891,
0.36830124258995056,
-0.7843011021614075,
0.4860150218009949,
0.6394040584564209,
-0.0868445485830307,
0.15704120695590973,
0.026242606341838837,
0.5444951057434082,
0.48187586665153503,
0.004000161308795214,
-0.9059945940971375,
-0.20825587213039398,
-0.6977155804634094,
0.008904796093702316,
0.1911337971687317,
0.6166419386863708,
-0.5616090893745422,
0.5912148952484131,
-0.12537910044193268,
-0.30455511808395386,
-0.2605820596218109,
-0.34933382272720337,
0.28113359212875366,
0.322436660528183,
0.17162743210792542,
-0.20640558004379272,
-0.1644051969051361,
-0.6658363938331604,
-0.3008502721786499,
-0.7659640312194824,
-0.07933671027421951,
-0.10945907980203629,
0.273918479681015,
0.20030885934829712,
0.93147212266922,
-0.5601741075515747,
-0.5226046442985535,
-0.4290613532066345,
-0.020307423546910286,
0.22663700580596924,
0.610709547996521,
0.3420182168483734,
-0.6095214486122131,
-0.760647714138031,
0.3831402659416199,
-0.37984412908554077,
-0.21548360586166382,
-0.24517573416233063,
0.24631047248840332,
-0.17544755339622498,
0.7853772044181824,
-0.27123644948005676,
0.5958955883979797,
0.5357763171195984,
-0.6659783720970154,
0.4302401542663574,
-0.20176009833812714,
-0.14970169961452484,
-1.228794813156128,
0.010365656577050686,
0.11114507168531418,
-0.15113945305347443,
-0.6902490854263306,
0.4278468191623688,
0.10431458801031113,
-0.07636872678995132,
-0.24088120460510254,
0.19378186762332916,
-0.6719868183135986,
-0.09662659466266632,
-0.03730006888508797,
-0.20936669409275055,
0.22938327491283417,
0.6229954957962036,
-0.25128403306007385,
0.5594249963760376,
0.21000416576862335,
-0.269122451543808,
0.17178478837013245,
0.03439263626933098,
-0.307770699262619,
0.3871067464351654,
-0.897661566734314,
-0.09133685380220413,
-0.1867339164018631,
0.24305066466331482,
-1.2346608638763428,
0.008412315510213375,
0.5673081874847412,
-0.18862180411815643,
0.3536549508571625,
-0.5776193737983704,
-0.715120255947113,
-0.08652914315462112,
-0.05616578087210655,
0.4745333194732666,
-0.1336992383003235,
-0.5868924260139465,
0.5595455765724182,
0.2956111431121826,
-0.28231436014175415,
-0.0882515236735344,
-0.6849672794342041,
0.22771233320236206,
-0.12796148657798767,
-0.8996031880378723,
0.8271152973175049,
0.01888292096555233,
-0.25358039140701294,
0.25334233045578003,
0.08777229487895966,
-0.37434443831443787,
0.15489418804645538,
0.13215185701847076,
0.23567795753479004,
-0.4019835889339447,
-0.06521010398864746,
0.07094835489988327,
0.07221263647079468,
-0.10099752992391586,
-0.17059026658535004,
0.4408772587776184,
0.004885333590209484,
-0.4696836769580841,
-0.5067428946495056,
0.43508005142211914,
0.3515172004699707,
-0.4493465721607208,
0.7524743676185608,
0.024383585900068283,
-0.5484965443611145,
-0.12649914622306824,
0.15688428282737732,
0.010101176798343658,
-0.44697803258895874,
0.6464703679084778,
-0.8832870721817017,
-0.733395516872406,
0.6520763635635376,
0.18216170370578766,
0.2873191237449646,
0.4912027418613434,
0.06501884013414383,
0.12919120490550995,
1.2595078945159912,
0.9331652522087097,
0.00395760964602232,
0.6971429586410522,
0.211527019739151,
0.33210933208465576,
-0.6924095749855042,
-0.02524561621248722,
-0.6301282048225403,
0.05859391391277313,
-0.5858376026153564,
-0.16864006221294403,
0.19773437082767487,
0.32123011350631714,
-0.06664737313985825,
0.48601841926574707,
-0.3889699876308441,
0.56081622838974,
0.10064667463302612,
-0.08537270128726959,
0.19422781467437744,
0.0023336843587458134,
-0.33993029594421387,
-0.09564024209976196,
-0.5049916505813599,
-0.2244095802307129,
-0.030195290222764015,
0.6653131246566772,
0.45715025067329407,
0.012021264061331749,
0.3847978115081787,
-0.029145849868655205,
-0.051299866288900375,
-0.9205994009971619,
0.335484117269516,
-0.7099938988685608,
-0.25470417737960815,
-0.48236334323883057,
-0.4084000885486603,
-0.9148352146148682,
0.5897294282913208,
0.18387295305728912,
-0.9340043663978577,
0.1045004278421402,
-0.13921146094799042,
-0.39189741015434265,
0.5621026754379272,
-0.6714590191841125,
0.923724353313446,
-0.2722058892250061,
-0.13615165650844574,
0.04861854016780853,
-0.6652854681015015,
0.45317670702934265,
0.2725101411342621,
-0.07149303704500198,
-0.08668206632137299,
0.1529901921749115,
0.36256298422813416,
-0.791100025177002,
0.9069504141807556,
-0.23242375254631042,
-0.4859045147895813,
0.22210852801799774,
0.246806338429451,
0.5363908410072327,
-0.22313645482063293,
0.028898881748318672,
0.1416880488395691,
0.37687718868255615,
-0.3673839569091797,
-0.593280553817749,
0.34076428413391113,
-0.6573253273963928,
-0.5725087523460388,
-0.5700294971466064,
-0.5167487859725952,
-0.0512189082801342,
0.17589636147022247,
0.15630947053432465,
0.43873360753059387,
-0.3314836919307709,
-0.17871862649917603,
0.09563449025154114,
-0.3322983384132385,
0.41054800152778625,
0.171696275472641,
-0.36663705110549927,
-0.17627562582492828,
0.7790946960449219,
0.4725431501865387,
0.11204847693443298,
0.7879221439361572,
0.3659638464450836,
-0.04791074991226196,
-0.5223188996315002,
-0.460419625043869,
0.16434015333652496,
-0.6094764471054077,
0.11348327249288559,
-0.6256095170974731,
-0.7101126313209534,
-0.3474178910255432,
0.1641855090856552,
-0.16594833135604858,
-0.22142350673675537,
-0.2503886818885803,
-0.016287945210933685,
-0.09690573066473007,
1.0380690097808838,
0.2892214357852936,
0.5543601512908936,
-1.0719877481460571,
0.24363096058368683,
0.07992054522037506,
0.5155549645423889,
0.10244692116975784,
-0.5927613377571106,
-0.44450923800468445,
-0.06042712181806564,
-0.1844143122434616,
-0.9472808837890625,
0.5295366644859314,
0.12054327130317688,
0.4467349946498871,
0.6960757374763489,
-0.050705838948488235,
0.9962315559387207,
-0.6512377858161926,
1.063199758529663,
0.24881362915039062,
-1.110579252243042,
0.5729108452796936,
-0.47199803590774536,
0.2790708839893341,
0.43656232953071594,
-0.09684498608112335,
-0.910808801651001,
-0.4945066273212433,
-0.4416380226612091,
-0.9995902180671692,
0.9699029922485352,
0.09481863677501678,
-0.12119182199239731,
0.20733176171779633,
0.33141040802001953,
0.10882953554391861,
-0.4128284156322479,
-0.9724547863006592,
-0.05207322537899017,
-0.10450462251901627,
-0.1926458477973938,
0.16670380532741547,
-0.2530549168586731,
0.3131107687950134,
-0.2800194323062897,
0.3791407346725464,
-0.02081717737019062,
-0.16880127787590027,
0.1433984935283661,
-0.24005553126335144,
-0.27879613637924194,
0.08299711346626282,
0.10731000453233719,
0.44777315855026245,
-0.2496732622385025,
0.3170037865638733,
-0.09283129870891571,
-0.3725789487361908,
0.1452917605638504,
0.09721880406141281,
-0.4079580008983612,
-0.030212417244911194,
0.5327050685882568,
0.7469199299812317,
-0.022364843636751175,
-0.2566113770008087,
0.38800135254859924,
-0.05421116203069687,
0.18675893545150757,
-0.27833279967308044,
-0.1663929671049118,
0.14800363779067993,
0.09786078333854675,
0.1250998079776764,
-0.2848966419696808,
-0.05033456161618233,
-0.624809980392456,
0.21079225838184357,
0.22906161844730377,
-0.6472688317298889,
-0.5788225531578064,
0.3930225372314453,
0.15842990577220917,
-0.20468752086162567,
0.7128587365150452,
-0.004810374695807695,
-0.6534959673881531,
0.7876240015029907,
0.616247832775116,
1.0358355045318604,
-0.43479621410369873,
0.17037543654441833,
0.5933763384819031,
0.41614004969596863,
-0.11198686063289642,
0.05147858336567879,
0.16869333386421204,
-0.6541945338249207,
-0.5145626068115234,
-0.508133590221405,
-0.2035433053970337,
0.13578647375106812,
-0.36879763007164,
0.4854588210582733,
-0.5700446367263794,
0.3298015892505646,
-0.22624114155769348,
-0.017296690493822098,
-0.06179680675268173,
0.1821698695421219,
0.39729753136634827,
0.7054619789123535,
-0.7102015614509583,
1.1200519800186157,
0.4815356135368347,
-0.7464765310287476,
-1.010906457901001,
0.5548921227455139,
-0.0562395416200161,
-0.40492919087409973,
0.6875683069229126,
0.6146860718727112,
0.004354801494628191,
-0.13990575075149536,
-0.34360271692276,
-0.8699791431427002,
0.8746131658554077,
0.30139705538749695,
-0.7339380979537964,
-0.3449726700782776,
0.2758435308933258,
0.4460889399051666,
-0.3952471911907196,
0.5528722405433655,
0.25019317865371704,
0.3476792275905609,
-0.02031233161687851,
-0.7144551873207092,
0.20730580389499664,
-0.4385814070701599,
0.32173678278923035,
0.3628253638744354,
-0.6018602252006531,
1.4447132349014282,
0.014651011675596237,
-0.7737205624580383,
0.07973279058933258,
1.1317557096481323,
0.1811612993478775,
-0.05752009525895119,
1.0358895063400269,
0.5341691374778748,
0.6641750931739807,
0.27087897062301636,
0.5960012674331665,
-0.46027517318725586,
0.2060355544090271,
1.2131441831588745,
-0.2575857639312744,
0.8409448862075806,
0.3487069308757782,
-0.42943572998046875,
0.9122422337532043,
0.914146363735199,
-0.15226107835769653,
0.2912675738334656,
0.3714774250984192,
-0.1030069887638092,
-0.023850655183196068,
-0.5669680237770081,
-0.2912411093711853,
0.4291435778141022,
0.5356029272079468,
-0.2690296173095703,
-0.32718589901924133,
-0.46685612201690674,
0.006173799280077219,
-0.04202210158109665,
-0.30119720101356506,
0.5765872597694397,
0.2730213701725006,
-0.6076040863990784,
0.16324904561042786,
0.24542157351970673,
0.5323677062988281,
-0.777715265750885,
-0.356806218624115,
-0.1529219150543213,
0.03797478973865509,
-0.3245520293712616,
-0.7083849310874939,
0.3164631724357605,
-0.12286189198493958,
-0.02741750329732895,
-0.23353378474712372,
0.6617477536201477,
-0.7443549036979675,
-0.5841020941734314,
0.5543558597564697,
0.5663681626319885,
0.11453196406364441,
-0.24139449000358582,
-0.49953871965408325,
-0.2564602494239807,
-0.05577829107642174,
-0.17875754833221436,
0.36175644397735596,
0.7444244027137756,
-0.1384267359972,
0.18275678157806396,
0.4778676927089691,
0.13885484635829926,
-0.17294436693191528,
0.2793596088886261,
0.8114098310470581,
-0.9014616012573242,
-1.1354855298995972,
-1.0475949048995972,
0.5956506729125977,
0.10542283207178116,
-0.2671065628528595,
0.5761144161224365,
0.3195473849773407,
0.8720147609710693,
0.3943173885345459,
0.7777908444404602,
-0.3162171542644501,
0.1772615611553192,
-0.35769417881965637,
0.7412246465682983,
-0.7910595536231995,
0.34900572896003723,
-0.44375988841056824,
-0.8418325185775757,
-0.44992077350616455,
0.4447019100189209,
-0.030438829213380814,
-0.13852126896381378,
0.9108839631080627,
0.7098143696784973,
-0.11607755720615387,
0.01923982799053192,
0.4616847336292267,
0.3306381404399872,
0.6790371537208557,
0.7392473816871643,
0.9083806872367859,
-0.11551067233085632,
0.551087498664856,
-0.31092405319213867,
-0.21544355154037476,
0.12637808918952942,
-0.8473150730133057,
-0.8995649218559265,
-0.8110241293907166,
0.095652736723423,
-0.28346866369247437,
-0.2076810747385025,
0.8899045586585999,
0.5213510394096375,
-0.8718436360359192,
-0.45100677013397217,
-0.5243361592292786,
-0.015999775379896164,
-0.17224149405956268,
-0.26614299416542053,
0.48913687467575073,
-0.5417128205299377,
-0.6528199315071106,
0.3508504629135132,
0.35301363468170166,
0.027960563078522682,
-0.513778805732727,
0.16238965094089508,
-0.20145027339458466,
-0.15689100325107574,
0.5814685225486755,
0.11114062368869781,
-1.0123051404953003,
-0.4337807297706604,
-0.1388765424489975,
-0.3576658070087433,
0.32202383875846863,
1.070098638534546,
-0.4665364623069763,
0.2332831621170044,
0.8666735291481018,
0.4701775014400482,
0.23188720643520355,
-0.060345087200403214,
0.8176382184028625,
-0.6316556930541992,
0.03464564308524132,
0.10164719074964523,
0.5775392651557922,
0.45266300439834595,
-0.5554898977279663,
0.37099742889404297,
0.336192786693573,
-0.23043960332870483,
-0.6601002216339111,
0.5674527883529663,
-0.7036590576171875,
-0.7418898344039917,
0.8600781559944153,
-0.6764751076698303,
-0.3060162663459778,
-0.2861253023147583,
-0.437133252620697,
0.5421294569969177,
-0.10914811491966248,
0.48063361644744873,
0.8191421627998352,
0.024474572390317917,
-0.6874358057975769,
-0.04550418630242348,
0.2970978915691376,
0.4846586287021637,
-0.8284215927124023,
0.4638558030128479,
0.33714696764945984,
-0.1836652159690857,
0.1498943418264389,
0.5390417575836182,
-0.11175873875617981,
-0.3787541389465332,
0.23425044119358063,
-0.14528001844882965,
0.04576360061764717,
-0.3962346017360687,
-0.28466489911079407,
0.3319782614707947,
0.08425889164209366,
0.062466204166412354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02409v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02409v1
|
Effective Context Selection in LLM-based Leaderboard Generation: An Empirical Study
| 2024-06-06T06:05:39 | 2024-06-06T06:05:39 |
Salomon Kabongo, Jennifer D'Souza, Sören Auer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores the impact of context selection on the efficiency of
Large Language Models (LLMs) in generating Artificial Intelligence (AI)
research leaderboards, a task defined as the extraction of (Task, Dataset,
Metric, Score) quadruples from scholarly articles. By framing this challenge as
a text generation objective and employing instruction finetuning with the
FLAN-T5 collection, we introduce a novel method that surpasses traditional
Natural Language Inference (NLI) approaches in adapting to new developments
without a predefined taxonomy. Through experimentation with three distinct
context types of varying selectivity and length, our study demonstrates the
importance of effective context selection in enhancing LLM accuracy and
reducing hallucinations, providing a new pathway for the reliable and efficient
generation of AI leaderboards. This contribution not only advances the state of
the art in leaderboard generation but also sheds light on strategies to
mitigate common challenges in LLM-based information extraction.
|
[
-0.3915223777294159,
-1.1136332750320435,
0.64200758934021,
0.13126243650913239,
-0.23402544856071472,
-0.0830264762043953,
-0.5335743427276611,
-0.4333750605583191,
0.09900470077991486,
0.24983426928520203,
-0.33997243642807007,
-0.6350926160812378,
-0.6012969017028809,
0.20176251232624054,
-0.27519097924232483,
1.140460729598999,
0.044972702860832214,
-0.2750037908554077,
-0.2728438079357147,
0.09302538633346558,
-0.783538818359375,
-0.35522618889808655,
-0.535664975643158,
-0.4441354274749756,
0.48484286665916443,
0.41287583112716675,
0.2844189703464508,
0.6611976623535156,
0.659177839756012,
0.23325768113136292,
-0.12307245284318924,
0.44857996702194214,
-0.6680355072021484,
0.4529339075088501,
-0.0743262767791748,
-0.13622085750102997,
-0.6375470161437988,
0.010392029769718647,
0.5150883793830872,
0.5645793080329895,
-0.16751649975776672,
0.20242761075496674,
0.17673282325267792,
0.5448893308639526,
-0.6900041699409485,
0.12003249675035477,
-0.8780173659324646,
0.06873314082622528,
-0.3388664126396179,
-0.6366677284240723,
-0.5484216809272766,
-0.26231443881988525,
0.29022216796875,
-0.5943537950515747,
-0.0428805835545063,
0.14535558223724365,
0.5846138000488281,
0.21474424004554749,
-0.4510215222835541,
-0.6296441555023193,
-0.7025662064552307,
0.9991565346717834,
-0.4070455729961395,
0.21180562674999237,
0.21786680817604065,
0.4393739700317383,
-0.08582194894552231,
-1.0233502388000488,
-0.23907919228076935,
0.02576075866818428,
0.0883621871471405,
0.12466154992580414,
0.11912602186203003,
-0.07730179280042648,
0.16132159531116486,
0.10893654823303223,
-0.2145303189754486,
0.10238528251647949,
-0.3484656810760498,
0.1527974158525467,
0.7221598625183105,
-0.06005994603037834,
0.07638376951217651,
-0.34545522928237915,
-0.15465432405471802,
-0.1261516660451889,
-0.7087505459785461,
-0.1778615564107895,
-0.1712900847196579,
0.38984599709510803,
0.32122549414634705,
0.25935202836990356,
0.012665094807744026,
0.49086496233940125,
-0.08840005099773407,
-0.42230451107025146,
0.07607803493738174,
-0.4089997112751007,
-0.08239096403121948,
0.22160641849040985,
0.5941424369812012,
0.5488695502281189,
0.19281905889511108,
-0.4575629234313965,
-0.3771214485168457,
-0.09519829601049423,
0.4895426332950592,
-0.893929123878479,
-0.11354406923055649,
0.17110124230384827,
-0.450848788022995,
-0.42967212200164795,
0.4274929463863373,
-0.8912973403930664,
-0.057209908962249756,
-0.1576225757598877,
0.22143442928791046,
-0.33252573013305664,
0.10375058650970459,
-0.5147919058799744,
-0.11534930020570755,
0.3490532636642456,
0.3401578664779663,
-0.9191709756851196,
0.08277659118175507,
0.7993187308311462,
0.8867038488388062,
-0.8480237722396851,
-0.16248857975006104,
-0.7319335341453552,
0.22014810144901276,
-0.5502169132232666,
0.6251020431518555,
-0.4917789399623871,
-0.5446726083755493,
0.06197202578186989,
-0.4241386651992798,
-0.07423535734415054,
-0.729097843170166,
0.6804731488227844,
-0.5150187015533447,
0.1825215220451355,
-0.1741238534450531,
-0.6733421087265015,
0.08160259574651718,
0.10041195899248123,
-0.5866230726242065,
1.003792643547058,
-0.09247388690710068,
-0.4092247784137726,
0.554568886756897,
-0.8614748120307922,
-0.6470015048980713,
0.14036588370800018,
-0.4171372652053833,
-0.20668628811836243,
0.13985934853553772,
0.2655760943889618,
0.509238600730896,
-0.1637236624956131,
0.6636424660682678,
0.2007952183485031,
-0.3030708432197571,
0.09838904440402985,
-0.4034143090248108,
0.4701104462146759,
0.2732274532318115,
-0.7307928204536438,
0.2475350797176361,
-0.5813308358192444,
0.14896844327449799,
0.02534913644194603,
-0.39241769909858704,
-0.33974021673202515,
0.3053281009197235,
0.1961480975151062,
0.034939199686050415,
0.2789228558540344,
-0.18271774053573608,
-0.058443594723939896,
-0.1048496812582016,
0.4004654586315155,
0.9731682538986206,
0.169518381357193,
0.3071628510951996,
-0.3389055132865906,
0.2478962391614914,
-0.29267245531082153,
-0.12811240553855896,
-0.04042912274599075,
-0.4947013556957245,
-0.4006575047969818,
-0.25049394369125366,
0.29049742221832275,
0.527175784111023,
-0.6714645624160767,
0.8052660822868347,
-0.34518417716026306,
-0.4016646146774292,
-0.2914668023586273,
0.23639452457427979,
0.21395738422870636,
0.6949601173400879,
0.4579119384288788,
-0.011876390315592289,
-0.5427576899528503,
-0.6813915967941284,
-0.21730706095695496,
0.06259965896606445,
0.04389790818095207,
0.5272088050842285,
0.5550321936607361,
-0.21220599114894867,
1.0819259881973267,
-0.4777970314025879,
-0.3267078697681427,
-0.4041316509246826,
-0.05231713131070137,
0.17423948645591736,
0.4863404333591461,
0.6153684258460999,
-0.8329773545265198,
-0.39454078674316406,
-0.08500628173351288,
-1.018064022064209,
-0.17459741234779358,
-0.34196045994758606,
-0.4525938034057617,
0.19149106740951538,
0.5220361351966858,
-0.5267836451530457,
0.34547534584999084,
0.20087940990924835,
-0.31801837682724,
0.3749631345272064,
0.03270808234810829,
0.04971877858042717,
-1.1016720533370972,
0.4493422210216522,
0.11187079548835754,
-0.1477876454591751,
-0.7227221727371216,
0.22278772294521332,
-0.09446694701910019,
0.42364874482154846,
-0.08134978264570236,
0.7164055705070496,
-0.3907100558280945,
-0.019003570079803467,
-0.2771441340446472,
0.5865786671638489,
-0.09042548388242722,
0.20236991345882416,
-0.024942198768258095,
0.8316981792449951,
0.23077058792114258,
-0.5912714600563049,
-0.1499275416135788,
0.40841686725616455,
-0.48688265681266785,
0.40431976318359375,
-0.327661395072937,
0.07379495352506638,
0.014238799922168255,
0.12058807164430618,
-0.6482575535774231,
-0.2629495859146118,
-0.06767789274454117,
-0.15043142437934875,
0.16504815220832825,
0.4738970696926117,
-0.19961491227149963,
0.03660587966442108,
-0.31807151436805725,
0.17630144953727722,
0.6879830360412598,
-0.7479097843170166,
0.2957438826560974,
0.5237303972244263,
-0.05263236537575722,
-0.48118919134140015,
-0.6835826635360718,
0.243817538022995,
-0.3960743546485901,
-0.27115723490715027,
0.572715163230896,
-0.3898646831512451,
-0.6011586785316467,
-0.31775960326194763,
-0.3528708517551422,
0.1574982851743698,
0.4929075539112091,
0.06484917551279068,
0.2629060745239258,
-0.3066430687904358,
-0.10517863184213638,
0.21089975535869598,
0.2562355399131775,
0.16981817781925201,
-0.0846787616610527,
0.22835977375507355,
0.014640433713793755,
-0.01355193555355072,
-0.531567394733429,
0.24871183931827545,
0.30405330657958984,
-0.08844790607690811,
0.8020750880241394,
0.44750499725341797,
-0.2658035457134247,
-0.6536177396774292,
-0.4142982065677643,
-0.48319441080093384,
-0.4725635051727295,
0.32589784264564514,
-0.2723066806793213,
-0.879498302936554,
0.37751418352127075,
-0.05060001090168953,
0.4032706916332245,
0.5447381734848022,
0.35506370663642883,
0.22138124704360962,
0.8385058641433716,
0.4343389868736267,
0.030560465529561043,
0.5861154794692993,
-0.12341061979532242,
0.264799028635025,
-0.8506738543510437,
-0.233530655503273,
-0.3773522675037384,
-0.29742881655693054,
-0.6292549967765808,
-0.12327063083648682,
0.44876769185066223,
0.16182035207748413,
0.017058847472071648,
-0.2068166583776474,
-0.6809585690498352,
0.4786571264266968,
0.4501148462295532,
0.07245242595672607,
0.32890957593917847,
0.2583398222923279,
0.03217753767967224,
-0.08223188668489456,
-0.6603201627731323,
-0.8506444692611694,
1.1766252517700195,
0.06110602989792824,
0.2624913454055786,
0.2992992103099823,
0.7378295660018921,
0.49802523851394653,
0.5402237772941589,
-0.7142516374588013,
0.692013680934906,
-0.09278079867362976,
-0.4273337423801422,
-0.3613472580909729,
-0.47736412286758423,
-0.7791299819946289,
0.3730866312980652,
-0.32333922386169434,
-0.8480424880981445,
-0.16762197017669678,
-0.19881455600261688,
-0.37208810448646545,
0.1811404675245285,
-0.3912220895290375,
0.8397066593170166,
-0.1953272968530655,
-0.4905417859554291,
0.034126799553632736,
-0.5323113799095154,
0.28620031476020813,
-0.3086211681365967,
0.1984594613313675,
0.25348490476608276,
-0.013181829825043678,
0.933918833732605,
-0.10677597671747208,
0.6151513457298279,
-0.15506766736507416,
-0.054321445524692535,
0.367025762796402,
-0.051258385181427,
0.3146475851535797,
0.1615552008152008,
-0.3884248435497284,
0.17848597466945648,
-0.3656529188156128,
-0.06362924724817276,
-0.5409051179885864,
0.7170623540878296,
-0.738303005695343,
-0.6834931969642639,
-0.13992294669151306,
-0.48420295119285583,
-0.03666696697473526,
0.38180020451545715,
0.19319120049476624,
0.37321358919143677,
-0.4319699704647064,
0.5885103344917297,
0.40788301825523376,
0.03366946429014206,
0.5847119092941284,
-0.14475446939468384,
-0.13572260737419128,
-0.43857190012931824,
0.8707594871520996,
0.2153308242559433,
-0.05380825325846672,
0.21446987986564636,
0.12203116714954376,
0.0032863051164895296,
-0.8830751180648804,
-0.2388334572315216,
-0.0026564747095108032,
-0.8394227623939514,
-0.056645069271326065,
-0.4514448046684265,
-0.4271542727947235,
-0.34937867522239685,
-0.3843681216239929,
-0.10141754895448685,
-0.3489040434360504,
-0.5484969019889832,
-0.26983511447906494,
-0.056123893707990646,
0.8088151216506958,
0.13762295246124268,
0.347822904586792,
-0.44983017444610596,
0.1265740990638733,
0.19256028532981873,
0.003929052501916885,
0.23814332485198975,
-0.35130900144577026,
-0.14179466664791107,
-0.23350629210472107,
-0.4814404547214508,
-0.7293676137924194,
0.29329004883766174,
0.4777323603630066,
0.8549743294715881,
0.4218040108680725,
0.10368690639734268,
0.6682994961738586,
-0.5486775636672974,
0.8770617842674255,
-0.19012217223644257,
-0.7766324281692505,
0.7233851552009583,
-0.28071650862693787,
0.2663504183292389,
0.7035897970199585,
0.24559928476810455,
-0.20095084607601166,
-0.3905729055404663,
-0.5252472162246704,
-1.0593039989471436,
0.5799660086631775,
0.5199452638626099,
-0.11158055067062378,
-0.32190564274787903,
0.7542273998260498,
0.26401907205581665,
0.3870545029640198,
-0.6835508346557617,
-0.2504628002643585,
-0.08247581124305725,
-0.3542095422744751,
-0.18578319251537323,
-0.19713281095027924,
-0.20449523627758026,
-0.1781468540430069,
0.6609082221984863,
-0.23983773589134216,
0.15190951526165009,
0.3758974075317383,
-0.30428966879844666,
-0.048979051411151886,
0.06568794697523117,
0.8849952220916748,
1.091073989868164,
-0.2446269392967224,
-0.006016734521836042,
0.1817961186170578,
-0.4561426639556885,
-0.3872646391391754,
-0.15887930989265442,
-0.3506801426410675,
-0.05572645366191864,
0.7108427286148071,
0.934333086013794,
-0.016064675524830818,
-0.7397735714912415,
0.30298376083374023,
-0.01747600920498371,
-0.2077654004096985,
-0.3980097770690918,
0.43451038002967834,
-0.2837192118167877,
0.291450560092926,
0.9696508049964905,
-0.17766301333904266,
0.06005571782588959,
-0.4930696487426758,
0.5740005373954773,
0.5499768853187561,
-0.12434571236371994,
-0.18333548307418823,
0.7161381840705872,
0.23619961738586426,
-0.5129473209381104,
0.5478944182395935,
-0.06783387064933777,
-0.2561710774898529,
0.6819282174110413,
0.6507137417793274,
0.7147521376609802,
-0.051584161818027496,
0.09740033745765686,
0.48846161365509033,
0.1719275265932083,
-0.19317707419395447,
-0.1468968689441681,
-0.2012147307395935,
-0.6409816741943359,
-0.23277053236961365,
-0.709256649017334,
-0.37132149934768677,
0.18360258638858795,
-0.7053920030593872,
-0.0005079660331830382,
-0.460050493478775,
-0.29180458188056946,
-0.0268101803958416,
0.12064169347286224,
-0.21389970183372498,
0.04792044311761856,
0.2627321481704712,
0.7224610447883606,
-0.4562031626701355,
0.643362820148468,
0.5299508571624756,
-0.03137856721878052,
-0.5466588139533997,
0.2853294014930725,
-0.08371592313051224,
-0.21855325996875763,
0.5826215744018555,
0.41434594988822937,
-0.07690247893333435,
0.06412184238433838,
-0.6429700255393982,
-0.5474540591239929,
1.410884976387024,
-0.002811702433973551,
-0.28186169266700745,
-0.16991733014583588,
-0.19130009412765503,
0.5143867135047913,
-0.9314786791801453,
0.3471605181694031,
0.6806615591049194,
0.5658255815505981,
0.03029400296509266,
-0.636936604976654,
0.19051675498485565,
-0.21893101930618286,
0.014614350162446499,
-0.13076604902744293,
-0.5362695455551147,
0.7123304009437561,
-0.020602498203516006,
-0.12963616847991943,
0.2208194136619568,
0.8267076015472412,
0.7338827252388,
0.37419745326042175,
0.3392421007156372,
0.031170904636383057,
0.9139953851699829,
0.020791858434677124,
0.8812742829322815,
-0.5583249926567078,
0.09444769471883774,
0.9913453459739685,
-0.3588438928127289,
0.9361152648925781,
0.6961233615875244,
0.4219452738761902,
0.6680721044540405,
0.6300439238548279,
-0.10754195600748062,
0.6483216285705566,
-0.1760895997285843,
-0.031856659799814224,
-0.19702264666557312,
-0.05712934955954552,
-0.2002146989107132,
0.7179409265518188,
0.37281927466392517,
-0.37112680077552795,
-0.1628258228302002,
-0.09091469645500183,
0.12101778388023376,
0.07315154373645782,
-0.057364195585250854,
0.7924311757087708,
0.06962797045707703,
-1.0860331058502197,
0.5038020014762878,
-0.03139438107609749,
0.6473215818405151,
-0.3484160602092743,
-0.14747726917266846,
-0.2905815839767456,
0.016780784353613853,
-0.18525129556655884,
-0.4271886348724365,
0.17228570580482483,
0.2078460305929184,
-0.02738405577838421,
-0.41625040769577026,
0.6151514649391174,
-0.3139421343803406,
-0.2388189733028412,
0.31281769275665283,
0.7813313603401184,
0.11362382769584656,
0.19790025055408478,
-0.429922878742218,
0.13284887373447418,
0.03824411705136299,
-0.6510875821113586,
0.17707587778568268,
0.41415587067604065,
-0.19206728041172028,
0.3807695508003235,
0.6367477178573608,
0.16163723170757294,
-0.14922069013118744,
-0.1657821089029312,
0.6154589653015137,
-0.7699753642082214,
-0.5465239882469177,
-1.008336067199707,
0.4141615331172943,
-0.489259272813797,
-0.3928872346878052,
0.6646466851234436,
0.5598214864730835,
0.6681346297264099,
0.2674303650856018,
0.7654493451118469,
-0.22716210782527924,
0.1506589949131012,
-0.5712460875511169,
1.0308077335357666,
-0.7147480845451355,
0.46018335223197937,
-0.31651613116264343,
-1.0498443841934204,
-0.4059906005859375,
0.8133711218833923,
-0.2637363374233246,
0.21485967934131622,
0.8979718685150146,
0.5602177977561951,
0.05837538093328476,
0.09556400775909424,
0.15570297837257385,
0.20522810518741608,
0.4579404890537262,
0.28976520895957947,
0.42662182450294495,
-0.3350061774253845,
0.4040127992630005,
-0.1546453833580017,
-0.31145691871643066,
-0.2796463966369629,
-0.8744454383850098,
-1.0848578214645386,
-0.5735363960266113,
-0.1288028359413147,
-0.13615472614765167,
0.25796014070510864,
0.8940006494522095,
0.576813817024231,
-0.7883355021476746,
-0.4148090183734894,
-0.09351272881031036,
0.39643990993499756,
-0.083686962723732,
-0.2905617952346802,
0.5309855341911316,
-0.5496180057525635,
-0.707857072353363,
0.7074844241142273,
0.052102286368608475,
-0.3526241183280945,
-0.1185448095202446,
-0.12880507111549377,
-0.37185487151145935,
-0.0362638384103775,
0.8751534819602966,
-0.09420373290777206,
-0.680827260017395,
-0.5013982653617859,
0.025042349472641945,
-0.37057530879974365,
0.2724629342556,
0.4956260919570923,
-0.644184410572052,
0.037765923887491226,
0.35465624928474426,
0.8803703188896179,
0.23155732452869415,
0.1611691415309906,
0.4589129090309143,
-0.733200192451477,
-0.08686767518520355,
0.009826541878283024,
0.04142006114125252,
0.2644655406475067,
-0.34770750999450684,
0.7860910296440125,
0.3289601802825928,
-0.6917530298233032,
-1.091044545173645,
-0.05236310884356499,
-0.8305237889289856,
-0.6086929440498352,
1.186886191368103,
0.27771326899528503,
-0.541491687297821,
0.19237034022808075,
-0.08142443001270294,
0.2794775068759918,
-0.4644818902015686,
1.0518611669540405,
0.6235618591308594,
-0.2808288633823395,
0.061247438192367554,
-0.9922689199447632,
0.6902026534080505,
0.485014408826828,
-0.9039420485496521,
-0.08584226667881012,
0.5934668779373169,
-0.06751316785812378,
0.22913703322410583,
0.5173075199127197,
0.27027058601379395,
0.11728275567293167,
-0.26514407992362976,
-0.011770161800086498,
0.06441505253314972,
-0.644965648651123,
-0.09197092801332474,
0.6434940695762634,
-0.004155739676207304,
0.2729173004627228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04383v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04383v1
|
Exploring the Latest LLMs for Leaderboard Extraction
| 2024-06-06T05:54:45 | 2024-06-06T05:54:45 |
Salomon Kabongo, Jennifer D'Souza, Sören Auer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have opened new
avenues for automating complex tasks in AI research. This paper investigates
the efficacy of different LLMs-Mistral 7B, Llama-2, GPT-4-Turbo and GPT-4.o in
extracting leaderboard information from empirical AI research articles. We
explore three types of contextual inputs to the models: DocTAET (Document
Title, Abstract, Experimental Setup, and Tabular Information), DocREC (Results,
Experiments, and Conclusions), and DocFULL (entire document). Our comprehensive
study evaluates the performance of these models in generating (Task, Dataset,
Metric, Score) quadruples from research papers. The findings reveal significant
insights into the strengths and limitations of each model and context type,
providing valuable guidance for future AI research automation efforts.
|
[
-0.06800875067710876,
-1.2983496189117432,
0.9194689393043518,
0.24117068946361542,
-0.06440071016550064,
0.10711836814880371,
-0.299588143825531,
-0.31450679898262024,
0.018078863620758057,
0.18942686915397644,
-0.22944988310337067,
-0.7549406886100769,
-1.0385218858718872,
0.1643361747264862,
-0.7201040983200073,
1.1375364065170288,
-0.17704927921295166,
-0.014918920584022999,
-0.3065894842147827,
0.35486558079719543,
-0.7444592118263245,
-0.5576072931289673,
-0.5114139318466187,
-0.44686517119407654,
0.5746747851371765,
0.564011812210083,
0.36094269156455994,
0.7524145841598511,
0.8100001811981201,
0.360377699136734,
0.07933490723371506,
0.11087702959775925,
-0.42911577224731445,
0.3619164824485779,
-0.03547236695885658,
-0.34054580330848694,
-1.0986011028289795,
0.4640105068683624,
0.5870320796966553,
0.2429979294538498,
-0.3904894292354584,
0.3068980872631073,
0.14215019345283508,
0.23205843567848206,
-0.20971646904945374,
0.6111252903938293,
-0.7037340402603149,
-0.19021330773830414,
-0.2118920236825943,
-0.23314212262630463,
-0.3300356864929199,
-0.3896232545375824,
0.1494808942079544,
-0.5109797716140747,
0.03878168761730194,
-0.08891873806715012,
0.9423263669013977,
0.12401323765516281,
-0.29897138476371765,
-0.7039191722869873,
-0.5618521571159363,
0.7374180555343628,
-0.7708250880241394,
0.08527805656194687,
0.43173032999038696,
0.47214967012405396,
-0.09638003259897232,
-1.1608245372772217,
-0.41252434253692627,
-0.08590226620435715,
0.04324342682957649,
0.21580447256565094,
-0.17962947487831116,
-0.19299092888832092,
0.07084717601537704,
0.25057747960090637,
-0.2837879955768585,
0.6077608466148376,
-0.2871890664100647,
0.34731584787368774,
0.7802597880363464,
0.30120840668678284,
0.20693568885326385,
-0.22637604176998138,
-0.136065274477005,
-0.21830235421657562,
-0.5570921301841736,
0.059920165687799454,
-0.12250266969203949,
0.1872093826532364,
-0.029121898114681244,
0.3449971675872803,
0.18168210983276367,
0.44480252265930176,
-0.07799148559570312,
-0.5253461599349976,
0.06936021894216537,
-0.41949164867401123,
-0.20879602432250977,
-0.27593475580215454,
0.8046109080314636,
0.3481599986553192,
0.13823683559894562,
-0.4648023843765259,
-0.32106807827949524,
-0.26721614599227905,
0.12336309254169464,
-0.8067763447761536,
-0.25107085704803467,
0.1742943674325943,
-0.4687948226928711,
-0.5055121183395386,
0.30273884534835815,
-0.8690376877784729,
-0.34315410256385803,
-0.3122291564941406,
0.2979975938796997,
-0.15290004014968872,
-0.12758296728134155,
-0.43141475319862366,
-0.3409900963306427,
0.6258642673492432,
0.7144501805305481,
-0.7969217300415039,
0.12973442673683167,
0.9635003209114075,
0.9495136737823486,
-1.1916130781173706,
-0.22545334696769714,
-0.6907424926757812,
-0.03871432691812515,
-0.5107895135879517,
0.8484839797019958,
-0.6089043617248535,
-0.6122111082077026,
-0.05338152498006821,
-0.03819507360458374,
-0.26351600885391235,
-0.6880166530609131,
0.5462253093719482,
-0.682280957698822,
0.10434763878583908,
-0.22737239301204681,
-0.6166308522224426,
0.04019731655716896,
0.3225873112678528,
-0.6723050475120544,
1.1348950862884521,
-0.2066754251718521,
-0.32268884778022766,
0.2089773416519165,
-0.7621728181838989,
-0.393271267414093,
0.07466784864664078,
-0.6124566793441772,
-0.33664190769195557,
0.010209297761321068,
0.29249072074890137,
0.6915749907493591,
-0.5783576369285583,
0.5948854684829712,
0.07296155393123627,
-0.06842762231826782,
0.25322455167770386,
-0.4862542748451233,
0.5795371532440186,
0.10155235975980759,
-0.3898870646953583,
0.23896434903144836,
-0.7230780124664307,
-0.12761521339416504,
0.16877470910549164,
-0.6014639735221863,
0.038287024945020676,
0.17851164937019348,
0.11773484200239182,
0.16401295363903046,
0.4918878972530365,
-0.37714025378227234,
0.1366235613822937,
0.30921417474746704,
0.493429571390152,
1.2112492322921753,
0.0393792986869812,
0.15734587609767914,
-0.2618212401866913,
0.844839870929718,
-0.30762237310409546,
-0.20040737092494965,
-0.1771463304758072,
-0.6091820001602173,
-0.309227854013443,
-0.6468740105628967,
0.51579350233078,
0.5624573230743408,
-0.343972384929657,
0.4641081988811493,
-0.24810390174388885,
-0.6363730430603027,
-0.40890389680862427,
0.17351871728897095,
0.17343516647815704,
0.7150213122367859,
0.22660405933856964,
-0.11726541072130203,
-0.37789177894592285,
-0.7596606016159058,
-0.09428779035806656,
-0.107850082218647,
0.17570506036281586,
0.29682978987693787,
0.5518668293952942,
-0.12108003348112106,
1.0826706886291504,
-0.6151471138000488,
-0.2414354383945465,
-0.3555122911930084,
0.2536522448062897,
0.41795438528060913,
0.2724350690841675,
0.4867807626724243,
-0.6713286638259888,
-0.576155424118042,
-0.08538971096277237,
-1.1623612642288208,
-0.1619092971086502,
-0.06288867443799973,
-0.10628284513950348,
-0.09814461320638657,
0.617115318775177,
-0.7815672159194946,
0.5390464067459106,
0.4420351982116699,
0.001224834006279707,
0.5842010378837585,
0.02626435086131096,
-0.016614330932497978,
-0.8655583262443542,
0.26461997628211975,
0.039829548448324203,
-0.25452888011932373,
-0.6636309027671814,
-0.03235062211751938,
-0.04665813967585564,
0.16326896846294403,
0.04467957094311714,
0.5722917914390564,
-0.6549204587936401,
-0.2489503026008606,
-0.3300551176071167,
0.47648143768310547,
-0.12352354824542999,
0.20125722885131836,
-0.002648006659001112,
0.9460345506668091,
0.3797684907913208,
-0.32375863194465637,
0.27442410588264465,
0.3373493254184723,
-0.24836428463459015,
0.12544798851013184,
-0.6885005831718445,
0.2126193344593048,
-0.13709864020347595,
0.23566679656505585,
-1.1495198011398315,
-0.18249206244945526,
-0.08659594506025314,
-0.4724816679954529,
0.24886511266231537,
0.21694737672805786,
-0.6420698761940002,
-0.08832133561372757,
-0.35611215233802795,
0.028986545279622078,
0.7599138617515564,
-0.5032070875167847,
0.5635404586791992,
0.7024518251419067,
-0.6307096481323242,
-0.2266829013824463,
-0.40329086780548096,
0.2990683317184448,
-0.36062902212142944,
-0.16590645909309387,
0.23852163553237915,
-0.23454974591732025,
-0.48024195432662964,
-0.19988766312599182,
-0.020214740186929703,
-0.03782876580953598,
0.4575062394142151,
0.4456610083580017,
0.47574615478515625,
-0.26683399081230164,
-0.1154770627617836,
-0.1300007402896881,
0.09149352461099625,
0.1452498733997345,
0.17564836144447327,
0.3668355345726013,
-0.04774252697825432,
-0.09749554842710495,
-0.5417194366455078,
0.3536912500858307,
0.47541677951812744,
-0.26093268394470215,
0.4639517664909363,
0.5036177039146423,
-0.20109209418296814,
-0.288849413394928,
-0.43650227785110474,
-0.19415807723999023,
-0.47040095925331116,
0.5754263401031494,
-0.15946385264396667,
-0.7192001938819885,
0.41087806224823,
-0.11940501630306244,
0.4251379370689392,
0.6565260291099548,
0.8178380727767944,
-0.10780912637710571,
0.9110062718391418,
0.6386751532554626,
-0.22945119440555573,
0.4712073504924774,
-0.24369804561138153,
0.07874095439910889,
-0.708034873008728,
-0.2971571385860443,
-0.6722438335418701,
-0.10518946498632431,
-0.3975037932395935,
-0.1458844393491745,
0.5378127098083496,
0.07202987372875214,
0.19982706010341644,
-0.06704909354448318,
-0.4471878707408905,
0.32754552364349365,
0.4145479202270508,
-0.21858429908752441,
0.5189894437789917,
0.2144918590784073,
0.18533410131931305,
0.044702209532260895,
-0.6847178339958191,
-0.8027077317237854,
1.2761709690093994,
0.3694048523902893,
0.694724977016449,
0.12895572185516357,
0.4985714256763458,
0.5833638310432434,
0.7373780012130737,
-0.7274255752563477,
0.6075348854064941,
-0.08641979843378067,
-0.5438507199287415,
-0.3409728705883026,
-0.11961854994297028,
-1.015404224395752,
0.4418814778327942,
-0.027057206258177757,
-0.7230426073074341,
-0.017900384962558746,
-0.2105131298303604,
-0.18290311098098755,
0.050679370760917664,
-0.2801189422607422,
0.5789855718612671,
-0.3504736125469208,
-0.19779542088508606,
0.04263530671596527,
-0.3973400592803955,
0.2623496353626251,
-0.40095412731170654,
0.3491789996623993,
-0.09403107315301895,
0.02321174554526806,
1.0202357769012451,
-0.12336698174476624,
0.7703096866607666,
-0.0810774713754654,
-0.3465965688228607,
0.17295536398887634,
-0.17673034965991974,
0.5860750079154968,
-0.01092060748487711,
-0.32110539078712463,
0.35467976331710815,
-0.28070375323295593,
0.016219722107052803,
-0.34938758611679077,
0.6100051999092102,
-0.9335524439811707,
-0.8822944760322571,
-0.4579542875289917,
-0.590258002281189,
-0.14910143613815308,
0.2794807553291321,
0.07368968427181244,
0.32896968722343445,
-0.2773335576057434,
0.2659960091114044,
0.24312442541122437,
0.09688544273376465,
0.7081056237220764,
0.48152273893356323,
-0.15621818602085114,
-0.27222007513046265,
0.5894116163253784,
0.24487251043319702,
-0.17448298633098602,
0.12460167706012726,
0.004069668706506491,
0.011605619452893734,
-0.9150580167770386,
-0.21673202514648438,
0.25121307373046875,
-0.7080079913139343,
-0.19438381493091583,
-0.6137493848800659,
-0.49193722009658813,
-0.7009371519088745,
-0.07905244082212448,
-0.09883029013872147,
-0.5508075952529907,
-0.5116211771965027,
-0.5203786492347717,
0.16060401499271393,
1.0995416641235352,
-0.11633448302745819,
0.47339433431625366,
-0.6624672412872314,
0.28605732321739197,
0.2887938916683197,
-0.19119921326637268,
0.3025893270969391,
-0.5101004242897034,
-0.3125052750110626,
-0.4239317774772644,
-0.3812194764614105,
-1.0077710151672363,
0.48711225390434265,
0.14981897175312042,
1.0506091117858887,
0.24149653315544128,
-0.3753540813922882,
0.5695587992668152,
-0.6097707748413086,
0.9936143755912781,
-0.11484771221876144,
-0.42192816734313965,
0.3773822486400604,
-0.3246752619743347,
0.06444590538740158,
0.4461040198802948,
0.5696633458137512,
-0.05865361914038658,
-0.22625280916690826,
-0.4113824963569641,
-0.8384876251220703,
0.6779731512069702,
0.25563299655914307,
-0.3166990578174591,
-0.040963314473629,
0.6087917685508728,
0.41958996653556824,
0.3699286878108978,
-0.46166059374809265,
-0.0711803063750267,
0.10167018324136734,
-0.2827926576137543,
-0.22033217549324036,
-0.23616589605808258,
-0.12425211817026138,
-0.08334790915250778,
0.5779640078544617,
0.08960282057523727,
0.08170079439878464,
0.1765129268169403,
-0.3219691216945648,
0.2157326191663742,
0.03734592720866203,
0.4257408082485199,
0.9992957711219788,
-0.3265874683856964,
-0.012750442139804363,
-0.0781886950135231,
-0.5409433245658875,
-0.0859910175204277,
0.23564673960208893,
-0.20414814352989197,
0.009265444241464138,
0.8851426243782043,
0.4743339419364929,
-0.2554030120372772,
-0.6242407560348511,
0.45904597640037537,
-0.19106245040893555,
0.028247976675629616,
-0.5020928382873535,
0.20628198981285095,
-0.05799739062786102,
0.23451529443264008,
0.6276085376739502,
-0.521854817867279,
0.1845538318157196,
-0.6428061723709106,
0.4011124074459076,
0.44807177782058716,
-0.10979869216680527,
-0.5904406309127808,
0.655257523059845,
0.17260995507240295,
-0.3942815363407135,
0.5304971933364868,
0.10572772473096848,
-0.2817479372024536,
0.8676387071609497,
0.582850992679596,
0.7683559060096741,
-0.12944726645946503,
0.09958850592374802,
0.33783406019210815,
0.057091400027275085,
-0.1015649065375328,
-0.12713655829429626,
-0.20549306273460388,
-0.5366314053535461,
-0.19290104508399963,
-0.5106568932533264,
-0.5051842927932739,
0.1628953069448471,
-0.7211560010910034,
-0.036111682653427124,
-0.41142022609710693,
-0.5007864832878113,
0.22277171909809113,
0.006916994694620371,
-0.7342988848686218,
-0.1565030962228775,
0.046886954456567764,
0.6518645286560059,
-0.684033989906311,
0.9816249012947083,
0.7228066921234131,
-0.3587389588356018,
-0.7019644379615784,
-0.1740504801273346,
0.20145972073078156,
-0.9059956073760986,
0.8596404194831848,
-0.06105038896203041,
-0.1075448989868164,
0.09765711426734924,
-0.7682083249092102,
-0.74240642786026,
1.5571250915527344,
-0.21299296617507935,
-0.3946400582790375,
-0.549768328666687,
0.0036412866320461035,
0.3593771159648895,
-0.7481768131256104,
0.45665091276168823,
0.8217297792434692,
0.5653896331787109,
-0.243989035487175,
-0.8959822058677673,
0.03994375839829445,
-0.31865185499191284,
-0.16782715916633606,
-0.4226624369621277,
-0.6348751783370972,
1.2573381662368774,
0.09537887573242188,
-0.11375722289085388,
0.230576291680336,
0.6523424386978149,
0.7320167422294617,
0.17886850237846375,
0.16560500860214233,
0.12377375364303589,
0.8358128070831299,
0.15125088393688202,
0.937143087387085,
-0.12411842495203018,
0.13629859685897827,
1.156945824623108,
-0.46116647124290466,
0.7947776317596436,
0.36914893984794617,
0.06493610888719559,
0.6901838779449463,
0.5877751708030701,
-0.2286708801984787,
0.4622497260570526,
-0.16647574305534363,
0.34488311409950256,
-0.1170169934630394,
0.0801486000418663,
-0.3388393223285675,
0.6426230072975159,
0.46796512603759766,
-0.32691991329193115,
-0.361968994140625,
-0.2479119747877121,
0.5321067571640015,
-0.1481941193342209,
-0.018524417653679848,
0.9556406736373901,
0.2988736033439636,
-1.0146465301513672,
0.3720797896385193,
0.29694420099258423,
0.5432289242744446,
-0.5070696473121643,
-0.36269062757492065,
-0.5054768323898315,
0.033005036413669586,
-0.013010322116315365,
-0.6266668438911438,
-0.24270665645599365,
0.42491471767425537,
-0.10385381430387497,
-0.299203097820282,
0.5674923062324524,
-0.22040238976478577,
-0.3436235189437866,
0.19876666367053986,
0.8410356044769287,
0.28439605236053467,
0.19376498460769653,
-0.6370368003845215,
0.1851564645767212,
-0.14080284535884857,
-0.5176879167556763,
0.2813434302806854,
0.4667816162109375,
-0.12543444335460663,
0.4131494164466858,
0.527762770652771,
0.35228025913238525,
0.07461436092853546,
-0.25742918252944946,
0.803101122379303,
-0.7952650189399719,
-0.4458916485309601,
-0.9486005306243896,
0.26045992970466614,
-0.3097193241119385,
-0.35309553146362305,
1.0384548902511597,
0.5612210631370544,
0.14234836399555206,
0.26465874910354614,
0.9280746579170227,
0.08034317940473557,
0.37045326828956604,
-0.5631011724472046,
0.8319687843322754,
-0.4797421395778656,
0.37739670276641846,
-0.16722071170806885,
-0.8004185557365417,
-0.07250307500362396,
0.3973029553890228,
-0.16619133949279785,
-0.014039548113942146,
0.6995013356208801,
0.46214228868484497,
0.10127639770507812,
0.03968818485736847,
0.0831463634967804,
0.5290151238441467,
0.9247288703918457,
0.20521824061870575,
0.6979904770851135,
-0.2331855148077011,
0.3093748092651367,
0.23535065352916718,
-0.5685043931007385,
-0.3030792474746704,
-0.8612443804740906,
-0.9346364736557007,
-0.4925127923488617,
-0.23441921174526215,
-0.05414407700300217,
0.2248808741569519,
0.5347124338150024,
0.7142677903175354,
-0.6057192087173462,
-0.4536259174346924,
0.24289847910404205,
0.0962475836277008,
0.055179476737976074,
-0.2457594871520996,
0.8176413178443909,
-0.3701588809490204,
-0.6029775142669678,
0.6453680396080017,
0.03581596165895462,
-0.2851259708404541,
-0.11991842836141586,
0.00735665624961257,
-0.3258722126483917,
0.07683924585580826,
0.6867727041244507,
0.07845819741487503,
-0.6027235984802246,
-0.09243873506784439,
0.07036794722080231,
-0.3461371064186096,
0.3257787525653839,
0.5964251160621643,
-0.6296003460884094,
-0.016866959631443024,
0.543059229850769,
0.7046632170677185,
0.5605400204658508,
0.39086729288101196,
0.48983970284461975,
-0.29479727149009705,
-0.26392000913619995,
-0.047695454210042953,
0.1845265030860901,
0.22081345319747925,
-0.1678125262260437,
0.7377238273620605,
0.21961025893688202,
-0.7458815574645996,
-0.9101357460021973,
-0.1970224529504776,
-0.9428915977478027,
-0.4955638349056244,
1.2782381772994995,
-0.0795726552605629,
-0.32767945528030396,
0.1994198113679886,
-0.0008638394647277892,
0.1511409878730774,
-0.4685862958431244,
0.8267351388931274,
0.9104399085044861,
-0.41337525844573975,
0.0011019743978977203,
-1.0118145942687988,
0.4220224916934967,
0.2528865337371826,
-1.1014002561569214,
-0.1387902796268463,
0.5658026933670044,
0.17972137033939362,
-0.012367187067866325,
0.8930612802505493,
-0.4287573993206024,
0.1393364518880844,
-0.12340355664491653,
-0.030610209330916405,
-0.1200999990105629,
-0.530779242515564,
-0.4002644717693329,
0.5581287741661072,
0.2990376651287079,
0.0908064991235733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03749v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03749v1
|
NAP^2: A Benchmark for Naturalness and Privacy-Preserving Text Rewriting by Learning from Human
| 2024-06-06T05:07:44 | 2024-06-06T05:07:44 |
Shuo Huang, William MacLean, Xiaoxi Kang, Anqi Wu, Lizhen Qu, Qiongkai Xu, Zhuang Li, Xingliang Yuan, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Increasing concerns about privacy leakage issues in academia and industry
arise when employing NLP models from third-party providers to process sensitive
texts. To protect privacy before sending sensitive data to those models, we
suggest sanitizing sensitive text using two common strategies used by humans:
i) deleting sensitive expressions, and ii) obscuring sensitive details by
abstracting them. To explore the issues and develop a tool for text rewriting,
we curate the first corpus, coined NAP^2, through both crowdsourcing and the
use of large language models (LLMs). Compared to the prior works based on
differential privacy, which lead to a sharp drop in information utility and
unnatural texts, the human-inspired approaches result in more natural rewrites
and offer an improved balance between privacy protection and data utility, as
demonstrated by our extensive experiments.
|
[
0.14259669184684753,
-0.8231808543205261,
0.21754147112369537,
0.17297223210334778,
-0.23674608767032623,
0.1960863173007965,
-0.20954465866088867,
-0.7611757516860962,
-0.21774473786354065,
0.7458045482635498,
-0.33180126547813416,
-0.3763044774532318,
-0.28246423602104187,
0.14367114007472992,
-0.4183075726032257,
1.0234192609786987,
0.11641936004161835,
-0.1060294434428215,
-0.17410048842430115,
0.2582828402519226,
0.22600573301315308,
-0.669573187828064,
-0.6745135188102722,
-0.23285409808158875,
0.7296659350395203,
0.37000012397766113,
0.6160795092582703,
0.5684257745742798,
0.5733559131622314,
0.2180178314447403,
-0.2727140486240387,
0.12615622580051422,
-0.6853325963020325,
0.13564559817314148,
-0.3646719753742218,
-0.7641387581825256,
-0.33008643984794617,
0.17516344785690308,
0.7855903506278992,
0.4908885359764099,
-0.21605512499809265,
0.3455680012702942,
0.08097419142723083,
1.134874939918518,
-0.7792280912399292,
-0.1726907342672348,
-0.7880155444145203,
0.22111406922340393,
-0.22390921413898468,
-0.05981509014964104,
-0.5254751443862915,
-0.7459743618965149,
-0.12435837835073471,
-0.45970866084098816,
0.7422524690628052,
0.13915452361106873,
0.937726616859436,
0.3692260980606079,
-0.04018586874008179,
0.3034490644931793,
-0.7215651869773865,
0.8648642897605896,
-0.5690070390701294,
0.20376603305339813,
0.9729786515235901,
0.2388906329870224,
-0.2392973005771637,
-0.9541035294532776,
-0.6305845379829407,
0.05472390726208687,
-0.12399812042713165,
-0.18496224284172058,
-0.3079584538936615,
-0.2740452289581299,
0.005914837121963501,
0.3272537887096405,
-0.5108265280723572,
0.22044214606285095,
-0.7142637372016907,
-0.3972441554069519,
1.1462488174438477,
-0.006597240921109915,
0.12920355796813965,
-0.2982105314731598,
-0.7757764458656311,
-0.112693190574646,
-1.044010043144226,
0.01821613311767578,
0.5664310455322266,
-0.04693203791975975,
0.08821505308151245,
0.4432074725627899,
-0.2734343409538269,
0.331981360912323,
-0.4209008514881134,
0.21757057309150696,
0.2753215730190277,
-0.35910916328430176,
-0.21011638641357422,
-0.26392096281051636,
0.7720838189125061,
0.6221646070480347,
0.38087451457977295,
-0.5192564725875854,
0.06121145188808441,
0.05824998393654823,
0.5958237051963806,
-0.7144358158111572,
-0.4166274070739746,
0.16309945285320282,
-0.6608681082725525,
-0.5567207336425781,
-0.07511533796787262,
-0.916412353515625,
-0.592268168926239,
-0.2652009427547455,
0.033807676285505295,
-0.24188880622386932,
-0.33444541692733765,
0.13855476677417755,
-0.24379785358905792,
0.3848733901977539,
0.197758749127388,
-1.0834143161773682,
0.6630868315696716,
1.1698451042175293,
0.6666300296783447,
-0.22509309649467468,
-0.25799041986465454,
-0.1448051631450653,
-0.054728325456380844,
-0.45136943459510803,
0.7151595950126648,
-0.20297221839427948,
-0.46159595251083374,
-0.09937571734189987,
-0.08579535782337189,
0.18192170560359955,
-0.6664262413978577,
0.7910272479057312,
-0.5189672112464905,
0.41445136070251465,
-0.04899373650550842,
-0.6307181119918823,
-0.25172412395477295,
0.05383347347378731,
-0.6121178865432739,
1.021056056022644,
0.19296513497829437,
-0.5581814050674438,
0.302774041891098,
-0.550258994102478,
-0.2797808349132538,
-0.014998803846538067,
0.03565534949302673,
-0.7583543062210083,
0.19463837146759033,
-0.21443073451519012,
0.23633700609207153,
-0.10685820132493973,
0.15415354073047638,
0.21345435082912445,
-0.1868688315153122,
0.38978609442710876,
-0.47804903984069824,
0.8677451014518738,
0.17142273485660553,
-0.26121991872787476,
0.05839238315820694,
-0.7033553123474121,
0.3603523075580597,
0.3133338987827301,
-0.306591659784317,
-0.23775839805603027,
0.08839335292577744,
0.24127839505672455,
-0.0023268461227416992,
0.20575249195098877,
-0.6540845036506653,
-0.06500151008367538,
-0.5683841109275818,
0.6903446912765503,
0.6752999424934387,
0.03374851122498512,
0.5805710554122925,
-0.5557683706283569,
0.427532821893692,
-0.5543296933174133,
0.23626843094825745,
0.035689130425453186,
-0.7732720375061035,
-0.1314452737569809,
-0.05648023635149002,
0.40654224157333374,
0.48573148250579834,
0.2082962840795517,
0.3899238407611847,
-0.028078895062208176,
-0.6451228857040405,
-0.6364786624908447,
0.2795230448246002,
0.7981431484222412,
0.48261862993240356,
0.3186936676502228,
-0.10098441690206528,
-0.38758206367492676,
-1.2515122890472412,
-0.7306730151176453,
-0.05448952689766884,
-0.35847193002700806,
0.36579740047454834,
0.119395911693573,
-0.29238325357437134,
0.771762490272522,
-0.49486181139945984,
-0.2367117702960968,
-0.005315450951457024,
0.18391691148281097,
-0.44297489523887634,
0.6342878937721252,
0.3234654366970062,
-1.0310825109481812,
-0.38006559014320374,
-0.48462972044944763,
-0.5586085319519043,
-0.06136227026581764,
0.14353212714195251,
-0.45162397623062134,
0.3208134174346924,
0.6296445727348328,
-0.5023475885391235,
0.5998162627220154,
0.43303531408309937,
-0.47597259283065796,
0.5602018237113953,
-0.2891441285610199,
-0.09981042891740799,
-0.9552527070045471,
0.2049291878938675,
-0.2836681008338928,
-0.5205184817314148,
-0.7680157423019409,
0.30149349570274353,
0.19660277664661407,
-0.18125776946544647,
-0.6154375076293945,
0.5209129452705383,
-0.5458258390426636,
0.01802186109125614,
-0.4560955762863159,
0.34637483954429626,
0.5103642344474792,
0.29379257559776306,
0.05854356288909912,
0.6022937297821045,
0.08306489139795303,
-0.4753686487674713,
-0.061441365629434586,
0.6625909805297852,
-0.4408823549747467,
0.11208146810531616,
-0.7008512020111084,
0.6448853015899658,
-0.07606463134288788,
0.41748490929603577,
-0.7106432914733887,
-0.3082496225833893,
0.30852362513542175,
-0.589357852935791,
0.20848868787288666,
-0.0034599285572767258,
-0.7106691002845764,
0.14202071726322174,
-0.6206420063972473,
0.3837384283542633,
0.6230125427246094,
-0.5276000499725342,
0.2338809072971344,
0.592224657535553,
-0.32261931896209717,
-0.49009495973587036,
-0.8948431611061096,
0.5144717693328857,
-0.144823357462883,
-0.7369111180305481,
0.832930862903595,
0.23525460064411163,
-0.35348373651504517,
0.019510619342327118,
-0.04640491306781769,
-0.30420640110969543,
0.3935578167438507,
0.3086795210838318,
0.34637224674224854,
0.0655350610613823,
0.17919671535491943,
-0.030079901218414307,
-0.45177891850471497,
0.2999655604362488,
0.23596926033496857,
0.48000866174697876,
-0.023274142295122147,
0.20801512897014618,
-0.9455800652503967,
0.6870195269584656,
0.06643925607204437,
-0.26686862111091614,
0.6329158544540405,
0.3426744043827057,
-0.4956158399581909,
-0.3054182529449463,
-0.4391358494758606,
-0.39479854702949524,
-0.487178236246109,
0.17582932114601135,
0.19974513351917267,
-0.8503097891807556,
0.18028929829597473,
-0.12429504096508026,
0.3403739631175995,
0.22107453644275665,
0.43844059109687805,
-0.02115805447101593,
0.3304615020751953,
0.7708454132080078,
0.10506988316774368,
0.3890397548675537,
-0.13830851018428802,
0.3819037973880768,
-0.9686800837516785,
-0.4584021270275116,
-0.6637483835220337,
-0.5679579377174377,
-0.7265259623527527,
-0.6482558846473694,
-0.1808500587940216,
0.2548202574253082,
-0.049363873898983,
0.4064013361930847,
-0.806781530380249,
0.8064547777175903,
0.7561894655227661,
0.28461214900016785,
0.22883394360542297,
-0.1340305507183075,
0.585042417049408,
-0.09391503781080246,
-0.21795114874839783,
-1.0344624519348145,
1.278585433959961,
0.253057062625885,
0.6039482355117798,
0.18640992045402527,
0.8722250461578369,
0.28318971395492554,
0.26567649841308594,
-0.3236379027366638,
0.5293282866477966,
-0.19717413187026978,
-1.0619601011276245,
-0.46272772550582886,
-0.3052712678909302,
-1.16219961643219,
0.2700149714946747,
-0.22161100804805756,
-1.00358247756958,
0.1401151418685913,
0.3314323127269745,
-0.5253341197967529,
0.2560446560382843,
-0.9732697606086731,
0.8765971064567566,
0.06925059854984283,
-0.807136595249176,
-0.33557698130607605,
-1.0051624774932861,
0.3254290223121643,
0.04526469483971596,
0.0687621608376503,
-0.4239543378353119,
-0.420099139213562,
0.737518310546875,
-0.24785903096199036,
0.9812997579574585,
-0.1402122974395752,
-0.03060300648212433,
0.3396601974964142,
0.2920977473258972,
0.5167140960693359,
0.19435270130634308,
-0.20078501105308533,
0.32904401421546936,
-0.16847382485866547,
-0.45941993594169617,
-0.39379507303237915,
0.5909539461135864,
-0.5907803177833557,
-0.40813660621643066,
-0.19379423558712006,
-0.15409280359745026,
-0.09051325172185898,
0.1816990077495575,
0.4154459536075592,
0.12074579298496246,
-0.5005077123641968,
0.3714677393436432,
0.6283040046691895,
-0.23969604074954987,
0.4831474721431732,
0.5894368886947632,
-0.20871348679065704,
-0.14500170946121216,
0.5814229249954224,
-0.4053749144077301,
0.3390401005744934,
0.4904285967350006,
0.5523361563682556,
-0.48125389218330383,
-0.4424717128276825,
-0.1324024796485901,
0.05015815421938896,
-0.3755163550376892,
-0.24689273536205292,
-0.7065362334251404,
-0.20800073444843292,
-0.4330999255180359,
-0.27554115653038025,
-0.47093576192855835,
-0.7778145670890808,
-0.23981671035289764,
-0.35533154010772705,
0.43478646874427795,
0.45270052552223206,
-0.2591479420661926,
0.0249223243445158,
-0.7518845200538635,
0.8368167877197266,
0.20968256890773773,
0.42987385392189026,
-0.35311776399612427,
-0.2407800406217575,
0.2708987891674042,
-0.12177394330501556,
-0.31038615107536316,
-0.5537818670272827,
0.3891005516052246,
0.3301450312137604,
0.24416010081768036,
0.2684257924556732,
0.2604367733001709,
-0.10322337597608566,
-0.7291693687438965,
0.8704511523246765,
0.033427894115448,
-0.6802942752838135,
0.511405348777771,
-0.1612732708454132,
-0.17970366775989532,
0.891762375831604,
0.017236726358532906,
-0.5969545245170593,
-0.1956009566783905,
-0.8939154148101807,
-1.2132186889648438,
0.5227352380752563,
0.46827682852745056,
0.4131297767162323,
0.11946556717157364,
0.4677930772304535,
0.5479052662849426,
0.30922865867614746,
-0.45182520151138306,
-0.11458291858434677,
0.0030571420211344957,
0.23943449556827545,
-0.1411028951406479,
-0.5748021006584167,
-0.21694524586200714,
-0.03456903249025345,
0.5099612474441528,
0.3673192858695984,
0.30462485551834106,
0.35652366280555725,
0.03114934079349041,
-0.06412942707538605,
0.34403297305107117,
0.5894602537155151,
0.42016205191612244,
0.005725086200982332,
0.20708799362182617,
-0.2714206576347351,
-0.5441953539848328,
0.05953788757324219,
-0.1309760957956314,
-0.48603346943855286,
-0.06597289443016052,
0.07489386945962906,
0.3125981092453003,
0.4679672122001648,
-0.6679668426513672,
0.4222981333732605,
0.004013975150883198,
-0.30917972326278687,
-0.47631627321243286,
0.39060768485069275,
0.28955212235450745,
-0.27196598052978516,
0.22430983185768127,
0.267523854970932,
0.24316874146461487,
-0.45259493589401245,
0.3129453957080841,
0.14540575444698334,
0.05864657089114189,
-0.43259280920028687,
0.8858001232147217,
0.417018860578537,
-0.989628791809082,
0.6126019954681396,
-0.22510863840579987,
-0.28951025009155273,
0.33472803235054016,
0.46557798981666565,
1.0527375936508179,
-0.27011406421661377,
0.292129248380661,
0.5085490345954895,
0.36606258153915405,
-0.1885673850774765,
0.3769707977771759,
-0.2362552285194397,
-0.5942195653915405,
-0.09066081792116165,
-0.3773910403251648,
-0.5625197887420654,
0.15877465903759003,
-0.7414039373397827,
-0.11498909443616867,
-0.8820146918296814,
-0.08578557521104813,
0.4294905662536621,
-0.03596731275320053,
-0.3857443332672119,
0.07689407467842102,
0.022614194080233574,
0.7909603714942932,
-0.4999193847179413,
0.5323709845542908,
0.27395913004875183,
-0.047743190079927444,
-0.4747583568096161,
0.05170191451907158,
0.21801073849201202,
-0.6064398884773254,
0.2393593043088913,
0.31454500555992126,
-0.26704463362693787,
-0.20664021372795105,
-0.8339253067970276,
-0.5614578127861023,
0.6958467364311218,
0.3477153480052948,
-0.811651349067688,
0.03145929053425789,
0.09145019948482513,
0.6015077829360962,
0.13310715556144714,
-0.625285267829895,
0.5596164464950562,
0.40604469180107117,
-0.7108950614929199,
-0.6357287168502808,
0.06648880988359451,
-0.48427411913871765,
-0.15383116900920868,
0.2610204517841339,
-0.7485334873199463,
0.7276197075843811,
-0.3023347854614258,
-0.4417177438735962,
0.14698190987110138,
0.3195827007293701,
-0.0055921850726008415,
0.558641254901886,
0.2443263828754425,
0.377951443195343,
1.0503097772598267,
-0.0908549502491951,
1.1712243556976318,
-0.10158935189247131,
0.03523842245340347,
1.3534055948257446,
-0.3643847405910492,
1.1818392276763916,
0.4113372564315796,
-0.32933440804481506,
0.5944234132766724,
0.2503385543823242,
-0.041852083057165146,
0.5270882248878479,
0.6584049463272095,
-0.4500265419483185,
0.03495551273226738,
0.09450718015432358,
-0.23025143146514893,
0.47447437047958374,
0.04418756440281868,
-0.48788177967071533,
-0.14043979346752167,
-0.39923104643821716,
0.3011902868747711,
0.7493845820426941,
0.1557854413986206,
1.0302292108535767,
0.18486446142196655,
-0.6669008731842041,
0.3805902600288391,
0.21039684116840363,
0.5324105620384216,
-0.2938965857028961,
0.18741902709007263,
-0.09889326244592667,
0.28813228011131287,
-0.3710484802722931,
-0.7132110595703125,
0.7012629508972168,
0.36218398809432983,
-0.43163904547691345,
-0.4668712019920349,
0.7063038945198059,
-0.16598260402679443,
-0.28748881816864014,
0.15661387145519257,
0.18035444617271423,
0.3947608768939972,
-0.33933359384536743,
-0.5434957146644592,
-0.34092316031455994,
-0.039683375507593155,
-0.37981924414634705,
0.34299105405807495,
0.12802566587924957,
0.060139454901218414,
0.48055773973464966,
0.8284744620323181,
-0.08498991280794144,
0.07357194274663925,
0.11623901128768921,
0.5799693465232849,
-0.8559812903404236,
-0.5356019139289856,
-0.8080564737319946,
0.4274785816669464,
-0.49221494793891907,
-0.6432743668556213,
0.6022544503211975,
0.857799232006073,
0.5446832180023193,
0.07333564013242722,
0.7773089408874512,
0.21355268359184265,
0.8885236978530884,
-0.3680553436279297,
1.0669485330581665,
-0.011799152940511703,
-0.013240896165370941,
0.05343230068683624,
-0.8589622974395752,
-0.41500842571258545,
0.5750361084938049,
0.004593741148710251,
-0.3352072238922119,
0.45063480734825134,
0.8718791604042053,
0.4327402412891388,
0.21927611529827118,
0.15869803726673126,
-0.11993613094091415,
0.3098205626010895,
0.3618296980857849,
0.6821271777153015,
-0.39349842071533203,
0.223044753074646,
-0.5183164477348328,
-0.3590642511844635,
-0.18433725833892822,
-0.9479716420173645,
-0.6735795736312866,
-0.39468276500701904,
-0.4911997616291046,
-0.30566728115081787,
0.07618799805641174,
0.638293981552124,
0.7043495774269104,
-0.6713911294937134,
0.3077326714992523,
-0.37711742520332336,
0.08380142599344254,
-0.3053922951221466,
-0.20357735455036163,
0.4779745042324066,
-0.09512156248092651,
-0.5780689716339111,
0.6684510111808777,
0.2498960793018341,
-0.05863635241985321,
-0.38864314556121826,
0.19642029702663422,
0.033736903220415115,
0.16586068272590637,
0.39819568395614624,
0.48872110247612,
-0.6122165322303772,
-0.12515853345394135,
0.017200687900185585,
-0.21386593580245972,
0.08423545211553574,
0.9362034201622009,
-0.6007297039031982,
0.2996857762336731,
0.4513135552406311,
0.5377350449562073,
0.257686585187912,
0.4027368128299713,
0.6089038848876953,
-0.8018490672111511,
0.2140721082687378,
0.7163739800453186,
-0.012638747692108154,
0.6485872268676758,
-0.5222343802452087,
0.6698353290557861,
-0.08958026766777039,
-0.8609899282455444,
-0.950325071811676,
0.297619491815567,
-0.8677204251289368,
-0.43771785497665405,
1.1613357067108154,
-0.22549264132976532,
-0.4452020227909088,
-0.3099682927131653,
-0.3484668731689453,
0.04303034022450447,
-0.2911762297153473,
1.3357129096984863,
0.17586064338684082,
0.10470432788133621,
0.16181358695030212,
-0.41603314876556396,
0.8688555359840393,
0.1719464659690857,
-0.8655411601066589,
0.7367348670959473,
0.31173309683799744,
0.33616364002227783,
0.1092614009976387,
0.7311417460441589,
-0.5260963439941406,
0.44955047965049744,
0.255426287651062,
0.07606712728738785,
-0.018505701795220375,
-0.2266293317079544,
-0.23782318830490112,
0.18116021156311035,
-0.2350824773311615,
-0.32387107610702515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03746v1
|
Efficient Knowledge Infusion via KG-LLM Alignment
| 2024-06-06T04:55:55 | 2024-06-06T04:55:55 |
Zhouyu Jiang, Ling Zhong, Mengshu Sun, Jun Xu, Rui Sun, Hui Cai, Shuhan Luo, Zhiqiang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To tackle the problem of domain-specific knowledge scarcity within large
language models (LLMs), knowledge graph-retrievalaugmented method has been
proven to be an effective and efficient technique for knowledge infusion.
However, existing approaches face two primary challenges: knowledge mismatch
between public available knowledge graphs and the specific domain of the task
at hand, and poor information compliance of LLMs with knowledge graphs. In this
paper, we leverage a small set of labeled samples and a large-scale corpus to
efficiently construct domain-specific knowledge graphs by an LLM, addressing
the issue of knowledge mismatch. Additionally, we propose a three-stage KG-LLM
alignment strategyto enhance the LLM's capability to utilize information from
knowledge graphs. We conduct experiments with a limited-sample setting on two
biomedical question-answering datasets, and the results demonstrate that our
approach outperforms existing baselines.
|
[
-0.23499031364917755,
-0.5741845965385437,
0.626883327960968,
-0.08981200307607651,
-0.04737832397222519,
0.34350913763046265,
0.15264634788036346,
-0.3438224196434021,
0.09055493026971817,
0.6936522126197815,
-0.320422887802124,
-0.4845547080039978,
-0.6361327767372131,
0.1430131196975708,
-0.16661828756332397,
0.9276676177978516,
-0.33789607882499695,
0.12788984179496765,
-0.9135124087333679,
-0.3005865514278412,
-0.4533403515815735,
-0.19952623546123505,
-0.5447075963020325,
-0.7834864854812622,
0.6342931985855103,
0.6215072274208069,
0.5461931228637695,
0.8056219816207886,
0.5937806963920593,
0.16302922368049622,
-0.10691845417022705,
0.5825210809707642,
-0.6180358529090881,
0.04840521141886711,
-0.16875554621219635,
-0.26080387830734253,
-0.43649759888648987,
-0.2728523910045624,
0.676720142364502,
1.0120233297348022,
0.022471336647868156,
-0.004581216722726822,
0.2520758807659149,
0.6592463254928589,
-0.6152700781822205,
-0.012231708504259586,
-0.5303125381469727,
-0.05107121914625168,
-0.39031311869621277,
-0.06963302940130234,
-0.3518393933773041,
-0.6877943277359009,
0.3026568293571472,
-0.8198658227920532,
-0.19303005933761597,
0.07108045369386673,
0.8912457227706909,
0.3776191174983978,
-0.48488473892211914,
-0.36986738443374634,
-0.3270096480846405,
0.5099514722824097,
-0.8041760325431824,
0.4073900580406189,
0.6561381816864014,
0.33081433176994324,
-0.2162652164697647,
-0.6896150708198547,
-0.6837533712387085,
0.15388894081115723,
-0.3056413233280182,
-0.0008584303432144225,
-0.004694732837378979,
0.00968135241419077,
-0.0023905879352241755,
-0.19953198730945587,
-0.5329105257987976,
0.10884036868810654,
-0.3197808563709259,
-0.449542373418808,
0.21363787353038788,
0.2284700870513916,
0.25445321202278137,
-0.17521899938583374,
-0.3837215304374695,
-0.06458966434001923,
-0.9875435829162598,
-0.46285051107406616,
0.35368478298187256,
0.4188195765018463,
0.16797451674938202,
0.8358542919158936,
-0.18996179103851318,
1.1434707641601562,
-0.039529893547296524,
-0.5844554305076599,
0.3933936655521393,
-0.502147912979126,
-0.14514584839344025,
0.15707919001579285,
0.5570784211158752,
0.37529027462005615,
0.15973703563213348,
-0.41796374320983887,
0.28559258580207825,
-0.45730605721473694,
0.26214271783828735,
-0.9569042325019836,
0.013278824277222157,
0.2935503423213959,
-0.05616891011595726,
-0.2538321912288666,
-0.35429680347442627,
-0.6353569030761719,
-0.6806845664978027,
-0.11333860456943512,
0.5875585079193115,
-0.611122190952301,
0.0898866131901741,
-0.046104881912469864,
-0.27594366669654846,
0.23378387093544006,
0.2864709496498108,
-0.6847727298736572,
0.05832463130354881,
0.44124749302864075,
0.687187135219574,
-0.31585606932640076,
0.014288230799138546,
-0.28203409910202026,
0.7918609976768494,
-0.17199744284152985,
0.6973689794540405,
-0.39433297514915466,
-0.19981087744235992,
0.07905565947294235,
-0.096913643181324,
-0.17890910804271698,
-0.8092618584632874,
0.18599875271320343,
-0.8120636343955994,
0.0751105472445488,
-0.39035898447036743,
-1.0015476942062378,
-0.09948038309812546,
0.39710432291030884,
-0.1773112565279007,
0.9665628671646118,
0.4820474684238434,
-0.8688119053840637,
0.3283379375934601,
-0.36530768871307373,
-0.39704135060310364,
0.21191592514514923,
-0.31581738591194153,
-0.31672823429107666,
-0.45886698365211487,
0.2617838382720947,
0.5921091437339783,
-0.16363009810447693,
0.14510971307754517,
-0.5253376364707947,
-0.03068171627819538,
0.3185977339744568,
0.14764156937599182,
0.6123167872428894,
0.22613565623760223,
0.22055844962596893,
-0.37495797872543335,
-0.6790372729301453,
0.1707422435283661,
-0.07532525807619095,
-0.3789050877094269,
-0.3775516152381897,
-0.11645116657018661,
-0.508003830909729,
0.03360946848988533,
0.294439435005188,
-0.5563559532165527,
0.4566437900066376,
-0.4809648096561432,
0.2800186574459076,
0.6244348883628845,
0.11890263855457306,
0.579529881477356,
-0.3830876350402832,
0.40879112482070923,
0.07539578527212143,
-0.06669973582029343,
0.43396130204200745,
-0.4182627201080322,
-0.4477164149284363,
-0.525225043296814,
0.5182880759239197,
0.650625467300415,
-1.071756362915039,
0.27695682644844055,
-0.45339488983154297,
-0.5048038363456726,
-0.7776148319244385,
0.4375768005847931,
0.48217615485191345,
1.1538902521133423,
0.5440934300422668,
-0.07683621346950531,
-0.29117295145988464,
-0.9951841235160828,
-0.019816461950540543,
0.02182525396347046,
-0.08174990862607956,
0.7129349112510681,
0.24122284352779388,
-0.517482578754425,
1.1757917404174805,
-0.8935962319374084,
-0.35070139169692993,
-0.2346309870481491,
-0.05548081547021866,
0.14808152616024017,
0.3751021921634674,
0.3128969073295593,
-0.5041061043739319,
-0.6483962535858154,
0.3029418885707855,
-0.8632791638374329,
-0.3480721116065979,
0.33765578269958496,
-0.5397525429725647,
-0.16856960952281952,
0.6121575832366943,
-0.442862331867218,
-0.04419152811169624,
0.3610866963863373,
-0.18534868955612183,
0.07105612754821777,
-0.107192762196064,
0.17648127675056458,
-1.2538151741027832,
0.25041791796684265,
-0.42806240916252136,
-0.31098464131355286,
-0.8431591391563416,
-0.28842902183532715,
0.38693833351135254,
0.04553501680493355,
-0.40856197476387024,
0.783358097076416,
-0.2180778831243515,
0.09872248768806458,
-0.33373910188674927,
0.5631869435310364,
0.05450958386063576,
0.26790761947631836,
-0.23553259670734406,
0.5619857907295227,
0.2506120204925537,
-0.6014463305473328,
0.21579676866531372,
0.7771855592727661,
-0.40881675481796265,
0.5992364883422852,
-0.25082865357398987,
0.4463232159614563,
-0.31729593873023987,
0.2937895357608795,
-1.0238759517669678,
-0.5147721171379089,
0.5045856237411499,
-0.34296754002571106,
0.5388852953910828,
-0.14365676045417786,
-0.4884653091430664,
-0.3879387676715851,
0.001777241355739534,
0.6134036779403687,
0.425220787525177,
-0.5213416218757629,
0.630156934261322,
0.384456992149353,
-0.36734461784362793,
-0.8856658339500427,
-0.704770028591156,
-0.2379288673400879,
-0.2304149568080902,
-0.7404332756996155,
0.437524676322937,
0.010357832536101341,
-0.0028456132858991623,
0.17107191681861877,
-0.17866013944149017,
0.008288024924695492,
-0.053704362362623215,
-0.05518283322453499,
0.2854302227497101,
-0.015662167221307755,
0.324537068605423,
0.19283057749271393,
0.1339048147201538,
-0.46808865666389465,
-0.5179247260093689,
0.39162978529930115,
0.5359621644020081,
-0.39739373326301575,
-0.2245692014694214,
0.1743224710226059,
0.3593488931655884,
0.22422896325588226,
0.8014644384384155,
0.3685763478279114,
-0.39722368121147156,
-0.12779276072978973,
-0.6780418157577515,
-0.004218145273625851,
-0.44352176785469055,
0.47892865538597107,
-0.054316308349370956,
-1.0443772077560425,
0.3348242938518524,
-0.23217587172985077,
-0.389075368642807,
0.2507219910621643,
0.567208468914032,
-0.2762410044670105,
0.7816764116287231,
0.5053991079330444,
-0.17394095659255981,
0.10161162912845612,
0.020072050392627716,
0.36302608251571655,
-0.9303596615791321,
-0.33724457025527954,
-0.49260422587394714,
-0.2939503788948059,
-0.14414271712303162,
-0.6253940463066101,
0.5586884021759033,
0.3706991374492645,
-0.28895246982574463,
0.2374231517314911,
-0.3411227762699127,
0.4650706946849823,
0.3036447763442993,
0.3890402019023895,
0.2234032303094864,
-0.10633436590433121,
-0.4244259297847748,
0.21890389919281006,
-1.0439058542251587,
-0.3329553008079529,
1.324790358543396,
0.0386514775454998,
0.5753695368766785,
0.18551190197467804,
0.5780376195907593,
-0.00210553128272295,
0.7270515561103821,
-0.5772488713264465,
0.4501889646053314,
-0.06818515062332153,
-0.4390186071395874,
-0.3368598520755768,
-0.5453957319259644,
-0.9182154536247253,
0.09584006667137146,
-0.26250821352005005,
-0.7588925361633301,
0.08119859546422958,
0.14237016439437866,
-0.4376427233219147,
0.1223716288805008,
-0.6755956411361694,
0.8763448596000671,
0.05186038836836815,
-0.07955005764961243,
0.1818837970495224,
-0.8612326383590698,
0.2644731104373932,
-0.5262720584869385,
0.30505427718162537,
-0.14946220815181732,
-0.13950221240520477,
0.8021174669265747,
-0.6708049774169922,
0.6805399656295776,
-0.19376595318317413,
-0.22736595571041107,
0.2636835277080536,
-0.24543896317481995,
0.7812750339508057,
-0.2447425127029419,
0.009350428357720375,
-0.1829150766134262,
-0.06836125999689102,
-0.5515413880348206,
-0.73225998878479,
0.522057056427002,
-0.8614925146102905,
-0.4644347131252289,
0.03875718265771866,
-0.9562097787857056,
-0.9579719305038452,
0.12400144338607788,
0.2913562059402466,
0.22040389478206635,
0.1268537938594818,
0.05130565166473389,
0.7940206527709961,
-0.3172629773616791,
0.006382182240486145,
0.5658316612243652,
-0.07190102338790894,
-0.7156314849853516,
1.0020718574523926,
0.16932059824466705,
0.6224104762077332,
0.5442904233932495,
0.2046346515417099,
-0.37449607253074646,
-0.6715403199195862,
-0.39690932631492615,
0.4455340504646301,
-0.8961557149887085,
-0.7160770297050476,
-0.8421470522880554,
-0.1459713727235794,
-0.6927851438522339,
-0.2732525169849396,
0.026037605479359627,
-0.3092835247516632,
-0.14799530804157257,
-0.0349469818174839,
0.46744081377983093,
0.5094514489173889,
0.057723842561244965,
0.2808668911457062,
-0.9599912166595459,
0.31790047883987427,
0.520160436630249,
0.20033392310142517,
-0.08371121436357498,
-0.5701615810394287,
-0.38990575075149536,
-0.049304474145174026,
-0.25170624256134033,
-1.040074110031128,
0.10945326834917068,
0.08753769844770432,
0.630964457988739,
0.35348862409591675,
-0.09804634749889374,
0.9148584604263306,
-0.39434799551963806,
0.4170754849910736,
0.2324870526790619,
-0.5668948292732239,
0.3827873170375824,
-0.24683403968811035,
0.29402655363082886,
0.7531071305274963,
0.6565929055213928,
-0.5569317936897278,
-0.7134852409362793,
-0.4331081509590149,
-0.9684106111526489,
0.6248337626457214,
0.2304699867963791,
-0.14049901068210602,
-0.09018254280090332,
0.3883714973926544,
0.0807986706495285,
0.20264272391796112,
-0.3027753531932831,
-0.18900518119335175,
0.2659453749656677,
-0.6772860884666443,
0.01951545476913452,
-0.18416303396224976,
-0.5573123097419739,
-0.22323374450206757,
0.8198688626289368,
-0.37005332112312317,
0.1799999177455902,
0.18975487351417542,
-0.22147096693515778,
0.06682107597589493,
0.07380132377147675,
0.35515880584716797,
0.49148181080818176,
-0.16036663949489594,
0.2128862738609314,
0.46944814920425415,
-0.43668586015701294,
0.19490012526512146,
0.22458963096141815,
-0.1959473341703415,
-0.42264294624328613,
0.251483678817749,
0.3491557836532593,
0.08774769306182861,
-0.7638474106788635,
0.503669261932373,
0.44042763113975525,
-0.4107685685157776,
0.24373534321784973,
-0.06034920737147331,
0.5847386717796326,
0.5123257040977478,
0.1623706966638565,
-0.17280635237693787,
-0.3082323670387268,
-0.18687599897384644,
0.20193421840667725,
0.5156974792480469,
-0.2625877857208252,
0.39045843482017517,
0.5370935201644897,
-0.008900955319404602,
-0.015242579393088818,
0.7915018796920776,
-0.13881564140319824,
-0.321340411901474,
0.4717947840690613,
0.6559271812438965,
0.3592941462993622,
0.04448813572525978,
0.1434308886528015,
0.2232324182987213,
-0.1669609695672989,
-0.09153492748737335,
0.1488020420074463,
0.07816603034734726,
-1.1753607988357544,
-0.5084233283996582,
-0.6374061703681946,
-0.4775201678276062,
-0.1825326383113861,
-0.4689020812511444,
0.10272485762834549,
0.006193355191498995,
-0.035375479608774185,
0.052588775753974915,
-0.17874431610107422,
-0.5702587366104126,
0.04161585494875908,
-0.031730204820632935,
0.8624976873397827,
-0.5783725380897522,
1.0910619497299194,
0.49277323484420776,
-0.3299826979637146,
-0.959931492805481,
-0.17294913530349731,
-0.13755398988723755,
-1.1503219604492188,
0.8800777792930603,
-0.23604771494865417,
0.10359795391559601,
0.236233651638031,
-0.583705484867096,
-1.1023359298706055,
1.445990800857544,
0.35994014143943787,
-0.32690680027008057,
0.1458989381790161,
0.35422593355178833,
0.35678601264953613,
-0.28706443309783936,
-0.16927126049995422,
0.6285122632980347,
0.6608700156211853,
0.3615305423736572,
-0.7390556335449219,
0.2534526586532593,
0.0422431156039238,
-0.182889923453331,
0.4650948941707611,
-0.46700847148895264,
0.19535276293754578,
-0.09572068601846695,
-0.01024592574685812,
0.13383831083774567,
0.6207846403121948,
0.3139108121395111,
0.1497880518436432,
0.3594120144844055,
0.9066876173019409,
1.2494385242462158,
0.04010680317878723,
0.8739296197891235,
-0.263062983751297,
0.20218557119369507,
0.8552695512771606,
-0.4691928029060364,
0.6035672426223755,
0.6144024729728699,
-0.33485808968544006,
0.15348222851753235,
0.4811093807220459,
0.0025358120910823345,
0.6811257004737854,
0.48640233278274536,
-0.3254885673522949,
-0.22559504210948944,
-0.21763527393341064,
-0.41022443771362305,
0.1554710865020752,
0.29478558897972107,
-0.16321438550949097,
-0.17399099469184875,
0.109107606112957,
0.2826094925403595,
-0.30148977041244507,
-0.264346718788147,
0.9486105442047119,
-0.02641916833817959,
-0.6482381820678711,
0.620792031288147,
-0.2707902789115906,
0.31996870040893555,
-0.7574163675308228,
0.01830986700952053,
-0.3147884011268616,
0.09132476150989532,
-0.2804158329963684,
-0.6576781272888184,
0.13642853498458862,
-0.0632646381855011,
-0.1583174169063568,
-0.2853301763534546,
0.8525232672691345,
-0.721687376499176,
-0.34807583689689636,
0.2239166498184204,
0.7706365585327148,
0.13707099854946136,
0.2609039545059204,
-0.24364802241325378,
-0.29445743560791016,
-0.012439421378076077,
0.04593367502093315,
0.7014576196670532,
0.3923850953578949,
0.15679451823234558,
0.7171205878257751,
0.32669955492019653,
0.17154914140701294,
-0.19779659807682037,
0.010345635935664177,
0.8787316679954529,
-0.3876093626022339,
0.011189059354364872,
-0.7779104113578796,
0.20584304630756378,
-0.1462758630514145,
-0.12718963623046875,
0.618195652961731,
0.5139200091362,
0.7997032403945923,
0.05757330730557442,
0.9504319429397583,
-0.12464548647403717,
0.5357164740562439,
-0.5375517010688782,
0.7069860100746155,
-0.6761205196380615,
0.022220201790332794,
-0.24121735990047455,
-0.49327924847602844,
-0.4985969662666321,
0.28726574778556824,
-0.15010420978069305,
-0.17052897810935974,
0.766724705696106,
1.0284239053726196,
0.260171502828598,
-0.16275237500667572,
0.2868805229663849,
0.2674432098865509,
0.0599050298333168,
0.6098552346229553,
0.7000081539154053,
-0.14187173545360565,
0.8057961463928223,
-0.1331736147403717,
-0.1351572424173355,
-0.07987863570451736,
-0.9424556493759155,
-0.6327797174453735,
-0.2863250970840454,
-0.4213636517524719,
-0.789277195930481,
0.09597109258174896,
0.7774123549461365,
0.5525765419006348,
-0.6682261228561401,
0.034227777272462845,
0.1238943561911583,
0.360199511051178,
-0.1729992777109146,
-0.14256002008914948,
0.5784519910812378,
-0.39810094237327576,
-0.5355730652809143,
0.43004339933395386,
0.20707371830940247,
0.12158162146806717,
0.20744295418262482,
0.005450456868857145,
-0.22195859253406525,
0.08143863826990128,
0.4490126669406891,
0.23027125000953674,
-0.3446686565876007,
-0.5199964046478271,
0.0046284557320177555,
-0.3556438088417053,
0.12499644607305527,
0.7185015082359314,
-0.6650415658950806,
0.3532974421977997,
0.5628987550735474,
1.1697475910186768,
0.5144882798194885,
0.1845182627439499,
0.6289517879486084,
-0.8458637595176697,
-0.3054675757884979,
0.25785741209983826,
0.22673319280147552,
0.4080478250980377,
-0.3545437753200531,
0.5494093298912048,
0.40947628021240234,
-0.618695855140686,
-0.7076274156570435,
0.2620347738265991,
-1.1328743696212769,
-0.3884562849998474,
1.434664011001587,
0.06807806342840195,
0.03960340470075607,
-0.38777804374694824,
-0.1811627745628357,
0.3654874861240387,
0.0256110318005085,
0.6063533425331116,
1.011427640914917,
-0.36386173963546753,
0.37495794892311096,
-0.4798595607280731,
0.5511881113052368,
0.32431110739707947,
-0.8453317880630493,
-0.06812828779220581,
0.19510681927204132,
0.3730665445327759,
0.044492803514003754,
0.9219989776611328,
-0.1498858630657196,
-0.17731092870235443,
-0.20553603768348694,
-0.1044139564037323,
0.07611092925071716,
-0.027781208977103233,
0.12898313999176025,
0.41526681184768677,
0.026039820164442062,
0.021196629852056503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03736v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03736v1
|
Your Absorbing Discrete Diffusion Secretly Models the Conditional Distributions of Clean Data
| 2024-06-06T04:22:11 | 2024-06-06T04:22:11 |
Jingyang Ou, Shen Nie, Kaiwen Xue, Fengqi Zhu, Jiacheng Sun, Zhenguo Li, Chongxuan Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Discrete diffusion models with absorbing processes have shown promise in
language modeling. The key quantities to be estimated are the ratios between
the marginal probabilities of two transitive states at all timesteps, called
the concrete score. In this paper, we reveal that the concrete score in
absorbing diffusion can be expressed as conditional probabilities of clean
data, multiplied by a time-dependent scalar in an analytic form. Motivated by
the finding, we propose reparameterized absorbing discrete diffusion (RADD), a
dedicated diffusion model that characterizes the time-independent conditional
probabilities. Besides its simplicity, RADD can reduce the number of function
evaluations (NFEs) by caching the output of the time-independent network when
the noisy sample remains unchanged in a sampling interval. Empirically, RADD is
up to 3.5 times faster while consistently achieving a better performance than
the strongest baseline. Built upon the new factorization of the concrete score,
we further prove a surprising result that the exact likelihood of absorbing
diffusion can be rewritten to a simple form (named denoising cross-entropy) and
then estimated efficiently by the Monte Carlo method. The resulting approach
also applies to the original parameterization of the concrete score. It
significantly advances the state-of-the-art discrete diffusion on 5 zero-shot
language modeling benchmarks (measured by perplexity) at the GPT-2 scale.
|
[
-0.284719318151474,
-0.9243760108947754,
0.6236879229545593,
0.40565431118011475,
-0.1667189747095108,
0.11392224580049515,
0.01869208738207817,
-0.405166894197464,
0.11992006748914719,
0.4528846740722656,
-0.18930456042289734,
-0.6372544169425964,
-0.8156572580337524,
-0.3205859065055847,
-0.5439774394035339,
1.0873068571090698,
0.10065611451864243,
-0.1802857518196106,
0.07897719740867615,
-0.041010573506355286,
0.052972111850976944,
0.05500541627407074,
-0.8159777522087097,
-0.45143336057662964,
0.6539511680603027,
0.09356662631034851,
0.5291007161140442,
0.36666515469551086,
0.3969261646270752,
0.26394417881965637,
0.2773188650608063,
-0.4982091784477234,
-0.4004908502101898,
-0.041467081755399704,
-0.2711009681224823,
-0.3384745419025421,
-0.4106782078742981,
0.28203287720680237,
0.741974413394928,
0.9342619776725769,
-0.438279926776886,
-0.14225438237190247,
-0.09508240222930908,
0.5832712650299072,
-0.9686514139175415,
0.1927006095647812,
-0.2627093493938446,
0.038901373744010925,
0.028966760262846947,
-0.16786691546440125,
-0.5587419271469116,
-0.4461752772331238,
-0.04848956689238548,
-0.4715188145637512,
0.3494308292865753,
-0.45372849702835083,
0.4765642285346985,
0.11694923043251038,
-0.39822378754615784,
0.07266925275325775,
-1.0564289093017578,
0.8478317856788635,
-0.39055049419403076,
0.33511555194854736,
0.593504011631012,
0.45320820808410645,
-0.0682811513543129,
-0.9559828639030457,
-0.5175747871398926,
-0.09571819007396698,
0.18121296167373657,
0.2270798534154892,
-0.38476043939590454,
0.07686429470777512,
-0.056485049426555634,
0.328373521566391,
-0.45098984241485596,
-0.17518413066864014,
-0.1978069394826889,
-0.19845463335514069,
0.6045557260513306,
0.15922312438488007,
0.36168238520622253,
0.11158867925405502,
-0.34661537408828735,
-0.10697083920240402,
-0.3441367745399475,
-0.17993596196174622,
0.09871707856655121,
0.0731799453496933,
-0.5064699053764343,
0.32267507910728455,
-0.5068249106407166,
0.4173552095890045,
-0.1260548084974289,
-0.04901132732629776,
0.14683163166046143,
-0.2938573956489563,
-0.3424912393093109,
-0.16843077540397644,
0.7088579535484314,
-0.0492997020483017,
0.4109751880168915,
-0.3232559859752655,
-0.18739363551139832,
0.1736244261264801,
0.02511775866150856,
-0.959323525428772,
-0.9542675614356995,
-0.03702358528971672,
-0.4284605383872986,
-0.2987254858016968,
-0.28382644057273865,
-0.5044710040092468,
-0.33829641342163086,
0.10575966536998749,
0.25686541199684143,
-0.4470159411430359,
-0.529076337814331,
0.5046901702880859,
-0.2326984703540802,
0.17738676071166992,
0.5828410983085632,
-0.6672284603118896,
0.7691953182220459,
0.728186845779419,
0.8430614471435547,
0.012310167774558067,
-0.005716485902667046,
-0.36501073837280273,
-0.00579600315541029,
-0.42277151346206665,
0.9855352640151978,
-0.8618175983428955,
-0.5718028545379639,
-0.40378305315971375,
-0.18428443372249603,
-0.07823505252599716,
-0.35240066051483154,
0.3806328773498535,
-0.640360414981842,
0.07379933446645737,
-0.0717393085360527,
-0.4548303782939911,
-0.3445430397987366,
0.07511097937822342,
-0.6351566314697266,
0.9460270404815674,
0.316624253988266,
-0.7112497687339783,
0.42702823877334595,
-0.39436987042427063,
-0.3845711350440979,
0.14006902277469635,
0.03399520367383957,
-0.22746306657791138,
0.2976754903793335,
-0.17747659981250763,
0.11285805702209473,
-0.06653539091348648,
-0.015000260435044765,
-0.8116664290428162,
-0.14677388966083527,
0.2650086581707001,
-0.7898153066635132,
0.9303706884384155,
0.2737228274345398,
-0.28669771552085876,
-0.2674848437309265,
-0.9911074638366699,
0.1376154124736786,
-0.43704718351364136,
-0.5221583247184753,
-0.572677731513977,
0.1400952786207199,
0.045310717076063156,
0.21235527098178864,
-0.13118349015712738,
-0.7800724506378174,
0.099370576441288,
-0.21728479862213135,
0.1524863988161087,
0.7817304730415344,
0.4434751272201538,
0.7352579236030579,
-0.3630717098712921,
0.5645723342895508,
-0.01359719317406416,
-0.04191514849662781,
0.30570167303085327,
-0.6048431396484375,
-0.4223773777484894,
-0.8226929903030396,
0.4618481993675232,
0.40683773159980774,
-0.5158283114433289,
0.17496083676815033,
-0.19197043776512146,
-0.45845016837120056,
-0.5948687791824341,
-0.13807934522628784,
0.3535718619823456,
0.535094678401947,
0.3039053678512573,
-0.23324692249298096,
-0.2341156303882599,
-0.7666122317314148,
-0.20865900814533234,
-0.22707445919513702,
-0.15405666828155518,
0.0898510068655014,
0.5560658574104309,
-0.15655890107154846,
0.891069769859314,
-0.6959871649742126,
-0.30181896686553955,
-0.08446962386369705,
0.3930550515651703,
0.048219628632068634,
0.682096004486084,
0.4034025967121124,
-0.45749419927597046,
-0.5331230163574219,
-0.14526543021202087,
-0.5298078060150146,
-0.25395071506500244,
-0.008115822449326515,
-0.1332802027463913,
-0.0009438880369998515,
0.42643651366233826,
-0.5145537257194519,
0.6303856372833252,
0.5553292632102966,
-0.4423375427722931,
0.5161622762680054,
-0.5572116374969482,
0.2248004674911499,
-0.5734025239944458,
0.09891316294670105,
0.08949580788612366,
-0.32060563564300537,
-0.49952638149261475,
0.058399226516485214,
-0.0033213901333510876,
0.050421133637428284,
-0.33917105197906494,
0.7022131085395813,
-0.5164015889167786,
-0.025012057274580002,
-0.2631032168865204,
0.11090273410081863,
0.1574685424566269,
0.2682536542415619,
0.04558885097503662,
0.3291148543357849,
0.568709135055542,
-0.7581745386123657,
-0.19483238458633423,
-0.24605660140514374,
-0.6590080261230469,
0.5850880742073059,
-0.758175790309906,
0.029509423300623894,
-0.194292813539505,
0.43418747186660767,
-1.3805522918701172,
0.233411967754364,
0.3551071584224701,
-0.3450266420841217,
0.18445037305355072,
-0.2943965792655945,
-0.2627435028553009,
0.2956595718860626,
-0.22498378157615662,
0.7280359864234924,
0.538663923740387,
-0.3997376561164856,
0.7368974089622498,
0.42832493782043457,
0.014546381309628487,
-0.5125429630279541,
-0.627885639667511,
-0.0868302509188652,
0.0767493024468422,
-0.7018712759017944,
0.5333561897277832,
-0.2561871111392975,
-0.4055061340332031,
0.3497482240200043,
-0.13034191727638245,
-0.22862884402275085,
0.23582778871059418,
0.2552858889102936,
-0.04885207861661911,
0.01640925370156765,
-0.18087893724441528,
0.007539625279605389,
-0.37201279401779175,
0.1819966584444046,
-0.043298665434122086,
0.3002668619155884,
0.3977295160293579,
-0.18617114424705505,
-0.5694414377212524,
0.2942350208759308,
0.4799834191799164,
-0.018952904269099236,
0.7821989059448242,
0.5630070567131042,
-0.5605574250221252,
-0.5862547755241394,
-0.33113616704940796,
-0.020844541490077972,
-0.4568849205970764,
0.25111207365989685,
-0.7638291120529175,
-0.4670306444168091,
0.6631289720535278,
-0.020509131252765656,
0.026062851771712303,
0.30130305886268616,
0.22928054630756378,
-0.23286467790603638,
1.1002228260040283,
0.586523175239563,
0.007108574733138084,
0.4271683394908905,
-0.5374646782875061,
0.37316590547561646,
-0.7919919490814209,
-0.26689407229423523,
-0.6138706207275391,
-0.3553365170955658,
-0.5978719592094421,
-0.6385608911514282,
0.044234853237867355,
0.21788011491298676,
0.08313078433275223,
-0.32602018117904663,
0.04898650944232941,
0.42701971530914307,
0.23398150503635406,
0.13533049821853638,
0.3237263262271881,
-0.1049574464559555,
-0.06697677820920944,
0.08326221257448196,
-0.3586809039115906,
0.05461401492357254,
0.966482937335968,
0.2013540416955948,
0.9620249271392822,
0.2737244963645935,
0.8742612600326538,
0.6955972909927368,
0.49596965312957764,
-0.44512704014778137,
0.5973696708679199,
-0.3448229730129242,
-0.40042197704315186,
-0.10716958343982697,
-0.7190646529197693,
-0.8890251517295837,
0.3944910764694214,
-0.16033001244068146,
-0.4729101061820984,
0.5107045769691467,
-0.14804551005363464,
-0.18088960647583008,
0.14984130859375,
-0.7296926975250244,
0.7105600237846375,
0.4071645736694336,
-0.2226538360118866,
-0.6156831979751587,
0.010915307328104973,
0.8158950209617615,
0.01393978763371706,
0.4203615188598633,
-0.37322017550468445,
-0.12172377109527588,
0.7983397245407104,
-0.517196774482727,
0.865836501121521,
-0.5653606057167053,
0.003011986380442977,
0.16140669584274292,
0.45613154768943787,
0.46970388293266296,
0.2171439677476883,
-0.13577720522880554,
0.23960627615451813,
0.04991729184985161,
-0.5838671922683716,
-0.9169244170188904,
0.9787280559539795,
-0.7018507122993469,
-0.4205962121486664,
-0.5106900930404663,
-0.45462217926979065,
0.1355152428150177,
0.20152704417705536,
-0.05348566174507141,
0.3707720935344696,
-0.4005204439163208,
-0.1466805338859558,
0.6348389983177185,
-0.22562098503112793,
0.6844667196273804,
0.9794376492500305,
-0.04213111475110054,
-0.3785265386104584,
0.8119751214981079,
0.23371437191963196,
0.4388934373855591,
0.47244536876678467,
0.31844621896743774,
-0.3774135410785675,
-0.6123085618019104,
0.06844104081392288,
0.3888889253139496,
-0.5484547019004822,
0.03024822287261486,
-0.8131689429283142,
-0.1364443153142929,
-0.4649289846420288,
-0.18675686419010162,
-0.41083210706710815,
-0.8077329993247986,
-0.16690276563167572,
-0.30950820446014404,
0.2657566964626312,
0.6014642119407654,
-0.6262269616127014,
0.12849415838718414,
-0.40245646238327026,
0.6305454969406128,
0.06474199891090393,
0.7078479528427124,
0.11394286155700684,
-0.613754391670227,
0.02313578687608242,
-0.04296572878956795,
0.1857881098985672,
-0.5985313057899475,
0.35370853543281555,
0.31922706961631775,
0.5749993324279785,
0.6260582208633423,
0.34648510813713074,
0.6670598387718201,
-0.4038684070110321,
0.24951794743537903,
0.005408240016549826,
-0.7326059341430664,
0.0977129116654396,
0.017494553700089455,
0.3154844641685486,
0.5882039070129395,
0.3569144606590271,
-0.5430774688720703,
-0.4932211935520172,
-0.6270061135292053,
-0.5769065618515015,
0.5282577276229858,
-0.04450005665421486,
0.14020632207393646,
-0.4394321143627167,
0.27911487221717834,
0.036743585020303726,
-0.2592892646789551,
-0.4302195608615875,
-0.2596108019351959,
0.1326286941766739,
-0.16582755744457245,
-0.23853273689746857,
-0.53807532787323,
0.09904047846794128,
-0.3068491220474243,
0.6530481576919556,
0.5309913754463196,
0.14314118027687073,
0.11990973353385925,
-0.11689157038927078,
0.19871383905410767,
-0.009958731010556221,
0.5176351070404053,
0.3675678074359894,
-0.4739418923854828,
0.3410239815711975,
-0.38627707958221436,
-0.8668550848960876,
0.31597864627838135,
-0.20141780376434326,
-0.3498137295246124,
0.06335283070802689,
0.3835439682006836,
0.23158450424671173,
0.40889084339141846,
-0.1170179471373558,
0.355292409658432,
-0.3075306713581085,
-0.3252459168434143,
-0.33055511116981506,
0.2784762978553772,
0.12047969549894333,
0.09724912792444229,
0.21096232533454895,
0.3039378821849823,
0.2987331748008728,
-0.4632585048675537,
0.47482869029045105,
0.5051812529563904,
-0.4270113706588745,
-0.4624232053756714,
0.5510941743850708,
0.18642321228981018,
-0.3355593979358673,
0.7179328203201294,
-0.5525516271591187,
-0.07010304927825928,
0.3855283558368683,
0.49570003151893616,
1.1540889739990234,
-0.4737483859062195,
0.6125840544700623,
0.3562881052494049,
0.26603034138679504,
-0.18423062562942505,
0.4248284101486206,
-0.31116753816604614,
-0.8703680634498596,
-0.48982661962509155,
-0.7611489295959473,
0.04213876277208328,
-0.16102612018585205,
-0.6501010656356812,
-0.1295384019613266,
-0.7454612851142883,
-0.1699923425912857,
0.23663805425167084,
0.12485961616039276,
-0.44074031710624695,
0.2062862068414688,
-0.38501325249671936,
1.0462911128997803,
-1.2168606519699097,
1.2584257125854492,
-0.1084657534956932,
-0.32207050919532776,
-0.40217164158821106,
-0.21188436448574066,
-0.1454523205757141,
-0.6364565491676331,
0.5888099074363708,
-0.4234902560710907,
-0.23957489430904388,
0.27890172600746155,
-0.0004297574341762811,
-0.7736966609954834,
0.6406726837158203,
0.24283264577388763,
-0.2267458289861679,
0.2735198736190796,
-0.06431451439857483,
0.47617921233177185,
-0.26390260457992554,
0.37869343161582947,
0.8265251517295837,
0.485567182302475,
-0.16636991500854492,
-0.20319190621376038,
0.08503210544586182,
-0.37483909726142883,
-0.12567026913166046,
0.42461463809013367,
-0.15153279900550842,
0.8392664790153503,
-0.32949352264404297,
-0.6355019211769104,
-0.07309573143720627,
0.49762460589408875,
-0.00683240732178092,
0.29175078868865967,
0.3528006076812744,
0.9205201268196106,
0.7084916234016418,
0.04509200528264046,
1.3601102828979492,
-0.15582869946956635,
0.1772010177373886,
1.1572736501693726,
-0.11728977411985397,
0.9332308769226074,
0.26560714840888977,
-0.3696229159832001,
0.8243740797042847,
0.30448004603385925,
0.28628548979759216,
0.981310248374939,
0.3183540105819702,
-0.7099764347076416,
-0.16278809309005737,
0.1418159157037735,
-0.10718795657157898,
0.33014345169067383,
0.3542795479297638,
-0.21446102857589722,
-0.45195791125297546,
0.03842710703611374,
-0.10485145449638367,
0.03565176576375961,
-0.1672874093055725,
0.5686483979225159,
0.19854629039764404,
-0.4235462248325348,
0.5025528073310852,
0.31195876002311707,
0.33065065741539,
-0.40968286991119385,
-0.19822384417057037,
-0.6867639422416687,
0.3775777220726013,
-0.20606181025505066,
-0.6798090934753418,
0.41054487228393555,
-0.2743723690509796,
-0.5796725749969482,
-0.2830515205860138,
0.23160333931446075,
-0.3635725975036621,
-0.7269323468208313,
0.558078944683075,
0.09246577322483063,
0.342830628156662,
-0.0012836981331929564,
-0.5774865746498108,
0.12678271532058716,
-0.20498566329479218,
-0.1333708018064499,
0.5722116827964783,
0.43370941281318665,
-0.08281083405017853,
0.7392808794975281,
0.6599852442741394,
0.2972536087036133,
0.274887353181839,
0.43515267968177795,
0.40895965695381165,
-0.5076118111610413,
-0.5290699601173401,
-0.8712962865829468,
0.3804027736186981,
0.15970897674560547,
-0.1745445728302002,
0.7414559721946716,
0.5344425439834595,
0.6615934371948242,
0.24800564348697662,
0.6886306405067444,
0.12244237214326859,
0.369710236787796,
-0.27715471386909485,
0.8378638625144958,
-0.1691083461046219,
0.6118900775909424,
-0.3557124435901642,
-0.820198655128479,
-0.28487300872802734,
0.535452127456665,
-0.45477771759033203,
0.2117857038974762,
0.6213567852973938,
0.8870738744735718,
-0.134369358420372,
-0.2777072787284851,
0.3003772497177124,
0.25301092863082886,
0.49938374757766724,
0.7092212438583374,
0.568706214427948,
-0.44674891233444214,
0.3223811388015747,
-0.5415756702423096,
-0.5113458037376404,
-0.044495996087789536,
-0.7707662582397461,
-0.45293110609054565,
-0.39989376068115234,
-0.876205563545227,
-0.5005589723587036,
0.16789644956588745,
-0.148952916264534,
0.5909488201141357,
-0.6675469279289246,
-0.16526079177856445,
-0.31357869505882263,
0.4995918869972229,
-0.5126701593399048,
-0.3041606843471527,
0.45536917448043823,
-0.1485593467950821,
-0.6286634802818298,
0.5237488150596619,
0.4215157926082611,
-0.12736791372299194,
-0.2415211945772171,
-0.13727927207946777,
-0.3205222189426422,
0.3554712235927582,
0.40899357199668884,
0.35586515069007874,
-0.2672424912452698,
-0.4171624481678009,
-0.1891082376241684,
-0.33087167143821716,
-0.24513262510299683,
0.7300479412078857,
-0.9187638163566589,
0.461385041475296,
0.908739447593689,
0.2300378978252411,
0.8414939045906067,
0.02607409656047821,
0.6034406423568726,
-0.47474971413612366,
-0.00995186623185873,
0.056454695761203766,
0.16596464812755585,
0.08971365541219711,
-0.004163962788879871,
0.25870850682258606,
0.43578359484672546,
-0.3949165642261505,
-0.7831186056137085,
0.28313887119293213,
-0.8814687132835388,
-0.554250180721283,
0.8285971879959106,
-0.26638421416282654,
-0.3435059189796448,
-0.5550736784934998,
0.4207358658313751,
0.06616824120283127,
-0.26779574155807495,
1.1766437292099,
0.28884756565093994,
-0.0835769772529602,
-0.25991079211235046,
-0.3736546039581299,
0.5369018912315369,
0.20044365525245667,
-0.4126740097999573,
0.04924030974507332,
0.518448531627655,
0.9368941187858582,
-0.35056012868881226,
1.3134464025497437,
-0.11541131138801575,
0.4290574789047241,
0.5699077248573303,
-0.020885992795228958,
0.10581061244010925,
-0.36724454164505005,
-0.43128716945648193,
0.4375016689300537,
-0.09869735687971115,
-0.32696178555488586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03725v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03725v1
|
LLMEmbed: Rethinking Lightweight LLM's Genuine Function in Text Classification
| 2024-06-06T03:46:59 | 2024-06-06T03:46:59 |
Chun Liu, Hongguang Zhang, Kainan Zhao, Xinghai Ju, Lin Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the booming of Large Language Models (LLMs), prompt-learning has become
a promising method mainly researched in various research areas. Recently, many
attempts based on prompt-learning have been made to improve the performance of
text classification. However, most of these methods are based on heuristic
Chain-of-Thought (CoT), and tend to be more complex but less efficient. In this
paper, we rethink the LLM-based text classification methodology, propose a
simple and effective transfer learning strategy, namely LLMEmbed, to address
this classical but challenging task. To illustrate, we first study how to
properly extract and fuse the text embeddings via various lightweight LLMs at
different network depths to improve their robustness and discrimination, then
adapt such embeddings to train the classifier. We perform extensive experiments
on publicly available datasets, and the results show that LLMEmbed achieves
strong performance while enjoys low training overhead using lightweight LLM
backbones compared to recent methods based on larger LLMs, i.e. GPT-3, and
sophisticated prompt-based strategies. Our LLMEmbed achieves adequate accuracy
on publicly available benchmarks without any fine-tuning while merely use 4%
model parameters, 1.8% electricity consumption and 1.5% runtime compared to its
counterparts. Code is available at:
https://github.com/ChunLiu-cs/LLMEmbed-ACL2024.
|
[
0.08428484201431274,
-0.5619728565216064,
0.5351412892341614,
0.1541011482477188,
-0.5784677863121033,
0.31941941380500793,
-0.33623507618904114,
-0.5784587860107422,
0.036101944744586945,
0.2877565920352936,
-0.244499072432518,
-0.47565963864326477,
-0.8017858862876892,
0.2587500810623169,
-0.4138292372226715,
0.9156116843223572,
-0.22558976709842682,
-0.083153136074543,
-0.05609504133462906,
-0.18126901984214783,
-0.31481149792671204,
-0.418439656496048,
-0.713888943195343,
-0.26904499530792236,
0.7208135724067688,
0.5657157301902771,
0.29249951243400574,
0.5646014213562012,
0.23648329079151154,
0.2608400881290436,
-0.268373966217041,
0.23169046640396118,
-0.5133095383644104,
0.2758696973323822,
-0.059958841651678085,
-0.5584492683410645,
0.029338056221604347,
0.036265116184949875,
0.46748921275138855,
0.5395170450210571,
0.02293909154832363,
0.06547073274850845,
0.6382215023040771,
0.39102351665496826,
-0.6063430905342102,
0.034395668655633926,
-0.7384631037712097,
0.13225848972797394,
-0.16795800626277924,
-0.2641221284866333,
-0.5778990983963013,
-0.3187963664531708,
0.12492199242115021,
-0.1212315484881401,
0.11227194219827652,
0.3927898108959198,
0.5812059640884399,
0.17694801092147827,
-0.6906378865242004,
-0.3008268177509308,
-0.3560132682323456,
0.8447669148445129,
-0.6019454002380371,
0.32182636857032776,
0.20602726936340332,
0.37353044748306274,
0.03929132595658302,
-0.7649406790733337,
-0.35123634338378906,
-0.2194754034280777,
0.06317568570375443,
-0.1504022181034088,
0.039464086294174194,
-0.04922018200159073,
0.17024239897727966,
0.34874892234802246,
-0.3136049211025238,
0.5028910040855408,
-0.1439753621816635,
-0.2457813024520874,
0.41613999009132385,
-0.05675444379448891,
0.23017536103725433,
-0.1259842813014984,
-0.8056651949882507,
0.16896265745162964,
-0.6503552198410034,
0.22407522797584534,
-0.015532531775534153,
0.3851390779018402,
-0.1270582675933838,
0.3110778331756592,
-0.054112937301397324,
0.3665793538093567,
0.054954539984464645,
-0.4741552770137787,
0.2372587025165558,
-0.06619405746459961,
-0.005548440385609865,
0.38110947608947754,
0.8403645157814026,
-0.038876309990882874,
0.13780486583709717,
-0.2041223645210266,
-0.5667791962623596,
-0.31792113184928894,
0.1007542535662651,
-1.0021036863327026,
-0.12337828427553177,
-0.1968848705291748,
-0.6080220937728882,
-0.6688206791877747,
-0.17729122936725616,
-0.40621745586395264,
-0.4721340835094452,
-0.2063131183385849,
0.5377121567726135,
-0.40484270453453064,
0.22970524430274963,
0.05206412076950073,
0.1372060924768448,
0.2591490149497986,
0.7309084534645081,
-0.8848362565040588,
0.4489770531654358,
0.5024397969245911,
1.123821496963501,
-0.545394778251648,
-0.20718403160572052,
-0.5197077989578247,
0.07523811608552933,
0.006926852744072676,
0.8884173035621643,
-0.20702704787254333,
-0.25766849517822266,
-0.1273411512374878,
0.017736811190843582,
-0.03770941495895386,
-0.1597176343202591,
0.7046892046928406,
-0.34706762433052063,
0.14905628561973572,
-0.2116069197654724,
-0.5658072829246521,
-0.24192047119140625,
0.4178049862384796,
-0.6093612909317017,
0.8610392808914185,
0.0029032956808805466,
-0.9305371046066284,
0.05661756545305252,
-0.007215558551251888,
-0.5873228907585144,
0.017429452389478683,
-0.07238840311765671,
-0.3569757044315338,
-0.09737346321344376,
0.15996968746185303,
0.7584798336029053,
-0.624186635017395,
0.17146669328212738,
-0.3478892147541046,
-0.5471526384353638,
0.36070823669433594,
-0.6690970659255981,
0.7751339673995972,
0.3018558919429779,
-0.40689077973365784,
-0.009017511270940304,
-0.660059928894043,
-0.23755685985088348,
-0.03660736605525017,
-0.5228871703147888,
-0.32024267315864563,
-0.17149804532527924,
0.014371328987181187,
-0.05346689745783806,
0.2097305953502655,
-0.429453045129776,
0.20539069175720215,
-0.3819252550601959,
0.34289631247520447,
0.994967520236969,
-0.12934550642967224,
0.712561309337616,
-0.45092135667800903,
0.4468623101711273,
-0.27140817046165466,
-0.15690939128398895,
-0.13748052716255188,
-0.422102153301239,
-0.6011611819267273,
-0.4860186278820038,
0.6128622889518738,
0.6927270293235779,
-0.8963028788566589,
0.3923608958721161,
-0.15711292624473572,
-0.5605578422546387,
-0.2823033332824707,
0.429733008146286,
0.2609950006008148,
0.7823178768157959,
0.30435872077941895,
0.06258384138345718,
-0.26081809401512146,
-0.6160538792610168,
-0.23687498271465302,
-0.2924482524394989,
0.050263479351997375,
0.2690854072570801,
0.2060815691947937,
-0.3128215968608856,
0.5675064921379089,
-0.44814884662628174,
-0.12231110781431198,
-0.6275284290313721,
0.008468716405332088,
0.13239340484142303,
0.48815467953681946,
0.5348637700080872,
-0.4702155888080597,
-0.3173733353614807,
-0.08520831167697906,
-0.6614750027656555,
-0.5616289973258972,
-0.2578251361846924,
-0.022540993988513947,
-0.10078466683626175,
0.5564972162246704,
-0.4075714647769928,
0.2484624832868576,
0.24022850394248962,
-0.06673289090394974,
0.5492777824401855,
0.1565701812505722,
0.08361762762069702,
-1.1910741329193115,
-0.1270666867494583,
0.04146317020058632,
-0.4660319983959198,
-0.33735519647598267,
-0.01718386635184288,
0.24448125064373016,
-0.0636942908167839,
-0.6845942735671997,
0.7109196782112122,
-0.5141708850860596,
0.0713614821434021,
-0.508959949016571,
0.28071919083595276,
-0.11214616894721985,
0.4393678605556488,
-0.4031079113483429,
0.7570775747299194,
0.6419035792350769,
-0.873029887676239,
0.47088825702667236,
0.14645427465438843,
-0.2215137630701065,
0.3197616934776306,
-0.4151177406311035,
0.04687536135315895,
-0.011102952063083649,
0.47358089685440063,
-1.175896406173706,
0.17135019600391388,
0.3950173258781433,
-0.23311422765254974,
0.44454509019851685,
-0.14460389316082,
-0.4605121910572052,
-0.0682225376367569,
-0.587553858757019,
0.6542989611625671,
0.7979597449302673,
-0.953862190246582,
0.6391823887825012,
0.09181677550077438,
-0.18591728806495667,
-0.4488813579082489,
-0.7515759468078613,
0.10558757185935974,
-0.2997758388519287,
-0.3566298186779022,
0.5259991884231567,
0.10264385491609573,
-0.02585567533969879,
-0.17728222906589508,
-0.2525765895843506,
0.03213910385966301,
0.41901493072509766,
-0.010804109275341034,
0.1673879623413086,
-0.06465128064155579,
0.35969290137290955,
0.29520654678344727,
-0.21534781157970428,
-0.24968433380126953,
-0.20943260192871094,
0.34261173009872437,
0.0163589920848608,
-0.20644859969615936,
-0.48713502287864685,
-0.10738819092512131,
0.2205350399017334,
0.19630256295204163,
0.4535825252532959,
0.7537491917610168,
-0.1624089777469635,
-0.6483988165855408,
-0.4153149425983429,
-0.293832004070282,
-0.5185693502426147,
0.10029077529907227,
-0.2771778404712677,
-1.2014464139938354,
0.23248012363910675,
-0.5807885527610779,
0.10258640348911285,
0.23296499252319336,
0.2588064670562744,
-0.16649381816387177,
0.5145207643508911,
0.8029229044914246,
-0.15895794332027435,
0.4611756205558777,
-0.05057818442583084,
-0.19182761013507843,
-0.8745967745780945,
-0.22092728316783905,
-0.7156344652175903,
-0.5803707242012024,
-0.6573286652565002,
-0.29786917567253113,
-0.027220604941248894,
0.31806594133377075,
-0.05081136152148247,
0.40161147713661194,
-0.2046879529953003,
0.4511092007160187,
0.1778569221496582,
0.39898380637168884,
0.13710449635982513,
-0.006026746239513159,
-0.22825190424919128,
0.06458714604377747,
-0.704457700252533,
-0.5927850008010864,
0.896661102771759,
0.3512475788593292,
1.0621217489242554,
0.0638386532664299,
0.8353013396263123,
0.44945114850997925,
0.35853350162506104,
-1.0722906589508057,
0.7781139016151428,
-0.04708844795823097,
0.3312651515007019,
0.04474521055817604,
-0.6844471096992493,
-0.8961673974990845,
0.4680129885673523,
-0.3229791820049286,
-0.624448835849762,
0.08976063877344131,
0.07683465629816055,
-0.016721608117222786,
0.5364996790885925,
-0.612075686454773,
0.3969457447528839,
-0.5298920273780823,
-0.37535664439201355,
-0.14383411407470703,
-0.4989006519317627,
0.5503658652305603,
-0.2549995183944702,
0.18837283551692963,
-0.13308171927928925,
-0.6068739891052246,
0.8711877465248108,
-0.3415607511997223,
1.0371452569961548,
0.06831353157758713,
-0.26686012744903564,
0.10368301719427109,
0.12236857414245605,
0.6749654412269592,
0.1187686026096344,
-0.13211120665073395,
0.04374666512012482,
-0.40650999546051025,
-0.47019892930984497,
-0.5943135023117065,
0.8052986860275269,
-0.7160958051681519,
-0.7124009132385254,
-0.4161349833011627,
-0.10533049702644348,
-0.2504587173461914,
0.1247277483344078,
0.2323109358549118,
0.5391585826873779,
-0.056916866451501846,
0.3614509403705597,
0.9467582106590271,
-0.3131292164325714,
0.7584683299064636,
0.31953972578048706,
-0.25734931230545044,
-0.40907832980155945,
0.7537275552749634,
-0.05642693117260933,
0.07907097786664963,
0.653322160243988,
0.4517025649547577,
-0.306675523519516,
-0.6657950282096863,
-0.33811479806900024,
0.06970427930355072,
-0.826329231262207,
-0.47084787487983704,
-0.7614028453826904,
-0.2854723334312439,
-0.3172958493232727,
-0.36552679538726807,
-0.08796055614948273,
-0.547095000743866,
-0.7744329571723938,
-0.17731989920139313,
0.3091012239456177,
0.43297097086906433,
0.2755562663078308,
0.5483786463737488,
-0.7665573358535767,
0.18451258540153503,
0.33559006452560425,
0.2007043957710266,
0.17655375599861145,
-0.9112651944160461,
-0.08038309961557388,
-0.4634934663772583,
-0.3895987272262573,
-0.9749274253845215,
0.24191166460514069,
0.270658016204834,
0.6260403394699097,
0.41476669907569885,
0.4820140600204468,
0.25328004360198975,
-0.4563816487789154,
0.6889274716377258,
0.33937448263168335,
-0.8793336749076843,
0.3794214725494385,
0.23525787889957428,
0.1891448199748993,
0.6368209719657898,
0.5163911581039429,
-0.3121398389339447,
-0.11874981224536896,
-0.4553138017654419,
-0.7571091651916504,
0.5018939971923828,
0.11010608077049255,
0.07890196889638901,
0.11707662791013718,
0.4016600549221039,
0.36680877208709717,
0.10286672413349152,
-0.7670331001281738,
-0.008285381831228733,
0.03478154540061951,
-0.3582255244255066,
-0.004702431615442038,
-0.3896499276161194,
0.36346495151519775,
-0.23272259533405304,
0.5458755493164062,
-0.19984830915927887,
0.13172732293605804,
0.16028015315532684,
-0.5138912200927734,
0.39246612787246704,
0.3660007417201996,
0.3431820571422577,
0.1916792243719101,
0.053629979491233826,
0.6128152012825012,
0.5726965069770813,
-0.41270962357521057,
0.4240458309650421,
-0.208872988820076,
-0.16154049336910248,
-0.08511857688426971,
0.5559640526771545,
0.7115944623947144,
0.6149281859397888,
-0.5155078768730164,
0.6968033313751221,
-0.08294535428285599,
-0.18179284036159515,
0.16600559651851654,
0.15380644798278809,
-0.13836733996868134,
0.2974647879600525,
0.38732588291168213,
0.17244838178157806,
0.28155818581581116,
-0.2716005742549896,
0.2790338397026062,
0.2975580096244812,
-0.2540045976638794,
-0.2847211956977844,
0.388830304145813,
0.5379870533943176,
-0.36101821064949036,
0.3161201477050781,
-0.23632103204727173,
-0.8000545501708984,
0.35719791054725647,
0.7199442982673645,
1.2408989667892456,
-0.07143254578113556,
0.1529596894979477,
0.0868423581123352,
0.40824398398399353,
-0.2202771157026291,
-0.09924724698066711,
-0.5226284861564636,
-0.6516551971435547,
-0.49661117792129517,
-0.6695668697357178,
-0.4408804476261139,
-0.18199199438095093,
-0.14745382964611053,
0.5117122530937195,
-0.8131005167961121,
0.07623696327209473,
-0.4588519334793091,
0.1026318147778511,
-0.31130123138427734,
-0.11512528359889984,
0.05846939608454704,
1.1501981019973755,
-0.749061107635498,
0.8324648141860962,
0.4377279281616211,
-0.032433461397886276,
-0.5754876136779785,
0.25100836157798767,
0.0009803338907659054,
-0.7692182660102844,
0.5395739674568176,
0.5320147275924683,
-0.44145479798316956,
0.1837688684463501,
-0.8944048881530762,
-0.6557146906852722,
1.2723469734191895,
0.3598995506763458,
-0.7288751602172852,
0.2536104917526245,
-0.39680448174476624,
0.16030018031597137,
-0.30776143074035645,
0.2534395754337311,
0.04947885498404503,
0.1674424111843109,
0.40991586446762085,
-0.7169820666313171,
0.4002666771411896,
-0.0944385901093483,
0.123280830681324,
-0.04413916915655136,
-0.7709112167358398,
0.6960315704345703,
-0.3489183187484741,
-0.4171360433101654,
0.12437164038419724,
0.765490710735321,
0.3303584158420563,
0.28446894884109497,
0.5137091279029846,
0.3985198140144348,
1.0229713916778564,
0.11890631914138794,
0.8767895698547363,
-0.10733141750097275,
0.14899282157421112,
0.7097570896148682,
-0.4146365225315094,
0.7919146418571472,
0.33296510577201843,
-0.030399836599826813,
0.4390987455844879,
0.6720964312553406,
0.06886347383260727,
0.5189753770828247,
0.2848544120788574,
-0.4329003095626831,
-0.23818439245224,
0.044683072715997696,
-0.2170569747686386,
0.1114901602268219,
0.04521071910858154,
-0.15717148780822754,
-0.3605143129825592,
0.31021931767463684,
0.03838364779949188,
0.0335531122982502,
-0.36289840936660767,
0.7662598490715027,
0.41074180603027344,
0.025001605972647667,
0.5278239846229553,
0.19378145039081573,
1.2637461423873901,
-0.2595956325531006,
0.10291290283203125,
-0.2386743128299713,
0.13004657626152039,
-0.14656037092208862,
-0.6098127365112305,
-0.19881293177604675,
-0.0011679428862407804,
0.0024325326085090637,
-0.36583825945854187,
1.1837244033813477,
-0.2014315128326416,
-0.3470980226993561,
0.2425508052110672,
0.4355347156524658,
0.13253918290138245,
0.21990281343460083,
-0.7520949840545654,
0.10884743183851242,
0.138106569647789,
-0.15381713211536407,
0.5709598064422607,
0.7226169109344482,
0.03191706910729408,
1.0036486387252808,
0.7306490540504456,
0.1390095204114914,
-0.32777121663093567,
-0.14832228422164917,
0.8698252439498901,
-0.851576566696167,
-0.6688786149024963,
-1.0056507587432861,
-0.01077059842646122,
0.07083026319742203,
-0.25111109018325806,
0.7376534938812256,
0.4025978446006775,
0.5049843788146973,
0.03248076140880585,
0.6120005249977112,
0.21447502076625824,
0.30601873993873596,
-0.8591124415397644,
0.5533989667892456,
-0.3668983578681946,
0.738524317741394,
-0.2211798131465912,
-0.9072252511978149,
-0.1294587254524231,
0.4223400354385376,
-0.08953456580638885,
-0.0192775409668684,
0.8314796090126038,
0.5318087935447693,
-0.0665896087884903,
0.049612924456596375,
0.26980677247047424,
0.08447382599115372,
0.3590642511844635,
0.5115465521812439,
1.0596688985824585,
-0.3775646686553955,
0.6389009356498718,
-0.1486695557832718,
-0.4297175109386444,
-0.33762985467910767,
-1.0287253856658936,
-0.9574525952339172,
-0.27543923258781433,
-0.32920020818710327,
-0.2098148763179779,
0.06032079830765724,
1.1696557998657227,
0.3963472843170166,
-0.4528091549873352,
-0.18059659004211426,
0.01861066371202469,
0.4871314465999603,
0.021283969283103943,
-0.20660674571990967,
0.30459484457969666,
-0.7495399117469788,
-0.37958064675331116,
0.3552546501159668,
0.11584477126598358,
0.2604900002479553,
0.06937766075134277,
-0.15343256294727325,
-0.06865409016609192,
-0.014922017231583595,
0.8456083536148071,
0.23392224311828613,
-0.4901374578475952,
-0.15527048707008362,
-0.21998290717601776,
-0.37997376918792725,
-0.21068152785301208,
0.7432628273963928,
-1.141192078590393,
-0.23087731003761292,
0.5484331250190735,
1.2063121795654297,
0.3083557188510895,
-0.06711491197347641,
0.21782620251178741,
-0.8264434337615967,
0.06098023056983948,
0.17895841598510742,
0.4674402177333832,
0.368348091840744,
-0.4056107699871063,
0.3247978687286377,
0.49903541803359985,
-0.5272306203842163,
-0.8749691843986511,
0.13704173266887665,
-1.1808180809020996,
-0.507576048374176,
1.3554375171661377,
-0.07435809820890427,
-0.5163920521736145,
-0.08206745982170105,
-0.5589756965637207,
0.1324280947446823,
-0.5062699913978577,
0.6705765128135681,
0.2278839647769928,
0.0020957947708666325,
-0.6495847105979919,
-0.17990106344223022,
0.3957241177558899,
0.1158326119184494,
-0.7538596987724304,
-0.016708536073565483,
0.2716396450996399,
0.34044012427330017,
-0.1724226474761963,
0.5619652271270752,
0.22689257562160492,
0.057697538286447525,
-0.21192018687725067,
-0.09219620376825333,
-0.056097645312547684,
-0.2997407913208008,
-0.3811083137989044,
0.34635093808174133,
0.13551567494869232,
-0.1692667156457901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03718v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03718v1
|
Generalization-Enhanced Code Vulnerability Detection via Multi-Task Instruction Fine-Tuning
| 2024-06-06T03:29:05 | 2024-06-06T03:29:05 |
Xiaohu Du, Ming Wen, Jiahao Zhu, Zifan Xie, Bin Ji, Huijun Liu, Xuanhua Shi, Hai Jin
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Code Pre-trained Models (CodePTMs) based vulnerability detection have
achieved promising results over recent years. However, these models struggle to
generalize as they typically learn superficial mapping from source code to
labels instead of understanding the root causes of code vulnerabilities,
resulting in poor performance in real-world scenarios beyond the training
instances. To tackle this challenge, we introduce VulLLM, a novel framework
that integrates multi-task learning with Large Language Models (LLMs) to
effectively mine deep-seated vulnerability features. Specifically, we construct
two auxiliary tasks beyond the vulnerability detection task. First, we utilize
the vulnerability patches to construct a vulnerability localization task.
Second, based on the vulnerability features extracted from patches, we leverage
GPT-4 to construct a vulnerability interpretation task. VulLLM innovatively
augments vulnerability classification by leveraging generative LLMs to
understand complex vulnerability patterns, thus compelling the model to capture
the root causes of vulnerabilities rather than overfitting to spurious features
of a single task. The experiments conducted on six large datasets demonstrate
that VulLLM surpasses seven state-of-the-art models in terms of effectiveness,
generalization, and robustness.
|
[
0.055915817618370056,
-0.7317571043968201,
0.464519739151001,
-0.07904160767793655,
-0.07574062049388885,
0.1668132245540619,
-0.20988327264785767,
-0.3161986768245697,
-0.37005963921546936,
0.7032429575920105,
-0.3407619595527649,
-0.8338253498077393,
-0.5323609709739685,
-0.3866731822490692,
-0.24680574238300323,
1.066811203956604,
0.25637534260749817,
-0.3346811830997467,
0.01998191885650158,
-0.12460213899612427,
-0.7927157878875732,
-0.6951667070388794,
-0.09185609221458435,
-0.098441481590271,
0.12153694778680801,
0.5919906497001648,
0.4222593903541565,
0.1531025618314743,
0.48752424120903015,
0.2946881651878357,
0.4762112498283386,
0.1988922655582428,
-0.4706152379512787,
0.14350271224975586,
0.09926728904247284,
-0.7523230314254761,
-0.4180603623390198,
-0.3264789283275604,
0.039547149091959,
0.19348475337028503,
-0.005170371383428574,
0.29710492491722107,
0.0964982807636261,
0.38386642932891846,
-0.7140527963638306,
-0.04206714406609535,
-0.9640242457389832,
-0.13838888704776764,
-0.29943954944610596,
-0.23375511169433594,
-0.41229933500289917,
-0.15892232954502106,
-0.025696899741888046,
-0.15783381462097168,
0.5419889092445374,
-0.17075489461421967,
0.5326345562934875,
0.1594715118408203,
-0.36752012372016907,
-0.07536936551332474,
-0.6741787791252136,
0.9521345496177673,
-0.5809195041656494,
0.3381168246269226,
0.439686119556427,
0.20787455141544342,
-0.06807397305965424,
-0.4368695914745331,
-0.036796290427446365,
-0.4155081808567047,
0.12348949909210205,
-0.37597617506980896,
-0.3028132915496826,
-0.0692543238401413,
0.2520630955696106,
0.39848724007606506,
-1.0372769832611084,
0.21524783968925476,
-0.3477802872657776,
-0.4599934220314026,
0.2579604387283325,
0.15443892776966095,
0.1600758135318756,
0.1980571448802948,
-0.45599305629730225,
0.14901305735111237,
-0.7469702363014221,
0.07826776802539825,
0.15467587113380432,
0.3026949167251587,
-0.23679974675178528,
0.073097825050354,
0.26425492763519287,
0.8800651431083679,
-0.23387916386127472,
-0.018094288185238838,
0.3898855447769165,
-0.12176689505577087,
-0.4616159498691559,
-0.4531548321247101,
0.43187206983566284,
0.161623015999794,
-0.05319277569651604,
-0.26546141505241394,
-0.1405334621667862,
0.17130227386951447,
0.5145925283432007,
-0.6277150511741638,
-0.3472289443016052,
0.3366434872150421,
-0.337536484003067,
-0.5242120623588562,
0.16570565104484558,
-0.742392897605896,
-0.6118717789649963,
-0.13312052190303802,
0.04472899064421654,
-0.4643608033657074,
-0.46190792322158813,
0.26328325271606445,
-0.016707967966794968,
0.2840220630168915,
0.14504297077655792,
-0.42875272035598755,
-0.07385000586509705,
0.6912160515785217,
0.7513704895973206,
-0.08362305909395218,
-0.2095905840396881,
-0.9213130474090576,
0.08026320487260818,
-0.10095320641994476,
0.856099545955658,
-0.6934089064598083,
-0.3220108449459076,
0.11383842676877975,
-0.11869199573993683,
0.07571280002593994,
-0.5467637777328491,
0.29622378945350647,
-0.43245118856430054,
-0.1871940791606903,
0.09852185100317001,
-0.12727965414524078,
0.051276881247758865,
0.5178405046463013,
-0.5572720170021057,
1.134726643562317,
0.3562985956668854,
-0.5959949493408203,
0.1545114517211914,
-0.47090616822242737,
-0.42552998661994934,
0.01807798072695732,
-0.06617303937673569,
-0.6087327599525452,
0.3961084485054016,
0.34331217408180237,
0.6432000398635864,
-0.3948286175727844,
0.06213327497243881,
-0.3888900876045227,
-0.3525930345058441,
0.15806987881660461,
-0.30942025780677795,
0.41515058279037476,
0.283149778842926,
-0.5697643160820007,
0.31920352578163147,
-0.5199827551841736,
0.216716930270195,
0.036030229181051254,
-0.3104296624660492,
-0.5439870357513428,
-0.23552845418453217,
0.08263573050498962,
0.12819397449493408,
0.21445679664611816,
-0.3303241729736328,
0.40066733956336975,
-0.540293276309967,
0.338146448135376,
0.7501301169395447,
-0.08079072833061218,
0.4109252393245697,
-0.19347058236598969,
0.695184051990509,
0.14124274253845215,
0.6258453130722046,
-0.31163841485977173,
-0.35967910289764404,
-0.48056674003601074,
-0.403852641582489,
0.014627193100750446,
0.8524987101554871,
-0.609585702419281,
0.28074198961257935,
-0.08730380237102509,
-0.43041589856147766,
-0.3865135610103607,
0.4469664394855499,
0.6292963624000549,
0.23929277062416077,
0.5473732948303223,
-0.11121649295091629,
-0.6013643145561218,
-0.40392181277275085,
-0.4097207486629486,
0.008200236596167088,
-0.09573641419410706,
0.04620280861854553,
0.3953109085559845,
-0.6263120174407959,
0.6025046706199646,
-0.8121284246444702,
-0.38005462288856506,
-0.3009147047996521,
0.1553957462310791,
0.35993558168411255,
0.5371334552764893,
0.6771788001060486,
-0.7804804444313049,
-0.13839469850063324,
0.22630007565021515,
-0.5562238097190857,
0.014146452769637108,
-0.03176723048090935,
0.17559786140918732,
-0.049606695771217346,
0.6197645664215088,
-0.23290540277957916,
0.4098752439022064,
0.5886427164077759,
-0.26530975103378296,
0.5764238834381104,
-0.47630175948143005,
0.21076036989688873,
-0.8527833819389343,
-0.15264500677585602,
-0.054049331694841385,
-0.2576965093612671,
-0.7958484292030334,
0.6852412819862366,
0.5062485933303833,
-0.42243802547454834,
-0.4119538962841034,
0.30173054337501526,
-0.7425757646560669,
0.014625177718698978,
-0.3212924003601074,
-0.36440685391426086,
0.05573480576276779,
0.345843642950058,
-0.5305426716804504,
0.6255197525024414,
0.7383716702461243,
-0.49895328283309937,
0.5200859904289246,
-0.45282959938049316,
0.020799437537789345,
0.3954635560512543,
-0.5151016116142273,
0.6497440338134766,
0.11715158820152283,
-0.03434225544333458,
-0.8511123657226562,
-0.10960670560598373,
0.07654404640197754,
-0.3050210773944855,
0.6442644596099854,
-0.3072855770587921,
-0.20221132040023804,
-0.6288692951202393,
-0.745059609413147,
0.22570377588272095,
0.42624008655548096,
-0.24965983629226685,
0.6591646075248718,
0.28417715430259705,
0.20593173801898956,
-0.6235589385032654,
-0.7353609800338745,
-0.006135404109954834,
-0.38204607367515564,
-0.5311375260353088,
0.05940115079283714,
-0.07576902210712433,
-0.04619989171624184,
-0.208968847990036,
-0.33063197135925293,
-0.42890363931655884,
0.4058394432067871,
0.5401851534843445,
0.2683020532131195,
-0.33363381028175354,
0.2683026194572449,
-0.18056222796440125,
-0.1753852665424347,
-0.22056487202644348,
-0.6624206304550171,
0.48200854659080505,
-0.4511536657810211,
-0.7066091299057007,
0.1909506767988205,
0.4714617133140564,
0.7464368939399719,
-0.7392014861106873,
0.3493407070636749,
0.818250298500061,
-0.4028546214103699,
-0.3881085216999054,
-0.8553538918495178,
-0.13627944886684418,
-0.4223032593727112,
0.5101972222328186,
-0.4823162257671356,
-1.1892989873886108,
0.44730237126350403,
-0.26959508657455444,
0.06870584189891815,
0.18809324502944946,
0.38463857769966125,
0.20000258088111877,
0.6238325238227844,
0.9388795495033264,
-0.6028954386711121,
0.37390267848968506,
-0.5084220767021179,
0.4030047059059143,
-0.5691778063774109,
-0.003507206216454506,
-0.622888445854187,
0.08820996433496475,
-0.28666022419929504,
-0.9656405448913574,
0.44379276037216187,
0.10789050906896591,
-0.08548479527235031,
0.5081949830055237,
-0.754996657371521,
0.5321359038352966,
0.3985005021095276,
0.3892516493797302,
0.015568205155432224,
-0.1994314342737198,
0.056527771055698395,
0.12148769199848175,
-0.45910072326660156,
-0.26996931433677673,
1.3443316221237183,
0.38983696699142456,
0.9702565670013428,
0.19468186795711517,
0.8666538596153259,
0.6024434566497803,
0.26565101742744446,
-0.39214587211608887,
0.2410249263048172,
-0.12727148830890656,
-0.3348044157028198,
-0.2872692048549652,
-0.20882897078990936,
-1.0251647233963013,
0.1515459269285202,
-0.03751835972070694,
-0.6522432565689087,
0.14016568660736084,
0.29806312918663025,
-0.5380917191505432,
0.19715523719787598,
-1.0140106678009033,
0.9990257620811462,
-0.26936665177345276,
-0.23803329467773438,
-0.3299948573112488,
-0.4387470483779907,
0.5407841801643372,
-0.21176904439926147,
0.5709895491600037,
-0.07048165053129196,
0.02129429019987583,
-0.03201423957943916,
-0.11560080200433731,
1.0573910474777222,
-0.43350833654403687,
-0.18710128962993622,
0.12316903471946716,
0.026044508442282677,
0.6895412802696228,
0.2398557960987091,
-0.14533181488513947,
0.1382274180650711,
-0.4745568335056305,
-0.4907173216342926,
-0.361825555562973,
0.8664162755012512,
-0.4926236867904663,
-0.6469463109970093,
-0.2719060182571411,
-0.6653605699539185,
-0.1694333255290985,
-0.023582730442285538,
0.26725155115127563,
0.6769869327545166,
-0.1559852510690689,
0.05356059595942497,
0.8845344185829163,
-0.51463383436203,
0.24745625257492065,
0.5644810199737549,
-0.0743308812379837,
-0.01972150057554245,
0.9858741760253906,
-0.13125856220722198,
0.09960202872753143,
0.49081578850746155,
0.16562193632125854,
0.005561479367315769,
-0.8093650937080383,
-0.21771490573883057,
-0.16657884418964386,
-0.5354729890823364,
-0.781533420085907,
-0.6041683554649353,
-0.11969424039125443,
-0.6612343192100525,
-0.26095762848854065,
-0.0660737082362175,
0.2576299011707306,
-0.2872900366783142,
-0.20200282335281372,
0.5359368324279785,
0.4497194290161133,
0.06453024595975876,
0.07589700073003769,
-1.178653597831726,
0.5733311772346497,
0.4776637554168701,
0.0977155864238739,
-0.30038774013519287,
-0.5469156503677368,
-0.3470167815685272,
-0.1598835289478302,
-0.294305682182312,
-1.0671610832214355,
0.391203373670578,
0.2665683329105377,
0.633714497089386,
0.12172254920005798,
0.12497628480195999,
0.5581576228141785,
-0.4320014715194702,
0.7157741189002991,
0.18939070403575897,
-0.9247090220451355,
0.8774709701538086,
-0.2366860806941986,
0.6179848909378052,
0.32931283116340637,
0.02648172341287136,
-0.11427260935306549,
-0.9012150168418884,
-0.26447129249572754,
-0.9556112289428711,
0.25279390811920166,
-0.02232106402516365,
0.3444876968860626,
0.05943800136446953,
0.1711542308330536,
0.12062741070985794,
0.028101308271288872,
-0.7278924584388733,
-0.12605342268943787,
-0.21953043341636658,
0.08848966658115387,
0.23465900123119354,
-0.4308120310306549,
0.131710022687912,
-0.2648371458053589,
0.2491280436515808,
-0.2891544997692108,
0.2880471348762512,
-0.04546823352575302,
-0.6372835040092468,
-0.012611952610313892,
0.6089401245117188,
0.846768856048584,
0.6358059048652649,
-0.049786705523729324,
0.30028262734413147,
0.41517898440361023,
-0.5916714668273926,
0.16673114895820618,
0.2031889259815216,
0.2787209153175354,
-0.09395448863506317,
0.7579846978187561,
0.6755966544151306,
0.44884052872657776,
-0.5949598550796509,
0.7348858714103699,
-0.016834121197462082,
0.1933470070362091,
-0.18086355924606323,
0.3599260151386261,
-0.1542041152715683,
0.47749534249305725,
0.5849131345748901,
0.23194268345832825,
0.24405455589294434,
-0.5864024758338928,
0.4898953139781952,
0.4532460868358612,
-0.3183242678642273,
-0.4156986176967621,
0.4402257800102234,
0.2085689902305603,
-0.18690790235996246,
0.3624415695667267,
-0.10814350843429565,
-0.6953768134117126,
0.8151910901069641,
0.46863335371017456,
1.0147345066070557,
-0.8559866547584534,
0.10486948490142822,
0.07815967500209808,
0.710382342338562,
0.2002062201499939,
0.426259309053421,
0.006800471339374781,
-0.4584680497646332,
-0.5084740519523621,
-0.5096566677093506,
-0.04613133892416954,
0.43394383788108826,
-0.6088101863861084,
0.3110969066619873,
-0.3324801027774811,
-0.047670260071754456,
-0.29389843344688416,
-0.4608529806137085,
-0.982598602771759,
-0.08438034355640411,
0.09116585552692413,
0.5650658011436462,
-1.0142802000045776,
1.0883034467697144,
0.6194595098495483,
-0.06874608993530273,
-0.5505761504173279,
0.18158410489559174,
0.15450111031532288,
-0.8612620234489441,
0.4062933325767517,
0.54443359375,
0.22917857766151428,
-0.1786598414182663,
-0.36537301540374756,
-0.5410134792327881,
0.7892602682113647,
0.7863564491271973,
-0.7270412445068359,
-0.11519549787044525,
0.0911611020565033,
0.3483295738697052,
-0.19200924038887024,
0.09207935631275177,
0.54436194896698,
0.3478320837020874,
-0.44147998094558716,
-0.7865504622459412,
-0.08648965507745743,
-0.27477067708969116,
0.049999989569187164,
0.5190477967262268,
-0.06475920975208282,
0.8293744325637817,
-0.5696802139282227,
0.17442215979099274,
-0.42068639397621155,
0.4734188914299011,
0.12944509088993073,
0.353314608335495,
0.5742670297622681,
0.49317774176597595,
0.6598210334777832,
0.009663687087595463,
1.0947091579437256,
-0.15452507138252258,
0.36663922667503357,
1.23793363571167,
-0.24839092791080475,
0.4895535409450531,
0.07060998678207397,
-0.1458457112312317,
0.4979032278060913,
0.2334718108177185,
-0.011932681314647198,
0.601041316986084,
0.4246671795845032,
-0.35424426198005676,
-0.3521975874900818,
0.16373728215694427,
-0.5784411430358887,
0.38544952869415283,
0.4410577118396759,
-0.2268652319908142,
-0.4383959472179413,
0.7185542583465576,
-0.1228596642613411,
0.05732601881027222,
-0.4860265552997589,
0.43982064723968506,
0.15502654016017914,
-0.13907268643379211,
0.6020029187202454,
0.06683894246816635,
0.8092235922813416,
-0.7780144214630127,
-0.21009744703769684,
-0.02870642952620983,
0.4384600818157196,
-0.13593052327632904,
-0.4905654191970825,
0.5375460982322693,
0.26570215821266174,
-0.3339681923389435,
-0.1959347277879715,
1.2289528846740723,
-0.31811243295669556,
-0.27971428632736206,
0.4573541581630707,
0.3120138645172119,
-0.20658370852470398,
-0.6806043982505798,
-0.6718204021453857,
0.2477404773235321,
-0.022105956450104713,
-0.14711430668830872,
0.5188291072845459,
0.6009771227836609,
-0.03368188068270683,
0.4304007291793823,
0.7038567066192627,
-0.09078552573919296,
0.15279671549797058,
0.11225856840610504,
1.1287826299667358,
-0.5672441124916077,
-0.2948073744773865,
-1.029863953590393,
0.8127769231796265,
-0.2344290316104889,
-0.17850813269615173,
0.7634009122848511,
0.5374875068664551,
0.6127535104751587,
-0.42227622866630554,
0.7754919528961182,
0.1345338225364685,
0.2597755789756775,
-0.4531140923500061,
0.30910971760749817,
-0.16409389674663544,
0.5271286368370056,
-0.2587992250919342,
-0.7275641560554504,
-0.5199787616729736,
0.34288308024406433,
-0.3399752974510193,
-0.15423928201198578,
0.6669643521308899,
1.0055357217788696,
-0.04046717658638954,
-0.5609991550445557,
0.7591162919998169,
0.17479552328586578,
0.42900580167770386,
0.8840407729148865,
0.6686460375785828,
-0.3166161775588989,
0.5448462963104248,
0.06142928823828697,
-0.34304794669151306,
-0.3778192698955536,
-0.8993451595306396,
-1.0693490505218506,
-0.5260470509529114,
-0.2615097463130951,
-0.20692317187786102,
0.19831499457359314,
0.6457926034927368,
0.8980213403701782,
-0.9587019681930542,
0.20792369544506073,
-0.08936415612697601,
0.222699835896492,
-0.29559260606765747,
-0.24572481215000153,
0.23875592648983002,
-0.6061142086982727,
-0.10672136396169662,
0.6032631993293762,
0.5753785967826843,
-0.24460282921791077,
-0.21410346031188965,
0.09315570443868637,
0.1765730082988739,
-0.21173818409442902,
0.6451515555381775,
0.20048105716705322,
-0.6075142621994019,
-0.42888501286506653,
0.12329723685979843,
-0.2612619698047638,
-0.12419427186250687,
1.1356496810913086,
-0.6386911273002625,
0.39783939719200134,
0.3328537940979004,
0.7846153974533081,
0.3457900285720825,
-0.5053946375846863,
0.47839266061782837,
-1.1684437990188599,
0.3778778612613678,
0.34220725297927856,
0.24585099518299103,
0.23916202783584595,
-0.7503766417503357,
0.4653364419937134,
0.2366718053817749,
-0.4223688244819641,
-1.0419672727584839,
0.35234108567237854,
-0.6813346147537231,
-0.4538341462612152,
1.0208243131637573,
-0.4846951961517334,
-0.08797737956047058,
-0.6286611557006836,
-0.2080298811197281,
0.040633443742990494,
-0.10484429448843002,
0.43613681197166443,
0.21960215270519257,
0.3503812551498413,
-0.23641827702522278,
-0.6964804530143738,
0.27092650532722473,
0.03438751772046089,
-0.9976805448532104,
0.28111621737480164,
0.4712766706943512,
0.1824733316898346,
0.0458553172647953,
0.6813589334487915,
-0.028859680518507957,
0.4751446843147278,
-0.28392294049263,
0.14432647824287415,
-0.25165921449661255,
-0.4013079106807709,
-0.5551729798316956,
0.401661217212677,
0.2532182037830353,
-0.2780226469039917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03712v1
|
A Survey on Medical Large Language Models: Technology, Application, Trustworthiness, and Future Directions
| 2024-06-06T03:15:13 | 2024-06-06T03:15:13 |
Lei Liu, Xiaoyan Yang, Junchi Lei, Xiaoyang Liu, Yue Shen, Zhiqiang Zhang, Peng Wei, Jinjie Gu, Zhixuan Chu, Zhan Qin, Kui Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs), such as GPT series models, have received
substantial attention due to their impressive capabilities for generating and
understanding human-level language. More recently, LLMs have emerged as an
innovative and powerful adjunct in the medical field, transforming traditional
practices and heralding a new era of enhanced healthcare services. This survey
provides a comprehensive overview of Medical Large Language Models (Med-LLMs),
outlining their evolution from general to the medical-specific domain (i.e,
Technology and Application), as well as their transformative impact on
healthcare (e.g., Trustworthiness and Safety). Concretely, starting from the
fundamental history and technology of LLMs, we first delve into the progressive
adaptation and refinements of general LLM models in the medical domain,
especially emphasizing the advanced algorithms that boost the LLMs' performance
in handling complicated medical environments, including clinical reasoning,
knowledge graph, retrieval-augmented generation, human alignment, and
multi-modal learning. Secondly, we explore the extensive applications of
Med-LLMs across domains such as clinical decision support, report generation,
and medical education, illustrating their potential to streamline healthcare
services and augment patient outcomes. Finally, recognizing the imperative and
responsible innovation, we discuss the challenges of ensuring fairness,
accountability, privacy, and robustness in Med-LLMs applications. Finally, we
conduct a concise discussion for anticipating possible future trajectories of
Med-LLMs, identifying avenues for the prudent expansion of Med-LLMs. By
consolidating above-mentioned insights, this review seeks to provide a
comprehensive investigation of the potential strengths and limitations of
Med-LLMs for professionals and researchers, ensuring a responsible landscape in
the healthcare setting.
|
[
-0.19857434928417206,
-0.7250779867172241,
1.0762706995010376,
-0.2548181712627411,
-0.09867473691701889,
0.19588762521743774,
-0.2158990055322647,
-0.6596783399581909,
0.10483212023973465,
0.6552407145500183,
-0.39199450612068176,
-0.41621074080467224,
-0.8669594526290894,
-0.021467270329594612,
-0.30675002932548523,
0.7622588872909546,
-0.039680734276771545,
0.5208444595336914,
-0.15762491524219513,
-0.07312200218439102,
-0.34213653206825256,
-0.9122167825698853,
-0.6736752986907959,
-0.62064129114151,
0.514457643032074,
0.02193012647330761,
0.8029631972312927,
0.620589554309845,
0.7387466430664062,
0.34692832827568054,
-0.10439152270555496,
0.14043055474758148,
-0.3363081216812134,
0.22265104949474335,
-0.1520371288061142,
-0.30579352378845215,
-0.8031338453292847,
0.042394641786813736,
0.7190849781036377,
0.9848016500473022,
-0.18009763956069946,
0.03814556077122688,
-0.09829190373420715,
0.5094369649887085,
-0.17205935716629028,
0.21908283233642578,
-0.4179416298866272,
-0.0686694085597992,
-0.09939072281122208,
-0.38739046454429626,
-0.25906988978385925,
-0.427684485912323,
0.33767756819725037,
-0.20222407579421997,
-0.1475435346364975,
0.11814634501934052,
0.5629284381866455,
0.09518755227327347,
-0.611922025680542,
-0.43507248163223267,
-0.8181838989257812,
0.8395854830741882,
-0.7953890562057495,
0.4812752306461334,
0.14394475519657135,
0.4837411046028137,
-0.5154545307159424,
-0.9681316018104553,
-0.22446712851524353,
-0.5018138289451599,
0.23203305900096893,
-0.0425814650952816,
0.005307027604430914,
0.1143953874707222,
-0.0186419989913702,
0.5090837478637695,
-0.4447495937347412,
0.5679768323898315,
-0.3309323191642761,
-0.08981917053461075,
0.5764201283454895,
0.5004005432128906,
0.43091079592704773,
0.221339613199234,
-0.2011173963546753,
0.25647369027137756,
-0.9984256029129028,
-0.2868140935897827,
-0.2800956964492798,
-0.1230531558394432,
-0.2519090175628662,
0.7009474635124207,
0.0912451520562172,
0.5199243426322937,
-0.2540430426597595,
-0.6650754809379578,
0.17598910629749298,
-0.37795692682266235,
-0.39418458938598633,
-0.17718292772769928,
0.7962064743041992,
0.4079664647579193,
0.22900165617465973,
-0.07366626709699631,
-0.14727984368801117,
-0.007095911540091038,
0.1794992983341217,
-0.7122946381568909,
0.09359331429004669,
0.31371212005615234,
-0.7766046524047852,
-0.4064847230911255,
-0.3917185068130493,
-0.4604508876800537,
-0.7817060351371765,
-0.4369852542877197,
0.11594171822071075,
-0.3727189004421234,
-0.2571316659450531,
0.43054208159446716,
0.35815271735191345,
0.23713746666908264,
0.42255958914756775,
-0.6574757099151611,
0.2853122353553772,
0.9395279288291931,
0.746807336807251,
-0.21879808604717255,
-0.07378824055194855,
-0.09928872436285019,
0.1924770623445511,
-0.42734986543655396,
0.48360809683799744,
-0.44291552901268005,
-0.6700060367584229,
0.2753639221191406,
0.13594956696033478,
0.09310969710350037,
-0.6898061633110046,
0.4730510413646698,
-0.5109675526618958,
0.1034766435623169,
-0.04901016876101494,
-0.6859719157218933,
-0.13780155777931213,
0.5005224347114563,
-0.5397022366523743,
0.3128361105918884,
-0.04730060324072838,
-0.4509497582912445,
0.2198459953069687,
-0.8154952526092529,
-0.42520469427108765,
0.15843471884727478,
-0.422251433134079,
-0.40073469281196594,
0.34716150164604187,
0.05416951701045036,
0.7204968929290771,
-0.8591669201850891,
0.5537645220756531,
-0.32569804787635803,
-0.12739628553390503,
0.5703545212745667,
-0.43727168440818787,
0.7609694600105286,
0.2960445284843445,
0.00894815381616354,
0.2983093559741974,
-0.5962548851966858,
-0.06677693873643875,
0.2781241536140442,
-0.2689698338508606,
-0.23205800354480743,
0.09753861278295517,
0.01771675981581211,
0.3185606300830841,
0.3397011160850525,
-0.3347487151622772,
0.13328228890895844,
-0.3824988007545471,
0.801262378692627,
0.5866429805755615,
0.2585732936859131,
0.2703671157360077,
-0.45665618777275085,
0.713204026222229,
-0.12012877315282822,
0.5732053518295288,
-0.1859532594680786,
-0.5456956624984741,
-0.13218681514263153,
-0.4519153833389282,
0.19408456981182098,
0.3786274492740631,
-0.5823262929916382,
0.23821169137954712,
-0.4063118100166321,
-0.5109872817993164,
-0.4217977225780487,
-0.15494249761104584,
0.026291603222489357,
0.5205360651016235,
0.008185350336134434,
-0.1477956920862198,
-0.2602303624153137,
-1.0152559280395508,
-0.11504340916872025,
-0.2556503415107727,
0.03865177184343338,
0.45047906041145325,
0.3774193823337555,
-0.6899721026420593,
0.49886929988861084,
-0.3832296133041382,
-0.043943993747234344,
-0.31387168169021606,
-0.2790420949459076,
0.20592090487480164,
0.28814297914505005,
0.45081666111946106,
-0.8377001881599426,
-0.16231246292591095,
0.12020425498485565,
-0.7481778860092163,
0.03967467322945595,
0.06340298801660538,
0.24641597270965576,
0.09647425264120102,
0.41051727533340454,
-0.5684594511985779,
-0.12690375745296478,
0.9606386423110962,
-0.2907043695449829,
0.5340192317962646,
-0.3639191687107086,
0.2032189518213272,
-1.3710730075836182,
0.1836833506822586,
0.04271232336759567,
-0.27013635635375977,
-0.6390872001647949,
0.13824798166751862,
-0.0828339010477066,
0.045792900025844574,
-0.2550838887691498,
0.7242757678031921,
-0.5117905139923096,
-0.05424033850431442,
-0.3286716938018799,
-0.012279359623789787,
-0.31248152256011963,
-0.21937447786331177,
-0.06616689264774323,
0.5654075145721436,
0.6033164858818054,
-0.47232526540756226,
0.46581703424453735,
0.12063807994127274,
-0.3745657205581665,
0.543607771396637,
-0.5433245301246643,
0.002031839918345213,
0.09404385089874268,
0.2900107502937317,
-0.670415461063385,
-0.3247458040714264,
-0.015536163933575153,
-0.40925583243370056,
0.3739078938961029,
0.0315021350979805,
-0.7384760975837708,
-0.5180492997169495,
-0.0390816330909729,
0.38692688941955566,
0.7055105566978455,
-0.17424066364765167,
0.427012175321579,
0.7353219389915466,
-0.5216248631477356,
-0.41766393184661865,
-0.6793360710144043,
0.45932793617248535,
-0.12288200110197067,
-0.5009331107139587,
0.01871638558804989,
-0.10814923793077469,
-0.49080634117126465,
-0.24537310004234314,
-0.013161382637917995,
-0.1568373739719391,
0.14154177904129028,
0.25259679555892944,
0.7038179636001587,
-0.27598482370376587,
0.19222500920295715,
-0.07482454925775528,
-0.04155552759766579,
0.3723948001861572,
-0.30788925290107727,
0.5631412863731384,
-0.1621313840150833,
-0.4516882002353668,
-0.2949303686618805,
0.3853324055671692,
0.9295366406440735,
-0.0990113615989685,
0.7551882863044739,
0.4127155840396881,
-0.4655335247516632,
0.24915941059589386,
-0.8345757126808167,
-0.2729186713695526,
-0.42362844944000244,
0.7249073386192322,
-0.03666155785322189,
-1.3623859882354736,
0.4027191996574402,
-0.4533708095550537,
0.19957518577575684,
0.36322593688964844,
1.0129389762878418,
0.09539222717285156,
0.9550437927246094,
0.6195029616355896,
-0.15473201870918274,
0.10895109921693802,
0.17974260449409485,
0.2534024119377136,
-0.6231314539909363,
-0.5111546516418457,
-0.44241848587989807,
0.02976733073592186,
-0.8870967030525208,
-0.3940260112285614,
0.6754056215286255,
-0.4120863378047943,
-0.1827564686536789,
-0.38633978366851807,
-0.2540971338748932,
0.022134074941277504,
0.11218921095132828,
0.05814671888947487,
0.5684753060340881,
-0.12934169173240662,
0.057120490819215775,
0.005695165600627661,
-0.4553370475769043,
-0.5078426003456116,
1.2270256280899048,
0.8407116532325745,
0.9586807489395142,
0.06563719362020493,
0.5057096481323242,
0.1299782246351242,
0.5938330888748169,
-0.8028535842895508,
0.5240906476974487,
-0.26928606629371643,
-0.7254815697669983,
-0.25078874826431274,
-0.46456462144851685,
-0.7287850975990295,
-0.07274048030376434,
-0.1875023990869522,
-0.4395577013492584,
-0.25199830532073975,
0.08905376493930817,
-0.23782230913639069,
0.4216938316822052,
-0.4939044415950775,
0.4359751343727112,
-0.4476169943809509,
-0.23652981221675873,
-0.2723836302757263,
-0.736304759979248,
0.4801844656467438,
-0.3944963812828064,
0.38015982508659363,
0.04232430085539818,
-0.35985779762268066,
0.43551546335220337,
-0.21357089281082153,
0.7681220769882202,
0.012530453503131866,
-0.4487728476524353,
0.03395427390933037,
-0.060546956956386566,
0.4664810597896576,
-0.01007839571684599,
0.12431133538484573,
0.29926425218582153,
0.07530070096254349,
-0.1047215387225151,
-0.2658153772354126,
0.8877193927764893,
-0.5374688506126404,
-0.6699146032333374,
-0.3748922646045685,
-0.7269952893257141,
-0.6918528079986572,
0.3530258536338806,
-0.051703229546546936,
0.4543251693248749,
-0.36162298917770386,
0.1949455589056015,
0.897905170917511,
-0.4665180742740631,
0.18829946219921112,
0.5333152413368225,
-0.46151837706565857,
-0.33308038115501404,
0.5350087285041809,
0.029817067086696625,
0.3337858021259308,
0.3541109561920166,
0.2537734806537628,
-0.5031776428222656,
-1.0127885341644287,
-0.26216939091682434,
0.606711208820343,
-0.4339269697666168,
0.10663585364818573,
-0.5348250865936279,
-0.36529695987701416,
-0.404195636510849,
-0.1619643121957779,
-0.3672710955142975,
-0.22027575969696045,
-0.10449311137199402,
0.059440117329359055,
0.32097917795181274,
1.0121430158615112,
0.3262092173099518,
0.11540526896715164,
-0.8455952405929565,
0.2037746161222458,
0.10096549987792969,
0.6253616809844971,
-0.1733027994632721,
-0.2799811065196991,
-0.08249276876449585,
-0.27032235264778137,
-0.004062049090862274,
-0.619722306728363,
0.400216281414032,
-0.24649985134601593,
0.5568870902061462,
0.4429822862148285,
-0.4214782416820526,
0.32699909806251526,
-0.9060004353523254,
0.8496710658073425,
0.5210300087928772,
-0.4759594202041626,
0.071055106818676,
-0.5267278552055359,
0.16053228080272675,
0.2225116640329361,
0.4055887460708618,
-0.6139619946479797,
-0.09620832651853561,
-0.33748847246170044,
-0.5814791917800903,
0.1366654634475708,
-0.2894863486289978,
0.1809527575969696,
0.12443314492702484,
0.5025720000267029,
0.10353907942771912,
0.23615561425685883,
-0.4816902279853821,
-0.26590535044670105,
0.3719785511493683,
-0.32861095666885376,
-0.2303953617811203,
-0.3314817249774933,
-0.2986006736755371,
-0.008212561719119549,
0.550804615020752,
-0.03098123148083687,
0.21559187769889832,
0.03570117801427841,
0.2618090808391571,
0.004429035820066929,
0.7192768454551697,
0.7628185153007507,
0.7559410333633423,
0.04857608675956726,
0.04046899825334549,
0.009019115939736366,
-0.7704748511314392,
0.18850241601467133,
0.10259167850017548,
0.09893669188022614,
-0.16004258394241333,
0.13611364364624023,
0.33532795310020447,
0.0939425379037857,
-0.8567931652069092,
0.49790459871292114,
0.08446212857961655,
-0.18970319628715515,
-0.37264543771743774,
-0.24588797986507416,
0.39257878065109253,
0.4493773579597473,
0.12284988909959793,
-0.12848372757434845,
0.17216484248638153,
-0.6154706478118896,
-0.012994739226996899,
0.6004160046577454,
-0.2575315237045288,
-0.18176235258579254,
0.6432691812515259,
0.05767258256673813,
-0.12038470059633255,
0.21862563490867615,
0.34865570068359375,
-0.0815076157450676,
0.34085196256637573,
0.688335657119751,
0.7814263105392456,
-0.3816687762737274,
-0.08373039960861206,
-0.054107606410980225,
0.2971794903278351,
-0.307491660118103,
0.2047211229801178,
0.5387343764305115,
-0.4762716591358185,
-0.5782954096794128,
-0.40091243386268616,
-0.5261722803115845,
0.5311087369918823,
-0.37150442600250244,
0.12095986306667328,
-0.5299126505851746,
-0.5542140603065491,
-0.025622211396694183,
-0.08651193976402283,
-0.5711745023727417,
0.20974081754684448,
0.3018265664577484,
0.9656276106834412,
-0.37157341837882996,
0.8669538497924805,
0.886250376701355,
0.028441153466701508,
-0.5388500690460205,
-0.20120495557785034,
0.2228441685438156,
-1.088950753211975,
0.3550761938095093,
-0.2945905327796936,
-0.1281639188528061,
-0.2542397379875183,
-0.5821034908294678,
-0.6309166550636292,
1.1141679286956787,
0.26746252179145813,
-0.7992448806762695,
-0.49304038286209106,
0.27737483382225037,
0.6410657167434692,
-0.4808562994003296,
-0.08801929652690887,
0.49238643050193787,
0.29643237590789795,
-0.11260206252336502,
-1.1586112976074219,
0.21734635531902313,
0.046250585466623306,
0.1350703239440918,
0.11612292379140854,
-0.5710959434509277,
0.6494234800338745,
-0.31071773171424866,
0.1800721287727356,
0.41744178533554077,
0.16917318105697632,
0.3813614249229431,
0.3191978931427002,
0.14608833193778992,
0.16873310506343842,
0.6319557428359985,
0.0018874508095905185,
1.2636239528656006,
-0.26852938532829285,
0.19288936257362366,
0.7974238991737366,
-0.506548285484314,
0.5485040545463562,
0.527302622795105,
-0.17998817563056946,
0.16490870714187622,
0.39363211393356323,
0.003443787805736065,
0.09174659103155136,
0.20897337794303894,
-0.3857942819595337,
-0.19479641318321228,
-0.27297359704971313,
-0.5735924243927002,
0.23842838406562805,
0.6489221453666687,
-0.9236805438995361,
-0.01806577667593956,
0.02599199488759041,
0.31026872992515564,
-0.05620284751057625,
-0.604252278804779,
0.6265332698822021,
0.4695940315723419,
-0.3637402355670929,
0.232744961977005,
0.03400718420743942,
0.4727761745452881,
-0.8421422839164734,
-0.03828785568475723,
0.1930578052997589,
0.21784867346286774,
-0.06779547035694122,
-0.7921828627586365,
-0.09444699436426163,
-0.07650730013847351,
-0.13813504576683044,
-0.1623133271932602,
0.7900439500808716,
-0.16160047054290771,
-0.41624516248703003,
0.09703478217124939,
0.7432622909545898,
0.04251432418823242,
0.2366030216217041,
-0.5512303709983826,
0.22561916708946228,
-0.20876052975654602,
-0.13594259321689606,
0.4764486253261566,
0.3865043818950653,
-0.10984832793474197,
0.8912312984466553,
0.4568355977535248,
0.5164110660552979,
-0.001345847500488162,
0.15357357263565063,
0.7214351296424866,
-0.7282485365867615,
-0.2712453305721283,
-0.9309374094009399,
0.17737221717834473,
0.07279645651578903,
-0.08513783663511276,
0.5629239082336426,
0.4513961374759674,
0.3322089612483978,
-0.05365357920527458,
0.963060736656189,
0.4289838373661041,
0.630143940448761,
-0.514778733253479,
0.9541106820106506,
-0.4652230143547058,
0.2800055742263794,
-0.12184877693653107,
-0.5280669331550598,
-0.5273742079734802,
0.08728019148111343,
-0.4224276542663574,
0.22007228434085846,
0.5310789346694946,
0.4655677378177643,
0.26180124282836914,
0.05649370700120926,
0.5827566981315613,
0.5089225769042969,
0.4643537104129791,
0.5303714275360107,
0.8825156688690186,
-0.07764143496751785,
0.16302832961082458,
0.22730837762355804,
-0.39693981409072876,
-0.33521705865859985,
-0.7046223878860474,
-0.7700002789497375,
-0.36979207396507263,
-0.26481306552886963,
-0.3929620683193207,
0.1084568127989769,
1.0208195447921753,
0.5870063304901123,
-0.6772119402885437,
-0.12530754506587982,
0.24852585792541504,
-0.16981516778469086,
0.05212225392460823,
-0.12674269080162048,
0.28553617000579834,
0.02771930582821369,
-0.5806535482406616,
0.3643917739391327,
0.5048904418945312,
0.21961890161037445,
-0.5156145095825195,
-0.07700244337320328,
0.14267106354236603,
0.15568825602531433,
0.8520138263702393,
0.2577418088912964,
-0.847096860408783,
-0.12139751762151718,
0.1764446347951889,
-0.36944812536239624,
-0.000722171796951443,
1.0213013887405396,
-0.46731287240982056,
0.2783795893192291,
0.09724903106689453,
0.8573076128959656,
0.08100970089435577,
-0.44039422273635864,
0.5595958232879639,
0.015032192692160606,
-0.26820772886276245,
0.43653732538223267,
0.6513084769248962,
0.2924486994743347,
-0.19963523745536804,
0.4068933129310608,
0.10705552250146866,
-0.8578223586082458,
-0.8477520942687988,
0.3474378287792206,
-1.0378743410110474,
-0.33607247471809387,
1.1682161092758179,
0.0631222203373909,
0.024336237460374832,
-0.27228841185569763,
-0.20731134712696075,
0.04277519881725311,
-0.0854460746049881,
0.7161884903907776,
0.5546085238456726,
-0.28751829266548157,
-0.09981179982423782,
-0.848792552947998,
0.42102569341659546,
0.19148439168930054,
-0.9920622110366821,
-0.028338901698589325,
0.7797811031341553,
0.5840654373168945,
-0.08212371915578842,
0.7329339981079102,
-0.8836090564727783,
0.10620521754026413,
-0.43196901679039,
-0.1411825716495514,
-0.10498940944671631,
-0.1550283432006836,
-0.5317848920822144,
0.318431556224823,
0.4759603440761566,
0.11254370212554932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03707v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03707v1
|
What Should Embeddings Embed? Autoregressive Models Represent Latent Generating Distributions
| 2024-06-06T03:06:46 | 2024-06-06T03:06:46 |
Liyi Zhang, Michael Y. Li, Thomas L. Griffiths
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML, I.2; I.5
|
Autoregressive language models have demonstrated a remarkable ability to
extract latent structure from text. The embeddings from large language models
have been shown to capture aspects of the syntax and semantics of language. But
what {\em should} embeddings represent? We connect the autoregressive
prediction objective to the idea of constructing predictive sufficient
statistics to summarize the information contained in a sequence of
observations, and use this connection to identify three settings where the
optimal content of embeddings can be identified: independent identically
distributed data, where the embedding should capture the sufficient statistics
of the data; latent state models, where the embedding should encode the
posterior distribution over states given the data; and discrete hypothesis
spaces, where the embedding should reflect the posterior distribution over
hypotheses given the data. We then conduct empirical probing studies to show
that transformers encode these three kinds of latent generating distributions,
and that they perform well in out-of-distribution cases and without token
memorization in these settings.
|
[
-0.3820347785949707,
-0.4151374399662018,
0.669339120388031,
0.30415451526641846,
-0.17062877118587494,
-0.1402919888496399,
0.030486734583973885,
0.029741402715444565,
0.2843489646911621,
0.38958412408828735,
-0.09762094914913177,
-0.2563130557537079,
-0.6463180780410767,
-0.2562919557094574,
-0.8809612989425659,
0.8728136420249939,
-0.137053444981575,
-0.19565074145793915,
-0.3344178795814514,
0.181963711977005,
-0.19858844578266144,
-0.5630653500556946,
-0.09209652245044708,
-0.2270245999097824,
0.18151813745498657,
-0.006677365396171808,
0.8568982481956482,
1.0792953968048096,
0.2877572476863861,
0.197679340839386,
0.3252463936805725,
-0.34742823243141174,
-0.2410142421722412,
0.40257981419563293,
0.04437738284468651,
-0.3939407467842102,
-0.11402331292629242,
0.19781403243541718,
0.6714087128639221,
0.708541750907898,
-0.41429147124290466,
-0.07659753412008286,
0.06530884653329849,
0.1841363161802292,
-0.762783408164978,
0.4688889682292938,
-0.3959897458553314,
0.26572299003601074,
-0.11796053498983383,
-0.22030307352542877,
-0.43245306611061096,
-0.46376270055770874,
-0.03974483907222748,
-0.17514149844646454,
0.4444783329963684,
0.09560191631317139,
0.464352011680603,
0.4178331196308136,
-0.5491903424263,
-0.051933709532022476,
-0.9593673348426819,
0.5542351007461548,
-0.48887836933135986,
0.6472131609916687,
0.5781884789466858,
0.2063073217868805,
-0.04989679157733917,
-0.539726972579956,
-0.35877931118011475,
-0.0031376739498227835,
-0.25172656774520874,
0.23594053089618683,
-0.2774914801120758,
-0.0105450339615345,
0.14692020416259766,
0.5480331778526306,
-0.4287232756614685,
0.17373450100421906,
0.016310596838593483,
-0.06777042895555496,
0.5354435443878174,
0.23950782418251038,
0.04468900337815285,
-0.3003457188606262,
0.007576249074190855,
-0.356594443321228,
-0.5542118549346924,
-0.3096996247768402,
0.48091045022010803,
0.11295310407876968,
-0.24258098006248474,
0.656257688999176,
0.21542955935001373,
0.35287120938301086,
0.0356580875813961,
0.17985981702804565,
0.18814785778522491,
-0.1037055030465126,
0.02736474946141243,
-0.04700814187526703,
0.884300947189331,
-0.12256798148155212,
0.30214357376098633,
-0.3569805920124054,
-0.49563702940940857,
0.0548267588019371,
0.28542715311050415,
-0.3959103524684906,
-0.494936466217041,
0.07047698646783829,
-0.5822177529335022,
-0.21866431832313538,
0.2599596679210663,
-0.5477345585823059,
0.054726678878068924,
-0.15055757761001587,
0.29342982172966003,
-0.255168616771698,
-0.4652608335018158,
-0.2164086401462555,
-0.36813223361968994,
0.08924955874681473,
0.054560694843530655,
-1.4096100330352783,
0.4832092523574829,
0.532202422618866,
0.5549865365028381,
-0.055354904383420944,
-0.014531672932207584,
-0.09062043577432632,
0.5152422189712524,
-0.5278533697128296,
0.7548724412918091,
-0.5982310771942139,
-0.38280919194221497,
0.4399101138114929,
0.08816695213317871,
-0.14454330503940582,
-0.1612367033958435,
0.1121760681271553,
-0.42252227663993835,
0.1676192730665207,
-0.17374597489833832,
-1.066326379776001,
-0.054769497364759445,
-0.34087052941322327,
-0.879249632358551,
0.7742395997047424,
0.14142774045467377,
-0.7957698702812195,
0.4856826663017273,
-0.5240345001220703,
-0.38849925994873047,
-0.15686216950416565,
-0.3000977337360382,
-0.3889003098011017,
0.465265691280365,
0.02984834648668766,
0.7843295335769653,
-0.0893421471118927,
0.24938401579856873,
-0.40066325664520264,
0.13434508442878723,
0.3823919892311096,
-0.6881682276725769,
0.28021374344825745,
0.4200308620929718,
-0.29835158586502075,
-0.528140127658844,
-0.3464961349964142,
-0.1971464306116104,
0.23010368645191193,
-0.07808922976255417,
-0.1778855323791504,
0.6346539258956909,
-0.007052646949887276,
-0.16264241933822632,
0.02796459011733532,
-0.44369277358055115,
0.18433329463005066,
-0.29237571358680725,
0.38027623295783997,
0.7069250345230103,
0.22918479144573212,
0.8389807343482971,
-0.04724007844924927,
0.5232422351837158,
0.13963976502418518,
0.035665642470121384,
-0.24504448473453522,
-0.3414447009563446,
-0.4983547627925873,
-0.10905372351408005,
0.32101696729660034,
0.4626086354255676,
-0.3537117838859558,
0.4509338140487671,
0.17058609426021576,
-0.39722853899002075,
-0.10644613206386566,
-0.13078802824020386,
0.02205977402627468,
0.030649783089756966,
0.2520473301410675,
-0.0052870213985443115,
-0.6209046840667725,
-0.9677778482437134,
0.13270078599452972,
-0.3772487938404083,
0.23019041121006012,
-0.1413896232843399,
0.6994176506996155,
-0.17987363040447235,
0.9651361703872681,
-0.8825754523277283,
0.011028800159692764,
-0.07526286691427231,
-0.05175270885229111,
-0.061337947845458984,
0.5676733255386353,
0.6517978310585022,
-0.6737378835678101,
-0.36156347393989563,
-0.3331418037414551,
-1.0051382780075073,
0.17295284569263458,
0.01813889853656292,
0.003826186992228031,
-0.023257840424776077,
0.5592960715293884,
-0.4847383499145508,
0.6254498958587646,
0.5761762857437134,
-0.21087731420993805,
0.26952746510505676,
-0.31786054372787476,
-0.22343696653842926,
-1.0706168413162231,
-0.23873218894004822,
-0.032830990850925446,
-0.42291420698165894,
-0.3992519676685333,
-0.38089266419410706,
0.08702819794416428,
-0.25318875908851624,
0.025370977818965912,
0.42893218994140625,
-0.4599992632865906,
-0.2675682604312897,
-0.27608948945999146,
-0.15058940649032593,
-0.05105500668287277,
-0.09682685881853104,
0.18775007128715515,
0.5285733938217163,
0.571464478969574,
-0.6781776547431946,
0.12298634648323059,
0.37530624866485596,
-0.2169131636619568,
0.015090725384652615,
-0.6166017651557922,
-0.23476815223693848,
-0.3144148886203766,
0.26707544922828674,
-0.9397211670875549,
-0.3049416244029999,
0.030682122334837914,
-0.5535847544670105,
0.4506993591785431,
0.0037168145645409822,
-0.7530950903892517,
-0.3119657635688782,
0.03393510356545448,
0.2561129927635193,
0.889021635055542,
-0.2842771112918854,
0.5090027451515198,
0.8998483419418335,
0.0849091112613678,
-0.5225966572761536,
-0.671550989151001,
-0.4013877809047699,
-0.129182368516922,
-0.0024336366914212704,
0.3186756372451782,
0.28873175382614136,
-0.08599845319986343,
0.49369797110557556,
0.33339348435401917,
-0.10728662461042404,
0.18230795860290527,
0.30918630957603455,
-0.03371380642056465,
-0.26972755789756775,
0.5547764897346497,
0.10888700187206268,
-0.38210341334342957,
0.13670800626277924,
-0.353395015001297,
0.43673598766326904,
0.20810534060001373,
-0.5648901462554932,
-0.15336057543754578,
0.6615821719169617,
0.2551734149456024,
-0.10165679454803467,
0.8317753076553345,
0.6917535662651062,
-0.6118422150611877,
-0.2484288364648819,
-0.5816116333007812,
-0.31633180379867554,
-0.3916260898113251,
0.2888574004173279,
-0.03471701964735985,
-0.7205174565315247,
0.5481964349746704,
0.2681103050708771,
0.12140453606843948,
0.6946197152137756,
0.681588888168335,
-0.40360763669013977,
1.2176514863967896,
0.9631739258766174,
-0.20384028553962708,
0.5642295479774475,
-0.41707947850227356,
0.11266198009252548,
-0.6679210662841797,
-0.25288257002830505,
-0.4498549997806549,
0.09286537766456604,
-0.808430552482605,
-0.33688968420028687,
0.07201942056417465,
0.03118053637444973,
-0.21444691717624664,
0.4262630343437195,
-0.2688259780406952,
0.3385666310787201,
0.6046918630599976,
-0.36313390731811523,
-0.20902518928050995,
0.12462051212787628,
-0.08708827197551727,
-0.13592354953289032,
-0.7879582643508911,
-0.6328514218330383,
1.030794382095337,
0.5111227631568909,
1.1262943744659424,
0.09842249751091003,
0.844174325466156,
0.4133763909339905,
0.247613325715065,
-0.7148799300193787,
0.14617928862571716,
-0.4187679588794708,
-0.49828508496284485,
-0.008333569392561913,
-0.13059625029563904,
-1.2362480163574219,
-0.0026487151626497507,
-0.3051780164241791,
-0.5961151123046875,
0.5274227857589722,
0.48686063289642334,
-0.16187220811843872,
0.2890971302986145,
-0.5704900026321411,
0.7918110489845276,
0.04540965333580971,
0.12817521393299103,
-0.13172875344753265,
-0.09422138333320618,
0.0014249354135245085,
0.019446032121777534,
0.01580391637980938,
0.0894382894039154,
-0.1791851967573166,
0.8349336385726929,
-0.2984304130077362,
0.9887098670005798,
-0.31664952635765076,
0.03601771965622902,
0.42816436290740967,
0.08828920871019363,
0.5161678791046143,
0.07060088217258453,
0.08297145366668701,
-0.17346368730068207,
0.1840551495552063,
-0.269676148891449,
-0.7326753735542297,
0.38463449478149414,
-0.9244407415390015,
-0.569753110408783,
-0.46491143107414246,
-0.16521571576595306,
-0.10489047318696976,
-0.1390940248966217,
0.43627554178237915,
0.6755068898200989,
-0.47304484248161316,
0.5125176906585693,
0.7225005030632019,
-0.13428109884262085,
0.6330545544624329,
0.24901536107063293,
-0.22390690445899963,
-0.3062063455581665,
0.826351523399353,
0.2738801836967468,
0.2136843353509903,
0.3562956750392914,
0.06439214944839478,
-0.6127763986587524,
-0.44200706481933594,
-0.16932852566242218,
0.40515652298927307,
-1.0264428853988647,
-0.1072455570101738,
-0.9470096826553345,
-0.3857188820838928,
-0.6379972696304321,
-0.05702585354447365,
-0.3797789514064789,
-0.39010265469551086,
-0.5595325827598572,
-0.2614586651325226,
0.2466806322336197,
1.099788784980774,
-0.6327197551727295,
0.43031758069992065,
-0.6890586614608765,
0.1330237239599228,
0.32700151205062866,
0.2013913094997406,
0.07083961367607117,
-0.35967180132865906,
-0.5373430848121643,
-0.16667614877223969,
-0.2212708741426468,
-1.0823651552200317,
0.4857846796512604,
0.3336305618286133,
1.0915080308914185,
0.5375519394874573,
0.004073395859450102,
0.3485189378261566,
-0.7332189679145813,
0.6331352591514587,
0.06046414375305176,
-0.6583974361419678,
0.614055871963501,
-0.32576173543930054,
0.03507537767291069,
0.3132511079311371,
0.6945268511772156,
-0.3987179398536682,
-0.6305659413337708,
-1.0344758033752441,
-0.5772301554679871,
0.2608136534690857,
0.25649183988571167,
0.480235755443573,
-0.6975764632225037,
0.3062668740749359,
0.2170582115650177,
0.3635398745536804,
-0.6774671673774719,
-0.2473118156194687,
-0.46396365761756897,
-0.5710192918777466,
-0.31013286113739014,
-0.35604986548423767,
0.10238299518823624,
0.04430236667394638,
0.10011010617017746,
0.029348595067858696,
0.8888514637947083,
0.02993098460137844,
-0.12985041737556458,
0.04772814363241196,
-0.1407255381345749,
0.160158172249794,
0.37973344326019287,
-0.16648167371749878,
0.23764199018478394,
-0.16203434765338898,
-0.4348342716693878,
0.3099585771560669,
-0.012644559144973755,
-0.10028717666864395,
0.17862050235271454,
0.46211230754852295,
0.8312281370162964,
-0.05192073807120323,
-0.10910892486572266,
0.6118161678314209,
0.019563477486371994,
0.16341668367385864,
-0.8280574679374695,
0.23826375603675842,
0.05431422218680382,
0.16209101676940918,
0.5494655966758728,
-0.00023802120995242149,
0.1962176263332367,
-0.6534063816070557,
0.4420704245567322,
0.4022160470485687,
-0.4261435270309448,
-0.692753255367279,
0.5635097622871399,
-0.06671984493732452,
-0.12547145783901215,
0.5882276296615601,
-0.18150237202644348,
-0.47284606099128723,
0.5981982946395874,
0.7061128616333008,
0.9457551836967468,
-0.38266196846961975,
0.3246845602989197,
0.4125698208808899,
0.401377409696579,
-0.32834944128990173,
0.2265983670949936,
-0.029632028192281723,
-0.8626444935798645,
-0.2987303137779236,
-0.6633921265602112,
-0.2530572712421417,
-0.28090283274650574,
-0.6864177584648132,
0.03620840981602669,
-0.35249438881874084,
-0.21490083634853363,
-0.0388304740190506,
-0.5046942234039307,
-0.9389873743057251,
0.3418608009815216,
0.2543836832046509,
0.5609598159790039,
-1.3650696277618408,
0.6907132267951965,
0.22544603049755096,
-0.5325965285301208,
-0.6917651295661926,
0.009310557506978512,
-0.07679025083780289,
-0.7101777195930481,
0.7418477535247803,
-0.16351789236068726,
0.37187373638153076,
0.20613566040992737,
-0.5408520102500916,
-1.294524908065796,
0.778826117515564,
0.3233100473880768,
-0.19082526862621307,
0.05292871966958046,
-0.054881658405065536,
0.35115063190460205,
-0.8695916533470154,
0.3422033190727234,
0.18189674615859985,
0.16426005959510803,
-0.28263288736343384,
-0.5279523730278015,
0.0011705626966431737,
0.008580018766224384,
0.13744524121284485,
0.33750805258750916,
-0.19254626333713531,
0.9843155145645142,
-0.1406985968351364,
-0.38686057925224304,
-0.18526072800159454,
0.7468214631080627,
-0.07873176783323288,
-0.15923766791820526,
0.3637096583843231,
0.5051848292350769,
0.5152183175086975,
-0.2784530222415924,
1.43686044216156,
-0.2697652578353882,
0.3344497084617615,
0.9161587953567505,
0.18705137073993683,
1.096415638923645,
0.20133782923221588,
-0.2135290652513504,
0.6742338538169861,
0.8444754481315613,
-0.22899888455867767,
0.8528145551681519,
-0.014028387144207954,
-0.046933408826589584,
-0.18676964938640594,
-0.0071763223968446255,
-0.6148268580436707,
0.5487001538276672,
0.6184266209602356,
-0.6296066045761108,
-0.07051525264978409,
0.12724189460277557,
-0.19959348440170288,
-0.12508442997932434,
0.14760281145572662,
0.9873844385147095,
0.1979333758354187,
-0.4855278432369232,
0.2188623547554016,
-0.23893027007579803,
0.22570458054542542,
-0.5449877977371216,
-0.10839078575372696,
-0.16915515065193176,
-0.004088378045707941,
-0.20412318408489227,
-0.9727354049682617,
0.47604113817214966,
-0.3457969129085541,
-0.28145503997802734,
-0.355680376291275,
0.6381661891937256,
-0.4168166220188141,
-0.40359267592430115,
0.25470682978630066,
0.7414688467979431,
0.3226293623447418,
0.13528993725776672,
-0.43033725023269653,
-0.20696832239627838,
-0.2825178802013397,
-0.33982083201408386,
0.25374090671539307,
0.5630149841308594,
0.12080628424882889,
0.5158248543739319,
0.4995976984500885,
0.22243285179138184,
-0.04054967686533928,
0.21553485095500946,
0.7508477568626404,
-0.819409966468811,
-0.6165380477905273,
-0.7677198052406311,
0.5400862097740173,
0.08958625793457031,
-0.025077667087316513,
0.7553271055221558,
0.4637710750102997,
0.39029645919799805,
-0.09679434448480606,
0.8003262877464294,
-0.07952143251895905,
0.27435576915740967,
-0.5476701259613037,
0.5629636645317078,
-0.3872199058532715,
-0.17104877531528473,
-0.10437418520450592,
-1.3139320611953735,
-0.03345368802547455,
0.8716570734977722,
-0.3644878566265106,
0.14992021024227142,
0.7517217993736267,
0.5044161677360535,
-0.09595682471990585,
-0.13072320818901062,
0.3363737165927887,
-0.04382375255227089,
0.16377028822898865,
0.2528418302536011,
0.9948355555534363,
-0.5329320430755615,
0.17858879268169403,
-0.1667497605085373,
-0.034628283232450485,
-0.26371562480926514,
-0.8374033570289612,
-0.6099679470062256,
-0.8008008599281311,
-0.4656347930431366,
-0.3810728192329407,
-0.4601607322692871,
0.7412570714950562,
0.6692625880241394,
-0.786427915096283,
-0.24081748723983765,
-0.1177944764494896,
-0.05664627626538277,
0.054542168974876404,
-0.23111051321029663,
0.3414728045463562,
-0.5105476975440979,
-0.5939140915870667,
0.17726880311965942,
0.32262757420539856,
0.6228588819503784,
-0.5758914351463318,
0.1326376348733902,
0.031024418771266937,
-0.07175089418888092,
0.5376695990562439,
0.16202598810195923,
-0.5159207582473755,
-0.5000309348106384,
0.10593748092651367,
-0.18220369517803192,
-0.186050146818161,
0.7807690501213074,
-0.7141859531402588,
0.3305193781852722,
0.6092730760574341,
0.5927759408950806,
0.4353328347206116,
-0.18126240372657776,
1.0197950601577759,
-0.7157575488090515,
0.3238922357559204,
0.4352688491344452,
0.626634418964386,
0.13962826132774353,
-0.25329068303108215,
0.45727670192718506,
0.1520845592021942,
-0.5561368465423584,
-0.8023194074630737,
0.254315584897995,
-0.49937522411346436,
-0.09265686571598053,
1.009751796722412,
-0.23489883542060852,
-0.32871437072753906,
-0.29084381461143494,
0.39739423990249634,
0.3137234151363373,
-0.28814882040023804,
0.4561314582824707,
0.6601569652557373,
-0.04156884923577309,
-0.3271084427833557,
-0.6287065744400024,
0.5304470658302307,
0.32650136947631836,
-0.4725082218647003,
-0.05392415449023247,
0.32040825486183167,
0.16812089085578918,
0.18067923188209534,
0.5427806377410889,
-0.17326423525810242,
0.11167483776807785,
0.2753516137599945,
-0.10898463428020477,
0.32539138197898865,
-0.19291383028030396,
-0.18422342836856842,
0.14855794608592987,
0.1413087546825409,
-0.20186296105384827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03706v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03706v1
|
Improving Audio Codec-based Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech Synthesis with Multi-Modal Context and Large Language Model
| 2024-06-06T03:06:45 | 2024-06-06T03:06:45 |
Jinlong Xue, Yayue Deng, Yicheng Han, Yingming Gao, Ya Li
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) and development of audio
codecs greatly propel the zero-shot TTS. They can synthesize personalized
speech with only a 3-second speech of an unseen speaker as acoustic prompt.
However, they only support short speech prompts and cannot leverage longer
context information, as required in audiobook and conversational TTS scenarios.
In this paper, we introduce a novel audio codec-based TTS model to adapt
context features with multiple enhancements. Inspired by the success of
Qformer, we propose a multi-modal context-enhanced Qformer (MMCE-Qformer) to
utilize additional multi-modal context information. Besides, we adapt a
pretrained LLM to leverage its understanding ability to predict semantic
tokens, and use a SoundStorm to generate acoustic tokens thereby enhancing
audio quality and speaker similarity. The extensive objective and subjective
evaluations show that our proposed method outperforms baselines across various
context TTS scenarios.
|
[
-0.3795185089111328,
-0.5965183973312378,
0.7108713984489441,
-0.001252473215572536,
-0.3207136392593384,
0.10613438487052917,
-0.38265788555145264,
-0.29741522669792175,
0.29184800386428833,
0.13673654198646545,
-0.7933664321899414,
-0.6897542476654053,
-0.28695154190063477,
0.30146080255508423,
-0.25028371810913086,
0.9512959718704224,
0.38634416460990906,
-0.08254093676805496,
0.16110120713710785,
-0.17948657274246216,
-0.9076098203659058,
-0.6774813532829285,
-0.42223984003067017,
0.1512530893087387,
0.3358393907546997,
0.4096424877643585,
0.31382423639297485,
0.3380337953567505,
-0.22122688591480255,
0.16835401952266693,
-0.1705087125301361,
0.019242949783802032,
-0.201273113489151,
0.40618038177490234,
0.2953011393547058,
-0.1961144506931305,
-0.7697175741195679,
-0.35224607586860657,
0.6674597263336182,
0.287667840719223,
-0.07381164282560349,
-0.04985276237130165,
-0.04572329670190811,
-0.059528645128011703,
-0.7241392135620117,
-0.04498351365327835,
-0.8960425853729248,
-0.01799793168902397,
0.08441577106714249,
-0.5035209059715271,
-0.6746382117271423,
0.15295416116714478,
-0.015167907811701298,
-0.6298309564590454,
0.13971522450447083,
-0.23631465435028076,
0.17398861050605774,
0.23272404074668884,
-0.5697211027145386,
-0.04824850335717201,
-0.9697699546813965,
0.9186097979545593,
-1.0386379957199097,
0.7628275156021118,
0.02668190188705921,
0.4029971957206726,
0.008945249952375889,
-0.46282342076301575,
-0.7037248015403748,
-0.31734126806259155,
0.3954828679561615,
0.19742168486118317,
0.11488866060972214,
0.1082916259765625,
-0.008544966578483582,
0.09933371841907501,
-0.43102923035621643,
-0.04414385184645653,
-0.06906834989786148,
-0.3913911283016205,
0.10093057155609131,
0.19367246329784393,
0.34277045726776123,
-0.2793545722961426,
-0.4358290433883667,
-0.20677389204502106,
-0.6325222849845886,
0.1683940589427948,
0.17404897511005402,
0.6664191484451294,
-0.24974019825458527,
0.5135020017623901,
-0.12412303686141968,
0.6963440179824829,
0.0563046894967556,
-0.565899133682251,
0.530938446521759,
-0.6702573299407959,
-0.2021859884262085,
0.42835667729377747,
0.6320384740829468,
0.31938284635543823,
-0.3223000466823578,
-0.036916639655828476,
-0.1825765073299408,
-0.08627508580684662,
0.13979026675224304,
-0.970678985118866,
0.28411319851875305,
0.3673548102378845,
-0.08686178922653198,
-0.24770839512348175,
-0.05866411700844765,
-0.6032988429069519,
-0.028927044942975044,
-0.4303765594959259,
0.49726393818855286,
-0.48116442561149597,
-0.10927601158618927,
0.1263696402311325,
-0.2084692418575287,
0.11896860599517822,
0.4400167167186737,
-0.825918972492218,
-0.07542147487401962,
0.26520535349845886,
0.959151029586792,
-0.1396913230419159,
-0.2423400580883026,
-0.8575172424316406,
0.6265432834625244,
-0.3154829740524292,
0.71627277135849,
-0.6057127118110657,
-0.5973352193832397,
-0.07634670287370682,
-0.21486005187034607,
0.20614826679229736,
-0.13773655891418457,
0.5361771583557129,
-0.12192529439926147,
0.5088117122650146,
-0.002913793781772256,
-0.4859115779399872,
0.13498526811599731,
-0.019479811191558838,
-0.42619502544403076,
0.7617784738540649,
0.0028694288339465857,
-0.4548100233078003,
0.3986372649669647,
-0.7495732307434082,
-0.49133551120758057,
0.1225934773683548,
-0.3075428307056427,
-0.13918188214302063,
0.12977845966815948,
0.4352700114250183,
0.3523753881454468,
-0.15071722865104675,
0.3532511293888092,
-0.1971110701560974,
-0.5184313654899597,
0.32129114866256714,
-0.8343687057495117,
0.1640789657831192,
0.19251227378845215,
-0.40545058250427246,
0.5957275032997131,
-0.9698253273963928,
0.09947478026151657,
-0.1800885647535324,
-0.402546763420105,
-0.06680803000926971,
-0.2688262164592743,
0.5738927125930786,
0.2591626048088074,
-0.05532076582312584,
-0.5491002202033997,
0.009462405927479267,
-0.5212522149085999,
0.7129731178283691,
0.585671067237854,
0.04265880212187767,
0.5604846477508545,
-0.4191882610321045,
0.4603336453437805,
-0.12237104028463364,
-0.0193405132740736,
-0.8245521783828735,
-0.34561964869499207,
-0.3433193266391754,
-0.7103369235992432,
0.28831323981285095,
0.45286062359809875,
-0.8283111453056335,
0.5732572078704834,
-0.4071284532546997,
-0.20108644664287567,
-0.34759098291397095,
-0.37214595079421997,
0.22048179805278778,
0.5064505934715271,
0.4334840178489685,
-0.2825410068035126,
-0.4854053258895874,
-0.4882982075214386,
-0.024447033181786537,
-0.08161789923906326,
-0.6086809635162354,
0.5678873062133789,
-0.11419034004211426,
-0.18654534220695496,
1.0002623796463013,
-0.2741413712501526,
-0.5354812741279602,
-0.1769992560148239,
-0.10803711414337158,
0.2527078688144684,
0.4101092219352722,
0.6720786690711975,
-0.4469270408153534,
-0.1998065859079361,
-0.09725867956876755,
-0.21488472819328308,
-0.1793021410703659,
-0.3553771674633026,
0.18841183185577393,
0.2227836698293686,
0.6807318329811096,
-0.39623022079467773,
0.22458231449127197,
0.5717954039573669,
-0.3939710855484009,
0.718802809715271,
-0.0964239314198494,
0.5054486393928528,
-1.3113173246383667,
0.10605478286743164,
-0.3387010991573334,
-0.3682442605495453,
-0.8480992913246155,
-0.2805212438106537,
-0.17303466796875,
-0.3762155771255493,
-0.8123987317085266,
0.592779278755188,
-0.047534096986055374,
-0.06857211887836456,
-0.36206018924713135,
0.3111487030982971,
0.14543847739696503,
0.5452430248260498,
-0.10323411971330643,
1.1759525537490845,
0.5748972296714783,
-0.39927414059638977,
0.10672982037067413,
0.33592426776885986,
-0.031056085601449013,
0.6109052300453186,
-0.6187562942504883,
0.22961276769638062,
-0.04926133155822754,
0.5493818521499634,
-0.9916027784347534,
-0.24509140849113464,
-0.016746344044804573,
-0.6528627872467041,
0.2023017853498459,
-0.15690267086029053,
-0.25205329060554504,
0.2093498557806015,
-0.4809356927871704,
0.7903568744659424,
0.3971467912197113,
-0.36144188046455383,
0.7904786467552185,
0.20138853788375854,
-0.5529115796089172,
-0.12707248330116272,
-0.5799157619476318,
0.5215237736701965,
-0.18778957426548004,
-0.3700065314769745,
0.6914883852005005,
-0.6807423233985901,
0.4490901827812195,
-0.2328331470489502,
-0.2321188747882843,
-0.21284916996955872,
-0.3150826096534729,
0.28073152899742126,
0.29918673634529114,
-0.34446337819099426,
0.2506767809391022,
0.2898249924182892,
-0.1161641776561737,
-0.3636581599712372,
-0.44796717166900635,
0.4665328860282898,
0.17657026648521423,
-0.2070431262254715,
-0.6544901728630066,
0.440897673368454,
0.9055149555206299,
-0.15943266451358795,
0.3908025026321411,
0.624612033367157,
-0.23798832297325134,
-0.10147783905267715,
-0.4901823103427887,
-0.24866598844528198,
-0.4597785174846649,
0.4804275929927826,
-0.5211565494537354,
-1.3555583953857422,
0.22808368504047394,
-0.03001873940229416,
-0.0825149342417717,
0.1339322328567505,
0.7716653943061829,
0.28232619166374207,
0.9852986931800842,
0.5670927166938782,
0.015680955722928047,
0.9049742221832275,
0.10293473303318024,
0.20922037959098816,
-0.7899202704429626,
-0.161191925406456,
-0.34864839911460876,
0.12570464611053467,
-0.4145764112472534,
-0.43893685936927795,
0.7147433161735535,
-0.19877047836780548,
-0.20906564593315125,
0.4933568835258484,
-0.45652472972869873,
0.3050251007080078,
0.48882848024368286,
0.03596328943967819,
0.26943084597587585,
0.13618865609169006,
-0.2257743924856186,
-0.08045224845409393,
-0.5653253793716431,
-0.3716699481010437,
1.1143946647644043,
0.3214576840400696,
0.2687746286392212,
0.2241501659154892,
0.5742849707603455,
0.19660784304141998,
-0.18880748748779297,
-0.8158324956893921,
0.2329934686422348,
-0.04924781247973442,
-0.5400075316429138,
-0.5021640062332153,
-0.3055775463581085,
-0.39015674591064453,
0.28029870986938477,
-0.5308657288551331,
-0.6295924782752991,
-0.006291452329605818,
-0.07510939985513687,
-0.7920174598693848,
0.10352182388305664,
-0.6144766807556152,
0.6547386050224304,
0.0861063078045845,
-0.2502661645412445,
-0.1311216950416565,
-0.42055368423461914,
-0.030065694823861122,
-0.20567509531974792,
0.5780355930328369,
-0.14898693561553955,
-0.1014585793018341,
0.4617476165294647,
-0.13383698463439941,
0.5978530645370483,
-0.1365959793329239,
-0.2340332269668579,
0.30696702003479004,
0.16803626716136932,
0.028376173228025436,
0.2850222587585449,
-0.06407611072063446,
0.05219292640686035,
0.27816733717918396,
-0.21362566947937012,
-0.5366126894950867,
0.8355671167373657,
-0.47599127888679504,
-0.30948153138160706,
0.11575452983379364,
-0.6238101124763489,
-0.5329772233963013,
0.28697091341018677,
0.10014133900403976,
0.9487078189849854,
-0.31137749552726746,
0.36511626839637756,
0.295897513628006,
-0.48660412430763245,
0.8047772645950317,
0.34387141466140747,
0.054511792957782745,
-0.8956844806671143,
0.7606119513511658,
-0.32643768191337585,
0.23705244064331055,
0.3775220513343811,
0.15919634699821472,
-0.31085991859436035,
-0.47495773434638977,
-0.764070987701416,
-0.07044666260480881,
-0.4676060676574707,
-0.40703922510147095,
-0.5387051105499268,
-0.06022325158119202,
-0.6430407166481018,
-0.3076167106628418,
-0.5394446849822998,
-0.4416253864765167,
-0.4219077229499817,
-0.1540980339050293,
0.2773478031158447,
0.43144670128822327,
0.12285446375608444,
0.5305719375610352,
-1.0677577257156372,
0.5194543600082397,
0.3890913426876068,
0.41649100184440613,
-0.06733552366495132,
-0.8464140892028809,
-0.1207149475812912,
0.11975835263729095,
-0.13489045202732086,
-0.8985515236854553,
0.3728882372379303,
0.2826016843318939,
0.1731431931257248,
0.19695985317230225,
0.022355305030941963,
0.6634986400604248,
-0.9543855786323547,
1.0086966753005981,
0.6437280774116516,
-1.1968202590942383,
0.4443545639514923,
-0.5076651573181152,
0.6374306082725525,
0.24725361168384552,
-0.2536647319793701,
-0.5275021195411682,
-0.39868587255477905,
-0.28933703899383545,
-1.0018185377120972,
0.5718514323234558,
0.5646023750305176,
0.38709700107574463,
0.10307732969522476,
0.26422715187072754,
0.11209093034267426,
0.16903471946716309,
-0.8126169443130493,
-0.1017681136727333,
-0.5010796189308167,
-0.3538811504840851,
-0.16537603735923767,
-0.3559705317020416,
0.12356137484312057,
-0.17871226370334625,
0.5080721974372864,
-0.4005083441734314,
0.28865471482276917,
0.4099098742008209,
0.14786876738071442,
-0.09084102511405945,
0.9503193497657776,
0.998982310295105,
0.4469022750854492,
-0.24398401379585266,
0.06876308470964432,
0.3107303977012634,
-0.1778363585472107,
0.33053210377693176,
-0.0011550724739208817,
0.02107314020395279,
0.23577934503555298,
0.3189717233181,
1.0636967420578003,
0.5222989916801453,
-0.7677637934684753,
0.7583366632461548,
-0.2293982207775116,
-0.09993655234575272,
-0.40945419669151306,
-0.010256560519337654,
0.014768742024898529,
0.1584150493144989,
0.5076600313186646,
0.12268803268671036,
0.27004629373550415,
-0.39481061697006226,
0.3620589077472687,
0.23947130143642426,
-0.5171509981155396,
-0.5136538147926331,
0.9266826510429382,
0.38014405965805054,
-0.3378223776817322,
-0.04413323849439621,
-0.11487190425395966,
-0.18012015521526337,
0.1675805002450943,
0.7222788333892822,
0.9190455675125122,
-0.34598466753959656,
-0.07009637355804443,
0.3541344702243805,
-0.05550236627459526,
0.343879371881485,
0.18985402584075928,
-0.295597106218338,
-0.4151369333267212,
-0.7543179988861084,
-0.5802102088928223,
-0.2068219631910324,
0.23727819323539734,
-0.2862025797367096,
0.518964409828186,
-0.40127137303352356,
-0.4000115394592285,
-0.06284511089324951,
-0.5717884302139282,
-0.5315588712692261,
0.21618175506591797,
0.21780914068222046,
0.5207276344299316,
-0.6595956683158875,
0.9621890187263489,
0.45461195707321167,
-0.2702764868736267,
-0.8079878687858582,
0.12412061542272568,
-0.03419642522931099,
-0.18212857842445374,
0.08367054164409637,
0.16978120803833008,
-0.3614617884159088,
0.08859040588140488,
-0.22674494981765747,
-0.6508117914199829,
1.0930176973342896,
0.5016131401062012,
-0.8026453852653503,
-0.10268919914960861,
0.11634068936109543,
0.39884185791015625,
-0.628182053565979,
0.3858018219470978,
0.295799195766449,
0.235029399394989,
0.40084242820739746,
-1.225512981414795,
-0.03275793790817261,
0.10771618783473969,
0.19983041286468506,
-0.18074800074100494,
-0.07488574832677841,
0.542614221572876,
-0.19502122700214386,
-0.16836561262607574,
0.095304474234581,
0.5826696157455444,
0.4127238988876343,
0.21776928007602692,
0.5880804657936096,
0.10379345715045929,
0.23433053493499756,
0.35164007544517517,
0.7833781838417053,
-0.4545418620109558,
0.08394276350736618,
1.243207335472107,
-0.30729183554649353,
0.9731254577636719,
0.5273064374923706,
0.018224548548460007,
0.40145665407180786,
0.12169668823480606,
0.3294011652469635,
0.6974354386329651,
-0.18188771605491638,
-0.5767062306404114,
-0.2642938196659088,
-0.2615973651409149,
-0.39013171195983887,
0.6446595788002014,
0.04434008151292801,
-0.10679900646209717,
-0.025439077988266945,
0.27176129817962646,
-0.18446661531925201,
-0.04304366558790207,
-0.05150337517261505,
0.9051395654678345,
-0.05630698800086975,
-0.19742801785469055,
0.5975334644317627,
0.18465034663677216,
0.9497998952865601,
-0.44075363874435425,
-0.16491590440273285,
0.0336623452603817,
-0.2633983790874481,
-0.0075381542555987835,
-0.4076482355594635,
0.145154669880867,
0.040989313274621964,
-0.3675919771194458,
-0.24066588282585144,
0.5242870450019836,
-0.5743008255958557,
-0.2641558051109314,
0.26427918672561646,
0.6210923790931702,
-0.188484326004982,
-0.3011881709098816,
-0.2640407085418701,
0.2537795901298523,
-0.005381928291171789,
0.021565524861216545,
0.3119086027145386,
0.5927347540855408,
0.1952255666255951,
0.1908453106880188,
0.9821786284446716,
0.08901364356279373,
0.024319134652614594,
0.5622432231903076,
0.7903164029121399,
-0.8377216458320618,
-0.7892987728118896,
-0.6325972676277161,
0.5114699006080627,
0.3479789197444916,
-0.15290586650371552,
0.4466248154640198,
0.4024461507797241,
0.7285728454589844,
-0.23018212616443634,
0.7915615439414978,
0.10186799615621567,
0.4976547360420227,
-0.5389408469200134,
0.593622624874115,
-0.5233299136161804,
0.24167685210704803,
-0.5615863800048828,
-0.9761202335357666,
-0.32737627625465393,
0.3409452736377716,
0.3065367043018341,
0.07946529239416122,
0.5945001840591431,
0.7236620187759399,
-0.012847861275076866,
-0.07410543411970139,
0.8560671210289001,
0.14747944474220276,
0.6366738677024841,
0.4930664002895355,
0.6672516465187073,
-0.5814235210418701,
0.7408406734466553,
0.10770787298679352,
-0.26703184843063354,
-0.11072434484958649,
-1.106030821800232,
-0.5703679919242859,
-0.7761659622192383,
-0.28154200315475464,
-0.09833422303199768,
-0.07389053702354431,
1.0402549505233765,
0.891714870929718,
-0.935184121131897,
-0.1228463277220726,
0.17148056626319885,
-0.1636657565832138,
0.10498842597007751,
-0.25535616278648376,
0.15341249108314514,
-0.23497796058654785,
-0.7699181437492371,
0.9754196405410767,
0.619631290435791,
0.18261735141277313,
0.1460580974817276,
-0.13487014174461365,
0.23507601022720337,
0.33828863501548767,
0.9610849618911743,
-0.1225346028804779,
-0.8824193477630615,
-0.640865683555603,
0.058873675763607025,
0.14444008469581604,
0.29774996638298035,
0.9965760111808777,
-0.9211008548736572,
0.5937367081642151,
0.2786625623703003,
0.41126686334609985,
0.2770341634750366,
-0.26623639464378357,
0.5402384996414185,
-0.9967089891433716,
0.38402801752090454,
0.22558315098285675,
0.2266395539045334,
0.3184085488319397,
-0.13526581227779388,
-0.15892869234085083,
0.03455282747745514,
-0.33413630723953247,
-0.7482519149780273,
0.27464595437049866,
-1.2197189331054688,
-0.4857734739780426,
1.2337926626205444,
0.22937899827957153,
-0.0431901291012764,
-0.0030276121105998755,
-0.5707436800003052,
0.3959961235523224,
-0.7942419052124023,
0.5878316164016724,
0.2549645006656647,
-0.038046978414058685,
-0.05565078556537628,
-0.6036477088928223,
0.4491862654685974,
0.30508366227149963,
-0.5958876609802246,
0.0889865830540657,
0.8108931183815002,
0.4799101948738098,
0.1056002825498581,
0.7857818007469177,
-0.18069447576999664,
0.31835195422172546,
-0.13895055651664734,
0.19348935782909393,
-0.31936201453208923,
-0.5107818245887756,
-0.5776180028915405,
0.30580824613571167,
0.05707190930843353,
-0.14466868340969086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03703v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03703v1
|
Synthesizing Conversations from Unlabeled Documents using Automatic Response Segmentation
| 2024-06-06T02:52:45 | 2024-06-06T02:52:45 |
Fanyou Wu, Weijie Xu, Chandan K. Reddy, Srinivasan H. Sengamedu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this study, we tackle the challenge of inadequate and costly training data
that has hindered the development of conversational question answering (ConvQA)
systems. Enterprises have a large corpus of diverse internal documents. Instead
of relying on a searching engine, a more compelling approach for people to
comprehend these documents is to create a dialogue system. In this paper, we
propose a robust dialog synthesising method. We learn the segmentation of data
for the dialog task instead of using segmenting at sentence boundaries. The
synthetic dataset generated by our proposed method achieves superior quality
when compared to WikiDialog, as assessed through machine and human evaluations.
