id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05564v1
|
Automata Extraction from Transformers
| 2024-06-08T20:07:24 | 2024-06-08T20:07:24 |
Yihao Zhang, Zeming Wei, Meng Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.FL
|
In modern machine (ML) learning systems, Transformer-based architectures have
achieved milestone success across a broad spectrum of tasks, yet understanding
their operational mechanisms remains an open problem. To improve the
transparency of ML systems, automata extraction methods, which interpret
stateful ML models as automata typically through formal languages, have proven
effective for explaining the mechanism of recurrent neural networks (RNNs).
However, few works have been applied to this paradigm to Transformer models. In
particular, understanding their processing of formal languages and identifying
their limitations in this area remains unexplored. In this paper, we propose an
automata extraction algorithm specifically designed for Transformer models.
Treating the Transformer model as a black-box system, we track the model
through the transformation process of their internal latent representations
during their operations, and then use classical pedagogical approaches like L*
algorithm to interpret them as deterministic finite-state automata (DFA).
Overall, our study reveals how the Transformer model comprehends the structure
of formal languages, which not only enhances the interpretability of the
Transformer-based ML systems but also marks a crucial step toward a deeper
understanding of how ML systems process formal languages. Code and data are
available at https://github.com/Zhang-Yihao/Transfomer2DFA.
|
[
-0.20847877860069275,
-0.6460541486740112,
0.5939163565635681,
-0.03723255172371864,
-0.16393059492111206,
0.3900202214717865,
0.05168391019105911,
-0.5732980370521545,
-0.11527743935585022,
0.3912607729434967,
-0.7209764719009399,
-0.06410662829875946,
-0.6277005076408386,
0.18303939700126648,
-0.6849594116210938,
0.7675053477287292,
-0.5065116286277771,
-0.2726028561592102,
0.3295172452926636,
0.30830490589141846,
-0.4260086417198181,
-0.2829844653606415,
-0.23252473771572113,
-0.7563104629516602,
-0.010149934329092503,
0.023224273696541786,
0.5151690244674683,
0.6601054072380066,
0.4945400357246399,
0.44205859303474426,
0.010349441319704056,
-0.021453628316521645,
-0.2921355664730072,
0.21075677871704102,
-0.03720490261912346,
-0.5810320973396301,
-0.1465882807970047,
-0.07865077257156372,
0.7637767195701599,
0.23942463099956512,
-0.09873974323272705,
0.37568631768226624,
0.007915839552879333,
0.4807126820087433,
-0.4666460156440735,
0.7685558199882507,
-0.6321544647216797,
0.4912189841270447,
-0.11262022703886032,
-0.3281927704811096,
-0.6175841093063354,
-0.1703440099954605,
0.10028563439846039,
-0.3979721963405609,
0.14317412674427032,
-0.3748539388179779,
1.000013828277588,
0.6210907697677612,
-0.17398107051849365,
-0.17571890354156494,
-1.328245997428894,
0.7168458104133606,
-0.49509215354919434,
0.4724392294883728,
-0.012515820562839508,
0.8297560214996338,
-0.23466825485229492,
-0.856109619140625,
-0.654835045337677,
0.06710463017225266,
-0.6852790117263794,
-0.1646743267774582,
-0.576158881187439,
-0.1886301338672638,
0.42162343859672546,
0.679239809513092,
-0.47273677587509155,
0.10412462800741196,
-0.36863791942596436,
-0.1760082244873047,
0.5632008910179138,
0.2536478042602539,
0.20456098020076752,
-0.1556391417980194,
-0.2736899256706238,
-0.02998180501163006,
-0.23799528181552887,
0.15368235111236572,
0.013537346385419369,
-0.06666851043701172,
-0.3348023593425751,
0.3287213444709778,
0.12025605887174606,
0.5059905052185059,
0.19187557697296143,
-0.06464243680238724,
0.08340179920196533,
-0.17109650373458862,
-0.46890270709991455,
-0.3818654716014862,
0.9910575747489929,
-0.5618516802787781,
0.49974119663238525,
-0.572336733341217,
-0.4918615221977234,
0.18004025518894196,
0.4044979512691498,
-0.6908956170082092,
-0.34264007210731506,
0.018429281190037727,
-0.533213198184967,
-0.4526859223842621,
0.04132736846804619,
-0.8750743269920349,
-0.053651951253414154,
-0.4146099090576172,
0.4448585510253906,
-0.17792417109012604,
-0.3762100636959076,
-0.14213478565216064,
0.17218098044395447,
0.5807831287384033,
-0.0001366062933811918,
-0.9699360728263855,
0.47564610838890076,
0.7104948163032532,
0.6223891973495483,
-0.03252429515123367,
0.13554120063781738,
-0.17219193279743195,
-0.15899436175823212,
-0.27554962038993835,
0.4552640914916992,
-0.5269291996955872,
-0.1905020773410797,
-0.24402280151844025,
0.24237723648548126,
-0.3518006205558777,
-0.339844673871994,
0.1328108012676239,
-0.8315154314041138,
0.2506895661354065,
0.5396472811698914,
-0.5827628374099731,
-0.5657972097396851,
-0.28435859084129333,
-0.9390497207641602,
0.8851751685142517,
0.1495770663022995,
-0.1586335450410843,
0.02378156967461109,
-0.8680908679962158,
-0.4789702594280243,
-0.02895362861454487,
-0.4874555468559265,
-0.6472411751747131,
0.33550697565078735,
0.2567196786403656,
0.5015539526939392,
-0.3162930905818939,
0.5812469720840454,
-0.02948405034840107,
-0.2835335433483124,
0.43023231625556946,
-0.8214095234870911,
0.8344078660011292,
0.4483259618282318,
-0.9989348649978638,
0.1691451072692871,
-0.7583305835723877,
-0.18504643440246582,
0.4595973491668701,
0.1358250379562378,
0.15034957230091095,
0.1072736606001854,
-0.2544330358505249,
0.5196753144264221,
0.2926735281944275,
-0.3985225558280945,
0.1807045191526413,
-0.5436647534370422,
0.5312549471855164,
0.7545547485351562,
0.08145277202129364,
0.5591796040534973,
0.07954612374305725,
0.5637091398239136,
0.000017219865185325034,
0.24370704591274261,
-0.4090345501899719,
-0.250291109085083,
-0.9188777208328247,
-0.2879531979560852,
0.1544303148984909,
0.4350035488605499,
-0.7210613489151001,
0.5228786468505859,
-0.16201330721378326,
-0.49850383400917053,
-0.6320661306381226,
-0.07530153542757034,
0.3296898901462555,
0.3610372841358185,
0.4498007595539093,
-0.21693754196166992,
-0.542032778263092,
-0.8692810535430908,
-0.10698861628770828,
-0.02713082917034626,
0.09597393870353699,
0.02970588393509388,
0.6494070887565613,
-0.23389507830142975,
1.0639305114746094,
-0.436657577753067,
-0.1498805284500122,
-0.036592379212379456,
0.0646546483039856,
0.36980536580085754,
0.31406837701797485,
0.30356404185295105,
-0.6006188988685608,
-0.1858840435743332,
0.05490603297948837,
-0.954314112663269,
0.17536917328834534,
-0.37839576601982117,
-0.11380993574857712,
0.08866420388221741,
0.44029054045677185,
-0.3666507601737976,
0.6738120317459106,
0.40716633200645447,
-0.3277653157711029,
0.3743598163127899,
0.1681847721338272,
-0.18766242265701294,
-0.7498201131820679,
0.32296022772789,
-0.031509581953287125,
-0.37387800216674805,
-0.5822903513908386,
0.25031131505966187,
0.03564131632447243,
-0.04589545726776123,
-0.22816604375839233,
0.5662497282028198,
-0.4569466710090637,
-0.37751686573028564,
-0.31471484899520874,
-0.2802187204360962,
-0.02170504815876484,
0.6508342027664185,
0.30007612705230713,
0.5958447456359863,
0.565226137638092,
-0.5075428485870361,
0.05845796689391136,
0.15214049816131592,
-0.26341333985328674,
-0.20402571558952332,
-0.48078563809394836,
0.19192805886268616,
-0.031449124217033386,
0.13438087701797485,
-0.7273855209350586,
0.18153516948223114,
0.6237710118293762,
-0.11150830239057541,
0.3858283758163452,
-0.3127802610397339,
-0.3242258131504059,
-0.21840068697929382,
0.5835421681404114,
0.20936569571495056,
0.6527950167655945,
-0.5938102602958679,
0.985989511013031,
0.3975997567176819,
0.3694334030151367,
-0.6643800139427185,
-0.28189074993133545,
-0.06944142282009125,
-0.0014812354929745197,
-0.07657188922166824,
0.29723095893859863,
0.08536430448293686,
-0.3163982033729553,
-0.091026671230793,
-0.3588642179965973,
-0.3690948188304901,
0.6337109804153442,
0.3268352448940277,
0.2837964594364166,
-0.3922572731971741,
-0.17818418145179749,
-0.013498259708285332,
-0.5276268720626831,
0.3849692940711975,
-0.3023433983325958,
0.5571673512458801,
-0.31406086683273315,
-0.1962178647518158,
-0.9727283716201782,
-0.13473708927631378,
0.8133451342582703,
-0.5487780570983887,
0.3828946053981781,
0.812283992767334,
-0.5081495642662048,
-0.5154963135719299,
-0.1039920449256897,
-0.6050898432731628,
-0.5170714259147644,
0.16712960600852966,
-0.5841971635818481,
-0.5550305843353271,
0.3597433269023895,
-0.01188518013805151,
0.5692712664604187,
0.7162663340568542,
0.5657603144645691,
0.08063247799873352,
0.5219839215278625,
0.6854609847068787,
-0.21554124355316162,
0.5491901636123657,
-0.5845481157302856,
0.20180562138557434,
-0.31966090202331543,
-0.27449744939804077,
-0.4358592629432678,
-0.3550673723220825,
-0.4540194571018219,
-0.43955543637275696,
-0.0255535077303648,
-0.30297210812568665,
-0.12524132430553436,
0.6142148375511169,
-0.47989460825920105,
0.26600381731987,
0.07554808259010315,
0.04945170134305954,
0.5282630920410156,
0.24338872730731964,
-0.011988414451479912,
0.08317841589450836,
-0.4019513428211212,
-0.5048550367355347,
0.6905681490898132,
0.9551795721054077,
0.6591936349868774,
0.0706617683172226,
0.8950827121734619,
0.27405276894569397,
0.4845481216907501,
-0.9338909983634949,
0.4660063683986664,
-0.17244140803813934,
-0.5179725289344788,
-0.2694394886493683,
-0.6449266076087952,
-0.8728422522544861,
0.2477729171514511,
-0.15059228241443634,
-0.5321727395057678,
0.46805423498153687,
-0.20397353172302246,
-0.23602955043315887,
0.46719595789909363,
-0.20639263093471527,
0.7618622183799744,
-0.26043686270713806,
0.005015425384044647,
-0.13585010170936584,
-0.32846665382385254,
0.3798617124557495,
-0.3798815608024597,
0.22397461533546448,
0.03406072035431862,
0.2923065423965454,
0.5201335549354553,
-0.1964435875415802,
0.9435233473777771,
-0.15997174382209778,
-0.7352534532546997,
0.22337892651557922,
0.545472264289856,
0.5166460871696472,
-0.20591340959072113,
0.06640711426734924,
0.647045373916626,
-0.12226337194442749,
-0.09167509526014328,
-0.8087455630302429,
0.12382402271032333,
-0.6721051335334778,
-0.17256072163581848,
-0.3259866535663605,
-0.5068866610527039,
0.09222671389579773,
0.14674708247184753,
-0.0004389365785755217,
0.4590241312980652,
0.03297021612524986,
-0.14063392579555511,
0.5363683700561523,
0.10207813233137131,
0.8203161954879761,
0.8573554754257202,
-0.23193179070949554,
0.042717624455690384,
0.8595409393310547,
-0.05987009406089783,
-0.05278253182768822,
0.686366856098175,
0.08342218399047852,
-0.31992337107658386,
-0.5037930607795715,
-0.6017347574234009,
0.11783986538648605,
-0.583206295967102,
0.05130219832062721,
-0.5180540680885315,
-0.47569113969802856,
-0.13542133569717407,
0.269827276468277,
-0.2928783893585205,
-0.6156056523323059,
-0.40794989466667175,
0.09443658590316772,
0.08536619693040848,
0.9717055559158325,
0.26543575525283813,
0.3941727876663208,
-0.8178659677505493,
0.5368620753288269,
0.25157439708709717,
0.45706412196159363,
0.18306109309196472,
-0.801565408706665,
-0.17167212069034576,
-0.2928318977355957,
-0.1838756650686264,
-0.8507532477378845,
0.2753203511238098,
0.14691458642482758,
0.7272893190383911,
0.5093309879302979,
-0.2165272831916809,
0.6712954640388489,
-0.6510317921638489,
0.3441999852657318,
-0.12080972641706467,
-0.964853823184967,
0.21056735515594482,
0.09656848758459091,
-0.05879157781600952,
0.2035921961069107,
0.3283136188983917,
-0.08379869163036346,
-0.43140873312950134,
-0.5501173138618469,
-0.5285253524780273,
0.6794992089271545,
0.4075465202331543,
-0.057477012276649475,
0.2536936104297638,
0.514025092124939,
0.11761517822742462,
-0.0517200343310833,
-0.9132747650146484,
-0.6655759215354919,
-0.08339392393827438,
-0.48174628615379333,
-0.13176944851875305,
0.01769474521279335,
0.04883473366498947,
0.10440254956483841,
0.5862190127372742,
0.08797343820333481,
0.4271075427532196,
0.12024740129709244,
-0.6037771105766296,
-0.3425283432006836,
0.3195311725139618,
0.38890334963798523,
0.5096722841262817,
0.1358191967010498,
0.01444118469953537,
-0.17342866957187653,
-0.5318351984024048,
0.4393119215965271,
0.35516202449798584,
-0.3930758833885193,
0.1184566393494606,
0.41151368618011475,
0.6806250810623169,
0.4178506135940552,
-0.3440020978450775,
0.10150347650051117,
-0.35483962297439575,
0.05016956850886345,
-0.44587668776512146,
0.2626676857471466,
-0.5073528289794922,
0.5120278000831604,
0.5750735402107239,
0.05584351345896721,
0.11228097230195999,
-0.21605902910232544,
0.7719699740409851,
0.2783169150352478,
-0.6314460039138794,
-0.45132699608802795,
0.4740929901599884,
0.09925539046525955,
-0.3649238049983978,
0.314689576625824,
-0.06933886557817459,
-0.36263614892959595,
0.5815595984458923,
0.6449650526046753,
1.3561989068984985,
-0.24858598411083221,
0.2174222767353058,
0.4965088963508606,
0.6099643707275391,
0.060557398945093155,
-0.022639237344264984,
-0.24956150352954865,
-0.5300697684288025,
-0.7761746644973755,
-0.9676876068115234,
-0.18227618932724,
0.19911198318004608,
-0.6207259893417358,
0.030232571065425873,
-0.4385487735271454,
0.01746554672718048,
0.1185508519411087,
-0.07529320567846298,
-0.718208372592926,
-0.010893911123275757,
0.40572506189346313,
0.7828110456466675,
-0.9018605351448059,
0.8710896372795105,
0.1640787273645401,
-0.29297107458114624,
-0.8403951525688171,
-0.040005579590797424,
-0.11570674926042557,
-0.6711660623550415,
0.6632439494132996,
0.011990333907306194,
-0.29118838906288147,
0.15526653826236725,
-0.0375230610370636,
-0.8371891379356384,
0.8207005262374878,
0.2769395411014557,
-0.9480838775634766,
-0.18199008703231812,
0.22892530262470245,
0.48791950941085815,
-0.25499916076660156,
0.37029024958610535,
0.8891173601150513,
0.5674538016319275,
-0.4550571143627167,
-0.8486902713775635,
0.30892589688301086,
-0.26319649815559387,
-0.4792194068431854,
0.3701136112213135,
-0.11831171065568924,
0.6498879790306091,
-0.02511456236243248,
-0.6594107747077942,
0.0515766404569149,
0.9426342844963074,
-0.2509182095527649,
0.1695009022951126,
0.6285192966461182,
0.25546857714653015,
0.47788387537002563,
-0.14033876359462738,
0.726931095123291,
-0.30824199318885803,
0.5074644684791565,
1.0326550006866455,
0.06350293010473251,
0.510618269443512,
0.2555852234363556,
-0.29370778799057007,
1.0848579406738281,
0.3914910852909088,
-0.27608826756477356,
0.15599370002746582,
0.08269336819648743,
-0.0854228213429451,
-0.16660700738430023,
0.46906447410583496,
-0.05439441278576851,
0.8524810075759888,
0.36469367146492004,
-0.7588359117507935,
-0.4543300271034241,
-0.2745243310928345,
-0.08804492652416229,
-0.07522433996200562,
-0.13629987835884094,
1.0104964971542358,
0.11104802787303925,
-0.5937437415122986,
0.6961041688919067,
-0.044491056352853775,
0.29688942432403564,
-0.49678754806518555,
-0.40478065609931946,
0.05543103069067001,
0.12128212302923203,
-0.29658791422843933,
-0.542634129524231,
0.47108882665634155,
0.0366024449467659,
-0.15513567626476288,
-0.19867904484272003,
0.5967043042182922,
-0.43104124069213867,
-0.5238370895385742,
0.34940657019615173,
0.6237635016441345,
0.23907504975795746,
0.17658033967018127,
-0.9637470245361328,
-0.010751809924840927,
-0.025185709819197655,
-0.11008964478969574,
0.029935410246253014,
0.2355365753173828,
-0.029214244335889816,
0.5816865563392639,
0.6226187348365784,
-0.08826102316379547,
-0.01605568267405033,
-0.09227646887302399,
0.5398431420326233,
-0.6853838562965393,
-0.4056203365325928,
-1.07951819896698,
0.4378197491168976,
0.3053668439388275,
0.16616982221603394,
0.4783032238483429,
0.28247225284576416,
0.4932747483253479,
-0.12081178277730942,
0.5822874307632446,
-0.010030042380094528,
0.10214193910360336,
-0.47053080797195435,
0.9127920269966125,
-0.2239374816417694,
0.4262113869190216,
-0.19810593128204346,
-0.8091491460800171,
-0.07876947522163391,
0.6352496147155762,
-0.30301472544670105,
-0.2679826617240906,
0.437954306602478,
0.6699634790420532,
-0.21140292286872864,
0.1300371289253235,
0.20765569806098938,
0.3637423813343048,
0.5165138244628906,
0.4669734239578247,
0.7239161133766174,
-0.631085991859436,
0.5494370460510254,
-0.6346051096916199,
-0.20791302621364594,
-0.036377761512994766,
-0.7333934307098389,
-0.6364548206329346,
-0.612555742263794,
-0.15506012737751007,
-0.21458150446414948,
-0.3502607047557831,
0.5051581859588623,
0.6262623071670532,
-0.9247227907180786,
-0.3062472641468048,
-0.1513524055480957,
0.4423099458217621,
-0.5487836003303528,
-0.3048074543476105,
0.419424444437027,
-0.5015006065368652,
-0.7036837935447693,
0.7899520993232727,
0.09410803765058517,
0.11424792557954788,
-0.6438907980918884,
-0.02523999661207199,
0.23655939102172852,
0.04854279384016991,
0.45630398392677307,
0.4676547646522522,
-0.6227951645851135,
-0.05829435586929321,
0.12142255157232285,
0.10736970603466034,
-0.030664047226309776,
1.0076218843460083,
-0.9298933744430542,
0.4870922565460205,
0.28280404210090637,
0.5751163363456726,
0.43896839022636414,
-0.3584451377391815,
0.7191112637519836,
-0.42842644453048706,
0.012052644975483418,
0.16046707332134247,
0.42014646530151367,
-0.08094477653503418,
-0.3293812572956085,
0.5009176731109619,
0.1506980061531067,
-0.28895777463912964,
-0.7523724436759949,
0.4335552752017975,
-0.5452076196670532,
-0.33331647515296936,
0.7432010769844055,
-0.2194075584411621,
-0.4050074815750122,
-0.48917239904403687,
0.20437729358673096,
0.6320590972900391,
-0.011128106154501438,
0.9729635715484619,
0.10803292691707611,
0.09661807119846344,
-0.1795407235622406,
-0.41756555438041687,
0.5190379023551941,
0.1526363343000412,
-0.7312575578689575,
0.2728275656700134,
0.19077765941619873,
0.32809993624687195,
0.32808494567871094,
0.27865201234817505,
-0.5204581618309021,
0.36004534363746643,
-0.3743540048599243,
0.153397336602211,
-0.15479141473770142,
-0.5755375623703003,
-0.8573218584060669,
0.13127700984477997,
-0.4862786829471588,
-0.19057776033878326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05559v1
|
ThatiAR: Subjectivity Detection in Arabic News Sentences
| 2024-06-08T19:24:17 | 2024-06-08T19:24:17 |
Reem Suwaileh, Maram Hasanain, Fatema Hubail, Wajdi Zaghouani, Firoj Alam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7
|
Detecting subjectivity in news sentences is crucial for identifying media
bias, enhancing credibility, and combating misinformation by flagging
opinion-based content. It provides insights into public sentiment, empowers
readers to make informed decisions, and encourages critical thinking. While
research has developed methods and systems for this purpose, most efforts have
focused on English and other high-resourced languages. In this study, we
present the first large dataset for subjectivity detection in Arabic,
consisting of ~3.6K manually annotated sentences, and GPT-4o based explanation.
In addition, we included instructions (both in English and Arabic) to
facilitate LLM based fine-tuning. We provide an in-depth analysis of the
dataset, annotation process, and extensive benchmark results, including PLMs
and LLMs. Our analysis of the annotation process highlights that annotators
were strongly influenced by their political, cultural, and religious
backgrounds, especially at the beginning of the annotation process. The
experimental results suggest that LLMs with in-context learning provide better
performance. We aim to release the dataset and resources for the community.
|
[
-0.5310611128807068,
-0.5909641981124878,
0.7063168883323669,
0.14516787230968475,
-0.526066243648529,
-0.10030297935009003,
-0.24151480197906494,
-0.2303907722234726,
-0.3021479845046997,
0.5929420590400696,
-0.3717333674430847,
-0.9729905128479004,
-0.7592520713806152,
0.24475301802158356,
-0.15891671180725098,
1.278698444366455,
-0.25325947999954224,
-0.125812828540802,
0.03322241082787514,
-0.5326759815216064,
-0.2520182728767395,
-0.49315911531448364,
-0.37324202060699463,
-0.05523228272795677,
0.5909618139266968,
0.6737653613090515,
0.7889472246170044,
0.5256235003471375,
0.5455501675605774,
0.2775055170059204,
-0.2915549576282501,
0.04449727013707161,
-0.08508120477199554,
0.10344010591506958,
-0.2981263995170593,
-0.3232361376285553,
-0.05227461829781532,
-0.010914306156337261,
0.6717251539230347,
0.3129417300224304,
0.32358628511428833,
0.5803243517875671,
0.005652297288179398,
0.927376389503479,
-0.7044890522956848,
0.1881205141544342,
-0.2772578299045563,
0.05693218857049942,
-0.46017587184906006,
-0.038673896342515945,
-0.05885787308216095,
-0.556563675403595,
0.00919368863105774,
-0.07869253307580948,
0.22027744352817535,
0.057376887649297714,
0.6307307481765747,
0.5335204005241394,
-0.7609090209007263,
-0.4426049292087555,
-0.43437886238098145,
0.8588487505912781,
-0.6292287707328796,
0.34727758169174194,
0.720652163028717,
-0.041325490921735764,
-0.0934765413403511,
-0.3803434669971466,
-0.6035503149032593,
-0.1337423175573349,
0.011158824898302555,
-0.05789220705628395,
-0.05256066098809242,
-0.17583748698234558,
0.29833731055259705,
0.4115687310695648,
-0.6644382476806641,
-0.17824243009090424,
-0.20905257761478424,
-0.19764402508735657,
0.5202197432518005,
-0.2514282464981079,
0.10790035128593445,
-0.4123328626155853,
-0.01707647740840912,
0.23079554736614227,
-0.9086799621582031,
0.1346186101436615,
0.31777748465538025,
-0.02482215315103531,
-0.2912225127220154,
0.5911653637886047,
-0.4762210249900818,
0.5580867528915405,
0.1311938315629959,
-0.4173535406589508,
0.36265575885772705,
-0.09648675471544266,
-0.03284531459212303,
0.41927680373191833,
0.572718620300293,
0.2599509358406067,
0.3756585419178009,
0.09339715540409088,
-0.03643440827727318,
0.0067512402310967445,
0.029969900846481323,
-1.141433835029602,
0.134755939245224,
0.2881651818752289,
-0.743860125541687,
-0.29429692029953003,
-0.043013572692871094,
-0.3994791507720947,
-0.40995168685913086,
-0.20276911556720734,
0.04883163049817085,
-0.19200044870376587,
-0.20396950840950012,
0.0499158576130867,
0.27960672974586487,
0.1991775780916214,
0.11979682743549347,
-0.4656789302825928,
0.07814961671829224,
0.7270463109016418,
0.9757963418960571,
-0.25948649644851685,
0.12539142370224,
-0.6247872114181519,
0.08725884556770325,
-0.18311519920825958,
0.6565567851066589,
-0.6212295889854431,
-0.23345288634300232,
0.22428885102272034,
-0.1983497589826584,
0.5464937686920166,
-0.53228360414505,
1.3411225080490112,
-0.764046311378479,
0.28985968232154846,
-0.5330857038497925,
-0.5898725390434265,
-0.515221357345581,
0.3276825547218323,
-0.7443051338195801,
0.7582687735557556,
0.14140893518924713,
-0.8894597291946411,
0.49936380982398987,
-0.710223376750946,
-0.7636154890060425,
-0.017139539122581482,
-0.1580602079629898,
-0.7790957689285278,
0.2119630128145218,
0.39732128381729126,
0.40333184599876404,
-0.056496698409318924,
0.34542110562324524,
0.21555308997631073,
-0.3897845447063446,
0.5564855933189392,
-0.1638779640197754,
0.4186181426048279,
0.35335829854011536,
-0.5903397798538208,
0.12081151455640793,
-0.5657172799110413,
-0.2051028460264206,
-0.4125455617904663,
-0.5005491375923157,
-0.23248516023159027,
0.08228747546672821,
0.321349173784256,
0.46790310740470886,
0.13804659247398376,
-0.5909690260887146,
-0.11430253833532333,
-0.44534921646118164,
0.16219395399093628,
0.46748635172843933,
0.23797926306724548,
0.24488630890846252,
-0.3774101436138153,
0.47989094257354736,
0.23228132724761963,
-0.1494227945804596,
-0.24899666011333466,
-0.5113176107406616,
-0.5324347019195557,
-0.3429521322250366,
0.028403909876942635,
0.39051464200019836,
-0.45622479915618896,
0.5169990658760071,
-0.016153432428836823,
-0.11052556335926056,
-0.4266945719718933,
0.4152699112892151,
0.28878873586654663,
0.5225386619567871,
0.30728116631507874,
0.026717722415924072,
-0.5356420278549194,
-1.0767985582351685,
-0.33056220412254333,
0.03383511304855347,
0.14948467910289764,
0.02671787515282631,
0.5295482873916626,
-0.10907579958438873,
1.01088285446167,
-0.3154982030391693,
-0.6515499353408813,
-0.20417118072509766,
0.3410670757293701,
0.4017200469970703,
0.22959952056407928,
0.526639461517334,
-1.1039360761642456,
-0.5825261473655701,
0.027464289218187332,
-0.8123362064361572,
-0.3187325596809387,
0.2341708540916443,
0.03492000326514244,
0.46962931752204895,
0.3135068714618683,
-0.3036259114742279,
0.6220539212226868,
0.39697888493537903,
-0.3680790364742279,
0.00043295425712130964,
0.2958858609199524,
0.3336331248283386,
-0.9527508020401001,
0.04778366908431053,
0.41527217626571655,
-0.4691573679447174,
-0.536194384098053,
-0.026782285422086716,
-0.13351547718048096,
0.06817162781953812,
-0.5605145692825317,
0.40338435769081116,
-0.44244006276130676,
0.08342908322811127,
-0.7794589400291443,
-0.11375298351049423,
-0.1199229285120964,
0.40867385268211365,
0.2599705159664154,
1.0471080541610718,
0.37558984756469727,
-0.42663416266441345,
0.00151407765224576,
0.42474934458732605,
-0.6891013979911804,
0.37374404072761536,
-0.4484921395778656,
0.2686472237110138,
-0.5271810293197632,
0.03271891549229622,
-0.918938159942627,
-0.307998389005661,
0.5847525596618652,
-0.22507132589817047,
-0.054816171526908875,
-0.16466647386550903,
-0.5541960597038269,
0.015406311489641666,
-0.45222824811935425,
0.44915667176246643,
0.4030769169330597,
-0.19353355467319489,
0.5695106983184814,
0.23555099964141846,
-0.3775845468044281,
-0.46277371048927307,
-0.5923867225646973,
0.23364365100860596,
-0.3033277094364166,
-0.38087713718414307,
-0.026683367788791656,
0.11425385624170303,
-0.5228828191757202,
0.057279203087091446,
-0.13714119791984558,
-0.056813761591911316,
0.10764916241168976,
0.5737195611000061,
-0.07019415497779846,
-0.25502511858940125,
0.11602863669395447,
0.2631554901599884,
-0.08117040246725082,
0.17330417037010193,
-0.0836663767695427,
0.3696347177028656,
-0.1989373117685318,
-0.33132150769233704,
-0.8266279101371765,
0.4204060435295105,
0.38761669397354126,
-0.501003623008728,
0.785526692867279,
0.6931580901145935,
-0.35497504472732544,
0.2783055305480957,
-0.7014870643615723,
0.053542785346508026,
-0.4643140137195587,
0.5031757950782776,
-0.27171584963798523,
-0.8074634075164795,
0.22884155809879303,
-0.035070013254880905,
-0.24785540997982025,
0.26346471905708313,
0.8877441883087158,
0.12823158502578735,
1.02433180809021,
0.5176741480827332,
-0.5972375869750977,
0.37245944142341614,
0.04302707314491272,
0.16086120903491974,
-0.4959588646888733,
-0.04740465059876442,
-0.43448856472969055,
-0.5274440050125122,
-0.8528456091880798,
-0.18103231489658356,
0.3894740641117096,
-0.3891839385032654,
-0.6027353405952454,
-0.4139542579650879,
-0.3676798343658447,
0.6497401595115662,
0.3430030047893524,
0.3326048254966736,
0.5218174457550049,
0.29214778542518616,
0.5244197845458984,
-0.29362741112709045,
-0.18014392256736755,
-0.9937812089920044,
1.0173799991607666,
0.2935650944709778,
0.5031797289848328,
0.4958606958389282,
0.7797244191169739,
0.6476839184761047,
0.9815874099731445,
-0.805290162563324,
0.35466310381889343,
-0.011626573279500008,
-0.53068608045578,
-0.051597826182842255,
-0.10612933337688446,
-0.5557546019554138,
-0.06423778831958771,
0.09081149846315384,
-0.5635497570037842,
0.1309792548418045,
-0.12278135120868683,
-0.17067047953605652,
0.11958640813827515,
-0.29170721769332886,
0.5636677742004395,
-0.23211203515529633,
-0.7228078246116638,
-0.2625429332256317,
-0.6271183490753174,
0.27956485748291016,
0.04861070588231087,
0.31526732444763184,
-0.2252180576324463,
-0.307463675737381,
0.7245858907699585,
-0.0385509617626667,
0.7497453689575195,
-0.17148332297801971,
-0.18236255645751953,
0.3370436728000641,
0.024193042889237404,
0.1817120909690857,
0.13134700059890747,
-0.36210790276527405,
0.169329434633255,
-0.4590988755226135,
-0.3601463735103607,
-0.134030282497406,
0.7714273929595947,
-0.9346251487731934,
-0.9429054856300354,
-0.7140954732894897,
-0.7203519344329834,
0.002598086604848504,
0.03803962469100952,
0.05060936138033867,
0.21605150401592255,
-0.17855876684188843,
0.2768828868865967,
0.56113600730896,
0.1681755781173706,
0.38734012842178345,
0.49161022901535034,
-0.19867455959320068,
-0.256046861410141,
0.8591070175170898,
0.012406429275870323,
-0.368688702583313,
0.39891836047172546,
0.02555791288614273,
-0.2346007078886032,
-0.7020072937011719,
-0.4862801432609558,
0.17621079087257385,
-0.6268929839134216,
-0.301710844039917,
-0.4517259895801544,
0.11114601045846939,
0.0643998458981514,
-0.007748516276478767,
0.12676949799060822,
-0.2063387632369995,
-0.4575008153915405,
-0.15652261674404144,
0.4582311809062958,
0.7860076427459717,
0.19625525176525116,
0.5159472823143005,
-0.7465354800224304,
0.4557008147239685,
-0.0020028832368552685,
0.19102588295936584,
-0.32431840896606445,
-0.6349628567695618,
-0.3808085322380066,
-0.004140236880630255,
-0.6505175232887268,
-1.170521855354309,
0.3081110715866089,
0.2892139256000519,
0.1361241340637207,
0.8868322372436523,
0.0011224119225516915,
0.06279651075601578,
-0.2586210072040558,
0.5724437236785889,
-0.46857789158821106,
-1.150020956993103,
0.743217408657074,
-0.39503365755081177,
0.22016949951648712,
0.6749851107597351,
0.7272910475730896,
-0.497984915971756,
-0.4122523367404938,
-0.19311587512493134,
-0.5180437564849854,
0.6988629102706909,
0.34429308772087097,
0.04136838763952255,
-0.04632355645298958,
0.7330918312072754,
0.28684213757514954,
0.5314154028892517,
-0.6264002919197083,
-0.4231804311275482,
-0.31216874718666077,
-0.7017472386360168,
0.06403368711471558,
-0.5839177966117859,
-0.1842576563358307,
-0.17824691534042358,
0.6226815581321716,
-0.26528260111808777,
-0.16373057663440704,
0.2969270348548889,
-0.515310525894165,
-0.3078096807003021,
0.42184147238731384,
0.664672315120697,
0.8276679515838623,
-0.31132277846336365,
0.11637330055236816,
0.0006363368593156338,
-0.49306055903434753,
0.5134392380714417,
0.21666018664836884,
-0.395221471786499,
0.17080970108509064,
0.3621176481246948,
0.6320823431015015,
-0.10277590900659561,
-0.7062534093856812,
0.5538177490234375,
0.22181539237499237,
0.006545588839799166,
-0.47218403220176697,
-0.016665667295455933,
-0.11209441721439362,
0.3876972496509552,
0.7173712253570557,
-0.25884246826171875,
0.44048598408699036,
-0.7364643216133118,
0.19104664027690887,
0.34143006801605225,
-0.2027936577796936,
-0.3015788197517395,
0.555584728717804,
0.3110947012901306,
-0.27843165397644043,
0.2995947301387787,
-0.33934593200683594,
-0.8943093419075012,
0.5548006892204285,
0.28225672245025635,
0.7371729612350464,
-0.1800561547279358,
0.34415730834007263,
0.1815563440322876,
0.19543513655662537,
-0.023219531401991844,
0.4914756715297699,
-0.27435755729675293,
-0.8833431601524353,
-0.6392443180084229,
-0.29238584637641907,
-0.6284626126289368,
0.22985583543777466,
-0.6146040558815002,
0.09644953906536102,
-0.5795396566390991,
-0.19054214656352997,
-0.038934770971536636,
0.309449166059494,
-0.5452701449394226,
0.29936861991882324,
0.5355134606361389,
0.6662341952323914,
-0.9768843650817871,
0.5363858342170715,
1.0320669412612915,
-0.42883390188217163,
-0.2601805031299591,
0.4492119252681732,
0.1617945283651352,
-0.65352463722229,
1.0755844116210938,
0.5435073971748352,
-0.10998764634132385,
-0.0010236003436148167,
-0.6405872106552124,
-0.6670824885368347,
0.7804878950119019,
0.22386685013771057,
-0.541882336139679,
0.4923042058944702,
0.3628357946872711,
0.41911181807518005,
-0.40249529480934143,
0.15743683278560638,
0.6199836134910583,
0.7832263708114624,
-0.14065511524677277,
-0.2637079358100891,
0.26438793540000916,
0.014926892705261707,
-0.24579067528247833,
0.13926173746585846,
-0.8124704360961914,
0.5086413025856018,
-0.0747678205370903,
-0.20492489635944366,
-0.0039009544998407364,
1.1260215044021606,
0.11770708113908768,
0.6136359572410583,
0.34426406025886536,
0.44250109791755676,
0.6223462224006653,
-0.06331271678209305,
0.8765932321548462,
-0.6644303798675537,
0.07604753226041794,
0.9168041348457336,
-0.5806086659431458,
0.6545684933662415,
0.43770185112953186,
0.05345921590924263,
0.6821940541267395,
0.40950247645378113,
0.12836986780166626,
0.7302372455596924,
0.1493232399225235,
-0.8036504983901978,
-0.22838690876960754,
-0.5840413570404053,
-0.16771955788135529,
0.4798656404018402,
0.2883038818836212,
-0.42525362968444824,
-0.15480129420757294,
0.32113152742385864,
0.4264694154262543,
0.39527273178100586,
-0.5825403928756714,
0.6271958947181702,
-0.04597282037138939,
-0.5745882987976074,
0.2691442370414734,
0.2772650420665741,
0.6606873273849487,
-0.23961660265922546,
0.027355588972568512,
-0.229914128780365,
0.215672105550766,
-0.5430818200111389,
-1.1222009658813477,
0.33741846680641174,
0.35461926460266113,
-0.3580676019191742,
-0.07649675756692886,
0.7844057679176331,
-0.3035446107387543,
-0.7225733995437622,
-0.12903441488742828,
0.7580028772354126,
0.1787181794643402,
-0.48322993516921997,
-0.10678880661725998,
0.23902356624603271,
0.18234969675540924,
-0.47408220171928406,
0.11730540543794632,
0.5249624252319336,
-0.3989018499851227,
0.5814370512962341,
0.6079903244972229,
-0.026532191783189774,
-0.4308931231498718,
0.11617718636989594,
1.0307502746582031,
-0.769831657409668,
-0.26544317603111267,
-1.0934770107269287,
0.16440986096858978,
-0.03553777188062668,
-0.3402756154537201,
0.7281423211097717,
0.7434665560722351,
0.5610172748565674,
0.04543236643075943,
0.9378387331962585,
0.11977426707744598,
0.4676440954208374,
-0.45250868797302246,
0.5939707159996033,
-0.30752429366111755,
-0.058043017983436584,
0.059824809432029724,
-0.7238332033157349,
-0.3006291389465332,
0.765810489654541,
-0.5241464376449585,
0.10130691528320312,
0.5282678604125977,
0.7949436902999878,
0.15465879440307617,
0.12331409007310867,
0.19704726338386536,
0.29139313101768494,
0.1233966127038002,
0.2732965350151062,
0.9395981431007385,
-0.14032410085201263,
0.28317633271217346,
-0.2500474750995636,
-0.21967366337776184,
-0.14253546297550201,
-0.908647358417511,
-1.2705949544906616,
-0.3513953387737274,
-0.5556098818778992,
-0.23555399477481842,
0.27607882022857666,
1.1814244985580444,
0.4067721366882324,
-1.0456022024154663,
-0.040774811059236526,
0.1451411247253418,
0.3785686194896698,
0.010326645337045193,
-0.1369878053665161,
0.6328824162483215,
-0.046950630843639374,
-0.70426344871521,
-0.08589015901088715,
0.10596972703933716,
-0.2679838240146637,
-0.165643572807312,
-0.016227269545197487,
-0.38450708985328674,
-0.15973620116710663,
0.5785923004150391,
0.19252444803714752,
-0.5435236692428589,
-0.4672792851924896,
-0.27591249346733093,
-0.05674843117594719,
0.3193829655647278,
0.8721812963485718,
-0.8848596215248108,
-0.14954756200313568,
0.16685529053211212,
0.4779543876647949,
0.5422421097755432,
0.2644007205963135,
0.030404428020119667,
-0.9316145181655884,
0.5933341979980469,
0.30132368206977844,
0.25813227891921997,
0.714616060256958,
-0.43111687898635864,
0.36352819204330444,
-0.06122443452477455,
-0.686538577079773,
-0.43611985445022583,
0.2446405291557312,
-0.911016583442688,
0.13646747171878815,
1.2646468877792358,
0.02705741487443447,
-0.2730012536048889,
-0.4473823308944702,
-0.7339269518852234,
0.24459661543369293,
-0.8004348874092102,
0.8603047728538513,
0.8401762843132019,
0.023735590279102325,
-0.4003957509994507,
-0.4613363742828369,
0.5367680788040161,
0.5140063166618347,
-0.867253839969635,
-0.40340977907180786,
0.5013788342475891,
0.35207879543304443,
-0.03242286294698715,
0.3571320176124573,
0.31979233026504517,
0.33523139357566833,
-0.833053708076477,
0.02115458995103836,
-0.13326023519039154,
0.13540062308311462,
-0.42693960666656494,
0.25897058844566345,
0.30502286553382874,
-0.2974839508533478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05551v1
|
Autoregressive Diffusion Transformer for Text-to-Speech Synthesis
| 2024-06-08T18:57:13 | 2024-06-08T18:57:13 |
Zhijun Liu, Shuai Wang, Sho Inoue, Qibing Bai, Haizhou Li
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Audio language models have recently emerged as a promising approach for
various audio generation tasks, relying on audio tokenizers to encode waveforms
into sequences of discrete symbols. Audio tokenization often poses a necessary
compromise between code bitrate and reconstruction accuracy. When dealing with
low-bitrate audio codes, language models are constrained to process only a
subset of the information embedded in the audio, which in turn restricts their
generative capabilities. To circumvent these issues, we propose encoding audio
as vector sequences in continuous space $\mathbb R^d$ and autoregressively
generating these sequences using a decoder-only diffusion transformer (ARDiT).
Our findings indicate that ARDiT excels in zero-shot text-to-speech and
exhibits performance that compares to or even surpasses that of
state-of-the-art models. High-bitrate continuous speech representation enables
almost flawless reconstruction, allowing our model to achieve nearly perfect
speech editing. Our experiments reveal that employing Integral Kullback-Leibler
(IKL) divergence for distillation at each autoregressive step significantly
boosts the perceived quality of the samples. Simultaneously, it condenses the
iterative sampling process of the diffusion model into a single step.
Furthermore, ARDiT can be trained to predict several continuous vectors in one
step, significantly reducing latency during sampling. Impressively, one of our
models can generate $170$ ms of $24$ kHz speech per evaluation step with
minimal degradation in performance. Audio samples are available at
http://ardit-tts.github.io/ .
|
[
-0.39511722326278687,
-0.831885576248169,
0.4486415982246399,
0.17165584862232208,
-0.10900865495204926,
0.16230441629886627,
-0.01915125548839569,
-0.058727726340293884,
0.25127533078193665,
0.3276568353176117,
-0.3253505825996399,
-0.44131961464881897,
-0.8158257007598877,
-0.05035087466239929,
-1.1020888090133667,
0.8074238300323486,
0.09515503793954849,
-0.15607517957687378,
0.25375476479530334,
-0.08273351192474365,
-0.33802732825279236,
-0.34195825457572937,
-0.792299211025238,
-0.08247610926628113,
0.358912855386734,
0.06691665947437286,
0.37965279817581177,
0.7868283987045288,
0.08640652894973755,
0.2405925691127777,
-0.21588562428951263,
-0.183082714676857,
-0.11566995084285736,
0.4981352388858795,
0.13269691169261932,
-0.16431599855422974,
-0.6102942228317261,
0.0709460973739624,
0.8078197836875916,
0.6183300018310547,
-0.5133417248725891,
0.18664923310279846,
0.03780999407172203,
0.7149927616119385,
-0.4208360016345978,
-0.24088844656944275,
-0.5864196419715881,
0.14985303580760956,
0.10743004083633423,
0.01570514589548111,
-0.4624459147453308,
-0.21304680407047272,
-0.1722048670053482,
-0.29534876346588135,
0.4925931394100189,
-0.10047426074743271,
0.33768513798713684,
0.5900567173957825,
-0.06641381233930588,
-0.33077430725097656,
-1.159497857093811,
0.5504394769668579,
-0.7748041152954102,
0.7389589548110962,
0.1322634071111679,
0.25194627046585083,
0.018891358748078346,
-0.7722505331039429,
-0.7080901861190796,
0.0556134395301342,
0.19635027647018433,
0.18218468129634857,
-0.6300385594367981,
-0.11458827555179596,
-0.010354201309382915,
0.5313464403152466,
-0.5959885716438293,
-0.027183840051293373,
-0.29404786229133606,
-0.11038517206907272,
0.4197014570236206,
0.0011431414168328047,
0.15256443619728088,
-0.175594761967659,
-0.1013796254992485,
-0.44204244017601013,
-0.472115695476532,
-0.09519346803426743,
0.5752629637718201,
0.17328521609306335,
-0.13095371425151825,
0.4382774233818054,
0.10988860577344894,
0.5853574275970459,
0.3015015125274658,
0.0636994019150734,
0.15538015961647034,
-0.24238266050815582,
-0.15965865552425385,
0.13992799818515778,
0.9794296026229858,
-0.19834206998348236,
-0.23433443903923035,
-0.08345584571361542,
-0.3651801347732544,
0.16518092155456543,
0.1494399607181549,
-0.9084696173667908,
-0.4632086157798767,
0.3506278097629547,
-0.4050840139389038,
-0.2404424548149109,
-0.2349816858768463,
-0.9449659585952759,
0.174454003572464,
-0.04903512820601463,
0.3272106349468231,
-0.3606676459312439,
-0.36283203959465027,
0.16677150130271912,
-0.21117918193340302,
-0.18804611265659332,
0.041262537240982056,
-0.8379117846488953,
0.2633024752140045,
0.17753462493419647,
1.0548663139343262,
-0.3596009612083435,
-0.04570625349879265,
-0.8860082626342773,
0.10532554239034653,
-0.42594796419143677,
0.8136323094367981,
-0.4731937646865845,
-0.9363088607788086,
-0.19231753051280975,
-0.3531228303909302,
0.12392178922891617,
-0.48847803473472595,
0.5582898855209351,
-0.254383385181427,
0.15477055311203003,
0.30306297540664673,
-0.4952617883682251,
0.2690715491771698,
-0.3688163459300995,
-0.674998939037323,
0.90395188331604,
0.10890793800354004,
-0.3349420726299286,
0.2233934998512268,
-0.7253782153129578,
-0.525621235370636,
-0.19416594505310059,
-0.07956250756978989,
-0.5680640935897827,
0.12817919254302979,
0.18543490767478943,
0.36298057436943054,
0.004668156150728464,
0.20672497153282166,
0.08808760344982147,
-0.1123109683394432,
0.22654058039188385,
-1.0047340393066406,
0.3549068868160248,
0.4409537613391876,
-0.3713834881782532,
-0.07986687868833542,
-1.053401231765747,
-0.3740317225456238,
-0.05431346222758293,
-0.5592256188392639,
-0.15150350332260132,
0.00804924126714468,
0.20353442430496216,
0.1184365525841713,
-0.3208642601966858,
-0.5580374002456665,
0.019534911960363388,
-0.5739403367042542,
0.8322178721427917,
0.6745603680610657,
0.1435784250497818,
0.9155359268188477,
-0.14555485546588898,
0.6560682058334351,
0.08093206584453583,
-0.030750472098588943,
-0.522084653377533,
-0.4582003951072693,
-0.8594319224357605,
-0.45143210887908936,
0.5447561144828796,
0.3969111442565918,
-0.5792617201805115,
0.5447337627410889,
-0.06736194342374802,
-0.4545356035232544,
-0.7847592830657959,
-0.199769988656044,
0.07569034397602081,
0.7574409246444702,
0.543438732624054,
-0.2706485092639923,
-0.34573429822921753,
-0.6365105509757996,
0.004526170436292887,
-0.23019953072071075,
-0.3175908327102661,
0.16072362661361694,
0.2714892327785492,
-0.22567106783390045,
0.9521013498306274,
-0.3914344906806946,
-0.2296004742383957,
0.02871103398501873,
0.5183703303337097,
0.2800154685974121,
0.6791684031486511,
0.4951641857624054,
-0.6067789793014526,
-0.5335001349449158,
-0.1510583758354187,
-0.08633439242839813,
-0.3109906017780304,
0.0465213842689991,
-0.21905109286308289,
0.406707763671875,
0.5917622447013855,
-0.4941413998603821,
0.5075849294662476,
0.8399637341499329,
-0.2833482623100281,
0.3090019226074219,
-0.22621895372867584,
0.2222857028245926,
-1.0165773630142212,
0.3280602693557739,
-0.155760258436203,
-0.4734005928039551,
-0.7670671939849854,
-0.5768930315971375,
-0.12186539173126221,
-0.35925671458244324,
-0.4983865022659302,
0.578819751739502,
-0.24327081441879272,
0.05665602535009384,
-0.4888821244239807,
0.07198019325733185,
0.10823596268892288,
0.32338768243789673,
0.15552091598510742,
1.0884675979614258,
0.4073585867881775,
-0.7238354682922363,
0.06889786571264267,
0.4600578844547272,
-0.2659832835197449,
0.5101289749145508,
-0.8154400587081909,
0.10901127010583878,
-0.21855145692825317,
0.35830411314964294,
-1.1468052864074707,
0.05313821882009506,
0.22172844409942627,
-0.7331084609031677,
0.24963179230690002,
-0.24947310984134674,
-0.3191763460636139,
-0.057104725390672684,
0.0826636552810669,
0.45575034618377686,
1.0619465112686157,
-0.49785223603248596,
0.7420581579208374,
0.4114656448364258,
-0.45208415389060974,
-0.4389429986476898,
-0.8049574494361877,
0.07245036959648132,
-0.14498576521873474,
-0.24060417711734772,
0.32426995038986206,
-0.3593199849128723,
-0.029686521738767624,
0.077041395008564,
-0.03470318764448166,
0.03208119794726372,
-0.31912556290626526,
0.11568604409694672,
0.30429571866989136,
0.03227685019373894,
-0.0944807305932045,
0.3987329304218292,
-0.30581676959991455,
-0.014924976043403149,
-0.4210611879825592,
0.4578076899051666,
0.3654068112373352,
-0.42703860998153687,
-0.2926546037197113,
0.586596667766571,
0.6460522413253784,
-0.15628862380981445,
0.25834283232688904,
0.657497227191925,
0.006229020189493895,
-0.5293278694152832,
-0.4340255558490753,
-0.09918904304504395,
-0.48494574427604675,
0.2131561040878296,
-0.1188557967543602,
-0.8721795678138733,
0.4694685637950897,
-0.012597554363310337,
0.14799311757087708,
0.5433226823806763,
0.5809610486030579,
-0.10802320390939713,
1.1069254875183105,
0.42358237504959106,
0.06014759838581085,
0.6298885941505432,
-0.3773353099822998,
0.23907655477523804,
-0.8779858946800232,
0.14612680673599243,
-0.45060351490974426,
-0.19898684322834015,
-0.2965075671672821,
-0.49266859889030457,
0.6361703276634216,
-0.29008495807647705,
0.0497974269092083,
0.3346632421016693,
-0.9245347380638123,
0.23950719833374023,
0.5418828129768372,
-0.31104424595832825,
0.2918507754802704,
0.13980893790721893,
-0.0037845605984330177,
0.08391367644071579,
-0.7989364862442017,
-0.3323931097984314,
0.8982119560241699,
0.4278511106967926,
0.8612670302391052,
0.031224938109517097,
0.8079005479812622,
0.6121774315834045,
-0.010243929922580719,
-0.6489031314849854,
0.2880607545375824,
-0.29307296872138977,
-0.2916531264781952,
-0.2903291583061218,
-0.3126196563243866,
-0.762976348400116,
0.2232557237148285,
-0.2574339807033539,
-0.04987593740224838,
0.543550968170166,
0.2789873480796814,
-0.5072919726371765,
0.3680320680141449,
-0.5368238687515259,
0.4437096118927002,
0.32599130272865295,
-0.12187027931213379,
-0.022920267656445503,
-0.3578650951385498,
0.05101468041539192,
-0.17458322644233704,
0.38790225982666016,
-0.03922906145453453,
0.10157112777233124,
0.6227348446846008,
-0.16402295231819153,
0.7084300518035889,
-0.2901293933391571,
-0.28574153780937195,
0.23830640316009521,
0.32425457239151,
0.4646499752998352,
0.12140057981014252,
0.10992340743541718,
0.1643766462802887,
0.04522111266851425,
-0.05808957293629646,
-0.46061205863952637,
0.6176822185516357,
-0.445478230714798,
-0.4001860022544861,
-0.08040381222963333,
-0.33579105138778687,
-0.05281386524438858,
0.08414024114608765,
0.45647433400154114,
0.5815987586975098,
-0.4121917188167572,
-0.06603749841451645,
0.9068612456321716,
-0.23868873715400696,
0.8122720122337341,
0.3799312114715576,
-0.1582031399011612,
-0.6918366551399231,
0.717686653137207,
-0.07925306260585785,
0.5322800278663635,
0.2378215789794922,
0.119272880256176,
-0.2501908838748932,
-0.637180745601654,
-0.557246208190918,
0.08999218046665192,
-0.6365872025489807,
-0.17776039242744446,
-0.9307772517204285,
-0.33279523253440857,
-0.4545193016529083,
-0.0667240172624588,
-0.818055272102356,
-0.6956976056098938,
-0.4923607409000397,
0.11386101692914963,
0.28293001651763916,
0.6383042335510254,
-0.5058206915855408,
0.35872647166252136,
-0.7602859139442444,
0.527437150478363,
0.4664241671562195,
0.21034227311611176,
0.11671556532382965,
-0.8235745429992676,
-0.2940642833709717,
0.030823852866888046,
-0.03412892669439316,
-0.5525709986686707,
0.7924804091453552,
0.1891711950302124,
0.3309086263179779,
0.01213210728019476,
0.003426220268011093,
0.5090982913970947,
-1.1342658996582031,
0.8809338212013245,
0.23690013587474823,
-0.9346799254417419,
0.5752065777778625,
-0.16729721426963806,
0.4288443624973297,
0.30318546295166016,
-0.07203107327222824,
-0.6546078324317932,
-0.6964365839958191,
-0.4975668489933014,
-1.0149006843566895,
0.3796895444393158,
0.47273939847946167,
0.31470492482185364,
-0.2466728538274765,
0.36654403805732727,
0.1753537803888321,
0.09294430166482925,
-0.372301310300827,
-0.5179601907730103,
-0.5612956285476685,
-0.17117629945278168,
-0.05155320093035698,
-0.23248174786567688,
-0.04369272664189339,
-0.22334042191505432,
0.8985752463340759,
0.22181464731693268,
0.5293692946434021,
0.5098066329956055,
0.1092810332775116,
-0.17220750451087952,
0.4515047073364258,
0.7044165730476379,
0.2201865017414093,
-0.03704938292503357,
0.08422538638114929,
-0.14179183542728424,
-0.5933929681777954,
0.5314579606056213,
0.08384037762880325,
-0.11028892546892166,
0.5221919417381287,
0.03865187615156174,
0.8919283747673035,
-0.07316578179597855,
-0.4441632628440857,
0.5965363383293152,
-0.2401684671640396,
-0.4734237492084503,
-0.5597191452980042,
0.09192203730344772,
-0.005666696932166815,
0.23060090839862823,
0.48661425709724426,
0.3239067792892456,
0.43116554617881775,
-0.02607312612235546,
0.25104203820228577,
0.3799162209033966,
-0.2630281150341034,
-0.3893935978412628,
1.3299081325531006,
0.23366914689540863,
-0.6141882538795471,
0.42605844140052795,
0.013738074339926243,
0.05341901630163193,
0.19083066284656525,
0.40505310893058777,
1.1715521812438965,
-0.5039811134338379,
0.05247819423675537,
0.41367629170417786,
-0.0843086987733841,
-0.09136870503425598,
-0.1184760108590126,
-0.4647117257118225,
-0.3958306908607483,
-0.5545488595962524,
-0.9040167927742004,
-0.4832233190536499,
0.027010347694158554,
-0.5211640000343323,
0.12919025123119354,
-0.16617785394191742,
-0.31127288937568665,
0.0835123360157013,
-0.9296992421150208,
-0.23468948900699615,
0.12179676443338394,
0.15358957648277283,
0.6668873429298401,
-0.7810242772102356,
0.9129837155342102,
0.03704818710684776,
-0.2249930202960968,
-0.38448604941368103,
-0.052988193929195404,
-0.39182111620903015,
-0.5088579654693604,
0.5501192212104797,
-0.4403819739818573,
-0.5035037994384766,
0.27090534567832947,
-0.40926676988601685,
-0.7955117225646973,
0.8636528849601746,
0.28221142292022705,
-0.7843791246414185,
-0.2077074646949768,
0.12302017211914062,
0.40651723742485046,
-0.2752167582511902,
-0.17062890529632568,
0.6496755480766296,
0.2294188141822815,
0.47018590569496155,
-0.7482751607894897,
-0.4392889142036438,
-0.2853594422340393,
0.20301464200019836,
0.30519503355026245,
-0.26590728759765625,
0.7827255129814148,
0.22029002010822296,
-0.3300294280052185,
0.10658210515975952,
0.643064558506012,
0.08052907884120941,
-0.12048334628343582,
0.5012041330337524,
0.4898450970649719,
0.27659595012664795,
0.08810628950595856,
0.5687655806541443,
-0.48034167289733887,
0.18300357460975647,
0.9176203608512878,
0.0386112704873085,
0.9753611087799072,
0.6355587840080261,
-0.24204328656196594,
0.47751206159591675,
0.05000516027212143,
0.11150587350130081,
0.7577758431434631,
-0.17347027361392975,
-0.573108434677124,
-0.0068878005258738995,
0.2545768916606903,
-0.17044849693775177,
0.3376636207103729,
0.21426483988761902,
-0.5855305790901184,
-0.03574252128601074,
0.382512629032135,
-0.1591985672712326,
0.14999200403690338,
-0.07345785200595856,
0.753876805305481,
-0.04412844777107239,
-0.4514484703540802,
0.5280061960220337,
-0.19466285407543182,
0.8660556077957153,
-0.4859564006328583,
-0.3274933397769928,
-0.2324882447719574,
-0.13692595064640045,
0.04140891134738922,
-0.662619948387146,
0.5887826681137085,
0.08184079825878143,
-0.4390946626663208,
-0.6534266471862793,
0.49169325828552246,
-0.6700604557991028,
-0.545580267906189,
-0.015518435277044773,
0.3502982258796692,
-0.01772421784698963,
0.1820078045129776,
-0.40771055221557617,
0.15010559558868408,
-0.10885490477085114,
-0.2953992486000061,
0.1066681444644928,
0.22992822527885437,
0.5436769127845764,
0.373748779296875,
0.7973442673683167,
0.497747540473938,
0.09323280304670334,
0.09219151735305786,
0.6298076510429382,
-0.5012076497077942,
-0.6933189034461975,
-0.8751533031463623,
0.6149348020553589,
0.27482861280441284,
0.14716096222400665,
0.4789254665374756,
0.579846203327179,
0.5176263451576233,
-0.05157698690891266,
0.9842034578323364,
-0.02215544320642948,
0.8904854655265808,
-0.5522176623344421,
0.9489569067955017,
-0.31748032569885254,
0.21580807864665985,
-0.1719198375940323,
-0.8400518298149109,
-0.1592714637517929,
0.6136681437492371,
0.13029572367668152,
-0.1456747204065323,
0.36653655767440796,
0.6111475229263306,
-0.14971080422401428,
-0.3394630551338196,
0.5708635449409485,
0.1511334925889969,
0.4831404387950897,
0.2704818844795227,
0.6123839020729065,
-0.6963870525360107,
0.6668722629547119,
-0.11359516531229019,
-0.13053330779075623,
0.2156475931406021,
-0.734582781791687,
-0.6011499762535095,
-0.8723036646842957,
-0.39112889766693115,
-0.38378089666366577,
-0.12040229141712189,
0.5378549695014954,
0.7365005612373352,
-0.6523562073707581,
-0.24163708090782166,
-0.33377984166145325,
-0.22624094784259796,
0.027266671881079674,
-0.2457522749900818,
0.3094632923603058,
-0.28022438287734985,
-1.1504074335098267,
0.6953165531158447,
0.5139031410217285,
0.4433468282222748,
-0.609571635723114,
-0.06858538091182709,
-0.04796506464481354,
0.37538743019104004,
0.5742657780647278,
0.3464372754096985,
-0.5579172968864441,
-0.09242386370897293,
0.01261721272021532,
0.1934938132762909,
0.44770577549934387,
0.6416503190994263,
-0.8830735683441162,
0.6418527364730835,
0.43072155117988586,
0.4064010977745056,
0.7955134510993958,
-0.09584145992994308,
0.5330073833465576,
-0.6313464045524597,
0.2706576883792877,
0.4032459557056427,
0.20243427157402039,
0.28697672486305237,
-0.24071498215198517,
0.1847144216299057,
0.03839845210313797,
-0.7914968729019165,
-0.8701084852218628,
0.20412832498550415,
-0.7839595079421997,
-0.1894959658384323,
1.1877028942108154,
0.2579016089439392,
-0.34159350395202637,
0.09953268617391586,
-0.2237119972705841,
0.4483169913291931,
-0.5924847722053528,
0.6149525046348572,
0.5323281288146973,
-0.4047454297542572,
-0.23059888184070587,
-0.4812059998512268,
0.5536854267120361,
0.12872113287448883,
-0.25697576999664307,
0.28449347615242004,
0.65853351354599,
0.36378881335258484,
0.09110748022794724,
0.8269690275192261,
-0.2716819643974304,
0.25577786564826965,
0.1848457306623459,
0.21952424943447113,
-0.07303036004304886,
-0.12256843596696854,
-0.6435877680778503,
0.06018448248505592,
0.001685240538790822,
-0.30968913435935974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05547v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05547v1
|
Exploring the Benefits of Tokenization of Discrete Acoustic Units
| 2024-06-08T18:34:28 | 2024-06-08T18:34:28 |
Avihu Dekel, Raul Fernandez
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Tokenization algorithms that merge the units of a base vocabulary into
larger, variable-rate units have become standard in natural language processing
tasks. This idea, however, has been mostly overlooked when the vocabulary
consists of phonemes or Discrete Acoustic Units (DAUs), an audio-based
representation that is playing an increasingly important role due to the
success of discrete language-modeling techniques. In this paper, we showcase
the advantages of tokenization of phonetic units and of DAUs on three
prediction tasks: grapheme-to-phoneme, grapheme-to-DAUs, and unsupervised
speech generation using DAU language modeling. We demonstrate that tokenization
yields significant improvements in terms of performance, as well as training
and inference speed, across all three tasks. We also offer theoretical insights
to provide some explanation for the superior performance observed.
|
[
-0.4878847599029541,
-0.42548197507858276,
0.4898654818534851,
-0.02354538068175316,
-0.5014440417289734,
0.3086724877357483,
-0.23750971257686615,
-0.5222306847572327,
0.39644554257392883,
0.08039826899766922,
0.07814621925354004,
-0.2987723648548126,
-0.32817044854164124,
0.15911270678043365,
-0.3144283592700958,
0.5657868981361389,
0.46040692925453186,
0.32412809133529663,
-0.1425274908542633,
0.05621175840497017,
-0.8682414293289185,
-0.9476538300514221,
-0.9806599617004395,
-0.4339166581630707,
0.6730473041534424,
0.19907867908477783,
0.6787638664245605,
0.8478298783302307,
0.33766499161720276,
0.3773004412651062,
0.011252985335886478,
-0.11502907425165176,
0.063972607254982,
-0.037964485585689545,
0.343678742647171,
-0.47843924164772034,
-0.7860279083251953,
0.3312855362892151,
0.9291110038757324,
1.2289141416549683,
-0.28747937083244324,
-0.1776404082775116,
-0.20536355674266815,
0.42844513058662415,
-0.16873255372047424,
0.26908108592033386,
-0.7507889270782471,
-0.27509114146232605,
-0.4619806408882141,
-0.14728420972824097,
-0.3379918336868286,
-0.2083248794078827,
-0.0459885336458683,
-0.8192656636238098,
-0.16411274671554565,
-0.21587607264518738,
0.4683098793029785,
0.3970243036746979,
-0.4757464826107025,
-0.26552507281303406,
-0.9155377149581909,
0.9660607576370239,
-0.9331068396568298,
0.6088287234306335,
0.47359126806259155,
0.1929141730070114,
-0.12005377560853958,
-0.9013111591339111,
-0.7570170164108276,
0.04407164454460144,
-0.3258153200149536,
0.024127300828695297,
-0.291276216506958,
0.4552454650402069,
0.03749086707830429,
0.5189356207847595,
-0.09704656898975372,
0.40968507528305054,
-0.3045581877231598,
-0.11771982908248901,
0.6345767974853516,
-0.21840177476406097,
0.42368680238723755,
-0.33005785942077637,
-0.26732364296913147,
-0.15289974212646484,
-0.2911849617958069,
0.15576396882534027,
0.5037437081336975,
0.5268392562866211,
-0.022165942937135696,
0.23416860401630402,
0.20915831625461578,
0.6453494429588318,
-0.029416296631097794,
-0.4501137435436249,
0.4247671365737915,
-0.2997763156890869,
-0.09581708163022995,
0.4532683789730072,
0.5426137447357178,
-0.10715796053409576,
0.07822719216346741,
-0.5671284198760986,
-0.34530264139175415,
0.462949275970459,
0.10187115520238876,
-0.6650246977806091,
0.023627962917089462,
0.4186083972454071,
-0.33836570382118225,
-0.3693365156650543,
0.1707732379436493,
-0.22512279450893402,
0.11152642965316772,
-0.7262098789215088,
0.1313515305519104,
-0.4877813160419464,
-0.5448958277702332,
0.2749963402748108,
-0.4867272973060608,
-0.17249536514282227,
0.18789708614349365,
-1.3004450798034668,
0.8612417578697205,
0.932432234287262,
0.8214201331138611,
-0.37383463978767395,
-0.025191815569996834,
-0.8292738795280457,
-0.054380469024181366,
-0.6971546411514282,
0.6132054924964905,
-0.6005463004112244,
-0.8112351298332214,
-0.40046942234039307,
-0.6715306639671326,
-0.32723021507263184,
-0.6347866654396057,
0.5341435670852661,
-0.2961995303630829,
-0.12203971296548843,
-0.29855263233184814,
-0.5890330076217651,
-0.14947178959846497,
-0.4675518870353699,
-0.8308479189872742,
1.3165321350097656,
0.04999366030097008,
-0.4283720552921295,
0.5409049391746521,
-0.8951149582862854,
-0.5296424031257629,
0.4861143231391907,
-0.44504114985466003,
-0.04265924543142319,
0.5779517292976379,
0.05816963315010071,
0.3568536043167114,
0.12105591595172882,
0.3099987804889679,
0.15467330813407898,
-0.5273288488388062,
0.45611849427223206,
-0.511812150478363,
0.560174822807312,
0.1703566163778305,
-0.49981996417045593,
0.006076422519981861,
-0.783761739730835,
-0.16191427409648895,
-0.2881312668323517,
-0.5598263740539551,
-0.6265941858291626,
0.023224951699376106,
-0.03137509897351265,
-0.1709568053483963,
-0.11500521004199982,
-0.7759242653846741,
0.09522813558578491,
-0.5628634691238403,
0.5960252285003662,
0.5956851243972778,
-0.21264421939849854,
0.7446487545967102,
-0.23238816857337952,
0.3009984791278839,
0.11437322944402695,
-0.16206477582454681,
-0.2773861289024353,
-0.708812415599823,
-0.4379664361476898,
-0.8496865630149841,
0.8840106725692749,
0.09390079230070114,
-0.573191225528717,
0.21299278736114502,
-0.35590437054634094,
-0.32392647862434387,
-0.47901037335395813,
-0.22871187329292297,
0.031296420842409134,
0.3262750506401062,
0.15045325458049774,
-0.5504741668701172,
-0.6383503675460815,
-0.3376416862010956,
0.1455671191215515,
-0.6245198845863342,
-0.21944034099578857,
0.4241863787174225,
0.01048359926789999,
-0.10638976097106934,
1.0759072303771973,
-0.11302214115858078,
-0.2524322271347046,
0.044843852519989014,
0.4758426249027252,
0.09477770328521729,
0.4225694537162781,
0.6889888644218445,
-0.952992856502533,
-0.17109236121177673,
0.24679358303546906,
-0.4855518043041229,
-0.17123396694660187,
-0.21433426439762115,
0.27143722772598267,
0.19779065251350403,
0.69910728931427,
-0.6159472465515137,
0.3983422517776489,
0.49543216824531555,
-0.1776021420955658,
0.5183704495429993,
-0.10648459941148758,
0.10511184483766556,
-0.7894237041473389,
-0.03237135335803032,
-0.33090007305145264,
-0.3154819905757904,
-0.9325922727584839,
-0.4070090055465698,
-0.2781533896923065,
-0.2365383803844452,
-0.3461552560329437,
0.5812093615531921,
-0.4604342579841614,
-0.5423539280891418,
-0.33130303025245667,
0.4675328731536865,
-0.13390588760375977,
0.32044875621795654,
-0.006894276011735201,
0.9479742646217346,
0.5253404378890991,
-0.747635543346405,
0.29369670152664185,
-0.049971260130405426,
-0.08049648255109787,
0.2500709295272827,
-0.6114261150360107,
0.45436787605285645,
0.09160946309566498,
0.17270511388778687,
-1.0292025804519653,
0.037979818880558014,
-0.38644006848335266,
-0.7000293731689453,
0.30188387632369995,
0.08372708410024643,
-0.4528994858264923,
-0.3606939911842346,
-0.0986068919301033,
0.7774775624275208,
0.46064281463623047,
-0.6626827716827393,
0.6970228552818298,
0.6182582974433899,
-0.1679253876209259,
-0.3321075737476349,
-0.6028679013252258,
0.28190502524375916,
-0.49086469411849976,
-0.27967140078544617,
0.8308963179588318,
-0.08463028818368912,
-0.6379474997520447,
0.08666175603866577,
-0.10601214319467545,
0.13595223426818848,
0.34994998574256897,
0.4773186147212982,
0.28541305661201477,
-0.23239116370677948,
0.5612843632698059,
-0.23294025659561157,
-0.4387510120868683,
-0.0525563508272171,
-0.6255699992179871,
0.6124587655067444,
-0.16248121857643127,
-0.15720607340335846,
-0.5426681637763977,
0.1958666443824768,
0.6737134456634521,
-0.3940591812133789,
0.29388439655303955,
0.5219367146492004,
-0.5723932981491089,
-0.03916752338409424,
-0.4812570810317993,
-0.2335677146911621,
-0.5051488280296326,
0.06700246781110764,
-0.535657525062561,
-0.5801852941513062,
0.3839063048362732,
-0.15910108387470245,
0.08756868541240692,
0.27710071206092834,
0.328201562166214,
-0.009305630810558796,
0.8932486772537231,
0.38638344407081604,
-0.28400319814682007,
0.5871546268463135,
-0.30305030941963196,
0.3318353295326233,
-0.6599573493003845,
-0.11655855923891068,
-0.5405953526496887,
-0.2524716556072235,
-0.6025643944740295,
-0.5967847108840942,
0.34706923365592957,
0.2210538238286972,
0.31867435574531555,
0.32277408242225647,
-0.33187633752822876,
0.20845001935958862,
0.7665786147117615,
-0.23121334612369537,
0.405243456363678,
0.1050228625535965,
-0.350903183221817,
0.01807740144431591,
-0.7521529197692871,
-0.5819328427314758,
0.9311537146568298,
0.5181565284729004,
0.1126086488366127,
0.00866838451474905,
1.0472301244735718,
0.36939868330955505,
-0.12522590160369873,
-1.320579171180725,
0.4962785840034485,
-0.41906654834747314,
-0.20989447832107544,
-0.8324368596076965,
-0.420073539018631,
-1.149611473083496,
0.3906574547290802,
-0.1240086704492569,
-0.6132960915565491,
0.5147289037704468,
-0.14360001683235168,
-0.505354106426239,
0.45055556297302246,
-0.5706635117530823,
0.270737886428833,
-0.13710978627204895,
0.4071037769317627,
-0.44265973567962646,
0.05003449320793152,
-0.12564142048358917,
-0.3527162969112396,
0.44610968232154846,
-0.17106294631958008,
-0.09600905328989029,
1.038704514503479,
-0.5290734767913818,
0.7329744696617126,
-0.2791275978088379,
0.1444878876209259,
0.41413578391075134,
-0.3425118923187256,
0.05979129299521446,
0.0634005069732666,
-0.3343641459941864,
0.5431962609291077,
-0.057570815086364746,
-0.2944241464138031,
-0.6383705139160156,
0.6612669229507446,
-0.6969508528709412,
-0.38077008724212646,
-0.24880042672157288,
-0.6572473049163818,
-0.2483423948287964,
0.2005298137664795,
-0.0027223078068345785,
0.9004684090614319,
-0.2765273451805115,
0.09668780863285065,
0.26204219460487366,
0.12526816129684448,
1.0284825563430786,
0.05390853062272072,
-0.23628321290016174,
-0.5988219380378723,
0.9368432760238647,
0.4746372401714325,
0.15431751310825348,
0.07371018826961517,
0.35012203454971313,
-0.26618316769599915,
-0.6759816408157349,
-0.5261760950088501,
0.3467281460762024,
-0.41205233335494995,
-0.1784379780292511,
-0.3754045367240906,
0.04288819432258606,
-0.5452131032943726,
0.02137271873652935,
-0.3721574544906616,
-0.8081966638565063,
-0.37908443808555603,
-0.4740819036960602,
0.23639090359210968,
0.9941293001174927,
-0.5719214677810669,
0.47517767548561096,
-0.4573080837726593,
0.31050917506217957,
0.6187075972557068,
0.23643122613430023,
0.04606546834111214,
-0.27879559993743896,
-0.3612065017223358,
-0.010321169160306454,
0.09854914993047714,
-0.688671350479126,
0.23580341041088104,
0.1795303374528885,
0.6914180517196655,
0.3947172164916992,
-0.08276139199733734,
0.7018409967422485,
-0.6559500694274902,
0.7633563876152039,
0.4414117932319641,
-1.1331919431686401,
0.27316814661026,
-0.2937461733818054,
0.04970874264836311,
0.18491411209106445,
0.0714525580406189,
-0.7528998255729675,
-0.17866599559783936,
-0.7370426654815674,
-0.759743332862854,
0.4915093183517456,
0.4790479242801666,
0.21754467487335205,
-0.5287993550300598,
0.34301111102104187,
-0.017078423872590065,
0.18115924298763275,
-0.18681690096855164,
-0.43120482563972473,
-0.24091503024101257,
0.06045028194785118,
-0.15900373458862305,
-0.28339797258377075,
0.10275814682245255,
-0.24414165318012238,
0.716357946395874,
-0.08645325154066086,
0.20724037289619446,
0.2097196877002716,
0.19518738985061646,
-0.04045947268605232,
0.2696952521800995,
0.39567476511001587,
0.37921151518821716,
0.011768068186938763,
0.19109413027763367,
0.2210269719362259,
-0.7053925395011902,
0.18737544119358063,
0.1773585081100464,
0.031946662813425064,
0.5996856093406677,
0.30955174565315247,
1.0903961658477783,
0.45393773913383484,
-0.17039291560649872,
0.3189704716205597,
-0.2201651632785797,
-0.2654179334640503,
-0.19381745159626007,
-0.21982410550117493,
0.0849393978714943,
-0.04189462959766388,
0.7638601064682007,
0.03315717726945877,
0.2609822154045105,
-0.5893809795379639,
0.31890684366226196,
0.37924978137016296,
-0.20717351138591766,
-0.5396774411201477,
0.6620718240737915,
0.4291531443595886,
-0.47622525691986084,
0.4277823269367218,
-0.16786767542362213,
-0.1696283221244812,
0.6638696789741516,
0.5290636420249939,
0.7357534170150757,
-0.543315052986145,
0.3209303319454193,
0.29445406794548035,
-0.08319751918315887,
0.13006851077079773,
0.010445840656757355,
-0.2767922878265381,
-0.7808658480644226,
-0.3735661208629608,
-0.7579618096351624,
-0.29060351848602295,
0.11424445360898972,
-0.7677634358406067,
0.15132007002830505,
-0.28350841999053955,
-0.7893967032432556,
0.45794597268104553,
-0.002735244808718562,
-0.5151517987251282,
0.3401423692703247,
0.617132842540741,
0.7348966598510742,
-0.6157509088516235,
0.9574915170669556,
0.5496082901954651,
-0.07815933972597122,
-1.213879942893982,
-0.30894580483436584,
-0.12930549681186676,
-0.4182778298854828,
0.816906750202179,
-0.0005586519255302846,
-0.1325741410255432,
0.10239283740520477,
0.3189697563648224,
-0.9161414504051208,
1.0172131061553955,
0.43113377690315247,
-0.7410959005355835,
-0.1901073008775711,
0.4682294428348541,
0.3781680762767792,
-0.5050979852676392,
0.12262282520532608,
0.9780788421630859,
0.37937119603157043,
0.005512380972504616,
-1.3174259662628174,
-0.2681073844432831,
0.01623949036002159,
0.34704509377479553,
0.17494811117649078,
-0.2537856101989746,
0.9146504402160645,
-0.16974011063575745,
-0.4891084134578705,
0.003002337645739317,
0.750055193901062,
0.04240335524082184,
0.2740590274333954,
0.9315468668937683,
0.42153990268707275,
1.4225832223892212,
-0.38345593214035034,
0.9839902520179749,
-0.25183722376823425,
-0.08069548010826111,
0.8560352325439453,
0.030937891453504562,
0.952079713344574,
0.5312572717666626,
-0.2496090829372406,
0.6725598573684692,
0.5057940483093262,
0.3872496783733368,
0.3314201533794403,
0.19075629115104675,
-0.7049946188926697,
-0.013235697522759438,
-0.30912280082702637,
-0.2680756747722626,
0.9224460124969482,
0.3094223439693451,
0.06905950605869293,
0.15145085752010345,
0.20180164277553558,
-0.08784946799278259,
0.2210381031036377,
-0.4075304865837097,
0.9947629570960999,
0.3315410912036896,
-0.39483919739723206,
0.6084682941436768,
-0.02013922482728958,
0.6613847613334656,
-0.34180182218551636,
-0.054993242025375366,
-0.21414154767990112,
-0.17862772941589355,
-0.25399908423423767,
-0.07427944242954254,
0.29766514897346497,
-0.2584560513496399,
-0.1326206624507904,
-0.26248857378959656,
0.7074133157730103,
-0.3385773003101349,
-0.440144807100296,
0.42300933599472046,
0.295217365026474,
0.4285081624984741,
-0.09088718146085739,
-0.24111098051071167,
0.0423441156744957,
-0.2955182194709778,
0.11242648214101791,
0.08279197663068771,
0.5379291772842407,
-0.1594255119562149,
0.20486147701740265,
0.8775486946105957,
0.5729693174362183,
0.15803684294223785,
0.45704251527786255,
0.7182675004005432,
-0.5242301821708679,
-0.6576755046844482,
-0.7204574942588806,
0.434314489364624,
-0.004166422411799431,
-0.027196349576115608,
0.6260470151901245,
0.7109382748603821,
0.8494940400123596,
0.21284937858581543,
0.8475559949874878,
0.32686343789100647,
0.4018949270248413,
-0.4197046756744385,
0.48050764203071594,
-0.12538203597068787,
0.36958611011505127,
-0.1941133588552475,
-0.6731487512588501,
-0.20827654004096985,
0.42053133249282837,
-0.2505260407924652,
-0.12714120745658875,
0.6497563123703003,
0.32104191184043884,
0.18809184432029724,
-0.004309924319386482,
0.8256615996360779,
-0.12994325160980225,
0.3122515380382538,
-0.10496341437101364,
0.4530586302280426,
-0.597476601600647,
0.24655193090438843,
-0.3736841678619385,
-0.1720452904701233,
0.16072256863117218,
-0.5658420324325562,
-0.7592400908470154,
-0.7905110716819763,
-0.3326253294944763,
0.13764935731887817,
-0.16280938684940338,
0.5881807208061218,
1.0857234001159668,
-0.7250667810440063,
-0.6151368618011475,
-0.09978575259447098,
0.03456725925207138,
-0.351203590631485,
-0.14806236326694489,
0.2684086263179779,
-0.6578769087791443,
-1.072820782661438,
0.7847265005111694,
0.31242451071739197,
0.32366523146629333,
0.03554278612136841,
-0.288673460483551,
0.12546411156654358,
0.40189290046691895,
0.6703669428825378,
0.13123847544193268,
-0.8076252937316895,
-0.16176311671733856,
-0.010993320494890213,
0.026069169864058495,
0.32555249333381653,
1.0023409128189087,
-1.1870139837265015,
0.4050113260746002,
0.11845264583826065,
0.4181031584739685,
0.4803096354007721,
0.1466192752122879,
0.8345968127250671,
-0.9508653283119202,
0.399314284324646,
0.1409178078174591,
0.5694429874420166,
0.5126643180847168,
-0.3211379647254944,
0.6032092571258545,
0.3280356824398041,
-0.29469209909439087,
-1.1002708673477173,
0.07731085270643234,
-0.9353141188621521,
-0.2510635554790497,
1.041743278503418,
0.005489204544574022,
-0.03904983401298523,
-0.2042868733406067,
-0.19415846467018127,
0.5363719463348389,
-0.49865034222602844,
0.48971378803253174,
0.510210394859314,
0.028257768601179123,
0.26301127672195435,
-0.3981681168079376,
0.7284566164016724,
0.37650513648986816,
-0.7207047343254089,
-0.017306655645370483,
0.2508857250213623,
-0.04109364375472069,
0.5256506204605103,
1.001105546951294,
-0.20328432321548462,
0.22495101392269135,
0.29399818181991577,
0.04068240895867348,
-0.04280271753668785,
-0.2550480365753174,
-0.4195850193500519,
-0.2039833515882492,
0.26483625173568726,
-0.6737332940101624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05540v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05540v1
|
A Fine-tuning Dataset and Benchmark for Large Language Models for Protein Understanding
| 2024-06-08T18:11:30 | 2024-06-08T18:11:30 |
Yiqing Shen, Zan Chen, Michail Mamalakis, Luhan He, Haiyang Xia, Tianbin Li, Yanzhou Su, Junjun He, Yu Guang Wang
|
q-bio.QM
|
q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The parallels between protein sequences and natural language in their
sequential structures have inspired the application of large language models
(LLMs) to protein understanding. Despite the success of LLMs in NLP, their
effectiveness in comprehending protein sequences remains an open question,
largely due to the absence of datasets linking protein sequences to descriptive
text. Researchers have then attempted to adapt LLMs for protein understanding
by integrating a protein sequence encoder with a pre-trained LLM. However, this
adaptation raises a fundamental question: "Can LLMs, originally designed for
NLP, effectively comprehend protein sequences as a form of language?" Current
datasets fall short in addressing this question due to the lack of a direct
correlation between protein sequences and corresponding text descriptions,
limiting the ability to train and evaluate LLMs for protein understanding
effectively. To bridge this gap, we introduce ProteinLMDataset, a dataset
specifically designed for further self-supervised pretraining and supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) of LLMs to enhance their capability for protein sequence
comprehension. Specifically, ProteinLMDataset includes 17.46 billion tokens for
pretraining and 893,000 instructions for SFT. Additionally, we present
ProteinLMBench, the first benchmark dataset consisting of 944 manually verified
multiple-choice questions for assessing the protein understanding capabilities
of LLMs. ProteinLMBench incorporates protein-related details and sequences in
multiple languages, establishing a new standard for evaluating LLMs' abilities
in protein comprehension. The large language model InternLM2-7B, pretrained and
fine-tuned on the ProteinLMDataset, outperforms GPT-4 on ProteinLMBench,
achieving the highest accuracy score. The dataset and the benchmark are
available at https://huggingface.co/datasets/tsynbio/ProteinLMBench.