By employing our inpainted data for ConvQA retrieval system pre-training, we
observed a notable improvement in performance across OR-QuAC benchmarks.
|
[
-0.6722345948219299,
-0.8199902176856995,
0.2551589012145996,
-0.2796984314918518,
-0.19693075120449066,
0.4061571955680847,
0.29893600940704346,
-0.446222186088562,
0.09655731171369553,
0.7173060774803162,
-0.8896368741989136,
-0.1900465041399002,
0.27739983797073364,
0.16589868068695068,
-0.39940518140792847,
0.7983412742614746,
0.33539435267448425,
0.21788766980171204,
-0.4221687614917755,
-0.030602270737290382,
-0.5944758057594299,
-0.6602998971939087,
-0.638105034828186,
-0.2784901559352875,
-0.18467435240745544,
0.4957663416862488,
0.4185153543949127,
0.3502279818058014,
0.08936513960361481,
0.38207003474235535,
0.09388311952352524,
0.6553179621696472,
-0.2743726372718811,
0.5102096199989319,
0.18975841999053955,
-0.24878521263599396,
-0.05322043597698212,
-0.07889599353075027,
0.5911788940429688,
0.6455150246620178,
0.12091070413589478,
-0.02416796050965786,
0.1606951802968979,
0.5913518667221069,
-0.37001290917396545,
-0.07223069667816162,
-0.899313747882843,
0.10143221914768219,
0.16987092792987823,
-0.29825693368911743,
-0.42749837040901184,
-0.4110940098762512,
0.41943037509918213,
-0.8092341423034668,
0.4111630320549011,
0.183683380484581,
0.6756995916366577,
0.09166304022073746,
-0.2996312975883484,
-0.6601858735084534,
-0.5722318887710571,
0.6163257956504822,
-0.6728223562240601,
0.22822533547878265,
0.1667039394378662,
0.3200685977935791,
-0.4643552899360657,
-0.7260310053825378,
-0.6783713698387146,
0.04583416134119034,
-0.12526251375675201,
0.3257836699485779,
0.00893103051930666,
0.06993967294692993,
0.1694723516702652,
0.33530017733573914,
-0.5516922473907471,
-0.3439129889011383,
-0.5151137113571167,
-0.35023030638694763,
0.4777129590511322,
0.47063133120536804,
0.2955135107040405,
-0.272603839635849,
-0.25713032484054565,
-0.19191491603851318,
-0.36773642897605896,
0.23873279988765717,
0.5218765735626221,
0.24009716510772705,
0.40208563208580017,
0.4399562180042267,
-0.3056066930294037,
0.6157755851745605,
0.3378475606441498,
-0.16033151745796204,
0.15449900925159454,
-0.4912284016609192,
-0.43078938126564026,
0.18033383786678314,
0.7776318192481995,
0.553326427936554,
0.05206630751490593,
-0.09518249332904816,
-0.025070568546652794,
-0.04433158040046692,
0.35262227058410645,
-0.9353735446929932,
-0.19975420832633972,
0.2601762115955353,
-0.23649486899375916,
-0.1433556079864502,
-0.25569796562194824,
-0.8177701234817505,
-0.22409334778785706,
-0.44214433431625366,
-0.0057921879924833775,
-0.5017271041870117,
0.25502392649650574,
-0.22544890642166138,
-0.23611637949943542,
0.23337508738040924,
0.533953070640564,
-0.7294405102729797,
0.3655610680580139,
0.31369826197624207,
0.3974534273147583,
0.0073021287098526955,
0.42838624119758606,
-0.7489952445030212,
0.04168170318007469,
-0.32632941007614136,
0.7970384955406189,
-0.45661091804504395,
-0.8173290491104126,
0.06655311584472656,
-0.10914013534784317,
-0.05842959135770798,
-0.9526503682136536,
0.42985376715660095,
-0.48298919200897217,
0.6605846881866455,
0.13112974166870117,
-0.6815385222434998,
-0.08560581505298615,
0.5605491995811462,
-0.4894299805164337,
0.8632432222366333,
0.31811124086380005,
-0.8217436671257019,
-0.0025530303828418255,
-0.5104491710662842,
-0.22544854879379272,
0.16563259065151215,
-0.1439848244190216,
-0.18694640696048737,
-0.3446548581123352,
0.48774680495262146,
0.06585817039012909,
-0.3488523066043854,
0.034839339554309845,
-0.11165175586938858,
-0.12732039391994476,
0.8164119124412537,
-0.3321164846420288,
0.8105305433273315,
0.4418128728866577,
-0.030402876436710358,
-0.05460701137781143,
-0.9835344552993774,
0.45177900791168213,
-0.33775919675827026,
-0.3932158648967743,
-0.2546995282173157,
-0.18044018745422363,
0.02174154482781887,
0.05317925289273262,
0.07018475979566574,
-0.789833128452301,
-0.004768110811710358,
-0.8760414123535156,
0.33410319685935974,
0.41838791966438293,
0.5140455961227417,
0.579149067401886,
-0.1573118418455124,
0.5137655735015869,
-0.06464936584234238,
0.22028538584709167,
-0.30328261852264404,
-0.2678651213645935,
-0.9433897137641907,
-0.0985201746225357,
0.13149631023406982,
0.5256688594818115,
-1.0163123607635498,
0.42847350239753723,
0.05063505098223686,
-0.2576109766960144,
-0.5985572338104248,
0.09897567331790924,
0.39829495549201965,
0.8628314733505249,
0.2762485444545746,
-0.5027787685394287,
-0.7982715368270874,
-1.0083086490631104,
0.12205523252487183,
-0.44693681597709656,
-0.45232492685317993,
0.3023211359977722,
-0.019572362303733826,
-0.18353025615215302,
1.1415542364120483,
-0.5920273065567017,
-0.09386356174945831,
-0.1486213207244873,
0.09409180283546448,
-0.05970705300569534,
0.5499584674835205,
0.09758225083351135,
-0.7825405597686768,
-0.559941828250885,
-0.045347098261117935,
-0.5020431876182556,
0.031892262399196625,
-0.2284943014383316,
-0.3332229256629944,
0.1200944259762764,
0.6976516842842102,
-0.6043944954872131,
0.35690733790397644,
0.02619677223265171,
-0.013180887326598167,
0.3563033938407898,
-0.03193295747041702,
0.22682978212833405,
-1.2635012865066528,
0.14537616074085236,
-0.1801477074623108,
-0.35219806432724,
-0.7397602796554565,
-0.382712721824646,
-0.2817472815513611,
-0.3965145945549011,
-0.44793227314949036,
0.32801932096481323,
-0.3894786834716797,
0.0650700256228447,
-0.10128732025623322,
0.17480385303497314,
0.24296694993972778,
0.6554439663887024,
-0.007769220508635044,
0.7178199887275696,
-0.020199881866574287,
-0.6294137239456177,
0.469596266746521,
1.1028810739517212,
-0.5299116373062134,
0.5931753516197205,
-0.6616316437721252,
0.36183521151542664,
-0.2199477106332779,
0.46962985396385193,
-0.9936909675598145,
-0.38259515166282654,
0.4275674819946289,
-0.6629412770271301,
0.08678007125854492,
-0.2663623094558716,
-0.1670449823141098,
-0.16542793810367584,
-0.22112901508808136,
0.21894246339797974,
0.501444935798645,
-0.2685040235519409,
0.42739030718803406,
0.7346649765968323,
-0.41390904784202576,
-0.1294848918914795,
-0.4448908865451813,
0.03062746487557888,
-0.3371714651584625,
-0.7288751602172852,
0.09016145020723343,
-0.39661791920661926,
-0.1970149576663971,
-0.46329066157341003,
-0.15351153910160065,
-0.45871973037719727,
-0.06920218467712402,
0.32440468668937683,
0.33506298065185547,
0.05764864757657051,
-0.08416689187288284,
0.0029557072557508945,
0.0800585001707077,
0.16218553483486176,
-0.059550587087869644,
0.4006085693836212,
0.21220842003822327,
-0.12308507412672043,
-0.4049842357635498,
0.6059176921844482,
0.6063165664672852,
-0.1923425793647766,
0.21052774786949158,
0.1669570654630661,
-0.16498588025569916,
-0.40964674949645996,
-0.3511686623096466,
-0.14341311156749725,
-0.5210689306259155,
-0.05555018410086632,
-0.059828419238328934,
-0.9054293036460876,
0.25470611453056335,
-0.1408083587884903,
0.18032942712306976,
0.214476078748703,
0.5449736714363098,
-0.3063949942588806,
0.8606347441673279,
0.1865040361881256,
0.27123427391052246,
0.6011820435523987,
-0.23505865037441254,
0.3516008257865906,
-0.8509652614593506,
-0.49194657802581787,
-0.6615281105041504,
0.12743672728538513,
-0.6244783401489258,
-0.4192918837070465,
0.7974222898483276,
-0.3944757282733917,
-0.04626183956861496,
0.21167917549610138,
-0.8093686699867249,
0.29710108041763306,
0.6762246489524841,
0.06699663400650024,
0.18224076926708221,
0.015537729486823082,
0.07896721363067627,
0.03298807889223099,
-0.5437072515487671,
-0.5371230840682983,
0.8851937651634216,
0.13307926058769226,
0.803419291973114,
-0.3488514721393585,
0.6126174330711365,
0.37418168783187866,
0.1436014473438263,
-0.7495249509811401,
0.6671082377433777,
0.19927085936069489,
-0.615094780921936,
-0.5186877250671387,
-0.5262830853462219,
-1.0197536945343018,
0.40010061860084534,
-0.35225120186805725,
-0.837738037109375,
0.08504565060138702,
-0.029350770637392998,
-0.5546251535415649,
-0.20461919903755188,
-0.9185378551483154,
0.7607365250587463,
0.0746794044971466,
0.1031791940331459,
0.09695444256067276,
-0.7769562005996704,
0.09275498241186142,
-0.16190773248672485,
0.057649049907922745,
-0.16116763651371002,
0.5754340887069702,
0.9351840019226074,
-0.8524197340011597,
0.6357149481773376,
-0.07805599272251129,
0.1660258173942566,
0.8932431936264038,
-0.08151976019144058,
0.291271448135376,
0.11443227529525757,
0.006765381898730993,
-0.623918890953064,
0.3995554745197296,
-0.23013384640216827,
-0.7434650659561157,
0.5347996950149536,
-0.5321303606033325,
-0.5833044052124023,
-0.06680405884981155,
-0.607975959777832,
-0.8276647329330444,
0.09537814557552338,
0.26218995451927185,
0.8125508427619934,
-0.7149187922477722,
0.3333755433559418,
0.7357125878334045,
-0.21377554535865784,
0.40565231442451477,
0.32302325963974,
0.23554402589797974,
-0.6597412824630737,
0.5368189811706543,
0.04518607258796692,
0.16240593791007996,
0.43107089400291443,
-0.12726791203022003,
-0.5332146286964417,
-0.43917763233184814,
-0.7101053595542908,
-0.22973231971263885,
-0.6947036385536194,
-0.4447462558746338,
-0.7881965041160583,
-0.37332144379615784,
-0.39848247170448303,
-0.10956132411956787,
-0.1970934271812439,
-0.46737438440322876,
-0.22491095960140228,
0.09315509349107742,
-0.08173739165067673,
0.5364018678665161,
0.547377347946167,
0.16335530579090118,
-1.161203145980835,
0.3214133679866791,
0.5666161775588989,
-0.17702525854110718,
0.0007576069328933954,
-0.43452057242393494,
-0.35284245014190674,
0.43043893575668335,
-0.6290844678878784,
-0.6560097932815552,
0.48241186141967773,
0.020614182576537132,
0.4002930819988251,
-0.08303163200616837,
0.4796629250049591,
0.5647822618484497,
-0.34190812706947327,
0.8414680361747742,
0.3469957113265991,
-0.7435486316680908,
0.522906482219696,
-0.302592933177948,
0.43682777881622314,
0.7877053618431091,
0.050432126969099045,
-0.4284344017505646,
-0.6312509179115295,
-0.6981205940246582,
-0.9556416273117065,
0.7254378795623779,
0.5471641421318054,
0.23919668793678284,
-0.03485746681690216,
-0.024697188287973404,
0.1635996252298355,
0.20090752840042114,
-0.06850581616163254,
0.13735134899616241,
-0.1340562105178833,
-0.3652392029762268,
0.3044400215148926,
-0.039624255150556564,
-0.16482850909233093,
-0.03456912934780121,
0.8789286613464355,
-0.35775694251060486,
0.23400762677192688,
0.4219702184200287,
0.0163735281676054,
-0.021734565496444702,
0.41505032777786255,
-0.12883923947811127,
0.4130444824695587,
-0.2925794720649719,
-0.27053019404411316,
0.06420246511697769,
-0.29890263080596924,
0.3454369604587555,
0.07130688428878784,
-0.41002553701400757,
0.27020031213760376,
-0.040784623473882675,
0.4805013835430145,
-0.17964155972003937,
-0.8701406121253967,
0.18242140114307404,
-0.41215068101882935,
-0.15588149428367615,
-0.31738489866256714,
0.2624843418598175,
0.12070392817258835,
0.29823529720306396,
0.3620526194572449,
-0.2178238183259964,
0.5421416759490967,
-0.6860454082489014,
0.10293885320425034,
0.47508132457733154,
-0.06290338188409805,
0.0035808717366307974,
0.3779093325138092,
0.625825822353363,
-0.28522443771362305,
0.9335917234420776,
0.21382851898670197,
-0.43674689531326294,
0.4761980473995209,
0.20405098795890808,
0.8349780440330505,
0.006506261881440878,
0.4012373983860016,
0.4303547143936157,
0.001014884328469634,
0.2978169322013855,
-0.0144500145688653,
-0.2903398275375366,
-0.637651264667511,
-0.11279450356960297,
-0.6369225978851318,
-0.7499550580978394,
0.2873913049697876,
-0.5434067249298096,
-0.2311764657497406,
-0.4642767906188965,
-0.23260848224163055,
0.3645784258842468,
0.08756618946790695,
-0.6124122738838196,
0.7154572010040283,
0.035142965614795685,
0.6696403622627258,
-0.4710647165775299,
0.5853076577186584,
0.5520032048225403,
-0.36295780539512634,
-0.8325780630111694,
0.05113319680094719,
-0.39114537835121155,
-0.320658415555954,
0.23818761110305786,
0.1480673849582672,
-0.0435510016977787,
-0.2927510738372803,
-0.6074689030647278,
-0.5440760254859924,
0.7090058922767639,
0.38586941361427307,
-0.19483648240566254,
-0.1437392234802246,
0.4219505488872528,
0.6524847745895386,
-0.4502129852771759,
0.19760742783546448,
0.5161484479904175,
0.0896124392747879,
0.3633991479873657,
-0.8111587166786194,
-0.08417141437530518,
-0.48281389474868774,
0.13128910958766937,
0.010603073053061962,
-0.6792779564857483,
0.29824012517929077,
0.4432322680950165,
-0.46946054697036743,
0.3444617986679077,
0.6455597877502441,
-0.20116737484931946,
0.4061554968357086,
0.49064016342163086,
0.18471454083919525,
0.8387020230293274,
0.0797257348895073,
0.7246215343475342,
0.0009260379592888057,
-0.061896663159132004,
1.2096552848815918,
-0.08813003450632095,
0.46645960211753845,
0.5996394753456116,
-0.06944447755813599,
0.36073827743530273,
0.6405460238456726,
0.2439136654138565,
0.5064176321029663,
0.27369609475135803,
-0.5075563788414001,
-0.38248440623283386,
-0.4343968331813812,
-0.05743570625782013,
0.545708417892456,
0.4272906184196472,
-0.17675644159317017,
-0.17901019752025604,
-0.16856633126735687,
-0.2705194354057312,
0.0726906955242157,
-0.03133320063352585,
1.180092692375183,
-0.01548692025244236,
-1.0871844291687012,
0.8600835204124451,
-0.20366381108760834,
0.1996505856513977,
-0.5926190614700317,
-0.17293111979961395,
-0.4666217863559723,
-0.007683370262384415,
-0.25962015986442566,
-0.7987679839134216,
0.29553037881851196,
0.14733950793743134,
-0.14054331183433533,
-0.22986121475696564,
0.6683940291404724,
-0.7976425886154175,
-0.07808070629835129,
-0.34328845143318176,
0.4931461215019226,
0.15336006879806519,
0.02205614186823368,
-0.5363196134567261,
-0.0692349299788475,
0.5142032504081726,
-0.12153761833906174,
0.4112895727157593,
0.5589784979820251,
-0.25606268644332886,
0.5924565196037292,
0.7598555684089661,
-0.6882047653198242,
-0.12551601231098175,
-0.17773385345935822,
1.2372355461120605,
-0.26513558626174927,
-0.7128711342811584,
-0.1769905984401703,
0.6352592706680298,
-0.3397802710533142,
-0.16874635219573975,
0.6236143112182617,
0.7380189895629883,
0.7600448131561279,
-0.08914712816476822,
1.1437338590621948,
0.031235121190547943,
0.6802017092704773,
-0.5038503408432007,
0.5039218664169312,
-0.23676815629005432,
-0.010965810157358646,
-0.19199177622795105,
-0.8910837769508362,
0.26169446110725403,
0.4335710406303406,
0.13141585886478424,
-0.3871435821056366,
0.4302271008491516,
1.0253181457519531,
0.01821981742978096,
0.20446479320526123,
0.35810327529907227,
-0.09630631655454636,
0.5378431677818298,
0.39387816190719604,
0.9401544332504272,
-0.47091203927993774,
0.8684377074241638,
0.10866348445415497,
-0.006428837310522795,
-0.14700697362422943,
-0.4183506369590759,
-0.9207481145858765,
-0.7378553152084351,
-0.21445269882678986,
-0.5650983452796936,
-0.0370299257338047,
0.8592037558555603,
0.6701809167861938,
-0.8166776299476624,
-0.18475833535194397,
0.15258218348026276,
-0.10723415017127991,
0.46053797006607056,
-0.2324945032596588,
0.1297670155763626,
-0.35990917682647705,
-0.7997270822525024,
0.7297104597091675,
0.2124304175376892,
0.3067108392715454,
-0.05040665343403816,
-0.06267382204532623,
-0.09146246314048767,
0.4747205674648285,
0.27559393644332886,
0.36767077445983887,
-0.18171752989292145,
-0.11767522990703583,
-0.09640612453222275,
-0.08816196769475937,
0.2115117460489273,
0.9033263921737671,
-0.7164983749389648,
0.9177861213684082,
0.4963567852973938,
0.9539035558700562,
0.8607456088066101,
0.3846774101257324,
0.8036203980445862,
-0.7776591181755066,
0.16554923355579376,
0.4056239426136017,
0.014531067572534084,
0.7796154022216797,
-0.3638123571872711,
0.4091515839099884,
0.0835217833518982,
-0.4489181637763977,
-0.556219756603241,
0.11266336590051651,
-1.0033009052276611,
-0.1475059986114502,
0.8959678411483765,
-0.08357813954353333,
-0.42688268423080444,
-0.38617202639579773,
-0.7389913201332092,
0.2958794832229614,
-0.6421489715576172,
0.6285304427146912,
0.4403807818889618,
-0.33239054679870605,
0.22905591130256653,
-0.12686704099178314,
0.603041410446167,
0.153425931930542,
-1.0970818996429443,
0.05424731597304344,
1.0909090042114258,
0.27310311794281006,
0.14679200947284698,
0.926460862159729,
-0.062225863337516785,
0.23705635964870453,
0.1950712949037552,
-0.1597202867269516,
0.022601710632443428,
0.036432214081287384,
0.38660722970962524,
0.255747526884079,
-0.1406318098306656,
-0.5668059587478638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03699v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03699v1
|
M-QALM: A Benchmark to Assess Clinical Reading Comprehension and Knowledge Recall in Large Language Models via Question Answering
| 2024-06-06T02:43:21 | 2024-06-06T02:43:21 |
Anand Subramanian, Viktor Schlegel, Abhinav Ramesh Kashyap, Thanh-Tung Nguyen, Vijay Prakash Dwivedi, Stefan Winkler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
There is vivid research on adapting Large Language Models (LLMs) to perform a
variety of tasks in high-stakes domains such as healthcare. Despite their
popularity, there is a lack of understanding of the extent and contributing
factors that allow LLMs to recall relevant knowledge and combine it with
presented information in the clinical and biomedical domain: a fundamental
pre-requisite for success on down-stream tasks. Addressing this gap, we use
Multiple Choice and Abstractive Question Answering to conduct a large-scale
empirical study on 22 datasets in three generalist and three specialist
biomedical sub-domains. Our multifaceted analysis of the performance of 15
LLMs, further broken down by sub-domain, source of knowledge and model
architecture, uncovers success factors such as instruction tuning that lead to
improved recall and comprehension. We further show that while recently proposed
domain-adapted models may lack adequate knowledge, directly fine-tuning on our
collected medical knowledge datasets shows encouraging results, even
generalising to unseen specialist sub-domains. We complement the quantitative
results with a skill-oriented manual error analysis, which reveals a
significant gap between the models' capabilities to simply recall necessary
knowledge and to integrate it with the presented context. To foster research
and collaboration in this field we share M-QALM, our resources, standardised
methodology, and evaluation results, with the research community to facilitate
further advancements in clinical knowledge representation learning within
language models.
|
[
-0.08610497415065765,
-0.5256552696228027,
0.8992210030555725,
-0.2228429615497589,
-0.010435612872242928,
0.15520118176937103,
0.1901416778564453,
-0.3636144697666168,
-0.036241501569747925,
0.5033213496208191,
-0.4780125617980957,
-0.6196790933609009,
-0.7475922107696533,
0.13334277272224426,
-0.152964249253273,
0.5312727689743042,
-0.11915422976016998,
0.3556005358695984,
-0.7284720540046692,
-0.2891993522644043,
-0.5872320532798767,
-0.7744992971420288,
-0.5481086373329163,
-0.48907870054244995,
0.6923933625221252,
0.3655591905117035,
0.5423893332481384,
0.5806179642677307,
0.5591504573822021,
0.1281188428401947,
-0.0258052758872509,
0.39225807785987854,
-0.45035549998283386,
0.040400899946689606,
-0.2441413849592209,
-0.7490885257720947,
-0.7202851176261902,
-0.05367017164826393,
0.7572944760322571,
0.8855271935462952,
-0.21232639253139496,
0.08203812688589096,
0.05446625500917435,
0.7022671103477478,
-0.7327115535736084,
-0.008293865248560905,
-0.4262624680995941,
-0.22271870076656342,
0.15505501627922058,
-0.5317895412445068,
-0.4441539943218231,
-0.5668321251869202,
0.37248316407203674,
-0.5788761377334595,
0.0933675691485405,
0.19072115421295166,
0.5068519115447998,
0.17590974271297455,
-0.7773137092590332,
-0.6064721941947937,
-0.40644320845603943,
0.8329868316650391,
-0.7750154733657837,
0.589085578918457,
0.56200110912323,
0.38586458563804626,
0.16504141688346863,
-0.6335706114768982,
-0.45167243480682373,
-0.2634872496128082,
-0.03169751912355423,
0.3197915554046631,
-0.16043397784233093,
0.23257328569889069,
0.11438869684934616,
0.29558423161506653,
-0.6288260221481323,
-0.068706214427948,
-0.48395463824272156,
-0.20924648642539978,
0.4137735962867737,
0.5493054389953613,
0.3120569586753845,
0.22703060507774353,
-0.3400405943393707,
-0.10149005800485611,
-0.9495760202407837,
0.003150842385366559,
-0.21120718121528625,
-0.13629692792892456,
-0.016149334609508514,
0.625712513923645,
-0.14521123468875885,
0.4836881160736084,
-0.39746174216270447,
-0.43326830863952637,
0.1968601644039154,
-0.5047558546066284,
-0.14364118874073029,
-0.15030670166015625,
0.40085136890411377,
0.5615562200546265,
0.3420138657093048,
-0.16453425586223602,
0.08482621610164642,
-0.2037755846977234,
0.259914368391037,
-0.716496467590332,
-0.17328794300556183,
0.4020734131336212,
-0.4985271692276001,
0.22993150353431702,
-0.36106520891189575,
-0.5965821146965027,
-0.4977852404117584,
-0.40003547072410583,
0.33726054430007935,
-0.5031511187553406,
-0.12732312083244324,
0.477547824382782,
-0.07545556128025055,
0.20230983197689056,
0.4694780707359314,
-0.6086510419845581,
0.28478726744651794,
0.47724130749702454,
0.6559947729110718,
-0.09317988902330399,
-0.24816343188285828,
-0.3100692331790924,
0.274598628282547,
-0.28913551568984985,
0.7567905187606812,
-0.44811421632766724,
-0.4436087906360626,
0.19611622393131256,
-0.030463799834251404,
-0.6757828593254089,
-0.7327911257743835,
0.34451502561569214,
-0.7011830806732178,
0.03510449454188347,
-0.3660842180252075,
-0.9319084286689758,
-0.25989097356796265,
0.5376358032226562,
-0.4263026714324951,
0.5953433513641357,
0.3599439263343811,
-0.47892752289772034,
0.27420172095298767,
-0.190109521150589,
-0.19676180183887482,
-0.06301051378250122,
-0.08616359531879425,
-0.1217656210064888,
0.13238036632537842,
0.17762625217437744,
0.2928725779056549,
-0.6349499225616455,
0.023983288556337357,
-0.3335396647453308,
-0.05562997981905937,
0.5183300375938416,
-0.2627470791339874,
0.3801298439502716,
0.0296240895986557,
0.2719602584838867,
0.020894961431622505,
-0.7118247747421265,
0.2448314130306244,
-0.17760197818279266,
-0.4569784998893738,
-0.3657456636428833,
-0.08986884355545044,
-0.1260940432548523,
0.47315022349357605,
0.17015774548053741,
-0.35533174872398376,
0.19416651129722595,
-0.22033637762069702,
0.5414531230926514,
0.11394753307104111,
0.2627756893634796,
0.19369523227214813,
-0.8186435103416443,
0.9749804735183716,
0.02223932184278965,
0.1635349541902542,
-0.3169567883014679,
-0.2693922519683838,
-0.49533119797706604,
-0.34425002336502075,
0.33950862288475037,
0.6690444946289062,
-0.7635048627853394,
-0.1494455188512802,
-0.1843050867319107,
-0.34811148047447205,
-0.9201459288597107,
0.22838354110717773,
0.5856685042381287,
0.6458159685134888,
0.563003420829773,
-0.12895861268043518,
-0.17461161315441132,
-0.7697956562042236,
-0.11371242254972458,
-0.25753453373908997,
0.021684138104319572,
0.6102690696716309,
0.4654006361961365,
-0.5120542645454407,
0.5058406591415405,
-0.43501174449920654,
-0.3066353499889374,
-0.17567165195941925,
-0.10424871742725372,
-0.03193533048033714,
0.3387849032878876,
0.23135046660900116,
-0.5460041761398315,
-0.06831272691488266,
-0.07880476862192154,
-0.9372894167900085,
-0.13577179610729218,
0.008116981014609337,
-0.03708268329501152,
-0.1903504878282547,
0.6961577534675598,
-0.5542887449264526,
0.19983267784118652,
0.48966458439826965,
-0.2752797603607178,
0.8284186720848083,
-0.46112319827079773,
0.46583858132362366,
-0.9676128625869751,
0.2362021505832672,
-0.29251912236213684,
-0.07789543271064758,
-0.6140010356903076,
0.17637090384960175,
0.48186251521110535,
0.09887940436601639,
-0.5158951282501221,
0.7512004971504211,
-0.4249870181083679,
0.20403443276882172,
-0.2397252768278122,
0.28336969017982483,
0.30821558833122253,
0.14063163101673126,
-0.030400114133954048,
0.7183490991592407,
0.35521358251571655,
-0.636644184589386,
-0.07219783216714859,
0.3872240483760834,
-0.27467942237854004,
0.617929995059967,
-0.79429030418396,
0.0571843720972538,
0.08343885093927383,
-0.11827202141284943,
-1.1584855318069458,
-0.12688782811164856,
-0.022157538682222366,
-0.36433663964271545,
0.23881638050079346,
-0.0410376600921154,
-0.4975198805332184,
-0.24576866626739502,
0.13142195343971252,
0.7309271693229675,
0.36173829436302185,
-0.09443214535713196,
0.6634926795959473,
0.39515599608421326,
-0.4473663568496704,
-0.4968435764312744,
-0.41851601004600525,
-0.10392656177282333,
-0.1255664825439453,
-0.5563034415245056,
0.11418205499649048,
-0.16880130767822266,
-0.15870076417922974,
-0.22150678932666779,
-0.12870097160339355,
-0.2217804342508316,
0.0688161626458168,
-0.00419593695551157,
0.2029900848865509,
-0.5026479363441467,
0.41589388251304626,
0.18621967732906342,
-0.14403104782104492,
0.24525393545627594,
-0.06200661137700081,
0.43754786252975464,
-0.009158968925476074,
-0.5546365976333618,
-0.3349730670452118,
0.28058719635009766,
0.8155236840248108,
-0.32991254329681396,
0.6283890008926392,
0.19446587562561035,
-0.4287130832672119,
0.0014594427775591612,
-0.608727216720581,
-0.13235323131084442,
-0.32780689001083374,
0.45007002353668213,
-0.37097781896591187,
-1.113214373588562,
0.5105631351470947,
-0.1880134791135788,
-0.14519473910331726,
0.27304112911224365,
0.6091869473457336,
-0.21816544234752655,
1.0918054580688477,
0.37351346015930176,
0.03833884745836258,
-0.12993068993091583,
-0.07280813157558441,
-0.19531644880771637,
-0.8953526616096497,
-0.2377902865409851,
-0.3962245583534241,
-0.12292321771383286,
-0.059721704572439194,
-0.623420238494873,
0.6326947212219238,
0.25134003162384033,
0.04135870561003685,
-0.3347492814064026,
0.09843632578849792,
0.17853783071041107,
0.42940792441368103,
0.26394444704055786,
0.6081874370574951,
-0.44348588585853577,
-0.39543280005455017,
0.03572291135787964,
-0.8492429852485657,
-0.7036254405975342,
1.3265002965927124,
0.44626691937446594,
0.6679434180259705,
0.0714598223567009,
0.48543477058410645,
0.20790797472000122,
0.322559654712677,
-0.8521512150764465,
0.2706958055496216,
0.1100149154663086,
-0.6504316926002502,
-0.11494482308626175,
-0.27522706985473633,
-1.0305018424987793,
0.466056227684021,
-0.3130684196949005,
-0.33595341444015503,
0.22568373382091522,
0.27227911353111267,
-0.7285875678062439,
0.031452734023332596,
-0.6271048188209534,
0.8418861627578735,
-0.1424681842327118,
-0.14814960956573486,
-0.36232876777648926,
-0.5660088658332825,
0.4747420847415924,
-0.12278521060943604,
0.27974453568458557,
-0.1023968830704689,
-0.2955745756626129,
0.5975409150123596,
-0.15026143193244934,
0.7042869925498962,
-0.04109017178416252,
-0.02946818619966507,
0.27293121814727783,
0.14680255949497223,
-0.09429917484521866,
0.17642821371555328,
-0.10316087305545807,
0.0060130576603114605,
0.8374138474464417,
-0.7571513056755066,
-0.5792605876922607,
0.24515610933303833,
-0.7315080761909485,
-0.5317914485931396,
-0.4628579020500183,
-0.8176995515823364,
-0.710981547832489,
0.21303220093250275,
-0.1296497881412506,
0.6770177483558655,
-0.36181411147117615,
0.22399595379829407,
0.8565967082977295,
-0.3498772978782654,
-0.19912029802799225,
0.9029220938682556,
-0.2105952501296997,
-0.47860318422317505,
0.6700301766395569,
0.00816350057721138,
0.5082305669784546,
0.566608726978302,
0.029193472117185593,
-0.5030094981193542,
-1.0520702600479126,
-0.3399350345134735,
0.47298794984817505,
-0.8058952689170837,
-0.013971485197544098,
-0.7364271879196167,
-0.28525838255882263,
-0.24575798213481903,
0.10294792056083679,
0.03012317791581154,
-0.18454483151435852,
-0.3004837930202484,
0.08890412002801895,
0.03779326751828194,
0.6764457821846008,
0.28387486934661865,
0.4074900448322296,
-1.2472541332244873,
0.2038498818874359,
0.3001866936683655,
0.0913454070687294,
0.13978005945682526,
-0.5493453145027161,
-0.4226590096950531,
0.02954157628118992,
-0.3813316226005554,
-0.7697674036026001,
0.4973045587539673,
0.284595787525177,
0.7960482239723206,
0.3563478887081146,
-0.04482784867286682,
0.49002474546432495,
-0.5126080513000488,
0.41362276673316956,
0.05263911187648773,
-0.5849551558494568,
0.311901330947876,
-0.30719226598739624,
0.4628585875034332,
0.7421252727508545,
0.681685209274292,
-0.6651262044906616,
-0.33436349034309387,
-0.4964614808559418,
-0.6223471164703369,
0.2216506153345108,
-0.16511757671833038,
-0.22639304399490356,
-0.0632503479719162,
0.5146792531013489,
0.20750309526920319,
0.3543190658092499,
-0.2034686952829361,
-0.09538612514734268,
0.31020182371139526,
-0.43330520391464233,
-0.4917620122432709,
-0.3488070070743561,
-0.2464953511953354,
-0.16450375318527222,
0.43669581413269043,
-0.2932609021663666,
0.135249063372612,
0.5373966693878174,
-0.5479515194892883,
0.10427132248878479,
0.39493709802627563,
0.6490391492843628,
1.1853431463241577,
-0.3632304072380066,
0.2894919216632843,
0.0722033828496933,
-0.5895754098892212,
0.1404346376657486,
0.01738624833524227,
0.09746932238340378,
-0.29763099551200867,
0.6480580568313599,
0.22128988802433014,
0.2858169376850128,
-1.1835863590240479,
0.36303797364234924,
-0.09396124631166458,
-0.4907514750957489,
0.013807318173348904,
0.17360790073871613,
0.4871408939361572,
0.45150068402290344,
0.3434261381626129,
-0.060465991497039795,
0.15225155651569366,
-0.4495694637298584,
0.38386863470077515,
0.25646770000457764,
-0.6113219857215881,
-0.2747633457183838,
0.5988553762435913,
-0.09853725880384445,
-0.0030689251143485308,
0.42423927783966064,
0.15862472355365753,
-0.23744787275791168,
0.6265843510627747,
0.4895389974117279,
0.25590598583221436,
-0.10722348839044571,
0.10639014840126038,
0.3307577073574066,
0.31906041502952576,
-0.0793856531381607,
0.5482161045074463,
0.2578234374523163,
-0.7420953512191772,
-0.29896602034568787,
-0.3518426716327667,
-0.6424221396446228,
0.16658276319503784,
-0.9267767071723938,
-0.2507316470146179,
-0.39315399527549744,
-0.09768281131982803,
-0.013525167480111122,
-0.01954459585249424,
-0.7901517748832703,
0.4455421566963196,
-0.07925597578287125,
1.242110252380371,
-0.757226824760437,
1.0305808782577515,
0.6285743713378906,
-0.49401381611824036,
-0.5102589726448059,
-0.1472039520740509,
-0.022049356251955032,
-1.2306994199752808,
0.32868966460227966,
-0.15544383227825165,
0.10664727538824081,
0.1995432823896408,
-0.170940563082695,
-0.7829701900482178,
1.294893741607666,
0.16154880821704865,
-0.6025068163871765,
-0.17033876478672028,
0.25523489713668823,
0.6799538135528564,
-0.5767195224761963,
0.46028321981430054,
0.8558478355407715,
0.11760108172893524,
0.014420515857636929,
-0.8151628971099854,
0.1467948853969574,
-0.1424151510000229,
-0.3494046926498413,
0.002299837302416563,
-0.5384317636489868,
0.713456928730011,
-0.323104590177536,
0.018331600353121758,
0.3256867527961731,
0.30319178104400635,
0.6613366603851318,
0.7310752272605896,
0.26257169246673584,
0.4221215844154358,
1.2337299585342407,
0.05841526389122009,
1.083451271057129,
-0.3906707465648651,
0.08038785308599472,
0.8849592804908752,
-0.4026572108268738,
1.0120388269424438,
0.5260763764381409,
-0.3240204155445099,
0.2607875168323517,
0.6272016763687134,
0.3749421238899231,
0.5064467191696167,
0.11098234355449677,
-0.1863417774438858,
-0.45990651845932007,
-0.06788581609725952,
-0.6443151831626892,
0.1160660982131958,
0.6397125720977783,
-0.5813794136047363,
-0.020732197910547256,
0.12817299365997314,
-0.2582065165042877,
0.0215914286673069,
-0.4925459623336792,
0.8176679015159607,
0.4766096770763397,
-0.5470408201217651,
0.9465540647506714,
-0.315278559923172,
0.15975065529346466,
-0.5914242267608643,
-0.0201333649456501,
-0.24171213805675507,
0.24595250189304352,
0.021220609545707703,
-0.6551148295402527,
0.04034992307424545,
-0.49013054370880127,
-0.5567306876182556,
0.07432869076728821,
0.6254448294639587,
-0.5778889060020447,
-0.39867261052131653,
0.2952346205711365,
1.204512357711792,
0.15211157500743866,
-0.03643368184566498,
-0.6565954685211182,
-0.2608853280544281,
-0.18232935667037964,
0.074528768658638,
0.5759674906730652,
0.4643707275390625,
0.03677002713084221,
0.9392522573471069,
0.5351303815841675,
0.2679254710674286,
0.10302450507879257,
0.20310474932193756,
0.6546247601509094,
-0.7793891429901123,
-0.30409178137779236,
-0.711685061454773,
0.28911566734313965,
0.26262497901916504,
-0.59920334815979,
0.6723516583442688,
0.4124039113521576,
0.5757216215133667,
-0.11067710071802139,
0.83745938539505,
0.5444951057434082,
0.8415848016738892,
-0.7232656478881836,
0.7453614473342896,
-0.7941175699234009,
0.2090056836605072,
0.08874264359474182,
-0.347362220287323,
-0.2537130117416382,
0.2143290936946869,
-0.5555455088615417,
-0.009587014093995094,
0.909877598285675,
0.7598638534545898,
0.02198880724608898,
0.07506446540355682,
0.5857060551643372,
0.1779187172651291,
0.08641458302736282,
0.9288253784179688,
1.1173559427261353,
-0.45736396312713623,
0.36752113699913025,
0.1950397789478302,
-0.24171359837055206,
-0.37112316489219666,
-0.6314160823822021,
-0.9937063455581665,
-0.3770628571510315,
-0.33291929960250854,
-0.4722479581832886,
0.32745033502578735,
0.7940577864646912,
0.7051259279251099,
-0.8618467450141907,
-0.15968407690525055,
0.40206390619277954,
0.1339469850063324,
-0.3462914526462555,
-0.11128325015306473,
0.5408799052238464,
-0.40312695503234863,
-0.2788982391357422,
0.3587527573108673,
0.18942013382911682,
-0.0796833485364914,
0.02822262980043888,
-0.2614317834377289,
-0.24947161972522736,
0.09750059247016907,
0.7292094826698303,
0.3189958930015564,
-0.5723958015441895,
0.12417814880609512,
0.2981760799884796,
-0.333890825510025,
0.18678948283195496,
0.8702955842018127,
-0.5462830066680908,
0.4729417860507965,
0.3298952281475067,
0.9653757810592651,
0.31238871812820435,
-0.0008978737168945372,
0.627375066280365,
-0.25582200288772583,
-0.3726153075695038,
0.41634005308151245,
0.43413370847702026,
0.0841992199420929,
0.06872065365314484,
0.216770201921463,
0.21168218553066254,
-0.7520651817321777,
-0.7150967717170715,
-0.10046690702438354,
-0.9026600122451782,
-0.42194247245788574,
1.1510688066482544,
-0.2579461336135864,
-0.05580955743789673,
-0.5369523763656616,
-0.4302190840244293,
0.07280441373586655,
-0.01944076642394066,
0.82783442735672,
0.8087570667266846,
-0.10834796726703644,
-0.33485737442970276,
-1.05595064163208,
0.48685795068740845,
0.5709711313247681,
-0.7655512690544128,
-0.050233352929353714,
0.41329267621040344,
0.4224552810192108,
-0.14197374880313873,
0.8185863494873047,
-0.16872133314609528,
0.5556875467300415,
-0.2298538088798523,
0.06021427735686302,
0.08252627402544022,
-0.2602460980415344,
-0.4736262857913971,
0.34934186935424805,
0.37735623121261597,
0.09244105219841003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03689v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03689v2
|
Evaluating the World Model Implicit in a Generative Model
| 2024-06-06T02:20:31 | 2024-06-22T18:23:08 |
Keyon Vafa, Justin Y. Chen, Jon Kleinberg, Sendhil Mullainathan, Ashesh Rambachan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent work suggests that large language models may implicitly learn world
models. How should we assess this possibility? We formalize this question for
the case where the underlying reality is governed by a deterministic finite
automaton. This includes problems as diverse as simple logical reasoning,
geographic navigation, game-playing, and chemistry. We propose new evaluation
metrics for world model recovery inspired by the classic Myhill-Nerode theorem
from language theory. We illustrate their utility in three domains: game
playing, logic puzzles, and navigation. In all domains, the generative models
we consider do well on existing diagnostics for assessing world models, but our
evaluation metrics reveal their world models to be far less coherent than they
appear. Such incoherence creates fragility: using a generative model to solve
related but subtly different tasks can lead it to fail badly. Building
generative models that meaningfully capture the underlying logic of the domains
they model would be immensely valuable; our results suggest new ways to assess
how close a given model is to that goal.
|
[
-0.3341083824634552,
-0.8198086619377136,
0.8430956602096558,
0.23796871304512024,
0.21000945568084717,
-0.06447971612215042,
-0.09772920608520508,
-0.47953489422798157,
-0.3280359208583832,
0.21611763536930084,
-0.7244797348976135,
-0.3957209289073944,
-0.4918246865272522,
0.09172232449054718,
-0.42139932513237,
1.0264512300491333,
0.01131727360188961,
-0.04331694915890694,
-0.4047827124595642,
-0.21242080628871918,
-0.26269349455833435,
-0.31062594056129456,
-0.7558268904685974,
-0.4560609757900238,
0.18462421000003815,
-0.10592983663082123,
0.8383150696754456,
0.4619188606739044,
0.4859355390071869,
0.3733457922935486,
0.06375977396965027,
-0.12195877730846405,
-0.45330923795700073,
0.3481040894985199,
-0.2115219086408615,
-0.4795529544353485,
-0.3310578167438507,
0.4602321684360504,
0.5331571698188782,
0.7803719639778137,
-0.17253179848194122,
0.016316307708621025,
0.08945576846599579,
0.48897674679756165,
-0.5825172066688538,
0.7113800048828125,
-0.2503211498260498,
0.3070504665374756,
0.46982768177986145,
0.15437071025371552,
-0.153842955827713,
-0.39345768094062805,
0.4338110089302063,
-0.8591814041137695,
0.2721088230609894,
0.18125633895397186,
0.6220974326133728,
0.24305211007595062,
-0.3537096679210663,
-0.20706923305988312,
-1.1315661668777466,
0.7940934896469116,
-0.39573124051094055,
0.37511423230171204,
0.24507342278957367,
0.5825091600418091,
-0.33945900201797485,
-0.43239668011665344,
-0.5834418535232544,
-0.6815277934074402,
0.17105741798877716,
0.5188085436820984,
-0.5680565237998962,
0.1257329285144806,
0.6678457260131836,
0.6007241010665894,
-0.5777568817138672,
-0.16158615052700043,
-0.10477734357118607,
-0.13085809350013733,
0.6271001100540161,
0.34214743971824646,
0.5661131143569946,
-0.09470687061548233,
-0.555815577507019,
-0.08717257529497147,
-0.72547847032547,
-0.12336407601833344,
0.2914711534976959,
-0.03921889513731003,
-0.2585727870464325,
0.2825782001018524,
-0.18394716084003448,
0.5579647421836853,
-0.10583243519067764,
-0.2859678864479065,
-0.22065195441246033,
-0.21029408276081085,
-0.07347237318754196,
-0.3893297016620636,
0.5143237709999084,
0.18178601562976837,
0.41312718391418457,
-0.353708416223526,
-0.4058026373386383,
0.22447656095027924,
0.17038454115390778,
-0.5477415919303894,
-0.4066782295703888,
0.14239288866519928,
-0.3755027949810028,
-0.12904024124145508,
0.13373026251792908,
-0.487552672624588,
-0.355808824300766,
-0.323286771774292,
0.44281667470932007,
-0.492800235748291,
-0.5628485083580017,
0.06522991508245468,
-0.2107364386320114,
0.3352251350879669,
0.4599158465862274,
-0.9010186195373535,
0.5709272027015686,
1.0757529735565186,
0.9732903242111206,
-0.010084639303386211,
-0.40958473086357117,
-0.3000524342060089,
-0.09671814739704132,
-0.5153952240943909,
0.8198763728141785,
-0.4095829427242279,
-0.49225670099258423,
-0.09100041538476944,
0.10782239586114883,
0.051411814987659454,
-0.6035106778144836,
0.3745279908180237,
-0.4457196593284607,
0.1360388547182083,
-0.30977559089660645,
-0.585661768913269,
-0.3773556053638458,
0.5247467756271362,
-0.9660502076148987,
0.8027473092079163,
0.17247438430786133,
-0.47558555006980896,
0.5036067962646484,
-0.6076723337173462,
-0.2840188145637512,
-0.04868602007627487,
-0.02117338217794895,
-0.30631518363952637,
0.4405071437358856,
-0.011685841716825962,
0.20595017075538635,
-0.639505922794342,
0.3601744771003723,
-0.5146011114120483,
-0.24406422674655914,
0.12345876544713974,
-0.7126225829124451,
1.0099784135818481,
0.19230662286281586,
-0.3188476860523224,
-0.14244304597377777,
-0.6207647919654846,
0.06489624828100204,
-0.022099371999502182,
-0.2300644814968109,
-0.4978625774383545,
0.2553379237651825,
-0.2784518897533417,
0.29210323095321655,
-0.10673720389604568,
-0.6848322749137878,
0.17536261677742004,
-0.42854782938957214,
0.2850022614002228,
0.7767186760902405,
0.21632547676563263,
0.40352863073349,
-0.47874578833580017,
0.6396365165710449,
-0.05840512737631798,
0.26420363783836365,
0.1383458822965622,
-0.6424679756164551,
-0.9487958550453186,
-0.24644921720027924,
0.25258868932724,
0.43852758407592773,
-0.697228729724884,
0.35454967617988586,
-0.4784691035747528,
-0.42027872800827026,
-0.4054439067840576,
-0.2507168650627136,
0.583692729473114,
0.2046511173248291,
0.2669341564178467,
-0.3657247722148895,
-0.2861844599246979,
-0.7913140654563904,
-0.36788010597229004,
-0.547298789024353,
-0.034666888415813446,
0.2603064179420471,
0.9005023241043091,
0.023164110258221626,
0.8416374921798706,
-0.4539751410484314,
-0.13073228299617767,
-0.13755320012569427,
0.14808538556098938,
-0.13128262758255005,
0.6285937428474426,
0.297313392162323,
-0.8157176375389099,
-0.25449231266975403,
-0.07637220621109009,
-1.0572926998138428,
0.11338590830564499,
-0.16661366820335388,
-0.21140411496162415,
0.018237343057990074,
0.3606691062450409,
-0.6408253312110901,
0.3110494613647461,
0.3623633086681366,
-0.29752182960510254,
0.6238546967506409,
-0.23351117968559265,
0.16809570789337158,
-0.5394896864891052,
0.034862227737903595,
0.05634592846035957,
-0.2263040393590927,
-0.43969401717185974,
0.3892851173877716,
-0.14382874965667725,
-0.05634624511003494,
-0.1864185631275177,
0.7935272455215454,
-0.6533634066581726,
-0.24191166460514069,
-0.06540001928806305,
0.23540517687797546,
0.0767921581864357,
0.32386448979377747,
-0.08105156570672989,
0.49622485041618347,
0.5459507703781128,
-0.761414110660553,
0.4485335350036621,
0.15752755105495453,
-0.7033766508102417,
0.8165923357009888,
-0.5905803442001343,
-0.08765662461519241,
-0.39635783433914185,
0.1992325335741043,
-1.0054187774658203,
-0.08676565438508987,
0.054140545427799225,
-0.22382965683937073,
0.053842637687921524,
-0.36518940329551697,
-0.32257241010665894,
-0.26853495836257935,
-0.019195523113012314,
0.25758233666419983,
0.7582488059997559,
-0.8237519264221191,
0.4588228762149811,
0.34305715560913086,
0.07476503401994705,
-0.27444159984588623,
-0.4217216968536377,
-0.12606005370616913,
-0.23212599754333496,
-0.4828815460205078,
0.09536416083574295,
-0.29039615392684937,
-0.6784834861755371,
0.016428228467702866,
-0.24643480777740479,
-0.09093070775270462,
0.44718414545059204,
0.47496941685676575,
0.1304917186498642,
-0.24878573417663574,
0.1716630458831787,
-0.13731393218040466,
-0.3505745232105255,
0.2800711691379547,
-0.5102710127830505,
0.25983476638793945,
-0.2583204209804535,
-0.41272449493408203,
0.0275033600628376,
0.289622038602829,
0.49252837896347046,
-0.32682928442955017,
0.44724157452583313,
0.2368909865617752,
-0.6990214586257935,
-0.3159155547618866,
-0.46425724029541016,
0.015574418939650059,
-0.4109672009944916,
0.4262619614601135,
-0.5868817567825317,
-0.5740349888801575,
0.5277345776557922,
-0.2316673845052719,
0.0411628820002079,
0.7165905237197876,
0.4219880700111389,
-0.02908622846007347,
1.2915478944778442,
0.9041197896003723,
0.03500194475054741,
0.1705707162618637,
-0.6297770738601685,
0.166852667927742,
-0.8765354752540588,
-0.39487168192863464,
-0.33033496141433716,
0.028264177963137627,
-0.5597532391548157,
-0.3288955092430115,
0.5510683655738831,
0.08294814079999924,
-0.24333903193473816,
0.05296828970313072,
0.015211605466902256,
0.6070849299430847,
0.2893792986869812,
-0.1330702304840088,
0.4985435903072357,
0.08755417913198471,
-0.2628630995750427,
-0.22415275871753693,
-0.7021707892417908,
-0.5414263606071472,
0.7255245447158813,
0.11285019665956497,
0.9481388926506042,
0.3596990406513214,
0.5852173566818237,
0.2700820565223694,
0.8466628193855286,
-0.9114981889724731,
0.39174190163612366,
-0.03990821912884712,
-0.7718502283096313,
-0.16007709503173828,
-0.5188272595405579,
-0.9819425940513611,
0.5850678086280823,
-0.21532368659973145,
-0.48899197578430176,
0.09614552557468414,
-0.052906583994627,
-0.43278566002845764,
0.1866162270307541,
-0.337821900844574,
1.063544511795044,
-0.19821158051490784,
-0.3737104833126068,
-0.12009887397289276,
-0.289895236492157,
0.7371959090232849,
0.24207627773284912,
0.16934499144554138,
-0.345502644777298,
0.11222248524427414,
0.48371681571006775,
-0.3225592076778412,
0.6157478094100952,
-0.262485533952713,
-0.4023289084434509,
0.38952964544296265,
0.5426046252250671,
0.10470569133758545,
0.15427711606025696,
-0.07400858402252197,
0.02071516402065754,
0.07251410186290741,
-0.15118883550167084,
-1.133861780166626,
0.8390397429466248,
-0.5961322784423828,
-0.7174659371376038,
-0.5864695906639099,
-0.4607769846916199,
-0.16890157759189606,
0.08784196525812149,
0.18740423023700714,
0.5130366086959839,
-0.9956531524658203,
-0.42247098684310913,
0.6755024194717407,
0.021580368280410767,
0.4610993266105652,
0.8080919981002808,
-0.266579806804657,
-0.05844978615641594,
1.0239025354385376,
0.12964262068271637,
0.4549766182899475,
0.1343003660440445,
0.0949227437376976,
-0.3552207350730896,
-0.21748730540275574,
-0.4619017243385315,
-0.024690529331564903,
-0.8586357831954956,
-0.15071450173854828,
-0.38301852345466614,
-0.23634563386440277,
0.20924484729766846,
0.11871348321437836,
-0.24763791263103485,
-0.6451382040977478,
0.08952648937702179,
-0.15171155333518982,
0.1667330265045166,
1.076385736465454,
-0.14195512235164642,
-0.0074766152538359165,
-0.5707549452781677,
0.2085772454738617,
0.4111786186695099,
0.3383089601993561,
0.21991857886314392,
-0.3422488272190094,
-0.1761815845966339,
0.21732497215270996,
-0.18427331745624542,
-0.6263958811759949,
0.3616499900817871,
0.5001503825187683,
0.7294992804527283,
0.3233746886253357,
-0.05989086255431175,
0.7176004648208618,
-0.8236147165298462,
0.6317220330238342,
0.01818554662168026,
-0.9872589111328125,
0.3307110369205475,
-0.08856769651174545,
0.23397283256053925,
0.32123512029647827,
0.6997323632240295,
-0.5775047540664673,
-0.5166898369789124,
-0.8447719216346741,
-0.4338526725769043,
0.1725030243396759,
0.03330623358488083,
0.2057647854089737,
-0.2037421315908432,
0.5670010447502136,
0.22076964378356934,
-0.015129776671528816,
-0.8895483613014221,
-0.22535768151283264,
-0.03193702921271324,
-0.22824163734912872,
-0.08247888833284378,
-0.006105589214712381,
-0.35896292328834534,
-0.17948783934116364,
0.42279890179634094,
-0.09668246656656265,
0.40996238589286804,
0.31615686416625977,
-0.5039743781089783,
-0.07193924486637115,
0.13939611613750458,
0.09374378621578217,
0.5307143330574036,
0.15516936779022217,
0.43580514192581177,
-0.11377448588609695,
-0.2610766589641571,
0.6754986643791199,
-0.04705873131752014,
-0.33232709765434265,
-0.29576990008354187,
0.6004985570907593,
0.5355405807495117,
0.23443026840686798,
-0.6364783644676208,
0.6267823576927185,
-0.0698675587773323,
0.023376984521746635,
-0.41649487614631653,
0.31960630416870117,
-0.29447460174560547,
0.3383505642414093,
0.08265668898820877,
0.3128816485404968,
0.48173245787620544,
-0.7624137997627258,
0.1859695017337799,
0.7678824067115784,
-0.6534141898155212,
-0.6727251410484314,
0.7097567915916443,
-0.06678333133459091,
-0.13978412747383118,
0.7278671264648438,
-0.4466676115989685,
-0.7371045351028442,
0.9493700265884399,
0.8199963569641113,
1.1642205715179443,
-0.16658662259578705,
0.2548358142375946,
0.5606736540794373,
0.4684578776359558,
-0.3382062315940857,
0.2736258804798126,
0.03835281729698181,
-0.8116625547409058,
-0.23171593248844147,
-0.5417917370796204,
-0.17250296473503113,
-0.10576772689819336,
-0.6633453369140625,
-0.23099039494991302,
-0.6947171092033386,
-0.10004249960184097,
0.007339350879192352,
-0.02267385832965374,
-0.5718432664871216,
0.3181580603122711,
0.008719137869775295,
0.5874699354171753,
-0.9875945448875427,
0.488986074924469,
0.31480321288108826,
-0.6498731374740601,
-0.2668207585811615,
0.2675916850566864,
0.04013458639383316,
-0.6320792436599731,
0.7760266661643982,
0.09942825138568878,
-0.31522855162620544,
-0.05012315511703491,
-0.7333455681800842,
-1.0352050065994263,
0.8309670090675354,
0.28784289956092834,
-0.2314005196094513,
0.21392425894737244,
-0.3818507194519043,
0.7075201272964478,
-0.4926964342594147,
0.21408070623874664,
0.6961800456047058,
0.44529643654823303,
-0.26913219690322876,
-0.6822980046272278,
0.277098149061203,
-0.3396724760532379,
0.22296807169914246,
0.10451065003871918,
-0.6390296220779419,
0.9569124579429626,
-0.6068688035011292,
-0.6895069479942322,
0.43741121888160706,
0.7483910322189331,
0.1163041815161705,
-0.1496354341506958,
0.6481603384017944,
0.5977498292922974,
0.6629032492637634,
-0.3272639214992523,
1.5122730731964111,
-0.13448871672153473,
0.5561763644218445,
0.7378937005996704,
-0.23017890751361847,
0.6206956505775452,
-0.04689088836312294,
-0.47771480679512024,
0.6181725859642029,
0.4258961081504822,
-0.045429129153490067,
0.5183367133140564,
0.5005574822425842,
-0.34827229380607605,
-0.470979243516922,
0.05391518026590347,
-0.22363437712192535,
0.5210671424865723,
0.536368727684021,
0.11187474429607391,
-0.3640829920768738,
-0.0766102746129036,
-0.06415711343288422,
-0.03767376020550728,
-0.06736214458942413,
0.7037039399147034,
0.10582487285137177,
-0.8232960104942322,
0.642704963684082,
0.10028328001499176,
0.20988689363002777,
-0.4616495966911316,
-0.5375926494598389,
-0.44020119309425354,
0.15863986313343048,
-0.11542598903179169,
-0.4006813168525696,
0.1505976766347885,
-0.20535025000572205,
-0.2958163321018219,
0.04905010387301445,
0.34147903323173523,
-0.539806604385376,
-0.5900686979293823,
0.38609153032302856,
0.7365576028823853,
0.1910003125667572,
0.11477930098772049,
-0.7200750112533569,
-0.05850734934210777,
-0.18935497105121613,
-0.12636475265026093,
0.0852033868432045,
0.3309946656227112,
-0.18791113793849945,
0.979220449924469,
0.41666874289512634,
-0.06193321570754051,
0.12565651535987854,
0.007126342039555311,
0.3653833270072937,
-0.6034999489784241,
-0.38436761498451233,
-0.9351803660392761,
0.2648622393608093,
0.08035753667354584,
-0.18639293313026428,
1.0701249837875366,
0.6665529608726501,
0.7234968543052673,
-0.1130940243601799,
1.0398563146591187,
-0.05544936656951904,
0.10634533315896988,
-0.7499305605888367,
0.6576102375984192,
-0.5693386197090149,
0.3364271819591522,
-0.2853107154369354,
-1.1302003860473633,
-0.24929021298885345,
1.06879460811615,
-0.3099510073661804,
0.31444117426872253,
0.7431876063346863,
0.4662494361400604,
-0.2664127051830292,
0.17856965959072113,
0.43461793661117554,
0.4896121323108673,
0.3433527648448944,
0.5792132019996643,
1.4240319728851318,
-0.5219601988792419,
0.12613333761692047,
-0.20264187455177307,
-0.4215063452720642,
0.21545974910259247,
-0.7947192788124084,
-0.43081900477409363,
-0.6180887818336487,
-0.48843589425086975,
-0.5214149951934814,
0.11498718708753586,
0.5972152948379517,
0.5649376511573792,
-0.6019516587257385,
-0.3113950192928314,
-0.18713052570819855,
0.31664398312568665,
-0.43975821137428284,
-0.2296910285949707,
0.3319460451602936,
-0.33675840497016907,
-0.9379258155822754,
0.40885433554649353,
0.4925224781036377,
0.33821773529052734,
-0.704335629940033,
-0.044432636350393295,
0.050266288220882416,
-0.0183898713439703,
0.6812683343887329,
0.3841749131679535,
-0.7861629724502563,
-0.4166709780693054,
-0.15604814887046814,
-0.09982512891292572,
-0.00366273638792336,
0.932036817073822,
-0.7958110570907593,
0.5974270701408386,
0.15953609347343445,
0.2667692005634308,
0.5215052962303162,
-0.006000065244734287,
0.8381285071372986,
-0.4843587279319763,
0.28144028782844543,
0.1944771558046341,
0.45452257990837097,
0.411678284406662,
-0.04739900305867195,
0.6820493340492249,
0.28372064232826233,
-0.2952694892883301,
-0.5311941504478455,
0.5320997834205627,
-0.38967323303222656,
-0.13473844528198242,
0.9651796221733093,
-0.579681932926178,
-0.20763568580150604,
-0.3046170771121979,
0.2384066879749298,
-0.0924224704504013,
0.14456626772880554,
0.7457180023193359,
0.7660059928894043,
-0.15259972214698792,
0.20844557881355286,
-0.9152966141700745,
0.8323512673377991,
0.45360657572746277,
-0.8049145340919495,
0.10871399194002151,
0.7651747465133667,
0.4922797977924347,
0.14576616883277893,
0.6932688355445862,
-0.21655169129371643,
0.2620215117931366,
0.31943657994270325,
-0.045580726116895676,
0.2335219383239746,
-0.598052442073822,
-0.5862969160079956,
-0.1703426092863083,
0.17695939540863037,
0.2600935399532318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03673v1
|
Linguistically Conditioned Semantic Textual Similarity
| 2024-06-06T01:23:45 | 2024-06-06T01:23:45 |
Jingxuan Tu, Keer Xu, Liulu Yue, Bingyang Ye, Kyeongmin Rim, James Pustejovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Semantic textual similarity (STS) is a fundamental NLP task that measures the
semantic similarity between a pair of sentences. In order to reduce the
inherent ambiguity posed from the sentences, a recent work called Conditional
STS (C-STS) has been proposed to measure the sentences' similarity conditioned
on a certain aspect. Despite the popularity of C-STS, we find that the current
C-STS dataset suffers from various issues that could impede proper evaluation
on this task. In this paper, we reannotate the C-STS validation set and observe
an annotator discrepancy on 55% of the instances resulting from the annotation
errors in the original label, ill-defined conditions, and the lack of clarity
in the task definition. After a thorough dataset analysis, we improve the C-STS
task by leveraging the models' capability to understand the conditions under a
QA task setting. With the generated answers, we present an automatic error
identification pipeline that is able to identify annotation errors from the
C-STS data with over 80% F1 score. We also propose a new method that largely
improves the performance over baselines on the C-STS data by training the
models with the answers. Finally we discuss the conditionality annotation based
on the typed-feature structure (TFS) of entity types. We show in examples that
the TFS is able to provide a linguistic foundation for constructing C-STS data
with new conditions.
|
[
0.04441531375050545,
-0.686942994594574,
0.6962026953697205,
0.27069246768951416,
-0.47141459584236145,
0.27072545886039734,
-0.37894800305366516,
-0.31906986236572266,
0.3150792419910431,
0.5904925465583801,
-0.6049432754516602,
-0.9002383351325989,
-0.8005912899971008,
0.432925283908844,
-0.7951650619506836,
0.9427614212036133,
-0.2638174593448639,
-0.09729868918657303,
-0.39684388041496277,
-0.15340864658355713,
-0.4582805037498474,
-0.6522195339202881,
-0.6183929443359375,
0.1825220137834549,
0.28562483191490173,
0.14840997755527496,
0.7673645615577698,
0.42346271872520447,
0.6206678152084351,
0.414880633354187,
-0.0349169485270977,
0.04711320623755455,
-0.40365496277809143,
0.22837932407855988,
-0.22429050505161285,
-0.5400632619857788,
-0.05372817441821098,
-0.20696350932121277,
0.5455785393714905,
0.6314069628715515,
0.12228286266326904,
0.18848492205142975,
0.15419279038906097,
0.4187246859073639,
-0.47971269488334656,
0.2720275819301605,
-0.7888054847717285,
0.10982616990804672,
0.0234749186784029,
-0.2215358167886734,
-0.32119467854499817,
-0.423678457736969,
0.3380381464958191,
-1.0199048519134521,
0.6325364708900452,
0.367654949426651,
1.307917833328247,
0.7581688165664673,
-0.41783106327056885,
-0.22532029449939728,
-0.30194327235221863,
0.6640755534172058,
-0.6179523468017578,
0.5426042675971985,
0.2922987639904022,
0.039041850715875626,
-0.23442025482654572,
-0.5810105800628662,
-0.8241755962371826,
-0.4995168447494507,
-0.5907336473464966,
-0.034722667187452316,
0.16957221925258636,
0.0901862382888794,
0.4040774703025818,
0.21883973479270935,
-0.519798755645752,
0.10655327886343002,
-0.3676215410232544,
-0.2709333002567291,
0.3839151859283447,
0.13549157977104187,
0.46083536744117737,
-0.589352548122406,
-0.6085550785064697,
-0.17838242650032043,
-0.5275902152061462,
0.09092438966035843,
0.1899607628583908,
0.42750847339630127,
-0.31030118465423584,
0.7954428195953369,
-0.2797013223171234,
0.4707227647304535,
0.08148390799760818,
0.145729660987854,
0.5614122152328491,
-0.3638944625854492,
-0.3572482466697693,
-0.12434173375368118,
0.5781209468841553,
0.4019995629787445,
0.44852158427238464,
-0.15213631093502045,
-0.41066446900367737,
0.29186806082725525,
0.35541847348213196,
-0.36515718698501587,
-0.16153976321220398,
0.25284063816070557,
-0.38264378905296326,
-0.022901829332113266,
0.09519006311893463,
-0.28150102496147156,
-0.19889149069786072,
-0.8709104657173157,
0.37128838896751404,
-0.5981075763702393,
-0.2047283798456192,
-0.048393614590168,
-0.2612878680229187,
0.0861496850848198,
0.11767219007015228,
-0.4278244078159332,
0.37821123003959656,
0.8792239427566528,
0.6492795944213867,
-0.4977419078350067,
-0.27155011892318726,
-0.24483858048915863,
-0.01917060650885105,
-0.1964719593524933,
0.8164304494857788,
-0.456662118434906,
-0.36475834250450134,
0.034348662942647934,
0.22104959189891815,
-0.3493728041648865,
-0.2973865866661072,
0.7416967749595642,
-0.3694392144680023,
0.2654057443141937,
-0.40382322669029236,
-0.7577901482582092,
-0.016420502215623856,
0.45697006583213806,
-0.5404610633850098,
1.0946964025497437,
0.37207460403442383,
-1.0600802898406982,
0.7830705046653748,
-0.20797249674797058,
-0.3713451325893402,
0.08089260756969452,
-0.16357484459877014,
-0.42261675000190735,
0.013785428367555141,
-0.07630869001150131,
0.34616294503211975,
-0.09181693941354752,
0.45068463683128357,
-0.44469529390335083,
-0.4614390730857849,
0.2604825794696808,
0.22238290309906006,
0.4840640723705292,
0.08183615654706955,
-0.21914803981781006,
0.12239904701709747,
-0.8237386345863342,
0.1754315048456192,
-0.23111703991889954,
-0.23830807209014893,
-0.8279829621315002,
0.08013156056404114,
0.1839161515235901,
0.17989996075630188,
0.1886410266160965,
-0.5773573517799377,
-0.10267604887485504,
-0.6087081432342529,
0.3301785886287689,
0.5029984712600708,
0.182927668094635,
0.3320506513118744,
-0.24622568488121033,
0.4304485619068146,
0.182377889752388,
0.09592664241790771,
0.23883910477161407,
-0.3044096827507019,
-0.9355535507202148,
-0.35491055250167847,
0.5151755809783936,
0.7437921762466431,
-1.0166045427322388,
0.6129541993141174,
-0.6251516938209534,
-0.27507486939430237,
-0.45808571577072144,
-0.11941453069448471,
0.7192288041114807,
0.6027148365974426,
0.5338773131370544,
-0.07774066925048828,
-0.8044347763061523,
-1.1165094375610352,
-0.366360604763031,
-0.25422659516334534,
-0.054756611585617065,
-0.030708231031894684,
0.5227623581886292,
-0.027225617319345474,
0.9003836512565613,
-0.36452218890190125,
-0.24810203909873962,
-0.017571313306689262,
-0.022870270535349846,
0.09471748024225235,
0.6789656281471252,
0.47911953926086426,
-0.9819191098213196,
-0.26203274726867676,
-0.2891661524772644,
-0.6018614172935486,
-0.20161408185958862,
-0.1645272672176361,
-0.053943779319524765,
0.3361259996891022,
0.5499764680862427,
-0.7496073246002197,
0.5832766890525818,
0.32444339990615845,
-0.5829226970672607,
0.38719022274017334,
-0.035006504505872726,
0.6336340308189392,
-1.0013540983200073,
-0.061507876962423325,
0.15415139496326447,
-0.08631383627653122,
-0.2914113402366638,
0.016169758513569832,
0.007314206101000309,
-0.06966249644756317,
-0.42406585812568665,
0.4872541129589081,
-0.08704716712236404,
-0.07425452023744583,
-0.08328908681869507,
0.40087640285491943,
-0.01650184765458107,
0.5703029036521912,
0.3514021039009094,
0.4414902627468109,
0.4491310119628906,
-0.6884915828704834,
-0.015272854827344418,
0.6470578908920288,
-0.08797883242368698,
0.7399734854698181,
-0.7028712630271912,
-0.1681518405675888,
-0.1566014289855957,
0.4155193865299225,
-0.8410422801971436,
0.05024503916501999,
0.19953548908233643,
-0.5415084362030029,
0.049129143357276917,
-0.2186993956565857,
-0.5534981489181519,
-0.23969443142414093,
-0.3309057354927063,
0.30075255036354065,
0.05473216995596886,
-0.41368207335472107,
0.5935810208320618,
0.05042017251253128,
-0.021918199956417084,
-0.6020583510398865,
-0.7090952396392822,
0.13728240132331848,
-0.20463834702968597,
-0.6046976447105408,
0.5283610820770264,
0.09979240596294403,
-0.22871257364749908,
0.3695443570613861,
-0.10073810070753098,
-0.12998232245445251,
0.19408383965492249,
0.5842349529266357,
0.413882851600647,
-0.25881749391555786,
0.4469405710697174,
0.19791626930236816,
-0.13858644664287567,
-0.05548837408423424,
-0.3197641968727112,
0.1266261786222458,
0.17658650875091553,
-0.34858861565589905,
-0.5681896805763245,
0.3915044367313385,
-0.03584080561995506,
0.0627380758523941,
0.6685607433319092,
0.2727817893028259,
-0.5598796010017395,
-0.2089516520500183,
-0.5387058854103088,
0.013369286432862282,
-0.38951584696769714,
0.16686566174030304,
-0.6039985418319702,
-0.9741144180297852,
0.28869345784187317,
0.4063281714916229,
0.022988704964518547,
0.7419366836547852,
0.2632817327976227,
-0.23713792860507965,
0.6095677018165588,
0.5286691188812256,
0.3010612726211548,
0.1458560973405838,
-0.00502564013004303,
0.33272066712379456,
-0.3956040143966675,
-0.33085915446281433,
-0.9067754745483398,
-0.1262001097202301,
-0.9795585870742798,
-0.3198778033256531,
0.13811565935611725,
-0.10314475744962692,
-0.4392102360725403,
0.6866434216499329,
-0.453408420085907,
0.1958189606666565,
0.43432918190956116,
0.08299090713262558,
0.07371512800455093,
-0.23228807747364044,
-0.3300805687904358,
-0.0770709216594696,
-0.3365146219730377,
-0.6088947057723999,
0.7644252777099609,
0.06376918405294418,
0.1082739382982254,
-0.03142453357577324,
0.7170740365982056,
0.5890699625015259,
0.20421186089515686,
-0.5235522389411926,
0.6142897009849548,
-0.40374112129211426,
-0.34293144941329956,
-0.07628325372934341,
-0.43728646636009216,
-0.6491515636444092,
0.07768715173006058,
-0.6989956498146057,
-0.39330345392227173,
0.16583523154258728,
0.3106059432029724,
-0.2295551300048828,
-0.12457669526338577,
-1.0908706188201904,
0.757475733757019,
-0.010821497067809105,
0.1352512538433075,
-0.09988392889499664,
-0.7746956944465637,
0.16158448159694672,
-0.08642277121543884,
0.10491231828927994,
-0.09510713070631027,
-0.12217183411121368,
0.6444219946861267,
-0.4367898404598236,
0.8002129793167114,
-0.31605252623558044,
0.20739217102527618,
0.1884792298078537,
0.0456230528652668,
0.4137569069862366,
0.03382071107625961,
-0.12482374161481857,
-0.03401532024145126,
0.5372726917266846,
-0.42604005336761475,
-0.6631576418876648,
0.7735462784767151,
-0.5973032712936401,
-0.6267529129981995,
-0.36675119400024414,
0.005442024674266577,
-0.369800329208374,
0.030275696888566017,
0.10846564173698425,
0.30806511640548706,
-0.1608986258506775,
-0.04897245764732361,
0.35517066717147827,
-0.252680242061615,
0.17374764382839203,
0.4934603273868561,
0.19966168701648712,
-0.2513027489185333,
0.4787804186344147,
-0.3002418875694275,
0.17723019421100616,
0.6167310476303101,
-0.16277197003364563,
-0.4442287087440491,
-0.6806029677391052,
-0.23607468605041504,
0.20057402551174164,
-0.9037176370620728,
-0.3026050925254822,
-0.7495964169502258,
-0.12371473759412766,
-0.4214777648448944,
-0.1254386305809021,
-0.003701271489262581,
-0.8075230121612549,
-0.368547260761261,
-0.3625175654888153,
0.4774254560470581,
0.4229886829853058,
0.4479510486125946,
0.20081870257854462,
-0.7818188667297363,
0.30848926305770874,
-0.15508760511875153,
0.3284662365913391,
-0.39203882217407227,
-0.6264310479164124,
-0.10004138946533203,
-0.20302408933639526,
0.0007755953120067716,
-0.6036904454231262,
0.12547308206558228,
0.3016483187675476,
0.4151953160762787,
-0.05554219335317612,
0.0728428065776825,
0.5623344779014587,
-0.4078563153743744,
0.9423612356185913,
-0.017808249220252037,
-1.1938371658325195,
0.6313513517379761,
-0.08516577631235123,
-0.06330040842294693,
0.8832941055297852,
0.4312843978404999,
-0.37706688046455383,
-0.8205603957176208,
-0.8920034170150757,
-0.830146074295044,
0.21634605526924133,
0.48679667711257935,
-0.05376027524471283,
-0.36664605140686035,
0.7602879405021667,
0.07110121846199036,
0.08470065891742706,
-0.7697769403457642,
-0.12166456878185272,
-0.40796878933906555,
-0.5537258982658386,
-0.08978089690208435,
-0.1514589637517929,
0.23976358771324158,
0.09640933573246002,
0.7486592531204224,
-0.09287235885858536,
-0.05476651340723038,
0.4849376976490021,
-0.42365598678588867,
0.18376368284225464,
0.376047819852829,
0.4370434880256653,
0.6168200373649597,
-0.02895287796854973,
0.22587351500988007,
0.4047347605228424,
-0.24811521172523499,
-0.019222691655158997,
0.23600466549396515,
-0.24437429010868073,
0.0550566203892231,
0.5748051404953003,
0.5765767097473145,
0.45098885893821716,
-0.7485421299934387,
0.6105061173439026,
-0.10018565505743027,
-0.060481101274490356,
-0.48811236023902893,
0.04799168184399605,
-0.07934817671775818,
0.11707871407270432,
0.09789524227380753,
0.07143379747867584,
0.2983464300632477,
-0.13843612372875214,
0.36263933777809143,
0.19891971349716187,
-0.5355252027511597,
-0.23863600194454193,
0.3875246047973633,
0.2218811810016632,
-0.27128997445106506,
0.5114737749099731,
-0.4188409745693207,
-0.8666313290596008,
0.6155090928077698,
0.24018283188343048,
0.6612556576728821,
0.019106142222881317,
0.12847067415714264,
0.5976876020431519,
0.27321887016296387,
0.016837438568472862,
0.26315274834632874,
-0.0012207884574308991,
-0.6433297991752625,
-0.5088424682617188,
-0.6586470603942871,
-0.2597508728504181,
-0.4863644242286682,
-0.5863825082778931,
0.6859466433525085,
-0.35613080859184265,
-0.11930321156978607,
-0.14297306537628174,
-0.09782716631889343,
-0.8176782727241516,
0.8718489408493042,
-0.01700236089527607,
0.7685882449150085,
-0.9886206984519958,
0.6814674139022827,
0.5521295070648193,
-0.37087151408195496,
-0.8609611988067627,
-0.25851279497146606,
-0.021676670759916306,
-0.6125841736793518,
0.8995469212532043,
0.049194224178791046,
-0.029495541006326675,
-0.4175119698047638,
-0.2028890997171402,
-0.6890380382537842,
0.9610531330108643,
0.07723608613014221,
-0.7543495297431946,
0.03513903543353081,
0.2350747138261795,
0.9093853831291199,
-0.4984816312789917,
0.14277879893779755,
0.6978893280029297,
0.44097840785980225,
-0.06779260188341141,
-0.9517294764518738,
0.42175453901290894,
-0.3077262043952942,
0.1220088005065918,
0.3421507179737091,
-0.18804115056991577,
0.4524824321269989,
-0.21574917435646057,
-0.32097145915031433,
0.24279636144638062,
0.7124829292297363,
0.319888174533844,
0.413573294878006,
1.0113086700439453,
0.8209651708602905,
0.6764464378356934,
-0.2510066628456116,
0.9321904182434082,
-0.09821226447820663,
0.44905608892440796,
1.0498062372207642,
-0.2491571456193924,
0.9714578986167908,
0.36720964312553406,
0.03636942058801651,
0.6134304404258728,
0.7956336736679077,
-0.1992899775505066,
0.28573983907699585,
0.589557945728302,
0.05240589752793312,
-0.2767567038536072,
-0.07678496092557907,
-0.2090204507112503,
0.38460174202919006,
0.3957569897174835,
-0.45647215843200684,
0.17802304029464722,
-0.0585557296872139,
-0.04726653918623924,
0.47859206795692444,
-0.049849733710289,
0.7278113961219788,
0.010641437955200672,
-0.6801044940948486,
0.4653376638889313,
-0.10427479445934296,
0.7157703638076782,
-0.35603442788124084,
-0.0125199556350708,
-0.0769815444946289,
-0.15230649709701538,
-0.342612087726593,
-0.6857291460037231,
0.6094014048576355,
0.09285039454698563,
-0.30622485280036926,
-0.10601120442152023,
0.49575865268707275,
-0.29307928681373596,
-0.5735167264938354,
0.3193918466567993,
0.25498437881469727,
0.02603387087583542,
0.0036831973120570183,
-0.736007809638977,
0.08051047474145889,
-0.013526523485779762,
0.14035238325595856,
-0.11562348902225494,
0.5032392740249634,
-0.23803302645683289,
0.6859447360038757,
0.367725133895874,
0.09873462468385696,
-0.030308902263641357,
0.29914557933807373,
0.7403517365455627,
-0.8777655363082886,
-0.521066427230835,
-0.4589022994041443,
0.36889174580574036,
-0.2680458724498749,
-0.5469034314155579,
0.4418729245662689,
0.5793815851211548,
0.750537633895874,
0.010532835498452187,
0.5994150638580322,
-0.18460193276405334,
1.041731357574463,
-0.9110715985298157,
0.4291447699069977,
-0.38400211930274963,
0.5637490749359131,
-0.2245633900165558,
-0.8289919495582581,
-0.3840670585632324,
0.10295254737138748,
-0.3045988380908966,
-0.0338343046605587,
1.2391152381896973,
0.7916359305381775,
-0.0437626875936985,
0.20607347786426544,
0.0036502813454717398,
0.22983835637569427,
0.10112173110246658,
0.4785093665122986,
0.91502445936203,
-0.49322858452796936,
0.5004978775978088,
-0.2087155282497406,
0.0028974702581763268,
0.23391084372997284,
-0.9374582171440125,
-0.7780942916870117,
-1.1230489015579224,
-0.7990458607673645,
-0.536551296710968,
0.3416922092437744,
1.0948518514633179,
0.546955943107605,
-1.0066282749176025,
0.3758015036582947,
0.08670908212661743,
0.3066510260105133,
0.03700757399201393,
-0.23796509206295013,
0.7123603224754333,
-0.4614078402519226,
-0.5272549986839294,
0.054905377328395844,
0.03473496437072754,
0.016960900276899338,
0.15939737856388092,
0.3143887221813202,
-0.028033485636115074,
-0.10193690657615662,
0.4847583472728729,
-0.04834943637251854,
-0.8631542325019836,
-0.8447828888893127,
-0.19286322593688965,
-0.09752822667360306,
-0.061650607734918594,
0.9597838521003723,
-0.9429947733879089,
-0.06516813486814499,
0.4107983708381653,
0.6729292869567871,
0.2842310667037964,
0.07552285492420197,
0.39501380920410156,
-0.8178598284721375,
0.13912923634052277,
0.2902153730392456,
0.5275532603263855,
0.6764476895332336,
-0.5543370246887207,
0.384733647108078,
0.2142910659313202,
-0.33545076847076416,
-0.5184616446495056,
0.02459476701915264,
-1.5224648714065552,
-0.129036083817482,
1.2721718549728394,
-0.37883418798446655,
-0.16465307772159576,
-0.3543485701084137,
0.0014866020064800978,
0.20877328515052795,
-0.22512540221214294,
0.9260298013687134,
0.5640683174133301,
0.384166419506073,
0.10899577289819717,
-0.2204286754131317,
0.6890206336975098,
0.5065121054649353,
-0.8825395703315735,
-0.32270076870918274,
0.48669201135635376,
0.6043559312820435,
0.044249072670936584,
0.2543480396270752,
0.13605988025665283,
0.25203627347946167,
-0.26480966806411743,
-0.03431718423962593,
0.31052452325820923,
0.09061939269304276,
0.041253942996263504,
0.1046634241938591,
0.006248449441045523,
-0.22747419774532318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03666v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03666v1
|
What Makes Language Models Good-enough?
| 2024-06-06T00:51:28 | 2024-06-06T00:51:28 |
Daiki Asami, Saku Sugawara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Psycholinguistic research suggests that humans may build a representation of
linguistic input that is 'good-enough' for the task at hand. This study
examines what architectural features make language models learn human-like
good-enough language processing. We focus on the number of layers and
self-attention heads in Transformers. We create a good-enough language
processing (GELP) evaluation dataset (7,680 examples), which is designed to
test the effects of two plausibility types, eight construction types, and three
degrees of memory cost on language processing. To annotate GELP, we first
conduct a crowdsourcing experiment whose design follows prior psycholinguistic
studies. Our model evaluation against the annotated GELP then reveals that the
full model as well as models with fewer layers and/or self-attention heads
exhibit a good-enough performance. This result suggests that models with
shallower depth and fewer heads can learn good-enough language processing.
|
[
-0.612419843673706,
-0.6252797245979309,
0.5794490575790405,
0.45537233352661133,
0.0008416908676736057,
-0.2439110428094864,
-0.3151206076145172,
-0.7186851501464844,
-0.07900123298168182,
0.5188766717910767,
-0.03287651389837265,
-0.02194460853934288,
-0.467562198638916,
0.1051253154873848,
-0.6862682104110718,
1.0810015201568604,
0.3385498523712158,
-0.06145504117012024,
-0.2318911999464035,
-0.18034668266773224,
-0.5877731442451477,
-0.4182228744029999,
-0.47511574625968933,
-0.3922456204891205,
0.3276267349720001,
0.3865273892879486,
0.9947600364685059,
0.9717376828193665,
0.3365193009376526,
0.2234426885843277,
0.11836838722229004,
-0.07006797194480896,
-0.46294331550598145,
0.030305378139019012,
-0.34805163741111755,
-0.393301397562027,
-0.6745598912239075,
0.36028948426246643,
0.7363479733467102,
0.896458089351654,
-0.39129096269607544,
0.2849716246128082,
0.2752530872821808,
0.7376156449317932,
-0.5178338885307312,
0.13914097845554352,
-0.503886878490448,
-0.03685956820845604,
-0.20565782487392426,
0.15907013416290283,
-0.6444116830825806,
-0.098965585231781,
0.009655982255935669,
-0.4002995789051056,
0.47670990228652954,
0.09271866083145142,
0.784405529499054,
0.3365999460220337,
-0.1616082787513733,
-0.10563921928405762,
-0.8119722604751587,
0.513793408870697,
-0.7643026113510132,
0.5986508727073669,
1.093432068824768,
0.23839743435382843,
0.029491527006030083,
-0.6053400039672852,
-0.42829954624176025,
-0.26817092299461365,
-0.3846580386161804,
-0.01505589485168457,
-0.1903185397386551,
0.19955269992351532,
0.31161966919898987,
0.22881938517093658,
-0.7235142588615417,
0.14130361378192902,
-0.815831184387207,
-0.2217077910900116,
0.4597139358520508,
-0.14197330176830292,
0.39648425579071045,
-0.1431729793548584,
-0.049906887114048004,
-0.03045002929866314,
-0.5492769479751587,
0.03755621984601021,
0.18532104790210724,
0.34417665004730225,
-0.19334806501865387,
0.5153526663780212,
0.11031028628349304,
0.7090499997138977,
0.010055117309093475,
0.21846133470535278,
0.027403729036450386,
0.00005208806396694854,
-0.23649629950523376,
-0.2806020677089691,
0.6266016364097595,
0.001399607746861875,
0.897568941116333,
-0.5522322058677673,
-0.317067950963974,
0.15344856679439545,
0.7742516398429871,
-0.4658430218696594,
-0.33384135365486145,
0.4941149055957794,
-0.45253786444664,
0.08016804605722427,
-0.067957304418087,
-0.07756761461496353,
0.04621756821870804,
-0.2269875854253769,
0.30412185192108154,
-0.4899353086948395,
-0.5391165614128113,
0.4861719012260437,
-0.19740842282772064,
0.2769605219364166,
-0.04260801896452904,
-1.1687402725219727,
0.5629651546478271,
0.6550894379615784,
0.7432416677474976,
-0.2684074342250824,
-0.7354273200035095,
-0.44427555799484253,
0.032436929643154144,
-0.641671359539032,
1.1311521530151367,
-0.4851173460483551,
-0.21186646819114685,
-0.2124733328819275,
-0.13537704944610596,
-0.20267462730407715,
-0.7981045842170715,
0.6554871797561646,
-0.4765430688858032,
0.3389420211315155,
-0.35819751024246216,
-0.6130326986312866,
-0.022280214354395866,
0.08350326865911484,
-0.8070429563522339,
0.6512779593467712,
0.22689218819141388,
-0.5232963562011719,
0.37039992213249207,
-0.5401366353034973,
-0.691993236541748,
0.2088327407836914,
-0.06044166535139084,
-0.2387755960226059,
0.4131467640399933,
-0.1408991515636444,
0.5824803113937378,
-0.021166449412703514,
0.34887146949768066,
-0.25583615899086,
-0.31954196095466614,
0.48440924286842346,
-0.2720964848995209,
0.6345980167388916,
0.3470510244369507,
-0.2617286741733551,
-0.16195937991142273,
-0.7830673456192017,
0.05828516557812691,
0.10727638751268387,
-0.44043901562690735,
0.10656460374593735,
0.22342412173748016,
0.1583820879459381,
0.34568512439727783,
0.006514891982078552,
-0.30257242918014526,
-0.1556731015443802,
-0.5621547698974609,
0.4653928577899933,
0.5293512344360352,
-0.4005242586135864,
0.5689736008644104,
-0.3448203206062317,
0.5218472480773926,
-0.2539454400539398,
-0.12855984270572662,
0.042281653732061386,
-0.3629828095436096,
-0.896152675151825,
-0.1772906482219696,
0.12902186810970306,
0.30417943000793457,
-0.3396405875682831,
0.2508510947227478,
0.1031024307012558,
-0.3225805461406708,
-0.526191234588623,
0.2455376535654068,
0.5065056681632996,
0.4570344388484955,
0.25493884086608887,
-0.44561803340911865,
-0.541459858417511,
-1.3521696329116821,
-0.014745974913239479,
-0.22757120430469513,
-0.21440938115119934,
0.0889689028263092,
0.2622149884700775,
0.12995575368404388,
0.9469051361083984,
-0.21148300170898438,
-0.11973977088928223,
-0.4853336215019226,
0.1316462606191635,
0.12182274460792542,
0.35961300134658813,
0.771369457244873,
-0.4744321405887604,
-0.350978285074234,
-0.2282853126525879,
-0.8033121228218079,
-0.13638806343078613,
0.05613839626312256,
-0.0029647445771843195,
-0.06745556741952896,
0.17516978085041046,
-1.0597585439682007,
0.006552171893417835,
0.3812966048717499,
-0.3612745404243469,
0.3859545886516571,
-0.4917181134223938,
-0.17281728982925415,
-0.7885711193084717,
0.2809293866157532,
0.11355958133935928,
-0.573276698589325,
-0.8972601890563965,
0.31910526752471924,
0.18756414949893951,
-0.3292352557182312,
-0.38513943552970886,
0.7641281485557556,
-0.4580615162849426,
-0.33759772777557373,
-0.656384289264679,
0.19024857878684998,
0.04222102463245392,
0.4686034917831421,
0.2754017412662506,
0.6163248419761658,
0.6694664359092712,
-0.6975898742675781,
-0.12040258944034576,
0.044280897825956345,
-0.4448395073413849,
0.43253186345100403,
-0.786604642868042,
0.4946845769882202,
-0.20119594037532806,
0.06626233458518982,
-0.9504831433296204,
-0.5607574582099915,
-0.0029580818954855204,
-0.2855672240257263,
0.2262614220380783,
0.2120327204465866,
-0.38409119844436646,
-0.32212427258491516,
0.12710528075695038,
0.4262925982475281,
0.4723127484321594,
-0.2325592041015625,
0.574725329875946,
0.5697515606880188,
-0.15990470349788666,
-0.23140767216682434,
-0.589087188243866,
0.210884690284729,
-0.058502066880464554,
-0.37157198786735535,
0.08543872088193893,
-0.046097900718450546,
-0.1685405820608139,
-0.09399319440126419,
0.11621592193841934,
-0.40184515714645386,
0.2327525019645691,
0.0460110642015934,
0.06301635503768921,
-0.3167631924152374,
0.19995318353176117,
-0.5337788462638855,
-0.37152770161628723,
0.24661852419376373,
0.007012252230197191,
0.6130415797233582,
-0.3019956648349762,
-0.26474931836128235,
-0.35950395464897156,
0.22531923651695251,
0.7140063047409058,
-0.3221588432788849,
0.4668314754962921,
0.502251923084259,
-0.5883030295372009,
-0.4435611963272095,
-0.660931408405304,
-0.2563076317310333,
-0.4358576834201813,
0.5401049256324768,
-0.33415430784225464,
-0.790527880191803,
0.5089889168739319,
0.7045673727989197,
0.00651213014498353,
0.5010867714881897,
0.4204891622066498,
-0.2791213393211365,
0.9325039982795715,
0.5535080432891846,
-0.23123839497566223,
0.012911961413919926,
-0.05601317062973976,
0.253390908241272,
-0.5227225422859192,
0.16740909218788147,
-0.5682274699211121,
-0.3454066216945648,
-0.4805537164211273,
-0.36572176218032837,
0.025165509432554245,
-0.02994755282998085,
-0.06924614310264587,
0.5933924913406372,
-0.4591256380081177,
0.6494971513748169,
0.41146183013916016,
-0.05274854600429535,
0.011648847721517086,
-0.17259912192821503,
0.3485850393772125,
0.0681251809000969,
-0.557084858417511,
-0.6649136543273926,
0.7455624938011169,
0.6207682490348816,
0.6552037596702576,
-0.08976360410451889,
0.14097049832344055,
0.337593674659729,
0.12352297455072403,
-0.365182489156723,
0.54746013879776,
-0.03660009056329727,
-0.9778744578361511,
-0.44019636511802673,
-0.15257202088832855,
-0.9428232908248901,
-0.004291905555874109,
0.038166407495737076,
-0.6985860466957092,
0.21089594066143036,
0.4503202736377716,
-0.40910273790359497,
0.04593644663691521,
-0.8159447908401489,
0.7753109931945801,
-0.3523853123188019,
-0.17997193336486816,
-0.6465173363685608,
-0.5410663485527039,
0.16710807383060455,
0.00228237290866673,
0.12442461401224136,
-0.22955988347530365,
0.19316895306110382,
0.4777708053588867,
0.2581639289855957,
0.6620306968688965,
-0.16841010749340057,
-0.08756095916032791,
0.5247936248779297,
0.5105820298194885,
0.2747586965560913,
-0.24893465638160706,
-0.08906471729278564,
0.20335760712623596,
-0.13833953440189362,
-0.632606029510498,
-0.721953809261322,
0.02037835493683815,
-0.6573429107666016,
-0.6321406960487366,
-0.09961409121751785,
-0.5525067448616028,
-0.3091817796230316,
0.08454559743404388,
0.13353502750396729,
0.2982180416584015,
-0.35354506969451904,
0.391347736120224,
0.5209692120552063,
-0.08694300055503845,
0.22984199225902557,
0.47847267985343933,
-0.45762568712234497,
0.06549053639173508,
1.1729719638824463,
0.26673004031181335,
0.49737846851348877,
0.16335344314575195,
0.34974953532218933,
-0.08726910501718521,
-0.5534987449645996,
-0.45617109537124634,
0.1314040720462799,
-0.6233737468719482,
0.1303478181362152,
-0.5978111624717712,
-0.6176058650016785,
-0.37858402729034424,
-0.032842572778463364,
-0.6749935150146484,
-0.5038521885871887,
-0.025817181915044785,
-0.2985302805900574,
-0.27755966782569885,
1.0663186311721802,
-0.28940874338150024,
0.0280663650482893,
-0.4706920385360718,
0.5447039604187012,
0.586639940738678,
0.5487170219421387,
0.3701174855232239,
-0.6298605799674988,
-0.5379425883293152,
0.09601321071386337,
-0.3047720491886139,
-0.5450748205184937,
0.13927796483039856,
0.47957998514175415,
0.8081710338592529,
0.4245535135269165,
-0.28078293800354004,
0.18513771891593933,
-0.628091037273407,
0.6156008243560791,
-0.17408204078674316,
-0.7041246294975281,
0.34537070989608765,
-0.4834666848182678,
0.39211732149124146,
0.35025423765182495,
0.28930360078811646,
-0.52818763256073,
-0.7051252126693726,
-0.5761976838111877,
-0.4740654230117798,
0.684181272983551,
0.5022381544113159,
0.3613387644290924,
-0.4410482943058014,
0.39787814021110535,
0.29334908723831177,
0.011204130947589874,
-1.0485044717788696,
-0.005457280203700066,
-0.4244305193424225,
-0.026364393532276154,
-0.06932240724563599,
-0.4154530465602875,
0.11833774298429489,
-0.01939188502728939,
0.44818997383117676,
0.06130678206682205,
0.3498374819755554,
-0.18492546677589417,
-0.22510327398777008,
-0.07571016997098923,
0.506691038608551,
0.7079214453697205,
0.8101211786270142,
-0.3536403775215149,
0.2840352952480316,
0.1633937507867813,
-0.3126632273197174,
0.14314764738082886,
-0.31367674469947815,
0.07833737879991531,
-0.3264598250389099,
0.6333401799201965,
0.8069721460342407,
0.1502477079629898,
-0.589219868183136,
0.38721030950546265,
0.06665883958339691,
-0.09757727384567261,
0.08098557591438293,
0.5911269187927246,
0.4090934991836548,
0.1390150636434555,
0.32957351207733154,
-0.052053991705179214,
0.21460147202014923,
-0.6414975523948669,
0.2916046977043152,
0.3991703391075134,
-0.2191503793001175,
-0.6873776316642761,
0.6156499981880188,
0.11255765706300735,
-0.8290882110595703,
0.6524657607078552,
-0.2381618171930313,
-0.31346026062965393,
0.4593545198440552,
0.9536763429641724,
0.9720325469970703,
-0.15316727757453918,
0.3968139588832855,
0.32604682445526123,
0.24797303974628448,
-0.34471431374549866,
0.08692057430744171,
-0.31948062777519226,
-1.0030577182769775,
-0.44969433546066284,
-0.706384003162384,
-0.5156496167182922,
0.1321423202753067,
-0.6811898350715637,
0.06119229272007942,
-0.39360421895980835,
-0.1314421147108078,
-0.13955502212047577,
-0.6482680439949036,
-0.9097065925598145,
0.4799858331680298,
0.2936086654663086,
0.7655068039894104,
-0.915917158126831,
0.728916347026825,
0.3257733881473541,
-0.32733216881752014,
-0.7941608428955078,
-0.2337018996477127,
-0.4994090795516968,
-1.0633902549743652,
0.5234973430633545,
0.24219729006290436,
-0.08597690612077713,
-0.033289577811956406,
-0.4945469796657562,
-0.9225612282752991,
0.3524165451526642,
0.8791371583938599,
-0.4196036458015442,
-0.3365023732185364,
0.4060538411140442,
0.7697392702102661,
-0.24011659622192383,
0.08960995823144913,
0.59593266248703,
0.3641056716442108,
-0.39250949025154114,
-1.0497530698776245,
-0.17624279856681824,
-0.29648882150650024,
-0.2879137694835663,
-0.09458822011947632,
-0.6406379342079163,
0.6375624537467957,
-0.25237831473350525,
-0.5287173390388489,
-0.026865899562835693,
0.6336984038352966,
0.23139405250549316,
-0.028929706662893295,
0.628377377986908,
0.6241347789764404,
0.5700162053108215,
0.10233116894960403,
1.2480220794677734,
-0.39391130208969116,
0.20889414846897125,
1.3293273448944092,
-0.06691627204418182,
0.9329985976219177,
0.17155888676643372,
-0.267133504152298,
0.39824628829956055,
0.5857540965080261,
0.18574103713035583,
0.5061752796173096,
0.033421967178583145,
0.39719074964523315,
-0.5917475819587708,
-0.01739327237010002,
-0.13486255705356598,
0.852103054523468,
0.012151134200394154,
-0.28556811809539795,
-0.069846011698246,
0.1093711107969284,
-0.4034453332424164,
0.1101551204919815,
0.03895097225904465,
0.5470662713050842,
0.3234598636627197,
-0.8107501268386841,
0.3412168622016907,
-0.19966082274913788,
0.23317652940750122,
-0.42862167954444885,
0.1343759149312973,
-0.12743933498859406,
-0.16941608488559723,
-0.12368083745241165,
-0.8966052532196045,
0.27440306544303894,
-0.09633969515562057,
-0.36253854632377625,
-0.3263644278049469,
0.6955206990242004,
-0.334318071603775,
-0.562611997127533,
0.3444981575012207,
0.7463448643684387,
0.4738531708717346,
0.04796254262328148,
-0.31721827387809753,
-0.23863555490970612,
-0.3232383131980896,
-0.3971457779407501,
0.3396066129207611,
0.272869348526001,
0.17496618628501892,
0.7864338159561157,
0.28058922290802,
0.5079715847969055,
-0.20676077902317047,
0.4652099013328552,
0.33828890323638916,
-0.6663984060287476,
-0.37776046991348267,
-0.9935563206672668,
0.6519909501075745,
0.13616111874580383,
-0.4543645977973938,
0.49881142377853394,
0.6188737154006958,
0.7678660154342651,
0.06576918065547943,
0.47122031450271606,
0.0899844691157341,
0.4837820529937744,
-0.430279403924942,
0.7928245067596436,
-0.2353798896074295,
-0.0638321042060852,
-0.12312667816877365,
-1.13445246219635,
-0.20452789962291718,
0.993164598941803,
-0.2274831384420395,
0.3123096227645874,
0.5692175030708313,
0.6235552430152893,
-0.3407420217990875,
-0.07432972639799118,
0.7212082147598267,
0.3046659231185913,
0.27975526452064514,
0.34517550468444824,
0.8170274496078491,
-0.08506006747484207,
0.15760403871536255,
-0.13435347378253937,
0.1739274561405182,
0.1921379417181015,
-0.7659667134284973,
-0.9506076574325562,
-0.6603568196296692,
-0.041197750717401505,
-0.2691090404987335,
0.019549595192074776,
0.7600002288818359,
0.9399074912071228,
-0.6827804446220398,
-0.5719540119171143,
0.04576561972498894,
-0.0221874862909317,
-0.06825799494981766,
-0.17569805681705475,
0.39031264185905457,
-0.6083694100379944,
-0.4011602997779846,
0.42629536986351013,
0.517878532409668,
-0.0009015967370942235,
-0.5936446785926819,
-0.2244979292154312,
0.13371285796165466,
0.006539970636367798,
0.5026494264602661,
0.3559625744819641,
-0.6857683658599854,
-0.6755374670028687,
0.13797664642333984,
-0.17646214365959167,
0.3210081458091736,
0.8531233668327332,
-0.5797331929206848,
0.4977414011955261,
0.2882785499095917,
0.6661233901977539,
0.2658079266548157,
-0.06693335622549057,
0.913266658782959,
-0.6251286268234253,
0.12470932304859161,
0.21953551471233368,
0.5563934445381165,
0.527649462223053,
-0.20280948281288147,
0.5634068250656128,
-0.09182033687829971,
-0.8365043997764587,
-0.7451943159103394,
0.0472375713288784,
-0.5953966975212097,
-0.3096865713596344,
1.0869474411010742,
0.17571528255939484,
-0.16008341312408447,
-0.19559383392333984,
-0.08443614095449448,
0.09997975081205368,
0.0101622324436903,
1.245076298713684,
1.0845329761505127,
-0.3118760883808136,
-0.3116054832935333,
-0.5992751121520996,
0.34277480840682983,
0.4612920880317688,
-0.7216607332229614,
0.2651945948600769,
0.23522628843784332,
0.3360276520252228,
0.2642761468887329,
0.7682831287384033,
0.40719425678253174,
0.6380946636199951,
-0.12233471870422363,
0.016560323536396027,
0.10210833698511124,
-0.5690857172012329,
0.04010697454214096,
0.28864023089408875,
0.5166928768157959,
0.10325435549020767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04379v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04379v1
|
VHDL-Eval: A Framework for Evaluating Large Language Models in VHDL Code Generation
| 2024-06-06T00:06:50 | 2024-06-06T00:06:50 |
Prashanth Vijayaraghavan, Luyao Shi, Stefano Ambrogio, Charles Mackin, Apoorva Nitsure, David Beymer, Ehsan Degan
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the unprecedented advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs), their
application domains have expanded to include code generation tasks across
various programming languages. While significant progress has been made in
enhancing LLMs for popular programming languages, there exists a notable gap in
comprehensive evaluation frameworks tailored for Hardware Description Languages
(HDLs), particularly VHDL. This paper addresses this gap by introducing a
comprehensive evaluation framework designed specifically for assessing LLM
performance in VHDL code generation task. We construct a dataset for evaluating
LLMs on VHDL code generation task. This dataset is constructed by translating a
collection of Verilog evaluation problems to VHDL and aggregating publicly
available VHDL problems, resulting in a total of 202 problems. To assess the
functional correctness of the generated VHDL code, we utilize a curated set of
self-verifying testbenches specifically designed for those aggregated VHDL
problem set. We conduct an initial evaluation of different LLMs and their
variants, including zero-shot code generation, in-context learning (ICL), and
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods. Our findings underscore the
considerable challenges faced by existing LLMs in VHDL code generation,
revealing significant scope for improvement. This study emphasizes the
necessity of supervised fine-tuning code generation models specifically for
VHDL, offering potential benefits to VHDL designers seeking efficient code
generation solutions.
|
[
-0.44808146357536316,
-1.1015431880950928,
0.6070912480354309,
0.27992820739746094,
-0.24542447924613953,
0.12678825855255127,
-0.2371082752943039,
-0.18506500124931335,
-0.34972888231277466,
0.6261449456214905,
-0.46888357400894165,
-0.4627368748188019,
-0.19676488637924194,
0.11096221953630447,
-0.44059085845947266,
1.0466996431350708,
-0.34519511461257935,
-0.09193249046802521,
-0.5668826103210449,
0.09060747921466827,
-0.5798212885856628,
-0.4998376667499542,
-0.0949799194931984,
-0.1309342384338379,
-0.07480179518461227,
0.12381561845541,
0.0710315853357315,
0.8673908710479736,
0.7272511720657349,
0.2945786118507385,
0.10421369224786758,
0.3033944368362427,
-0.5318304300308228,
0.23793040215969086,
-0.0620611272752285,
-0.0754312053322792,
-0.5193617939949036,
-0.5173782706260681,
0.6495174765586853,
0.5482677221298218,
-0.11449482291936874,
0.7339829206466675,
-0.09391774982213974,
0.4635078012943268,
-0.6634791493415833,
0.07332664728164673,
-0.6140288710594177,
0.18829511106014252,
-0.37249839305877686,
-0.39387747645378113,
-0.3673723042011261,
-0.22542840242385864,
-0.27730685472488403,
0.021459253504872322,
0.1170022115111351,
0.09753700345754623,
0.5722874402999878,
0.4173641502857208,
-0.4524777829647064,
0.019866079092025757,
-0.8088244199752808,
0.8864061832427979,
-0.6405194401741028,
0.47207608819007874,
0.03430388122797012,
0.3549465835094452,
-0.1191888377070427,
-0.6662103533744812,
-0.40136921405792236,
-0.3724225163459778,
0.18810157477855682,
-0.06344861537218094,
-0.19138838350772858,
0.1093292236328125,
0.4740607440471649,
0.6695279479026794,
-0.7106794714927673,
0.22958403825759888,
-0.4888184368610382,
-0.16240768134593964,
0.7445203065872192,
0.4519467055797577,
0.04580284282565117,
-0.1476716548204422,
-0.39436158537864685,
0.037034761160612106,
-1.0644285678863525,
-0.23587366938591003,
0.4548778235912323,
0.2008233666419983,
-0.07202541083097458,
0.5673217177391052,
-0.2717314064502716,
0.9613741040229797,
-0.09725530445575714,
0.15146033465862274,
0.3066301643848419,
-0.5096244215965271,
-0.3832288682460785,
-0.0667884573340416,
0.3669832944869995,
0.2859525680541992,
-0.026952337473630905,
0.18198560178279877,
-0.6512774229049683,
0.15135009586811066,
0.5399269461631775,
-1.0226789712905884,
0.036439139395952225,
0.404274046421051,
-0.4447539150714874,
-0.5136173367500305,
-0.20292113721370697,
-0.6476117968559265,
-0.2507418692111969,
-0.31679192185401917,
0.2517511546611786,
-0.0029419665224850178,
-0.10388961434364319,
0.05289791524410248,
0.1665370613336563,
0.4459156394004822,
0.033967241644859314,
-0.552110493183136,
0.28756025433540344,
0.8196033835411072,
0.4255927801132202,
-0.37890511751174927,
-0.10488886386156082,
-1.007069706916809,
-0.08629634231328964,
-0.36616185307502747,
0.5964587330818176,
-0.25138619542121887,
-0.4488428831100464,
0.3310195505619049,
-0.19684751331806183,
0.23704594373703003,
-0.7701453566551208,
0.3789128363132477,
-0.5097036361694336,
-0.11331278830766678,
0.03801102936267853,
-0.7090883255004883,
0.2204112410545349,
0.33551445603370667,
-0.4701094329357147,
0.9413108825683594,
0.3680235743522644,
-0.5266247391700745,
0.23194658756256104,
-0.4890841245651245,
-0.5959416031837463,
0.44686052203178406,
-0.4830957055091858,
-0.5082099437713623,
0.479149729013443,
-0.0014516903320327401,
0.45141103863716125,
-0.47228971123695374,
0.33787423372268677,
-0.44545742869377136,
-0.4917891025543213,
0.27409932017326355,
-0.5847040414810181,
0.6219577193260193,
0.31828269362449646,
-0.3463636040687561,
0.42502132058143616,
-0.7953940033912659,
0.39936044812202454,
-0.10926947742700577,
-0.5101650953292847,
0.11468225717544556,
-0.03285389766097069,
0.23089562356472015,
0.020619569346308708,
0.6009843349456787,
-0.46089833974838257,
0.04592658951878548,
-0.3122863173484802,
0.2541259527206421,
0.9180681109428406,
0.07371646165847778,
-0.29666826128959656,
-0.09825816005468369,
0.7103890776634216,
-0.20715473592281342,
0.19983108341693878,
-0.4453519284725189,
-0.18029122054576874,
-0.5178008079528809,
-0.0509011447429657,
0.16362546384334564,
0.3722357749938965,
-0.7134101986885071,
0.4951673448085785,
-0.05131854861974716,
-0.24092641472816467,
-0.3043777644634247,
0.43327462673187256,
0.8243346810340881,
0.4865914583206177,
0.2134922444820404,
-0.2033233344554901,
-0.48556724190711975,
-1.0327954292297363,
0.09719429165124893,
-0.22334696352481842,
-0.014372526668012142,
0.48770755529403687,
0.41704127192497253,
-0.3703843355178833,
0.3981330692768097,
-0.4516541063785553,
0.02329895831644535,
-0.361224502325058,
-0.22980192303657532,
0.28846243023872375,
0.3970552086830139,
0.4217994511127472,
-0.41822361946105957,
-0.36582329869270325,
0.3599151074886322,
-0.5967261791229248,
-0.30866435170173645,
0.046756818890571594,
-0.014059371314942837,
0.5444165468215942,
0.5080612301826477,
-0.26824837923049927,
0.23604479432106018,
0.6272991299629211,
-0.13463592529296875,
0.8594984412193298,
-0.5260640382766724,
0.1214737594127655,
-0.6866999268531799,
0.18286846578121185,
0.09656286984682083,
-0.14029665291309357,
-0.3967578709125519,
0.5170239210128784,
0.12265102565288544,
0.041240010410547256,
-0.49002206325531006,
0.5286406874656677,
-0.12004907429218292,
-0.3189251720905304,
-0.25571683049201965,
-0.05525786429643631,
-0.19155211746692657,
0.3439810872077942,
-0.12299803644418716,
0.8057792782783508,
0.6488456130027771,
-0.5479085445404053,
0.4610097110271454,
-0.1461241990327835,
-0.43813633918762207,
0.7841033339500427,
-0.8367725610733032,
0.19257305562496185,
-0.010931456461548805,
-0.2771078050136566,
-0.8865799903869629,
-0.4193952679634094,
-0.14900179207324982,
0.08792903274297714,
0.4251731336116791,
0.010147402063012123,
-0.44447487592697144,
-0.6423633098602295,
-0.3451244831085205,
0.5827568769454956,
0.7090162038803101,
-0.6998187899589539,
0.0480409599840641,
0.36977583169937134,
0.0072895847260952,
-0.412453830242157,
-0.2566031813621521,
-0.2727509140968323,
-0.2902170419692993,
-0.5523832440376282,
0.35497984290122986,
-0.25627946853637695,
-0.4357701539993286,
-0.18156278133392334,
-0.35987016558647156,
-0.15599870681762695,
0.25260958075523376,
0.12825438380241394,
0.3862805664539337,
-0.49649760127067566,
0.12581966817378998,
0.2522082030773163,
-0.12357395887374878,
0.13576127588748932,
-0.3265243470668793,
0.6060743927955627,
-0.5536216497421265,
-0.574394166469574,
-0.10353824496269226,
0.11467164009809494,
0.17724981904029846,
-0.3610571622848511,
-0.0347052626311779,
0.5004773139953613,
-0.28948986530303955,
-0.6415309906005859,
-0.3271161615848541,
0.06812100857496262,
-0.4850952923297882,
0.743075966835022,
-0.3808540105819702,
-0.8718157410621643,
0.22387753427028656,
-0.23702359199523926,
0.14129455387592316,
0.37944507598876953,
0.9238072633743286,
0.030750567093491554,
1.0235497951507568,
0.6692051291465759,
0.07630286365747452,
0.17808732390403748,
-0.13248787820339203,
0.13570775091648102,
-0.6577478647232056,
0.08044347167015076,
-0.3384596109390259,
-0.08257722854614258,
-0.5436407327651978,
-0.4409726560115814,
0.3118090033531189,
-0.13430145382881165,
-0.3943183720111847,
0.31175732612609863,
-0.5598713755607605,
0.6980267763137817,
0.08797609806060791,
-0.2267923802137375,
0.1673438847064972,
0.23204994201660156,
0.11776823550462723,
-0.002359433565288782,
-0.3617832660675049,
-0.4711953103542328,
1.1092681884765625,
0.2833699584007263,
0.7144335508346558,
-0.02881775237619877,
0.7319110631942749,
0.7258216738700867,
0.32115456461906433,
-0.485815167427063,
0.4400995373725891,
-0.2677094638347626,
-0.37038931250572205,
-0.14364004135131836,
-0.568631649017334,
-0.7823196649551392,
0.12942719459533691,
0.3815385103225708,
-0.9554312825202942,
-0.24157454073429108,
0.20482137799263,
-0.5845599174499512,
-0.06930585950613022,
-0.3469977378845215,
1.1569050550460815,
-0.6158037185668945,
-0.4889921247959137,
-0.4881093204021454,
-0.18342773616313934,
0.6113553643226624,
-0.42069393396377563,
-0.06353163719177246,
0.1308731883764267,
0.22737623751163483,
0.42369553446769714,
-0.44316890835762024,
0.40028735995292664,
-0.07327964156866074,
-0.3474821150302887,
0.36681076884269714,
0.2042456865310669,
0.17336182296276093,
0.08491794019937515,
-0.16444337368011475,
0.1333896517753601,
0.1158454492688179,
-0.16248075664043427,
-0.33443161845207214,
0.8781179785728455,
-0.5273609161376953,
-0.5504446625709534,
0.11331096291542053,
-0.42562222480773926,
-0.16399161517620087,
0.24075670540332794,
-0.03411651775240898,
0.7136927843093872,
-0.15754428505897522,
0.2567899525165558,
0.7743044495582581,
-0.43538686633110046,
0.2664172351360321,
0.23119668662548065,
-0.7870399355888367,
-0.2556709945201874,
1.2333998680114746,
-0.16204826533794403,
0.21917295455932617,
0.08005042374134064,
-0.10325367748737335,
-0.2868833839893341,
-0.6237362027168274,
-0.7135806679725647,
-0.051625967025756836,
-0.5601687431335449,
-0.44438716769218445,
-0.123311847448349,
-0.34069201350212097,
-0.002705961000174284,
-0.18403147161006927,
-0.44463688135147095,
-0.10261179506778717,
0.10461548715829849,
-0.10606468468904495,
0.08408255130052567,
0.8123197555541992,
0.14934851229190826,
0.3620147705078125,
-0.7051123976707458,
0.38139474391937256,
0.15852278470993042,
0.4539645314216614,
-0.1876610815525055,
-0.4795460104942322,
-0.3505312502384186,
-0.17528584599494934,
-0.5783922076225281,
-0.5026044249534607,
0.29302066564559937,
-0.017685264348983765,
0.7651206254959106,
0.2275037169456482,
-0.10228169709444046,
0.6433407068252563,
-0.2762916386127472,
0.6453180909156799,
-0.14695310592651367,
-1.1294959783554077,
0.6038843393325806,
-0.24156956374645233,
0.07188936322927475,
0.3308393955230713,
-0.06057985872030258,
-0.1365405023097992,
-0.11730602383613586,
-0.5937256217002869,
-0.8334629535675049,
0.48866063356399536,
0.08024033904075623,
0.2887791693210602,
0.05352174863219261,
0.17969994246959686,
0.13483880460262299,
0.4780649244785309,
-0.36446982622146606,
-0.09973982721567154,
0.22394074499607086,
-0.16895192861557007,
0.16879865527153015,
-0.24536176025867462,
-0.056056465953588486,
-0.12791217863559723,
0.4990411400794983,
-0.25064972043037415,
0.16071943938732147,
-0.190241739153862,
-0.15765319764614105,
-0.2819465398788452,
0.11491348594427109,
0.6086652278900146,
0.7704697847366333,
-0.2987109422683716,
0.028875436633825302,
0.1695340871810913,
-0.0632033571600914,
0.059554845094680786,
0.13100075721740723,
-0.11831007152795792,
-0.19770124554634094,
0.2745040953159332,
0.8507147431373596,
-0.07708723843097687,
-1.066217064857483,
0.5735205411911011,
-0.08554423600435257,
-0.08138106018304825,
-0.20070438086986542,
0.25114887952804565,
-0.2526729106903076,
0.29628658294677734,
0.10878865420818329,
-0.21574777364730835,
0.2607135772705078,
-0.2968671917915344,
0.5051370859146118,
0.4145558476448059,
-0.22296728193759918,
-0.30160021781921387,
0.6172125339508057,
0.10423934459686279,
-0.37753555178642273,
0.8263804316520691,
-0.349646657705307,
-0.3334152102470398,
0.888059675693512,
0.6614586710929871,
0.9119581580162048,
-0.09628313779830933,
0.16305579245090485,
0.1733541339635849,
0.18464848399162292,
0.30564871430397034,
0.5562258362770081,
-0.32711225748062134,
-0.3796873688697815,
-0.7198889851570129,
-1.038527488708496,
-0.23025839030742645,
0.2960439920425415,
-0.4452449381351471,
0.34696364402770996,
-0.5363021492958069,
-0.17621736228466034,
-0.17552882432937622,
0.06041427329182625,
-0.7990291714668274,
-0.08276469260454178,
0.3797611594200134,
0.6589589715003967,
-0.6127254962921143,
0.8350547552108765,
0.7293806672096252,
-0.14738647639751434,
-0.49169132113456726,
-0.0036348907742649317,
-0.2888331413269043,
-0.5875985026359558,
0.7796005606651306,
0.23769958317279816,
0.07896880060434341,
-0.1262340098619461,
-0.37819424271583557,
-0.6334012746810913,
0.7488189935684204,
0.5269632339477539,
-0.5003470778465271,
0.4186834394931793,
0.20636484026908875,
0.7314261794090271,
-0.4309256076812744,
0.11027739942073822,
0.6493110060691833,
0.3471742272377014,
-0.061975106596946716,
-0.9156540036201477,
-0.02449270337820053,
-0.31098514795303345,
0.3445580303668976,
0.23204723000526428,
-0.4704020321369171,
0.9600383639335632,
-0.29384684562683105,
0.00752628780901432,
0.15018801391124725,
0.6188030242919922,
0.6701298952102661,
0.21055981516838074,
0.159182608127594,
0.1735023707151413,
0.73015296459198,
0.08093783259391785,
1.21640944480896,
-0.7063627243041992,
0.45465579628944397,
1.0984457731246948,
-0.6199030876159668,
0.6950662136077881,
0.3525969088077545,
-0.35941603779792786,
-0.01057130191475153,
0.37696677446365356,
-0.2912486791610718,
0.2919005751609802,
0.6980302333831787,
-0.07228989899158478,
-0.5376686453819275,
-0.017294269055128098,
-0.3476816415786743,
0.43278181552886963,
0.36609065532684326,
-0.31964945793151855,
-0.47287702560424805,
-0.08420748263597488,
-0.3929670751094818,
-0.09082458168268204,
-0.3046509325504303,
0.3413325250148773,
-0.008320405147969723,
-0.4568026661872864,
0.6631073951721191,
0.17213883996009827,
0.29036131501197815,
-0.20798441767692566,
-0.29884448647499084,
-0.23090369999408722,
0.5157318115234375,
-0.16181693971157074,
-0.7388122081756592,
0.3753727674484253,
0.17488336563110352,
-0.03568556532263756,
-0.24654069542884827,
0.8011748194694519,
-0.15224193036556244,
-0.6245945692062378,
0.047494109719991684,
0.6013895869255066,
0.3358534276485443,
0.0852193608880043,
-0.42013266682624817,
0.6290062069892883,
0.1419207602739334,
-0.2722845673561096,
0.3987694978713989,
0.20355592668056488,
-0.2006547749042511,
0.5187188386917114,
0.4446987211704254,
0.016946353018283844,
0.09137603640556335,
-0.10681553184986115,
0.6329526305198669,
-0.40908175706863403,
-0.159523144364357,
-0.9550546407699585,
0.5334699153900146,
-0.02548251301050186,
-0.4833446145057678,
0.8560355305671692,
0.7270650267601013,
1.1140820980072021,
-0.255294531583786,
0.8506994247436523,
-0.19062776863574982,
-0.06844721734523773,
-0.3594963848590851,
0.43707481026649475,
-0.4579687714576721,
0.4354584813117981,
-0.15911899507045746,
-1.0086333751678467,
-0.18158575892448425,
0.5857245326042175,
-0.18394513428211212,
0.11018610745668411,
0.2706984877586365,
0.7330589294433594,
-0.0939658135175705,
-0.20744983851909637,
0.5254461765289307,
0.2472640872001648,
0.3789491057395935,
0.5618036389350891,
0.9219281673431396,
-0.3268775939941406,
0.19709978997707367,
-0.2567858099937439,
-0.11544473469257355,
-0.3122078776359558,
-0.8668306469917297,
-0.6063643097877502,
-0.4253631830215454,
-0.6026746034622192,
-0.24884147942066193,
0.04457749053835869,
0.7702056765556335,
0.469216525554657,
-0.728511393070221,
-0.6496440172195435,
-0.10760356485843658,
0.27093663811683655,
-0.20573973655700684,
-0.1966523379087448,
0.3674393892288208,
-0.5956379175186157,
-0.5572813749313354,
0.4484189450740814,
0.37470319867134094,
-0.1892390102148056,
-0.7360111474990845,
-0.2687344551086426,
0.6489284634590149,
0.055140815675258636,
0.8834233283996582,
0.1609136015176773,
-0.41092678904533386,
-0.10420546680688858,
-0.02749214507639408,
-0.09987061470746994,
-0.14687927067279816,
0.6809337735176086,
-0.8485586047172546,
0.3700633943080902,
0.5265471935272217,
0.8616623282432556,
0.43537265062332153,
-0.21447612345218658,
0.47248125076293945,
-0.6993791460990906,
-0.2881692945957184,
-0.0066075860522687435,
0.3903588354587555,
0.18309172987937927,
-0.25447097420692444,
0.3459784686565399,
0.029767798259854317,
-0.670932948589325,
-1.401749610900879,
0.25658735632896423,
-0.8166136741638184,
-0.06645362824201584,
1.104414463043213,
-0.011755434796214104,
-0.4865906536579132,
0.23150651156902313,
-0.17695970833301544,
-0.09860964119434357,
0.07746794819831848,
0.8050022125244141,
0.426518052816391,
-0.25962546467781067,
0.2721391022205353,
-0.754321813583374,
0.3357143700122833,
0.13840679824352264,
-0.8787602782249451,
0.36863842606544495,
0.7597285509109497,
0.05887940153479576,
-0.02422041818499565,
0.5156039595603943,
-0.10981035232543945,
0.39903733134269714,
-0.000675305025652051,
0.16859561204910278,
-0.10857245326042175,
-0.5028652548789978,
-0.48987582325935364,
0.2809351086616516,
0.23111025989055634,
0.07044234126806259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03642v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03642v1
|
Is Free Self-Alignment Possible?
| 2024-06-05T22:35:17 | 2024-06-05T22:35:17 |
Dyah Adila, Changho Shin, Yijing Zhang, Frederic Sala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Aligning pretrained language models (LMs) is a complex and resource-intensive
process, often requiring access to large amounts of ground-truth preference
data and substantial compute. Are these costs necessary? That is, it is
possible to align using only inherent model knowledge and without additional
training? We tackle this challenge with AlignEZ, a novel approach that uses (1)
self-generated preference data and (2) representation editing to provide nearly
cost-free alignment. During inference, AlignEZ modifies LM representations to
reduce undesirable and boost desirable components using subspaces identified
via self-generated preference pairs. Our experiments reveal that this nearly
cost-free procedure significantly narrows the gap between base pretrained and
tuned models by an average of 31.6%, observed across six datasets and three
model architectures. Additionally, we explore the potential of using AlignEZ as
a means of expediting more expensive alignment procedures. Our experiments show
that AlignEZ improves DPO models tuned only using a small subset of
ground-truth preference data. Lastly, we study the conditions under which
improvement using AlignEZ is feasible, providing valuable insights into its
effectiveness.
|
[
-0.08905718475580215,
-0.07756585627794266,
0.6448038816452026,
-0.12038116157054901,
-0.1298174262046814,
0.1171356812119484,
-0.4102996587753296,
-0.3485864996910095,
0.21442937850952148,
0.6305230855941772,
-0.7426487803459167,
-0.21516603231430054,
-0.21459150314331055,
-0.18807338178157806,
-0.07122842967510223,
0.7090959548950195,
-0.07500489801168442,
0.0945051908493042,
-0.3049655556678772,
-0.2637651264667511,
-0.48045292496681213,
-0.2083379328250885,
0.07331832498311996,
-0.2688077986240387,
0.3141568899154663,
0.6688262224197388,
1.0386418104171753,
1.051688313484192,
0.30601024627685547,
0.2657724618911743,
0.41597333550453186,
0.032666612416505814,
-0.3237980604171753,
-0.010152332484722137,
-0.233413428068161,
-0.5245115756988525,
-0.7841647267341614,
0.3373411297798157,
0.5249044895172119,
0.652961790561676,
-0.43766453862190247,
0.2243887037038803,
0.07869625836610794,
1.0914638042449951,
-0.668790340423584,
-0.35297608375549316,
-0.8728326559066772,
0.024815872311592102,
-0.39883172512054443,
0.11758915334939957,
-0.32340580224990845,
-0.32667097449302673,
-0.15879321098327637,
-0.796158492565155,
0.14523626863956451,
0.13435646891593933,
0.8847284317016602,
0.7687216401100159,
-0.04256334900856018,
0.023842377588152885,
-0.5735758543014526,
0.7946304082870483,
-0.7535398006439209,
0.6729016304016113,
0.09412214159965515,
0.319865345954895,
-0.1706828624010086,
-0.2589193284511566,
-0.6787088513374329,
-0.04038484767079353,
-0.14677055180072784,
-0.01634802855551243,
-0.26102665066719055,
0.19563603401184082,
0.24813884496688843,
0.4039042294025421,
-0.5095090866088867,
0.3620353937149048,
-0.21825462579727173,
-0.20827175676822662,
0.698897659778595,
0.014274396933615208,
0.5951663255691528,
0.02194906584918499,
-0.541820228099823,
0.05275852233171463,
-1.0252381563186646,
0.04395950958132744,
0.700639545917511,
0.616438627243042,
-0.08427317440509796,
0.6578090190887451,
-0.18572279810905457,
0.8813843727111816,
0.49674856662750244,
0.03144271299242973,
0.3080173134803772,
-0.02939666621387005,
-0.5329222083091736,
0.1446126401424408,
1.0163575410842896,
0.3834458589553833,
0.3158610463142395,
-0.26460543274879456,
-0.15908919274806976,
-0.047948651015758514,
0.47820597887039185,
-0.4408037066459656,
-0.3405923545360565,
0.29512402415275574,
-0.15042363107204437,
-0.15004360675811768,
-0.3324842154979706,
-0.5749175548553467,
-0.2337469458580017,
-0.6159489154815674,
0.624015212059021,
-0.16771449148654938,
-0.24971602857112885,
0.2823817729949951,
0.2303297519683838,
0.23763836920261383,
0.40626102685928345,
-1.1392791271209717,
0.2304835170507431,
0.4896388351917267,
0.6415692567825317,
-0.04650754854083061,
-0.2175181359052658,
-0.3920692503452301,
0.08265188336372375,
-0.6382287740707397,
0.6882266402244568,
-0.24905335903167725,
-0.14080001413822174,
-0.38672685623168945,
-0.2002437561750412,
0.022726867347955704,
-0.480900377035141,
0.31479719281196594,
-0.4772929847240448,
0.26456862688064575,
-0.478146493434906,
-0.7180225849151611,
0.4912359416484833,
-0.17531940340995789,
-0.7808334231376648,
1.1140679121017456,
0.3390994071960449,
-0.6702899932861328,
0.28587788343429565,
-0.2133730947971344,
-0.12491779774427414,
0.04196951910853386,
-0.43510642647743225,
-0.37184885144233704,
0.06251515448093414,
0.36314520239830017,
0.1556607484817505,
-0.09784933179616928,
0.4887691140174866,
-0.3801090717315674,
-0.13599903881549835,
0.09003660082817078,
0.048799145966768265,
0.8760699033737183,
0.3100244700908661,
-0.4926767647266388,
0.3006495535373688,
-0.7169510722160339,
0.22174213826656342,
0.015115680173039436,
0.1448575109243393,
-0.32491758465766907,
0.022343778982758522,
-0.6465885043144226,
0.24610450863838196,
0.5157894492149353,
-0.6548585295677185,
0.5853930711746216,
-0.48596855998039246,
-0.10380103439092636,
0.8980444073677063,
-0.6922768950462341,
0.9655033349990845,
-0.1638091504573822,
0.575154185295105,
-0.14339202642440796,
0.1065254732966423,
0.1986977458000183,
-0.10793565213680267,
-0.8755483031272888,
-0.34611639380455017,
0.43795865774154663,
0.3023502826690674,
-0.22389070689678192,
0.6045421957969666,
-0.4038999676704407,
-0.5104315876960754,
-1.0056790113449097,
0.3281518816947937,
0.46846967935562134,
1.0083374977111816,
0.6654470562934875,
0.09171216189861298,
-0.49551552534103394,
-1.0107896327972412,
-0.3514776825904846,
0.17173859477043152,
0.07456184923648834,
-0.10004516690969467,
-0.14685773849487305,
0.22516202926635742,
1.2411367893218994,
-0.5881255865097046,
-0.3427235782146454,
-0.16545267403125763,
-0.1621149629354477,
0.02577088586986065,
0.7293639779090881,
0.8444107174873352,
-0.22993098199367523,
-0.6715143322944641,
-0.18713335692882538,
-0.2998512387275696,
-0.49077630043029785,
0.15245957672595978,
-0.4103301167488098,
0.03936969116330147,
0.5528486371040344,
-0.4354264438152313,
0.17463505268096924,
0.769787609577179,
-0.09207848459482193,
0.31899914145469666,
-0.29037806391716003,
-0.08807740360498428,
-0.8664425611495972,
0.007316477596759796,
-0.2309490144252777,
-0.3650919795036316,
-0.6022184491157532,
-0.18628551065921783,
0.5730620622634888,
-0.20263031125068665,
-0.2052399069070816,
0.6647292971611023,
-0.8074087500572205,
-0.11119420826435089,
-0.23796021938323975,
0.2110757976770401,
0.0564483106136322,
0.5006819367408752,
0.018978139385581017,
1.05545973777771,
0.504605770111084,
-0.47073665261268616,
0.009843028150498867,
0.372397780418396,
-0.5702409744262695,
0.19235052168369293,
-0.36835628747940063,
0.3525133430957794,
-0.2795250415802002,
0.0004061369691044092,
-0.9213110208511353,
-0.0553925447165966,
0.4276830852031708,
-0.21324782073497772,
0.45618265867233276,
-0.2820749282836914,
0.25620707869529724,
0.03124540112912655,
-0.1147371158003807,
0.31546810269355774,
0.4840993583202362,
-0.7879039645195007,
0.44633686542510986,
0.456533819437027,
-0.11306833475828171,
-1.2196890115737915,
-0.5616551041603088,
-0.3282676935195923,
-0.12396195530891418,
-0.2527937889099121,
0.6714609265327454,
-0.08846719563007355,
0.007290177047252655,
0.2021995633840561,
-0.2994125783443451,
0.26912182569503784,
0.191340371966362,
0.10832473635673523,
0.32006946206092834,
-0.2671445906162262,
0.22180472314357758,
0.1080489307641983,
-0.13151241838932037,
-0.35394999384880066,
-0.3860951066017151,
0.44682377576828003,
-0.013210313394665718,
-0.5101112723350525,
-0.48478472232818604,
0.28705742955207825,
0.5206484794616699,
-0.72458416223526,
0.48410865664482117,
0.1272459179162979,
-0.4504453241825104,
-0.41657552123069763,
-0.6577679514884949,
0.32748693227767944,
-0.5056178569793701,
-0.004025873262435198,
-0.19018474221229553,
-0.8769250512123108,
0.36629772186279297,
0.21816910803318024,
0.11048343032598495,
0.45290929079055786,
0.2741745412349701,
-0.1803709715604782,
1.1181819438934326,
0.6851487159729004,
-0.11208007484674454,
0.6079288721084595,
0.29309383034706116,
0.4604035019874573,
-0.8331780433654785,
-0.198537215590477,
-0.7473880052566528,
-0.42396217584609985,
-0.4193868041038513,
-0.33935555815696716,
0.1139044240117073,
0.3117062449455261,
-0.20584794878959656,
0.4449664056301117,
-0.5395774245262146,
0.7123907804489136,
0.4980505108833313,
0.20730578899383545,
0.07067261636257172,
-0.16357368230819702,
-0.06590589135885239,
-0.3092648386955261,
-0.6366341710090637,
-0.5616962313652039,
1.2145025730133057,
0.1081685945391655,
0.920118510723114,
0.1631690263748169,
0.8741040825843811,
0.088407963514328,
0.4859771132469177,
-0.812092125415802,
0.3821094036102295,
-0.12749037146568298,
-0.538520097732544,
-0.5387234687805176,
-0.31753772497177124,
-0.7325112223625183,
0.03015933744609356,
-0.41074737906455994,
-0.7689311504364014,
0.26751071214675903,
0.816965639591217,
-0.7972329258918762,
0.29612231254577637,
-0.6867644786834717,
0.9765515327453613,
-0.7721589803695679,
-0.43673649430274963,
-0.12514431774616241,
-0.7629382610321045,
0.1682678759098053,
-0.004570921882987022,
0.2444036304950714,
-0.6618595719337463,
0.10528985410928726,
0.546530544757843,
-0.4816772937774658,
0.5051732063293457,
-0.32755133509635925,
-0.23864436149597168,
0.14996829628944397,
0.13859610259532928,
0.2675161361694336,
-0.4203634262084961,
-0.10256224125623703,
-0.06163433939218521,
-0.12412437796592712,
-0.33525869250297546,
-0.8664312362670898,
0.6456726789474487,
-0.7590656876564026,
-0.8800897002220154,
-0.21208737790584564,
-0.4878326952457428,
-0.6595523357391357,
0.3812912106513977,
0.09300893545150757,
0.2838139832019806,
-0.27573147416114807,
-0.22249294817447662,
0.5030163526535034,
0.04284431412816048,
0.22901871800422668,
0.4151941239833832,
-0.24905309081077576,
-0.5534335374832153,
0.7339615821838379,
0.12624365091323853,
0.3446556627750397,
0.4312261641025543,
0.4842435121536255,
-0.6237683892250061,
-0.45786264538764954,
-0.632607102394104,
0.24309319257736206,
-0.5436058640480042,
-0.5449858903884888,
-0.5920058488845825,
0.17881982028484344,
-0.7049732208251953,
-0.15507341921329498,
-0.7987430095672607,
-0.6949986815452576,
-0.18612700700759888,
-0.2581993639469147,
-0.04159630089998245,
0.47872820496559143,
-0.348056435585022,
0.462920218706131,
-0.9217373728752136,
0.1920856237411499,
0.3481028974056244,
0.6717836260795593,
-0.16965019702911377,
-0.2711280286312103,
-0.2747126519680023,
0.15810084342956543,
-0.11279696226119995,
-1.0671563148498535,
0.3710452616214752,
0.1492028683423996,
0.7677051424980164,
0.4633809030056,
0.22448945045471191,
1.0233745574951172,
-0.6685994267463684,
0.6437512636184692,
0.2397177666425705,
-1.370617151260376,
0.43672433495521545,
-0.27195385098457336,
-0.10083073377609253,
0.7242643237113953,
0.37673041224479675,
-0.18643246591091156,
0.01610843650996685,
-0.6249459981918335,
-0.44338154792785645,
0.819782555103302,
-0.19192089140415192,
0.13007257878780365,
0.155329167842865,
0.45529264211654663,
0.12294845283031464,
0.23153457045555115,
-0.8429699540138245,
-0.06615559011697769,
-0.23645301163196564,
-0.7529251575469971,
-0.0904219001531601,
-0.18439827859401703,
-0.2969791889190674,
-0.2793920040130615,
0.8760682344436646,
-0.20884212851524353,
0.04483901709318161,
0.2495710849761963,
-0.24954628944396973,
-0.42073944211006165,
0.4404323399066925,
0.5141870379447937,
0.4949968755245209,
-0.13577236235141754,
0.10179635882377625,
-0.15332376956939697,
0.24710191786289215,
0.3105889558792114,
-0.049305226653814316,
-0.08246353268623352,
-0.2919677793979645,
-0.17540155351161957,
0.8921142220497131,
0.25782373547554016,
-0.500977098941803,
0.7447758913040161,
0.10225134342908859,
-0.15768174827098846,
0.01700250431895256,
0.14088469743728638,
0.13011237978935242,
0.13773368299007416,
-0.09402929246425629,
0.013976234942674637,
-0.1498413383960724,
-0.23177552223205566,
0.08641821891069412,
0.9181511998176575,
-0.34539076685905457,
-0.3416009545326233,
0.8310409784317017,
0.2792443633079529,
-0.1448519378900528,
0.5916672945022583,
0.029791267588734627,
-0.49343234300613403,
0.285535603761673,
0.6458238363265991,
0.815879762172699,
-0.6557387709617615,
0.18224042654037476,
0.44812309741973877,
0.3312024176120758,
-0.31029659509658813,
0.09897398203611374,
-0.2108563929796219,
-1.256793737411499,
-0.2848743200302124,
-0.5674054026603699,
-0.4994310140609741,
0.16294260323047638,
-0.801664412021637,
0.4395454525947571,
-0.3611953854560852,
0.02440907247364521,
-0.11062032729387283,
-0.2768747806549072,
-0.46006569266319275,
0.37810587882995605,
0.26142168045043945,
0.7137068510055542,
-0.900047779083252,
0.8252408504486084,
0.5107420086860657,
-0.13252472877502441,
-1.318433403968811,
-0.08851104974746704,
-0.09516995400190353,
-0.9903595447540283,
0.18368560075759888,
0.15352767705917358,
-0.4737359583377838,
0.16013847291469574,
-0.7253524661064148,
-1.2071336507797241,
0.7518191337585449,
0.9778228998184204,
-0.8169388175010681,
-0.2700210213661194,
-0.0071432688273489475,
0.3297007977962494,
-0.31183508038520813,
0.007903500460088253,
0.42791295051574707,
0.1783362478017807,
-0.24102450907230377,
-0.8398433923721313,
0.07826786488294601,
-0.07955178618431091,
-0.4668799936771393,
0.5903096199035645,
-0.7188861966133118,
0.8379169702529907,
-0.4350142776966095,
-0.5703086256980896,
-0.17887035012245178,
0.6936841011047363,
-0.17615319788455963,
-0.16247640550136566,
0.6969599723815918,
0.8345150351524353,
1.0714162588119507,
0.0265808068215847,
0.5084103941917419,
-0.6418103575706482,
0.3992542028427124,
1.3932100534439087,
-0.4362410604953766,
0.6254045963287354,
0.5524725914001465,
-0.13560248911380768,
0.507505476474762,
0.42541438341140747,
0.23517292737960815,
0.47907036542892456,
-0.013976400718092918,
-0.057582199573516846,
-0.7430965900421143,
0.25018250942230225,
-0.3998225927352905,
0.5132572054862976,
0.10545915365219116,
0.016104282811284065,
-0.2019157111644745,
-0.3424537181854248,
0.012914199382066727,
0.37706536054611206,
-0.1898607760667801,
0.5588372945785522,
-0.2211603820323944,
-1.0355029106140137,
0.26364919543266296,
-0.2646504342556,
0.40805232524871826,
-0.7781848311424255,
0.20636588335037231,
-0.13197053968906403,
0.1551220417022705,
-0.36840081214904785,
-0.5924181938171387,
0.33879294991493225,
-0.09693655371665955,
0.03838401287794113,
-0.6574314832687378,
0.6289690136909485,
-0.8483760356903076,
-0.14035125076770782,
0.09479302912950516,
0.7118817567825317,
-0.2954578101634979,
0.018826836720108986,
-0.4552662670612335,
-0.34126174449920654,
0.20783060789108276,
-0.13982728123664856,
0.4076673090457916,
0.050680581480264664,
-0.014992165379226208,
0.5157191753387451,
0.5728121399879456,
0.1444494128227234,
0.08651935309171677,
-0.04232695326209068,
0.6778751015663147,
-0.6337519288063049,
-0.6150215864181519,
-0.8087064623832703,
0.6315988302230835,
0.11751189827919006,
-0.1021505668759346,
0.5077688097953796,
0.5215752124786377,
1.0151162147521973,
-0.13512764871120453,
0.805135190486908,
0.09562724828720093,
0.6361993551254272,
-0.7672237157821655,
0.6523922681808472,
-0.8323430418968201,
0.00601839367300272,
-0.22196851670742035,
-0.6632047891616821,
-0.17092682421207428,
0.61361163854599,
-0.18117208778858185,
-0.3311815559864044,
0.3702925741672516,
0.7741531133651733,
-0.133938729763031,
-0.19495068490505219,
0.23757493495941162,
-0.28716644644737244,
0.1426624208688736,
0.2551180124282837,
0.796194314956665,
-0.154361292719841,
0.18635591864585876,
-0.4986550211906433,
-0.319857120513916,
0.1958245486021042,
-1.1834170818328857,
-0.5220556855201721,
-0.47492125630378723,
-0.3238452672958374,
-0.11202232539653778,
-0.16882984340190887,
1.3955405950546265,
0.5094020962715149,
-0.6581159830093384,
-0.17417952418327332,
0.015846623107790947,
0.07056152075529099,
-0.13471917808055878,
-0.08297013491392136,
0.30442267656326294,
-0.5422086119651794,
-0.8793314695358276,
0.7155752778053284,
0.21123479306697845,
0.41521841287612915,
0.07033199071884155,
-0.0013516531325876713,
0.1908731758594513,
0.062466997653245926,
-0.029614510014653206,
0.5452394485473633,
-0.5500190258026123,
-0.4237348139286041,
0.30363619327545166,
-0.2401013821363449,
0.6451674699783325,
1.009048342704773,
-0.6562003493309021,
0.7202797532081604,
0.3524869382381439,
0.657254695892334,
0.11095307767391205,
0.40583720803260803,
0.8895627856254578,
-0.7373858690261841,
0.10551045835018158,
0.12847484648227692,
0.5206258893013,
0.4901300370693207,
-0.4828726351261139,
0.166846364736557,
-0.10529395192861557,
-0.5114079117774963,
-0.7660371661186218,
0.4679182469844818,
-0.9969695806503296,
-0.02228698320686817,
0.7680054306983948,
-0.014058737084269524,
-0.08212589472532272,
0.36267948150634766,
-0.06939267367124557,
0.5373020172119141,
-0.027647260576486588,
0.5564965009689331,
0.529883086681366,
-0.4453328847885132,
-0.0906786397099495,
-0.02100326307117939,
0.8283006548881531,
0.7567429542541504,
-0.7059825658798218,
0.4810972213745117,
0.7464160323143005,
0.6384057402610779,
0.11640719324350357,
0.9540770649909973,
-0.220971018075943,
-0.15962821245193481,
-0.3254969120025635,
0.5107752084732056,
-0.11774981021881104,
-0.42720314860343933,
-0.539930522441864,
-0.10689568519592285,
0.2537580132484436,
-0.29044559597969055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03637v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03637v1
|
Style Mixture of Experts for Expressive Text-To-Speech Synthesis
| 2024-06-05T22:17:47 | 2024-06-05T22:17:47 |
Ahad Jawaid, Shreeram Suresh Chandra, Junchen Lu, Berrak Sisman
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Recent advances in style transfer text-to-speech (TTS) have improved the
expressiveness of synthesized speech. Despite these advancements, encoding
stylistic information from diverse and unseen reference speech remains
challenging. This paper introduces StyleMoE, an approach that divides the
embedding space, modeled by the style encoder, into tractable subsets handled
by style experts. The proposed method replaces the style encoder in a TTS
system with a Mixture of Experts (MoE) layer. By utilizing a gating network to
route reference speeches to different style experts, each expert specializes in
aspects of the style space during optimization. Our experiments objectively and
subjectively demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method in increasing
the coverage of the style space for diverse and unseen styles. This approach
can enhance the performance of existing state-of-the-art style transfer TTS
models, marking the first study of MoE in style transfer TTS to our knowledge.
|
[
-0.549405038356781,
-0.6851744055747986,
0.27841097116470337,
0.4394935369491577,
-0.19221235811710358,
0.42590346932411194,
-0.39532384276390076,
-0.26888588070869446,
0.7148410081863403,
0.29980891942977905,
-0.6665482521057129,
-0.33291545510292053,
-0.553281307220459,
0.07145847380161285,
-0.44876307249069214,
0.742960512638092,
0.04860420525074005,
-0.11852893233299255,
0.08214475959539413,
0.09601226449012756,
-0.5227299332618713,
-0.25375962257385254,
-0.43886929750442505,
-0.1610788106918335,
0.11462342739105225,
0.22281311452388763,
0.36233583092689514,
0.542816698551178,
0.10107623040676117,
0.3405598998069763,
-0.11422549188137054,
0.5000942349433899,
-0.46229106187820435,
0.5673322081565857,
-0.484790176153183,
-0.21491146087646484,
-0.5807110667228699,
-0.012695172801613808,
0.2411726415157318,
0.29886186122894287,
-0.14763793349266052,
-0.2512296438217163,
0.028777020052075386,
0.33984628319740295,
-0.6836085915565491,
-0.10121835023164749,
-0.7755857110023499,
0.11510483175516129,
-0.1585184931755066,
-0.45851585268974304,
-0.5698766708374023,
-0.2556813359260559,
0.38819748163223267,
-0.5921751856803894,
0.02068324200809002,
-0.03097088821232319,
0.27208346128463745,
0.1274328976869583,
-0.265878289937973,
-0.15248845517635345,
-0.9278137683868408,
0.7080507874488831,
-0.6109338402748108,
0.4680364727973938,
0.12654545903205872,
0.38244298100471497,
-0.04389054700732231,
-0.6790248155593872,
-0.5732625722885132,
0.014333859086036682,
0.17025217413902283,
0.21969322860240936,
-0.09237967431545258,
-0.08876238763332367,
-0.3265669047832489,
0.1430439054965973,
-0.10555228590965271,
-0.18549613654613495,
-0.3691239655017853,
-0.24290581047534943,
0.8515387773513794,
-0.1560065597295761,
0.3599702715873718,
0.041015755385160446,
-0.3553246855735779,
-0.09175176918506622,
-0.2982606887817383,
-0.3906720280647278,
0.17796191573143005,
0.12725363671779633,
0.09975187480449677,
0.17821916937828064,
-0.2507779002189636,
0.509746253490448,
0.2992536723613739,
-0.3572498857975006,
0.1644497811794281,
-0.37194201350212097,
-0.07844222337007523,
0.002879297360777855,
0.7830833792686462,
0.4267021715641022,
0.2571939527988434,
-0.5827252268791199,
-0.2976386249065399,
-0.5570564270019531,
0.2708188593387604,
-0.6407756805419922,
-0.4393059313297272,
-0.2011881172657013,
-0.056104741990566254,
-0.3015725910663605,
0.18868036568164825,
-1.028982162475586,
-0.30856049060821533,
-0.5085799098014832,
0.5211407542228699,
-0.4889550805091858,
-0.3961764872074127,
-0.17159149050712585,
-0.3539002239704132,
-0.193243145942688,
0.3542422354221344,
-1.0284487009048462,
0.18675443530082703,
0.3690652847290039,
0.6466219425201416,
-0.21665430068969727,
0.08111529797315598,
-0.3503483831882477,
0.5337264537811279,
-0.5238403081893921,
0.5511138439178467,
-0.684826672077179,
-0.7708708047866821,
-0.11646813899278641,
-0.5945125222206116,
-0.07509104162454605,
-0.5387921929359436,
0.3014048933982849,
-0.22177642583847046,
0.165491983294487,
-0.030330704525113106,
-0.5779010057449341,
-0.014155714772641659,
-0.269128680229187,
-0.32603511214256287,
0.8771417140960693,
0.125484436750412,
-0.24554868042469025,
0.21239638328552246,
-0.5530374050140381,
-0.4250982403755188,
0.019739026203751564,
-0.3069567382335663,
-0.03314485028386116,
0.3700491189956665,
0.49812769889831543,
0.44037413597106934,
0.09881465882062912,
0.22695788741111755,
-0.27150318026542664,
-0.1459583342075348,
0.5694542527198792,
-0.24939852952957153,
0.26332539319992065,
0.5561342835426331,
-0.22525060176849365,
0.24896155297756195,
-0.82039475440979,
0.2822911739349365,
-0.1824023425579071,
-0.1313323825597763,
-0.47970327734947205,
-0.1557939350605011,
0.42625996470451355,
0.18588495254516602,
0.17265650629997253,
-0.4189167022705078,
0.14737671613693237,
0.01274549774825573,
0.6838015913963318,
0.9681274890899658,
0.12397325783967972,
0.7083618640899658,
-0.3325054347515106,
0.4537520110607147,
-0.37250426411628723,
-0.14706392586231232,
0.023377634584903717,
-0.44119516015052795,
-0.7142196893692017,
-0.38205018639564514,
0.3017788827419281,
0.4406965672969818,
-0.9052632451057434,
0.6476444602012634,
-0.24569624662399292,
-0.4811573922634125,
-0.6596083641052246,
-0.09002865850925446,
0.2756141424179077,
0.37966153025627136,
0.4270711839199066,
-0.19196930527687073,
-0.3822268843650818,
-1.0418870449066162,
-0.354340523481369,
-0.006408049259334803,
-0.32891425490379333,
0.2911377251148224,
0.1171383261680603,
0.027354678139090538,
1.2646552324295044,
-0.3288799822330475,
-0.0049372767098248005,
-0.16271845996379852,
0.21391454339027405,
-0.3447292447090149,
0.8369520902633667,
0.7317568063735962,
-0.5045796036720276,
-0.5733090043067932,
0.05065719410777092,
-0.3038979172706604,
-0.49480709433555603,
-0.056200165301561356,
-0.33009475469589233,
0.012182969599962234,
0.6198551654815674,
0.0011509779142215848,
0.0436905138194561,
0.5777645707130432,
-0.06234845519065857,
0.45578381419181824,
0.04796432703733444,
0.24559888243675232,
-1.4286965131759644,
-0.05080830305814743,
0.14623554050922394,
-0.16789917647838593,
-0.7814756631851196,
0.17306390404701233,
-0.40373706817626953,
-0.22028332948684692,
-0.2012389451265335,
0.6176502704620361,
-0.3791654407978058,
0.16898922622203827,
-0.10913393646478653,
0.1437823623418808,
0.16836073994636536,
0.6724300980567932,
0.10419072210788727,
0.8668642640113831,
0.44844359159469604,
-0.2819454073905945,
0.19799788296222687,
0.22629369795322418,
-0.3159295320510864,
0.8070454001426697,
-0.5759120583534241,
0.9340038299560547,
0.19141879677772522,
0.19032327830791473,
-0.9328447580337524,
-0.3024252653121948,
0.3087337613105774,
-0.29840055108070374,
0.559057354927063,
-0.2652468681335449,
-0.25892841815948486,
0.1689443439245224,
-0.047337647527456284,
0.47130537033081055,
0.6666123270988464,
-0.18952515721321106,
0.8886170387268066,
0.5048195719718933,
-0.6110466718673706,
-0.16874724626541138,
-0.7377642393112183,
0.24337007105350494,
-0.2988065779209137,
-0.973882257938385,
0.7516784071922302,
-0.12367842346429825,
-0.2375236302614212,
-0.13535717129707336,
-0.29744258522987366,
-0.4272631108760834,
-0.04103125259280205,
-0.23238779604434967,
0.007831026799976826,
-0.1415879726409912,
-0.1665864884853363,
0.4904385209083557,
0.2792292535305023,
-0.03209986910223961,
-0.4158816933631897,
0.4911527931690216,
0.15675939619541168,
-0.15015168488025665,
-0.741780698299408,
0.7665130496025085,
0.5317386388778687,
-0.35646986961364746,
0.40659192204475403,
0.5257821083068848,
0.011755130253732204,
-0.6218132972717285,
-0.5803765058517456,
-0.11997800320386887,
-0.49846380949020386,
0.4796118140220642,
-0.4423881471157074,
-0.6706802248954773,
0.4955219030380249,
-0.10053133219480515,
0.07312481850385666,
0.25832125544548035,
0.23687848448753357,
0.013668809086084366,
0.8179327249526978,
0.696246325969696,
0.0644136369228363,
0.9949750900268555,
-0.12549865245819092,
0.01349993608891964,
-0.7775299549102783,
-0.4448409676551819,
-0.47698554396629333,
-0.5991406440734863,
-0.4376898407936096,
-0.5686483383178711,
0.6096122860908508,
-0.09545370191335678,
0.02974354848265648,
0.09763671457767487,
-0.5857610702514648,
0.4454484283924103,
0.5764681696891785,
0.4209030270576477,
0.15109407901763916,
0.38768571615219116,
0.04742734134197235,
-0.02047419175505638,
-0.6038252115249634,
-0.2711271047592163,
0.935600757598877,
0.1958552896976471,
0.8499168753623962,
0.02625344507396221,
0.9372059106826782,
0.18510369956493378,
-0.025859348475933075,
-0.9589904546737671,
0.6253188252449036,
-0.3947840631008148,
-0.3156510889530182,
-0.24207749962806702,
-0.34806206822395325,
-0.2511332929134369,
0.29678604006767273,
-0.3576022684574127,
-0.7616649866104126,
0.47290411591529846,
0.07002852112054825,
-0.18259654939174652,
0.2065596729516983,
-0.5628082752227783,
0.2357356697320938,
0.2570694386959076,
-0.30914196372032166,
-0.3228819966316223,
-0.6189755797386169,
0.06707407534122467,
-0.11395922303199768,
0.17135150730609894,
0.18641014397144318,
0.022328563034534454,
1.0784728527069092,
-0.43336790800094604,
0.5641666054725647,
0.2521912455558777,
-0.2079627364873886,
0.26910582184791565,
0.4244900941848755,
0.4754228889942169,
-0.298899382352829,
-0.1608695238828659,
-0.02215370163321495,
-0.42937466502189636,
-0.1792471706867218,
-1.0313752889633179,
0.5016438961029053,
-0.6372448205947876,
-0.645280659198761,
0.2651844322681427,
-0.6566309332847595,
-0.7058749198913574,
0.03410807251930237,
0.3962371051311493,
0.7847347855567932,
-0.15196062624454498,
0.33710211515426636,
0.5421270132064819,
0.23803642392158508,
0.3418562412261963,
0.17221172153949738,
-0.02572069689631462,
-0.7759841680526733,
0.8116472959518433,
0.15634702146053314,
0.4174935221672058,
0.3233779966831207,
0.3505648672580719,
-0.16818587481975555,
-0.7518821954727173,
-0.5340370535850525,
-0.06277264654636383,
-0.6492786407470703,
0.3243466019630432,
-0.39893051981925964,
-0.20567099750041962,
-0.4708960950374603,
-0.4479488432407379,
-0.5034542083740234,
-0.7145224213600159,
-0.31784138083457947,
0.034053921699523926,
0.33377155661582947,
0.8459048271179199,
0.25904253125190735,
0.3794596493244171,
-0.757392168045044,
-0.059277404099702835,
0.5243646502494812,
0.10300476849079132,
-0.13421109318733215,
-0.6671176552772522,
-0.14409521222114563,
0.050007060170173645,
-0.27668988704681396,
-1.0760083198547363,
0.5040377378463745,
0.29031047224998474,
0.7211493253707886,
0.35847774147987366,
-0.06211969256401062,
0.6424975395202637,
-0.5465380549430847,
0.7217128872871399,
0.24011066555976868,
-1.140243649482727,
0.4590296447277069,
-0.5697311758995056,
-0.06714276224374771,
0.45712220668792725,
-0.07185282558202744,
-0.6181667447090149,
-0.6780493855476379,
-0.5238974094390869,
-0.8290101289749146,
0.4842626750469208,
0.428564190864563,
0.18676473200321198,
0.20376871526241302,
0.16983099281787872,
0.3062722682952881,
0.3083183169364929,
-0.06429596245288849,
-0.21280629932880402,
-0.5076617002487183,
-0.26430895924568176,
0.19725142419338226,
-0.009724458679556847,
-0.4963825047016144,
-0.14591528475284576,
0.6421527862548828,
-0.12038280069828033,
0.5427454710006714,
0.12929028272628784,
0.15044723451137543,
0.0011770928977057338,
0.6328831315040588,
0.7374316453933716,
0.744413435459137,
-0.0796155333518982,
-0.059140801429748535,
-0.22835572063922882,
-0.29071226716041565,
-0.020439110696315765,
-0.06604596227407455,
-0.280510812997818,
0.2397967427968979,
0.2865351736545563,
1.0717135667800903,
0.12283388525247574,
0.030209161341190338,
0.24907279014587402,
0.28629907965660095,
-0.16438384354114532,
0.058865729719400406,
0.3620861768722534,
-0.21165698766708374,
0.06415857374668121,
0.5613573789596558,
0.613342821598053,
0.21511606872081757,
-0.5849701166152954,
0.22860592603683472,
0.23416770994663239,
-0.1673281341791153,
-0.44011354446411133,
0.7625024318695068,
0.8777490258216858,
-0.4941566586494446,
0.21985222399234772,
0.17171137034893036,
-0.3598714768886566,
0.5438445806503296,
0.523082435131073,
1.2953311204910278,
-0.4167689383029938,
0.11910843849182129,
-0.09299730509519577,
-0.03029993362724781,
0.13604265451431274,
0.07014331221580505,
-0.05932564288377762,
-0.6112677454948425,
-0.3189592957496643,
-0.32748115062713623,
-0.49334490299224854,
-0.1015114039182663,
-0.6686038374900818,
0.2576902210712433,
-0.43236082792282104,
-0.22073683142662048,
-0.046480294317007065,
-0.6762048602104187,
-0.360066682100296,
0.1663476675748825,
0.11600474268198013,
0.6723855137825012,
-0.8550501465797424,
0.6356951594352722,
0.8290064930915833,
-0.12705308198928833,
-0.9141047596931458,
0.3128335475921631,
-0.09267241507768631,
-0.6417515277862549,
0.5573750138282776,
-0.2734202742576599,
-0.34951603412628174,
0.15970635414123535,
-0.5389258861541748,
-0.6911432147026062,
0.8495010733604431,
0.4149964451789856,
-0.42748406529426575,
-0.14809195697307587,
-0.32336610555648804,
0.4827951192855835,
-0.5829430222511292,
0.2805406153202057,
0.2757089138031006,
0.32240059971809387,
0.4808460772037506,
-1.212682843208313,
-0.044228725135326385,
-0.4055596590042114,
0.2337258756160736,
-0.011926235631108284,
-0.6625833511352539,
0.7058407664299011,
0.2126913070678711,
-0.05276297777891159,
0.09140680730342865,
0.8584879040718079,
0.14950355887413025,
0.08607751131057739,
0.5377815365791321,
0.1370738446712494,
0.7866820693016052,
0.0211491696536541,
0.7205826044082642,
-0.2841270864009857,
0.16608278453350067,
0.8028932809829712,
0.16726930439472198,
0.7242266535758972,
0.36433130502700806,
-0.20862935483455658,
0.6816700100898743,
0.25935718417167664,
0.3319571614265442,
0.8338614106178284,
-0.0886792540550232,
-0.3472880721092224,
-0.3374064266681671,
-0.1498769074678421,
-0.6032687425613403,
0.5465329885482788,
0.31408989429473877,
-0.6358863711357117,
0.10568232834339142,
-0.06081532686948776,
0.08886823803186417,
0.10564950853586197,
-0.3024493455886841,
0.8039846420288086,
-0.02841428853571415,
-0.5809770822525024,
0.44271954894065857,
-0.10083350539207458,
0.7391946315765381,
-0.6408316493034363,
-0.04076765105128288,
-0.18584366142749786,
-0.2527962028980255,
-0.215279683470726,
-0.800937831401825,
0.03971723094582558,
-0.4433199167251587,
-0.08657658845186234,
-0.46914777159690857,
0.5819916725158691,
-0.7684397101402283,
-0.33000823855400085,
-0.1750916838645935,
0.43944889307022095,
-0.10614676028490067,
0.08393286168575287,
-0.20948699116706848,
-0.2124478965997696,
0.06296038627624512,
-0.19077688455581665,
0.30916592478752136,
0.6445541977882385,
-0.108885757625103,
0.7186396718025208,
0.41093307733535767,
0.11340197175741196,
0.25540345907211304,
0.11487853527069092,
0.8844669461250305,
-0.1897704303264618,
-0.9462589621543884,
-0.6786041259765625,
0.451632022857666,
-0.1345033496618271,
-0.2590031027793884,
0.686521053314209,
0.16230285167694092,
0.6582231521606445,
-0.39526933431625366,
0.9369285106658936,
0.000868858362082392,
0.15760289132595062,
-0.8024687767028809,
0.8049209713935852,
-0.559289276599884,
0.02942492812871933,
-0.8093727827072144,
-0.8494203090667725,
0.11969995498657227,
0.6683727502822876,
0.0039587486535310745,
0.3214063346385956,
0.5968676805496216,
0.7450262308120728,
-0.026571065187454224,
0.24434690177440643,
0.23697133362293243,
0.004518407862633467,
0.31524205207824707,
0.3044773042201996,
0.6906241178512573,
0.13786567747592926,
0.36551034450531006,
-0.5377315282821655,
-0.27204567193984985,
-0.2909814417362213,
-0.7458403706550598,
-0.5697951912879944,
-0.6458163261413574,
-0.4308205246925354,
-0.043136779218912125,
0.06474056839942932,
1.198251485824585,
1.0762231349945068,
-0.7308734655380249,
-0.13926436007022858,
0.18390211462974548,
-0.1701936274766922,
-0.37578457593917847,
-0.22174833714962006,
0.1588258296251297,
0.007651174440979958,
-1.2318611145019531,
0.8203324675559998,
0.254732221364975,
0.036544572561979294,
-0.27335861325263977,
0.19739241898059845,
0.3481721580028534,
0.32368966937065125,
0.5887750387191772,
-0.010704663582146168,
-0.7597162127494812,
-0.30285125970840454,
-0.07801727950572968,
0.0304973553866148,
0.048353828489780426,
1.0466256141662598,
-0.4620940089225769,
0.7829717993736267,
0.8932974934577942,
0.6971258521080017,
0.17389294505119324,
0.15991948544979095,
0.8159991502761841,
-1.159371018409729,
0.029677871614694595,
0.3058858811855316,
0.4158202111721039,
0.10536589473485947,
-0.22257092595100403,
0.40531349182128906,
0.5485715270042419,
-0.397046834230423,
-0.35439687967300415,
0.20232221484184265,
-1.3564541339874268,
-0.24594472348690033,
1.2793861627578735,
0.005320684984326363,
-0.0671466663479805,
0.10822072625160217,
-0.49620091915130615,
0.16460935771465302,
-0.9082120656967163,
0.7480032444000244,
0.7853881120681763,
-0.28157639503479004,
-0.03678254038095474,
-0.3044964075088501,
0.2598607838153839,
0.3557007312774658,
-0.6510733366012573,
-0.262501984834671,
0.5718675851821899,
0.3824115991592407,
0.3138248324394226,
0.5272143483161926,
0.14325526356697083,
0.0344037190079689,
-0.01763649471104145,
-0.01727442443370819,
-0.5302983522415161,
-0.43324729800224304,
0.0631488487124443,
0.24297592043876648,
-0.1716381162405014,
-0.35176628828048706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00047v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00047v1
|
One Queue Is All You Need: Resolving Head-of-Line Blocking in Large Language Model Serving
| 2024-06-05T21:17:34 | 2024-06-05T21:17:34 |
Archit Patke, Dhemath Reddy, Saurabh Jha, Haoran Qiu, Christian Pinto, Shengkun Cui, Chandra Narayanaswami, Zbigniew Kalbarczyk, Ravishankar Iyer
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
$ $Large language models (LLMs) have become an increasingly important
workload for cloud providers catering to both enterprise and consumer
applications. LLM inference requests from these applications have end-to-end
latency SLOs that must be adhered to in production settings. However, existing
LLM serving systems focus on optimization objectives such as request serving
throughput or request execution latency rather than the end-to-end latency
SLOs. Achieving end-to-end SLOs for latency-sensitive requests is challenging
due to head-of-line (HOL) blocking in the request queue, which results from
bursty arrival rates and insufficient resources.
To address the above challenge, we propose QLM, a multi-model queue
management framework for LLM serving. QLM uses stochastic programming to
orchestrate the actions of multiple LLM Serving Operations (LSOs) to reduce HOL
blocking and maximize SLO attainment. Specifically, QLM uses the following
LSOs: model swapping, request eviction, GPU-CPU state swapping, load balancing,
and warm model start. Evaluation on heterogeneous GPU devices and models with
real-world LLM serving dataset shows that QLM improves SLO attainment by 40-90%
and throughput by 20-400% while maintaining or improving device utilization
compared to other state-of-the-art LLM serving systems.
|
[
-0.5261419415473938,
-0.9499841332435608,
0.7358947396278381,
0.27534011006355286,
-0.28651154041290283,
0.20855006575584412,
0.24798205494880676,
-0.5089609622955322,
0.033611346036195755,
1.1540437936782837,
-0.6174697875976562,
0.016362346708774567,
-0.2522035837173462,
-0.329348623752594,
-0.41267287731170654,
0.6697857975959778,
0.34442028403282166,
0.01824359968304634,
-0.21321484446525574,
0.030249416828155518,
-0.3710504174232483,
-0.6325705647468567,
-1.127543568611145,
-0.13809747993946075,
0.5537044405937195,
0.3704541027545929,
1.1929892301559448,
0.6705701351165771,
0.3922063708305359,
0.23611615598201752,
-0.02742682211101055,
0.3195904493331909,
-0.5355657935142517,
0.6045195460319519,
0.06861218065023422,
-0.2015899121761322,
-0.7404777407646179,
-0.4040611684322357,
0.90439772605896,
0.4558078348636627,
-0.45988914370536804,
0.07231972366571426,
-0.0826568678021431,
0.6394246220588684,
-0.7331174612045288,
-0.5018142461776733,
-0.7325120568275452,
0.08175458014011383,
-0.38051676750183105,
0.13196375966072083,
-0.5198953151702881,
-0.08479459583759308,
0.052885111421346664,
-0.52420574426651,
-0.14134481549263,
0.43056628108024597,
0.8263105154037476,
0.4132864773273468,
-0.1614246517419815,
0.2581786513328552,
-0.5929601788520813,
0.8310846090316772,
-1.1512857675552368,
0.6197416186332703,
0.40319883823394775,
0.48077183961868286,
-0.14636889100074768,
-0.590619683265686,
-0.39446985721588135,
0.11208216100931168,
0.05097345635294914,
-0.06791417300701141,
0.03149225190281868,
0.06900007277727127,
0.364046573638916,
0.3707493543624878,
-0.6913967728614807,
0.455750435590744,
-0.16601966321468353,
0.011111419647932053,
0.661027193069458,
0.4222950339317322,
0.15521088242530823,
0.44178131222724915,
-0.3541877865791321,
0.33641180396080017,
-0.7327889800071716,
0.08416067808866501,
0.09029172360897064,
0.31113845109939575,
-0.04645468294620514,
0.34144124388694763,
-0.12825243175029755,
1.0321236848831177,
-0.08182407170534134,
-0.07850039750337601,
-0.2758932113647461,
-0.12276614457368851,
-0.45304298400878906,
-0.3104839026927948,
0.7383806705474854,
0.07603786140680313,
-0.20007169246673584,
-0.38986778259277344,
-0.5547981858253479,
-0.359442800283432,
0.3091558814048767,
-0.8127034306526184,
0.2100924700498581,
0.36750513315200806,
-0.14994430541992188,
-0.07610110193490982,
-0.1974479705095291,
-0.8635189533233643,
-0.5372206568717957,
-0.11212296783924103,
0.11447346955537796,
0.058542244136333466,
-0.2924051582813263,
-0.007801746483892202,
0.33950912952423096,
0.2919085919857025,
0.24384893476963043,
-0.7620047926902771,
0.5761972665786743,
0.5653531551361084,
1.157142162322998,
-0.22875694930553436,
-0.3019688129425049,
-1.192452073097229,
0.152432382106781,
-0.3458632826805115,
0.6211842894554138,
-0.4819185733795166,
-0.32723796367645264,
0.15672728419303894,
-0.03066231682896614,
-0.11934937536716461,
-0.526420533657074,
0.5637628436088562,
-0.8460188508033752,
-0.019632164388895035,
-0.00879910122603178,
-0.49346286058425903,
0.29787617921829224,
0.07901769131422043,
-0.8652188777923584,
1.075792670249939,
0.08320587873458862,
-0.271241158246994,
-0.14668501913547516,
-0.43533918261528015,
-0.4442415237426758,
0.39121270179748535,
-0.04906788468360901,
-0.6314705014228821,
0.1430412381887436,
0.11716675013303757,
0.5529109835624695,
-0.6538977026939392,
0.23294521868228912,
-0.4995899498462677,
-0.17876365780830383,
0.14384496212005615,
-0.02392604760825634,
0.5978625416755676,
0.497151643037796,
0.044190045446157455,
0.5284841656684875,
-0.6124692559242249,
0.24755506217479706,
0.024671422317624092,
-0.22947223484516144,
-0.044050298631191254,
0.355674684047699,
0.2696896195411682,
0.610532820224762,
0.15834639966487885,
-0.40020832419395447,
0.2458343803882599,
-0.24394188821315765,
0.8155840635299683,
0.6183954477310181,
-0.39885231852531433,
0.28694045543670654,
-0.4839659631252289,
0.7073163986206055,
-0.13951191306114197,
0.6144663691520691,
-0.18416015803813934,
-0.46245262026786804,
-0.6767880320549011,
-0.357194185256958,
-0.33244532346725464,
0.3158951699733734,
-0.7179137468338013,
-0.03643931820988655,
0.18397074937820435,
-0.3361959755420685,
-0.9538321495056152,
0.06346670538187027,
0.35226142406463623,
0.4967440366744995,
0.33348241448402405,
0.05428885668516159,
-0.5109848380088806,
-1.0272160768508911,
0.18350562453269958,
0.09513042867183685,
0.18059708178043365,
0.34608879685401917,
-0.11637436598539352,
-0.15358544886112213,
0.8403500914573669,
-0.34213757514953613,
-0.25214555859565735,
0.06967723369598389,
-0.234074667096138,
0.45052552223205566,
0.28862476348876953,
0.38603195548057556,
-0.8266134262084961,
-0.6499393582344055,
0.10649766772985458,
-0.46522530913352966,
-0.3094947934150696,
-0.03285277262330055,
-0.5028602480888367,
0.3963952958583832,
0.3109947443008423,
-0.3476920425891876,
0.04642019793391228,
0.9193344116210938,
-0.3996548056602478,
0.7561773657798767,
-0.269300639629364,
-0.02980591170489788,
-0.5766952037811279,
-0.07486416399478912,
-0.23527321219444275,
-0.5235686898231506,
-0.9976053833961487,
0.3813183605670929,
-0.04354683309793472,
-0.4728900194168091,
-0.6339572668075562,
0.6760632395744324,
-0.43656080961227417,
-0.5169394612312317,
-0.3464573621749878,
0.006813826505094767,
0.38433003425598145,
0.37861356139183044,
-0.09823045134544373,
0.9844197630882263,
0.8112679123878479,
-0.9458264708518982,
0.3613719046115875,
-0.07224731892347336,
0.03999588266015053,
0.53983473777771,
-0.806345522403717,
0.36990615725517273,
-0.05994388088583946,
-0.03766439110040665,
-1.0252982378005981,
0.253010094165802,
0.19688324630260468,
0.20871573686599731,
-0.13767006993293762,
-0.2386663556098938,
-0.36837512254714966,
-0.5398158431053162,
0.11712184548377991,
0.3835911452770233,
0.4242790639400482,
-0.4179104268550873,
0.7369665503501892,
0.6121361255645752,
0.00814070925116539,
-0.5173174738883972,
-0.517082154750824,
0.019452162086963654,
-0.16610577702522278,
-0.6837967038154602,
0.574229896068573,
-0.36103951930999756,
-0.18687300384044647,
-0.24701644480228424,
0.06016248092055321,
-0.5095347762107849,
0.3908728361129761,
0.40281781554222107,
0.43412983417510986,
-0.12064803391695023,
-0.08123835176229477,
-0.23294344544410706,
0.1998404860496521,
0.014952145516872406,
-0.6840886473655701,
0.9197934865951538,
0.04569012299180031,
-0.5478768944740295,
-0.3785174787044525,
0.5605725049972534,
1.207149624824524,
-0.3245046138763428,
0.7262133955955505,
0.5963578224182129,
-0.4416434168815613,
-0.0558745376765728,
-0.7281944751739502,
-0.034084007143974304,
-0.39700281620025635,
0.3553674817085266,
-0.6762765645980835,
-0.9007072448730469,
0.6574665307998657,
0.4987502694129944,
0.5443156957626343,
0.10273021459579468,
0.4768950343132019,
-0.08666866272687912,
1.0716606378555298,
0.5359538793563843,
-0.1899605095386505,
0.46508896350860596,
0.06678615510463715,
0.23468229174613953,
-0.8556270599365234,
-0.0033883138094097376,
-0.29466512799263,
0.04702504351735115,
-0.2044665664434433,
-0.5467748641967773,
0.3032554090023041,
0.3275110721588135,
-0.4137231111526489,
0.027381403371691704,
-0.3794236183166504,
0.22468307614326477,
0.2534434497356415,
0.2122926115989685,
0.5446382761001587,
0.014659618027508259,
-0.10500414669513702,
0.06096813827753067,
-0.8306905627250671,
-0.4264020621776581,
0.6194618344306946,
0.49886447191238403,
0.5449908375740051,
0.4042501747608185,
0.19066108763217926,
0.4715214669704437,
0.25091832876205444,
-0.5847641825675964,
0.5250768661499023,
-0.204228475689888,
-0.5385878682136536,
-0.775483250617981,
-0.33221107721328735,
-0.6709456443786621,
0.7864680886268616,
-0.15635548532009125,
-0.6231462955474854,
-0.18245643377304077,
0.2735627293586731,
-0.6736388802528381,
0.5420948266983032,
-0.2138829082250595,
0.6644872426986694,
-0.5365996360778809,
-0.9853768348693848,
-0.32657986879348755,
-0.3348306715488434,
0.4777471125125885,
-0.11023403704166412,
0.38273271918296814,
-0.3788706958293915,
0.1267591416835785,
0.5339062809944153,
-0.5952280163764954,
0.549707293510437,
-0.06699305027723312,
-0.33148065209388733,
0.27076980471611023,
0.009912564419209957,
0.9591647386550903,
-0.006682735402137041,
-0.29392382502555847,
0.01411297544836998,
0.021923258900642395,
-0.6477610468864441,
-0.3529617488384247,
0.6365906596183777,
-0.7059465646743774,
-0.629055917263031,
-0.21630264818668365,
-0.5935616493225098,
-0.1650402694940567,
0.1986035853624344,
-0.03943540155887604,
0.24217697978019714,
-0.08185672760009766,
-0.27728450298309326,
0.5245267152786255,
-0.12525108456611633,
0.6433851718902588,
0.6168642044067383,
-0.843360960483551,
-0.04855364188551903,
0.6155824661254883,
-0.029644735157489777,
0.6053972840309143,
0.22143961489200592,
0.042131613940000534,
-0.43837770819664,
-0.6317526698112488,
-0.8523808717727661,
0.29992538690567017,
-0.3003831207752228,
0.014447357505559921,
-0.8114827275276184,
-0.46824249625205994,
-0.3874377906322479,
-0.043774280697107315,
-0.6661719083786011,
0.10923291742801666,
-0.22506338357925415,
0.4343121349811554,
0.33575132489204407,
0.5151028633117676,
0.33730900287628174,
0.8810065388679504,
-0.6921163201332092,
0.26313719153404236,
0.34289297461509705,
0.44693633913993835,
0.34245991706848145,
-0.7515147924423218,
-0.4585731327533722,
-0.0465475395321846,
-0.20998814702033997,
-0.6809481382369995,
0.802410900592804,
0.10628058016300201,
0.5869241952896118,
0.6446917653083801,
0.01040392741560936,
0.9736911058425903,
-0.6777095794677734,
0.477064311504364,
0.35431331396102905,
-0.9145582914352417,
0.2085794061422348,
-0.2627016305923462,
0.2608836591243744,
0.14352470636367798,
0.43922966718673706,
-0.8937017321586609,
-0.26805579662323,
-0.2200007289648056,
-0.9604725241661072,
0.6578775644302368,
-0.23208087682724,
-0.2938891053199768,
0.2452852874994278,
0.22527389228343964,
-0.1049366146326065,
0.44271737337112427,
-0.5112684965133667,
-0.1341308057308197,
0.05255144089460373,
0.3773655891418457,
0.06162145361304283,
-0.3518279492855072,
-0.03261496499180794,
0.18761347234249115,
0.6387633085250854,
-0.2023976594209671,
0.07575708627700806,
-0.07737226784229279,
-0.18274278938770294,
-0.19899022579193115,
0.32540616393089294,
0.5737680196762085,
1.0079481601715088,
-0.19961731135845184,
0.12360519170761108,
0.014079347252845764,
-0.02016015723347664,
0.019034814089536667,
-0.02650846168398857,
-0.3599567115306854,
-0.11690524965524673,
-0.16062182188034058,
1.0362128019332886,
0.15727122128009796,
-0.8979085087776184,
0.04874381795525551,
0.06284886598587036,
0.10188756138086319,
-0.29886767268180847,
-0.05493722856044769,
0.11193345487117767,
0.25936102867126465,
0.41578027606010437,
-0.4327947497367859,
-0.005228255409747362,
-0.3534863591194153,
0.16763651371002197,
0.6834086775779724,
-0.3562868535518646,
-0.020869914442300797,
0.7575548887252808,
0.06123451888561249,
-0.44844019412994385,
0.7470098733901978,
-0.047965675592422485,
-0.5147254467010498,
0.45283177495002747,
0.6296912431716919,
0.5767024159431458,
-0.3824051022529602,
0.21068857610225677,
0.1868765503168106,
-0.051621343940496445,
-0.29148203134536743,
0.29005667567253113,
0.26172617077827454,
-0.7227061986923218,
-0.6450613141059875,
-0.7349094748497009,
-0.5529809594154358,
0.3481610119342804,
-0.6855871677398682,
0.17229607701301575,
-0.6802620887756348,
-0.3526850938796997,
-0.19505658745765686,
-0.2061878740787506,
-0.6891316771507263,
-0.11602867394685745,
0.3788078725337982,
0.48285534977912903,
-0.7906876802444458,
1.006914496421814,
0.6184433698654175,
-0.19842176139354706,
-0.3371683657169342,
-0.6694751381874084,
-0.14859947562217712,
-0.898399293422699,
0.6012368202209473,
-0.27082711458206177,
-0.17061899602413177,
0.33139535784721375,
-0.12314485758543015,
-1.0594371557235718,
0.9022371768951416,
0.030330779030919075,
-1.3158025741577148,
-0.13046468794345856,
0.09520821273326874,
0.1645640730857849,
-0.7592967748641968,
0.6074568629264832,
0.4335944950580597,
0.41781556606292725,
0.05211528390645981,
-0.8404623866081238,
0.14285701513290405,
0.20370373129844666,
0.15172076225280762,
0.14845535159111023,
-0.8619410395622253,
1.1123281717300415,
-0.20287959277629852,
-0.25978872179985046,
0.01668541133403778,
0.5663022994995117,
0.6900425553321838,
0.2777882218360901,
0.751577615737915,
0.5020356178283691,
0.9936703443527222,
0.15945568680763245,
0.9162232279777527,
-0.4303712248802185,
0.21522122621536255,
1.133514165878296,
-0.7364009618759155,
0.8508864641189575,
0.7388020157814026,
-0.266960084438324,
-0.08511272817850113,
0.7845770716667175,
0.20804397761821747,
0.3855844736099243,
0.49961185455322266,
-0.24525997042655945,
-0.3845628798007965,
-0.4307363033294678,
-0.33455055952072144,
-0.11618367582559586,
0.27383819222450256,
-0.02057001180946827,
-0.14015674591064453,
0.20054759085178375,
0.05178562551736832,
-0.08693725615739822,
-0.6347349882125854,
0.32695847749710083,
0.10268109291791916,
-0.7663491368293762,
0.8623108863830566,
-0.07620129734277725,
0.6574885845184326,
-0.47167959809303284,
0.16151149570941925,
-0.327530175447464,
-0.02636702172458172,
-0.1447630673646927,
-0.4269814193248749,
0.24692387878894806,
-0.12259217351675034,
-0.4884418249130249,
-0.3878767490386963,
0.43646448850631714,
-0.4549262821674347,
-0.28477853536605835,
0.551947832107544,
0.8135512471199036,
0.2556978166103363,
-0.2827865481376648,
-0.7374217510223389,
0.3987853229045868,
-0.2532842755317688,
0.0019119534408673644,
0.5588051080703735,
0.09861418604850769,
-0.15359090268611908,
1.0763975381851196,
0.8101053833961487,
0.2562103271484375,
0.4658803641796112,
0.44859397411346436,
0.820075273513794,
-0.47969475388526917,
-0.637713611125946,
-0.9078959822654724,
0.32222363352775574,
-0.05986948311328888,
-0.21529418230056763,
0.42393502593040466,
0.4784872829914093,
0.4359070062637329,
0.0717720240354538,
0.7081630825996399,
0.1946091204881668,
0.27507197856903076,
-0.641334593296051,
0.5463232398033142,
-0.6363758444786072,
0.39563000202178955,
0.11387722194194794,
-0.8154808282852173,
-0.12787963449954987,
0.5239149928092957,
-0.07499678432941437,
-0.40544015169143677,
0.4481731653213501,
0.7662829756736755,
0.10554198175668716,
-0.18799971044063568,
0.9037389755249023,
0.17263369262218475,
0.3881149888038635,
0.7495946884155273,
1.0579121112823486,
-0.368063360452652,
0.2409059852361679,
-0.09054823219776154,
-0.08440320193767548,
-0.41644716262817383,
-0.7401966452598572,
-0.5658174157142639,
-0.40940287709236145,
-0.3759303689002991,
-0.5160074830055237,
0.5224459171295166,
0.7601059079170227,
0.9908934235572815,
-0.7069479823112488,
-0.6612429022789001,
0.0534684881567955,
0.24310468137264252,
-0.6381179094314575,
-0.19125640392303467,
0.14220991730690002,
-0.5324257016181946,
-0.6822696328163147,
0.3474455773830414,
0.2871848940849304,
-0.08473186194896698,
-0.6066101789474487,
-0.3093109726905823,
-0.35670676827430725,
-0.15294015407562256,
0.7569252848625183,
0.39102381467819214,
-0.8957901000976562,
0.12380267679691315,
0.14268215000629425,
-0.3978005349636078,
0.19372007250785828,
0.9209322333335876,
-0.5629923343658447,
0.05358168110251427,
0.3015376031398773,
0.9895028471946716,
0.7512956857681274,
-0.08050379157066345,
0.39338213205337524,
-0.44085392355918884,
0.09314156323671341,
0.3147823214530945,
0.4319070875644684,
0.10270664840936661,
-0.47289958596229553,
0.30610692501068115,
0.06498094648122787,
-0.8128017783164978,
-0.9525244235992432,
0.5509931445121765,
-0.9385984539985657,
-0.3371392786502838,
0.8770287036895752,
-0.07191839814186096,
-0.15186895430088043,
-0.3888144791126251,
0.1381736844778061,
0.0308065265417099,
-0.5814359188079834,
0.45962148904800415,
0.6500539183616638,
-0.27655789256095886,
-0.849342942237854,
-1.1455942392349243,
0.2579199969768524,
0.6708549857139587,
-0.780922532081604,
0.2876756489276886,
0.560319721698761,
-0.1214137002825737,
-0.09873247891664505,
0.7991135716438293,
0.12255655974149704,
-0.20404650270938873,
-0.5130900740623474,
0.1419541835784912,
-0.12119732797145844,
-0.3758339583873749,
-0.2324734479188919,
0.2529540956020355,
0.2269129604101181,
-0.22630709409713745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03618v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03618v1
|
TACT: Advancing Complex Aggregative Reasoning with Information Extraction Tools
| 2024-06-05T20:32:56 | 2024-06-05T20:32:56 |
Avi Caciularu, Alon Jacovi, Eyal Ben-David, Sasha Goldshtein, Tal Schuster, Jonathan Herzig, Gal Elidan, Amir Globerson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) often do not perform well on queries that
require the aggregation of information across texts. To better evaluate this
setting and facilitate modeling efforts, we introduce TACT - Text And
Calculations through Tables, a dataset crafted to evaluate LLMs' reasoning and
computational abilities using complex instructions. TACT contains challenging
instructions that demand stitching information scattered across one or more
texts, and performing complex integration on this information to generate the
answer. We construct this dataset by leveraging an existing dataset of texts
and their associated tables. For each such tables, we formulate new queries,
and gather their respective answers. We demonstrate that all contemporary LLMs
perform poorly on this dataset, achieving an accuracy below 38\%. To pinpoint
the difficulties and thoroughly dissect the problem, we analyze model
performance across three components: table-generation, Pandas
command-generation, and execution. Unexpectedly, we discover that each
component presents substantial challenges for current LLMs. These insights lead
us to propose a focused modeling framework, which we refer to as IE as a tool.
Specifically, we propose to add "tools" for each of the above steps, and
implement each such tool with few-shot prompting. This approach shows an
improvement over existing prompting techniques, offering a promising direction
for enhancing model capabilities in these tasks.
|
[
-0.17574205994606018,
-1.4389559030532837,
0.8483256101608276,
0.06175701692700386,
-0.1112748384475708,
0.11046840995550156,
-0.09172903001308441,
-0.4068754315376282,
-0.21983866393566132,
0.40849176049232483,
-0.485921710729599,
-0.4511648118495941,
-0.630587100982666,
0.01492915116250515,
-0.6015172600746155,
0.8238901495933533,
-0.12268096208572388,
-0.048996031284332275,
-0.10573431849479675,
0.1287207454442978,
-0.29245713353157043,
-0.36293452978134155,
-0.5119912028312683,
-0.3826097846031189,
0.3708339333534241,
0.7690199613571167,
0.6121306419372559,
0.7347772717475891,
0.538111686706543,
0.2872985303401947,
-0.08065052330493927,
0.3916771411895752,
-0.3233201801776886,
0.2555081844329834,
-0.2944585382938385,
-0.4214589297771454,
-0.3606424331665039,
-0.034893784672021866,
0.693649172782898,
0.8228718042373657,
-0.14655755460262299,
0.176894873380661,
0.039280034601688385,
0.42454373836517334,
-0.5449658036231995,
0.110527403652668,
-0.6820727586746216,
-0.009719692170619965,
-0.20510369539260864,
-0.08747199177742004,
-0.5146476030349731,
-0.44794660806655884,
0.31434908509254456,
-0.6208029389381409,
-0.22879448533058167,
-0.02717515081167221,
0.9435086250305176,
0.12773072719573975,
-0.6354554295539856,
-0.2780550420284271,
-0.6735280156135559,
0.8494628667831421,
-0.5749950408935547,
0.3776029944419861,
0.1884242296218872,
0.26878002285957336,
-0.4961070418357849,
-0.9391284584999084,
-0.7382097244262695,
-0.2917832136154175,
0.16889947652816772,
-0.13574635982513428,
-0.31122055649757385,
0.06623972952365875,
0.4766521751880646,
0.2860966920852661,
-0.4004432260990143,
0.15198132395744324,
-0.11343437433242798,
-0.05537855997681618,
0.27452751994132996,
0.4849662780761719,
0.37204039096832275,
-0.033687524497509,
-0.5161060094833374,
-0.09506341069936752,
-0.7158200740814209,
0.19591498374938965,
0.13682861626148224,
0.42392000555992126,
-0.057985421270132065,
0.9183298349380493,
0.006916912738233805,
0.8724772930145264,
-0.17504626512527466,
-0.1902773380279541,
-0.09400049597024918,
-0.2515965700149536,
-0.3289003372192383,
-0.2235303819179535,
0.7239224910736084,
0.2056257575750351,
0.5449179410934448,
-0.08423160761594772,
-0.3513493835926056,
-0.015165385790169239,
0.005040299147367477,
-0.8063454031944275,
-0.2193487137556076,
0.3550770580768585,
-0.08224372565746307,
-0.255035400390625,
0.08069244027137756,
-0.5947489738464355,
-0.5192641615867615,
-0.39069628715515137,
0.5087763667106628,
-0.5629482269287109,
-0.2616894543170929,
0.12908171117305756,
-0.3496827781200409,
0.2544977068901062,
0.7343128323554993,
-0.571951150894165,
0.4352852404117584,
0.7655557990074158,
0.8691860437393188,
-0.3929935395717621,
-0.3043120801448822,
-0.9593871235847473,
0.32497167587280273,
-0.2213340401649475,
0.883851945400238,
-0.9007923603057861,
-0.303987056016922,
-0.0001259310229215771,
-0.09794866293668747,
0.2005232274532318,
-0.4837280809879303,
0.557711124420166,
-0.20510423183441162,
0.27378761768341064,
-0.5605282187461853,
-0.6392303705215454,
-0.19304680824279785,
0.3790951371192932,
-0.7682546377182007,
1.2251183986663818,
0.349344402551651,
-0.6880659461021423,
0.38624536991119385,
-0.8533154129981995,
-0.6696113348007202,
0.23957626521587372,
-0.2759189009666443,
-0.22242943942546844,
-0.09331879019737244,
0.15413162112236023,
0.755209743976593,
-0.6569379568099976,
0.38872140645980835,
-0.4429100751876831,
-0.24848943948745728,
0.11138276755809784,
-0.22238634526729584,
0.7808148860931396,
0.35713592171669006,
-0.24734200537204742,
0.1574842482805252,
-0.7310329079627991,
0.09469550848007202,
0.14799188077449799,
-0.5052688717842102,
-0.3230947256088257,
0.055817652493715286,
0.07587086409330368,
0.023387989029288292,
0.21212349832057953,
-0.3315541446208954,
0.5037452578544617,
-0.14519231021404266,
0.6455236673355103,
0.6756078600883484,
0.06519170105457306,
0.49617984890937805,
-0.046066854149103165,
0.5546919703483582,
0.15370771288871765,
0.09251224249601364,
-0.15351466834545135,
-0.34264683723449707,
-0.6337624788284302,
-0.20193366706371307,
0.13664504885673523,
0.5575390458106995,
-1.0142792463302612,
0.24469289183616638,
-0.1725701093673706,
-0.623881995677948,
-0.36099159717559814,
-0.026811126619577408,
0.3465867042541504,
0.9691988825798035,
0.36142396926879883,
-0.02570604719221592,
-0.3368261456489563,
-0.8927677869796753,
-0.40857452154159546,
-0.33009007573127747,
0.08623441308736801,
0.07229731976985931,
0.4504343271255493,
0.07912720739841461,
0.8134138584136963,
-0.4457385540008545,
0.032959844917058945,
-0.38637351989746094,
0.40376371145248413,
0.06699895858764648,
0.41623491048812866,
0.3777463734149933,
-0.6056420803070068,
-0.3036065399646759,
0.253968209028244,
-0.8419353365898132,
-0.2806602120399475,
-0.1408414989709854,
-0.09653425216674805,
-0.04174723103642464,
0.48355022072792053,
-0.501526415348053,
0.3131937086582184,
0.089561827480793,
-0.506258487701416,
0.7595849633216858,
0.24759700894355774,
0.21322934329509735,
-0.8788337707519531,
0.2375320941209793,
0.3812194764614105,
-0.34419378638267517,
-0.8077356219291687,
0.3968096077442169,
0.035167086869478226,
0.05593768134713173,
-0.5549589395523071,
0.761353075504303,
-0.5674193501472473,
0.19650596380233765,
0.05649130418896675,
-0.046302758157253265,
0.3610248863697052,
0.18645259737968445,
-0.02641674503684044,
1.1815277338027954,
0.2819066047668457,
-0.7215763330459595,
0.32068806886672974,
0.04169575124979019,
-0.4986799955368042,
0.4430760443210602,
-0.6928614974021912,
0.1290624588727951,
0.2851203978061676,
-0.30551794171333313,
-0.8669732809066772,
-0.3186320960521698,
-0.03049773909151554,
-0.2281409353017807,
0.38305211067199707,
-0.06465408951044083,
-0.6160219311714172,
-0.21097882091999054,
-0.3220352530479431,
0.0804179310798645,
0.12232695519924164,
-0.4657067060470581,
0.8886237740516663,
0.6765595078468323,
-0.3261718153953552,
-0.8386943340301514,
-0.6948460340499878,
0.25107067823410034,
-0.31859728693962097,
-0.6881641149520874,
0.0528411790728569,
0.09067662060260773,
-0.6995618939399719,
-0.07755523920059204,
-0.00728788785636425,
-0.29224684834480286,
0.3605254888534546,
-0.08893725275993347,
0.17874428629875183,
-0.048771556466817856,
0.348387211561203,
0.15450410544872284,
0.2580362558364868,
0.23514392971992493,
-0.09859868139028549,
0.5444881319999695,
-0.35896387696266174,
-0.22011415660381317,
-0.2961162328720093,
0.516248881816864,
0.6275159120559692,
-0.32007020711898804,
0.5121375322341919,
0.6266103386878967,
-0.40125927329063416,
-0.32567548751831055,
-0.822887659072876,
-0.22424787282943726,
-0.47227007150650024,
0.5420233011245728,
-0.7459841966629028,
-0.9285239577293396,
0.7897304892539978,
-0.3092631995677948,
0.13554011285305023,
0.3105347454547882,
0.6710871458053589,
0.06113153323531151,
0.9550151824951172,
0.6280308961868286,
0.17055946588516235,
0.6568863987922668,
-0.13336355984210968,
-0.05823235586285591,
-0.4915241301059723,
-0.4473216235637665,
-0.5783389806747437,
0.0174527820199728,
-0.03872651979327202,
-0.1462976336479187,
0.46198633313179016,
-0.05144428089261055,
-0.4624922275543213,
0.18270863592624664,
-0.5656498670578003,
0.5833500623703003,
0.6509899497032166,
0.09112708270549774,
0.37222880125045776,
0.0683717355132103,
-0.18738201260566711,
0.038958217948675156,
-0.6649808883666992,
-0.7103597521781921,
0.861056387424469,
0.40150612592697144,
1.0253965854644775,
0.10041869431734085,
0.3871955871582031,
0.27534472942352295,
0.023336512967944145,
-1.1059472560882568,
0.6533451080322266,
-0.06095751002430916,
-0.42678213119506836,
-0.36664247512817383,
-0.5309280753135681,
-0.7634313702583313,
-0.050681162625551224,
-0.3160271942615509,
-0.7109633088111877,
0.19637557864189148,
0.014729573391377926,
-0.2753158211708069,
0.23224173486232758,
-1.3760918378829956,
0.9013116359710693,
-0.055352628231048584,
-0.7965995669364929,
0.2844521105289459,
-0.6038735508918762,
0.5838339924812317,
-0.07644078135490417,
0.04263753816485405,
0.040877629071474075,
-0.1128246933221817,
0.7056429386138916,
-0.6963335275650024,
0.5728272795677185,
-0.197517991065979,
-0.22757458686828613,
0.5455431342124939,
0.5998370051383972,
0.7794954180717468,
-0.36599960923194885,
-0.35605818033218384,
-0.24157634377479553,
0.1464000791311264,
-0.15001025795936584,
-0.6868922710418701,
0.5786548852920532,
-0.6502352952957153,
-0.7024880051612854,
-0.18342599272727966,
-0.5185759663581848,
-0.10038893669843674,
0.2791682779788971,
-0.026691369712352753,
0.3486194610595703,
-0.021695293486118317,
0.003645131131634116,
0.5126024484634399,
0.10380030423402786,
0.48790407180786133,
0.394035667181015,
-0.03847891837358475,
-0.1805913746356964,
0.7856881618499756,
0.34055763483047485,
0.22192884981632233,
0.2661625146865845,
0.23460237681865692,
-0.4689699411392212,
-0.46410876512527466,
-0.396961510181427,
-0.02065218798816204,
-0.8647798299789429,
-0.3632887005805969,
-0.6450648307800293,
0.10173481702804565,
-0.24047888815402985,
0.08214583992958069,
-0.07652909308671951,
-0.6638715863227844,
-0.4085000157356262,
-0.16203415393829346,
0.5436621308326721,
0.9568058252334595,
0.33473920822143555,
0.5039745569229126,
-0.854961633682251,
0.14975647628307343,
0.37278687953948975,
0.26160553097724915,
0.08304213732481003,
-0.4473770260810852,
-0.2567049562931061,
-0.32098570466041565,
-0.10972052067518234,
-1.1181529760360718,
0.3226618766784668,
0.1809648722410202,
0.4422619640827179,
0.32442882657051086,
0.056444715708494186,
0.9248338341712952,
-0.5693582892417908,
0.8104457259178162,
0.07524122297763824,
-1.2839494943618774,
0.6485329866409302,
-0.3024453818798065,
0.1445699781179428,
0.6319241523742676,
0.3466590344905853,
-0.2041264772415161,
-0.2976429760456085,
-0.43867310881614685,
-0.7851225137710571,
0.6094217896461487,
-0.02109835296869278,
-0.37095966935157776,
-0.0453176386654377,
0.5011244416236877,
0.17207881808280945,
0.15853628516197205,
-0.856909453868866,
0.1409435123205185,
0.10766874253749847,
-0.2521166503429413,
0.41985785961151123,
-0.18265514075756073,
-0.21452483534812927,
-0.36957302689552307,
0.3849483132362366,
-0.14198289811611176,
-0.019857145845890045,
0.3188644349575043,
-0.1394140124320984,
-0.18361788988113403,
0.4072076678276062,
0.348374605178833,
0.6395171880722046,
-0.043872617185115814,
0.38541388511657715,
0.11512917280197144,
-0.5743257999420166,
0.04850134626030922,
0.019844915717840195,
0.08523747324943542,
-0.1852516233921051,
0.5145701766014099,
0.45883816480636597,
-0.3151206970214844,
-0.7395962476730347,
0.6673802137374878,
-0.06777475029230118,
-0.02812497317790985,
-0.17614080011844635,
0.14679518342018127,
-0.07534343004226685,
0.3275739550590515,
0.4536919891834259,
-0.2564486861228943,
0.37861013412475586,
-0.6097844839096069,
0.27774620056152344,
0.535996675491333,
-0.28247642517089844,
-0.25381478667259216,
0.6204820275306702,
0.2136661410331726,
-0.2655821442604065,
0.5056212544441223,
-0.2812906503677368,
-0.4238411784172058,
0.5285882353782654,
0.40293946862220764,
0.7673750519752502,
-0.19035914540290833,
-0.07292422652244568,
0.11462830752134323,
0.47770026326179504,
-0.12033522874116898,
0.6859710812568665,
0.03549809381365776,
-0.6254134178161621,
-0.8575746417045593,
-0.25997576117515564,
-0.6872239112854004,
0.2252029925584793,
-0.6130942106246948,
0.5542082190513611,
-0.5753549933433533,
-0.18976609408855438,
0.13242267072200775,
0.09288068860769272,
-0.7315607666969299,
0.11408212035894394,
-0.1703297197818756,
0.9820675253868103,
-1.0745493173599243,
0.8477798700332642,
0.888329803943634,
-0.5105701684951782,
-1.1213207244873047,
-0.311788946390152,
0.03502005711197853,
-0.9939627647399902,
0.5259639024734497,
0.007002884056419134,
-0.26058512926101685,
0.018428465351462364,
-1.1072028875350952,
-0.37293779850006104,
0.825846791267395,
0.5966094732284546,
-0.5005921721458435,
-0.08027122169733047,
0.07184115052223206,
0.29809871315956116,
-0.3393547534942627,
0.5382945537567139,
0.8019095659255981,
0.727989673614502,
0.06546159088611603,
-0.8121023774147034,
0.21994231641292572,
-0.46117886900901794,
-0.4436350464820862,
0.20137403905391693,
-0.3747010827064514,
1.1701751947402954,
-0.309670090675354,
-0.2702147364616394,
-0.2834995985031128,
0.4695516526699066,
0.29220378398895264,
0.19129596650600433,
0.5018329620361328,
0.5266014933586121,
0.8123701214790344,
-0.2590709626674652,
0.941810667514801,
-0.0015906284097582102,
0.040719155222177505,
1.1794471740722656,
-0.49141669273376465,
0.9071839451789856,
0.7508495450019836,
-0.16997376084327698,
0.4508468508720398,
0.6049941182136536,
0.04019184783101082,
0.139135479927063,
0.007450973615050316,
-0.26312148571014404,
-0.520114004611969,
-0.4620780646800995,
-0.2901726961135864,
0.5405630469322205,
0.7088620066642761,
-0.15358899533748627,
-0.30234745144844055,
-0.23666730523109436,
0.11961020529270172,
0.2162150889635086,
-0.1957770437002182,
0.8947030305862427,
-0.00824812799692154,
-0.5673646926879883,
0.4019111096858978,
-0.06266729533672333,
0.2949497401714325,
-0.473053902387619,
-0.5088160037994385,
0.01601426675915718,
-0.15236420929431915,
-0.2725858688354492,
-1.1881988048553467,
0.013130953535437584,
0.18798308074474335,
-0.06875891238451004,
0.11740023642778397,
0.7603598237037659,
-0.3880646228790283,
-0.34842532873153687,
0.14110295474529266,
0.942953884601593,
0.22700819373130798,
-0.13680727779865265,
-0.6764175891876221,
0.15920333564281464,
0.04838510602712631,
-0.3956332206726074,
0.05462805926799774,
1.116659164428711,
-0.15887601673603058,
0.8962523341178894,
0.5769941806793213,
0.23773230612277985,
-0.09696076065301895,
0.2042173445224762,
1.2132046222686768,
-0.8657551407814026,
-0.34509074687957764,
-1.1100660562515259,
0.693856418132782,
-0.14177587628364563,
-0.2465529590845108,
0.43495479226112366,
0.5457828044891357,
0.4851548671722412,
0.06770417839288712,
0.7979376316070557,
0.18558631837368011,
0.6026487350463867,
-0.5754858255386353,
0.4937286376953125,
-0.6645460724830627,
0.47953924536705017,
-0.34019291400909424,
-0.9111493229866028,
-0.4369179606437683,
0.5320053696632385,
-0.27940040826797485,
-0.12239165604114532,
0.640449047088623,
0.6014260649681091,
-0.05960841849446297,
-0.043578166514635086,
0.15066568553447723,
0.2610965371131897,
0.7327266335487366,
0.5371209979057312,
1.0216219425201416,
-0.1788351982831955,
0.5351707339286804,
0.020405365154147148,
-0.2765900790691376,
0.0010559718357399106,
-1.0771615505218506,
-0.9170597791671753,
-0.5628429651260376,
-0.1351400464773178,
-0.30882784724235535,
-0.06674106419086456,
1.0431177616119385,
0.49687767028808594,
-0.5564954876899719,
-0.3499612510204315,
-0.23097437620162964,
0.2716546356678009,
0.11904441565275192,
-0.3241083025932312,
0.3627415597438812,
-0.3912792503833771,
-0.8256402015686035,
0.364671915769577,
0.21681654453277588,
0.25682446360588074,
-0.1756855845451355,
0.23596309125423431,
-0.3771947920322418,
-0.1442520171403885,
0.8100789785385132,
0.1977725327014923,
-0.740972638130188,
-0.4943358302116394,
0.061002302914857864,
-0.03687136620283127,
0.12109815329313278,
0.629452645778656,
-0.7956849336624146,
0.5957181453704834,
0.498102605342865,
0.6433536410331726,
0.41371068358421326,
0.1213483139872551,
0.7161785960197449,
-0.7854368090629578,
0.058963727205991745,
0.44410061836242676,
0.4301581382751465,
0.2929663360118866,
-0.3177659809589386,
0.6952692270278931,
-0.08372855931520462,
-0.5237194895744324,
-1.1808336973190308,
0.26833418011665344,
-1.1607693433761597,
-0.337246835231781,
1.1797431707382202,
-0.16696250438690186,
-0.4271596670150757,
-0.3464832007884979,
-0.24150104820728302,
0.24712654948234558,
-0.7058412432670593,
0.47819268703460693,
0.9233651161193848,
-0.16403383016586304,
-0.1993648260831833,
-0.30138862133026123,
0.30857333540916443,
0.3802313804626465,
-0.9022235870361328,
0.2373552769422531,
0.5393497347831726,
0.07155013829469681,
0.00839720293879509,
0.3353806138038635,
-0.14764058589935303,
0.10424131900072098,
-0.035538822412490845,
0.30343377590179443,
-0.3923083245754242,
-0.47571229934692383,
-0.35416191816329956,
0.4311661720275879,
0.3410950303077698,
0.20636124908924103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03614v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03614v1
|
Advancing Anomaly Detection: Non-Semantic Financial Data Encoding with LLMs
| 2024-06-05T20:19:09 | 2024-06-05T20:19:09 |
Alexander Bakumenko, Kateřina Hlaváčková-Schindler, Claudia Plant, Nina C. Hubig
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, q-fin.RM
|
Detecting anomalies in general ledger data is of utmost importance to ensure
trustworthiness of financial records. Financial audits increasingly rely on
machine learning (ML) algorithms to identify irregular or potentially
fraudulent journal entries, each characterized by a varying number of
transactions. In machine learning, heterogeneity in feature dimensions adds
significant complexity to data analysis. In this paper, we introduce a novel
approach to anomaly detection in financial data using Large Language Models
(LLMs) embeddings. To encode non-semantic categorical data from real-world
financial records, we tested 3 pre-trained general purpose sentence-transformer
models. For the downstream classification task, we implemented and evaluated 5
optimized ML models including Logistic Regression, Random Forest, Gradient
Boosting Machines, Support Vector Machines, and Neural Networks. Our
experiments demonstrate that LLMs contribute valuable information to anomaly
detection as our models outperform the baselines, in selected settings even by
a large margin. The findings further underscore the effectiveness of LLMs in
enhancing anomaly detection in financial journal entries, particularly by
tackling feature sparsity. We discuss a promising perspective on using LLM
embeddings for non-semantic data in the financial context and beyond.
|
[
0.08673121780157089,
-0.945364236831665,
0.3894420564174652,
0.14894144237041473,
-0.14998586475849152,
0.20056724548339844,
0.10305878520011902,
-0.6322651505470276,
0.33648744225502014,
0.8605159521102905,
-0.421866238117218,
-0.8362630605697632,
-0.988413393497467,
-0.04723657667636871,
-0.7626657485961914,
1.2562289237976074,
0.05075378343462944,
0.029963094741106033,
-0.19282230734825134,
0.008489487692713737,
-0.11017211526632309,
-0.7254929542541504,
-0.505119800567627,
-0.06495852768421173,
0.1797545701265335,
0.0024526487104594707,
0.5396003723144531,
0.7155330181121826,
0.682026207447052,
0.2786068022251129,
0.20018033683300018,
0.5249103307723999,
-0.3017292022705078,
-0.17898045480251312,
0.11731511354446411,
-0.6029365658760071,
-0.6595314145088196,
-0.24141687154769897,
0.6056452989578247,
0.5015063881874084,
-0.14677433669567108,
-0.02682396024465561,
0.01872900314629078,
0.7609238028526306,
-0.4457167983055115,
0.523402988910675,
-0.505988597869873,
0.27165496349334717,
-0.3795992136001587,
-0.3442225456237793,
-0.39897656440734863,
-0.3752603828907013,
0.18305543065071106,
-0.6080149412155151,
0.4462936520576477,
0.32171908020973206,
0.8378099799156189,
0.28627437353134155,
-0.2868482172489166,
-0.683177649974823,
-0.5101585388183594,
0.7461603283882141,
-0.6106273531913757,
0.5947961211204529,
0.37192094326019287,
0.0005073148640803993,
-0.4605937600135803,
-0.6170952916145325,
-0.35071298480033875,
-0.11992465704679489,
-0.042620085179805756,
-0.08038094639778137,
-0.6606876850128174,
-0.11976128071546555,
-0.06561026722192764,
0.27198293805122375,
-0.44438156485557556,
0.4315201938152313,
-0.0007498712511733174,
-0.2910444438457489,
0.5986378788948059,
0.28541165590286255,
0.05880112200975418,
0.09954261779785156,
-0.47305163741111755,
-0.27039170265197754,
-0.7159584164619446,
0.04967797175049782,
0.9165053963661194,
0.39296257495880127,
-0.4608890116214752,
0.4186050295829773,
0.0966087132692337,
0.575858473777771,
-0.020932650193572044,
-0.43090373277664185,
0.11766067892313004,
-0.1389678716659546,
-0.2550082802772522,
0.2661215364933014,
0.23341630399227142,
0.0970248430967331,
0.23123270273208618,
-0.10596462339162827,
-0.6469329595565796,
-0.160410538315773,
0.10586832463741302,
-0.1772034764289856,
-0.29121267795562744,
0.0005799962091259658,
-0.5909909009933472,
-0.34411633014678955,
0.27288582921028137,
-0.7442284226417542,
-0.6052531003952026,
-0.2696034610271454,
0.35815343260765076,
-0.15416543185710907,
-0.07908917218446732,
0.3071158528327942,
-0.3512011468410492,
0.11844055354595184,
0.18138010799884796,
-1.0528759956359863,
0.4009356200695038,
1.0669293403625488,
0.474176824092865,
0.03797942027449608,
-0.012220459058880806,
-0.8806414008140564,
0.40173351764678955,
-0.3337179124355316,
0.6816365122795105,
-0.5559142231941223,
-0.37563660740852356,
0.10868639498949051,
0.09407687932252884,
-0.0027073246892541647,
-0.5961390137672424,
0.29660117626190186,
-0.5946493148803711,
-0.15321685373783112,
0.14176622033119202,
-0.8239660859107971,
-0.07898468524217606,
0.44763749837875366,
-0.6327673196792603,
0.7269521355628967,
0.30846214294433594,
-0.6680747866630554,
0.5087129473686218,
-0.8733406066894531,
-0.23421747982501984,
0.04506900906562805,
-0.10838613659143448,
-0.8190417885780334,
0.18301858007907867,
0.47668373584747314,
0.4336075782775879,
-0.39714622497558594,
0.3867994248867035,
-0.4710133969783783,
-0.3372165262699127,
0.7805849313735962,
-0.7560445666313171,
0.1521044373512268,
-0.18632471561431885,
-0.02741275541484356,
-0.10555757582187653,
-0.6664351224899292,
-0.4625314772129059,
0.3702460825443268,
-0.17821040749549866,
-0.5535520911216736,
-0.015102549456059933,
0.28852084279060364,
-0.39359545707702637,
0.5145277976989746,
-0.5188430547714233,
0.215683251619339,
-0.4140511453151703,
0.3710433840751648,
0.8118368983268738,
0.040302205830812454,
0.16038013994693756,
-0.4055940508842468,
0.35612010955810547,
0.6285749077796936,
0.033052701503038406,
-0.16450363397598267,
-0.4989081919193268,
-0.6007206439971924,
-0.4167289435863495,
0.49931955337524414,
0.7827487587928772,
-0.36453136801719666,
0.7474583983421326,
-0.18874970078468323,
-0.0011691572144627571,
-0.5304675698280334,
0.593396782875061,
0.010526894591748714,
0.5762959718704224,
0.1870798021554947,
-0.008557391352951527,
-0.5730825662612915,
-1.1036897897720337,
-0.5878262519836426,
-0.05079970136284828,
-0.14552929997444153,
0.09219301491975784,
0.3914623260498047,
-0.6658931374549866,
0.8321298360824585,
-0.5621156096458435,
-0.4241880774497986,
-0.11430703103542328,
0.24095271527767181,
0.4623855948448181,
0.5660011172294617,
0.567628800868988,
-0.8313451409339905,
0.0080308448523283,
0.16989673674106598,
-0.7600747346878052,
0.17886169254779816,
-0.4280927777290344,
0.2986189126968384,
0.5077739357948303,
0.39799556136131287,
-0.06770730763673782,
0.6090356707572937,
0.5493893027305603,
-0.4306189715862274,
-0.1418018937110901,
-0.5244813561439514,
-0.2914848029613495,
-0.8221537470817566,
-0.29497554898262024,
0.40708327293395996,
-0.30338743329048157,
-0.6733651161193848,
-0.6053614616394043,
0.3218620717525482,
0.07739020884037018,
0.032296016812324524,
0.39262840151786804,
-0.18126420676708221,
-0.21581658720970154,
-0.11612860858440399,
0.08939480036497116,
0.06278831511735916,
0.26546111702919006,
-0.022466305643320084,
0.4619804918766022,
0.5744436383247375,
-0.2088138312101364,
0.2383354902267456,
0.11999685317277908,
-0.3780696988105774,
0.3451097309589386,
-0.23602353036403656,
-0.07679831236600876,
-0.2923803925514221,
0.18087413907051086,
-1.1022080183029175,
-0.21128256618976593,
0.19156868755817413,
-0.2807425856590271,
0.5949562191963196,
-0.06356553733348846,
-0.5530721545219421,
-0.20900766551494598,
-0.3143291175365448,
0.1577652245759964,
0.23658977448940277,
-0.772407591342926,
0.648638129234314,
0.2857801020145416,
-0.04454454779624939,
-0.6607455015182495,
-0.9226205348968506,
0.24274621903896332,
-0.5232956409454346,
-0.659752368927002,
0.025434253737330437,
0.4847572147846222,
-0.13571424782276154,
0.28797897696495056,
-0.18429727852344513,
-0.021426266059279442,
0.5482844710350037,
-0.041035935282707214,
0.852634072303772,
-0.6173916459083557,
0.06450802832841873,
-0.005581570323556662,
-0.2709521949291229,
0.1071309968829155,
-0.6542083024978638,
0.18388882279396057,
-0.22934499382972717,
-0.6283974051475525,
-0.6343033313751221,
0.37690097093582153,
0.24309301376342773,
0.22523677349090576,
0.8520607352256775,
0.47306278347969055,
-0.404862642288208,
-0.19429422914981842,
-0.6450534462928772,
0.13105951249599457,
-0.5078151226043701,
0.43451130390167236,
0.025463933125138283,
-1.241296410560608,
0.6815755367279053,
-0.05940388888120651,
0.023719968274235725,
0.5184497237205505,
0.3841382563114166,
-0.07297546416521072,
0.8239837884902954,
0.8989291191101074,
-0.33924028277397156,
0.4617387652397156,
-0.18657273054122925,
0.834139347076416,
-0.48334527015686035,
-0.45400166511535645,
-0.24194470047950745,
-0.36004945635795593,
-0.835456371307373,
-0.532487154006958,
0.4622981548309326,
0.08834030479192734,
-0.0012437849072739482,
-0.02303059957921505,
-0.034715212881565094,
0.43761372566223145,
0.1465236246585846,
-0.17893297970294952,
0.2370373010635376,
0.04154893755912781,
0.18460875749588013,
-0.11535349488258362,
-0.4498279392719269,
-0.3750786781311035,
1.3309948444366455,
0.7457030415534973,
0.9908443689346313,
0.05301200971007347,
0.7003644704818726,
0.8271403908729553,
0.33110862970352173,
-0.47850602865219116,
-0.197495236992836,
-0.44433799386024475,
-0.13483142852783203,
-0.44583237171173096,
-0.5221601724624634,
-0.7971843481063843,
-0.14984138309955597,
-0.3351936340332031,
-0.7233753204345703,
0.4664822816848755,
0.10878419876098633,
-0.3265611231327057,
0.5567572712898254,
-0.6560385227203369,
0.7063260078430176,
-0.37011483311653137,
0.0637916773557663,
0.3480966091156006,
-0.22033445537090302,
0.5381152629852295,
-0.42054396867752075,
0.3864560127258301,
0.06105005741119385,
-0.5237716436386108,
0.3918062746524811,
-0.29205846786499023,
0.993588924407959,
-0.20206588506698608,
-0.4553261697292328,
0.16801533102989197,
-0.22424407303333282,
1.0106972455978394,
0.41316020488739014,
0.21799872815608978,
0.35717231035232544,
-0.22500774264335632,
-0.4078710675239563,
-0.6969491839408875,
0.5882878303527832,
-0.6708970069885254,
-0.6560041308403015,
-0.30651623010635376,
-0.7914085984230042,
-0.4258100688457489,
-0.40678444504737854,
-0.136649027466774,
0.23946590721607208,
-0.00587200652807951,
0.3483668863773346,
0.824759304523468,
-0.1613600254058838,
0.44586145877838135,
0.4341522753238678,
0.0030651732813566923,
-0.2877872586250305,
0.9811800718307495,
0.015697170048952103,
-0.0976048931479454,
0.4842364192008972,
0.2326653152704239,
-0.5613144636154175,
-0.6831796765327454,
-0.47994479537010193,
0.1855098307132721,
-0.6694507002830505,
-0.44895389676094055,
-0.7532659769058228,
-0.3476656973361969,
-0.6121440529823303,
-0.2045820951461792,
-0.2264353185892105,
-0.44892773032188416,
-0.4372394382953644,
-0.09766265004873276,
0.742464542388916,
0.8507476449012756,
-0.3145184814929962,
0.18239320814609528,
-1.2778264284133911,
0.20838215947151184,
0.17017729580402374,
0.30543553829193115,
0.26945382356643677,
-0.48125141859054565,
-0.4288608431816101,
-0.1925036460161209,
0.02669340930879116,
-0.4985095262527466,
0.5397728681564331,
0.09082850068807602,
0.6495197415351868,
1.0115084648132324,
-0.20124226808547974,
0.6556123495101929,
0.053831830620765686,
0.49156561493873596,
0.19174781441688538,
-0.8108155131340027,
0.30850502848625183,
-0.4713195264339447,
-0.16448789834976196,
0.09480727463960648,
0.3006303012371063,
-0.5888915657997131,
-0.5547218322753906,
-0.6413981914520264,
-0.8175826072692871,
0.6565629243850708,
-0.05778884142637253,
0.1550886183977127,
0.02396390400826931,
0.42053815722465515,
0.16218848526477814,
0.3919837772846222,
-0.6052641272544861,
-0.17602089047431946,
-0.3395216166973114,
-0.29202747344970703,
-0.11533404886722565,
-0.25872984528541565,
-0.04805032163858414,
-0.10807596892118454,
0.41541048884391785,
-0.10150156170129776,
0.05846353620290756,
0.07835154980421066,
0.04209621995687485,
0.05669771879911423,
0.10249379277229309,
0.5574504137039185,
0.3558669090270996,
-0.01689274050295353,
-0.11655297875404358,
0.3324025571346283,
-0.5212855935096741,
0.03270522877573967,
0.053533606231212616,
0.19788844883441925,
-0.023769937455654144,
0.6725150942802429,
0.6092494130134583,
0.4736015498638153,
-0.8813402056694031,
0.6093418598175049,
-0.041344448924064636,
-0.3725895583629608,
-0.6223410964012146,
0.10644654184579849,
0.23057404160499573,
0.4147493243217468,
0.5712597370147705,
-0.12384910881519318,
0.15918046236038208,
-0.571118950843811,
0.19380268454551697,
0.40425604581832886,
-0.28114449977874756,
-0.09546028822660446,
0.32849520444869995,
-0.10226121544837952,
-0.09392333030700684,
0.7716721892356873,
0.025715993717312813,
-0.447762668132782,
0.8239027261734009,
0.8227614760398865,
0.9186791777610779,
0.08199837803840637,
-0.1967296451330185,
-0.29032954573631287,
0.5112624764442444,
-0.18005724251270294,
0.23749342560768127,
0.010971048846840858,
-0.8619228005409241,
-0.08995722234249115,
-0.7410280108451843,
-0.40810415148735046,
0.2670572102069855,
-0.6135494709014893,
0.24908863008022308,
-0.6392844915390015,
0.11198944598436356,
-0.041272930800914764,
-0.3943871855735779,
-0.5929027199745178,
-0.21097911894321442,
0.4333154261112213,
0.8194993734359741,
-1.0095187425613403,
0.7680028080940247,
0.3860642611980438,
0.13897724449634552,
-0.38180384039878845,
-0.19334006309509277,
0.14228332042694092,
-0.9520025253295898,
0.6467782258987427,
-0.023268572986125946,
0.25246554613113403,
-0.35674476623535156,
-0.27501556277275085,
-0.8282469511032104,
0.8655966520309448,
0.19220353662967682,
-0.7829847931861877,
0.040913887321949005,
0.5214183330535889,
0.32124966382980347,
-0.6698587536811829,
-0.45779621601104736,
0.8665145635604858,
0.7050608396530151,
0.023860959336161613,
-0.3107587993144989,
-0.3578881025314331,
-0.13310961425304413,
0.03584601357579231,
0.6693850755691528,
-0.40060675144195557,
0.9195181727409363,
0.18274877965450287,
0.31898096203804016,
-0.09584701806306839,
0.7276872992515564,
0.2279844880104065,
0.6061769127845764,
0.42239874601364136,
0.7075608372688293,
1.3189257383346558,
-0.20073136687278748,
1.0548592805862427,
-0.19020479917526245,
0.24667736887931824,
0.8055205941200256,
-0.35021114349365234,
0.5561982989311218,
0.2936539053916931,
0.019056757912039757,
0.44181180000305176,
0.640943169593811,
-0.5193461775779724,
0.249416321516037,
0.41365668177604675,
-0.17580927908420563,
-0.45914432406425476,
-0.043522004038095474,
-0.20251129567623138,
0.5569746494293213,
0.709923267364502,
-0.502962589263916,
-0.1939540058374405,
0.1373094916343689,
-0.09571757912635803,
0.038152433931827545,
-0.4071551561355591,
0.7576295137405396,
0.20918025076389313,
0.13298764824867249,
0.06728465855121613,
0.30483606457710266,
0.8936934471130371,
-0.7837850451469421,
0.03378467634320259,
-0.22425666451454163,
0.2089196890592575,
-0.18691469728946686,
-0.355852872133255,
0.3913877010345459,
0.3539653420448303,
-0.24905776977539062,
-0.3361823558807373,
0.8004917502403259,
-0.14975224435329437,
-0.779902994632721,
0.2423907071352005,
0.4293939173221588,
0.01920500583946705,
0.19412805140018463,
-0.44615796208381653,
-0.37823233008384705,
-0.15715713798999786,
-0.09259055554866791,
0.6673666834831238,
0.9031137824058533,
-0.39399731159210205,
0.4291115999221802,
1.1104927062988281,
-0.1280534863471985,
-0.12419218569993973,
0.09380407631397247,
0.7953246235847473,
-0.9278050065040588,
-0.8542119860649109,
-1.0262900590896606,
0.07694986462593079,
-0.0749545618891716,
-0.23732790350914001,
0.7596991062164307,
0.8453037738800049,
0.7175481915473938,
-0.09605870395898819,
0.6215211153030396,
0.7528587579727173,
0.30047836899757385,
-0.7846348881721497,
0.733894944190979,
-0.4094030559062958,
0.533126175403595,
-0.10876255482435226,
-0.668143630027771,
-0.4890718460083008,
0.24408560991287231,
-0.24787698686122894,
-0.30594903230667114,
0.376931756734848,
0.7290104031562805,
-0.07241495698690414,
0.4720357656478882,
0.3650146722793579,
-0.0733468234539032,
0.12458577752113342,
0.42266204953193665,
0.9274469017982483,
-0.25516873598098755,
0.28212374448776245,
0.1748529076576233,
0.08818026632070541,
-0.46729689836502075,
-0.9629089832305908,
-0.9961192011833191,
-0.190352663397789,
-0.24440521001815796,
-0.08859821408987045,
-0.22891470789909363,
0.8589454889297485,
0.0717335045337677,
-0.9490069150924683,
-0.2762589156627655,
0.15700583159923553,
0.3694811761379242,
0.017484430223703384,
-0.1754031628370285,
0.39374130964279175,
-0.4444045424461365,
-0.5305087566375732,
0.4907999336719513,
0.6743573546409607,
0.5243256092071533,
-0.3831501007080078,
0.11898472905158997,
0.14319507777690887,
0.16956409811973572,
0.23366998136043549,
-0.006993907503783703,
-0.5063059329986572,
-0.24637649953365326,
0.04024128243327141,
0.20148731768131256,
0.07700948417186737,
0.9503408074378967,
-0.388665109872818,
-0.06404633074998856,
0.22566024959087372,
1.1950680017471313,
0.438982754945755,
-0.015825903043150902,
0.3839670419692993,
-0.5973767042160034,
0.4601433575153351,
0.2314143180847168,
0.43298324942588806,
0.1598825454711914,
-0.823996901512146,
0.1888626515865326,
0.296889066696167,
-0.19774098694324493,
-0.8812863826751709,
-0.39321351051330566,
-0.6325747966766357,
-0.24089336395263672,
0.5166735053062439,
-0.39280128479003906,
-0.5575175285339355,
-0.3124704957008362,
0.5979182124137878,
-0.09375955909490585,
-0.4296799600124359,
0.8174657821655273,
0.7059053778648376,
-0.2472495138645172,
0.32288363575935364,
-0.6813337802886963,
0.42498382925987244,
0.16773483157157898,
-0.6374649405479431,
0.06535891443490982,
0.1444043219089508,
0.1394006758928299,
0.07259470969438553,
0.15798945724964142,
-0.26069796085357666,
0.3518047630786896,
0.17444324493408203,
-0.3377002775669098,
-0.24387800693511963,
-0.22358201444149017,
-0.6832185983657837,
0.11626382917165756,
-0.2275809347629547,
-0.03063986636698246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03600v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03600v1
|
Knowledge-Infused Legal Wisdom: Navigating LLM Consultation through the Lens of Diagnostics and Positive-Unlabeled Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-06-05T19:47:35 | 2024-06-05T19:47:35 |
Yang Wu, Chenghao Wang, Ece Gumusel, Xiaozhong Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The integration of generative Large Language Models (LLMs) into various
applications, including the legal domain, has been accelerated by their
expansive and versatile nature. However, when facing a legal case, users
without a legal background often struggle to formulate professional queries and
may inadvertently overlook critical legal factors when presenting their case
narrative to LLMs. To address this issue, we propose the Diagnostic Legal Large
Language Model (D3LM), which utilizes adaptive lawyer-like diagnostic questions
to collect additional case information and then provides high-quality feedback.
D3LM incorporates an innovative graph-based Positive-Unlabeled Reinforcement
Learning (PURL) algorithm, enabling the generation of critical questions and
enhancing user-LLM interactions. Moreover, an integrated LLM-based stopping
criterion facilitates precise Court Views Generation (CVG). Our research also
introduces a new English-language CVG dataset based on the US case law
database, enriching the realm of LLM research and deployment with a vital
dimension. D3LM surpasses classical LLMs by delivering outstanding performance
and a remarkable user experience in the legal domain.
|
[
-0.15416036546230316,
-0.7151538133621216,
1.0481884479522705,
0.10729103535413742,
-0.6123223304748535,
0.20792211592197418,
-0.16555432975292206,
-0.262551873922348,
-0.0774206668138504,
0.8391801118850708,
-0.30376365780830383,
-0.8197340369224548,
-0.4591577351093292,
-0.2112632393836975,
-0.3336283266544342,
1.0532723665237427,
0.18792058527469635,
0.3391687870025635,
-0.21624960005283356,
-0.2546391189098358,
-0.6796667575836182,
-0.5403668284416199,
-0.9908086657524109,
-0.3779316544532776,
0.4227007031440735,
0.04619427025318146,
0.6808838844299316,
0.3450290858745575,
0.17921508848667145,
0.15605351328849792,
-0.23942792415618896,
0.09816564619541168,
-0.49172112345695496,
0.19220717251300812,
-0.13318482041358948,
-0.5935747027397156,
-0.4813953936100006,
-0.1111990287899971,
0.26129090785980225,
0.5491455793380737,
-0.8255615234375,
-0.29246091842651367,
-0.20802022516727448,
0.7902897596359253,
-0.5698139071464539,
0.2286665141582489,
-0.5311397910118103,
0.20565995573997498,
-0.15001921355724335,
-0.2696964144706726,
-0.3671344816684723,
-0.4635496735572815,
-0.00765080563724041,
-0.832158625125885,
0.0690818503499031,
0.04193160682916641,
0.519968569278717,
0.5576860308647156,
-0.7093108892440796,
-0.28586018085479736,
-0.8800442814826965,
0.16562147438526154,
-0.6688847541809082,
0.47232586145401,
0.24965806305408478,
0.46332022547721863,
-0.33611127734184265,
-0.7559615969657898,
-0.6911422610282898,
-0.42711424827575684,
0.23016250133514404,
0.43030714988708496,
-0.5027204155921936,
0.06421101838350296,
0.21227237582206726,
0.0010705896420404315,
-0.41215524077415466,
0.5211242437362671,
-0.28926271200180054,
-0.09164101630449295,
0.7670630216598511,
0.3383774161338806,
0.007891884073615074,
0.09138766676187515,
-0.10731752216815948,
0.18400925397872925,
-1.0293498039245605,
-0.03124723955988884,
0.18388822674751282,
0.13336287438869476,
-0.016078246757388115,
0.29967111349105835,
0.12097032368183136,
0.9998056888580322,
0.24889865517616272,
-0.32221195101737976,
0.1323261857032776,
-0.010293940082192421,
-0.22128356993198395,
0.31658294796943665,
0.9932459592819214,
0.37499117851257324,
0.18452587723731995,
-0.08087305724620819,
-0.36654606461524963,
-0.41289934515953064,
0.4338936507701874,
-0.4307437837123871,
-0.049347810447216034,
0.23326487839221954,
-0.21645651757717133,
-0.3236827552318573,
-0.06145023927092552,
-0.6264399290084839,
-1.109046459197998,
-0.4370461106300354,
0.10336979478597641,
-0.5288058519363403,
-0.23392650485038757,
0.5648230910301208,
0.13369229435920715,
0.07584621757268906,
0.5187188982963562,
-0.4694892466068268,
0.2665970027446747,
0.6111798286437988,
0.2672518789768219,
0.14129118621349335,
0.26551246643066406,
-0.941912055015564,
0.3587276041507721,
-0.539019763469696,
0.5129085779190063,
-0.4712355136871338,
-0.5965404510498047,
0.32014769315719604,
-0.03520135208964348,
0.36108723282814026,
-0.8172813057899475,
0.47031810879707336,
-0.9040400385856628,
0.04238160327076912,
-0.14834235608577728,
-0.4505579471588135,
-0.24725165963172913,
0.5554983019828796,
-0.42326435446739197,
0.7458335161209106,
0.23788298666477203,
-0.5026465058326721,
0.9187275171279907,
-0.6712905764579773,
-0.5338172912597656,
0.7558079361915588,
-0.5505384802818298,
-0.3299844563007355,
-0.05984678864479065,
0.2251751869916916,
0.4775983393192291,
-0.4528738856315613,
0.5813043117523193,
-0.2398746758699417,
-0.12208069115877151,
0.10014909505844116,
-0.07576322555541992,
0.8259771466255188,
0.2520045340061188,
-0.19106259942054749,
0.18508635461330414,
-0.8684550523757935,
-0.33502843976020813,
0.2397085577249527,
-0.46486303210258484,
-0.2917488217353821,
0.17273877561092377,
-0.546574592590332,
0.24316240847110748,
0.10262638330459595,
-0.4784696698188782,
0.1964903324842453,
-0.4051456153392792,
0.3397764563560486,
0.5695903301239014,
0.2300664782524109,
-0.11854411661624908,
-0.28054124116897583,
0.8961411118507385,
0.379198282957077,
0.021425021812319756,
0.24525512754917145,
-0.42674902081489563,
-0.6496885418891907,
-0.10596227645874023,
0.10727553814649582,
0.5862361192703247,
-0.979968786239624,
0.20577208697795868,
-0.44623976945877075,
-0.37126055359840393,
-0.7559248208999634,
0.2595140039920807,
0.17074650526046753,
0.5181989669799805,
0.3207565248012543,
0.06457020342350006,
-0.4608014225959778,
-0.7295246720314026,
0.07807190716266632,
-0.5072187781333923,
0.04458856210112572,
0.6674225330352783,
0.17087101936340332,
-0.27189165353775024,
0.7490785121917725,
-0.4017668664455414,
-0.3540094494819641,
-0.5182252526283264,
0.05290566757321358,
0.4189484417438507,
-0.23509016633033752,
0.5008834004402161,
-0.6326585412025452,
-0.46742483973503113,
0.371847927570343,
-0.7271113395690918,
-0.1005970686674118,
-0.12178420275449753,
0.17175167798995972,
-0.016956036910414696,
0.5966807007789612,
-0.44023799896240234,
0.27208438515663147,
-0.0027889027260243893,
-0.5162836313247681,
0.651715874671936,
-0.6103277206420898,
-0.01757347583770752,
-0.9082733392715454,
-0.20600055158138275,
0.14776046574115753,
-0.5364543199539185,
-0.483451247215271,
0.04355822876095772,
0.16133767366409302,
0.04035009816288948,
-0.6726613640785217,
0.5228398442268372,
-0.34229737520217896,
-0.06597241759300232,
-0.2108953446149826,
0.4619184136390686,
0.027798959985375404,
0.22005915641784668,
-0.25578388571739197,
0.765977680683136,
0.6415903568267822,
-0.8775376677513123,
0.7390217781066895,
0.277409166097641,
-0.24271981418132782,
0.8762103319168091,
-0.4092251658439636,
-0.12115407735109329,
-0.21616868674755096,
0.12373357266187668,
-0.38193902373313904,
-0.005416454281657934,
0.28340449929237366,
0.1518941968679428,
0.4486425518989563,
-0.3364278972148895,
-0.8419902920722961,
-0.6407619714736938,
0.04998902976512909,
0.29878440499305725,
0.697546124458313,
-0.5619714856147766,
0.628146767616272,
0.5337607264518738,
-0.12161942571401596,
-0.3422620892524719,
-0.3211340606212616,
0.17883549630641937,
-0.46236515045166016,
-0.36999884247779846,
0.2831028401851654,
0.21149654686450958,
-0.49874573945999146,
-0.01716451346874237,
0.37335580587387085,
-0.11972460150718689,
0.22394169867038727,
0.23935402929782867,
0.22793853282928467,
-0.13322287797927856,
0.37845420837402344,
-0.24521727859973907,
0.212389275431633,
0.5171983242034912,
-0.28485703468322754,
0.4726349115371704,
-0.005623295903205872,
-0.5469866394996643,
-0.16700826585292816,
-0.11204471439123154,
0.5907193422317505,
-0.22026188671588898,
0.28862234950065613,
0.2510301172733307,
-0.09695689380168915,
-0.22250309586524963,
-0.6460913419723511,
0.2139541655778885,
-0.4391506016254425,
0.33886146545410156,
-0.18699005246162415,
-1.0246481895446777,
0.33524107933044434,
-0.02551714889705181,
0.012775587849318981,
0.40331435203552246,
0.8690962195396423,
-0.05465194955468178,
0.9382206201553345,
0.6607002019882202,
-0.05267060548067093,
0.19875985383987427,
0.12017657607793808,
0.4071178734302521,
-0.7921944856643677,
-0.4734494984149933,
-0.0985223799943924,
0.21439248323440552,
-0.39344877004623413,
-0.42022058367729187,
0.7110642194747925,
0.04598679021000862,
-0.3087987005710602,
-0.08842383325099945,
-0.2869763970375061,
0.2817502021789551,
0.37769874930381775,
0.2503988742828369,
0.5115421414375305,
-0.3405708968639374,
-0.5735892653465271,
0.1251298189163208,
-0.7192217707633972,
-0.2507608234882355,
1.125866413116455,
0.3152090609073639,
0.6665987372398376,
0.3437235355377197,
0.6592895984649658,
0.24612702429294586,
0.2947651445865631,
-1.0280839204788208,
0.5764353275299072,
-0.18218004703521729,
-0.1963319331407547,
-0.0064397212117910385,
-0.3449457883834839,
-1.0892767906188965,
0.16667944192886353,
-0.08104535937309265,
-0.643143892288208,
-0.06563363969326019,
0.08202715218067169,
-0.9313530921936035,
0.25562167167663574,
-0.1897580623626709,
0.43693840503692627,
-0.49509426951408386,
-0.6186667084693909,
-0.3180231750011444,
-0.3093918263912201,
0.4820588231086731,
-0.24103012681007385,
0.40161389112472534,
-0.0519740991294384,
0.1016046479344368,
0.7366551756858826,
-0.3606003522872925,
0.7218287587165833,
-0.29656317830085754,
-0.3671876788139343,
0.2961164116859436,
0.21817803382873535,
0.43935805559158325,
0.2457484006881714,
0.08356424421072006,
-0.4555656611919403,
-0.055240448564291,
0.00910829845815897,
-0.7628229856491089,
0.4405607283115387,
-0.5561268329620361,
-1.0820282697677612,
-0.3811088502407074,
-0.5580796599388123,
-0.6247527003288269,
0.2169620841741562,
-0.2880147099494934,
0.1862790584564209,
-0.22440853714942932,
-0.0030706466641277075,
0.6458593606948853,
-0.41283392906188965,
0.173478901386261,
1.2645565271377563,
-0.4755767285823822,
-0.07824791967868805,
0.8322991132736206,
0.029014043509960175,
-0.19211949408054352,
0.050364792346954346,
0.30256518721580505,
-0.5823273062705994,
-0.8628488779067993,
-0.19127094745635986,
0.5182094573974609,
-0.823320209980011,
-0.3323061168193817,
-0.5907291769981384,
-0.36192557215690613,
-0.11696990579366684,
0.02617604099214077,
-0.16473209857940674,
0.05166291445493698,
-0.5038869380950928,
-0.27381476759910583,
0.6429458856582642,
0.9896622896194458,
0.09184286743402481,
-0.03582702949643135,
-0.8012104630470276,
0.18395911157131195,
0.3821674883365631,
0.39717310667037964,
-0.18020612001419067,
-0.714749813079834,
-0.13872933387756348,
-0.1169276088476181,
-0.4848228991031647,
-0.6562296152114868,
0.4494094252586365,
-0.21760055422782898,
0.8264284133911133,
0.7893054485321045,
0.018966656178236008,
0.6966933012008667,
-0.6853605508804321,
0.8129429817199707,
0.32465437054634094,
-0.4628276228904724,
0.5475033521652222,
-0.576285183429718,
0.05858241394162178,
0.46354198455810547,
0.38886240124702454,
-0.4862232506275177,
-0.4736260175704956,
-0.5455688834190369,
-0.6570860147476196,
0.43821144104003906,
-0.37881720066070557,
0.08260319381952286,
-0.20386384427547455,
0.6151652336120605,
-0.02308632619678974,
0.14726388454437256,
-0.5791402459144592,
0.1348157674074173,
-0.010160224512219429,
-0.06634576618671417,
0.02104155160486698,
-0.30725860595703125,
-0.5241383910179138,
-0.5788738131523132,
0.626386284828186,
-0.11208806931972504,
-0.023017797619104385,
-0.07681626081466675,
-0.04017186909914017,
0.16961996257305145,
0.4125826358795166,
0.5049711465835571,
0.6600119471549988,
-0.05622944235801697,
-0.0008162274025380611,
0.024227498099207878,
-0.23722657561302185,
0.29745104908943176,
0.11195484548807144,
0.12268389016389847,
-0.21502266824245453,
0.11307170242071152,
0.9589728116989136,
0.10328216850757599,
-0.8845680952072144,
0.7227678894996643,
-0.1228007897734642,
-0.752538800239563,
-0.42860203981399536,
0.15410491824150085,
0.0989588275551796,
0.43768447637557983,
0.19209428131580353,
-0.5281099677085876,
0.028294797986745834,
-0.40106892585754395,
0.1994817703962326,
0.5076008439064026,
-0.7837257981300354,
0.05551323667168617,
0.7578254342079163,
0.24798953533172607,
-0.1285427212715149,
0.5845330953598022,
-0.41930505633354187,
-0.4552783966064453,
0.3575921356678009,
0.49965301156044006,
0.6035876274108887,
0.3242804706096649,
0.3890535235404968,
-0.005156391300261021,
0.001795485382899642,
-0.27167871594429016,
0.3920512795448303,
0.1721937358379364,
-0.71648108959198,
-0.3123876452445984,
-0.4366180896759033,
-0.2952807545661926,
0.4369570016860962,
-0.789161205291748,
0.24016577005386353,
-0.6746962070465088,
0.005590227432549,
-0.27832654118537903,
-0.08217192441225052,
-0.7852972745895386,
0.1252632737159729,
0.055763013660907745,
0.8003589510917664,
-0.32492542266845703,
0.8885693550109863,
0.5688597559928894,
-0.4221685826778412,
-0.7466514706611633,
-0.08383753150701523,
0.18927867710590363,
-1.0492610931396484,
0.8796828389167786,
-0.17933471500873566,
0.02321712300181389,
0.08183788508176804,
-0.34069138765335083,
-0.27779966592788696,
1.2747726440429688,
0.3913198709487915,
-0.7991437911987305,
0.12450839579105377,
0.09885409474372864,
0.7739772200584412,
-0.3097452223300934,
-0.023027395829558372,
0.8918660879135132,
0.2920956313610077,
0.2855260372161865,
-0.6672639846801758,
0.2408667504787445,
-0.08258499950170517,
-0.07265804708003998,
0.21766504645347595,
-0.38353708386421204,
0.46823859214782715,
-0.3023640215396881,
-0.17390958964824677,
-0.36902451515197754,
0.3625567853450775,
0.40168502926826477,
-0.07016297429800034,
0.4420405328273773,
0.7249824404716492,
1.0806504487991333,
-0.0470694862306118,
1.3550997972488403,
-0.6472330689430237,
0.0074279652908444405,
1.0656499862670898,
-0.6642429232597351,
0.5625818967819214,
0.46689966320991516,
-0.24749387800693512,
0.46327951550483704,
0.48688429594039917,
-0.30351781845092773,
0.38703638315200806,
0.37282758951187134,
-0.5965054035186768,
-0.3709474205970764,
-0.3497304618358612,
-0.17752191424369812,
0.371844619512558,
0.46801283955574036,
-0.3440065085887909,
-0.32091113924980164,
-0.037202730774879456,
0.07592780888080597,
0.2432519793510437,
-0.31876954436302185,
1.1005412340164185,
-0.07320456951856613,
-0.6336868405342102,
0.4892016351222992,
-0.018804997205734253,
0.34826231002807617,
-0.5118493437767029,
-0.10698273032903671,
-0.2739763557910919,
0.001878635142929852,
-0.028999941423535347,
-1.004854679107666,
0.010968917049467564,
0.033220212906599045,
0.09785495698451996,
-0.21017086505889893,
0.3044697642326355,
-0.18985189497470856,
-0.4986114203929901,
0.5309154987335205,
0.6310559511184692,
0.05537993088364601,
0.0806659609079361,
-0.728093683719635,
-0.19705210626125336,
-0.1941331923007965,
0.04958174377679825,
0.36752843856811523,
0.7667986154556274,
-0.12063510715961456,
0.9401023387908936,
0.5054557919502258,
0.4212055802345276,
-0.09643201529979706,
0.6274740099906921,
1.1877623796463013,
-0.6496366262435913,
-0.5961238145828247,
-0.8557447195053101,
0.6159525513648987,
-0.06284119933843613,
-0.10380429774522781,
0.35328221321105957,
0.3703579902648926,
0.5030471682548523,
0.3297772705554962,
0.8412795066833496,
0.2914292812347412,
0.46828120946884155,
-0.809417724609375,
0.6594581007957458,
-0.5618434548377991,
0.5521960854530334,
0.09140653908252716,
-0.37191474437713623,
-0.437631756067276,
0.3861536979675293,
-0.4129425287246704,
-0.049438245594501495,
0.6053814888000488,
0.6948856711387634,
0.028597505763173103,
-0.29803329706192017,
0.7725563645362854,
0.4392443597316742,
0.7374922633171082,
0.5806514024734497,
0.8482027053833008,
0.03379148244857788,
0.5978547930717468,
0.09371265769004822,
-0.1472032070159912,
-0.3114626407623291,
-0.8345072865486145,
-0.9369065761566162,
-0.11208915710449219,
-0.2328852415084839,
-0.4568391740322113,
-0.0017156002577394247,
0.6289330720901489,
0.4276103973388672,
-0.39704978466033936,
-0.18479803204536438,
-0.36382144689559937,
0.02650264836847782,
0.13227349519729614,
-0.2402583509683609,
0.0059384750202298164,
-0.33871743083000183,
-0.0820501297712326,
0.5723156929016113,
0.48175302147865295,
0.06806443631649017,
-0.4466334581375122,
-0.2931932508945465,
-0.042381566017866135,
-0.04069650545716286,
0.5325679183006287,
0.2607578933238983,
-0.8474645018577576,
-0.12704870104789734,
-0.4751424491405487,
-0.10267286747694016,
0.33793529868125916,
0.9174495935440063,
-0.8243615031242371,
0.6156800389289856,
-0.2221263200044632,
0.8144498467445374,
0.5441921353340149,
-0.20520363748073578,
0.9576911330223083,
-0.6103804111480713,
0.1797291338443756,
0.5757447481155396,
0.6169418096542358,
0.1508193463087082,
-0.5800994038581848,
0.3598620593547821,
0.036776114255189896,
-0.2692863643169403,
-0.5817455053329468,
0.33471766114234924,
-0.6729745864868164,
-0.2932710647583008,
1.2818162441253662,
-0.14337725937366486,
-0.007169682066887617,
-0.38671138882637024,
-0.17964619398117065,
-0.0009652546723373234,
-0.37877315282821655,
0.9126875400543213,
0.7516453862190247,
-0.15559740364551544,
-0.34983864426612854,
-0.837325930595398,
0.6606624126434326,
0.18828701972961426,
-0.7835023403167725,
0.0595061331987381,
0.6033011674880981,
0.4332065284252167,
-0.09276813268661499,
0.8527999520301819,
-0.3214184045791626,
0.40345853567123413,
-0.3151867389678955,
-0.06203221529722214,
-0.4162696897983551,
-0.17581582069396973,
-0.3878856897354126,
0.14273034036159515,
0.3793167769908905,
0.33504751324653625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03592v1
|
Measuring Retrieval Complexity in Question Answering Systems
| 2024-06-05T19:30:52 | 2024-06-05T19:30:52 |
Matteo Gabburo, Nicolaas Paul Jedema, Siddhant Garg, Leonardo F. R. Ribeiro, Alessandro Moschitti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we investigate which questions are challenging for
retrieval-based Question Answering (QA). We (i) propose retrieval complexity
(RC), a novel metric conditioned on the completeness of retrieved documents,
which measures the difficulty of answering questions, and (ii) propose an
unsupervised pipeline to measure RC given an arbitrary retrieval system. Our
proposed pipeline measures RC more accurately than alternative estimators,
including LLMs, on six challenging QA benchmarks. Further investigation reveals
that RC scores strongly correlate with both QA performance and expert judgment
across five of the six studied benchmarks, indicating that RC is an effective
measure of question difficulty. Subsequent categorization of high-RC questions
shows that they span a broad set of question shapes, including multi-hop,
compositional, and temporal QA, indicating that RC scores can categorize a new
subset of complex questions. Our system can also have a major impact on
retrieval-based systems by helping to identify more challenging questions on
existing datasets.
|
[
-0.402192085981369,
-0.43500006198883057,
0.7585704922676086,
0.271513968706131,
-0.11553527414798737,
0.4447084963321686,
0.07216040790081024,
-0.3860228657722473,
0.14150890707969666,
0.21683692932128906,
-0.4526849687099457,
-0.16508212685585022,
-0.7450591921806335,
0.28126490116119385,
-0.4413370192050934,
0.8275068998336792,
-0.08922915905714035,
0.14735738933086395,
-0.5094650983810425,
-0.31846505403518677,
-0.5502316355705261,
-0.12009050697088242,
-0.25778770446777344,
-0.11767838150262833,
0.8296132683753967,
0.41534170508384705,
0.6451094746589661,
0.4130702018737793,
1.092557668685913,
0.19317175447940826,
-0.17824377119541168,
0.07004709541797638,
-0.35636571049690247,
0.48651593923568726,
-0.36325082182884216,
-0.8634770512580872,
-0.0677930936217308,
-0.3241758942604065,
0.4653215706348419,
1.1639524698257446,
-0.1934300810098648,
0.37509945034980774,
-0.1501411646604538,
0.8389091491699219,
-0.9575661420822144,
-0.13874028623104095,
-0.6681993007659912,
0.061200518161058426,
-0.23732762038707733,
-0.5495004057884216,
-0.20441509783267975,
-0.25203803181648254,
0.2623974084854126,
-0.5350868701934814,
0.2845747470855713,
0.47685757279396057,
0.5099204182624817,
0.439791738986969,
-0.6625948548316956,
-0.6765277981758118,
-0.9378280639648438,
0.9377747178077698,
-0.3081705570220947,
0.2615625560283661,
0.155315101146698,
0.44601672887802124,
-0.06923426687717438,
-0.7145671248435974,
-0.2289864420890808,
0.04112767055630684,
-0.024443168193101883,
0.11519214510917664,
-0.17550212144851685,
0.05435102805495262,
0.4024128019809723,
0.700773298740387,
-0.7312105298042297,
-0.16856610774993896,
-0.5945959091186523,
-0.14894962310791016,
0.537236750125885,
0.5208008289337158,
0.21871621906757355,
-0.4803382158279419,
-0.19014093279838562,
-0.00129026104696095,
-0.4211421608924866,
0.2836383879184723,
0.32717761397361755,
0.09461946785449982,
0.6310014128684998,
0.6854010820388794,
-0.44532227516174316,
0.4838102459907532,
-0.25432392954826355,
0.22959929704666138,
-0.04142250493168831,
-0.24869802594184875,
0.08250078558921814,
-0.40547844767570496,
0.5479843020439148,
-0.08585303276777267,
0.0950990617275238,
-0.18110957741737366,
-0.37469974160194397,
-0.4726772606372833,
0.33945798873901367,
-0.6120644211769104,
-0.16360653936862946,
0.3874569237232208,
-0.22895897924900055,
0.18658354878425598,
0.30502158403396606,
-0.3850071430206299,
-0.2247074991464615,
0.09913765639066696,
0.650102436542511,
-0.3249790668487549,
-0.1754400134086609,
0.1421496868133545,
-0.30945494771003723,
0.4668046534061432,
0.2940448820590973,
-0.5587877035140991,
0.4476225972175598,
0.7747333645820618,
0.74847412109375,
-0.3782203793525696,
0.09881222993135452,
-0.6324048638343811,
-0.1741306632757187,
-0.39627236127853394,
0.8440226912498474,
-0.48978811502456665,
-0.2679316997528076,
-0.12033335864543915,
0.026668043807148933,
-0.01301562786102295,
-0.7092921137809753,
0.453035831451416,
-1.1081342697143555,
0.15350984036922455,
-0.41970211267471313,
-0.6598281860351562,
0.029555104672908783,
0.4021928608417511,
-0.5924474000930786,
1.028570532798767,
0.3785386085510254,
-0.8703707456588745,
0.18144042789936066,
-0.3713063895702362,
-0.2533373534679413,
0.29032501578330994,
0.22679682075977325,
-0.03735630214214325,
0.3037550449371338,
-0.007772741373628378,
0.2250773310661316,
-0.5770114660263062,
-0.1001584380865097,
-0.2965885400772095,
-0.6290268898010254,
0.15591931343078613,
-0.18974077701568604,
0.4996032416820526,
0.4191451966762543,
0.12463993579149246,
-0.3516492545604706,
-0.561646044254303,
0.517268180847168,
-0.2935596704483032,
-0.40027451515197754,
-0.537482738494873,
-0.10930105298757553,
-0.29703760147094727,
-0.16556000709533691,
0.37721407413482666,
-0.670120358467102,
0.03375687450170517,
-0.2303013652563095,
0.31225401163101196,
0.45916303992271423,
0.30027177929878235,
0.32821276783943176,
-0.44870877265930176,
0.9361259937286377,
-0.20507773756980896,
0.18331898748874664,
-0.058044277131557465,
-0.38734757900238037,
-0.6397038698196411,
-0.15557657182216644,
0.5238626003265381,
0.7671314477920532,
-0.4453418254852295,
0.0922093391418457,
-0.383561909198761,
-0.7380536198616028,
-0.630988597869873,
0.04612124338746071,
0.5121853351593018,
0.17739365994930267,
0.5311163067817688,
-0.7955710887908936,
-0.18551021814346313,
-0.7784894704818726,
-0.4544580578804016,
-0.4783916175365448,
-0.49445536732673645,
0.595781683921814,
0.7335493564605713,
0.32097986340522766,
0.7113110423088074,
-0.6586148142814636,
-0.056220054626464844,
0.1077752336859703,
0.382028192281723,
0.28064095973968506,
0.3349873423576355,
0.03194022551178932,
-0.8360191583633423,
-0.39471521973609924,
-0.26202547550201416,
-0.733006477355957,
-0.18710292875766754,
0.13031406700611115,
0.13304473459720612,
-0.2794235348701477,
0.3433291018009186,
-0.6515196561813354,
0.3073783814907074,
-0.07599058747291565,
-0.0475989505648613,
0.6305555105209351,
-0.29584944248199463,
0.4361558258533478,
-0.4338546097278595,
0.2983193099498749,
-0.3888377845287323,
0.16756682097911835,
-0.278117835521698,
0.3058003783226013,
-0.0013423041673377156,
0.13977637887001038,
-0.4993334412574768,
0.21779587864875793,
-0.6774197816848755,
-0.5353879332542419,
0.15524446964263916,
0.21674537658691406,
0.09711900353431702,
0.39927050471305847,
-0.3578590452671051,
0.5934317111968994,
-0.023845402523875237,
-0.546841025352478,
0.4624619781970978,
0.14620985090732574,
-0.5121788382530212,
0.7895639538764954,
-0.9129902124404907,
0.3633425831794739,
-0.37246614694595337,
0.08216303586959839,
-1.3378437757492065,
-0.20816506445407867,
-0.2594589293003082,
-0.6744316220283508,
0.16272127628326416,
-0.17028382420539856,
-0.30589932203292847,
-0.41424551606178284,
-0.23130878806114197,
0.762353241443634,
0.27689114212989807,
-0.03939809650182724,
0.5561061501502991,
-0.22506937384605408,
-0.0942230075597763,
-0.9686184525489807,
-0.4539955258369446,
-0.08735471218824387,
-0.056383002549409866,
-0.597406268119812,
0.35857871174812317,
-0.39453625679016113,
-0.20440082252025604,
-0.010004320181906223,
-0.34909114241600037,
-0.17682380974292755,
0.163221076130867,
0.23600724339485168,
-0.03273884952068329,
-0.28274065256118774,
0.2636888027191162,
0.14827056229114532,
0.19390833377838135,
0.3371645212173462,
0.14945633709430695,
0.18206669390201569,
-0.09500570595264435,
-0.6476054191589355,
-0.20511214435100555,
0.5126858353614807,
0.7720036506652832,
-0.328766793012619,
0.3283401429653168,
0.22365626692771912,
-0.3021077811717987,
-0.02438962087035179,
-0.5252432823181152,
-0.08800436556339264,
-0.3841482102870941,
0.4121491312980652,
-0.5447660088539124,
-1.0246809720993042,
0.8779968023300171,
0.19503796100616455,
-0.10358739644289017,
0.40581411123275757,
0.16728827357292175,
-0.35391688346862793,
0.9397938251495361,
0.11536061763763428,
0.2101428508758545,
-0.0268330629914999,
-0.3054032325744629,
0.14606435596942902,
-0.8599899411201477,
-0.5338786840438843,
-0.9015290141105652,
-0.39189812541007996,
-0.5578071475028992,
-0.3822087049484253,
0.4007260799407959,
0.4332368075847626,
-0.5851143002510071,
0.12346251308917999,
-0.4315725862979889,
0.3112720251083374,
0.5690889954566956,
0.15232467651367188,
0.599330723285675,
-0.36943739652633667,
0.04304009675979614,
-0.10819267481565475,
-0.5327097773551941,
-0.30014899373054504,
1.1603935956954956,
0.20844177901744843,
0.6503381729125977,
0.262610524892807,
0.586161732673645,
0.38150858879089355,
0.20440088212490082,
-0.8522247076034546,
0.35965991020202637,
0.11597583442926407,
-0.9966202974319458,
-0.5612604022026062,
-0.6353112459182739,
-0.9070486426353455,
0.1783405989408493,
-0.19915051758289337,
-0.4433426856994629,
0.13031692802906036,
-0.2281656712293625,
-0.4084579348564148,
0.16419503092765808,
-0.3971720039844513,
0.41364434361457825,
-0.010604286566376686,
-0.1973816305398941,
-0.10042048990726471,
-0.8785521984100342,
0.2016850709915161,
0.10961693525314331,
0.16930322349071503,
0.0685780718922615,
-0.24549803137779236,
0.9797593355178833,
-0.37412533164024353,
0.22497011721134186,
-0.1078399196267128,
0.17091697454452515,
0.4736124575138092,
0.46189019083976746,
0.25146421790122986,
0.03449680283665657,
-0.048998408019542694,
-0.37301206588745117,
0.6646519303321838,
-0.7126575112342834,
-1.1568657159805298,
0.5608403086662292,
-0.6054978966712952,
-0.732093334197998,
-0.5672791004180908,
-0.5159907341003418,
-0.29984480142593384,
0.24344484508037567,
0.16705642640590668,
0.31467610597610474,
-0.0370858795940876,
0.5137421488761902,
0.8468295931816101,
0.007738931570202112,
0.03747926652431488,
0.7630760073661804,
0.23996838927268982,
-0.2327328473329544,
0.788076639175415,
0.6316419243812561,
0.21961012482643127,
0.8603690266609192,
-0.04882754012942314,
-0.4206978976726532,
-1.0237668752670288,
-0.20355036854743958,
0.1354704052209854,
-0.6389706134796143,
-0.4710729420185089,
-0.668118953704834,
-0.23136141896247864,
-0.0542890764772892,
0.2538115382194519,
-0.22051005065441132,
-0.44792261719703674,
-0.46342384815216064,
-0.08836188167333603,
0.1626136153936386,
0.9102116227149963,
0.017487619072198868,
-0.07634122669696808,
-0.7607211470603943,
0.15086135268211365,
0.5543491244316101,
0.5268368124961853,
0.06245025247335434,
-0.8370470404624939,
0.017110217362642288,
-0.2066948562860489,
-0.27867552638053894,
-0.8140427470207214,
0.12371719628572464,
0.0915227010846138,
0.3033125400543213,
0.037114229053258896,
0.6112456321716309,
0.5200095772743225,
-0.08960739523172379,
0.7651540637016296,
-0.06752140820026398,
-0.7152555584907532,
0.42263662815093994,
-0.20293322205543518,
0.17632529139518738,
0.6952527165412903,
0.6821555495262146,
-0.39154547452926636,
-0.4560965895652771,
-0.5027932524681091,
-0.7872801423072815,
0.20009352266788483,
0.018590610474348068,
0.18957392871379852,
-0.1759040653705597,
0.8801937699317932,
-0.14711478352546692,
0.10555726289749146,
-0.20395931601524353,
-0.17573019862174988,
0.14012770354747772,
-0.19574706256389618,
0.22135013341903687,
-0.3840397596359253,
0.13889290392398834,
0.04227490723133087,
0.28938281536102295,
0.028908200562000275,
0.06871268898248672,
0.4829062819480896,
-0.1790563464164734,
-0.2280157059431076,
0.5269395112991333,
0.16401958465576172,
0.7600039839744568,
-0.6452712416648865,
0.007863509468734264,
0.21665984392166138,
-0.3922787308692932,
0.27301979064941406,
-0.2686779499053955,
-0.017491159960627556,
-0.3664678633213043,
0.7669406533241272,
0.2826271653175354,
0.015373452566564083,
-0.7424436211585999,
0.653078019618988,
-0.026244526728987694,
-0.36086609959602356,
-0.3346115052700043,
0.2333695888519287,
-0.05033582076430321,
0.22331924736499786,
0.9874852895736694,
-0.2063269168138504,
0.4458376169204712,
-0.517675518989563,
0.14430366456508636,
0.540026068687439,
-0.8378051519393921,
-0.06837647408246994,
0.4132571220397949,
-0.022062968462705612,
-0.5534637570381165,
0.8716596364974976,
-0.07455337792634964,
-0.41406989097595215,
0.6686682105064392,
0.14631158113479614,
0.3677620589733124,
-0.008517468348145485,
0.09079442173242569,
0.47719237208366394,
0.42308443784713745,
-0.17499257624149323,
0.37030190229415894,
-0.13269734382629395,
-0.3998900353908539,
-0.3640885055065155,
-0.6134063601493835,
-0.7841618657112122,
-0.09921909868717194,
-1.2737152576446533,
-0.2141909897327423,
-0.4921029806137085,
0.05402509123086929,
-0.10616767406463623,
0.5655056834220886,
-0.5907379388809204,
0.6042781472206116,
-0.7133645415306091,
1.0243016481399536,
-0.5238735675811768,
-0.04661014676094055,
0.4341249167919159,
-0.5340766906738281,
-0.6214410662651062,
-0.34216928482055664,
-0.4352162480354309,
-0.5352959632873535,
0.6309980750083923,
-0.08630970865488052,
-0.31431087851524353,
-0.02740517258644104,
-0.5811666250228882,
-0.7929885387420654,
1.339060664176941,
0.28302958607673645,
-0.26885607838630676,
-0.12200767546892166,
-0.08116070181131363,
0.8406687378883362,
-0.29161345958709717,
0.8709548711776733,
0.5510775446891785,
0.35913848876953125,
0.21354734897613525,
-0.8548294305801392,
0.0123943155631423,
-0.3118019104003906,
0.02428412064909935,
0.1686474233865738,
-0.5683934688568115,
0.5664359927177429,
-0.5053688883781433,
-0.4382965862751007,
0.35703545808792114,
0.7748329639434814,
0.03471805527806282,
0.6411086916923523,
0.5901901125907898,
0.5154187679290771,
0.8413112163543701,
-0.1048765778541565,
0.7571706175804138,
0.07320176064968109,
0.3548155725002289,
0.9412779808044434,
-0.06880287826061249,
1.068954586982727,
0.595529317855835,
-0.5344855785369873,
0.7237052917480469,
0.7222994565963745,
0.2990991175174713,
0.18819721043109894,
0.9630070328712463,
-0.14102934300899506,
-0.5648157000541687,
-0.1380138099193573,
-0.3593377470970154,
0.4428565502166748,
0.22454622387886047,
-0.09088078141212463,
0.07273001223802567,
-0.1066296398639679,
-0.4040033519268036,
0.36144644021987915,
-0.12701202929019928,
0.6110048890113831,
0.003942954353988171,
-0.8344473242759705,
0.5915382504463196,
-0.11262170970439911,
0.4690134823322296,
-0.5141808390617371,
0.0894184559583664,
-0.5933408141136169,
-0.20778405666351318,
-0.27655842900276184,
-1.0933970212936401,
0.3842637240886688,
-0.18637749552726746,
-0.5698045492172241,
0.25866618752479553,
0.24150407314300537,
-0.12855412065982819,
-0.23178085684776306,
0.41915667057037354,
0.8489465713500977,
0.4563612937927246,
-0.23814451694488525,
-0.39858177304267883,
-0.10031626373529434,
-0.26793020963668823,
-0.433541864156723,
0.36105555295944214,
0.533481776714325,
0.0819774717092514,
1.20685613155365,
0.334700345993042,
-0.06835754215717316,
0.11094695329666138,
-0.15633828938007355,
0.5570908784866333,
-0.8184436559677124,
-0.04762013256549835,
-0.23790955543518066,
0.18474081158638,
0.16466820240020752,
-0.2856660783290863,
0.4140738546848297,
0.5290809869766235,
0.7307385802268982,
0.2136831134557724,
0.5119508504867554,
-0.21692998707294464,
0.9622751474380493,
-0.250924676656723,
0.3720639646053314,
-0.9084447026252747,
0.5516788363456726,
-0.26464399695396423,
-0.8930731415748596,
-0.4324890375137329,
0.08555667102336884,
-0.14417491853237152,
0.09667336195707321,
0.8450180888175964,
1.0133240222930908,
0.14138482511043549,
-0.036619141697883606,
0.2622417211532593,
-0.1553196758031845,
0.17064137756824493,
1.0379340648651123,
0.8805941939353943,
-0.7664872407913208,
1.0911506414413452,
-0.1353931427001953,
-0.24866758286952972,
-0.04339081048965454,
-0.5591253638267517,
-0.510095477104187,
-0.7648295760154724,
-0.22567787766456604,
-0.44980350136756897,
0.146525576710701,
0.45286574959754944,
0.4253631830215454,
-0.851571798324585,
-0.2067202627658844,
0.13054099678993225,
0.5358457565307617,
-0.2716081142425537,
-0.26697447896003723,
0.4415518343448639,
-0.41919758915901184,
-0.5582687258720398,
0.11954446136951447,
0.15456551313400269,
-0.2091427892446518,
-0.44261258840560913,
0.10346979647874832,
-0.15922494232654572,
0.12020351737737656,
0.3905118405818939,
0.4943699836730957,
-0.511734127998352,
-0.7293812036514282,
0.5286134481430054,
-0.15575070679187775,
-0.06127393618226051,
0.964444100856781,
-0.49598464369773865,
0.5632088780403137,
0.8154932260513306,
0.7041108012199402,
0.6685830354690552,
0.0880272313952446,
0.37453964352607727,
-0.5826510190963745,
-0.7229556441307068,
0.5103321075439453,
0.03601374104619026,
0.36338549852371216,
-0.23293626308441162,
0.5816306471824646,
0.2570708990097046,
-0.6499340534210205,
-1.0721216201782227,
0.30958738923072815,
-0.9551259279251099,
-0.1544989049434662,
0.7739721536636353,
-0.34919968247413635,
-0.026289088651537895,
-0.5081998109817505,
0.1676630675792694,
-0.029750164598226547,
-0.14723311364650726,
0.6442970037460327,
0.8056111931800842,
-0.23406949639320374,
-0.2738450765609741,
-0.41216474771499634,
0.33703741431236267,
0.6276568174362183,
-0.3058149814605713,
0.001522200764156878,
0.3105393052101135,
0.4750068783760071,
0.40220189094543457,
0.8103537559509277,
-0.2925279140472412,
0.3497867286205292,
-0.2700454890727997,
-0.2987395226955414,
0.13589662313461304,
-0.34045764803886414,
-0.0827394425868988,
0.8075777888298035,
0.25089022517204285,
0.09998111426830292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06592v1
|
Improve Mathematical Reasoning in Language Models by Automated Process Supervision
| 2024-06-05T19:25:40 | 2024-06-05T19:25:40 |
Liangchen Luo, Yinxiao Liu, Rosanne Liu, Samrat Phatale, Harsh Lara, Yunxuan Li, Lei Shu, Yun Zhu, Lei Meng, Jiao Sun, Abhinav Rastogi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Complex multi-step reasoning tasks, such as solving mathematical problems or
generating code, remain a significant hurdle for even the most advanced large
language models (LLMs). Verifying LLM outputs with an Outcome Reward Model
(ORM) is a standard inference-time technique aimed at enhancing the reasoning
performance of LLMs. However, this still proves insufficient for reasoning
tasks with a lengthy or multi-hop reasoning chain, where the intermediate
outcomes are neither properly rewarded nor penalized. Process supervision
addresses this limitation by assigning intermediate rewards during the
reasoning process. To date, the methods used to collect process supervision
data have relied on either human annotation or per-step Monte Carlo estimation,
both prohibitively expensive to scale, thus hindering the broad application of
this technique. In response to this challenge, we propose a novel
divide-and-conquer style Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) algorithm named
\textit{OmegaPRM} for the efficient collection of high-quality process
supervision data. This algorithm swiftly identifies the first error in the
Chain of Thought (CoT) with binary search and balances the positive and
negative examples, thereby ensuring both efficiency and quality. As a result,
we are able to collect over 1.5 million process supervision annotations to
train a Process Reward Model (PRM). Utilizing this fully automated process
supervision alongside the weighted self-consistency algorithm, we have enhanced
the instruction tuned Gemini Pro model's math reasoning performance, achieving
a 69.4\% success rate on the MATH benchmark, a 36\% relative improvement from
the 51\% base model performance. Additionally, the entire process operates
without any human intervention, making our method both financially and
computationally cost-effective compared to existing methods.
|
[
-0.3687017261981964,
-0.6385053396224976,
0.757739245891571,
0.0740419402718544,
-0.17601749300956726,
0.04743485152721405,
-0.14471223950386047,
-0.0971204936504364,
-0.060706768184900284,
0.6980094909667969,
-0.6687200665473938,
-0.6333000063896179,
-0.9068167805671692,
0.0336604118347168,
0.04065525531768799,
0.8634629845619202,
-0.38351970911026,
-0.021021835505962372,
-0.15515047311782837,
0.2696562707424164,
0.008322841487824917,
-0.6087468266487122,
-1.0682822465896606,
-0.36558306217193604,
0.43059390783309937,
0.5309745073318481,
0.5876469612121582,
0.7465440034866333,
0.8364353775978088,
0.3023507595062256,
0.028774861246347427,
0.527411699295044,
-0.15825966000556946,
0.021290376782417297,
-0.29771384596824646,
-0.47111427783966064,
-0.6785579919815063,
0.10415905714035034,
0.26998254656791687,
0.35835155844688416,
-0.43226030468940735,
0.03102429397404194,
-0.2706931531429291,
0.6768065094947815,
-0.7786791324615479,
0.4925382733345032,
-0.5385226607322693,
0.00869788508862257,
-0.2587195634841919,
-0.5369210839271545,
-0.5420103669166565,
-0.40684956312179565,
-0.25288182497024536,
-0.48598915338516235,
0.14750799536705017,
-0.09793992340564728,
0.5039682388305664,
0.27157607674598694,
-0.3232300877571106,
-0.5284693837165833,
-0.48577621579170227,
0.8123126029968262,
-0.7876882553100586,
0.08379842340946198,
0.4523569643497467,
0.36476317048072815,
-0.3298511207103729,
-0.5758007764816284,
-0.3433038294315338,
-0.3461902439594269,
0.09751439839601517,
0.19955413043498993,
0.08131689578294754,
0.21878467500209808,
0.506190836429596,
0.0930158793926239,
-0.19881194829940796,
-0.2304447442293167,
-0.19379405677318573,
-0.09486512094736099,
0.7276211380958557,
0.14545516669750214,
0.20240814983844757,
-0.14330129325389862,
-0.04736662283539772,
-0.43554699420928955,
-0.4259968101978302,
0.24875777959823608,
0.39695343375205994,
0.27727892994880676,
0.33396241068840027,
0.6642886996269226,
-0.24230925738811493,
0.5098379254341125,
-0.2627658545970917,
-0.2797592282295227,
-0.004130987916141748,
-0.08345649391412735,
-0.12988010048866272,
0.22493411600589752,
0.7405231595039368,
0.011351874098181725,
0.4948750138282776,
0.18820823729038239,
-0.42746227979660034,
0.44127947092056274,
0.29759126901626587,
-0.6257016658782959,
-0.5029315948486328,
0.060602817684412,
-0.01376019511371851,
-0.14763613045215607,
0.18538321554660797,
-0.2249094694852829,
-0.03668037801980972,
-0.5186153650283813,
0.3272603750228882,
-0.7127972841262817,
-0.15339002013206482,
0.1955295205116272,
-0.016634782776236534,
-0.2877780795097351,
0.5035078525543213,
-0.8378259539604187,
0.3391638398170471,
0.9752472043037415,
0.7220796942710876,
-0.1408291459083557,
0.020469093695282936,
-0.8823919892311096,
-0.0032042129896581173,
-0.6141122579574585,
0.6698710918426514,
-0.6848223209381104,
-0.1385464072227478,
-0.38817980885505676,
-0.298715204000473,
-0.19521942734718323,
-0.6227744817733765,
0.9907773733139038,
-0.5082423686981201,
0.03268146142363548,
-0.19749580323696136,
-0.5341730117797852,
-0.037350259721279144,
0.28532713651657104,
-0.27570196986198425,
1.107365369796753,
0.027046164497733116,
-0.7527864575386047,
0.22134998440742493,
-0.8787534832954407,
-0.32106348872184753,
-0.15121839940547943,
-0.25640514492988586,
-0.6205477118492126,
0.22135289013385773,
0.6550877094268799,
0.354429692029953,
-0.07428515702486038,
0.5085852742195129,
-0.48762276768684387,
-0.33920034766197205,
0.25311461091041565,
-0.24247612059116364,
0.6375622749328613,
0.24654123187065125,
-0.4059816002845764,
0.23312823474407196,
-0.5901690721511841,
0.12378150224685669,
0.017752505838871002,
-0.08625254034996033,
-0.35107240080833435,
0.19079579412937164,
-0.5278581976890564,
0.44283491373062134,
-0.024906069040298462,
-0.5461984276771545,
0.46167537569999695,
-0.3515370190143585,
0.33445975184440613,
0.8883037567138672,
0.05122365057468414,
0.2483702152967453,
-0.15629909932613373,
0.7075288891792297,
0.2720142602920532,
0.3344372510910034,
-0.3632716238498688,
-0.40635815262794495,
-0.8497869968414307,
-0.4182514250278473,
0.23605968058109283,
0.5235759019851685,
-0.8946242928504944,
0.36172062158584595,
0.018967704847455025,
-0.2765459418296814,
-0.4805566966533661,
0.09729716181755066,
0.42460158467292786,
0.4951733350753784,
0.34633952379226685,
-0.38973602652549744,
-0.5945271253585815,
-0.7987037301063538,
-0.22091838717460632,
-0.147524893283844,
-0.08956822752952576,
0.15032564103603363,
0.48160773515701294,
-0.0022687199525535107,
0.9631159901618958,
-0.4302047789096832,
-0.3549440801143646,
0.005802322644740343,
0.49799594283103943,
0.4836348295211792,
0.6139132976531982,
-0.015292273834347725,
-0.44774168729782104,
-0.4803828299045563,
-0.12709183990955353,
-0.8433723449707031,
-0.3208986222743988,
-0.10078184306621552,
-0.3543148338794708,
0.196122944355011,
0.46692317724227905,
-0.3931257128715515,
0.41055822372436523,
0.4156941771507263,
-0.24212764203548431,
0.6127623915672302,
-0.41908591985702515,
0.1807292103767395,
-0.6475861072540283,
-0.11727265268564224,
0.15675747394561768,
-0.258178174495697,
-0.15527866780757904,
0.032168276607990265,
0.28291431069374084,
0.15831494331359863,
-0.2514321506023407,
0.239431232213974,
-0.44946420192718506,
-0.026070671156048775,
-0.3751894235610962,
0.10572605580091476,
-0.3495522737503052,
0.6377302408218384,
0.3012620210647583,
0.7306486368179321,
0.6854966878890991,
-0.5373307466506958,
0.38094425201416016,
-0.2612268328666687,
-0.23499560356140137,
0.7241421937942505,
-0.4648693799972534,
-0.02406497113406658,
-0.06467960774898529,
0.3792573809623718,
-0.8712447285652161,
-0.003273123176768422,
0.354869544506073,
-0.5794456601142883,
0.15146902203559875,
-0.23258143663406372,
-0.7437496781349182,
-0.29150840640068054,
-0.1592586487531662,
0.13497518002986908,
0.4530475437641144,
-0.6446426510810852,
0.7339786291122437,
0.0726226270198822,
-0.2688140571117401,
-0.4537412226200104,
-0.4000132381916046,
0.08982614427804947,
-0.06166793406009674,
-0.6019871234893799,
0.11457043141126633,
0.12852166593074799,
-0.21612435579299927,
-0.05746893957257271,
-0.4405481517314911,
0.2039644867181778,
0.14924922585487366,
0.2309737652540207,
0.375396728515625,
0.035208724439144135,
-0.013119122013449669,
0.3633529543876648,
-0.5409960150718689,
0.4904276430606842,
-0.559131383895874,
0.2664549946784973,
0.02101009711623192,
-0.7281729578971863,
-0.4693908393383026,
0.0419745072722435,
0.391088604927063,
-0.3248724639415741,
0.6958832740783691,
0.44542112946510315,
-0.2836896777153015,
-0.3455347418785095,
-0.5375969409942627,
-0.3489028513431549,
-0.4681673049926758,
0.091359943151474,
-0.5291032195091248,
-0.786141037940979,
0.2523834705352783,
-0.2507877051830292,
0.1495133638381958,
0.5361906886100769,
0.38887545466423035,
-0.09107526391744614,
1.667659044265747,
0.336789608001709,
0.19947680830955505,
0.3918767273426056,
-0.29750582575798035,
0.23851698637008667,
-0.9023674726486206,
-0.3538815379142761,
-0.5157489776611328,
-0.14409026503562927,
-0.3727213144302368,
-0.5760065913200378,
0.643076479434967,
0.4281449019908905,
-0.24061651527881622,
0.184648796916008,
-0.7644395232200623,
0.39319270849227905,
0.903969407081604,
0.07407259196043015,
0.6098887324333191,
0.03894074633717537,
-0.5933332443237305,
-0.1916269212961197,
-0.7513446807861328,
-0.6460965275764465,
1.0033315420150757,
0.17847144603729248,
0.7724294662475586,
-0.10813844203948975,
0.9369977712631226,
0.2390543669462204,
0.753434419631958,
-0.4193662405014038,
0.5350421071052551,
-0.005960864946246147,
-0.44353973865509033,
-0.28320086002349854,
-0.9674830436706543,
-0.6668292880058289,
0.33487141132354736,
0.0967027023434639,
-0.8237367868423462,
-0.12275026738643646,
0.30651792883872986,
-0.1739097535610199,
0.4174292981624603,
-0.5998451113700867,
0.7874189019203186,
-0.3732267916202545,
-0.37572434544563293,
-0.21955038607120514,
-0.4097404479980469,
0.6675904393196106,
-0.12372657656669617,
0.45579618215560913,
-0.2260512411594391,
0.1320164054632187,
0.7159686088562012,
-0.8524216413497925,
0.5558243989944458,
-0.15908688306808472,
-0.12909825146198273,
0.40627163648605347,
0.350970059633255,
0.7925443649291992,
0.28385400772094727,
0.027394507080316544,
-0.14191651344299316,
-0.004128915723413229,
-0.46329694986343384,
-0.6973219513893127,
0.6715548634529114,
-0.6283369064331055,
-0.46474167704582214,
-0.7387681603431702,
-0.5566970109939575,
-0.2159036099910736,
-0.07934839278459549,
-0.00404439028352499,
0.13870178163051605,
0.39398932456970215,
-0.11369981616735458,
0.6264503002166748,
-0.0942235067486763,
0.3684800863265991,
0.33570748567581177,
-0.35920631885528564,
-0.5549139380455017,
0.7154914140701294,
-0.03487532585859299,
0.17395490407943726,
0.37554070353507996,
0.11911727488040924,
-0.41739344596862793,
-0.2608199417591095,
-0.2643708288669586,
0.25480908155441284,
-0.5614826679229736,
-0.27144885063171387,
-0.7354146242141724,
-0.23207144439220428,
-0.31505247950553894,
-0.12661580741405487,
-0.6238242983818054,
-0.5099930167198181,
0.047021444886922836,
-0.0024626024533063173,
0.2990676760673523,
0.2655283510684967,
-0.24657343327999115,
0.35842955112457275,
-0.6368205547332764,
0.2603380084037781,
0.32907339930534363,
0.48235470056533813,
0.03779659420251846,
-0.5157460570335388,
-0.20354488492012024,
0.05038462206721306,
-0.49498480558395386,
-0.5947946906089783,
0.5374391674995422,
-0.17667554318904877,
0.42922863364219666,
0.38299909234046936,
0.21378971636295319,
0.7082679867744446,
-0.21063940227031708,
0.3035581409931183,
0.31018781661987305,
-1.0956709384918213,
0.6424528360366821,
-0.22291085124015808,
0.34189993143081665,
0.24459002912044525,
0.24341300129890442,
-0.49844884872436523,
-0.5673835873603821,
-0.8991203308105469,
-0.7259871959686279,
1.1687709093093872,
0.5083833932876587,
-0.39169827103614807,
-0.2060748040676117,
0.40772613883018494,
-0.267198771238327,
0.036201510578393936,
-0.3218889832496643,
0.020082222297787666,
0.18309880793094635,
-0.2511632740497589,
-0.14375552535057068,
-0.11902806162834167,
-0.01931096613407135,
-0.14591094851493835,
1.0406943559646606,
-0.11957554519176483,
0.051509782671928406,
0.2584429085254669,
0.0991920605301857,
-0.36561933159828186,
0.18583586812019348,
0.3439185321331024,
0.6827300190925598,
-0.24107736349105835,
0.5473657846450806,
0.08032698184251785,
-0.20607531070709229,
0.10818648338317871,
0.1865185648202896,
-0.009837783873081207,
-0.016331959515810013,
0.33854779601097107,
0.5892831087112427,
0.05870521813631058,
-0.8190264105796814,
0.22612957656383514,
-0.06387242674827576,
-0.3705219328403473,
-0.3335127532482147,
0.34551864862442017,
0.2653166353702545,
0.35304319858551025,
0.42561566829681396,
0.11127188056707382,
0.04901924729347229,
-0.4612285792827606,
0.28133994340896606,
0.38399091362953186,
-0.2484363168478012,
-0.07401666790246964,
0.6877281665802002,
-0.3032197058200836,
-0.4204168915748596,
0.9522638916969299,
-0.2486783266067505,
-0.665582001209259,
0.7858260273933411,
0.2092568427324295,
0.613059401512146,
-0.3527279794216156,
0.2597108483314514,
0.375800758600235,
0.34604576230049133,
-0.5570672154426575,
0.33563926815986633,
-0.1338040679693222,
-0.5320449471473694,
-0.8325496315956116,
-0.6053884029388428,
-0.6963630318641663,
-0.33378222584724426,
-0.5361091494560242,
0.2457377165555954,
-0.41283103823661804,
-0.308372437953949,
-0.052070848643779755,
0.05427220091223717,
-0.37558841705322266,
0.37673434615135193,
0.15172336995601654,
0.7580458521842957,
-0.7820397615432739,
1.004744291305542,
0.5433427691459656,
-0.3049205541610718,
-0.8576474189758301,
-0.5877336263656616,
-0.08444129675626755,
-0.5449928045272827,
0.7236458659172058,
0.059521861374378204,
-0.19067756831645966,
-0.0685219019651413,
-0.5223259329795837,
-0.8258039951324463,
0.7340183854103088,
0.400412917137146,
-0.7161259055137634,
0.12343893945217133,
0.12001445144414902,
0.5899364352226257,
-0.38698288798332214,
0.7202732563018799,
0.6613038778305054,
0.4063880145549774,
0.6223427653312683,
-0.7229204773902893,
-0.17083697021007538,
-0.2658540606498718,
0.0701771080493927,
0.5137138962745667,
-0.17800156772136688,
0.8250361084938049,
-0.24609635770320892,
-0.020511096343398094,
-0.26734763383865356,
0.628657877445221,
1.001770257949829,
0.5286813974380493,
0.5379615426063538,
0.7573087215423584,
0.5545651912689209,
-0.30989405512809753,
1.090726613998413,
-0.2590290904045105,
0.6088384985923767,
1.2056937217712402,
-0.16643865406513214,
0.7195221185684204,
0.5158007144927979,
-0.24736008048057556,
0.44653892517089844,
0.7665679454803467,
0.28812870383262634,
0.23662690818309784,
0.517777681350708,
-0.04963302239775658,
-0.7324374914169312,
0.038189634680747986,
-0.10605058819055557,
-0.02399200014770031,
0.3459230363368988,
-0.48626482486724854,
-0.24147580564022064,
-0.17775584757328033,
0.09687615931034088,
0.19506512582302094,
-0.24350030720233917,
0.47865408658981323,
0.2765580713748932,
-0.943603515625,
0.33399680256843567,
0.40134957432746887,
0.48467668890953064,
-0.635767936706543,
-0.18725241720676422,
-0.29018262028694153,
0.6019095182418823,
-0.16551730036735535,
-0.5036001205444336,
0.3624972105026245,
0.10533016175031662,
0.2104230523109436,
-0.43257424235343933,
0.3731096684932709,
-0.33773645758628845,
-0.8231907486915588,
0.15175166726112366,
0.3751380443572998,
0.11599060148000717,
-0.41400548815727234,
-0.7782795429229736,
0.07245894521474838,
-0.2381310760974884,
-0.3571063280105591,
0.12935657799243927,
0.8181519508361816,
-0.31449994444847107,
0.7827379703521729,
0.9123110771179199,
0.11205422878265381,
0.0729791522026062,
0.06584940105676651,
0.7680895924568176,
-0.6186990141868591,
-0.5478013753890991,
-1.1298542022705078,
0.33734264969825745,
-0.19023002684116364,
-0.06823877990245819,
0.7538480162620544,
0.688984751701355,
0.9954074025154114,
0.18028540909290314,
0.5985714793205261,
0.11537917703390121,
0.45946425199508667,
-0.4968903064727783,
0.1462731808423996,
-0.4050239026546478,
0.4904491603374481,
-0.46506139636039734,
-0.9184384346008301,
-0.45106056332588196,
0.9013112783432007,
-0.63254714012146,
0.18184182047843933,
0.8008797764778137,
0.6573498249053955,
-0.28547292947769165,
0.07360225170850754,
0.11180022358894348,
-0.0715557411313057,
0.5016601085662842,
0.8399213552474976,
0.7976234555244446,
-0.1488495022058487,
0.494655966758728,
-0.4960118532180786,
-0.42365461587905884,
-0.0973314642906189,
-0.9576349854469299,
-0.7819435596466064,
-0.09224247932434082,
-0.5805588960647583,
-0.29767221212387085,
0.12422274798154831,
1.073988437652588,
0.8607766032218933,
-0.9119524955749512,
-0.45509591698646545,
-0.4515935778617859,
0.1517307162284851,
-0.6487460136413574,
-0.1970369815826416,
0.4614390730857849,
-0.6354055404663086,
-0.7198091149330139,
0.1063086986541748,
0.5545801520347595,
-0.4567585587501526,
-0.21619287133216858,
-0.2794218957424164,
-0.15384334325790405,
0.18903817236423492,
0.37827131152153015,
-0.03801431879401207,
-0.6944888830184937,
0.050123218446969986,
-0.009004157036542892,
-0.1267455816268921,
0.08895717561244965,
0.9204884171485901,
-0.6243961453437805,
0.6206942200660706,
0.4084646999835968,
0.43563205003738403,
0.8991060853004456,
0.10651569813489914,
0.3744331896305084,
-0.485975444316864,
-0.3160278797149658,
0.2608502507209778,
0.41308438777923584,
0.10334296524524689,
-0.24898740649223328,
0.7567031979560852,
0.3624890446662903,
-0.41825753450393677,
-0.6307594776153564,
0.16218945384025574,
-0.9349097609519958,
-0.19440226256847382,
0.781350314617157,
-0.2916441857814789,
-0.32814720273017883,
0.28816041350364685,
-0.39607107639312744,
0.49472329020500183,
-0.653891384601593,
1.1250666379928589,
0.6967423558235168,
-0.32699817419052124,
-0.4940890371799469,
-0.4404536783695221,
0.30908724665641785,
0.6206855773925781,
-0.8381524085998535,
-0.02586503140628338,
0.3692149519920349,
0.10669159889221191,
0.06756353378295898,
0.5296814441680908,
-0.3370547592639923,
0.2602322995662689,
-0.267688125371933,
0.2266155481338501,
-0.36530593037605286,
-0.35485678911209106,
-0.10185661911964417,
0.38084515929222107,
-0.02670634351670742,
-0.0034421442542225122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03589v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03589v2
|
Ranking Manipulation for Conversational Search Engines
| 2024-06-05T19:14:21 | 2024-06-13T01:12:56 |
Samuel Pfrommer, Yatong Bai, Tanmay Gautam, Somayeh Sojoudi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Major search engine providers are rapidly incorporating Large Language Model
(LLM)-generated content in response to user queries. These conversational
search engines operate by loading retrieved website text into the LLM context
for summarization and interpretation. Recent research demonstrates that LLMs
are highly vulnerable to jailbreaking and prompt injection attacks, which
disrupt the safety and quality goals of LLMs using adversarial strings. This
work investigates the impact of prompt injections on the ranking order of
sources referenced by conversational search engines. To this end, we introduce
a focused dataset of real-world consumer product websites and formalize
conversational search ranking as an adversarial problem. Experimentally, we
analyze conversational search rankings in the absence of adversarial injections
and show that different LLMs vary significantly in prioritizing product name,
document content, and context position. We then present a tree-of-attacks-based
jailbreaking technique which reliably promotes low-ranked products.
Importantly, these attacks transfer effectively to state-of-the-art
conversational search engines such as perplexity.ai. Given the strong financial
incentive for website owners to boost their search ranking, we argue that our
problem formulation is of critical importance for future robustness work.
|
[
-0.21999776363372803,
-1.0826544761657715,
0.5182046294212341,
0.10050640255212784,
-0.08130396157503128,
0.4509432315826416,
-0.22092439234256744,
-0.5352109670639038,
0.13721349835395813,
0.6362395882606506,
-0.2511848211288452,
-0.5055896043777466,
-0.731218159198761,
-0.040925558656454086,
-0.5354325771331787,
0.9841363430023193,
0.6626313328742981,
-0.3299935460090637,
-0.056030839681625366,
0.08059070259332657,
-0.44110140204429626,
-0.8823302388191223,
-0.6701127290725708,
0.2502012252807617,
0.7225558161735535,
0.22170758247375488,
1.2770907878875732,
0.5841517448425293,
0.7089386582374573,
0.37638041377067566,
-0.27823564410209656,
-0.1320561170578003,
-0.8047975301742554,
0.549953043460846,
-0.21994271874427795,
-0.7207719087600708,
-0.2388758808374405,
0.056199848651885986,
0.12482526153326035,
0.6285823583602905,
-0.28513291478157043,
-0.23892639577388763,
0.07847185432910919,
0.30210167169570923,
-0.7591447830200195,
-0.18277479708194733,
-1.186248779296875,
-0.28647580742836,
-0.1786368489265442,
-0.43550896644592285,
-0.8302143812179565,
-0.4554758667945862,
0.11386167258024216,
-0.38359665870666504,
0.19773228466510773,
0.2507026493549347,
0.841947615146637,
0.26706111431121826,
-0.2442847341299057,
-0.39526063203811646,
-0.3477015495300293,
0.6324661374092102,
-0.7059832811355591,
0.11086345463991165,
0.24754180014133453,
0.3271949589252472,
-0.6656803488731384,
-0.6505400538444519,
-0.21157754957675934,
-0.22752529382705688,
-0.14313559234142303,
-0.06842486560344696,
-0.35569313168525696,
0.15855233371257782,
0.3281586766242981,
0.2045944631099701,
-0.5605833530426025,
0.41178542375564575,
-0.1552804410457611,
0.028583811596035957,
0.6620088219642639,
0.1172635480761528,
0.734423816204071,
-0.29569780826568604,
-0.37182965874671936,
-0.22840635478496552,
-0.9797662496566772,
0.032377272844314575,
0.4444252848625183,
0.5125173926353455,
0.32469701766967773,
0.5142158269882202,
-0.1770007312297821,
0.6417597532272339,
0.23436546325683594,
-0.0505543053150177,
-0.03818376734852791,
-0.2922493517398834,
-0.21850325167179108,
0.3514980673789978,
0.8056394457817078,
0.41577139496803284,
0.09787627309560776,
-0.22581003606319427,
-0.11282261461019516,
-0.27062860131263733,
0.5686010122299194,
-0.8621424436569214,
-0.07069691270589828,
0.19444864988327026,
-0.21456095576286316,
-0.8863604664802551,
0.33141615986824036,
-0.6536701321601868,
-0.573401153087616,
0.32609081268310547,
0.43141427636146545,
-0.14859990775585175,
0.24179407954216003,
-0.005292965564876795,
-0.12966378033161163,
-0.016700366511940956,
0.09804491698741913,
-0.9596587419509888,
0.08368896692991257,
0.7877146601676941,
0.8032276630401611,
-0.13416077196598053,
-0.09620992094278336,
-0.57200688123703,
0.3048080503940582,
-0.2910999059677124,
0.6923421025276184,
-0.6375096440315247,
-0.763725757598877,
0.24290446937084198,
0.08133719861507416,
-0.01906149834394455,
-0.8552479147911072,
0.42692282795906067,
-0.9907131791114807,
0.25490182638168335,
-0.042584195733070374,
-0.3882310390472412,
0.16976144909858704,
0.27332401275634766,
-0.5839715003967285,
0.5165250897407532,
-0.25875139236450195,
-0.6043639183044434,
-0.013471406884491444,
-0.3968828022480011,
-0.7909573912620544,
0.1482936590909958,
0.12503089010715485,
-0.3267849087715149,
0.042855873703956604,
0.4192664623260498,
0.4440365433692932,
0.07819028198719025,
0.3171309530735016,
-0.44539645314216614,
-0.3744452893733978,
0.5491059422492981,
-0.5333326458930969,
0.8113471269607544,
0.24222548305988312,
-0.33169248700141907,
-0.08851472288370132,
-0.2278187870979309,
-0.08661424368619919,
0.31709909439086914,
-0.3092704713344574,
-0.6199212074279785,
0.03951260447502136,
-0.1884414404630661,
0.031255025416612625,
0.3472592234611511,
-0.03949584811925888,
0.4904828369617462,
-0.8486733436584473,
0.5511918067932129,
0.8611341118812561,
0.485808402299881,
0.32813286781311035,
-0.1403270661830902,
0.5674330592155457,
-0.23557132482528687,
0.3530946969985962,
-0.2598845958709717,
-0.6498489379882812,
-0.6293246150016785,
0.023949163034558296,
0.28115811944007874,
0.6621353626251221,
-0.6293479800224304,
0.43512535095214844,
-0.3683537244796753,
-0.4641341269016266,
-0.22377893328666687,
0.06319443136453629,
0.45309439301490784,
0.34814131259918213,
0.2836812436580658,
-0.062504842877388,
-0.09050281345844269,
-0.8130089044570923,
-0.5853659510612488,
-0.2992216646671295,
-0.24930362403392792,
0.532211184501648,
-0.005024766083806753,
-0.019481593742966652,
0.6763668060302734,
-0.8723061680793762,
-0.12514770030975342,
-0.12143022567033768,
0.3110774755477905,
0.37153467535972595,
0.3492354154586792,
0.5029796957969666,
-0.848207414150238,
-0.32311803102493286,
-0.11063846200704575,
-0.48941460251808167,
-0.34723857045173645,
-0.22746679186820984,
-0.17065945267677307,
0.0004929215065203607,
0.4360317289829254,
-0.5922385454177856,
0.30176621675491333,
0.24510708451271057,
-0.21093866229057312,
0.5636326670646667,
0.11675623059272766,
0.382897287607193,
-1.036192536354065,
-0.12736615538597107,
-0.08184614032506943,
-0.31187617778778076,
-0.5994018316268921,
0.48726266622543335,
-0.2246631681919098,
-0.3793585002422333,
-0.7090324759483337,
0.25968921184539795,
-0.13393354415893555,
0.030976612120866776,
-0.16608567535877228,
0.18866433203220367,
0.06456873565912247,
0.3142072260379791,
-0.46889132261276245,
1.2615716457366943,
0.26220282912254333,
-0.6187761425971985,
0.15005037188529968,
0.39681345224380493,
-0.19237802922725677,
0.32194259762763977,
-0.7749255299568176,
0.1702740490436554,
0.20451070368289948,
0.1558810919523239,
-0.8290011882781982,
-0.11562454700469971,
0.20872144401073456,
-0.6284146904945374,
0.40307262539863586,
-0.30881643295288086,
-0.5939368009567261,
0.07999086380004883,
-0.5121178030967712,
0.20038048923015594,
0.37884461879730225,
-0.6666015982627869,
-0.05477071925997734,
0.5255420804023743,
-0.5580624938011169,
-0.6022734642028809,
-0.47253328561782837,
0.6940978169441223,
-0.4294387400150299,
-0.7318601608276367,
0.6139466166496277,
-0.22042293846607208,
-0.4498264193534851,
-0.23846735060214996,
-0.02475881017744541,
0.08176883310079575,
0.5583032965660095,
0.2405920773744583,
0.2586866021156311,
0.004917800426483154,
-0.11314591765403748,
0.011864744126796722,
-0.02768571674823761,
0.13803474605083466,
0.1617237627506256,
0.45957431197166443,
0.025210939347743988,
-0.30924907326698303,
-0.30223071575164795,
0.21929004788398743,
0.6148701310157776,
-0.08391670882701874,
0.755009651184082,
-0.08533472567796707,
-0.1419801265001297,
-0.08091716468334198,
-0.5326613187789917,
-0.3330051302909851,
-0.5840654969215393,
0.11767782270908356,
-0.22167851030826569,
-0.7694907188415527,
0.3160361647605896,
-0.06430564820766449,
-0.18624314665794373,
0.2252485454082489,
0.45077067613601685,
-0.15352560579776764,
1.539624810218811,
0.2974880635738373,
-0.441884845495224,
0.5396727919578552,
-0.06790555268526077,
0.4275846481323242,
-0.46592825651168823,
-0.1463407278060913,
-0.6118928790092468,
-0.3847847878932953,
-0.8905194997787476,
-0.10412275046110153,
0.2948729395866394,
0.1614074558019638,
0.03219980001449585,
0.4975551664829254,
-0.37603554129600525,
0.6611741185188293,
0.4944409728050232,
0.22960220277309418,
0.32828786969184875,
0.23241469264030457,
-0.07256883382797241,
0.03752004727721214,
-0.32874032855033875,
-0.4195331633090973,
0.8991300463676453,
0.024411693215370178,
0.8165588974952698,
0.4358164370059967,
0.4626551866531372,
0.6918258666992188,
-0.007825647480785847,
-0.7587946653366089,
0.5945065021514893,
-0.20460018515586853,
-0.4780614972114563,
-0.08675925433635712,
-0.26909497380256653,
-1.2810473442077637,
0.2638663947582245,
0.05478343740105629,
-0.7822971343994141,
0.12158516049385071,
-0.18124286830425262,
-0.33010968565940857,
-0.04451102763414383,
-0.6571000218391418,
0.6345662474632263,
-0.45102304220199585,
-0.589739978313446,
-0.4501093327999115,
-0.6838624477386475,
0.2716425955295563,
0.10509514063596725,
0.16745781898498535,
0.06259801238775253,
0.11851918697357178,
0.46823418140411377,
-0.5407823324203491,
0.7131521105766296,
0.06300270557403564,
0.00788724422454834,
-0.09562327712774277,
0.3075178563594818,
0.7658641934394836,
0.37180978059768677,
0.09429848939180374,
0.06720050424337387,
-0.31531938910484314,
-0.4653458297252655,
-0.8632872700691223,
1.0655955076217651,
-0.5548775792121887,
-1.3568528890609741,
-0.5474669337272644,
-0.11813484132289886,
-0.2517949044704437,
0.2598697543144226,
0.32745474576950073,
0.2203327715396881,
-0.2380514144897461,
0.3092191219329834,
0.8567986488342285,
-0.45712554454803467,
0.37713000178337097,
0.3234875798225403,
-0.0759194865822792,
-0.35404127836227417,
0.9752371311187744,
-0.06096181645989418,
0.33255887031555176,
0.37538570165634155,
0.1307036429643631,
-0.1262238472700119,
-0.738395094871521,
-0.18739068508148193,
0.013079486787319183,
-0.6259012222290039,
-0.2866371273994446,
-0.6085953712463379,
-0.3020731210708618,
-0.5326507687568665,
-0.4150238335132599,
-0.08672408014535904,
-0.4890299439430237,
-0.334879606962204,
-0.20546966791152954,
0.1013956218957901,
0.4615706503391266,
0.32058781385421753,
0.44577452540397644,
-0.5491488575935364,
0.35907161235809326,
0.5109138488769531,
-0.007892071269452572,
-0.23864294588565826,
-0.3704838454723358,
-0.1133633553981781,
-0.08913154155015945,
-0.4873731732368469,
-1.0572928190231323,
0.4753739833831787,
-0.035565610975027084,
0.4822026789188385,
0.6179978847503662,
0.16927242279052734,
0.7056810259819031,
-0.39125901460647583,
0.8301621675491333,
0.05938747152686119,
-0.6795005798339844,
0.8680041432380676,
-0.4427882432937622,
0.15875732898712158,
0.6982372999191284,
0.1780366450548172,
-0.4614415168762207,
-0.7549054026603699,
-0.5123155117034912,
-1.0359137058258057,
0.5040920972824097,
0.42743390798568726,
0.3206496834754944,
-0.11572501063346863,
0.11478572338819504,
-0.03337183967232704,
0.3616156280040741,
-0.32426199316978455,
-0.35605430603027344,
-0.11359903961420059,
0.16934387385845184,
0.1619488000869751,
-0.4114760160446167,
-0.0015482795424759388,
-0.07961054891347885,
0.8201907873153687,
0.16534142196178436,
-0.17730030417442322,
-0.06997596472501755,
-0.3516983687877655,
0.4035895764827728,
0.415086954832077,
0.40061357617378235,
0.43367353081703186,
-0.22232608497142792,
0.2373744696378708,
-0.29253530502319336,
-0.30855363607406616,
0.20275616645812988,
0.10069556534290314,
-0.40473219752311707,
-0.1563691645860672,
0.06928570568561554,
0.47973132133483887,
0.539723813533783,
-0.7861502766609192,
0.520955502986908,
-0.18091411888599396,
0.5517086982727051,
-0.021344732493162155,
0.13368558883666992,
-0.11482340842485428,
0.040498264133930206,
0.4093998372554779,
0.02448488026857376,
0.5376441478729248,
-0.5152491927146912,
0.20486751198768616,
0.7338541746139526,
-0.13860772550106049,
-0.2731880843639374,
0.6985910534858704,
0.29654234647750854,
-0.5086881518363953,
0.6576848030090332,
0.10417082160711288,
-0.6033896207809448,
0.5975974202156067,
0.5479075908660889,
0.8811112642288208,
-0.46873143315315247,
0.17913907766342163,
0.24759924411773682,
0.3571832478046417,
0.045708026736974716,
-0.30137863755226135,
0.02350297011435032,
-0.49417540431022644,
-0.069167859852314,
-0.34780147671699524,
-0.5389077663421631,
0.21913652122020721,
-0.5657106637954712,
0.3650430738925934,
-0.5124797821044922,
-0.2991170883178711,
0.12121505290269852,
-0.22459614276885986,
-0.3046807646751404,
-0.009686477482318878,
0.08504265546798706,
0.5047845244407654,
-0.4016120731830597,
0.423540860414505,
0.3101206123828888,
-0.45893940329551697,
-0.25592371821403503,
0.3022063076496124,
0.06873206794261932,
-0.7813255190849304,
0.3969128727912903,
0.39118853211402893,
-0.24253416061401367,
-0.027126677334308624,
-0.7996422052383423,
-0.760721743106842,
0.7749906182289124,
0.5189931392669678,
-0.4143012762069702,
-0.092032290995121,
0.15798711776733398,
0.3263169825077057,
-0.060237493366003036,
0.24031873047351837,
0.3809589147567749,
0.30926990509033203,
-0.13440769910812378,
-0.6519883275032043,
0.2671512961387634,
-0.3265499472618103,
-0.01859995722770691,
0.11587945371866226,
-0.49232709407806396,
0.2003878653049469,
-0.09796552360057831,
-0.46563854813575745,
0.12881357967853546,
0.18774226307868958,
0.3425351679325104,
0.1909438818693161,
0.4323400855064392,
0.5773609280586243,
0.49759793281555176,
0.01844656467437744,
1.1333950757980347,
-0.4190574586391449,
0.19803230464458466,
1.0036979913711548,
-0.26739731431007385,
0.9700788855552673,
0.6182416081428528,
-0.23449267446994781,
0.43975961208343506,
0.5501335263252258,
-0.18372391164302826,
0.6283037066459656,
0.24688322842121124,
-0.20667649805545807,
-0.09614338725805283,
-0.25868088006973267,
-0.5725919008255005,
0.4622112512588501,
0.3952401578426361,
-0.5115389227867126,
-0.11036335676908493,
0.004298041108995676,
0.3739904463291168,
0.047834642231464386,
0.09521184116601944,
0.9668386578559875,
-0.014330782927572727,
-0.6446126103401184,
0.8340880870819092,
0.06323090195655823,
0.625295102596283,
-0.41595619916915894,
0.13376066088676453,
-0.3154005706310272,
-0.16447192430496216,
-0.1769898533821106,
-0.635267436504364,
0.030768053606152534,
0.08915424346923828,
-0.1035686507821083,
-0.37619486451148987,
0.7213923335075378,
-0.03553071990609169,
-0.43563729524612427,
0.2921472489833832,
0.28165286779403687,
0.06814680993556976,
-0.33293718099594116,
-0.6176451444625854,
0.03549150004982948,
-0.16155178844928741,
-0.5645419359207153,
0.6298211812973022,
-0.2616966664791107,
0.1276562511920929,
0.6881036758422852,
0.9542601704597473,
-0.0600249357521534,
0.03283493220806122,
0.07272130995988846,
1.041770339012146,
-0.6762239336967468,
-0.5432701706886292,
-0.9425562024116516,
0.12386038899421692,
-0.34449371695518494,
0.22375935316085815,
0.8971272706985474,
0.5847991108894348,
0.6517539620399475,
0.27128615975379944,
0.8072949647903442,
0.14905399084091187,
-0.010657699778676033,
-0.6092867255210876,
1.1412686109542847,
-0.4489513039588928,
0.7682269811630249,
-0.16102838516235352,
-0.8299680948257446,
-0.354098379611969,
-0.013568013906478882,
-0.26528704166412354,
-0.28528615832328796,
0.46985581517219543,
0.8955963850021362,
0.11234617978334427,
-0.1311737298965454,
0.3387032449245453,
0.38773980736732483,
0.53657066822052,
0.3949037790298462,
0.7854110598564148,
-0.2117830365896225,
0.9151677489280701,
-0.25264957547187805,
-0.13924014568328857,
-0.43885689973831177,
-0.5508543848991394,
-0.7154291868209839,
-0.08446972072124481,
-0.3425213694572449,
-0.49207574129104614,
0.4663139879703522,
0.4896322190761566,
0.6192423105239868,
-0.8040866851806641,
-0.02691660448908806,
0.03595926985144615,
0.5157753825187683,
-0.14809899032115936,
-0.3389666974544525,
0.1030295267701149,
-0.3978620767593384,
-0.8741194605827332,
0.9819486141204834,
0.3926638662815094,
-0.0822291299700737,
-0.2699665129184723,
0.20228958129882812,
-0.12395572662353516,
0.21706613898277283,
0.5208810567855835,
0.18371601402759552,
-1.02755606174469,
-0.22740280628204346,
0.14606843888759613,
-0.2059853971004486,
0.3711824417114258,
0.7895435094833374,
-0.9883406758308411,
0.6148831248283386,
0.5718852877616882,
0.7682852149009705,
0.09200681746006012,
0.4776765704154968,
0.63564532995224,
-0.8777783513069153,
-0.05667916312813759,
0.08344539254903793,
0.14042066037654877,
0.31615808606147766,
-0.8017800450325012,
0.20798903703689575,
0.0729595422744751,
-0.48549002408981323,
-0.9957993030548096,
0.4004335105419159,
-0.8530117869377136,
-0.5640716552734375,
1.1069931983947754,
-0.10831265151500702,
-0.10242456942796707,
-0.03055107779800892,
-0.12160120159387589,
-0.05993703752756119,
-0.6689937710762024,
1.1682183742523193,
0.6449631452560425,
0.16662971675395966,
0.0998639464378357,
-0.48910942673683167,
0.3262852728366852,
0.2969433069229126,
-0.7872825860977173,
-0.08351169526576996,
0.3822757601737976,
0.1711372435092926,
0.23374608159065247,
0.03393057361245155,
-0.1599327027797699,
0.05726150795817375,
-0.4032704830169678,
-0.4624384939670563,
0.018553728237748146,
-0.1932753622531891,
-0.4091300070285797,
0.5936607718467712,
0.1138286218047142,
-0.12514278292655945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03496v1
|
Wings: Learning Multimodal LLMs without Text-only Forgetting
| 2024-06-05T17:59:40 | 2024-06-05T17:59:40 |
Yi-Kai Zhang, Shiyin Lu, Yang Li, Yanqing Ma, Qing-Guo Chen, Zhao Xu, Weihua Luo, Kaifu Zhang, De-Chuan Zhan, Han-Jia Ye
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs), initiated with a trained LLM, first
align images with text and then fine-tune on multimodal mixed inputs. However,
the MLLM catastrophically forgets the text-only instructions, which do not
include images and can be addressed within the initial LLM. In this paper, we
present Wings, a novel MLLM that excels in both text-only dialogues and
multimodal comprehension. Analyzing MLLM attention in multimodal instructions
reveals that text-only forgetting is related to the attention shifts from
pre-image to post-image text. From that, we construct extra modules that act as
the boosted learner to compensate for the attention shift. The complementary
visual and textual learners, like "wings" on either side, are connected in
parallel within each layer's attention block. Initially, image and text inputs
are aligned with visual learners operating alongside the main attention,
balancing focus on visual elements. Textual learners are later collaboratively
integrated with attention-based routing to blend the outputs of the visual and
textual learners. We design the Low-Rank Residual Attention (LoRRA) to
guarantee high efficiency for learners. Our experimental results demonstrate
that Wings outperforms equally-scaled MLLMs in both text-only and visual
question-answering tasks. On a newly constructed Interleaved Image-Text (IIT)
benchmark, Wings exhibits superior performance from text-only-rich to
multimodal-rich question-answering tasks.
|
[
-0.1297169327735901,
-0.7583572268486023,
0.3239588737487793,
0.35466697812080383,
-0.16876573860645294,
0.31902000308036804,
-0.15678636729717255,
-0.09548971056938171,
0.309452086687088,
0.5160179138183594,
-1.0243282318115234,
-0.3322980999946594,
-0.4649774730205536,
-0.018198028206825256,
-0.15851260721683502,
0.9386834502220154,
-0.016438663005828857,
-0.09460834413766861,
-0.6771215796470642,
-0.45080941915512085,
-0.033548809587955475,
-0.3775976300239563,
-0.7226899862289429,
0.06148269400000572,
1.3316315412521362,
0.35734331607818604,
0.3979533314704895,
0.6829574108123779,
0.44763854146003723,
0.24687787890434265,
0.02941279113292694,
0.6323712468147278,
-0.456109881401062,
0.18527890741825104,
0.030367054045200348,
-0.4540000259876251,
-0.15159954130649567,
-0.44382280111312866,
0.787723183631897,
0.4074811041355133,
0.26395824551582336,
0.16534525156021118,
0.02101125754415989,
0.9659088850021362,
-0.650177001953125,
0.299207866191864,
-0.7926676273345947,
0.06608375161886215,
-0.06319223344326019,
-0.4262010455131531,
-0.5800476670265198,
0.17223066091537476,
-0.16151298582553864,
-0.7072983980178833,
-0.09464317560195923,
-0.07731308043003082,
0.7380768656730652,
0.5124876499176025,
-0.5499725937843323,
-0.2902790606021881,
-0.2749932110309601,
0.8068149089813232,
-0.2868534326553345,
0.5078495144844055,
0.16953089833259583,
0.20580197870731354,
0.14895538985729218,
-0.6241983771324158,
-0.4578418731689453,
-0.06655216217041016,
0.027205629274249077,
0.44753989577293396,
0.1316608488559723,
0.1819482296705246,
-0.029940340667963028,
0.03908700868487358,
-0.6091893911361694,
-0.02775084599852562,
-0.31851229071617126,
-0.24373048543930054,
0.29136180877685547,
-0.025247199460864067,
0.44132155179977417,
-0.056457992643117905,
-0.7669885754585266,
-0.11672816425561905,
-0.6676115393638611,
0.4903913736343384,
-0.07617824524641037,
0.3649476170539856,
-0.2931082844734192,
0.6656072735786438,
0.2598491609096527,
0.6066814661026001,
-0.05785159766674042,
-0.5349257588386536,
0.2205413281917572,
-0.15707212686538696,
-0.3212892711162567,
-0.4598862826824188,
0.7074331641197205,
0.29914113879203796,
0.2615417242050171,
-0.0813046470284462,
-0.12224722653627396,
-0.12342256307601929,
-0.03125176951289177,
-0.492344468832016,
-0.03235350176692009,
0.1048731654882431,
-0.5857555270195007,
-0.09417790174484253,
-0.32686111330986023,
-0.31933414936065674,
-0.29510319232940674,
-0.14022110402584076,
0.6120855808258057,
-0.41278454661369324,
-0.27003714442253113,
-0.3795328438282013,
-0.09460052847862244,
0.28265732526779175,
0.13920587301254272,
-1.050726294517517,
-0.10532230138778687,
0.2797345221042633,
0.7744431495666504,
-0.2262227088212967,
-0.7183191776275635,
-0.7235262393951416,
0.2090982347726822,
-0.41483989357948303,
0.8297461867332458,
-0.48645567893981934,
-0.030366042628884315,
0.1413978636264801,
0.13857075572013855,
-0.4032275080680847,
-0.22114725410938263,
0.47750911116600037,
-0.4682953655719757,
0.0036775204353034496,
-0.2620626986026764,
-0.41228461265563965,
-0.29648804664611816,
0.4757561981678009,
-0.4907763600349426,
0.882946252822876,
-0.16421230137348175,
-0.7454057335853577,
0.14978773891925812,
-0.43378946185112,
-0.6748523712158203,
-0.12925931811332703,
-0.3205357491970062,
-0.5236886739730835,
-0.1169247031211853,
0.366151362657547,
0.707663893699646,
0.1484818309545517,
0.023433588445186615,
-0.3425509035587311,
-0.46458110213279724,
0.35078543424606323,
-0.6936009526252747,
0.5635067820549011,
-0.24479416012763977,
0.03231223300099373,
0.5000464916229248,
-0.6555468440055847,
0.07613291591405869,
0.02602706477046013,
-0.4580984115600586,
-0.11373268812894821,
0.07523936033248901,
0.46112769842147827,
0.25937673449516296,
0.17054973542690277,
-0.3349165618419647,
0.170587420463562,
-0.3052976131439209,
0.43554410338401794,
0.7706872820854187,
-0.04956553876399994,
0.543113112449646,
-0.6451693177223206,
0.316038578748703,
0.20632144808769226,
0.23050391674041748,
-1.0164988040924072,
-0.23264800012111664,
-1.1392017602920532,
-0.6423993110656738,
-0.18591594696044922,
0.4772980511188507,
-1.2326587438583374,
-0.1492595374584198,
-0.07461198419332504,
-0.24637150764465332,
-0.5381079912185669,
0.5480133295059204,
0.4881764054298401,
0.18644841015338898,
0.24687880277633667,
0.4537930190563202,
-0.5111455917358398,
-1.0281131267547607,
-0.20115472376346588,
-0.12516820430755615,
0.3475944697856903,
0.38572782278060913,
0.43189358711242676,
-0.4664786458015442,
0.5935745239257812,
-0.1700783520936966,
-0.5847595930099487,
-0.36544832587242126,
-0.1055055782198906,
-0.21968618035316467,
0.10211274027824402,
0.5416879057884216,
-1.0026146173477173,
-0.6880875825881958,
-0.05114739388227463,
-0.7140976190567017,
0.42089104652404785,
-0.5190871953964233,
0.040879104286432266,
0.46017399430274963,
0.577998161315918,
-0.7411574125289917,
0.11494524776935577,
0.48428839445114136,
-0.048631008714437485,
0.17029321193695068,
-0.28101709485054016,
-0.014621129259467125,
-1.1159485578536987,
0.009491275995969772,
-0.07681931555271149,
-0.1080152615904808,
-0.3766193985939026,
0.047417815774679184,
0.5489230155944824,
-0.06760729849338531,
-0.5680528283119202,
0.8638243079185486,
-0.6363780498504639,
0.009886843152344227,
-0.22021818161010742,
0.037612903863191605,
0.11890460550785065,
1.1237589120864868,
0.10462919622659683,
0.5574588179588318,
0.786582350730896,
-0.45403242111206055,
0.2166147530078888,
0.22823171317577362,
-0.042940404266119,
0.354620099067688,
-0.1839754432439804,
0.10301599651575089,
-0.653427004814148,
0.16370992362499237,
-1.4549696445465088,
-0.24463936686515808,
0.20786195993423462,
-0.5871615409851074,
0.3735118806362152,
0.057720281183719635,
-0.23123177886009216,
-0.25688546895980835,
-0.48631584644317627,
0.058607377111911774,
0.23048195242881775,
-0.4659784138202667,
0.8524325489997864,
-0.10370884090662003,
-0.28962862491607666,
-1.0382322072982788,
-0.7418708801269531,
0.05850042775273323,
0.12569181621074677,
-0.3124539256095886,
0.011016766540706158,
-0.3038709759712219,
0.21389350295066833,
0.23493434488773346,
-0.04815741255879402,
-0.3420296013355255,
-0.008088945411145687,
0.4313820004463196,
0.36141788959503174,
-0.2988450229167938,
0.5906732678413391,
0.4126887321472168,
0.14040197432041168,
-0.1916644424200058,
-0.19081297516822815,
0.09194982796907425,
-0.051515158265829086,
-0.4580947458744049,
-0.3348846435546875,
0.5265365242958069,
1.3149609565734863,
-0.3505899906158447,
0.7197880744934082,
0.9105002880096436,
-0.20074769854545593,
-0.16188427805900574,
-0.5914390683174133,
-0.11040420085191727,
-0.4064277708530426,
0.7784588932991028,
-0.5135478973388672,
-0.8637215495109558,
0.30278488993644714,
0.28935375809669495,
0.47741013765335083,
0.1711282730102539,
0.45135748386383057,
-0.6994987726211548,
0.6962376236915588,
0.8037398457527161,
0.04603598266839981,
0.5296693444252014,
-0.08339354395866394,
-0.06282129883766174,
-0.6571158170700073,
-0.3547644317150116,
0.022518036887049675,
-0.4595634937286377,
-0.12897151708602905,
-0.4765975773334503,
0.4193738102912903,
-0.11296556890010834,
-0.17064958810806274,
-0.20343296229839325,
-0.14099788665771484,
0.5760054588317871,
0.38402217626571655,
0.2872775197029114,
0.10990113765001297,
0.2402683049440384,
-0.22517265379428864,
-0.1728120893239975,
-0.8436062335968018,
-0.12943314015865326,
1.2193676233291626,
0.27954089641571045,
0.6438404321670532,
-0.16305793821811676,
0.5766974687576294,
0.21657952666282654,
0.46391117572784424,
-0.7711494565010071,
0.471734881401062,
-0.33238643407821655,
-0.5737330317497253,
-0.18341130018234253,
-0.30363622307777405,
-0.6289820075035095,
0.5250128507614136,
-0.4317495822906494,
-0.06981433928012848,
-0.31778010725975037,
0.14478915929794312,
-0.359739750623703,
0.38850125670433044,
-0.695181667804718,
0.7754561901092529,
-0.6440299153327942,
-0.6440985798835754,
0.06055649742484093,
-0.7169651389122009,
0.2852476239204407,
0.003627470461651683,
0.31819024682044983,
0.0589805468916893,
-0.3934014141559601,
0.5165183544158936,
0.16182851791381836,
1.1182996034622192,
-0.12027140706777573,
0.20756547152996063,
0.26132798194885254,
-0.29716941714286804,
0.2981775999069214,
-0.19669869542121887,
0.406637042760849,
-0.29361337423324585,
-0.12828294932842255,
-0.520534098148346,
-0.7423001527786255,
0.8346624970436096,
-0.859916627407074,
-0.3425294756889343,
-0.23658375442028046,
-0.6455013155937195,
-0.403089314699173,
0.2198898196220398,
0.04440423101186752,
0.5955811738967896,
0.015527530573308468,
0.3674583435058594,
0.9402668476104736,
-0.3040213882923126,
0.8378272652626038,
0.5741673111915588,
-0.39875760674476624,
-0.6560573577880859,
1.0284717082977295,
0.03432507812976837,
0.3283267915248871,
0.9731360077857971,
-0.04721216484904289,
-0.5666376948356628,
-0.30851510167121887,
-0.8319621682167053,
0.3830379545688629,
-0.8868576288223267,
-0.13336555659770966,
-1.0363441705703735,
-0.3957541286945343,
-0.15916761755943298,
-0.1928698569536209,
-0.2723407745361328,
-0.21224191784858704,
-0.443206787109375,
0.05277279019355774,
0.15830273926258087,
0.4696645140647888,
0.3023526966571808,
0.11561309546232224,
-0.8996760249137878,
0.5502185821533203,
0.4164144992828369,
0.06346781551837921,
0.22875885665416718,
-0.40713855624198914,
-0.27748027443885803,
0.008297472260892391,
-0.28553688526153564,
-0.4779964089393616,
0.20688912272453308,
0.6015344858169556,
0.7772209644317627,
0.4740138649940491,
-0.14283041656017303,
0.6799900531768799,
-0.4406968653202057,
0.5068115592002869,
0.6115089654922485,
-0.5686913132667542,
0.1813383847475052,
-0.33896833658218384,
0.6359996199607849,
0.33687087893486023,
0.4163613021373749,
-0.6434598565101624,
-0.28753936290740967,
-0.0776623860001564,
-0.5977984666824341,
0.44827327132225037,
0.0304331686347723,
0.21744930744171143,
0.13067448139190674,
0.30558857321739197,
0.11784040182828903,
0.2933850586414337,
-1.297025442123413,
-0.3698389232158661,
-0.1994442343711853,
-0.589900553226471,
-0.17668423056602478,
-0.4325565695762634,
0.17040513455867767,
-0.17491142451763153,
0.4776930510997772,
-0.38711994886398315,
0.1886403113603592,
0.22913604974746704,
-0.34660565853118896,
0.04288586229085922,
0.2045052945613861,
1.0065122842788696,
0.387443482875824,
0.13594064116477966,
0.2747403085231781,
-0.07195229083299637,
-0.2559654712677002,
0.27507150173187256,
-0.3727322518825531,
-0.1268560141324997,
0.005799711216241121,
0.7765801548957825,
0.9133486151695251,
0.6422975659370422,
-0.9134541749954224,
0.6353656649589539,
0.08836746215820312,
-0.46202874183654785,
-0.15181072056293488,
-0.2374730110168457,
0.47762513160705566,
0.41322389245033264,
0.5716384053230286,
0.6589998602867126,
-0.3176814019680023,
-0.6401064991950989,
0.2501785457134247,
0.5506056547164917,
-0.5586526989936829,
-0.08534020930528641,
0.5320411920547485,
0.4771081209182739,
-0.21605528891086578,
0.20663303136825562,
0.09034346044063568,
-0.5786172151565552,
0.5000629425048828,
0.4525490403175354,
0.7804043889045715,
-0.014985498040914536,
0.29811328649520874,
0.13833323121070862,
0.6754860281944275,
0.1378343403339386,
0.2535325884819031,
-0.42182767391204834,
-0.5222368240356445,
-0.5842965841293335,
-0.3780231177806854,
-0.28860193490982056,
0.1442386656999588,
-0.2966224253177643,
0.030691107735037804,
-0.5915075540542603,
0.022072182968258858,
-0.22617462277412415,
-0.3280074894428253,
-0.3334587514400482,
0.13082031905651093,
0.3435284495353699,
0.7870245575904846,
-0.8284928202629089,
0.7897667288780212,
0.9602083563804626,
-0.38589078187942505,
-0.4614981412887573,
0.0214393250644207,
-0.03549125790596008,
-0.801276445388794,
0.8079840540885925,
0.35364681482315063,
-0.31373876333236694,
-0.11867158859968185,
-0.24695834517478943,
-0.7366491556167603,
0.89692622423172,
0.2914883494377136,
-0.6125149726867676,
-0.21479368209838867,
-0.028728818520903587,
0.2710311710834503,
-0.2999756336212158,
0.4809068739414215,
-0.3286585807800293,
0.2775524854660034,
0.41737422347068787,
-0.6688302755355835,
-0.5625995993614197,
-0.3419596254825592,
-0.12699225544929504,
-0.07934565842151642,
-1.0603516101837158,
0.9641419649124146,
-0.36986449360847473,
-0.24181917309761047,
0.152467742562294,
0.6400207877159119,
-0.005967473145574331,
0.4772442579269409,
0.3523555397987366,
0.15771231055259705,
0.6266676783561707,
0.1499335616827011,
0.764226496219635,
0.04037743806838989,
0.05854178965091705,
0.8981367349624634,
-0.20561431348323822,
1.1798163652420044,
0.8056235909461975,
0.2892502248287201,
0.2832551896572113,
0.47370028495788574,
0.3895415663719177,
0.6993458867073059,
-0.2021537572145462,
-0.2030830830335617,
-0.5065338015556335,
0.17398902773857117,
-0.15118786692619324,
0.2338169813156128,
0.17437921464443207,
-0.32943883538246155,
-0.12341814488172531,
0.6452634334564209,
-0.2080097794532776,
0.3392859101295471,
-0.4943714141845703,
0.8193840384483337,
0.08963749557733536,
-0.6767706274986267,
0.7403785586357117,
-0.19111159443855286,
0.9144354462623596,
-0.9757386445999146,
0.0065727876499295235,
-0.2678675651550293,
0.5204688310623169,
-0.15450157225131989,
-0.5560550689697266,
0.13056938350200653,
-0.16151246428489685,
-0.5877525210380554,
-0.44093865156173706,
0.6433005928993225,
-0.9306368231773376,
-0.7414847016334534,
0.320538192987442,
0.35544800758361816,
-0.2744712233543396,
-0.0823778361082077,
-0.779068112373352,
0.3983529508113861,
0.2670483887195587,
-0.16437073051929474,
0.2603791654109955,
0.23294539749622345,
0.14996956288814545,
1.1804167032241821,
0.39925524592399597,
-0.21999719738960266,
0.14486199617385864,
-0.05126059427857399,
0.7949931621551514,
-0.462816059589386,
-0.39083045721054077,
-0.8388224840164185,
0.6453457474708557,
0.09157533198595047,
-0.22761598229408264,
0.7705798149108887,
0.5986405611038208,
0.39163538813591003,
-0.4461750388145447,
0.7823196649551392,
0.3739778995513916,
0.4331353008747101,
-0.7827686667442322,
0.8707102537155151,
-1.0717062950134277,
-0.17462803423404694,
0.056195925921201706,
-0.714194655418396,
-0.3050326108932495,
0.45302635431289673,
0.1831977218389511,
-0.16815081238746643,
0.8726072311401367,
0.7332761883735657,
0.017658168449997902,
-0.22959676384925842,
0.6899439096450806,
0.029274769127368927,
0.08600720018148422,
0.95918208360672,
0.968542218208313,
-0.5324794054031372,
0.7679200768470764,
0.11282163858413696,
-0.22706162929534912,
-0.299243688583374,
-0.5530667304992676,
-1.5882771015167236,
-0.8117052912712097,
-0.16443589329719543,
0.12741082906723022,
0.20359283685684204,
0.8630093932151794,
0.6767605543136597,
-0.37903156876564026,
-0.14001783728599548,
0.22375355660915375,
0.29221856594085693,
-0.39087584614753723,
-0.16891543567180634,
0.3000553548336029,
-0.5191006064414978,
-0.45435693860054016,
0.4469904899597168,
0.7610664367675781,
0.07756627351045609,
-0.4697076678276062,
-0.21907471120357513,
-0.4478658139705658,
0.1709626317024231,
0.7951852083206177,
0.1704835742712021,
-0.9971399903297424,
0.06562182307243347,
0.44304201006889343,
-0.35403597354888916,
0.06852345168590546,
0.6776297688484192,
-0.4755436182022095,
0.41770288348197937,
0.12609697878360748,
1.086371898651123,
0.6266754865646362,
-0.3800685703754425,
0.036251649260520935,
-0.889189600944519,
0.41353079676628113,
0.09407456964254379,
0.17095017433166504,
0.4313707649707794,
-0.18384237587451935,
-0.18922634422779083,
0.22700685262680054,
-0.17946140468120575,
-0.5412597060203552,
0.19814760982990265,
-1.1540436744689941,
-0.3084337115287781,
0.9440077543258667,
-0.15382020175457,
-0.43172547221183777,
0.1953534185886383,
-0.6078052520751953,
-0.07984474301338196,
-0.1518036276102066,
0.42310506105422974,
0.7528183460235596,
0.11899620294570923,
-0.8980918526649475,
-0.15267392992973328,
0.2793981730937958,
0.48821964859962463,
-0.6870118379592896,
0.03071957640349865,
0.30428385734558105,
0.18625043332576752,
-0.046888016164302826,
0.6583800315856934,
0.2470603734254837,
0.35450980067253113,
0.048038169741630554,
-0.01719336025416851,
-0.5013546943664551,
-0.6947669982910156,
-0.03964902460575104,
0.39353108406066895,
-0.08283648639917374,
-0.41846221685409546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03487v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03487v1
|
Analyzing LLM Behavior in Dialogue Summarization: Unveiling Circumstantial Hallucination Trends
| 2024-06-05T17:49:47 | 2024-06-05T17:49:47 |
Sanjana Ramprasad, Elisa Ferracane, Zachary C. Lipton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have considerably
advanced the capabilities of summarization systems. However, they continue to
face concerns about hallucinations. While prior work has evaluated LLMs
extensively in news domains, most evaluation of dialogue summarization has
focused on BART-based models, leaving a gap in our understanding of their
faithfulness. Our work benchmarks the faithfulness of LLMs for dialogue
summarization, using human annotations and focusing on identifying and
categorizing span-level inconsistencies. Specifically, we focus on two
prominent LLMs: GPT-4 and Alpaca-13B. Our evaluation reveals subtleties as to
what constitutes a hallucination: LLMs often generate plausible inferences,
supported by circumstantial evidence in the conversation, that lack direct
evidence, a pattern that is less prevalent in older models. We propose a
refined taxonomy of errors, coining the category of "Circumstantial Inference"
to bucket these LLM behaviors and release the dataset. Using our taxonomy, we
compare the behavioral differences between LLMs and older fine-tuned models.
Additionally, we systematically assess the efficacy of automatic error
detection methods on LLM summaries and find that they struggle to detect these
nuanced errors. To address this, we introduce two prompt-based approaches for
fine-grained error detection that outperform existing metrics, particularly for
identifying "Circumstantial Inference."
|
[
-0.36711248755455017,
-0.9155910015106201,
0.7610867023468018,
0.3834155797958374,
-0.20767413079738617,
0.18908749520778656,
-0.04275153949856758,
-0.3053760230541229,
0.35403671860694885,
0.630071222782135,
-0.6439638137817383,
-0.5779305696487427,
-0.5545180439949036,
0.31630152463912964,
-0.49340811371803284,
0.9908655285835266,
0.03613397479057312,
0.03252590075135231,
-0.19514530897140503,
-0.04712388291954994,
-0.446744441986084,
-0.6431248188018799,
-0.4810790419578552,
-0.28107988834381104,
0.4665789008140564,
0.13389872014522552,
0.6631598472595215,
0.3495239019393921,
0.34959790110588074,
0.2673454284667969,
-0.27095693349838257,
0.5423858761787415,
-0.47719794511795044,
0.1764935851097107,
0.26230475306510925,
-0.26936817169189453,
-0.6740570664405823,
-0.15385465323925018,
0.44578418135643005,
0.9193547368049622,
-0.1971297264099121,
-0.18343539535999298,
0.20721150934696198,
0.6278219223022461,
-0.4382775127887726,
0.32461896538734436,
-0.664705216884613,
0.10522811114788055,
-0.005171988625079393,
-0.3534802198410034,
-0.38443058729171753,
-0.647681474685669,
0.13023288547992706,
-0.4509759843349457,
0.4095810353755951,
0.13299109041690826,
0.6947119832038879,
0.4427652060985565,
-0.2047320455312729,
-0.7619713544845581,
-0.5731592774391174,
0.5433993935585022,
-0.9221564531326294,
0.09073170274496078,
0.48586225509643555,
0.046585939824581146,
-0.42956170439720154,
-0.5675742030143738,
-0.4851972162723541,
-0.3818913400173187,
-0.23986980319023132,
0.03712015971541405,
-0.42584189772605896,
0.31152111291885376,
0.29111355543136597,
0.44973406195640564,
-0.4881662130355835,
0.06356076151132584,
-0.29425472021102905,
-0.4192105531692505,
0.37424567341804504,
0.43427014350891113,
0.13590489327907562,
-0.1857486218214035,
0.020568465813994408,
0.07320266216993332,
-0.5943006873130798,
-0.1702582836151123,
0.5243883728981018,
0.1868714541196823,
-0.17743131518363953,
0.5999327898025513,
-0.26760977506637573,
0.22268284857273102,
0.03986821696162224,
-0.058780260384082794,
0.1241292953491211,
-0.344015896320343,
-0.2823239862918854,
0.18873019516468048,
0.769154965877533,
0.7551712393760681,
0.3501646816730499,
-0.27454042434692383,
-0.20050032436847687,
-0.02040031924843788,
0.1516764760017395,
-0.5667281150817871,
-0.362677663564682,
0.26235267519950867,
-0.4220591187477112,
-0.3245234489440918,
0.054263416677713394,
-0.7008360028266907,
-0.6491777896881104,
-0.2672378420829773,
0.11640534549951553,
-0.16443298757076263,
-0.11901409924030304,
0.10524013638496399,
-0.11265083402395248,
0.2136988490819931,
0.527213990688324,
-0.854600191116333,
0.42508605122566223,
0.7773053050041199,
1.0993545055389404,
-0.43346285820007324,
-0.2788647413253784,
-0.4377598166465759,
-0.019026411697268486,
-0.5128037333488464,
0.9228041768074036,
-0.17767713963985443,
-0.4929378032684326,
0.08328358829021454,
0.2009020298719406,
-0.07671576738357544,
-0.7400001883506775,
0.4734356105327606,
-0.15531966090202332,
0.14821191132068634,
-0.5227037668228149,
-0.576736330986023,
-0.35570865869522095,
0.2751161754131317,
-0.5694935917854309,
0.848594069480896,
0.11130480468273163,
-0.754000723361969,
0.048072587698698044,
-0.5416116118431091,
-0.06408833712339401,
-0.22150053083896637,
-0.2013840228319168,
-0.45453324913978577,
0.4499463140964508,
0.12341231852769852,
0.46792009472846985,
-0.041453730314970016,
0.5199002623558044,
-0.18710222840309143,
-0.6100981831550598,
0.44085800647735596,
-0.5909793972969055,
0.6374574303627014,
-0.002443882403895259,
-0.2719113528728485,
0.1795775592327118,
-0.5340779423713684,
-0.36723002791404724,
0.024411406368017197,
0.09705600142478943,
-0.22262871265411377,
-0.0936732143163681,
-0.378086656332016,
-0.22577321529388428,
0.0308638047426939,
-0.1027301698923111,
0.2375025600194931,
-0.31830838322639465,
0.19356362521648407,
0.6664596199989319,
0.3125385344028473,
0.22854386270046234,
-0.4908004105091095,
0.47197291254997253,
0.020016944035887718,
-0.04308714717626572,
-0.5104296803474426,
-0.3349459171295166,
-0.9200353622436523,
-0.17101749777793884,
-0.07818753272294998,
0.4511621296405792,
-0.48766008019447327,
0.48853957653045654,
-0.07249020785093307,
-0.32293546199798584,
-0.2398272156715393,
-0.01815013960003853,
0.2915399372577667,
0.46961817145347595,
0.3180369436740875,
-0.5359517931938171,
-0.590022623538971,
-0.7872401475906372,
-0.1728638857603073,
-0.44665956497192383,
-0.09759685397148132,
0.03816936910152435,
0.457433819770813,
-0.4179568588733673,
0.714058518409729,
-0.293494313955307,
-0.236575186252594,
-0.3572647273540497,
0.5284218788146973,
0.057222798466682434,
0.26775774359703064,
0.3040832281112671,
-0.12710072100162506,
0.06756332516670227,
-0.29740238189697266,
-0.9222065210342407,
-0.381438285112381,
-0.35459861159324646,
0.2152058482170105,
0.3979911804199219,
0.6692346334457397,
-0.6324659585952759,
0.6366121768951416,
0.3725036680698395,
-0.24194805324077606,
0.8398152589797974,
-0.15347324311733246,
0.08899994939565659,
-0.47545337677001953,
-0.2255946844816208,
-0.12026628851890564,
-0.13817360997200012,
-0.5871155858039856,
-0.4235280752182007,
-0.35189956426620483,
0.5753296613693237,
-0.12008615583181381,
0.13393297791481018,
-0.38105085492134094,
-0.4873887598514557,
-0.3298593759536743,
0.16758741438388824,
0.005056515336036682,
0.6283301711082458,
0.054172586649656296,
0.824288010597229,
0.10569653660058975,
-0.6079009175300598,
0.4050033390522003,
0.2796418368816376,
-0.24502258002758026,
0.2590128183364868,
-0.6557501554489136,
0.09152572602033615,
-0.28016480803489685,
0.4497585594654083,
-1.1120949983596802,
-0.5591909289360046,
0.5033870935440063,
-0.37171292304992676,
-0.025961382314562798,
0.10245093703269958,
-0.5632103085517883,
0.006610587239265442,
-0.599336564540863,
0.3659418225288391,
0.28181391954421997,
-0.32265058159828186,
0.5735793113708496,
0.1927565336227417,
-0.4266830086708069,
-0.3597998321056366,
-0.682216465473175,
0.22357475757598877,
-0.42567864060401917,
-0.3652760982513428,
0.024346068501472473,
0.0010327446507290006,
-0.609222948551178,
-0.4591580033302307,
-0.35310229659080505,
0.16580483317375183,
0.2584124803543091,
0.33894291520118713,
0.31425490975379944,
-0.1634111851453781,
-0.08822187781333923,
0.07842844724655151,
-0.039573997259140015,
0.43796253204345703,
0.3312439024448395,
0.6976457834243774,
-0.36602696776390076,
-0.5023453831672668,
-0.5975325703620911,
0.23659388720989227,
0.5860572457313538,
0.3089436888694763,
0.33875772356987,
0.3768378794193268,
-0.25769296288490295,
0.15419557690620422,
-0.7885422110557556,
-0.3427776098251343,
-0.384584903717041,
0.3912340998649597,
-0.06807597726583481,
-0.7640926241874695,
0.8395443558692932,
0.017680779099464417,
0.11608719080686569,
0.2963443994522095,
0.5575960874557495,
-0.19835585355758667,
0.835936963558197,
0.44247230887413025,
0.08850445598363876,
0.16791896522045135,
-0.10630810260772705,
0.182517409324646,
-0.8755334615707397,
-0.4091914892196655,
-0.4249303936958313,
0.08836294710636139,
-0.5923084616661072,
-0.25999483466148376,
0.43109652400016785,
0.010645288974046707,
-0.1451568454504013,
0.036842525005340576,
-0.2878293991088867,
0.6014602780342102,
0.3611226975917816,
-0.22239834070205688,
0.740752637386322,
-0.06758134812116623,
0.06957888603210449,
-0.09594210982322693,
-0.41468754410743713,
-0.8691117763519287,
0.8092070817947388,
0.5713027119636536,
0.8477333188056946,
0.2279379665851593,
0.5951939225196838,
0.5165126323699951,
0.25545570254325867,
-0.9509435892105103,
0.509846568107605,
0.2904212176799774,
-0.12000863999128342,
-0.2949551045894623,
-0.2987443208694458,
-0.7324463725090027,
0.40823230147361755,
0.04764241725206375,
-0.9210968613624573,
0.16246706247329712,
0.17821986973285675,
-0.42464500665664673,
0.12757699191570282,
-0.5207032561302185,
0.8251139521598816,
-0.12527868151664734,
-0.11899683624505997,
-0.05058293789625168,
-0.7168228030204773,
0.8709743022918701,
0.0523129366338253,
0.18933463096618652,
-0.2863540053367615,
0.044407203793525696,
0.5915544629096985,
-0.3025434613227844,
1.0647467374801636,
0.03092312067747116,
-0.4536221921443939,
0.15317535400390625,
0.30162644386291504,
0.6192190647125244,
-0.016370289027690887,
0.31799566745758057,
0.20287850499153137,
0.0789434015750885,
-0.1303606629371643,
-0.5879936814308167,
0.35608237981796265,
-0.5385558605194092,
-0.5445586442947388,
-0.6518101692199707,
-0.6014190316200256,
-0.30589354038238525,
-0.3019294738769531,
0.3243980407714844,
0.35313159227371216,
-0.3560057580471039,
-0.06751835346221924,
0.7766110897064209,
-0.2819931209087372,
0.5834597945213318,
0.2921810746192932,
-0.42945072054862976,
-0.25629210472106934,
0.7591781616210938,
-0.03756868094205856,
0.2619548738002777,
0.00518924230709672,
0.014542177319526672,
-0.32742464542388916,
-0.868242084980011,
-0.2853272557258606,
0.4415251910686493,
-0.7803433537483215,
-0.08652470260858536,
-0.7453390955924988,
-0.22861483693122864,
-0.24637648463249207,
-0.028636101633310318,
-0.19947397708892822,
-0.47242119908332825,
-0.3947930634021759,
-0.20902834832668304,
0.14324723184108734,
0.7933993339538574,
0.09825789928436279,
0.5345529913902283,
-0.7014506459236145,
0.25034284591674805,
0.09293541312217712,
0.009082677774131298,
0.12042747437953949,
-0.6886053681373596,
-0.06263460963964462,
-0.08448191732168198,
-0.4899919927120209,
-0.9004730582237244,
0.5035384297370911,
-0.09873642772436142,
0.3423927426338196,
0.5901280045509338,
0.06803052872419357,
0.8490524291992188,
-0.285439133644104,
1.0075496435165405,
0.1675611436367035,
-1.0441890954971313,
0.3143365979194641,
-0.38728898763656616,
0.2209802269935608,
0.53972989320755,
0.15293464064598083,
-0.7320843935012817,
-0.87905353307724,
-0.6274960041046143,
-0.6441099643707275,
0.5197516679763794,
0.18199418485164642,
0.10033278912305832,
-0.14427949488162994,
0.25722038745880127,
0.2893539071083069,
0.27828264236450195,
-0.6300294995307922,
-0.15922492742538452,
-0.21238914132118225,
-0.14181843400001526,
0.07984194904565811,
-0.5050702095031738,
-0.1691143661737442,
-0.11897570639848709,
0.5912787318229675,
-0.3051120936870575,
0.22306160628795624,
0.26674774289131165,
-0.28364038467407227,
0.015678731724619865,
0.24505648016929626,
0.9553239345550537,
0.8640281558036804,
-0.3746289312839508,
0.26261791586875916,
0.3460194766521454,
-0.43443942070007324,
0.024026082828640938,
-0.08586938679218292,
-0.05530881881713867,
0.4326464533805847,
0.6497288942337036,
0.6692555546760559,
0.15391935408115387,
-0.8304779529571533,
0.6304689049720764,
-0.19820094108581543,
-0.14004234969615936,
-0.6137070059776306,
-0.0029310232494026423,
-0.11274541914463043,
0.26339176297187805,
0.4025213122367859,
-0.007321290671825409,
0.5266076922416687,
-0.6848843693733215,
-0.045899923890829086,
0.4878635108470917,
-0.22072766721248627,
-0.4605312943458557,
0.43296873569488525,
0.1556386649608612,
-0.07597324997186661,
0.43472182750701904,
-0.3943920433521271,
-0.4642743766307831,
0.49932944774627686,
0.2037707269191742,
1.1151158809661865,
-0.08368251472711563,
0.22676528990268707,
0.19283455610275269,
0.4428200125694275,
-0.3052542507648468,
-0.06813979893922806,
-0.12802071869373322,
-0.6937600374221802,
-0.5750473141670227,
-0.29023507237434387,
-0.7490670084953308,
0.2229413390159607,
-0.7423813939094543,
0.0789903774857521,
-0.3098588287830353,
0.0006864449824206531,
-0.06812717765569687,
-0.22212231159210205,
-0.20753100514411926,
-0.2500568628311157,
0.14362706243991852,
0.5818924307823181,
-0.8262622356414795,
0.46604448556900024,
0.10909780114889145,
-0.29511144757270813,
-0.43380028009414673,
0.1914297342300415,
0.3212577700614929,
-0.7837033271789551,
0.3094594180583954,
0.23755526542663574,
-0.3376782536506653,
-0.3038390874862671,
-0.5232589840888977,
-0.43408846855163574,
1.095354437828064,
0.24067245423793793,
-0.7018150687217712,
-0.3872593939304352,
0.11147762089967728,
0.4412168860435486,
-0.4558812975883484,
0.45406123995780945,
1.1430346965789795,
0.3774615526199341,
0.2534545958042145,
-1.0010377168655396,
0.08463141322135925,
0.22071970999240875,
0.04386533051729202,
-0.008863787166774273,
-0.5587838292121887,
0.45397502183914185,
-0.31307122111320496,
-0.22285597026348114,
0.3556126654148102,
0.654220461845398,
0.3928636908531189,
0.7102082371711731,
0.4245648980140686,
0.23060594499111176,
0.9605067372322083,
-0.3674880862236023,
0.7389456629753113,
0.19239076972007751,
0.1756526082754135,
1.3054823875427246,
-0.17884324491024017,
0.3720908463001251,
0.6007927656173706,
-0.14369404315948486,
0.3789938688278198,
0.6751383543014526,
-0.09740174561738968,
0.39257970452308655,
0.32398056983947754,
-0.28561270236968994,
-0.04769667610526085,
-0.09806400537490845,
-0.28198152780532837,
0.36356303095817566,
0.5507848262786865,
-0.3474779427051544,
-0.2910897731781006,
-0.10631348937749863,
0.26968109607696533,
-0.11012832820415497,
-0.23543602228164673,
1.1729527711868286,
0.11582258343696594,
-0.7919497489929199,
0.5595616698265076,
-0.1734744906425476,
0.5750152468681335,
-0.30748334527015686,
-0.08916470408439636,
-0.7056406736373901,
-0.17467942833900452,
-0.2939549684524536,
-0.45967334508895874,
0.582473874092102,
0.1778629720211029,
0.021213971078395844,
0.005139362532645464,
0.3381679058074951,
-0.3540654182434082,
-0.18294979631900787,
-0.02454472705721855,
0.576950192451477,
0.655853807926178,
-0.11648552864789963,
-0.35157766938209534,
0.5657975077629089,
0.23068125545978546,
-0.03564120829105377,
0.06344389915466309,
0.6219199895858765,
-0.20011670887470245,
0.6301327347755432,
0.3887141942977905,
0.11004170775413513,
0.00996032077819109,
0.3409748673439026,
0.7763720154762268,
-0.8031334280967712,
-0.17153242230415344,
-1.0519471168518066,
0.3805783689022064,
-0.07628495991230011,
-0.28244826197624207,
0.7682408094406128,
0.553175151348114,
0.5204586386680603,
0.09286215901374817,
0.7466851472854614,
0.36317652463912964,
0.45941951870918274,
-0.7601518034934998,
0.31603193283081055,
-0.13068005442619324,
0.7896013855934143,
-0.32530152797698975,
-1.1509027481079102,
-0.3033197820186615,
0.7111929059028625,
-0.15653429925441742,
-0.05169229954481125,
0.8165939450263977,
0.9369473457336426,
0.1730453372001648,
0.32817545533180237,
0.2625297009944916,
0.39324259757995605,
0.2837955355644226,
0.32051295042037964,
1.2678861618041992,
-0.22917093336582184,
0.5186183452606201,
-0.013129167258739471,
-0.15026089549064636,
-0.5016812086105347,
-0.9308995008468628,
-1.0097614526748657,
-0.4442017376422882,
-0.484619140625,
-0.4483433961868286,
0.03561455011367798,
0.9562364816665649,
0.2686629891395569,
-0.853841245174408,
-0.23961347341537476,
-0.3405982553958893,
0.2879353165626526,
-0.12245675176382065,
-0.24890244007110596,
0.33394795656204224,
-0.511014997959137,
-0.7557723522186279,
0.25538790225982666,
0.3508041203022003,
0.4793030619621277,
-0.4445968270301819,
-0.13861753046512604,
0.4168391823768616,
0.1440085619688034,
0.5585688948631287,
0.24917545914649963,
-1.2306733131408691,
-0.22030170261859894,
-0.06643687188625336,
0.04808005318045616,
0.13709008693695068,
0.9061643481254578,
-0.5450081825256348,
0.33757802844047546,
0.17498411238193512,
0.4496098756790161,
0.3954450488090515,
0.19432449340820312,
0.46913427114486694,
-0.6088487505912781,
-0.05598078668117523,
0.3139554560184479,
0.3837866187095642,
0.4921446740627289,
-0.14750008285045624,
0.5441285967826843,
0.18139316141605377,
-0.602972686290741,
-1.0788514614105225,
0.06388358026742935,
-1.182149052619934,
-0.13143281638622284,
1.055755615234375,
-0.04002949222922325,
-0.08187270909547806,
-0.31113046407699585,
-0.39158448576927185,
0.036194682121276855,
-0.42262566089630127,
1.118687629699707,
0.9921256303787231,
-0.4017603099346161,
-0.2463136911392212,
-0.6541445255279541,
0.7137665152549744,
0.28343474864959717,
-0.9402732849121094,
0.4973238706588745,
0.8337160348892212,
0.005635308101773262,
0.22284075617790222,
0.632645308971405,
-0.0798460990190506,
0.3373507261276245,
-0.17452146112918854,
-0.16190128028392792,
-0.01808272860944271,
-0.1678173840045929,
-0.4720318913459778,
-0.010358696803450584,
0.06286495923995972,
-0.03682241961359978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03486v1
|
BIPED: Pedagogically Informed Tutoring System for ESL Education
| 2024-06-05T17:49:24 | 2024-06-05T17:49:24 |
Soonwoo Kwon, Sojung Kim, Minju Park, Seunghyun Lee, Kyuseok Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have a great potential to serve as readily
available and cost-efficient Conversational Intelligent Tutoring Systems (CITS)
for teaching L2 learners of English. Existing CITS, however, are designed to
teach only simple concepts or lack the pedagogical depth necessary to address
diverse learning strategies. To develop a more pedagogically informed CITS
capable of teaching complex concepts, we construct a BIlingual
PEDagogically-informed Tutoring Dataset (BIPED) of one-on-one, human-to-human
English tutoring interactions. Through post-hoc analysis of the tutoring
interactions, we come up with a lexicon of dialogue acts (34 tutor acts and 9
student acts), which we use to further annotate the collected dataset. Based on
a two-step framework of first predicting the appropriate tutor act then
generating the corresponding response, we implemented two CITS models using
GPT-4 and SOLAR-KO, respectively. We experimentally demonstrate that the
implemented models not only replicate the style of human teachers but also
employ diverse and contextually appropriate pedagogical strategies.
|
[
-0.09508636593818665,
-0.8208165764808655,
0.09617393463850021,
0.26040545105934143,
-0.20502543449401855,
0.48684558272361755,
-0.287977397441864,
-0.36327728629112244,
0.07719454914331436,
0.250807523727417,
-0.5016818642616272,
-0.2631502151489258,
-0.22258782386779785,
-0.1382182240486145,
-0.41359493136405945,
0.9728301167488098,
0.39189767837524414,
0.605515718460083,
-0.14388985931873322,
0.1835635006427765,
-0.5613300800323486,
-0.3424461781978607,
-0.4835030734539032,
-0.39215075969696045,
0.4809376299381256,
0.8229117393493652,
0.3392484784126282,
0.1396283060312271,
0.15980277955532074,
0.2186017483472824,
-0.06798597425222397,
0.12889637053012848,
-0.3458101451396942,
0.09216014295816422,
-0.6300196647644043,
-0.6439417004585266,
-0.2015385925769806,
-0.2668437659740448,
0.3544917702674866,
0.9216312766075134,
-0.19693423807621002,
-0.002049378352239728,
0.37423214316368103,
0.5274052023887634,
-0.15312471985816956,
0.12177335470914841,
-0.6480557918548584,
0.024205448105931282,
-0.07964840531349182,
0.0004879373882431537,
-0.5352076292037964,
-0.2276735007762909,
0.5213675498962402,
-0.5021222233772278,
0.21235810220241547,
0.06244789436459541,
0.4059053957462311,
-0.03852701932191849,
-0.3297909200191498,
-0.35723865032196045,
-0.6219548583030701,
0.46226951479911804,
-0.4582090377807617,
0.5098106861114502,
0.5639779567718506,
0.28256678581237793,
0.1872662454843521,
-0.6068357825279236,
-0.5287263989448547,
0.15581975877285004,
-0.21381719410419464,
0.19912554323673248,
0.30889055132865906,
-0.005295633338391781,
-0.024064473807811737,
-0.08978157490491867,
-0.6257563829421997,
0.3819541037082672,
-0.5079461336135864,
-0.04867584630846977,
0.3778780698776245,
-0.05657162889838219,
0.25565826892852783,
-0.09778708964586258,
-0.6457133889198303,
0.07186581939458847,
-0.9921863079071045,
0.3600764274597168,
0.6745796203613281,
0.5376992225646973,
-0.38077691197395325,
0.5863202214241028,
0.11633197218179703,
0.44385674595832825,
0.19890521466732025,
-0.13949273526668549,
-0.07698365300893784,
-0.3058381974697113,
0.18758869171142578,
0.08314801007509232,
0.48914265632629395,
0.35589826107025146,
0.5739431977272034,
-0.25924962759017944,
-0.05110923573374748,
-0.31466972827911377,
-0.23532672226428986,
-0.8426958918571472,
-0.3582712411880493,
0.09280616044998169,
0.07633409649133682,
-0.25396111607551575,
0.21630612015724182,
-0.9369553327560425,
-0.4712180495262146,
-0.6056811213493347,
0.2607679069042206,
-0.6071175336837769,
-0.3193301856517792,
0.31836432218551636,
0.3166385591030121,
0.3900587856769562,
0.2775144875049591,
-1.117728352546692,
0.5359671711921692,
0.583284854888916,
0.5513482093811035,
0.030971325933933258,
-0.41092371940612793,
-0.40953683853149414,
0.36643093824386597,
0.026520265266299248,
0.9199002981185913,
-0.5729241967201233,
-0.5588548183441162,
0.2558303475379944,
0.13962991535663605,
-0.06081842631101608,
-0.08407972753047943,
0.19098766148090363,
-0.33282575011253357,
0.5418300628662109,
-0.09311632812023163,
-0.7594936490058899,
-0.3068300783634186,
0.4401659369468689,
-0.24826781451702118,
0.9289013147354126,
-0.030101779848337173,
-0.770435094833374,
-0.20577970147132874,
-0.5587977766990662,
-0.6395283341407776,
0.2885102331638336,
-0.21598072350025177,
-0.08081479370594025,
-0.39848750829696655,
0.16084204614162445,
0.47708162665367126,
-0.2698183059692383,
0.5737975835800171,
0.14136525988578796,
-0.3144669234752655,
-0.04648645222187042,
-0.3217809498310089,
1.0019831657409668,
-0.17284397780895233,
-0.37733983993530273,
-0.03754708543419838,
-0.5045757293701172,
-0.06408336013555527,
0.25813028216362,
-0.2451772689819336,
-0.2980213165283203,
0.16143304109573364,
0.07124412059783936,
-0.11100513488054276,
0.3012312054634094,
-0.5600056052207947,
0.3451804220676422,
-0.6302111744880676,
0.4526364207267761,
0.643475353717804,
0.027133094146847725,
0.38327378034591675,
-0.17117081582546234,
0.440917044878006,
-0.2516353726387024,
0.07092011719942093,
-0.5315544605255127,
-0.49282175302505493,
-0.7012909650802612,
-0.13959090411663055,
0.34338921308517456,
0.8731246590614319,
-0.7399642467498779,
0.4176577627658844,
-0.18117938935756683,
-0.5878974199295044,
-0.22317464649677277,
0.06195087358355522,
0.5175497531890869,
0.5125864744186401,
0.2776985764503479,
0.22847267985343933,
-0.3778979480266571,
-0.9860998392105103,
-0.22761359810829163,
-0.4266725480556488,
-0.14232957363128662,
0.043541353195905685,
0.40939217805862427,
0.03631050884723663,
0.9934985041618347,
-0.10403086245059967,
0.13270218670368195,
-0.21377380192279816,
-0.08312319219112396,
-0.06840165704488754,
0.48979905247688293,
0.724153459072113,
-0.6192048192024231,
-0.7644904255867004,
0.06763951480388641,
-0.35037583112716675,
-0.1705264300107956,
-0.06516005843877792,
-0.07995019108057022,
-0.12450981140136719,
0.30847591161727905,
-0.5398831963539124,
0.3031662702560425,
0.35430702567100525,
-0.4738352596759796,
0.5292053818702698,
-0.2187311202287674,
-0.10035396367311478,
-0.8236060738563538,
-0.2095063328742981,
-0.14802636206150055,
-0.30713242292404175,
-0.5057216882705688,
-0.38429000973701477,
0.28636714816093445,
-0.08420398086309433,
-0.4877952039241791,
0.6501453518867493,
-0.3825951814651489,
-0.20775829255580902,
0.0016027935780584812,
0.37532734870910645,
0.3063454031944275,
0.7953450083732605,
0.106566421687603,
0.6699687838554382,
0.6048075556755066,
-0.25690895318984985,
0.42437976598739624,
0.35183557868003845,
-0.37393492460250854,
0.8216429352760315,
-0.9234851002693176,
0.3732582628726959,
-0.02775227278470993,
0.08981706947088242,
-0.8099038004875183,
-0.04797685891389847,
0.19375187158584595,
-0.16029983758926392,
0.4767846167087555,
-0.4341486990451813,
-0.685732901096344,
-0.2069031447172165,
-0.1600639969110489,
0.20419830083847046,
0.1827341914176941,
-0.8166218400001526,
0.4737686514854431,
0.37377873063087463,
-0.8803095817565918,
-0.38346749544143677,
-0.3945418894290924,
-0.10045148432254791,
0.0740005224943161,
-0.4739406108856201,
0.2512556314468384,
-0.26614752411842346,
-0.15035492181777954,
-0.037522222846746445,
0.19046705961227417,
-0.0431956872344017,
-0.02684592828154564,
0.08003481477499008,
0.5583987236022949,
0.13551224768161774,
0.40569183230400085,
0.39856311678886414,
0.15288996696472168,
-0.0346558652818203,
-0.15214850008487701,
0.700123131275177,
-0.2719736695289612,
-0.9184939861297607,
-0.34525996446609497,
0.29521799087524414,
0.565545380115509,
-0.492135226726532,
0.33474475145339966,
0.3095555901527405,
-0.4080687165260315,
-0.25720077753067017,
-0.25944775342941284,
-0.2510205805301666,
-0.42780032753944397,
0.5795024037361145,
-0.18270964920520782,
-0.5598346590995789,
0.4698980152606964,
0.03944635018706322,
0.3712344467639923,
-0.1723431646823883,
0.6020812392234802,
-0.4008483588695526,
0.9051293134689331,
0.2972879409790039,
0.1537884622812271,
0.6167113780975342,
-0.3482391834259033,
0.28770801424980164,
-0.6409366130828857,
-0.8532364964485168,
-0.34418022632598877,
-0.3270270824432373,
-0.23244525492191315,
-0.2804863452911377,
0.16520866751670837,
0.21158728003501892,
-0.6633166074752808,
0.09031631052494049,
-0.4022296369075775,
0.6807478070259094,
0.5788516998291016,
0.29409709572792053,
0.0795530378818512,
0.23004847764968872,
-0.2173202633857727,
0.13842664659023285,
-0.6337754726409912,
-0.6558912992477417,
1.0630772113800049,
0.3240237236022949,
0.703557014465332,
0.46131986379623413,
0.1575416475534439,
0.15039873123168945,
0.26453354954719543,
-0.778790295124054,
0.5046314597129822,
0.06249234825372696,
-0.6948251128196716,
-0.2783300280570984,
0.27337825298309326,
-1.0120259523391724,
0.21860098838806152,
-0.25447285175323486,
-0.8195258378982544,
-0.009464755654335022,
-0.19921594858169556,
-0.5148425102233887,
0.3100404441356659,
-1.0022826194763184,
0.5023743510246277,
-0.7029421329498291,
-0.8373616933822632,
-0.14451979100704193,
-0.8384732007980347,
-0.014609036967158318,
-0.08193202316761017,
0.23956915736198425,
0.07898476719856262,
-0.06431776285171509,
0.7252452373504639,
-0.5437257885932922,
1.2790840864181519,
-0.37877771258354187,
0.1322822868824005,
0.5373779535293579,
0.19874520599842072,
0.6785309314727783,
-0.06483859568834305,
-0.07949165254831314,
-0.16598285734653473,
0.23784510791301727,
-0.6429874897003174,
-0.4927288889884949,
0.5962736010551453,
-0.7879399061203003,
-0.6833279132843018,
-0.10860703885555267,
-0.5386592745780945,
-0.6255303621292114,
0.08800450712442398,
-0.005749324336647987,
0.5871068835258484,
-0.0199937354773283,
0.21847330033779144,
0.49512457847595215,
-0.13202667236328125,
0.36563143134117126,
0.813346266746521,
-0.3246770203113556,
-0.2309883087873459,
0.8207038640975952,
0.11260182410478592,
0.11921993643045425,
0.178386390209198,
0.2806400656700134,
-0.44377660751342773,
-0.45498353242874146,
-0.35934898257255554,
0.5220407843589783,
-0.5488583445549011,
-0.14674125611782074,
-0.29825037717819214,
-0.06416083127260208,
-0.3452025055885315,
-0.3427579998970032,
-0.2598554790019989,
-0.31441110372543335,
-0.10457752645015717,
-0.4095132052898407,
0.32256776094436646,
0.9852681756019592,
0.1915266513824463,
0.5370563268661499,
-0.5917132496833801,
-0.19959264993667603,
0.5144836902618408,
0.3224956691265106,
-0.2698434889316559,
-0.7494758367538452,
-0.3239474594593048,
0.30246302485466003,
-0.31645119190216064,
-0.9757127165794373,
0.14581027626991272,
0.30667656660079956,
0.5489738583564758,
0.5359065532684326,
-0.08404906839132309,
0.35042354464530945,
-0.5592333078384399,
0.8621612787246704,
0.354909747838974,
-0.703636884689331,
0.6848809123039246,
-0.4813568592071533,
-0.06961173564195633,
0.22048860788345337,
0.22308698296546936,
-0.4094300866127014,
0.038269516080617905,
-0.5269308686256409,
-0.6678130626678467,
0.7586329579353333,
-0.1581106334924698,
0.33307623863220215,
0.22929206490516663,
0.10828354209661484,
0.4317823648452759,
0.21944886445999146,
-0.5633347034454346,
-0.2518594563007355,
-0.464613676071167,
-0.46492302417755127,
0.15858827531337738,
-0.3048865795135498,
-0.014103690162301064,
-0.4110734164714813,
0.7421528697013855,
-0.1529601514339447,
-0.208591029047966,
-0.04539897292852402,
-0.1857629120349884,
0.0502338632941246,
0.20534715056419373,
0.4206138253211975,
0.4517953395843506,
-0.07754861563444138,
0.13771387934684753,
0.059241265058517456,
-0.31064432859420776,
0.03376484662294388,
0.10081175714731216,
-0.24685300886631012,
-0.058302875608205795,
0.4190627932548523,
0.7616764307022095,
0.6531235575675964,
-0.9209192991256714,
0.7737892866134644,
0.1495511531829834,
0.07007487863302231,
-0.3809041976928711,
-0.07761690020561218,
0.4055527448654175,
0.48137304186820984,
0.19057142734527588,
0.02746863104403019,
-0.12288772314786911,
-0.41101065278053284,
-0.02457297407090664,
0.2635405659675598,
-0.17403580248355865,
-0.8550570607185364,
0.3226003646850586,
0.77667635679245,
-0.8516980409622192,
0.4262773096561432,
-0.11662653088569641,
-0.7975340485572815,
0.5941073298454285,
0.6880004405975342,
0.5633212924003601,
-0.42567193508148193,
0.3278573751449585,
0.5250668525695801,
0.2712506651878357,
0.005546092055737972,
-0.0033336118794977665,
-0.11938329041004181,
-0.71905517578125,
-0.1603815257549286,
-0.16621166467666626,
-0.734932005405426,
0.018691543489694595,
-0.5424304604530334,
0.7527807354927063,
-0.4040749967098236,
0.2555652856826782,
-0.13431446254253387,
-0.07524999976158142,
-0.8935856223106384,
-0.16755440831184387,
0.2756161689758301,
0.7270210981369019,
-0.7924526929855347,
0.977893590927124,
1.009045958518982,
-0.3034931719303131,
-0.8070855140686035,
-0.392660528421402,
0.03488289564847946,
-0.6954766511917114,
0.6321969032287598,
-0.06734775006771088,
-0.20207205414772034,
0.20264017581939697,
-0.5183025002479553,
-0.5169318914413452,
1.0780013799667358,
0.5139937996864319,
-0.9502992033958435,
-0.2818012237548828,
0.23559312522411346,
0.5083796977996826,
-0.41511237621307373,
0.3160199820995331,
0.26992377638816833,
0.42101556062698364,
-0.06160377711057663,
-0.7697564363479614,
-0.6365817785263062,
-0.27595198154449463,
-0.38419991731643677,
-0.2933604121208191,
-0.7117093205451965,
0.6615827083587646,
-0.2948249280452728,
-0.22233572602272034,
-0.0706038847565651,
0.2887638807296753,
0.15288622677326202,
0.3510913848876953,
0.6643702387809753,
0.008708729408681393,
0.9579606056213379,
0.01989290863275528,
0.7192426323890686,
-0.5495900511741638,
0.4404577314853668,
1.3412517309188843,
-0.344325989484787,
0.7866204977035522,
0.5990175008773804,
-0.6377097964286804,
0.6210145354270935,
0.8437115550041199,
0.09174714982509613,
0.30451884865760803,
-0.013384689576923847,
-0.37908878922462463,
-0.25576767325401306,
-0.012490817345678806,
-0.10446806997060776,
0.38033294677734375,
0.5505015254020691,
0.12601853907108307,
-0.19043880701065063,
0.23080386221408844,
-0.03371531143784523,
0.2867676615715027,
-0.17952199280261993,
0.5533381700515747,
-0.2930426001548767,
-0.6441674828529358,
0.08663147687911987,
-0.36393100023269653,
0.5717111229896545,
-0.5035731792449951,
0.011963394470512867,
-0.30753108859062195,
-0.23740287125110626,
-0.2871917486190796,
-1.117391586303711,
-0.3086581826210022,
0.3459695875644684,
-0.15008151531219482,
-0.20496749877929688,
0.6010153293609619,
-1.0477991104125977,
-0.5326245427131653,
0.2815757393836975,
0.7681865692138672,
0.2429703027009964,
0.3650582432746887,
-0.6395249962806702,
-0.33642134070396423,
0.1815776228904724,
-0.4777977466583252,
0.20734930038452148,
0.46581733226776123,
-0.029118740931153297,
0.8083953857421875,
0.4333059787750244,
0.047523222863674164,
-0.005703216418623924,
0.31346407532691956,
0.7130833268165588,
-0.18025076389312744,
-0.3275097906589508,
-0.4307239055633545,
0.8962339162826538,
-0.03669202700257301,
0.004924152046442032,
0.3873746395111084,
0.5847034454345703,
0.7886532545089722,
-0.035974305123090744,
0.9525058269500732,
0.03793220967054367,
0.8869274258613586,
-0.27402910590171814,
0.33717969059944153,
-0.18899427354335785,
0.7744544148445129,
0.22936683893203735,
-0.8370415568351746,
0.02588529698550701,
0.6334368586540222,
-0.3827707767486572,
-0.10929347574710846,
0.41530510783195496,
0.8521552681922913,
-0.07115291059017181,
0.3802391290664673,
0.3609510362148285,
0.06856876611709595,
0.286639928817749,
0.2884707748889923,
0.8361644148826599,
-0.2754802405834198,
0.4566618800163269,
-0.3307461738586426,
-0.14788034558296204,
-0.2994532883167267,
-0.42011865973472595,
-1.0233821868896484,
-0.6632549166679382,
-0.29083994030952454,
0.052222371101379395,
0.13339057564735413,
1.1928142309188843,
0.5980222821235657,
-0.6466691493988037,
-0.14034181833267212,
-0.07888805866241455,
0.11595461517572403,
0.2455577701330185,
-0.20561151206493378,
0.4335591793060303,
-0.2821812629699707,
-1.1793962717056274,
0.3710780143737793,
0.11757567524909973,
0.031159264966845512,
-0.5206658244132996,
-0.28062376379966736,
-0.314762145280838,
0.17327630519866943,
0.8008622527122498,
0.2519303560256958,
-0.6681707501411438,
-0.7123565077781677,
0.20720221102237701,
-0.19429895281791687,
-0.20496313273906708,
0.6759328246116638,
-0.7777113914489746,
0.6016685366630554,
0.2770731449127197,
0.7252871990203857,
0.46421560645103455,
-0.13086281716823578,
0.23009753227233887,
-0.5695808529853821,
0.38483095169067383,
0.2991907298564911,
0.5311053395271301,
0.4802204370498657,
-0.034636419266462326,
0.5809562802314758,
0.41379159688949585,
-0.45397916436195374,
-0.8196576833724976,
0.16933484375476837,
-0.8349944353103638,
-0.3168482780456543,
1.1740326881408691,
-0.45661595463752747,
0.12629082798957825,
-0.2783527374267578,
-0.6240044236183167,
0.24321399629116058,
-0.09040182828903198,
0.5013912320137024,
0.6901686787605286,
-0.15779025852680206,
-0.1903878003358841,
-0.15584062039852142,
-0.13065673410892487,
0.49581775069236755,
-0.7587158679962158,
0.0515485517680645,
0.3220461308956146,
0.4728737771511078,
-0.17816422879695892,
0.16281947493553162,
0.11927507072687149,
0.07018499076366425,
-0.06733721494674683,
0.2645260691642761,
-0.19872184097766876,
-0.35761648416519165,
0.1550104320049286,
0.041813112795352936,
0.025813927873969078,
-0.09384402632713318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03482v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03482v1
|
QJL: 1-Bit Quantized JL Transform for KV Cache Quantization with Zero Overhead
| 2024-06-05T17:42:05 | 2024-06-05T17:42:05 |
Amir Zandieh, Majid Daliri, Insu Han
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PF
|
Serving LLMs requires substantial memory due to the storage requirements of
Key-Value (KV) embeddings in the KV cache, which grows with sequence length. An
effective approach to compress KV cache is quantization. However, traditional
quantization methods face significant memory overhead due to the need to store
quantization constants (at least a zero point and a scale) in full precision
per data block. Depending on the block size, this overhead can add 1 or 2 bits
per quantized number. We introduce QJL, a new quantization approach that
consists of a Johnson-Lindenstrauss (JL) transform followed by sign-bit
quantization. In contrast to existing methods, QJL eliminates memory overheads
by removing the need for storing quantization constants. We propose an
asymmetric estimator for the inner product of two vectors and demonstrate that
applying QJL to one vector and a standard JL transform without quantization to
the other provides an unbiased estimator with minimal distortion. We have
developed an efficient implementation of the QJL sketch and its corresponding
inner product estimator, incorporating a lightweight CUDA kernel for optimized
computation. When applied across various LLMs and NLP tasks to quantize the KV
cache to only 3 bits, QJL demonstrates a more than fivefold reduction in KV
cache memory usage without compromising accuracy, all while achieving faster
runtime. Codes are available at \url{https://github.com/amirzandieh/QJL}.
|
[
-0.1794470250606537,
-0.7324810028076172,
0.3278592824935913,
0.2855168879032135,
-0.5481694936752319,
0.21023982763290405,
-0.10023903846740723,
-0.4052763283252716,
0.19749347865581512,
0.35290753841400146,
-0.2614894509315491,
-0.49978289008140564,
-0.361568421125412,
-0.5069980025291443,
-0.3341919481754303,
0.6856086254119873,
-0.06736449897289276,
0.06886424124240875,
-0.3464045822620392,
-0.15406042337417603,
-0.09053222090005875,
-0.21200217306613922,
-0.7344748973846436,
0.15808460116386414,
0.25649258494377136,
0.12254008650779724,
0.8766859769821167,
0.40893450379371643,
0.47847306728363037,
0.155594140291214,
-0.06158296763896942,
0.03498765453696251,
-0.35445618629455566,
0.4606698751449585,
0.34036895632743835,
-0.5901293754577637,
-0.45357152819633484,
-0.2780192792415619,
0.7105856537818909,
0.5951462388038635,
-0.054548732936382294,
0.6139485239982605,
-0.2938462495803833,
1.1824895143508911,
-1.3401944637298584,
0.06709542125463486,
-0.3781222999095917,
0.3917207419872284,
-0.29862985014915466,
0.01611325331032276,
-0.3424690067768097,
-0.717896580696106,
0.020085245370864868,
-0.9229328036308289,
-0.08509914577007294,
0.23960919678211212,
0.5288709998130798,
0.4859386682510376,
-0.40904921293258667,
0.1959003508090973,
-0.7362362146377563,
0.9396750926971436,
-0.6356223821640015,
0.6054180264472961,
0.0053171864710748196,
0.3940693140029907,
0.2246958464384079,
-0.7874011993408203,
-0.5513963103294373,
-0.012868321500718594,
0.24635523557662964,
0.2981380820274353,
-0.22321254014968872,
0.25175940990448,
0.34098079800605774,
0.44449833035469055,
-0.7484076619148254,
-0.23719972372055054,
-0.23486065864562988,
0.01699322834610939,
0.5133206844329834,
0.18457920849323273,
0.07763271033763885,
0.15167254209518433,
-0.6338966488838196,
-0.1908566951751709,
-0.9055020809173584,
0.2657180726528168,
0.3174547553062439,
0.039833541959524155,
0.09447651356458664,
0.31565433740615845,
-0.24188774824142456,
0.3672730326652527,
0.051725197583436966,
-0.1231258288025856,
-0.09900550544261932,
-0.18764840066432953,
-0.5539832711219788,
0.1961907595396042,
0.6797219514846802,
0.09259606152772903,
0.07948840409517288,
-0.2072358876466751,
-0.2371114194393158,
0.03094686008989811,
0.32084083557128906,
-1.0834779739379883,
-0.6251038312911987,
0.2492683231830597,
-0.5585719347000122,
-0.12469456344842911,
0.01688883639872074,
-0.4307413101196289,
-0.1004873663187027,
0.09595313668251038,
0.626164972782135,
-0.11401944607496262,
-0.11300308257341385,
0.2128765881061554,
-0.23217768967151642,
0.0939396321773529,
0.39079248905181885,
-0.6242960691452026,
0.5897008180618286,
0.19743552803993225,
0.6543578505516052,
-0.2422417849302292,
0.7560247182846069,
-0.37200501561164856,
0.17145560681819916,
-0.5021126866340637,
0.22665654122829437,
-0.06027588993310928,
-0.5537978410720825,
0.10055070370435715,
-0.3918575048446655,
0.48626989126205444,
-0.49834516644477844,
0.39181262254714966,
-0.9059634804725647,
-0.10129209607839584,
-0.36389344930648804,
-0.5163146257400513,
0.015416799113154411,
0.1287122517824173,
-0.8699586987495422,
1.0529603958129883,
0.29383230209350586,
-0.4921092092990875,
0.20304541289806366,
-0.6746503710746765,
-0.32396191358566284,
0.12617464363574982,
-0.0530933178961277,
-0.7234293818473816,
0.3042210042476654,
0.4102236032485962,
0.1261642724275589,
-0.4772935211658478,
-0.08376887440681458,
-0.29464608430862427,
-0.5914291739463806,
0.5932064652442932,
-0.6738222241401672,
1.133388876914978,
0.35357555747032166,
-0.044326052069664,
0.09043601155281067,
-0.6156764030456543,
0.5079627633094788,
0.16103334724903107,
-0.42051318287849426,
-0.3468593657016754,
-0.23566783964633942,
0.1478036344051361,
0.0015179102774709463,
0.657810389995575,
-0.5285471081733704,
0.45834746956825256,
-0.40275731682777405,
-0.12277772277593613,
0.6070339679718018,
0.06946536153554916,
0.5500521659851074,
-0.017859723418951035,
0.7503247261047363,
0.03155287727713585,
0.7097206115722656,
0.050910208374261856,
-0.2988283336162567,
-0.8886600136756897,
-0.19643694162368774,
0.385842502117157,
0.16218821704387665,
-1.0248674154281616,
0.12395884096622467,
-0.388955682516098,
-0.17701204121112823,
-0.799472987651825,
-0.07672986388206482,
0.5420701503753662,
0.05293576419353485,
0.5068941116333008,
-0.3501375615596771,
-0.5757205486297607,
-0.9510861039161682,
-0.11916497349739075,
-0.18814820051193237,
-0.1967124342918396,
-0.0959983617067337,
-0.11949106305837631,
0.30551913380622864,
0.7594970464706421,
-0.48629188537597656,
-0.01584983803331852,
0.2118605673313141,
0.07159925997257233,
0.13832783699035645,
0.5368589758872986,
0.15464147925376892,
-0.8061532378196716,
-0.9579185247421265,
-0.02103169448673725,
-0.5618016123771667,
-0.1820448786020279,
-0.15080922842025757,
-0.05995411053299904,
0.46635472774505615,
0.4521208703517914,
-0.7083885669708252,
0.6281507611274719,
0.5185041427612305,
-0.2249155342578888,
0.44294729828834534,
-0.024898970499634743,
0.009399539791047573,
-0.8259750604629517,
0.21330684423446655,
-0.25867772102355957,
-0.5078343152999878,
-0.5618141293525696,
0.1735963225364685,
0.4829854965209961,
0.11213849484920502,
-0.6139364838600159,
0.40915706753730774,
-0.6313409805297852,
-0.35786086320877075,
-0.08118060231208801,
-0.034929484128952026,
0.2106635868549347,
0.3818800151348114,
-0.45882776379585266,
1.0563050508499146,
0.2774030268192291,
-0.3751496374607086,
-0.008940563537180424,
0.12959052622318268,
-0.08838390558958054,
0.28506073355674744,
-0.4877781867980957,
0.11204997450113297,
-0.07494033873081207,
-0.003209502436220646,
-0.8828358054161072,
0.6635416746139526,
0.2692977488040924,
-0.3812084496021271,
0.5476021766662598,
-0.33537644147872925,
-0.5755339860916138,
-0.26149871945381165,
-0.6262338757514954,
0.4704589545726776,
0.8277105689048767,
-0.42319372296333313,
0.3331531286239624,
0.31429263949394226,
0.30854934453964233,
-0.6443406343460083,
-0.6656044125556946,
-0.2102299928665161,
-0.012572149746119976,
-0.3648707866668701,
0.4769448935985565,
-0.18985146284103394,
-0.17772309482097626,
0.28370562195777893,
-0.6669466495513916,
-0.27126607298851013,
0.034173402935266495,
0.2985452711582184,
0.40598127245903015,
-0.4644351601600647,
0.26338085532188416,
0.35447993874549866,
-0.22777149081230164,
0.18947172164916992,
-0.7607275247573853,
0.2491312026977539,
-0.10451853275299072,
-0.3470247983932495,
-0.4292193651199341,
0.2728438377380371,
0.46661168336868286,
0.10625863075256348,
0.4645095765590668,
0.8482652306556702,
-0.13089486956596375,
-0.11672887206077576,
-0.32639649510383606,
0.1718115657567978,
-0.5385360717773438,
0.15863727033138275,
-0.3885515034198761,
-0.9717544317245483,
0.39928340911865234,
-0.043530095368623734,
-0.035069968551397324,
0.4542180001735687,
0.43175268173217773,
-0.1869601011276245,
0.9158565998077393,
0.3643079102039337,
0.0013836669968441129,
0.49987927079200745,
-0.3552555739879608,
0.49787187576293945,
-0.892070472240448,
0.17047306895256042,
-0.14140591025352478,
-0.5584985613822937,
-0.6824166178703308,
-0.6935745477676392,
0.8195405602455139,
0.36740949749946594,
-0.5211849808692932,
0.14621782302856445,
-0.6365835070610046,
0.7389379739761353,
0.5754495859146118,
-0.0001045579556375742,
0.20043498277664185,
-0.14668837189674377,
0.2528385818004608,
-0.20743729174137115,
-0.5494261980056763,
-0.0389881506562233,
1.2825331687927246,
0.14559167623519897,
1.0185693502426147,
0.39355847239494324,
0.5458980202674866,
0.3316088020801544,
0.1995178461074829,
-0.545682966709137,
0.45521265268325806,
-0.23063048720359802,
-0.4127736985683441,
-0.44798392057418823,
-0.3193548023700714,
-0.7562732100486755,
0.21939405798912048,
-0.3279273808002472,
-0.7503343820571899,
-0.04541194811463356,
0.2397279590368271,
-0.5883669853210449,
0.29455605149269104,
-0.48634058237075806,
0.5870905518531799,
-0.06851810961961746,
-0.3073279559612274,
-0.17690877616405487,
-0.7403997182846069,
0.45947518944740295,
0.15429376065731049,
-0.5619668364524841,
-0.0976824164390564,
-0.1432277113199234,
0.7261186242103577,
-0.3908408582210541,
0.46027401089668274,
-0.4651879072189331,
0.12245064973831177,
0.3874877989292145,
0.3300115168094635,
0.7731111645698547,
0.2583712041378021,
0.27483615279197693,
0.10486257076263428,
0.3495410084724426,
-0.6207603216171265,
-1.0473085641860962,
0.6104298830032349,
-0.7985684871673584,
-0.4209069311618805,
0.008255240507423878,
-0.5849021077156067,
-0.19995878636837006,
-0.06452792882919312,
-0.12643681466579437,
0.07579377293586731,
0.15993237495422363,
0.16425345838069916,
0.8843110799789429,
-0.23744289577007294,
0.4872559607028961,
0.39906370639801025,
-0.40489158034324646,
-0.28551244735717773,
0.7934842109680176,
0.23315727710723877,
0.535464882850647,
0.7114778161048889,
0.14673081040382385,
-0.39486855268478394,
-0.5332658290863037,
-0.38718733191490173,
-0.2994822859764099,
-0.7592998147010803,
-0.5999906659126282,
-0.6407015323638916,
-0.3926820456981659,
-0.2765659987926483,
-0.26909324526786804,
-0.9227765798568726,
-0.9391531944274902,
-0.16230599582195282,
0.37057408690452576,
0.235940620303154,
0.23834769427776337,
0.09472186863422394,
0.4231376349925995,
-0.6273124814033508,
0.28910279273986816,
0.3979233205318451,
0.06198284775018692,
0.08147429674863815,
-0.2757270336151123,
-0.6310111880302429,
-0.06025123968720436,
-0.38871777057647705,
-0.5576701760292053,
0.6212056875228882,
-0.09033713489770889,
0.15403862297534943,
0.5171160697937012,
0.3287864327430725,
0.9623605608940125,
-0.05065835267305374,
0.8331198692321777,
0.2824552655220032,
-1.201530933380127,
0.1933797299861908,
0.11531130969524384,
0.4482771158218384,
0.553471565246582,
0.4484253227710724,
-0.5550886988639832,
-0.14692580699920654,
-0.5263274908065796,
-1.1038051843643188,
0.12857621908187866,
0.1779409795999527,
-0.11872825771570206,
0.1589168906211853,
0.1856515109539032,
-0.08036766946315765,
0.32809343934059143,
-0.6292126774787903,
-0.687874436378479,
0.0004227529279887676,
-0.12446599453687668,
0.5175097584724426,
-0.4457555413246155,
0.16750235855579376,
-0.32292550802230835,
0.6234915256500244,
-0.22088538110256195,
0.7982215881347656,
0.18059352040290833,
-0.23221635818481445,
-0.24199135601520538,
0.07127343863248825,
0.3370777666568756,
0.27637597918510437,
-0.41679078340530396,
0.44329431653022766,
0.19980302453041077,
-0.36254850029945374,
0.1141415536403656,
-0.16642995178699493,
-0.2822040319442749,
0.030490638688206673,
-0.1729244738817215,
0.5825322866439819,
0.3208494186401367,
-0.545600414276123,
0.6611413955688477,
-0.1528148353099823,
-0.030857305973768234,
-0.5770470499992371,
-0.06405939906835556,
0.04672955721616745,
0.544132649898529,
0.34081897139549255,
-0.20199467241764069,
0.4475398063659668,
-0.01134744193404913,
0.09155848622322083,
0.7580888271331787,
-0.39055371284484863,
-0.2062402069568634,
0.8638433814048767,
-0.12621553242206573,
0.128790944814682,
0.6501892805099487,
-0.6954771280288696,
-0.19638444483280182,
0.4013642966747284,
0.7668299078941345,
1.1486821174621582,
0.06874606758356094,
-0.037285372614860535,
0.25064775347709656,
0.16253416240215302,
0.32102230191230774,
0.42422616481781006,
-0.3614193797111511,
-0.7110818028450012,
-0.6655774712562561,
-0.7538354396820068,
-0.3956967294216156,
-0.15628266334533691,
-0.7455103397369385,
-0.12535105645656586,
-0.6931530237197876,
0.06342963874340057,
-0.10174384713172913,
0.3121594488620758,
-0.703987717628479,
-0.05528942495584488,
0.18827001750469208,
0.6760998368263245,
-0.5942807793617249,
1.2931218147277832,
0.10599618405103683,
-0.24485962092876434,
-0.45523837208747864,
-0.19857774674892426,
-0.07326985150575638,
-0.8765527606010437,
0.8513432145118713,
-0.19453935325145721,
0.26134055852890015,
0.1388593465089798,
-0.5364380478858948,
-1.0219049453735352,
1.2583967447280884,
0.26401564478874207,
-0.6869195699691772,
0.1496170461177826,
0.06677982956171036,
0.25734415650367737,
0.0043757399544119835,
0.1818302422761917,
0.3668639659881592,
0.43078866600990295,
-0.13395948708057404,
-0.5753940343856812,
0.25331124663352966,
-0.1577153354883194,
0.4258148968219757,
0.6699355840682983,
-0.4025055766105652,
0.9877282977104187,
0.10984303057193756,
-0.5464010834693909,
0.12444152683019638,
0.6872218251228333,
0.01771647296845913,
0.0008733627037145197,
0.32158803939819336,
0.6357961297035217,
0.67320716381073,
0.12926344573497772,
0.9941939115524292,
-0.4979231357574463,
0.5052252411842346,
0.8606951236724854,
-0.09763022512197495,
0.7270942330360413,
0.8714616894721985,
-0.6692436933517456,
0.06488774716854095,
0.12318406999111176,
0.29497507214546204,
0.4299411475658417,
0.4462736248970032,
-0.7950659990310669,
-0.13271641731262207,
-0.017499007284641266,
-0.07262159883975983,
0.013871998526155949,
0.35174527764320374,
-0.1126851961016655,
-0.10314071923494339,
-0.2675447165966034,
-0.025104032829403877,
-0.28920891880989075,
-0.2372136414051056,
0.4496009051799774,
0.04919923096895218,
-0.005101643968373537,
0.6932445168495178,
-0.013775989413261414,
0.6600543260574341,
-0.49245989322662354,
0.004357127472758293,
-0.045565083622932434,
-0.03386567160487175,
0.061661187559366226,
-0.5872136354446411,
0.4530712962150574,
-0.449285626411438,
-0.29584893584251404,
-0.3959988057613373,
0.7274071574211121,
-0.4610864222049713,
-0.3321571946144104,
-0.2240336835384369,
0.4774850606918335,
0.015555416233837605,
-0.33403390645980835,
-0.5451122522354126,
0.19438426196575165,
0.03833925351500511,
-0.5100979208946228,
0.564055323600769,
0.2166534811258316,
-0.2391916960477829,
0.7007647752761841,
0.8419328927993774,
0.06141216680407524,
0.3087862432003021,
-0.20256149768829346,
0.852107048034668,
-0.6761600375175476,
-0.21394196152687073,
-0.6839854121208191,
0.5410105586051941,
-0.05772128328680992,
-0.2730124890804291,
0.7702285051345825,
0.6569492220878601,
0.6822565793991089,
-0.09125873446464539,
0.6838822364807129,
0.03724706918001175,
-0.022015264257788658,
-0.7776244282722473,
0.6946205496788025,
-0.41969674825668335,
0.02035396918654442,
0.1587943434715271,
-0.7630181908607483,
-0.5986787676811218,
0.7147946357727051,
0.0559346079826355,
-0.2536970376968384,
0.739714503288269,
0.7198835015296936,
0.21937543153762817,
-0.2189902663230896,
0.9438757300376892,
0.07277484983205795,
0.3830200731754303,
0.6969243884086609,
0.459784597158432,
-0.8000791668891907,
0.30649399757385254,
-0.2672404646873474,
0.3022677004337311,
-0.11090321093797684,
-0.7127713561058044,
-0.5053119659423828,
-0.501649022102356,
-0.5424579977989197,
-0.2707897126674652,
0.23057246208190918,
0.998412013053894,
0.6900882720947266,
-0.5835841298103333,
0.05318666622042656,
-0.1301630586385727,
0.09778769314289093,
-0.22755572199821472,
-0.3175215721130371,
0.5585423707962036,
-0.5086995959281921,
-0.5642728209495544,
0.3241037130355835,
0.7953267097473145,
0.10698893666267395,
-0.6455798149108887,
-0.262863427400589,
0.13163085281848907,
-0.07170191407203674,
0.6782699823379517,
0.30144011974334717,
-0.619266152381897,
-0.13678357005119324,
-0.004036304075270891,
-0.15010637044906616,
0.23265306651592255,
0.8610547780990601,
-0.9426392316818237,
0.7147259712219238,
0.3687339127063751,
0.8727863430976868,
1.0070842504501343,
-0.31800541281700134,
0.1337532252073288,
-1.1073449850082397,
0.19395464658737183,
0.4576854705810547,
0.009227019734680653,
-0.005885069724172354,
-0.32829463481903076,
0.4025213122367859,
0.08679571002721786,
-0.6695414781570435,
-0.5135656595230103,
0.07830064743757248,
-1.3937665224075317,
-0.23255813121795654,
0.8291234374046326,
-0.1699739545583725,
-0.5050273537635803,
0.003675910411402583,
-0.04601060971617699,
0.3140868842601776,
-0.36510851979255676,
0.776988685131073,
0.05746311694383621,
-0.012446005828678608,
-0.4242996573448181,
-0.8059897422790527,
0.609802782535553,
0.28765615820884705,
-0.44337376952171326,
-0.09404750168323517,
0.08460740000009537,
-0.09409332275390625,
0.05480961874127388,
0.8598318696022034,
-0.21414245665073395,
0.31935834884643555,
0.2295004427433014,
0.7017619013786316,
0.00012575693835970014,
0.051632001996040344,
-0.30197465419769287,
0.17638732492923737,
0.22488126158714294,
-0.5530354380607605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03479v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03479v2
|
MODABS: Multi-Objective Learning for Dynamic Aspect-Based Summarization
| 2024-06-05T17:32:28 | 2024-06-17T19:56:37 |
Xiaobo Guo, Soroush Vosoughi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid proliferation of online content necessitates effective
summarization methods, among which dynamic aspect-based summarization stands
out. Unlike its traditional counterpart, which assumes a fixed set of known
aspects, this approach adapts to the varied aspects of the input text. We
introduce a novel multi-objective learning framework employing a
Longformer-Encoder-Decoder for this task. The framework optimizes aspect number
prediction, minimizes disparity between generated and reference summaries for
each aspect, and maximizes dissimilarity across aspect-specific summaries.
Extensive experiments show our method significantly outperforms baselines on
three diverse datasets, largely due to the effective alignment of generated and
reference aspect counts without sacrificing single-aspect summarization
quality.
|
[
-0.4602104425430298,
-0.5676991939544678,
0.5436480641365051,
0.28674396872520447,
-0.6119959950447083,
0.44712358713150024,
-0.07470792531967163,
-0.37148284912109375,
0.4953146278858185,
0.2875352203845978,
-0.618390679359436,
-0.44026389718055725,
-0.6050870418548584,
0.4603523313999176,
-0.20240136981010437,
1.2830480337142944,
-0.12743820250034332,
-0.1458996683359146,
-0.3726709187030792,
-0.21293644607067108,
-0.16458246111869812,
-0.4102068543434143,
-0.37405332922935486,
-0.057955652475357056,
0.5780168175697327,
0.5208544135093689,
0.20258024334907532,
0.6827489137649536,
0.6666872501373291,
0.3037874102592468,
-0.1241903230547905,
0.7721725106239319,
-0.4342268109321594,
0.5551049709320068,
-0.03153879567980766,
-0.3388007581233978,
-0.7072317004203796,
-0.35016289353370667,
0.7061303853988647,
0.6016560792922974,
-0.20311011373996735,
0.15807834267616272,
0.156437948346138,
0.9135844111442566,
-0.658100962638855,
0.342963308095932,
-0.27116838097572327,
0.0724310651421547,
-0.03517843782901764,
-0.08944663405418396,
-0.23677438497543335,
-0.3255069851875305,
-0.11618082970380783,
-0.7935705780982971,
0.06698928028345108,
-0.011268701404333115,
0.5781703591346741,
0.31559211015701294,
-0.9001193046569824,
-0.6306030750274658,
-0.519665539264679,
0.972861647605896,
-0.6341163516044617,
0.41059592366218567,
0.47117990255355835,
0.3213515281677246,
0.1384836584329605,
-0.5022124648094177,
-0.32921096682548523,
0.2007203847169876,
-0.09206485003232956,
0.39876261353492737,
0.30894267559051514,
0.34174224734306335,
-0.16961699724197388,
0.8328226804733276,
-0.2341691255569458,
-0.1665099859237671,
-0.39868175983428955,
-0.002819325774908066,
0.5511630773544312,
0.1958736628293991,
-0.24203357100486755,
-0.47405359148979187,
-0.09725727885961533,
0.19754274189472198,
-0.33618810772895813,
0.17552493512630463,
0.32524752616882324,
0.15956895053386688,
-0.39008256793022156,
0.3158465027809143,
-0.6375854015350342,
0.32401442527770996,
0.6486266255378723,
-0.8762203454971313,
0.5199821591377258,
-0.5006033182144165,
-0.025788281112909317,
0.07873355597257614,
0.4428393244743347,
0.32010015845298767,
-0.5236510634422302,
-0.03148750215768814,
-0.30150294303894043,
-0.6583231091499329,
0.3027859330177307,
-0.8585514426231384,
0.04394116997718811,
0.3832605183124542,
-0.7661174535751343,
-0.4069150984287262,
0.365718811750412,
-0.8256611824035645,
-0.399970144033432,
-0.5933561325073242,
0.21842330694198608,
-0.4701981246471405,
-0.022415271028876305,
-0.13806819915771484,
-0.13479237258434296,
-0.17510159313678741,
0.6337411403656006,
-0.7692388892173767,
0.02931389957666397,
0.6354233622550964,
0.9250960350036621,
-0.3006264269351959,
-0.20941852033138275,
-0.6218689680099487,
0.37631580233573914,
-0.1630505919456482,
0.6760554313659668,
-0.6233322620391846,
-0.33410030603408813,
-0.09441519528627396,
-0.16806942224502563,
0.4382002353668213,
-0.4605574607849121,
0.18591850996017456,
-0.1855199635028839,
0.23304840922355652,
-0.16102363169193268,
-0.3294665813446045,
-0.7367890477180481,
0.465157151222229,
-0.5492029786109924,
0.9476556181907654,
0.09171651303768158,
-0.47137096524238586,
0.36259081959724426,
-0.663489580154419,
-0.7188488245010376,
-0.5148252248764038,
-0.05498397350311279,
-0.7513868808746338,
0.722038984298706,
0.34706544876098633,
0.565669596195221,
-0.017287977039813995,
0.44259539246559143,
-0.04869648814201355,
0.022350337356328964,
0.24601955711841583,
-0.4945763051509857,
0.09900517016649246,
0.34152376651763916,
-0.04833284392952919,
0.48044511675834656,
-0.955432653427124,
-0.3726916015148163,
-0.22084572911262512,
-0.6184552311897278,
-0.2838461697101593,
0.381818562746048,
-0.3855655789375305,
0.08835621923208237,
0.22236138582229614,
-0.34681636095046997,
0.31446367502212524,
-0.060323361307382584,
0.22722582519054413,
0.5571883320808411,
0.26079869270324707,
0.33206814527511597,
-0.5392123460769653,
0.38746875524520874,
0.33119282126426697,
0.3189966082572937,
-0.8417458534240723,
0.12185067683458328,
-0.7798973917961121,
-0.6063708662986755,
-0.0004231291532050818,
0.12876982986927032,
-1.0923577547073364,
0.5783918499946594,
-0.21532177925109863,
-0.6923379302024841,
-0.07079317420721054,
0.19449202716350555,
0.603560745716095,
0.2294716089963913,
0.5563153028488159,
-0.6844380497932434,
-0.19064858555793762,
-0.8593645691871643,
0.07143982499837875,
-0.004053707234561443,
0.006808127276599407,
0.1360989362001419,
0.4576142132282257,
-0.0804491639137268,
0.6414210200309753,
-0.5111621022224426,
-0.5110486745834351,
-0.8071749210357666,
0.4787794351577759,
0.18214604258537292,
0.3248022496700287,
0.7258877158164978,
-0.985141932964325,
-0.3169235587120056,
-0.22060735523700714,
-0.8502933382987976,
-0.03844531252980232,
-0.4562547206878662,
0.009783384390175343,
-0.13537155091762543,
0.30525025725364685,
-0.18301162123680115,
0.10810381174087524,
0.6457439064979553,
-0.018371326848864555,
0.48160624504089355,
-0.34267574548721313,
0.5346156358718872,
-1.576665997505188,
-0.2047354131937027,
-0.06773573160171509,
-0.42083466053009033,
-0.3796485960483551,
0.14439396560192108,
0.35724127292633057,
-0.1256018728017807,
-0.5097240805625916,
0.070523202419281,
-0.712415337562561,
0.14394335448741913,
-0.382450133562088,
-0.12423280626535416,
0.2315305471420288,
0.5241150856018066,
-0.06502356380224228,
0.5710718631744385,
0.35737696290016174,
-0.8135730624198914,
0.40674686431884766,
0.2524525821208954,
-0.22379010915756226,
0.6548771262168884,
-0.22579564154148102,
-0.12243910878896713,
-0.6084279417991638,
0.5290467143058777,
-0.44562864303588867,
-0.597888171672821,
0.012956133112311363,
-0.27889055013656616,
0.4640517234802246,
-0.013307923451066017,
0.11561871320009232,
-0.03233962506055832,
-0.9037783145904541,
0.787434995174408,
0.04784908890724182,
-0.29493239521980286,
1.2367007732391357,
0.3869301974773407,
-0.4421384334564209,
-0.7035499215126038,
-0.5625038146972656,
-0.10280248522758484,
-0.009179866872727871,
-0.083647221326828,
0.525750994682312,
-0.043727342039346695,
-0.11022751033306122,
-0.008239373564720154,
-0.4107685983181,
-0.1469796746969223,
0.036509282886981964,
0.48609107732772827,
-0.3076229691505432,
-0.16819137334823608,
0.06526343524456024,
0.6748300790786743,
-0.04597120359539986,
-0.24744337797164917,
0.049794506281614304,
0.44323471188545227,
0.1878090500831604,
-0.5378798246383667,
-0.6321792602539062,
0.727463960647583,
0.7398086190223694,
-0.5760456323623657,
0.6028726100921631,
0.15645785629749298,
-0.34230098128318787,
-0.14229917526245117,
-0.4462909400463104,
0.192963644862175,
-0.45003610849380493,
1.0205219984054565,
-0.26322850584983826,
-0.4382491111755371,
0.5369468927383423,
-0.05699209123849869,
0.29206016659736633,
0.407622367143631,
0.3792637884616852,
-0.11978000402450562,
0.7011535167694092,
0.885438084602356,
-0.008812949061393738,
0.8956304788589478,
-0.29136255383491516,
0.213009774684906,
-0.8520194292068481,
-0.6012272238731384,
-0.1240081787109375,
-0.39354798197746277,
-0.1641530841588974,
-0.33546003699302673,
0.49787551164627075,
0.15230777859687805,
-0.08599705249071121,
-0.07182867079973221,
-0.24324747920036316,
0.6462664604187012,
0.3322783410549164,
0.25298452377319336,
0.4724949896335602,
-0.2650897204875946,
0.44331473112106323,
0.18669827282428741,
-0.27704793214797974,
-0.1709413230419159,
1.1121654510498047,
0.26040464639663696,
0.9041082859039307,
0.5248699188232422,
0.9404463768005371,
0.5500625371932983,
0.22956648468971252,
-0.8045714497566223,
0.3480512499809265,
-0.13415269553661346,
-0.3010273575782776,
-0.1515403836965561,
-0.5123308300971985,
-0.5492285490036011,
0.25924596190452576,
-0.4706867039203644,
-0.14738541841506958,
0.24269680678844452,
0.29836761951446533,
-0.4343806505203247,
0.38270094990730286,
-0.3588528633117676,
0.39342769980430603,
-0.7055452466011047,
-0.206620454788208,
-0.5443769097328186,
-0.5476195812225342,
0.3478359282016754,
-0.32929983735084534,
0.5104161500930786,
-0.20182690024375916,
-0.3163136839866638,
0.6689009666442871,
-0.18174852430820465,
0.6880505084991455,
0.08109244704246521,
0.14818502962589264,
0.08108948171138763,
0.1441529095172882,
0.115065798163414,
0.47482025623321533,
-0.08322342485189438,
0.18857957422733307,
-0.23067834973335266,
-0.4086838960647583,
-0.41453784704208374,
0.5092536807060242,
-0.6547471284866333,
-0.45916423201560974,
-0.812520444393158,
-0.6047033667564392,
-0.009072883985936642,
0.4195352792739868,
-0.035672347992658615,
0.9478628039360046,
-0.17992112040519714,
0.5323274731636047,
0.37685737013816833,
-0.286117285490036,
0.6143152117729187,
0.43663492798805237,
-0.36053115129470825,
-0.8463017344474792,
0.944136917591095,
-0.026248179376125336,
0.41756510734558105,
0.7107721567153931,
-0.08404368162155151,
0.19958682358264923,
-0.9104982614517212,
-0.4336840510368347,
0.23871035873889923,
-0.5548129677772522,
-0.5753549337387085,
-0.4858531355857849,
-0.031026240438222885,
-0.154837504029274,
-0.46690914034843445,
-0.5820701718330383,
-0.18045666813850403,
-0.06853117048740387,
-0.25649330019950867,
-0.09510644525289536,
1.1853021383285522,
-0.07680531591176987,
0.2964121401309967,
-1.0753577947616577,
0.6638959050178528,
0.27326178550720215,
0.29843178391456604,
0.06937530636787415,
-0.3586958050727844,
-0.4238355755805969,
0.08963538706302643,
-0.7720748782157898,
-0.9254614114761353,
0.39076465368270874,
0.6078017354011536,
0.4474702775478363,
0.8838199973106384,
0.2922959327697754,
0.6406161785125732,
-0.21727748215198517,
0.9736785292625427,
0.41067013144493103,
-1.0678304433822632,
0.49732136726379395,
-0.21989335119724274,
0.3770372271537781,
0.8631982803344727,
0.35402175784111023,
-0.558688759803772,
-0.5457378625869751,
-0.19276192784309387,
-1.1341556310653687,
0.6946085691452026,
0.08571864664554596,
0.12449070811271667,
0.08267036080360413,
0.5138397812843323,
0.8560465574264526,
0.6275514364242554,
-0.5127198100090027,
-0.3213450312614441,
-0.4309348165988922,
-0.6967222094535828,
-0.015728138387203217,
-0.41649866104125977,
0.10006217658519745,
-0.24141091108322144,
0.7533867955207825,
-0.22589252889156342,
0.09416224807500839,
0.13924099504947662,
-0.45525163412094116,
0.19818001985549927,
0.23871758580207825,
0.7997373938560486,
1.175265908241272,
-0.27001166343688965,
0.23617883026599884,
0.20693886280059814,
-0.6314430832862854,
0.11169444024562836,
-0.04250650852918625,
-0.13881780207157135,
-0.07893600314855576,
0.5300790071487427,
0.8967162370681763,
0.3493136167526245,
-0.705426812171936,
0.5431204438209534,
-0.13668380677700043,
-0.007722729351371527,
-0.326961874961853,
-0.04018561914563179,
-0.3093765079975128,
0.24833109974861145,
0.7437168955802917,
0.1798466145992279,
0.22861774265766144,
-0.811375617980957,
0.05379116162657738,
0.02285756729543209,
-0.29687872529029846,
-0.5720607042312622,
0.5388306379318237,
0.8699974417686462,
-0.24738489091396332,
0.15849189460277557,
-0.3740456998348236,
-0.529342532157898,
0.5764002203941345,
0.2594057619571686,
0.8348748087882996,
-0.13666588068008423,
0.2142624706029892,
0.28223007917404175,
-0.17792657017707825,
0.005246981047093868,
0.132880300283432,
-0.30588653683662415,
-0.24593237042427063,
-0.5100539326667786,
-0.6419876217842102,
-0.772034764289856,
-0.07382918149232864,
-0.890062689781189,
0.22729533910751343,
-0.1940247118473053,
0.02505890280008316,
-0.1130608320236206,
-0.2615751326084137,
-0.21967355906963348,
0.1287277340888977,
-0.010143295861780643,
0.5487560033798218,
-0.6228082776069641,
0.44580045342445374,
0.7764785885810852,
-0.6786455512046814,
-0.23457473516464233,
0.3018154799938202,
0.3152464032173157,
-0.3799445629119873,
0.01417929120361805,
0.3903859555721283,
-0.0026103013660758734,
-0.22046777606010437,
-0.04323034733533859,
-1.0765435695648193,
1.1472727060317993,
0.16070042550563812,
-0.39096301794052124,
-0.2299158126115799,
-0.0890871062874794,
0.0630977526307106,
-0.3536759614944458,
0.327758252620697,
0.09822989255189896,
0.2833917438983917,
-0.3490905463695526,
-0.9500115513801575,
-0.3054691255092621,
-0.10256040841341019,
-0.45029357075691223,
0.6359829902648926,
-0.9373127222061157,
0.7654373645782471,
-0.20189453661441803,
0.08098310977220535,
-0.15823855996131897,
1.1338378190994263,
-0.1948656588792801,
0.4049445688724518,
0.2758199870586395,
0.1514030247926712,
0.6679130792617798,
-0.13849060237407684,
0.8782820701599121,
-0.33590853214263916,
0.4143258035182953,
0.9954627752304077,
0.22718574106693268,
0.574867308139801,
0.4051392376422882,
-0.014768626540899277,
0.4732098877429962,
0.5433695912361145,
0.3257173001766205,
0.8769497275352478,
-0.37565553188323975,
-0.06122906133532524,
-0.30343031883239746,
0.0737171396613121,
-0.3548482656478882,
0.43049129843711853,
0.320820152759552,
-0.40177443623542786,
-0.32436898350715637,
0.3055846095085144,
0.030123848468065262,
0.09222718328237534,
-0.5905548930168152,
1.203851580619812,
-0.04597777500748634,
-0.43538475036621094,
0.01979689858853817,
0.08586835116147995,
1.0241039991378784,
-0.8743117451667786,
0.053384024649858475,
-0.3697284162044525,
0.354593962430954,
-0.3448754847049713,
-0.6962755918502808,
0.2252538502216339,
-0.10188288241624832,
-0.4925360679626465,
-0.3144298791885376,
0.18674352765083313,
-0.6300082802772522,
-0.6030964851379395,
-0.08555823564529419,
0.4911021292209625,
-0.08637498319149017,
-0.13129940629005432,
-0.3297761082649231,
0.022071000188589096,
0.05759911611676216,
-0.3049340546131134,
0.4875729978084564,
0.5909578800201416,
-0.010858653113245964,
0.628069281578064,
0.3337515890598297,
0.008365046232938766,
-0.23394940793514252,
-0.1825980544090271,
0.8105389475822449,
-0.7785755395889282,
-0.8224499225616455,
-0.661478579044342,
0.6128853559494019,
-0.36596205830574036,
-0.57830411195755,
0.4616137742996216,
1.075333595275879,
0.8182206153869629,
-0.07433229684829712,
0.9321762919425964,
-0.15827779471874237,
0.39754486083984375,
-0.6287291646003723,
0.6018028259277344,
-0.831935703754425,
0.04852056875824928,
0.11493664234876633,
-1.0680691003799438,
-0.28944095969200134,
0.3834976553916931,
-0.06635703146457672,
-0.09277689456939697,
0.8721639513969421,
0.3071880638599396,
-0.3740547001361847,
-0.21215903759002686,
0.03502360358834267,
-0.03533304110169411,
0.6552332043647766,
0.4603196382522583,
0.5001033544540405,
-0.13041092455387115,
0.40610450506210327,
-0.5426604747772217,
-0.4207916259765625,
-0.41237378120422363,
-1.0408345460891724,
-0.8955293297767639,
-0.8211665153503418,
-0.28822144865989685,
0.08494910597801208,
0.214260533452034,
1.2796738147735596,
0.5689574480056763,
-0.9651849269866943,
-0.040806472301483154,
0.477532297372818,
0.21892036497592926,
-0.5415840148925781,
-0.11612526327371597,
0.4108872413635254,
-0.21841555833816528,
-0.8902288675308228,
0.29377859830856323,
0.508209764957428,
-0.09933093190193176,
-0.0064268046990036964,
-0.18104176223278046,
0.15579700469970703,
0.2202131152153015,
0.8444069027900696,
0.14043942093849182,
-0.6327763795852661,
-0.40194886922836304,
-0.2980041801929474,
0.054757457226514816,
0.2263217568397522,
0.9453982710838318,
-0.398276686668396,
0.4269535541534424,
0.5268228650093079,
0.6036016345024109,
0.46413442492485046,
0.5223424434661865,
0.46502363681793213,
-0.828818142414093,
0.3355206251144409,
0.20638181269168854,
0.4221082031726837,
0.12638330459594727,
-0.18876779079437256,
0.11335968971252441,
0.035857997834682465,
-0.2984545826911926,
-0.7714942693710327,
0.1919114589691162,
-1.229872703552246,
-0.30612388253211975,
1.088145136833191,
-0.047824326902627945,
-0.08705437183380127,
-0.1931680142879486,
-0.4044474959373474,
0.2675764858722687,
-0.7548105120658875,
0.9601436853408813,
0.3525327742099762,
-0.5285314321517944,
0.10068193823099136,
-0.10131771117448807,
0.3467022776603699,
0.04889169707894325,
-1.1555477380752563,
0.040745075792074203,
0.7980152368545532,
0.19809533655643463,
0.19684652984142303,
0.2596556544303894,
0.10697700083255768,
0.16900332272052765,
-0.2793691158294678,
0.1921812742948532,
-0.8857161998748779,
-0.5413717031478882,
-0.15695467591285706,
0.516157329082489,
-0.12992219626903534,
-0.2692534327507019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03476v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03476v1
|
Does your data spark joy? Performance gains from domain upsampling at the end of training
| 2024-06-05T17:29:15 | 2024-06-05T17:29:15 |
Cody Blakeney, Mansheej Paul, Brett W. Larsen, Sean Owen, Jonathan Frankle
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Pretraining datasets for large language models (LLMs) have grown to trillions
of tokens composed of large amounts of CommonCrawl (CC) web scrape along with
smaller, domain-specific datasets. It is expensive to understand the impact of
these domain-specific datasets on model capabilities as training at large FLOP
scales is required to reveal significant changes to difficult and emergent
benchmarks. Given the increasing cost of experimenting with pretraining data,
how does one determine the optimal balance between the diversity in general web
scrapes and the information density of domain specific data? In this work, we
show how to leverage the smaller domain specific datasets by upsampling them
relative to CC at the end of training to drive performance improvements on
difficult benchmarks. This simple technique allows us to improve up to 6.90 pp
on MMLU, 8.26 pp on GSM8K, and 6.17 pp on HumanEval relative to the base data
mix for a 7B model trained for 1 trillion (T) tokens, thus rivaling Llama-2
(7B)$\unicode{x2014}$a model trained for twice as long. We experiment with
ablating the duration of domain upsampling from 5% to 30% of training and find
that 10% to 20% percent is optimal for navigating the tradeoff between general
language modeling capabilities and targeted benchmarks. We also use domain
upsampling to characterize at scale the utility of individual datasets for
improving various benchmarks by removing them during this final phase of
training. This tool opens up the ability to experiment with the impact of
different pretraining datasets at scale, but at an order of magnitude lower
cost compared to full pretraining runs.
|
[
-0.5823864936828613,
-0.4283120930194855,
0.04089690372347832,
0.19939929246902466,
-0.46624675393104553,
0.35044077038764954,
-0.6467421650886536,
-0.21020197868347168,
0.08834987878799438,
0.39801087975502014,
-0.6725407242774963,
-0.17940454185009003,
-0.630480170249939,
-0.04003025218844414,
-0.3775659501552582,
0.8460379242897034,
0.363921195268631,
0.2325231432914734,
-0.4593890607357025,
-0.04306654632091522,
-0.4113357961177826,
-0.9150580763816833,
-0.5972661972045898,
-0.3843975365161896,
0.35158514976501465,
0.5055555701255798,
0.656379222869873,
0.6172299981117249,
0.47718679904937744,
0.23012606799602509,
-0.07296290248632431,
0.22308045625686646,
-0.9227566719055176,
0.04273071885108948,
0.09452477842569351,
-0.5712165236473083,
-0.22610294818878174,
0.042050790041685104,
0.46498218178749084,
1.0762006044387817,
-0.32543885707855225,
0.32582417130470276,
0.1606075018644333,
0.7304350733757019,
-0.6140903234481812,
-0.09274881333112717,
-0.8613388538360596,
-0.14456208050251007,
-0.6189031004905701,
-0.38383960723876953,
-0.23068587481975555,
-0.13407059013843536,
-0.16149304807186127,
-0.5473185181617737,
0.30218443274497986,
0.08190848678350449,
0.9989199042320251,
0.2508178651332855,
-0.15248706936836243,
-0.006257181521505117,
-0.5422403812408447,
1.197352409362793,
-0.5084543824195862,
0.5595837235450745,
0.3021736145019531,
0.22973209619522095,
-0.14404438436031342,
-0.8044134974479675,
-0.5405858159065247,
-0.05623340606689453,
0.22240059077739716,
-0.07196762412786484,
-0.23966853320598602,
-0.04302532970905304,
0.35598883032798767,
0.555136501789093,
-0.43865838646888733,
0.19917654991149902,
-0.18793387711048126,
0.0622575469315052,
0.6708920001983643,
0.15169799327850342,
0.26428091526031494,
0.3905373811721802,
-0.07425818592309952,
-0.5390781760215759,
-0.9893062114715576,
0.18370956182479858,
0.4126702845096588,
0.4992275536060333,
0.22297437489032745,
0.41500282287597656,
-0.1723030060529709,
0.7652623057365417,
0.02479899488389492,
-0.02944728173315525,
0.36015912890434265,
-0.2630654573440552,
-0.3321565091609955,
-0.31814834475517273,
0.13037042319774628,
0.5403528213500977,
0.9071688652038574,
-0.3004535436630249,
-0.20700271427631378,
0.06684223562479019,
0.5133662819862366,
-0.8011506199836731,
-0.28143683075904846,
0.15131767094135284,
-0.19183611869812012,
-0.2205684781074524,
-0.1165509819984436,
-0.6649166345596313,
-0.24287623167037964,
-0.8185968995094299,
0.23520199954509735,
-0.28565630316734314,
-0.11679067462682724,
0.48186516761779785,
-0.16598019003868103,
-0.08218856900930405,
0.37041106820106506,
-0.9835695624351501,
0.5586146712303162,
0.47198256850242615,
0.6165675520896912,
-0.2513085603713989,
-0.26569053530693054,
-0.4039285182952881,
-0.11705431342124939,
-0.2560267150402069,
0.7493625283241272,
-0.5514387488365173,
-0.4559001922607422,
-0.006741722580045462,
-0.15709693729877472,
-0.38623273372650146,
-0.9149360060691833,
0.4049508571624756,
-0.9256355166435242,
-0.07733016461133957,
-0.25509896874427795,
-0.6369534134864807,
-0.07521390914916992,
0.011069693602621555,
-0.6757327914237976,
1.0757702589035034,
0.28744184970855713,
-0.7123913764953613,
0.6436598300933838,
-0.39118513464927673,
-0.5628072619438171,
-0.01631312444806099,
-0.17035849392414093,
-0.4110647737979889,
0.21183361113071442,
0.08900516480207443,
0.3305707275867462,
-0.4622449576854706,
-0.01694307290017605,
-0.5374749302864075,
-0.4339028596878052,
0.15964703261852264,
-0.21456031501293182,
0.783855140209198,
0.27525463700294495,
-0.17095983028411865,
-0.20659758150577545,
-0.909990131855011,
0.45654213428497314,
0.15952010452747345,
-0.4250607490539551,
-0.4822511672973633,
-0.12247081845998764,
-0.09999561309814453,
0.12777838110923767,
-0.010023213922977448,
-0.34771665930747986,
0.29399439692497253,
-0.14480850100517273,
-0.04119228199124336,
0.7213554382324219,
-0.15857112407684326,
0.20922403037548065,
-0.40792688727378845,
0.7614279389381409,
-0.0024772435426712036,
0.0704578086733818,
0.039157021790742874,
-0.20335274934768677,
-0.8750794529914856,
-0.24285940825939178,
0.7346298098564148,
0.08756997436285019,
-0.4721825122833252,
0.45195379853248596,
-0.4440247118473053,
-0.37759479880332947,
-0.6977948546409607,
0.24673199653625488,
0.18449591100215912,
0.302489310503006,
0.518483579158783,
-0.7107133865356445,
-0.6339052319526672,
-0.6327152848243713,
-0.4240635633468628,
0.24047403037548065,
-0.19668729603290558,
0.09463053196668625,
0.277892529964447,
-0.007250901311635971,
1.0937104225158691,
-0.5837296843528748,
-0.2530023753643036,
-0.5258912444114685,
0.1283058077096939,
0.31795835494995117,
0.23467974364757538,
0.6052778363227844,
-0.8956618309020996,
-0.6991015076637268,
-0.11895644664764404,
-0.44394782185554504,
-0.1692621260881424,
-0.142067089676857,
-0.0338851623237133,
-0.04338845610618591,
0.016331003978848457,
-0.5630038380622864,
0.3487020432949066,
0.48379382491111755,
0.015212345868349075,
0.7673964500427246,
-0.1004607155919075,
0.22385193407535553,
-0.45611563324928284,
0.0450761653482914,
-0.08219588547945023,
-0.17031417787075043,
-0.8398272395133972,
-0.021510712802410126,
0.023329677060246468,
0.17828190326690674,
-0.24714796245098114,
0.2803589999675751,
-0.566809356212616,
-0.18427161872386932,
-0.23137390613555908,
-0.0614832304418087,
-0.014325477182865143,
0.4426693022251129,
-0.13487188518047333,
1.0292118787765503,
0.7058354020118713,
-0.7199609875679016,
0.025321537628769875,
0.12588489055633545,
-0.47459277510643005,
0.22824066877365112,
-0.5242559909820557,
0.17193318903446198,
0.18769621849060059,
-0.099735789000988,
-0.8410611152648926,
-0.320211797952652,
-0.3575434684753418,
-0.4939802587032318,
0.4551408290863037,
0.05098448321223259,
-0.4971318542957306,
-0.5578524470329285,
-0.5884815454483032,
0.23339968919754028,
0.7712929844856262,
-0.8465404510498047,
0.2945362329483032,
0.6162803769111633,
-0.14886479079723358,
-0.6821759343147278,
-0.585305392742157,
0.01626572012901306,
-0.2977009415626526,
-0.8163476586341858,
0.4176231920719147,
-0.33281847834587097,
-0.32462331652641296,
-0.35584524273872375,
-0.05936156585812569,
-0.1791568547487259,
0.14595504105091095,
0.1352320909500122,
-0.01123842317610979,
-0.0387338250875473,
0.0932551845908165,
-0.0014298720052465796,
0.10089198499917984,
-0.08566660434007645,
-0.19119298458099365,
0.9641619324684143,
0.04652698338031769,
-0.39585384726524353,
-0.11130288243293762,
0.026401668787002563,
0.3210645914077759,
-0.08572741597890854,
0.6595237851142883,
0.1640346497297287,
-0.20646338164806366,
-0.4974043071269989,
-0.4031344950199127,
0.017142893746495247,
-0.5214463472366333,
0.3222462832927704,
-0.42917752265930176,
-0.6988949775695801,
0.3807085454463959,
-0.23946325480937958,
0.00426715100184083,
0.26917579770088196,
0.5574601292610168,
-0.00871583353728056,
0.957179844379425,
0.8741476535797119,
-0.27791133522987366,
0.4237070083618164,
-0.3873448073863983,
0.17330600321292877,
-0.6302591562271118,
-0.015163843519985676,
-0.3596697151660919,
-0.2780669629573822,
-0.07802504301071167,
-0.4460693895816803,
0.0656687393784523,
0.42338430881500244,
-0.1409134864807129,
0.2618737518787384,
-0.2262682467699051,
0.6176149249076843,
0.5931914448738098,
0.06335951387882233,
0.44952091574668884,
0.5893592238426208,
-0.015011279843747616,
-0.21037279069423676,
-0.7115996479988098,
-0.12144406884908676,
1.4993586540222168,
0.14313121140003204,
0.9042416214942932,
-0.19016198813915253,
0.5783847570419312,
0.5465458035469055,
0.32479557394981384,
-0.5540802478790283,
0.45492151379585266,
-0.35507676005363464,
-0.3663751184940338,
-0.22964926064014435,
-0.5624107718467712,
-0.8793635368347168,
0.31263279914855957,
0.038723841309547424,
-0.5452152490615845,
0.2528671324253082,
0.3699076175689697,
-0.21330948173999786,
0.3380303382873535,
-0.5870985388755798,
0.6310210227966309,
-0.280985027551651,
-0.34214434027671814,
-0.3595399558544159,
-0.5940179228782654,
0.19602614641189575,
-0.44544386863708496,
0.2522772550582886,
0.1244783028960228,
0.28398773074150085,
0.746734619140625,
-0.4444403350353241,
0.6752646565437317,
-0.14983312785625458,
0.14226002991199493,
0.292230486869812,
-0.12745146453380585,
0.2910347282886505,
-0.5061504244804382,
-0.10052844136953354,
0.20241765677928925,
-0.32137158513069153,
-0.42350757122039795,
-0.549540638923645,
0.33259108662605286,
-0.8561022877693176,
-0.3189530074596405,
-0.10779716819524765,
-0.3164428770542145,
-0.46062150597572327,
0.11171054095029831,
0.4003874361515045,
0.6208717226982117,
0.00040671229362487793,
0.3560810089111328,
0.5380720496177673,
0.054699916392564774,
0.26547911763191223,
0.44305047392845154,
-0.15967722237110138,
-0.2517209053039551,
0.9736176133155823,
0.24723728001117706,
0.44340261816978455,
0.10887021571397781,
-0.23591911792755127,
-0.5052868127822876,
-0.8231107592582703,
-0.3742184340953827,
0.18395395576953888,
-0.8544495701789856,
-0.46204182505607605,
-0.6511638760566711,
-0.008072388358414173,
-0.4654855728149414,
-0.1639219969511032,
-0.34560683369636536,
-0.567610502243042,
-0.3099464476108551,
-0.06432870775461197,
0.20438475906848907,
0.5105608105659485,
-0.2014295607805252,
0.8527029156684875,
-0.5469526648521423,
0.09341812133789062,
0.10911750793457031,
0.3792378604412079,
0.17021720111370087,
-0.8198320269584656,
-0.6241639256477356,
0.2647066116333008,
-0.3083150386810303,
-0.37678268551826477,
0.5750444531440735,
0.51168292760849,
0.5275300145149231,
0.2981414794921875,
-0.04136135056614876,
0.967294454574585,
-0.32383957505226135,
0.8462169766426086,
0.28635963797569275,
-0.7639679312705994,
0.15453483164310455,
-0.08817961066961288,
0.041866496205329895,
0.8534741401672363,
0.6784853935241699,
-0.4824574887752533,
-0.20840080082416534,
-0.6403334140777588,
-0.9484906792640686,
0.6819103360176086,
0.06969562917947769,
0.09847718477249146,
0.04412159323692322,
0.22554218769073486,
0.12115025520324707,
0.4800666868686676,
-0.5552603602409363,
-0.2303001433610916,
0.0739588513970375,
-0.13246096670627594,
-0.17127789556980133,
-0.0966201201081276,
-0.152552530169487,
-0.5164631009101868,
0.6553305983543396,
-0.1148773804306984,
0.04313705861568451,
-0.3168931305408478,
-0.5414302349090576,
-0.2611285150051117,
0.06535909324884415,
0.13411951065063477,
0.7921459078788757,
-0.2968108355998993,
0.09895116090774536,
0.2546573877334595,
-0.5200215578079224,
0.16042232513427734,
-0.020244332030415535,
0.1938282996416092,
-0.1886489987373352,
0.2575630843639374,
0.6151451468467712,
0.11040516942739487,
-0.792992889881134,
0.6258096694946289,
-0.15391384065151215,
-0.06805230677127838,
-0.09373393654823303,
0.2921546995639801,
-0.09661857038736343,
-0.02146788500249386,
0.3604770004749298,
0.06739974021911621,
-0.017826484516263008,
-0.3488789498806,
0.6033145785331726,
0.3341858685016632,
0.12659749388694763,
-0.4839780330657959,
0.5695492625236511,
0.06559368222951889,
-0.040407877415418625,
0.6786103248596191,
-0.06964083015918732,
-0.5778178572654724,
0.6806716918945312,
0.6230527758598328,
0.6484208703041077,
-0.23394875228405,
0.0018785489955917,
0.1293286234140396,
-0.07422849535942078,
-0.24554137885570526,
0.19594120979309082,
-0.04966842755675316,
-0.82535719871521,
-0.5405570864677429,
-0.9202006459236145,
-0.4125230312347412,
0.1845260113477707,
-0.8366894721984863,
0.4691139757633209,
-0.17009420692920685,
-0.19323773682117462,
-0.08091244846582413,
0.23759646713733673,
-0.959786593914032,
0.6150045394897461,
0.10766277462244034,
1.031168818473816,
-0.7373886108398438,
0.9782788157463074,
0.4860410690307617,
-0.3411390781402588,
-0.6509904861450195,
-0.04686126112937927,
-0.05634034797549248,
-1.0225831270217896,
0.7377805113792419,
0.2313200682401657,
-0.3096953332424164,
0.24063730239868164,
-0.533778727054596,
-0.8463423252105713,
0.8758108615875244,
0.29734158515930176,
-0.79169100522995,
0.08136238902807236,
0.45486775040626526,
0.6618528962135315,
-0.5520827174186707,
0.2520747482776642,
0.8776519894599915,
0.29770633578300476,
-0.059980202466249466,
-0.5759547352790833,
-0.06574169546365738,
-0.3437514305114746,
-0.15134988725185394,
-0.004584267735481262,
-0.5648532509803772,
1.0640649795532227,
-0.2648599147796631,
-0.36798128485679626,
-0.14843125641345978,
0.5069844722747803,
0.08974593132734299,
0.1663353592157364,
0.7677790522575378,
0.7367556691169739,
0.886036217212677,
0.03622465953230858,
1.291995882987976,
-0.4505232870578766,
0.49519219994544983,
1.1410725116729736,
-0.3938733637332916,
0.6493318676948547,
0.35724738240242004,
-0.5595455765724182,
0.21165914833545685,
0.9720652103424072,
-0.09594825655221939,
0.6712687015533447,
0.4679172933101654,
-0.27103373408317566,
-0.39886805415153503,
-0.021719666197896004,
-0.4827759265899658,
0.08813347667455673,
0.2137003391981125,
-0.05205268785357475,
-0.2958683669567108,
0.07227907329797745,
0.05905912443995476,
-0.1478385627269745,
-0.1389293521642685,
0.47533586621284485,
-0.002027553739026189,
-0.4501488506793976,
0.9300979971885681,
-0.2982234060764313,
0.7002351880073547,
-0.8480494618415833,
0.2562728822231293,
-0.43142545223236084,
0.4058310091495514,
-0.053844332695007324,
-0.5478967428207397,
0.06544550508260727,
0.029921138659119606,
-0.1553630232810974,
-0.2603815793991089,
0.618354082107544,
-0.6092154383659363,
-0.10648856312036514,
0.5978460311889648,
0.3093089163303375,
0.2787904739379883,
-0.35951924324035645,
-0.5399184823036194,
0.258005291223526,
0.23950839042663574,
-0.585383415222168,
0.7539640069007874,
0.1977805495262146,
0.18303819000720978,
0.6734475493431091,
0.7962313294410706,
0.3818891942501068,
0.17464220523834229,
0.4706496298313141,
1.4658282995224,
-0.5442395210266113,
-0.4119323194026947,
-0.6302923560142517,
0.5648027062416077,
-0.34531834721565247,
-0.3746686279773712,
0.7926484942436218,
0.6830533146858215,
1.1188931465148926,
-0.0582711286842823,
0.8674344420433044,
0.03994285315275192,
0.6401791572570801,
-0.40652409195899963,
0.5495882630348206,
-0.9096595644950867,
0.3643757998943329,
0.1387867033481598,
-0.8104941248893738,
-0.3250432014465332,
0.20858044922351837,
-0.27897632122039795,
0.0988752543926239,
0.4345568120479584,
0.7184026837348938,
-0.1643080711364746,
0.12209048122167587,
0.4633258283138275,
-0.008223995566368103,
0.35409560799598694,
0.1861179620027542,
0.803695023059845,
-0.0482342392206192,
0.44781747460365295,
-0.3000066578388214,
-0.42542994022369385,
-0.17940019071102142,
-0.5377393364906311,
-0.9003291726112366,
-0.1711551398038864,
-0.040146902203559875,
-0.11583298444747925,
0.1745099425315857,
0.8843185305595398,
0.7541685104370117,
-0.7257290482521057,
-0.49450841546058655,
0.05217139050364494,
-0.2892395555973053,
-0.13749296963214874,
-0.22936363518238068,
0.322496235370636,
-0.8165653347969055,
-0.4595243036746979,
0.3148987591266632,
-0.027703644707798958,
0.010191717185080051,
0.16670191287994385,
0.07994008809328079,
0.000529412180185318,
0.18900054693222046,
0.627300500869751,
0.15814240276813507,
-0.15664534270763397,
-0.19165341556072235,
0.008833714760839939,
0.10845328122377396,
0.28828683495521545,
0.9616643786430359,
-0.6447587609291077,
0.48524209856987,
0.0806627869606018,
0.8211095929145813,
0.6009303331375122,
0.2373073548078537,
0.627859890460968,
-1.0388649702072144,
0.0062804571352899075,
0.009596400894224644,
0.21689976751804352,
0.34938883781433105,
-0.2626986503601074,
0.7029401659965515,
0.34529462456703186,
-0.6291809678077698,
-0.9992569088935852,
-0.054667502641677856,
-0.8102702498435974,
-0.3264366090297699,
0.948448657989502,
-0.21820373833179474,
-0.18774409592151642,
-0.05573218688368797,
-0.01788240484893322,
0.1634310483932495,
-0.11940822750329971,
0.8721731305122375,
0.7371797561645508,
-0.36237993836402893,
0.2266603708267212,
-0.4449075162410736,
0.8357394337654114,
0.5443086624145508,
-0.7989098429679871,
0.5169200897216797,
0.18851888179779053,
0.2781524062156677,
-0.0078094168566167355,
0.7581039071083069,
0.028023479506373405,
-0.1198413148522377,
0.0854375958442688,
0.1217876598238945,
-0.06635874509811401,
-0.6408239006996155,
-0.45816078782081604,
0.05760574713349342,
0.0465674065053463,
-0.1536780744791031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03452v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03452v3
|
Using Synchronic Definitions and Semantic Relations to Classify Semantic Change Types
| 2024-06-05T16:52:21 | 2024-06-11T12:05:22 |
Pierluigi Cassotti, Stefano De Pascale, Nina Tahmasebi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
There is abundant evidence of the fact that the way words change their
meaning can be classified in different types of change, highlighting the
relationship between the old and new meanings (among which generalization,
specialization and co-hyponymy transfer). In this paper, we present a way of
detecting these types of change by constructing a model that leverages
information both from synchronic lexical relations and definitions of word
meanings. Specifically, we use synset definitions and hierarchy information
from WordNet and test it on a digitized version of Blank's (1997) dataset of
semantic change types. Finally, we show how the sense relationships can improve
models for both approximation of human judgments of semantic relatedness as
well as binary Lexical Semantic Change Detection.
|
[
-0.24570873379707336,
-0.3158603310585022,
0.3656073808670044,
-0.28136271238327026,
-0.2230892777442932,
-0.2594919204711914,
-0.054071586579084396,
-0.8816103339195251,
0.447457492351532,
0.28706756234169006,
-0.768140435218811,
-0.15940974652767181,
-0.5932003855705261,
0.3071773648262024,
-0.6058473587036133,
0.7623283863067627,
-0.3652670085430145,
-0.047902148216962814,
0.039091888815164566,
-0.378744512796402,
-0.42406025528907776,
-0.25700604915618896,
-0.12976029515266418,
-0.48452433943748474,
0.7143232226371765,
-0.04723278060555458,
1.2360209226608276,
0.808262825012207,
0.6391875743865967,
0.248263880610466,
-0.4014235734939575,
-0.2073502391576767,
0.01795291341841221,
0.4073745012283325,
-0.44605398178100586,
-0.5869576334953308,
-0.24503567814826965,
0.28617286682128906,
0.43338456749916077,
0.7657202482223511,
-0.06090126931667328,
0.4329456686973572,
-0.36074385046958923,
0.45196181535720825,
-0.8364779353141785,
0.5081599354743958,
-1.0568910837173462,
0.07424396276473999,
-0.4326668977737427,
-0.42365562915802,
0.012414542958140373,
0.16817399859428406,
0.18359515070915222,
-0.7197450995445251,
0.3167778551578522,
0.027382759377360344,
1.1867765188217163,
0.15707844495773315,
-0.35426244139671326,
-0.3094772398471832,
-0.4863399565219879,
0.36632877588272095,
-0.5055844783782959,
1.0612117052078247,
0.4147105813026428,
0.23612484335899353,
-0.2742668390274048,
-0.613113284111023,
-0.7769713401794434,
-0.4139755964279175,
-0.014452283270657063,
0.2537939250469208,
0.1299140453338623,
-0.053521618247032166,
0.2925965189933777,
0.48845407366752625,
0.11575839668512344,
-0.0793033316731453,
-0.1277795135974884,
-0.4943620264530182,
0.5215582251548767,
0.39733606576919556,
0.6755333542823792,
-0.4988130033016205,
-0.31630417704582214,
-0.28426507115364075,
-0.4630604386329651,
-0.23964497447013855,
0.24085105955600739,
0.1927996426820755,
-0.14958173036575317,
0.555173933506012,
-0.2642129361629486,
0.8442997932434082,
0.10840394347906113,
-0.1855325549840927,
0.16971170902252197,
-0.8578863143920898,
-0.17892798781394958,
-0.011529752984642982,
-0.004095358774065971,
0.4781665503978729,
0.09801281988620758,
-0.4214176833629608,
-0.2145816534757614,
0.628568172454834,
-0.2600592076778412,
-0.5362594723701477,
-0.20423607528209686,
-0.13716714084148407,
-0.6426038146018982,
-0.25260332226753235,
-0.12291653454303741,
-0.3124615252017975,
-0.62272047996521,
-0.8880736827850342,
0.38191595673561096,
-0.6123683452606201,
-0.5037128925323486,
0.21945345401763916,
-0.7093271017074585,
0.37738117575645447,
0.676526665687561,
-0.8157352209091187,
0.24853180348873138,
0.672319233417511,
0.7423456907272339,
-0.04087269306182861,
-0.30816709995269775,
-0.04492803290486336,
0.025073237717151642,
-0.4267442524433136,
0.5277414321899414,
-0.45545053482055664,
0.07923315465450287,
0.00022697092208545655,
0.02498452179133892,
-0.2065878063440323,
-0.596688985824585,
-0.12486674636602402,
-0.9593382477760315,
0.2456909418106079,
-0.03852648660540581,
-0.7276911735534668,
0.05367055907845497,
0.37600570917129517,
-0.6789424419403076,
0.6967139840126038,
0.37915968894958496,
-1.2684221267700195,
0.5928898453712463,
-0.29239562153816223,
-0.1623847931623459,
0.20534566044807434,
0.22598494589328766,
-0.18302157521247864,
0.17241992056369781,
-0.6259781122207642,
0.052133262157440186,
0.10799834877252579,
0.3182411789894104,
-0.41868627071380615,
0.002909807488322258,
0.45801374316215515,
0.33520543575286865,
0.7279651761054993,
0.18128594756126404,
0.11266044527292252,
0.09650400280952454,
-1.0269875526428223,
-0.19522972404956818,
-0.11219530552625656,
-0.022173665463924408,
-1.009499430656433,
0.3885500729084015,
-0.2134404480457306,
0.5968652367591858,
0.43371692299842834,
-0.5241178870201111,
-0.08059978485107422,
-0.25639769434928894,
0.2732957601547241,
0.40102311968803406,
0.13609375059604645,
0.4759613275527954,
-0.37324631214141846,
0.1301291286945343,
0.6202018857002258,
0.1966352015733719,
-0.2012873739004135,
-0.5654080510139465,
-1.0251461267471313,
0.3643210530281067,
0.4791482388973236,
0.30563536286354065,
-0.6883143186569214,
0.6246957778930664,
-0.31746453046798706,
-0.2641991972923279,
-0.427828311920166,
-0.27623069286346436,
-0.23061880469322205,
0.6793546676635742,
0.5179658532142639,
-0.44801071286201477,
-0.6535673141479492,
-0.4887691140174866,
-0.5664039254188538,
-0.48514288663864136,
0.1501680314540863,
-0.10295694321393967,
0.6821367740631104,
-0.5203149914741516,
1.1497853994369507,
-0.3385904133319855,
-0.015178523026406765,
0.3397795557975769,
0.18058592081069946,
-0.22012493014335632,
0.06056249886751175,
0.079872265458107,
-0.8316974639892578,
0.1761707067489624,
0.09165654331445694,
-0.4672931432723999,
-0.12790343165397644,
-0.06196180731058121,
-0.13788367807865143,
-0.097990483045578,
0.7431628704071045,
-0.2336914837360382,
0.6233004927635193,
0.3328719437122345,
-0.7674098014831543,
0.6520290970802307,
0.17503002285957336,
-0.07114440202713013,
-1.2065660953521729,
-0.18145549297332764,
-0.25813543796539307,
-0.1277933567762375,
-0.5518516302108765,
0.1636912226676941,
0.23150593042373657,
0.17246834933757782,
-0.4327079653739929,
0.6075329184532166,
-0.3936832845211029,
-0.3755849599838257,
0.0568300299346447,
0.17962582409381866,
-0.22574329376220703,
-0.09121540188789368,
0.20393456518650055,
0.2309185117483139,
0.33721718192100525,
-0.6165180802345276,
0.5453353524208069,
0.5158894658088684,
-0.3525488078594208,
0.3472955524921417,
-0.17132779955863953,
-0.15800175070762634,
-0.40282395482063293,
0.2122592180967331,
-0.86139315366745,
-0.4045852720737457,
0.1860264241695404,
-0.4726763367652893,
-0.24330870807170868,
-0.0738414078950882,
-0.86040198802948,
-0.18549270927906036,
-0.2843008041381836,
0.09069737046957016,
0.1259433627128601,
-0.4719149172306061,
0.2943979501724243,
0.15585307776927948,
0.403601735830307,
-0.09840350598096848,
-0.7483323812484741,
-0.016345972195267677,
-0.11763850599527359,
-0.8455066084861755,
0.5533432364463806,
0.12530075013637543,
-0.7091015577316284,
0.4854476749897003,
-0.46488088369369507,
-0.36736997961997986,
0.41435113549232483,
0.17189806699752808,
0.4685080647468567,
-0.08642967790365219,
0.7851628065109253,
-0.047699134796857834,
-0.08867401629686356,
0.04929225146770477,
-0.18082807958126068,
0.49541085958480835,
0.3456166088581085,
0.2401031255722046,
-0.34470653533935547,
-0.015085863880813122,
0.5141090154647827,
-0.2546413242816925,
0.831222414970398,
0.6400699019432068,
-0.5130684971809387,
-0.03652792051434517,
-0.23156459629535675,
-0.3939083218574524,
-0.33535927534103394,
0.32694369554519653,
-0.4366130828857422,
-0.9940093159675598,
0.7263935804367065,
-0.0852048322558403,
-0.2829884886741638,
0.614147961139679,
0.4869941771030426,
0.258109450340271,
0.5602166652679443,
0.389201819896698,
0.2118491232395172,
0.8237335681915283,
0.15447667241096497,
-0.03368184715509415,
-0.9728451371192932,
-0.1699874997138977,
-0.4250495135784149,
-0.2273263931274414,
-0.9655377268791199,
-0.26427799463272095,
0.22965282201766968,
0.27891430258750916,
-0.2329092174768448,
0.6971073150634766,
-0.17580772936344147,
0.1453344076871872,
0.10873914510011673,
0.03814500942826271,
0.5648150444030762,
-0.1594683676958084,
-0.12908673286437988,
-0.0447223074734211,
-0.2818778157234192,
-0.0387844443321228,
0.7350226044654846,
0.24946235120296478,
0.7547776103019714,
0.3398263454437256,
0.7447007894515991,
0.2939010560512543,
0.42102521657943726,
-0.891950249671936,
0.6034530401229858,
0.08558830618858337,
-0.417784184217453,
-0.1469651460647583,
-0.5203643441200256,
-1.175618290901184,
0.4494040012359619,
-0.4603946805000305,
-0.652472198009491,
0.2653120458126068,
0.031405895948410034,
0.2764832377433777,
0.3679608702659607,
-0.47911208868026733,
0.6186328530311584,
0.3046800196170807,
-0.06442826986312866,
-0.4209255278110504,
-0.527772843837738,
0.32950958609580994,
-0.04886360093951225,
-0.1277262270450592,
-0.5875415205955505,
-0.4150330722332001,
0.6989457607269287,
-0.5915964841842651,
0.5875163078308105,
0.04942784830927849,
-0.14202162623405457,
0.17635475099086761,
0.49182960391044617,
0.27166178822517395,
-0.2688499093055725,
-0.1797943413257599,
0.07376960664987564,
0.3398706018924713,
-0.06750437617301941,
-0.6772655844688416,
0.3664264976978302,
-0.8115947246551514,
-0.17581115663051605,
-0.48772120475769043,
-0.6827599406242371,
-0.26947492361068726,
0.190530925989151,
0.2919532060623169,
0.4802621304988861,
-0.05259047821164131,
-0.47723156213760376,
0.08115553855895996,
0.14257530868053436,
0.2513495087623596,
0.772627055644989,
-0.3667023181915283,
0.011236400343477726,
0.27939873933792114,
0.27859386801719666,
0.5408870577812195,
0.39605268836021423,
0.45184266567230225,
-0.4443712830543518,
-0.18324992060661316,
0.09542863816022873,
0.30086395144462585,
-0.5994827151298523,
-0.16190575063228607,
-0.23051752150058746,
-0.17313499748706818,
-0.5653080940246582,
0.21618914604187012,
0.11305604875087738,
-0.5339054465293884,
-0.15334537625312805,
0.37275758385658264,
0.6086704730987549,
0.687228262424469,
0.008241442032158375,
0.03153400495648384,
-0.6033616662025452,
0.2538054883480072,
0.602603554725647,
0.42452651262283325,
-0.013071367517113686,
-0.6422155499458313,
-0.046360813081264496,
-0.04098355397582054,
-0.19942505657672882,
-1.3089720010757446,
0.407990962266922,
0.21361833810806274,
-0.05234411731362343,
0.29812100529670715,
0.009887351654469967,
0.8074150681495667,
-0.357745498418808,
0.575842559337616,
0.4301781952381134,
-1.1872912645339966,
0.5887048840522766,
-0.40238264203071594,
0.470310777425766,
0.28271451592445374,
0.22669917345046997,
-1.3363912105560303,
-0.0875365361571312,
-0.8921509981155396,
-0.322418749332428,
0.7501387596130371,
0.017648151144385338,
0.04259714111685753,
-0.0381527915596962,
0.4797709584236145,
-0.09521717578172684,
0.36145082116127014,
-0.3675318658351898,
-0.21667827665805817,
0.07345420867204666,
-0.034835778176784515,
0.20155498385429382,
0.03345607593655586,
0.09316474199295044,
-0.3784201741218567,
0.2125859558582306,
0.005393547937273979,
0.21944977343082428,
0.17962512373924255,
-0.252031147480011,
-0.2358013093471527,
0.6961575746536255,
0.21748438477516174,
0.7105762958526611,
-0.33120378851890564,
0.7273189425468445,
0.09102027118206024,
-0.3799852132797241,
0.06409900635480881,
0.04242585971951485,
-0.23912879824638367,
0.2403046190738678,
0.5904784202575684,
0.7062212824821472,
0.32018882036209106,
-0.2589983344078064,
0.5539481043815613,
0.2838340699672699,
0.03673914447426796,
-0.15021874010562897,
0.1948329657316208,
0.12881839275360107,
-0.32985609769821167,
-0.399917334318161,
0.4524892568588257,
0.2645486295223236,
-0.9356604218482971,
0.4483620524406433,
-0.16671475768089294,
-0.5938747525215149,
-0.8431033492088318,
0.31763139367103577,
-0.10113584995269775,
-0.15377672016620636,
0.5509642362594604,
-0.4960532784461975,
-0.5856367349624634,
0.4624324440956116,
0.6607289910316467,
0.7502187490463257,
-0.5615401864051819,
0.24718761444091797,
0.3088349997997284,
-0.12358127534389496,
-0.08142142742872238,
0.146979421377182,
-0.42319753766059875,
-1.6113600730895996,
-0.1828799843788147,
-0.44057127833366394,
-0.3261744976043701,
0.06416960805654526,
-0.8572958707809448,
0.43160563707351685,
-0.3729054629802704,
-0.19010774791240692,
0.5018178820610046,
-0.2843920588493347,
-0.6351958513259888,
0.023686490952968597,
0.17519181966781616,
0.9969038367271423,
-0.8660988211631775,
0.7855255007743835,
0.8869073390960693,
-0.33754071593284607,
-0.6224051713943481,
0.218971848487854,
0.16521088778972626,
-0.78662109375,
1.1325173377990723,
0.06482407450675964,
-0.0666973888874054,
-0.2100095897912979,
-0.47286662459373474,
-0.9080359935760498,
0.9693275690078735,
0.09760421514511108,
-0.5797593593597412,
-0.04855944588780403,
-0.006414112169295549,
0.7390256524085999,
-0.07352253049612045,
0.11134344339370728,
0.5146303176879883,
0.467074453830719,
0.005242153070867062,
-1.0445045232772827,
-0.19675815105438232,
-0.03879176080226898,
0.286256343126297,
0.7873151302337646,
-0.2953912615776062,
1.1232621669769287,
0.07481478154659271,
-0.8241367936134338,
0.004684016574174166,
0.47620588541030884,
-0.20204496383666992,
0.4327607750892639,
0.8791430592536926,
0.7891682982444763,
0.6294413805007935,
-0.10121297836303711,
0.8889247179031372,
-0.5314128398895264,
0.5487217903137207,
1.1414045095443726,
-0.3354181945323944,
0.93319171667099,
0.2647143304347992,
-0.26623666286468506,
0.8514330387115479,
0.6559935808181763,
0.12711209058761597,
0.239183709025383,
0.5266523361206055,
-0.3702503740787506,
-0.5407586097717285,
-0.36720144748687744,
-0.39723658561706543,
0.5017876625061035,
0.5818846225738525,
-0.326158732175827,
-0.6912040710449219,
-0.24655014276504517,
0.36101505160331726,
-0.09557705372571945,
-0.6174224019050598,
0.7736602425575256,
-0.03999900072813034,
-0.6924296617507935,
0.4172433614730835,
0.1176251620054245,
0.5966171026229858,
-0.48563942313194275,
0.058746155351400375,
0.18363431096076965,
0.3342472314834595,
-0.288181334733963,
-0.8142557740211487,
0.47442764043807983,
-0.6051155924797058,
-0.189059317111969,
0.19256100058555603,
1.0549733638763428,
-0.7101997137069702,
-0.13906091451644897,
0.699131190776825,
0.5213913321495056,
-0.1466568410396576,
0.23259387910366058,
-0.7072694301605225,
0.09851303696632385,
-0.38792502880096436,
0.5735033750534058,
0.21650430560112,
0.3355371952056885,
-0.5000767111778259,
0.31737497448921204,
0.414835661649704,
0.39852073788642883,
0.3655874729156494,
-0.05735692009329796,
0.5420157313346863,
-0.8041685819625854,
-0.6925784945487976,
-0.3858003318309784,
-0.1287762075662613,
-0.09791605919599533,
-0.6744866371154785,
0.7024409174919128,
0.10245269536972046,
0.8821488618850708,
-0.0049775345250964165,
0.5091475248336792,
-0.18945515155792236,
0.33337855339050293,
-0.40150073170661926,
0.08389195054769516,
-0.3893733620643616,
-0.1443808227777481,
-0.08218320459127426,
-0.6281810998916626,
-0.35903066396713257,
0.3151905834674835,
-0.2826831042766571,
-0.30693334341049194,
0.7384654879570007,
0.781905472278595,
-0.19009612500667572,
0.3591751158237457,
0.3038530647754669,
0.4088088572025299,
-0.2657480239868164,
0.2131698727607727,
1.2118408679962158,
-0.4297095537185669,
-0.3325046896934509,
-0.04482503980398178,
-0.1986648440361023,
-0.060319580137729645,
-0.5751326084136963,
-0.5666534304618835,
-1.148815631866455,
-0.7748106718063354,
-0.7720099091529846,
0.1297880858182907,
0.8911990523338318,
0.6992893218994141,
-0.6985542178153992,
-0.2847048342227936,
-0.24451497197151184,
0.1584402471780777,
-0.25414079427719116,
-0.2908443808555603,
0.40497204661369324,
-0.6046008467674255,
-0.20761270821094513,
-0.0631823018193245,
0.29431161284446716,
0.10189354419708252,
-0.142446830868721,
0.17767588794231415,
-0.1301916241645813,
0.18832595646381378,
0.724937379360199,
0.1783910095691681,
-0.7618101239204407,
-0.6904417276382446,
-0.27593427896499634,
0.10759451985359192,
-0.08165452629327774,
1.0121476650238037,
-0.6384243965148926,
0.6957286596298218,
1.0475239753723145,
0.23980610072612762,
0.181381493806839,
-0.2660105526447296,
-0.03222993016242981,
-0.5089787244796753,
0.3017948567867279,
-0.18352662026882172,
0.5110944509506226,
0.3052467703819275,
0.04270084202289581,
0.457817941904068,
0.9012600779533386,
-0.19070108234882355,
-0.3085922300815582,
0.675384521484375,
-0.9901251196861267,
-0.19759956002235413,
1.1227712631225586,
0.09256845712661743,
-0.4195059537887573,
-0.41128575801849365,
0.2922140061855316,
0.3377242088317871,
-0.07888930290937424,
0.7131857872009277,
0.6637560725212097,
-0.3834990859031677,
0.050807610154151917,
0.06972991675138474,
0.6344648599624634,
0.0956372544169426,
-0.781606137752533,
-0.07119215279817581,
0.5529567003250122,
0.5404726266860962,
0.5829564929008484,
0.32454270124435425,
-0.4132005572319031,
0.3551141023635864,
-0.054957419633865356,
0.1253497302532196,
0.24118290841579437,
0.057877153158187866,
-0.24317212402820587,
-0.054859012365341187,
-0.13126587867736816,
-0.33551469445228577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03450v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03450v1
|
What is the Best Way for ChatGPT to Translate Poetry?
| 2024-06-05T16:48:26 | 2024-06-05T16:48:26 |
Shanshan Wang, Derek F. Wong, Jingming Yao, Lidia S. Chao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Machine translation (MT) has historically faced significant challenges when
applied to literary works, particularly in the domain of poetry translation.
The advent of Large Language Models such as ChatGPT holds potential for
innovation in this field. This study examines ChatGPT's capabilities in
English-Chinese poetry translation tasks, utilizing targeted prompts and small
sample scenarios to ascertain optimal performance. Despite promising outcomes,
our analysis reveals persistent issues in the translations generated by ChatGPT
that warrant attention. To address these shortcomings, we propose an
Explanation-Assisted Poetry Machine Translation (EAPMT) method, which leverages
monolingual poetry explanation as a guiding information for the translation
process. Furthermore, we refine existing evaluation criteria to better suit the
nuances of modern poetry translation. We engaged a panel of professional poets
for assessments, complemented evaluations by using GPT-4. The results from both
human and machine evaluations demonstrate that our EAPMT method outperforms
traditional translation methods of ChatGPT and the existing online systems.
This paper validates the efficacy of our method and contributes a novel
perspective to machine-assisted literary translation.
|
[
-0.009223473258316517,
-0.5494988560676575,
0.5758489370346069,
0.4527444541454315,
-0.771813690662384,
-0.20413753390312195,
-0.44217896461486816,
-0.5203394889831543,
-0.2008202224969864,
0.16162651777267456,
-0.6589785814285278,
-0.20948411524295807,
-0.9001418948173523,
0.2773565351963043,
-0.5564355850219727,
1.2834365367889404,
-0.42288917303085327,
-0.1437438279390335,
0.2843663692474365,
0.07480357587337494,
-0.7214103937149048,
-0.18113790452480316,
-0.9858090281486511,
-0.4623338282108307,
0.49335989356040955,
-0.0072291032411158085,
0.8851310014724731,
0.45048853754997253,
0.6456027626991272,
0.2934320569038391,
0.12038058787584305,
0.517871081829071,
-0.14792999625205994,
-0.15435339510440826,
0.21791104972362518,
-0.5424331426620483,
-0.32830125093460083,
0.25649866461753845,
0.480773001909256,
0.488517165184021,
-0.05527070537209511,
0.1183699518442154,
0.1792503446340561,
0.6240556240081787,
-0.1635994166135788,
0.2860608994960785,
-0.6987664699554443,
0.5710895657539368,
-0.420645534992218,
-0.5859368443489075,
-0.5720926523208618,
-0.34142976999282837,
0.16223080456256866,
-0.6603535413742065,
0.11112736165523529,
0.2493688017129898,
0.786870539188385,
0.48110881447792053,
-0.4895736873149872,
-0.25831279158592224,
-0.6421948075294495,
0.4002687633037567,
-0.47344014048576355,
0.09995497018098831,
0.03519180789589882,
0.6293622851371765,
-0.300884485244751,
-0.7936871647834778,
-0.4858301877975464,
-0.21713438630104065,
-0.334587424993515,
0.5383598208427429,
-0.3961810767650604,
-0.031335439532995224,
-0.04670220986008644,
0.31127989292144775,
-1.0059040784835815,
-0.28144657611846924,
-0.16481295228004456,
-0.10067860037088394,
0.42748376727104187,
-0.0934317484498024,
0.7927497625350952,
-0.3614305853843689,
-0.44829049706459045,
0.23358602821826935,
-0.16453659534454346,
0.23901475965976715,
0.1476312130689621,
0.15852560102939606,
-0.020375248044729233,
0.5531909465789795,
0.1783728003501892,
0.5741024613380432,
-0.257463663816452,
0.21845553815364838,
0.23512236773967743,
-0.18944208323955536,
-0.018098384141921997,
0.14047609269618988,
0.812788724899292,
0.4593174159526825,
0.09200043976306915,
-0.43175843358039856,
-0.22803939878940582,
0.09857451170682907,
-0.005393689963966608,
-0.5644867420196533,
-0.432490736246109,
0.34101414680480957,
-0.5209938883781433,
-0.229930579662323,
-0.2363852560520172,
-0.4156044125556946,
-0.36970794200897217,
-0.17782166600227356,
0.64593505859375,
-0.5088000893592834,
-0.26863163709640503,
0.4042566120624542,
-0.5949649810791016,
0.11620167642831802,
0.3593749701976776,
-0.6727888584136963,
-0.0917210727930069,
0.7398506999015808,
0.9532632231712341,
-0.18421132862567902,
-0.5452666878700256,
-0.5118195414543152,
-0.07643592357635498,
-0.311739057302475,
0.7144289016723633,
-0.14586687088012695,
0.3429419994354248,
-0.1737225353717804,
-0.07671509683132172,
-0.43408921360969543,
-0.18739427626132965,
1.1830391883850098,
-0.11250198632478714,
0.39893072843551636,
-0.02142302133142948,
-0.28363728523254395,
-0.22246576845645905,
0.16161906719207764,
-0.3397713005542755,
0.8439434170722961,
-0.2114628404378891,
-0.797725260257721,
0.11154031753540039,
-0.9130268692970276,
-0.2677382826805115,
0.3241578936576843,
0.013314690440893173,
-0.20612765848636627,
0.05735546723008156,
0.44373032450675964,
0.46841496229171753,
-0.13106873631477356,
-0.1383965164422989,
0.33907103538513184,
-0.3731992542743683,
0.5923582315444946,
-0.779545247554779,
0.832854688167572,
0.5202509164810181,
-0.42882758378982544,
-0.10300643742084503,
-0.31118422746658325,
0.07999031245708466,
0.6361207962036133,
-0.18863177299499512,
0.007725998759269714,
-0.06951342523097992,
0.21326331794261932,
0.24540598690509796,
0.3684152066707611,
-0.4639418125152588,
-0.1768198013305664,
-0.5093073844909668,
0.8853698372840881,
0.6354275345802307,
-0.22263911366462708,
0.08352969586849213,
-0.435977578163147,
0.7403645515441895,
-0.3325049877166748,
0.15487933158874512,
-0.4594804346561432,
-0.839397668838501,
-0.32774263620376587,
-0.14910635352134705,
0.18390342593193054,
0.6292000412940979,
-0.6742205023765564,
0.252317875623703,
-0.27514949440956116,
-0.6734142303466797,
-0.9484666585922241,
0.05967530980706215,
0.15708424150943756,
0.2601322531700134,
0.3384498655796051,
-0.27503156661987305,
-0.05222919210791588,
-0.6356419324874878,
-0.6501066088676453,
-0.18356020748615265,
0.10166606307029724,
-0.026848793029785156,
-0.11834731698036194,
-0.05687019228935242,
0.46327534317970276,
-0.17705713212490082,
0.03343186154961586,
-0.30056044459342957,
0.45497649908065796,
0.4120853841304779,
0.27396172285079956,
0.38560226559638977,
-1.017681360244751,
-0.6820346713066101,
0.47634023427963257,
-0.5367425680160522,
-0.42244818806648254,
-0.5696533918380737,
-0.5518588423728943,
-0.13815872371196747,
-0.0827288031578064,
-0.8248600363731384,
0.33947768807411194,
0.6378278732299805,
-0.09201515465974808,
0.5923678278923035,
-0.3376084566116333,
0.290360689163208,
-0.7431965470314026,
0.04227372258901596,
-0.29063454270362854,
-0.4721042215824127,
-0.49916115403175354,
0.506263256072998,
0.14341238141059875,
-0.4505488872528076,
-0.1376783400774002,
0.10062412917613983,
-0.4046114981174469,
0.2000313699245453,
-0.3773193955421448,
0.6678462624549866,
0.13754361867904663,
0.3390292227268219,
-0.19362938404083252,
0.3550635576248169,
0.31232449412345886,
-0.10223106294870377,
0.6269308924674988,
0.24646899104118347,
0.09544892609119415,
0.5029286742210388,
-0.3268025517463684,
0.5188283920288086,
-0.22684717178344727,
0.39123377203941345,
-1.5030792951583862,
0.07114140689373016,
0.5738463997840881,
-0.7715644240379333,
0.2232549637556076,
-0.3156599998474121,
-0.5270777344703674,
-0.4215848445892334,
0.03505785018205643,
0.27834242582321167,
0.6698945164680481,
-0.5777751803398132,
0.32283177971839905,
-0.24224413931369781,
-0.1201612576842308,
-0.37953612208366394,
-0.7607795000076294,
0.44506001472473145,
-0.3567890226840973,
-0.8381657004356384,
0.26436904072761536,
-0.2327103465795517,
0.13284121453762054,
-0.0022140354849398136,
-0.06627552211284637,
0.019348692148923874,
0.08431640267372131,
-0.22553440928459167,
0.016819477081298828,
-0.1685236692428589,
0.3181953728199005,
-0.09805183857679367,
-0.4573669135570526,
-0.06911692768335342,
-0.6492318511009216,
0.5370498299598694,
-0.015265420079231262,
-0.5778920650482178,
-0.5502655506134033,
0.4568721354007721,
0.4442903697490692,
-0.5097357034683228,
0.4178988039493561,
1.1370935440063477,
-0.11449136584997177,
-0.28655341267585754,
-0.24167224764823914,
0.3122119903564453,
-0.3918759524822235,
0.1992669701576233,
-0.5003185272216797,
-0.2720688581466675,
0.22858764231204987,
-0.2487000674009323,
0.31632497906684875,
0.5251400470733643,
0.3626522123813629,
-0.1490442305803299,
0.877054750919342,
0.33922165632247925,
-0.14589948952198029,
0.29965582489967346,
0.06521903723478317,
0.597945511341095,
-0.5984315276145935,
0.27288442850112915,
-0.61644047498703,
-0.4383576810359955,
-0.6656053066253662,
-0.326992928981781,
0.5469778180122375,
0.08636894077062607,
0.22230519354343414,
0.6075764894485474,
-0.9339640736579895,
0.26238131523132324,
0.03989553824067116,
0.1870017945766449,
0.4340243339538574,
-0.005224982276558876,
-0.20793572068214417,
-0.0903424322605133,
-0.6040003299713135,
-0.4524867534637451,
0.7426497936248779,
0.20421314239501953,
-0.007927135564386845,
0.3429395854473114,
0.5163400173187256,
0.12456345558166504,
0.03246729075908661,
-0.8674193024635315,
0.37577569484710693,
-0.36710798740386963,
-0.355658620595932,
-0.42891666293144226,
-0.3524104654788971,
-1.1603375673294067,
0.5756458640098572,
-0.01120811514556408,
-0.5024085640907288,
-0.6773388385772705,
0.034107692539691925,
0.02150474674999714,
0.10262361913919449,
-0.9515987038612366,
1.1455020904541016,
-0.5695415735244751,
0.06636761873960495,
-0.15165600180625916,
-0.5166345834732056,
0.06072524935007095,
-0.1719021201133728,
0.45889854431152344,
-0.06300865858793259,
-0.26415467262268066,
0.11694346368312836,
-0.29173821210861206,
0.4491299092769623,
0.002742409473285079,
-0.16510334610939026,
0.029857106506824493,
0.14719119668006897,
0.7574870586395264,
-0.49610257148742676,
-0.21364617347717285,
-0.003823533421382308,
0.0776364654302597,
-0.570167064666748,
-0.9445292353630066,
0.2645617723464966,
-0.5896561145782471,
-0.41480544209480286,
0.020076267421245575,
-0.4965907335281372,
0.10057031363248825,
0.029886385425925255,
0.6273171305656433,
0.17906342446804047,
0.12205728143453598,
-0.17622356116771698,
0.09656661003828049,
-0.2352883517742157,
0.407589852809906,
0.3222270905971527,
-0.42655932903289795,
-0.024072498083114624,
0.5936620831489563,
0.17877744138240814,
0.18191610276699066,
0.5247170925140381,
0.5325772166252136,
-0.26832422614097595,
-0.7406132817268372,
-1.163572072982788,
0.004890521056950092,
-0.7641662955284119,
0.3487495481967926,
-0.5037306547164917,
-0.25952592492103577,
-0.23089542984962463,
-0.1841934323310852,
-0.17835471034049988,
-0.40753597021102905,
0.30273377895355225,
0.08799030631780624,
0.3225165903568268,
0.37746506929397583,
0.21175605058670044,
0.10801156610250473,
-0.7140630483627319,
0.2676349878311157,
0.0837850272655487,
0.031337711960077286,
-0.10180824249982834,
-0.7100427746772766,
-0.08691117912530899,
-0.1532537341117859,
-0.3532724678516388,
-1.1838334798812866,
0.2589433789253235,
0.1969580501317978,
0.4920242428779602,
0.13207374513149261,
0.0076423268765211105,
0.7314292788505554,
-0.9674814939498901,
0.8350417017936707,
0.06564319878816605,
-0.7939964532852173,
0.6828029751777649,
-0.5053232908248901,
0.176705002784729,
0.057313911616802216,
0.34730836749076843,
-1.2358894348144531,
-0.42871811985969543,
-0.4440821707248688,
-0.8699910044670105,
0.32717862725257874,
0.7847573757171631,
0.4719735383987427,
0.20928265154361725,
0.5756463408470154,
0.13418734073638916,
-0.018051980063319206,
-0.985399603843689,
-0.2537608742713928,
-0.22626328468322754,
-0.2921675443649292,
-0.34415486454963684,
0.40954744815826416,
0.023689037188887596,
-0.1469196379184723,
0.6309018135070801,
0.1176503375172615,
0.4701809287071228,
0.28700265288352966,
-0.07244659215211868,
-0.2849089205265045,
0.44350385665893555,
0.35014867782592773,
0.5211350321769714,
0.14843519032001495,
0.2300521433353424,
0.07531218230724335,
-0.19554181396961212,
-0.02974465675652027,
0.3490382432937622,
-0.292173832654953,
0.23331166803836823,
0.35795465111732483,
0.7064663767814636,
-0.15857535600662231,
-0.3376951515674591,
0.6804160475730896,
0.0636669397354126,
0.2912942171096802,
-0.49093136191368103,
-0.1356550008058548,
0.0838460624217987,
0.22999879717826843,
0.19401010870933533,
0.22186404466629028,
0.38778355717658997,
-0.3862261176109314,
-0.05955638363957405,
0.3422406315803528,
-0.340935081243515,
-0.2088392972946167,
0.6341099739074707,
-0.034432221204042435,
-0.551599383354187,
-0.024689486250281334,
-0.42737483978271484,
-0.8097965121269226,
0.40511927008628845,
0.6549145579338074,
1.1583783626556396,
-0.0013057232135906816,
0.3625721037387848,
0.04834403470158577,
0.7891082763671875,
0.06913308054208755,
-0.06325999647378922,
-0.10919022560119629,
-0.5365010499954224,
-0.6029632687568665,
-0.35844507813453674,
-0.3420390784740448,
-0.15920040011405945,
-0.11575420200824738,
0.3913704752922058,
0.07453728467226028,
0.08503652364015579,
0.1455724686384201,
-0.10589881241321564,
-0.5911147594451904,
-0.2522917687892914,
0.1530298888683319,
0.6258940696716309,
-0.8204715847969055,
0.5966215133666992,
0.8428267240524292,
-0.46434420347213745,
-1.1024929285049438,
0.137873575091362,
0.11850740015506744,
-0.8127716779708862,
0.40771904587745667,
0.18889349699020386,
-0.16138164699077606,
0.3562866151332855,
-0.3799998462200165,
-0.1455191820859909,
0.8286756873130798,
0.45592382550239563,
-0.13780759274959564,
0.37836360931396484,
0.3488737642765045,
0.6839359402656555,
0.059579771012067795,
0.39429283142089844,
0.3383585810661316,
0.6215937733650208,
-0.11394426226615906,
-1.2650607824325562,
0.04300083592534065,
-0.5745025873184204,
-0.06001478061079979,
0.3317721486091614,
-0.7517522573471069,
0.7117271423339844,
0.3099030554294586,
-0.3637832701206207,
0.31924498081207275,
0.196782186627388,
-0.08753348886966705,
0.532780647277832,
0.39333575963974,
0.440581738948822,
0.9150358438491821,
0.059457987546920776,
1.1470134258270264,
0.02747422084212303,
0.2049618661403656,
0.7280378341674805,
0.13421471416950226,
0.840053379535675,
0.31471437215805054,
-0.4020306169986725,
0.35130006074905396,
0.6869217753410339,
0.19472341239452362,
0.19475193321704865,
0.41723787784576416,
-0.46114641427993774,
-0.16901887953281403,
-0.0030607038643211126,
-0.3835091292858124,
0.44566136598587036,
-0.048336211591959,
-0.4697721004486084,
-0.2825705409049988,
0.11612068116664886,
0.13020451366901398,
0.24845866858959198,
-0.16506530344486237,
0.5988062620162964,
0.15552350878715515,
-0.7340888977050781,
0.5976515412330627,
0.3868681788444519,
0.5883665680885315,
-0.4822149872779846,
-0.09825334697961807,
-0.09005039930343628,
0.0627380907535553,
-0.21050876379013062,
-0.5298842787742615,
0.1757269948720932,
0.14941804111003876,
0.25061777234077454,
-0.45483484864234924,
0.8097967505455017,
-0.36898383498191833,
-0.49099263548851013,
0.14261774718761444,
0.49508529901504517,
0.7978194355964661,
-0.3697448968887329,
-0.8642907738685608,
-0.29311272501945496,
0.0710323378443718,
0.09209837019443512,
0.11760631203651428,
1.208980679512024,
0.053346168249845505,
0.522859513759613,
0.6197230219841003,
0.42887893319129944,
0.2028842270374298,
-0.2277308851480484,
0.37829262018203735,
-0.28441953659057617,
-0.6647931337356567,
-0.9065367579460144,
0.6516018509864807,
0.1861676722764969,
-0.3212226331233978,
0.6530846953392029,
0.24852469563484192,
0.618342399597168,
0.0007625570287927985,
0.917522132396698,
0.09394975006580353,
0.3959715664386749,
-0.5737025737762451,
0.8486858606338501,
-0.42114174365997314,
0.12329033762216568,
-0.35569483041763306,
-0.7003664374351501,
-0.257491797208786,
0.6431614756584167,
-0.3551672101020813,
-0.30413082242012024,
0.9678099155426025,
0.49134719371795654,
-0.12276449054479599,
0.3357546925544739,
0.39948570728302,
0.06041363626718521,
0.3633319139480591,
0.8214030861854553,
0.8755688071250916,
-0.8066986203193665,
1.07799232006073,
-0.23319651186466217,
-0.42889919877052307,
0.03363172337412834,
-1.200006127357483,
-0.5481352806091309,
-0.5473864078521729,
-0.2883487641811371,
-0.029224561527371407,
-0.08654502034187317,
1.1527442932128906,
0.4843387007713318,
-0.3944760262966156,
0.08226548135280609,
-0.014343718998134136,
-0.2698740065097809,
-0.6004205942153931,
-0.0991784855723381,
0.6586991548538208,
-0.6243952512741089,
-0.7258828282356262,
0.237873837351799,
0.3081512451171875,
-0.26888182759284973,
-0.09270206093788147,
-0.17976690828800201,
0.2856338918209076,
-0.0496165007352829,
0.6760716438293457,
-0.09406734257936478,
-0.8403542041778564,
-0.3610222041606903,
-0.1824032962322235,
-0.08142503350973129,
0.154372900724411,
0.7082035541534424,
-0.05893292650580406,
0.7274313569068909,
0.4740077555179596,
1.11322820186615,
0.5173051953315735,
-0.08265820145606995,
0.4007347822189331,
-0.5524263978004456,
0.10109729319810867,
-0.005231659859418869,
0.4185855984687805,
0.21931111812591553,
-0.6012370586395264,
0.5903754830360413,
0.4572432041168213,
-0.6166654825210571,
-0.3920045793056488,
0.19240398705005646,
-1.104888677597046,
-0.09124737977981567,
0.8183958530426025,
-0.5209579467773438,
0.05640248954296112,
-0.2517136335372925,
-0.697721004486084,
0.537479817867279,
-0.0933530330657959,
0.7342470288276672,
1.1664092540740967,
-0.30122289061546326,
-0.6789258122444153,
-1.2130866050720215,
0.2320532500743866,
0.7309848070144653,
-0.6347433924674988,
-0.011597140692174435,
0.17547018826007843,
-0.047891583293676376,
0.02074514515697956,
0.7294267416000366,
-0.31893596053123474,
0.40942659974098206,
-0.27245500683784485,
0.13448992371559143,
0.042826276272535324,
0.20164412260055542,
-0.3729214072227478,
0.14799590408802032,
0.45066970586776733,
-0.31373029947280884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03445v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03445v1
|
Pre-trained Large Language Models Use Fourier Features to Compute Addition
| 2024-06-05T16:40:53 | 2024-06-05T16:40:53 |
Tianyi Zhou, Deqing Fu, Vatsal Sharan, Robin Jia
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Pre-trained large language models (LLMs) exhibit impressive mathematical
reasoning capabilities, yet how they compute basic arithmetic, such as
addition, remains unclear. This paper shows that pre-trained LLMs add numbers
using Fourier features -- dimensions in the hidden state that represent numbers
via a set of features sparse in the frequency domain. Within the model, MLP and
attention layers use Fourier features in complementary ways: MLP layers
primarily approximate the magnitude of the answer using low-frequency features,
while attention layers primarily perform modular addition (e.g., computing
whether the answer is even or odd) using high-frequency features. Pre-training
is crucial for this mechanism: models trained from scratch to add numbers only
exploit low-frequency features, leading to lower accuracy. Introducing
pre-trained token embeddings to a randomly initialized model rescues its
performance. Overall, our analysis demonstrates that appropriate pre-trained
representations (e.g., Fourier features) can unlock the ability of Transformers
to learn precise mechanisms for algorithmic tasks.
|
[
-0.9287932515144348,
-0.4185939431190491,
0.6130536198616028,
0.5111268758773804,
-0.06806781142950058,
0.06038550287485123,
-0.17024804651737213,
-0.45515507459640503,
0.048935554921627045,
0.6784623861312866,
-0.5467435717582703,
-0.03300679102540016,
-0.6145368814468384,
-0.1405489295721054,
-0.48508283495903015,
0.7672333717346191,
0.26016199588775635,
0.08641261607408524,
-0.2163909524679184,
-0.010960767976939678,
-0.2156430184841156,
-0.8565892577171326,
-0.30830568075180054,
-0.4471302628517151,
0.3933320641517639,
0.16420283913612366,
0.8533653616905212,
0.3767610192298889,
0.6713075637817383,
0.4644795358181,
0.355823278427124,
-0.23894096910953522,
-0.35444915294647217,
-0.2775963544845581,
0.10683657974004745,
-0.759985625743866,
-0.687954306602478,
0.017626212909817696,
0.7234789729118347,
1.0087743997573853,
0.03678670525550842,
0.3514055609703064,
-0.04358317330479622,
0.8760820031166077,
-0.4212718904018402,
0.46149200201034546,
-0.6079208850860596,
0.23878973722457886,
-0.24024951457977295,
-0.1402759999036789,
-0.38167041540145874,
-0.302960604429245,
0.25912684202194214,
-0.5752015709877014,
0.32261478900909424,
-0.1581260859966278,
0.6634793877601624,
0.5685322880744934,
-0.23557856678962708,
-0.3021862506866455,
-0.9075377583503723,
0.7161232829093933,
-0.5404722690582275,
0.8041929602622986,
0.4745306372642517,
0.10304707288742065,
0.13500556349754333,
-0.7411296963691711,
-0.5010931491851807,
-0.1447896659374237,
-0.1256452351808548,
-0.17248515784740448,
-0.08366311341524124,
0.0007993369363248348,
0.5071269869804382,
0.37284621596336365,
-0.12875297665596008,
-0.020570646971464157,
-0.34272512793540955,
0.030718570575118065,
0.7022534012794495,
-0.0643761083483696,
0.0341501459479332,
0.2727505564689636,
-0.1444844901561737,
-0.3875466287136078,
-0.6248536109924316,
0.3085240423679352,
0.20039625465869904,
0.12022195756435394,
-0.2964390516281128,
0.7170624732971191,
0.15711750090122223,
0.6064785122871399,
0.41828465461730957,
0.06574706733226776,
0.31854310631752014,
-0.0250824224203825,
-0.4015777111053467,
0.16419686377048492,
0.585376501083374,
-0.5200605392456055,
0.944385826587677,
0.06967790424823761,
-0.4024754762649536,
-0.17808032035827637,
0.5217059254646301,
-0.5368103981018066,
-0.24619156122207642,
0.013006174005568027,
-0.1872602105140686,
-0.23216214776039124,
-0.007074578199535608,
-0.03150663152337074,
0.05294109508395195,
-0.5006438493728638,
0.6855285167694092,
-0.4046052098274231,
-0.015754280611872673,
0.4682377278804779,
0.034642789512872696,
0.1407686173915863,
0.3903505504131317,
-1.1269326210021973,
0.5923703908920288,
0.8998540043830872,
0.3136805295944214,
0.3833065927028656,
-0.5048263669013977,
-0.44908514618873596,
-0.04207849130034447,
-0.4431908428668976,
0.6496789455413818,
-0.7710678577423096,
-0.1154661625623703,
-0.16769787669181824,
-0.09714663773775101,
-0.012612596154212952,
-0.4429711699485779,
0.1777285635471344,
-0.9187320470809937,
0.0925116166472435,
-0.19757382571697235,
-0.30937516689300537,
-0.27714109420776367,
-0.29731765389442444,
-0.7886107563972473,
1.158371090888977,
0.29943323135375977,
-0.6213138103485107,
0.08374614268541336,
-0.6922528147697449,
-0.556562066078186,
-0.005972428247332573,
-0.12180357426404953,
-0.43069958686828613,
0.7085801362991333,
0.44162553548812866,
0.5760995745658875,
-0.16667097806930542,
0.30658653378486633,
-0.5018534660339355,
-0.6070498824119568,
0.7254928946495056,
-0.6377590894699097,
0.6634014248847961,
0.05296223610639572,
-0.1986437439918518,
0.07954595983028412,
-0.6586165428161621,
-0.11324220895767212,
0.13674329221248627,
-0.40705057978630066,
-0.007098670583218336,
-0.08476884663105011,
-0.33096039295196533,
0.15769639611244202,
0.12210109084844589,
-0.220533549785614,
-0.24570681154727936,
-0.7359856367111206,
0.1808464676141739,
0.8098471164703369,
-0.3088657557964325,
0.628126859664917,
-0.3537759780883789,
0.28845614194869995,
0.06062448397278786,
-0.07639273256063461,
-0.348392516374588,
-0.3720671832561493,
-0.9951796531677246,
-0.2082332819700241,
0.42147016525268555,
0.6654150485992432,
-0.7063122987747192,
0.6472585201263428,
-0.5664769411087036,
-0.3784744441509247,
-0.4715888202190399,
0.3332452178001404,
0.22542895376682281,
0.22313876450061798,
0.2822759449481964,
-0.24916955828666687,
-0.19731588661670685,
-0.8391980528831482,
-0.11520479619503021,
-0.013675660826265812,
-0.39078956842422485,
0.20385192334651947,
0.3035615384578705,
0.1708909422159195,
0.7539526224136353,
-0.5325631499290466,
-0.08571062237024307,
-0.12476354092359543,
-0.04133208096027374,
0.4154472053050995,
0.39237502217292786,
0.47770440578460693,
-0.6669145822525024,
-0.27112099528312683,
-0.14620289206504822,
-0.673265814781189,
0.011894423514604568,
-0.28577756881713867,
0.13130728900432587,
-0.11126375943422318,
0.31821438670158386,
-0.5830354690551758,
0.27072057127952576,
0.38297250866889954,
-0.022143270820379257,
0.21948756277561188,
-0.2721898555755615,
0.061629775911569595,
-0.5745497941970825,
-0.1805151104927063,
0.12063512206077576,
-0.27730628848075867,
-0.6468217372894287,
-0.006382301915436983,
0.2123657763004303,
-0.4223352372646332,
-0.39919281005859375,
0.2591814696788788,
-0.4544559419155121,
-0.3302837610244751,
-0.08776360005140305,
-0.15753477811813354,
0.05722169205546379,
0.8899582028388977,
0.184012770652771,
0.8455176949501038,
0.47906890511512756,
-0.570737361907959,
0.4119895100593567,
0.017680194228887558,
-0.37065401673316956,
0.21286220848560333,
-0.7220953702926636,
0.11506704986095428,
-0.1392993927001953,
-0.006775420159101486,
-0.8395063281059265,
-0.1704002022743225,
-0.23673966526985168,
-0.5047198534011841,
0.5761445760726929,
-0.03827585652470589,
-0.5519412159919739,
-0.5061734914779663,
-0.38195860385894775,
0.6257078051567078,
0.6572080254554749,
-0.31638041138648987,
0.8227285146713257,
0.47363221645355225,
-0.35733509063720703,
-0.5357110500335693,
-0.7820269465446472,
-0.15682946145534515,
0.03587405011057854,
-0.859856367111206,
0.32335999608039856,
0.16607560217380524,
-0.16245096921920776,
-0.02719607576727867,
0.024844827130436897,
-0.11102486401796341,
0.3841376304626465,
0.2490890622138977,
0.11288401484489441,
-0.49744969606399536,
0.21368199586868286,
-0.018165504559874535,
-0.24359916150569916,
0.32521599531173706,
-0.23612119257450104,
1.0070178508758545,
-0.3887810707092285,
-0.8234765529632568,
-0.33880773186683655,
0.3392121195793152,
0.6097263693809509,
-0.4666205048561096,
0.4001438021659851,
0.6552057266235352,
-0.4774920344352722,
-0.2522827088832855,
-0.7209336757659912,
-0.27324894070625305,
-0.6294031143188477,
0.5328763127326965,
-0.5048317313194275,
-1.0462653636932373,
0.4291797876358032,
0.1328781396150589,
-0.03348270803689957,
0.5302156209945679,
0.6287955045700073,
-0.30424317717552185,
0.9680222272872925,
0.673366367816925,
0.1664285957813263,
0.46094217896461487,
-0.08806857466697693,
0.19688677787780762,
-0.6394862532615662,
-0.17465558648109436,
-0.5814924240112305,
-0.29396453499794006,
-0.4132499098777771,
-0.5930715203285217,
0.26691490411758423,
0.21553339064121246,
-0.5877372026443481,
0.11033228784799576,
-0.22717460989952087,
0.5194526314735413,
0.7577505111694336,
0.2344999611377716,
-0.11829777806997299,
0.23055703938007355,
0.0694388896226883,
-0.077949658036232,
-0.5907273292541504,
-0.0374586246907711,
1.0800681114196777,
0.7521973848342896,
0.9109439849853516,
-0.11885850876569748,
0.7564429044723511,
0.2332155853509903,
0.25110989809036255,
-0.7678711414337158,
0.4667038321495056,
-0.2941215932369232,
-0.3731999397277832,
-0.45136216282844543,
-0.4103821814060211,
-0.4415366053581238,
-0.026725515723228455,
-0.37653738260269165,
-0.30188602209091187,
0.26821959018707275,
0.09463177621364594,
-0.6387407183647156,
0.15058192610740662,
-0.8612640500068665,
0.3811083734035492,
-0.5693954825401306,
-0.10750588774681091,
-0.22289228439331055,
-0.427886962890625,
0.3264760971069336,
-0.5476627349853516,
0.270318865776062,
0.09089594334363937,
0.021145137026906013,
0.5817105174064636,
-0.3352283835411072,
1.063350796699524,
-0.01585964299738407,
-0.450601726770401,
0.17783521115779877,
0.15178850293159485,
0.5365337133407593,
0.1267356276512146,
0.2054317593574524,
0.30811065435409546,
-0.2849242389202118,
-0.4276150166988373,
-0.6184746623039246,
0.5657527446746826,
-0.9307997822761536,
-0.9574460983276367,
-0.24377748370170593,
-0.624904453754425,
-0.5605451464653015,
-0.005165251437574625,
-0.04759075865149498,
0.506198525428772,
0.16252391040325165,
0.30788397789001465,
1.0490635633468628,
-0.377480149269104,
0.631334125995636,
0.2579849362373352,
-0.3471035957336426,
-0.5022435784339905,
0.9285135269165039,
0.3772100508213043,
0.35868191719055176,
0.4803168475627899,
0.08209118247032166,
-0.3375684320926666,
-0.4489423632621765,
-0.31981438398361206,
0.34772688150405884,
-0.771225094795227,
0.01218611653894186,
-0.7883342504501343,
-0.6085403561592102,
-0.4908294379711151,
-0.3311185836791992,
-0.2788325548171997,
-0.7557616233825684,
-0.19812707602977753,
-0.099428690969944,
0.20624695718288422,
0.571549654006958,
-0.11426063627004623,
0.4679061472415924,
-1.3034147024154663,
0.6532825827598572,
0.8601757287979126,
0.5320166349411011,
0.29680880904197693,
-0.5669990181922913,
-0.5282174944877625,
0.039157893508672714,
-0.11977559328079224,
-0.4799601435661316,
0.23465445637702942,
0.3043326735496521,
0.5105176568031311,
0.5117699503898621,
-0.35072633624076843,
0.6539090275764465,
-0.7351858019828796,
0.4719586968421936,
0.20110547542572021,
-1.209628701210022,
0.19831174612045288,
-0.20501890778541565,
0.5135740637779236,
0.21871915459632874,
0.4411199688911438,
-0.06843648850917816,
-0.15506090223789215,
-0.61278235912323,
-0.23766183853149414,
1.027359127998352,
0.1231781616806984,
0.5744310617446899,
0.044437941163778305,
0.0893133208155632,
-0.20702789723873138,
0.3086508810520172,
-0.8316943645477295,
-0.35193508863449097,
-0.39344045519828796,
-0.37675923109054565,
-0.13134834170341492,
-0.5115508437156677,
-0.09979734569787979,
-0.45641863346099854,
0.22598035633563995,
0.11383426189422607,
0.5194804072380066,
-0.11321903765201569,
-0.25762197375297546,
-0.16328655183315277,
0.21023377776145935,
0.7141814231872559,
0.5175060033798218,
-0.14792989194393158,
0.34536969661712646,
0.35109078884124756,
-0.6856908202171326,
0.004109121859073639,
0.21437084674835205,
0.21812014281749725,
-0.2776351869106293,
0.7596891522407532,
0.7964073419570923,
0.5090867877006531,
-0.38417813181877136,
0.46994131803512573,
0.06361345201730728,
-0.19704222679138184,
-0.4239765405654907,
0.3463723361492157,
0.4281996190547943,
0.2467290461063385,
0.6017338633537292,
0.37743252515792847,
-0.12598726153373718,
-0.3940291404724121,
0.39230114221572876,
0.4569379985332489,
-0.5502719283103943,
-0.5699479579925537,
0.46321675181388855,
0.23367728292942047,
-0.5096027851104736,
0.5081852674484253,
0.30841898918151855,
-0.7402851581573486,
0.7989375591278076,
0.5848557949066162,
0.8728063702583313,
-0.30186864733695984,
0.001520328689366579,
0.08687721937894821,
0.6568284034729004,
0.059816159307956696,
0.3510615825653076,
-0.34784162044525146,
-0.8743974566459656,
-0.7730244994163513,
-0.9349213242530823,
0.17118096351623535,
-0.12654925882816315,
-0.5475906729698181,
0.18258745968341827,
-0.8257326483726501,
-0.11380524188280106,
0.22441916167736053,
-0.11674574017524719,
-1.1023765802383423,
0.16771309077739716,
0.48142242431640625,
0.7383461594581604,
-0.7524210810661316,
0.9843241572380066,
0.21559719741344452,
-0.012005449272692204,
-0.772093653678894,
-0.26219338178634644,
-0.3083666265010834,
-1.303605318069458,
0.8925526738166809,
0.25643429160118103,
-0.23454518616199493,
0.2986973226070404,
-0.5252401232719421,
-1.1525424718856812,
0.553864598274231,
0.5928353667259216,
-0.6956932544708252,
0.06556494534015656,
0.7018450498580933,
0.5021743178367615,
-0.3852837085723877,
0.08719941973686218,
0.24487468600273132,
0.4258204400539398,
0.16081644594669342,
-0.984157383441925,
-0.06583457440137863,
-0.26120713353157043,
-0.1623620092868805,
0.5030012726783752,
-0.36447009444236755,
1.1526005268096924,
-0.3258587718009949,
-0.32973629236221313,
-0.6316994428634644,
0.5284385681152344,
-0.06663170456886292,
0.03757574036717415,
0.4087355434894562,
0.8909844160079956,
0.41798168420791626,
-0.1726517379283905,
1.1875852346420288,
-0.1715727299451828,
0.18027500808238983,
1.0021723508834839,
-0.2761783301830292,
0.6645042896270752,
0.2697974443435669,
-0.5149477124214172,
0.2953830063343048,
0.3938802480697632,
-0.16641682386398315,
0.31568220257759094,
0.15052887797355652,
-0.24737237393856049,
-0.6400702595710754,
0.20467863976955414,
-0.5023618340492249,
0.4405879080295563,
0.6361918449401855,
-0.34716570377349854,
-0.11825151741504669,
0.08408091217279434,
-0.13175249099731445,
-0.18726222217082977,
-0.5396068096160889,
1.0252470970153809,
0.29943031072616577,
-0.3383702337741852,
0.7889633178710938,
-0.07525037974119186,
0.4204784631729126,
-0.6402812004089355,
-0.1465364545583725,
-0.05679037794470787,
0.11279229074716568,
-0.18902476131916046,
-0.9341616034507751,
0.26460981369018555,
-0.2128974348306656,
-0.3437121510505676,
-0.06904447078704834,
0.3185407221317291,
-0.21057094633579254,
-1.1320252418518066,
0.1473650187253952,
0.4222952723503113,
-0.2942267060279846,
-0.2904892563819885,
-0.6631640195846558,
-0.14276373386383057,
-0.031126147136092186,
-0.22959353029727936,
0.3945750594139099,
0.7101925611495972,
-0.1872812956571579,
0.7093290090560913,
1.011898398399353,
0.06444104015827179,
0.35974642634391785,
0.35271236300468445,
1.1340128183364868,
-0.70281583070755,
-0.30232933163642883,
-0.9847585558891296,
0.38880982995033264,
0.19971132278442383,
0.043132565915584564,
0.4166052043437958,
0.2394341677427292,
1.0242705345153809,
-0.28984513878822327,
0.43760135769844055,
0.5564925670623779,
0.13217280805110931,
-0.6699414849281311,
0.7458275556564331,
-0.32333338260650635,
0.5085960030555725,
-0.08486934006214142,
-1.0994541645050049,
-0.44841837882995605,
0.3948921263217926,
-0.2869110405445099,
0.2308661788702011,
0.6074411869049072,
0.5288262963294983,
-0.2167184203863144,
-0.09644288569688797,
0.43072617053985596,
0.2126758098602295,
0.14101286232471466,
0.6297478079795837,
0.8120585680007935,
-0.23752951622009277,
0.24333393573760986,
-0.5015966296195984,
-0.13392652571201324,
-0.00011086141603300348,
-0.5613306760787964,
-1.0972439050674438,
-0.3452499806880951,
0.1767154335975647,
0.046806249767541885,
-0.6313645839691162,
0.8150227665901184,
0.5602754950523376,
-0.9000090956687927,
-0.20833493769168854,
0.2238471955060959,
0.08487912267446518,
0.07618123292922974,
-0.1671127825975418,
0.45899417996406555,
-0.42003175616264343,
-0.49534299969673157,
0.2588264048099518,
0.555427610874176,
0.3260701298713684,
-0.4132077097892761,
0.11841568350791931,
0.017735358327627182,
0.5009226202964783,
0.5353865623474121,
-0.03879726678133011,
-0.482848584651947,
-0.2908633351325989,
0.33877500891685486,
0.07325031608343124,
0.012083787471055984,
1.0440031290054321,
-0.9372783899307251,
0.10604780167341232,
0.48979952931404114,
0.7529997229576111,
0.6112508773803711,
-0.057237669825553894,
0.6011979579925537,
-0.7553500533103943,
0.48184478282928467,
0.31457775831222534,
0.41611549258232117,
0.18798023462295532,
-0.330161452293396,
0.1208583265542984,
0.11824166029691696,
-0.22685207426548004,
-0.7980644106864929,
0.2900038957595825,
-0.7854537963867188,
-0.22993575036525726,
0.44753497838974,
-0.10146796703338623,
-0.3417809009552002,
-0.10361485928297043,
0.07677934318780899,
-0.13959147036075592,
-0.06763704121112823,
0.7492743730545044,
0.6521870493888855,
-0.04697396606206894,
-0.33752870559692383,
-0.12354306131601334,
0.5891982913017273,
0.3360830545425415,
-0.6190823316574097,
-0.008389318361878395,
0.2464631348848343,
-0.014775256626307964,
0.45569494366645813,
0.4572336971759796,
-0.24244149029254913,
0.34130382537841797,
0.08621533960103989,
-0.08225894719362259,
-0.39028260111808777,
-0.5849735736846924,
-0.3700735867023468,
0.44925549626350403,
0.16641737520694733,
0.29651132225990295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03442v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03442v1
|
Are language models rational? The case of coherence norms and belief revision
| 2024-06-05T16:36:21 | 2024-06-05T16:36:21 |
Thomas Hofweber, Peter Hase, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Do norms of rationality apply to machine learning models, in particular
language models? In this paper we investigate this question by focusing on a
special subset of rational norms: coherence norms. We consider both logical
coherence norms as well as coherence norms tied to the strength of belief. To
make sense of the latter, we introduce the Minimal Assent Connection (MAC) and
propose a new account of credence, which captures the strength of belief in
language models. This proposal uniformly assigns strength of belief simply on
the basis of model internal next token probabilities. We argue that rational
norms tied to coherence do apply to some language models, but not to others.
This issue is significant since rationality is closely tied to predicting and
explaining behavior, and thus it is connected to considerations about AI safety
and alignment, as well as understanding model behavior more generally.
|
[
-0.2412937730550766,
-0.7548018097877502,
0.7475355267524719,
-0.036244820803403854,
0.13265767693519592,
-0.3860718607902527,
-0.1259405016899109,
-0.471590131521225,
-0.21042762696743011,
0.574312686920166,
-0.41801536083221436,
0.005273816641420126,
-0.6139193773269653,
0.056887365877628326,
-0.27495595812797546,
0.8337761759757996,
-0.01580868288874626,
-0.08054929226636887,
-0.2990585267543793,
-0.45090287923812866,
-0.4396820366382599,
-0.75544673204422,
-0.3815784752368927,
-0.5207552313804626,
0.37123849987983704,
0.3822508454322815,
1.046867847442627,
0.7165805697441101,
0.46523338556289673,
0.3773851990699768,
0.2118573784828186,
-0.31377673149108887,
-0.2090308964252472,
0.21150608360767365,
-0.25060975551605225,
-0.7341687679290771,
-0.6271621584892273,
0.336162805557251,
0.5802618861198425,
1.1282756328582764,
0.016330014914274216,
-0.20512761175632477,
0.11464548856019974,
0.7573478817939758,
-0.19239112734794617,
0.29860353469848633,
-0.9914183616638184,
-0.13499417901039124,
0.2923840582370758,
-0.07579028606414795,
-0.7400423288345337,
-0.22538718581199646,
0.32933568954467773,
-0.5836278200149536,
0.23746784031391144,
0.418078750371933,
1.0332746505737305,
0.28708240389823914,
-0.7768258452415466,
-0.3811708390712738,
-0.205324187874794,
1.0000300407409668,
-0.6788861155509949,
0.6295226216316223,
0.7633343935012817,
0.450366348028183,
-0.23176437616348267,
-0.359144926071167,
-0.7364123463630676,
-0.6328930258750916,
0.030694808810949326,
-0.20698663592338562,
-0.1283685714006424,
0.3950490355491638,
0.4610587954521179,
0.2617728114128113,
-0.35206368565559387,
-0.2493179887533188,
-0.19431133568286896,
-0.2670963406562805,
0.528287410736084,
0.06626521795988083,
0.3629896342754364,
0.00972427986562252,
-0.22096334397792816,
0.054515913128852844,
-0.466098815202713,
0.24784111976623535,
0.04066117852926254,
0.18603822588920593,
-0.24054910242557526,
0.8324781656265259,
-0.16604122519493103,
0.5901271104812622,
0.24982112646102905,
-0.3938175141811371,
-0.06097421050071716,
-0.20046108961105347,
-0.5198575258255005,
0.08654975146055222,
0.6099591851234436,
0.04200994223356247,
0.5876598358154297,
0.01615842990577221,
-0.24901726841926575,
0.2951442301273346,
-0.05635315552353859,
-0.5691875219345093,
-0.4987344741821289,
-0.007531733252108097,
-0.45243918895721436,
-0.1247924342751503,
-0.14256037771701813,
0.12063145637512207,
-0.14980418980121613,
-0.8296816349029541,
0.18358339369297028,
-0.6321095824241638,
-0.33980488777160645,
0.20256508886814117,
-0.04106849431991577,
0.08249516785144806,
0.5340143442153931,
-1.1578197479248047,
0.5817923545837402,
1.1477742195129395,
0.49883371591567993,
0.13870231807231903,
-0.17484264075756073,
-0.23021434247493744,
0.07314608246088028,
-0.4838942289352417,
0.4323081076145172,
-0.8680826425552368,
-0.06541813164949417,
-0.30115437507629395,
0.2014371156692505,
-0.37333235144615173,
-0.38674208521842957,
0.513533890247345,
-0.6010870933532715,
-0.01401633583009243,
-0.45552510023117065,
-0.8831053972244263,
-0.5102219581604004,
0.18173924088478088,
-0.39292657375335693,
0.33930179476737976,
-0.002752695232629776,
-0.7654640078544617,
0.6170775890350342,
-0.5108330845832825,
-0.32296496629714966,
-0.26247328519821167,
-0.14677606523036957,
-0.14822210371494293,
0.1483151912689209,
-0.3161011338233948,
0.241714209318161,
0.013477979227900505,
0.4478192925453186,
-0.8006375432014465,
0.019666539505124092,
0.5005289316177368,
-0.5929571986198425,
1.0351799726486206,
0.33662644028663635,
0.07800982892513275,
0.17648433148860931,
-0.532810628414154,
0.017822932451963425,
-0.12048183381557465,
-0.08833082020282745,
-0.483716756105423,
0.06640615314245224,
-0.4029342532157898,
0.30137524008750916,
0.0239633210003376,
-0.30478140711784363,
0.20223931968212128,
-0.3151826858520508,
0.46146801114082336,
0.8057003021240234,
0.08611472696065903,
0.857591450214386,
-0.5699242949485779,
0.1183871403336525,
0.17922928929328918,
0.15756483376026154,
0.0023106392472982407,
-0.8700249791145325,
-0.8942268490791321,
-0.4897686541080475,
0.10984735190868378,
0.5690038800239563,
-0.07267408072948456,
0.44576436281204224,
-0.004248189739882946,
-0.21049395203590393,
-0.28546303510665894,
-0.08137407153844833,
0.053297922015190125,
0.8819605112075806,
0.22473542392253876,
0.024234112352132797,
-0.6923741102218628,
-0.9452954530715942,
-0.6119008660316467,
-0.9250882863998413,
0.21028375625610352,
0.36937564611434937,
0.6355293989181519,
-0.25840839743614197,
0.9762664437294006,
0.015056602656841278,
0.23751075565814972,
-0.02404988743364811,
0.0701511800289154,
0.041144959628582,
0.6600692868232727,
0.5105500817298889,
-0.7683600783348083,
-0.40733450651168823,
0.01872146688401699,
-0.8995936512947083,
0.03356533870100975,
-0.11154387146234512,
0.0003947475925087929,
0.6479687094688416,
0.12701299786567688,
-0.4407316744327545,
0.33607062697410583,
0.6613615155220032,
-0.5022199749946594,
0.17270751297473907,
-0.18504664301872253,
0.17455917596817017,
-0.903745174407959,
-0.24515756964683533,
0.08933848887681961,
-0.5846434831619263,
-0.7630175352096558,
-0.20504692196846008,
-0.08214910328388214,
0.11752855777740479,
-0.21540603041648865,
0.4397118091583252,
0.02519775927066803,
-0.12840645015239716,
-0.19571468234062195,
0.09341802448034286,
0.15809990465641022,
0.312849760055542,
0.23073281347751617,
0.4348854720592499,
0.46636146306991577,
-0.7416441440582275,
-0.18453460931777954,
0.14373564720153809,
-0.07221554219722748,
0.5425150990486145,
-0.8319055438041687,
-0.06638050824403763,
-0.03984444588422775,
-0.026484733447432518,
-0.7358442544937134,
-0.39770448207855225,
0.2858911156654358,
-0.6652665138244629,
0.08763618022203445,
-0.3304944634437561,
-0.03656526282429695,
0.22122345864772797,
0.1724485456943512,
0.18919871747493744,
0.8495636582374573,
-0.23886138200759888,
0.27683764696121216,
0.6478406190872192,
-0.1916142851114273,
-0.3864056169986725,
-0.8815637230873108,
-0.09405606985092163,
0.0668850988149643,
-0.9431930184364319,
-0.13328592479228973,
-0.2199305295944214,
-1.0214389562606812,
-0.0713832676410675,
0.061155349016189575,
-0.355367511510849,
0.5069137215614319,
0.47145843505859375,
0.39182230830192566,
-0.36565741896629333,
0.00824694987386465,
0.2671165466308594,
0.016869647428393364,
0.024833030998706818,
-0.3121737539768219,
0.2293197363615036,
-0.5094273090362549,
-0.5157932639122009,
-0.844788134098053,
0.20953159034252167,
0.6697811484336853,
0.30048036575317383,
0.710868775844574,
-0.11984404176473618,
-0.5520179271697998,
0.060236912220716476,
-0.2126529961824417,
-0.35492339730262756,
-0.46087267994880676,
0.047138672322034836,
-0.7090579867362976,
-1.1261262893676758,
0.3427201509475708,
0.3270205855369568,
0.04736212641000748,
0.7813979983329773,
0.6663531064987183,
-0.3769431710243225,
1.4017140865325928,
0.827995777130127,
-0.005262915510684252,
0.4227122962474823,
0.041427306830883026,
0.1942562758922577,
-0.5306715369224548,
-0.08457846194505692,
-0.7199349403381348,
0.06173873692750931,
-0.676753580570221,
-0.2077072113752365,
-0.031814344227313995,
0.49088412523269653,
-0.6277398467063904,
0.3805670738220215,
-0.09114396572113037,
0.1286814957857132,
0.06610705703496933,
-0.40215954184532166,
0.4622800648212433,
-0.034029219299554825,
-0.40339529514312744,
-0.24366459250450134,
-0.8807141780853271,
-0.9398924112319946,
0.4476412236690521,
0.5160921812057495,
0.5085113644599915,
0.023526282981038094,
0.5612374544143677,
0.362874835729599,
0.37727823853492737,
-0.7622205018997192,
0.4967145621776581,
0.3649592399597168,
-0.9036999940872192,
-0.3358575999736786,
-0.5495834350585938,
-0.7129324674606323,
0.26845264434814453,
-0.3231140673160553,
-0.6087050437927246,
0.4231962561607361,
0.3459935784339905,
0.15335899591445923,
0.2882675230503082,
-0.6603637337684631,
0.8171532154083252,
0.05009287968277931,
-0.04009987786412239,
-0.5190466046333313,
-0.3283834159374237,
0.7960396409034729,
0.04768817499279976,
0.30455920100212097,
-0.4461651146411896,
-0.1683395951986313,
0.5698480010032654,
-0.8446202278137207,
0.9154666066169739,
-0.10629909485578537,
-0.0639045238494873,
0.3688064217567444,
0.44619810581207275,
0.678934633731842,
0.16271701455116272,
-0.3720715641975403,
0.14081351459026337,
0.3537573218345642,
-0.6480856537818909,
-0.4589647054672241,
0.5473212003707886,
-0.8498277068138123,
-0.703926146030426,
-0.5007287859916687,
-0.6909096240997314,
-0.2600095272064209,
0.20966437458992004,
-0.0945785865187645,
0.22509033977985382,
-0.21822626888751984,
0.18312178552150726,
0.7427914142608643,
0.08668803423643112,
0.2987246811389923,
0.38371145725250244,
-0.1271762102842331,
-0.34901008009910583,
0.835215151309967,
0.22720500826835632,
0.576507568359375,
0.0014181914739310741,
0.176011860370636,
-0.22514329850673676,
-0.3546571135520935,
-0.15442469716072083,
0.15705381333827972,
-0.8285703659057617,
0.404170960187912,
-0.894811749458313,
-0.03496735543012619,
-0.5116211175918579,
-0.4599666893482208,
-0.12868253886699677,
-0.832295835018158,
-0.10473257303237915,
0.09505356103181839,
0.6154165863990784,
0.6002638936042786,
0.10621510446071625,
-0.0918271467089653,
-0.865274965763092,
0.3963606655597687,
0.23920315504074097,
0.056214697659015656,
-0.1998181939125061,
-0.803497314453125,
0.10937125235795975,
0.5293211936950684,
-0.05258341506123543,
-0.5350824594497681,
0.25002723932266235,
0.3091791868209839,
0.5539653301239014,
0.3104090094566345,
0.36489835381507874,
0.5639433264732361,
-0.3963182866573334,
0.648228108882904,
0.4573916792869568,
-1.098839521408081,
0.2678031623363495,
-0.41932713985443115,
-0.1528235226869583,
0.6079989671707153,
0.467978835105896,
-0.7323087453842163,
-0.46047332882881165,
-0.910835325717926,
0.04516444355249405,
0.28937312960624695,
0.032821666449308395,
0.18775400519371033,
0.009603409096598625,
0.25697779655456543,
0.34308069944381714,
0.124107725918293,
-0.42598578333854675,
0.0983477532863617,
-0.275684118270874,
-0.5017896294593811,
0.19434234499931335,
-0.14749236404895782,
-0.10741282254457474,
-0.3034400939941406,
0.647244930267334,
-0.39234817028045654,
0.0423310324549675,
0.26796576380729675,
-0.22475501894950867,
-0.1927284300327301,
0.28547152876853943,
0.5971607565879822,
0.5689723491668701,
0.13550008833408356,
0.048591628670692444,
0.15888568758964539,
-0.37190937995910645,
0.21042504906654358,
-0.5153805017471313,
-0.5564639568328857,
-0.263711154460907,
0.4642443060874939,
0.8525263071060181,
-0.03220018371939659,
-0.4054790437221527,
0.455539733171463,
-0.11345875263214111,
-0.4623318612575531,
-0.2599610686302185,
0.2730136513710022,
-0.19635722041130066,
0.220783993601799,
0.014872550033032894,
0.9493830800056458,
-0.08777236938476562,
-0.9713186025619507,
0.3049689829349518,
0.5263516902923584,
-0.6974207162857056,
-0.6849145293235779,
0.5988205671310425,
-0.13415341079235077,
-0.2671239674091339,
0.40339165925979614,
0.07813730835914612,
-0.5735822319984436,
0.48224878311157227,
0.4897748529911041,
0.8417931199073792,
0.23529841005802155,
0.023014169186353683,
0.30614960193634033,
0.36889660358428955,
-0.06401506066322327,
0.40668758749961853,
-0.16315893828868866,
-0.8969964385032654,
-0.4132479131221771,
-0.33671239018440247,
-0.7753444314002991,
-0.5542625188827515,
-0.2997470796108246,
0.18070653080940247,
-0.7015083432197571,
-0.22024525701999664,
-0.09052158892154694,
0.15458142757415771,
-0.22553187608718872,
0.30787259340286255,
0.09817348420619965,
0.8490376472473145,
-0.6878051161766052,
1.2741237878799438,
0.28758466243743896,
-0.5998271107673645,
-0.7664016485214233,
-0.04375438764691353,
0.0741146057844162,
-0.6718246340751648,
0.7402634024620056,
-0.17676502466201782,
-0.1390511691570282,
-0.16818641126155853,
-0.6859475374221802,
-0.7964824438095093,
0.7602503895759583,
0.5685290098190308,
-0.44240081310272217,
0.2632405459880829,
0.16113941371440887,
0.3506135940551758,
-0.6413840055465698,
-0.24160955846309662,
0.26080355048179626,
0.5972124338150024,
0.05173955857753754,
-0.7941818237304688,
-0.11515176296234131,
-0.08842474222183228,
-0.3002835512161255,
-0.17185193300247192,
-0.5972382426261902,
0.8917787671089172,
-0.4633803963661194,
-0.21503010392189026,
0.11779742687940598,
0.8980023264884949,
0.5814957618713379,
0.46826013922691345,
0.5469821691513062,
0.3994026184082031,
1.2092947959899902,
-0.2075197994709015,
1.1430968046188354,
-0.4303993284702301,
0.15159770846366882,
0.8489813208580017,
-0.4644053280353546,
0.9978086352348328,
0.54481440782547,
-0.17416484653949738,
0.5684431791305542,
0.6420648097991943,
0.43538039922714233,
0.21689581871032715,
-0.09749078005552292,
0.0740666314959526,
-0.4935389757156372,
-0.2486792355775833,
-0.2432287484407425,
-0.049304403364658356,
0.40269309282302856,
-0.3064782917499542,
0.2987363338470459,
-0.11065725237131119,
0.2349521666765213,
0.1453140825033188,
-0.38807395100593567,
0.7325249910354614,
0.48572540283203125,
-0.8725875616073608,
0.9660962820053101,
0.06971266120672226,
0.22993803024291992,
-0.31843623518943787,
0.013623740524053574,
0.09344412386417389,
0.4102983772754669,
-0.2401445358991623,
-0.6954141855239868,
0.5999611616134644,
-0.08794248849153519,
-0.4937189221382141,
-0.12645532190799713,
0.8312170505523682,
-0.3244243562221527,
-0.3387596011161804,
0.03478366136550903,
0.27061331272125244,
0.03870130330324173,
0.26298773288726807,
-0.8852506279945374,
0.08437146991491318,
-0.11678167432546616,
-0.2759431302547455,
0.38291770219802856,
0.6791642904281616,
-0.36710792779922485,
0.8965884447097778,
0.7857921123504639,
-0.025903908535838127,
0.3614640235900879,
-0.09173919260501862,
0.6384594440460205,
-0.514901340007782,
-0.2134217768907547,
-0.7946711778640747,
0.35561051964759827,
0.07163045555353165,
0.03500490263104439,
0.7971714735031128,
0.26320135593414307,
0.702647864818573,
0.14426583051681519,
1.0978749990463257,
0.040786415338516235,
0.15537448227405548,
-0.40287894010543823,
0.7010554075241089,
-0.5223792791366577,
0.021794380620121956,
-0.07404530793428421,
-0.6831094622612,
-0.3470888137817383,
0.7251640558242798,
-0.5284668207168579,
-0.09290221333503723,
0.6802887320518494,
0.7910118699073792,
0.03591686859726906,
0.36028507351875305,
0.5871012806892395,
0.2649580240249634,
0.0982268750667572,
0.3361283838748932,
0.8403748869895935,
-0.5723174214363098,
-0.08168788254261017,
-0.04240075498819351,
-0.0893125832080841,
-0.3518657386302948,
-0.73326176404953,
-0.9470121264457703,
-0.6485425233840942,
-0.42995020747184753,
-0.44734105467796326,
-0.12678243219852448,
1.163966417312622,
0.7490463852882385,
-1.16093111038208,
-0.2608489394187927,
-0.5884218811988831,
0.3167964816093445,
-0.11451054364442825,
-0.13751035928726196,
-0.0957140177488327,
-0.6288633942604065,
-0.4508706033229828,
0.3289456069469452,
0.39416083693504333,
0.4099007546901703,
-0.06076186150312424,
-0.7074229717254639,
-0.25015318393707275,
0.7520549297332764,
0.5311166644096375,
0.4981326460838318,
-0.8183445930480957,
-0.643336832523346,
0.28026092052459717,
-0.4827159643173218,
0.04047972336411476,
0.7477144002914429,
-0.6241511702537537,
0.1608695536851883,
0.961206316947937,
0.3348939120769501,
-0.08130939304828644,
-0.19789831340312958,
0.62631756067276,
-0.012338841333985329,
0.37148910760879517,
0.3326011002063751,
0.8077613711357117,
0.17917633056640625,
0.05544868856668472,
0.17492952942848206,
0.6089693903923035,
-0.5474604368209839,
-1.0124406814575195,
0.6104927659034729,
-0.9716014266014099,
-0.028814133256673813,
0.7926784157752991,
-0.20927806198596954,
-0.5522838830947876,
-0.5128553509712219,
-0.2310602217912674,
0.21108780801296234,
-0.23302632570266724,
0.3332493305206299,
0.6272162795066833,
-0.10441410541534424,
-0.22657997906208038,
-0.5959678888320923,
0.5263894200325012,
0.4445130527019501,
-0.14867983758449554,
0.332669198513031,
0.4754098653793335,
0.22919023036956787,
-0.15044665336608887,
0.5091354250907898,
-0.07730478793382645,
0.1605401635169983,
0.10138671100139618,
-0.2712879180908203,
0.18191388249397278,
-0.2883440852165222,
-0.2559473216533661,
0.14150600135326385,
0.6245961785316467,
0.4458528757095337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03441v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03441v1
|
Cycles of Thought: Measuring LLM Confidence through Stable Explanations
| 2024-06-05T16:35:30 | 2024-06-05T16:35:30 |
Evan Becker, Stefano Soatto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In many high-risk machine learning applications it is essential for a model
to indicate when it is uncertain about a prediction. While large language
models (LLMs) can reach and even surpass human-level accuracy on a variety of
benchmarks, their overconfidence in incorrect responses is still a
well-documented failure mode. Traditional methods for ML uncertainty
quantification can be difficult to directly adapt to LLMs due to the
computational cost of implementation and closed-source nature of many models. A
variety of black-box methods have recently been proposed, but these often rely
on heuristics such as self-verbalized confidence. We instead propose a
framework for measuring an LLM's uncertainty with respect to the distribution
of generated explanations for an answer. While utilizing explanations is not a
new idea in and of itself, by interpreting each possible model+explanation pair
as a test-time classifier we can calculate a posterior answer distribution over
the most likely of these classifiers. We demonstrate how a specific instance of
this framework using explanation entailment as our classifier likelihood
improves confidence score metrics (in particular AURC and AUROC) over baselines
across five different datasets. We believe these results indicate that our
framework is both a well-principled and effective way of quantifying
uncertainty in LLMs.
|
[
-0.2813315987586975,
-1.1112104654312134,
0.9350813031196594,
0.18137337267398834,
-0.0801711305975914,
0.05056056007742882,
-0.1376851499080658,
-0.1558564156293869,
-0.22049695253372192,
0.07913640886545181,
-0.6254670023918152,
-0.5903565883636475,
-0.7126815915107727,
-0.020550865679979324,
-0.4481167197227478,
0.6958411335945129,
-0.40245816111564636,
-0.11799946427345276,
-0.37676143646240234,
0.11642266809940338,
-0.1736668348312378,
-0.3735528290271759,
-0.5692370533943176,
-0.43619728088378906,
0.7191452383995056,
0.23653344810009003,
0.8346139788627625,
0.635589063167572,
0.4135498106479645,
0.2584385573863983,
-0.010378187522292137,
0.17367282509803772,
-0.34889763593673706,
0.3824818432331085,
-0.07945787906646729,
-0.6620022654533386,
-0.35245558619499207,
0.14264582097530365,
0.543894350528717,
0.8655532002449036,
-0.3512231409549713,
0.13909707963466644,
0.1475370228290558,
0.5274481773376465,
-1.0527653694152832,
0.09007258713245392,
-0.6288143992424011,
0.08545515686273575,
0.12646518647670746,
-0.5386922955513,
-0.5596010088920593,
-0.29300299286842346,
0.2200227975845337,
-0.6430540084838867,
0.06677117943763733,
0.16995567083358765,
0.662955105304718,
0.5985751748085022,
-0.209124356508255,
-0.31594178080558777,
-0.8944528102874756,
0.8221162557601929,
-0.6737891435623169,
0.21388505399227142,
0.3990882337093353,
0.40104183554649353,
-0.3941742777824402,
-0.47325897216796875,
-0.5917410850524902,
0.013454031199216843,
0.1131940558552742,
0.28570929169654846,
-0.09461288154125214,
0.11680291593074799,
-0.014822352677583694,
0.3653758764266968,
-0.3862171173095703,
0.0019493356812745333,
0.008506052196025848,
-0.284315824508667,
0.6019808650016785,
0.10790056735277176,
-0.3145388960838318,
0.22819481790065765,
-0.4222739338874817,
0.005496430676430464,
-0.7199314832687378,
0.0802285373210907,
0.43875446915626526,
-0.0824451893568039,
0.035130951553583145,
0.6678234934806824,
0.0954209491610527,
0.7181448340415955,
0.14987052977085114,
-0.2304951548576355,
-0.0480225645005703,
-0.10495974123477936,
-0.5563960671424866,
0.17653147876262665,
0.685049295425415,
0.2745419144630432,
0.2604886591434479,
-0.1544046252965927,
-0.20362764596939087,
0.2119581252336502,
0.30049604177474976,
-0.7999398708343506,
0.08084198832511902,
0.5792032480239868,
-0.246597558259964,
-0.5720341205596924,
-0.022482184693217278,
-0.6260879039764404,
-0.5533902645111084,
-0.0010834670392796397,
0.36072707176208496,
-0.2533673644065857,
-0.16791687905788422,
0.4064633548259735,
0.09580421447753906,
0.0335238017141819,
0.3704712986946106,
-0.579710841178894,
0.09741544723510742,
0.6557117700576782,
0.5847845673561096,
-0.40290123224258423,
-0.14111892879009247,
-0.3125012218952179,
0.14170032739639282,
-0.8076877593994141,
0.48210859298706055,
-0.3495789170265198,
-0.3271046280860901,
0.13926750421524048,
0.024892911314964294,
-0.09635650366544724,
-0.16236791014671326,
0.39280062913894653,
-0.3618420660495758,
0.24940165877342224,
0.11598356813192368,
-0.8982783555984497,
-0.2542214095592499,
0.6070912480354309,
-0.0866939052939415,
1.0957849025726318,
0.030396083369851112,
-0.9483093619346619,
0.3188413977622986,
-0.22824852168560028,
-0.1717856526374817,
-0.18279847502708435,
-0.12013228237628937,
-0.6467130184173584,
0.05300245061516762,
0.1872119903564453,
0.6213703751564026,
-0.2429688423871994,
0.3488366901874542,
-0.7992947101593018,
-0.3878208100795746,
1.0698829889297485,
-0.8276827931404114,
0.679329514503479,
0.18392547965049744,
-0.33655187487602234,
0.09226900339126587,
-0.7089192271232605,
0.16326160728931427,
-0.068579763174057,
-0.13295914232730865,
-0.110835000872612,
0.1374986320734024,
-0.5361706018447876,
0.00045510937343351543,
0.2172824740409851,
-0.3374554216861725,
-0.18066172301769257,
-0.43396228551864624,
0.5947598814964294,
0.9235847592353821,
0.33563047647476196,
0.3122582733631134,
-0.3043195605278015,
0.6136765480041504,
0.202198788523674,
0.20789238810539246,
-0.20514830946922302,
-0.5351025462150574,
-0.8168291449546814,
-0.022507457062602043,
0.1601804792881012,
0.6129389405250549,
-0.2484995573759079,
0.464966744184494,
-0.015107832849025726,
-0.42094799876213074,
-0.6326650977134705,
0.1410709172487259,
0.28913846611976624,
0.6337370276451111,
0.17791001498699188,
-0.05474875867366791,
-0.31560179591178894,
-0.6943783760070801,
-0.05312403291463852,
-0.5659629702568054,
-0.005282565951347351,
0.11933767795562744,
0.4877171218395233,
-0.342151403427124,
0.8904212713241577,
-0.33570611476898193,
0.41137903928756714,
0.18382593989372253,
0.28646203875541687,
0.09891538321971893,
0.31005609035491943,
0.1771090030670166,
-0.6379690766334534,
0.011807137168943882,
-0.15909112989902496,
-0.9203809499740601,
0.25504493713378906,
-0.16449053585529327,
-0.2915055453777313,
0.35683301091194153,
0.5444682836532593,
-0.5664148330688477,
0.5457685589790344,
0.5455601215362549,
-0.16830876469612122,
0.5472708940505981,
-0.2498948723077774,
0.03502386808395386,
-1.0263789892196655,
-0.2684321701526642,
0.08743136376142502,
-0.2746030390262604,
-0.2044411152601242,
0.017164940014481544,
-0.12776148319244385,
0.28287240862846375,
-0.19191275537014008,
0.36917951703071594,
-0.30465221405029297,
-0.07073688507080078,
-0.10921773314476013,
0.4079318046569824,
0.06900546699762344,
0.2024616152048111,
-0.17871496081352234,
0.5954500436782837,
0.7040443420410156,
-0.5181506276130676,
0.3587823212146759,
-0.0843176618218422,
-0.22888518869876862,
0.6268485188484192,
-0.7560787200927734,
0.1352829933166504,
-0.1766127496957779,
0.24459736049175262,
-1.3998993635177612,
-0.39157819747924805,
0.3514539301395416,
-0.6850773692131042,
0.3560102880001068,
-0.2911994755268097,
-0.22185118496418,
-0.53404301404953,
-0.141340970993042,
0.1655910164117813,
0.49295276403427124,
-0.2763789892196655,
0.3946775197982788,
0.17967143654823303,
-0.09944421052932739,
-0.8990827798843384,
-0.8347504734992981,
-0.09300827234983444,
-0.39390164613723755,
-0.6912652850151062,
0.1693870723247528,
-0.3516038954257965,
-0.603536069393158,
0.021097175776958466,
-0.3912910521030426,
-0.12164714932441711,
0.5724269151687622,
0.5513031482696533,
0.3463185727596283,
-0.32973596453666687,
0.5044143199920654,
-0.05186295509338379,
-0.2401694506406784,
0.3906238079071045,
-0.5325366258621216,
0.17777495086193085,
-0.30828210711479187,
-0.6799701452255249,
-0.32140809297561646,
-0.04111042618751526,
0.5941966772079468,
-0.059121374040842056,
0.9095818400382996,
0.4478168189525604,
-0.4890187680721283,
-0.31340768933296204,
-0.38903290033340454,
-0.18861031532287598,
-0.43481457233428955,
-0.012915310449898243,
-0.38485226035118103,
-0.7609886527061462,
0.5795943140983582,
-0.03211477771401405,
0.0038411973509937525,
0.3853909969329834,
0.795836329460144,
-0.5111898183822632,
1.0263006687164307,
0.482997328042984,
0.03159033879637718,
0.043121058493852615,
-0.004685663152486086,
0.24166642129421234,
-0.3044585585594177,
-0.015395556576550007,
-0.38183486461639404,
-0.10085237771272659,
-0.6276494860649109,
-0.5949718952178955,
0.15392205119132996,
0.35123252868652344,
-0.4433991014957428,
-0.28193575143814087,
-0.4379989802837372,
0.2299668937921524,
0.3948850631713867,
0.09741192311048508,
0.2272622436285019,
-0.185227632522583,
-0.042151451110839844,
0.18679805099964142,
-0.5967689752578735,
-0.7697231769561768,
1.1019015312194824,
0.7026060819625854,
0.953498125076294,
-0.11305166780948639,
0.7585299611091614,
0.05809511989355087,
0.4893215000629425,
-0.853135883808136,
0.19616056978702545,
0.3953535258769989,
-0.6893966794013977,
-0.7178356647491455,
-0.4552798569202423,
-0.842914879322052,
0.08021160960197449,
-0.26671022176742554,
-0.5554022789001465,
0.09049522131681442,
0.4638882875442505,
-0.5324071049690247,
0.07334285974502563,
-0.42843466997146606,
0.7949522733688354,
-0.2138657122850418,
-0.4203976094722748,
-0.026915280148386955,
-0.6287175416946411,
0.3398840129375458,
-0.1774703860282898,
0.28724098205566406,
-0.249525249004364,
-0.1340189129114151,
0.36914435029029846,
-0.38666102290153503,
0.9235861301422119,
-0.003379217814654112,
-0.2571764588356018,
0.5622291564941406,
0.19448135793209076,
0.6207989454269409,
0.32520782947540283,
-0.3519120216369629,
-0.03640730306506157,
-0.0502847395837307,
-0.47171881794929504,
-0.8976051211357117,
0.4817662835121155,
-0.6229297518730164,
-0.5558545589447021,
-0.2869025766849518,
-0.6672776937484741,
-0.3556475043296814,
-0.11513519287109375,
0.41390061378479004,
0.12484235316514969,
-0.003159797051921487,
0.2357252985239029,
0.9743417501449585,
-0.20716281235218048,
0.21490749716758728,
0.3649190366268158,
-0.13246096670627594,
-0.2404264360666275,
0.342402845621109,
-0.01396202202886343,
0.4822143018245697,
0.21273788809776306,
0.4203592538833618,
-0.32734599709510803,
-0.7941348552703857,
-0.4313991069793701,
-0.16499818861484528,
-0.7917274236679077,
-0.08834653347730637,
-0.301001638174057,
-0.23789967596530914,
-0.18547436594963074,
-0.3320029377937317,
-0.23207546770572662,
-0.4025661051273346,
-0.13177528977394104,
-0.6927948594093323,
0.42880377173423767,
0.6145187020301819,
0.17436888813972473,
0.3817681074142456,
-0.3347362279891968,
0.10092907398939133,
0.25988325476646423,
0.2521580159664154,
-0.16053147614002228,
-0.6107115149497986,
-0.02885090373456478,
0.35817617177963257,
-0.2097511738538742,
-1.058565378189087,
0.23263852298259735,
0.0977979376912117,
0.646296501159668,
0.5728569626808167,
0.2099173665046692,
0.6652930974960327,
-0.24534377455711365,
0.6282501220703125,
0.08260903507471085,
-0.8820381760597229,
0.6489609479904175,
-0.20563994348049164,
-0.1921958178281784,
0.4099142849445343,
0.47226881980895996,
-0.38289058208465576,
-0.8196173310279846,
-0.733485758304596,
-0.6811598539352417,
0.13145823776721954,
0.2306242287158966,
-0.11437197029590607,
-0.1305357962846756,
0.8173346519470215,
0.038271598517894745,
0.2778702676296234,
-0.6225899457931519,
-0.47447171807289124,
-0.11587779968976974,
-0.5556310415267944,
-0.34375622868537903,
-0.38936129212379456,
-0.4778561294078827,
0.058359064161777496,
0.8033831715583801,
-0.3853534162044525,
0.225502148270607,
0.3766155242919922,
-0.052707839757204056,
-0.4614643156528473,
0.38923564553260803,
0.5353485345840454,
0.9292599558830261,
-0.2668043076992035,
0.571044385433197,
0.2421225756406784,
-0.05547238886356354,
0.23887553811073303,
0.10691087692975998,
-0.3505710959434509,
-0.06693653017282486,
0.5895984768867493,
0.54883873462677,
0.23219193518161774,
-0.4613671898841858,
0.533315122127533,
0.12533266842365265,
-0.25879785418510437,
-0.49737051129341125,
0.02926655299961567,
0.38332489132881165,
0.19075120985507965,
0.2639089524745941,
0.10115965455770493,
0.041447609663009644,
-0.5666971206665039,
0.3140755891799927,
0.3333308696746826,
-0.6907017230987549,
-0.06262893229722977,
0.5445386171340942,
-0.11779852956533432,
-0.20913487672805786,
0.3239450752735138,
-0.20829777419567108,
-0.4317820966243744,
0.5355899333953857,
0.5402119159698486,
0.8008495569229126,
-0.22166045010089874,
0.32007643580436707,
0.2608056962490082,
0.37202516198158264,
-0.31638291478157043,
0.3426551818847656,
0.2206040769815445,
-0.9876155853271484,
-0.5946540832519531,
-0.6266624927520752,
-0.5616376996040344,
-0.216570645570755,
-0.7831403017044067,
-0.19406229257583618,
-0.36589714884757996,
-0.30497443675994873,
-0.007050259970128536,
-0.19318382441997528,
-0.41758283972740173,
0.2352454513311386,
0.22711855173110962,
0.9209733009338379,
-0.7044656276702881,
0.6167209148406982,
0.42091453075408936,
-0.2952226400375366,
-0.7826341390609741,
0.04004630818963051,
0.09744853526353836,
-1.0498924255371094,
0.3311581611633301,
0.195572629570961,
-0.37766435742378235,
-0.21131490170955658,
-0.7592816352844238,
-0.7308119535446167,
1.075814962387085,
0.46508410573005676,
-0.7155218720436096,
0.21281076967716217,
0.02769049070775509,
0.6023743748664856,
-0.43036580085754395,
-0.01671752892434597,
0.4873057007789612,
0.624467134475708,
0.22973719239234924,
-0.4208754301071167,
-0.004694125149399042,
0.11767996102571487,
-0.16867995262145996,
0.10867473483085632,
-0.15379934012889862,
0.668231189250946,
-0.4851313829421997,
-0.2532913386821747,
0.07162174582481384,
0.7477408051490784,
0.4906037747859955,
0.579227089881897,
0.5899888873100281,
0.5027592182159424,
1.2111390829086304,
-0.30231940746307373,
1.077257752418518,
-0.42549118399620056,
0.4254631996154785,
1.1696951389312744,
-0.08513380587100983,
1.0396454334259033,
0.6548096537590027,
-0.30298739671707153,
0.6081927418708801,
1.1214886903762817,
0.26784655451774597,
0.12280487269163132,
0.6268149614334106,
-0.135778546333313,
-0.6264819502830505,
0.21443641185760498,
-0.058701954782009125,
0.032952599227428436,
0.6308563947677612,
-0.4949384033679962,
0.10897116363048553,
-0.12874232232570648,
-0.10667350143194199,
0.0324954055249691,
-0.2730824053287506,
0.44340193271636963,
0.4171573519706726,
-0.8127901554107666,
0.6147599816322327,
-0.1576942354440689,
0.3106507658958435,
-0.3241196572780609,
0.20347164571285248,
-0.050047118216753006,
0.5774416923522949,
-0.09331198781728745,
-1.1602959632873535,
0.26957395672798157,
-0.24028483033180237,
-0.1320188343524933,
-0.26025503873825073,
0.5814065933227539,
-0.5235843062400818,
-0.8362597227096558,
0.21038112044334412,
0.566547691822052,
0.33312174677848816,
-0.07060540467500687,
-0.8286804556846619,
-0.048086978495121,
-0.2626070976257324,
-0.33022525906562805,
-0.10400652140378952,
0.785393238067627,
0.06155892089009285,
1.0773752927780151,
0.339116632938385,
-0.009486725553870201,
0.2764662802219391,
-0.05713288486003876,
0.35064905881881714,
-0.28441011905670166,
-0.22150161862373352,
-1.1109521389007568,
0.48639315366744995,
0.09806223958730698,
-0.31694918870925903,
0.747448742389679,
0.2536642551422119,
0.5676701068878174,
0.3700059950351715,
0.8472238183021545,
0.3408166766166687,
0.44852206110954285,
-0.5610982775688171,
0.3422847092151642,
-0.5212110280990601,
0.36781707406044006,
-0.06167493015527725,
-0.7499722242355347,
-0.254154771566391,
0.9492901563644409,
-0.21449577808380127,
-0.10301949083805084,
0.6126144528388977,
0.7350199818611145,
0.25779077410697937,
0.037822235375642776,
0.21521703898906708,
0.4625492990016937,
0.09439516067504883,
0.35948413610458374,
0.9711408615112305,
-0.2799151837825775,
0.6386484503746033,
-0.30154526233673096,
-0.22611898183822632,
-0.21085228025913239,
-1.0837862491607666,
-0.8069002628326416,
-0.43355804681777954,
-0.523925244808197,
-0.7051740884780884,
0.2985476851463318,
0.587727963924408,
0.8588923215866089,
-0.757507860660553,
-0.031036008149385452,
-0.3095925450325012,
0.3839397430419922,
-0.3777104914188385,
-0.16198047995567322,
0.21674758195877075,
-0.49888718128204346,
-0.34080085158348083,
0.27641135454177856,
0.3882709741592407,
0.3622046113014221,
-0.6924417614936829,
-0.33040177822113037,
0.3157254755496979,
0.3158751130104065,
0.402521014213562,
-0.1802365928888321,
-0.9059777855873108,
-0.5711106061935425,
0.13097772002220154,
-0.18095508217811584,
-0.03692363202571869,
0.5649411082267761,
-0.4144537150859833,
0.5153940916061401,
0.2434699982404709,
0.6191509366035461,
0.6006641983985901,
0.09030864387750626,
0.9870530962944031,
-0.7410531640052795,
-0.04072903096675873,
0.19298458099365234,
0.5367180705070496,
0.3663633167743683,
-0.4372340738773346,
0.6388053894042969,
0.048865724354982376,
-0.5487538576126099,
-0.896220326423645,
0.28371286392211914,
-0.9366289377212524,
-0.32118064165115356,
1.0832340717315674,
-0.5712794065475464,
-0.30154016613960266,
-0.1743566244840622,
0.1894243359565735,
0.2183200865983963,
-0.16185683012008667,
0.8498352766036987,
1.1068978309631348,
-0.05366562306880951,
-0.22821664810180664,
-0.5864670872688293,
0.40432196855545044,
0.18202322721481323,
-0.7668505311012268,
0.2949029207229614,
0.27855709195137024,
0.27540233731269836,
0.32571765780448914,
0.3398294448852539,
-0.013787860050797462,
0.17960993945598602,
0.042656440287828445,
-0.06379421800374985,
0.16339828073978424,
-0.23524266481399536,
-0.18984878063201904,
0.2059791535139084,
0.25778719782829285,
-0.2427079975605011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06591v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06591v2
|
Exploring Multilingual Large Language Models for Enhanced TNM classification of Radiology Report in lung cancer staging
| 2024-06-05T16:11:55 | 2024-06-12T15:19:46 |
Hidetoshi Matsuo, Mizuho Nishio, Takaaki Matsunaga, Koji Fujimoto, Takamichi Murakami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Background: Structured radiology reports remains underdeveloped due to
labor-intensive structuring and narrative-style reporting. Deep learning,
particularly large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3.5, offers promise in
automating the structuring of radiology reports in natural languages. However,
although it has been reported that LLMs are less effective in languages other
than English, their radiological performance has not been extensively studied.
Purpose: This study aimed to investigate the accuracy of TNM classification
based on radiology reports using GPT3.5-turbo (GPT3.5) and the utility of
multilingual LLMs in both Japanese and English. Material and Methods: Utilizing
GPT3.5, we developed a system to automatically generate TNM classifications
from chest CT reports for lung cancer and evaluate its performance. We
statistically analyzed the impact of providing full or partial TNM definitions
in both languages using a Generalized Linear Mixed Model. Results: Highest
accuracy was attained with full TNM definitions and radiology reports in
English (M = 94%, N = 80%, T = 47%, and ALL = 36%). Providing definitions for
each of the T, N, and M factors statistically improved their respective
accuracies (T: odds ratio (OR) = 2.35, p < 0.001; N: OR = 1.94, p < 0.01; M: OR
= 2.50, p < 0.001). Japanese reports exhibited decreased N and M accuracies (N
accuracy: OR = 0.74 and M accuracy: OR = 0.21). Conclusion: This study
underscores the potential of multilingual LLMs for automatic TNM classification
in radiology reports. Even without additional model training, performance
improvements were evident with the provided TNM definitions, indicating LLMs'
relevance in radiology contexts.
|
[
-0.09113449603319168,
-0.31993257999420166,
0.8899757862091064,
0.12436579167842865,
-0.5304009914398193,
0.03697902336716652,
-0.34001949429512024,
-0.5074542760848999,
-0.011410193517804146,
0.6148117184638977,
-0.13050992786884308,
-0.9363877177238464,
-1.0069197416305542,
0.2940092384815216,
-0.11956921219825745,
0.8216775059700012,
-0.05596393346786499,
0.5887534022331238,
0.21173371374607086,
-0.10476861149072647,
-0.497968465089798,
-0.5743227601051331,
-0.8436083793640137,
-0.293954074382782,
0.7673113346099854,
0.23960858583450317,
0.7677986025810242,
0.44267359375953674,
0.6563714742660522,
0.2884024977684021,
-0.11785523593425751,
0.20439229905605316,
0.023660996928811073,
0.047486189752817154,
0.14369076490402222,
-0.39081573486328125,
-0.26159414649009705,
-0.034432508051395416,
0.6088720560073853,
0.5666512846946716,
-0.20145246386528015,
-0.2981035113334656,
-0.04559344798326492,
0.756035327911377,
-0.4276838004589081,
0.2854764461517334,
-0.3326362371444702,
0.24239587783813477,
-0.04462543502449989,
-0.5123528242111206,
-0.47378814220428467,
-0.5468167066574097,
0.012539602816104889,
-0.591188371181488,
0.14722807705402374,
-0.3421115279197693,
0.7755424976348877,
-0.04875015467405319,
-0.804269015789032,
-0.5851404070854187,
-0.7209073901176453,
0.3773079514503479,
-0.788091242313385,
0.5429848432540894,
0.2884235382080078,
0.5877262949943542,
-0.009575099684298038,
-1.0865659713745117,
-0.22125361859798431,
-0.27023303508758545,
-0.3463844954967499,
0.38401511311531067,
-0.08098315447568893,
0.3240639567375183,
0.3096025884151459,
0.4112458825111389,
-0.8845915794372559,
0.4698968529701233,
-0.45739805698394775,
-0.3913534879684448,
0.4810715913772583,
0.3607713580131531,
0.31944188475608826,
-0.2537567913532257,
-0.2180950939655304,
-0.01911095902323723,
-0.6090788245201111,
-0.31080731749534607,
-0.1440756916999817,
0.5504157543182373,
-0.11566992104053497,
0.5273891687393188,
-0.3004518747329712,
0.7377537488937378,
-0.18743926286697388,
-0.35621753334999084,
0.4131219685077667,
-0.34294381737709045,
-0.4421773850917816,
0.2956444323062897,
1.0416662693023682,
0.22377200424671173,
0.04407602921128273,
0.09393945336341858,
0.2106648087501526,
-0.06332957744598389,
0.013228711672127247,
-0.8542031049728394,
0.11979999393224716,
-0.08931055665016174,
-0.7023811936378479,
-0.3635477125644684,
0.032313499599695206,
-0.37165892124176025,
-0.5296998023986816,
-0.19736890494823456,
0.30847808718681335,
-0.25604620575904846,
-0.15768784284591675,
0.4628353714942932,
0.35896992683410645,
-0.10968951880931854,
0.4877510964870453,
-0.22074681520462036,
0.2051549255847931,
0.4972854554653168,
0.9474440217018127,
0.21520251035690308,
-0.0726039782166481,
-0.6974793672561646,
0.253338485956192,
-0.4010128974914551,
0.6629809737205505,
-0.47042274475097656,
-0.5558607578277588,
0.05532804876565933,
0.3713887929916382,
-0.5051278471946716,
-0.38787853717803955,
0.6419277191162109,
-0.44697511196136475,
0.9075732231140137,
0.18350468575954437,
-0.5260388851165771,
-0.5170539617538452,
0.33192580938339233,
-0.6968247294425964,
0.708909809589386,
0.09440728276968002,
-0.45054471492767334,
0.4291107952594757,
-0.32518187165260315,
-0.546425461769104,
0.23796719312667847,
-0.36573174595832825,
-0.281464546918869,
0.0010788289364427328,
0.337047815322876,
0.9610478281974792,
-0.34869465231895447,
0.5141469836235046,
0.12590351700782776,
-0.3720184564590454,
-0.00009198072802973911,
-0.5109423398971558,
0.7298935055732727,
0.2587122619152069,
-0.33764201402664185,
-0.025715313851833344,
-0.5588406920433044,
0.09522322565317154,
-0.049029964953660965,
-0.2860250174999237,
-0.09818325191736221,
-0.27194634079933167,
-0.27018338441848755,
0.6406525373458862,
-0.1876247525215149,
-0.560664713382721,
0.1913526952266693,
-0.44263145327568054,
-0.03752424567937851,
0.18915487825870514,
0.18009863793849945,
-0.21541303396224976,
-0.3309239149093628,
0.67452073097229,
0.050935521721839905,
0.011225184425711632,
0.0641193687915802,
-0.7081152200698853,
-0.3682786226272583,
-0.3103664517402649,
0.28436970710754395,
0.5087636709213257,
-0.6897358894348145,
0.07119540125131607,
-0.5592060089111328,
-0.5027502775192261,
-0.221055269241333,
-0.1317412555217743,
0.4390334486961365,
0.7892816066741943,
0.2151683121919632,
-0.24224449694156647,
-0.5947221517562866,
-0.9558115601539612,
0.14817167818546295,
-0.11101602762937546,
-0.14768360555171967,
0.49726420640945435,
0.018977686762809753,
-0.21093511581420898,
-0.026231179013848305,
-0.698394238948822,
-0.801141083240509,
-0.42056822776794434,
0.02489045448601246,
0.44925373792648315,
-0.025003958493471146,
0.3067381978034973,
-0.6744654178619385,
-0.8625524640083313,
0.5166284441947937,
-0.7972690463066101,
-0.011711739003658295,
-0.06156092882156372,
0.138048455119133,
0.4828028976917267,
0.7335079908370972,
-0.3182102143764496,
0.6186801791191101,
0.6288332939147949,
-0.07169365137815475,
0.24787288904190063,
-0.4842737317085266,
0.48746824264526367,
-1.184576153755188,
0.0763479545712471,
0.16411079466342926,
-0.4000649154186249,
-0.6245680451393127,
-0.16885119676589966,
0.0843718945980072,
-0.0785319060087204,
-0.7177393436431885,
0.47422417998313904,
-0.4905790686607361,
0.1980353742837906,
-0.38352707028388977,
-0.1254359781742096,
0.24247367680072784,
0.2201051265001297,
0.5766476392745972,
0.5168020725250244,
0.3410519063472748,
-0.6816367506980896,
-0.009186876937747002,
-0.03722785785794258,
-0.5246661901473999,
0.17279189825057983,
-0.38602206110954285,
-0.07344986498355865,
0.13565094769001007,
0.5040927529335022,
-0.7345828413963318,
-0.2700890004634857,
0.035927340388298035,
-0.3841944932937622,
0.7574861645698547,
-0.36269769072532654,
-0.5411432981491089,
-0.5356558561325073,
0.2068345546722412,
0.17689642310142517,
0.26210924983024597,
-0.20795173943042755,
0.5857402682304382,
0.08695569634437561,
-0.3441144526004791,
-0.3251199722290039,
-0.9001500606536865,
0.10243742167949677,
-0.2101830095052719,
-0.4554804265499115,
0.22228482365608215,
0.19104154407978058,
0.07074963301420212,
-0.17483358085155487,
0.18691523373126984,
-0.13712625205516815,
0.0020889583975076675,
0.11735647916793823,
0.19451230764389038,
-0.3266295790672302,
0.14096756279468536,
-0.2949153482913971,
-0.12867024540901184,
-0.15495851635932922,
-0.1185346245765686,
0.6634916067123413,
-0.35427841544151306,
-0.34236904978752136,
-0.6537973284721375,
0.16081401705741882,
0.7036258578300476,
0.18272683024406433,
0.7489420175552368,
0.9524589776992798,
-0.5309234261512756,
0.38633057475090027,
-0.7255182862281799,
0.07869140803813934,
-0.35776734352111816,
0.5028806328773499,
-0.45990124344825745,
-1.1297632455825806,
0.6466411352157593,
0.12660345435142517,
-0.2514462172985077,
0.9202889800071716,
1.0510183572769165,
-0.07060066610574722,
1.1684865951538086,
0.44452545046806335,
0.04541772976517677,
0.0974687710404396,
-0.09979692846536636,
0.05407959595322609,
-0.9191654920578003,
-0.5354267954826355,
-0.7826066017150879,
-0.16725024580955505,
-0.9318258762359619,
-0.5968104004859924,
0.6680406332015991,
-0.4878293573856354,
-0.2912507653236389,
-0.09979947656393051,
-0.7537103295326233,
0.4609866738319397,
0.15911105275154114,
0.3525683283805847,
0.4361859858036041,
0.16648295521736145,
0.010705188848078251,
-0.29366299510002136,
-0.9437932968139648,
-0.3425213098526001,
1.4064488410949707,
0.343171089887619,
0.2587122619152069,
0.27579957246780396,
0.5598189830780029,
-0.019229700788855553,
0.4212588369846344,
-0.7710269093513489,
0.279900461435318,
-0.828900158405304,
-0.6232436299324036,
-0.233578160405159,
-0.5460615158081055,
-1.099302887916565,
0.2717137336730957,
0.11067528277635574,
-0.5539697408676147,
0.09997271746397018,
-0.4859921336174011,
-0.4876638352870941,
0.4749491512775421,
-0.2793622314929962,
0.5761353373527527,
-0.6303713917732239,
-0.09928146004676819,
-0.2269251048564911,
-0.6216182708740234,
0.43153640627861023,
-0.17783482372760773,
0.39042195677757263,
-0.15791791677474976,
-0.20754271745681763,
0.5758377313613892,
-0.2967577576637268,
0.7339330315589905,
-0.13432949781417847,
0.04801477491855621,
-0.06589590758085251,
0.08439845591783524,
0.4205299913883209,
0.17639045417308807,
-0.3736655116081238,
0.27485591173171997,
0.03174874931573868,
-0.17276562750339508,
-0.5338317155838013,
0.8140307664871216,
-0.8101555109024048,
-0.3736670911312103,
-0.6683160066604614,
-0.40703055262565613,
-0.3818902373313904,
0.4503152370452881,
0.5066994428634644,
0.6421515941619873,
-0.0903727263212204,
0.4139673113822937,
0.5929015278816223,
-0.5881596803665161,
-0.010116162709891796,
0.8186513781547546,
-0.21603325009346008,
-0.6455856561660767,
0.8692545294761658,
0.29000425338745117,
0.03408604487776756,
0.6371716260910034,
0.5793761610984802,
-0.33324071764945984,
-0.8949151635169983,
-0.37930238246917725,
0.1281510293483734,
-0.6964063048362732,
-0.19803650677204132,
-0.9455856680870056,
-0.5684670209884644,
-0.2747913599014282,
-0.1630420982837677,
-0.2262907475233078,
-0.4521256685256958,
-0.10153444856405258,
-0.09585997462272644,
0.16489027440547943,
0.7580640316009521,
-0.03679145872592926,
0.16719947755336761,
-0.803034782409668,
-0.05722789838910103,
-0.07882969826459885,
0.50665283203125,
-0.08039145916700363,
-0.8499446511268616,
-0.5843457579612732,
-0.040446050465106964,
-0.11282075941562653,
-0.5915694832801819,
0.8569850325584412,
0.24675266444683075,
0.5468108654022217,
0.069925956428051,
-0.1521700918674469,
0.8157799243927002,
-0.11505059897899628,
0.7602418661117554,
0.28366386890411377,
-0.3105485141277313,
0.5623369216918945,
-0.6334415078163147,
0.535301685333252,
0.571428120136261,
0.5490704774856567,
-0.6689911484718323,
-0.38080787658691406,
-0.7681097388267517,
-0.9499069452285767,
0.892301082611084,
0.016817063093185425,
-0.07808845490217209,
-0.12566493451595306,
0.18142467737197876,
0.24604767560958862,
0.11058079451322556,
-0.6974765062332153,
0.07798739522695541,
-0.08864044398069382,
-0.15666323900222778,
-0.512866735458374,
-0.40118637681007385,
-0.4044192135334015,
-0.26212960481643677,
0.7986348867416382,
-0.2587534189224243,
0.3939698040485382,
0.16797760128974915,
-0.1187576875090599,
0.05049591511487961,
0.3460841774940491,
1.0399378538131714,
0.5295082926750183,
-0.2654660940170288,
0.0896853655576706,
0.2507665455341339,
-0.6332424283027649,
0.11580006778240204,
0.09943665564060211,
0.06557860225439072,
0.16114158928394318,
0.5998552441596985,
0.8046887516975403,
0.27399441599845886,
-0.2886545956134796,
0.47282224893569946,
-0.5388943552970886,
-0.5832237601280212,
-0.24445360898971558,
-0.3314046859741211,
-0.04826419800519943,
0.053270429372787476,
0.2908571660518646,
-0.1297939270734787,
0.23185251653194427,
-0.1196017786860466,
0.054189592599868774,
0.09966709464788437,
-0.6703717708587646,
0.18432846665382385,
0.3709050714969635,
-0.07278909534215927,
0.2933465242385864,
0.8378131985664368,
0.1332055777311325,
-0.3678353428840637,
0.6971989870071411,
0.3606017827987671,
0.9046386480331421,
0.02721887268126011,
0.3606277406215668,
0.6199504733085632,
0.38350710272789,
-0.12013396620750427,
0.09315730631351471,
0.5989912748336792,
-0.5412417054176331,
-0.6371971964836121,
-0.4463633596897125,
-0.3619190454483032,
0.6452435851097107,
-0.6151082515716553,
0.20713220536708832,
-0.6190503835678101,
-0.13398823142051697,
-0.09536639600992203,
0.3234635591506958,
-0.7279313802719116,
0.5911545753479004,
0.5289808511734009,
0.7795861959457397,
-0.6241400837898254,
0.7974652051925659,
0.9343401789665222,
-0.2502622604370117,
-1.3973429203033447,
-0.027555331587791443,
0.35204795002937317,
-0.7294040322303772,
0.6800071001052856,
0.4785700738430023,
0.15157189965248108,
-0.22506536543369293,
0.15561145544052124,
-0.9822162985801697,
1.1937484741210938,
0.156766876578331,
-0.4619409739971161,
0.20067545771598816,
0.3082886040210724,
0.8162719011306763,
-0.4865965247154236,
0.6690859198570251,
0.0753796249628067,
0.42775192856788635,
0.37881550192832947,
-1.2833281755447388,
0.01681612618267536,
-0.1368088275194168,
-0.09416007995605469,
0.09869019687175751,
-0.6904099583625793,
0.3329467177391052,
0.07417815923690796,
-0.1942756474018097,
-0.09811024367809296,
0.35251814126968384,
0.13119517266750336,
0.5439294576644897,
0.09751880168914795,
0.6287183165550232,
0.697368323802948,
-0.20252150297164917,
1.313145637512207,
-0.494295597076416,
0.0867350697517395,
0.7837302684783936,
-0.3281429409980774,
0.5484753847122192,
0.0022037040907889605,
-0.09396186470985413,
0.6394937038421631,
0.7873508334159851,
0.27497807145118713,
0.3100340664386749,
-0.30725452303886414,
-0.12879106402397156,
-0.3909563720226288,
-0.05049723759293556,
-0.6312392950057983,
0.4255969524383545,
0.48398855328559875,
-0.5046966075897217,
-0.0824611634016037,
0.22860097885131836,
0.13361236453056335,
-0.1146094873547554,
-0.3668827414512634,
1.0320452451705933,
0.14331011474132538,
-0.5823454856872559,
0.7964888215065002,
-0.05095545947551727,
0.5515099763870239,
-0.7203302383422852,
0.30130505561828613,
-0.3137989640235901,
0.39745959639549255,
-0.5211594104766846,
-0.9627490639686584,
0.5614127516746521,
-0.05573674663901329,
-0.1359998732805252,
-0.04170004278421402,
0.5645889639854431,
-0.3175409138202667,
-0.9807743430137634,
0.1729043424129486,
0.35018491744995117,
0.23632828891277313,
0.048342861235141754,
-0.5568732023239136,
0.14949584007263184,
0.2502247989177704,
-0.40666964650154114,
0.7581660747528076,
0.3735640048980713,
-0.3036019802093506,
0.7350041270256042,
0.48741617798805237,
0.37487250566482544,
-0.3291994333267212,
0.37619689106941223,
0.6475253701210022,
-0.4702755808830261,
-0.41281023621559143,
-0.5091462135314941,
0.31106477975845337,
0.22815649211406708,
-0.1678069829940796,
0.5640367269515991,
0.8132619261741638,
0.9331792593002319,
0.13300152122974396,
0.8273662328720093,
0.17621475458145142,
0.606347382068634,
-0.752036988735199,
0.5750272274017334,
-0.687768280506134,
0.5260237455368042,
-0.2070568948984146,
-0.5266196131706238,
-0.8366103172302246,
0.3464864194393158,
-0.6392307281494141,
0.23583994805812836,
0.827366054058075,
0.7447102665901184,
-0.05261244252324104,
-0.048295989632606506,
0.503848135471344,
0.3978583812713623,
0.31044262647628784,
0.7042244672775269,
0.32981109619140625,
-0.3427504301071167,
0.6054062843322754,
-0.5878593921661377,
-0.13491582870483398,
-0.273800253868103,
-0.6658947467803955,
-0.5149311423301697,
-0.37492674589157104,
-0.503701388835907,
-0.4293808341026306,
0.09682363271713257,
0.6437731981277466,
0.704944908618927,
-0.7001103162765503,
-0.29498565196990967,
0.3086724281311035,
-0.12211506813764572,
-0.076209656894207,
-0.16772450506687164,
0.7930390238761902,
-0.015193814411759377,
-0.46740469336509705,
0.5420128703117371,
0.3764212131500244,
-0.018872283399105072,
0.04774366691708565,
-0.3548274338245392,
-0.12964025139808655,
-0.5588397979736328,
0.6766168475151062,
0.1834457367658615,
-0.7001196146011353,
0.019904516637325287,
0.04465904086828232,
-0.49243640899658203,
0.11653326451778412,
0.6779932379722595,
-0.7908493280410767,
0.7414873838424683,
0.3371880054473877,
0.3677392303943634,
0.6218002438545227,
-0.2812552750110626,
0.5319901704788208,
-0.6199555993080139,
0.2680019736289978,
0.6068691611289978,
0.24562706053256989,
0.3930944800376892,
-0.6481583714485168,
0.5411612391471863,
0.25715556740760803,
-0.6508687734603882,
-0.7922187447547913,
0.030336350202560425,
-0.9684448838233948,
-0.5111532211303711,
1.2505143880844116,
-0.04392591491341591,
0.03840205445885658,
-0.32403764128685,
-0.04342694580554962,
0.3637731373310089,
-0.1470244824886322,
0.5304974317550659,
0.45383697748184204,
-0.465090274810791,
-0.5468062162399292,
-0.6072453856468201,
0.5030266642570496,
0.17562207579612732,
-0.49383679032325745,
-0.3468705415725708,
0.5868996381759644,
0.3206179738044739,
-0.1938042938709259,
0.8459399938583374,
-0.5988192558288574,
0.7123541235923767,
-0.5717369914054871,
0.013558403588831425,
-0.4608006179332733,
-0.12229310721158981,
-0.4787144362926483,
0.3910996615886688,
0.1170426458120346,
0.23407785594463348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03397v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03397v1
|
Automating Turkish Educational Quiz Generation Using Large Language Models
| 2024-06-05T15:54:50 | 2024-06-05T15:54:50 |
Kamyar Zeinalipour, Yusuf Gökberk Keptiğ, Marco Maggini, Marco Gori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Crafting quizzes from educational content is a pivotal activity that benefits
both teachers and students by reinforcing learning and evaluating
understanding. In this study, we introduce a novel approach to generate quizzes
from Turkish educational texts, marking a pioneering endeavor in educational
technology specifically tailored to the Turkish educational context. We present
a specialized dataset, named the Turkish-Quiz-Instruct, comprising an extensive
collection of Turkish educational texts accompanied by multiple-choice and
short-answer quizzes. This research leverages the capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs), including GPT-4-Turbo, GPT-3.5-Turbo,
Llama-2-7b-chat-hf, and Llama-2-13b-chat-hf, to automatically generate quiz
questions and answers from the Turkish educational content. Our work delineates
the methodology for employing these LLMs in the context of Turkish educational
material, thereby opening new avenues for automated Turkish quiz generation.