|
[
-0.3066892623901367,
-0.5945537090301514,
0.4691034257411957,
0.09785838425159454,
-0.4439280331134796,
0.0873747244477272,
-0.021156109869480133,
-0.3337641656398773,
0.006098234094679356,
0.41523706912994385,
-0.644179105758667,
-0.4960598647594452,
-0.7033596634864807,
0.5336852669715881,
-0.3555629849433899,
1.0198384523391724,
0.024680087342858315,
0.38398632407188416,
-0.20084738731384277,
-0.17855292558670044,
-0.33819106221199036,
-0.3148181438446045,
-0.37621966004371643,
-0.5667866468429565,
0.6317287087440491,
0.19422918558120728,
0.47045087814331055,
0.8095390796661377,
0.5087010860443115,
0.17458932101726532,
-0.046027764678001404,
0.2351589798927307,
-0.738551139831543,
0.04929741844534874,
-0.444048136472702,
-0.4254635274410248,
-0.48251739144325256,
-0.16974301636219025,
0.5001887679100037,
1.127917766571045,
0.21987363696098328,
0.2812023162841797,
0.2714936435222626,
1.0110763311386108,
-0.5711584091186523,
0.29337185621261597,
-0.5755913257598877,
0.18676628172397614,
-0.4185104966163635,
-0.2379089593887329,
-0.33996132016181946,
0.07415717095136642,
0.07410724461078644,
-0.3272472620010376,
0.27918848395347595,
0.1730385273694992,
0.6318283081054688,
0.4520914554595947,
-0.4639284908771515,
-0.08385100215673447,
-0.1998337358236313,
0.3615747094154358,
-0.6989184021949768,
0.6936625838279724,
0.5822833776473999,
0.07350073754787445,
-0.5511761903762817,
-0.7986679673194885,
-0.2606065273284912,
-0.10455092042684555,
-0.036434195935726166,
0.160972461104393,
0.057370174676179886,
0.17951832711696625,
0.37215161323547363,
0.46123412251472473,
-1.220386266708374,
0.24934746325016022,
-0.3131259083747864,
-0.04389791190624237,
0.5305090546607971,
0.01117301918566227,
0.014115173369646072,
-0.24166420102119446,
0.007906680926680565,
-0.0715218186378479,
-0.7265349626541138,
-0.15300573408603668,
0.0349770113825798,
0.20674479007720947,
0.18485940992832184,
0.6253979802131653,
-0.4062145948410034,
1.0484369993209839,
-0.019207706674933434,
0.26647886633872986,
0.27832937240600586,
-0.10433976352214813,
-0.46184805035591125,
0.14170107245445251,
0.47570332884788513,
0.30289533734321594,
0.2487204223871231,
-0.31184738874435425,
-0.10920616239309311,
-0.28437599539756775,
0.2079424113035202,
-0.9745707511901855,
-0.49879390001296997,
0.5191770195960999,
-0.5887971520423889,
0.05261949822306633,
0.20259606838226318,
-0.5029054284095764,
-0.41043657064437866,
-0.4735065996646881,
0.46947070956230164,
-0.4707903265953064,
0.2542349100112915,
0.5289539098739624,
-0.07636139541864395,
0.308217853307724,
0.029438085854053497,
-0.8317286968231201,
0.2023106962442398,
0.8261458873748779,
0.8816164135932922,
-0.38459503650665283,
-0.4456680119037628,
-0.6760743260383606,
0.28929877281188965,
-0.15482547879219055,
0.7086489200592041,
-0.45732632279396057,
0.034704238176345825,
-0.1857827603816986,
0.18193045258522034,
-0.05104687809944153,
-0.5783627033233643,
0.34869569540023804,
-0.6663076281547546,
-0.26822370290756226,
-0.12745949625968933,
-1.1679902076721191,
-0.2854374051094055,
0.05549643933773041,
-0.6433078646659851,
0.5663003325462341,
-0.047971174120903015,
-0.7114689946174622,
0.344758003950119,
-0.4817412197589874,
-0.6169456839561462,
0.20609228312969208,
-0.09077949821949005,
-0.08780482411384583,
0.3661448657512665,
0.3386748135089874,
0.5434805750846863,
-0.2249622344970703,
0.3267916738986969,
-0.528115451335907,
-0.3178500831127167,
0.259636253118515,
-0.14787840843200684,
0.4131810963153839,
0.21642187237739563,
0.10294842720031738,
0.11148958653211594,
-0.9541168808937073,
0.31166261434555054,
-0.040013473480939865,
-0.1301882117986679,
-0.06860847771167755,
-0.043584294617176056,
-0.2957368493080139,
0.11282157152891159,
0.16411703824996948,
-0.23144185543060303,
0.3678623139858246,
-0.37163618206977844,
0.713984489440918,
0.6760877966880798,
0.017203768715262413,
0.1521443873643875,
-0.17847895622253418,
0.310390442609787,
-0.3153565227985382,
-0.0034968440886586905,
-0.33021989464759827,
-0.15520472824573517,
-0.6446841359138489,
-0.0928264707326889,
0.26825278997421265,
0.3570055365562439,
-0.42484545707702637,
0.6197128891944885,
-0.19859886169433594,
-0.29153862595558167,
-0.6152083873748779,
0.3825298845767975,
0.19504676759243011,
0.4658209979534149,
0.6980864405632019,
-0.33062607049942017,
-0.5898362398147583,
-0.8894957900047302,
-0.41628652811050415,
0.20291514694690704,
-0.475542813539505,
0.12075715512037277,
0.6360039710998535,
-0.2050919085741043,
0.6055985689163208,
-0.38737431168556213,
-0.18179015815258026,
-0.1647537350654602,
0.08114451169967651,
0.6762268543243408,
0.37394630908966064,
0.14755482971668243,
-0.6040651798248291,
-0.40571728348731995,
-0.1638922244310379,
-0.7390350699424744,
-0.3091779053211212,
-0.028561599552631378,
-0.11354384571313858,
-0.2713979184627533,
0.7076365351676941,
-0.3896234929561615,
0.22030651569366455,
0.6657723784446716,
-0.22396638989448547,
0.48452141880989075,
-0.30556729435920715,
-0.03458729013800621,
-0.7587777972221375,
0.23410998284816742,
-0.25893041491508484,
-0.2395549714565277,
-0.534243106842041,
0.0068044159561395645,
0.2316906452178955,
0.10646268725395203,
-0.36504125595092773,
0.49615806341171265,
-0.4647478461265564,
-0.29408037662506104,
-0.3861514925956726,
0.0037189999129623175,
0.18456342816352844,
0.274869829416275,
-0.0749259740114212,
0.6623272895812988,
0.5028872489929199,
-0.5426290035247803,
0.19544994831085205,
0.5419256687164307,
-0.5503284931182861,
0.32673510909080505,
-0.8763837814331055,
0.25127893686294556,
-0.20888566970825195,
0.29375582933425903,
-0.6415784955024719,
-0.45953285694122314,
0.10293099284172058,
-0.12959767878055573,
0.2583463191986084,
-0.21733714640140533,
-0.4622992277145386,
-0.4291419982910156,
-0.2260993868112564,
0.227219820022583,
0.20421040058135986,
-0.5826026797294617,
0.3079407215118408,
0.09801509231328964,
-0.21248716115951538,
-0.4139975905418396,
-0.6736563444137573,
0.03689814358949661,
0.03884747624397278,
-0.5030510425567627,
0.3076847195625305,
-0.2633584141731262,
0.17785851657390594,
-0.3909185230731964,
-0.4483473598957062,
0.025089940056204796,
-0.10706599056720734,
0.22315019369125366,
-0.0822797417640686,
-0.06628815829753876,
0.4317968785762787,
0.01219391543418169,
-0.09998757392168045,
-0.08004685491323471,
-0.5464705228805542,
0.7601038217544556,
-0.11237139999866486,
-0.28537189960479736,
-0.30887338519096375,
0.06671175360679626,
0.22651222348213196,
-0.38662368059158325,
0.7515351176261902,
0.4988991618156433,
-0.002517073880881071,
-0.27198106050491333,
-0.3440631628036499,
-0.39729076623916626,
-0.44144532084465027,
0.6532269716262817,
-0.5735366344451904,
-0.8945180773735046,
0.43528100848197937,
-0.18718759715557098,
-0.12392186373472214,
0.27940189838409424,
0.3657275438308716,
-0.29855620861053467,
0.8326377868652344,
0.43282100558280945,
0.03567269444465637,
0.07049468904733658,
-0.1546863615512848,
0.023543374612927437,
-0.8597291111946106,
-0.16611550748348236,
-0.4614851772785187,
-0.5742847323417664,
-0.42659223079681396,
-0.40975767374038696,
-0.0492420494556427,
0.46220678091049194,
-0.3536703586578369,
0.1421462446451187,
-0.10047213733196259,
0.6945531368255615,
0.27977439761161804,
0.29352763295173645,
0.35973337292671204,
-0.0017136642709374428,
-0.028596194460988045,
0.004965205676853657,
-0.7396169900894165,
-0.45005732774734497,
1.0577127933502197,
0.28365546464920044,
0.83137446641922,
-0.09588347375392914,
0.5334091186523438,
0.1973983198404312,
0.055021606385707855,
-0.6783468723297119,
0.2943088114261627,
-0.461356520652771,
-0.3269563317298889,
-0.151731938123703,
-0.37029632925987244,
-0.9396218657493591,
0.19436782598495483,
0.021341422572731972,
-0.6545454263687134,
0.14413681626319885,
0.10446390509605408,
-0.04466792196035385,
-0.014753852970898151,
-0.49708035588264465,
1.114951252937317,
-0.32712557911872864,
-0.3827013671398163,
-0.046193111687898636,
-0.741836428642273,
0.2702803909778595,
-0.5007186532020569,
0.10191433131694794,
-0.24098527431488037,
0.042524322867393494,
0.7643405199050903,
-0.4278518855571747,
0.6792678833007812,
0.13735389709472656,
-0.05993757024407387,
-0.31808334589004517,
0.20115742087364197,
0.278977632522583,
0.16898760199546814,
-0.4422265887260437,
0.16108283400535583,
0.16121356189250946,
-0.6420750617980957,
-0.5416988134384155,
0.5585630536079407,
-0.5064929127693176,
-0.5196439623832703,
-0.21606221795082092,
-0.5504903793334961,
-0.35375696420669556,
0.32464170455932617,
0.3243526518344879,
0.22516882419586182,
-0.019339412450790405,
0.3807026445865631,
0.6397063136100769,
-0.23947519063949585,
0.10594697296619415,
0.785838782787323,
-0.23479494452476501,
-0.2557320296764374,
0.5897394418716431,
-0.05711203068494797,
0.20551010966300964,
0.4813404381275177,
0.07795682549476624,
-0.34735310077667236,
-0.9614322781562805,
-0.02465735375881195,
0.2428232878446579,
-0.6128612756729126,
-0.44390517473220825,
-0.5518388748168945,
-0.17087063193321228,
-0.3088127374649048,
0.0053540924564003944,
-0.26813673973083496,
-0.10888230800628662,
-0.11018878221511841,
-0.24408352375030518,
0.35061347484588623,
0.7576829195022583,
-0.209378182888031,
0.21409408748149872,
-0.9518904685974121,
0.4908957779407501,
0.058570630848407745,
0.5886424779891968,
-0.1317196488380432,
-0.8002620935440063,
-0.19115300476551056,
0.15915028750896454,
-0.004315081052482128,
-0.8443871736526489,
0.5094318985939026,
0.7842526435852051,
0.5285894870758057,
0.29469841718673706,
0.009958585724234581,
0.7214395403862,
-0.6239349246025085,
0.417822003364563,
-0.2782860994338989,
-0.8485901355743408,
0.7900827527046204,
-0.08409202098846436,
0.6688953042030334,
0.7731608748435974,
0.7350776195526123,
-0.553694486618042,
-0.4055330157279968,
-0.26056328415870667,
-0.7397918105125427,
0.6086348295211792,
0.0900866836309433,
-0.1663399040699005,
-0.10364862531423569,
0.7110208868980408,
0.6288250088691711,
0.11811821162700653,
-0.519017219543457,
-0.12594585120677948,
-0.04131671041250229,
-0.34543153643608093,
-0.5087342262268066,
-0.21445146203041077,
-0.03801790624856949,
-0.344162255525589,
0.591433584690094,
-0.31303369998931885,
-0.11112161725759506,
0.16976962983608246,
-0.6279736161231995,
0.08063339442014694,
0.11202520877122879,
0.26184025406837463,
0.873089075088501,
-0.5561061501502991,
0.32838794589042664,
0.09320449084043503,
-0.5055484175682068,
-0.01985427923500538,
0.291522353887558,
-0.07043848186731339,
-0.3555822968482971,
0.8074619770050049,
0.7638219594955444,
0.041674524545669556,
-0.6957600712776184,
0.13719365000724792,
-0.024703163653612137,
-0.2022724151611328,
0.3277239203453064,
0.04343533515930176,
0.11381496489048004,
0.3082777261734009,
0.45583999156951904,
-0.2635916471481323,
0.3021515905857086,
-0.3170948326587677,
0.5693712830543518,
0.1653939187526703,
-0.2382519543170929,
-0.26401618123054504,
0.4691661298274994,
-0.007843086495995522,
-0.10598663240671158,
0.8006380796432495,
-0.0939536988735199,
-0.3849148154258728,
0.42597952485084534,
0.5275481343269348,
0.5419425964355469,
-0.13351556658744812,
0.1338702142238617,
0.38559940457344055,
0.09697650372982025,
-0.12128133326768875,
0.27455607056617737,
0.10569571703672409,
-0.6619929075241089,
-0.6264223456382751,
-1.1698558330535889,
-0.12510639429092407,
0.38492995500564575,
-0.7371683716773987,
0.13096731901168823,
-0.3167062997817993,
0.11376558989286423,
0.3305218815803528,
0.13717994093894958,
-0.7307024598121643,
-0.11074428260326385,
-0.03784247860312462,
1.1911858320236206,
-0.8785481452941895,
1.057548999786377,
0.5528150200843811,
-0.3612252473831177,
-0.44138482213020325,
-0.10946949571371078,
-0.14068876206874847,
-0.7897269129753113,
0.8634980916976929,
0.40113183856010437,
0.1804608553647995,
0.23721016943454742,
-0.5651700496673584,
-0.687637209892273,
0.830076277256012,
0.4474901556968689,
-0.9563877582550049,
0.21241267025470734,
0.2011938989162445,
0.5118469595909119,
-0.20614825189113617,
-0.001277254312299192,
0.8903116583824158,
0.5877138376235962,
-0.007329271640628576,
-0.7836607098579407,
-0.029676012694835663,
-0.12791553139686584,
-0.1639123558998108,
0.0639481171965599,
-0.4064106047153473,
0.7101569771766663,
-0.09893360733985901,
0.07015838474035263,
0.05347311496734619,
0.68630450963974,
0.27459725737571716,
0.015868952497839928,
0.10149559378623962,
0.36643916368484497,
0.91629558801651,
0.04866456985473633,
0.9761589765548706,
-0.21786674857139587,
0.2462185025215149,
1.4638537168502808,
-0.34623098373413086,
0.856218695640564,
0.4645296335220337,
-0.31925973296165466,
0.04754336178302765,
0.8246340155601501,
-0.2857021987438202,
0.514435887336731,
0.5797877907752991,
0.13928042352199554,
-0.377509742975235,
0.028969192877411842,
-0.4324014186859131,
0.4906574785709381,
0.4107282757759094,
-0.2841198444366455,
-0.20929008722305298,
0.2799968719482422,
-0.3891821503639221,
-0.032715484499931335,
-0.3286096453666687,
0.877177894115448,
0.22153274714946747,
-0.22182685136795044,
0.684489905834198,
-0.21354027092456818,
0.3917100131511688,
-0.7422688603401184,
0.027184050530195236,
-0.5221010446548462,
0.2569524049758911,
-0.20510241389274597,
-0.8976343274116516,
0.133906289935112,
-0.16330282390117645,
-0.1885497272014618,
-0.016337759792804718,
0.48601847887039185,
-0.5048910975456238,
-0.42684870958328247,
0.3595702648162842,
0.4515026807785034,
0.3583270013332367,
-0.16844157874584198,
-0.7965211868286133,
0.3880960941314697,
-0.0605887807905674,
-0.24547773599624634,
0.4024101495742798,
0.3616335690021515,
0.28916308283805847,
0.7480893135070801,
0.42152974009513855,
0.16397450864315033,
-0.09812036901712418,
0.3185853362083435,
0.6381992101669312,
-0.6939637660980225,
-0.2185559719800949,
-0.9334551692008972,
0.031121186912059784,
-0.034136682748794556,
0.0018299026414752007,
0.678913950920105,
0.6827613115310669,
0.924915611743927,
-0.36605849862098694,
0.5041391253471375,
0.1435481607913971,
0.3595818281173706,
-0.7814965844154358,
0.7295693755149841,
-0.5906220078468323,
0.0021175346337258816,
0.05034831166267395,
-0.9472678899765015,
-0.5785440802574158,
0.8042340874671936,
-0.25180232524871826,
0.08627835661172867,
0.7412360906600952,
0.821008026599884,
-0.0488809198141098,
0.1688634753227234,
0.27086159586906433,
0.5983706116676331,
0.38874414563179016,
0.562853217124939,
0.5559222102165222,
-0.42525479197502136,
0.21040281653404236,
-0.08930112421512604,
-0.18453820049762726,
-0.3773149847984314,
-1.096930980682373,
-1.0082826614379883,
-0.44475507736206055,
-0.17615774273872375,
-0.06019887700676918,
0.5371425151824951,
0.9513684511184692,
0.7054267525672913,
-1.1042808294296265,
-0.25738558173179626,
-0.1733442097902298,
-0.2531597912311554,
-0.2020234763622284,
-0.12242450565099716,
0.5952501893043518,
-0.5025747418403625,
-0.497360497713089,
0.7515411972999573,
0.3445260226726532,
0.048479992896318436,
0.021267496049404144,
-0.294953852891922,
-0.37366586923599243,
-0.19662590324878693,
0.8346633911132812,
0.4191887378692627,
-0.5173550844192505,
-0.1976798176765442,
-0.12925074994564056,
0.08599629998207092,
0.010702868923544884,
0.6869149804115295,
-0.6701220273971558,
0.37014418840408325,
0.44862037897109985,
0.7613130807876587,
0.6055680513381958,
-0.11475726217031479,
0.8286910057067871,
-0.6454663872718811,
0.06848731637001038,
0.14377491176128387,
0.30158185958862305,
0.23587334156036377,
-0.17277613282203674,
0.650165319442749,
-0.13913123309612274,
-0.5661712288856506,
-0.5644698739051819,
0.17755159735679626,
-0.9346616268157959,
-0.5731176733970642,
0.8117117285728455,
0.08103631436824799,
-0.27458664774894714,
-0.16166841983795166,
-0.1396608054637909,
0.27324506640434265,
-0.050683051347732544,
0.7237088680267334,
0.6780769228935242,
-0.23268453776836395,
-0.19160394370555878,
-0.6988600492477417,
0.6914515495300293,
0.5222009420394897,
-0.8312402367591858,
0.46951454877853394,
0.3243553042411804,
0.2070925533771515,
-0.47062525153160095,
0.3320004642009735,
0.10231885313987732,
0.058041155338287354,
-0.35225072503089905,
-0.21227191388607025,
-0.23968493938446045,
-0.2781819701194763,
-0.47476524114608765,
-0.05916298180818558,
0.0915127694606781,
0.17126038670539856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05534v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05534v1
|
Online DPO: Online Direct Preference Optimization with Fast-Slow Chasing
| 2024-06-08T17:30:54 | 2024-06-08T17:30:54 |
Biqing Qi, Pengfei Li, Fangyuan Li, Junqi Gao, Kaiyan Zhang, Bowen Zhou
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) improves the alignment of large language
models (LLMs) with human values by training directly on human preference
datasets, eliminating the need for reward models. However, due to the presence
of cross-domain human preferences, direct continual training can lead to
catastrophic forgetting, limiting DPO's performance and efficiency. Inspired by
intraspecific competition driving species evolution, we propose a Online
Fast-Slow chasing DPO (OFS-DPO) for preference alignment, simulating
competition through fast and slow chasing among models to facilitate rapid
adaptation. Specifically, we first derive the regret upper bound for online
learning, validating our motivation with a min-max optimization pattern. Based
on this, we introduce two identical modules using Low-rank Adaptive (LoRA) with
different optimization speeds to simulate intraspecific competition, and
propose a new regularization term to guide their learning. To further mitigate
catastrophic forgetting in cross-domain scenarios, we extend the OFS-DPO with
LoRA modules combination strategy, resulting in the Cross domain Online
Fast-Slow chasing DPO (COFS-DPO). This method leverages linear combinations of
fast modules parameters from different task domains, fully utilizing historical
information to achive continual value alignment. Experimental results show that
OFS-DPO outperforms DPO in in-domain alignment, while COFS-DPO excels in
cross-domain continual learning scenarios.
|
[
-0.28219079971313477,
-0.544165313243866,
0.5259955525398254,
0.23823845386505127,
-0.23601053655147552,
0.5615628361701965,
-0.27600184082984924,
-0.37337011098861694,
0.4109559953212738,
0.26076847314834595,
-0.9454297423362732,
0.06287690252065659,
-0.31181198358535767,
0.28241443634033203,
0.34703099727630615,
0.7211528420448303,
-0.1983514428138733,
-0.2303890436887741,
-0.31647592782974243,
-0.00808583851903677,
-0.5584378242492676,
-0.3992951512336731,
-0.8114178776741028,
-0.24139171838760376,
0.7119297981262207,
0.65798419713974,
0.5493586659431458,
0.8877639770507812,
0.6100351214408875,
0.2790296673774719,
-0.12826108932495117,
0.518777072429657,
-0.9737035036087036,
0.2887815833091736,
-0.3593786656856537,
-0.40855011343955994,
-0.656657874584198,
-0.07419001311063766,
0.5319046378135681,
0.5339677333831787,
-0.30616506934165955,
-0.1966286301612854,
-0.05513998493552208,
0.8858354091644287,
-0.7306037545204163,
-0.1742936372756958,
-0.8707995414733887,
0.3173689544200897,
-0.002822650596499443,
-0.6723687052726746,
-0.3320640027523041,
-0.6000198125839233,
0.48951974511146545,
-0.9815338850021362,
-0.010283153504133224,
0.17842009663581848,
0.9549441337585449,
0.3628365397453308,
-0.11864800751209259,
-0.37356647849082947,
-0.8082403540611267,
0.9085122346878052,
-0.3653191030025482,
0.28708699345588684,
0.36681947112083435,
0.21733002364635468,
-0.32292309403419495,
-0.22026151418685913,
-0.4362413287162781,
-0.1537657529115677,
0.4506705701351166,
0.20368118584156036,
-0.0048966240137815475,
0.005311219021677971,
0.10677661001682281,
0.3579661250114441,
-0.3466101586818695,
0.2675253450870514,
0.07457981258630753,
0.04269980639219284,
0.6984502077102661,
0.09662117063999176,
-0.011250516399741173,
0.36377590894699097,
-0.5175118446350098,
0.003061713185161352,
-0.689376950263977,
0.13726255297660828,
0.5539914965629578,
0.4786248505115509,
0.05253381282091141,
0.23269638419151306,
-0.29860952496528625,
0.6258854866027832,
0.6501535773277283,
-0.4570671617984772,
0.25855761766433716,
-0.033618830144405365,
0.2350482940673828,
0.2652670443058014,
0.44359493255615234,
0.3365545868873596,
0.2782558798789978,
-0.23265455663204193,
-0.03492579981684685,
-0.08383241295814514,
0.2839925289154053,
-0.5009323954582214,
0.200133815407753,
0.1470252275466919,
-0.3644067347049713,
-0.2987320125102997,
-0.4501366913318634,
-1.0121402740478516,
-0.13797248899936676,
-0.4129728674888611,
0.6269070506095886,
-0.5044229626655579,
-0.09500422328710556,
0.27860409021377563,
-0.11175260692834854,
0.06841474026441574,
0.4401751756668091,
-1.238006830215454,
0.5109890103340149,
0.6162029504776001,
1.0656518936157227,
-0.6615242958068848,
-0.5936103463172913,
-0.6872405409812927,
0.1627538800239563,
-0.17852401733398438,
0.7369161248207092,
-0.5932273864746094,
-0.28977078199386597,
-0.14090941846370697,
-0.2470095306634903,
-0.2114269733428955,
-0.5365464091300964,
0.41975122690200806,
-0.7535703182220459,
0.1764371246099472,
-0.33931994438171387,
-0.7228233218193054,
-0.02259095571935177,
0.23263058066368103,
-0.5344411134719849,
1.0649224519729614,
-0.020375167950987816,
-0.6777637004852295,
0.46665406227111816,
-0.6980551481246948,
-0.22786428034305573,
-0.03397626802325249,
0.07622995972633362,
-0.6306806802749634,
0.051102541387081146,
-0.12201743572950363,
0.29564788937568665,
-0.24997670948505402,
0.15943193435668945,
-0.6566855907440186,
-0.6680334210395813,
-0.11606045067310333,
0.1368490606546402,
0.6644991040229797,
-0.03598026558756828,
-0.5884401798248291,
0.08982055634260178,
-0.844570517539978,
-0.16912515461444855,
0.5761070847511292,
-0.40825867652893066,
-0.6264415383338928,
0.5688446164131165,
-0.7111145853996277,
0.25427350401878357,
0.0843292623758316,
-0.5667585730552673,
0.6746827363967896,
-0.16780295968055725,
0.3274122476577759,
1.2003982067108154,
-0.08070319145917892,
0.3804110884666443,
-0.3906066417694092,
0.39106929302215576,
-0.03016063943505287,
0.48575910925865173,
0.2966693341732025,
-0.41766026616096497,
-0.8548625707626343,
-0.2839030921459198,
0.012907727621495724,
0.4193067252635956,
-0.6804475784301758,
0.4957772195339203,
-0.5399898886680603,
-0.32718992233276367,
-0.313190221786499,
0.06508342921733856,
0.22678007185459137,
0.5828018188476562,
0.4006059765815735,
-0.527461051940918,
-0.4215470552444458,
-0.5618588328361511,
-0.07412109524011612,
0.05097990855574608,
0.27642086148262024,
0.6222203373908997,
0.3681584894657135,
-0.3390129804611206,
1.056976318359375,
-0.6866203546524048,
-0.43539655208587646,
-0.10797441005706787,
-0.19720692932605743,
-0.09504655003547668,
0.21340322494506836,
0.6191121339797974,
-0.6984055638313293,
-0.7397608160972595,
-0.17241401970386505,
-0.3711009621620178,
0.19493745267391205,
-0.06273293495178223,
-0.33364105224609375,
0.1546073704957962,
-0.23119895160198212,
-0.30439651012420654,
-0.03455246612429619,
0.3834570348262787,
-0.088284932076931,
0.08228735625743866,
-0.2670189440250397,
0.2107737958431244,
-0.7525684833526611,
-0.05054674670100212,
-0.034165848046541214,
-0.05438711866736412,
-0.500954806804657,
-0.1390119194984436,
-0.03476456180214882,
-0.056929368525743484,
-0.5681295394897461,
0.45162272453308105,
-0.3357313573360443,
-0.11565186828374863,
-0.2045019418001175,
0.17575351893901825,
-0.12961198389530182,
0.7031357884407043,
0.3955215513706207,
0.6575855612754822,
0.5285055637359619,
-0.9002100825309753,
0.32928386330604553,
0.43496906757354736,
-0.09061602503061295,
0.36586636304855347,
-0.048189837485551834,
0.5406309366226196,
-0.15111766755580902,
0.24197162687778473,
-0.507797122001648,
-0.04367822781205177,
0.20441851019859314,
-0.08787453919649124,
0.3035253584384918,
-0.14043882489204407,
-0.1083480566740036,
-0.1612718254327774,
-0.4765852689743042,
0.4180845618247986,
0.5074524879455566,
-0.7841632962226868,
0.3458537459373474,
0.25569087266921997,
-0.16862386465072632,
-0.7606532573699951,
-0.1052156463265419,
-0.05152822285890579,
-0.3288680911064148,
-0.26483485102653503,
0.5856016874313354,
-0.3308941423892975,
-0.08722884207963943,
-0.31093958020210266,
0.039417143911123276,
0.007624209392815828,
0.2461521476507187,
-0.06550711393356323,
0.402995228767395,
-0.01189965195953846,
-0.057640884071588516,
-0.024094972759485245,
-0.08189469575881958,
-0.42028823494911194,
-0.369937539100647,
0.49293509125709534,
0.2660691738128662,
0.0044990587048232555,
-0.40315133333206177,
0.5395960211753845,
0.33598366379737854,
0.12666961550712585,
0.3825930058956146,
0.015990855172276497,
-0.2571538984775543,
-0.5236173868179321,
-0.3919246196746826,
-0.1316138505935669,
-0.5344648957252502,
0.27608391642570496,
-0.47180718183517456,
-0.8598120212554932,
0.09656164050102234,
-0.23547935485839844,
-0.024232616648077965,
0.31576743721961975,
0.3550768196582794,
-0.11860277503728867,
0.8392683863639832,
0.9918932914733887,
-0.15292714536190033,
0.6740254163742065,
0.041509684175252914,
-0.30351558327674866,
-0.5930570960044861,
-0.19102028012275696,
-0.2671501040458679,
-0.3711681663990021,
-0.4103018343448639,
-0.3293609619140625,
0.07226860523223877,
0.05332846939563751,
-0.3616616427898407,
0.3670421838760376,
-0.6205019354820251,
0.5154548287391663,
0.502204418182373,
0.34017637372016907,
0.3095669150352478,
0.3005891740322113,
-0.18416064977645874,
-0.3494192957878113,
-0.9142276048660278,
-0.054793305695056915,
1.0635336637496948,
0.24117207527160645,
0.6570014953613281,
-0.025945443660020828,
0.6827384829521179,
0.46165308356285095,
0.20802795886993408,
-0.9574915766716003,
0.4688105881214142,
-0.216035857796669,
-0.526715874671936,
-0.1340508610010147,
-0.5453071594238281,
-0.752857506275177,
-0.016326311975717545,
-0.04320674389600754,
-0.47460177540779114,
0.3973449468612671,
0.6057345867156982,
-0.6728780269622803,
0.45875391364097595,
-0.2524403929710388,
0.6705666184425354,
-0.8126260042190552,
-0.7167477011680603,
-0.3887384533882141,
-0.686314582824707,
0.16533638536930084,
-0.23575448989868164,
-0.08629830926656723,
-0.3921440541744232,
-0.3455427289009094,
0.5619235038757324,
-0.1889525055885315,
0.7065083384513855,
-0.10881683230400085,
0.015942895784974098,
0.24418200552463531,
0.091401606798172,
0.5970438122749329,
-0.38063865900039673,
-0.21837453544139862,
0.11095879226922989,
-0.5394377708435059,
-0.3329930007457733,
-0.17430198192596436,
0.8222680687904358,
-0.8761201500892639,
-0.5701642632484436,
-0.7364574670791626,
-0.10462203621864319,
-0.3121068477630615,
0.03387993946671486,
0.1491314172744751,
0.0028628716245293617,
-0.28993773460388184,
-0.2735922336578369,
0.8472142815589905,
-0.1583690047264099,
0.4544942378997803,
0.5953810811042786,
0.02947375923395157,
-0.6571665406227112,
1.242089867591858,
0.05047658085823059,
0.731231689453125,
0.7131552696228027,
0.48162418603897095,
-0.24257396161556244,
-0.4828844368457794,
-0.44565099477767944,
0.19243572652339935,
-0.6821417212486267,
-0.09763755649328232,
-0.4742918610572815,
0.17492036521434784,
-0.15538065135478973,
-0.4515910744667053,
-0.5638521313667297,
-0.2854154109954834,
-0.48331859707832336,
0.37418320775032043,
0.5282023549079895,
0.5071172714233398,
-0.06851769983768463,
0.06905809789896011,
-0.5708620548248291,
0.31128573417663574,
0.4559849500656128,
0.7418481111526489,
-0.05352168530225754,
-0.719110369682312,
-0.15021167695522308,
-0.050792258232831955,
-0.5094625353813171,
-0.5846573710441589,
0.40397220849990845,
0.5166428089141846,
0.42061281204223633,
0.3475930988788605,
-0.07523483037948608,
0.8929977416992188,
-0.7253344655036926,
0.3689099848270416,
0.14040300250053406,
-0.7989663481712341,
0.561386227607727,
-0.3370543420314789,
-0.010651017539203167,
0.7820778489112854,
1.1020116806030273,
-0.5251664519309998,
0.390763521194458,
-0.2104683518409729,
-0.6917433142662048,
0.923414409160614,
-0.07976490259170532,
-0.2038898766040802,
0.09516944736242294,
0.7831776738166809,
0.5619354844093323,
0.09602657705545425,
-0.6200823187828064,
-0.25655215978622437,
-0.19784624874591827,
0.11409394443035126,
-0.11131951957941055,
-0.18438398838043213,
-0.10154900699853897,
-0.23454442620277405,
0.8971855044364929,
-0.38743892312049866,
0.3418721854686737,
0.2767966687679291,
0.06756874918937683,
-0.49965131282806396,
-0.11775363981723785,
0.6830788254737854,
0.40346696972846985,
-0.6345440149307251,
-0.28265583515167236,
0.13795381784439087,
-0.46599671244621277,
0.511383056640625,
-0.04384629800915718,
-0.3536730408668518,
-0.14636565744876862,
-0.06861118972301483,
1.0471817255020142,
0.3362100124359131,
-0.623106062412262,
0.3583984971046448,
-0.14398615062236786,
-0.10381418466567993,
-0.18313081562519073,
0.03568455949425697,
-0.05215657129883766,
-0.14606475830078125,
0.40272507071495056,
0.23041993379592896,
-0.13543711602687836,
-0.7037696242332458,
0.11041830480098724,
0.2549838721752167,
-0.3936038911342621,
-0.35835787653923035,
0.6449378728866577,
0.4880346357822418,
-0.4605444371700287,
0.2605830430984497,
-0.24020569026470184,
-0.5473527312278748,
0.473805695772171,
0.5417628288269043,
1.0423109531402588,
-0.21211674809455872,
0.03817791864275932,
0.36470210552215576,
-0.14078719913959503,
-0.5306445956230164,
0.2508847117424011,
-0.20375876128673553,
-0.6494936943054199,
-0.29240840673446655,
-0.6667890548706055,
-0.9211461544036865,
-0.13172893226146698,
-0.4348313808441162,
0.5641700625419617,
-0.5087664723396301,
-0.11763513833284378,
-0.10422658175230026,
0.09201428294181824,
-0.3646063804626465,
0.1534772664308548,
0.27012869715690613,
0.7495553493499756,
-0.48545581102371216,
0.9142860174179077,
0.37626969814300537,
-0.17357105016708374,
-0.2601465880870819,
0.1865309625864029,
0.1395118087530136,
-0.542983889579773,
0.684815526008606,
0.07366693019866943,
-0.4768911302089691,
0.2701733410358429,
-0.21908509731292725,
-1.2767928838729858,
1.170912504196167,
0.35880202054977417,
-0.9091458320617676,
-0.1659121811389923,
0.15151117742061615,
0.18685759603977203,
-0.5329388380050659,
0.10032554715871811,
0.3925200402736664,
0.10245206952095032,
0.1678657829761505,
-0.8620082139968872,
0.04147958755493164,
0.1840619146823883,
-0.2701285779476166,
0.16993723809719086,
-1.2960504293441772,
0.6779090762138367,
-0.3015531897544861,
-0.16784466803073883,
-0.007586557883769274,
0.25563353300094604,
0.17538054287433624,
0.0892818495631218,
0.7230029702186584,
0.5636563301086426,
0.41211655735969543,
-0.11097405850887299,
0.719484269618988,
-0.014127754606306553,
0.3553380072116852,
1.1409295797348022,
-0.914345920085907,
1.022016167640686,
0.49982401728630066,
-0.29433709383010864,
0.40252551436424255,
0.9025448560714722,
0.15634755790233612,
0.8096054196357727,
0.17867937684059143,
-0.2957897484302521,
-0.3863413631916046,
-0.016781549900770187,
-0.3835770785808563,
0.41142094135284424,
-0.03242715075612068,
0.023556051775813103,
0.18692125380039215,
-0.1350804567337036,
-0.25573623180389404,
0.03995059058070183,
-0.42839139699935913,
0.8486995697021484,
-0.1906837522983551,
-1.0404798984527588,
0.7490524053573608,
-0.2578432559967041,
1.041257619857788,
-0.9861289262771606,
0.10822071135044098,
-0.33882901072502136,
0.6591643691062927,
0.03235217183828354,
-0.22929811477661133,
0.033129338175058365,
-0.028349246829748154,
-0.09476784616708755,
-0.3433416783809662,
0.5545098185539246,
-0.17417480051517487,
-0.1563437283039093,
0.7536473274230957,
0.21269606053829193,
-0.21918043494224548,
0.11418542265892029,
-0.7798805236816406,
0.24900569021701813,
0.08700712025165558,
-0.4621184468269348,
0.612537145614624,
0.10095402598381042,
-0.06929001212120056,
0.8844782114028931,
0.5990866422653198,
0.06971881538629532,
0.016745299100875854,
-0.16472801566123962,
0.872395932674408,
-0.7780210375785828,
-0.4687385857105255,
-0.8281259536743164,
0.11463165283203125,
-0.1400597244501114,
-0.6244274973869324,
0.6385354995727539,
0.831127405166626,
1.0235271453857422,
-0.19375550746917725,
0.63931804895401,
0.015190178528428078,
0.5540633201599121,
-0.35583779215812683,
0.36534619331359863,
-0.7555443048477173,
-0.1417967975139618,
-0.2849084436893463,
-1.008533000946045,
-0.09293008595705032,
0.3500247001647949,
-0.1282041370868683,
-0.23889952898025513,
0.7006382346153259,
0.33134251832962036,
-0.12778235971927643,
-0.18525980412960052,
0.24577751755714417,
-0.15505541861057281,
-0.030751502141356468,
0.9346888065338135,
0.871726393699646,
-0.1847565472126007,
0.5422573685646057,
-0.6459389925003052,
-0.4339164197444916,
-0.3887253701686859,
-1.204789400100708,
-0.7732698917388916,
-0.34902501106262207,
-0.5361994504928589,
-0.19742904603481293,
0.3448239862918854,
1.3936063051223755,
0.6570032835006714,
-0.6382215023040771,
-0.40321725606918335,
0.007868604734539986,
-0.07554186880588531,
-0.5248322486877441,
-0.16610923409461975,
0.19564281404018402,
-0.2464149296283722,
-0.8436450958251953,
0.6054262518882751,
0.5948795080184937,
0.2642190158367157,
-0.10962720215320587,
-0.34709519147872925,
-0.6114292740821838,
0.29395559430122375,
0.4318735599517822,
0.6574729681015015,
-0.4972081780433655,
-0.3876008093357086,
0.18954694271087646,
-0.06431054323911667,
0.5557520389556885,
0.9133095145225525,
-0.6781781315803528,
0.6219556927680969,
0.2738195061683655,
0.7556095123291016,
0.5782759785652161,
-0.09460357576608658,
0.618698239326477,
-0.3389458954334259,
0.19674964249134064,
0.4440774619579315,
0.23256556689739227,
0.3134182095527649,
-0.46193233132362366,
0.3609224557876587,
0.7540207505226135,
-0.5680819749832153,
-0.660710871219635,
0.25798675417900085,
-0.9592342376708984,
-0.2163638323545456,
1.0226733684539795,
-0.18151363730430603,
-0.12970510125160217,
-0.05042079836130142,
-0.10251275449991226,
0.17508265376091003,
-0.5048008561134338,
1.2000250816345215,
0.4587280750274658,
-0.38754338026046753,
0.35911041498184204,
-0.26129475235939026,
0.8880988359451294,
0.5959247350692749,
-0.8467429876327515,
0.07608376443386078,
0.29166916012763977,
0.41063565015792847,
0.03975791856646538,
0.6730242967605591,
0.3506259322166443,
0.18430748581886292,
-0.06873288750648499,
0.1601480394601822,
0.017883244901895523,
-0.3190842270851135,
-0.3797021210193634,
0.1189752072095871,
-0.018493985757231712,
-0.20566847920417786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05516v1
|
Verbalized Probabilistic Graphical Modeling with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-08T16:35:31 | 2024-06-08T16:35:31 |
Hengguan Huang, Xing Shen, Songtao Wang, Dianbo Liu, Hao Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Faced with complex problems, the human brain demonstrates a remarkable
capacity to transcend sensory input and form latent understandings of perceived
world patterns. However, this cognitive capacity is not explicitly considered
or encoded in current large language models (LLMs). As a result, LLMs often
struggle to capture latent structures and model uncertainty in complex
compositional reasoning tasks. This work introduces a novel Bayesian prompting
approach that facilitates training-free Bayesian inference with LLMs by using a
verbalized Probabilistic Graphical Model (PGM). While traditional Bayesian
approaches typically depend on extensive data and predetermined mathematical
structures for learning latent factors and dependencies, our approach
efficiently reasons latent variables and their probabilistic dependencies by
prompting LLMs to adhere to Bayesian principles. We evaluated our model on
several compositional reasoning tasks, both close-ended and open-ended. Our
results indicate that the model effectively enhances confidence elicitation and
text generation quality, demonstrating its potential to improve AI language
understanding systems, especially in modeling uncertainty.
|
[
-0.07647804915904999,
-1.2589043378829956,
1.1320189237594604,
0.19333796203136444,
-0.10391069948673248,
-0.1273173987865448,
-0.22625046968460083,
0.04341912642121315,
-0.35503360629081726,
0.4098271429538727,
-0.4484149217605591,
-0.7164700627326965,
-0.5805202126502991,
-0.29321718215942383,
0.07976721227169037,
0.6888173222541809,
0.0004300297296140343,
0.06259094923734665,
-0.15722106397151947,
0.5084289312362671,
-0.38952428102493286,
-0.17154040932655334,
-0.9799726009368896,
-0.47451913356781006,
0.6148731708526611,
0.21378472447395325,
0.9529867768287659,
0.012697960250079632,
-0.018134452402591705,
0.2768647074699402,
0.07249860465526581,
0.10084724426269531,
-0.12784452736377716,
0.1505832076072693,
-0.36605924367904663,
-0.7069522738456726,
-0.36746153235435486,
0.009296542964875698,
0.6216990947723389,
1.1581476926803589,
-0.208787202835083,
-0.25783228874206543,
0.05257188528776169,
0.17119254171848297,
-0.6453312635421753,
0.8908481001853943,
-0.5622470378875732,
-0.17100165784358978,
0.3121030032634735,
0.17197182774543762,
-0.6294511556625366,
-0.08204817026853561,
0.2694510817527771,
-0.7683873772621155,
0.2095891237258911,
-0.23388831317424774,
0.5182619690895081,
0.14502936601638794,
-0.47579923272132874,
0.13998286426067352,
-0.6288006901741028,
0.5881679654121399,
-0.7120167016983032,
0.16989853978157043,
0.6167298555374146,
0.287017285823822,
-0.4956762194633484,
-0.5593042969703674,
-0.834470272064209,
-0.3937865197658539,
0.07101548463106155,
0.43791505694389343,
-0.3729484975337982,
0.35854724049568176,
0.3227315843105316,
-0.19227510690689087,
-0.6226547360420227,
0.16912959516048431,
-0.003598537528887391,
0.021946381777524948,
0.5596916675567627,
0.0021863235160708427,
0.45675069093704224,
-0.14179176092147827,
-0.060593392699956894,
-0.28852593898773193,
-0.5220248699188232,
0.07356841117143631,
0.24787583947181702,
0.4295322895050049,
-0.2806565761566162,
0.6104755997657776,
-0.20307932794094086,
0.8774698376655579,
-0.07895482331514359,
-0.14783905446529388,
-0.1253444403409958,
0.21093101799488068,
-0.19391018152236938,
-0.1754174679517746,
0.917327344417572,
0.2750956416130066,
0.5450696349143982,
0.048065342009067535,
-0.08350522071123123,
0.2611699104309082,
0.10051076114177704,
-0.5931411385536194,
-0.5214873552322388,
0.4132356345653534,
-0.3454139530658722,
-0.021972982212901115,
0.1480332911014557,
-0.38022714853286743,
-0.2691248655319214,
-0.3423398733139038,
0.6533365249633789,
-0.7998127341270447,
-0.343761682510376,
0.18606439232826233,
-0.11765031516551971,
-0.004101385362446308,
0.6382949352264404,
-0.8605511784553528,
-0.006911661475896835,
0.6398382782936096,
0.7436342239379883,
0.11205022037029266,
-0.10135199129581451,
-0.5374257564544678,
0.48706743121147156,
-0.5758224129676819,
0.688372790813446,
-0.7941649556159973,
-0.48305612802505493,
-0.08686328679323196,
-0.05727453529834747,
-0.2039795070886612,
-0.3200449049472809,
0.24093493819236755,
-0.3929479122161865,
0.30129167437553406,
-0.0728817880153656,
-0.6174042224884033,
-0.3674672842025757,
0.11686557531356812,
-0.5511205196380615,
0.6752009987831116,
0.28068193793296814,
-0.865646243095398,
0.27581071853637695,
-0.26638394594192505,
-0.3375985324382782,
0.31284844875335693,
-0.4978419840335846,
-0.3345775604248047,
0.2916366159915924,
0.5283541679382324,
0.7564512491226196,
-0.0740106999874115,
0.7060378789901733,
-0.509213387966156,
-0.2485591173171997,
0.44077596068382263,
-0.7381079196929932,
0.6193400621414185,
0.09369892627000809,
-0.19170254468917847,
0.27921387553215027,
-0.6254469156265259,
0.005025311838835478,
0.1025155559182167,
-0.10823751986026764,
-0.3207649290561676,
0.267286092042923,
-0.28519415855407715,
0.1647927314043045,
0.15484130382537842,
-0.29231390357017517,
0.17205475270748138,
-0.46695226430892944,
0.2990199029445648,
0.6169001460075378,
0.29959768056869507,
0.43980875611305237,
-0.2909989356994629,
0.5936281681060791,
0.08337768167257309,
-0.04589527100324631,
-0.1736690104007721,
-0.7319291234016418,
-0.3170236647129059,
-0.6103128790855408,
0.06254974007606506,
0.7978686094284058,
-1.0162736177444458,
0.4679339826107025,
-0.20297665894031525,
-0.35370397567749023,
-0.10906804352998734,
-0.3140740990638733,
0.19839760661125183,
0.5045192837715149,
0.1603829264640808,
-0.22120651602745056,
-0.03929327428340912,
-0.6291572451591492,
0.14278145134449005,
-0.5702146291732788,
-0.4638146758079529,
0.18023967742919922,
0.34124791622161865,
-0.11029669642448425,
1.0377730131149292,
-0.6088190078735352,
0.23841270804405212,
-0.45484957098960876,
0.5990253686904907,
0.31099486351013184,
0.42524856328964233,
0.2900036871433258,
-0.4700709283351898,
-0.1653061807155609,
-0.21591816842556,
-0.6881709694862366,
-0.32984301447868347,
-0.5065036416053772,
-0.300310343503952,
-0.06709219515323639,
0.5024933815002441,
-0.9652318358421326,
0.5869495868682861,
0.4153903126716614,
-0.30456438660621643,
0.6706092357635498,
-0.5085644125938416,
-0.005635170731693506,
-1.0583086013793945,
0.019349966198205948,
0.18399210274219513,
-0.08246087282896042,
-0.4339245557785034,
-0.13410747051239014,
-0.1039137989282608,
-0.3217312693595886,
-0.0631546676158905,
0.6366264820098877,
-0.4889981746673584,
-0.033307839184999466,
-0.31206873059272766,
0.08282782882452011,
-0.0909101590514183,
0.42428743839263916,
0.5653277635574341,
0.5772284269332886,
0.6630620956420898,
-0.5678379535675049,
0.1549118012189865,
0.21644379198551178,
-0.418510764837265,
0.5717173218727112,
-0.8417384028434753,
-0.48708468675613403,
-0.45252683758735657,
0.46586647629737854,
-1.324223518371582,
-0.3521919846534729,
0.4359704852104187,
-0.46324753761291504,
0.45691820979118347,
-0.24240227043628693,
-0.49924078583717346,
-0.3138323426246643,
0.19658905267715454,
-0.0033249864354729652,
0.51930171251297,
-0.31131792068481445,
0.5868774056434631,
0.026386629790067673,
-0.6213140487670898,
-0.3815896511077881,
-0.5313165187835693,
0.11613540351390839,
0.08260809630155563,
-0.5862166285514832,
0.34555551409721375,
0.028924530372023582,
-0.3499894440174103,
-0.21813015639781952,
0.0502089187502861,
0.08403283357620239,
0.23896099627017975,
0.4957883954048157,
0.4061778783798218,
0.006582916714251041,
0.1885194331407547,
0.4596003592014313,
-0.2913569211959839,
0.34078896045684814,
-0.41218873858451843,
0.4468231797218323,
0.2545875012874603,
-0.5563981533050537,
-0.6008852124214172,
0.47063788771629333,
0.16070227324962616,
-0.16264164447784424,
0.9065079689025879,
0.7304726839065552,
-0.4502372145652771,
-0.36283957958221436,
-0.21297207474708557,
-0.42706868052482605,
-0.3626921772956848,
0.45275449752807617,
-0.4883602261543274,
-0.8481094837188721,
0.3610773980617523,
-0.1685274988412857,
-0.32937851548194885,
0.19390787184238434,
0.6026828289031982,
-0.16389323770999908,
1.3630815744400024,
0.344191312789917,
0.09922865033149719,
0.6233042478561401,
-0.09339670836925507,
0.2317134290933609,
-0.40530315041542053,
-0.16715063154697418,
-0.2731764614582062,
0.11108049750328064,
-0.4758448898792267,
-0.7686426639556885,
0.4444044232368469,
0.362371563911438,
-0.44541460275650024,
-0.32457947731018066,
-0.08159776031970978,
0.32279717922210693,
0.7217986583709717,
0.5234757661819458,
0.0189141146838665,
0.26827603578567505,
-0.41525667905807495,
0.06431882083415985,
-0.7019453048706055,
-0.7112967371940613,
0.7996255159378052,
0.2071940153837204,
1.050843358039856,
0.047889649868011475,
0.4269174039363861,
-0.10810508579015732,
0.26922130584716797,
-0.6283448934555054,
0.6338581442832947,
-0.025819862261414528,
-0.31768798828125,
-0.3543696403503418,
-0.621324896812439,
-1.1194469928741455,
0.15237008035182953,
-0.30158594250679016,
-1.0789244174957275,
-0.025534622371196747,
0.08483796566724777,
-0.40243521332740784,
0.2212858498096466,
-0.5968339443206787,
0.8627611994743347,
-0.07083509862422943,
-0.39558717608451843,
-0.07407303899526596,
-0.8079366087913513,
0.22303985059261322,
0.25063857436180115,
0.15680021047592163,
-0.23801720142364502,
-0.20343947410583496,
0.35834115743637085,
-0.40271562337875366,
1.2879053354263306,
-0.27446022629737854,
-0.31486016511917114,
0.49034544825553894,
0.3220401704311371,
0.55479496717453,
0.314089298248291,
-0.021016228944063187,
-0.11563670635223389,
-0.3305763304233551,
-0.41062960028648376,
-0.8190436363220215,
0.40812569856643677,
-0.8590419292449951,
-0.5433534383773804,
-0.2937661409378052,
-0.7548085451126099,
-0.5477972030639648,
0.04152868688106537,
0.35965994000434875,
0.1272571086883545,
-0.1338871270418167,
-0.2753995656967163,
0.7889188528060913,
-0.5234166979789734,
0.2729625105857849,
0.32654616236686707,
-0.1233873963356018,
-0.37399640679359436,
0.6741909980773926,
0.005912582390010357,
0.32972830533981323,
0.5804504156112671,
0.23305915296077728,
-0.3366911709308624,
-0.588422417640686,
-0.27081388235092163,
0.38452786207199097,
-0.5503935813903809,
0.11469024419784546,
-0.656886100769043,
-0.034432217478752136,
-0.38262611627578735,
-0.15575383603572845,
0.18532149493694305,
-0.3594258725643158,
-0.49166592955589294,
-0.16180096566677094,
0.23169881105422974,
0.5534077286720276,
-0.03888021409511566,
0.8237809538841248,
-0.7405334711074829,
0.296398401260376,
0.5097591876983643,
0.18151403963565826,
0.07285675406455994,
-0.45790183544158936,
0.05648405849933624,
0.1368611454963684,
-0.1651458889245987,
-1.17833411693573,
0.4958153963088989,
0.10996457934379578,
0.8221883773803711,
0.526880145072937,
-0.08202600479125977,
0.32298776507377625,
-0.25414931774139404,
0.8076519966125488,
0.22419039905071259,
-0.9377521872520447,
0.807958722114563,
-0.8007156252861023,
0.49598169326782227,
0.12555056810379028,
0.6973279714584351,
-0.30147165060043335,
-0.5142561197280884,
-0.7041935920715332,
-0.7064456343650818,
0.37338563799858093,
0.044393982738256454,
0.030869103968143463,
-0.40704259276390076,
0.43844956159591675,
0.10128585994243622,
0.26676344871520996,
-0.4803597033023834,
0.19254831969738007,
0.0613483265042305,
-0.6726468205451965,
-0.22566859424114227,
-0.2917785942554474,
0.17122027277946472,
-0.024244746193289757,
0.6967263221740723,
-0.42033839225769043,
0.3080630302429199,
0.027245957404375076,
-0.07980003207921982,
0.20167623460292816,
0.32238224148750305,
0.1865389496088028,
0.6761361956596375,
-0.09899427741765976,
0.24240615963935852,
-0.045531559735536575,
-0.15937912464141846,
0.06758949905633926,
0.28040891885757446,
-0.2767123579978943,
-0.09122151136398315,
0.4795159697532654,
0.8479138016700745,
0.18804523348808289,
-0.6949739456176758,
0.5722305178642273,
-0.006267237942665815,
-0.22172826528549194,
0.008851738646626472,
0.16238494217395782,
0.3757457435131073,
0.3993980586528778,
0.22485001385211945,
-0.25380417704582214,
-0.08368870615959167,
-0.4049421548843384,
0.07408186793327332,
0.4772641658782959,
-0.1427145153284073,
-0.21901589632034302,
0.7740921378135681,
-0.2819260060787201,
0.1896665245294571,
0.7299373745918274,
-0.2571829855442047,
-0.35162028670310974,
0.40558767318725586,
0.7289614677429199,
0.5039935111999512,
-0.40412768721580505,
0.6792454719543457,
0.4054979383945465,
0.1416592299938202,
-0.3615008592605591,
0.6774402260780334,
-0.031642816960811615,
-0.797653317451477,
-0.8045076131820679,
-0.4573518931865692,
-0.4998140037059784,
-0.018778515979647636,
-0.40298140048980713,
-0.07049646973609924,
-0.4823060929775238,
-0.38787269592285156,
-0.07847562432289124,
-0.19682545959949493,
-0.36656731367111206,
0.4853712320327759,
0.45195746421813965,
0.5615298748016357,
-1.1084880828857422,
0.6393495798110962,
0.5103193521499634,
-0.5857053995132446,
-0.9996617436408997,
0.0486823171377182,
-0.25779619812965393,
-0.6352253556251526,
0.5181655883789062,
0.06084567308425903,
0.0959974080324173,
-0.05837288498878479,
-0.8853621482849121,
-0.6016349792480469,
0.8051695823669434,
0.731170654296875,
-0.5814095139503479,
-0.019765134900808334,
0.017309147864580154,
0.41127443313598633,
-0.3008613884449005,
0.4757000207901001,
0.362598180770874,
0.3779194951057434,
0.22501955926418304,
-0.39023470878601074,
0.1718982756137848,
-0.10177416354417801,
0.3855209946632385,
-0.011594695039093494,
-0.2418961375951767,
1.0480151176452637,
-0.5484490990638733,
-0.1502985656261444,
0.10798051953315735,
0.8590059876441956,
0.5636358857154846,
0.22077205777168274,
0.4239858388900757,
0.46067389845848083,
1.0007717609405518,
-0.13900448381900787,
1.0242422819137573,
-0.16893120110034943,
-0.02633999101817608,
1.3924223184585571,
-0.182019904255867,
1.0139753818511963,
0.22473856806755066,
-0.30663812160491943,
0.7234981060028076,
0.8660667538642883,
0.21794354915618896,
0.219551220536232,
0.3716283440589905,
-0.5910701155662537,
-0.613477885723114,
-0.0015568116214126348,
-0.15287809073925018,
0.34134232997894287,
0.7701468467712402,
-0.31887221336364746,
-0.15586639940738678,
0.02941235713660717,
0.1344565898180008,
0.08402879536151886,
-0.3136447072029114,
0.677681565284729,
0.17654941976070404,
-0.8240536451339722,
0.1574147343635559,
0.03879944607615471,
0.32668498158454895,
-0.6509476900100708,
0.026412371546030045,
-0.06227695569396019,
-0.025869715958833694,
-0.022828102111816406,
-0.8960599303245544,
-0.03722943365573883,
-0.2450328916311264,
-0.0650709792971611,
-0.06234220787882805,
0.6568381190299988,
-0.7221012711524963,
-0.7400373220443726,
0.019836734980344772,
0.851415753364563,
0.13583603501319885,
-0.5633281469345093,
-0.6140899658203125,
-0.2579258680343628,
-0.33162644505500793,
-0.24429503083229065,
0.20863206684589386,
0.7903361916542053,
-0.3744378685951233,
0.6850150227546692,
0.5766883492469788,
0.147800475358963,
-0.19026970863342285,
0.5061214566230774,
0.41625329852104187,
-0.4969704747200012,
-0.7332178354263306,
-0.8332261443138123,
0.3290998637676239,
0.12026163935661316,
0.1746840924024582,
0.5652403831481934,
0.08614330738782883,
0.49343207478523254,
-0.23086017370224,
1.0295894145965576,
0.2754151225090027,
0.0699663981795311,
-0.6263231039047241,
0.5680698156356812,
-0.3158946931362152,
-0.014202985912561417,
-0.4375110864639282,
-0.6866499185562134,
-0.4323987066745758,
1.0131213665008545,
-0.6715099215507507,
0.32257840037345886,
0.449593186378479,
0.7655823230743408,
0.08911680430173874,
0.08202090114355087,
0.33375829458236694,
0.21850232779979706,
0.29785671830177307,
0.8078263998031616,
0.8072704672813416,
0.1387551724910736,
0.20893755555152893,
0.0916496142745018,
-0.512864351272583,
0.014035730622708797,
-0.9218505620956421,
-0.8724415898323059,
-0.5211426019668579,
-0.5551284551620483,
-0.34553712606430054,
-0.02163563296198845,
0.8734959363937378,
0.6137633323669434,
-0.5220373272895813,
-0.09037013351917267,
-0.35981377959251404,
0.025357525795698166,
-0.33470776677131653,
-0.23065176606178284,
0.31430304050445557,
-0.3387283384799957,
-0.6133450269699097,
0.22752028703689575,
0.33664560317993164,
0.47623831033706665,
-0.07270192354917526,
0.12893855571746826,
-0.13423486053943634,
0.23306766152381897,
0.668265700340271,
-0.13316009938716888,
-0.7153872847557068,
-0.25336921215057373,
-0.42411622405052185,
-0.14750400185585022,
-0.2691560983657837,
0.6070289015769958,
-0.8884344696998596,
0.39423099160194397,
0.6817648410797119,
0.3837769031524658,
0.5531591773033142,
0.06485152244567871,
0.8008034229278564,
-0.7721220254898071,
0.14882881939411163,
0.06017465889453888,
0.45184844732284546,
0.33506348729133606,
-0.1712563931941986,
0.33628296852111816,
0.17675632238388062,
-0.28636056184768677,
-0.2583494484424591,
0.3680812418460846,
-1.0799905061721802,
-0.6677314639091492,
1.0281471014022827,
-0.33796975016593933,
-0.32745471596717834,
-0.0075271762907505035,
-0.43577083945274353,
0.5543575882911682,
-0.34831503033638,
0.4836105406284332,
0.6463767886161804,
-0.09944890439510345,
-0.33594954013824463,
-0.5295989513397217,
0.09822265058755875,
0.38556811213493347,
-0.9325258135795593,
0.0018978652078658342,
0.8240191340446472,
0.21506570279598236,
-0.3035067915916443,
0.5668028593063354,
0.21973787248134613,
0.2316909283399582,
0.29892346262931824,
-0.08154748380184174,
0.16371361911296844,
-0.34242963790893555,
-0.15693196654319763,
0.3299521505832672,
0.05839333310723305,
0.07189331203699112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05515v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05515v1
|
Mmm whatcha say? Uncovering distal and proximal context effects in first and second-language word perception using psychophysical reverse correlation
| 2024-06-08T16:25:30 | 2024-06-08T16:25:30 |
Paige Tuttösí, H. Henny Yeung, Yue Wang, Fenqi Wang, Guillaume Denis, Jean-Julien Aucouturier, Angelica Lim
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Acoustic context effects, where surrounding changes in pitch, rate or timbre
influence the perception of a sound, are well documented in speech perception,
but how they interact with language background remains unclear. Using a
reverse-correlation approach, we systematically varied the pitch and speech
rate in phrases around different pairs of vowels for second language (L2)
speakers of English (/i/-/I/) and French (/u/-/y/), thus reconstructing, in a
data-driven manner, the prosodic profiles that bias their perception. Testing
English and French speakers (n=25), we showed that vowel perception is in fact
influenced by conflicting effects from the surrounding pitch and speech rate: a
congruent proximal effect 0.2s pre-target and a distal contrastive effect up to
1s before; and found that L1 and L2 speakers exhibited strikingly similar
prosodic profiles in perception. We provide a novel method to investigate
acoustic context effects across stimuli, timescales, and acoustic domain.
|
[
-0.43389207124710083,
-1.156654715538025,
0.5643406510353088,
0.2591063380241394,
-0.1362193375825882,
-0.3143784999847412,
-0.009561381302773952,
-0.5975334644317627,
0.5991942286491394,
0.42743420600891113,
-0.5588197112083435,
-0.28129076957702637,
-0.468694269657135,
-0.056886039674282074,
-0.12120181322097778,
0.5271075963973999,
0.5810989737510681,
0.2675275206565857,
0.04418099299073219,
-0.2997930347919464,
-0.7348563075065613,
-0.3591019809246063,
-0.5502508878707886,
-0.33981627225875854,
0.3511936366558075,
0.5042626261711121,
0.8680330514907837,
0.24738766252994537,
0.27567097544670105,
0.33677273988723755,
-0.17605112493038177,
-0.13156796991825104,
-0.14893341064453125,
0.19956839084625244,
-0.14531461894512177,
-0.5962284803390503,
-0.30031880736351013,
0.09307948499917984,
0.6043623685836792,
0.689257025718689,
0.020640728995203972,
-0.060752023011446,
0.20890550315380096,
0.666521430015564,
-0.45195603370666504,
-0.11978669464588165,
-0.49258720874786377,
-0.05314938724040985,
-0.22843314707279205,
-0.6423820853233337,
-0.20736464858055115,
-0.09081107378005981,
0.2344937026500702,
-0.5462206602096558,
0.17809715867042542,
0.02314755693078041,
0.6757071018218994,
0.13677974045276642,
-0.5312990546226501,
-0.09117292612791061,
-0.613526463508606,
0.6809046864509583,
-0.616133451461792,
1.0330719947814941,
0.6984884142875671,
0.11064283549785614,
0.033060915768146515,
-0.555385172367096,
-0.8127097487449646,
-0.28151217103004456,
-0.2973282039165497,
0.19068516790866852,
-0.1976289451122284,
-0.08276939392089844,
-0.03366903215646744,
0.1401909738779068,
-0.6648197174072266,
0.08971456438302994,
-0.2997235357761383,
-0.31654950976371765,
0.31322526931762695,
-0.27873316407203674,
0.3625759482383728,
0.013253063894808292,
-0.12831377983093262,
-0.07950612902641296,
-0.777627170085907,
0.1752338856458664,
0.43360814452171326,
0.38248029351234436,
-0.33554601669311523,
0.5537277460098267,
0.1192520409822464,
0.42257630825042725,
0.1816403865814209,
-0.4162255823612213,
0.4276121258735657,
-0.3635459244251251,
0.06721163541078568,
0.08262665569782257,
0.6311309337615967,
0.5385162234306335,
0.2041434496641159,
-0.0542009174823761,
0.1975051313638687,
0.027198035269975662,
-0.15483510494232178,
-0.4743795692920685,
-0.05612122267484665,
-0.038904644548892975,
-0.26035305857658386,
-0.026949718594551086,
-0.14179997146129608,
-0.5035428404808044,
-0.5534012913703918,
-0.3153838813304901,
0.43394580483436584,
-0.30178916454315186,
-0.5431644916534424,
-0.07624812424182892,
-0.31787124276161194,
0.42041265964508057,
-0.22330066561698914,
-0.7539840936660767,
0.3333044946193695,
0.6198074221611023,
0.8265491724014282,
0.10328587889671326,
-0.40303754806518555,
-0.5072993636131287,
-0.12359267473220825,
-0.2772994637489319,
0.9031469821929932,
-0.7853567004203796,
-0.8890184760093689,
-0.10813349485397339,
0.0063443873077631,
0.14448948204517365,
-0.7068891525268555,
0.6880462169647217,
-0.30029386281967163,
0.14137427508831024,
-0.3841949999332428,
-0.22966954112052917,
0.06616995483636856,
-0.16142822802066803,
-0.5669216513633728,
0.9074051976203918,
-0.01015735138207674,
-0.9489380121231079,
0.38611167669296265,
-0.07861100882291794,
-0.6812402606010437,
-0.0802057757973671,
-0.649945855140686,
-0.1499740183353424,
0.2963602542877197,
0.11369455605745316,
0.059512555599212646,
-0.12382660806179047,
-0.10751008242368698,
-0.11922498792409897,
-0.2795192003250122,
0.4471849203109741,
-0.3897937834262848,
0.6141653656959534,
-0.1886565238237381,
-0.5116421580314636,
-0.06936673820018768,
-0.7492080926895142,
-0.2417968511581421,
0.20881253480911255,
0.2127518653869629,
-0.6629766821861267,
0.13084228336811066,
0.1639232188463211,
0.09854138642549515,
0.1238502562046051,
-0.5893999934196472,
-0.003799294587224722,
-0.6070146560668945,
0.607358455657959,
0.35950925946235657,
0.3349251449108124,
0.4420599639415741,
-0.3038925528526306,
0.10739824920892715,
0.069639652967453,
-0.01740366965532303,
-0.17161168158054352,
-0.6484447717666626,
-0.2843746244907379,
-0.09384805709123611,
-0.17705406248569489,
0.40336042642593384,
-0.15244239568710327,
0.3238682746887207,
0.04370316490530968,
-0.33742302656173706,
-0.614836573600769,
-0.09440582245588303,
0.4541609287261963,
0.8786154985427856,
0.33935338258743286,
-0.1349581480026245,
-0.5859947800636292,
-1.2274888753890991,
-0.3644818365573883,
-0.6035157442092896,
-0.23699642717838287,
0.3688240051269531,
0.15966562926769257,
0.04765191674232483,
1.0502318143844604,
-0.6429890990257263,
-0.662106454372406,
0.11801636964082718,
0.11336857080459595,
0.07775644212961197,
0.34899505972862244,
0.5317717790603638,
-1.0211809873580933,
-0.1125621646642685,
-0.14849695563316345,
-0.060683511197566986,
-0.3116438686847687,
0.21510152518749237,
0.18761469423770905,
0.14723144471645355,
0.7174727320671082,
-0.2389185130596161,
0.05747614800930023,
0.4301324784755707,
-0.40785476565361023,
0.7571854591369629,
-0.08962906897068024,
0.16180865466594696,
-0.9715039134025574,
-0.11423184722661972,
0.059127628803253174,
0.0929536297917366,
-0.4719044268131256,
-0.11637476086616516,
-0.1893605887889862,
0.23898945748806,
-0.5583810210227966,
0.7876158952713013,
-0.380666583776474,
-0.2974647879600525,
-0.3096037805080414,
0.4581051170825958,
0.23476815223693848,
0.2334529608488083,
0.3867817223072052,
1.131445050239563,
0.6738790273666382,
-0.5947667956352234,
-0.1997918039560318,
0.2521815001964569,
-0.45108139514923096,
0.8859233856201172,
-0.7207193970680237,
0.21065253019332886,
-0.11137552559375763,
0.20172367990016937,
-1.5484622716903687,
0.09761510789394379,
-0.1734883040189743,
-0.8365840911865234,
0.15945500135421753,
-0.09786838293075562,
-0.35055726766586304,
-0.008852931670844555,
-0.14147725701332092,
0.402606725692749,
0.5800004601478577,
-0.3053987920284271,
0.2660539448261261,
0.7946784496307373,
-0.32357755303382874,
-0.3291333317756653,
-0.9759517908096313,
-0.19011998176574707,
-0.3930606245994568,
-0.4315953254699707,
0.20953236520290375,
0.06387936323881149,
-0.7393417954444885,
-0.4583981931209564,
-0.27706649899482727,
-0.160117045044899,
0.06711982190608978,
0.4708288609981537,
-0.06843622773885727,
-0.20599229633808136,
0.11329866200685501,
0.20846472680568695,
-0.004377644043415785,
0.20375880599021912,
-0.2958625555038452,
0.42620396614074707,
-0.15230722725391388,
-0.14561836421489716,
-0.41773948073387146,
0.23987992107868195,
0.5405386090278625,
-0.1686619073152542,
0.5307362675666809,
0.6072960495948792,
-0.2842656672000885,
0.21011143922805786,
-0.6005058884620667,
-0.5659233927726746,
-0.4759225845336914,
0.44891563057899475,
-0.673439621925354,
-0.6587569117546082,
0.5086283683776855,
0.14346525073051453,
-0.15492959320545197,
0.23045003414154053,
0.6665917634963989,
-0.31676915287971497,
0.8779481053352356,
0.3007107079029083,
-0.14740055799484253,
0.5083199739456177,
-0.11975757032632828,
0.21563638746738434,
-0.9211822748184204,
-0.16834715008735657,
-0.6841504573822021,
-0.15790872275829315,
-0.749922513961792,
-0.19872663915157318,
0.648604691028595,
0.2549252510070801,
0.12652312219142914,
0.310014933347702,
0.0456528440117836,
0.5291638970375061,
0.20112371444702148,
0.06661747395992279,
0.30142635107040405,
-0.10802964866161346,
-0.37671801447868347,
-0.4002293646335602,
-0.2294512391090393,
-0.34166795015335083,
0.7740964293479919,
0.3189549446105957,
0.1587286740541458,
0.26047483086586,
0.366183340549469,
0.3963318467140198,
-0.24551138281822205,
-0.8002179265022278,
0.5544823408126831,
0.01912108063697815,
-0.36969929933547974,
-0.46642351150512695,
0.06632601469755173,
-1.1289455890655518,
0.3571108281612396,
-0.2233552783727646,
-0.9939201474189758,
0.2269362509250641,
0.199848011136055,
-0.08774664998054504,
-0.026670392602682114,
-0.5328311324119568,
0.3706715703010559,
0.10583120584487915,
-0.6074559092521667,
-0.4136820435523987,
-0.6419193744659424,
0.14764750003814697,
0.09572848677635193,
0.8238680362701416,
-0.09222320467233658,
-0.1332497000694275,
0.621412456035614,
-0.3456134498119354,
0.7688880562782288,
-0.2454659342765808,
-0.6798883676528931,
0.3449890911579132,
0.39584964513778687,
0.33549150824546814,
0.16636031866073608,
-0.028480079025030136,
0.409096896648407,
-0.12058290839195251,
-0.24792484939098358,
-0.5993940234184265,
0.8446820974349976,
-0.706795871257782,
-0.6817451119422913,
0.12598522007465363,
-0.4359080493450165,
-0.6124346852302551,
0.22634188830852509,
0.5388785004615784,
0.7359446287155151,
-0.538151204586029,
-0.13526199758052826,
0.24649596214294434,
0.019635384902358055,
0.24402187764644623,
0.8276865482330322,
-0.22845980525016785,
-0.005017441231757402,
0.8337651491165161,
0.25307658314704895,
0.21335402131080627,
0.712666392326355,
0.6554554104804993,
-0.7859062552452087,
-0.25180181860923767,
-0.10193465650081635,
0.3461959660053253,
-0.4813604950904846,
0.4444667398929596,
-0.5515312552452087,
0.18903984129428864,
-0.7279096841812134,
-0.13813334703445435,
-0.3632243275642395,
-0.6287041902542114,
0.09768954664468765,
-0.22769618034362793,
0.21752652525901794,
0.3446320593357086,
-0.37550652027130127,
0.4805798828601837,
-0.5477903485298157,
0.20135673880577087,
0.3457205295562744,
0.16110752522945404,
-0.19669193029403687,
-0.9963330626487732,
0.0847739577293396,
0.054860953241586685,
-0.1254819631576538,
-0.9832489490509033,
0.39201390743255615,
0.3942049741744995,
0.25898340344429016,
0.5541844367980957,
-0.05409453064203262,
0.39294543862342834,
-0.6725820899009705,
0.9292919039726257,
0.15154175460338593,
-0.8578047156333923,
0.5906562209129333,
-0.2690618336200714,
0.2644381821155548,
0.4040534496307373,
0.2988860011100769,
-0.49866554141044617,
-0.5528989434242249,
-0.5120375752449036,
-0.8808360695838928,
0.21349678933620453,
0.2867341935634613,
-0.0962037444114685,
-0.21707312762737274,
-0.05839961767196655,
0.3227890133857727,
-0.03668436035513878,
-0.21470478177070618,
-0.6003996729850769,
-0.006070093717426062,
0.43079259991645813,
-0.39949914813041687,
-0.19721603393554688,
-0.23108607530593872,
-0.1601359099149704,
0.3247908353805542,
0.04745687544345856,
0.22561055421829224,
0.30532991886138916,
-0.06828096508979797,
-0.062483642250299454,
0.5550671815872192,
0.784139096736908,
0.6783438920974731,
-0.2655502259731293,
0.4809299111366272,
0.2695433795452118,
-0.7267871499061584,
0.1172381266951561,
-0.10396434366703033,
-0.03931037709116936,
0.27749791741371155,
0.7595576047897339,
0.722949206829071,
0.30797305703163147,
-0.5299616456031799,
0.4682621359825134,
0.09196591377258301,
-0.15588818490505219,
-0.2644686698913574,
-0.13412736356258392,
0.2557295858860016,
0.27718502283096313,
0.4007108211517334,
-0.12842018902301788,
0.4865401089191437,
-0.7515686750411987,
0.23582397401332855,
0.3522828221321106,
-0.4852477014064789,
-0.6870733499526978,
0.46062085032463074,
0.006084626540541649,
-0.3965006470680237,
0.1896783858537674,
0.25457996129989624,
-0.44863229990005493,
0.6159932017326355,
0.6686464548110962,
0.9219880700111389,
-0.3826964199542999,
0.06354302912950516,
0.4236380159854889,
-0.05348937213420868,
0.4655967056751251,
0.5604038238525391,
-0.44557687640190125,
-0.8464780449867249,
-0.06239258125424385,
-0.3579300045967102,
-0.4051063358783722,
0.27956289052963257,
-0.8833041191101074,
0.0583626925945282,
0.06032392010092735,
-0.4186280369758606,
0.3753504157066345,
-0.19101126492023468,
-0.5353272557258606,
0.17774930596351624,
0.17435234785079956,
0.5925045609474182,
-1.0148322582244873,
0.8078634738922119,
0.7833921909332275,
-0.1591731607913971,
-0.47787922620773315,
0.411750465631485,
0.4022273123264313,
-0.9276077151298523,
0.8273413777351379,
0.05187075585126877,
-0.6679884791374207,
0.12316366285085678,
-0.31186217069625854,
-0.5659752488136292,
0.5930991768836975,
-0.08513068407773972,
-0.8750631213188171,
0.13142037391662598,
0.436679482460022,
0.696614682674408,
-0.013252265751361847,
0.47680234909057617,
1.0234402418136597,
0.5330683588981628,
-0.03096870891749859,
-1.2199550867080688,
-0.2262692153453827,
-0.06715043634176254,
-0.24300415813922882,
0.1222870945930481,
-0.6970588564872742,
0.5714954137802124,
-0.5495363473892212,
-0.4147012531757355,
-0.1893128901720047,
0.5454360246658325,
0.4765703082084656,
0.28525668382644653,
0.5595394968986511,
0.1984812319278717,
0.6057013273239136,
0.11445757746696472,
0.722425103187561,
-0.4849764406681061,
-0.07747333496809006,
1.186662197113037,
-0.4501489996910095,
1.1070265769958496,
0.8369710445404053,
-0.503291666507721,
0.29796871542930603,
0.3367060124874115,
0.6607308983802795,
0.5877991318702698,
0.26414892077445984,
-0.21458931267261505,
0.12046747654676437,
-0.5263165831565857,
-0.7232457399368286,
0.6252859234809875,
0.5703471899032593,
0.07576512545347214,
0.11014098674058914,
0.2570376396179199,
0.05075602978467941,
0.31302574276924133,
-0.16522058844566345,
0.6440310478210449,
0.19236597418785095,
-0.4705451428890228,
0.6426770091056824,
-0.15770955383777618,
0.541591227054596,
-0.5225626826286316,
0.020771240815520287,
-0.49546995759010315,
0.020277587696909904,
-0.1609325408935547,
-1.0601285696029663,
0.402295857667923,
-0.25330421328544617,
-0.12861302495002747,
0.1408439576625824,
0.5116103887557983,
-0.43171483278274536,
-0.04893620312213898,
0.5418633222579956,
0.463849276304245,
0.23712991178035736,
-0.020810827612876892,
-0.3957192301750183,
0.03233028203248978,
-0.3781130313873291,
-0.11289594322443008,
0.17030806839466095,
0.3508501648902893,
-0.06346026808023453,
0.3745385408401489,
0.4001848101615906,
0.24333199858665466,
-0.02319110929965973,
0.36841627955436707,
0.4354916214942932,
-0.3825925290584564,
-0.7741675972938538,
-0.7068454623222351,
0.10506559908390045,
0.4706045091152191,
-0.5061163306236267,
0.6600185036659241,
0.619077205657959,
1.0321978330612183,
-0.07234103977680206,
0.6259995102882385,
0.15523050725460052,
0.6652814149856567,
-0.5661792755126953,
0.5466808676719666,
-0.7006701827049255,
0.1590457409620285,
-0.370714008808136,
-0.8719009757041931,
0.0556391105055809,
0.5806612968444824,
-0.3831822872161865,
-0.2710806131362915,
0.8257524967193604,
1.006832480430603,
0.14294908940792084,
0.09342251718044281,
0.5202968716621399,
0.6038030982017517,
-0.017680441960692406,
0.03811810538172722,
0.6217702627182007,
-0.2806985676288605,
0.21348708868026733,
-0.2047162503004074,
-0.10062368214130402,
-0.10115500539541245,
-0.5008994340896606,
-0.5058500170707703,
-1.0917977094650269,
-0.33507269620895386,
-0.36843636631965637,
0.11401302367448807,
0.7131465673446655,
0.6141009330749512,
-0.8196425437927246,
-0.37097328901290894,
-0.08028123527765274,
-0.0024817108642309904,
-0.4126221835613251,
-0.29518187046051025,
0.6517390012741089,
-0.06971807032823563,
-0.7912974953651428,
0.808975875377655,
0.26265040040016174,
0.13308608531951904,
-0.2826308310031891,
-0.18537838757038116,
-0.10122981667518616,
0.23584148287773132,
0.6089618802070618,
0.5290822386741638,
-0.7766528725624084,
-0.15257366001605988,
-0.009410865604877472,
-0.17771226167678833,
0.18014127016067505,
0.8238246440887451,
-0.7864654660224915,
0.402854323387146,
0.5282522439956665,
0.16167213022708893,
0.15673993527889252,
-0.16187097132205963,
0.4156401455402374,
-0.8387426733970642,
0.5518614053726196,
-0.036844655871391296,
0.34504130482673645,
0.13197922706604004,
-0.15923546254634857,
0.3668425977230072,
0.4607260525226593,
-0.22529171407222748,
-0.7574511170387268,
0.44367390871047974,
-0.9481967091560364,
-0.30769166350364685,
1.2115046977996826,
0.2771620750427246,
0.08458779007196426,
-0.24751153588294983,
-0.583672285079956,
0.19622032344341278,
-0.2706526815891266,
0.4387238621711731,
0.5967591404914856,
-0.12446213513612747,
-0.1447010338306427,
-0.43721750378608704,
0.4922058880329132,
0.729374885559082,
-0.3487907648086548,
-0.15325847268104553,
0.42075249552726746,
0.1563149094581604,
0.15185317397117615,
0.715324878692627,
-0.0004175413050688803,
0.015268021263182163,
0.23679214715957642,
-0.2688330113887787,
0.06375934183597565,
-0.4554777145385742,
-0.2124640941619873,
-0.04266568273305893,
0.040020156651735306,
-0.4333830177783966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05510v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05510v1
|
Representation Learning with Conditional Information Flow Maximization
| 2024-06-08T16:19:18 | 2024-06-08T16:19:18 |
Dou Hu, Lingwei Wei, Wei Zhou, Songlin Hu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
This paper proposes an information-theoretic representation learning
framework, named conditional information flow maximization, to extract
noise-invariant sufficient representations for the input data and target task.