The study not only demonstrates the efficacy of using such models for
generating coherent and relevant quiz content but also sets a precedent for
future research in the domain of automated educational content creation for
languages other than English. The Turkish-Quiz-Instruct dataset is introduced
as a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners aiming to explore the
boundaries of educational technology and language-specific applications of LLMs
in Turkish. By addressing the challenges of quiz generation in a non-English
context specifically Turkish, this study contributes significantly to the field
of Turkish educational technology, providing insights into the potential of
leveraging LLMs for educational purposes across diverse linguistic landscapes.
|
[
-0.5516652464866638,
-1.150451898574829,
0.4190423786640167,
-0.11073413491249084,
-0.2399771362543106,
-0.0769624263048172,
-0.43517082929611206,
-0.2106747329235077,
0.1384476274251938,
0.4347240924835205,
-0.704807460308075,
-0.5825831890106201,
-0.174862340092659,
0.28027546405792236,
-0.2184995710849762,
1.084151029586792,
-0.2783239781856537,
0.11746808886528015,
-0.4853832721710205,
0.10811705887317657,
-0.46403178572654724,
-0.3566380441188812,
-0.5666642189025879,
-0.07296813279390335,
0.5397509932518005,
0.7349748015403748,
0.2562590539455414,
0.18445110321044922,
0.3578529953956604,
0.2665786147117615,
0.1659402698278427,
0.22570964694023132,
-0.1248197853565216,
0.4288232624530792,
-0.1731719970703125,
-0.2491346150636673,
-0.1141446903347969,
0.04051186516880989,
0.8189407587051392,
0.4336090683937073,
-0.10834623873233795,
0.8329571485519409,
0.25429898500442505,
0.4090269207954407,
-0.48810872435569763,
0.1667541116476059,
-0.5876080989837646,
0.05490203574299812,
-0.18094250559806824,
-0.19891875982284546,
-0.08906173706054688,
-0.5590549111366272,
0.15216462314128876,
-0.4383775293827057,
0.10844168812036514,
-0.040751293301582336,
0.5883617401123047,
0.10600294172763824,
-0.6387763023376465,
-0.5801568031311035,
-0.6600931286811829,
0.5892212390899658,
-0.5327267050743103,
0.3032919466495514,
0.5093047022819519,
0.6717403531074524,
-0.45393839478492737,
-0.7337606549263,
-0.6400739550590515,
-0.44416317343711853,
0.1694011390209198,
0.12023036181926727,
0.45190560817718506,
-0.329746812582016,
0.09226219356060028,
0.46455323696136475,
-0.6343564391136169,
-0.12816207110881805,
-0.46102339029312134,
-0.008212747052311897,
0.6531665921211243,
0.5621777176856995,
0.26606300473213196,
-0.18113552033901215,
-0.0949549674987793,
-0.09677248448133469,
-0.8567384481430054,
0.22180576622486115,
0.6229515075683594,
0.2613033354282379,
0.2709374725818634,
1.0317713022232056,
-0.39682602882385254,
0.653282880783081,
0.04473546892404556,
-0.5039361119270325,
-0.046996574848890305,
-0.27238985896110535,
-0.1804320365190506,
-0.005313953850418329,
0.7842986583709717,
0.15600694715976715,
0.1836962103843689,
0.014172392897307873,
-0.1315070241689682,
0.014368178322911263,
-0.11268553882837296,
-0.7450416684150696,
-0.1737816482782364,
0.26975828409194946,
0.11308892071247101,
-0.493399053812027,
-0.14401306211948395,
-0.612181544303894,
-0.2690887451171875,
-0.08395075798034668,
0.9240933060646057,
-0.3480246961116791,
-0.08302005380392075,
0.16254878044128418,
0.1315114051103592,
0.26944175362586975,
0.3582826554775238,
-0.9844767451286316,
0.024045061320066452,
0.39676544070243835,
0.3409235179424286,
0.0697856917977333,
-0.30764761567115784,
-0.27490732073783875,
0.3689012825489044,
-0.28784820437431335,
0.622952401638031,
-0.5722408294677734,
-0.4821566939353943,
0.30109766125679016,
0.04950755834579468,
-0.10603252798318863,
-0.42793652415275574,
0.33201324939727783,
-0.49385467171669006,
0.9733724594116211,
-0.14931784570217133,
-0.8276601433753967,
-0.26505306363105774,
0.6467382907867432,
-0.6927932500839233,
1.356139898300171,
-0.05058851093053818,
-0.9235050678253174,
0.3988359570503235,
-0.3989505469799042,
-0.4212883412837982,
0.2751355767250061,
-0.2547990083694458,
-0.42894646525382996,
-0.2363223135471344,
0.24478374421596527,
0.47097423672676086,
-0.3902125060558319,
0.26717013120651245,
0.03059082105755806,
-0.5452491641044617,
0.29988959431648254,
-0.22039437294006348,
0.6967397928237915,
-0.07384014129638672,
-0.6192430257797241,
-0.09708370268344879,
-0.28745466470718384,
-0.08853500336408615,
0.3583550751209259,
-0.7233769297599792,
-0.15295365452766418,
-0.02390710823237896,
-0.09713934361934662,
0.2815101146697998,
0.43685027956962585,
-0.5200429558753967,
0.31699350476264954,
-0.14000168442726135,
-0.022716203704476357,
0.39141562581062317,
0.39013007283210754,
0.24207080900669098,
-0.4895343482494354,
0.8895353078842163,
-0.3368769884109497,
0.1915116310119629,
-0.22801648080348969,
-0.5423964858055115,
-0.7658868432044983,
-0.20148538053035736,
0.2117632031440735,
0.7735830545425415,
-0.7798517346382141,
0.3185027539730072,
-0.17123296856880188,
-0.6998597979545593,
-0.39411988854408264,
0.24064044654369354,
0.04274952784180641,
0.7875553965568542,
-0.03707432001829147,
0.19576887786388397,
-0.30492886900901794,
-0.5905050039291382,
-0.09412839263677597,
-0.2729252278804779,
-0.05626501888036728,
0.6190143823623657,
0.6487199664115906,
0.055957645177841187,
0.6581158638000488,
-0.13562758266925812,
-0.40946143865585327,
-0.29309549927711487,
-0.12276727706193924,
0.19202366471290588,
0.46898147463798523,
0.4039871394634247,
-0.5389673113822937,
-0.6317520141601562,
-0.1707591861486435,
-0.7054455280303955,
0.1563073843717575,
-0.03992508724331856,
-0.29286253452301025,
0.3084080219268799,
0.40959644317626953,
-0.7257589101791382,
0.22538287937641144,
0.1443394273519516,
-0.45033004879951477,
0.9600082039833069,
0.030604148283600807,
0.4360591173171997,
-1.1880666017532349,
0.06829766184091568,
-0.25757309794425964,
0.005778506398200989,
-0.30460622906684875,
0.18399390578269958,
-0.19090574979782104,
0.0044211288914084435,
-0.49782615900039673,
0.8166412711143494,
-0.25268736481666565,
0.38190141320228577,
0.13045956194400787,
0.2582539916038513,
-0.05862830579280853,
0.35991865396499634,
-0.03645272180438042,
0.8304248452186584,
0.38829904794692993,
-0.5473220348358154,
0.5763363242149353,
0.5742525458335876,
-0.6909413933753967,
0.43289563059806824,
-0.4410160779953003,
0.09601046144962311,
0.025969091802835464,
0.39124569296836853,
-0.9088281393051147,
-0.4667370319366455,
0.4085713028907776,
-0.5449798107147217,
0.18181294202804565,
-0.24974504113197327,
-0.6644208431243896,
-0.43967586755752563,
-0.37531402707099915,
0.32470962405204773,
0.7163922190666199,
-0.5374260544776917,
0.3621205687522888,
0.45469051599502563,
-0.4574807584285736,
-0.6581335067749023,
-0.4962262511253357,
0.2041342705488205,
-0.7910035252571106,
-0.6762170791625977,
-0.15640942752361298,
-0.19584810733795166,
-0.2496984750032425,
-0.030647963285446167,
0.07783380150794983,
-0.09545332193374634,
0.0789484828710556,
0.050345245748758316,
0.4271698594093323,
-0.42010024189949036,
0.35946863889694214,
0.3476400673389435,
0.5143519043922424,
0.381121963262558,
-0.6407424211502075,
0.4461311101913452,
-0.06362327188253403,
-0.313781201839447,
-0.2988438010215759,
0.5568717122077942,
0.39167165756225586,
-0.37788522243499756,
0.785045862197876,
0.7754428386688232,
-0.30024492740631104,
-0.2615729868412018,
-0.7467694878578186,
-0.3605705797672272,
-0.5083045363426208,
0.37959015369415283,
-0.37419191002845764,
-0.9959539175033569,
0.4354248642921448,
-0.008901749737560749,
0.4081466794013977,
0.3249853253364563,
0.9251890182495117,
-0.3627641499042511,
1.0169837474822998,
0.4576582610607147,
0.15115360915660858,
0.4370746612548828,
-0.1901484727859497,
-0.018187319859862328,
-0.507112443447113,
-0.6417608261108398,
-0.4270109236240387,
-0.02914922684431076,
-0.6106691360473633,
-0.19989219307899475,
0.496460884809494,
-0.18364493548870087,
-0.4317588210105896,
-0.18557323515415192,
-0.2145456075668335,
0.4755350947380066,
0.7262558937072754,
0.15878385305404663,
0.17032311856746674,
0.3914971649646759,
-0.3402923047542572,
0.13571208715438843,
-0.7814322710037231,
-0.8716673254966736,
1.4037929773330688,
-0.0798102393746376,
0.5897175073623657,
0.28933027386665344,
1.1450579166412354,
0.24536438286304474,
0.36820197105407715,
-0.7811399698257446,
0.5759861469268799,
0.09219233691692352,
-0.8747379779815674,
-0.7064117789268494,
-0.2572507858276367,
-1.035943865776062,
-0.045357272028923035,
-0.43260666728019714,
-0.6221785545349121,
-0.49234405159950256,
0.12224069982767105,
-0.27245789766311646,
0.1672835350036621,
-0.5397403836250305,
0.8771721124649048,
-0.07121611386537552,
-0.5245177149772644,
-0.1243722066283226,
-0.4357275664806366,
0.5992807149887085,
-0.23538517951965332,
-0.00032586624729447067,
-0.03673509508371353,
0.04515538737177849,
0.9393700361251831,
-0.21207164227962494,
0.4646851420402527,
-0.17154763638973236,
-0.27748769521713257,
0.7193975448608398,
0.308398574590683,
0.3238450884819031,
0.2813471257686615,
0.022652748972177505,
-0.4069006145000458,
0.15579064190387726,
-0.29187268018722534,
-0.5509793162345886,
0.6531711220741272,
-0.6535907983779907,
-0.8849467039108276,
-0.20956915616989136,
-0.6684640645980835,
-0.31525734066963196,
0.06587463617324829,
0.14189638197422028,
0.4105316996574402,
-0.36820563673973083,
-0.2832934260368347,
0.6543375253677368,
-0.41185739636421204,
0.17104637622833252,
0.5326427221298218,
-0.1524437963962555,
-0.24659565091133118,
0.979840099811554,
0.00016872775449883193,
-0.04782921448349953,
0.11815527081489563,
0.12572896480560303,
-0.613701581954956,
-0.2755812406539917,
-0.7521112561225891,
0.27455994486808777,
-0.8925884962081909,
-0.031629037111997604,
-0.3604812026023865,
-0.14949864149093628,
-0.4994778335094452,
-0.11978188157081604,
0.03280055150389671,
-0.5208317637443542,
-0.06181958317756653,
-0.04392656683921814,
0.35511547327041626,
0.9381056427955627,
0.03932252526283264,
0.04098943620920181,
-0.6844253540039062,
0.022469298914074898,
0.7984343767166138,
-0.03765397146344185,
-0.16186881065368652,
-0.5937038064002991,
-0.31509312987327576,
0.04972343519330025,
-0.06461326032876968,
-0.9727281928062439,
0.23431064188480377,
0.39014217257499695,
0.5359058976173401,
0.11351905763149261,
0.005376586690545082,
0.24506191909313202,
-0.6015840768814087,
0.9883455634117126,
-0.2520059645175934,
-0.5159555673599243,
0.45876461267471313,
-0.5659580230712891,
0.348246306180954,
0.5900817513465881,
0.31609484553337097,
-0.5447999835014343,
-0.6125794649124146,
-0.47329607605934143,
-0.9278010725975037,
0.5160138010978699,
0.12864862382411957,
0.5255988836288452,
-0.07391605526208878,
0.37360039353370667,
0.43088817596435547,
0.28750723600387573,
-0.4253450334072113,
-0.10922986268997192,
-0.17820240557193756,
-0.5413589477539062,
-0.01391559187322855,
-0.2542526423931122,
-0.0967356413602829,
-0.32400304079055786,
0.9773625135421753,
0.026446213945746422,
0.0878232792019844,
-0.033036794513463974,
-0.33234935998916626,
0.05104583129286766,
0.22832117974758148,
0.45840275287628174,
0.4496663212776184,
-0.1352374106645584,
0.005116439890116453,
0.3402898907661438,
-0.7901071310043335,
0.2939660847187042,
0.0955066978931427,
-0.2379487156867981,
-0.12065532058477402,
0.0012806678423658013,
0.40506190061569214,
-0.23260730504989624,
-0.9112862944602966,
0.4128532409667969,
-0.3704274594783783,
-0.21110953390598297,
-0.8458222150802612,
0.126651793718338,
0.1100740134716034,
0.4369165301322937,
0.3705484867095947,
-0.8222337365150452,
0.025942763313651085,
-0.21620136499404907,
0.361762672662735,
0.5113049149513245,
0.0042075542733073235,
-0.1662302315235138,
0.7144556045532227,
0.27801722288131714,
-0.13696527481079102,
0.8773372173309326,
-0.1564003974199295,
-0.4345180094242096,
0.6713900566101074,
0.45946449041366577,
0.8090881109237671,
-0.3628018796443939,
0.5868511199951172,
0.7356016039848328,
0.3250259757041931,
0.18819107115268707,
0.5391808152198792,
-0.46520373225212097,
-0.4751535952091217,
-0.42016366124153137,
-0.6787587404251099,
-0.5458902716636658,
0.47807103395462036,
-0.5273491740226746,
0.4519226849079132,
-0.33665552735328674,
-0.01938985101878643,
-0.33156174421310425,
0.2823822498321533,
-0.8217523694038391,
0.518736720085144,
0.5225588083267212,
0.8024963140487671,
-0.9048457145690918,
0.76338130235672,
1.2074353694915771,
-0.2565992772579193,
-0.919830322265625,
-0.04357275366783142,
-0.22173985838890076,
-0.5769456028938293,
0.4864819347858429,
0.05209041386842728,
-0.033720213919878006,
0.19135427474975586,
-0.6699408292770386,
-0.7039567828178406,
1.0072062015533447,
0.20907342433929443,
-0.11701088398694992,
0.057841695845127106,
0.6314318776130676,
0.35035181045532227,
-0.36818090081214905,
0.3335874676704407,
0.5026288628578186,
0.5781940221786499,
-0.03327363729476929,
-0.7038190960884094,
0.11046408861875534,
-0.39750662446022034,
-0.593838095664978,
-0.11623947322368622,
-0.39427855610847473,
0.6471704840660095,
-0.2482716590166092,
-0.10006005316972733,
0.2510667145252228,
0.7053443789482117,
0.4321528673171997,
0.15074753761291504,
0.36154142022132874,
0.36004438996315,
0.6128733158111572,
0.1479177176952362,
0.5519046783447266,
-0.4045395255088806,
0.17395249009132385,
1.0607614517211914,
0.0910303145647049,
0.660364031791687,
0.5306405425071716,
-0.06636974960565567,
0.4250277876853943,
1.042542815208435,
-0.09851498156785965,
0.26554930210113525,
0.1090983971953392,
-0.5867170095443726,
-0.34447216987609863,
-0.12185779213905334,
-0.28992438316345215,
0.6903631091117859,
0.38334622979164124,
0.012716724537312984,
-0.3269280791282654,
-0.11956675350666046,
0.2239876091480255,
-0.22442449629306793,
-0.1844245046377182,
0.7074426412582397,
-0.21265099942684174,
-0.845596969127655,
0.47255730628967285,
-0.11437378078699112,
0.2837848365306854,
-0.552801787853241,
-0.09143645316362381,
-0.42740994691848755,
-0.22574084997177124,
0.11706725507974625,
-0.7777376770973206,
-0.11853913217782974,
0.1671864539384842,
0.17187827825546265,
0.22816339135169983,
0.40197527408599854,
-0.9271419048309326,
-0.6501398682594299,
-0.42098990082740784,
0.7517701387405396,
0.39966320991516113,
0.04900903254747391,
-0.5081915259361267,
-0.4352348744869232,
-0.08116818219423294,
-0.4397374391555786,
0.22825253009796143,
0.5708163380622864,
-0.340770423412323,
0.45331695675849915,
0.4008919894695282,
-0.055271733552217484,
0.23466302454471588,
-0.08246560394763947,
0.6261581182479858,
-0.5120734572410583,
-0.5657963752746582,
-0.5397659540176392,
0.4824734330177307,
0.23737211525440216,
-0.36699575185775757,
0.8843068480491638,
0.5374984741210938,
0.818971574306488,
-0.26307153701782227,
1.138738751411438,
-0.08199203759431839,
0.25134363770484924,
-0.36760464310646057,
0.9342161417007446,
-0.7985585927963257,
0.038802895694971085,
-0.20640094578266144,
-1.0168346166610718,
-0.041877638548612595,
0.2624487578868866,
-0.1679297387599945,
-0.016535505652427673,
0.5009217262268066,
0.6839401125907898,
0.15009470283985138,
-0.1169419214129448,
0.11084344238042831,
0.047151654958724976,
0.15133731067180634,
0.6787689924240112,
1.0796599388122559,
-0.2600334584712982,
0.6838341355323792,
-0.3493044674396515,
-0.11631941050291061,
-0.057130664587020874,
-0.5076287388801575,
-1.4295328855514526,
-0.9035454392433167,
-0.22145166993141174,
-0.2094666212797165,
-0.06063512712717056,
0.831847608089447,
0.1351117044687271,
-0.73997563123703,
-0.261627197265625,
0.2811275124549866,
0.13013970851898193,
0.2304079234600067,
-0.20036110281944275,
0.7162573933601379,
-0.34628695249557495,
-0.8591084480285645,
0.3138737082481384,
-0.17972975969314575,
0.22848713397979736,
-0.49865612387657166,
0.13416339457035065,
-0.08292537182569504,
0.3952697217464447,
0.4239128530025482,
0.23000866174697876,
-0.5503595471382141,
-0.3154905438423157,
0.21771864593029022,
-0.1780335158109665,
-0.35059472918510437,
0.6141769289970398,
-1.0052659511566162,
0.37661993503570557,
0.5495107769966125,
0.47063758969306946,
0.5126280188560486,
-0.2504330575466156,
0.4617621600627899,
-0.47357988357543945,
0.15901736915111542,
0.27746084332466125,
0.1325032114982605,
0.5456217527389526,
-0.31152284145355225,
0.22915096580982208,
-0.06245981529355049,
-0.45876961946487427,
-0.8411332964897156,
0.20801867544651031,
-0.5238950252532959,
0.01140754483640194,
1.321258306503296,
-0.12223057448863983,
-0.31040158867836,
-0.17562153935432434,
-0.298652708530426,
0.45720374584198,
-0.10218916088342667,
1.3272467851638794,
0.5510870218276978,
0.08246906846761703,
0.16764655709266663,
-0.5700305700302124,
0.5733844637870789,
0.404419869184494,
-0.7397618293762207,
-0.3055620491504669,
0.42995283007621765,
0.5539259910583496,
-0.38517776131629944,
0.26833561062812805,
-0.06556109338998795,
0.45696184039115906,
-0.008438057266175747,
0.11837316304445267,
-0.24555030465126038,
-0.18039146065711975,
-0.00041226058965548873,
0.14001671969890594,
-0.08217282593250275,
-0.1823483556509018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06590v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06590v2
|
Are LLMs classical or nonmonotonic reasoners? Lessons from generics
| 2024-06-05T15:23:11 | 2024-06-12T11:18:40 |
Alina Leidinger, Robert van Rooij, Ekaterina Shutova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent scholarship on reasoning in LLMs has supplied evidence of impressive
performance and flexible adaptation to machine generated or human feedback.
Nonmonotonic reasoning, crucial to human cognition for navigating the real
world, remains a challenging, yet understudied task. In this work, we study
nonmonotonic reasoning capabilities of seven state-of-the-art LLMs in one
abstract and one commonsense reasoning task featuring generics, such as 'Birds
fly', and exceptions, 'Penguins don't fly' (see Fig. 1). While LLMs exhibit
reasoning patterns in accordance with human nonmonotonic reasoning abilities,
they fail to maintain stable beliefs on truth conditions of generics at the
addition of supporting examples ('Owls fly') or unrelated information ('Lions
have manes'). Our findings highlight pitfalls in attributing human reasoning
behaviours to LLMs, as well as assessing general capabilities, while consistent
reasoning remains elusive.
|
[
-0.3974218964576721,
-0.37625065445899963,
0.7461578249931335,
-0.10718704760074615,
-0.22742147743701935,
0.06400711089372635,
-0.21038904786109924,
-0.47747084498405457,
-0.022707443684339523,
0.31181710958480835,
-0.7399083375930786,
-0.3669514060020447,
-0.31364256143569946,
0.5135908126831055,
-0.14233696460723877,
0.8164665699005127,
0.0017740881303325295,
-0.37596559524536133,
-0.4694046080112457,
-0.3702701926231384,
-0.1539091169834137,
-0.5891783833503723,
-0.3078036606311798,
-0.4530055820941925,
0.7753039598464966,
0.2618325650691986,
0.639767587184906,
0.1382439285516739,
0.12406665086746216,
0.1842944473028183,
-0.09630224853754044,
0.7115494012832642,
-0.2528093755245209,
0.23376072943210602,
-0.7326698303222656,
-0.7964282631874084,
-0.14886072278022766,
0.060514431446790695,
0.2766799330711365,
0.7486556768417358,
0.011935618706047535,
0.07933918386697769,
-0.000914646137971431,
0.6410165429115295,
-0.6979741454124451,
-0.008935733698308468,
-0.7603052854537964,
0.17323189973831177,
-0.1371004283428192,
-0.38073912262916565,
-0.4555376172065735,
-0.21438196301460266,
0.03620300814509392,
-1.0487120151519775,
0.21977584064006805,
0.33906978368759155,
0.5982068181037903,
0.3834991455078125,
-0.6170290112495422,
-0.5511284470558167,
-0.5926533341407776,
1.007153868675232,
-0.6160873174667358,
0.0750298723578453,
0.38165283203125,
0.4572877883911133,
-0.4398473799228668,
-0.6268534064292908,
-0.40032100677490234,
-0.5619060397148132,
-0.09218201786279678,
0.2244519293308258,
-0.15443913638591766,
0.14000865817070007,
0.3045452833175659,
0.03594721108675003,
-0.577258288860321,
0.2943514585494995,
-0.0834764614701271,
-0.24963930249214172,
0.5043407082557678,
0.12349749356508255,
0.022381523624062538,
-0.04692959785461426,
-0.38916295766830444,
0.3367172181606293,
-0.5856652855873108,
0.27906596660614014,
-0.021288445219397545,
0.13515901565551758,
0.01734909601509571,
0.4304794371128082,
0.025819430127739906,
0.8089834451675415,
0.04754026234149933,
-0.313314288854599,
-0.4114502966403961,
0.13077116012573242,
-0.1355390101671219,
-0.24769096076488495,
0.381468802690506,
0.4429119825363159,
0.6316651105880737,
-0.4077833592891693,
-0.4067416489124298,
0.017482085153460503,
0.23939970135688782,
0.039017122238874435,
-0.06358271092176437,
0.07327645272016525,
-0.6499901413917542,
-0.18014591932296753,
-0.008769029751420021,
-0.5160730481147766,
-0.22378669679164886,
-0.36060377955436707,
0.4211525022983551,
-0.44120773673057556,
-0.2727316915988922,
0.09476500749588013,
-0.5851942300796509,
0.43229860067367554,
0.6306465864181519,
-0.875499427318573,
0.2119443267583847,
0.9207779169082642,
0.6574833989143372,
0.04284190386533737,
-0.3082834780216217,
0.12284044921398163,
0.39234229922294617,
-0.714094340801239,
1.0769108533859253,
-0.49501392245292664,
-0.5009949207305908,
0.03328001871705055,
-0.025982284918427467,
-0.3106377422809601,
-0.8511838912963867,
0.6168811321258545,
-0.2974470853805542,
0.14269676804542542,
-0.7087123394012451,
-0.4932865500450134,
-0.6033490300178528,
0.528037965297699,
-0.2530064284801483,
0.4594363570213318,
0.060079507529735565,
-0.5069044828414917,
0.3915160894393921,
-0.5000110268592834,
-0.5503581166267395,
0.21757392585277557,
-0.2909886837005615,
0.038062650710344315,
0.378639817237854,
-0.07024043053388596,
0.10347416996955872,
-0.46036648750305176,
0.1004272848367691,
-0.665208637714386,
-0.6083469986915588,
0.6631720066070557,
-0.426802396774292,
0.4518425464630127,
0.2112608551979065,
-0.5431580543518066,
-0.11750848591327667,
-0.5346418619155884,
-0.02826542593538761,
-0.001367212156765163,
-0.25594523549079895,
-0.13150566816329956,
0.38386207818984985,
-0.19662392139434814,
0.26523181796073914,
0.2301519513130188,
-0.19457213580608368,
0.4027707576751709,
0.1701689064502716,
0.8641155958175659,
1.0114576816558838,
-0.13786263763904572,
0.07283920794725418,
-1.1049474477767944,
0.37526512145996094,
-0.02243291772902012,
0.14944419264793396,
0.2859126627445221,
-0.6149349212646484,
-0.8755190372467041,
-0.18287293612957,
-0.16463157534599304,
0.5162653923034668,
-0.8988934755325317,
0.07798096537590027,
-0.12827377021312714,
-0.3309938311576843,
-0.05339016765356064,
0.19059157371520996,
0.36725908517837524,
0.4373264014720917,
0.2053655982017517,
0.3389537036418915,
-0.41014364361763,
-0.9250732660293579,
-0.5687100291252136,
-0.3575279712677002,
-0.11433132737874985,
0.27675434947013855,
0.6356580853462219,
-0.17943117022514343,
0.756665050983429,
0.16947314143180847,
-0.05494450032711029,
-0.32635435461997986,
0.25656330585479736,
0.08634383976459503,
0.2660268545150757,
0.47357723116874695,
-0.5216276049613953,
0.19125895202159882,
-0.21427547931671143,
-1.1965841054916382,
-0.0980529636144638,
-0.6145201325416565,
0.11244408041238785,
0.4430677890777588,
0.337388813495636,
-0.7252586483955383,
-0.008108405396342278,
0.12861347198486328,
-0.27245742082595825,
0.5821463465690613,
-0.1842140555381775,
0.018762998282909393,
-0.35678738355636597,
0.07512524724006653,
0.27227213978767395,
-0.12861378490924835,
-0.41049858927726746,
-0.04875988885760307,
-0.2586154639720917,
0.24040792882442474,
-0.3358182907104492,
0.46725785732269287,
-0.4564639925956726,
-0.23621325194835663,
-0.2853027284145355,
0.2873586118221283,
-0.04603622481226921,
0.4027301073074341,
0.39164525270462036,
0.6290086507797241,
0.6329051852226257,
-0.9045455455780029,
0.3437950313091278,
-0.2187020629644394,
-0.09107089042663574,
0.8977824449539185,
-0.3921160399913788,
0.06372059881687164,
-0.2657766044139862,
0.4640190601348877,
-0.9149876832962036,
0.008941173553466797,
0.29139137268066406,
-0.44505414366722107,
0.05014106258749962,
-0.02706305868923664,
-0.6169838905334473,
-0.35788190364837646,
-0.2184372842311859,
0.1716068536043167,
0.6141045689582825,
-0.5036948919296265,
0.4543909728527069,
-0.17143544554710388,
0.38516342639923096,
-0.24293337762355804,
-0.8896173238754272,
0.2695823013782501,
-0.37402236461639404,
-0.6165726780891418,
0.024828528985381126,
0.1649044007062912,
-0.7332271933555603,
0.04063380882143974,
-0.48124709725379944,
-0.022482313215732574,
0.18647466599941254,
0.17126114666461945,
0.25836634635925293,
-0.41653677821159363,
0.11645567417144775,
-0.0737825334072113,
-0.1588345170021057,
0.08394446223974228,
-0.5826375484466553,
-0.21844573318958282,
-0.2978377640247345,
-0.43266239762306213,
-0.568016529083252,
0.15164582431316376,
0.8372336626052856,
0.2636162042617798,
0.5607823133468628,
0.141695037484169,
-0.28233593702316284,
-0.3886621296405792,
-0.5622325539588928,
-0.23200759291648865,
-0.4486199915409088,
-0.226861834526062,
-0.5577751398086548,
-1.0020705461502075,
0.38226521015167236,
-0.2217562347650528,
0.2775494158267975,
0.4738708436489105,
0.1804596185684204,
-0.5965405702590942,
0.6074196696281433,
-0.06058268994092941,
0.3872613310813904,
-0.17214688658714294,
-0.1236065998673439,
-0.0878029465675354,
-0.930166482925415,
-0.43715700507164,
-0.1717083603143692,
-0.6825932264328003,
-0.6916946768760681,
-0.43219518661499023,
0.3303387761116028,
0.011824104003608227,
-0.19675037264823914,
-0.11946109682321548,
-0.4189166724681854,
0.2560477554798126,
0.39826449751853943,
-0.055397383868694305,
0.14406001567840576,
-0.34975504875183105,
-0.17175327241420746,
0.17729680240154266,
-0.9409689903259277,
-0.9117164611816406,
1.0520879030227661,
0.11307782679796219,
0.7267926335334778,
0.30096083879470825,
0.47296345233917236,
0.36932292580604553,
0.3901556432247162,
-0.5841642022132874,
0.9356104135513306,
-0.2118655890226364,
-0.8227300643920898,
0.09285759925842285,
-0.5143003463745117,
-1.114392638206482,
0.6004418134689331,
-0.19823837280273438,
-0.5171958208084106,
0.0786503255367279,
0.18401716649532318,
-0.36576828360557556,
0.6837109327316284,
-0.23052844405174255,
0.527084231376648,
-0.43346163630485535,
-0.3330196440219879,
-0.09208213537931442,
-0.6604198217391968,
0.6755493879318237,
0.2728358209133148,
0.4571799337863922,
-0.201994389295578,
-0.43692320585250854,
0.6457214951515198,
-0.16462045907974243,
0.9553282260894775,
-0.1390124410390854,
-0.08362440019845963,
0.5582406520843506,
0.24522055685520172,
0.13633199036121368,
-0.017725922167301178,
0.04702816903591156,
0.10944898426532745,
0.21350426971912384,
-0.5923883318901062,
-0.7055198550224304,
0.563412606716156,
-0.674561619758606,
-0.8770988583564758,
-0.765287458896637,
-0.4131852686405182,
-0.37062105536460876,
-0.07206534594297409,
0.34956955909729004,
0.3850288689136505,
0.11174274981021881,
0.12151563167572021,
0.6897493600845337,
0.09591743350028992,
0.4366724491119385,
0.6457504630088806,
0.10563844442367554,
-0.42077770829200745,
0.9108681082725525,
0.3311726450920105,
0.2680884897708893,
0.6393225193023682,
0.1470438539981842,
-0.6022308468818665,
-0.6645015478134155,
-0.23964814841747284,
0.43488994240760803,
-0.9242217540740967,
0.12312623113393784,
0.011312821879982948,
0.10283955186605453,
-0.1524452567100525,
-0.4203152060508728,
0.12822139263153076,
-0.6397084593772888,
-0.34537971019744873,
0.20556220412254333,
-0.04828439652919769,
0.8460021018981934,
-0.2380625158548355,
-0.35797181725502014,
-0.5789076089859009,
0.36676788330078125,
0.7908263206481934,
-0.02444910630583763,
0.0041887168772518635,
-0.505028247833252,
0.15070460736751556,
-0.15791015326976776,
-0.39866903424263,
-0.7704004049301147,
-0.2544257640838623,
0.14137768745422363,
1.1928890943527222,
0.6830226182937622,
0.32849639654159546,
0.5510966777801514,
0.032801877707242966,
1.0323278903961182,
-0.012236375361680984,
-0.7474119067192078,
0.498375803232193,
-0.5771223306655884,
0.12676994502544403,
0.33293864130973816,
0.23614390194416046,
-0.609312117099762,
-0.3719203770160675,
-0.44551345705986023,
-0.18634267151355743,
0.44750598073005676,
0.19660186767578125,
-0.3317680060863495,
-0.09877005964517593,
0.750066876411438,
0.07718653976917267,
0.2698424756526947,
-0.7512258887290955,
-0.0178748220205307,
-0.4707663655281067,
0.040517162531614304,
-0.36653122305870056,
-0.11513844132423401,
-0.26673808693885803,
-0.1242864802479744,
0.4093101918697357,
-0.16863082349300385,
0.18501195311546326,
0.2938998341560364,
0.006327809300273657,
-0.09362700581550598,
0.4532454311847687,
1.2569711208343506,
0.7030949592590332,
-0.2831920087337494,
0.6478446125984192,
0.08608683198690414,
0.15088513493537903,
0.45338869094848633,
-0.3368741273880005,
-0.06966251879930496,
-0.14260844886302948,
0.8140068650245667,
0.37567898631095886,
0.3674749433994293,
-0.7876638770103455,
0.12971153855323792,
0.10403890907764435,
-0.7938374280929565,
-0.37072765827178955,
0.23013335466384888,
-0.05649575963616371,
0.24160243570804596,
0.25828951597213745,
0.36719101667404175,
-0.0911407321691513,
-0.8537923693656921,
-0.18600618839263916,
0.7009939551353455,
-0.0733298733830452,
-0.4854983687400818,
0.6541145443916321,
0.26497161388397217,
-0.24630017578601837,
0.5386471152305603,
-0.43180426955223083,
-0.3640778064727783,
0.5304341316223145,
0.5321377515792847,
0.9294196367263794,
0.3015519380569458,
0.033609528094530106,
-0.05648970976471901,
0.7438421845436096,
-0.09238395094871521,
0.1811775267124176,
-0.36748823523521423,
-0.6574034094810486,
-0.19224275648593903,
-0.1454792320728302,
-0.7150863409042358,
0.14420831203460693,
-0.5764756202697754,
-0.224096417427063,
-0.8559420108795166,
-0.3151269555091858,
-0.3336961269378662,
-0.26885470747947693,
-0.06832104921340942,
0.01796209253370762,
0.37919116020202637,
1.0852651596069336,
-0.5895242691040039,
0.5197810530662537,
1.0300909280776978,
-0.19191089272499084,
-0.2674984037876129,
0.32215073704719543,
0.30298909544944763,
-0.7946462035179138,
0.8106763958930969,
0.258662611246109,
-0.4052180349826813,
-0.39024943113327026,
-0.41605624556541443,
-0.6082172989845276,
1.0389195680618286,
0.4260038435459137,
-0.4567016363143921,
-0.0950576588511467,
0.0901268720626831,
0.4851682186126709,
-0.07830120623111725,
0.08163494616746902,
0.31670060753822327,
0.8444425463676453,
0.4142425060272217,
-0.8526945114135742,
0.09473829716444016,
-0.23639914393424988,
0.15728449821472168,
-0.04073287546634674,
-0.9310149550437927,
0.6775484085083008,
-0.2276362031698227,
-0.0645446628332138,
0.27088266611099243,
0.4968348741531372,
0.6974681615829468,
0.612167239189148,
0.47530239820480347,
0.68263840675354,
0.8121870756149292,
-0.06622198969125748,
0.9119059443473816,
-0.06936444342136383,
0.14612264931201935,
0.585202693939209,
-0.30024662613868713,
0.6003973484039307,
0.5176613926887512,
-0.26632165908813477,
0.7201284766197205,
0.8200250864028931,
0.07597550004720688,
0.44860967993736267,
0.3823230564594269,
-0.47226446866989136,
-0.8681620955467224,
0.3692963719367981,
-0.20443521440029144,
0.31465017795562744,
0.31560492515563965,
-0.011881421320140362,
-0.19560672342777252,
-0.06836821138858795,
-0.10766251385211945,
0.133357971906662,
-0.545636773109436,
0.6614775657653809,
0.2470317929983139,
-1.1584945917129517,
1.0803488492965698,
0.0017490120371803641,
0.8243932127952576,
-0.35006168484687805,
0.15455293655395508,
-0.11393232643604279,
0.1941176950931549,
-0.26600182056427,
-0.739933431148529,
0.42032524943351746,
-0.2043823003768921,
-0.051937006413936615,
-0.28015846014022827,
0.56772780418396,
0.3154217302799225,
-0.2516098618507385,
0.032899416983127594,
0.32909294962882996,
0.3671773374080658,
0.23928359150886536,
-0.6747321486473083,
-0.33698731660842896,
-0.07062556594610214,
0.1110355481505394,
0.3418427109718323,
0.6059444546699524,
-0.01730256713926792,
1.1014256477355957,
0.5798380374908447,
0.11103195697069168,
0.11879570782184601,
-0.2593097686767578,
0.5627987384796143,
-0.946426510810852,
-0.17973250150680542,
-0.9229879975318909,
0.19066683948040009,
0.3109612464904785,
-0.35323217511177063,
0.8110564947128296,
0.3164912164211273,
0.4034542441368103,
-0.10635904967784882,
0.8379504084587097,
0.37893423438072205,
0.4190470278263092,
-0.8274377584457397,
0.2390318512916565,
-0.662355363368988,
0.2958352267742157,
0.2170722782611847,
-0.5137088298797607,
-0.27266183495521545,
0.684912383556366,
-0.4371664226055145,
0.10338491201400757,
0.720487654209137,
0.42552512884140015,
0.11257342994213104,
0.29425567388534546,
0.4847012460231781,
0.04901326075196266,
0.39279285073280334,
1.0404478311538696,
1.4477243423461914,
0.2799767255783081,
0.30460768938064575,
0.23947596549987793,
-0.2663109004497528,
-0.3984714150428772,
-0.8334267735481262,
-1.0919878482818604,
-0.14377973973751068,
-0.46863624453544617,
-0.05029034987092018,
0.15122517943382263,
0.8694466352462769,
0.7401407361030579,
-0.5374624133110046,
-0.37695422768592834,
-0.5186465978622437,
0.5351356267929077,
-0.4822109341621399,
-0.21166285872459412,
-0.23056018352508545,
-0.6984658241271973,
-0.1419248729944229,
0.4677046537399292,
0.5393733978271484,
0.21433883905410767,
-0.2726074457168579,
-0.17870984971523285,
0.17025762796401978,
0.5456075072288513,
0.5564271211624146,
0.6670196056365967,
-1.3255561590194702,
-0.2935263216495514,
-0.10311336070299149,
0.152461439371109,
-0.14203789830207825,
0.921174168586731,
-0.7585107684135437,
0.1552686095237732,
0.1625566929578781,
0.10945849120616913,
0.09808899462223053,
-0.16285456717014313,
0.09410785138607025,
-0.1385207623243332,
0.12971369922161102,
0.4713355004787445,
0.4254935085773468,
0.1222827136516571,
0.13572199642658234,
0.07381171733140945,
0.8046166896820068,
-0.7279173135757446,
-0.6628907918930054,
0.45671507716178894,
-1.0866656303405762,
-0.5975520014762878,
1.2183560132980347,
-0.1878211796283722,
-0.2652660012245178,
-0.4185657203197479,
0.022714681923389435,
-0.26241642236709595,
-0.25898799300193787,
0.8177651762962341,
0.5803439021110535,
-0.8028045892715454,
-0.4455752372741699,
-0.4234648644924164,
0.4261064827442169,
0.36036068201065063,
-0.7025187611579895,
-0.257855087518692,
0.37140244245529175,
0.4178970456123352,
0.23368744552135468,
0.4600686728954315,
0.2190319299697876,
0.38244301080703735,
0.071672223508358,
-0.5675721764564514,
-0.13849815726280212,
-0.11547750234603882,
-0.17424450814723969,
0.2966223359107971,
0.5018932223320007,
-0.2813485562801361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03368v1
|
IrokoBench: A New Benchmark for African Languages in the Age of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-05T15:23:08 | 2024-06-05T15:23:08 |
David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Jessica Ojo, Israel Abebe Azime, Jian Yun Zhuang, Jesujoba O. Alabi, Xuanli He, Millicent Ochieng, Sara Hooker, Andiswa Bukula, En-Shiun Annie Lee, Chiamaka Chukwuneke, Happy Buzaaba, Blessing Sibanda, Godson Kalipe, Jonathan Mukiibi, Salomon Kabongo, Foutse Yuehgoh, Mmasibidi Setaka, Lolwethu Ndolela, Nkiruka Odu, Rooweither Mabuya, Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Salomey Osei, Sokhar Samb, Tadesse Kebede Guge, Pontus Stenetorp
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the widespread adoption of Large language models (LLMs), their
remarkable capabilities remain limited to a few high-resource languages.
Additionally, many low-resource languages (e.g. African languages) are often
evaluated only on basic text classification tasks due to the lack of
appropriate or comprehensive benchmarks outside of high-resource languages. In
this paper, we introduce IrokoBench -- a human-translated benchmark dataset for
16 typologically-diverse low-resource African languages covering three tasks:
natural language inference~(AfriXNLI), mathematical reasoning~(AfriMGSM), and
multi-choice knowledge-based QA~(AfriMMLU). We use IrokoBench to evaluate
zero-shot, few-shot, and translate-test settings~(where test sets are
translated into English) across 10 open and four proprietary LLMs. Our
evaluation reveals a significant performance gap between high-resource
languages~(such as English and French) and low-resource African languages. We
observe a significant performance gap between open and proprietary models, with
the highest performing open model, Aya-101 only at 58\% of the best-performing
proprietary model GPT-4o performance. Machine translating the test set to
English before evaluation helped to close the gap for larger models that are
English-centric, like LLaMa 3 70B. These findings suggest that more efforts are
needed to develop and adapt LLMs for African languages.
|
[
-0.7216120958328247,
-0.4601413905620575,
0.15649855136871338,
0.27696606516838074,
-0.2051965296268463,
0.0021810103207826614,
-0.45503026247024536,
-0.7115315794944763,
0.15013796091079712,
0.585015594959259,
-0.47179996967315674,
-0.39866235852241516,
-0.7397375106811523,
0.39646685123443604,
-0.29147809743881226,
0.6828052401542664,
-0.4569752514362335,
-0.05862165987491608,
-0.032659828662872314,
-0.7238799929618835,
-0.3498229384422302,
-0.39723101258277893,
-0.18560931086540222,
-0.6763824820518494,
0.43313050270080566,
0.6579406261444092,
0.6192827224731445,
0.3964672088623047,
0.3145836889743805,
0.24846802651882172,
0.16978566348552704,
0.1543056219816208,
-0.15186184644699097,
0.21853192150592804,
-0.0032853102311491966,
-0.5436165928840637,
-0.13183699548244476,
0.239585280418396,
0.2802029252052307,
0.6867993474006653,
-0.11905865371227264,
0.43948614597320557,
-0.009484745562076569,
0.6493754386901855,
-0.867666482925415,
0.23415493965148926,
-0.32426393032073975,
0.05007798969745636,
-0.542005181312561,
0.21747268736362457,
-0.37617141008377075,
-0.3917991816997528,
-0.12041051685810089,
-0.1806836873292923,
-0.12141311913728714,
-0.11664127558469772,
0.8482012152671814,
0.08406227082014084,
-0.45774903893470764,
0.020062843337655067,
-0.3623632788658142,
0.8475380539894104,
-0.8385525345802307,
0.25246500968933105,
0.6686120629310608,
0.7147923707962036,
-0.0599980428814888,
-0.601660966873169,
-0.5359958410263062,
-0.211993008852005,
0.33171546459198,
-0.12623673677444458,
-0.18810616433620453,
-0.042119234800338745,
0.11888381838798523,
0.336110383272171,
-0.25553464889526367,
0.26626119017601013,
-0.0033994875848293304,
-0.1929919272661209,
0.48818421363830566,
-0.14474254846572876,
0.4198891818523407,
-0.3106570243835449,
0.10163357108831406,
-0.17993922531604767,
-0.5185701251029968,
-0.2455337643623352,
0.40176036953926086,
0.5015035271644592,
-0.1955586075782776,
0.5851477384567261,
-0.6078845262527466,
0.8254113793373108,
-0.520796000957489,
-0.12764301896095276,
0.3979436159133911,
-0.022866521030664444,
0.029485421255230904,
0.020724935457110405,
0.9134134650230408,
0.1359129548072815,
0.6122025847434998,
-0.19343885779380798,
-0.21030807495117188,
0.2526799142360687,
0.056975945830345154,
-0.9256909489631653,
-0.15987202525138855,
-0.2504250705242157,
-0.39731812477111816,
-0.19895903766155243,
-0.44384899735450745,
-0.8598472476005554,
-0.2631895840167999,
0.11302793025970459,
0.3522825837135315,
-0.3470538258552551,
0.05818207189440727,
-0.024277346208691597,
0.3891103267669678,
0.05065016448497772,
0.29500117897987366,
-0.808664083480835,
0.4431641399860382,
0.4147990345954895,
1.0228655338287354,
-0.03817418962717056,
-0.31829679012298584,
-0.38526707887649536,
-0.13850170373916626,
-0.2290988713502884,
0.8347286581993103,
-0.44574424624443054,
-0.05559565871953964,
0.03682471066713333,
-0.16979390382766724,
0.19834847748279572,
-0.526057243347168,
0.5999037623405457,
-0.4529682397842407,
0.08114685863256454,
-0.19712990522384644,
-0.21440011262893677,
-0.5606870651245117,
0.37367507815361023,
-0.7121615409851074,
1.0551540851593018,
0.4078684151172638,
-0.2896534204483032,
0.2635020613670349,
-0.4098966717720032,
-0.6124721765518188,
0.1168416291475296,
-0.35843849182128906,
-0.2589673399925232,
0.11862483620643616,
0.180769145488739,
0.0808325707912445,
-0.9376991987228394,
0.07484310865402222,
-0.4135272204875946,
-0.25214841961860657,
0.29509279131889343,
-0.620051383972168,
0.7276688814163208,
0.26511770486831665,
-0.5863759517669678,
-0.31846150755882263,
-0.8021537661552429,
0.5269168615341187,
0.019911129027605057,
-0.2664933502674103,
-0.16610243916511536,
-0.14377795159816742,
0.077528215944767,
0.4828495979309082,
0.12902569770812988,
-0.5275030136108398,
0.2096194624900818,
-0.18607181310653687,
0.4371253550052643,
0.5592309236526489,
-0.23690776526927948,
0.12558817863464355,
-0.053556304425001144,
0.8710824847221375,
-0.23101171851158142,
-0.025542002171278,
0.27694156765937805,
-0.6473952531814575,
-0.93708336353302,
-0.15518207848072052,
0.6984144449234009,
0.4867735803127289,
-0.7700520157814026,
0.2576799988746643,
-0.2316139191389084,
-0.4908549189567566,
-0.8077895045280457,
0.40395280718803406,
0.40677088499069214,
0.18684937059879303,
0.22433388233184814,
-0.5877174735069275,
-0.1805945485830307,
-1.1418460607528687,
-0.20224221050739288,
-0.2504240572452545,
0.04383085295557976,
0.423319548368454,
0.40512165427207947,
-0.3643571436405182,
0.5237712264060974,
-0.17808210849761963,
-0.3527350127696991,
-0.5023186206817627,
0.43890294432640076,
0.3653757870197296,
0.25894907116889954,
0.8493345975875854,
-0.44988444447517395,
-0.5467466115951538,
0.24391768872737885,
-0.549019455909729,
-0.5662381052970886,
0.3495399057865143,
-0.319049209356308,
0.3485279083251953,
0.26256465911865234,
-0.2946383059024811,
0.3144840598106384,
0.9035623669624329,
-0.10296183079481125,
0.35524025559425354,
-0.11402318626642227,
0.2412843406200409,
-0.8717320561408997,
0.20156370103359222,
-0.1773000955581665,
-0.16760462522506714,
-0.23881250619888306,
0.14369884133338928,
0.12604385614395142,
-0.26210999488830566,
-0.054357752203941345,
0.8234822750091553,
-0.5650326013565063,
-0.39076927304267883,
-0.40538015961647034,
0.31338825821876526,
-0.1382037103176117,
0.34417834877967834,
-0.2967737019062042,
0.9735988974571228,
0.11530135571956635,
-0.4054357409477234,
0.40511900186538696,
0.5149859189987183,
-0.867729127407074,
0.31173133850097656,
-0.2179965078830719,
0.1171761006116867,
0.2573103904724121,
-0.05682862922549248,
-0.8068212866783142,
-0.2725132703781128,
0.11418773978948593,
-0.3123399615287781,
0.21948571503162384,
-0.23874375224113464,
-0.6478235721588135,
-0.3245369493961334,
0.1636926233768463,
0.537452757358551,
0.40812569856643677,
-0.39064863324165344,
0.6822186708450317,
0.2796488106250763,
-0.5033840537071228,
-0.663676381111145,
-0.9529473185539246,
0.36957255005836487,
0.17883466184139252,
-0.5271444320678711,
-0.0854506716132164,
0.26977860927581787,
-0.34317371249198914,
0.019623810425400734,
-0.22037795186042786,
-0.3721265494823456,
0.47317221760749817,
-0.0131868040189147,
0.0010321243898943067,
-0.2671838700771332,
0.11499587446451187,
-0.08912263065576553,
-0.23710300028324127,
-0.19708901643753052,
-0.2436584085226059,
0.711807370185852,
-0.12493512779474258,
-0.25333693623542786,
-0.1407471001148224,
0.21482062339782715,
0.5408692359924316,
-0.5348515510559082,
0.9109694957733154,
0.273628294467926,
-0.14998570084571838,
-0.40340927243232727,
-0.6557202339172363,
0.060606155544519424,
-0.37827134132385254,
0.29155173897743225,
-0.4390498697757721,
-0.47112545371055603,
0.6070212125778198,
-0.06982918083667755,
-0.03186529874801636,
0.22061847150325775,
0.35609638690948486,
0.2118997722864151,
0.8225001096725464,
0.6019718050956726,
-0.5191660523414612,
0.5444642305374146,
-0.2820735573768616,
0.2246643751859665,
-0.6403687000274658,
0.07408551126718521,
-0.7406884431838989,
-0.6406694650650024,
-0.7522116899490356,
-0.4363175332546234,
0.2187165468931198,
0.12667490541934967,
0.037992555648088455,
0.4983346164226532,
0.07457747310400009,
0.38941118121147156,
0.5363193154335022,
-0.04675024747848511,
0.383137583732605,
0.13333415985107422,
-0.26789945363998413,
-0.08272510021924973,
-0.6899376511573792,
-0.662485659122467,
1.0823472738265991,
-0.13661202788352966,
0.7639729976654053,
0.24461020529270172,
0.5633895993232727,
0.23080360889434814,
0.6213681101799011,
-0.8401703238487244,
0.5950500965118408,
-0.36658528447151184,
-0.6462447643280029,
-0.05200427025556564,
-0.5997192859649658,
-0.6460654735565186,
0.48572564125061035,
-0.03262461721897125,
-0.5407847762107849,
0.15239980816841125,
-0.04311812296509743,
-0.010407262481749058,
0.2518634796142578,
-0.5179610252380371,
0.9827832579612732,
-0.5423620343208313,
-0.48888829350471497,
-0.275432288646698,
-0.2902713418006897,
0.21144573390483856,
-0.18970352411270142,
0.3090365529060364,
-0.5980913639068604,
-0.06753028184175491,
0.46941545605659485,
-0.507677435874939,
0.4487494230270386,
-0.05394519865512848,
-0.0672324076294899,
0.21535709500312805,
0.390574187040329,
0.32963988184928894,
-0.1841307431459427,
-0.5302254557609558,
0.4593745768070221,
-0.4059559106826782,
-0.5757114291191101,
-0.4087243974208832,
0.6229746341705322,
-0.776448667049408,
-0.35362449288368225,
-0.6016859412193298,
-0.5841604471206665,
-0.5701779723167419,
0.3698616325855255,
0.3959909975528717,
0.4609137177467346,
-0.28321027755737305,
0.2776632010936737,
0.2407549023628235,
-0.2920694947242737,
0.0534769669175148,
0.8674528002738953,
-0.09931755065917969,
-0.40240511298179626,
0.7029017806053162,
0.17975173890590668,
0.43561866879463196,
0.137429878115654,
-0.1659313291311264,
-0.035012003034353256,
-0.674694836139679,
-0.5287129282951355,
0.3254553973674774,
-0.6353617906570435,
-0.3936183750629425,
-0.5001369714736938,
0.038917284458875656,
-0.13696424663066864,
-0.12841302156448364,
-0.3691094219684601,
-0.4908031225204468,
0.015021868981420994,
-0.025720741599798203,
0.3026100695133209,
0.2868503928184509,
-0.07631652802228928,
0.2822466194629669,
-0.6852015852928162,
0.505028247833252,
0.19313554465770721,
0.6537006497383118,
-0.04554213210940361,
-0.5069364905357361,
-0.21265344321727753,
0.07213146239519119,
-0.3782171308994293,
-0.5561727285385132,
0.46253475546836853,
0.3149058222770691,
0.5945789813995361,
0.30547961592674255,
0.05345354601740837,
0.5424746870994568,
-0.550011396408081,
0.35792478919029236,
0.006917075254023075,
-0.8722333908081055,
0.2888357639312744,
-0.05693413317203522,
0.41101497411727905,
1.071428656578064,
0.1922098994255066,
-1.0039606094360352,
-0.2596154808998108,
-0.23351480066776276,
-0.7153802514076233,
0.9399634599685669,
0.32621338963508606,
-0.09504376351833344,
-0.035490505397319794,
0.2605000436306,
0.16601411998271942,
0.37977468967437744,
-0.7128475308418274,
-0.19896569848060608,
-0.003248262219130993,
-0.22560352087020874,
-0.39991408586502075,
-0.2014678567647934,
0.10559264570474625,
0.04681660607457161,
0.8063637018203735,
-0.4396302103996277,
0.07610855251550674,
-0.2517028748989105,
-0.5136860013008118,
-0.29562968015670776,
0.47455212473869324,
0.04043056443333626,
0.5422230362892151,
-0.18468350172042847,
-0.07256550341844559,
0.02992241643369198,
-0.3364158272743225,
0.4865912199020386,
0.44119882583618164,
-0.36685845255851746,
-0.08138734847307205,
0.44198817014694214,
0.7555829882621765,
0.320096880197525,
-0.7561477422714233,
0.2573981285095215,
-0.10404336452484131,
0.14512835443019867,
-0.08732461929321289,
0.06856518238782883,
-0.09653396159410477,
0.05760588496923447,
0.09737250208854675,
-0.038919538259506226,
0.055006057024002075,
-0.8301984071731567,
-0.027022065594792366,
0.31790974736213684,
-0.37224528193473816,
-0.16322924196720123,
0.44855713844299316,
0.5708691477775574,
0.010419709607958794,
0.8207363486289978,
-0.07703855633735657,
-0.5733710527420044,
0.5168867111206055,
0.17896831035614014,
0.9633975028991699,
-0.3894089460372925,
0.3784762918949127,
0.2578982710838318,
0.5803613662719727,
-0.24640582501888275,
0.5257881879806519,
-0.17984938621520996,
-0.7351990938186646,
-0.34891363978385925,
-0.6903782486915588,
-0.5526039600372314,
0.09560155868530273,
-0.8221653699874878,
0.10134096443653107,
-0.30691736936569214,
-0.18947304785251617,
-0.034925878047943115,
0.3267742991447449,
-0.5202870965003967,
-0.08976858109235764,
0.02572823129594326,
1.1814813613891602,
-0.7637717723846436,
0.8501696586608887,
0.5470535755157471,
-0.3213840126991272,
-0.21984834969043732,
-0.04022252559661865,
0.0325588621199131,
-0.745262086391449,
0.6172337532043457,
0.29370221495628357,
-0.17650921642780304,
-0.08901683986186981,
-0.30935055017471313,
-0.6157983541488647,
0.7233397960662842,
0.7053926587104797,
-0.5755744576454163,
0.20994004607200623,
0.1980551779270172,
0.5189103484153748,
-0.07555460929870605,
0.18124912679195404,
0.6796461343765259,
0.5953769087791443,
-0.324235200881958,
-0.8475664258003235,
-0.25731781125068665,
-0.3376349210739136,
0.08142004907131195,
0.6956999897956848,
-0.7528050541877747,
0.7740002870559692,
-0.12077755481004715,
-0.31869128346443176,
0.5589599609375,
0.6029850244522095,
0.00310761877335608,
-0.12827759981155396,
0.24917790293693542,
0.5188345313072205,
0.5861556529998779,
-0.3718944191932678,
1.3420556783676147,
-0.4148896634578705,
0.15986742079257965,
1.0713526010513306,
-0.6764242053031921,
0.8186818957328796,
0.20473945140838623,
-0.20770424604415894,
0.6138274073600769,
0.25544649362564087,
0.15386031568050385,
0.4594007730484009,
0.15389035642147064,
-0.37084099650382996,
-0.5637362003326416,
-0.32888364791870117,
-0.31659427285194397,
0.5735270977020264,
0.2012348771095276,
-0.03145654499530792,
-0.4019327163696289,
0.04019808769226074,
-0.03578735142946243,
0.18780019879341125,
-0.11831958591938019,
0.6285468339920044,
0.2395661324262619,
-0.5992626547813416,
0.6121187210083008,
0.2110971063375473,
0.5388103723526001,
-0.9805995225906372,
0.05947493761777878,
-0.5009787678718567,
0.3774750232696533,
0.2248360961675644,
-0.6060150861740112,
-0.2719310522079468,
0.22156845033168793,
-0.02855513244867325,
-0.053220897912979126,
0.4330328702926636,
-0.4226163327693939,
-0.4608989357948303,
0.5927878022193909,
0.4174380898475647,
-0.01324499025940895,
-0.0018356235232204199,
-0.5708165168762207,
0.08126194030046463,
-0.026883944869041443,
-0.067779041826725,
0.3332923650741577,
0.6208367943763733,
-0.28709232807159424,
0.9475842714309692,
0.27734795212745667,
0.36577484011650085,
-0.18223349750041962,
0.12732519209384918,
0.5468973517417908,
-0.6869879364967346,
-0.6354416608810425,
-0.4471834599971771,
-0.26442599296569824,
0.003066804027184844,
-0.46221837401390076,
0.8690106868743896,
0.4754773676395416,
0.8908458352088928,
0.0818965956568718,
0.9151419997215271,
-0.11920013278722763,
0.41554081439971924,
-0.3714095652103424,
0.7651311755180359,
-0.5571889281272888,
-0.19852513074874878,
-0.27510809898376465,
-1.078045129776001,
0.045402269810438156,
0.7307375073432922,
-0.28282687067985535,
0.16057442128658295,
0.5388590097427368,
0.3008802533149719,
-0.08004794269800186,
-0.14181816577911377,
0.3086027204990387,
0.4138266444206238,
0.304939329624176,
0.6362408995628357,
0.6606765389442444,
-0.5861572623252869,
0.6751458048820496,
-0.45674991607666016,
-0.1578490436077118,
-0.5228787064552307,
-0.8259555697441101,
-0.7179581522941589,
-0.2843623757362366,
-0.1685062199831009,
-0.20512723922729492,
-0.0784958228468895,
0.8521121740341187,
0.4976712465286255,
-1.114387035369873,
-0.6379925012588501,
0.07825280725955963,
-0.08236202597618103,
-0.4459019601345062,
-0.16389410197734833,
-0.12805631756782532,
-0.1641828715801239,
-0.6318207383155823,
0.35608625411987305,
0.27380698919296265,
0.1254086196422577,
-0.21107764542102814,
-0.07144125550985336,
-0.3771741986274719,
-0.06994399428367615,
0.5383750200271606,
0.639803946018219,
-0.5821737051010132,
-0.08611400425434113,
-0.35873639583587646,
-0.2047681212425232,
0.012993048876523972,
0.7179808616638184,
-0.8535067439079285,
0.6236762404441833,
0.42542925477027893,
0.6679838299751282,
0.616683304309845,
-0.2690403461456299,
0.8764353394508362,
-0.551479697227478,
0.5242693424224854,
0.32356753945350647,
0.6084566116333008,
0.41847339272499084,
0.2680107653141022,
0.8249572515487671,
-0.0038870032876729965,
-0.24039213359355927,
-0.84873366355896,
0.21359474956989288,
-0.4723436236381531,
-0.1639743149280548,
0.8917151093482971,
-0.12190031260251999,
-0.2292989194393158,
-0.03389321640133858,
-0.013924892991781235,
0.13557371497154236,
-0.3871830403804779,
0.8773630261421204,
1.0655115842819214,
0.2756170332431793,
-0.13254760205745697,
-0.9041638970375061,
0.1961343139410019,
0.4976131319999695,
-1.1433378458023071,
0.16424627602100372,
0.6225572824478149,
0.1775355190038681,
0.1772291362285614,
0.31605130434036255,
-0.1362161487340927,
0.5167198181152344,
-0.21035665273666382,
0.4142182171344757,
-0.04809708148241043,
-0.3175399899482727,
-0.36723241209983826,
-0.12994429469108582,
0.22877129912376404,
0.008765526115894318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03363v1
|
LLM-based Rewriting of Inappropriate Argumentation using Reinforcement Learning from Machine Feedback
| 2024-06-05T15:18:08 | 2024-06-05T15:18:08 |
Timon Ziegenbein, Gabriella Skitalinskaya, Alireza Bayat Makou, Henning Wachsmuth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ensuring that online discussions are civil and productive is a major
challenge for social media platforms. Such platforms usually rely both on users
and on automated detection tools to flag inappropriate arguments of other
users, which moderators then review. However, this kind of post-hoc moderation
is expensive and time-consuming, and moderators are often overwhelmed by the
amount and severity of flagged content. Instead, a promising alternative is to
prevent negative behavior during content creation. This paper studies how
inappropriate language in arguments can be computationally mitigated. We
propose a reinforcement learning-based rewriting approach that balances content
preservation and appropriateness based on existing classifiers, prompting an
instruction-finetuned large language model (LLM) as our initial policy. Unlike
related style transfer tasks, rewriting inappropriate arguments allows deleting
and adding content permanently. It is therefore tackled on document level
rather than sentence level. We evaluate different weighting schemes for the
reward function in both absolute and relative human assessment studies.
Systematic experiments on non-parallel data provide evidence that our approach
can mitigate the inappropriateness of arguments while largely preserving their
content. It significantly outperforms competitive baselines, including few-shot
learning, prompting, and humans.
|
[
-0.3685733377933502,
-1.2626029253005981,
0.34272435307502747,
0.11203564703464508,
-0.5242982506752014,
0.06678876280784607,
-0.31371036171913147,
-0.03640912473201752,
0.2271304875612259,
0.5428001284599304,
-0.6506487727165222,
-0.26346221566200256,
-0.5767484307289124,
0.15605944395065308,
-0.24518941342830658,
1.3765596151351929,
-0.39334630966186523,
-0.12707871198654175,
-0.33276963233947754,
-0.21068546175956726,
-0.4137818217277527,
-0.4081824719905853,
-1.0950802564620972,
-0.3678753077983856,
0.9409037232398987,
0.5762262344360352,
0.48775678873062134,
0.6491708755493164,
0.08244513720273972,
0.3790050745010376,
0.03512865677475929,
0.40129953622817993,
-0.8744887113571167,
0.3791104555130005,
-0.38939332962036133,
-0.23117269575595856,
-0.2458077371120453,
-0.11729370057582855,
0.5657892227172852,
0.036370594054460526,
-0.3508263826370239,
-0.13563784956932068,
0.06160292401909828,
0.6867432594299316,
-0.5654438734054565,
-0.1123323068022728,
-0.8907416462898254,
0.04675484448671341,
0.14822401106357574,
-0.6027109026908875,
-0.4932585656642914,
-0.5097537636756897,
-0.05124369636178017,
-0.7004156708717346,
-0.08080928772687912,
-0.11686541885137558,
0.8563838601112366,
0.2528012990951538,
-0.2576521635055542,
-0.40328261256217957,
-0.6464812755584717,
0.8160803914070129,
-0.5931273698806763,
0.03310447931289673,
0.44749245047569275,
0.14164483547210693,
-0.30083462595939636,
-0.4952489137649536,
-0.6203709244728088,
-0.1793762594461441,
0.221025750041008,
0.11618664860725403,
-0.40659448504447937,
-0.01978561282157898,
0.07379378378391266,
-0.11686349660158157,
-0.29473474621772766,
0.364285945892334,
-0.4614265263080597,
-0.31124892830848694,
0.8118394613265991,
0.14678595960140228,
0.12131623178720474,
-0.3108848035335541,
-0.31269702315330505,
0.06299199908971786,
-0.6442597508430481,
0.05646907910704613,
0.5777931809425354,
0.2665882110595703,
0.19462598860263824,
0.5571185350418091,
-0.11866186559200287,
0.19180136919021606,
0.4150015413761139,
0.1720525473356247,
-0.09161055833101273,
-0.02619372308254242,
-0.11923732608556747,
0.17964813113212585,
0.7546541690826416,
0.6837148666381836,
0.4704340994358063,
0.03055010363459587,
-0.12549860775470734,
0.35989081859588623,
0.7214542627334595,
-0.7466418147087097,
0.026142077520489693,
0.1526203751564026,
-0.40334776043891907,
-0.6366147994995117,
-0.24349527060985565,
-0.6181560754776001,
-0.6968809962272644,
-0.43912646174430847,
0.32279637455940247,
-0.28086772561073303,
-0.07881664484739304,
0.05995460972189903,
0.0330134853720665,
0.14937420189380646,
0.4259853959083557,
-0.7213848829269409,
0.43577781319618225,
0.8006036281585693,
0.4857686460018158,
-0.18146249651908875,
-0.2715747058391571,
-0.838850200176239,
0.13147398829460144,
-0.5379645228385925,
0.8410263657569885,
-0.49636298418045044,
-0.26488637924194336,
0.25019389390945435,
0.18258319795131683,
0.3110949397087097,
-0.46498507261276245,
0.9516084790229797,
-0.6999104022979736,
0.2859688997268677,
-0.25258713960647583,
-0.6356846690177917,
-0.0547342449426651,
0.5385034084320068,
-0.403329461812973,
0.6171650290489197,
-0.03750702366232872,
-0.6361224055290222,
0.5098027586936951,
-0.4229762852191925,
-0.6226339340209961,
-0.02443605102598667,
-0.14820419251918793,
-0.8635455369949341,
-0.0940149649977684,
0.16522367298603058,
0.3327071964740753,
0.09432002156972885,
0.3813318610191345,
-0.42228859663009644,
-0.45943111181259155,
0.337382435798645,
-0.43272650241851807,
0.23812136054039001,
0.19727663695812225,
-0.43131816387176514,
0.7069082260131836,
-0.2804340720176697,
-0.062346529215574265,
0.2572207748889923,
-0.5015913248062134,
-0.2725553810596466,
0.27566033601760864,
-0.2027369737625122,
0.46983325481414795,
-0.12287573516368866,
-0.5676536560058594,
0.07133948802947998,
-0.3612716495990753,
0.7305623888969421,
1.1530303955078125,
0.19860965013504028,
0.35558661818504333,
-0.8100404739379883,
0.49837252497673035,
-0.1639765053987503,
-0.033216867595911026,
0.1689702272415161,
-0.15331600606441498,
-0.6997153759002686,
-0.021629182621836662,
-0.11335712671279907,
0.5086293816566467,
-0.8525152802467346,
0.1266816109418869,
-0.10710249841213226,
-0.3899313807487488,
-0.4677729308605194,
0.23737044632434845,
0.448115736246109,
0.26477089524269104,
0.2914813458919525,
-0.08392611145973206,
-0.6386778354644775,
-0.762822151184082,
-0.32381612062454224,
-0.3164674639701843,
0.14889419078826904,
0.5461363792419434,
0.15661855041980743,
-0.23953944444656372,
0.5540614128112793,
-0.15876595675945282,
-0.11148283630609512,
-0.3502502143383026,
0.3918693959712982,
-0.3163869082927704,
0.4180378317832947,
0.08258381485939026,
-0.6111932992935181,
-0.37536758184432983,
-0.1806255429983139,
-0.46310582756996155,
-0.3733084499835968,
-0.5297226309776306,
-0.3308570384979248,
0.6670110821723938,
0.649467408657074,
-0.41933348774909973,
0.2849328815937042,
0.19066686928272247,
-0.26084569096565247,
0.5137853622436523,
-0.17074549198150635,
0.2088257223367691,
-0.9175093173980713,
-0.22851702570915222,
0.144592747092247,
-0.47152984142303467,
-0.32599443197250366,
-0.18179768323898315,
-0.2812885046005249,
0.12335474044084549,
-0.5619428157806396,
0.4216539263725281,
0.07518031448125839,
0.41713419556617737,
-0.6500235199928284,
0.338080495595932,
0.08893757313489914,
0.6611629724502563,
0.08997788280248642,
0.21662497520446777,
-0.06032422184944153,
-0.5413588285446167,
0.35626277327537537,
0.11420990526676178,
-0.007658577524125576,
0.7966132760047913,
-0.6454224586486816,
0.16299861669540405,
-0.3061602711677551,
0.6447800993919373,
-0.8410908579826355,
0.00363161345012486,
0.5041612982749939,
-0.4079904556274414,
0.049793876707553864,
-0.2169090211391449,
-0.1438399851322174,
-0.15103879570960999,
-0.7846826910972595,
0.12769977748394012,
0.23012565076351166,
-0.2962716519832611,
0.3536224663257599,
0.4021279215812683,
-0.4444567561149597,
-0.5775395035743713,
-0.2919689416885376,
0.13918021321296692,
-0.5436827540397644,
-0.3991253674030304,
0.5882601737976074,
-0.06724411249160767,
-0.16862444579601288,
0.18647603690624237,
0.07701266556978226,
-0.06037566810846329,
0.11079545319080353,
0.25129640102386475,
0.150096133351326,
-0.01270290557295084,
0.22512607276439667,
0.1489885002374649,
0.043674033135175705,
0.3135581910610199,
-0.12744992971420288,
0.5738491415977478,
-0.10961635410785675,
-0.2056661695241928,
-0.6227742433547974,
0.4108509421348572,
0.517021894454956,
0.1252729445695877,
0.47334104776382446,
0.6816118359565735,
-0.3900313079357147,
-0.4249374270439148,
-0.42776206135749817,
-0.3036532402038574,
-0.48021405935287476,
0.5744447708129883,
-0.029347898438572884,
-1.112367033958435,
0.2524808943271637,
0.014993430115282536,
0.4838724732398987,
0.39752933382987976,
0.8188589215278625,
-0.21455860137939453,
0.9497319459915161,
0.3030438721179962,
0.02153274230659008,
0.7872417569160461,
0.05856524407863617,
0.1406407654285431,
-0.45014700293540955,
0.029288971796631813,
-0.31100910902023315,
-0.48771044611930847,
-0.6954960823059082,
-0.3231516182422638,
-0.23239171504974365,
0.0187737587839365,
-0.5746708512306213,
0.11626309156417847,
-0.31921571493148804,
0.6248737573623657,
0.2801748812198639,
0.20168285071849823,
0.10497961193323135,
0.08022134751081467,
0.04108718782663345,
-0.2864137887954712,
-0.659371554851532,
-0.5888535380363464,
0.9264335632324219,
0.46568548679351807,
0.6939647793769836,
0.12678122520446777,
0.7446824908256531,
0.7200014591217041,
0.653065025806427,
-0.9948367476463318,
0.40863317251205444,
-0.1632494181394577,
-0.28952455520629883,
-0.5022875666618347,
-0.6988644003868103,
-0.9970235824584961,
0.2489880621433258,
-0.4688158631324768,
-0.546559751033783,
-0.10871536284685135,
0.3095722794532776,
-0.24801620841026306,
0.4214111864566803,
-0.41094887256622314,
0.849582850933075,
-0.32890942692756653,
-0.9414201378822327,
-0.4714162051677704,
-0.30122217535972595,
0.2825746536254883,
0.017829738557338715,
0.25151872634887695,
0.11353250592947006,
0.1939784288406372,
0.8680441975593567,
-0.2889849841594696,
0.798792839050293,
-0.24248351156711578,
-0.2260250300168991,
0.5209298133850098,
0.3551764190196991,
0.5498450994491577,
0.10814211517572403,
0.025480609387159348,
-0.31501179933547974,
-0.0034707135055214167,
-0.2290288805961609,
-0.6429411172866821,
0.6870472431182861,
-0.7047499418258667,
-0.6372195482254028,
-0.11513197422027588,
-0.32821664214134216,
-0.1284852921962738,
0.07783785462379456,
0.034444306045770645,
0.18366068601608276,
-0.29309457540512085,
0.36376094818115234,
0.5770217776298523,
-0.4927961230278015,
0.17700091004371643,
0.5120393633842468,
-0.15467685461044312,
-0.5203161835670471,
1.3447530269622803,
-0.05740998685359955,
0.15666601061820984,
0.042970288544893265,
0.6416888236999512,
-0.4742352068424225,
-0.3819262385368347,
-0.4600592851638794,
0.07057743519544601,
-0.641412079334259,
-0.2164728194475174,
-0.6034784317016602,
-0.11555138230323792,
-0.1258762627840042,
-0.5959620475769043,
-0.2760476768016815,
-0.3995705246925354,
-0.02054399810731411,
-0.15251818299293518,
0.0557408481836319,
0.5283780097961426,
-0.047531548887491226,
0.07552632689476013,
-0.6343616843223572,
0.1691463440656662,
0.24878573417663574,
0.4490928053855896,
0.09622230380773544,
-0.6518717408180237,
0.08206517994403839,
-0.025556448847055435,
-0.6471512913703918,
-0.5515026450157166,
0.19119499623775482,
0.06849368661642075,
0.4774097502231598,
0.5334298014640808,
0.3465934991836548,
0.4974403977394104,
-0.5215933918952942,
0.5740124583244324,
0.11441343277692795,
-0.7542283535003662,
0.3360917568206787,
-0.4555269479751587,
-0.046918805688619614,
0.45848217606544495,
0.3429102599620819,
-0.9862774014472961,
-0.5293678045272827,
-0.6273823976516724,
-1.0571905374526978,
0.5904459953308105,
-0.02168448455631733,
0.3628499209880829,
-0.29464828968048096,
0.3539072573184967,
0.02588249370455742,
0.13161854445934296,
-0.9813360571861267,
0.27438345551490784,
-0.35319387912750244,
-0.060065288096666336,
0.24532823264598846,
-0.37581056356430054,
-0.4313141107559204,
-0.14452756941318512,
0.8635124564170837,
-0.04843498021364212,
0.08043808490037918,
0.020163480192422867,
-0.23416073620319366,
-0.4011303186416626,
0.5951095819473267,
0.9032690525054932,
0.25390198826789856,
0.01903737708926201,
-0.002991167828440666,
0.24669016897678375,
-0.05713985860347748,
0.19854320585727692,
-0.18269045650959015,
-0.028844742104411125,
-0.29859304428100586,
0.09909043461084366,
0.6166877150535583,
0.26954561471939087,
-0.6566797494888306,
0.43726739287376404,
-0.269115149974823,
-0.5805465579032898,
-0.23249360918998718,
-0.05746961385011673,
0.15206676721572876,
0.18125660717487335,
-0.23262706398963928,
-0.3336988091468811,
-0.15019039809703827,
-0.532530665397644,
0.4764932692050934,
0.37687766551971436,
-0.44925764203071594,
0.03101896122097969,
0.41103243827819824,
0.33419981598854065,
-0.40653643012046814,
0.48912084102630615,
-0.2354247123003006,
-0.66058748960495,
0.46334218978881836,
0.5998342037200928,
0.7459649443626404,
0.07162374258041382,
0.5234805941581726,
0.3875134587287903,
0.18786753714084625,
0.17506763339042664,
0.3168083727359772,
-0.015050736255943775,
-0.799160361289978,
-0.3729025721549988,
-0.524721086025238,
-0.5018227100372314,
0.24708907306194305,
-0.2455267757177353,
0.20803624391555786,
-0.8601688146591187,
0.016542494297027588,
0.05478353798389435,
0.0797242522239685,
-0.09864725172519684,
-0.09274755418300629,
0.19187955558300018,
0.37463146448135376,
-0.7987409830093384,
0.4388885498046875,
0.6811696887016296,
-0.3839169442653656,
-0.5272040963172913,
-0.08704797923564911,
0.20833462476730347,
-0.5156920552253723,
0.36425551772117615,
0.049430765211582184,
-0.48193836212158203,
-0.28796592354774475,
-0.714945375919342,
-0.34557342529296875,
0.5319311022758484,
0.3178148865699768,
-0.31386348605155945,
0.3261623680591583,
0.01759583316743374,
0.6733419895172119,
-0.15198829770088196,
-0.05951003357768059,
0.027271972969174385,
0.324199914932251,
0.10825002938508987,
-0.3944787085056305,
0.29605942964553833,
-0.2475646585226059,
-0.18023471534252167,
0.0217947568744421,
-0.4572920799255371,
0.6760088205337524,
-0.05858844891190529,
-0.2967380881309509,
-0.1132417544722557,
0.5538413524627686,
0.33760660886764526,
0.3931717872619629,
0.7013534307479858,
0.3698457181453705,
0.660660982131958,
0.15972550213336945,
0.7749653458595276,
-0.09543079137802124,
0.23224268853664398,
1.0165904760360718,
-0.35367724299430847,
0.9297129511833191,
0.4873289167881012,
0.10240491479635239,
0.7582675814628601,
0.7005878686904907,
0.02682562544941902,
0.1871098428964615,
0.9153987169265747,
-0.2574184238910675,
-0.33152100443840027,
-0.41822195053100586,
-0.05190732702612877,
0.33252984285354614,
0.2620585858821869,
-0.2743164896965027,
-0.16891853511333466,
-0.3549998104572296,
0.45072945952415466,
0.5493451356887817,
-0.34203657507896423,
1.0057108402252197,
-0.029262619093060493,
-1.0054504871368408,
0.6800696849822998,
0.4048369824886322,
0.8331241011619568,
-0.5111746788024902,
-0.11820612847805023,
-0.14934362471103668,
0.15097466111183167,
-0.34550049901008606,
-0.7864311337471008,
0.5464622378349304,
0.23457026481628418,
-0.1379225254058838,
-0.41585636138916016,
0.8288030624389648,
-0.47363710403442383,
-0.23984040319919586,
0.1891985982656479,
0.28319913148880005,
-0.07191085815429688,
0.10897429287433624,
-0.7597551345825195,
0.002741617616266012,
-0.23419933021068573,
-0.20284634828567505,
0.4100111424922943,
0.46792539954185486,
-0.5412895679473877,
0.615821123123169,
0.7560769319534302,
-0.10494773834943771,
-0.17425352334976196,
0.1778099685907364,
0.9392033219337463,
-0.39075350761413574,
-0.5589262247085571,
-1.0166159868240356,
0.2808811366558075,
-0.23285430669784546,
-0.08685877174139023,
0.4209862947463989,
0.2411462664604187,
0.8852658867835999,
0.2384004443883896,
0.6640472412109375,
0.18895383179187775,
0.23907256126403809,
-0.3303208649158478,
0.7383437156677246,
-0.5796893239021301,
0.005011475645005703,
-0.6974161863327026,
-0.5697493553161621,
-0.34064018726348877,
0.7376935482025146,
-0.35922732949256897,
-0.05606607347726822,
0.44036921858787537,
0.7810268402099609,
0.19627726078033447,
-0.015167340636253357,
0.1692134439945221,
0.06478027999401093,
0.5939676761627197,
0.5624470710754395,
1.1027876138687134,
0.12588800489902496,
0.789063572883606,
-0.04055733233690262,
-0.15663769841194153,
-0.3470931947231293,
-1.0051894187927246,
-0.6857323050498962,
-0.21237380802631378,
-0.383868932723999,
-0.7080258131027222,
0.24275973439216614,
1.2028446197509766,
0.4083119034767151,
-0.6687577366828918,
-0.2561138868331909,
-0.11379057914018631,
0.42279061675071716,
-0.3187856674194336,
-0.23635075986385345,
0.25391167402267456,
-0.34800660610198975,
-0.34106847643852234,
0.16098707914352417,
0.12672795355319977,
-0.43004369735717773,
-0.2015952318906784,
-0.48506101965904236,
-0.38006824254989624,
0.5019323825836182,
0.8016695380210876,
0.6101143956184387,
-0.7318576574325562,
-0.39330652356147766,
-0.2739482522010803,
-0.10117550194263458,
0.03858190402388573,
0.8644767999649048,
-0.445074200630188,
0.40344831347465515,
0.4311106204986572,
1.0625152587890625,
0.22045046091079712,
0.3039853274822235,
0.5903782844543457,
-0.6479823589324951,
-0.2399926483631134,
0.30066099762916565,
0.3308562934398651,
0.35321831703186035,
-0.2667205035686493,
-0.01138448528945446,
0.28040197491645813,
-0.6242274641990662,
-0.5958107709884644,
0.3239816725254059,
-0.7868107557296753,
-0.42563414573669434,
1.2267711162567139,
-0.2158501148223877,
0.010737131349742413,
0.023490041494369507,
-0.4720299541950226,
0.45528897643089294,
-0.582410991191864,
1.3817822933197021,
0.7663163542747498,
-0.055340658873319626,
-0.2566394805908203,
-0.3660533130168915,
0.6121575832366943,
0.6481238603591919,
-0.8354412913322449,
0.3911035358905792,
0.775751531124115,
0.340408056974411,
-0.28755030035972595,
0.7019019722938538,
-0.09300161153078079,
0.39508578181266785,
-0.29206913709640503,
-0.2684924900531769,
-0.07853607833385468,
-0.3424469530582428,
-0.369132399559021,
0.17446483671665192,
0.05735912173986435,
-0.021295398473739624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03339v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03339v2
|
The Challenges of Evaluating LLM Applications: An Analysis of Automated, Human, and LLM-Based Approaches
| 2024-06-05T14:55:10 | 2024-06-13T15:13:40 |
Bhashithe Abeysinghe, Ruhan Circi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Chatbots have been an interesting application of natural language generation
since its inception. With novel transformer based Generative AI methods,
building chatbots have become trivial. Chatbots which are targeted at specific
domains for example medicine and psychology are implemented rapidly. This
however, should not distract from the need to evaluate the chatbot responses.
Especially because the natural language generation community does not entirely
agree upon how to effectively evaluate such applications. With this work we
discuss the issue further with the increasingly popular LLM based evaluations
and how they correlate with human evaluations. Additionally, we introduce a
comprehensive factored evaluation mechanism that can be utilized in conjunction
with both human and LLM-based evaluations. We present the results of an
experimental evaluation conducted using this scheme in one of our chatbot
implementations which consumed educational reports, and subsequently compare
automated, traditional human evaluation, factored human evaluation, and
factored LLM evaluation. Results show that factor based evaluation produces
better insights on which aspects need to be improved in LLM applications and
further strengthens the argument to use human evaluation in critical spaces
where main functionality is not direct retrieval.
|
[
-0.32685017585754395,
-0.949660062789917,
0.5594418048858643,
0.4547097682952881,
0.14304792881011963,
0.7230847477912903,
-0.35547304153442383,
-0.4220728576183319,
-0.1428752988576889,
0.3126783072948456,
-0.8087364435195923,
-0.31457504630088806,
-0.4642994999885559,
0.4419918656349182,
-0.32838547229766846,
0.5692246556282043,
0.13247503340244293,
0.1905936300754547,
-0.7892694473266602,
0.03814968466758728,
-0.681506335735321,
-0.770573079586029,
-0.8443370461463928,
-0.9432459473609924,
0.15268103778362274,
0.4934718608856201,
0.6698028445243835,
0.0820784717798233,
1.0025215148925781,
0.4602327346801758,
0.013804825022816658,
0.3220304548740387,
-0.497371643781662,
-0.00931516382843256,
0.005044314544647932,
-0.4419669806957245,
-0.30638206005096436,
0.11324706673622131,
0.2821010649204254,
0.7903392314910889,
-0.11378385126590729,
0.16052742302417755,
0.12234464287757874,
0.9647108912467957,
-0.3843836784362793,
0.055461738258600235,
-0.48980414867401123,
0.3129837214946747,
0.18593816459178925,
-0.5243546962738037,
-0.35383352637290955,
-0.4860713481903076,
0.46700119972229004,
-0.25429394841194153,
0.33592119812965393,
0.11782791465520859,
0.5460396409034729,
0.14217644929885864,
-0.3434545695781708,
-0.7787119746208191,
-0.9738751649856567,
0.906440258026123,
-0.38604286313056946,
0.21251417696475983,
0.24313586950302124,
0.48204514384269714,
-0.7378486394882202,
-0.3264598548412323,
-0.5447605848312378,
-0.5846501588821411,
-0.06336081773042679,
0.14245976507663727,
-0.44092628359794617,
0.09173084795475006,
-0.02735302597284317,
0.5602360963821411,
-0.4952164888381958,
0.3207968771457672,
-0.2996895909309387,
-0.40628036856651306,
0.890362560749054,
0.5181882381439209,
0.3510015308856964,
-0.4878706634044647,
-0.40065643191337585,
-0.03373514860868454,
-0.4978775382041931,
-0.15658725798130035,
0.48944738507270813,
0.18532301485538483,
-0.13884444534778595,
0.7924550175666809,
-0.18048714101314545,
0.3901190459728241,
0.09656482189893723,
-0.1772625595331192,
0.16475485265254974,
-0.47863608598709106,
-0.1864617019891739,
-0.4075702428817749,
1.043206810951233,
0.6227863430976868,
0.4716176986694336,
-0.23222222924232483,
-0.1702374666929245,
0.3121515214443207,
0.5687846541404724,
-0.48139169812202454,
0.09389574080705643,
0.45960697531700134,
-0.40055087208747864,
-0.6284074187278748,
-0.3373543918132782,
-0.7110987901687622,
-0.5865073800086975,
-0.30464282631874084,
0.45531147718429565,
-0.37299978733062744,
0.12478463351726532,
-0.002732260152697563,
-0.08967488259077072,
0.397175669670105,
0.42206552624702454,
-0.7777398824691772,
0.4273824095726013,
0.9512841701507568,
0.5726851224899292,
-0.49172404408454895,
0.05327959358692169,
-0.0783495157957077,
-0.5256353616714478,
-0.15386797487735748,
0.9822710156440735,
-0.519607424736023,
-0.8198692798614502,
0.1314397156238556,
-0.33095404505729675,
-0.07486043125391006,
-0.9859616160392761,
0.7900273203849792,
-0.3414625823497772,
0.5447279810905457,
0.15107294917106628,
-0.7124497294425964,
-0.07112836092710495,
0.26615065336227417,
-0.33762529492378235,
0.9617982506752014,
0.25384342670440674,
-0.4117170572280884,
0.3748781085014343,
-1.0166012048721313,
-0.5232115387916565,
0.3758927583694458,
-0.13095204532146454,
-0.41150641441345215,
0.15108805894851685,
0.21858598291873932,
0.43501853942871094,
-0.5970526337623596,
0.3098030388355255,
0.06925065070390701,
-0.4418957829475403,
0.6183479428291321,
-0.716118335723877,
0.8119117021560669,
0.13076850771903992,
-0.288524329662323,
0.517075777053833,
-0.6503886580467224,
0.02749646268785,
0.14559052884578705,
-0.5446798205375671,
0.14584185183048248,
0.23552782833576202,
0.04710566997528076,
-0.07523799687623978,
0.12524335086345673,
-0.3699268400669098,
-0.02882111817598343,
-0.4991237223148346,
0.4470730125904083,
0.6777324080467224,
0.1374141126871109,
0.46608278155326843,
-0.42486491799354553,
0.8596896529197693,
-0.3432352840900421,
0.35443010926246643,
-0.07525134831666946,
-0.43221935629844666,
-1.010515570640564,
-0.11042506992816925,
0.09141877293586731,
0.6734596490859985,
-0.8469436764717102,
0.7290146350860596,
-0.2232087403535843,
-0.7192217707633972,
-0.6668664813041687,
0.4678819477558136,
0.4037627875804901,
0.5008604526519775,
0.12280246615409851,
-0.4991036355495453,
-0.5166295766830444,
-0.9701774716377258,
-0.16828666627407074,
-0.5247535705566406,
-0.3327380418777466,
0.5784974694252014,
0.35709384083747864,
-0.5545082092285156,
1.0114600658416748,
-0.35921505093574524,
-0.22229279577732086,
-0.5160189270973206,
0.11983664333820343,
0.055222008377313614,
0.21381264925003052,
0.30968019366264343,
-0.4819380044937134,
-0.2299279272556305,
-0.16168315708637238,
-0.7621376514434814,
-0.24038466811180115,
-0.29945024847984314,
-0.04670773819088936,
0.2119654268026352,
0.16673079133033752,
-0.5804020762443542,
0.3560539484024048,
0.4167504906654358,
-0.28464385867118835,
0.5263867378234863,
-0.16028322279453278,
0.16868585348129272,
-0.5627493858337402,
-0.0890720933675766,
0.10732202231884003,
-0.30492082238197327,
-0.6691244840621948,
0.09153473377227783,
-0.24898815155029297,
-0.27392739057540894,
-0.46726053953170776,
0.5007286667823792,
-0.19656001031398773,
-0.039440590888261795,
-0.4127245545387268,
0.5536101460456848,
-0.08932404965162277,
0.34215936064720154,
-0.3046422302722931,
0.7291170954704285,
0.2893058955669403,
-0.469045490026474,
0.49244266748428345,
0.17400573194026947,
-0.41590455174446106,
0.6629567742347717,
-0.7971396446228027,
0.5019826292991638,
0.07064402103424072,
0.16434912383556366,
-0.8822233080863953,
-0.12628749012947083,
0.44749897718429565,
-0.5570584535598755,
0.1693602353334427,
0.4415554702281952,
-0.5262194871902466,
-0.7135326862335205,
-0.6175012588500977,
-0.11055395007133484,
0.4965952932834625,
-0.3023645877838135,
0.48387834429740906,
0.30201977491378784,
0.06563253700733185,
-0.23545625805854797,
-0.29134052991867065,
0.4429919123649597,
-0.31359851360321045,
-0.7812176942825317,
0.002773603657260537,
-0.28080034255981445,
-0.46961015462875366,
-0.16271689534187317,
-0.11749337613582611,
0.18389712274074554,
0.5479470491409302,
0.42455995082855225,
0.5123651027679443,
-0.09613394737243652,
-0.12330502271652222,
-0.2968190610408783,
-0.32534220814704895,
0.22468231618404388,
0.2991766929626465,
0.6397202014923096,
-0.29416215419769287,
-0.6859729290008545,
-0.4330903887748718,
0.09081171452999115,
0.3650054633617401,
0.19442258775234222,
0.3524525761604309,
0.5477486848831177,
-0.16434726119041443,
0.07610509544610977,
-0.7399293780326843,
-0.22912847995758057,
-0.5173175930976868,
0.44770658016204834,
0.1047007367014885,
-1.055558681488037,
0.15262864530086517,
-0.17285488545894623,
0.0065992893651127815,
0.4465342164039612,
1.00648832321167,
-0.3513686954975128,
0.6890321969985962,
0.6803174614906311,
0.03952907398343086,
0.3483336865901947,
-0.0911945328116417,
0.29909035563468933,
-0.8033642172813416,
-0.31495797634124756,
-0.3894788324832916,
-0.3596717119216919,
-0.5921521186828613,
-0.5379701256752014,
0.3461238145828247,
-0.04079363867640495,
0.22262461483478546,
0.3026543855667114,
-0.4844464659690857,
0.2785930335521698,
0.41309863328933716,
0.08318708091974258,
0.48791730403900146,
-0.05486089363694191,
0.09103420376777649,
0.12287686765193939,
-0.7217004299163818,
-0.9139006733894348,
1.186921238899231,
0.5492101907730103,
0.5512109994888306,
0.06169077008962631,
0.6399490237236023,
0.6972843408584595,
0.8832942247390747,
-1.3118596076965332,
0.7763533592224121,
0.09342263638973236,
-0.5444008111953735,
-0.4416090250015259,
-0.41016802191734314,
-1.1344406604766846,
0.21227939426898956,
-0.44277095794677734,
-0.740591824054718,
-0.30595502257347107,
-0.2538606822490692,
-0.2567223906517029,
-0.281459778547287,
-1.0394200086593628,
0.560132622718811,
-0.4388604164123535,
-0.21819716691970825,
-0.4629993438720703,
-0.40204480290412903,
0.2919226586818695,
-0.2627851963043213,
0.13373759388923645,
-0.2647557258605957,
0.2289673238992691,
0.7081550359725952,
-0.4312865436077118,
0.792685866355896,
0.006658012978732586,
-0.14202621579170227,
0.5480042695999146,
-0.13863670825958252,
-0.14404726028442383,
-0.08125291019678116,
-0.2138015776872635,
0.09777919203042984,
-0.21037527918815613,
-0.21912933886051178,
-0.866397500038147,
0.4534536898136139,
-0.8051974773406982,
-1.0158761739730835,
-0.33224132657051086,
-0.4223403334617615,
-0.5221153497695923,
-0.0771172046661377,
-0.11126072704792023,
0.19899201393127441,
-0.5761959552764893,
0.1946987807750702,
-0.025620758533477783,
-0.6028860807418823,
0.44409358501434326,
0.6466748118400574,
-0.3699127435684204,
-0.3255491554737091,
0.7286586761474609,
-0.35285958647727966,
0.16452132165431976,
0.3158687353134155,
0.41080138087272644,
-0.25075051188468933,
-0.3750711679458618,
-0.5637567043304443,
0.017326246947050095,
-0.667514979839325,
-0.21154235303401947,
-0.2646558880805969,
-0.2900024652481079,
-0.009593835100531578,
-0.26788797974586487,
-0.14417003095149994,
-0.24050390720367432,
-0.1750345379114151,
-0.0024772370234131813,
0.21567648649215698,
0.814037561416626,
0.18476463854312897,
0.3134821057319641,
-0.7023035287857056,
0.3008791208267212,
0.2838777005672455,
0.230215921998024,
0.18322741985321045,
-0.22122758626937866,
-0.040640681982040405,
-0.02283884771168232,
-0.7602509260177612,
-0.5071929693222046,
0.09702610969543457,
0.20513522624969482,
0.7059522867202759,
0.2356775403022766,
-0.11758072674274445,
0.5672933459281921,
-0.38816359639167786,
0.7753109335899353,
0.16299428045749664,
-0.8039262890815735,
0.5330104827880859,
0.055914659053087234,
0.1579701155424118,
0.6417632699012756,
0.1921522170305252,
-0.403549462556839,
-0.429288774728775,
-0.43583670258522034,
-0.790518045425415,
0.5489080548286438,
0.6221571564674377,
0.5503535866737366,
-0.10601282864809036,
0.30043870210647583,
0.03322097659111023,
0.08955927193164825,
-0.4116005003452301,
-0.31975170969963074,
0.2716659903526306,
-0.1574876606464386,
0.0002598451392259449,
-0.2677823305130005,
-0.077394038438797,
-0.09650164097547531,
0.34642985463142395,
0.031904712319374084,
0.3798002004623413,
0.1543155312538147,
-0.15944026410579681,
-0.05013571307063103,
0.4469113051891327,
0.5449063181877136,
0.5919543504714966,
-0.21059371531009674,
-0.21733780205249786,
0.13353537023067474,
-0.5278565883636475,
0.23282085359096527,
-0.1422717124223709,
-0.05541455000638962,
-0.16440477967262268,
0.7492143511772156,
0.6596418023109436,
0.3291305899620056,
-0.934273898601532,
0.5475746989250183,
-0.24420501291751862,
-0.09367761015892029,
-0.17321522533893585,
0.29451385140419006,
0.18650363385677338,
0.27700772881507874,
0.5075437426567078,
0.04703138396143913,
0.1280340850353241,
-0.7958635687828064,
0.15953747928142548,
0.4965679347515106,
-0.5503376126289368,
-0.18279202282428741,
0.3307405412197113,
0.6485840082168579,
-1.0226631164550781,
0.6960110664367676,
-0.1222970187664032,
-0.6435084939002991,
0.6843740344047546,
0.45931267738342285,
1.2592518329620361,
0.005157319363206625,
0.29324257373809814,
0.009469744749367237,
0.27977287769317627,
0.44914352893829346,
0.31638190150260925,
-0.08303014934062958,
-0.8563358783721924,
-0.3671526610851288,
-0.6963743567466736,
-0.8958562016487122,
-0.08492030948400497,
-0.2783701419830322,
0.3262995481491089,
-0.39131850004196167,
-0.4218912124633789,
-0.06743473559617996,
0.17767685651779175,
-0.9015258550643921,
0.027002954855561256,
0.0641297772526741,
0.7223015427589417,
-0.45739853382110596,
0.3804684579372406,
0.6958165168762207,
-0.13189511001110077,
-0.3158162534236908,
0.021774722263216972,
0.1577410250902176,
-0.9736778736114502,
0.6504637002944946,
0.061361223459243774,
-0.29406097531318665,
-0.3719175457954407,
-0.2510755658149719,
-0.3411949574947357,
1.010068416595459,
0.15828995406627655,
-0.5249304175376892,
0.24117730557918549,
0.48299047350883484,
1.1070462465286255,
-0.3324388563632965,
0.4918820559978485,
0.6729795336723328,
0.427663117647171,
0.0466487854719162,
-0.9686135053634644,
-0.10809491574764252,
-0.22680826485157013,
0.02784975804388523,
-0.15812993049621582,
-0.6088446378707886,
0.02835371531546116,
-0.24712802469730377,
-0.489022433757782,
0.07397715002298355,
0.5162497162818909,
0.2639561593532562,
0.49973955750465393,
0.4530329406261444,
0.09591193497180939,
0.7063652276992798,
0.04444734379649162,
1.210352897644043,
-0.4188545048236847,
0.34601882100105286,
0.8216894865036011,
-0.25342056155204773,
0.7905621528625488,
0.4439935088157654,
-0.7594667673110962,
0.26308774948120117,
0.47866278886795044,
-0.23884029686450958,
0.06793743371963501,
0.6377199292182922,
-0.33503249287605286,
0.01678781397640705,
-0.2046683132648468,
0.16731829941272736,
0.7742043733596802,
0.4036400318145752,
-0.08611472696065903,
-0.19709239900112152,
-0.17560701072216034,
-0.07786218822002411,
0.24985216557979584,
-0.06442049145698547,
0.7995442748069763,
0.22961950302124023,
-0.5576666593551636,
0.3663990795612335,
0.19197233021259308,
0.7573118209838867,
-0.2806108593940735,
0.0039392015896737576,
-0.18975864350795746,
-0.03408775106072426,
-0.4008029103279114,
-0.7337518930435181,
0.4812587797641754,
0.28080692887306213,
0.09888762980699539,
-0.20798809826374054,
1.0483137369155884,
0.04966648295521736,
-0.7126010656356812,
0.30184394121170044,
0.9340346455574036,
0.10956978797912598,
0.14799323678016663,
-0.6620404720306396,
0.10026556253433228,
-0.10479342937469482,
-0.25778520107269287,
0.1664915829896927,
0.2131550908088684,
-0.13516898453235626,
1.069777250289917,
0.7472424507141113,
-0.15669892728328705,
-0.2669537365436554,
0.3714553713798523,
0.690913736820221,
-0.6436600685119629,
0.15915390849113464,
-1.1693693399429321,
0.22421185672283173,
0.10760391503572464,
-0.2225474715232849,
0.8391635417938232,
0.5613394975662231,
0.3766000270843506,
0.004586908500641584,
0.6974883675575256,
-0.023165350779891014,
0.3622613549232483,
-0.3509833514690399,
0.6667854189872742,
-0.176656574010849,
0.6664603352546692,
-0.3112405240535736,
-1.0301001071929932,
-0.302374929189682,
0.4620170295238495,
-0.3312428295612335,
0.06981346756219864,
0.4870145618915558,
0.5736634731292725,
0.335725873708725,
0.1121676042675972,
0.3436353802680969,
-0.17447052896022797,
0.5190893411636353,
0.42306816577911377,
1.2471736669540405,
-0.35514456033706665,
0.3964749872684479,
-0.32094326615333557,
-0.29959750175476074,
-0.3812487721443176,
-0.9483243823051453,
-1.069197177886963,
-0.30221110582351685,
-0.39604315161705017,
-0.057550787925720215,
-0.14550042152404785,
1.1107269525527954,
0.3429272472858429,
-0.7104607224464417,
-0.5233228206634521,
0.11052077263593674,
0.3384779095649719,
0.16404888033866882,
-0.3606243431568146,
0.14697712659835815,
-0.39295488595962524,
-0.736354649066925,
0.6110544204711914,
0.5811934471130371,
-0.1924469769001007,
-0.7371651530265808,
-0.03518059477210045,
0.09435855597257614,
0.2337828278541565,
0.9681806564331055,
-0.05582389235496521,
-0.7468827366828918,
-0.6048349142074585,
0.10793503373861313,
-0.17315839231014252,
0.26694947481155396,
0.8119080066680908,
-0.941131055355072,
0.40378692746162415,
0.3144429922103882,
0.8004377484321594,
0.19748632609844208,
0.1467379480600357,
0.828845202922821,
-0.4234880805015564,
-0.1990429311990738,
0.2376563549041748,
0.008504478260874748,
0.7145909070968628,
-0.23012760281562805,
0.8973084092140198,
0.1889631599187851,
-0.5438598394393921,
-0.7232130169868469,
-0.021394291892647743,
-1.0165170431137085,
0.11442752182483673,
0.9977774024009705,
0.051429152488708496,
0.035813599824905396,
-0.2738760709762573,
-0.3741598427295685,
0.09171169251203537,
-0.2686058580875397,
1.026761531829834,
0.8481374979019165,
-0.7063234448432922,
0.16461679339408875,
-0.650273859500885,
0.24908313155174255,
0.39251405000686646,
-0.7647044658660889,
-0.20017585158348083,
0.28134337067604065,
0.08455051481723785,
0.33136674761772156,
0.6283655166625977,
-0.16559265553951263,
0.044189661741256714,
-0.1614491045475006,
0.04227856546640396,
0.10724416375160217,
0.08976820856332779,
-0.46311745047569275,
0.09219305962324142,
0.22138457000255585,
0.03452092036604881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03299v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03299v1
|
The Good, the Bad, and the Hulk-like GPT: Analyzing Emotional Decisions of Large Language Models in Cooperation and Bargaining Games
| 2024-06-05T14:08:54 | 2024-06-05T14:08:54 |
Mikhail Mozikov, Nikita Severin, Valeria Bodishtianu, Maria Glushanina, Mikhail Baklashkin, Andrey V. Savchenko, Ilya Makarov
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7; J.4
|
Behavior study experiments are an important part of society modeling and
understanding human interactions. In practice, many behavioral experiments
encounter challenges related to internal and external validity,
reproducibility, and social bias due to the complexity of social interactions
and cooperation in human user studies. Recent advances in Large Language Models
(LLMs) have provided researchers with a new promising tool for the simulation
of human behavior. However, existing LLM-based simulations operate under the
unproven hypothesis that LLM agents behave similarly to humans as well as
ignore a crucial factor in human decision-making: emotions.
In this paper, we introduce a novel methodology and the framework to study
both, the decision-making of LLMs and their alignment with human behavior under
emotional states. Experiments with GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 on four games from two
different classes of behavioral game theory showed that emotions profoundly
impact the performance of LLMs, leading to the development of more optimal
strategies. While there is a strong alignment between the behavioral responses
of GPT-3.5 and human participants, particularly evident in bargaining games,
GPT-4 exhibits consistent behavior, ignoring induced emotions for rationality
decisions. Surprisingly, emotional prompting, particularly with `anger'
emotion, can disrupt the "superhuman" alignment of GPT-4, resembling human
emotional responses.
|
[
-0.6256909370422363,
-0.9191352725028992,
0.6512438058853149,
0.08157183229923248,
-0.15887878835201263,
0.16684846580028534,
-0.21065421402454376,
-0.507282555103302,
0.330653578042984,
0.13397054374217987,
-0.4323757588863373,
-0.24645596742630005,
-0.5495651960372925,
0.3223665654659271,
0.1290738433599472,
1.356201410293579,
-0.09055076539516449,
0.27746930718421936,
0.13935638964176178,
-0.2337280511856079,
-0.3460330069065094,
-0.8558136820793152,
-0.9794014692306519,
-0.7655691504478455,
0.7439745664596558,
-0.05208699777722359,
1.022308588027954,
0.14348039031028748,
0.4826330542564392,
0.41670018434524536,
0.04904218763113022,
-0.23253865540027618,
-0.8353925347328186,
0.32402870059013367,
-0.4767586886882782,
-0.35129514336586,
-0.5351529717445374,
0.39902055263519287,
0.3120327293872833,
0.0692937895655632,
-0.19780702888965607,
-0.21915841102600098,
0.0441870279610157,
0.7646685838699341,
-0.28662610054016113,
0.442709356546402,
-0.32867705821990967,
0.2606779932975769,
-0.09952007234096527,
-0.1716294288635254,
-0.1012079268693924,
-0.3678814172744751,
0.03434332460165024,
-0.5740311741828918,
-0.038317903876304626,
0.05385235697031021,
0.8980788588523865,
0.25661778450012207,
-0.6318393349647522,
-0.5804498195648193,
-0.4827304780483246,
0.5668951272964478,
-0.4469103217124939,
0.12573553621768951,
0.3237135410308838,
0.10190561413764954,
-0.5185819268226624,
-0.23886889219284058,
-0.950596809387207,
-0.21449124813079834,
0.11368412524461746,
0.629306435585022,
-0.5625876784324646,
0.5276047587394714,
0.15624193847179413,
-0.07987891882658005,
-0.5989612936973572,
0.0998140424489975,
-0.19036662578582764,
0.04958294332027435,
0.6342997550964355,
0.23930545151233673,
0.5214819312095642,
-0.2572605311870575,
-0.2664079964160919,
-0.046031009405851364,
-0.6164111495018005,
-0.08482689410448074,
0.7498688101768494,
0.20997580885887146,
-0.06988723576068878,
0.8490289449691772,
0.09210719168186188,
0.19637393951416016,
0.36797523498535156,
0.16261431574821472,
0.02038007788360119,
-0.0013427912490442395,
-0.31108441948890686,
0.07468680292367935,
0.9654956459999084,
0.6508790850639343,
0.5581893920898438,
-0.13697724044322968,
-0.3575340211391449,
0.5708633065223694,
0.31653714179992676,
-0.45536795258522034,
-0.06107886880636215,
0.25061407685279846,
-0.442167729139328,
-0.3920092284679413,
-0.17769105732440948,
-0.9249816536903381,
-0.5189837217330933,
-0.40057358145713806,
0.5571427345275879,
-0.40367525815963745,
-0.38361895084381104,
0.1183554083108902,
-0.07918058335781097,
0.3496227562427521,
0.07228928059339523,
-0.8232179880142212,
0.37231990694999695,
0.9874670505523682,
0.7012547254562378,
-0.17754095792770386,
-0.5082871317863464,
-0.45128580927848816,
0.0437174029648304,
-0.451459139585495,
0.6742967367172241,
-0.6070930361747742,
-0.5848226547241211,
-0.04404483735561371,
-0.12682583928108215,
0.050261154770851135,
-0.4079529047012329,
0.6934916377067566,
-0.4519241154193878,
0.14689227938652039,
-0.5766414999961853,
-0.6962573528289795,
-0.12877123057842255,
0.7239413261413574,
-0.6254461407661438,
0.6544105410575867,
-0.050411902368068695,
-0.6906522512435913,
0.2213691920042038,
-0.874483048915863,
-0.4770579934120178,
-0.05740504339337349,
-0.25198835134506226,
-0.32765206694602966,
0.347647488117218,
-0.347755491733551,
0.3461105227470398,
-0.38984745740890503,
0.08109075576066971,
-0.5465724468231201,
-0.5737168788909912,
0.30526459217071533,
-0.05183769762516022,
0.6035320162773132,
0.2994866967201233,
-0.593776524066925,
0.16955530643463135,
-0.010469119995832443,
-0.21006415784358978,
0.3691065311431885,
-0.2685457170009613,
-0.18492834270000458,
0.09280382096767426,
-0.42087939381599426,
0.3970639407634735,
-0.050638094544410706,
-0.34221309423446655,
0.4878689646720886,
0.09560076147317886,
0.25408807396888733,
0.8848236203193665,
-0.05328051745891571,
0.43309229612350464,
-0.379280149936676,
0.7880271077156067,
-0.1304430216550827,
0.11078616231679916,
0.6224348545074463,
-0.4898473024368286,
-0.42954766750335693,
-0.056425534188747406,
-0.12352189421653748,
0.4289548695087433,
-0.9109494090080261,
-0.08158615231513977,
0.0296175554394722,
-0.37503939867019653,
-0.24390292167663574,
-0.48613569140434265,
0.40644529461860657,
0.29917576909065247,
0.00023563377908430994,
-0.234369158744812,
-0.5430757403373718,
-0.6172246932983398,
-0.638372540473938,
-0.5252898335456848,
0.1535511016845703,
0.2763958275318146,
0.4840855896472931,
-0.283441960811615,
0.7790234088897705,
-0.344994455575943,
-0.12187065184116364,
-0.20113253593444824,
0.5097694396972656,
0.16099804639816284,
0.27780598402023315,
0.49751660227775574,
-0.5796693563461304,
-0.35568761825561523,
0.02298157662153244,
-0.7001621723175049,
-0.027690576389431953,
-0.020948005840182304,
-0.22864966094493866,
0.5165367126464844,
0.21703842282295227,
-1.0758775472640991,
0.30552858114242554,
0.5943813323974609,
-0.6128131747245789,
1.1366206407546997,
-0.11770841479301453,
0.5520563721656799,
-0.6000640988349915,
-0.1434483379125595,
0.12719915807247162,
0.11585523933172226,
-0.6764057278633118,
0.17154701054096222,
-0.0936015397310257,
-0.09564629197120667,
-0.3755369782447815,
0.49032047390937805,
-0.4719333350658417,
-0.17166095972061157,
-0.15781117975711823,
0.11332102119922638,
-0.18255867063999176,
0.5238078236579895,
0.08171232044696808,
0.8973056674003601,
0.3149793744087219,
-0.43725284934043884,
0.31599703431129456,
0.2460416704416275,
-0.09796228259801865,
0.9947047829627991,
-0.6132235527038574,
0.3397364318370819,
-0.312022864818573,
0.42545944452285767,
-0.7284771203994751,
-0.26414066553115845,
0.3692626655101776,
-0.26964932680130005,
0.11866085231304169,
-0.19353121519088745,
-0.6261292695999146,
-0.4241733253002167,
-0.33595240116119385,
0.4540342390537262,
0.6787551641464233,
-0.15234223008155823,
0.7805956602096558,
0.5491984486579895,
-0.33122411370277405,
-0.3198949098587036,
-0.46436479687690735,
0.2698465585708618,
-0.5115319490432739,
-0.40474286675453186,
-0.009987237863242626,
-0.17140161991119385,
-0.5490462779998779,
-0.25524553656578064,
0.05102843418717384,
-0.013298338279128075,
-0.26652294397354126,
0.06510905921459198,
0.2576352059841156,
-0.0289065632969141,
-0.001886192592792213,
-0.3009795844554901,
-0.07142350822687149,
0.2642838954925537,
-0.0344567708671093,
0.4968612492084503,
-0.4895459711551666,
-0.2945786714553833,
-0.11493831872940063,
0.37158480286598206,
0.6636213660240173,
-0.06029190123081207,
0.3278360664844513,
0.4764045774936676,
-0.3133547902107239,
0.2894607186317444,
-0.3796345591545105,
-0.10374388098716736,
-0.487637996673584,
0.6427736282348633,
-0.4501863420009613,
-0.7042592763900757,
0.5498290657997131,
0.032481126487255096,
-0.21817506849765778,
0.14659447968006134,
0.7808109521865845,
-0.2704854905605316,
1.3680130243301392,
0.14546532928943634,
-0.23934781551361084,
0.33342447876930237,
0.16577890515327454,
0.3947746753692627,
-0.695727527141571,
-0.06799791008234024,
-0.4678799510002136,
-0.5943598747253418,
-0.7262193560600281,
-0.3951624929904938,
0.3583645820617676,
-0.2052721530199051,
-0.8230379819869995,
-0.019124452024698257,
-0.17390969395637512,
0.9076370000839233,
0.17446833848953247,
0.05393107980489731,
-0.0006446416955441236,
-0.3682123124599457,
-0.09506991505622864,
-0.18344692885875702,
-0.4016326665878296,
-0.3773069977760315,
0.6672875285148621,
0.279349148273468,
0.6581327319145203,
0.5062752962112427,
0.8121612071990967,
0.15358729660511017,
0.4613041281700134,
-0.805237352848053,
0.6057461500167847,
0.03991013765335083,
-0.7463889718055725,
-0.339708536863327,
-0.5929888486862183,
-1.2049355506896973,
0.26199913024902344,
-0.21013033390045166,
-0.9213870167732239,
-0.018896929919719696,
0.013135586865246296,
-0.13096152245998383,
0.44103920459747314,
-0.724301278591156,
0.7735907435417175,
-0.3634580373764038,
-0.5549564361572266,
-0.2480771541595459,
-0.5322109460830688,
0.4693982005119324,
0.03910983353853226,
0.38363945484161377,
-0.08845150470733643,
0.028351984918117523,
0.5554048418998718,
-0.05977160856127739,
0.7455688118934631,
-0.20885637402534485,
-0.33648020029067993,
0.25213757157325745,
0.6447727084159851,
1.080883264541626,
-0.2161191999912262,
-0.30983468890190125,
0.03624352067708969,
-0.34174463152885437,
-0.4735303521156311,
-0.5974891781806946,
0.7060692310333252,
-0.9364843964576721,
-0.6125576496124268,
-0.654981255531311,
-0.7143886089324951,
-0.31364575028419495,
0.18528734147548676,
0.19191305339336395,
-0.018545210361480713,
-0.4307781755924225,
-0.3548275828361511,
0.5145687460899353,
-0.34166574478149414,
0.1865478754043579,
0.45990514755249023,
-0.2534708082675934,
-0.16609933972358704,
1.079609990119934,
-0.054544564336538315,
0.15581680834293365,
-0.06874242424964905,
0.2699818015098572,
-0.39886796474456787,
-0.4459942579269409,
0.11212460696697235,
0.3417045474052429,
-0.5921797752380371,
-0.09289753437042236,
-0.2834368646144867,
0.32111912965774536,
-0.16632501780986786,
-0.325238972902298,
-0.31025153398513794,
0.11916613578796387,
-0.11697821319103241,
-0.33225587010383606,
-0.012369774281978607,
1.1714818477630615,
-0.2328985333442688,
-0.005601668730378151,
-0.5771057605743408,
0.20243754982948303,
0.3611781895160675,
0.5866004228591919,
0.05579371750354767,
-0.07987040281295776,
0.06530202925205231,
0.03724127262830734,
-0.4239601492881775,
-1.1320322751998901,
0.4017541706562042,
-0.20396320521831512,
0.2240736037492752,
0.40131697058677673,
0.12291157245635986,
0.6649134755134583,
-0.5158753395080566,
0.834993302822113,
0.45815417170524597,
-1.0022369623184204,
-0.14979597926139832,
-0.9828061461448669,
0.1359788477420807,
0.28368115425109863,
0.2732202708721161,
-0.6904456615447998,
-0.4496920704841614,
-0.6591545939445496,
-0.7219922542572021,
0.6489898562431335,
0.3393856883049011,
0.005918892100453377,
-0.3794456422328949,
0.24859702587127686,
0.010728927329182625,
0.09827370941638947,
-0.7615178823471069,
-0.1676349639892578,
-0.159361332654953,
-0.11023706942796707,
-0.1774454116821289,
-0.0828341543674469,
-0.16258132457733154,
0.008431224152445793,
0.6132891178131104,
0.09800165146589279,
0.443057119846344,
0.054317303001880646,
-0.0703384131193161,
-0.3805203139781952,
0.2912968397140503,
0.7025637626647949,
0.16238068044185638,
-0.13233688473701477,
0.21503780782222748,
0.24206668138504028,
-0.2342858612537384,
0.45755067467689514,
-0.09556563943624496,
0.3475561738014221,
-0.34427982568740845,
0.09013350307941437,
0.544293224811554,
0.3265480399131775,
-0.5633165836334229,
0.42609715461730957,
-0.19585292041301727,
-0.4454881250858307,
-0.06104423850774765,
-0.17100560665130615,
0.23158656060695648,
0.6852598190307617,
0.12650398910045624,
-0.10559174418449402,
0.2772669494152069,
-0.8183536529541016,
0.22350436449050903,
0.46568936109542847,
-0.4569588005542755,
-0.5254274010658264,
0.42009660601615906,
0.2825993001461029,
-0.4462145268917084,
0.6302317976951599,
-0.7620078921318054,
-0.924115002155304,
0.5936555862426758,
0.6093619465827942,
0.845923125743866,
-0.07911940664052963,
0.5227828621864319,
0.22937294840812683,
0.15009021759033203,
-0.13750377297401428,
0.3706461191177368,
0.4747687578201294,
-0.7298316359519958,
-0.44594666361808777,
-0.17639656364917755,
-0.5066908001899719,
0.07753226161003113,
-0.6402598023414612,
0.02671339549124241,
-0.2550589144229889,
-0.3355110287666321,
-0.3916633725166321,
0.2182721048593521,
-0.8578553199768066,
0.02914922684431076,
0.3861982822418213,
0.39479124546051025,
-0.633842945098877,
0.5140491724014282,
0.7787020802497864,
-0.35226377844810486,
-0.9923421740531921,
0.12966957688331604,
0.41831639409065247,
-0.8204922676086426,
0.5561086535453796,
-0.15919974446296692,
-0.12369731813669205,
-0.05685586482286453,
-0.5449584126472473,
-0.5605801343917847,
0.7148230671882629,
0.5638275146484375,
-0.5926068425178528,
-0.01949474774301052,
0.04076283797621727,
0.5693461298942566,
0.004304344300180674,
0.40936267375946045,
0.7467758059501648,
0.8668330311775208,
-0.060577936470508575,
-0.8114035725593567,
0.2270013689994812,
-0.1803554892539978,
-0.3634198307991028,
0.4463329613208771,
-0.9812889695167542,
0.9468129277229309,
-0.4194330871105194,
-0.24205611646175385,
-0.019702989608049393,
0.4014837443828583,
0.6356288194656372,
0.18215395510196686,
0.5716303586959839,
0.5318849682807922,
0.8064541220664978,
-0.18819767236709595,
1.2885462045669556,
-0.025724848732352257,
0.6949189901351929,
0.7867326736450195,
-0.6861547231674194,
0.5319887399673462,
0.5547058582305908,
-0.32561665773391724,
0.2236105501651764,
0.7033822536468506,
0.07471778988838196,
0.25167471170425415,
0.6312864422798157,
-0.158333882689476,
-0.11976436525583267,
0.11584353446960449,
-0.18611447513103485,
0.426281213760376,
0.10968222469091415,
0.2946794331073761,
-0.31386125087738037,
-0.2741294801235199,
0.36926642060279846,
-0.2627008259296417,
-0.23886004090309143,
0.7339155673980713,
0.00007714382081758231,
-0.7150408029556274,
0.29091379046440125,
-0.20411154627799988,
0.7205535769462585,
-0.4977225065231323,
0.07539071887731552,
-0.352360337972641,
-0.03594595193862915,
-0.1330532431602478,
-0.8314323425292969,
0.034776486456394196,
0.15482349693775177,
0.01200109627097845,
0.11013111472129822,
0.39584508538246155,
-0.4158202111721039,
-0.03970877081155777,
0.3887020945549011,
0.3550695478916168,
0.3924481272697449,
-0.16082797944545746,
-0.9056146144866943,
0.3727056384086609,
-0.15204033255577087,
-0.5818684101104736,
0.6492963433265686,
0.7839240431785583,
0.08397020399570465,
0.4428694248199463,
0.6076184511184692,
0.04877108708024025,
-0.4661736488342285,
-0.01045521255582571,
0.6004685759544373,
-0.8564063310623169,
-0.5415166616439819,
-1.030116319656372,
0.38610342144966125,
0.08326251804828644,
-0.23209625482559204,
0.424209326505661,
0.2316562831401825,
0.33318740129470825,
0.043013252317905426,
0.8460879921913147,
-0.04869711026549339,
-0.11467021703720093,
-0.35783517360687256,
0.8474568128585815,
-0.4211105406284332,
-0.036167312413454056,
-0.7581323385238647,
-0.9577156901359558,
-0.1777198165655136,
0.6333951354026794,
-0.34985581040382385,
0.23497121036052704,
0.8186882138252258,
0.48499956727027893,
0.18982048332691193,
0.28133252263069153,
0.3598403334617615,
0.5732938051223755,
0.6133711934089661,
0.646094024181366,
0.9972728490829468,
0.07028023153543472,
0.4961450397968292,
0.27768418192863464,
-0.33429738879203796,
-0.19568511843681335,
-1.0646610260009766,
-0.7367551326751709,
-0.48408305644989014,
-0.0996905118227005,
-0.48433250188827515,
0.26157402992248535,
1.0911803245544434,
0.21387825906276703,
-0.4252704083919525,
-0.3191382884979248,
-0.06748100370168686,
0.17520172894001007,
-0.17742569744586945,
-0.23275922238826752,
0.3382595479488373,
-0.3746001720428467,
-0.7489678263664246,
0.015010334551334381,
0.15852752327919006,
0.3067203164100647,
0.08216467499732971,
-0.6677442193031311,
-0.020523779094219208,
0.398465633392334,
0.708038330078125,
0.3957065939903259,
-0.6294746398925781,
-0.5026088953018188,
-0.2303381711244583,
-0.09261913597583771,
-0.03814378008246422,
0.8731399774551392,
-0.4205907881259918,
0.2898676097393036,
0.245472714304924,
0.30868759751319885,
0.25349298119544983,
-0.17323996126651764,
1.0634279251098633,
-0.32207152247428894,
0.06608934700489044,
0.3785761892795563,
0.518991231918335,
0.08994825184345245,
-0.29448169469833374,
0.6097538471221924,
-0.16018512845039368,
-0.8984643816947937,
-0.79541015625,
0.3313533365726471,
-0.7439656853675842,
-0.32193365693092346,
1.1774871349334717,
-0.12267028540372849,
-0.164169579744339,
-0.004087719134986401,
-0.4888204038143158,
0.5345562100410461,
-0.627964973449707,
1.2250431776046753,
1.0558511018753052,
-0.41992607712745667,
0.08421625196933746,
-0.5234399437904358,
0.5364446043968201,
0.5719093680381775,
-0.7553084492683411,
0.20882785320281982,
0.5499391555786133,
-0.071229949593544,
-0.07113886624574661,
0.5543006658554077,
-0.029334427788853645,
0.3095681965351105,
-0.0835845023393631,
0.21745064854621887,
0.2060503512620926,
0.1604589968919754,
-0.26186779141426086,
0.1000794991850853,
-0.05489067733287811,
0.1446964144706726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03287v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03287v1
|
SpikeLM: Towards General Spike-Driven Language Modeling via Elastic Bi-Spiking Mechanisms
| 2024-06-05T13:59:03 | 2024-06-05T13:59:03 |
Xingrun Xing, Zheng Zhang, Ziyi Ni, Shitao Xiao, Yiming Ju, Siqi Fan, Yequan Wang, Jiajun Zhang, Guoqi Li
|
cs.NE
|
cs.NE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Towards energy-efficient artificial intelligence similar to the human brain,
the bio-inspired spiking neural networks (SNNs) have advantages of biological
plausibility, event-driven sparsity, and binary activation. Recently,
large-scale language models exhibit promising generalization capability, making
it a valuable issue to explore more general spike-driven models. However, the
binary spikes in existing SNNs fail to encode adequate semantic information,
placing technological challenges for generalization. This work proposes the
first fully spiking mechanism for general language tasks, including both
discriminative and generative ones. Different from previous spikes with {0,1}
levels, we propose a more general spike formulation with bi-directional,
elastic amplitude, and elastic frequency encoding, while still maintaining the
addition nature of SNNs. In a single time step, the spike is enhanced by
direction and amplitude information; in spike frequency, a strategy to control
spike firing rate is well designed. We plug this elastic bi-spiking mechanism
in language modeling, named SpikeLM. It is the first time to handle general
language tasks with fully spike-driven models, which achieve much higher
accuracy than previously possible. SpikeLM also greatly bridges the performance
gap between SNNs and ANNs in language modeling. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Xingrun-Xing/SpikeLM.
|
[
-0.004233998246490955,
-1.2019703388214111,
0.3088478744029999,
0.5947083234786987,
-0.20996934175491333,
0.1159183531999588,
-0.3623599112033844,
-0.32110145688056946,
0.464870423078537,
0.12643826007843018,
-0.2144668698310852,
-0.34807899594306946,
-0.41863295435905457,
-0.07539977878332138,
-0.6898059844970703,
1.064164161682129,
0.15564985573291779,
0.039706647396087646,
0.007959272712469101,
-0.0011878114892169833,
-0.11689680814743042,
-0.5523396134376526,
-0.5785843133926392,
-0.5711716413497925,
0.8400970697402954,
-0.22106654942035675,
0.4115421175956726,
0.7426824569702148,
0.07980531454086304,
0.2006968855857849,
-0.20157957077026367,
-0.026060009375214577,
-0.4123052656650543,
0.0698910653591156,
0.024979734793305397,
-0.3919433355331421,
-0.42413198947906494,
-0.3614162802696228,
0.7590345144271851,
0.8890647888183594,
-0.314300537109375,
-0.015621970407664776,
0.002531463047489524,
0.3758392035961151,
-0.13531124591827393,
0.07045437395572662,
-0.9194378852844238,
-0.0740010142326355,
-0.4043365716934204,
-0.4191893935203552,
-0.35903123021125793,
-0.013137005269527435,
-0.15140391886234283,
-0.31123465299606323,
0.4088665843009949,
0.18925654888153076,
0.7376735806465149,
0.06286134570837021,
-0.1429043412208557,
-0.08003349602222443,
-0.7806881666183472,
0.43289652466773987,
-0.3707519769668579,
0.6193075776100159,
0.339093953371048,
-0.06740535795688629,
-0.18597517907619476,
-0.7419575452804565,
-0.19350092113018036,
-0.5208720564842224,
0.29356229305267334,
-0.1252097487449646,
-0.13648001849651337,
0.2030998021364212,
0.21573735773563385,
0.1643562912940979,
-0.6466577649116516,
0.0698905661702156,
-0.30776479840278625,
-0.08897526562213898,
0.55000239610672,
0.1708279550075531,
0.3153577446937561,
0.24785065650939941,
-0.5585792064666748,
0.35205087065696716,
-0.7891129851341248,
0.20784908533096313,
0.45065686106681824,
0.47042927145957947,
-0.04934878647327423,
0.3537570834159851,
0.2363297939300537,
0.4200345277786255,
-0.012841330841183662,
0.6272071003913879,
0.21896228194236755,
-0.2667326033115387,
-0.02858717367053032,
0.06344982236623764,
0.6657560467720032,
0.30423909425735474,
0.07248544692993164,
-0.5592976808547974,
-0.3581886291503906,
0.1920544058084488,
0.4063918888568878,
-0.8199759125709534,
-0.08541449904441833,
0.3987748324871063,
-0.2725614607334137,
-0.1185440719127655,
-0.4783552587032318,
-0.7920648455619812,
-0.21038244664669037,
-0.10568366944789886,
0.4683608412742615,
-0.6860673427581787,
-0.7169185280799866,
0.4305161237716675,
0.026106232777237892,
-0.08202598989009857,
-0.0039061300922185183,
-1.3493770360946655,
0.5257703065872192,
0.7479038238525391,
0.9241781830787659,
-0.12955407798290253,
-0.6444728374481201,
-0.49246636033058167,
0.021301135420799255,
-0.4582531452178955,
0.5347127914428711,
-0.4876305162906647,
-0.1749015599489212,
0.14048515260219574,
-0.17558391392230988,
0.05143977329134941,
-0.16609464585781097,
0.3312201499938965,
-0.4546361565589905,
-0.26979726552963257,
0.2691304683685303,
-0.4137619137763977,
-0.15970119833946228,
-0.13358496129512787,
-0.4771062433719635,
1.3361037969589233,
-0.024713559076189995,
-0.6974042654037476,
0.2716403603553772,
-0.6389970779418945,
-0.6740068793296814,
0.5277727842330933,
-0.242619588971138,
-0.40206366777420044,
0.3616372048854828,
-0.23698300123214722,
0.37041446566581726,
-0.4476279020309448,
0.7349729537963867,
-0.21025516092777252,
-0.48707321286201477,
-0.02823362872004509,
-0.5629912614822388,
0.894648551940918,
-0.1094476655125618,
-0.5568044781684875,
0.3790654242038727,
-0.7637830376625061,
-0.155001699924469,
0.4867793917655945,
-0.26905709505081177,
-0.3640635013580322,
0.4458288550376892,
0.15729598701000214,
-0.07660079002380371,
0.2551528811454773,
-0.5832829475402832,
0.21107956767082214,
-0.6513327360153198,
0.3824666738510132,
0.6025301218032837,
-0.1497257649898529,
0.44923850893974304,
-0.1329556703567505,
0.13583652675151825,
-0.07664859294891357,
-0.09047873318195343,
-0.2615119218826294,
-0.5889211297035217,
-0.5500441193580627,
-0.24785366654396057,
0.2500764727592468,
0.34426647424697876,
-0.5070549249649048,
0.5788960456848145,
-0.1342952400445938,
-0.5432752370834351,
-0.7472522854804993,
0.037487540394067764,
0.13804642856121063,
0.2543790340423584,
0.4464207589626312,
0.03229348734021187,
-0.38563835620880127,
-0.7304314970970154,
-0.369693785905838,
-0.08923517167568207,
-0.09974698722362518,
0.16207782924175262,
0.25823575258255005,
-0.12063974142074585,
0.8126693964004517,
0.12699833512306213,
0.4379308223724365,
-0.3398583233356476,
0.5482478737831116,
0.22190330922603607,
0.48104169964790344,
0.6411736011505127,
-0.7045530080795288,
-0.21906428039073944,
0.08211790025234222,
-0.3885248899459839,
-0.44040167331695557,
-0.10912050306797028,
0.08662741631269455,
0.17987173795700073,
0.17875780165195465,
-0.7449818253517151,
0.6521455645561218,
0.29319310188293457,
-0.3032483160495758,
0.7525673508644104,
-0.37091970443725586,
-0.02630789391696453,
-0.6280839443206787,
0.21385426819324493,
0.18720851838588715,
-0.2712049186229706,
-1.1960225105285645,
-0.007678483612835407,
0.2557249069213867,
-0.1893835812807083,
-0.42263978719711304,
0.5118370652198792,
-0.4548536241054535,
-0.05480276420712471,
-0.44372105598449707,
-0.062160614877939224,
-0.10986613482236862,
0.6897943615913391,
0.05894506350159645,
0.6160938739776611,
1.1380822658538818,
-0.851848304271698,
0.3195515275001526,
-0.31911003589630127,
-0.16268520057201385,
0.13443271815776825,
-0.8880702257156372,
0.165689155459404,
-0.37246403098106384,
-0.08642266690731049,
-0.68802410364151,
0.19059936702251434,
0.12407225370407104,
-0.4451254606246948,
0.4919182360172272,
-0.061707429587841034,
-0.46778541803359985,
-0.24872063100337982,
-0.11361609399318695,
0.4152933955192566,
0.4641246795654297,
-0.42145392298698425,
0.6194260120391846,
0.31269827485084534,
-0.24987877905368805,
-0.2569269835948944,
-0.6356564164161682,
0.08434251695871353,
-0.13290494680404663,
-0.6218528747558594,
0.5710830688476562,
-0.2512800991535187,
0.11036107689142227,
0.0023919851519167423,
0.07411971688270569,
0.20287051796913147,
0.15591873228549957,
0.0404648631811142,
0.2866205871105194,
-0.23806917667388916,
0.37768250703811646,
-0.023297013714909554,
-0.1658635437488556,
0.06434305012226105,
-0.32209885120391846,
1.1123031377792358,
-0.14610956609249115,
-0.5289838910102844,
-0.2214832454919815,
0.6772729158401489,
0.5921036601066589,
-0.4695568084716797,
0.6113988161087036,
0.7076032161712646,
-0.5221906900405884,
-0.3323031961917877,
-0.2784540057182312,
-0.3860841691493988,
-0.42629894614219666,
0.7795423865318298,
-0.3261040151119232,
-0.7796293497085571,
0.18645669519901276,
-0.14469286799430847,
0.27625399827957153,
0.16896411776542664,
0.8659989237785339,
0.17449085414409637,
1.5242770910263062,
0.6810877323150635,
-0.06758569926023483,
0.5510880351066589,
0.0839424803853035,
0.2739005982875824,
-0.6517422795295715,
-0.1683792769908905,
-0.4549016058444977,
-0.30066192150115967,
-0.20377223193645477,
-0.39910468459129333,
0.03195194527506828,
0.2226666659116745,
-0.26052582263946533,
0.257442831993103,
-0.7067644596099854,
0.06363927572965622,
0.46736767888069153,
-0.2529624104499817,
-0.309719055891037,
0.30794548988342285,
-0.47014352679252625,
0.14915871620178223,
-0.9308356046676636,
-0.2734556496143341,
0.7043793201446533,
0.6011994481086731,
0.652070164680481,
-0.3608524203300476,
0.34333688020706177,
0.11009379476308823,
0.06928312033414841,
-0.533265233039856,
0.6720475554466248,
-0.03188899904489517,
-0.6426712274551392,
-0.16182538866996765,
-0.5237835645675659,
-1.1336947679519653,
0.14812953770160675,
-0.24249960482120514,
-1.0557109117507935,
-0.1480027139186859,
0.12263412773609161,
-0.10643377155065536,
0.5231308341026306,
-0.5166068077087402,
0.6004087924957275,
-0.737687885761261,
-0.6246615052223206,
-0.32436057925224304,
-0.5712038278579712,
-0.07464096695184708,
0.12606856226921082,
0.145050510764122,
-0.37030622363090515,
0.011399464681744576,
0.5886995196342468,
-0.18129678070545197,
0.7787554860115051,
-0.4620097577571869,
0.1952948272228241,
0.15394727885723114,
0.08389841020107269,
0.6383553743362427,
-0.18194541335105896,
-0.23169967532157898,
0.5002375841140747,
-0.280525803565979,
-0.49739328026771545,
-0.5758877396583557,
0.4215184152126312,
-0.48126932978630066,
-0.5101397633552551,
-0.22663898766040802,
-0.5520182847976685,
0.06985635310411453,
0.2644950747489929,
0.17097829282283783,
0.5190908908843994,
-0.11722437292337418,
0.21020840108394623,
0.2678244709968567,
0.09101183712482452,
0.4074482023715973,
0.3941096067428589,
-0.8205907940864563,
-0.3097926080226898,
1.1974326372146606,
0.09348134696483612,
0.02368861623108387,
0.011031129397451878,
0.10553444921970367,
-0.32063910365104675,
-0.6879404783248901,
-0.6613815426826477,
0.18377374112606049,
-0.12055378407239914,
0.10483349114656448,
-0.5909680724143982,
-0.40248891711235046,
-0.350933313369751,
-0.19662168622016907,
-0.276847243309021,
-0.04172533378005028,
-0.2085503339767456,
-0.1643279641866684,
0.5584349036216736,
0.6296806931495667,
-0.06792566180229187,
0.12946248054504395,
-0.6026104092597961,
0.35937708616256714,
0.052122294902801514,
0.5305855870246887,
0.059005070477724075,
-0.23392167687416077,
-0.3891647160053253,
0.16686344146728516,
0.20115789771080017,
-1.0142546892166138,
0.4652601182460785,
0.29802313446998596,
0.6558675169944763,
0.25062254071235657,
-0.4086481034755707,
0.37888655066490173,
-0.9738904237747192,
0.7356468439102173,
0.5357816815376282,
-0.8120212554931641,
0.25966376066207886,
-0.27059563994407654,
-0.038564521819353104,
0.09519365429878235,
0.4948072135448456,
-0.6786317825317383,
-0.27464380860328674,
-0.4807496964931488,
-1.1749625205993652,
0.6631083488464355,
0.11647744476795197,
0.16085758805274963,
-0.18331730365753174,
0.19477884471416473,
0.2504345774650574,
0.22065849602222443,
-0.5930039882659912,
-0.42559564113616943,
-0.35824623703956604,
-0.3033300042152405,
0.057963933795690536,
-0.14910294115543365,
0.044853005558252335,
-0.3340204358100891,
0.6731569170951843,
0.038517337292432785,
0.3723262548446655,
0.0600099116563797,
-0.08692548424005508,
-0.26830869913101196,
-0.0031271043699234724,
0.5574603080749512,
0.13221600651741028,
-0.10736165940761566,
0.35798734426498413,
0.2246578484773636,
-0.49162375926971436,
0.28857657313346863,
0.2321726679801941,
-0.4448413848876953,
0.11949983984231949,
-0.19651538133621216,
1.272984266281128,
0.333345502614975,
-0.32699570059776306,
0.2787225842475891,
0.014160756021738052,
-0.21427346765995026,
0.1772458255290985,
0.04542819410562515,
0.2461993396282196,
0.21743233501911163,
0.5599403381347656,
-0.00420091999694705,
-0.19257758557796478,
-0.2991536557674408,
0.24122023582458496,
0.370160847902298,
-0.3946113586425781,
-0.7037670612335205,
0.7889849543571472,
0.2504936456680298,
-1.0103594064712524,
0.2509966790676117,
-0.30030983686447144,
-0.5175151824951172,
0.3489663004875183,
1.1931536197662354,
0.932242214679718,
-0.31060591340065,
-0.013785583898425102,
0.18739740550518036,
0.2956910729408264,
0.18791495263576508,
0.24103491008281708,
-0.13296231627464294,
-0.5594027638435364,
-0.4292218089103699,
-0.9538536071777344,
0.029729843139648438,
0.11272633820772171,
-0.25462836027145386,
0.3276250660419464,
-0.6558830738067627,
-0.23507478833198547,
0.07794270664453506,
-0.19128872454166412,
-0.3808850646018982,
0.09509706497192383,
0.27322012186050415,
1.0189540386199951,
-0.6817505955696106,
0.8937107920646667,
0.7332116961479187,
-0.39442071318626404,
-0.4284040033817291,
-0.26023903489112854,
-0.2508760094642639,
-0.678469717502594,
0.5065540671348572,
0.26493534445762634,
-0.3080211579799652,
0.30556821823120117,
-0.7221088409423828,
-0.6807458996772766,
0.6800994873046875,
0.1869014948606491,
-0.4561571478843689,
-0.16141031682491302,
0.22462482750415802,
0.3757924735546112,
-0.3687230050563812,
0.282930850982666,
0.3864001929759979,
0.2647533118724823,
-0.0707232654094696,
-0.400103896856308,
-0.1751202642917633,
-0.7499088048934937,
0.010172516107559204,
0.46822836995124817,
-0.5425316095352173,
0.8621968626976013,
0.45565158128738403,
-0.32887157797813416,
-0.07928545773029327,
0.8622273802757263,
0.4507072865962982,
0.30922257900238037,
0.5756580233573914,
0.3994216322898865,
0.8228499293327332,
-0.056755438446998596,
0.7074074745178223,
-0.8024927973747253,
0.2511271834373474,
0.5665315985679626,
-0.6669908165931702,
0.6275879144668579,
0.23652689158916473,
-0.19663982093334198,
0.2661132514476776,
0.3583972752094269,
0.12650546431541443,
0.27591851353645325,
0.3306314945220947,
-0.5613364577293396,
-0.18219801783561707,
0.00014627778728026897,
-0.27733147144317627,
0.0974985882639885,
0.7650100588798523,
0.0688561275601387,
-0.19723933935165405,
0.04529334232211113,
-0.13878895342350006,
-0.17267237603664398,
-0.5143263339996338,
0.47244805097579956,
-0.00008448237349512056,
-0.3590262532234192,
0.6343464851379395,
0.0048477789387106895,
0.8950079679489136,
-0.9444540143013,
-0.016789894551038742,
-0.014352923259139061,
-0.3680998384952545,
-0.026759933680295944,
-0.6105818748474121,
0.3394080400466919,
0.22155512869358063,
-0.2530384063720703,
-0.12612824141979218,
1.096705436706543,
-0.7207836508750916,
-0.36135339736938477,
0.6253958344459534,
-0.045154958963394165,
0.43244943022727966,
0.0832400694489479,
-0.7427064776420593,
0.059324514120817184,
-0.2305479347705841,
-0.1344221830368042,
0.3018113374710083,
0.38559913635253906,
0.027633722871541977,
0.49695152044296265,
0.8332997560501099,
0.5435774326324463,
0.4867165684700012,
0.20763611793518066,
0.6403212547302246,
-0.6974782347679138,
-0.5058762431144714,
-0.8134103417396545,
0.6859679222106934,
-0.1025538370013237,
-0.0999976247549057,
0.5050680637359619,
0.5860722661018372,
0.30142325162887573,
0.29413047432899475,
0.7002283930778503,
-0.024758044630289078,
0.5960478782653809,
-0.28184273838996887,
1.0799169540405273,
-0.7161997556686401,
-0.10722480714321136,
0.15413790941238403,
-0.7953329086303711,
-0.4236008822917938,
0.40969938039779663,
-0.12554268538951874,
0.024814767763018608,
0.5688567757606506,
0.9613116979598999,
-0.06909315288066864,
0.043131761252880096,
0.6173664927482605,
0.4192982614040375,
0.27903297543525696,
0.31574302911758423,
0.6474056839942932,
-0.0003080321184825152,
0.31872931122779846,
-0.074369415640831,
-0.27392253279685974,
-0.6108600497245789,
-0.745778501033783,
-0.6719575524330139,
-0.6176723837852478,
-0.11971215903759003,
-0.015839166939258575,
0.17329923808574677,
1.117027997970581,
0.7938697934150696,
-0.6735218167304993,
-0.2183225005865097,
-0.5759934782981873,
-0.16703979671001434,
-0.2663056552410126,
-0.1613292694091797,
0.2449304461479187,
-0.6680004000663757,
-0.5900189280509949,
0.8511152267456055,
0.8350372910499573,
-0.10659054666757584,
-0.371456116437912,
-0.07498396188020706,
-0.45772072672843933,
0.3693277835845947,
0.33645063638687134,
0.5107660293579102,
-0.5395938754081726,
-0.31375372409820557,
-0.014978954568505287,
-0.22134648263454437,
0.20304933190345764,
0.7114419341087341,
-0.5500134825706482,
0.38739678263664246,
0.5045152306556702,
0.9096912145614624,
0.6550402045249939,
-0.14852407574653625,
0.47329822182655334,
-0.7636805176734924,
0.26889970898628235,
0.47485023736953735,
0.40739917755126953,
0.23784852027893066,
-0.08919510245323181,
0.16237154603004456,
0.297232449054718,
-0.7723438739776611,
-0.8586015105247498,
0.287357896566391,
-0.7129292488098145,
-0.04361014813184738,
1.0223544836044312,
-0.03679833561182022,
-0.8722904324531555,
-0.22185561060905457,
-0.28650522232055664,
0.5764882564544678,
-0.2203202098608017,
0.6018280386924744,
0.40363427996635437,
0.03548813611268997,
-0.11819769442081451,
-0.40355074405670166,
0.29969868063926697,
0.7511659264564514,
-0.4932290315628052,
0.39284566044807434,
0.19205667078495026,
0.049421269446611404,
0.08516775071620941,
0.5112334489822388,
0.1190963163971901,
0.3374965190887451,
0.44119131565093994,
0.572050929069519,
-0.17206354439258575,
-0.7125633358955383,
-0.5503950715065002,
0.3066858649253845,
-0.05884570628404617,
-0.1059703454375267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06589v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06589v2
|
PatentEval: Understanding Errors in Patent Generation
| 2024-06-05T13:55:27 | 2024-06-25T08:23:03 |
You Zuo, Kim Gerdes, Eric Villemonte de La Clergerie, Benoît Sagot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this work, we introduce a comprehensive error typology specifically
designed for evaluating two distinct tasks in machine-generated patent texts:
claims-to-abstract generation, and the generation of the next claim given
previous ones. We have also developed a benchmark, PatentEval, for
systematically assessing language models in this context. Our study includes a
comparative analysis, annotated by humans, of various models. These range from
those specifically adapted during training for tasks within the patent domain
to the latest general-purpose large language models (LLMs). Furthermore, we
explored and evaluated some metrics to approximate human judgments in patent
text evaluation, analyzing the extent to which these metrics align with expert
assessments. These approaches provide valuable insights into the capabilities
and limitations of current language models in the specialized field of patent
text generation.
|
[
0.25001612305641174,
-0.4358292520046234,
0.4432249069213867,
0.6475684642791748,
0.18199096620082855,
0.5610008835792542,
0.0977763682603836,
-0.6491063237190247,
-0.2913654148578644,
0.32256850600242615,
-0.12848366796970367,
-0.5071194171905518,
-0.49193060398101807,
0.1664864718914032,
-0.19133754074573517,
0.7658371329307556,
-0.34518054127693176,
0.0842495858669281,
-0.5111417174339294,
0.3424461781978607,
-0.5284020900726318,
-0.6983793377876282,
-0.35787951946258545,
-0.3875615894794464,
0.0693049505352974,
0.363277792930603,
0.16544455289840698,
0.5402259230613708,
0.44378945231437683,
0.2606661021709442,
-0.210588738322258,
0.09107787162065506,
-0.051300037652254105,
0.02934308722615242,
-0.12495498359203339,
-0.40202319622039795,
-0.6893949508666992,
0.05184239521622658,
0.26659145951271057,
0.7980518341064453,
-0.032059647142887115,
0.37112730741500854,
0.19279146194458008,
0.47963178157806396,
-0.5412954092025757,
0.32493674755096436,
-0.826668918132782,
0.14018529653549194,
-0.19748187065124512,
-0.2074701339006424,
-0.765285074710846,
-0.325367271900177,
0.5121346712112427,
-0.4102625548839569,
0.7180269956588745,
0.49944019317626953,
0.9114025235176086,
-0.05186561122536659,
-0.04680098593235016,
-0.32679998874664307,
-0.3721122443675995,
0.8035220503807068,
-0.6271712183952332,
-0.2431478649377823,
0.10923127830028534,
0.20001114904880524,
-0.3100261986255646,
-1.1286369562149048,
-0.5315366983413696,
-0.48431044816970825,
0.17685435712337494,
-0.11772891879081726,
-0.20969511568546295,
0.24557781219482422,
0.2287055104970932,
0.21012896299362183,
-0.513805627822876,
0.3092278838157654,
-0.5114637017250061,
-0.2872034013271332,
0.6991479396820068,
-0.058359719812870026,
0.418191134929657,
-0.51918625831604,
-0.26272809505462646,
-0.21380029618740082,
-0.909398078918457,
-0.064796082675457,
0.42560604214668274,
0.27056631445884705,
0.06217775493860245,
0.5954544544219971,
-0.11776841431856155,
0.6280057430267334,
0.026563381776213646,
0.2047029584646225,
0.3169623911380768,
-0.330750972032547,
-0.38892823457717896,
0.20902366936206818,
0.5527847409248352,
0.4052966833114624,
0.32871466875076294,
-0.22120581567287445,
-0.217044398188591,
-0.3902455270290375,
0.3935786187648773,
-0.7494388818740845,
-0.22140894830226898,
0.2701476812362671,
-0.5983797311782837,
-0.7333599328994751,
0.15617208182811737,
-0.6947299242019653,
-0.8279418349266052,
-0.05911685526371002,
0.44480428099632263,
-0.05832898989319801,
-0.05851999297738075,
0.07791651040315628,
-0.517661452293396,
-0.036604199558496475,
0.03366386890411377,
-0.8543859720230103,
0.21908651292324066,
0.8973720669746399,
0.6340008974075317,
-0.020133614540100098,
-0.5613715648651123,
-0.2415243685245514,
-0.08546246588230133,
-0.5745201706886292,
1.0947669744491577,
-0.07157468050718307,
-0.654071569442749,
0.03712849318981171,
-0.1915932148694992,
-0.32254597544670105,
-0.9144981503486633,
0.9349969625473022,
-0.5685076117515564,
0.07599815726280212,
-0.11826822906732559,
-0.5080804228782654,
-0.1745307594537735,
0.04433635249733925,
-0.2985370457172394,
0.5485914349555969,
0.03609223663806915,
-0.8209934234619141,
0.7965442538261414,
-0.862642228603363,
-0.4296029210090637,
0.22174973785877228,
-0.14755554497241974,
-0.39663374423980713,
0.47290757298469543,
-0.1298377960920334,
0.2946770489215851,
-0.780677855014801,
0.36042216420173645,
-0.1883922964334488,
0.2234243005514145,
0.38689032196998596,
-0.22623310983181,
0.8347410559654236,
0.15326237678527832,
-0.7068057060241699,
0.020381733775138855,
-1.0086435079574585,
0.05317141115665436,
0.18182431161403656,
-0.2498929351568222,
-0.18866969645023346,
0.33221545815467834,
-0.024988802149891853,
0.10624060034751892,
0.46251773834228516,
-0.8354277014732361,
-0.12937425076961517,
-0.43736085295677185,
0.587050199508667,
0.6386308073997498,
0.15375512838363647,
-0.09998831897974014,
-0.35310858488082886,
0.5843179821968079,
-0.1613592952489853,
0.09303493052721024,
-0.2797781527042389,
-0.5855149030685425,
-0.702911913394928,
0.11314275115728378,
0.710202693939209,
0.5164995789527893,
-0.15606346726417542,
0.45118096470832825,
-0.3212411105632782,
-0.5143795013427734,
-0.45400336384773254,
0.11787614971399307,
0.6860489249229431,
0.6857814192771912,
0.142918661236763,
-0.473187655210495,
-0.6607334017753601,
-0.9646861553192139,
-0.5196279883384705,
-0.5401253700256348,
-0.06348251551389694,
0.46129369735717773,
0.4968178868293762,
-0.023000387474894524,
1.0448410511016846,
-0.34280309081077576,
0.1713084727525711,
-0.02020857483148575,
1.004469394683838,
-0.043451812118291855,
0.44445210695266724,
0.45688000321388245,
-0.5584919452667236,
-0.5494188666343689,
0.27368754148483276,
-0.5201914310455322,
-0.5237729549407959,
-0.0899074375629425,
0.30253735184669495,
0.2643168568611145,
0.34892675280570984,
-0.5670831203460693,
0.47083643078804016,
0.20852135121822357,
-0.4117782711982727,
0.9517829418182373,
-0.4398333430290222,
0.27630361914634705,
-0.9231764078140259,
0.12567663192749023,
0.13237588107585907,
0.09023996442556381,
-0.5604287385940552,
-0.14643770456314087,
0.17421336472034454,
0.013528683222830296,
-0.44251537322998047,
0.47801673412323,
-0.512753427028656,
-0.2939925789833069,
-0.26361939311027527,
-0.028416303917765617,
0.3436901271343231,
-0.15104688704013824,
-0.18288655579090118,
0.9774267077445984,
0.4441443681716919,
-0.31925222277641296,
0.2878444492816925,
0.1046760305762291,
-0.438252717256546,
0.41147029399871826,
-0.9915046095848083,
0.13154475390911102,
-0.003136226674541831,
-0.08236581087112427,
-1.1433086395263672,
-0.5400799512863159,
-0.1691611409187317,
-0.5702480673789978,
0.5085741877555847,
0.02990628592669964,
-0.6916487216949463,
-0.6675387024879456,
-0.30481410026550293,
0.16488878428936005,
0.5015354752540588,
-0.7837112545967102,
0.3401293158531189,
0.372562438249588,
-0.5141249299049377,
-0.6109415292739868,
-0.6393099427223206,
0.45844027400016785,
-0.34663107991218567,
-0.8443784117698669,
0.5626292824745178,
0.2401580810546875,
-0.6057019829750061,
-0.06931919604539871,
0.20173859596252441,
-0.26452377438545227,
0.1553875058889389,
0.22859768569469452,
0.33634668588638306,
-0.3889915347099304,
0.16679225862026215,
0.1019069254398346,
-0.006754353642463684,
0.39344102144241333,
-0.30507758259773254,
0.1352088749408722,
0.06568752974271774,
-0.19016113877296448,
-0.3742964565753937,
-0.023070551455020905,
0.6201547384262085,
0.040118928998708725,
0.2573285400867462,
-0.3358123302459717,
-0.32321345806121826,
-0.25917476415634155,
-0.6194605827331543,
0.3022719621658325,
-0.45885851979255676,
0.4924076795578003,
-0.2729893624782562,
-0.2274416834115982,
0.39170438051223755,
0.011541564017534256,
0.2536604106426239,
0.9797974228858948,
0.4728168249130249,
0.08131856471300125,
0.971089780330658,
0.5895853042602539,
0.15566101670265198,
-0.17038525640964508,
0.02736152894794941,
0.3847503662109375,
-0.6162528395652771,
-0.3066166043281555,
-0.943587064743042,
0.0936572253704071,
-0.23217903077602386,
-0.3921148478984833,
-0.05424976348876953,
0.10754642635583878,
-0.3433249294757843,
0.5130075812339783,
-0.6490498185157776,
0.39500191807746887,
0.5261405110359192,
-0.3486314117908478,
0.3418135941028595,
0.33335447311401367,
-0.35796499252319336,
-0.24168673157691956,
-0.6112477779388428,
-0.9591493606567383,
1.4692540168762207,
0.4251762330532074,
0.5962300896644592,
-0.2478407323360443,
0.5943722128868103,
0.4583519697189331,
0.5641828179359436,
-0.6176445484161377,
0.3521451950073242,
-0.39611366391181946,
-0.7058765888214111,
0.17383459210395813,
-0.15499240159988403,
-0.7328194975852966,
0.1558510661125183,
0.0003031803935300559,
-0.8469406366348267,
0.3432205021381378,
0.3556106388568878,
-0.57594233751297,
0.10383941978216171,
-1.17549729347229,
1.1048802137374878,
-0.6675307750701904,
-0.18988923728466034,
-0.43946799635887146,
-0.5174595713615417,
0.36275604367256165,
-0.40516945719718933,
0.030385447666049004,
0.16400304436683655,
-0.024219932034611702,
0.9597415924072266,
-0.46433237195014954,
0.8752657175064087,
-0.1812417060136795,
0.06931540369987488,
0.509808361530304,
-0.20141467452049255,
0.2534446120262146,
-0.5722445845603943,
-0.29569998383522034,
-0.15827178955078125,
-0.012818246148526669,
-0.18424326181411743,
-0.3569782078266144,
0.38419005274772644,
-0.6542416214942932,
-0.591658353805542,
-0.5234054923057556,
-0.3537901043891907,
-0.29982343316078186,
0.11911472678184509,
0.5397994518280029,
0.46054399013519287,
-0.47752439975738525,
0.07030756026506424,
0.22385388612747192,
-0.5330864787101746,
0.31373658776283264,
0.32946088910102844,
0.0031106220558285713,
-0.35277608036994934,
0.864051878452301,
0.0941622331738472,
0.21218833327293396,
0.10848824679851532,
0.20093874633312225,
-0.5658748149871826,
-1.0300078392028809,
-0.26746976375579834,
0.10379675030708313,
-0.7561656832695007,
-0.017145898193120956,
-0.6488988399505615,
-0.18326638638973236,
-0.5064293146133423,
0.1826646775007248,
-0.18987642228603363,
-0.6589677929878235,
-0.4364550709724426,
-0.20355433225631714,
0.10718145221471786,
0.8186259865760803,
0.08528070896863937,
0.2395648956298828,
-0.732072651386261,
0.0735461637377739,
0.3611241579055786,
0.13733045756816864,
0.0022018984891474247,
-0.7209753394126892,
0.02985747903585434,
-0.14041250944137573,
-0.7540525197982788,
-0.530555248260498,
0.12317579239606857,
0.2342379093170166,
0.567845344543457,
0.06773348152637482,
-0.18176597356796265,
0.5257017612457275,
-0.7540743350982666,
1.0103970766067505,
0.37257254123687744,
-0.952788770198822,
0.6078952550888062,
-0.10433841496706009,
-0.3093264698982239,
0.42996227741241455,
0.04776352643966675,
-0.23487944900989532,
-0.11004150658845901,
-0.9426203370094299,
-0.9404987692832947,
0.3059430420398712,
-0.15083810687065125,
0.2035445123910904,
-0.09319551289081573,
0.36637163162231445,
0.19963039457798004,
0.1324121057987213,
-0.5071508288383484,
0.20585617423057556,
0.017789455130696297,
-0.2649635076522827,
0.16487030684947968,
-0.43432530760765076,
-0.14114977419376373,
0.11327367275953293,
0.6572883725166321,
0.07923619449138641,
-0.07985670119524002,
0.21849586069583893,
-0.14631815254688263,
-0.06724689900875092,
0.30634865164756775,
0.8843531012535095,
1.0617334842681885,
-0.15366892516613007,
0.00790473259985447,
-0.05022115632891655,
-0.40607374906539917,
0.12049607932567596,
0.5715275406837463,
-0.08932305872440338,
0.252289742231369,
0.29924634099006653,
0.6695067882537842,
0.05191610008478165,
-0.9838012456893921,
0.5558063983917236,
-0.02437126822769642,
-0.42172449827194214,
-0.06912871450185776,
-0.15058454871177673,
-0.10429498553276062,
0.10070168972015381,
0.6521332859992981,
0.2085653841495514,
0.25571656227111816,
-0.25814250111579895,
0.3785859942436218,
0.28693753480911255,
-0.17249146103858948,
-0.5429989695549011,
0.8451833128929138,
0.5185614228248596,
-0.40554019808769226,
0.01933218352496624,
-0.22903551161289215,
-0.513430655002594,
0.8168615102767944,
0.5344557166099548,
1.4596638679504395,
0.06222251430153847,
0.310895711183548,
0.14476563036441803,
0.24087677896022797,
-0.19636020064353943,
-0.08231081068515778,
0.092307448387146,
-0.47632408142089844,
-0.5335558652877808,
-0.36260274052619934,
-0.6258129477500916,
0.051350366324186325,
-0.14551229774951935,
0.12735193967819214,
-0.49018171429634094,
-0.42366427183151245,
0.4034416973590851,
-0.13052144646644592,
-0.319886714220047,
0.04628238454461098,
-0.19906345009803772,
0.9644803404808044,
-0.6738760471343994,
0.4161767065525055,
0.7096811532974243,
-0.3436160385608673,
-0.6539574861526489,
0.15915189683437347,
0.013050287961959839,
-0.7726490497589111,
1.4207792282104492,
0.05001261457800865,
-0.046610359102487564,
-0.2421489804983139,
-0.2918250858783722,
-0.2417333573102951,
0.8660816550254822,
0.11639575660228729,
-0.3473401367664337,
-0.0997890904545784,
0.2292301505804062,
0.563126802444458,
-0.5783288478851318,
-0.11925789713859558,
0.6321644186973572,
0.18586096167564392,
-0.1157294288277626,
-1.1721923351287842,
-0.13183964788913727,
-0.18248139321804047,
0.2897350788116455,
-0.2831183969974518,
-0.11052059382200241,
0.8106449246406555,
-0.3027953803539276,
-0.15278662741184235,
0.5774436593055725,
0.4193040728569031,
0.5277469158172607,
0.4291204512119293,
0.24429935216903687,
0.38082247972488403,
0.8590568900108337,
-0.08796720206737518,
1.159566044807434,
-0.43717148900032043,
0.2787211537361145,
1.1858515739440918,
-0.404981791973114,
0.885040819644928,
0.43115702271461487,
-0.3911575376987457,
0.2651696503162384,
0.7848920226097107,
-0.15668362379074097,
0.23763589560985565,
0.6150774955749512,
-0.3049295246601105,
0.2511357367038727,
-0.16196459531784058,
-0.2654986083507538,
0.08805382996797562,
0.22040438652038574,
-0.7730163931846619,
-0.1986175924539566,
-0.30728912353515625,
-0.19280804693698883,
0.18030279874801636,
-0.08673040568828583,
0.5819972157478333,
0.03091929666697979,
-0.9088211059570312,
0.5581616759300232,
0.2075730860233307,
0.5370157361030579,
0.023672867566347122,
0.07328140735626221,
0.10384572297334671,
0.3048110008239746,
-0.17030088603496552,
-0.635209321975708,
0.07226259261369705,
0.5743677616119385,
-0.2625984251499176,
-0.0535903126001358,
0.6992272734642029,
0.08477451652288437,
-0.5676677227020264,
0.05773467943072319,
0.1512528508901596,
0.20864520967006683,
0.15317359566688538,
-0.7844369411468506,
-0.1946224570274353,
-0.004225665703415871,
-0.09400708228349686,
-0.16501890122890472,
0.21634940803050995,
-0.1271485835313797,
0.44457149505615234,
0.16518928110599518,
0.3751310110092163,
0.551044762134552,
0.1571672558784485,
0.26789018511772156,
-0.48286283016204834,
-0.27846086025238037,
-0.5712602734565735,
0.7080508470535278,
-0.3520829379558563,
-0.5071240067481995,
0.5647547245025635,
0.6190691590309143,
0.26061365008354187,
-0.27278101444244385,
1.180594563484192,
-0.04436805471777916,
0.8250696063041687,
-0.33774417638778687,
0.6911184191703796,
-0.16584354639053345,
0.45024412870407104,
-0.23734980821609497,
-0.8318849205970764,
-0.49061042070388794,
0.3760630786418915,
-0.40748855471611023,
-0.038334693759679794,
0.6514359712600708,
0.8021811842918396,
0.22340674698352814,
0.07118649780750275,
-0.056422486901283264,
0.3189907371997833,
0.5185258388519287,
0.21358437836170197,
1.106113076210022,
-0.5941068530082703,
0.44983920454978943,
-0.046763479709625244,
-0.37577372789382935,
-0.31005173921585083,
-1.001753568649292,
-0.5574364066123962,
-0.38196802139282227,
-0.5431744456291199,
-0.5932150483131409,
0.013091572560369968,
0.7712765336036682,
0.566087007522583,
-0.9459644556045532,
-0.44699105620384216,
-0.5062722563743591,
-0.03891291469335556,
0.19385336339473724,
-0.19375425577163696,
0.5580428838729858,
-0.8068897724151611,
-0.5965431928634644,
0.20883943140506744,
0.3543195426464081,
0.2629958689212799,
-0.1758219599723816,
-0.0033089020289480686,
0.31930387020111084,
0.13442236185073853,
0.6373283267021179,
0.5785499215126038,
-0.827471911907196,
-0.31482288241386414,
0.04580176994204521,
-0.11742496490478516,
0.11175541579723358,
0.9022098779678345,
-0.32023122906684875,
0.7557108402252197,
0.7029311060905457,
0.8462252020835876,
0.23212265968322754,
0.13375206291675568,
0.9153759479522705,
-0.528131902217865,
0.050768494606018066,
0.11743573844432831,
0.34642964601516724,
0.5988256931304932,
-0.046340908855199814,
0.29392144083976746,
0.39392298460006714,
-0.662973940372467,
-0.9611687064170837,
-0.06297080963850021,
-0.627235472202301,
-0.19607754051685333,
0.8532028794288635,
-0.2585930824279785,
-0.21684712171554565,
-0.2397843301296234,
-0.28896966576576233,
-0.12547801434993744,
0.01438585203140974,
1.093448519706726,
0.9277875423431396,
-0.1745534986257553,
0.2200261950492859,
-0.7310375571250916,
0.5917794704437256,
0.35665658116340637,
-0.8397306203842163,
0.2562563717365265,
0.42825552821159363,
0.2456589639186859,
0.5925549864768982,
0.3431268334388733,
-0.43102824687957764,
0.6033048629760742,
0.21094875037670135,
0.2181069403886795,
0.21838988363742828,
-0.11401889473199844,
-0.26445454359054565,
0.34063732624053955,
0.8656898140907288,
-0.40466105937957764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03280v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03280v3
|
FusionBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark of Deep Model Fusion
| 2024-06-05T13:54:28 | 2024-06-14T07:19:51 |
Anke Tang, Li Shen, Yong Luo, Han Hu, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Deep model fusion is an emerging technique that unifies the predictions or
parameters of several deep neural networks into a single model in a
cost-effective and data-efficient manner. This enables the unified model to
take advantage of the original models' strengths, potentially exceeding their
performance. Although a variety of deep model fusion techniques have been
introduced, their evaluations tend to be inconsistent and often inadequate to
validate their effectiveness and robustness against distribution shifts. To
address this issue, we introduce FusionBench, which is the first comprehensive
benchmark dedicated to deep model fusion. FusionBench covers a wide range of
tasks, including open-vocabulary image classification, text classification, and
text-to-text generation. Each category includes up to eight tasks with
corresponding task-specific models, featuring both full fine-tuning and LoRA
fine-tuning, as well as models of different sizes, to ensure fair and balanced
comparisons of various multi-task model fusion techniques across different
tasks, model scales, and fine-tuning strategies. We implement and evaluate a
broad spectrum of deep model fusion techniques. These techniques range from
model ensemble methods, which combine the predictions to improve the overall
performance, to model merging, which integrates different models into a single
one, and model mixing methods, which upscale or recombine the components of the
original models. FusionBench now contains 26 distinct tasks, 74 fine-tuned
models, and 16 fusion techniques, and we are committed to consistently
expanding the benchmark with more tasks, models, and fusion techniques. In
addition, we offer a well-documented set of resources and guidelines to aid
researchers in understanding and replicating the benchmark results. Homepage
https://github.com/tanganke/fusion_bench
|
[
-0.6752033829689026,
-0.4337019920349121,
0.2213803231716156,
-0.0007628026651218534,
-0.3451751470565796,
0.13213606178760529,
-0.1968642920255661,
-0.4472997784614563,
-0.21091483533382416,
0.45980897545814514,
-0.6702063083648682,
-0.46999579668045044,
-0.2644389271736145,
-0.2914848029613495,
-0.671520471572876,
0.5483987331390381,
-0.009169443510472775,
0.20679964125156403,
-0.41656020283699036,
-0.0858735591173172,
-0.6708114147186279,
0.017106622457504272,
-0.3498486876487732,
-0.737619936466217,
0.47395846247673035,
0.14582636952400208,
0.5370568037033081,
0.4586429297924042,
0.9034382104873657,
0.29901209473609924,
0.03144094720482826,
0.09900669753551483,
-0.4887548089027405,
0.21350929141044617,
-0.4270220398902893,
-0.09893839806318283,
-0.13897904753684998,
-0.056690581142902374,
0.6422209739685059,
0.842017650604248,
-0.10987406969070435,
0.3784610629081726,
0.18065106868743896,
0.7235519886016846,
-1.1406445503234863,
-0.21537862718105316,
-0.4862026274204254,
0.23794163763523102,
-0.4389064908027649,
0.40605613589286804,
-0.2674049735069275,
-0.1796017438173294,
-0.01564774475991726,
-0.260842502117157,
0.26020923256874084,
-0.28575968742370605,
0.6301342844963074,
0.5625781416893005,
-0.49905404448509216,
0.8008408546447754,
-0.8307388424873352,
0.518760085105896,
-0.6939517259597778,
0.4063579738140106,
-0.09399902820587158,
0.7859240174293518,
-0.025674419477581978,
-1.0389851331710815,
-0.6281613111495972,
-0.15103180706501007,
0.10846663266420364,
0.30729565024375916,
-0.18048235774040222,
0.11686260253190994,
0.1689838171005249,
0.6519482135772705,
-0.7821981310844421,
0.4505547285079956,
-0.12870441377162933,
-0.09515919536352158,
0.8390481472015381,
0.3100886046886444,
-0.06078900769352913,
-0.09328631311655045,
-0.5011788010597229,
-0.756983757019043,
-0.39860019087791443,
-0.17403000593185425,
0.24029524624347687,
0.2586132287979126,
-0.02479887194931507,
0.5854713916778564,
-0.6546267867088318,
0.7772281765937805,
-0.031069094315171242,
0.3330514132976532,
0.2357790172100067,
-0.4780036211013794,
-0.38906651735305786,
-0.012426595203578472,
0.9301048517227173,
0.5631824135780334,
-0.3438100814819336,
-0.22994934022426605,
-0.23137368261814117,
0.38679713010787964,
0.3965570032596588,
-0.7387910485267639,
-0.37962865829467773,
0.12437555938959122,
-0.6899179816246033,
-0.39585137367248535,
-0.1184907928109169,
-0.9707216620445251,
-1.0146600008010864,
-0.23518450558185577,
0.4490552246570587,
-0.2120453268289566,
-0.40617650747299194,
0.10746102035045624,
-0.29430800676345825,
0.32044318318367004,
0.17331218719482422,
-0.562870442867279,
0.4795946776866913,
1.0261938571929932,
0.8135324120521545,
-0.4631275236606598,
-0.41814419627189636,
-0.2906518876552582,
-0.174608051776886,
-0.19826340675354004,
0.8717496395111084,
-0.30479326844215393,
-0.37738683819770813,
-0.20910386741161346,
-0.1515853852033615,
0.01682676002383232,
-0.5587807893753052,
0.5453217625617981,
-0.30252182483673096,
-0.21281220018863678,
-0.21455320715904236,
-0.772990882396698,
-0.27306851744651794,
0.27723413705825806,
-0.9140022993087769,
0.9208064079284668,
0.02120465599000454,
-0.42100533843040466,
0.2341495305299759,
-0.5880250334739685,
-0.485752135515213,
0.06733711808919907,
-0.08591123670339584,
-0.25168079137802124,
0.258928507566452,
-0.008497790433466434,
0.6229609847068787,
-0.8946800827980042,
0.22974041104316711,
-0.6484182476997375,
-0.3106699585914612,
0.057277631014585495,
-0.39975038170814514,
0.48033055663108826,
0.3045705556869507,
-0.5689130425453186,
0.3646383583545685,
-0.6845663189888,
0.2220526933670044,
0.12699070572853088,
0.09623443335294724,
0.0029220711439847946,
-0.155315563082695,
0.22329619526863098,
0.21964910626411438,
0.12543122470378876,
-0.47345879673957825,
0.2235821932554245,
-0.39416083693504333,
0.1555282324552536,
0.5674799680709839,
-0.06366906315088272,
0.3789287209510803,
-0.157812237739563,
0.18968980014324188,
-0.15650001168251038,
0.130325585603714,
-0.02597569115459919,
-0.16409389674663544,
-0.7596626281738281,
0.09603915363550186,
0.5735471844673157,
0.40086236596107483,
-0.2897051274776459,
0.5640918016433716,
-0.35332101583480835,
-1.2304447889328003,
-0.6175430417060852,
0.2203003168106079,
0.48542824387550354,
0.559083104133606,
0.31220754981040955,
-0.5760036110877991,
-0.45902419090270996,
-1.1395286321640015,
-0.23186664283275604,
0.35826870799064636,
0.12021993100643158,
0.10544546693563461,
0.5405504703521729,
-0.09930312633514404,
0.5632963180541992,
-0.3633354604244232,
-0.17203141748905182,
0.009128034114837646,
0.273485392332077,
0.05337268114089966,
0.7072063684463501,
0.4120214581489563,
-0.9090283513069153,
-0.2555696368217468,
0.14765682816505432,
-0.7307621836662292,
0.4449085295200348,
-0.07394885271787643,
-0.33425408601760864,
0.03028949163854122,
0.4930787682533264,
-0.7237755656242371,
0.28102967143058777,
0.5997308492660522,
-0.0938522145152092,
0.3861502707004547,
0.03981528431177139,
0.18083928525447845,
-1.173621416091919,
0.4594007432460785,
-0.14267462491989136,
0.09353604167699814,
-0.4453054666519165,
0.4314207434654236,
0.1377507597208023,
-0.4228498041629791,
-0.45393896102905273,
0.5647961497306824,
-0.1334756314754486,
-0.2920352518558502,
-0.4377138018608093,
0.02813081443309784,
-0.03812090680003166,
0.15601488947868347,
-0.208476722240448,
0.49633169174194336,
0.5039301514625549,
-0.4508359432220459,
0.9720617532730103,
0.07958680391311646,
-0.5467749834060669,
0.5166415572166443,
-0.7438703179359436,
0.21935419738292694,
0.23246408998966217,
0.37049010396003723,
-1.1337617635726929,
-0.25492557883262634,
0.1155235543847084,
-0.09137799590826035,
0.28796032071113586,
0.05464797839522362,
-0.71153324842453,
-0.4641159176826477,
-0.1236201599240303,
0.2995632588863373,
0.6776275634765625,
-0.6170161962509155,
0.8377776145935059,
0.2895662188529968,
0.26310649514198303,
-0.5824722647666931,
-0.5711238980293274,
-0.0877210795879364,
0.027601908892393112,
-0.6541488766670227,
0.7369396686553955,
0.0585259385406971,
-0.02663617581129074,
0.15028510987758636,
-0.30912506580352783,
-0.120443195104599,
0.36016395688056946,
0.47561711072921753,
0.2479270100593567,
-0.18239045143127441,
0.23294872045516968,
0.1302698701620102,
-0.2917163074016571,
-0.11646372079849243,
-0.16974295675754547,
0.7914038300514221,
-0.15824846923351288,
-0.6480021476745605,
-0.31367942690849304,
0.036645207554101944,
0.5013321042060852,
-0.5328077673912048,
0.4310932159423828,
0.9486161470413208,
-0.516228973865509,
0.04300139471888542,
-0.8256620764732361,
-0.4049093425273895,
-0.4530937373638153,
0.3126870095729828,
-0.35089024901390076,
-0.547940194606781,
0.4589548110961914,
-0.5093182325363159,
0.18829728662967682,
0.8163198828697205,
0.38427942991256714,
-0.04824953153729439,
1.0893769264221191,
0.4157889187335968,
-0.30194559693336487,
0.171979621052742,
-0.28077441453933716,
-0.24984683096408844,
-0.7112476229667664,
-0.23308610916137695,
-0.5273380875587463,
-0.9011984467506409,
-0.4248219430446625,
-0.40541431307792664,
0.0539991557598114,
-0.011990498751401901,
-0.34206902980804443,
0.30079224705696106,
-0.7535693645477295,
0.548577606678009,
0.7689617276191711,
0.1917772740125656,
-0.030580587685108185,
-0.17773891985416412,
0.04066808894276619,
0.2823995053768158,
-0.5346704721450806,
-0.05066969618201256,
1.0572552680969238,
0.023253872990608215,
0.6255882978439331,
-0.10703860968351364,
0.7694317102432251,
0.25778669118881226,
-0.05162719637155533,
-0.4720403254032135,
0.7414175271987915,
-0.4298195242881775,
-0.6930673718452454,
-0.2360067367553711,
-0.37763717770576477,
-0.976067066192627,
0.4154950678348541,
-0.5046892166137695,
-0.7005203366279602,
0.28153112530708313,
0.1771986484527588,
-0.5271081328392029,
0.39375966787338257,
-0.593803346157074,
1.4383893013000488,
-0.3669995069503784,
-0.4487629532814026,
-0.7250664830207825,
-0.7452340722084045,
0.6141726970672607,
0.05642141401767731,
-0.29293230175971985,
-0.48978129029273987,
0.19291703402996063,
0.5529335141181946,
-0.07546884566545486,
0.8666173219680786,
-0.16258063912391663,
0.2437782734632492,
0.02383635938167572,
0.17028090357780457,
0.3892415463924408,
-0.22556830942630768,
-0.13925093412399292,
0.19424016773700714,
-0.017797473818063736,
-0.22983531653881073,
-0.4834180176258087,
0.9952887892723083,
-0.7893913388252258,
-0.3011854290962219,
-0.18116776645183563,
-0.5679320096969604,
-0.23099805414676666,
0.5671441555023193,
0.3271317481994629,
0.15832409262657166,
-0.5046960711479187,
0.5818222761154175,
0.5743660926818848,
0.027301443740725517,
0.28685927391052246,
0.11436457931995392,
-0.10323482006788254,
-0.3017163574695587,
0.8917025327682495,
-0.2284928411245346,
0.1448127031326294,
0.3938945531845093,
-0.031707752496004105,
-0.22359153628349304,
-0.6314375996589661,
-0.22748415172100067,
-0.16976259648799896,
-0.8108533620834351,
-0.4965273439884186,
-0.368084192276001,
-0.19120964407920837,
-0.4374569356441498,
-0.09537526965141296,
-0.7673705816268921,
-0.2772531807422638,
-0.10262643545866013,
0.14753510057926178,
0.15935227274894714,
0.3259263038635254,
0.005876720882952213,
0.2701765298843384,
-0.905517578125,
0.530502438545227,
0.30117547512054443,
0.5916576981544495,
0.04544458165764809,
-0.04433964937925339,
0.013145577162504196,
0.08422409743070602,
-0.4180283546447754,
-0.5827747583389282,
-0.013772370293736458,
0.1509244441986084,
0.7485094666481018,
0.2733486294746399,
0.16673840582370758,
0.6276717185974121,
-0.09096628427505493,
0.7390231490135193,
0.35189101099967957,
-0.9444684386253357,
0.5926738977432251,
-0.11224666237831116,
0.5719406008720398,
0.7706426978111267,
0.0483197420835495,
-0.40913665294647217,
0.0943911001086235,
-0.7136552929878235,
-0.9144456386566162,
0.47790592908859253,
-0.02007242850959301,
0.010266653262078762,
0.5386369824409485,
0.14905431866645813,
0.19101248681545258,
0.1343996375799179,
-0.21824020147323608,
-0.2609112560749054,
-0.36222389340400696,
-0.2748802900314331,
-0.37364813685417175,
0.11652855575084686,
-0.4043416380882263,
-0.3618408441543579,
0.6452800035476685,
-0.21813514828681946,
-0.019649693742394447,
-0.2824268937110901,
-0.1648099571466446,
-0.007375530898571014,
0.03193345665931702,
0.4784702956676483,
0.4277889132499695,
-0.1929880827665329,
0.06478021293878555,
0.4255034327507019,
-0.040168169885873795,
-0.032490093261003494,
0.8742918968200684,
0.011705325916409492,
-0.15221399068832397,
0.12045692652463913,
1.0232603549957275,
0.5028835535049438,
-0.7742246389389038,
0.13219337165355682,
-0.08278524875640869,
-0.2610320746898651,
0.025053566321730614,
0.44786354899406433,
0.20265039801597595,
0.559381365776062,
0.06731150299310684,
0.27967289090156555,
0.5047614574432373,
-0.20441536605358124,
0.13660117983818054,
0.4706317186355591,
-0.43055713176727295,
0.10193315148353577,
0.5347302556037903,
0.3386285603046417,
0.10638675093650818,
0.7859288454055786,
0.10379145294427872,
-0.17351123690605164,
0.6331875920295715,
0.10958468168973923,
1.069139003753662,
-0.14539332687854767,
0.23894867300987244,
0.35541263222694397,
0.07542867958545685,
-0.2495449036359787,
0.07219702750444412,
-0.12821705639362335,
-0.6215606927871704,
-0.24252377450466156,
-0.4532504379749298,
-0.45039767026901245,
-0.034145426005125046,
-0.7955688238143921,
0.06749238818883896,
-0.3968965709209442,
-0.20354998111724854,
0.505651593208313,
0.10308458656072617,
-0.7698782086372375,
0.15586628019809723,
0.523082971572876,
1.2136781215667725,
-0.5658407211303711,
0.5437000393867493,
0.7138198018074036,
-0.19873332977294922,
-0.6615362167358398,
-0.37722453474998474,
0.19057658314704895,
-0.5048269629478455,
0.2002284973859787,
0.22480244934558868,
0.021841276437044144,
0.07030737400054932,
-0.4158477485179901,
-0.7917039394378662,
1.2655761241912842,
0.5045996308326721,
-0.7798923850059509,
0.11939951032400131,
0.06584246456623077,
0.3010105788707733,
-0.19427454471588135,
-0.04308401793241501,
0.7137264609336853,
0.5674554109573364,
0.13009756803512573,
-0.9205790758132935,
0.2830219864845276,
-0.37069767713546753,
0.10774658620357513,
0.3287501037120819,
-0.42344415187835693,
0.8493285179138184,
0.040280867367982864,
-0.1095370277762413,
0.25154614448547363,
0.5102527141571045,
0.1392243206501007,
0.2837587893009186,
0.6267802119255066,
0.7064365744590759,
0.7983589172363281,
-0.43393468856811523,
1.238940954208374,
-0.2907666862010956,
0.3843892514705658,
1.1620601415634155,
-0.6507409811019897,
0.8896580934524536,
0.18455161154270172,
0.018627244979143143,
0.2798575460910797,
0.7345095872879028,
-0.6290058493614197,
0.7140461206436157,
0.07725085318088531,
-0.1186690628528595,
-0.531863808631897,
-0.3425450026988983,
-0.6641297340393066,
0.44073066115379333,
-0.06615032255649567,
-0.24066860973834991,
-0.41043007373809814,
0.17185254395008087,
-0.505305290222168,
-0.1915581226348877,
-0.3050200343132019,
0.8921199440956116,
-0.09164713323116302,
-0.7137264609336853,
0.4116838872432709,
-0.25530168414115906,
0.4789423644542694,
-0.6058459877967834,
0.060807984322309494,
0.07881800085306168,
0.7698377370834351,
-0.07232465595006943,
-0.9927966594696045,
-0.0403980128467083,
-0.48372137546539307,
-0.11138486862182617,
0.09162934124469757,
1.1884489059448242,
-0.19944484531879425,
-0.3875776529312134,
0.18112507462501526,
0.32671189308166504,
-0.16049590706825256,
-0.3696421682834625,
-0.8384177684783936,
0.34749892354011536,
-0.16377593576908112,
-0.17262627184391022,
0.504542350769043,
-0.14558197557926178,
0.3597531020641327,
0.5471171736717224,
0.7175719141960144,
-0.38371822237968445,
-0.13393597304821014,
0.17056137323379517,
0.9471347332000732,
-0.6463760733604431,
-0.18352457880973816,
-0.758735716342926,
0.6693288087844849,
-0.5093016028404236,
-0.5615823268890381,
0.6898326277732849,
0.5320609211921692,
0.9065009951591492,
-0.12090301513671875,
0.7044228911399841,
0.02282704971730709,
0.24807126820087433,
-0.2903379499912262,
0.8053450584411621,
-0.7701287865638733,
-0.2776288390159607,
-0.2819199562072754,
-0.9495176076889038,
-0.24224649369716644,
0.30000677704811096,
0.044097431004047394,
0.12353717535734177,
0.38175180554389954,
0.48298361897468567,
-0.17845016717910767,
0.1990295797586441,
0.2488340139389038,
-0.02946363016963005,
0.07351057976484299,
0.41081613302230835,
0.7329448461532593,
-0.46745941042900085,
0.5738855600357056,
-0.853564977645874,
0.15229374170303345,
-0.3791952133178711,
-0.7468888759613037,
-0.5729684829711914,
-0.5907859802246094,
-0.41057053208351135,
-0.19185000658035278,
-0.042013492435216904,
0.6747555732727051,
1.0812245607376099,
-0.6724847555160522,
-0.22520022094249725,
-0.3513871431350708,
0.042632807046175,
-0.7164678573608398,
-0.15220162272453308,
0.24664337933063507,
-0.15297575294971466,
-0.5091701745986938,
0.5411337614059448,
0.06973955780267715,
0.060350824147462845,
-0.340656578540802,
0.00016444106586277485,
-0.02839783951640129,
-0.3137708008289337,
0.37676817178726196,
0.41127631068229675,
-0.6098315715789795,
0.009177913889288902,
0.009547014720737934,
-0.186496302485466,
-0.4345909059047699,
0.6666498780250549,
-0.7735280394554138,
0.5806645750999451,
0.572770893573761,
1.0897853374481201,
0.7557653188705444,
-0.2450425624847412,
0.6733413338661194,
-0.6911507844924927,
-0.03656729683279991,
0.3952593505382538,
0.4018126428127289,
0.27526360750198364,
-0.07285483181476593,
0.7188798785209656,
-0.0410679467022419,
-0.4207436740398407,
-1.1518925428390503,
0.07793283462524414,
-1.18455970287323,
-0.4501149654388428,
0.6653693318367004,
0.11167774349451065,
-0.03029310517013073,
0.5408423542976379,
-0.08935967832803726,
0.49960988759994507,
-0.06739568710327148,
0.6017642617225647,
0.5240495800971985,
-0.10165076702833176,
-0.3911176025867462,
-0.17714492976665497,
0.1743360012769699,
0.6706812977790833,
-0.9723684787750244,
0.24616721272468567,
0.4908352494239807,
-0.030776815488934517,
0.27137333154678345,
-0.07001321762800217,
0.24235843122005463,
0.6926683187484741,
0.26299723982810974,
0.3592284619808197,
-0.14158222079277039,
-0.14106285572052002,
-0.369817316532135,
0.2922605872154236,
-0.1908189058303833,
-0.22198794782161713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03248v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03248v2
|
Large Language Models as Evaluators for Recommendation Explanations
| 2024-06-05T13:23:23 | 2024-06-06T04:31:37 |
Xiaoyu Zhang, Yishan Li, Jiayin Wang, Bowen Sun, Weizhi Ma, Peijie Sun, Min Zhang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The explainability of recommender systems has attracted significant attention
in academia and industry. Many efforts have been made for explainable
recommendations, yet evaluating the quality of the explanations remains a
challenging and unresolved issue. In recent years, leveraging LLMs as
evaluators presents a promising avenue in Natural Language Processing tasks
(e.g., sentiment classification, information extraction), as they perform
strong capabilities in instruction following and common-sense reasoning.
However, evaluating recommendation explanatory texts is different from these
NLG tasks, as its criteria are related to human perceptions and are usually
subjective. In this paper, we investigate whether LLMs can serve as evaluators
of recommendation explanations. To answer the question, we utilize real user
feedback on explanations given from previous work and additionally collect
third-party annotations and LLM evaluations. We design and apply a 3-level meta
evaluation strategy to measure the correlation between evaluator labels and the
ground truth provided by users. Our experiments reveal that LLMs, such as GPT4,
can provide comparable evaluations with appropriate prompts and settings. We
also provide further insights into combining human labels with the LLM
evaluation process and utilizing ensembles of multiple heterogeneous LLM
evaluators to enhance the accuracy and stability of evaluations. Our study
verifies that utilizing LLMs as evaluators can be an accurate, reproducible and
cost-effective solution for evaluating recommendation explanation texts. Our
code is available at https://github.com/Xiaoyu-SZ/LLMasEvaluator.
|
[
-0.38876470923423767,
-0.6999123692512512,
1.0225818157196045,
0.06499193608760834,
-0.37778663635253906,
-0.21598969399929047,
-0.5465501546859741,
-0.41878414154052734,
0.08453387022018433,
0.3661966621875763,
-0.690270721912384,
-0.6222155690193176,
-0.4854135513305664,
0.26488620042800903,
-0.23807959258556366,
1.3887100219726562,
-0.15277351438999176,
0.16835132241249084,
-0.48855772614479065,
0.003775313962250948,
-0.6046270728111267,
-0.29629090428352356,
-0.5425376296043396,
-0.7336826920509338,
0.7821324467658997,
0.33071717619895935,
0.6222916841506958,
0.22394022345542908,
0.38814595341682434,
0.27234262228012085,
-0.14095543324947357,
0.30434247851371765,
-0.33962538838386536,
0.18490678071975708,
-0.2477668970823288,
-0.41073763370513916,
-0.4903278350830078,
0.11324961483478546,
0.37023282051086426,
0.5758349299430847,
-0.21052108705043793,
0.23613062500953674,
0.27065256237983704,
0.696298360824585,
-0.5946555137634277,
0.09134236723184586,
-0.35729944705963135,
0.12530304491519928,
0.1757746934890747,
-0.40680333971977234,
-0.43320387601852417,
-0.6981092691421509,
0.5328866243362427,
-0.577470600605011,
0.10949736833572388,
0.2283688187599182,
0.568463921546936,
0.13370729982852936,
-0.032328955829143524,
-0.6221852898597717,
-0.8180944919586182,
0.7802132368087769,
-0.7844831347465515,
0.1670861840248108,
0.304620623588562,
0.5242588520050049,
-0.08291533589363098,
-0.4968757927417755,
-0.45562973618507385,
-0.3246053159236908,
-0.28952935338020325,
0.2074146866798401,
-0.3072530925273895,
0.02762836217880249,
0.05147527530789375,
0.5367350578308105,
-0.6297916173934937,
0.33250316977500916,
-0.07324571907520294,
-0.3608255088329315,
0.4728374779224396,
0.2490541785955429,
0.09431295096874237,
-0.16590243577957153,
-0.5296111106872559,
0.3283843696117401,
-0.5328623652458191,
0.019163016229867935,
0.361155241727829,
0.006547456607222557,
0.02981881983578205,
0.4829721450805664,
-0.005171344615519047,
0.7488132119178772,
0.11011848598718643,
-0.258976012468338,
0.12949059903621674,
-0.45538461208343506,
-0.28589722514152527,
-0.038573507219552994,
1.0224283933639526,
0.5694251656532288,
0.32453903555870056,
-0.12860476970672607,
-0.2483556568622589,
-0.20482613146305084,
0.12545500695705414,
-0.8133548498153687,
-0.0014334809966385365,
0.2245069444179535,
-0.7694462537765503,
-0.33774980902671814,
0.05127353593707085,
-0.704592227935791,
-0.6300743222236633,
-0.4224606454372406,
0.4501762092113495,
-0.19743305444717407,
0.007242048624902964,
0.20117461681365967,
-0.07688228040933609,
0.02000032551586628,
0.4062979817390442,
-0.7987890243530273,
0.32316073775291443,
0.6502959728240967,
0.6837869882583618,
-0.2816011309623718,
-0.3588300347328186,
-0.4796280860900879,
-0.08048362284898758,
-0.03483903035521507,
0.8275398015975952,
-0.5900231003761292,
-0.36602163314819336,
0.08283299952745438,
-0.007502850145101547,
0.17974069714546204,
-0.464173823595047,
0.7519397735595703,
-0.5041868686676025,
0.41083160042762756,
-0.3428862690925598,
-0.5536789298057556,
-0.5260792970657349,
0.2738858461380005,
-0.39110738039016724,
0.7828512787818909,
-0.08138339221477509,
-0.523389995098114,
0.45924633741378784,
-0.8048644065856934,
-0.2212018221616745,
0.13567133247852325,
0.15198059380054474,
-0.212856262922287,
0.09626413881778717,
0.5686501264572144,
0.7490282654762268,
-0.7222240567207336,
0.5267430543899536,
-0.4241984486579895,
-0.8013007044792175,
0.5420746803283691,
-0.7663543820381165,
0.390821248292923,
0.17449241876602173,
-0.10950043797492981,
0.37567418813705444,
-0.6118203401565552,
-0.2375471442937851,
0.04193837195634842,
-0.4012370705604553,
-0.18943141400814056,
-0.0022608591243624687,
-0.245635524392128,
-0.20802196860313416,
0.36029335856437683,
-0.18298715353012085,
-0.012527741491794586,
-0.43855226039886475,
0.36858290433883667,
0.8611621856689453,
0.11148560047149658,
0.4208301305770874,
-0.28104183077812195,
0.7691726088523865,
-0.3344479203224182,
0.022428477182984352,
-0.4074671268463135,
-0.3990602195262909,
-0.49880242347717285,
-0.2363433837890625,
0.14870299398899078,
0.043161261826753616,
-0.501264750957489,
0.397366464138031,
-0.20737038552761078,
-0.3816554844379425,
-0.41133615374565125,
0.315572053194046,
0.42861491441726685,
0.30348944664001465,
0.25509393215179443,
0.3304252326488495,
-0.535505473613739,
-0.907724916934967,
-0.6412950158119202,
-0.290330708026886,
-0.251006543636322,
0.4004078507423401,
0.34001463651657104,
-0.41345927119255066,
0.9634365439414978,
-0.38428163528442383,
0.04038234427571297,
-0.3982732594013214,
0.044504616409540176,
0.5445497035980225,
-0.22121036052703857,
0.395244300365448,
-0.3436645269393921,
-0.18482452630996704,
-0.1215510442852974,
-0.6131438612937927,
-0.4749986231327057,
0.0693402886390686,
0.14604434370994568,
-0.1071610152721405,
0.07882412523031235,
-0.35299545526504517,
-0.15001526474952698,
0.6554656624794006,
-0.3468343913555145,
0.803094208240509,
-0.389229953289032,
-0.031184077262878418,
-0.6739047169685364,
-0.1812898814678192,
0.3524358570575714,
-0.3338281810283661,
-0.3146807551383972,
-0.10378643125295639,
-0.29542240500450134,
0.09777311235666275,
-0.2621135115623474,
0.6295761466026306,
-0.33271872997283936,
-0.23140883445739746,
-0.3968987762928009,
0.5997713208198547,
0.2483428418636322,
0.3851664066314697,
-0.33426305651664734,
0.4756286144256592,
0.3352215588092804,
-0.5869990587234497,
0.5817508697509766,
-0.06543488800525665,
-0.4624062180519104,
0.5864344239234924,
-0.7033104300498962,
0.18828292191028595,
-0.028622746467590332,
0.6640951037406921,
-1.0791436433792114,
-0.19870059192180634,
0.4733799397945404,
-0.175480917096138,
-0.15948042273521423,
-0.22588901221752167,
-0.36807358264923096,
-0.451882541179657,
-0.5248432755470276,
-0.0018884247401729226,
0.3633662164211273,
-0.9541308283805847,
0.6435839533805847,
0.022350912913680077,
0.03676050156354904,
-0.5859614610671997,
-0.461353063583374,
0.014794443733990192,
-0.5360268950462341,
-0.41538023948669434,
0.1975904256105423,
-0.3199274241924286,
-0.3999022841453552,
0.018637971952557564,
-0.15497401356697083,
0.27358439564704895,
0.3426334261894226,
0.613308846950531,
0.5991750955581665,
-0.1642741858959198,
0.29937198758125305,
-0.15790043771266937,
-0.343180775642395,
0.33745551109313965,
-0.4107280373573303,
0.356560617685318,
-0.33738183975219727,
-0.4652327597141266,
-0.47167307138442993,
-0.19955293834209442,
0.39766550064086914,
-0.0036096572875976562,
0.5175359845161438,
1.0922763347625732,
-0.02368568442761898,
-0.16832970082759857,
-0.6873284578323364,
-0.0748104527592659,
-0.45794129371643066,
0.23556797206401825,
-0.39964422583580017,
-0.9908832907676697,
0.23289966583251953,
0.01709681563079357,
0.03717663884162903,
0.5684038996696472,
0.852263867855072,
-0.17804281413555145,
0.92784184217453,
0.2037370651960373,
-0.05069924518465996,
0.11423466354608536,
0.033495280891656876,
0.3832646310329437,
-0.8811386823654175,
-0.2134609967470169,
-0.37557005882263184,
-0.39116987586021423,
-0.35736513137817383,
-0.2348414957523346,
0.14261649549007416,
0.187570720911026,
0.14667323231697083,
-0.022093720734119415,
-0.45816922187805176,
0.7021210193634033,
0.24411550164222717,
0.024227941408753395,
0.3723079562187195,
-0.040829792618751526,
-0.043358150869607925,
0.1699681133031845,
-0.3780757784843445,
-0.9318271279335022,
0.9266766905784607,
0.7256038784980774,
0.8223811388015747,
0.04118397459387779,
0.4074271321296692,
0.45677533745765686,
0.5467018485069275,
-1.1296435594558716,
0.5672158002853394,
-0.14112892746925354,
-0.2392604649066925,
-0.3008212447166443,
-0.29564040899276733,
-0.5533934831619263,
0.556235134601593,
-0.29529494047164917,
-0.7583616971969604,
-0.11898276209831238,
0.09060630202293396,
-0.4239141643047333,
0.0018147594528272748,
-0.6585261821746826,
0.6727387309074402,
-0.4133206605911255,
-0.22487546503543854,
-0.33213135600090027,
-0.1600191742181778,
0.43306952714920044,
-0.2443205565214157,
0.43677639961242676,
-0.2412646859884262,
0.07163656502962112,
1.0127217769622803,
-0.32522571086883545,
0.6548224091529846,
-0.3423427641391754,
-0.3516296446323395,
0.18139220774173737,
0.0584220215678215,
0.432429701089859,
0.2004723846912384,
-0.5362207293510437,
0.28475087881088257,
-0.013822678476572037,
0.11683952063322067,
-0.9815752506256104,
0.9968985319137573,
-0.6454353332519531,
-0.898856520652771,
-0.03226358816027641,
-0.41906651854515076,
-0.18660101294517517,
-0.08270204067230225,
-0.05557147040963173,
0.3388507068157196,
-0.12825971841812134,
0.3018583357334137,
0.2586163282394409,
-0.29700154066085815,
0.3988323211669922,
0.6376523971557617,
-0.5434313416481018,
-0.44242414832115173,
0.9701569080352783,
-0.32178083062171936,
-0.08502677828073502,
0.3114834725856781,
0.7937397956848145,
-0.39089855551719666,
-0.8073060512542725,
-0.404435932636261,
0.18900255858898163,
-0.9378306865692139,
0.0733729749917984,
-0.5581899285316467,
0.23696109652519226,
0.14354394376277924,
-0.11912378668785095,
0.3744184672832489,
-0.32407087087631226,
-0.26456183195114136,
-0.40481850504875183,
0.2499428540468216,
1.011623501777649,
0.12592822313308716,
0.37764638662338257,
-0.6134341359138489,
0.3322763442993164,
0.36581259965896606,
0.3389016091823578,
0.0711798444390297,
-0.5914844870567322,
-0.4859531819820404,
0.06938455998897552,
-0.0693545863032341,
-0.783682644367218,
0.15543463826179504,
0.05295270308852196,
0.5618840456008911,
0.7648869156837463,
-0.22291457653045654,
0.6112924814224243,
-0.2525995075702667,
1.0583910942077637,
0.08794540911912918,
-0.8794082403182983,
0.37630051374435425,
-0.32243967056274414,
0.2036425620317459,
0.37074407935142517,
0.26857879757881165,
-0.28500205278396606,
-0.1944751888513565,
-0.20822395384311676,
-0.573973536491394,
0.8416770100593567,
-0.004156278446316719,
-0.03176334872841835,
0.22992542386054993,
0.6244701743125916,
0.4388827085494995,
-0.003881101729348302,
-0.7089099884033203,
-0.2692803740501404,
0.014987208880484104,
-0.12142681330442429,
-0.5087050795555115,
-0.8035522103309631,
-0.19706472754478455,
0.14505726099014282,
0.6955500245094299,
-0.08427496254444122,
-0.0038963728584349155,
-0.06929491460323334,
-0.12684975564479828,
-0.12054402381181717,
0.4620387852191925,
0.5515338182449341,
0.7808637022972107,
-0.36106184124946594,
0.24357280135154724,
0.312461256980896,
-0.05442436411976814,
0.17570842802524567,
-0.02038651332259178,
0.20793019235134125,
0.13693585991859436,
0.5645971894264221,
0.8960807919502258,
0.29556283354759216,
-0.5168041586875916,
0.5765525698661804,
-0.2926110029220581,
-0.2662432789802551,
-0.18265077471733093,
0.11335056275129318,
0.23464956879615784,
0.17547225952148438,
0.28839829564094543,
-0.15072360634803772,
0.3129078447818756,
-0.4912738502025604,
-0.23951542377471924,
0.4823329746723175,
-0.49190986156463623,
-0.380962610244751,
0.34775128960609436,
0.297184556722641,
-0.4001479148864746,
0.10053390264511108,
0.1264166235923767,
-0.5057410001754761,
0.3470972776412964,
0.5286971926689148,
1.061102271080017,
0.06472969800233841,
0.31065404415130615,
0.04604893922805786,
0.0747043564915657,
-0.05058002471923828,
-0.2447734922170639,
-0.3643518388271332,
-0.7295120358467102,
-0.534313440322876,
-0.8263062834739685,
-0.6742619276046753,
0.08543571829795837,
-0.5741775631904602,
0.33578017354011536,
-0.23359958827495575,
-0.0626617819070816,
0.2725740671157837,
-0.214573934674263,
-0.5914754867553711,
0.06511447578668594,
0.1840985119342804,
0.616048276424408,
-0.7033597230911255,
0.4000304937362671,
0.7200095653533936,
-0.2553311884403229,
-0.6304556727409363,
0.18246173858642578,
0.007565037347376347,
-0.7838290929794312,
0.771796703338623,
0.2069096565246582,
-0.3766116201877594,
-0.5018629431724548,
-0.2771264612674713,
-0.408363401889801,
0.950881838798523,
0.389710396528244,
-0.6601141095161438,
-0.035807494074106216,
-0.07648009806871414,
0.807598352432251,
-0.424275666475296,
0.8785815834999084,
0.6494566202163696,
0.9101076126098633,
0.013467020355165005,
-0.6376736760139465,
0.16792546212673187,
-0.021652888506650925,
-0.15341030061244965,
-0.1665789633989334,
-0.25940945744514465,
0.31501710414886475,
-0.21093815565109253,
0.133490189909935,
-0.05085406452417374,
0.35150542855262756,
0.435870885848999,
0.4291177988052368,
0.6860266327857971,
0.09906227141618729,
0.7179231643676758,
-0.07632826268672943,
1.2598589658737183,
-0.11493843793869019,
0.3158356845378876,
1.0763440132141113,
-0.1065414547920227,
0.4765450060367584,
0.42942357063293457,
-0.38236749172210693,
0.8918634057044983,
0.8236244916915894,
-0.14093077182769775,
0.20652088522911072,
0.30308961868286133,
-0.014077848754823208,
-0.24887830018997192,
-0.12976065278053284,
0.020102139562368393,
0.3126857578754425,
0.2772223651409149,
-0.5916100740432739,
-0.17109091579914093,
0.11857607215642929,
-0.19261905550956726,
-0.1532609760761261,
-0.19058582186698914,
0.8522613644599915,
0.19351795315742493,
-0.6867809891700745,
0.5815054774284363,
0.129313126206398,
0.5756316781044006,
-0.3493479788303375,
-0.16869311034679413,
0.03535635396838188,
0.1417587399482727,
-0.5554434657096863,
-0.8787132501602173,
-0.016691073775291443,
0.20432010293006897,
-0.31178170442581177,
-0.49677473306655884,
0.7034922242164612,
-0.05386672168970108,
-0.34959614276885986,
0.3566676676273346,
0.3409634828567505,
0.4532860815525055,
0.003272284986451268,
-0.5538062453269958,
-0.008440239354968071,
0.12676085531711578,
-0.35839131474494934,
0.08462993800640106,
0.2738535404205322,
0.14709971845149994,
0.8009958863258362,
0.7649373412132263,
0.07058446854352951,
-0.4416408836841583,
0.5459231734275818,
0.4957919120788574,
-0.5195074677467346,
-0.19419726729393005,
-1.308151364326477,
0.33624327182769775,
0.33711156249046326,
-0.036230649799108505,
0.9483171105384827,
0.27219024300575256,
0.3313595950603485,
-0.011870510876178741,
0.7724959254264832,
0.4694969058036804,
0.4824734926223755,
-0.6771554946899414,
0.39520013332366943,
-0.39598312973976135,
1.0069239139556885,
-0.2328719198703766,
-1.3598095178604126,
-0.09657756984233856,
0.3303256034851074,
-0.5011069178581238,
0.2215365171432495,
0.6971454620361328,
0.3958013355731964,
0.12453491240739822,
0.29627153277397156,
0.3125532567501068,
0.2800755202770233,
0.4890007972717285,
0.2766787111759186,
1.1458405256271362,
-0.04324554279446602,
0.5851080417633057,
0.06439134478569031,
-0.13087695837020874,
-0.5587502717971802,
-0.8977891206741333,
-1.0532333850860596,
-0.18869778513908386,
-0.13097430765628815,
-0.2013699859380722,
0.13062375783920288,
0.9908323884010315,
0.4506126940250397,
-0.5797598958015442,
-0.16016605496406555,
0.09703151136636734,
0.4452199339866638,
-0.09833940118551254,
-0.27818751335144043,
0.3507245182991028,
-0.14635954797267914,
-0.6886605620384216,
0.7298436164855957,
0.35058632493019104,
-0.33350425958633423,
-0.7533562779426575,
-0.32232382893562317,
0.48085251450538635,
-0.10522015392780304,
0.5746697783470154,
-0.36995550990104675,
-1.253554344177246,
-0.3349758982658386,
-0.2639825940132141,
0.22432368993759155,
-0.07974818348884583,
0.8027474284172058,
-0.8770326972007751,
0.5374411344528198,
0.4195373058319092,
0.4657267928123474,
0.38408318161964417,
0.10420314967632294,
0.7819399237632751,
-0.28181594610214233,
-0.44689035415649414,
-0.0552087239921093,
0.5531113147735596,
0.28355440497398376,
-0.386836975812912,
0.4844871163368225,
-0.26689329743385315,
-0.6098182201385498,
-0.6822900772094727,
-0.13102836906909943,
-0.857650876045227,
-0.12220088392496109,
1.4806488752365112,
-0.29940682649612427,
0.045922696590423584,
0.029109392315149307,
-0.40525826811790466,
-0.05077331140637398,
-0.5263051986694336,
0.6182636022567749,
0.964168131351471,
-0.14052219688892365,
-0.15799930691719055,
-0.3354109823703766,
0.24700798094272614,
0.2663939595222473,
-0.7573196291923523,
0.09413141012191772,
0.4718313217163086,
0.31027403473854065,
0.043172791600227356,
0.3472677171230316,
-0.0010007912060245872,
0.2027987688779831,
-0.6981483697891235,
-0.0903744027018547,
-0.22823509573936462,
-0.03679801896214485,
-0.850570559501648,
0.14580358564853668,
0.3259979486465454,
0.07545378804206848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03239v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03239v2
|
Document-level Claim Extraction and Decontextualisation for Fact-Checking
| 2024-06-05T13:16:46 | 2024-06-12T11:11:48 |
Zhenyun Deng, Michael Schlichtkrull, Andreas Vlachos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Selecting which claims to check is a time-consuming task for human
fact-checkers, especially from documents consisting of multiple sentences and
containing multiple claims. However, existing claim extraction approaches focus
more on identifying and extracting claims from individual sentences, e.g.,
identifying whether a sentence contains a claim or the exact boundaries of the
claim within a sentence. In this paper, we propose a method for document-level
claim extraction for fact-checking, which aims to extract check-worthy claims
from documents and decontextualise them so that they can be understood out of
context. Specifically, we first recast claim extraction as extractive
summarization in order to identify central sentences from documents, then
rewrite them to include necessary context from the originating document through
sentence decontextualisation. Evaluation with both automatic metrics and a
fact-checking professional shows that our method is able to extract
check-worthy claims from documents more accurately than previous work, while
also improving evidence retrieval.
|
[
-0.23853084444999695,
-0.4576750099658966,
0.5573557615280151,
0.01651996374130249,
-0.31799817085266113,
0.10707782953977585,
0.10187717527151108,
-0.7532173991203308,
0.13416787981987,
0.34135451912879944,
-0.2420715093612671,
-0.32170891761779785,
-0.941638171672821,
0.3417645990848541,
-0.5906168818473816,
1.0061005353927612,
-0.1720454841852188,
-0.37161707878112793,
-0.6331309080123901,
0.12048736959695816,
-0.3132808208465576,
-0.1766851395368576,
-0.5166066288948059,
-0.42393365502357483,
0.4202286899089813,
0.3930251896381378,
0.21921342611312866,
0.4390234351158142,
0.4330768585205078,
0.33578622341156006,
-0.18214064836502075,
0.5305303335189819,
-0.029197605326771736,
0.017008792608976364,
-0.32211917638778687,
-0.4871022403240204,
-0.45037129521369934,
0.15367867052555084,
0.6690199375152588,
0.07859724760055542,
0.0886501669883728,
0.2942182123661041,
-0.12911760807037354,
0.33526137471199036,
-0.9579350352287292,
0.5400760769844055,
-0.5356964468955994,
0.16676999628543854,
-0.04604014381766319,
-0.23607264459133148,
-0.4285339415073395,
-0.5336180329322815,
-0.019584938883781433,
-0.45648595690727234,
0.5072535276412964,
0.040120311081409454,
1.2140713930130005,
0.03735575079917908,
-0.7613953948020935,
-0.3815069794654846,
-0.3598383665084839,
0.39484381675720215,
-0.74797123670578,
0.33028730750083923,
0.36446112394332886,
0.15326344966888428,
0.20780250430107117,
-0.8720118403434753,
-0.6221905946731567,
-0.011067650280892849,
-0.7823891043663025,
0.29823341965675354,
-0.2844332158565521,
-0.1699816733598709,
0.6109316945075989,
0.5255663394927979,
-0.45867037773132324,
-0.1490730345249176,
-0.5850328207015991,
-0.756740927696228,
0.6476871967315674,
-0.39022985100746155,
0.4799463450908661,
-0.547563374042511,
-0.4483937621116638,
0.05337325856089592,
-0.6309340000152588,
0.05581957474350929,
-0.003448450705036521,
0.16090208292007446,
0.04732202738523483,
0.460321843624115,
-0.5091493129730225,
0.387717068195343,
0.15943779051303864,
-0.6278361082077026,
0.15486742556095123,
-0.5760222673416138,
-0.3072812855243683,
0.5285416841506958,
0.44269832968711853,
0.28268522024154663,
-0.3606277406215668,
-0.37301838397979736,
-0.2905418574810028,
-0.10732965916395187,
0.21542520821094513,
-0.8242729306221008,
0.21120040118694305,
0.4048067033290863,
-0.541229248046875,
-0.40411755442619324,
0.2788504958152771,
-0.8643527626991272,
-0.5162187218666077,
0.029633905738592148,
0.4388129413127899,
-0.3112138509750366,
-0.3389580249786377,
0.005891603417694569,
-0.5771881341934204,
0.3498241603374481,
0.36004796624183655,
-0.5345607399940491,
-0.13943621516227722,
0.5756816267967224,
0.6647711992263794,
0.08818146586418152,
-0.0663018748164177,
-0.8613521456718445,
0.25911396741867065,
-0.30934563279151917,
1.072564721107483,
-0.27532702684402466,
-0.30596625804901123,
0.17600277066230774,
0.1800626814365387,
0.109813392162323,
-0.5314246416091919,
1.1704964637756348,
-0.6252899169921875,
0.3603103756904602,
-0.5404278039932251,
-0.407722532749176,
-0.22151358425617218,
0.6643960475921631,
-0.8598175644874573,
0.8875674605369568,
0.19152849912643433,
-0.7636025547981262,
0.689677357673645,
-0.643670916557312,
-0.8236251473426819,
0.1382937729358673,
-0.21173177659511566,
-0.3657244145870209,
0.19794578850269318,
0.47804296016693115,
0.27588123083114624,
-0.3183267414569855,
0.19162151217460632,
0.2891736924648285,
0.1532246321439743,
0.06847123801708221,
-0.10125068575143814,
1.036497950553894,
0.3311655521392822,
-0.6379416584968567,
-0.12122002989053726,
-0.821980357170105,
-0.27089250087738037,
0.06054389476776123,
-0.5908757448196411,
-0.46552398800849915,
0.07107699662446976,
-0.34748271107673645,
0.3076494038105011,
0.4891781210899353,
-1.0845221281051636,
0.16178935766220093,
-0.2498181164264679,
0.25241363048553467,
0.12477735430002213,
0.07086239755153656,
0.2045448273420334,
-0.35659319162368774,
0.35578295588493347,
0.11382527649402618,
-0.1191134825348854,
-0.4912237823009491,
0.040161602199077606,
-0.6272293329238892,
-0.5126358866691589,
0.5520192384719849,
0.7187144160270691,
-0.6923915147781372,
0.6250999569892883,
-0.28247377276420593,
-0.07239247113466263,
-0.3440815210342407,
0.006000552326440811,
0.2900741994380951,
0.9214602112770081,
0.5168251991271973,
-0.04385371506214142,
-0.5687678456306458,
-0.7678451538085938,
-0.5740251541137695,
-0.37711137533187866,
-0.11696182191371918,
-0.23011954128742218,
0.508668839931488,
-0.07738122344017029,
1.3208643198013306,
-0.7555361390113831,
-0.32751592993736267,
-0.27951866388320923,
0.5843978524208069,
-0.09162310510873795,
0.3023088574409485,
0.5158423185348511,
-0.9804576635360718,
-0.2420559823513031,
0.11167455464601517,
-0.8981299996376038,
-0.27804702520370483,
-0.4621398448944092,
0.15838588774204254,
0.18769094347953796,
0.5541999340057373,
-0.7902125120162964,
0.4672398865222931,
-0.0922028049826622,
-0.3921778202056885,
0.3360840976238251,
-0.3209691345691681,
0.2975211441516876,
-0.9992320537567139,
-0.0014100847765803337,
0.021118052303791046,
-0.651934027671814,
-0.334854394197464,
0.22237026691436768,
0.5871900320053101,
0.020982718095183372,
-0.2855849862098694,
0.29216867685317993,
-0.8192304968833923,
-0.021981142461299896,
-0.29938170313835144,
0.4129975140094757,
0.48156359791755676,
0.1331106573343277,
-0.11166861653327942,
0.4276435375213623,
0.533309280872345,
-0.3511199653148651,
0.1916620433330536,
0.30397123098373413,
-0.581191897392273,
0.8773460388183594,
-0.3681858777999878,
-0.15451891720294952,
-0.3197101652622223,
0.4410279095172882,
-1.2461923360824585,
-0.1454119086265564,
0.05458535999059677,
-0.2835719883441925,
0.2908809781074524,
-0.06010269373655319,
-0.4638647735118866,
-0.2588602304458618,
-0.3174656331539154,
-0.045281991362571716,
0.1998201161623001,
-0.8219152092933655,
1.0938432216644287,
0.4442957639694214,
-0.3957006633281708,
-0.7651550769805908,
-0.5705444812774658,
0.38167357444763184,
-0.26656365394592285,
-0.3318715989589691,
0.573075532913208,
0.5429027080535889,
-0.3955744206905365,
-0.11529970169067383,
-0.5612016320228577,
-0.16883979737758636,
0.2135934829711914,
0.0977192297577858,
0.1908026486635208,
-0.015832828357815742,
-0.0348941870033741,
0.5968249440193176,
-0.2402501255273819,
0.37257373332977295,
-0.13452313840389252,
-0.07507253438234329,
0.18707437813282013,
-0.2959725558757782,
-0.2434876263141632,
0.8274295926094055,
0.5432986617088318,
-0.6270293593406677,
0.26938939094543457,
0.7305927276611328,
-0.672252357006073,
0.0802040547132492,
-0.818748414516449,
0.0162245761603117,
-0.3872525691986084,
0.16488221287727356,
-0.41190120577812195,
-0.6829453110694885,
0.43725624680519104,
-0.4035485088825226,
0.5852109789848328,
1.0344113111495972,
0.13245783746242523,
-0.1371898651123047,
0.4884604215621948,
0.47014355659484863,
0.02828202396631241,
0.28028810024261475,
-0.11456496268510818,
0.3432829678058624,
-0.46230071783065796,
-0.3880773186683655,
-0.8607045412063599,
0.12979871034622192,
-0.11299187690019608,
-0.12859584391117096,
0.3376692235469818,
0.0941702201962471,
0.29248014092445374,
0.42215943336486816,
-0.1653091460466385,
0.6645426154136658,
0.11656676232814789,
0.2980031669139862,
0.7189292311668396,
0.05234498903155327,
0.1963464915752411,
0.2816493511199951,
-0.221244677901268,
-0.3693801164627075,
0.542744517326355,
0.08254819363355637,
0.2852351665496826,
0.4947429299354553,
0.9162285327911377,
0.6730228662490845,
0.483242005109787,
-0.6703941226005554,
0.36484500765800476,
-0.035461559891700745,
-0.5952221155166626,
-0.20018018782138824,
-0.3994101285934448,
-0.9394530057907104,
0.5158287286758423,
-0.4666043519973755,
-0.6319648623466492,
0.5157429575920105,
-0.19079917669296265,
-0.5785946846008301,
0.085584357380867,
-0.5554394721984863,
0.6326811909675598,
-0.10988159477710724,
0.15878617763519287,
-0.35766682028770447,
-0.69579017162323,
0.4372127950191498,
-0.13736020028591156,
0.29146185517311096,
-0.000031652274628868327,
0.17103271186351776,
0.7342140078544617,
-0.50229412317276,
0.9740793704986572,
-0.14601458609104156,
-0.6434066295623779,
0.46604254841804504,
0.11650004982948303,
0.6464672684669495,
0.18828964233398438,
0.04757646098732948,
0.07100829482078552,
0.34142258763313293,
-0.2933727502822876,
-0.5510090589523315,
0.19976501166820526,
-0.5124473571777344,
-0.6923632025718689,
-0.5366672873497009,
-0.3383679687976837,
0.04872875660657883,
0.6955245733261108,
0.13632024824619293,
0.897861897945404,
-0.3504732847213745,
0.11705762147903442,
0.7480060458183289,
-0.15400198101997375,
0.5754128694534302,
0.7170028686523438,
0.11232686787843704,
-0.2921011447906494,
0.8210428953170776,
0.08776556700468063,
0.017399242147803307,
0.8680903315544128,
0.3294258117675781,
-0.725480318069458,
-0.3934553265571594,
-0.25223225355148315,
-0.06205219402909279,
-0.7742594480514526,
-0.41104620695114136,
-0.9259498119354248,
-0.049845315515995026,
-0.7562697529792786,
-0.011971142143011093,
-0.13264374434947968,
-0.6947815418243408,
0.2069680094718933,
-0.2903789281845093,
0.013883226551115513,
0.5571349859237671,
-0.35734087228775024,
0.1342463344335556,
-0.9229586720466614,
0.8332654237747192,
0.5532459616661072,
-0.11483541876077652,
-0.5362675189971924,
-0.34925320744514465,
-0.14536088705062866,
-0.2117333710193634,
-0.2069082409143448,
-0.7969098091125488,
0.15640808641910553,
0.10625367611646652,
0.7246590852737427,
0.4565996825695038,
0.3433647155761719,
0.36432215571403503,
-0.38689401745796204,
0.8646620512008667,
0.15483766794204712,
-0.85298091173172,
0.7903777956962585,
0.15182803571224213,
-0.06311926245689392,
0.5182932615280151,
0.41333988308906555,
-0.4565599858760834,
-0.2820111811161041,
-0.7100410461425781,
-0.7529212236404419,
0.566081166267395,
-0.14530113339424133,
-0.20305541157722473,
-0.14097367227077484,
0.4173813462257385,
0.17655839025974274,
-0.1532505601644516,
-0.47973135113716125,
0.04531378298997879,
-0.2909757196903229,
0.0041578481905162334,
0.13208220899105072,
-0.48243117332458496,
-0.6224159598350525,
0.20286044478416443,
0.38437455892562866,
-0.22816644608974457,
0.11225003004074097,
0.6165004968643188,
-0.6293343901634216,
-0.0395214781165123,
0.8093004822731018,
0.6471217274665833,
0.9162341356277466,
-0.3671390116214752,
0.5245328545570374,
0.2006174921989441,
-0.4563888609409332,
0.22595347464084625,
0.3628135919570923,
-0.286670446395874,
0.34384024143218994,
0.5914539098739624,
0.23346661031246185,
0.08787851780653,
-0.38204094767570496,
0.699938952922821,
-0.16748487949371338,
-0.22057895362377167,
0.04595809429883957,
-0.12910933792591095,
-0.20783299207687378,
0.3444918394088745,
0.4581345021724701,
0.034099940210580826,
0.21042007207870483,
-0.5618898272514343,
0.42510586977005005,
0.25309908390045166,
0.1515805870294571,
0.14870205521583557,
0.44019615650177,
0.268330842256546,
-0.03789844363927841,
0.40575191378593445,
-0.06307152658700943,
-0.4462682902812958,
0.7005715370178223,
0.6155940294265747,
1.034879207611084,
0.012997865676879883,
0.4405834376811981,
0.5862740874290466,
0.42480093240737915,
-0.3269265592098236,
-0.11564628034830093,
-0.29906001687049866,
-0.7121871709823608,
-0.5616648197174072,
-0.22600120306015015,
-0.3424985706806183,
-0.054384130984544754,
-0.9039385914802551,
-0.15942995250225067,
-0.12288480252027512,
-0.003180523170158267,
0.301025390625,
0.1542797088623047,
-0.2768239676952362,
0.2692719101905823,
0.1710716336965561,
1.0543595552444458,
-0.8162250518798828,
0.6698731184005737,
0.22687570750713348,
-0.6268601417541504,
-0.39571335911750793,
0.11914097517728806,
0.19616511464118958,
-0.47047391533851624,
0.752263605594635,
0.05323801189661026,
-0.4586174786090851,
-0.24999970197677612,
-0.5073585510253906,
-0.5858943462371826,
1.2335602045059204,
0.5235489010810852,
-0.398296982049942,
-0.014380661770701408,
-0.07773853093385696,
0.14792729914188385,
-0.33944740891456604,
0.08876599371433258,
0.5788059234619141,
0.3937736451625824,
0.22640134394168854,
-0.6920381188392639,
0.5195273756980896,
0.08522137999534607,
-0.3161291778087616,
-0.0555434450507164,
-0.5236820578575134,
0.6965976357460022,
-0.23470903933048248,
-0.5119850635528564,
-0.22858616709709167,
0.9864689707756042,
-0.10777612030506134,
0.2146470993757248,
0.8218361139297485,
0.31276604533195496,
1.0896844863891602,
-0.08422226458787918,
1.1644763946533203,
-0.24689222872257233,
0.4786239266395569,
1.176958680152893,
-0.21852165460586548,
0.5924217700958252,
0.13661612570285797,
0.12099242955446243,
0.6016770601272583,
0.587513267993927,
0.13246019184589386,
0.3706348240375519,
-0.07609450072050095,
-0.3507609963417053,
-0.20917990803718567,
-0.07445687055587769,
-0.29925498366355896,
0.43528348207473755,
0.34531617164611816,
-0.24295204877853394,
-0.6992512345314026,
-0.44726163148880005,
0.28511562943458557,
-0.3129238188266754,
-0.2919454276561737,
0.9459483027458191,
-0.3206323981285095,
-1.0086106061935425,
0.4143627882003784,
0.11744947731494904,
0.2915138602256775,
-0.6033913493156433,
-0.2117045372724533,
-0.43448948860168457,
-0.036422841250896454,
-0.608446478843689,
-0.7110940217971802,
0.43274495005607605,
0.13911022245883942,
-0.35747405886650085,
-0.28329700231552124,
1.181005597114563,
-0.7277802228927612,
-0.08060671389102936,
-0.12482500821352005,
0.49786436557769775,
-0.03904116153717041,
-0.21049125492572784,
-0.45522627234458923,
-0.36850225925445557,
-0.061537567526102066,
0.1579214483499527,
0.20122455060482025,
0.5827220678329468,
-0.14752818644046783,
0.11555147171020508,
0.44737085700035095,
-0.0295922439545393,
-0.39282700419425964,
0.014200323261320591,
0.8456564545631409,
-0.553325355052948,
-0.7188717126846313,
-0.8898693323135376,
0.5139126181602478,
-0.5208542943000793,
0.034785304218530655,
0.7422405481338501,
0.7391700744628906,
0.5260541439056396,
0.12145776301622391,
0.9852367043495178,
-0.4876464903354645,
0.24445579946041107,
-0.5525004863739014,
0.7744157314300537,
-0.45992395281791687,
-0.13892459869384766,
-0.3525577783584595,
-0.5470399856567383,
-0.32075026631355286,
0.592383086681366,
-0.18246307969093323,
-0.49820801615715027,
0.996362030506134,
0.7804862856864929,
-0.11915323138237,
0.1349378377199173,
0.15558917820453644,
0.2766229212284088,
0.5201379060745239,
0.21499350666999817,
0.685805082321167,
-0.4469890594482422,
0.613696813583374,
0.048570092767477036,
-0.3758270740509033,
-0.11351671069860458,
-1.2650086879730225,
-0.6540917754173279,
-0.5212290287017822,
-0.8481196761131287,
-0.5924813747406006,
-0.4565415680408478,
0.5336493849754333,
0.5396759510040283,
-0.9197800159454346,
0.2967962920665741,
0.3438335359096527,
0.5108625292778015,
-0.481649249792099,
-0.15238770842552185,
0.5424880385398865,
-0.535063624382019,
-0.3770613372325897,
0.49282383918762207,
0.3024251163005829,
-0.18758009374141693,
-0.005881207995116711,
0.3023265302181244,
-0.4315020740032196,
0.16158075630664825,
0.8756329417228699,
0.4717893898487091,
-0.5421343445777893,
-0.5130658149719238,
-0.6112695336341858,
-0.24984340369701385,
0.2443748265504837,
1.291473388671875,
-0.43417486548423767,
0.39396053552627563,
0.6619106531143188,
0.9668247103691101,
0.7317839860916138,
0.20659449696540833,
0.35717397928237915,
-1.0212712287902832,
-0.17545786499977112,
-0.4729843735694885,
0.6231856942176819,
0.23287318646907806,
-0.6311365962028503,
0.6318880915641785,
0.4185401201248169,
0.015086350962519646,
-0.6980451941490173,
0.14199155569076538,
-1.0552722215652466,
-0.3802797794342041,
0.8571727275848389,
-0.5822011232376099,
-0.2597036063671112,
-0.35588958859443665,
-0.3271148204803467,
0.3544211685657501,
-0.13378627598285675,
1.0152699947357178,
0.675178587436676,
0.09308532625436783,
-0.13295695185661316,
-0.10804882645606995,
0.4986894130706787,
0.06916631758213043,
-1.041892409324646,
0.39278724789619446,
0.5680105686187744,
0.47400596737861633,
0.7380046844482422,
0.5845397114753723,
-0.45591527223587036,
0.26945510506629944,
0.1647453010082245,
0.043986305594444275,
-0.03383135050535202,
-0.16496379673480988,
-0.19743642210960388,
0.5859928727149963,
-0.41556599736213684,
-0.3457217514514923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03235v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03235v1
|
Error-preserving Automatic Speech Recognition of Young English Learners' Language
| 2024-06-05T13:15:37 | 2024-06-05T13:15:37 |
Janick Michot, Manuela Hürlimann, Jan Deriu, Luzia Sauer, Katsiaryna Mlynchyk, Mark Cieliebak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
One of the central skills that language learners need to practice is speaking
the language. Currently, students in school do not get enough speaking
opportunities and lack conversational practice. Recent advances in speech
technology and natural language processing allow for the creation of novel
tools to practice their speaking skills. In this work, we tackle the first
component of such a pipeline, namely, the automated speech recognition module
(ASR), which faces a number of challenges: first, state-of-the-art ASR models
are often trained on adult read-aloud data by native speakers and do not
transfer well to young language learners' speech. Second, most ASR systems
contain a powerful language model, which smooths out errors made by the
speakers. To give corrective feedback, which is a crucial part of language
learning, the ASR systems in our setting need to preserve the errors made by
the language learners. In this work, we build an ASR system that satisfies
these requirements: it works on spontaneous speech by young language learners
and preserves their errors. For this, we collected a corpus containing around
85 hours of English audio spoken by learners in Switzerland from grades 4 to 6
on different language learning tasks, which we used to train an ASR model. Our
experiments show that our model benefits from direct fine-tuning on children's
voices and has a much higher error preservation rate than other models.
|
[
0.03281885012984276,
-0.5972892045974731,
-0.01691589690744877,
-0.013796906918287277,
-0.03089873678982258,
0.2741782069206238,
-0.23515675961971283,
-0.5551018714904785,
-0.3693523705005646,
0.21313253045082092,
-0.4581450819969177,
-0.06432387977838516,
-0.4944475591182709,
0.31634053587913513,
-0.6930829286575317,
0.6071427464485168,
-0.007287424523383379,
0.33755695819854736,
0.019908776506781578,
0.013649269007146358,
-0.4108474552631378,
-0.2821683883666992,
-1.3830841779708862,
-0.3425167202949524,
0.26324573159217834,
0.8267850279808044,
0.135080948472023,
0.7762910723686218,
0.17443914711475372,
0.33832088112831116,
-0.06679829955101013,
0.23650290071964264,
-0.17899858951568604,
0.12366511672735214,
-0.2188592553138733,
-0.18848411738872528,
-0.21132509410381317,
-0.42430800199508667,
0.9999790191650391,
0.654984176158905,
-0.24886734783649445,
-0.12291853874921799,
0.30785316228866577,
0.4965735673904419,
-0.11590462177991867,
0.22912311553955078,
-0.7268333435058594,
-0.11631123721599579,
-0.3179081380367279,
0.06220852583646774,
-0.3564389944076538,
-0.1733342856168747,
0.07874134182929993,
-0.3733709454536438,
0.43682289123535156,
-0.2093460112810135,
0.8663933277130127,
0.35967856645584106,
-0.16904574632644653,
-0.3096800446510315,
-1.0184279680252075,
0.7564490437507629,
-0.8015408515930176,
0.5175794959068298,
0.5975819826126099,
0.45990487933158875,
0.05625851824879646,
-0.32156622409820557,
-0.6991298794746399,
-0.017216136679053307,
-0.011395796202123165,
-0.015731120482087135,
-0.15609215199947357,
-0.026093611493706703,
-0.0016062891809269786,
0.07303772121667862,
-0.5252593159675598,
0.352308064699173,
-0.7448140978813171,
-0.5697913765907288,
0.7510361671447754,
0.0794028490781784,
0.2236013561487198,
-0.031566817313432693,
0.06250183284282684,
-0.24530914425849915,
-0.5165025591850281,
0.27632778882980347,
0.29724493622779846,
0.7082855105400085,
-0.024028567597270012,
0.43627965450286865,
-0.16297993063926697,
0.7842539548873901,
0.09932635724544525,
-0.28145885467529297,
0.08833646774291992,
0.019615156576037407,
0.019617736339569092,
0.300473153591156,
0.5887328386306763,
-0.04515855759382248,
0.4214566946029663,
0.13364069163799286,
-0.6535759568214417,
0.44623440504074097,
0.05347117781639099,
-0.4804789125919342,
-0.2889237403869629,
-0.004423174075782299,
-0.16933920979499817,
0.06835247576236725,
0.11555617302656174,
-0.36031854152679443,
0.08259382098913193,
-0.4559999406337738,
0.5962220430374146,
-0.6040747761726379,
0.028489472344517708,
0.1949588805437088,
0.2245021015405655,
-0.02308860421180725,
0.6203389763832092,
-0.7390195727348328,
0.6301602125167847,
0.35650938749313354,
0.44699928164482117,
-0.15808553993701935,
-0.2899029850959778,
-0.8488554954528809,
0.028361346572637558,
-0.13181476294994354,
0.8889216184616089,
-0.315365195274353,
-0.5143954753875732,
0.10111933946609497,
0.3073900640010834,
-0.19066525995731354,
-0.6953663229942322,
0.544049084186554,
-0.4083884656429291,
0.05780486762523651,
0.16089792549610138,
-0.72105872631073,
-0.14360235631465912,
-0.0682431012392044,
-0.3720260560512543,
0.508190929889679,
-0.44644996523857117,
-0.3097269535064697,
0.3569236695766449,
-0.5809083580970764,
-0.5722234845161438,
0.2526252269744873,
-0.058489903807640076,
-0.5368637442588806,
-0.009286481887102127,
0.012813970446586609,
0.33122408390045166,
0.24564164876937866,
-0.10194854438304901,
0.2545960247516632,
-0.2677532434463501,
0.1278001070022583,
-0.705400288105011,
0.6068437099456787,
0.29531028866767883,
-0.29736632108688354,
-0.011802244000136852,
-0.9126677513122559,
0.04069485142827034,
-0.05899136886000633,
-0.5691395401954651,
-0.18141742050647736,
0.2409399151802063,
0.23675677180290222,
0.0576338991522789,
0.12859569489955902,
-0.7193724513053894,
-0.060499295592308044,
-0.4966966211795807,
0.42741262912750244,
0.5582761764526367,
-0.07097844034433365,
0.12648753821849823,
-0.4644482135772705,
0.316011905670166,
0.1668323278427124,
-0.08521483093500137,
-0.16338776051998138,
-0.2832828760147095,
-0.9302617311477661,
-0.06844959408044815,
0.3771931529045105,
0.7741947770118713,
-0.5748891830444336,
0.4666661322116852,
-0.14511121809482574,
-0.39453113079071045,
-0.6842637062072754,
0.25358614325523376,
0.5408582091331482,
0.2885553240776062,
0.2912830412387848,
-0.3081042766571045,
-0.721384584903717,
-0.6323336362838745,
0.036545805633068085,
-0.3985142707824707,
-0.1913226693868637,
0.19032515585422516,
0.11104544997215271,
-0.33134615421295166,
1.0229439735412598,
-0.04932516813278198,
-0.6110665798187256,
-0.10851702839136124,
0.0754476860165596,
-0.05322685465216637,
0.8505446910858154,
-0.08144577592611313,
-0.5481007099151611,
-0.5441408753395081,
-0.03947772830724716,
-0.26715436577796936,
-0.14300060272216797,
0.01400170847773552,
0.4209626317024231,
0.431224524974823,
0.5244022011756897,
-0.3352632522583008,
0.2749781906604767,
0.5479232668876648,
-0.33876341581344604,
0.35975006222724915,
-0.5051840543746948,
-0.0024742933455854654,
-0.6324626803398132,
-0.048209015280008316,
-0.17509596049785614,
-0.4211805760860443,
-0.6623123288154602,
-0.4643322825431824,
0.11976691335439682,
-0.04521192982792854,
-0.4192514419555664,
0.6256248950958252,
-0.454926997423172,
0.16074249148368835,
-0.4282492399215698,
0.009492650628089905,
-0.18913677334785461,
-0.125349223613739,
0.22812803089618683,
0.8190682530403137,
0.6403294205665588,
-0.6111107468605042,
0.029475053772330284,
0.2673291265964508,
-0.021669680252671242,
0.489332914352417,
-0.5513986349105835,
0.5274865627288818,
-0.16904522478580475,
-0.02449834533035755,
-0.827278196811676,
-0.34490084648132324,
-0.05508527159690857,
-0.8189952969551086,
0.725587785243988,
-0.12731316685676575,
-0.2667767405509949,
-0.46554917097091675,
0.2641834020614624,
0.08620982617139816,
0.513197660446167,
-0.4592612683773041,
0.5422726273536682,
0.5646224021911621,
-0.3678399920463562,
-0.48316794633865356,
-0.467887818813324,
-0.11001142114400864,
0.014647715725004673,
-0.4974762797355652,
0.10354094952344894,
-0.1302253156900406,
-0.2066795378923416,
0.1662483960390091,
-0.1529845893383026,
-0.3595639765262604,
-0.12746624648571014,
0.32420384883880615,
0.20976242423057556,
-0.26834291219711304,
0.16539865732192993,
0.04773830994963646,
-0.2037699818611145,
-0.22304457426071167,
-0.3500104546546936,
0.36292243003845215,
-0.27765753865242004,
-0.40220487117767334,
-0.7745107412338257,
0.29158371686935425,
0.5403743982315063,
-0.0811588317155838,
0.3676140308380127,
0.22358438372612,
-0.7924381494522095,
-0.4493188261985779,
-0.6852893829345703,
-0.30833566188812256,
-0.46639588475227356,
0.24281436204910278,
-0.3278617858886719,
-0.756912350654602,
0.5698865056037903,
0.4643254578113556,
0.075043223798275,
0.28969135880470276,
0.10713770240545273,
-0.2534511089324951,
0.9178826212882996,
0.6395216584205627,
-0.10640519112348557,
0.39129549264907837,
-0.10867079347372055,
0.0482771210372448,
-0.3060813546180725,
-0.16208283603191376,
-0.7160534858703613,
0.028182024136185646,
-0.07348334044218063,
-0.26652848720550537,
0.07887038588523865,
-0.09339450299739838,
-0.06027429178357124,
0.21419553458690643,
-0.38573357462882996,
0.5308758616447449,
0.655996561050415,
0.029682330787181854,
0.38012853264808655,
0.0955103188753128,
0.0892224982380867,
-0.2523155212402344,
-0.6825211644172668,
-0.8111873269081116,
0.6651848554611206,
0.2758149206638336,
0.8814672231674194,
-0.052901942282915115,
0.7157851457595825,
0.2636166512966156,
0.14452016353607178,
-1.0154889822006226,
0.5448148846626282,
-0.5513904690742493,
-0.5243952870368958,
-0.6593272686004639,
-0.5238838195800781,
-1.0650134086608887,
-0.13214506208896637,
-0.003430640557780862,
-0.3943030834197998,
0.2783783972263336,
0.6155356764793396,
-0.6967138051986694,
0.29157721996307373,
-0.7125809192657471,
0.4791187644004822,
0.022078752517700195,
-0.3925076723098755,
-0.17576251924037933,
-0.6518206596374512,
-0.10755250602960587,
-0.1800985485315323,
0.27448323369026184,
0.13340269029140472,
0.2863059937953949,
0.8248196840286255,
-0.3014278709888458,
0.811465859413147,
-0.5343334078788757,
-0.020139379426836967,
0.4452609121799469,
0.11513447761535645,
0.4753831624984741,
-0.1902887374162674,
0.02736971341073513,
-0.10205873847007751,
0.04145471006631851,
-0.17423273622989655,
-0.2007569819688797,
0.5076653957366943,
-0.8699393272399902,
-0.40178316831588745,
-0.3951674699783325,
-0.22927038371562958,
-0.2024468034505844,
0.22551307082176208,
0.14384956657886505,
0.5690601468086243,
-0.18029828369617462,
0.24828769266605377,
0.7190423011779785,
-0.0355779230594635,
0.5980451703071594,
0.9016944766044617,
0.03185660019516945,
-0.22945907711982727,
1.03916335105896,
0.6433454155921936,
0.33842068910598755,
0.01729029044508934,
0.24362406134605408,
-0.2423657476902008,
-0.734154224395752,
-0.45654281973838806,
0.22008538246154785,
-0.5551769137382507,
-0.3052266836166382,
-0.7330123782157898,
-0.47061628103256226,
-0.4217831492424011,
-0.2534821331501007,
-0.4770395755767822,
-0.48138126730918884,
-0.4188198745250702,
0.032154373824596405,
0.19233980774879456,
0.7232404947280884,
-0.5428536534309387,
0.26150771975517273,
-0.9221761226654053,
0.10006123781204224,
0.5811275839805603,
0.17647363245487213,
-0.06278955936431885,
-0.6796603202819824,
-0.2960808575153351,
0.055856406688690186,
-0.10530741512775421,
-0.4418647289276123,
0.7482576966285706,
0.7121070623397827,
0.3936990797519684,
0.3157404959201813,
0.12326443195343018,
0.6322936415672302,
-0.8665652275085449,
0.5892491340637207,
-0.08976975828409195,
-0.9475713968276978,
0.657164454460144,
-0.2526991367340088,
0.38208773732185364,
0.6716985702514648,
-0.055194392800331116,
-0.7050691843032837,
-0.5066462159156799,
-0.6628630757331848,
-0.8033729195594788,
0.8440212607383728,
-0.14575597643852234,
0.022588202729821205,
0.12497119605541229,
-0.030402792617678642,
0.14532668888568878,
0.01045999489724636,
-0.42517560720443726,
0.06242962181568146,
-0.2779918909072876,
-0.5472362041473389,
-0.17588333785533905,
-0.09734615683555603,
-0.10593432188034058,
-0.3051510155200958,
0.9189054369926453,
-0.17262336611747742,
0.10162024945020676,
0.23945215344429016,
-0.24786418676376343,
-0.54855877161026,
0.3160156309604645,
0.49232223629951477,
0.2518194317817688,
-0.05496186017990112,
0.2186075896024704,
0.20310385525226593,
-0.8247406482696533,
0.4926284849643707,
0.33051466941833496,
-0.4237936735153198,
0.15822641551494598,
0.013537544757127762,
0.5730260014533997,
0.20911653339862823,
-0.8964590430259705,
0.38814589381217957,
-0.0763561874628067,
-0.0011410615406930447,
-0.8569815158843994,
0.17333589494228363,
-0.0854172483086586,
0.11974573135375977,
0.5869614481925964,
0.45596396923065186,
0.18850164115428925,
-0.4019874930381775,
0.5649561285972595,
0.21489271521568298,
-0.3868468403816223,
-0.42453351616859436,
0.5745557546615601,
0.1498415619134903,
-0.8685650825500488,
0.45704448223114014,
-0.2911205291748047,
-0.5880939960479736,
0.33976495265960693,
0.6404791474342346,
0.9209415912628174,
-0.7402087450027466,
0.05283764377236366,
0.45814424753189087,
0.18041467666625977,
-0.23494772613048553,
0.1938849538564682,
-0.05145196616649628,
-0.9859183430671692,
-0.3553198277950287,
-0.48980453610420227,
-0.5278723835945129,
-0.037426188588142395,
-0.640289306640625,
0.45512405037879944,
-0.46207916736602783,
0.043241336941719055,
-0.062992624938488,
0.006039859261363745,
-0.6381937861442566,
0.4403720796108246,
0.34685808420181274,
0.6172013878822327,
-0.7750581502914429,
1.0852305889129639,
0.7639583945274353,
0.007801680359989405,
-1.0284082889556885,
-0.017023442313075066,
0.22588296234607697,
-0.5244447588920593,
0.8257773518562317,
0.10480204224586487,
-0.48484906554222107,
0.30331525206565857,
-0.3510822653770447,
-0.7089666128158569,
0.5531274676322937,
0.14587366580963135,
-0.8933589458465576,
-0.09241577237844467,
-0.04529791325330734,
0.4489295482635498,
-0.17379364371299744,
-0.18508309125900269,
0.4303446412086487,
0.13299524784088135,
0.2427317351102829,
-1.2628675699234009,
-0.4775780439376831,
-0.3425038158893585,
-0.3782864809036255,
-0.07612878084182739,
-0.43621253967285156,
0.6737356781959534,
-0.15213939547538757,
-0.5486171245574951,
-0.03328545391559601,
0.6293750405311584,
0.274068146944046,
0.44231024384498596,
0.7772225141525269,
0.3100084960460663,
0.7362402677536011,
-0.11809612810611725,
0.5178418755531311,
-0.006550052668899298,
0.148342564702034,
1.1183055639266968,
-0.23527127504348755,
1.2118295431137085,
0.4678911864757538,
-0.0499684140086174,
0.0593271367251873,
0.32379841804504395,
0.24527719616889954,
0.5597478747367859,
0.08328000456094742,
-0.5847307443618774,
-0.13319210708141327,
0.07015226036310196,
0.013693463988602161,
0.4377443492412567,
0.5575016140937805,
0.014477001503109932,
0.12707380950450897,
0.33038976788520813,
-0.006931268610060215,
0.19036903977394104,
-0.45251157879829407,
0.8939319252967834,
0.0376092903316021,
-0.4400862157344818,
0.4922388792037964,
-0.2604929208755493,
0.8801653385162354,
-0.5971291065216064,
-0.014714685268700123,
-0.05331515520811081,
0.5511885285377502,
-0.30184847116470337,
-0.32492583990097046,
0.5245371460914612,
0.2619714140892029,
-0.20413385331630707,
-0.21327997744083405,
0.8595004081726074,
-0.7733784317970276,
-0.513579785823822,
0.10781380534172058,
0.36996471881866455,
0.036307018250226974,
0.438219279050827,
-0.261444091796875,
0.22801467776298523,
-0.06544622778892517,
0.14578285813331604,
-0.010301348753273487,
0.39966362714767456,
0.23777298629283905,
0.6520689725875854,
0.44798341393470764,
0.4691386818885803,
0.35163187980651855,
0.09666086733341217,
0.43503519892692566,
-0.37305504083633423,
-0.4848960340023041,
-0.367428719997406,
0.9091541767120361,
0.07528423517942429,
-0.18254928290843964,
0.7201757431030273,
0.4830991327762604,
0.9946680665016174,
-0.15495635569095612,
0.7524270415306091,
0.11162638664245605,
1.0623908042907715,
-0.5027951002120972,
0.8499716520309448,
-0.3786841630935669,
0.08149442821741104,
-0.2555720806121826,
-0.6279033422470093,
-0.44719892740249634,
1.1426236629486084,
-0.0668225884437561,
-0.3174227774143219,
0.3774118721485138,
0.8504589200019836,
0.01828610710799694,
0.12404440343379974,
0.5376451015472412,
0.3270834684371948,
0.3265160918235779,
0.22244952619075775,
0.8865107297897339,
-0.5043854117393494,
0.2779950499534607,
-0.19788262248039246,
-0.1700448989868164,
-0.23174983263015747,
-0.3371223509311676,
-0.3801208734512329,
-0.6178786158561707,
-0.5002943277359009,
-0.34941166639328003,
0.40400803089141846,
1.1980812549591064,
0.7140899300575256,
-1.171342134475708,
-0.5171467065811157,
-0.11150531470775604,
-0.3456566035747528,
-0.30570274591445923,
-0.17541052401065826,
0.07486657053232193,
-0.4333222508430481,
-0.90676349401474,
0.8342899680137634,
-0.049651019275188446,
0.5003246665000916,
-0.11763259023427963,
-0.26721376180648804,
0.05928559973835945,
0.18250982463359833,
0.3983336091041565,
0.6853334307670593,
-0.39402908086776733,
-0.6628606915473938,
0.07850125432014465,
0.061797965317964554,
0.023523500189185143,
0.48476773500442505,
-0.7640902996063232,
0.5819318890571594,
0.14249351620674133,
0.853497326374054,
0.4949801564216614,
-0.25872838497161865,
0.6363577842712402,
-0.5372679829597473,
0.04538118839263916,
0.5640292763710022,
0.3630485236644745,
0.6919811964035034,
-0.0863005667924881,
0.2843902111053467,
0.2289969027042389,
-0.7234829664230347,
-1.110536813735962,
-0.07163438200950623,
-0.7669959664344788,
0.27243471145629883,
0.8048715591430664,
-0.1268763244152069,
0.054148849099874496,
-0.42384374141693115,
-0.5018159747123718,
0.3679354786872864,
-0.4771791398525238,
0.7860724925994873,
0.6135228872299194,
-0.032633502036333084,
-0.30034300684928894,
-0.4690164625644684,
0.6424446105957031,
0.3780543804168701,
-0.5266153216362,
0.05011346936225891,
0.6704513430595398,
0.40693405270576477,
0.24315005540847778,
0.5169587731361389,
-0.0019130755681544542,
0.35311660170555115,
0.06859856098890305,
0.009127927012741566,
0.12263274937868118,
-0.6539549827575684,
-0.8556458950042725,
0.11147159337997437,
0.34071049094200134,
-0.35612452030181885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03221v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03221v1
|
Linking Named Entities in Diderot's \textit{Encyclopédie} to Wikidata
| 2024-06-05T13:00:04 | 2024-06-05T13:00:04 |
Pierre Nugues
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Diderot's \textit{Encyclop\'edie} is a reference work from XVIIIth century in
Europe that aimed at collecting the knowledge of its era. \textit{Wikipedia}
has the same ambition with a much greater scope. However, the lack of digital
connection between the two encyclopedias may hinder their comparison and the
study of how knowledge has evolved. A key element of \textit{Wikipedia} is
Wikidata that backs the articles with a graph of structured data. In this
paper, we describe the annotation of more than 10,300 of the
\textit{Encyclop\'edie} entries with Wikidata identifiers enabling us to
connect these entries to the graph. We considered geographic and human
entities. The \textit{Encyclop\'edie} does not contain biographic entries as
they mostly appear as subentries of locations. We extracted all the geographic
entries and we completely annotated all the entries containing a description of
human entities. This represents more than 2,600 links referring to locations or
human entities. In addition, we annotated more than 9,500 entries having a
geographic content only. We describe the annotation process as well as
application examples. This resource is available at
https://github.com/pnugues/encyclopedie_1751
|
[
-0.8277043700218201,
-0.5168392658233643,
0.7826464772224426,
-0.11237633973360062,
-0.14403502643108368,
-0.18907439708709717,
-0.23508277535438538,
-0.8103768825531006,
0.8812525272369385,
0.49146586656570435,
-0.7766624689102173,
-0.623193085193634,
-0.10647972673177719,
0.6186690926551819,
-0.23959378898143768,
1.108079195022583,
-0.20834460854530334,
-0.26167649030685425,
-0.2737797498703003,
-0.11461851000785828,
0.07023663073778152,
-0.19207195937633514,
-0.15513189136981964,
-0.3060574531555176,
0.9204292893409729,
0.33906862139701843,
0.4952903389930725,
0.6956108212471008,
0.42392680048942566,
0.2033834308385849,
-0.03249474614858627,
0.5241110920906067,
-0.6024002432823181,
0.22151371836662292,
-0.44292688369750977,
-0.21844129264354706,
-0.580651044845581,
-0.007461128290742636,
0.6309615969657898,
0.8499447107315063,
0.30962827801704407,
0.26605236530303955,
-0.21668583154678345,
0.5215931534767151,
-0.47385841608047485,
0.29629766941070557,
-0.49729764461517334,
-0.35693734884262085,
-0.573072612285614,
-0.3040009140968323,
-0.15380831062793732,
-0.27764588594436646,
0.18881531059741974,
-1.3235366344451904,
0.005207170266658068,
0.20035120844841003,
0.8243035674095154,
0.16875773668289185,
-0.5267190337181091,
-0.5438156127929688,
-0.7306581139564514,
0.12214990705251694,
-0.15227292478084564,
0.32338541746139526,
0.46874359250068665,
-0.07138723880052567,
-0.5575660467147827,
-0.7586034536361694,
-0.904729425907135,
-0.21128500998020172,
-0.1467435359954834,
-0.017230307683348656,
0.18722307682037354,
-0.17219845950603485,
0.4557994306087494,
0.06808971613645554,
-0.13651737570762634,
0.12811347842216492,
-0.7303076386451721,
0.02275615558028221,
0.8054465651512146,
-0.16579708456993103,
0.4604959189891815,
-0.6960175633430481,
-0.5414616465568542,
-0.08749445527791977,
-0.9385297298431396,
-0.3387465178966522,
0.6371818780899048,
0.09488054364919662,
0.10262400656938553,
0.9283095002174377,
-0.4920683801174164,
0.48767951130867004,
0.3486306369304657,
-0.19232386350631714,
0.6266836524009705,
-0.17281557619571686,
0.17642049491405487,
0.38144785165786743,
0.8030063509941101,
0.5015835762023926,
0.5962375998497009,
-0.6357443332672119,
0.18868862092494965,
-0.41171225905418396,
0.04581602290272713,
-0.4189380407333374,
-0.6242691874504089,
-0.018128562718629837,
0.002875985112041235,
-0.18638969957828522,
0.5759871006011963,
-0.6256214380264282,
-0.2926114797592163,
-0.2882215082645416,
0.20330990850925446,
-0.18575137853622437,
-0.30791062116622925,
-0.42742910981178284,
-0.22043925523757935,
-0.3371225893497467,
0.32689759135246277,
-0.8389039635658264,
0.34796231985092163,
0.7787915468215942,
0.5923274159431458,
-0.03788987919688225,
-0.49616119265556335,
0.04978619143366814,
0.7140399813652039,
-0.186971977353096,
0.9656184315681458,
-0.39149636030197144,
-0.08203761279582977,
-0.13659453392028809,
0.28159675002098083,
-0.09371443092823029,
-0.13060565292835236,
0.42612916231155396,
-0.7359011769294739,
-0.010195757262408733,
-0.6899940371513367,
-0.5418750047683716,
-0.47816184163093567,
0.25757431983947754,
-1.1956865787506104,
1.0931971073150635,
0.010904673486948013,
-1.2952841520309448,
0.6084203124046326,
-0.7525773644447327,
-0.16365855932235718,
0.4209066331386566,
-0.1776132583618164,
0.2230112999677658,
-0.14262858033180237,
0.08929484337568283,
-0.010987072251737118,
-0.08192400634288788,
0.27777528762817383,
-0.5457944273948669,
-0.3401537537574768,
0.4119427800178528,
0.13268159329891205,
1.1129704713821411,
-0.0821973979473114,
-0.1367436796426773,
-0.39641013741493225,
-0.9417046904563904,
-0.26378676295280457,
-0.05136028304696083,
-0.43238312005996704,
-0.9886258244514465,
0.07842376083135605,
-0.031209157779812813,
0.02787509188055992,
0.41474708914756775,
-1.0090116262435913,
0.4794367849826813,
-0.3365006744861603,
0.4009280800819397,
0.41887667775154114,
0.3953598141670227,
0.44600439071655273,
0.08568569272756577,
-0.12981709837913513,
-0.08098295331001282,
0.14759834110736847,
0.2617036700248718,
-0.688080906867981,
-0.6397501826286316,
-0.349336177110672,
0.575018048286438,
0.5553834438323975,
-0.8261703252792358,
0.3401641547679901,
-0.8566125631332397,
-0.6192646622657776,
-0.3430338501930237,
-0.11889681965112686,
-0.3869010806083679,
0.6249400973320007,
0.32733774185180664,
-0.09721790999174118,
-0.5050170421600342,
-0.9081212282180786,
0.4187963008880615,
-0.5521111488342285,
-0.3339652121067047,
0.5431435704231262,
0.8000702261924744,
-0.5181471109390259,
1.037123203277588,
-0.4410712718963623,
0.04520687460899353,
0.7239155173301697,
-0.21976971626281738,
0.026034126058220863,
0.04716033115983009,
0.7102295160293579,
-0.9996834397315979,
-0.43306705355644226,
0.09102769196033478,
-0.6953057646751404,
-0.3640504479408264,
0.1390131711959839,
-0.7976797223091125,
-0.3671697974205017,
0.045288484543561935,
-0.9002296328544617,
0.31303486227989197,
0.16238224506378174,
-0.2498793751001358,
0.11882584542036057,
-0.08064854145050049,
0.5779252052307129,
-0.9613581895828247,
0.13043561577796936,
-0.3430183231830597,
-0.06086459755897522,
-0.248526930809021,
-0.24961937963962555,
0.07615005224943161,
-0.12164852768182755,
-0.0873836874961853,
0.17414507269859314,
-0.3641921579837799,
-0.008136475458741188,
0.21539901196956635,
0.7014533877372742,
-0.12630194425582886,
0.35601940751075745,
-0.07364087551832199,
0.2985445559024811,
0.3714885711669922,
-0.3344680368900299,
0.8968214988708496,
0.6679548025131226,
0.2539823651313782,
0.8074616193771362,
-0.17681114375591278,
0.3757242262363434,
-0.23165634274482727,
0.23397564888000488,
-0.8129855990409851,
-0.4097350239753723,
0.5709227323532104,
-0.27928876876831055,
0.126497283577919,
-0.08264817297458649,
-0.7975732088088989,
-0.25618958473205566,
-0.5069626569747925,
0.336548775434494,
-0.07872456312179565,
-0.6636909246444702,
0.4278031587600708,
0.6492398381233215,
-0.11831340193748474,
-0.3566853106021881,
-0.290155827999115,
0.35590827465057373,
-0.2586137652397156,
-0.7879131436347961,
0.5976343750953674,
-0.040808387100696564,
-0.5464200377464294,
0.6331915855407715,
0.16629067063331604,
-0.3480103015899658,
0.03772906959056854,
0.6428573131561279,
0.38724592328071594,
0.05597773566842079,
0.5573108792304993,
0.07150717079639435,
-0.08860974758863449,
-0.00502299377694726,
-0.41545847058296204,
-0.003186336485669017,
0.49718987941741943,
-0.13301001489162445,
-0.16570472717285156,
0.457710862159729,
0.4214688241481781,
-0.18681825697422028,
0.8846964836120605,
0.07049085199832916,
-0.736580491065979,
0.05731440708041191,
-0.5114744901657104,
0.03740285336971283,
-0.3646323084831238,
0.06220068410038948,
-0.33297842741012573,
-0.4472008943557739,
0.5133408308029175,
-0.17904357612133026,
0.14331699907779694,
1.0437874794006348,
0.22267824411392212,
-0.4772721529006958,
0.0763368010520935,
0.44996166229248047,
0.16259266436100006,
0.2746720612049103,
-0.0064441668801009655,
0.21238559484481812,
-0.7493494153022766,
-0.671999454498291,
-0.5441856384277344,
-0.37638136744499207,
-1.0477502346038818,
-0.20763374865055084,
0.16346076130867004,
0.1838911771774292,
-0.2613009512424469,
0.7553132772445679,
-0.47465747594833374,
0.197321817278862,
0.459511935710907,
0.371349960565567,
0.5709302425384521,
0.19800356030464172,
0.14233876764774323,
0.013888349756598473,
-0.5031002163887024,
-0.5945265889167786,
1.149229884147644,
0.1311371922492981,
0.7160083055496216,
0.19589924812316895,
1.1646689176559448,
0.2393438071012497,
0.5067557692527771,
-0.40125757455825806,
0.3855586349964142,
0.1635044664144516,
-0.7681900262832642,
-0.37907299399375916,
-0.31428778171539307,
-0.7727513909339905,
-0.3628374934196472,
-0.4956247806549072,
-0.8724802136421204,
0.7432298064231873,
-0.008054479025304317,
-0.06023497134447098,
0.2511664032936096,
-0.41792917251586914,
0.4111695885658264,
-0.12980864942073822,
-0.055016014724969864,
-0.1711646318435669,
-0.3306899964809418,
-0.03850496932864189,
-0.25329306721687317,
0.19029900431632996,
-0.1865985244512558,
-0.3381832242012024,
0.9944407939910889,
-0.34552621841430664,
0.6826708316802979,
0.1761375069618225,
0.06761561334133148,
0.5045343637466431,
-0.16555996239185333,
0.5020190477371216,
0.1652076542377472,
-0.014567499980330467,
0.48421022295951843,
0.09691286087036133,
-0.057502128183841705,
-0.2990415096282959,
1.1273388862609863,
-0.7253321409225464,
-0.24563907086849213,
-0.15831920504570007,
-0.329182893037796,
0.12225107103586197,
0.2575562596321106,
0.28085172176361084,
0.36636635661125183,
-0.017699167132377625,
-0.0029214879032224417,
0.7485659122467041,
0.23468784987926483,
0.17385946214199066,
0.17318123579025269,
0.2727198898792267,
-0.5608097910881042,
0.41422104835510254,
0.826239287853241,
-0.26714804768562317,
0.486118346452713,
-0.3649574816226959,
-0.2629125416278839,
-0.33993294835090637,
-0.4522448182106018,
0.7053213715553284,
-0.975151777267456,
-0.2626788318157196,
-0.6062366962432861,
-0.0035061188973486423,
-0.19001606106758118,
-0.12797075510025024,
-0.05826892331242561,
-0.5673651695251465,
-0.3868895471096039,
-0.39168480038642883,
0.9193629026412964,
0.9889349937438965,
0.06435470283031464,
-0.1980285346508026,
-0.33081281185150146,
0.18917493522167206,
0.3058474659919739,
0.470869243144989,
-0.002553145634010434,
0.25588566064834595,
-0.3047061264514923,
0.13735802471637726,
0.14380227029323578,
-1.5782142877578735,
-0.18492311239242554,
0.17900149524211884,
0.6690077781677246,
0.11498355865478516,
0.32713019847869873,
0.7949979305267334,
-0.6991717219352722,
0.3641972541809082,
-0.016750385984778404,
-0.40114155411720276,
0.48649340867996216,
-0.3626868724822998,
-0.5087980628013611,
0.6787657141685486,
0.6194709539413452,
-0.395079642534256,
-0.17228096723556519,
-0.6549546718597412,
-0.9654443860054016,
0.30657652020454407,
0.2449268102645874,
-0.0029502592515200377,
-0.6691378951072693,
0.8501182794570923,
0.11296815425157547,
0.029303373768925667,
-0.7501472234725952,
-0.280621200799942,
0.01705189235508442,
-0.4248886704444885,
0.4155288338661194,
-0.47811052203178406,
-0.3448568284511566,
-0.05769246444106102,
0.648923933506012,
0.2120702564716339,
-0.0895615965127945,
0.6948436498641968,
-0.5647546648979187,
-0.2658343017101288,
-0.07406476140022278,
-0.03801225125789642,
0.9471189379692078,
-0.16662563383579254,
0.2016194760799408,
0.23325833678245544,
-0.7573257684707642,
-0.17363965511322021,
0.4148626923561096,
-0.7057361006736755,
0.07296294718980789,
0.6477750539779663,
0.6290028095245361,
0.5584782958030701,
-0.47804805636405945,
0.17998145520687103,
0.3995574712753296,
0.08932965993881226,
-0.801418662071228,
-0.02398180402815342,
0.11373855918645859,
0.7490726113319397,
0.6368597149848938,
-0.5767282843589783,
0.3454846441745758,
-0.37408921122550964,
0.26590219140052795,
-0.014626782387495041,
-0.11290987581014633,
-0.43303173780441284,
0.783571183681488,
0.5141522288322449,
-0.43934014439582825,
0.7900468707084656,
-0.19199292361736298,
-0.3345751464366913,
0.43458855152130127,
0.15761011838912964,
0.5864514708518982,
0.29901283979415894,
-0.039027050137519836,
0.672655463218689,
0.3800654113292694,
0.28863686323165894,
0.021503429859876633,
-0.24578192830085754,
-0.4771014153957367,
-0.2564334273338318,
-0.5494816899299622,
0.0975312665104866,
-0.37382563948631287,
-0.5643281936645508,
0.275627464056015,
-0.2193445861339569,
-0.3939738869667053,
0.2925224304199219,
0.26652586460113525,
-1.035170316696167,
-0.007566629443317652,
0.35905924439430237,
0.9934868812561035,
-0.9546077251434326,
0.6089731454849243,
0.8711421489715576,
-0.5416007041931152,
-0.5836089849472046,
0.14838255941867828,
-0.2889705002307892,
-0.3868573009967804,
1.0840532779693604,
-0.1811244785785675,
0.14220714569091797,
0.3065822422504425,
-0.15936270356178284,
-0.9155899882316589,
1.4696404933929443,
0.09331578016281128,
-0.7593995332717896,
-0.11482305079698563,
-0.2773635685443878,
0.4923191964626312,
-0.6096620559692383,
-0.04998699203133583,
0.3702917695045471,
0.7142096161842346,
-0.11951194703578949,
-1.0107301473617554,
0.1842261254787445,
-0.15525688230991364,
-0.2714848518371582,
0.4177115261554718,
-0.18234895169734955,
0.8105337619781494,
-0.2650979459285736,
-0.45327651500701904,
-0.18647804856300354,
0.40619906783103943,
-0.12394602596759796,
0.20229917764663696,
0.6495680212974548,
0.6991082429885864,
0.8900718092918396,
-0.16590702533721924,
0.7649295926094055,
-0.0850769579410553,
0.7051653265953064,
0.7504921555519104,
-0.13988079130649567,
0.9407539963722229,
0.5963385105133057,
-0.24998115003108978,
0.7468358874320984,
0.8974790573120117,
-0.3557509481906891,
0.6634277105331421,
-0.1928998827934265,
-0.2938830256462097,
0.14937454462051392,
-0.038584012538194656,
-0.027183856815099716,
0.19534768164157867,
0.19688299298286438,
-0.35165444016456604,
-0.2582090497016907,
-0.11482840776443481,
0.07492227107286453,
-0.08551764488220215,
-0.40752068161964417,
0.8768103718757629,
-0.3580755591392517,
-0.47151434421539307,
0.06290848553180695,
-0.3566681146621704,
0.19754762947559357,
-0.24144810438156128,
-0.3700411915779114,
0.28330424427986145,
-0.4580196440219879,
-0.6103190779685974,
-0.8434850573539734,
-0.0621177963912487,
0.0014660697197541595,
-0.3391437828540802,
0.3921004831790924,
0.6696710586547852,
-0.660520613193512,
-0.4727870225906372,
0.42735156416893005,
0.15322253108024597,
0.2583378851413727,
0.29820725321769714,
-0.05116730555891991,
-0.16871929168701172,
0.0012564260978251696,
-0.45171117782592773,
-0.173797145485878,
0.7869539260864258,
-0.39256855845451355,
0.21164292097091675,
0.5578364133834839,
0.15269003808498383,
0.015378672629594803,
-0.17146529257297516,
1.0341604948043823,
-0.5248497128486633,
-0.40644538402557373,
-0.8233068585395813,
0.4689646363258362,
-0.4559268355369568,
-0.15867534279823303,
0.8504683971405029,
0.4601195454597473,
1.0219680070877075,
0.09522091597318649,
0.47964632511138916,
-0.4666913151741028,
0.2722996175289154,
-0.1856601983308792,
0.6771348118782043,
-0.1266641765832901,
0.0013832596596330404,
-0.232587069272995,
-1.1390843391418457,
-0.05867897346615791,
0.6015965938568115,
-0.4629845917224884,
-0.33922842144966125,
0.5355221033096313,
0.41629335284233093,
-0.06681031733751297,
-0.37514594197273254,
-0.2822781503200531,
0.1589788943529129,
-0.1345376819372177,
0.3675087094306946,
0.3963632583618164,
-0.26395881175994873,
0.40987566113471985,
-0.513401448726654,
-0.38208821415901184,
-0.15313340723514557,
-0.7277281284332275,
-0.8209302425384521,
-0.7708054184913635,
-0.45140519738197327,
-0.21111083030700684,
0.030765783041715622,
0.8506659269332886,
0.5520572066307068,
-0.6038001179695129,
0.3268124759197235,
0.4616956114768982,
0.051852673292160034,
0.14052580296993256,
-0.091093510389328,
0.6284446120262146,
0.4760211706161499,
-0.790338933467865,
0.01580744981765747,
0.3793222904205322,
-0.008723365142941475,
-0.3926837146282196,
0.0008681151666678488,
-0.2876811623573303,
-0.04083608090877533,
0.17256595194339752,
0.1063062995672226,
-0.6351026296615601,
-0.5381487011909485,
-0.18322014808654785,
0.020405642688274384,
-0.030243130400776863,
0.6049848198890686,
-0.7313404083251953,
0.6520475149154663,
0.5671727657318115,
0.22156892716884613,
0.7777345180511475,
0.07085181772708893,
0.07674548029899597,
-0.5921234488487244,
0.47091174125671387,
0.05046990513801575,
0.44661232829093933,
0.43833187222480774,
-0.8123824596405029,
0.5045115947723389,
0.40075168013572693,
-0.35449984669685364,
-0.6444464325904846,
0.006396039389073849,
-0.8799235224723816,
0.033960673958063126,
0.7318017482757568,
-0.20577098429203033,
-0.44818115234375,
-0.06716834753751755,
-0.058916736394166946,
0.47553256154060364,
-0.20561762154102325,
0.9145538806915283,
0.8141679763793945,
-0.08020198345184326,
0.07553106546401978,
-0.8270947933197021,
0.20088912546634674,
-0.9777848124504089,
-0.7435076236724854,
-0.20296037197113037,
0.6797001957893372,
0.6256402730941772,
0.6202518939971924,
0.5944889783859253,
-0.032439690083265305,
0.137405663728714,
0.3197883665561676,
0.1597941517829895,
-0.3780561685562134,
-0.3546833395957947,
0.536472499370575,
0.05380046367645264,
0.15746115148067474,
-0.28887608647346497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03202v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03202v2
|
ChatLang-8: An LLM-Based Synthetic Data Generation Framework for Grammatical Error Correction
| 2024-06-05T12:35:00 | 2024-06-11T07:06:34 |
Jeiyoon Park, Chanjun Park, Heuiseok Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explore and improve the capabilities of LLMs to generate data for
grammatical error correction (GEC). When merely producing parallel sentences,
their patterns are too simplistic to be valuable as a corpus. To address this
issue, we propose an automated framework that includes a Subject Selector,
Grammar Selector, Prompt Manager, and Evaluator. Additionally, we introduce a
new dataset for GEC tasks, named ChatLang-8, which encompasses eight types of
subject nouns and 23 types of grammar. It consists of 1 million pairs featuring
human-like grammatical errors. Our experiments reveal that ChatLang-8 exhibits
a more uniform pattern composition compared to existing GEC datasets.
Furthermore, we observe improved model performance when using ChatLang-8
instead of existing GEC datasets. The experimental results suggest that our
framework and ChatLang-8 are valuable resources for enhancing ChatGPT's data
generation capabilities.
|
[
0.008495367132127285,
-0.8544691205024719,
0.5547152161598206,
0.5805056095123291,
0.16737543046474457,
0.18064755201339722,
-0.3664906620979309,
-0.03293420374393463,
0.0938173308968544,
0.372426837682724,
-0.6114832162857056,
-0.6588010191917419,
-0.29579052329063416,
0.5567657947540283,
-0.5141348242759705,
0.7730154395103455,
0.08985912799835205,
0.338287353515625,
-0.3248005211353302,
0.14331069588661194,
-0.5242105722427368,
-0.7522607445716858,
-0.6045693159103394,
0.06364716589450836,
0.48971831798553467,
0.9165162444114685,
0.5287800431251526,
0.6133331656455994,
0.5335668921470642,
0.40462416410446167,
-0.02523135021328926,
0.8414500951766968,
-0.6073039770126343,
0.03866647928953171,
-0.07128981500864029,
-0.6358170509338379,
-0.783155620098114,
-0.40187036991119385,
0.7187596559524536,
0.6783560514450073,
-0.24327394366264343,
-0.10427451878786087,
0.11692528426647186,
0.7777225971221924,
-0.26852789521217346,
0.49627551436424255,
-0.5716286897659302,
-0.10306033492088318,
-0.4538026750087738,
0.03881185129284859,
-0.5860714912414551,
-0.2789888083934784,
-0.5245367288589478,
-0.6431305408477783,
0.505905270576477,
0.30103397369384766,
0.6725049018859863,
0.052454981952905655,
-0.010191262699663639,
-0.3388804793357849,
-0.6243361830711365,
0.4729558527469635,
-0.8905630707740784,
0.12121858447790146,
0.31231123208999634,
0.24818001687526703,
-0.6099261045455933,
-0.5675770044326782,
-0.557690441608429,
-0.16362962126731873,
-0.15470080077648163,
0.15006335079669952,
0.05649588629603386,
0.21122190356254578,
0.3937903046607971,
0.460794061422348,
-0.7015243172645569,
-0.15522648394107819,
-0.48396599292755127,
-0.2072765827178955,
0.5846412777900696,
0.30476999282836914,
0.4868868887424469,
-0.2426804155111313,
0.40161392092704773,
0.061243686825037,
-0.9175626635551453,
-0.32168713212013245,
0.6945768594741821,
0.4531833231449127,
-0.16518080234527588,
0.5357327461242676,
-0.3680475652217865,
0.6933865547180176,
0.14028669893741608,
0.07853428274393082,
0.27110549807548523,
-0.20099514722824097,
-0.21862132847309113,
0.07925524562597275,
0.9315376877784729,
0.37859392166137695,
0.24921445548534393,
-0.0719279944896698,
-0.23923775553703308,
0.4355905055999756,
0.2526630163192749,
-0.3411000967025757,
-0.3105908930301666,
0.0992337092757225,
-0.06077875196933746,
-0.5334861278533936,
0.21050181984901428,
-0.7701443433761597,
-0.22110770642757416,
-0.44429585337638855,
-0.04183010011911392,
-0.4665575623512268,
0.1630452424287796,
0.30570316314697266,
0.14034134149551392,
-0.08528529107570648,
0.34686753153800964,
-0.9236752390861511,
0.5813369750976562,
0.5756897330284119,
0.6599105596542358,
-0.29823243618011475,
-0.49027037620544434,
-0.6151280999183655,
-0.08713232725858688,
-0.5559121370315552,
0.9145172834396362,
-0.2905561029911041,
-0.5182011127471924,
0.006485440768301487,
0.1108996793627739,
-0.22095678746700287,
-0.7479376792907715,
0.6219582557678223,
-0.1309230774641037,
0.40666770935058594,
-0.23174472153186798,
-0.7322328090667725,
-0.0656449943780899,
0.16803960502147675,
-0.758397102355957,
1.3163936138153076,
0.18899789452552795,
-0.5093466639518738,
-0.2205830067396164,
-0.5309522747993469,
-0.47576308250427246,
0.05038845166563988,
-0.3936117887496948,
-0.5470333695411682,
-0.04184951260685921,
0.3313778042793274,
0.3029932975769043,
-0.33255451917648315,
0.5763401389122009,
-0.22593766450881958,
-0.44022420048713684,
0.25966042280197144,
-0.21295669674873352,
0.5461516380310059,
0.13193054497241974,
-0.3495389521121979,
0.15181931853294373,
-1.1982606649398804,
0.06159212067723274,
0.06489157676696777,
-0.4005317986011505,
0.16509754955768585,
0.12357073277235031,
-0.020279714837670326,
-0.1555887758731842,
-0.04211324080824852,
-0.5778772830963135,
0.12622109055519104,
-0.32243111729621887,
0.4241688549518585,
0.6798374652862549,
-0.2534305155277252,
0.3589927554130554,
-0.7453573942184448,
0.5587529540061951,
0.03135104849934578,
-0.058844808489084244,
-0.3132789134979248,
-0.5288721323013306,
-1.2092795372009277,
-0.07313323765993118,
0.23082588613033295,
0.8360708355903625,
-0.5935034155845642,
0.4886697828769684,
-0.18454556167125702,
-0.3335186541080475,
-0.42579665780067444,
0.2544773817062378,
0.38966938853263855,
0.5418612360954285,
0.1619667261838913,
0.029822150245308876,
-1.1569374799728394,
-0.6679372787475586,
-0.17805594205856323,
-0.3256782293319702,
0.1211332157254219,
0.2675701081752777,
0.06417176127433777,
-0.1776779592037201,
0.8978902101516724,
-0.24051648378372192,
-0.14068320393562317,
-0.4255724549293518,
-0.06694317609071732,
0.29705294966697693,
0.4667131304740906,
0.4134097993373871,
-0.44831180572509766,
-0.41689690947532654,
0.10037805140018463,
-0.8069905638694763,
-0.6129749417304993,
-0.1082632839679718,
-0.4348047375679016,
0.3849266469478607,
0.5355694890022278,
-0.6044985055923462,
0.0007453581201843917,
0.5678678750991821,
-0.24652470648288727,
0.7419470548629761,
-0.2421233355998993,
0.18247829377651215,
-1.102866291999817,
-0.2032267153263092,
-0.3001757264137268,
-0.32777851819992065,
-0.5831325650215149,
-0.11740437895059586,
0.20364388823509216,
-0.2208710014820099,
-0.4293995797634125,
0.3194100856781006,
-0.32489049434661865,
-0.09845268726348877,
-0.10804475843906403,
-0.059093330055475235,
0.03631209954619408,
0.5165774822235107,
-0.373207688331604,
0.7868802547454834,
0.45979219675064087,
-0.37690579891204834,
0.7811556458473206,
0.11836370825767517,
-0.06729578226804733,
0.35098835825920105,
-0.4916965663433075,
0.3944855034351349,
-0.2456323355436325,
0.007925796322524548,
-0.8674682378768921,
-0.7931517362594604,
0.41377586126327515,
-0.4288212060928345,
0.19155335426330566,
0.0013684601290151477,
-0.5428285598754883,
-0.13751181960105896,
-0.08980286866426468,
0.1035764068365097,
0.5672264695167542,
-0.42750364542007446,
0.5415914058685303,
0.07977548241615295,
-0.4111974835395813,
-0.2248527854681015,
-0.7037680149078369,
0.1443433314561844,
-0.12155451625585556,
-0.9381827712059021,
0.22347144782543182,
-0.120271235704422,
-0.3552357852458954,
-0.05135710537433624,
0.28287816047668457,
0.31914830207824707,
-0.05630699545145035,
0.3036150336265564,
0.4341713488101959,
-0.3238409161567688,
0.03320896252989769,
-0.15147918462753296,
0.08392135798931122,
-0.01740151084959507,
-0.20507384836673737,
0.48883870244026184,
-0.4634701907634735,
-0.5913700461387634,
-0.06762974709272385,
0.4546745717525482,
0.36487969756126404,
0.14419548213481903,
0.21908186376094818,
0.0677998811006546,
-0.3667618930339813,
-0.4369158446788788,
-0.5743939280509949,
0.1867324858903885,
-0.4850960373878479,
0.36200207471847534,
-0.23078063130378723,
-0.7510507702827454,
0.574888288974762,
0.2524876892566681,
-0.05195261165499687,
0.19835028052330017,
0.7169842720031738,
-0.24149583280086517,
0.6841954588890076,
0.3088100552558899,
-0.10720854997634888,
0.34778544306755066,
0.13573363423347473,
0.09084534645080566,
-0.21697592735290527,
-0.07663322240114212,
-0.4326116442680359,
-0.18258482217788696,
-0.6989688873291016,
-0.4952271580696106,
0.2370326668024063,
-0.03748990595340729,
-0.28157180547714233,
0.14780859649181366,
-0.2153848558664322,
0.4079782962799072,
0.7191607356071472,
0.1407659500837326,
0.400486022233963,
0.18615257740020752,
-0.1895005702972412,
-0.0036809188313782215,
-0.6868545413017273,
-0.588941216468811,
0.9370852112770081,
-0.1118820458650589,
0.9336446523666382,
0.050575125962495804,
0.6793164610862732,
0.2739398181438446,
0.12739361822605133,
-0.6163946986198425,
0.7182207703590393,
-0.3765356242656708,
-0.30123671889305115,
-0.1616867184638977,
-0.3859892785549164,
-0.5396846532821655,
0.16944658756256104,
0.12104793637990952,
-0.360980361700058,
-0.04750631004571915,
0.6203147172927856,
-0.34723174571990967,
0.1377101093530655,
-1.0446869134902954,
0.8793014883995056,
-0.19819439947605133,
-0.21306805312633514,
0.2847817540168762,
-0.4192647337913513,
0.20800292491912842,
0.0016065946547314525,
0.2848476767539978,
-0.30456748604774475,
0.23498888313770294,
0.28193962574005127,
-0.5896023511886597,
1.0911271572113037,
0.10166199505329132,
0.046585679054260254,
0.4574226438999176,
0.12951618432998657,
0.7886669635772705,
-0.12137368321418762,
-0.14352208375930786,
-0.05946291983127594,
-0.518699586391449,
-0.23877237737178802,
-0.6808938384056091,
0.4944838285446167,
-0.6940873265266418,
-0.606950044631958,
-0.19687248766422272,
-0.5683615803718567,
-0.33476442098617554,
0.04547207057476044,
0.299630731344223,
0.3744737505912781,
-0.3305705785751343,
0.10014575719833374,
0.31281039118766785,
-0.15467223525047302,
0.19573774933815002,
0.45635053515434265,
-0.3893401324748993,
-0.4049678444862366,
0.9168137907981873,
0.01237795501947403,
0.2019391655921936,
0.2960413992404938,
0.10401774197816849,
0.11138100922107697,
-0.47030651569366455,
-0.6151436567306519,
0.15979111194610596,
-0.5809847712516785,
-0.26275166869163513,
-0.49168646335601807,
-0.2839456796646118,
-0.5692583918571472,
-0.08700180798768997,
-0.3578660488128662,
-0.41066837310791016,
-0.31004929542541504,
-0.33766239881515503,
0.585824191570282,
0.5751394629478455,
-0.10445050150156021,
0.49028125405311584,
-0.8497939109802246,
0.06973391771316528,
-0.060735005885362625,
0.10179288685321808,
-0.6115624308586121,
-0.4573632478713989,
-0.052326101809740067,
0.1283603459596634,
-0.22041307389736176,
-0.7070363759994507,
0.5787234306335449,
0.4172039031982422,
0.2524965703487396,
-0.0933823212981224,
-0.24336615204811096,
0.8093467354774475,
-0.8550477623939514,
0.6696716547012329,
-0.06987812370061874,
-0.8578731417655945,
0.618679940700531,
-0.6932665705680847,
0.2193119078874588,
0.10337164998054504,
-0.19829070568084717,
-1.0099822282791138,
-0.6978935599327087,
-0.7288369536399841,
-0.5450100898742676,
0.8674510717391968,
0.3355524241924286,
-0.06530354171991348,
-0.2123204618692398,
0.3506264388561249,
0.0022586556151509285,
0.11391652375459671,
-0.5542645454406738,
-0.12155240774154663,
-0.1593591272830963,
-0.7208800315856934,
-0.025738554075360298,
-0.4219209849834442,
0.04450751096010208,
0.1392291933298111,
0.8486148715019226,
-0.4061296284198761,
0.22165679931640625,
0.11406359821557999,
-0.19057679176330566,
-0.1726612001657486,
0.33176910877227783,
0.605378270149231,
0.4294687807559967,
0.1133146733045578,
0.1513325721025467,
0.17463113367557526,
-0.45689958333969116,
0.19600297510623932,
0.09129038453102112,
-0.4038592576980591,
0.3161599040031433,
0.36680516600608826,
0.8334766030311584,
0.27618688344955444,
-0.8317768573760986,
0.15231448411941528,
0.2250620275735855,
-0.11285437643527985,
-0.38374394178390503,
0.19209574162960052,
0.31624799966812134,
-0.014481006190180779,
-0.02587791532278061,
0.14988145232200623,
0.13529165089130402,
-0.2812807857990265,
0.29812219738960266,
-0.12925174832344055,
0.2738496661186218,
-0.4040354788303375,
0.5503659844398499,
0.2091817855834961,
-0.2752438485622406,
0.6311178803443909,
-0.42224201560020447,
-0.31819042563438416,
0.7705786228179932,
0.5541105270385742,
0.6508921384811401,
-0.28410354256629944,
0.2789132595062256,
0.376877099275589,
0.06723032891750336,
-0.3977164924144745,
0.5768733620643616,
0.5801259279251099,
-0.9944087266921997,
-0.5310838222503662,
-0.4261218309402466,
-0.47761037945747375,
0.08646833151578903,
-0.4186112880706787,
0.6036446690559387,
-0.49968239665031433,
0.1543819010257721,
-0.14545786380767822,
-0.47943252325057983,
-0.31395068764686584,
-0.02730332501232624,
0.23012234270572662,
0.4173283874988556,
-0.6844154000282288,
0.7207746505737305,
0.8565317988395691,
-0.09822278469800949,
-0.9264631867408752,
-0.4403826594352722,
0.4363384246826172,
-0.9309683442115784,
0.570571780204773,
0.03855803236365318,
-0.016566945239901543,
-0.14437627792358398,
-0.42867544293403625,
-0.7681531310081482,
0.7822888493537903,
0.7669275999069214,
-1.009204387664795,
-0.3289848566055298,
0.5875440835952759,
0.5634720325469971,
-0.4107717275619507,
-0.022094063460826874,
0.5978356003761292,
0.23869134485721588,
0.058813512325286865,
-0.7884219288825989,
-0.22642308473587036,
-0.40555813908576965,
0.30938977003097534,
0.00903235748410225,
-0.6302374005317688,
0.8920204639434814,
-0.03712523728609085,
-0.18887318670749664,
0.2349272519350052,
0.6844696998596191,
0.3539518117904663,
-0.19816477596759796,
0.2598121166229248,
0.5747926235198975,
0.8545717000961304,
-0.2694946825504303,
0.8258278965950012,
-0.12498748302459717,
0.446679025888443,
1.4993070363998413,
-0.39305388927459717,
0.5483527183532715,
0.3230390250682831,
-0.38864168524742126,
0.33243757486343384,
0.7101497054100037,
-0.10666697472333908,
0.17990784347057343,
0.23042088747024536,
-0.3264399766921997,
-0.14451944828033447,
0.18700814247131348,
0.056805551052093506,
0.2902791202068329,
0.47793102264404297,
-0.28144803643226624,
-0.2915087640285492,
-0.08870000392198563,
0.14709612727165222,
0.23208725452423096,
-0.239601731300354,
0.5673589706420898,
-0.02828144282102585,
-0.7214964628219604,
0.37502169609069824,
0.13807934522628784,
0.5891196131706238,
-0.3411943018436432,
-0.1322472244501114,
-0.7452523708343506,
0.5508329272270203,
-0.36740297079086304,
-0.4456328749656677,
0.3884907364845276,
0.23254919052124023,
-0.19670294225215912,
-0.2307991087436676,
0.8994741439819336,
-0.729393720626831,
-0.8419524431228638,
-0.06958351284265518,
0.5383396744728088,
0.1403828263282776,
-0.03420286998152733,
-0.3890157639980316,
0.2964211106300354,
0.22890159487724304,
0.07073386013507843,
0.04512061923742294,
0.6631343364715576,
-0.06887637078762054,
0.5520020723342896,
0.5371010303497314,
0.20394398272037506,
0.5411997437477112,
0.2814342975616455,
0.7011091113090515,
-0.6344090104103088,
-0.49083271622657776,
-0.8934826254844666,
0.408684104681015,
-0.10747215151786804,
-0.09936247020959854,
0.7740814089775085,
0.5988510251045227,
1.1228288412094116,
-0.41330134868621826,
1.0173407793045044,
-0.25188300013542175,
0.7890971899032593,
-0.7381758689880371,
0.18944595754146576,
-0.057874761521816254,
0.3743751049041748,
-0.043151289224624634,
-0.6617206931114197,
-0.3644181787967682,
0.4842227101325989,
-0.034788914024829865,
-0.15865710377693176,
0.7435541749000549,
1.4024862051010132,
0.09689915925264359,
0.218611478805542,
0.46391087770462036,
0.2666041851043701,
0.27722105383872986,
0.4491465985774994,
1.0299237966537476,
-0.4705386757850647,
0.5138463377952576,
-0.3059743642807007,
0.04644060879945755,
-0.27039286494255066,
-0.5986145734786987,
-0.7529213428497314,
-0.3051168620586395,
-0.22531309723854065,
-0.33673664927482605,
0.47760164737701416,
1.066884160041809,
0.38096556067466736,
-0.962958812713623,
-0.49921324849128723,
-0.5598410964012146,
-0.020603341981768608,
-0.05364066734910011,
-0.2448660135269165,
0.05931723117828369,
-0.9459532499313354,
-1.0281496047973633,
0.4768434166908264,
0.3047167956829071,
0.1037389487028122,
0.01450375560671091,
-0.1790928840637207,
0.07565775513648987,
-0.3180953562259674,
0.5178519487380981,
0.14797358214855194,
-0.6619499921798706,
-0.23027567565441132,
0.28855541348457336,
-0.26642492413520813,
0.4274424910545349,
1.035206913948059,
-0.3899688124656677,
0.32984697818756104,
0.46358397603034973,
0.7215208411216736,
0.08431580662727356,
-0.04590790346264839,
1.0108051300048828,
-0.9591150283813477,
0.25183290243148804,
0.12177722901105881,
0.7539888620376587,
0.5593811273574829,
-0.500452995300293,
0.6226956844329834,
0.7587746977806091,
-0.42388927936553955,
-0.48518261313438416,
-0.0574975349009037,
-0.9397704601287842,
0.09282197803258896,
1.468406319618225,
-0.2427026629447937,
-0.4050736725330353,
0.07912898808717728,
-0.5521254539489746,
-0.010157818906009197,
-0.4615114629268646,
0.5324005484580994,
1.0819427967071533,
-0.21582339704036713,
-0.16532807052135468,
-0.4775444269180298,
0.5821000337600708,
0.516829788684845,
-1.1496505737304688,
0.20171865820884705,
0.9745566248893738,
0.2994532585144043,
-0.06558822095394135,
0.6881375908851624,
-0.3012348413467407,
0.46889954805374146,
0.1573001742362976,
0.1554650068283081,
0.0017799645429477096,
-0.2418363243341446,
-0.17801137268543243,
-0.1228460893034935,
0.02680681273341179,
-0.15447795391082764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06588v1
|
Assessing the Emergent Symbolic Reasoning Abilities of Llama Large Language Models
| 2024-06-05T12:22:43 | 2024-06-05T12:22:43 |
Flavio Petruzzellis, Alberto Testolin, Alessandro Sperduti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) achieve impressive performance in a wide range
of tasks, even if they are often trained with the only objective of chatting
fluently with users. Among other skills, LLMs show emergent abilities in
mathematical reasoning benchmarks, which can be elicited with appropriate
prompting methods. In this work, we systematically investigate the capabilities
and limitations of popular open-source LLMs on different symbolic reasoning
tasks. We evaluate three models of the Llama 2 family on two datasets that
require solving mathematical formulas of varying degrees of difficulty. We test
a generalist LLM (Llama 2 Chat) as well as two fine-tuned versions of Llama 2
(MAmmoTH and MetaMath) specifically designed to tackle mathematical problems.
We observe that both increasing the scale of the model and fine-tuning it on
relevant tasks lead to significant performance gains. Furthermore, using
fine-grained evaluation measures, we find that such performance gains are
mostly observed with mathematical formulas of low complexity, which
nevertheless often remain challenging even for the largest fine-tuned models.
|
[
-0.14735658466815948,
-1.0066962242126465,
0.8212336897850037,
0.5647444725036621,
-0.3673862814903259,
0.2608528733253479,
-0.4127365052700043,
-0.6923953890800476,
-0.13481643795967102,
0.28497353196144104,
-0.4407045245170593,
-0.3919907510280609,
-0.91925448179245,
0.4044399559497833,
-0.3860471844673157,
0.7191380262374878,
-0.1424928903579712,
-0.08186895400285721,
-0.23667751252651215,
0.024456854909658432,
-0.49144247174263,
-0.40979522466659546,
-0.6867184042930603,
-0.34051600098609924,
0.4098711907863617,
0.2714574933052063,
0.9830729365348816,
0.5744377970695496,
0.6096742153167725,
0.3361080288887024,
-0.357945054769516,
0.4265305697917938,
-0.4043084979057312,
0.4312259554862976,
-0.049106113612651825,
-0.7214338779449463,
-0.2991269528865814,
-0.1994815617799759,
0.646490752696991,
0.46221983432769775,
-0.21344463527202606,
0.47569501399993896,
0.03792678937315941,
0.33813342452049255,
-0.4805537164211273,
0.5001587867736816,
-0.973138153553009,
-0.15561021864414215,
-0.28870296478271484,
0.0958520770072937,
-0.3687112033367157,
-0.3526107370853424,
0.11613047868013382,
-0.6045332551002502,
-0.28071656823158264,
-0.12233906984329224,
0.6431770920753479,
0.48008233308792114,
-0.2692283093929291,
-0.4161092936992645,
-0.8131018877029419,
0.9862759709358215,
-0.7445909380912781,
0.22937731444835663,
0.3262158930301666,
0.5127378106117249,
-0.2956586480140686,
-0.6577082872390747,
-0.3897235691547394,
-0.44479599595069885,
0.10283680260181427,
-0.28890225291252136,
-0.745262622833252,
-0.3053849935531616,
0.4892551898956299,
0.1878613382577896,
-0.329422265291214,
0.4345146119594574,
-0.21115702390670776,
0.06893885135650635,
0.6994448304176331,
0.40427166223526,
0.3110259473323822,
-0.07299885898828506,
0.020382435992360115,
-0.07662797719240189,
-0.8436607718467712,
-0.06006962060928345,
0.24430184066295624,
0.2827748954296112,
-0.11368141323328018,
0.8631839156150818,
-0.12936539947986603,
0.5314363241195679,
-0.2924055755138397,
-0.2298896759748459,
-0.10678055137395859,
-0.11799322813749313,
-0.21195295453071594,
-0.16973544657230377,
0.698807418346405,
-0.0874863862991333,
0.731661319732666,
0.09963279962539673,
-0.3638765215873718,
0.2002582997083664,
-0.0931941494345665,
-0.7177448868751526,
-0.1507485806941986,
0.18182672560214996,
-0.256735622882843,
-0.026498502120375633,
-0.27543526887893677,
-0.36061397194862366,
-0.4952352046966553,
-0.42342984676361084,
0.4357593357563019,
-0.2612081468105316,
-0.34698688983917236,
0.10128850489854813,
-0.05275038257241249,
0.15161952376365662,
0.6763558983802795,
-0.8350155353546143,
0.11056506633758545,
1.0034290552139282,
0.9250085949897766,
-0.06458335369825363,
-0.04961974918842316,
-0.44491666555404663,
-0.07632100582122803,
-0.49817097187042236,
0.9155101180076599,
-0.7131724953651428,
-0.2708970308303833,
-0.08184344321489334,
-0.2930750846862793,
-0.08460425585508347,
-0.7864031791687012,
0.4520890712738037,
-0.5007888674736023,
-0.21388374269008636,
-0.3261649012565613,
-0.2244284451007843,
-0.15030305087566376,
0.1872580647468567,
-0.6073136329650879,
1.1612850427627563,
0.18156680464744568,
-0.532701313495636,
0.04021254926919937,
-0.6941626667976379,
-0.3051057457923889,
0.20054006576538086,
-0.2516450881958008,
-0.18675436079502106,
0.32367444038391113,
0.24546921253204346,
0.5256150364875793,
-0.8197324872016907,
0.33862340450286865,
-0.3498659133911133,
-0.3314496576786041,
0.43798893690109253,
-0.4806528091430664,
0.7454723715782166,
0.2400817573070526,
-0.37811020016670227,
0.14687275886535645,
-0.6920319199562073,
0.07337119430303574,
0.5776476263999939,
-0.11916875094175339,
-0.35087141394615173,
0.27034616470336914,
-0.40895748138427734,
0.15852761268615723,
0.31683310866355896,
-0.1381523311138153,
0.2694651186466217,
-0.33713874220848083,
0.7020049095153809,
0.860843300819397,
-0.14899660646915436,
-0.08177393674850464,
-0.30640125274658203,
0.5801772475242615,
-0.009030613116919994,
-0.09853833168745041,
-0.10220125317573547,
-0.8123907446861267,
-0.8430911898612976,
-0.4359089136123657,
0.11919153481721878,
0.5580322742462158,
-0.6435359716415405,
0.09720595926046371,
-0.19527675211429596,
-0.7702710628509521,
-0.36680278182029724,
0.5161563158035278,
0.3713362216949463,
0.004834444262087345,
0.20320314168930054,
0.13700136542320251,
-0.3612115681171417,
-0.9834442138671875,
-0.308823823928833,
-0.35408011078834534,
-0.27744489908218384,
0.4466785192489624,
0.6554446220397949,
-0.2269258052110672,
0.6533774137496948,
-0.42179161310195923,
0.13573729991912842,
-0.19980989396572113,
0.2092524915933609,
0.3525560200214386,
0.062479570508003235,
0.342480331659317,
-0.302491158246994,
-0.2300899773836136,
0.12118932604789734,
-0.9292691946029663,
-0.44526207447052,
0.0595865361392498,
0.18350282311439514,
0.11752759665250778,
0.32142072916030884,
-0.863917350769043,
0.2090040147304535,
0.5924229621887207,
-0.22111040353775024,
0.72613525390625,
-0.11466947942972183,
-0.15103299915790558,
-0.7604778409004211,
-0.2000107765197754,
0.07368236780166626,
0.1311069130897522,
-0.6244193911552429,
0.15988346934318542,
-0.06532744318246841,
0.07814446836709976,
-0.4461669325828552,
0.4882158637046814,
-0.4903396666049957,
-0.2753240466117859,
-0.12788069248199463,
0.2368800938129425,
-0.4509561359882355,
0.1807776540517807,
0.04463551566004753,
0.8021244406700134,
0.5535466074943542,
-0.6565356254577637,
0.20214688777923584,
0.03660338371992111,
-0.5412911176681519,
0.33295947313308716,
-1.0908894538879395,
0.23165611922740936,
0.10084939748048782,
0.14447686076164246,
-1.1357828378677368,
-0.3001245856285095,
0.0583045668900013,
-0.15411706268787384,
-0.0640021339058876,
0.15859882533550262,
-0.9488898515701294,
-0.547235906124115,
-0.09178397059440613,
0.4261506497859955,
0.47213679552078247,
-0.6062253713607788,
0.6920892000198364,
0.10430711507797241,
-0.3275754153728485,
-0.3607388734817505,
-0.36421093344688416,
0.14403875172138214,
-0.387808620929718,
-0.817298948764801,
-0.1910492479801178,
0.06625945121049881,
-0.7573690414428711,
-0.2656446099281311,
0.026449494063854218,
0.11729048937559128,
0.4081009328365326,
0.3727368116378784,
0.30457210540771484,
-0.43971478939056396,
0.21377381682395935,
0.2864203453063965,
-0.08208094537258148,
0.3890930414199829,
0.054841384291648865,
0.5363224148750305,
-0.4614424705505371,
-0.6234596371650696,
-0.22370672225952148,
-0.04125091806054115,
0.611421525478363,
-0.3542778491973877,
0.665623128414154,
0.3214053213596344,
-0.514869213104248,
-0.2716919481754303,
-0.6164259910583496,
-0.17089039087295532,
-0.46416470408439636,
0.36015066504478455,
-0.45515090227127075,
-1.022951364517212,
0.5886071920394897,
-0.21303091943264008,
0.37751641869544983,
0.6605835556983948,
0.8576011061668396,
0.23016147315502167,
1.28755521774292,
0.13190093636512756,
0.33534130454063416,
0.13454550504684448,
-0.1406988650560379,
0.06310483068227768,
-0.7293164730072021,
-0.369813472032547,
-0.6951060891151428,
-0.2654608488082886,
-0.36733269691467285,
-0.6374996304512024,
0.40178942680358887,
0.24432842433452606,
-0.40909919142723083,
0.3443223237991333,
-0.36375683546066284,
0.5582547187805176,
0.3054521679878235,
-0.0604480504989624,
0.6309027075767517,
-0.0023953893687576056,
-0.04343881085515022,
0.10486064851284027,
-0.49527716636657715,
-0.8086225986480713,
1.1619987487792969,
0.5330610275268555,
0.8691112995147705,
0.35012054443359375,
0.2204141467809677,
-0.0002554333768785,
0.4295978844165802,
-0.7415716052055359,
0.7960805892944336,
-0.05629783868789673,
-0.4078699052333832,
-0.3171312212944031,
-0.5516082048416138,
-0.977036714553833,
0.3400232195854187,
-0.28848549723625183,
-0.9801848530769348,
-0.23241747915744781,
-0.020834362134337425,
-0.22835952043533325,
0.2192879170179367,
-0.6668159365653992,
0.3980156481266022,
-0.46074387431144714,
-0.11274244636297226,
-0.3891807198524475,
-0.43805766105651855,
0.7392326593399048,
-0.4519520401954651,
0.12346955388784409,
-0.45753955841064453,
-0.21611288189888,
0.7110320925712585,
-0.15134914219379425,
0.9032491445541382,
0.17234842479228973,
-0.4989906847476959,
0.40644246339797974,
0.5424495339393616,
0.5585681796073914,
0.1373303383588791,
-0.02600429765880108,
0.5279650092124939,
0.008332830853760242,
-0.1155068427324295,
-0.8182048201560974,
0.6622169613838196,
-0.8818264007568359,
-1.069372296333313,
-0.2561398148536682,
-0.7085251808166504,
-0.3093540370464325,
-0.031511079519987106,
-0.27466073632240295,
0.12571266293525696,
0.06823181360960007,
0.2808530032634735,
0.513987123966217,
-0.12859944999217987,
0.3138466775417328,
0.5271092057228088,
-0.2120514065027237,
-0.229236900806427,
0.6340013146400452,
0.09501396119594574,
0.44521570205688477,
0.06196624040603638,
0.4562302529811859,
-0.39654242992401123,
-0.4577031433582306,
-0.599567711353302,
0.43869176506996155,
-0.7297583818435669,
-0.20528247952461243,
-0.470719575881958,
-0.3939928114414215,
0.023392364382743835,
0.16007265448570251,
-0.2923722267150879,
-0.6266701221466064,
-0.46637865900993347,
0.11933362483978271,
0.48959556221961975,
1.061087965965271,
0.09543640166521072,
0.2205851525068283,
-0.7117763161659241,
0.028924912214279175,
0.4153169095516205,
0.13464246690273285,
0.357086181640625,
-0.5971475839614868,
0.06320486217737198,
0.054137710481882095,
-0.4380338788032532,
-0.7749492526054382,
0.0873531922698021,
0.018186397850513458,
0.5922947525978088,
0.6468225121498108,
-0.18377438187599182,
0.597538948059082,
-0.40803176164627075,
0.7791262269020081,
0.0757112056016922,
-0.8740760684013367,
0.5507397651672363,
-0.3310154378414154,
0.2951849699020386,
-0.04306052625179291,
0.47472673654556274,
-0.06894103437662125,
-0.45329177379608154,
-0.490637868642807,
-0.3807428777217865,
0.3932796120643616,
0.4515218436717987,
0.21705858409404755,
-0.08636458218097687,
0.30990323424339294,
-0.0054886494763195515,
0.10752569139003754,
-0.44753211736679077,
-0.05648680031299591,
0.12561465799808502,
-0.015014519914984703,
-0.21928678452968597,
-0.2103314995765686,
-0.22296638786792755,
-0.34404847025871277,
0.2506980001926422,
-0.07204809039831161,
0.020874561741948128,
-0.16066023707389832,
0.03470050171017647,
-0.21143870055675507,
0.3205467760562897,
0.7610533237457275,
0.680162250995636,
0.12004508078098297,
0.28193676471710205,
0.446780264377594,
-0.30232226848602295,
0.1911889910697937,
0.1861799955368042,
0.059496551752090454,
-0.24995394051074982,
0.5341627597808838,
0.703475832939148,
0.45734110474586487,
-1.0478078126907349,
0.10314516723155975,
0.021912017837166786,
-0.2835715115070343,
-0.1140371561050415,
0.3528063893318176,
0.3766190707683563,
0.5653239488601685,
0.3468422591686249,
-0.3098851442337036,
-0.24447676539421082,
-0.4166736900806427,
-0.32591840624809265,
0.7189249992370605,
0.19639162719249725,
-0.3615151643753052,
0.626075804233551,
-0.06241331622004509,
-0.49251535534858704,
0.6293924450874329,
-0.023017505183815956,
-0.48699256777763367,
0.6028425097465515,
0.9373478889465332,
0.6456363201141357,
-0.22929747402668,
0.13705892860889435,
0.2502068281173706,
0.5112231373786926,
-0.17460398375988007,
0.13259300589561462,
-0.13125431537628174,
-0.6003192663192749,
-0.4684809148311615,
-0.5539684295654297,
-0.5120260715484619,
0.1259675920009613,
-0.29027989506721497,
0.15610703825950623,
-0.4297541081905365,
-0.23615121841430664,
0.09703606367111206,
0.12498929351568222,
-0.5321386456489563,
-0.19996672868728638,
0.030078765004873276,
0.9436786770820618,
-0.7137678861618042,
0.35822594165802,
0.6285309791564941,
-0.10972446948289871,
-0.9063977003097534,
-0.4076232314109802,
0.13738013803958893,
-1.1859489679336548,
0.9065017700195312,
0.12999211251735687,
-0.06432617455720901,
-0.055127132683992386,
-0.49330490827560425,
-0.9990692734718323,
1.120116114616394,
0.7058631777763367,
-0.6582005620002747,
-0.07785365730524063,
0.3840245306491852,
0.6869139671325684,
-0.35533493757247925,
0.5024119019508362,
0.7205047011375427,
0.4861023426055908,
0.38639140129089355,
-1.1028368473052979,
0.15569451451301575,
-0.20406858623027802,
0.12052153795957565,
0.2148667722940445,
-0.5665380954742432,
0.9599831700325012,
-0.4913347661495209,
-0.356456995010376,
0.32988181710243225,
0.6631207466125488,
0.8031734824180603,
0.2753555178642273,
0.6453958749771118,
0.5370460748672485,
0.9567747116088867,
-0.24242368340492249,
1.0508848428726196,
-0.2095000445842743,
-0.010118384845554829,
0.8082929253578186,
-0.4135758578777313,
1.157863974571228,
0.2763988971710205,
-0.2784629464149475,
0.6581022143363953,
0.6207760572433472,
0.0018591823754832149,
-0.13364598155021667,
0.5674619674682617,
-0.20146602392196655,
-0.5703732967376709,
-0.06378371268510818,
-0.3493410050868988,
0.5560466051101685,
0.6590065956115723,
-0.29359278082847595,
-0.3814181685447693,
-0.3915163576602936,
0.08764814585447311,
-0.1143086776137352,
-0.3402929902076721,
0.5677019357681274,
0.37123581767082214,
-0.6448102593421936,
0.618408739566803,
-0.06137390434741974,
0.23522640764713287,
-0.5545951128005981,
-0.19091859459877014,
-0.00937115028500557,
0.0853610560297966,
-0.14141611754894257,
-0.9357755184173584,
0.19006343185901642,
0.32219573855400085,
0.23387368023395538,
0.24122384190559387,
0.7206918597221375,
-0.01713108830153942,
-0.6315554976463318,
0.1415283977985382,
0.8417462706565857,
0.3010222613811493,
-0.07342350482940674,
-0.6402429342269897,
0.29888787865638733,
-0.42149728536605835,
-0.2276659458875656,
0.2860102653503418,
0.4686948359012604,
-0.5188378095626831,
1.0205590724945068,
0.9642210006713867,
0.011622983030974865,
0.0024551411624997854,
0.1010608896613121,
0.8483368158340454,
-0.38409289717674255,
-0.06917402148246765,
-1.1376549005508423,
0.07399138808250427,
0.1631447821855545,
-0.40648984909057617,
0.9201942086219788,
0.2842516601085663,
0.3799838423728943,
0.0016205222345888615,
0.2470933347940445,
0.39033687114715576,
0.14643804728984833,
-0.5067986249923706,
0.4641337990760803,
-0.4355533719062805,
0.4902005195617676,
-0.22019651532173157,
-1.1091512441635132,
-0.3152013123035431,
0.4787740707397461,
-0.3756755590438843,
0.11014941334724426,
0.4953286945819855,
0.6905408501625061,
0.09944091737270355,
0.30589768290519714,
0.2634321451187134,
0.34928253293037415,
0.3377380967140198,
0.8067455887794495,
1.3836508989334106,
0.12154442816972733,
0.4738136827945709,
0.0623888336122036,
-0.29118314385414124,
-0.06846330314874649,
-1.0120155811309814,
-1.191024899482727,
-0.30559366941452026,
-0.18791143596172333,
-0.3261295258998871,
-0.09337610751390457,
0.9415733814239502,
0.4289223849773407,
-0.5513923168182373,
-0.2811623513698578,
0.019005410373210907,
0.19713376462459564,
-0.15663586556911469,
-0.20554137229919434,
0.33153364062309265,
-0.11420264840126038,
-0.5737909078598022,
0.35699012875556946,
0.26721784472465515,
0.09710244834423065,
-0.5025759339332581,
-0.05838153138756752,
0.19717127084732056,
0.429531067609787,
0.8362125754356384,
0.24293698370456696,
-1.0251456499099731,
-0.2421295940876007,
0.11550561338663101,
0.033708032220602036,
-0.2798325717449188,
0.7136373519897461,
-0.5508503317832947,
0.12338849902153015,
0.27551883459091187,
0.7619859576225281,
0.21671879291534424,
-0.045143209397792816,
0.2540898025035858,
-0.2366241216659546,
-0.15940210223197937,
0.0680212751030922,
0.39193087816238403,
0.14404146373271942,
-0.11094792932271957,
0.5645800828933716,
0.11173637956380844,
-0.502173900604248,
-1.091550588607788,
0.11140359938144684,
-0.8822524547576904,
-0.10917653143405914,
1.4441314935684204,
0.0011316185118630528,
-0.04733044281601906,
0.08913033455610275,
-0.13324183225631714,
0.0029623524751514196,
-0.24875004589557648,
0.7505477070808411,
0.7408224940299988,
-0.16334430873394012,
-0.05267709493637085,
-0.6585105061531067,
0.14697524905204773,
0.3615986406803131,
-0.9353004097938538,
0.09663520753383636,
0.3501492738723755,
0.21222926676273346,
0.2718961238861084,
0.2809728980064392,
-0.08515363186597824,
0.32113489508628845,
-0.08823773264884949,
-0.5366224646568298,
-0.24278275668621063,
-0.4234728515148163,
-0.29552221298217773,
0.06804603338241577,
0.2855057418346405,
0.3283849358558655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03181v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03181v1
|
Missci: Reconstructing Fallacies in Misrepresented Science
| 2024-06-05T12:11:10 | 2024-06-05T12:11:10 |
Max Glockner, Yufang Hou, Preslav Nakov, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Health-related misinformation on social networks can lead to poor
decision-making and real-world dangers. Such misinformation often misrepresents
scientific publications and cites them as "proof" to gain perceived
credibility. To effectively counter such claims automatically, a system must
explain how the claim was falsely derived from the cited publication. Current
methods for automated fact-checking or fallacy detection neglect to assess the
(mis)used evidence in relation to misinformation claims, which is required to
detect the mismatch between them. To address this gap, we introduce Missci, a
novel argumentation theoretical model for fallacious reasoning together with a
new dataset for real-world misinformation detection that misrepresents
biomedical publications. Unlike previous fallacy detection datasets, Missci (i)
focuses on implicit fallacies between the relevant content of the cited
publication and the inaccurate claim, and (ii) requires models to verbalize the
fallacious reasoning in addition to classifying it. We present Missci as a
dataset to test the critical reasoning abilities of large language models
(LLMs), that are required to reconstruct real-world fallacious arguments, in a
zero-shot setting. We evaluate two representative LLMs and the impact of
different levels of detail about the fallacy classes provided to the LLM via
prompts. Our experiments and human evaluation show promising results for GPT 4,
while also demonstrating the difficulty of this task.
|
[
0.0549161359667778,
-0.7853109836578369,
0.7855758666992188,
-0.14069955050945282,
0.07106300443410873,
-0.020197158679366112,
0.1347854882478714,
-0.23541517555713654,
0.17143404483795166,
0.320258766412735,
-0.4494134485721588,
-0.4351804852485657,
-0.6170180439949036,
0.497393399477005,
-0.24668587744235992,
1.1292780637741089,
-0.009000826627016068,
0.06501224637031555,
-0.31355732679367065,
-0.18846191465854645,
-0.21629765629768372,
-0.2986776530742645,
-0.3503752052783966,
-0.45819199085235596,
0.533704936504364,
0.6351195573806763,
0.5475589632987976,
0.22628329694271088,
0.4126802384853363,
0.21747370064258575,
-0.0476112961769104,
0.5044244527816772,
-0.4462308883666992,
-0.11450053751468658,
-0.18663524091243744,
-0.45769453048706055,
-0.07732826471328735,
0.11653777211904526,
0.6071171164512634,
0.7705415487289429,
-0.16666072607040405,
0.1643831878900528,
-0.22943240404129028,
0.5505993962287903,
-0.6899771094322205,
-0.04846668243408203,
-0.6009613275527954,
0.054413601756095886,
-0.053132522851228714,
-0.21551518142223358,
-0.6845614910125732,
-0.4742026627063751,
0.07975494861602783,
-0.2936568558216095,
0.4856550097465515,
-0.0719919353723526,
0.9599325656890869,
0.3986910283565521,
-0.31162700057029724,
-0.22029507160186768,
-0.6013444066047668,
0.4905451536178589,
-0.9560057520866394,
0.5216813683509827,
0.1681288182735443,
0.17134732007980347,
-0.3523428440093994,
-0.4915313124656677,
-0.5750088095664978,
-0.40921279788017273,
0.0586639903485775,
0.20758363604545593,
-0.1925061196088791,
-0.2319103181362152,
0.5007518529891968,
0.16292265057563782,
-0.7853119969367981,
-0.3805532455444336,
-0.6059534549713135,
-0.2494838386774063,
0.4159619212150574,
-0.038762401789426804,
0.51288241147995,
-0.2465663105249405,
-0.029037535190582275,
0.14800985157489777,
-0.9080130457878113,
-0.43580329418182373,
0.0899217426776886,
0.34201839566230774,
-0.3582044541835785,
0.31596267223358154,
0.22152146697044373,
0.6252121925354004,
0.10333015024662018,
-0.04005918279290199,
0.48348119854927063,
-0.521820604801178,
-0.2502555549144745,
0.24376538395881653,
0.5889177322387695,
0.26860103011131287,
0.005778858903795481,
-0.06058138981461525,
0.15956494212150574,
0.17863300442695618,
0.36539551615715027,
-0.4894693195819855,
-0.1356518566608429,
0.0802769809961319,
-0.6877854466438293,
-0.34513479471206665,
-0.2692834436893463,
-0.6053228974342346,
-0.32418638467788696,
0.02090945467352867,
0.2003566324710846,
-0.4231695830821991,
-0.2885022759437561,
0.17417049407958984,
-0.41890668869018555,
-0.15915553271770477,
0.39885246753692627,
-0.3350532352924347,
0.09719087183475494,
0.3631531894207001,
1.0411678552627563,
0.015777917578816414,
-0.2651958465576172,
-0.2686696946620941,
0.26380422711372375,
-0.5404193997383118,
1.0817301273345947,
-0.6671094298362732,
-0.4782467484474182,
-0.08616828918457031,
0.16215398907661438,
-0.31247973442077637,
-0.5117473006248474,
0.8884283304214478,
-0.2088344842195511,
0.19142474234104156,
-0.5255586504936218,
-0.3058241903781891,
-0.12908735871315002,
0.47427842020988464,
-0.6400694251060486,
0.616769552230835,
-0.013683738186955452,
-1.0461044311523438,
0.4243318438529968,
-0.8473433256149292,
-0.49779462814331055,
-0.05430999770760536,
-0.2670897841453552,
-0.5433188080787659,
0.04566485434770584,
0.12620633840560913,
0.11711230129003525,
-0.3354188799858093,
0.20048309862613678,
-0.5893490314483643,
-0.052368972450494766,
0.2662389576435089,
-0.5958329439163208,
0.7205331325531006,
0.19107066094875336,
-0.1773887276649475,
-0.04246482253074646,
-0.6239179372787476,
-0.1975206583738327,
0.2482750117778778,
-0.36080583930015564,
-0.4226197898387909,
0.17657101154327393,
-0.303599089384079,
0.12686555087566376,
-0.07176058739423752,
-0.746809720993042,
0.08101646602153778,
-0.5341753959655762,
0.590207040309906,
0.33568236231803894,
0.12720033526420593,
-0.2361651062965393,
-0.47020474076271057,
0.10288452357053757,
0.2462075799703598,
0.14000776410102844,
-0.18550387024879456,
-0.5621268153190613,
-0.504080593585968,
-0.03459124639630318,
0.1729733645915985,
0.5050655603408813,
-0.7805511355400085,
-0.02125152386724949,
-0.4193987250328064,
-0.33903712034225464,
-0.44947341084480286,
-0.2593061029911041,
0.3740752637386322,
0.9789033532142639,
0.6548004746437073,
0.15984073281288147,
-0.525581419467926,
-1.1560330390930176,
-0.3170362412929535,
-0.4872676134109497,
-0.05655457079410553,
0.2565781772136688,
0.8931272625923157,
-0.36489778757095337,
0.7365298867225647,
-0.4185146391391754,
0.1858089119195938,
-0.16513746976852417,
0.38291457295417786,
0.2273675501346588,
0.27872881293296814,
0.45101064443588257,
-0.8204848766326904,
0.16110186278820038,
-0.17285314202308655,
-0.959651529788971,
-0.3293311297893524,
-0.06843370199203491,
0.13854384422302246,
0.12334281951189041,
0.06138864904642105,
-0.6667858958244324,
0.6002030372619629,
0.15001028776168823,
-0.24439041316509247,
0.9385001063346863,
-0.2645317614078522,
0.6235575079917908,
-0.8083858489990234,
0.14748713374137878,
0.2532764673233032,
-0.3166247308254242,
-0.4873439371585846,
-0.11757881939411163,
-0.010263406671583652,
-0.12778648734092712,
-0.2532959282398224,
0.27554333209991455,
-0.4272207021713257,
0.2323266714811325,
-0.24884873628616333,
-0.04302365332841873,
0.045152004808187485,
-0.09410364180803299,
0.12616412341594696,
0.5115283727645874,
0.22911125421524048,
-0.576453447341919,
0.2189946472644806,
0.38610807061195374,
0.0324053056538105,
0.7277781963348389,
-0.7230525016784668,
-0.09375061839818954,
-0.16796165704727173,
0.5604508519172668,
-0.9052125811576843,
-0.3262961506843567,
0.4393503665924072,
-0.6683257818222046,
0.06099741533398628,
-0.3524627685546875,
-0.49649202823638916,
-0.7704052925109863,
-0.07356955111026764,
0.2715422809123993,
-0.15572895109653473,
-0.5139074921607971,
0.4471852779388428,
0.4959115982055664,
0.012334008701145649,
-0.6341232061386108,
-1.0265989303588867,
0.17884176969528198,
-0.036836765706539154,
-0.5767270922660828,
0.10328232496976852,
-0.14366483688354492,
-0.2029893845319748,
-0.1389269232749939,
-0.25383320450782776,
-0.1264365017414093,
-0.25644445419311523,
0.3713381290435791,
0.34458571672439575,
-0.16693086922168732,
0.33675140142440796,
0.14046023786067963,
-0.006813306827098131,
0.1118788793683052,
-0.1392294317483902,
0.005077476613223553,
-0.1139012947678566,
-0.6873458027839661,
-0.34596213698387146,
0.4947962164878845,
0.6580620408058167,
0.2677331268787384,
0.508329451084137,
-0.09663942456245422,
-0.7879683971405029,
-0.09214817732572556,
-0.7288880348205566,
-0.2221730649471283,
-0.33567073941230774,
0.3851099908351898,
-0.2110852152109146,
-0.30643346905708313,
0.21474500000476837,
0.031817346811294556,
0.3725956976413727,
0.3630943298339844,
0.6167619228363037,
0.07642922550439835,
0.7273489832878113,
0.09112338721752167,
-0.005255648400634527,
-0.18793712556362152,
-0.08797825127840042,
0.14832216501235962,
-0.32952845096588135,
-0.08979134261608124,
-0.5845299959182739,
-0.011638255789875984,
-0.10999983549118042,
-0.6985599994659424,
0.182268425822258,
-0.3097984194755554,
-0.34432902932167053,
0.2731199562549591,
-0.5010290741920471,
0.550236701965332,
0.2330453097820282,
0.303658664226532,
0.39129623770713806,
0.006334982346743345,
-0.0326378270983696,
-0.11657502502202988,
-0.8171223402023315,
-0.7378093004226685,
0.9113151431083679,
0.5190752148628235,
0.585359513759613,
0.12248693406581879,
0.4526856243610382,
0.574209451675415,
0.7102838754653931,
-0.5738478899002075,
0.27548807859420776,
-0.027080953121185303,
-0.8454440236091614,
-0.037194523960351944,
-0.6751899719238281,
-0.639407217502594,
0.21239715814590454,
-0.14615266025066376,
-0.5859106779098511,
0.3342059254646301,
0.26228877902030945,
-0.36225610971450806,
0.4696979820728302,
-0.6343908905982971,
0.8217393159866333,
-0.19387228786945343,
-0.16199788451194763,
-0.2665521502494812,
-0.7071100473403931,
0.5355889797210693,
-0.008517386391758919,
0.37726786732673645,
-0.029082415625452995,
0.35048824548721313,
0.7992591857910156,
-0.40347525477409363,
0.8730831742286682,
-0.15867194533348083,
0.004757027141749859,
0.2459484487771988,
0.22237002849578857,
0.18783991038799286,
0.06462369859218597,
-0.2643374502658844,
0.492329478263855,
0.33913835883140564,
-0.31174373626708984,
-0.45900002121925354,
0.6375352144241333,
-0.43041273951530457,
-0.5072345733642578,
-0.45049113035202026,
-0.32038450241088867,
-0.24254953861236572,
0.10920189321041107,
0.2600763142108917,
0.3232230544090271,
-0.4115007519721985,
-0.16049981117248535,
0.5332002639770508,
-0.2129199057817459,
0.07315071672201157,
0.6951761245727539,
0.2541353702545166,
-0.3009294271469116,
0.9198944568634033,
0.2020101100206375,
0.043833229690790176,
0.16716228425502777,
0.19138027727603912,
-0.31557497382164,
-0.6096087694168091,
-0.5067574381828308,
0.6327523589134216,
-0.7070211172103882,
-0.1955103576183319,
-0.5358507037162781,
-0.1861749142408371,
-0.6492841839790344,
0.09729350358247757,
-0.413532555103302,
-0.09757557511329651,
-0.15573854744434357,
-0.1223708987236023,
-0.08157557994127274,
0.6782135367393494,
-0.44714057445526123,
0.05800751969218254,
-1.0028018951416016,
0.3367987871170044,
-0.030174069106578827,
0.1115693598985672,
-0.0948580726981163,
-0.5832419991493225,
-0.11497818678617477,
0.3927818536758423,
-0.542212963104248,
-1.3382965326309204,
0.29744550585746765,
-0.017900710925459862,
0.7298809885978699,
0.6683330535888672,
0.03446192666888237,
0.6187050342559814,
-0.7330143451690674,
0.578626275062561,
0.3955472707748413,
-0.7468023896217346,
0.7409330010414124,
-0.2348247915506363,
-0.08698703348636627,
0.5442659258842468,
0.6041459441184998,
-0.6385201811790466,
-0.2199891060590744,
-0.7782265543937683,
-0.44271671772003174,
0.5906291604042053,
0.27483201026916504,
-0.413922518491745,
-0.3886120915412903,
0.3736966848373413,
0.07235920429229736,
-0.19490468502044678,
-0.671920120716095,
-0.2362530380487442,
-0.17420336604118347,
-0.29393377900123596,
0.24264058470726013,
-0.3522108495235443,
-0.6178140044212341,
0.17333674430847168,
0.6918647885322571,
-0.20197801291942596,
0.2729206681251526,
0.567777693271637,
-0.1604287475347519,
-0.2506103515625,
0.32448315620422363,
0.698391318321228,
0.8090195059776306,
-0.12989374995231628,
0.31783080101013184,
0.25603464245796204,
-0.30343782901763916,
0.18863445520401,
0.21857938170433044,
-0.34894540905952454,
0.3701328933238983,
0.6558833718299866,
0.4830630421638489,
0.2098350077867508,
-0.694783627986908,
0.60752272605896,
-0.05973564833402634,
-0.17080307006835938,
-0.14551490545272827,
-0.1248064786195755,
0.10149895399808884,
0.16474030911922455,
0.34647348523139954,
0.24416646361351013,
0.32802993059158325,
-0.410774290561676,
0.3641360402107239,
0.37666720151901245,
-0.3312263488769531,
-0.4296920895576477,
0.5776658654212952,
0.27883481979370117,
-0.11608503758907318,
0.3485775887966156,
0.3074188828468323,
-0.26711195707321167,
0.6064733862876892,
0.6145153641700745,
0.444043904542923,
-0.310700386762619,
0.5661346912384033,
0.5440840721130371,
0.46254971623420715,
-0.23889105021953583,
-0.023729363456368446,
0.17141033709049225,
-0.812911331653595,
-0.3102942705154419,
-0.1821533590555191,
-0.4082971513271332,
0.3120467960834503,
-0.18685954809188843,
0.1514345407485962,
-0.44230911135673523,
-0.2209680825471878,
0.37844231724739075,
-0.3898075222969055,
-0.15888604521751404,
0.19945140182971954,
0.4942699372768402,
0.9030114412307739,
-1.2239420413970947,
0.29348209500312805,
0.4553317725658417,
-0.7499256730079651,
-0.39795592427253723,
0.3493057191371918,
0.4165993332862854,
-0.6239511966705322,
0.8578083515167236,
0.2687552571296692,
-0.4647957980632782,
-0.5338077545166016,
-1.0359570980072021,
-0.6675072312355042,
0.47093403339385986,
0.6731277108192444,
-0.6499630808830261,
-0.07685989886522293,
0.0006736139766871929,
0.3378705680370331,
-0.5588034391403198,
0.5297040343284607,
0.41739800572395325,
0.4920423626899719,
0.382987916469574,
-0.892760157585144,
0.24412399530410767,
-0.041280973702669144,
-0.34558796882629395,
-0.18239523470401764,
-0.4176886975765228,
0.5404943823814392,
-0.6917920112609863,
-0.3055051565170288,
-0.2777216136455536,
0.5077598690986633,
0.6871379613876343,
0.7389695644378662,
0.5749083161354065,
0.6486246585845947,
0.8970352411270142,
0.037881527096033096,
0.8789777159690857,
0.13128137588500977,
0.34308475255966187,
1.1138607263565063,
-0.475624144077301,
0.6103482842445374,
0.28366249799728394,
-0.24985021352767944,
0.6390261650085449,
0.9129438996315002,
0.0022648663725703955,
0.22001570463180542,
0.20349638164043427,
-0.17884038388729095,
-0.6193645596504211,
0.07645460218191147,
-0.7587850689888,
0.08481555432081223,
0.6664443016052246,
-0.49816659092903137,
-0.52366042137146,
-0.13695202767848969,
0.12971650063991547,
-0.11678706854581833,
-0.1098901629447937,
0.47538888454437256,
0.046332355588674545,
-0.42552822828292847,
0.853574812412262,
-0.09313927590847015,
0.22868293523788452,
-0.31451159715652466,
-0.458109587430954,
-0.150875061750412,
0.07339739799499512,
-0.27128085494041443,
-0.6075115203857422,
0.46714913845062256,
0.04993129149079323,
-0.522200882434845,
0.4025084972381592,
0.768507182598114,
-0.15437999367713928,
-0.5697378516197205,
0.20302219688892365,
0.40568992495536804,
0.5481787323951721,
0.23299598693847656,
-1.0985161066055298,
-0.08964571356773376,
0.03717677667737007,
0.05676908791065216,
-0.21756534278392792,
0.44626981019973755,
-0.02224111184477806,
0.8379586338996887,
0.7995306849479675,
0.41475149989128113,
-0.4929368197917938,
0.19734032452106476,
0.8869211673736572,
-0.5420995950698853,
-0.4640192985534668,
-0.8841515183448792,
0.048669055104255676,
-0.3780857026576996,
-0.02768404223024845,
0.37202027440071106,
0.5629732608795166,
0.3515378534793854,
-0.10677465796470642,
1.0697609186172485,
0.15964381396770477,
1.0286085605621338,
-0.3030249774456024,
0.8644497990608215,
-0.7012286186218262,
0.044945213943719864,
-0.3356202244758606,
-0.264288991689682,
-0.5505901575088501,
0.5699174404144287,
-0.721907377243042,
-0.054541703313589096,
0.7897669076919556,
0.7127587199211121,
-0.17654907703399658,
0.28556889295578003,
0.26253706216812134,
0.6693108677864075,
0.3435405194759369,
0.6705833077430725,
0.7311166524887085,
-0.38346895575523376,
0.571073591709137,
0.46586716175079346,
-0.4007790982723236,
-0.32334014773368835,
-0.8595542311668396,
-0.8264538049697876,
-0.23620764911174774,
-0.6909894347190857,
-0.7638327479362488,
0.46833792328834534,
0.7360363602638245,
0.7342361807823181,
-0.8790767788887024,
0.26520630717277527,
0.02869783155620098,
0.4370795488357544,
-0.07925469428300858,
-0.18354381620883942,
0.275453120470047,
-0.03662499785423279,
-0.43952974677085876,
0.6109784245491028,
0.3935198485851288,
-0.017713269218802452,
-0.13014377653598785,
0.010903777554631233,
-0.4271775782108307,
0.3001289963722229,
0.2283424735069275,
0.6872689127922058,
-0.7194615006446838,
-0.1965818703174591,
-0.6054205894470215,
-0.04567002132534981,
0.24977268278598785,
0.862714946269989,
-0.7113248705863953,
0.3405425548553467,
0.49671265482902527,
0.615292489528656,
0.05113397538661957,
-0.00891848187893629,
0.42263731360435486,
-0.4356038570404053,
-0.08603895455598831,
0.18993443250656128,
0.4964764416217804,
0.5584322810173035,
-0.30837932229042053,
0.41243821382522583,
0.8253517746925354,
-0.54902184009552,
-1.0277900695800781,
0.20966985821723938,
-0.7088104486465454,
-0.4798109233379364,
1.0558626651763916,
-0.2686784863471985,
-0.5314130187034607,
-0.4301703870296478,
-0.0789942815899849,
0.23573952913284302,
-0.5057094693183899,
1.0887155532836914,
0.7494064569473267,
-0.01830027997493744,
-0.1302853375673294,
-0.637231171131134,
0.3662896454334259,
0.19579832255840302,
-0.9212037324905396,
0.4233492612838745,
0.7854733467102051,
0.5752318501472473,
0.44370564818382263,
0.7315715551376343,
-0.20886476337909698,
0.5357197523117065,
0.1282220035791397,
-0.09113769978284836,
-0.06992977112531662,
-0.237906351685524,
0.012277457863092422,
0.1185278370976448,
-0.4062083661556244,
-0.19649848341941833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03170v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03170v2
|
StatBot.Swiss: Bilingual Open Data Exploration in Natural Language
| 2024-06-05T12:03:19 | 2024-06-06T08:29:23 |
Farhad Nooralahzadeh, Yi Zhang, Ellery Smith, Sabine Maennel, Cyril Matthey-Doret, Raphaël de Fondville, Kurt Stockinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The potential for improvements brought by Large Language Models (LLMs) in
Text-to-SQL systems is mostly assessed on monolingual English datasets.
However, LLMs' performance for other languages remains vastly unexplored. In
this work, we release the StatBot.Swiss dataset, the first bilingual benchmark
for evaluating Text-to-SQL systems based on real-world applications. The
StatBot.Swiss dataset contains 455 natural language/SQL-pairs over 35 big
databases with varying level of complexity for both English and German.
We evaluate the performance of state-of-the-art LLMs such as GPT-3.5-Turbo
and mixtral-8x7b-instruct for the Text-to-SQL translation task using an
in-context learning approach. Our experimental analysis illustrates that
current LLMs struggle to generalize well in generating SQL queries on our novel
bilingual dataset.
|
[
-0.28822004795074463,
-0.9798287153244019,
0.38108494877815247,
0.36221492290496826,
-0.32178282737731934,
0.1572355180978775,
-0.4225694537162781,
-0.453241229057312,
0.15208058059215546,
0.6541512608528137,
-0.7031359672546387,
-0.8262535333633423,
-0.4589827358722687,
0.5103529691696167,
-0.3391668498516083,
0.8234108686447144,
-0.1002422422170639,
0.5116432905197144,
-0.34694522619247437,
-0.22513245046138763,
-0.5858020782470703,
-0.8221524953842163,
-0.33153191208839417,
-0.1891217678785324,
0.32640963792800903,
0.3274180591106415,
0.474542498588562,
0.16017158329486847,
0.5086153745651245,
0.18914292752742767,
0.035879991948604584,
0.28650784492492676,
-0.7779355049133301,
0.051138006150722504,
-0.2976512014865875,
-0.654323160648346,
-0.4015628397464752,
-0.47468891739845276,
0.768160343170166,
0.7739943265914917,
-0.1300896555185318,
0.2071683406829834,
-0.168892502784729,
0.9034169912338257,
-0.1742708832025528,
0.575404167175293,
-0.6299669742584229,
0.035046063363552094,
-0.39708593487739563,
0.04005604237318039,
-0.45369014143943787,
-0.5531633496284485,
0.08785334974527359,
-0.35759109258651733,
0.24634677171707153,
0.24430906772613525,
0.5194107294082642,
0.021526969969272614,
-0.5914821624755859,
0.04490386322140694,
-0.6159776449203491,
0.8316822052001953,
-0.39165544509887695,
0.4692785441875458,
0.32803407311439514,
0.48922666907310486,
-0.4322640001773834,
-0.3100776672363281,
-0.26474303007125854,
0.0001247286854777485,
-0.2019604593515396,
-0.06808730959892273,
-0.157446026802063,
-0.44963154196739197,
0.12827832996845245,
0.07540086656808853,
-0.833829402923584,
0.3424563407897949,
-0.24314309656620026,
-0.2073822021484375,
0.8027045130729675,
0.3100045621395111,
0.30995118618011475,
-0.07888897508382797,
-0.2405177801847458,
-0.11762608587741852,
-0.8828601837158203,
-0.06438571214675903,
0.3605497479438782,
0.7936885356903076,
-0.319297194480896,
0.8027337789535522,
-0.2528793215751648,
0.8440393805503845,
-0.5776674747467041,
0.21259938180446625,
0.3227745294570923,
-0.5486329197883606,
-0.14734774827957153,
0.2127760946750641,
1.0519802570343018,
0.13182619214057922,
0.6228070259094238,
-0.37925705313682556,
-0.24852140247821808,
-0.2452150136232376,
0.008299200795590878,
-0.7079940438270569,
0.1448633074760437,
0.12011052668094635,
-0.1868608444929123,
0.05550041049718857,
0.09450750797986984,
-0.7768409252166748,
-0.08008261024951935,
-0.28172028064727783,
0.15720799565315247,
-0.5084328055381775,
-0.2572641372680664,
0.07750814408063889,
0.06213141977787018,
0.009483451023697853,
0.2241339385509491,
-0.6457875370979309,
0.5715022087097168,
0.7760626077651978,
0.7937828302383423,
-0.5583204627037048,
-0.21129800379276276,
-0.44250547885894775,
0.0691351369023323,
-0.5678209066390991,
0.8957310914993286,
-0.23673681914806366,
-0.5773904919624329,
0.16597704589366913,
0.1580602079629898,
-0.1239950880408287,
-0.6873363852500916,
0.5911470055580139,
-0.5585856437683105,
0.28368890285491943,
-0.2689187526702881,
-0.48560017347335815,
-0.06003160402178764,
0.010830353945493698,
-0.8337005376815796,
1.2215733528137207,
0.09752476960420609,
-0.5957223176956177,
0.5776659846305847,
-0.5899810791015625,
-0.8552759885787964,
0.1513172686100006,
-0.2363434135913849,
-0.16593904793262482,
0.21930284798145294,
0.33685821294784546,
0.35627418756484985,
-0.8853217959403992,
0.43522587418556213,
-0.15084317326545715,
-0.4630662500858307,
0.2021198719739914,
-0.2155560553073883,
0.9751988053321838,
-0.07713606208562851,
0.051752764731645584,
-0.14094287157058716,
-0.7066863179206848,
0.052147746086120605,
0.237835094332695,
-0.3119587302207947,
-0.35699397325515747,
0.2926730513572693,
0.1488620638847351,
-0.03527194634079933,
0.24356916546821594,
-0.7030544877052307,
-0.05628488212823868,
-0.43707332015037537,
0.05915508791804314,
0.6319043636322021,
-0.30213692784309387,
0.20159770548343658,
-0.15128472447395325,
0.45406651496887207,
-0.14946037530899048,
-0.28797632455825806,
-0.09409347921609879,
-0.4005225598812103,
-0.38200342655181885,
-0.6575331687927246,
0.44741010665893555,
0.9117600321769714,
-0.5693551898002625,
0.6440364718437195,
-0.6860013604164124,
-0.36825183033943176,
-0.3317950963973999,
0.3219999372959137,
0.2000511884689331,
0.42953822016716003,
0.4289069175720215,
-0.21708737313747406,
-0.23501043021678925,
-1.1871228218078613,
-0.5597777366638184,
-0.03472095727920532,
-0.14871881902217865,
0.47109025716781616,
0.48857101798057556,
0.0715038999915123,
1.0560883283615112,
-0.43016114830970764,
-0.4381064474582672,
-0.2816610634326935,
0.09195537120103836,
0.5230929851531982,
0.2206203192472458,
0.6265407800674438,
-0.5693666934967041,
-0.8041989207267761,
0.3235306143760681,
-1.0208125114440918,
0.07692592591047287,
0.5033392310142517,
-0.09706905484199524,
0.6341535449028015,
0.26669639348983765,
-0.5000623464584351,
0.18008705973625183,
0.426897794008255,
-0.12087103724479675,
0.332437127828598,
-0.3412353992462158,
0.15323187410831451,
-0.9049457907676697,
-0.005565638653934002,
0.16467539966106415,
-0.26364701986312866,
-0.5301195979118347,
-0.31963208317756653,
0.3828704357147217,
-0.17720402777194977,
-0.4718605875968933,
0.741651713848114,
-0.4112211763858795,
-0.12327179312705994,
0.27664726972579956,
-0.05800021067261696,
-0.3639458119869232,
0.25606706738471985,
0.11270662397146225,
0.8831490278244019,
0.8161069750785828,
-0.4769695997238159,
0.2804119884967804,
0.30183055996894836,
-0.7625274062156677,
0.8813635110855103,
-0.5394126176834106,
-0.04577808082103729,
-0.18101118505001068,
0.3732428252696991,
-0.9018221497535706,
-0.4036901593208313,
-0.1518861949443817,
-0.3065061569213867,
0.3366979956626892,
-0.09270241856575012,
-1.1789090633392334,
-0.3634627163410187,
0.004342913627624512,
0.32236167788505554,
0.5443388223648071,
-0.569749116897583,
0.2630833387374878,
0.4757641553878784,
-0.3944641947746277,
-0.473104864358902,
-0.8476629257202148,
0.24069111049175262,
-0.052055638283491135,
-0.6672102212905884,
0.09991956502199173,
0.21620848774909973,
-0.32365188002586365,
-0.1710660755634308,
-0.1419638842344284,
-0.36512094736099243,
-0.11962875723838806,
-0.30877915024757385,
0.3763107657432556,
-0.21255889534950256,
0.34713876247406006,
0.27411115169525146,
0.09351424872875214,
0.20553556084632874,
0.051560163497924805,
0.40813231468200684,
0.04401933774352074,
-0.3021436631679535,
-0.3342762291431427,
0.4659331440925598,
0.24074921011924744,
-0.1777155101299286,
0.722944974899292,
0.1875326931476593,
-0.3178257942199707,
-0.43192243576049805,
-0.3540140986442566,
-0.07643914222717285,
-0.37518689036369324,
0.6085137724876404,
-0.5221275687217712,
-0.9091830849647522,
0.49844643473625183,
0.07435573637485504,
0.012844191864132881,
0.3897474706172943,
0.43758049607276917,
-0.07938673347234726,
1.054225206375122,
0.5345880389213562,
-0.15931366384029388,
0.16580888628959656,
0.10726135224103928,
0.2220274806022644,
-0.12322990596294403,
-0.2740184962749481,
-0.7493800520896912,
0.04693327471613884,
-0.6499379277229309,
-0.6752578616142273,
0.36242103576660156,
-0.07095262408256531,
-0.20029371976852417,
0.5126241445541382,
-0.14169052243232727,
0.43675968050956726,
0.20383122563362122,
0.07455753535032272,
0.5154340267181396,
0.46828365325927734,
-0.17148946225643158,
-0.2892749607563019,
-0.7853167057037354,
-0.35582253336906433,
1.246611475944519,
-0.04270990937948227,
0.8217509984970093,
0.2029344141483307,
0.6293693780899048,
0.2841462790966034,
0.3124937117099762,
-0.544370174407959,
0.680496335029602,
-0.45614248514175415,
-0.8657993674278259,
-0.32844725251197815,
-0.7702960968017578,
-0.827446460723877,
0.31021425127983093,
-0.009552618488669395,
-0.6947254538536072,
-0.11272799223661423,
-0.12855033576488495,
0.4174737334251404,
0.194668248295784,
-0.7045354247093201,
0.8212576508522034,
-0.676893413066864,
-0.4909493029117584,
-0.2937206029891968,
-0.3657199740409851,
0.37082362174987793,
-0.5789631009101868,
0.48196056485176086,
-0.389453262090683,
-0.16734404861927032,
0.5478854775428772,
-0.2630831301212311,
0.8167691230773926,
-0.1312304586172104,
-0.2741171419620514,
0.09964242577552795,
0.15242654085159302,
0.5766728520393372,
0.05749034881591797,
-0.4940991997718811,
0.6484202146530151,
-0.05096453055739403,
-0.4128206968307495,
-0.3264894187450409,
0.7732511162757874,
-0.34835514426231384,
-0.32534563541412354,
-0.4377322793006897,
-0.658966064453125,
-0.4187987446784973,
0.32464978098869324,
-0.03457777947187424,
0.2728824019432068,
-0.850856363773346,
0.2595016360282898,
0.598673403263092,
-0.4272945821285248,
0.10954640060663223,
0.846461296081543,
-0.2148672640323639,
-0.21691730618476868,
0.8593938946723938,
0.14542964100837708,
0.0649486854672432,
0.6198956370353699,
-0.10740247368812561,
-0.5393399596214294,
-0.2637103497982025,
-0.6974205374717712,
0.4106036424636841,
-0.43581435084342957,
-0.17564894258975983,
-0.48574233055114746,
0.2245968133211136,
-0.36864057183265686,
0.060234393924474716,
-0.3742852509021759,
-0.4239739775657654,
-0.055849313735961914,
-0.02391935884952545,
0.5586960315704346,
0.6786191463470459,
0.1811782419681549,
-0.005437007173895836,
-0.6267694234848022,
0.2883654534816742,
-0.06162393093109131,
0.6904448866844177,
-0.42406779527664185,
-0.16712942719459534,
-0.229455828666687,
0.018531478941440582,
0.20184408128261566,
-0.7754945158958435,
0.39555060863494873,
0.08838724344968796,
0.8907685875892639,
-0.0851660668849945,
-0.016781462356448174,
0.40236857533454895,
-0.6579685807228088,
0.5738535523414612,
0.1614753156900406,
-0.6770809292793274,
0.4315616488456726,
-0.5132976174354553,
0.22880889475345612,
0.5645084977149963,
0.662428081035614,
-0.18802906572818756,
-0.19711051881313324,
-0.17408759891986847,
-0.7067704200744629,
1.0503020286560059,
0.09990643709897995,
0.1067323237657547,
-0.0026710766833275557,
-0.06522499769926071,
0.33195576071739197,
0.3731831908226013,
-0.5556430220603943,
-0.23726065456867218,
0.21094663441181183,
-0.2516639232635498,
-0.534421980381012,
0.07176338136196136,
-0.294124037027359,
-0.37210190296173096,
0.35245171189308167,
-0.29989808797836304,
0.21806567907333374,
-0.09986218065023422,
-0.2553638517856598,
-0.04101458936929703,
0.2788752615451813,
0.2469848245382309,
0.8467965722084045,
-0.36383533477783203,
-0.32875677943229675,
0.40434420108795166,
-0.06464237719774246,
-0.0004085575637873262,
0.3257499635219574,
-0.13739676773548126,
0.20650169253349304,
0.21465612947940826,
0.7170751690864563,
0.289743036031723,
-1.0135918855667114,
0.35126984119415283,
-0.09190300107002258,
-0.3626292049884796,
-0.09685816615819931,
0.01011683326214552,
0.18547582626342773,
-0.22416532039642334,
0.35126960277557373,
-0.35210514068603516,
-0.17519620060920715,
-0.6434732675552368,
0.01605796441435814,
0.641544759273529,
-0.5710752010345459,
-0.2614406943321228,
0.45765674114227295,
0.097345270216465,
-0.4648075997829437,
0.47912412881851196,
0.08092484623193741,
-0.3599317967891693,
0.6024813652038574,
0.6204584240913391,
0.7481715679168701,
-0.0024234929587692022,
0.2668166160583496,
0.6107270121574402,
0.4681811034679413,
-0.26905280351638794,
0.5004458427429199,
-0.10529877245426178,
-0.5406272411346436,
-0.38610854744911194,
-0.5217316150665283,
-0.42051103711128235,
-0.37230879068374634,
-0.6111421585083008,
0.5101567506790161,
0.07081468403339386,
0.011614786460995674,
-0.298698753118515,
-0.16960585117340088,
-0.8661055564880371,
-0.06923598051071167,
-0.39776426553726196,
1.0890904664993286,
-0.9184937477111816,
0.9149705171585083,
0.7884254455566406,
-0.06076605245471001,
-0.09178397804498672,
-0.3048058748245239,
-0.16145117580890656,
-0.7360846400260925,
0.7249163389205933,
-0.0008681925246492028,
0.024187376722693443,
-0.1374094933271408,
-0.41048356890678406,
-0.6006523966789246,
0.7644202709197998,
0.6150726079940796,
-0.4252174496650696,
0.22379854321479797,
0.6729394197463989,
0.7357476353645325,
-0.26664766669273376,
0.07772240787744522,
0.6657313704490662,
0.6046592593193054,
-0.4559902250766754,
-0.9533862471580505,
-0.09950316697359085,
-0.01835598051548004,
-0.20037990808486938,
0.44932425022125244,
-0.6662166118621826,
0.6543450355529785,
-0.020537346601486206,
-0.24272681772708893,
-0.05732866749167442,
0.5325323939323425,
0.1489492505788803,
0.1658851057291031,
0.27994245290756226,
0.40915828943252563,
0.6674654483795166,
-0.28741443157196045,
1.2243049144744873,
-0.20250797271728516,
0.18368613719940186,
1.11693274974823,
-0.7006857395172119,
0.9381451606750488,
0.41039830446243286,
-0.4585394859313965,
0.3423924446105957,
0.3756057620048523,
0.01896454021334648,
0.4116288721561432,
0.3220802843570709,
-0.1739715337753296,
-0.1916772425174713,
-0.007625871803611517,
-0.3599347770214081,
0.2771611213684082,
0.3677668273448944,
-0.027182562276721,
-0.5045010447502136,
-0.20489487051963806,
-0.1248483881354332,
0.3254947066307068,
0.15248914062976837,
0.7602734565734863,
-0.06282790005207062,
-0.7810550332069397,
0.593450665473938,
-0.09545411914587021,
0.5205445885658264,
-0.8980947136878967,
0.03190518915653229,
-0.44297340512275696,
0.022720927372574806,
0.1183307096362114,
-0.8723524808883667,
0.08229218423366547,
0.2934144139289856,
-0.11727052181959152,
-0.2951887845993042,
0.4966528117656708,
-0.3258313536643982,
-0.8077090382575989,
0.6041816473007202,
0.7228250503540039,
0.27467262744903564,
0.03699246793985367,
-0.5336907505989075,
-0.06132499873638153,
-0.11358467489480972,
-0.0952400416135788,
0.5248318314552307,
0.5625852346420288,
-0.2656853199005127,
0.5858762860298157,
0.5601367354393005,
0.2039080411195755,
0.06665703654289246,
0.053415875881910324,
0.5821163058280945,
-0.6503520607948303,
-0.5058627128601074,
-0.6434255242347717,
0.24574796855449677,
-0.1971682608127594,
-0.14892037212848663,
0.9097747206687927,
1.1111445426940918,
0.9001942873001099,
-0.1520901918411255,
0.8695284724235535,
-0.08132254332304001,
0.9398208856582642,
-0.34074631333351135,
0.6538170576095581,
-0.752103865146637,
0.11752539873123169,
-0.15434812009334564,
-0.9706552624702454,
-0.2573915123939514,
0.19456636905670166,
-0.20018088817596436,
-0.19107182323932648,
0.7531428933143616,
0.9015209674835205,
-0.14948350191116333,
0.06938839703798294,
0.2502967417240143,
0.23162390291690826,
0.20478475093841553,
0.3273323178291321,
0.5000648498535156,
-0.2896621823310852,
0.5028751492500305,
-0.1275482475757599,
-0.24250270426273346,
-0.04915403574705124,
-0.8747336864471436,
-0.9723600149154663,
-0.2840364873409271,
0.06370257586240768,
0.00039154436672106385,
0.25437840819358826,
0.6296894550323486,
0.43644052743911743,
-0.8903005719184875,
-0.9282688498497009,
-0.15304721891880035,
0.21681562066078186,
-0.1889059692621231,
-0.19635584950447083,
0.34549060463905334,
-0.4244959354400635,
-0.8626165390014648,
0.7339938282966614,
0.11659896373748779,
-0.15739597380161285,
-0.25830745697021484,
-0.01146079134196043,
-0.26782986521720886,
-0.015969550237059593,
0.6768481731414795,
0.37253332138061523,
-0.3494161069393158,
0.17403776943683624,
0.07947985082864761,
-0.2233116328716278,
0.12185544520616531,
0.758534848690033,
-0.6516454219818115,
0.564122200012207,
0.7323293089866638,
0.6403771638870239,
0.7478365302085876,
-0.08366740494966507,
0.9560154676437378,
-0.6272469758987427,
0.2200082540512085,
0.14192137122154236,
0.21941882371902466,
0.3113112449645996,
-0.0788823589682579,
0.7605533599853516,
0.12209784239530563,
-0.3263040781021118,
-1.1069591045379639,
-0.028931695967912674,
-0.8244261741638184,
-0.2826913893222809,
0.9386321306228638,
0.1736837774515152,
-0.23934796452522278,
-0.11195091903209686,
0.0023034431505948305,
0.004388939589262009,
-0.4631796181201935,
0.2570071518421173,
0.7576650381088257,
-0.09974595159292221,
0.36728808283805847,
-0.9954424500465393,
0.3007785975933075,
0.5019405484199524,
-0.9656322002410889,
0.2504899501800537,
0.5752178430557251,
0.21137119829654694,
-0.34491923451423645,
0.6206457614898682,
-0.3275843560695648,
0.16624964773654938,
-0.179486945271492,
0.034880585968494415,
0.19527137279510498,
-0.29613596200942993,
-0.2801040709018707,
0.0014742502244189382,
-0.2899101972579956,
0.26518887281417847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03158v1
|
CSS: Contrastive Semantic Similarity for Uncertainty Quantification of LLMs
| 2024-06-05T11:35:44 | 2024-06-05T11:35:44 |
Shuang Ao, Stefan Rueger, Advaith Siddharthan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the impressive capability of large language models (LLMs), knowing
when to trust their generations remains an open challenge. The recent
literature on uncertainty quantification of natural language generation (NLG)
utilises a conventional natural language inference (NLI) classifier to measure
the semantic dispersion of LLMs responses. These studies employ logits of NLI
classifier for semantic clustering to estimate uncertainty. However, logits
represent the probability of the predicted class and barely contain feature
information for potential clustering. Alternatively, CLIP (Contrastive
Language-Image Pre-training) performs impressively in extracting image-text
pair features and measuring their similarity. To extend its usability, we
propose Contrastive Semantic Similarity, the CLIP-based feature extraction
module to obtain similarity features for measuring uncertainty for text pairs.
We apply this method to selective NLG, which detects and rejects unreliable
generations for better trustworthiness of LLMs. We conduct extensive
experiments with three LLMs on several benchmark question-answering datasets
with comprehensive evaluation metrics. Results show that our proposed method
performs better in estimating reliable responses of LLMs than comparable
baselines. Results show that our proposed method performs better in estimating
reliable responses of LLMs than comparable baselines. The code are available at
\url{https://github.com/AoShuang92/css_uq_llms}.
|
[
-0.39888283610343933,
-0.8199108242988586,
0.6592103242874146,
0.2691357731819153,
-0.5392764210700989,
0.2961271107196808,
-0.14430932700634003,
-0.5132774710655212,
0.1446956843137741,
0.2883310317993164,
-0.7030069828033447,
-0.5948227047920227,
-0.5776090025901794,
0.12444547563791275,
-0.6636472344398499,
0.5415270328521729,
0.04191228374838829,
-0.014789343811571598,
-0.4662933349609375,
-0.06790062040090561,
-0.06142532825469971,
-0.1745617389678955,
-0.686507523059845,
-0.24965886771678925,
0.20355431735515594,
0.09472934156656265,
0.9946436285972595,
0.5318278670310974,
0.4796903133392334,
0.35788577795028687,
-0.3142702281475067,
-0.03281034901738167,
-0.3713700473308563,
0.16627800464630127,
-0.229783833026886,
-0.30990827083587646,
-0.04976385459303856,
-0.137128546833992,
0.4632441997528076,
0.5467104315757751,
0.007502259686589241,
0.1035701185464859,
0.4015319347381592,
0.5330515503883362,
-0.602156937122345,
-0.23763924837112427,
-1.1345716714859009,
0.1416226029396057,
-0.011160074733197689,
-0.1760328710079193,
-0.14241385459899902,
-0.439144492149353,
0.31762605905532837,
-0.7108769416809082,
0.4161747395992279,
0.24006161093711853,
1.1138441562652588,
0.33398860692977905,
-0.2497304528951645,
-0.3464790880680084,
-0.40151575207710266,
1.1218546628952026,
-0.852878212928772,
0.39911916851997375,
0.3064364492893219,
-0.08968693763017654,
-0.32526567578315735,
-0.735171377658844,
-0.8322296738624573,
-0.09611139446496964,
-0.04868348315358162,
0.1338420957326889,
-0.2686424255371094,
-0.1181330755352974,
-0.12055078148841858,
0.45451316237449646,
-0.6528819799423218,
0.2324390560388565,
0.03270220756530762,
-0.5518922805786133,
0.29613301157951355,
0.06024016812443733,
0.19908462464809418,
-0.4223601222038269,
-0.7164339423179626,
-0.2894413471221924,
-0.5887047648429871,
-0.060547005385160446,
0.4472932815551758,
-0.006743778474628925,
-0.23745249211788177,
0.2772339880466461,
-0.14950904250144958,
0.4212760627269745,
0.05172782018780708,
-0.32837310433387756,
0.23398175835609436,
-0.3889157772064209,
-0.1334628015756607,
-0.21520014107227325,
1.0336270332336426,
0.6687014698982239,
0.15567806363105774,
-0.18296802043914795,
0.07085222750902176,
0.30686280131340027,
0.16321371495723724,
-0.5894307494163513,
-0.07994327694177628,
0.09553903341293335,
-0.3953680098056793,
-0.5407477617263794,
0.15146669745445251,
-0.9418873190879822,
-0.21149592101573944,
-0.13502566516399384,
0.2886740565299988,
-0.5914932489395142,
-0.02382820099592209,
-0.08921436220407486,
-0.15856105089187622,
0.5791972875595093,
0.19000470638275146,
-0.6479611396789551,
0.33608946204185486,
0.6917815804481506,
0.6393144726753235,
-0.6827733516693115,
-0.21000555157661438,
-0.19651560485363007,
0.11139781773090363,
-0.35356590151786804,
0.7608040571212769,
-0.5675618648529053,
-0.48046332597732544,
0.09513243287801743,
-0.09949491173028946,
0.16875040531158447,
-0.6370883584022522,
0.7218076586723328,
-0.5795220732688904,
0.1526232212781906,
-0.07519866526126862,
-0.7125275731086731,
0.19947558641433716,
0.3696238696575165,
-0.6215001344680786,
1.3610551357269287,
0.01602838560938835,
-1.1800512075424194,
0.3891045153141022,
0.11545658111572266,
-0.05541447177529335,
-0.004993157926946878,
-0.36750444769859314,
-0.7340052723884583,
-0.12863391637802124,
0.28777971863746643,
0.46907666325569153,
-0.3372534513473511,
0.09196390956640244,
-0.8234395384788513,
-0.27079862356185913,
0.6114546656608582,
-0.4310283064842224,
0.41393789649009705,
0.32057899236679077,
-0.12077646702528,
0.027598170563578606,
-0.7996814250946045,
0.36311325430870056,
0.028599048033356667,
-0.1224912479519844,
-0.4414919316768646,
0.006242162548005581,
-0.04481092095375061,
0.0900452733039856,
0.3726503551006317,
-0.5579020380973816,
-0.5440310835838318,
-0.19476474821567535,
0.3998197317123413,
0.6742579340934753,
0.17832061648368835,
0.4222601652145386,
-0.28189966082572937,
0.5007017254829407,
-0.020894628018140793,
0.023218700662255287,
0.2213185429573059,
-0.31450793147087097,
-0.7462254762649536,
-0.11500222235918045,
0.4258630871772766,
0.5603497624397278,
-0.7429516315460205,
0.7736489772796631,
-0.318799763917923,
-0.3264991343021393,
-0.3792797327041626,
0.2905832827091217,
0.6192577481269836,
0.532986581325531,
0.2925637364387512,
-0.4078286290168762,
-0.5695059895515442,
-0.7996324300765991,
-0.16096293926239014,
-0.21285215020179749,
-0.48313722014427185,
0.08533958345651627,
0.23693066835403442,
-0.04683295637369156,
0.9327738285064697,
-0.5038551688194275,
0.06210387498140335,
0.011108540929853916,
0.3444289267063141,
-0.1852921098470688,
0.3472291827201843,
0.45888185501098633,
-0.9044721722602844,
-0.3525775969028473,
-0.22932876646518707,
-0.615837574005127,
-0.11084984242916107,
-0.053007822483778,
-0.3122144639492035,
0.05056076869368553,
0.8539150357246399,
-0.4017464220523834,
0.3048604726791382,
0.7413014769554138,
-0.15408238768577576,
0.44441741704940796,
0.029402732849121094,
0.14725393056869507,
-1.3752925395965576,
-0.03349025174975395,
0.11143001168966293,
-0.25675496459007263,
-0.18492497503757477,
0.09130313992500305,
-0.08963685482740402,
0.2793425917625427,
-0.5766437649726868,
0.30079570412635803,
-0.3499803841114044,
-0.2964843809604645,
-0.12920784950256348,
0.6079313158988953,
0.14935801923274994,
0.11169694364070892,
0.07789812982082367,
0.8614620566368103,
0.510997474193573,
-0.5442848801612854,
0.20495660603046417,
0.332130491733551,
-0.3978680968284607,
0.8993068337440491,
-0.6400708556175232,
0.16677650809288025,
0.17518366873264313,
0.012297187931835651,
-0.9391108155250549,
-0.025289170444011688,
0.022578807547688484,
-0.5690283179283142,
0.2116948813199997,
0.08933115005493164,
-0.3717242479324341,
-0.2808403968811035,
-0.7207332253456116,
0.15734511613845825,
0.6108070611953735,
-0.4123421013355255,
0.26992642879486084,
0.24705976247787476,
-0.3621339797973633,
-0.6654226779937744,
-0.8192019462585449,
0.021026935428380966,
-0.46388912200927734,
-0.5360060930252075,
0.6078475117683411,
-0.06646636873483658,
-0.27345097064971924,
0.33903947472572327,
-0.37999284267425537,
-0.39037415385246277,
0.19271470606327057,
0.18074144423007965,
0.38010844588279724,
-0.23257562518119812,
0.136621356010437,
0.1759348064661026,
-0.036581482738256454,
0.08210880309343338,
-0.08558458834886551,
0.40531107783317566,
-0.23240098357200623,
-0.3960152566432953,
0.01640881597995758,
0.17043696343898773,
0.06988988071680069,
-0.08932001143693924,
0.4385557770729065,
0.8901486396789551,
-0.19916509091854095,
-0.24548731744289398,
-0.682637631893158,
-0.06876356154680252,
-0.52188640832901,
0.26773950457572937,
-0.285078763961792,
-1.2232074737548828,
0.5452296733856201,
-0.17748263478279114,
-0.39228683710098267,
0.4418179988861084,
0.19751477241516113,
-0.3208580017089844,
0.4968849718570709,
0.6598511934280396,
-0.12651273608207703,
0.37746042013168335,
0.10883864760398865,
-0.09684865176677704,
-0.6977959871292114,
-0.07522355765104294,
-0.6122214198112488,
-0.10886305570602417,
-0.7087127566337585,
-0.5433803796768188,
0.19557790458202362,
0.47413644194602966,
0.0981440320611,
0.20580525696277618,
-0.4697660803794861,
0.5819666385650635,
0.5147942900657654,
0.10760340094566345,
0.3460630178451538,
0.11994030326604843,
-0.21616224944591522,
-0.2983727753162384,
-0.4498748779296875,
-0.6949639320373535,
0.8248664736747742,
0.19372588396072388,
1.0154926776885986,
0.04412902146577835,
0.8313952088356018,
0.21498510241508484,
-0.1337529420852661,
-0.517831027507782,
0.6596283912658691,
-0.19995293021202087,
-0.05473996698856354,
-0.4504729211330414,
-0.43752554059028625,
-1.0534071922302246,
0.12401457130908966,
-0.6278735995292664,
-0.8025709390640259,
0.017077121883630753,
0.17830462753772736,
-0.31211963295936584,
0.3132691979408264,
-0.38340702652931213,
0.5642198324203491,
0.07074293494224548,
-0.33113497495651245,
-0.16968493163585663,
-0.908353328704834,
0.2072272151708603,
-0.12569274008274078,
0.05606689676642418,
-0.1738358587026596,
-0.13712535798549652,
0.7704851627349854,
-0.35636675357818604,
0.8486033082008362,
0.4918624758720398,
-0.012223449535667896,
0.6256648302078247,
0.1275147795677185,
0.24532152712345123,
-0.02634221687912941,
-0.08674034476280212,
0.08427080512046814,
0.1599910855293274,
-0.3430825471878052,
-0.6524651050567627,
0.9992852807044983,
-0.5353688597679138,
-0.35861244797706604,
-0.2754039168357849,
-0.34263402223587036,
-0.2876511216163635,
0.14421455562114716,
0.5348247289657593,
0.11383238434791565,
-0.37434056401252747,
0.1936197429895401,
0.7885257005691528,
-0.16441476345062256,
0.6948220729827881,
0.2196102887392044,
0.05699707195162773,
-0.467964231967926,
0.8001373410224915,
-0.4094367027282715,
0.4012890160083771,
0.553604245185852,
0.2749389708042145,
-0.4277934730052948,
-0.7118633985519409,
-0.22181908786296844,
0.08117852360010147,
-0.6567726731300354,
-0.37461304664611816,
-0.29306837916374207,
-0.2514466941356659,
-0.29222145676612854,
-0.3863937258720398,
-0.1913241297006607,
-0.3862416744232178,
-0.46352195739746094,
-0.25493982434272766,
0.42513346672058105,
0.7154011726379395,
0.07831796258687973,
0.22780902683734894,
-0.8367753028869629,
0.29869261384010315,
0.4652296006679535,
0.395368367433548,
-0.2397793084383011,
-0.48689448833465576,
0.16448216140270233,
-0.21173761785030365,
-0.547588586807251,
-0.9048759341239929,
0.19530798494815826,
0.26712432503700256,
0.6067812442779541,
0.4561225473880768,
0.23581455647945404,
0.6144459843635559,
-0.33092764019966125,
0.9919911623001099,
0.32074785232543945,
-1.1730245351791382,
0.3238840103149414,
-0.14601300656795502,
0.09367908537387848,
0.8771352171897888,
0.43636423349380493,
-0.2166273295879364,
-0.7154978513717651,
-0.7709681391716003,
-0.8671280741691589,
0.18450967967510223,
0.26047709584236145,
0.05989978834986687,
-0.1746559590101242,
0.32286083698272705,
0.024182217195630074,
0.15071949362754822,
-0.8017983436584473,
-0.16081802546977997,
-0.11597049981355667,
-0.40582579374313354,
0.0925799161195755,
-0.4352332055568695,
0.09948185086250305,
0.19395621120929718,
0.4762965738773346,
-0.24856041371822357,
0.15177667140960693,
0.2377706915140152,
-0.0425957553088665,
-0.08278556913137436,
0.7260019183158875,
0.3962339460849762,
0.4587249159812927,
-0.23928336799144745,
0.5377457141876221,
0.5550682544708252,
-0.4233602285385132,
0.01234516128897667,
-0.03402631729841232,
-0.19763776659965515,
0.12436826527118683,
0.47555211186408997,
0.4973796308040619,
0.41440287232398987,
-0.6381598114967346,
0.7477060556411743,
0.08508092164993286,
-0.26806533336639404,
-0.40787699818611145,
-0.16000059247016907,
0.2939487397670746,
0.08008375763893127,
0.11296491324901581,
-0.11122024059295654,
0.23135869204998016,
-0.3224518299102783,
0.5077829957008362,
0.6607868671417236,
-0.5867823362350464,
-0.13847877085208893,
0.42654892802238464,
0.25044241547584534,
-0.15409034490585327,
0.19106422364711761,
-0.4660203158855438,
-0.42085710167884827,
0.4970759451389313,
0.5445252656936646,
0.7199961543083191,
-0.1094001978635788,
0.2870195508003235,
0.28522229194641113,
0.13064053654670715,
-0.09621621668338776,
0.21599669754505157,
0.06229892000555992,
-0.8984463810920715,
-0.4410695731639862,
-0.6389521360397339,
-0.6092880964279175,
0.17499084770679474,
-0.9215725660324097,
0.15553157031536102,
-0.37961193919181824,
-0.10299970209598541,
-0.38706645369529724,
-0.2264675348997116,
-0.6133323311805725,
0.30875083804130554,
0.20633426308631897,
0.714286208152771,
-0.8310098648071289,
0.7283148765563965,
0.4463525712490082,
-0.0906359925866127,
-0.7870779633522034,
0.3308960497379303,
-0.03592561557888985,
-0.6930609345436096,
0.33501341938972473,
-0.012705748900771141,
-0.43896469473838806,
-0.2911258637905121,
-0.6558975577354431,
-0.7629997730255127,
1.328498125076294,
0.33382710814476013,
-0.4552178382873535,
0.058408286422491074,
0.29136350750923157,
0.6142315864562988,
-0.224373921751976,
0.14207780361175537,
0.5234390497207642,
0.05778660997748375,
0.3272503614425659,
-0.736343502998352,
0.2289285957813263,
0.03753563389182091,
0.2253912091255188,
0.20739419758319855,
-0.4887648820877075,
0.6354503631591797,
-0.1934196949005127,
-0.30646437406539917,
0.363100528717041,
0.8213793039321899,
0.34823915362358093,
0.33734843134880066,
0.7074825763702393,
0.7124142050743103,
0.6657750606536865,
-0.02956768125295639,
0.8175719380378723,
-0.37983468174934387,
0.3849295675754547,
1.271870732307434,
-0.18077148497104645,
1.2318040132522583,
0.7064529657363892,
-0.44414380192756653,
0.6666073799133301,
0.44890761375427246,
-0.08823782205581665,
0.41256505250930786,
0.3172999620437622,
-0.33986327052116394,
-0.4110868573188782,
-0.16154469549655914,
-0.2586579918861389,
0.23951034247875214,
0.3088436722755432,
-0.3702874481678009,
-0.1732082962989807,
-0.4682399332523346,
0.11816055327653885,
0.5784998536109924,
-0.05501091480255127,
0.7998420000076294,
0.336269736289978,
-0.38002797961235046,
0.39031240344047546,
-0.18364283442497253,
1.0748082399368286,
-0.6987011432647705,
-0.04614030197262764,
-0.06312486529350281,
-0.15483084321022034,
-0.0810122862458229,
-1.021522879600525,
0.3351464569568634,
-0.06755197048187256,
0.008427891880273819,
0.05306696519255638,
0.7976717352867126,
-0.4388107657432556,
-0.5474532246589661,
0.3697781264781952,
0.4302990436553955,
-0.015768133103847504,
0.20466169714927673,
-0.7337950468063354,
0.1747836470603943,
0.061444081366062164,
0.05238886550068855,
0.4104028642177582,
0.4318753480911255,
-0.00793270580470562,
0.7929170727729797,
0.34110310673713684,
0.07186754792928696,
0.22329764068126678,
-0.12160533666610718,
0.6288715600967407,
-0.49288490414619446,
-0.3761771619319916,
-0.7789400815963745,
0.16071651875972748,
-0.38729792833328247,
-0.4628399610519409,
0.7841989994049072,
0.39785683155059814,
0.9947549104690552,
-0.005645398516207933,
0.7080563306808472,
0.1038261204957962,
0.6955198645591736,
-0.8117972612380981,
0.359188437461853,
-0.16945521533489227,
0.3438199758529663,
-0.6410320401191711,
-0.9138551950454712,
-0.2626499831676483,
0.5682872533798218,
-0.09546569734811783,
-0.17404574155807495,
0.9417879581451416,
0.9553724527359009,
0.05949094891548157,
-0.07421599328517914,
0.34517985582351685,
-0.06523079425096512,
-0.008425888605415821,
0.47435644268989563,
0.9009321331977844,
-0.2928798198699951,
1.0213857889175415,
-0.44209328293800354,
0.02905927039682865,
0.19385698437690735,
-1.2224690914154053,
-0.7786224484443665,
-0.4777030050754547,
-0.5211031436920166,
-0.33320313692092896,
0.03024960123002529,
0.853547990322113,
0.5575576424598694,
-0.8704102039337158,
0.037921302020549774,
-0.2396191656589508,
0.19168710708618164,
-0.023851027712225914,
-0.2695387005805969,
0.4887852370738983,
-0.25476962327957153,
-0.5043573975563049,
0.19070084393024445,
-0.06142332777380943,
0.3708605468273163,
-0.14382924139499664,
-0.04582824185490608,
0.13766101002693176,
0.19062167406082153,
0.3225259482860565,
0.16909560561180115,
-1.014675498008728,
-0.6062943339347839,
-0.11779677867889404,
-0.15485097467899323,
0.014843348413705826,
0.6374831199645996,
-0.6574097871780396,
0.10507427901029587,
0.40482497215270996,
0.7350707054138184,
0.42474499344825745,
0.19843702018260956,
0.305816650390625,
-0.9817609786987305,
0.143783837556839,
-0.0008053517085500062,
0.3603673279285431,
0.6489851474761963,
-0.17769025266170502,
0.3845442533493042,
0.11237878352403641,
-0.4631054401397705,
-0.4709599018096924,
0.5069624185562134,
-1.3235665559768677,
-0.1832454651594162,
1.2292804718017578,
-0.41257333755493164,
-0.12524381279945374,
-0.1583278924226761,
-0.04401303827762604,
0.020667510107159615,
-0.44647833704948425,
0.6522555351257324,
0.5304241180419922,
0.0614333301782608,
-0.22863367199897766,
-0.06277536600828171,
0.5893659591674805,
0.5881532430648804,
-0.7810213565826416,
-0.2942853271961212,
0.2816821336746216,
0.4479464888572693,
0.27841973304748535,
0.33393776416778564,
-0.2112434208393097,
0.011776825413107872,
0.22186462581157684,
0.17536160349845886,
0.3524942100048065,
0.24905909597873688,
-0.27308389544487,
0.24566692113876343,
0.38722580671310425,
-0.307472288608551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03151v2
|
Which Side Are You On? A Multi-task Dataset for End-to-End Argument Summarisation and Evaluation
| 2024-06-05T11:15:45 | 2024-06-06T09:30:11 |
Hao Li, Yuping Wu, Viktor Schlegel, Riza Batista-Navarro, Tharindu Madusanka, Iqra Zahid, Jiayan Zeng, Xiaochi Wang, Xinran He, Yizhi Li, Goran Nenadic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
With the recent advances of large language models (LLMs), it is no longer
infeasible to build an automated debate system that helps people to synthesise
persuasive arguments. Previous work attempted this task by integrating multiple
components. In our work, we introduce an argument mining dataset that captures
the end-to-end process of preparing an argumentative essay for a debate, which
covers the tasks of claim and evidence identification (Task 1 ED), evidence
convincingness ranking (Task 2 ECR), argumentative essay summarisation and
human preference ranking (Task 3 ASR) and metric learning for automated
evaluation of resulting essays, based on human feedback along argument quality
dimensions (Task 4 SQE). Our dataset contains 14k examples of claims that are
fully annotated with the various properties supporting the aforementioned
tasks. We evaluate multiple generative baselines for each of these tasks,
including representative LLMs. We find, that while they show promising results
on individual tasks in our benchmark, their end-to-end performance on all four
tasks in succession deteriorates significantly, both in automated measures as
well as in human-centred evaluation. This challenge presented by our proposed
dataset motivates future research on end-to-end argument mining and
summarisation. The repository of this project is available at
https://github.com/HarrywillDr/ArgSum-Datatset
|
[
-0.4812450408935547,
-0.42134222388267517,
0.467931866645813,
0.007290324661880732,
-0.27060872316360474,
0.053197842091321945,
-0.18996118009090424,
0.06966866552829742,
0.1754167079925537,
0.6843377351760864,
-0.4869222640991211,
-0.602972149848938,
-0.6171213388442993,
0.26857128739356995,
-0.3618345260620117,
1.2769650220870972,
-0.15042202174663544,
0.05244961380958557,
-0.8515326380729675,
-0.40960100293159485,
-0.2054620385169983,
-0.7520514726638794,
-0.7999335527420044,
-0.473468542098999,
0.5404692888259888,
0.7452117800712585,
0.11492940038442612,
0.35771235823631287,
0.06272806972265244,
0.34758222103118896,
0.1752675175666809,
0.0085592120885849,
-0.2943927049636841,
0.40434029698371887,
-0.32408466935157776,
-0.3325670063495636,
-0.2507953643798828,
0.07269014418125153,
0.312660276889801,
0.3806627094745636,
-0.12144274264574051,
0.3644857108592987,
-0.13040600717067719,
0.5539645552635193,
-0.47403767704963684,
0.004415284842252731,
-0.6438871026039124,
0.0949157178401947,
-0.41995951533317566,
-0.26010045409202576,
-0.3979942798614502,
-0.022672822698950768,
0.14019657671451569,
-0.2712251543998718,
0.1412516087293625,
-0.020034847781062126,
0.8285841941833496,
0.2439955472946167,
-0.4845291078090668,
-0.44247379899024963,
-0.13050371408462524,
0.7518868446350098,
-0.9204158782958984,
-0.08718270808458328,
0.007506245747208595,
0.16127003729343414,
-0.22081801295280457,
-0.8144947290420532,
-0.4845131039619446,
0.09067325294017792,
-0.026321066543459892,
0.6241116523742676,
-0.3427944481372833,
0.07575027644634247,
0.1138748973608017,
0.14377519488334656,
-0.40583547949790955,
0.23691247403621674,
-0.2753184735774994,
-0.1374037265777588,
0.6711671352386475,
0.24151816964149475,
0.08559225499629974,
-0.3534340262413025,
-0.2588289976119995,
-0.06445903331041336,
-0.4846465587615967,
0.08148950338363647,
0.8562138676643372,
0.18438377976417542,
-0.0761486366391182,
0.783623993396759,
-0.21270792186260223,
0.5881994366645813,
0.20670607686042786,
0.016611693426966667,
-0.09150680899620056,
-0.32852575182914734,
-0.1613714098930359,
0.05687086284160614,
0.9298917651176453,
0.5672974586486816,
0.02896418236196041,
-0.04657960683107376,
-0.07219112664461136,
0.29096904397010803,
0.1765976846218109,
-0.7920685410499573,
-0.19020769000053406,
0.35133621096611023,
-0.6103991866111755,
-0.18281157314777374,
-0.2224772870540619,
-0.8748557567596436,
-0.5648917555809021,
-0.4284731149673462,
0.21511341631412506,
-0.06992235779762268,
-0.06652173399925232,
0.1131664365530014,
-0.3128998279571533,
0.18474552035331726,
0.08343713730573654,
-0.6355212926864624,
0.5127158164978027,
0.8202585577964783,
0.7013197541236877,
-0.12147029489278793,
-0.252704381942749,
-0.4465497136116028,
0.02939898706972599,
-0.478262722492218,
1.4911390542984009,
-0.7394700050354004,
-0.281537264585495,
-0.014485841616988182,
0.16761364042758942,
-0.13614320755004883,
-0.7645940184593201,
1.1408421993255615,
-0.18109473586082458,
0.7249124646186829,
-0.4746898412704468,
-0.802487850189209,
-0.1743314564228058,
0.23385588824748993,
-0.8012925386428833,
0.7593023180961609,
-0.19960041344165802,
-0.810756504535675,
0.4870205223560333,
-0.841687798500061,
-0.7397575378417969,
-0.03286942094564438,
-0.48014122247695923,
-0.6457206010818481,
0.1633501499891281,
0.25371453166007996,
0.6710911393165588,
-0.5496091246604919,
0.21718841791152954,
-0.2199091613292694,
0.02659628726541996,
0.07909543812274933,
-0.16048023104667664,
0.7407194375991821,
0.08083974570035934,
-0.1893790364265442,
0.3081803619861603,
-0.6320203542709351,
-0.31939664483070374,
0.03216058760881424,
-0.2295210361480713,
-0.13989877700805664,
0.3791046142578125,
-0.26085183024406433,
0.3737879991531372,
0.3644539415836334,
-0.729919970035553,
0.011924246326088905,
-0.12294105440378189,
0.5019885301589966,
0.883238673210144,
0.25108328461647034,
-0.11741940677165985,
-0.4935681223869324,
0.5577428340911865,
0.1525445133447647,
-0.34271904826164246,
-0.4013523459434509,
-0.4872692823410034,
-0.8493121266365051,
0.08343826979398727,
0.1911657154560089,
0.5496922135353088,
-0.4757791757583618,
0.3630346655845642,
-0.2946469485759735,
-0.11363038420677185,
-0.4017760753631592,
0.026321321725845337,
0.3404746949672699,
0.4748345613479614,
0.26175543665885925,
-0.20695459842681885,
-0.8564172983169556,
-1.1675184965133667,
-0.29120612144470215,
-0.45634913444519043,
-0.06777112185955048,
0.17926330864429474,
0.5660592913627625,
0.15291815996170044,
1.0701853036880493,
-0.2829526364803314,
-0.2696716785430908,
-0.3469560742378235,
0.5259313583374023,
0.32058510184288025,
0.08354496210813522,
0.2204965353012085,
-0.4114368259906769,
-0.42257872223854065,
0.1403571516275406,
-0.8012330532073975,
-0.2999635338783264,
-0.5929389595985413,
-0.0960366278886795,
0.2616826891899109,
0.3135967552661896,
-0.41954725980758667,
-0.06370002031326294,
0.12520942091941833,
-0.45238909125328064,
0.6060775518417358,
-0.06653708219528198,
0.24432507157325745,
-1.3814055919647217,
-0.03118983842432499,
0.3418196439743042,
-0.1524476408958435,
-0.4569680690765381,
-0.2795259356498718,
-0.3982948958873749,
0.1629015952348709,
0.04585783928632736,
0.3883551061153412,
-0.27478471398353577,
0.16788148880004883,
-0.25626492500305176,
0.0009747949079610407,
-0.0038464113604277372,
0.3811587691307068,
0.01715865544974804,
0.6203321218490601,
0.3729060888290405,
-0.1057611033320427,
0.5397253632545471,
0.24935372173786163,
-0.31877294182777405,
1.092261791229248,
-0.5545817613601685,
0.12376807630062103,
-0.2049989551305771,
0.34840628504753113,
-1.085228443145752,
-0.3792029917240143,
0.09585799276828766,
-0.34285208582878113,
-0.003847298678010702,
-0.2415326088666916,
-0.25131526589393616,
-0.34389355778694153,
-0.5224676728248596,
-0.24768057465553284,
0.1948288083076477,
-0.560930609703064,
0.7376374006271362,
0.6496230363845825,
-0.7387661337852478,
-0.5510692000389099,
-0.3203967809677124,
0.6970582008361816,
-0.7155545353889465,
-0.4855632781982422,
0.4604283273220062,
0.12589648365974426,
-0.4386058449745178,
0.07324786484241486,
0.052478939294815063,
-0.02780136466026306,
-0.3160537779331207,
0.31007832288742065,
-0.13923436403274536,
-0.06982246041297913,
0.06883163750171661,
0.09503263235092163,
-0.23358356952667236,
0.44758370518684387,
-0.0842214822769165,
0.10285581648349762,
0.040519289672374725,
-0.451035737991333,
-0.1768273562192917,
0.762611448764801,
0.6729879975318909,
0.13064435124397278,
0.22657646238803864,
0.15022800862789154,
-0.4702538847923279,
-0.2464779019355774,
-0.7503904700279236,
0.13870812952518463,
-0.3467679023742676,
0.4947301149368286,
-0.4407981038093567,
-0.49506333470344543,
0.6810829639434814,
-0.23503854870796204,
0.8493490815162659,
0.6800268292427063,
0.762836217880249,
-0.11519672721624374,
0.7793660163879395,
0.15844008326530457,
-0.19383959472179413,
0.04223379120230675,
-0.16423338651657104,
0.21498648822307587,
-0.6404209733009338,
-0.19336539506912231,
-0.39907732605934143,
-0.3405526280403137,
-0.07103969901800156,
-0.3175671398639679,
0.07386291027069092,
-0.08699435740709305,
-0.10302991420030594,
0.1405077427625656,
-0.41921189427375793,
0.40020987391471863,
0.2100243717432022,
-0.02839827537536621,
0.2848277688026428,
0.009253262542188168,
0.06820213794708252,
0.004332185722887516,
-0.5644260048866272,
-0.7670741081237793,
1.3160516023635864,
0.19496826827526093,
0.3881094753742218,
-0.045436590909957886,
0.661685049533844,
0.7284807562828064,
0.5256701707839966,
-0.6217772960662842,
0.7695032954216003,
-0.5174092054367065,
-0.3518276512622833,
-0.08739181607961655,
-0.32747772336006165,
-0.8408541083335876,
0.35763317346572876,
-0.02002020739018917,
-0.462926983833313,
-0.0839085802435875,
-0.07824498414993286,
-0.5373063087463379,
0.404671847820282,
-0.5983154773712158,
1.0290749073028564,
-0.24916119873523712,
-0.3772699236869812,
-0.3224288821220398,
-0.5682632327079773,
0.21553412079811096,
0.1403767317533493,
0.06899458169937134,
-0.08950816839933395,
0.11089453846216202,
1.326846718788147,
-0.42441245913505554,
0.7149221897125244,
-0.3002907633781433,
-0.044074974954128265,
0.5528018474578857,
-0.6406764984130859,
0.3886070251464844,
-0.037771642208099365,
-0.1708020269870758,
-0.1968671828508377,
-0.05503050610423088,
-0.27434149384498596,
-0.42146316170692444,
0.6309158205986023,
-0.4999821186065674,
-0.755298376083374,
-0.3056764602661133,
-0.24957792460918427,
-0.08875714987516403,
-0.19142940640449524,
0.21846593916416168,
0.4769534766674042,
-0.3531937003135681,
0.16710859537124634,
0.3924912214279175,
-0.12566548585891724,
0.4836775064468384,
0.17795029282569885,
0.15691141784191132,
-0.5745623707771301,
1.1243605613708496,
0.26152166724205017,
-0.20337213575839996,
0.10201600939035416,
0.34468913078308105,
-0.5941399335861206,
-0.5385987162590027,
-0.8124402165412903,
-0.0623389407992363,
-0.9633894562721252,
-0.26894882321357727,
-0.7621795535087585,
-0.00940194632858038,
-0.159265398979187,
-0.18528839945793152,
-0.3001052141189575,
-0.4793320298194885,
-0.08264175802469254,
-0.26414021849632263,
0.28588712215423584,
0.871608316898346,
0.0283176451921463,
0.0936553105711937,
-0.07614957541227341,
0.2954093813896179,
0.3493334949016571,
0.19521787762641907,
-0.1161331832408905,
-0.45264843106269836,
-0.24837256968021393,
-0.22742995619773865,
-0.5271113514900208,
-0.9662414193153381,
0.08456778526306152,
0.2090073823928833,
0.7358543872833252,
0.5394579172134399,
0.03397933393716812,
0.7109684944152832,
-0.34053418040275574,
0.9748654961585999,
0.2256614714860916,
-0.6693355441093445,
0.10081996023654938,
0.010441478341817856,
0.1002168208360672,
0.6118308305740356,
0.22783222794532776,
-0.4906262159347534,
-0.12394386529922485,
-0.4762785732746124,
-1.0224605798721313,
0.32987281680107117,
-0.04522929713129997,
-0.18733607232570648,
-0.10934822261333466,
0.16033656895160675,
0.4140586853027344,
0.030777761712670326,
-0.5988065004348755,
0.02455085702240467,
-0.10623269528150558,
-0.34639599919319153,
0.23019425570964813,
-0.18044638633728027,
-0.4156138598918915,
-0.0897514671087265,
0.7409265041351318,
-0.30723488330841064,
0.13501675426959991,
0.02928837016224861,
0.03078227862715721,
0.03767513111233711,
0.5755620002746582,
0.33091363310813904,
0.6453844308853149,
0.11698037385940552,
0.1379212588071823,
0.5614194273948669,
0.09932500123977661,
0.16882675886154175,
0.34898391366004944,
0.06494200229644775,
0.23521435260772705,
0.542251706123352,
0.6509416699409485,
-0.1028057411313057,
-0.588466227054596,
0.4476472735404968,
-0.19318103790283203,
-0.43845877051353455,
-0.40720435976982117,
-0.4808083772659302,
0.33642345666885376,
0.1808377504348755,
0.3813886046409607,
-0.1587442308664322,
0.06169086694717407,
-0.5273314118385315,
0.31663379073143005,
0.609372079372406,
-0.02423943765461445,
-0.2677652835845947,
0.525327205657959,
0.2908778786659241,
-0.004985089413821697,
0.045085128396749496,
-0.17648296058177948,
-0.5826693773269653,
0.6094887852668762,
0.29844701290130615,
0.980672299861908,
0.006170452106744051,
0.23583699762821198,
0.2611596882343292,
-0.013529185205698013,
0.10215795040130615,
0.4249546527862549,
-0.07829942554235458,
-0.35264095664024353,
-0.6645923852920532,
-0.5376977920532227,
-0.5505927801132202,
0.3626534640789032,
-0.5146361589431763,
0.2662121653556824,
-0.13376165926456451,
-0.1234712302684784,
0.22693535685539246,
0.13326022028923035,
-0.2668505012989044,
0.04877202957868576,
0.13761456310749054,
0.5117409229278564,
-1.0840253829956055,
0.22980819642543793,
0.8661837577819824,
-0.08158908039331436,
0.052120476961135864,
-0.11896232515573502,
-0.027169110253453255,
-0.11177033931016922,
0.2100171446800232,
0.15596126019954681,
-0.2839214503765106,
-0.4259474277496338,
-0.4478391408920288,
-0.305774986743927,
0.7933559417724609,
0.3751959204673767,
-0.30151796340942383,
0.09180518239736557,
0.20617909729480743,
0.49265822768211365,
-0.6031394004821777,
0.4995165467262268,
0.39744827151298523,
0.4462337791919708,
0.032635074108839035,
-0.4108651280403137,
0.03129638731479645,
-0.3312949538230896,
-0.321483850479126,
-0.09730783104896545,
-0.6486607789993286,
0.7519304752349854,
-0.2861790060997009,
-0.46220776438713074,
0.0612444132566452,
0.8025870323181152,
0.10170359909534454,
0.36414238810539246,
0.6104557514190674,
0.9589177966117859,
0.5563466548919678,
-0.06419254094362259,
0.7254822254180908,
-0.39728185534477234,
0.045144423842430115,
1.2865045070648193,
-0.40362706780433655,
0.8225143551826477,
0.47562175989151,
-0.18110007047653198,
0.5311005115509033,
0.9020156860351562,
-0.021013936027884483,
0.22167375683784485,
0.552801251411438,
-0.4748237729072571,
-0.4896382689476013,
-0.31122496724128723,
-0.20125624537467957,
0.26249757409095764,
0.4292810261249542,
-0.1846040040254593,
-0.5623076558113098,
-0.24469567835330963,
0.2237386703491211,
0.2870258092880249,
0.035050902515649796,
0.9734355211257935,
-0.10207068920135498,
-1.002926230430603,
0.13228292763233185,
0.03579176962375641,
0.5192757844924927,
-0.44563594460487366,
-0.31514230370521545,
-0.21295888721942902,
0.04219083487987518,
-0.39179086685180664,
-0.9261986613273621,
0.16960589587688446,
0.3034842908382416,
-0.20588989555835724,
-0.24817566573619843,
0.5045604705810547,
-0.37402400374412537,
-0.5716919898986816,
0.15329132974147797,
0.46336057782173157,
0.20800800621509552,
0.2672906816005707,
-0.5680673122406006,
-0.2169537991285324,
0.008459484204649925,
-0.5605558753013611,
0.30811870098114014,
0.5065262317657471,
-0.15313361585140228,
0.44883689284324646,
0.6152903437614441,
0.02985483407974243,
-0.05005057528614998,
0.2592688202857971,
1.1162505149841309,
-0.5218745470046997,
-0.2506450414657593,
-1.0253430604934692,
0.5575733184814453,
-0.5089989900588989,
-0.5061718225479126,
0.6207686066627502,
1.0391396284103394,
0.6148876547813416,
0.2728160321712494,
1.144574761390686,
-0.13771164417266846,
0.6007323265075684,
-0.2994824945926666,
0.4605058431625366,
-0.36130568385124207,
-0.009138999506831169,
-0.06723066419363022,
-0.4798852205276489,
-0.052278369665145874,
0.5016846656799316,
-0.1401536613702774,
-0.2868136167526245,
0.5417062044143677,
0.4650549292564392,
0.019376618787646294,
0.32655319571495056,
0.06331739574670792,
0.2594220042228699,
0.47008955478668213,
0.782216489315033,
0.8481588959693909,
-0.22570116817951202,
0.5059838891029358,
-0.033077042549848557,
-0.2786375880241394,
0.18564538657665253,
-1.028389811515808,
-0.9272865653038025,
-0.8013530969619751,
-0.48648500442504883,
-0.2883894443511963,
0.2675212621688843,
0.8228724598884583,
0.43334588408470154,
-0.9911374449729919,
-0.5712071061134338,
0.001346238306723535,
0.04960710182785988,
-0.19815336167812347,
-0.1437443345785141,
0.3355761170387268,
-0.3891662657260895,
-0.5016226172447205,
0.4487658739089966,
0.3023068308830261,
-0.5715886354446411,
-0.24100984632968903,
-0.15122628211975098,
-0.42308729887008667,
0.2076983004808426,
0.5875273942947388,
0.38180264830589294,
-0.7977805733680725,
-0.0888734981417656,
-0.3900570273399353,
0.2857341766357422,
0.18637874722480774,
0.9424718022346497,
-0.7454264163970947,
0.5512346625328064,
0.3113209009170532,
0.8016993999481201,
0.4256642460823059,
0.27067336440086365,
0.6044228076934814,
-0.5775695443153381,
-0.3454151451587677,
0.17939560115337372,
0.6613516211509705,
0.49271470308303833,
-0.017632657662034035,
0.5021606087684631,
0.10808361321687698,
-0.572836697101593,
-0.7663457989692688,
0.03736163675785065,
-0.7605085968971252,
-0.24834033846855164,
0.9618738889694214,
-0.4944925308227539,
0.01934722438454628,
-0.3337276577949524,
-0.3001726567745209,
0.27051639556884766,
-0.394257128238678,
0.8038650751113892,
1.122260570526123,
-0.44726571440696716,
-0.02584289386868477,
-0.4832777678966522,
0.31743955612182617,
0.6099616289138794,
-1.133063554763794,
0.5598664283752441,
0.510192334651947,
0.09118752926588058,
0.1936277598142624,
0.46405157446861267,
-0.05810586363077164,
0.03582533076405525,
0.08074171841144562,
-0.058958686888217926,
0.046679332852363586,
-0.30635082721710205,
-0.2806703448295593,
0.5715529322624207,
-0.27268490195274353,
-0.13489380478858948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03127v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03127v1
|
Towards Real-world Scenario: Imbalanced New Intent Discovery
| 2024-06-05T10:22:27 | 2024-06-05T10:22:27 |
Shun Zhang, Chaoran Yan, Jian Yang, Jiaheng Liu, Ying Mo, Jiaqi Bai, Tongliang Li, Zhoujun Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
New Intent Discovery (NID) aims at detecting known and previously undefined
categories of user intent by utilizing limited labeled and massive unlabeled
data. Most prior works often operate under the unrealistic assumption that the
distribution of both familiar and new intent classes is uniform, overlooking
the skewed and long-tailed distributions frequently encountered in real-world
scenarios. To bridge the gap, our work introduces the imbalanced new intent
discovery (i-NID) task, which seeks to identify familiar and novel intent
categories within long-tailed distributions. A new benchmark (ImbaNID-Bench)
comprised of three datasets is created to simulate the real-world long-tail
distributions. ImbaNID-Bench ranges from broad cross-domain to specific
single-domain intent categories, providing a thorough representation of
practical use cases. Besides, a robust baseline model ImbaNID is proposed to
achieve cluster-friendly intent representations. It includes three stages:
model pre-training, generation of reliable pseudo-labels, and robust
representation learning that strengthens the model performance to handle the
intricacies of real-world data distributions. Our extensive experiments on
previous benchmarks and the newly established benchmark demonstrate the
superior performance of ImbaNID in addressing the i-NID task, highlighting its
potential as a powerful baseline for uncovering and categorizing user intents
in imbalanced and long-tailed
distributions\footnote{\url{https://github.com/Zkdc/i-NID}}.
|
[
-0.5050989985466003,
-0.5915718674659729,
0.29436278343200684,
0.242699533700943,
-0.20718830823898315,
0.042564913630485535,
-0.004291119985282421,
-0.36135122179985046,
0.5952837467193604,
0.3293515145778656,
-0.8730337023735046,
-0.6929513216018677,
-0.4179616868495941,
-0.2728479206562042,
-0.2787415683269501,
0.9404153823852539,
-0.07674350589513779,
-0.15153582394123077,
-0.35765281319618225,
-0.45428627729415894,
-0.6617388725280762,
-0.30724290013313293,
-0.44139575958251953,
-0.3835729956626892,
0.5227115154266357,
0.8135724067687988,
0.21934889256954193,
0.09134646505117416,
0.42324596643447876,
0.062489841133356094,
0.13225804269313812,
0.13597647845745087,
-0.5777273178100586,
0.11745955795049667,
-0.2103237807750702,
-0.2519221305847168,
-0.4413277804851532,
0.26317036151885986,
0.5415444374084473,
0.5795214772224426,
-0.2547447085380554,
0.30730724334716797,
0.012704302556812763,
0.5309528708457947,
-0.9940213561058044,
-0.016155602410435677,
-0.3650656044483185,
0.07095806300640106,
-0.40125662088394165,
-0.1448228359222412,
-0.4277392327785492,
-0.11179103702306747,
0.3018094599246979,
-0.5884824395179749,
0.08986667543649673,
0.21581131219863892,
0.6763755083084106,
0.052473943680524826,
-0.6553295850753784,
-0.2594353258609772,
-0.6726656556129456,
0.7702169418334961,
-0.7230738401412964,
0.20574072003364563,
0.18949313461780548,
0.5294917821884155,
-0.09328769147396088,
-0.48211151361465454,
-0.4189162254333496,
-0.13841664791107178,
-0.0018396159866824746,
-0.08700352907180786,
0.05420539155602455,
-0.27462664246559143,
0.2862962484359741,
0.1945931613445282,
-0.4066990315914154,
0.21249011158943176,
-0.20696821808815002,
0.059234391897916794,
0.4627154469490051,
0.2596764862537384,
0.14108438789844513,
-0.09051912277936935,
-0.5212271809577942,
-0.14998018741607666,
-0.64447420835495,
0.4084489345550537,
0.4605112373828888,
0.2550683915615082,
-0.3042614459991455,
0.7001357078552246,
-0.6990463733673096,
0.5600628852844238,
0.3911009430885315,
-0.0873003676533699,
0.40221306681632996,
-0.4119515120983124,
0.049731940031051636,
0.29530057311058044,
0.3482501208782196,
0.5275225043296814,
0.06727991253137589,
-0.09655787795782089,
-0.03964710235595703,
-0.20956319570541382,
0.5062613487243652,
-0.8518651723861694,
-0.02433585561811924,
0.24388831853866577,
-0.643867015838623,
-0.19694481790065765,
-0.0873180702328682,
-0.2221941202878952,
-0.36551985144615173,
-0.2601364850997925,
0.5638784766197205,
-0.4447605311870575,
-0.4106413722038269,
0.2631179988384247,
-0.0019389981171116233,
0.0907328650355339,
0.3905070722103119,
-0.939103901386261,
0.29069289565086365,
0.8700726628303528,
0.7426350116729736,
-0.5261277556419373,
-0.08838200569152832,
-0.4103548526763916,
0.19714105129241943,
0.0575687512755394,
0.7980343699455261,
-0.2294446974992752,
0.026596928015351295,
-0.17531734704971313,
-0.002982387086376548,
0.014734047465026379,
-0.6382418274879456,
0.8542523980140686,
-0.256533682346344,
-0.06089853495359421,
-0.21058917045593262,
-0.5832632184028625,
-0.2438344806432724,
0.6418182849884033,
-0.6460618376731873,
0.6579291820526123,
0.3164154291152954,
-0.7679604291915894,
0.8659881353378296,
-0.8435573577880859,
-0.484681099653244,
0.18388906121253967,
0.02124434895813465,
-0.5090214014053345,
0.16617628931999207,
-0.21152843534946442,
0.4937436282634735,
-0.3981819152832031,
0.5055184364318848,
-0.6117743253707886,
-0.4432305693626404,
0.1690574288368225,
-0.557812511920929,
0.759625256061554,
0.03803129866719246,
-0.3687230348587036,
0.03213178366422653,
-0.4576174318790436,
0.04600037261843681,
-0.22806419432163239,
-0.07358842343091965,
-0.6322507262229919,
0.16831113398075104,
0.13789823651313782,
0.13025200366973877,
0.07420896738767624,
-0.8576517105102539,
0.35422995686531067,
0.01031698938459158,
0.048195675015449524,
0.8218645453453064,
-0.01457569282501936,
0.411239892244339,
-0.32970792055130005,
0.45298391580581665,
0.22183844447135925,
0.5173840522766113,
0.11938365548849106,
-0.39023351669311523,
-0.176925390958786,
-0.2105511873960495,
0.4403592050075531,
0.5309275984764099,
-0.2804514765739441,
0.3781941831111908,
-0.6471031904220581,
-0.2535264492034912,
-0.2323961853981018,
0.02779274247586727,
0.29138273000717163,
0.3850243389606476,
0.2478172779083252,
-0.4612663686275482,
-0.10702420771121979,
-1.0338746309280396,
-0.21524980664253235,
0.10825599730014801,
0.2218506634235382,
0.5121641159057617,
0.23633696138858795,
-0.5383830666542053,
0.9757474064826965,
-0.4478544592857361,
-0.7138006091117859,
-0.1952384114265442,
0.32567790150642395,
0.463845819234848,
0.5731080770492554,
0.5973907113075256,
-0.9946092367172241,
-0.713773787021637,
-0.10676123946905136,
-0.5448222160339355,
-0.21841412782669067,
0.019073840230703354,
-0.41731101274490356,
-0.28895458579063416,
0.6876647472381592,
-0.4164675772190094,
0.4988340735435486,
0.3555181324481964,
-0.4250016212463379,
0.5060601830482483,
0.15907008945941925,
0.26516667008399963,
-0.8953388333320618,
-0.06518223881721497,
0.0577164851129055,
0.27385371923446655,
-0.5304288864135742,
-0.4234977662563324,
0.46311840415000916,
0.2503960132598877,
-0.5685660243034363,
0.8754112720489502,
-0.3847472369670868,
-0.005828124936670065,
-0.1846197545528412,
-0.29282721877098083,
-0.3059205412864685,
0.23588374257087708,
-0.24548348784446716,
0.49598437547683716,
0.23633955419063568,
-0.7523738145828247,
-0.07624247670173645,
0.14547869563102722,
-0.7633016705513,
1.0844414234161377,
-0.2251628190279007,
-0.705764651298523,
-0.27040040493011475,
0.23694686591625214,
-1.1265615224838257,
-0.4870932102203369,
0.3222994804382324,
-0.43126991391181946,
0.2532522678375244,
-0.3643762469291687,
-0.49334806203842163,
-0.31937089562416077,
-0.31776171922683716,
1.123404622077942,
0.35484766960144043,
-0.7253313064575195,
0.6467793583869934,
0.4600095748901367,
0.11603017151355743,
-0.7465913891792297,
-0.3669314980506897,
-0.18496890366077423,
-0.3139202296733856,
-0.6807205677032471,
0.4196831285953522,
-0.24123604595661163,
-0.1981133222579956,
0.11893217265605927,
-0.09168015420436859,
0.03200767934322357,
0.23884104192256927,
0.47851693630218506,
-0.03455595299601555,
-0.16719950735569,
0.10104384273290634,
0.172272726893425,
-0.2726893424987793,
0.017807921394705772,
-0.19086579978466034,
0.6697255969047546,
0.3545955717563629,
-0.7482078075408936,
-0.37720292806625366,
0.5016273856163025,
0.6555318832397461,
-0.16396182775497437,
0.6510174870491028,
0.6743847727775574,
-0.37901633977890015,
-0.3746703565120697,
-0.5294488072395325,
-0.178749218583107,
-0.4678996801376343,
-0.024924570694565773,
-0.2765336334705353,
-0.5788184404373169,
0.29284656047821045,
-0.3868696391582489,
0.41239485144615173,
-0.06716162711381912,
0.2407688945531845,
-0.2502064108848572,
1.0387166738510132,
0.5094093084335327,
0.06757289916276932,
0.6262368559837341,
-0.40890705585479736,
0.683610737323761,
-1.2712146043777466,
-0.2606567442417145,
0.07699092477560043,
-0.8554738759994507,
-0.2595750391483307,
-0.2962770462036133,
0.6671739816665649,
-0.14490431547164917,
0.22409625351428986,
0.014536784961819649,
-0.3593756854534149,
0.2746206521987915,
0.8542318940162659,
0.10896334797143936,
0.006699373479932547,
0.003309631021693349,
-0.01786026731133461,
-0.1120002269744873,
-0.2796931266784668,
-0.1495048552751541,
1.5282989740371704,
-0.23960484564304352,
0.9185829162597656,
0.3045318126678467,
0.8846389055252075,
0.607173502445221,
0.8067810535430908,
-0.774874210357666,
0.3328539729118347,
-0.26697880029678345,
-0.8080649375915527,
-0.05564196780323982,
0.00525179598480463,
-1.142201542854309,
0.4201115667819977,
-0.39125388860702515,
-0.5399240255355835,
0.37839195132255554,
0.38415464758872986,
-0.2591002285480499,
0.41302430629730225,
-0.9446976780891418,
1.026387095451355,
-0.4872881770133972,
-0.534121036529541,
-0.0868675708770752,
-0.41542938351631165,
0.8701850771903992,
0.15142524242401123,
0.14825113117694855,
-0.689281165599823,
0.21327655017375946,
0.4830152094364166,
-0.11200480908155441,
0.606645941734314,
-0.44193002581596375,
0.0356290228664875,
0.08227880299091339,
-0.2155349850654602,
0.6024478077888489,
0.1487569659948349,
-0.14298732578754425,
-0.37398993968963623,
-0.38443633913993835,
-0.4719427824020386,
-0.3372263014316559,
0.9752967357635498,
-0.26080840826034546,
-0.21513834595680237,
-0.5728081464767456,
-0.6368386745452881,
-0.20208659768104553,
0.3251013159751892,
0.24338456988334656,
0.7050254344940186,
-0.521517276763916,
0.6336859464645386,
1.0094685554504395,
0.10262461751699448,
0.12298210710287094,
0.48582494258880615,
0.12784510850906372,
-0.014376187697052956,
0.6369380354881287,
0.1978125125169754,
0.4361480474472046,
0.48639440536499023,
-0.06948459148406982,
-0.43822434544563293,
-0.6181987524032593,
-0.3431081771850586,
0.05106273666024208,
-0.5996289253234863,
-0.15604741871356964,
-0.9167084097862244,
0.07843160629272461,
-0.3636413812637329,
-0.30341845750808716,
-0.28866133093833923,
-0.06963963806629181,
-0.2608624994754791,
-0.11134611815214157,
0.10948815196752548,
0.21064633131027222,
-0.08210244029760361,
0.4925995469093323,
-0.11639454215765,
0.7112038731575012,
0.047751687467098236,
0.5144377946853638,
0.02238454297184944,
0.03433924540877342,
-0.31410902738571167,
0.24095255136489868,
-0.1083250641822815,
-0.3993685245513916,
0.33008819818496704,
-0.0542844794690609,
0.8877934217453003,
0.6326284408569336,
0.49594131112098694,
0.33216366171836853,
-0.13304202258586884,
0.16497386991977692,
0.21641278266906738,
-0.2389959990978241,
0.2528117299079895,
-0.21023568511009216,
0.4111591577529907,
0.8703153133392334,
0.49259963631629944,
-0.5905655026435852,
-0.022009577602148056,
-0.7165294885635376,
-1.0529818534851074,
0.792539656162262,
-0.06313466280698776,
-0.05000033229589462,
-0.10150167346000671,
0.3716452419757843,
0.3286519944667816,
0.24627168476581573,
-1.0012489557266235,
-0.4390900135040283,
0.07945339381694794,
-0.5375056266784668,
-0.13650932908058167,
-0.3857026696205139,
-0.026097793132066727,
-0.23299504816532135,
0.5676373243331909,
-0.12024924904108047,
0.15295013785362244,
-0.03309385105967522,
-0.32767897844314575,
0.2071455717086792,
0.15753965079784393,
0.28497982025146484,
0.5140569806098938,
-0.6575475335121155,
0.13493871688842773,
-0.3311159610748291,
-0.7260364890098572,
0.4899972975254059,
-0.1814906746149063,
-0.6318492293357849,
-0.17244462668895721,
-0.15593473613262177,
0.6965054273605347,
0.4172995984554291,
-1.031437873840332,
0.8383504152297974,
-0.30880478024482727,
-0.32246947288513184,
-0.5563433170318604,
0.23247173428535461,
-0.07570518553256989,
-0.02681623212993145,
0.346225768327713,
0.23215775191783905,
0.42927300930023193,
-0.706069827079773,
0.37833142280578613,
0.8845706582069397,
-0.493673712015152,
-0.22663608193397522,
0.3400935232639313,
0.09781833738088608,
-0.12636896967887878,
0.5302100777626038,
-0.7551147937774658,
-0.06172259524464607,
0.5970571041107178,
0.6112252473831177,
0.9107246994972229,
-0.01939481496810913,
0.30623671412467957,
0.5280281901359558,
0.38148343563079834,
-0.09696609526872635,
0.3450351655483246,
-0.17821577191352844,
-0.6275970935821533,
0.11184359341859818,
-0.42332130670547485,
-0.3255804777145386,
0.044685475528240204,
-0.7855921387672424,
0.5509151816368103,
-0.4924599230289459,
-0.19037014245986938,
0.136050745844841,
-0.1945549100637436,
-0.5071387887001038,
0.02368902787566185,
-0.23916739225387573,
0.5362905263900757,
-0.8237910270690918,
0.6911941766738892,
0.42100515961647034,
0.29391658306121826,
-0.1711873561143875,
0.07454068958759308,
0.14293891191482544,
-0.5519687533378601,
0.28078699111938477,
0.46800991892814636,
-0.07836019992828369,
-0.0672755241394043,
-0.6388348340988159,
-1.0546592473983765,
1.257393717765808,
-0.16664473712444305,
-0.26654860377311707,
0.38973015546798706,
-0.09843992441892624,
0.181575745344162,
-0.670720636844635,
0.21838253736495972,
0.17897166311740875,
0.48093125224113464,
0.10072670131921768,
-0.3872002363204956,
-0.01954079605638981,
-0.4706646203994751,
-0.43217870593070984,
0.65163654088974,
-0.31628650426864624,
1.2168354988098145,
-0.18340353667736053,
-0.3439544439315796,
-0.019171882420778275,
0.4229516386985779,
0.4520745873451233,
0.7697256803512573,
0.7276344895362854,
0.6941590309143066,
0.5367769002914429,
-0.07550336420536041,
0.889667809009552,
0.05717650428414345,
-0.14729854464530945,
1.1439244747161865,
-0.4508151710033417,
0.7491757273674011,
0.4303727149963379,
0.23696978390216827,
0.550861120223999,
0.6082619428634644,
0.1335587352514267,
0.9179439544677734,
0.21234798431396484,
-0.5140587091445923,
-0.01609041541814804,
-0.1844887137413025,
-0.1324455291032791,
-0.06403648853302002,
0.6833333373069763,
0.17641210556030273,
-0.37113192677497864,
0.3585122227668762,
-0.4251745045185089,
-0.11401459574699402,
-0.13131259381771088,
0.5203765630722046,
-0.42663824558258057,
-0.8362823128700256,
0.5170838832855225,
-0.0653514564037323,
1.2833930253982544,
-0.5425259470939636,
-0.061099935322999954,
-0.07772041112184525,
0.4907861351966858,
-0.19197000563144684,
-0.7366446852684021,
-0.13460202515125275,
-0.428903192281723,
-0.42736417055130005,
-0.10508126020431519,
0.48034051060676575,
-0.308319091796875,
-0.28289681673049927,
0.28065720200538635,
0.06632012873888016,
-0.08526120334863663,
-0.20328602194786072,
-0.48466840386390686,
-0.10208473354578018,
0.144955113530159,
0.2644690275192261,
0.4946896731853485,
0.4716286361217499,
-0.6236070394515991,
0.9921939969062805,
0.7036277055740356,
-0.36421141028404236,
0.3970044255256653,
-0.13594017922878265,
0.36304333806037903,
-0.6071582436561584,
-0.59977126121521,
-0.27906250953674316,
0.3150305151939392,
-0.23515291512012482,
-0.563433051109314,
0.6533806324005127,
0.8163750767707825,
0.8857060074806213,
-0.06132277101278305,
0.6684622764587402,
-0.41170912981033325,
0.8484647274017334,
-0.28565922379493713,
0.2437056303024292,
-0.7867713570594788,
0.26182278990745544,
0.06403137743473053,
-0.7755815386772156,
0.01759030483663082,
0.27869459986686707,
-0.11280073970556259,
-0.2538166344165802,
0.42032870650291443,
0.5912995338439941,
-0.9104747772216797,
-0.16999147832393646,
-0.042549800127744675,
-0.0022289766930043697,
0.4572601914405823,
0.470043808221817,
0.9714305400848389,
-0.31012973189353943,
0.21164783835411072,
-0.4096295237541199,
-0.2872282862663269,
-0.8795387744903564,
-0.6978462934494019,
-0.5560938119888306,
-0.6027780771255493,
-0.25868451595306396,
0.07295684516429901,
-0.18247127532958984,
0.7590433359146118,
0.8116806745529175,
-0.6717751026153564,
-0.4681057035923004,
-0.061500489711761475,
0.29418814182281494,
-0.3689737319946289,
-0.317982017993927,
-0.0343538373708725,
-0.17369787395000458,
-0.5659045577049255,
0.04429851099848747,
0.35528838634490967,
0.289213627576828,
-0.14893874526023865,
-0.14624853432178497,
-0.6938100457191467,
-0.09665380418300629,
0.704108715057373,
0.3915630280971527,
-0.5090433955192566,
-0.10433607548475266,
-0.012083291076123714,
-0.020362863317131996,
0.007195209618657827,
0.8659471273422241,
-0.7533466219902039,
0.2564084231853485,
0.4646780490875244,
0.3076270520687103,
0.7868105173110962,
0.19310511648654938,
0.328077495098114,
-0.6857556700706482,
0.20286306738853455,
0.38065484166145325,
0.10099123418331146,
0.1463472843170166,
-0.31791701912879944,
0.6056616902351379,
-0.1962004154920578,
-0.15416613221168518,
-1.0482438802719116,
0.0709894523024559,
-1.305307149887085,
-0.32449010014533997,
0.9014235138893127,
0.1826815903186798,
-0.28137797117233276,
-0.37254777550697327,
-0.20802515745162964,
-0.3310886323451996,
-0.4282103180885315,
0.5575062036514282,
0.5345547795295715,
-0.30439919233322144,
0.10523513704538345,
-0.6137939095497131,
0.5479769110679626,
0.4593614339828491,
-0.739607572555542,
0.1070924624800682,
0.5706524848937988,
0.3551793694496155,
0.10612216591835022,
0.876177966594696,
-0.09532345831394196,
0.41892915964126587,
-0.3979385495185852,
0.05504739284515381,
0.3594256043434143,
-0.4770752191543579,
0.31202811002731323,
0.12007774412631989,
-0.1529376357793808,
-0.19378098845481873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03125v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03125v1
|
Space Decomposition for Sentence Embedding
| 2024-06-05T10:20:10 | 2024-06-05T10:20:10 |
Wuttikorn Ponwitayarat, Peerat Limkonchotiwat, Ekapol Chuangsuwanich, Sarana Nutanong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Determining sentence pair similarity is crucial for various NLP tasks. A
common technique to address this is typically evaluated on a continuous
semantic textual similarity scale from 0 to 5. However, based on a linguistic
observation in STS annotation guidelines, we found that the score in the range
[4,5] indicates an upper-range sample, while the rest are lower-range samples.
This necessitates a new approach to treating the upper-range and lower-range
classes separately. In this paper, we introduce a novel embedding space
decomposition method called MixSP utilizing a Mixture of Specialized
Projectors, designed to distinguish and rank upper-range and lower-range
samples accurately. The experimental results demonstrate that MixSP decreased
the overlap representation between upper-range and lower-range classes
significantly while outperforming competitors on STS and zero-shot benchmarks.
|
[
-0.41988909244537354,
-0.6379322409629822,
0.4154643416404724,
0.34574538469314575,
-0.25860798358917236,
0.305071085691452,
-0.16737565398216248,
-0.15699461102485657,
0.5255289673805237,
0.13360249996185303,
-0.2016298621892929,
-0.5497443079948425,
-0.6695483922958374,
-0.2973620593547821,
-0.5251764059066772,
0.6053664088249207,
-0.17795415222644806,
-0.16788636147975922,
-0.4876933693885803,
-0.32420387864112854,
-0.44521570205688477,
-0.4623173773288727,
0.006759702228009701,
0.013299668207764626,
0.16260942816734314,
0.271628201007843,
0.6292840242385864,
0.4810154438018799,
0.5472602248191833,
0.3019394874572754,
-0.4938133656978607,
0.3288472592830658,
-0.32304108142852783,
0.2737290859222412,
0.16253578662872314,
-0.126117542386055,
0.0025570965372025967,
0.06597428023815155,
0.6823053956031799,
1.0494940280914307,
-0.2804897725582123,
-0.04168044030666351,
-0.03168927878141403,
0.28623729944229126,
-0.996253490447998,
-0.40891820192337036,
-0.5309615135192871,
0.41339004039764404,
-0.07379058748483658,
-0.3598134219646454,
-0.5083141922950745,
-0.09922594577074051,
0.25879430770874023,
-0.6144301295280457,
0.28106728196144104,
0.3973943293094635,
0.8626642823219299,
0.10654423385858536,
-0.24724715948104858,
-0.11293523758649826,
-0.5184516906738281,
0.7582583427429199,
-0.536016583442688,
0.2667583227157593,
-0.08101752400398254,
0.13195927441120148,
0.030834585428237915,
-0.4195588231086731,
-0.681350588798523,
-0.05596964433789253,
-0.11159680783748627,
0.13759922981262207,
-0.20826473832130432,
-0.2680826485157013,
0.13944610953330994,
0.5225160717964172,
-0.5277055501937866,
-0.049547236412763596,
-0.4906783103942871,
-0.0960342288017273,
0.25149139761924744,
0.11355844885110855,
0.569634199142456,
-0.3424910604953766,
-0.7562964558601379,
-0.2570890784263611,
-0.6493722200393677,
-0.31835731863975525,
0.08530008792877197,
0.1097063273191452,
-0.09430168569087982,
1.0696091651916504,
0.19326306879520416,
0.42628905177116394,
-0.22953692078590393,
0.3380020260810852,
0.46507492661476135,
-0.3209139406681061,
-0.49220985174179077,
-0.18155138194561005,
0.5628049969673157,
0.5789397954940796,
0.07505536824464798,
-0.028477340936660767,
0.005575166549533606,
0.4811614453792572,
0.23403775691986084,
-0.38641753792762756,
-0.22135226428508759,
-0.09179863333702087,
-0.43485555052757263,
-0.08133827894926071,
0.012189815752208233,
-0.4625951945781708,
-0.3244342803955078,
-0.10506904870271683,
0.3868181109428406,
-0.6734318733215332,
-0.03657762333750725,
0.19588510692119598,
-0.5718039274215698,
0.24428124725818634,
0.2773279845714569,
-0.6684412956237793,
0.7809974551200867,
0.6750220656394958,
1.024122953414917,
-0.19618821144104004,
-0.31812432408332825,
-0.4700532555580139,
0.19101107120513916,
-0.2726753056049347,
0.8046429753303528,
-0.6952804327011108,
-0.4725857079029083,
-0.05727642774581909,
-0.5747994184494019,
-0.326876699924469,
-0.8373711705207825,
0.35674747824668884,
-0.14993901550769806,
0.534618079662323,
0.018996186554431915,
-1.0265246629714966,
0.22197534143924713,
0.2599012553691864,
-0.3615467846393585,
1.467347502708435,
0.48235899209976196,
-0.9553490877151489,
0.6670181751251221,
-0.5930051803588867,
-0.29686740040779114,
0.2360677421092987,
-0.19765812158584595,
-0.3616334795951843,
0.23041942715644836,
0.35529372096061707,
0.5045541524887085,
0.33520400524139404,
-0.16648024320602417,
-0.4111303389072418,
-0.658923327922821,
0.10367263108491898,
0.13823460042476654,
0.34059977531433105,
0.20425064861774445,
-0.07318449765443802,
0.10335146635770798,
-0.6606301665306091,
0.11098569631576538,
-0.03789457306265831,
-0.018158432096242905,
-1.0445419549942017,
0.06912156194448471,
0.36092352867126465,
0.1369321495294571,
0.03381546586751938,
-0.765034019947052,
-0.011400646530091763,
-0.5841472744941711,
0.32899782061576843,
0.6381716728210449,
0.1150471642613411,
0.7422046065330505,
-0.3089449405670166,
0.38867560029029846,
0.17814986407756805,
-0.41154545545578003,
-0.1170952171087265,
-0.39669936895370483,
-0.8913052082061768,
-0.31328949332237244,
0.19626329839229584,
0.44832080602645874,
-0.2606309652328491,
1.09227454662323,
-0.3185758590698242,
-0.3671882152557373,
-0.777671754360199,
-0.11686356365680695,
0.23447439074516296,
0.04496987536549568,
0.7108789086341858,
-0.10825716704130173,
-0.7435698509216309,
-0.8310129046440125,
-0.4629027247428894,
0.23395811021327972,
-0.285568505525589,
0.04762238264083862,
0.6040013432502747,
-0.03513961657881737,
0.8582416772842407,
-0.886532723903656,
-0.4928038418292999,
-0.41731321811676025,
-0.30562159419059753,
-0.18690356612205505,
0.6493043303489685,
0.5821199417114258,
-0.7165284752845764,
-0.4145694077014923,
-0.26077038049697876,
-0.39335179328918457,
0.17114335298538208,
-0.08841210603713989,
-0.28816458582878113,
-0.2627393305301666,
0.5651745796203613,
-0.5221211314201355,
0.562431812286377,
0.5118063688278198,
-0.7322414517402649,
-0.09549438953399658,
-0.2128058522939682,
0.09324871003627777,
-1.2079116106033325,
-0.07568076997995377,
0.2817092835903168,
-0.21360382437705994,
-0.26214873790740967,
0.12163154780864716,
-0.1512805074453354,
-0.14715759456157684,
-0.371024489402771,
0.2014514058828354,
-0.29196909070014954,
-0.3406566381454468,
0.011672922410070896,
0.5589926242828369,
0.03616074100136757,
0.2017054259777069,
0.1013060212135315,
0.4481041431427002,
0.22911322116851807,
-0.23124036192893982,
-0.18777605891227722,
0.461850643157959,
-0.5427960753440857,
0.3627198040485382,
-0.7199775576591492,
0.028432101011276245,
-0.035099733620882034,
0.4359714388847351,
-1.2774404287338257,
0.08840098977088928,
-0.024776825681328773,
-0.37116149067878723,
-0.2206452637910843,
0.15622510015964508,
-0.5998216867446899,
-0.043029844760894775,
-0.47006291151046753,
0.27786633372306824,
0.6822539567947388,
-0.2057182639837265,
0.21735581755638123,
0.5301952958106995,
-0.02301517128944397,
-0.3307211101055145,
-0.9752134084701538,
-0.22337403893470764,
-0.19750846922397614,
-0.6101597547531128,
0.7890320420265198,
-0.053071845322847366,
-0.5071226954460144,
0.34287840127944946,
-0.15917129814624786,
0.06632190197706223,
-0.10171546041965485,
0.40552082657814026,
0.1508336067199707,
-0.07659024000167847,
-0.21487446129322052,
0.3829757273197174,
-0.11824367195367813,
-0.23144102096557617,
0.16133761405944824,
0.67872554063797,
0.20022472739219666,
-0.5677343606948853,
-0.04376276955008507,
0.8247630596160889,
0.2324627786874771,
0.11219549179077148,
0.8945958018302917,
0.47200462222099304,
-0.5534335374832153,
-0.6416847109794617,
-0.36275753378868103,
0.3100461959838867,
-0.451376736164093,
0.06428403407335281,
-0.5155558586120605,
-1.1503217220306396,
0.21519355475902557,
-0.10107377171516418,
0.10098067671060562,
0.47418084740638733,
0.5084968209266663,
-0.3566102087497711,
0.612878143787384,
0.6881610155105591,
0.023059485480189323,
0.32028135657310486,
-0.17909353971481323,
0.3466821610927582,
-0.9477565884590149,
-0.4032958447933197,
-0.6876983046531677,
-0.6482273936271667,
-0.33142009377479553,
-0.9081259369850159,
0.3437085747718811,
-0.0358576700091362,
-0.06801158934831619,
0.4872705936431885,
-0.560774028301239,
0.7500281929969788,
0.46903806924819946,
-0.04568012058734894,
-0.06554018706083298,
0.17188028991222382,
-0.42175108194351196,
-0.4276622533798218,
-0.4065469205379486,
-0.20342929661273956,
0.6162499189376831,
0.2825225591659546,
0.35459616780281067,
-0.025946859270334244,
1.0682437419891357,
0.5408077836036682,
-0.03422519564628601,
-0.7287351489067078,
0.6156187653541565,
-0.5438629388809204,
-0.2692849636077881,
-0.11164594441652298,
-0.36451050639152527,
-0.635130763053894,
0.9138476252555847,
-0.15456648170948029,
-0.5511319637298584,
-0.12668471038341522,
-0.3474426567554474,
-0.2731109857559204,
0.23800909519195557,
-0.8399224877357483,
0.5254189968109131,
0.5010419487953186,
0.40831223130226135,
-0.3308539390563965,
-0.6702823042869568,
-0.23658108711242676,
0.44820916652679443,
0.2980090081691742,
-0.2045772522687912,
-0.057604335248470306,
1.0029197931289673,
-0.566860020160675,
0.5746985077857971,
-0.36772215366363525,
0.20537984371185303,
0.1027260422706604,
0.29495126008987427,
-0.17990973591804504,
-0.139271080493927,
0.03866144269704819,
-0.18161115050315857,
-0.12789452075958252,
-0.5126559138298035,
-0.4957249164581299,
0.8069626688957214,
-0.8561428785324097,
-0.02127191051840782,
-0.42705485224723816,
-0.42506954073905945,
-0.35509374737739563,
0.007817492820322514,
0.19797420501708984,
0.18589557707309723,
-0.1500004231929779,
0.44159916043281555,
0.46195605397224426,
-0.31760886311531067,
0.44754475355148315,
0.07306279987096786,
0.2125139981508255,
-0.5902252793312073,
0.1808856725692749,
-0.14629025757312775,
0.06423798203468323,
0.8123273253440857,
0.025726234540343285,
-0.24695627391338348,
-0.37414491176605225,
-0.06877251714468002,
0.041914504021406174,
-0.8152307271957397,
0.03707490861415863,
-0.7221980690956116,
-0.2914309501647949,
-0.44005101919174194,
-0.8776769638061523,
-0.3404996693134308,
-0.591813325881958,
-0.02829592116177082,
-0.37165191769599915,
-0.16073092818260193,
0.4265960454940796,
0.31051257252693176,
0.27275073528289795,
-0.6942623257637024,
0.4199387729167938,
-0.2782759368419647,
0.17211401462554932,
-0.3292010426521301,
-0.46863338351249695,
-0.05513601005077362,
-0.22505657374858856,
-0.0658530443906784,
-0.6288446187973022,
0.5492547750473022,
0.1609674096107483,
0.6302505731582642,
-0.17638491094112396,
-0.06710341572761536,
1.0928974151611328,
-0.5830215811729431,
1.1265919208526611,
0.2979971170425415,
-1.4059019088745117,
0.8364715576171875,
-0.0750335231423378,
0.32216161489486694,
0.5589796900749207,
0.2486526221036911,
-0.6203590631484985,
-0.49480634927749634,
-0.7781354784965515,
-1.2647068500518799,
0.42186012864112854,
0.5056226849555969,
0.17393477261066437,
0.01519771758466959,
0.1151510700583458,
0.1321949064731598,
0.006665745284408331,
-0.8747631907463074,
-0.2418304681777954,
0.19052566587924957,
-0.3810046315193176,
-0.15425874292850494,
-0.2208159863948822,
-0.28531572222709656,
-0.27222034335136414,
0.20624536275863647,
0.18355746567249298,
0.5389545559883118,
0.1972101926803589,
-0.380862295627594,
-0.17343135178089142,
0.41930925846099854,
0.3446418046951294,
0.4864734709262848,
-0.1485925167798996,
0.3791632652282715,
0.3282487988471985,
-0.37983444333076477,
0.21280530095100403,
-0.13418400287628174,
-0.08756452053785324,
0.2361116111278534,
0.7098985910415649,
0.536246120929718,
0.4038322865962982,
-0.5947630405426025,
0.7190040349960327,
0.2010194957256317,
-0.37452077865600586,
-0.37885573506355286,
0.015394086018204689,
-0.030205529183149338,
0.11817213147878647,
0.3587619662284851,
0.5454279780387878,
0.20086494088172913,
-0.31887903809547424,
0.4438347816467285,
-0.12790340185165405,
-0.30856528878211975,
-0.18297676742076874,
0.41282033920288086,
0.17018333077430725,
-0.1297006905078888,
0.5999950766563416,
0.03731321170926094,
-0.4463008642196655,
0.5160496830940247,
0.7339617013931274,
0.7223755121231079,
0.053323548287153244,
0.24870780110359192,
0.06582371890544891,
0.19625824689865112,
0.21700303256511688,
0.4109574258327484,
-0.06467176973819733,
-0.8688766956329346,
-0.47670361399650574,
-0.569398045539856,
-0.3901420533657074,
-0.28916648030281067,
-0.7227358222007751,
0.17372636497020721,
-0.48262932896614075,
0.2798270881175995,
0.22159184515476227,
-0.054441291838884354,
-0.5183983445167542,
0.3171210289001465,
0.5136640667915344,
0.7865920662879944,
-1.0749598741531372,
0.6809816360473633,
0.8659995794296265,
-0.03939130902290344,
-0.6741306185722351,
0.12004551291465759,
-0.03935782238841057,
-0.6434099078178406,
0.7742974758148193,
0.3647087812423706,
-0.040363214910030365,
-0.34880751371383667,
-0.26062220335006714,
-0.5504344701766968,
0.9945879578590393,
0.11491331458091736,
-0.38246405124664307,
-0.03884217143058777,
0.21819157898426056,
0.7522234320640564,
-0.5496006608009338,
0.24641045928001404,
0.12745681405067444,
0.19711339473724365,
0.1274396926164627,
-0.8501861095428467,
0.23417207598686218,
-0.440442830324173,
0.28979358077049255,
0.35832807421684265,
-0.4214387834072113,
0.7581955790519714,
0.03598548099398613,
-0.18041470646858215,
0.06816957145929337,
0.5808886885643005,
0.5789448022842407,
0.4639754891395569,
0.7375795841217041,
0.9552973508834839,
0.3419141173362732,
-0.23890303075313568,
0.5904006361961365,
0.15994274616241455,
0.43715131282806396,
0.9195461869239807,
-0.5824210047721863,
1.3826384544372559,
0.701481282711029,
-0.32304811477661133,
0.8930912613868713,
0.3323981761932373,
-0.1288444548845291,
0.710289478302002,
0.5331987738609314,
-0.009054258465766907,
0.022837722674012184,
0.13526974618434906,
-0.41901782155036926,
0.4685218632221222,
0.6303903460502625,
-0.41852566599845886,
-0.2194700837135315,
0.08371555805206299,
0.039006490260362625,
0.39628279209136963,
0.1559663712978363,
0.7758104205131531,
-0.01568162813782692,
-0.567579448223114,
0.2138814926147461,
0.16739943623542786,
0.7879448533058167,
-0.43793433904647827,
0.005666480865329504,
-0.12965700030326843,
0.310395210981369,
-0.18019773066043854,
-0.9881998896598816,
0.4698570966720581,
-0.10407504439353943,
0.10573434084653854,
-0.3657483756542206,
0.6886802315711975,
-0.48100030422210693,
-0.05268853157758713,
0.45272910594940186,
0.3970569670200348,
-0.19164568185806274,
0.14601074159145355,
-0.4502541422843933,
0.25862371921539307,
-0.14856307208538055,
-0.2911374568939209,
0.30415481328964233,
0.3810579776763916,
0.30538445711135864,
0.4334080219268799,
0.5801756381988525,
0.1277984082698822,
0.13910503685474396,
0.26884403824806213,
1.0083919763565063,
-0.8751010298728943,
-0.8977593779563904,
-0.8066278696060181,
0.6299077868461609,
-0.431308776140213,
-0.6177952885627747,
0.8419231176376343,
0.7443437576293945,
0.9663966298103333,
-0.2001357227563858,
0.736224889755249,
-0.37691667675971985,
0.7277323603630066,
-0.4249115288257599,
0.08196569234132767,
-0.4699558615684509,
0.415671169757843,
-0.5177386999130249,
-1.1381726264953613,
-0.6459212303161621,
0.7974209189414978,
-0.11727678030729294,
-0.048087939620018005,
0.9772599935531616,
0.3257676064968109,
-0.15376834571361542,
-0.060800183564424515,
0.14881622791290283,
-0.2805909216403961,
0.24243676662445068,
0.4764001667499542,
1.1416023969650269,
-0.4565107822418213,
0.4260941743850708,
-0.3732842206954956,
0.013956877402961254,
-0.1863172948360443,
-0.5016521215438843,
-0.7883202433586121,
-0.5447181463241577,
-0.39670488238334656,
-0.14243760704994202,
-0.0677882507443428,
0.8655751347541809,
0.9037728309631348,
-0.5983717441558838,
-0.06201334297657013,
-0.002611463889479637,
-0.34121963381767273,
-0.3665609359741211,
-0.32197219133377075,
0.5027371644973755,
-0.14388488233089447,
-0.6360265016555786,
0.6241960525512695,
0.502600371837616,
-0.13777421414852142,
-0.1584833711385727,
0.1456666886806488,
-0.32979506254196167,
0.07882373034954071,
0.6269691586494446,
-0.5288370847702026,
-0.6264667510986328,
-0.4904417097568512,
0.04794841632246971,
-0.17434094846248627,
-0.10341314226388931,
1.0409300327301025,
-0.6586219072341919,
0.18737472593784332,
0.8658434152603149,
0.4937087893486023,
0.5462667346000671,
0.03592061251401901,
0.3736281394958496,
-1.4989022016525269,
0.45377498865127563,
0.48664426803588867,
0.6509737372398376,
0.2204405814409256,
-0.28539881110191345,
0.6613260507583618,
0.3277502954006195,
-0.38250043988227844,
-0.7238959670066833,
0.04902870953083038,
-1.5468140840530396,
-0.4654020667076111,
1.1667922735214233,
-0.29350021481513977,
0.09270187467336655,
0.21634821593761444,
-0.30203109979629517,
-0.019710425287485123,
-0.27358564734458923,
0.5731168389320374,
0.6106297969818115,
-0.02341628633439541,
-0.07762832939624786,
0.04608044773340225,
0.06597109138965607,
0.7044065594673157,
-0.8768893480300903,
-0.3381895124912262,
0.6337428092956543,
0.29555124044418335,
0.4126860499382019,
0.5955826640129089,
-0.20484276115894318,
-0.09185660630464554,
0.49324190616607666,
-0.19672967493534088,
0.22786016762256622,
-0.09788264334201813,
0.10497500747442245,
0.7671326994895935,
-0.38491740822792053,
-0.4586917757987976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03092v1
|
FragRel: Exploiting Fragment-level Relations in the External Memory of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-05T09:31:37 | 2024-06-05T09:31:37 |
Xihang Yue, Linchao Zhu, Yi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To process contexts with unlimited length using Large Language Models (LLMs),
recent studies explore hierarchically managing the long text. Only several text
fragments are taken from the external memory and passed into the temporary
working memory, i.e., LLM's context window. However, existing approaches
isolatedly handle the text fragments without considering their structural
connections, thereby suffering limited capability on texts with intensive
inter-relations, e.g., coherent stories and code repositories. This work
attempts to resolve this by exploiting the fragment-level relations in external
memory. First, we formulate the fragment-level relations and present several
instantiations for different text types. Next, we introduce a relation-aware
fragment assessment criteria upon previous independent fragment assessment.
Finally, we present the fragment-connected Hierarchical Memory based LLM. We
validate the benefits of involving these relations on long story understanding,
repository-level code generation, and long-term chatting.
|
[
-0.47131961584091187,
-0.8799819350242615,
0.6216591000556946,
0.581307053565979,
-0.16390861570835114,
-0.048901889473199844,
-0.49860894680023193,
-0.808605432510376,
-0.0762866660952568,
0.3105165958404541,
-0.34008005261421204,
-0.2669425904750824,
-0.24684762954711914,
0.05838704854249954,
-0.5759516358375549,
0.9411490559577942,
-0.1532396674156189,
-0.09030196070671082,
-0.21457064151763916,
-0.348905086517334,
-0.399017333984375,
-0.7661734819412231,
-0.601350724697113,
-0.03233357146382332,
0.43194741010665894,
-0.03833813965320587,
0.5785614252090454,
0.5834247469902039,
0.3511205017566681,
0.33306992053985596,
-0.4516502022743225,
-0.07900147140026093,
-0.7568719983100891,
0.3723055422306061,
-0.32344987988471985,
-0.35318610072135925,
-0.37038764357566833,
-0.27119311690330505,
0.9196791052818298,
0.517086386680603,
-0.044562291353940964,
-0.0046510701067745686,
0.15414248406887054,
0.7364839315414429,
-0.5396391153335571,
0.43429315090179443,
-0.6452641487121582,
0.1226523220539093,
-0.13421152532100677,
-0.07556027919054031,
-0.6026355624198914,
-0.21332623064517975,
0.18826518952846527,
-0.2735512852668762,
-0.2043893039226532,
0.01253356970846653,
0.7046642899513245,
-0.0854986235499382,
-0.5401310920715332,
-0.6396498084068298,
-0.8293973207473755,
0.7777419686317444,
-0.4422999322414398,
0.33556967973709106,
0.30507564544677734,
0.18897570669651031,
-0.2184547483921051,
-0.6891486644744873,
-0.17245255410671234,
-0.30137187242507935,
-0.2622438073158264,
-0.1720447540283203,
-0.05870162323117256,
0.22924751043319702,
0.15324819087982178,
0.9064003825187683,
-0.2573045492172241,
-0.11724167317152023,
-0.5591769218444824,
-0.13874869048595428,
0.42474570870399475,
0.36739856004714966,
0.4626864790916443,
-0.05609859898686409,
-0.7284553050994873,
0.4840630888938904,
-0.9049727320671082,
-0.14265330135822296,
-0.22547848522663116,
0.2448299378156662,
0.04194221273064613,
0.4713013172149658,
0.07157747447490692,
0.6333004236221313,
0.060801126062870026,
-0.32187291979789734,
0.04531372711062431,
-0.47433313727378845,
-0.5326365828514099,
-0.08193641901016235,
0.7650782465934753,
-0.10592371225357056,
0.0977705866098404,
-0.2364715337753296,
-0.18740451335906982,
-0.3817245364189148,
0.08412269502878189,
-0.8680235147476196,
-0.0031258119270205498,
0.3772338032722473,
-0.46694880723953247,
-0.1318015307188034,
-0.3104989230632782,
-0.7585157752037048,
-0.1452418714761734,
-0.06499255448579788,
0.5475921034812927,
-0.6837146878242493,
-0.027037210762500763,
-0.1691199541091919,
0.13714398443698883,
-0.11368297785520554,
0.2426498383283615,
-0.7178348898887634,
0.3845374882221222,
0.6621598601341248,
1.102335810661316,
-0.1449529081583023,
-0.5033192038536072,
-0.5578681230545044,
0.6437438726425171,
-0.33871889114379883,
0.5058957934379578,
-0.5807552337646484,
-0.44284966588020325,
0.24304533004760742,
0.021965626627206802,
0.17739887535572052,
-0.3713187575340271,
0.21963073313236237,
-0.7329121232032776,
0.6835873126983643,
-0.05791690945625305,
-0.7376363277435303,
-0.14279380440711975,
0.21818657219409943,
-0.7665922045707703,
1.0723031759262085,
0.24132689833641052,
-0.8349364995956421,
0.08858092129230499,
-0.4368011951446533,
-0.5110646486282349,
-0.08236807584762573,
-0.14848966896533966,
0.0635986477136612,
0.2777126729488373,
0.13122215867042542,
0.45821645855903625,
-0.2850900888442993,
0.40089958906173706,
-0.060916319489479065,
-0.24225255846977234,
0.12646286189556122,
-0.1451260894536972,
0.7457795739173889,
0.1881428062915802,
0.10310662537813187,
0.3283896744251251,
-0.4166752099990845,
-0.36876848340034485,
-0.13628754019737244,
-0.8288638591766357,
-0.6527271866798401,
0.1088072881102562,
-0.25852617621421814,
0.48163220286369324,
0.5030466318130493,
-0.2776239216327667,
0.27258583903312683,
-0.3693099617958069,
0.47726890444755554,
0.8126951456069946,
0.06231110170483589,
0.8219841718673706,
-0.19469088315963745,
0.4557875990867615,
0.15418805181980133,
0.1083054170012474,
-0.8199964761734009,
-0.05348183214664459,
-0.6840205788612366,
-0.39077797532081604,
0.19212326407432556,
0.24330605566501617,
-0.8086585402488708,
0.3442206084728241,
-0.3011067807674408,
-0.15177087485790253,
-0.0058572604320943356,
0.12058912217617035,
0.35171324014663696,
0.34866437315940857,
0.28027066588401794,
-0.2330794632434845,
-0.2612980604171753,
-0.8343645334243774,
-0.1439436674118042,
-0.2908066213130951,
-0.02990877442061901,
0.34675854444503784,
0.3986472487449646,
-0.009871220216155052,
0.8507548570632935,
-0.5283668637275696,
-0.48413029313087463,
-0.36903658509254456,
-0.17263737320899963,
0.09180037677288055,
0.3519708514213562,
0.47129806876182556,
-0.608213484287262,
-0.534754753112793,
-0.14225703477859497,
-0.7566496729850769,
0.10747423022985458,
-0.3706780970096588,
-0.2627265155315399,
0.474069207906723,
0.8683979511260986,
-0.63365638256073,
-0.009181276895105839,
0.8820778131484985,
-0.49730613827705383,
0.32888564467430115,
-0.19412557780742645,
0.026469433680176735,
-1.2196558713912964,
-0.16457028687000275,
0.09424494951963425,
-0.617011308670044,
-0.5347426533699036,
0.4412137269973755,
0.10968559235334396,
-0.008816471323370934,
-0.5351883172988892,
0.6699226498603821,
-1.0130711793899536,
-0.20268939435482025,
-0.2579173445701599,
0.15256069600582123,
-0.16693362593650818,
0.5003277063369751,
0.10681907832622528,
0.6996443271636963,
0.5062714219093323,
-0.47056707739830017,
0.12275809794664383,
0.049667228013277054,
-0.5085715055465698,
0.2850300669670105,
-0.2861591577529907,
-0.11275498569011688,
-0.10425284504890442,
0.54631507396698,
-0.8324739933013916,
-0.2004638910293579,
0.05526495724916458,
-0.1300356388092041,
0.37671083211898804,
-0.48981574177742004,
-0.6926013827323914,
0.07009156048297882,
-0.3413107991218567,
0.56309574842453,
0.5097959041595459,
-0.6553802490234375,
0.8205798268318176,
0.6120989918708801,
-0.5122091770172119,
-0.3956325948238373,
-0.707781970500946,
0.03497079014778137,
-0.5228648781776428,
-0.7872589826583862,
0.24128349125385284,
-0.08446956425905228,
-0.4221176505088806,
-0.049024272710084915,
-0.035926416516304016,
-0.49567940831184387,
-0.21470385789871216,
0.3446250259876251,
0.1330532431602478,
-0.36889150738716125,
0.3832310140132904,
0.27637922763824463,
-0.024309752508997917,
0.06487300246953964,
0.09504763036966324,
0.7033810615539551,
-0.05588262155652046,
-0.011548280715942383,
-0.12280678004026413,
0.5696690082550049,
0.6287838816642761,
0.10551600903272629,
0.9810943603515625,
0.19537991285324097,
-0.4538174867630005,
-0.2506289482116699,
-0.4397278428077698,
0.08050864934921265,
-0.5153748989105225,
0.5067345499992371,
-0.4671332538127899,
-1.3492013216018677,
0.5219135880470276,
-0.19087764620780945,
0.04794416204094887,
0.23132188618183136,
0.6814241409301758,
0.2356952279806137,
0.42615798115730286,
0.7863096594810486,
-0.6435331702232361,
0.5756944417953491,
0.26313549280166626,
0.050513703376054764,
-0.9553239345550537,
-0.16032814979553223,
-0.1211700290441513,
-0.14350606501102448,
-0.20539230108261108,
-0.7882080674171448,
0.31796735525131226,
0.5943849682807922,
-0.26336681842803955,
0.3661188781261444,
-0.08540832996368408,
0.807211697101593,
0.06010523438453674,
-0.18990632891654968,
0.7219427227973938,
0.08745147287845612,
0.03756020963191986,
-0.0397358313202858,
-0.5532089471817017,
-0.18373045325279236,
0.5937312841415405,
0.7486169934272766,
0.7750305533409119,
0.13045498728752136,
0.6115795969963074,
0.008059527724981308,
0.4177960157394409,
-0.6926785707473755,
0.6576179265975952,
0.10767637938261032,
-0.8154032826423645,
-0.2445121705532074,
-0.5979981422424316,
-0.7683632969856262,
0.651530385017395,
0.19256597757339478,
-1.028913140296936,
0.004487148951739073,
0.013959922827780247,
-0.08748111873865128,
0.3017708361148834,
-0.5019625425338745,
0.5073259472846985,
-0.06311125308275223,
-0.45297911763191223,
-0.4326411485671997,
-0.534220278263092,
0.6242712140083313,
-0.12741968035697937,
0.3216855525970459,
0.050782762467861176,
-0.23326367139816284,
0.5296396017074585,
-0.17303773760795593,
0.7460212111473083,
0.12186285108327866,
-0.6323539614677429,
0.40887656807899475,
0.7602469325065613,
0.438832551240921,
0.2838883697986603,
-0.05180404707789421,
0.22038786113262177,
-0.06330051273107529,
-0.35453230142593384,
-0.1619451344013214,
1.187366008758545,
-0.2617054879665375,
-0.5329345464706421,
-0.6101765036582947,
-0.7979952096939087,
-0.3837551474571228,
0.1482602208852768,
0.030706288293004036,
0.5770641565322876,
-0.3424944281578064,
0.15479415655136108,
0.3890775144100189,
-0.3870646059513092,
0.9233357310295105,
0.48500174283981323,
-0.8689528107643127,
-0.2806713879108429,
0.6942871809005737,
-0.12955911457538605,
0.5230065584182739,
0.40971773862838745,
0.027437495067715645,
-0.1098642498254776,
-0.4035376012325287,
-0.43216490745544434,
0.1771111935377121,
-0.5606699585914612,
-0.22943639755249023,
-0.5716158151626587,
-0.19692374765872955,
0.11739645898342133,
-0.26102033257484436,
-0.2764028310775757,
-0.29987505078315735,
-0.11574159562587738,
-0.11223665624856949,
0.3692178726196289,
0.747614324092865,
-0.1257065087556839,
0.08317609876394272,
-1.0780280828475952,
0.2637521028518677,
0.07939105480909348,
0.2951712906360626,
0.4125688970088959,
-0.37964388728141785,
-0.4531507194042206,
-0.1999019980430603,
-0.038858987390995026,
-0.7109721302986145,
0.5164821743965149,
0.10199154913425446,
0.09158820658922195,
0.345714271068573,
-0.36042076349258423,
0.8634334802627563,
-0.6507172584533691,
0.9431630969047546,
0.11405104398727417,
-1.0953729152679443,
0.22716377675533295,
-0.5819542407989502,
0.34072640538215637,
0.46448659896850586,
0.591926634311676,
-0.5644756555557251,
-0.5374013781547546,
-0.26621147990226746,
-1.1421842575073242,
0.7730978727340698,
0.22129851579666138,
0.33925047516822815,
-0.13162389397621155,
0.19830523431301117,
0.015375468879938126,
0.21929053962230682,
-1.1136952638626099,
-0.06776399165391922,
0.46800345182418823,
0.03824011981487274,
0.1327914297580719,
-0.5354553461074829,
-0.27420639991760254,
-0.19797390699386597,
0.3074093759059906,
0.09224110841751099,
0.18461382389068604,
0.07597939670085907,
-0.3551689088344574,
-0.02243760973215103,
0.32789164781570435,
0.31304410099983215,
0.927958071231842,
0.06673082709312439,
0.19208617508411407,
0.3401715159416199,
-0.22932471334934235,
-0.04369926452636719,
-0.139325350522995,
0.12840643525123596,
-0.10339613258838654,
0.5693941116333008,
0.16715583205223083,
0.2637450397014618,
-0.8443049788475037,
0.5349680185317993,
-0.04173608496785164,
0.19965901970863342,
-0.3416500687599182,
-0.22897475957870483,
0.5195246338844299,
0.4162498414516449,
0.35226112604141235,
-0.3110813498497009,
-0.04637362062931061,
-0.9912665486335754,
0.19981276988983154,
0.26527488231658936,
-0.6574943661689758,
-0.3012976348400116,
0.2561275362968445,
0.22814777493476868,
0.09101101011037827,
0.5695891976356506,
-0.06146298348903656,
-0.3264700770378113,
0.33919763565063477,
0.8757690787315369,
0.563560962677002,
-0.27074289321899414,
-0.04510311037302017,
0.26106640696525574,
0.12362480163574219,
-0.17985649406909943,
0.14057639241218567,
-0.00297285127453506,
-0.454559326171875,
-0.8496036529541016,
-0.8084647059440613,
0.12381116300821304,
0.24115459620952606,
-0.47776278853416443,
-0.04802944138646126,
-0.3873642086982727,
0.28733697533607483,
-0.5460063815116882,
-0.30995211005210876,
-0.0614427886903286,
0.017895951867103577,
0.08377247303724289,
1.1869624853134155,
-0.5939364433288574,
1.0911682844161987,
0.17944210767745972,
-0.34705594182014465,
-0.536675214767456,
0.27152153849601746,
-0.03365018591284752,
-0.5423030257225037,
0.7949862480163574,
0.057747095823287964,
-0.07740091532468796,
-0.3557175397872925,
-0.2386361062526703,
-0.8324596285820007,
0.8940466642379761,
0.2686299681663513,
-0.8289785385131836,
-0.274944931268692,
-0.14392738044261932,
0.69523686170578,
-0.43999382853507996,
-0.10924435406923294,
0.2879926562309265,
0.15272420644760132,
-0.12816721200942993,
-0.8806986808776855,
0.41835901141166687,
0.05547207221388817,
-0.019399289041757584,
0.7554560899734497,
-0.8298081755638123,
0.9509154558181763,
0.014756102114915848,
-0.46768003702163696,
0.31828436255455017,
0.9340803623199463,
0.22076013684272766,
0.039592862129211426,
0.40905797481536865,
0.47479358315467834,
0.3543822467327118,
0.18236248195171356,
1.0680161714553833,
-0.6016170382499695,
0.35154858231544495,
1.460397720336914,
-0.24909240007400513,
1.0128610134124756,
0.5232115983963013,
-0.0379243940114975,
0.6585703492164612,
0.352844774723053,
0.3708375096321106,
0.4282950162887573,
0.17392674088478088,
-0.7329134941101074,
-0.013032572343945503,
0.07398869842290878,
-0.47139090299606323,
-0.015852604061365128,
0.5695086717605591,
-0.7459532022476196,
-0.35972413420677185,
-0.1357787847518921,
0.32674455642700195,
-0.05758928135037422,
-0.39734771847724915,
0.9438801407814026,
0.44182220101356506,
-0.458555668592453,
0.2689976394176483,
0.17170366644859314,
0.6601950526237488,
-0.530353307723999,
0.26985254883766174,
-0.23748116195201874,
0.1330268234014511,
-0.1510632187128067,
-0.8035486340522766,
0.4965225160121918,
0.12010879069566727,
-0.13735879957675934,
-0.130949929356575,
0.7048474550247192,
-0.7858368158340454,
-0.2757728397846222,
0.6286661624908447,
0.4779137670993805,
-0.09282024204730988,
-0.1569661647081375,
-0.3001805245876312,
0.15211696922779083,
-0.06723989546298981,
-0.36248981952667236,
0.8125127553939819,
0.7324894666671753,
-0.06492483615875244,
0.643826425075531,
0.38567841053009033,
0.053146421909332275,
0.01097634993493557,
-0.23909851908683777,
1.0979779958724976,
-0.9058987498283386,
-0.47944217920303345,
-1.1661232709884644,
0.3592130243778229,
0.053220536559820175,
-0.2868768870830536,
0.8365108966827393,
0.8190687894821167,
0.6034669280052185,
0.005146454554051161,
0.622023344039917,
-0.12101417779922485,
0.22846774756908417,
-0.6227556467056274,
0.4190759062767029,
-0.30480605363845825,
0.2766105830669403,
-0.2444676160812378,
-1.013576626777649,
-0.11036043614149094,
0.3870697319507599,
-0.2943863272666931,
-0.2080758512020111,
0.9465895295143127,
0.5162843465805054,
-0.3151604235172272,
-0.06637566536664963,
0.19062276184558868,
0.4518001973628998,
0.25296059250831604,
0.9794948101043701,
1.0379215478897095,
-0.04759341478347778,
0.7539106607437134,
-0.11595947295427322,
-0.09875407069921494,
0.007368247024714947,
-0.8719453811645508,
-1.0874727964401245,
-0.7071840763092041,
-0.00897219218313694,
-0.4512248635292053,
-0.01613474264740944,
0.7030426263809204,
0.5681502819061279,
-0.32500964403152466,
-0.5003465414047241,
-0.040620818734169006,
0.004314712714403868,
0.286586731672287,
-0.2882923185825348,
0.3307487964630127,
-0.3221927583217621,
-0.7515421509742737,
0.6560062170028687,
0.7027914524078369,
0.03928745165467262,
-0.5397056341171265,
0.0840674415230751,
-0.09090229123830795,
0.15392526984214783,
1.1481255292892456,
0.125286266207695,
-0.4093882441520691,
-0.17397768795490265,
-0.44190219044685364,
-0.20401699841022491,
0.248594269156456,
1.1189801692962646,
-0.7562212944030762,
0.09553533792495728,
0.8302311301231384,
0.34434211254119873,
0.46144410967826843,
0.1911502331495285,
0.8073088526725769,
-0.7397107481956482,
0.4025711119174957,
0.1806514710187912,
0.47840845584869385,
0.1393875777721405,
-0.3414853513240814,
0.34727150201797485,
-0.3527829945087433,
-0.624711275100708,
-0.7533998489379883,
0.4817050099372864,
-0.9031839966773987,
-0.8568549752235413,
1.3336867094039917,
-0.35683274269104004,
-0.2492574155330658,
-0.09700680524110794,
-0.24983108043670654,
-0.23758846521377563,
-0.5611013770103455,
0.7948281168937683,
0.8259459137916565,
-0.3030381500720978,
-0.009119447320699692,
-0.4673229455947876,
0.6381517052650452,
0.0763346329331398,
-0.9142932891845703,
0.22630807757377625,
0.7913394570350647,
0.32001999020576477,
0.2653428018093109,
0.8629302978515625,
-0.517457902431488,
-0.24208880960941315,
-0.1742408573627472,
-0.41251885890960693,
0.0923612043261528,
-0.5799150466918945,
-0.48652011156082153,
0.6565249562263489,
0.008937042206525803,
0.1687583327293396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03079v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03079v1
|
Cryptocurrency Frauds for Dummies: How ChatGPT introduces us to fraud?
| 2024-06-05T09:09:32 | 2024-06-05T09:09:32 |
Wail Zellagui, Abdessamad Imine, Yamina Tadjeddine
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advances in the field of large language models (LLMs), particularly
the ChatGPT family, have given rise to a powerful and versatile machine
interlocutor, packed with knowledge and challenging our understanding of
learning. This interlocutor is a double-edged sword: it can be harnessed for a
wide variety of beneficial tasks, but it can also be used to cause harm. This
study explores the complicated interaction between ChatGPT and the growing
problem of cryptocurrency fraud. Although ChatGPT is known for its adaptability
and ethical considerations when used for harmful purposes, we highlight the
deep connection that may exist between ChatGPT and fraudulent actions in the
volatile cryptocurrency ecosystem. Based on our categorization of
cryptocurrency frauds, we show how to influence outputs, bypass ethical terms,
and achieve specific fraud goals by manipulating ChatGPT prompts. Furthermore,
our findings emphasize the importance of realizing that ChatGPT could be a
valuable instructor even for novice fraudsters, as well as understanding and
safely deploying complex language models, particularly in the context of
cryptocurrency frauds. Finally, our study underlines the importance of using
LLMs responsibly and ethically in the digital currency sector, identifying
potential risks and resolving ethical issues. It should be noted that our work
is not intended to encourage and promote fraud, but rather to raise awareness
of the risks of fraud associated with the use of ChatGPT.
|
[
-0.038117747753858566,
-1.1252855062484741,
0.3259919583797455,
-0.10264495760202408,
-0.4516959488391876,
0.5751692056655884,
0.054262060672044754,
-0.5983620285987854,
0.13150882720947266,
0.8760890960693359,
-0.3505895435810089,
-0.07973939180374146,
-0.885526716709137,
-0.3818305730819702,
-0.781083345413208,
1.676361083984375,
0.13542774319648743,
0.16784627735614777,
0.1316521316766739,
0.4199675917625427,
-0.2551405727863312,
-0.9549533128738403,
-1.0466108322143555,
-0.30901265144348145,
0.39781975746154785,
0.2594051659107208,
0.7345970273017883,
-0.04137277230620384,
0.7496313452720642,
0.380523145198822,
0.0949808731675148,
-0.040478236973285675,
-0.7579655051231384,
-0.05119890719652176,
-0.09376306086778641,
-0.5415834784507751,
-0.24884070456027985,
-0.02232389524579048,
-0.18793319165706635,
0.331552654504776,
-0.5418358445167542,
-0.03446713835000992,
0.1593569666147232,
0.7002952098846436,
-0.40565168857574463,
0.13735441863536835,
-0.8047668933868408,
-0.10238096117973328,
-0.3281863033771515,
-0.5825910568237305,
-0.19286100566387177,
-0.29283764958381653,
0.18538863956928253,
-0.48570770025253296,
0.19280463457107544,
0.0033537251874804497,
0.4119402766227722,
0.11362141370773315,
-0.3602970242500305,
-0.9933427572250366,
-0.8192765712738037,
0.3053951561450958,
-0.31854408979415894,
-0.05240011587738991,
0.3461897671222687,
0.34512564539909363,
-0.20804698765277863,
-0.8856096267700195,
-0.5053966641426086,
-0.21518592536449432,
0.12971298396587372,
0.08031398802995682,
-0.259275883436203,
0.4017356038093567,
0.37828943133354187,
0.604701042175293,
-0.30075886845588684,
-0.07003618031740189,
-0.7199270129203796,
-0.39961448311805725,
0.45891866087913513,
0.22656458616256714,
0.5532634854316711,
0.03186700865626335,
-0.4776928722858429,
-0.08226950466632843,
-0.9653659462928772,
-0.10789838433265686,
1.1193156242370605,
0.15492774546146393,
-0.11729668825864792,
0.5381352305412292,
0.38136768341064453,
0.4033811092376709,
-0.12912310659885406,
-0.29834339022636414,
-0.33479470014572144,
-0.3132915496826172,
-0.1507425606250763,
0.45572951436042786,
0.6779033541679382,
0.1969885379076004,
0.626228392124176,
-0.05768626928329468,
-0.31395286321640015,
-0.02634432353079319,
0.1923425793647766,
-0.8156662583351135,
-0.33244141936302185,
0.18913419544696808,
-0.28022727370262146,
-0.7623469829559326,
0.25694650411605835,
-0.8079360127449036,
-0.520259439945221,
-0.16195352375507355,
0.5502817034721375,
-0.24378511309623718,
-0.17642483115196228,
0.40641266107559204,
-0.23423589766025543,
0.043199095875024796,
0.3003365397453308,
-0.893896758556366,
0.7853897213935852,
1.0671720504760742,
0.5343155264854431,
0.14633159339427948,
-0.22155487537384033,
-0.6056231260299683,
-0.05356616526842117,
-0.20936256647109985,
0.5596898794174194,
-0.31908878684043884,
-0.5161547064781189,
0.1662372350692749,
-0.18065854907035828,
0.0587417334318161,
-0.3868315815925598,
0.37315472960472107,
-0.7803953289985657,
0.46170446276664734,
-0.23099419474601746,
-0.29447177052497864,
-0.30524805188179016,
0.17629416286945343,
-0.4202714264392853,
0.6630404591560364,
-0.05892128869891167,
-1.0674822330474854,
-0.06326468288898468,
-0.5629294514656067,
-0.3831288814544678,
0.20848074555397034,
-0.09430737048387527,
-0.12495164573192596,
-0.06475908309221268,
-0.2745702564716339,
0.1808672696352005,
-0.3137756884098053,
0.2287716269493103,
-0.25898829102516174,
-0.7039388418197632,
0.9139623641967773,
-1.1776155233383179,
1.01773202419281,
-0.11628933995962143,
-0.2562548518180847,
-0.24759842455387115,
-0.4360578656196594,
-0.2928459346294403,
0.1351780891418457,
-0.14049866795539856,
-0.3994673788547516,
-0.11606637388467789,
0.19213023781776428,
0.275429904460907,
0.3438366651535034,
-0.2013837695121765,
0.22236929833889008,
-0.3012518286705017,
0.7852495312690735,
0.9443563222885132,
0.25232070684432983,
-0.03990594670176506,
-0.28527766466140747,
0.6145103573799133,
-0.17450468242168427,
0.263094961643219,
-0.22354434430599213,
-0.43972811102867126,
-0.6155738830566406,
-0.03732496500015259,
0.4929979145526886,
1.0737075805664062,
-0.52009516954422,
0.12522125244140625,
-0.10127521306276321,
-0.2693191468715668,
-0.37906816601753235,
-0.1170976534485817,
0.0001734970574034378,
0.393652081489563,
-0.09825686365365982,
-0.23802487552165985,
-0.2065214365720749,
-0.8332160115242004,
-0.48435282707214355,
-0.31890904903411865,
0.12549351155757904,
0.1604020744562149,
0.6336817145347595,
-0.22477993369102478,
0.5419979691505432,
-0.24142830073833466,
-0.06448628753423691,
0.08564508706331253,
0.07467316836118698,
0.0246890839189291,
0.47538748383522034,
0.2320663332939148,
-0.7569224238395691,
-0.30833950638771057,
0.15365014970302582,
-0.29804664850234985,
0.19204317033290863,
-0.5039584040641785,
0.11214674264192581,
-0.0371059849858284,
0.42888978123664856,
-0.6732245683670044,
0.4500456750392914,
0.5391649007797241,
-0.34641551971435547,
0.6539915204048157,
-0.41628485918045044,
0.2968539893627167,
-0.9161105751991272,
-0.14223673939704895,
-0.5130652785301208,
-0.27437520027160645,
-0.675093948841095,
-0.18561479449272156,
-0.15335561335086823,
-0.1499520093202591,
-0.33859390020370483,
0.27379852533340454,
-0.018149521201848984,
-0.018603820353746414,
-0.4891657829284668,
0.3539084792137146,
-0.28522664308547974,
0.2219347357749939,
-0.3344684839248657,
0.8735523819923401,
0.6962951421737671,
-0.24538767337799072,
0.6137096285820007,
-0.022647349163889885,
-0.36493000388145447,
0.5621320605278015,
-0.7297268509864807,
0.2808757722377777,
0.11238253861665726,
0.07245785742998123,
-0.9410626292228699,
-0.2278500199317932,
0.933457612991333,
-0.5643277764320374,
0.4053420424461365,
-0.3411386013031006,
-0.8617581725120544,
-0.06462519615888596,
-0.12014319002628326,
0.31848472356796265,
0.5431459546089172,
-0.43048417568206787,
0.4024512767791748,
0.3079749643802643,
-0.29428601264953613,
-0.9902076721191406,
-0.8513147234916687,
0.39551201462745667,
-0.630995512008667,
-0.590296745300293,
0.17421308159828186,
-0.21277888119220734,
-0.5145500302314758,
-0.25470206141471863,
-0.03056522086262703,
0.06702717393636703,
0.48518773913383484,
0.34146156907081604,
0.4311019778251648,
0.07695990055799484,
0.1167307198047638,
-0.1209699735045433,
-0.4269929528236389,
0.23216129839420319,
-0.21859672665596008,
0.7001188397407532,
-0.21726348996162415,
-0.6920871734619141,
-0.5270437598228455,
0.39080607891082764,
0.5264665484428406,
0.014957343228161335,
0.6195566654205322,
0.18421204388141632,
-0.24022646248340607,
0.04000018909573555,
-0.5517779588699341,
-0.2821836769580841,
-0.5512179732322693,
0.3277947008609772,
-0.1065143272280693,
-1.0777161121368408,
0.6672132015228271,
-0.07131902128458023,
-0.04215352237224579,
0.09242938458919525,
0.5917859673500061,
-0.01507433783262968,
0.8220577836036682,
0.8484150767326355,
-0.08892330527305603,
0.5614871382713318,
-0.05919978395104408,
0.5236860513687134,
-0.44608867168426514,
-0.23794575035572052,
-0.3963943123817444,
0.045225515961647034,
-1.0906962156295776,
-0.5208296775817871,
0.18556785583496094,
0.19644920527935028,
-0.398140549659729,
-0.03195808455348015,
-0.15320445597171783,
0.6070590615272522,
0.4292367696762085,
-0.07853285223245621,
0.640585720539093,
0.40110161900520325,
0.21772384643554688,
0.05066878721117973,
-0.7332906723022461,
-0.6698009967803955,
0.9235483407974243,
0.30726486444473267,
0.9487203359603882,
-0.011695018969476223,
0.7384741306304932,
0.3072458505630493,
0.34877631068229675,
-0.8621345162391663,
0.26926273107528687,
0.006718211341649294,
-0.5916932821273804,
-0.014027680270373821,
-0.29609212279319763,
-0.8526110649108887,
0.14043723046779633,
0.16889867186546326,
-0.6414056420326233,
-0.0335996076464653,
0.16442854702472687,
-0.3027651607990265,
0.4826369881629944,
-0.4475184679031372,
0.8263359069824219,
-0.5616856813430786,
-0.2542327642440796,
-0.3537985384464264,
-0.47031739354133606,
0.5069399476051331,
-0.3244134187698364,
0.49308356642723083,
-0.06512204557657242,
-0.29828107357025146,
0.42108672857284546,
-0.6539000868797302,
1.212193250656128,
0.30270156264305115,
-0.40377017855644226,
0.48688751459121704,
0.33816441893577576,
0.9200021028518677,
0.2756727933883667,
0.2629212439060211,
0.3651198148727417,
-0.06936416029930115,
-0.2586425840854645,
-0.42794284224510193,
0.7597842812538147,
-0.6297593116760254,
-0.7219025492668152,
-0.5530511140823364,
-0.28177762031555176,
0.017275482416152954,
0.04345524311065674,
0.31730782985687256,
0.2928222715854645,
-0.33900192379951477,
-0.10128772258758545,
0.7588104605674744,
-0.1200060248374939,
0.30249911546707153,
0.3496379852294922,
-0.12412116676568985,
-0.4738626778125763,
1.1280301809310913,
-0.08131009340286255,
0.5509676933288574,
0.2826961576938629,
0.27983883023262024,
-0.004598670173436403,
-0.4463381767272949,
-0.16925020515918732,
0.3790355622768402,
-0.8210206627845764,
0.01917475089430809,
-0.4128791391849518,
-0.22694359719753265,
-0.1075138971209526,
-0.2392052710056305,
-0.3503395617008209,
-0.4202069342136383,
-0.271705687046051,
-0.06829803436994553,
0.6016233563423157,
0.5740261673927307,
-0.1507200002670288,
0.6543645858764648,
-0.6542525887489319,
0.016096459701657295,
0.5978950262069702,
0.3723001778125763,
-0.2569303810596466,
-0.5533069372177124,
0.14185942709445953,
0.21635745465755463,
-0.2161378413438797,
-0.901589035987854,
0.007667228579521179,
-0.2632080912590027,
0.41083967685699463,
0.5382120609283447,
-0.15665215253829956,
0.7219406366348267,
-0.2919064462184906,
0.6542404294013977,
0.29945164918899536,
-0.991890013217926,
0.17934633791446686,
-0.42717626690864563,
-0.3452540338039398,
0.4165322184562683,
0.41039660573005676,
-1.3313589096069336,
-0.2633078694343567,
-1.0388137102127075,
-0.7667146921157837,
0.5882632732391357,
0.44406381249427795,
0.5184510350227356,
0.10511873662471771,
0.21736332774162292,
0.3103591501712799,
0.4886247217655182,
-0.9258562326431274,
-0.38268253207206726,
-0.14676178991794586,
-0.002203673589974642,
0.14678922295570374,
-0.42814013361930847,
-0.39945608377456665,
0.3743581175804138,
0.715198278427124,
-0.00926500279456377,
0.0013378588482737541,
-0.17193658649921417,
-0.012398796156048775,
-0.08192465454339981,
0.13305014371871948,
0.47313761711120605,
0.5418119430541992,
0.3849197030067444,
0.10193148255348206,
0.08210621029138565,
-0.6268013715744019,
-0.15505853295326233,
0.11076997220516205,
-0.1649063378572464,
-0.3390543460845947,
0.3153381645679474,
0.5625830888748169,
0.42943620681762695,
-0.9623008966445923,
0.7790992856025696,
-0.18440456688404083,
-0.18755000829696655,
-0.6325150728225708,
0.010468957014381886,
0.07956796884536743,
0.33394286036491394,
0.26971080899238586,
0.3677123486995697,
0.2893681228160858,
-0.5684987306594849,
0.02287239022552967,
0.5826655626296997,
-0.4497980773448944,
-0.287692666053772,
0.3125072121620178,
0.23320487141609192,
-0.654017984867096,
0.7793288230895996,
0.17149819433689117,
-0.8186565041542053,
0.6709597706794739,
0.36894840002059937,
0.7603200674057007,
-0.18962855637073517,
0.19379527866840363,
-0.030025942251086235,
0.7275009155273438,
-0.2193307727575302,
0.01216301042586565,
-0.12065877765417099,
-0.7428703308105469,
-0.23326992988586426,
-0.17278645932674408,
-0.2960398495197296,
0.16724108159542084,
-0.1427682340145111,
0.45156368613243103,
-0.4289829730987549,
0.07149996608495712,
-0.19076058268547058,
-0.10961760580539703,
-0.37138763070106506,
-0.3121474087238312,
0.2821715176105499,
0.5547577142715454,
-0.5285398364067078,
0.5217539072036743,
0.1284380406141281,
-0.10744229704141617,
-0.16508302092552185,
0.16874125599861145,
0.05776180699467659,
-1.1032518148422241,
0.5715575814247131,
0.07346818596124649,
-0.35627251863479614,
-0.15696905553340912,
-0.6251764297485352,
-0.6717454195022583,
0.7761624455451965,
0.3805290758609772,
-0.6361938714981079,
0.17314030230045319,
0.6046096682548523,
0.3538069725036621,
-0.10866670310497284,
0.09420362114906311,
0.2946788966655731,
0.3624182939529419,
0.20143787562847137,
-0.7883386611938477,
-0.24534398317337036,
0.04971473664045334,
-0.16755995154380798,
0.4920646846294403,
-0.8254896402359009,
0.7479584813117981,
-0.3329332768917084,
-0.21088697016239166,
-0.039892006665468216,
0.07215578854084015,
0.26129472255706787,
0.1397644728422165,
0.4100341200828552,
0.12509086728096008,
0.9228102564811707,
-0.038641009479761124,
0.8947947025299072,
-0.36996182799339294,
0.5637627243995667,
0.8937047719955444,
-0.0452086478471756,
0.3218991458415985,
0.6440442204475403,
-0.23047137260437012,
0.3362056016921997,
0.7872306704521179,
-0.04278631880879402,
0.10161694884300232,
0.49345794320106506,
-0.4744134545326233,
-0.4540339410305023,
0.2880892753601074,
-0.30601292848587036,
0.47858747839927673,
0.8060659170150757,
-0.4527362287044525,
-0.05589393898844719,
0.01366781909018755,
0.2934594750404358,
-0.31042733788490295,
-0.16953569650650024,
0.496095210313797,
0.3193889558315277,
-0.24383683502674103,
-0.08264747262001038,
-0.015025399625301361,
0.7205929160118103,
-0.6922479867935181,
0.007000308949500322,
-0.006685514468699694,
0.1993650645017624,
-0.03950544819235802,
-0.46805110573768616,
0.11626936495304108,
-0.2216145396232605,
0.3082530200481415,
-0.2542336583137512,
0.9166341423988342,
-0.4082001745700836,
-0.43915894627571106,
0.07169713079929352,
0.31985676288604736,
0.28018155694007874,
-0.3643556535243988,
-0.9546130299568176,
-0.12350715696811676,
-0.009983906522393227,
-0.21452923119068146,
0.45281466841697693,
0.5366033315658569,
0.012251358479261398,
0.9066106081008911,
0.9074296951293945,
-0.0825573280453682,
-0.2077518105506897,
-0.2948603332042694,
0.5843866467475891,
-0.6920245289802551,
-0.47430676221847534,
-1.0761734247207642,
0.38378608226776123,
-0.09037275612354279,
-0.2005876898765564,
0.6597381234169006,
0.6569347977638245,
0.8451306223869324,
0.05582616478204727,
0.8641625046730042,
0.13512739539146423,
0.18792039155960083,
-0.45976001024246216,
0.799476683139801,
-0.215290367603302,
0.6663644909858704,
-0.1333034783601761,
-0.43719834089279175,
-0.01625535823404789,
0.48278889060020447,
-0.3566412925720215,
0.19505417346954346,
0.5413769483566284,
0.7545357942581177,
0.03296814113855362,
0.33932316303253174,
0.26993533968925476,
0.0716254934668541,
0.3178611695766449,
0.26120322942733765,
1.3518952131271362,
-0.6298319101333618,
1.0434424877166748,
-0.44705554842948914,
0.02578067220747471,
-0.47143808007240295,
-0.8230546116828918,
-0.8350465893745422,
-0.20619934797286987,
-0.5120497941970825,
-0.3928872346878052,
0.02891867235302925,
0.7106833457946777,
0.26123589277267456,
-0.4541589915752411,
-0.42268067598342896,
-0.08369810879230499,
0.3525962233543396,
-0.09013256430625916,
-0.20435459911823273,
0.162752166390419,
-0.016238775104284286,
-0.8309165239334106,
-0.16232344508171082,
0.38989076018333435,
0.4609605669975281,
-0.42996102571487427,
0.16719657182693481,
0.4967837631702423,
0.10835953801870346,
0.5620899796485901,
0.18177318572998047,
-0.7109456658363342,
-0.1227479800581932,
-0.12548942863941193,
-0.1749010682106018,
0.009546225890517235,
1.3927638530731201,
-0.5010736584663391,
0.21785132586956024,
0.23422496020793915,
0.4479157626628876,
0.3263692259788513,
-0.18156969547271729,
0.3593986928462982,
-0.10706675797700882,
0.09997361153364182,
0.30364131927490234,
0.20779858529567719,
0.21881423890590668,
-0.6620056629180908,
0.1625974178314209,
0.5826797485351562,
-0.6778895854949951,
-0.7413657903671265,
0.15944476425647736,
-0.9089841246604919,
-0.30855369567871094,
0.9021962881088257,
0.09306254237890244,
-0.15519964694976807,
-0.3119529187679291,
-0.5586068034172058,
-0.1614087074995041,
-0.2805618345737457,
1.0589171648025513,
0.8369110822677612,
-0.02747104875743389,
0.054964832961559296,
-1.0636812448501587,
0.5458284616470337,
-0.10316895693540573,
-0.7866665124893188,
0.5451809763908386,
0.255517840385437,
0.6953586339950562,
0.00017899238446261734,
0.617384672164917,
-0.3067309260368347,
0.40663206577301025,
0.09359262883663177,
-0.1567339152097702,
-0.014771622605621815,
0.09694661945104599,
-0.3386938273906708,
0.13043443858623505,
0.008621587418019772,
0.1658564805984497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03075v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03075v1
|
Towards Detecting LLMs Hallucination via Markov Chain-based Multi-agent Debate Framework
| 2024-06-05T08:59:45 | 2024-06-05T08:59:45 |
Xiaoxi Sun, Jinpeng Li, Yan Zhong, Dongyan Zhao, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advent of large language models (LLMs) has facilitated the development of
natural language text generation. It also poses unprecedented challenges, with
content hallucination emerging as a significant concern. Existing solutions
often involve expensive and complex interventions during the training process.
Moreover, some approaches emphasize problem disassembly while neglecting the
crucial validation process, leading to performance degradation or limited
applications. To overcome these limitations, we propose a Markov Chain-based
multi-agent debate verification framework to enhance hallucination detection
accuracy in concise claims. Our method integrates the fact-checking process,
including claim detection, evidence retrieval, and multi-agent verification. In
the verification stage, we deploy multiple agents through flexible Markov
Chain-based debates to validate individual claims, ensuring meticulous
verification outcomes. Experimental results across three generative tasks
demonstrate that our approach achieves significant improvements over baselines.
|
[
-0.47878292202949524,
-1.0780715942382812,
0.8834087252616882,
-0.02870245836675167,
-0.13240592181682587,
0.21687009930610657,
-0.17972981929779053,
-0.27912482619285583,
0.24560047686100006,
0.7199102640151978,
-0.6728381514549255,
-0.5946742296218872,
-0.5273122787475586,
0.4534655511379242,
-0.25148898363113403,
0.8721888065338135,
-0.08023646473884583,
-0.12663431465625763,
-0.251457542181015,
-0.0303608700633049,
-0.3631691336631775,
-0.5000126361846924,
-0.46768808364868164,
-0.3549049198627472,
0.5418593883514404,
0.16504886746406555,
0.46887460350990295,
0.375496506690979,
0.31899216771125793,
0.39787259697914124,
-0.04262411594390869,
0.9216030240058899,
-0.06277298182249069,
0.648426353931427,
-0.058150433003902435,
-0.35544058680534363,
-0.4103386104106903,
-0.19423140585422516,
0.625163197517395,
0.16984663903713226,
-0.5358725786209106,
-0.25367259979248047,
-0.08435820788145065,
0.622154176235199,
-0.7034454345703125,
-0.16711275279521942,
-1.1811572313308716,
0.07284709066152573,
-0.10999689251184464,
-0.5252389311790466,
-0.7080143690109253,
-0.3565453290939331,
0.0012761829420924187,
-0.04006033390760422,
0.1946459710597992,
0.01882699504494667,
0.916600227355957,
0.3718852996826172,
-0.6347886919975281,
-0.601750373840332,
-0.6901567578315735,
0.4561741352081299,
-0.6043938994407654,
0.2882348895072937,
0.38217097520828247,
0.28537532687187195,
-0.5970245003700256,
-0.45295530557632446,
-0.9126260280609131,
-0.48981812596321106,
0.14371950924396515,
-0.16731995344161987,
-0.09295669198036194,
0.1247229054570198,
0.2539370656013489,
0.16265282034873962,
-0.6659198999404907,
0.04845670983195305,
0.09701811522245407,
-0.4249608814716339,
0.42211276292800903,
0.11975514143705368,
0.28017714619636536,
-0.2693609893321991,
-0.3747694492340088,
0.09521806240081787,
-0.5873647332191467,
-0.45130103826522827,
0.5954985618591309,
0.356153279542923,
0.134512796998024,
0.7165441513061523,
-0.254637211561203,
0.37558066844940186,
-0.043166160583496094,
-0.2953695058822632,
0.22225534915924072,
-0.3233703672885895,
-0.20954467356204987,
0.29347264766693115,
0.7651383280754089,
0.13364672660827637,
-0.03941227123141289,
-0.22678719460964203,
-0.365091472864151,
0.32433226704597473,
0.4485107362270355,
-0.7559817433357239,
-0.11280138790607452,
0.564330518245697,
-0.2126447558403015,
-0.13403478264808655,
-0.16438797116279602,
-0.5505008101463318,
-0.8103043437004089,
-0.10234621912240982,
0.5159638524055481,
-0.31162551045417786,
-0.4194380044937134,
0.3574494421482086,
-0.005822567734867334,
0.09087693691253662,
0.4144574701786041,
-0.5621107220649719,
0.19366560876369476,
0.6233127117156982,
0.8159559965133667,
-0.195852130651474,
-0.2771669030189514,
-0.6215054392814636,
0.21353480219841003,
-0.41542506217956543,
1.2384098768234253,
-0.20191079378128052,
0.11296654492616653,
0.11144762486219406,
-0.035329949110746384,
-0.02182653918862343,
-0.7741202116012573,
0.44363144040107727,
-0.4025760889053345,
0.10129811614751816,
-0.13651736080646515,
-0.4420219659805298,
0.08495735377073288,
0.9226635694503784,
-0.8203837275505066,
0.9274894595146179,
-0.3197048008441925,
-0.8819581866264343,
0.4464810788631439,
-0.3927813172340393,
-0.5227529406547546,
-0.02499379776418209,
-0.4730314612388611,
-0.8502647280693054,
-0.17645026743412018,
0.3427479565143585,
0.49319392442703247,
-0.20541203022003174,
0.4712698757648468,
-0.1997179388999939,
-0.143332377076149,
0.6105729937553406,
-0.5411143898963928,
0.4487382173538208,
0.08757157623767853,
-0.6557343006134033,
0.3683561384677887,
-1.0943121910095215,
-0.3366703391075134,
0.058255765587091446,
-0.3234383463859558,
-0.08233899623155594,
0.28545835614204407,
-0.2206062227487564,
0.16128428280353546,
-0.2096768021583557,
-0.4198891520500183,
0.3375087380409241,
-0.21099328994750977,
0.12304804474115372,
0.7926106452941895,
0.3508976101875305,
-0.10160385072231293,
-0.5365917086601257,
0.42754656076431274,
0.407366007566452,
-0.05955592542886734,
-0.059942107647657394,
-0.38942626118659973,
-0.7852725386619568,
-0.47057610750198364,
-0.03134787082672119,
0.3613663911819458,
-1.2505810260772705,
0.6564180254936218,
0.020045023411512375,
-0.14240998029708862,
-0.44660240411758423,
-0.12189605087041855,
0.08403840661048889,
0.3280104398727417,
0.4239213466644287,
-0.13249805569648743,
-0.6729419827461243,
-0.7416411638259888,
-0.04766388237476349,
-0.43889787793159485,
-0.006242542061954737,
0.10799400508403778,
0.6211479902267456,
-0.5348591804504395,
0.6954013705253601,
-0.21641774475574493,
-0.3171199858188629,
-0.2698825001716614,
0.3334464430809021,
-0.01296774111688137,
0.3104166090488434,
0.031438760459423065,
-0.496594101190567,
-0.004495659843087196,
0.0260385163128376,
-0.7985928654670715,
0.10049012303352356,
-0.6279458403587341,
-0.011448852717876434,
0.8623136281967163,
0.265404611825943,
-0.833051323890686,
0.46901190280914307,
0.24745455384254456,
-0.43207794427871704,
0.8115097880363464,
-0.1867562234401703,
0.3606863021850586,
-0.949537992477417,
-0.23757457733154297,
-0.1837560534477234,
-0.4059261977672577,
-0.4441775679588318,
-0.10635891556739807,
-0.31363165378570557,
0.4117077887058258,
-0.28117382526397705,
-0.1069638803601265,
-0.5060042142868042,
0.05367930978536606,
-0.5040804147720337,
0.3675574064254761,
-0.15825973451137543,
0.4021588861942291,
0.17507900297641754,
0.5007110238075256,
0.4672395586967468,
-0.802844226360321,
0.3706507384777069,
0.0892043486237526,
-0.5222764015197754,
0.6763466596603394,
-0.3167368471622467,
0.19227246940135956,
-0.2614743113517761,
0.47712835669517517,
-1.1193273067474365,
-0.029549172148108482,
0.6076589822769165,
-0.3678692579269409,
-0.16625180840492249,
0.07656858116388321,
-0.8601685166358948,
-0.13648995757102966,
-0.3917142450809479,
0.09406135976314545,
0.06401453912258148,
-0.6885842680931091,
0.7236586213111877,
0.40977561473846436,
0.18556296825408936,
-0.6643064022064209,
-0.5228795409202576,
0.3971741199493408,
-0.19237856566905975,
-0.562947690486908,
0.14861075580120087,
-0.11979138106107712,
-0.31019356846809387,
-0.2749943733215332,
-0.2220267802476883,
0.042112138122320175,
0.17572692036628723,
0.09946255385875702,
0.17505046725273132,
-0.16415728628635406,
0.2810046970844269,
0.12076787650585175,
0.08091920614242554,
0.23840026557445526,
-0.29444828629493713,
0.6336230039596558,
-0.04726523905992508,
-0.5084007382392883,
-0.5538998246192932,
0.23322831094264984,
0.6267973184585571,
-0.10721036046743393,
0.7168684005737305,
0.6161577701568604,
-0.6747190356254578,
-0.6688513159751892,
-0.9647149443626404,
-0.4443477690219879,
-0.4648143947124481,
0.2995716631412506,
-0.5559315085411072,
-0.8318716883659363,
0.5028521418571472,
-0.3016952872276306,
-0.003082474460825324,
0.380065381526947,
0.9964410662651062,
0.2057092934846878,
0.884813666343689,
0.22040216624736786,
0.3321116864681244,
0.049991901963949203,
-0.04158531129360199,
0.18178778886795044,
-0.5616754293441772,
-0.6169414520263672,
-0.5931397676467896,
-0.06856676936149597,
-0.5934465527534485,
-0.47637873888015747,
0.23650312423706055,
-0.3256058096885681,
0.01466454565525055,
0.1394544243812561,
-0.5826858878135681,
0.5319032669067383,
-0.05276695638895035,
0.2479093223810196,
0.6225873231887817,
0.1898377388715744,
-0.32630598545074463,
0.008593411184847355,
-0.35406172275543213,
-0.8261057734489441,
0.7920176386833191,
0.3492982089519501,
0.5552108287811279,
0.4370814561843872,
0.7958778142929077,
0.5962525606155396,
0.18136002123355865,
-0.7085395455360413,
0.7931643724441528,
0.4557608962059021,
-0.5409275889396667,
-0.463054358959198,
-0.5168629884719849,
-1.0744073390960693,
0.7297528982162476,
-0.4783989489078522,
-0.8693400621414185,
0.07243901491165161,
-0.08281583338975906,
-0.2835344076156616,
0.5420812964439392,
-0.021879956126213074,
0.6800123453140259,
0.02251923829317093,
-0.3355567753314972,
-0.48167380690574646,
-0.42767900228500366,
0.5225718021392822,
0.15040473639965057,
0.1596539467573166,
-0.23213134706020355,
0.10255201905965805,
0.48288559913635254,
-0.5593200325965881,
0.7186823487281799,
0.04455993324518204,
-0.6097738742828369,
0.48221340775489807,
0.17472466826438904,
0.7069901823997498,
0.23830975592136383,
0.07628390192985535,
-0.21952097117900848,
-0.24981746077537537,
-0.02568681910634041,
-0.4355008602142334,
0.3682730495929718,
-0.5142486095428467,
-0.47060084342956543,
-0.6598081588745117,
-0.5272338390350342,
-0.12215053290128708,
-0.15205609798431396,
0.03840851038694382,
0.17087441682815552,
-0.28865981101989746,
-0.1408596634864807,
0.8345642685890198,
-0.1869398057460785,
0.3020612895488739,
0.3971245586872101,
-0.2879716753959656,
-0.5407829880714417,
0.9984157681465149,
-0.150270015001297,
0.008040228858590126,
0.13305529952049255,
0.08290936052799225,
-0.3599760830402374,
-0.7280452847480774,
-0.4030192792415619,
0.24112558364868164,
-0.7048045992851257,
-0.2198677659034729,
-1.0107744932174683,
-0.20822544395923615,
-0.3803611099720001,
0.2816139757633209,
-0.5189851522445679,
-0.21885758638381958,
-0.15144169330596924,
-0.08011622726917267,
0.1446777582168579,
0.9120105504989624,
-0.07084228843450546,
0.12259611487388611,
-0.47104841470718384,
0.755786120891571,
0.3706448972225189,
0.16158857941627502,
-0.056611500680446625,
-0.41933751106262207,
-0.04730718210339546,
-0.13226822018623352,
-0.6390937566757202,
-1.0371736288070679,
0.25986695289611816,
-0.17149008810520172,
0.5415593385696411,
0.493818074464798,
0.2546994984149933,
0.4809287190437317,
-0.48165634274482727,
0.7498787045478821,
0.10953763127326965,
-1.0555520057678223,
0.5222950577735901,
-0.07768916338682175,
-0.328696072101593,
0.40384674072265625,
0.3503887951374054,
-0.4261114299297333,
-0.7009053230285645,
-0.5159277319908142,
-0.7686880826950073,
0.4044490456581116,
0.4127829372882843,
-0.25678402185440063,
-0.2743847966194153,
0.20629481971263885,
0.14444896578788757,
0.2830890715122223,
-0.877355694770813,
-0.14990009367465973,
0.22037434577941895,
0.06059359014034271,
0.3293830454349518,
-0.3016308844089508,
-0.20853754878044128,
-0.10541579127311707,
0.8028786778450012,
-0.22676785290241241,
0.05254069343209267,
0.39479440450668335,
-0.3908143937587738,
-0.00679682195186615,
0.5849621891975403,
0.8006189465522766,
0.686421275138855,
-0.21230283379554749,
0.6177736520767212,
0.14605285227298737,
-0.23182937502861023,
0.4946152865886688,
-0.10042115300893784,
-0.004630618263036013,
0.30907928943634033,
0.26774856448173523,
0.724663257598877,
-0.14679604768753052,
-0.6984204053878784,
0.45555707812309265,
-0.2578561305999756,
-0.4825882315635681,
-0.1944752335548401,
-0.09882277250289917,
-0.06560949236154556,
0.6018628478050232,
0.30059799551963806,
-0.05045544356107712,
0.3363608717918396,
-0.6207339763641357,
0.5169298052787781,
0.5688679814338684,
0.010769745334982872,
-0.032836709171533585,
0.38008466362953186,
-0.019139885902404785,
-0.34662073850631714,
0.5348017811775208,
-0.5112263560295105,
-0.622211217880249,
0.7213947176933289,
0.6029558181762695,
0.9244892001152039,
-0.21579553186893463,
0.590592086315155,
0.19110919535160065,
0.7274607419967651,
-0.3675200939178467,
0.46460291743278503,
-0.08145685493946075,
-0.8015450835227966,
-0.28137409687042236,
-0.2625913619995117,
-0.6745754480361938,
0.28353944420814514,
-0.3716152012348175,
0.21989226341247559,
-0.34535813331604004,
-0.3053182065486908,
-0.15557263791561127,
0.048514656722545624,
-0.1935097575187683,
-0.11429298669099808,
0.34031468629837036,
0.3467482030391693,
-0.7666050791740417,
0.7977356910705566,
0.4226102828979492,
-0.23793454468250275,
-0.31806954741477966,
0.2727501392364502,
0.10507212579250336,
-0.39870449900627136,
0.37511003017425537,
0.5113909840583801,
-0.5479843616485596,
-0.2939720153808594,
-0.555904746055603,
-0.29863467812538147,
0.9620571136474609,
0.5251517295837402,
-0.5097171068191528,
0.18124988675117493,
0.12128090858459473,
0.41256168484687805,
-0.4201643764972687,
0.2854398787021637,
0.43579310178756714,
0.39254575967788696,
0.42109957337379456,
-0.5764043927192688,
0.3926395773887634,
0.09211871027946472,
-0.16138839721679688,
-0.1327274888753891,
-0.33827584981918335,
0.9223765730857849,
-0.415448933839798,
-0.4546390473842621,
0.11649110913276672,
1.0013781785964966,
0.7798683643341064,
0.4181215167045593,
0.7442607879638672,
0.32352644205093384,
1.284870982170105,
0.1771368533372879,
0.683404266834259,
-0.09305988252162933,
0.2561620771884918,
1.0641547441482544,
-0.5517318844795227,
0.84023517370224,
0.5981155037879944,
-0.055525489151477814,
0.8175836205482483,
0.5582916736602783,
-0.03020622394979,
0.1471865326166153,
0.8522250652313232,
-0.44732654094696045,
-0.6208517551422119,
-0.4226034879684448,
-0.3373604118824005,
0.2661954164505005,
0.38235920667648315,
-0.016316020861268044,
-0.12426646798849106,
0.01792057789862156,
0.031446147710084915,
0.15766921639442444,
0.19047811627388,
0.7746440768241882,
-0.161918506026268,
-0.8075281381607056,
0.6925128698348999,
0.1184801310300827,
0.745972752571106,
-0.3775877058506012,
-0.30758020281791687,
-0.13501112163066864,
0.2912108302116394,
-0.12253755331039429,
-0.3164491653442383,
0.12700717151165009,
0.036245763301849365,
-0.01930905506014824,
-0.0014810289721935987,
0.6870250105857849,
-0.8034766912460327,
-0.1797250211238861,
0.1603141874074936,
0.6895793080329895,
0.38741177320480347,
-0.29474470019340515,
-0.3875531554222107,
0.3752067983150482,
-0.2773742079734802,
-0.18918584287166595,
0.037566039711236954,
0.6368988752365112,
0.1193290650844574,
0.7546705007553101,
0.5001025795936584,
0.14521531760692596,
-0.0432562455534935,
0.3122450113296509,
0.8101933598518372,
-0.48978090286254883,
-0.38101062178611755,
-1.2822247743606567,
0.46976184844970703,
-0.10816534608602524,
0.09727425128221512,
0.661529541015625,
0.4979814291000366,
0.5429612994194031,
0.06599517911672592,
0.6056321263313293,
0.29590725898742676,
0.060101352632045746,
-0.770943284034729,
0.903931736946106,
-0.42522698640823364,
0.5125973224639893,
-0.34833115339279175,
-0.66497802734375,
-0.3561166822910309,
0.8790978789329529,
0.21846628189086914,
-0.11022897809743881,
1.0603545904159546,
0.9400215744972229,
0.2610994875431061,
-0.032935142517089844,
0.293389230966568,
0.19828811287879944,
0.4894152879714966,
0.6257616281509399,
1.3588316440582275,
-0.3650292158126831,
0.5241172909736633,
0.16501402854919434,
-0.056168943643569946,
-0.02281625010073185,
-1.0310087203979492,
-1.3295398950576782,
-0.5830555558204651,
-0.8028661608695984,
-0.8929286003112793,
0.20560790598392487,
1.1102981567382812,
0.3642716705799103,
-0.6526224613189697,
-0.37904882431030273,
-0.035649899393320084,
0.6582018136978149,
-0.27446654438972473,
-0.18928831815719604,
0.38490086793899536,
-0.5202085375785828,
-0.39188915491104126,
0.40169021487236023,
0.31857213377952576,
0.006307546980679035,
-0.5198656916618347,
-0.23208880424499512,
-0.6158561110496521,
0.41351309418678284,
0.6468550562858582,
-0.028557326644659042,
-0.9376978278160095,
-0.2137463390827179,
-0.3337263762950897,
-0.3017941117286682,
0.19592972099781036,
0.8881201148033142,
-0.8850685358047485,
0.2851606011390686,
0.2509915232658386,
0.8868846297264099,
0.27741193771362305,
-0.20981983840465546,
0.19240348041057587,
-0.7237114310264587,
-0.012205886654555798,
0.13177235424518585,
0.29445892572402954,
0.3215450942516327,
-0.3086232542991638,
0.35895833373069763,
0.4873984158039093,
-0.48006734251976013,
-1.2650412321090698,
0.2642580270767212,
-0.9919275641441345,
-0.3292508125305176,
1.1256489753723145,
0.07338742166757584,
-0.14326243102550507,
-0.37939634919166565,
-0.21135075390338898,
0.40275171399116516,
-0.22476522624492645,
1.2324721813201904,
0.7801145315170288,
0.04556594043970108,
-0.17217379808425903,
-0.38149169087409973,
0.5109357833862305,
0.39598384499549866,
-1.2539293766021729,
0.34216853976249695,
0.5843929052352905,
-0.0756986141204834,
0.1651790738105774,
0.78647381067276,
0.07760962098836899,
0.014411869458854198,
0.045492254197597504,
0.3141917288303375,
0.06665968149900436,
-0.6782639622688293,
-0.27323609590530396,
0.36769214272499084,
-0.047224096953868866,
-0.3532060980796814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03068v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03068v1
|
How Truncating Weights Improves Reasoning in Language Models
| 2024-06-05T08:51:08 | 2024-06-05T08:51:08 |
Lei Chen, Joan Bruna, Alberto Bietti
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
In addition to the ability to generate fluent text in various languages,
large language models have been successful at tasks that involve basic forms of
logical "reasoning" over their context. Recent work found that selectively
removing certain components from weight matrices in pre-trained models can
improve such reasoning capabilities. We investigate this phenomenon further by
carefully studying how certain global associations tend to be stored in
specific weight components or Transformer blocks, in particular feed-forward
layers. Such associations may hurt predictions in reasoning tasks, and removing
the corresponding components may then improve performance. We analyze how this
arises during training, both empirically and theoretically, on a two-layer
Transformer trained on a basic reasoning task with noise, a toy associative
memory model, and on the Pythia family of pre-trained models tested on simple
reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.30801165103912354,
-0.5190539956092834,
0.4900897741317749,
-0.11307141184806824,
-0.12369388341903687,
-0.01129315234720707,
-0.3316322863101959,
-0.7640267014503479,
-0.1828307956457138,
0.5811312794685364,
-0.299038290977478,
0.044806379824876785,
-0.7694823145866394,
-0.12577904760837555,
-0.6731255054473877,
1.0500996112823486,
-0.25298866629600525,
-0.05549922212958336,
-0.32980257272720337,
-0.09120644629001617,
-0.6618586182594299,
-0.5312161445617676,
-0.6302173733711243,
-0.8876053094863892,
0.6160180568695068,
0.12519201636314392,
0.9972014427185059,
0.7352441549301147,
0.49494174122810364,
0.31861206889152527,
-0.1976313441991806,
0.055560920387506485,
-0.5129985809326172,
0.21809060871601105,
-0.27046942710876465,
-0.7030695080757141,
-0.23730327188968658,
0.05285881459712982,
0.677442729473114,
0.9465849995613098,
-0.11088713258504868,
0.009856550954282284,
0.04447343572974205,
0.5421666502952576,
-0.6530797481536865,
0.13565342128276825,
-0.6613993048667908,
-0.051763974130153656,
-0.037077613174915314,
0.007187678012996912,
-0.6085755825042725,
-0.13016095757484436,
0.4122212827205658,
-0.6503050923347473,
0.30835920572280884,
-0.0812201201915741,
1.2258727550506592,
0.17865732312202454,
-0.36536622047424316,
-0.1860332041978836,
-1.1126222610473633,
0.910369336605072,
-0.3019980788230896,
0.43092140555381775,
0.6068523526191711,
0.11642894148826599,
0.13444460928440094,
-0.7498589158058167,
-0.21397849917411804,
-0.19581551849842072,
-0.5900282859802246,
-0.15207792818546295,
-0.4317251443862915,
0.15110982954502106,
0.7146773338317871,
0.25195470452308655,
-0.36926496028900146,
-0.13597163558006287,
-0.8596608638763428,
-0.27581891417503357,
0.5788726210594177,
-0.38159072399139404,
0.4592675268650055,
-0.04555049538612366,
0.04736195132136345,
-0.017757438123226166,
-0.9487073421478271,
-0.06693591177463531,
0.4774225950241089,
0.030709603801369667,
0.2545602023601532,
0.5488630533218384,
-0.1501377373933792,
0.6498652100563049,
0.059693120419979095,
0.14682692289352417,
0.03948693349957466,
0.03479107469320297,
-0.1655268669128418,
-0.09217655658721924,
0.32501739263534546,
0.16466355323791504,
0.61799156665802,
-0.5028679370880127,
-0.3256576955318451,
0.2532532811164856,
0.48518234491348267,
-0.6718736886978149,
-0.5958977937698364,
-0.14189448952674866,
-0.7107510566711426,
-0.12530438601970673,
0.06459233164787292,
-0.16046448051929474,
-0.21617762744426727,
-0.4570859968662262,
0.8168174028396606,
-0.5828890204429626,
-0.3689703345298767,
0.20500564575195312,
-0.395050048828125,
-0.015313905663788319,
0.2728256285190582,
-0.8426457047462463,
0.717713475227356,
0.5506947040557861,
0.36139798164367676,
0.006496808025985956,
-0.13458673655986786,
-0.7716619968414307,
0.13301128149032593,
-0.2537727355957031,
0.7315182685852051,
-0.7622196078300476,
-0.2622345983982086,
-0.2935192883014679,
-0.04989764466881752,
-0.08388566225767136,
-0.9085968732833862,
0.5504993200302124,
-0.4758200943470001,
0.20957235991954803,
-0.6033120155334473,
-0.35378167033195496,
-0.3557736873626709,
0.05992479622364044,
-0.8413289189338684,
0.9888253211975098,
0.012606717646121979,
-0.5100643038749695,
0.38285472989082336,
-0.09528182446956635,
-0.7917785048484802,
-0.1499321609735489,
0.1395786851644516,
-0.47611215710639954,
0.4830819368362427,
0.358822226524353,
0.144454225897789,
-0.2982594668865204,
0.24818742275238037,
-0.04233815521001816,
-0.7028625011444092,
0.0780601054430008,
-0.1332382708787918,
0.5934704542160034,
0.18582186102867126,
-0.32835522294044495,
0.10244318097829819,
-0.6684882640838623,
0.018268844112753868,
0.20824368298053741,
-0.16349633038043976,
-0.5853012800216675,
0.13790971040725708,
-0.4091389775276184,
0.46739107370376587,
-0.31350502371788025,
-0.4677657186985016,
0.22386977076530457,
-0.5913249850273132,
0.6148087382316589,
0.49798375368118286,
-0.04400957375764847,
0.632731556892395,
-0.44491511583328247,
0.3583906888961792,
0.16935886442661285,
-0.1478947550058365,
0.043941348791122437,
-0.2898327112197876,
-1.0152515172958374,
-0.0009293907205574214,
0.26090800762176514,
0.2655087113380432,
-0.7598612308502197,
0.037750281393527985,
-0.24324609339237213,
-0.4592720568180084,
-0.3266550898551941,
0.22220410406589508,
0.4257236421108246,
0.537174642086029,
0.48879730701446533,
-0.21506989002227783,
-0.6647990345954895,
-1.005516529083252,
-0.649217426776886,
-0.24648450314998627,
-0.16986337304115295,
-0.1522810161113739,
0.6096599102020264,
0.3164825737476349,
0.8359367251396179,
-0.6355602145195007,
-0.014386056922376156,
-0.4426024854183197,
0.20800699293613434,
-0.1532754749059677,
0.7229496836662292,
0.363747239112854,
-0.6804243326187134,
-0.06831883639097214,
-0.24691429734230042,
-0.40760213136672974,
-0.031997136771678925,
-0.3991287350654602,
-0.34463322162628174,
-0.18406818807125092,
0.2768397629261017,
-1.2186808586120605,
0.8051051497459412,
0.11669254302978516,
-0.1301671415567398,
0.8027811050415039,
-0.2894454598426819,
-0.1740044504404068,
-0.5133876800537109,
-0.03033546172082424,
0.17423546314239502,
-0.20498216152191162,
-0.7142256498336792,
-0.11876030266284943,
0.034298986196517944,
0.010011697188019753,
-0.21226565539836884,
0.621938169002533,
-0.6191002726554871,
-0.18147794902324677,
-0.2715882956981659,
0.10097472369670868,
0.5361965894699097,
0.3708568215370178,
0.4062477648258209,
0.7163823843002319,
0.3476950526237488,
-0.8526464104652405,
0.03284528851509094,
0.1596934199333191,
-0.30087295174598694,
0.20964102447032928,
-0.8105020523071289,
0.043369110673666,
-0.3063020706176758,
0.13598762452602386,
-0.7430450916290283,
0.2819703221321106,
0.0767914429306984,
-0.16361187398433685,
0.3218856453895569,
0.05476706847548485,
-0.4494493901729584,
-0.5696880221366882,
-0.019017120823264122,
0.5412616729736328,
0.5145500898361206,
-0.5009651184082031,
0.6509299874305725,
0.1705431342124939,
0.1550714671611786,
-0.5341571569442749,
-0.9319994449615479,
-0.2559129297733307,
-0.25250211358070374,
-0.26776760816574097,
0.48823538422584534,
-0.03718898817896843,
-0.5075164437294006,
0.15910065174102783,
-0.5300406813621521,
-0.07628754526376724,
0.13712482154369354,
0.14662809669971466,
0.13807569444179535,
0.09038253128528595,
0.5798277854919434,
0.020854365080595016,
-0.04659342020750046,
0.34913161396980286,
-0.39795008301734924,
0.49138781428337097,
-0.2802509367465973,
-0.2539305090904236,
-0.3951956033706665,
0.012942078523337841,
0.14514006674289703,
-0.5234588980674744,
0.9401178956031799,
0.512005090713501,
-0.49562501907348633,
-0.24007239937782288,
-0.6231261491775513,
-0.33052346110343933,
-0.45506617426872253,
0.5680315494537354,
-0.5904626846313477,
-0.6403560638427734,
0.6040087938308716,
0.0914001539349556,
-0.09383544325828552,
0.543861448764801,
0.327877014875412,
-0.09385986626148224,
1.293229341506958,
0.3701573610305786,
0.1574200987815857,
0.4014742970466614,
-0.4378918707370758,
0.3660190999507904,
-0.82048499584198,
-0.1781989485025406,
-0.6344295144081116,
-0.4361576437950134,
-0.411073237657547,
-0.3378443717956543,
-0.021333932876586914,
0.2908354699611664,
-0.37429749965667725,
0.2878850996494293,
-0.5427930355072021,
0.7721991539001465,
0.43043071031570435,
0.22357724606990814,
0.2672782838344574,
0.08014341443777084,
-0.057210199534893036,
-0.022334737703204155,
-0.5077124834060669,
-0.27431175112724304,
0.9036273956298828,
0.32390594482421875,
0.7361759543418884,
-0.17243795096874237,
0.4588943123817444,
-0.028943771496415138,
0.3398858904838562,
-0.8741380572319031,
0.5087924599647522,
-0.09718862920999527,
-0.6848592162132263,
0.028779519721865654,
-0.7133036851882935,
-0.7889691591262817,
0.4206327497959137,
-0.16456444561481476,
-0.9700731635093689,
0.03441392630338669,
0.19114050269126892,
-0.28905048966407776,
0.7795097231864929,
-0.6955503821372986,
0.4924298822879791,
-0.0713992789387703,
-0.268823504447937,
-0.47720324993133545,
-0.5982024669647217,
0.4359229505062103,
0.3499913811683655,
-0.003138419007882476,
0.11200760304927826,
0.299765944480896,
0.8597612977027893,
-0.46558740735054016,
0.5917791128158569,
-0.08964365720748901,
-0.11250454187393188,
0.5593653321266174,
0.5037257671356201,
0.5703290700912476,
-0.2956852912902832,
-0.13976508378982544,
0.09846802055835724,
-0.047831207513809204,
-0.3358444571495056,
-0.7348567843437195,
0.23978640139102936,
-0.8775461316108704,
-0.7767486572265625,
-0.10526402294635773,
-0.928516149520874,
-0.23218725621700287,
0.32890212535858154,
0.08491533994674683,
0.6317821145057678,
0.2016945481300354,
0.3664149045944214,
0.8513112664222717,
-0.13567054271697998,
0.3005507290363312,
0.06206847354769707,
-0.21481488645076752,
-0.04506745934486389,
0.7666289806365967,
0.4548676609992981,
0.40987178683280945,
0.5621919631958008,
0.24056905508041382,
0.03091444820165634,
-0.36643779277801514,
0.15124689042568207,
0.36544370651245117,
-0.9256963729858398,
-0.15835069119930267,
-0.6760916709899902,
-0.42720815539360046,
-0.22289098799228668,
0.034062065184116364,
-0.3125370144844055,
-1.0744718313217163,
0.04709390550851822,
-0.4591540992259979,
-0.18151924014091492,
0.8543850183486938,
0.19411522150039673,
0.5853688716888428,
-0.7513428330421448,
0.23794060945510864,
0.3785566985607147,
0.33718377351760864,
0.34024226665496826,
-0.4298070967197418,
-0.3998752236366272,
-0.10560568422079086,
-0.26447346806526184,
-0.6277151703834534,
0.31614360213279724,
0.1451473981142044,
0.6239655017852783,
0.41308730840682983,
-0.15475313365459442,
0.8059948682785034,
-0.350503534078598,
0.6293637156486511,
0.10994172841310501,
-1.2543946504592896,
0.4400881230831146,
-0.1383620649576187,
0.5113692283630371,
0.148077130317688,
0.12424640357494354,
-0.5276811122894287,
-0.4667597711086273,
-0.6572126746177673,
-0.4547888934612274,
0.6954828500747681,
0.3290592432022095,
0.11125906556844711,
0.07395849376916885,
0.7362886667251587,
0.1245923638343811,
0.3471145033836365,
-0.882205069065094,
-0.21095183491706848,
-0.10973649471998215,
-0.11691677570343018,
0.15884989500045776,
-0.32236453890800476,
0.02870815247297287,
-0.6840077638626099,
0.7812683582305908,
0.07741370052099228,
0.13645674288272858,
-0.009665855206549168,
-0.5660473704338074,
-0.3937571346759796,
0.15782083570957184,
0.3793574571609497,
0.8712330460548401,
0.050543006509542465,
0.3814541697502136,
0.2335861772298813,
-0.5090762972831726,
0.08463691920042038,
-0.010440913029015064,
-0.39533719420433044,
-0.25374674797058105,
0.6017374396324158,
0.8873709440231323,
0.3043067753314972,
-0.5202391743659973,
0.1310867965221405,
-0.14891782402992249,
-0.4280529320240021,
0.11829070001840591,
0.10548901557922363,
0.04256795719265938,
0.00403922563418746,
0.32553303241729736,
0.47176915407180786,
0.0573924221098423,
-0.42519378662109375,
0.24488350749015808,
0.3884255886077881,
-0.3600776791572571,
-0.6391128301620483,
0.6280400156974792,
-0.04880185425281525,
0.05897851288318634,
0.8494520783424377,
0.019420240074396133,
-0.6610556244850159,
0.5075221657752991,
0.7082194089889526,
0.6130286455154419,
-0.12007657438516617,
0.3854829967021942,
0.4665008783340454,
0.7335735559463501,
-0.24574197828769684,
-0.08330404758453369,
-0.1514858603477478,
-1.0261130332946777,
-0.6354596614837646,
-0.5535076260566711,
-0.02945035696029663,
-0.051038142293691635,
-0.7060006856918335,
0.10460296273231506,
-0.39281392097473145,
-0.2577283978462219,
-0.1440461426973343,
0.3280337452888489,
-0.8814214468002319,
0.4093899726867676,
0.3830259442329407,
0.723552405834198,
-0.9102327823638916,
0.9080851674079895,
0.6854245662689209,
-0.6019924283027649,
-1.290824294090271,
-0.06615651398897171,
-0.22754542529582977,
-0.584137499332428,
0.9454123973846436,
0.40376585721969604,
-0.09609704464673996,
-0.19745400547981262,
-0.47848618030548096,
-1.1639142036437988,
0.6110708117485046,
0.6607219576835632,
-0.43060681223869324,
-0.5535109639167786,
0.0727580189704895,
0.4318086802959442,
-0.18830528855323792,
0.4694433808326721,
0.7943592071533203,
0.48725399374961853,
0.27373531460762024,
-0.8971574902534485,
0.2434653341770172,
-0.29117512702941895,
0.10183163732290268,
0.2613307535648346,
-0.5631738305091858,
1.1938172578811646,
-0.18701915442943573,
-0.14040035009384155,
-0.016474397853016853,
0.7665194272994995,
0.05409574136137962,
-0.15138348937034607,
0.6553080081939697,
0.7342824339866638,
1.0139787197113037,
-0.23291392624378204,
1.0734248161315918,
-0.07874530553817749,
0.20908097922801971,
1.2129294872283936,
-0.39603278040885925,
0.4778963029384613,
0.41752222180366516,
0.0738070011138916,
0.9329736232757568,
0.30677422881126404,
0.10644325613975525,
0.39695632457733154,
0.27794331312179565,
0.09889637678861618,
-0.5809919238090515,
-0.0985042154788971,
-0.12754566967487335,
0.5893334746360779,
0.2921905219554901,
-0.25080838799476624,
-0.29996398091316223,
0.18383802473545074,
0.22915320098400116,
-0.008201719261705875,
-0.47756215929985046,
0.5370500087738037,
0.2148704081773758,
-0.8584710359573364,
0.46984460949897766,
-0.0601387619972229,
0.25333309173583984,
-0.5570724010467529,
-0.02980564348399639,
0.09799013286828995,
0.3163914680480957,
-0.24916669726371765,
-0.5420951843261719,
0.6928848624229431,
-0.26074910163879395,
-0.17180676758289337,
-0.3677980303764343,
1.2945563793182373,
-0.5687766671180725,
-0.38364720344543457,
0.3442091643810272,
0.6628405451774597,
-0.012643299996852875,
-0.16843584179878235,
-0.6041805148124695,
0.08698973059654236,
-0.23229703307151794,
-0.5766746401786804,
0.2436945140361786,
0.2931269407272339,
-0.2068815976381302,
0.8681405782699585,
0.5558571815490723,
0.4724855422973633,
-0.13552166521549225,
0.30261141061782837,
1.1215734481811523,
-0.5299744009971619,
-0.37292301654815674,
-0.7634551525115967,
0.4887215793132782,
-0.10433004051446915,
0.15860959887504578,
0.6969553232192993,
0.4504159092903137,
0.7489796280860901,
0.10667172074317932,
0.5222957730293274,
0.01033188495784998,
0.179724782705307,
-0.40429383516311646,
0.6406073570251465,
-0.4994371831417084,
0.23070912063121796,
-0.153018519282341,
-0.9642476439476013,
-0.34809374809265137,
0.651477575302124,
-0.7800664305686951,
0.2646430730819702,
0.9220659732818604,
0.48587730526924133,
0.0647808089852333,
0.1754288673400879,
0.2793799936771393,
0.4188773036003113,
0.5062946677207947,
0.5494641661643982,
0.6887515783309937,
-0.5246832966804504,
0.7969608306884766,
-0.48662251234054565,
0.24403029680252075,
0.27431488037109375,
-0.6558139324188232,
-0.9976519346237183,
-0.3376128673553467,
-0.409357488155365,
-0.5092714428901672,
-0.029075579717755318,
0.7496334314346313,
0.901885449886322,
-0.7708713412284851,
-0.1863211989402771,
-0.0787578895688057,
0.4088737368583679,
-0.6648304462432861,
-0.21770326793193817,
0.2900407910346985,
-0.2576196789741516,
-0.49619174003601074,
0.1214994490146637,
0.07330254465341568,
-0.22791290283203125,
-0.06330038607120514,
0.08436961472034454,
-0.29585322737693787,
0.1243869811296463,
0.48260077834129333,
-0.015628205612301826,
-0.6421216130256653,
-0.7143536806106567,
-0.32051774859428406,
0.13149119913578033,
0.08928356319665909,
0.966580867767334,
-1.2221360206604004,
0.35495999455451965,
0.6065355539321899,
0.27008092403411865,
0.6556346416473389,
0.14316192269325256,
0.8406144976615906,
-1.0227102041244507,
0.47610580921173096,
0.19051584601402283,
0.4397090673446655,
0.22819402813911438,
-0.40182361006736755,
0.44603201746940613,
0.2610546052455902,
-0.42731860280036926,
-0.8979156017303467,
0.15935227274894714,
-0.31828951835632324,
-0.3107604682445526,
0.7980260848999023,
-0.06893157958984375,
-0.4609530568122864,
0.19757474958896637,
-0.07878056168556213,
0.4592723548412323,
-0.04219812899827957,
0.5749668478965759,
0.9936882853507996,
0.01309152040630579,
-0.43026646971702576,
-0.5238273739814758,
0.6043924689292908,
0.7372609972953796,
-0.6216937303543091,
0.2383614480495453,
0.38615649938583374,
0.2859668731689453,
0.23966573178768158,
0.3475130498409271,
-0.07750163972377777,
0.17918969690799713,
-0.10996244102716446,
0.0404079295694828,
-0.05330609902739525,
-0.49581822752952576,
-0.14390994608402252,
0.3246174156665802,
-0.03837618604302406,
0.3064763844013214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06587v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06587v1
|
Exploring Human-AI Perception Alignment in Sensory Experiences: Do LLMs Understand Textile Hand?
| 2024-06-05T08:46:07 | 2024-06-05T08:46:07 |
Shu Zhong, Elia Gatti, Youngjun Cho, Marianna Obrist
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Aligning large language models (LLMs) behaviour with human intent is critical
for future AI. An important yet often overlooked aspect of this alignment is
the perceptual alignment. Perceptual modalities like touch are more
multifaceted and nuanced compared to other sensory modalities such as vision.