It promotes the learned representations have good feature uniformity and
sufficient predictive ability, which can enhance the generalization of
pre-trained language models (PLMs) for the target task. Firstly, an information
flow maximization principle is proposed to learn more sufficient
representations by simultaneously maximizing both input-representation and
representation-label mutual information. In contrast to information bottleneck,
we handle the input-representation information in an opposite way to avoid the
over-compression issue of latent representations. Besides, to mitigate the
negative effect of potential redundant features, a conditional information
minimization principle is designed to eliminate negative redundant features
while preserve noise-invariant features from the input. Experiments on 13
language understanding benchmarks demonstrate that our method effectively
improves the performance of PLMs for classification and regression. Extensive
experiments show that the learned representations are more sufficient, robust
and transferable.
|
[
-0.362626850605011,
-0.42657971382141113,
0.5064448118209839,
0.10847098380327225,
-0.405279278755188,
0.007871730253100395,
-0.35821932554244995,
-0.06639015674591064,
0.15986640751361847,
0.5926645398139954,
-0.42192158102989197,
-0.4409744441509247,
-1.0043468475341797,
-0.1647670716047287,
-0.42107659578323364,
0.775749921798706,
-0.12745772302150726,
0.2282949686050415,
-0.26583608984947205,
-0.22301733493804932,
-0.5191478729248047,
-0.6340383887290955,
-0.6829084157943726,
-0.15933093428611755,
0.30806875228881836,
0.19596439599990845,
0.48181015253067017,
0.7337326407432556,
0.31854456663131714,
0.35429325699806213,
0.3348439633846283,
-0.16191372275352478,
-0.6417992115020752,
0.25107017159461975,
-0.15783248841762543,
-0.8247718214988708,
0.1404796987771988,
0.0953407734632492,
0.8549389839172363,
0.7872723937034607,
-0.281341016292572,
0.09076852351427078,
0.17577968537807465,
0.574034571647644,
-0.7415032982826233,
0.7920882105827332,
-0.4598742723464966,
0.04855533316731453,
-0.06400825083255768,
-0.5226390361785889,
-0.5124325752258301,
-0.2619974613189697,
-0.057305190712213516,
-0.8526308536529541,
-0.033733293414115906,
-0.15776179730892181,
0.8539328575134277,
0.5607861280441284,
-0.2882791757583618,
-0.10760313272476196,
-0.6536205410957336,
0.6643539667129517,
-0.2663933336734772,
0.5933145880699158,
0.5099583864212036,
0.5942546129226685,
0.0035077796783298254,
-0.7839040756225586,
-0.44796305894851685,
0.024511776864528656,
-0.18255501985549927,
0.17757342755794525,
-0.2556471526622772,
0.3384394943714142,
0.5192448496818542,
0.12244681268930435,
-0.6444942355155945,
-0.26750972867012024,
-0.3207213878631592,
-0.5783740282058716,
0.3874454200267792,
-0.1649838387966156,
0.19573672115802765,
0.1957600861787796,
-0.3695521354675293,
-0.21637330949306488,
-0.4909907281398773,
0.3135499656200409,
0.12001284956932068,
0.1897532194852829,
-0.26064231991767883,
0.2869615852832794,
-0.009577237069606781,
0.8713766932487488,
0.07946621626615524,
-0.3789365589618683,
0.4376622140407562,
-0.27013030648231506,
-0.19406408071517944,
-0.21473683416843414,
0.5363888144493103,
-0.3477654755115509,
0.24632437527179718,
-0.20712710916996002,
-0.2780352234840393,
0.0716632604598999,
-0.013788608834147453,
-0.8857926726341248,
-0.059819746762514114,
-0.14995017647743225,
-0.5605514049530029,
-0.010674550198018551,
0.3404943346977234,
-0.4996553063392639,
-0.3297592103481293,
-0.6161201000213623,
0.45616981387138367,
-0.4946974515914917,
-0.552770733833313,
0.017620977014303207,
-0.05611565709114075,
0.16224993765354156,
0.2694234848022461,
-0.6233633160591125,
0.3455345034599304,
0.4267180860042572,
0.638684093952179,
-0.07996807992458344,
-0.0941285789012909,
-0.8152459263801575,
0.2340359389781952,
-0.2927303612232208,
0.42714163661003113,
-0.5749422311782837,
0.046671513468027115,
0.12615911662578583,
-0.12061860412359238,
-0.3019578158855438,
-0.5823866128921509,
0.2794502079486847,
-0.6053074598312378,
0.09398631006479263,
-0.3661489188671112,
-0.7423890829086304,
-0.3514626920223236,
-0.23585611581802368,
-0.8079032897949219,
0.34387150406837463,
0.4693731665611267,
-0.7574883103370667,
0.5072634220123291,
-0.3265180289745331,
-0.46171504259109497,
-0.04870631918311119,
-0.35305002331733704,
-0.24332770705223083,
0.028152933344244957,
-0.0996336042881012,
0.48679855465888977,
-0.07477586716413498,
0.42908212542533875,
-0.23000481724739075,
-0.2940440773963928,
0.020853392779827118,
-0.26104894280433655,
0.6002917289733887,
0.46019649505615234,
-0.15707702934741974,
0.015129707753658295,
-0.8146968483924866,
-0.20912477374076843,
0.16142170131206512,
-0.5260722637176514,
-0.20099203288555145,
0.011800349690020084,
-0.32567310333251953,
0.15466681122779846,
0.303062379360199,
-0.4060072600841522,
-0.08309932798147202,
-0.1950903832912445,
0.2016013264656067,
0.7398679256439209,
-0.049503665417432785,
0.6711120009422302,
-0.41785967350006104,
0.6554816365242004,
0.31982704997062683,
-0.1345357447862625,
-0.09475254267454147,
-0.1599944680929184,
-0.8405214548110962,
-0.4373716711997986,
0.5062820911407471,
0.7292227149009705,
-1.1214168071746826,
0.3250102698802948,
-0.06027252972126007,
0.4027545750141144,
-0.24161970615386963,
0.5024785995483398,
0.3200703561306,
0.4331708550453186,
0.20353581011295319,
-0.17101961374282837,
-0.9807217121124268,
-0.6668825149536133,
-0.10188154876232147,
-0.3505963087081909,
0.25142189860343933,
-0.1270001381635666,
0.05892585590481758,
-0.055239856243133545,
0.7065532207489014,
-0.1890556365251541,
-0.17026790976524353,
-0.6075697541236877,
0.35289767384529114,
0.3151214122772217,
0.4284084737300873,
0.6660728454589844,
-1.0886284112930298,
-0.5490791201591492,
-0.2047073394060135,
-0.5701643228530884,
-0.1682269275188446,
-0.19197410345077515,
-0.18561741709709167,
0.06848197430372238,
0.6345150470733643,
-0.4876389801502228,
0.43007996678352356,
0.6101334095001221,
-0.3156360685825348,
0.015922097489237785,
-0.15849004685878754,
-0.17169158160686493,
-0.8231300115585327,
-0.08518589287996292,
0.12651318311691284,
-0.7337296009063721,
-0.5605483055114746,
-0.20123015344142914,
0.04676103964447975,
-0.32511869072914124,
-0.12525705993175507,
0.42672765254974365,
-0.5150002241134644,
0.055349212139844894,
-0.39848387241363525,
-0.2511940598487854,
-0.07935236394405365,
0.6311814188957214,
0.29455316066741943,
0.6358171701431274,
0.8176756501197815,
-0.73228520154953,
-0.06959277391433716,
-0.34847772121429443,
-0.010460282675921917,
0.44995927810668945,
-0.2249961942434311,
-0.10951920598745346,
-0.5157988667488098,
0.10002744942903519,
-0.7905393242835999,
-0.09298120439052582,
0.2342042326927185,
-0.47910967469215393,
0.8520729541778564,
-0.11781295388936996,
-0.4403092861175537,
-0.071710966527462,
-0.051137082278728485,
0.013338787481188774,
0.7615268230438232,
-0.5095141530036926,
0.8551461696624756,
0.5662433505058289,
-0.052916381508111954,
-0.6113319993019104,
-0.5508224368095398,
-0.47239717841148376,
0.009309054352343082,
-0.5591027736663818,
0.33526811003685,
-0.03555937856435776,
0.1254124939441681,
0.06677614152431488,
-0.22960497438907623,
-0.304857075214386,
-0.011793897487223148,
0.19606491923332214,
0.02719884365797043,
-0.1340319812297821,
0.2955612540245056,
-0.013250312767922878,
-0.19253528118133545,
-0.03714362159371376,
-0.4787026345729828,
0.6151853203773499,
-0.04092523083090782,
-0.1862545907497406,
-0.5261204242706299,
0.44352883100509644,
0.3035978674888611,
0.024468638002872467,
0.8114976286888123,
0.8216943144798279,
-0.4758490324020386,
-0.23724117875099182,
-0.5574228167533875,
-0.1143418550491333,
-0.4750552475452423,
0.690871000289917,
-0.5447499752044678,
-0.8223801255226135,
0.3194431662559509,
-0.09435860812664032,
-0.11271210014820099,
0.29704776406288147,
0.20913729071617126,
-0.2469262033700943,
1.127305269241333,
1.1921788454055786,
-0.316679447889328,
0.7966597676277161,
-0.5599574446678162,
0.05899886041879654,
-0.32010921835899353,
-0.04577865079045296,
-0.2804456353187561,
-0.11290155351161957,
-0.28881508111953735,
-0.4026120603084564,
-0.09951023757457733,
0.6604132652282715,
-0.2885631024837494,
0.2422802746295929,
-0.11980856209993362,
0.29455462098121643,
0.45354682207107544,
0.10800635814666748,
-0.045533306896686554,
0.15934628248214722,
-0.3657950460910797,
0.05848228186368942,
-0.9364722371101379,
-0.22064241766929626,
0.9822812676429749,
0.3435297906398773,
0.640034556388855,
-0.023731671273708344,
0.8814107775688171,
0.23549939692020416,
0.29188603162765503,
-0.5802751183509827,
0.46712225675582886,
-0.2825550138950348,
-0.13918069005012512,
-0.20521506667137146,
-0.7403223514556885,
-0.7750020027160645,
0.19526724517345428,
-0.22630976140499115,
-0.5590471029281616,
0.5712956190109253,
0.35248273611068726,
0.02570251375436783,
0.29060500860214233,
-1.0078761577606201,
0.6113743782043457,
-0.14540860056877136,
-0.10973375290632248,
-0.22819794714450836,
-0.5877640843391418,
0.06819029897451401,
0.010075762867927551,
0.26736339926719666,
0.1614573895931244,
-0.21558690071105957,
0.8177023530006409,
-0.5247042775154114,
0.8687014579772949,
-0.6374483108520508,
0.46616998314857483,
0.3490038216114044,
-0.07374315708875656,
0.5505005121231079,
-0.020789859816432,
-0.04925917834043503,
0.04354234039783478,
-0.011981891468167305,
-0.3867231011390686,
-0.837399423122406,
0.1583317667245865,
-0.8739181160926819,
-0.5827122330665588,
-0.27884212136268616,
-0.3622068166732788,
-0.3396335542201996,
0.16748765110969543,
0.43074488639831543,
0.1467047780752182,
0.09978649020195007,
0.19945155084133148,
0.6587920784950256,
0.004682573024183512,
0.3860095739364624,
0.48474109172821045,
-0.05445067957043648,
-0.4065329134464264,
1.2715868949890137,
0.14209207892417908,
0.17694172263145447,
0.7633671164512634,
0.17493046820163727,
-0.23762694001197815,
-0.7622362375259399,
0.011776741594076157,
0.37375199794769287,
-0.925520122051239,
-0.3677259385585785,
-0.46280622482299805,
-0.4570915102958679,
-0.2650444507598877,
0.2858329713344574,
-0.2177508920431137,
-0.2894566059112549,
-0.5121724605560303,
-0.12623463571071625,
0.06490639597177505,
0.5752500891685486,
-0.4711166322231293,
0.33539268374443054,
-0.42520642280578613,
0.32580339908599854,
0.4475724399089813,
0.262765109539032,
-0.26832759380340576,
-0.5180527567863464,
-0.2564234137535095,
-0.15399223566055298,
-0.34094128012657166,
-0.8374034762382507,
0.3077313005924225,
0.5178092122077942,
0.9992474317550659,
0.5981383919715881,
-0.05941036343574524,
0.4083901345729828,
-0.0809222087264061,
0.2368282675743103,
0.5430744886398315,
-1.1370443105697632,
0.44141051173210144,
0.09835731983184814,
0.1408553570508957,
0.5243276357650757,
0.5211350321769714,
-0.11974848806858063,
-0.41756707429885864,
-0.560707688331604,
-0.37118563055992126,
0.6865605711936951,
0.2668773829936981,
-0.06280732899904251,
0.3467925488948822,
0.44834768772125244,
0.21249842643737793,
0.3504095673561096,
-0.8997964262962341,
-0.3579025864601135,
-0.43745526671409607,
-0.45685717463493347,
-0.06875471025705338,
-0.34991133213043213,
0.24544395506381989,
-0.3036021888256073,
0.44416821002960205,
-0.1264258623123169,
0.6146887540817261,
-0.013606025837361813,
-0.4208619296550751,
-0.0245570857077837,
0.06481169164180756,
0.4616168439388275,
0.780278742313385,
-0.17506204545497894,
0.1272713541984558,
-0.12196707725524902,
-0.5585650205612183,
0.33428218960762024,
0.19915594160556793,
-0.10870680212974548,
0.043819282203912735,
0.4977169930934906,
1.1750891208648682,
-0.325226366519928,
-0.3406553566455841,
0.9710065126419067,
-0.20792214572429657,
-0.3502531051635742,
-0.11561796814203262,
0.2294340282678604,
0.045662183314561844,
0.35521918535232544,
0.43514353036880493,
0.464744508266449,
0.1335480809211731,
-0.4989239275455475,
0.3768619894981384,
0.38110771775245667,
-0.36171063780784607,
-0.29493024945259094,
0.23365852236747742,
-0.16280221939086914,
0.014306914992630482,
0.06184801459312439,
-0.4656161069869995,
-0.5303122997283936,
0.5465090274810791,
0.4300329089164734,
0.6229636669158936,
-0.2315482497215271,
0.3439021706581116,
0.3687534034252167,
0.0904955044388771,
-0.047522399574518204,
0.6483191251754761,
-0.3263395130634308,
-0.7724118828773499,
-0.6324253678321838,
-0.5219632387161255,
-0.08649259805679321,
0.2554478645324707,
-0.6121559143066406,
0.3693295419216156,
-0.5949031114578247,
-0.2608829438686371,
-0.37169215083122253,
-0.12999311089515686,
-1.0358766317367554,
0.22214633226394653,
0.2785017490386963,
0.6462546586990356,
-0.7669191360473633,
1.0864369869232178,
0.5745396614074707,
-0.5541654229164124,
-1.0890626907348633,
-0.11554562300443649,
-0.33812272548675537,
-0.8307104110717773,
1.0130805969238281,
0.07376401126384735,
0.012198921293020248,
-0.19805395603179932,
-0.6599471569061279,
-1.2066869735717773,
0.8659892082214355,
1.1589686870574951,
-0.6658437848091125,
0.0921725258231163,
0.02126733958721161,
0.2770264148712158,
-0.6636924743652344,
0.10155217349529266,
0.27687811851501465,
0.38883769512176514,
0.3606921434402466,
-0.6206119656562805,
0.08461733907461166,
-0.3830026686191559,
0.04483071342110634,
-0.006588732823729515,
-0.36065906286239624,
0.801433265209198,
-0.13674670457839966,
-0.660817563533783,
-0.07009696960449219,
0.7199083566665649,
0.0737648531794548,
0.017480922862887383,
0.6839332580566406,
0.4692675471305847,
0.9121522903442383,
-0.2438804656267166,
1.046101450920105,
-0.3808647394180298,
0.21214477717876434,
0.9887164235115051,
0.10751202702522278,
0.6541978120803833,
0.33146336674690247,
-0.1720840483903885,
0.42040854692459106,
0.5132426619529724,
0.4218703806400299,
0.9930747151374817,
0.42727428674697876,
0.006171676330268383,
-0.4048190414905548,
0.150735005736351,
-0.43862372636795044,
0.4031226336956024,
0.48943325877189636,
-0.49720075726509094,
-0.19267450273036957,
0.42643794417381287,
-0.2724531292915344,
-0.1900428831577301,
-0.24904261529445648,
0.8692941665649414,
0.11997116357088089,
-0.4560388922691345,
0.9085144400596619,
-0.1319979429244995,
0.6420577168464661,
-0.8441342115402222,
-0.3051198720932007,
-0.15860290825366974,
-0.1315384805202484,
-0.1284908652305603,
-0.40930551290512085,
0.20131587982177734,
-0.4279372990131378,
-0.34514716267585754,
-0.40202948451042175,
0.8976151943206787,
-0.4407852590084076,
-0.3643588423728943,
0.5059057474136353,
0.28523582220077515,
-0.0006482481257990003,
0.030287131667137146,
-0.7109835743904114,
0.1009879931807518,
0.21235525608062744,
-0.040416646748781204,
0.2487560212612152,
0.42200350761413574,
0.25999292731285095,
0.6928390264511108,
0.37110018730163574,
0.7375521659851074,
0.31367000937461853,
0.22702589631080627,
0.8268177509307861,
-0.43225735425949097,
-0.6736277937889099,
-0.6445968151092529,
0.25402510166168213,
-0.18003278970718384,
0.1483561247587204,
0.17955996096134186,
0.2018686980009079,
0.8073304295539856,
0.15219077467918396,
1.0714690685272217,
0.1866924911737442,
0.616069495677948,
-0.8210733532905579,
0.5242910981178284,
-0.34117552638053894,
0.23805567622184753,
-0.030873917043209076,
-0.8342461585998535,
-0.29515406489372253,
0.8462072014808655,
-0.27195897698402405,
0.13414651155471802,
0.862070620059967,
0.6313460469245911,
-0.01849382184445858,
-0.03609291464090347,
0.4925718605518341,
0.08280443400144577,
0.09379563480615616,
0.7271881103515625,
0.8028881549835205,
-0.2685237228870392,
0.5824447274208069,
-0.4586367607116699,
-0.33131134510040283,
-0.00806890893727541,
-0.7660998106002808,
-0.863014817237854,
-0.8920565843582153,
-0.5064712166786194,
-0.2671937942504883,
0.1252698451280594,
0.7040491104125977,
1.1348814964294434,
-0.87527996301651,
-0.2423742562532425,
-0.3796689212322235,
0.3707311749458313,
-0.04190703108906746,
-0.23885521292686462,
0.3307357728481293,
-0.7555047273635864,
-0.27731049060821533,
0.0706508606672287,
0.2655467689037323,
0.21389120817184448,
-0.2643996477127075,
-0.4619322419166565,
0.09107203781604767,
-0.09242929518222809,
0.47158119082450867,
0.512855052947998,
-0.3311203420162201,
0.006569211371243,
-0.3896494507789612,
-0.12078239023685455,
0.32999852299690247,
1.059585452079773,
-0.7498989105224609,
0.6553504467010498,
0.8078436851501465,
0.7970810532569885,
0.7005696892738342,
-0.24737635254859924,
0.7884975671768188,
-0.7442419528961182,
0.5239434838294983,
0.21297883987426758,
0.7008382081985474,
0.2817032039165497,
-0.46442049741744995,
0.1618736982345581,
0.28614920377731323,
-0.0368361659348011,
-0.4106895625591278,
0.11097255349159241,
-0.8549484014511108,
-0.2958649694919586,
1.048903226852417,
-0.3702962100505829,
-0.1593986451625824,
-0.15038608014583588,
0.08907986432313919,
0.4369591772556305,
-0.5238238573074341,
0.07423854619264603,
0.5953649878501892,
-0.17556461691856384,
-0.5151157379150391,
-0.5559386610984802,
0.561428964138031,
0.27796000242233276,
-0.5748358368873596,
-0.5145769715309143,
0.22739988565444946,
0.34116658568382263,
0.15531887114048004,
0.7664309740066528,
0.03980554640293121,
0.21787817776203156,
-0.14729265868663788,
-0.1842241883277893,
-0.0905379056930542,
-0.41457444429397583,
-0.17185622453689575,
0.2062678188085556,
0.22403904795646667,
-0.299224317073822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05496v1
|
Generalist Multimodal AI: A Review of Architectures, Challenges and Opportunities
| 2024-06-08T15:30:46 | 2024-06-08T15:30:46 |
Sai Munikoti, Ian Stewart, Sameera Horawalavithana, Henry Kvinge, Tegan Emerson, Sandra E Thompson, Karl Pazdernik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal models are expected to be a critical component to future advances
in artificial intelligence. This field is starting to grow rapidly with a surge
of new design elements motivated by the success of foundation models in natural
language processing (NLP) and vision. It is widely hoped that further extending
the foundation models to multiple modalities (e.g., text, image, video, sensor,
time series, graph, etc.) will ultimately lead to generalist multimodal models,
i.e. one model across different data modalities and tasks. However, there is
little research that systematically analyzes recent multimodal models
(particularly the ones that work beyond text and vision) with respect to the
underling architecture proposed. Therefore, this work provides a fresh
perspective on generalist multimodal models (GMMs) via a novel architecture and
training configuration specific taxonomy. This includes factors such as
Unifiability, Modularity, and Adaptability that are pertinent and essential to
the wide adoption and application of GMMs. The review further highlights key
challenges and prospects for the field and guide the researchers into the new
advancements.
|
[
-0.5588443875312805,
-0.617755651473999,
0.5685232281684875,
-0.04595044627785683,
-0.038474418222904205,
0.15885092318058014,
0.09976182132959366,
-0.6558160185813904,
-0.04443135857582092,
0.18998117744922638,
-0.44448989629745483,
-0.22930723428726196,
-0.6575244069099426,
-0.07131510227918625,
-0.3820338547229767,
0.6881210207939148,
-0.12687231600284576,
0.10141590237617493,
-0.5419597029685974,
-0.40341588854789734,
-0.6574990153312683,
-0.5597478747367859,
-0.392281174659729,
-0.27607229351997375,
0.3374912142753601,
0.008019912987947464,
0.851008951663971,
0.2856289744377136,
0.5836803317070007,
0.48659589886665344,
0.005526546388864517,
0.3202390968799591,
0.3092772960662842,
-0.12470707297325134,
-0.05983804166316986,
-0.11822831630706787,
-0.5944411754608154,
0.16879862546920776,
0.7332190275192261,
0.7507645487785339,
0.03640919551253319,
-0.0390281155705452,
-0.00930782500654459,
0.4272385239601135,
-0.6074220538139343,
0.25270339846611023,
-0.5563751459121704,
0.06259041279554367,
0.022965403273701668,
0.002983855316415429,
-0.09217797964811325,
0.26343825459480286,
0.28047990798950195,
-0.5317696332931519,
0.17032477259635925,
-0.24547256529331207,
0.46329548954963684,
0.35074612498283386,
-0.7016734480857849,
-0.4619387686252594,
-0.802049458026886,
0.6909098625183105,
-0.5800389647483826,
0.4618234932422638,
0.03511936590075493,
0.53813636302948,
0.037648845463991165,
-0.6980589628219604,
-0.4891242980957031,
-0.22337161004543304,
-0.1202159896492958,
-0.0778016746044159,
-0.34589141607284546,
0.3068901300430298,
-0.12860053777694702,
0.4639820456504822,
-0.5835803747177124,
0.04607259854674339,
-0.23306459188461304,
-0.055868182331323624,
0.463484525680542,
0.3751460909843445,
0.48512333631515503,
-0.1046576201915741,
-0.5043084621429443,
0.11596225202083588,
-0.12610992789268494,
0.14540128409862518,
0.2211267650127411,
0.11051952093839645,
-0.2337803691625595,
0.3138124942779541,
-0.3297150135040283,
0.7139965891838074,
-0.23501835763454437,
0.006047929171472788,
0.5207626223564148,
-0.5090471506118774,
-0.38790109753608704,
-0.5308093428611755,
0.6994097828865051,
0.3146965801715851,
0.1668119579553604,
-0.28453853726387024,
-0.31470781564712524,
0.4963819682598114,
0.5607098937034607,
-0.38796138763427734,
-0.06063663214445114,
0.2822614014148712,
-0.6322274208068848,
-0.32270580530166626,
-0.06926319748163223,
-0.7495741248130798,
-0.17441776394844055,
-0.5948536396026611,
0.4184984564781189,
-0.42132872343063354,
-0.3693372309207916,
0.19038639962673187,
-0.14422981441020966,
0.2411222606897354,
0.5629146099090576,
-1.2112735509872437,
0.06073937937617302,
0.6683339476585388,
0.9518694877624512,
-0.10856874287128448,
-0.2539956271648407,
0.10187730938196182,
0.24006547033786774,
-0.15861041843891144,
0.8089146018028259,
-1.0211679935455322,
-0.6036025881767273,
0.03635132312774658,
-0.04790594428777695,
-0.5109155178070068,
-0.24192771315574646,
0.1920270472764969,
-0.38270726799964905,
0.344014972448349,
0.218359112739563,
-0.19477751851081848,
-0.5891145467758179,
0.7958335280418396,
-0.6579266786575317,
0.39662328362464905,
-0.025979075580835342,
-0.5648797154426575,
0.11772215366363525,
-1.1180918216705322,
-0.24927261471748352,
0.0725427195429802,
-0.5621718764305115,
-0.08344758301973343,
0.4075610935688019,
0.36171433329582214,
0.4306594431400299,
-0.3895271420478821,
0.5234173536300659,
-0.2979618012905121,
-0.18007807433605194,
0.07818838208913803,
-0.6953675150871277,
0.5290313959121704,
0.2967106103897095,
-0.13797329366207123,
0.39855116605758667,
-0.8270420432090759,
0.19537286460399628,
-0.09403114020824432,
-0.4232866168022156,
-0.1607424020767212,
0.32679569721221924,
0.20046855509281158,
0.2585381269454956,
0.06030530110001564,
-0.23602761328220367,
0.4342540204524994,
-0.06063121184706688,
0.6742178797721863,
0.7329497933387756,
-0.30838659405708313,
0.6589252948760986,
-0.45217180252075195,
0.7164629101753235,
0.04914122447371483,
0.4845501780509949,
-0.4448711574077606,
-0.6594067811965942,
-0.3922690749168396,
-0.5272082090377808,
0.10195250064134598,
0.667038083076477,
-0.8312969207763672,
-0.12097194045782089,
-0.22401006519794464,
-0.4468945562839508,
-0.674948513507843,
0.08406530320644379,
0.32624682784080505,
0.15611198544502258,
0.45800095796585083,
-0.5032089948654175,
-0.5098403096199036,
-0.8540331125259399,
0.060845788568258286,
0.006922160275280476,
-0.02728271670639515,
0.409779816865921,
0.5880904793739319,
-1.144763708114624,
1.0002292394638062,
-0.019459757953882217,
-0.27007752656936646,
-0.243851438164711,
0.33553335070610046,
0.02773960493505001,
0.768124520778656,
0.8149054646492004,
-1.3203809261322021,
-0.07733221352100372,
0.10710442811250687,
-0.9323084950447083,
0.35724034905433655,
-0.19288700819015503,
0.3657671809196472,
0.19130845367908478,
0.4334009289741516,
-0.9698411226272583,
0.31153517961502075,
0.6824641227722168,
-0.09049516171216965,
0.5277955532073975,
-0.13681787252426147,
0.33868810534477234,
-1.1060696840286255,
0.2990977168083191,
0.001691998913884163,
0.20440420508384705,
-0.7844125032424927,
0.29840409755706787,
-0.21575681865215302,
-0.17692500352859497,
-0.3290694057941437,
0.7176705598831177,
-0.5575528144836426,
-0.1422875076532364,
-0.2586030662059784,
-0.3470870554447174,
-0.17453573644161224,
0.4716688394546509,
-0.08357571810483932,
0.577628493309021,
0.643602728843689,
-0.5928441882133484,
0.6532793045043945,
0.1774061620235443,
-0.2537679672241211,
0.4662691652774811,
-0.7391124367713928,
0.06191287562251091,
-0.2777669429779053,
0.1491451859474182,
-1.2216509580612183,
-0.35134363174438477,
0.3742864727973938,
-0.468659907579422,
0.38994085788726807,
0.04071345552802086,
-0.2336198091506958,
-0.37553784251213074,
-0.3621757924556732,
0.8281794190406799,
0.1190115213394165,
-0.29412323236465454,
1.3100229501724243,
0.24825294315814972,
-0.07448408752679825,
-0.625862717628479,
-0.554733157157898,
0.22795280814170837,
-0.1482550948858261,
-0.7403658628463745,
0.4712676703929901,
-0.3556552231311798,
-0.3654167950153351,
0.11016298085451126,
0.1626269370317459,
-0.1430199146270752,
0.31893640756607056,
0.4470594525337219,
0.38724178075790405,
-0.3456289768218994,
0.06137756258249283,
-0.10762213170528412,
-0.27889660000801086,
-0.0915820449590683,
-0.1274942308664322,
0.3216787576675415,
-0.44621244072914124,
-0.4135189950466156,
-0.5392469167709351,
0.6795879006385803,
0.7383672595024109,
-0.497514545917511,
0.43887755274772644,
0.8459984064102173,
-0.31078001856803894,
0.2567113935947418,
-0.47190508246421814,
0.17755328118801117,
-0.4843386113643646,
0.5959149599075317,
-0.48863697052001953,
-0.8595456480979919,
0.43054521083831787,
-0.10170181095600128,
0.11079712212085724,
0.4334743022918701,
0.6288638710975647,
-0.10203336924314499,
1.2754825353622437,
1.0103695392608643,
-0.23268625140190125,
0.5516011118888855,
-0.29964810609817505,
-0.06630467623472214,
-0.8467771410942078,
-0.4412741959095001,
-0.3367325961589813,
-0.4893926978111267,
-0.5657453536987305,
-0.5102974772453308,
0.2392061948776245,
-0.3344484567642212,
-0.04779418557882309,
-0.22517232596874237,
-0.4620240032672882,
0.3257887065410614,
0.5176162719726562,
-0.34294092655181885,
0.22372740507125854,
-0.07455340027809143,
-0.22934161126613617,
0.34791848063468933,
-0.506492018699646,
-0.5886707305908203,
1.1486570835113525,
0.32098400592803955,
0.7497947216033936,
0.18512234091758728,
0.02688656933605671,
0.5505362153053284,
0.30540138483047485,
-0.45521730184555054,
0.4492599070072174,
-0.17570613324642181,
-0.913972795009613,
-0.1076870709657669,
-0.2121553272008896,
-0.7020910978317261,
0.461106538772583,
-0.3082279562950134,
-0.6934157013893127,
0.29504677653312683,
0.2697119414806366,
-0.33318957686424255,
0.5015700459480286,
-0.7455754280090332,
1.00527822971344,
-0.4405395984649658,
0.03203386813402176,
-0.2955334186553955,
-0.9590102434158325,
0.4206308126449585,
0.1572907716035843,
0.4097471833229065,
-0.0011808376293629408,
-0.0023247497156262398,
0.26550909876823425,
0.34062013030052185,
0.8924480676651001,
-0.19363000988960266,
0.11504632979631424,
0.21975992619991302,
-0.12834909558296204,
-0.07265654951334,
-0.026676872745156288,
0.29168805480003357,
0.2828300893306732,
0.01797671616077423,
-0.23609237372875214,
-0.4271898567676544,
0.4138665497303009,
-0.9654306173324585,
-0.5647412538528442,
-0.44837531447410583,
-0.7747536301612854,
-0.5180704593658447,
0.025180988013744354,
-0.02557479217648506,
0.7288292646408081,
-0.34113866090774536,
0.3110947906970978,
0.4486052691936493,
-0.07016041874885559,
0.6037066578865051,
0.06999669969081879,
-0.10256937891244888,
-0.5182428956031799,
0.7449804544448853,
-0.1535482108592987,
0.1878315955400467,
0.44782042503356934,
-0.17306479811668396,
-0.24241222441196442,
-0.7855085730552673,
-0.606181800365448,
-0.1664452701807022,
-0.6464923024177551,
0.10478424280881882,
-0.5809722542762756,
-0.2153310924768448,
-0.5845199227333069,
-0.2108314484357834,
-0.1284460872411728,
-0.28669828176498413,
-0.49281275272369385,
0.1420031636953354,
-0.14609000086784363,
0.9054057002067566,
-0.057768017053604126,
0.36063432693481445,
-0.7860722541809082,
0.49122366309165955,
0.6731595993041992,
0.36762064695358276,
0.22512580454349518,
-0.3019004762172699,
-0.13795539736747742,
0.1687125712633133,
-0.5508384108543396,
-0.4711701273918152,
0.12339303642511368,
0.3811374008655548,
1.0049190521240234,
0.5995795130729675,
-0.6023527383804321,
0.4635099470615387,
-0.626808226108551,
0.6948440670967102,
0.29019132256507874,
-0.6110883355140686,
0.21439673006534576,
-0.4108986556529999,
0.28478631377220154,
0.35475486516952515,
0.7011460065841675,
-0.6702970266342163,
0.172197163105011,
-0.3411106765270233,
-0.7527958750724792,
0.25196966528892517,
-0.23820187151432037,
0.3490968644618988,
0.10947175323963165,
0.28698301315307617,
0.05300099775195122,
0.4992632269859314,
-0.720434308052063,
0.15103282034397125,
-0.48920074105262756,
-0.35935959219932556,
-0.3281356394290924,
-0.39638346433639526,
-0.11987366527318954,
-0.2844572961330414,
0.3923841118812561,
-0.439164936542511,
0.4935658276081085,
-0.13012053072452545,
-0.2152658849954605,
0.11471322923898697,
0.5220188498497009,
0.8147916197776794,
0.5853070020675659,
-0.14634215831756592,
0.07733471691608429,
-0.08798879384994507,
-0.19419609010219574,
0.1641194224357605,
0.0731661319732666,
-0.10484803467988968,
-0.21480441093444824,
0.4777498245239258,
0.8734303712844849,
0.33953508734703064,
-0.5853825807571411,
0.32781097292900085,
0.08730878680944443,
-0.3030666410923004,
-0.25232478976249695,
0.08986853063106537,
-0.11136126518249512,
0.6994999647140503,
0.49803173542022705,
0.4305182993412018,
0.09607195109128952,
-0.8951332569122314,
0.013233071193099022,
0.9008052349090576,
-0.1995735764503479,
-0.562897264957428,
0.9325222969055176,
0.343647837638855,
-0.15494145452976227,
0.6851779818534851,
-0.03186286613345146,
-0.31864839792251587,
0.4153081476688385,
0.34829217195510864,
0.982542872428894,
-0.21349969506263733,
0.20804622769355774,
-0.25329312682151794,
0.33216267824172974,
0.18409956991672516,
0.08355243504047394,
-0.09199037402868271,
-0.9174813032150269,
-0.30143555998802185,
-0.6316618323326111,
-0.4827589988708496,
0.013567117042839527,
-0.2858421206474304,
-0.16103719174861908,
-0.4694075882434845,
-0.27571767568588257,
0.00021387243759818375,
-0.2811059057712555,
-0.5760539770126343,
0.40544357895851135,
0.5762696266174316,
0.7583640813827515,
-0.6262810826301575,
0.7397319674491882,
1.016664981842041,
-0.30948179960250854,
-0.06516754627227783,
-0.4381192624568939,
0.28113120794296265,
-0.7680299878120422,
0.3593639135360718,
0.373920738697052,
-0.09095582365989685,
-0.176898792386055,
-0.5364511013031006,
-0.6963200569152832,
1.2175487279891968,
0.2108386754989624,
-0.17360317707061768,
-0.7916529774665833,
0.18898682296276093,
0.49121299386024475,
-0.7044945359230042,
0.18659022450447083,
0.251341313123703,
0.42257413268089294,
0.14588046073913574,
-0.784285306930542,
-0.41782906651496887,
-0.6187320947647095,
0.30456429719924927,
0.025988895446062088,
-0.5798535346984863,
1.224327564239502,
-0.09233599901199341,
-0.05741344392299652,
0.3565453290939331,
0.4633195400238037,
-0.1793556660413742,
0.4473617672920227,
0.43932050466537476,
0.6713669300079346,
0.26435717940330505,
0.03613800182938576,
0.9432692527770996,
-0.10343116521835327,
0.20446111261844635,
0.7539040446281433,
-0.16237927973270416,
0.5300951600074768,
0.41411006450653076,
0.018644040450453758,
0.6117677688598633,
0.46561139822006226,
-0.243924081325531,
0.5361107587814331,
-0.25760719180107117,
-0.12973672151565552,
-0.25309455394744873,
-0.04894290864467621,
-0.5725849866867065,
0.7797512412071228,
0.4042504131793976,
-0.23798400163650513,
-0.29357779026031494,
0.27463507652282715,
-0.45240896940231323,
-0.021277572959661484,
-0.6244608759880066,
0.5878779292106628,
-0.17428287863731384,
-0.2565367817878723,
0.08359526097774506,
0.24231059849262238,
0.9875640273094177,
-0.8214824795722961,
-0.010802183300256729,
-0.06951037049293518,
0.2722383737564087,
-0.07849351316690445,
-0.389530211687088,
0.3770825266838074,
-0.23380836844444275,
-0.3954124450683594,
-0.38678768277168274,
0.7042204737663269,
-0.16357703506946564,
-0.4745112955570221,
0.3100994825363159,
0.717501163482666,
-0.274949312210083,
-0.20401236414909363,
-0.8225536942481995,
0.08470182865858078,
-0.20985467731952667,
-0.16191285848617554,
0.39467546343803406,
0.26494815945625305,
-0.09548752009868622,
0.8878465890884399,
0.5618376731872559,
-0.3449009954929352,
0.11819867044687271,
-0.19568413496017456,
0.9496095776557922,
-0.7883649468421936,
-0.462066650390625,
-0.8068775534629822,
0.738223135471344,
0.30272936820983887,
-0.3876059055328369,
0.49631670117378235,
0.2288355976343155,
0.7796797156333923,
-0.06974494457244873,
0.6692304015159607,
-0.04047805443406105,
0.0601787194609642,
-0.527789831161499,
0.6253092885017395,
-0.9448224306106567,
-0.22954469919204712,
-0.5311353802680969,
-0.6101941466331482,
-0.42930206656455994,
0.405900776386261,
-0.297468364238739,
0.1682964712381363,
0.330686092376709,
0.4644838273525238,
-0.1409658044576645,
0.13324791193008423,
0.37060895562171936,
-0.08448299765586853,
0.39680227637290955,
0.6074768304824829,
0.8788953423500061,
-0.11589587479829788,
0.3912396728992462,
0.12353088706731796,
-0.03506482020020485,
-0.3738003671169281,
-0.6340950727462769,
-0.7549804449081421,
-0.7581743597984314,
-0.015576858073472977,
0.3476153314113617,
-0.11503437161445618,
0.7773295044898987,
0.7387106418609619,
-0.7369948029518127,
-0.13056957721710205,
0.1336916834115982,
0.036943480372428894,
-0.13839192688465118,
-0.14489419758319855,
-0.045918505638837814,
-0.2829552888870239,
-0.5544087886810303,
0.43462830781936646,
0.39555180072784424,
0.376784086227417,
-0.40056028962135315,
-0.13116079568862915,
-0.4111953377723694,
0.1469685584306717,
0.6784257888793945,
0.33564966917037964,
-0.6721416115760803,
-0.42496201395988464,
-0.24367402493953705,
-0.05474388226866722,
0.17226943373680115,
0.7808719277381897,
-0.7787885665893555,
0.5833583474159241,
0.17281624674797058,
0.9708983302116394,
-0.125898078083992,
0.012671884149312973,
0.3698332905769348,
-0.5740255117416382,
0.4680737257003784,
0.3401802182197571,
0.47062012553215027,
0.338407039642334,
0.14714814722537994,
0.5356374382972717,
0.5467478036880493,
-0.39740005135536194,
-0.759533166885376,
0.37538641691207886,
-0.8665363788604736,
-0.45922791957855225,
0.735381543636322,
0.09554937481880188,
-0.04902428761124611,
0.010713662952184677,
-0.1004536896944046,
-0.07712548971176147,
0.020190125331282616,
0.8117178082466125,
0.7445242404937744,
-0.1327051967382431,
-0.28982627391815186,
-0.6539498567581177,
0.24501504004001617,
0.1965208351612091,
-0.7678441405296326,
-0.35423463582992554,
0.7326970100402832,
0.008398013189435005,
0.4744197726249695,
0.5744805335998535,
-0.06344447284936905,
0.4342621862888336,
0.04404723644256592,
0.1155693307518959,
-0.32762598991394043,
-0.8632287979125977,
-0.5347233414649963,
0.4434095025062561,
-0.1984572559595108,
-0.3623870611190796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05494v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05494v1
|
Investigating and Addressing Hallucinations of LLMs in Tasks Involving Negation
| 2024-06-08T15:20:56 | 2024-06-08T15:20:56 |
Neeraj Varshney, Satyam Raj, Venkatesh Mishra, Agneet Chatterjee, Ritika Sarkar, Amir Saeidi, Chitta Baral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance across a
wide variety of natural language tasks. However, they have been shown to suffer
from a critical limitation pertinent to 'hallucination' in their output. Recent
research has focused on investigating and addressing this problem for a variety
of tasks such as biography generation, question answering, abstractive
summarization, and dialogue generation. However, the crucial aspect pertaining
to 'negation' has remained considerably underexplored. Negation is important
because it adds depth and nuance to the understanding of language and is also
crucial for logical reasoning and inference. In this work, we address the above
limitation and particularly focus on studying the impact of negation in LLM
hallucinations. Specifically, we study four tasks with negation: 'false premise
completion', 'constrained fact generation', 'multiple choice question
answering', and 'fact generation'. We show that open-source state-of-the-art
LLMs such as LLaMA-2-chat, Vicuna, and Orca-2 hallucinate considerably on all
these tasks involving negation which underlines a critical shortcoming of these
models. Addressing this problem, we further study numerous strategies to
mitigate these hallucinations and demonstrate their impact.
|
[
-0.6256094574928284,
-1.1916699409484863,
0.8112581968307495,
0.1430840939283371,
-0.21013577282428741,
-0.2701307237148285,
-0.21256811916828156,
-0.598475456237793,
0.49137553572654724,
0.9912503957748413,
-0.6490610837936401,
-0.5588244199752808,
-0.6528499722480774,
0.37209147214889526,
-0.5246734023094177,
0.9612880349159241,
0.14747749269008636,
-0.03308869153261185,
-0.4586351811885834,
0.10346121340990067,
-0.81060791015625,
-0.8814185857772827,
-0.37459030747413635,
-0.4431379735469818,
0.4707699120044708,
0.4138526916503906,
0.7417117357254028,
0.21790385246276855,
0.48243752121925354,
0.22176067531108856,
-0.11063853651285172,
0.4168130159378052,
-0.732061505317688,
0.5576584339141846,
0.012632094323635101,
-0.5046771764755249,
-0.430629700422287,
-0.14838266372680664,
0.37971746921539307,
0.8803631067276001,
0.06455864757299423,
-0.005824293475598097,
0.1186986193060875,
0.6209520697593689,
-0.5721820592880249,
0.08829160779714584,
-0.8530420660972595,
0.21651144325733185,
-0.03362511843442917,
-0.3169940710067749,
-0.35900360345840454,
-0.49970394372940063,
0.04352398216724396,
-0.39624646306037903,
0.08284545689821243,
-0.0023480704985558987,
0.8105852007865906,
0.6558650732040405,
-0.48097559809684753,
-0.6270416975021362,
-0.7163277268409729,
0.661457359790802,
-0.8339080214500427,
0.285707026720047,
0.5955927968025208,
0.13319194316864014,
-0.4306938648223877,
-0.29130324721336365,
-0.7162216901779175,
-0.5068627595901489,
-0.1974332183599472,
-0.23256349563598633,
-0.09090244024991989,
0.23911091685295105,
0.44722041487693787,
0.2023460566997528,
-0.4598695635795593,
0.24504108726978302,
-0.38406655192375183,
-0.4371602535247803,
0.40829354524612427,
0.3522413671016693,
0.243892639875412,
-0.6048957705497742,
0.024414245039224625,
0.30350586771965027,
-0.9533132910728455,
-0.6348594427108765,
0.6135729551315308,
0.1512455940246582,
0.2723146080970764,
0.8561330437660217,
-0.1531153917312622,
0.6302960515022278,
-0.13825152814388275,
-0.16097693145275116,
0.1824294626712799,
-0.2518123686313629,
-0.2162262201309204,
0.16164733469486237,
0.48196494579315186,
0.37689241766929626,
0.29266104102134705,
-0.3638138175010681,
-0.1671433448791504,
0.2835366725921631,
0.38111063838005066,
-0.6355271339416504,
0.0037305839359760284,
0.25734221935272217,
-0.3313709795475006,
-0.1869213879108429,
-0.32473355531692505,
-0.717207133769989,
-0.7408689260482788,
-0.4317217469215393,
0.656268298625946,
-0.33838483691215515,
-0.2179679125547409,
0.1591798961162567,
0.024660689756274223,
0.4088023006916046,
0.46369725465774536,
-0.7360886335372925,
0.5093903541564941,
0.7014676928520203,
0.6854499578475952,
-0.11033120006322861,
-0.23760555684566498,
-0.5886244773864746,
-0.024757854640483856,
-0.5334451794624329,
0.5929480791091919,
-0.46654820442199707,
-0.3053871989250183,
-0.15524987876415253,
-0.05820387601852417,
0.048614319413900375,
-0.7894065380096436,
0.4048420190811157,
-0.21243807673454285,
0.21442247927188873,
-0.31949782371520996,
-0.4436856508255005,
-0.6470478773117065,
0.38001248240470886,
-0.5717813372612,
0.6746441125869751,
-0.28457045555114746,
-0.5803297162055969,
-0.09164021164178848,
-0.2394442856311798,
-0.6400682926177979,
-0.19444243609905243,
-0.5293632745742798,
-0.14574477076530457,
0.48322004079818726,
-0.055167388170957565,
0.5904219150543213,
-0.45326077938079834,
0.5441220998764038,
0.0061154658906161785,
-0.5471246838569641,
0.26537635922431946,
-0.18450787663459778,
0.562691867351532,
-0.12917014956474304,
-0.6646187901496887,
0.16051986813545227,
-0.54709392786026,
-0.522386372089386,
0.02832551673054695,
0.18144303560256958,
-0.32983940839767456,
-0.006740893702954054,
-0.3478025496006012,
0.035521335899829865,
0.0965481624007225,
-0.34647223353385925,
0.011147543787956238,
-0.4744635820388794,
0.39999502897262573,
0.6216357350349426,
0.15575748682022095,
0.1820567399263382,
-0.2965352237224579,
0.4483865797519684,
-0.05309097841382027,
-0.017867213115096092,
-0.022152196615934372,
-0.5951879024505615,
-1.108537197113037,
0.10193318873643875,
-0.06057072430849075,
0.4065004289150238,
-0.7119083404541016,
0.21266286075115204,
0.025243893265724182,
-0.37692299485206604,
-0.30249717831611633,
0.07345545291900635,
0.2662203907966614,
0.7183905839920044,
0.4433985650539398,
-0.11202562600374222,
-0.6822627186775208,
-1.0097274780273438,
0.025829441845417023,
-0.17191782593727112,
0.2576514780521393,
0.2719835340976715,
0.7545857429504395,
-0.3445367217063904,
0.5961620211601257,
-0.4918515384197235,
-0.5308740735054016,
-0.22155827283859253,
0.14601679146289825,
0.25261980295181274,
0.259537011384964,
0.25371652841567993,
-0.6347233653068542,
0.05954454839229584,
-0.338746577501297,
-1.0262247323989868,
-0.21235471963882446,
-0.3616623878479004,
0.12119312584400177,
0.6438273191452026,
0.7933464050292969,
-0.8729504346847534,
0.6465466618537903,
0.4760172665119171,
-0.15243878960609436,
0.767101526260376,
-0.05034615099430084,
-0.01831728219985962,
-0.6305863261222839,
-0.1980307698249817,
-0.3563089966773987,
0.003791915252804756,
-0.782981812953949,
-0.004908266942948103,
-0.3258243501186371,
0.11100778728723526,
-0.4028576910495758,
0.30305200815200806,
-0.4983980059623718,
-0.11038035899400711,
-0.4876737594604492,
0.33359554409980774,
-0.1370963752269745,
0.34285786747932434,
0.14406350255012512,
0.35100191831588745,
0.68800950050354,
-0.864852786064148,
0.22678060829639435,
0.1923239380121231,
-0.19330738484859467,
0.021097134798765182,
-0.4584208130836487,
0.2487017810344696,
-0.4509360194206238,
0.04808010905981064,
-0.9892309308052063,
-0.1574334055185318,
0.5556793212890625,
-0.5185248255729675,
0.06674733757972717,
0.17801575362682343,
-0.6911670565605164,
-0.07363448292016983,
-0.26141777634620667,
0.2665310502052307,
0.5288673043251038,
-0.3612941801548004,
0.5941311120986938,
0.3461509943008423,
0.027715465053915977,
-0.5134046673774719,
-0.782793402671814,
0.3931361734867096,
-0.41253408789634705,
-0.3892618417739868,
0.2516522705554962,
0.0036517831031233072,
-0.6626736521720886,
-0.022438131272792816,
-0.2326798439025879,
0.3105519115924835,
0.14375698566436768,
0.5866467952728271,
0.3063710331916809,
-0.10062292218208313,
0.18744613230228424,
0.034078340977430344,
-0.13128043711185455,
0.4264627695083618,
0.12213118374347687,
0.7834156155586243,
-0.02076319232583046,
-0.4871918559074402,
-0.2653966248035431,
0.21624556183815002,
0.5275947451591492,
0.03699260950088501,
0.8846943378448486,
0.3254930078983307,
-0.7205536961555481,
-0.2703149914741516,
-1.0033113956451416,
-0.6411675810813904,
-0.3671698570251465,
0.3365769386291504,
-0.283430278301239,
-0.9806653261184692,
0.5495923161506653,
0.24449218809604645,
-0.0892176702618599,
0.3460494577884674,
0.5179759860038757,
0.16659623384475708,
0.7686726450920105,
0.4214631915092468,
0.18359728157520294,
-0.10041452199220657,
-0.14097915589809418,
0.44352012872695923,
-0.8144213557243347,
-0.37164461612701416,
-0.4567185640335083,
-0.101889967918396,
-0.5734968185424805,
-0.5322891473770142,
0.2776816189289093,
-0.0025555440224707127,
0.07970181852579117,
0.2358623743057251,
-0.3514624536037445,
0.4227326512336731,
0.265927255153656,
-0.03761470317840576,
0.4395388662815094,
-0.08990680426359177,
0.09341259300708771,
-0.26670771837234497,
-0.39920610189437866,
-0.8169181942939758,
1.1277046203613281,
0.21970239281654358,
0.644729733467102,
0.24417860805988312,
0.846778154373169,
0.10942855477333069,
-0.015010692179203033,
-0.8269146680831909,
1.0239635705947876,
0.08064501732587814,
-0.5837072134017944,
-0.4565471112728119,
-0.3616284728050232,
-0.7584971785545349,
0.5496390461921692,
-0.28320395946502686,
-0.8527792692184448,
0.10694897919893265,
-0.0030854051001369953,
-0.3440742492675781,
0.2446005940437317,
-0.41361862421035767,
0.5732075572013855,
-0.1906837671995163,
-0.5113711357116699,
-0.3727918565273285,
-0.5324657559394836,
0.8588151335716248,
-0.1158289909362793,
0.12332537770271301,
-0.1385992467403412,
-0.04872612655162811,
0.6892735362052917,
-0.12438738346099854,
1.150032639503479,
0.07725252211093903,
-0.349438339471817,
0.37182557582855225,
0.3708482086658478,
0.4561564326286316,
0.11698877811431885,
-0.20458726584911346,
0.2875376343727112,
-0.22445254027843475,
-0.05166434869170189,
-0.5141623616218567,
0.7712944149971008,
-0.487989604473114,
-1.129325270652771,
-0.540496289730072,
-0.5891401767730713,
-0.17817141115665436,
0.07211613655090332,
0.23717957735061646,
0.2953363358974457,
-0.1390230655670166,
0.0450468510389328,
0.8554204106330872,
-0.6054186224937439,
0.29306715726852417,
0.26854458451271057,
-0.602801501750946,
-0.11868032068014145,
0.9739803075790405,
0.4657769799232483,
0.37017086148262024,
0.11671053618192673,
0.05727323144674301,
-0.28865402936935425,
-0.8844101428985596,
-0.10877861827611923,
0.6235833764076233,
-0.9004153609275818,
-0.009221336804330349,
-0.9099507331848145,
-0.38541147112846375,
-0.6873701810836792,
0.08282022178173065,
0.012753887102007866,
-0.47524505853652954,
-0.639743447303772,
-0.3189520835876465,
0.2139958292245865,
0.9306825399398804,
-0.06967069953680038,
0.024344034492969513,
-0.2902735769748688,
0.7568634152412415,
0.2067445069551468,
-0.11679256707429886,
0.3555462062358856,
-0.40837034583091736,
0.1300794929265976,
-0.2057970017194748,
-0.3241877555847168,
-1.194443941116333,
0.45245712995529175,
-0.2791897654533386,
0.5946479439735413,
0.4559810161590576,
0.29117026925086975,
0.75721675157547,
-0.33696356415748596,
0.741341769695282,
0.02627631463110447,
-0.9232051372528076,
0.41591542959213257,
-0.05505722761154175,
-0.02304758131504059,
0.4599049389362335,
0.3745436370372772,
-0.5280546545982361,
-0.7455298900604248,
-0.46387767791748047,
-0.8778591156005859,
0.3766729235649109,
0.3802621066570282,
0.26140791177749634,
-0.2622809410095215,
0.3312724530696869,
0.4573975205421448,
0.5252538323402405,
-0.8301975131034851,
-0.19080209732055664,
-0.09143611043691635,
0.45370006561279297,
-0.1787705421447754,
-0.5434108376502991,
0.10747630894184113,
-0.3197554647922516,
0.7826237082481384,
0.05999487638473511,
0.035204384475946426,
0.29186055064201355,
-0.45930948853492737,
0.07892335951328278,
0.18424251675605774,
0.7516361474990845,
0.5709085464477539,
-0.17463286221027374,
0.4100475609302521,
0.3433866798877716,
-0.10485954582691193,
-0.0974767804145813,
-0.19517837464809418,
-0.33340704441070557,
0.07792244851589203,
0.4330614507198334,
0.798576831817627,
-0.045815687626600266,
-0.7227570414543152,
0.20463459193706512,
0.23822687566280365,
-0.4327695667743683,
-0.49568983912467957,
0.07512659579515457,
0.150912806391716,
0.16758142411708832,
0.21727482974529266,
-0.2211286574602127,
0.33738982677459717,
-0.8491791486740112,
-0.0035901216324418783,
0.5774157047271729,
-0.37559542059898376,
-0.158189594745636,
0.47387856245040894,
-0.07380777597427368,
-0.28510820865631104,
0.824927806854248,
-0.31946030259132385,
-0.6016142964363098,
0.7073440551757812,
0.6422611474990845,
0.9075515866279602,
0.10031335055828094,
0.25985661149024963,
0.38618046045303345,
0.7897784113883972,
0.12484601885080338,
0.3245513439178467,
-0.011713486164808273,
-0.7221840023994446,
-0.4838278293609619,
-0.5588236451148987,
-0.45579034090042114,
0.5079489946365356,
-0.35767456889152527,
0.20000353455543518,
-0.38790878653526306,
-0.24063065648078918,
-0.3198113441467285,
-0.19215470552444458,
-0.3027620017528534,
-0.05048380792140961,
0.411812961101532,
0.5401407480239868,
-0.6967521905899048,
0.5129528045654297,
0.3158632218837738,
-0.4490218460559845,
-0.39773762226104736,
0.1735473871231079,
0.14239755272865295,
-0.5189201235771179,
0.7273262739181519,
0.46210989356040955,
-0.4487353563308716,
-0.10528422147035599,
-0.3922301232814789,
-0.6625667810440063,
0.7413958311080933,
0.3467424511909485,
-0.4321942925453186,
-0.1705864667892456,
0.47119593620300293,
0.6175029873847961,
-0.387156218290329,
0.09793344885110855,
0.6723106503486633,
0.7518600225448608,
-0.010621788911521435,
-0.7511661648750305,
0.4211978614330292,
0.019985854625701904,
-0.3227618932723999,
0.16209791600704193,
-0.4557987153530121,
0.9235538244247437,
-0.4915525019168854,
-0.1349293738603592,
0.03898732736706734,
0.5855914950370789,
0.2686433792114258,
0.23982763290405273,
0.4793945550918579,
0.3259538412094116,
0.8037919998168945,
0.004084574989974499,
0.6129809021949768,
0.03562942519783974,
-0.12412992864847183,
1.2487083673477173,
-0.5513492822647095,
0.5530254244804382,
0.9115400910377502,
0.4845121204853058,
0.24325813353061676,
0.4424622058868408,
0.006470934022217989,
0.13284136354923248,
0.6653631329536438,
-0.07642174512147903,
-0.3525499701499939,
-0.3912210166454315,
-0.4604332447052002,
0.3388350009918213,
0.5326188206672668,
-0.19034570455551147,
-0.19442379474639893,
0.17111247777938843,
0.09369027614593506,
0.14138533174991608,
-0.08300938457250595,
0.7953206300735474,
0.2035420835018158,
-0.7859954237937927,
0.7503841519355774,
-0.19022515416145325,
0.6273588538169861,
-0.368272066116333,
-0.32630544900894165,
-0.2949399948120117,
-0.18560796976089478,
-0.41118448972702026,
-0.42228636145591736,
0.6368668079376221,
-0.006275321822613478,
0.11097964644432068,
-0.1663864701986313,
0.7229313254356384,
-0.1982482522726059,
-0.3125028610229492,
0.580223560333252,
0.5698975920677185,
0.5381715297698975,
-0.28057926893234253,
-0.07622015476226807,
0.2133498191833496,
0.021111054345965385,
-0.19508561491966248,
0.19172251224517822,
0.3433379828929901,
-0.18683908879756927,
0.770393431186676,
0.44279882311820984,
0.21162641048431396,
0.23085881769657135,
0.14369097352027893,
0.7607430219650269,
-0.9018757939338684,
-0.10292629152536392,
-1.0555204153060913,
0.1413865089416504,
0.17083054780960083,
-0.09517963230609894,
0.9964397549629211,
0.6560349464416504,
0.6985084414482117,
0.0370572954416275,
0.6976160407066345,
0.05199592560529709,
0.1920519471168518,
-0.6187114715576172,
0.6758633852005005,
-0.6028010249137878,
0.4796575605869293,
-0.3681015968322754,
-1.0432026386260986,
-0.44250044226646423,
0.5610393285751343,
-0.5429466962814331,
-0.27565279603004456,
0.9588176608085632,
1.1122709512710571,
0.30313676595687866,
0.21861609816551208,
0.5908647179603577,
0.5937130451202393,
0.09631156921386719,
0.6153585314750671,
1.242416501045227,
-0.21674995124340057,
0.6041231751441956,
-0.37580233812332153,
0.05667249858379364,
-0.27127209305763245,
-0.9198736548423767,
-1.3173043727874756,
-0.5713646411895752,
-0.40017980337142944,
-0.4221704602241516,
0.08849263191223145,
0.5997560024261475,
0.29242947697639465,
-0.6118671298027039,
-0.4792852997779846,
-0.15619336068630219,
0.5335531234741211,
0.1263621747493744,
-0.20996278524398804,
0.22417739033699036,
-0.37978309392929077,
-0.5139067769050598,
0.30584916472435,
0.349867582321167,
0.1440810263156891,
-0.5781557559967041,
-0.11992237716913223,
-0.22464759647846222,
0.11098669469356537,
0.6775497198104858,
-0.04859457165002823,
-1.0626707077026367,
-0.18714362382888794,
0.07349513471126556,
-0.020267074927687645,
-0.048533350229263306,
0.6054262518882751,
-0.9781396985054016,
0.12529447674751282,
0.502669632434845,
0.5051318407058716,
0.5401670336723328,
-0.2996163070201874,
0.393957257270813,
-0.13167066872119904,
-0.010663379915058613,
0.39604824781417847,
0.1325378268957138,
0.38898178935050964,
-0.32589250802993774,
0.5181998014450073,
0.06011808663606644,
-0.27974364161491394,
-1.1280256509780884,
0.3465719521045685,
-0.601456880569458,
-0.5079527497291565,
1.149492621421814,
0.5395821928977966,
-0.15734893083572388,
-0.19144944846630096,
-0.37308526039123535,
0.35320132970809937,
-0.09444442391395569,
0.8481757044792175,
0.9619242548942566,
-0.35506993532180786,
-0.03511921688914299,
-0.924654483795166,
0.4140971004962921,
0.6270503997802734,
-0.8150483965873718,
0.18858423829078674,
0.7564951777458191,
-0.06738661229610443,
0.2925100326538086,
0.5464669466018677,
-0.03592647239565849,
0.01411750353872776,
-0.08464072644710541,
0.07676472514867783,
-0.06895124912261963,
-0.6239715814590454,
-0.30922645330429077,
0.31529170274734497,
0.0854845717549324,
-0.0038399973418563604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10248v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10248v2
|
On the Worst Prompt Performance of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-08T13:40:38 | 2024-06-21T08:55:37 |
Bowen Cao, Deng Cai, Zhisong Zhang, Yuexian Zou, Wai Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The performance of large language models (LLMs) is acutely sensitive to the
phrasing of prompts, which raises significant concerns about their reliability
in real-world scenarios. Existing studies often divide prompts into task-level
instructions and case-level inputs and primarily focus on evaluating and
improving robustness against variations in tasks-level instructions. However,
this setup fails to fully address the diversity of real-world user queries and
assumes the existence of task-specific datasets. To address these limitations,
we introduce RobustAlpacaEval, a new benchmark that consists of semantically
equivalent case-level queries and emphasizes the importance of using the worst
prompt performance to gauge the lower bound of model performance. Extensive
experiments on RobustAlpacaEval with ChatGPT and six open-source LLMs from the
Llama, Mistral, and Gemma families uncover substantial variability in model
performance; for instance, a difference of 45.48% between the worst and best
performance for the Llama-2-70B-chat model, with its worst performance dipping
as low as 9.38%. We further illustrate the difficulty in identifying the worst
prompt from both model-agnostic and model-dependent perspectives, emphasizing
the absence of a shortcut to characterize the worst prompt. We also attempt to
enhance the worst prompt performance using existing prompt engineering and
prompt consistency methods, but find that their impact is limited. These
findings underscore the need to create more resilient LLMs that can maintain
high performance across diverse prompts. Data and code are available at
https://github.com/cbwbuaa/On-the-Worst-Prompt- Performance-of-LLMs.
|
[
-0.349823921918869,
-0.9767023324966431,
0.6663530468940735,
0.21999794244766235,
-0.2125101536512375,
0.04069063067436218,
-0.3226042687892914,
-0.34298408031463623,
-0.2929985821247101,
0.1684933304786682,
-0.8081645369529724,
-0.4953238368034363,
-0.6100451350212097,
0.2891591191291809,
-0.26185575127601624,
0.6020987033843994,
0.30788126587867737,
-0.06580600142478943,
-0.2534823715686798,
-0.379389226436615,
-0.824785053730011,
-0.617936372756958,
-0.6579477787017822,
-0.08975162357091904,
0.6036542654037476,
0.34938448667526245,
0.9221448302268982,
0.4806590676307678,
0.28479450941085815,
0.28344905376434326,
-0.3925428092479706,
0.08151132613420486,
-0.6952376365661621,
0.4972628653049469,
-0.06352270394563675,
-0.4839121401309967,
-0.18843376636505127,
-0.23117762804031372,
0.3922800123691559,
0.7160059809684753,
-0.15217702090740204,
0.018915677443146706,
0.2061924785375595,
0.047754786908626556,
-0.5361069440841675,
0.18095596134662628,
-0.693536102771759,
-0.28989264369010925,
-0.43955495953559875,
-0.11092408746480942,
-0.5000086426734924,
-0.4730113744735718,
0.06024833023548126,
-0.3881046772003174,
0.02813323587179184,
0.2920559346675873,
0.9327868819236755,
0.39332035183906555,
-0.26551806926727295,
-0.2723015248775482,
-0.30423229932785034,
0.8985677361488342,
-0.7864075303077698,
0.1763547658920288,
0.383199542760849,
0.501156747341156,
-0.49387481808662415,
-0.4505024552345276,
-0.4526342451572418,
-0.4514157176017761,
0.26094967126846313,
-0.2189658284187317,
-0.5898467302322388,
0.06847131997346878,
0.3372824788093567,
0.07983945310115814,
-0.7634302973747253,
0.6180897355079651,
0.06959753483533859,
-0.4330718517303467,
0.26794785261154175,
0.6259419918060303,
0.3611677587032318,
-0.09721367061138153,
-0.12352744489908218,
-0.27659517526626587,
-0.9422884583473206,
0.4045254588127136,
0.3345421254634857,
0.6579357981681824,
-0.07964051514863968,
0.5154159665107727,
-0.06466152518987656,
0.7131618857383728,
-0.030412042513489723,
-0.4782046973705292,
0.05636253580451012,
-0.05212726071476936,
0.013345787301659584,
-0.2211119681596756,
0.8379452228546143,
0.43085816502571106,
0.13201798498630524,
-0.08869019895792007,
-0.4330923855304718,
0.21978799998760223,
0.041343629360198975,
-0.824108898639679,
-0.19121472537517548,
0.04915516451001167,
-0.3873446583747864,
-0.17196986079216003,
-0.5068926215171814,
-0.6963409781455994,
-0.8100506067276001,
0.11300744116306305,
0.21648520231246948,
-0.4070327579975128,
0.1584315448999405,
-0.1787455826997757,
0.28716564178466797,
0.1152365654706955,
0.36128103733062744,
-0.5989165902137756,
0.12557685375213623,
0.7104550004005432,
0.824373722076416,
-0.3061336278915405,
-0.46184346079826355,
-0.9088886380195618,
-0.385563462972641,
-0.3963361978530884,
0.9221231341362,
-0.6879996657371521,
-0.6166678071022034,
0.06830590218305588,
0.11938107013702393,
-0.04801448807120323,
-0.7002891898155212,
1.0110095739364624,
-0.289928138256073,
0.16222789883613586,
-0.677330493927002,
-0.4753645360469818,
0.13295800983905792,
0.13118556141853333,
-0.4474177360534668,
0.9007071852684021,
0.0688486248254776,
-0.5984736084938049,
0.24351973831653595,
-0.11782562732696533,
-0.31530559062957764,
-0.13218949735164642,
-0.029920704662799835,
-0.28789079189300537,
0.09244918823242188,
0.24901527166366577,
0.38556838035583496,
-0.7237932085990906,
0.43687060475349426,
-0.6062551736831665,
-0.506902813911438,
0.354263573884964,
-0.813439667224884,
0.8396891951560974,
0.2346208244562149,
-0.17207010090351105,
0.02739046886563301,
-0.825131893157959,
-0.2819267511367798,
0.28391122817993164,
-0.19765129685401917,
-0.2502221167087555,
-0.13119913637638092,
-0.2132050096988678,
0.0820036306977272,
0.11547145992517471,
-0.40823933482170105,
0.23519767820835114,
-0.3082358241081238,
0.49090084433555603,
0.8544092774391174,
-0.035764358937740326,
0.2917354106903076,
-0.4765089154243469,
0.7556983828544617,
-0.1523505598306656,
0.2147853970527649,
-0.5191060304641724,
-0.7145193815231323,
-0.468142032623291,
-0.2986922264099121,
-0.04355157911777496,
0.5885390639305115,
-0.5320236682891846,
0.06949234753847122,
-0.03532884642481804,
-0.6157419085502625,
-0.29854536056518555,
-0.007668290752917528,
0.48666033148765564,
0.8835457563400269,
0.2381560504436493,
-0.14371246099472046,
-0.26764431595802307,
-0.9596303701400757,
-0.35515499114990234,
-0.6106961965560913,
-0.006543492898344994,
0.28134068846702576,
0.04945530369877815,
-0.16933657228946686,
0.6365224123001099,
-0.3534996509552002,
0.19683654606342316,
-0.1988520324230194,
0.04937019944190979,
0.46438416838645935,
0.1693851798772812,
0.6352367401123047,
-0.167097806930542,
0.008369800634682178,
-0.6455374956130981,
-0.35629862546920776,
-0.7100433707237244,
-0.04511445388197899,
-0.028105169534683228,
0.25969424843788147,
0.20206330716609955,
-0.9123044610023499,
0.20135369896888733,
0.6370271444320679,
-0.5271073579788208,
0.763005256652832,
0.11885576695203781,
0.06642629206180573,
-0.8861947655677795,
0.0272373054176569,
-0.036485400050878525,
-0.12222065031528473,
-0.5194731950759888,
0.013315904885530472,
0.04746364802122116,
-0.1965707540512085,
-0.4082430303096771,
0.6401981115341187,
-0.25874045491218567,
0.05029357969760895,
-0.18052896857261658,
0.10208187997341156,
0.09109048545360565,
0.3674696683883667,
-0.4572365880012512,
1.200499415397644,
0.5994240045547485,
-0.5738887190818787,
0.3190716803073883,
0.3270578980445862,
-0.40876102447509766,
0.6448876261711121,
-0.8113461136817932,
0.0428706556558609,
-0.006052416283637285,
0.2277037650346756,
-1.2356857061386108,
-0.17892923951148987,
0.2470235973596573,
-0.3482404947280884,
0.2423458695411682,
-0.24633678793907166,
-0.5732795000076294,
-0.31305643916130066,
-0.26750844717025757,
0.4335044026374817,
0.6045771241188049,
-0.6341249346733093,
0.36329180002212524,
0.2748939096927643,
-0.3587980270385742,
-0.6160159707069397,
-0.6635899543762207,
0.3231450319290161,
-0.4981887936592102,
-0.7703902721405029,
0.10147843509912491,
-0.19244082272052765,
-0.3995654881000519,
-0.39035332202911377,
-0.1469116508960724,
-0.03440350666642189,
0.3535306751728058,
0.3752119541168213,
0.29892587661743164,
-0.28864577412605286,
0.11407368630170822,
-0.043901000171899796,
-0.10740891098976135,
0.18650445342063904,
0.15206067264080048,
0.6324362754821777,
-0.1759958118200302,
-0.5043835639953613,
-0.43397125601768494,
0.3195423483848572,
0.6737399101257324,
-0.0671771690249443,
0.8227459788322449,
0.20080064237117767,
-0.2742038369178772,
-0.21272477507591248,
-0.606019914150238,
-0.12509773671627045,
-0.49303218722343445,
0.11474582552909851,
-0.41898268461227417,
-0.957004725933075,
0.9233148694038391,
-0.004192732274532318,
0.23592230677604675,
0.22115372121334076,
0.5182793736457825,
0.14454765617847443,
0.9878009557723999,
0.46762943267822266,
-0.17964047193527222,
0.34807145595550537,
0.2615540325641632,
0.25024643540382385,
-0.38380947709083557,
-0.19690321385860443,
-0.8680084347724915,
0.14535023272037506,
-0.3875340223312378,
-0.3634068965911865,
0.37617459893226624,
0.1707041710615158,
-0.4456643760204315,
0.2855835258960724,
-0.16035138070583344,
0.25324490666389465,
0.4200730323791504,
-0.1899450570344925,
0.3065231740474701,
-0.2446957677602768,
-0.35769006609916687,
-0.11255152523517609,
-0.8294124603271484,
-0.7907213568687439,
0.6859726905822754,
0.3975951671600342,
0.8580791354179382,
0.2430247962474823,
0.3665207028388977,
0.2260926067829132,
0.06598247587680817,
-0.711642861366272,
0.6205108761787415,
0.15368875861167908,
-0.19480866193771362,
-0.12203097343444824,
-0.4960465729236603,
-0.9705329537391663,
0.20387516915798187,
-0.034556977450847626,
-0.9074370265007019,
0.23442062735557556,
0.1610720157623291,
-0.5642527341842651,
0.1827230155467987,
-0.7035157084465027,
0.8910235166549683,
-0.03857308626174927,
-0.43984997272491455,
0.27756038308143616,
-0.5046176910400391,
0.464250773191452,
-0.034997906535863876,
0.20240549743175507,
-0.34712058305740356,
-0.21186871826648712,
0.337332159280777,
-0.7101105451583862,
0.9640780687332153,
-0.14396736025810242,
-0.3246517479419708,
0.3602224886417389,
0.4714479446411133,
0.8506695628166199,
0.1337914913892746,
-0.18565060198307037,
0.15372301638126373,
0.046863965690135956,
-0.48367446660995483,
-0.3999585807323456,
0.8201870918273926,
-0.7180473208427429,
-0.6701213717460632,
-0.2883879542350769,
-0.43535536527633667,
-0.620930552482605,
-0.06808251142501831,
0.4573177993297577,
0.8037120699882507,
-0.14239531755447388,
-0.13321979343891144,
0.6459653377532959,
-0.5859206914901733,
0.6485017538070679,
0.41723084449768066,
-0.04116947576403618,
-0.01035396009683609,
0.6983447074890137,
0.0433807335793972,
0.12538157403469086,
0.16518907248973846,
0.19326357543468475,
-0.42292535305023193,
-0.6603783369064331,
-0.6043910384178162,
0.06946469843387604,
-0.9173053503036499,
-0.47199177742004395,
-0.618053138256073,
0.14162154495716095,
-0.13690036535263062,
-0.06174791604280472,
-0.4389726519584656,
-0.31044551730155945,
-0.44808611273765564,
-0.05217868462204933,
0.30553239583969116,
0.43010714650154114,
0.16990385949611664,
0.3656686842441559,
-0.8246669173240662,
-0.0010234253713861108,
0.14224444329738617,
0.18099716305732727,
0.13534578680992126,
-0.6936453580856323,
0.29915493726730347,
-0.20539939403533936,
-0.1336473822593689,
-0.8662332892417908,
0.3373121917247772,
0.06432174891233444,
0.6789736747741699,
0.44134432077407837,
0.4883197247982025,
0.6001467704772949,
-0.3032844662666321,
1.146651029586792,
0.0861457884311676,
-0.8511150479316711,
0.3692820370197296,
-0.5185649991035461,
0.5355984568595886,
0.6884059309959412,
0.1627279371023178,
-0.4640650749206543,
-0.5495406985282898,
-0.3656597435474396,
-1.0014958381652832,
0.5876624584197998,
0.062119144946336746,
0.20245769619941711,
-0.24443866312503815,
0.21274740993976593,
0.43055543303489685,
0.07098226994276047,
-0.39810577034950256,
-0.25710293650627136,
0.019174812361598015,
-0.0767926275730133,
-0.11345989257097244,
-0.4542858600616455,
0.05163414776325226,
0.23217758536338806,
0.5067339539527893,
-0.1957678198814392,
0.07489698380231857,
-0.03278905898332596,
-0.0753963515162468,
-0.06442414969205856,
0.3355741500854492,
0.5938549637794495,
0.8532668352127075,
0.013833112083375454,
0.14055046439170837,
0.4523746073246002,
-0.1509294956922531,
0.017902251332998276,
0.10233638435602188,
-0.1153266429901123,
-0.05259496346116066,
0.7382669448852539,
0.7565447688102722,
0.2751551866531372,
-1.1816825866699219,
0.6991285681724548,
-0.45922690629959106,
0.25924578309059143,
-0.1509011834859848,
0.14592523872852325,
-0.09292443841695786,
0.3104619085788727,
0.4231317937374115,
0.0995432585477829,
0.06078602001070976,
-0.5539056062698364,
-0.0009190418641082942,
0.2912129759788513,
-0.28716984391212463,
-0.3335827589035034,
0.6626764535903931,
0.14767517149448395,
-0.31770238280296326,
0.5472671389579773,
-0.27795302867889404,
-0.3259153962135315,
0.5507251620292664,
0.40134525299072266,
0.6663066744804382,
-0.2547380328178406,
0.12209654599428177,
0.31388571858406067,
0.3222261965274811,
-0.0944356694817543,
0.22621701657772064,
0.09324196726083755,
-0.3187277913093567,
-0.4251466393470764,
-0.5388412475585938,
-0.527237594127655,
0.2781067490577698,
-0.41550084948539734,
0.22179852426052094,
-0.4326939582824707,
-0.3130268156528473,
-0.42230263352394104,
-0.16728365421295166,
-0.5648316740989685,
-0.1758536845445633,
0.04142923280596733,
1.001267910003662,
-0.7433364391326904,
0.3572283685207367,
0.6424717903137207,
-0.10948055982589722,
-0.9403321146965027,
-0.0018638249021023512,
0.4074964225292206,
-0.770313560962677,
0.09604839980602264,
0.0942721962928772,
-0.10007573664188385,
-0.48803290724754333,
-0.4862750768661499,
-0.7182339429855347,
0.9095247387886047,
0.6603226661682129,
-0.8271254897117615,
0.10853908956050873,
0.023136373609304428,
0.6015287041664124,
-0.23334656655788422,
0.5616509318351746,
0.4501708447933197,
0.2955579459667206,
0.12294924259185791,
-1.0387619733810425,
0.30278462171554565,
-0.14621305465698242,
0.08368365466594696,
-0.10071755945682526,
-0.8268621563911438,
0.868613064289093,
-0.23659276962280273,
-0.4168696999549866,
0.6398748159408569,
0.38194361329078674,
0.5774348974227905,
0.47615671157836914,
0.4377369284629822,
0.4965260922908783,
1.0836941003799438,
-0.3337116837501526,
1.2724131345748901,
-0.3060168921947479,
0.009633977897465229,
1.0295614004135132,
-0.2294938862323761,
0.6323150992393494,
0.26905015110969543,
-0.0467170886695385,
0.04867836460471153,
0.8796075582504272,
0.21299730241298676,
0.43847742676734924,
0.21741151809692383,
-0.22524648904800415,
-0.447677344083786,
-0.30390214920043945,
-0.3087327480316162,
0.3779478669166565,
0.18301108479499817,
-0.12388446182012558,
-0.33694860339164734,
0.020681947469711304,
0.2572355270385742,
0.07037815451622009,
-0.14992325007915497,
0.6117205023765564,
0.17203792929649353,
-0.6928247809410095,
0.9538394808769226,
-0.01607823744416237,
0.6634162664413452,
-0.49490228295326233,
0.09129764884710312,
-0.6292114853858948,
-0.04740634933114052,
0.13802701234817505,
-0.5863980650901794,
0.07448673248291016,
0.29540684819221497,
0.03854374960064888,
0.03677757456898689,
0.5884912610054016,
0.0794927328824997,
-0.14913305640220642,
0.25931116938591003,
0.7025629281997681,
0.13963529467582703,
0.0061818817630410194,
-0.6466926336288452,
0.5614396333694458,
-0.26048046350479126,
-0.3499435484409332,
0.43707504868507385,
0.683079719543457,
-0.19058291614055634,
1.1153275966644287,
0.5450338125228882,
-0.03747361898422241,
0.16187560558319092,
0.32973694801330566,
1.1027785539627075,
-0.49249643087387085,
-0.27828559279441833,
-0.8525571823120117,
0.2587275207042694,
0.14224325120449066,
-0.721550464630127,
0.6895607709884644,
0.35599711537361145,
0.5008381009101868,
0.34852007031440735,
0.6036965250968933,
0.14704276621341705,
0.4448733925819397,
-0.38874199986457825,
0.48818010091781616,
-0.39077112078666687,
0.7601330280303955,
-0.374070942401886,
-1.1157512664794922,
-0.20975303649902344,
0.2588638663291931,
-0.1468280404806137,
0.002279463689774275,
0.5105316042900085,
1.064754843711853,
0.08101780712604523,
0.08716035634279251,
0.4858291447162628,
0.47580158710479736,
0.4545479714870453,
0.6266385912895203,
1.3036364316940308,
-0.05269404873251915,
0.8065249919891357,
-0.18653790652751923,
-0.1599583923816681,
-0.27934902906417847,
-0.8243481516838074,
-1.0461620092391968,
-0.6169527173042297,
-0.05615873634815216,
-0.4979023337364197,
0.37067654728889465,
0.9234638810157776,
0.42682403326034546,
-0.7767146825790405,
0.03782806918025017,
0.02361144684255123,
0.08511175960302353,
0.06317927688360214,
-0.20836161077022552,
0.32347074151039124,
-0.41901105642318726,
-0.5966593027114868,
0.6585392951965332,
0.10738813877105713,
-0.061903100460767746,
-0.1698339283466339,
-0.0761697068810463,
0.3004123568534851,
0.14963674545288086,
0.5203893184661865,
0.4024278223514557,
-0.7950361967086792,
-0.4127277731895447,
0.057296376675367355,
-0.2386728972196579,
-0.05987682193517685,
0.6387702822685242,
-0.6989122033119202,
0.12290046364068985,
0.43762826919555664,
0.7594227194786072,
-0.1407039761543274,
0.07504846155643463,
0.5128481388092041,
-0.5358440279960632,
-0.09583254903554916,
0.3996359407901764,
0.6198672652244568,
0.5477350950241089,
-0.20842374861240387,
0.19655349850654602,
0.09450044482946396,
-0.6719845533370972,
-1.0223746299743652,
0.23620161414146423,
-1.0641676187515259,
-0.2395170032978058,
1.3072394132614136,
-0.41604283452033997,
-0.34149637818336487,
-0.23834912478923798,
-0.36024585366249084,
-0.016341447830200195,
-0.8712062239646912,
0.7913772463798523,
0.7023187875747681,
-0.14701804518699646,
-0.3357269763946533,
-0.48715969920158386,
0.2992061376571655,
0.6009480357170105,
-0.35614731907844543,
0.32913938164711,
0.8176511526107788,
0.2405453473329544,
-0.0869068056344986,
0.3898720145225525,
0.002462615491822362,
0.11078060418367386,
0.10890738666057587,
-0.43238621950149536,
-0.18056678771972656,
-0.255647748708725,
-0.5689401626586914,
0.43435269594192505,
0.48098036646842957,
0.22897128760814667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05460v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05460v2
|
Fighting Against the Repetitive Training and Sample Dependency Problem in Few-shot Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-06-08T12:36:30 | 2024-06-18T23:45:14 |
Chang Tian, Wenpeng Yin, Dan Li, Marie-Francine Moens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Few-shot named entity recognition (NER) systems recognize entities using a
few labeled training examples. The general pipeline consists of a span detector
to identify entity spans in text and an entity-type classifier to assign types
to entities. Current span detectors rely on extensive manual labeling to guide
training. Almost every span detector requires initial training on basic span
features followed by adaptation to task-specific features. This process leads
to repetitive training of the basic span features among span detectors.