This work investigates how well LLMs align with human touch experiences using
the "textile hand" task. We created a "Guess What Textile" interaction in which
participants were given two textile samples -- a target and a reference -- to
handle. Without seeing them, participants described the differences between
them to the LLM. Using these descriptions, the LLM attempted to identify the
target textile by assessing similarity within its high-dimensional embedding
space. Our results suggest that a degree of perceptual alignment exists,
however varies significantly among different textile samples. For example, LLM
predictions are well aligned for silk satin, but not for cotton denim.
Moreover, participants didn't perceive their textile experiences closely
matched by the LLM predictions. This is only the first exploration into
perceptual alignment around touch, exemplified through textile hand. We discuss
possible sources of this alignment variance, and how better human-AI perceptual
alignment can benefit future everyday tasks.
|
[
-0.3090984523296356,
-0.2498885542154312,
0.7371012568473816,
-0.0288385059684515,
-0.2977299690246582,
0.12069999426603317,
0.003990045748651028,
-0.874891459941864,
0.21735385060310364,
0.3833876848220825,
-0.7139625549316406,
-0.5157274007797241,
-0.552708625793457,
-0.00858377292752266,
-0.24297654628753662,
0.5942910313606262,
-0.2613181173801422,
-0.12823012471199036,
-0.5378943681716919,
-0.4801988899707794,
-0.12050163000822067,
-0.6604116559028625,
-0.3238910138607025,
-0.4589078724384308,
0.6981136202812195,
0.4412229061126709,
0.6556850671768188,
0.5858900547027588,
0.8358815312385559,
0.3741816282272339,
0.04119563102722168,
0.3820554316043854,
-0.11064670979976654,
-0.15791083872318268,
0.005098100285977125,
-0.5073607563972473,
-0.4571157693862915,
0.3706987202167511,
0.14844512939453125,
0.6463356018066406,
0.08792775124311447,
0.3212396800518036,
0.5687373876571655,
0.3933526277542114,
-0.8232038021087646,
-0.49523401260375977,
-0.03022659197449684,
0.09944302588701248,
-0.07149166613817215,
0.08657471090555191,
-0.1660854071378708,
0.31306904554367065,
-0.05936809256672859,
-0.5490865707397461,
0.2526460886001587,
0.293925404548645,
0.910810112953186,
0.5234455466270447,
-0.7589699625968933,
0.04875732958316803,
-0.6647738814353943,
0.6963521838188171,
-0.6121981739997864,
0.6907492876052856,
0.4114997386932373,
0.022362370043992996,
0.10392971336841583,
-0.3349210321903229,
-1.0052435398101807,
-0.08474795520305634,
-0.1851869374513626,
0.2581329345703125,
0.274077832698822,
-0.02821962721645832,
0.2363353669643402,
-0.006990700028836727,
-0.5039739608764648,
0.2946400046348572,
0.14022208750247955,
-0.0610019750893116,
0.6258330941200256,
0.29427310824394226,
0.3135105073451996,
0.039241451770067215,
-1.0812501907348633,
-0.15447396039962769,
-0.30535969138145447,
-0.07218273729085922,
0.35188889503479004,
-0.0184441227465868,
-0.5388952493667603,
0.6166728138923645,
0.27179640531539917,
0.9770904779434204,
0.3216208517551422,
-0.14959199726581573,
0.03896257281303406,
-0.37118101119995117,
-0.2975059151649475,
-0.05944055691361427,
0.7185183167457581,
0.7263807058334351,
0.15777017176151276,
-0.1278277039527893,
-0.05894540250301361,
-0.19922196865081787,
0.7659578919410706,
-0.21058739721775055,
0.15263976156711578,
-0.03578762710094452,
-0.5657339096069336,
-0.4596710205078125,
0.41399452090263367,
-0.4535661041736603,
-0.9950074553489685,
-0.679465651512146,
0.3189208209514618,
-0.021393369883298874,
-0.24794316291809082,
0.08324743062257767,
-0.18981851637363434,
0.6639713644981384,
0.41678375005722046,
-1.0117536783218384,
0.3747904896736145,
0.8960005640983582,
0.5374240875244141,
-0.5242097973823547,
-0.6429636478424072,
0.08795846253633499,
0.318802148103714,
-0.30197855830192566,
0.567766547203064,
-0.3738507032394409,
-0.11827615648508072,
-0.37521928548812866,
-0.11033578962087631,
0.11423693597316742,
-0.5399341583251953,
0.428434282541275,
-0.22081498801708221,
0.10107097774744034,
-0.4708835482597351,
-0.18800871074199677,
-0.008690050803124905,
0.23418255150318146,
-0.582377016544342,
0.6177392601966858,
0.07404287904500961,
-0.9508281350135803,
0.8698241114616394,
-0.47443923354148865,
-0.22070886194705963,
-0.30019477009773254,
-0.32746076583862305,
-0.11853493005037308,
0.3391556143760681,
0.010291553102433681,
0.17269085347652435,
-0.36281508207321167,
-0.39904269576072693,
-0.47961729764938354,
-0.5459888577461243,
0.6684982180595398,
-0.5926249027252197,
0.5091922879219055,
0.003668063087388873,
-0.4869953691959381,
0.05803310498595238,
-0.5051287412643433,
-0.3986077308654785,
-0.06473156064748764,
-0.05346966162323952,
-0.3411850333213806,
-0.15182192623615265,
0.3038107752799988,
0.23602794110774994,
0.7597092986106873,
-0.6371452808380127,
0.3408357501029968,
-0.13606813549995422,
0.1669374257326126,
1.04932701587677,
-0.28470873832702637,
0.728769838809967,
-0.4307214915752411,
0.415802001953125,
0.11854610592126846,
0.423162579536438,
0.24842426180839539,
-0.05574284493923187,
-0.8429522514343262,
-0.006694973446428776,
0.09911686927080154,
0.4232826232910156,
-0.22498983144760132,
0.35352450609207153,
-0.027147458866238594,
-0.322979599237442,
-0.44661250710487366,
0.09651871770620346,
0.3973691165447235,
0.595384418964386,
0.036832623183727264,
-0.39380720257759094,
-0.43828192353248596,
-0.9838190078735352,
-0.49529826641082764,
-0.08623252063989639,
-0.2942162752151489,
0.6270075440406799,
-0.01962810568511486,
-0.1835980862379074,
0.9253883361816406,
-0.4673524498939514,
-0.3715958595275879,
0.39096295833587646,
0.18831652402877808,
0.31270867586135864,
0.4640602171421051,
0.3259076774120331,
-0.8208348155021667,
-0.20967286825180054,
0.2032068818807602,
-0.8155008554458618,
-0.07371999323368073,
-0.06632658839225769,
-0.24561333656311035,
0.5173764824867249,
0.5296829342842102,
-0.45749783515930176,
0.48777520656585693,
0.8797101974487305,
-0.6788397431373596,
0.3656783401966095,
-0.2544996738433838,
0.36573123931884766,
-1.0608748197555542,
0.2360876053571701,
0.21679536998271942,
0.06257250159978867,
-0.4046563506126404,
-0.10273274034261703,
0.10901398211717606,
0.12851765751838684,
-0.385781854391098,
0.779858410358429,
-0.6908203959465027,
-0.4568445682525635,
-0.3786202073097229,
-0.1133137047290802,
0.24493806064128876,
0.6138729453086853,
0.1292666494846344,
0.8203653693199158,
0.07600060105323792,
-0.21540400385856628,
0.20613805949687958,
0.3120615482330322,
-0.4533642530441284,
0.7881220579147339,
-0.3873366415500641,
0.7586641311645508,
0.22188350558280945,
-0.21849799156188965,
-1.3206133842468262,
-0.018405022099614143,
0.3080883026123047,
-0.552812933921814,
0.3506597578525543,
0.12277647107839584,
-0.23251116275787354,
-0.23973126709461212,
-0.18942689895629883,
0.8558492064476013,
0.31381240487098694,
-0.634303092956543,
1.0415517091751099,
0.29537293314933777,
0.12670767307281494,
-0.7609053254127502,
-0.7100741863250732,
0.11206933110952377,
-0.5845242738723755,
-0.3482843041419983,
0.1839848905801773,
0.013444478623569012,
-0.434888631105423,
-0.4110094904899597,
-0.7375997304916382,
0.13025301694869995,
0.24534820020198822,
0.632399320602417,
0.5259057283401489,
-0.08526910841464996,
-0.2918289303779602,
-0.45041099190711975,
-0.01823307015001774,
0.14138510823249817,
-0.2900555729866028,
0.6291447877883911,
0.2090112715959549,
-0.8895378112792969,
-0.5852333903312683,
-0.054654404520988464,
0.6108514666557312,
-0.07026071101427078,
0.32920026779174805,
0.5872246623039246,
-0.09033714979887009,
0.45564979314804077,
-0.7250072956085205,
-0.12885776162147522,
-0.5618893504142761,
-0.06036435440182686,
-0.489891916513443,
-0.5778290629386902,
0.396711140871048,
-0.010350908152759075,
-0.1714436262845993,
0.1494964212179184,
0.18744876980781555,
-0.9141975045204163,
1.024285912513733,
0.8292441368103027,
-0.42406198382377625,
0.4647875726222992,
0.00907585397362709,
0.2901463806629181,
-1.241847038269043,
-0.4189685583114624,
-0.3370800316333771,
-1.1673786640167236,
-0.4443391263484955,
-0.5184784531593323,
0.39934995770454407,
0.18764729797840118,
-0.6235849261283875,
0.35535678267478943,
-0.5247906446456909,
0.41191065311431885,
0.8156296610832214,
0.4632854461669922,
0.12710070610046387,
-0.10027506947517395,
-0.16834670305252075,
0.15067070722579956,
-0.3456861078739166,
-0.6181564927101135,
0.85023033618927,
0.19223704934120178,
0.6847116351127625,
0.034590382128953934,
0.790952742099762,
0.2555530071258545,
0.14698441326618195,
-0.5030167698860168,
0.30420637130737305,
-0.21252933144569397,
-0.09905103594064713,
-0.4039980173110962,
0.1471334844827652,
-1.0091861486434937,
-0.11476165056228638,
-0.5277745723724365,
-0.9780201315879822,
0.49223971366882324,
0.3099454641342163,
-0.24077053368091583,
0.12146645784378052,
-0.5300251841545105,
0.7524632215499878,
-0.7221691012382507,
-0.6081253886222839,
0.06292492151260376,
-0.623447835445404,
-0.0945999026298523,
0.10260940343141556,
0.22519798576831818,
-0.06205163523554802,
-0.6181370615959167,
0.6832241415977478,
-0.026121407747268677,
1.1295143365859985,
-0.00544119905680418,
-0.4993329644203186,
-0.14446711540222168,
0.08008068054914474,
0.24455730617046356,
-0.5695192813873291,
0.021335531026124954,
0.48203304409980774,
-0.36028844118118286,
-0.4294876754283905,
-0.6213204264640808,
0.5126132965087891,
-0.8573320508003235,
-0.7931724786758423,
-0.29792365431785583,
-0.6905105113983154,
-0.386823445558548,
0.041491683572530746,
0.22965316474437714,
0.07538937032222748,
-0.19430114328861237,
-0.4079003632068634,
0.27921250462532043,
0.04460945352911949,
0.2804754078388214,
0.2242187261581421,
-0.06372631341218948,
-0.14853306114673615,
0.7809277176856995,
-0.19549496471881866,
-0.01159888505935669,
0.5622111558914185,
0.19408054649829865,
-0.38734737038612366,
-0.5029968619346619,
-0.433622270822525,
0.26896119117736816,
-0.3290521204471588,
-0.06452808529138565,
-0.34446749091148376,
0.16962337493896484,
-0.41662123799324036,
-0.3926624059677124,
0.20623983442783356,
-0.07420000433921814,
-0.382119357585907,
-0.1622033268213272,
0.24523498117923737,
1.0234291553497314,
0.11287778615951538,
0.38895174860954285,
-0.8457920551300049,
0.3882431387901306,
0.372604101896286,
0.48218733072280884,
-0.09678525477647781,
-0.5432997941970825,
-0.3071112036705017,
0.17343617975711823,
-0.060084566473960876,
-0.7075713276863098,
0.1644587516784668,
-0.23177501559257507,
0.416674941778183,
0.8425703644752502,
-0.07122799754142761,
0.6013695001602173,
-0.3184872269630432,
0.7942208647727966,
0.3759055733680725,
-0.8483560681343079,
0.09052570909261703,
-0.4362720847129822,
0.33950725197792053,
0.40255698561668396,
0.46105095744132996,
-0.6647666692733765,
-0.1906093955039978,
-0.7282751202583313,
-0.6718153357505798,
0.6411633491516113,
-0.29840633273124695,
0.030250491574406624,
0.24713453650474548,
0.23311513662338257,
0.10356851667165756,
0.2431972473859787,
-0.114622563123703,
0.023558925837278366,
0.24893556535243988,
-0.4599390923976898,
-0.4544670283794403,
-0.21385043859481812,
-0.4034596383571625,
-0.061287131160497665,
-0.1634896993637085,
-0.16773629188537598,
0.31699639558792114,
-0.12991970777511597,
0.029100216925144196,
-0.22937455773353577,
-0.45895853638648987,
0.6795206665992737,
0.7914648056030273,
0.10683611780405045,
0.2051883488893509,
0.30678755044937134,
-0.4380173683166504,
0.1442626565694809,
-0.25015661120414734,
0.16087493300437927,
-0.5651819705963135,
0.7121061086654663,
0.7609900236129761,
0.09471120685338974,
-0.5532363057136536,
0.5319589972496033,
0.09492575377225876,
-0.14222808182239532,
-0.14347895979881287,
0.20432984828948975,
0.2608662545681,
0.6283988356590271,
0.27414411306381226,
0.1657276153564453,
0.20580518245697021,
-0.5344454646110535,
0.003669397672638297,
0.5038178563117981,
-0.3834906816482544,
-0.07169784605503082,
0.7920618653297424,
0.19063597917556763,
-0.6703453063964844,
0.7871860265731812,
0.663798451423645,
-0.6300081014633179,
0.8878039717674255,
0.2590372860431671,
0.7618489265441895,
-0.12216181308031082,
-0.35123705863952637,
0.05409415811300278,
-0.027602726593613625,
0.4406055212020874,
0.18527652323246002,
-0.5077094435691833,
-1.285772681236267,
-0.19008435308933258,
-0.6615800261497498,
-0.5950969457626343,
-0.3313826024532318,
-0.7358160614967346,
0.38467636704444885,
-0.2787425220012665,
-0.07621284574270248,
-0.0502568818628788,
-0.11404740065336227,
-0.764238715171814,
0.369332492351532,
0.6118120551109314,
0.7163498401641846,
-1.216753602027893,
0.6957926750183105,
0.7421598434448242,
-0.2467474490404129,
-0.96820068359375,
0.45030686259269714,
0.1340387910604477,
-1.3310991525650024,
0.5373643040657043,
0.10504086315631866,
-0.38001054525375366,
-0.19433094561100006,
-0.5875577926635742,
-0.848573625087738,
1.1964384317398071,
0.3471413552761078,
-0.6564386487007141,
-0.16223375499248505,
0.35047447681427,
0.29738590121269226,
-0.05645173788070679,
0.17237837612628937,
0.6911683082580566,
0.6897217035293579,
0.04005806893110275,
-0.8906717896461487,
0.005383416544646025,
-0.26841747760772705,
-0.047098685055971146,
0.5333003401756287,
-0.8754148483276367,
0.5662692189216614,
-0.23722751438617706,
0.19286850094795227,
0.09049462527036667,
0.5948331356048584,
0.25464922189712524,
0.603290855884552,
0.6564805507659912,
0.7377863526344299,
0.6848554015159607,
0.022213762626051903,
1.0702683925628662,
-0.2480386197566986,
-0.03535034507513046,
1.0380769968032837,
-0.49626144766807556,
0.601710855960846,
0.8154897689819336,
-0.3225976526737213,
0.42731407284736633,
0.7414706349372864,
0.1467079222202301,
0.13717401027679443,
0.2830330729484558,
-0.36269110441207886,
-0.19996924698352814,
-0.08124236762523651,
0.05818343162536621,
0.873301088809967,
0.0684334933757782,
-0.18515706062316895,
0.20862485468387604,
0.19561545550823212,
-0.41469019651412964,
0.1952744424343109,
-0.18624936044216156,
1.3367751836776733,
-0.026233544573187828,
-0.5396474599838257,
0.49430933594703674,
-0.4257728159427643,
0.8128339052200317,
-0.3397418260574341,
-0.2036803513765335,
-0.3038211464881897,
0.017523135989904404,
-0.37160858511924744,
-0.9700925350189209,
0.09395390003919601,
-0.14246027171611786,
-0.22634349763393402,
-0.348575234413147,
0.7644689083099365,
-0.2753642499446869,
-0.27060508728027344,
0.29235124588012695,
0.38904571533203125,
0.3622215688228607,
-0.08908168226480484,
-0.4852566421031952,
0.27476009726524353,
-0.05400017648935318,
-0.22664207220077515,
0.6788864135742188,
0.5900217890739441,
-0.21080997586250305,
0.22416728734970093,
0.5335372090339661,
-0.09760161489248276,
-0.11342430114746094,
-0.028282353654503822,
0.528050422668457,
-0.7477136254310608,
0.03651639074087143,
-0.8428269028663635,
0.33538469672203064,
0.01857270486652851,
-0.3179551362991333,
0.4583897590637207,
0.41005563735961914,
0.7078989148139954,
-0.04839136078953743,
0.493063747882843,
0.16839279234409332,
0.06599579006433487,
-0.4632248878479004,
0.6647993326187134,
-0.6949473023414612,
-0.17144639790058136,
-0.16976560652256012,
-0.9660871028900146,
-0.10124226659536362,
0.8463792204856873,
-0.1776745319366455,
0.11582420766353607,
0.5790305137634277,
0.7503032684326172,
-0.14300084114074707,
-0.16827282309532166,
0.4277328550815582,
0.18948040902614594,
-0.24635718762874603,
0.32749512791633606,
0.8982076644897461,
0.042308658361434937,
0.06288706511259079,
-0.2462441325187683,
-0.22836153209209442,
-0.06979846209287643,
-1.1269774436950684,
-0.2683905065059662,
-0.7226803302764893,
0.029835006222128868,
-0.1802002489566803,
-0.07122975587844849,
0.9196974635124207,
0.571479856967926,
-0.5017462968826294,
-0.5913426280021667,
-0.04548266902565956,
-0.15965251624584198,
-0.3459090292453766,
-0.10178764909505844,
0.34699326753616333,
-0.026358073577284813,
-1.0283195972442627,
0.24234864115715027,
0.24769680202007294,
0.21912750601768494,
0.02989974059164524,
-0.08602779358625412,
-0.2184387892484665,
-0.17575719952583313,
0.28734272718429565,
0.08028645068407059,
-0.6391321420669556,
-0.5301414728164673,
0.19060349464416504,
-0.2836082875728607,
0.2402389794588089,
0.7837409377098083,
-0.773597002029419,
0.08386152982711792,
0.3917063772678375,
0.6638593673706055,
0.5872789621353149,
0.3546799421310425,
0.8352959156036377,
-0.5322824120521545,
0.14510826766490936,
0.23373614251613617,
0.3133107125759125,
0.18769174814224243,
-0.6615542769432068,
0.4941605031490326,
-0.06905516237020493,
-0.48308682441711426,
-0.3353217542171478,
0.23182007670402527,
-1.53215491771698,
-0.14835979044437408,
0.9669972062110901,
0.07886745035648346,
-0.4827304184436798,
0.2098720222711563,
-0.6157417893409729,
0.3929591178894043,
0.07781399041414261,
0.8960428237915039,
0.8127352595329285,
-0.3788576126098633,
-0.22071607410907745,
0.13346926867961884,
0.14931847155094147,
0.5237715840339661,
-0.4597238302230835,
0.08100613206624985,
0.3972124755382538,
0.13200736045837402,
0.18114104866981506,
0.6449488997459412,
0.26534220576286316,
0.16475909948349,
-0.24517181515693665,
0.35910800099372864,
-0.06526850908994675,
-0.289619117975235,
-0.3855833113193512,
-0.09480392187833786,
0.44107943773269653,
-0.5796095132827759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03062v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03062v1
|
RadBARTsum: Domain Specific Adaption of Denoising Sequence-to-Sequence Models for Abstractive Radiology Report Summarization
| 2024-06-05T08:43:11 | 2024-06-05T08:43:11 |
Jinge Wu, Abul Hasan, Honghan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Radiology report summarization is a crucial task that can help doctors
quickly identify clinically significant findings without the need to review
detailed sections of reports. This study proposes RadBARTsum, a domain-specific
and ontology facilitated adaptation of the BART model for abstractive radiology
report summarization. The approach involves two main steps: 1) re-training the
BART model on a large corpus of radiology reports using a novel entity masking
strategy to improving biomedical domain knowledge learning, and 2) fine-tuning
the model for the summarization task using the Findings and Background sections
to predict the Impression section. Experiments are conducted using different
masking strategies. Results show that the re-training process with domain
knowledge facilitated masking improves performances consistently across various
settings. This work contributes a domain-specific generative language model for
radiology report summarization and a method for utilising medical knowledge to
realise entity masking language model. The proposed approach demonstrates a
promising direction of enhancing the efficiency of language models by deepening
its understanding of clinical knowledge in radiology reports.
|
[
-0.3180540204048157,
-0.6163815855979919,
0.4478714168071747,
0.12350784987211227,
-0.4058816134929657,
0.30505266785621643,
0.026732059195637703,
-0.7780654430389404,
0.4324586093425751,
0.7377380132675171,
-0.34010422229766846,
-0.5614059567451477,
-0.6925369501113892,
0.21523937582969666,
-0.18138405680656433,
1.1022188663482666,
-0.04614079371094704,
0.06045300513505936,
-0.3972306549549103,
-0.1146104484796524,
-0.774073600769043,
-0.1926693320274353,
-0.41583728790283203,
-0.33756113052368164,
0.17201034724712372,
0.4857126772403717,
0.7091166973114014,
0.459566593170166,
0.6732625365257263,
0.1368831843137741,
0.1985335350036621,
0.3721904754638672,
-0.4538043737411499,
0.34775230288505554,
-0.31369835138320923,
-0.2800626754760742,
-0.961015522480011,
-0.588832676410675,
0.5855682492256165,
0.9507837891578674,
-0.296698659658432,
-0.1166873425245285,
-0.27325621247291565,
0.7093225717544556,
-0.5029850602149963,
0.24320250749588013,
-0.39486590027809143,
-0.01014230027794838,
0.23359739780426025,
-0.6560494899749756,
-0.5990397930145264,
-0.24963194131851196,
-0.005280177108943462,
-0.889473021030426,
0.3968103528022766,
0.15095895528793335,
0.8340349197387695,
-0.035875219851732254,
0.025045640766620636,
-0.20783239603042603,
-0.6012081503868103,
0.6349233388900757,
-0.7512022256851196,
0.15231424570083618,
0.4808219373226166,
0.23387765884399414,
0.1619633287191391,
-1.0507487058639526,
-0.06078696995973587,
0.27653032541275024,
-0.3538149297237396,
0.3519638180732727,
-0.3601132929325104,
0.2511007785797119,
-0.005457236431539059,
0.3061823844909668,
-0.7489409446716309,
-0.14430831372737885,
-0.4476988613605499,
-0.013757331296801567,
0.6144867539405823,
0.4779512584209442,
0.41353654861450195,
-0.07620684057474136,
-0.19706928730010986,
-0.05040888860821724,
-0.6389293670654297,
-0.4562436044216156,
-0.5685120820999146,
0.08922964334487915,
-0.19604584574699402,
0.1355038434267044,
-0.5009973049163818,
0.7175707817077637,
0.06988294422626495,
-0.19109651446342468,
0.27822479605674744,
0.11565736681222916,
-0.3593935966491699,
0.28272372484207153,
0.10817967355251312,
0.22382724285125732,
-0.12238506227731705,
-0.21927505731582642,
-0.3085036277770996,
0.1211104691028595,
0.47987568378448486,
-1.0350966453552246,
-0.487454354763031,
0.24991774559020996,
-0.544249951839447,
-0.45070725679397583,
-0.12563078105449677,
-0.34174060821533203,
-0.24957552552223206,
-0.1833505481481552,
0.40268829464912415,
-0.587083637714386,
-0.26457175612449646,
0.5807679295539856,
0.12436985224485397,
-0.09989107400178909,
0.6829460263252258,
-0.8713281750679016,
0.5560387372970581,
0.4352753162384033,
0.8187353014945984,
0.006634557619690895,
0.16211411356925964,
-0.33582010865211487,
0.5623248219490051,
-0.26268336176872253,
1.1321102380752563,
-0.7087714076042175,
-0.6320047974586487,
-0.24423015117645264,
0.05372030660510063,
-0.021349608898162842,
-0.499508798122406,
0.1468624472618103,
-1.0133811235427856,
0.044214878231287,
0.07227545231580734,
-0.5070491433143616,
-0.6958224177360535,
-0.10142229497432709,
-0.4511276185512543,
0.3660008907318115,
0.410425066947937,
-0.7829272150993347,
0.20319601893424988,
-0.7338443398475647,
-0.7728844285011292,
0.315727174282074,
-0.2698875963687897,
-0.5981792211532593,
0.2319728136062622,
0.3204130530357361,
0.5559570789337158,
-0.12601548433303833,
0.111548513174057,
0.11489570140838623,
-0.2767561674118042,
0.2657420337200165,
0.3117070198059082,
0.6537055969238281,
0.24868227541446686,
0.25106027722358704,
0.19694094359874725,
-0.6895725727081299,
0.018933145329356194,
0.14915384352207184,
-0.04701339453458786,
-0.5493845343589783,
-0.2529989778995514,
0.047084540128707886,
-0.02170499414205551,
-0.29867279529571533,
-0.28656667470932007,
0.11560318619012833,
-0.4452653229236603,
0.17974740266799927,
0.2800213098526001,
0.5182997584342957,
0.363193541765213,
-0.9592616558074951,
0.9376505017280579,
-0.09275785088539124,
-0.13434244692325592,
-0.4726727306842804,
-0.6225054860115051,
-0.3227321207523346,
-0.7002261281013489,
0.5694326758384705,
0.4188774526119232,
-0.48728662729263306,
0.08302539587020874,
-0.6012002229690552,
-0.3261892795562744,
-0.45910438895225525,
-0.2874070107936859,
0.35535353422164917,
0.5089243650436401,
0.37423524260520935,
-1.1213306188583374,
-0.8424541354179382,
-0.5207184553146362,
0.22831442952156067,
0.098637655377388,
-0.04743815213441849,
0.11885804682970047,
0.27152663469314575,
-0.2808379828929901,
0.903021514415741,
-0.8068113327026367,
-0.6229240894317627,
-0.44158345460891724,
0.3486599326133728,
0.12416509538888931,
0.33809542655944824,
0.5673605799674988,
-0.542239785194397,
-0.38003674149513245,
0.043009378015995026,
-1.0363898277282715,
-0.20658192038536072,
-0.1979777216911316,
0.009816301055252552,
0.25289687514305115,
0.5887773036956787,
-0.2569321393966675,
0.6438711285591125,
0.5514717698097229,
-0.2203558385372162,
0.4093571901321411,
-0.5436583161354065,
0.2766021490097046,
-1.052718997001648,
0.20261840522289276,
-0.444341242313385,
-0.7105579376220703,
-0.5581499338150024,
0.13102860748767853,
0.022856254130601883,
-0.17724789679050446,
-0.031734365969896317,
0.29068389534950256,
-0.9138746857643127,
-0.28721264004707336,
-0.47548094391822815,
0.0461200587451458,
0.5509551167488098,
0.2234586924314499,
0.5837141871452332,
0.2598576843738556,
0.767062783241272,
-0.7629818320274353,
-0.13484448194503784,
0.8175028562545776,
-0.6282774209976196,
0.217040553689003,
-0.5135775804519653,
0.013117517344653606,
-0.3696536123752594,
0.30062243342399597,
-1.0137460231781006,
-0.27475640177726746,
-0.08517646789550781,
-0.567048192024231,
0.7790206670761108,
-0.14968931674957275,
0.09514981508255005,
0.09382966160774231,
-0.2545223832130432,
0.5952851176261902,
0.6072984337806702,
-0.1203838661313057,
0.8522492051124573,
0.5381303429603577,
-0.7093507051467896,
-0.579897403717041,
-0.8305651545524597,
0.2764156758785248,
0.0495620034635067,
-0.7117344737052917,
0.8989598751068115,
0.04848574474453926,
-0.17051129043102264,
0.10299123078584671,
0.08810892701148987,
-0.17315173149108887,
0.043138839304447174,
0.4282469153404236,
0.3693259060382843,
-0.48991769552230835,
-0.04401965066790581,
0.39476147294044495,
-0.201578751206398,
0.06543689966201782,
0.27663272619247437,
0.2552594542503357,
0.22286172211170197,
-0.04824100807309151,
-0.22406350076198578,
0.4306810200214386,
0.39241844415664673,
-0.09379778057336807,
0.5757191181182861,
0.18613721430301666,
-0.3867698609828949,
-0.2995171546936035,
-0.3642892837524414,
-0.6031413078308105,
-0.35897326469421387,
0.852408766746521,
-0.43979355692863464,
-0.6765176057815552,
0.6267165541648865,
-0.14158783853054047,
0.08710171282291412,
0.1512148380279541,
0.5947041511535645,
-0.002255941741168499,
0.5145584940910339,
0.7407989501953125,
0.21998992562294006,
0.05896636098623276,
-0.3468310534954071,
0.24073803424835205,
-0.8018810749053955,
-0.12023372948169708,
-0.10333720594644547,
0.19408003985881805,
0.002942949067801237,
-0.4519921541213989,
0.621016263961792,
-0.0674649104475975,
0.35650497674942017,
0.05520293861627579,
-0.48951923847198486,
0.35784879326820374,
-0.13487175107002258,
0.3656274378299713,
0.7970994710922241,
0.40507054328918457,
0.4349466860294342,
-0.0959818959236145,
-1.026000738143921,
-0.22227218747138977,
1.108168601989746,
0.2905851900577545,
0.8746460676193237,
0.2522013485431671,
0.5112841725349426,
0.7409234046936035,
0.6115121245384216,
-0.514728307723999,
0.3201788663864136,
-0.07067292183637619,
-0.508945107460022,
-0.2335025817155838,
-0.017203979194164276,
-0.9788516163825989,
0.2056555300951004,
-0.40219390392303467,
-0.07034444808959961,
0.26284512877464294,
-0.004282935988157988,
-0.6794293522834778,
0.07664915174245834,
-0.2997158169746399,
0.3639872372150421,
0.4700833261013031,
-0.037719689309597015,
-0.7805395722389221,
-0.7010632753372192,
0.5442895293235779,
-0.22208917140960693,
0.6504843235015869,
-0.11942600458860397,
0.006309316027909517,
0.8430984020233154,
-0.31952133774757385,
1.0456403493881226,
0.036145709455013275,
0.0221113171428442,
0.18619662523269653,
0.5545905828475952,
0.20618653297424316,
0.19011379778385162,
0.3083040416240692,
0.2467065155506134,
-0.059787943959236145,
-0.32323503494262695,
-0.32945993542671204,
0.5984905362129211,
-0.6371914744377136,
-0.517536997795105,
-0.5624883770942688,
-0.9088084697723389,
-0.29328814148902893,
-0.0007279176497831941,
0.18569046258926392,
0.8375537395477295,
-0.5231903195381165,
-0.32000303268432617,
0.8879184126853943,
-0.34343600273132324,
0.1004243791103363,
0.8879614472389221,
-0.3355567753314972,
-0.269775927066803,
0.7622846364974976,
-0.12510503828525543,
0.34601032733917236,
0.7687987089157104,
-0.03807792812585831,
0.06296169757843018,
-0.7411115169525146,
-0.3738698363304138,
0.49513673782348633,
-0.9390544891357422,
-0.6382457613945007,
-0.9473183155059814,
-0.3131067752838135,
-0.717592179775238,
-0.5434257388114929,
-0.019532103091478348,
-0.911387026309967,
-0.08356890082359314,
-0.017460614442825317,
0.762602686882019,
0.913806676864624,
-0.3585430383682251,
0.07724739611148834,
-0.7161304950714111,
0.3888157606124878,
0.04837064445018768,
0.16488970816135406,
0.060399629175662994,
-1.2309927940368652,
-0.5268195867538452,
-0.46827059984207153,
-0.16238664090633392,
-0.5881559252738953,
0.6027969121932983,
0.42235663533210754,
0.20936089754104614,
0.26042646169662476,
0.2947964072227478,
0.383906751871109,
-0.38934406638145447,
0.19848406314849854,
0.20900438725948334,
-0.7326536774635315,
0.4477534294128418,
-0.35745352506637573,
0.10939080268144608,
0.2187962383031845,
0.25153878331184387,
-0.5183568000793457,
-0.4594731330871582,
-0.4887004792690277,
-0.9157865643501282,
0.7405904531478882,
-0.18803800642490387,
0.054068971425294876,
-0.0037717297673225403,
0.3929000794887543,
0.2616788446903229,
-0.1414821445941925,
-0.33634722232818604,
-0.23166939616203308,
-0.14785371720790863,
-0.04275818541646004,
0.2046046406030655,
-0.7039669752120972,
-0.30322781205177307,
-0.13044574856758118,
0.9654255509376526,
0.07247184962034225,
0.4479295313358307,
0.44494011998176575,
-0.48129066824913025,
-0.21492348611354828,
0.19910836219787598,
0.9471669793128967,
1.1393285989761353,
-0.4624638855457306,
0.004852754529565573,
0.09549589455127716,
-0.7765868306159973,
-0.05299067124724388,
-0.2995539903640747,
-0.05680383741855621,
0.44206929206848145,
0.48629626631736755,
0.5054201483726501,
0.2722366750240326,
-0.5897000432014465,
0.5527548789978027,
0.002172961598262191,
-0.37223970890045166,
-0.20516952872276306,
-0.05982065945863724,
0.037694163620471954,
-0.21211186051368713,
0.19049586355686188,
0.3166297972202301,
0.3472368121147156,
-0.2960679829120636,
0.36851534247398376,
0.005246447864919901,
-0.20449316501617432,
-0.43178799748420715,
0.7412862181663513,
0.08022776991128922,
0.28454262018203735,
0.28113120794296265,
0.14697657525539398,
-0.06594020128250122,
0.44772854447364807,
0.7462124228477478,
0.6631141304969788,
-0.5935183763504028,
0.23111867904663086,
0.4947354793548584,
0.08512687683105469,
0.016705570742487907,
0.17994774878025055,
0.19790413975715637,
-0.7717275023460388,
-0.772739589214325,
-0.1359313428401947,
-0.43527793884277344,
-0.23312599956989288,
-1.0061936378479004,
0.20328053832054138,
-0.6615421772003174,
0.05800678953528404,
0.16666696965694427,
-0.4533863961696625,
-0.1262071430683136,
0.5194036960601807,
-0.04956330358982086,
0.755377471446991,
-0.9616808891296387,
0.9925245046615601,
0.6710063815116882,
-0.5351552367210388,
-0.3978734314441681,
-0.564399242401123,
-0.3590761423110962,
-1.1680089235305786,
0.7071660757064819,
-0.2823413908481598,
-0.18829673528671265,
-0.05919468775391579,
-0.03318279609084129,
-0.7936152219772339,
1.0602740049362183,
0.0637337788939476,
-0.34550777077674866,
-0.007669869810342789,
-0.06910683214664459,
0.2458709329366684,
-0.6774101257324219,
0.2166585773229599,
0.3220655024051666,
0.016962628811597824,
0.005375033710151911,
-0.705237090587616,
0.5253831744194031,
-0.11351016908884048,
0.11821240931749344,
0.052257172763347626,
-0.09879204630851746,
0.5799053311347961,
-0.7086026668548584,
-0.17239396274089813,
0.06227460131049156,
0.7849974632263184,
0.14451968669891357,
0.30319473147392273,
0.1450163722038269,
0.4016607999801636,
0.6159730553627014,
0.23057329654693604,
1.1321520805358887,
-0.35885077714920044,
0.20511779189109802,
1.0630742311477661,
-0.338514506816864,
0.5341871976852417,
0.13981059193611145,
0.010524149052798748,
1.0977143049240112,
0.14742086827754974,
0.22164306044578552,
0.9631924629211426,
0.05353902280330658,
-0.4897148013114929,
-0.26246482133865356,
-0.15944136679172516,
-0.7076671123504639,
0.22560593485832214,
0.6851418614387512,
-0.2665196657180786,
-0.057489652186632156,
0.22710064053535461,
0.02321295067667961,
0.1899891495704651,
-0.4244627058506012,
0.8434314727783203,
0.30941927433013916,
-0.3719015419483185,
0.871507465839386,
0.33602532744407654,
0.36046841740608215,
-0.7173059582710266,
-0.107378289103508,
-0.4053601622581482,
0.18143092095851898,
-0.5543449521064758,
-0.2972022593021393,
0.6958121061325073,
-0.2673775255680084,
-0.7272987365722656,
-0.0199287086725235,
0.6864452362060547,
-0.24980086088180542,
-0.35245072841644287,
-0.09475132822990417,
0.2761407494544983,
0.22126351296901703,
0.07815985381603241,
-0.3173394501209259,
0.13119646906852722,
0.008292312733829021,
0.017234940081834793,
0.5646998882293701,
0.28856948018074036,
-0.3001382052898407,
0.6003078818321228,
0.26435789465904236,
0.1188451498746872,
-0.5374657511711121,
0.29021430015563965,
0.8662427067756653,
-0.5883548259735107,
-0.7845391035079956,
-0.27133986353874207,
0.31840622425079346,
0.12666110694408417,
0.2682096064090729,
0.3273879587650299,
0.5757305026054382,
0.3933316767215729,
-0.4537370204925537,
0.9734222888946533,
-0.04938673600554466,
0.9039627313613892,
-0.659823477268219,
0.8429706692695618,
-0.21530623733997345,
0.49826937913894653,
-0.2594932019710541,
-0.44173914194107056,
-0.6404106616973877,
0.7987157702445984,
-0.19741171598434448,
0.08688642829656601,
0.8701293468475342,
0.9484266638755798,
-0.1351737231016159,
0.014410962350666523,
0.6885574460029602,
0.4974324703216553,
-0.01775699108839035,
0.6786003708839417,
0.3909197449684143,
-0.5920050144195557,
0.3485492765903473,
-0.0963403657078743,
-0.4338551163673401,
-0.4140670597553253,
-0.7443265914916992,
-0.7717693448066711,
-0.5227726101875305,
-0.9659760594367981,
-0.5958600640296936,
0.2505408227443695,
0.4010341763496399,
0.8558670282363892,
-0.9802138805389404,
-0.10083068162202835,
0.23901702463626862,
-0.22757886350154877,
-0.34612682461738586,
-0.20451763272285461,
0.7566148042678833,
-0.16467350721359253,
0.033112186938524246,
0.2868751585483551,
0.4972688555717468,
-0.10277193784713745,
0.21790029108524323,
-0.019696807488799095,
0.17678414285182953,
0.13736113905906677,
0.6299529075622559,
0.3793295919895172,
-0.4980739951133728,
-0.08296849578619003,
-0.16715164482593536,
-0.008954320102930069,
0.30711179971694946,
0.9796836376190186,
-0.9232515692710876,
0.5286315083503723,
0.09756729751825333,
0.4894746243953705,
0.6965839266777039,
0.004451423417776823,
0.5063802003860474,
-0.7361057996749878,
0.221631720662117,
0.19684463739395142,
0.2659491002559662,
0.4240841269493103,
-0.37026387453079224,
0.3928099274635315,
0.18152478337287903,
-0.3623533546924591,
-0.6871272325515747,
0.09448658674955368,
-1.3188464641571045,
-0.667850136756897,
0.8726934194564819,
-0.250873863697052,
-0.07685672491788864,
-0.6706429719924927,
-0.17522600293159485,
0.053810298442840576,
-0.20437341928482056,
1.1688424348831177,
0.017877839505672455,
-0.22160232067108154,
-0.18327738344669342,
-0.1450873613357544,
0.5999248027801514,
0.4953746795654297,
-0.6462973356246948,
0.1315787434577942,
0.5030016303062439,
0.7234170436859131,
-0.07400160282850266,
1.0464388132095337,
-0.3967239260673523,
0.7852744460105896,
-0.08912371844053268,
0.4950430691242218,
-0.3436116874217987,
-0.14905978739261627,
-0.4376053214073181,
0.1840153932571411,
0.30998215079307556,
-0.0741206482052803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03049v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03049v1
|
StreamSpeech: Simultaneous Speech-to-Speech Translation with Multi-task Learning
| 2024-06-05T08:24:22 | 2024-06-05T08:24:22 |
Shaolei Zhang, Qingkai Fang, Shoutao Guo, Zhengrui Ma, Min Zhang, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Simultaneous speech-to-speech translation (Simul-S2ST, a.k.a streaming speech
translation) outputs target speech while receiving streaming speech inputs,
which is critical for real-time communication. Beyond accomplishing translation
between speech, Simul-S2ST requires a policy to control the model to generate
corresponding target speech at the opportune moment within speech inputs,
thereby posing a double challenge of translation and policy. In this paper, we
propose StreamSpeech, a direct Simul-S2ST model that jointly learns translation
and simultaneous policy in a unified framework of multi-task learning. Adhering
to a multi-task learning approach, StreamSpeech can perform offline and
simultaneous speech recognition, speech translation and speech synthesis via an
"All-in-One" seamless model. Experiments on CVSS benchmark demonstrate that
StreamSpeech achieves state-of-the-art performance in both offline S2ST and
Simul-S2ST tasks. Besides, StreamSpeech is able to present high-quality
intermediate results (i.e., ASR or translation results) during simultaneous
translation process, offering a more comprehensive real-time communication
experience.
|
[
0.031615614891052246,
-0.684247612953186,
0.24268148839473724,
0.46465426683425903,
-0.5892184376716614,
0.3267396092414856,
-0.38815391063690186,
-0.0877450555562973,
0.09911755472421646,
0.3616967499256134,
-0.8467566967010498,
0.06490575522184372,
-0.8885324001312256,
-0.0019071106798946857,
-0.5135630965232849,
0.864203929901123,
-0.13108232617378235,
0.37298300862312317,
-0.30747395753860474,
0.18201875686645508,
-0.6181303262710571,
-0.33037394285202026,
-0.7629517316818237,
-0.35754668712615967,
0.2857793867588043,
0.4829305410385132,
0.35452690720558167,
0.49182257056236267,
0.2860490381717682,
0.28191009163856506,
0.1504029631614685,
0.26859644055366516,
-0.49355199933052063,
0.6004477739334106,
-0.18103687465190887,
-0.34419628977775574,
-0.20004762709140778,
-0.18647803366184235,
0.8807564377784729,
0.2798682451248169,
-0.3058278560638428,
0.2840496897697449,
0.360487163066864,
0.3704356253147125,
-0.4871819019317627,
0.3910360038280487,
-0.5492931008338928,
-0.14873220026493073,
-0.40444454550743103,
-0.2154039591550827,
-0.475314199924469,
-0.036631349474191666,
-0.09974535554647446,
-0.4606100916862488,
-0.10205920040607452,
-0.15063264966011047,
0.7931398153305054,
0.47203412652015686,
-0.4719039499759674,
-0.10640227794647217,
-0.8234710097312927,
0.9286132454872131,
-0.4046107828617096,
0.7417409420013428,
0.261770099401474,
0.44852516055107117,
-0.040468692779541016,
-0.7666100263595581,
-0.508773684501648,
-0.07961610704660416,
0.28558290004730225,
0.4815308153629303,
-0.07357430458068848,
-0.1911367028951645,
0.08824421465396881,
-0.0592321902513504,
-0.4443783164024353,
-0.1472638100385666,
-0.34899041056632996,
-0.18059642612934113,
0.5855509638786316,
0.1324382722377777,
0.10541178286075592,
-0.17084021866321564,
-0.7415671348571777,
-0.04855121299624443,
-0.4181567430496216,
0.4357471466064453,
0.24216696619987488,
0.8055585622787476,
-0.2720518708229065,
0.32458770275115967,
-0.4108161926269531,
0.45054611563682556,
-0.22751982510089874,
-0.2834114730358124,
0.1398625671863556,
-0.3611687421798706,
-0.0006289798766374588,
0.1993323117494583,
0.6754685640335083,
-0.23041322827339172,
-0.2653152048587799,
-0.3322054147720337,
-0.09394224733114243,
0.03171379864215851,
0.4507990777492523,
-0.45402514934539795,
0.29520973563194275,
0.4188964068889618,
-0.10506762564182281,
-0.1974613219499588,
-0.10059089213609695,
-0.38692963123321533,
-0.034830767661333084,
-0.694783091545105,
0.5250509977340698,
-0.19943644106388092,
-0.726776123046875,
-0.2150893211364746,
-0.08613434433937073,
0.014367562718689442,
0.5186602473258972,
-0.38780447840690613,
0.64037024974823,
0.8481053113937378,
1.0167535543441772,
-0.5398454666137695,
-0.9161673784255981,
-1.0006911754608154,
0.3099464178085327,
-0.2505996525287628,
0.8304435014724731,
-0.18676917254924774,
-0.46691781282424927,
-0.12736962735652924,
-0.19226689636707306,
-0.25383320450782776,
-0.10031257569789886,
0.35184016823768616,
0.04879327118396759,
-0.251674622297287,
-0.41373828053474426,
-0.5085161924362183,
0.10838552564382553,
-0.17944109439849854,
-0.35959962010383606,
1.0972521305084229,
-0.05753225460648537,
-0.5999160408973694,
0.03711865842342377,
-0.5150057077407837,
-0.6438722610473633,
0.23888731002807617,
-0.170831561088562,
-0.4365277886390686,
0.044884130358695984,
-0.1864694356918335,
0.43235528469085693,
-0.3678239583969116,
0.481569766998291,
-0.08380018919706345,
-0.2752755880355835,
0.06226314976811409,
-0.4795502722263336,
0.884781539440155,
0.3207247257232666,
-0.5021471381187439,
0.2415575236082077,
-0.1953679472208023,
0.06796690076589584,
0.31771692633628845,
-0.2752402126789093,
0.11086861044168472,
0.40590760111808777,
0.44292938709259033,
0.518511950969696,
0.09384111315011978,
-0.8032808899879456,
0.026200924068689346,
0.08024611324071884,
0.7041857838630676,
0.4970698356628418,
-0.3435182273387909,
0.45957842469215393,
-0.10160551965236664,
0.17405414581298828,
-0.0194501131772995,
0.3550345003604889,
-0.1518852859735489,
-0.5268306136131287,
-0.6583980321884155,
-0.3041139245033264,
0.2538478672504425,
0.7716384530067444,
-0.8236539959907532,
0.13294300436973572,
-0.5966333150863647,
-0.426776647567749,
-0.7365190386772156,
0.16588270664215088,
0.6021518111228943,
0.42386844754219055,
0.42775020003318787,
-0.25081101059913635,
-0.26978591084480286,
-0.58927983045578,
-0.523777425289154,
0.028738446533679962,
0.12624138593673706,
0.12702679634094238,
0.16213345527648926,
0.13215918838977814,
0.636798620223999,
-0.1637793630361557,
-0.5474539399147034,
-0.4991929829120636,
0.224153533577919,
-0.3055313527584076,
0.3581355810165405,
-0.10771271586418152,
-0.8339915871620178,
-0.6587568521499634,
-0.22251346707344055,
-0.451709121465683,
-0.0021063259337097406,
-0.2902142107486725,
-0.05715437978506088,
0.10485152900218964,
0.5119256377220154,
-0.5814076662063599,
0.4358450174331665,
0.7825848460197449,
0.004288788419216871,
0.5313171744346619,
-0.11765283346176147,
0.19662237167358398,
-1.327587604522705,
-0.1565730720758438,
-0.5309222340583801,
-0.51192706823349,
-0.7795427441596985,
0.2882559895515442,
0.2631683945655823,
-0.47837916016578674,
-0.8704020380973816,
0.42645177245140076,
-0.21386773884296417,
-0.25715622305870056,
-0.25478607416152954,
0.05238402634859085,
-0.0447869710624218,
0.3998350203037262,
0.12789908051490784,
1.1329401731491089,
0.6755919456481934,
-0.39048507809638977,
0.5187101364135742,
0.3906101584434509,
-0.18279334902763367,
0.48566269874572754,
-0.3315443992614746,
0.11535684764385223,
0.23835501074790955,
0.6161187291145325,
-1.0717923641204834,
-0.15313781797885895,
-0.04071866720914841,
-0.5497516393661499,
0.3039447069168091,
-0.052847810089588165,
-0.4234657883644104,
-0.2620437741279602,
0.12686240673065186,
0.23817157745361328,
0.36927899718284607,
-0.39433205127716064,
0.7881986498832703,
0.4871356785297394,
-0.6582576632499695,
-0.4484440088272095,
-0.661112368106842,
0.2886209487915039,
0.3186712861061096,
-0.4120911955833435,
0.36914944648742676,
0.13207130134105682,
0.22646977007389069,
-0.043791331350803375,
-0.337330162525177,
-0.14494000375270844,
-0.2595711946487427,
0.5823689699172974,
0.20447678864002228,
0.17222128808498383,
-0.10874515026807785,
0.36369574069976807,
-0.1957552284002304,
-0.2181515246629715,
-0.22143180668354034,
0.5836296677589417,
0.03687923401594162,
-0.5109550356864929,
-0.5785532593727112,
0.924734354019165,
0.3265242874622345,
-0.36529868841171265,
0.28346869349479675,
0.49333831667900085,
0.003190306480973959,
-0.5298857092857361,
-0.4992406964302063,
-0.28182128071784973,
-0.4526495933532715,
0.33640027046203613,
-0.6935877203941345,
-0.885277509689331,
0.05447166785597801,
-0.4261417090892792,
0.13706845045089722,
0.21331040561199188,
0.5230721235275269,
-0.3711261451244354,
0.8150968551635742,
0.09238791465759277,
0.21139879524707794,
0.4056870639324188,
-0.1481623351573944,
0.3478100299835205,
-0.6454384922981262,
-0.34121882915496826,
-0.3981037437915802,
-0.09078342467546463,
-0.19887495040893555,
-0.6771764755249023,
0.354348748922348,
0.1316920667886734,
-0.12766143679618835,
0.6075002551078796,
-0.2390090376138687,
0.24851465225219727,
0.8209224343299866,
0.10771199315786362,
-0.007910279557108879,
0.31765615940093994,
-0.15112446248531342,
-0.04428411275148392,
-0.7383837699890137,
0.018188683316111565,
0.6679648756980896,
0.11352893710136414,
0.3814094364643097,
0.004244566895067692,
0.7386206388473511,
0.3409574329853058,
-0.2575845718383789,
-0.7453691363334656,
0.44749030470848083,
-0.42780447006225586,
-0.37399595975875854,
-0.40932655334472656,
-0.5827195644378662,
-0.7082743644714355,
0.38503924012184143,
-0.1525903195142746,
-0.3980426490306854,
-0.33039265871047974,
0.2600950598716736,
-0.2602396309375763,
0.3930515646934509,
-0.6065211296081543,
0.604593813419342,
-0.3594542443752289,
-0.5136025547981262,
-0.4699980616569519,
-0.7906370759010315,
0.14105132222175598,
0.06180424988269806,
0.3348202407360077,
-0.4135414659976959,
-0.06927783042192459,
0.5107165575027466,
0.0469677671790123,
0.7294455766677856,
-0.2874343693256378,
0.25559765100479126,
0.28923478722572327,
0.38060855865478516,
0.5792921185493469,
-0.11631917208433151,
0.4007883071899414,
0.7523403763771057,
0.23280203342437744,
-0.5991644263267517,
-0.16631212830543518,
0.8651471138000488,
-0.8254459500312805,
-0.38932639360427856,
-0.7001118659973145,
-0.6373746991157532,
-0.3997304141521454,
0.282532274723053,
0.13098610937595367,
0.45310279726982117,
-0.23630474507808685,
-0.05136317014694214,
0.2551126480102539,
-0.008620553649961948,
0.43690577149391174,
0.5707876086235046,
-0.1546531617641449,
-0.25361061096191406,
1.382035493850708,
0.21077193319797516,
0.536775529384613,
0.2986413538455963,
0.13939006626605988,
-0.5444819927215576,
-0.1734594702720642,
-0.5967528820037842,
0.19254843890666962,
-0.3088834285736084,
-0.2940903604030609,
-0.641207754611969,
-0.5373006463050842,
-0.7154214978218079,
0.02858472242951393,
-0.8639082908630371,
-0.27526459097862244,
-0.016894809901714325,
0.2857476770877838,
0.05032358318567276,
0.6477977633476257,
-0.2579558491706848,
0.37273868918418884,
-0.7578649520874023,
0.775546133518219,
0.5665323138237,
0.2840293347835541,
-0.32140928506851196,
-0.5129389762878418,
-0.04001379385590553,
0.23921218514442444,
-0.27788883447647095,
-0.8141470551490784,
0.18691307306289673,
0.280964195728302,
0.21215584874153137,
0.06951502710580826,
-0.0963699147105217,
0.8847267031669617,
-1.0578393936157227,
0.7982236742973328,
0.504277229309082,
-1.1537961959838867,
0.45331642031669617,
-0.28475508093833923,
0.4662635028362274,
0.4643266201019287,
0.05650630593299866,
-0.8377058506011963,
-0.38995060324668884,
-0.409403532743454,
-0.7655471563339233,
1.1125271320343018,
0.4119648337364197,
0.2000887244939804,
0.29736173152923584,
-0.16060414910316467,
0.23518215119838715,
0.31273508071899414,
0.037511467933654785,
-0.15298329293727875,
-0.41940197348594666,
0.21293316781520844,
-0.16837137937545776,
-0.05777939781546593,
-0.05360144376754761,
-0.29995235800743103,
0.7682554721832275,
0.1101418137550354,
0.44708487391471863,
-0.10365570336580276,
-0.014492860063910484,
-0.1624073088169098,
0.38096633553504944,
0.7020222544670105,
0.32316693663597107,
-0.04590759426355362,
0.048174623399972916,
0.0657140463590622,
-0.500718891620636,
0.1339651644229889,
0.22145818173885345,
-0.11685898900032043,
0.07933203130960464,
0.16063207387924194,
1.1974384784698486,
0.5602802634239197,
-0.5163019299507141,
0.9300609827041626,
-0.024661844596266747,
-0.38420966267585754,
-0.2784244418144226,
-0.1368037313222885,
0.3468294143676758,
0.153427854180336,
0.2706054151058197,
0.612537145614624,
-0.05249195173382759,
-0.14387570321559906,
0.3481089472770691,
0.13305871188640594,
-0.4584598243236542,
-0.23624520003795624,
0.8147836327552795,
0.5947790145874023,
-0.4311269521713257,
0.4385993480682373,
-0.16543613374233246,
-0.34953853487968445,
0.2556912302970886,
0.44292065501213074,
0.9438856244087219,
-0.807447075843811,
0.5250061750411987,
0.18404629826545715,
-0.009598685428500175,
-0.3458671569824219,
0.5768946409225464,
-0.44778138399124146,
-0.12941773235797882,
-0.777807891368866,
-0.750783383846283,
-0.4466455578804016,
-0.11831329017877579,
-0.8259388208389282,
0.2673453390598297,
0.04637249559164047,
-0.12235482782125473,
-0.023566393181681633,
-0.3536542057991028,
-0.6019490957260132,
0.00816037692129612,
0.34410545229911804,
0.7277252674102783,
-0.9827155470848083,
1.2589073181152344,
0.3323388993740082,
-0.3671286106109619,
-0.9406912326812744,
-0.16322660446166992,
0.3066616356372833,
-0.8594127297401428,
0.5012264251708984,
-0.16213464736938477,
-0.3279350996017456,
0.39948856830596924,
-0.227996826171875,
-0.9396263957023621,
0.9214733839035034,
0.4766715466976166,
-0.855133056640625,
-0.11234211176633835,
0.42488259077072144,
-0.030552776530385017,
-0.026812169700860977,
0.007271811366081238,
0.3336973786354065,
0.1531640887260437,
0.2414112389087677,
-1.336187720298767,
-0.36241769790649414,
0.09665608406066895,
-0.055228687822818756,
0.318818062543869,
-0.7787868976593018,
0.9339463710784912,
-0.032926253974437714,
-0.3125731945037842,
-0.36494481563568115,
0.6150110363960266,
0.14474889636039734,
0.12866754829883575,
0.5606008172035217,
0.3619476556777954,
0.14493052661418915,
-0.15940435230731964,
1.056150197982788,
-0.022609466686844826,
0.33785948157310486,
1.5905832052230835,
-0.35076791048049927,
1.528062343597412,
0.8698155879974365,
-0.3498677909374237,
-0.032150667160749435,
0.26566648483276367,
0.41459083557128906,
0.7753963470458984,
-0.09706348180770874,
-0.43273964524269104,
-0.5201968550682068,
-0.47705355286598206,
-0.24105575680732727,
0.6316997408866882,
0.32644912600517273,
0.3340214490890503,
-0.4884051978588104,
0.3081468343734741,
-0.001399293658323586,
-0.028572482988238335,
-0.2011738121509552,
0.8616209030151367,
0.27306291460990906,
-0.6616681218147278,
0.4754275381565094,
-0.15301446616649628,
0.44087404012680054,
-0.9439133405685425,
-0.17702648043632507,
-0.002833264647051692,
0.1269349753856659,
0.053591255098581314,
-0.6399356722831726,
0.3055654466152191,
-0.1676277369260788,
0.18422213196754456,
-0.5477530360221863,
0.5949236154556274,
-0.8504668474197388,
-0.375781387090683,
0.44884514808654785,
0.6256198883056641,
0.1610139161348343,
-0.35763415694236755,
-1.1295099258422852,
0.3727785646915436,
0.03930198773741722,
-0.035141471773386,
0.43048426508903503,
-0.14304859936237335,
0.0729890912771225,
0.598576009273529,
0.7948192358016968,
0.6423896551132202,
0.5031231045722961,
0.10283313691616058,
0.5688632130622864,
-0.053967297077178955,
-0.8714770674705505,
-0.3417452573776245,
0.4766314923763275,
-0.17708748579025269,
-0.15396621823310852,
0.5964986681938171,
0.575987696647644,
1.0236204862594604,
-0.07824978232383728,
1.062628984451294,
-0.14224305748939514,
0.9149597883224487,
0.008840465918183327,
0.6486374139785767,
-0.6676447987556458,
-0.5557543039321899,
0.112403005361557,
-0.7330132126808167,
0.20725518465042114,
0.29137662053108215,
0.06033466011285782,
-0.5571002960205078,
0.8569077253341675,
0.5296764373779297,
-0.40754467248916626,
0.17666561901569366,
0.5628299713134766,
-0.09238386899232864,
0.10070411115884781,
0.3865097463130951,
0.6276375651359558,
-0.6030473709106445,
0.7296929955482483,
-0.4243389964103699,
-0.19124673306941986,
0.04933406412601471,
-0.49350234866142273,
-0.4964327812194824,
-1.2451378107070923,
-0.20148788392543793,
-0.2683696448802948,
0.31687602400779724,
0.9578816294670105,
0.7712876796722412,
-0.9678844809532166,
-0.6172091364860535,
0.024281468242406845,
-0.44304242730140686,
-0.7014076113700867,
-0.14201341569423676,
0.2452908456325531,
-0.7053294777870178,
-0.7791507840156555,
0.8261126279830933,
0.5115124583244324,
-0.35598865151405334,
-0.15213164687156677,
-0.33621475100517273,
-0.33370816707611084,
0.1967320442199707,
0.5453857779502869,
0.24175691604614258,
-1.1515679359436035,
0.0372350811958313,
-0.31838110089302063,
-0.24200014770030975,
-0.24574017524719238,
1.0618577003479004,
-0.3100217580795288,
0.7567883133888245,
0.4921426773071289,
0.8910300731658936,
0.8340265154838562,
-0.10201387852430344,
0.2613447606563568,
-0.9242434501647949,
0.3880007266998291,
0.18485073745250702,
-0.06732841581106186,
0.08495217561721802,
-0.07284119725227356,
0.13707223534584045,
0.34280654788017273,
-0.4558410942554474,
-0.8173944354057312,
0.37055638432502747,
-1.199610710144043,
-0.3414977192878723,
1.2211776971817017,
-0.13960851728916168,
-0.12771391868591309,
-0.2529403269290924,
-0.29499340057373047,
0.7111262679100037,
-0.6972885727882385,
0.3747052252292633,
0.49249032139778137,
-0.09700437635183334,
-0.1755831241607666,
-0.9346819519996643,
0.6019946336746216,
0.5427571535110474,
-0.6105429530143738,
0.36480656266212463,
0.13839466869831085,
0.3255871534347534,
-0.16423439979553223,
0.6797724366188049,
0.1451832354068756,
0.22840388119220734,
0.2744417190551758,
0.10742510855197906,
-0.4692559242248535,
-0.5228452682495117,
0.0409587137401104,
0.1059364527463913,
-0.3196934461593628,
-0.4457699656486511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06586v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06586v1
|
Bi-Chainer: Automated Large Language Models Reasoning with Bidirectional Chaining
| 2024-06-05T08:15:38 | 2024-06-05T08:15:38 |
Shuqi Liu, Bowei He, Linqi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown human-like reasoning abilities but
still face challenges in solving complex logical problems. Existing
unidirectional chaining methods, such as forward chaining and backward
chaining, suffer from issues like low prediction accuracy and efficiency. To
address these, we propose a bidirectional chaining method, Bi-Chainer, which
dynamically switches to depth-first reasoning in the opposite reasoning
direction when it encounters multiple branching options within the current
direction. Thus, the intermediate reasoning results can be utilized as guidance
to facilitate the reasoning process. We show that Bi-Chainer achieves sizable
accuracy boots over unidirectional chaining frameworks on four challenging
logical reasoning datasets. Moreover, Bi-Chainer enhances the accuracy of
intermediate proof steps and reduces the average number of inference calls,
resulting in more efficient and accurate reasoning.
|
[
-0.1271997094154358,
-0.7216156721115112,
0.6552802324295044,
0.2627890706062317,
-0.30011656880378723,
0.4229811728000641,
-0.23462314903736115,
-0.372252881526947,
-0.19179470837116241,
0.48953914642333984,
-0.43741029500961304,
-0.4114241302013397,
-0.4407026767730713,
0.1148836761713028,
-0.5157021880149841,
0.732763409614563,
-0.2108083963394165,
0.17400908470153809,
-0.05020923167467117,
0.09592240303754807,
-0.30533236265182495,
-0.23948627710342407,
-0.7173013687133789,
-0.6122680902481079,
0.8364100456237793,
0.5444816946983337,
0.9752727746963501,
0.5765705704689026,
0.46434831619262695,
0.3075198233127594,
-0.024591192603111267,
0.33900317549705505,
-0.29269838333129883,
0.28418439626693726,
-0.7424842715263367,
-0.4733198881149292,
-0.4088946580886841,
-0.3959715962409973,
0.6476237177848816,
1.0401734113693237,
-0.15334764122962952,
-0.015455590561032295,
-0.26120471954345703,
1.0104596614837646,
-0.5273008346557617,
0.1305045634508133,
-0.7784045934677124,
-0.3878142535686493,
-0.2125418335199356,
-0.03202686831355095,
-0.42504894733428955,
-0.2075520157814026,
0.20166711509227753,
-0.279460608959198,
-0.09010650962591171,
0.2907114326953888,
0.5990233421325684,
0.0647205039858818,
-0.6390736699104309,
-0.2518026530742645,
-0.9896560311317444,
0.6009237766265869,
-0.8223397135734558,
0.7372080683708191,
0.14043393731117249,
0.41962572932243347,
-0.1870878040790558,
-0.7275916934013367,
-0.6790684461593628,
0.08520935475826263,
-0.008375554345548153,
-0.12430035322904587,
-0.10415113717317581,
0.25869879126548767,
0.16735370457172394,
0.2560771405696869,
-0.4960922598838806,
0.08994434028863907,
-0.28359436988830566,
0.005550873465836048,
0.7982543706893921,
0.0011661582393571734,
0.16366985440254211,
0.15948493778705597,
-0.12650832533836365,
-0.23836518824100494,
-0.8067606687545776,
0.061337124556303024,
0.2706252336502075,
0.3819962441921234,
0.08594129234552383,
0.6580532193183899,
-0.2959214150905609,
0.7461151480674744,
0.20815110206604004,
-0.003413236467167735,
0.12487036734819412,
-0.2652909755706787,
-0.10416138172149658,
0.032178692519664764,
0.6506301164627075,
0.3888651132583618,
0.4036630094051361,
-0.19810201227664948,
-0.3402288854122162,
-0.0896715521812439,
-0.05354895815253258,
-0.7486566305160522,
-0.43584775924682617,
0.3490246534347534,
-0.3006749451160431,
-0.1456444263458252,
0.11520013213157654,
-0.755179226398468,
-0.3143567740917206,
-0.4611058831214905,
0.2987169921398163,
-0.26406410336494446,
-0.04538136348128319,
0.21775396168231964,
0.07535813748836517,
0.3021503686904907,
0.4746263921260834,
-0.599146842956543,
0.40844446420669556,
0.5672770738601685,
0.7448522448539734,
-0.018078090623021126,
-0.3916621208190918,
-0.6745469570159912,
0.5061197876930237,
-0.5209548473358154,
0.7253252863883972,
-0.6900444626808167,
0.11776658147573471,
-0.1555572897195816,
0.1353917270898819,
0.10361500084400177,
-0.3266260027885437,
0.2543816864490509,
-0.7982769012451172,
0.07131712138652802,
-0.17184749245643616,
-0.2540850043296814,
-0.5158395767211914,
0.2624506950378418,
-0.4761302173137665,
0.705839991569519,
-0.2271585762500763,
-0.641411304473877,
0.06330272555351257,
-0.1379338502883911,
-0.7868726253509521,
-0.07890573889017105,
-0.13369791209697723,
-0.2596924304962158,
0.016443714499473572,
0.2421010136604309,
0.14095908403396606,
-0.713040292263031,
0.5078729391098022,
-0.3282890319824219,
-0.34537848830223083,
0.044415947049856186,
-0.49985453486442566,
0.8554748296737671,
-0.06779308617115021,
-0.44824549555778503,
0.3137129545211792,
-0.870608389377594,
-0.1455152928829193,
0.14593133330345154,
-0.3886753022670746,
-0.282314658164978,
0.2693614959716797,
-0.17366351187229156,
0.503099799156189,
0.12421327829360962,
-0.34814009070396423,
0.2919336259365082,
-0.5353332757949829,
0.2509903907775879,
0.8235131502151489,
-0.17528143525123596,
0.49590498208999634,
-0.12501248717308044,
0.22710707783699036,
0.29969295859336853,
-0.06596029549837112,
-0.09863979369401932,
-0.5306732654571533,
-1.0289697647094727,
-0.06899037212133408,
0.48666054010391235,
0.8984909653663635,
-0.7680585384368896,
0.6154769062995911,
-0.15693946182727814,
-0.3420364558696747,
-0.3918725848197937,
0.33987677097320557,
0.3898235261440277,
0.366983562707901,
0.49751365184783936,
-0.061531636863946915,
-0.5704562664031982,
-0.8623339533805847,
-0.3626824617385864,
-0.5061006546020508,
-0.04289983958005905,
-0.0844045877456665,
0.4956556260585785,
-0.5341073274612427,
0.6897267699241638,
-0.3081809878349304,
0.35080912709236145,
-0.31261569261550903,
0.3606609106063843,
0.3686889111995697,
0.4367032051086426,
-0.17470017075538635,
-0.7435427308082581,
-0.33236294984817505,
0.1158757135272026,
-0.6297830939292908,
-0.2345729023218155,
-0.3773506283760071,
-0.42396536469459534,
0.3594628572463989,
0.31942299008369446,
-0.5277833342552185,
0.3817759156227112,
0.36144378781318665,
-0.26205548644065857,
0.550305962562561,
-0.4148320257663727,
-0.1294783502817154,
-0.6994476914405823,
-0.022991156205534935,
-0.11471900343894958,
-0.3178655505180359,
-0.4902709722518921,
-0.1329367607831955,
0.047336068004369736,
0.2598154842853546,
0.06325945258140564,
0.3286679983139038,
-0.7144601941108704,
-0.13364297151565552,
-0.17130599915981293,
0.17556513845920563,
0.2345358282327652,
0.33758360147476196,
0.19265149533748627,
0.4309729039669037,
0.6251570582389832,
-0.48593637347221375,
0.837238609790802,
0.15153294801712036,
-0.31183522939682007,
0.3389192819595337,
-0.683709442615509,
0.22482340037822723,
-0.058011677116155624,
0.37631553411483765,
-1.1238988637924194,
0.026820840314030647,
0.06693518906831741,
-0.0877576470375061,
0.3116692304611206,
-0.16769114136695862,
-0.8625453114509583,
-0.707599937915802,
-0.227987602353096,
0.42809852957725525,
0.2983228862285614,
-0.6478967666625977,
0.657007098197937,
0.1649782955646515,
-0.24305903911590576,
-0.3974436819553375,
-0.8201284408569336,
0.20736871659755707,
0.14332349598407745,
-0.6773688793182373,
0.15289661288261414,
-0.17886044085025787,
-0.4298230707645416,
-0.32269489765167236,
-0.24551554024219513,
0.06760453432798386,
-0.2434358298778534,
-0.10138032585382462,
0.521418571472168,
0.028943020850419998,
0.15331193804740906,
0.32163992524147034,
-0.18392637372016907,
0.3162382245063782,
-0.49345776438713074,
0.37482601404190063,
-0.41091370582580566,
-0.696679949760437,
-0.2667953670024872,
0.2722328007221222,
0.8184036016464233,
-0.238883376121521,
0.7558227777481079,
0.115210622549057,
-0.41827085614204407,
-0.07632531970739365,
-0.7265706062316895,
-0.17702530324459076,
-0.42470821738243103,
0.1644316017627716,
-0.501411497592926,
-0.4990120232105255,
0.48622700572013855,
-0.3501288592815399,
0.15353628993034363,
-0.006461432669311762,
0.6190224289894104,
-0.1426466405391693,
1.477842092514038,
0.14492641389369965,
-0.04135337844491005,
-0.009066946804523468,
-0.19785723090171814,
0.7984486818313599,
-0.5674537420272827,
-0.4220420718193054,
-0.15065690875053406,
-0.4012237787246704,
-0.7173501253128052,
-0.6444995999336243,
0.2948310673236847,
0.6627902388572693,
-0.6785091161727905,
0.1440008282661438,
-0.34207406640052795,
0.4182896912097931,
0.5821167826652527,
0.061229243874549866,
0.6404250264167786,
-0.046933308243751526,
-0.2922706604003906,
0.42678648233413696,
-0.7097029089927673,
-0.4564003348350525,
0.6474639177322388,
0.2476038932800293,
0.9278455972671509,
0.255277156829834,
0.30726009607315063,
-0.04839207977056503,
0.06344884634017944,
-0.6581001877784729,
0.6274028420448303,
-0.05144001916050911,
-0.6666985750198364,
-0.4387056231498718,
-0.46991831064224243,
-0.5948101282119751,
0.3352675139904022,
-0.07492049783468246,
-0.7219678163528442,
0.35645902156829834,
0.1860099583864212,
-0.13951845467090607,
0.6996291875839233,
-0.4025605022907257,
0.6390805840492249,
-0.4812518060207367,
-0.7183178067207336,
-0.1151922196149826,
-1.2026852369308472,
0.3748495280742645,
-0.058182042092084885,
0.32030346989631653,
0.039553143084049225,
0.09290770441293716,
0.44202595949172974,
-0.6577291488647461,
0.7795218825340271,
0.006018371786922216,
-0.2037133276462555,
0.42656025290489197,
0.47594791650772095,
0.9512096643447876,
-0.019017474725842476,
-0.17551644146442413,
0.16321907937526703,
-0.049099184572696686,
-0.35184213519096375,
-0.637020468711853,
0.5731009840965271,
-0.41251224279403687,
-0.8121671080589294,
-0.3920595049858093,
-0.8214165568351746,
-0.39176610112190247,
0.46339190006256104,
-0.05981839448213577,
0.3277152478694916,
0.2568926513195038,
0.045869678258895874,
0.4613153338432312,
-0.07112004607915878,
0.2948578894138336,
0.4847832918167114,
-0.4420620799064636,
-0.48096516728401184,
0.7543026208877563,
-0.018337519839406013,
0.24919715523719788,
0.6670274138450623,
0.3175855278968811,
-0.554267406463623,
-0.5447224974632263,
-0.7071991562843323,
0.523478090763092,
-0.6635797619819641,
-0.32843053340911865,
-0.45838865637779236,
-0.24731789529323578,
-0.22670526802539825,
-0.2622608542442322,
-0.40625107288360596,
-0.45220819115638733,
0.21580176055431366,
-0.16081754863262177,
0.24575063586235046,
0.5387396812438965,
-0.1933668553829193,
0.0197257362306118,
-0.7524272799491882,
0.2660806179046631,
0.6967615485191345,
0.44043415784835815,
0.07308465987443924,
-0.3792937397956848,
-0.0870918408036232,
0.21366989612579346,
-0.15186792612075806,
-0.8369641304016113,
0.11136159300804138,
-0.10505271703004837,
0.24479496479034424,
0.6989651918411255,
0.07728353887796402,
0.8275834918022156,
-0.6458525061607361,
0.3102223575115204,
0.41663649678230286,
-1.156813383102417,
0.6871129274368286,
-0.38679054379463196,
0.336076021194458,
0.5455468893051147,
0.34631282091140747,
-0.3980158865451813,
-0.23643383383750916,
-0.23253954946994781,
-0.8659621477127075,
0.6034537553787231,
0.25764021277427673,
-0.2895539104938507,
-0.09109566360712051,
0.1496204286813736,
0.026516418904066086,
0.24549898505210876,
-0.6454330086708069,
-0.2236781120300293,
-0.005645375233143568,
-0.10165172070264816,
0.01999768428504467,
-0.24172453582286835,
0.018777649849653244,
-0.7144373655319214,
0.8385307192802429,
-0.1700323224067688,
-0.1542174518108368,
0.013004799373447895,
-0.1283675730228424,
-0.4362016022205353,
0.3769766390323639,
0.18793413043022156,
1.112294316291809,
-0.33989253640174866,
0.6103466153144836,
0.3175286054611206,
0.09063979983329773,
0.27314552664756775,
0.23618179559707642,
-0.2665851414203644,
-0.15232495963573456,
0.5221080780029297,
0.685916543006897,
0.24218620359897614,
-0.9003289937973022,
0.5769544839859009,
0.38240012526512146,
-0.020741842687129974,
-0.07228478789329529,
-0.24046984314918518,
0.4099963903427124,
0.5858629941940308,
0.03427925333380699,
-0.0484391450881958,
0.27797162532806396,
-0.6671337485313416,
-0.1293012797832489,
0.3226112425327301,
-0.15907835960388184,
-0.3593360185623169,
0.5332016348838806,
0.19054478406906128,
-0.3687758147716522,
1.0464775562286377,
-0.1064155176281929,
-0.6762254238128662,
0.29244428873062134,
0.7185589671134949,
0.6920226812362671,
-0.28202587366104126,
0.08530236035585403,
0.2560007572174072,
0.334565669298172,
-0.34024760127067566,
0.2145419865846634,
-0.1502162218093872,
-0.8631355166435242,
-0.5895793437957764,
-0.5848646759986877,
-0.5254605412483215,
-0.16884401440620422,
-0.6373564004898071,
0.37907347083091736,
-0.377412885427475,
0.3021203577518463,
-0.16005076467990875,
-0.24473737180233002,
-0.3423269987106323,
0.11975468695163727,
0.30799055099487305,
0.994683563709259,
-0.6070001125335693,
0.8655021786689758,
0.7938181757926941,
-0.42926672101020813,
-0.5552670359611511,
0.044306281954050064,
-0.016107140108942986,
-0.5438541769981384,
0.7357774972915649,
0.157725527882576,
-0.7152365446090698,
-0.09382609277963638,
-0.5036458969116211,
-0.6109147667884827,
1.0865192413330078,
0.17540524899959564,
-1.1194852590560913,
-0.25365129113197327,
0.18050020933151245,
0.46693968772888184,
-0.2840561866760254,
0.3411140739917755,
0.7743459343910217,
0.6034767627716064,
0.5911074280738831,
-0.7252658605575562,
0.22739548981189728,
-0.2337859719991684,
0.21357958018779755,
0.27625730633735657,
-0.6706836819648743,
0.7022649645805359,
-0.49331384897232056,
-0.09961575269699097,
-0.1814388632774353,
0.6290474534034729,
0.6096283197402954,
0.4045971930027008,
0.8952734470367432,
0.5866810083389282,
0.8779336810112,
0.17804591357707977,
0.7997666001319885,
-0.35158565640449524,
0.10173580795526505,
1.2224069833755493,
-0.6837015151977539,
0.83670973777771,
0.4517965316772461,
-0.4050643742084503,
1.2139649391174316,
0.3973011076450348,
0.20843978226184845,
0.42017513513565063,
0.4430728554725647,
-0.2867658734321594,
-0.8139026761054993,
0.3275376558303833,
-0.1489705592393875,
0.2217654585838318,
0.18134886026382446,
-0.10835812985897064,
-0.20486819744110107,
-0.2215142846107483,
0.012642955407500267,
-0.09220113605260849,
-0.1606609970331192,
0.5099402070045471,
0.016231128945946693,
-0.6794610619544983,
0.6432377696037292,
0.08953893929719925,
0.2799626886844635,
-0.4554121494293213,
-0.19746538996696472,
-0.1564604789018631,
0.41060253977775574,
-0.10863977670669556,
-0.9366825222969055,
0.38805490732192993,
0.03683967888355255,
-0.3814348876476288,
-0.2658606171607971,
0.8177481889724731,
-0.5747199058532715,
-0.8057206869125366,
0.7088730335235596,
0.6013930439949036,
0.10517347604036331,
-0.10620111227035522,
-0.7040544152259827,
-0.15585307776927948,
-0.13012529909610748,
-0.20709972083568573,
-0.07550409436225891,
0.7777746915817261,
-0.26502394676208496,
0.906276524066925,
0.8348480463027954,
0.17740540206432343,
-0.06159621849656105,
0.29996034502983093,
1.1153916120529175,
-0.7574412822723389,
-0.43045154213905334,
-0.9323252439498901,
0.4023977220058441,
-0.21696026623249054,
0.25290369987487793,
0.5832772254943848,
0.7266561985015869,
0.8485612273216248,
0.25069791078567505,
0.5674256086349487,
0.12202988564968109,
0.5299766063690186,
-0.3991341292858124,
0.29848384857177734,
-0.4439377784729004,
0.6953856348991394,
-0.11196906119585037,
-0.8044789433479309,
-0.3287343978881836,
0.7030141949653625,
-0.5875697731971741,
0.0345238633453846,
0.764133632183075,
0.8056382536888123,
-0.23016808927059174,
0.17458607256412506,
0.15649858117103577,
0.6061955690383911,
0.24171632528305054,
0.7028539776802063,
0.8477746248245239,
-0.30589836835861206,
0.4923396706581116,
-0.40782085061073303,
-0.3375028669834137,
-0.017486462369561195,
-0.8630654811859131,
-1.1005858182907104,
-0.36768364906311035,
-0.26471659541130066,
-0.38374343514442444,
0.2912176549434662,
0.9029486179351807,
0.7080785036087036,
-1.0581697225570679,
-0.5847102999687195,
-0.6244779825210571,
0.5177849531173706,
-0.24241600930690765,
-0.2636486887931824,
0.19303973019123077,
-0.1353914886713028,
-0.49205899238586426,
0.4247683584690094,
0.5285183787345886,
-0.2535354197025299,
-0.37983575463294983,
-0.14914821088314056,
-0.8297486901283264,
0.3530765771865845,
0.8014569282531738,
0.03546218201518059,
-0.8355410099029541,
-0.10771550983190536,
-0.4086516797542572,
0.24104318022727966,
0.0017802573274821043,
0.8159927129745483,
-0.6944040060043335,
0.46409064531326294,
0.8475841283798218,
0.46703091263771057,
0.6483457088470459,
0.07719115167856216,
0.6641600131988525,
-0.23778976500034332,
-0.14821958541870117,
0.04368751123547554,
0.47181108593940735,
0.29866448044776917,
-0.12714536488056183,
0.4209900200366974,
0.4414382576942444,
-0.5314251184463501,
-0.8690072894096375,
0.26661810278892517,
-0.8435119390487671,
-0.5297126173973083,
1.1170655488967896,
-0.08698660880327225,
-0.16881468892097473,
-0.2141575813293457,
-0.0063543012365698814,
0.48507067561149597,
-0.21986232697963715,
0.4884830117225647,
0.6198749542236328,
-0.38812360167503357,
-0.4289291799068451,
-0.1267317831516266,
-0.07903341948986053,
0.34382200241088867,
-0.9018371105194092,
0.2174183428287506,
0.47010043263435364,
0.29700717329978943,
0.13007743656635284,
0.32918474078178406,
-0.01636316627264023,
-0.042675212025642395,
-0.2337387353181839,
0.007086871191859245,
0.03221393749117851,
-0.7299426794052124,
-0.1519547998905182,
-0.1774662435054779,
0.019113976508378983,
0.09841251373291016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03030v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03030v1
|
From Tarzan to Tolkien: Controlling the Language Proficiency Level of LLMs for Content Generation
| 2024-06-05T07:57:17 | 2024-06-05T07:57:17 |
Ali Malik, Stephen Mayhew, Chris Piech, Klinton Bicknell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We study the problem of controlling the difficulty level of text generated by
Large Language Models (LLMs) for contexts where end-users are not fully
proficient, such as language learners. Using a novel framework, we evaluate the
effectiveness of several key approaches for this task, including few-shot
prompting, supervised finetuning, and reinforcement learning (RL), utilising
both GPT-4 and open source alternatives like LLama2-7B and Mistral-7B.
Our findings reveal a large performance gap between GPT-4 and the open source
models when using prompt-based strategies. However, we show how to bridge this
gap with a careful combination of finetuning and RL alignment. Our best model,
CALM (CEFR-Aligned Language Model), surpasses the performance of GPT-4 and
other strategies, at only a fraction of the cost. We further validate the
quality of our results through a small-scale human study.
|
[
-0.413345605134964,
-0.7094452977180481,
0.11531110852956772,
0.23583784699440002,
-0.009847083128988743,
0.3096788227558136,
-0.3699679970741272,
-0.22652184963226318,
-0.3413276970386505,
0.49772974848747253,
-0.4323421120643616,
-0.5393847823143005,
-0.6073958873748779,
0.3640272617340088,
-0.3126180171966553,
1.3527686595916748,
-0.25583261251449585,
-0.2629283666610718,
-0.07985297590494156,
0.0015264300163835287,
-0.3319190740585327,
-0.24429653584957123,
-0.906637966632843,
-0.4094238579273224,
0.8468554019927979,
0.6637745499610901,
0.8434481620788574,
0.6738066673278809,
0.5052669644355774,
0.1761828064918518,
-0.3918774127960205,
0.2667393386363983,
-0.7914009094238281,
0.3984520435333252,
-0.4327523708343506,
-0.32791078090667725,
-0.33621951937675476,
-0.242916077375412,
0.584567129611969,
0.4707374572753906,
-0.23088763654232025,
0.10122399777173996,
0.2518298923969269,
0.8816821575164795,
-0.33483245968818665,
0.029652617871761322,
-0.49472156167030334,
0.21158836781978607,
-0.4496845602989197,
-0.27271467447280884,
-0.3810561001300812,
-0.2537493407726288,
-0.34323665499687195,
-0.6370072960853577,
0.3198356628417969,
0.19337871670722961,
0.7963181734085083,
0.30130553245544434,
-0.43832361698150635,
-0.6938958168029785,
-0.7161299586296082,
0.9917672276496887,
-0.6240649819374084,
0.3713621497154236,
0.6100009679794312,
0.10136134177446365,
-0.3307507038116455,
-0.3292512595653534,
-0.6812702417373657,
-0.4278659224510193,
0.16658566892147064,
0.14209918677806854,
0.049313824623823166,
0.1288020759820938,
0.28648847341537476,
0.21844066679477692,
-0.6363461017608643,
0.4604320228099823,
-0.6118972301483154,
-0.042116403579711914,
0.5698670744895935,
0.25494956970214844,
0.2878844439983368,
-0.35647866129875183,
-0.10371337831020355,
-0.201411172747612,
-1.080871343612671,
0.3937353193759918,
0.6859877705574036,
0.43636685609817505,
0.019958076998591423,
0.8854441046714783,
-0.21860189735889435,
0.6890630125999451,
0.44515204429626465,
-0.6733203530311584,
-0.19413678348064423,
-0.16892699897289276,
0.006619599182158709,
-0.16394387185573578,
0.6164452433586121,
0.2878281772136688,
0.3173617720603943,
0.008964474312961102,
-0.5428891181945801,
-0.16781355440616608,
0.17560122907161713,
-0.6201133728027344,
-0.1011548563838005,
0.2681664824485779,
-0.20518268644809723,
-0.4972246587276459,
-0.29386085271835327,
-0.7543669939041138,
-0.497307151556015,
-0.22078149020671844,
0.22022362053394318,
-0.4357118606567383,
-0.3719576299190521,
-0.17251193523406982,
0.2155507206916809,
0.4303646385669708,
0.3163248598575592,
-1.3791521787643433,
0.2925405204296112,
0.680557906627655,
0.7968170642852783,
-0.5585904717445374,
-0.2621718943119049,
-0.601439356803894,
0.4428532123565674,
-0.8492591977119446,
0.5686132907867432,
-0.4034487009048462,
-0.6106005907058716,
0.19464091956615448,
-0.3103767931461334,
0.1740952879190445,
-0.5236251354217529,
0.6003228425979614,
-0.830122709274292,
0.2312586009502411,
-0.08884333074092865,
-0.5043572187423706,
-0.1227748915553093,
0.4020962119102478,
-0.6424777507781982,
1.0589823722839355,
0.4157968759536743,
-0.6706793904304504,
0.2599462866783142,
-0.4038558602333069,
-0.4967181384563446,
0.044278375804424286,
-0.12813909351825714,
-0.29443392157554626,
0.013046556152403355,
0.15130102634429932,
0.41308167576789856,
-0.3852277398109436,
0.46310484409332275,
0.14329801499843597,
-0.10860525816679001,
0.007352001033723354,
-0.3658107817173004,
0.5378146767616272,
0.5651348829269409,
-0.20292770862579346,
0.11538786441087723,
-0.5293988585472107,
0.0012264823308214545,
-0.002580053173005581,
-0.7391242384910583,
0.10432261228561401,
-0.02495836280286312,
-0.06285181641578674,
0.2630203664302826,
0.27679142355918884,
-0.15264317393302917,
0.2528144419193268,
-0.19816729426383972,
0.00733896205201745,
0.7364669442176819,
-0.08723171800374985,
0.5648007988929749,
-0.5748162865638733,
0.9695861339569092,
0.08850051462650299,
-0.03165316581726074,
-0.12511508166790009,
-0.373609334230423,
-0.7110499143600464,
-0.009222198277711868,
0.3461989760398865,
0.6012588739395142,
-0.9184249639511108,
0.026761330664157867,
-0.08276352286338806,
-0.5757209062576294,
-0.4091453552246094,
0.8427685499191284,
0.6407160758972168,
0.48363247513771057,
0.2812414765357971,
-0.39454588294029236,
-0.03584843501448631,
-0.37815240025520325,
-0.10147029906511307,
-0.426330029964447,
-0.10923323035240173,
0.2216324657201767,
0.15020540356636047,
-0.04969065263867378,
0.8642493486404419,
-0.17173701524734497,
-0.4537346065044403,
-0.6364693641662598,
0.18971803784370422,
0.19282881915569305,
0.7112480998039246,
0.2271530032157898,
-0.7822821140289307,
-0.8639513850212097,
0.3287549912929535,
-0.7463647127151489,
-0.3218322694301605,
-0.11803469806909561,
0.23773692548274994,
0.5402798056602478,
0.679472029209137,
-0.4472598731517792,
0.09098915755748749,
0.7966102957725525,
0.036106567829847336,
0.5347987413406372,
-0.23735035955905914,
0.20838698744773865,
-0.8306240439414978,
-0.08752036094665527,
0.02883448451757431,
-0.06556196510791779,
-0.6923253536224365,
0.2601633667945862,
-0.04851024970412254,
-0.17350627481937408,
-0.4930112361907959,
0.6064077019691467,
-0.29725587368011475,
0.16419324278831482,
-0.2007455825805664,
0.26596036553382874,
0.038343217223882675,
0.6082050204277039,
0.06970568746328354,
0.81760174036026,
0.45080775022506714,
-0.5546984672546387,
0.19814179837703705,
0.29961085319519043,
-0.16872504353523254,
0.622161865234375,
-0.6745394468307495,
0.0885658860206604,
-0.25061875581741333,
0.24035310745239258,
-0.8643730878829956,
-0.6427310705184937,
0.2710055112838745,
-0.3953176438808441,
0.5967330932617188,
-0.24329985678195953,
-0.5179802179336548,
-0.15821047127246857,
-0.19150866568088531,
0.2695976793766022,
0.8171171545982361,
-0.32886388897895813,
0.4388282001018524,
0.1182856634259224,
-0.7021703124046326,
-0.5340117812156677,
-0.4494161307811737,
0.16530665755271912,
-0.31839612126350403,
-0.528509259223938,
0.24407148361206055,
-0.04821452125906944,
-0.3474995195865631,
-0.177856907248497,
0.12201426923274994,
-0.05332522466778755,
0.011908085085451603,
0.02595297060906887,
-0.10844216495752335,
-0.22357839345932007,
0.12138313055038452,
0.34041914343833923,
-0.17887447774410248,
-0.377352774143219,
-0.19835759699344635,
0.3736479580402374,
0.10774506628513336,
-0.5546489953994751,
-0.27943524718284607,
0.4235697388648987,
0.22832593321800232,
-0.4243758022785187,
0.5561679005622864,
0.581589937210083,
-0.12341631203889847,
-0.26908814907073975,
-0.4360008239746094,
0.1360585242509842,
-0.5235781073570251,
0.2402513474225998,
-0.4348505437374115,
-1.0899684429168701,
0.3740227520465851,
-0.14419770240783691,
0.19837582111358643,
0.24224595725536346,
0.6252917647361755,
-0.13792143762111664,
1.1253613233566284,
0.8252503275871277,
0.1758243590593338,
0.45035359263420105,
-0.07084906846284866,
0.16125333309173584,
-0.5866232514381409,
-0.15411335229873657,
-0.5140088200569153,
-0.18231943249702454,
-0.7703105807304382,
-0.5188071131706238,
0.4327118694782257,
0.7332890629768372,
-0.37250983715057373,
0.12803977727890015,
-0.23357118666172028,
0.5969979166984558,
0.48700928688049316,
-0.1457672417163849,
0.44914576411247253,
-0.042920298874378204,
-0.21418142318725586,
-0.02834218367934227,
-0.8593205213546753,
-0.6929099559783936,
1.0103627443313599,
0.3485996425151825,
0.9317413568496704,
0.5135945677757263,
0.8380122184753418,
0.33391088247299194,
0.4547317326068878,
-0.5187011361122131,
0.37163251638412476,
-0.10639894753694534,
-0.7404928803443909,
-0.566100537776947,
-0.32641223073005676,
-0.9032921195030212,
-0.037988536059856415,
-0.021045850589871407,
-0.45658591389656067,
-0.06015484035015106,
0.26654842495918274,
-0.36617523431777954,
0.25683149695396423,
-0.5077649354934692,
0.6482986807823181,
-0.10589373856782913,
-0.7628815770149231,
-0.032632045447826385,
-0.6289464235305786,
0.45045584440231323,
-0.4031262993812561,
0.37242013216018677,
0.08108735829591751,
-0.1525726616382599,
0.6114656925201416,
-0.13999739289283752,
0.9920981526374817,
-0.15172050893306732,
-0.5533912181854248,
0.5971615314483643,
0.43371692299842834,
0.6638167500495911,
-0.20996253192424774,
-0.21819017827510834,
-0.24371373653411865,
-0.07217525690793991,
-0.6002221703529358,
-0.4437409043312073,
0.7017630934715271,
-0.859972357749939,
-0.7725563645362854,
-0.3081626296043396,
-0.5856850147247314,
-0.2992810010910034,
0.09363007545471191,
0.19316905736923218,
0.38731810450553894,
-0.11969497799873352,
0.07363683730363846,
0.7663478255271912,
-0.5222748517990112,
0.3428441882133484,
0.6064412593841553,
-0.48513463139533997,
-0.38390839099884033,
1.202966332435608,
0.11064309626817703,
0.6175264716148376,
0.24615676701068878,
0.16153420507907867,
-0.3214399814605713,
-0.9144631624221802,
-0.6029393076896667,
0.04284223914146423,
-0.8314694762229919,
-0.2559688985347748,
-0.32402655482292175,
-0.19334909319877625,
-0.40682923793792725,
-0.49935030937194824,
-0.0023606109898537397,
-0.17176933586597443,
-0.3733884394168854,
-0.1330396682024002,
0.35322171449661255,
1.259374976158142,
-0.3832859396934509,
0.6328669190406799,
-0.761097252368927,
0.2725794017314911,
0.2480446994304657,
0.2303885668516159,
0.07904858142137527,
-0.7269038558006287,
-0.2948460280895233,
-0.1707555651664734,
-0.7533554434776306,
-0.6672645807266235,
0.47791749238967896,
0.2524373531341553,
0.25170254707336426,
0.47261783480644226,
0.03864287957549095,
0.49485087394714355,
-0.6290069222450256,
1.0162358283996582,
0.2767527103424072,
-0.8967291712760925,
0.2848013937473297,
-0.7424411177635193,
0.14500415325164795,
0.4852849543094635,
0.550896942615509,
-0.6599393486976624,
-0.6697626709938049,
-0.46389031410217285,
-0.673638105392456,
0.5791882872581482,
0.02310311794281006,
0.2421586662530899,
-0.10376015305519104,
0.13683025538921356,
0.16158872842788696,
0.14150452613830566,
-0.9021549224853516,
0.31602367758750916,
-0.18349234759807587,
-0.3171203136444092,
-0.27534887194633484,
-0.186705082654953,
-0.05883583426475525,
0.08063797652721405,
0.6056928038597107,
-0.2568831741809845,
-0.3611840605735779,
0.1447356790304184,
-0.28291693329811096,
-0.5662299990653992,
0.3672378957271576,
0.6597282290458679,
0.623953640460968,
0.1465907245874405,
0.03429476171731949,
0.15407253801822662,
-0.2391156405210495,
0.291364461183548,
-0.24910478293895721,
-0.3288736939430237,
-0.37544140219688416,
0.5129532217979431,
0.5283178091049194,
0.15849940478801727,
-0.6504096388816833,
0.3779439330101013,
0.4092310667037964,
-0.24439992010593414,
-0.062018707394599915,
0.324725478887558,
0.09376662969589233,
0.30173346400260925,
0.20429521799087524,
-0.19840021431446075,
-0.363858163356781,
-0.1177983433008194,
0.1324821263551712,
0.1804867535829544,
-0.48899516463279724,
-0.2042539268732071,
0.8356398344039917,
0.25044482946395874,
-0.5010400414466858,
0.38706985116004944,
-0.5298661589622498,
-0.4033464193344116,
0.5277244448661804,
0.62547767162323,
0.41275864839553833,
-0.20144005119800568,
0.5432645678520203,
0.3461560904979706,
0.28900113701820374,
-0.24262790381908417,
0.09450439363718033,
-0.016152290627360344,
-0.5758640170097351,
-0.774970531463623,
-0.841825008392334,
-0.6441085934638977,
-0.19150544703006744,
-0.5379788875579834,
0.27603548765182495,
-0.454782098531723,
0.17277048528194427,
-0.45053234696388245,
0.16525115072727203,
-0.5558624863624573,
0.13783514499664307,
0.02302713692188263,
0.9180087447166443,
-0.7935605049133301,
0.9198526740074158,
0.2768048942089081,
-0.7870697975158691,
-1.0217522382736206,
0.06375661492347717,
0.06060764938592911,
-0.5639453530311584,
0.8523429036140442,
-0.12807606160640717,
-0.10559825599193573,
0.4988311231136322,
-0.6868422627449036,
-0.5694780945777893,
0.9841012358665466,
0.04721705988049507,
-0.577568531036377,
-0.1348649114370346,
0.20400428771972656,
0.6737045049667358,
-0.0921388566493988,
-0.11033601313829422,
0.4657643735408783,
0.469619482755661,
0.19863522052764893,
-0.8938076496124268,
-0.23132719099521637,
0.1254184991121292,
-0.014998503029346466,
-0.015020102262496948,
-0.642295777797699,
0.7611350417137146,
-0.3615646958351135,
-0.22898657619953156,
0.3583810329437256,
0.8684470653533936,
0.5099160075187683,
0.23847904801368713,
0.3822741210460663,
0.4072731137275696,
0.766116201877594,
0.22477470338344574,
1.039573073387146,
-0.3215004503726959,
0.21243087947368622,
0.696377694606781,
-0.516879141330719,
0.8335068821907043,
0.49368616938591003,
-0.2484692931175232,
0.37178662419319153,
0.7025290727615356,
0.23198248445987701,
0.45953553915023804,
0.526779294013977,
-0.4576333463191986,
-0.10369888693094254,
-0.37016865611076355,
-0.24584628641605377,
0.17621880769729614,
0.3965858817100525,
-0.016112564131617546,
-0.2581388056278229,
0.04250824451446533,
0.21491315960884094,
0.4123128354549408,
-0.38545241951942444,
0.936255156993866,
0.02859785407781601,
-1.0632247924804688,
0.8030943274497986,
0.05009894818067551,
0.7344329357147217,
-0.7935740947723389,
0.07348434627056122,
-0.4748459458351135,
-0.06463579088449478,
-0.2580218017101288,
-0.9124941229820251,
0.13853107392787933,
0.4605955183506012,
-0.08427555114030838,
-0.44155153632164,
0.5816738605499268,
-0.764054536819458,
-0.424428254365921,
0.1249459907412529,
0.7105950117111206,
0.20995810627937317,
0.38831260800361633,
-0.4410210847854614,
0.13754169642925262,
0.0715959444642067,
-0.3338721990585327,
0.5651670694351196,
0.739630937576294,
-0.23617899417877197,
0.6759865283966064,
0.6718099117279053,
0.20071017742156982,
0.0858708843588829,
-0.06915102899074554,
0.8338173627853394,
-0.533501148223877,
-0.1990296095609665,
-0.509514570236206,
0.34503477811813354,
0.2619772255420685,
-0.4691246449947357,
0.610140323638916,
0.21585771441459656,
0.9564260840415955,
-0.020146414637565613,
0.7342936396598816,
-0.22223326563835144,
0.5000168681144714,
-0.6184651851654053,
0.6510047316551208,
-0.6037652492523193,
0.24704283475875854,
-0.32514750957489014,
-0.818899929523468,
-0.3984001874923706,
0.30165189504623413,
-0.20854006707668304,
0.006257717031985521,
0.5771307349205017,
1.1467190980911255,
0.06317247450351715,
-0.3192673921585083,
0.5879641175270081,
-0.04153694957494736,
0.6010696291923523,
0.4637773036956787,
0.9586607813835144,
0.20414169132709503,
0.7257750630378723,
-0.07486104965209961,
-0.33478468656539917,
0.0012188429245725274,
-1.130603313446045,
-0.8378441333770752,
-0.574272632598877,
0.02251783199608326,
-0.40073201060295105,
0.16179844737052917,
0.8876307010650635,
0.28809654712677,
-0.8106662034988403,
-0.3790891170501709,
-0.1786612570285797,
0.23225685954093933,
-0.16205812990665436,
-0.14898240566253662,
0.30129992961883545,
-0.780139684677124,
-0.8155452013015747,
0.2756570279598236,
0.0037006917409598827,
0.19731229543685913,
-0.5446286797523499,
-0.6003005504608154,
0.14237286150455475,
0.09428635239601135,
0.502302885055542,
0.5698811411857605,
-0.7517314553260803,
-0.02524428628385067,
0.03322992101311684,
-0.3597772419452667,
-0.01592225767672062,
0.6790120601654053,
-0.42887359857559204,
0.23850396275520325,
0.41690999269485474,
0.739128053188324,
0.2677527964115143,
0.12095537781715393,
0.6731268763542175,
-0.7153791785240173,
-0.006322156637907028,
0.21809278428554535,
-0.09070824831724167,
0.6237186789512634,
-0.07690385729074478,
0.3896884322166443,
-0.10406742990016937,
-0.7795313596725464,
-0.7295153141021729,
0.4664700925350189,
-0.7485241293907166,
-0.024078432470560074,
1.3854552507400513,
-0.24711549282073975,
-0.015952110290527344,
-0.17679078876972198,
-0.45676180720329285,
0.21592921018600464,
-0.21718370914459229,
0.7518002986907959,
0.7909795045852661,
-0.11665492504835129,
-0.22146818041801453,
-0.7459677457809448,
0.8891565799713135,
0.371185302734375,
-0.5943776369094849,
0.06367844343185425,
0.455064058303833,
0.1623835563659668,
0.15310142934322357,
0.6582241654396057,
-0.12497120350599289,
0.08307133615016937,
-0.10823579877614975,
0.0565624013543129,
-0.08235670626163483,
-0.541286826133728,
-0.43917813897132874,
0.22135399281978607,
0.6703075766563416,
0.501417875289917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03009v1
|
Unveiling Selection Biases: Exploring Order and Token Sensitivity in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-05T07:16:51 | 2024-06-05T07:16:51 |
Sheng-Lun Wei, Cheng-Kuang Wu, Hen-Hsen Huang, Hsin-Hsi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we investigate the phenomena of "selection biases" in Large
Language Models (LLMs), focusing on problems where models are tasked with
choosing the optimal option from an ordered sequence. We delve into biases
related to option order and token usage, which significantly impact LLMs'
decision-making processes. We also quantify the impact of these biases through
an extensive empirical analysis across multiple models and tasks. Furthermore,
we propose mitigation strategies to enhance model performance. Our key
contributions are threefold: 1) Precisely quantifying the influence of option
order and token on LLMs, 2) Developing strategies to mitigate the impact of
token and order sensitivity to enhance robustness, and 3) Offering a detailed
analysis of sensitivity across models and tasks, which informs the creation of
more stable and reliable LLM applications for selection problems.
|
[
-0.38091129064559937,
-0.7447896599769592,
0.42182838916778564,
0.03379061818122864,
-0.26217055320739746,
0.09967836737632751,
-0.25305864214897156,
-0.6334893107414246,
0.14431415498256683,
0.8062960505485535,
-0.4351738393306732,
-0.22296002507209778,
-0.7792266011238098,
-0.013526935130357742,
-0.26528477668762207,
0.9628392457962036,
0.2011885792016983,
0.3980117440223694,
-0.2169252634048462,
-0.21390117704868317,
-0.48194441199302673,
-0.8431370854377747,
-0.8552744388580322,
-0.37106290459632874,
0.4312799274921417,
0.09443102031946182,
0.8779072165489197,
0.6286276578903198,
0.488561749458313,
0.24294045567512512,
-0.498384952545166,
-0.09670987725257874,
-0.4667857587337494,
0.582891583442688,
-0.05411749333143234,
-0.7378723621368408,
-0.41314372420310974,
-0.017260918393731117,
0.6814317107200623,
0.7654975652694702,
0.2372041493654251,
0.46392109990119934,
0.025740433484315872,
0.5046479105949402,
-0.8804044127464294,
-0.005650409031659365,
-0.8631649613380432,
-0.03894413635134697,
-0.3259202539920807,
-0.045159246772527695,
-0.6616928577423096,
0.006118352524936199,
0.31073325872421265,
-0.21135404706001282,
0.044808752834796906,
0.42145445942878723,
0.35977065563201904,
0.1940358579158783,
-0.47704631090164185,
-0.0984773114323616,
-0.578335165977478,
1.0316007137298584,
-0.6538918018341064,
0.37482064962387085,
0.37962764501571655,
-0.0600680410861969,
-0.15725994110107422,
-0.6944448351860046,
0.02037695422768593,
-0.1425754576921463,
0.15480348467826843,
-0.12955757975578308,
-0.12708495557308197,
0.2060798704624176,
0.4758974611759186,
0.31850874423980713,
-0.24766211211681366,
0.6129890084266663,
-0.2487054467201233,
-0.3277330696582794,
0.4899679720401764,
0.024417882785201073,
0.16045477986335754,
-0.028723303228616714,
-0.12919197976589203,
-0.1224532499909401,
-0.7286636829376221,
0.007772150449454784,
0.6031654477119446,
0.4314136207103729,
0.13426005840301514,
0.7683513760566711,
-0.02201685681939125,
0.7370594143867493,
-0.013000980019569397,
0.18145471811294556,
0.10077253729104996,
-0.29093846678733826,
-0.39175039529800415,
0.04723166301846504,
0.6520597338676453,
0.20940130949020386,
0.11490093171596527,
0.06233696639537811,
-0.41733038425445557,
-0.3146168291568756,
0.14498835802078247,
-0.5804570317268372,
0.14621394872665405,
0.3277069926261902,
-0.695086658000946,
-0.5585023760795593,
-0.01662600226700306,
-0.9482186436653137,
-0.5407682061195374,
-0.24421326816082,
0.10846028476953506,
0.0697304978966713,
-0.18176840245723724,
-0.0005287855747155845,
-0.13817638158798218,
0.18025432527065277,
-0.04850088432431221,
-1.2083377838134766,
0.31306707859039307,
0.6999541521072388,
0.6790655851364136,
-0.5134530663490295,
-0.2124917209148407,
-0.7962870001792908,
0.17438814043998718,
-0.4449043869972229,
0.6067331433296204,
-0.7324639558792114,
-0.7028517723083496,
0.1282949298620224,
-0.40319016575813293,
0.05800923705101013,
-0.5656123757362366,
0.8016855716705322,
-0.6921530365943909,
0.144305020570755,
-0.49976152181625366,
-0.42879030108451843,
0.22932732105255127,
-0.11365790665149689,
-0.7966881990432739,
1.2239265441894531,
0.038860127329826355,
-1.0460084676742554,
0.6246567368507385,
-0.697963297367096,
-0.46697619557380676,
-0.2019999474287033,
-0.29236218333244324,
-0.3175545632839203,
0.41229867935180664,
0.28041872382164,
0.395540714263916,
-0.29874181747436523,
0.0479603074491024,
-0.47034475207328796,
-0.24104349315166473,
0.45791321992874146,
-0.5420858263969421,
0.9925345182418823,
0.24703750014305115,
-0.43519312143325806,
0.44616737961769104,
-0.5320479869842529,
-0.08594956248998642,
0.19877706468105316,
-0.3983301818370819,
-0.5187753438949585,
0.16985806822776794,
0.010283214040100574,
0.16390302777290344,
0.18222878873348236,
-0.1985756903886795,
0.15487635135650635,
-0.5352783799171448,
0.5448665022850037,
1.183147668838501,
-0.15054577589035034,
0.8176791071891785,
-0.12802627682685852,
0.5831364393234253,
0.08783883601427078,
0.5950582027435303,
0.1844194084405899,
-0.3629724681377411,
-0.8513848185539246,
-0.09881201386451721,
0.5566093325614929,
0.3716667890548706,
-0.3832431137561798,
0.20534822344779968,
-0.09154155105352402,
0.06835167855024338,
-0.46934905648231506,
-0.041691072285175323,
0.32837966084480286,
0.10013676434755325,
0.038357049226760864,
-0.22041967511177063,
-0.4044483006000519,
-1.0058881044387817,
-0.3709990680217743,
-0.3724832534790039,
-0.02637472189962864,
0.23753726482391357,
0.2584823668003082,
-0.13739705085754395,
0.893829345703125,
-0.5729924440383911,
0.16524602472782135,
-0.2785780429840088,
-0.12036357820034027,
0.1752060055732727,
0.17548945546150208,
0.7225989103317261,
-0.8608130216598511,
-0.06164268031716347,
-0.060191310942173004,
-0.01894487999379635,
-0.34233465790748596,
0.09899051487445831,
-0.3937879502773285,
0.5677369832992554,
0.7271178960800171,
-0.6755497455596924,
0.2418348640203476,
0.34562695026397705,
-0.2899324893951416,
0.6116997599601746,
0.015369672328233719,
-0.25065866112709045,
-1.108137607574463,
0.04470013827085495,
-0.20274348556995392,
-0.04569822549819946,
-0.6685716509819031,
0.1373477429151535,
-0.035456426441669464,
0.402810275554657,
-0.49350425601005554,
0.7044718265533447,
-0.5126413702964783,
-0.38637757301330566,
-0.16243387758731842,
-0.140229731798172,
-0.14903686940670013,
0.15928038954734802,
-0.09051072597503662,
0.7349792122840881,
0.4775160551071167,
-0.5976786613464355,
-0.05860888212919235,
0.17270538210868835,
-0.4197935461997986,
0.08631014078855515,
-0.31233689188957214,
0.1266443282365799,
-0.07038012146949768,
-0.10421432554721832,
-0.9816321730613708,
-0.004039956722408533,
0.2176329791545868,
-0.34262076020240784,
0.5293872952461243,
-0.29089784622192383,
-0.5546177625656128,
-0.41298526525497437,
-0.44483456015586853,
0.5138534307479858,
0.3643188178539276,
-0.29932641983032227,
0.5025210380554199,
0.47130900621414185,
-0.2873986065387726,
-0.9703549146652222,
-0.5417165160179138,
-0.05861462280154228,
-0.39682698249816895,
-0.09000508487224579,
0.24191607534885406,
-0.382786363363266,
-0.6680853962898254,
-0.43505147099494934,
-0.26781538128852844,
0.13917672634124756,
0.38959455490112305,
0.008961993269622326,
0.47927576303482056,
0.013474228791892529,
0.04003914073109627,
0.024420134723186493,
-0.06613712757825851,
0.2587072551250458,
-0.3953956961631775,
0.698935866355896,
0.22649870812892914,
-0.5103182196617126,
0.20128080248832703,
0.29333993792533875,
0.8088301420211792,
-0.42182472348213196,
0.6055099368095398,
0.3111700415611267,
-0.1407453864812851,
-0.34983137249946594,
-0.7438019514083862,
-0.35643109679222107,
-0.4945726692676544,
0.5279940366744995,
-0.15270072221755981,
-0.9553865194320679,
0.7573534846305847,
0.23896671831607819,
0.24315279722213745,
0.33120864629745483,
0.9285778999328613,
0.28000980615615845,
1.323221206665039,
0.5233518481254578,
-0.6028212308883667,
0.9737223386764526,
0.03873218595981598,
0.32606515288352966,
-0.7817751169204712,
-0.09845411777496338,
-0.7014771103858948,
-0.19855867326259613,
-0.7176623940467834,
-0.32339414954185486,
0.19854530692100525,
-0.060810454189777374,
-0.33858340978622437,
-0.2898995876312256,
-0.374891459941864,
0.6446982026100159,
0.646131157875061,
-0.06564777344465256,
0.19784758985042572,
0.06615468114614487,
-0.47549259662628174,
0.2458769679069519,
-0.6680716276168823,
-0.5268073081970215,
1.3121881484985352,
0.39407405257225037,
0.5948922634124756,
0.019555868580937386,
0.2930186688899994,
0.14373674988746643,
0.08151836693286896,
-0.7152667045593262,
0.5444279313087463,
0.01961943693459034,
-0.861934244632721,
-0.3588612377643585,
-0.24306799471378326,
-0.9577324390411377,
0.4166266918182373,
-0.24532680213451385,
-0.9043889045715332,
0.026972651481628418,
-0.07753428816795349,
-0.47037506103515625,
0.290293425321579,
-0.6382737755775452,
0.5776233077049255,
-0.45992982387542725,
-0.40677136182785034,
-0.026252906769514084,
-0.7820298075675964,
0.2709231376647949,
-0.014161360450088978,
0.23585286736488342,
-0.037502869963645935,
-0.1211276724934578,
0.7472165822982788,
-0.08214826136827469,
0.8348355889320374,
0.11365818232297897,
-0.12195322662591934,
0.0027412918861955404,
0.25903835892677307,
0.5894780158996582,
-0.008693835698068142,
-0.4556376338005066,
0.17187026143074036,
0.06270145624876022,
-0.43560460209846497,
-0.27790534496307373,
0.6072004437446594,
-0.7604787349700928,
-0.7822114825248718,
-0.29421383142471313,
-0.5419042110443115,
-0.4255543351173401,
0.4822496473789215,
0.4288078546524048,
0.3355380892753601,
-0.03637691214680672,
-0.15634186565876007,
0.7619200944900513,
-0.24776554107666016,
0.7577289938926697,
0.19836893677711487,
-0.40334904193878174,
-0.4125436842441559,
0.39450931549072266,
0.44536739587783813,
0.5412322282791138,
0.22501620650291443,
0.2818228602409363,
-0.4394080936908722,
-1.1259255409240723,
-0.32956215739250183,
0.1556672751903534,
-0.8626389503479004,
-0.07539063692092896,
-0.46494364738464355,
-0.13389621675014496,
-0.47372743487358093,
-0.03113975003361702,
-0.1923607438802719,
-0.40953871607780457,
-0.7224517464637756,
-0.4974777102470398,
0.2090178281068802,
0.8216015696525574,
0.3478791415691376,
0.14972546696662903,
-0.5218496918678284,
-0.03205478563904762,
0.15176138281822205,
0.4825538396835327,
0.10398861765861511,
-0.4953802227973938,
-0.12387552112340927,
-0.10617437958717346,
-0.24865618348121643,
-0.6416327357292175,
0.29295212030410767,
-0.3183209300041199,
0.8863023519515991,
0.631449818611145,
0.130837082862854,
0.4093753695487976,
-0.2988019287586212,
0.9065098762512207,
-0.08826230466365814,
-0.9287240505218506,
0.4986923635005951,
-0.5560896992683411,
0.1626354157924652,
0.5152141451835632,
0.027462748810648918,
-0.2253657877445221,
-0.40296632051467896,
-0.5432526469230652,
-1.0637989044189453,
0.7796475291252136,
0.2555767893791199,
0.22235624492168427,
-0.21592895686626434,
0.5562350153923035,
0.17972582578659058,
0.3829141855239868,
-0.7996567487716675,
-0.5482279062271118,
0.28166985511779785,
0.058201294392347336,
-0.16901583969593048,
-0.6948903799057007,
0.019130367785692215,
-0.12492000311613083,
0.59873366355896,
-0.13688814640045166,
0.10115772485733032,
-0.13089139759540558,
-0.10222024470567703,
-0.18037502467632294,
0.25916698575019836,
0.770143985748291,
0.7597891688346863,
-0.08308041095733643,
0.027128739282488823,
0.39236897230148315,
-0.36706167459487915,
-0.22211451828479767,
-0.222896009683609,
-0.2613314986228943,
-0.15434908866882324,
0.3949262499809265,
0.9474766254425049,
0.18140389025211334,
-0.6060212254524231,
0.44814783334732056,
0.07708875834941864,
0.14269715547561646,
-0.09937574714422226,
-0.08902855962514877,
-0.16741721332073212,
0.2893625497817993,
0.4131517708301544,
-0.13305941224098206,
0.20622506737709045,
-0.3621552288532257,
-0.0594048872590065,
0.9365414977073669,
-0.19173261523246765,
-0.038862403482198715,
0.6168874502182007,
0.1470353752374649,
-0.27572378516197205,
0.5762232542037964,
0.2389066070318222,
-0.6268755793571472,
0.708768367767334,
0.5760836601257324,
0.967830240726471,
-0.17745967209339142,
-0.012304644100368023,
-0.10109279304742813,
0.36124926805496216,
-0.21448582410812378,
0.23061862587928772,
0.2114531397819519,
-0.7567621469497681,
-0.556818425655365,
-0.6136556267738342,
-0.4290255308151245,
0.28116053342819214,
-0.8381361365318298,
0.40703150629997253,
-0.4183957874774933,
-0.596005380153656,
-0.12155310809612274,
-0.06815995275974274,
-0.408721923828125,
-0.18854832649230957,
0.46632546186447144,
0.8599034547805786,
-0.7340480089187622,
0.42923596501350403,
0.6504531502723694,
-0.13259965181350708,
-0.5128735303878784,
0.1008949875831604,
-0.010937231592833996,
-0.9259528517723083,
0.7496657371520996,
-0.024559250101447105,
0.02678954042494297,
-0.0667300596833229,
-0.4231117069721222,
-1.0980243682861328,
0.8906313180923462,
0.6436298489570618,
-0.2565585970878601,
0.09819245338439941,
0.2638840079307556,
0.40280431509017944,
-0.30194926261901855,
0.6153717041015625,
0.8207260966300964,
0.40367257595062256,
-0.06139960139989853,
-1.0229960680007935,
-0.1530054360628128,
0.04983057826757431,
0.24640892446041107,
0.5437829494476318,
-0.86822909116745,
0.7025415897369385,
-0.06648243218660355,
0.04470352455973625,
-0.03584529832005501,
0.2966282367706299,
0.15700767934322357,
0.024997403845191002,
0.41982781887054443,
0.3450160324573517,
0.8455329537391663,
0.1263994574546814,
1.0815203189849854,
-0.22762997448444366,
0.13250502943992615,
0.7886519432067871,
-0.5919261574745178,
0.9743969440460205,
0.9031663537025452,
-0.3434390425682068,
0.09780221432447433,
1.186355471611023,
0.17779222130775452,
0.38842901587486267,
0.4303453862667084,
-0.27334651350975037,
-0.26101934909820557,
-0.21362300217151642,
-0.15813614428043365,
0.4162006974220276,
0.18896709382534027,
-0.6210893392562866,
0.14100243151187897,
-0.022354403510689735,
0.09384500980377197,
-0.4784434735774994,
-0.5275616645812988,
0.8556962609291077,
-0.014192218892276287,
-0.7288217544555664,
0.19969522953033447,
-0.09958463907241821,
0.6020675897598267,
-0.46598440408706665,
0.3352943956851959,
-0.23259054124355316,
-0.012537339702248573,
-0.016937708482146263,
-0.6304315328598022,
-0.13300961256027222,
-0.23179814219474792,
-0.5395589470863342,
-0.26602837443351746,
0.6728447079658508,
-0.066766157746315,
-0.6860107779502869,
0.5943796634674072,
0.6129377484321594,
-0.1935081034898758,
0.06804205477237701,
-0.6625058650970459,
0.353175550699234,
0.021567754447460175,
-0.7302192449569702,
0.7105914354324341,
0.1781071126461029,
-0.4722408950328827,
0.7623109817504883,
0.8710742592811584,
0.12417689710855484,
0.2469559907913208,
0.18245528638362885,
0.7881021499633789,
-0.33518481254577637,
-0.4600868821144104,
-1.2598484754562378,
0.29506370425224304,
-0.2402401864528656,
-0.1418086737394333,
0.54060298204422,
0.6217299699783325,
0.9861838221549988,
-0.10360588878393173,
0.9039039611816406,
0.3158014118671417,
0.24918346107006073,
-0.682525098323822,
0.7399542331695557,
-0.12044556438922882,
0.6627049446105957,
-0.2153177559375763,
-1.0647863149642944,
-0.5519741773605347,
0.33611413836479187,
-0.5045276880264282,
0.2969680428504944,
0.5965932607650757,
0.8110237121582031,
0.11025040596723557,
-0.17263184487819672,
0.23325300216674805,
0.20766037702560425,
0.10347378998994827,
0.16067291796207428,
0.9043924808502197,
-0.04410279914736748,
0.39507436752319336,
-0.03273560851812363,
-0.06802070885896683,
-0.3147154152393341,
-0.993312656879425,
-1.1244510412216187,
-0.4308359920978546,
-0.15125077962875366,
-0.27926039695739746,
0.022537922486662865,
1.2760236263275146,
0.48716816306114197,
-0.9385197162628174,
-0.38359516859054565,
0.11843746155500412,
0.5722481608390808,
0.026131123304367065,
-0.16459348797798157,
0.4101792871952057,
-0.3908451795578003,
-0.8016476631164551,
0.0927199125289917,
0.181870698928833,
0.2789355516433716,
-0.09805397689342499,
0.11402168869972229,
-0.039419807493686676,
0.24531595408916473,
0.7361489534378052,
-0.03404949605464935,
-0.891314685344696,
-0.30374258756637573,
0.02622261829674244,
0.012871888466179371,
0.1263049840927124,
1.0985138416290283,
-0.41634827852249146,
0.2776910364627838,
0.5110747218132019,
0.657418429851532,
0.17645663022994995,
-0.19094425439834595,
0.6802414655685425,
-0.6796818971633911,
0.04542776197195053,
0.17493854463100433,
0.5920921564102173,
0.011529108509421349,
-0.4148615598678589,
0.41475772857666016,
0.012113473378121853,
-0.5966362357139587,
-1.1864526271820068,
0.34289634227752686,
-0.821511447429657,
-0.5771068334579468,
1.5624310970306396,
0.40679001808166504,
0.10893218219280243,
-0.14340463280677795,
-0.45231103897094727,
0.1868397742509842,
-0.25962957739830017,
0.6803444027900696,
1.0811567306518555,
-0.11082908511161804,
-0.052111729979515076,
-0.7922391891479492,
0.5758601427078247,
0.7331908941268921,
-0.4355858266353607,
0.4740684926509857,
0.5645166039466858,
0.2539101839065552,
-0.21546725928783417,
0.4059416651725769,
-0.13427603244781494,
-0.028037460520863533,
-0.5303628444671631,
-0.28384900093078613,
0.10715742409229279,
-0.10950255393981934,
-0.6934037208557129,
0.1855635792016983,
0.6587826013565063,
0.05901649221777916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03008v1
|
DriVLMe: Enhancing LLM-based Autonomous Driving Agents with Embodied and Social Experiences
| 2024-06-05T07:14:44 | 2024-06-05T07:14:44 |
Yidong Huang, Jacob Sansom, Ziqiao Ma, Felix Gervits, Joyce Chai
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in foundation models (FMs) have unlocked new prospects in
autonomous driving, yet the experimental settings of these studies are
preliminary, over-simplified, and fail to capture the complexity of real-world
driving scenarios in human environments. It remains under-explored whether FM
agents can handle long-horizon navigation tasks with free-from dialogue and
deal with unexpected situations caused by environmental dynamics or task
changes. To explore the capabilities and boundaries of FMs faced with the
challenges above, we introduce DriVLMe, a video-language-model-based agent to
facilitate natural and effective communication between humans and autonomous
vehicles that perceive the environment and navigate. We develop DriVLMe from
both embodied experiences in a simulated environment and social experiences
from real human dialogue. While DriVLMe demonstrates competitive performance in
both open-loop benchmarks and closed-loop human studies, we reveal several
limitations and challenges, including unacceptable inference time, imbalanced
training data, limited visual understanding, challenges with multi-turn
interactions, simplified language generation from robotic experiences, and
difficulties in handling on-the-fly unexpected situations like environmental
dynamics and task changes.
|
[
-0.38083723187446594,
-0.7363862991333008,
0.696927011013031,
0.15961730480194092,
-0.16204389929771423,
0.3558414578437805,
-0.05788111686706543,
-0.8006834983825684,
-0.047213129699230194,
0.2617802321910858,
-1.1456127166748047,
-0.4182368218898773,
-0.373305082321167,
-0.10161402076482773,
-0.35774046182632446,
0.5302679538726807,
-0.09305181354284286,
-0.11605554819107056,
-0.27584657073020935,
-0.27185797691345215,
-0.4246608018875122,
-0.36433374881744385,
-0.616865873336792,
-0.35377898812294006,
0.4537890553474426,
0.08529739081859589,
0.9638822674751282,
0.3046736419200897,
0.18633833527565002,
0.3879667818546295,
0.03201924264431,
0.273282915353775,
-0.6159595847129822,
0.3015703856945038,
-0.28388383984565735,
-0.20848886668682098,
-0.33373790979385376,
0.015859127044677734,
0.6270590424537659,
0.6140910983085632,
-0.15658602118492126,
-0.17843087017536163,
-0.06579826027154922,
0.6090633273124695,
-0.4546985924243927,
0.24356085062026978,
-0.07598184049129486,
0.12036305665969849,
0.2433812916278839,
-0.0037770639173686504,
-0.1004873663187027,
0.057218991219997406,
0.09505166113376617,
-0.7735466957092285,
-0.02122284471988678,
-0.20487412810325623,
0.7338854670524597,
0.6755111813545227,
-0.5828642845153809,
-0.23252719640731812,
-1.1796596050262451,
0.5971484184265137,
-0.7175027132034302,
0.5515652894973755,
-0.03014792874455452,
0.5011452436447144,
-0.6117771863937378,
-0.5822888612747192,
-0.7487357258796692,
-0.43884727358818054,
0.039738547056913376,
0.10022426396608353,
0.18413510918617249,
0.4297483563423157,
-0.0046213543973863125,
0.028190651908516884,
-0.3959440290927887,
0.1230984702706337,
-0.17061330378055573,
0.036373671144247055,
0.9373548626899719,
0.5282484889030457,
0.26665475964546204,
-0.0262309480458498,
-0.4747137725353241,
-0.4441313147544861,
-0.48828935623168945,
0.5849427580833435,
0.22418208420276642,
-0.038849130272865295,
-0.45560526847839355,
0.30690497159957886,
-0.33099648356437683,
0.7830502986907959,
-0.2928658425807953,
-0.14959296584129333,
0.03904660418629646,
-0.1289663016796112,
-0.40385207533836365,
-0.4516106843948364,
0.6015233993530273,
0.5223783850669861,
0.10314375907182693,
-0.24993091821670532,
-0.3904605507850647,
0.12745796144008636,
0.3969574272632599,
-0.5467749238014221,
-0.03817857801914215,
0.17055760324001312,
-0.31143131852149963,
-0.4934104084968567,
0.20212534070014954,
-0.7015307545661926,
-0.39820683002471924,
-0.6012951135635376,
0.19488129019737244,
-0.21274609863758087,
-0.6390777826309204,
0.2104276418685913,
-0.09330661594867706,
0.4979892373085022,
0.6426042318344116,
-0.7000482678413391,
0.5105741024017334,
0.5509587526321411,
0.67820143699646,
-0.1633012890815735,
-0.47583287954330444,
-0.24339476227760315,
0.08783289045095444,
-0.3226725161075592,
0.5340582728385925,
-0.32924097776412964,
-0.7282365560531616,
-0.1225276067852974,
0.08832847326993942,
-0.08860313147306442,
-0.3357473313808441,
0.26667240262031555,
-0.29877397418022156,
-0.14829237759113312,
-0.08853241801261902,
-0.21699227392673492,
-0.36634474992752075,
-0.018394866958260536,
-0.3929636478424072,
0.9562661647796631,
0.24544624984264374,
-0.05435507744550705,
0.23101770877838135,
-0.775922954082489,
-0.7444243431091309,
0.11087489128112793,
-0.6582491993904114,
0.01203090324997902,
0.35149481892585754,
-0.2559487819671631,
0.3013152778148651,
-0.05309147760272026,
0.582866907119751,
0.05399472638964653,
-0.39513713121414185,
0.1383301168680191,
-0.7397499084472656,
0.7402618527412415,
0.042068663984537125,
-0.6614359617233276,
0.5233418941497803,
-0.5676918029785156,
-0.30284640192985535,
0.33980226516723633,
-0.07971347868442535,
-0.23084817826747894,
0.1580817550420761,
0.13827504217624664,
0.40107208490371704,
0.021142104640603065,
-0.5094244480133057,
0.1760639101266861,
-0.3903045654296875,
0.31492507457733154,
1.0130294561386108,
-0.1380542665719986,
0.6249768733978271,
-0.4643208980560303,
0.7174566984176636,
-0.0426570326089859,
0.35188227891921997,
0.03146105259656906,
-0.5965335369110107,
-0.6404282450675964,
-0.15410476922988892,
-0.3045314848423004,
0.5260049700737,
-0.899499773979187,
-0.018125468865036964,
-0.21106871962547302,
-0.3762993812561035,
-0.5929610729217529,
0.24030473828315735,
0.15947116911411285,
0.2920210361480713,
0.0695909783244133,
-0.11858333647251129,
-0.12823215126991272,
-0.8649454116821289,
0.22893692553043365,
-0.25248754024505615,
0.09661464393138885,
0.9052984714508057,
0.6661816239356995,
-0.521186888217926,
1.212965488433838,
-0.4875856935977936,
-0.23367467522621155,
-0.18615201115608215,
0.21594397723674774,
-0.3262816071510315,
0.5165476202964783,
0.7122129201889038,
-1.0288602113723755,
-0.11558279395103455,
-0.0401509664952755,
-1.1143263578414917,
0.15471039712429047,
-0.5119490027427673,
-0.11753764748573303,
0.045611899346113205,
0.2354385107755661,
-0.8317304253578186,
0.6873998045921326,
0.5079131126403809,
-0.40809622406959534,
0.44465383887290955,
-0.5473405122756958,
0.31238433718681335,
-0.46185302734375,
-0.3521706163883209,
-0.08949867635965347,
-0.44583162665367126,
-0.5208788514137268,
-0.01729261502623558,
-0.25336700677871704,
-0.08602038770914078,
-0.7357394099235535,
0.7011542320251465,
-0.5209739804267883,
-0.24693019688129425,
-0.46942082047462463,
0.2641089856624603,
-0.1668653041124344,
0.40587565302848816,
0.46608009934425354,
0.8431680798530579,
0.8228256106376648,
-0.7905476093292236,
0.7725018262863159,
0.23155945539474487,
-0.29696032404899597,
0.46962714195251465,
-0.45328813791275024,
0.15193596482276917,
-0.47773006558418274,
0.30707553029060364,
-0.7846160531044006,
-0.2747417688369751,
0.16188812255859375,
-0.30105459690093994,
0.23995596170425415,
0.10984513908624649,
-0.40251195430755615,
-0.267183780670166,
-0.032659657299518585,
0.54986572265625,
0.5652017593383789,
-0.48707693815231323,
1.0798404216766357,
0.3810921609401703,
-0.06555952876806259,
-0.2108033448457718,
-0.3884165585041046,
0.5702986717224121,
-0.20999126136302948,
-1.0641965866088867,
0.2626684606075287,
-0.1637154221534729,
-0.6094716787338257,
-0.0031338799744844437,
-0.028916001319885254,
0.07078881561756134,
0.41904112696647644,
0.7393748164176941,
0.14743149280548096,
-0.07728832960128784,
-0.02760876715183258,
0.17658336460590363,
-0.024904517456889153,
0.27525201439857483,
0.12243513017892838,
0.10835455358028412,
-0.1961735635995865,
-0.24359358847141266,
-0.6631585955619812,
0.5711960792541504,
0.6962501406669617,
-0.23861905932426453,
0.581146240234375,
0.3157293200492859,
-0.437406063079834,
-0.28103023767471313,
-0.2753322124481201,
-0.6121425032615662,
-0.5620164275169373,
0.3142818212509155,
-0.5406903624534607,
-0.672883927822113,
0.3304087817668915,
-0.2827129364013672,
0.2593889832496643,
-0.046102747321128845,
0.3930535316467285,
-0.32321324944496155,
0.7664422392845154,
0.7877196669578552,
0.10484854131937027,
0.549045741558075,
-0.34893178939819336,
-0.10285809636116028,
-0.5758908987045288,
-0.4706327021121979,
0.15571828186511993,
-0.3114387094974518,
-0.3711029589176178,
-0.6565306782722473,
0.36091551184654236,
-0.531560480594635,
-0.0221859160810709,
0.17047487199306488,
-0.20520304143428802,
0.0226458627730608,
0.4282999634742737,
0.09253387898206711,
0.2920365333557129,
-0.2873392105102539,
0.030343564227223396,
-0.020873507484793663,
-0.8022080659866333,
-0.6317136287689209,
0.4298534095287323,
0.3971688449382782,
0.9731244444847107,
0.2622844874858856,
0.5042193531990051,
0.623272180557251,
0.4802590608596802,
-0.5395943522453308,
0.8731871247291565,
0.38305285573005676,
-0.5748451352119446,
-0.36560046672821045,
-0.4720308482646942,
-0.796617329120636,
0.3971063792705536,
-0.431388258934021,
-0.5443650484085083,
0.1970132738351822,
-0.21273258328437805,
-0.5572684407234192,
0.09278419613838196,
-0.1623118370771408,
0.8527984619140625,
-0.6381842494010925,
-0.7924323678016663,
-0.39792007207870483,
-1.0999280214309692,
0.36755117774009705,
0.4467795491218567,
0.568518877029419,
-0.29377061128616333,
0.0018887778278440237,
0.4595813453197479,
-0.151752308011055,
1.1311041116714478,
-0.390121191740036,
-0.40896502137184143,
0.47532927989959717,
0.20501768589019775,
0.5047299861907959,
0.2454318404197693,
0.34180229902267456,
-0.12048257142305374,
-0.17720620334148407,
-0.23772373795509338,
-0.6982046365737915,
0.7199230194091797,
-0.7627894878387451,
-0.7072704434394836,
-0.5434502959251404,
-0.7141542434692383,
-0.13854600489139557,
-0.10857035219669342,
-0.29760733246803284,
0.47157177329063416,
-0.6094234585762024,
-0.13562092185020447,
0.5484366416931152,
-0.3272758722305298,
0.5091434121131897,
0.7691488862037659,
-0.21625131368637085,
-0.15914355218410492,
0.6766514778137207,
-0.23034846782684326,
0.4029885232448578,
0.06743385642766953,
-0.0761663019657135,
-0.40247637033462524,
-0.34426045417785645,
-0.8910890221595764,
0.310062974691391,
-0.6920510530471802,
0.14075195789337158,
-0.5457024574279785,
-0.19485194981098175,
-0.2685548961162567,
-0.2796817421913147,
-0.6827518939971924,
-0.2948399782180786,
-0.4388847053050995,
-0.5692129731178284,
0.22127225995063782,
1.108999252319336,
-0.28483691811561584,
0.40799933671951294,
-0.5347333550453186,
0.45676806569099426,
0.42765581607818604,
0.11530441045761108,
0.025819234549999237,
-0.2938249409198761,
-0.16682513058185577,
0.27935171127319336,
-0.08497721701860428,
-0.7809850573539734,
0.2216186374425888,
-0.02851293981075287,
0.807060718536377,
0.33643433451652527,
0.30243128538131714,
0.6005221009254456,
-0.35027340054512024,
0.7219513058662415,
-0.07399207353591919,
-0.39548560976982117,
0.39551541209220886,
-0.41849619150161743,
-0.10749388486146927,
0.4308203160762787,
-0.10370582342147827,
-0.23416464030742645,
-0.5500682592391968,
-0.514180064201355,
-0.8343412280082703,
0.3338351845741272,
0.5740633606910706,
0.33789557218551636,
0.2234332114458084,
0.5700763463973999,
-0.019109904766082764,
0.2663792371749878,
-0.7024972438812256,
-0.4196607172489166,
-0.2540864944458008,
-0.1642446666955948,
-0.19376088678836823,
-0.1234474703669548,
-0.09807472676038742,
-0.21540497243404388,
0.4864051043987274,
0.03677554056048393,
-0.07673484086990356,
0.4895365238189697,
-0.11651613563299179,
-0.04489540308713913,
0.06548865884542465,
1.1557013988494873,
0.3932381272315979,
-0.36146754026412964,
0.0171289574354887,
0.012167127802968025,
-0.14373688399791718,
0.5729635953903198,
0.09001938253641129,
-0.14057239890098572,
-0.1350528746843338,
0.1288580596446991,
0.7947189211845398,
0.2995561957359314,
-1.0012197494506836,
0.387226939201355,
-0.24206379055976868,
-0.18756316602230072,
-0.6136122345924377,
0.35869935154914856,
0.019853757694363594,
0.38652950525283813,
0.4131426513195038,
0.012060923501849174,
0.1690308153629303,
-0.6426197290420532,
0.29462501406669617,
0.637211263179779,
-0.6971440315246582,
-0.34221673011779785,
1.0394256114959717,
0.711198091506958,
-0.3783300817012787,
0.528376579284668,
-0.3526267111301422,
-0.2506732940673828,
0.7468796968460083,
0.1080833226442337,
0.7974214553833008,
-0.11884696781635284,
0.18361805379390717,
0.02597023732960224,
0.43994301557540894,
-0.16689912974834442,
0.10167194902896881,
-0.32025933265686035,
-0.7096807360649109,
-0.28834038972854614,
-0.4040742814540863,
-0.4439895749092102,
-0.1731237769126892,
-0.53529953956604,
-0.11113859713077545,
-0.24577561020851135,
-0.29427865147590637,
-0.4665164351463318,
-0.30285054445266724,
-0.5090716481208801,
0.4305344820022583,
0.28547805547714233,
0.8326812982559204,
-0.8700648546218872,
0.7583063244819641,
0.7774381041526794,
-0.12007696181535721,
-0.3197629451751709,
-0.45355090498924255,
0.16871123015880585,
-0.409710168838501,
0.6530880331993103,
0.11800941079854965,
-0.7764202356338501,
0.08627261221408844,
-0.23792381584644318,
-0.37231385707855225,
1.5328840017318726,
0.20481713116168976,
-0.3981321156024933,
-0.2865738570690155,
0.13787515461444855,
0.4401601552963257,
-0.6854820847511292,
-0.01007053442299366,
0.5249720811843872,
0.548363447189331,
0.10161887854337692,
-0.8420103192329407,
0.003033095970749855,
-0.11024923622608185,
-0.07963208109140396,
-0.1810273975133896,
-0.854699432849884,
0.49007508158683777,
-0.42041340470314026,
-0.2521110773086548,
0.3523709177970886,
0.9319801330566406,
0.13159428536891937,
0.5802581906318665,
0.7330064177513123,
0.2915535569190979,
0.4885016977787018,
0.14635536074638367,
1.0865329504013062,
-0.10243421792984009,
0.0841270387172699,
1.1197315454483032,
-0.5880421996116638,
0.4414135217666626,
0.43004193902015686,
-0.014664548449218273,
0.5994806885719299,
0.48738622665405273,
0.40849387645721436,
0.6965984106063843,
0.1736942082643509,
-0.8683397769927979,
-0.5356289744377136,
-0.1414388120174408,
-0.03126337379217148,
0.5449691414833069,
0.2931511104106903,
0.02921365015208721,
-0.15594755113124847,
0.5035016536712646,
-0.476595401763916,
0.3746104836463928,
-0.05657537654042244,
0.9409655928611755,
0.3396168649196625,
-0.4910001754760742,
0.3408636748790741,
-0.040551286190748215,
0.48996689915657043,
-0.47923406958580017,
-0.2670620083808899,
-0.2401479035615921,
0.12581866979599,
0.057818703353405,
-0.6653763651847839,
0.25382182002067566,
-0.2688785791397095,
0.06861776858568192,
-0.43861788511276245,
0.6207867860794067,
-0.2523548901081085,
-0.2570332884788513,
0.6373751759529114,
0.7042641043663025,
0.18089300394058228,
0.00893999170511961,
-0.5901703834533691,
0.132868692278862,
-0.050747182220220566,
-0.29890719056129456,
0.32471147179603577,
0.33551648259162903,
0.11005508154630661,
1.1707884073257446,
0.4536096155643463,
-0.2154049575328827,
0.056939225643873215,
-0.07029369473457336,
0.8988767862319946,
-1.0387080907821655,
-0.39891400933265686,
-0.8191065192222595,
0.7187991142272949,
0.0564081184566021,
-0.04628464952111244,
0.4406985342502594,
0.5281617045402527,
0.39164942502975464,
-0.08120593428611755,
0.8428837656974792,
-0.017782574519515038,
-0.043669551610946655,
-0.5482303500175476,
0.6404820680618286,
-0.810375452041626,
0.12947909533977509,
0.07337423413991928,
-0.42675191164016724,
0.19570037722587585,
0.9601184725761414,
0.09360215812921524,
0.01908877119421959,
0.18948476016521454,
0.7524012327194214,
-0.09828933328390121,
-0.16714929044246674,
0.7151337265968323,
0.13204127550125122,
0.6086055636405945,
0.6754568815231323,
1.1068261861801147,
-0.1383109837770462,
0.21262788772583008,
-0.3137352168560028,
-0.47052523493766785,
-0.10099378228187561,
-0.7905939221382141,
-0.969548225402832,
-0.5312568545341492,
-0.2590424418449402,
-0.1632205694913864,
0.31921637058258057,
0.947609543800354,
0.8601706624031067,
-0.13525763154029846,
-0.4596567749977112,
-0.26639458537101746,
0.279745876789093,
-0.2171945571899414,
-0.2115200310945511,
-0.27270427346229553,
0.08744154125452042,
-0.7461991310119629,
1.010380744934082,
0.4709361493587494,
0.7154958248138428,
-0.654198408126831,
-0.45978960394859314,
0.009363899007439613,
0.09206469357013702,
0.6028769612312317,
0.3460865914821625,
-0.6459036469459534,
-0.2265908122062683,
0.020496046170592308,
-0.1726638376712799,
0.08052334189414978,
0.846878170967102,
-1.005212426185608,
0.26739197969436646,
-0.033779069781303406,
0.37323668599128723,
0.6636976599693298,
0.21925529837608337,
1.021647334098816,
-0.3170754611492157,
0.5931744575500488,
0.18054381012916565,
0.2691592574119568,
0.4547192454338074,
-0.29301247000694275,
0.583141565322876,
0.3367444574832916,
-0.4889066517353058,
-0.7485862970352173,
0.5823836326599121,
-1.1170830726623535,
-0.3319368064403534,
1.2122547626495361,
-0.16035880148410797,
-0.24243858456611633,
-0.2508893311023712,
-0.47195887565612793,
0.06540092825889587,
-0.46665114164352417,
0.6422037482261658,
0.39670470356941223,
-0.18072983622550964,
-0.4894946217536926,
-1.1570725440979004,
0.5576837658882141,
0.2606431245803833,
-0.7122923135757446,
0.16068865358829498,
0.6219004392623901,
0.25367841124534607,
-0.18685822188854218,
0.6890763640403748,
0.426433265209198,
0.44149458408355713,
0.0237110648304224,
-0.1437298208475113,
-0.37632083892822266,
-0.4603980779647827,
-0.14821304380893707,
-0.14726601541042328,
0.22735439240932465,
0.007728348486125469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03007v1
|
BadAgent: Inserting and Activating Backdoor Attacks in LLM Agents
| 2024-06-05T07:14:28 | 2024-06-05T07:14:28 |
Yifei Wang, Dizhan Xue, Shengjie Zhang, Shengsheng Qian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
With the prosperity of large language models (LLMs), powerful LLM-based
intelligent agents have been developed to provide customized services with a
set of user-defined tools. State-of-the-art methods for constructing LLM agents
adopt trained LLMs and further fine-tune them on data for the agent task.
However, we show that such methods are vulnerable to our proposed backdoor
attacks named BadAgent on various agent tasks, where a backdoor can be embedded
by fine-tuning on the backdoor data. At test time, the attacker can manipulate
the deployed LLM agents to execute harmful operations by showing the trigger in
the agent input or environment. To our surprise, our proposed attack methods
are extremely robust even after fine-tuning on trustworthy data. Though
backdoor attacks have been studied extensively in natural language processing,
to the best of our knowledge, we could be the first to study them on LLM agents
that are more dangerous due to the permission to use external tools. Our work
demonstrates the clear risk of constructing LLM agents based on untrusted LLMs
or data. Our code is public at https://github.com/DPamK/BadAgent
|
[
-0.2144468128681183,
-0.9731252789497375,
0.46993711590766907,
-0.022284286096692085,
-0.03742355480790138,
0.17541857063770294,
0.12366752326488495,
-0.635522186756134,
-0.12444441765546799,
1.0541584491729736,
-0.37445589900016785,
-0.8026145696640015,
-0.49922651052474976,
-0.1836685985326767,
-0.48661595582962036,
1.0673025846481323,
0.26572197675704956,
0.04543101415038109,
-0.12047575414180756,
0.05322302132844925,
-0.6213533878326416,
-0.6966468691825867,
-0.5839176774024963,
-0.28973206877708435,
0.3819655776023865,
0.32687845826148987,
1.0549554824829102,
0.35509324073791504,
0.5667736530303955,
0.4100315570831299,
0.3634253740310669,
-0.10667834430932999,
-0.6255574226379395,
0.42588257789611816,
-0.5972774028778076,
-0.5742635130882263,
-0.5884676575660706,
0.16232824325561523,
0.34412118792533875,
0.03798215463757515,
-0.0394393652677536,
0.09517044574022293,
-0.2724091112613678,
0.22110114991664886,
-0.5294223427772522,
-0.09457068890333176,
-0.9369284510612488,
-0.07315921783447266,
-0.24605005979537964,
-0.25624874234199524,
-0.41093939542770386,
-0.5183742046356201,
-0.2723849415779114,
-0.016890529543161392,
0.011213576421141624,
0.020161785185337067,
0.5609054565429688,
0.5543944239616394,
-0.1642097681760788,
-0.2727215588092804,
-0.5804305076599121,
0.591190755367279,
-0.6605305671691895,
0.35250234603881836,
0.3690759539604187,
0.5086066722869873,
-0.7227268218994141,
-0.4020991325378418,
-0.618696391582489,
-0.6269723176956177,
-0.016690978780388832,
-0.1277310848236084,
-0.4667682945728302,
0.051236364990472794,
0.057484664022922516,
0.3152230679988861,
-0.5442719459533691,
0.6683197021484375,
-0.07295817136764526,
-0.36505427956581116,
0.7732404470443726,
0.35353657603263855,
0.5231951475143433,
0.19754990935325623,
-0.35600048303604126,
-0.007830154150724411,
-0.9189209938049316,
-0.29098019003868103,
0.8519405126571655,
0.4454784095287323,
-0.11826503276824951,
0.7894332408905029,
0.13970836997032166,
0.4215066134929657,
-0.0552595816552639,
-0.00517865177243948,
-0.018113136291503906,
-0.14858613908290863,
-0.1460137963294983,
0.09945954382419586,
0.6521170139312744,
0.20894140005111694,
0.37029603123664856,
-0.5191458463668823,
-0.5440731048583984,
0.1219465434551239,
0.5497983694076538,
-0.7394387722015381,
0.11428280174732208,
0.4578601121902466,
-0.015180859714746475,
-0.8436951637268066,
0.07127463817596436,
-0.5003877282142639,
-0.5461316108703613,
0.2907061278820038,
0.46066051721572876,
-0.3740016520023346,
0.10217390209436417,
-0.004412245936691761,
0.08876360207796097,
0.48649388551712036,
0.15452896058559418,
-0.27941954135894775,
0.4287644326686859,
0.977712869644165,
0.4866890013217926,
0.005464707035571337,
-0.6453824639320374,
-0.9299800992012024,
0.28067746758461,
-0.4442720413208008,
0.7471618056297302,
-0.33973026275634766,
-0.4738284945487976,
0.24717210233211517,
0.20059093832969666,
0.4287753105163574,
-0.5683926939964294,
0.23011600971221924,
-0.9924743175506592,
0.009310961700975895,
0.15824028849601746,
-0.3166735768318176,
-0.03998174890875816,
0.5549734234809875,
-0.5552058815956116,
0.8249131441116333,
-0.007030650973320007,
-0.47641658782958984,
-0.22471128404140472,
-0.5915698409080505,
-0.6128174662590027,
0.021473068743944168,
0.12350240349769592,
-0.4268282353878021,
-0.0030064284801483154,
-0.012589058838784695,
0.7727304100990295,
-0.12303107976913452,
-0.21083953976631165,
-0.3589046597480774,
-0.23511265218257904,
0.9409568905830383,
-0.4347742795944214,
0.8265425562858582,
0.16644859313964844,
-0.21759989857673645,
0.018090615049004555,
-0.6286076307296753,
-0.13593871891498566,
0.19378143548965454,
-0.09903833270072937,
-0.3807436227798462,
-0.1350971907377243,
-0.2623768448829651,
0.2015119045972824,
0.4252575635910034,
-0.6867173910140991,
0.3257093131542206,
-0.8039423227310181,
0.056293681263923645,
0.8904172778129578,
0.3056405186653137,
0.3495130240917206,
-0.24825580418109894,
0.5761295557022095,
-0.04448898136615753,
0.21258586645126343,
0.05369311571121216,
-0.2761625349521637,
-0.21987834572792053,
-0.210566446185112,
-0.0625903308391571,
0.8330788016319275,
-0.8003894090652466,
0.4107363224029541,
0.059059761464595795,
-0.8080374002456665,
-0.3660924732685089,
0.27404698729515076,
0.6695555448532104,
0.2580890357494354,
0.20519286394119263,
-0.010937594808638096,
-0.11128423362970352,
-0.8483350872993469,
-0.19713330268859863,
-0.16754528880119324,
0.12291737645864487,
0.17816676199436188,
0.6009752750396729,
-0.695155918598175,
0.7082391381263733,
-0.6941549181938171,
-0.2677971422672272,
-0.08680033683776855,
-0.2710164785385132,
0.050741564482450485,
0.6019920706748962,
0.547895610332489,
-0.42014187574386597,
-0.3075798451900482,
-0.12376166135072708,
-0.6059773564338684,
-0.1780560314655304,
0.10801026970148087,
-0.2047950178384781,
0.14113330841064453,
0.4762996435165405,
-0.8998306393623352,
0.42612025141716003,
0.6323329210281372,
-0.38575100898742676,
0.5641561150550842,
-0.17421530187129974,
-0.16457998752593994,
-1.2479491233825684,
-0.2797700762748718,
-0.19066789746284485,
-0.3398286700248718,
-0.8235446810722351,
0.48624011874198914,
-0.14762380719184875,
-0.4363171458244324,
-0.8290969729423523,
0.7930296063423157,
-0.15434715151786804,
-0.09130513668060303,
-0.28386354446411133,
0.07264290004968643,
-0.35072895884513855,
0.365123987197876,
-0.6371555924415588,
0.8693455457687378,
0.5644158720970154,
-0.45828181505203247,
0.7303673624992371,
0.26054179668426514,
0.11474049091339111,
0.4472772181034088,
-0.5373843312263489,
0.6623867750167847,
0.2629527151584625,
0.25416651368141174,
-0.7627171874046326,
-0.2346666157245636,
0.848641574382782,
-0.5067487359046936,
0.4562203288078308,
-0.15448395907878876,
-0.7289964556694031,
0.034931499511003494,
-0.5654731392860413,
0.14931046962738037,
0.3167964816093445,
-0.6028451323509216,
0.361177533864975,
0.3604593276977539,
0.03573698550462723,
-0.6537185311317444,
-0.9436138868331909,
0.3768671452999115,
-0.2609716057777405,
-0.692082941532135,
0.2882254421710968,
0.001718513434752822,
-0.6012538075447083,
-0.032315388321876526,
0.113597571849823,
-0.1271677166223526,
0.35194265842437744,
0.4793255031108856,
0.076227568089962,
-0.056227486580610275,
0.016797330230474472,
-0.04735946282744408,
-0.3572171628475189,
0.17555741965770721,
-0.2628798186779022,
0.33172640204429626,
-0.14181482791900635,
-0.5349600315093994,
-0.4578631520271301,
0.5168628096580505,
0.6782398223876953,
-0.33617833256721497,
0.6427788138389587,
0.39872848987579346,
-0.4658442437648773,
-0.4320727288722992,
-0.5182874798774719,
-0.3132467567920685,
-0.5326160192489624,
0.4455306828022003,
-0.17558099329471588,
-0.6648057699203491,
0.4934062957763672,
0.2031419426202774,
0.16878025233745575,
-0.02469063363969326,
0.5680215954780579,
-0.06797555088996887,
0.8582640886306763,
0.6254962086677551,
-0.2559187710285187,
0.29144635796546936,
-0.13079211115837097,
0.02125701867043972,
-0.3502127230167389,
0.03400873765349388,
-0.5611734390258789,
-0.0531681627035141,
-0.9419768452644348,
-0.3198947012424469,
-0.10570040345191956,
-0.4221736788749695,
-0.1446940153837204,
0.20448535680770874,
-0.19833073019981384,
0.46414873003959656,
0.43461939692497253,
0.11689533293247223,
0.2610645592212677,
-0.34549304842948914,
0.18306466937065125,
0.3800080418586731,
-0.12633495032787323,
-0.7981926798820496,
1.1361937522888184,
0.609750509262085,
1.4042912721633911,
0.4255247414112091,
1.034297227859497,
0.48818907141685486,
0.3099575936794281,
-0.8113078474998474,
0.7025898098945618,
-0.12536485493183136,
-0.6268381476402283,
-0.37221425771713257,
0.014498082920908928,
-0.9612050652503967,
-0.13173654675483704,
0.061907242983579636,
-0.8741399645805359,
-0.035789914429187775,
0.15387345850467682,
-0.26687997579574585,
0.19534486532211304,
-0.7721264958381653,
0.6339879035949707,
-0.513155996799469,
-0.38352298736572266,
-0.19704945385456085,
-0.5346785187721252,
0.18479712307453156,
-0.20670345425605774,
-0.024085281416773796,
0.019407112151384354,
-0.12870287895202637,
0.4716174006462097,
-0.575714647769928,
1.1063388586044312,
-0.3525654971599579,
-0.5256340503692627,
0.20833811163902283,
0.3299033045768738,
1.1194828748703003,
0.42769908905029297,
0.031108783558011055,
0.3297405242919922,
-0.22977279126644135,
-0.4435940980911255,
-0.8598212003707886,
0.792564868927002,
-0.7564558982849121,
-1.059132695198059,
-0.41055989265441895,
-0.4562174677848816,
-0.22778676450252533,
0.1443239450454712,
-0.0844745934009552,
0.27874717116355896,
-0.21075665950775146,
-0.08659784495830536,
0.522556483745575,
-0.3458355963230133,
0.37303534150123596,
0.746225118637085,
-0.057407643646001816,
-0.2301437258720398,
1.1931174993515015,
-0.045521847903728485,
0.2405398190021515,
0.4391183853149414,
0.22596527636051178,
0.041324079036712646,
-0.9510250687599182,
-0.10948223620653152,
0.06352785974740982,
-0.5634158253669739,
-0.4597839415073395,
-0.3063850402832031,
-0.29082372784614563,
-0.22803841531276703,
-0.15812774002552032,
-0.6092212200164795,
-0.0294355321675539,
-0.2195446491241455,
-0.12414426356554031,
0.3159811198711395,
0.7650275230407715,
0.051051266491413116,
0.5261061191558838,
-0.9650994539260864,
0.11140778660774231,
0.4395790696144104,
0.2604619264602661,
-0.25068536400794983,
-0.056338611990213394,
-0.5176372528076172,
-0.04265420511364937,
-0.3357946276664734,
-1.1136480569839478,
0.3457612097263336,
-0.29111817479133606,
0.6386659145355225,
0.39359110593795776,
0.06692355871200562,
0.03095228038728237,
-0.3921893239021301,
0.7095499038696289,
-0.2035364806652069,
-0.5471325516700745,
0.42506590485572815,
-0.39615413546562195,
0.09709344804286957,
0.5632283091545105,
0.175556480884552,
-0.1644149273633957,
-0.8605940937995911,
-0.4967656135559082,
-0.4321206510066986,
0.517047643661499,
0.20976155996322632,
0.40058383345603943,
0.19918584823608398,
0.23118726909160614,
0.33365219831466675,
0.19797107577323914,
-0.6283119320869446,
-0.16522163152694702,
-0.25071775913238525,
-0.006276146043092012,
-0.1055138036608696,
-0.1791628748178482,
-0.2995469272136688,
0.270750492811203,
0.6841251850128174,
0.02178727462887764,
0.26484450697898865,
-0.034642353653907776,
-0.45298880338668823,
-0.014319232665002346,
0.5398426651954651,
0.6366555690765381,
0.25515350699424744,
-0.21640627086162567,
0.26335203647613525,
0.27248403429985046,
-0.6957438588142395,
0.24988135695457458,
0.3703441619873047,
0.08390741795301437,
-0.42917317152023315,
0.41904425621032715,
0.18985088169574738,
0.13941547274589539,
-0.5380954742431641,
0.47842514514923096,
-0.1950148642063141,
0.10136925429105759,
-0.4080536365509033,
0.2530252933502197,
-0.11874940991401672,
0.6820640563964844,
0.15710051357746124,
-0.09614058583974838,
-0.07850337028503418,
-0.5457291007041931,
0.16784915328025818,
0.6224524974822998,
-0.5001426339149475,
-0.4840642213821411,
-0.02622765302658081,
0.37167420983314514,
-0.8104730844497681,
0.45879822969436646,
-0.4382006824016571,
-0.6808888912200928,
0.37721583247184753,
0.7494283318519592,
1.097918152809143,
-0.5030483603477478,
-0.10991685092449188,
-0.48712483048439026,
0.6432672739028931,
0.45037680864334106,
0.24050241708755493,
0.27759015560150146,
-0.9652855396270752,
-0.1677369922399521,
-0.30453139543533325,
-0.4431766867637634,
0.38990890979766846,
0.01998157985508442,
0.19305577874183655,
-0.467128723859787,
-0.0035061840899288654,
-0.3067302405834198,
-0.018947185948491096,
-0.53327876329422,
-0.016279833391308784,
0.04936538636684418,
0.7262373566627502,
-0.5934166312217712,
0.7792890071868896,
0.822323739528656,
-0.24447312951087952,
-0.5093028545379639,
0.3791586458683014,
0.11632469296455383,
-0.8739106059074402,
0.5528686046600342,
-0.04861443489789963,
-0.30771973729133606,
-0.02355295605957508,
-0.7509037852287292,
-0.7309852838516235,
0.823790967464447,
0.4640562832355499,
-0.2994063198566437,
-0.037735406309366226,
0.2544805109500885,
0.32786378264427185,
-0.17789867520332336,
-0.19187647104263306,
0.2819610834121704,
0.5582068562507629,
-0.17379897832870483,
-0.4581314027309418,
0.4960486590862274,
-0.04328807443380356,
-0.3817105293273926,
0.3409426510334015,
-0.550977349281311,
0.6012780666351318,
-0.25806036591529846,
-0.16961859166622162,
0.04051204398274422,
0.41601526737213135,
0.17507801949977875,
0.34415754675865173,
0.17871324717998505,
0.558674156665802,
0.5511834025382996,
0.1839238405227661,
0.9833623766899109,
-0.20948980748653412,
-0.09822994470596313,
1.1654679775238037,
-0.22395606338977814,
0.47346702218055725,
0.5212611556053162,
0.06054734066128731,
0.17198234796524048,
0.39909663796424866,
-0.3822116255760193,
0.45283111929893494,
0.25534939765930176,
-0.13079088926315308,
0.08217553794384003,
0.03127061203122139,
-0.297201544046402,
0.7561663389205933,
0.3345350921154022,
-0.1284126192331314,
-0.33585482835769653,
0.19840751588344574,
0.284761905670166,
-0.010029854252934456,
-0.2441767454147339,
0.674297571182251,
0.2392057180404663,
-0.2779843807220459,
0.20206379890441895,
0.199111208319664,
0.5914592146873474,
-0.5212807059288025,
-0.10798580944538116,
-0.10719256103038788,
0.13875742256641388,
-0.3765295147895813,
-0.7558211088180542,
0.29206809401512146,
0.019828420132398605,
0.23172485828399658,
-0.0255038570612669,
1.1062700748443604,
0.03337731584906578,
-0.06444081664085388,
0.2625466585159302,
0.5687072277069092,
0.034060992300510406,
-0.132603257894516,
-0.5743398070335388,
-0.09594139456748962,
-0.2426709681749344,
-0.3401525914669037,
0.34174755215644836,
0.3489134609699249,
-0.14363671839237213,
0.7936827540397644,
0.9229966998100281,
0.22562745213508606,
-0.18320542573928833,
0.12017165124416351,
0.9754422903060913,
-0.842299222946167,
-0.46246927976608276,
-1.21452796459198,
0.4875432550907135,
0.013798028230667114,
-0.027912259101867676,
0.9764878749847412,
0.4061732888221741,
0.7197906374931335,
0.02949625253677368,
0.6569737792015076,
0.3551490604877472,
0.07202325016260147,
-0.6144410967826843,
1.0854448080062866,
-0.20113512873649597,
0.5478140115737915,
-0.4086403548717499,
-0.7181665897369385,
-0.2234666645526886,
-0.1088060662150383,
-0.44796645641326904,
-0.020277639850974083,
0.554583728313446,
1.1818991899490356,
0.1341555416584015,
-0.22889594733715057,
0.40474027395248413,
0.5103504061698914,
0.7306236624717712,
0.20582100749015808,
1.2364294528961182,
-0.10487549006938934,
0.598139226436615,
-0.24246151745319366,
-0.1726098358631134,
-0.2692228853702545,
-0.7306151390075684,
-1.2242460250854492,
-0.1295391023159027,
-0.12309028953313828,
-0.4598912000656128,
0.4952408969402313,
0.8085727095603943,
0.32696011662483215,
-0.5830397605895996,
-0.11069606989622116,
0.11870401352643967,
0.6365922689437866,
0.10063186287879944,
-0.24875012040138245,
0.026249071583151817,
-0.09903546422719955,
-0.48405230045318604,
0.5871360898017883,
0.1515078842639923,
0.3162050247192383,
-0.6807324886322021,
-0.12129770219326019,
-0.0943690612912178,
0.217029869556427,
0.32881370186805725,
0.3535967469215393,
-0.6051890254020691,
-0.5620589256286621,
-0.2780117094516754,
-0.3314611315727234,
-0.15798774361610413,
0.5005850791931152,
-0.5680728554725647,
0.06704572588205338,
0.23483462631702423,
0.8042706847190857,
0.15912023186683655,
-0.13701987266540527,
0.6562821269035339,
-0.7996988296508789,
0.1571628451347351,
0.5067867040634155,
0.039570000022649765,
0.274215430021286,
-0.892866849899292,
0.2613646686077118,
-0.03884173557162285,
-0.5414570569992065,
-1.041323184967041,
0.40198057889938354,
-0.7644055485725403,
-0.2970251441001892,
1.1544767618179321,
-0.003992846235632896,
-0.5072072148323059,
-0.29397353529930115,
-0.25949883460998535,
0.17206113040447235,
-0.7168554663658142,
0.7078169584274292,
0.34990325570106506,
-0.06383500248193741,
0.46001380681991577,
-0.5025296807289124,
0.3776502311229706,
-0.18409249186515808,
-0.9890048503875732,
-0.02931028977036476,
0.19390682876110077,
0.3167286515235901,
0.15302503108978271,
0.24307744204998016,
-0.15473635494709015,
0.2805059552192688,
0.04929139465093613,
-0.07940737158060074,
-0.5654256343841553,
-0.23549696803092957,
-0.41859927773475647,
0.21664710342884064,
0.2433125227689743,
-0.35909131169319153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03004v1
|
Evaluation of data inconsistency for multi-modal sentiment analysis
| 2024-06-05T07:11:56 | 2024-06-05T07:11:56 |
Yufei Wang, Mengyue Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Emotion semantic inconsistency is an ubiquitous challenge in multi-modal
sentiment analysis (MSA). MSA involves analyzing sentiment expressed across
various modalities like text, audio, and videos. Each modality may convey
distinct aspects of sentiment, due to subtle and nuanced expression of human
beings, leading to inconsistency, which may hinder the prediction of artificial
agents. In this work, we introduce a modality conflicting test set and assess
the performance of both traditional multi-modal sentiment analysis models and
multi-modal large language models (MLLMs). Our findings reveal significant
performance degradation across traditional models when confronted with
semantically conflicting data and point out the drawbacks of MLLMs when
handling multi-modal emotion analysis. Our research presents a new challenge
and offer valuable insights for the future development of sentiment analysis
systems.
|
[
-0.39399364590644836,
-0.8769188523292542,
0.42507418990135193,
0.41863110661506653,
-0.1581614762544632,
0.129222109913826,
-0.18207237124443054,
-0.5645436644554138,
0.01934473216533661,
-0.1341455727815628,
-0.7422146797180176,
-0.23825450241565704,
-0.6904906630516052,
0.27115973830223083,
-0.07874510437250137,
0.8116387724876404,
-0.2783162593841553,
0.40544185042381287,
-0.43817585706710815,
-0.7499943375587463,
-0.7045630216598511,
-0.488639235496521,
-0.24387642741203308,
0.04000915586948395,
0.4926605224609375,
0.10638809204101562,
0.9852086305618286,
-0.11662767827510834,
0.6384066939353943,
0.2826904058456421,
0.054679811000823975,
0.45426928997039795,
-0.17163513600826263,
0.4092404842376709,
-0.0038659535348415375,
-0.12484811246395111,
-0.44764095544815063,
0.04260437563061714,
0.4874688684940338,
0.5949873328208923,
0.2601569592952728,
0.04238960146903992,
-0.100727379322052,
0.7273054122924805,
-0.8395760655403137,
0.21464256942272186,
-0.6247444152832031,
0.25641757249832153,
-0.10626564174890518,
-0.1552247256040573,
-0.28761744499206543,
-0.22265702486038208,
0.1530846357345581,
-0.1944863498210907,
0.06298724561929703,
-0.0789022445678711,
0.9260129332542419,
0.43817687034606934,
-0.8178333640098572,
-0.38574299216270447,
-0.8173292279243469,
0.7847638130187988,
-0.8228840231895447,
0.6501027941703796,
0.09664028882980347,
0.1474878489971161,
0.1348414123058319,
-0.2692250907421112,
-0.9125218391418457,
-0.5650278329849243,
0.10232697427272797,
0.3088301718235016,
-0.21898585557937622,
-0.06586553901433945,
0.3375924825668335,
0.24369101226329803,
-0.5984997749328613,
-0.11327584832906723,
0.07916881144046783,
-0.0714714303612709,
0.575081467628479,
0.47438573837280273,
0.19211238622665405,
-0.6545550227165222,
-0.5643756985664368,
-0.26266855001449585,
-0.40167930722236633,
0.29012230038642883,
0.6197806596755981,
0.38494905829429626,
-0.22957292199134827,
0.7637971639633179,
-0.23774512112140656,
0.5120894312858582,
-0.09801430255174637,
-0.13007213175296783,
0.7162004113197327,
-0.41545355319976807,
-0.4305339753627777,
-0.23745591938495636,
0.9114187359809875,
0.4183410406112671,
-0.20682960748672485,
0.09225913137197495,
-0.3720034956932068,
0.3114016354084015,
0.23865872621536255,
-0.4198776185512543,
0.04650280252099037,
0.4490465819835663,
-0.59739750623703,
-0.1670902967453003,
0.09358540922403336,
-1.0733972787857056,
-0.6090012788772583,
-0.36394062638282776,
0.7183358669281006,
-0.33523982763290405,
-0.6175984144210815,
0.05261009931564331,
-0.05569639801979065,
0.00034986616810783744,
0.3417978286743164,
-0.5307000279426575,
-0.14354251325130463,
0.45097652077674866,
0.5462669134140015,
-0.13868708908557892,
-0.35851508378982544,
-0.22392740845680237,
-0.41187453269958496,
-0.2318422794342041,
0.6083198189735413,
-0.8322746157646179,
-0.4003831446170807,
-0.07581976056098938,
-0.0517522394657135,
-0.5595950484275818,
-0.3635108768939972,
0.6725664138793945,
-0.5226150155067444,
0.22342680394649506,
-0.4453500211238861,
-0.5849436521530151,
-0.2427515685558319,
0.4625142216682434,
-0.8694804906845093,
1.2265022993087769,
0.19257724285125732,
-0.8659151792526245,
0.5703820586204529,
-0.7116961479187012,
-0.2278338074684143,
-0.5029650926589966,
-0.266137957572937,
-0.4205641448497772,
0.43810147047042847,
-0.3270415961742401,
0.4609214961528778,
-0.38445237278938293,
0.21195049583911896,
-0.6366817355155945,
-0.17139241099357605,
0.808057427406311,
-0.8163759708404541,
0.38016942143440247,
0.27063918113708496,
-0.5485702157020569,
0.14646220207214355,
-0.943475604057312,
-0.004543942399322987,
-0.17370979487895966,
-0.2987551987171173,
-0.32766538858413696,
0.22268275916576385,
0.3442234992980957,
0.7223728895187378,
0.24209748208522797,
-0.6346051096916199,
0.13940508663654327,
-0.04876963049173355,
0.057049643248319626,
0.9395467638969421,
-0.24965527653694153,
0.09100016206502914,
-0.1143425777554512,
0.6396315693855286,
0.4603451192378998,
0.35054662823677063,
-0.017039291560649872,
-0.3329065442085266,
-0.6554070711135864,
-0.11487835645675659,
0.21822033822536469,
0.4805471897125244,
-0.6885864734649658,
0.22214612364768982,
-0.2153724879026413,
-0.3947743773460388,
-0.6066434979438782,
-0.0007291635847650468,
0.021082578226923943,
0.2999584376811981,
0.28986260294914246,
-0.2803398072719574,
-0.46767136454582214,
-0.9170269966125488,
-0.21907426416873932,
-0.10941106826066971,
0.30356597900390625,
0.24113039672374725,
0.44221481680870056,
-0.5097590088844299,
0.9079980254173279,
-0.007004936225712299,
0.10154054313898087,
0.054860059171915054,
0.39472970366477966,
-0.25044572353363037,
0.3330966532230377,
0.32039421796798706,
-0.9334826469421387,
-0.29690515995025635,
0.11441449820995331,
-0.7988789081573486,
0.08496104925870895,
-0.27600085735321045,
0.31236737966537476,
0.663131833076477,
0.1928851157426834,
-0.7389456629753113,
0.43161994218826294,
0.9013139605522156,
-0.5023266673088074,
0.661393940448761,
0.1013074740767479,
0.5920621752738953,
-0.7974863052368164,
0.09774310886859894,
-0.018434129655361176,
0.009792565368115902,
-0.36864060163497925,
-0.2557831406593323,
0.2179708629846573,
0.07238829135894775,
-0.39887112379074097,
0.16780810058116913,
-0.2793608009815216,
0.11835377663373947,
-0.09674427658319473,
-0.05863075703382492,
0.09543412923812866,
0.3899436593055725,
-0.3599015772342682,
0.7047274112701416,
0.5626780986785889,
-0.24754221737384796,
0.5095513463020325,
-0.004768985323607922,
-0.1303766369819641,
0.9290003180503845,
-0.4051371216773987,
0.08150086551904678,
-0.2223191112279892,
-0.024256376549601555,
-1.2594062089920044,
-0.2621568739414215,
0.25277578830718994,
-0.36607587337493896,
0.1930549591779709,
0.19057659804821014,
-0.556818425655365,
-0.0707845538854599,
-0.4746015965938568,
0.6092419624328613,
0.011238747276365757,
-0.2295907884836197,
1.043177604675293,
0.040050406008958817,
0.10654611885547638,
-0.74952232837677,
-0.36265289783477783,
0.04358704015612602,
-0.22823457419872284,
-0.7822100520133972,
-0.4469134211540222,
-0.27856457233428955,
-0.41451919078826904,
0.08352353423833847,
-0.25502029061317444,
-0.10882982611656189,
0.05835260450839996,
0.6062045097351074,
0.39472758769989014,
-0.2720194458961487,
0.5399770140647888,
-0.09212646633386612,
0.21274620294570923,
0.11371303349733353,
0.35204389691352844,
0.38757404685020447,
-0.37195366621017456,
-0.7693002223968506,
-0.339349627494812,
0.497979074716568,
1.141160011291504,
-0.24523791670799255,
0.5605408549308777,
0.7869777083396912,
-0.2123343050479889,
0.17607973515987396,
-0.7410292029380798,
0.20598401129245758,
-0.3862685263156891,
0.4559530019760132,
-0.5050783157348633,
-0.8037422299385071,
0.5711606740951538,
-0.032712191343307495,
-0.3344896137714386,
0.637708306312561,
0.36150047183036804,
0.035521384328603745,
1.464169979095459,
0.4361175298690796,
-0.018546653911471367,
0.3610641062259674,
0.08317568153142929,
0.3287788927555084,
-0.7253628373146057,
-0.4361768066883087,
-0.4132273495197296,
-0.3614363372325897,
-0.7165989875793457,
-0.19727566838264465,
0.41554516553878784,
-0.22939404845237732,
-0.10746210813522339,
-0.17095044255256653,
0.0036198380403220654,
0.21988101303577423,
0.1868894249200821,
-0.08611820638179779,
0.37045934796333313,
-0.11374031007289886,
0.03242377191781998,
-0.17032459378242493,
-0.42636874318122864,
-0.4978494346141815,
1.063655138015747,
0.32147353887557983,
0.7113565802574158,
0.24642810225486755,
0.024294869974255562,
0.45740100741386414,
0.15148885548114777,
-0.9679490327835083,
0.29633328318595886,
-0.06145312637090683,
-0.4773755967617035,
-0.12900495529174805,
-0.5442215800285339,
-0.9124146103858948,
0.5665158629417419,
-0.5032764673233032,
-0.543977677822113,
0.3464359939098358,
-0.1908431202173233,
-0.11352092772722244,
0.277778297662735,
-0.6738227605819702,
1.2445902824401855,
-0.15004122257232666,
-0.2840827405452728,
-0.1100178062915802,
-0.8214436769485474,
0.4691554009914398,
-0.11674516648054123,
0.22476089000701904,
-0.35942190885543823,
-0.008767303079366684,
0.36888355016708374,
-0.2629965841770172,
0.6750746965408325,
-0.20583830773830414,
-0.2395421713590622,
0.0030644950456917286,
0.24362210929393768,
0.4625861644744873,
-0.0370015874505043,
-0.1339578479528427,
0.18362882733345032,
0.0995735228061676,
-0.31411978602409363,
-0.5859473943710327,
0.6258088946342468,
-0.8862860798835754,
-0.15375305712223053,
-0.4459935128688812,
-0.7036201357841492,
-0.6856215000152588,
-0.17197681963443756,
0.1671382486820221,
0.5692810416221619,
-0.23492003977298737,
0.09086517989635468,
0.6270139217376709,
0.029668401926755905,
0.4868548810482025,
0.4744875729084015,
0.1312289983034134,
-0.28565558791160583,
0.8569973707199097,
0.09269881993532181,
0.42019346356391907,
-0.043910447508096695,
0.005184465553611517,
-0.3508943021297455,
-0.2393101155757904,
-0.650796115398407,
-0.06250422447919846,
-0.7035687565803528,
-0.23004257678985596,
-0.6231813430786133,
0.322471559047699,
-0.32531726360321045,
0.23446713387966156,
-0.6442003846168518,
-0.1977161020040512,
-0.22205939888954163,
0.10395058989524841,
0.17847523093223572,
0.9121691584587097,
-0.08993084728717804,
-0.128016859292984,
-1.0584337711334229,
0.13063059747219086,
0.19914373755455017,
0.26835906505584717,
-0.0768805518746376,
-0.20541200041770935,
-0.077553391456604,
0.07733752578496933,
-0.33960309624671936,
-1.2180325984954834,
0.09603876620531082,
-0.013677490875124931,
0.37196940183639526,
0.528917133808136,
-0.0021492033265531063,
0.5762084126472473,
-0.09283260256052017,
0.9804093241691589,
0.322666198015213,
-1.2753571271896362,
0.41622400283813477,
-0.35298871994018555,
0.18680226802825928,
0.6027055382728577,
0.30872204899787903,
-0.7824617624282837,
-0.3218151926994324,
-0.6219192147254944,
-0.9405033588409424,
0.4667937457561493,
0.03994399309158325,
0.16702601313591003,
-0.03802419453859329,
-0.06507299095392227,
0.3884078562259674,
0.39791882038116455,
-0.6411994695663452,
-0.32575881481170654,
-0.24866150319576263,
-0.350195974111557,
0.02738487720489502,
-0.2860652208328247,
-0.32095786929130554,
-0.09665369242429733,
0.35729217529296875,
-0.26113101840019226,
0.15502329170703888,
0.25230664014816284,
-0.12732601165771484,
-0.376809686422348,
0.442279189825058,
0.829057514667511,
0.8482735753059387,
-0.18192830681800842,
0.19078780710697174,
0.2225366234779358,
-0.22263099253177643,
0.30183061957359314,
0.09119822829961777,
0.0921546146273613,
0.18567562103271484,
0.3163239657878876,
0.9244347214698792,
0.28765279054641724,
-0.8980352878570557,
0.8953004479408264,
-0.11123606562614441,
0.12633197009563446,
-0.149273082613945,
-0.3620091378688812,
-0.1464746743440628,
0.3350721001625061,
0.2683108448982239,
0.7741093635559082,
0.20983663201332092,
-0.6782472729682922,
-0.0008888281881809235,
0.601322591304779,
-0.49906089901924133,
-0.4024662673473358,
0.4005384147167206,
0.010382859036326408,
0.22522476315498352,
0.32006874680519104,
-0.34427982568740845,
-0.45099207758903503,
0.5325016379356384,
0.022460976615548134,
0.9781321287155151,
-0.21741990745067596,
0.29617342352867126,
-0.1693541407585144,
0.41531187295913696,
-0.1218835711479187,
0.41082677245140076,
0.10765480995178223,
-0.7030259966850281,
-0.4167407751083374,
-0.3853987455368042,
-0.536311149597168,
0.03399188444018364,
-0.8636128902435303,
0.03473345562815666,
-0.20837314426898956,
-0.3045543134212494,
-0.27468740940093994,
-0.26281753182411194,
-0.8087401986122131,
0.35127222537994385,
0.16176210343837738,
0.6775661110877991,
-1.0109783411026,
0.34369155764579773,
0.7785064578056335,
-0.4630756080150604,
-0.8539202809333801,
0.043964941054582596,
0.16926057636737823,
-0.29755792021751404,
0.7508033514022827,
0.10961579531431198,
-0.47240975499153137,
-0.7408594489097595,
-0.41659682989120483,
-0.6885994076728821,
0.7908421158790588,
0.22226344048976898,
-0.12602199614048004,
0.4115660786628723,
0.3133869171142578,
0.6830132603645325,
-0.32379862666130066,
0.3705446720123291,
0.5130521655082703,
0.6420980095863342,
-0.007142567075788975,
-1.1359014511108398,
0.10085003077983856,
-0.3405367136001587,
-0.14447957277297974,
0.04375741258263588,
-0.752041220664978,
1.3275490999221802,
0.21778492629528046,
-0.30329129099845886,
-0.08746889978647232,
0.5545492172241211,
0.0028854296542704105,
0.6892333626747131,
0.729701817035675,
0.6598337888717651,
0.8500021696090698,
-0.10747368633747101,
0.9493200778961182,
-0.1304224729537964,
0.7232142686843872,
0.9448162317276001,
-0.6419270038604736,
1.0274380445480347,
0.40929386019706726,
-0.290360689163208,
0.464926153421402,
0.6541367173194885,
0.060398347675800323,
0.11459890007972717,
-0.09306691586971283,
-0.5492757558822632,
-0.39637041091918945,
-0.009067220613360405,
-0.6487373113632202,
0.8771265745162964,
0.11642920225858688,
-0.08735722303390503,
-0.2180728167295456,
0.3116741180419922,
0.01882455311715603,
-0.1804066151380539,
-0.08500619232654572,
0.5105472207069397,
-0.41995590925216675,
-0.3306508958339691,
0.4306230843067169,
-0.10922660678625107,
0.7897376418113708,
-0.6560817956924438,
0.16099530458450317,
-0.24093012511730194,
0.08411352336406708,
-0.3476259410381317,
-0.4722386300563812,
0.30752065777778625,
-0.0661621242761612,
-0.26067763566970825,
0.16013410687446594,
0.5547624826431274,
-0.3343314826488495,
-0.3955094814300537,
0.36223042011260986,
0.7731022238731384,
-0.04256238415837288,
-0.33525973558425903,
-0.7787797451019287,
0.6285173296928406,
-0.1686629056930542,
-0.43431058526039124,
0.19439701735973358,
0.6914490461349487,
0.2094302922487259,
0.5411587953567505,
0.582614541053772,
-0.22340261936187744,
0.1190076619386673,
0.12588359415531158,
0.9219561815261841,
-0.7315420508384705,
-0.08463609218597412,
-0.9329252243041992,
0.6739329099655151,
0.0464453287422657,
-0.6089446544647217,
1.0455647706985474,
0.5700576305389404,
0.6628168821334839,
-0.18355441093444824,
0.7469916939735413,
-0.2124451994895935,
0.26803725957870483,
-0.6735835671424866,
0.3636718988418579,
-0.8441024422645569,
0.15465061366558075,
-0.4630543291568756,
-0.794996976852417,
-0.1340782195329666,
0.368448942899704,
-0.07443969696760178,
0.17884120345115662,
1.0781605243682861,
0.768941342830658,
0.008381298743188381,
0.40158355236053467,
0.36876946687698364,
0.31711018085479736,
0.1237366646528244,
0.4968128800392151,
1.4052358865737915,
-0.5029307007789612,
0.3297449052333832,
-0.17531615495681763,
-0.07185088843107224,
-0.20218922197818756,
-0.8863216042518616,
-0.5554664731025696,
-0.6573768854141235,
-0.34823668003082275,
-0.6250274181365967,
-0.2427830696105957,
1.103309154510498,
0.5005035400390625,
-0.8462449312210083,
-0.06291677802801132,
0.3779720664024353,
0.24273577332496643,
-0.14047665894031525,
-0.3464129865169525,
0.23606190085411072,
-0.4043121039867401,
-0.8195738196372986,
0.5682309865951538,
0.36607569456100464,
-0.07127686589956284,
-0.45228153467178345,
0.12176498770713806,
-0.09340004622936249,
0.29433733224868774,
0.7876312136650085,
0.17803074419498444,
-0.8075221180915833,
-0.5743230581283569,
-0.045007944107055664,
-0.2927274703979492,
0.2125922590494156,
1.0349897146224976,
-0.4858175814151764,
0.6512064933776855,
0.598240315914154,
0.6391133666038513,
-0.04038441553711891,
0.0022333890665322542,
0.2106751799583435,
-0.7038659453392029,
-0.07787764817476273,
0.025198599323630333,
0.4429718852043152,
0.4345270097255707,
-0.36197930574417114,
0.22220253944396973,
0.46814706921577454,
-0.47308868169784546,
-0.805769681930542,
0.268454372882843,
-1.5435205698013306,
-0.20814919471740723,
1.1531809568405151,
-0.010322130285203457,
0.07944560796022415,
-0.1074189618229866,
-0.3291662037372589,
-0.005743435118347406,
-0.47578686475753784,
0.9174705743789673,
1.0228179693222046,
-0.34507864713668823,
0.19462443888187408,
-0.6603123545646667,
0.30083709955215454,
0.7491400837898254,
-0.8537843823432922,
0.1163673996925354,
0.9332956075668335,
0.1891433596611023,
0.31631970405578613,
0.3859349489212036,
-0.12132157385349274,
0.2553888261318207,
0.11855914443731308,
-0.007006291765719652,
0.06119922921061516,
-0.1709624081850052,
-0.7208942770957947,
0.5562370419502258,
-0.17506586015224457,
-0.3080247938632965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02974v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02974v1
|
Readability-guided Idiom-aware Sentence Simplification (RISS) for Chinese
| 2024-06-05T06:15:48 | 2024-06-05T06:15:48 |
Jingshen Zhang, Xinglu Chen, Xinying Qiu, Zhimin Wang, Wenhe Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chinese sentence simplification faces challenges due to the lack of
large-scale labeled parallel corpora and the prevalence of idioms. To address
these challenges, we propose Readability-guided Idiom-aware Sentence
Simplification (RISS), a novel framework that combines data augmentation
techniques with lexcial simplification. RISS introduces two key components: (1)
Readability-guided Paraphrase Selection (RPS), a method for mining high-quality
sentence pairs, and (2) Idiom-aware Simplification (IAS), a model that enhances
the comprehension and simplification of idiomatic expressions. By integrating
RPS and IAS using multi-stage and multi-task learning strategies, RISS
outperforms previous state-of-the-art methods on two Chinese sentence
simplification datasets. Furthermore, RISS achieves additional improvements
when fine-tuned on a small labeled dataset. Our approach demonstrates the
potential for more effective and accessible Chinese text simplification.
|
[
0.10585597157478333,
-0.4122152328491211,
0.47591331601142883,
0.6950594782829285,
-0.6986377835273743,
-0.05638541281223297,
-0.3262210488319397,
-0.19194047152996063,
0.016642853617668152,
0.3909480571746826,
-0.6004552245140076,
-0.6026698350906372,
-0.1799698770046234,
0.2556915283203125,
-0.21089455485343933,
1.1285400390625,
0.042685676366090775,
0.12661267817020416,
-0.2590954303741455,
-0.2791597545146942,
-0.4122609496116638,
-0.0881676971912384,
-0.4157430827617645,
-0.26220303773880005,
0.5500584840774536,
0.754416286945343,
0.9223600625991821,
1.24253249168396,
0.6925502419471741,
0.14519637823104858,
-0.4123000502586365,
0.5259041786193848,
-0.029787350445985794,
0.29677319526672363,
-0.014243889600038528,
-0.42930054664611816,
-0.46001264452934265,
-0.3390520215034485,
0.5588811635971069,
0.6397624611854553,
-0.030265793204307556,
0.11703237146139145,
0.4873257279396057,
0.6466823220252991,
-0.49344557523727417,
0.45265427231788635,
-0.32104262709617615,
0.06092575564980507,
-0.5172855854034424,
-0.487211674451828,
-0.41293925046920776,
-0.3405231833457947,
-0.1048467829823494,
-0.9410815238952637,
-0.04154394939541817,
0.21241095662117004,
0.49745216965675354,
0.33253902196884155,
-0.3617742359638214,
-0.15663191676139832,
-0.227000892162323,
0.7197405099868774,
-0.7974129319190979,
0.21978092193603516,
0.014834216795861721,
-0.030233653262257576,
-0.05243831127882004,
-0.938471257686615,
-0.35316869616508484,
-0.2398313581943512,
-0.5142621397972107,
-0.14503364264965057,
0.4324369728565216,
0.29514315724372864,
0.4767366349697113,
0.48904678225517273,
-0.8083662390708923,
-0.055351682007312775,
-0.1782982498407364,
-0.04347328469157219,
0.5795586705207825,
0.3988887667655945,
0.6004070043563843,
-0.27411261200904846,
-0.648486852645874,
0.04710507392883301,
-0.798280656337738,
0.20705071091651917,
0.07871593534946442,
0.6826050281524658,
-0.12889721989631653,
0.3488537669181824,
-0.46805861592292786,
0.496183305978775,
-0.42019397020339966,
-0.3002426326274872,
0.3669019043445587,
-0.6826725006103516,
-0.02448706328868866,
-0.24869684875011444,
0.550485372543335,
0.2910081744194031,
0.3672465682029724,
-0.050935856997966766,
-0.2531577944755554,
-0.33972200751304626,
-0.28481799364089966,
-0.806236207485199,
-0.2732507884502411,
0.26011133193969727,
-0.7093435525894165,
-0.24540367722511292,
0.2203896939754486,
-0.7804399132728577,
-0.522336483001709,
-0.3162536025047302,
0.07127229869365692,
-0.4297247529029846,
-0.011473328806459904,
0.2893041670322418,
-0.28278401494026184,
0.2268580198287964,
0.39696696400642395,
-0.6495136618614197,
0.0879112035036087,
0.931526243686676,
0.9294045567512512,
-0.008029315620660782,
-0.5012344121932983,
-0.7279056310653687,
0.3575495481491089,
-0.1557585597038269,
0.5529167652130127,
-0.4416695535182953,
-0.18896354734897614,
-0.19177094101905823,
-0.40127527713775635,
-0.020567212253808975,
-0.767052173614502,
1.0649571418762207,
-0.1523267775774002,
-0.10631106793880463,
-0.29718607664108276,
-0.6442497372627258,
-0.12807543575763702,
0.00926128774881363,
-0.4955601394176483,
0.8893768191337585,
-0.20892015099525452,
-0.9079430103302002,
0.31603580713272095,
-0.677886962890625,
-0.8073464632034302,
0.34682697057724,
-0.2013670802116394,
-0.4833484888076782,
-0.1570557951927185,
0.4443093240261078,
0.38944369554519653,
-0.34851646423339844,
0.2668309807777405,
-0.32559776306152344,
-0.5999748706817627,
-0.1293487250804901,
-0.566161036491394,
0.8801398873329163,
0.49614837765693665,
-0.17022211849689484,
0.24890995025634766,
-0.3814678490161896,
0.2581334412097931,
-0.023768652230501175,
-0.21938768029212952,
-0.41347554326057434,
-0.10485592484474182,
0.10644707083702087,
0.19044050574302673,
0.5514374375343323,
-0.42922648787498474,
0.06948978453874588,
-0.11647845804691315,
0.39245274662971497,
0.4160511791706085,
0.2134571373462677,
0.19261959195137024,
-0.3378598988056183,
0.4448719918727875,
0.37715011835098267,
0.4323946237564087,
-0.7647293210029602,
-0.312170147895813,
-0.5854442119598389,
-0.6351345181465149,
0.2110893279314041,
0.926285982131958,
-0.7036318182945251,
0.4839039444923401,
-0.2153346985578537,
-0.6192251443862915,
-0.5132100582122803,
0.35539382696151733,
0.5132609605789185,
0.37737366557121277,
0.5370333194732666,
0.22901657223701477,
-0.1330793797969818,
-0.8805249333381653,
-0.8464640378952026,
-0.17389588057994843,
0.15556283295154572,
-0.26728326082229614,
0.16425678133964539,
0.20320196449756622,
0.6008816957473755,
-0.5958910584449768,
-0.4131592810153961,
-0.46149349212646484,
0.13136683404445648,
0.15468207001686096,
0.6315969228744507,
0.2964794635772705,
-1.193272352218628,
-0.7226127982139587,
0.017834823578596115,
-0.7514293789863586,
-0.19827046990394592,
-0.22059044241905212,
0.2995077967643738,
-0.34008845686912537,
1.0268105268478394,
-0.4305912256240845,
0.7023665308952332,
-0.07319554686546326,
-0.28566619753837585,
0.21875272691249847,
-0.4229573905467987,
0.02308594435453415,
-0.8336946964263916,
-0.07462943345308304,
0.13499507308006287,
-0.26751449704170227,
-0.470553994178772,
0.455637663602829,
0.4299897253513336,
-0.03625203296542168,
-0.3305153250694275,
0.4388847053050995,
-0.6451869010925293,
-0.0766797587275505,
-0.1657284051179886,
0.1746511459350586,
0.2593933045864105,
0.3552909195423126,
-0.2046494334936142,
1.0793429613113403,
0.4150768220424652,
-0.5653268694877625,
0.25522351264953613,
0.27008017897605896,
-0.605288028717041,
0.38418006896972656,
-0.6292183995246887,
-0.415910542011261,
-0.3026818037033081,
0.2721605896949768,
-0.8586694002151489,
-0.06345686316490173,
0.4039733409881592,
-0.15004678070545197,
-0.11184299737215042,
0.33839672803878784,
-0.7227356433868408,
0.17354775965213776,
-0.3782508671283722,
0.3744841516017914,
0.14585110545158386,
-0.8723825216293335,
0.4258688688278198,
-0.12357953190803528,
-0.5922577977180481,
-0.7964532971382141,
-0.6646502017974854,
0.11102130264043808,
-0.4767450988292694,
-0.4971509277820587,
0.2856539487838745,
-0.262105256319046,
-0.3887350261211395,
-0.05125848948955536,
0.10248216241598129,
-0.1312718689441681,
0.2212080955505371,
-0.1328013837337494,
0.04950859397649765,
-0.0954035148024559,
0.3546818792819977,
0.2665967345237732,
0.02112104557454586,
-0.403690367937088,
0.3304840326309204,
0.17098933458328247,
-0.303997665643692,
-0.28686240315437317,
-0.7505688071250916,
0.5311830043792725,
0.5062523484230042,
-0.5969197750091553,
0.24135522544384003,
0.5547837018966675,
-0.28116175532341003,
-0.4848007261753082,
0.12783165276050568,
-0.20477627217769623,
-0.4559823274612427,
0.30587923526763916,
-0.5798302888870239,
-0.5905138850212097,
0.3543705642223358,
-0.17408908903598785,
0.524500846862793,
0.19778403639793396,
-0.04290591552853584,
-0.12019072473049164,
0.8814346790313721,
0.4619053900241852,
0.019612735137343407,
0.5041062831878662,
0.306578129529953,
0.4857620894908905,
-0.5723608732223511,
-0.24484995007514954,
-0.5822336673736572,
-0.16693471372127533,
-0.39568084478378296,
-0.28221917152404785,
0.47209128737449646,
0.17740866541862488,
-0.19962458312511444,
0.17130526900291443,
-0.3220268189907074,
0.41777464747428894,
0.5784564018249512,
0.40650635957717896,
0.643489420413971,
-0.22611699998378754,
0.04951830953359604,
-0.41626033186912537,
-0.5743025541305542,
-0.42511647939682007,
0.5996671319007874,
0.32522544264793396,
0.7502023577690125,
0.07971715927124023,
0.549626886844635,
0.5393598675727844,
0.0014183808816596866,
-0.5612603425979614,
0.8829147219657898,
-0.5746214389801025,
-0.19348296523094177,
-0.2487105131149292,
-0.290632426738739,
-0.5127543210983276,
0.3076013922691345,
-0.08207350969314575,
-0.4385719895362854,
0.006298677530139685,
0.04831235855817795,
-0.4241611659526825,
0.18504787981510162,
-0.6370911598205566,
0.8297498822212219,
-0.15359611809253693,
-0.003877794835716486,
-0.1835314929485321,
-0.7750424146652222,
0.2226981520652771,
0.16688889265060425,
0.2140413373708725,
0.06418731063604355,
-0.3743046820163727,
0.2437439113855362,
-0.6096929311752319,
0.669097900390625,
-0.0902625098824501,
0.09474378824234009,
0.2042345553636551,
-0.18211568892002106,
0.545928418636322,
0.21066731214523315,
-0.056546732783317566,
-0.2397284358739853,
-0.03107869252562523,
-0.3799082636833191,
-0.9824727177619934,
0.4891308844089508,
-0.1165250688791275,
-0.6721974015235901,
-0.3429390788078308,
-0.8739274740219116,
0.017185380682349205,
0.31509295105934143,
0.004306941758841276,
0.5079811215400696,
0.07949145138263702,
0.4415169656276703,
0.7882639765739441,
-0.11063332855701447,
0.31092095375061035,
0.19737759232521057,
-0.1633884608745575,
-0.39906513690948486,
0.8289437294006348,
0.033843059092760086,
0.11930113285779953,
0.5140992999076843,
0.06948596984148026,
-0.08307730406522751,
-0.607753574848175,
-0.3676512539386749,
0.31117522716522217,
-0.7058683633804321,
0.007651374209672213,
-0.41497868299484253,
-0.2223663479089737,
-0.5140080451965332,
-0.07706160843372345,
0.1638047993183136,
-0.3582111597061157,
-0.3961499333381653,
-0.13740220665931702,
0.315197616815567,
0.5608111619949341,
-0.25273647904396057,
0.2833443880081177,
-0.6961231827735901,
0.5603479146957397,
-0.0773347020149231,
0.2794768810272217,
-0.3701304495334625,
-0.5722111463546753,
-0.31379470229148865,
-0.10756321251392365,
0.08168777078390121,
-0.6711515188217163,
0.26000067591667175,
0.1163862869143486,
0.44341906905174255,
0.3663346469402313,
0.4012294113636017,
0.842837393283844,
-0.13401594758033752,
0.6313194036483765,
-0.2213018387556076,
-0.891974151134491,
0.31553199887275696,
-0.3593244254589081,
0.2548391819000244,
0.7090051770210266,
-0.1281675398349762,
-0.5461298823356628,
-0.3115295469760895,
-0.4938405156135559,
-0.8929728269577026,
0.4252983629703522,
-0.004451137036085129,
-0.047511231154203415,
0.1518835574388504,
0.6959497332572937,
0.051590196788311005,
0.21566249430179596,
-0.7462183833122253,
-0.42763984203338623,
0.19778330624103546,
-0.6429411172866821,
-0.05553463101387024,
-0.16638408601284027,
0.07334303110837936,
-0.07475528866052628,
0.867314875125885,
-0.16743291914463043,
-0.26597145199775696,
0.21201197803020477,
0.035087332129478455,
0.27114295959472656,
0.4332190454006195,
0.33417320251464844,
0.35469406843185425,
-0.1455182433128357,
-0.22118224203586578,
-0.03396279737353325,
-0.36298516392707825,
-0.16023775935173035,
0.23382723331451416,
-0.78123539686203,
0.3060009479522705,
0.2989041209220886,
0.7614920139312744,
-0.33050304651260376,
-1.00178861618042,
0.7500802278518677,
-0.04545196145772934,
0.09643472731113434,
-0.4005448520183563,
0.10885175317525864,
-0.1040719598531723,
0.45849350094795227,
0.30871933698654175,
-0.038197971880435944,
0.3619784414768219,
-0.3378710150718689,
0.45179426670074463,
0.14112071692943573,
-0.23918211460113525,
0.13502590358257294,
0.5426068902015686,
0.11022137105464935,
-0.1800137758255005,
0.4652212858200073,
-0.032495345920324326,
-0.08671027421951294,
0.6489454507827759,
0.27545660734176636,
0.8381597995758057,
0.0684407651424408,
0.1477786898612976,
0.3002207577228546,
0.6097687482833862,
-0.3542836308479309,
0.5424023270606995,
-0.09510033577680588,
-0.2990866005420685,
-0.07951075583696365,
0.0593516007065773,
-0.5943336486816406,
0.11634010076522827,
-1.0577844381332397,
0.6519049406051636,
-0.39279454946517944,
0.37034931778907776,
-0.022736569866538048,
-0.031359605491161346,
-0.23973670601844788,
0.604647159576416,
-0.17652784287929535,
1.2860100269317627,
-0.7790281772613525,
0.807632565498352,
0.6556437015533447,
-0.48447680473327637,
-0.7574828863143921,
0.6299729347229004,
-0.3200649321079254,
-0.47159409523010254,
0.6276227831840515,
0.3007195293903351,
0.10846231877803802,
0.026215141639113426,
-0.43270039558410645,
-0.48666539788246155,
1.392797827720642,
0.3533543646335602,
-0.24474385380744934,
-0.1484888345003128,
0.14501714706420898,
0.3872867524623871,
-0.4428780972957611,
-0.02608332969248295,
0.4226974844932556,
0.5228718519210815,
-0.347680002450943,
-0.8161492943763733,
0.03920966014266014,
-0.23827801644802094,
-0.024166427552700043,
0.03599853441119194,
-0.8774495124816895,
1.0316896438598633,
-0.3854140043258667,
-0.14458784461021423,
0.4142856001853943,
1.0870054960250854,
0.4063543677330017,
0.6201838254928589,
0.7075161337852478,
0.5799350738525391,
0.7847113013267517,
-0.006585363298654556,
0.8160147070884705,
-0.43328526616096497,
0.07568857073783875,
1.241740107536316,
-0.12794867157936096,
0.7724065184593201,
0.508070707321167,
0.0808774083852768,
0.621976375579834,
0.41531822085380554,
0.3674938678741455,
0.6324843168258667,
0.16293519735336304,
-0.5237505435943604,
-0.4081653356552124,
-0.40657347440719604,
-0.23673203587532043,
0.33089205622673035,
0.578626275062561,
-0.423630028963089,
-0.41836827993392944,
0.005871450994163752,
0.2764676511287689,
0.6107756495475769,
-0.2830371856689453,
0.42460188269615173,
0.028399739414453506,
-0.7354569435119629,
0.024533597752451897,
0.13444256782531738,
0.6650239825248718,
-0.6497557163238525,
-0.21293067932128906,
-0.2619468569755554,
0.3297232389450073,
-0.25020653009414673,
-1.1602392196655273,
0.14569498598575592,
-0.05704445019364357,
-0.1688503921031952,
-0.2918621897697449,
0.7649498581886292,
-0.698675811290741,
-0.13914254307746887,
0.2636398375034332,
0.5956845879554749,
0.12385760247707367,
0.052959613502025604,
-0.8174868822097778,
-0.1396208256483078,
0.2940567135810852,
-0.23259484767913818,
0.2443476766347885,
0.7083644866943359,
-0.12304393202066422,
0.9384362697601318,
0.41962239146232605,
0.008535707369446754,
-0.12866833806037903,
-0.005511655937880278,
0.7913603186607361,
-0.8414605259895325,
-0.8657894134521484,
-0.5959466695785522,
0.41950148344039917,
-0.2519698739051819,
-0.5244152545928955,
0.8348192572593689,
0.6742782592773438,
0.7221249938011169,
0.23483715951442719,
1.0622990131378174,
0.2280668318271637,
1.0215691328048706,
-0.40552499890327454,
0.31770196557044983,
-0.727613627910614,
0.41521209478378296,
-0.111036516726017,
-0.5305041074752808,
-0.5589303374290466,
0.3069978952407837,
-0.1044318899512291,
-0.09553937613964081,
0.5735485553741455,
0.9355972409248352,
0.08119668066501617,
0.1645965427160263,
0.15755175054073334,
-0.08688067644834518,
0.09489676356315613,
0.3273233473300934,
0.3365774154663086,
-0.41831856966018677,
0.7595558762550354,
-0.4750345051288605,
-0.13505639135837555,
-0.09815533459186554,
-0.9101727604866028,
-0.5982654094696045,
-0.605559229850769,
-0.457116961479187,
-0.12237853556871414,
0.18749603629112244,
0.8378129005432129,
0.0783303901553154,
-0.5273020267486572,
-0.16601453721523285,
-0.13612884283065796,
0.0998314693570137,
-0.6531387567520142,
-0.24618439376354218,
0.38284367322921753,
-0.6150304079055786,
-0.8273899555206299,
0.5223796963691711,
0.4317152202129364,
-0.130209818482399,
-0.0543154701590538,
0.045436207205057144,
-0.22951561212539673,
0.08747051656246185,
0.20269307494163513,
0.413394033908844,
-0.5198059678077698,
-0.03470747172832489,
0.02214263752102852,
-0.43628013134002686,
-0.02649984136223793,
0.873477041721344,
-0.4591328799724579,
0.39678075909614563,
0.7168254256248474,
0.7324186563491821,
-0.2001575380563736,
0.29415929317474365,
0.40908312797546387,
-0.6162977814674377,
0.28236114978790283,
0.17152491211891174,
0.5499191880226135,
0.42248591780662537,
-0.5465254187583923,
0.5401822328567505,
0.20049144327640533,
-0.4394051730632782,
-0.8184026479721069,
0.35395389795303345,
-0.9649612307548523,
-0.4952850937843323,
1.240350365638733,
-0.5643670558929443,
0.017239201813936234,
-0.2716767489910126,
-0.32209473848342896,
0.2172851413488388,
-0.2585931420326233,
0.2147037833929062,
0.41727519035339355,
-0.004010173957794905,
-0.36817705631256104,
-0.24568849802017212,
0.5768842101097107,
0.9152939915657043,
-0.876497209072113,
0.44780096411705017,
0.3829019367694855,
0.08218653500080109,
-0.16647782921791077,
0.4510065019130707,
-0.1179698258638382,
0.37587082386016846,
-0.1463133692741394,
0.05746239796280861,
-0.28257986903190613,
-0.4572978913784027,
-0.3536934554576874,
0.11407694220542908,
0.033371202647686005,
-0.24007466435432434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02969v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02969v1
|
Filtered not Mixed: Stochastic Filtering-Based Online Gating for Mixture of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-05T05:53:50 | 2024-06-05T05:53:50 |
Raeid Saqur, Anastasis Kratsios, Florian Krach, Yannick Limmer, Jacob-Junqi Tian, John Willes, Blanka Horvath, Frank Rudzicz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-fin.CP, q-fin.MF, 60J05, 60G35, 68T20, 68T42, 68T50, I.2.6; I.2.7; G.3
|
We propose MoE-F -- a formalised mechanism for combining $N$ pre-trained
expert Large Language Models (LLMs) in online time-series prediction tasks by
adaptively forecasting the best weighting of LLM predictions at every time
step. Our mechanism leverages the conditional information in each expert's
running performance to forecast the best combination of LLMs for predicting the
time series in its next step. Diverging from static (learned) Mixture of
Experts (MoE) methods, MoE-F employs time-adaptive stochastic filtering
techniques to combine experts. By framing the expert selection problem as a
finite state-space, continuous-time Hidden Markov model (HMM), we can leverage
the Wohman-Shiryaev filter. Our approach first constructs $N$ parallel filters
corresponding to each of the $N$ individual LLMs. Each filter proposes its best
combination of LLMs, given the information that they have access to.
Subsequently, the $N$ filter outputs are aggregated to optimize a lower bound
for the loss of the aggregated LLMs, which can be optimized in closed-form,
thus generating our ensemble predictor. Our contributions here are: (I) the
MoE-F algorithm -- deployable as a plug-and-play filtering harness, (II)
theoretical optimality guarantees of the proposed filtering-based gating
algorithm, and (III) empirical evaluation and ablative results using state of
the art foundational and MoE LLMs on a real-world Financial Market Movement
task where MoE-F attains a remarkable 17% absolute and 48.5% relative F1
measure improvement over the next best performing individual LLM expert.
|
[
-0.6151182651519775,
-0.8843287229537964,
0.5306856632232666,
0.26448875665664673,
-0.3041594922542572,
0.47098374366760254,
-0.2935592532157898,
-0.6455665826797485,
0.5638401508331299,
0.38268396258354187,
-0.7203174829483032,
-0.2884660065174103,
-0.5354762673377991,
-0.17418290674686432,
-0.4013618528842926,
0.9305153489112854,
0.18150711059570312,
0.20738643407821655,
-0.2449781596660614,
0.2577405571937561,
-0.25471025705337524,
-0.12675420939922333,
-0.7617691159248352,
-0.4906023442745209,
0.21948443353176117,
0.13320279121398926,
0.5546546578407288,
0.3107909858226776,
0.48030516505241394,
0.3373839259147644,
0.12566186487674713,
0.3498908281326294,
-0.6938548684120178,
0.23511001467704773,
-0.015411131083965302,
-0.4920509159564972,
-0.6305361986160278,
-0.18001426756381989,
0.27579453587532043,
0.4088386595249176,
-0.7275362014770508,
-0.1940688043832779,
-0.0010698535479605198,
0.367299348115921,
-0.5812559127807617,
0.03550651669502258,
-0.7527163028717041,
0.1779150515794754,
-0.31477656960487366,
-0.5021308660507202,
-0.3183358907699585,
-0.05540211498737335,
-0.1245570108294487,
-0.6385281682014465,
0.03930062800645828,
0.32787251472473145,
0.5351335406303406,
0.20164787769317627,
-0.25516632199287415,
-0.0018243396189063787,
-0.8384129405021667,
1.0194951295852661,
-0.9883823394775391,
0.16806384921073914,
0.6703839302062988,
0.5168272852897644,
-0.3527515232563019,
-0.5414438843727112,
-0.4815748929977417,
-0.13228757679462433,
0.3594982922077179,
0.3969084322452545,
-0.038670167326927185,
0.08866392076015472,
-0.02539248950779438,
0.6711716651916504,
-0.34278398752212524,
0.17876474559307098,
-0.37606367468833923,
-0.07356804609298706,
0.9396066069602966,
0.042914316058158875,
0.13672609627246857,
0.613284707069397,
-0.4309959411621094,
0.22641047835350037,
-0.5305966734886169,
-0.19089658558368683,
0.5929578542709351,
0.06737668067216873,
-0.3059573471546173,
0.23913975059986115,
-0.4326266050338745,
0.5557495951652527,
0.4721015691757202,
-0.42345118522644043,
-0.14290989935398102,
-0.19311238825321198,
-0.2014831155538559,
-0.09301474690437317,
0.9607606530189514,
0.30643582344055176,
0.2745018005371094,
-0.23019708693027496,
-0.3856644332408905,
-0.28655126690864563,
-0.04063337296247482,
-0.5786063075065613,
-0.5875537395477295,
0.0005439598462544382,
-0.17958539724349976,
-0.5340064167976379,
0.14084094762802124,
-1.0767221450805664,
-0.4324168562889099,
-0.14047633111476898,
0.6414893865585327,
-0.05362647399306297,
-0.3644968867301941,
-0.03889412805438042,
0.055193666368722916,
-0.27508026361465454,
0.1850779801607132,
-1.101996660232544,
0.3984934985637665,
0.5818267464637756,
0.703728973865509,
-0.09996185451745987,
-0.19331376254558563,
-0.8474183678627014,
0.1958734691143036,
-0.25830891728401184,
0.7446901202201843,
-0.7767820358276367,
-0.6299790740013123,
0.03440390154719353,
-0.6147727370262146,
0.03552089259028435,
-0.3181633949279785,
0.19446615874767303,
-0.7363823652267456,
0.11887099593877792,
0.05558278039097786,
-0.5453184247016907,
-0.3477482497692108,
-0.07281069457530975,
-0.5158019065856934,
1.2767387628555298,
-0.024833381175994873,
-0.5909982323646545,
0.5277138948440552,
-0.6217490434646606,
-0.573072075843811,
-0.13550293445587158,
0.16465449333190918,
-0.18380875885486603,
-0.05809899792075157,
0.6415932774543762,
0.5475326180458069,
-0.29303357005119324,
0.541160523891449,
-0.9526563286781311,
-0.36913782358169556,
0.3262317478656769,
-0.46804508566856384,
0.4207293391227722,
0.34039485454559326,
-0.31946390867233276,
0.4568271338939667,
-0.7851247191429138,
-0.05075470358133316,
-0.12527799606323242,
-0.1339757889509201,
-0.13040389120578766,
0.4639955163002014,
0.21831895411014557,
0.2969861626625061,
0.1997988373041153,
-0.4404357373714447,
0.13594147562980652,
-0.34855958819389343,
0.7126927375793457,
0.9088284969329834,
0.17585022747516632,
0.5900564789772034,
-0.5930209159851074,
0.5590274333953857,
0.05021265149116516,
0.059477176517248154,
0.020407604053616524,
-0.8479453325271606,
-0.724215567111969,
-0.4621950089931488,
0.17051395773887634,
0.5573709011077881,
-0.998553991317749,
0.5139890313148499,
-0.25177478790283203,
-0.6644589900970459,
-0.40034928917884827,
0.350139319896698,
-0.01492859236896038,
0.18252518773078918,
0.2207583338022232,
-0.2617952525615692,
-0.44180265069007874,
-0.7041124701499939,
-0.10844001919031143,
-0.11234432458877563,
-0.0888543501496315,
0.022131815552711487,
0.20202109217643738,
-0.1700521558523178,
0.9963881969451904,
-0.5024195909500122,
-0.2632029056549072,
-0.16027919948101044,
0.3667854070663452,
0.2373974770307541,
0.2024787813425064,
0.5357170701026917,
-0.6661148071289062,
-0.6003974080085754,
0.1475311666727066,
-0.45584622025489807,
-0.2523699402809143,
-0.11675558239221573,
-0.15332536399364471,
-0.051500964909791946,
0.35370945930480957,
-0.4088730812072754,
0.2243906408548355,
0.6161200404167175,
0.05254705622792244,
0.24231834709644318,
-0.4038187861442566,
0.14653824269771576,
-1.2131932973861694,
-0.3241213262081146,
0.12739114463329315,
-0.5149934887886047,
-0.6132410764694214,
0.249558687210083,
-0.25385406613349915,
0.0670892670750618,
-0.2950834333896637,
0.7039838433265686,
-0.37601780891418457,
0.03238401934504509,
-0.5256032347679138,
0.06221834197640419,
-0.28032124042510986,
0.6585884690284729,
-0.15213614702224731,
0.747958242893219,
0.9390934705734253,
-0.8180941343307495,
0.4655241072177887,
-0.15248416364192963,
-0.4722147583961487,
0.5836265087127686,
-0.21444202959537506,
0.34883663058280945,
0.153914213180542,
0.3084198534488678,
-0.8454010486602783,
-0.225618377327919,
0.1600736379623413,
-0.29249683022499084,
0.2947987914085388,
-0.039823662489652634,
-0.35007593035697937,
-0.19858576357364655,
-0.15690197050571442,
0.23341545462608337,
0.44701769948005676,
-0.39163661003112793,
0.8538486957550049,
0.5682052969932556,
-0.5055912733078003,
-0.39890092611312866,
-0.8693413138389587,
0.167347714304924,
-0.24253006279468536,
-0.8684266209602356,
0.26789265871047974,
-0.14501655101776123,
-0.3541157841682434,
-0.10179385542869568,
-0.12335410714149475,
-0.32607802748680115,
0.34589239954948425,
0.16002300381660461,
0.32990676164627075,
-0.21164585649967194,
-0.14120735228061676,
-0.025490568950772285,
-0.04315108060836792,
-0.2410857081413269,
-0.5623406767845154,
0.46088388562202454,
0.06416420638561249,
-0.6429710984230042,
-0.20462289452552795,
0.6539801359176636,
0.3746682405471802,
-0.20252583920955658,
0.6618663668632507,
0.9643818140029907,
-0.4434104859828949,
-0.48005861043930054,
-0.6829783916473389,
-0.24926318228244781,
-0.5279816389083862,
0.37540870904922485,
-0.28012314438819885,
-1.115119457244873,
0.7238154411315918,
0.4805051386356354,
0.2712094187736511,
0.35813406109809875,
0.6598927974700928,
-0.1922304928302765,
0.9898976683616638,
0.6395092010498047,
-0.40002134442329407,
0.6591784954071045,
0.10814983397722244,
0.6716586947441101,
-0.19139964878559113,
0.07150817662477493,
0.04860176891088486,
-0.6537507176399231,
-0.6224587559700012,
-0.5120168924331665,
0.3943428695201874,
0.11035457998514175,
0.03360627591609955,
-0.15557777881622314,
-0.08402244746685028,
0.41550400853157043,
0.8600952625274658,
0.2897935211658478,
0.27302077412605286,
0.0954776406288147,
-0.030262794345617294,
0.18400903046131134,
-0.6469424962997437,
0.04360051825642586,
1.386891484260559,
0.19665776193141937,
1.1660035848617554,
-0.023164497688412666,
0.5936245322227478,
0.5362134575843811,
0.4169246554374695,
-0.8214412927627563,
0.7273102402687073,
-0.011080436408519745,
-0.7049168348312378,
-0.21864818036556244,
-0.510941207408905,
-0.431835800409317,
0.28308284282684326,
-0.4660138487815857,
-0.7949698567390442,
0.10910717397928238,
0.2257131189107895,
-0.5085597038269043,
0.8117661476135254,
-0.48386451601982117,
0.21935376524925232,
-0.25731906294822693,
-0.46287867426872253,
-0.5688082575798035,
-0.28911933302879333,
0.5323611497879028,
-0.4022272527217865,
0.3576124310493469,
-0.1665000021457672,
0.08718124032020569,
0.7192056775093079,
-0.33055153489112854,
0.8050246834754944,
-0.15644587576389313,
0.08290664106607437,
0.24613386392593384,
0.14498528838157654,
0.789831280708313,
-0.09359289705753326,
-0.014208081178367138,
0.3980182707309723,
-0.12860329449176788,
-0.42981410026550293,
-0.40134912729263306,
0.8160243034362793,
-0.615005373954773,
-0.726487398147583,
-0.3979102671146393,
-0.5577386617660522,
-0.5489289164543152,
0.14077922701835632,
0.21192869544029236,
0.3245668411254883,
0.06827950477600098,
0.34354060888290405,
0.35184797644615173,
0.38298311829566956,
0.6051427721977234,
0.4394935071468353,
-0.4532490074634552,
-0.7014572024345398,
1.1320195198059082,
-0.0011347479885444045,
0.20618899166584015,
0.5791317224502563,
0.14637333154678345,
-0.24741250276565552,
-0.8879177570343018,
-0.26869064569473267,
0.0463850311934948,
-0.664139449596405,
0.04137328267097473,
-0.49456703662872314,
-0.13906200230121613,
-0.3256200850009918,
-0.20057198405265808,
-0.07366945594549179,
-0.19692204892635345,
-0.4466886520385742,
-0.25565674901008606,
0.42096126079559326,
0.7263591289520264,
-0.08851675689220428,
0.6473137140274048,
-0.8905936479568481,
0.17822913825511932,
0.4954470098018646,
0.38431406021118164,
0.03955511748790741,
-0.42846888303756714,
-0.4000961482524872,
0.24316997826099396,
-0.47720226645469666,
-0.704164445400238,
0.6080446839332581,
0.6163289546966553,
0.6337624788284302,
0.9857363700866699,
0.09035282582044601,
1.0091378688812256,
-0.36147353053092957,
0.7216042280197144,
0.17764565348625183,
-0.722004234790802,
0.15328016877174377,
-0.7575918436050415,
-0.22699928283691406,
0.3625355064868927,
0.009857255965471268,
-0.45323318243026733,
-0.6787499189376831,
-0.35394036769866943,
-0.9858778119087219,
0.8875012993812561,
0.1691739708185196,
-0.07555229961872101,
0.2547720968723297,
-0.2644733488559723,
0.3322180211544037,
0.42801573872566223,
-0.6358016133308411,
-0.18304628133773804,
0.0029733849223703146,
-0.41257360577583313,
-0.412130206823349,
-0.19377900660037994,
-0.2161007970571518,
0.006134680472314358,
0.8463870286941528,
-0.08901422470808029,
0.37382641434669495,
-0.10585759580135345,
-0.14963853359222412,
-0.3705873191356659,
0.1929452270269394,
0.6167347431182861,
0.7369003891944885,
-0.24518311023712158,
-0.14754590392112732,
0.15499098598957062,
-0.3862260580062866,
-0.0469568595290184,
0.050091587007045746,
-0.20482316613197327,
-0.17921265959739685,
0.16436278820037842,
1.1239888668060303,
0.7102250456809998,
-0.4959903061389923,
0.2165481448173523,
0.33868396282196045,
-0.4353851079940796,
-0.4308475852012634,
0.29870307445526123,
0.1045147180557251,
0.2588881254196167,
0.725406289100647,
0.358429878950119,
0.07881473749876022,
-0.47984832525253296,
0.2712689936161041,
0.34746935963630676,
-0.19195926189422607,
-0.4098318815231323,
0.9016156792640686,
0.3955020308494568,
-0.23343579471111298,
0.14715935289859772,
-0.10441035032272339,
-0.35371944308280945,
0.46666786074638367,
0.2825538218021393,
1.0230778455734253,
-0.2983873784542084,
0.11805900931358337,
0.028973285108804703,
0.12701156735420227,
-0.3141212463378906,
0.27689746022224426,
-0.25796929001808167,
-0.6252155303955078,
-0.3929751515388489,
-0.6939867734909058,
-0.5202727913856506,
0.11914091557264328,
-0.505498468875885,
0.2086108773946762,
-0.5432826280593872,
-0.3417421579360962,
-0.06749045848846436,
-0.09243851900100708,
-0.47588875889778137,
0.115732841193676,
0.24558235704898834,
0.7537667155265808,
-0.9728604555130005,
0.722633957862854,
0.5897841453552246,
-0.029412802308797836,
-0.4187566637992859,
0.22629934549331665,
0.08378024399280548,
-0.804529070854187,
0.22097522020339966,
-0.03426831215620041,
-0.05967172235250473,
0.12839174270629883,
-0.3424146771430969,
-0.9870709180831909,
0.9039490818977356,
0.23286807537078857,
-0.6154223680496216,
0.07088447362184525,
-0.1511492282152176,
0.3354760408401489,
-0.3599843978881836,
0.4942432940006256,
0.23402011394500732,
0.5645057559013367,
0.3456486165523529,
-1.0513535737991333,
-0.4159410893917084,
-0.5071108341217041,
-0.24414660036563873,
0.3388608694076538,
-0.5888581871986389,
0.8725938200950623,
0.03616383299231529,
-0.1849099099636078,
0.09319117665290833,
0.8085383176803589,
0.1099587082862854,
0.5762059092521667,
0.5676945447921753,
0.5480126142501831,
0.8146923780441284,
-0.24295106530189514,
0.9829249382019043,
-0.29306483268737793,
0.30568382143974304,
0.9651303291320801,
-0.42569518089294434,
1.126161813735962,
0.5576574206352234,
-0.6583472490310669,
0.2528896629810333,
1.0270097255706787,
0.06739290058612823,
0.7949456572532654,
-0.14233504235744476,
-0.5148681998252869,
-0.6446685194969177,
0.3904510736465454,
-0.2841745615005493,
0.04002467170357704,
0.20152638852596283,
0.12506847083568573,
-0.14518120884895325,
0.11127559095621109,
-0.32011160254478455,
-0.13928915560245514,
-0.5746693015098572,
0.6794756054878235,
0.2782604396343231,
-0.6851763129234314,
0.12110483646392822,
0.1820029318332672,
1.0888910293579102,
-0.7966925501823425,
0.37015432119369507,
-0.15474621951580048,
0.056277405470609665,
-0.23246219754219055,
-0.7063742876052856,
-0.06319373100996017,
-0.10596809536218643,
-0.22653083503246307,
-0.19600290060043335,
0.8150919675827026,
-0.7801783084869385,
-0.7397842407226562,
0.31626296043395996,
0.4118591248989105,
0.04049878194928169,
-0.13523930311203003,
-0.29902955889701843,
-0.6591214537620544,
0.07317747175693512,
-0.23599469661712646,
0.48417407274246216,
0.0366801917552948,
-0.21059691905975342,
1.0742919445037842,
1.0776159763336182,
0.37702372670173645,
0.4707317054271698,
0.007337276823818684,
0.6067916750907898,
-0.4777756929397583,
-1.1861586570739746,
-0.7023904919624329,
0.49204984307289124,
0.053137149661779404,
0.08648499101400375,
0.5280532836914062,
0.1820351928472519,
0.8563340306282043,
-0.2889974117279053,
0.9009818434715271,
0.24586598575115204,
0.2503087520599365,
-0.7136869430541992,
0.9523282647132874,
-0.7337886095046997,
0.10203632712364197,
0.02918609417974949,
-1.0063934326171875,
0.04198674485087395,
0.3438965380191803,
-0.4095011353492737,
0.4123876392841339,
0.4097451865673065,
0.8319450616836548,
-0.22574202716350555,
0.36012938618659973,
0.5469885468482971,
0.11420115828514099,
0.1965218186378479,
0.5426563620567322,
0.6452473402023315,
-0.0578831247985363,
0.47337156534194946,
-0.2889193892478943,
-0.12860575318336487,
-0.6757235527038574,
-0.825063943862915,
-0.8579239845275879,
-0.41828271746635437,
-0.27514225244522095,
0.36005041003227234,
-0.15042512118816376,
1.0888923406600952,
0.9340851902961731,
-1.132568597793579,
-0.2508185803890228,
0.074361652135849,
-0.01407866645604372,
-0.4172286093235016,
-0.17096121609210968,
-0.16917140781879425,
-0.1254880279302597,
-0.8684531450271606,
0.772306501865387,
0.41452643275260925,
-0.1271650344133377,
-0.40205681324005127,
-0.21829701960086823,
-0.15525764226913452,
0.15215060114860535,
0.37837639451026917,
-0.0473453551530838,
-0.7424134612083435,
-0.08990823477506638,
-0.1899256706237793,
0.11926759779453278,
0.12589724361896515,
0.5818535685539246,
-0.2395382970571518,
0.6426528096199036,
0.748278796672821,
0.6610488295555115,
0.5794613361358643,
-0.028533942997455597,
0.6875792741775513,
-0.6398424506187439,
0.17480163276195526,
0.20146538317203522,
0.6249068379402161,
0.12033622711896896,
-0.2705681622028351,
0.19459344446659088,
0.387967050075531,
-0.5113117098808289,
-0.7636597156524658,
-0.05996008217334747,
-0.9718964695930481,
0.0044267503544688225,
1.1126400232315063,
-0.16639623045921326,
-0.07205494493246078,
-0.16609902679920197,
0.009507719427347183,
0.0757770761847496,
-0.7506548762321472,
0.8419312834739685,
1.1481189727783203,
0.11313905566930771,
-0.20986947417259216,
-0.7494978904724121,
0.04051090031862259,
0.22768071293830872,
-0.4589396119117737,
-0.40204766392707825,
0.3498070538043976,
0.38089442253112793,
-0.16658930480480194,
0.5911332368850708,
0.36967259645462036,
0.12675218284130096,
-0.11021363735198975,
-0.06209253892302513,
-0.5137066841125488,
-0.15004953742027283,
-0.2019045650959015,
0.18925006687641144,
-0.176044300198555,
-0.235213965177536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02962v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02962v1
|
Docs2KG: Unified Knowledge Graph Construction from Heterogeneous Documents Assisted by Large Language Models
| 2024-06-05T05:35:59 | 2024-06-05T05:35:59 |
Qiang Sun, Yuanyi Luo, Wenxiao Zhang, Sirui Li, Jichunyang Li, Kai Niu, Xiangrui Kong, Wei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Even for a conservative estimate, 80% of enterprise data reside in
unstructured files, stored in data lakes that accommodate heterogeneous
formats. Classical search engines can no longer meet information seeking needs,
especially when the task is to browse and explore for insight formulation. In
other words, there are no obvious search keywords to use. Knowledge graphs, due
to their natural visual appeals that reduce the human cognitive load, become
the winning candidate for heterogeneous data integration and knowledge
representation.
In this paper, we introduce Docs2KG, a novel framework designed to extract
multimodal information from diverse and heterogeneous unstructured documents,
including emails, web pages, PDF files, and Excel files. Dynamically generates
a unified knowledge graph that represents the extracted key information,
Docs2KG enables efficient querying and exploration of document data lakes.
Unlike existing approaches that focus on domain-specific data sources or
pre-designed schemas, Docs2KG offers a flexible and extensible solution that
can adapt to various document structures and content types. The proposed
framework unifies data processing supporting a multitude of downstream tasks
with improved domain interpretability. Docs2KG is publicly accessible at
https://docs2kg.ai4wa.com, and a demonstration video is available at
https://docs2kg.ai4wa.com/Video.
|
[
-0.22842943668365479,
-0.7384384870529175,
0.635515034198761,
-0.031183812767267227,
-0.11730644106864929,
0.1782991886138916,
-0.08929143846035004,
-0.39242783188819885,
-0.013755724765360355,
0.4869857728481293,
-0.4486354887485504,
-0.8045068979263306,
-0.6126133799552917,
-0.14086738228797913,
-0.10985666513442993,
0.5545815229415894,
0.012330923229455948,
-0.1536155790090561,
-0.5545235872268677,
-0.04108697548508644,
-0.21106505393981934,
0.13137464225292206,
-0.20556938648223877,
-0.47876742482185364,
0.21631839871406555,
0.6586840748786926,
0.6205244660377502,
0.6775071024894714,
0.18729114532470703,
0.2895644009113312,
0.3799852132797241,
0.3512021005153656,
-0.4872444272041321,
0.3155316412448883,
-0.22145459055900574,
-0.4512674808502197,
-0.1948053538799286,
0.14185018837451935,
0.58556067943573,
0.6823280453681946,
-0.13776548206806183,
-0.12732772529125214,
0.05695834010839462,
0.5623247623443604,
-0.32950377464294434,
0.7324060797691345,
-0.5288949608802795,
0.19607152044773102,
-0.4131954312324524,
-0.24192066490650177,
-0.2757549583911896,
-0.1187189593911171,
0.11732903122901917,
-1.113234043121338,
0.10373657196760178,
0.10767251253128052,
0.7137779593467712,
0.20826572179794312,
-0.8300994038581848,
-0.4159657955169678,
-0.505699872970581,
0.5101105570793152,
-0.5079845190048218,
0.6833655834197998,
0.45917215943336487,
0.5106134414672852,
-0.3028402328491211,
-1.3483531475067139,
-0.6531397104263306,
0.3422826826572418,
-0.25499024987220764,
0.3858951926231384,
-0.1390421986579895,
-0.03375370055437088,
0.0770537406206131,
0.14051660895347595,
-0.6322987079620361,
0.17286577820777893,
-0.40827810764312744,
-0.2987005114555359,
0.42620527744293213,
0.19036470353603363,
0.2788856327533722,
-0.2754572331905365,
-0.4366972744464874,
-0.060188859701156616,
-0.47336718440055847,
0.06592991203069687,
0.5496717095375061,
0.22527343034744263,
0.10599867254495621,
0.6361992359161377,
-0.24290290474891663,
0.512322723865509,
-0.07633025199174881,
-0.22542963922023773,
0.21827198565006256,
-0.1922840178012848,
0.010305458679795265,
-0.029223183169960976,
0.6876417994499207,
0.5724714994430542,
-0.2223130464553833,
-0.5129415988922119,
-0.0276168305426836,
-0.07567062973976135,
0.37843403220176697,
-0.6667046546936035,
-0.31999748945236206,
0.1851627230644226,
-0.5703455209732056,
-0.3007652461528778,
0.10615366697311401,
-1.0892672538757324,
-0.506910502910614,
-0.5220308303833008,
-0.17767837643623352,
-0.5431533455848694,
-0.2809491455554962,
-0.2164975255727768,
-0.4354272782802582,
0.04854099825024605,
0.5950043201446533,
-0.6291073560714722,
0.0999070405960083,
0.5106549859046936,
0.7320879101753235,
-0.0301364678889513,
-0.19967888295650482,
-0.4019336700439453,
0.760086178779602,
-0.12256722152233124,
0.962992787361145,
-0.6897665858268738,
-0.4755662977695465,
0.06969869881868362,
0.03616510331630707,
-0.05895492807030678,
-0.18101811408996582,
0.5204370021820068,
-0.5996109247207642,
0.4257976710796356,
-0.29201412200927734,
-0.8219282627105713,
-0.3039233982563019,
0.44674810767173767,
-0.6788765788078308,
1.1799250841140747,
0.51389080286026,
-0.8635809421539307,
0.28898346424102783,
-1.0240517854690552,
-0.38334619998931885,
0.5124713182449341,
-0.6033037304878235,
0.003989746794104576,
-0.24287739396095276,
-0.14718417823314667,
0.35617297887802124,
-0.5456802248954773,
-0.0035907665733247995,
-0.41372233629226685,
0.08898536115884781,
-0.44280001521110535,
0.22894355654716492,
0.5837525725364685,
0.5496487617492676,
-0.11363761126995087,
-0.3565344214439392,
-0.6483714580535889,
0.2585909366607666,
0.2966773808002472,
-0.6923240423202515,
-0.5294516682624817,
0.004389062058180571,
0.2874886393547058,
0.27004045248031616,
0.301078736782074,
-0.5269651412963867,
0.49063974618911743,
-0.006078534293919802,
0.2932180166244507,
0.6021925210952759,
-0.2468888908624649,
0.5087171792984009,
0.11575242877006531,
0.44018715620040894,
-0.03738877549767494,
0.05581327900290489,
-0.017253415659070015,
-0.5598410964012146,
-0.09161478281021118,
-0.19921475648880005,
0.08836828917264938,
0.41818007826805115,
-0.7663779258728027,
0.14615803956985474,
-0.47357892990112305,
-0.4775964319705963,
-0.24599847197532654,
0.45569807291030884,
0.026955198496580124,
0.8337796330451965,
0.1275431215763092,
-0.15913522243499756,
-0.46766233444213867,
-0.8153125643730164,
-0.09488622844219208,
-0.04865901172161102,
-0.17136621475219727,
0.5597310066223145,
0.1681748777627945,
-0.694734513759613,
1.173821210861206,
-0.7274208068847656,
-0.4700988233089447,
-0.030146434903144836,
0.562280535697937,
-0.1679176241159439,
0.17754387855529785,
0.5855542421340942,
-1.2318823337554932,
-0.6072239279747009,
0.4403648376464844,
-1.09420907497406,
-0.16312763094902039,
0.26854854822158813,
-0.08639620244503021,
0.1981355994939804,
0.7183298468589783,
-0.5045779943466187,
0.03002178855240345,
0.32054221630096436,
-0.5671135783195496,
0.5062175989151001,
-0.34845244884490967,
-0.03813393414020538,
-1.1575648784637451,
0.2910584807395935,
-0.09064170718193054,
-0.13044168055057526,
-0.5355057120323181,
-0.005083469673991203,
0.2660848796367645,
-0.35432708263397217,
0.0660276710987091,
0.6483952403068542,
-0.6359493732452393,
-0.23004484176635742,
0.003193995449692011,
0.23221729695796967,
0.228485107421875,
0.2992430329322815,
-0.1568170189857483,
0.33842554688453674,
0.4731071889400482,
-0.22018784284591675,
0.6767716407775879,
0.520460307598114,
-0.1603647619485855,
0.6580321788787842,
-0.21844767034053802,
0.2112981081008911,
-0.14927197992801666,
0.36677464842796326,
-0.9198516011238098,
-0.5245935320854187,
0.007799084763973951,
-0.2901320159435272,
0.501663863658905,
-0.3363814651966095,
-0.776814341545105,
-0.4826793670654297,
-0.3538110554218292,
-0.055845052003860474,
0.20004704594612122,
-0.5209665298461914,
1.0796823501586914,
0.5342770218849182,
-0.26814720034599304,
-0.4063693881034851,
-0.48985323309898376,
0.282985121011734,
0.027661582455039024,
-1.0726218223571777,
0.323051393032074,
0.061272576451301575,
-0.1718420535326004,
0.40702691674232483,
-0.26075953245162964,
-0.17375724017620087,
-0.10374446958303452,
0.4954966604709625,
0.20808951556682587,
-0.08830270171165466,
0.28151464462280273,
0.1760505884885788,
-0.04519122093915939,
-0.1991778314113617,
-0.6526550650596619,
0.48420217633247375,
0.036494094878435135,
-0.36780864000320435,
0.04807484522461891,
0.6155375242233276,
0.8834649920463562,
-0.2208155393600464,
0.35359153151512146,
0.9820358753204346,
-0.4175897240638733,
-0.14639827609062195,
-0.43296605348587036,
0.02837504632771015,
-0.47586482763290405,
0.34228360652923584,
-0.4161854684352875,
-0.6846631169319153,
0.4070722162723541,
-0.5917790532112122,
0.12730853259563446,
0.5802598595619202,
0.39328718185424805,
-0.34508565068244934,
0.8762144446372986,
0.8278326988220215,
0.09551626443862915,
0.29218873381614685,
-0.34870627522468567,
0.4130415618419647,
-0.6122011542320251,
-0.8525901436805725,
-0.5814805626869202,
-0.19923467934131622,
-0.4188270568847656,
-0.2481231689453125,
0.4290686249732971,
0.1952308714389801,
0.22884908318519592,
-0.03187797591090202,
-0.38222452998161316,
0.3209410309791565,
0.39035242795944214,
-0.29626840353012085,
0.2304248809814453,
0.21172159910202026,
-0.5281525254249573,
0.10245245695114136,
-0.7386659979820251,
-0.5150991082191467,
1.1961956024169922,
0.11413532495498657,
0.77473384141922,
0.11942213028669357,
0.3061305284500122,
0.6383533477783203,
0.06745730340480804,
-0.6201914548873901,
0.21236999332904816,
-0.3185993731021881,
-0.4676128625869751,
-0.4104713201522827,
-0.4556228220462799,
-0.9715132713317871,
0.08970987051725388,
-0.24074377119541168,
-0.8923133015632629,
0.02923894114792347,
-0.08731431514024734,
0.08933308720588684,
0.3520877957344055,
-0.9249529838562012,
0.8521654605865479,
-0.12637701630592346,
-0.33526480197906494,
-0.1484602391719818,
-0.7121827006340027,
0.24979712069034576,
-0.12366878241300583,
0.45339712500572205,
0.10437531769275665,
0.06307487189769745,
0.8068379759788513,
-0.45645415782928467,
0.386322945356369,
-0.3707432448863983,
-0.09732929617166519,
0.17007838189601898,
0.02626020833849907,
0.7680577039718628,
0.015255788341164589,
-0.036414410918951035,
0.10631652921438217,
0.08826708793640137,
-0.46613800525665283,
-0.7443388104438782,
0.807011067867279,
-0.7918026447296143,
-0.18055137991905212,
-0.09917070716619492,
-0.9393129348754883,
-0.4093707501888275,
0.6090419292449951,
0.2425578534603119,
0.46328315138816833,
-0.04895823821425438,
0.33252567052841187,
0.4301345944404602,
0.030672777444124222,
0.13599078357219696,
0.5819679498672485,
-0.06024511903524399,
-0.10304003953933716,
0.8018924593925476,
0.31089717149734497,
-0.06898362189531326,
0.2425851970911026,
0.056544527411460876,
-0.8115206360816956,
-0.4379899501800537,
-0.3133428394794464,
0.14599598944187164,
-0.9337029457092285,
-0.07211270183324814,
-1.0094574689865112,
0.09947150945663452,
-0.8442211151123047,
-0.25516584515571594,
-0.1880193054676056,
-0.41908371448516846,
-0.0524880476295948,
-0.0682840421795845,
0.21633760631084442,
0.9876753687858582,
-0.21803012490272522,
0.026851868256926537,
-0.7695755958557129,
0.2684279680252075,
0.5828633308410645,
0.6180059909820557,
-0.26993218064308167,
0.10028362274169922,
-0.29144755005836487,
-0.09012217074632645,
-0.22425778210163116,
-0.7138420343399048,
0.03734090179204941,
0.07796519994735718,
0.7854692339897156,
0.703059196472168,
-0.0053133005276322365,
0.1960238367319107,
-0.12633052468299866,
0.6480607390403748,
0.3640383780002594,
-0.32957372069358826,
0.36164069175720215,
-0.6035965085029602,
0.10417109727859497,
0.44105857610702515,
0.4645334482192993,
-0.6907913088798523,
-0.052901528775691986,
-0.5123794674873352,
-1.035254716873169,
0.9940738081932068,
0.04222368821501732,
-0.258325457572937,
0.39590808749198914,
0.2912096083164215,
0.2563319802284241,
0.0619012750685215,
-0.1903422325849533,
-0.2074231058359146,
-0.6319301128387451,
-0.290932834148407,
0.11803528666496277,
-0.26046597957611084,
-0.4538284242153168,
-0.030409198254346848,
0.5664380192756653,
-0.4979504942893982,
0.2383180856704712,
-0.07050952315330505,
-0.22386735677719116,
-0.11011185497045517,
0.007183943875133991,
0.06775796413421631,
0.4154508411884308,
-0.4745347797870636,
0.46882811188697815,
-0.3445580303668976,
-0.7639615535736084,
-0.18478238582611084,
0.5614887475967407,
-0.09871792048215866,
-0.023913277313113213,
0.2967781722545624,
0.42171812057495117,
-0.13231225311756134,
-0.6567845940589905,
0.31718680262565613,
-0.24975883960723877,
-0.27597329020500183,
0.04072610288858414,
-0.06650939583778381,
0.3037702143192291,
0.3593337833881378,
0.45318612456321716,
-0.2801090180873871,
0.07450303435325623,
-0.7120435237884521,
0.16301944851875305,
0.36481401324272156,
-0.236509308218956,
-0.1305309385061264,
0.5884815454483032,
0.22133958339691162,
-0.036298226565122604,
0.6454774141311646,
-0.3323061764240265,
-0.4813707768917084,
0.37161269783973694,
0.4627205729484558,
0.43816182017326355,
-0.026760950684547424,
0.2338748276233673,
0.10319758951663971,
0.1440487653017044,
0.09942413866519928,
0.1515726000070572,
-0.3050462603569031,
-0.7017399072647095,
0.09423418343067169,
-0.5600219368934631,
-0.226933091878891,
0.1783919781446457,
-0.2855154275894165,
0.010966641828417778,
-0.3230799436569214,
0.19258520007133484,
0.31471753120422363,
0.291073203086853,
-0.7320188879966736,
0.23531846702098846,
0.07385453581809998,
0.9065504670143127,
-0.7044803500175476,
0.8972664475440979,
0.9589698314666748,
-0.389606237411499,
-0.7982167601585388,
-0.3244829475879669,
0.42104464769363403,
-0.7082776427268982,
0.4881003797054291,
-0.05243184417486191,
0.07805880159139633,
0.015091153793036938,
-0.4010390043258667,
-0.5823315382003784,
1.5677984952926636,
0.298315167427063,
-0.29765036702156067,
-0.1895618438720703,
0.5239760875701904,
0.23863330483436584,
-0.3041890263557434,
0.05745363235473633,
0.41032132506370544,
1.0245121717453003,
0.25664931535720825,
-0.4257136285305023,
0.020790807902812958,
-0.7406316995620728,
-0.1066000834107399,
0.021817099303007126,
-0.33702540397644043,
0.8035082817077637,
0.13583965599536896,
-0.144871324300766,
-0.4685051739215851,
0.09186048805713654,
-0.19695191085338593,
0.5064923763275146,
0.44331657886505127,
0.8797124028205872,
1.1489286422729492,
-0.12848463654518127,
1.0781959295272827,
-0.32201436161994934,
0.3310142457485199,
1.1399863958358765,
-0.36342212557792664,
0.03290149196982384,
0.4810110330581665,
-0.01931297406554222,
0.4316087067127228,
0.41743040084838867,
-0.15727351605892181,
0.6340007185935974,
-0.34308919310569763,
-0.22045288980007172,
-0.08435779809951782,
-0.2510971426963806,
-0.4307936429977417,
0.5562776923179626,
0.3587377369403839,
-0.17363341152668,
-0.7626301050186157,
-0.16927233338356018,
0.14119642972946167,
0.01029213983565569,
0.013358993455767632,
0.6854009032249451,
-0.12874376773834229,
-0.34207192063331604,
0.09636170417070389,
0.2552853524684906,
0.34426337480545044,
-1.0156065225601196,
0.04322945326566696,
-0.27041715383529663,
-0.07140173017978668,
-0.47666195034980774,
-0.9885185360908508,
0.1870419681072235,
-0.0557284913957119,
-0.29561227560043335,
-0.29754143953323364,
1.120711326599121,
-0.3789967894554138,
-0.08899273723363876,
0.4744585454463959,
0.5161061882972717,
-0.04612596705555916,
-0.13435955345630646,
-0.5258638858795166,
-0.37076523900032043,
0.005029992200434208,
-0.3821064531803131,
0.41531017422676086,
0.9116598963737488,
-0.018233604729175568,
0.4799330234527588,
0.9370512962341309,
-0.17676158249378204,
0.07704684138298035,
-0.10893873870372772,
0.9494938254356384,
-0.26497313380241394,
-0.7651187777519226,
-0.16758845746517181,
0.46314242482185364,
-0.368037611246109,
0.01470730360597372,
0.7899967432022095,
0.9609828591346741,
0.6100428700447083,
0.15805286169052124,
1.2561492919921875,
-0.5048370957374573,
0.15230250358581543,
-0.3699161410331726,
1.0075840950012207,
-0.7743453979492188,
-0.0821511298418045,
-0.1741315871477127,
-0.7480652332305908,
-0.08879320323467255,
0.13670191168785095,
-0.15445953607559204,
-0.39585909247398376,
0.5820956230163574,
0.8119893670082092,
-0.4455573260784149,
0.21891631186008453,
0.2606017291545868,
0.310834676027298,
0.5675496459007263,
0.14850319921970367,
0.3894685208797455,
-0.06596347689628601,
0.6645632982254028,
0.06539286673069,
-0.17691504955291748,
-0.41011521220207214,
-0.6789369583129883,
-0.5372827053070068,
-0.9002052545547485,
0.05057438090443611,
-0.2558310329914093,
-0.27560317516326904,
0.6425710320472717,
0.7467151880264282,
-0.3464891314506531,
0.20142342150211334,
0.044940125197172165,
0.236422598361969,
0.27804502844810486,
-0.24278400838375092,
0.5238340497016907,
-0.3473658561706543,
-0.4139823913574219,
0.4362064599990845,
0.5267586708068848,
0.03513612970709801,
0.024093886837363243,
-0.4461674392223358,
-0.3325413167476654,
-0.05988410487771034,
0.48931631445884705,
0.35633012652397156,
-0.1652647703886032,
0.035357244312763214,
-0.23477330803871155,
-0.25021347403526306,
0.06905899196863174,
0.796198844909668,
-0.5029960870742798,
0.8297048211097717,
0.38498908281326294,
0.6223226189613342,
0.8153312802314758,
-0.21865400671958923,
0.33878034353256226,
-0.7414423823356628,
0.14044927060604095,
-0.029994221404194832,
0.4349115192890167,
0.3099658787250519,
-0.5053876638412476,
0.7477464079856873,
0.6462550759315491,
-0.10556494444608688,
-0.5725853443145752,
0.1711128205060959,
-1.2298147678375244,
-0.614098310470581,
1.12551748752594,
-0.16234518587589264,
-0.0733962133526802,
-0.42988815903663635,
-0.16665850579738617,
0.5023947358131409,
-0.5301011800765991,
0.8474928140640259,
0.621597409248352,
-0.11320917308330536,
0.19333356618881226,
-0.5427290201187134,
0.32809287309646606,
-0.04041486978530884,
-1.1330246925354004,
0.0046914429403841496,
0.7454717755317688,
0.4428880214691162,
0.28974518179893494,
0.6400249600410461,
-0.3729470372200012,
0.12686990201473236,
0.24286919832229614,
0.1384698450565338,
-0.6610286235809326,
-0.1798945814371109,
0.15181414783000946,
0.5123630166053772,
-0.29350975155830383,
0.15400810539722443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02959v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02959v1
|
Adversarial Moment-Matching Distillation of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-05T05:27:29 | 2024-06-05T05:27:29 |
Chen Jia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Knowledge distillation (KD) has been shown to be highly effective in guiding
a student model with a larger teacher model and achieving practical benefits in
improving the computational and memory efficiency for large language models
(LLMs). State-of-the-art KD methods for LLMs mostly rely on minimizing explicit
distribution distance between teacher and student probability predictions.