Additionally, metric-based entity-type classifiers, such as prototypical
networks, typically employ a specific metric that gauges the distance between
the query sample and entity-type referents, ultimately assigning the most
probable entity type to the query sample. However, these classifiers encounter
the sample dependency problem, primarily stemming from the limited samples
available for each entity-type referent. To address these challenges, we
proposed an improved few-shot NER pipeline. First, we introduce a steppingstone
span detector that is pre-trained on open-domain Wikipedia data. It can be used
to initialize the pipeline span detector to reduce the repetitive training of
basic features. Second, we leverage a large language model (LLM) to set
reliable entity-type referents, eliminating reliance on few-shot samples of
each type. Our model exhibits superior performance with fewer training steps
and human-labeled data compared with baselines, as demonstrated through
extensive experiments on various datasets. Particularly in fine-grained
few-shot NER settings, our model outperforms strong baselines, including
ChatGPT. We will publicly release the code, datasets, LLM outputs, and model
checkpoints.
|
[
-0.6105347275733948,
-0.1589803248643875,
0.32619041204452515,
-0.08484034240245819,
-0.11636454612016678,
-0.138639435172081,
0.006825377233326435,
-0.691598117351532,
0.2725796103477478,
0.5642957091331482,
-0.3749816417694092,
-0.26991868019104004,
-0.8300740122795105,
0.3554609715938568,
-0.5476548075675964,
1.1450191736221313,
-0.08232905715703964,
0.10124774277210236,
0.2116471827030182,
-0.14382532238960266,
-0.14888517558574677,
-0.12007468193769455,
-0.9960249066352844,
-0.38100549578666687,
0.6477585434913635,
0.3423151671886444,
0.061235588043928146,
0.4102168679237366,
0.5642121434211731,
0.23133477568626404,
0.11505107581615448,
0.09778651595115662,
-0.6309685707092285,
-0.10611375421285629,
0.06294328719377518,
-0.539787232875824,
-0.29549962282180786,
-0.2776520550251007,
0.8356630802154541,
0.577399730682373,
0.018916962668299675,
0.20147264003753662,
0.11310460418462753,
0.4140278995037079,
-0.8642020225524902,
-0.024507328867912292,
-0.9859419465065002,
-0.09284212440252304,
-0.6896859407424927,
-0.004520732443779707,
-0.4023555815219879,
-0.00973908044397831,
0.22956466674804688,
-0.6468362808227539,
0.44892024993896484,
0.16693571209907532,
1.1654396057128906,
0.38328149914741516,
-0.28943514823913574,
0.06100240349769592,
-0.7488869428634644,
0.5632193088531494,
-0.4804357588291168,
0.5033700466156006,
0.2939123511314392,
0.3728819489479065,
-0.27626895904541016,
-0.7871108055114746,
-0.6601298451423645,
-0.036579232662916183,
-0.07368447631597519,
-0.19881229102611542,
-0.28546056151390076,
-0.00044615549268200994,
0.24350425601005554,
0.049352098256349564,
-0.4608710706233978,
0.36300256848335266,
-0.39839619398117065,
-0.17622533440589905,
0.24079591035842896,
0.2795087695121765,
0.15281419456005096,
-0.2748952805995941,
-0.3606994152069092,
0.2710539996623993,
-0.9004453420639038,
-0.0627719834446907,
0.3294840157032013,
0.5229166150093079,
0.02293807454407215,
0.555797278881073,
-0.3711246848106384,
0.7905815243721008,
0.5107480883598328,
-0.18278366327285767,
0.19995635747909546,
0.04225529730319977,
-0.14439335465431213,
0.1618715077638626,
0.7029862403869629,
0.03083612211048603,
0.42909473180770874,
-0.21550169587135315,
-0.13956421613693237,
0.007579173892736435,
0.3189796209335327,
-0.9862990379333496,
-0.38326773047447205,
0.08231963962316513,
-0.22375017404556274,
-0.09619326889514923,
-0.03845513239502907,
-0.5349121689796448,
-0.2670907974243164,
-0.1351105123758316,
0.38708600401878357,
-0.5973891019821167,
-0.019246352836489677,
-0.09528879076242447,
-0.14630244672298431,
0.10908843576908112,
0.34765195846557617,
-1.0772627592086792,
0.5869543552398682,
0.6056262850761414,
0.8897343277931213,
-0.3459876477718353,
-0.44714030623435974,
-0.8772615790367126,
0.19014912843704224,
-0.18333689868450165,
1.1798127889633179,
-0.4480943977832794,
-0.04544496163725853,
-0.32780978083610535,
0.02789340168237686,
-0.0766037330031395,
-0.5768495202064514,
0.049940045922994614,
-0.6483973264694214,
-0.042084500193595886,
-0.04191531985998154,
-0.8216533660888672,
0.16594748198986053,
0.4350185990333557,
-0.874697208404541,
0.9705718755722046,
0.1894446164369583,
-1.1410810947418213,
0.8690559267997742,
-0.4728354215621948,
-0.08653027564287186,
0.3712922930717468,
-0.19230860471725464,
-0.44485217332839966,
-0.1087893471121788,
0.07587844133377075,
0.3383265435695648,
-0.007755024824291468,
-0.17581449449062347,
-0.4165377616882324,
-0.5227113962173462,
-0.22568662464618683,
-0.11782433837652206,
0.47760844230651855,
-0.1709406077861786,
-0.2167622447013855,
-0.40232884883880615,
-1.0963201522827148,
-0.021267516538500786,
-0.013797637075185776,
-0.644795298576355,
-0.4954458475112915,
-0.07262873649597168,
0.23202115297317505,
0.14530831575393677,
-0.20284438133239746,
-0.631933867931366,
0.1777663677930832,
-0.5164172053337097,
-0.06607884168624878,
0.6172744035720825,
0.2356579601764679,
0.649378776550293,
-0.11257729679346085,
0.44786661863327026,
0.25479456782341003,
-0.3275362551212311,
-0.19096657633781433,
-0.22118455171585083,
-0.9289255142211914,
-0.5085434913635254,
0.43477073311805725,
0.5360085368156433,
-0.6717078685760498,
0.2154380977153778,
-0.576125979423523,
-0.2886776328086853,
-0.3171190023422241,
0.3993404805660248,
0.29575857520103455,
0.6605958342552185,
0.6290661096572876,
-0.5856725573539734,
-0.9367603659629822,
-0.6494792103767395,
-0.20622462034225464,
-0.2695767879486084,
-0.11572743207216263,
0.2071748822927475,
0.7780612707138062,
0.03246127441525459,
1.2239574193954468,
-0.3983258306980133,
-0.5428223609924316,
-0.269887775182724,
0.23640687763690948,
0.15070848166942596,
0.3738872706890106,
0.34363287687301636,
-0.4291607737541199,
-0.590831995010376,
-0.1108492910861969,
-0.4883630871772766,
0.12194094806909561,
-0.16675850749015808,
-0.019278747960925102,
-0.04705842211842537,
0.3562781810760498,
-0.42261752486228943,
0.22084040939807892,
0.1811004877090454,
0.16932325065135956,
0.4377438724040985,
0.44467267394065857,
-0.30988505482673645,
-0.9271837472915649,
0.03491165488958359,
0.26337385177612305,
-0.324844628572464,
-0.6123058199882507,
-0.2858949601650238,
-0.14745929837226868,
0.16501447558403015,
-0.7629178762435913,
0.6846041083335876,
-0.47298526763916016,
-0.001136175007559359,
-0.37889325618743896,
-0.10003280639648438,
-0.1255473494529724,
0.2870921790599823,
0.2614436745643616,
0.6275376677513123,
0.5118071436882019,
-0.8817154169082642,
0.16346311569213867,
0.31113794445991516,
-0.3587786555290222,
1.014846682548523,
-0.6734471917152405,
0.3688947558403015,
-0.39823299646377563,
0.6904088854789734,
-0.5757609009742737,
-0.3151707053184509,
0.36316925287246704,
-0.26932817697525024,
0.5767630934715271,
-0.7967366576194763,
-0.35800161957740784,
-0.3534073829650879,
0.009756109677255154,
0.16971874237060547,
0.06275466829538345,
-0.622341513633728,
0.5412620902061462,
0.18982785940170288,
0.1946493238210678,
-0.732460081577301,
-0.7978519797325134,
-0.00724875507876277,
-0.15614613890647888,
-0.5769836902618408,
0.5560354590415955,
0.3234352767467499,
0.1541229784488678,
0.2356598824262619,
-0.42455828189849854,
-0.41393420100212097,
-0.1904413402080536,
0.24972383677959442,
0.3314720392227173,
-0.3989880084991455,
0.26952895522117615,
-0.3288207948207855,
-0.4062080681324005,
-0.27139919996261597,
-0.5753907561302185,
0.5399133563041687,
-0.04880087450146675,
-0.28182223439216614,
-0.3285147547721863,
0.17200663685798645,
0.022873438894748688,
-0.011245952919125557,
0.7301440238952637,
0.7685747742652893,
-0.5947864651679993,
-0.3702371120452881,
-0.6260644197463989,
-0.186055988073349,
-0.38670092821121216,
0.3431066870689392,
-0.6244938969612122,
-0.9578747749328613,
0.2096889168024063,
-0.11210542172193527,
0.01112421415746212,
0.3268047571182251,
0.3760860860347748,
-0.32807669043540955,
0.4085618853569031,
0.5670216679573059,
-0.4330636262893677,
0.5343905687332153,
-0.39143481850624084,
0.006244182586669922,
-0.8717865943908691,
0.014434014447033405,
-0.47355562448501587,
-0.5347935557365417,
-0.5388339757919312,
-0.12026175856590271,
0.30805277824401855,
0.11315988749265671,
-0.34649211168289185,
0.7220450639724731,
-0.2949160039424896,
0.6807013750076294,
0.3633095324039459,
0.14482668042182922,
0.23440879583358765,
-0.04146598279476166,
-0.0954500362277031,
-0.1179661825299263,
-0.514662504196167,
-0.5922538042068481,
1.170924186706543,
0.21222734451293945,
0.9231029152870178,
-0.10911767929792404,
1.412045955657959,
-0.12331732362508774,
0.2574402093887329,
-0.9024041891098022,
0.3730188310146332,
-0.2667792737483978,
-0.8369520306587219,
-0.1770269274711609,
-0.3079689145088196,
-1.0525331497192383,
0.042791325598955154,
-0.19782334566116333,
-1.0099815130233765,
0.34615951776504517,
0.33479800820350647,
-0.5546221733093262,
0.4153374135494232,
-0.5603910088539124,
0.656488299369812,
0.08310789614915848,
-0.22924666106700897,
0.26281410455703735,
-0.589830219745636,
0.519096314907074,
-0.0179460309445858,
-0.32507914304733276,
-0.05810655280947685,
0.035201508551836014,
0.5253281593322754,
-0.4578001797199249,
0.950778603553772,
-0.10265864431858063,
0.26393768191337585,
0.35445040464401245,
0.007766347378492355,
0.7050295472145081,
-0.06828685849905014,
0.15908117592334747,
0.0551426075398922,
-0.09689395129680634,
-0.4286049008369446,
-0.35781583189964294,
0.5000074505805969,
-0.5575269460678101,
-0.28055575489997864,
-0.32625138759613037,
-0.08954186737537384,
-0.22115075588226318,
0.22909820079803467,
0.79909747838974,
0.12505152821540833,
-0.45358216762542725,
-0.060610316693782806,
0.7696918249130249,
0.25396355986595154,
0.558851957321167,
0.28768712282180786,
-0.06971902400255203,
-0.1425200253725052,
0.8113066554069519,
0.21716928482055664,
0.16402536630630493,
0.43818363547325134,
-0.3248840570449829,
0.031825680285692215,
-0.559131920337677,
-0.4890251159667969,
0.20052073895931244,
-0.5754089951515198,
-0.38426080346107483,
-0.8966989517211914,
-0.3701983690261841,
-0.18762896955013275,
0.09371209144592285,
-0.6966648101806641,
-0.3459201753139496,
-0.4785437285900116,
0.002635963959619403,
0.3197842836380005,
0.4049738645553589,
0.09336376935243607,
0.4829828143119812,
-0.8779053688049316,
0.5847921371459961,
0.4528009593486786,
0.3715355694293976,
-0.15134213864803314,
-0.6229430437088013,
-0.12150204926729202,
-0.37476053833961487,
-0.1915706843137741,
-0.8706890344619751,
0.14359593391418457,
0.37741756439208984,
0.4331691563129425,
0.5011283159255981,
-0.2597997486591339,
0.7538571953773499,
-0.8481355905532837,
0.5195096731185913,
0.389049232006073,
-0.817420244216919,
0.526090681552887,
-0.04266660660505295,
0.1027102917432785,
0.8549463748931885,
0.6396173238754272,
-0.5207646489143372,
-0.15190979838371277,
-0.42589715123176575,
-0.7023708820343018,
0.8063657283782959,
0.11529272049665451,
0.10228001326322556,
-0.21453158557415009,
0.08373263478279114,
0.04088469594717026,
-0.06892857700586319,
-0.8617762923240662,
-0.2475527673959732,
-0.19500644505023956,
0.027837540954351425,
0.44907906651496887,
0.08910053968429565,
0.07123610377311707,
0.11455044150352478,
0.6928898096084595,
-0.2353854477405548,
0.16653898358345032,
-0.0027361998800188303,
-0.4652555286884308,
-0.0994226485490799,
0.47892388701438904,
0.1192263513803482,
0.26988956332206726,
-0.14596353471279144,
0.2371576875448227,
0.48222506046295166,
-0.518688976764679,
0.27797988057136536,
0.20859861373901367,
-0.4198075234889984,
0.38177961111068726,
0.2892894148826599,
0.9347919821739197,
0.26080140471458435,
-0.15901169180870056,
0.3917333483695984,
0.4716159403324127,
0.08699898421764374,
-0.34141111373901367,
0.1494920402765274,
0.09110057353973389,
0.23466163873672485,
0.3031235635280609,
0.2296561747789383,
0.1964086890220642,
-0.22831383347511292,
0.415394127368927,
0.29177844524383545,
-0.37044697999954224,
-0.27074766159057617,
0.4509885013103485,
0.12950678169727325,
-0.0961676836013794,
0.696760356426239,
-0.5041857361793518,
-0.4367823600769043,
0.497491717338562,
0.6407882571220398,
0.7831146717071533,
-0.054428186267614365,
0.2566928565502167,
0.6691133975982666,
0.2946361303329468,
-0.40700188279151917,
0.03943167254328728,
0.18248246610164642,
-1.0745643377304077,
-0.2794862389564514,
-0.5751299858093262,
-0.2451840490102768,
0.14795057475566864,
-0.4590848982334137,
0.7406188249588013,
-0.6705181002616882,
-0.3330707252025604,
0.354103684425354,
-0.22796528041362762,
-1.0714693069458008,
0.15834254026412964,
0.34000536799430847,
0.6914934515953064,
-0.6801224946975708,
0.9002459049224854,
0.5271669030189514,
-0.7357078194618225,
-0.8725990653038025,
-0.05719520151615143,
0.4581323564052582,
-0.6915955543518066,
1.0608949661254883,
0.20520944893360138,
-0.20257142186164856,
0.22489409148693085,
-0.6196002960205078,
-0.9648343324661255,
1.0443952083587646,
0.14419448375701904,
-0.920074462890625,
-0.3655731678009033,
-0.10655257105827332,
0.39372745156288147,
-0.5121485590934753,
0.24658536911010742,
0.640800416469574,
0.38245880603790283,
0.171366885304451,
-0.9338752627372742,
-0.1765475869178772,
-0.0337471105158329,
0.14121964573860168,
0.5322347283363342,
-0.44283559918403625,
0.5001927018165588,
-0.362229585647583,
-0.22716329991817474,
-0.032493382692337036,
0.6526878476142883,
0.4908631443977356,
0.3709143400192261,
0.6404176354408264,
0.8583943843841553,
0.6895623207092285,
-0.025369049981236458,
0.9371387362480164,
0.12293399125337601,
0.2667793333530426,
1.7616838216781616,
-0.4165008068084717,
1.0893888473510742,
0.5280565619468689,
-0.43750858306884766,
0.6352617740631104,
0.40494605898857117,
-0.5372393131256104,
0.4240156412124634,
0.3765154182910919,
-0.44188541173934937,
-0.11393657326698303,
-0.136010080575943,
-0.2032795548439026,
0.6519440412521362,
0.16032446920871735,
-0.33677464723587036,
-0.4453085958957672,
-0.12202874571084976,
0.11022944748401642,
-0.4667189121246338,
-0.2263760268688202,
0.7358114719390869,
0.2442370057106018,
-0.36849212646484375,
0.41809260845184326,
-0.06885962188243866,
1.0424244403839111,
-0.5717371106147766,
0.1284818798303604,
-0.13428430259227753,
-0.01114475168287754,
-0.6001015305519104,
-0.28464508056640625,
0.23956969380378723,
0.4309708774089813,
-0.2435092329978943,
0.22253751754760742,
0.8117308616638184,
-0.2985908091068268,
-0.36336880922317505,
0.01632583700120449,
0.4546831548213959,
0.32389798760414124,
-0.08239714801311493,
-0.40418148040771484,
-0.347632497549057,
-0.4590754210948944,
-0.15866133570671082,
0.4337509572505951,
0.36678245663642883,
0.00283208885230124,
0.5150579810142517,
0.5942954421043396,
0.26839184761047363,
0.5693085193634033,
0.28854766488075256,
0.8463329076766968,
-0.4957221746444702,
-0.27504676580429077,
-0.6264505982398987,
0.5733487606048584,
0.04704465717077255,
-0.4319334626197815,
0.2075849324464798,
0.5909445881843567,
1.0231777429580688,
-0.10636696219444275,
0.6527811288833618,
-0.21201001107692719,
0.4210446774959564,
-0.5175381898880005,
0.4172394871711731,
-0.34752392768859863,
0.277695894241333,
-0.3657666742801666,
-0.9992648959159851,
-0.37651327252388,
0.46264660358428955,
-0.14819036424160004,
0.08296813070774078,
0.8999162316322327,
0.776308536529541,
-0.34683099389076233,
-0.33884158730506897,
0.12789607048034668,
-0.010544664226472378,
0.0988822877407074,
0.739559531211853,
0.7904768586158752,
-0.5568519830703735,
0.9295530915260315,
-0.1786556839942932,
0.32213208079338074,
-0.0005747227114625275,
-0.890045166015625,
-0.7466768622398376,
-0.24504980444908142,
-0.538276731967926,
-0.3445347845554352,
-0.04712958633899689,
1.0350250005722046,
0.9286518692970276,
-1.0059281587600708,
0.11169523745775223,
-0.31317323446273804,
-0.04914815351366997,
-0.017529647797346115,
-0.28408578038215637,
0.014347219839692116,
-0.4847906231880188,
-0.8708397746086121,
0.2995195686817169,
0.47154200077056885,
0.11610554158687592,
0.006306429859250784,
-0.06293907761573792,
-0.27295413613319397,
-0.20652753114700317,
0.2658650875091553,
0.5235256552696228,
-0.7026456594467163,
-0.5100043416023254,
0.06163371726870537,
-0.27046364545822144,
0.29791179299354553,
0.750191330909729,
-0.8452363014221191,
0.39136171340942383,
0.4791282117366791,
0.9044390320777893,
0.9567680954933167,
-0.26478779315948486,
0.1502164602279663,
-0.9790560007095337,
-0.04231218993663788,
0.30977296829223633,
0.44379809498786926,
0.3521447479724884,
-0.28668174147605896,
0.647149920463562,
0.3224363327026367,
-0.21312879025936127,
-0.47772619128227234,
0.3413209915161133,
-0.9967600703239441,
0.15490426123142242,
0.9950418472290039,
-0.3844168186187744,
0.04749998822808266,
-0.2897303104400635,
0.14989003539085388,
0.19413602352142334,
-0.4509871304035187,
0.5509926676750183,
0.816047728061676,
-0.2171708047389984,
-0.46276652812957764,
-0.305939644575119,
0.2147762030363083,
0.18313255906105042,
-0.9665095210075378,
-0.5402458906173706,
0.5381850004196167,
0.7755506038665771,
0.19935187697410583,
0.989661455154419,
-0.014788070693612099,
0.21584446728229523,
0.11500446498394012,
0.11161574721336365,
0.17082181572914124,
-0.46524086594581604,
-0.33220791816711426,
0.23391161859035492,
-0.018679922446608543,
-0.4360326826572418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05446v1
|
Design of reliable technology valuation model with calibrated machine learning of patent indicators
| 2024-06-08T11:52:37 | 2024-06-08T11:52:37 |
Seunghyun Lee, Janghyeok Yoon, Jaewoong Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Machine learning (ML) has revolutionized the digital transformation of
technology valuation by predicting the value of patents with high accuracy.
However, the lack of validation regarding the reliability of these models
hinders experts from fully trusting the confidence of model predictions. To
address this issue, we propose an analytical framework for reliable technology
valuation using calibrated ML models, which provide robust confidence levels in
model predictions. We extract quantitative patent indicators that represent
various technology characteristics as input data, using the patent maintenance
period as a proxy for technology values. Multiple ML models are developed to
capture the nonlinear relationship between patent indicators and technology
value. The reliability and accuracy of these models are evaluated, presenting a
Pareto-front map where the expected calibration error, Matthews correlation
coefficient and F1-scores are compared. After identifying the best-performing
model, we apply SHapley Additive exPlanation (SHAP) analysis to pinpoint the
most significant input features by confidence bin. Through a case study, we
confirmed that the proposed approach offers a practical guideline for
developing reliable and accurate ML-based technology valuation models, with
significant implications for both academia and industry.
|
[
-0.11842989921569824,
-0.4319174885749817,
0.4736202657222748,
0.4343021810054779,
-0.0755419060587883,
0.0935501828789711,
0.3806690573692322,
-0.3564877510070801,
-0.001659145811572671,
0.3457721173763275,
-0.13621605932712555,
-0.12431485950946808,
-0.5321043729782104,
-0.47242388129234314,
-0.3063018321990967,
0.6381996870040894,
-0.08937666565179825,
0.025609545409679413,
-0.191734179854393,
0.02612963877618313,
-0.6797652244567871,
-0.6082603335380554,
-0.20137818157672882,
-0.4029598534107208,
0.2592739760875702,
0.14799068868160248,
0.7243894934654236,
0.6766327023506165,
0.5453922748565674,
0.23344039916992188,
-0.04637008160352707,
0.0871579721570015,
-0.012156877666711807,
-0.016968699172139168,
0.22471724450588226,
-0.1682518571615219,
-0.6451115012168884,
0.30795469880104065,
0.25340017676353455,
0.8423391580581665,
0.1293928623199463,
0.4330018162727356,
0.28395479917526245,
0.6525781750679016,
-0.6087772846221924,
0.7041391134262085,
-0.7916986346244812,
0.18186624348163605,
0.1626446396112442,
-0.5677007436752319,
-0.6704216599464417,
-0.5394335389137268,
0.2589968740940094,
-0.5261954665184021,
0.1184200718998909,
-0.004833338316529989,
1.359349250793457,
0.515707790851593,
-0.17550420761108398,
0.08344502747058868,
-0.68402099609375,
0.9638616442680359,
-0.4064469337463379,
0.05264457315206528,
0.5444509387016296,
0.5844607353210449,
-0.11919156461954117,
-0.6951619386672974,
-0.15032266080379486,
-0.6518314480781555,
0.20936113595962524,
-0.20842692255973816,
0.1459624022245407,
-0.28778955340385437,
-0.020176658406853676,
0.04275158792734146,
-0.3004871904850006,
0.011786897666752338,
-0.49512943625450134,
-0.48741820454597473,
0.39616239070892334,
-0.0189284048974514,
-0.13842448592185974,
0.08713793009519577,
-0.7408527731895447,
-0.048315148800611496,
-0.690062403678894,
0.49890533089637756,
0.36482366919517517,
0.5260015726089478,
0.1884586364030838,
0.5792035460472107,
0.1261206716299057,
0.6525543928146362,
0.3353671729564667,
-0.3068426847457886,
0.3348866403102875,
-0.4216603934764862,
-0.15412473678588867,
0.18171635270118713,
0.4135672152042389,
0.455963671207428,
0.28659865260124207,
-0.13779574632644653,
-0.3371184766292572,
-0.18898777663707733,
0.5224837064743042,
-0.8706029653549194,
-0.3305012583732605,
0.4961702823638916,
-0.6181108951568604,
-0.6288517713546753,
0.31324905157089233,
-0.3244815170764923,
-0.634428083896637,
-0.32057785987854004,
0.932013988494873,
-0.2593061327934265,
-0.3727717399597168,
-0.0029340037144720554,
-0.3870116174221039,
-0.1813584417104721,
0.21588094532489777,
-0.5515165328979492,
-0.22381967306137085,
0.9043915271759033,
0.8352662920951843,
0.09118922799825668,
-0.2910023629665375,
-0.43529054522514343,
-0.04289653152227402,
-0.6787559390068054,
0.6401788592338562,
-0.2965882122516632,
-0.6023132801055908,
-0.2627503573894501,
-0.010826566256582737,
-0.099554143846035,
-0.7650243043899536,
0.6516188383102417,
-0.7208909392356873,
-0.004049451556056738,
-0.18389399349689484,
-0.35678768157958984,
-0.29509004950523376,
0.5174763202667236,
-0.8107484579086304,
0.7891842722892761,
0.22335489094257355,
-0.8205076456069946,
0.8815362453460693,
-0.7603644728660583,
-0.14070479571819305,
0.14045467972755432,
0.23246684670448303,
-0.9076368808746338,
0.016601072624325752,
0.05791040137410164,
0.48780858516693115,
-0.1357242316007614,
0.9524286389350891,
-0.8376493453979492,
-0.4697926640510559,
0.5480746030807495,
-0.48549598455429077,
0.939885139465332,
0.3843371272087097,
-0.372478723526001,
0.0420355387032032,
-0.9690166711807251,
0.23082292079925537,
-0.2722078859806061,
0.001127720228396356,
-0.06669704616069794,
-0.015505392104387283,
-0.29111507534980774,
0.21493761241436005,
0.5470215082168579,
-0.7275145053863525,
-0.43179795145988464,
-0.11595459282398224,
0.47982096672058105,
0.7368156313896179,
0.08081457018852234,
0.13377785682678223,
-0.5428012013435364,
0.5523561835289001,
0.1881866306066513,
0.3796433210372925,
-0.37925592064857483,
-0.644652247428894,
-0.5943864583969116,
-0.38594114780426025,
0.6653591394424438,
0.38986313343048096,
-0.3713655471801758,
0.5119604468345642,
-0.5005587935447693,
-0.4037301242351532,
-0.49497708678245544,
-0.30373701453208923,
0.007323991507291794,
1.0652731657028198,
0.3343293368816376,
-0.23159870505332947,
-0.3304250240325928,
-0.9572501182556152,
-0.1766095608472824,
-0.4925191402435303,
-0.18902704119682312,
0.3009797930717468,
0.2439461350440979,
0.05501333624124527,
1.052916169166565,
0.051859043538570404,
-0.015299972146749496,
0.39796191453933716,
0.5650062561035156,
0.5512334704399109,
0.4177766740322113,
0.32832667231559753,
-0.8165122270584106,
-0.4825073480606079,
0.25751838088035583,
-0.5290107727050781,
-0.032633036375045776,
-0.053856540471315384,
0.11127057671546936,
0.12951868772506714,
-0.13054576516151428,
-0.2698579728603363,
0.6805928945541382,
0.31376001238822937,
-0.22458620369434357,
0.5938624739646912,
-0.22783610224723816,
0.6411451697349548,
-0.7661360502243042,
0.6659963130950928,
0.23414377868175507,
-0.07016780227422714,
-0.2562618553638458,
-0.23043736815452576,
0.13760991394519806,
-0.2082754373550415,
-0.25994977355003357,
0.6552697420120239,
0.2798326015472412,
-0.07049819827079773,
-0.3220526874065399,
-0.3213635981082916,
0.3767850399017334,
0.010094896890223026,
-0.39288392663002014,
1.0235692262649536,
0.2925961911678314,
-0.6799028515815735,
0.26211652159690857,
-0.3472156822681427,
-0.3134380877017975,
0.6894923448562622,
-0.8317083120346069,
-0.23239125311374664,
0.3714142143726349,
-0.1380702555179596,
-0.7571184635162354,
0.17421849071979523,
-0.11708447337150574,
-0.7253805994987488,
0.26812851428985596,
-0.4312932789325714,
-0.2672864496707916,
-0.33254727721214294,
-0.37844401597976685,
0.02854633703827858,
0.27380093932151794,
-0.43260666728019714,
0.7552269101142883,
0.5889294743537903,
-0.401866614818573,
-0.9392164349555969,
-0.769486129283905,
0.03467835113406181,
-0.3374757766723633,
-0.9995566606521606,
0.4372340440750122,
0.14106681942939758,
-0.27292531728744507,
0.04002811759710312,
-0.0010501615470275283,
-0.5231062173843384,
0.46613091230392456,
0.5117049217224121,
0.5945905447006226,
-0.06293369829654694,
0.13685645163059235,
-0.1391228884458542,
-0.7159545421600342,
0.2829670011997223,
-0.5726826190948486,
0.2230892777442932,
-0.035954948514699936,
-0.21021388471126556,
-0.6325556635856628,
-0.35398250818252563,
0.5959340333938599,
0.12263882160186768,
0.5581409335136414,
0.5571666955947876,
-0.3551066815853119,
-0.2142619639635086,
-0.3531371057033539,
0.038723062723875046,
-0.47157928347587585,
0.13930074870586395,
-0.7496529221534729,
-0.25089871883392334,
0.632897675037384,
-0.06626410782337189,
0.053097814321517944,
0.8471124172210693,
0.49593502283096313,
-0.02012663334608078,
0.8832435607910156,
0.7950913906097412,
-0.10230857133865356,
0.20583516359329224,
-0.24845533072948456,
0.5782718658447266,
-0.19368769228458405,
-0.6316126585006714,
-0.8472543358802795,
-0.05327243730425835,
-0.44565874338150024,
0.0018897647969424725,
0.46723654866218567,
-0.143199160695076,
-0.6698269844055176,
0.28081539273262024,
-0.5789093375205994,
-0.05048016086220741,
0.8710082769393921,
0.22091268002986908,
0.14732134342193604,
0.2699502110481262,
-0.2837599515914917,
-0.04373671114444733,
-0.4228374660015106,
-0.8213412165641785,
1.2890105247497559,
0.7072114944458008,
0.4223984181880951,
-0.5092384815216064,
0.44201594591140747,
0.6500996947288513,
0.16931134462356567,
-0.6628727316856384,
0.17644274234771729,
-0.16188809275627136,
-0.596288800239563,
-0.0770571380853653,
-0.5353707075119019,
-0.5338841676712036,
-0.29244768619537354,
0.2333623766899109,
-0.5028969049453735,
0.5308083891868591,
0.49004244804382324,
-0.5292952656745911,
0.1442248821258545,
-0.6657478213310242,
0.8238169550895691,
-0.42097777128219604,
-0.5196573138237,
-0.3443205654621124,
-0.42144206166267395,
0.40330377221107483,
-0.4251769185066223,
0.10148949176073074,
-0.0765390694141388,
0.0830567330121994,
0.49819594621658325,
-0.6512455940246582,
0.40452492237091064,
-0.4583386778831482,
0.11766712367534637,
0.3947857618331909,
0.2709740102291107,
0.04883148893713951,
-0.2786461114883423,
-0.9529408812522888,
0.15835799276828766,
0.3416306972503662,
-0.418443888425827,
-0.34965625405311584,
0.6615134477615356,
-0.5167239308357239,
-0.23452134430408478,
-0.4169028103351593,
-0.5038761496543884,
-0.18410231173038483,
0.010851324535906315,
0.0974825844168663,
0.26649555563926697,
0.11738043278455734,
0.2149924337863922,
0.3398928940296173,
-0.07221880555152893,
0.44609951972961426,
-0.04163879156112671,
0.03387318179011345,
-0.607403039932251,
1.2127891778945923,
0.31416022777557373,
0.06350872665643692,
0.20741553604602814,
0.31464505195617676,
-0.3289348781108856,
-0.40839269757270813,
-0.42451125383377075,
-0.4057982563972473,
-0.525010347366333,
-0.18382370471954346,
-0.37587255239486694,
-0.4505311846733093,
-0.052856434136629105,
-0.15144185721874237,
-0.3629128038883209,
-0.753173828125,
-0.46182122826576233,
-0.17995281517505646,
0.16141971945762634,
0.4578688442707062,
0.014128667302429676,
-0.07813142240047455,
-0.6455420255661011,
0.17322376370429993,
0.26243823766708374,
0.5221084356307983,
0.053683869540691376,
-0.8085801601409912,
-0.24805998802185059,
0.48549988865852356,
-0.6494009494781494,
-0.24508051574230194,
0.5377339124679565,
0.010290384292602539,
0.5435894727706909,
0.3476908504962921,
0.019127026200294495,
0.6103136539459229,
-0.204482764005661,
0.9592475295066833,
0.11482458561658859,
-0.9035472869873047,
0.37489426136016846,
0.05913436412811279,
-0.18013009428977966,
0.349923700094223,
0.2853061556816101,
0.11786840111017227,
0.26060351729393005,
-0.6687255501747131,
-0.6089699864387512,
0.23444601893424988,
-0.37162110209465027,
0.127968430519104,
0.45781663060188293,
0.31451696157455444,
0.40391820669174194,
0.2644537091255188,
-0.5794618129730225,
0.12139131128787994,
-0.5586345195770264,
-0.3143077790737152,
0.41292521357536316,
-0.2800690233707428,
-0.1540517359972,
-0.06211558356881142,
1.0240428447723389,
0.048115324229002,
0.10435789823532104,
-0.44844549894332886,
0.10040558874607086,
0.09475255757570267,
-0.038026660680770874,
0.2817595303058624,
1.095812201499939,
-0.4455474317073822,
0.11971751600503922,
-0.4059531092643738,
-0.35323113203048706,
0.14609433710575104,
0.49291515350341797,
-0.48313191533088684,
0.10796308517456055,
-0.12238264083862305,
0.31954118609428406,
-0.13283033668994904,
-0.2922280430793762,
0.5242784023284912,
0.20463624596595764,
-0.17715021967887878,
-0.21830715239048004,
-0.18067306280136108,
-0.21236680448055267,
0.1668369024991989,
0.5923947095870972,
0.27942684292793274,
0.22059695422649384,
-0.16565783321857452,
0.5705098509788513,
0.5238242149353027,
-0.6863903403282166,
-0.1390787959098816,
0.9048459529876709,
0.19170741736888885,
-0.3225007951259613,
0.28993839025497437,
-0.11226915568113327,
-0.677483856678009,
0.925286054611206,
0.0863216370344162,
1.2065012454986572,
0.19410128891468048,
0.45669248700141907,
0.27374109625816345,
0.4077945947647095,
-0.09949769824743271,
0.27537769079208374,
0.010197759605944157,
-0.43449339270591736,
-0.19726669788360596,
-0.5302594900131226,
-0.6616317629814148,
-0.1963004320859909,
-0.19069956243038177,
0.49627092480659485,
-0.5778045654296875,
-0.897734522819519,
0.12711523473262787,
0.286769837141037,
-0.4671626091003418,
0.2295379936695099,
-0.19297759234905243,
0.5625883936882019,
-0.6401662826538086,
0.6035919189453125,
0.05163494497537613,
-0.47155332565307617,
-0.6533178091049194,
-0.320528119802475,
-0.21462273597717285,
-0.8451816439628601,
0.9687777757644653,
0.3193971514701843,
-0.3620350658893585,
-0.2077631950378418,
-0.5513387322425842,
-0.673203706741333,
1.0279414653778076,
0.3335729241371155,
-0.1955115795135498,
0.5351860523223877,
0.16324317455291748,
0.34650078415870667,
-0.3316454589366913,
0.20547747611999512,
0.09918126463890076,
0.44452181458473206,
0.17900866270065308,
-1.1015305519104004,
-0.2290753722190857,
-0.18463222682476044,
0.0825718566775322,
-0.07684262096881866,
-0.2138141691684723,
0.824175238609314,
-0.26802584528923035,
-0.08873677998781204,
0.4659174084663391,
0.16436263918876648,
0.46900656819343567,
0.9560350179672241,
0.2395847588777542,
0.4865824282169342,
0.6233090758323669,
-0.20371511578559875,
0.7718056440353394,
-0.9622229337692261,
0.43069958686828613,
0.6955031752586365,
-0.12797799706459045,
0.9177420735359192,
0.2945784330368042,
-0.24446211755275726,
0.5408421754837036,
0.7382122874259949,
-0.48851603269577026,
0.3398928940296173,
0.030237607657909393,
-0.17633478343486786,
-0.07722241431474686,
-0.21323701739311218,
-0.2669892907142639,
-0.002020669635385275,
0.20174309611320496,
-0.9018763303756714,
0.3689364194869995,
-0.29069527983665466,
-0.05192945897579193,
-0.06749178469181061,
-0.12237140536308289,
0.29177671670913696,
-0.016483264043927193,
-0.47570180892944336,
0.5044471025466919,
0.07773206382989883,
0.295498251914978,
-0.29346567392349243,
-0.14204008877277374,
0.11911316215991974,
0.36298441886901855,
-0.1671813726425171,
-0.5985162854194641,
-0.008540403097867966,
-0.1623045802116394,
-0.16495771706104279,
-0.2688840329647064,
0.466526597738266,
0.045409832149744034,
-0.9741877913475037,
-0.2185230851173401,
0.11234374344348907,
-0.02230476215481758,
-0.03502752259373665,
-0.5183685421943665,
-0.058683741837739944,
-0.13995568454265594,
0.19120782613754272,
0.026236791163682938,
0.2550031542778015,
0.0157298780977726,
0.959805965423584,
0.4555447995662689,
-0.0025196243077516556,
0.14696983993053436,
-0.19285757839679718,
0.4556562900543213,
-0.5426069498062134,
-0.3150949478149414,
-0.651037871837616,
1.013814091682434,
-0.2237798571586609,
-0.2254457026720047,
0.47897207736968994,
0.5592038631439209,
0.43965837359428406,
0.15905576944351196,
0.7123631834983826,
0.3756048381328583,
0.5016660094261169,
-0.2466016411781311,
0.796789824962616,
-0.13249728083610535,
0.5985851287841797,
-0.06386952847242355,
-0.6616031527519226,
-0.47202467918395996,
0.5382976531982422,
-0.15918371081352234,
0.28330790996551514,
0.3205649256706238,
0.8170461654663086,
0.019159989431500435,
0.2928473651409149,
0.21313394606113434,
0.07476305216550827,
0.4921271502971649,
0.17486973106861115,
0.5935688614845276,
-0.5817199945449829,
0.2860878109931946,
-0.6980863809585571,
-0.3871311843395233,
-0.2706574499607086,
-1.3451893329620361,
-0.23843912780284882,
-0.4132276475429535,
-0.5484890937805176,
-0.7575653195381165,
-0.12901906669139862,
0.4644983410835266,
0.9572850465774536,
-1.0489723682403564,
-0.16746661067008972,
0.1986217349767685,
0.15731610357761383,
-0.31151992082595825,
-0.27554112672805786,
0.5513336658477783,
-0.4987753927707672,
-0.36869120597839355,
-0.039961718022823334,
0.5864027142524719,
-0.06467605382204056,
-0.516937792301178,
0.09401286393404007,
0.37863555550575256,
0.008097629994153976,
0.47756874561309814,
0.34278374910354614,
-0.7064241766929626,
-0.18952560424804688,
0.2517000734806061,
-0.03428827226161957,
0.05372094362974167,
0.4371112287044525,
-0.9479653835296631,
0.8329514265060425,
0.34646737575531006,
0.8683246374130249,
0.37248265743255615,
0.17973192036151886,
0.582383394241333,
-0.21892423927783966,
-0.029119502753019333,
0.21685221791267395,
0.40806126594543457,
0.4709012508392334,
-0.25153887271881104,
0.31605538725852966,
0.17677226662635803,
-0.7877389192581177,
-0.8178162574768066,
-0.11365392059087753,
-0.8665890097618103,
-0.013920445926487446,
0.6843212246894836,
-0.5280143618583679,
-0.14241355657577515,
-0.09961723536252975,
0.07420492172241211,
-0.1629377156496048,
-0.1363527774810791,
1.315151572227478,
0.6429152488708496,
-0.09494959563016891,
-0.01644771732389927,
-0.3544178307056427,
0.0034648175351321697,
0.14121325314044952,
-0.36669450998306274,
-0.27440425753593445,
0.5090806484222412,
0.15672168135643005,
0.3972185552120209,
-0.14043386280536652,
-0.3960511088371277,
0.39331573247909546,
0.29017558693885803,
-0.07563129812479019,
-0.4929380714893341,
-0.45607709884643555,
-0.26324212551116943,
0.747586727142334,
0.4795474112033844,
-0.6450178623199463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05431v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05431v1
|
MaTableGPT: GPT-based Table Data Extractor from Materials Science Literature
| 2024-06-08T10:31:18 | 2024-06-08T10:31:18 |
Gyeong Hoon Yi, Jiwoo Choi, Hyeongyun Song, Olivia Miano, Jaewoong Choi, Kihoon Bang, Byungju Lee, Seok Su Sohn, David Buttler, Anna Hiszpanski, Sang Soo Han, Donghun Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Efficiently extracting data from tables in the scientific literature is
pivotal for building large-scale databases. However, the tables reported in
materials science papers exist in highly diverse forms; thus, rule-based
extractions are an ineffective approach. To overcome this challenge, we present
MaTableGPT, which is a GPT-based table data extractor from the materials
science literature. MaTableGPT features key strategies of table data
representation and table splitting for better GPT comprehension and filtering
hallucinated information through follow-up questions. When applied to a vast
volume of water splitting catalysis literature, MaTableGPT achieved an
extraction accuracy (total F1 score) of up to 96.8%. Through comprehensive
evaluations of the GPT usage cost, labeling cost, and extraction accuracy for
the learning methods of zero-shot, few-shot and fine-tuning, we present a
Pareto-front mapping where the few-shot learning method was found to be the
most balanced solution owing to both its high extraction accuracy (total F1
score>95%) and low cost (GPT usage cost of 5.97 US dollars and labeling cost of
10 I/O paired examples). The statistical analyses conducted on the database
generated by MaTableGPT revealed valuable insights into the distribution of the
overpotential and elemental utilization across the reported catalysts in the
water splitting literature.
|
[
-0.4615645110607147,
-0.7783929705619812,
0.6485629677772522,
0.1841200739145279,
-0.2602369785308838,
0.16958405077457428,
0.11143992096185684,
-0.046124447137117386,
0.15115384757518768,
0.2478475272655487,
-0.3440634608268738,
-0.3420119881629944,
-0.459819495677948,
-0.104197196662426,
-0.07945193350315094,
1.2486947774887085,
-0.07901336252689362,
0.02772679552435875,
0.10856319218873978,
0.24766378104686737,
-0.2870641052722931,
0.17478147149085999,
-0.31987398862838745,
-0.6687438488006592,
0.7300599217414856,
0.4211049973964691,
0.7226952314376831,
0.9207392930984497,
0.6199122071266174,
0.16253647208213806,
0.011154626496136189,
-0.014143828302621841,
-0.186892569065094,
-0.20799598097801208,
-0.4530490040779114,
-0.29867544770240784,
-0.3231111168861389,
0.2537785470485687,
0.44293850660324097,
0.46411800384521484,
-0.4987483620643616,
0.2765877842903137,
0.2730180621147156,
0.9932026863098145,
-0.4888237714767456,
0.47612667083740234,
-0.7900214195251465,
0.6152002811431885,
-0.5697503685951233,
-0.47882434725761414,
-0.314750611782074,
-0.5246984362602234,
0.055856529623270035,
-0.5321938395500183,
0.42547839879989624,
-0.09791851043701172,
1.0209640264511108,
0.11683287471532822,
-0.1874094158411026,
-0.2110762745141983,
-0.589410662651062,
0.620642364025116,
-0.08069255948066711,
0.3971254825592041,
0.17742812633514404,
0.6860131025314331,
-0.19852732121944427,
-0.839876651763916,
-0.4945436716079712,
-0.16211852431297302,
-0.010007071308791637,
0.32439857721328735,
0.09090123325586319,
-0.048998717218637466,
0.23745642602443695,
0.6546796560287476,
-1.0596596002578735,
-0.45601290464401245,
-0.3775196969509125,
0.13883033394813538,
0.18399524688720703,
0.06002309173345566,
0.20058000087738037,
-0.20096300542354584,
-0.6099948883056641,
-0.16470080614089966,
-0.488191694021225,
-0.5535938739776611,
0.17222189903259277,
0.47341975569725037,
0.23260577023029327,
0.7824485301971436,
-0.10180514305830002,
0.3144848346710205,
-0.3932659924030304,
-0.09072782099246979,
0.23373566567897797,
-0.016534877941012383,
-0.1678655445575714,
0.04816359654068947,
0.6504095196723938,
-0.0209959764033556,
0.17653506994247437,
-0.4623144268989563,
-0.025183867663145065,
0.15005894005298615,
0.18764947354793549,
-0.988796055316925,
-0.7218778729438782,
0.0336788184940815,
-0.3018364906311035,
-0.3117452561855316,
0.17125990986824036,
-1.309846043586731,
-0.5102701187133789,
-0.18966837227344513,
0.5887826681137085,
-0.2736210525035858,
-0.5055861473083496,
-0.054116155952215195,
-0.4889046549797058,
0.3137042224407196,
0.07821919769048691,
-0.781451404094696,
0.3262108266353607,
0.6411275267601013,
1.2374778985977173,
-0.6597176790237427,
-0.18519164621829987,
-0.5188440680503845,
0.19706875085830688,
-0.056934747844934464,
1.0251129865646362,
-0.32185056805610657,
-0.41725262999534607,
-0.4564579427242279,
-0.23346994817256927,
-0.1421353965997696,
-0.6759060621261597,
0.5869476199150085,
-0.3464193642139435,
0.0954904556274414,
-0.4051300585269928,
-0.30422666668891907,
-0.011007125489413738,
0.3625696003437042,
-0.7466407418251038,
1.1078529357910156,
0.1885070502758026,
-0.8206379413604736,
0.4158681333065033,
-0.8529928922653198,
-0.4195350110530853,
0.29956290125846863,
-0.018854031339287758,
-0.7142221927642822,
-0.0216135922819376,
0.14619001746177673,
0.2605428695678711,
-0.4851478934288025,
0.21977436542510986,
-0.2870231568813324,
0.06875216960906982,
0.12968584895133972,
-0.7086480259895325,
0.5801070928573608,
0.3286530375480652,
-0.27721160650253296,
-0.13594244420528412,
-0.9357420206069946,
0.10865464806556702,
0.23437996208667755,
-0.5075632333755493,
0.09445790201425552,
0.0955420583486557,
0.2014150321483612,
0.3094303011894226,
-0.2864471971988678,
-0.8214709758758545,
0.1854487657546997,
0.16351844370365143,
0.21146994829177856,
0.6461719274520874,
0.2235083281993866,
0.2732515037059784,
-0.2417462021112442,
0.4749637246131897,
-0.436246782541275,
0.01308982539921999,
0.21805711090564728,
-0.5253123044967651,
-0.5444393157958984,
-0.45419377088546753,
0.4802750051021576,
0.7457918524742126,
-0.8918222784996033,
0.04451735317707062,
-0.2686871290206909,
-0.8366875052452087,
-0.155138298869133,
-0.08057050406932831,
0.14293256402015686,
0.7553281188011169,
0.6360781192779541,
-0.011639919131994247,
-0.31031161546707153,
-0.7541041374206543,
-0.38069266080856323,
-0.0318586491048336,
0.10000362992286682,
0.07755214720964432,
0.7109147906303406,
0.072783462703228,
1.2275395393371582,
-1.0219812393188477,
-0.5031792521476746,
-0.21351143717765808,
0.33327099680900574,
0.30901312828063965,
0.37547656893730164,
0.04058944433927536,
-0.67566978931427,
-0.8870487809181213,
0.5158036947250366,
-0.6760064959526062,
-0.12321139872074127,
-0.10200568288564682,
-0.3739261031150818,
-0.10688911378383636,
0.12292879819869995,
-0.6741137504577637,
0.20852512121200562,
0.22443366050720215,
0.018114665523171425,
0.510648250579834,
-0.00601212726905942,
-0.14203597605228424,
-0.6112850904464722,
0.21811555325984955,
0.21476836502552032,
-0.14054706692695618,
-0.5200021266937256,
-0.03953450545668602,
0.0631776824593544,
-0.20313017070293427,
-0.41632384061813354,
0.23449984192848206,
-0.5814192295074463,
-0.07468272745609283,
-0.255496621131897,
-0.2472844421863556,
0.015575550496578217,
0.528769850730896,
0.13158905506134033,
0.6941608190536499,
0.220439150929451,
-0.24367818236351013,
0.1155436709523201,
0.10018061846494675,
-0.04019036516547203,
0.4568917155265808,
-0.4243350625038147,
0.13144654035568237,
0.10645941644906998,
0.15496346354484558,
-1.0057607889175415,
0.08658181130886078,
0.2809694707393646,
-0.1233406737446785,
0.44716691970825195,
-0.4012661576271057,
-0.37130826711654663,
-0.0915302038192749,
-0.35175782442092896,
-0.2924046516418457,
0.1710897982120514,
-0.7027719020843506,
0.9268962144851685,
0.41560009121894836,
-0.18116988241672516,
-0.3571453094482422,
-0.4790441393852234,
-0.22788508236408234,
-0.44785305857658386,
-0.3117954134941101,
0.2321939766407013,
-0.030207987874746323,
0.01565992273390293,
-0.05284488946199417,
-0.5995006561279297,
-0.2540929615497589,
-0.15361198782920837,
0.19028516113758087,
0.10168114304542542,
0.09074932336807251,
-0.10734253376722336,
-0.046720147132873535,
-0.4846508800983429,
-0.012552435509860516,
-0.1629914939403534,
0.7278959155082703,
-0.048868030309677124,
0.005555122159421444,
-0.16018278896808624,
0.08155015856027603,
0.4434601366519928,
-0.14375238120555878,
0.47655269503593445,
0.6929550170898438,
-0.2071332335472107,
-0.35074689984321594,
-0.30572709441185,
0.13367950916290283,
-0.5174821615219116,
0.28416648507118225,
-0.6398270130157471,
-0.22736234962940216,
0.5346704721450806,
-0.034673742949962616,
0.10526096075773239,
0.6412879824638367,
0.27158689498901367,
-0.0247418824583292,
0.5711236596107483,
0.209603413939476,
-0.006745781749486923,
0.3118230402469635,
-0.3235553801059723,
-0.04344925656914711,
-0.5509785413742065,
-0.27813297510147095,
-0.6801775693893433,
-0.14637649059295654,
-0.38965311646461487,
-0.3305806517601013,
0.4181234836578369,
-0.2713749408721924,
-0.030230015516281128,
0.29180657863616943,
-0.7495803833007812,
0.9574208855628967,
0.32062068581581116,
0.20439459383487701,
0.5729039907455444,
0.331694632768631,
-0.005463513545691967,
-0.1838475912809372,
-0.4894604980945587,
-0.1980639398097992,
0.936287522315979,
0.26437127590179443,
0.8259469270706177,
-0.011125235818326473,
0.7281420826911926,
0.34214532375335693,
0.5028271675109863,
-0.698203980922699,
0.5250149965286255,
0.13433560729026794,
-0.9078379273414612,
-0.4095326066017151,
-0.695321261882782,
-0.7608057856559753,
0.8936378955841064,
0.0008012517937459052,
-0.16538585722446442,
0.10234761983156204,
-0.08780954033136368,
0.1122351735830307,
0.41966408491134644,
-0.8231378197669983,
1.0166715383529663,
-0.12150879204273224,
-0.612860918045044,
0.2376205027103424,
-0.3530232906341553,
0.2698981463909149,
-0.24957604706287384,
0.07365836948156357,
-0.13001741468906403,
0.04468541964888573,
0.6430343389511108,
-0.6530689001083374,
0.3655904233455658,
-0.4690898656845093,
-0.1943075805902481,
0.34391769766807556,
0.26463913917541504,
0.6274873614311218,
0.0013461803318932652,
-0.014557472430169582,
0.1388925313949585,
-0.17215925455093384,
-0.2679820954799652,
-0.4352005422115326,
0.3608742654323578,
-0.3548274040222168,
-0.32102885842323303,
-0.8481181859970093,
-0.34234675765037537,
-0.018897224217653275,
0.16955360770225525,
0.42767849564552307,
-0.16042178869247437,
-0.20336411893367767,
0.06724248826503754,
0.4155721962451935,
0.029404809698462486,
0.538798451423645,
0.468170166015625,
-0.1362752914428711,
-0.5566469430923462,
1.6038132905960083,
0.5297804474830627,
0.1436954140663147,
0.4621082544326782,
0.5076196193695068,
-0.2877868413925171,
-0.7099072933197021,
-0.4951690137386322,
0.08773253113031387,
-0.472015380859375,
-0.3914130628108978,
-0.4951779544353485,
-0.192927747964859,
0.2577720880508423,
-0.04443468526005745,
-0.6213653087615967,
-0.5628997087478638,
-0.24201752245426178,
-0.44346293807029724,
0.473955363035202,
0.26077479124069214,
-0.17787016928195953,
0.41219255328178406,
-0.7246272563934326,
0.5979066491127014,
0.41148850321769714,
0.38096821308135986,
-0.13848865032196045,
-0.03200153261423111,
-0.02491798810660839,
-0.37583187222480774,
-0.5323060154914856,
-0.9549632668495178,
0.5465500950813293,
0.4192485213279724,
0.4354707896709442,
0.205492302775383,
-0.09520120918750763,
0.9226646423339844,
-0.8571619987487793,
0.4526456594467163,
0.047236498445272446,
-0.8184767961502075,
0.45057380199432373,
-0.5327935814857483,
-0.14053834974765778,
0.5591212511062622,
0.5284372568130493,
-0.3557021915912628,
0.03586798161268234,
-0.5251519083976746,
-0.9125379323959351,
0.5824137330055237,
0.29763591289520264,
-0.45072126388549805,
0.2476816177368164,
0.15023264288902283,
0.49501457810401917,
-0.10893835127353668,
-1.0544164180755615,
-0.1517733633518219,
-0.17070451378822327,
-0.06637006253004074,
0.3049556016921997,
0.10939870029687881,
-0.06624241173267365,
-0.27840882539749146,
0.9863038659095764,
-0.06357445567846298,
0.03522457927465439,
0.1830165833234787,
-0.3839186728000641,
0.01919775828719139,
0.27843740582466125,
0.15849854052066803,
0.4360266327857971,
-0.5227754712104797,
0.11961787194013596,
0.013559084385633469,
-0.9136612415313721,
0.0260627381503582,
0.40051594376564026,
-0.13624580204486847,
0.16281774640083313,
-0.0222933292388916,
0.4251941740512848,
-0.40049538016319275,
-0.22760942578315735,
0.13335764408111572,
0.0471862368285656,
-0.36828121542930603,
-0.09206555783748627,
-0.012073086574673653,
-0.139387845993042,
0.34813645482063293,
0.6685439348220825,
-0.09861833602190018,
0.46756699681282043,
-0.36012575030326843,
0.4667137861251831,
0.5711048245429993,
-0.22818723320960999,
-0.15861299633979797,
0.5403569340705872,
0.038453780114650726,
0.02430291660130024,
0.21592549979686737,
-0.297307550907135,
-0.4672311544418335,
0.29472169280052185,
0.3831155300140381,
0.849822998046875,
-0.11043085902929306,
0.5887993574142456,
0.06902866810560226,
0.341910719871521,
-0.32615095376968384,
0.26947343349456787,
-0.31121960282325745,
-0.5173549652099609,
-0.11314818263053894,
-0.5987675786018372,
-0.6595123410224915,
0.20521660149097443,
-0.4492519795894623,
0.08686405420303345,
-0.5553092360496521,
0.08510182797908783,
0.3998676538467407,
0.27347874641418457,
-0.20967702567577362,
-0.04879205673933029,
-0.2320590615272522,
0.39769110083580017,
-1.0370988845825195,
0.7220423221588135,
0.12337930500507355,
-0.6474051475524902,
-0.532600462436676,
-0.23244008421897888,
-0.03480212390422821,
-0.3610806465148926,
0.3922608494758606,
-0.029302464798092842,
0.0455971360206604,
-0.049485474824905396,
-0.21837881207466125,
-0.8045682311058044,
0.8207938075065613,
0.41263434290885925,
-0.17060121893882751,
0.05013909563422203,
0.5517088174819946,
0.23149563372135162,
0.1944011151790619,
0.4027561843395233,
0.8195162415504456,
0.6741136312484741,
0.16220533847808838,
-0.7126257419586182,
0.08811724931001663,
-0.2490134984254837,
-0.19433777034282684,
0.6254687905311584,
-0.468146950006485,
0.8051255941390991,
0.3186599314212799,
-0.267900675535202,
-0.2980740964412689,
0.3367212116718292,
0.2514401376247406,
0.29868748784065247,
0.19282300770282745,
0.7575550079345703,
0.6458463072776794,
-0.37860342860221863,
0.692297637462616,
0.49434006214141846,
0.7020277976989746,
0.9692680835723877,
-0.6465723514556885,
0.66118985414505,
0.5834029912948608,
-0.5128746032714844,
0.40483492612838745,
0.6042101383209229,
-0.4386173486709595,
0.8220083713531494,
0.18377307057380676,
-0.18867646157741547,
0.11224335432052612,
0.20724409818649292,
-0.5266873836517334,
0.05890475586056709,
0.2815193831920624,
-0.26712146401405334,
-0.7510845065116882,
-0.07533026486635208,
-0.009534128941595554,
-0.43087875843048096,
-0.07422976195812225,
0.6533324122428894,
-0.11859765648841858,
-0.3352987468242645,
0.6185264587402344,
-0.29058536887168884,
0.4588741064071655,
-0.5197041034698486,
-0.31390276551246643,
-0.17112433910369873,
0.3097115159034729,
-0.4842909872531891,
-0.8616382479667664,
0.2956503927707672,
0.05527983605861664,
-0.2975987493991852,
-0.33221006393432617,
0.7806175947189331,
-0.30209073424339294,
-0.3315737545490265,
-0.05672738701105118,
0.5883594751358032,
0.32292863726615906,
-0.4286109209060669,
-0.5146389603614807,
-0.19847947359085083,
0.37064704298973083,
-0.5010144710540771,
0.4081239402294159,
0.42930537462234497,
-0.017088815569877625,
0.4243554174900055,
1.0276479721069336,
0.09139588475227356,
0.13220089673995972,
-0.2803192436695099,
0.847761869430542,
-0.5883039832115173,
-0.3146912157535553,
-0.9974169731140137,
0.684466540813446,
-0.22357822954654694,
-0.2801436483860016,
0.6520713567733765,
1.0699321031570435,
0.39593765139579773,
-0.2546367049217224,
0.6858193874359131,
0.07963595539331436,
0.5617997646331787,
-0.471883088350296,
0.772689163684845,
-0.22067353129386902,
0.20003150403499603,
-0.49530938267707825,
-1.3213504552841187,
-0.47464507818222046,
0.8519350290298462,
-0.04554186016321182,
-0.19525091350078583,
0.8539731502532959,
0.6245212554931641,
-0.32746145129203796,
0.37254488468170166,
-0.11823570728302002,
-0.12421964108943939,
0.6455073356628418,
-0.017037326470017433,
0.4963424503803253,
-0.30810073018074036,
0.9317848682403564,
-0.21534430980682373,
-0.22767262160778046,
0.09935164451599121,
-0.717397153377533,
-0.512980580329895,
-0.18588359653949738,
-0.47723209857940674,
-0.2819339334964752,
-0.0844760462641716,
0.6633377075195312,
0.4343396723270416,
-0.4938073456287384,
-0.2793491780757904,
-0.598973274230957,
0.09234254062175751,
-0.14604657888412476,
-0.3131831884384155,
0.7612316608428955,
-0.283703476190567,
-0.47655293345451355,
0.4259713292121887,
0.24502794444561005,
-0.03606828302145004,
0.10732225328683853,
0.24908098578453064,
-0.2785107493400574,
-0.2784431278705597,
0.5758591890335083,
0.5251386165618896,
0.1437285989522934,
0.12166109681129456,
-0.2511015236377716,
0.16985423862934113,
0.5628026127815247,
0.5250138640403748,
-0.6154026389122009,
0.07479218393564224,
0.5813502073287964,
0.7713714241981506,
1.3506793975830078,
-0.03748659789562225,
0.2227746993303299,
-0.7670819163322449,
-0.1556960940361023,
0.12831950187683105,
0.15756212174892426,
0.1958666294813156,
-0.2079841047525406,
1.165968418121338,
0.5392152070999146,
-0.546521008014679,
-0.9178245663642883,
-0.12327403575181961,
-1.2447439432144165,
-0.2948613166809082,
1.071422815322876,
0.16484923660755157,
-0.3874201774597168,
-0.0007058843621052802,
-0.4172729551792145,
0.3468784689903259,
-0.6296886205673218,
0.6333499550819397,
0.760326623916626,
-0.3753000795841217,
-0.08049192279577255,
-0.7745190858840942,
0.47528311610221863,
0.2467012256383896,
-1.093174695968628,
0.14375446736812592,
0.3537217080593109,
0.41096553206443787,
0.2604331970214844,
0.24005578458309174,
-0.38987553119659424,
-0.038729749619960785,
-0.013986503705382347,
0.12769770622253418,
-0.0640084519982338,
-0.30917248129844666,
-0.08780764043331146,
0.5940229296684265,
-0.39126870036125183,
-0.30562180280685425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05424v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05424v1
|
Recent advancements in computational morphology : A comprehensive survey
| 2024-06-08T10:07:33 | 2024-06-08T10:07:33 |
Jatayu Baxi, Brijesh Bhatt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Computational morphology handles the language processing at the word level.
It is one of the foundational tasks in the NLP pipeline for the development of
higher level NLP applications. It mainly deals with the processing of words and
word forms. Computational Morphology addresses various sub problems such as
morpheme boundary detection, lemmatization, morphological feature tagging,
morphological reinflection etc. In this paper, we present exhaustive survey of
the methods for developing computational morphology related tools. We survey
the literature in the chronological order starting from the conventional
methods till the recent evolution of deep neural network based approaches. We
also review the existing datasets available for this task across the languages.
We discuss about the effectiveness of neural model compared with the
traditional models and present some unique challenges associated with building
the computational morphology tools. We conclude by discussing some recent and
open research issues in this field.
|
[
-0.5045062303543091,
-1.1370137929916382,
0.38700902462005615,
0.26476311683654785,
-0.10724812000989914,
0.3008061945438385,
-0.08298277109861374,
-0.7346370220184326,
0.48236557841300964,
0.408620685338974,
-0.48656508326530457,
-0.41940945386886597,
-0.424953430891037,
0.14738544821739197,
-0.523527204990387,
0.20383325219154358,
0.10410657525062561,
0.04641087353229523,
-0.23635566234588623,
0.2341454029083252,
-0.2678421437740326,
-0.7420687675476074,
-0.8698357939720154,
-0.3523341715335846,
0.33996307849884033,
-0.25847291946411133,
0.6268073916435242,
0.692786455154419,
0.4191957116127014,
0.4511588513851166,
-0.7433760762214661,
0.17625664174556732,
0.2577197253704071,
0.4094042181968689,
0.04767591878771782,
-0.22810065746307373,
-0.5394278764724731,
-0.39297348260879517,
0.682267427444458,
0.9873610734939575,
-0.15739476680755615,
-0.2816648781299591,
-0.04665758088231087,
0.5762965083122253,
-0.7119470238685608,
-0.11754190921783447,
-0.5980159044265747,
0.37111952900886536,
-0.75645911693573,
-0.03770545870065689,
-0.15814392268657684,
-0.03051180951297283,
0.16949141025543213,
-0.01663706824183464,
0.24433757364749908,
-0.5467831492424011,
0.504289984703064,
0.06839967519044876,
0.03537197783589363,
-0.46973520517349243,
-0.6161165237426758,
0.6619288921356201,
-0.83930504322052,
0.7403115034103394,
0.20617683231830597,
0.20638422667980194,
-0.24122697114944458,
-1.091884732246399,
-0.19059810042381287,
-0.3536331355571747,
0.1690671443939209,
-0.1365671306848526,
-0.2528819143772125,
0.15551142394542694,
-0.033601537346839905,
0.707421064376831,
-0.4612194895744324,
0.5782467722892761,
-0.24669182300567627,
-0.5843130350112915,
0.4230589270591736,
0.21457256376743317,
0.6667826771736145,
-0.3913912773132324,
0.1802399605512619,
0.05721874535083771,
-0.6276029944419861,
-0.07279037684202194,
0.4854591190814972,
0.36086028814315796,
-0.15037716925144196,
0.6850042939186096,
-0.167058065533638,
0.8092941641807556,
-0.09414795786142349,
0.10016611963510513,
0.23488354682922363,
-0.4474307596683502,
-0.20415298640727997,
0.049741409718990326,
0.6085904240608215,
-0.18471156060695648,
0.24548396468162537,
-0.1553739309310913,
-0.023505499586462975,
-0.20170937478542328,
0.1918882429599762,
-0.40654876828193665,
0.0629279688000679,
0.17785924673080444,
-0.28882932662963867,
-0.32212719321250916,
-0.5077922344207764,
-0.9351834058761597,
-0.49352937936782837,
-0.2759629786014557,
-0.33334845304489136,
-0.4975939691066742,
-0.5016001462936401,
0.05883939564228058,
-0.025791499763727188,
0.4696207344532013,
0.38552799820899963,
-1.0550625324249268,
0.30686885118484497,
0.8767207264900208,
1.1736758947372437,
-0.4649483263492584,
0.04197048023343086,
0.06955619901418686,
-0.531855046749115,
-0.5209720134735107,
0.9850326776504517,
-0.5807092189788818,
-0.3001123070716858,
0.15465737879276276,
-0.10776994377374649,
-0.14353898167610168,
-0.39420968294143677,
0.409649133682251,
-0.31344619393348694,
-0.029312286525964737,
0.45178887248039246,
-0.4346977472305298,
-0.148214191198349,
0.42079704999923706,
-0.4838695824146271,
0.8763524889945984,
0.146333247423172,
-0.8587402701377869,
-0.11696207523345947,
-0.5396245718002319,
-0.4459823966026306,
0.16649633646011353,
-0.18146683275699615,
-0.11986592411994934,
0.2762202024459839,
0.4139721691608429,
0.3703194558620453,
-0.011950855143368244,
0.2580750584602356,
-0.11682964861392975,
-0.08567279577255249,
0.07894665747880936,
-0.18049763143062592,
1.0192192792892456,
0.3250831067562103,
-0.10228836536407471,
0.2310030460357666,
-0.4862203001976013,
0.24148084223270416,
-0.08938796818256378,
0.032170165330171585,
-0.1649850457906723,
0.08091089874505997,
-0.053211238235235214,
0.0021237197797745466,
0.21089906990528107,
-0.3687334358692169,
0.2050715535879135,
-0.8925332427024841,
0.7114014029502869,
0.4054544270038605,
0.22873160243034363,
0.5473407506942749,
0.07539204508066177,
0.6144640445709229,
-0.25331181287765503,
0.14091776311397552,
-0.21821191906929016,
-0.8176624178886414,
-0.4491921365261078,
-0.21767376363277435,
0.7346241474151611,
0.521432101726532,
-0.4887697696685791,
0.40638968348503113,
-0.051976874470710754,
-0.8298889994621277,
-0.35799655318260193,
-0.23368842899799347,
0.08058275282382965,
0.16970610618591309,
0.07831601053476334,
-0.3328149616718292,
-0.7421526908874512,
-0.967587411403656,
0.08568569272756577,
0.046020761132240295,
0.10954505950212479,
-0.10618457198143005,
0.24306903779506683,
-0.25671297311782837,
0.6878668665885925,
-0.5028772354125977,
0.16803771257400513,
-0.2991129755973816,
0.2320074886083603,
0.08449091017246246,
0.6484351754188538,
0.9237984418869019,
-0.8113892674446106,
-0.30837786197662354,
0.2128625214099884,
-0.30938300490379333,
-0.14708015322685242,
0.203879252076149,
0.03394652530550957,
0.433432400226593,
0.8215625286102295,
-0.6147491931915283,
0.38534659147262573,
0.5632689595222473,
0.03323384374380112,
0.5222457051277161,
-0.0022716426756232977,
-0.06322656571865082,
-0.9522777199745178,
0.05539365112781525,
-0.15231679379940033,
-0.14910095930099487,
-0.7653468251228333,
0.5152387619018555,
-0.22267435491085052,
0.05440014600753784,
-0.6619353890419006,
0.4810924232006073,
-0.3945760428905487,
-0.24404609203338623,
-0.3629457652568817,
-0.12434842437505722,
-0.4630822539329529,
0.2696647644042969,
0.27451473474502563,
0.4843830466270447,
0.7689794301986694,
-0.7406301498413086,
0.3420230448246002,
0.06306379288434982,
-0.1074310690164566,
0.04898947477340698,
-0.5679180026054382,
0.25162431597709656,
0.027837514877319336,
-0.15993191301822662,
-0.777424693107605,
-0.13311907649040222,
0.39985108375549316,
-0.5251771807670593,
0.325222373008728,
-0.15311414003372192,
-0.5172867774963379,
-0.38637542724609375,
-0.4545576572418213,
0.3282807171344757,
0.6397081613540649,
-0.08135141432285309,
0.2532970905303955,
0.5849242210388184,
-0.5079647302627563,
-0.35873255133628845,
-0.7091917395591736,
0.27269813418388367,
-0.08498980104923248,
-0.6993229389190674,
0.697277307510376,
-0.20712953805923462,
-0.36427709460258484,
-0.27728548645973206,
0.13737687468528748,
-0.5116866230964661,
0.12631021440029144,
0.10307586938142776,
-0.06267362087965012,
-0.3380005657672882,
-0.22360336780548096,
0.13521099090576172,
0.17873281240463257,
-0.0215085968375206,
0.02954566664993763,
1.0632660388946533,
0.2669857442378998,
-0.22555282711982727,
-0.23332911729812622,
0.2037462741136551,
0.49829089641571045,
-0.26386797428131104,
0.20292802155017853,
0.6375359892845154,
-0.7163965106010437,
0.00645935395732522,
-0.4016534388065338,
0.13187749683856964,
-0.4056095480918884,
0.5153577923774719,
-0.33998027443885803,
-0.8560122847557068,
0.5675777196884155,
-0.3631290793418884,
0.04579325020313263,
0.5814996957778931,
0.6737039685249329,
0.2423640489578247,
1.0932549238204956,
0.7793232798576355,
0.15204158425331116,
0.6205161213874817,
-0.08207376301288605,
0.09026964753866196,
-0.8093245625495911,
-0.27617204189300537,
-0.8036295175552368,
0.00033560078009031713,
-0.8866639733314514,
-0.40397557616233826,
-0.011353716254234314,
0.10699857771396637,
0.3204917907714844,
0.3761742413043976,
-0.7492561340332031,
0.1349158138036728,
0.21049556136131287,
-0.26362091302871704,
0.026718083769083023,
0.3617129623889923,
-0.40435150265693665,
-0.2085166722536087,
-0.41883549094200134,
-0.21021510660648346,
0.5177680850028992,
0.3687446415424347,
0.2660524845123291,
-0.2517721652984619,
0.42626088857650757,
0.5339693427085876,
-0.23635417222976685,
-0.899961531162262,
0.5907109975814819,
-0.27034011483192444,
-0.3888392746448517,
-0.3342926800251007,
-0.06134309619665146,
-1.0413079261779785,
0.26130181550979614,
-0.21531446278095245,
-0.9037511944770813,
0.22790762782096863,
-0.04083826765418053,
-0.07899946719408035,
0.3027203679084778,
-0.21825289726257324,
0.4817275106906891,
-0.19886061549186707,
-0.013872286304831505,
-0.14434552192687988,
-0.5829793214797974,
0.2511591911315918,
-0.2519732713699341,
0.05740933120250702,
0.05661710351705551,
0.010819602757692337,
0.6553074717521667,
-0.4224945306777954,
0.7122278213500977,
-0.022402392700314522,
-0.39304956793785095,
0.5006767511367798,
0.07692711055278778,
-0.06059085205197334,
-0.17091278731822968,
-0.23686721920967102,
0.31197869777679443,
0.06519105285406113,
-0.15043304860591888,
-0.3244892954826355,
0.6501176357269287,
-0.256352037191391,
-0.2516477704048157,
-0.40101632475852966,
-0.36931613087654114,
-0.26195743680000305,
0.3174313008785248,
0.32922253012657166,
0.38590675592422485,
-0.3506350517272949,
-0.07166154682636261,
0.2503022849559784,
-0.3468138873577118,
0.741655170917511,
-0.11320263147354126,
-0.4881572425365448,
-0.49725961685180664,
0.5872755646705627,
0.20659781992435455,
-0.0972553938627243,
0.33438441157341003,
0.24445787072181702,
-0.15509052574634552,
-1.2063612937927246,
-0.5319778323173523,
0.11918039619922638,
-0.33153945207595825,
-0.13481009006500244,
-0.6503568887710571,
-0.7574321031570435,
-0.809704065322876,
-0.06682964414358139,
-0.34929826855659485,
-0.6392589211463928,
0.09708166122436523,
0.004035844933241606,
0.34423357248306274,
0.9371180534362793,
-0.20131729543209076,
0.13557328283786774,
-0.6295570731163025,
0.21211059391498566,
0.02043258585035801,
0.14454881846904755,
0.1411665827035904,
-0.07473233342170715,
0.14995910227298737,
0.2367984652519226,
-0.21027475595474243,
-0.7960937023162842,
0.4522465765476227,
-0.008700228296220303,
0.5789315104484558,
0.22958779335021973,
-0.46653300523757935,
0.7634578347206116,
-0.40849271416664124,
1.0449737310409546,
0.01256993692368269,
-0.7661911249160767,
0.6119817495346069,
-0.13086490333080292,
0.40087005496025085,
0.13975688815116882,
0.441205233335495,
-0.6449621319770813,
-0.20686358213424683,
-0.4060090184211731,
-1.0009028911590576,
0.318933367729187,
0.32378828525543213,
0.34128379821777344,
-0.13106998801231384,
0.6460458040237427,
0.27531924843788147,
0.14224804937839508,
-0.06867890805006027,
-0.1001240685582161,
0.19103452563285828,
-0.017519397661089897,
0.16682212054729462,
-0.2084193378686905,
0.6995596289634705,
-0.5736468434333801,
0.30239108204841614,
0.1428752988576889,
0.21865956485271454,
0.1399250477552414,
-0.18569518625736237,
0.27625808119773865,
0.32721197605133057,
0.9026737809181213,
0.4863748848438263,
-0.010339022614061832,
-0.08286742866039276,
0.18925358355045319,
-0.9422246813774109,
-0.19971275329589844,
0.08605799823999405,
-0.433898389339447,
0.19691859185695648,
0.6509829759597778,
0.5038917660713196,
0.01720070280134678,
-0.5179811716079712,
0.2458544820547104,
0.17587867379188538,
-0.37920770049095154,
-0.42348915338516235,
-0.07483961433172226,
0.19648949801921844,
-0.04537747800350189,
0.01405525952577591,
0.13415417075157166,
0.4522757828235626,
-0.5081541538238525,
0.06488959491252899,
0.3894132673740387,
-0.5547652840614319,
-0.46942535042762756,
0.0016179351368919015,
0.02511805109679699,
-0.4901394844055176,
0.9254673719406128,
0.022362086921930313,
-0.4840257465839386,
0.7515472769737244,
0.6787864565849304,
0.73017418384552,
-0.4017803370952606,
0.17391669750213623,
0.3034721314907074,
-0.1098170280456543,
0.18562249839305878,
0.32437145709991455,
-0.07801567018032074,
-0.5843194723129272,
-0.6045133471488953,
-0.911867082118988,
-0.3604974150657654,
0.37035658955574036,
-0.12311239540576935,
0.1625199168920517,
-0.4707929193973541,
-0.2709333598613739,
0.3771060109138489,
-0.1619293987751007,
-0.18743930757045746,
0.07643295079469681,
0.45935967564582825,
0.9349443316459656,
-0.272658109664917,
0.34982970356941223,
1.0670746564865112,
-0.17212583124637604,
-0.1144915521144867,
-0.4389641582965851,
0.18514791131019592,
-0.6420068740844727,
0.380238801240921,
-0.03270261734724045,
-0.2867814302444458,
0.020551564171910286,
-0.5400463342666626,
-0.7957859635353088,
0.5993923544883728,
0.30806711316108704,
-0.29723623394966125,
-0.4174783527851105,
0.40035280585289,
0.8050270080566406,
-0.2974708378314972,
0.056270960718393326,
0.43666109442710876,
0.45812711119651794,
0.19096027314662933,
-0.8879905343055725,
-0.296869158744812,
-0.4838874936103821,
0.08714880049228668,
0.46757689118385315,
0.037438225001096725,
1.0404367446899414,
0.17345057427883148,
-0.39135482907295227,
0.6030360460281372,
0.44831961393356323,
0.03130686655640602,
0.007920518517494202,
0.44129064679145813,
0.36595961451530457,
0.5508405566215515,
-0.027961617335677147,
0.8741217851638794,
-0.17430585622787476,
-0.03347869589924812,
0.6238070726394653,
-0.03309275954961777,
0.6736161708831787,
0.3013424873352051,
-0.16345533728599548,
0.37866583466529846,
0.9143973588943481,
-0.15982429683208466,
0.28292232751846313,
0.6476360559463501,
-0.017531724646687508,
-0.11187219619750977,
-0.34520116448402405,
-0.512952983379364,
0.6758189797401428,
0.672337532043457,
-0.2127094715833664,
-0.49442940950393677,
0.03154010325670242,
-0.04022025689482689,
0.1858123242855072,
-0.629061222076416,
0.6874198913574219,
0.0851142480969429,
-0.411472350358963,
0.2684161365032196,
0.10173850506544113,
1.0673929452896118,
-0.6416777968406677,
-0.3567964732646942,
-0.03524487093091011,
-0.06669621914625168,
-0.23512884974479675,
-0.8391052484512329,
0.7377219796180725,
-0.05361265689134598,
0.05832551792263985,
-0.07465874403715134,
1.1142578125,
-0.03663873299956322,
-0.2733258605003357,
0.16992448270320892,
0.8647554516792297,
0.3493804931640625,
-0.32476329803466797,
-0.6560959219932556,
0.15686377882957458,
-0.38428667187690735,
0.1154530942440033,
0.10759614408016205,
0.22450822591781616,
-0.42372262477874756,
0.6271873712539673,
0.5252956748008728,
0.32061636447906494,
0.43372842669487,
0.262759804725647,
0.5774716138839722,
-0.731876790523529,
-0.4013529121875763,
-0.8693059682846069,
0.16780194640159607,
-0.22565118968486786,
-0.12542712688446045,
0.45782917737960815,
0.4315471351146698,
0.7083630561828613,
-0.13960564136505127,
0.47242307662963867,
-0.1311178356409073,
0.3005039095878601,
-0.6261489391326904,
0.7878822684288025,
-0.3851637840270996,
-0.29036223888397217,
-0.3737224042415619,
-1.019162654876709,
-0.7219153642654419,
0.3639238178730011,
0.04206365346908569,
0.02019885554909706,
0.6806025505065918,
0.42394623160362244,
-0.10390413552522659,
-0.011482546105980873,
0.21249878406524658,
-0.13898621499538422,
0.00884182844310999,
-0.10354062169790268,
0.8848345279693604,
0.04690009355545044,
0.13833065330982208,
-0.5283963084220886,
0.20589813590049744,
-0.09603893756866455,
-0.7523442506790161,
-0.6575586795806885,
-0.7550466656684875,
-0.3935440480709076,
0.1559680849313736,
0.08099639415740967,
0.6105242371559143,
0.815403938293457,
-0.7706336379051208,
-0.1839541345834732,
-0.5590190291404724,
0.14936308562755585,
-0.19629359245300293,
-0.24037541449069977,
0.4552193880081177,
-0.4742465019226074,
-0.8304126262664795,
0.43952739238739014,
0.34393027424812317,
0.35752150416374207,
-0.2205757200717926,
0.28159841895103455,
-0.4141707420349121,
-0.13575942814350128,
0.7406433820724487,
0.4143892526626587,
-0.5414597392082214,
0.14322680234909058,
0.10946410894393921,
-0.10594423860311508,
0.2852416932582855,
0.9472863078117371,
-0.5517418384552002,
0.09399718791246414,
0.8761447072029114,
0.7636532783508301,
0.36201727390289307,
-0.39530229568481445,
0.6233431100845337,
-0.5858882069587708,
0.0715446025133133,
0.3244669735431671,
0.3196773827075958,
0.6244543194770813,
-0.42506757378578186,
0.7007961869239807,
0.03570634126663208,
-0.11911282688379288,
-0.7486477494239807,
0.39712730050086975,
-0.9856899380683899,
-0.491123229265213,
0.5328077077865601,
0.3022134602069855,
-0.3900303542613983,
-0.170499786734581,
-0.427335649728775,
0.2814856469631195,
0.13895724713802338,
0.3266601860523224,
0.5761404633522034,
-0.5054578185081482,
-0.3751239478588104,
-0.3218749463558197,
0.5409078001976013,
0.020310113206505775,
-0.8546754717826843,
-0.22371847927570343,
0.35671567916870117,
-0.014667706564068794,
0.606545090675354,
0.6692057847976685,
-0.6003504991531372,
0.06434610486030579,
-0.010569221340119839,
0.14535637199878693,
-0.008412107825279236,
-0.22537225484848022,
-0.5577160716056824,
0.29286396503448486,
0.12925903499126434,
0.10506805777549744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05410v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05410v1
|
MLLM-SR: Conversational Symbolic Regression base Multi-Modal Large Language Models
| 2024-06-08T09:17:54 | 2024-06-08T09:17:54 |
Yanjie Li, Weijun Li, Lina Yu, Min Wu, Jingyi Liu, Wenqiang Li, Shu Wei, Yusong Deng
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Formulas are the language of communication between humans and nature. It is
an important research topic of artificial intelligence to find expressions from
observed data to reflect the relationship between each variable in the data,
which is called a symbolic regression problem. The existing symbolic regression
methods directly generate expressions according to the given observation data,
and we cannot require the algorithm to generate expressions that meet specific
requirements according to the known prior knowledge. For example, the
expression needs to contain $\sin$ or be symmetric, and so on. Even if it can,
it often requires very complex operations, which is very inconvenient. In this
paper, based on multi-modal large language models, we propose MLLM-SR, a
conversational symbolic regression method that can generate expressions that
meet the requirements simply by describing the requirements with natural
language instructions. By experimenting on the Nguyen dataset, we can
demonstrate that MLLM-SR leads the state-of-the-art baselines in fitting
performance. More notably, we experimentally demonstrate that MLLM-SR can well
understand the prior knowledge we add to the natural language instructions.
Moreover, the addition of prior knowledge can effectively guide MLLM-SR to
generate correct expressions.
|
[
-0.02035454660654068,
-1.1603975296020508,
0.568158745765686,
0.2558586001396179,
-0.33484116196632385,
-0.03999524191021919,
-0.15601606667041779,
-0.24687960743904114,
0.05230850353837013,
0.5035498142242432,
-0.8277590274810791,
-0.3173927664756775,
-0.3932165801525116,
0.16467611491680145,
-0.22309939563274384,
0.7947168350219727,
-0.008252731524407864,
0.4415113627910614,
-0.08874143660068512,
0.05160848796367645,
-0.5297690033912659,
-0.7456530332565308,
-0.35453858971595764,
0.01599351316690445,
0.5433956384658813,
-0.06498473137617111,
0.5206144452095032,
0.3725164234638214,
0.6939210891723633,
0.32186973094940186,
0.23710113763809204,
0.4494783580303192,
-0.5543325543403625,
0.47434934973716736,
0.5087891817092896,
-0.40092578530311584,
-0.2521728277206421,
-0.13998278975486755,
0.8235704302787781,
0.41746750473976135,
-0.21430879831314087,
0.36276423931121826,
-0.02907375991344452,
0.7026091814041138,
-0.44962573051452637,
0.4572037160396576,
-0.6868537664413452,
-0.12708881497383118,
0.11845971643924713,
-0.36584335565567017,
-0.6058103442192078,
-0.5744377374649048,
0.05365555360913277,
-0.37115776538848877,
-0.005118065979331732,
0.16028743982315063,
0.8782440423965454,
0.4121949076652527,
-0.4755260944366455,
-0.12909884750843048,
-0.8087438941001892,
1.0395679473876953,
-0.8698549270629883,
0.6184789538383484,
0.23226389288902283,
0.5574819445610046,
-0.3411242365837097,
-0.7247318625450134,
-0.4532611668109894,
-0.9527396559715271,
-0.4541906714439392,
-0.1592249721288681,
-0.12424010038375854,
0.011290001682937145,
0.34050649404525757,
-0.2056436985731125,
-0.6054648160934448,
-0.46507811546325684,
-0.5323625206947327,
-0.18448615074157715,
0.7299596667289734,
0.34035322070121765,
0.2564540207386017,
-0.28777146339416504,
-0.47440025210380554,
0.21772022545337677,
-0.7048748135566711,
0.025388561189174652,
0.09932255744934082,
0.8438597321510315,
-0.2687496542930603,
0.8328366875648499,
-0.07729730755090714,
0.9072116613388062,
-0.4273971617221832,
-0.32875800132751465,
0.18365947902202606,
-0.40119537711143494,
-0.4586843252182007,
-0.002628696383908391,
0.7935498356819153,
0.0678991973400116,
0.35765737295150757,
0.09688878804445267,
-0.2094862014055252,
0.014938894659280777,
-0.011444991454482079,
-0.8992578387260437,
0.04305295646190643,
-0.14585308730602264,
-0.542056679725647,
-0.14710533618927002,
0.16189581155776978,
-0.3076198995113373,
-0.1053541898727417,
-0.866926372051239,
0.3178480863571167,
-0.49457207322120667,
-0.11522677540779114,
-0.0660402849316597,
-0.035902656614780426,
0.09250642359256744,
0.5153546333312988,
-0.2518838942050934,
0.10588795691728592,
0.5216730237007141,
0.8565302491188049,
0.12435726076364517,
-0.23034974932670593,
-0.8269474506378174,
0.16814014315605164,
-0.19542810320854187,
0.2768397629261017,
-0.5582918524742126,
-0.31927862763404846,
-0.1852499544620514,
-0.26296329498291016,
-0.28065893054008484,
-0.15994225442409515,
0.40353500843048096,
-0.3343658447265625,
0.5548651814460754,
-0.10005027800798416,
-0.28052857518196106,
-0.1732160449028015,
0.33945730328559875,
-0.5473986864089966,
1.0927133560180664,
0.4169107675552368,
-0.685514509677887,
-0.05443129315972328,
-0.7798066735267639,
-0.4347415566444397,
0.02927050180733204,
-0.11239989846944809,
-0.33644556999206543,
0.034502625465393066,
0.05864698067307472,
0.42149388790130615,
-0.5516852140426636,
0.6931227445602417,
-0.24738700687885284,
-0.22556215524673462,
0.5150863528251648,
-0.6105732321739197,
0.7782948613166809,
0.21067114174365997,
-0.27505093812942505,
0.3715746998786926,
-0.550137460231781,
0.10508245974779129,
0.07814650982618332,
-0.20694826543331146,
-0.374931275844574,
-0.056166451424360275,
0.20672839879989624,
0.3772725760936737,
0.29021477699279785,
-0.33899468183517456,
0.04286634922027588,
-0.28196096420288086,
0.3482983410358429,
0.7600753903388977,
-0.17872323095798492,
0.008745408616960049,
-0.29894372820854187,
0.4834638833999634,
-0.23033949732780457,
0.34839096665382385,
-0.1610081046819687,
-0.5509280562400818,
-0.8029231429100037,
-0.4619913101196289,
0.20976762473583221,
0.5472708344459534,
-0.6484634876251221,
0.4455908238887787,
-0.12241464108228683,
-0.41951313614845276,
-0.6254619359970093,
0.12565958499908447,
0.3877295255661011,
0.7651327252388,
0.38052815198898315,
0.38713181018829346,
-0.9567778706550598,
-1.0989890098571777,
-0.11626463383436203,
-0.3120090663433075,
-0.05404132977128029,
0.5860270261764526,
0.3380860984325409,
-0.24448993802070618,
1.0347270965576172,
-0.7237529158592224,
-0.29217061400413513,
-0.2884049117565155,
0.28494730591773987,
0.037153616547584534,
0.19001303613185883,
0.5156852602958679,
-1.0027923583984375,
-0.6779760122299194,
0.03612130135297775,
-0.8071447014808655,
-0.1490451842546463,
0.05335894227027893,
-0.12022828310728073,
0.4143674373626709,
0.4351271688938141,
-0.6981794238090515,
0.2404979020357132,
0.6190589070320129,
-0.25868454575538635,
0.7875332832336426,
-0.18720437586307526,
0.14284616708755493,
-1.128595232963562,
0.23540422320365906,
0.251091331243515,
-0.31082022190093994,
-0.7107965350151062,
0.04806665703654289,
-0.08691203594207764,
-0.007146378979086876,
-0.5234560966491699,
0.5674759149551392,
-0.3129916191101074,
0.21838605403900146,
0.051294900476932526,
-0.028678003698587418,
-0.24044562876224518,
0.5314621329307556,
0.12499582022428513,
0.59382563829422,
0.5333527326583862,
-0.5167598128318787,
0.4756719768047333,
-0.041800785809755325,
-0.0515284538269043,
0.35693806409835815,
-0.6918082237243652,
-0.1045604720711708,
-0.31538259983062744,
0.34184888005256653,
-0.9455220699310303,
-0.016858436167240143,
0.26466241478919983,
-0.3391837477684021,
0.04759931564331055,
-0.07193215936422348,
-0.34407687187194824,
-0.35807520151138306,
-0.014380034990608692,
0.16320990025997162,
0.42937901616096497,
0.10537562519311905,
0.9768146276473999,
0.25799497961997986,
-0.3014952838420868,
-0.5886270403862,
-0.3870334029197693,
0.06882847845554352,
-0.3680313527584076,
-0.5551877021789551,
-0.04860972240567207,
-0.2592112720012665,
-0.39583924412727356,
-0.2118738889694214,
0.18157656490802765,
-0.056661397218704224,
-0.18507389724254608,
0.18255582451820374,
0.7535647749900818,
-0.5909538269042969,
0.11200104653835297,
-0.2610623240470886,
-0.1397271603345871,
0.09877829253673553,
0.23669695854187012,
0.74277663230896,
-0.30733630061149597,
-0.40209993720054626,
-0.8249838948249817,
0.37359026074409485,
0.8181463479995728,
-0.14899472892284393,
0.5839241743087769,
0.6791582703590393,
-0.34350964426994324,
-0.03868334740400314,
-0.6527788043022156,
-0.3416774570941925,
-0.4558446705341339,
0.46829453110694885,
-0.5045797228813171,
-0.7511403560638428,
0.062481146305799484,
0.08376090973615646,
0.07083094865083694,
0.3487281799316406,
0.6601352095603943,
-0.048952389508485794,
1.3791204690933228,
0.5536544322967529,
0.04323812946677208,
0.43993687629699707,
0.0522347055375576,
0.3727758228778839,
-0.4900335371494293,
-0.33714061975479126,
-0.6282222270965576,
-0.2679929733276367,
-0.39121076464653015,
-0.5091927647590637,
0.4145943522453308,
-0.12968136370182037,
-0.6248268485069275,
0.35296550393104553,
-0.5037634372711182,
-0.016332214698195457,
0.5999132990837097,
0.22914820909500122,
0.26686233282089233,
-0.08386719971895218,
0.10061816871166229,
-0.2500026822090149,
-0.3433348536491394,
-0.4197595417499542,
0.6794285774230957,
0.29123473167419434,
0.9799667000770569,
0.16259323060512543,
0.3941291868686676,
0.41863492131233215,
0.6303237676620483,
-0.9106032252311707,
0.660887598991394,
-0.11616869270801544,
-0.2313985526561737,
-0.4332740902900696,
-0.8225558996200562,
-0.7775793075561523,
0.3079087734222412,
-0.18504825234413147,
-0.504783034324646,
-0.3927181363105774,
0.057203445583581924,
-0.038613252341747284,
-0.13597047328948975,
-0.8069358468055725,
0.8488467931747437,
-0.6197056770324707,
0.2061985284090042,
-0.1157286986708641,
-0.799228310585022,
0.4812639057636261,
-0.05114349350333214,
0.22310934960842133,
-0.28670933842658997,
0.1930888146162033,
0.5002501010894775,
-0.32226815819740295,
1.013836145401001,
-0.3085685670375824,
0.023919889703392982,
0.1434151828289032,
0.22269050776958466,
0.7529172301292419,
-0.19057685136795044,
-0.02959197759628296,
-0.21467767655849457,
0.15756824612617493,
-0.06810904294252396,
-0.9360629916191101,
0.49945536255836487,
-0.5846676230430603,
-0.5104210376739502,
-0.1394658386707306,
-0.8249019980430603,
-0.20296110212802887,
0.19333192706108093,
-0.1756047010421753,
0.26361796259880066,
-0.3224087059497833,
0.27648523449897766,
0.199879452586174,
0.0032073615584522486,
0.17537085711956024,
0.6940045356750488,
-0.40302523970603943,
-0.2951139211654663,
0.8616153001785278,
-0.00010015567386290058,
0.21741659939289093,
0.5673461556434631,
0.6746931076049805,
-0.44131141901016235,
0.033351924270391464,
-0.4103684425354004,
0.41677045822143555,
-0.27018922567367554,
-0.35354289412498474,
-0.7123172879219055,
-0.4620164930820465,
-0.4503423869609833,
-0.06810548156499863,
-0.17588429152965546,
-0.41355055570602417,
-0.07959277927875519,
0.13276612758636475,
0.32454589009284973,
0.6011734008789062,
0.2963569760322571,
0.14809004962444305,
-0.9454805254936218,
0.5762863159179688,
0.35914483666419983,
-0.11729828268289566,
-0.13391518592834473,
-0.2996600270271301,
0.03333430364727974,
0.6561460494995117,
0.018300173804163933,
-0.8761091828346252,
0.69835364818573,
0.175663024187088,
0.6113502979278564,
0.13134443759918213,
0.29374977946281433,
0.9162209630012512,
-0.3890104293823242,
0.5686718821525574,
0.4376116096973419,
-0.9694768190383911,
0.6513358950614929,
-0.2061142921447754,
-0.01415368914604187,
0.023074932396411896,
0.25119873881340027,
-0.6642758846282959,
-0.5922095775604248,
-0.45732444524765015,
-0.5833780765533447,
0.6564953923225403,
0.3672153055667877,
0.3419221043586731,
0.3400169312953949,
-0.042537931352853775,
-0.0396578274667263,
0.471458375453949,
-0.8418591618537903,
-0.45008593797683716,
-0.07631482928991318,
-0.35617104172706604,
0.12743037939071655,
-0.11632116883993149,
-0.32503941655158997,
-0.4830985367298126,
0.6782718300819397,
-0.18432042002677917,
0.1642642319202423,
-0.07425530254840851,
-0.07757315784692764,
-0.15147608518600464,
0.20006123185157776,
0.98821622133255,
0.7514477968215942,
-0.32663750648498535,
0.06728476285934448,
0.0836523026227951,
-0.336818665266037,
-0.043929845094680786,
0.21974217891693115,
-0.2037057876586914,
0.2429371327161789,
0.1446903645992279,
0.8740435242652893,
0.05563697591423988,
-1.0010194778442383,
0.4647475481033325,
-0.09750212728977203,
-0.07009290903806686,
-0.36850184202194214,
-0.06290023028850555,
0.042066242545843124,
0.1989780068397522,
0.5262250900268555,
0.19326935708522797,
0.003140696557238698,
-0.5024792551994324,
0.3410792648792267,
0.7833876609802246,
-0.5130355358123779,
-0.19435374438762665,
0.5228021144866943,
-0.06541860103607178,
-0.5200492739677429,
0.7711638808250427,
0.18713268637657166,
-0.6593847274780273,
0.6169901490211487,
0.789120614528656,
0.7555317282676697,
-0.3016829490661621,
0.5259485840797424,
0.3869682848453522,
0.19224059581756592,
0.05081552639603615,
0.3415234386920929,
0.11222673207521439,
-0.6306231021881104,
-0.5161712169647217,
-0.7164961099624634,
-0.17407779395580292,
0.051909834146499634,
-0.5343670845031738,
0.4946388006210327,
-0.009774528443813324,
-0.14807608723640442,
-0.0058255926705896854,
-0.24848096072673798,
-0.6173895597457886,
0.08817218244075775,
0.12302933633327484,
0.7039352655410767,
-0.8515578508377075,
0.8135711550712585,
0.38166990876197815,
-0.356950044631958,
-0.9785953164100647,
-0.3394862115383148,
0.006986645516008139,
-1.0825989246368408,
1.1174511909484863,
0.20381098985671997,
-0.30017465353012085,
-0.07565279304981232,
-0.6307137608528137,
-0.921604573726654,
0.8680462837219238,
0.7623911499977112,
-0.3446626365184784,
-0.3106578290462494,
0.22327536344528198,
0.7096736431121826,
-0.6197862029075623,
0.09039732068777084,
0.3602847158908844,
0.7980853915214539,
0.3192129135131836,
-1.0574798583984375,
0.20702818036079407,
-0.2560511827468872,
-0.048225123435258865,
0.4227531850337982,
-0.40525802969932556,
0.9180384278297424,
-0.29487118124961853,
-0.13117343187332153,
0.19402292370796204,
0.5935987234115601,
0.5024193525314331,
0.29829296469688416,
0.48419737815856934,
0.15595775842666626,
0.6084482669830322,
-0.0597413033246994,
0.8135687708854675,
-0.3966841399669647,
0.5255196690559387,
1.0382872819900513,
-0.29236236214637756,
1.0314545631408691,
0.528101921081543,
-0.2830863893032074,
0.6232485175132751,
0.21972967684268951,
-0.08569668233394623,
0.24210354685783386,
0.3411511480808258,
-0.16031987965106964,
-0.47424569725990295,
-0.2675265371799469,
-0.3594651520252228,
0.49197813868522644,
0.4931892156600952,
-0.6201835870742798,
-0.32330209016799927,
-0.06598223745822906,
-0.016434403136372566,
-0.1732678860425949,
0.030499940738081932,
0.5361101627349854,
0.06313533335924149,
-0.5110558867454529,
0.7007748484611511,
-0.0269152969121933,
0.4506824314594269,
-1.1030879020690918,
-0.39619529247283936,
0.10780742019414902,
-0.14874663949012756,
-0.02867230400443077,
-0.5053877234458923,
0.2783772349357605,
-0.1909848153591156,
-0.02887692116200924,
-0.23549716174602509,
0.6656876802444458,
-0.7019162774085999,
-0.8796769976615906,
0.01896793209016323,
0.9296349883079529,
0.12950818240642548,
-0.15084697306156158,
-0.9187591671943665,
-0.10326532274484634,
0.1392936110496521,
-0.24162150919437408,
0.12473544478416443,
0.29302558302879333,
-0.1817626953125,
0.924038827419281,
0.914434015750885,
0.0589238703250885,
0.00546258594840765,
0.19944512844085693,
0.8620539903640747,
-0.542085587978363,
-0.36804813146591187,
-0.9842214584350586,
0.6348583698272705,
-0.043597061187028885,
-0.06955816596746445,
0.7258517146110535,
0.7364482283592224,
0.19235795736312866,
-0.10735061764717102,
0.9198230504989624,
-0.1950327605009079,
0.4825720489025116,
-0.5025068521499634,
0.5248765349388123,
-0.5696961283683777,
0.03897285461425781,
-0.12852197885513306,
-0.9720396995544434,
-0.5546346306800842,
0.6855912804603577,
-0.13580656051635742,
0.09946338087320328,
0.6323897242546082,
1.0000824928283691,
0.044316280633211136,
-0.041464392095804214,
0.46300795674324036,
0.27352526783943176,
0.36954769492149353,
0.23434720933437347,
0.9118027687072754,
-0.20161615312099457,
0.5289344191551208,
-0.2079688310623169,
-0.13324448466300964,
-0.27119874954223633,
-0.8172696232795715,
-0.7577489614486694,
-0.8348643183708191,
-0.0846361592411995,
-0.4889637231826782,
-0.03963668644428253,
1.1433827877044678,
0.7087044715881348,
-0.6962590217590332,
-0.34275975823402405,
0.06026802211999893,
0.263308584690094,
-0.4290124475955963,
-0.34786438941955566,
0.618382453918457,
-0.3787032961845398,
-0.7936992049217224,
0.32334890961647034,
0.20950335264205933,
0.21659135818481445,
-0.5562372803688049,
-0.3520086109638214,
-0.10759437084197998,
0.03507107123732567,
0.9170307517051697,
0.05143841356039047,
-0.9697977900505066,
-0.14413928985595703,
0.2983172833919525,
-0.4037379026412964,
-0.05345110967755318,
1.2336876392364502,
-0.8449198603630066,
0.34867721796035767,
0.5511851906776428,
0.27505409717559814,
0.3481140732765198,
0.20576713979244232,
0.8943543434143066,
-0.8253251314163208,
-0.04976562038064003,
0.34917694330215454,
0.42808982729911804,
0.259755402803421,
-0.3875235617160797,
0.4236277639865875,
0.2965148091316223,
-0.3237304389476776,
-1.0502623319625854,
0.33846941590309143,
-1.1108391284942627,
-0.31214144825935364,
1.2452704906463623,
0.08181194216012955,
-0.06669721007347107,
-0.2760940492153168,
-0.6998754143714905,
0.1899680644273758,
-0.4614204168319702,
0.8855097889900208,
0.32341268658638,
-0.41309282183647156,
-0.3347897529602051,
-0.5390611886978149,
0.4129982888698578,
0.054601579904556274,
-0.7740482687950134,
0.24225831031799316,
0.6929012537002563,
0.02999117411673069,
0.14222483336925507,
0.5753716230392456,
0.22098742425441742,
0.038424860686063766,
-0.14372210204601288,
-0.2838345766067505,
-0.2480081170797348,
-0.2112860083580017,
0.361308753490448,
0.2501612603664398,
-0.08506550639867783,
0.03784242272377014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05392v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05392v1
|
Deconstructing The Ethics of Large Language Models from Long-standing Issues to New-emerging Dilemmas
| 2024-06-08T07:55:01 | 2024-06-08T07:55:01 |
Chengyuan Deng, Yiqun Duan, Xin Jin, Heng Chang, Yijun Tian, Han Liu, Henry Peng Zou, Yiqiao Jin, Yijia Xiao, Yichen Wang, Shenghao Wu, Zongxing Xie, Kuofeng Gao, Sihong He, Jun Zhuang, Lu Cheng, Haohan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved unparalleled success across
diverse language modeling tasks in recent years. However, this progress has
also intensified ethical concerns, impacting the deployment of LLMs in everyday
contexts. This paper provides a comprehensive survey of ethical challenges
associated with LLMs, from longstanding issues such as copyright infringement,
systematic bias, and data privacy, to emerging problems like truthfulness and
social norms. We critically analyze existing research aimed at understanding,
examining, and mitigating these ethical risks. Our survey underscores
integrating ethical standards and societal values into the development of LLMs,
thereby guiding the development of responsible and ethically aligned language
models.
|
[
-0.09767390787601471,
-0.7001113891601562,
0.8044407367706299,
-0.04552217200398445,
-0.07012253254652023,
0.26506713032722473,
-0.3336554765701294,
-0.8019766807556152,
-0.37190601229667664,
1.1267998218536377,
-0.4745568037033081,
-0.03528708964586258,
-0.8005085587501526,
0.07618308067321777,
-0.3289008140563965,
0.8788034915924072,
0.03137475252151489,
0.1348409652709961,
-0.3372880518436432,
-0.27831536531448364,
-0.16600064933300018,
-0.8262238502502441,
-0.6172834634780884,
-0.20008596777915955,
0.5422126650810242,
0.1385953575372696,
0.6826249361038208,
0.6559157371520996,
0.4986715316772461,
0.3635963499546051,
-0.5061274766921997,
-0.01363240648061037,
-0.6770617365837097,
0.24033795297145844,
-0.18646669387817383,
-0.19740121066570282,
-0.382964164018631,
0.25034335255622864,
0.7652761936187744,
0.8442051410675049,
-0.21505695581436157,
0.503525972366333,
0.03967829793691635,
0.6438447833061218,
-0.6249425411224365,
-0.13407002389431,
-0.37315234541893005,
-0.09532712399959564,
-0.27986064553260803,
-0.13758492469787598,
-0.44130939245224,
-0.7077674865722656,
0.099323570728302,
-0.2836630642414093,
-0.3588758409023285,
0.04975537583231926,
0.5026867985725403,
0.055338628590106964,
-0.7368490099906921,
-0.8020665645599365,
-0.8003394603729248,
1.3443903923034668,
-0.7882611155509949,
0.4005151689052582,
0.13952891528606415,
0.18011994659900665,
-0.2959672212600708,
-0.6094169616699219,
-0.4872467517852783,
-0.12463994324207306,
0.32256782054901123,
-0.40439465641975403,
-0.18447601795196533,
-0.22846665978431702,
0.1947069615125656,
0.34903767704963684,
-0.1954014152288437,
0.5078808069229126,
-0.40918731689453125,
-0.051389336585998535,
0.801417887210846,
0.16966058313846588,
0.41999030113220215,
-0.2854763865470886,
-0.27831658720970154,
0.2798665761947632,
-1.128462314605713,
0.11387283354997635,
0.9054986238479614,
-0.021249450743198395,
-0.058136239647865295,
0.4594442546367645,
0.3065457344055176,
0.47457098960876465,
-0.2067839503288269,
-0.10271342843770981,
0.19251525402069092,
-0.27010419964790344,
-0.1456764042377472,
-0.006003053858876228,
0.6494343280792236,
0.5426592230796814,
0.6407460570335388,
0.1834900826215744,
-0.18911002576351166,
-0.40193015336990356,
0.08499721437692642,
-0.4914395213127136,
0.4397306442260742,
0.5589154362678528,
-0.6729012727737427,
-0.5356409549713135,
-0.40526705980300903,
-0.5644319653511047,
-0.6846063137054443,
-0.6086792945861816,
0.052184123545885086,
0.015220850706100464,
-0.5872933864593506,
0.377045214176178,
-0.011151649057865143,
0.6217591762542725,
0.3163827657699585,
-0.46347692608833313,
0.11455430835485458,
1.0330653190612793,
0.48107194900512695,
0.09757545590400696,
0.0792105495929718,
-0.27299100160598755,
0.28470322489738464,
-0.4413864016532898,
0.19569584727287292,
-0.60733962059021,
-0.595535397529602,
0.14498017728328705,
0.26157087087631226,
0.38763636350631714,
-0.5140014886856079,
0.5412194728851318,
-0.4424828588962555,
0.15341387689113617,
-0.440532922744751,
-0.597957968711853,
-0.0983857661485672,
0.4356072247028351,
-0.5212572813034058,
0.7062307596206665,
-0.221877321600914,
-0.7365605235099792,
-0.03554615005850792,
-0.5908471345901489,
-0.20733429491519928,
0.23073619604110718,
-0.3087124526500702,
-0.25655779242515564,
0.1706635057926178,
-0.18179000914096832,
0.6721293330192566,
-0.571456253528595,
0.619231104850769,
-0.27041950821876526,
-0.13356831669807434,
0.4490460157394409,
-0.6057265996932983,
1.4366375207901,
0.3153795897960663,
-0.21515706181526184,
-0.01688707061111927,
-0.8457881212234497,
-0.04467657953500748,
0.36222532391548157,
-0.1539025753736496,
-0.4617796838283539,
0.17705759406089783,
0.09614095836877823,
0.1668563336133957,
0.40123865008354187,
-0.48295509815216064,
-0.13238148391246796,
-0.004023358691483736,
0.8489141464233398,
1.004179835319519,
0.12574760615825653,
0.31517353653907776,
-0.3642268478870392,
0.5460047721862793,
-0.4322233498096466,
0.543684720993042,
0.03978871554136276,
-0.29639509320259094,
-0.5051537752151489,
-0.08041313290596008,
-0.050917498767375946,
0.3685479164123535,
-0.08541280776262283,
0.3885939419269562,
-0.4987260699272156,
-0.4088180661201477,
-0.541824221611023,
0.15110501646995544,
0.13601699471473694,
0.12375196814537048,
0.012057221494615078,
0.14370004832744598,
-0.11545895785093307,
-1.195167899131775,
-0.3278151750564575,
-0.022055363282561302,
0.07399418205022812,
0.5312191843986511,
0.5530927181243896,
-0.38892510533332825,
0.7691025137901306,
-0.02867705374956131,
0.028607714921236038,
-0.23875202238559723,
-0.03520387411117554,
-0.04304517060518265,
0.7169009447097778,
0.3336736559867859,
-0.7625746130943298,
-0.05812954157590866,
-0.03084215708076954,
-0.773669958114624,
-0.023940615355968475,
0.017485231161117554,
0.3036513924598694,
0.177724689245224,
0.655432403087616,
-0.6171593070030212,
-0.0071823145262897015,
0.7260372042655945,
-0.0589895062148571,
0.6411007642745972,
-0.013823910616338253,
0.18235091865062714,
-1.0722569227218628,
0.14776386320590973,
-0.2046000063419342,
-0.1687241494655609,
-0.4565694332122803,
0.4046935439109802,
0.005974131170660257,
-0.06726309657096863,
-0.7089992165565491,
0.5622235536575317,
-0.7027485966682434,
-0.10667333751916885,
-0.2282228171825409,
-0.03564503416419029,
0.004125015810132027,
-0.35039928555488586,
-0.15350212156772614,
0.36266130208969116,
0.5962808728218079,
-0.5001358985900879,
0.6396453380584717,
0.0765320286154747,
-0.47200807929039,
0.5485290884971619,
-0.7320588231086731,
0.2734485864639282,
-0.4154079854488373,
0.31127694249153137,
-0.4229469895362854,
-0.08929826319217682,
0.1641344428062439,
-0.4166312515735626,
0.1382349580526352,
-0.35648491978645325,
-0.7928246855735779,
-0.13610143959522247,
-0.43781429529190063,
0.7968767285346985,
0.8319486975669861,
-0.2508181929588318,
0.5038044452667236,
0.641941249370575,
-0.5098838806152344,
-0.8705052137374878,
-0.6952221989631653,
0.3897877335548401,
-0.3785552978515625,
-0.6432249546051025,
-0.18173503875732422,
0.031900253146886826,
-0.7727904915809631,
-0.16487900912761688,
0.21240422129631042,
0.16247466206550598,
0.3244744539260864,
0.053415991365909576,
-0.005088797304779291,
0.05145200714468956,
-0.15479230880737305,
-0.20471495389938354,
-0.003844636958092451,
0.48643144965171814,
-0.03440367802977562,
0.47701215744018555,
-0.17245814204216003,
-0.36429449915885925,
-0.1191321387887001,
0.623325526714325,
0.594292163848877,
-0.45325300097465515,
0.44307461380958557,
0.24650409817695618,
-0.6206925511360168,
-0.1841355264186859,
-0.9192551970481873,
0.08713634312152863,
-0.5705302953720093,
0.29882803559303284,
0.2367544323205948,
-1.2403236627578735,
0.48595255613327026,
-0.13883404433727264,
0.4430824816226959,
0.09411565214395523,
0.6435306668281555,
-0.10216581076383591,
0.7290178537368774,
0.6907054781913757,
0.03631914034485817,
0.08858972042798996,
-0.032602276653051376,
0.4488188326358795,
-0.8681461215019226,
-0.3787136971950531,
-0.5278316140174866,
-0.06290752440690994,
-0.8209295868873596,
-0.6139276027679443,
0.05854550376534462,
-0.18856166303157806,
-0.3037726581096649,
-0.04211457818746567,
-0.2732376158237457,
0.6622388958930969,
0.08074206113815308,
-0.35596078634262085,
0.6798604726791382,
-0.3580326735973358,
0.26434850692749023,
0.10529566556215286,
-0.21513472497463226,
-0.9859270453453064,
0.8741750717163086,
0.7787075042724609,
1.0374919176101685,
0.309291273355484,
0.6259352564811707,
0.10943697392940521,
0.12301154434680939,
-0.7041828036308289,
0.6724103689193726,
-0.12252764403820038,
-0.9748410582542419,
-0.3356865644454956,
-0.6082316040992737,
-0.9140728116035461,
-0.02987995371222496,
0.18636465072631836,
-0.9661648869514465,
0.2850170433521271,
-0.1074199303984642,
-0.16607548296451569,
0.33510056138038635,
-0.3126150071620941,
0.6113084554672241,
-0.5327649712562561,
-0.5149717926979065,
-0.24658681452274323,
-0.8677343130111694,
0.5227795839309692,
-0.18157441914081573,
0.6434735655784607,
-0.4445686340332031,
0.01727297529578209,
0.698615550994873,
-0.17333856225013733,
0.7638576626777649,
0.13858230412006378,
-0.7070725560188293,
0.3569856286048889,
0.12567873299121857,
0.5471392273902893,
0.10094638168811798,
-0.14705730974674225,
0.09829272329807281,
0.2364732027053833,
-0.4057708978652954,
-0.07801438868045807,
0.9993630051612854,
-0.4596482217311859,
-0.7711860537528992,
-0.47384560108184814,
-0.5262442231178284,
-0.36721381545066833,
0.30169403553009033,
0.062273334711790085,
0.2642905116081238,
-0.29933223128318787,
0.4306834638118744,
1.00400972366333,
-0.734889805316925,
0.41953805088996887,
0.572886049747467,
-0.3015890121459961,
-0.06952913850545883,
0.7241355776786804,
0.07866771519184113,
0.47906234860420227,
-0.2580970823764801,
0.1483471542596817,
-0.30075502395629883,
-0.6825444102287292,
-0.20924121141433716,
0.3795592486858368,
-0.8414178490638733,
0.20943103730678558,
-0.5075481534004211,
-0.22584015130996704,
-0.3535690903663635,
-0.3459702134132385,
-0.6740622520446777,
0.1292075663805008,
-0.3498665392398834,
-0.16714656352996826,
0.313874214887619,
0.8065916895866394,
0.16728255152702332,
-0.03462260216474533,
-0.9729893207550049,
0.03254396468400955,
0.07963687181472778,
0.45385482907295227,
-0.006129669025540352,
-0.36519962549209595,
0.2691095769405365,
0.009415838867425919,
-0.022930379956960678,
-0.33818480372428894,
0.006863935850560665,
-0.36668670177459717,
0.4843798279762268,
0.15426963567733765,
0.01133606769144535,
0.41195040941238403,
-0.7576361298561096,
0.9226365685462952,
0.1460413634777069,
-0.9082568287849426,
0.13064107298851013,
-0.5171594619750977,
-0.08845818787813187,
0.40950915217399597,
0.6214461326599121,
-0.7822452783584595,
-0.3118974566459656,
-0.5385856032371521,
-0.9922094941139221,
0.23556718230247498,
0.27716654539108276,
0.6597667932510376,
0.018952608108520508,
0.30069077014923096,
0.16419222950935364,
0.1910490095615387,
-0.9092637896537781,
-0.02243432216346264,
0.4163137972354889,
-0.19183042645454407,
-0.02527662366628647,
-0.2678140699863434,
-0.1956249475479126,
-0.13936063647270203,
0.4543333947658539,
0.38606998324394226,
-0.15794560313224792,
-0.17941045761108398,
-0.16005268692970276,
-0.1798318773508072,
0.6537419557571411,
0.4416049122810364,
0.8623887300491333,
0.059130024164915085,
-0.0823538601398468,
-0.04281509667634964,
-0.11109992116689682,
0.39331701397895813,
-0.054132238030433655,
-0.07169250398874283,
-0.36406293511390686,
0.2730003595352173,
0.28461477160453796,
0.19896790385246277,
-0.921890377998352,
0.6528028845787048,
0.1958284229040146,
-0.16126081347465515,
-0.6759472489356995,
-0.3636927902698517,
0.5025030970573425,
0.13479457795619965,
0.31948205828666687,
-0.48528406023979187,
0.08944012224674225,
-0.7913196682929993,
-0.0200062096118927,
0.70732182264328,
-0.13232466578483582,
-0.06860792636871338,
0.36589762568473816,
0.4105565547943115,
-0.1704479455947876,
0.4077872633934021,
0.15507417917251587,
-0.3662450909614563,
0.6182372570037842,
0.3428807556629181,
0.6144370436668396,
-0.2022387534379959,
0.08675255626440048,
-0.26672035455703735,
0.6311338543891907,
-0.36895158886909485,
0.2441464215517044,
0.35365989804267883,
-0.6354421973228455,
-0.49878886342048645,
-0.5338525772094727,
-0.5575656890869141,
0.38775813579559326,
-0.6091922521591187,
0.11482036113739014,
-0.5101606249809265,
-0.10669488459825516,
-0.09782718867063522,
0.03330731391906738,
-0.4028908312320709,
0.03364202380180359,
0.2950727343559265,
0.5709335803985596,
-0.4454415738582611,
0.5686559081077576,
0.41523322463035583,
-0.03544248640537262,
-0.3778931200504303,
-0.16958191990852356,
0.1688118577003479,
-0.7876300811767578,
0.4585326015949249,
0.09534920006990433,
-0.4159993529319763,
0.03758401423692703,
-0.8076833486557007,
-0.7679069638252258,
0.8385022282600403,
0.5753161311149597,
-0.7021333575248718,
-0.2151605635881424,
0.5107700228691101,
0.28486350178718567,
-0.05412207916378975,
-0.2727116644382477,
0.5561183094978333,
0.6195562481880188,
-0.19382824003696442,
-0.7924149632453918,
0.10335347801446915,
-0.06217149645090103,
-0.02814112976193428,
0.2792348563671112,
-0.8072482347488403,
0.8296041488647461,
-0.027314038947224617,
-0.20657877624034882,
0.12646496295928955,
0.004877686500549316,
0.3028426170349121,
0.20982007682323456,
0.31326332688331604,
0.21366319060325623,
0.6126638650894165,
0.20198984444141388,
0.9267812967300415,
-0.09917464852333069,
0.3232415020465851,
0.7048506140708923,
-0.6970709562301636,
0.4862178862094879,
0.6563441753387451,
-0.0004012373392470181,
-0.13410870730876923,
0.4840160310268402,
-0.21715939044952393,
-0.1574857085943222,
0.7203263640403748,
-0.12544448673725128,
-0.23563739657402039,
-0.3883306384086609,
-0.468241810798645,
0.386729896068573,
0.5180913209915161,
-0.43992745876312256,
-0.24114662408828735,
-0.03730223327875137,
0.29643765091896057,
0.07897215336561203,
-0.3763340711593628,
0.5307908058166504,
0.39143624901771545,
-0.24916504323482513,
0.2522163689136505,
0.161259725689888,
0.7944862246513367,
-0.46097689867019653,
0.03280963748693466,
0.06525780260562897,
0.04671017825603485,
-0.20763611793518066,
-0.903078019618988,
0.2284190058708191,
0.2732464671134949,
0.18236017227172852,
-0.46437710523605347,
0.5097585916519165,
-0.30595672130584717,
-0.546665370464325,
0.4082460105419159,
0.5949469208717346,
0.05849708989262581,
0.058978207409381866,
-0.5083500146865845,
0.6946662068367004,
-0.2519114911556244,
-0.3316946029663086,
0.36077195405960083,
0.38051366806030273,
-0.05426657944917679,
1.0830851793289185,
0.62177574634552,
-0.0004501938819885254,
0.0866459459066391,
-0.08453133702278137,
0.5010324120521545,
-0.8701391220092773,
-0.1860640048980713,
-0.9643179178237915,
0.4275220036506653,
-0.11343887448310852,
-0.3487510681152344,
0.603257954120636,
0.36956843733787537,
0.545615017414093,
0.10957121849060059,
0.7799989581108093,
0.1492348611354828,
0.40550264716148376,
-0.6151626110076904,
1.1453497409820557,
-0.6323605179786682,
0.5319775938987732,
-0.2091885805130005,
-0.6965146660804749,
-0.11095070093870163,
0.38926857709884644,
-0.1326092630624771,
0.2692667245864868,
0.2967867851257324,
0.4008372724056244,
0.17151670157909393,
0.10635107755661011,
0.2139291912317276,
0.04959072917699814,
0.5691457390785217,
0.3596077561378479,
1.1865150928497314,
-0.10320954024791718,
0.3154248893260956,
-0.1480284333229065,
-0.017100464552640915,
-0.1660279780626297,
-1.3511605262756348,
-0.6110602021217346,
-0.4176236391067505,
-0.36690980195999146,
-0.09880059212446213,
0.12368834763765335,
1.0895147323608398,
0.33968600630760193,
-0.6090089082717896,
-0.4649656414985657,
0.10948294401168823,
0.14673073589801788,
0.23038770258426666,
-0.20245780050754547,
0.0954008474946022,
0.05846666917204857,
-0.7816064953804016,
0.20260222256183624,
0.24787026643753052,
0.18963982164859772,
-0.45131224393844604,
0.06512383371591568,
-0.05533488839864731,
0.4434809684753418,
0.8060608506202698,
0.2547449469566345,
-0.8166847825050354,
-0.553242027759552,
-0.043125178664922714,
-0.2585950195789337,
-0.2460789680480957,
0.831798791885376,
-0.06912156939506531,
0.09396356344223022,
0.15579181909561157,
0.9829365015029907,
-0.1095295175909996,
-0.11828967183828354,
0.7465937733650208,
-0.32933494448661804,
-0.07021305710077286,
0.8137957453727722,
0.41860175132751465,
0.4995424747467041,
-0.40779566764831543,
0.2852227985858917,
-0.07007203251123428,
-0.7565514445304871,
-1.301488995552063,
0.5198653936386108,
-1.0317492485046387,
-0.36766812205314636,
1.427011489868164,
0.09384096413850784,
-0.0468270480632782,
-0.1989574134349823,
0.03241083025932312,
0.05043467506766319,
-0.013501943089067936,
0.542008101940155,
0.9419746994972229,
0.11792990565299988,
-0.24483276903629303,
-0.8804383277893066,
0.38539308309555054,
0.19492186605930328,
-0.7347301840782166,
0.5951035022735596,
0.8351463675498962,
0.6627208590507507,
-0.11723902076482773,
0.4415416121482849,
-0.7392167448997498,
0.025397155433893204,
-0.6247100234031677,
-0.04603300616145134,
-0.027555670589208603,
-0.03992130234837532,
-0.3413250744342804,
-0.024777891114354134,
0.30985283851623535,
0.2784934639930725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10247v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10247v1
|
QCQA: Quality and Capacity-aware grouped Query Attention
| 2024-06-08T07:49:55 | 2024-06-08T07:49:55 |
Vinay Joshi, Prashant Laddha, Shambhavi Sinha, Om Ji Omer, Sreenivas Subramoney
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Excessive memory requirements of key and value features (KV-cache) present
significant challenges in the autoregressive inference of large language models
(LLMs), restricting both the speed and length of text generation. Approaches
such as Multi-Query Attention (MQA) and Grouped Query Attention (GQA) mitigate
these challenges by grouping query heads and consequently reducing the number
of corresponding key and value heads. However, MQA and GQA decrease the
KV-cache size requirements at the expense of LLM accuracy (quality of text
generation). These methods do not ensure an optimal tradeoff between KV-cache
size and text generation quality due to the absence of quality-aware grouping
of query heads. To address this issue, we propose Quality and Capacity-Aware
Grouped Query Attention (QCQA), which identifies optimal query head groupings
using an evolutionary algorithm with a computationally efficient and
inexpensive fitness function. We demonstrate that QCQA achieves a significantly
better tradeoff between KV-cache capacity and LLM accuracy compared to GQA. For
the Llama2 $7\,$B model, QCQA achieves $\mathbf{20}$\% higher accuracy than GQA
with similar KV-cache size requirements in the absence of fine-tuning. After
fine-tuning both QCQA and GQA, for a similar KV-cache size, QCQA provides
$\mathbf{10.55}\,$\% higher accuracy than GQA. Furthermore, QCQA requires
$40\,$\% less KV-cache size than GQA to attain similar accuracy. The proposed
quality and capacity-aware grouping of query heads can serve as a new paradigm
for KV-cache optimization in autoregressive LLM inference.
|
[
-0.46981868147850037,
-0.30369165539741516,
0.422542542219162,
0.1794285774230957,
-0.462963730096817,
0.1790584921836853,
0.020926741883158684,
-0.14091935753822327,
0.266357421875,
0.6339864134788513,
-0.6506398916244507,
-0.346942663192749,
-0.3290625214576721,
-0.18414252996444702,
-0.35685327649116516,
0.4422036409378052,
0.14815440773963928,
-0.16055911779403687,
-0.2635335624217987,
-0.6459693908691406,
-0.4932291507720947,
-0.6239756345748901,
-0.735019326210022,
0.012598689645528793,
0.5604956150054932,
0.22127823531627655,
0.543110728263855,
0.8663308620452881,
0.30004140734672546,
0.1980670690536499,
0.008941815234720707,
0.4941604733467102,
-0.831378161907196,
0.28447064757347107,
-0.02797412872314453,
-0.4145577549934387,
-0.5640290379524231,
-0.10500364750623703,
0.7097570896148682,
0.22146442532539368,
-0.3231393098831177,
0.1813199669122696,
0.07448136061429977,
1.168871521949768,
-1.0270804166793823,
-0.04184293746948242,
-1.063024640083313,
-0.023400578647851944,
0.012997768819332123,
-0.32321539521217346,
-0.4456009268760681,
-0.46859654784202576,
-0.07222863286733627,
-0.7113441824913025,
0.4019090533256531,
0.23378339409828186,
0.8502125144004822,
0.7649644613265991,
-0.36141133308410645,
0.0456402413547039,
-0.3425337076187134,
1.0001541376113892,
-0.4182969033718109,
0.572105348110199,
0.5609908103942871,
0.2135741412639618,
-0.22995838522911072,
-0.6379955410957336,
-0.5408321619033813,
0.3040301501750946,
0.08434081822633743,
0.39642333984375,
-0.17252661287784576,
0.060969654470682144,
-0.05516021326184273,
0.5931371450424194,
-0.7273351550102234,
0.02999272011220455,
-0.23098108172416687,
-0.29775744676589966,
0.6517723798751831,
0.31278666853904724,
0.028549963608384132,
0.2848939001560211,
-0.1617722064256668,
0.015234368853271008,
-0.7665085196495056,
0.000344983913237229,
0.02606290392577648,
0.1677665263414383,
0.2120998203754425,
0.27213478088378906,
-0.7144754528999329,
0.6245235204696655,
0.521004319190979,
-0.12442263215780258,
-0.059100378304719925,
-0.6181087493896484,
-0.37985867261886597,
-0.12136596441268921,
0.8555118441581726,
0.24597665667533875,
0.07749916613101959,
-0.3810455799102783,
-0.07279882580041885,
-0.04360727593302727,
0.4085373282432556,
-0.7914814949035645,
-0.40448233485221863,
0.3991808593273163,
-0.520571231842041,
-0.10920993983745575,
-0.3872814476490021,
-0.668300449848175,
0.13412150740623474,
-0.14162851870059967,
0.578857421875,
-0.1527729630470276,
0.08417172729969025,
0.04692942649126053,
0.06062692031264305,
0.25151100754737854,
0.36468175053596497,
-1.2250899076461792,
0.08578570932149887,
0.21250326931476593,
0.714839518070221,
-0.3933950960636139,
-0.013431953266263008,
-0.798725962638855,
0.4064009189605713,
-0.2111823707818985,
0.8621734976768494,
-0.3661934733390808,
-0.28067004680633545,
-0.38705646991729736,
-0.19470857083797455,
-0.18253900110721588,
-0.513390302658081,
0.2644348442554474,
-0.9554277658462524,
0.13065458834171295,
-0.5684924125671387,
-0.38321951031684875,
-0.29980653524398804,
0.12195799499750137,
-0.8791700601577759,
1.1516520977020264,
0.48611998558044434,
-0.5289762020111084,
0.6194796562194824,
-0.06775281578302383,
-0.17973946034908295,
0.1954655647277832,
-0.29404258728027344,
-0.44754093885421753,
0.16050133109092712,
0.6127272248268127,
0.315611869096756,
-0.4418000876903534,
0.08986826241016388,
-0.12843085825443268,
-0.35146790742874146,
-0.04144174978137016,
-0.05001410096883774,
0.5680132508277893,
0.15497349202632904,
-0.3486919105052948,
0.26123371720314026,
-0.49008339643478394,
0.6214805841445923,
0.01060014683753252,
-0.6282580494880676,
-0.21812604367733002,
0.1626494824886322,
-0.29435113072395325,
0.15689553320407867,
0.161241814494133,
0.09403835237026215,
0.3388732969760895,
-0.24288778007030487,
0.6338379979133606,
0.6323010325431824,
0.046811819076538086,
0.532132089138031,
-0.3867538273334503,
0.5388372540473938,
-0.1281752586364746,
0.3669239580631256,
0.20097006857395172,
-0.2861345410346985,
-0.9320970773696899,
-0.3723641335964203,
0.3507547676563263,
0.273383229970932,
-0.8602649569511414,
0.44426682591438293,
-0.20364931225776672,
-0.43088167905807495,
-0.5958357453346252,
0.25881996750831604,
0.4653790593147278,
0.317399799823761,
0.44486525654792786,
-0.7155489921569824,
-0.08624850958585739,
-1.004823923110962,
-0.1039041131734848,
-0.48408669233322144,
0.15520574152469635,
0.5144960284233093,
-0.0624484047293663,
0.07200009375810623,
0.8890566825866699,
-0.4242883026599884,
-0.09261690080165863,
-0.09571641683578491,
-0.0663524940609932,
-0.14983612298965454,
0.30547666549682617,
0.48564136028289795,
-0.8436242938041687,
-0.43828052282333374,
-0.22321069240570068,
-0.29956570267677307,
-0.15699635446071625,
-0.10342498123645782,
-0.6435794830322266,
0.36276668310165405,
0.29007744789123535,
-0.5689049363136292,
0.19446779787540436,
0.6611608862876892,
-0.04472694173455238,
0.5976500511169434,
0.2148006707429886,
0.2514691948890686,
-0.9879964590072632,
-0.13840815424919128,
-0.177957683801651,
-0.16979484260082245,
-0.3045228123664856,
0.1633225977420807,
0.40838107466697693,
0.42244765162467957,
-0.3444378077983856,
0.6474480032920837,
-0.6330981850624084,
-0.10748079419136047,
-0.3298770785331726,
-0.02818562649190426,
0.2700203061103821,
0.8933941125869751,
-0.200461283326149,
1.1217604875564575,
0.275460809469223,
-1.0047982931137085,
0.11651433259248734,
0.19249284267425537,
-0.11934330314397812,
0.30386465787887573,
-0.38837316632270813,
0.17013682425022125,
0.08232103288173676,
0.2156497687101364,
-1.0849730968475342,
-0.32075992226600647,
0.04806765913963318,
-0.7019850611686707,
0.35506048798561096,
-0.04788650572299957,
-0.5425282120704651,
-0.35232609510421753,
-0.2513435482978821,
0.9007382392883301,
0.5921168327331543,
-0.7273723483085632,
0.6480941772460938,
0.564470648765564,
0.06205163151025772,
-0.6281124353408813,
-0.5691685080528259,
-0.23045623302459717,
-0.3482116162776947,
-0.5231450200080872,
0.3735769987106323,
0.03890596702694893,
0.18047818541526794,
-0.0007050011190585792,
-0.3041524291038513,
-0.46251925826072693,
-0.10431861877441406,
-0.1876230686903,
-0.002617675345391035,
-0.245263010263443,
0.5816417932510376,
0.2959102988243103,
0.09216924011707306,
-0.07524614781141281,
-0.5836352705955505,
0.5908583998680115,
0.027230409905314445,
-0.05858735367655754,
-0.40805742144584656,
0.3186549246311188,
0.7539530992507935,
-0.5688682794570923,
0.7748245596885681,
0.6335827708244324,
-0.23008112609386444,
-0.158530592918396,
-1.0461792945861816,
-0.3111419677734375,
-0.48619556427001953,
0.34726935625076294,
-0.16049857437610626,
-1.3645890951156616,
0.6458409428596497,
0.29128241539001465,
-0.014598214067518711,
0.6964858770370483,
0.866382360458374,
0.12443067878484726,
0.9420519471168518,
0.3161163926124573,
-0.4733375012874603,
0.1881197988986969,
-0.04197484627366066,
-0.03528696298599243,
-1.1710221767425537,
-0.12770679593086243,
-0.47041529417037964,
-0.2861810624599457,
-0.5799067616462708,
-0.5747926235198975,
0.3703998029232025,
0.2699141502380371,
-0.3673790991306305,
0.15713633596897125,
-0.9472251534461975,
0.3181701600551605,
0.7651407122612,
0.24401982128620148,
0.298360675573349,
0.07573769986629486,
-0.03614067658782005,
-0.0623151957988739,
-0.9629100561141968,
-0.09801305085420609,
1.0978432893753052,
-0.20472432672977448,
0.7558096051216125,
0.21693752706050873,
0.4630635380744934,
0.2262456715106964,
0.123601995408535,
-0.9153789281845093,
0.5260719656944275,
0.013903763145208359,
-0.5291236639022827,
-0.3940650224685669,
-0.69340980052948,
-0.9915879368782043,
0.4627414047718048,
0.08530914038419724,
-0.7848175764083862,
0.2099546194076538,
0.5409473180770874,
-0.6361289620399475,
0.10354158282279968,
-0.412602961063385,
0.5659158229827881,
-0.1658676415681839,
-0.6211503148078918,
-0.31860366463661194,
-0.4180601239204407,
0.6575879454612732,
-0.28077980875968933,
-0.2862533926963806,
-0.015060395933687687,
-0.20871171355247498,
0.6269336938858032,
-0.338153213262558,
0.5066480040550232,
0.06775011867284775,
0.11977587640285492,
0.5613293647766113,
-0.15883468091487885,
0.647900402545929,
0.1255817413330078,
0.08838740736246109,
-0.1717386096715927,
-0.2705032527446747,
-0.6847919225692749,
-0.5225241780281067,
0.7158608436584473,
-0.6417264342308044,
-0.7193126082420349,
-0.09170868247747421,
-0.5253146290779114,
-0.3517247438430786,
0.07028180360794067,
0.4287172257900238,
0.2391832321882248,
0.13494367897510529,
0.2069728672504425,
0.9338556528091431,
-0.16336289048194885,
0.514631986618042,
0.3878431022167206,
0.09991712123155594,
-0.652633011341095,
0.7620963454246521,
0.06290088593959808,
0.6074174642562866,
0.29895228147506714,
-0.08216885477304459,
-0.39017122983932495,
-0.8678088188171387,
-0.5846642255783081,
0.20762543380260468,
-0.3862400949001312,
-0.3938262462615967,
-1.0623990297317505,
-0.26822134852409363,
-0.2408601939678192,
0.0459853895008564,
-0.5481336116790771,
-0.5925413966178894,
-0.3744870126247406,
0.44250962138175964,
0.403293639421463,
-0.0897260308265686,
0.20029009878635406,
0.6841274499893188,
-0.9939107298851013,
0.2765686511993408,
0.7667403221130371,
0.15198072791099548,
0.322094589471817,
-0.5262442231178284,
-0.4740956723690033,
-0.20389743149280548,
-0.6088519096374512,
-0.7054199576377869,
0.6090852618217468,
0.26693591475486755,
0.7179518342018127,
0.40401285886764526,
0.09825557470321655,
0.6118227243423462,
-0.22579680383205414,
0.6425198316574097,
0.07466867566108704,
-0.7590146064758301,
0.37816786766052246,
-0.4629235863685608,
0.590633749961853,
0.9046647548675537,
0.19689279794692993,
-0.2846122682094574,
-0.4965854287147522,
-0.4398159384727478,
-0.9786090850830078,
0.5369364619255066,
0.4231414496898651,
-0.08341294527053833,
-0.027750570327043533,
0.6550397872924805,
-0.16026705503463745,
0.3454403579235077,
-0.6796908378601074,
-0.016802111640572548,
0.003440891858190298,
-0.04417937248945236,
0.3984822928905487,
-0.21332168579101562,
0.08413436263799667,
-0.21818459033966064,
0.7917546033859253,
-0.4098832905292511,
0.38943594694137573,
0.18023978173732758,
0.10368452966213226,
-0.23156511783599854,
0.057305801659822464,
0.3693006634712219,
0.6681001782417297,
-0.057806238532066345,
-0.24154514074325562,
0.19008690118789673,
-0.58186274766922,
0.21217967569828033,
-0.19427034258842468,
-0.04484858736395836,
-0.23476006090641022,
0.049238163977861404,
0.582962691783905,
-0.2024865746498108,
-0.4798367917537689,
0.13724084198474884,
-0.3405746519565582,
-0.2038264125585556,
0.08754266053438187,
0.45990321040153503,
0.2974618375301361,
0.33019521832466125,
0.5438220500946045,
-0.3678573966026306,
0.22395963966846466,
-0.25715208053588867,
0.15195214748382568,
0.6643604636192322,
-0.2868541181087494,
0.05231363698840141,
0.7627093195915222,
0.11367056518793106,
0.14919523894786835,
0.7546948194503784,
-0.42506152391433716,
-0.6248529553413391,
0.8579700589179993,
0.10707245022058487,
0.9675676822662354,
-0.5593230724334717,
-0.15052376687526703,
0.620352566242218,
0.43255385756492615,
-0.32346779108047485,
0.3084758222103119,
-0.04926983267068863,
-0.7603523135185242,
-0.6304864287376404,
-0.7752686142921448,
-0.28444671630859375,
0.3691372573375702,
-0.9186155796051025,
-0.16677822172641754,
-0.1867201030254364,
-0.2616617679595947,
-0.24976734817028046,
-0.01627582311630249,
-0.5048267245292664,
0.5741929411888123,
-0.30439576506614685,
0.4497148394584656,
-0.2570915222167969,
0.9646984338760376,
0.30654072761535645,
-0.031473804265260696,
-0.8940902352333069,
0.2181147336959839,
0.05710740014910698,
-0.9667015075683594,
0.46251022815704346,
0.13084591925144196,
-0.03075343556702137,
0.24514584243297577,
-0.4332330524921417,
-1.2422728538513184,
1.2684619426727295,
0.037117231637239456,
-0.8099303245544434,
0.009513691067695618,
-0.29187044501304626,
0.21790657937526703,
-0.37711888551712036,
-0.00876226369291544,
0.4660904109477997,
0.28167209029197693,
0.28543683886528015,
-0.770420253276825,
0.17252160608768463,
-0.008252358995378017,
0.0758894607424736,
0.6081727743148804,
-1.4678460359573364,
0.845531702041626,
-0.06608517467975616,
-0.34954550862312317,
0.009517389349639416,
0.8017502427101135,
0.4931463301181793,
0.00997752696275711,
0.4754467308521271,
0.7949250340461731,
0.7714225649833679,
-0.07645614445209503,
0.8943905234336853,
-0.22276130318641663,
0.268019437789917,
1.2320911884307861,
-0.02689911425113678,
0.6757454872131348,
0.36486029624938965,
-0.2522534430027008,
-0.010602396912872791,
1.0471827983856201,
0.09473467618227005,
0.8329365849494934,
0.258653461933136,
-0.4414646327495575,
-0.4841112196445465,
0.1431913524866104,
-0.41358909010887146,
0.43847161531448364,
0.4275904595851898,
-0.3927370607852936,
0.05024110898375511,
-0.49339759349823,
-0.33701634407043457,
-0.343791127204895,
-0.4398442208766937,
0.7693687081336975,
-0.049629803746938705,
-0.8503970503807068,
0.923768162727356,
-0.1826019287109375,
0.4964762032032013,
-0.2734353542327881,
0.25520390272140503,
-0.555830180644989,
-0.08483751863241196,
-0.03904642537236214,
-0.20898909866809845,
0.08979122340679169,
-0.33159494400024414,
-0.5642717480659485,
0.3693090081214905,
0.54930579662323,
-0.45126059651374817,
-0.315878301858902,
0.13788892328739166,
0.523039698600769,
0.04803077504038811,
-0.48995739221572876,
-0.5087651014328003,
0.004573456477373838,
0.24816922843456268,
-0.4341745674610138,
0.5911081433296204,
0.5095942616462708,
-0.1681685596704483,
0.7569069266319275,
0.4588768184185028,
-0.09466807544231415,
0.23421117663383484,
-0.12647728621959686,
1.1902786493301392,
-0.6261098384857178,
-0.5363605618476868,
-0.7703049778938293,
0.21026946604251862,
0.021116724237799644,
-0.3110712766647339,
0.39827874302864075,
0.5474801063537598,
0.544221043586731,
0.19918213784694672,
0.8064954876899719,
0.2876284122467041,
0.12504228949546814,
-0.8486791849136353,
0.9163292050361633,
-0.9330630302429199,
0.014728138223290443,
0.056665223091840744,
-1.204622507095337,
-0.06507451087236404,
0.40532729029655457,
0.17243756353855133,
0.2620394825935364,
0.8216989636421204,
0.7279457449913025,
-0.0489422045648098,
-0.12531715631484985,
0.3027772605419159,
0.02021127939224243,
0.18343693017959595,
0.9593227505683899,
0.5186812877655029,
-0.387492835521698,
0.7830984592437744,
0.11920616775751114,
-0.27925509214401245,
-0.2756541669368744,
-0.6252723932266235,
-0.8891454935073853,
-0.48507407307624817,
-0.42229321599006653,
-0.2538416385650635,
0.24963374435901642,
0.3894627094268799,
0.8471367955207825,
-0.6360102891921997,
0.20768572390079498,
-0.15398426353931427,
-0.21806156635284424,
-0.16215050220489502,
-0.2981503903865814,
0.5798022150993347,
-0.5728747248649597,
-0.5873951315879822,
0.17987562716007233,
0.5395309329032898,
0.06314218044281006,
-0.28661826252937317,
-0.05529281497001648,
-0.16038630902767181,
0.21264925599098206,
0.5227112770080566,
0.3191544711589813,
-0.9003499150276184,
-0.1556246131658554,
0.02910616062581539,
-0.3918144106864929,
0.20993642508983612,
0.5796958804130554,
-0.9270397424697876,
0.4594689607620239,
0.2868983745574951,
0.9685433506965637,
0.701693058013916,
0.1534118354320526,
0.6119493842124939,
-0.5995345115661621,
0.1390385776758194,
0.4387547969818115,
0.0601317472755909,
0.10389880836009979,
-0.6500206589698792,
0.6682015061378479,
0.102334164083004,
-0.953961968421936,
-0.45320746302604675,
0.21350416541099548,
-1.2205795049667358,
-0.05981406942009926,
1.04735267162323,
0.024120699614286423,
-0.23791222274303436,
-0.028599169105291367,
0.03769475221633911,
0.27137237787246704,
-0.6550661325454712,
1.1581084728240967,
0.9215895533561707,
-0.2724680006504059,
-0.5377584099769592,
-0.5857027769088745,
0.6295696496963501,
0.8201907873153687,
-0.9198459982872009,
0.07645856589078903,
0.5855690240859985,
-0.22083672881126404,
-0.11988814175128937,
0.7994577884674072,
-0.08977680653333664,
0.5657955408096313,
-0.168332040309906,
0.09376491606235504,
0.24576792120933533,
-0.12852051854133606,
0.19705359637737274,
0.12992560863494873,
-0.01382419839501381,
-0.31651613116264343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05374v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05374v1
|
Planning Like Human: A Dual-process Framework for Dialogue Planning
| 2024-06-08T06:52:47 | 2024-06-08T06:52:47 |
Tao He, Lizi Liao, Yixin Cao, Yuanxing Liu, Ming Liu, Zerui Chen, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In proactive dialogue, the challenge lies not just in generating responses
but in steering conversations toward predetermined goals, a task where Large
Language Models (LLMs) typically struggle due to their reactive nature.
Traditional approaches to enhance dialogue planning in LLMs, ranging from
elaborate prompt engineering to the integration of policy networks, either face
efficiency issues or deliver suboptimal performance. Inspired by the
dualprocess theory in psychology, which identifies two distinct modes of
thinking - intuitive (fast) and analytical (slow), we propose the Dual-Process
Dialogue Planning (DPDP) framework. DPDP embodies this theory through two
complementary planning systems: an instinctive policy model for familiar
contexts and a deliberative Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) mechanism for
complex, novel scenarios. This dual strategy is further coupled with a novel
two-stage training regimen: offline Reinforcement Learning for robust initial
policy model formation followed by MCTS-enhanced on-the-fly learning, which
ensures a dynamic balance between efficiency and strategic depth. Our empirical
evaluations across diverse dialogue tasks affirm DPDP's superiority in
achieving both high-quality dialogues and operational efficiency, outpacing
existing methods.
|
[
-0.5496407151222229,
-0.7039299011230469,
0.632924497127533,
0.18036064505577087,
-0.09589886665344238,
0.52579265832901,
-0.2813514471054077,
-0.17364777624607086,
0.32820358872413635,
0.5217902660369873,
-0.9913360476493835,
0.04327061027288437,
-0.10893619805574417,
-0.15574383735656738,
0.3889438807964325,
0.5886870622634888,
0.012014860287308693,
0.31700649857521057,
0.43068063259124756,
0.07205480337142944,
-0.3807516098022461,
-0.3962734341621399,
-1.119891881942749,
-0.44602906703948975,
0.5077250599861145,
0.5150802135467529,
0.9201560020446777,
0.04126958176493645,
-0.007080459501594305,
0.21302808821201324,
0.03794635459780693,
0.36158397793769836,
-0.37657952308654785,
0.2525339126586914,
-0.4326184093952179,
-0.20738115906715393,
-0.4509575068950653,
0.07015624642372131,
0.3002856969833374,
0.6056804060935974,
-0.45186927914619446,
-0.2676050662994385,
0.0971965566277504,
0.5277474522590637,
-0.41174882650375366,
0.345628947019577,
-0.6158804297447205,
0.26350927352905273,
0.37472885847091675,
-0.3365668058395386,
-0.04142870008945465,
-0.023460816591978073,
0.42927947640419006,
-0.3345552384853363,
-0.07788757979869843,
-0.23113366961479187,
0.011080514639616013,
0.06639173626899719,
-0.4054596722126007,
-0.23548392951488495,
-0.99184650182724,
0.3838973045349121,
-0.5933418869972229,
0.15478229522705078,
0.29593250155448914,
0.3311299979686737,
-0.5729641914367676,
-0.5564175844192505,
-0.8690122961997986,
-0.09467054903507233,
0.09233081340789795,
0.08666020631790161,
0.09072621911764145,
0.6414231657981873,
0.4360424280166626,
-0.0013521822402253747,
-0.47572124004364014,
0.15755699574947357,
0.07129142433404922,
-0.11512365937232971,
0.7593543529510498,
0.18046818673610687,
-0.07676061242818832,
0.0770016461610794,
-0.31899917125701904,
-0.14328181743621826,
-0.35283800959587097,
0.2840118408203125,
0.43973585963249207,
0.3497537672519684,
0.1072116270661354,
0.27438831329345703,
-0.5219206213951111,
0.33790090680122375,
-0.0016873145941644907,
-0.1267985850572586,
-0.29309558868408203,
-0.4478307366371155,
-0.14870613813400269,
-0.04481850564479828,
0.737034022808075,
0.31342998147010803,
0.26994332671165466,
-0.07499801367521286,
-0.34464237093925476,
0.3358422815799713,
0.2846134901046753,
-0.7290105819702148,
-0.26432114839553833,
0.16064085066318512,
-0.14882351458072662,
-0.31617632508277893,
-0.4584299325942993,
-0.8674348592758179,
-0.28551456332206726,
-0.4927763044834137,
0.23083415627479553,
-0.15481561422348022,
-0.6018579602241516,
0.2060418277978897,
0.0650804415345192,
-0.10878205299377441,
0.306216299533844,
-1.1199588775634766,
0.6314684748649597,
0.567803144454956,
0.46314916014671326,
0.36521631479263306,
-0.17904050648212433,
-0.523693859577179,
0.11670716851949692,
-0.4865756630897522,
0.81038498878479,
-0.5845430493354797,
-0.5408462285995483,
0.11751268804073334,
-0.4475431442260742,
-0.06140610948204994,
-0.41944003105163574,
0.7262430191040039,
-0.3242287337779999,
0.25643008947372437,
-0.35490307211875916,
0.08207419514656067,
-0.29577457904815674,
0.4492449164390564,
-0.40569257736206055,
0.9760783910751343,
0.19931553304195404,
-0.5975159406661987,
0.5433804392814636,
-0.9764896631240845,
-0.34920498728752136,
-0.15295054018497467,
-0.5175089836120605,
0.039280958473682404,
-0.09479817748069763,
0.07643558084964752,
0.4060228168964386,
-0.3817169666290283,
0.7219089269638062,
-0.4235197901725769,
-0.19507864117622375,
0.17880967259407043,
-0.35975658893585205,
0.539188027381897,
0.12100735306739807,
-0.438480943441391,
0.39353567361831665,
-0.6042290329933167,
0.31158962845802307,
0.1811933070421219,
-0.30197787284851074,
0.10128618031740189,
0.33956965804100037,
-0.23779551684856415,
0.8227186799049377,
-0.12249365448951721,
-0.4975303113460541,
0.4869518578052521,
-0.5348033308982849,
0.7087266445159912,
0.5780772566795349,
0.03242361918091774,
0.5753037333488464,
-0.3914615213871002,
0.47134748101234436,
-0.16818423569202423,
0.11587247997522354,
-0.0462048165500164,
-0.38457807898521423,
-0.7081784009933472,
-0.058150194585323334,
-0.2916904091835022,
0.7512726187705994,
-0.8854092955589294,
0.2755522131919861,
-0.09289918839931488,
-0.20736277103424072,
-0.16436712443828583,
-0.2010047733783722,
0.4681188464164734,
0.2904769480228424,
0.14242783188819885,
-0.7083722352981567,
-0.6110134720802307,
-0.7340304255485535,
-0.18542681634426117,
-0.6781641244888306,
0.02368319034576416,
0.1894315928220749,
0.23969274759292603,
-0.18222464621067047,
1.02533757686615,
-0.37302228808403015,
-0.1665342152118683,
-0.7617655396461487,
0.49926674365997314,
0.0902772843837738,
0.12337668240070343,
0.11267153918743134,
-0.8553772568702698,
-0.5420096516609192,
-0.47484520077705383,
-0.3020564019680023,
-0.02838859334588051,
-0.3680140972137451,
-0.19136036932468414,
0.2478698194026947,
0.1342398077249527,
-0.7737798094749451,
0.5417528748512268,
0.2582527697086334,
-0.25451430678367615,
0.6309085488319397,
-0.315816193819046,
0.05063512921333313,
-0.8742642998695374,
-0.1580701321363449,
-0.19448937475681305,
-0.19932875037193298,
-0.8721189498901367,
-0.15215614438056946,
-0.25379329919815063,
-0.34609928727149963,
-0.3147227168083191,
0.4666209816932678,
-0.25830796360969543,
-0.21252208948135376,
-0.26132386922836304,
-0.07059598714113235,
-0.0598987340927124,
1.1697947978973389,
0.5389711260795593,
0.7327494025230408,
0.1970079094171524,
-0.5304811596870422,
0.39173874258995056,
0.3140551447868347,
-0.4533502459526062,
0.6160860657691956,
-0.39707767963409424,
0.11715319752693176,
0.009415043517947197,
0.8236854672431946,
-0.7366043329238892,
-0.13273972272872925,
0.477761834859848,
-0.010997901670634747,
0.5338696837425232,
-0.07178609818220139,
-0.5271546244621277,
-0.5215252637863159,
-0.4111579358577728,
0.09269051253795624,
0.46490001678466797,
-0.25763368606567383,
0.5221174359321594,
0.5268635749816895,
-0.5573137402534485,
-0.3265530467033386,
-0.3605072796344757,
0.18322846293449402,
-0.07474151253700256,
-0.6968519687652588,
0.3095436990261078,
0.06566853821277618,
-0.2591019570827484,
-0.47766825556755066,
-0.20214301347732544,
-0.22525794804096222,
0.013477698899805546,
0.10531028360128403,
0.03659185767173767,
0.13225416839122772,
-0.054553497582674026,
-0.11755584925413132,
-0.311472624540329,
0.06670393794775009,
-0.30579012632369995,
0.7904276251792908,
0.2675130367279053,
-0.29995906352996826,
-0.7374431490898132,
0.6251881122589111,
0.49915948510169983,
-0.056952156126499176,
0.38395416736602783,
0.33275240659713745,
-0.002576396567746997,
-0.13103584945201874,
-0.44020944833755493,
-0.49823126196861267,
-0.3950635492801666,
0.4464566111564636,
-0.5061752796173096,
-0.37288957834243774,
0.283380389213562,
-0.44621676206588745,
0.3958194851875305,
-0.05466976761817932,
0.4567367136478424,
-0.16067612171173096,
1.3375449180603027,
0.63865727186203,
0.21816737949848175,
0.5240882039070129,
-0.3361887037754059,
0.560298502445221,
-0.8343008160591125,
-0.331830233335495,
-0.09036529064178467,
-0.5026674270629883,
-0.34603798389434814,
-0.7503299713134766,
0.2660452127456665,
0.17338664829730988,
-0.3294452130794525,
0.22821559011936188,
-0.25784584879875183,
0.11083828657865524,
0.5771825313568115,
-0.14460329711437225,
0.23463362455368042,
-0.10036859661340714,
-0.4708026349544525,
-0.23333081603050232,
-0.8769018054008484,
-0.8325639367103577,
0.8272143006324768,
0.3724178075790405,
0.5439211130142212,
0.053368888795375824,
0.47606033086776733,
0.0692344456911087,
-0.0828927755355835,
-0.6800146102905273,
0.8353658318519592,
0.36106953024864197,
-0.6746668219566345,
-0.45647650957107544,
-0.25676751136779785,
-0.6108611226081848,
0.5125967860221863,
-0.2692875564098358,
-0.9287226796150208,
0.056766193360090256,
0.28546351194381714,
-0.47232291102409363,
0.5473170876502991,
-0.5415305495262146,
0.8482421040534973,
-0.5004318952560425,
-0.49308472871780396,
-0.7322497367858887,
-0.8419885635375977,
0.2193082571029663,
0.04981522262096405,
0.16597820818424225,
-0.5003803968429565,
0.08041568100452423,
0.6554372310638428,
-0.12673337757587433,
0.7574697136878967,
-0.44562140107154846,
0.12033217400312424,
0.578774094581604,
0.302449494600296,
0.7289828062057495,
0.09326446056365967,
0.1173982098698616,
-0.19139735400676727,
0.04461551457643509,
-0.24284301698207855,
-0.6953327059745789,
0.27658185362815857,
-0.5225983262062073,
-0.6022680997848511,
-0.46066492795944214,
-0.5633498430252075,
-0.5039647221565247,
0.08037280291318893,
-0.19434022903442383,
0.43399688601493835,
-0.8230533599853516,
-0.526311457157135,
0.617978036403656,
-0.25235769152641296,
0.49788331985473633,
0.7872099280357361,
-0.2797982096672058,
-0.1691041886806488,
0.4253426492214203,
0.0446862168610096,
0.5080122351646423,
0.4661354422569275,
0.12403488159179688,
-0.47474586963653564,
-0.3463113307952881,
-0.38877665996551514,
0.04035703465342522,
-0.34653523564338684,
0.1638338565826416,
-0.8263877034187317,
-0.1816079020500183,
-0.44058921933174133,
-0.1114099845290184,
-0.43493014574050903,
-0.570383608341217,
0.10060203075408936,
0.014888482168316841,
-0.12514863908290863,
0.5351581573486328,
-0.2951146066188812,
0.15808063745498657,
-0.3551212251186371,
0.46633121371269226,
0.5758178234100342,
0.2375868856906891,
-0.016798382624983788,
-0.24287371337413788,
0.15507560968399048,
0.5834143757820129,
-0.8936554193496704,
-0.8383269906044006,
0.504690945148468,
0.1759289801120758,
0.48670482635498047,
0.5335155725479126,
0.31361085176467896,
0.5267041325569153,
-0.5834508538246155,
0.5920100212097168,
0.252096027135849,
-0.3394904136657715,
0.5628488659858704,
-0.42430320382118225,
0.2106136977672577,
0.7285090088844299,
0.4490163028240204,
-0.7626594305038452,
-0.10913398116827011,
-0.6212124824523926,
-0.58808434009552,
1.0472086668014526,
0.00930771604180336,
0.09301358461380005,
0.11762535572052002,
-0.17680394649505615,
-0.026035858318209648,
0.30982500314712524,
-0.3729369640350342,
0.2674567997455597,
0.07142685353755951,
0.22526657581329346,
-0.11977008730173111,
-0.49003732204437256,
-0.4051457941532135,
-0.18518826365470886,
0.6152684688568115,
-0.27740171551704407,
0.4222775101661682,
0.1665344387292862,
0.25378987193107605,
-0.13544589281082153,
0.6024765372276306,
0.5895235538482666,
0.5913529992103577,
-0.2269735187292099,
-0.031094305217266083,
0.11218250542879105,
-0.030117610469460487,
0.2550398111343384,
-0.08795062452554703,
0.20099599659442902,
-0.3477136790752411,
0.0335947684943676,
0.7541724443435669,
0.6382156014442444,
-0.7867335081100464,
0.23928393423557281,
-0.2015233337879181,
-0.2010221779346466,
-0.42119064927101135,
0.2356429249048233,
0.08783826231956482,
0.516889750957489,
0.14870993793010712,
0.13724195957183838,
0.008112585172057152,
-1.0921658277511597,
-0.04956825077533722,
0.4361302852630615,
-0.4064624309539795,
-0.45262500643730164,
0.3640630543231964,
0.6692407131195068,
-0.7417892217636108,
0.6309601664543152,
-0.5379819869995117,
-0.8207922577857971,
0.20072665810585022,
0.33249497413635254,
1.0308506488800049,
-0.06688455492258072,
0.6448562741279602,
0.16529817879199982,
0.030942149460315704,
-0.23960472643375397,
0.6706624031066895,
-0.5908063650131226,
-0.9024941921234131,
-0.36155954003334045,
-0.5509545803070068,
-0.4169912040233612,
-0.07131487876176834,
-0.35798367857933044,
0.2722479999065399,
-0.4748847484588623,
-0.21522612869739532,
-0.16129061579704285,
0.44988372921943665,
-0.5732706785202026,
-0.10458778589963913,
0.10517123341560364,
0.8559226393699646,
-0.7114881873130798,
0.8607388734817505,
0.5525187849998474,
-0.22637172043323517,
-0.7545146942138672,
-0.017583684995770454,
0.22725126147270203,
-0.7762911319732666,
0.5535449385643005,
0.11459166556596756,
-0.24898117780685425,
-0.01710239052772522,
0.03846802935004234,
-0.5370721220970154,
0.9499064683914185,
0.09787078201770782,
-0.7175287008285522,
-0.570709228515625,
-0.019001062959432602,
0.42423301935195923,
-0.37429752945899963,
0.4364355206489563,
0.8082213997840881,
0.33864954113960266,
0.5039972066879272,
-1.1989911794662476,
-0.16126605868339539,
0.12898777425289154,
0.045722443610429764,
0.5168591141700745,
-0.557309627532959,
0.34077852964401245,
-0.5025918483734131,
-0.4876531660556793,
0.07714355736970901,
0.32575586438179016,
0.02084636688232422,
0.45492154359817505,
0.5162653923034668,
0.6343706250190735,
0.42199182510375977,
0.01837526634335518,
0.7396540641784668,
-0.23425176739692688,
-0.16985948383808136,
1.196654200553894,
-0.6255926489830017,
0.7883293628692627,
0.37910714745521545,
-0.4412112534046173,
0.49039509892463684,
0.6212655305862427,
0.6498247981071472,
0.6615447998046875,
0.12122314423322678,
-0.47143471240997314,
-0.3020845353603363,
-0.21863454580307007,
0.10107729583978653,
0.49552276730537415,
0.4988332986831665,
-0.01839963160455227,
-0.21839283406734467,
-0.21715670824050903,
0.1440100073814392,
0.2579224407672882,
-0.07362426072359085,
1.029566764831543,
0.07360374927520752,
-1.1766841411590576,
0.23437370359897614,
-0.030698606744408607,
0.483122855424881,
-0.637348473072052,
0.03441396355628967,
0.11312960833311081,
0.1540995091199875,
0.1561686098575592,
-0.9362764954566956,
0.4023853838443756,
-0.24639944732189178,
-0.10781704634428024,
-0.8807244300842285,
0.4807981848716736,
-0.546171247959137,
-0.0632130354642868,
0.34508830308914185,
0.4515702426433563,
0.012945044785737991,
-0.13826921582221985,
-0.9799056053161621,
-0.18130503594875336,
0.07075627148151398,
-0.3017434775829315,
0.4548686742782593,
0.3448003828525543,
-0.16513995826244354,
0.6537858247756958,
0.5986059308052063,
0.18758688867092133,
-0.34973597526550293,
0.03164808824658394,
0.8805165886878967,
-0.5773088932037354,
-0.8339183330535889,
-0.5166345238685608,
0.4759107828140259,
-0.33347827196121216,
-0.1865212768316269,
0.06778178364038467,
0.3636522591114044,
0.880299985408783,
0.40210554003715515,
0.5486010909080505,
-0.045090775936841965,
0.6621161699295044,
-0.33573275804519653,
0.10746407508850098,
-0.03604786843061447,
0.20115771889686584,
-0.11052238196134567,
-1.1842927932739258,
0.13329553604125977,
0.9220617413520813,
-0.5371049642562866,
-0.10669106245040894,
0.6425238847732544,
0.8739038705825806,
0.015093747526407242,
0.23145267367362976,
0.3419235944747925,
-0.09015979617834091,
0.576900064945221,
0.8601554036140442,
1.0257856845855713,
0.2135811150074005,
0.18627698719501495,
-0.3111276626586914,
-0.48891738057136536,
-0.1909344494342804,
-0.5590972304344177,
-0.9150039553642273,
-0.6548053622245789,
-0.07650191336870193,
0.11285607516765594,
-0.028681917116045952,
1.2558636665344238,
0.8969773054122925,
-0.19869376718997955,
-0.45477765798568726,
-0.3702342212200165,
-0.1513257920742035,
0.01297762244939804,
-0.19120657444000244,
-0.22628049552440643,
-0.29390665888786316,
-0.47963449358940125,
0.5498331189155579,
0.6301145553588867,
0.08794920146465302,
-0.54478520154953,
-0.372009813785553,
-0.4509364068508148,
0.3661600351333618,
0.4702194333076477,
0.6527419090270996,
-0.7778283357620239,
-0.010222326964139938,
-0.3949490189552307,
-0.12796138226985931,
-0.10821761190891266,
1.3738728761672974,
-1.0007694959640503,
0.8018932342529297,
0.4870550036430359,
0.17544668912887573,
0.6422281861305237,
-0.2345503866672516,
0.8976675868034363,
-0.2920626103878021,
0.5540485978126526,
0.8059786558151245,
0.002699689008295536,
0.10002807527780533,
-0.018210453912615776,
0.5311641097068787,
-0.0290827676653862,
-0.7403332591056824,
-0.6996529698371887,
0.918163537979126,
-0.6643853783607483,
-0.30149778723716736,
0.9183493256568909,
-0.051937565207481384,
0.4515637457370758,
-0.3647664487361908,
-0.6996652483940125,
0.36649540066719055,
-0.45784619450569153,
0.6953734755516052,
0.3927687704563141,
-0.6201040744781494,
0.006622475106269121,
-0.5953701734542847,
0.8132307529449463,
0.34216710925102234,
-0.37501728534698486,
0.1677299588918686,
0.37514936923980713,
-0.04908321797847748,
0.1119922548532486,
1.31150484085083,
0.40094396471977234,
-0.006178232375532389,
0.12885203957557678,
-0.10764811187982559,
0.18363036215305328,
-0.5990611910820007,
0.16080422699451447,
-0.09937500953674316,
0.15629763901233673,
0.12048807740211487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05370v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05370v2
|
VALL-E 2: Neural Codec Language Models are Human Parity Zero-Shot Text to Speech Synthesizers
| 2024-06-08T06:31:03 | 2024-06-17T04:39:08 |
Sanyuan Chen, Shujie Liu, Long Zhou, Yanqing Liu, Xu Tan, Jinyu Li, Sheng Zhao, Yao Qian, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This paper introduces VALL-E 2, the latest advancement in neural codec
language models that marks a milestone in zero-shot text-to-speech synthesis
(TTS), achieving human parity for the first time. Based on its predecessor,
VALL-E, the new iteration introduces two significant enhancements: Repetition
Aware Sampling refines the original nucleus sampling process by accounting for
token repetition in the decoding history. It not only stabilizes the decoding
but also circumvents the infinite loop issue. Grouped Code Modeling organizes
codec codes into groups to effectively shorten the sequence length, which not
only boosts inference speed but also addresses the challenges of long sequence
modeling. Our experiments on the LibriSpeech and VCTK datasets show that VALL-E
2 surpasses previous systems in speech robustness, naturalness, and speaker
similarity. It is the first of its kind to reach human parity on these
benchmarks. Moreover, VALL-E 2 consistently synthesizes high-quality speech,
even for sentences that are traditionally challenging due to their complexity
or repetitive phrases. The advantages of this work could contribute to valuable
endeavors, such as generating speech for individuals with aphasia or people
with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. See https://aka.ms/valle2 for demos of
VALL-E 2.