Instead of optimizing these mandatory behaviour cloning objectives, we explore
an imitation learning strategy for KD of LLMs. In particular, we minimize the
imitation gap by matching the action-value moments of the teacher's behavior
from both on- and off-policy perspectives. To achieve this action-value
moment-matching goal, we propose an adversarial training algorithm to jointly
estimate the moment-matching distance and optimize the student policy to
minimize it. Results from both task-agnostic instruction-following experiments
and task-specific experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our method and
achieve new state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.19664673507213593,
-0.9536924362182617,
0.667798638343811,
-0.032788753509521484,
-0.21790942549705505,
0.1812659651041031,
-0.10964792966842651,
0.12850572168827057,
0.10127583146095276,
0.14407038688659668,
-0.3367144465446472,
-0.24693521857261658,
-0.655005693435669,
-0.5171295404434204,
-0.31992968916893005,
0.641444206237793,
0.16382481157779694,
0.38784295320510864,
-0.3339313268661499,
-0.17110145092010498,
-0.15287037193775177,
-0.5150696635246277,
-0.6691633462905884,
-0.608741044998169,
0.4272077679634094,
0.2858860492706299,
0.8628008961677551,
0.7041893601417542,
-0.00519558833912015,
0.3069102168083191,
-0.4658358097076416,
0.20533102750778198,
-0.5871062278747559,
-0.05194433778524399,
-0.3256494700908661,
-0.5118066072463989,
-0.1793535351753235,
0.22808802127838135,
0.5753587484359741,
0.7140212059020996,
-0.28648531436920166,
-0.15435777604579926,
0.2357296198606491,
0.7243959307670593,
-0.8286981582641602,
0.04549630731344223,
-0.5641802549362183,
0.28890058398246765,
0.24136649072170258,
-0.03050706349313259,
-0.4082561731338501,
-0.6186512112617493,
0.19870854914188385,
-0.5037005543708801,
0.24088354408740997,
-0.23094260692596436,
0.6565907001495361,
0.05293809995055199,
-0.4819657504558563,
-0.4386032521724701,
-0.7507914900779724,
0.6410197615623474,
-0.564426600933075,
0.2095232754945755,
0.23723842203617096,
0.3838970959186554,
-0.49280136823654175,
-0.3608516454696655,
-0.9887757301330566,
0.07967381924390793,
0.0014686237554997206,
0.06904348731040955,
-0.17924150824546814,
0.045364487916231155,
0.15634585916996002,
0.27471718192100525,
-0.30369633436203003,
0.14582231640815735,
-0.3097376525402069,
0.20045605301856995,
0.30668118596076965,
-0.004989775829017162,
0.16774927079677582,
0.04903654754161835,
-0.3872566819190979,
-0.60059654712677,
-0.7084925770759583,
-0.008782765828073025,
0.5170114636421204,
0.3113422989845276,
0.32331496477127075,
0.43833282589912415,
-0.04853358119726181,
0.43030184507369995,
0.20325779914855957,
-0.2682986557483673,
0.08511537313461304,
-0.12562276422977448,
-0.14662522077560425,
0.12990064918994904,
0.7044836282730103,
0.43216022849082947,
0.2367788553237915,
-0.2175694853067398,
-0.016087917611002922,
0.10858847200870514,
0.15048855543136597,
-0.72002112865448,
-0.5347906351089478,
-0.3524383306503296,
-0.10367954522371292,
-0.6380633115768433,
-0.22278083860874176,
-1.0389877557754517,
-0.4751194417476654,
-0.6158837676048279,
0.9624314308166504,
-0.3899973928928375,
-0.3537261486053467,
-0.12164311110973358,
-0.23235882818698883,
0.04975900799036026,
0.1051100492477417,
-0.8519973754882812,
0.24719266593456268,
0.5915895700454712,
0.850188672542572,
-0.1772465854883194,
-0.6194950938224792,
-0.41678640246391296,
0.03672129288315773,
-0.4516141414642334,
0.24091343581676483,
-0.40749040246009827,
-0.6086268424987793,
-0.13334403932094574,
-0.16906757652759552,
-0.07647708803415298,
-0.7170606851577759,
0.06100108101963997,
-0.7353273630142212,
-0.019549312070012093,
-0.4727039635181427,
-0.8104681372642517,
-0.38761675357818604,
0.35891643166542053,
-0.5983638167381287,
0.9570654630661011,
0.3340292274951935,
-0.43320122361183167,
0.38833746314048767,
-0.6450938582420349,
-0.5416839718818665,
-0.37882256507873535,
-0.04430228844285011,
-0.5441772937774658,
0.08180540055036545,
0.3222872316837311,
0.5763397812843323,
0.05358941853046417,
0.01937742717564106,
-0.6732131838798523,
-0.3053452968597412,
0.30410072207450867,
-0.927803635597229,
0.8640835881233215,
0.13943685591220856,
-0.32131853699684143,
-0.10458097606897354,
-0.579409658908844,
-0.11184777319431305,
0.3241931200027466,
-0.18623606860637665,
-0.8156424164772034,
-0.0633714497089386,
-0.4231187403202057,
0.12866243720054626,
0.08604446798563004,
-0.10418267548084259,
0.42963582277297974,
-0.3382442593574524,
0.3935966491699219,
0.9509238004684448,
0.08255784213542938,
0.8012517094612122,
-0.39604422450065613,
0.48939815163612366,
0.2110825777053833,
0.12471986562013626,
0.023463265970349312,
0.16377773880958557,
-0.44466859102249146,
-0.4247265160083771,
0.16164177656173706,
0.40257635712623596,
-0.9511138796806335,
0.1148836687207222,
-0.3177041709423065,
-0.5753431916236877,
-0.6353217363357544,
0.2201346904039383,
0.4981318712234497,
0.41522493958473206,
0.35179010033607483,
0.17343652248382568,
-0.3828031122684479,
-0.49696260690689087,
-0.2488018423318863,
-0.15855175256729126,
0.1651424616575241,
0.388027161359787,
0.3197034001350403,
0.09172812104225159,
0.9381403923034668,
-0.7739721536636353,
-0.23630791902542114,
-0.23368176817893982,
-0.09954696148633957,
0.08312644064426422,
0.33926644921302795,
0.8615241050720215,
-0.8779244422912598,
-0.9203007817268372,
-0.1408928781747818,
-0.5812932252883911,
0.006882368586957455,
0.05713871121406555,
-0.27396804094314575,
0.1947920024394989,
0.6314365863800049,
-0.4072619080543518,
0.349318265914917,
0.6193440556526184,
-0.36111828684806824,
0.5210672616958618,
-0.43462231755256653,
0.5435360074043274,
-1.3996773958206177,
-0.07980674505233765,
-0.20160271227359772,
-0.3303598463535309,
-0.5484844446182251,
0.10749849677085876,
0.013412108644843102,
-0.054056111723184586,
-0.6603551506996155,
0.5209184885025024,
-0.37428659200668335,
-0.06991802901029587,
-0.4914689362049103,
0.37319400906562805,
0.0011903955601155758,
0.5348415374755859,
-0.24716877937316895,
0.8104154467582703,
0.6911671161651611,
-0.8396661877632141,
0.5931685566902161,
-0.030371803790330887,
-0.36711403727531433,
0.9676158428192139,
-0.33580294251441956,
-0.07606292515993118,
-0.046056438237428665,
0.07227162271738052,
-0.8698458671569824,
0.06829112023115158,
0.05122477188706398,
-0.3628721833229065,
0.23519250750541687,
-0.4108828902244568,
-0.3738836944103241,
-0.2603030800819397,
-0.2514665722846985,
0.4307469129562378,
0.9400814175605774,
-1.1972204446792603,
0.7984394431114197,
0.22426995635032654,
0.001232035574503243,
-0.6259744763374329,
-0.28996962308883667,
-0.2203400731086731,
-0.4418564438819885,
-0.1266900599002838,
0.19219662249088287,
-0.030262824147939682,
-0.1528163105249405,
0.13126477599143982,
-0.010120444931089878,
-0.10266226530075073,
0.3228190541267395,
0.08737152814865112,
0.244871586561203,
-0.0326915867626667,
-0.12325040996074677,
0.19350287318229675,
0.27190694212913513,
-0.09442152827978134,
-0.07499692589044571,
0.5377945303916931,
0.33966895937919617,
-0.566085696220398,
-0.4257645905017853,
0.1064964011311531,
0.9578179121017456,
0.41378262639045715,
0.847923994064331,
0.40437769889831543,
-0.17042814195156097,
-0.5575420260429382,
-0.3081386983394623,
-0.28723397850990295,
-0.538670539855957,
0.5714990496635437,
-0.4448177218437195,
-0.42599111795425415,
0.21454134583473206,
-0.31488126516342163,
-0.02842017449438572,
-0.0855889767408371,
0.2254798859357834,
-0.08714501559734344,
0.9189560413360596,
0.33043372631073,
-0.6667180061340332,
0.6128149032592773,
-0.3351368010044098,
0.028274813666939735,
-0.6803274154663086,
0.04064411669969559,
-0.2789061963558197,
-0.5080541372299194,
0.01662713848054409,
-0.5258947014808655,
0.45025554299354553,
0.5667129755020142,
-0.000888239243067801,
0.3395695090293884,
-0.2146248072385788,
0.9325583577156067,
0.702129065990448,
0.23787783086299896,
0.05254093185067177,
0.01950063742697239,
-0.26286202669143677,
-0.05378041788935661,
-0.8709620237350464,
-0.1177021712064743,
1.1244736909866333,
-0.044728755950927734,
0.7465476989746094,
0.3307253420352936,
0.6945072412490845,
0.2022363245487213,
0.04842570424079895,
-0.7099459767341614,
0.7770366072654724,
-0.3061434030532837,
-0.05519718676805496,
-0.4688839912414551,
-0.7535516619682312,
-0.8834752440452576,
0.6079894304275513,
-0.06111857667565346,
-0.3601500391960144,
-0.24226520955562592,
0.47062158584594727,
-0.1326131969690323,
0.5044729709625244,
-0.7555385231971741,
0.8547825813293457,
0.16274890303611755,
0.0011431456077843904,
-0.4003591239452362,
-0.02973010390996933,
0.2769411504268646,
0.006626543588936329,
0.18132686614990234,
0.11937222629785538,
0.3993831276893616,
0.4414854943752289,
-0.2940846383571625,
0.6922107338905334,
-0.6022660732269287,
0.026062779128551483,
0.2622513771057129,
0.366239070892334,
0.88376784324646,
-0.2602309584617615,
0.057380061596632004,
-0.2010018229484558,
0.03133160620927811,
-0.4088936448097229,
-0.8656773567199707,
0.867605984210968,
-0.750466525554657,
-0.7014011740684509,
-0.22737950086593628,
-0.4071171283721924,
-0.04413963109254837,
-0.03279097378253937,
0.01665477827191353,
0.22826863825321198,
-0.45307204127311707,
0.12120343744754791,
0.7278294563293457,
0.037009354680776596,
0.7168254256248474,
0.7938116788864136,
-0.09219741076231003,
-0.4453762173652649,
1.0012085437774658,
0.025536566972732544,
0.6966856122016907,
0.33538591861724854,
0.549221932888031,
-0.5550323724746704,
-0.21649964153766632,
-0.5032354593276978,
-0.024068046361207962,
-0.7063993811607361,
-0.06744001060724258,
-0.39097264409065247,
-0.11068864166736603,
-0.6468828320503235,
-0.5215471386909485,
-0.6324785351753235,
-0.15081070363521576,
-0.5751753449440002,
0.06903230398893356,
0.31414884328842163,
0.37371763586997986,
-0.14586901664733887,
0.23741666972637177,
-0.5461230278015137,
0.2589638829231262,
0.7403190732002258,
0.02497919276356697,
0.2673293948173523,
-0.7904943227767944,
0.047751396894454956,
0.36285194754600525,
-0.4362201988697052,
-0.7200056314468384,
0.24317419528961182,
0.41693779826164246,
0.5553842782974243,
0.5590237975120544,
0.4967159330844879,
0.9647992849349976,
-0.6040364503860474,
0.6449235677719116,
0.2625502049922943,
-0.9125311970710754,
0.3793785870075226,
0.21282055974006653,
0.4134788513183594,
0.32346412539482117,
0.44939330220222473,
-0.46361109614372253,
-0.41778627038002014,
-0.5681689977645874,
-0.6886705160140991,
0.697972297668457,
0.1362968236207962,
0.2252286970615387,
0.06880311667919159,
0.31403809785842896,
-0.2611818015575409,
-0.07039246708154678,
-0.49910998344421387,
-0.33529919385910034,
0.06151168420910835,
-0.5457186102867126,
-0.260488361120224,
0.042338546365499496,
-0.16392667591571808,
-0.04425303637981415,
0.9770740270614624,
-0.16312532126903534,
-0.10391475260257721,
-0.15270483493804932,
-0.19249628484249115,
0.14519070088863373,
0.17740635573863983,
0.5687134861946106,
0.38757845759391785,
0.37691158056259155,
0.4819066822528839,
0.5368800163269043,
-0.6336569786071777,
0.605141818523407,
-0.019893094897270203,
-0.21203768253326416,
-0.02892560139298439,
-0.16494789719581604,
0.5750921368598938,
0.2708642780780792,
-0.5999536514282227,
0.8491090536117554,
0.23129764199256897,
-0.25841036438941956,
-0.32174405455589294,
0.3878802955150604,
0.1521773785352707,
0.9292484521865845,
0.20413760840892792,
-0.11494631320238113,
-0.052582997828722,
-0.526990532875061,
0.18789634108543396,
0.5168827772140503,
-0.23294371366500854,
-0.3714820146560669,
0.4445767402648926,
-0.15571698546409607,
-0.36290544271469116,
0.3496307134628296,
-0.5395641326904297,
-0.9179820418357849,
0.6427105069160461,
0.468643456697464,
0.5761454701423645,
-0.6324623227119446,
0.3182971477508545,
0.29121947288513184,
-0.2606812119483948,
-0.6070348024368286,
0.08839170634746552,
0.02686481922864914,
-0.6950058937072754,
-0.11500542610883713,
-0.5765372514724731,
-0.2949022352695465,
0.004713672213256359,
-0.8117203712463379,
0.3689250648021698,
-0.3272957503795624,
0.13367870450019836,
0.1446215808391571,
-0.1758391410112381,
-0.2898649275302887,
-0.1428888440132141,
-0.2712171673774719,
0.33110424876213074,
-1.0441114902496338,
1.1757631301879883,
0.35662421584129333,
-0.03689045086503029,
-0.8404541015625,
-0.07821166515350342,
0.1444232165813446,
-0.7586329579353333,
0.6347830891609192,
-0.22055403888225555,
-0.03719877824187279,
0.07693669945001602,
0.019731028005480766,
-0.4828999936580658,
1.3595455884933472,
0.36901921033859253,
-0.6577215790748596,
0.08924639970064163,
0.03878198564052582,
0.3184940218925476,
0.014763327315449715,
-0.1852925717830658,
0.6587609648704529,
-0.09436853229999542,
0.6123844981193542,
-0.7803387641906738,
-0.04208686202764511,
0.3207891583442688,
0.057072319090366364,
0.5182237029075623,
-0.5636650323867798,
0.7391217947006226,
-0.26452937722206116,
-0.10798920691013336,
-0.15414437651634216,
0.5146178007125854,
0.33785581588745117,
0.32096007466316223,
0.8921098113059998,
0.7258462309837341,
0.6044019460678101,
0.13332010805606842,
0.3318850100040436,
-0.3285216689109802,
0.5028603076934814,
1.2983165979385376,
-0.293273001909256,
0.8242434859275818,
0.6326401233673096,
-0.5320612192153931,
0.011238793842494488,
0.04059309512376785,
-0.12781357765197754,
0.7991357445716858,
0.1807825267314911,
-0.553531289100647,
0.04013834148645401,
0.2882881760597229,
-0.07528113573789597,
0.2737613618373871,
0.15010760724544525,
-0.514874279499054,
-0.23101241886615753,
0.3503820598125458,
0.22798560559749603,
0.44830283522605896,
-0.3263026177883148,
0.9712486863136292,
-0.20029237866401672,
-0.6351538896560669,
0.5557317137718201,
-0.10092579573392868,
0.5422908663749695,
-0.3845859467983246,
-0.09286285191774368,
-0.28336355090141296,
0.5793910026550293,
0.48231422901153564,
-0.5142621397972107,
0.2056085169315338,
-0.21682552993297577,
-0.3009277582168579,
-0.11272955685853958,
0.2887711226940155,
-0.861434817314148,
-0.18202972412109375,
0.19976797699928284,
-0.03577211871743202,
0.08561869710683823,
-0.10473010689020157,
-0.5174493193626404,
-0.30976223945617676,
-0.08901288360357285,
-0.17743265628814697,
0.8168017268180847,
0.6985622048377991,
0.39196228981018066,
0.6193802356719971,
0.46536070108413696,
0.1960953325033188,
0.03484980762004852,
-0.08236270397901535,
0.8586528301239014,
-0.48036402463912964,
-0.6873688697814941,
-1.2521346807479858,
0.013558396138250828,
-0.08907211571931839,
-0.01809273473918438,
0.6856298446655273,
0.5025045871734619,
0.8754187822341919,
-0.11751618981361389,
0.6266628503799438,
0.06857723742723465,
0.4466879665851593,
-0.5703366994857788,
0.837000846862793,
-0.5042831897735596,
0.141001895070076,
-0.3891497850418091,
-0.9752519726753235,
0.2463473081588745,
0.6511880159378052,
0.05279019474983215,
-0.10799650102853775,
0.5038243532180786,
1.0390863418579102,
-0.3835902512073517,
-0.19666999578475952,
0.6864771246910095,
0.10018546879291534,
0.45101210474967957,
0.6694304943084717,
0.5581865310668945,
-0.3667382597923279,
0.8625450730323792,
-0.27432674169540405,
-0.25639283657073975,
-0.3252907395362854,
-0.7163904905319214,
-1.028329849243164,
-0.5334081649780273,
-0.4448821246623993,
-0.5651921629905701,
0.22459055483341217,
0.9619334936141968,
0.604560375213623,
-0.44346246123313904,
0.039939023554325104,
-0.21271157264709473,
0.1424970030784607,
-0.6172168254852295,
-0.22195667028427124,
0.5992433428764343,
-0.2138264775276184,
-0.9840704202651978,
0.47357749938964844,
-0.1668587625026703,
0.600468635559082,
-0.3967221677303314,
-0.28194621205329895,
-0.15991607308387756,
0.28913745284080505,
0.6047566533088684,
0.24813459813594818,
-0.6784913539886475,
-0.3198336660861969,
-0.1695179045200348,
-0.2844426929950714,
-0.33530759811401367,
0.6456894874572754,
-0.4978075623512268,
0.47118911147117615,
0.2580873668193817,
0.7234554886817932,
0.34731757640838623,
-0.14757870137691498,
0.449252188205719,
-0.9284039735794067,
0.14462019503116608,
0.08334553241729736,
0.07043202966451645,
0.008109310641884804,
-0.15580251812934875,
0.21286867558956146,
0.4557209610939026,
-0.4631146490573883,
-0.9057086110115051,
0.19767117500305176,
-0.5807701349258423,
-0.6939290165901184,
1.294390082359314,
-0.673453152179718,
-0.14315886795520782,
0.19828760623931885,
-0.20506487786769867,
0.3511328399181366,
-0.18582481145858765,
1.1736972332000732,
0.7090951204299927,
0.3531617820262909,
-0.022544648498296738,
-0.2215798795223236,
0.43737319111824036,
0.3301421105861664,
-0.47766605019569397,
0.16895537078380585,
0.35621869564056396,
0.4647061824798584,
-0.15409748256206512,
0.3139916956424713,
0.08833061903715134,
0.2318141907453537,
0.33207350969314575,
-0.05747155100107193,
-0.2555689811706543,
-0.39252278208732605,
-0.2808021605014801,
0.23026131093502045,
-0.021231096237897873,
-0.4816301167011261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02958v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02958v1
|
PrE-Text: Training Language Models on Private Federated Data in the Age of LLMs
| 2024-06-05T05:27:02 | 2024-06-05T05:27:02 |
Charlie Hou, Akshat Shrivastava, Hongyuan Zhan, Rylan Conway, Trang Le, Adithya Sagar, Giulia Fanti, Daniel Lazar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.DC
|
On-device training is currently the most common approach for training machine
learning (ML) models on private, distributed user data. Despite this, on-device
training has several drawbacks: (1) most user devices are too small to train
large models on-device, (2) on-device training is communication- and
computation-intensive, and (3) on-device training can be difficult to debug and
deploy. To address these problems, we propose Private Evolution-Text
(PrE-Text), a method for generating differentially private (DP) synthetic
textual data. First, we show that across multiple datasets, training small
models (models that fit on user devices) with PrE-Text synthetic data
outperforms small models trained on-device under practical privacy regimes
($\epsilon=1.29$, $\epsilon=7.58$). We achieve these results while using
9$\times$ fewer rounds, 6$\times$ less client computation per round, and
100$\times$ less communication per round. Second, finetuning large models on
PrE-Text's DP synthetic data improves large language model (LLM) performance on
private data across the same range of privacy budgets. Altogether, these
results suggest that training on DP synthetic data can be a better option than
training a model on-device on private distributed data. Code is available at
https://github.com/houcharlie/PrE-Text.
|
[
-0.07783127576112747,
-0.6128836870193481,
0.6623921990394592,
0.24394111335277557,
-0.28440120816230774,
0.36018702387809753,
-0.2763991951942444,
-0.4046768546104431,
0.06889709830284119,
0.5413137078285217,
-0.7654946446418762,
-0.5731396079063416,
-0.48340582847595215,
0.24400727450847626,
-0.4426829218864441,
1.1027114391326904,
-0.0179470032453537,
0.05387866869568825,
-0.14065639674663544,
-0.06501307338476181,
0.2406160980463028,
-0.8962988257408142,
-0.2352197766304016,
-0.10412735491991043,
0.4590630531311035,
0.1674940288066864,
0.5620534420013428,
0.8432576060295105,
0.42645758390426636,
0.3200715482234955,
0.19871886074543,
0.392574667930603,
-0.7410191297531128,
0.3021227717399597,
0.08633843809366226,
-0.4155645966529846,
-0.5332642197608948,
0.2703457176685333,
0.7355762124061584,
0.5594417452812195,
0.04990168288350105,
0.10785951465368271,
0.07231622189283371,
0.8022597432136536,
-0.5147135853767395,
0.13280844688415527,
-0.7511193156242371,
0.32320430874824524,
-0.3094376027584076,
-0.18107682466506958,
-0.5622608065605164,
-0.5530120730400085,
0.2523227632045746,
-0.7008985877037048,
0.3231477439403534,
0.05390259623527527,
0.8285201191902161,
0.29264116287231445,
-0.2458384484052658,
0.04603157564997673,
-1.0667587518692017,
0.6271947622299194,
-0.579310953617096,
0.643481969833374,
0.5830203294754028,
0.13564778864383698,
-0.14016063511371613,
-1.097139835357666,
-0.6663463711738586,
-0.25286638736724854,
-0.23192338645458221,
-0.045641377568244934,
-0.11404507607221603,
-0.038400568068027496,
0.10059195011854172,
0.5481679439544678,
-0.297681599855423,
0.3104743957519531,
-0.22111421823501587,
-0.007079545874148607,
0.9040890336036682,
0.06950637698173523,
0.04117997735738754,
0.2619122266769409,
-0.2093408703804016,
-0.0638393834233284,
-1.070267915725708,
-0.30206871032714844,
0.7646716237068176,
0.2344619631767273,
-0.27398771047592163,
0.5079874992370605,
-0.3126935064792633,
0.4773055911064148,
0.33310022950172424,
-0.07923372834920883,
0.28300294280052185,
-0.33275917172431946,
-0.3620390295982361,
0.1220918521285057,
1.0469132661819458,
-0.13297094404697418,
0.10013922303915024,
-0.40824809670448303,
-0.2873256802558899,
-0.21473336219787598,
0.1860424280166626,
-0.993929922580719,
-0.4359322786331177,
0.1689750701189041,
-0.28859373927116394,
-0.5747588872909546,
-0.13230282068252563,
-0.892966628074646,
-0.6169699430465698,
-0.4191228151321411,
0.3670257031917572,
-0.00416515814140439,
-0.05074305087327957,
0.1176583543419838,
0.25099003314971924,
-0.18272726237773895,
0.09110046178102493,
-1.1480423212051392,
0.5625736713409424,
0.5402681231498718,
0.834627091884613,
-0.14392217993736267,
-0.30340975522994995,
-0.6580966114997864,
0.10091543942689896,
-0.0770343691110611,
0.4898776710033417,
-0.4084264039993286,
-0.6037235856056213,
-0.09252078086137772,
0.182109996676445,
-0.13448074460029602,
-0.3452867269515991,
0.31391555070877075,
-0.40587306022644043,
0.6307824850082397,
0.17956234514713287,
-0.6406242251396179,
0.2688867449760437,
-0.0730256736278534,
-0.6043435335159302,
0.7739877700805664,
-0.017593612894415855,
-1.0182987451553345,
0.19515454769134521,
-0.8499098420143127,
-0.5901368260383606,
-0.04275910556316376,
-0.39627352356910706,
-0.9882300496101379,
0.03372529521584511,
0.19256193935871124,
0.8440861701965332,
-0.02597806416451931,
0.30732083320617676,
-0.49890661239624023,
-0.24071264266967773,
0.3144463896751404,
-0.35329094529151917,
0.7723326086997986,
0.35216569900512695,
-0.8264960646629333,
-0.1141073927283287,
-0.9850373864173889,
-0.03634076938033104,
0.26617375016212463,
-0.38199907541275024,
-0.41738930344581604,
0.14685535430908203,
-0.3698269724845886,
-0.17692923545837402,
0.32518425583839417,
-0.6864853501319885,
0.12253504991531372,
-0.7226215600967407,
0.6408040523529053,
0.8794411420822144,
-0.3362632393836975,
0.8665000200271606,
-0.25973081588745117,
0.38717523217201233,
-0.13603486120700836,
0.18822234869003296,
-0.18009547889232635,
-0.4827849864959717,
-0.4949797987937927,
-0.360275536775589,
0.41221505403518677,
0.5375069379806519,
-0.491595596075058,
0.5059216022491455,
-0.476450115442276,
-0.5916451215744019,
-0.5777392387390137,
0.18041689693927765,
0.48395055532455444,
0.3221096098423004,
0.1786104440689087,
-0.036931250244379044,
-0.5925973057746887,
-0.6370550394058228,
-0.2738516330718994,
-0.03528473153710365,
0.07144755125045776,
0.5866222381591797,
0.25944963097572327,
-0.619381844997406,
1.078668236732483,
-0.40467900037765503,
-0.11787976324558258,
-0.14682671427726746,
-0.07992188632488251,
-0.3283000588417053,
0.5735471844673157,
0.288499116897583,
-0.7930805087089539,
-0.5525997877120972,
0.3712793290615082,
-0.6289017200469971,
-0.25390809774398804,
-0.06155906990170479,
0.032844457775354385,
0.38852396607398987,
0.16485778987407684,
-0.47261425852775574,
0.21504178643226624,
1.083081603050232,
-0.2170712947845459,
0.3414247930049896,
-0.5455853343009949,
-0.038758937269449234,
-1.259792447090149,
-0.060648199170827866,
-0.18422724306583405,
-0.5211232900619507,
-0.7028213143348694,
-0.04761253297328949,
0.027126479893922806,
-0.4550676941871643,
-0.5510470867156982,
0.738451361656189,
-0.4886781573295593,
-0.11481858789920807,
-0.03818042203783989,
0.11777898669242859,
-0.025698058307170868,
0.2398708611726761,
0.143415629863739,
0.9017957448959351,
0.37352654337882996,
-0.6344664692878723,
0.28189483284950256,
0.3274838626384735,
-0.17422622442245483,
-0.027423961088061333,
-0.5214476585388184,
0.5085164904594421,
-0.01707092486321926,
0.21514445543289185,
-0.5588663220405579,
-0.40063339471817017,
0.20355015993118286,
-0.2139197438955307,
0.368900328874588,
0.10619834065437317,
-0.5610369443893433,
-0.09816114604473114,
-0.34801891446113586,
0.19292129576206207,
0.7747189402580261,
-0.9839128255844116,
0.48387613892555237,
0.637566328048706,
-0.012929731979966164,
-0.4754999577999115,
-0.9640417695045471,
-0.15314236283302307,
-0.40391403436660767,
-0.702453076839447,
0.6184878945350647,
-0.052851226180791855,
-0.2384335994720459,
-0.11119084060192108,
0.08203894644975662,
-0.25519782304763794,
0.23987041413784027,
0.3614373505115509,
0.014153996482491493,
-0.14878308773040771,
0.05761855095624924,
0.4481888711452484,
-0.08096993714570999,
-0.06171070784330368,
-0.37941473722457886,
0.4450767934322357,
-0.14796128869056702,
-0.039738841354846954,
-0.7072323560714722,
0.03990791365504265,
0.08705862611532211,
-0.21421563625335693,
0.9149324297904968,
0.19592031836509705,
-0.18383775651454926,
-0.444557785987854,
-0.24488304555416107,
-0.3622206747531891,
-0.5858359336853027,
0.06158585473895073,
-0.24259166419506073,
-1.082431435585022,
0.20059745013713837,
-0.20774205029010773,
0.15434877574443817,
0.051594577729701996,
0.6141127347946167,
-0.09170626848936081,
0.9563080072402954,
0.9130429625511169,
0.06229459121823311,
0.6148737072944641,
-0.17090773582458496,
0.3144906163215637,
-0.25610753893852234,
-0.2837684154510498,
-0.4515937268733978,
-0.13957341015338898,
-1.088829517364502,
-0.1690116822719574,
0.0695142075419426,
-0.05883380025625229,
-0.32325810194015503,
0.4201681613922119,
-0.6237403750419617,
0.6035991311073303,
0.38481706380844116,
0.3330478370189667,
0.5375230312347412,
0.34413942694664,
0.18813860416412354,
-0.16135507822036743,
-0.5210160613059998,
-0.6218926310539246,
1.4138344526290894,
0.606209397315979,
0.9635167717933655,
-0.19110172986984253,
1.331303358078003,
0.1750912070274353,
0.5347659587860107,
-0.26351967453956604,
0.48464521765708923,
-0.5138799548149109,
-0.5264824032783508,
-0.18820634484291077,
-0.7828197479248047,
-0.9693083763122559,
0.0025228215381503105,
-0.19645485281944275,
-0.6804458498954773,
0.12465529888868332,
0.4654236435890198,
-0.35128048062324524,
0.25026413798332214,
-1.1156524419784546,
0.828809380531311,
-0.22526493668556213,
-0.39221230149269104,
0.15770401060581207,
-0.6068722605705261,
0.3748055398464203,
-0.5453569293022156,
0.24699616432189941,
0.04091544821858406,
0.0713195949792862,
0.765667736530304,
-0.5414251089096069,
0.9741896986961365,
-0.26416686177253723,
-0.10567504912614822,
0.1251232922077179,
0.016007428988814354,
0.7855129241943359,
0.28984391689300537,
0.010111198760569096,
0.2027169018983841,
-0.0822283998131752,
-0.16430775821208954,
-0.4287237226963043,
0.7948480248451233,
-1.030472993850708,
-0.6139389872550964,
-0.2612646520137787,
-0.2150186002254486,
-0.24702347815036774,
0.17791439592838287,
0.3421165645122528,
0.29014068841934204,
-0.2089187055826187,
0.37106117606163025,
0.8449739813804626,
-0.4317314624786377,
0.28174638748168945,
0.5450800657272339,
-0.31277474761009216,
-0.1781226098537445,
0.8934580087661743,
-0.033211953938007355,
0.21412846446037292,
0.4750651717185974,
0.41179943084716797,
-0.5772590637207031,
-0.5566281080245972,
-0.5499388575553894,
0.2327868640422821,
-0.38757044076919556,
-0.12985441088676453,
-1.0408345460891724,
-0.447541207075119,
-0.31128570437431335,
-0.03077542781829834,
-0.6215745806694031,
-0.5453935265541077,
-0.5604658126831055,
-0.29186439514160156,
0.545708954334259,
0.46716201305389404,
-0.1666226089000702,
0.7329817414283752,
-0.8631718158721924,
0.21228303015232086,
0.1892719566822052,
0.392374724149704,
-0.544502854347229,
-0.4416910707950592,
-0.12382514029741287,
0.4094497263431549,
-0.4004887342453003,
-0.6942470669746399,
0.4868188798427582,
0.4803673326969147,
0.34549620747566223,
0.18078453838825226,
0.18034504354000092,
0.3389005959033966,
-0.7945051789283752,
0.6396805644035339,
-0.036725081503391266,
-0.9102653861045837,
0.432578980922699,
-0.4072074592113495,
-0.13484662771224976,
0.5491712093353271,
0.5393450260162354,
-0.07907939702272415,
-0.6144595146179199,
-0.6970757842063904,
-0.4539560079574585,
0.7229256629943848,
0.4358113408088684,
0.7333259582519531,
0.34775811433792114,
0.3504835069179535,
0.4911790192127228,
0.3379923701286316,
-1.1342980861663818,
-0.4001917541027069,
-0.23801909387111664,
-0.45294106006622314,
-0.11337748169898987,
0.11608810722827911,
-0.04764268919825554,
-0.3438708782196045,
0.4610711634159088,
0.11955533921718597,
0.4577156901359558,
0.08391974866390228,
0.06646663695573807,
0.06341534852981567,
0.14566490054130554,
0.5551798939704895,
0.532608151435852,
-0.09520719945430756,
0.1250215470790863,
-0.07014770805835724,
-0.6980543732643127,
0.3581998646259308,
0.6080789566040039,
-0.3306124210357666,
0.11761227995157242,
-0.07404711097478867,
0.8489312529563904,
0.0232811588793993,
-0.5938318967819214,
0.5648388266563416,
-0.27793750166893005,
-0.4163070321083069,
-0.26216402649879456,
0.1265048384666443,
0.038792360574007034,
0.17934828996658325,
-0.08313644677400589,
-0.1914210468530655,
-0.11004289984703064,
-0.3456283211708069,
0.2195236086845398,
0.18302075564861298,
-0.06266568601131439,
-0.5665454864501953,
0.9947915077209473,
0.4092497229576111,
-0.4602665901184082,
0.39230045676231384,
-0.2768535614013672,
-0.30566495656967163,
0.2042313814163208,
0.6288895010948181,
0.9331451654434204,
-0.44244277477264404,
0.5165454745292664,
-0.21806621551513672,
0.1595851182937622,
-0.29544952511787415,
0.13269181549549103,
-0.183807834982872,
-0.647857129573822,
-0.317397803068161,
-0.7593536972999573,
-0.378458708524704,
0.45858922600746155,
-0.12864311039447784,
0.20291608572006226,
-0.7299475073814392,
0.012098385952413082,
-0.032358258962631226,
0.06078724190592766,
-0.7150148153305054,
0.2011929303407669,
0.02665681578218937,
0.4891309142112732,
-0.587745726108551,
1.2018941640853882,
0.4057108759880066,
0.020582692697644234,
-0.7215010523796082,
-0.09525886923074722,
-0.2770595848560333,
-0.6352426409721375,
0.6794537901878357,
0.270379900932312,
-0.017613209784030914,
0.2963522672653198,
-0.5457047820091248,
-0.5324507355690002,
0.9395315647125244,
0.5796056389808655,
-0.9891356229782104,
-0.07809945195913315,
0.4444628357887268,
0.7142678499221802,
-0.34397903084754944,
-0.35924819111824036,
0.3453977704048157,
0.24541056156158447,
-0.5947924852371216,
-0.8910621404647827,
0.017931770533323288,
0.08276620507240295,
-0.22986425459384918,
0.233940988779068,
-0.36400294303894043,
0.8618187308311462,
-0.08188456296920776,
-0.4803009629249573,
-0.0315377302467823,
0.46197351813316345,
0.10549664497375488,
0.6231241822242737,
0.19139821827411652,
0.42077162861824036,
0.8731082677841187,
0.06195440515875816,
1.1803909540176392,
-0.30034390091896057,
0.4208582639694214,
1.1248345375061035,
-0.43797993659973145,
0.7360191345214844,
0.27869096398353577,
-0.1528688222169876,
0.3841685950756073,
0.6537078619003296,
0.1838863641023636,
0.9866306781768799,
0.2602435350418091,
-0.5437597632408142,
0.16337069869041443,
0.41000545024871826,
-0.44801586866378784,
0.2342466115951538,
0.028363561257719994,
-0.6019981503486633,
-0.0684109777212143,
0.15962806344032288,
0.07201021909713745,
0.3161555230617523,
-0.0829956978559494,
0.8199159502983093,
0.30289557576179504,
-0.12237834185361862,
0.5362929701805115,
0.28332993388175964,
0.7131096124649048,
-0.505695104598999,
0.4280756413936615,
-0.3671562671661377,
0.46342962980270386,
-0.18441203236579895,
-0.2794884145259857,
0.4914971590042114,
0.3670255243778229,
-0.012904956005513668,
-0.5737702250480652,
0.6489317417144775,
-0.4152209460735321,
-0.4000808298587799,
0.06738192588090897,
0.5940324068069458,
0.21217741072177887,
0.013833783566951752,
-0.6667352914810181,
-0.05459164083003998,
-0.08306331187486649,
-0.4859994053840637,
0.5705227851867676,
0.5317187309265137,
0.043587882071733475,
0.5171822905540466,
0.7594541907310486,
-0.1421443521976471,
0.37920206785202026,
-0.07132940739393234,
1.1257692575454712,
-0.36070963740348816,
-0.808626115322113,
-1.1340970993041992,
0.30661454796791077,
-0.1453995704650879,
-0.19863517582416534,
0.7787062525749207,
0.6043334007263184,
1.1446974277496338,
-0.10100672394037247,
0.8699327707290649,
0.11630829423666,
0.5519651770591736,
-0.6566296219825745,
1.041037678718567,
-0.5232004523277283,
0.3976286053657532,
-0.01277264952659607,
-0.9708489775657654,
-0.2582941949367523,
0.6319860219955444,
-0.5092961192131042,
-0.07674626260995865,
0.6647821664810181,
0.8053549528121948,
-0.313367635011673,
0.2885783612728119,
0.13329117000102997,
0.0730469599366188,
0.3408206105232239,
0.22998149693012238,
0.9244375228881836,
-0.3658706843852997,
0.3995387554168701,
-0.5517714023590088,
-0.07824807614088058,
0.057160306721925735,
-0.8625166416168213,
-1.1029627323150635,
-0.6662964820861816,
-0.19321589171886444,
-0.26912423968315125,
0.3152136206626892,
0.8166423439979553,
0.9037088751792908,
-0.5447232127189636,
-0.07700959593057632,
-0.4924185276031494,
-0.09487943351268768,
0.295565664768219,
-0.11418049782514572,
0.27337852120399475,
-0.18535466492176056,
-0.8189308643341064,
0.5982141494750977,
0.0567263625562191,
0.5205373167991638,
-0.42670580744743347,
-0.35834765434265137,
0.26147934794425964,
0.01289308536797762,
0.48343804478645325,
0.3041512668132782,
-0.30851590633392334,
-0.011504031717777252,
0.052366483956575394,
-0.28298425674438477,
0.06783317774534225,
1.013436198234558,
-0.7965048551559448,
0.36723053455352783,
0.25192099809646606,
1.1432068347930908,
0.7339791059494019,
0.04868267849087715,
0.7094385027885437,
-1.066525936126709,
0.525132417678833,
0.2974804937839508,
-0.008216419257223606,
0.41210028529167175,
-0.7002148628234863,
0.2515411972999573,
0.2532459795475006,
-0.7474347949028015,
-1.1947261095046997,
0.14263249933719635,
-0.6023128032684326,
-0.16280870139598846,
1.228175163269043,
-0.49005448818206787,
-0.3875545561313629,
-0.025110561400651932,
-0.07511946558952332,
-0.009300733916461468,
-0.32698193192481995,
1.1056350469589233,
0.23984162509441376,
0.09742731600999832,
0.0022841552272439003,
-0.31801310181617737,
0.9149506092071533,
0.171089768409729,
-1.2346060276031494,
0.23671935498714447,
0.23902645707130432,
0.16612428426742554,
-0.16864219307899475,
0.8803735375404358,
-0.07290298491716385,
-0.09723882377147675,
-0.015637027099728584,
-0.3757682144641876,
-0.34174036979675293,
-0.48131847381591797,
-0.3724745512008667,
-0.1354234367609024,
-0.1514652818441391,
-0.3619282841682434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02950v1
|
4D ASR: Joint Beam Search Integrating CTC, Attention, Transducer, and Mask Predict Decoders
| 2024-06-05T05:18:20 | 2024-06-05T05:18:20 |
Yui Sudo, Muhammad Shakeel, Yosuke Fukumoto, Brian Yan, Jiatong Shi, Yifan Peng, Shinji Watanabe
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
End-to-end automatic speech recognition (E2E-ASR) can be classified into
several network architectures, such as connectionist temporal classification
(CTC), recurrent neural network transducer (RNN-T), attention-based
encoder-decoder, and mask-predict models. Each network architecture has
advantages and disadvantages, leading practitioners to switch between these
different models depending on application requirements. Instead of building
separate models, we propose a joint modeling scheme where four decoders (CTC,
RNN-T, attention, and mask-predict) share the same encoder -- we refer to this
as 4D modeling. The 4D model is trained using multitask learning, which will
bring model regularization and maximize the model robustness thanks to their
complementary properties. To efficiently train the 4D model, we introduce a
two-stage training strategy that stabilizes multitask learning. In addition, we
propose three novel one-pass beam search algorithms by combining three decoders
(CTC, RNN-T, and attention) to further improve performance. These three beam
search algorithms differ in which decoder is used as the primary decoder. We
carefully evaluate the performance and computational tradeoffs associated with
each algorithm. Experimental results demonstrate that the jointly trained 4D
model outperforms the E2E-ASR models trained with only one individual decoder.
Furthermore, we demonstrate that the proposed one-pass beam search algorithm
outperforms the previously proposed CTC/attention decoding.
|
[
-0.33365026116371155,
-0.3714113235473633,
0.44111984968185425,
-0.004592560697346926,
-0.2788757085800171,
0.1987326741218567,
0.284662127494812,
-0.5596296787261963,
0.058408044278621674,
0.44278842210769653,
-0.3716796040534973,
-0.4299301207065582,
-0.882217288017273,
0.43307018280029297,
-0.407288134098053,
0.27040910720825195,
-0.12538327276706696,
0.12459376454353333,
0.17935329675674438,
-0.15851525962352753,
-0.525405764579773,
-0.4018239676952362,
-0.8383679986000061,
-0.3141157627105713,
0.33723071217536926,
0.03081904537975788,
0.23163194954395294,
0.7477763891220093,
0.6130991578102112,
0.37360697984695435,
-0.16824600100517273,
0.11725261062383652,
-0.06788459420204163,
0.06923690438270569,
0.05845961719751358,
-0.026221374049782753,
-0.46896007657051086,
-0.002290270058438182,
0.5262558460235596,
0.5350387096405029,
-0.15046900510787964,
-0.19636878371238708,
-0.08214347064495087,
0.4941153824329376,
-0.7568941116333008,
0.4629964828491211,
-0.40845590829849243,
0.19200298190116882,
-0.2982860207557678,
-0.45285120606422424,
-0.29395246505737305,
-0.10557980090379715,
0.3324490785598755,
-0.5369855165481567,
0.26646456122398376,
-0.13951538503170013,
0.5847663283348083,
0.5101810693740845,
-0.6171318888664246,
-0.3060867190361023,
-0.6919775605201721,
0.5585599541664124,
-0.6099541783332825,
1.054317593574524,
0.49286848306655884,
0.24658921360969543,
0.20974251627922058,
-0.7912713885307312,
-0.3961155414581299,
0.03554826229810715,
0.08190198987722397,
0.38403913378715515,
-0.14718970656394958,
0.42658254504203796,
0.12413529306650162,
0.09988811612129211,
-0.8512451648712158,
-0.18765823543071747,
-0.5985832810401917,
-0.19871892035007477,
0.5108537673950195,
0.04038750380277634,
-0.09327958524227142,
0.10497412085533142,
-0.5337912440299988,
-0.03493297100067139,
-0.44250163435935974,
0.1695823073387146,
0.03803601488471031,
0.2643977105617523,
-0.1363292634487152,
0.28067198395729065,
-0.18499355018138885,
0.9173911809921265,
0.3211163580417633,
-0.11267711222171783,
0.3865334987640381,
-0.6531392931938171,
0.04860975220799446,
0.3417479395866394,
0.6166077852249146,
-0.016803599894046783,
-0.17841580510139465,
-0.22762426733970642,
-0.42604097723960876,
0.4954549968242645,
0.28501901030540466,
-0.49530038237571716,
-0.1661478877067566,
0.2110276073217392,
-0.5622182488441467,
0.12380758672952652,
-0.09158612042665482,
-0.4289117455482483,
0.13131752610206604,
-0.550582766532898,
0.5359888672828674,
-0.2731063663959503,
-0.21887655556201935,
0.31712377071380615,
-0.10624406486749649,
0.21387486159801483,
0.021292049437761307,
-0.8071202635765076,
0.640091061592102,
0.451364666223526,
0.9058243632316589,
-0.0822305679321289,
-0.2690046429634094,
-0.6636213660240173,
0.30293402075767517,
-0.36067336797714233,
0.7779225707054138,
-0.5931295156478882,
-0.4942460358142853,
-0.11112271994352341,
-0.24156033992767334,
-0.2908592224121094,
-0.40187186002731323,
0.4221436381340027,
-0.8850341439247131,
-0.04647544026374817,
-0.0108458511531353,
-0.6009652614593506,
-0.4183569848537445,
0.2091856151819229,
-0.9306426644325256,
0.48811885714530945,
-0.08891995996236801,
-0.7060606479644775,
0.17872120440006256,
-0.8537939786911011,
-0.49978402256965637,
0.01796693727374077,
-0.28382375836372375,
-0.5616803765296936,
-0.06412407755851746,
0.3461746573448181,
0.43781813979148865,
-0.40664610266685486,
0.002853442681953311,
-0.17919208109378815,
-0.31172001361846924,
0.05072347819805145,
-0.2551117241382599,
0.6562401056289673,
0.5031684637069702,
-0.26095956563949585,
0.09041174501180649,
-0.5783160328865051,
-0.11608313024044037,
-0.005281532648950815,
-0.6081739068031311,
0.01481371559202671,
0.03058561310172081,
0.01842600293457508,
0.25176674127578735,
0.21282047033309937,
-0.7532627582550049,
-0.4213349223136902,
-0.7205778360366821,
0.537770688533783,
0.30897456407546997,
-0.022203676402568817,
0.4195588529109955,
-0.39432448148727417,
0.4255874454975128,
0.16763612627983093,
-0.09326709061861038,
-0.3453434407711029,
-0.4011703133583069,
-0.3875366449356079,
-0.08958709985017776,
0.16692784428596497,
0.36866194009780884,
-0.7876768112182617,
0.19176077842712402,
-0.17310351133346558,
-0.027910497039556503,
-0.6534964442253113,
-0.16765442490577698,
0.7714852094650269,
0.13788703083992004,
0.44856923818588257,
-0.5074530243873596,
-0.9111402034759521,
-0.5254434943199158,
-0.1810455322265625,
0.1261359453201294,
-0.0022951001301407814,
0.10469815880060196,
0.18032586574554443,
-0.0931105688214302,
0.7256579399108887,
-0.1110285297036171,
-0.592536985874176,
-0.4219815731048584,
0.015690870583057404,
0.13478653132915497,
0.2388143688440323,
0.25420403480529785,
-0.9175231456756592,
-0.4432348608970642,
0.0946013554930687,
-0.6070256233215332,
0.27435213327407837,
0.2785475254058838,
0.5764967799186707,
0.2526575028896332,
0.4512159824371338,
-0.41623783111572266,
0.5829118490219116,
0.569058358669281,
-0.13492538034915924,
0.014467271976172924,
-0.15765957534313202,
0.13894259929656982,
-1.0730301141738892,
-0.017886584624648094,
-0.014200838282704353,
-0.13764123618602753,
-0.8697072267532349,
0.03536294773221016,
0.20171234011650085,
-0.24797049164772034,
-0.3751014173030853,
0.45075109601020813,
-0.8521894216537476,
-0.5046988725662231,
-0.29605889320373535,
0.07204240560531616,
0.11738771200180054,
0.47156381607055664,
0.21317154169082642,
0.5287653803825378,
0.7318711876869202,
-0.6326034069061279,
0.5666916370391846,
0.4202219247817993,
-0.12242938578128815,
0.20178848505020142,
-0.5951775908470154,
0.5037590265274048,
-0.10468509048223495,
0.5508114099502563,
-0.767266571521759,
-0.13796645402908325,
-0.027495184913277626,
-0.6317818760871887,
0.5989584922790527,
-0.11645456403493881,
-0.2938993573188782,
-0.6028498411178589,
-0.2925543785095215,
0.7645076513290405,
0.05240542069077492,
-0.6966713070869446,
0.8613041639328003,
0.6391193866729736,
-0.07325203716754913,
-0.4737838804721832,
-0.6044282913208008,
0.05837365612387657,
0.00008526066085323691,
-0.6811279654502869,
0.7308350205421448,
0.01045910082757473,
0.25590959191322327,
-0.059646934270858765,
-0.21074818074703217,
-0.230966255068779,
-0.26903262734413147,
0.23922166228294373,
0.05926733836531639,
-0.1567240059375763,
-0.23493894934654236,
-0.26668524742126465,
-0.4825286269187927,
-0.12607857584953308,
-0.4203040301799774,
0.5201345682144165,
0.053781986236572266,
-0.40715378522872925,
-0.8336654305458069,
0.6542355418205261,
0.38515356183052063,
-0.7384427785873413,
0.027360286563634872,
0.48895809054374695,
-0.5976837277412415,
0.012615932151675224,
-0.8089649081230164,
-0.4433682858943939,
-0.5250673890113831,
0.5339013338088989,
-0.8320368528366089,
-0.8341221809387207,
0.4101165533065796,
0.1322508454322815,
0.03175247833132744,
-0.07854026556015015,
0.6847096681594849,
0.04964711517095566,
1.0807313919067383,
0.4981115162372589,
0.011647418141365051,
0.28956329822540283,
-0.4500579833984375,
0.4482923448085785,
-0.9343231320381165,
-0.37180525064468384,
-0.3920299708843231,
-0.3570376932621002,
-0.3341880440711975,
-0.4530196785926819,
0.6411750316619873,
-0.3525508940219879,
-0.2919546365737915,
0.3805696964263916,
-0.5929772257804871,
0.4510381519794464,
0.5983737707138062,
0.15238720178604126,
0.24756895005702972,
0.025855401530861855,
-0.025938156992197037,
0.200015127658844,
-0.7136345505714417,
-0.056660160422325134,
1.1987839937210083,
0.3896801769733429,
0.6522412300109863,
0.0787879005074501,
0.7447443604469299,
-0.20950396358966827,
-0.5204578042030334,
-0.6219794154167175,
0.3041757345199585,
-0.4477808177471161,
-0.7338329553604126,
-0.24318747222423553,
-0.3514920175075531,
-0.9910579919815063,
0.13904151320457458,
0.4205111563205719,
-0.4742818772792816,
0.4757566750049591,
0.19876964390277863,
-0.7206466197967529,
0.3304159343242645,
-0.5011599659919739,
0.6858782768249512,
-0.12128029763698578,
-0.07160181552171707,
-0.22569182515144348,
-0.9478306770324707,
0.1497025340795517,
-0.023200100287795067,
0.0547945573925972,
-0.022230174392461777,
0.1451602727174759,
0.7974595427513123,
0.15048547089099884,
0.5444298982620239,
-0.2860249876976013,
0.32865652441978455,
0.32160359621047974,
0.06258520483970642,
0.5064358115196228,
-0.1646900624036789,
-0.1258876621723175,
0.24185939133167267,
0.0729256346821785,
-0.18727782368659973,
-0.2320028692483902,
0.535462498664856,
-0.9405290484428406,
-0.39498916268348694,
-0.4218951165676117,
-0.6494036316871643,
-0.23662593960762024,
0.03822384774684906,
0.37378451228141785,
0.882523238658905,
0.12896530330181122,
0.24467778205871582,
0.39786964654922485,
0.19237561523914337,
0.6584798693656921,
0.5204038023948669,
0.214122012257576,
-0.3664247989654541,
0.8347154259681702,
0.16937680542469025,
0.17268286645412445,
0.6165118217468262,
-0.048353537917137146,
-0.5661581754684448,
-0.7450852394104004,
-0.17646677792072296,
0.18454569578170776,
-0.5224916338920593,
-0.5235341191291809,
-0.9097628593444824,
-0.7217659950256348,
-0.6246083974838257,
-0.20627398788928986,
-0.6203157305717468,
-0.036086928099393845,
-0.4966265559196472,
-0.10767404735088348,
0.19234754145145416,
0.7914140820503235,
-0.2605171501636505,
0.1585126370191574,
-0.8151837587356567,
0.4844929277896881,
0.4142894446849823,
0.403998464345932,
-0.13990643620491028,
-0.6489303708076477,
-0.3004939556121826,
0.02285970188677311,
-0.4411301612854004,
-0.8194662928581238,
0.7197220921516418,
0.3080337345600128,
0.4353106915950775,
0.3993557393550873,
0.10020841658115387,
0.4983043074607849,
-0.5574643611907959,
0.35712823271751404,
0.40637683868408203,
-0.8095025420188904,
0.3888393044471741,
-0.2254342883825302,
0.45245134830474854,
0.20049604773521423,
0.18595556914806366,
-0.2679089307785034,
0.025028163567185402,
-0.18680228292942047,
-0.6216977834701538,
1.2732874155044556,
0.1792459636926651,
-0.30349001288414,
0.19552509486675262,
0.08764977753162384,
-0.10601416975259781,
-0.09668010473251343,
-0.4973170757293701,
-0.12097390741109848,
-0.5850680470466614,
-0.3778002858161926,
0.13667689263820648,
-0.29319527745246887,
-0.15010161697864532,
0.015420153737068176,
0.3714653253555298,
-0.0006945083732716739,
0.5906251668930054,
0.13614951074123383,
0.10206890106201172,
-0.1827496737241745,
0.07154649496078491,
0.4512600600719452,
0.25200533866882324,
-0.3938438892364502,
0.3051019310951233,
0.2640449106693268,
-0.30090388655662537,
0.26159414649009705,
0.49852925539016724,
0.2854301333427429,
0.0967368483543396,
0.1515611857175827,
1.0676676034927368,
0.4986433684825897,
-0.20011980831623077,
0.5679237842559814,
-0.10686904937028885,
-0.49958598613739014,
-0.45531344413757324,
-0.26868295669555664,
0.20153526961803436,
0.536262571811676,
0.2946830093860626,
0.23074676096439362,
0.5024095773696899,
-0.1439124196767807,
0.36244526505470276,
0.2996149957180023,
-0.1644096076488495,
-0.7035098671913147,
0.8867390751838684,
0.3751624524593353,
-0.3797125220298767,
0.36217567324638367,
-0.3214230537414551,
-0.6069429516792297,
0.7032104134559631,
0.6331517696380615,
1.0140076875686646,
-0.8010439276695251,
-0.09912519156932831,
0.525702714920044,
-0.03679007291793823,
-0.13106796145439148,
0.32531219720840454,
-0.23028427362442017,
-0.9239788055419922,
-0.3928254544734955,
-0.5617746710777283,
-0.13755865395069122,
0.0017142471624538302,
-0.595537006855011,
0.3914123475551605,
-0.3399030268192291,
-0.0828053280711174,
0.09305256605148315,
0.039680127054452896,
-0.8568994998931885,
0.1440688669681549,
0.3884845972061157,
0.30709683895111084,
-0.2932884991168976,
1.147254228591919,
0.41701459884643555,
-0.18488235771656036,
-0.928752064704895,
-0.20820260047912598,
0.4635330140590668,
-0.5682570934295654,
0.806361198425293,
0.35930028557777405,
-0.3976886570453644,
0.36264681816101074,
0.06982790678739548,
-1.4453790187835693,
1.3122531175613403,
-0.012277363799512386,
-0.6131958365440369,
-0.4778808653354645,
-0.05078883841633797,
0.06604120135307312,
-0.5666875839233398,
0.28440338373184204,
0.6723604798316956,
0.21772387623786926,
0.4093150496482849,
-1.3287162780761719,
-0.2919846177101135,
-0.1693810224533081,
0.33461660146713257,
0.06875469535589218,
-0.43686386942863464,
0.8913768529891968,
-0.3451928198337555,
-0.6027777791023254,
-0.09790708869695663,
0.32996049523353577,
0.47316357493400574,
0.6152519583702087,
0.4137516915798187,
0.5038570761680603,
0.017760394141077995,
0.010818720795214176,
0.8632078170776367,
-0.4694313704967499,
0.3626702129840851,
1.0870640277862549,
-0.5423762798309326,
0.8562719225883484,
0.12890852987766266,
-0.2808385193347931,
-0.2270127534866333,
0.6036015748977661,
0.15538464486598969,
1.01700758934021,
-0.19687944650650024,
-0.3402775824069977,
0.025680817663669586,
0.058091841638088226,
-0.33237650990486145,
0.8002609014511108,
0.45841240882873535,
0.022008560597896576,
-0.2763688266277313,
0.23559530079364777,
-0.4407561123371124,
-0.003078489564359188,
-0.17110098898410797,
0.9760355949401855,
0.21512405574321747,
-0.24243046343326569,
0.6548193097114563,
0.022523144260048866,
0.8145499229431152,
-0.506963849067688,
-0.0025644428096711636,
-0.10935164242982864,
0.2916615307331085,
-0.16846492886543274,
-0.3476015627384186,
0.5085265040397644,
-0.2591154873371124,
-0.2535809278488159,
-0.23969969153404236,
0.5635672211647034,
-0.6360164880752563,
-0.33290866017341614,
0.7150800824165344,
0.23473438620567322,
0.007298919837921858,
-0.046233274042606354,
-0.5423369407653809,
0.49565643072128296,
0.1365232765674591,
-0.02033032849431038,
0.15162654221057892,
0.2530835270881653,
0.3740229904651642,
0.5883895754814148,
0.5591201782226562,
-0.028125956654548645,
0.42247095704078674,
0.07305346429347992,
0.8581154346466064,
-0.5031552314758301,
-0.7037550806999207,
-0.34611475467681885,
0.33615365624427795,
0.28342488408088684,
0.040319688618183136,
0.2536645531654358,
0.5206373333930969,
0.9657652378082275,
0.1808498501777649,
0.5661864280700684,
0.18501169979572296,
1.1116352081298828,
-0.46490344405174255,
0.4982645809650421,
-0.4779084324836731,
0.26379144191741943,
-0.07109381258487701,
-0.8281965851783752,
-0.5608956217765808,
0.7949103713035583,
-0.005182591266930103,
0.3467046916484833,
0.8367884159088135,
0.9389051795005798,
-0.05767148360610008,
0.2887144684791565,
0.6968733072280884,
0.21909469366073608,
0.5102789998054504,
0.7600677609443665,
0.5621646046638489,
-0.6545075178146362,
0.6812171936035156,
-0.28954842686653137,
-0.0075010620057582855,
-0.23044152557849884,
-0.13494811952114105,
-0.6285309195518494,
-1.0313067436218262,
-0.32244667410850525,
0.11451176553964615,
0.2188739776611328,
0.827539324760437,
0.8520170450210571,
-0.8159035444259644,
-0.30460137128829956,
-0.19571121037006378,
-0.39414069056510925,
-0.1266240030527115,
-0.12189236283302307,
0.47287875413894653,
-0.3396538496017456,
-0.8324487805366516,
0.8924576640129089,
0.5154799818992615,
-0.09315237402915955,
-0.03774154186248779,
-0.3424341082572937,
-0.39524444937705994,
-0.24388253688812256,
0.44791749119758606,
0.21198515594005585,
-1.0913680791854858,
-0.20940686762332916,
0.00621745316311717,
-0.01957876980304718,
0.11781086772680283,
0.8255608081817627,
-0.9434126615524292,
1.0392175912857056,
0.3888842463493347,
0.8306198716163635,
0.8432038426399231,
-0.1668257862329483,
0.5614523887634277,
-0.5910513997077942,
0.16768990457057953,
0.5030202269554138,
0.33739665150642395,
0.37810346484184265,
-0.024398313835263252,
0.3585379123687744,
0.039181314408779144,
-0.7329244017601013,
-0.5472362637519836,
0.1366412341594696,
-0.9246785044670105,
-0.17801320552825928,
0.8954187035560608,
-0.23112058639526367,
0.15268807113170624,
-0.6103320717811584,
0.051345303654670715,
0.5349220037460327,
-0.5490980744361877,
0.6088209748268127,
0.21051140129566193,
-0.26427093148231506,
-0.492276668548584,
-0.5096030831336975,
0.46199360489845276,
0.16552209854125977,
-0.3646973967552185,
-0.21526874601840973,
0.3419308662414551,
0.22912651300430298,
0.18877571821212769,
0.6523556113243103,
-0.1709417998790741,
0.49937155842781067,
0.12247689068317413,
0.18026354908943176,
-0.29398009181022644,
-0.4952394366264343,
-0.4755318760871887,
0.24867309629917145,
-0.20208917558193207,
-0.7056512236595154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02943v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02943v1
|
The Task-oriented Queries Benchmark (ToQB)
| 2024-06-05T05:05:41 | 2024-06-05T05:05:41 |
Keun Soo Yim
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.NE
|
Task-oriented queries (e.g., one-shot queries to play videos, order food, or
call a taxi) are crucial for assessing the quality of virtual assistants,
chatbots, and other large language model (LLM)-based services. However, a
standard benchmark for task-oriented queries is not yet available, as existing
benchmarks in the relevant NLP (Natural Language Processing) fields have
primarily focused on task-oriented dialogues. Thus, we present a new
methodology for efficiently generating the Task-oriented Queries Benchmark
(ToQB) using existing task-oriented dialogue datasets and an LLM service. Our
methodology involves formulating the underlying NLP task to summarize the
original intent of a speaker in each dialogue, detailing the key steps to
perform the devised NLP task using an LLM service, and outlining a framework
for automating a major part of the benchmark generation process. Through a case
study encompassing three domains (i.e., two single-task domains and one
multi-task domain), we demonstrate how to customize the LLM prompts (e.g.,
omitting system utterances or speaker labels) for those three domains and
characterize the generated task-oriented queries. The generated ToQB dataset is
made available to the public. We further discuss new domains that can be added
to ToQB by community contributors and its practical applications.
|
[
-0.5852733254432678,
-0.7133324146270752,
0.37049591541290283,
0.33305221796035767,
-0.042285047471523285,
-0.13990525901317596,
-0.18942198157310486,
-0.22632907330989838,
0.07150730490684509,
0.9911097288131714,
-0.8043568730354309,
-0.709480881690979,
-0.08223196119070053,
0.07172279059886932,
-0.3964425325393677,
0.604123592376709,
0.38253945112228394,
-0.13691000640392303,
-0.4214835464954376,
-0.2786594331264496,
-0.5681902766227722,
-0.6295143961906433,
-0.8083410859107971,
0.02728486992418766,
0.27529239654541016,
0.3117290437221527,
0.36003929376602173,
0.5958362817764282,
0.3264925181865692,
0.26301267743110657,
0.188120037317276,
0.4578048586845398,
-0.5337496995925903,
0.5707153081893921,
-0.39196428656578064,
-0.3556729257106781,
-0.42685621976852417,
-0.3424150049686432,
0.4680325388908386,
0.8628729581832886,
-0.2617833912372589,
0.3885628283023834,
0.0637272521853447,
0.6537353992462158,
-0.6527412533760071,
0.33832061290740967,
-0.8010275363922119,
-0.0385434553027153,
-0.41514021158218384,
-0.5177001953125,
-0.446718692779541,
-0.2350330799818039,
-0.11756070703268051,
-0.45003777742385864,
0.23885047435760498,
0.3709220290184021,
0.5153883695602417,
0.4479158818721771,
-0.22749103605747223,
-0.22938694059848785,
-0.36243295669555664,
0.7901656031608582,
-0.6530725359916687,
0.33458900451660156,
0.2906626760959625,
0.6582872867584229,
-0.5068119764328003,
-0.548125147819519,
-0.5334779024124146,
-0.046720948070287704,
-0.033801767975091934,
0.016581829637289047,
-0.25195884704589844,
-0.21107445657253265,
0.30365583300590515,
0.1267077624797821,
-0.6443144679069519,
-0.08010716736316681,
0.25893640518188477,
0.045712292194366455,
0.6843128204345703,
0.5368642807006836,
-0.0016466608503833413,
-0.40095746517181396,
-0.2382613718509674,
-0.0072672259993851185,
-0.6281482577323914,
0.3636048436164856,
0.20159420371055603,
0.6272984147071838,
0.3533928394317627,
0.6772480607032776,
-0.7901471257209778,
0.7869923710823059,
0.1750524789094925,
-0.230869859457016,
0.21665291488170624,
-0.39926978945732117,
-0.1634937971830368,
-0.16070511937141418,
0.9132105708122253,
0.7510492205619812,
-0.023765185847878456,
-0.4827495515346527,
-0.18787726759910583,
-0.29070761799812317,
0.43506959080696106,
-0.7750180959701538,
0.1665959656238556,
0.3458324372768402,
-0.3600834012031555,
0.06222573295235634,
-0.5551949739456177,
-0.45758163928985596,
-0.214929461479187,
-0.23058833181858063,
0.24207626283168793,
-0.37191858887672424,
-0.03347506374120712,
-0.09703202545642853,
0.04427134618163109,
0.18852245807647705,
0.15827900171279907,
-0.6907470226287842,
0.805857241153717,
0.8103994131088257,
0.4447178840637207,
-0.6531347036361694,
-0.08140835165977478,
-0.7647494077682495,
0.23381386697292328,
-0.2478105127811432,
1.0270063877105713,
-0.4466944932937622,
-0.5908071994781494,
0.16692385077476501,
0.04905509203672409,
-0.015995316207408905,
-0.9632607698440552,
0.42574217915534973,
-0.3968677520751953,
0.08117834478616714,
-0.3909825086593628,
-0.5131165385246277,
-0.028036197647452354,
0.5140235424041748,
-0.41231516003608704,
1.4004056453704834,
0.20706719160079956,
-0.35490792989730835,
0.1428319811820984,
-0.6699029803276062,
-0.40825146436691284,
0.23464877903461456,
-0.39487385749816895,
-0.12278121709823608,
0.036432307213544846,
0.4254036843776703,
0.38236814737319946,
-0.9781184792518616,
0.3288332223892212,
-0.03778691962361336,
-0.05995209887623787,
0.17256753146648407,
-0.11267963796854019,
0.8377667665481567,
0.03853880986571312,
-0.23111756145954132,
-0.09614333510398865,
-0.8241320848464966,
0.4117000699043274,
0.08796603977680206,
-0.0628325417637825,
-0.11422746628522873,
0.2545575499534607,
-0.10861017554998398,
0.14847096800804138,
0.23030605912208557,
-0.5226015448570251,
0.08415134251117706,
-0.2736382782459259,
0.21663352847099304,
0.2769615948200226,
0.21298041939735413,
-0.061464063823223114,
-0.2738891839981079,
0.44155868887901306,
-0.09827173501253128,
0.2025960236787796,
-0.27971401810646057,
-0.48598313331604004,
-0.6509778499603271,
-0.3790596127510071,
-0.0671919733285904,
0.5149608254432678,
-0.7634875178337097,
0.32740896940231323,
-0.21239586174488068,
-0.5458475947380066,
-0.5372254252433777,
0.07165243476629257,
0.5567435026168823,
0.8403148055076599,
0.37024274468421936,
-0.49964889883995056,
-0.30410629510879517,
-1.0134822130203247,
-0.4852895438671112,
-0.26426786184310913,
-0.17392383515834808,
0.741310715675354,
0.034061823040246964,
0.16904297471046448,
1.0364620685577393,
-0.4866960942745209,
-0.27009180188179016,
0.037221767008304596,
0.036523591727018356,
0.34552982449531555,
0.31220802664756775,
0.6088545322418213,
-0.5703292489051819,
-0.6619547605514526,
-0.16866149008274078,
-0.5679574608802795,
-0.41728752851486206,
0.20399093627929688,
-0.502216637134552,
0.03628690540790558,
0.5121253728866577,
-0.5138676166534424,
0.12427227199077606,
0.28372901678085327,
-0.1743713766336441,
0.5955093502998352,
0.22653166949748993,
0.37665241956710815,
-1.0658663511276245,
0.16344666481018066,
-0.0839531198143959,
-0.3379133343696594,
-0.5961887240409851,
-0.0342278778553009,
-0.09089004993438721,
-0.2939949631690979,
-0.40434587001800537,
0.6522685885429382,
-0.3267727792263031,
-0.3418387472629547,
-0.22271840274333954,
0.17049656808376312,
0.024347133934497833,
0.9202786087989807,
-0.01586860604584217,
0.9201003909111023,
0.5329945683479309,
-0.6927641034126282,
0.4041997492313385,
0.5435739159584045,
-0.35902586579322815,
0.8775864839553833,
-0.6583933234214783,
0.2122480869293213,
0.05336585268378258,
0.05709698423743248,
-1.0632007122039795,
0.12330184876918793,
0.08973068743944168,
-0.33931902050971985,
-0.03999676555395126,
-0.3065173923969269,
-0.6836571097373962,
-0.059773776680231094,
-0.05610720440745354,
0.3541686236858368,
0.4546253979206085,
-0.541254460811615,
0.7294976115226746,
0.5484431385993958,
-0.4922076463699341,
-0.4354090988636017,
-0.3104584217071533,
0.2434733510017395,
-0.10397361218929291,
-0.6562497019767761,
0.6318596005439758,
0.0177512988448143,
-0.05114342272281647,
-0.12509772181510925,
-0.1885594129562378,
-0.24701686203479767,
-0.009269475936889648,
0.44065427780151367,
0.029208697378635406,
-0.2666557729244232,
-0.0036212329287081957,
-0.023479891940951347,
-0.019436854869127274,
0.31179285049438477,
-0.2519804537296295,
0.6333716511726379,
0.1302807629108429,
-0.47721657156944275,
-0.3886337876319885,
0.678618311882019,
0.18384557962417603,
-0.41284286975860596,
0.16042885184288025,
0.2828972041606903,
-0.10735687613487244,
-0.424640953540802,
-0.832969069480896,
-0.13904398679733276,
-0.4911367893218994,
0.2984497547149658,
-0.5375533103942871,
-0.7305029630661011,
0.3829493522644043,
-0.275698184967041,
0.4251002371311188,
0.24808281660079956,
0.6725788712501526,
0.0006219087517820299,
0.9953296184539795,
0.4260433316230774,
0.09590934216976166,
0.4604814350605011,
0.0931716114282608,
0.10662416368722916,
-0.778122067451477,
-0.3087134063243866,
-0.8782815933227539,
0.09315570443868637,
-0.5988867878913879,
-0.8017410039901733,
0.4874919056892395,
-0.08294381946325302,
-0.18231530487537384,
0.5069131851196289,
-0.3451574146747589,
0.25130462646484375,
0.672661304473877,
-0.047195158898830414,
0.3794512152671814,
-0.03759687766432762,
-0.028599314391613007,
0.045056845992803574,
-0.5568218231201172,
-0.5132328867912292,
1.1445269584655762,
-0.12766414880752563,
0.31237736344337463,
0.2860428988933563,
0.669154703617096,
0.3121986389160156,
0.19150416553020477,
-0.623060405254364,
1.0263519287109375,
-0.2434670329093933,
-0.5938945412635803,
-0.28056997060775757,
-0.38200587034225464,
-0.8113498091697693,
0.2404394894838333,
-0.02447517029941082,
-0.926014244556427,
-0.008537158370018005,
0.09723465144634247,
-0.3078269064426422,
-0.2539101243019104,
-0.5262040495872498,
0.945581316947937,
-0.09422439336776733,
-0.43799638748168945,
-0.13985630869865417,
-0.4097553789615631,
0.038792360574007034,
0.13137464225292206,
-0.07337326556444168,
-0.5615344643592834,
-0.0011002498213201761,
0.5426586270332336,
-0.4756794571876526,
0.6194710731506348,
-0.4094694256782532,
0.14071929454803467,
0.37165307998657227,
0.0328352227807045,
0.5841725468635559,
0.1294420063495636,
-0.5273438096046448,
-0.08957546204328537,
0.006866473238915205,
-0.4250970482826233,
-0.5942888855934143,
0.5272597670555115,
-0.47652700543403625,
-0.9276598691940308,
0.053419943898916245,
-0.7124396562576294,
-0.8472340703010559,
0.18003079295158386,
-0.24522030353546143,
0.49813178181648254,
-0.37096819281578064,
0.10980669409036636,
0.513906717300415,
-0.3173365592956543,
0.3244500756263733,
0.9838190078735352,
-0.22188320755958557,
0.016728155314922333,
0.7255132794380188,
-0.23628661036491394,
0.12529264390468597,
0.6224921345710754,
-0.18882054090499878,
-0.385748028755188,
-0.7323295474052429,
-0.36450132727622986,
0.06062161177396774,
-0.5766796469688416,
-0.20136967301368713,
-0.7856225371360779,
0.016319917514920235,
-0.5421373248100281,
0.2569417655467987,
-0.5013517737388611,
-0.3239874839782715,
0.15773797035217285,
0.39785587787628174,
0.18756186962127686,
0.01775534637272358,
0.43508753180503845,
0.23460562527179718,
-0.6446313261985779,
0.6412336230278015,
0.3505842983722687,
0.23324543237686157,
-0.20346027612686157,
-0.3771519660949707,
0.0131727559491992,
-0.2646946907043457,
-0.39052507281303406,
-0.4495227634906769,
0.3791743516921997,
0.29924309253692627,
0.7654989361763,
0.14266249537467957,
0.28248342871665955,
0.7953677773475647,
-0.7654501795768738,
0.9234789609909058,
0.13296695053577423,
-0.8252880573272705,
0.5385833382606506,
-0.36973342299461365,
0.3609428405761719,
0.6690430045127869,
0.4456246793270111,
-0.46882444620132446,
-0.515263557434082,
-0.2798157334327698,
-0.8901395797729492,
0.7805788516998291,
0.22653819620609283,
0.06478313356637955,
-0.26029035449028015,
0.12941990792751312,
0.339568167924881,
0.47620490193367004,
-0.15912498533725739,
-0.5437986850738525,
-0.2362210750579834,
0.06431508809328079,
0.029141750186681747,
-0.03793499246239662,
-0.27855804562568665,
-0.019562792032957077,
0.6154775619506836,
-0.36291390657424927,
0.4446049630641937,
-0.08522412925958633,
-0.07099337130784988,
0.11129432916641235,
0.23758091032505035,
0.09218750149011612,
0.5569685697555542,
-0.35369932651519775,
-0.2582981586456299,
-0.005156422965228558,
0.012181887403130531,
-0.20900669693946838,
0.34324613213539124,
0.00014967490278650075,
0.18541955947875977,
-0.06273461878299713,
0.7321977019309998,
-0.036802854388952255,
-1.2197977304458618,
0.31438642740249634,
-0.26770463585853577,
-0.046109896153211594,
-0.14245013892650604,
0.2532394528388977,
0.3025861382484436,
0.4266139268875122,
0.4389288127422333,
-0.33605605363845825,
0.48098641633987427,
-0.7234017848968506,
0.052410271018743515,
0.6077713370323181,
-0.047741711139678955,
-0.02222169190645218,
0.48708242177963257,
0.3643004596233368,
-0.4657847583293915,
0.5323019027709961,
-0.2570907771587372,
-0.1323920339345932,
0.3737647533416748,
0.4390096962451935,
0.8202305436134338,
-0.0667867511510849,
0.22329990565776825,
0.4386017620563507,
-0.12566086649894714,
0.09701390564441681,
0.4988507032394409,
-0.3316645920276642,
-0.600102424621582,
-0.452806681394577,
-0.583716630935669,
-0.7659448981285095,
0.038589395582675934,
-0.8976449966430664,
0.08584857732057571,
-0.270054429769516,
-0.4410751163959503,
0.5186152458190918,
0.005491449497640133,
-0.7758747935295105,
0.30897256731987,
-0.0522565059363842,
0.6957327723503113,
-0.2684299051761627,
0.7854400277137756,
0.6314398050308228,
-0.0025850648526102304,
-0.5552327036857605,
-0.13311418890953064,
-0.07530227303504944,
-1.03530752658844,
0.6515594124794006,
-0.037678301334381104,
-0.06504108011722565,
-0.13030436635017395,
-0.28506147861480713,
-0.6894206404685974,
0.8586405515670776,
0.3039878308773041,
-0.7612473964691162,
-0.12046986073255539,
0.5637710690498352,
0.5071392059326172,
-0.6207742691040039,
0.2227834016084671,
0.5340918302536011,
0.21233485639095306,
-0.23341895639896393,
-0.9804873466491699,
0.2911566495895386,
-0.4843023121356964,
0.12225175648927689,
0.1585468202829361,
-0.5764530301094055,
0.6612266898155212,
0.196943998336792,
-0.08537223190069199,
0.039521604776382446,
0.4567950367927551,
0.196530282497406,
0.41219839453697205,
0.5897194147109985,
0.3270588517189026,
0.3905286490917206,
-0.1635022610425949,
0.9084179997444153,
-0.539044201374054,
-0.026808878406882286,
1.47974693775177,
-0.5629488229751587,
0.8692375421524048,
0.6328825354576111,
-0.21310757100582123,
0.039461225271224976,
0.2568441927433014,
-0.10291269421577454,
0.5596485733985901,
0.3406790494918823,
-0.15349780023097992,
-0.3035052716732025,
-0.5861110687255859,
-0.17560608685016632,
0.39241692423820496,
0.36099007725715637,
-0.0978270098567009,
-0.29295235872268677,
-0.10513602942228317,
-0.3197517991065979,
0.17020799219608307,
-0.13514821231365204,
1.036157250404358,
-0.046785108745098114,
-1.1241164207458496,
0.7232469916343689,
-0.051014792174100876,
0.39383378624916077,
-0.5371840596199036,
0.22321723401546478,
-0.2112361639738083,
-0.003347876714542508,
-0.031879737973213196,
-0.5878627896308899,
0.30668410658836365,
0.22520817816257477,
-0.24554267525672913,
-0.423460990190506,
0.3062277138233185,
-0.2728453576564789,
-0.1534424126148224,
0.23770561814308167,
0.7390707731246948,
0.41209676861763,
-0.27047449350357056,
-0.8599532842636108,
0.08092939108610153,
0.00791960209608078,
-0.3722074329853058,
0.43609490990638733,
0.618158757686615,
-0.04858808591961861,
0.7073913216590881,
0.5130707621574402,
-0.05543721467256546,
0.10306911915540695,
0.2951352298259735,
0.9058193564414978,
-0.8204985857009888,
-0.3099122941493988,
-0.28192174434661865,
0.30780714750289917,
-0.22135639190673828,
-0.4544103145599365,
0.7271292209625244,
0.6969848275184631,
0.8543336391448975,
0.07165247201919556,
0.8520951867103577,
-0.16734597086906433,
0.9303804039955139,
-0.3150859773159027,
0.3030965328216553,
-0.6509684920310974,
0.28551626205444336,
-0.10297977179288864,
-0.9441583156585693,
0.22902342677116394,
0.05437331274151802,
-0.08483219891786575,
-0.06250171363353729,
0.6587749123573303,
1.127162218093872,
0.2741827368736267,
-0.0007792558171786368,
0.44385167956352234,
-0.1001255065202713,
0.42727866768836975,
0.38614001870155334,
0.5788969993591309,
-0.42198655009269714,
0.6777215600013733,
-0.39120927453041077,
0.09221173822879791,
-0.5102723240852356,
-0.8415374755859375,
-1.0087746381759644,
-0.6181979775428772,
-0.5559598207473755,
-0.2926885783672333,
0.4932277798652649,
0.9107955694198608,
0.7718644142150879,
-0.8442239165306091,
-0.5421299934387207,
0.0687408298254013,
-0.17523148655891418,
-0.6425408720970154,
-0.18175071477890015,
0.2278183251619339,
-0.5562123656272888,
-0.855883777141571,
0.586183488368988,
0.31801167130470276,
-0.4057912528514862,
0.06008213013410568,
0.20619763433933258,
0.04871490225195885,
0.17983630299568176,
0.658448338508606,
0.34693443775177,
-0.6136846542358398,
0.09701728820800781,
0.13886627554893494,
-0.1715337038040161,
0.16930773854255676,
0.8362683057785034,
-0.6360694766044617,
0.3731659948825836,
0.2555901110172272,
0.8318219184875488,
0.700137734413147,
0.081748366355896,
0.6943816542625427,
-0.8412286639213562,
-0.10155493766069412,
0.5098210573196411,
-0.009092521853744984,
0.2728627324104309,
-0.06030500680208206,
0.5229536890983582,
-0.21486294269561768,
-0.3352903127670288,
-1.0808889865875244,
0.2889707088470459,
-1.387178897857666,
-0.10903330147266388,
0.9540147185325623,
-0.2470085471868515,
-0.18494634330272675,
-0.27528539299964905,
-0.06867760419845581,
0.06689111143350601,
-0.6516212821006775,
0.76836097240448,
0.34217146039009094,
-0.32116028666496277,
-0.011677541770040989,
-0.6917667984962463,
0.5414988398551941,
0.6436043977737427,
-1.1388177871704102,
0.33771786093711853,
0.3701348304748535,
0.2780665159225464,
0.009176506660878658,
0.6943786144256592,
-0.20741164684295654,
0.22061413526535034,
-0.009364939294755459,
0.08929921686649323,
-0.1234460100531578,
0.07192808389663696,
0.5144583582878113,
0.5199782252311707,
0.02616855688393116,
-0.18357226252555847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02925v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02925v2
|
Task Arithmetic can Mitigate Synthetic-to-Real Gap in Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-06-05T04:25:56 | 2024-06-15T15:58:22 |
Hsuan Su, Hua Farn, Fan-Yun Sun, Shang-Tse Chen, Hung-yi Lee
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Synthetic data is widely used in speech recognition due to the availability
of text-to-speech models, which facilitate adapting models to previously unseen
text domains. However, existing methods suffer in performance when they
fine-tune an automatic speech recognition (ASR) model on synthetic data as they
suffer from the distributional shift commonly referred to as the
synthetic-to-real gap. In this paper, we find that task vector arithmetic is
effective at mitigating this gap. Our proposed method, SYN2REAL task vector,
shows an average improvement of 10.03\% improvement in word error rate over
baselines on the SLURP dataset. Additionally, we show that an average of
SYN2REAL task vectors, when we have real speeches from multiple different
domains, can further adapt the original ASR model to perform better on the
target text domain.
|
[
-0.14082475006580353,
-0.7159008383750916,
0.10614931583404541,
0.12006140500307083,
-0.24996355175971985,
0.20620128512382507,
-0.1444743424654007,
-0.7205628752708435,
0.016752388328313828,
0.20144444704055786,
-0.5001057982444763,
-0.04387165606021881,
-0.8338569402694702,
0.00809355266392231,
-0.24348174035549164,
0.5215522050857544,
0.022280501201748848,
0.27185872197151184,
-0.549481213092804,
-0.3058196008205414,
-0.6503220200538635,
-0.5447348952293396,
-0.8307532668113708,
-0.30028125643730164,
0.0702572911977768,
0.3235006630420685,
0.541658341884613,
0.8611743450164795,
0.5954016447067261,
0.39109405875205994,
0.15885749459266663,
0.42671048641204834,
-0.33112987875938416,
0.17067408561706543,
-0.23125481605529785,
-0.613459050655365,
-0.6034751534461975,
-0.16078877449035645,
0.9388564229011536,
0.5643740296363831,
-0.14392735064029694,
0.2982877492904663,
-0.04631125181913376,
1.0287758111953735,
-0.5851624011993408,
0.29620125889778137,
-0.5609205365180969,
0.06848830729722977,
-0.44643622636795044,
-0.20923160016536713,
-0.11151648312807083,
0.081998310983181,
-0.07088786363601685,
-0.9231947064399719,
0.43816399574279785,
0.07778821885585785,
0.5055272579193115,
0.6779872179031372,
-0.08696051687002182,
-0.13689671456813812,
-1.0917363166809082,
0.7181680798530579,
-0.7283424735069275,
0.7045027613639832,
0.29558849334716797,
0.32985919713974,
-0.23923099040985107,
-0.7677664160728455,
-0.9734591245651245,
0.06502534449100494,
0.3066745102405548,
-0.03331264108419418,
-0.4882586598396301,
0.10238607972860336,
0.5126625299453735,
0.08094656467437744,
-0.5682305693626404,
-0.13195151090621948,
-0.7184035181999207,
-0.38332006335258484,
0.6919941902160645,
0.2280968576669693,
0.5120443105697632,
0.04552176594734192,
-0.23527760803699493,
-0.3384318947792053,
-0.6671187281608582,
0.27012795209884644,
0.3073568344116211,
0.42877137660980225,
-0.008314467035233974,
0.828472375869751,
-0.1475464403629303,
0.890353262424469,
-0.051020339131355286,
-0.10108722746372223,
0.47819843888282776,
-0.30699294805526733,
-0.2227775901556015,
0.39141845703125,
0.33649128675460815,
0.32173192501068115,
0.3981710374355316,
0.022875070571899414,
-0.3908887803554535,
0.7440170049667358,
0.4817490577697754,
-0.7559403777122498,
-0.3236940801143646,
0.008756083436310291,
-0.05368509143590927,
0.2531948685646057,
0.04678267985582352,
-0.2683948278427124,
-0.18112784624099731,
-0.8355957865715027,
0.6448575258255005,
-0.3150448799133301,
-0.0959908738732338,
0.10665829479694366,
-0.33310040831565857,
-0.2326086163520813,
0.33588388562202454,
-0.49955427646636963,
0.8145753741264343,
0.9201781749725342,
1.0507328510284424,
-0.2960895597934723,
0.005014491267502308,
-0.9759945273399353,
-0.007618371397256851,
-0.3777823746204376,
0.9452828764915466,
-0.4028664529323578,
-0.3501800000667572,
-0.4064202904701233,
-0.2951962649822235,
-0.42316362261772156,
-0.9147016406059265,
0.6665496230125427,
-0.3328782021999359,
-0.14738401770591736,
-0.10569744557142258,
-0.7009982466697693,
-0.08434941619634628,
-0.0699813961982727,
-0.6668702363967896,
1.1578395366668701,
-0.019344955682754517,
-0.57319575548172,
0.03894716128706932,
-0.6466112732887268,
-0.5745824575424194,
0.11698366701602936,
-0.19105792045593262,
-0.4363684058189392,
0.3207402527332306,
0.26241809129714966,
-0.025192920118570328,
-0.14365163445472717,
-0.16317594051361084,
0.03504517674446106,
-0.5574710965156555,
0.30740392208099365,
-0.32600080966949463,
0.5351312160491943,
0.13858254253864288,
-0.38463836908340454,
0.12341543287038803,
-0.7549702525138855,
0.08700674027204514,
-0.09206615388393402,
-0.05739036947488785,
-0.7564569711685181,
0.26300400495529175,
-0.10794869065284729,
0.4758799970149994,
-0.14170250296592712,
-0.8151106238365173,
-0.0883864238858223,
-1.1210788488388062,
0.31594398617744446,
0.5389294624328613,
-0.04583120346069336,
0.5863932371139526,
-0.49512389302253723,
0.5817588567733765,
0.18438535928726196,
-0.4931960105895996,
0.35713547468185425,
-0.5618205070495605,
-0.9329468011856079,
-0.34805071353912354,
0.5453159809112549,
0.8252028822898865,
-0.8880325555801392,
0.30680254101753235,
-0.4403102993965149,
-0.4685002565383911,
-0.7610254287719727,
0.03367127478122711,
0.41653576493263245,
0.5613155961036682,
0.25704649090766907,
-0.40250125527381897,
-0.5753768086433411,
-0.4728049337863922,
-0.5031632781028748,
-0.10483011603355408,
-0.2301960587501526,
0.25601446628570557,
0.10793517529964447,
-0.10515367239713669,
0.9326192140579224,
-0.5519708395004272,
-0.6101229190826416,
-0.2220875769853592,
0.145385280251503,
-0.051451120525598526,
0.5869818925857544,
0.15710489451885223,
-0.7703980207443237,
-0.3406924903392792,
-0.4567126929759979,
-0.13179978728294373,
-0.2381899356842041,
-0.0021274923346936703,
-0.14849010109901428,
0.2928531765937805,
0.30958831310272217,
-0.8489035964012146,
0.5672999620437622,
0.6172014474868774,
-0.4018652141094208,
0.29779407382011414,
-0.3589513301849365,
-0.021802356466650963,
-0.8571362495422363,
-0.1726468950510025,
0.28691813349723816,
-0.417572557926178,
-0.9521103501319885,
-0.2618456482887268,
0.11295734345912933,
-0.3064604699611664,
-0.5079464316368103,
0.6118624806404114,
-0.14634905755519867,
-0.22548489272594452,
-0.4373890459537506,
0.18823885917663574,
-0.17850527167320251,
0.30936872959136963,
-0.17900364100933075,
1.1893080472946167,
0.4440954029560089,
-0.7164086699485779,
0.24100640416145325,
0.4225553572177887,
-0.08296379446983337,
0.5538669228553772,
-0.8434849381446838,
0.1946423500776291,
-0.13928550481796265,
0.38169464468955994,
-1.1496999263763428,
0.0010227853199467063,
0.2889241874217987,
-0.7647963166236877,
0.4020099341869354,
0.19623970985412598,
-0.2928289473056793,
-0.10384327173233032,
-0.2567700147628784,
0.771404504776001,
0.5762585401535034,
-0.3952091634273529,
0.5319233536720276,
0.7784859538078308,
-0.5030208230018616,
-0.31805554032325745,
-0.434872031211853,
0.0074688284657895565,
0.013607259839773178,
-0.7615984678268433,
0.7973991632461548,
0.10043169558048248,
-0.4276373088359833,
-0.08863920718431473,
-0.5188837051391602,
0.11981286108493805,
-0.31871160864830017,
0.5024303793907166,
0.1826915740966797,
-0.04571836441755295,
0.1424756497144699,
-0.007900963537395,
-0.3626086115837097,
0.31519845128059387,
-0.27954062819480896,
0.3934904932975769,
0.2859967052936554,
-0.17441153526306152,
-0.5100614428520203,
0.08058906346559525,
0.41666826605796814,
-0.2793358862400055,
0.213446244597435,
0.5841342210769653,
-0.789556622505188,
-0.49189844727516174,
-0.3075539171695709,
-0.16825972497463226,
-0.5226042866706848,
0.31473881006240845,
-0.3779861330986023,
-0.6689260601997375,
0.12341412901878357,
-0.0618966780602932,
-0.10673673450946808,
0.6064465045928955,
0.5314825177192688,
-0.14004899561405182,
0.9787462949752808,
0.26280975341796875,
0.1478777825832367,
0.4033917486667633,
-0.35836488008499146,
0.3548770546913147,
-0.9878658652305603,
-0.1220303326845169,
-0.48913002014160156,
-0.5028054118156433,
-0.4623149633407593,
-1.1133910417556763,
0.6483868956565857,
-0.3098379969596863,
0.14900733530521393,
0.2721061706542969,
-0.41379019618034363,
0.042692624032497406,
0.6017484664916992,
0.21942126750946045,
-0.07785972207784653,
0.3453236520290375,
0.10497963428497314,
-0.4476590156555176,
-0.8109471201896667,
-0.029755719006061554,
0.6375086903572083,
0.23753590881824493,
0.3978170156478882,
-0.057003747671842575,
0.5122005939483643,
0.7789360284805298,
-0.19458553194999695,
-0.774882972240448,
0.7019485235214233,
-0.5303471088409424,
-0.2718050181865692,
-0.5669350624084473,
-0.5353339314460754,
-0.7940893173217773,
0.33338695764541626,
-0.34937429428100586,
-0.19609473645687103,
0.1743823140859604,
0.5361717939376831,
-0.3217162787914276,
-0.07127587497234344,
-0.44680842757225037,
0.5337944626808167,
0.12257898598909378,
-0.15944580733776093,
-0.5951354503631592,
-0.5660756826400757,
-0.041215930134058,
-0.015370199456810951,
0.298897385597229,
-0.5177315473556519,
-0.1011604368686676,
1.0687214136123657,
-0.7846252918243408,
0.6854999661445618,
-0.4698600769042969,
0.06834726780653,
0.4658854901790619,
-0.08042497932910919,
0.9494608640670776,
-0.36034008860588074,
-0.08357695490121841,
0.3150682747364044,
-0.28741970658302307,
-0.29197564721107483,
-0.7646466493606567,
0.5172353982925415,
-0.6334235072135925,
-0.4205862879753113,
-0.6333140730857849,
-0.7699402570724487,
-0.49832290410995483,
-0.3074488043785095,
0.08006775379180908,
0.8894436359405518,
0.03234538808465004,
-0.14791324734687805,
0.5416201949119568,
-0.022845309227705002,
0.31909793615341187,
0.30473119020462036,
0.5417982339859009,
-0.6050395369529724,
1.2438328266143799,
0.35369792580604553,
0.32627585530281067,
0.4178706109523773,
0.16497738659381866,
-0.6154649257659912,
-0.5304487943649292,
-0.7533546686172485,
0.04876406490802765,
-0.5119078755378723,
-0.37619903683662415,
-0.7395758032798767,
-0.2370142787694931,
-0.599775493144989,
-0.007107434328645468,
-0.2961469292640686,
-1.213197946548462,
-0.27940258383750916,
0.03005671501159668,
0.32210874557495117,
0.27049773931503296,
-0.0719764232635498,
0.10026009380817413,
-0.8161807060241699,
0.9041106104850769,
0.22525617480278015,
0.0856899693608284,
-0.17211660742759705,
-1.0684324502944946,
-0.08017478883266449,
0.4709464907646179,
-0.007924717850983143,
-0.4739879369735718,
0.7043295502662659,
0.7263973355293274,
0.38691332936286926,
-0.22088223695755005,
0.27786099910736084,
1.1442958116531372,
-0.9150374531745911,
0.5200086236000061,
0.24623361229896545,
-1.0335508584976196,
0.2340916395187378,
-0.04872206971049309,
0.430382639169693,
0.21012374758720398,
-0.02606176771223545,
-0.32170847058296204,
-0.5147159099578857,
-0.44972023367881775,
-1.0339428186416626,
0.7506678104400635,
0.562084436416626,
0.20608137547969818,
0.36564168334007263,
0.05611760914325714,
-0.21212506294250488,
0.12170126289129257,
-0.0654517337679863,
-0.2867390513420105,
-0.08364500105381012,
-0.4078885614871979,
-0.13420900702476501,
-0.11434802412986755,
0.0564706064760685,
-0.621933102607727,
0.6780776381492615,
0.12718252837657928,
0.5153703093528748,
0.17665298283100128,
-0.2111162394285202,
-0.4814254939556122,
0.19804538786411285,
0.8492916822433472,
0.7000144720077515,
0.14324191212654114,
0.31555503606796265,
0.5070434808731079,
-0.933618426322937,
0.2676968574523926,
0.4296788275241852,
-0.07121361792087555,
0.23952031135559082,
0.18060310184955597,
0.8359488844871521,
0.2077205330133438,
-0.8993523716926575,
0.43272635340690613,
0.18039029836654663,
-0.1819969266653061,
-0.36547765135765076,
0.4605275094509125,
-0.046465300023555756,
0.2687739133834839,
0.4950709640979767,
0.5742644667625427,
0.28812551498413086,
-0.27278000116348267,
0.44772687554359436,
0.2724896967411041,
-0.18531478941440582,
-0.25609275698661804,
0.8277255892753601,
0.3123261630535126,
-0.7851234078407288,
0.5871824622154236,
-0.2079795002937317,
-0.5473840832710266,
0.6167994141578674,
0.9286025762557983,
0.7709348201751709,
-0.4298185408115387,
-0.01916814036667347,
0.3640782833099365,
0.027695702388882637,
-0.11258301138877869,
0.5488326549530029,
0.07889652997255325,
-0.6830991506576538,
-0.5497716665267944,
-0.7760389447212219,
-0.30559906363487244,
-0.33574584126472473,
-0.4073450565338135,
0.12123122811317444,
-0.19181357324123383,
-0.19960080087184906,
0.45806896686553955,
0.03313692659139633,
-0.509110689163208,
0.5529657602310181,
0.1915023922920227,
0.679796040058136,
-0.6829584240913391,
0.9560485482215881,
0.6824346780776978,
0.2509964406490326,
-0.6078163385391235,
-0.00037788235931657255,
-0.005891885608434677,
-0.766875147819519,
0.662536084651947,
0.20236316323280334,
-0.35670918226242065,
0.14882536232471466,
0.00942465104162693,
-0.8607134819030762,
0.7920810580253601,
0.24968749284744263,
-0.9500401020050049,
0.07849059998989105,
0.6402825117111206,
0.6798186898231506,
-0.15886440873146057,
-0.5161712169647217,
0.4603794515132904,
0.25251850485801697,
0.2818014323711395,
-0.9127996563911438,
0.10394254326820374,
-0.3218483328819275,
0.19242599606513977,
0.594042181968689,
-0.03735869377851486,
0.5859593152999878,
-0.30279943346977234,
-0.29491955041885376,
-0.30541500449180603,
0.7292944192886353,
0.4855911433696747,
0.7130370736122131,
0.9553196430206299,
0.631331205368042,
0.5790343880653381,
-0.035563874989748,
0.7334622144699097,
-0.26227885484695435,
-0.12273593991994858,
0.9084147214889526,
-0.33213910460472107,
1.029556155204773,
0.3207399547100067,
-0.3312326669692993,
0.05302400887012482,
0.07350388169288635,
0.09338252991437912,
0.4348512291908264,
0.38184353709220886,
-0.5145632028579712,
-0.22336943447589874,
0.002964239800348878,
0.05212817341089249,
0.469583660364151,
0.7080329656600952,
0.10313151776790619,
0.043048832565546036,
0.16866275668144226,
-0.18331624567508698,
0.24630311131477356,
-0.5925376415252686,
0.7869303822517395,
0.22483429312705994,
-0.5391396284103394,
0.7055714130401611,
0.2286948710680008,
0.5480887293815613,
-0.3680416941642761,
-0.4321344792842865,
0.2373305857181549,
0.4425646960735321,
-0.26459231972694397,
-0.3650687336921692,
0.6135858297348022,
-0.022302474826574326,
-0.2113819718360901,
-0.13668808341026306,
1.1433058977127075,
-0.6547166705131531,
-0.8643006086349487,
-0.24192239344120026,
0.20896904170513153,
-0.09506847709417343,
-0.29337742924690247,
-0.7865582704544067,
0.12656821310520172,
-0.16716395318508148,
0.16354812681674957,
0.18141724169254303,
0.24491740763187408,
-0.3066362142562866,
0.5093866586685181,
0.840836763381958,
0.3322864770889282,
0.13830974698066711,
-0.10071302950382233,
0.7401677966117859,
-0.53035968542099,
-0.7100435495376587,
-0.7624253034591675,
0.4266704022884369,
-0.0003622643416747451,
-0.04545266553759575,
0.8002103567123413,
0.666714072227478,
0.7716937065124512,
-0.039295636117458344,
0.617353081703186,
-0.14876960217952728,
0.8608351945877075,
-0.4444410502910614,
0.4425792396068573,
-0.44104596972465515,
0.1378762423992157,
-0.15613262355327606,
-0.7430601119995117,
-0.34154215455055237,
0.7631915211677551,
-0.012482608668506145,
-0.20653608441352844,
0.4399193823337555,
0.8963016867637634,
-0.1520056277513504,
-0.23963427543640137,
0.3425075113773346,
0.00828209612518549,
0.08272368460893631,
0.27003201842308044,
0.4116106331348419,
-0.5710551738739014,
0.28159117698669434,
-0.3070688247680664,
-0.043339770287275314,
-0.1533121019601822,
-0.471822589635849,
-0.5966700315475464,
-0.5232912302017212,
-0.48821961879730225,
-0.45296379923820496,
0.4593033790588379,
1.2069510221481323,
0.5695664286613464,
-0.8662950992584229,
-0.19833867251873016,
-0.15664972364902496,
-0.2551553547382355,
-0.6108128428459167,
-0.1514545977115631,
0.391353964805603,
-0.3747387230396271,
-0.7757712602615356,
0.5433422923088074,
0.31814876198768616,
0.05359313264489174,
0.17008954286575317,
-0.157166987657547,
0.16039413213729858,
0.4161096513271332,
0.6418353319168091,
0.24847152829170227,
-0.40727344155311584,
-0.05724464729428291,
-0.0032454831525683403,
0.069803386926651,
0.20482586324214935,
1.015914797782898,
-0.7675126791000366,
0.6200385689735413,
0.7693519592285156,
0.6641431450843811,
0.5443267822265625,
0.4501991271972656,
0.8267517685890198,
-0.994268000125885,
0.4548000693321228,
0.4516385793685913,
0.15187668800354004,
0.4399198591709137,
-0.3102429509162903,
0.4389743506908417,
0.5024206042289734,
-0.45358604192733765,
-0.8471314311027527,
-0.048463374376297,
-1.1167347431182861,
-0.00551724573597312,
1.3043209314346313,
0.11449344456195831,
-0.06927141547203064,
-0.20452895760536194,
-0.25695016980171204,
0.5106993913650513,
-0.37994831800460815,
0.8540939688682556,
0.18661513924598694,
-0.3268383741378784,
0.1274830549955368,
-0.7263386249542236,
0.7745130658149719,
0.4215853214263916,
-0.7652842998504639,
0.2004604935646057,
0.639212965965271,
0.24877609312534332,
-0.02975141815841198,
0.6185399293899536,
0.08204352855682373,
0.4613863229751587,
0.08294276893138885,
-0.20031596720218658,
-0.2115413397550583,
-0.3716944456100464,
-0.2973061501979828,
-0.08444695174694061,
-0.13264679908752441,
-0.6185644268989563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02924v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02924v1
|
Pruner-Zero: Evolving Symbolic Pruning Metric from scratch for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-05T04:25:23 | 2024-06-05T04:25:23 |
Peijie Dong, Lujun Li, Zhenheng Tang, Xiang Liu, Xinglin Pan, Qiang Wang, Xiaowen Chu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE
|
Despite the remarkable capabilities, Large Language Models (LLMs) face
deployment challenges due to their extensive size. Pruning methods drop a
subset of weights to accelerate, but many of them require retraining, which is
prohibitively expensive and computationally demanding. Recently, post-training
pruning approaches introduced novel metrics, enabling the pruning of LLMs
without retraining. However, these metrics require the involvement of human
experts and tedious trial and error. To efficiently identify superior pruning
metrics, we develop an automatic framework for searching symbolic pruning
metrics using genetic programming. In particular, we devise an elaborate search
space encompassing the existing pruning metrics to discover the potential
symbolic pruning metric. We propose an opposing operation simplification
strategy to increase the diversity of the population. In this way, Pruner-Zero
allows auto-generation of symbolic pruning metrics. Based on the searched
results, we explore the correlation between pruning metrics and performance
after pruning and summarize some principles. Extensive experiments on LLaMA and
LLaMA-2 on language modeling and zero-shot tasks demonstrate that our
Pruner-Zero obtains superior performance than SOTA post-training pruning
methods. Code at: \url{https://github.com/pprp/Pruner-Zero}.
|
[
-0.2699490189552307,
-0.7157043814659119,
0.5360898971557617,
0.2431422919034958,
-0.49808040261268616,
0.3452691435813904,
-0.4052791893482208,
-0.21699108183383942,
0.3505212366580963,
0.1432211995124817,
-0.8230394124984741,
-0.5467888712882996,
-0.7357519865036011,
0.2360946089029312,
-0.340721070766449,
0.940631628036499,
0.06600437313318253,
-0.09995047748088837,
-0.0757598876953125,
-0.3181430697441101,
-0.45570090413093567,
-0.6010554432868958,
-0.43895018100738525,
-0.13079380989074707,
0.4642748534679413,
0.5626298189163208,
0.6975810527801514,
1.01908278465271,
0.3813905715942383,
0.27661800384521484,
-0.30033281445503235,
0.12732382118701935,
-0.7438981533050537,
0.17236852645874023,
0.1358901858329773,
-0.5084401369094849,
-0.1918814778327942,
-0.2884993553161621,
0.7048379182815552,
0.584183931350708,
-0.38480955362319946,
0.3431303799152374,
-0.2607998847961426,
0.43503516912460327,
-0.5392897725105286,
0.03324929624795914,
-0.7717816233634949,
0.2453666776418686,
-0.45132118463516235,
-0.4001740515232086,
0.07635694742202759,
-0.5987833738327026,
-0.38361141085624695,
-0.5717772245407104,
0.45622947812080383,
-0.15152662992477417,
0.7776003479957581,
0.5026971101760864,
-0.2557077705860138,
0.31643667817115784,
-0.9716334939002991,
0.9893867373466492,
-0.7922654747962952,
0.4544236361980438,
0.027895618230104446,
0.2580752670764923,
-0.24347342550754547,
-0.27224117517471313,
-0.5047045350074768,
-0.49455979466438293,
0.14905360341072083,
-0.16526120901107788,
-0.07672788947820663,
-0.08409567922353745,
0.2904045879840851,
0.37064114212989807,
-0.5459744930267334,
0.13951028883457184,
-0.5928375124931335,
-0.036116160452365875,
0.6924563646316528,
0.02794346958398819,
0.37164491415023804,
0.19039322435855865,
0.029262898489832878,
-0.27979886531829834,
-0.9840813279151917,
-0.3695886433124542,
0.4803893268108368,
-0.07115831971168518,
0.20314309000968933,
0.5161067247390747,
-0.2704179286956787,
0.567334771156311,
-0.34978511929512024,
-0.039987340569496155,
0.41466304659843445,
-0.2940116226673126,
0.006585690658539534,
0.05448317900300026,
0.812294065952301,
0.10948837548494339,
0.45115429162979126,
-0.2767564654350281,
-0.18023721873760223,
0.41637444496154785,
0.2770782709121704,
-0.7271816730499268,
-0.2976365387439728,
-0.0069312164559960365,
-0.19215618073940277,
-0.3729461431503296,
-0.07466450333595276,
-0.43115735054016113,
-0.10702063888311386,
-0.17439314723014832,
0.00063504179706797,
-0.5445798635482788,
-0.463214635848999,
0.27148762345314026,
-0.26652005314826965,
0.33194538950920105,
0.1956404447555542,
-0.5990170240402222,
0.32439446449279785,
0.9811924695968628,
0.9951248168945312,
-0.12917092442512512,
-0.30837228894233704,
-0.27264952659606934,
0.024269750341773033,
-0.5096985697746277,
0.4375353157520294,
-0.518977701663971,
-0.4889334738254547,
-0.33283379673957825,
-0.012112242169678211,
-0.01768355444073677,
-0.65833979845047,
0.6262905597686768,
-0.23371396958827972,
-0.12035128474235535,
-0.10939399898052216,
-0.3275913894176483,
-0.3884907066822052,
0.13246631622314453,
-0.42804548144340515,
1.1295098066329956,
0.18732602894306183,
-0.45965710282325745,
0.4236043095588684,
-0.6394909620285034,
-0.6046797633171082,
0.25276827812194824,
-0.24383941292762756,
-0.7055333852767944,
0.5634436011314392,
0.11736368387937546,
0.26308196783065796,
-0.4914921820163727,
0.5506693124771118,
-0.5476014614105225,
-0.6280879974365234,
-0.21705186367034912,
-0.07782882452011108,
0.946771502494812,
0.1416262686252594,
-0.42138561606407166,
0.24841588735580444,
-0.4770071804523468,
-0.002538512460887432,
0.6878862977027893,
0.016906648874282837,
-0.336713045835495,
0.2765360176563263,
-0.3446607291698456,
0.15840505063533783,
0.25193122029304504,
-0.8334181904792786,
0.3908843994140625,
-0.5787588357925415,
0.5761163830757141,
0.6423702239990234,
-0.03266915678977966,
0.2787492573261261,
-0.2982034981250763,
0.6596940755844116,
-0.1723661720752716,
0.36035284399986267,
-0.05434209108352661,
-0.3139033019542694,
-0.9356385469436646,
-0.01956835575401783,
0.20323139429092407,
0.5712147951126099,
-0.29968884587287903,
0.6954733729362488,
-0.6127310991287231,
-0.7416495680809021,
-0.4920639991760254,
0.4259810149669647,
0.3139503002166748,
0.051525309681892395,
0.1869119554758072,
-0.7812319397926331,
-0.48058417439460754,
-0.8728740811347961,
-0.18087178468704224,
-0.21250435709953308,
-0.1676076054573059,
0.3475310206413269,
0.3339608907699585,
-0.05576013773679733,
1.0102200508117676,
-0.7761061787605286,
-0.26579615473747253,
-0.3806133568286896,
0.1269812285900116,
0.18617501854896545,
0.47110965847969055,
0.5515587329864502,
-0.5352662801742554,
-0.11143005639314651,
0.15284043550491333,
-0.7849343419075012,
-0.22655479609966278,
-0.11480211466550827,
0.06345435231924057,
-0.12610435485839844,
0.4741426408290863,
-0.677688479423523,
0.04595606401562691,
0.5272282958030701,
-0.053336646407842636,
0.7494164109230042,
-0.17725110054016113,
-0.3004877269268036,
-0.6291768550872803,
0.13944830000400543,
0.14282862842082977,
-0.018954766914248466,
-0.5782284140586853,
0.4267348349094391,
-0.03128764033317566,
-0.11386779695749283,
-0.3782670795917511,
0.4190833270549774,
-0.6266820430755615,
-0.11526495218276978,
0.06680671870708466,
-0.1918962448835373,
-0.4162912666797638,
0.6271488666534424,
0.10123185068368912,
0.578166127204895,
0.5234338045120239,
-0.4234609603881836,
0.20305921137332916,
0.09977070987224579,
-0.06827610731124878,
0.04886866360902786,
-0.7994048595428467,
0.27157866954803467,
-0.1310989260673523,
0.21271218359470367,
-0.6230403184890747,
0.07942681759595871,
0.31950414180755615,
-0.373140811920166,
0.23006948828697205,
-0.16600732505321503,
-0.558984100818634,
-0.46807926893234253,
-0.5219646692276001,
0.44949012994766235,
0.6848503947257996,
-0.22321705520153046,
0.16962271928787231,
0.3400081694126129,
-0.565904438495636,
-0.1676047146320343,
-0.23972032964229584,
0.3339952230453491,
-0.35803619027137756,
-0.5214213728904724,
0.1836540400981903,
-0.07815942168235779,
0.07364806532859802,
-0.2395903617143631,
-0.4881710708141327,
0.061314210295677185,
0.40778666734695435,
0.13582397997379303,
0.11003977060317993,
-0.25463947653770447,
-0.01677762158215046,
0.09020735323429108,
-0.21759139001369476,
0.08624681830406189,
-0.404262900352478,
0.6655151844024658,
-0.03044235333800316,
-0.5771453976631165,
-0.3353104293346405,
0.020295219495892525,
0.529869556427002,
-0.6363744139671326,
0.7374217510223389,
0.43090343475341797,
-0.058436281979084015,
-0.29671794176101685,
-0.5441049933433533,
-0.3653859794139862,
-0.48802632093429565,
0.5224185585975647,
-0.11840730160474777,
-1.0895534753799438,
0.04072580859065056,
-0.5092268586158752,
0.3538271486759186,
0.22524526715278625,
0.37623560428619385,
0.15982449054718018,
1.1424680948257446,
0.979453444480896,
-0.14626048505306244,
0.5957282781600952,
-0.20695704221725464,
0.400276243686676,
-0.5188655853271484,
-0.08922716975212097,
-0.6461969614028931,
-0.5090228915214539,
-0.5280844569206238,
-0.5603664517402649,
0.3690641224384308,
0.22307279706001282,
-0.30908459424972534,
0.6146106719970703,
-0.8489592671394348,
0.4792357087135315,
0.49123525619506836,
-0.26336318254470825,
0.15388454496860504,
0.14501963555812836,
0.26008081436157227,
-0.007875045761466026,
-0.8185761570930481,
-0.31660231947898865,
0.871953010559082,
0.4041742980480194,
0.5095339417457581,
-0.0591004304587841,
0.9326702952384949,
-0.11238045990467072,
0.5720540881156921,
-0.7766602039337158,
0.7898443937301636,
-0.20825931429862976,
-0.14907747507095337,
-0.3411298096179962,
-0.7854927182197571,
-0.8656479716300964,
0.18214201927185059,
-0.026808788999915123,
-0.6654911041259766,
0.0417548231780529,
0.24191440641880035,
-0.224140465259552,
0.2049347162246704,
-0.5405305027961731,
0.9481986165046692,
-0.7261512279510498,
0.1311953216791153,
-0.36791616678237915,
-0.6447649002075195,
0.4731052815914154,
-0.38953685760498047,
-0.008617709390819073,
-0.20973025262355804,
-0.15776284039020538,
0.835677981376648,
-0.44765299558639526,
0.6382301449775696,
-0.22155046463012695,
-0.029420122504234314,
-0.05353999510407448,
0.5850621461868286,
0.5372967720031738,
-0.40862247347831726,
0.06489289551973343,
0.5582301616668701,
-0.11284931004047394,
-0.21917268633842468,
-0.6293411254882812,
0.6439753770828247,
-0.7881104946136475,
-0.7586480975151062,
-0.22892439365386963,
-0.37623804807662964,
-0.15121851861476898,
0.18813148140907288,
-0.15220613777637482,
-0.16898062825202942,
-0.2078000158071518,
0.3950567841529846,
0.34775590896606445,
-0.4506542682647705,
0.25158244371414185,
0.4823899567127228,
-0.03236135095357895,
-0.11095210164785385,
1.3507033586502075,
0.09082319587469101,
0.06395294517278671,
0.23404958844184875,
0.3804110884666443,
-0.05252091959118843,
-0.7724769115447998,
-0.38134363293647766,
0.47141706943511963,
-0.028068561106920242,
-0.26809245347976685,
-0.5786113739013672,
-0.314353346824646,
-0.08459655940532684,
-0.059596605598926544,
-0.28487932682037354,
-0.5929538607597351,
-0.0967036560177803,
-0.18221840262413025,
0.49541863799095154,
0.7009865641593933,
0.08992043137550354,
0.5813162922859192,
-0.846360445022583,
0.17552520334720612,
-0.08988327533006668,
0.3204079270362854,
-0.04237617179751396,
-0.3223169445991516,
0.10482493042945862,
0.11166767030954361,
-0.41968101263046265,
-0.8279549479484558,
0.65235435962677,
0.46016761660575867,
0.3660486340522766,
0.26411888003349304,
-0.10506697744131088,
0.7027437686920166,
-0.506558895111084,
0.5066705942153931,
0.3647436201572418,
-0.7317590117454529,
0.4716021418571472,
-0.41408321261405945,
0.3694988489151001,
0.3290822505950928,
0.337524950504303,
-0.7656724452972412,
-0.6272237300872803,
-0.6950147747993469,
-1.0750430822372437,
0.7333353161811829,
0.27617356181144714,
0.0871814489364624,
0.13102908432483673,
0.21441496908664703,
-0.06770700961351395,
0.3629903793334961,
-0.5491399168968201,
-0.17127743363380432,
-0.15880918502807617,
-0.10630517452955246,
-0.39215463399887085,
-0.14921218156814575,
-0.14055903255939484,
-0.36916300654411316,
0.5500831007957458,
-0.08807502686977386,
0.02519652619957924,
-0.2289813607931137,
-0.1500885784626007,
-0.224081888794899,
0.24943841993808746,
0.3951367139816284,
0.4750271141529083,
-0.05031483620405197,
-0.1610380858182907,
0.3270416855812073,
-0.3603634536266327,
0.33765238523483276,
0.07231350988149643,
-0.3659477233886719,
0.07846395671367645,
0.2051602154970169,
0.7181820273399353,
0.1505584418773651,
-0.7134929895401001,
0.45423367619514465,
0.03649572655558586,
-0.26751258969306946,
-0.23448675870895386,
0.26674166321754456,
0.12716300785541534,
-0.23657791316509247,
0.2577170431613922,
-0.061688121408224106,
-0.1586875319480896,
-0.2633584439754486,
0.23382851481437683,
0.49741071462631226,
-0.26393985748291016,
-0.37749019265174866,
0.5177865624427795,
0.17647813260555267,
-0.5591176748275757,
0.7205774784088135,
-0.33638036251068115,
-0.5892602205276489,
0.7656665444374084,
0.39749035239219666,
1.0018119812011719,
-0.2638729214668274,
0.38779115676879883,
0.27639418840408325,
0.5356138944625854,
-0.1584368199110031,
0.07341095060110092,
-0.2848280370235443,
-0.6025881767272949,
-0.6096358299255371,
-0.9553077816963196,
-0.048008181154727936,
0.0001435063168173656,
-0.26335054636001587,
0.21648168563842773,
-0.7328885793685913,
0.09033999592065811,
-0.23308390378952026,
-0.055641788989305496,
-0.5117815136909485,
0.05054681375622749,
0.01778290420770645,
0.9375908374786377,
-0.921467661857605,
0.8141568899154663,
0.6391106843948364,
-0.1282922625541687,
-0.8406178951263428,
-0.21656650304794312,
0.2641964852809906,
-0.7604725360870361,
0.5733755826950073,
0.17447325587272644,
-0.14797371625900269,
0.11553839594125748,
-0.3523489832878113,
-0.8198092579841614,
0.9826754331588745,
0.7657445669174194,
-1.1221845149993896,
-0.025834962725639343,
0.19159963726997375,
0.5851514935493469,
0.12887386977672577,
0.16457128524780273,
0.7218764424324036,
0.45268023014068604,
0.17058852314949036,
-0.9911819100379944,
0.07429971545934677,
-0.344180703163147,
0.13560441136360168,
0.7326430678367615,
-0.6473268866539001,
0.5893309116363525,
-0.2016284018754959,
-0.46814441680908203,
0.2053537666797638,
0.38530999422073364,
0.4300103187561035,
-0.020172985270619392,
0.6855355501174927,
0.8571789264678955,
0.3986586332321167,
-0.1878858506679535,
0.9556983113288879,
-0.5435453057289124,
0.320587694644928,
0.82403963804245,
-0.32121187448501587,
0.5944176912307739,
0.4456384778022766,
-0.20249879360198975,
0.27172762155532837,
0.581642746925354,
-0.1785358041524887,
0.056123286485672,
0.5220702290534973,
-0.19295181334018707,
-0.30906400084495544,
-0.2879314124584198,
-0.3027117848396301,
0.29711011052131653,
0.26922115683555603,
0.049799785017967224,
-0.33753153681755066,
-0.511853039264679,
0.17560641467571259,
-0.20432725548744202,
0.04784884676337242,
0.7612796425819397,
0.23248796164989471,
-0.5163239240646362,
0.6638004779815674,
0.22492913901805878,
0.8280492424964905,
-0.9313700199127197,
-0.12124539911746979,
-0.3937215805053711,
0.2077626734972,
-0.19447821378707886,
-0.4171358048915863,
0.4166676998138428,
-0.06752628087997437,
0.3301803469657898,
-0.5304822325706482,
0.5041373372077942,
-0.2151603251695633,
-0.6381949186325073,
0.2818388044834137,
0.665594756603241,
0.2079106569290161,
-0.09512513875961304,
-0.6849530935287476,
0.16815808415412903,
0.027257191017270088,
-0.20778562128543854,
0.37430137395858765,
0.2892759144306183,
-0.41452839970588684,
0.8821248412132263,
0.999169111251831,
0.5016222596168518,
-0.027223030105233192,
-0.06967908889055252,
0.8085461854934692,
-0.6921637654304504,
-0.4026113748550415,
-0.9763671159744263,
-0.05123860388994217,
-0.053966570645570755,
-0.3043527603149414,
0.793483316898346,
0.5866316556930542,
0.9945284128189087,
0.018204977735877037,
0.522436261177063,
-0.17723985016345978,
0.2674953043460846,
0.055572547018527985,
0.7421177625656128,
-0.7723777890205383,
0.13058122992515564,
-0.18264783918857574,
-1.1520782709121704,
-0.3859352469444275,
0.6311789751052856,
-0.3466692268848419,
0.09939883649349213,
0.39822614192962646,
1.1540223360061646,
-0.2339213788509369,
-0.2018803507089615,
0.16409428417682648,
0.33879053592681885,
0.3278661072254181,
0.46770575642585754,
0.6652463674545288,
0.18541397154331207,
0.7021405100822449,
-0.1668696403503418,
-0.2635743319988251,
-0.046011801809072495,
-0.8831836581230164,
-0.24075724184513092,
-0.23255306482315063,
-0.3688269853591919,
0.2896125316619873,
0.2657485604286194,
0.6043014526367188,
0.8569231033325195,
-0.6518554091453552,
-0.5141582489013672,
-0.40526309609413147,
-0.09654771536588669,
-0.37242579460144043,
-0.22123274207115173,
0.042991455644369125,
0.02469576522707939,
-0.34599918127059937,
0.4339863657951355,
0.46018674969673157,
-0.16254198551177979,
-0.3212989866733551,
-0.2283632904291153,
-0.006774044595658779,
-0.15226709842681885,
0.2716909348964691,
0.8224644064903259,
-0.575616717338562,
-0.03930710628628731,
-0.07384604215621948,
0.318234384059906,
-0.00903171394020319,
0.9630777835845947,
-0.7969405651092529,
0.10738999396562576,
0.30003654956817627,
0.6968453526496887,
0.4123029410839081,
0.06122336909174919,
0.8982120156288147,
-0.9203680753707886,
0.24026302993297577,
0.4523976445198059,
0.23661531507968903,
0.44446632266044617,
-0.09204127639532089,
0.5545380711555481,
0.3847106695175171,
-0.31583061814308167,
-0.9519957304000854,
0.28489649295806885,
-0.5023022294044495,
-0.2816917300224304,
1.0664910078048706,
0.0420343279838562,
-0.2806791663169861,
0.1869320124387741,
-0.2527754008769989,
0.30215004086494446,
-0.3374423384666443,
0.8319522738456726,
0.21493805944919586,
0.14232777059078217,
-0.27729156613349915,
-0.4542878270149231,
0.2992921769618988,
0.7853504419326782,
-0.6758560538291931,
0.09695960581302643,
0.46882644295692444,
0.45553064346313477,
0.14261628687381744,
0.4977899491786957,
-0.01257481798529625,
0.22860190272331238,
-0.24457421898841858,
0.18801932036876678,
-0.2936915159225464,
-0.4472217261791229,
-0.3979569971561432,
0.10805363953113556,
0.2566123604774475,
-0.030619807541370392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02921v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02921v2
|
Text Injection for Neural Contextual Biasing
| 2024-06-05T04:20:17 | 2024-06-11T04:11:56 |
Zhong Meng, Zelin Wu, Rohit Prabhavalkar, Cal Peyser, Weiran Wang, Nanxin Chen, Tara N. Sainath, Bhuvana Ramabhadran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE, eess.AS
|
Neural contextual biasing effectively improves automatic speech recognition
(ASR) for crucial phrases within a speaker's context, particularly those that
are infrequent in the training data. This work proposes contextual text
injection (CTI) to enhance contextual ASR. CTI leverages not only the paired
speech-text data, but also a much larger corpus of unpaired text to optimize
the ASR model and its biasing component. Unpaired text is converted into
speech-like representations and used to guide the model's attention towards
relevant bias phrases. Moreover, we introduce a contextual text-injected (CTI)
minimum word error rate (MWER) training, which minimizes the expected WER
caused by contextual biasing when unpaired text is injected into the model.
Experiments show that CTI with 100 billion text sentences can achieve up to
43.3% relative WER reduction from a strong neural biasing model. CTI-MWER
provides a further relative improvement of 23.5%.
|
[
-0.13173554837703705,
-0.5848032832145691,
0.33467376232147217,
0.15567506849765778,
-0.3754682242870331,
-0.2054470181465149,
-0.433622270822525,
-0.4193996489048004,
-0.08107956498861313,
0.38923072814941406,
-0.2194451540708542,
-0.3092495799064636,
-0.5807282328605652,
0.0788617953658104,
-0.5790386199951172,
0.755756676197052,
0.270815372467041,
0.5353723168373108,
-0.06438149511814117,
-0.04486158490180969,
-0.7803491353988647,
-0.6623554825782776,
-0.762788712978363,
-0.5399632453918457,
0.2544783055782318,
0.0480257086455822,
0.25076359510421753,
0.6942523717880249,
0.24391868710517883,
0.329283207654953,
-0.4328031539916992,
-0.021845277398824692,
-0.10698118060827255,
-0.08960184454917908,
-0.21861740946769714,
-0.4300238788127899,
-0.11433227360248566,
0.004235383588820696,
0.547285795211792,
0.6391211748123169,
0.046310629695653915,
-0.3314144015312195,
0.3640899062156677,
0.558279812335968,
-0.9306604862213135,
-0.19320480525493622,
-0.6902959942817688,
0.15834496915340424,
-0.15578636527061462,
-0.3778384029865265,
-0.4709879159927368,
-0.1253727674484253,
0.6545145511627197,
-0.3534829616546631,
0.13912387192249298,
-0.18793901801109314,
0.4780331254005432,
0.5496826171875,
-0.7196217179298401,
-0.19102445244789124,
-0.5815201997756958,
0.7787336111068726,
-0.688308596611023,
0.3755590319633484,
0.33074694871902466,
0.039141979068517685,
0.0467856228351593,
-0.5787996649742126,
-0.5978813171386719,
-0.05122330039739609,
-0.2463751882314682,
0.13474641740322113,
-0.30071231722831726,
0.3435104787349701,
0.2577168643474579,
0.04604266583919525,
-0.3236859142780304,
-0.07199256122112274,
-0.17665663361549377,
-0.2676924169063568,
0.41881346702575684,
-0.04942910373210907,
0.48227766156196594,
-0.22654235363006592,
-0.26961031556129456,
-0.013927338644862175,
-0.6015351414680481,
-0.1165027841925621,
0.17604303359985352,
0.4473171830177307,
0.12782172858715057,
0.40389692783355713,
-0.13736702501773834,
0.9198092222213745,
0.35901331901550293,
0.08445664495229721,
0.1782713681459427,
-0.47393953800201416,
-0.32807913422584534,
0.4899664521217346,
0.7801904082298279,
0.5232142210006714,
0.4569716155529022,
-0.1921640932559967,
-0.09890100359916687,
0.2285890132188797,
0.34307438135147095,
-0.8361369371414185,
0.035511408001184464,
0.013390752486884594,
-0.3821849822998047,
-0.36055612564086914,
0.10603725910186768,
-0.6335719227790833,
-0.4573443531990051,
-0.17808347940444946,
0.445169597864151,
-0.6124387979507446,
0.0561019629240036,
-0.04701607674360275,
-0.6254924535751343,
0.14186765253543854,
0.08363077789545059,
-0.8036760687828064,
0.22537308931350708,
0.3424793779850006,
0.7878307104110718,
-0.396606981754303,
-0.0995841771364212,
-0.5867757201194763,
0.33856070041656494,
-0.20692774653434753,
0.8727057576179504,
-0.5895857214927673,
-0.550369918346405,
0.2957035005092621,
-0.14825649559497833,
-0.10408095270395279,
-0.6869228482246399,
0.5769476890563965,
-0.4231652617454529,
0.3009932339191437,
-0.22826354205608368,
-0.5393363237380981,
0.042895615100860596,
0.11475943773984909,
-0.37176355719566345,
0.6917526721954346,
-0.32032474875450134,
-0.6609793901443481,
0.5662229657173157,
-1.0426304340362549,
-0.7025042772293091,
-0.15743891894817352,
-0.27921220660209656,
-0.11714734882116318,
0.07020197063684464,
0.43702536821365356,
0.21326395869255066,
-0.0019624221604317427,
0.47149336338043213,
0.12473169714212418,
-0.4423520565032959,
0.4175925850868225,
-0.7126078009605408,
0.6918603181838989,
0.15678957104682922,
-0.640230655670166,
0.23073209822177887,
-0.6437478065490723,
0.05703214555978775,
-0.306172251701355,
-0.4429413676261902,
-0.7050735354423523,
-0.13276492059230804,
0.8232986330986023,
-0.008925040252506733,
-0.02450481988489628,
-0.5746880173683167,
-0.14096994698047638,
-0.9542538523674011,
0.6853793263435364,
0.5937255024909973,
0.026042897254228592,
0.9060326218605042,
-0.0975634977221489,
0.011941516771912575,
0.31645262241363525,
-0.29476678371429443,
-0.19684143364429474,
-0.326565146446228,
-0.6471991539001465,
-0.09825956076383591,
0.4458766281604767,
0.7573363780975342,
-0.90752774477005,
0.6385018229484558,
-0.17827758193016052,
-0.07003384083509445,
-0.16965584456920624,
-0.04621469974517822,
0.8313210606575012,
0.7222526669502258,
0.3476454019546509,
-0.15660788118839264,
-0.7657248377799988,
-0.9472233653068542,
-0.5254476070404053,
0.1811220943927765,
-0.5075000524520874,
0.286047101020813,
0.09637042880058289,
-0.3860480785369873,
1.119483470916748,
-0.4032317101955414,
-0.6108512282371521,
-0.1894482970237732,
0.17122602462768555,
-0.01772972382605076,
0.6499722599983215,
0.32431671023368835,
-0.815157413482666,
-0.648621141910553,
-0.12147662043571472,
-0.43597644567489624,
-0.25380751490592957,
-0.09533733874559402,
0.04463546350598335,
0.2828355133533478,
0.5539186000823975,
-0.34071001410484314,
0.7145837545394897,
0.267173171043396,
-0.40463411808013916,
-0.13755472004413605,
-0.2843918800354004,
0.24635450541973114,
-1.27459716796875,
0.12403831630945206,
0.2982027232646942,
-0.1977246105670929,
-1.1084098815917969,
-0.3085739314556122,
0.03761528059840202,
0.0075225611217319965,
-0.5851938724517822,
0.6815292835235596,
-0.4724135398864746,
0.10138528794050217,
-0.5807066559791565,
0.24024519324302673,
-0.06841617822647095,
0.18002595007419586,
0.20857800543308258,
1.2231063842773438,
0.4393713176250458,
-0.6327412128448486,
-0.1477201282978058,
0.517426609992981,
-0.30489665269851685,
0.5157096982002258,
-0.7670407295227051,
0.2977012097835541,
-0.012018322013318539,
0.4959779679775238,
-0.6588864922523499,
-0.08890435099601746,
-0.037065327167510986,
-0.47934338450431824,
0.40256449580192566,
0.01508217304944992,
-0.07240252941846848,
-0.08663659542798996,
-0.19698864221572876,
0.6743121147155762,
0.42122766375541687,
-0.8029877543449402,
0.7318743467330933,
0.5457009673118591,
0.22821606695652008,
-0.8273732662200928,
-1.041455864906311,
0.2871077358722687,
-0.17775198817253113,
-0.4135729968547821,
0.8523036241531372,
-0.05060765519738197,
-0.1220613494515419,
-0.2321220189332962,
-0.11894676089286804,
-0.4428764581680298,
-0.365898460149765,
0.21894866228103638,
0.0399470254778862,
-0.07748430222272873,
0.029402948915958405,
0.1824735850095749,
-0.23843717575073242,
-0.13821332156658173,
-0.38890644907951355,
0.5817368626594543,
0.155905082821846,
0.0201905257999897,
-1.0033549070358276,
0.4327861964702606,
0.3072386384010315,
0.11331969499588013,
0.3504268527030945,
0.5403892397880554,
-0.4918070435523987,
0.15289707481861115,
-0.7719764709472656,
-0.30481934547424316,
-0.4987884759902954,
0.45275354385375977,
-0.31927555799484253,
-0.7197426557540894,
0.13268963992595673,
0.16177013516426086,
-0.3845823407173157,
0.10371189564466476,
0.27870309352874756,
0.04448062181472778,
1.1899586915969849,
0.4989410936832428,
-0.5386108756065369,
0.964148223400116,
-0.21884089708328247,
-0.00032767478842288256,
-0.912031352519989,
0.06337092816829681,
-0.4022797644138336,
-0.2504119575023651,
-0.4822797477245331,
-0.5172090530395508,
0.28487759828567505,
-0.3157925009727478,
-0.14195504784584045,
0.06149845942854881,
-0.8165075182914734,
0.6949689984321594,
0.8274540305137634,
0.3827306926250458,
0.07651980966329575,
-0.09163621813058853,
0.1483442336320877,
-0.1988600641489029,
-0.6236932873725891,
-0.35750871896743774,
1.1086362600326538,
0.07410432398319244,
0.44599804282188416,
-0.15705078840255737,
0.3993220031261444,
0.31384745240211487,
0.24874521791934967,
-0.9331128597259521,
0.3560955822467804,
-0.4142175614833832,
-0.5652649402618408,
-0.0886673852801323,
-0.3122875988483429,
-0.7919684052467346,
-0.11696320027112961,
-0.2808119058609009,
-0.8186801075935364,
0.46515676379203796,
0.5722907781600952,
-0.5485001802444458,
0.07759557664394379,
-0.8515844941139221,
0.553512692451477,
0.10595069825649261,
-0.2635047733783722,
-0.16676515340805054,
-0.739582359790802,
-0.029170963913202286,
0.1589413285255432,
-0.23814179003238678,
0.5323179960250854,
-0.16554036736488342,
0.8647999167442322,
-0.3015900254249573,
0.8927444219589233,
-0.5267954468727112,
0.30562824010849,
0.20698320865631104,
-0.4393210709095001,
0.44460371136665344,
-0.07859095185995102,
-0.09414657950401306,
0.3112570643424988,
-0.20166847109794617,
-0.18440744280815125,
-0.6682759523391724,
0.6283332109451294,
-0.6310456991195679,
-0.5012339949607849,
-0.5067681074142456,
-0.6793322563171387,
-0.33083951473236084,
0.14178001880645752,
0.4522421658039093,
0.7604098916053772,
-0.3643167018890381,
0.24885030090808868,
0.7932659983634949,
-0.2799155116081238,
0.6952883005142212,
0.12575934827327728,
0.4799064099788666,
-0.6768731474876404,
0.5830681920051575,
-0.10053734481334686,
0.15931205451488495,
0.5587809085845947,
0.29479870200157166,
-0.39934107661247253,
-0.6726565957069397,
-0.38671109080314636,
-0.01728985831141472,
-0.4977515637874603,
-0.30162081122398376,
-0.9929347634315491,
-0.3143809139728546,
-0.4583507180213928,
-0.4992940127849579,
-0.19081200659275055,
-0.35208427906036377,
-0.369636207818985,
-0.03686179593205452,
0.258274644613266,
0.5164281725883484,
-0.02023063786327839,
0.9328713417053223,
-0.5113499760627747,
0.13171909749507904,
0.35799750685691833,
0.06101697310805321,
-0.3054146468639374,
-0.5899881720542908,
0.0787852331995964,
0.09793711453676224,
-0.10753319412469864,
-0.9086774587631226,
0.6916332244873047,
0.31523045897483826,
0.1977640837430954,
0.6006941199302673,
-0.08349954336881638,
0.9382787942886353,
-0.9320960640907288,
0.80344557762146,
0.3154682517051697,
-1.3177061080932617,
0.8089221715927124,
-0.2907903492450714,
0.713423490524292,
0.7400730848312378,
-0.11641443520784378,
-0.46469879150390625,
-0.32873207330703735,
-0.17214825749397278,
-0.8311241269111633,
0.6864057183265686,
0.02985266223549843,
0.48368018865585327,
-0.03419230505824089,
0.5797755718231201,
-0.27689221501350403,
0.2359423041343689,
-0.747208297252655,
-0.30252382159233093,
-0.2763065993785858,
-0.4777035415172577,
-0.1598934829235077,
-0.47060301899909973,
-0.13290898501873016,
-0.3866916596889496,
0.675966739654541,
-0.30103155970573425,
0.5328176617622375,
0.4197450280189514,
-0.22993743419647217,
0.08152065426111221,
0.2644272744655609,
0.8091168999671936,
0.34710389375686646,
-0.21876487135887146,
0.20156791806221008,
0.4936184287071228,
-0.6829127669334412,
-0.08444879949092865,
0.11076507717370987,
-0.45251625776290894,
0.15808159112930298,
-0.003989509306848049,
0.68674635887146,
0.2918332815170288,
-0.5892059206962585,
0.6941967010498047,
-0.09573239088058472,
0.18682408332824707,
-0.45181432366371155,
0.059891823679208755,
-0.238553985953331,
0.2947557270526886,
0.4698971211910248,
0.3726285994052887,
0.6078731417655945,
-0.4233633875846863,
0.4038539528846741,
0.6215662360191345,
-0.9352402091026306,
-0.027767224237322807,
0.8698009252548218,
0.33476680517196655,
-0.5812200903892517,
0.33607158064842224,
0.30108946561813354,
-0.7240965366363525,
0.47305434942245483,
0.8974633812904358,
0.9571423530578613,
-0.450967937707901,
-0.1944235861301422,
0.46121129393577576,
0.045255858451128006,
0.10358458012342453,
-0.010009735822677612,
-0.16090476512908936,
-0.7535420060157776,
-0.24702127277851105,
-0.228470116853714,
-0.1353466510772705,
-0.026984184980392456,
-0.6176910996437073,
0.3060750365257263,
-0.14545050263404846,
-0.25039249658584595,
0.0751776248216629,
-0.3135957717895508,
-0.3151153028011322,
0.476103812456131,
-0.03376023471355438,
0.8852304816246033,
-0.664792537689209,
0.991244375705719,
0.6717833876609802,
-0.2782217860221863,
-0.3429935574531555,
0.4308515787124634,
0.19368375837802887,
-0.6438352465629578,
0.8401074409484863,
0.35519325733184814,
-0.22917816042900085,
0.0860791876912117,
-0.532349169254303,
-0.6384795308113098,
0.9405953884124756,
0.11658607423305511,
-0.2990850508213043,
-0.021649492904543877,
0.08383350074291229,
0.5070363283157349,
-0.5982682704925537,
0.39808475971221924,
0.41117897629737854,
0.2917090654373169,
0.056930821388959885,
-0.771336019039154,
0.12670773267745972,
-0.35922250151634216,
0.44866088032722473,
0.037257738411426544,
-0.22234603762626648,
0.2427477240562439,
0.0394454151391983,
-0.11703786998987198,
0.00877014547586441,
0.7480547428131104,
0.0006815617671236396,
0.49563661217689514,
0.78987056016922,
0.13216206431388855,
0.4634014070034027,
-0.06846050918102264,
1.0107479095458984,
-0.3426869511604309,
-0.1646946221590042,
1.269171118736267,
-0.1583997756242752,
1.028433084487915,
0.763678789138794,
0.409574955701828,
0.2601737082004547,
0.20136700570583344,
0.35858890414237976,
0.8697799444198608,
0.0035768221132457256,
-0.6268205642700195,
0.1775013506412506,
-0.4014590084552765,
-0.24725043773651123,
0.6301836371421814,
0.17872737348079681,
-0.5478772521018982,
0.2941846549510956,
0.31785836815834045,
0.2410167008638382,
0.3226311206817627,
-0.07959925383329391,
1.0119153261184692,
-0.040681615471839905,
-0.6500622630119324,
0.3761144280433655,
-0.14162690937519073,
1.19840669631958,
-0.3345327079296112,
0.11092839390039444,
-0.16790783405303955,
0.2926660180091858,
0.0017117259558290243,
-0.3184010088443756,
0.5233402252197266,
0.2115572839975357,
-0.5190998911857605,
-0.45652323961257935,
0.8555206060409546,
-0.659354031085968,
-0.15211732685565948,
0.3041704595088959,
0.28058651089668274,
-0.20989538729190826,
-0.2631293833255768,
-0.45110803842544556,
-0.2083301693201065,
0.03886205703020096,
-0.024253301322460175,
0.33406180143356323,
0.11738050729036331,
0.24941545724868774,
0.4197242856025696,
0.6876357793807983,
0.025668909773230553,
-0.17889557778835297,
0.2099856585264206,
0.9543150067329407,
-0.7232803106307983,
-0.5235728025436401,
-0.9200731515884399,
0.5745702385902405,
-0.5358598828315735,
-0.22340308129787445,
0.5416523814201355,
0.6177502274513245,
0.5510050058364868,
-0.01009652391076088,
0.7228329181671143,
0.005364193581044674,
0.34935879707336426,
-0.42207667231559753,
1.150572419166565,
-0.36549732089042664,
0.018984444439411163,
-0.4062289595603943,
-0.5811465382575989,
-0.5223177671432495,
0.829032838344574,
-0.3970663845539093,
-0.0723530724644661,
0.7885044813156128,
0.8680457472801208,
0.01785094290971756,
0.022848334163427353,
0.5248469114303589,
0.26141199469566345,
0.07738900929689407,
0.4297022819519043,
0.697178840637207,
-0.7684487104415894,
0.5928805470466614,
-0.2522223889827728,
-0.37958139181137085,
0.06548158824443817,
-0.7501228451728821,
-1.1118652820587158,
-0.5556107759475708,
-0.3679615259170532,
-0.39647287130355835,
0.36202865839004517,
1.0970362424850464,
0.9085483551025391,
-1.0477592945098877,
-0.27634328603744507,
-0.3495975136756897,
-0.08384764194488525,
-0.09642797708511353,
-0.24245312809944153,
0.2221975475549698,
-0.25560641288757324,
-1.010252594947815,
0.6943786144256592,
0.1914239078760147,
0.010672369971871376,
0.15739813446998596,
0.045987218618392944,
-0.36598071455955505,
0.24240930378437042,
0.5869280099868774,
0.013388211838901043,
-0.7574087977409363,
-0.562701404094696,
-0.049715280532836914,
-0.08267802000045776,
0.20381753146648407,
0.904866635799408,
-0.8068469166755676,
0.5470015406608582,
0.27973514795303345,
0.9080649018287659,
0.3210888206958771,
0.08366212993860245,
0.9011332392692566,
-0.9348601698875427,
0.42482665181159973,
0.19915078580379486,
0.26272836327552795,
0.2627752721309662,
-0.5205891728401184,
0.39238759875297546,
0.15503227710723877,
-0.5566475987434387,
-0.8536339402198792,
-0.033125344663858414,
-1.005411982536316,
-0.07494375109672546,
1.2942264080047607,
0.19533437490463257,
-0.32719138264656067,
-0.27776551246643066,
-0.47000476717948914,
0.5130354166030884,
-0.6653420925140381,
0.8569604158401489,
0.4012063145637512,
0.005904895719140768,
-0.06061623990535736,
-0.46014609932899475,
0.6606594324111938,
0.6525592803955078,
-0.8284208178520203,
-0.10630173236131668,
0.685066282749176,
0.21753843128681183,
0.2807629704475403,
0.6896259188652039,
0.19361931085586548,
0.18663017451763153,
-0.04910292103886604,
0.10474712401628494,
0.26813212037086487,
-0.055960122495889664,
-0.6243876218795776,
0.029206039384007454,
-0.38281866908073425,
-0.2825721204280853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02919v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02919v1
|
MultifacetEval: Multifaceted Evaluation to Probe LLMs in Mastering Medical Knowledge
| 2024-06-05T04:15:07 | 2024-06-05T04:15:07 |
Yuxuan Zhou, Xien Liu, Chen Ning, Ji Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have excelled across domains, also delivering
notable performance on the medical evaluation benchmarks, such as MedQA.
However, there still exists a significant gap between the reported performance
and the practical effectiveness in real-world medical scenarios. In this paper,
we aim to explore the causes of this gap by employing a multifaceted
examination schema to systematically probe the actual mastery of medical
knowledge by current LLMs. Specifically, we develop a novel evaluation
framework MultifacetEval to examine the degree and coverage of LLMs in encoding
and mastering medical knowledge at multiple facets (comparison, rectification,
discrimination, and verification) concurrently. Based on the MultifacetEval
framework, we construct two multifaceted evaluation datasets: MultiDiseK (by
producing questions from a clinical disease knowledge base) and MultiMedQA (by
rephrasing each question from a medical benchmark MedQA into multifaceted
questions). The experimental results on these multifaceted datasets demonstrate
that the extent of current LLMs in mastering medical knowledge is far below
their performance on existing medical benchmarks, suggesting that they lack
depth, precision, and comprehensiveness in mastering medical knowledge.
Consequently, current LLMs are not yet ready for application in real-world
medical tasks. The codes and datasets are available at
https://github.com/THUMLP/MultifacetEval.
|
[
-0.21488529443740845,
-0.6801190972328186,
0.8162224292755127,
0.2356095016002655,
0.04637625440955162,
0.5374170541763306,
-0.12962134182453156,
-0.3292434513568878,
0.07413267344236374,
0.43469879031181335,
-0.48887738585472107,
-0.6631265878677368,
-0.8101524710655212,
-0.10114409029483795,
0.06721402704715729,
0.9232831001281738,
-0.17056822776794434,
0.5409834384918213,
-0.8581367135047913,
-0.35637912154197693,
-0.32713139057159424,
-0.589841902256012,
-0.2963607609272003,
-0.7195030450820923,
0.39414969086647034,
0.44281408190727234,
0.24843758344650269,
0.20525355637073517,
0.7105619311332703,
0.23676374554634094,
-0.05633927509188652,
0.32276424765586853,
-0.2744828164577484,
0.21794116497039795,
-0.028195293620228767,
-0.40747925639152527,
-0.5227971076965332,
-0.021344078704714775,
0.7498870491981506,
1.1499935388565063,
-0.07297933101654053,
0.08412042260169983,
-0.08479141443967819,
0.9327642917633057,
-0.6049644351005554,
0.13670378923416138,
-0.3152713179588318,
0.12742646038532257,
-0.13373421132564545,
-0.38842159509658813,
-0.10489654541015625,
-0.34160879254341125,
0.1907571703195572,
-0.4404214322566986,
-0.01731223240494728,
-0.07169225066900253,
0.6131820678710938,
0.236504465341568,
-0.7313383221626282,
-0.37124091386795044,
-0.40116095542907715,
0.6241447925567627,
-0.41982126235961914,
0.5692368149757385,
0.17427238821983337,
0.5261004567146301,
0.03436405584216118,
-0.7634462118148804,
-0.46582338213920593,
-0.5102409720420837,
0.09628307074308395,
0.423854261636734,
0.16009533405303955,
0.14145000278949738,
0.1144520491361618,
0.7011159062385559,
-0.4310365319252014,
-0.04116278141736984,
-0.3497927188873291,
-0.36705949902534485,
0.35094454884529114,
0.41614586114883423,
0.39234888553619385,
-0.19400730729103088,
-0.6371049880981445,
-0.03148438408970833,
-0.9365090131759644,
0.14279858767986298,
-0.01167673896998167,
-0.19091568887233734,
-0.08000302314758301,
0.6821005940437317,
-0.15542717278003693,
0.5119830369949341,
-0.26978498697280884,
-0.6416893601417542,
0.5940530300140381,
-0.5682490468025208,
-0.04270796477794647,
-0.21251949667930603,
0.48391208052635193,
0.5699182152748108,
0.1388455480337143,
-0.19183091819286346,
0.03995179757475853,
0.0022553885355591774,
0.45500287413597107,
-0.7354258894920349,
-0.1758221536874771,
0.6853757500648499,
-0.40851128101348877,
-0.15520241856575012,
-0.18217898905277252,
-0.6948505640029907,
-0.6441906690597534,
-0.44446054100990295,
0.45892319083213806,
-0.54249507188797,
-0.2655565142631531,
0.4023931920528412,
-0.0339164063334465,
0.041653089225292206,
0.43877875804901123,
-0.46210527420043945,
0.177688866853714,
0.6780075430870056,
0.5947248935699463,
-0.24716699123382568,
-0.36202654242515564,
-0.27613210678100586,
0.02753465808928013,
-0.17783759534358978,
0.8373804688453674,
-0.36167973279953003,
-0.252029150724411,
-0.1424197256565094,
-0.10938216745853424,
-0.3321993052959442,
-0.9118902683258057,
0.31661057472229004,
-0.4684854745864868,
-0.20850227773189545,
-0.32601630687713623,
-0.5991595387458801,
-0.06822340935468674,
0.6459130644798279,
-0.6225946545600891,
0.8639691472053528,
0.26555222272872925,
-0.780401349067688,
0.6009738445281982,
-0.7578467726707458,
-0.4579506516456604,
0.06826727837324142,
-0.5105934739112854,
-0.4521944522857666,
-0.13294623792171478,
0.2911747694015503,
0.48658692836761475,
-0.4957164525985718,
0.4899847209453583,
-0.1863996982574463,
-0.2735767066478729,
0.34728312492370605,
-0.2335498034954071,
0.723664402961731,
-0.11486382782459259,
-0.2073216587305069,
0.10787809640169144,
-0.7703067660331726,
-0.07428675889968872,
-0.012745457701385021,
-0.4289911687374115,
-0.35038918256759644,
-0.18129372596740723,
-0.33242520689964294,
0.40460798144340515,
0.19337809085845947,
-0.6295390725135803,
0.34568095207214355,
-0.41845256090164185,
0.14939957857131958,
0.4909139573574066,
0.302277147769928,
0.2346600890159607,
-0.6434618830680847,
0.7673535943031311,
0.3182074725627899,
0.2585352659225464,
-0.09334943443536758,
-0.5158361792564392,
-0.6300541162490845,
-0.27564722299575806,
0.28916412591934204,
0.6496579647064209,
-0.9218127727508545,
-0.02788950316607952,
-0.5752649307250977,
-0.5175309181213379,
-0.8431975245475769,
0.15126419067382812,
0.4702143371105194,
0.6994767785072327,
0.44481566548347473,
-0.2948180139064789,
-0.2818004786968231,
-0.985925555229187,
-0.17811711132526398,
-0.08355066925287247,
-0.03343846648931503,
0.5610244274139404,
0.7849653959274292,
-0.3949129283428192,
0.49764886498451233,
-0.40757885575294495,
-0.3625713884830475,
-0.07332564145326614,
0.12811480462551117,
-0.03166167810559273,
0.47474023699760437,
0.2565678060054779,
-0.5417546033859253,
-0.04066057503223419,
0.056461017578840256,
-0.878119945526123,
-0.07276766002178192,
-0.02612651325762272,
0.020522627979516983,
-0.19721758365631104,
0.41552478075027466,
-0.3066161572933197,
0.14589768648147583,
0.6378989815711975,
-0.17950159311294556,
0.8288342356681824,
-0.1857081949710846,
0.5242397785186768,
-0.7869204878807068,
0.25333425402641296,
-0.32846930623054504,
0.019688906148076057,
-0.49670419096946716,
0.2252623438835144,
0.31411099433898926,
0.1777855008840561,
-0.3948777914047241,
0.5727676153182983,
-0.34284934401512146,
-0.14271926879882812,
0.2140345424413681,
0.13819855451583862,
0.2535640001296997,
0.25175100564956665,
-0.08382093906402588,
0.7874727249145508,
0.5247549414634705,
-0.6211328506469727,
0.3049676716327667,
0.2306046336889267,
-0.6391243934631348,
1.0949069261550903,
-0.5680992007255554,
-0.09153582900762558,
-0.1633143573999405,
0.18485255539417267,
-0.8867942094802856,
-0.04269983246922493,
0.07108896225690842,
-0.43259093165397644,
0.1805998682975769,
-0.1788366585969925,
-0.7547261714935303,
-0.33284226059913635,
-0.4066043198108673,
0.5503126382827759,
-0.04725807160139084,
-0.27487069368362427,
0.6264712810516357,
0.3378862738609314,
-0.3885866701602936,
-0.7280358672142029,
-0.6510932445526123,
0.1144695058465004,
-0.10522350668907166,
-0.7836281061172485,
0.3926388621330261,
-0.24896635115146637,
-0.2513923943042755,
-0.3226476311683655,
-0.14064717292785645,
0.016173293814063072,
0.10438641905784607,
0.29618003964424133,
0.13522301614284515,
-0.269019216299057,
0.3213607370853424,
0.38444650173187256,
-0.14938250184059143,
0.3188166320323944,
-0.03933829441666603,
0.37106823921203613,
-0.2085379660129547,
-0.9112517833709717,
-0.06026460602879524,
0.31059056520462036,
0.8215153813362122,
-0.43027642369270325,
0.5329506397247314,
0.5636317729949951,
-0.4537210464477539,
0.08510945737361908,
-0.7335380911827087,
-0.23531530797481537,
-0.33733734488487244,
0.4827778935432434,
-0.568264365196228,
-0.958321750164032,
0.5939648747444153,
-0.4222087562084198,
-0.08915409445762634,
0.4296421706676483,
0.6800783276557922,
-0.22949320077896118,
0.7160858511924744,
0.1787865161895752,
0.3612094521522522,
-0.3649797737598419,
-0.488064706325531,
-0.18573065102100372,
-1.259000539779663,
-0.6227603554725647,
-0.2670089900493622,
-0.10400349646806717,
-0.19768781960010529,
-0.7345523238182068,
1.000420331954956,
-0.15712620317935944,
-0.1878788024187088,
-0.2583780884742737,
-0.17287582159042358,
0.10197266191244125,
0.3605668842792511,
0.3612998127937317,
0.7059741616249084,
-0.1981336623430252,
-0.6668930053710938,
-0.3355266749858856,
-0.7805945873260498,
-0.3886389136314392,
1.4343156814575195,
0.5913479328155518,
0.5045058727264404,
0.07579061388969421,
0.5531018376350403,
0.11511753499507904,
0.5114305019378662,
-0.8773394227027893,
0.12943361699581146,
0.012214613147079945,
-0.47984588146209717,
-0.12714973092079163,
-0.4460030198097229,
-0.9518017172813416,
0.399224191904068,
-0.17479000985622406,
-0.26938045024871826,
-0.02292291261255741,
-0.1077539250254631,
-0.5310437679290771,
0.3099101185798645,
-0.3166404962539673,
0.8889080882072449,
-0.4564375877380371,
-0.1769806295633316,
-0.01723318360745907,
-0.813258945941925,
0.6477020978927612,
-0.2461252361536026,
0.43624377250671387,
-0.05649762973189354,
-0.15296629071235657,
0.6769832372665405,
-0.2571202516555786,
0.7324545979499817,
-0.24924926459789276,
-0.31669849157333374,
-0.165895015001297,
-0.012287327088415623,
-0.08063868433237076,
0.3624068796634674,
0.056887462735176086,
0.1054721400141716,
0.3687358796596527,
-0.45478740334510803,
-0.515874445438385,
0.5119458436965942,
-0.5692949891090393,
-0.2323685735464096,
-0.3775723874568939,
-0.4449818730354309,
-0.7855888605117798,
0.08170735090970993,
0.11623040586709976,
0.4712120294570923,
-0.2384616732597351,
0.09542010724544525,
0.8432806134223938,
-0.4665554165840149,
-0.257057249546051,
0.4873923063278198,
-0.14284108579158783,
-0.36834216117858887,
0.7518231868743896,
0.08728626370429993,
0.3968869149684906,
0.37765541672706604,
0.20936740934848785,
-0.2816120982170105,
-0.8169571757316589,
-0.7079509496688843,
0.248064324259758,
-0.9064671993255615,
-0.30181172490119934,
-0.8547689318656921,
-0.2766171395778656,
-0.29901206493377686,
0.18730801343917847,
-0.3269278407096863,
-0.08910894393920898,
0.15551768243312836,
0.038440901786088943,
0.2276161015033722,
0.8348103165626526,
0.10055167227983475,
0.1330309510231018,
-0.807364821434021,
0.4479844272136688,
0.2656603753566742,
0.6089474558830261,
0.06879919767379761,
-0.3439982235431671,
-0.24717098474502563,
0.04675521329045296,
-0.2240481972694397,
-0.7811626195907593,
0.005934670101851225,
0.10227897018194199,
1.0165468454360962,
0.20491757988929749,
-0.21831847727298737,
0.6683468818664551,
-0.5007070302963257,
0.5136972665786743,
-0.0860256478190422,
-0.6861223578453064,
0.3840768337249756,
-0.10459145903587341,
0.3363310694694519,
0.9068917632102966,
0.2489125281572342,
-0.5662500262260437,
-0.39216408133506775,
-0.5731375813484192,
-0.8862992525100708,
0.30331891775131226,
-0.0836322084069252,
-0.2289842665195465,
0.17383721470832825,
0.3674851655960083,
0.1830659806728363,
0.44230079650878906,
-0.4296431541442871,
-0.4126949906349182,
0.09029781073331833,
-0.0548207089304924,
0.08134894073009491,
-0.11472949385643005,
-0.47271838784217834,
-0.2877243459224701,
0.3205159306526184,
-0.20440661907196045,
0.40721064805984497,
0.31283825635910034,
-0.4697391390800476,
0.2466515153646469,
0.36763399839401245,
0.7546579241752625,
0.872045636177063,
-0.20096461474895477,
0.17150749266147614,
0.1859397441148758,
-0.6683685183525085,
0.1533341258764267,
0.1601959466934204,
0.21274061501026154,
-0.25866183638572693,
0.6905040144920349,
0.38830050826072693,
0.416927695274353,
-0.8276645541191101,
0.912351131439209,
0.130426287651062,
-0.3269132375717163,
-0.23769047856330872,
-0.42600706219673157,
0.3825491964817047,
0.10246153920888901,
0.3467792570590973,
0.07256186008453369,
0.2668704390525818,
-0.2909141480922699,
0.5168785452842712,
0.277194082736969,
-0.2734556198120117,
-0.007423084229230881,
0.44991400837898254,
-0.00923639815300703,
0.37621763348579407,
0.4611620008945465,
-0.10143125802278519,
-0.5327194929122925,
0.6268378496170044,
0.18724235892295837,
0.1251467913389206,
-0.2155270129442215,
0.1143002063035965,
0.27700692415237427,
0.498121976852417,
0.191630557179451,
0.4924393892288208,
0.10562539100646973,
-0.7306181788444519,
-0.7773340344429016,
-0.5020424723625183,
-0.4636526107788086,
0.2430732548236847,
-0.6662042140960693,
-0.031785909086465836,
-0.5007380843162537,
0.00003641358489403501,
-0.049539025872945786,
0.04583309218287468,
-0.720650315284729,
0.364484578371048,
-0.12029450386762619,
0.8780847787857056,
-0.8607816100120544,
0.6876814365386963,
0.6724699139595032,
-0.5265686511993408,
-0.41776078939437866,
-0.1467083841562271,
0.13018691539764404,
-1.1044152975082397,
0.5748505592346191,
0.14702290296554565,
-0.05682716146111488,
-0.3176894187927246,
-0.12099064141511917,
-0.5968034267425537,
1.2209826707839966,
0.22860029339790344,
-0.25651147961616516,
0.01942022703588009,
0.34310001134872437,
0.585911750793457,
-0.43063780665397644,
0.2306208610534668,
0.721153736114502,
0.6084928512573242,
0.028894653543829918,
-1.0350284576416016,
-0.026088621467351913,
-0.22614097595214844,
-0.32021966576576233,
0.0058087073266506195,
-0.36411863565444946,
0.7221188545227051,
-0.3426624536514282,
0.12679751217365265,
-0.07619238644838333,
0.11690731346607208,
0.5916587710380554,
0.49559956789016724,
0.4015110731124878,
0.6883985996246338,
0.8060139417648315,
-0.17300501465797424,
0.9945201277732849,
-0.3834535777568817,
0.2634270489215851,
0.9642296433448792,
-0.39147964119911194,
0.6132985949516296,
0.5802279710769653,
-0.42775166034698486,
0.5239564776420593,
0.5412778854370117,
0.05097346380352974,
0.14939449727535248,
0.5400559902191162,
-0.31760936975479126,
-0.2923140823841095,
0.05473403260111809,
-0.6261352896690369,
0.46532779932022095,
0.7373484373092651,
-0.29088860750198364,
-0.2281399518251419,
0.35743674635887146,
0.004158150404691696,
0.07723171263933182,
-0.09476673603057861,
0.8111447095870972,
-0.011790654622018337,
-0.43899357318878174,
0.6500676870346069,
-0.03679169714450836,
0.5494954586029053,
-0.5069524049758911,
-0.1825655996799469,
-0.20900003612041473,
-0.05581587553024292,
-0.13686418533325195,
-0.771859347820282,
0.24188314378261566,
-0.42901334166526794,
0.03987215831875801,
-0.041248619556427,
0.5487803816795349,
-0.42205527424812317,
-0.5196601748466492,
0.41374528408050537,
0.9844413995742798,
0.22598236799240112,
-0.2077094167470932,
-0.8703330159187317,
-0.0477340929210186,
-0.3710993230342865,
-0.047846898436546326,
0.25294601917266846,
0.30679869651794434,
-0.07919121533632278,
0.8753858804702759,
0.5627148747444153,
0.41518181562423706,
-0.09859547019004822,
0.5159899592399597,
0.8426580429077148,
-0.4611314535140991,
-0.09890051186084747,
-0.6207366585731506,
0.5854452252388,
0.11517549306154251,
-0.28587082028388977,
0.4174460768699646,
0.7124970555305481,
0.5893213152885437,
0.009544298984110355,
0.8221393823623657,
0.2201785147190094,
0.713254451751709,
-0.6777358651161194,
0.9157201647758484,
-0.7915434837341309,
0.33116352558135986,
-0.3535725474357605,
-0.37046703696250916,
-0.5149839520454407,
0.4048929512500763,
-0.18789713084697723,
0.2981182336807251,
0.8240886926651001,
0.5316973328590393,
0.029882891103625298,
-0.16539938747882843,
0.34729820489883423,
0.122874915599823,
0.17843182384967804,
0.8244550228118896,
0.8904658555984497,
-0.4337497055530548,
0.17924168705940247,
-0.2905210852622986,
-0.4547191262245178,
-0.10655545443296432,
-0.8115831613540649,
-0.7974758148193359,
-0.638299822807312,
-0.16823604702949524,
-0.42143094539642334,
0.14351694285869598,
0.6386391520500183,
0.6214333176612854,
-0.6513766050338745,
-0.05466654524207115,
0.38206222653388977,
-0.005788570735603571,
-0.37086349725723267,
-0.16488076746463776,
0.6133334636688232,
-0.21595999598503113,
-0.48481035232543945,
0.4096783995628357,
0.37059205770492554,
0.017387699335813522,
-0.566578209400177,
0.015820549800992012,
-0.2882370054721832,
-0.2925565242767334,
0.8273782134056091,
-0.10464540868997574,
-0.678324818611145,
0.010351436212658882,
0.20255687832832336,
-0.16424068808555603,
0.33979400992393494,
0.9503450393676758,
-0.823567271232605,
0.5103655457496643,
0.17720873653888702,
0.897739052772522,
0.34037384390830994,
-0.093518927693367,
0.35903772711753845,
-0.6333777904510498,
-0.34290817379951477,
0.4422105550765991,
0.3225727379322052,
0.5065220594406128,
-0.2569117844104767,
0.306643009185791,
0.2754535377025604,
-0.36109766364097595,
-0.5910165905952454,
0.09979190677404404,
-0.9942062497138977,
-0.22871133685112,
1.1057056188583374,
-0.15292946994304657,
0.190667524933815,
-0.43170008063316345,
-0.09563187509775162,
0.16423910856246948,
0.05401356518268585,
0.647075891494751,
0.7887494564056396,
-0.2855621874332428,
0.04520460218191147,
-0.9160744547843933,
0.41281256079673767,
0.6694000959396362,
-0.949520468711853,
-0.11061108857393265,
0.3602526783943176,
0.5876004099845886,
0.16813738644123077,
0.9287736415863037,
-0.6415125131607056,
0.44150879979133606,
-0.1545041799545288,
0.08307091146707535,
-0.17570798099040985,
-0.45473697781562805,
-0.5074415802955627,
0.2153700590133667,
0.1382012516260147,
0.0063390485011041164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02911v1
|
Improving In-Context Learning with Prediction Feedback for Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-06-05T04:04:08 | 2024-06-05T04:04:08 |
Hongling Xu, Qianlong Wang, Yice Zhang, Min Yang, Xi Zeng, Bing Qin, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved promising results in sentiment
analysis through the in-context learning (ICL) paradigm. However, their ability
to distinguish subtle sentiments still remains a challenge. Inspired by the
human ability to adjust understanding via feedback, this paper enhances ICL by
incorporating prior predictions and feedback, aiming to rectify sentiment
misinterpretation of LLMs. Specifically, the proposed framework consists of
three steps: (1) acquiring prior predictions of LLMs, (2) devising predictive
feedback based on correctness, and (3) leveraging a feedback-driven prompt to
refine sentiment understanding. Experimental results across nine sentiment
analysis datasets demonstrate the superiority of our framework over
conventional ICL methods, with an average F1 improvement of 5.95%.
|
[
-0.35076451301574707,
-0.43966948986053467,
0.6231735944747925,
0.3746354579925537,
-0.3741511106491089,
0.274308443069458,
-0.5993649363517761,
-0.45852410793304443,
-0.17090463638305664,
0.2032441347837448,
-0.9013091325759888,
-0.5685979723930359,
-0.5090982913970947,
0.2143387496471405,
-0.0101221464574337,
1.1539260149002075,
0.00969038438051939,
0.48002272844314575,
-0.3407157063484192,
-0.03803371265530586,
-0.5576764941215515,
-0.46404367685317993,
-0.7546169757843018,
-0.4315422475337982,
0.6120109558105469,
0.7170877456665039,
0.21978561580181122,
-0.03409073129296303,
0.36288920044898987,
0.1718115359544754,
-0.2761175036430359,
0.20717135071754456,
-0.5139806270599365,
-0.006592269521206617,
-0.20653992891311646,
-0.5580556988716125,
-0.21004457771778107,
0.009733601473271847,
0.6808704137802124,
0.8446536064147949,
0.0353090763092041,
-0.0909142941236496,
0.5903688073158264,
0.7180492877960205,
-0.5039266347885132,
0.3023292124271393,
-0.7565715909004211,
0.19957426190376282,
0.07171456515789032,
-0.17687775194644928,
-0.7947816252708435,
-0.2877572774887085,
0.38715383410453796,
-0.26741650700569153,
0.06780973821878433,
0.08495257794857025,
0.4809010326862335,
0.3141074478626251,
-0.22109974920749664,
-0.26974186301231384,
-0.6016494035720825,
1.0455812215805054,
-0.9919536709785461,
0.42578381299972534,
0.22025957703590393,
0.31741395592689514,
-0.1220817044377327,
-0.591802716255188,
-0.3458501398563385,
-0.33195093274116516,
-0.14297562837600708,
0.2520374357700348,
0.21135155856609344,
-0.0893167108297348,
0.15905597805976868,
0.14314760267734528,
-0.011572465300559998,
0.062375620007514954,
-0.13305386900901794,
0.006059977225959301,
0.5292503833770752,
0.13059717416763306,
-0.13769316673278809,
-0.06015763804316521,
-0.4434957206249237,
0.15204928815364838,
-0.8816558122634888,
0.33172717690467834,
-0.10358468443155289,
0.5134752988815308,
-0.17291748523712158,
-0.012150545604526997,
-0.23988276720046997,
0.5844360589981079,
0.40017515420913696,
-0.31576648354530334,
0.5016428828239441,
-0.006960292812436819,
-0.27821192145347595,
0.059323206543922424,
0.41730087995529175,
0.4404144585132599,
0.03580240532755852,
-0.19753766059875488,
-0.41597673296928406,
-0.046049438416957855,
0.15105286240577698,
-0.6906152367591858,
-0.010001378133893013,
0.20961838960647583,
-0.5455846190452576,
-0.47992727160453796,
0.3619084060192108,
-0.8343164324760437,
-0.8360649347305298,
-0.5794503092765808,
0.1850728839635849,
-0.3115263283252716,
-0.22593285143375397,
0.13730795681476593,
0.15535058081150055,
0.2530854642391205,
0.7893131971359253,
-0.5147801041603088,
0.018381817266345024,
0.6080988049507141,
0.7463522553443909,
-0.03349904716014862,
-0.3005971610546112,
-0.5820052623748779,
-0.09431825578212738,
-0.36869141459465027,
0.8441419005393982,
-0.5521122217178345,
-0.45647096633911133,
0.07924612611532211,
-0.13707154989242554,
0.07907019555568695,
-0.6355186700820923,
0.46348702907562256,
-0.4748326539993286,
0.31532493233680725,
-0.4894886016845703,
-0.5973111391067505,
-0.36201056838035583,
0.6133580207824707,
-0.32346922159194946,
0.7779081463813782,
0.13017092645168304,
-0.9590027332305908,
0.5834794044494629,
-0.6971843838691711,
-0.3210328221321106,
-0.04270593076944351,
0.03742209076881409,
-0.2332228124141693,
0.39559879899024963,
0.48432180285453796,
0.5777857899665833,
-0.13835111260414124,
0.30764803290367126,
-0.5996177792549133,
-0.4218515455722809,
0.5345882177352905,
-0.29325515031814575,
0.35538703203201294,
0.167596235871315,
-0.5168141722679138,
0.25239381194114685,
-0.5922643542289734,
-0.09266243875026703,
-0.46763166785240173,
-0.4001992642879486,
-0.063224658370018,
0.22928394377231598,
-0.15206292271614075,
0.29426705837249756,
0.154050812125206,
-0.604523241519928,
0.1741577684879303,
-0.8181516528129578,
0.2918241620063782,
1.022596836090088,
0.039227258414030075,
0.6165434718132019,
0.03074600175023079,
0.5276443362236023,
0.43940263986587524,
0.189078688621521,
-0.17402558028697968,
-0.05890839546918869,
-0.6801832914352417,
-0.009457312524318695,
0.26620811223983765,
0.2723071277141571,
-0.7949656844139099,
0.22823064029216766,
-0.28609803318977356,
-0.165696382522583,
-0.39960435032844543,
0.340459406375885,
0.2875368595123291,
0.6351126432418823,
0.33617982268333435,
-0.1393878310918808,
-0.721547544002533,
-0.3700994551181793,
-0.5167410373687744,
-0.35335612297058105,
0.03818079084157944,
0.24586904048919678,
0.3121280372142792,
-0.5098246932029724,
1.0441445112228394,
-0.27351778745651245,
-0.33302992582321167,
-0.4120625853538513,
0.1495891809463501,
0.16056594252586365,
0.2849278450012207,
0.18547853827476501,
-0.6109691262245178,
-0.6287699341773987,
-0.0014236062997952104,
-0.5932286381721497,
0.04254530742764473,
0.1109781414270401,
0.23010580241680145,
0.23402409255504608,
0.9107457995414734,
-0.16696344316005707,
0.18336591124534607,
0.2789950966835022,
-0.2625647187232971,
0.2886754870414734,
0.24445341527462006,
-0.1949065774679184,
-1.0460506677627563,
-0.21233010292053223,
0.19808800518512726,
-0.24160043895244598,
-0.31084519624710083,
-0.16201083362102509,
0.1173151507973671,
0.2986278235912323,
-0.5312057733535767,
0.6896283030509949,
-0.3250696361064911,
0.13724134862422943,
-0.4049012362957001,
0.06424304842948914,
-0.24253876507282257,
0.3835413157939911,
-0.06323673576116562,
0.6752554178237915,
0.451233446598053,
-0.39047110080718994,
0.09803726524114609,
-0.11717745661735535,
-0.47936397790908813,
0.5835193991661072,
-0.3591775596141815,
0.1709035187959671,
-0.4779095947742462,
0.5376842021942139,
-1.227908730506897,
-0.4171636998653412,
0.3749965727329254,
-0.703727126121521,
0.352787584066391,
-0.12876568734645844,
-0.29147669672966003,
-0.3373454511165619,
-0.4839624762535095,
0.06324057281017303,
0.3321067988872528,
-0.9375362396240234,
0.7067623138427734,
0.08152511715888977,
0.00030219071777537465,
-0.9710981845855713,
-0.557258129119873,
-0.07526242733001709,
-0.23126688599586487,
-0.17833152413368225,
0.0728607103228569,
-0.3351265788078308,
-0.6230411529541016,
-0.14950746297836304,
0.14410945773124695,
0.21251074969768524,
0.12423823028802872,
0.2926870584487915,
0.18386787176132202,
0.015342563390731812,
0.5356020331382751,
-0.05362922325730324,
-0.029423289000988007,
0.23876617848873138,
-0.3680797219276428,
0.4393283724784851,
-0.39639538526535034,
-0.07321659475564957,
-0.37141600251197815,
-0.02691916562616825,
0.5678383708000183,
-0.07223304361104965,
0.42934298515319824,
0.6404884457588196,
-0.34624284505844116,
-0.48725008964538574,
-0.42941781878471375,
-0.4233854115009308,
-0.46527230739593506,
0.37952691316604614,
-0.2606901228427887,
-1.0104008913040161,
0.41347745060920715,
-0.3037499189376831,
-0.06244521588087082,
0.18316011130809784,
0.4976106286048889,
-0.4412718713283539,
1.3232454061508179,
0.7597485184669495,
-0.5064388513565063,
0.6377723813056946,
-0.2001107931137085,
0.2399628460407257,
-0.9614887833595276,
-0.1968795508146286,
-0.26503315567970276,
-0.26741480827331543,
-0.15979506075382233,
-0.13669490814208984,
0.22708119451999664,
0.1958143413066864,
-0.1527864933013916,
-0.4473502039909363,
-0.0984301045536995,
0.5152075290679932,
0.22631126642227173,
0.316239595413208,
-0.06092491000890732,
0.027409175410866737,
-0.1834796518087387,
-0.2161465287208557,
-0.4720896780490875,
-0.378875732421875,
0.9975156188011169,
0.5993931293487549,
0.6823725700378418,
-0.08531080931425095,
0.6567171216011047,
0.17881931364536285,
1.0002011060714722,
-0.9257469177246094,
0.3374432325363159,
-0.06151116266846657,
-0.1653585284948349,
-0.03649862855672836,
-0.3475332260131836,
-0.4017835259437561,
0.2440095990896225,
-0.1619568020105362,
-0.6395842432975769,
-0.04478444531559944,
0.1976955384016037,
-0.3825359344482422,
0.16438432037830353,
-0.4809119701385498,
0.605778694152832,
-0.04806956648826599,
-0.34676995873451233,
-0.24267882108688354,
-0.7346659898757935,
0.25524279475212097,
0.04529339820146561,
0.5802437663078308,
0.08033870160579681,
0.08075117319822311,
0.4409621059894562,
-0.31306445598602295,
1.4208422899246216,
-0.5984616279602051,
-0.3410155475139618,
0.2604953348636627,
-0.15869010984897614,
0.4669795334339142,
0.38501593470573425,
-0.2486855387687683,
-0.2771151661872864,
-0.3751179575920105,
-0.1216755211353302,
-0.8932528495788574,
0.7365629076957703,
-0.7039182782173157,
-0.5214532613754272,
-0.14729022979736328,
-0.38983896374702454,
-0.6279329657554626,
-0.2118660807609558,
0.41139736771583557,
0.5655542016029358,
-0.1043694019317627,
0.20813001692295074,
0.7763515114784241,
0.007988223806023598,
0.4846706986427307,
0.5362085700035095,
-0.3804798424243927,
-0.5140231251716614,
0.6704828143119812,
-0.10977765917778015,
0.026600221171975136,
0.4956802725791931,
0.42105552554130554,
-0.5576779842376709,
-0.45196542143821716,
-0.43513405323028564,
0.07842304557561874,
-1.1133290529251099,
-0.433364599943161,
-0.3418633043766022,
0.1781882643699646,
-0.38234177231788635,
-0.21909157931804657,
-0.07117073237895966,
0.1424243450164795,
-0.6022418141365051,
-0.25923025608062744,
0.28053584694862366,
0.9487692713737488,
0.08008912205696106,
0.6138182878494263,
-0.7207372188568115,
-0.3582361340522766,
0.18262773752212524,
0.4882241487503052,
0.30370503664016724,
-0.7365772724151611,
-0.38336843252182007,
0.09424572438001633,
-0.18567556142807007,
-0.761878490447998,
0.4997958242893219,
0.16198566555976868,
0.23188380897045135,
0.5706421732902527,
-0.11864867061376572,
0.7268383502960205,
-0.25801536440849304,
1.000148057937622,
0.20119155943393707,
-1.136845350265503,
0.7778143286705017,
-0.17099668085575104,
0.5343661308288574,
0.7299642562866211,
0.26032930612564087,
-0.5285215973854065,
-0.4230232536792755,
-0.5395592451095581,
-0.5661055445671082,
0.49584096670150757,
-0.6090267300605774,
0.26512929797172546,
-0.008620762266218662,
0.8150588870048523,
0.21823330223560333,
0.2783677279949188,
-0.9506645202636719,
0.04716906324028969,
0.03339271992444992,
-0.4985025227069855,
-0.4105592966079712,
-0.35282498598098755,
0.05354944244027138,
-0.5460185408592224,
0.7379037737846375,
-0.5693103671073914,
-0.03295213356614113,
0.24236296117305756,
-0.25023695826530457,
-0.3524243235588074,
0.26143354177474976,
0.4584752023220062,
0.8908551335334778,
-0.15751874446868896,
0.08416131138801575,
0.5797672271728516,
-0.2108108252286911,
-0.03584090992808342,
-0.3502497673034668,
0.004666404332965612,
0.0488785095512867,
0.4770832061767578,
0.7827613949775696,
0.4227294623851776,
-0.5752177834510803,
0.7068719863891602,
-0.18652284145355225,
0.04260624572634697,
-0.44300004839897156,
-0.11676632612943649,
-0.06686728447675705,
0.28872939944267273,
0.35141026973724365,
0.42201942205429077,
0.13923850655555725,
-0.5373305678367615,
0.21094650030136108,
0.47039952874183655,
-0.9936816096305847,
-0.42485398054122925,
0.2523766756057739,
0.1916416734457016,
0.09256485104560852,
0.3281153738498688,
-0.18835550546646118,
-0.8087232112884521,
0.3752328157424927,
0.5432068109512329,
0.9512490630149841,
-0.15858499705791473,
0.21038681268692017,
0.5133905410766602,
-0.07621066272258759,
-0.16899996995925903,
0.34421050548553467,
-0.08146011084318161,
-0.8577492833137512,
-0.6292273998260498,
-0.6501816511154175,
-0.49219247698783875,
0.0038721354212611914,
-0.7213336229324341,
0.41709789633750916,
-0.6621320247650146,
-0.055284179747104645,
-0.3312249481678009,
0.08367862552404404,
-0.5158600211143494,
0.5699456334114075,
0.14236676692962646,
0.8958091139793396,
-0.6932185292243958,
0.9952885508537292,
0.9302693605422974,
-0.34977540373802185,
-0.9408457279205322,
0.4706338942050934,
0.0013177470536902547,
-0.41388896107673645,
1.0204471349716187,
0.5243961811065674,
-0.44281747937202454,
-0.09026757627725601,
-1.0156031847000122,
-0.6436727643013,
0.8393558263778687,
0.15841327607631683,
-0.6383034586906433,
0.4281057119369507,
-0.24787086248397827,
0.7923208475112915,
-0.6734097599983215,
0.2740623354911804,
0.5048952698707581,
0.2899484932422638,
-0.04190472885966301,
-0.5823960304260254,
-0.21068339049816132,
-0.13248497247695923,
0.08889797329902649,
-0.01068432442843914,
-0.4949715733528137,
0.7988229990005493,
-0.27975523471832275,
-0.08465685695409775,
-0.05413853004574776,
1.0947036743164062,
0.13953223824501038,
0.3662208616733551,
0.761109471321106,
0.35695475339889526,
0.8296323418617249,
-0.027966557070612907,
1.1336405277252197,
-0.21754279732704163,
0.3756917715072632,
1.1894654035568237,
-0.300781786441803,
1.2150596380233765,
0.6408193111419678,
0.006010313984006643,
0.8428001403808594,
0.8285143375396729,
0.40659379959106445,
0.6844066381454468,
0.20290297269821167,
-0.4823620617389679,
-0.2537199854850769,
-0.034972045570611954,
-0.309993714094162,
0.364576518535614,
0.5928707718849182,
-0.4706716239452362,
0.018653618171811104,
0.33772146701812744,
0.00862383283674717,
0.14575017988681793,
-0.6903292536735535,
0.9735444188117981,
0.16484147310256958,
-0.6794552803039551,
0.38372036814689636,
-0.06729310005903244,
1.0232783555984497,
-0.3055249750614166,
-0.02023247256875038,
-0.32686272263526917,
0.5459885001182556,
-0.337657630443573,
-0.783348023891449,
0.08858784288167953,
-0.19603002071380615,
-0.4658782184123993,
-0.16833637654781342,
0.8070094585418701,
-0.4052327871322632,
-0.4164769947528839,
0.5453523397445679,
0.30436745285987854,
-0.27025771141052246,
-0.10636405646800995,
-0.6499524712562561,
0.1344665288925171,
0.2853985130786896,
-0.09277261048555374,
0.268510103225708,
0.37820231914520264,
0.016611065715551376,
0.7044323682785034,
0.4016266167163849,
0.07607776671648026,
-0.24301984906196594,
0.34136855602264404,
0.9217584133148193,
-0.6159769892692566,
-0.6193568706512451,
-1.0155431032180786,
0.4441263675689697,
-0.07559217512607574,
-0.39412447810173035,
0.6473597884178162,
0.10077530890703201,
1.2368158102035522,
-0.3113778233528137,
1.0137733221054077,
0.3590732514858246,
0.9473040699958801,
-0.5892736315727234,
0.3908925950527191,
-0.6397904753684998,
0.4732668995857239,
-0.3886410593986511,
-0.849141001701355,
-0.6352851986885071,
0.7146337628364563,
-0.5495255589485168,
-0.0352402999997139,
0.5915290713310242,
0.7166382074356079,
0.13948838412761688,
0.2651623487472534,
0.04048125818371773,
0.34388482570648193,
0.2151382714509964,
0.2856179475784302,
1.3410365581512451,
-0.138832226395607,
0.16548138856887817,
-0.5095741152763367,
-0.16437362134456635,
-0.3458298444747925,
-0.8898444175720215,
-0.8625192642211914,
-0.3804014027118683,
-0.26700952649116516,
-0.46254098415374756,
-0.014452764764428139,
1.3127925395965576,
0.6265826225280762,
-0.9437939524650574,
-0.2721000909805298,
-0.15208259224891663,
0.14822529256343842,
-0.17745345830917358,
-0.2896803915500641,
0.10531538724899292,
-1.0340584516525269,
-0.6193619966506958,
0.45721298456192017,
0.25345155596733093,
-0.24637453258037567,
-0.3095460832118988,
-0.32952386140823364,
0.3541719615459442,
-0.13400781154632568,
0.9868051409721375,
-0.0405779704451561,
-0.9993062019348145,
-0.6033399701118469,
-0.13631290197372437,
0.00337268877774477,
0.20635481178760529,
0.8993072509765625,
-0.9037092924118042,
0.4301210641860962,
0.4233376383781433,
0.5343925356864929,
0.049833573400974274,
-0.002290824893862009,
0.692829966545105,
-1.0092532634735107,
0.12838983535766602,
0.3192298412322998,
0.5557733774185181,
0.6054173707962036,
-0.5433543920516968,
0.28556421399116516,
0.11827889084815979,
-0.3213353157043457,
-0.7194559574127197,
0.2146463543176651,
-0.7177156805992126,
-0.5456085801124573,
1.1998379230499268,
-0.18216505646705627,
-0.27795955538749695,
0.08998306095600128,
-0.5489262342453003,
-0.06618299335241318,
-0.40266963839530945,
0.8729272484779358,
0.6625219583511353,
-0.042400822043418884,
-0.32162272930145264,
-0.10697952657938004,
0.725296139717102,
0.6497033834457397,
-0.6922662854194641,
0.15549130737781525,
0.657629132270813,
0.2885603904724121,
-0.07720697671175003,
0.47233593463897705,
-0.16317026317119598,
0.21930886805057526,
-0.6390334963798523,
-0.05889875441789627,
0.38163483142852783,
-0.6280186772346497,
-0.8059844374656677,
0.14812223613262177,
0.4406898021697998,
0.11022473126649857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02903v1
|
Open Grounded Planning: Challenges and Benchmark Construction
| 2024-06-05T03:46:52 | 2024-06-05T03:46:52 |
Shiguang Guo, Ziliang Deng, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Xianpei Han, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has increasingly drawn
attention to the use of LLMs for human-like planning. Existing work on
LLM-based planning either focuses on leveraging the inherent language
generation capabilities of LLMs to produce free-style plans, or employs
reinforcement learning approaches to learn decision-making for a limited set of
actions within restricted environments. However, both approaches exhibit
significant discrepancies from the open and executable requirements in
real-world planning. In this paper, we propose a new planning task--open
grounded planning. The primary objective of open grounded planning is to ask
the model to generate an executable plan based on a variable action set,
thereby ensuring the executability of the produced plan. To this end, we
establishes a benchmark for open grounded planning spanning a wide range of
domains. Then we test current state-of-the-art LLMs along with five planning
approaches, revealing that existing LLMs and methods still struggle to address
the challenges posed by grounded planning in open domains. The outcomes of this
paper define and establish a foundational dataset for open grounded planning,
and shed light on the potential challenges and future directions of LLM-based
planning.
|
[
-0.41931113600730896,
-0.6405113339424133,
0.6393714547157288,
0.07543890178203583,
0.15739768743515015,
-0.21456320583820343,
-0.4123397469520569,
-0.21939872205257416,
0.11257649213075638,
0.6687639355659485,
-0.8084067702293396,
-0.5646026730537415,
-0.14078904688358307,
-0.24918663501739502,
0.07015085965394974,
0.374166876077652,
-0.5690720677375793,
-0.22607050836086273,
-0.11566785722970963,
-0.4646894037723541,
-0.8713988065719604,
-0.6999079585075378,
-0.37349414825439453,
-0.4399407207965851,
0.11572320759296417,
0.8959429860115051,
0.7802018523216248,
0.39422324299812317,
0.0719880536198616,
0.1103382408618927,
-0.15799091756343842,
0.24822524189949036,
-0.5708847045898438,
0.12352067232131958,
-0.3953402638435364,
-0.18046456575393677,
-0.46213504672050476,
0.13829557597637177,
0.5672323107719421,
0.9189653992652893,
-0.22873251140117645,
0.11192357540130615,
-0.41101235151290894,
0.5892598628997803,
-0.892082691192627,
0.2326030135154724,
-0.6986387968063354,
0.3687726557254791,
0.25682333111763,
0.09678041934967041,
-0.23596598207950592,
-0.22877296805381775,
-0.11198195815086365,
-0.4485388398170471,
0.0805605798959732,
0.11046609282493591,
0.4733456075191498,
0.1836545318365097,
-0.250247061252594,
-0.12321825325489044,
-1.03677237033844,
0.5244507789611816,
-0.43196219205856323,
0.4812796413898468,
0.36387842893600464,
0.5458504557609558,
-0.5711150169372559,
-0.40910789370536804,
-0.4904104471206665,
-0.15258607268333435,
0.2130959928035736,
0.2389274537563324,
0.1804499328136444,
-0.13557122647762299,
0.5918153524398804,
0.20325274765491486,
-0.3863987922668457,
0.3692736029624939,
-0.0004028411058243364,
0.35325178503990173,
0.42381608486175537,
0.19624154269695282,
-0.10445515066385269,
-0.036024097353219986,
-0.452621191740036,
-0.07498764991760254,
-1.04253351688385,
0.26611053943634033,
0.26962727308273315,
0.4110621213912964,
-0.09726151078939438,
0.9571703672409058,
-0.7078336477279663,
0.247699573636055,
-0.24085624516010284,
0.15190620720386505,
-0.1266808956861496,
0.12326207011938095,
-0.42905569076538086,
0.004964647348970175,
0.1632092297077179,
0.5140454173088074,
0.6297095417976379,
-0.15445730090141296,
-0.44203290343284607,
-0.11712252348661423,
0.2699183523654938,
-0.5615943074226379,
0.012748029083013535,
0.35041478276252747,
-0.3984067738056183,
-0.2432444542646408,
-0.15365159511566162,
-0.7629194855690002,
-0.4306442141532898,
-0.5170234441757202,
0.03910525515675545,
-0.3563043177127838,
-0.6272667050361633,
0.37198299169540405,
0.20490050315856934,
0.29443979263305664,
0.3313490152359009,
-0.8158010840415955,
0.6227648854255676,
0.6773548126220703,
0.3586042523384094,
0.1269315630197525,
-0.28551197052001953,
-0.7841338515281677,
0.3143063485622406,
-0.6228067278862,
0.6232610940933228,
-0.2600984573364258,
-0.5637579560279846,
0.4004092216491699,
-0.25221049785614014,
0.1940140426158905,
-0.5975165367126465,
0.7072576880455017,
-0.307922899723053,
-0.03665664792060852,
-0.5725452899932861,
-0.2272997796535492,
-0.12272613495588303,
0.6516331434249878,
-0.48577743768692017,
1.0631955862045288,
0.1137603297829628,
-0.2996634244918823,
0.7203712463378906,
-0.5348103642463684,
-0.15216581523418427,
0.06615948677062988,
-0.6257778406143188,
-0.11962465941905975,
0.30498960614204407,
0.15597651898860931,
0.5469539165496826,
-0.45040619373321533,
0.6179792284965515,
-0.06731749325990677,
-0.12001102417707443,
0.06823830306529999,
0.0022238201927393675,
0.5632625222206116,
0.023747049272060394,
-0.5353228449821472,
0.4966507852077484,
-0.9766793847084045,
0.4688683748245239,
0.2703471779823303,
-0.38698825240135193,
-0.07899222522974014,
0.6024742722511292,
-0.2487511932849884,
0.47551506757736206,
-0.15516310930252075,
-0.3947973847389221,
0.19763942062854767,
-0.29497030377388,
0.20670028030872345,
0.7920612096786499,
-0.021087970584630966,
0.4294162392616272,
-0.4128241539001465,
0.369750052690506,
-0.2014605849981308,
0.05223824828863144,
-0.2796836495399475,
-0.27491554617881775,
-0.6833525896072388,
-0.11642969399690628,
-0.07111387699842453,
0.34821203351020813,
-0.4723876416683197,
0.45390254259109497,
-0.39086979627609253,
-0.47635963559150696,
0.06773321330547333,
-0.3897305428981781,
0.3711756467819214,
0.45599809288978577,
0.3865339756011963,
-0.1407429277896881,
-0.4136660397052765,
-0.5159467458724976,
-0.26832422614097595,
-0.2154860943555832,
0.16735726594924927,
0.38509947061538696,
0.4193858802318573,
0.18688401579856873,
1.1633644104003906,
-0.6132264733314514,
-0.3005230724811554,
-0.22958329319953918,
-0.021020779386162758,
0.1774299293756485,
0.3548900783061981,
0.48828068375587463,
-0.8498677611351013,
-0.2751357853412628,
0.03901498764753342,
-0.8414429426193237,
0.016378939151763916,
-0.10132984071969986,
-0.15690700709819794,
-0.27990251779556274,
0.7334437370300293,
-0.7751258015632629,
0.5161418914794922,
0.13806995749473572,
-0.30762529373168945,
0.700588583946228,
-0.12639738619327545,
-0.18046307563781738,
-0.7274285554885864,
0.13029882311820984,
-0.21980158984661102,
-0.16887550055980682,
-0.5759903192520142,
0.606456995010376,
0.1804453581571579,
-0.5710992813110352,
-0.6443638801574707,
0.6869913339614868,
-0.5998613834381104,
-0.32364967465400696,
0.02925572544336319,
-0.19486072659492493,
-0.3943951725959778,
0.7486249208450317,
0.3305904269218445,
0.6637950539588928,
0.2569010257720947,
-0.6840498447418213,
0.03982444852590561,
0.44134020805358887,
-0.2621215879917145,
0.49654898047447205,
-0.3905388116836548,
-0.022008251398801804,
-0.11933592706918716,
0.20939789712429047,
-0.47956597805023193,
-0.45554596185684204,
0.35136181116104126,
-0.08604802191257477,
0.22483140230178833,
-0.09885670244693756,
-0.505888044834137,
-0.2677198052406311,
-0.17419780790805817,
0.22239507734775543,
0.6661972403526306,
-0.6118367910385132,
0.7735306620597839,
0.09873693436384201,
-0.06998465210199356,
-0.2805072069168091,
-0.3006414771080017,
0.0007353125838562846,
-0.10634514689445496,
-0.6044453978538513,
0.2984768748283386,
0.10890071094036102,
-0.6032884120941162,
0.07524732500314713,
-0.3152436912059784,
0.061581991612911224,
0.15848995745182037,
0.6834427118301392,
-0.2911863327026367,
-0.20513767004013062,
-0.16365721821784973,
-0.2058594971895218,
-0.24674616754055023,
0.2176535725593567,
-0.3842008709907532,
0.4997030198574066,
0.15644878149032593,
-0.6405243873596191,
0.1450451910495758,
0.5159735083580017,
0.5885867476463318,
-0.48766082525253296,
0.4329833388328552,
-0.25599464774131775,
-0.670676589012146,
-0.3999364972114563,
-0.3268444836139679,
0.4611464738845825,
-0.39979687333106995,
-0.026364188641309738,
-0.711323082447052,
-0.47515174746513367,
0.32007935643196106,
-0.7339057922363281,
0.4685991704463959,
0.10135389119386673,
0.3786800503730774,
0.130416139960289,
0.7711663842201233,
0.680395245552063,
0.32441896200180054,
0.02926168404519558,
-0.0726097971200943,
0.12166580557823181,
-0.5415357947349548,
-0.4928284287452698,
-0.5328555703163147,
-0.29180365800857544,
-0.1749042570590973,
-0.6568892598152161,
0.14909663796424866,
0.2546531856060028,
-0.3800884187221527,
0.26523488759994507,
-0.03646344318985939,
0.36516353487968445,
0.5804237723350525,
-0.2719610631465912,
0.16594946384429932,
-0.05371371656656265,
-0.7409653663635254,
-0.07374604046344757,
-0.46477261185646057,
-0.6946547031402588,
0.8952106237411499,
0.3675617277622223,
0.5355144143104553,
0.18785099685192108,
0.5659735202789307,
-0.10723286867141724,
0.11999968439340591,
-0.5968025922775269,
0.8196544051170349,
0.3108985424041748,
-0.43290916085243225,
-0.32406526803970337,
-0.07087040692567825,
-0.49363741278648376,
0.39998891949653625,
-0.45276811718940735,
-0.5830267667770386,
0.3122914433479309,
-0.05663059279322624,
0.066167913377285,
0.4847830533981323,
-0.5284428000450134,
0.46524494886398315,
-0.470541775226593,
-0.5240995287895203,
-0.02390381693840027,
-0.51389080286026,
0.26129350066185,
-0.07531251013278961,
0.18562275171279907,
-0.47357749938964844,
0.1900656372308731,
0.29456865787506104,
-0.2871921956539154,
0.6422231197357178,
-0.512691080570221,
-0.05236806347966194,
0.20079068839550018,
0.15730735659599304,
0.8093461990356445,
-0.06987427175045013,
-0.26463568210601807,
0.010531925596296787,
-0.6235675811767578,
-0.26867982745170593,
-0.24216225743293762,
0.5445346236228943,
-0.5631601214408875,
-0.4048037827014923,
-0.3849240243434906,
-0.46188613772392273,
-0.7167350649833679,
0.42660021781921387,
0.04062948003411293,
0.22169926762580872,
-0.9678937792778015,
-0.0035444507375359535,
0.6070956587791443,
-0.46965548396110535,
0.48693016171455383,
0.6118775606155396,
-0.6270421147346497,
-0.5345132350921631,
0.5381045341491699,
0.13403286039829254,
0.24904370307922363,
0.3180224895477295,
0.04542412608861923,
-0.07484093308448792,
-0.7985221743583679,
-0.30179548263549805,
-0.08197176456451416,
-0.5895710587501526,
0.04174121469259262,
-0.39393681287765503,
-0.2790640592575073,
-0.2775159180164337,
-0.4837561547756195,
-0.37716224789619446,
-0.2799728512763977,
0.008561867289245129,
-0.3083767294883728,
-0.2097240835428238,
0.6605009436607361,
0.0192829929292202,
0.012064347974956036,
-0.3287745416164398,
0.6047368049621582,
0.06319858878850937,
0.5181379318237305,
-0.20669837296009064,
0.3690994679927826,
0.010516572743654251,
0.14955450594425201,
-0.3268011212348938,
-0.4821713864803314,
0.4456556737422943,
-0.203327015042305,
0.8688248991966248,
0.5077252984046936,
0.410078763961792,
0.6480941772460938,
-0.9041193127632141,
0.64557284116745,
0.2044428288936615,
-0.3658527731895447,
0.7061727643013,
-0.5499991774559021,
0.18938995897769928,
0.672627866268158,
0.4255233407020569,
-0.3727591335773468,
-0.040036533027887344,
-0.8059948682785034,
-0.9239716529846191,
0.6033200025558472,
0.38558724522590637,
-0.13530446588993073,
-0.011990982107818127,
0.23566576838493347,
0.2726331353187561,
0.41199424862861633,
-0.6614007353782654,
0.14055366814136505,
-0.03826531767845154,
0.35895925760269165,
-0.3602420687675476,
-0.5068171620368958,
-0.3992288112640381,
-0.11384239792823792,
0.31769484281539917,
-0.26316037774086,
0.2762851119041443,
-0.09161069244146347,
-0.019642114639282227,
-0.5310972929000854,
0.39718836545944214,
0.7766813039779663,
0.5433096885681152,
-0.40397027134895325,
0.16981278359889984,
0.15933628380298615,
-0.038909658789634705,
0.3477232754230499,
-0.004101164173334837,
-0.3529798686504364,
-0.3592670261859894,
0.22171947360038757,
0.676604151725769,
0.5102980136871338,
-0.9660463929176331,
0.3465955853462219,
-0.004413096699863672,
-0.6631851196289062,
-0.619362473487854,
0.09145667403936386,
0.016345474869012833,
0.24525907635688782,
0.19680260121822357,
0.06543979048728943,
-0.6287959814071655,
-0.5336088538169861,
-0.06381750851869583,
0.20305658876895905,
-0.48970526456832886,
-0.230143204331398,
0.679912269115448,
0.261140912771225,
-0.41449227929115295,
0.5237531661987305,
-0.14198735356330872,
-0.2662765085697174,
0.4241480529308319,
0.5677001476287842,
1.030165433883667,
0.058346107602119446,
0.05906381085515022,
0.2263329029083252,
0.4976724088191986,
-0.07799888402223587,
0.9120088815689087,
0.11023198813199997,
-0.7229153513908386,
-0.11084873974323273,
-0.4988558292388916,
-0.6088945865631104,
0.22128136456012726,
-0.6363052129745483,
0.5724722146987915,
-0.8568867444992065,
0.29943299293518066,
-0.632466733455658,
-0.0954233929514885,
-0.6502829194068909,
0.40635839104652405,
-0.05947133153676987,
1.3583160638809204,
-0.7958119511604309,
0.31830576062202454,
1.0809060335159302,
-0.24686244130134583,
-0.6429616808891296,
0.3389807343482971,
0.08038606494665146,
-0.7636896967887878,
0.7419862151145935,
0.2895839512348175,
-0.11328825354576111,
-0.01633780635893345,
-0.3588307797908783,
-0.7736479043960571,
1.1399332284927368,
0.14424648880958557,
-0.29627901315689087,
-0.32593101263046265,
0.21599619090557098,
0.17271248996257782,
-0.3958679139614105,
-0.2426319122314453,
0.22877059876918793,
0.4515664279460907,
0.07758887857198715,
-0.5784937143325806,
0.15342764556407928,
0.030141495168209076,
-0.2344922125339508,
0.4605601727962494,
-0.5383252501487732,
0.8733282089233398,
-0.18762779235839844,
-0.41063201427459717,
0.007920058444142342,
0.7501875162124634,
0.305036336183548,
0.4007669985294342,
0.4315418004989624,
0.8444772362709045,
0.7060386538505554,
0.05217364430427551,
0.7565807104110718,
-0.000006216833298822166,
-0.009172490797936916,
1.307525873184204,
-1.044663667678833,
1.125044822692871,
0.2068900614976883,
0.015394290909171104,
0.17974166572093964,
0.532984733581543,
0.30439436435699463,
0.8267893195152283,
0.33449840545654297,
-0.3286423683166504,
-0.15747500956058502,
0.003785132896155119,
-0.36217403411865234,
0.5261853933334351,
0.3839051127433777,
0.04601261019706726,
-0.7089391350746155,
-0.01199952233582735,
-0.11001312732696533,
0.49713262915611267,
-0.3758179545402527,
0.5315831303596497,
-0.11206633597612381,
-0.822830080986023,
0.3366173803806305,
0.26958292722702026,
0.09714281558990479,
-0.4557263255119324,
-0.16732525825500488,
0.0640992820262909,
0.12471096962690353,
0.0440061017870903,
-0.6936984658241272,
0.3036612570285797,
0.10602736473083496,
-0.12272213399410248,
-0.7624553442001343,
0.9543870687484741,
0.061542779207229614,
0.05212051048874855,
0.4301246702671051,
0.7746167778968811,
-0.034544896334409714,
-0.26260894536972046,
-0.223488450050354,
-0.09132909774780273,
-0.28671467304229736,
-0.22311171889305115,
0.49309441447257996,
0.664544939994812,
-0.44829481840133667,
0.6482657790184021,
0.7240572571754456,
0.07099103927612305,
0.09126178175210953,
-0.2582683563232422,
1.0535794496536255,
-0.9567694067955017,
-0.7459721565246582,
-0.325789213180542,
0.5947766304016113,
-0.10140370577573776,
-0.4218277037143707,
0.3929400146007538,
0.6742176413536072,
0.9246072769165039,
-0.06512719392776489,
0.7496506571769714,
-0.08093657344579697,
0.5526816844940186,
-0.9461584091186523,
0.3574065566062927,
-0.1847960352897644,
0.18637557327747345,
0.008548545651137829,
-1.0260196924209595,
-0.10021021217107773,
0.4047272503376007,
-0.35298776626586914,
-0.17545054852962494,
0.757901132106781,
0.3527039587497711,
-0.22062727808952332,
0.0037521400954574347,
0.5869432687759399,
-0.24588002264499664,
0.46506795287132263,
0.5090129375457764,
0.9851338267326355,
0.11489807069301605,
0.035024140030145645,
-0.1781930774450302,
-0.40470683574676514,
-0.23945645987987518,
-1.1776514053344727,
-0.9629754424095154,
-0.3757123649120331,
-0.010913209058344364,
-0.10924793034791946,
0.043288704007864,
1.1992682218551636,
0.5845229029655457,
-0.5878004431724548,
-0.38864320516586304,
-0.6349086761474609,
-0.12160900235176086,
-0.31247982382774353,
-0.1420268714427948,
-0.045381005853414536,
-0.0964290127158165,
-0.26418745517730713,
0.8721392750740051,
0.1834930181503296,
0.0895092636346817,
-0.10738071799278259,
-0.3001873791217804,
-0.3818782567977905,
-0.07102566212415695,
0.5995170474052429,
0.8345291018486023,
-0.7312942147254944,
-0.41004395484924316,
-0.051981616765260696,
0.07164986431598663,
-0.033585332334041595,
1.2090789079666138,
-0.9125204086303711,
0.3543427586555481,
0.14069633185863495,
0.6221669912338257,
0.5555277466773987,
0.06256350129842758,
0.7545890808105469,
-1.0689398050308228,
0.2347981184720993,
0.4711272120475769,
0.24866226315498352,
-0.09927275031805038,
-0.1213458701968193,
0.8636417984962463,
-0.12830397486686707,
-0.3662988543510437,
-0.7505260109901428,
0.4918186068534851,
-0.8447544574737549,
-0.23057833313941956,
1.2839982509613037,
-0.08787660300731659,
0.2732161283493042,
-0.0755520686507225,
-0.3111104667186737,
-0.05037229508161545,
-0.06015395745635033,
0.25012505054473877,
0.7251692414283752,
-0.3029289245605469,
0.00017912001931108534,
-0.7396227717399597,
0.3103973865509033,
0.14573876559734344,
-0.820730447769165,
0.46357035636901855,
0.9112790822982788,
-0.0330522283911705,
-0.057071566581726074,
1.0422741174697876,
0.13380256295204163,
0.10197924077510834,
0.1356843262910843,
0.3231932520866394,
-0.3528068959712982,
-0.7856781482696533,
-0.14853574335575104,
0.5992321968078613,
0.35551363229751587,
-0.05305371806025505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02902v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02902v2
|
S$^2$GSL: Incorporating Segment to Syntactic Enhanced Graph Structure Learning for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-06-05T03:44:35 | 2024-06-07T07:32:50 |
Bingfeng Chen, Qihan Ouyang, Yongqi Luo, Boyan Xu, Ruichu Cai, Zhifeng Hao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous graph-based approaches in Aspect based Sentiment Analysis(ABSA) have
demonstrated impressive performance by utilizing graph neural networks and
attention mechanisms to learn structures of static dependency trees and dynamic
latent trees. However, incorporating both semantic and syntactic information
simultaneously within complex global structures can introduce irrelevant
contexts and syntactic dependencies during the process of graph structure
learning, potentially resulting in inaccurate predictions. In order to address
the issues above, we propose S$^2$GSL, incorporating Segment to Syntactic
enhanced Graph Structure Learning for ABSA. Specifically,S$^2$GSL is featured
with a segment-aware semantic graph learning and a syntax-based latent graph
learning enabling the removal of irrelevant contexts and dependencies,
respectively. We further propose a self-adaptive aggregation network that
facilitates the fusion of two graph learning branches, thereby achieving
complementarity across diverse structures. Experimental results on four
benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework.
|
[
-0.18838508427143097,
-0.965925395488739,
0.6743305921554565,
0.29615721106529236,
-0.7162238359451294,
0.49356967210769653,
0.1872851699590683,
-0.43460431694984436,
0.7646385431289673,
0.3980257213115692,
-0.4625873267650604,
-0.6554040312767029,
-0.508598268032074,
-0.0015560331521555781,
-0.0047670090571045876,
1.4567841291427612,
-0.0268945824354887,
0.19661474227905273,
-0.39027297496795654,
-0.47492218017578125,
-0.0045225960202515125,
-0.7202525734901428,
-0.7126032114028931,
0.05550109222531319,
0.5987470149993896,
0.14364643394947052,
0.3190233111381531,
0.4369810223579407,
0.37823304533958435,
0.2922719717025757,
-0.32188090682029724,
0.193281888961792,
-0.11861170083284378,
0.3507947027683258,
-0.3938366174697876,
-0.30036845803260803,
-0.8266521692276001,
-0.2899453341960907,
0.7153860926628113,
0.796416163444519,
0.03745333105325699,
-0.07771104574203491,
0.2792614698410034,
0.9739310145378113,
-0.335017591714859,
0.6666898131370544,
-0.5567793250083923,
0.12533259391784668,
-0.10582099109888077,
0.34890827536582947,
-0.16113194823265076,
-0.09162736684083939,
-0.12351640313863754,
-0.2263532280921936,
0.08165836334228516,
-0.04358397051692009,
0.8354568481445312,
0.24574878811836243,
-0.3894069492816925,
-0.22528916597366333,
-0.07234833389520645,
0.4469658434391022,
-0.5109716653823853,
0.4633237421512604,
0.14944179356098175,
0.03400684893131256,
0.22017891705036163,
-0.832770824432373,
-0.197950080037117,
0.29982930421829224,
-0.2076014280319214,
0.3642716109752655,
-0.12436734884977341,
0.19915102422237396,
-0.11786454170942307,
0.5599076747894287,
-0.36696335673332214,
-0.028529183939099312,
-0.39208105206489563,
-0.18424856662750244,
0.7580609321594238,
0.10652732104063034,
0.11705204844474792,
-0.6283480525016785,
-0.41112902760505676,
0.2972991168498993,
-0.723069965839386,
0.23837317526340485,
0.415894478559494,
0.7362899780273438,
-0.3063925504684448,
0.29272568225860596,
-0.20569923520088196,
0.5050104260444641,
0.25383231043815613,
0.27536410093307495,
0.5081083178520203,
-0.41387179493904114,
-0.20403310656547546,
-0.13381071388721466,
0.8225120902061462,
0.28748223185539246,
-0.4294310510158539,
-0.12940117716789246,
-0.20481514930725098,
0.02833057940006256,
0.3483126163482666,
-0.7236765623092651,
-0.4784228801727295,
0.375093936920166,
-0.356487900018692,
-0.16184017062187195,
-0.09377749264240265,
-0.732532799243927,
-0.33416634798049927,
-0.21888282895088196,
0.06689253449440002,
-0.4505493938922882,
-0.22144079208374023,
-0.4643001854419708,
0.028781121596693993,
-0.0357561893761158,
0.2643655836582184,
-0.7688732147216797,
0.12292984127998352,
0.8037065863609314,
0.9494084119796753,
-0.07457823306322098,
-0.27849364280700684,
-0.48991379141807556,
-0.05656051263213158,
-0.25839748978614807,
1.0857841968536377,
-0.5474299192428589,
-0.42756953835487366,
-0.3091888725757599,
0.042314562946558,
-0.15169484913349152,
-0.29063960909843445,
0.3362245261669159,
-0.5414700508117676,
0.10218441486358643,
-0.29422953724861145,
-0.3685959577560425,
-0.5680115222930908,
0.39343422651290894,
-0.4730861485004425,
1.1163909435272217,
0.6572623252868652,
-0.818120002746582,
0.12326796352863312,
-0.5349154472351074,
-0.8142122626304626,
-0.06332316249608994,
-0.41624659299850464,
-0.7907822132110596,
0.21505959331989288,
0.26572340726852417,
0.44969817996025085,
0.19782906770706177,
0.2506472170352936,
-0.4903227686882019,
0.2749735713005066,
0.06851829588413239,
0.03914960101246834,
0.4757089912891388,
0.22148534655570984,
-0.006909131072461605,
0.6515904068946838,
-0.4943922162055969,
-0.03309766948223114,
0.04788580164313316,
-0.09312491118907928,
-0.30275043845176697,
0.23269744217395782,
-0.2371760904788971,
0.23373383283615112,
0.3847118020057678,
-0.49391916394233704,
0.11557362228631973,
-0.7277626395225525,
0.41180258989334106,
0.7433210015296936,
0.23891903460025787,
0.37648457288742065,
0.28871816396713257,
0.38797301054000854,
0.17949064075946808,
0.11829271167516708,
-0.14848560094833374,
-0.10756237059831619,
-0.8076046705245972,
-0.2001447081565857,
0.03199687972664833,
0.2195698469877243,
-0.862901508808136,
0.713001012802124,
-0.20334184169769287,
-0.2650253474712372,
-0.17974133789539337,
0.25619077682495117,
0.5282394886016846,
0.5443951487541199,
0.4289678931236267,
-0.9264259934425354,
-0.541893720626831,
-0.8332387804985046,
-0.16251912713050842,
-0.5212367177009583,
0.29761120676994324,
0.4736091196537018,
0.20768141746520996,
0.1429262012243271,
1.0953750610351562,
-0.6918197274208069,
-0.5213578343391418,
-0.6832888722419739,
-0.15597957372665405,
-0.1343669295310974,
0.09330674260854721,
0.6541094779968262,
-0.6276142001152039,
-0.5565893650054932,
-0.07962504774332047,
-0.8120670914649963,
0.003360053291544318,
0.19809037446975708,
-0.05587499961256981,
0.30801254510879517,
0.47084543108940125,
-0.3129436671733856,
0.20559923350811005,
0.5868895053863525,
-0.7182519435882568,
0.35478246212005615,
0.1389780342578888,
-0.3970082104206085,
-1.4338146448135376,
-0.31236323714256287,
0.07185102254152298,
-0.33475592732429504,
-0.40331727266311646,
0.26602309942245483,
0.029320620000362396,
-0.12724438309669495,
-0.43152517080307007,
0.26083895564079285,
-0.3779737949371338,
-0.48111388087272644,
-0.4866314232349396,
0.1244327574968338,
0.37298110127449036,
0.6968957185745239,
-0.0920998826622963,
0.6839672327041626,
0.604279637336731,
-0.1749379187822342,
0.10399457812309265,
0.13756966590881348,
0.04916459694504738,
0.6056761145591736,
-0.5056037306785583,
0.210252046585083,
-0.1336386501789093,
0.5061718225479126,
-0.9532925486564636,
-0.16638460755348206,
0.7633641362190247,
-0.2616339921951294,
0.3231915533542633,
-0.3480943441390991,
-0.03146464005112648,
-0.054987479001283646,
-0.46276313066482544,
0.4079129695892334,
0.038276366889476776,
-0.35458260774612427,
1.0147641897201538,
0.6081069111824036,
-0.5581275224685669,
-0.3238842487335205,
-0.32546254992485046,
0.0635085180401802,
-0.06606972217559814,
-0.4825392961502075,
0.1541542410850525,
0.21251918375492096,
-0.11505122482776642,
0.33216896653175354,
-0.19503624737262726,
0.0950375571846962,
0.2859092950820923,
0.4170930087566376,
0.16224321722984314,
-0.2700338363647461,
0.06390425562858582,
0.2789989411830902,
-0.2921249568462372,
-0.008425782434642315,
-0.3728008568286896,
0.6984665393829346,
-0.5529884099960327,
-0.4365391135215759,
-0.29365307092666626,
0.4234990179538727,
0.2257302701473236,
-0.5096782445907593,
0.42715486884117126,
0.32831454277038574,
-0.05850176140666008,
-0.21336206793785095,
-0.08331216871738434,
0.10165136307477951,
-0.41847509145736694,
0.9317810535430908,
-0.3874013423919678,
-1.090944528579712,
0.6250518560409546,
0.04838493466377258,
-0.29964500665664673,
0.6615370512008667,
0.4447382092475891,
-0.12370496243238449,
0.9017157554626465,
0.45286479592323303,
-0.45244938135147095,
0.7919189929962158,
-0.37204766273498535,
0.4011988639831543,
-1.253344178199768,
-0.1395246982574463,
-0.2320111244916916,
-0.04345055669546127,
-0.14827273786067963,
-0.5282943248748779,
0.31884923577308655,
0.487852543592453,
-0.15103031694889069,
-0.0012215146562084556,
-0.372517466545105,
0.3942870795726776,
0.05208636075258255,
0.18165326118469238,
-0.08529651165008545,
0.22319486737251282,
0.1977280080318451,
0.23734748363494873,
-0.46271634101867676,
-0.15391287207603455,
0.7650510668754578,
0.36686211824417114,
0.4947270452976227,
0.08547582477331161,
0.6013228297233582,
0.391777902841568,
0.4009108543395996,
-1.050126552581787,
0.5216135382652283,
-0.544446587562561,
0.02192589081823826,
-0.22808748483657837,
-0.32900410890579224,
-0.6317959427833557,
0.5050064325332642,
0.24476991593837738,
-0.80705726146698,
-0.06610240787267685,
0.046012334525585175,
-0.37752023339271545,
0.2686917185783386,
-0.4321140646934509,
0.8015356659889221,
-0.30212023854255676,
-0.3460226058959961,
-0.17487776279449463,
-0.6252396702766418,
-0.1100548580288887,
0.20780770480632782,
0.26254159212112427,
-0.3357113003730774,
0.11125665158033371,
0.627889096736908,
-0.3448010981082916,
1.2188373804092407,
-0.4558538794517517,
-0.1420755535364151,
0.6017957925796509,
-0.03170735761523247,
0.6456679105758667,
0.13364166021347046,
-0.009962768293917179,
0.41349151730537415,
-0.4092966914176941,
-0.4223996102809906,
-0.7129115462303162,
0.49059149622917175,
-0.8076847791671753,
-0.7313190698623657,
-0.3289605379104614,
-0.3665767312049866,
-0.35429254174232483,
0.16758304834365845,
-0.12864086031913757,
0.5101678371429443,
0.007668145000934601,
-0.08720969408750534,
-0.07655821740627289,
0.3611313998699188,
0.46956607699394226,
0.4043445885181427,
-0.4018884301185608,
-0.8765951991081238,
1.1276979446411133,
0.16368530690670013,
0.15598870813846588,
-0.008739258162677288,
0.24432840943336487,
-0.4847719073295593,
-0.7665623426437378,
-0.7608004212379456,
0.2441997230052948,
-0.7674140334129333,
-0.3249029219150543,
-0.8285695910453796,
-0.36559149622917175,
-0.46119725704193115,
-0.09117301553487778,
-0.4123089611530304,
-0.35550054907798767,
-0.24321195483207703,
-0.4524180293083191,
0.19724807143211365,
0.6863366365432739,
0.24929283559322357,
0.39944735169410706,
-0.7110055088996887,
-0.01869298703968525,
0.1504386067390442,
0.42782655358314514,
0.016209617257118225,
-0.25081872940063477,
-0.41784077882766724,
-0.2213907539844513,
-0.4773026704788208,
-0.757632851600647,
0.1730206310749054,
0.2567313313484192,
0.35779687762260437,
0.5673847198486328,
-0.15901578962802887,
0.5048397183418274,
-0.3149574100971222,
1.1176965236663818,
0.2651914358139038,
-1.0441876649856567,
0.6220278143882751,
-0.14684565365314484,
-0.07154330611228943,
0.6083754301071167,
0.10601532459259033,
-0.578529417514801,
-0.6328669786453247,
-0.6983344554901123,
-1.1181987524032593,
0.7789275646209717,
-0.114145927131176,
0.14758716523647308,
0.016153769567608833,
0.4961681067943573,
0.1934511512517929,
0.1524399369955063,
-0.8107551336288452,
-0.19014380872249603,
-0.4978090226650238,
-0.5897774696350098,
0.11808517575263977,
-0.4410512447357178,
-0.19325408339500427,
-0.06111476570367813,
0.7065788507461548,
-0.6613523364067078,
-0.09671629220247269,
0.19517286121845245,
-0.032940808683633804,
0.06113559752702713,
0.21346762776374817,
0.02333124540746212,
0.5189314484596252,
0.049471836537122726,
0.3220570683479309,
0.21562476456165314,
-0.2074679732322693,
0.024540185928344727,
0.17030848562717438,
-0.3842273950576782,
-0.32488492131233215,
0.4410645365715027,
1.1720465421676636,
0.08206474781036377,
-0.12770961225032806,
0.5074014067649841,
0.2056574672460556,
-0.006836718413978815,
-0.0462924987077713,
-0.013060483150184155,
0.1298583447933197,
0.498726487159729,
0.2526189982891083,
0.11859102547168732,
0.15643754601478577,
-0.5643879771232605,
0.37351611256599426,
0.4069671332836151,
-1.0374119281768799,
-0.8404263854026794,
0.288722962141037,
0.3137502372264862,
-0.19468650221824646,
0.2394120693206787,
-0.6483398675918579,
-1.0393755435943604,
0.5825963616371155,
0.5464160442352295,
1.1182217597961426,
-0.2116297334432602,
0.4322967529296875,
0.15684817731380463,
-0.13489192724227905,
0.444425106048584,
0.4723453223705292,
-0.14982952177524567,
-0.7318242192268372,
-0.4089074730873108,
-0.9520204663276672,
-0.21967600286006927,
-0.3706391155719757,
-0.5707511305809021,
-0.21142560243606567,
-0.6946733593940735,
0.025159217417240143,
-0.07974608242511749,
-0.06728643923997879,
-0.04087148606777191,
0.37462860345840454,
-0.024186883121728897,
0.37702012062072754,
-1.1485011577606201,
0.6647351384162903,
1.0113331079483032,
-0.7029658555984497,
-0.9732339382171631,
0.23173803091049194,
-0.11427395790815353,
-0.5977147221565247,
0.5043281316757202,
0.3492954969406128,
-0.2665420472621918,
-0.25791648030281067,
-0.16781188547611237,
-0.902458906173706,
0.9016028642654419,
0.03983823210000992,
-0.03753019869327545,
0.3663557767868042,
-0.0671350434422493,
0.7149170637130737,
-0.6871610283851624,
0.04212145134806633,
0.2975243628025055,
-0.047416336834430695,
0.13839086890220642,
-0.31253084540367126,
0.1823771893978119,
-0.20751918852329254,
-0.011500360444188118,
0.3813280463218689,
-1.3128259181976318,
0.970004141330719,
0.024051601067185402,
-0.3898448646068573,
-0.27144545316696167,
1.2523524761199951,
0.09773615747690201,
0.6910308003425598,
0.8042458295822144,
0.5271790027618408,
0.6117696762084961,
-0.08691912144422531,
0.8092181086540222,
-0.5320959687232971,
0.6011626124382019,
1.3198941946029663,
-0.46398666501045227,
0.9486923813819885,
0.3607425391674042,
-0.5525431632995605,
0.9581255912780762,
0.7770152688026428,
0.17044691741466522,
0.5368733406066895,
-0.17277298867702484,
-0.31611594557762146,
-0.23903612792491913,
-0.4904859960079193,
-0.3488852083683014,
0.5597916841506958,
0.5254072546958923,
-0.4199954867362976,
-0.3866146206855774,
-0.20878461003303528,
0.11842577159404755,
-0.026380199939012527,
-0.3336496949195862,
0.9941504001617432,
0.23329341411590576,
-0.42599350214004517,
-0.22621223330497742,
-0.0037679453380405903,
0.2862708866596222,
-0.6719707250595093,
0.2950493395328522,
-0.490938276052475,
-0.08497304469347,
-0.5035538077354431,
-0.8930608630180359,
0.7498653531074524,
-0.13897375762462616,
-0.2084072232246399,
0.07183393090963364,
0.7727536559104919,
-0.4461877942085266,
-0.763023853302002,
0.46868768334388733,
0.493019700050354,
-0.002059787744656205,
-0.24656985700130463,
-0.7005439400672913,
-0.08292021602392197,
0.14929048717021942,
-0.3049679696559906,
0.47856420278549194,
0.3773203492164612,
-0.1402178406715393,
0.3016575872898102,
0.4760816693305969,
0.1195993423461914,
-0.561657190322876,
0.2913425862789154,
1.2493818998336792,
-0.6426294445991516,
-1.1282659769058228,
-0.9262357354164124,
0.40296831727027893,
-0.34840214252471924,
-0.10689368098974228,
0.8943732976913452,
0.8610177636146545,
0.6394720673561096,
0.34784555435180664,
0.9462948441505432,
-0.20161651074886322,
0.2681347131729126,
-0.772613525390625,
0.4268331527709961,
-0.6492159366607666,
0.1802261620759964,
-0.03457266092300415,
-0.9137608408927917,
-0.4150836169719696,
0.3489258587360382,
-0.49169984459877014,
-0.01311187818646431,
0.7933481335639954,
0.6540990471839905,
-0.04795343056321144,
0.2948782444000244,
-0.0794643685221672,
0.2348451316356659,
0.45164331793785095,
0.2570941150188446,
0.7307404279708862,
-0.08505062013864517,
0.2762230336666107,
-0.13418470323085785,
-0.1686001867055893,
-0.19816169142723083,
-0.572999894618988,
-0.6877659559249878,
-0.48184558749198914,
-0.4439223110675812,
-0.7371479868888855,
-0.08728701621294022,
0.8282116055488586,
0.3567000925540924,
-0.8736636638641357,
0.15116319060325623,
-0.016717586666345596,
0.4033038914203644,
-0.22592180967330933,
-0.29455307126045227,
1.0444170236587524,
-0.6806865930557251,
-0.4880935251712799,
0.5968398451805115,
0.9833928942680359,
-0.10566755384206772,
-0.34499314427375793,
0.018874019384384155,
0.15912604331970215,
-0.14885614812374115,
0.8447316288948059,
0.19710099697113037,
-0.6975938081741333,
-0.7044467926025391,
-0.41594254970550537,
-0.07427225261926651,
0.4658178389072418,
0.811468780040741,
-0.4761849045753479,
0.3823012113571167,
0.5183554291725159,
0.6348599195480347,
0.3472599685192108,
0.5293996334075928,
0.12989582121372223,
-1.0935944318771362,
0.13497190177440643,
0.16839547455310822,
0.5222779512405396,
0.5186154842376709,
-0.3456246256828308,
0.5317186713218689,
0.5255879163742065,
-0.16477976739406586,
-0.3568827509880066,
0.5861600041389465,
-1.0685125589370728,
-0.478032648563385,
1.1348775625228882,
-0.5527963042259216,
-0.5147759318351746,
-0.17626741528511047,
-0.3239568769931793,
0.2852367162704468,
-0.4435414969921112,
0.6614474654197693,
0.42709946632385254,
-0.6080617904663086,
0.21500007808208466,
0.2611948251724243,
0.37034162878990173,
0.5549532771110535,
-1.034579873085022,
0.23561519384384155,
0.6800669431686401,
0.25678572058677673,
0.2218322455883026,
0.9388802647590637,
-0.05506779998540878,
-0.1545497179031372,
0.1732269823551178,
-0.05330278351902962,
-0.2679916024208069,
-0.5177731513977051,
-0.416040301322937,
0.60442715883255,
0.11770389974117279,
-0.23721806704998016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02900v1
|
Scaling Laws for Reward Model Overoptimization in Direct Alignment Algorithms
| 2024-06-05T03:41:37 | 2024-06-05T03:41:37 |
Rafael Rafailov, Yaswanth Chittepu, Ryan Park, Harshit Sikchi, Joey Hejna, Bradley Knox, Chelsea Finn, Scott Niekum
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has been crucial to the
recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs), however, it is often a complex
and brittle process. In the classical RLHF framework, a reward model is first
trained to represent human preferences, which is in turn used by an online
reinforcement learning (RL) algorithm to optimize the LLM. A prominent issue
with such methods is \emph{reward over-optimization} or \emph{reward hacking},
where performance as measured by the learned proxy reward model increases, but
true quality plateaus or even deteriorates. Direct Alignment Algorithms (DDAs)
like Direct Preference Optimization have emerged as alternatives to the
classical RLHF pipeline by circumventing the reward modeling phase. However,
although DAAs do not use a separate proxy reward model, they still commonly
deteriorate from over-optimization. While the so-called reward hacking
phenomenon is not well-defined for DAAs, we still uncover similar trends: at
higher KL budgets, DAA algorithms exhibit similar degradation patterns to their
classic RLHF counterparts. In particular, we find that DAA methods deteriorate
not only across a wide range of KL budgets but also often before even a single
epoch of the dataset is completed. Through extensive empirical experimentation,
this work formulates and formalizes the reward over-optimization or hacking
problem for DAAs and explores its consequences across objectives, training
regimes, and model scales.
|
[
-0.3521064221858978,
-0.7392497062683105,
0.6431484818458557,
0.12323655933141708,
0.00883226003497839,
0.004422767087817192,
-0.044100649654865265,
-0.4605633616447449,
0.22763743996620178,
0.7389844059944153,
-0.7997264862060547,
0.07126352936029434,
-0.48741042613983154,
-0.14235661923885345,
-0.00214845547452569,
1.1584488153457642,
-0.20004813373088837,
0.19441764056682587,
-0.23657473921775818,
-0.3058311641216278,
-0.40581902861595154,
-0.7322919368743896,
-0.66778165102005,
-0.503487229347229,
0.5617802143096924,
0.34056809544563293,
0.6750626564025879,
1.1184959411621094,
0.624603271484375,
0.21081195771694183,
-0.0726214274764061,
-0.11465810984373093,
-0.6374099254608154,
0.10887271165847778,
-0.1563427746295929,
-0.42058590054512024,
-0.39979973435401917,
0.15457087755203247,
0.5408620238304138,
0.6505246758460999,
-0.5483515858650208,
0.07282249629497528,
-0.20744720101356506,
1.177617073059082,
-1.0520832538604736,
0.04465167596936226,
-0.4003702998161316,
-0.09629134833812714,
-0.11144264787435532,
-0.16369181871414185,
-0.4399544298648834,
-0.5588015913963318,
0.19856533408164978,
-0.5933250784873962,
-0.2243337780237198,
-0.2562168538570404,
0.8754293918609619,
0.44747963547706604,
-0.5498398542404175,
-0.7054017782211304,
-0.8066011071205139,
0.9552087783813477,
-0.5184935927391052,
0.21975699067115784,
0.5849984288215637,
0.36146342754364014,
-0.18961721658706665,
-0.4234298765659332,
-0.2909758687019348,
-0.4342973530292511,
0.08159933239221573,
-0.22001563012599945,
-0.163363978266716,
0.15778444707393646,
0.3099091649055481,
0.4042591154575348,
-0.2540520429611206,
0.4910416305065155,
-0.3546290099620819,
0.12465786188840866,
0.7735369205474854,
0.4201796352863312,
0.16681982576847076,
-0.03798198327422142,
-0.6185857653617859,
-0.4375755786895752,
-0.973405122756958,
0.3533455729484558,
0.6460949778556824,
0.26882585883140564,
0.07521286606788635,
0.2608735263347626,
-0.0451362244784832,
0.6065574884414673,
0.4575435221195221,
-0.13419020175933838,
0.3292067348957062,
-0.2440512478351593,
-0.1216149851679802,
0.07747422158718109,
0.5156124234199524,
0.31688836216926575,
0.3248816430568695,
-0.0722515806555748,
-0.4252745509147644,
-0.05565476045012474,
0.4793941080570221,
-0.8440582752227783,
-0.0398341603577137,
0.4359756410121918,
-0.47521334886550903,
-0.5124849081039429,
-0.1313660591840744,
-0.6709766387939453,
-0.6833944916725159,
-0.24238312244415283,
0.5950106978416443,
0.003644583048298955,
-0.3351310193538666,
0.08772639185190201,
-0.0935719832777977,
0.30927419662475586,
-0.0010671925265341997,
-1.0036200284957886,
0.4975132346153259,
0.7594224214553833,
0.7766745686531067,
-0.16701407730579376,
-0.5420244336128235,
-0.697399914264679,
-0.18651093542575836,
-0.4032709002494812,
0.24525916576385498,
-0.1664208173751831,
-0.39670008420944214,
0.2336609810590744,
-0.2600206434726715,
-0.0249334629625082,
-0.7186903953552246,
0.5517410635948181,
-0.9852892160415649,
0.0997103676199913,
-0.39692971110343933,
-0.7884397506713867,
0.058893267065286636,
0.25265663862228394,
-0.9821850061416626,
0.47590792179107666,
0.05207589268684387,
-0.6519201397895813,
0.782287061214447,
-0.7911564111709595,
-0.3694431185722351,
-0.19172777235507965,
0.04136151820421219,
-0.7953487634658813,
-0.10554320365190506,
0.02473468706011772,
0.22847530245780945,
-0.323404461145401,
0.5459263920783997,
-0.4654694199562073,
-0.23990030586719513,
0.2954276502132416,
-0.12015349417924881,
0.8785121440887451,
0.2583580017089844,
-0.39527231454849243,
0.3602750897407532,
-0.602414071559906,
-0.04754145070910454,
0.1751517653465271,
-0.3539728820323944,
-0.4472431242465973,
0.2961288392543793,
-0.14389702677726746,
0.22591081261634827,
0.233883336186409,
-0.646902859210968,
0.5015032887458801,
-0.3455604910850525,
0.7682825922966003,
1.0198512077331543,
0.07010156661272049,
0.6639184355735779,
-0.30714860558509827,
0.6158090233802795,
-0.07270680367946625,
0.34665223956108093,
-0.02281961403787136,
-0.06602601706981659,
-0.3460308909416199,
-0.4063417315483093,
0.24252311885356903,
0.42657703161239624,
-0.21227425336837769,
0.3299725651741028,
-0.1655636727809906,
-0.36429905891418457,
-0.5374821424484253,
-0.17471346259117126,
0.4853266775608063,
0.28682464361190796,
0.320797324180603,
-0.3508135974407196,
-0.42014890909194946,
-0.8852618336677551,
-0.21874260902404785,
-0.0959768295288086,
-0.0718935951590538,
0.4040415287017822,
0.43507876992225647,
-0.1863996833562851,
1.0462803840637207,
-0.5403860211372375,
-0.6400985717773438,
-0.10447483509778976,
0.2630496621131897,
0.3386063575744629,
0.5561150312423706,
0.4675723910331726,
-0.8443924784660339,
-0.2805812954902649,
-0.27814751863479614,
-0.22037383913993835,
0.07654453814029694,
-0.3773380517959595,
0.21292436122894287,
0.41706955432891846,
0.3925885558128357,
-0.503091037273407,
0.2812942564487457,
0.5267813801765442,
-0.5196504592895508,
0.7028558254241943,
-0.3225502371788025,
0.29051005840301514,
-0.6805205345153809,
0.04479745030403137,
-0.039548054337501526,
-0.059424009174108505,
-0.5187739133834839,
0.25459975004196167,
0.2613658607006073,
0.1751309484243393,
-0.2489277571439743,
0.4673970341682434,
-0.394578218460083,
-0.15610644221305847,
-0.4842810332775116,
-0.15054665505886078,
-0.28105396032333374,
0.7913148403167725,
0.19942256808280945,
0.6021071672439575,
0.4190022051334381,
-0.624988853931427,
0.42832252383232117,
-0.10555072128772736,
-0.2079143226146698,
0.5661683678627014,
-0.8357385993003845,
0.017998872324824333,
0.01632039248943329,
0.47825542092323303,
-0.7628064155578613,
-0.2568160593509674,
0.06747039407491684,
-0.2562083601951599,
0.3800351917743683,
-0.13240469992160797,
-0.17149503529071808,
-0.19107018411159515,
-0.718807578086853,
0.7991883158683777,
0.5856086015701294,
-0.8150840997695923,
0.20803570747375488,
0.5076151490211487,
0.2784319818019867,
-0.6978244185447693,
-0.42738062143325806,
-0.17039397358894348,
-0.40585166215896606,
-0.5292056202888489,
0.4205557405948639,
0.00011879076191689819,
-0.30575987696647644,
-0.06594362109899521,
0.003723174100741744,
-0.25097817182540894,
0.1549193114042282,
0.2926906645298004,
0.24413622915744781,
0.03226518630981445,
-0.059310365468263626,
-0.19970105588436127,
-0.04110822454094887,
0.2900734543800354,
-0.15528661012649536,
0.5296826362609863,
0.038166411221027374,
-0.4042838513851166,
-0.25990188121795654,
0.18361297249794006,
0.6789122223854065,
-0.12101440876722336,
0.8172813653945923,
0.2784325182437897,
-0.15301211178302765,
-0.05985382944345474,
-0.4592931270599365,
-0.4245499074459076,
-0.4264782965183258,
0.46288731694221497,
-0.39334744215011597,
-0.6501082181930542,
0.7430513501167297,
-0.0008771736756898463,
0.15509304404258728,
0.45367738604545593,
0.6349185109138489,
0.18553180992603302,
1.1367735862731934,
0.693533718585968,
-0.29530975222587585,
0.6061698794364929,
-0.0696488469839096,
-0.1903030276298523,
-0.7208934426307678,
-0.16520270705223083,
-0.4671299159526825,
-0.40126487612724304,
-0.8743173480033875,
-0.12835219502449036,
0.17861701548099518,
0.08169383555650711,
-0.6309951543807983,
0.22642835974693298,
-0.30849769711494446,
0.7597436308860779,
0.7198390960693359,
0.13389356434345245,
0.11248394101858139,
-0.18737110495567322,
0.1931418478488922,
-0.06762482225894928,
-0.7051918506622314,
0.10122165828943253,
1.2683948278427124,
0.7387619018554688,
1.0187407732009888,
-0.02678869292140007,
0.8266893625259399,
0.46942564845085144,
0.11552499234676361,
-0.8529852032661438,
0.05197351425886154,
0.1338985711336136,
-0.6528491973876953,
-0.6890218257904053,
-0.7019003033638,
-1.0251121520996094,
0.016102733090519905,
0.2438764125108719,
-0.723124623298645,
0.5689823031425476,
0.37295225262641907,
-0.2607284188270569,
0.3871535658836365,
-0.44012168049812317,
0.9858245253562927,
-0.05780769884586334,
-0.34137246012687683,
-0.34100082516670227,
-0.7483295798301697,
0.44902876019477844,
-0.007601436693221331,
0.21894754469394684,
0.13034623861312866,
0.10179447382688522,
0.8504723906517029,
-0.6664978861808777,
0.7709770202636719,
-0.3559325635433197,
-0.33288487792015076,
0.08196777105331421,
0.16354277729988098,
0.9531806707382202,
-0.1493271440267563,
0.19948162138462067,
0.0059622772969305515,
0.04095897078514099,
-0.6875250339508057,
-0.5058454871177673,
0.7479722499847412,
-1.0651179552078247,
-0.3606381118297577,
-0.580691397190094,
-0.46075713634490967,
-0.2869172692298889,
-0.10934755206108093,
0.23328055441379547,
0.35799840092658997,
0.0007989532314240932,
-0.05209902301430702,
0.7565973997116089,
-0.05736847594380379,
0.27324068546295166,
0.42575308680534363,
-0.12642157077789307,
-0.659155547618866,
0.9553535580635071,
0.11574462056159973,
0.7422850728034973,
0.13175995647907257,
0.32139208912849426,
-0.3711565434932709,
-0.364814817905426,
-0.5294292569160461,
0.23341470956802368,
-0.5809509754180908,
-0.22004730999469757,
-0.15050993859767914,
-0.08319048583507538,
-0.3199012279510498,
-0.3995477557182312,
-0.6305449604988098,
-0.4326273798942566,
-0.13144348561763763,
0.050778597593307495,
0.30468061566352844,
0.9184218049049377,
-0.3889642357826233,
0.04536237195134163,
-0.47284191846847534,
0.1834091991186142,
0.31718918681144714,
0.6334583759307861,
0.18182720243930817,
-0.8597574830055237,
-0.28704363107681274,
0.00030250666895881295,
-0.06655464321374893,
-0.9133921265602112,
0.39188072085380554,
-0.09777295589447021,
0.40734410285949707,
0.4099537432193756,
0.16184093058109283,
0.6635922789573669,
-0.3147871196269989,
0.5581875443458557,
0.379793256521225,
-0.8827540278434753,
0.20972388982772827,
-0.32382267713546753,
0.3533918559551239,
0.45049169659614563,
0.5855433344841003,
-0.7689675688743591,
-0.023419031873345375,
-0.4864732027053833,
-1.0943000316619873,
1.007881999015808,
-0.16889260709285736,
-0.016597779467701912,
0.29087868332862854,
0.4991765022277832,
0.08547717332839966,
0.1470762938261032,
-0.9040589928627014,
-0.2890234589576721,
-0.18971280753612518,
0.02840154990553856,
-0.04410037025809288,
-0.5869354009628296,
-0.22818347811698914,
0.12154754251241684,
0.8347069621086121,
-0.010111914947628975,
-0.051009517163038254,
-0.031419478356838226,
-0.00400477135553956,
-0.5262482166290283,
0.1824447363615036,
0.7688553929328918,
0.7540145516395569,
-0.3755682706832886,
-0.1470262110233307,
-0.13544459640979767,
-0.49239984154701233,
0.43617674708366394,
-0.0962856188416481,
-0.2651192843914032,
-0.639344334602356,
0.32662704586982727,
0.8754531145095825,
0.05534970387816429,
-0.7783219218254089,
0.49733251333236694,
0.0718156099319458,
-0.31460684537887573,
-0.24053534865379333,
-0.22311151027679443,
-0.18697233498096466,
0.17954765260219574,
0.5898762345314026,
-0.23925091326236725,
0.1553429812192917,
-0.642924427986145,
0.345841646194458,
0.6255221962928772,
-0.583091139793396,
-0.14377260208129883,
0.44661787152290344,
0.22341834008693695,
-0.42639780044555664,
0.7280570864677429,
-0.30016380548477173,
-0.501121997833252,
0.8175008296966553,
0.47001129388809204,
1.1009224653244019,
-0.1917053461074829,
0.3105802834033966,
0.4750767648220062,
0.22441622614860535,
-0.29565590620040894,
-0.11372482776641846,
-0.16339461505413055,
-0.5639548897743225,
-0.5688327550888062,
-0.566119372844696,
-0.44632089138031006,
0.12720638513565063,
-0.9689257144927979,
0.0362490676343441,
-0.4379822313785553,
-0.04522932693362236,
-0.1394231766462326,
0.1130913645029068,
-0.3091101050376892,
0.07778634876012802,
-0.004412051755934954,
0.555483341217041,
-0.8847754597663879,
0.6732590794563293,
0.5218384265899658,
-0.5751375555992126,
-0.7785656452178955,
-0.07986001670360565,
0.029026031494140625,
-0.9345363974571228,
0.9469262361526489,
-0.1894177943468094,
0.051262758672237396,
-0.10054813325405121,
-0.4503593444824219,
-1.0803654193878174,
0.9993937015533447,
0.26719826459884644,
-0.5632993578910828,
-0.2624526023864746,
0.07514823973178864,
0.37115827202796936,
-0.26124507188796997,
0.11498196423053741,
0.7029634118080139,
0.33382630348205566,
0.22189363837242126,
-1.1978628635406494,
0.11008068174123764,
0.29836219549179077,
-0.2995316684246063,
0.7858626842498779,
-0.5221990346908569,
0.886507511138916,
-0.42949438095092773,
-0.08410860598087311,
-0.02139940857887268,
0.2251647412776947,
0.3823603391647339,
0.15394729375839233,
0.6243534684181213,
0.7819135785102844,
0.3800305426120758,
0.08106052130460739,
1.0912792682647705,
0.04323918744921684,
0.7357690930366516,
0.9237290024757385,
-0.2647727429866791,
0.8138676285743713,
0.7346729040145874,
-0.4744208753108978,
0.36951372027397156,
0.8099665641784668,
0.11031752824783325,
0.6341193914413452,
0.6556819677352905,
0.11703493446111679,
-0.1737108677625656,
-0.010890385136008263,
-0.3015080988407135,
0.1882329136133194,
-0.08439210057258606,
-0.3082139194011688,
-0.2946111857891083,
0.06557168811559677,
0.003947268705815077,
0.14288364350795746,
-0.6360148787498474,
0.9775537252426147,
-0.18689945340156555,
-0.7329118847846985,
0.7472808957099915,
-0.021344007924199104,
0.6913509368896484,
-0.5858288407325745,
0.07579315453767776,
-0.39683517813682556,
0.3465823233127594,
-0.2195093035697937,
-0.5922079086303711,
0.12767347693443298,
-0.23932433128356934,
-0.3528624176979065,
-0.3596608638763428,
0.3845905065536499,
-0.44834640622138977,
-0.21932817995548248,
0.38563892245292664,
0.16745977103710175,
-0.04181031882762909,
-0.08911281824111938,
-0.6517444252967834,
0.12772688269615173,
-0.09694258123636246,
-0.5969883799552917,
0.7244781255722046,
0.03818294033408165,
-0.041680749505758286,
0.8650853037834167,
0.4530768096446991,
0.11830329149961472,
0.023873742669820786,
-0.027375690639019012,
0.707107424736023,
-0.6946741938591003,
-0.7416486740112305,
-1.1494163274765015,
0.23110230267047882,
0.06203233823180199,
-0.23818209767341614,
0.6854493021965027,
0.30530714988708496,
0.8393144607543945,
0.036947742104530334,
0.3328933119773865,
0.041888199746608734,
0.32056909799575806,
-0.5632461905479431,
0.5730515122413635,
-0.6077983975410461,
0.007838375866413116,
-0.2553686499595642,
-0.6555321216583252,
-0.05907655134797096,
0.2782991826534271,
-0.32796934247016907,
0.07790812849998474,
0.4056277871131897,
0.47054657340049744,
0.13027527928352356,
-0.33161693811416626,
0.28990694880485535,
-0.05780477076768875,
0.35665714740753174,
0.6093742251396179,
0.5451065301895142,
-0.14327563345432281,
0.5200121998786926,
-0.31279256939888,
-0.4058101773262024,
-0.34068766236305237,
-0.8438466787338257,
-0.424720823764801,
-0.6856585144996643,
-0.46937352418899536,
-0.49076563119888306,
0.06277651339769363,
0.8548902273178101,
0.7892072200775146,
-0.9007492661476135,
-0.46873781085014343,
-0.4607747197151184,
0.3290780782699585,
-0.5176126956939697,
-0.2580423057079315,
0.5160908699035645,
-0.6041839718818665,
-0.524446964263916,
0.10331038385629654,
0.232640340924263,
-0.11849382519721985,
-0.7625018954277039,
-0.38160836696624756,
-0.2098340541124344,
0.2439011186361313,
0.2781834900379181,
0.6733343601226807,
-0.6355539560317993,
-0.057280492037534714,
0.05082585662603378,
-0.2832067608833313,
0.05648747459053993,
1.0444148778915405,
-0.7297241687774658,
0.4375413954257965,
0.35795068740844727,
0.9017385840415955,
0.42765575647354126,
0.17887549102306366,
0.687788188457489,
-0.5529831647872925,
-0.06564952433109283,
0.2539752125740051,
0.17788267135620117,
-0.08546298742294312,
-0.3356364369392395,
0.2905789613723755,
0.09047868102788925,
-1.0064412355422974,
-1.1716095209121704,
0.5589589476585388,
-0.6087616086006165,
-0.4053800106048584,
1.1771819591522217,
-0.22951048612594604,
-0.2757713198661804,
0.2944203019142151,
-0.06642110645771027,
-0.14752855896949768,
-0.4755319356918335,
1.1753298044204712,
0.7760581374168396,
-0.2203911691904068,
0.21180494129657745,
-0.16008241474628448,
1.01063871383667,
0.6679860353469849,
-0.6755480766296387,
0.48650169372558594,
0.716331958770752,
0.18569497764110565,
0.28195464611053467,
0.5955202579498291,
0.0263534989207983,
0.705588161945343,
-0.016335276886820793,
0.009586289525032043,
-0.07229325920343399,
-0.16095398366451263,
-0.9012470245361328,
0.37930217385292053,
0.4626309275627136,
-0.3705108165740967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02893v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02893v2
|
Language Model Can Do Knowledge Tracing: Simple but Effective Method to Integrate Language Model and Knowledge Tracing Task
| 2024-06-05T03:26:59 | 2024-06-09T10:53:29 |
Unggi Lee, Jiyeong Bae, Dohee Kim, Sookbun Lee, Jaekwon Park, Taekyung Ahn, Gunho Lee, Damji Stratton, Hyeoncheol Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge Tracing (KT) is a critical task in online learning for modeling
student knowledge over time. Despite the success of deep learning-based KT
models, which rely on sequences of numbers as data, most existing approaches
fail to leverage the rich semantic information in the text of questions and
concepts. This paper proposes Language model-based Knowledge Tracing (LKT), a
novel framework that integrates pre-trained language models (PLMs) with KT
methods. By leveraging the power of language models to capture semantic
representations, LKT effectively incorporates textual information and
significantly outperforms previous KT models on large benchmark datasets.
Moreover, we demonstrate that LKT can effectively address the cold-start
problem in KT by leveraging the semantic knowledge captured by PLMs.