|
[
-0.2852138578891754,
-0.8694279193878174,
0.2887357771396637,
0.03839968889951706,
-0.0424586683511734,
0.11948837339878082,
0.03559846058487892,
-0.38864564895629883,
0.10438600927591324,
0.5144155621528625,
-0.26125985383987427,
-0.5702038407325745,
-0.46077394485473633,
0.10750412940979004,
-0.667013943195343,
0.7894645929336548,
0.436622679233551,
0.25932538509368896,
0.04509997367858887,
-0.19954104721546173,
-0.31833046674728394,
-0.8446841835975647,
-0.8401790261268616,
-0.29148557782173157,
0.6828148365020752,
0.03968953713774681,
0.4428275227546692,
0.5703624486923218,
-0.08492611348628998,
0.1725471168756485,
-0.3531399369239807,
-0.20748962461948395,
-0.33631569147109985,
0.19460982084274292,
0.1254168599843979,
-0.5351497530937195,
-0.8945872783660889,
-0.26479285955429077,
0.6682642102241516,
0.6101444363594055,
-0.03181970492005348,
-0.11447248607873917,
0.10722475498914719,
0.8558180332183838,
-0.3729161322116852,
-0.026632077991962433,
-0.6752957105636597,
-0.02300824038684368,
0.006615573074668646,
-0.060932282358407974,
-0.7960863709449768,
-0.1416475474834442,
-0.052926912903785706,
-0.47544535994529724,
0.17675763368606567,
-0.14196918904781342,
0.5200760364532471,
0.257975697517395,
-0.3789892792701721,
-0.018364835530519485,
-0.6751573085784912,
0.638566792011261,
-0.7086542844772339,
0.47111082077026367,
0.5907554030418396,
0.24846741557121277,
0.01657702960073948,
-1.0183215141296387,
-0.4746338725090027,
-0.003570694476366043,
0.39476385712623596,
-0.053558435291051865,
-0.2427418977022171,
0.1419583559036255,
0.17357929050922394,
-0.010090642608702183,
-0.8353089690208435,
0.26140955090522766,
-0.590644121170044,
-0.10815662890672684,
0.17062677443027496,
0.16589123010635376,
0.38541221618652344,
-0.0033436273224651814,
-0.2881160378456116,
0.0887162983417511,
-1.035976767539978,
0.16041362285614014,
0.25627753138542175,
0.07808683067560196,
-0.12269638478755951,
0.41297003626823425,
-0.13263630867004395,
0.8201130628585815,
-0.14699037373065948,
0.31038835644721985,
0.352422833442688,
-0.2044542133808136,
-0.21160854399204254,
0.08146509528160095,
0.42218291759490967,
0.3702186048030853,
0.10257230699062347,
-0.08600472658872604,
-0.15385615825653076,
0.02089829184114933,
0.12223868072032928,
-0.7953322529792786,
-0.12870721518993378,
0.32218030095100403,
-0.6770688891410828,
-0.3671796917915344,
-0.13659578561782837,
-0.8214865922927856,
-0.06167759746313095,
-0.4883321225643158,
0.16719302535057068,
-0.276936799287796,
-0.4457038938999176,
0.021110473200678825,
0.00826595351099968,
0.2546776235103607,
0.12918612360954285,
-1.1175055503845215,
0.4694741368293762,
0.8990843296051025,
0.7850319147109985,
-0.06997831165790558,
-0.39418357610702515,
-0.7608898282051086,
-0.19046996533870697,
-0.5624313950538635,
0.8809076547622681,
-0.36667993664741516,
-0.22227241098880768,
0.07981464266777039,
-0.1957159787416458,
0.4064749777317047,
-0.5180062651634216,
0.4620618522167206,
-0.670844554901123,
0.18055583536624908,
-0.5045122504234314,
-0.5173472762107849,
-0.03781092166900635,
-0.20011301338672638,
-0.7633172273635864,
0.8931172490119934,
0.40147528052330017,
-0.4757188856601715,
0.2545805275440216,
-0.3815975487232208,
-0.2184199094772339,
0.2615390717983246,
-0.3693370819091797,
-0.24395114183425903,
0.20047743618488312,
0.02661222591996193,
0.04212973639369011,
-0.5598767995834351,
0.2857671082019806,
-0.15271082520484924,
-0.45574766397476196,
0.3687816560268402,
-0.5604971051216125,
0.7705200910568237,
0.4280225336551666,
-0.2719406187534332,
-0.033823467791080475,
-0.4924115538597107,
0.4439867436885834,
-0.18323969841003418,
-0.3435574173927307,
-0.058368559926748276,
0.2101047784090042,
0.4695972502231598,
0.44210466742515564,
-0.15545758605003357,
-0.25260382890701294,
0.007907469756901264,
-0.6790806651115417,
0.9259196519851685,
0.5670145153999329,
-0.07836759835481644,
0.4926927387714386,
-0.3392634689807892,
0.3179871141910553,
-0.24644525349140167,
-0.005595749709755182,
-0.46712198853492737,
-0.7029004096984863,
-0.571750819683075,
-0.25327378511428833,
0.5208559632301331,
0.620698869228363,
-0.883817195892334,
0.6921543478965759,
-0.25660040974617004,
0.02203976735472679,
-0.6116322875022888,
-0.37897178530693054,
0.5680850148200989,
0.33760321140289307,
0.25283318758010864,
-0.16541364789009094,
-0.6935591697692871,
-1.0828042030334473,
-0.30910491943359375,
-0.29900550842285156,
-0.4349024295806885,
0.11637880653142929,
0.028757257387042046,
-0.009098013862967491,
0.9339301586151123,
0.04725109785795212,
0.21417710185050964,
-0.35502415895462036,
0.38153982162475586,
-0.16371050477027893,
0.3568796217441559,
0.4939092993736267,
-0.7036591172218323,
-0.413335382938385,
-0.14917327463626862,
-0.628386378288269,
-0.29015466570854187,
0.047189176082611084,
0.10380245000123978,
0.7501426935195923,
0.3012644350528717,
-0.1491370052099228,
0.4279036223888397,
0.49267348647117615,
-0.5414445400238037,
0.15740033984184265,
-0.14356732368469238,
0.400285542011261,
-1.133145809173584,
0.007058979012072086,
-0.23643508553504944,
-0.27972450852394104,
-1.0271337032318115,
-0.22124336659908295,
-0.024171706289052963,
-0.2061230093240738,
-0.8150891661643982,
0.3415454924106598,
-0.1962311714887619,
-0.55314040184021,
-0.3749300539493561,
-0.12672871351242065,
-0.06490083783864975,
0.5545742511749268,
-0.13423709571361542,
1.1163746118545532,
0.5588402152061462,
-0.4633007049560547,
0.15010705590248108,
0.11525928229093552,
-0.288495272397995,
0.3632728159427643,
-0.8766049742698669,
0.5196139812469482,
-0.0472458153963089,
0.23992131650447845,
-0.6151918172836304,
-0.15228088200092316,
-0.12344915419816971,
-0.9895614981651306,
0.2244958132505417,
-0.08101124316453934,
-0.4357803463935852,
-0.09735820442438126,
-0.1553398221731186,
0.783968985080719,
1.1397576332092285,
-0.4581891596317291,
0.22488418221473694,
0.6394038796424866,
-0.29409584403038025,
-0.15105028450489044,
-1.0318924188613892,
0.43289294838905334,
0.05209599435329437,
-0.6931110620498657,
0.3460407257080078,
-0.023724213242530823,
-0.18280625343322754,
-0.13905969262123108,
0.24068373441696167,
-0.440580815076828,
-0.23270082473754883,
0.03385835513472557,
0.30177876353263855,
-0.13647526502609253,
0.11472617089748383,
0.18834733963012695,
-0.39755958318710327,
-0.09206565469503403,
-0.5049961805343628,
0.7613518238067627,
-0.4048069715499878,
-0.2107810527086258,
-0.8371879458427429,
0.7225402593612671,
0.7615072727203369,
-0.07170362770557404,
0.33337461948394775,
0.30169951915740967,
-0.6657261848449707,
-0.06496013700962067,
-0.5199791193008423,
-0.2036045789718628,
-0.3953428566455841,
0.7686681151390076,
-0.4003022611141205,
-1.145007610321045,
0.36253973841667175,
0.11748356372117996,
-0.3027050495147705,
0.3312869966030121,
0.8798293471336365,
0.0821569636464119,
1.0864408016204834,
0.21432772278785706,
-0.06821727752685547,
0.32233935594558716,
-0.008948990143835545,
0.23615813255310059,
-0.8904547691345215,
-0.2752010226249695,
-0.5351369976997375,
-0.1366380751132965,
-0.423427551984787,
-0.5017347931861877,
0.4387090802192688,
0.24341154098510742,
-0.2858181595802307,
0.3320053815841675,
-0.6657136678695679,
0.652197003364563,
0.3628578186035156,
0.022872108966112137,
-0.10389016568660736,
0.5096796154975891,
0.17052321135997772,
-0.39886659383773804,
-0.5716440081596375,
-0.48496440052986145,
1.1842280626296997,
0.45095551013946533,
0.2716529071331024,
-0.06338609009981155,
0.4844796657562256,
0.49164527654647827,
-0.14521637558937073,
-0.602561891078949,
0.43442001938819885,
-0.4686717092990875,
-0.37462830543518066,
-0.23869049549102783,
-0.32088491320610046,
-0.6697126626968384,
0.039264015853405,
-0.03803843632340431,
-0.7150049209594727,
0.13943399488925934,
0.15575851500034332,
-0.48550689220428467,
0.3838473856449127,
-0.6183727979660034,
0.559891402721405,
-0.12067022919654846,
-0.5492883324623108,
-0.27198630571365356,
-0.6572937965393066,
0.23389364778995514,
0.07905548065900803,
0.09971503168344498,
0.05959875509142876,
-0.09995526820421219,
0.5229082107543945,
-0.10686672478914261,
0.49067768454551697,
-0.032761100679636,
0.1881801337003708,
0.6305574774742126,
0.11099336296319962,
0.4585220217704773,
-0.020400788635015488,
-0.1505458950996399,
0.3505849242210388,
-0.04018823802471161,
-0.5996497869491577,
-0.6808323860168457,
0.9440504312515259,
-0.6145854592323303,
-0.10340573638677597,
-0.2805998921394348,
-0.2932237982749939,
0.009833808057010174,
-0.10982931405305862,
0.45456671714782715,
0.761964738368988,
-0.30051591992378235,
0.4546734094619751,
0.7670162916183472,
-0.4764547348022461,
0.5885710120201111,
0.28910407423973083,
-0.19863107800483704,
-1.0307915210723877,
0.8775957822799683,
0.09394840896129608,
0.5053962469100952,
0.3422428071498871,
-0.3528977334499359,
-0.32419899106025696,
-0.25861555337905884,
-0.6159123182296753,
-0.09759101271629333,
-0.4397125244140625,
-0.1484590768814087,
-0.8477756381034851,
-0.3887622058391571,
-0.4891263544559479,
-0.23480913043022156,
-0.5912092328071594,
-0.7222731113433838,
-0.24083605408668518,
-0.1276063323020935,
0.12763939797878265,
0.8107535243034363,
-0.08894971758127213,
-0.03837095946073532,
-0.6990026831626892,
0.4141400158405304,
0.4568485915660858,
0.29195526242256165,
-0.16038523614406586,
-0.568023681640625,
-0.10917270928621292,
0.10455125570297241,
-0.010686774738132954,
-0.9550944566726685,
0.6324451565742493,
-0.058729659765958786,
0.07672547549009323,
-0.12726366519927979,
-0.4287244975566864,
0.13810451328754425,
-0.5347182154655457,
1.1400294303894043,
0.5472516417503357,
-1.0967093706130981,
0.39694473147392273,
-0.39481592178344727,
0.20631833374500275,
0.4057663083076477,
-0.3533790707588196,
-0.7207740545272827,
0.1723453551530838,
-0.47097957134246826,
-0.9573622345924377,
0.7204347848892212,
0.5555894374847412,
-0.11072023212909698,
-0.17692692577838898,
0.5070451498031616,
0.016164157539606094,
0.1659674048423767,
-0.5977046489715576,
-0.2994591295719147,
-0.32510918378829956,
-0.17729192972183228,
0.33812785148620605,
-0.8240830898284912,
0.20507104694843292,
-0.3647054135799408,
0.5681740045547485,
0.11415368318557739,
0.7109264731407166,
0.1836756467819214,
0.23903104662895203,
-0.1376599818468094,
0.592498242855072,
1.043009877204895,
0.4351118505001068,
-0.058589983731508255,
0.296595960855484,
0.35947659611701965,
-0.1952633559703827,
0.33161160349845886,
-0.24824324250221252,
-0.3272797763347626,
0.05392305180430412,
0.22617317736148834,
1.0477718114852905,
0.19292689859867096,
-0.5137284994125366,
0.6302331686019897,
-0.07216137647628784,
-0.4681171178817749,
-0.3158535957336426,
-0.2934856116771698,
-0.010820605792105198,
0.09457595646381378,
0.24689872562885284,
0.13490794599056244,
0.24353156983852386,
-0.2966475784778595,
0.519120454788208,
0.018197713419795036,
-0.4117342531681061,
-0.6284741759300232,
0.8173955678939819,
0.36845144629478455,
-0.8463757038116455,
0.6693715453147888,
-0.3830161690711975,
-0.4726892113685608,
0.7084737420082092,
0.6546030640602112,
1.3598226308822632,
-0.32920706272125244,
0.08288504928350449,
0.6103866100311279,
0.273531049489975,
-0.1754162311553955,
0.4144730567932129,
0.18259140849113464,
-0.24337716400623322,
-0.461442232131958,
-0.4883933961391449,
0.12484382092952728,
0.2562794089317322,
-0.7580133676528931,
0.4139083921909332,
-0.3271900713443756,
-0.12302422523498535,
-0.21769283711910248,
-0.5904924869537354,
-0.3849862217903137,
-0.09075254201889038,
0.17084914445877075,
0.6510807871818542,
-0.8662525415420532,
1.3152351379394531,
0.3629299998283386,
-0.35479822754859924,
-0.64521324634552,
-0.2128876894712448,
0.1172601506114006,
-0.47237250208854675,
0.7107404470443726,
0.029696321114897728,
0.045955952256917953,
0.19536258280277252,
-0.41855207085609436,
-0.5953956842422485,
1.2429358959197998,
0.2481750249862671,
-0.8360416293144226,
-0.21181759238243103,
0.27509722113609314,
0.6290568709373474,
-0.5810496807098389,
0.19179092347621918,
0.745429515838623,
0.19618679583072662,
0.018833238631486893,
-0.7580755949020386,
-0.3381408452987671,
-0.4457266926765442,
0.5046471357345581,
0.14865174889564514,
-0.2914687991142273,
1.1112345457077026,
0.12222525477409363,
-0.009515759535133839,
0.3013495206832886,
0.5865412950515747,
0.2889834940433502,
0.37382662296295166,
0.25237584114074707,
0.689529299736023,
0.4885404407978058,
-0.18319092690944672,
0.9892785549163818,
-0.5426238775253296,
0.29775819182395935,
1.1383098363876343,
-0.39646971225738525,
0.9861313700675964,
0.4120052456855774,
-0.3306213617324829,
0.1345813125371933,
0.33991047739982605,
0.1847028285264969,
0.6739569902420044,
0.09639754891395569,
-0.694584310054779,
-0.2802291214466095,
-0.04120572656393051,
-0.5781511068344116,
0.1644410789012909,
0.2757529318332672,
-0.34865760803222656,
-0.05116615444421768,
-0.00425533065572381,
-0.28908783197402954,
0.1623971164226532,
-0.048128966242074966,
0.8250260353088379,
0.14227840304374695,
-0.6582271456718445,
0.9200313687324524,
0.18813925981521606,
0.464221328496933,
-0.25734803080558777,
-0.38330402970314026,
-0.10422410815954208,
-0.10122466087341309,
-0.012953944504261017,
-0.4310147166252136,
0.4996702969074249,
0.18887069821357727,
-0.5226972103118896,
-0.23689621686935425,
0.654430627822876,
-0.6015653014183044,
-0.2045838087797165,
0.31236445903778076,
0.3521059453487396,
0.26830610632896423,
-0.1700689047574997,
-0.5454243421554565,
0.2551180422306061,
0.22411291301250458,
-0.054214246571063995,
0.3848136365413666,
0.11326128244400024,
0.0861041471362114,
0.1926468312740326,
0.44374945759773254,
0.07457900047302246,
0.27748724818229675,
0.27589380741119385,
0.7498146891593933,
-0.5949582457542419,
-0.38760170340538025,
-0.6397178769111633,
0.6947619915008545,
0.11535058915615082,
-0.26887643337249756,
0.013686279766261578,
0.8168782591819763,
0.583984375,
-0.10684169083833694,
0.9492162466049194,
0.027825618162751198,
0.6314135193824768,
-0.6751704216003418,
0.7820090651512146,
-0.20346006751060486,
0.34134823083877563,
0.2657819092273712,
-0.8662577867507935,
-0.2821226119995117,
0.5159507393836975,
0.1727958470582962,
0.0573589913547039,
1.044325828552246,
0.972099244594574,
0.3802548944950104,
0.08977487683296204,
0.7340791821479797,
0.16514591872692108,
0.403642863035202,
0.9681682586669922,
0.7415844202041626,
-0.8628919124603271,
0.3072071969509125,
0.053531769663095474,
-0.3488357365131378,
-0.018733199685811996,
-0.46498143672943115,
-0.6688323020935059,
-0.8636302351951599,
-0.134102001786232,
-0.5429400205612183,
0.3448464870452881,
1.198007583618164,
0.6273431777954102,
-0.8152492642402649,
-0.15408162772655487,
-0.7414263486862183,
-0.220004141330719,
0.0891064703464508,
-0.1717388778924942,
0.15147855877876282,
-0.3468448519706726,
-0.8553924560546875,
0.611832320690155,
0.7103772759437561,
0.16800415515899658,
-0.10405893623828888,
-0.39994457364082336,
0.03182508423924446,
0.07414207607507706,
0.7345075011253357,
0.4206768274307251,
-1.2600657939910889,
-0.14879754185676575,
0.16944655776023865,
-0.30637842416763306,
0.1633893847465515,
1.1184399127960205,
-0.8640853762626648,
0.6530479192733765,
0.7902592420578003,
0.6766327023506165,
0.3191787600517273,
-0.14405524730682373,
0.526150643825531,
-0.4452413022518158,
0.3247183859348297,
0.4890216588973999,
0.19304844737052917,
0.13838738203048706,
-0.11892898380756378,
0.28733885288238525,
0.19022105634212494,
-0.8217898011207581,
-0.8963415622711182,
0.3681170642375946,
-0.982856273651123,
-0.2638270854949951,
1.3153964281082153,
0.026837803423404694,
-0.20584765076637268,
-0.1373373568058014,
-0.2123914510011673,
0.3928096890449524,
-0.3947826027870178,
0.668936014175415,
0.6656040549278259,
0.05034616217017174,
-0.25163641571998596,
-0.7719676494598389,
0.600446343421936,
0.6563469171524048,
-0.881431519985199,
0.08487196266651154,
0.6576110124588013,
0.17480286955833435,
-0.3696087598800659,
0.8875201940536499,
-0.4235031008720398,
0.5996546745300293,
0.22006718814373016,
0.42844635248184204,
-0.2124841958284378,
-0.5354417562484741,
-0.8542378544807434,
0.11351324617862701,
0.09213978052139282,
-0.0004448080435395241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05369v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05369v1
|
Venn Diagram Prompting : Accelerating Comprehension with Scaffolding Effect
| 2024-06-08T06:27:26 | 2024-06-08T06:27:26 |
Sakshi Mahendru, Tejul Pandit
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce Venn Diagram (VD) Prompting, an innovative prompting technique
which allows Large Language Models (LLMs) to combine and synthesize information
across complex, diverse and long-context documents in knowledge-intensive
question-answering tasks. Generating answers from multiple documents involves
numerous steps to extract relevant and unique information and amalgamate it
into a cohesive response. To improve the quality of the final answer, multiple
LLM calls or pretrained models are used to perform different tasks such as
summarization, reorganization and customization. The approach covered in the
paper focuses on replacing the multi-step strategy via a single LLM call using
VD prompting. Our proposed technique also aims to eliminate the inherent
position bias in the LLMs, enhancing consistency in answers by removing
sensitivity to the sequence of input information. It overcomes the challenge of
inconsistency traditionally associated with varying input sequences. We also
explore the practical applications of the VD prompt based on our examination of
the prompt's outcomes. In the experiments performed on four public benchmark
question-answering datasets, VD prompting continually matches or surpasses the
performance of a meticulously crafted instruction prompt which adheres to
optimal guidelines and practices.
|
[
-0.27389293909072876,
-1.3529826402664185,
0.6490800976753235,
0.4405979812145233,
-0.2711835205554962,
0.07653278857469559,
0.06894104927778244,
-0.017309585586190224,
0.20503494143486023,
0.4712372422218323,
-0.7489629983901978,
-0.3789081275463104,
-0.27649667859077454,
0.22436654567718506,
-0.4266378581523895,
0.6558293700218201,
-0.16999265551567078,
0.18443255126476288,
-0.6414430141448975,
0.022730952128767967,
-0.5446828603744507,
-0.20018096268177032,
-0.7003253102302551,
-0.43178674578666687,
1.0527974367141724,
0.9165030121803284,
0.4574282467365265,
0.8710266351699829,
0.043824657797813416,
0.30232682824134827,
-0.18920421600341797,
0.1959979236125946,
-0.5634636282920837,
0.731631875038147,
0.09161261469125748,
-0.3090723752975464,
-0.31924718618392944,
-0.19538746774196625,
0.6099948883056641,
0.8427937626838684,
-0.0740373507142067,
0.32082200050354004,
0.2846051752567291,
0.7373716831207275,
-0.5478339195251465,
0.08732720464468002,
-0.4341539144515991,
-0.16382750868797302,
0.12237388640642166,
-0.5154323577880859,
-0.40878403186798096,
-0.33910515904426575,
0.3405950963497162,
-0.7156702876091003,
-0.10811090469360352,
-0.21517668664455414,
0.7986504435539246,
0.3087945580482483,
-0.45060795545578003,
-0.14892904460430145,
-0.3702465295791626,
0.10794097930192947,
-0.2530013918876648,
0.19996756315231323,
0.14219602942466736,
0.29507210850715637,
-0.0026801833882927895,
-0.981408953666687,
-0.7271461486816406,
-0.20309016108512878,
0.29410773515701294,
0.39911916851997375,
0.08053363114595413,
0.08119076490402222,
0.7163593769073486,
0.18302123248577118,
-0.5701952576637268,
-0.002404843457043171,
-0.700381338596344,
0.056325048208236694,
0.43466976284980774,
0.34255969524383545,
0.2517160177230835,
-0.1348285675048828,
-0.5123142004013062,
-0.1967364400625229,
-0.8013954758644104,
0.33066192269325256,
0.4040810763835907,
0.19294095039367676,
0.1702398806810379,
0.861423134803772,
-0.7189899682998657,
0.9171452522277832,
0.2839323580265045,
0.20804519951343536,
0.2775458097457886,
-0.43123283982276917,
-0.24568487703800201,
0.08492494374513626,
0.33184877038002014,
0.5028570294380188,
0.6622744202613831,
0.35576799511909485,
0.1853272020816803,
-0.03860028088092804,
0.338853657245636,
-0.8112037777900696,
-0.05892527848482132,
0.2797553241252899,
-0.267157644033432,
-0.24936334788799286,
-0.13896702229976654,
-0.6434536576271057,
-0.4972437620162964,
-0.7083792090415955,
0.3807820677757263,
-0.42674487829208374,
-0.12499450892210007,
0.2394832819700241,
-0.2715335488319397,
0.5159775018692017,
0.5724779963493347,
-0.6474044919013977,
-0.1299125999212265,
0.4425649046897888,
0.7655096650123596,
-0.1385783553123474,
-0.5613036155700684,
-0.9281237721443176,
0.22466051578521729,
-0.22628402709960938,
0.8466721177101135,
-0.5245671272277832,
-0.525701642036438,
0.3255017101764679,
-0.04638109728693962,
-0.10152912884950638,
-0.28971460461616516,
0.3390798270702362,
-0.5034319162368774,
0.15949392318725586,
-0.6322925090789795,
-0.5007926821708679,
-0.15036669373512268,
0.6247547268867493,
-0.6352053284645081,
1.16673743724823,
0.16180548071861267,
-0.9237496852874756,
0.22738812863826752,
-0.4688618779182434,
-0.5473577976226807,
0.04974299669265747,
-0.3597824275493622,
-0.023285599425435066,
0.08279994130134583,
0.5409722328186035,
0.5837004780769348,
-0.10495256632566452,
-0.13098013401031494,
-0.3453451991081238,
-0.30809661746025085,
0.1910795122385025,
-0.4327593743801117,
0.8234832882881165,
0.09360254555940628,
0.1175958439707756,
0.46061861515045166,
-0.5859274864196777,
0.25888827443122864,
0.08182785660028458,
-0.4000903069972992,
-0.20878872275352478,
-0.3360617458820343,
-0.2808758318424225,
0.35049355030059814,
0.11241316050291061,
-0.027981897816061974,
0.4368685185909271,
-0.1834208071231842,
0.3205666244029999,
0.7900637984275818,
0.2384239137172699,
0.32493430376052856,
-0.6684828996658325,
0.8648921847343445,
0.0855363979935646,
-0.03393544256687164,
-0.8456510901451111,
-0.6464822292327881,
-0.649348258972168,
-0.027186710387468338,
0.06659127026796341,
0.7320680022239685,
-1.2314581871032715,
-0.2196367233991623,
-0.43319833278656006,
-0.3771332800388336,
-0.558854877948761,
0.20130200684070587,
0.18450425565242767,
1.0391931533813477,
0.28535589575767517,
-0.07722906023263931,
-0.2722111940383911,
-0.5511474609375,
-0.2554115355014801,
-0.4182106554508209,
-0.18793292343616486,
-0.019786210730671883,
0.3136610984802246,
0.2464318871498108,
0.6983265280723572,
-0.4098699688911438,
0.13365298509597778,
-0.28693631291389465,
0.06988575309515,
0.18214064836502075,
0.23836538195610046,
0.11297369748353958,
-0.623909056186676,
-0.5973197221755981,
-0.2172120064496994,
-0.7786773443222046,
-0.1410023421049118,
-0.2383011430501938,
-0.1021542176604271,
-0.08880715817213058,
0.911219596862793,
-0.512956976890564,
0.5132965445518494,
0.05205664038658142,
-0.28331127762794495,
0.804707407951355,
-0.35923925042152405,
0.3027474880218506,
-1.0300852060317993,
-0.12025891244411469,
-0.19070768356323242,
0.18449847400188446,
-0.7948752045631409,
0.02111707627773285,
0.2696559727191925,
-0.05989440158009529,
-0.5794657468795776,
0.5556307435035706,
-0.5483831763267517,
0.1409183293581009,
-0.03579325973987579,
0.4064520001411438,
0.03311610966920853,
0.26923176646232605,
-0.07141872495412827,
0.7579047679901123,
0.732952356338501,
-0.7565773725509644,
0.34491410851478577,
0.29580408334732056,
-0.11507285386323929,
1.063176155090332,
-0.9820948243141174,
0.2979748249053955,
-0.5068249106407166,
0.19832268357276917,
-1.351347804069519,
-0.42289999127388,
0.3078312873840332,
-0.3647707402706146,
0.3149256408214569,
-0.07228104770183563,
-0.3739115297794342,
-0.5585484504699707,
-0.4963088929653168,
0.37120383977890015,
0.25039491057395935,
-0.6045320630073547,
0.6691862940788269,
-0.14409852027893066,
-0.42818260192871094,
-0.5358180403709412,
-0.5334718823432922,
0.07926596701145172,
-0.27131012082099915,
-1.1713052988052368,
0.26450929045677185,
-0.4489717483520508,
-0.05817916616797447,
-0.2565456032752991,
-0.20793317258358002,
0.0742236003279686,
0.18289020657539368,
0.26370659470558167,
0.259553462266922,
-0.3270435035228729,
0.21675650775432587,
0.36750608682632446,
-0.2822311222553253,
0.23153597116470337,
-0.34683260321617126,
0.5010255575180054,
0.2267775535583496,
-0.5191180109977722,
-0.6086885333061218,
0.7180561423301697,
0.5634317398071289,
-0.13201725482940674,
0.3600020408630371,
0.42089617252349854,
-0.23651377856731415,
-0.15716955065727234,
-0.3423983156681061,
-0.4564502537250519,
-0.4674546718597412,
0.15436816215515137,
-0.5650155544281006,
-0.9069416522979736,
0.4004404842853546,
-0.19907568395137787,
0.08255334198474884,
-0.16508066654205322,
0.5669518709182739,
-0.20525164902210236,
1.1577130556106567,
0.44060590863227844,
0.09243185073137283,
0.7002418041229248,
-0.20221398770809174,
0.098272904753685,
-0.6632426381111145,
-0.2025705724954605,
-0.6503995656967163,
-0.19341719150543213,
-0.19492536783218384,
-0.4194119870662689,
0.3786318600177765,
0.23930175602436066,
-0.12431240826845169,
-0.1613626331090927,
-0.5025164484977722,
0.6438358426094055,
0.6958107352256775,
0.20069549977779388,
0.1864754855632782,
0.22956594824790955,
-0.164303719997406,
0.11797820031642914,
-0.8216039538383484,
-0.4169628620147705,
0.9867755174636841,
0.010834715329110622,
0.5574353337287903,
-0.39819762110710144,
0.7195068001747131,
-0.06681574881076813,
0.23912735283374786,
-0.6730653047561646,
0.5965922474861145,
0.4415428936481476,
-0.2848908305168152,
-0.5715630650520325,
-0.11262484639883041,
-0.9735576510429382,
0.33027833700180054,
-0.07529699802398682,
-0.9297513961791992,
-0.0741189494729042,
0.2512252926826477,
-0.5211769342422485,
-0.33722275495529175,
-0.7213783264160156,
0.6973291039466858,
-0.015521801076829433,
-0.3823506832122803,
0.010950583964586258,
-0.6454397439956665,
0.45846113562583923,
0.32728803157806396,
-0.15612970292568207,
0.12180015444755554,
0.13474108278751373,
0.49988317489624023,
-0.357500821352005,
0.6383520364761353,
-0.05686526000499725,
0.022586841136217117,
0.26933082938194275,
-0.07514724135398865,
0.6408012509346008,
0.1579028069972992,
-0.2641083002090454,
-0.4015830457210541,
0.005951009690761566,
-0.6178707480430603,
-0.9078820943832397,
0.6364338994026184,
-0.3494168221950531,
-1.1128829717636108,
-0.18229778110980988,
-0.5827608704566956,
-0.16632860898971558,
0.19007664918899536,
0.2851135730743408,
0.5097167491912842,
0.09289129823446274,
0.08302526921033859,
0.9694263339042664,
0.07666311413049698,
0.2809411585330963,
0.127964049577713,
-0.27014079689979553,
-0.4124045968055725,
0.6607695817947388,
0.4039793312549591,
0.48218202590942383,
-0.11680498719215393,
0.11505906283855438,
-0.4952986538410187,
-0.5573381185531616,
-0.5689780712127686,
0.262168288230896,
-1.0677604675292969,
-0.04205048829317093,
-0.7548206448554993,
-0.2537723183631897,
-0.5124544501304626,
-0.2896216809749603,
0.42569759488105774,
-0.35381025075912476,
-0.2551930248737335,
-0.4937528073787689,
0.3834744095802307,
0.5990176200866699,
0.03124336712062359,
0.39182421565055847,
-0.4342951774597168,
0.43641600012779236,
0.606944739818573,
-0.15331771969795227,
-0.05475668981671333,
-0.3643623888492584,
0.029983827844262123,
-0.1081525981426239,
-0.2956405580043793,
-1.2652326822280884,
-0.15286529064178467,
-0.07999318838119507,
0.6251707673072815,
0.3954836428165436,
0.3101729452610016,
0.8608841896057129,
-0.49255335330963135,
0.7944524884223938,
0.20433712005615234,
-0.7078313827514648,
0.5672856569290161,
-0.20592382550239563,
0.7251566052436829,
0.5527260303497314,
0.32360661029815674,
-0.6108988523483276,
-0.3946889042854309,
-0.6030230522155762,
-1.1594284772872925,
0.4516090452671051,
-0.02698618732392788,
0.2855954170227051,
-0.09211643785238266,
0.5032075047492981,
-0.09550048410892487,
0.1886521875858307,
-0.03670608624815941,
-0.41436439752578735,
-0.19117063283920288,
-0.1818424016237259,
0.3469659686088562,
-0.5111834406852722,
-0.30420976877212524,
-0.1843220591545105,
0.5233400464057922,
-0.447569340467453,
0.02645445242524147,
0.5925218462944031,
-0.11530410498380661,
0.09523889422416687,
0.05413326993584633,
0.7597748637199402,
0.9250563979148865,
0.4684968888759613,
0.19268345832824707,
0.46690818667411804,
-0.382199227809906,
0.06951312720775604,
0.058875881135463715,
-0.37328240275382996,
-0.029132995754480362,
0.3379233479499817,
0.6226013898849487,
-0.07846628129482269,
-0.22159385681152344,
0.37434834241867065,
-0.23808540403842926,
-0.2995010316371918,
-0.03945046290755272,
0.18542571365833282,
0.291208416223526,
0.3580542802810669,
0.4555712044239044,
-0.47413766384124756,
0.02417834661900997,
-0.3075645864009857,
0.4026857316493988,
0.12404237687587738,
-0.4625616669654846,
-0.11493219435214996,
0.6261708736419678,
-0.007805557455867529,
-0.6126180291175842,
0.6468181014060974,
0.10785181820392609,
-0.4362342357635498,
0.6207144856452942,
0.41813692450523376,
0.7556864023208618,
-0.40689322352409363,
0.6534979939460754,
0.39105501770973206,
0.25251442193984985,
-0.0965614765882492,
0.7966827154159546,
-0.33370906114578247,
-0.269219309091568,
-0.5867291688919067,
0.010614361613988876,
-0.2995625138282776,
0.005438218824565411,
-0.8044189810752869,
0.3158983588218689,
-0.4856639802455902,
0.08342698216438293,
-0.0929720401763916,
-0.11152151226997375,
-0.7512967586517334,
0.06763507425785065,
-0.07563118636608124,
1.2870327234268188,
-0.7144940495491028,
0.7428500056266785,
0.6578646302223206,
-0.5918461680412292,
-1.0707781314849854,
0.116785429418087,
0.22420892119407654,
-0.7478408217430115,
0.41408446431159973,
0.47069457173347473,
-0.10891523212194443,
0.34093302488327026,
-0.8048297166824341,
-0.5050108432769775,
1.151139497756958,
0.4084809720516205,
-0.22451810538768768,
0.023689772933721542,
-0.029412738978862762,
0.27488771080970764,
-0.4670012593269348,
0.5088534355163574,
0.5554475784301758,
0.6147115230560303,
0.3623311519622803,
-0.3879317045211792,
0.32851800322532654,
-0.3355552554130554,
0.10331295430660248,
-0.4679405391216278,
-0.2354394495487213,
0.7068266868591309,
-0.47447770833969116,
-0.40129777789115906,
0.17531804740428925,
0.9099413752555847,
0.7501429915428162,
0.5285981893539429,
0.7472923994064331,
0.09531839936971664,
1.2355594635009766,
-0.14671587944030762,
0.9276798367500305,
-0.3330688178539276,
-0.2573908567428589,
1.1423771381378174,
-0.3266616761684418,
0.6125368475914001,
0.9617123603820801,
0.323213130235672,
0.37913012504577637,
0.840045690536499,
0.4459144175052643,
0.2437906563282013,
0.6678873300552368,
-0.22423788905143738,
-0.4819389283657074,
-0.2551195025444031,
-0.5390316247940063,
-0.11753427237272263,
0.3282969295978546,
0.1146915853023529,
-0.3945658504962921,
0.03263326361775398,
0.039218831807374954,
0.2751139998435974,
-0.1288568675518036,
0.5919749140739441,
0.14970293641090393,
-0.8634637594223022,
0.5054454803466797,
-0.7387413382530212,
0.007463242392987013,
-0.5400457382202148,
-0.22806839644908905,
-0.3945366144180298,
-0.2846832871437073,
-0.024638935923576355,
-0.9056093692779541,
-0.18588820099830627,
-0.2620599567890167,
-0.31246376037597656,
-0.6057600378990173,
0.5846849083900452,
-0.6396132707595825,
-0.27169790863990784,
0.2168707698583603,
0.738125205039978,
-0.05142185837030411,
-0.12925074994564056,
-0.8919718265533447,
0.21547555923461914,
-0.12402740120887756,
-0.5738871693611145,
-0.003319886513054371,
0.9608005881309509,
-0.1767900288105011,
0.861445426940918,
0.7647863626480103,
-0.21617895364761353,
0.05040065199136734,
0.26252806186676025,
1.021899700164795,
-0.5052104592323303,
-0.7879031896591187,
-0.5618635416030884,
1.073710322380066,
-0.5283793210983276,
-0.5419521927833557,
0.8341822624206543,
0.07584754377603531,
0.9032102227210999,
0.05501744523644447,
0.7201295495033264,
0.2944265902042389,
0.19092164933681488,
-0.7884487509727478,
0.5095038414001465,
-0.41673189401626587,
0.29062238335609436,
-0.34228411316871643,
-0.7415010333061218,
-0.27968630194664,
0.35043832659721375,
-0.12989728152751923,
-0.07887596637010574,
0.8346904516220093,
0.9923775792121887,
0.2463386207818985,
0.14422979950904846,
0.4420568645000458,
0.054266877472400665,
0.24878430366516113,
0.281392902135849,
1.3492813110351562,
-0.09685558825731277,
0.6638697385787964,
0.04418662190437317,
-0.07843716442584991,
-0.38951820135116577,
-0.7875914573669434,
-1.1432459354400635,
-0.8181533217430115,
-0.4704399108886719,
-0.6524890661239624,
0.19816617667675018,
0.5953404903411865,
0.4977094233036041,
-0.30589529871940613,
-0.16203421354293823,
-0.009174731560051441,
0.6640455722808838,
-0.372800350189209,
-0.1697075515985489,
0.29051679372787476,
-0.5935488343238831,
-0.5466562509536743,
0.583773136138916,
0.3522367775440216,
0.12608209252357483,
-0.3000902831554413,
-0.1865176558494568,
-0.16335424780845642,
0.10628172755241394,
0.3299896717071533,
0.2152564376592636,
-0.5933278203010559,
-0.4393156170845032,
0.40449410676956177,
-0.07841003686189651,
0.11826710402965546,
0.9483073949813843,
-0.8345512747764587,
0.7144107222557068,
0.9770638346672058,
0.7557013630867004,
0.5808984041213989,
0.06670372188091278,
0.7661447525024414,
-0.5547961592674255,
-0.2889820635318756,
-0.1997642070055008,
0.14057712256908417,
0.3526966869831085,
-0.4041946530342102,
0.37239545583724976,
0.02828649990260601,
-0.38180917501449585,
-0.911249041557312,
0.42590174078941345,
-0.997877299785614,
-0.21544969081878662,
1.024645209312439,
-0.19785957038402557,
-0.5138596296310425,
-0.3345133662223816,
-0.6005399227142334,
0.19575564563274384,
-0.3928664028644562,
0.697534441947937,
0.795068085193634,
0.04661030322313309,
-0.2652536630630493,
-0.535124659538269,
0.30562758445739746,
0.5404161810874939,
-0.731792688369751,
0.11152008175849915,
0.5099083185195923,
0.10345283895730972,
0.08128293603658676,
0.7702323198318481,
0.2835656702518463,
0.5884746313095093,
-0.039711035788059235,
-0.488549143075943,
-0.3732667565345764,
-0.6278031468391418,
-0.785764217376709,
0.3963150382041931,
-0.14482566714286804,
-0.19007308781147003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05365v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05365v2
|
CaLM: Contrasting Large and Small Language Models to Verify Grounded Generation
| 2024-06-08T06:04:55 | 2024-06-24T07:39:26 |
I-Hung Hsu, Zifeng Wang, Long T. Le, Lesly Miculicich, Nanyun Peng, Chen-Yu Lee, Tomas Pfister
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Grounded generation aims to equip language models (LMs) with the ability to
produce more credible and accountable responses by accurately citing verifiable
sources. However, existing methods, by either feeding LMs with raw or
preprocessed materials, remain prone to errors. To address this, we introduce
CaLM, a novel verification framework. CaLM leverages the insight that a robust
grounded response should be consistent with information derived solely from its
cited sources. Our framework empowers smaller LMs, which rely less on
parametric memory and excel at processing relevant information given a query,
to validate the output of larger LMs. Larger LM responses that closely align
with the smaller LMs' output, which relies exclusively on cited documents, are
verified. Responses showing discrepancies are iteratively refined through a
feedback loop. Experiments on three open-domain question-answering datasets
demonstrate significant performance gains of 1.5% to 7% absolute average
without any required model fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.3123738765716553,
-0.9752647280693054,
0.7463211417198181,
0.2098340094089508,
-0.04496026411652565,
0.2409711629152298,
-0.5580646991729736,
-0.20130720734596252,
-0.17433300614356995,
0.13345055282115936,
-0.4574936628341675,
-0.3240455389022827,
-0.2189575582742691,
0.07864245772361755,
-0.4703894555568695,
0.5796678066253662,
0.02999332919716835,
-0.05266386643052101,
-0.35551315546035767,
-0.17232663929462433,
-0.31955021619796753,
-0.3776470720767975,
-0.7362821102142334,
-0.5652554631233215,
0.425307035446167,
0.5283365249633789,
0.7659458518028259,
0.43283647298812866,
0.3099004030227661,
0.3366974890232086,
-0.3060793876647949,
0.1690060943365097,
-0.6262288689613342,
0.18350082635879517,
-0.46444764733314514,
-0.26465022563934326,
-0.2367926388978958,
-0.1559116244316101,
0.5978112816810608,
0.4791696071624756,
-0.04418939724564552,
0.20417116582393646,
-0.043106868863105774,
0.4139149785041809,
-0.7783888578414917,
-0.1844312846660614,
-0.7913591265678406,
-0.042509615421295166,
0.288565069437027,
-0.07886579632759094,
-0.8671825528144836,
-0.5379125475883484,
-0.4075620174407959,
-0.20996691286563873,
0.3394359052181244,
0.11762413382530212,
1.2222970724105835,
0.35423770546913147,
-0.6024454236030579,
-0.19849398732185364,
-0.853503406047821,
0.8342458605766296,
-0.7689948678016663,
0.4127299189567566,
0.5410985946655273,
0.22403880953788757,
-0.17068994045257568,
-0.8783780336380005,
-0.8007645010948181,
-0.4049229323863983,
-0.06101559102535248,
0.2013940066099167,
0.08855277299880981,
-0.10573142766952515,
0.4311310946941376,
0.6689127087593079,
-0.4182441532611847,
0.22985970973968506,
-0.0437922403216362,
-0.15295091271400452,
0.44665050506591797,
-0.10810279101133347,
0.19870705902576447,
-0.07019521296024323,
-0.19817329943180084,
-0.23549729585647583,
-0.7868722081184387,
0.3916897177696228,
0.15904372930526733,
0.4695926904678345,
-0.2703731656074524,
0.7166054248809814,
-0.39162445068359375,
0.45968908071517944,
0.593866229057312,
-0.3165558874607086,
-0.04879144951701164,
-0.1753871738910675,
-0.3260267674922943,
0.05078340694308281,
0.5506146550178528,
0.43091392517089844,
0.07023926824331284,
0.026120467111468315,
-0.2980111837387085,
-0.055604081600904465,
0.13161718845367432,
-0.9778435230255127,
-0.07912106066942215,
0.588144838809967,
-0.3122204542160034,
-0.4365761876106262,
-0.0670492872595787,
-0.7757148742675781,
-0.6472996473312378,
-0.3311682641506195,
0.09594464302062988,
-0.11307667940855026,
-0.520567774772644,
0.00767885148525238,
0.1734415888786316,
0.3604147732257843,
0.3787562847137451,
-0.6240029335021973,
0.16432003676891327,
0.7873287200927734,
0.5684127807617188,
0.22500523924827576,
-0.130186066031456,
-0.8491805791854858,
-0.11027244478464127,
-0.5736116170883179,
0.741981029510498,
-0.40148285031318665,
-0.13044312596321106,
0.4453731179237366,
-0.030552469193935394,
0.0633680671453476,
-0.4220360517501831,
0.8980702757835388,
-0.6112043857574463,
0.24102391302585602,
-0.5473788976669312,
-0.38705721497535706,
0.11611928045749664,
0.5417559146881104,
-0.49753624200820923,
1.5284799337387085,
0.14462777972221375,
-0.9407110810279846,
0.514542281627655,
0.012327782809734344,
-0.4660308361053467,
-0.1852964162826538,
-0.35596129298210144,
-0.4210117757320404,
0.2797745168209076,
0.06793287396430969,
0.32857638597488403,
-0.7114133238792419,
0.6508434414863586,
-0.5882434844970703,
-0.24064625799655914,
0.44879692792892456,
-0.24352478981018066,
0.681641161441803,
0.4651825428009033,
-0.5112614035606384,
0.3340156674385071,
-1.1939606666564941,
0.5565103888511658,
0.2410532385110855,
-0.49204766750335693,
-0.14816607534885406,
0.07375330477952957,
-0.10298402607440948,
0.41512930393218994,
-0.08022817969322205,
-0.5946210026741028,
-0.12166732549667358,
-0.023616602644324303,
0.49060767889022827,
0.45380091667175293,
0.15615668892860413,
0.3822264075279236,
-0.3615628778934479,
0.40869584679603577,
0.17402680218219757,
-0.23500384390354156,
-0.4721725881099701,
-0.1564507931470871,
-0.9002217054367065,
-0.4836784303188324,
0.30171528458595276,
0.3616451621055603,
-0.7108728885650635,
0.536811351776123,
-0.3496403396129608,
-0.4500969648361206,
-0.4164755642414093,
0.21689367294311523,
0.23695148527622223,
0.8442511558532715,
0.35896071791648865,
0.16579826176166534,
-0.582925021648407,
-0.5491814613342285,
-0.2714928090572357,
-0.5542043447494507,
-0.20487596094608307,
0.29280588030815125,
0.18764299154281616,
-0.19936007261276245,
1.163666844367981,
-0.19411306083202362,
0.4075755774974823,
-0.08476302027702332,
0.4336118996143341,
0.07616492360830307,
0.6937742233276367,
0.4426218867301941,
-0.5846046805381775,
-0.42096173763275146,
0.07782959192991257,
-0.755751371383667,
-0.30148810148239136,
-0.33300819993019104,
-0.04129401594400406,
-0.1385548859834671,
0.8920056819915771,
-0.7070901989936829,
0.24281072616577148,
0.3402149975299835,
-0.37454599142074585,
0.2583998739719391,
-0.013884704560041428,
0.27646404504776,
-0.8912939429283142,
0.21964789927005768,
-0.3220343589782715,
-0.5548673868179321,
-0.3840240240097046,
0.41438502073287964,
0.3494235873222351,
-0.283877432346344,
-0.249326691031456,
0.4203662872314453,
-0.41762804985046387,
0.25800982117652893,
-0.28831255435943604,
0.11914496123790741,
0.24970532953739166,
0.12642407417297363,
-0.1639089286327362,
0.748157262802124,
0.6157345175743103,
-0.5676336884498596,
0.0592142790555954,
-0.12452574819326401,
-0.23763693869113922,
0.7643428444862366,
-0.904273509979248,
0.5118045210838318,
-0.3095545172691345,
0.2618221044540405,
-0.9821135401725769,
-0.6349024176597595,
-0.19760406017303467,
-0.1722646951675415,
0.26899123191833496,
-0.26341143250465393,
-0.6474509239196777,
-0.45750129222869873,
-0.2525426745414734,
0.2942987382411957,
0.758674681186676,
-0.753570556640625,
0.7899549603462219,
0.0041832285933196545,
-0.19417211413383484,
-0.41716891527175903,
-0.5512697100639343,
-0.14547517895698547,
-0.18827760219573975,
-0.5602114796638489,
-0.21368567645549774,
-0.13549639284610748,
-0.7622663378715515,
-0.12396895885467529,
-0.21129246056079865,
-0.2995465099811554,
0.39489784836769104,
0.36027801036834717,
-0.18841667473316193,
-0.6718571186065674,
0.2253878265619278,
0.13962948322296143,
0.1554642915725708,
0.06525721400976181,
-0.19036760926246643,
0.40656572580337524,
-0.2862069010734558,
-0.48543158173561096,
-0.11971694231033325,
0.47860535979270935,
0.9575653076171875,
-0.17994152009487152,
0.7190433144569397,
0.5390058755874634,
-0.5717941522598267,
-0.3413689136505127,
-0.5975461602210999,
-0.28375542163848877,
-0.5174579620361328,
-0.24099966883659363,
-0.44503846764564514,
-0.974648118019104,
0.6908249258995056,
-0.39637017250061035,
0.011878852732479572,
0.4460417628288269,
0.6668120622634888,
0.1526254117488861,
1.1121251583099365,
0.5864001512527466,
0.16268813610076904,
0.07876645028591156,
0.38135311007499695,
0.490448921918869,
-0.19075067341327667,
-0.26499685645103455,
-1.1344666481018066,
-0.041212048381567,
-0.22497832775115967,
-0.4983941614627838,
-0.4167870581150055,
0.507672131061554,
-0.5003089904785156,
-0.17491553723812103,
-0.12776051461696625,
0.6284059882164001,
0.4191667437553406,
-0.16060616075992584,
0.25438088178634644,
-0.12076611071825027,
-0.5860163569450378,
-0.11103596538305283,
-0.5347092747688293,
-0.7479220628738403,
0.6502975225448608,
0.47123169898986816,
0.7141806483268738,
0.125355526804924,
0.48454487323760986,
0.07023842632770538,
0.7024812698364258,
-0.754734456539154,
0.5628193020820618,
0.4089873135089874,
-0.7290679216384888,
0.07318812608718872,
-0.4764111042022705,
-0.49976810812950134,
0.255968302488327,
-0.22263328731060028,
-0.48151224851608276,
0.23616747558116913,
0.2623021602630615,
-0.43037235736846924,
0.08250483870506287,
-0.750505268573761,
0.4674011468887329,
-0.13412189483642578,
-0.9161756038665771,
0.11032771319150925,
-0.559637725353241,
0.5154139399528503,
-0.12299264222383499,
0.193793386220932,
-0.2712373435497284,
0.39118051528930664,
0.08867397159337997,
-0.5265348553657532,
0.7535169720649719,
-0.12375538051128387,
-0.403809130191803,
0.4942758083343506,
0.12691523134708405,
0.5197126865386963,
0.3010648787021637,
-0.28633004426956177,
-0.34330105781555176,
-0.2556225061416626,
-0.45218425989151,
-0.49379101395606995,
1.0546882152557373,
-0.5731414556503296,
-0.4824022650718689,
-0.4613938629627228,
-0.33552244305610657,
-0.514312744140625,
0.5840214490890503,
0.34771233797073364,
0.1602456271648407,
-0.34323298931121826,
0.5430237650871277,
0.7131500840187073,
-0.1461860090494156,
0.3004975914955139,
0.6674381494522095,
-0.514388918876648,
-0.4783557653427124,
0.4054810404777527,
-0.3179935812950134,
0.18402442336082458,
0.2589308023452759,
0.2650049924850464,
-0.2417164146900177,
-0.36609840393066406,
-0.3510270416736603,
-0.05364969000220299,
-0.8969783782958984,
-0.3086378276348114,
-0.6052414178848267,
-0.10887257009744644,
-0.5032687783241272,
-0.37765607237815857,
-0.6000080704689026,
-0.18239952623844147,
-0.028147170320153236,
-0.500015377998352,
0.19936427474021912,
0.5573711395263672,
-0.03363487124443054,
0.20235411822795868,
-0.5048215389251709,
0.4880017340183258,
0.46800094842910767,
0.30651894211769104,
-0.2110436111688614,
-0.47366008162498474,
-0.03142712265253067,
0.2224515676498413,
-0.06243555620312691,
-0.7885373830795288,
-0.06995557248592377,
0.27082639932632446,
0.3522646725177765,
0.7764250636100769,
0.385625958442688,
0.8316715955734253,
-0.5678930878639221,
0.9971989393234253,
0.08661845326423645,
-1.098036527633667,
0.6533803343772888,
-0.4521242082118988,
0.31436091661453247,
1.067137598991394,
0.03750649094581604,
-0.07765628397464752,
-0.5123364925384521,
-0.8826791048049927,
-1.0058479309082031,
0.19644178450107574,
0.13183826208114624,
0.054603323340415955,
-0.052782200276851654,
0.3818918764591217,
-0.10102935135364532,
0.2728922963142395,
-0.7295293807983398,
0.1253412365913391,
-0.29768237471580505,
-0.23704519867897034,
-0.1218101978302002,
-0.6124333739280701,
-0.5178509950637817,
-0.12576918303966522,
0.5552701354026794,
-0.3953102231025696,
0.046081122010946274,
0.3176989257335663,
-0.1489734798669815,
-0.5213665962219238,
0.475630521774292,
0.8037500381469727,
0.5155704617500305,
-0.27547022700309753,
0.7829506993293762,
-0.015282138250768185,
-0.1730692982673645,
0.4884824752807617,
-0.24949459731578827,
-0.5953037142753601,
0.313351035118103,
0.2812964916229248,
0.4697936475276947,
0.3821342885494232,
-0.7503047585487366,
0.4236695468425751,
-0.2584249675273895,
-0.06717773526906967,
-0.26162317395210266,
-0.17376886308193207,
0.027066024020314217,
-0.05061090365052223,
0.19752836227416992,
0.18833157420158386,
-0.2563665807247162,
-0.4481537640094757,
0.2666887044906616,
-0.03356616199016571,
-0.2858758270740509,
-0.4614775776863098,
0.7298538684844971,
0.10829702019691467,
-0.11344913393259048,
0.5093157291412354,
-0.21198007464408875,
-0.2720307409763336,
0.4858056306838989,
0.6557074189186096,
1.046471118927002,
-0.1358538269996643,
0.21731336414813995,
0.673749566078186,
0.5563316345214844,
-0.3601756691932678,
0.6706398129463196,
-0.0883694738149643,
-0.6430186033248901,
-0.34447455406188965,
-0.3903801143169403,
-0.6509038805961609,
0.4797896146774292,
-1.0776909589767456,
0.051897987723350525,
-0.9083104729652405,
-0.24477829039096832,
-0.4302193522453308,
-0.22551770508289337,
-0.6326584219932556,
0.43494683504104614,
-0.03910553455352783,
1.0814152956008911,
-1.1449415683746338,
0.7889935374259949,
0.9196091294288635,
-0.3667466342449188,
-1.2503442764282227,
0.37341442704200745,
0.15567749738693237,
-0.427670419216156,
0.519935131072998,
0.2753310203552246,
-0.3729155957698822,
-0.023420602083206177,
-0.8830106258392334,
-0.6687340140342712,
0.8697945475578308,
0.6061394214630127,
-0.30992767214775085,
0.5791088938713074,
-0.12375802546739578,
0.7726677656173706,
-0.262265145778656,
0.10928402841091156,
0.4294329881668091,
0.38150063157081604,
0.30814966559410095,
-0.5476523041725159,
0.2078624963760376,
-0.5219310522079468,
-0.07308758795261383,
-0.38382622599601746,
-0.5543088316917419,
0.7411724328994751,
-0.2172507345676422,
-0.41402408480644226,
0.2152896672487259,
1.0106104612350464,
0.6775900721549988,
0.5765345096588135,
0.3559858202934265,
0.5094922780990601,
1.3386858701705933,
-0.2887873351573944,
1.0982915163040161,
-0.4704199731349945,
0.36836400628089905,
1.4472960233688354,
-0.9689992666244507,
1.1019291877746582,
0.6455185413360596,
0.14468063414096832,
0.5253803133964539,
0.5425626039505005,
0.3782024383544922,
0.36756008863449097,
0.2402789145708084,
-0.37844881415367126,
-0.25643688440322876,
-0.32110169529914856,
-0.5640797019004822,
0.18758843839168549,
0.13273988664150238,
-0.2719159424304962,
-0.16050057113170624,
-0.12092496454715729,
0.3933488130569458,
0.6085581183433533,
-0.32385388016700745,
0.5648953318595886,
0.05306228622794151,
-1.0797139406204224,
0.748816192150116,
0.2886190116405487,
0.08207085728645325,
-0.5138487219810486,
0.292854368686676,
-0.5457484722137451,
0.5628126859664917,
-0.13112255930900574,
-0.23771578073501587,
0.005095615983009338,
0.3707438111305237,
-0.2826812267303467,
-0.5901843905448914,
1.0965412855148315,
-0.404257595539093,
-0.33164140582084656,
0.025240154936909676,
0.47071191668510437,
-0.3213663101196289,
0.10155666619539261,
-0.33732765913009644,
0.3121541142463684,
-0.1303853839635849,
-0.2332533746957779,
0.05593693628907204,
0.8642454147338867,
0.07953640073537827,
0.5993532538414001,
0.7639625668525696,
-0.08050772547721863,
0.2921549081802368,
0.19400550425052643,
0.8918094635009766,
-0.5561561584472656,
-0.6433466672897339,
-0.44224610924720764,
0.7820809483528137,
-0.3973369896411896,
-0.33672142028808594,
1.095828652381897,
0.3997712731361389,
0.5592126846313477,
-0.25140875577926636,
0.6651678681373596,
0.013300083577632904,
0.6411865949630737,
-0.6485397219657898,
0.45779022574424744,
-0.19731871783733368,
0.3234197497367859,
0.005305747967213392,
-0.7093204259872437,
-0.28937992453575134,
0.8755860328674316,
-0.16165710985660553,
0.2069578915834427,
1.0175994634628296,
0.738518238067627,
-0.12838521599769592,
0.003379242494702339,
0.2931520938873291,
0.4704081416130066,
0.3617649972438812,
0.0783117413520813,
1.211775302886963,
-0.2970307767391205,
0.04044566676020622,
-0.23417939245700836,
-0.1523772031068802,
-0.3190867304801941,
-1.3265529870986938,
-1.0287959575653076,
-0.12331091612577438,
-0.7289961576461792,
-0.9181658029556274,
-0.2959625720977783,
0.9428145885467529,
0.6746363639831543,
-1.1496729850769043,
0.03561306744813919,
-0.3245564103126526,
0.0353265255689621,
-0.334121435880661,
-0.2479257583618164,
0.004566635005176067,
-0.316019743680954,
-0.5103082656860352,
0.7810564041137695,
0.23812322318553925,
0.11286403238773346,
-0.18222855031490326,
-0.0793977752327919,
-0.05055711790919304,
0.5645874738693237,
0.4745336174964905,
0.7537668347358704,
-0.6756637692451477,
-0.4577620327472687,
0.07317004352807999,
-0.592985987663269,
-0.039941608905792236,
1.2925946712493896,
-0.6828121542930603,
0.3292968273162842,
0.5614640712738037,
0.7752976417541504,
0.07118784636259079,
0.25399935245513916,
0.5537531971931458,
-0.9886021614074707,
0.508922815322876,
0.24959133565425873,
0.45608818531036377,
0.5282976627349854,
-0.3712175190448761,
0.3553287386894226,
-0.01624995283782482,
-0.4738132059574127,
-1.2709238529205322,
0.37946125864982605,
-1.1728947162628174,
0.060725823044776917,
1.4250425100326538,
-0.4537850022315979,
0.15803110599517822,
-0.2658024728298187,
-0.16516844928264618,
-0.08972428739070892,
-0.1148511990904808,
0.7681677937507629,
0.806125283241272,
0.6290917992591858,
-0.32281413674354553,
-0.2899969816207886,
0.4729328453540802,
0.668189287185669,
-0.822583794593811,
0.13048242032527924,
0.6783269643783569,
0.21501588821411133,
0.20289354026317596,
0.6642942428588867,
-0.08187856525182724,
0.17039795219898224,
0.2383325695991516,
-0.0844530463218689,
0.059953927993774414,
-0.32254964113235474,
-0.5439081788063049,
0.6579967737197876,
0.5745856165885925,
0.30644312500953674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05361v1
|
Write Summary Step-by-Step: A Pilot Study of Stepwise Summarization
| 2024-06-08T05:37:26 | 2024-06-08T05:37:26 |
Xiuying Chen, Shen Gao, Mingzhe Li, Qingqing Zhu, Xin Gao, Xiangliang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Nowadays, neural text generation has made tremendous progress in abstractive
summarization tasks. However, most of the existing summarization models take in
the whole document all at once, which sometimes cannot meet the needs in
practice. Practically, social text streams such as news events and tweets keep
growing from time to time, and can only be fed to the summarization system step
by step. Hence, in this paper, we propose the task of Stepwise Summarization,
which aims to generate a new appended summary each time a new document is
proposed. The appended summary should not only summarize the newly added
content but also be coherent with the previous summary, to form an up-to-date
complete summary. To tackle this challenge, we design an adversarial learning
model, named Stepwise Summary Generator (SSG). First, SSG selectively processes
the new document under the guidance of the previous summary, obtaining polished
document representation. Next, SSG generates the summary considering both the
previous summary and the document. Finally, a convolutional-based discriminator
is employed to determine whether the newly generated summary is coherent with
the previous summary. For the experiment, we extend the traditional two-step
update summarization setting to a multi-step stepwise setting, and re-propose a
large-scale stepwise summarization dataset based on a public story generation
dataset. Extensive experiments on this dataset show that SSG achieves
state-of-the-art performance in terms of both automatic metrics and human
evaluations. Ablation studies demonstrate the effectiveness of each module in
our framework. We also discuss the benefits and limitations of recent large
language models on this task.
|
[
-0.08041484653949738,
-0.7659997940063477,
0.40456128120422363,
0.1895848959684372,
-0.39058345556259155,
0.20371904969215393,
0.009449333883821964,
-0.31015685200691223,
0.21521851420402527,
0.43390241265296936,
-0.36833688616752625,
-0.599540114402771,
-0.7773639559745789,
0.007785198278725147,
-0.8844995498657227,
1.3841313123703003,
-0.005282511468976736,
-0.16100910305976868,
0.05987150967121124,
0.10869485139846802,
-0.12421481311321259,
-0.1452338695526123,
-1.2965104579925537,
-0.5913895964622498,
0.5540696382522583,
0.11528380960226059,
0.7315393090248108,
0.610723614692688,
0.15737316012382507,
0.32878220081329346,
-0.2437179833650589,
0.17457708716392517,
-0.40126773715019226,
0.2094152867794037,
0.09229644387960434,
-0.2868456542491913,
-0.5260795950889587,
-0.08335743099451065,
0.634289562702179,
0.6897797584533691,
-0.04673419147729874,
-0.000012639718988793902,
0.11515180766582489,
0.8240200281143188,
-0.3553657531738281,
0.034436166286468506,
-0.46123042702674866,
-0.01646493189036846,
0.2499009221792221,
-0.11919555068016052,
-0.3340790569782257,
-0.6235688924789429,
-0.04762087017297745,
-0.4226447343826294,
0.6443179845809937,
-0.37335139513015747,
0.4937525689601898,
0.014526336453855038,
-0.38709890842437744,
-0.5094431042671204,
-0.6487962007522583,
0.3123566210269928,
-0.7163194417953491,
-0.0010189046151936054,
0.06212266907095909,
0.03508537635207176,
-0.14622902870178223,
-0.7291225790977478,
-0.3929923474788666,
-0.19868279993534088,
-0.013825378380715847,
0.2467436045408249,
-0.10408290475606918,
-0.1452864110469818,
-0.07935144752264023,
0.3213315010070801,
-0.5815808773040771,
-0.11755632609128952,
-0.4988528788089752,
-0.14675560593605042,
0.909447431564331,
0.27486392855644226,
0.0888696238398552,
-0.1620904952287674,
-0.28377947211265564,
-0.10803341865539551,
-0.5661716461181641,
-0.14992369711399078,
0.3696599304676056,
0.5000547170639038,
-0.1866660863161087,
0.4902336299419403,
-0.30928951501846313,
0.3628799021244049,
0.29265928268432617,
-0.017944037914276123,
0.10148824006319046,
-0.6200173497200012,
-0.06768874824047089,
0.37805652618408203,
1.0527846813201904,
0.6428603529930115,
0.29167670011520386,
-0.14765286445617676,
-0.2262783795595169,
-0.23964528739452362,
0.47970178723335266,
-0.8904010057449341,
-0.2823258340358734,
0.38152986764907837,
-0.5015735626220703,
-0.8763787150382996,
-0.23822878301143646,
-0.5430545210838318,
-0.7266245484352112,
-0.2683444023132324,
0.42599496245384216,
-0.5669732689857483,
-0.07301145792007446,
-0.09366951882839203,
-0.2796311676502228,
-0.1475200057029724,
0.6693012118339539,
-0.7163134217262268,
0.12648837268352509,
0.6212556958198547,
1.0695701837539673,
-0.0649271085858345,
-0.6300048232078552,
-0.534250795841217,
0.08060364425182343,
-0.6079022884368896,
0.47536006569862366,
-0.022932378575205803,
-0.40768811106681824,
0.16944687068462372,
-0.1778518110513687,
0.03306009992957115,
-0.16876816749572754,
0.1593204289674759,
-0.5939231514930725,
0.2063608318567276,
-0.09332816302776337,
-0.2941790521144867,
-0.13095086812973022,
0.3028409779071808,
-0.46829551458358765,
0.7286929488182068,
-0.07067310065031052,
-1.0297755002975464,
0.30126816034317017,
-0.3488086462020874,
-1.0807074308395386,
-0.2893419861793518,
-0.0011766502866521478,
-0.6766987442970276,
0.3178822696208954,
0.2988530695438385,
0.7173823118209839,
0.2190268337726593,
0.2637731730937958,
-0.10584726184606552,
-0.3386508822441101,
0.01780415140092373,
-0.361442506313324,
0.8162690997123718,
0.10622557252645493,
-0.04835459217429161,
0.3446599245071411,
-0.8439590930938721,
-0.5138960480690002,
0.09623312950134277,
-0.6485390663146973,
-0.17982910573482513,
0.19740457832813263,
-0.19526438415050507,
0.043764159083366394,
0.3042881488800049,
-0.43634939193725586,
0.15781649947166443,
-0.26531264185905457,
0.20879624783992767,
0.6112394332885742,
0.4394904375076294,
0.5973032712936401,
-0.5303699374198914,
0.39064136147499084,
0.01656382344663143,
0.057358719408512115,
-0.7622165679931641,
-0.18442168831825256,
-0.5826395750045776,
0.10078267008066177,
0.3497195541858673,
0.47126322984695435,
-1.0005714893341064,
0.3141341209411621,
-0.2727024555206299,
-0.4449926018714905,
-0.11262234300374985,
0.03798279911279678,
0.3911387026309967,
0.4771654009819031,
0.17447537183761597,
-0.01823504827916622,
-0.5038424730300903,
-0.5499838590621948,
-0.22277778387069702,
-0.3717579245567322,
-0.20803888142108917,
-0.34123730659484863,
0.5165062546730042,
0.17039276659488678,
0.36860546469688416,
-0.5765488147735596,
-0.11596555262804031,
-0.6285536885261536,
0.585289716720581,
-0.01096755638718605,
0.30747464299201965,
0.281657874584198,
-0.7179014086723328,
-0.3439561724662781,
0.03913743793964386,
-0.8314164280891418,
0.17209263145923615,
-0.7412149906158447,
-0.022171035408973694,
0.2026582509279251,
0.7239794731140137,
-0.5280544757843018,
0.36774447560310364,
0.3488691449165344,
-0.32565629482269287,
0.4409835636615753,
-0.44782695174217224,
0.17716878652572632,
-1.4522308111190796,
-0.05828434228897095,
0.01731751300394535,
-0.3197697699069977,
-0.7285031080245972,
0.12129388004541397,
0.12423362582921982,
-0.13516385853290558,
-0.3973272144794464,
0.35419759154319763,
-0.26914966106414795,
0.11770154535770416,
-0.5334622263908386,
0.19984234869480133,
-0.16149456799030304,
0.4468953013420105,
0.018866214901208878,
0.3810051381587982,
0.25853654742240906,
-0.7137713432312012,
0.3123847246170044,
0.3981506824493408,
0.01854494959115982,
0.19440756738185883,
-0.5668866634368896,
-0.2290942519903183,
-0.44620344042778015,
0.5979933738708496,
-0.9668301939964294,
-0.3844815492630005,
0.0216219462454319,
-0.8814500570297241,
0.4349689185619354,
0.009903543628752232,
-0.3615388572216034,
-0.11930341273546219,
-0.7682192325592041,
-0.09305617958307266,
0.2264297604560852,
-0.44870322942733765,
0.8192818760871887,
0.12793302536010742,
-0.45340943336486816,
-0.30298709869384766,
-0.6874584555625916,
0.37518957257270813,
-0.06354060024023056,
-0.551650881767273,
0.23068194091320038,
0.17000651359558105,
-0.19292283058166504,
-0.12779651582241058,
-0.05299960821866989,
0.26080217957496643,
0.1275309920310974,
0.038991063833236694,
0.12170977890491486,
0.1650838851928711,
-0.16157570481300354,
0.097877636551857,
0.05098376423120499,
0.22629410028457642,
-0.08353782445192337,
0.2870897650718689,
0.35702669620513916,
0.04544716328382492,
-0.1878015100955963,
0.5419979691505432,
0.5620162487030029,
-0.0740518867969513,
0.5226815938949585,
0.768526554107666,
-0.37064284086227417,
-0.35217347741127014,
-0.012144011445343494,
0.09841400384902954,
-0.41475921869277954,
0.5004940629005432,
-0.07862838357686996,
-0.5608465075492859,
0.6243026852607727,
0.23299790918827057,
0.5450869798660278,
0.4274309575557709,
0.5124109387397766,
-0.0752943903207779,
0.9950996041297913,
0.4958555996417999,
-0.16027189791202545,
0.6879465579986572,
-0.3279312551021576,
0.034824371337890625,
-0.699510931968689,
-0.18696139752864838,
-0.30917391180992126,
-0.27369651198387146,
-0.3805869519710541,
-0.13433383405208588,
0.25724324584007263,
0.15288498997688293,
0.06466402113437653,
0.39830341935157776,
-0.3104701638221741,
0.32185646891593933,
0.5778254270553589,
0.3268927037715912,
0.28566932678222656,
-0.2606448531150818,
0.0721055343747139,
0.5942499041557312,
-0.6199209094047546,
-0.30790701508522034,
1.2385066747665405,
0.1529824137687683,
0.6503198742866516,
-0.025073587894439697,
1.1490927934646606,
0.5499517321586609,
0.36045706272125244,
-0.49160444736480713,
0.6266708374023438,
-0.3572370111942291,
-0.23661696910858154,
-0.4374610185623169,
-0.4349745810031891,
-0.7513028979301453,
0.32293617725372314,
-0.17978690564632416,
-0.4075745940208435,
-0.005625776015222073,
0.21059828996658325,
-0.45965832471847534,
0.2518935799598694,
-0.549956202507019,
0.39418041706085205,
-0.052930086851119995,
-0.19365179538726807,
-0.1391141265630722,
-0.7402717471122742,
0.5689583420753479,
-0.2016480714082718,
0.15493112802505493,
0.2815215289592743,
0.0684167891740799,
0.616432785987854,
-0.43979978561401367,
0.7959843277931213,
-0.15675564110279083,
-0.15118055045604706,
0.32009151577949524,
0.050259608775377274,
0.8772550225257874,
0.05278020724654198,
0.0020507134031504393,
-0.13756069540977478,
-0.5538175702095032,
-0.2935396730899811,
-0.4180443584918976,
0.7643641829490662,
-0.35419926047325134,
-0.3747257888317108,
-0.408272385597229,
-0.45075780153274536,
0.04145941510796547,
0.28039708733558655,
0.40399685502052307,
0.5906484127044678,
-0.4187735915184021,
-0.05745256319642067,
0.6014333963394165,
-0.20443671941757202,
0.7676154971122742,
0.32578620314598083,
-0.23240943253040314,
-0.6611392498016357,
0.9289885759353638,
0.023776574060320854,
0.2654227316379547,
0.4241957366466522,
0.13857197761535645,
-0.24463491141796112,
-1.1328588724136353,
-0.5465685129165649,
0.12649640440940857,
-0.5052068829536438,
-0.08399453014135361,
-0.8222124576568604,
-0.31893298029899597,
-0.5735066533088684,
-0.6128762364387512,
-0.123851478099823,
-0.48431864380836487,
-0.1628795564174652,
-0.2105933278799057,
0.009959561750292778,
0.9663837552070618,
-0.17291948199272156,
0.21943950653076172,
-0.6285348534584045,
0.7085070610046387,
0.13980694115161896,
0.02666478045284748,
0.2820287346839905,
-0.2777228057384491,
-0.4573582112789154,
-0.04786824434995651,
-0.5375649929046631,
-0.6473333835601807,
0.2524562180042267,
-0.004949011839926243,
0.17170365154743195,
0.3101491332054138,
0.2837549149990082,
0.3948203921318054,
-0.5932192802429199,
0.8886234164237976,
0.3543880581855774,
-0.6111099720001221,
0.6221610903739929,
-0.7812963128089905,
0.7206600904464722,
0.6182994842529297,
0.2098044455051422,
-0.380820631980896,
-0.9184931516647339,
-0.6180060505867004,
-1.0832610130310059,
0.6545009613037109,
0.4092029631137848,
0.09225501120090485,
-0.12276429682970047,
0.29689741134643555,
0.018425341695547104,
0.28075188398361206,
-0.3588021695613861,
-0.15214332938194275,
-0.3152967393398285,
-0.2888451814651489,
-0.32764679193496704,
0.009166156873106956,
-0.010907978750765324,
0.0554056279361248,
0.8149933815002441,
-0.05905396118760109,
0.003643007716163993,
0.18795055150985718,
0.056445684283971786,
0.01364218257367611,
0.07794442027807236,
0.5898360013961792,
0.5702430009841919,
-0.10174687951803207,
0.0247157271951437,
0.1728133112192154,
-0.5648897290229797,
-0.03534887731075287,
0.42105698585510254,
-0.6135345101356506,
0.1810164898633957,
0.7885915040969849,
0.5953928828239441,
0.20000040531158447,
-0.24644289910793304,
0.6571938395500183,
-0.1923057734966278,
-0.6807354688644409,
-0.3560430705547333,
0.1572503000497818,
0.1372797191143036,
0.3717987835407257,
0.4751631021499634,
0.3468901813030243,
0.3069203794002533,
-0.5442935824394226,
0.2682245671749115,
0.21390840411186218,
-0.20051856338977814,
-0.35412687063217163,
0.9615742564201355,
0.3071507513523102,
-0.32690560817718506,
0.2636164426803589,
-0.271670937538147,
-0.5687851309776306,
0.5768137574195862,
0.29303911328315735,
1.2296724319458008,
-0.12440235912799835,
0.4829699695110321,
0.49101072549819946,
0.24658943712711334,
-0.25505802035331726,
0.21583139896392822,
-0.1689051389694214,
-0.367098867893219,
-0.4292890131473541,
-0.7018076181411743,
-0.34029093384742737,
0.21703080832958221,
-0.5071256756782532,
0.16846530139446259,
-0.418287992477417,
0.13777567446231842,
0.37761566042900085,
0.031139541417360306,
-0.12674470245838165,
0.4982675015926361,
0.13884656131267548,
0.7961984276771545,
-0.9257152676582336,
0.5089691281318665,
0.5498252511024475,
-0.4599425494670868,
-0.39628490805625916,
0.3781580328941345,
0.1660548895597458,
-0.4815925657749176,
-0.07667087763547897,
0.002122456207871437,
-0.07834039628505707,
-0.34762272238731384,
-0.1339796483516693,
-0.6019271016120911,
1.1959980726242065,
0.07737518846988678,
-0.2129095047712326,
-0.4004361033439636,
-0.16722546517848969,
0.6702625155448914,
-0.2995094954967499,
-0.037924256175756454,
0.3067309260368347,
0.14275525510311127,
0.45654362440109253,
-0.4203186333179474,
0.2266194224357605,
-0.29109033942222595,
0.03192261978983879,
0.40042635798454285,
-0.6942199468612671,
0.9625616073608398,
-0.5303745269775391,
-0.08772537857294083,
0.06605019420385361,
0.6559672951698303,
0.1096266359090805,
0.5062596797943115,
0.3571632504463196,
0.34425345063209534,
0.4365547299385071,
0.07129073143005371,
1.2146199941635132,
-0.17576459050178528,
-0.022939858958125114,
1.4185420274734497,
0.17277538776397705,
0.6407377123832703,
0.06781602650880814,
-0.011065054684877396,
0.11020725965499878,
0.5869623422622681,
0.0629132017493248,
0.5366954803466797,
0.1729309856891632,
-0.26882627606391907,
-0.059757571667432785,
0.2276952564716339,
-0.13974127173423767,
0.37230566143989563,
-0.05286046117544174,
-0.717247486114502,
-0.5847475528717041,
-0.1094658151268959,
0.3820195496082306,
0.08919402956962585,
-0.5500272512435913,
1.0576742887496948,
-0.07773170620203018,
-0.8738589882850647,
0.19417057931423187,
0.004485636483877897,
0.4280746877193451,
-0.7542605996131897,
-0.019089119508862495,
-0.26027190685272217,
0.28257063031196594,
-0.2967557907104492,
-0.7446897625923157,
0.44100531935691833,
0.12529438734054565,
-0.20794638991355896,
-0.40126797556877136,
0.5230011940002441,
-0.6060727834701538,
-0.6858536005020142,
0.14545950293540955,
0.08530886471271515,
-0.03916008397936821,
-0.12383776158094406,
-0.4927898645401001,
-0.04290923848748207,
0.306366503238678,
-0.48302045464515686,
0.347087562084198,
0.4976781904697418,
-0.05168859660625458,
0.5000463128089905,
0.5784473419189453,
0.3050186336040497,
-0.13834112882614136,
0.33093854784965515,
0.88120436668396,
-0.5675309896469116,
-0.8010522127151489,
-0.8588611483573914,
0.6516696214675903,
-0.22757726907730103,
-0.37228119373321533,
0.7394694685935974,
0.7872145771980286,
0.6612957715988159,
0.28781941533088684,
1.23634672164917,
-0.1180085763335228,
0.4749646782875061,
-0.5250529646873474,
0.8519198894500732,
-0.5399718284606934,
0.14217610657215118,
-0.2712058424949646,
-0.5139374732971191,
-0.27169764041900635,
0.18451367318630219,
0.05877290666103363,
-0.0948643833398819,
0.6182571053504944,
0.4158534109592438,
0.2139294594526291,
0.09511014819145203,
0.19214904308319092,
0.23764346539974213,
0.3492973744869232,
0.37268921732902527,
0.6079233288764954,
-0.5958408117294312,
0.697140097618103,
-0.17445167899131775,
-0.194904625415802,
-0.07535406202077866,
-0.8386279940605164,
-1.1267110109329224,
-0.6740410923957825,
-0.46430832147598267,
-0.42527666687965393,
0.27300021052360535,
0.4483128488063812,
0.2803848087787628,
-0.7397164106369019,
-0.019997810944914818,
-0.30988237261772156,
0.08227432519197464,
-0.19897814095020294,
-0.17484667897224426,
0.47615593671798706,
-0.33714765310287476,
-0.6768300533294678,
0.3841797411441803,
-0.0203830786049366,
0.1826229840517044,
-0.20416058599948883,
0.04636676236987114,
-0.18197065591812134,
0.20315995812416077,
0.6330852508544922,
0.02841617353260517,
-0.27936848998069763,
-0.1256176084280014,
-0.47859591245651245,
0.01495009008795023,
-0.17264486849308014,
0.7588497400283813,
-0.4505787193775177,
0.3232865035533905,
0.521624743938446,
0.5249851942062378,
0.8009751439094543,
0.16819459199905396,
0.8610785603523254,
-0.835768461227417,
-0.28119218349456787,
-0.005819419864565134,
0.30253538489341736,
0.45776617527008057,
-0.5152762532234192,
0.3652617335319519,
-0.24441348016262054,
-0.34741970896720886,
-0.40241777896881104,
0.09514576941728592,
-0.7316430807113647,
-0.4783373773097992,
0.9654729962348938,
-0.09871132671833038,
-0.07654733955860138,
0.07398334890604019,
-0.14386901259422302,
0.5236502289772034,
-0.5917908549308777,
0.9126967191696167,
0.5493954420089722,
-0.1946769803762436,
0.10935568064451218,
-0.15644685924053192,
0.5240413546562195,
-0.3059646785259247,
-0.6811065077781677,
0.3244299590587616,
0.6278100609779358,
0.27053481340408325,
0.16298656165599823,
0.80976402759552,
-0.050059974193573,
0.3179470896720886,
0.35227739810943604,
-0.15051253139972687,
-0.42653247714042664,
-0.4499365985393524,
-0.5658280849456787,
0.5531081557273865,
-0.372535765171051,
-0.38567736744880676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05360v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05360v1
|
Flexible and Adaptable Summarization via Expertise Separation
| 2024-06-08T05:31:19 | 2024-06-08T05:31:19 |
Xiuying Chen, Mingzhe Li, Shen Gao, Xin Cheng, Qingqing Zhu, Rui Yan, Xin Gao, Xiangliang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A proficient summarization model should exhibit both flexibility -- the
capacity to handle a range of in-domain summarization tasks, and adaptability
-- the competence to acquire new knowledge and adjust to unseen out-of-domain
tasks. Unlike large language models (LLMs) that achieve this through parameter
scaling, we propose a more parameter-efficient approach in this study. Our
motivation rests on the principle that the general summarization ability to
capture salient information can be shared across different tasks, while the
domain-specific summarization abilities need to be distinct and tailored.
Concretely, we propose MoeSumm, a Mixture-of-Expert Summarization architecture,
which utilizes a main expert for gaining the general summarization capability
and deputy experts that selectively collaborate to meet specific summarization
task requirements. We further propose a max-margin loss to stimulate the
separation of these abilities. Our model's distinct separation of general and
domain-specific summarization abilities grants it with notable flexibility and
adaptability, all while maintaining parameter efficiency. MoeSumm achieves
flexibility by managing summarization across multiple domains with a single
model, utilizing a shared main expert and selected deputy experts. It exhibits
adaptability by tailoring deputy experts to cater to out-of-domain few-shot and
zero-shot scenarios. Experimental results on 11 datasets show the superiority
of our model compared with recent baselines and LLMs. We also provide
statistical and visual evidence of the distinct separation of the two abilities
in MoeSumm (https://github.com/iriscxy/MoE_Summ).
|
[
-0.5566216111183167,
-0.555103600025177,
0.33755892515182495,
0.18960534036159515,
-0.31495386362075806,
0.09961643815040588,
-0.4473816752433777,
-0.3815046548843384,
0.40002694725990295,
0.47219887375831604,
-0.20512545108795166,
-0.35116857290267944,
-1.0080467462539673,
0.08984962105751038,
-0.10863626003265381,
1.1179368495941162,
-0.08882810920476913,
-0.20683753490447998,
-0.5187848806381226,
-0.2968701422214508,
-0.540787935256958,
-0.38791897892951965,
-0.1083793193101883,
-0.22854278981685638,
0.3870329260826111,
0.8210209012031555,
0.5940073728561401,
0.4840124249458313,
0.6819326281547546,
0.22634030878543854,
-0.19562706351280212,
0.40224531292915344,
-0.6128241419792175,
0.2623250484466553,
-0.39743202924728394,
-0.4742709994316101,
-1.1685760021209717,
-0.08583489060401917,
0.53035968542099,
0.8175342679023743,
-0.363837331533432,
-0.027381913736462593,
0.26929548382759094,
0.5764020681381226,
-0.6211667060852051,
0.11727689206600189,
-0.8299238681793213,
-0.48028022050857544,
0.050320982933044434,
-0.18113262951374054,
-0.16606496274471283,
0.08264726400375366,
0.24537044763565063,
-0.6930652856826782,
0.20818446576595306,
-0.25280794501304626,
0.7918547987937927,
0.26400408148765564,
-0.41374069452285767,
-0.038086265325546265,
-0.5791822671890259,
0.8512002229690552,
-0.8164697885513306,
0.04266192391514778,
0.3773858845233917,
0.4543112814426422,
0.26288333535194397,
-0.5335385799407959,
-0.09121624380350113,
0.04699603468179703,
0.15688416361808777,
0.3362194895744324,
-0.03226722776889801,
-0.3007749021053314,
-0.3572283983230591,
0.45434632897377014,
-0.3065098226070404,
0.09196176379919052,
-0.3629193902015686,
0.05766790732741356,
0.8055934309959412,
0.3991519510746002,
0.17653363943099976,
0.06586084514856339,
-0.35399264097213745,
0.3474922478199005,
-0.5369855761528015,
-0.11274035274982452,
0.20562072098255157,
0.3549703359603882,
-0.11565601825714111,
0.5055192112922668,
-0.5026382803916931,
0.46761390566825867,
0.15727347135543823,
-0.38676974177360535,
-0.19577229022979736,
-0.3373851180076599,
-0.18811319768428802,
-0.24968747794628143,
0.4329608082771301,
0.6169100403785706,
0.2848871946334839,
-0.23922201991081238,
-0.15962976217269897,
-0.5180880427360535,
0.3297552764415741,
-0.8378077745437622,
-0.5551242232322693,
0.19404450058937073,
-0.5029208660125732,
-0.0801544338464737,
0.0031254624482244253,
-0.6628192663192749,
-0.23482871055603027,
-0.31877586245536804,
0.5073907971382141,
-0.5980784296989441,
-0.44903114438056946,
0.05509555712342262,
-0.429529070854187,
-0.1754772663116455,
0.6887097358703613,
-1.1761513948440552,
0.6530469655990601,
0.6084197163581848,
0.8548764586448669,
-0.6346083283424377,
-0.249241903424263,
-0.3274233043193817,
0.5205305218696594,
0.08736151456832886,
0.875613272190094,
-0.45820754766464233,
-0.5031452775001526,
-0.418243944644928,
-0.4032502770423889,
-0.24827313423156738,
-0.7414039969444275,
-0.04459473863244057,
-0.6265496015548706,
0.15159738063812256,
-0.1487208753824234,
-0.6892666220664978,
-0.5406912565231323,
0.2085169106721878,
-0.4352874755859375,
0.5542123913764954,
0.24199599027633667,
-0.6582641005516052,
0.5175201296806335,
-0.4869135618209839,
-0.42333948612213135,
0.019273821264505386,
0.0015629582339897752,
-0.38023117184638977,
0.20832526683807373,
0.4925815165042877,
0.6829959154129028,
-0.08891167491674423,
0.19329135119915009,
-0.4584576487541199,
-0.07842668145895004,
0.0935048833489418,
-0.23681725561618805,
0.5585559606552124,
-0.036705613136291504,
0.13586609065532684,
0.24707020819187164,
-0.6412848234176636,
-0.2215174436569214,
-0.05250459164381027,
-0.3866458237171173,
-0.4292280972003937,
0.03999962657690048,
0.13131557404994965,
-0.003919810056686401,
0.3704773187637329,
0.10451430827379227,
0.3798219561576843,
-0.18780101835727692,
0.17439806461334229,
0.6020351052284241,
0.29547640681266785,
0.7889983654022217,
-0.7226398587226868,
0.6772276759147644,
0.028323370963335037,
-0.1144629493355751,
-0.25931915640830994,
-0.5729863047599792,
-0.5269612669944763,
-1.0021995306015015,
0.33138689398765564,
0.5601346492767334,
-0.5755820870399475,
0.4285881221294403,
-0.3173527121543884,
-0.5008857846260071,
-0.15782366693019867,
0.37142980098724365,
0.23796117305755615,
0.6096827387809753,
0.45452409982681274,
-0.5582688450813293,
-0.2368294894695282,
-0.8184896111488342,
-0.4060715138912201,
-0.02618609555065632,
-0.1523469239473343,
0.02462499961256981,
0.5485994815826416,
0.23444591462612152,
1.1727972030639648,
-0.7533936500549316,
-0.34823551774024963,
-0.6798375844955444,
0.06463591754436493,
0.1765262633562088,
0.30447080731391907,
0.6940709352493286,
-0.8332496285438538,
-0.5994060635566711,
-0.00937194935977459,
-0.7928943037986755,
-0.2419111132621765,
0.04729228839278221,
-0.07823125272989273,
-0.11493507027626038,
0.1280086189508438,
-0.6353514194488525,
0.2754337787628174,
0.13154569268226624,
0.0029993015341460705,
0.5618039965629578,
-0.4869193136692047,
0.1273396909236908,
-1.3706154823303223,
0.07733811438083649,
-0.1259051412343979,
-0.36835113167762756,
-0.682844877243042,
0.24530909955501556,
0.14843036234378815,
0.27651193737983704,
-0.29456189274787903,
0.4590226411819458,
-0.6012632250785828,
0.06564829498529434,
-0.3712994456291199,
0.1995745301246643,
0.024538185447454453,
0.5134134292602539,
0.16129033267498016,
0.5255521535873413,
0.5260551571846008,
-0.8631826639175415,
0.14115434885025024,
0.32194235920906067,
-0.12465159595012665,
0.7711728811264038,
-0.7649700045585632,
-0.14488577842712402,
0.06772177666425705,
0.06000696122646332,
-0.988007128238678,
-0.6866778135299683,
0.05916745588183403,
-0.3796711564064026,
0.48996421694755554,
-0.07098619639873505,
-0.13690932095050812,
0.4061802327632904,
-0.41121652722358704,
0.37451353669166565,
0.62933349609375,
-0.1534285843372345,
0.9835429191589355,
0.602763295173645,
-0.9495435953140259,
-0.326181024312973,
-0.5284152626991272,
0.22044633328914642,
-0.4570119380950928,
-0.7535322904586792,
0.540585994720459,
-0.08260135352611542,
-0.5229587554931641,
0.07947909086942673,
-0.1798231303691864,
-0.41585859656333923,
0.08245489746332169,
0.27020263671875,
0.28172925114631653,
-0.1313779503107071,
-0.09267457574605942,
0.4035421311855316,
-0.14042533934116364,
-0.25498589873313904,
0.06590096652507782,
-0.004695411305874586,
0.14107193052768707,
-0.11996864527463913,
-0.2130936086177826,
0.7904115915298462,
0.6649796366691589,
-0.3296467065811157,
0.8159950375556946,
0.22067981958389282,
-0.19771987199783325,
-0.2312019318342209,
-0.487365186214447,
-0.08612220734357834,
-0.3593730330467224,
0.476866215467453,
-0.35649463534355164,
-0.6573976278305054,
0.939532995223999,
0.10209643840789795,
0.4685473144054413,
0.5337264537811279,
0.8474693894386292,
-0.030848423019051552,
0.6905812621116638,
0.8051465153694153,
-0.03839156776666641,
0.37365469336509705,
-0.1351252794265747,
-0.09110622853040695,
-0.8407018780708313,
-0.16278137266635895,
-0.22244930267333984,
-0.24536684155464172,
0.1516353338956833,
-0.19001802802085876,
0.5803817510604858,
0.2103947401046753,
0.20049266517162323,
0.14549706876277924,
-0.1618381291627884,
0.4692351818084717,
0.4062119126319885,
0.053891751915216446,
0.5429553389549255,
-0.149383544921875,
0.18290512263774872,
0.06733325123786926,
-0.9598734974861145,
-0.4890460669994354,
1.1271488666534424,
0.21824975311756134,
0.5652754306793213,
0.4013027846813202,
0.7323430180549622,
0.2173299342393875,
0.38624727725982666,
-0.6804154515266418,
0.5982986092567444,
-0.24189569056034088,
-0.5049839019775391,
-0.23958466947078705,
-0.39123645424842834,
-0.5689473748207092,
0.5644321441650391,
-0.08060719817876816,
-0.5324114561080933,
0.1179688572883606,
0.07030301541090012,
-0.4839651882648468,
0.3465381860733032,
-0.8242445588111877,
0.30513930320739746,
0.27054256200790405,
-0.05344843119382858,
-0.28565657138824463,
-0.7254700660705566,
0.503919780254364,
-0.273610919713974,
0.13901302218437195,
-0.2762255370616913,
-0.47614169120788574,
0.6776244044303894,
-0.5193529725074768,
0.8469821214675903,
0.029876980930566788,
-0.03062204271554947,
0.227403461933136,
0.11122661083936691,
0.10828488320112228,
0.10959465056657791,
-0.0779295414686203,
0.2010025531053543,
-0.29268878698349,
-0.6031855344772339,
-0.5910673141479492,
0.35819047689437866,
-0.6617974638938904,
-0.758861243724823,
-0.019413083791732788,
-1.053871989250183,
-0.3586393892765045,
0.2286931723356247,
0.46013328433036804,
0.4676585793495178,
-0.17296232283115387,
0.21954123675823212,
0.5465457439422607,
0.24943682551383972,
0.5578254461288452,
0.6762513518333435,
-0.010712654329836369,
-0.5167381763458252,
0.779276430606842,
0.539542555809021,
0.3441593050956726,
0.488646537065506,
0.025925694033503532,
-0.001935989479534328,
-0.8264530301094055,
-0.2465873658657074,
-0.003947683610022068,
-0.6299267411231995,
-0.20958195626735687,
-0.6368363499641418,
0.1061837300658226,
-0.4731139838695526,
-0.5300451517105103,
-0.15147651731967926,
-0.753689169883728,
-0.4444311857223511,
-0.0533411018550396,
0.3795052468776703,
0.5328431129455566,
0.09505823254585266,
0.27799299359321594,
-0.8427680730819702,
0.5725806951522827,
0.6275297403335571,
0.0466938391327858,
0.0039323801174759865,
-0.8954346776008606,
-0.41528061032295227,
-0.2581474781036377,
-0.2910696268081665,
-0.9774143099784851,
0.47777435183525085,
0.46095937490463257,
0.6848784685134888,
0.5100095868110657,
0.18066520988941193,
0.494826078414917,
-0.26296374201774597,
0.9115616679191589,
0.2026502937078476,
-0.9288913607597351,
0.3123527467250824,
-0.750898540019989,
0.4083588719367981,
0.5418442487716675,
0.2820707857608795,
0.02359112724661827,
-0.8601096272468567,
-0.43520814180374146,
-1.0393807888031006,
0.6546812653541565,
0.2126135230064392,
-0.08386588841676712,
0.30903056263923645,
0.23679767549037933,
0.6433753967285156,
0.132301926612854,
-0.047468334436416626,
0.07438892871141434,
-0.0004644282744266093,
-0.2777085304260254,
-0.0826415941119194,
-0.2112824022769928,
-0.33815237879753113,
-0.1593642234802246,
0.6397538185119629,
-0.04630649462342262,
-0.0696595311164856,
0.043982453644275665,
-0.37550464272499084,
0.2649991810321808,
0.24475927650928497,
0.7008348703384399,
1.1254007816314697,
-0.25767219066619873,
0.20991794764995575,
0.4562132954597473,
-0.5354405045509338,
-0.040583763271570206,
0.023445969447493553,
0.005406624171882868,
0.026053689420223236,
0.8205657005310059,
0.32138440012931824,
0.3440079092979431,
-0.5249862670898438,
0.4930388331413269,
0.09678478538990021,
-0.48595064878463745,
0.31038063764572144,
0.49917277693748474,
0.13583850860595703,
0.2358037829399109,
0.5339437127113342,
0.3598012328147888,
0.11506741493940353,
-0.26370835304260254,
0.30574744939804077,
0.025133296847343445,
0.00019419575983192772,
-0.4426954984664917,
0.805633544921875,
0.36604171991348267,
-0.10150332003831863,
0.13122378289699554,
0.010944628156721592,
-0.11996227502822876,
0.6988892555236816,
0.15576113760471344,
0.9091171622276306,
-0.3800988793373108,
0.015907365828752518,
-0.3680870234966278,
0.10977651178836823,
-0.028820928186178207,
0.10157240927219391,
-0.07408200949430466,
-0.6002470850944519,
-0.34918156266212463,
0.12053641676902771,
-0.664248526096344,
-0.4747881293296814,
-0.9874345064163208,
0.14895105361938477,
-0.3412303328514099,
-0.27049490809440613,
0.10299111157655716,
-0.22580410540103912,
-0.3550761938095093,
0.1298007220029831,
-0.38555845618247986,
0.888332724571228,
-0.6343928575515747,
0.4988365173339844,
0.9548097848892212,
-0.3876764476299286,
-0.44902878999710083,
0.07283800095319748,
0.0007935626781545579,
-0.6861769556999207,
0.17195025086402893,
-0.1296193152666092,
0.003112954320386052,
-0.3764226734638214,
-0.3121882975101471,
-0.44080355763435364,
1.3142262697219849,
0.5235093235969543,
-0.17193688452243805,
0.0051270644180476665,
-0.4170171022415161,
0.37600210309028625,
-0.5582811832427979,
0.3339628577232361,
0.2929146885871887,
0.0989382192492485,
-0.022180432453751564,
-1.0388511419296265,
-0.1257072389125824,
-0.2625594437122345,
-0.0003488717193249613,
0.08165370672941208,
-0.866197407245636,
0.9620370864868164,
-0.3221208155155182,
0.16202132403850555,
-0.06594941020011902,
0.9593960642814636,
0.11852390319108963,
0.4947810173034668,
0.27680617570877075,
0.29255470633506775,
0.7608973383903503,
0.1847020834684372,
0.8321253061294556,
-0.3324483036994934,
0.2714644968509674,
1.318398356437683,
-0.2916422486305237,
0.890591025352478,
0.36054715514183044,
-0.018874289467930794,
0.374416708946228,
0.30549106001853943,
0.30303701758384705,
0.6076444387435913,
-0.4593624174594879,
-0.24494826793670654,
-0.42785799503326416,
0.13554996252059937,
-0.4115883409976959,
0.4058990776538849,
0.1733270287513733,
-0.1983116716146469,
-0.31660717725753784,
-0.13379140198230743,
0.10138694941997528,
0.0656874030828476,
-0.501363217830658,
0.8927512764930725,
0.2050706446170807,
-0.6181148886680603,
0.3175688683986664,
0.15636949241161346,
0.5445753335952759,
-0.6813678741455078,
0.1695840209722519,
-0.29867127537727356,
0.023202477023005486,
-0.3453122675418854,
-0.7721869945526123,
0.4307408928871155,
0.12818686664104462,
-0.5397436022758484,
-0.2769339084625244,
0.802033543586731,
-0.593799352645874,
-0.26291853189468384,
-0.12524138391017914,
0.738581120967865,
0.05675218626856804,
-0.2329074889421463,
-0.1909242570400238,
-0.33619317412376404,
-0.24798583984375,
-0.3383718729019165,
0.6279365420341492,
0.4317384958267212,
0.011723896488547325,
0.6984943151473999,
0.19017939269542694,
0.20603463053703308,
-0.07609502226114273,
-0.06212431192398071,
0.9044451117515564,
-0.30946674942970276,
-0.7725790739059448,
-0.8336583971977234,
0.8017442226409912,
-0.19493061304092407,
-0.46953675150871277,
0.9236526489257812,
0.43640777468681335,
0.3065382242202759,
-0.2553391456604004,
0.7680333852767944,
0.1764982044696808,
0.4195229113101959,
-0.4278208017349243,
0.7612279653549194,
-0.6624252200126648,
0.29023247957229614,
-0.22026221454143524,
-0.8245630860328674,
-0.3890436887741089,
0.2876693606376648,
-0.42175355553627014,
0.26674196124076843,
0.3746793866157532,
0.4362128674983978,
-0.15083713829517365,
-0.09914780408143997,
0.3515949845314026,
-0.05145058035850525,
0.2642648220062256,
0.5481730103492737,
0.42699986696243286,
0.09679866582155228,
0.40241146087646484,
0.08009999245405197,
-0.5344863533973694,
-0.6256670355796814,
-0.7340483069419861,
-1.0791101455688477,
-0.47493457794189453,
-0.5289705991744995,
0.22036609053611755,
-0.1992902010679245,
0.6680081486701965,
1.0078730583190918,
-0.6170558333396912,
-0.0727074146270752,
0.25961828231811523,
0.25125300884246826,
-0.6359297633171082,
-0.2407403588294983,
0.27170342206954956,
-0.17974267899990082,
-0.6970058083534241,
0.3114190697669983,
0.7171919941902161,
-0.16769295930862427,
0.020419666543602943,
0.0012367209419608116,
0.3221191465854645,
0.48151880502700806,
0.6077942848205566,
0.07728955149650574,
-0.4551735818386078,
0.048804569989442825,
-0.09220524877309799,
-0.06470859050750732,
-0.024645116180181503,
0.6947062611579895,
-0.28205642104148865,
0.5648214817047119,
0.6330588459968567,
0.6072949767112732,
0.21398226916790009,
0.12514178454875946,
0.7560011148452759,
-0.820006787776947,
-0.0017015148187056184,
0.14033646881580353,
0.39617496728897095,
0.03303688392043114,
-0.42212340235710144,
0.34175315499305725,
0.12217684835195541,
-0.48059436678886414,
-0.5572606325149536,
0.09482218325138092,
-1.3007690906524658,
-0.3576171398162842,
1.1677837371826172,
-0.43830394744873047,
0.1597156524658203,
-0.3147740662097931,
-0.3219356834888458,
0.09958066046237946,
-0.47073888778686523,
0.8622751235961914,
0.9171814322471619,
-0.40338146686553955,
-0.09738048166036606,
-0.2169153392314911,
0.08574717491865158,
0.49075940251350403,
-0.9249516725540161,
-0.060535985976457596,
0.24739563465118408,
0.5641475915908813,
-0.1475108563899994,
0.7586576342582703,
0.0007385665667243302,
0.3276214599609375,
0.054026272147893906,
-0.07890886813402176,
-0.5116913318634033,
-0.47822850942611694,
-0.3921612799167633,
0.7153751254081726,
-0.00455816276371479,
-0.1328207105398178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05348v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05348v1
|
Toward Reliable Ad-hoc Scientific Information Extraction: A Case Study on Two Materials Datasets
| 2024-06-08T04:24:16 | 2024-06-08T04:24:16 |
Satanu Ghosh, Neal R. Brodnik, Carolina Frey, Collin Holgate, Tresa M. Pollock, Samantha Daly, Samuel Carton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
We explore the ability of GPT-4 to perform ad-hoc schema based information
extraction from scientific literature. We assess specifically whether it can,
with a basic prompting approach, replicate two existing material science
datasets, given the manuscripts from which they were originally manually
extracted. We employ materials scientists to perform a detailed manual error
analysis to assess where the model struggles to faithfully extract the desired
information, and draw on their insights to suggest research directions to
address this broadly important task.
|
[
0.1236056387424469,
-0.7408088445663452,
0.91461580991745,
-0.11234179884195328,
-0.17602868378162384,
0.056657902896404266,
0.05424042046070099,
-0.4769382178783417,
-0.02200165018439293,
0.22763194143772125,
-0.3030129671096802,
-0.12329139560461044,
-0.5719178915023804,
0.36006081104278564,
-0.4636985659599304,
1.0664730072021484,
-0.33546578884124756,
0.18502338230609894,
-0.09248735010623932,
0.12308437377214432,
-0.1601065993309021,
-0.11764208227396011,
-0.45731353759765625,
-0.2884597182273865,
0.3246570825576782,
0.4261338412761688,
0.6019738912582397,
0.8346776366233826,
0.7653397917747498,
0.20138563215732574,
0.17431826889514923,
0.3901068866252899,
-0.10191033780574799,
0.2620515525341034,
-0.4783400893211365,
-0.14468687772750854,
-0.4770238399505615,
0.5466660261154175,
0.655866265296936,
0.4312054216861725,
-0.42891108989715576,
0.3296527862548828,
0.10671362280845642,
0.37521985173225403,
-0.18001802265644073,
0.3958567976951599,
-0.8530390858650208,
-0.07595649361610413,
-0.4964653253555298,
-0.679160475730896,
-0.39501675963401794,
-0.5650025010108948,
0.2552317678928375,
-1.1088072061538696,
0.6887690424919128,
0.07883486151695251,
1.0525227785110474,
-0.10363297909498215,
-0.33432552218437195,
-0.8279591798782349,
-0.6920408606529236,
0.824742317199707,
-0.41724997758865356,
0.16580387949943542,
0.42230451107025146,
0.2774086892604828,
-0.20561811327934265,
-1.1398085355758667,
-0.5677080154418945,
-0.05336212366819382,
-0.2324846237897873,
0.19595883786678314,
0.2948029637336731,
-0.3495731055736542,
0.46218207478523254,
0.5170146226882935,
-0.6404706239700317,
-0.5994423031806946,
-0.9860764741897583,
-0.17223364114761353,
0.5750033855438232,
-0.03196924179792404,
0.34252694249153137,
-0.3627331554889679,
-0.27597808837890625,
-0.03663995862007141,
-0.7445752024650574,
-0.446023553609848,
0.3000721037387848,
0.1952899545431137,
0.37076276540756226,
0.7995319962501526,
0.12596555054187775,
0.2744852602481842,
-0.12857604026794434,
0.49312159419059753,
0.3251199424266815,
-0.8683115243911743,
0.08718610554933548,
0.15565116703510284,
0.6986715197563171,
0.2299923598766327,
-0.06502802670001984,
-0.3210213780403137,
-0.10760022699832916,
0.14492300152778625,
0.35660216212272644,
-0.5588646531105042,
-0.7077420353889465,
0.31768226623535156,
-0.387022465467453,
-0.4139587879180908,
0.48337236046791077,
-0.9278001189231873,
-0.7388739585876465,
-0.43783026933670044,
0.4170930087566376,
-0.4060451090335846,
-0.5255678296089172,
0.06366687268018723,
-0.6117352247238159,
0.248909130692482,
0.5658000111579895,
-0.939477801322937,
0.422493577003479,
0.538637638092041,
1.2128440141677856,
-0.5532494783401489,
-0.1396874636411667,
-0.4780190587043762,
0.5143743753433228,
-0.10435564070940018,
0.8760411739349365,
-0.1967686116695404,
-0.5789064168930054,
-0.5643213987350464,
0.24495671689510345,
0.00691539840772748,
-0.22097380459308624,
0.5288955569267273,
-0.5723575949668884,
0.2678988575935364,
-0.7573155164718628,
-0.23489348590373993,
-0.03840937837958336,
0.0531647726893425,
-1.020143747329712,
1.1991198062896729,
0.4325014352798462,
-1.198063850402832,
0.3674730062484741,
-0.6572378277778625,
-0.16443751752376556,
0.11757015436887741,
-0.36473533511161804,
-0.3187737464904785,
-0.0826394185423851,
-0.049641821533441544,
0.18326763808727264,
-0.5416479706764221,
0.1942078322172165,
-0.5027142763137817,
-0.21554578840732574,
-0.06823159009218216,
-0.4624709486961365,
0.761913001537323,
0.34754183888435364,
-0.14175544679164886,
-0.31622764468193054,
-0.8442800045013428,
-0.2287793755531311,
0.44962435960769653,
-0.3226518929004669,
-0.40586352348327637,
-0.1162121370434761,
0.013830459676682949,
0.2976403534412384,
0.3224785029888153,
-0.8771754503250122,
0.7138868570327759,
-0.0016584780532866716,
0.5736731290817261,
0.8084394931793213,
0.23105716705322266,
0.7444050312042236,
-0.34617337584495544,
0.34650370478630066,
-0.5096074342727661,
-0.08532489836215973,
-0.21908842027187347,
-0.2652558982372284,
-0.18666283786296844,
-0.24529746174812317,
0.5023886561393738,
0.48718637228012085,
-1.0669682025909424,
-0.16914933919906616,
-0.13465653359889984,
-0.4923466742038727,
-0.42126110196113586,
0.10685490816831589,
-0.03595158830285072,
0.7881691455841064,
0.5090392827987671,
-0.30743950605392456,
-0.5978152751922607,
-0.400936484336853,
-0.30396008491516113,
-0.1048794612288475,
-0.12380947172641754,
0.2480563372373581,
0.49359408020973206,
0.06957467645406723,
1.308882236480713,
-0.5839405655860901,
0.12574240565299988,
0.12175529450178146,
0.5405837297439575,
0.39701902866363525,
0.3577328026294708,
0.30840742588043213,
-0.9615389108657837,
-0.5463509559631348,
0.3089715540409088,
-1.2638436555862427,
-0.11579703539609909,
0.10156305134296417,
0.0038895963225513697,
0.019329959526658058,
0.5386455059051514,
-0.9691781401634216,
0.31358450651168823,
0.003992467653006315,
-0.1871209740638733,
1.0904836654663086,
-0.20214350521564484,
0.4423547089099884,
-0.8802506923675537,
0.5997140407562256,
0.0024213867727667093,
0.10507147759199142,
-0.5417214035987854,
-0.36937931180000305,
0.2814287841320038,
-0.006484840996563435,
-0.397844523191452,
0.7148805260658264,
-0.8508636951446533,
-0.2766115367412567,
-0.1689915955066681,
0.07051514089107513,
0.4288948178291321,
0.013972514308989048,
0.20950503647327423,
0.6914669871330261,
0.3174650967121124,
-0.3814709782600403,
0.6612637042999268,
0.3865465521812439,
-0.1804099977016449,
0.7133360505104065,
-0.7810481190681458,
0.3872743844985962,
-0.11144319921731949,
0.4552266299724579,
-0.9177561402320862,
-0.49927541613578796,
0.5622735619544983,
-0.2813626527786255,
0.5880281925201416,
-0.15096992254257202,
-0.6914311051368713,
-0.48622560501098633,
-0.5271527767181396,
0.19540619850158691,
0.05460219830274582,
-0.4155200719833374,
0.6262891888618469,
0.33710479736328125,
-1.0120195150375366,
-0.3982219099998474,
-0.29163992404937744,
-0.2616366446018219,
-0.2807765305042267,
-0.33058127760887146,
0.15197588503360748,
-0.1881551593542099,
-0.2564290165901184,
0.1301080733537674,
-0.46195292472839355,
-0.10542032122612,
-0.0728013888001442,
0.042853161692619324,
0.5033250451087952,
0.08245285600423813,
0.06438111513853073,
-0.17292383313179016,
-0.1972493976354599,
0.09875974804162979,
-0.2910687327384949,
0.21961310505867004,
-0.15159252285957336,
-0.4578205645084381,
-0.4498573839664459,
0.22066158056259155,
0.5775871872901917,
-0.0027745417319238186,
0.11083819717168808,
0.5050228834152222,
-0.4551141560077667,
0.13223902881145477,
-0.4181998074054718,
-0.5100802779197693,
-0.5362353920936584,
0.19688622653484344,
-0.43959152698516846,
0.029066801071166992,
0.4611564576625824,
-0.11983447521924973,
0.38562119007110596,
0.5900062322616577,
0.008787563070654869,
-0.30578652024269104,
0.8247530460357666,
0.35788798332214355,
0.2469446063041687,
0.37401488423347473,
-0.2679001986980438,
-0.3428054451942444,
-0.6706331372261047,
-0.2541145980358124,
-0.7390633225440979,
0.3268536925315857,
0.1726115494966507,
-0.17370158433914185,
0.2548936903476715,
-0.17947152256965637,
-0.1526114046573639,
0.41546228528022766,
-0.699735701084137,
0.34605181217193604,
0.6225193738937378,
0.20266884565353394,
0.5613600611686707,
0.3919692635536194,
0.11157695204019547,
0.028800135478377342,
-0.6470426917076111,
-0.7376307249069214,
1.1107804775238037,
0.29636916518211365,
0.6472424268722534,
-0.2460126280784607,
0.2834468483924866,
0.4021433889865875,
0.4483780860900879,
-0.5582967400550842,
0.2102333903312683,
0.20875833928585052,
-0.776042640209198,
-0.5532852411270142,
-0.46543586254119873,
-0.7788893580436707,
0.21717241406440735,
-0.08472802489995956,
-0.3960196375846863,
0.3659636974334717,
0.10183541476726532,
-0.22927120327949524,
0.12483007460832596,
-0.6394500732421875,
0.5528786778450012,
-0.10273636132478714,
-0.3284148871898651,
0.22345983982086182,
-0.8808543086051941,
0.21945679187774658,
-0.5900022387504578,
0.7020605206489563,
0.10593747347593307,
0.27077698707580566,
0.9790794253349304,
-0.2579943537712097,
0.509882926940918,
-0.3458159863948822,
-0.2228468805551529,
0.5263850092887878,
0.42300817370414734,
0.8660049438476562,
-0.0015657281037420034,
-0.5755825638771057,
0.24233052134513855,
0.35903069376945496,
-0.34201890230178833,
-0.65380859375,
0.3590622842311859,
-0.46743980050086975,
-0.37359240651130676,
-0.7799306511878967,
-0.5943427681922913,
0.03235188499093056,
0.3431932032108307,
0.4237058162689209,
0.41209110617637634,
0.005490655545145273,
0.14111526310443878,
0.4820181131362915,
0.32351061701774597,
0.3990744948387146,
0.8741142749786377,
0.4618713855743408,
-0.42474088072776794,
1.1763075590133667,
0.42308318614959717,
0.06494230777025223,
-0.24710388481616974,
0.2795804440975189,
-0.418778657913208,
-0.5391961336135864,
-0.6323022246360779,
0.30044621229171753,
-0.6848466992378235,
-0.2366594821214676,
-0.6472082138061523,
-0.20765835046768188,
-0.2586679756641388,
-0.214494526386261,
-0.5267530083656311,
-0.6579915881156921,
-0.46003904938697815,
-0.38251110911369324,
0.3438548743724823,
1.0841985940933228,
-0.11862514168024063,
0.1136825904250145,
-1.0420727729797363,
0.1984734982252121,
0.008051352575421333,
0.08251111209392548,
-0.4079301357269287,
-0.4620129466056824,
-0.15154007077217102,
0.09297998249530792,
-0.3591545820236206,
-1.0165470838546753,
0.06960830092430115,
0.17063407599925995,
0.7411260604858398,
0.007954791188240051,
-0.04627223685383797,
0.31363171339035034,
-0.7898336052894592,
0.8873632550239563,
0.19936762750148773,
-0.7299639582633972,
0.683968186378479,
-0.756611704826355,
-0.1618555784225464,
0.6747284531593323,
0.6033441424369812,
-0.14512822031974792,
-0.12262295931577682,
-0.9683413505554199,
-0.8738400936126709,
0.9225494265556335,
0.1849861890077591,
-0.515457808971405,
0.08773095160722733,
0.5762737989425659,
0.5977669358253479,
0.10790585726499557,
-0.6821386814117432,
0.011049493215978146,
-0.2963540852069855,
-0.35079875588417053,
0.08293874561786652,
-0.10950468480587006,
-0.4415784478187561,
0.18766923248767853,
0.7199226021766663,
-0.08699077367782593,
0.06985050439834595,
0.499549925327301,
-0.12679260969161987,
-0.2777199447154999,
-0.12705007195472717,
0.2731385827064514,
0.9120681881904602,
-0.35998407006263733,
0.3914116322994232,
-0.05183349922299385,
-0.9762669205665588,
0.08569802343845367,
0.4587695300579071,
-0.06182750687003136,
-0.00893594790250063,
0.2976236641407013,
-0.14698131382465363,
-0.13597646355628967,
-0.11419717967510223,
0.3757823705673218,
-0.046624548733234406,
-0.31450000405311584,
0.06793380528688431,
-0.3589937686920166,
-0.4077857434749603,
0.10438506305217743,
0.7756564617156982,
0.027897153049707413,
0.5371058583259583,
-0.3926060199737549,
0.9246917366981506,
0.43851709365844727,
-0.2690625786781311,
-0.7497814893722534,
0.6316983699798584,
0.0652352049946785,
0.10344803333282471,
0.4150877594947815,
-0.27297040820121765,
-0.188673734664917,
0.5909742712974548,
0.4458431303501129,
0.19172140955924988,
-0.5084257125854492,
0.48534631729125977,
0.23343795537948608,
0.26737743616104126,
-0.6260625720024109,
0.331805020570755,
0.02596070058643818,
-0.4971480965614319,
-0.2109353244304657,
-0.36121898889541626,
-0.6602970957756042,
-0.17359092831611633,
-0.6436691284179688,
0.5389037132263184,
-0.2276104837656021,
0.1617652028799057,
0.1480693817138672,
0.3066391944885254,
-0.3882262706756592,
0.11026307940483093,
-0.5199406147003174,
0.6908640265464783,
-1.2053171396255493,
0.747643232345581,
0.653162956237793,
-0.3862863779067993,
-0.7968310713768005,
-0.6246817111968994,
0.24967476725578308,
-0.489913672208786,
0.5056142807006836,
-0.22097912430763245,
0.018520209938287735,
0.06755703687667847,
-0.6502413153648376,
-1.127805471420288,
1.5215634107589722,
0.27979975938796997,
-0.2511177062988281,
0.010322801768779755,
-0.42786428332328796,
0.22764457762241364,
0.14931868016719818,
0.44340604543685913,
0.507692813873291,
0.522383451461792,
0.5653998255729675,
-1.0148229598999023,
0.3344303071498871,
-0.43704289197921753,
-0.813370406627655,
0.013567594811320305,
-0.4077112674713135,
0.9359475374221802,
0.04314685985445976,
-0.4069749116897583,
-0.090195432305336,
0.5426605939865112,
0.6611807942390442,
0.6305236220359802,
0.44956621527671814,
0.004022832494229078,
1.3337957859039307,
0.04546819254755974,
0.8061312437057495,
-0.03749953582882881,
0.4752857983112335,
1.0523226261138916,
-0.6952353715896606,
0.303716778755188,
0.5648714303970337,
-0.14238540828227997,
0.208245649933815,
0.8624540567398071,
-0.20493216812610626,
0.8200779557228088,
-0.25452300906181335,
-0.1968158334493637,
0.34833911061286926,
0.034956056624650955,
-0.7522140145301819,
0.13619907200336456,
0.7700453996658325,
-0.2507120668888092,
-0.24219509959220886,
-0.3166787028312683,
0.008005794137716293,
-0.5799516439437866,
0.01091549638658762,
0.5106997489929199,
0.21089954674243927,
-0.43239372968673706,
0.05853115767240524,
-0.22564734518527985,
0.11325295269489288,
-0.635051429271698,
-0.5772088766098022,
0.11842043697834015,
-0.25674012303352356,
-0.2999243140220642,
-0.6705499887466431,
0.44888758659362793,
-0.24455173313617706,
-0.1693488359451294,
-0.26809415221214294,
1.1379882097244263,
-0.3262632191181183,
-0.1643669456243515,
-0.2791465222835541,
0.471558541059494,
0.3454609811306,
0.1371403932571411,
-0.5377904176712036,
0.09177181124687195,
-0.0361902192234993,
-0.5993907451629639,
-0.07892654836177826,
0.6368553638458252,
-0.056378331035375595,
0.3231762647628784,
0.9201095104217529,
0.4856559932231903,
-0.1729946732521057,
-0.5508450269699097,
0.9205693602561951,
-0.5992408394813538,
-0.3378858268260956,
-0.74107426404953,
0.5587374567985535,
-0.526751697063446,
-0.030594725161790848,
0.9531465172767639,
0.4892141819000244,
0.24761773645877838,
-0.06258592009544373,
1.1728770732879639,
-0.11798378080129623,
0.6787124276161194,
-0.5327615141868591,
0.5824301838874817,
-0.1465492695569992,
0.45434698462486267,
-0.41314730048179626,
-1.104095458984375,
-0.22057503461837769,
0.752051055431366,
-0.07115453481674194,
-0.12381624430418015,
1.073491096496582,
0.5610092282295227,
-0.3538609445095062,
0.5122823119163513,
-0.46807587146759033,
0.26339828968048096,
0.5475439429283142,
-0.12773169577121735,
0.7485826015472412,
-0.3723638355731964,
0.604932963848114,
0.12135883420705795,
-0.5526192784309387,
0.025378786027431488,
-1.1432256698608398,
-0.3052256107330322,
-0.46626266837120056,
-0.31302812695503235,
-0.6399931907653809,
0.08693636208772659,
0.5210229754447937,
0.6204119920730591,
-0.7462100386619568,
0.27494895458221436,
-0.3245393931865692,
-0.005346362944692373,
0.03748820722103119,
-0.25716254115104675,
0.9772051572799683,
-0.18214218318462372,
-0.4604372978210449,
0.5808748602867126,
0.13768090307712555,
0.1339634507894516,
0.117434561252594,
0.20252716541290283,
-0.09178537130355835,
0.04519378021359444,
0.20198988914489746,
0.5486543774604797,
-0.005064438562840223,
-0.4377887547016144,
-0.013889218680560589,
-0.24354086816310883,
-0.13920553028583527,
0.8144442439079285,
-0.25271469354629517,
0.5277586579322815,
0.5106356143951416,
0.41559088230133057,
0.6429121494293213,
0.32042282819747925,
0.8569626212120056,
-0.7893193364143372,
-0.053556717932224274,
0.08254453539848328,
0.30607882142066956,
0.39000171422958374,
-0.5584176182746887,
0.914628803730011,
0.7838831543922424,
-0.8682106137275696,
-1.0144606828689575,
0.041109710931777954,
-1.1287386417388916,
-0.23545540869235992,
1.5917291641235352,
-0.2425912618637085,
-0.21563434600830078,
-0.7401681542396545,
-0.4976889491081238,
0.27167046070098877,
-0.2372918426990509,
0.7342658042907715,
1.0910252332687378,
-0.1350053995847702,
0.24261341989040375,
-0.8034484386444092,
0.7118964791297913,
-0.10036371648311615,
-0.6946951746940613,
0.12405779212713242,
0.3750089108943939,
0.5885199308395386,
0.3404127359390259,
0.9223085045814514,
-0.4548451900482178,
0.3473600149154663,
0.19714124500751495,
0.06338240206241608,
-0.24500252306461334,
-0.5459938645362854,
-0.19684059917926788,
0.3645167946815491,
-0.2344779670238495,
0.03194216266274452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05344v1
|
MemeGuard: An LLM and VLM-based Framework for Advancing Content Moderation via Meme Intervention
| 2024-06-08T04:09:20 | 2024-06-08T04:09:20 |
Prince Jha, Raghav Jain, Konika Mandal, Aman Chadha, Sriparna Saha, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the digital world, memes present a unique challenge for content moderation
due to their potential to spread harmful content. Although detection methods
have improved, proactive solutions such as intervention are still limited, with
current research focusing mostly on text-based content, neglecting the
widespread influence of multimodal content like memes. Addressing this gap, we
present \textit{MemeGuard}, a comprehensive framework leveraging Large Language
Models (LLMs) and Visual Language Models (VLMs) for meme intervention.
\textit{MemeGuard} harnesses a specially fine-tuned VLM, \textit{VLMeme}, for
meme interpretation, and a multimodal knowledge selection and ranking mechanism
(\textit{MKS}) for distilling relevant knowledge. This knowledge is then
employed by a general-purpose LLM to generate contextually appropriate
interventions. Another key contribution of this work is the
\textit{\textbf{I}ntervening} \textit{\textbf{C}yberbullying in
\textbf{M}ultimodal \textbf{M}emes (ICMM)} dataset, a high-quality, labeled
dataset featuring toxic memes and their corresponding human-annotated
interventions. We leverage \textit{ICMM} to test \textit{MemeGuard},
demonstrating its proficiency in generating relevant and effective responses to
toxic memes.
|
[
-0.31764134764671326,
-1.112109899520874,
0.4186636507511139,
0.14949367940425873,
-0.4739159047603607,
0.521355152130127,
0.2812715768814087,
-0.15101665258407593,
0.4107316732406616,
0.6221237778663635,
-0.66996169090271,
-0.4820721745491028,
-0.836840808391571,
0.0320165641605854,
-0.23405855894088745,
0.9460623860359192,
-0.12291021645069122,
-0.05781710520386696,
-0.12654802203178406,
0.009159413166344166,
-0.8214624524116516,
-0.45051297545433044,
-0.6668355464935303,
-0.0001611695042811334,
0.8048110604286194,
0.4295884370803833,
0.19683051109313965,
0.2867850065231323,
0.4774135947227478,
0.2793918550014496,
-0.07576415687799454,
0.2553307116031647,
-0.5945119857788086,
0.3183422088623047,
-0.5802320241928101,
-0.19201546907424927,
-0.23617099225521088,
0.20800210535526276,
0.29639244079589844,
-0.17922398447990417,
-0.10094013810157776,
0.0069822585210204124,
0.2219255417585373,
0.39388778805732727,
-0.8725147843360901,
-0.3341613709926605,
-0.5796591639518738,
0.0997743308544159,
-0.2075117826461792,
-0.5421276688575745,
-0.35209107398986816,
0.04274951294064522,
-0.11664827167987823,
-0.2132117599248886,
-0.4230721890926361,
0.13750237226486206,
0.38991284370422363,
0.10763232409954071,
-0.6199690699577332,
-0.29128003120422363,
-0.6985788941383362,
1.0056469440460205,
-0.6425002217292786,
0.21923977136611938,
0.37747588753700256,
0.29294851422309875,
-0.2318480759859085,
-0.7499948740005493,
-0.4926617741584778,
0.17608535289764404,
0.17585454881191254,
0.14117257297039032,
-0.3850005865097046,
0.02875034138560295,
0.0023552479688078165,
0.007363293319940567,
-0.5436386466026306,
0.24367474019527435,
-0.393213152885437,
-0.6867703199386597,
0.4286861717700958,
0.41316959261894226,
0.5882510542869568,
-0.3447464406490326,
-0.8463937044143677,
-0.13431872427463531,
-0.8353268504142761,
0.3156803250312805,
0.17738771438598633,
-0.14157503843307495,
-0.13486316800117493,
0.6025523543357849,
-0.16103799641132355,
0.5885863900184631,
-0.24426904320716858,
-0.4618222713470459,
-0.3332430422306061,
-0.444146066904068,
-0.16567687690258026,
0.047023262828588486,
0.7551194429397583,
0.7197464108467102,
0.04526546597480774,
0.18349957466125488,
-0.21023374795913696,
0.12175565212965012,
0.41231009364128113,
-1.0359394550323486,
-0.17313559353351593,
0.12601837515830994,
-0.5079704523086548,
-0.5447958111763,
0.12175394594669342,
-1.007123589515686,
-0.5812073945999146,
-0.2985275089740753,
0.5449045300483704,
-0.12443509697914124,
-0.5198284387588501,
0.17644931375980377,
-0.2470044046640396,
0.06578130275011063,
0.1737748235464096,
-0.713010311126709,
-0.0372697152197361,
0.7242169380187988,
0.847815215587616,
-0.03654981404542923,
0.08456068485975266,
-0.5419715046882629,
0.5172523260116577,
0.020794644951820374,
0.8364256620407104,
-0.9423269033432007,
-0.26771342754364014,
0.1965254545211792,
0.20390906929969788,
-0.1322125792503357,
-0.3232719898223877,
0.6414099335670471,
-0.6796566247940063,
0.11224374175071716,
-0.19869302213191986,
-0.5566191077232361,
-0.2882910370826721,
0.5626553893089294,
-0.6483180522918701,
0.2583586275577545,
-0.056135144084692,
-0.7333993315696716,
0.28960782289505005,
-0.593036413192749,
-0.11734773963689804,
-0.13166889548301697,
-0.052093133330345154,
-0.3770041763782501,
-0.07236292958259583,
0.015389937907457352,
0.653316855430603,
-0.2008509784936905,
0.05169300734996796,
-0.4955029785633087,
-0.28934890031814575,
0.13531707227230072,
-0.7856066823005676,
0.48187780380249023,
0.5258530378341675,
-0.26938173174858093,
0.41155320405960083,
-0.11686927080154419,
-0.28866511583328247,
0.19333688914775848,
-0.44998717308044434,
-0.6874900460243225,
0.2841622829437256,
0.08305574953556061,
0.4961114227771759,
0.17795167863368988,
-0.6608491539955139,
-0.013803369365632534,
0.3272758722305298,
0.623441755771637,
1.1434203386306763,
0.3585163652896881,
0.178757444024086,
-0.5215446352958679,
0.5245431065559387,
0.17812266945838928,
0.6771644949913025,
-0.20312462747097015,
-0.40987083315849304,
-0.1435740441083908,
-0.5262566208839417,
-0.10951745510101318,
0.6087283492088318,
-1.179739236831665,
0.25782087445259094,
-0.16650912165641785,
-0.17240610718727112,
-0.10068666189908981,
0.5525931119918823,
0.48308226466178894,
0.27647292613983154,
0.572946310043335,
-0.3536456525325775,
-0.5188075304031372,
-0.6468645334243774,
-0.0901709720492363,
-0.16743947565555573,
0.06072022393345833,
0.28416886925697327,
0.13773562014102936,
-0.4457056522369385,
0.5473094582557678,
-0.18765480816364288,
-0.4495393633842468,
-0.19163087010383606,
0.1260993331670761,
-0.03752351552248001,
0.48088082671165466,
0.6357786655426025,
-0.7518833875656128,
-0.5230984687805176,
-0.49102291464805603,
-0.8397928476333618,
-0.3551810681819916,
-0.17478851974010468,
-0.4272692799568176,
-0.15908406674861908,
0.9686087369918823,
0.08523694425821304,
0.3698759973049164,
0.9512320756912231,
-0.7633339762687683,
0.5784257054328918,
0.10472584515810013,
0.4878947138786316,
-1.1461902856826782,
-0.2711453437805176,
-0.030460242182016373,
-0.40841764211654663,
-0.606073796749115,
-0.13576610386371613,
-0.07480773329734802,
0.07783970981836319,
-0.7193476557731628,
0.7634198665618896,
-0.18271569907665253,
0.7747458219528198,
-0.3304094672203064,
0.07355207949876785,
0.08785977214574814,
0.23192033171653748,
-0.16345247626304626,
0.636627733707428,
0.24996402859687805,
-0.6555669903755188,
0.09341324865818024,
0.18266817927360535,
-0.10876414179801941,
1.1003937721252441,
-0.5185582637786865,
0.047330595552921295,
-0.07042279839515686,
-0.003110642544925213,
-0.8725162744522095,
-0.11345506459474564,
0.5902928113937378,
0.08453874289989471,
0.4623885154724121,
-0.11259839683771133,
-0.5953782200813293,
-0.6060153245925903,
-0.7922238707542419,
0.4927229583263397,
0.14368368685245514,
-0.4590413272380829,
0.5733004808425903,
0.6433750987052917,
-0.2096274197101593,
-0.7697510719299316,
-0.3179115951061249,
0.40750598907470703,
-0.47164198756217957,
-0.7104679942131042,
0.014956727623939514,
-0.563232958316803,
-0.30102255940437317,
-0.012215211056172848,
-0.15950733423233032,
-0.001301635056734085,
0.3156326413154602,
0.1031784936785698,
0.06341242045164108,
-0.03978912904858589,
-0.023489700630307198,
0.4823435842990875,
-0.14899303019046783,
-0.04762725904583931,
-0.023405835032463074,
0.7046470046043396,
0.16296593844890594,
-0.7179223895072937,
-0.2985920011997223,
0.3046291172504425,
0.5741655826568604,
-0.37991464138031006,
0.7176899909973145,
0.5286329388618469,
-0.14064255356788635,
0.0008921945700421929,
-0.7124908566474915,
-0.5130279660224915,
-0.5529927015304565,
0.05563830956816673,
-0.057885874062776566,
-1.2813751697540283,
0.18559493124485016,
-0.21705390512943268,
0.153936967253685,
0.05932750552892685,
0.47436898946762085,
-0.3152472674846649,
1.1868278980255127,
0.4151134192943573,
-0.487292617559433,
0.9687286615371704,
-0.10520820319652557,
0.21829135715961456,
-0.7646768093109131,
-0.18087179958820343,
0.07019170373678207,
-0.5752229690551758,
-0.3129717707633972,
-0.5310541987419128,
0.4143098294734955,
0.05612167716026306,
-0.039195213466882706,
0.25537362694740295,
-0.3832665681838989,
0.41454970836639404,
0.4311632513999939,
0.44483882188796997,
0.2604043781757355,
0.12074457108974457,
-0.17420518398284912,
-0.2681656777858734,
-0.5167801380157471,
-0.571768581867218,
1.0110106468200684,
0.3964602053165436,
1.1365324258804321,
0.5332199335098267,
0.48695456981658936,
0.8716734051704407,
0.624788761138916,
-0.40266284346580505,
0.434285968542099,
-0.1312580704689026,
-0.7804098725318909,
-0.09806233644485474,
-0.19848817586898804,
-1.0037988424301147,
0.12061291188001633,
-0.5568960905075073,
-0.6239773035049438,
0.05716410651803017,
0.1795656383037567,
-0.05558056756854057,
0.515994131565094,
-0.44304895401000977,
0.757806122303009,
-0.22038774192333221,
-0.683821976184845,
-0.7291771769523621,
-0.4397032856941223,
0.5298658609390259,
-0.2434147447347641,
0.367262065410614,
-0.36462053656578064,
0.025647612288594246,
0.43373867869377136,
-0.29471448063850403,
1.1702247858047485,
-0.4309684634208679,
0.032567813992500305,
0.6012328267097473,
0.27044519782066345,
0.39435404539108276,
0.09524627029895782,
0.20780161023139954,
0.09008293598890305,
-0.06320372223854065,
-0.4544443190097809,
-0.21786056458950043,
0.784637987613678,
-0.2754746675491333,
-0.588581919670105,
0.0421905480325222,
-0.4122731387615204,
0.21448463201522827,
0.24035674333572388,
-0.07974792271852493,
0.4407804608345032,
-0.2761443853378296,
0.6638430953025818,
1.051171898841858,
-0.29219990968704224,
0.5032188892364502,
0.7521719932556152,
-0.20253261923789978,
-0.5837712287902832,
0.9687878489494324,
0.012198804877698421,
0.22233599424362183,
0.3524577021598816,
0.30212411284446716,
-0.4660578668117523,
-0.386710524559021,
-0.259444922208786,
0.07063519209623337,
-0.7079784870147705,
-0.537975013256073,
-0.7416269779205322,
-0.29718637466430664,
-0.07566402852535248,
-0.18755991756916046,
0.08581473678350449,
0.03185228630900383,
-0.07792438566684723,
-0.21164874732494354,
0.3275020718574524,
0.6633663177490234,
-0.27105215191841125,
0.5069879293441772,
-0.8565797209739685,
0.08439910411834717,
0.5825223922729492,
0.34519240260124207,
-0.13454043865203857,
-0.5732893943786621,
-0.0812990814447403,
0.14846280217170715,
-0.4505338668823242,
-0.8940384984016418,
0.041895605623722076,
0.04237421229481697,
0.7735556960105896,
0.8581324219703674,
0.14409737288951874,
0.31361740827560425,
-0.4474189579486847,
0.6084033846855164,
0.26716816425323486,
-0.6492406129837036,
0.4575926661491394,
-0.41243982315063477,
-0.13607171177864075,
0.529829204082489,
0.2268606275320053,
-0.8307268619537354,
-0.6081953644752502,
-0.3588704466819763,
-0.6726733446121216,
0.12711359560489655,
-0.021066421642899513,
0.7330735921859741,
-0.28967034816741943,
0.07000396400690079,
-0.31775927543640137,
0.3898504972457886,
-0.9302011132240295,
0.07888983935117722,
-0.30835601687431335,
-0.2550813853740692,
0.14656619727611542,
-0.9836650490760803,
-0.4364996552467346,
-0.08892932534217834,
0.7241044640541077,
-0.03153935447335243,
-0.004894210025668144,
0.029814885929226875,
-0.5888062715530396,
-0.04659155383706093,
0.11289674043655396,
0.8083145618438721,
0.20018793642520905,
-0.05777629092335701,
0.5141016244888306,
-0.17427916824817657,
-0.5415786504745483,
0.27289167046546936,
-0.3465670645236969,
-0.2423548400402069,
-0.37801799178123474,
0.26532605290412903,
0.3880758583545685,
0.4121663272380829,
-0.8230917453765869,
0.8698435425758362,
-0.14149115979671478,
0.04662511870265007,
-0.012261471711099148,
0.1310330033302307,
-0.14809657633304596,
0.4114989638328552,
-0.026851264759898186,
-0.3022100627422333,
0.15217125415802002,
-0.20532801747322083,
0.6710950136184692,
0.748654842376709,
-0.7592028379440308,
-0.35609161853790283,
0.819464385509491,
0.19968213140964508,
0.10907362401485443,
0.12343019992113113,
-0.02145380526781082,
-0.5053415894508362,
0.4067075252532959,
0.4892244338989258,
0.7656111717224121,
-0.6379100680351257,
0.27537330985069275,
0.3836563229560852,
0.5681889057159424,
0.25673046708106995,
0.3224414587020874,
0.10535645484924316,
-0.6651846170425415,
-0.36112236976623535,
-0.7167914509773254,
-0.07503998279571533,
0.34003061056137085,
-0.07246133685112,
0.28929486870765686,
-0.9544004201889038,
-0.03003799356520176,
-0.26728126406669617,
-0.3647794723510742,
-0.2730734646320343,
-0.055551521480083466,
0.15472932159900665,
1.0415412187576294,
-1.125138759613037,
0.3515357971191406,
0.5098288655281067,
-0.5286120176315308,
-0.4111216962337494,
-0.16361016035079956,
0.5470162630081177,
-0.8188326358795166,
0.009913557209074497,
0.27519139647483826,
-0.04403020814061165,
0.03173108026385307,
-0.9980725049972534,
-0.6096746921539307,
1.127747654914856,
-0.018301015719771385,
-0.2846008241176605,
0.6197274923324585,
0.11709465831518173,
0.4611387252807617,
-0.32404106855392456,
-0.03582659363746643,
0.27704039216041565,
0.5701360106468201,
0.0549016147851944,
-0.2981894910335541,
0.12187094986438751,
-0.28110769391059875,
-0.18132543563842773,
0.07685999572277069,
-0.46105867624282837,
0.5258431434631348,
0.2108016014099121,
-0.04712209105491638,
-0.10022977739572525,
0.29139912128448486,
0.27310675382614136,
0.36327552795410156,
0.7480801939964294,
0.3219285011291504,
0.34155207872390747,
0.07903487235307693,
0.8677086234092712,
-0.4404646158218384,
-0.048707421869039536,
0.9016044735908508,
0.1852140575647354,
0.7050431370735168,
0.5924462080001831,
0.23100589215755463,
0.6790831089019775,
0.6651951670646667,
-0.11073388159275055,
0.861269474029541,
0.2151133120059967,
-0.8258013725280762,
-0.4021082818508148,
-0.7412698864936829,
-0.12648893892765045,
0.3938574194908142,
0.5888442993164062,
-0.5202216506004333,
-0.33464810252189636,
0.1861771047115326,
0.5220857262611389,
0.2297815978527069,
-0.4656270146369934,
0.8983432650566101,
0.1364138126373291,
-0.27867236733436584,
0.24885234236717224,
0.038868825882673264,
0.7064909934997559,
-0.6550896763801575,
-0.15950731933116913,
-0.15380987524986267,
0.0644167959690094,
-0.12137071788311005,
-0.8109354376792908,
0.33858951926231384,
-0.06254870444536209,
-0.2815534472465515,
-0.3229913115501404,
1.1408709287643433,
-0.5016774535179138,
-0.21033026278018951,
0.6041281819343567,
0.5880727767944336,
-0.08452260494232178,
-0.22261942923069,
-0.8640081286430359,
0.06849279254674911,
-0.0799013152718544,
-0.22683006525039673,
0.397135853767395,
0.16488930583000183,
-0.5932758450508118,
0.6006448864936829,
0.9538348913192749,
-0.29959720373153687,
0.27315041422843933,
0.2211846560239792,
1.1002336740493774,
-0.17700867354869843,
-0.20021991431713104,
-1.1253434419631958,
0.8052029609680176,
-0.3406258523464203,
0.39470377564430237,
0.6350512504577637,
0.3061327338218689,
0.44200584292411804,
0.06515863537788391,
0.7564061880111694,
-0.21634499728679657,
0.25113731622695923,
-0.519179105758667,
0.7793210744857788,
-0.6951378583908081,
0.2584168016910553,
-0.44403043389320374,
-0.8288643956184387,
-0.21158091723918915,
0.3651287257671356,
-0.025497207418084145,
-0.3562932014465332,
0.255624383687973,
0.938493549823761,
-0.22821290791034698,
-0.368421733379364,
0.6154982447624207,
0.24028219282627106,
0.8031147718429565,
0.3594818711280823,
1.0462455749511719,
0.05973147973418236,
0.588085949420929,
-0.18651604652404785,
-0.46712467074394226,
-0.3726710081100464,
-0.9509125351905823,
-1.1893965005874634,
-0.33087772130966187,
0.21740292012691498,
-0.40007519721984863,
-0.0076823062263429165,
0.8866300582885742,
0.5777126550674438,
-0.8780842423439026,
0.12153755128383636,
0.2794579863548279,
0.462494820356369,
-0.06859607249498367,
-0.16109658777713776,
-0.0525406077504158,
-0.16637594997882843,
-0.6750167608261108,
0.44159695506095886,
0.5034809708595276,
0.1404099464416504,
-0.47994235157966614,
-0.11948537081480026,
-0.35964345932006836,
0.3913157284259796,
0.9462152123451233,
0.19041697680950165,
-0.4686708450317383,
-0.507745087146759,
0.025558795779943466,
-0.27375227212905884,
-0.15525992214679718,
0.7315443754196167,
-0.10514289885759354,
0.8232836723327637,
0.5945857763290405,
0.5664455890655518,
0.05581389740109444,
-0.021228725090622902,
0.4847817122936249,
-0.8362089395523071,
0.21322515606880188,
0.0641937106847763,
0.6086437106132507,
0.23099593818187714,
-0.2864166498184204,
0.6762607097625732,
0.4487423300743103,
-0.28604036569595337,
-0.6749573945999146,
0.3660390377044678,
-0.5770668983459473,
-0.4248350262641907,
1.0796518325805664,
-0.12646928429603577,
0.035377368330955505,
-0.46953681111335754,
-0.4367468059062958,
0.008758289739489555,
-0.29751110076904297,
0.9370183944702148,
0.64503413438797,
0.33845555782318115,
-0.27657216787338257,
-0.7193485498428345,
0.496183305978775,
0.3347100019454956,
-0.8413990139961243,
-0.15093496441841125,
0.5960428714752197,
0.5171605944633484,
0.2324291616678238,
0.5055165886878967,
-0.11209779232740402,
0.17895060777664185,
-0.516690731048584,
0.15550929307937622,
-0.04690222814679146,
-0.6293588876724243,
-0.1001010313630104,
-0.17179998755455017,
-0.09798035025596619,
0.06661923974752426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05343v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05343v2
|
M3GIA: A Cognition Inspired Multilingual and Multimodal General Intelligence Ability Benchmark
| 2024-06-08T04:07:09 | 2024-06-14T08:35:06 |
Wei Song, Yadong Li, Jianhua Xu, Guowei Wu, Lingfeng Ming, Kexin Yi, Weihua Luo, Houyi Li, Yi Du, Fangda Guo, Kaicheng Yu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
As recent multi-modality large language models (MLLMs) have shown formidable
proficiency on various complex tasks, there has been increasing attention on
debating whether these models could eventually mirror human intelligence.
However, existing benchmarks mainly focus on evaluating solely on task
performance, such as the accuracy of identifying the attribute of an object.
Combining well-developed cognitive science to understand the intelligence of
MLLMs beyond superficial achievements remains largely unexplored. To this end,
we introduce the first cognitive-driven multi-lingual and multi-modal benchmark
to evaluate the general intelligence ability of MLLMs, dubbed M3GIA.
Specifically, we identify five key cognitive factors based on the
well-recognized Cattell-Horn-Carrol (CHC) model of intelligence and propose a
novel evaluation metric. In addition, since most MLLMs are trained to perform
in different languages, a natural question arises: is language a key factor
influencing the cognitive ability of MLLMs? As such, we go beyond English to
encompass other languages based on their popularity, including Chinese, French,
Spanish, Portuguese and Korean, to construct our M3GIA. We make sure all the
data relevant to the cultural backgrounds are collected from their native
context to avoid English-centric bias. We collected a significant corpus of
data from human participants, revealing that the most advanced MLLM reaches the
lower boundary of human intelligence in English. Yet, there remains a
pronounced disparity in the other five languages assessed. We also reveals an
interesting winner takes all phenomenon that are aligned with the discovery in
cognitive studies. Our benchmark will be open-sourced, with the aspiration of
facilitating the enhancement of cognitive capabilities in MLLMs.
|
[
-0.6182039380073547,
-0.5376007556915283,
0.5728632807731628,
0.1982870250940323,
0.07119231671094894,
0.09197942167520523,
-0.507330596446991,
-0.5307459831237793,
0.01686304248869419,
0.07513799518346786,
-0.7143644690513611,
-0.5036460757255554,
-0.638771653175354,
0.15687455236911774,
0.07633770257234573,
0.75749671459198,
0.3587765097618103,
0.5337001085281372,
-0.30041828751564026,
-0.5570406317710876,
-0.35866644978523254,
-0.6566723585128784,
-0.5585238933563232,
-0.267808735370636,
0.9410622119903564,
0.19126616418361664,
0.5704202651977539,
0.23126599192619324,
0.5760214924812317,
0.24376630783081055,
0.11047114431858063,
0.7022554874420166,
-0.4623123109340668,
-0.2822766602039337,
-0.21657034754753113,
-0.5629072189331055,
-0.5531886219978333,
0.06913481652736664,
0.4975930154323578,
0.7327569723129272,
-0.1216830238699913,
0.3817542493343353,
0.2774428725242615,
0.9035449624061584,
-0.7407417297363281,
0.1571323573589325,
-0.7584662437438965,
0.020520158112049103,
-0.24449563026428223,
-0.008964701555669308,
-0.32691460847854614,
-0.12405899912118912,
-0.2842792570590973,
-0.8090893626213074,
-0.08696882426738739,
0.13128463923931122,
0.5971748232841492,
0.06230546161532402,
-0.5133901238441467,
-0.3138038218021393,
-0.29474973678588867,
0.8534207940101624,
-0.3957754075527191,
0.5722227692604065,
0.2902221381664276,
0.4573386013507843,
-0.19951894879341125,
-0.4797288477420807,
-0.5631212592124939,
-0.5036577582359314,
-0.04690701141953468,
0.2617535889148712,
-0.14740967750549316,
-0.15520194172859192,
0.12495323270559311,
0.07517024874687195,
-0.8419861793518066,
-0.09497042000293732,
-0.4670228660106659,
-0.21162086725234985,
0.5673496723175049,
0.3207893967628479,
0.5089792609214783,
0.10856615006923676,
-0.3430776000022888,
0.14126503467559814,
-0.7248647809028625,
0.2239779233932495,
0.3757402300834656,
0.1550750583410263,
0.10854741930961609,
0.6332457661628723,
-0.3518698811531067,
0.4399806559085846,
-0.292585551738739,
-0.21922840178012848,
0.5159493684768677,
-0.3604559898376465,
-0.021448755636811256,
-0.154663547873497,
0.8090799450874329,
0.4627789855003357,
0.5181643962860107,
-0.278390496969223,
0.009027635678648949,
0.08927745372056961,
0.17972318828105927,
-0.7860924005508423,
-0.1396990269422531,
0.10550887137651443,
-0.4722469449043274,
0.09782104939222336,
-0.02912660874426365,
-0.6080123782157898,
-0.43023109436035156,
-0.2877136766910553,
0.4264768064022064,
-0.6094931960105896,
-0.4945983588695526,
0.06101054325699806,
0.04723738133907318,
0.11226759105920792,
-0.008291722275316715,
-1.0859808921813965,
0.20831431448459625,
1.0629591941833496,
0.7529922127723694,
-0.13031603395938873,
-0.6898618340492249,
-0.2578311860561371,
0.12168438732624054,
-0.5772873759269714,
0.8680757880210876,
-0.6055541038513184,
-0.2900840938091278,
-0.259183406829834,
-0.03162245452404022,
-0.3172546923160553,
-0.4941358268260956,
0.6345716714859009,
-0.34961333870887756,
0.3665214478969574,
-0.4716755151748657,
-0.4161326587200165,
-0.5014084577560425,
0.575813353061676,
-0.6498183012008667,
0.8360585570335388,
-0.06364893168210983,
-0.5543842315673828,
0.5040490627288818,
-0.893020510673523,
-0.310463547706604,
0.04013470932841301,
-0.43099701404571533,
-0.13169334828853607,
0.09086071699857712,
0.26777324080467224,
0.2314632683992386,
-0.6787896156311035,
0.4915359616279602,
-0.5194969773292542,
-0.37714552879333496,
0.4681318700313568,
-0.7622855305671692,
1.1237733364105225,
0.10206099599599838,
-0.26701977849006653,
0.16298645734786987,
-0.8080829381942749,
0.4437660276889801,
0.033124905079603195,
-0.4220274090766907,
-0.12862540781497955,
0.11976531893014908,
-0.11869799345731735,
0.3954181969165802,
0.3142869472503662,
-0.3788178563117981,
0.09704461693763733,
0.016689641401171684,
0.19224900007247925,
0.569083571434021,
-0.17014476656913757,
0.13809916377067566,
-0.4408644139766693,
0.19961467385292053,
-0.10100261867046356,
0.36625149846076965,
0.18595477938652039,
-0.7517357468605042,
-0.4588475823402405,
-0.764003336429596,
0.25746047496795654,
0.7133339047431946,
-0.6557136178016663,
0.23396477103233337,
-0.5856988430023193,
-0.6746680736541748,
-0.8926265239715576,
0.5762256979942322,
0.4847602844238281,
0.2262384444475174,
0.29043087363243103,
-0.19327415525913239,
-0.3943652808666229,
-1.0920668840408325,
-0.3124188780784607,
-0.10927218943834305,
-0.3687690198421478,
0.48778194189071655,
0.32804885506629944,
-0.24888253211975098,
0.3411937952041626,
-0.18495726585388184,
-0.40415260195732117,
-0.2610841989517212,
0.0889262706041336,
0.21869921684265137,
0.4862927794456482,
0.6546197533607483,
-0.7398968935012817,
-0.2429521232843399,
0.1787492334842682,
-1.0783650875091553,
0.06218283250927925,
0.14649076759815216,
-0.41390806436538696,
0.08692827820777893,
0.5068588852882385,
-0.6792064309120178,
-0.047957129776477814,
0.7382140159606934,
-0.45717546343803406,
0.47329023480415344,
-0.2744096517562866,
0.4345678687095642,
-0.8785686492919922,
0.3751864731311798,
-0.3445683717727661,
0.30873844027519226,
-0.5590643286705017,
0.10255880653858185,
0.2223525047302246,
-0.048975348472595215,
-0.4284384250640869,
0.5395920872688293,
-0.6096309423446655,
-0.08425350487232208,
0.025977076962590218,
0.16490335762500763,
0.025305690243840218,
0.8842152953147888,
-0.15738101303577423,
0.6780016422271729,
0.5387465357780457,
-0.621802031993866,
0.22025881707668304,
-0.27004265785217285,
-0.6924476027488708,
0.7772810459136963,
-0.35671237111091614,
-0.005820427555590868,
-0.03725070133805275,
-0.25102415680885315,
-0.9355767369270325,
0.08576951175928116,
0.17249277234077454,
-0.6324753165245056,
0.13044697046279907,
0.13756227493286133,
-0.3841146230697632,
-0.20995952188968658,
-0.1322568953037262,
0.296459436416626,
0.22502237558364868,
-0.32420021295547485,
0.9135239720344543,
0.2891024649143219,
0.05278586223721504,
-0.5461152791976929,
-0.6486492156982422,
0.3267275393009186,
-0.20930777490139008,
-0.6080281734466553,
0.237726092338562,
-0.5385773181915283,
-0.2995586693286896,
-0.1441129893064499,
0.2575174570083618,
0.07443665713071823,
0.3516401946544647,
0.031187234446406364,
0.3153938055038452,
-0.5607976913452148,
0.13209214806556702,
-0.23887485265731812,
-0.0721098780632019,
0.15097209811210632,
-0.2238720804452896,
0.3566659092903137,
-0.4187898635864258,
-0.5681669116020203,
-0.12152909487485886,
0.4692682921886444,
0.9582761526107788,
-0.5377212166786194,
0.7522764801979065,
1.0308665037155151,
-0.2697699964046478,
0.3175975978374481,
-0.5112829208374023,
-0.03314311429858208,
-0.3793710768222809,
0.5818362832069397,
-0.7080653309822083,
-0.6423746943473816,
0.3608368933200836,
-0.06456615775823593,
0.11502949893474579,
0.3314683139324188,
0.6646873950958252,
-0.036894913762807846,
1.3347212076187134,
0.5201687216758728,
-0.12388123571872711,
0.3674817383289337,
-0.06393460929393768,
0.008362026885151863,
-1.128133773803711,
-0.3299270570278168,
-0.2813031077384949,
-0.4358098804950714,
-0.6440280675888062,
-0.48584505915641785,
0.5058072209358215,
0.029000980779528618,
-0.2237015664577484,
-0.19334663450717926,
-0.08834834396839142,
0.32536178827285767,
0.521817147731781,
0.13083516061306,
0.17588810622692108,
-0.2837362289428711,
-0.598063051700592,
0.05184369161725044,
-0.7692068815231323,
-0.42053624987602234,
1.3628790378570557,
0.08278749138116837,
0.020106937736272812,
0.630290150642395,
0.22414034605026245,
0.37530988454818726,
0.517729640007019,
-0.604385495185852,
0.6892656683921814,
-0.029742619022727013,
-0.8723492622375488,
-0.2715279757976532,
-0.36240527033805847,
-0.9633280634880066,
0.7316249012947083,
-0.4588337540626526,
-0.7467162013053894,
-0.05051974952220917,
-0.23322366178035736,
-0.2610275149345398,
0.10885007679462433,
-0.8085144758224487,
1.0049469470977783,
-0.7062307596206665,
-0.5713618993759155,
-0.4928872883319855,
-0.29356831312179565,
0.5349674224853516,
0.2032269984483719,
0.46153825521469116,
-0.6029394865036011,
-0.33455827832221985,
0.5019304156303406,
0.1833280622959137,
0.5095887184143066,
-0.23242293298244476,
0.19091378152370453,
0.16168080270290375,
0.09631335735321045,
0.031145183369517326,
0.024022318422794342,
-0.22250260412693024,
0.41460567712783813,
-0.1753247082233429,
-0.8214849233627319,
-0.7276416420936584,
0.7120406627655029,
-0.7294586300849915,
-0.8078182935714722,
-0.11596722900867462,
-0.5250142216682434,
-0.6615946292877197,
0.2876890003681183,
-0.058250438421964645,
0.47064587473869324,
-0.5335773825645447,
0.28058990836143494,
0.34529978036880493,
0.206104576587677,
0.49492719769477844,
0.8268064260482788,
-0.36499813199043274,
-0.6290760636329651,
1.130537509918213,
0.06453723460435867,
0.02924039587378502,
0.39586326479911804,
0.07106324285268784,
-0.15664361417293549,
-0.6242511868476868,
-0.8752764463424683,
0.08755753934383392,
-0.6461145877838135,
0.14284971356391907,
-0.5639591813087463,
0.01139671541750431,
-0.1035001277923584,
-0.011210061609745026,
-0.21162626147270203,
-0.1306595802307129,
0.012662157416343689,
-0.0025560022331774235,
-0.12261737138032913,
0.6941828727722168,
-0.14081989228725433,
-0.3443581163883209,
-0.6889829039573669,
0.2203446477651596,
0.5137456655502319,
0.3083839416503906,
0.07668918371200562,
-0.15924915671348572,
-0.3036292493343353,
0.18729135394096375,
-0.016006771475076675,
-0.5101467370986938,
0.14065596461296082,
0.3487269878387451,
1.091477870941162,
0.6317400932312012,
-0.44849255681037903,
0.584182620048523,
-0.503269374370575,
0.8422086238861084,
0.09602593630552292,
-0.6945663094520569,
0.08875220268964767,
-0.29487794637680054,
0.4829196631908417,
0.6490176916122437,
0.45826956629753113,
-0.5065100789070129,
-0.18691882491111755,
-0.2981957495212555,
-0.5542312264442444,
0.21620382368564606,
0.05023076757788658,
-0.08877701312303543,
-0.20030592381954193,
-0.20365212857723236,
0.08089429885149002,
0.18357357382774353,
-0.6049748063087463,
-0.055486273020505905,
-0.12305233627557755,
-0.2595021426677704,
-0.3226906359195709,
-0.15414266288280487,
-0.19489745795726776,
-0.3168191611766815,
0.6618081331253052,
-0.45666250586509705,
0.15343308448791504,
0.06170836091041565,
-0.23757213354110718,
0.29263120889663696,
0.29554635286331177,
1.0194073915481567,
0.7615247964859009,
-0.02769644372165203,
0.17931607365608215,
0.3968678116798401,
-0.5979669094085693,
-0.045244816690683365,
-0.09199148416519165,
0.13124799728393555,
-0.33072733879089355,
0.4428512454032898,
0.48115450143814087,
0.3660027086734772,
-1.0424286127090454,
0.28818655014038086,
-0.34879544377326965,
-0.19607502222061157,
-0.16561174392700195,
0.16183032095432281,
0.4015701711177826,
0.386052668094635,
0.5494555234909058,
0.23299890756607056,
0.25246307253837585,
-0.6813065409660339,
-0.00012681503721978515,
0.6044650077819824,
-0.5674903392791748,
-0.25763261318206787,
0.407615602016449,
0.2334175705909729,
-0.13327890634536743,
0.4901319444179535,
-0.49857866764068604,
-0.493853360414505,
0.34647098183631897,
0.3179558515548706,
0.7972512245178223,
-0.0966019406914711,
-0.03733640909194946,
0.4512477517127991,
0.6539614200592041,
0.25841668248176575,
0.3317564129829407,
-0.1543596088886261,
-0.8372431397438049,
-0.0781284049153328,
-0.3919524848461151,
-0.17753063142299652,
-0.050698935985565186,
-0.4555295407772064,
0.07056758552789688,
-0.22622881829738617,
-0.20205137133598328,
-0.05758647993206978,
0.2476567178964615,
-0.8062865138053894,
0.3012360632419586,
0.6074498891830444,
0.8036896586418152,
-0.5244404077529907,
0.957024097442627,
0.5606716275215149,
-0.23992741107940674,
-0.3879249393939972,
-0.1995597630739212,
0.14193004369735718,
-0.9402211904525757,
0.4941501319408417,
0.2757044732570648,
-0.4917048215866089,
-0.14702771604061127,
-0.06106782332062721,
-1.0067791938781738,
1.3255265951156616,
0.3191830515861511,
-0.34526070952415466,
0.21743375062942505,
0.081806980073452,
0.5921506285667419,
-0.6738740801811218,
0.5069067478179932,
0.516021728515625,
0.6924673914909363,
-0.21842209994792938,
-0.7785207629203796,
-0.11174290627241135,
-0.7629492282867432,
-0.11141573637723923,
0.00955641083419323,
-0.7997602820396423,
0.8065854907035828,
-0.3804607689380646,
-0.1509810984134674,
-0.019042398780584335,
0.8389772176742554,
0.25803831219673157,
0.37978315353393555,
0.35129889845848083,
0.3823280930519104,
1.165624737739563,
-0.052803587168455124,
0.8440447449684143,
-0.6267063021659851,
-0.12336448580026627,
0.9047313332557678,
-0.34445834159851074,
0.9739254713058472,
0.3517780005931854,
-0.09002409875392914,
0.7505964040756226,
0.297931045293808,
0.07001601159572601,
0.5022764801979065,
0.08186773955821991,
-0.3098298907279968,
-0.22444100677967072,
-0.19229310750961304,
-0.17985104024410248,
0.7145392298698425,
0.6198357343673706,
-0.2477424144744873,
0.14362786710262299,
0.0640377551317215,
0.34313762187957764,
0.08035605400800705,
-0.5690085887908936,
0.7159574031829834,
-0.2913641035556793,
-0.9940771460533142,
0.7854329943656921,
-0.05879347026348114,
0.7419472336769104,
-0.7864277362823486,
0.2322002649307251,
-0.1538098305463791,
0.20675064623355865,
-0.0028621212113648653,
-0.6082940697669983,
0.07941047847270966,
-0.13865892589092255,
-0.22110232710838318,
0.17603358626365662,
0.3702986240386963,
-0.5102241635322571,
-0.7138045430183411,
0.5566163063049316,
0.8145553469657898,
0.03299595043063164,
-0.15541280806064606,
-0.8574625849723816,
-0.0020836549811065197,
0.06290528178215027,
-0.25303155183792114,
0.5060499310493469,
0.5534289479255676,
0.015998609364032745,
0.8131554126739502,
0.872601330280304,
0.005810687784105539,
0.038409776985645294,
0.10962063074111938,
0.5944263339042664,
-0.6159608960151672,
-0.1779596358537674,
-0.9348065257072449,
0.40697410702705383,
-0.18412205576896667,
-0.578542172908783,
0.7019614577293396,
0.7671107649803162,
0.6337159872055054,
-0.006169500295072794,
0.8260024785995483,
0.07014355808496475,
0.26404160261154175,
-0.6017981171607971,
1.005842924118042,
-0.6277019381523132,
-0.03956267610192299,
0.10274423658847809,
-0.6370211243629456,
-0.10012082010507584,
0.10458086431026459,
-0.33846515417099,
0.10528340935707092,
0.9090662002563477,
0.9805631041526794,
0.12958011031150818,
0.060587093234062195,
0.8366676568984985,
0.002117904368788004,
0.19440576434135437,
0.9411947131156921,
0.6560826301574707,
-0.16975447535514832,
0.7473417520523071,
-0.17325495183467865,
-0.22198712825775146,
-0.11625855416059494,
-0.725386381149292,
-1.0944124460220337,
-0.6573589444160461,
0.0942610502243042,
0.09744613617658615,
0.1304626762866974,
0.9940400719642639,
0.6308253407478333,
-0.6803293228149414,
-0.24118760228157043,
0.21441951394081116,
0.11015542596578598,
-0.6689445376396179,
-0.18036819994449615,
0.16857032477855682,
-0.2664121091365814,
-0.6300032734870911,
0.5723184943199158,
0.4900849759578705,
-0.1530483514070511,
-0.5845668315887451,
-0.1328330785036087,
-0.41992709040641785,
0.356318861246109,
0.7744393944740295,
0.11545844376087189,
-0.839705228805542,
-0.19833651185035706,
0.17387431859970093,
-0.43590712547302246,
-0.053568895906209946,
0.7642326354980469,
-0.5490718483924866,
0.3102463185787201,
0.16703185439109802,
0.49066877365112305,
0.002055504359304905,
-0.3246234655380249,
0.4819291830062866,
-0.22405315935611725,
0.11271755397319794,
0.1470545381307602,
0.5848221182823181,
0.4443444609642029,
-0.15839865803718567,
0.6419702172279358,
0.2078842669725418,
-0.34254682064056396,
-0.37646180391311646,
0.05178863927721977,
-0.6698126792907715,
-0.41742709279060364,
1.004977822303772,
-0.20291286706924438,
-0.4782806932926178,
-0.21543791890144348,
-0.4035683274269104,
-0.12683172523975372,
-0.12688444554805756,
0.9370072484016418,
0.9382633566856384,
-0.17955803871154785,
-0.12500451505184174,
-0.6638267636299133,
0.4452948570251465,
0.5081234574317932,
-0.7420424818992615,
0.010292712599039078,
0.42016568779945374,
0.14063231647014618,
0.26716747879981995,
0.5792916417121887,
-0.10163777321577072,
0.589680552482605,
0.2774291932582855,
0.24229486286640167,
-0.23111142218112946,
-0.43206462264060974,
-0.0297083742916584,
0.48227962851524353,
0.15003038942813873,
-0.1173839196562767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05328v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05328v1
|
Hidden Question Representations Tell Non-Factuality Within and Across Large Language Models
| 2024-06-08T02:59:52 | 2024-06-08T02:59:52 |
Yanling Wang, Haoyang Li, Hao Zou, Jing Zhang, Xinlei He, Qi Li, Ke Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite the remarkable advance of large language models (LLMs), the
prevalence of non-factual responses remains a common issue. This work studies
non-factuality prediction (NFP), which predicts whether an LLM will generate
non-factual responses to a question before the generation process. Previous
efforts on NFP usually rely on extensive computation. In this work, we conduct
extensive analysis to explore the capabilities of using a lightweight probe to
elicit ``whether an LLM knows'' from the hidden representations of questions.
Additionally, we discover that the non-factuality probe employs similar
patterns for NFP across multiple LLMs. Motivated by the intriguing finding, we
conduct effective transfer learning for cross-LLM NFP and propose a
question-aligned strategy to ensure the efficacy of mini-batch based training.
|
[
-0.5321541428565979,
-0.7097550630569458,
0.7666468620300293,
-0.19371017813682556,
0.041892167180776596,
0.07360587269067764,
-0.07883727550506592,
-0.5085597038269043,
0.2612811028957367,
0.36463662981987,
-0.7602266669273376,
-0.2450844794511795,
-0.7571154236793518,
0.09680277109146118,
-0.5019264221191406,
0.8807536363601685,
0.09196943044662476,
0.042412880808115005,
-0.5744459629058838,
-0.26398763060569763,
-0.3307923972606659,
-0.346713125705719,
-0.5748379230499268,
-0.20480787754058838,
0.6086105108261108,
0.5289201140403748,
0.3330172300338745,
0.4240821599960327,
0.16548345983028412,
0.18442372977733612,
0.016799280419945717,
0.22027944028377533,
-0.62856125831604,
0.021608669310808182,
-0.3729439377784729,
-1.0451719760894775,
0.05448038503527641,
0.09802152216434479,
0.7767338156700134,
0.8609308004379272,
0.2569811940193176,
0.4735184609889984,
-0.03172091394662857,
0.38897183537483215,
-0.5709301233291626,
0.18918579816818237,
-0.7588907480239868,
0.19895468652248383,
0.17972615361213684,
-0.20273691415786743,
-0.5956252217292786,
-0.39251628518104553,
0.18008705973625183,
-0.15619529783725739,
0.6478415131568909,
0.4181572198867798,
0.6988698840141296,
0.19850213825702667,
-0.7127460241317749,
-0.23635238409042358,
-0.7298002243041992,
0.6925173401832581,
-0.5506613254547119,
0.39527425169944763,
0.4607406556606293,
0.3657207489013672,
-0.15580442547798157,
-0.37524986267089844,
-0.7303435802459717,
-0.33360546827316284,
-0.2835760712623596,
-0.14892339706420898,
0.05604931712150574,
-0.30384179949760437,
0.40480557084083557,
0.295693039894104,
-0.6627445220947266,
0.10891875624656677,
-0.1250944286584854,
-0.3294004499912262,
0.4471047818660736,
0.08229875564575195,
0.17594820261001587,
-0.12688501179218292,
-0.531055212020874,
0.12227348983287811,
-0.6551291942596436,
0.058934733271598816,
0.08519957214593887,
0.26315879821777344,
-0.3448319435119629,
0.598761796951294,
-0.10020942240953445,
0.48013216257095337,
0.47563809156417847,
-0.1984064280986786,
-0.03459896519780159,
-0.45266398787498474,
-0.09420081228017807,
0.17388148605823517,
0.6577919125556946,
0.05876694619655609,
-0.14046266674995422,
-0.20414437353610992,
-0.22808396816253662,
-0.23419585824012756,
-0.10483679920434952,
-0.7806656956672668,
-0.011490542441606522,
0.0879029929637909,
-0.15650084614753723,
-0.32849225401878357,
-0.025502357631921768,
-0.7002059817314148,
-0.5609318614006042,
0.029758084565401077,
0.4389904737472534,
-0.22655151784420013,
-0.31447097659111023,
-0.08460549265146255,
-0.06423391401767731,
0.4191543757915497,
0.48415809869766235,
-0.9305851459503174,
0.1990918517112732,
0.36180001497268677,
0.48746705055236816,
0.04301316291093826,
-0.1364784687757492,
-0.7152734994888306,
0.2551107108592987,
-0.5242206454277039,
0.8665606379508972,
-0.5440412759780884,
-0.30307453870773315,
-0.11458626389503479,
0.2154955416917801,
-0.38758137822151184,
-0.45976540446281433,
0.20398961007595062,
-0.7207645177841187,
0.46831193566322327,
-0.7791556119918823,
-0.665349006652832,
-0.2961050868034363,
0.6801902651786804,
-0.8162621855735779,
0.9791642427444458,
-0.09204886853694916,
-0.9446032047271729,
0.37291908264160156,
-0.26256412267684937,
-0.08127876371145248,
-0.14345666766166687,
-0.4445632994174957,
-0.3495408594608307,
0.25640612840652466,
0.418079137802124,
0.49854186177253723,
-0.3061735928058624,
0.17981435358524323,
-0.43940192461013794,
-0.3812450170516968,
0.5608342885971069,
-0.40392059087753296,
0.28846052289009094,
-0.3562198877334595,
-0.5144147276878357,
-0.17811305820941925,
-0.517301619052887,
-0.0670316219329834,
0.24908988177776337,
-0.45450887084007263,
0.10282137244939804,
-0.5454484820365906,
-0.5154057145118713,
0.19790303707122803,
0.3081391751766205,
-0.7835631966590881,
0.17899097502231598,
-0.38534578680992126,
-0.17473706603050232,
0.5713649988174438,
0.2059999704360962,
0.4762629270553589,
-0.45671987533569336,
0.6317048072814941,
0.01397713553160429,
-0.1712341010570526,
0.12548190355300903,
-0.6445870399475098,
-0.8344417214393616,
0.1273057907819748,
0.449880987405777,
0.5066810250282288,
-1.0810424089431763,
-0.0068420106545090675,
-0.005409558303654194,
-0.5395910143852234,
-0.299220472574234,
0.11812807619571686,
0.5160885453224182,
0.747890830039978,
0.34661865234375,
0.0711151584982872,
-0.48630034923553467,
-0.7914862632751465,
-0.4941297173500061,
-0.4456362724304199,
0.36226046085357666,
0.5000172257423401,
0.6327228546142578,
-0.14735284447669983,
0.7808921933174133,
-0.47094348073005676,
0.04173082485795021,
-0.634590208530426,
0.7112807631492615,
0.20322194695472717,
0.19152964651584625,
0.5621481537818909,
-0.7678998112678528,
-0.4065704345703125,
-0.14483018219470978,
-0.6973654627799988,
0.11020629853010178,
-0.26813194155693054,
0.1432594656944275,
0.37506452202796936,
0.6059331893920898,
-0.6477441191673279,
0.3227645456790924,
0.6714205741882324,
-0.11042177677154541,
0.4872380793094635,
-0.08240576833486557,
0.028845321387052536,
-0.8418440222740173,
0.10412229597568512,
-0.10970906913280487,
-0.3007289469242096,
-0.45350515842437744,
-0.15815261006355286,
0.26442408561706543,
0.001698175212368369,
-0.4981708526611328,
0.7017804384231567,
-0.6057227253913879,
-0.20540675520896912,
-0.17092494666576385,
-0.04400757700204849,
0.05613546073436737,
0.5012409090995789,
0.023917317390441895,
0.9388024210929871,
0.496024489402771,
-0.5817316770553589,
0.12266944348812103,
0.19103877246379852,
-0.31603899598121643,
0.10979308187961578,
-0.39240744709968567,
0.4011109471321106,
-0.5338646173477173,
0.2883300185203552,
-1.1528944969177246,
-0.049699898809194565,
-0.018147429451346397,
-0.7673689723014832,
0.5396469831466675,
-0.5285233855247498,
-0.5891105532646179,
-0.13128897547721863,
-0.26351210474967957,
0.49772951006889343,
0.4052295684814453,
-0.46909797191619873,
0.52469801902771,
0.07456429302692413,
-0.0852588415145874,
-0.7210732102394104,
-0.7214399576187134,
-0.13944609463214874,
-0.023351460695266724,
-0.47282564640045166,
-0.09482505917549133,
-0.021566614508628845,
0.02417282573878765,
0.06865676492452621,
-0.28246331214904785,
-0.05108814686536789,
0.061966631561517715,
0.13825733959674835,
0.35213154554367065,
-0.5790757536888123,
0.20624226331710815,
-0.062498610466718674,
0.056274861097335815,
0.28434911370277405,
-0.07159234583377838,
0.5116890668869019,
-0.10617072880268097,
-0.5058975219726562,
-0.11707736551761627,
0.18660467863082886,
0.43641287088394165,
-0.20017698407173157,
1.0638231039047241,
0.5951327085494995,
-0.30795785784721375,
-0.5241281986236572,
-0.6157518029212952,
-0.22621819376945496,
-0.4673456847667694,
0.22366933524608612,
-0.08462663739919662,
-0.9355981349945068,
0.4125204384326935,
-0.19324269890785217,
-0.1958194375038147,
0.42037394642829895,
0.5097634792327881,
-0.12435390055179596,
0.8397490978240967,
0.8288138508796692,
0.00830836407840252,
0.16618409752845764,
-0.32006704807281494,
0.19916610419750214,
-0.5958750247955322,
-0.6263973712921143,
-0.31157031655311584,
-0.31500279903411865,
-0.5698248744010925,
-0.9795166254043579,
0.39135414361953735,
-0.0675768107175827,
0.1254323571920395,
0.14129555225372314,
0.3569224178791046,
0.5446518659591675,
0.25523874163627625,
-0.15392924845218658,
0.1785833239555359,
-0.1728930026292801,
-0.4058513641357422,
0.05252878740429878,
-0.7726702690124512,
-0.2957307994365692,
1.1569819450378418,
0.20996245741844177,
0.5989148616790771,
0.1589076966047287,
0.8554238080978394,
0.1137542650103569,
0.21907542645931244,
-0.7695465087890625,
0.6879555583000183,
0.23800469934940338,
-0.8390753269195557,
-0.3461111783981323,
-0.6365894079208374,
-0.7103611826896667,
0.2242131531238556,
-0.4794939458370209,
-0.33244484663009644,
0.29681602120399475,
0.0069413804449141026,
-0.5604544281959534,
0.52267986536026,
-0.6337273120880127,
0.41019824147224426,
-0.287964403629303,
-0.34257668256759644,
0.1495053470134735,
-0.5775328874588013,
0.426166296005249,
-0.2066177874803543,
0.12223339825868607,
-0.09639091044664383,
-0.058181390166282654,
0.676904022693634,
0.06835099309682846,
0.9603105187416077,
-0.1877133548259735,
-0.06582539528608322,
0.2681252658367157,
0.28398704528808594,
0.5434549450874329,
0.4094330668449402,
-0.10096300393342972,
-0.19772669672966003,
-0.09188570827245712,
-0.37721362709999084,
-0.8280225992202759,
0.6359740495681763,
-0.5332891345024109,
-0.7427478432655334,
-0.482395738363266,
-0.5451726913452148,
-0.7990785837173462,
0.3260885775089264,
0.16553395986557007,
0.2669045925140381,
-0.27756667137145996,
0.059716884046792984,
1.2396535873413086,
-0.48818886280059814,
0.2826007306575775,
0.752018392086029,
-0.19092197716236115,
0.13513493537902832,
0.7286794185638428,
0.14638398587703705,
0.3862757384777069,
0.7267466187477112,
0.32653671503067017,
-0.6104625463485718,
-0.5171844959259033,
-0.578546404838562,
0.6430342197418213,
-0.7904011607170105,
-0.13390740752220154,
-0.6402355432510376,
-0.21654623746871948,
-0.5514478087425232,
0.3042833209037781,
-0.4148994982242584,
-0.3987645208835602,
-0.3866281807422638,
-0.453349232673645,
0.180031880736351,
0.9287713766098022,
-0.0072003616951406,
-0.12936802208423615,
-0.7356870174407959,
0.48055216670036316,
0.5604943633079529,
0.11995740234851837,
-0.12091667205095291,
-0.6196756362915039,
-0.19693271815776825,
0.1546226441860199,
-0.046770669519901276,
-0.8169929385185242,
0.2507869005203247,
0.2328803539276123,
0.6330581903457642,
0.41110745072364807,
0.3465355634689331,
0.3813115358352661,
-0.2491103559732437,
0.6661053895950317,
0.048317477107048035,
-0.7522173523902893,
0.39371153712272644,
-0.220637708902359,
0.04882659763097763,
0.6197249293327332,
0.6630118489265442,
-0.35443684458732605,
-0.23999440670013428,
-0.6583304405212402,
-0.32335394620895386,
0.5794568061828613,
0.023347854614257812,
0.14743566513061523,
0.08679217845201492,
0.3395240902900696,
0.3306751847267151,
0.38257861137390137,
-0.5266814827919006,
-0.28312310576438904,
0.08460178971290588,
0.16426998376846313,
-0.0724894255399704,
-0.31548428535461426,
-0.13603132963180542,
-0.32676026225090027,
0.33391696214675903,
-0.4425315260887146,
0.5968239903450012,
0.13542862236499786,
-0.08484067022800446,
-0.13244105875492096,
0.23416931927204132,
0.3871802091598511,
0.5824426412582397,
-0.31611815094947815,
0.42754894495010376,
0.46800467371940613,
-0.23509268462657928,
0.024326413869857788,
-0.26565954089164734,
0.056287217885255814,
0.014733333140611649,
0.6510687470436096,
0.7722741365432739,
0.17871253192424774,
-0.4772394597530365,
0.7265334725379944,
-0.21021020412445068,
-0.4231294095516205,
-0.22812627255916595,
0.04394565150141716,
0.30831944942474365,
0.23309874534606934,
0.12858904898166656,
-0.01130692195147276,
-0.0888536348938942,
-0.8926068544387817,
0.27908939123153687,
0.4674970805644989,
-0.32983583211898804,
-0.43900108337402344,
0.5255178809165955,
-0.1680729240179062,
0.28168046474456787,
0.5253550410270691,
-0.36705395579338074,
-0.6548725962638855,
0.6616687178611755,
0.6219755411148071,
0.6033620238304138,
-0.07920611649751663,
0.5505288243293762,
0.26988664269447327,
0.4419589936733246,
0.06780454516410828,
0.5692775249481201,
-0.03651086613535881,
-0.8074780702590942,
-0.4223845303058624,
-0.4481518566608429,
-0.5117016434669495,
0.21420826017856598,
-0.7242063879966736,
0.19668030738830566,
-0.8800907135009766,
0.0802062377333641,
-0.29261621832847595,
0.17504581809043884,
-0.6299704313278198,
0.4297327399253845,
0.5405635833740234,
0.7667250633239746,
-1.0331100225448608,
0.9688277244567871,
0.5532577037811279,
-0.3479812741279602,
-0.9848825931549072,
0.4132750630378723,
-0.0884874239563942,
-1.2271835803985596,
0.7099558115005493,
0.2563934028148651,
-0.2534680664539337,
-0.42930367588996887,
-0.7061905264854431,
-1.228179931640625,
1.0992646217346191,
0.776864230632782,
-0.3370877504348755,
0.04511650279164314,
0.4651952087879181,
0.35087427496910095,
-0.13623476028442383,
0.1552816480398178,
0.34343570470809937,
0.37974944710731506,
0.6085145473480225,
-0.7614713311195374,
0.39830514788627625,
-0.12804727256298065,
-0.25148147344589233,
0.17380274832248688,
-0.6044235825538635,
1.1535993814468384,
-0.5259767770767212,
-0.3945263624191284,
-0.1389228105545044,
0.7801865935325623,
0.12434260547161102,
0.4648635983467102,
0.30857744812965393,
0.39925727248191833,
1.0851430892944336,
0.11670178920030594,
0.9655271172523499,
-0.16685503721237183,
0.2843533754348755,
1.1098819971084595,
-0.25266894698143005,
0.6779555678367615,
0.5670611262321472,
0.12293940037488937,
0.6389530897140503,
0.45168718695640564,
-0.08447396010160446,
0.44795361161231995,
0.09528613090515137,
-0.11700670421123505,
-0.3762422502040863,
-0.20721237361431122,
-0.5049639940261841,
0.37435150146484375,
0.3008477985858917,
-0.286161869764328,
-0.2832110822200775,
-0.2981724739074707,
0.014392295852303505,
-0.17175032198429108,
-0.19722875952720642,
0.699970543384552,
0.01784590259194374,
-0.5616176724433899,
0.7568252086639404,
0.09030545502901077,
0.5717189908027649,
-0.45635154843330383,
-0.17618843913078308,
-0.5117501020431519,
-0.06516662240028381,
-0.3038707971572876,
-0.6974593997001648,
0.28155580163002014,
-0.23313018679618835,
-0.18887630105018616,
-0.15854066610336304,
0.7756437063217163,
-0.3727897107601166,
-0.5370705723762512,
0.2920368015766144,
0.8648353815078735,
-0.007552122697234154,
-0.09049609303474426,
-0.49274247884750366,
-0.41518768668174744,
0.11608198285102844,
0.0014576787361875176,
0.6460691690444946,
0.7276056408882141,
-0.049315329641103745,
0.6896700263023376,
0.609552264213562,
0.1779107302427292,
0.4698096513748169,
-0.31733667850494385,
0.8715230822563171,
-0.6387953162193298,
-0.3541244864463806,
-0.6038904190063477,
0.12283381819725037,
0.10778474807739258,
-0.1234879344701767,
1.0679816007614136,
0.4322803020477295,
0.8237673044204712,
-0.017192866653203964,
0.8711669445037842,
0.22208604216575623,
0.49766287207603455,
-0.6421588063240051,
0.5718135833740234,
-0.5897361636161804,
0.2800266742706299,
-0.09572585672140121,
-0.5813896059989929,
0.056502778083086014,
0.2581382691860199,
-0.4705284833908081,
-0.0037836909759789705,
0.8666404485702515,
0.8069009780883789,
-0.11542722582817078,
0.41395291686058044,
0.4359343349933624,
0.06196793541312218,
0.17182254791259766,
0.631528377532959,
1.014477252960205,
-0.2591964900493622,
0.38612887263298035,
-0.32317227125167847,
-0.05482987314462662,
-0.12165290862321854,
-0.8370039463043213,
-1.071552038192749,
-0.3257831633090973,
-0.23370927572250366,
-0.06427522748708725,
-0.3318304121494293,
0.6627552509307861,
0.45441222190856934,
-0.8389752507209778,
-0.12194092571735382,
0.14608262479305267,
0.232016459107399,
0.07708866149187088,
-0.1259387582540512,
0.2526718080043793,
-0.17100167274475098,
-0.40648162364959717,
0.6342330574989319,
-0.05544586479663849,
0.26466429233551025,
-0.2871010899543762,
0.18789042532444,
-0.42507922649383545,
0.36625760793685913,
0.29993557929992676,
0.274896502494812,
-0.24011415243148804,
-0.282905638217926,
0.09942392259836197,
0.18696656823158264,
-0.060815077275037766,
0.8719191551208496,
-0.8500429391860962,
0.14309631288051605,
0.45856478810310364,
0.9307452440261841,
0.6125576496124268,
-0.13249178230762482,
0.4835490882396698,
-1.08809232711792,
0.04921494796872139,
0.351567804813385,
0.32682177424430847,
0.37000471353530884,
-0.620214581489563,
0.03804685175418854,
0.3582930266857147,
-0.11965449154376984,
-0.8263195157051086,
0.4326696991920471,
-0.5776677131652832,
-0.2598917484283447,
1.3359042406082153,
-0.1829199194908142,
-0.3190270960330963,
-0.19977283477783203,
0.0505545549094677,
0.22575761377811432,
-0.2953092157840729,
0.5170526504516602,
0.5089583992958069,
-0.4258124530315399,
-0.26131120324134827,
-0.6955430507659912,
0.3235888183116913,
0.6320173740386963,
-0.5730612874031067,
-0.12018648535013199,
0.14409783482551575,
0.5657767653465271,
0.13004669547080994,
0.44853752851486206,
-0.010868843644857407,
-0.033917322754859924,
-0.0806182250380516,
-0.41507935523986816,
-0.16161611676216125,
-0.4532760977745056,
-0.12678033113479614,
0.4079294502735138,
0.19226643443107605,
-0.25754034519195557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05326v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05326v1
|
Advancing Semantic Textual Similarity Modeling: A Regression Framework with Translated ReLU and Smooth K2 Loss
| 2024-06-08T02:52:43 | 2024-06-08T02:52:43 |
Bowen Zhang, Chunping Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Since the introduction of BERT and RoBERTa, research on Semantic Textual
Similarity (STS) has made groundbreaking progress. Particularly, the adoption
of contrastive learning has substantially elevated state-of-the-art performance
across various STS benchmarks. However, contrastive learning categorizes text
pairs as either semantically similar or dissimilar, failing to leverage
fine-grained annotated information and necessitating large batch sizes to
prevent model collapse. These constraints pose challenges for researchers
engaged in STS tasks that require nuanced similarity levels or those with
limited computational resources, compelling them to explore alternatives like
Sentence-BERT. Nonetheless, Sentence-BERT tackles STS tasks from a
classification perspective, overlooking the progressive nature of semantic
relationships, which results in suboptimal performance. To bridge this gap,
this paper presents an innovative regression framework and proposes two simple
yet effective loss functions: Translated ReLU and Smooth K2 Loss. Experimental
analyses demonstrate that our method achieves convincing performance across
seven established STS benchmarks, especially when supplemented with
task-specific training data.