Interpretability of LKT is enhanced compared to traditional KT models due to
its use of text-rich data. We conducted the local interpretable model-agnostic
explanation technique and analysis of attention scores to interpret the model
performance further. Our work highlights the potential of integrating PLMs with
KT and paves the way for future research in KT domain.
|
[
-0.013621392659842968,
-0.747665286064148,
0.7013916969299316,
-0.2240675836801529,
-0.3321986496448517,
0.41483253240585327,
-0.15834033489227295,
-0.4026741683483124,
-0.14748945832252502,
0.7437543869018555,
-0.43553224205970764,
-0.49255338311195374,
-0.3285789489746094,
-0.461056113243103,
-0.5404136180877686,
0.9166613817214966,
-0.11096087098121643,
-0.07771352678537369,
-0.3411090672016144,
0.09245715290307999,
-0.657339870929718,
-0.558842658996582,
-0.43430498242378235,
-0.4075179100036621,
0.4003933370113373,
0.3617400527000427,
0.45799869298934937,
0.6376711130142212,
0.2687818109989166,
0.1883087158203125,
0.1686873883008957,
-0.08791600167751312,
-0.4927956759929657,
0.11854130774736404,
-0.06638580560684204,
-0.5822417140007019,
-0.5195592045783997,
-0.0733131542801857,
0.6889097094535828,
0.749422013759613,
-0.14039646089076996,
0.06235140189528465,
0.17605112493038177,
0.4870206415653229,
-0.38695669174194336,
0.34935376048088074,
-0.4223272204399109,
-0.17096583545207977,
-0.2005012184381485,
-0.04985828697681427,
-0.5054580569267273,
-0.3908855617046356,
0.6859747171401978,
-0.6046670079231262,
0.23695844411849976,
-0.2883402407169342,
0.8262943625450134,
0.21487009525299072,
-0.48187440633773804,
-0.4324386715888977,
-0.7877890467643738,
0.7804038524627686,
-0.9290234446525574,
0.7025055885314941,
0.5439396500587463,
0.4859258830547333,
0.29097506403923035,
-0.8547955751419067,
-0.46076422929763794,
-0.27471938729286194,
-0.2029699683189392,
0.13322775065898895,
0.3565073311328888,
-0.22500696778297424,
0.013616138137876987,
0.20667503774166107,
-0.285107284784317,
-0.062065448611974716,
-0.4044729173183441,
-0.28714126348495483,
0.2582474946975708,
0.13386985659599304,
0.3342219591140747,
0.00837088841944933,
-0.5942786931991577,
0.08149450272321701,
-0.477256715297699,
0.006264451425522566,
0.05763795226812363,
0.5595779418945312,
-0.2808874249458313,
0.2815002501010895,
-0.2752886116504669,
0.9015686511993408,
-0.3759410083293915,
-0.35015541315078735,
-0.21390469372272491,
-0.3005807399749756,
0.0029680824372917414,
0.11304313689470291,
0.4280596673488617,
0.21641476452350616,
0.4570997655391693,
-0.5258294939994812,
0.00541889201849699,
0.06847722083330154,
-0.13051827251911163,
-0.8416036367416382,
-0.5668942332267761,
-0.21394658088684082,
-0.32593271136283875,
-0.04547731205821037,
-0.16066554188728333,
-0.7804934978485107,
-0.5412864685058594,
-0.3843406140804291,
0.37940359115600586,
-0.60756915807724,
-0.7184221744537354,
0.24102070927619934,
0.3386552929878235,
0.408926784992218,
0.42223119735717773,
-0.5226805806159973,
0.36168962717056274,
0.5421770811080933,
0.8217454552650452,
-0.21037128567695618,
0.019894886761903763,
-0.1330709457397461,
0.262265145778656,
-0.04753139615058899,
0.6129163503646851,
-0.3698914647102356,
-0.05629805848002434,
0.030422372743487358,
-0.2783207297325134,
-0.1730496734380722,
-0.20817117393016815,
0.15571945905685425,
-0.770043671131134,
0.23906540870666504,
-0.2941102385520935,
-1.1191960573196411,
-0.47109296917915344,
0.2208690345287323,
-0.6834172010421753,
1.0588935613632202,
0.09949034452438354,
-0.8483502268791199,
0.16916027665138245,
-0.42831116914749146,
-0.2493128478527069,
0.3601498007774353,
-0.0015169462421908975,
-0.24298962950706482,
-0.2177741378545761,
-0.02851477824151516,
0.7074069380760193,
-0.28820449113845825,
0.3514442443847656,
-0.21236680448055267,
-0.03480927646160126,
0.00005531783972401172,
0.08043055981397629,
0.7710790634155273,
0.1842389553785324,
-0.30769363045692444,
-0.08888287097215652,
-0.9364229440689087,
0.08270128816366196,
0.3345518410205841,
-0.37850940227508545,
-0.7603854537010193,
0.06729434430599213,
-0.3020758032798767,
0.2643626034259796,
0.3700849115848541,
-0.39556995034217834,
0.14825589954853058,
-0.297441303730011,
0.23847158253192902,
0.5675222277641296,
-0.2533450722694397,
0.5234382152557373,
0.07051925361156464,
0.7370286583900452,
-0.13039638102054596,
-0.30657973885536194,
-0.4013102948665619,
-0.5331867933273315,
-0.8878410458564758,
-0.15227001905441284,
0.3481285870075226,
0.5661918520927429,
-0.9713218212127686,
-0.26652950048446655,
-0.24622821807861328,
-0.5947819352149963,
-0.7304951548576355,
0.1707533895969391,
0.2811598777770996,
0.7599518299102783,
0.19586144387722015,
-0.19643063843250275,
-0.3165584206581116,
-0.5132430195808411,
-0.6101239323616028,
-0.11345381289720535,
0.14622530341148376,
0.4186733663082123,
0.3400617837905884,
0.2510145306587219,
1.373489499092102,
-0.5019474029541016,
-0.2614085376262665,
-0.639578640460968,
0.06797380745410919,
-0.014100895263254642,
0.3208382725715637,
0.2650631368160248,
-0.7079609632492065,
-0.7377563714981079,
0.07115105539560318,
-0.7153763175010681,
-0.15475626289844513,
0.014020406641066074,
-0.10133914649486542,
-0.04388274624943733,
0.5844773054122925,
-0.49919915199279785,
0.1920003741979599,
0.2934427857398987,
-0.8641738295555115,
0.4378076493740082,
-0.016338476911187172,
-0.04555850103497505,
-1.1468870639801025,
0.23698480427265167,
-0.28277701139450073,
-0.37299373745918274,
-0.7427104711532593,
0.07639170438051224,
0.20439745485782623,
-0.2141151875257492,
-0.520349383354187,
0.8873592615127563,
-0.37792137265205383,
-0.0660550519824028,
-0.26341235637664795,
0.25258928537368774,
0.009506087750196457,
0.35278257727622986,
0.11516080796718597,
0.1903521716594696,
0.5494385957717896,
-0.554737389087677,
0.5028224587440491,
-0.06831628829240799,
-0.6067239046096802,
0.37289002537727356,
-0.27166759967803955,
0.41044726967811584,
-0.04573606699705124,
0.0680888369679451,
-0.980924129486084,
-0.036132313311100006,
0.09152057021856308,
-0.3390481770038605,
0.12971480190753937,
-0.34130752086639404,
-0.6468479633331299,
-0.045231886208057404,
0.21858078241348267,
0.5114790201187134,
0.6037265658378601,
-0.24655279517173767,
0.8468313217163086,
-0.008163523860275745,
-0.2624798119068146,
-0.2727508544921875,
-0.20980241894721985,
-0.2756040096282959,
-0.2772144079208374,
-0.64894700050354,
-0.03837139904499054,
0.045051272958517075,
-0.1169433444738388,
0.13635045289993286,
0.04831273481249809,
-0.32778921723365784,
0.35922038555145264,
-0.11015225201845169,
0.3255530595779419,
-0.5453999638557434,
0.29602566361427307,
-0.44733864068984985,
-0.11766745895147324,
0.12116977572441101,
-0.3215217590332031,
0.7038267850875854,
0.035671573132276535,
-0.24167810380458832,
-0.4604138135910034,
0.15103866159915924,
0.5554785132408142,
-0.40132221579551697,
0.8450660705566406,
0.4865535497665405,
-0.303772896528244,
-0.3459833264350891,
-0.6614680290222168,
-0.5063894987106323,
-0.3765350878238678,
0.36261066794395447,
-0.2296570986509323,
-0.9618943929672241,
0.6718785166740417,
-0.3002908229827881,
-0.04463338851928711,
0.3703613877296448,
0.2919105887413025,
-0.17558395862579346,
0.862949013710022,
1.1318758726119995,
-0.0502617284655571,
0.359518826007843,
-0.06051784008741379,
0.28493839502334595,
-0.22743384540081024,
-0.39163243770599365,
-0.44761383533477783,
-0.04562535509467125,
-0.16951031982898712,
-0.2826717793941498,
-0.03692609444260597,
0.3766099810600281,
-0.03503933548927307,
0.02857222966849804,
-0.1180701032280922,
0.5509205460548401,
0.5181597471237183,
0.04855075478553772,
0.4527997672557831,
-0.2132299691438675,
-0.3752394914627075,
-0.15880706906318665,
-0.9080743193626404,
-0.1851271688938141,
1.0624871253967285,
0.5126600861549377,
0.7000717520713806,
-0.12661948800086975,
0.5286694169044495,
-0.026599278673529625,
0.44533732533454895,
-0.727439284324646,
0.6645330786705017,
-0.04540782794356346,
-0.6443062424659729,
-0.20157863199710846,
-0.43037328124046326,
-0.3975331485271454,
0.044599395245313644,
0.15593256056308746,
-0.6724320650100708,
-0.368341326713562,
0.3481772840023041,
-0.502555787563324,
0.5218242406845093,
-0.9076395630836487,
1.0687705278396606,
-0.33232244849205017,
-0.36836013197898865,
-0.1438591033220291,
-0.5929536819458008,
0.560425341129303,
-0.23568935692310333,
0.37424013018608093,
-0.18316838145256042,
0.17722679674625397,
1.1748636960983276,
-0.4375172257423401,
1.2699331045150757,
-0.4851631224155426,
-0.3640410304069519,
0.4193476140499115,
0.21740581095218658,
0.705961287021637,
-0.5364018678665161,
0.17368844151496887,
-0.12254965305328369,
0.018422763794660568,
-0.3964317739009857,
-0.5721437335014343,
0.6572631597518921,
-0.4692091643810272,
-0.2133159637451172,
-0.2022642195224762,
-0.6643223166465759,
-0.34767261147499084,
0.4128267467021942,
-0.19409358501434326,
0.25540268421173096,
0.24229706823825836,
0.18998050689697266,
0.7999656200408936,
-0.38584211468696594,
0.41766414046287537,
1.068334698677063,
-0.49107277393341064,
0.03175491839647293,
1.1983191967010498,
0.22636692225933075,
0.4828343689441681,
0.3330046236515045,
0.38372376561164856,
-0.3613553047180176,
-0.3632970154285431,
-0.28150585293769836,
0.3172065019607544,
-0.9334229826927185,
-0.13878007233142853,
-0.5781901478767395,
-0.043206438422203064,
-0.2762525677680969,
-0.12200647592544556,
-0.5491257905960083,
-0.21892648935317993,
0.0075910137966275215,
-0.0314604789018631,
0.5452872514724731,
0.7789337635040283,
0.37418073415756226,
0.5899679660797119,
-0.7748093605041504,
0.3266933858394623,
0.4553447365760803,
0.7803828120231628,
0.436619371175766,
-0.3796602487564087,
-0.5986641049385071,
-0.18369963765144348,
-0.04058965668082237,
-1.0256661176681519,
0.4084475338459015,
0.04512420669198036,
0.3591316044330597,
0.2844673693180084,
0.19823525846004486,
0.6101340651512146,
-0.2673031687736511,
0.7793665528297424,
-0.00916039478033781,
-0.9033704996109009,
0.552770733833313,
-0.49502095580101013,
0.642894983291626,
0.18940621614456177,
0.34625038504600525,
-0.6564065217971802,
-0.44957879185676575,
-0.5401498675346375,
-1.029442548751831,
0.8916372060775757,
-0.036576349288225174,
-0.2015676349401474,
0.2788638472557068,
0.29503965377807617,
0.2626537084579468,
0.03417855128645897,
-0.7346165776252747,
-0.18433073163032532,
-0.2688209116458893,
-0.30904263257980347,
-0.15105435252189636,
-0.27389612793922424,
0.4106255769729614,
-0.1426239013671875,
0.6236447691917419,
-0.07635138928890228,
0.040360596030950546,
-0.03960058465600014,
-0.6068345904350281,
0.16148386895656586,
0.16537579894065857,
0.4742980897426605,
0.7763054370880127,
-0.2229403555393219,
0.3036550283432007,
0.09273923188447952,
-0.3243124186992645,
-0.2472711205482483,
0.05543733015656471,
-0.2507894039154053,
-0.014635465107858181,
0.4773079454898834,
0.528052806854248,
0.4575304687023163,
-0.7473960518836975,
0.3315856158733368,
0.23218724131584167,
0.19397911429405212,
-0.11430738866329193,
-0.3053574562072754,
0.6685431003570557,
0.25697818398475647,
0.2821125090122223,
-0.5886603593826294,
-0.16457350552082062,
-0.28636500239372253,
0.3788985013961792,
0.26229411363601685,
-0.5252679586410522,
-0.4942704439163208,
0.6227191090583801,
0.34002983570098877,
-0.1076083704829216,
0.7130975723266602,
0.30718615651130676,
-0.7284185886383057,
0.594666063785553,
0.5735335946083069,
0.6315150856971741,
-0.5804218649864197,
0.17367637157440186,
0.1622225046157837,
0.05906398594379425,
-0.028265303000807762,
0.4305804669857025,
-0.2334839552640915,
-0.6537399291992188,
-0.6997532248497009,
-0.7920517325401306,
-0.08802555501461029,
0.34062591195106506,
-0.6137000322341919,
0.14329057931900024,
-0.2665167450904846,
0.2760569155216217,
-0.26476746797561646,
-0.11680535972118378,
-0.9364660978317261,
0.2771221697330475,
0.3063916265964508,
0.7932717204093933,
-0.9446038007736206,
1.214133620262146,
0.4799136519432068,
-0.20112007856369019,
-0.9689518809318542,
-0.3192029595375061,
-0.12285570800304413,
-1.0741288661956787,
0.9763349294662476,
0.13013054430484772,
-0.11688465625047684,
0.48215749859809875,
-0.3791980445384979,
-0.7109730839729309,
1.0937234163284302,
0.36952850222587585,
-0.3846520185470581,
-0.1148974671959877,
0.5066579580307007,
0.29833534359931946,
-0.3478512763977051,
0.014078496024012566,
0.574364960193634,
0.3057999908924103,
-0.07173679769039154,
-0.9707770943641663,
0.06854140013456345,
0.12262140959501266,
-0.3698248565196991,
0.30534568428993225,
-0.30183377861976624,
0.8056696653366089,
-0.12860576808452606,
-0.3058329224586487,
-0.07091691344976425,
0.6232175230979919,
-0.20285366475582123,
0.37810128927230835,
0.325734943151474,
0.7105412483215332,
0.5932471752166748,
0.1324608325958252,
0.9312740564346313,
-0.39743074774742126,
0.5333349704742432,
1.260326623916626,
-0.10658727586269379,
0.7869720458984375,
0.42008739709854126,
0.04098876565694809,
0.33747225999832153,
0.28647473454475403,
0.2654840648174286,
0.7134131193161011,
0.14736586809158325,
-0.24087819457054138,
-0.5165801644325256,
-0.1910523623228073,
-0.36308401823043823,
0.28750619292259216,
0.2174779623746872,
-0.4759622812271118,
-0.6411494612693787,
0.13638277351856232,
0.13079217076301575,
-0.09023243933916092,
-0.3948044776916504,
0.8731581568717957,
0.1523754596710205,
-0.42719578742980957,
0.35934340953826904,
-0.11166955530643463,
0.4714098870754242,
-0.8420275449752808,
-0.2801473140716553,
-0.3418945074081421,
0.45340436697006226,
0.0808120146393776,
-0.40307044982910156,
-0.05608312040567398,
-0.05179954692721367,
-0.036250293254852295,
-0.6940832734107971,
1.0198838710784912,
-0.6214439272880554,
-0.507774829864502,
0.3659386932849884,
0.8718193769454956,
0.15055106580257416,
-0.12735538184642792,
-0.4044802188873291,
-0.23021200299263,
-0.05040324479341507,
-0.23634269833564758,
0.3898271918296814,
0.442445307970047,
-0.07044348865747452,
0.925771176815033,
0.5620579123497009,
-0.17722894251346588,
0.34537407755851746,
-0.05294734612107277,
0.5438165664672852,
-0.8474310636520386,
-0.7495251297950745,
-1.0090588331222534,
0.70489501953125,
0.1474195420742035,
-0.10859169065952301,
0.8800498843193054,
0.4616934657096863,
0.7873569130897522,
-0.1387413889169693,
0.9664610028266907,
0.07688324898481369,
0.9961468577384949,
-0.5510869026184082,
1.055008053779602,
-0.24827449023723602,
0.27635177969932556,
-0.17656680941581726,
-0.6549303531646729,
-0.06723567843437195,
0.37366414070129395,
-0.32422399520874023,
0.003340467344969511,
0.5952014327049255,
0.29991230368614197,
-0.208963543176651,
-0.10708819329738617,
0.37630215287208557,
0.47383999824523926,
0.3032997250556946,
0.5705324411392212,
0.9021933078765869,
-0.07839348912239075,
0.563049852848053,
-0.3752198815345764,
-0.23018382489681244,
-0.2975124716758728,
-0.9736185073852539,
-0.8742567896842957,
-0.6518467664718628,
-0.3503197729587555,
-0.16425178945064545,
0.01497033704072237,
0.2734341621398926,
0.5958955883979797,
-0.6589036583900452,
-0.28090551495552063,
-0.044790126383304596,
0.1436079442501068,
-0.0814453586935997,
-0.30120545625686646,
0.6864243149757385,
-0.22996531426906586,
-0.2242916077375412,
0.2798192799091339,
-0.2111630141735077,
0.14389654994010925,
-0.3217390179634094,
-0.20416274666786194,
-0.23205262422561646,
-0.132499560713768,
0.5838384628295898,
0.2871745526790619,
-0.7863173484802246,
-0.18817950785160065,
0.20205938816070557,
0.10637188702821732,
-0.25150424242019653,
1.1292001008987427,
-1.2296063899993896,
0.6426756381988525,
0.39947745203971863,
0.7167496085166931,
0.4922593832015991,
-0.37162870168685913,
0.7741303443908691,
-0.5614619255065918,
-0.13210298120975494,
0.5022333264350891,
0.08435051888227463,
0.4564148783683777,
-0.09624206274747849,
0.20287920534610748,
0.40948551893234253,
-0.10596854984760284,
-0.8835644125938416,
0.27523818612098694,
-0.8757780194282532,
-0.3947758376598358,
1.020753264427185,
-0.5055772662162781,
0.21261577308177948,
-0.3833615183830261,
-0.007151932455599308,
0.49974530935287476,
-0.07203319668769836,
0.7989518642425537,
0.9269633889198303,
0.056230850517749786,
-0.4905056357383728,
-1.131692886352539,
0.6688198447227478,
0.5103816390037537,
-0.7447413802146912,
0.28380024433135986,
0.09961210936307907,
0.5310271382331848,
-0.019420690834522247,
0.5412336587905884,
0.14821356534957886,
0.023545783013105392,
-0.1941203474998474,
0.005380569025874138,
-0.163025364279747,
-0.1533774882555008,
0.06381343305110931,
0.45004895329475403,
-0.01695679873228073,
-0.029664702713489532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02888v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02888v2
|
HYDRA: Model Factorization Framework for Black-Box LLM Personalization
| 2024-06-05T03:08:46 | 2024-06-11T01:51:57 |
Yuchen Zhuang, Haotian Sun, Yue Yu, Rushi Qiang, Qifan Wang, Chao Zhang, Bo Dai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Personalization has emerged as a critical research area in modern intelligent
systems, focusing on mining users' behavioral history and adapting to their
preferences for delivering tailored experiences. Despite the remarkable
few-shot capabilities exhibited by black-box large language models (LLMs), the
inherent opacity of their model parameters presents significant challenges in
aligning the generated output with individual expectations. Existing solutions
have primarily focused on prompt design to incorporate user-specific profiles
and behaviors; however, such approaches often struggle to generalize
effectively due to their inability to capture shared knowledge among all users.
To address these challenges, we propose HYDRA, a model factorization framework
that captures both user-specific behavior patterns from historical data and
shared general knowledge among all users to deliver personalized generation. In
order to capture user-specific behavior patterns, we first train a reranker to
prioritize the most useful information from top-retrieved relevant historical
records. By combining the prioritized history with the corresponding query, we
train an adapter to align the output with individual user-specific preferences,
eliminating the reliance on access to inherent model parameters of black-box
LLMs. Both the reranker and the adapter can be decomposed into a base model
with multiple user-specific heads, resembling a hydra. The base model maintains
shared knowledge across users, while the multiple personal heads capture
user-specific preferences. Experimental results demonstrate that HYDRA
outperforms existing state-of-the-art prompt-based methods by an average
relative improvement of 9.01% across five diverse personalization tasks in the
LaMP benchmark. Our implementation is available at
https://github.com/night-chen/HYDRA.
|
[
-0.2188519686460495,
-0.6518850326538086,
0.7813306450843811,
0.377728670835495,
-0.1808820217847824,
0.14834952354431152,
-0.043505873531103134,
-0.14577701687812805,
0.42227134108543396,
0.4085255265235901,
-0.5600912570953369,
-0.6755697131156921,
-0.1135290116071701,
-0.007544988766312599,
-0.13318189978599548,
1.1468205451965332,
-0.07231595367193222,
-0.23511862754821777,
-0.20658257603645325,
-0.11502876877784729,
-0.6651564240455627,
-0.5756198167800903,
-0.7881088256835938,
-0.5530263185501099,
0.8881266117095947,
0.3901917636394501,
0.5054399967193604,
0.499477744102478,
0.11398789286613464,
0.2604771852493286,
0.014031440019607544,
0.2937600612640381,
-0.7846871614456177,
0.6614262461662292,
-0.4647641181945801,
-0.2973162531852722,
-0.5495929718017578,
-0.22419211268424988,
0.2993544340133667,
0.33250316977500916,
-0.14549893140792847,
0.19149638712406158,
-0.013907822780311108,
0.44255656003952026,
-0.6322681903839111,
0.24969777464866638,
-0.4434599280357361,
-0.08842695504426956,
-0.20294424891471863,
-0.5767548680305481,
-0.41935253143310547,
-0.19325882196426392,
0.14201045036315918,
-0.8291401267051697,
0.29281559586524963,
0.6194801926612854,
0.699334979057312,
0.39443454146385193,
-0.5273056626319885,
-0.17680624127388,
-1.040148138999939,
0.7246657609939575,
-0.4257952570915222,
0.2383868545293808,
0.12180176377296448,
0.3727016746997833,
-0.13971050083637238,
-0.8213498592376709,
-0.5148438215255737,
-0.09328927844762802,
-0.02326839417219162,
0.12739931046962738,
-0.4738072454929352,
-0.12280288338661194,
0.08676013350486755,
0.37116125226020813,
-0.48236602544784546,
0.014374250546097755,
-0.2767227590084076,
-0.32260316610336304,
0.6541696190834045,
0.4028508961200714,
0.4008813798427582,
-0.1267947256565094,
-0.6399950981140137,
0.025047680363059044,
-0.7350382208824158,
0.4530602693557739,
0.3828572928905487,
0.2426539659500122,
-0.24887335300445557,
0.7103189826011658,
-0.6284499764442444,
0.6052854061126709,
0.3600770831108093,
-0.006874454207718372,
0.1430603265762329,
-0.40572288632392883,
-0.031675707548856735,
0.15977108478546143,
0.8217030167579651,
0.49581506848335266,
0.3474920988082886,
-0.3477928638458252,
-0.24317067861557007,
-0.17758193612098694,
0.32605549693107605,
-1.022763967514038,
-0.26742905378341675,
0.20585927367210388,
-0.13115167617797852,
-0.3612639605998993,
-0.04550245776772499,
-0.8242139220237732,
-0.6701340675354004,
-0.2112804353237152,
0.29637253284454346,
-0.089875727891922,
0.029497206211090088,
0.20344141125679016,
-0.05969405919313431,
-0.12798430025577545,
0.40056630969047546,
-0.7155683040618896,
0.13000428676605225,
0.57245272397995,
0.8513398766517639,
-0.49230965971946716,
-0.11208979785442352,
-0.8577920198440552,
0.40494340658187866,
-0.0636867955327034,
0.7146125435829163,
-0.6904488205909729,
-0.35630595684051514,
-0.0015399804105982184,
-0.2624627947807312,
0.11722039431333542,
-0.2643921375274658,
0.4181644916534424,
-0.8445772528648376,
0.21612197160720825,
-0.33933886885643005,
-0.47468486428260803,
-0.1481667011976242,
0.0030238803010433912,
-0.26280978322029114,
0.6559422612190247,
0.20612512528896332,
-0.7521016001701355,
0.21451270580291748,
-0.5794751644134521,
-0.22105887532234192,
0.3241027295589447,
-0.3391580283641815,
-0.49407199025154114,
0.26404663920402527,
0.2105157971382141,
0.5149341821670532,
-0.47352999448776245,
0.4171876013278961,
-0.6273096799850464,
-0.36319851875305176,
0.21425236761569977,
0.04230089858174324,
0.6512886881828308,
0.15804558992385864,
-0.23176270723342896,
0.8645651936531067,
-0.45035603642463684,
-0.06848689168691635,
0.2721925377845764,
-0.33655545115470886,
-0.38197001814842224,
-0.17887428402900696,
0.16917726397514343,
0.32979410886764526,
0.45901939272880554,
-0.6039493680000305,
0.29908591508865356,
-0.1505528837442398,
0.40244603157043457,
0.8799592852592468,
0.2563534080982208,
0.5106285214424133,
-0.6191326975822449,
0.6865088939666748,
0.03710386902093887,
-0.13102565705776215,
-0.34529370069503784,
-0.5105668902397156,
-0.7775982022285461,
-0.3782280385494232,
0.17726926505565643,
0.6406081318855286,
-0.5046764612197876,
0.3900791108608246,
-0.4554215371608734,
-0.2947778105735779,
-0.27702075242996216,
0.5456674098968506,
0.40230274200439453,
0.6428205370903015,
0.322482705116272,
-0.25144970417022705,
-0.3697912096977234,
-1.1723686456680298,
-0.09440683573484421,
-0.1019129678606987,
-0.22787176072597504,
0.8456616401672363,
0.19254930317401886,
-0.5803189277648926,
1.226395606994629,
-0.9593884944915771,
-0.37432217597961426,
-0.33573174476623535,
0.010910567827522755,
0.1338263750076294,
0.29150763154029846,
0.36375728249549866,
-0.7554665803909302,
-0.46317562460899353,
0.021366970613598824,
-0.7088972926139832,
-0.15092352032661438,
-0.008588004857301712,
-0.3049710690975189,
-0.2339799404144287,
0.33118879795074463,
-0.43434733152389526,
0.3313978910446167,
0.3894410729408264,
-0.6022907495498657,
0.3275427520275116,
-0.2790028750896454,
-0.00496265571564436,
-1.2932031154632568,
0.14786547422409058,
0.3232520818710327,
-0.3121092617511749,
-0.738033652305603,
-0.010654335841536522,
-0.025996819138526917,
-0.20955945551395416,
-0.22783611714839935,
1.0408729314804077,
0.023476680740714073,
0.11492567509412766,
-0.2501438856124878,
-0.18751472234725952,
-0.10781583935022354,
0.7433473467826843,
-0.0469847247004509,
0.8194149732589722,
0.2697822153568268,
-0.5912715792655945,
0.3655785918235779,
0.2123616486787796,
-0.10417202115058899,
0.6585385799407959,
-1.0818384885787964,
0.3860762119293213,
-0.19780516624450684,
0.32583773136138916,
-1.039316177368164,
-0.3737686276435852,
0.41204628348350525,
-0.12301835417747498,
0.11124148964881897,
-0.2809573709964752,
-0.3043321669101715,
0.05021750554442406,
-0.2812083065509796,
0.49723052978515625,
0.5343227982521057,
-0.41051191091537476,
0.9537895321846008,
0.2519807815551758,
-0.35996344685554504,
-0.45304691791534424,
0.016098424792289734,
-0.16283762454986572,
-0.46125027537345886,
-0.9000797271728516,
0.8372771739959717,
-0.5453125238418579,
-0.2325381189584732,
-0.17667843401432037,
-0.4083828032016754,
0.04387390986084938,
-0.020954539999365807,
0.6441710591316223,
0.3229635953903198,
-0.18569937348365784,
-0.010557924397289753,
-0.01214064471423626,
-0.19875334203243256,
-0.18642523884773254,
-0.2248000204563141,
0.9284588098526001,
-0.0867576152086258,
-0.0457087866961956,
-0.5644335746765137,
0.1086718812584877,
0.5696569085121155,
-0.38580426573753357,
0.4759821593761444,
0.6763283610343933,
-0.20269496738910675,
-0.5021905899047852,
-0.5797780752182007,
-0.27816393971443176,
-0.5291756987571716,
0.05441253259778023,
-0.44027408957481384,
-1.0155795812606812,
0.526832640171051,
-0.17054490745067596,
0.19170375168323517,
0.041241224855184555,
0.6967651844024658,
-0.37168318033218384,
0.7804281711578369,
0.8008506894111633,
-0.36366695165634155,
0.530808687210083,
-0.05398786813020706,
0.1084880381822586,
-0.9856104254722595,
-0.32759907841682434,
-0.22653794288635254,
-0.4919639825820923,
-0.30644291639328003,
-0.12184462696313858,
0.37553671002388,
0.08563017845153809,
-0.3155393600463867,
0.0775039941072464,
-0.2358817160129547,
0.053072940558195114,
0.7502834796905518,
0.3936363756656647,
0.3585231304168701,
0.2327243536710739,
-0.11438839882612228,
0.04994700476527214,
-0.532541811466217,
-0.3199019730091095,
1.1680376529693604,
0.23321302235126495,
0.7883956432342529,
0.15677998960018158,
0.9536293148994446,
0.5509994029998779,
0.2312464565038681,
-0.7375891208648682,
0.39437317848205566,
0.04555131122469902,
-0.5273334383964539,
-0.35379457473754883,
-0.542670726776123,
-1.0812103748321533,
0.05270257592201233,
-0.2632557153701782,
-0.6558774709701538,
0.2935502529144287,
0.5492879748344421,
-0.7332104444503784,
-0.04121854901313782,
-0.49937114119529724,
0.7817223072052002,
-0.12083762884140015,
-0.6144665479660034,
-0.12064346671104431,
-0.18289510905742645,
0.48733454942703247,
-0.20865890383720398,
0.015274924226105213,
-0.11946210265159607,
-0.15238946676254272,
0.44675034284591675,
0.02137386053800583,
0.8248026371002197,
-0.07271397858858109,
0.08083841949701309,
-0.16200260818004608,
0.277048259973526,
0.7173741459846497,
0.293931245803833,
0.17535604536533356,
0.007393890526145697,
-0.4956982731819153,
-0.3015131652355194,
-0.6637494564056396,
1.0005043745040894,
-0.656528115272522,
-0.9782902002334595,
-0.3861874043941498,
-0.7502544522285461,
-0.20867937803268433,
0.2822909951210022,
0.2290842980146408,
0.2723134458065033,
-0.06941071897745132,
0.2935110032558441,
0.8067710995674133,
-0.24527029693126678,
0.16617704927921295,
0.7691010236740112,
-0.4344974756240845,
-0.4521714150905609,
1.192328929901123,
-0.18595731258392334,
-0.19416534900665283,
0.47087422013282776,
0.30323103070259094,
-0.14224988222122192,
-0.6891763806343079,
-0.29861390590667725,
0.3268038034439087,
-0.39312657713890076,
-0.07803472131490707,
-0.638156533241272,
0.03219503536820412,
-0.07689779996871948,
-0.22282478213310242,
-0.004684014245867729,
-0.12898637354373932,
-0.309395432472229,
0.1434209942817688,
0.1854613721370697,
0.7089865803718567,
0.6752755045890808,
0.37024441361427307,
-0.19074788689613342,
0.6848556995391846,
0.5953745245933533,
0.3081389367580414,
-0.20441779494285583,
-0.4668295681476593,
0.18763837218284607,
-0.19957073032855988,
-0.25462886691093445,
-0.8641839027404785,
0.22765713930130005,
-0.0715341567993164,
0.6387773752212524,
0.30001604557037354,
0.2519032955169678,
0.6080251336097717,
-0.5885718464851379,
0.38693657517433167,
0.17711466550827026,
-0.7166500091552734,
0.6098242998123169,
-0.34860920906066895,
0.15339720249176025,
0.4068022668361664,
0.37524843215942383,
-0.6331518888473511,
-0.06290551275014877,
-0.4700307548046112,
-0.8008518218994141,
0.7696155309677124,
0.23555833101272583,
0.02188427746295929,
0.45587268471717834,
0.5588310360908508,
-0.07036019116640091,
0.23470589518547058,
-0.5702050924301147,
-0.5880753993988037,
-0.19642767310142517,
-0.40770289301872253,
-0.32904696464538574,
-0.3203171491622925,
-0.18317987024784088,
0.0030846677254885435,
0.5248932838439941,
-0.17299599945545197,
-0.18815618753433228,
-0.004367426503449678,
-0.21121644973754883,
-0.030292481184005737,
0.3136886954307556,
0.7347502708435059,
0.6479083895683289,
-0.38544854521751404,
0.009192533791065216,
-0.03554548695683479,
-0.11466791480779648,
0.2196778953075409,
0.15982669591903687,
-0.7699208855628967,
-0.1617182344198227,
0.04571305960416794,
0.7909021973609924,
0.5464625358581543,
-0.4403012692928314,
0.33626800775527954,
-0.1292712390422821,
0.3300233483314514,
-0.26087629795074463,
0.6451789140701294,
0.183399498462677,
0.3750976026058197,
0.3929223120212555,
0.26166999340057373,
0.09450995177030563,
-0.4778173565864563,
0.08362267166376114,
0.5114340782165527,
-0.3155854046344757,
-0.5695328712463379,
0.7538286447525024,
0.4119866192340851,
-0.4714764356613159,
0.4434845745563507,
-0.09681117534637451,
-0.17023923993110657,
0.13439324498176575,
0.45221903920173645,
0.8805308938026428,
-0.38463085889816284,
0.18012575805187225,
0.3452635705471039,
-0.04326818138360977,
0.08740800619125366,
0.19665032625198364,
-0.2735917270183563,
-0.7988919615745544,
0.12127438187599182,
-0.73687744140625,
-0.26388823986053467,
0.2444041669368744,
-0.5706166625022888,
0.40666481852531433,
-0.7157618999481201,
-0.38965409994125366,
0.24337808787822723,
-0.0410819873213768,
-1.0100083351135254,
-0.15096083283424377,
-0.027758700773119926,
0.6436387300491333,
-0.6334128975868225,
0.8371227383613586,
0.7695497870445251,
-0.5198356509208679,
-0.2804599702358246,
-0.08229836821556091,
0.19487538933753967,
-0.8478444218635559,
0.7080634236335754,
-0.11511006206274033,
-0.16773585975170135,
0.09875315427780151,
-0.25535139441490173,
-0.7407150864601135,
1.4322679042816162,
0.532683253288269,
-0.7196768522262573,
-0.26555880904197693,
-0.16176672279834747,
0.38935762643814087,
-0.7858785390853882,
0.046676963567733765,
0.33158206939697266,
0.3449186086654663,
0.029708921909332275,
-0.6458359360694885,
0.2584909498691559,
-0.23155900835990906,
0.14332419633865356,
-0.04669640213251114,
-0.5585631132125854,
0.6604891419410706,
-0.25569820404052734,
-0.39080706238746643,
-0.1522298902273178,
0.7287647128105164,
0.6891214847564697,
0.6075904369354248,
0.5396791100502014,
0.33196231722831726,
0.7667577266693115,
0.05217950418591499,
1.1604785919189453,
-0.5370720028877258,
0.014710239134728909,
1.3157682418823242,
-0.3298092186450958,
0.7384406328201294,
0.30672934651374817,
0.08387447893619537,
0.5212305188179016,
0.36635205149650574,
0.07975925505161285,
0.427072674036026,
0.1558549851179123,
-0.2820926606655121,
-0.4919542968273163,
-0.22711773216724396,
-0.23253828287124634,
0.11736001074314117,
0.19358976185321808,
-0.47833409905433655,
-0.1526162475347519,
-0.2476830929517746,
0.1028403714299202,
0.03681747987866402,
-0.23198388516902924,
0.8175639510154724,
-0.03502440080046654,
-0.6455925107002258,
0.28485020995140076,
0.22723330557346344,
0.9732627272605896,
-0.7263952493667603,
0.08321426808834076,
-0.4088341295719147,
0.09671306610107422,
-0.32517704367637634,
-0.6647603511810303,
-0.2650149166584015,
0.001405014074407518,
-0.6954531073570251,
-0.22881004214286804,
0.6394292712211609,
-0.40441617369651794,
-0.36337053775787354,
0.16078773140907288,
0.43034598231315613,
-0.08379074931144714,
-0.20942369103431702,
-0.5095419883728027,
0.2791576087474823,
0.30516505241394043,
-0.10958316922187805,
0.34256789088249207,
-0.11650265753269196,
-0.19472917914390564,
0.9937698841094971,
0.9102887511253357,
0.13993848860263824,
0.08746469765901566,
0.08358002454042435,
0.794073224067688,
-0.6655921339988708,
-0.3859683573246002,
-0.7742380499839783,
0.5221887826919556,
-0.1019539162516594,
-0.6300575137138367,
0.7855541706085205,
0.6575164794921875,
0.6624605655670166,
-0.10258709639310837,
0.6420503854751587,
0.33702173829078674,
0.24826547503471375,
-0.34193262457847595,
0.5204641819000244,
-0.4518286883831024,
0.45095717906951904,
-0.04580606520175934,
-1.0992027521133423,
0.07857616245746613,
0.2626040279865265,
-0.22066061198711395,
0.12711744010448456,
0.13960470259189606,
0.8225036859512329,
-0.27186962962150574,
-0.2817859351634979,
0.2538772523403168,
0.1078735738992691,
0.5751056671142578,
0.4631916880607605,
0.6084511280059814,
-0.026834769174456596,
0.5189447402954102,
-0.4145389497280121,
-0.3562358319759369,
-0.47420597076416016,
-0.6200734972953796,
-1.1027143001556396,
-0.7735620737075806,
-0.35763776302337646,
-0.15487180650234222,
0.10467686504125595,
1.0345321893692017,
0.8775579929351807,
-0.8478851318359375,
-0.22480276226997375,
0.17142531275749207,
0.18450912833213806,
-0.013779581524431705,
-0.2287130504846573,
0.24734452366828918,
-0.3447294235229492,
-0.6837918758392334,
0.5721431970596313,
0.3879726231098175,
0.10957468301057816,
-0.3634612262248993,
-0.3514535129070282,
0.4166291356086731,
0.12164544314146042,
0.5562563538551331,
0.4100077450275421,
-1.0138330459594727,
-0.108856201171875,
0.14799050986766815,
-0.0727476254105568,
0.013835080899298191,
1.0771533250808716,
-0.8522749543190002,
0.5750914812088013,
0.5050971508026123,
0.5127686858177185,
0.7294521331787109,
0.2639250159263611,
0.8278878927230835,
-0.7527264356613159,
-0.28971225023269653,
0.0850335955619812,
0.6108139753341675,
0.2724577784538269,
-0.5171670913696289,
0.21407660841941833,
0.03921916335821152,
-0.38858112692832947,
-0.8186057209968567,
0.4182514548301697,
-1.1731430292129517,
-0.16861508786678314,
1.180841326713562,
-0.20100054144859314,
0.02164948359131813,
-0.25394725799560547,
-0.24055354297161102,
-0.003532104194164276,
-0.8940208554267883,
0.9576817154884338,
0.6203597187995911,
-0.23189878463745117,
-0.1235324963927269,
-0.3910180330276489,
0.5908713936805725,
0.18967287242412567,
-0.6614308953285217,
0.0003575756272766739,
0.4661067724227905,
0.6584019064903259,
0.3604075312614441,
0.43992742896080017,
0.36662036180496216,
0.31073468923568726,
-0.4938918650150299,
-0.01632297970354557,
-0.5912528038024902,
-0.5157987475395203,
-0.44607144594192505,
0.5317333340644836,
-0.12233372777700424,
0.17382150888442993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02886v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02886v2
|
PLaD: Preference-based Large Language Model Distillation with Pseudo-Preference Pairs
| 2024-06-05T03:08:25 | 2024-06-06T12:47:31 |
Rongzhi Zhang, Jiaming Shen, Tianqi Liu, Haorui Wang, Zhen Qin, Feng Han, Jialu Liu, Simon Baumgartner, Michael Bendersky, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive capabilities in
various tasks, yet their vast parameter sizes restrict their applicability in
resource-constrained settings. Knowledge distillation (KD) offers a viable
solution by transferring expertise from large teacher models to compact student
models. However, traditional KD techniques face specific challenges when
applied to LLMs, including restricted access to LLM outputs, significant
teacher-student capacity gaps, and the inherited mis-calibration issue. In this
work, we present PLaD, a novel preference-based LLM distillation framework.
PLaD exploits the teacher-student capacity discrepancy to generate
pseudo-preference pairs where teacher outputs are preferred over student
outputs. Then, PLaD leverages a ranking loss to re-calibrate student's
estimation of sequence likelihood, which steers the student's focus towards
understanding the relative quality of outputs instead of simply imitating the
teacher. PLaD bypasses the need for access to teacher LLM's internal states,
tackles the student's expressivity limitations, and mitigates the student
mis-calibration issue. Through extensive experiments on two sequence generation
tasks and with various LLMs, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed
PLaD framework.
|
[
-0.4499422311782837,
-0.4046590328216553,
0.7900933623313904,
-0.08629938960075378,
-0.41998976469039917,
0.30059564113616943,
-0.5183939337730408,
0.31470435857772827,
0.110518679022789,
0.4561549127101898,
-0.07728812098503113,
-0.2835373878479004,
-0.7202818989753723,
0.0390767976641655,
-0.14074108004570007,
1.1309289932250977,
-0.20728076994419098,
0.13289760053157806,
-0.61480313539505,
-0.07980158179998398,
-0.5814305543899536,
-0.5864577293395996,
-0.22930754721164703,
-0.5064781308174133,
0.3435728847980499,
0.9213284850120544,
0.47123557329177856,
0.13876652717590332,
0.23344728350639343,
0.29985132813453674,
0.048032425343990326,
0.25408780574798584,
-0.7668007612228394,
0.16809788346290588,
-0.11791148036718369,
-0.4160494804382324,
-0.33340418338775635,
0.22012779116630554,
0.6619052290916443,
0.7945212125778198,
-0.2577672600746155,
0.19201642274856567,
0.30216678977012634,
1.0105968713760376,
-0.5937877893447876,
-0.04249345511198044,
-0.7396188378334045,
-0.1807428002357483,
-0.3155687153339386,
0.02654372900724411,
-0.5443375110626221,
-0.4708356559276581,
0.4662157893180847,
-0.4107823967933655,
0.32758110761642456,
-0.111278235912323,
0.37771812081336975,
0.2844686508178711,
-0.5205960869789124,
-0.1931844800710678,
-0.6430363059043884,
0.8565321564674377,
-0.7191392779350281,
0.1719077229499817,
0.6419709324836731,
0.5250484347343445,
-0.26964694261550903,
-0.7602496147155762,
-0.8247064352035522,
-0.07658189535140991,
0.05183806270360947,
-0.11267492920160294,
0.3671252429485321,
0.10601215809583664,
0.09224565327167511,
0.5973770022392273,
-0.43196746706962585,
-0.06523891538381577,
-0.3970130681991577,
-0.033516671508550644,
0.5377854108810425,
-0.14215023815631866,
0.03410331904888153,
-0.024782974272966385,
-0.31935569643974304,
-0.302064448595047,
-0.6875892877578735,
-0.00029329588869586587,
0.5260292291641235,
0.23956377804279327,
-0.018899347633123398,
0.6510950326919556,
-0.009217068552970886,
0.719368577003479,
0.24855172634124756,
-0.42608439922332764,
0.2553202211856842,
0.0507366880774498,
-0.24956458806991577,
0.249673530459404,
0.6739078760147095,
0.22252638638019562,
0.14859841763973236,
0.02276243083178997,
-0.2090219408273697,
0.09512858837842941,
-0.12309533357620239,
-0.8238412737846375,
-0.744583010673523,
0.1388157606124878,
-0.2879147231578827,
-0.2762570083141327,
-0.14068946242332458,
-0.7530571222305298,
-0.6378492116928101,
-0.38632944226264954,
0.43976181745529175,
-0.2537058889865875,
-0.41377386450767517,
0.2413206547498703,
-0.1344119906425476,
-0.13512790203094482,
0.04390627145767212,
-0.8899757266044617,
0.06566045433282852,
0.44898197054862976,
0.8511306047439575,
-0.43162938952445984,
-0.25799182057380676,
-0.4389733076095581,
0.10661166161298752,
0.05790230259299278,
0.47602391242980957,
-0.5778627991676331,
-0.7847877740859985,
-0.3695197105407715,
-0.3362228274345398,
0.029006196185946465,
-0.8193367123603821,
0.35453301668167114,
-0.5203657746315002,
0.17908959090709686,
-0.417873352766037,
-0.820848286151886,
0.050348442047834396,
-0.08806668967008591,
-0.6834614276885986,
0.8852640390396118,
0.10746721923351288,
-0.6776172518730164,
0.34963545203208923,
-0.390455424785614,
-0.2583959996700287,
0.013864118605852127,
-0.34701547026634216,
-0.40237298607826233,
0.19553594291210175,
-0.04062135890126228,
0.3796481490135193,
-0.47698119282722473,
0.7809920907020569,
-0.422499418258667,
-0.13100409507751465,
0.10720337182283401,
-0.4750414788722992,
0.624778151512146,
0.2425827980041504,
-0.0024766135029494762,
0.10240843147039413,
-0.8222618699073792,
-0.21064279973506927,
0.22180841863155365,
-0.32319843769073486,
-0.7492924332618713,
-0.2025144100189209,
-0.2306215912103653,
0.09373480081558228,
0.5690147876739502,
-0.46179673075675964,
0.3521057367324829,
-0.25405314564704895,
0.5770118236541748,
0.9229822754859924,
-0.215232253074646,
0.7518609166145325,
-0.4766350984573364,
0.3826432228088379,
-0.03369242325425148,
-0.22549384832382202,
0.055456358939409256,
-0.31671714782714844,
-0.581139862537384,
-0.4634621739387512,
0.24121147394180298,
0.17888832092285156,
-0.9581050872802734,
0.2710196077823639,
-0.23576952517032623,
-0.4728274643421173,
-0.5293406844139099,
0.4927766025066376,
0.280985951423645,
0.7719020843505859,
0.2727825939655304,
-0.20961102843284607,
-0.5323259830474854,
-0.6886926889419556,
0.11098306626081467,
-0.27381324768066406,
0.13549219071865082,
0.4157470166683197,
0.18569089472293854,
0.19968059659004211,
1.2359734773635864,
-0.8205088376998901,
-0.3878256678581238,
-0.5441210269927979,
0.12622082233428955,
0.4244377911090851,
0.31400737166404724,
0.5657705068588257,
-0.8799834251403809,
-0.6178698539733887,
-0.4104732871055603,
-0.3160873353481293,
-0.30225518345832825,
-0.014009220525622368,
-0.34309008717536926,
0.14872750639915466,
0.16239328682422638,
-0.3678319454193115,
0.17321017384529114,
0.7061047554016113,
-0.18977205455303192,
0.5980912446975708,
-0.4450959861278534,
-0.021874122321605682,
-1.181692123413086,
0.026278890669345856,
-0.03460371121764183,
-0.2412155717611313,
-0.40716397762298584,
-0.17030057311058044,
0.14374156296253204,
0.03146492317318916,
-0.42087262868881226,
0.48690974712371826,
-0.27378228306770325,
-0.14434674382209778,
-0.5315454006195068,
0.10161012411117554,
0.24935859441757202,
0.23963455855846405,
0.2861838936805725,
0.8282281756401062,
0.30966487526893616,
-0.4742748439311981,
0.4955732226371765,
0.24628464877605438,
-0.46669280529022217,
0.48437249660491943,
-0.5404397249221802,
0.26211681962013245,
-0.0672847330570221,
0.5419491529464722,
-1.3505468368530273,
-0.037431806325912476,
-0.23710674047470093,
-0.13830645382404327,
0.3063753545284271,
-0.2755551040172577,
-0.2970619797706604,
-0.3354046046733856,
-0.33242660760879517,
0.8039043545722961,
0.6094695329666138,
-0.7322063446044922,
0.44721588492393494,
0.3316513001918793,
-0.19220666587352753,
-0.4824988543987274,
-0.4575933516025543,
-0.0005037077353335917,
-0.3991590738296509,
-0.5127012729644775,
0.4114581048488617,
-0.4186992943286896,
-0.2150784581899643,
-0.08501267433166504,
-0.22804419696331024,
-0.08907799422740936,
-0.012863628566265106,
0.21451684832572937,
0.5983687043190002,
-0.08315311372280121,
0.03608303144574165,
0.28431612253189087,
-0.022752543911337852,
-0.15798068046569824,
-0.305404394865036,
0.6600418090820312,
0.1065971776843071,
-0.28808021545410156,
-0.20510289072990417,
0.045467525720596313,
0.755012035369873,
-0.12718938291072845,
0.7040092945098877,
0.05309326946735382,
0.07919163256883621,
-0.5669009685516357,
-0.6734396815299988,
-0.42168089747428894,
-0.5092859864234924,
0.20990483462810516,
-0.3578358590602875,
-0.8546348214149475,
0.24614112079143524,
-0.3219795227050781,
0.05233616754412651,
-0.02271914854645729,
0.4822903573513031,
-0.058238811790943146,
0.4643573760986328,
0.4402198791503906,
-0.323367714881897,
0.350389689207077,
-0.37548378109931946,
0.3055292069911957,
-0.7515074610710144,
-0.02446606755256653,
-0.3354972004890442,
-0.6324198246002197,
-0.1547693908214569,
-0.4288109540939331,
0.5147101879119873,
0.15126286447048187,
-0.13359443843364716,
0.13037726283073425,
-0.2803848683834076,
0.6680780649185181,
0.7604897022247314,
-0.0725736916065216,
0.33301645517349243,
-0.08991924673318863,
-0.44266143441200256,
-0.16957825422286987,
-0.5869723558425903,
-0.5804336071014404,
1.477278470993042,
0.04308594763278961,
0.6092953681945801,
0.2767196595668793,
1.0281282663345337,
0.27818241715431213,
0.17801021039485931,
-0.6110367178916931,
0.683508038520813,
-0.5022251605987549,
-0.39982298016548157,
-0.3179727792739868,
-0.38504594564437866,
-0.39672785997390747,
0.2542848587036133,
-0.09286126494407654,
-0.29336485266685486,
0.12871791422367096,
0.35539159178733826,
-0.3633422553539276,
0.4357357323169708,
-0.9691462516784668,
0.8236016631126404,
-0.21158498525619507,
-0.5293448567390442,
-0.1357956826686859,
-0.5796642899513245,
0.5489894151687622,
-0.36283543705940247,
0.15597566962242126,
-0.1179099977016449,
0.33840882778167725,
0.5479578375816345,
-0.7141785621643066,
0.8256427645683289,
-0.39343497157096863,
-0.17851762473583221,
0.360110342502594,
0.2206556797027588,
0.4776444137096405,
0.1443372517824173,
-0.3279789090156555,
0.0482211634516716,
-0.05362394079566002,
-0.17838510870933533,
-0.48755577206611633,
1.1119712591171265,
-0.8942607045173645,
-0.9250847101211548,
-0.3103216588497162,
-0.6814778447151184,
-0.3078155219554901,
0.1444486826658249,
0.13335131108760834,
0.13274924457073212,
0.06473337113857269,
0.07452910393476486,
0.6142557859420776,
-0.30378252267837524,
0.5047847628593445,
0.5540640354156494,
-0.2567285895347595,
-0.3471749424934387,
1.133026361465454,
0.16061937808990479,
0.5938177704811096,
0.060993682593107224,
0.43431785702705383,
-0.5640786290168762,
-0.5400184392929077,
-0.5141648054122925,
0.20455701649188995,
-0.5104156136512756,
-0.09496615827083588,
-0.23125995695590973,
0.0038578982930630445,
-0.5632322430610657,
-0.20779962837696075,
-0.43543320894241333,
-0.40886640548706055,
-0.46128031611442566,
-0.21298591792583466,
0.3493933081626892,
0.3685086965560913,
0.01718566007912159,
0.22471274435520172,
-0.5522815585136414,
0.5092890858650208,
0.5662068724632263,
0.33568277955055237,
-0.05126231536269188,
-0.8628042936325073,
0.1999756395816803,
0.023160645738244057,
-0.4135536253452301,
-0.7587740421295166,
0.5125048756599426,
0.3510892391204834,
0.3461393415927887,
0.40331435203552246,
0.6361037492752075,
0.6915225386619568,
-0.4948808252811432,
0.7599539756774902,
0.25472909212112427,
-0.9486528635025024,
0.4815056324005127,
0.060527969151735306,
0.09319201111793518,
0.7166528701782227,
0.32107779383659363,
-0.29740551114082336,
-0.2824995219707489,
-0.26694563031196594,
-1.0008703470230103,
0.7526214122772217,
-0.1470644474029541,
0.04465077444911003,
0.04231392964720726,
0.36324164271354675,
0.4829023778438568,
0.3569490313529968,
-0.5730523467063904,
-0.4727333188056946,
-0.26127302646636963,
-0.4890821874141693,
-0.2966117858886719,
-0.41556888818740845,
-0.005175703205168247,
-0.1436365842819214,
0.8029366135597229,
0.015900589525699615,
-0.5023412108421326,
0.07140286266803741,
-0.17797835171222687,
0.058950453996658325,
0.3042086958885193,
0.38757026195526123,
0.6052417159080505,
-0.2820454239845276,
0.49377402663230896,
-0.016774732619524002,
-0.5278199315071106,
0.5148966312408447,
0.0562128946185112,
-0.16616088151931763,
-0.19722601771354675,
-0.17978207767009735,
0.7143856287002563,
0.0023162185680121183,
-0.7343197464942932,
0.5794485807418823,
0.00979197584092617,
-0.20669162273406982,
-0.18934448063373566,
0.08817988634109497,
0.12647601962089539,
0.20260901749134064,
0.35654157400131226,
-0.10438302904367447,
0.047721490263938904,
-0.25338903069496155,
0.16131827235221863,
0.20082397758960724,
0.1382284015417099,
-0.18699052929878235,
0.5627594590187073,
0.33809027075767517,
0.1010197103023529,
0.4049306809902191,
-0.2362680435180664,
-0.22379471361637115,
0.5222061276435852,
0.5802140235900879,
0.6396112442016602,
-0.3223946690559387,
0.395154744386673,
0.19570262730121613,
-0.2892831265926361,
-0.42499783635139465,
0.15062135457992554,
-0.14700162410736084,
-0.874146044254303,
-0.31836575269699097,
-0.7608693838119507,
-0.3661741316318512,
0.3868217468261719,
-0.6128951907157898,
0.3919394612312317,
-0.4911626875400543,
-0.24151010811328888,
-0.07431846857070923,
-0.05564520135521889,
-0.276358962059021,
-0.10740578919649124,
0.18653357028961182,
0.5300285220146179,
-0.907260000705719,
1.2286633253097534,
0.876112163066864,
-0.16096343100070953,
-0.7593342661857605,
-0.046050600707530975,
0.12259651720523834,
-0.536378026008606,
0.8944916725158691,
-0.10125279426574707,
-0.011257464997470379,
0.1361810266971588,
-0.06512659043073654,
-0.563453197479248,
1.210532546043396,
0.6771974563598633,
-0.9876258373260498,
0.11488965153694153,
0.2607002556324005,
0.2068004459142685,
-0.22009359300136566,
-0.03659937158226967,
0.601040780544281,
0.2362203299999237,
0.4353327453136444,
-0.9582589864730835,
-0.047441478818655014,
0.03490876406431198,
0.053591735661029816,
0.21089830994606018,
-0.623340368270874,
0.8330705761909485,
-0.46487516164779663,
-0.0697031021118164,
-0.09781143814325333,
0.6823655366897583,
0.6246839165687561,
0.5442516207695007,
0.6247338652610779,
0.6382116079330444,
0.8437779545783997,
0.10239891707897186,
0.5563710927963257,
-0.41034889221191406,
0.29899919033050537,
1.604158878326416,
-0.7747204899787903,
0.860130786895752,
0.8789861798286438,
-0.30380940437316895,
0.2660597562789917,
0.3214849531650543,
0.29153311252593994,
0.8705598711967468,
0.3863268196582794,
-0.5213273167610168,
-0.29852578043937683,
-0.0563473254442215,
-0.3728690445423126,
0.25942346453666687,
0.12385126948356628,
-0.3151717483997345,
-0.09987829625606537,
0.3054448962211609,
-0.1335226148366928,
0.4425705373287201,
-0.17801982164382935,
0.6465202569961548,
0.13507145643234253,
-0.8540218472480774,
0.5631566643714905,
-0.001640952075831592,
0.7657724618911743,
-0.4169040024280548,
-0.01599983498454094,
-0.341445654630661,
0.1448383331298828,
-0.062338441610336304,
-0.6667622923851013,
-0.05215023085474968,
0.07791711390018463,
-0.34209248423576355,
-0.3235686421394348,
0.5612472295761108,
-0.7967337369918823,
-0.3691640794277191,
-0.011470125988125801,
0.3619129955768585,
-0.014912864193320274,
0.1948932707309723,
-0.26307427883148193,
0.08826956152915955,
0.1108739972114563,
-0.028957340866327286,
0.47561657428741455,
0.3874136805534363,
0.08261948823928833,
0.3719222843647003,
0.5556177496910095,
0.36444973945617676,
0.008396424353122711,
0.17100092768669128,
0.9162301421165466,
-0.15329501032829285,
-0.41344600915908813,
-0.9037070870399475,
0.2109632045030594,
0.04141249135136604,
-0.23793745040893555,
0.631219744682312,
0.5784327387809753,
1.0133073329925537,
-0.09217147529125214,
1.0429115295410156,
-0.016729997470974922,
0.40515798330307007,
-0.3960910141468048,
0.6683228015899658,
-0.297930508852005,
0.7032889723777771,
-0.19368530809879303,
-0.9235689640045166,
0.06801524758338928,
0.7222771644592285,
-0.6564186215400696,
-0.024763599038124084,
0.5072104334831238,
0.5895270705223083,
-0.10153057426214218,
0.046763185411691666,
0.40329423546791077,
0.29057198762893677,
0.4734098017215729,
0.8574782609939575,
0.6961228251457214,
0.04632517322897911,
0.33796826004981995,
-0.34583544731140137,
-0.3365356922149658,
-0.20308548212051392,
-0.9606836438179016,
-0.902063250541687,
-0.8017780184745789,
-0.367378830909729,
-0.20916251838207245,
-0.038967542350292206,
1.2266137599945068,
0.5235360264778137,
-0.7096368074417114,
-0.32473060488700867,
-0.12318752706050873,
0.10664131492376328,
0.33147546648979187,
-0.20506975054740906,
0.4499214291572571,
-0.18370294570922852,
-0.8001061677932739,
0.37527620792388916,
-0.06103115156292915,
0.2299913614988327,
-0.37836018204689026,
-0.21972936391830444,
0.023896612226963043,
-0.14052660763263702,
0.3554055988788605,
0.13132420182228088,
-0.6443155407905579,
-0.03641776740550995,
-0.28851380944252014,
0.034561268985271454,
-0.1629745215177536,
0.910810649394989,
-0.9142999053001404,
0.5990232825279236,
0.542572557926178,
0.7127541303634644,
0.3763832747936249,
-0.21609506011009216,
0.6545169353485107,
-0.9330385327339172,
0.24195238947868347,
0.07803680002689362,
0.4098210334777832,
0.3179399073123932,
-0.1779358983039856,
0.13026176393032074,
0.3828203082084656,
-0.49911198019981384,
-0.9888511300086975,
0.14083892107009888,
-0.8037164211273193,
-0.41816696524620056,
1.2590303421020508,
-0.40920886397361755,
0.10826675593852997,
0.003926308825612068,
-0.49218034744262695,
0.22305777668952942,
-0.6259132623672485,
0.9935477375984192,
0.8141935467720032,
0.21730346977710724,
0.12864451110363007,
-0.4506121575832367,
0.47036999464035034,
0.519366443157196,
-0.36223161220550537,
0.1778486967086792,
0.6911709308624268,
0.3418302834033966,
-0.22410565614700317,
0.5555530786514282,
-0.025471454486250877,
0.03300047293305397,
-0.6013100743293762,
-0.06292397528886795,
-0.43458810448646545,
-0.44922077655792236,
-0.12542939186096191,
0.3431798219680786,
0.36211657524108887,
-0.2595301866531372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02882v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02882v3
|
Outdated Issue Aware Decoding for Reasoning Questions on Edited Knowledge
| 2024-06-05T03:00:15 | 2024-06-16T08:50:34 |
Zengkui Sun, Yijin Liu, Jiaan Wang, Fandong Meng, Jinan Xu, Yufeng Chen, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, Knowledge Editing has received increasing attention, since it could
update the specific knowledge from outdated ones in pretrained models without
re-training. However, as pointed out by recent studies, existing related
methods tend to merely memorize the superficial word composition of the edited
knowledge, rather than truly learning and absorbing it. Consequently, on the
reasoning questions, we discover that existing methods struggle to utilize the
edited knowledge to reason the new answer, and tend to retain outdated
responses, which are generated by the original models utilizing original
knowledge. Nevertheless, the outdated responses are unexpected for the correct
answers to reasoning questions, which we named as the outdated issue. To
alleviate this issue, in this paper, we propose a simple yet effective decoding
strategy, i.e., outDated ISsue aware deCOding (DISCO), to enhance the
performance of edited models on reasoning questions. Specifically, we capture
the difference in the probability distribution between the original and edited
models. Further, we amplify the difference of the token prediction in the
edited model to alleviate the outdated issue, and thus enhance the model
performance w.r.t the edited knowledge. Experimental results suggest that
applying DISCO could enhance edited models to reason, e.g., on reasoning
questions, DISCO outperforms the prior SOTA method by 12.99 F1 scores, and
reduces the ratio of the outdated issue to 5.78% on the zsRE dataset.
|
[
-0.34177979826927185,
-0.9833048582077026,
0.5484952330589294,
-0.09603317826986313,
-0.39887720346450806,
-0.22385944426059723,
-0.015721021220088005,
-0.4669773280620575,
0.22750113904476166,
0.6226283311843872,
-0.6397081613540649,
-0.2955092191696167,
-0.2407083958387375,
0.36343494057655334,
-0.21903356909751892,
0.7634430527687073,
0.06376053392887115,
0.0897173136472702,
-0.43186649680137634,
-0.18412764370441437,
-0.7391368746757507,
-0.5184012055397034,
-0.6261104941368103,
-0.08941727876663208,
-0.06940735131502151,
0.2654857039451599,
0.42506644129753113,
0.5322023630142212,
0.36615362763404846,
0.2769817113876343,
-0.7084974050521851,
0.6716527938842773,
-0.4251859188079834,
-0.1488896757364273,
-0.5361394286155701,
-0.5841587781906128,
-0.5576798915863037,
-0.34522926807403564,
0.24604947865009308,
0.4645146429538727,
-0.07923884689807892,
-0.07171673327684402,
-0.27507808804512024,
0.8342540264129639,
-1.0837675333023071,
-0.07641971856355667,
-0.9603251814842224,
-0.09599790722131729,
0.17300523817539215,
-0.5268414616584778,
-0.6376771926879883,
-0.3875461518764496,
-0.07552115619182587,
-0.9121698141098022,
0.21636973321437836,
-0.3189273178577423,
0.5598100423812866,
0.3917916417121887,
-0.36415836215019226,
-0.46982327103614807,
-0.6662752628326416,
0.3243701159954071,
-0.8370853066444397,
0.5680544376373291,
0.3116834759712219,
-0.03023512475192547,
-0.3637291193008423,
-0.6585606336593628,
-0.7032593488693237,
0.08675933629274368,
0.2907368838787079,
0.29644739627838135,
-0.6184316277503967,
-0.0475313626229763,
0.27560359239578247,
0.185598686337471,
0.011934242211282253,
-0.22679027915000916,
-0.284176766872406,
-0.3070823550224304,
0.684387743473053,
0.06593640148639679,
0.1841755211353302,
-0.501483142375946,
-0.2055395394563675,
0.17360654473304749,
-0.5727635025978088,
0.005239891819655895,
0.531223714351654,
-0.08077611774206161,
0.4539235532283783,
0.546821117401123,
-0.3929751217365265,
0.9008393287658691,
0.3370608985424042,
0.30276742577552795,
0.2464488297700882,
-0.46986231207847595,
-0.006243487354367971,
0.1403651237487793,
0.37044912576675415,
0.37660297751426697,
0.0640287697315216,
0.0733116939663887,
-0.12603551149368286,
-0.24082441627979279,
0.3892490863800049,
-0.30931490659713745,
-0.6248983144760132,
0.24112139642238617,
-0.11789749562740326,
0.09133685380220413,
-0.055171046406030655,
-0.9056009650230408,
-0.6691850423812866,
-0.249561607837677,
0.4754907488822937,
-0.7043560147285461,
-0.4423009157180786,
0.6532267332077026,
-0.3489791750907898,
-0.07501070201396942,
0.8675569891929626,
-0.4385572075843811,
-0.10302664339542389,
0.5360532402992249,
0.29399988055229187,
0.4745906591415405,
0.28247758746147156,
-0.2983129620552063,
-0.04777920991182327,
-0.4204363226890564,
1.0088156461715698,
-0.4319465756416321,
-0.3440527021884918,
-0.20938637852668762,
-0.2976042628288269,
-0.010054324753582478,
-0.4843299984931946,
0.6247031688690186,
-0.8629887104034424,
-0.15007023513317108,
-0.5779210329055786,
-0.8687095046043396,
-0.23515883088111877,
0.3172624707221985,
-0.8376122117042542,
0.7781000137329102,
-0.009485941380262375,
-1.0648021697998047,
0.12537474930286407,
-0.6617498397827148,
0.033355969935655594,
-0.1843378096818924,
0.10406369715929031,
-0.27500858902931213,
0.18873712420463562,
0.6888653039932251,
-0.0716540515422821,
0.10121729224920273,
0.1495039463043213,
-0.24644728004932404,
-0.3163832724094391,
0.4751133620738983,
-0.35216596722602844,
0.7749636173248291,
0.24238918721675873,
-0.09880542755126953,
-0.17903505265712738,
-0.8410254120826721,
0.2611902952194214,
-0.016973624005913734,
-0.35302215814590454,
-0.7225116491317749,
0.10361077636480331,
-0.7293351888656616,
0.004865451715886593,
0.34569329023361206,
-0.537445068359375,
0.22609843313694,
-0.4404168725013733,
0.2674514949321747,
0.8908307552337646,
0.6299524903297424,
0.4164852499961853,
-0.12883858382701874,
0.5036118030548096,
0.30570921301841736,
0.14964410662651062,
-0.1065104529261589,
-0.42555496096611023,
-0.9053806066513062,
-0.10987693071365356,
0.46134382486343384,
0.6818937659263611,
-1.1296169757843018,
0.4907817542552948,
-0.18647713959217072,
-0.5903171300888062,
-1.064217209815979,
0.13815131783485413,
0.2736603021621704,
0.5212033987045288,
0.670071005821228,
0.05102543532848358,
-0.7433825135231018,
-0.575559675693512,
-0.7803145051002502,
-0.33359286189079285,
0.3947908282279968,
0.32008272409439087,
0.39186087250709534,
-0.10194647312164307,
1.1911990642547607,
-0.674720048904419,
0.027677657082676888,
-0.3340960741043091,
0.012093990109860897,
-0.1513405293226242,
0.5161091089248657,
0.06747887283563614,
-0.8261098265647888,
0.15356841683387756,
-0.027791915461421013,
-0.7136324644088745,
-0.23810133337974548,
-0.2728029787540436,
-0.3200242817401886,
0.3271169364452362,
0.6613796353340149,
-0.5800982713699341,
0.444090873003006,
-0.004785945173352957,
-0.5816197991371155,
0.7084782123565674,
-0.2784411311149597,
0.33390143513679504,
-0.9824260473251343,
-0.06847134232521057,
-0.0004797970468644053,
-0.029226813465356827,
-0.5398915410041809,
0.0894647166132927,
0.37434765696525574,
0.035994067788124084,
-0.615679144859314,
0.39386922121047974,
-0.42002272605895996,
0.35267773270606995,
-0.005615323781967163,
0.152211531996727,
0.2976643145084381,
0.3300589919090271,
-0.0317913293838501,
0.3292325437068939,
0.030209142714738846,
-0.545142412185669,
0.157077357172966,
0.40354123711586,
-0.47594234347343445,
0.4800117015838623,
-0.5332836508750916,
0.4571209251880646,
-0.5416353344917297,
0.14632177352905273,
-0.7372539043426514,
0.15099798142910004,
0.25885656476020813,
-0.4300420880317688,
0.16796845197677612,
-0.19189439713954926,
-0.3560791015625,
-0.2587733864784241,
-0.036621738225221634,
0.48793259263038635,
0.3002919852733612,
-0.4072572886943817,
0.7309710383415222,
0.07314278185367584,
0.05327003076672554,
-0.7321725487709045,
-0.5121632218360901,
-0.2699565887451172,
-0.13128231465816498,
-0.6623970866203308,
-0.019542930647730827,
-0.1462211161851883,
-0.3034142255783081,
0.4152250289916992,
-0.557013213634491,
-0.30053311586380005,
0.1696694940328598,
-0.3138236999511719,
0.13603954017162323,
-0.14027796685695648,
0.23270520567893982,
0.25297683477401733,
-0.1247837096452713,
0.10454072803258896,
-0.057051967829465866,
0.2797287702560425,
0.0007066008984111249,
-0.35303014516830444,
-0.3929647207260132,
0.26788172125816345,
0.4233027696609497,
-0.6989930868148804,
0.63835209608078,
0.26682689785957336,
-0.4353525936603546,
-0.2585480511188507,
-0.6307533383369446,
-0.1934073567390442,
-0.45932263135910034,
0.5632251501083374,
-0.5298411250114441,
-0.7791746258735657,
0.7460154891014099,
-0.38531729578971863,
-0.12567102909088135,
0.4573843479156494,
0.0775018036365509,
-0.166664719581604,
0.9168912172317505,
0.24783973395824432,
0.38959038257598877,
0.5460124611854553,
-0.45716407895088196,
0.32328322529792786,
-0.9192174077033997,
-0.4566527307033539,
-0.5496087074279785,
-0.0475599505007267,
-0.05811072513461113,
-0.46714553236961365,
0.2229539453983307,
0.7935873866081238,
-0.021492403000593185,
0.12762822210788727,
-0.5068576335906982,
0.5134642124176025,
0.31573572754859924,
0.5945152640342712,
0.5660318732261658,
-0.28545162081718445,
0.13869896531105042,
-0.1925918310880661,
-1.002699375152588,
-0.144707590341568,
0.7653664946556091,
0.1560734212398529,
0.6765879988670349,
0.14198745787143707,
0.7311500310897827,
0.40309807658195496,
-0.056384582072496414,
-0.5022556185722351,
0.6765453219413757,
0.06907705217599869,
-0.5864838361740112,
-0.1225472167134285,
-0.78189617395401,
-0.6324731707572937,
0.25290799140930176,
-0.3947184383869171,
-0.4766230881214142,
0.6880471110343933,
0.4767925441265106,
-0.25499868392944336,
0.44151371717453003,
-0.7515565156936646,
1.0112553834915161,
0.11082815378904343,
-0.03659431263804436,
-0.08216274529695511,
-0.35140007734298706,
0.45254358649253845,
-0.2525586187839508,
0.27859368920326233,
0.17011719942092896,
0.2473292052745819,
0.8396091461181641,
-0.6208993792533875,
0.680464506149292,
-0.278145432472229,
0.06680376082658768,
0.6341902613639832,
0.2522576153278351,
0.7372557520866394,
0.23450903594493866,
-0.38106265664100647,
-0.013045208528637886,
0.028584055602550507,
-0.20966552197933197,
-1.0328372716903687,
0.2666504383087158,
-0.7836123108863831,
-0.9426253437995911,
-0.14180874824523926,
-0.5762893557548523,
-0.05287677422165871,
0.26407191157341003,
0.47716468572616577,
0.611679196357727,
0.052195120602846146,
-0.10486774146556854,
1.0440853834152222,
-0.19527915120124817,
-0.005331986118108034,
0.7186558246612549,
0.19402892887592316,
-0.5316059589385986,
0.5515584349632263,
0.24574129283428192,
0.36340874433517456,
0.2781887352466583,
0.04210357367992401,
-0.43677201867103577,
-0.6543917059898376,
-0.3573015034198761,
0.06935800611972809,
-1.2334089279174805,
-0.43967801332473755,
-1.0202717781066895,
-0.11042642593383789,
-0.2968725562095642,
-0.20906363427639008,
-0.5404794216156006,
-0.5307358503341675,
-0.48774847388267517,
-0.25017866492271423,
0.7209293842315674,
0.32502076029777527,
-0.0969894677400589,
-0.03315665200352669,
-0.8390415906906128,
0.38066837191581726,
0.11137551814317703,
0.16231170296669006,
-0.03968947380781174,
-0.6058493852615356,
-0.11911680549383163,
0.4477551281452179,
-0.27650186419487,
-1.3390753269195557,
0.03841704875230789,
-0.017897898331284523,
0.6234817504882812,
0.13915923237800598,
0.8390331268310547,
1.114599585533142,
-0.3755927085876465,
0.5720859169960022,
-0.016428133472800255,
-1.3558349609375,
0.937013566493988,
0.004559188615530729,
0.34732046723365784,
0.6879925727844238,
0.03905865177512169,
-0.35356780886650085,
-0.6238082647323608,
-0.85282301902771,
-0.814742386341095,
0.6294527649879456,
0.0894019603729248,
0.13788092136383057,
-0.4254845976829529,
0.6642892956733704,
0.00006900264270370826,
-0.02955816313624382,
-0.6349890828132629,
-0.14813117682933807,
-0.30147239565849304,
-0.13528718054294586,
0.5019262433052063,
-0.29809531569480896,
0.11150503158569336,
-0.47652673721313477,
0.7487406134605408,
0.09665821492671967,
0.35730108618736267,
0.6482133865356445,
-0.16444991528987885,
-0.09987818449735641,
0.5479617118835449,
0.3788537383079529,
0.5826749801635742,
-0.2478272020816803,
0.1348634660243988,
0.375943124294281,
-0.2575695216655731,
0.13648420572280884,
-0.04264656454324722,
-0.30790066719055176,
0.20603734254837036,
0.3473495543003082,
0.8934527039527893,
0.1547941118478775,
-0.6406155824661255,
0.3615642786026001,
-0.03113616444170475,
-0.13062500953674316,
-0.14699357748031616,
0.20966140925884247,
0.15016037225723267,
0.33023595809936523,
0.12669254839420319,
0.6399880051612854,
0.1572054922580719,
-0.2695161700248718,
0.2863773703575134,
0.1687411218881607,
-0.3200889229774475,
-0.008329181000590324,
0.5141373872756958,
0.1699737161397934,
-0.245421901345253,
0.7778171896934509,
-0.39092519879341125,
-0.6206157207489014,
0.7007688283920288,
0.7297090291976929,
0.5509123802185059,
-0.28003358840942383,
0.15375636518001556,
0.3805640637874603,
0.4592422842979431,
-0.22876256704330444,
0.6034480929374695,
0.10839121788740158,
-0.9578802585601807,
-0.4769204556941986,
-0.17090611159801483,
-0.14957323670387268,
0.025977015495300293,
-0.9716488718986511,
0.2674320340156555,
-0.26291075348854065,
-0.17231400310993195,
-0.2197287380695343,
-0.19092820584774017,
-0.5826272368431091,
0.2527429759502411,
-0.4955892264842987,
1.3484954833984375,
-0.8582165837287903,
0.4466846287250519,
0.9367592334747314,
-0.3291092813014984,
-0.848305881023407,
-0.10619828850030899,
-0.23931346833705902,
-0.21721972525119781,
0.16920030117034912,
-0.13895046710968018,
0.1535445600748062,
0.3010817766189575,
-0.26623719930648804,
-0.801373302936554,
0.8218552470207214,
0.5938433408737183,
-0.32034969329833984,
0.12853536009788513,
-0.22500957548618317,
0.40809351205825806,
0.020617857575416565,
0.09866166859865189,
0.6217895150184631,
0.29679691791534424,
0.16802473366260529,
-0.4934150278568268,
-0.0472109392285347,
-0.5941694378852844,
-0.1583627611398697,
0.5176545977592468,
-0.13492527604103088,
0.6980054974555969,
-0.48474183678627014,
-0.1426054984331131,
0.019397379830479622,
0.7918893098831177,
0.4368041753768921,
0.5462509989738464,
0.5809903144836426,
0.7674382328987122,
1.0140981674194336,
-0.10935615748167038,
0.9463081359863281,
0.023253923282027245,
0.297318696975708,
1.1315559148788452,
-0.00798666849732399,
0.8621698617935181,
0.3684118986129761,
0.17947155237197876,
0.5068575143814087,
0.5357333421707153,
0.21328578889369965,
0.7999614477157593,
0.11170890927314758,
-0.2887834906578064,
-0.5466089248657227,
0.030044211074709892,
-0.48673301935195923,
0.4933771789073944,
0.4248240888118744,
-0.13392013311386108,
-0.216095432639122,
0.13701103627681732,
0.1579686850309372,
0.3183097541332245,
-0.6473866701126099,
0.9791871905326843,
-0.11635193973779678,
-0.5255933403968811,
0.5701547861099243,
0.05497653782367706,
0.1827627271413803,
-0.5278202295303345,
-0.239790141582489,
-0.31057658791542053,
0.23075930774211884,
-0.22004245221614838,
-0.6525560021400452,
0.2508998215198517,
0.03702625259757042,
-0.33089181780815125,
0.30514633655548096,
0.8803972005844116,
-0.432956337928772,
-0.5617337822914124,
-0.11440153419971466,
0.5598263144493103,
-0.0039008772000670433,
-0.023823093622922897,
-0.6314406394958496,
0.15019343793392181,
0.4016866683959961,
-0.12759467959403992,
-0.21698477864265442,
0.881934404373169,
-0.09067333489656448,
0.8088512420654297,
0.5916285514831543,
0.005275160074234009,
0.17201633751392365,
-0.1927686184644699,
0.8982977867126465,
-0.6022632122039795,
-0.8843803405761719,
-0.7309595346450806,
0.9676476716995239,
-0.05871880427002907,
-0.3139474093914032,
0.6937471628189087,
0.13201101124286652,
0.6657965779304504,
-0.15795016288757324,
0.7245782017707825,
0.06981553882360458,
0.1605396270751953,
-0.8857237100601196,
0.5338589549064636,
-0.578382134437561,
0.635775089263916,
-0.5314269661903381,
-0.6212788224220276,
-0.10030104964971542,
0.6114170551300049,
-0.41336318850517273,
0.034436069428920746,
0.5884589552879333,
0.6877116560935974,
0.11315391212701797,
0.5745784044265747,
-0.006843091454356909,
0.13987162709236145,
0.18199288845062256,
0.6008657813072205,
0.9051507711410522,
-0.4997590184211731,
0.3498402535915375,
-0.33647459745407104,
-0.11821483075618744,
-0.14643558859825134,
-0.8190374970436096,
-0.6426251530647278,
-0.3911501467227936,
-0.655398964881897,
-0.5593675971031189,
0.3608562648296356,
0.685424268245697,
0.20215162634849548,
-0.4347645342350006,
0.6710786819458008,
-0.3002934753894806,
0.3350529074668884,
-0.628838300704956,
-0.187935009598732,
0.5047658681869507,
-0.09714879840612411,
-0.32582059502601624,
0.2781519591808319,
-0.06634320318698883,
-0.14076068997383118,
0.37217000126838684,
0.07195158302783966,
-0.2625548541545868,
0.41013145446777344,
0.3260481059551239,
0.2231317013502121,
-0.5757379531860352,
-0.5261141657829285,
0.0909062847495079,
0.1605779528617859,
-0.08619612455368042,
0.7472472190856934,
-0.8503029346466064,
0.9348320364952087,
0.6346829533576965,
0.7923662066459656,
0.13154439628124237,
0.3410862684249878,
0.5415277481079102,
-0.7322683334350586,
-0.00912616215646267,
0.40280675888061523,
0.44757530093193054,
0.2874152362346649,
-0.6117773056030273,
0.38187241554260254,
0.3616061508655548,
-0.32510673999786377,
-0.8674826622009277,
0.2842802405357361,
-1.0230214595794678,
-0.5228729248046875,
1.0286563634872437,
-0.30730873346328735,
-0.13592353463172913,
-0.36178645491600037,
-0.31975507736206055,
0.49576306343078613,
-0.2045159488916397,
0.9113402366638184,
0.5940829515457153,
-0.016722263768315315,
-0.40217408537864685,
-0.24869690835475922,
0.4115716516971588,
0.6015740036964417,
-0.8915050029754639,
0.28593873977661133,
0.73213130235672,
0.20342658460140228,
0.10215458273887634,
0.7088862657546997,
-0.32238030433654785,
0.8230606913566589,
0.10951536893844604,
0.07130549848079681,
-0.5457773208618164,
-0.2230871170759201,
-0.26873475313186646,
0.08665543049573898,
0.012391374446451664,
-0.09334723651409149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06584v1
|
Evaluating the Efficacy of Large Language Models in Detecting Fake News: A Comparative Analysis
| 2024-06-05T02:55:21 | 2024-06-05T02:55:21 |
Sahas Koka, Anthony Vuong, Anish Kataria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In an era increasingly influenced by artificial intelligence, the detection
of fake news is crucial, especially in contexts like election seasons where
misinformation can have significant societal impacts. This study evaluates the
effectiveness of various LLMs in identifying and filtering fake news content.
Utilizing a comparative analysis approach, we tested four large LLMs -- GPT-4,
Claude 3 Sonnet, Gemini Pro 1.0, and Mistral Large -- and two smaller LLMs --
Gemma 7B and Mistral 7B. By using fake news dataset samples from Kaggle, this
research not only sheds light on the current capabilities and limitations of
LLMs in fake news detection but also discusses the implications for developers
and policymakers in enhancing AI-driven informational integrity.
|
[
-0.1767786294221878,
-1.0981096029281616,
0.8473974466323853,
0.18574655055999756,
-0.2027115672826767,
0.23633278906345367,
-0.1156221553683281,
-0.662564754486084,
0.18738682568073273,
0.45120659470558167,
-0.13431501388549805,
-0.5446996688842773,
-0.8155248761177063,
0.15133823454380035,
-0.9562322497367859,
0.7581896781921387,
0.05834069848060608,
0.3034347593784332,
-0.04338875412940979,
0.12105901539325714,
-0.24068088829517365,
-0.573886513710022,
-0.7436748147010803,
-0.3802497684955597,
0.5579259991645813,
0.07537882030010223,
0.6141836643218994,
0.2970598638057709,
0.3839324712753296,
0.32128340005874634,
-0.0633339136838913,
0.31641051173210144,
-0.620254635810852,
-0.4110918641090393,
-0.13709446787834167,
-0.647915780544281,
-0.20143002271652222,
0.39473670721054077,
0.5699285864830017,
-0.06855759769678116,
0.06576389819383621,
0.1031268909573555,
-0.11532969772815704,
0.506901204586029,
-0.5558616518974304,
0.015714257955551147,
-0.9082157015800476,
-0.1070106253027916,
-0.31553032994270325,
-0.02700117975473404,
-0.3868880271911621,
-0.4222632646560669,
-0.09017764031887054,
-0.3319961130619049,
0.1284845769405365,
0.16776660084724426,
0.9010487198829651,
0.03958326205611229,
-0.6354084610939026,
-0.7804160118103027,
-0.7099990248680115,
0.8027151823043823,
-1.049423098564148,
0.4033290445804596,
0.2910763621330261,
0.2687431573867798,
-0.3253757953643799,
-0.7212716937065125,
-1.0479720830917358,
-0.5449067950248718,
-0.03439643979072571,
0.13655108213424683,
-0.3650364875793457,
-0.18745875358581543,
-0.055807486176490784,
0.44250398874282837,
-0.7062935829162598,
0.390026330947876,
-0.3350715637207031,
-0.5781538486480713,
0.5962806940078735,
-0.04679502919316292,
0.37028318643569946,
-0.29351991415023804,
-0.3063880205154419,
0.05297356843948364,
-0.829531192779541,
-0.3790464699268341,
0.8114749193191528,
0.11092936992645264,
-0.006163947284221649,
0.4427068531513214,
-0.19668090343475342,
0.5721766948699951,
-0.04302766174077988,
-0.5810874104499817,
0.18100063502788544,
-0.2389286309480667,
-0.3454135060310364,
-0.0022022263146936893,
0.8468436002731323,
0.14143848419189453,
0.27717188000679016,
0.055386610329151154,
-0.4316345155239105,
0.45225903391838074,
0.32931363582611084,
-0.5120537281036377,
-0.02016778290271759,
0.0625225231051445,
-0.6883300542831421,
-0.634335458278656,
0.44996631145477295,
-0.42892754077911377,
-0.6193327903747559,
-0.41162917017936707,
0.6976863145828247,
-0.11798571795225143,
-0.26032447814941406,
0.06573773920536041,
-0.17996084690093994,
0.2622102200984955,
0.5151499509811401,
-0.1803033947944641,
0.06940161436796188,
0.8623800277709961,
0.7329402565956116,
-0.2923736274242401,
-0.03545016795396805,
-0.45547154545783997,
-0.21491168439388275,
-0.6421165466308594,
0.6930608153343201,
-0.49623432755470276,
-0.0068938350304961205,
-0.01097160018980503,
0.10414094477891922,
0.031484685838222504,
-0.8312469720840454,
0.5341862440109253,
-0.9158093929290771,
0.25767982006073,
-0.23088419437408447,
-0.6822102665901184,
-0.29373615980148315,
0.5681623220443726,
-0.8737823367118835,
0.7798915505409241,
0.11847572773694992,
-0.46970537304878235,
0.42311373353004456,
-0.2706926465034485,
-0.4644414782524109,
-0.17391034960746765,
-0.1399957239627838,
-0.5052239298820496,
0.1136445477604866,
0.2193860113620758,
0.41648441553115845,
-0.1267513930797577,
0.28995266556739807,
-0.17459867894649506,
-0.485269695520401,
0.3578089773654938,
-0.8465830683708191,
0.5494146943092346,
0.18116752803325653,
-0.5317795276641846,
0.1060125082731247,
-0.4881199300289154,
-0.5470611453056335,
0.18091005086898804,
-0.32063722610473633,
-0.1603931337594986,
-0.06781770288944244,
0.025360532104969025,
0.2327461838722229,
0.16410616040229797,
-0.5875832438468933,
0.04487813636660576,
-0.05483774468302727,
0.28120601177215576,
0.8076727986335754,
-0.09067998081445694,
0.054887864738702774,
-0.3736426532268524,
0.5330381989479065,
0.1721303015947342,
0.16486845910549164,
0.05580615624785423,
-0.501992404460907,
-0.7348167300224304,
-0.28205451369285583,
0.5917018055915833,
0.6667190194129944,
-1.0176247358322144,
0.23411905765533447,
-0.1042528972029686,
-0.3351253569126129,
-0.37637796998023987,
0.27383843064308167,
0.37424978613853455,
0.20943093299865723,
0.13191068172454834,
-0.031321242451667786,
-0.3673045039176941,
-0.9834430813789368,
-0.6565758585929871,
-0.265451043844223,
0.1306256353855133,
0.11574821919202805,
0.7880532741546631,
-0.2465589940547943,
0.7195104360580444,
0.09587565809488297,
-0.30490192770957947,
-0.3079703748226166,
0.02266276441514492,
0.27877917885780334,
-0.02394561655819416,
0.6238569617271423,
-1.041887879371643,
-0.44102224707603455,
-0.13729695975780487,
-0.6675071716308594,
-0.15800200402736664,
-0.20499280095100403,
0.28824156522750854,
0.49518513679504395,
0.4910987615585327,
-0.7591142058372498,
0.7697978019714355,
0.8768417835235596,
-0.45385196805000305,
0.7180489897727966,
0.042659975588321686,
0.600519061088562,
-0.7396808862686157,
-0.18958474695682526,
0.2557237148284912,
-0.7301296591758728,
-0.7098855972290039,
-0.20676849782466888,
0.17284180223941803,
0.2911774814128876,
-0.6281808614730835,
0.7337560057640076,
-0.37101519107818604,
-0.22571079432964325,
-0.614282488822937,
0.3493727445602417,
-0.13119885325431824,
-0.19889749586582184,
-0.1956973373889923,
0.6790541410446167,
0.22944283485412598,
-0.45001617074012756,
0.7006123661994934,
-0.3216922879219055,
-0.831206202507019,
0.4989248812198639,
-0.6089654564857483,
0.0028791504446417093,
-0.15460608899593353,
0.6745501160621643,
-0.7991099953651428,
-0.3576107919216156,
0.46973156929016113,
-0.7152908444404602,
0.1127413958311081,
-0.03091212548315525,
-1.0973798036575317,
-0.4502231180667877,
-0.31131690740585327,
0.0676165297627449,
0.42904412746429443,
-0.8508300185203552,
0.48719659447669983,
0.2535717487335205,
0.18141873180866241,
-0.4854382872581482,
-0.5469460487365723,
0.4575100243091583,
-0.3765643835067749,
-0.5622627139091492,
0.11488264054059982,
0.22957170009613037,
-0.6349479556083679,
0.10703528672456741,
-0.22134579718112946,
0.284976601600647,
0.03908616304397583,
-0.03566158562898636,
0.1877845674753189,
-0.3256465494632721,
-0.022956108674407005,
-0.23342733085155487,
0.06945318728685379,
-0.0840228721499443,
-0.09478273242712021,
0.4512721300125122,
-0.0565916933119297,
-0.4718770682811737,
-0.8237076997756958,
-0.1115557998418808,
0.7005809545516968,
0.07193277031183243,
1.0256624221801758,
0.8407666683197021,
-0.47734391689300537,
-0.2936287522315979,
-0.8862485885620117,
-0.19619083404541016,
-0.4539371430873871,
0.26412728428840637,
0.032143644988536835,
-0.8123454451560974,
0.3113314211368561,
0.0952172726392746,
-0.26163598895072937,
0.5635103583335876,
0.6050127744674683,
0.22392722964286804,
1.0090968608856201,
0.2707943022251129,
-0.7857143878936768,
0.4207582473754883,
-0.0823916643857956,
0.31489163637161255,
-0.29733631014823914,
-0.12055652588605881,
-0.27350637316703796,
-0.3281887471675873,
-0.4049723744392395,
-0.4050089418888092,
0.34159132838249207,
0.0547122061252594,
0.02139377035200596,
-0.00029166816966608167,
-0.25501611828804016,
0.49193525314331055,
0.6708287000656128,
0.15625198185443878,
0.6008667349815369,
0.06696929037570953,
0.40510180592536926,
0.2604582905769348,
-0.6127141118049622,
-0.7834153175354004,
1.1438987255096436,
0.47756677865982056,
0.6748235821723938,
0.18560266494750977,
0.14141349494457245,
0.7598103284835815,
0.7350791692733765,
-0.7027947306632996,
0.48125916719436646,
-0.2645011246204376,
-0.8361443281173706,
-0.14057804644107819,
-0.5228345394134521,
-0.8405989408493042,
0.4080754220485687,
-0.3295980393886566,
-0.5015949606895447,
-0.11329431086778641,
0.06832968443632126,
0.07560297101736069,
0.6361368894577026,
-0.4948669672012329,
0.4691736400127411,
-0.3650344908237457,
0.05483541265130043,
-0.5599942803382874,
-0.15349265933036804,
0.5085931420326233,
-0.3928323984146118,
0.42883145809173584,
-0.15634070336818695,
-0.1077275201678276,
0.5474396347999573,
-0.012058556079864502,
1.0209674835205078,
-0.11526390165090561,
-0.20673847198486328,
0.34708356857299805,
-0.10752374678850174,
0.6825999617576599,
0.11546485126018524,
-0.01632048562169075,
0.46561089158058167,
-0.2004602700471878,
-0.33754369616508484,
-0.34553906321525574,
0.9465267062187195,
-0.6536824107170105,
-0.6271379590034485,
-0.5236265659332275,
-0.5160102844238281,
0.04316559433937073,
0.13452641665935516,
0.2654522955417633,
0.4061661660671234,
-0.24297042191028595,
0.47764021158218384,
0.4629751145839691,
-0.4411151707172394,
0.3045579195022583,
0.7119717597961426,
-0.4029199182987213,
-0.332715779542923,
0.857097327709198,
0.2328231930732727,
0.09019705653190613,
0.10861096531152725,
0.31337299942970276,
-0.29662707448005676,
-0.6767362952232361,
-0.37071627378463745,
0.3285863995552063,
-0.4737550914287567,
-0.17329412698745728,
-0.31907081604003906,
-0.31906065344810486,
-0.5852082967758179,
0.10765315592288971,
-0.29590776562690735,
-0.10865721106529236,
-0.26717913150787354,
0.12189093232154846,
0.14183610677719116,
1.065072774887085,
0.056379955261945724,
0.44742393493652344,
-0.5346234440803528,
0.737951934337616,
0.24630998075008392,
0.0668693408370018,
-0.17601117491722107,
-0.6863768100738525,
-0.1389366239309311,
0.16813696920871735,
-0.2500668466091156,
-0.9257234334945679,
0.34493109583854675,
-0.17376942932605743,
0.8224843144416809,
0.5408041477203369,
-0.10079480707645416,
0.28271594643592834,
-0.14600257575511932,
1.0356605052947998,
-0.08894873410463333,
-0.905306339263916,
0.45917069911956787,
-0.5623087286949158,
0.05987202003598213,
0.10552278906106949,
0.5228664875030518,
-0.39742809534072876,
-0.5311471223831177,
-0.7021252512931824,
-0.4355219006538391,
0.4096858501434326,
0.3637447655200958,
0.19186320900917053,
-0.02896922454237938,
0.4611632227897644,
0.19447679817676544,
0.42915084958076477,
-1.0430842638015747,
-0.20207132399082184,
0.13341307640075684,
-0.32765495777130127,
-0.1927921175956726,
-0.3282748758792877,
0.01807555742561817,
-0.02692134492099285,
0.9121923446655273,
0.08814329653978348,
0.1278819888830185,
0.17461435496807098,
-0.29180681705474854,
0.12663644552230835,
-0.01492997258901596,
0.7394521832466125,
0.829074501991272,
0.3224959373474121,
0.05215492472052574,
0.1347501426935196,
-0.4848266541957855,
-0.07031761854887009,
-0.2949652671813965,
-0.3347522020339966,
0.26450708508491516,
0.8212395310401917,
0.6205461621284485,
-0.24909870326519012,
-0.6239725947380066,
0.7683814167976379,
0.19818931818008423,
-0.3894176781177521,
-0.5753244757652283,
0.090695820748806,
-0.05095580965280533,
0.49322885274887085,
0.42185840010643005,
-0.23855330049991608,
0.05689797177910805,
-0.9577193856239319,
-0.029410429298877716,
0.7550299763679504,
-0.13262927532196045,
-0.31546393036842346,
0.4980802536010742,
0.044003501534461975,
-0.28101056814193726,
0.5994962453842163,
-0.07334674149751663,
-0.8007667064666748,
0.8091848492622375,
0.6208655834197998,
0.321760356426239,
-0.2671150863170624,
0.2736990451812744,
-0.04466303810477257,
0.7648996114730835,
-0.464519739151001,
0.05300617590546608,
0.4104433059692383,
-1.0311871767044067,
-0.39326557517051697,
-0.37813299894332886,
-0.2322763353586197,
0.7364386320114136,
-0.13730402290821075,
0.19681482017040253,
-0.2962827980518341,
-0.25211042165756226,
-0.10575307905673981,
0.11689580976963043,
-0.4540981650352478,
0.24799393117427826,
0.45511454343795776,
0.9340143799781799,
-0.9553159475326538,
0.6400719881057739,
0.5301198959350586,
0.11103487014770508,
-0.4738283157348633,
0.3499010503292084,
0.6205610036849976,
-0.7945465445518494,
0.5112202763557434,
0.2416311353445053,
-0.0056216600351035595,
-0.3077552616596222,
-0.8998831510543823,
-0.724088728427887,
0.9693082571029663,
0.3546086847782135,
-0.5679065585136414,
0.21591854095458984,
0.3085566759109497,
0.545463502407074,
-0.36386507749557495,
-0.0014022400137037039,
0.6692720651626587,
0.8046894669532776,
-0.1589154452085495,
-1.0282657146453857,
-0.22887389361858368,
-0.020619399845600128,
-0.2134639173746109,
0.15045630931854248,
-0.8796730041503906,
0.6682872176170349,
0.2706625163555145,
-0.07595010846853256,
0.07646354287862778,
0.6809623837471008,
0.3585597276687622,
0.7128293514251709,
0.7395120859146118,
0.5498425364494324,
0.6161272525787354,
-0.08951506018638611,
1.0981791019439697,
-0.16037224233150482,
0.25953271985054016,
0.7521795034408569,
-0.0561780221760273,
0.6587303876876831,
0.1883222609758377,
-0.08520640432834625,
0.5606704354286194,
0.6014115810394287,
-0.18368494510650635,
0.24394889175891876,
0.327451229095459,
-0.2787612974643707,
-0.1758638620376587,
0.05155273526906967,
-0.10236190259456635,
0.548032820224762,
0.4770362675189972,
-0.5142173767089844,
0.09435798972845078,
0.1343660205602646,
0.24920199811458588,
0.05330418795347214,
-0.6387232542037964,
0.33430173993110657,
0.17439737915992737,
-0.38309553265571594,
0.22638554871082306,
0.18132205307483673,
0.8258379697799683,
-0.29692038893699646,
0.03745151683688164,
-0.1820836067199707,
0.17011921107769012,
-0.23254278302192688,
-0.6438888907432556,
0.10446690022945404,
0.06622470915317535,
-0.020775549113750458,
0.06448664516210556,
1.074568510055542,
-0.26163098216056824,
-0.5490824580192566,
0.32854634523391724,
0.6216346621513367,
0.16076569259166718,
-0.4222525358200073,
-0.6055921316146851,
0.3414912223815918,
-0.09267394989728928,
-0.5650632381439209,
0.1070098802447319,
0.18126489222049713,
-0.21760322153568268,
0.7823522686958313,
0.83234041929245,
0.4869381785392761,
0.0788729339838028,
0.11266124993562698,
0.6659975051879883,
-0.5612826347351074,
-0.2989806830883026,
-0.9095568060874939,
0.14017410576343536,
-0.32949116826057434,
-0.046006496995687485,
1.1429516077041626,
0.6037643551826477,
0.8664762377738953,
0.06250394880771637,
0.857399046421051,
0.10651565343141556,
0.6690177321434021,
-0.739017128944397,
0.7181152701377869,
-0.4851655066013336,
0.5264208912849426,
-0.2521623373031616,
-1.0870281457901,
-0.22316454350948334,
0.4685823619365692,
-0.4771025776863098,
0.2093704789876938,
0.4640219211578369,
0.9036186337471008,
-0.19279295206069946,
-0.06657616794109344,
0.39094042778015137,
0.4700013995170593,
0.24974983930587769,
0.08731810748577118,
1.2910820245742798,
-0.31668561697006226,
0.41535142064094543,
0.09395483136177063,
-0.11502077430486679,
-0.35202473402023315,
-0.7885381579399109,
-1.1666765213012695,
-0.23113785684108734,
-0.263347327709198,
-0.4831574261188507,
0.23933495581150055,
0.5020081400871277,
0.8706932067871094,
-0.6605860590934753,
0.16145335137844086,
0.19920453429222107,
0.18880580365657806,
0.19511306285858154,
-0.28822678327560425,
0.24058499932289124,
0.045277293771505356,
-0.6867444515228271,
0.6087193489074707,
0.12462721019983292,
-0.043944232165813446,
-0.42059704661369324,
-0.08821063488721848,
0.012601255439221859,
0.5236226916313171,
0.7926991581916809,
-0.00402153842151165,
-1.0463902950286865,
-0.5301571488380432,
-0.2265860140323639,
-0.19420146942138672,
-0.3458084762096405,
0.7646760940551758,
-0.9779264330863953,
-0.07373106479644775,
0.46527835726737976,
0.5234737992286682,
0.42233166098594666,
0.25491979718208313,
0.242547869682312,
-0.3504199981689453,
0.10211345553398132,
0.06320785731077194,
0.2195085734128952,
0.2271585464477539,
-0.4598012864589691,
0.48369717597961426,
0.4836611747741699,
-0.7677426934242249,
-0.6632735133171082,
0.04662138223648071,
-0.6830407977104187,
-0.5688177943229675,
1.541450023651123,
0.21307313442230225,
-0.17183269560337067,
-0.19280262291431427,
-0.1178184226155281,
-0.024251310154795647,
-0.2538025677204132,
0.8589150309562683,
0.8944647908210754,
0.00557925458997488,
-0.1197086051106453,
-0.9798352718353271,
0.34166932106018066,
0.03979635611176491,
-0.8287726640701294,
-0.6048131585121155,
0.6347119808197021,
0.40586164593696594,
-0.07018126547336578,
0.5641884803771973,
-0.22683599591255188,
0.2030763030052185,
-0.20510810613632202,
-0.32857745885849,
0.09303200989961624,
-0.39471909403800964,
-0.2732228636741638,
-0.07417182624340057,
-0.2538048028945923,
0.09695041924715042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02876v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02876v2
|
LCS: A Language Converter Strategy for Zero-Shot Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-06-05T02:52:17 | 2024-06-06T03:22:38 |
Zengkui Sun, Yijin Liu, Fandong Meng, Jinan Xu, Yufeng Chen, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multilingual neural machine translation models generally distinguish
translation directions by the language tag (LT) in front of the source or
target sentences. However, current LT strategies cannot indicate the desired
target language as expected on zero-shot translation, i.e., the off-target
issue. Our analysis reveals that the indication of the target language is
sensitive to the placement of the target LT. For example, when placing the
target LT on the decoder side, the indication would rapidly degrade along with
decoding steps, while placing the target LT on the encoder side would lead to
copying or paraphrasing the source input. To address the above issues, we
propose a simple yet effective strategy named Language Converter Strategy
(LCS). By introducing the target language embedding into the top encoder
layers, LCS mitigates confusion in the encoder and ensures stable language
indication for the decoder. Experimental results on MultiUN, TED, and OPUS-100
datasets demonstrate that LCS could significantly mitigate the off-target
issue, with language accuracy up to 95.28%, 96.21%, and 85.35% meanwhile
outperforming the vanilla LT strategy by 3.07, 3,3, and 7.93 BLEU scores on
zero-shot translation, respectively.
|
[
-0.1872171312570572,
-0.46447446942329407,
0.4021267890930176,
0.19682934880256653,
-0.38903486728668213,
0.18234951794147491,
-0.5179875493049622,
0.2001674771308899,
-0.0896618664264679,
0.3365686535835266,
-0.24687345325946808,
-0.48584312200546265,
-0.6425231695175171,
0.06984911859035492,
-0.3412386178970337,
1.1741472482681274,
-0.16920295357704163,
0.2601992189884186,
0.1740306317806244,
-0.3460869789123535,
-0.4526461362838745,
-0.6142232418060303,
-0.9004387259483337,
-0.13782620429992676,
0.7771376967430115,
0.2990160882472992,
0.5171276926994324,
0.6876394748687744,
0.35389244556427,
0.22206979990005493,
-0.1364373415708542,
-0.06763040274381638,
-0.2842296361923218,
0.23969681560993195,
-0.09670576453208923,
-0.6355574727058411,
-0.16260674595832825,
-0.2955802083015442,
0.7116873860359192,
0.48045337200164795,
-0.023722857236862183,
0.08587473630905151,
0.0543304905295372,
0.6156696677207947,
-0.9454545974731445,
-0.19399070739746094,
-0.8181809186935425,
0.42409321665763855,
-0.3492181897163391,
-0.42988693714141846,
-0.7802765369415283,
0.16645780205726624,
-0.17311212420463562,
-0.24326030910015106,
0.03946271538734436,
-0.18440930545330048,
0.5485808849334717,
0.30468687415122986,
-0.4474791884422302,
-0.11129682511091232,
-1.0212574005126953,
1.1365129947662354,
-0.7117763161659241,
0.5133668184280396,
0.016899241134524345,
0.47694656252861023,
0.02881934866309166,
-0.030617816373705864,
-0.5021339654922485,
-0.11943729966878891,
0.012869263999164104,
0.32352975010871887,
-0.36843496561050415,
-0.11940228939056396,
0.2027377337217331,
-0.09156855940818787,
-0.6888977289199829,
-0.037272825837135315,
-0.11983605474233627,
-0.3615845739841461,
0.3978387117385864,
-0.23249077796936035,
0.43389877676963806,
-0.024289878085255623,
-0.457131028175354,
-0.10913104563951492,
-0.8170552849769592,
-0.06934276968240738,
0.250360369682312,
0.550785481929779,
0.0751916691660881,
0.6472335457801819,
-0.021812589839100838,
0.6876270771026611,
0.3247724175453186,
-0.07417896389961243,
0.19452987611293793,
-0.487674355506897,
-0.04980058968067169,
0.5268133282661438,
0.6736953854560852,
0.5655057430267334,
-0.021687977015972137,
-0.3716946244239807,
-0.4414530098438263,
-0.05644810199737549,
0.26323026418685913,
-0.7664669752120972,
0.3974893391132355,
0.023918261751532555,
-0.2818089723587036,
-0.11399628221988678,
-0.4470152258872986,
-0.5253982543945312,
-0.24753859639167786,
0.025772353634238243,
0.3685154616832733,
-0.38804879784584045,
-0.07043469697237015,
-0.1521894335746765,
-0.03373461216688156,
0.5915098786354065,
0.04600284993648529,
-0.8484713435173035,
0.12994112074375153,
0.17397868633270264,
0.86138516664505,
-0.21345525979995728,
-0.2656776010990143,
-0.6859872341156006,
0.5091111660003662,
-0.5627550482749939,
0.602534294128418,
-0.09997579455375671,
-0.09577754884958267,
0.222118079662323,
-0.12169414013624191,
-0.35649701952934265,
-0.29280850291252136,
0.6565511226654053,
-0.5042791366577148,
0.1531846821308136,
-0.22426989674568176,
-0.34727492928504944,
-0.06893587112426758,
0.5412547588348389,
-0.5112321376800537,
0.7814967632293701,
0.04289748892188072,
-0.5262496471405029,
0.14632129669189453,
-0.3351312577724457,
-0.5038497447967529,
0.026134120300412178,
-0.23187382519245148,
-0.3237210512161255,
0.23052535951137543,
0.2390100359916687,
0.21220023930072784,
-0.05586790293455124,
0.1404118537902832,
0.08371564000844955,
-0.45362913608551025,
0.3648930788040161,
-0.7236388921737671,
0.5478842258453369,
0.35423731803894043,
-0.3881703019142151,
0.04048044607043266,
-0.3492245674133301,
0.1361236870288849,
0.2550438642501831,
-0.5080093741416931,
-0.3212471008300781,
0.03921448439359665,
0.13958071172237396,
0.5736171007156372,
0.13262233138084412,
-0.6272399425506592,
0.15757550299167633,
-0.39359256625175476,
0.4122302234172821,
0.21281735599040985,
-0.22599917650222778,
0.9596543908119202,
-0.16116125881671906,
0.6507828235626221,
0.0914631187915802,
0.016810234636068344,
-0.14715231955051422,
-0.4562286138534546,
-1.0017154216766357,
0.1495393067598343,
0.4237307906150818,
0.9119681119918823,
-1.0727043151855469,
0.5516443252563477,
-0.1888476014137268,
-0.37566325068473816,
-0.7915037274360657,
0.14267940819263458,
0.7945483922958374,
0.3498784601688385,
0.6542837619781494,
-0.13828960061073303,
-0.37271344661712646,
-0.7803510427474976,
-0.4550356864929199,
0.06803575903177261,
0.03649720177054405,
-0.09035513550043106,
0.2073337882757187,
0.1692984700202942,
0.5640401244163513,
-0.059836260974407196,
-0.4677640199661255,
-0.8375022411346436,
-0.15298455953598022,
0.08088454604148865,
0.4640744626522064,
0.5490469932556152,
-0.6524084210395813,
-0.7224522829055786,
0.33951902389526367,
-0.5324816107749939,
-0.012719548307359219,
-0.5651851892471313,
-0.08282351493835449,
0.6483369469642639,
0.7036834955215454,
-0.5997912883758545,
0.5654498934745789,
0.6097251772880554,
0.06836706399917603,
0.053805503994226456,
-0.38144057989120483,
0.021484799683094025,
-0.9568930864334106,
0.07870054990053177,
-0.1296660453081131,
-0.10479078441858292,
-0.9391278028488159,
0.0844201147556305,
0.21250280737876892,
-0.0826655924320221,
-0.8090388774871826,
0.31740128993988037,
-0.28933268785476685,
-0.05495724827051163,
-0.12970982491970062,
0.3008727431297302,
0.09315318614244461,
0.5717831254005432,
-0.030517365783452988,
0.5012379884719849,
0.3170951306819916,
-0.33648252487182617,
0.12196658551692963,
0.015010058879852295,
0.012788789346814156,
0.6757438778877258,
-0.5185241103172302,
0.18311911821365356,
-0.1379505693912506,
0.31106889247894287,
-0.900410532951355,
0.4740099310874939,
0.5794333815574646,
-0.60832679271698,
0.6378644108772278,
-0.3298831284046173,
-0.27284812927246094,
-0.07818933576345444,
-0.19456857442855835,
0.5090110301971436,
0.3409958481788635,
-0.05078910291194916,
0.5519436001777649,
-0.09020170569419861,
0.06572440266609192,
-0.7099118828773499,
-1.197204828262329,
0.30856144428253174,
-0.16212902963161469,
-0.16947245597839355,
0.5039897561073303,
-0.18308795988559723,
0.28088340163230896,
-0.053296759724617004,
-0.15005122125148773,
-0.01232913788408041,
-0.0664694607257843,
-0.28590527176856995,
0.10900451242923737,
-0.36662089824676514,
-0.1103181540966034,
0.11272893846035004,
-0.38788720965385437,
-0.17017023265361786,
-0.42001476883888245,
0.6503878235816956,
0.09732571244239807,
-0.5665687322616577,
-0.41061702370643616,
0.3457504212856293,
0.6820619702339172,
-0.39283671975135803,
0.9045017957687378,
0.7140024304389954,
-0.3284420073032379,
-0.2597488760948181,
-0.21749666333198547,
0.03379468619823456,
-0.38378921151161194,
0.47663986682891846,
-0.467864453792572,
-0.20929238200187683,
0.3863006830215454,
0.093610480427742,
-0.12394213676452637,
0.2779581844806671,
0.4740563631057739,
-0.027549684047698975,
1.3511090278625488,
0.4517665505409241,
-0.1784086972475052,
0.3939872682094574,
-0.4143148362636566,
0.7092858552932739,
-0.8715617060661316,
-0.08503741770982742,
-0.6190327405929565,
-0.5542188286781311,
-0.46538034081459045,
-0.44417837262153625,
0.07325592637062073,
0.4290196895599365,
-0.15350192785263062,
0.7571183443069458,
-0.5060474872589111,
0.5225260853767395,
0.3009832799434662,
-0.14987777173519135,
0.15932807326316833,
0.1314193606376648,
-0.4014164209365845,
-0.3300707936286926,
-0.9527148008346558,
-0.2663043439388275,
0.9063583016395569,
0.26771068572998047,
0.2981972396373749,
0.10592256486415863,
0.8414610624313354,
-0.018786082044243813,
0.09423969686031342,
-1.1052019596099854,
0.49562564492225647,
-0.3980161249637604,
-0.5811135768890381,
-0.298604279756546,
-0.3089904189109802,
-0.6654333472251892,
0.26958605647087097,
-0.07739794999361038,
-0.20892205834388733,
0.06885167211294174,
-0.04228529334068298,
-0.262508362531662,
0.4760010540485382,
-0.5172626376152039,
1.0454572439193726,
-0.5677341222763062,
-0.24292278289794922,
0.12147887796163559,
-0.6165454387664795,
-0.22063715755939484,
-0.21891550719738007,
0.3077103793621063,
0.16250699758529663,
-0.11525788903236389,
0.305596262216568,
-0.0673770010471344,
0.644696831703186,
-0.288577675819397,
-0.1829843670129776,
0.20296090841293335,
0.34336596727371216,
0.35069146752357483,
-0.4046724736690521,
-0.19017751514911652,
0.25239861011505127,
-0.23935338854789734,
-0.4519425630569458,
-0.8270679116249084,
0.6077960133552551,
-0.6108275651931763,
-0.3647974729537964,
-0.5057616233825684,
-0.6019436717033386,
0.07194295525550842,
0.43639156222343445,
0.5494670271873474,
0.13556569814682007,
-0.10514726489782333,
0.2458726018667221,
0.44371822476387024,
-0.3338882327079773,
0.6729145646095276,
0.6506789326667786,
-0.12290281802415848,
-0.4445479214191437,
1.118399977684021,
0.22103600203990936,
0.6352919936180115,
0.6070427894592285,
0.12944833934307098,
-0.2982182204723358,
-0.909119725227356,
-1.0783823728561401,
0.10164454579353333,
-0.7879352569580078,
-0.3052063584327698,
-0.19419555366039276,
-0.4122936427593231,
-0.3034357726573944,
-0.49461910128593445,
-0.6878575682640076,
-0.331953763961792,
0.028508739545941353,
0.1932569146156311,
-0.19832003116607666,
0.48204272985458374,
0.15145134925842285,
0.4179695248603821,
-0.9189759492874146,
-0.08088968694210052,
-0.10446178168058395,
0.002060862025246024,
-0.22452037036418915,
-0.7764108180999756,
-0.3764357268810272,
0.26085150241851807,
-0.2829821705818176,
-1.0199763774871826,
0.5701733827590942,
0.22581709921360016,
0.7083003520965576,
0.4143410325050354,
0.062454674392938614,
0.4893452227115631,
-0.6440452337265015,
0.5353476405143738,
0.32650959491729736,
-1.1679930686950684,
0.5282909870147705,
-0.18984124064445496,
0.5180092453956604,
0.5232489109039307,
0.34203892946243286,
-0.8827834725379944,
-0.42733490467071533,
-0.13212163746356964,
-0.7414959669113159,
0.787646472454071,
0.3574848771095276,
0.24035681784152985,
-0.15025809407234192,
0.19328628480434418,
-0.2958376705646515,
0.12475400418043137,
-0.868457555770874,
-0.3908141851425171,
-0.2081524282693863,
-0.2432190626859665,
-0.05158231779932976,
0.13278166949748993,
0.055037498474121094,
-0.06688300520181656,
0.47732317447662354,
-0.340717613697052,
0.23363465070724487,
0.1484053134918213,
-0.3285524845123291,
-0.35340800881385803,
0.5496020913124084,
0.7012857794761658,
0.2590409815311432,
-0.14646205306053162,
0.1443079560995102,
0.4077477753162384,
-0.17222684621810913,
0.13105998933315277,
-0.166440948843956,
-0.7515369057655334,
0.16414815187454224,
0.3064790964126587,
0.6823121905326843,
0.3276769816875458,
-0.2505759298801422,
0.7406723499298096,
0.19926871359348297,
-0.1800672560930252,
-0.034039780497550964,
-0.3450937867164612,
0.15953487157821655,
0.012897725217044353,
0.23671166598796844,
0.4486910402774811,
-0.04002651199698448,
-0.43514496088027954,
-0.051364973187446594,
0.40629497170448303,
-0.770441472530365,
-0.316415399312973,
0.39971816539764404,
0.16239498555660248,
-0.4246101975440979,
0.41489773988723755,
-0.39678701758384705,
-0.8650672435760498,
0.5636085867881775,
0.9873569011688232,
0.9582772850990295,
-0.7236732840538025,
0.33364608883857727,
0.4642433524131775,
0.5527297258377075,
0.08932053297758102,
0.07419627159833908,
-0.03886226937174797,
-0.8887706995010376,
-0.5121782422065735,
-0.6524737477302551,
-0.15333276987075806,
-0.10263087600469589,
-0.7962529063224792,
0.3617975413799286,
-0.2765369117259979,
0.013291394338011742,
-0.16771821677684784,
-0.4090372622013092,
-0.3709462583065033,
0.0026275895070284605,
0.608711838722229,
0.7323958873748779,
-0.7980698943138123,
1.212908148765564,
0.6060724258422852,
-0.6514598727226257,
-0.4078655242919922,
-0.007986858487129211,
-0.14906631410121918,
-0.7839477062225342,
0.7619826793670654,
0.1849846988916397,
-0.14041633903980255,
0.044989462941884995,
-0.2558514177799225,
-0.8902116417884827,
0.9184430241584778,
0.4171765148639679,
-0.702855110168457,
-0.10605410486459732,
0.6432373523712158,
0.6156867146492004,
-0.48125043511390686,
0.19277149438858032,
0.5862736105918884,
0.45367637276649475,
0.29756835103034973,
-0.8105326294898987,
0.1521369218826294,
-0.07252100110054016,
0.11719854921102524,
0.39473843574523926,
-0.4496269226074219,
0.6794987320899963,
-0.22771528363227844,
-0.2844679057598114,
0.10859064012765884,
0.10723930597305298,
0.12676960229873657,
0.21549032628536224,
0.5342113971710205,
0.6466370820999146,
0.14836347103118896,
0.01161827053874731,
0.8223106265068054,
-0.34965547919273376,
0.25277039408683777,
0.8886516094207764,
-0.42817071080207825,
1.1665210723876953,
0.7102507948875427,
0.08012321591377258,
0.35017067193984985,
0.10815335810184479,
0.025520797818899155,
0.868590772151947,
0.33729279041290283,
-0.2337726503610611,
-0.3084690272808075,
-0.21751244366168976,
-0.322146475315094,
0.5817534923553467,
0.5991249084472656,
-0.46698081493377686,
-0.4559937119483948,
0.1619112342596054,
0.3559945821762085,
0.046853918582201004,
-0.1401038020849228,
0.6648578643798828,
-0.04283585771918297,
-0.7510582208633423,
0.8280995488166809,
0.14862748980522156,
0.5263441801071167,
-0.6962541937828064,
-0.08945546299219131,
-0.31045442819595337,
0.5477064251899719,
-0.0994311198592186,
-0.6284024715423584,
0.5966558456420898,
-0.16724102199077606,
-0.04205850511789322,
-0.5542440414428711,
0.6308579444885254,
-0.8826093077659607,
-0.4501506984233856,
0.7046045660972595,
0.5458585619926453,
0.13549795746803284,
-0.20395557582378387,
-0.9238391518592834,
0.1433141827583313,
0.26280125975608826,
-0.07552618533372879,
0.4390268623828888,
0.45244863629341125,
-0.12718629837036133,
0.3480139970779419,
0.6180676221847534,
0.20489200949668884,
0.08635859936475754,
0.14020617306232452,
0.6909972429275513,
-0.6181097030639648,
-0.16921085119247437,
-0.7637234330177307,
0.4319700300693512,
0.15369758009910583,
-0.27883440256118774,
0.9945725202560425,
0.44027477502822876,
1.0442931652069092,
-0.0672612190246582,
0.7286613583564758,
0.09039133042097092,
0.12836934626102448,
-0.39797794818878174,
0.971203088760376,
-0.5857269167900085,
0.20057421922683716,
0.09629546850919724,
-1.1249078512191772,
-0.6736931204795837,
0.519183874130249,
-0.2286035269498825,
-0.12552645802497864,
0.9335381984710693,
0.7484644651412964,
0.27794915437698364,
-0.48869138956069946,
0.6479525566101074,
0.04182346165180206,
0.20821335911750793,
0.782002329826355,
0.763355553150177,
-0.7023953199386597,
1.1668156385421753,
-0.43498694896698,
-0.061553649604320526,
-0.12657061219215393,
-1.007112979888916,
-0.7883908748626709,
-0.1240718737244606,
-0.37166500091552734,
-0.19299660623073578,
0.09430135786533356,
0.5534990429878235,
0.5527535676956177,
-1.1389890909194946,
-0.3253474831581116,
-0.18300998210906982,
0.08895248174667358,
-0.30080386996269226,
-0.12179957330226898,
0.17440226674079895,
-0.5551555156707764,
-0.6948692202568054,
0.6392664313316345,
0.48516857624053955,
-0.06909843534231186,
-0.27864548563957214,
-0.28723055124282837,
-0.34907180070877075,
0.019074704498052597,
0.5586999654769897,
0.13804711401462555,
-0.9194457530975342,
-0.06581425666809082,
0.44184446334838867,
-0.4116852581501007,
0.02587882988154888,
0.7930281758308411,
-0.493622362613678,
0.6160142421722412,
0.48878103494644165,
0.7518684267997742,
0.3198871612548828,
-0.37197908759117126,
0.6111218929290771,
-0.8935297727584839,
0.15518341958522797,
0.2271658033132553,
0.37285152077674866,
0.4728652238845825,
-0.3735259771347046,
0.1065097451210022,
0.1678740382194519,
-0.4672797620296478,
-0.5579976439476013,
0.05596039071679115,
-1.0009257793426514,
-0.2515279948711395,
1.1542712450027466,
-0.3573853373527527,
-0.3419678211212158,
-0.1684131622314453,
-0.29290640354156494,
0.5659538507461548,
-0.22942917048931122,
0.330212265253067,
0.6083740592002869,
0.3066890835762024,
-0.09121762216091156,
-0.6511299014091492,
0.365837037563324,
0.8142157196998596,
-0.2774111330509186,
-0.1134490966796875,
0.006736149080097675,
0.01989409327507019,
0.6299145221710205,
0.27138593792915344,
-0.18203772604465485,
0.19751353561878204,
-0.07278616726398468,
0.370799720287323,
0.18705236911773682,
-0.36754751205444336,
-0.7335692644119263,
-0.14804328978061676,
-0.04295790195465088,
-0.5218029022216797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02864v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02864v1
|
NUMCoT: Numerals and Units of Measurement in Chain-of-Thought Reasoning using Large Language Models
| 2024-06-05T02:26:14 | 2024-06-05T02:26:14 |
Ancheng Xu, Minghuan Tan, Lei Wang, Min Yang, Ruifeng Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Numeral systems and units of measurement are two conjoined topics in
activities of human beings and have mutual effects with the languages
expressing them. Currently, the evaluation of Large Language Models (LLMs)
often involves mathematical reasoning, yet little attention is given to how
minor changes in numbers or units can drastically alter the complexity of
problems and the performance of LLMs. In this paper, we scrutinize existing
LLMs on processing of numerals and units of measurement by constructing
datasets with perturbations. We first anatomize the reasoning of math word
problems to different sub-procedures like numeral conversions from language to
numbers and measurement conversions based on units. Then we further annotate
math word problems from ancient Chinese arithmetic works which are challenging
in numerals and units of measurement. Experiments on perturbed datasets
demonstrate that LLMs still encounter difficulties in handling numeral and
measurement conversions.
|
[
-0.5414702296257019,
-0.9341338276863098,
0.7664827704429626,
0.17428623139858246,
-0.5497145056724548,
0.024301661178469658,
-0.32343006134033203,
-0.22010928392410278,
0.2989598512649536,
0.8832839131355286,
-0.36305636167526245,
-0.2418866902589798,
-0.3494281470775604,
0.08974169939756393,
-0.13757099211215973,
0.6084084510803223,
-0.23006217181682587,
0.20079286396503448,
-0.12047937512397766,
-0.2802390456199646,
-0.48197516798973083,
-1.0321184396743774,
-0.2694966793060303,
-0.6106597781181335,
0.4833191931247711,
0.45133695006370544,
1.1125937700271606,
0.2588253617286682,
0.8655661940574646,
0.32502037286758423,
0.01799297146499157,
0.19001080095767975,
-0.28911489248275757,
0.25302112102508545,
0.0019512311555445194,
-0.42313769459724426,
-0.6175292134284973,
-0.17087778449058533,
0.9142271280288696,
1.1282588243484497,
0.1162252128124237,
0.22384321689605713,
-0.12046532332897186,
0.7310632467269897,
-0.5711005926132202,
0.06317511200904846,
-0.6468901038169861,
-0.10435279458761215,
-0.08653739839792252,
-0.14739221334457397,
-0.4098457098007202,
-0.3088303804397583,
-0.04575003683567047,
-0.42309772968292236,
-0.31710919737815857,
-0.12261038273572922,
0.34990060329437256,
0.34713950753211975,
-0.39564308524131775,
-0.44007939100265503,
-0.7794769406318665,
0.9532219171524048,
-0.9639979004859924,
0.2509264349937439,
0.5954844355583191,
0.07919488847255707,
-0.32791656255722046,
-0.441621869802475,
-0.4546481668949127,
-0.3503023386001587,
0.09678143262863159,
-0.3257998824119568,
-0.01799553446471691,
-0.1710953265428543,
0.6994847059249878,
0.4004916548728943,
-0.3668482005596161,
0.3479624390602112,
-0.125817209482193,
-0.06777853518724442,
1.0024737119674683,
0.5094565153121948,
0.2943599224090576,
-0.10731875151395798,
-0.21373502910137177,
-0.21754810214042664,
-0.9625878930091858,
-0.5152360200881958,
0.14774088561534882,
-0.008877567946910858,
0.01866784133017063,
0.6137691736221313,
-0.23372943699359894,
0.6360934972763062,
-0.2624606490135193,
-0.019302701577544212,
0.16296641528606415,
-0.044693153351545334,
-0.6104559898376465,
0.12025796622037888,
0.7636616826057434,
-0.004340290557593107,
0.47317492961883545,
-0.0053773601539433,
-0.2970445454120636,
0.2784096896648407,
-0.17121709883213043,
-0.7558183670043945,
-0.19551454484462738,
-0.0827423483133316,
0.12339392304420471,
-0.3529350161552429,
-0.015405555255711079,
-0.1868024617433548,
-0.3378210961818695,
-0.4851934611797333,
0.5298333764076233,
-0.3683798015117645,
-0.2648722231388092,
0.2716083824634552,
0.33768466114997864,
-0.028790859505534172,
0.4091763496398926,
-0.7535740733146667,
0.18484453856945038,
0.9153462648391724,
0.6137735843658447,
0.2596819996833801,
-0.1254977136850357,
-0.11459971964359283,
-0.21312758326530457,
-0.7757419347763062,
0.5412361025810242,
-0.4927580952644348,
-0.3733416497707367,
-0.317470908164978,
-0.2018769085407257,
0.003579558338969946,
-0.41515684127807617,
0.18446776270866394,
-0.7313783764839172,
-0.3680131137371063,
-0.47446826100349426,
-0.6747695803642273,
-0.18184402585029602,
0.4576117694377899,
-0.8115320801734924,
0.6317132711410522,
-0.028099756687879562,
-0.6482607126235962,
0.019466226920485497,
-0.6150953769683838,
-0.5268500447273254,
0.276650071144104,
-0.23334214091300964,
-0.11722742021083832,
0.5757037401199341,
0.15369343757629395,
0.3857317268848419,
-0.5018938779830933,
0.32549938559532166,
-0.5112027525901794,
-0.4244646430015564,
0.9227977395057678,
-0.6837479472160339,
0.9701059460639954,
0.2027299553155899,
-0.16351179778575897,
-0.11250905692577362,
-0.783136785030365,
0.32870346307754517,
0.09378363192081451,
0.05326567962765694,
-0.539306104183197,
0.05904993787407875,
-0.5229672193527222,
0.09822521358728409,
0.12268287688493729,
-0.19030849635601044,
0.3826794922351837,
-0.344655841588974,
0.6535825729370117,
0.6374497413635254,
0.1975647658109665,
0.3627183139324188,
0.0010235931258648634,
0.3671208322048187,
-0.2231048196554184,
-0.03451375663280487,
-0.1514095515012741,
-0.39757096767425537,
-0.8346152305603027,
0.260773241519928,
0.5213457345962524,
0.2566143274307251,
-1.0904148817062378,
0.17773479223251343,
-0.2892106771469116,
-0.5939794182777405,
-0.11026286333799362,
-0.11606324464082718,
0.0575721450150013,
-0.021311497315764427,
0.049851395189762115,
-0.2542804479598999,
-0.24847395718097687,
-0.4536364674568176,
-0.07806868106126785,
-0.22850292921066284,
-0.24649009108543396,
-0.20707976818084717,
0.5689668655395508,
-0.09729935228824615,
0.4745306968688965,
-0.4956217408180237,
0.11397905647754669,
0.10397057235240936,
0.35139697790145874,
0.32767021656036377,
0.38444438576698303,
0.26154327392578125,
-0.4010401666164398,
-0.120073102414608,
0.1006619781255722,
-0.9051347970962524,
-0.34994441270828247,
-0.16951686143875122,
-0.015483181923627853,
0.11455834656953812,
0.7085202932357788,
-0.20053935050964355,
0.6919144988059998,
0.6848018765449524,
-0.26770415902137756,
0.7788046002388,
-0.2542318105697632,
-0.050906162708997726,
-0.5575345158576965,
-0.19433441758155823,
-0.16629807651042938,
0.05238804593682289,
-0.710550844669342,
0.2748984396457672,
0.15047477185726166,
0.22738225758075714,
-0.40564608573913574,
0.2685389816761017,
-0.5560751557350159,
-0.40776416659355164,
-0.3013683259487152,
0.14219380915164948,
-0.08024604618549347,
0.23586349189281464,
-0.04173853620886803,
0.448233038187027,
0.35546064376831055,
-0.8907293677330017,
0.5345749855041504,
-0.07701986283063889,
-0.6376907825469971,
0.581089437007904,
-0.626194953918457,
0.41873303055763245,
0.11760758608579636,
0.16565340757369995,
-1.0664751529693604,
0.03940047696232796,
0.016932018101215363,
-0.43512603640556335,
-0.1432369202375412,
0.06788986176252365,
-0.9993252158164978,
-0.26199889183044434,
-0.1123422235250473,
0.7651905417442322,
0.147951140999794,
-0.3191189765930176,
0.18596012890338898,
0.2421242594718933,
0.12166784703731537,
-0.19735842943191528,
-0.8072888255119324,
0.09873493015766144,
-0.22646774351596832,
-0.6864364147186279,
-0.034821826964616776,
-0.12198832631111145,
-0.764934241771698,
-0.28955307602882385,
-0.09879251569509506,
-0.010430499911308289,
0.2562199831008911,
0.2567172646522522,
0.43856093287467957,
-0.3882485032081604,
0.6187916994094849,
-0.06822008639574051,
-0.22785791754722595,
0.5889002680778503,
-0.03369157388806343,
0.80491042137146,
-0.2975998818874359,
-0.643082320690155,
-0.19212093949317932,
-0.08600553870201111,
0.784612774848938,
-0.25391262769699097,
0.4100487530231476,
0.43672680854797363,
-0.5044059753417969,
0.13880334794521332,
-0.6248258948326111,
-0.22473706305027008,
-0.4536086320877075,
0.35380274057388306,
-0.7594020962715149,
-0.7541941404342651,
0.43014755845069885,
-0.15114004909992218,
-0.10949846357107162,
0.6067081093788147,
0.7541881799697876,
0.064903624355793,
1.1239863634109497,
0.005146399140357971,
-0.03351614996790886,
0.26431846618652344,
-0.4712235629558563,
0.32690495252609253,
-1.098082423210144,
0.13776718080043793,
-0.41580912470817566,
-0.529865562915802,
-0.7116621732711792,
-0.7514708042144775,
0.3449949026107788,
0.14924514293670654,
-0.7916207909584045,
0.2184954136610031,
-0.1946570873260498,
0.4952843487262726,
-0.023081427440047264,
0.026244353502988815,
0.4888148605823517,
0.17559804022312164,
-0.31907162070274353,
-0.25560566782951355,
-0.6133514642715454,
-0.6493529677391052,
0.9388461112976074,
0.31433558464050293,
0.9988897442817688,
0.03084278292953968,
0.36146804690361023,
-0.06893124431371689,
0.5537866950035095,
-0.9985468983650208,
0.6715698838233948,
-0.1889759749174118,
-0.5253627300262451,
-0.5799277424812317,
-0.6401490569114685,
-0.8381755948066711,
0.5325949192047119,
0.01409707497805357,
-0.8364301323890686,
0.26084649562835693,
-0.40423715114593506,
-0.24242275953292847,
0.6814892292022705,
-0.33266618847846985,
0.46415549516677856,
-0.6440062522888184,
-0.14266186952590942,
-0.2556378245353699,
-0.31322091817855835,
0.39470550417900085,
-0.11204793304204941,
0.44059374928474426,
-0.2781906723976135,
0.09311559051275253,
0.7417920231819153,
-0.820699155330658,
0.7662999033927917,
0.2755889594554901,
-0.3772168755531311,
0.5307567119598389,
0.5992448925971985,
0.3084820806980133,
0.18229958415031433,
-0.31483644247055054,
0.3432440757751465,
0.05773841589689255,
-0.26869282126426697,
-0.6440582275390625,
0.8058169484138489,
-0.7953286170959473,
-0.471698135137558,
-0.5348048806190491,
-0.7285500764846802,
-0.28855761885643005,
0.04866867884993553,
0.24238887429237366,
0.4668700397014618,
-0.057021308690309525,
0.26659098267555237,
0.5716294646263123,
-0.1019568219780922,
0.4900350570678711,
0.44488707184791565,
-0.5154012441635132,
-0.5518968105316162,
0.5076038837432861,
0.586904764175415,
0.6626368761062622,
0.3301573395729065,
0.27373409271240234,
-0.15017080307006836,
-0.13072118163108826,
-0.34457099437713623,
0.3288860023021698,
-0.7376846075057983,
-0.24675635993480682,
-0.2116643488407135,
-0.2902745008468628,
-0.3054446876049042,
-0.06864407658576965,
-0.2062871903181076,
-0.5441616177558899,
-0.2823988199234009,
0.03916097432374954,
0.31185898184776306,
0.7044734954833984,
-0.2329763025045395,
0.3166543245315552,
-0.6852271556854248,
0.17060460150241852,
0.4725310504436493,
0.26716482639312744,
0.45479562878608704,
-0.7189673185348511,
-0.20522065460681915,
0.31202006340026855,
-0.16317978501319885,
-0.9541241526603699,
0.23223508894443512,
-0.42283201217651367,
0.039913736283779144,
0.5905196666717529,
0.14369875192642212,
0.8960545659065247,
-0.2417467087507248,
0.40892764925956726,
0.34668058156967163,
-1.233301043510437,
0.11859874427318573,
0.18640048801898956,
0.47648170590400696,
0.21869328618049622,
0.22264854609966278,
-0.8453919887542725,
0.037337444722652435,
-0.6328915357589722,
-0.6578328609466553,
0.20675037801265717,
0.23457227647304535,
0.04056477174162865,
-0.0974295511841774,
0.32981082797050476,
-0.2261197715997696,
0.060542527586221695,
-0.3189280331134796,
-0.10454454272985458,
0.3251207172870636,
0.4409327208995819,
-0.19637323915958405,
-0.22743824124336243,
0.35445812344551086,
-0.49139949679374695,
0.4249693751335144,
0.055458974093198776,
-0.11982912570238113,
0.2030901163816452,
-0.2944883406162262,
-0.312968373298645,
0.4350796341896057,
0.6205934286117554,
1.0975379943847656,
0.05032198131084442,
0.3961789309978485,
0.553429126739502,
-0.4335272014141083,
0.20719602704048157,
-0.5213545560836792,
0.02237715944647789,
0.07806454598903656,
0.46503347158432007,
0.8720005750656128,
0.40631362795829773,
-0.3413507640361786,
-0.13468532264232635,
0.19003090262413025,
-0.2839338481426239,
-0.5159962773323059,
-0.17194117605686188,
0.12840807437896729,
0.01963857188820839,
0.28213876485824585,
-0.22059015929698944,
-0.11104696244001389,
-0.699079692363739,
-0.10278132557868958,
0.27394068241119385,
-0.3719079792499542,
-0.4726518392562866,
0.2473829686641693,
-0.20892129838466644,
-0.4088513255119324,
0.8819889426231384,
-0.2759149968624115,
-0.7344598770141602,
0.9086297154426575,
0.5383612513542175,
0.6175468564033508,
-0.5218901038169861,
0.2747094929218292,
0.303714394569397,
0.6146408915519714,
-0.13892130553722382,
0.1917153149843216,
0.11728953570127487,
-0.9601271152496338,
-0.7338113784790039,
-0.38985344767570496,
-0.5803040862083435,
0.3355805575847626,
-0.689505934715271,
0.2335648238658905,
-0.6777099370956421,
-0.43943077325820923,
0.22717218101024628,
0.354655385017395,
-0.7295063734054565,
0.33081772923469543,
0.4101031422615051,
0.5783318281173706,
-0.9011913537979126,
0.8293214440345764,
0.7612655162811279,
-0.2295752912759781,
-0.9494858384132385,
-0.4138047695159912,
-0.24524396657943726,
-0.8472024202346802,
0.5097472071647644,
-0.021604444831609726,
-0.03841226547956467,
-0.04417709633708,
-0.5837011933326721,
-0.916404664516449,
0.8862320780754089,
0.22774474322795868,
-0.9069462418556213,
0.2997443377971649,
0.6433624029159546,
0.7386115193367004,
-0.2473905235528946,
0.21313250064849854,
0.889857828617096,
0.7366245985031128,
0.30426040291786194,
-0.985788106918335,
0.09823790937662125,
0.19182336330413818,
0.1486663967370987,
0.550433874130249,
-0.5255669951438904,
1.3158059120178223,
-0.2468358725309372,
-0.12214815616607666,
0.06132246181368828,
0.39787861704826355,
0.46814966201782227,
0.3716726303100586,
0.5400980710983276,
0.8181247711181641,
0.748898983001709,
-0.0929175317287445,
0.8397849798202515,
0.1949986070394516,
0.4753001034259796,
1.0584675073623657,
-0.5234538316726685,
0.8593009114265442,
0.3996656835079193,
-0.6851975917816162,
0.513189971446991,
0.46814775466918945,
-0.03994808718562126,
-0.14335092902183533,
0.8277289867401123,
-0.19179947674274445,
-0.531144917011261,
0.22177208960056305,
-0.4725959300994873,
0.4040716886520386,
0.8560219407081604,
-0.14625398814678192,
-0.05268530175089836,
0.0010744554456323385,
0.2670000493526459,
-0.054532136768102646,
-0.5038069486618042,
0.632734477519989,
0.38890767097473145,
-0.4066997766494751,
0.8688809871673584,
0.04446885362267494,
0.1979241818189621,
-0.16880609095096588,
0.10400208830833435,
-0.3042401075363159,
0.17491529881954193,
-0.22480285167694092,
-0.7309271097183228,
0.18543602526187897,
-0.1029808297753334,
0.1758451610803604,
0.18330374360084534,
0.6236688494682312,
-0.14922790229320526,
-1.0234477519989014,
0.025867264717817307,
0.5685530304908752,
0.5315375328063965,
-0.5850221514701843,
-0.3258029520511627,
0.4091242253780365,
-0.08160565793514252,
-0.11107982695102692,
0.21614685654640198,
0.9791132807731628,
-0.4337659478187561,
0.41831302642822266,
0.6050400137901306,
0.07790274173021317,
0.06375842541456223,
0.31782129406929016,
0.7095616459846497,
-0.9628176689147949,
-0.3492034673690796,
-1.1906921863555908,
-0.05008820444345474,
0.15948770940303802,
-0.1014108657836914,
0.589180588722229,
0.1954440176486969,
0.6644429564476013,
0.15536381304264069,
0.49295127391815186,
0.19640472531318665,
-0.0033598016016185284,
-0.4701687693595886,
0.5843762755393982,
-0.20416906476020813,
0.6434515118598938,
-0.2777697741985321,
-1.0001271963119507,
-0.5549718737602234,
0.6850536465644836,
-0.8448326587677002,
-0.18621104955673218,
0.9399622082710266,
0.2305513173341751,
0.2936653792858124,
0.17575307190418243,
0.6101120114326477,
0.3747101426124573,
0.23673821985721588,
0.6768600940704346,
0.9680784940719604,
-0.6284670829772949,
0.22030605375766754,
-0.2663607895374298,
-0.11579210311174393,
-0.31255072355270386,
-0.7408983707427979,
-0.8245576620101929,
-0.417631059885025,
-0.43951231241226196,
-0.25453463196754456,
-0.37173306941986084,
0.6819033026695251,
0.3183920681476593,
-0.7206102013587952,
-0.6555368304252625,
0.08403736352920532,
0.5338499546051025,
-0.10263336449861526,
-0.20485717058181763,
0.5044432282447815,
-0.1783764660358429,
-0.3443702459335327,
-0.013370788656175137,
0.4323377013206482,
0.045687124133110046,
-0.706223726272583,
0.05612916126847267,
-0.0812307596206665,
0.19648194313049316,
0.9531283974647522,
-0.07458751648664474,
-0.7094928026199341,
-0.2240614891052246,
-0.003265491221100092,
-0.08501112461090088,
0.07235505431890488,
1.0960135459899902,
-0.8368527889251709,
0.4303175210952759,
0.6524224281311035,
0.4185181260108948,
0.462654173374176,
-0.13988052308559418,
0.2878006398677826,
-0.44041937589645386,
0.189827099442482,
0.28228339552879333,
0.3344406485557556,
0.24053730070590973,
-0.04230358079075813,
0.5588964819908142,
0.0925198420882225,
-0.6442375779151917,
-0.8958051204681396,
0.4095677435398102,
-0.6247069835662842,
-0.2892822027206421,
0.9702185988426208,
-0.12753792107105255,
-0.3573477566242218,
0.12828099727630615,
-0.0016748380148783326,
0.08691100776195526,
0.1452019065618515,
0.6402921676635742,
0.9418256282806396,
0.12389743328094482,
0.018658243119716644,
-0.4631778597831726,
-0.19421331584453583,
0.4931323528289795,
-0.5846577286720276,
-0.05767035856842995,
0.4505200684070587,
0.11757493764162064,
0.3689800202846527,
0.5220820903778076,
-0.21952800452709198,
0.10481510311365128,
0.063174769282341,
-0.1022978201508522,
0.28427717089653015,
-0.014993309043347836,
-0.2564522624015808,
-0.005601795390248299,
0.1635618358850479,
-0.060486260801553726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02863v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02863v1
|
LLM as a Scorer: The Impact of Output Order on Dialogue Evaluation
| 2024-06-05T02:25:10 | 2024-06-05T02:25:10 |
Yi-Pei Chen, KuanChao Chu, Hideki Nakayama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This research investigates the effect of prompt design on dialogue evaluation
using large language models (LLMs). While LLMs are increasingly used for
scoring various inputs, creating effective prompts for dialogue evaluation
remains challenging due to model sensitivity and subjectivity in dialogue
assessments. Our study experimented with different prompt structures, altering
the sequence of output instructions and including explanatory reasons. We found
that the order of presenting reasons and scores significantly influences LLMs'
scoring, with a "reason-first" approach yielding more comprehensive
evaluations. This insight is crucial for enhancing the accuracy and consistency
of LLM-based evaluations.
|
[
-0.21773064136505127,
-0.5859994888305664,
1.0245025157928467,
0.44553303718566895,
-0.30121830105781555,
-0.052186958491802216,
-0.0711594820022583,
-0.30845391750335693,
0.07263116538524628,
0.48580148816108704,
-0.5800769329071045,
-0.6857597231864929,
-0.75970458984375,
0.277131587266922,
-0.08443833887577057,
0.7359456419944763,
0.08924522250890732,
0.42507702112197876,
-0.2924855351448059,
-0.09042660146951675,
-0.8747718334197998,
-0.6399192810058594,
-0.8434526324272156,
-0.19095879793167114,
0.7499085068702698,
0.47821998596191406,
0.6174728870391846,
0.49438223242759705,
0.4453667402267456,
0.3775137960910797,
-0.20032690465450287,
-0.08515048772096634,
-0.5899038314819336,
0.644608199596405,
-0.04166778177022934,
-0.43280544877052307,
-0.27753907442092896,
0.32897332310676575,
0.7043649554252625,
0.589634358882904,
-0.0001861019991338253,
0.23276975750923157,
0.2354944944381714,
0.5049256682395935,
-0.42227765917778015,
0.3416125476360321,
-0.23809383809566498,
-0.05213411524891853,
0.00590710062533617,
-0.7050619125366211,
-0.8567515015602112,
-0.718283474445343,
0.2887795865535736,
-0.07417336851358414,
-0.3592454791069031,
0.07038537412881851,
0.5237571001052856,
0.10628033429384232,
-0.37831494212150574,
-0.5956783294677734,
-0.6320680975914001,
0.9596647620201111,
-0.7384001016616821,
0.16724686324596405,
-0.1799880713224411,
0.4429418444633484,
-0.2949996292591095,
-0.4656151533126831,
-0.06968666613101959,
-0.31027135252952576,
-0.0070702447555959225,
0.3346039652824402,
0.049859240651130676,
0.3137646019458771,
0.49778518080711365,
0.36188894510269165,
-0.3111704885959625,
0.5123544931411743,
-0.2119278758764267,
-0.15323619544506073,
0.7394391894340515,
0.8498312830924988,
0.2463519424200058,
-0.34019479155540466,
-0.17663171887397766,
-0.06304488331079483,
-0.8109883666038513,
0.58445805311203,
0.5013793706893921,
0.5606427192687988,
0.001801413600333035,
0.6127418279647827,
-0.32010459899902344,
0.7927114367485046,
0.02755209244787693,
-0.37362855672836304,
-0.22596843540668488,
-0.3850252032279968,
0.003577481023967266,
0.22509479522705078,
0.9566653966903687,
0.9153295159339905,
-0.07443307340145111,
0.2830579876899719,
-0.2795253396034241,
-0.0892309844493866,
0.15952812135219574,
-1.0405076742172241,
0.011721733957529068,
-0.04355118051171303,
-0.636057436466217,
-0.366034597158432,
0.12501390278339386,
-0.828849732875824,
-0.5474651455879211,
-0.5725299119949341,
0.3414432406425476,
-0.0765056237578392,
0.335251122713089,
-0.14905643463134766,
-0.07398509234189987,
0.40238502621650696,
0.8068113923072815,
-0.734807014465332,
0.3227154016494751,
0.6494264602661133,
0.7448517680168152,
-0.3298497498035431,
-0.08532758057117462,
-0.9943953156471252,
-0.46095380187034607,
-0.5147479176521301,
0.6859394907951355,
-0.7458321452140808,
-0.7436248064041138,
0.14156220853328705,
-0.1347305178642273,
0.047345854341983795,
-0.3549371361732483,
0.7985122203826904,
-0.420386403799057,
0.6278752088546753,
-0.34095123410224915,
-0.6020116209983826,
-0.2616240084171295,
-0.168929323554039,
-0.5114519596099854,
0.6945773959159851,
0.12840057909488678,
-0.31125137209892273,
0.3952469825744629,
-0.5166195631027222,
-0.35796284675598145,
0.14254595339298248,
-0.42624431848526,
-0.00023466991842724383,
0.44743379950523376,
0.03592024743556976,
0.304027795791626,
-0.5693877339363098,
0.19333693385124207,
0.010688870213925838,
-0.5606191158294678,
0.6721357107162476,
-0.8266667723655701,
0.648971676826477,
0.15857243537902832,
-0.12325280159711838,
0.3621334731578827,
-0.6047680974006653,
0.19053448736667633,
-0.12645478546619415,
-0.6940814852714539,
-0.022291971370577812,
-0.03120805136859417,
-0.41121745109558105,
0.23395049571990967,
0.1613023281097412,
-0.373273640871048,
0.06181502714753151,
-0.43004071712493896,
-0.009063598699867725,
1.0197011232376099,
0.33468565344810486,
0.4199703335762024,
-0.47496917843818665,
0.9527146816253662,
-0.3179757595062256,
0.35685989260673523,
-0.5610080361366272,
-0.8924275636672974,
-0.4929380416870117,
-0.17948584258556366,
0.36558496952056885,
0.5708178281784058,
-0.4278280735015869,
0.2004624307155609,
0.046746667474508286,
-0.548126757144928,
-0.41928431391716003,
0.16269904375076294,
0.6133754253387451,
0.38567429780960083,
-0.20123837888240814,
-0.504368782043457,
-0.3765757381916046,
-0.6709854006767273,
-0.36275291442871094,
-0.325446218252182,
-0.10921228677034378,
0.4397798776626587,
-0.02112734131515026,
0.23747654259204865,
0.828348696231842,
-0.7141743898391724,
0.13528716564178467,
-0.4723069965839386,
0.1107792854309082,
0.8706444501876831,
0.18034476041793823,
0.5374218225479126,
-0.3186807930469513,
-0.5172654986381531,
-0.46960142254829407,
-0.4999793767929077,
-0.6704701781272888,
-0.13643878698349,
-0.2388754040002823,
0.06820966303348541,
0.4031732678413391,
-0.7692570090293884,
0.5468316674232483,
0.27767232060432434,
-0.40131875872612,
1.033121943473816,
0.10174348205327988,
0.5726922750473022,
-0.7460537552833557,
-0.5075427293777466,
-0.04074114188551903,
0.04498780146241188,
-0.7152376174926758,
-0.23312260210514069,
-0.4084847569465637,
-0.19091372191905975,
-0.6421592831611633,
0.6125391125679016,
-0.29877108335494995,
-0.20097914338111877,
-0.14925134181976318,
0.24176016449928284,
0.40189671516418457,
0.34828370809555054,
-0.25619348883628845,
0.9795215129852295,
0.3003058135509491,
-0.8056825399398804,
0.39004841446876526,
0.19965998828411102,
-0.8283403515815735,
0.3276873826980591,
-0.7174651622772217,
0.17451001703739166,
0.08415720611810684,
0.08000895380973816,
-1.533835530281067,
-0.10464739799499512,
0.3473288416862488,
-0.5248444676399231,
0.4938315451145172,
-0.08558850735425949,
-0.3469868302345276,
-0.3093249797821045,
-0.41476699709892273,
0.2734418511390686,
0.5498067736625671,
-0.5141336917877197,
0.4182039797306061,
0.07897187769412994,
-0.5541676878929138,
-0.14275802671909332,
-0.25484833121299744,
-0.04907480254769325,
-0.48400378227233887,
-0.7040839195251465,
0.23470436036586761,
-0.45778101682662964,
-0.6672115921974182,
-0.716895580291748,
-0.17365390062332153,
0.3759264051914215,
0.3722580075263977,
0.37610381841659546,
0.5145740509033203,
-0.2414872944355011,
0.06586375832557678,
-0.05305058881640434,
-0.1413128823041916,
0.4590511918067932,
0.24267463386058807,
0.6546633243560791,
0.22434954345226288,
-0.3177093267440796,
-0.7157300114631653,
0.48910677433013916,
0.6313400268554688,
0.1819189488887787,
0.6946448087692261,
-0.02444552257657051,
0.14022430777549744,
0.04730590805411339,
-0.38999125361442566,
-0.07681695371866226,
-0.574779748916626,
0.051785994321107864,
-0.4570217430591583,
-0.8870256543159485,
0.4775117337703705,
-0.09399280697107315,
0.14203761518001556,
0.4397611618041992,
0.7697382569313049,
-0.1750226467847824,
1.3116154670715332,
0.2302761822938919,
0.24095411598682404,
0.7678012847900391,
0.28001636266708374,
0.37299469113349915,
-0.9412758350372314,
-0.17229415476322174,
-0.5750488638877869,
-0.13202345371246338,
-0.4306694567203522,
-0.3249145746231079,
0.24832235276699066,
0.16312655806541443,
-0.07997007668018341,
0.001768849790096283,
-0.49881047010421753,
0.5688180327415466,
0.31730395555496216,
0.05725516006350517,
0.15510748326778412,
-0.30994632840156555,
-0.2826298475265503,
-0.1411435902118683,
-0.5454389452934265,
-0.9649359583854675,
0.9062286019325256,
0.5235503911972046,
0.8018975853919983,
0.447555273771286,
0.7953159213066101,
0.3632194399833679,
0.3439215421676636,
-1.3229738473892212,
0.6868083477020264,
0.13883234560489655,
-0.13736455142498016,
-0.4572713375091553,
-0.37150508165359497,
-0.8468351364135742,
0.21979211270809174,
0.26414743065834045,
-1.0504134893417358,
-0.05658627673983574,
-0.2587929964065552,
-0.6696904301643372,
-0.47490450739860535,
-0.9201661348342896,
0.7961364984512329,
-0.39802682399749756,
-0.39033564925193787,
0.1291390359401703,
-0.3423718512058258,
0.48989295959472656,
0.19170090556144714,
0.1604074090719223,
-0.1518140286207199,
0.2006598562002182,
0.9713951349258423,
-0.5932838916778564,
0.920272946357727,
-0.13733282685279846,
-0.28414449095726013,
0.5678890943527222,
0.308880478143692,
0.3944319486618042,
0.059566009789705276,
-0.3309519588947296,
-0.14329437911510468,
-0.30079030990600586,
0.01462536957114935,
-1.019663691520691,
0.6396911144256592,
-0.7155799865722656,
-1.455310583114624,
-0.2992968261241913,
-0.5191252827644348,
-0.19595493376255035,
-0.3003562092781067,
0.24503293633460999,
0.8642671704292297,
-0.17411811649799347,
-0.1025816798210144,
0.46553918719291687,
-0.5189770460128784,
0.497065931558609,
0.5993828177452087,
-0.5524725317955017,
-0.4255691468715668,
0.5897099375724792,
0.17422589659690857,
0.5544434785842896,
0.23971091210842133,
0.39006486535072327,
-0.5917255282402039,
-0.5024628639221191,
-0.45175406336784363,
0.11223867535591125,
-1.2523871660232544,
-0.2275003343820572,
-0.2784229815006256,
-0.21367725729942322,
-0.37415021657943726,
-0.20310556888580322,
0.13456596434116364,
-0.5479253530502319,
-0.5514612793922424,
-0.22327519953250885,
0.42650607228279114,
1.0517805814743042,
0.27962249517440796,
0.5253129005432129,
-0.8119602799415588,
-0.09091915190219879,
0.4154256284236908,
0.3054511249065399,
0.03470427915453911,
-0.9642924666404724,
0.027296975255012512,
-0.3029840886592865,
-0.46321243047714233,
-1.0369396209716797,
0.27615585923194885,
-0.07409090548753738,
0.8520837426185608,
0.5134137272834778,
-0.08130809664726257,
0.5321869850158691,
-0.5608446598052979,
1.1743836402893066,
0.6241188049316406,
-0.9063425660133362,
0.6938629746437073,
-0.32697245478630066,
0.6349677443504333,
0.5233058333396912,
0.07144807279109955,
-0.40077292919158936,
-0.16650362312793732,
-0.20540380477905273,
-0.5277026295661926,
1.0033193826675415,
0.033154603093862534,
0.17201201617717743,
-0.16166335344314575,
0.10819927603006363,
0.35435229539871216,
0.08757057040929794,
-0.26593104004859924,
-0.2165219485759735,
0.05797995999455452,
-0.07695272564888,
-0.13071049749851227,
-0.7353527545928955,
-0.13554072380065918,
-0.22287589311599731,
0.4052974283695221,
-0.006031019147485495,
0.3516605794429779,
0.07024464011192322,
-0.06903574615716934,
-0.098549485206604,
0.4778270721435547,
0.8182557821273804,
0.7552793025970459,
-0.00007045183156151325,
-0.15829408168792725,
0.13527758419513702,
-0.006251186598092318,
0.24900980293750763,
-0.35098734498023987,
-0.030910378322005272,
0.2954298257827759,
0.45102211833000183,
1.0576093196868896,
0.36596065759658813,
-0.4610888659954071,
0.5955275297164917,
-0.3748244345188141,
-0.11451051384210587,
-0.08130652457475662,
0.29628437757492065,
-0.15838244557380676,
0.34131985902786255,
0.32484713196754456,
-0.1532236784696579,
0.30264002084732056,
-0.801225483417511,
0.10178551077842712,
0.19363869726657867,
-0.3733668923377991,
-0.12070197612047195,
0.3337251543998718,
0.16610407829284668,
-0.8846376538276672,
0.5690008401870728,
-0.034748151898384094,
-0.7677491307258606,
0.6295166611671448,
0.5365108847618103,
0.8925628066062927,
-0.7717907428741455,
0.3380615711212158,
0.32777297496795654,
-0.07089795917272568,
0.20959538221359253,
0.4347763657569885,
-0.20332150161266327,
-0.46866661310195923,
-0.5930862426757812,
-0.931801974773407,
-0.7099751830101013,
-0.22032365202903748,
-0.5862061381340027,
0.42606309056282043,
-0.6594743728637695,
-0.3694344758987427,
-0.0777762159705162,
-0.10551035404205322,
-0.6290387511253357,
0.17255012691020966,
0.3023242950439453,
0.716468334197998,
-0.6187548041343689,
0.34120678901672363,
0.30260494351387024,
-0.3569239377975464,
-1.0063385963439941,
-0.2480190396308899,
0.1810716688632965,
-0.7548101544380188,
0.9825690984725952,
0.5234044790267944,
-0.22149957716464996,
-0.3215220868587494,
-0.3498243987560272,
-0.8864548206329346,
0.9730085134506226,
0.25550228357315063,
-0.64499431848526,
0.09951253235340118,
0.06938541680574417,
0.6211443543434143,
-0.8360488414764404,
0.871584951877594,
0.5431251525878906,
0.459444135427475,
0.47110840678215027,
-0.7487362623214722,
0.09230434894561768,
-0.23647966980934143,
0.11608701199293137,
0.18353568017482758,
-0.5829693078994751,
0.5889177322387695,
-0.15156860649585724,
-0.39942464232444763,
0.33272549510002136,
0.5087462663650513,
0.5360514521598816,
0.2822340726852417,
0.2510814666748047,
0.1717221885919571,
0.6194743514060974,
-0.3282448649406433,
1.2738498449325562,
-0.14350378513336182,
-0.09865989536046982,
1.2223858833312988,
-0.4725867211818695,
0.5379149913787842,
0.5066491365432739,
-0.3943854570388794,
0.6737779378890991,
0.7808154821395874,
0.17620781064033508,
0.4966222643852234,
0.6146652698516846,
-0.24510473012924194,
-0.2087375521659851,
-0.4829472005367279,
-0.04813331365585327,
0.5703532099723816,
0.432083398103714,
-0.6899600625038147,
0.004914441611617804,
-0.21344831585884094,
-0.13957712054252625,
-0.0409398227930069,
-0.45715945959091187,
0.9002813696861267,
0.43342429399490356,
-0.9469847083091736,
0.39887964725494385,
-0.22722968459129333,
0.20392465591430664,
-0.4027152359485626,
-0.2524031102657318,
-0.15111200511455536,
-0.14962397515773773,
-0.13841481506824493,
-1.0467078685760498,
-0.006665217690169811,
0.0780959203839302,
-0.1885683834552765,
-0.4419225752353668,
0.5391455292701721,
-0.058568499982357025,
-0.41229090094566345,
0.41737836599349976,
0.5050382614135742,
0.40963253378868103,
0.3081430196762085,
-0.5013571977615356,
0.4121149480342865,
0.001740397303365171,
-0.5412346124649048,
0.3650945723056793,
0.5752376317977905,
0.05926767364144325,
0.3776693046092987,
0.639418363571167,
-0.3583715260028839,
0.07438772916793823,
0.7099522352218628,
0.9180980920791626,
-0.6634500026702881,
-0.2560887932777405,
-1.157994031906128,
0.6626834273338318,
-0.012022504583001137,
-0.3327139616012573,
0.9216826558113098,
0.484744131565094,
0.21002507209777832,
0.06120346859097481,
0.483183890581131,
0.3526774048805237,
0.4931388795375824,
-0.7866798639297485,
0.38947799801826477,
-0.18483784794807434,
0.645963728427887,
-0.5240285396575928,
-1.2163779735565186,
-0.21816058456897736,
0.21556296944618225,
-0.608588695526123,
0.0621158666908741,
0.7706084251403809,
0.7158899903297424,
0.6426949501037598,
0.2272775024175644,
0.7218102812767029,
0.15149973332881927,
0.39444905519485474,
0.5006557703018188,
1.456294298171997,
-0.32283449172973633,
0.4469612240791321,
0.10138518363237381,
-0.28908780217170715,
-0.2504512667655945,
-0.678556501865387,
-1.0132216215133667,
-0.22823366522789001,
-0.284592866897583,
-0.32077980041503906,
-0.18072040379047394,
0.9608038067817688,
0.10470198094844818,
-0.7493146657943726,
-0.4230860471725464,
0.2121777981519699,
0.3640623986721039,
0.0992826595902443,
-0.33789610862731934,
0.15444637835025787,
-0.49187880754470825,
-0.6563310623168945,
0.6718565225601196,
0.4966450333595276,
-0.017281437292695045,
-0.1611911505460739,
-0.2883967459201813,
0.05536714196205139,
0.2976250946521759,
0.8997551798820496,
-0.2563011348247528,
-0.9763815999031067,
-0.5161327123641968,
0.0420939140021801,
-0.18167509138584137,
0.32257136702537537,
0.8060336112976074,
-0.6935861706733704,
0.4959195852279663,
0.6708466410636902,
0.34404492378234863,
0.06483973562717438,
0.24529269337654114,
1.073042392730713,
-0.3806067407131195,
-0.32480791211128235,
0.14007873833179474,
0.4973936975002289,
0.2986515462398529,
-0.6311138868331909,
0.3572370111942291,
-0.17747950553894043,
-0.7423374652862549,
-0.6970517635345459,
0.357505202293396,
-1.027611494064331,
-0.0874287337064743,
1.2713655233383179,
-0.3733258545398712,
-0.21897605061531067,
-0.011172543279826641,
-0.6144322156906128,
0.205912247300148,
-0.7895693182945251,
0.5842281579971313,
1.1311854124069214,
-0.38691529631614685,
-0.4334779977798462,
-0.34053146839141846,
0.4236241579055786,
0.5015300512313843,
-0.4781665802001953,
0.03162294998764992,
0.6131442785263062,
-0.09504447132349014,
0.16111312806606293,
0.475647896528244,
-0.15288056433200836,
0.4298766851425171,
-0.14639706909656525,
-0.4614776372909546,
0.35991206765174866,
-0.46053841710090637,
-0.6993595957756042,
0.27567899227142334,
0.5403090119361877,
-0.01574571430683136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02856v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02856v4
|
Xmodel-LM Technical Report
| 2024-06-05T02:12:06 | 2024-06-26T06:28:45 |
Yichuan Wang, Yang Liu, Yu Yan, Qun Wang, Xucheng Huang, Ling Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce Xmodel-LM, a compact and efficient 1.1B language model
pre-trained on around 2 trillion tokens. Trained on our self-built dataset
(Xdata), which balances Chinese and English corpora based on downstream task
optimization, Xmodel-LM exhibits remarkable performance despite its smaller
size. It notably surpasses existing open-source language models of similar
scale. Our model checkpoints and code are publicly accessible on GitHub at
https://github.com/XiaoduoAILab/XmodelLM.
|
[
-0.011783696711063385,
-0.3535817861557007,
0.27916431427001953,
0.17859888076782227,
-0.19197113811969757,
0.04027269035577774,
-0.2782628536224365,
-0.5770260095596313,
0.05235711857676506,
0.6298750042915344,
-0.6194035410881042,
-0.5033240914344788,
-0.26193317770957947,
-0.1996297985315323,
-0.5717479586601257,
0.7414515614509583,
0.13267995417118073,
0.43432381749153137,
0.03887084871530533,
-0.15905480086803436,
-0.21490219235420227,
-0.6591960787773132,
-0.7112728953361511,
-0.2711966335773468,
0.6470524072647095,
0.3322784900665283,
0.7141334414482117,
1.028110384941101,
0.4470336437225342,
0.29414787888526917,
0.058451905846595764,
-0.09486144781112671,
-0.6333397626876831,
-0.35446837544441223,
-0.1472073346376419,
-0.795508861541748,
-0.5097151398658752,
0.08232894539833069,
0.7047227025032043,
0.7580909132957458,
-0.12814627587795258,
0.3419015407562256,
-0.24825482070446014,
0.47992008924484253,
-0.38950884342193604,
0.35035961866378784,
-0.6215006113052368,
-0.015425190329551697,
-0.4035302698612213,
-0.09787718951702118,
-0.6394461989402771,
-0.21734201908111572,
0.05573473870754242,
-0.5329515337944031,
-0.0319211445748806,
0.4035503566265106,
0.876333475112915,
0.03840550407767296,
-0.42097020149230957,
-0.3066193461418152,
-0.538438081741333,
1.0398763418197632,
-0.658753514289856,
0.5656687617301941,
0.37649834156036377,
0.3305605947971344,
0.1418813169002533,
-1.0821261405944824,
-0.5140324234962463,
-0.36468061804771423,
-0.3000680208206177,
-0.18069276213645935,
-0.22291837632656097,
0.11840417236089706,
-0.12707145512104034,
0.5982623100280762,
-0.7765380144119263,
0.3786890506744385,
-0.5502036213874817,
0.028380803763866425,
0.6677517294883728,
0.4327675402164459,
0.3524542450904846,
-0.2277800440788269,
-0.43356531858444214,
0.0340808741748333,
-0.7000880241394043,
-0.08517134189605713,
0.1178324818611145,
0.6204061508178711,
-0.12733864784240723,
0.481780469417572,
0.002763667143881321,
0.6258807182312012,
-0.32633697986602783,
-0.21522754430770874,
0.24243532121181488,
-0.7397854924201965,
-0.4182538092136383,
-0.029047848656773567,
0.8844506740570068,
0.10805648565292358,
-0.01433655060827732,
-0.210299551486969,
-0.45019766688346863,
0.025149578228592873,
0.10628898441791534,
-0.9794877767562866,
-0.30716273188591003,
0.21626372635364532,
-0.6517549157142639,
-0.3133220672607422,
-0.16428568959236145,
-0.0054429396986961365,
0.015522194094955921,
-0.29418516159057617,
0.5580282807350159,
-0.42975130677223206,
-0.2848590314388275,
0.2994936406612396,
0.186800017952919,
-0.04381219670176506,
0.03618192672729492,
-0.782925009727478,
0.5012723207473755,
0.702733039855957,
1.0830100774765015,
-0.20629611611366272,
-0.001009342959150672,
-0.3494722843170166,
-0.1953457146883011,
-0.5532994270324707,
0.40363821387290955,
-0.2340383678674698,
-0.48098501563072205,
-0.14900986850261688,
0.041758615523576736,
-0.023991871625185013,
-0.4812912046909332,
0.6611036062240601,
-0.5113038420677185,
0.37060338258743286,
-0.08766697347164154,
-0.9858407974243164,
-0.14899756014347076,
0.2159128189086914,
-0.9771353602409363,
1.0593174695968628,
0.42228254675865173,
-0.7694342732429504,
0.34879082441329956,
-0.835119903087616,
-0.26126331090927124,
0.24999341368675232,
-0.2611493170261383,
-0.2689366340637207,
-0.01803431287407875,
-0.24202501773834229,
0.4789637625217438,
-0.4703323245048523,
0.07146330177783966,
0.0259246826171875,
-0.37581557035446167,
0.025167234241962433,
-0.11092134565114975,
1.2038758993148804,
0.6220134496688843,
-0.22061659395694733,
0.40438443422317505,
-1.1200240850448608,
0.19326943159103394,
0.24971002340316772,
-0.3290238678455353,
-0.4942176640033722,
-0.0017897181678563356,
0.34088820219039917,
0.3473023772239685,
0.3173220157623291,
-0.6102617979049683,
0.2986004054546356,
-0.4423772096633911,
0.6102690100669861,
0.5648522973060608,
-0.763776421546936,
0.5812838673591614,
-0.46630334854125977,
0.5807210206985474,
-0.02178245224058628,
-0.07194995880126953,
-0.7001277804374695,
-0.2709875702857971,
-0.7904940843582153,
-0.705452561378479,
0.5696219205856323,
0.5549055337905884,
-0.463334858417511,
0.2415100485086441,
-0.44335079193115234,
-0.6319670677185059,
-0.6847025156021118,
0.3269897401332855,
0.4357508718967438,
0.27036187052726746,
0.1226985901594162,
0.017951831221580505,
-0.9459217190742493,
-0.98509681224823,
0.24317175149917603,
-0.2477402687072754,
0.10587134212255478,
-0.03211049735546112,
0.4839054346084595,
-0.25904974341392517,
1.2180486917495728,
-0.39499661326408386,
-0.10345698893070221,
-0.544804573059082,
0.07728619128465652,
0.0774262472987175,
0.5188959240913391,
0.7188720703125,
-0.6897120475769043,
-0.6184041500091553,
0.36317330598831177,
-0.5729689598083496,
-0.13699251413345337,
-0.005854250863194466,
0.013842933811247349,
0.46367740631103516,
0.686506450176239,
-0.6586900949478149,
-0.07593326270580292,
0.985293447971344,
-0.37680473923683167,
0.4861568212509155,
-0.10773515701293945,
-0.10330786556005478,
-1.3200379610061646,
0.22004851698875427,
-0.22045068442821503,
-0.7031957507133484,
-0.5813382267951965,
0.2814624011516571,
0.44259145855903625,
0.019951339811086655,
-0.6988296508789062,
1.019002079963684,
-0.6646716594696045,
0.14616268873214722,
-0.26197871565818787,
0.19744759798049927,
-0.2152157872915268,
0.5163770318031311,
0.13812732696533203,
0.8140172362327576,
0.34905245900154114,
-0.3880295157432556,
0.12959353625774384,
0.0988849624991417,
-0.9269902110099792,
-0.09282181411981583,
-0.6873780488967896,
0.016118159517645836,
0.18691648542881012,
-0.15105940401554108,
-0.920522153377533,
0.012096373364329338,
0.1183304712176323,
-0.10224898904561996,
0.3929727077484131,
0.14125147461891174,
-0.6272046566009521,
-0.42201706767082214,
-0.35843223333358765,
0.41660550236701965,
0.6442732810974121,
-0.6793884038925171,
0.464262455701828,
0.48025044798851013,
-0.15054182708263397,
-0.2060946822166443,
-0.759765088558197,
-0.022949911653995514,
0.1413647085428238,
-0.8118025660514832,
0.3374524712562561,
-0.30245205760002136,
-0.34305351972579956,
0.08708920329809189,
0.21961461007595062,
-0.11652253568172455,
0.0760732889175415,
0.3233020007610321,
0.4556104242801666,
-0.3241257071495056,
0.17634505033493042,
-0.2158212810754776,
-0.07109242677688599,
-0.0539105050265789,
-0.19535021483898163,
0.6603832840919495,
0.10999684035778046,
-0.15113802254199982,
-0.27016741037368774,
0.27785956859588623,
0.4329988360404968,
0.08723854273557663,
0.8548579216003418,
0.1366729736328125,
-0.367360383272171,
-0.24912689626216888,
-0.19081221520900726,
0.16899071633815765,
-0.49727362394332886,
0.7706906199455261,
-0.3801195025444031,
-1.02637779712677,
0.4302658140659332,
0.24775998294353485,
0.37191882729530334,
0.15925028920173645,
0.8545764088630676,
0.2657507061958313,
1.2706407308578491,
0.8648244142532349,
-0.32209262251853943,
0.5349894165992737,
-0.18555204570293427,
0.22458596527576447,
-0.14203166961669922,
-0.16333453357219696,
-0.576867401599884,
-0.04642346501350403,
-0.5941388607025146,
-0.777825653553009,
-0.1443677693605423,
0.009051828645169735,
-0.2024386078119278,
0.5536515116691589,
-0.23042389750480652,
0.32468754053115845,
0.7260446548461914,
-0.04760958254337311,
0.48648735880851746,
-0.44508427381515503,
0.06888755410909653,
0.06297943741083145,
-1.04062819480896,
-0.668735921382904,
1.0628713369369507,
0.5867038369178772,
0.922832727432251,
-0.14346803724765778,
0.47170019149780273,
0.10288600623607635,
0.4679814279079437,
-0.737716019153595,
0.6023186445236206,
-0.23316343128681183,
-1.0812957286834717,
-0.1590770184993744,
-0.6570578217506409,
-0.8853729367256165,
0.161166712641716,
-0.08226452767848969,
-0.3976723253726959,
-0.4277273714542389,
0.32329124212265015,
-0.32953402400016785,
0.46534407138824463,
-0.979066014289856,
0.9679936766624451,
-0.4828728139400482,
-0.08503637462854385,
-0.32432833313941956,
-0.500995397567749,
0.6948763132095337,
-0.4617981016635895,
0.3151382803916931,
-0.06120581924915314,
-0.12507364153862,
0.7769610285758972,
-0.5725473165512085,
0.8211002349853516,
0.10301733016967773,
-0.2443787306547165,
0.18955372273921967,
-0.1520409733057022,
0.46663719415664673,
-0.19986827671527863,
-0.16298997402191162,
0.46428459882736206,
0.23433171212673187,
-0.54964280128479,
-0.34125182032585144,
0.5998205542564392,
-0.8355886936187744,
-0.465384840965271,
-0.20990559458732605,
-0.8690035939216614,
0.1747571974992752,
0.4088670611381531,
0.35010018944740295,
0.2620120048522949,
-0.5358000993728638,
0.26020580530166626,
0.47222083806991577,
-0.18567702174186707,
0.43440553545951843,
0.6228849291801453,
-0.9402869939804077,
-0.12758544087409973,
0.8094883561134338,
0.5574073195457458,
0.3820456564426422,
0.6454941630363464,
-0.02577395737171173,
-0.016707900911569595,
-0.4349977374076843,
-0.3560329079627991,
0.05161163583397865,
-0.6044063568115234,
-0.15141548216342926,
-0.8063755631446838,
-0.36193105578422546,
-0.38563236594200134,
0.03970061615109444,
-0.7431574463844299,
-0.7466517090797424,
-0.09785757213830948,
-0.23068760335445404,
0.0242422204464674,
0.6755896210670471,
0.03870868310332298,
0.485544353723526,
-0.9596075415611267,
0.13409632444381714,
0.1340091973543167,
0.3454791307449341,
-0.17330984771251678,
-0.5729540586471558,
-0.8860328793525696,
0.13610567152500153,
0.01962018944323063,
-0.20464448630809784,
0.5254150032997131,
0.1002836674451828,
0.5383589267730713,
0.6895331740379333,
-0.18753682076931,
0.44535449147224426,
-0.5772145390510559,
0.869523823261261,
0.21329046785831451,
-1.0858361721038818,
0.23820847272872925,
-0.15388506650924683,
0.2973529100418091,
0.15676452219486237,
0.5694828629493713,
-0.4489213228225708,
-0.2982553541660309,
-0.2594255208969116,
-0.6723529696464539,
0.8152163624763489,
0.24632269144058228,
0.29864051938056946,
-0.2836696207523346,
0.16197195649147034,
0.4670617878437042,
0.1082988902926445,
-0.8658870458602905,
-0.5326111316680908,
-0.0679476335644722,
-0.2930911183357239,
-0.1952417939901352,
-0.4559537172317505,
0.016855793073773384,
-0.37123194336891174,
0.8214829564094543,
-0.0009365295409224927,
0.10091011971235275,
-0.2902062237262726,
-0.3145308792591095,
-0.031472258269786835,
-0.010432437062263489,
0.7643097639083862,
0.6434102058410645,
-0.2538723647594452,
0.046226829290390015,
0.136519193649292,
-0.3564775586128235,
0.074689581990242,
0.07093878835439682,
-0.11561092734336853,
0.15168136358261108,
0.4761505424976349,
0.8729881644248962,
0.5250658988952637,
-1.166799545288086,
0.3376186192035675,
-0.20967857539653778,
-0.36956843733787537,
-0.30027008056640625,
0.11557665467262268,
0.40289735794067383,
0.23568418622016907,
0.2984316349029541,
-0.36473292112350464,
-0.2010830044746399,
-0.6774421334266663,
0.26001644134521484,
0.44975394010543823,
-0.21787065267562866,
-0.5570257306098938,
0.8000574707984924,
0.21639375388622284,
-0.22795546054840088,
0.6117044687271118,
-0.3182070255279541,
-0.4847222566604614,
0.2612982392311096,
0.5860316157341003,
0.6464173793792725,
-0.23485147953033447,
-0.006466541439294815,
0.23980045318603516,
0.35892921686172485,
-0.2606070637702942,
0.33355122804641724,
0.14129868149757385,
-0.8022921085357666,
-0.5400645136833191,
-0.5241230130195618,
-0.3874393403530121,
0.006671334151178598,
-0.48726916313171387,
0.6590116620063782,
-0.313880056142807,
-0.11149280518293381,
-0.07560361176729202,
0.30630841851234436,
-0.4957119822502136,
0.33610057830810547,
0.34751710295677185,
1.5982041358947754,
-0.6116670966148376,
1.376699447631836,
0.43192926049232483,
-0.3083636462688446,
-0.8308060169219971,
-0.7892634272575378,
-0.19244426488876343,
-1.0946354866027832,
1.000152587890625,
0.13529467582702637,
0.020256023854017258,
-0.012163347564637661,
-0.6309217810630798,
-0.9122201204299927,
1.195934534072876,
0.5984269380569458,
-1.0531779527664185,
-0.2470090389251709,
0.1807371973991394,
0.3937760293483734,
-0.508731484413147,
0.10513914376497269,
0.47328951954841614,
0.18049132823944092,
-0.16619975864887238,
-0.966844916343689,
-0.16320450603961945,
-0.5528335571289062,
0.08652635663747787,
0.34888318181037903,
-0.725487470626831,
1.1975491046905518,
-0.23845142126083374,
-0.43353748321533203,
0.4563971161842346,
0.9453206658363342,
0.039528168737888336,
0.049360521137714386,
0.5681352615356445,
0.5551275014877319,
0.9314502477645874,
0.04181520268321037,
1.1085186004638672,
-0.8511541485786438,
0.43287816643714905,
1.492472767829895,
-0.40985286235809326,
0.7392833828926086,
0.4126880466938019,
-0.03002755716443062,
0.41142070293426514,
0.6683468818664551,
0.09056482464075089,
0.5246325135231018,
0.2026345282793045,
-0.1415027379989624,
-0.1917669028043747,
0.18151485919952393,
-0.24880832433700562,
0.3782591223716736,
0.041056547313928604,
-0.5013201832771301,
0.023483911529183388,
0.1363622546195984,
0.19569720327854156,
-0.1464368849992752,
-0.47537872195243835,
0.3484581410884857,
0.11170224100351334,
-0.31366589665412903,
0.3337668180465698,
0.20344765484333038,
0.7152395248413086,
-0.8394235968589783,
0.21197105944156647,
-0.2039734572172165,
0.32058632373809814,
-0.07524019479751587,
-0.5243552327156067,
0.2980976998806,
-0.14120760560035706,
-0.43526771664619446,
-0.28681448101997375,
0.5518426895141602,
-0.6187628507614136,
-0.7604929208755493,
0.5038223266601562,
0.3803193271160126,
0.019062303006649017,
0.018767574802041054,
-0.5364504456520081,
0.20459038019180298,
-0.058021944016218185,
-0.6507167220115662,
0.3019285798072815,
0.41288870573043823,
-0.3806658089160919,
1.099307656288147,
0.49451154470443726,
0.032054297626018524,
0.3514867126941681,
-0.0688934251666069,
0.8713681101799011,
-0.8836512565612793,
-0.5942760109901428,
-0.7721535563468933,
0.5936974287033081,
0.1301317662000656,
-0.11346196383237839,
0.908836305141449,
0.9639161825180054,
1.1627211570739746,
-0.006700929254293442,
0.9234311580657959,
-0.06041935831308365,
0.7329567074775696,
-0.38702571392059326,
0.7553691864013672,
-0.6714628338813782,
0.24724838137626648,
0.1277744024991989,
-0.5138065814971924,
-0.30020174384117126,
0.40355655550956726,
0.06766081601381302,
0.1485949158668518,
0.5638431310653687,
1.0473709106445312,
0.0404103621840477,
-0.04822690784931183,
0.8630979657173157,
0.3329637050628662,
0.1236606314778328,
0.27953681349754333,
0.6092338562011719,
-0.47430717945098877,
0.6939573287963867,
-0.4593784809112549,
-0.13386593759059906,
-0.2454765886068344,
-0.8297697901725769,
-1.0976767539978027,
-0.5473203063011169,
-0.2585318088531494,
-0.039208363741636276,
-0.11114337295293808,
1.4187309741973877,
1.213637113571167,
-0.8252565264701843,
-0.4686354994773865,
0.08597943931818008,
-0.027133900672197342,
-0.047430239617824554,
-0.15389621257781982,
0.17551636695861816,
-0.5081547498703003,
-1.0665466785430908,
0.43195515871047974,
0.3131856620311737,
-0.0654449462890625,
-0.6601536273956299,
-0.4864601194858551,
-0.17108893394470215,
0.44633227586746216,
0.7861387729644775,
-0.0168254766613245,
-0.3200748562812805,
-0.09150128811597824,
0.40552371740341187,
-0.6993053555488586,
0.1444479078054428,
1.0440477132797241,
-0.543837308883667,
0.30422449111938477,
0.5158965587615967,
0.3965686559677124,
0.41344860196113586,
-0.30049046874046326,
0.8046637177467346,
-0.6526064872741699,
0.2325964868068695,
-0.14739292860031128,
0.577534556388855,
0.2915206849575043,
-0.15804512798786163,
0.6670506596565247,
-0.03305695205926895,
-0.5314568281173706,
-1.0164921283721924,
-0.04807623103260994,
-1.0523258447647095,
-0.5147631168365479,
0.8275733590126038,
-0.30704250931739807,
-0.414089173078537,
0.0783500075340271,
-0.3583025336265564,
0.11249113827943802,
-0.046054258942604065,
0.65179044008255,
0.6130644083023071,
0.1807403862476349,
-0.4171680510044098,
-0.49348676204681396,
0.21053029596805573,
0.4154839515686035,
-0.6956767439842224,
0.023956449702382088,
0.018296675756573677,
0.3567688763141632,
0.1632765680551529,
0.8136561512947083,
-0.0032658891286700964,
0.21988731622695923,
0.21551060676574707,
0.4372931718826294,
-0.19975818693637848,
-0.049416910856962204,
-0.2151055783033371,
0.17737747728824615,
0.15381692349910736,
-0.2831922769546509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02844v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02844v1
|
Item-Language Model for Conversational Recommendation
| 2024-06-05T01:35:50 | 2024-06-05T01:35:50 |
Li Yang, Anushya Subbiah, Hardik Patel, Judith Yue Li, Yanwei Song, Reza Mirghaderi, Vikram Aggarwal
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Large-language Models (LLMs) have been extremely successful at tasks like
complex dialogue understanding, reasoning and coding due to their emergent
abilities. These emergent abilities have been extended with multi-modality to
include image, audio, and video capabilities. Recommender systems, on the other
hand, have been critical for information seeking and item discovery needs.
Recently, there have been attempts to apply LLMs for recommendations. One
difficulty of current attempts is that the underlying LLM is usually not
trained on the recommender system data, which largely contains user interaction
signals and is often not publicly available. Another difficulty is user
interaction signals often have a different pattern from natural language text,
and it is currently unclear if the LLM training setup can learn more
non-trivial knowledge from interaction signals compared with traditional
recommender system methods. Finally, it is difficult to train multiple LLMs for
different use-cases, and to retain the original language and reasoning
abilities when learning from recommender system data. To address these three
limitations, we propose an Item-Language Model (ILM), which is composed of an
item encoder to produce text-aligned item representations that encode user
interaction signals, and a frozen LLM that can understand those item
representations with preserved pretrained knowledge. We conduct extensive
experiments which demonstrate both the importance of the language-alignment and
of user interaction knowledge in the item encoder.
|
[
-0.3320574164390564,
-0.7255286574363708,
0.6310946345329285,
-0.04911785572767258,
-0.32756417989730835,
-0.10389918088912964,
-0.2903100550174713,
-0.5211070775985718,
0.2533426582813263,
0.7337149381637573,
-0.38744601607322693,
-0.34050917625427246,
-0.3443986773490906,
-0.017308268696069717,
-0.1929389238357544,
1.0782817602157593,
-0.024833079427480698,
0.06792816519737244,
-0.23545615375041962,
-0.03764377161860466,
-0.639198899269104,
-0.44422444701194763,
-0.6642187833786011,
-0.6693889498710632,
0.43327459692955017,
0.42084500193595886,
0.6395261883735657,
0.35331836342811584,
0.3823670446872711,
0.2718246877193451,
0.09102106839418411,
0.2889574468135834,
-0.4863739609718323,
0.15330658853054047,
-0.14108380675315857,
-0.11854948848485947,
-0.5214094519615173,
-0.14070013165473938,
0.3236810564994812,
0.6396486759185791,
-0.36197614669799805,
-0.21967297792434692,
0.17949628829956055,
0.4239727556705475,
-0.23113717138767242,
0.21911342442035675,
-0.6485334038734436,
-0.10198993980884552,
0.22809287905693054,
-0.14396701753139496,
-0.5663706064224243,
-0.21876469254493713,
0.6140074729919434,
-0.6687495708465576,
-0.19808799028396606,
0.5590431690216064,
0.7317458391189575,
-0.1279250681400299,
-0.41567370295524597,
-0.5234073996543884,
-0.975161075592041,
0.7962290048599243,
-0.6110216975212097,
0.5865596532821655,
0.7502328157424927,
-0.03683612123131752,
-0.09404409676790237,
-0.29138824343681335,
-0.5121955275535583,
-0.3709487020969391,
-0.028536396101117134,
-0.09473837912082672,
-0.1010596975684166,
0.06286417692899704,
-0.03253835812211037,
0.29204776883125305,
-0.36765140295028687,
0.11871926486492157,
-0.09147842228412628,
0.11351712048053741,
0.4842560589313507,
0.21190406382083893,
0.3099796175956726,
-0.08053547888994217,
-0.6370468735694885,
-0.07367489486932755,
-0.6087470650672913,
-0.005372451152652502,
0.20948141813278198,
0.17916689813137054,
-0.24792595207691193,
0.7584049105644226,
-0.053976960480213165,
0.7363150715827942,
0.23049518465995789,
-0.22511588037014008,
0.16543623805046082,
-0.36471521854400635,
-0.177277073264122,
-0.07867025583982468,
0.8893534541130066,
0.7248687744140625,
0.263888418674469,
-0.0729033425450325,
-0.17897967994213104,
-0.39429140090942383,
0.1513541340827942,
-0.8188415765762329,
-0.27519357204437256,
-0.1340060532093048,
-0.598476767539978,
-0.14164642989635468,
0.050869185477495193,
-0.3433105945587158,
-0.6346635222434998,
-0.3192467987537384,
0.5256780385971069,
-0.6530207991600037,
-0.05040310323238373,
0.28309184312820435,
0.25233203172683716,
0.028126582503318787,
0.34535396099090576,
-0.8370699882507324,
0.26512858271598816,
0.2949987053871155,
0.5595744848251343,
-0.05718709155917168,
-0.241355761885643,
-0.3939831554889679,
0.20888669788837433,
-0.2562408447265625,
0.9328418374061584,
-0.8345322608947754,
-0.3073062002658844,
0.20521613955497742,
0.1554611176252365,
-0.017060372978448868,
-0.3267514407634735,
0.2971237897872925,
-0.5547677278518677,
0.4087783098220825,
-0.25942346453666687,
-0.8121368288993835,
-0.4610748291015625,
0.27745044231414795,
-0.35567593574523926,
0.6976256966590881,
0.06370104849338531,
-0.4660648703575134,
0.31556499004364014,
-0.49236997961997986,
-0.4316628575325012,
0.15148474276065826,
-0.07355013489723206,
-0.2837487459182739,
-0.058900825679302216,
0.20131729543209076,
0.5875117182731628,
-0.5594287514686584,
0.29799991846084595,
-0.4723365306854248,
-0.3817808926105499,
0.5108517408370972,
-0.5487080812454224,
0.15877816081047058,
0.3266332447528839,
0.10476867109537125,
0.07664566487073898,
-0.44529271125793457,
-0.33078932762145996,
0.10489170998334885,
-0.574044406414032,
-0.42039915919303894,
0.30094650387763977,
0.15666484832763672,
-0.01227719895541668,
0.5604162812232971,
-0.45528268814086914,
0.33651497960090637,
-0.5793060064315796,
0.22640377283096313,
0.6605671644210815,
0.05383124202489853,
0.5746561288833618,
-0.5493124723434448,
0.39839285612106323,
0.15662238001823425,
-0.2117466926574707,
-0.5904455184936523,
-0.3659231662750244,
-0.9258432984352112,
0.08368608355522156,
-0.006365250330418348,
0.5501769781112671,
-0.7783995866775513,
0.6552085280418396,
0.053130052983760834,
-0.08650678396224976,
-0.4462582468986511,
0.3714125454425812,
0.4080579876899719,
0.2647860646247864,
0.21318358182907104,
-0.3424034118652344,
-0.589110791683197,
-0.8034271597862244,
0.06312451511621475,
-0.3431488275527954,
-0.1999601572751999,
0.7577342391014099,
0.09207712858915329,
-0.4434022307395935,
0.7726443409919739,
-0.5313007235527039,
-0.481238454580307,
-0.48761674761772156,
0.007632647641003132,
0.39259418845176697,
0.151054248213768,
0.2108537256717682,
-0.19633100926876068,
-0.41628584265708923,
0.19215048849582672,
-0.5997484922409058,
-0.09469230473041534,
0.021533366292715073,
0.16965173184871674,
0.135491743683815,
0.46291711926460266,
-0.2943919003009796,
0.24812588095664978,
0.4008728265762329,
-0.3896113634109497,
0.15237030386924744,
-0.4908291697502136,
0.15174248814582825,
-1.424582600593567,
-0.3558100163936615,
0.24129903316497803,
-0.19489887356758118,
-0.7137370705604553,
-0.43951094150543213,
-0.17677739262580872,
-0.16386382281780243,
-0.14146772027015686,
0.6735137104988098,
-0.33277007937431335,
0.23648107051849365,
-0.5063573718070984,
0.21813270449638367,
0.06592226773500443,
0.5529939532279968,
0.358676016330719,
0.5651967525482178,
0.45706906914711,
-0.5135730504989624,
0.20809614658355713,
0.3698645234107971,
-0.4309532046318054,
0.8347450494766235,
-0.6350642442703247,
0.2963522672653198,
-0.10771822184324265,
-0.029572686180472374,
-0.9213525652885437,
0.009335396811366081,
0.12004608660936356,
0.1864231377840042,
0.17019005119800568,
-0.3545723259449005,
-0.3015078604221344,
0.002436333568766713,
-0.15630388259887695,
0.4390098452568054,
0.49938130378723145,
-0.5694953203201294,
0.7359415292739868,
0.4655684530735016,
-0.2369837909936905,
-0.38947606086730957,
-0.02889462560415268,
0.04241513833403587,
-0.28123798966407776,
-0.45213693380355835,
0.1585020124912262,
-0.4766925871372223,
-0.09357569366693497,
-0.14313437044620514,
0.2667936384677887,
0.08535872399806976,
-0.06701083481311798,
0.4101419448852539,
0.422069251537323,
-0.08255188167095184,
0.36519381403923035,
-0.3766128420829773,
-0.08532234281301498,
-0.16910552978515625,
-0.3765362501144409,
0.7227084040641785,
-0.3624146580696106,
-0.5732306241989136,
-0.36291155219078064,
0.1683846414089203,
0.4251285791397095,
0.012234359048306942,
0.632070779800415,
0.6251316666603088,
-0.32545211911201477,
0.010375550016760826,
-0.7854703068733215,
-0.3701319694519043,
-0.4767417907714844,
0.5013632774353027,
-0.30228063464164734,
-0.8243686556816101,
0.2145615667104721,
0.0036469141487032175,
-0.08345267921686172,
-0.07709413021802902,
0.5295441746711731,
-0.5077831745147705,
1.1457573175430298,
0.5618935823440552,
-0.3571949601173401,
0.6497051119804382,
-0.10782285034656525,
0.4792645573616028,
-1.057146668434143,
-0.315133661031723,
-0.15565140545368195,
-0.17252777516841888,
-0.26220032572746277,
-0.2240152508020401,
0.23689089715480804,
0.3016670346260071,
-0.2652442455291748,
0.286440372467041,
-0.1630246490240097,
0.4131254255771637,
0.5020938515663147,
0.3567495048046112,
0.41208162903785706,
0.13045908510684967,
-0.03270493447780609,
0.0765385553240776,
-0.697801947593689,
-0.5596057176589966,
0.9424015879631042,
0.473124623298645,
1.187484622001648,
-0.018132304772734642,
0.25528833270072937,
0.1797115057706833,
-0.00420067273080349,
-0.9939765930175781,
0.525865912437439,
-0.37001481652259827,
-0.13165061175823212,
-0.21017351746559143,
-0.011481603607535362,
-1.0441911220550537,
-0.11278507858514786,
-0.5803662538528442,
-0.9960926175117493,
0.06089603528380394,
0.13646629452705383,
-0.22074559330940247,
0.20869529247283936,
-0.6167747378349304,
0.4789869785308838,
-0.33022910356521606,
-0.16309167444705963,
-0.1018066555261612,
-0.1469346582889557,
-0.04861397296190262,
-0.03380477428436279,
0.3781835734844208,
-0.23576737940311432,
0.3104967772960663,
0.8445342183113098,
-0.34757915139198303,
0.8940016031265259,
0.07243062555789948,
-0.13575305044651031,
0.13010920584201813,
0.38038477301597595,
0.7087358832359314,
0.1472359150648117,
0.06304223090410233,
-0.08289460837841034,
-0.17418964207172394,
0.07412480562925339,
-0.409619003534317,
0.685038685798645,
-0.9224892258644104,
-0.7732228636741638,
-0.28476718068122864,
-0.7430793642997742,
-0.16491585969924927,
0.1946379691362381,
-0.021926486864686012,
0.5429257750511169,
-0.27044329047203064,
0.4903593063354492,
0.7612829804420471,
-0.17247232794761658,
0.3905903697013855,
0.8271111249923706,
-0.4999085068702698,
-0.5074864029884338,
1.0148646831512451,
-0.1773608922958374,
-0.023823006078600883,
0.4231635630130768,
0.14829707145690918,
-0.18945999443531036,
-0.6643516421318054,
-0.18616944551467896,
0.256072074174881,
-0.5584244728088379,
0.010983231477439404,
-0.6326633095741272,
-0.12740017473697662,
0.05929795280098915,
-0.24238477647304535,
-0.13730014860630035,
0.00020534593204502016,
-0.6053154468536377,
-0.1049945279955864,
0.6360307335853577,
0.9503380060195923,
0.2910451591014862,
0.3469381034374237,
-0.5333442091941833,
0.297374427318573,
0.39306873083114624,
0.5669443607330322,
-0.15955686569213867,
-0.6277549266815186,
-0.5995915532112122,
0.07909528911113739,
-0.14354129135608673,
-0.6806760430335999,
0.44594624638557434,
0.19831669330596924,
0.4206677973270416,
0.9381757378578186,
0.1261082887649536,
0.4626007080078125,
-0.5014659762382507,
0.6472477316856384,
0.3370048999786377,
-0.5790788531303406,
0.3654593825340271,
-0.4734026789665222,
0.46927180886268616,
0.27095741033554077,
0.2673872113227844,
-0.6410946249961853,
-0.1749623715877533,
-0.2865550220012665,
-0.722409725189209,
0.9046523571014404,
0.01693294569849968,
0.20002180337905884,
-0.1825401335954666,
0.08579673618078232,
0.0851484015583992,
0.2352825552225113,
-0.6555845737457275,
-0.10781873017549515,
-0.12843556702136993,
-0.37608903646469116,
-0.21445438265800476,
-0.589762806892395,
-0.14920945465564728,
0.11907736212015152,
0.6449496150016785,
-0.11746275424957275,
0.19347921013832092,
-0.04993431642651558,
-0.13749924302101135,
-0.1358904391527176,
0.3776107430458069,
0.3640387952327728,
0.4321307837963104,
-0.34786778688430786,
0.11489967256784439,
0.30223092436790466,
-0.22915206849575043,
0.14870017766952515,
0.13162367045879364,
0.05220232158899307,
-0.42791879177093506,
0.02715250663459301,
1.0820577144622803,
0.41072362661361694,
-0.6817214488983154,
0.4691465198993683,
-0.13399575650691986,
-0.021608950570225716,
-0.5579171180725098,
-0.03936993330717087,
0.2930453419685364,
0.26909804344177246,
0.18896296620368958,
0.03496163710951805,
-0.0020954697392880917,
-0.6372741460800171,
-0.08715501427650452,
0.5879409909248352,
-0.7172006964683533,
-0.23801757395267487,
0.32514798641204834,
0.44671428203582764,
-0.6237388849258423,
0.6673175692558289,
0.07028548419475555,
-0.2762885093688965,
0.17444618046283722,
0.6128110885620117,
0.8436800241470337,
-0.11494266241788864,
0.1284136176109314,
-0.03391006961464882,
0.20242850482463837,
-0.09280233830213547,
0.07861821353435516,
-0.05674966424703598,
-1.3359376192092896,
0.04258456081151962,
-0.5367866158485413,
-0.3917841613292694,
0.3758484125137329,
-0.4675191044807434,
0.4300326406955719,
-0.3166077136993408,
-0.10392861068248749,
-0.3224889039993286,
-0.2449367642402649,
-0.9039574265480042,
0.015233015641570091,
0.13124027848243713,
0.3816877603530884,
-0.6306658387184143,
0.8358333706855774,
0.705044686794281,
-0.33862605690956116,
-0.68358314037323,
-0.31017643213272095,
-0.17910094559192657,
-0.7800863981246948,
0.45176681876182556,
-0.07369410991668701,
-0.08656559884548187,
-0.27416756749153137,
-0.08016284555196762,
-0.8520906567573547,
1.0368120670318604,
0.2702488899230957,
-0.6120427250862122,
0.020315688103437424,
-0.034193005412817,
0.49057620763778687,
-0.9519580602645874,
0.7325876951217651,
0.3272366523742676,
0.21998648345470428,
0.08344193547964096,
-1.007001280784607,
-0.06476609408855438,
-0.32615363597869873,
0.24577097594738007,
0.11527201533317566,
-0.47913065552711487,
0.5078999400138855,
-0.14482863247394562,
0.1280590146780014,
0.10477480292320251,
0.3385063707828522,
0.3724021017551422,
0.20012806355953217,
0.6080369353294373,
0.5118952989578247,
0.5238229632377625,
0.04824777692556381,
0.9208115935325623,
-0.45400479435920715,
0.025030408054590225,
1.287052869796753,
-0.6832931637763977,
0.955810010433197,
0.2906446158885956,
-0.030001744627952576,
0.6299278736114502,
0.5642715692520142,
-0.06651001423597336,
0.39714252948760986,
-0.18159371614456177,
-0.2851262390613556,
-0.29339736700057983,
-0.46412330865859985,
-0.20384739339351654,
0.3991332948207855,
0.4179970920085907,
-0.5948672890663147,
0.16697336733341217,
0.25498440861701965,
-0.011066469363868237,
-0.04739337041974068,
-0.13531818985939026,
1.3729348182678223,
0.0732099786400795,
-0.4777410328388214,
0.47047877311706543,
-0.13483108580112457,
0.6709239482879639,
-0.581746518611908,
-0.23221595585346222,
-0.04684685915708542,
-0.040870554745197296,
-0.06940718740224838,
-0.6693315505981445,
-0.2561988830566406,
-0.20239979028701782,
-0.4318753778934479,
-0.21487733721733093,
0.8688014149665833,
-0.6674619913101196,
-0.5382181406021118,
0.30023398995399475,
0.38646695017814636,
0.20343321561813354,
0.3258591294288635,
-0.40100616216659546,
-0.10718368738889694,
0.08617643266916275,
-0.34587740898132324,
0.4167502820491791,
0.15376682579517365,
0.06288144737482071,
0.9165627360343933,
0.6017796993255615,
0.04895085096359253,
-0.35573655366897583,
0.2604200839996338,
0.7062933444976807,
-0.5099794864654541,
-0.38035789132118225,
-0.5215716361999512,
0.25418853759765625,
0.09302538633346558,
0.026078183203935623,
0.45835891366004944,
0.2600647211074829,
0.7355848550796509,
-0.05346233770251274,
0.8406370282173157,
0.23280563950538635,
0.25910818576812744,
-0.6555384993553162,
0.5026980042457581,
-0.21551986038684845,
0.9081281423568726,
-0.15207237005233765,
-1.1572879552841187,
0.16878053545951843,
0.5988836288452148,
-0.30457544326782227,
0.3331541121006012,
0.7369716167449951,
0.6509830951690674,
0.01947125233709812,
0.012055673636496067,
0.4982028901576996,
0.3138507008552551,
0.20086562633514404,
0.5783113241195679,
0.8470611572265625,
-0.2742118835449219,
0.6885533928871155,
-0.07258100062608719,
-0.13284453749656677,
-0.4229154586791992,
-0.8932358622550964,
-1.1788990497589111,
-0.8412837982177734,
-0.2834200859069824,
-0.24929098784923553,
0.16297240555286407,
1.4007349014282227,
0.8462892174720764,
-0.7201762199401855,
-0.7276841402053833,
0.02198575623333454,
0.12446315586566925,
-0.03846730291843414,
-0.20040346682071686,
0.15547999739646912,
-0.0768800750374794,
-0.7134141325950623,
0.7887280583381653,
0.3405855596065521,
0.240604966878891,
-0.22540993988513947,
-0.3620038330554962,
-0.14109861850738525,
0.14376845955848694,
0.6118792295455933,
0.053798872977495193,
-0.8405568599700928,
-0.4603329300880432,
-0.019670631736516953,
0.2006031572818756,
0.06525690853595734,
0.7173604965209961,
-0.7643760442733765,
0.7314646244049072,
0.36413371562957764,
0.3469163179397583,
0.5567537546157837,
-0.05976927652955055,
1.0721431970596313,
-0.4976741075515747,
-0.05522898584604263,
-0.09421059489250183,
0.77411288022995,
0.27222660183906555,
-0.33448782563209534,
0.14891040325164795,
-0.2575496435165405,
-0.7312759160995483,
-0.529748797416687,
0.41199585795402527,
-0.9323667883872986,
-0.11712745577096939,
1.2171765565872192,
-0.19767166674137115,
0.2598439157009125,
-0.4205325245857239,
-0.5563203692436218,
-0.07507593929767609,
-0.8364438414573669,
0.8099564909934998,
0.7077471613883972,
-0.11360819637775421,
-0.5324598550796509,
-0.11657089740037918,
0.3914805054664612,
0.19937360286712646,
-0.47339919209480286,
-0.02217179909348488,
0.3725459575653076,
0.25101619958877563,
0.06432825326919556,
0.5757180452346802,
0.23291997611522675,
0.014577469788491726,
-0.4730278253555298,
0.1311320811510086,
-0.12320981174707413,
-0.29884013533592224,
-0.33245304226875305,
0.23534351587295532,
0.5963112711906433,
0.014963185414671898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02832v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02832v1
|
Efficient Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding using Low-Rank Matrix Completion Algorithms
| 2024-06-05T00:54:03 | 2024-06-05T00:54:03 |
Firas Trabelsi, David Vilar, Mara Finkelstein, Markus Freitag
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding is a powerful decoding strategy widely used
for text generation tasks, but its quadratic computational complexity limits
its practical application. This paper presents a novel approach for
approximating MBR decoding using matrix completion techniques, focusing on the
task of machine translation. We formulate MBR decoding as a matrix completion
problem, where the utility metric scores between candidate hypotheses and
pseudo-reference translations form a low-rank matrix. First, we empirically
show that the scores matrices indeed have a low-rank structure. Then, we
exploit this by only computing a random subset of the scores and efficiently
recover the missing entries in the matrix by applying the Alternating Least
Squares (ALS) algorithm, thereby enabling a fast approximation of the MBR
decoding process. Our experimental results on machine translation tasks
demonstrate that the proposed method requires 1/16 utility metric computations
compared to vanilla MBR decoding while achieving equal translation quality
measured by COMET22 on the WMT22 dataset (en<>de and en<>ru). We also benchmark
our method against other approximation methods and we show gains in quality
when comparing to them.
|
[
-0.1488986313343048,
-0.44957825541496277,
0.6535698175430298,
0.0005834666080772877,
-0.3902338445186615,
0.31252989172935486,
0.21765369176864624,
-0.08555691689252853,
-0.065764419734478,
0.4347746968269348,
-0.43815839290618896,
-0.6362268328666687,
-0.8518608212471008,
0.1508912891149521,
-0.10600975155830383,
0.916199266910553,
0.016970202326774597,
0.07763388007879257,
0.13479135930538177,
0.23982548713684082,
-0.11936173588037491,
-0.4819961488246918,
-0.5791745185852051,
0.0629940927028656,
0.3573044538497925,
0.5744556188583374,
0.7906792759895325,
0.6094889640808105,
0.8289597034454346,
0.22446255385875702,
-0.14301550388336182,
0.25574010610580444,
-0.6264191269874573,
-0.2817252278327942,
0.2707640528678894,
-0.47717714309692383,
-0.40936151146888733,
-0.055663641542196274,
0.9553049802780151,
1.1023346185684204,
-0.16122110188007355,
0.44539761543273926,
0.2777947187423706,
1.0022764205932617,
-0.7158275842666626,
-0.05673862248659134,
-0.4838840067386627,
0.22154095768928528,
0.03463561832904816,
-0.5541427731513977,
-0.8397196531295776,
-0.5375747084617615,
-0.2609327435493469,
-0.13384906947612762,
0.1867774873971939,
0.26429080963134766,
0.47161704301834106,
0.22602629661560059,
-0.6873149871826172,
0.09061521291732788,
-0.790382444858551,
0.88360196352005,
-0.4413987398147583,
0.2517976462841034,
0.569855272769928,
0.42108583450317383,
-0.4769284725189209,
-0.08534697443246841,
-0.28238645195961,
-0.16774658858776093,
-0.14514103531837463,
0.026817508041858673,
-0.7160786390304565,
0.25760313868522644,
0.31897133588790894,
0.17484751343727112,
-0.5155460238456726,
-0.21077679097652435,
-0.648343563079834,
-0.1884632706642151,
0.425133615732193,
0.21832524240016937,
-0.016443448141217232,
-0.4924484193325043,
-0.3046211898326874,
-0.30533191561698914,
-0.717035710811615,
0.5185611248016357,
0.43035125732421875,
0.16688357293605804,
0.0025272706989198923,
0.8630548715591431,
-0.1300698071718216,
0.5414175987243652,
0.011188121512532234,
-0.3263254463672638,
0.2250373363494873,
-0.0811002179980278,
-0.30303624272346497,
0.08738148957490921,
0.6230068802833557,
0.5528272390365601,
-0.2983723282814026,
-0.3234565258026123,
-0.11975391209125519,
-0.10585763305425644,
0.40590566396713257,
-0.5292620658874512,
-0.14887860417366028,
-0.0008139812271110713,
-0.9505005478858948,
-0.21947962045669556,
-0.19562789797782898,
-0.7973584532737732,
-0.19853532314300537,
-0.008463138714432716,
0.876301646232605,
-0.4906890392303467,
0.30534476041793823,
-0.011163938790559769,
-0.15957286953926086,
0.2297350913286209,
0.08832348138093948,
-0.3801790177822113,
0.5707067847251892,
0.30306562781333923,
0.8817923665046692,
-0.0008900400134734809,
0.08481494337320328,
-1.0837699174880981,
0.11677764356136322,
-0.5297646522521973,
0.45530906319618225,
-0.1371230185031891,
-0.5174316763877869,
-0.29582372307777405,
-0.2525705397129059,
-0.048834241926670074,
-0.20746561884880066,
0.5442149043083191,
-0.4215661883354187,
-0.3731371760368347,
-0.2094898223876953,
-0.20846480131149292,
-0.1632409244775772,
-0.09041473269462585,
-0.6078501343727112,
0.8860313296318054,
0.047053512185811996,
-0.7246856689453125,
0.09443842619657516,
-0.349722683429718,
-0.6391617655754089,
-0.3028261959552765,
0.06937111914157867,
-0.4774360656738281,
0.5511525273323059,
0.22324663400650024,
0.6134715676307678,
-0.06023731455206871,
-0.23329292237758636,
-0.36233532428741455,
-0.5715078115463257,
0.4825204312801361,
-0.5425238013267517,
0.47670429944992065,
0.26241347193717957,
-0.14128442108631134,
-0.37153810262680054,
-0.8694287538528442,
0.07883083820343018,
0.024062616750597954,
-0.3333105146884918,
-0.3651446998119354,
0.2416975498199463,
0.005394160747528076,
0.12860162556171417,
0.1774800717830658,
-0.5228341817855835,
0.12492991983890533,
-0.32987064123153687,
0.18345656991004944,
0.6772518157958984,
0.15497982501983643,
0.6270545721054077,
-0.6336421370506287,
0.4716681241989136,
0.01775476522743702,
0.08302738517522812,
0.06434094160795212,
-0.6109889149665833,
-0.5928680896759033,
-0.3944748044013977,
0.2952237129211426,
0.7949422001838684,
-0.7722135782241821,
0.38821348547935486,
-0.5620206594467163,
-0.6621495485305786,
-1.0594085454940796,
-0.01931864395737648,
0.6198190450668335,
0.2428474724292755,
0.6403871774673462,
-0.2373942732810974,
-0.6140660047531128,
-1.152345061302185,
-0.19592949748039246,
-0.22569073736667633,
-0.10290244966745377,
-0.0017033739713951945,
0.2723676562309265,
-0.19392220675945282,
0.7433630228042603,
-0.6502652764320374,
-0.22293820977210999,
-0.30387547612190247,
0.23390129208564758,
0.47570082545280457,
0.7726929783821106,
0.4191095530986786,
-0.39549964666366577,
-0.5076355934143066,
-0.1278725266456604,
-0.2914521396160126,
0.24272342026233673,
-0.14689111709594727,
-0.21443623304367065,
0.24672575294971466,
0.1660066395998001,
-0.40067416429519653,
0.5662996768951416,
0.598956823348999,
0.12668953835964203,
0.12176205962896347,
-0.5367208123207092,
0.5227022767066956,
-1.0514378547668457,
0.36506927013397217,
0.05183517932891846,
-0.49907347559928894,
-0.7476563453674316,
-0.24755288660526276,
-0.05596050247550011,
-0.09040786325931549,
-0.12527887523174286,
-0.009255009703338146,
-0.4500647485256195,
-0.13054867088794708,
-0.32512274384498596,
-0.1767747402191162,
-0.18137690424919128,
0.43441590666770935,
-0.21663926541805267,
0.6664857864379883,
0.06361132115125656,
-0.5084128379821777,
-0.41060715913772583,
0.3919380307197571,
-0.3519352972507477,
0.22206221520900726,
-0.25464576482772827,
0.0865630954504013,
-0.5545955896377563,
0.11341457068920135,
-1.357729434967041,
0.20486781001091003,
0.4330361485481262,
-0.5930944681167603,
0.3768312931060791,
-0.627284049987793,
-0.4992983043193817,
-0.37241607904434204,
-0.2584567964076996,
0.23442022502422333,
0.9747851490974426,
-0.38578715920448303,
0.4189317226409912,
0.6175540685653687,
-0.46493658423423767,
-0.8220027089118958,
-0.8240801692008972,
0.19556501507759094,
-0.0015216764295473695,
-0.13418422639369965,
0.2725178599357605,
-0.3521072566509247,
0.07589148730039597,
-0.12958340346813202,
-0.3034210205078125,
-0.08061401546001434,
0.18459467589855194,
0.27347537875175476,
0.23925980925559998,
0.0028280047699809074,
-0.6163302659988403,
0.6763152480125427,
-0.4347406029701233,
-0.027324168011546135,
-0.10630270838737488,
-0.002351695206016302,
-0.03914794325828552,
-0.2201860249042511,
-0.38591334223747253,
0.8093284368515015,
0.4718153178691864,
0.27755191922187805,
0.6782481074333191,
0.4424865245819092,
-0.576848030090332,
-0.10729962587356567,
-0.609396755695343,
-0.06100840121507645,
-0.4704052209854126,
0.07872128486633301,
-0.7204424142837524,
-0.742268979549408,
0.3241448402404785,
0.11489124596118927,
-0.13089501857757568,
0.3908027112483978,
0.3114461898803711,
-0.5243412256240845,
1.5040229558944702,
0.9213924407958984,
-0.2659343183040619,
0.14834105968475342,
-0.25459742546081543,
0.4246780574321747,
-0.6854000687599182,
-0.19891712069511414,
-0.559806227684021,
-0.49467387795448303,
-0.6592712998390198,
-0.4717884659767151,
0.6565160751342773,
0.1524646133184433,
0.19216974079608917,
0.4715917706489563,
-0.22690396010875702,
0.39811190962791443,
0.7670435905456543,
0.35608333349227905,
0.5157749652862549,
0.47470715641975403,
-0.3798929750919342,
-0.32539480924606323,
-0.8183487057685852,
-0.5436199903488159,
1.1228090524673462,
0.35860592126846313,
0.6031808257102966,
0.23825985193252563,
0.9410188794136047,
0.5496922731399536,
0.3261704742908478,
-0.6594468355178833,
0.41930443048477173,
-0.1994829922914505,
-0.2520941495895386,
-0.00041001191129907966,
-0.9944698214530945,
-0.9019214510917664,
0.36803215742111206,
-0.4483318626880646,
-0.7223392724990845,
0.273126482963562,
0.22114048898220062,
-0.5368943810462952,
0.2007361650466919,
-0.3853558599948883,
0.7528470158576965,
0.19573132693767548,
0.03904407098889351,
-0.32810884714126587,
-0.8917394280433655,
0.3504098951816559,
0.060650553554296494,
0.5292784571647644,
0.05309220775961876,
-0.06942608207464218,
0.7317583560943604,
-0.2196245789527893,
0.683900773525238,
-0.25679218769073486,
0.09272559732198715,
0.01738404855132103,
0.31629708409309387,
0.5983054637908936,
-0.09793293476104736,
-0.03271417319774628,
0.019243739545345306,
0.3930392265319824,
-0.6966467499732971,
-0.22816649079322815,
0.2718242406845093,
-0.7507731318473816,
-0.17565231025218964,
-0.5668814182281494,
-0.3490791320800781,
-0.25988179445266724,
0.15351055562496185,
0.5061237215995789,
0.030985316261649132,
-0.3082329332828522,
0.008065578527748585,
0.5085773468017578,
0.03344941884279251,
0.2875305712223053,
0.46685120463371277,
0.22553233802318573,
-0.8563225865364075,
0.8731445074081421,
0.03950342908501625,
0.02003880962729454,
0.8223292827606201,
-0.22803851962089539,
-0.09411817789077759,
-0.9093066453933716,
-0.47738105058670044,
0.10954462736845016,
-0.6722728610038757,
-0.5359092354774475,
-0.8158189654350281,
-0.14124128222465515,
-0.03710382059216499,
-0.3005709946155548,
-0.31107017397880554,
-0.4368518888950348,
0.17544880509376526,
-0.005951063707470894,
0.0072152623906731606,
0.4612848162651062,
-0.37668925523757935,
0.6284934282302856,
-1.3971304893493652,
0.4635505676269531,
-0.13885679841041565,
0.08807529509067535,
-0.1876533329486847,
-0.4127715826034546,
-0.5629701018333435,
0.16260993480682373,
-0.14426027238368988,
-1.1445902585983276,
0.4343916177749634,
-0.04381076991558075,
0.7039216756820679,
0.21743275225162506,
0.2705630660057068,
0.6693491339683533,
-0.8210325837135315,
0.28199267387390137,
0.29551005363464355,
-1.0318140983581543,
0.42652592062950134,
-0.1668708175420761,
-0.05768856406211853,
1.0156068801879883,
0.44729167222976685,
-0.39675870537757874,
-0.3235000967979431,
-0.4430426061153412,
-0.6522408127784729,
0.6401194930076599,
0.640600323677063,
-0.1374521106481552,
-0.037918251007795334,
0.29911938309669495,
0.021088022738695145,
0.20404914021492004,
-0.5236693024635315,
-0.42032182216644287,
0.2692639231681824,
-0.4459407925605774,
-0.4970429539680481,
-0.35798850655555725,
0.031155649572610855,
-0.0733528807759285,
0.777299702167511,
-0.04814036563038826,
0.6638692617416382,
0.14603225886821747,
-0.5659435391426086,
-0.46954333782196045,
0.4704034626483917,
0.326774001121521,
0.05116523057222366,
-0.6337679624557495,
0.23983412981033325,
0.2955246567726135,
-0.5035375952720642,
0.4503704309463501,
0.4430742859840393,
-0.23631587624549866,
0.11744479835033417,
-0.11159350723028183,
0.3715580403804779,
0.38865289092063904,
-0.5218132138252258,
0.7018903493881226,
-0.17233900725841522,
-0.027453573420643806,
0.018612077459692955,
-0.2704642117023468,
-0.4483000934123993,
0.21810369193553925,
0.7766691446304321,
0.6125047206878662,
0.6147083640098572,
-0.18023499846458435,
0.27122098207473755,
0.4136756360530853,
-0.47360846400260925,
-0.12508037686347961,
0.5656476616859436,
-0.17269344627857208,
0.262262761592865,
0.3639141917228699,
-0.43619945645332336,
-0.2625630795955658,
0.34323781728744507,
0.5096637010574341,
0.6987659335136414,
-0.17132289707660675,
0.1357688158750534,
0.43713024258613586,
0.9440918564796448,
-0.20060428977012634,
0.6008376479148865,
0.05712909623980522,
-0.2817472815513611,
-0.7709690928459167,
-0.7449716329574585,
-0.519070029258728,
-0.18348413705825806,
-0.6565777659416199,
-0.040653079748153687,
-0.3546818792819977,
-0.3818768858909607,
-0.3314422070980072,
0.11495315283536911,
-0.502916157245636,
0.04746672883629799,
0.2047993540763855,
0.7334554195404053,
-0.7819229960441589,
0.6231712698936462,
0.5486133694648743,
-0.15976399183273315,
-0.30696094036102295,
-0.1655583381652832,
-0.02766057476401329,
-0.41891828179359436,
0.22201448678970337,
0.1423366516828537,
-0.28800448775291443,
0.3809031844139099,
-0.034418683499097824,
-1.0326980352401733,
0.9000719785690308,
0.48844239115715027,
-0.37732917070388794,
-0.11567122489213943,
0.24774104356765747,
0.0775991901755333,
-0.07547365128993988,
-0.05083436146378517,
0.5456010103225708,
0.39549314975738525,
-0.2120835930109024,
-0.6040050387382507,
0.27660831809043884,
-0.3521065413951874,
0.14230825006961823,
0.34711387753486633,
-0.035527125000953674,
0.24037125706672668,
-0.4801538288593292,
-0.16658343374729156,
0.47676655650138855,
0.6802074909210205,
0.2383367270231247,
0.32800450921058655,
0.3034418523311615,
0.38596853613853455,
0.6036461591720581,
0.25945404171943665,
0.9314404726028442,
-0.28224143385887146,
0.35187673568725586,
0.6110437512397766,
0.2644982635974884,
1.146616816520691,
0.35341623425483704,
-0.4001237154006958,
0.19375121593475342,
0.5975673198699951,
0.023781975731253624,
0.7959652543067932,
0.20132286846637726,
0.03461531549692154,
-0.2245083451271057,
0.35871490836143494,
-0.23379459977149963,
0.1298549473285675,
0.328006386756897,
-0.4081578850746155,
-0.12365900725126266,
0.24367645382881165,
-0.018960746005177498,
-0.019683215767145157,
-0.44051527976989746,
0.6174941658973694,
0.34637847542762756,
-0.5022523403167725,
0.5610018372535706,
0.5474746227264404,
0.432804137468338,
-0.3727642595767975,
0.07462900131940842,
-0.0530398003757,
0.32329612970352173,
0.017898641526699066,
-0.44376012682914734,
0.38436004519462585,
0.010036560706794262,
-0.46314728260040283,
-0.23179250955581665,
0.5975249409675598,
-0.4676153361797333,
-0.7410345673561096,
0.0613756999373436,
0.4804055988788605,
0.21886922419071198,
-0.08557964116334915,
-0.31175053119659424,
-0.13662466406822205,
-0.23830759525299072,
-0.053166311234235764,
0.47316017746925354,
-0.03218179941177368,
0.3410860002040863,
0.5511255264282227,
0.7107445001602173,
-0.07475362718105316,
0.24263186752796173,
-0.6948572993278503,
0.44480806589126587,
-0.5895791053771973,
-0.5128224492073059,
-0.855092465877533,
0.5294053554534912,
0.30042800307273865,
0.19420979917049408,
0.5863526463508606,
0.8676143884658813,
0.45940345525741577,
-0.4019443094730377,
0.936319887638092,
0.20275095105171204,
0.31716689467430115,
-0.6400494575500488,
0.8502963781356812,
-0.3867453932762146,
-0.012765257619321346,
-0.43958523869514465,
-0.9166596531867981,
-0.4035830795764923,
0.8662416934967041,
-0.18914933502674103,
-0.2835675776004791,
0.7052097916603088,
0.5903174877166748,
-0.23411257565021515,
-0.3170044422149658,
0.44373244047164917,
0.14580264687538147,
-0.10263355076313019,
0.876588761806488,
0.560397207736969,
-0.8365620374679565,
0.90936678647995,
-0.3301480710506439,
-0.48479145765304565,
-0.4831816852092743,
-0.7339721322059631,
-0.831530749797821,
-0.47371476888656616,
-0.26597854495048523,
-0.6134779453277588,
0.07021135091781616,
1.0540046691894531,
0.44488397240638733,
-0.6327622532844543,
-0.1902984231710434,
0.2212059199810028,
0.2119857370853424,
-0.5992709994316101,
-0.10630123317241669,
0.3906805217266083,
-0.25971177220344543,
-0.533433735370636,
0.707204282283783,
0.3717867136001587,
0.20920264720916748,
0.26499488949775696,
-0.15323707461357117,
-0.001797664794139564,
0.24650010466575623,
0.6799944639205933,
0.13050860166549683,
-0.2484464943408966,
-0.04836468771100044,
0.04036806523799896,
-0.47703829407691956,
0.08286333829164505,
0.6523035764694214,
-0.653648316860199,
0.11078257858753204,
0.5914344191551208,
0.879693329334259,
0.7184495329856873,
-0.16402338445186615,
0.5058927536010742,
-0.7378402948379517,
-0.20159828662872314,
0.05709360912442207,
0.4273551404476166,
0.15172167122364044,
-0.37727001309394836,
0.26236069202423096,
0.20268066227436066,
-0.22811514139175415,
-0.894456148147583,
0.1597035527229309,
-1.4184435606002808,
-0.055224157869815826,
0.7002303600311279,
0.04725922644138336,
-0.4057613015174866,
-0.01426920760422945,
-0.188332661986351,
0.19798992574214935,
-0.4077361524105072,
0.8194704651832581,
0.3766932785511017,
0.17373575270175934,
-0.12976641952991486,
-0.7524965405464172,
0.47488173842430115,
0.33128103613853455,
-0.3028840720653534,
-0.23682846128940582,
0.4655895531177521,
0.2557049095630646,
0.04812125489115715,
0.9185023903846741,
-0.06052162125706673,
0.4755142033100128,
-0.05334964394569397,
-0.04054185003042221,
0.08192402124404907,
-0.33774274587631226,
-0.32336699962615967,
0.33685794472694397,
0.13867098093032837,
-0.19465874135494232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02830v1
|
Too Big to Fail: Larger Language Models are Disproportionately Resilient to Induction of Dementia-Related Linguistic Anomalies
| 2024-06-05T00:31:50 | 2024-06-05T00:31:50 |
Changye Li, Zhecheng Sheng, Trevor Cohen, Serguei Pakhomov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As artificial neural networks grow in complexity, understanding their inner
workings becomes increasingly challenging, which is particularly important in
healthcare applications. The intrinsic evaluation metrics of autoregressive
neural language models (NLMs), perplexity (PPL), can reflect how "surprised" an
NLM model is at novel input. PPL has been widely used to understand the
behavior of NLMs. Previous findings show that changes in PPL when masking
attention layers in pre-trained transformer-based NLMs reflect linguistic
anomalies associated with Alzheimer's disease dementia. Building upon this, we
explore a novel bidirectional attention head ablation method that exhibits
properties attributed to the concepts of cognitive and brain reserve in human
brain studies, which postulate that people with more neurons in the brain and
more efficient processing are more resilient to neurodegeneration. Our results
show that larger GPT-2 models require a disproportionately larger share of
attention heads to be masked/ablated to display degradation of similar
magnitude to masking in smaller models. These results suggest that the
attention mechanism in transformer models may present an analogue to the
notions of cognitive and brain reserve and could potentially be used to model
certain aspects of the progression of neurodegenerative disorders and aging.
|
[
-0.4405815899372101,
-0.5959994196891785,
0.5594196319580078,
0.00660589849576354,
0.0018463458400219679,
-0.2813899517059326,
-0.227911576628685,
-0.2021702378988266,
0.0405295304954052,
0.5340116620063782,
-0.822485089302063,
-0.015335315838456154,
-0.8482875227928162,
0.09325938671827316,
-0.35952749848365784,
0.9854293465614319,
0.13852830231189728,
-0.11670856922864914,
-0.05616156384348869,
-0.07082486897706985,
-0.3389865458011627,
-0.5094283819198608,
-0.8934967517852783,
-0.6626119613647461,
0.582487165927887,
0.12968114018440247,
0.9218311309814453,
0.6190552711486816,
0.7287111878395081,
0.2649582028388977,
-0.19304907321929932,
-0.18438871204853058,
-0.23196640610694885,
-0.201969712972641,
-0.19897407293319702,
-0.4074515104293823,
-0.6002113223075867,
-0.05051873251795769,
0.5064167380332947,
0.9743630886077881,
-0.17645244300365448,
-0.1322135478258133,
-0.04201182723045349,
0.9415454864501953,
-0.2618754804134369,
-0.01973886229097843,
-0.6150327920913696,
0.17957836389541626,
-0.08408477902412415,
0.15480861067771912,
-0.25714167952537537,
-0.14320699870586395,
0.4862542748451233,
-0.13900531828403473,
0.2135380208492279,
-0.07478471100330353,
0.7680914402008057,
0.820327639579773,
-0.15577289462089539,
-0.3154474198818207,
-0.7732951641082764,
0.7625421285629272,
-0.687843918800354,
0.15310674905776978,
0.5108795166015625,
0.2899143397808075,
0.08495038002729416,
-0.5566688776016235,
-0.691874623298645,
-0.47252771258354187,
-0.26164156198501587,
0.0420745387673378,
-0.4051654636859894,
0.15334458649158478,
0.37566933035850525,
0.20989909768104553,
-0.7069435715675354,
0.08596448600292206,
-0.3366856873035431,
-0.04693228006362915,
0.1764613687992096,
0.28107863664627075,
0.47218841314315796,
-0.1769825667142868,
-0.34228575229644775,
0.016030896455049515,
-0.5227740406990051,
-0.3012144863605499,
0.276228666305542,
-0.02115689218044281,
0.005882218014448881,
0.47056958079338074,
0.03953981772065163,
0.5748961567878723,
0.24994175136089325,
0.16894413530826569,
0.0441630594432354,
-0.0550992488861084,
-0.19494721293449402,
0.20981049537658691,
0.46613791584968567,
0.20017161965370178,
0.32073748111724854,
-0.3113018572330475,
0.056569814682006836,
0.22840797901153564,
0.44868576526641846,
-0.5407419800758362,
-0.595767080783844,
0.5114186406135559,
-0.3539275527000427,
-0.0045002177357673645,
-0.1861756294965744,
-0.49065303802490234,
-0.11130796372890472,
-0.015749935060739517,
0.4504747688770294,
-0.46290597319602966,
-0.324027419090271,
0.3730699419975281,
-0.04772547632455826,
0.16090910136699677,
-0.003988540731370449,
-0.8185098171234131,
-0.031325504183769226,
0.49439382553100586,
0.7506731748580933,
-0.3303496837615967,
-0.4560585618019104,
-0.0518609844148159,
0.18781226873397827,
-0.20959614217281342,
0.7797765731811523,
-0.3668288290500641,
-0.10542478412389755,
-0.18024460971355438,
0.0727071762084961,
-0.211439311504364,
-0.6229793429374695,
0.44978487491607666,
-0.6339438557624817,
0.04763399064540863,
-0.22406528890132904,
-0.02500501647591591,
-0.2774640917778015,
0.11968345940113068,
-0.8146439790725708,
0.42612937092781067,
0.3581584393978119,
-0.7220093011856079,
0.03348531201481819,
-0.7729347348213196,
-0.5080558657646179,
0.10501933842897415,
0.08645065128803253,
-0.6710168123245239,
0.30121856927871704,
-0.10543552041053772,
0.11120246350765228,
-0.37003159523010254,
0.312164843082428,
-0.1884210854768753,
-0.00438208831474185,
0.5231996774673462,
-0.7096560597419739,
0.807074785232544,
-0.016142508015036583,
-0.5118855834007263,
0.07461296021938324,
-0.5014316439628601,
-0.17076510190963745,
0.28135737776756287,
-0.23611126840114594,
-0.26879507303237915,
-0.19581779837608337,
-0.16508156061172485,
0.5246493220329285,
0.29816004633903503,
-0.3052786886692047,
-0.2285091131925583,
-0.5312805771827698,
0.7577661275863647,
0.5617417097091675,
-0.0805564597249031,
0.33954113721847534,
-0.5154139399528503,
0.32383468747138977,
0.2374095618724823,
0.16417261958122253,
-0.13147006928920746,
-0.20282064378261566,
-0.7753349542617798,
-0.174848273396492,
0.10916545242071152,
0.5798579454421997,
-0.5280278921127319,
0.7299113869667053,
-0.31837597489356995,
-0.31837141513824463,
-0.45991790294647217,
-0.1763456016778946,
0.4697408974170685,
0.6876968741416931,
0.39265385270118713,
-0.5417070388793945,
-0.304015576839447,
-1.2066422700881958,
-0.044433239847421646,
-0.1862069070339203,
-0.366897851228714,
0.3359961211681366,
0.3456566631793976,
-0.6259599328041077,
0.7865944504737854,
-0.3823734521865845,
-0.5876500010490417,
0.06668508052825928,
0.08261183649301529,
0.001644238829612732,
0.514645516872406,
0.14568816125392914,
-0.706157922744751,
0.0790727362036705,
-0.08493498712778091,
-0.7166150212287903,
0.017467383295297623,
0.03420456498861313,
0.08315569907426834,
0.2905734181404114,
0.3958524763584137,
-0.8209847211837769,
0.2994445860385895,
0.565898597240448,
-0.23840321600437164,
0.5725224018096924,
-0.34711387753486633,
-0.1678057461977005,
-0.5632991790771484,
0.2049262374639511,
-0.09019918739795685,
0.19417375326156616,
-0.6250301599502563,
-0.275423526763916,
-0.022190824151039124,
-0.1543606072664261,
-0.16694524884223938,
0.23483483493328094,
-0.4493544101715088,
-0.006154284812510014,
-0.46616843342781067,
-0.13859881460666656,
-0.035430509597063065,
0.34170570969581604,
0.0737520158290863,
0.47162532806396484,
0.5537248253822327,
-0.39008480310440063,
0.235340416431427,
0.3639175295829773,
0.04847625270485878,
0.5861721038818359,
-0.8452027440071106,
0.36750394105911255,
-0.43147581815719604,
0.22418704628944397,
-1.3428114652633667,
-0.39772841334342957,
-0.10297830402851105,
-0.5088933706283569,
0.4456028938293457,
0.09665610641241074,
-0.02018560655415058,
-0.6432384252548218,
-0.108432836830616,
0.5921560525894165,
0.4374707341194153,
-0.3960103690624237,
0.7788073420524597,
0.426130473613739,
-0.2347085177898407,
-0.4431596100330353,
-1.1391985416412354,
0.25403276085853577,
-0.4141838550567627,
-0.6744939088821411,
0.31640490889549255,
-0.10556299239397049,
-0.28654053807258606,
0.20373283326625824,
-0.19669005274772644,
0.0017209489597007632,
0.12172472476959229,
0.11121135950088501,
0.23903371393680573,
-0.2504521608352661,
0.06834173202514648,
-0.20464003086090088,
-0.3943968713283539,
0.3266642987728119,
-0.3375253677368164,
0.6780135035514832,
-0.13767346739768982,
-0.4658481478691101,
-0.643742024898529,
0.5087324976921082,
0.882722795009613,
-0.15936429798603058,
0.5559694170951843,
0.2741781771183014,
-0.5492227077484131,
0.014081565663218498,
-0.6874676942825317,
-0.5985294580459595,
-0.46077948808670044,
0.6352397799491882,
-0.23762209713459015,
-0.8122118711471558,
0.6086298227310181,
-0.0029339741449803114,
-0.12267721444368362,
0.4557756185531616,
0.701530933380127,
0.15081900358200073,
0.9969273209571838,
0.6462870240211487,
-0.06270182877779007,
0.2540511190891266,
-0.0729043111205101,
0.3174264132976532,
-1.1082028150558472,
-0.12183181196451187,
-0.33830103278160095,
-0.20960895717144012,
-0.3100477159023285,
-0.3880206048488617,
0.40033629536628723,
-0.3117459714412689,
-0.31910407543182373,
0.14636901021003723,
-0.7402674555778503,
0.32759830355644226,
0.3239413797855377,
0.10107821971178055,
0.15976135432720184,
-0.04354925826191902,
0.26626965403556824,
-0.10110020637512207,
-0.5943767428398132,
-0.48155078291893005,
0.8716322779655457,
0.33235958218574524,
0.6227818131446838,
0.005790513474494219,
0.17975401878356934,
0.18837077915668488,
0.36732903122901917,
-0.7462762594223022,
0.3216310739517212,
-0.32841211557388306,
-0.5883368253707886,
-0.6332290768623352,
-0.29149776697158813,
-0.9673365950584412,
-0.10112404078245163,
0.33243489265441895,
-0.5933937430381775,
0.2593129575252533,
0.24536743760108948,
-0.6431804895401001,
0.10872828960418701,
-0.6146121025085449,
0.834352433681488,
-0.2760045826435089,
-0.19622915983200073,
-0.10983633249998093,
-0.865665853023529,
0.40749040246009827,
-0.2543851435184479,
-0.02279587648808956,
-0.022106623277068138,
-0.048122748732566833,
0.726848304271698,
-0.03080000728368759,
0.7026431560516357,
0.0031986269168555737,
-0.164682537317276,
0.05945241078734398,
0.11812552809715271,
0.5045211315155029,
-0.0011535773519426584,
0.0033725115936249495,
0.33137276768684387,
-0.629547119140625,
-0.38816365599632263,
-0.44326430559158325,
0.8316769003868103,
-0.7070826888084412,
-0.8522977232933044,
-0.45030906796455383,
-0.8111775517463684,
-0.3179015517234802,
0.08955629169940948,
0.34345027804374695,
0.20016585290431976,
0.1844308227300644,
-0.054839491844177246,
0.9468092322349548,
-0.11916276067495346,
0.4957728981971741,
0.4839140772819519,
0.3628002405166626,
-0.3057674765586853,
0.7106220722198486,
0.28483298420906067,
0.4475767910480499,
0.024510027840733528,
0.10990074276924133,
-0.14380276203155518,
-0.7453108429908752,
-0.12653490900993347,
0.5389115214347839,
-0.45059141516685486,
0.01181113999336958,
-0.8017162680625916,
-0.34861278533935547,
-0.12887047231197357,
-0.13907022774219513,
-0.536816418170929,
-0.30827754735946655,
-0.09599418193101883,
-0.0411551408469677,
0.22150227427482605,
0.5561641454696655,
-0.08799563348293304,
0.27794086933135986,
-0.49375057220458984,
0.2614823281764984,
0.6522665023803711,
0.24594411253929138,
0.21220549941062927,
-0.7453896999359131,
0.0067894007079303265,
0.022245952859520912,
-0.13546517491340637,
-0.75166916847229,
0.4060401916503906,
-0.0012424832675606012,
0.48648470640182495,
0.37137338519096375,
-0.0669017881155014,
0.43251100182533264,
-0.5755237936973572,
0.6082555651664734,
0.31849178671836853,
-0.6266486644744873,
0.4020254611968994,
-0.3482004702091217,
0.5587437748908997,
0.4234972298145294,
0.44789087772369385,
-0.4751385748386383,
-0.21982711553573608,
-0.8154670000076294,
-1.2239983081817627,
0.7298424243927002,
0.00704390462487936,
0.08735766261816025,
-0.1573445051908493,
0.4020759165287018,
0.027244364842772484,
-0.001996732084080577,
-0.5923439264297485,
-0.4961394667625427,
-0.06540121138095856,
-0.029085444286465645,
-0.21938347816467285,
-0.4423835277557373,
-0.3656791150569916,
0.1838291734457016,
0.47199568152427673,
-0.09357472509145737,
0.6118704676628113,
0.4643489420413971,
-0.016642244532704353,
-0.2741803228855133,
-0.06237233802676201,
0.7555601000785828,
0.626994788646698,
-0.20039159059524536,
0.36158064007759094,
0.167072132229805,
-0.5219777226448059,
0.08569736033678055,
0.1758100986480713,
-0.09414449334144592,
-0.1802336722612381,
0.17300830781459808,
0.7542405128479004,
-0.11181468516588211,
-0.5761032700538635,
0.25551944971084595,
-0.03778121620416641,
-0.032286543399095535,
-0.4889932870864868,
-0.21694275736808777,
0.38854917883872986,
0.2495487779378891,
0.6723156571388245,
0.31485217809677124,
0.1180448904633522,
-0.4956148862838745,
0.5640165209770203,
0.6111964583396912,
-0.643480122089386,
-0.44710785150527954,
0.8330352306365967,
-0.04650241881608963,
-0.5550163388252258,
0.7214386463165283,
0.0687047615647316,
-0.6096903085708618,
0.7683297395706177,
0.5502737760543823,
1.1213570833206177,
-0.4766906201839447,
-0.13514994084835052,
0.061897892504930496,
0.5607069730758667,
-0.23301316797733307,
-0.358889102935791,
0.2925107181072235,
-0.5845475792884827,
-0.4492338001728058,
-0.49091193079948425,
-0.23080219328403473,
0.4536205232143402,
-0.6390617489814758,
-0.08760151267051697,
-0.3250092566013336,
-0.38463330268859863,
0.22643683850765228,
-0.4141440689563751,
-0.4740861654281616,
0.25820568203926086,
0.18972274661064148,
0.42489928007125854,
-1.0085159540176392,
0.7648336291313171,
0.6551241278648376,
-0.15002553164958954,
-0.4885199964046478,
0.48415878415107727,
-0.11683434993028641,
-0.6512499451637268,
0.6957616806030273,
0.13134020566940308,
-0.10178195685148239,
0.0751093253493309,
-0.06395234912633896,
-0.9949467182159424,
0.7481216788291931,
0.4276908338069916,
-0.3849990963935852,
-0.28020936250686646,
0.057937394827604294,
0.434553861618042,
-0.28907495737075806,
0.2711823582649231,
0.9309156537055969,
0.49164435267448425,
0.007778020575642586,
-1.0413556098937988,
0.2705654501914978,
0.033901654183864594,
0.13240325450897217,
0.12939663231372833,
-0.7890994548797607,
1.0045360326766968,
-0.3816371560096741,
-0.12046493589878082,
-0.3622939884662628,
0.4707851707935333,
0.1650218665599823,
0.23540091514587402,
0.38169005513191223,
0.7160193920135498,
0.5501699447631836,
-0.09017080813646317,
1.0501357316970825,
-0.21674804389476776,
0.237160786986351,
0.6704064607620239,
-0.24764256179332733,
0.4382835924625397,
0.5212116241455078,
-0.17794235050678253,
0.20909887552261353,
0.12479686737060547,
0.23972615599632263,
0.6190312504768372,
0.28873777389526367,
-0.12634174525737762,
-0.15741023421287537,
0.0537734292447567,
-0.23238788545131683,
0.28462478518486023,
0.5064682364463806,
-0.2428310364484787,
-0.2972113788127899,
0.327144056558609,
0.15151315927505493,
0.08425161987543106,
-0.18306736648082733,
0.7323246598243713,
0.22016870975494385,
-0.8094967007637024,
0.8238709568977356,
-0.18225562572479248,
0.7497924566268921,
-0.5326724052429199,
0.21240079402923584,
-0.19345539808273315,
0.3938046991825104,
-0.10340077430009842,
-0.42508962750434875,
0.7632563710212708,
-0.4136364459991455,
-0.4912651479244232,
0.10737117379903793,
0.6130960583686829,
-0.3588753640651703,
-0.322369784116745,
0.4835071563720703,
0.20123575627803802,
0.12597203254699707,
-0.2070234715938568,
-0.6336456537246704,
0.07013992965221405,
0.07150106877088547,
-0.4478905498981476,
0.5020368695259094,
0.3917175531387329,
-0.06351091712713242,
0.7572954893112183,
0.4301225244998932,
0.06695711612701416,
0.05441673472523689,
-0.1535157412290573,
0.7546281814575195,
-0.581792950630188,
-0.2542015612125397,
-1.1186835765838623,
0.25683659315109253,
0.04634791985154152,
-0.22019293904304504,
0.6555920839309692,
0.3533872961997986,
0.4620358347892761,
-0.14934615790843964,
0.8317713141441345,
0.11390336602926254,
0.42475369572639465,
-0.2645381987094879,
0.8239209651947021,
-0.24542373418807983,
0.14299896359443665,
0.049634434282779694,
-0.78581303358078,
-0.444588303565979,
0.6734349131584167,
-0.5653223395347595,
0.3109428882598877,
0.9287564754486084,
0.7953850626945496,
0.1729293167591095,
-0.1789153516292572,
0.40608006715774536,
0.44032183289527893,
0.11843889951705933,
1.009178876876831,
0.5349371433258057,
-0.2860313355922699,
0.49646317958831787,
-0.25287050008773804,
-0.4068009853363037,
-0.33562108874320984,
-0.6875185370445251,
-0.8325849175453186,
-0.6729876399040222,
-0.642048180103302,
-0.48449447751045227,
0.2649502456188202,
0.4550130069255829,
0.5341921448707581,
-0.7179360389709473,
0.09246988594532013,
-0.2093796283006668,
-0.04569685831665993,
-0.3352678120136261,
-0.17155185341835022,
0.763805627822876,
-0.186991885304451,
-0.6721503734588623,
0.16037043929100037,
0.469093918800354,
0.22329401969909668,
-0.4870748221874237,
0.30720803141593933,
-0.04043298959732056,
0.1435764729976654,
0.36446741223335266,
0.36486294865608215,
-0.8493541479110718,
-0.3614700138568878,
-0.14405947923660278,
-0.19669504463672638,
0.06944584101438522,
0.5227839946746826,
-0.6276618838310242,
0.05162951722741127,
0.23517544567584991,
0.5816895961761475,
0.25326722860336304,
0.06414853036403656,
0.35317304730415344,
-0.37202635407447815,
0.10817735642194748,
0.5669822692871094,
0.11972321569919586,
0.5440260171890259,
-0.6528642177581787,
0.26148808002471924,
0.07858292013406754,
-0.7245463132858276,
-0.8698505759239197,
0.3825635313987732,
-0.9970486760139465,
-0.28436580300331116,
1.0766793489456177,
-0.0546581856906414,
-0.5374510288238525,
-0.3524594008922577,
-0.1012159138917923,
0.1470969319343567,
-0.15940146148204803,
1.219190239906311,
0.7349483966827393,
-0.17198863625526428,
-0.15390558540821075,
-0.6478782296180725,
0.6564474105834961,
0.7368702292442322,
-0.4049130082130432,
0.5025072693824768,
0.2301323115825653,
0.3160805106163025,
0.5175679922103882,
0.3256246745586395,
-0.31156665086746216,
0.5490606427192688,
0.014760911464691162,
0.08180675655603409,
-0.06765563786029816,
-0.20981833338737488,
-0.7619263529777527,
0.35133612155914307,
0.11709069460630417,
-0.06014515459537506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02826v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02826v1
|
Exploring Robustness in Doctor-Patient Conversation Summarization: An Analysis of Out-of-Domain SOAP Notes
| 2024-06-05T00:11:20 | 2024-06-05T00:11:20 |
Yu-Wen Chen, Julia Hirschberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Summarizing medical conversations poses unique challenges due to the
specialized domain and the difficulty of collecting in-domain training data. In
this study, we investigate the performance of state-of-the-art doctor-patient
conversation generative summarization models on the out-of-domain data. We
divide the summarization model of doctor-patient conversation into two
configurations: (1) a general model, without specifying subjective (S),
objective (O), and assessment (A) and plan (P) notes; (2) a SOAP-oriented model
that generates a summary with SOAP sections. We analyzed the limitations and
strengths of the fine-tuning language model-based methods and GPTs on both
configurations. We also conducted a Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count analysis
to compare the SOAP notes from different datasets. The results exhibit a strong
correlation for reference notes across different datasets, indicating that
format mismatch (i.e., discrepancies in word distribution) is not the main
cause of performance decline on out-of-domain data. Lastly, a detailed analysis
of SOAP notes is included to provide insights into missing information and
hallucinations introduced by the models.
|
[
-0.34447231888771057,
-0.9156969785690308,
0.7202647924423218,
-0.1693500429391861,
-0.5929497480392456,
0.030464785173535347,
-0.15747658908367157,
-0.4900924861431122,
0.08761652559041977,
0.6203172206878662,
-0.268844336271286,
-0.6261730194091797,
-0.8321658372879028,
0.17348650097846985,
-0.24604293704032898,
1.3992366790771484,
0.02468225732445717,
0.3489800691604614,
-0.5131635665893555,
-0.36960262060165405,
-0.4128704369068146,
-0.5979688167572021,
-0.5643917322158813,
-0.1443633884191513,
-0.16595253348350525,
0.1315380036830902,
0.9397932887077332,
0.4553830623626709,
0.7309085130691528,
0.21387100219726562,
-0.2740996778011322,
0.6094308495521545,
-0.5887570381164551,
0.2709025740623474,
-0.11311265081167221,
-0.2379530668258667,
-0.9339220523834229,
-0.1802145391702652,
0.39144906401634216,
1.039538025856018,
-0.2534154951572418,
0.03031971864402294,
0.07789060473442078,
0.4738747179508209,
-0.2856578528881073,
0.28454872965812683,
-0.42433178424835205,
-0.22773489356040955,
-0.06615196913480759,
-0.3474481403827667,
-0.30415916442871094,
-0.1917848140001297,
0.5537355542182922,
-0.3400404751300812,
0.5405740141868591,
-0.08996438980102539,
0.6954599022865295,
0.13515545427799225,
-0.5187845230102539,
-0.652613639831543,
-0.7348210215568542,
0.4299480617046356,
-1.268083930015564,
0.04863855242729187,
0.5918315649032593,
0.1991111785173416,
-0.08622612059116364,
-0.7778105139732361,
-0.10070322453975677,
-0.14342503249645233,
-0.2181483805179596,
0.3579181134700775,
-0.14777356386184692,
0.05813838914036751,
0.13284893333911896,
0.5499314069747925,
-0.3590637743473053,
0.04368611052632332,
-0.15775519609451294,
0.12335778772830963,
0.6350963115692139,
0.7086602449417114,
0.15093348920345306,
0.16410793364048004,
-0.15664972364902496,
0.11474089324474335,
-0.5745147466659546,
-0.000721086747944355,
0.0036653403658419847,
0.38898929953575134,
-0.6154051423072815,
0.5188215970993042,
0.22524571418762207,
0.6865445375442505,
-0.025601373985409737,
-0.6302821636199951,
-0.18032105267047882,
-0.47503823041915894,
-0.18821437656879425,
-0.11428851634263992,
0.8154789805412292,
0.8825390338897705,
0.33225566148757935,
-0.28398823738098145,
-0.09071306884288788,
-0.29299962520599365,
0.4079352617263794,
-1.1163078546524048,
-0.587793231010437,
0.38093218207359314,
-0.8724179267883301,
-0.3066307008266449,
-0.059057846665382385,
-0.48783373832702637,
-0.4228861331939697,
0.02741800993680954,
0.023260096088051796,
-0.42442336678504944,
-0.3368237614631653,
0.01050897128880024,
-0.17681124806404114,
-0.4845467805862427,
0.39624565839767456,
-1.1244149208068848,
0.6934221982955933,
0.6397718787193298,
0.8630945086479187,
-0.23175357282161713,
0.023618508130311966,
-0.17374323308467865,
0.14066968858242035,
-0.3519876301288605,
0.7253682017326355,
-0.4002267122268677,
-1.0778402090072632,
-0.1611463725566864,
-0.1263539046049118,
-0.5446877479553223,
-0.8155914545059204,
0.34712183475494385,
-0.15280140936374664,
0.5046486258506775,
-0.2366700917482376,
-1.0062631368637085,
-0.055435094982385635,
0.08892571181058884,
-0.2926357686519623,
0.46879684925079346,
0.5505372881889343,
-0.9827090501785278,
0.3499966561794281,
-0.4655323922634125,
-0.7533957362174988,
0.041971851140260696,
-0.39833059906959534,
-0.8257359862327576,
0.4311051070690155,
0.20988619327545166,
0.5290989875793457,
-0.3505426347255707,
0.19624298810958862,
-0.18207669258117676,
-0.6712971925735474,
0.5964505672454834,
-0.38780227303504944,
0.606655478477478,
0.050136759877204895,
-0.1419941633939743,
-0.13855212926864624,
-0.6746562123298645,
-0.0991530567407608,
0.16784484684467316,
-0.2524677515029907,
-0.3151020109653473,
0.0736282542347908,
-0.0628754198551178,
0.08088794350624084,
-0.11895503848791122,
-0.19052793085575104,
0.0340191051363945,
-0.5158138275146484,
0.5603811144828796,
0.26773136854171753,
0.5254592299461365,
0.18189728260040283,
-0.531475305557251,
0.6472089886665344,
0.23339588940143585,
0.3046678602695465,
-0.5933276414871216,
-0.8680378198623657,
-0.2594951391220093,
-0.45593640208244324,
0.25645342469215393,
0.462348997592926,
-0.3065424859523773,
0.17353114485740662,
-0.45038264989852905,
-0.3649875223636627,
-0.5514059662818909,
-0.12743186950683594,
0.6571726202964783,
1.0749857425689697,
0.3864520490169525,
-0.737671434879303,
-0.11479471623897552,
-0.6729316115379333,
-0.07716012746095657,
-0.3320864140987396,
0.06027434393763542,
0.6595433354377747,
0.4228154122829437,
-0.03723086789250374,
0.8089628219604492,
-0.527518630027771,
-0.09823514521121979,
-0.4722047746181488,
0.011677811853587627,
-0.011855454184114933,
0.1355399340391159,
0.5362982153892517,
-0.6121751070022583,
-0.5923022627830505,
-0.1282106190919876,
-0.6843563914299011,
0.1984594315290451,
-0.1864655762910843,
0.36965325474739075,
0.2574397921562195,
0.2969419062137604,
-0.741051971912384,
0.7213348746299744,
0.2836554944515228,
-0.2114851027727127,
0.5475471615791321,
-0.4809170067310333,
0.23311607539653778,
-1.4174445867538452,
0.13220548629760742,
-0.11756683140993118,
-0.3124598264694214,
-0.8268439173698425,
-0.2817128300666809,
-0.004697140771895647,
-0.18219158053398132,
-0.139332577586174,
0.06150028482079506,
-0.3465183675289154,
0.06382375210523605,
-0.40645164251327515,
0.09365342557430267,
0.15008792281150818,
0.3351328372955322,
0.01396175753325224,
0.9448979496955872,
0.4282522201538086,
-0.6136868000030518,
-0.008424216881394386,
0.5762373805046082,
-0.2003403753042221,
0.6944754123687744,
-0.7058007717132568,
0.23702503740787506,
0.07739099860191345,
0.26358187198638916,
-0.9836596846580505,
-0.16417813301086426,
0.15255191922187805,
-0.6047918796539307,
0.4951454699039459,
-0.357273668050766,
-0.2396303415298462,
0.0005569562781602144,
-0.23698465526103973,
0.2523733675479889,
0.3853156268596649,
0.12132322788238525,
0.3596186339855194,
0.6320828795433044,
-0.6302719712257385,
-0.2548093795776367,
-0.5892341136932373,
0.3058638870716095,
-0.3707750737667084,
-0.4360370337963104,
0.20423167943954468,
0.048544175922870636,
-0.4324165880680084,
-0.056467823684215546,
-0.11746980249881744,
-0.07348807901144028,
0.17883078753948212,
0.257127583026886,
0.33305612206459045,
-0.33887186646461487,
-0.14661067724227905,
0.08586139231920242,
0.05874576047062874,
0.3408440053462982,
0.05630182847380638,
0.4468681812286377,
-0.030387142673134804,
-0.4862801730632782,
-0.4440186619758606,
0.6983539462089539,
0.7700530290603638,
-0.0059997341595590115,
0.7801558375358582,
0.28632283210754395,
-0.2914380133152008,
-0.04720728471875191,
-0.16685481369495392,
-0.3264131247997284,
-0.35007309913635254,
0.4445827901363373,
-0.22520498931407928,
-0.6332867741584778,
0.6137409806251526,
-0.21088625490665436,
0.05545039847493172,
0.23742219805717468,
0.6048780083656311,
-0.4244394898414612,
1.1519064903259277,
0.5219339728355408,
0.05160979554057121,
-0.12489119917154312,
-0.15742608904838562,
0.5246121287345886,
-0.6959261298179626,
-0.27398720383644104,
-0.3493746221065521,
0.15816372632980347,
-0.4056512713432312,
-0.014052929356694221,
0.6785600185394287,
-0.029091650620102882,
0.22166506946086884,
0.11821737885475159,
-0.27856695652008057,
0.14356465637683868,
0.30099526047706604,
0.045625705271959305,
0.3902488052845001,
-0.04839596152305603,
0.03640260174870491,
-0.2349124401807785,
-0.714947521686554,
-0.6212165951728821,
1.1613150835037231,
0.35716938972473145,
0.6660477519035339,
0.3167460560798645,
0.442996621131897,
0.23107412457466125,
0.14146363735198975,
-0.5570322871208191,
0.41334477066993713,
-0.4051996171474457,
-0.23838749527931213,
-0.11636986583471298,
-0.5272212028503418,
-0.8171923756599426,
0.2934338450431824,
-0.196158304810524,
-0.6606451869010925,
-0.013231082819402218,
0.20619156956672668,
-0.5780125260353088,
0.2801690697669983,
-0.7655748128890991,
0.7778814435005188,
-0.004825101234018803,
0.13237364590168,
-0.050937872380018234,
-0.9472035765647888,
0.20718440413475037,
-0.009120006114244461,
0.17842720448970795,
0.024117618799209595,
0.1523289531469345,
0.391059547662735,
-0.901884913444519,
0.8705578446388245,
-0.017655136063694954,
-0.3606454133987427,
0.1468653678894043,
0.04623531922698021,
0.40300264954566956,
0.24846342206001282,
0.4015517234802246,
0.14411406219005585,
0.099930539727211,
-0.2849259674549103,
-0.6312940120697021,
0.322394996881485,
-0.5265858769416809,
-0.5625532865524292,
-0.15493279695510864,
-0.6193022727966309,
-0.6647253632545471,
0.00556327635422349,
0.6442983746528625,
0.9441727995872498,
-0.45258283615112305,
-0.20493383705615997,
0.7256092429161072,
-0.09253399074077606,
0.2847674787044525,
0.6471881866455078,
0.0896671935915947,
-0.39484426379203796,
0.8172402381896973,
0.06618214398622513,
0.5230926275253296,
0.20807623863220215,
0.11419188231229782,
-0.3273288309574127,
-0.9084250926971436,
-0.850985586643219,
0.26749762892723083,
-0.7633952498435974,
-0.011426392011344433,
-0.7506392002105713,
-0.18608905375003815,
-0.67950439453125,
0.07014064490795135,
-0.2211163491010666,
-0.47849011421203613,
-0.3552541732788086,
0.017033927142620087,
0.18796610832214355,
0.8421692252159119,
0.607359766960144,
0.09424369782209396,
-0.9129296541213989,
0.0795823186635971,
-0.1638815999031067,
0.06519211828708649,
0.05047078803181648,
-0.6798246502876282,
-0.5409608483314514,
0.00008210939995478839,
-0.31392794847488403,
-0.8670641779899597,
0.3336859345436096,
0.21895702183246613,
0.22770722210407257,
0.6453953981399536,
-0.0010133348405361176,
0.7966324090957642,
-0.2232031375169754,
0.9900690317153931,
0.11300735920667648,
-0.6872320771217346,
0.48305580019950867,
-0.5068729519844055,
0.3043733239173889,
0.4692976176738739,
0.1545087844133377,
-0.4038175344467163,
-0.7726505398750305,
-0.7882015109062195,
-0.9058207273483276,
0.500519871711731,
0.26778924465179443,
0.08230625092983246,
-0.10079722851514816,
0.33231648802757263,
0.3404485583305359,
0.31805306673049927,
0.15619643032550812,
-0.3941744863986969,
-0.14516271650791168,
-0.20295260846614838,
-0.20338848233222961,
-0.3300846815109253,
-0.5327588319778442,
-0.025054126977920532,
0.3660255968570709,
-0.08318167179822922,
0.1361514776945114,
0.13028647005558014,
-0.022096535190939903,
-0.005969835910946131,
0.24193334579467773,
1.009676218032837,
0.9718097448348999,
-0.37752628326416016,
0.014595866203308105,
0.25016865134239197,
-0.8764976263046265,
-0.29753783345222473,
0.2644910216331482,
-0.24149681627750397,
0.2603107988834381,
0.6855644583702087,
0.9062653183937073,
0.23556558787822723,
-0.6760833263397217,
0.7301473617553711,
-0.3864365518093109,
-0.02045905962586403,
-0.039813488721847534,
-0.019059114158153534,
0.1285894513130188,
-0.04295046254992485,
-0.02149834856390953,
0.4473884403705597,
0.39154186844825745,
-0.40536248683929443,
-0.03173385187983513,
0.2644650340080261,
-0.5009751915931702,
-0.3638315796852112,
0.8185123205184937,
0.05563272535800934,
-0.04355667531490326,
0.661342442035675,
0.06092048063874245,
-0.09497956186532974,
0.4490053355693817,
0.7283453345298767,
0.5871667861938477,
0.06584931164979935,
0.28693312406539917,
-0.12720754742622375,
-0.012946134433150291,
0.04856351017951965,
0.1423110067844391,
-0.2104734629392624,
-0.442486435174942,
-0.247847318649292,
0.17257294058799744,
-0.8005949854850769,
0.14712049067020416,
-1.0221222639083862,
-0.2846953272819519,
-0.38510721921920776,
-0.7278863787651062,
-0.0061817714013159275,
-0.12296873331069946,
-0.347197949886322,
0.23843945562839508,
-0.14689017832279205,
0.7272015810012817,
-0.6511910557746887,
0.5869978666305542,
0.8132376074790955,
-0.35620301961898804,
-0.7424682974815369,
0.12071841210126877,
0.050764281302690506,
-0.6333185434341431,
-0.09898699820041656,
-0.09893951565027237,
-0.2775610387325287,
-0.3735581338405609,
-0.020993685349822044,
-0.37344422936439514,
0.999529242515564,
0.367470920085907,
-0.2694038450717926,
0.032351862639188766,
0.43624815344810486,
0.7622712850570679,
-0.3779221177101135,
0.2934369444847107,
0.5909757614135742,
-0.27046871185302734,
-0.18736805021762848,
-1.3202388286590576,
0.09489019960165024,
-0.3368362486362457,
-0.01529668364673853,
0.04736660420894623,
-0.6510815024375916,
0.8968868255615234,
-0.569664716720581,
-0.2646152675151825,
0.21161720156669617,
0.2892409563064575,
0.0880170464515686,
0.5602461695671082,
0.15434297919273376,
0.5653899312019348,
0.9242345094680786,
-0.08821587264537811,
1.2802923917770386,
-0.40298229455947876,
0.25926387310028076,
1.1525208950042725,
-0.4055272936820984,
0.49494272470474243,
0.17022044956684113,
-0.14795240759849548,
0.31215035915374756,
0.4576379060745239,
0.09490395337343216,
0.5910933017730713,
-0.054943617433309555,
-0.4856203496456146,
-0.0053808484226465225,
-0.05880125239491463,
-0.6217813491821289,
0.24255552887916565,
0.4284791648387909,
-0.6464582085609436,
-0.11699547618627548,
-0.15114913880825043,
0.49888867139816284,
0.05074753612279892,
-0.13094587624073029,
1.1808651685714722,
0.3664286732673645,
-0.7980742454528809,
0.7104990482330322,
0.056784264743328094,
0.23345492780208588,
-0.4905604422092438,
0.04926455020904541,
-0.48543110489845276,
0.420416921377182,
-0.16542024910449982,
-0.4670324921607971,
0.20669099688529968,
0.1567148119211197,
-0.20721298456192017,
-0.02705317921936512,
0.5609495639801025,
-0.3933449387550354,
-0.14404089748859406,
-0.14839698374271393,
0.7499601244926453,
0.3953864276409149,
0.09975717961788177,
-0.5683733224868774,
-0.05498852580785751,
-0.15518401563167572,
-0.011019827798008919,
0.5312468409538269,
0.38939738273620605,
-0.17824731767177582,
0.6879174113273621,
0.2585015892982483,
0.3144775629043579,
-0.32571402192115784,
0.588595986366272,
0.8494856357574463,
-0.3939276337623596,
-0.6152913570404053,
-0.9190594553947449,
0.39874622225761414,
-0.183061882853508,
-0.6528445482254028,
0.8107707500457764,
0.7401021718978882,
0.5959432721138,
-0.20864976942539215,
0.9198043942451477,
0.4465184211730957,
0.774853527545929,
-0.46207356452941895,
0.923964262008667,
-0.18275347352027893,
0.3196648955345154,
-0.3897749185562134,
-0.39457738399505615,
-0.07088255137205124,
0.3281746506690979,
0.04741542413830757,
0.19379854202270508,
0.6587328314781189,
0.683772087097168,
-0.01958760991692543,
0.5743584632873535,
0.2039250135421753,
0.1148286908864975,
0.4104580283164978,
0.5096115469932556,
0.7322865724563599,
-0.36245059967041016,
0.2583571970462799,
-0.2530823349952698,
-0.11279482394456863,
-0.18036162853240967,
-0.529922366142273,
-1.151371717453003,
-0.5655083060264587,
-0.4333440661430359,
-0.5033466815948486,
0.18288396298885345,
0.6132574081420898,
0.7631836533546448,
-0.9369233250617981,
-0.08320290595293045,
0.22045189142227173,
-0.4329485595226288,
-0.380484402179718,
-0.13248880207538605,
0.715085506439209,
-0.06709357351064682,
-0.5232003331184387,
0.4927212595939636,
0.44647374749183655,
0.502086341381073,
0.06604134291410446,
-0.052065152674913406,
0.660785973072052,
0.04122598096728325,
0.4332173466682434,
0.12084069848060608,
-0.4161243140697479,
0.1662864089012146,
-0.05029258877038956,
-0.1661079078912735,
0.08846098184585571,
1.191847562789917,
-0.36760273575782776,
0.41091188788414,
-0.06648938357830048,
0.36128345131874084,
0.4636758267879486,
0.4698511064052582,
0.6775546073913574,
-0.7566164135932922,
-0.15229471027851105,
0.3282195031642914,
0.3858979046344757,
0.522605836391449,
-0.4052811563014984,
0.14091111719608307,
0.18630743026733398,
-0.5218194127082825,
-0.8813038468360901,
0.07123031467199326,
-0.8903085589408875,
-0.3462602198123932,
0.8428034782409668,
-0.5617265701293945,
0.3323120176792145,
-0.6353920698165894,
-0.2370913326740265,
0.13152414560317993,
-0.22365577518939972,
1.0291783809661865,
0.5889744758605957,
-0.5279224514961243,
0.025624630972743034,
-0.3502212464809418,
0.7587447762489319,
0.3427501916885376,
-0.7189562916755676,
0.1985277682542801,
0.34729623794555664,
0.48124995827674866,
0.01306557934731245,
1.0641056299209595,
-0.4582241177558899,
0.3002614676952362,
-0.012406986206769943,
-0.7164674401283264,
-0.3367828130722046,
-0.1061386838555336,
-0.24667467176914215,
0.3215430676937103,
0.07156841456890106,
-0.16137613356113434
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.