|
[
0.12926676869392395,
-0.74833083152771,
0.7578041553497314,
0.08541491627693176,
-0.4026595652103424,
-0.07668808102607727,
-0.28407296538352966,
-0.337643027305603,
-0.017830075696110725,
0.6422511339187622,
-0.8197751045227051,
-0.557120680809021,
-0.6680824756622314,
0.015515017323195934,
-0.6744290590286255,
1.1072402000427246,
-0.23305389285087585,
0.12804582715034485,
-0.53370201587677,
-0.24270763993263245,
-0.26809465885162354,
-0.28390562534332275,
-0.5478386878967285,
-0.567702054977417,
0.7671078443527222,
0.05476785823702812,
0.6850281953811646,
0.3024842441082001,
0.6069759130477905,
0.3020831346511841,
0.020536428317427635,
-0.06505495309829712,
-0.7935625314712524,
0.4219423830509186,
0.08036722987890244,
-0.6428030729293823,
0.008214554749429226,
-0.030046371743083,
0.6072839498519897,
0.8312561511993408,
0.1390991359949112,
0.03534727916121483,
0.5637288689613342,
0.8641253113746643,
-0.2344241440296173,
0.14924974739551544,
-0.7373352646827698,
0.0409492552280426,
0.10390304028987885,
0.033916719257831573,
-0.4315434992313385,
-0.4551132619380951,
0.5024113059043884,
-0.894817054271698,
0.5519012808799744,
-0.0848444476723671,
1.3208379745483398,
0.4417502284049988,
-0.33133968710899353,
-0.29376134276390076,
-0.2907853126525879,
0.9628884792327881,
-0.5395802855491638,
0.5821595788002014,
0.2787591516971588,
-0.04184325784444809,
-0.22085757553577423,
-0.733029305934906,
-0.3476303517818451,
-0.4491803050041199,
-0.2901264429092407,
0.14575143158435822,
-0.05562243610620499,
-0.32572153210639954,
-0.37903618812561035,
0.041881393641233444,
-0.6572667956352234,
0.12767581641674042,
-0.09075827151536942,
-0.09449675679206848,
0.26460719108581543,
0.26685401797294617,
-0.10972710698843002,
-0.10831478983163834,
-0.7404207587242126,
-0.26354411244392395,
-0.5342186093330383,
-0.20967911183834076,
0.43369150161743164,
0.6883512735366821,
-0.19056940078735352,
0.1206568107008934,
-0.06690783053636551,
0.2731229364871979,
-0.4439009130001068,
0.0006767778540961444,
0.4345116913318634,
-0.29453244805336,
-0.2959136664867401,
-0.3744503855705261,
0.4789816737174988,
0.631760835647583,
0.26075243949890137,
-0.3624608814716339,
-0.17301642894744873,
0.05679377540946007,
0.3429431617259979,
-0.6209338903427124,
-0.4232274889945984,
-0.26448625326156616,
-0.8572918176651001,
-0.33666571974754333,
-0.18330569565296173,
-0.5170807838439941,
-0.35761749744415283,
-0.5881447792053223,
0.7097617983818054,
-0.6558119654655457,
0.014166465029120445,
-0.04616514593362808,
-0.256737619638443,
0.2940842807292938,
0.47501814365386963,
-0.5204185843467712,
0.5897022485733032,
0.9836743474006653,
0.9748541116714478,
-0.11165862530469894,
-0.1411135494709015,
-0.2141062468290329,
-0.18832644820213318,
-0.20607328414916992,
0.6125893592834473,
-0.5195860266685486,
-0.4756011962890625,
0.16926456987857819,
-0.04559752345085144,
-0.07374075055122375,
-0.4347767233848572,
0.5474328994750977,
-0.38323503732681274,
0.3465035855770111,
-0.14487811923027039,
-0.6244393587112427,
-0.2545928657054901,
0.2654554843902588,
-0.5190580487251282,
1.273581862449646,
0.20109763741493225,
-0.8084472417831421,
0.4919274151325226,
-0.0002352769224671647,
-0.4507593512535095,
-0.11004281789064407,
0.014472486451268196,
-0.8051043152809143,
0.19333183765411377,
-0.3694036304950714,
0.5985549688339233,
-0.4620088040828705,
0.03253033757209778,
-0.43851524591445923,
-0.456537663936615,
-0.008657816797494888,
-0.14190421998500824,
0.4844258427619934,
0.21851612627506256,
0.042605429887771606,
0.2120361626148224,
-0.8122751116752625,
0.040961362421512604,
0.03733517602086067,
-0.2657683789730072,
-1.094751000404358,
0.0021953852847218513,
0.7461853623390198,
-0.023192601278424263,
0.19029413163661957,
-0.5072736740112305,
-0.06662099063396454,
-0.39366793632507324,
0.38302093744277954,
0.6125954389572144,
-0.5283883810043335,
0.40868356823921204,
-0.37171000242233276,
0.12647384405136108,
-0.19619931280612946,
-0.12099606543779373,
0.0010855157161131501,
-0.3422277867794037,
-0.6521543860435486,
-0.26926568150520325,
0.6703026294708252,
0.2829864025115967,
-0.666594386100769,
0.24454545974731445,
-0.47409456968307495,
-0.6595450639724731,
-0.850837767124176,
0.08122211694717407,
0.6171066164970398,
0.7938525676727295,
0.4194079339504242,
-0.21395538747310638,
-0.42035147547721863,
-1.203026294708252,
-0.44968393445014954,
-0.1927674263715744,
-0.3399447202682495,
0.17822076380252838,
0.4035831093788147,
-0.08496662974357605,
0.5516733527183533,
-0.538244903087616,
-0.7168799042701721,
-0.10125354677438736,
0.424868643283844,
-0.06351231783628464,
0.5758626461029053,
0.4922509491443634,
-1.0122359991073608,
-0.5260511636734009,
0.05701448395848274,
-0.6422673463821411,
-0.004239656962454319,
-0.19568869471549988,
0.018245968967676163,
0.3603702485561371,
0.56733238697052,
-0.17530594766139984,
0.388314425945282,
0.3010367155075073,
-0.35219407081604004,
0.27250510454177856,
-0.35689643025398254,
0.22234149277210236,
-1.1241679191589355,
0.06805189698934555,
0.08260080218315125,
-0.2369617372751236,
-0.5732036232948303,
0.004461211152374744,
0.048032552003860474,
0.21847033500671387,
-0.2633041441440582,
0.4594563841819763,
0.03861924260854721,
-0.09526233375072479,
-0.29241201281547546,
0.342928946018219,
0.035565558820962906,
0.31657153367996216,
0.03471887856721878,
0.502390444278717,
0.2440856248140335,
-0.45592716336250305,
-0.08153070509433746,
0.4587784707546234,
-0.25279855728149414,
0.49531129002571106,
-0.6597139835357666,
-0.23284702003002167,
-0.19516603648662567,
0.41539129614830017,
-1.067307710647583,
0.08734820038080215,
0.02388104796409607,
-0.5519959330558777,
0.17401853203773499,
0.04439534991979599,
-0.4423532485961914,
0.027620811015367508,
-0.732765793800354,
0.29109644889831543,
0.8261405229568481,
-0.2575737535953522,
0.5834863781929016,
-0.18844395875930786,
-0.3898680806159973,
-0.5620455145835876,
-0.9814912676811218,
0.014520127326250076,
-0.35017964243888855,
-0.642448365688324,
0.7057416439056396,
0.38589438796043396,
-0.1337256133556366,
0.40029439330101013,
-0.12264758348464966,
-0.21682079136371613,
0.20989780128002167,
0.17562292516231537,
0.32994672656059265,
-0.2886539399623871,
0.6282927989959717,
-0.010301738977432251,
-0.18228894472122192,
-0.012906069867312908,
-0.25252410769462585,
0.3885638117790222,
0.07714221626520157,
0.17878185212612152,
-0.4206269681453705,
0.4991406798362732,
0.0679839700460434,
0.22321449220180511,
0.7992454171180725,
0.9126755595207214,
-0.27107828855514526,
-0.052698634564876556,
-0.4767276644706726,
-0.09399425238370895,
-0.3690965473651886,
0.6214364767074585,
-0.6077371835708618,
-1.0286202430725098,
0.4665403366088867,
-0.12270773202180862,
0.005836437921971083,
0.5537146329879761,
0.4145062267780304,
-0.28196731209754944,
0.3752055764198303,
0.9930559396743774,
0.25559213757514954,
0.46386685967445374,
-0.033871229737997055,
-0.0265479926019907,
-0.5972919464111328,
-0.5451521277427673,
-0.8595457077026367,
-0.2974337041378021,
-0.9031046032905579,
-0.3792341947555542,
0.011392991989850998,
-0.05039410665631294,
-0.41428354382514954,
0.4939930737018585,
-0.2837623357772827,
0.1293269842863083,
0.7400896549224854,
0.20210617780685425,
0.1282341033220291,
-0.0696517825126648,
-0.07380454987287521,
-0.3481605350971222,
-0.5170056223869324,
-0.6520894169807434,
1.016701340675354,
0.29066765308380127,
0.9532304406166077,
-0.08619280904531479,
0.9227375388145447,
0.4693257808685303,
0.2198380082845688,
-0.6613060832023621,
0.4811859130859375,
-0.6165833473205566,
-0.06195755675435066,
-0.20772741734981537,
-0.3819476068019867,
-1.0254665613174438,
0.28223055601119995,
-0.43158218264579773,
-0.5134838223457336,
-0.04577208682894707,
0.1202026754617691,
0.1309644877910614,
0.134928360581398,
-0.7753468155860901,
0.7457480430603027,
0.24403564631938934,
-0.41602644324302673,
-0.3168792128562927,
-1.240227460861206,
-0.07182101160287857,
-0.25836220383644104,
-0.024766936898231506,
-0.20932617783546448,
-0.4721287786960602,
0.8444811105728149,
-0.317609578371048,
0.7193066477775574,
-0.07344658672809601,
-0.004835329484194517,
-0.060122761875391006,
0.11139946430921555,
0.2725594937801361,
-0.2759661078453064,
-0.12806078791618347,
0.03824606165289879,
-0.02046508528292179,
-0.635536789894104,
-0.5540969371795654,
1.111238956451416,
-0.6170514225959778,
-0.23153212666511536,
-0.21936868131160736,
-0.4603293836116791,
-0.1246052011847496,
0.11709154397249222,
-0.03157317638397217,
0.28588300943374634,
-0.3312941789627075,
0.19797556102275848,
0.49464985728263855,
-0.20652009546756744,
0.3565857410430908,
0.3961925208568573,
0.19889163970947266,
-0.29061681032180786,
0.8765259385108948,
-0.18709611892700195,
0.21314136683940887,
0.6979053616523743,
0.09710969030857086,
-0.6333053708076477,
-0.33075037598609924,
-0.03322185203433037,
0.17228925228118896,
-0.656628429889679,
-0.29033440351486206,
-0.6204400658607483,
0.0977814570069313,
-0.42736196517944336,
-0.5221506953239441,
-0.17296534776687622,
-0.4883703887462616,
-0.2354860156774521,
0.07475603371858597,
0.4048766493797302,
0.8865569829940796,
0.18625105917453766,
0.14462949335575104,
-0.6196789145469666,
0.11888791620731354,
-0.05776723846793175,
0.45807260274887085,
0.06303723901510239,
-0.4816090762615204,
-0.17482560873031616,
-0.33614760637283325,
-0.21033576130867004,
-0.45237234234809875,
0.3663610816001892,
0.33765414357185364,
0.2615984380245209,
-0.04137570038437843,
0.2775750160217285,
0.6579370498657227,
-0.7190088629722595,
0.7163346409797668,
0.29057222604751587,
-0.8891310691833496,
0.3844570815563202,
-0.23926517367362976,
0.0737701803445816,
0.834612250328064,
0.5268030762672424,
-0.3805694282054901,
-0.420497864484787,
-0.5750303864479065,
-0.9855015277862549,
0.5812867283821106,
0.5702148675918579,
0.3363519012928009,
0.14429394900798798,
0.2720988094806671,
0.5730628371238708,
0.10199899971485138,
-0.6768479943275452,
-0.27196651697158813,
-0.21511344611644745,
-0.6238652467727661,
-0.10670557618141174,
-0.0965607613325119,
0.19543401896953583,
0.145863875746727,
0.8253573179244995,
-0.0010355260455980897,
0.2763862907886505,
0.406668096780777,
-0.10850226134061813,
0.24485377967357635,
0.37543773651123047,
0.3553518056869507,
0.06359091401100159,
-0.20459741353988647,
0.15808327496051788,
0.2576264441013336,
-0.4123421013355255,
0.07642684876918793,
0.3486473560333252,
-0.19562208652496338,
0.08730632066726685,
0.5905489325523376,
0.29110440611839294,
0.6518387198448181,
-0.710811972618103,
0.37123703956604004,
0.003057566937059164,
-0.46541622281074524,
-0.06681042164564133,
-0.3326343894004822,
0.22020840644836426,
0.24146857857704163,
0.23741529881954193,
0.03755848854780197,
0.29483163356781006,
-0.36442479491233826,
0.3750891089439392,
0.27574265003204346,
-0.820906400680542,
0.008999720215797424,
0.7712342143058777,
0.3827270269393921,
-0.3476259410381317,
0.6202707290649414,
0.043619297444820404,
-0.46790820360183716,
0.5545102953910828,
0.44894036650657654,
0.822172224521637,
0.142915740609169,
0.14779534935951233,
0.24339580535888672,
0.014334565959870815,
-0.07466455549001694,
0.05916215479373932,
-0.01227000541985035,
-0.3263500928878784,
-0.12685559689998627,
-0.6219112873077393,
-0.1257408857345581,
0.021073177456855774,
-0.9061861038208008,
0.324330598115921,
-0.07385381311178207,
0.054517827928066254,
0.10221980512142181,
0.08414077013731003,
-0.6536223292350769,
0.32272666692733765,
0.09594892710447311,
0.7846208214759827,
-0.9222847819328308,
0.7776477336883545,
0.7091584205627441,
-0.4023866355419159,
-0.32445213198661804,
0.08717765659093857,
-0.009019333869218826,
-0.6926917433738708,
0.8136329650878906,
0.3091735541820526,
-0.1747312694787979,
-0.23896640539169312,
-0.12935945391654968,
-0.3965841233730316,
1.154923915863037,
0.18957160413265228,
-0.5306039452552795,
-0.09884721785783768,
0.06418561190366745,
0.812389075756073,
-0.5367004871368408,
-0.00014904537238180637,
0.44472599029541016,
0.2120971530675888,
-0.0162340234965086,
-0.7298569679260254,
0.1157941073179245,
-0.06531690806150436,
0.33779069781303406,
0.5097274780273438,
-0.690706193447113,
0.6913191676139832,
-0.10024631023406982,
-0.037432488054037094,
0.7102139592170715,
0.6756373047828674,
-0.16573920845985413,
0.645182192325592,
0.4456501007080078,
0.5978043675422668,
0.45497384667396545,
-0.2740356922149658,
0.8642162680625916,
0.008825177326798439,
0.6102456450462341,
1.2607868909835815,
-0.4186646044254303,
1.0867727994918823,
0.39216235280036926,
-0.22244712710380554,
0.5944644808769226,
0.5660232901573181,
-0.16625583171844482,
0.6811969876289368,
0.3734826445579529,
-0.1472279578447342,
-0.37761130928993225,
-0.2659550905227661,
-0.29823994636535645,
0.2519568204879761,
0.2062026858329773,
-0.6459429264068604,
-0.4106934368610382,
0.03197713941335678,
0.152107834815979,
0.8251999020576477,
-0.09526576101779938,
0.8395028114318848,
0.06821754574775696,
-0.3258618712425232,
0.343912273645401,
-0.12569233775138855,
0.8027675151824951,
-0.717721700668335,
-0.14888301491737366,
-0.08054608851671219,
0.2444165050983429,
0.08512801676988602,
-0.6379715800285339,
0.4671279788017273,
-0.13720394670963287,
-0.24802839756011963,
-0.2599455416202545,
0.7368122339248657,
-0.622331976890564,
-0.47433650493621826,
0.597471296787262,
0.41541990637779236,
0.1008702889084816,
0.30682137608528137,
-0.8800905346870422,
0.058234803378582,
-0.02625727280974388,
0.03258057311177254,
0.4498803913593292,
0.3474951684474945,
0.030364319682121277,
0.8594093918800354,
0.2055588960647583,
-0.32877224683761597,
-0.24377891421318054,
0.26788708567619324,
0.9034852981567383,
-0.7369860410690308,
-0.43360835313796997,
-0.5987306237220764,
0.1977822482585907,
-0.1443168967962265,
-0.43438321352005005,
0.6889423727989197,
0.6930707693099976,
0.9212954044342041,
-0.22269658744335175,
0.6119562983512878,
0.0009549150126986206,
0.7523943185806274,
-0.5037625432014465,
0.7205314636230469,
-0.842100977897644,
0.14207248389720917,
-0.40090951323509216,
-0.8435918688774109,
-0.49388501048088074,
0.4070405960083008,
-0.02174840122461319,
-0.04531925916671753,
0.8197919130325317,
0.7679327726364136,
0.1095946729183197,
-0.0923960953950882,
0.44222867488861084,
0.19635844230651855,
0.11325757950544357,
0.5766324996948242,
0.6087201833724976,
-0.7708662748336792,
0.7487310767173767,
0.10247630625963211,
-0.0014566198224201798,
-0.20353765785694122,
-0.7461019158363342,
-0.9109587669372559,
-0.9949910044670105,
-0.44244009256362915,
-0.35432547330856323,
0.5854395627975464,
0.9224098324775696,
0.4918159544467926,
-0.5377878546714783,
0.17567172646522522,
-0.19218525290489197,
0.037259291857481,
-0.12495245784521103,
-0.2173164337873459,
0.6898026466369629,
-0.5887088775634766,
-0.7410191297531128,
-0.15152718126773834,
0.0725216269493103,
0.11981592327356339,
0.044454216957092285,
-0.16749684512615204,
-0.28487372398376465,
0.03518429026007652,
0.6043373942375183,
-0.1359640657901764,
-1.2180110216140747,
-0.4539373219013214,
-0.2726864218711853,
-0.16795532405376434,
-0.2925441265106201,
0.8138020038604736,
-1.2396169900894165,
0.2781791388988495,
0.5602769255638123,
0.903101921081543,
0.3310733437538147,
-0.00134921760763973,
0.4389515221118927,
-0.7463703751564026,
-0.008444533683359623,
0.2257412075996399,
0.17655101418495178,
0.4903212785720825,
-0.09914585947990417,
0.7345866560935974,
0.15471898019313812,
-0.48487910628318787,
-0.7502639293670654,
0.22244544327259064,
-1.2480313777923584,
-0.3516239523887634,
0.9604805111885071,
-0.5622420907020569,
-0.032430972903966904,
-0.26372072100639343,
-0.13948707282543182,
0.1506040096282959,
-0.423129141330719,
0.8136365413665771,
0.6437312364578247,
0.020782137289643288,
0.21413034200668335,
-0.12332893162965775,
0.4910767376422882,
0.7114087343215942,
-0.43457475304603577,
0.1603342443704605,
0.26064956188201904,
0.37711644172668457,
-0.014425186440348625,
0.21235793828964233,
-0.036404263228178024,
0.1454983651638031,
0.32670289278030396,
-0.11527051031589508,
0.13921889662742615,
-0.08555719256401062,
-0.3061603307723999,
0.18861991167068481,
-0.14474715292453766,
-0.13960695266723633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05322v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05322v1
|
Teaching-Assistant-in-the-Loop: Improving Knowledge Distillation from Imperfect Teacher Models in Low-Budget Scenarios
| 2024-06-08T02:17:43 | 2024-06-08T02:17:43 |
Yuhang Zhou, Wei Ai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
There is increasing interest in distilling task-specific knowledge from large
language models (LLM) to smaller student models. Nonetheless, LLM distillation
presents a dual challenge: 1) there is a high cost associated with querying the
teacher LLM, such as GPT-4, for gathering an ample number of demonstrations; 2)
the teacher LLM might provide imperfect outputs with a negative impact on the
student's learning process. To enhance sample efficiency within
resource-constrained, imperfect teacher scenarios, we propose a three-component
framework leveraging three signal types. The first signal is the student's
self-consistency (consistency of student multiple outputs), which is a proxy of
the student's confidence. Specifically, we introduce a ``teaching assistant''
(TA) model to assess the uncertainty of both the student's and the teacher's
outputs via confidence scoring, which serves as another two signals for student
training. Furthermore, we propose a two-stage training schema to first warm up
the student with a small proportion of data to better utilize student's signal.
Experiments have shown the superiority of our proposed framework for four
complex reasoning tasks. On average, our proposed two-stage framework brings a
relative improvement of up to 20.79% compared to fine-tuning without any
signals across datasets.
|
[
-0.3179200291633606,
-0.774258017539978,
0.8383057117462158,
0.01669454760849476,
-0.3162766098976135,
0.23074844479560852,
-0.16069084405899048,
-0.04600754752755165,
-0.12208160012960434,
0.19006496667861938,
-0.29468563199043274,
-0.16647852957248688,
-0.7710874080657959,
0.18011367321014404,
-0.6047301888465881,
0.751339316368103,
-0.23156529664993286,
0.3913591802120209,
-0.3372613787651062,
0.11725635826587677,
-0.7101405262947083,
-0.1738576591014862,
-0.7065297365188599,
-0.6934338808059692,
0.23693729937076569,
1.0696656703948975,
0.35236063599586487,
0.5994645953178406,
0.31069818139076233,
0.218629851937294,
0.22419022023677826,
0.3077020049095154,
-0.23534277081489563,
0.24156738817691803,
-0.19237272441387177,
-0.6378379464149475,
-0.5345933437347412,
0.17816534638404846,
0.4098935127258301,
0.8338160514831543,
-0.2854103147983551,
0.008011110126972198,
0.5004191398620605,
0.5654460787773132,
-0.6367864012718201,
0.18906302750110626,
-0.6474356651306152,
-0.24188119173049927,
0.08153592050075531,
-0.057839684188365936,
-0.23342980444431305,
-0.28914517164230347,
0.24401968717575073,
-0.6950717568397522,
0.3181491196155548,
-0.3654746115207672,
0.7476421594619751,
0.5698215365409851,
-0.3585919439792633,
-0.4139653146266937,
-0.8007927536964417,
0.5930498838424683,
-0.5606914758682251,
0.1973755657672882,
0.6895590424537659,
0.5081434845924377,
-0.0806116908788681,
-0.7045304775238037,
-0.8017253279685974,
0.052390944212675095,
0.28897517919540405,
0.2229151874780655,
0.06704007834196091,
0.20035581290721893,
0.13617543876171112,
0.48020240664482117,
-0.05815941467881203,
-0.09492787718772888,
-0.5068966150283813,
0.12472708523273468,
0.32976487278938293,
0.007841958664357662,
-0.07378127425909042,
0.027902690693736076,
-0.17050482332706451,
-0.22099299728870392,
-0.46576908230781555,
-0.30642324686050415,
0.5769044160842896,
0.3955934941768646,
-0.11066296696662903,
0.5224581360816956,
-0.09534087777137756,
0.7208829522132874,
0.30920225381851196,
-0.5683490037918091,
-0.13012070953845978,
-0.229094460606575,
-0.11923643201589584,
-0.02006717398762703,
0.3058614730834961,
-0.05249103158712387,
0.20022769272327423,
-0.0231475867331028,
-0.3054535388946533,
0.31768250465393066,
0.26008132100105286,
-0.551399827003479,
-0.6404317021369934,
0.18642453849315643,
0.18797479569911957,
-0.2547135651111603,
-0.059796176850795746,
-0.706338107585907,
-0.2870998680591583,
-0.6882614493370056,
0.8112496137619019,
-0.48365768790245056,
-0.34009167551994324,
-0.026783159002661705,
-0.03591189906001091,
-0.23539488017559052,
0.48235735297203064,
-0.6743195652961731,
0.48437342047691345,
0.4774215519428253,
0.9061893820762634,
-0.16889317333698273,
-0.5124449729919434,
-0.512697160243988,
0.01992158405482769,
-0.22483541071414948,
0.5966348648071289,
-0.40687358379364014,
-0.4726211130619049,
-0.18943071365356445,
-0.1421174556016922,
-0.012790828943252563,
-0.4251455068588257,
0.34222179651260376,
-0.23681598901748657,
0.17638038098812103,
-0.37320756912231445,
-0.5824819207191467,
0.1140579804778099,
0.24207596480846405,
-0.5649368166923523,
1.1631745100021362,
0.34414204955101013,
-0.373652845621109,
0.39661356806755066,
-0.6236169934272766,
-0.37157514691352844,
-0.4219583570957184,
-0.13913847506046295,
-0.4010021984577179,
-0.19082842767238617,
0.29492419958114624,
0.42650333046913147,
-0.3690428137779236,
0.24395787715911865,
-0.25595149397850037,
-0.6851763725280762,
0.002757434966042638,
-0.6510832905769348,
0.40303322672843933,
0.28768596053123474,
-0.42603540420532227,
-0.281321257352829,
-0.9161484837532043,
-0.2989141643047333,
-0.13515369594097137,
-0.3847515881061554,
-0.39485418796539307,
-0.33152028918266296,
-0.2517615854740143,
0.05651182308793068,
-0.03826804831624031,
-0.30724436044692993,
0.4481936991214752,
-0.25746268033981323,
0.282443642616272,
0.8690198063850403,
0.055495548993349075,
0.6589407920837402,
-0.230437770485878,
0.7366313934326172,
0.3161379098892212,
0.013072732836008072,
-0.24533340334892273,
-0.3306947946548462,
-1.0081514120101929,
-0.3533255457878113,
0.2885754406452179,
0.17075102031230927,
-1.2286546230316162,
-0.09838444739580154,
-0.03589193522930145,
-0.4374047517776489,
-0.8103728294372559,
0.3723432421684265,
0.45033690333366394,
0.8124479651451111,
0.4615267217159271,
0.0651579424738884,
-0.44268572330474854,
-0.2972561717033386,
-0.12393663823604584,
-0.07975822687149048,
-0.020574670284986496,
-0.11415517330169678,
0.46640220284461975,
0.115955650806427,
0.973848819732666,
-0.5934085249900818,
-0.37225741147994995,
-0.16092394292354584,
0.12592078745365143,
0.29555755853652954,
0.6414650678634644,
0.38605034351348877,
-0.5500631332397461,
-0.5618941783905029,
-0.2145105004310608,
-0.4899093806743622,
-0.07738076895475388,
0.0025320968125015497,
-0.20604276657104492,
0.19407324492931366,
0.19913816452026367,
-0.42040660977363586,
0.382673978805542,
0.35587888956069946,
-0.16331201791763306,
0.3614182770252228,
-0.3534974157810211,
0.17542031407356262,
-1.111285924911499,
-0.23173579573631287,
-0.06965340673923492,
-0.1329772174358368,
-0.42898058891296387,
-0.340610146522522,
-0.023220570757985115,
-0.2369319200515747,
-0.10450496524572372,
0.4156681299209595,
-0.6134234070777893,
-0.06511721014976501,
-0.6556029915809631,
0.2891349792480469,
0.3283053934574127,
0.5804662704467773,
-0.09214804321527481,
0.8670786023139954,
0.5587405562400818,
-0.5926160216331482,
0.35404306650161743,
-0.09755700081586838,
-0.12896081805229187,
0.9564095735549927,
-0.6002178192138672,
0.3436976373195648,
0.11173801869153976,
0.25259929895401,
-0.9285109043121338,
-0.48260697722435,
0.2335229218006134,
-0.1788458526134491,
0.5107434988021851,
-0.28877919912338257,
-0.3343149423599243,
-0.4410359263420105,
-0.0423218198120594,
0.31515952944755554,
0.4952487051486969,
-0.6958554983139038,
0.7163024544715881,
0.1016760766506195,
0.12978266179561615,
-0.7195937037467957,
-0.6399635672569275,
-0.24927952885627747,
-0.1720804125070572,
-0.1331985890865326,
0.09483397006988525,
0.22548791766166687,
-0.11054174602031708,
0.12120327353477478,
-0.542249858379364,
-0.2775081396102905,
0.19446814060211182,
0.309030681848526,
0.24883607029914856,
0.13545897603034973,
0.12512987852096558,
0.30913200974464417,
-0.14831256866455078,
-0.062257058918476105,
-0.6564579606056213,
0.3014165759086609,
-0.02082832343876362,
-0.8652101159095764,
-0.5829141139984131,
0.024329986423254013,
0.6045677065849304,
0.2803499698638916,
0.44808802008628845,
0.37486183643341064,
-0.4465230405330658,
-0.44173356890678406,
-0.5659791231155396,
-0.48876953125,
-0.4598970115184784,
0.2124088704586029,
-0.5122483372688293,
-0.269654244184494,
0.31889599561691284,
-0.08677631616592407,
0.012709198519587517,
0.015351517125964165,
0.41239893436431885,
-0.15276889503002167,
0.6757115721702576,
0.5416130423545837,
0.06514982879161835,
0.41670042276382446,
-0.49766141176223755,
0.2901994585990906,
-0.544431209564209,
-0.23560012876987457,
-0.44225776195526123,
-0.11074153333902359,
0.021315179765224457,
-0.5248192548751831,
0.6192688941955566,
0.23877805471420288,
-0.310901403427124,
0.17702211439609528,
-0.5930651426315308,
0.492325097322464,
0.8777192234992981,
0.31314873695373535,
0.3611886203289032,
-0.0920841246843338,
0.01676005683839321,
0.30334845185279846,
-0.9531664848327637,
-0.676786482334137,
1.4261451959609985,
0.34563955664634705,
0.8162944316864014,
-0.029641013592481613,
0.8432771563529968,
0.05743074417114258,
0.18455518782138824,
-0.569502592086792,
0.34552761912345886,
0.09250757843255997,
-0.49816030263900757,
-0.4169364869594574,
-0.1931302696466446,
-0.5550864934921265,
0.2907927930355072,
-0.05513230338692665,
-0.38087230920791626,
0.18410570919513702,
0.6382843852043152,
-0.35017210245132446,
0.3246060907840729,
-1.0850740671157837,
0.6729656457901001,
0.013302348554134369,
-0.5198771357536316,
-0.025381851941347122,
-0.3937962055206299,
0.40070533752441406,
-0.2939465045928955,
0.198294535279274,
-0.18307675421237946,
0.2496795952320099,
0.4134359359741211,
-0.7725821733474731,
0.8844124674797058,
-0.5837071537971497,
-0.0850222036242485,
0.6957194805145264,
0.06775584816932678,
0.6176305413246155,
0.13092119991779327,
-0.2561979293823242,
-0.13151861727237701,
0.22014224529266357,
-0.6695947051048279,
-0.7396989464759827,
0.5642200112342834,
-0.8815309405326843,
-0.6431421041488647,
-0.43381863832473755,
-0.6211340427398682,
-0.45147955417633057,
-0.17505958676338196,
0.3142458498477936,
0.3283632695674896,
0.3218282163143158,
-0.17633619904518127,
0.41352036595344543,
0.3842783272266388,
0.2872108817100525,
0.35017338395118713,
0.16985668241977692,
-0.16553476452827454,
1.0177702903747559,
0.2846086919307709,
0.6594289541244507,
-0.18244695663452148,
0.06806031614542007,
-0.330283522605896,
-0.3703630268573761,
-0.3715897798538208,
-0.11677730083465576,
-0.8823348879814148,
-0.44151872396469116,
-0.3762121796607971,
0.18605302274227142,
-0.4869869649410248,
-0.2611996829509735,
-0.5347294807434082,
-0.39034372568130493,
-0.7873991131782532,
-0.18543127179145813,
0.40447133779525757,
0.6842410564422607,
-0.25995180010795593,
0.6419661045074463,
-0.23897184431552887,
0.29077836871147156,
0.5901181101799011,
0.2976199686527252,
0.15678170323371887,
-0.7184850573539734,
-0.3134177029132843,
0.30074864625930786,
-0.559792697429657,
-0.8868825435638428,
0.17615561187267303,
0.40527576208114624,
0.3166821300983429,
0.5031676888465881,
0.3195995092391968,
0.9294039011001587,
-0.21093939244747162,
0.7686448097229004,
0.24090366065502167,
-1.1706823110580444,
0.7059952616691589,
-0.1172192394733429,
0.14937502145767212,
0.5989355444908142,
0.1770336627960205,
-0.09040980786085129,
-0.7648206353187561,
-0.5697721242904663,
-0.7906716465950012,
1.0165797472000122,
0.09973970055580139,
0.025411779060959816,
0.1639370620250702,
0.5511787533760071,
0.2975950837135315,
0.1171453446149826,
-0.5924252867698669,
-0.21119295060634613,
-0.5771312713623047,
-0.45550501346588135,
0.08900608122348785,
-0.15577636659145355,
-0.3103387653827667,
-0.27402031421661377,
0.8868670463562012,
-0.39846572279930115,
-0.06009898707270622,
0.22263289988040924,
0.03478413075208664,
0.035157423466444016,
0.22915492951869965,
0.17833946645259857,
0.7539763450622559,
-0.0373711958527565,
0.5064688324928284,
0.5524827241897583,
-0.7099673748016357,
0.5780637860298157,
-0.06053812801837921,
0.1203344464302063,
-0.06742265075445175,
0.4390672445297241,
0.6064453721046448,
0.3416263163089752,
-0.4057999849319458,
0.48213693499565125,
0.09145297110080719,
-0.17929041385650635,
-0.3445604741573334,
0.4315822124481201,
-0.09855835884809494,
0.3456633985042572,
0.4851152300834656,
0.016178611665964127,
0.04749797657132149,
-0.45328643918037415,
0.12419818341732025,
-0.01431498397141695,
-0.11559801548719406,
-0.35580676794052124,
0.6267474293708801,
0.21907708048820496,
-0.02845858596265316,
0.5612765550613403,
-0.1896039992570877,
-0.21564172208309174,
0.7090922594070435,
0.6390427350997925,
0.5864813923835754,
-0.33229050040245056,
0.16454654932022095,
0.22367404401302338,
-0.014745686203241348,
-0.47676050662994385,
0.4091966450214386,
-0.26724180579185486,
-0.5753916501998901,
-0.13532178103923798,
-0.5497520565986633,
-0.646771252155304,
-0.14482904970645905,
-0.9377301931381226,
0.5211939215660095,
-0.264361709356308,
-0.07166189700365067,
-0.0742562934756279,
0.11576878279447556,
-0.7579297423362732,
0.23728640377521515,
-0.1931239515542984,
0.6178328394889832,
-1.0028204917907715,
1.32848060131073,
0.7701628804206848,
-0.42059391736984253,
-1.3911418914794922,
-0.03220200538635254,
-0.021227441728115082,
-0.6582591533660889,
0.3538030683994293,
-0.23229831457138062,
-0.12087409198284149,
0.006693716626614332,
-0.2442864030599594,
-0.6926490068435669,
1.4027303457260132,
0.7074079513549805,
-0.8473756313323975,
-0.15168088674545288,
0.05508311092853546,
0.3940078020095825,
-0.3831053078174591,
0.21606580913066864,
0.998818576335907,
0.2607384920120239,
0.5150522589683533,
-0.9390408992767334,
-0.1749000996351242,
0.09570585191249847,
-0.127141073346138,
-0.15164607763290405,
-0.360054612159729,
1.0152177810668945,
-0.3664174973964691,
-0.08278993517160416,
-0.20231793820858002,
0.5908716917037964,
0.35829928517341614,
0.7575726509094238,
0.5123013854026794,
0.48465561866760254,
1.025427222251892,
-0.31030088663101196,
0.7656027674674988,
-0.43907272815704346,
0.43246275186538696,
1.4045708179473877,
-0.17662034928798676,
0.48765143752098083,
0.7908177375793457,
-0.39360177516937256,
0.23348107933998108,
0.5786478519439697,
0.148549422621727,
0.4525624215602875,
-0.02106497995555401,
-0.38232699036598206,
-0.25884681940078735,
0.17438705265522003,
-0.32043948769569397,
0.4588819444179535,
0.23189963400363922,
0.099031001329422,
-0.14804241061210632,
0.5494484901428223,
0.018066762015223503,
0.24261212348937988,
-0.3839728534221649,
0.6086985468864441,
0.22300314903259277,
-0.8379016518592834,
0.5366852283477783,
-0.2875831127166748,
0.3954816162586212,
-0.3188081979751587,
-0.20274367928504944,
-0.39430683851242065,
0.3081066310405731,
-0.23668359220027924,
-0.618926465511322,
0.24066829681396484,
0.12056338787078857,
-0.07450788468122482,
-0.0997265875339508,
0.5149593949317932,
-0.7086256742477417,
-0.403840571641922,
0.02346966043114662,
0.5004260540008545,
0.23324467241764069,
0.09005622565746307,
-0.29174283146858215,
0.12915144860744476,
-0.2403692901134491,
-0.07711150497198105,
0.08306680619716644,
0.6959235668182373,
0.34010860323905945,
0.5504648089408875,
0.3983435332775116,
0.18799938261508942,
-0.03946966305375099,
0.1427842527627945,
1.006530523300171,
-0.1166408583521843,
-0.3439503610134125,
-0.715131938457489,
0.3671512305736542,
0.08828520774841309,
-0.3789826035499573,
0.6322810053825378,
0.25192946195602417,
0.8254567384719849,
0.04433749243617058,
0.7862663269042969,
0.14226947724819183,
0.5005689263343811,
-0.4728504419326782,
0.3732278048992157,
-0.6209350228309631,
0.7177032828330994,
-0.5110323429107666,
-0.8145326972007751,
0.18142040073871613,
0.5594785213470459,
-0.30342647433280945,
0.0373188816010952,
0.5677690505981445,
0.524778425693512,
-0.19120390713214874,
0.191641166806221,
0.28268226981163025,
-0.029080860316753387,
0.34357109665870667,
0.5336423516273499,
0.7748613357543945,
-0.5401124358177185,
0.4736117422580719,
-0.5564985275268555,
-0.17526167631149292,
-0.07124199718236923,
-0.560376763343811,
-0.8564910292625427,
-0.7924304008483887,
-0.4237931966781616,
-0.48392021656036377,
0.2558785676956177,
1.008465051651001,
0.8597951531410217,
-0.6266770362854004,
-0.11714784801006317,
-0.36787739396095276,
0.3001697063446045,
-0.2552478015422821,
-0.18248596787452698,
0.4944145083427429,
-0.6032616496086121,
-1.0727455615997314,
0.2521994113922119,
-0.12237754464149475,
0.29490867257118225,
-0.3359631299972534,
-0.1023230329155922,
0.016558915376663208,
0.05456450954079628,
0.34638354182243347,
0.09770383685827255,
-0.7140001654624939,
-0.41312968730926514,
-0.20456542074680328,
-0.02269989624619484,
-0.20537610352039337,
0.6233168244361877,
-0.8220785856246948,
0.6322618722915649,
-0.09215490520000458,
0.5109195709228516,
0.6156142354011536,
-0.050100523978471756,
0.6259656548500061,
-0.9427134990692139,
0.38457635045051575,
0.3153630793094635,
0.2662435472011566,
0.21645064651966095,
-0.46234095096588135,
0.628608763217926,
0.3580944538116455,
-0.49213477969169617,
-1.1155439615249634,
-0.06483793258666992,
-0.8523738384246826,
-0.3142281472682953,
1.0722553730010986,
-0.4993348717689514,
-0.00456038536503911,
-0.27477729320526123,
-0.13255470991134644,
0.547119140625,
-0.3783743977546692,
0.9780129790306091,
0.7444630265235901,
-0.2056204229593277,
0.061305318027734756,
-0.4710116386413574,
0.5330991148948669,
0.27317219972610474,
-0.7581052184104919,
-0.20349813997745514,
0.4639151692390442,
0.4898418188095093,
0.007886772975325584,
0.7118863463401794,
0.14443339407444,
0.38709568977355957,
0.33169567584991455,
0.045698393136262894,
-0.40460270643234253,
-0.7008736729621887,
-0.3034215569496155,
0.4000294804573059,
0.18826830387115479,
-0.6086288690567017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05317v1
|
LoCoCo: Dropping In Convolutions for Long Context Compression
| 2024-06-08T01:35:11 | 2024-06-08T01:35:11 |
Ruisi Cai, Yuandong Tian, Zhangyang Wang, Beidi Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
This paper tackles the memory hurdle of processing long context sequences in
Large Language Models (LLMs), by presenting a novel approach, Dropping In
Convolutions for Long Context Compression (LoCoCo). LoCoCo employs only a
fixed-size Key-Value (KV) cache, and can enhance efficiency in both inference
and fine-tuning stages. Diverging from prior methods that selectively drop KV
pairs based on heuristics, LoCoCo leverages a data-driven adaptive fusion
technique, blending previous KV pairs with incoming tokens to minimize the loss
of contextual information and ensure accurate attention modeling. This token
integration is achieved through injecting one-dimensional convolutional kernels
that dynamically calculate mixing weights for each KV cache slot. Designed for
broad compatibility with existing LLM frameworks, LoCoCo allows for
straightforward "drop-in" integration without needing architectural
modifications, while incurring minimal tuning overhead. Experiments demonstrate
that LoCoCo maintains consistently outstanding performance across various
context lengths and can achieve a high context compression rate during both
inference and fine-tuning phases. During inference, we successfully compressed
up to 3482 tokens into a 128-size KV cache, while retaining comparable
performance to the full sequence - an accuracy improvement of up to 0.2791
compared to baselines at the same cache size. During post-training tuning, we
also effectively extended the context length from 4K to 32K using a KV cache of
fixed size 512, achieving performance similar to fine-tuning with entire
sequences.
|
[
-0.5810326933860779,
-0.4241969883441925,
0.21742229163646698,
0.277298241853714,
-0.525586724281311,
-0.12974117696285248,
-0.7046881318092346,
-0.5164825320243835,
0.084449902176857,
0.4031292796134949,
-0.6455947160720825,
-0.5920263528823853,
-0.40192386507987976,
-0.016549527645111084,
-0.40252256393432617,
0.6793458461761475,
0.36094409227371216,
-0.18018978834152222,
-0.49707797169685364,
-0.17313140630722046,
-0.7405926585197449,
-0.31467917561531067,
-0.7540302872657776,
-0.06094909459352493,
0.685291588306427,
0.5621857047080994,
0.3844154179096222,
0.8147948384284973,
0.23067925870418549,
0.2035251259803772,
-0.5573143362998962,
0.3400825560092926,
-0.6266332268714905,
0.31777670979499817,
-0.036689937114715576,
-0.3549002408981323,
-0.336459755897522,
-0.23789779841899872,
0.8230035305023193,
0.4283044636249542,
-0.16963598132133484,
-0.16071708500385284,
0.11539749801158905,
0.7333400249481201,
-1.2058348655700684,
0.017909474670886993,
-0.7981447577476501,
0.023804012686014175,
-0.2585720121860504,
-0.10877306014299393,
-0.7007202506065369,
0.18078230321407318,
-0.1346438080072403,
-0.5562005043029785,
0.1785556972026825,
-0.1032940074801445,
0.43675360083580017,
0.5666249990463257,
-0.40625783801078796,
-0.27604782581329346,
-0.6197435259819031,
0.7570475339889526,
-0.5796418786048889,
0.682701587677002,
0.344403475522995,
0.24805927276611328,
-0.3214881718158722,
-0.6963638663291931,
-0.574230968952179,
0.010690296068787575,
0.14068621397018433,
0.1407233029603958,
0.43228256702423096,
0.19034869968891144,
0.32643407583236694,
0.3444691598415375,
-0.2845131456851959,
0.1914663165807724,
-0.36077645421028137,
-0.26638469099998474,
0.34499621391296387,
0.3269205391407013,
-0.20405921339988708,
-0.09608598798513412,
-0.3665540814399719,
-0.04226158931851387,
-1.1280796527862549,
0.15681762993335724,
0.15290404856204987,
0.26131144165992737,
-0.054189279675483704,
0.07957333326339722,
-0.34343308210372925,
0.7554807066917419,
0.10012341290712357,
-0.0707937628030777,
-0.042756903916597366,
-0.23862870037555695,
-0.5999898314476013,
0.11180076748132706,
0.604888379573822,
0.24732011556625366,
-0.14255709946155548,
-0.28805011510849,
0.038210026919841766,
-0.18629632890224457,
0.23624810576438904,
-0.9226548671722412,
-0.1114858016371727,
0.40286779403686523,
-0.23209643363952637,
-0.049267854541540146,
-0.06307797878980637,
-0.9135051369667053,
-0.40681755542755127,
-0.046093400567770004,
0.01027449406683445,
-0.28029686212539673,
0.3170085847377777,
0.3065319359302521,
-0.03163035586476326,
0.45165780186653137,
0.30852189660072327,
-1.0284854173660278,
0.3535548746585846,
0.8629148602485657,
0.9097806811332703,
-0.3623451292514801,
-0.013193443417549133,
-1.031895637512207,
0.26218584179878235,
-0.16416491568088531,
0.41228899359703064,
-0.5164095163345337,
-0.5807128548622131,
0.23516975343227386,
0.32350867986679077,
0.21430876851081848,
-0.6248502731323242,
0.7892225384712219,
-0.7406855225563049,
-0.27571988105773926,
-0.27591225504875183,
-0.5668495297431946,
-0.10707931965589523,
0.18872590363025665,
-0.7133939862251282,
0.9704497456550598,
-0.10137573629617691,
-0.5340551733970642,
0.4241759181022644,
-0.21326810121536255,
-0.713487446308136,
0.10030223429203033,
-0.0832216739654541,
-0.259071946144104,
0.07846441119909286,
0.1622719019651413,
0.640143871307373,
-0.49929261207580566,
0.20559902489185333,
-0.2955690622329712,
-0.5386374592781067,
-0.17864908277988434,
-0.2486460953950882,
0.679891049861908,
0.3228307068347931,
-0.20062018930912018,
-0.059734608978033066,
-0.8389788866043091,
-0.14599134027957916,
-0.3176009953022003,
-0.5583273768424988,
-0.43168097734451294,
0.1412297934293747,
-0.024126555770635605,
0.37742194533348083,
0.15287193655967712,
-0.38296017050743103,
0.5430285334587097,
-0.5036392211914062,
0.6922677159309387,
0.6392054557800293,
-0.21801072359085083,
0.777087390422821,
0.04674483835697174,
0.2601287066936493,
0.20620901882648468,
0.3582022786140442,
-0.32498571276664734,
-0.24546031653881073,
-0.9632042050361633,
-0.49219533801078796,
0.23191021382808685,
0.28651463985443115,
-0.7580209970474243,
0.5097268223762512,
-0.6694161295890808,
-0.30744242668151855,
-0.3802708387374878,
0.16332601010799408,
0.3218348026275635,
0.6177696585655212,
0.2435978502035141,
-0.33601564168930054,
-0.6575857996940613,
-0.8627930879592896,
0.0071287560276687145,
0.2641594409942627,
-0.06736737489700317,
0.3260308504104614,
0.2604973614215851,
-0.2828226685523987,
0.9882540106773376,
-0.26554784178733826,
-0.1898840367794037,
0.15036536753177643,
-0.13819487392902374,
0.17427068948745728,
0.5719001293182373,
0.24923016130924225,
-0.7111913561820984,
-0.3257504403591156,
0.10658629238605499,
-0.2873978614807129,
0.19834193587303162,
0.023305660113692284,
-0.06875906884670258,
0.4610788822174072,
0.548443078994751,
-0.7300719618797302,
0.4976656436920166,
0.7309941649436951,
-0.13150961697101593,
0.3353748619556427,
-0.22142472863197327,
-0.061484258621931076,
-1.340846061706543,
0.17079609632492065,
-0.3743298351764679,
-0.3923114836215973,
-0.4318532645702362,
-0.17449922859668732,
0.4774886965751648,
0.22667132318019867,
-0.9143005013465881,
0.830605149269104,
-0.5606707334518433,
-0.02281372621655464,
-0.20911039412021637,
-0.08429957181215286,
0.04136109724640846,
0.5659202933311462,
-0.08406471461057663,
0.7318418025970459,
0.46802276372909546,
-0.939348042011261,
0.4051557183265686,
0.02885356731712818,
-0.7050947546958923,
0.0027005162555724382,
-0.31877055764198303,
0.4163253903388977,
-0.0515628382563591,
0.5081743001937866,
-0.8889457583427429,
-0.24545243382453918,
0.11323712766170502,
-0.07098474353551865,
0.40036267042160034,
-0.4944181740283966,
-0.47430306673049927,
-0.15350212156772614,
-0.3545472323894501,
0.6845270395278931,
0.5567803978919983,
-0.6234062910079956,
0.3442859649658203,
0.4192334711551666,
0.2680165469646454,
-0.8881466388702393,
-0.764539897441864,
0.15527887642383575,
-0.3253973722457886,
-0.4471726417541504,
0.569513738155365,
-0.265841007232666,
0.1791563481092453,
-0.29806408286094666,
-0.13858945667743683,
-0.0992463082075119,
-0.0791257843375206,
0.3778846263885498,
-0.05145096406340599,
0.12559174001216888,
0.3906475007534027,
0.2664574682712555,
0.0022145395632833242,
-0.18727193772792816,
-0.3424839973449707,
0.7307685613632202,
0.0952678918838501,
0.14385902881622314,
-0.24589689075946808,
0.20894569158554077,
0.8614616990089417,
0.08324334025382996,
0.8611920475959778,
0.4405825138092041,
-0.29763832688331604,
-0.3554190397262573,
-0.40039005875587463,
-0.0886540412902832,
-0.49529165029525757,
0.23765632510185242,
-0.44347476959228516,
-1.1787517070770264,
0.9564390182495117,
-0.1606554538011551,
0.06620307266712189,
0.23299746215343475,
0.7060228586196899,
0.03023884817957878,
0.46142342686653137,
0.58806312084198,
-0.3438090980052948,
0.7435330748558044,
-0.5130097270011902,
0.1270267814397812,
-1.0577203035354614,
-0.3125424087047577,
-0.3139897584915161,
-0.3601033091545105,
-0.5205377340316772,
-0.7558594942092896,
0.12517163157463074,
0.09952129423618317,
-0.1426648050546646,
0.28055909276008606,
-0.428280770778656,
0.642337441444397,
0.22488512098789215,
0.14220423996448517,
0.010381714440882206,
-0.36177054047584534,
0.0020099070388823748,
0.1934184730052948,
-0.8511287569999695,
0.12964925169944763,
0.8157303333282471,
0.19189445674419403,
0.7645285129547119,
-0.1164616122841835,
0.39824461936950684,
0.23713429272174835,
0.18077443540096283,
-1.1394472122192383,
0.4969610869884491,
-0.1366230994462967,
-0.3793327808380127,
-0.34106048941612244,
-0.25766289234161377,
-0.9253420233726501,
-0.019909698516130447,
-0.07078328728675842,
-0.4811570942401886,
0.379089891910553,
0.25515061616897583,
-0.5981419086456299,
0.11097969859838486,
-0.3174830973148346,
0.7565299868583679,
0.1882667988538742,
-0.6475327610969543,
-0.251159131526947,
-0.9504081010818481,
0.3431703448295593,
0.06173846125602722,
0.054681938141584396,
0.03385205939412117,
-0.26762673258781433,
0.5696665048599243,
-0.534907341003418,
0.7543125152587891,
0.031080948188900948,
-0.20974791049957275,
0.45430484414100647,
0.11075475066900253,
0.9579005837440491,
0.28232818841934204,
-0.15008068084716797,
0.24271848797798157,
-0.2282717227935791,
-0.3886018991470337,
-0.9213150143623352,
0.9908717274665833,
-0.40825867652893066,
-0.40706339478492737,
0.03174386918544769,
-0.6838715076446533,
-0.10645055770874023,
-0.048884984105825424,
0.40724626183509827,
0.5542375445365906,
-0.01336600724607706,
0.6965208053588867,
0.7810436487197876,
-0.14421766996383667,
0.7579396963119507,
0.164913147687912,
0.22382107377052307,
-0.7336937785148621,
0.3486490845680237,
0.06632902473211288,
0.2577803432941437,
0.6295312643051147,
0.07372452318668365,
-0.3660404086112976,
-0.5642396807670593,
-0.26386260986328125,
0.04489167034626007,
-0.8229746222496033,
-0.3444182276725769,
-0.563433825969696,
-0.2085046023130417,
-0.5343360304832458,
-0.23639823496341705,
-0.7325893640518188,
-0.23165930807590485,
-0.12574492394924164,
0.08178995549678802,
0.4636877775192261,
0.11929517239332199,
0.27064982056617737,
0.5158249735832214,
-0.8110440373420715,
-0.07558480650186539,
0.3556066155433655,
0.2956157922744751,
0.01196520496159792,
-0.7258880138397217,
-0.7547620534896851,
0.01644984260201454,
0.007744691800326109,
-0.46805083751678467,
0.5581353306770325,
0.10491979867219925,
0.08633425086736679,
0.605224609375,
0.0763896256685257,
1.1537750959396362,
-0.5396019816398621,
0.8162735104560852,
0.12731486558914185,
-0.9626033902168274,
0.3474957346916199,
-0.45338794589042664,
0.49227502942085266,
0.585391104221344,
0.07140087336301804,
-0.650153398513794,
-0.09915050119161606,
-0.39101511240005493,
-1.1026216745376587,
0.48436975479125977,
0.021822961047291756,
0.13223174214363098,
-0.36053165793418884,
0.7112612128257751,
0.07711473852396011,
0.14967583119869232,
-0.4131523668766022,
-0.18789874017238617,
0.2596626281738281,
-0.11561659723520279,
-0.3222908079624176,
-0.3887765109539032,
-0.017995813861489296,
-0.6078890562057495,
0.4281800091266632,
-0.21111026406288147,
0.23629926145076752,
0.21692779660224915,
-0.23579370975494385,
0.12217458337545395,
0.0862484723329544,
0.9715561270713806,
0.5143737196922302,
-0.1254556030035019,
0.24826529622077942,
0.48913395404815674,
-0.5243315100669861,
-0.14988580346107483,
-0.49209263920783997,
0.09117993712425232,
0.020601803436875343,
0.14567412436008453,
0.9377320408821106,
0.6744257211685181,
-0.8146893978118896,
0.42505940794944763,
-0.029426394030451775,
-0.023297404870390892,
-0.2830795645713806,
0.07252146303653717,
0.11343567073345184,
0.0760054737329483,
0.1777743101119995,
-0.15710321068763733,
0.22244812548160553,
-0.5493963956832886,
0.3091103136539459,
0.4240356683731079,
-0.48346805572509766,
-0.2346341460943222,
0.5066463351249695,
0.42400914430618286,
-0.20237211883068085,
0.884255588054657,
0.1152147725224495,
-0.14962531626224518,
0.8153700828552246,
0.521987795829773,
1.0992542505264282,
-0.08551909029483795,
-0.37573912739753723,
0.38168054819107056,
-0.008409281261265278,
-0.31050926446914673,
-0.17530889809131622,
-0.5721888542175293,
-0.6457745432853699,
-0.6662200093269348,
-0.6817486882209778,
-0.27195683121681213,
0.4732029139995575,
-0.6639491319656372,
0.5441555976867676,
-0.38509541749954224,
0.07128019630908966,
-0.39850983023643494,
0.08051760494709015,
-0.6145434379577637,
0.21113765239715576,
0.02689773216843605,
1.0929313898086548,
-0.5286287665367126,
1.3687083721160889,
0.4000108540058136,
0.07059469074010849,
-0.4822133481502533,
-0.12493976950645447,
-0.2443084716796875,
-0.32070809602737427,
0.5832347273826599,
0.3141699731349945,
-0.0686841532588005,
-0.007085555233061314,
-0.5917671918869019,
-0.7545850872993469,
1.1488699913024902,
0.4822862446308136,
-0.9007900953292847,
0.008872057311236858,
-0.16147519648075104,
0.3292445242404938,
-0.40152090787887573,
-0.0845787525177002,
0.6053858995437622,
0.3128633201122284,
0.5787853598594666,
-0.6891601085662842,
-0.06927992403507233,
-0.051836397498846054,
0.013683348894119263,
0.5465160012245178,
-0.8712713718414307,
0.8715431094169617,
0.08525656163692474,
-0.2768622636795044,
0.09614921361207962,
0.7095697522163391,
0.09410934150218964,
0.2750610113143921,
0.49721530079841614,
0.7127304673194885,
0.5467877388000488,
0.2018021196126938,
1.0109455585479736,
-0.4985010623931885,
0.5487123131752014,
1.2096350193023682,
-0.04982683062553406,
0.9051967263221741,
0.795032799243927,
0.2296818345785141,
0.1716141402721405,
0.789838969707489,
0.5577107071876526,
0.8803737163543701,
0.11005721986293793,
-0.544806957244873,
-0.38988709449768066,
0.21599918603897095,
-0.0053133005276322365,
0.4401538074016571,
0.3543512523174286,
-0.24479486048221588,
0.05453413724899292,
-0.07171497493982315,
-0.019158141687512398,
-0.4017679691314697,
-0.39944887161254883,
0.669614315032959,
0.19906026124954224,
-0.944932758808136,
0.8985652327537537,
-0.2395610809326172,
0.7425060868263245,
-0.3988032341003418,
0.10982543230056763,
-0.4847125709056854,
0.21276995539665222,
-0.10634667426347733,
-0.5115877985954285,
0.41183269023895264,
-0.1775629073381424,
-0.38528573513031006,
-0.22107329964637756,
0.5035542249679565,
-0.6663658618927002,
-0.028009671717882156,
0.2995361387729645,
-0.07251114398241043,
0.23935610055923462,
-0.10690822452306747,
-0.23587633669376373,
0.3973519504070282,
-0.272456556558609,
-0.2708495259284973,
0.4274241328239441,
0.4741789996623993,
-0.18871745467185974,
0.7741918563842773,
0.5933849215507507,
-0.11363529413938522,
0.24861249327659607,
0.05884123221039772,
1.0730488300323486,
-0.8662538528442383,
-0.49500060081481934,
-1.0675493478775024,
0.48530223965644836,
-0.011525825597345829,
-0.23501533269882202,
0.5196210145950317,
0.7934927344322205,
0.8025665879249573,
-0.1963171660900116,
0.4108419418334961,
-0.13682790100574493,
-0.17204292118549347,
-0.7127473950386047,
0.6506674289703369,
-0.6151480078697205,
0.19495071470737457,
0.05470246821641922,
-0.6711947917938232,
-0.4306676387786865,
0.32506439089775085,
-0.0768202468752861,
-0.20176830887794495,
0.6891739964485168,
0.8148372173309326,
-0.11353635042905807,
-0.44144386053085327,
0.5865002274513245,
0.17123205959796906,
0.3821104168891907,
0.9274143576622009,
0.5909231901168823,
-0.7190815806388855,
0.5083668828010559,
-0.24061128497123718,
0.1738087385892868,
-0.518660843372345,
-1.022637963294983,
-0.8308044075965881,
-0.746618926525116,
-0.028447862714529037,
-0.22390340268611908,
0.14555765688419342,
0.696982204914093,
0.9835758805274963,
-0.5739912390708923,
-0.0957845076918602,
-0.14910058677196503,
0.24225886166095734,
-0.11334514617919922,
-0.19922427833080292,
0.27802103757858276,
-0.414783775806427,
-1.0569026470184326,
0.5059046149253845,
0.5987755656242371,
-0.2843726575374603,
-0.09643805027008057,
-0.36026620864868164,
-0.1102992445230484,
-0.005334556568413973,
0.9148409366607666,
0.3287406861782074,
-0.7657245397567749,
-0.5286502242088318,
-0.09171564131975174,
-0.23668120801448822,
0.2515830397605896,
0.9692599177360535,
-1.0649503469467163,
0.6651557683944702,
0.7526029944419861,
0.7107418775558472,
0.6154388785362244,
-0.11178774386644363,
0.4994717538356781,
-1.0204720497131348,
0.9070123434066772,
0.30888843536376953,
0.22988831996917725,
-0.010697891935706139,
-0.4850003123283386,
0.3982390761375427,
0.20225267112255096,
-0.5290663838386536,
-0.8794960975646973,
0.12206988781690598,
-1.4995787143707275,
-0.11864259093999863,
1.2924970388412476,
-0.004669180605560541,
-0.598145067691803,
0.013019203208386898,
-0.03757905215024948,
0.4762181043624878,
-0.40304285287857056,
0.9284152388572693,
0.8321748375892639,
0.20185953378677368,
-0.4088711142539978,
-0.4289679229259491,
0.8379256725311279,
0.2570784389972687,
-0.591572642326355,
0.3448370695114136,
0.42934831976890564,
0.2093835175037384,
-0.026100538671016693,
0.43655386567115784,
0.04717029258608818,
0.3640112280845642,
-0.22774295508861542,
0.2664856016635895,
-0.10324513912200928,
-0.5470288395881653,
-0.4720190763473511,
0.20046399533748627,
-0.47079136967658997,
-0.39707884192466736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05315v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05315v1
|
Concept Formation and Alignment in Language Models: Bridging Statistical Patterns in Latent Space to Concept Taxonomy
| 2024-06-08T01:27:19 | 2024-06-08T01:27:19 |
Mehrdad Khatir, Chandan K. Reddy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper explores the concept formation and alignment within the realm of
language models (LMs). We propose a mechanism for identifying concepts and
their hierarchical organization within the semantic representations learned by
various LMs, encompassing a spectrum from early models like Glove to the
transformer-based language models like ALBERT and T5. Our approach leverages
the inherent structure present in the semantic embeddings generated by these
models to extract a taxonomy of concepts and their hierarchical relationships.
This investigation sheds light on how LMs develop conceptual understanding and
opens doors to further research to improve their ability to reason and leverage
real-world knowledge. We further conducted experiments and observed the
possibility of isolating these extracted conceptual representations from the
reasoning modules of the transformer-based LMs. The observed concept formation
along with the isolation of conceptual representations from the reasoning
modules can enable targeted token engineering to open the door for potential
applications in knowledge transfer, explainable AI, and the development of more
modular and conceptually grounded language models.
|
[
-0.280028760433197,
-0.7361658215522766,
0.6132904887199402,
-0.25297921895980835,
0.0757996216416359,
0.4122552275657654,
0.2184872329235077,
-0.2593388855457306,
0.15103724598884583,
0.346228688955307,
-0.4288516938686371,
-0.36418965458869934,
-0.313331663608551,
-0.24283914268016815,
-0.5082663893699646,
0.8241702318191528,
-0.1001700684428215,
-0.23439624905586243,
-0.4063425064086914,
0.1387859433889389,
-0.6153205633163452,
-0.42826467752456665,
-0.23883067071437836,
-0.5289404988288879,
0.47498953342437744,
0.08940574526786804,
0.7847665548324585,
0.9985176920890808,
0.7416749000549316,
0.2914004325866699,
-0.21900472044944763,
-0.00047688785707578063,
-0.13937975466251373,
0.27092379331588745,
-0.24063673615455627,
-0.6321603655815125,
-0.4407191574573517,
0.07655477523803711,
0.6771848797798157,
0.9671837091445923,
-0.32674387097358704,
-0.008297152817249298,
-0.16632811725139618,
0.14461418986320496,
-0.5132408142089844,
0.3533226549625397,
-0.7963800430297852,
-0.024472901597619057,
-0.2965932786464691,
-0.14671137928962708,
-0.38754159212112427,
-0.03534400463104248,
0.17565244436264038,
-0.639377236366272,
0.2774064838886261,
0.2978893518447876,
1.1528419256210327,
0.18202809989452362,
-0.17083270847797394,
-0.3863532543182373,
-0.7632719874382019,
0.7615979313850403,
-0.4854108691215515,
0.5675054788589478,
0.10348035395145416,
0.2973293662071228,
-0.06247260794043541,
-0.6251683235168457,
-0.8053196668624878,
0.054690271615982056,
-0.25613874197006226,
0.014840345829725266,
-0.03010711446404457,
-0.1539342850446701,
-0.016401125118136406,
0.15687771141529083,
-0.5429047346115112,
0.24276918172836304,
-0.35412222146987915,
-0.3021478056907654,
0.42951205372810364,
0.261567085981369,
0.5266373157501221,
-0.3780596852302551,
-0.33534398674964905,
0.03689785674214363,
-0.880028247833252,
-0.28754791617393494,
-0.030244354158639908,
0.43474918603897095,
-0.30683091282844543,
0.8027277588844299,
0.2528674304485321,
0.36148950457572937,
0.0464327335357666,
-0.23108594119548798,
0.3232431411743164,
-0.4332159757614136,
-0.17924632132053375,
0.03983306884765625,
0.6766518950462341,
-0.04996507614850998,
0.12237817794084549,
-0.49184250831604004,
-0.3366968631744385,
0.5359277129173279,
0.6009941101074219,
-0.36611461639404297,
-0.06823202222585678,
0.13471026718616486,
-0.4357527792453766,
-0.6127436757087708,
0.22751086950302124,
-0.36579376459121704,
-0.12104706466197968,
-0.4175751507282257,
0.28690773248672485,
-0.3358924686908722,
-0.611869215965271,
-0.12244176864624023,
-0.25572219491004944,
0.46611377596855164,
0.13241834938526154,
-1.0437161922454834,
0.4271336495876312,
1.0901387929916382,
0.7819389700889587,
-0.3034246563911438,
-0.05890890955924988,
0.2855706512928009,
0.6192044615745544,
-0.758230447769165,
0.5911131501197815,
-0.721337616443634,
-0.3431492745876312,
0.08019468933343887,
-0.17497114837169647,
0.014689000323414803,
-0.5343783497810364,
0.18824800848960876,
-0.8142122030258179,
0.20346175134181976,
0.11286132037639618,
-0.9319125413894653,
0.05513053387403488,
0.10595211386680603,
-0.6074283123016357,
1.047599196434021,
-0.11635459959506989,
-0.7590200901031494,
0.3555121123790741,
-0.9149711728096008,
-0.0639580637216568,
0.2591487169265747,
-0.627200186252594,
-0.18875357508659363,
0.2665891945362091,
-0.15397310256958008,
0.576684296131134,
-0.3360840380191803,
0.3403160870075226,
-0.31727170944213867,
0.13894356787204742,
0.46450573205947876,
0.1335800439119339,
0.5029026865959167,
0.5042253136634827,
0.014792746864259243,
0.04039609804749489,
-0.5915437340736389,
-0.2252405881881714,
0.2484346628189087,
0.24129356443881989,
-0.7401635646820068,
0.2246433049440384,
-0.26028332114219666,
0.16956748068332672,
0.08530251681804657,
-0.3741098940372467,
0.20472335815429688,
-0.5105358362197876,
0.4987243711948395,
0.5262344479560852,
0.06358659267425537,
0.9454724192619324,
-0.18468572199344635,
0.3180696964263916,
0.525516152381897,
-0.2133958339691162,
-0.19943498075008392,
-0.34415191411972046,
-0.8256338238716125,
-0.09973679482936859,
0.2540813386440277,
0.34376227855682373,
-0.6636750102043152,
0.7814907431602478,
-0.5730312466621399,
-0.5257854461669922,
-0.573108434677124,
-0.058860063552856445,
0.1642582267522812,
0.5511902570724487,
0.09413828700780869,
-0.22307200729846954,
-0.385234534740448,
-0.8880788087844849,
0.1915067434310913,
-0.4606098532676697,
0.06759138405323029,
-0.1898038238286972,
0.6950209736824036,
-0.21617013216018677,
1.4612691402435303,
-0.5371864438056946,
0.02336326241493225,
-0.17829450964927673,
0.04468579590320587,
0.1292809545993805,
0.5847306847572327,
0.429899126291275,
-0.8494684100151062,
0.09712062031030655,
0.18173810839653015,
-0.9506582617759705,
-0.08066613227128983,
0.030751759186387062,
-0.3153570592403412,
-0.022615281865000725,
0.7972801327705383,
-0.7831454277038574,
0.08092909306287766,
0.16970784962177277,
-0.11987683922052383,
0.23238006234169006,
0.17736439406871796,
-0.4373928904533386,
-1.6390984058380127,
-0.02899259328842163,
0.03180091083049774,
0.032429903745651245,
-0.8115047812461853,
0.25030094385147095,
-0.012008033692836761,
-0.008243519812822342,
-0.20474740862846375,
0.5960060954093933,
-0.4648827612400055,
0.011883124709129333,
-0.08773064613342285,
0.3644769787788391,
-0.0637657642364502,
0.17221206426620483,
0.3059508502483368,
0.5024353861808777,
0.5762803554534912,
-0.793321430683136,
-0.027661947533488274,
0.3356800079345703,
-0.3381910026073456,
0.2755785584449768,
-0.7098541855812073,
-0.07599637657403946,
-0.18115699291229248,
-0.014134331606328487,
-0.9360774159431458,
-0.09406499564647675,
0.30850228667259216,
-0.45307523012161255,
0.32633209228515625,
-0.08325859904289246,
-0.545028567314148,
-0.06963110715150833,
0.15741343796253204,
0.4613058865070343,
0.5874805450439453,
-0.1889905333518982,
0.44790634512901306,
0.8678888082504272,
-0.1360207051038742,
-0.3339049816131592,
-0.5960394144058228,
-0.1871463507413864,
-0.6311970949172974,
-0.4965667128562927,
0.5907548069953918,
0.3096531927585602,
-0.7163930535316467,
0.19524559378623962,
-0.20114979147911072,
-0.03924518823623657,
0.3866918981075287,
0.18527647852897644,
0.5074819326400757,
-0.5013453960418701,
0.5646518468856812,
0.06196073442697525,
-0.14409740269184113,
0.21614737808704376,
-0.4537849724292755,
0.450834184885025,
0.2290879189968109,
-0.276531457901001,
-0.27481141686439514,
0.16812922060489655,
0.4764370024204254,
-0.20421379804611206,
0.894244909286499,
0.26732128858566284,
-0.659818708896637,
-0.33814334869384766,
-0.29708564281463623,
-0.24541912972927094,
-0.4434780478477478,
0.35232123732566833,
-0.7484689950942993,
-0.928034782409668,
0.6035390496253967,
-0.13793352246284485,
0.09217426925897598,
0.6961508393287659,
0.6824012398719788,
-0.22963441908359528,
0.8710223436355591,
0.8746499419212341,
0.05952167138457298,
0.4423225224018097,
-0.15971192717552185,
0.48748090863227844,
-0.7648495435714722,
-0.3175581395626068,
-0.6337762475013733,
0.041313521564006805,
-0.7776222825050354,
-0.6851431727409363,
0.1984487920999527,
0.38452816009521484,
-0.3301076889038086,
0.354057252407074,
-0.3274763226509094,
0.2584869861602783,
0.05329132080078125,
-0.3292766213417053,
0.13000062108039856,
-0.02287653647363186,
-0.34051984548568726,
-0.0847683697938919,
-0.739699125289917,
-0.879996657371521,
0.8251548409461975,
0.6457151770591736,
0.7053516507148743,
0.38352298736572266,
0.8723952174186707,
0.17111431062221527,
0.3546648323535919,
-0.8559421896934509,
0.3863944113254547,
0.24541901051998138,
-0.5758167505264282,
-0.26999351382255554,
-0.31410524249076843,
-0.8664788007736206,
0.16574522852897644,
-0.14346584677696228,
-0.858164370059967,
0.10796327888965607,
-0.18632270395755768,
-0.1373947411775589,
-0.07285450398921967,
-0.5177837610244751,
0.7858114838600159,
0.07258903980255127,
-0.06483570486307144,
-0.18131592869758606,
-0.6612112522125244,
0.3217092454433441,
-0.21577364206314087,
0.4699563980102539,
-0.08782239258289337,
-0.2788561284542084,
0.7912279963493347,
-0.48852989077568054,
0.9177396893501282,
0.1377243846654892,
-0.7317742109298706,
0.36980316042900085,
0.28960826992988586,
0.1436619758605957,
-0.24576117098331451,
0.08966879546642303,
0.08442512154579163,
-0.03506394103169441,
-0.23503242433071136,
-0.8555719256401062,
0.2855759263038635,
-0.8736240863800049,
-0.5819434523582458,
-0.2590293288230896,
-0.5845329761505127,
-0.22704273462295532,
0.10617747157812119,
-0.14521613717079163,
0.2725101709365845,
-0.4083004295825958,
0.10034745931625366,
0.552604615688324,
0.13687178492546082,
0.3897634744644165,
0.2693391740322113,
-0.49791210889816284,
-0.07225892692804337,
0.8070897459983826,
0.0033276421017944813,
0.4499635100364685,
0.8014075756072998,
0.013396098278462887,
-0.37247705459594727,
-0.471128910779953,
-0.05461684241890907,
0.3214297294616699,
-0.6509827375411987,
-0.09209386259317398,
-0.4826399087905884,
-0.4029141664505005,
-0.4948959946632385,
-0.0018339423695579171,
-0.2867526113986969,
-0.7108964920043945,
-0.07358819246292114,
-0.2628841698169708,
0.18082864582538605,
0.9045121669769287,
0.15623275935649872,
0.5225580930709839,
-0.7253576517105103,
0.03294416889548302,
-0.048499997705221176,
0.027181480079889297,
0.20008595287799835,
-0.45306721329689026,
-0.40292254090309143,
0.008633549325168133,
-0.3982396125793457,
-0.773239254951477,
0.2796829342842102,
-0.002306734910234809,
0.7361389994621277,
0.5224272012710571,
-0.2868614196777344,
0.7039235234260559,
-0.6168692111968994,
0.8328414559364319,
0.3528088927268982,
-1.1069512367248535,
0.5777825117111206,
-0.42662742733955383,
-0.06920427083969116,
-0.13169622421264648,
0.40919360518455505,
-0.6252743601799011,
-0.49323180317878723,
-0.8720370531082153,
-0.64072585105896,
0.6024929881095886,
0.3682316541671753,
0.1439630091190338,
-0.16338007152080536,
0.38626036047935486,
0.15431725978851318,
0.22473841905593872,
-0.579586386680603,
-0.2814989686012268,
-0.08041693270206451,
-0.5187660455703735,
-0.02395426481962204,
-0.06960134208202362,
-0.23041455447673798,
-0.07733441889286041,
0.4848473370075226,
-0.26707395911216736,
0.3618966042995453,
-0.2610246241092682,
-0.24534817039966583,
0.07322825491428375,
0.16686715185642242,
0.44525057077407837,
0.6322779655456543,
0.20152507722377777,
0.3803994059562683,
-0.25759458541870117,
-0.11636670678853989,
0.09144995361566544,
-0.2546003758907318,
-0.07353464514017105,
-0.02503219060599804,
0.5799211859703064,
0.7433217763900757,
0.21362009644508362,
-0.19892047345638275,
0.17046663165092468,
0.21190334856510162,
0.05479273200035095,
-0.11206655949354172,
0.18192043900489807,
0.4491513669490814,
0.13319408893585205,
0.24449306726455688,
-0.163089781999588,
-0.20087657868862152,
-0.7762564420700073,
0.40175795555114746,
0.45067834854125977,
-0.1160058006644249,
-0.614467442035675,
0.5049906373023987,
0.1369297355413437,
-0.25399163365364075,
0.46356600522994995,
0.02794531174004078,
-0.3803660273551941,
0.6049849987030029,
0.6806139945983887,
0.7882477641105652,
-0.19380299746990204,
0.2783576548099518,
0.12438619881868362,
0.1701379120349884,
0.023446816951036453,
-0.018111281096935272,
-0.10324078053236008,
-1.6065036058425903,
-0.3231971561908722,
-0.7398951053619385,
-0.19674482941627502,
-0.09252337366342545,
-0.6721435785293579,
0.3046596348285675,
-0.09868437051773071,
-0.06236318126320839,
0.4565977156162262,
-0.21994467079639435,
-0.39784741401672363,
0.07790382206439972,
0.4720058739185333,
0.651833713054657,
-1.0152567625045776,
0.9317780137062073,
0.7205008864402771,
-0.6077816486358643,
-0.9538163542747498,
0.15647156536579132,
0.058795519173145294,
-0.8750622868537903,
0.9555004835128784,
-0.1538909673690796,
0.05579972639679909,
-0.0029998186510056257,
-0.5267481207847595,
-1.0712649822235107,
1.0559611320495605,
0.08996252715587616,
-0.45385506749153137,
-0.24731846153736115,
0.3097521662712097,
0.6561421751976013,
-0.7840654850006104,
0.21471883356571198,
0.5230206847190857,
0.17485734820365906,
0.2297048717737198,
-0.8450208306312561,
0.053146492689847946,
-0.23665650188922882,
0.2512598931789398,
0.4950253963470459,
-0.30287766456604004,
0.6870307922363281,
-0.07989723980426788,
-0.4372512996196747,
0.11911610513925552,
0.8309987187385559,
0.3406534790992737,
0.014623158611357212,
0.24279139935970306,
0.6278650164604187,
0.7332720160484314,
-0.17606569826602936,
0.7195502519607544,
-0.3625262975692749,
0.37435582280158997,
0.7179173231124878,
-0.37413039803504944,
0.7174679040908813,
0.738388180732727,
-0.11081930994987488,
0.6915057301521301,
0.6745701432228088,
0.1667412966489792,
0.6544212102890015,
0.26112672686576843,
0.07330963760614395,
-0.19749125838279724,
-0.2510415017604828,
-0.3072132468223572,
0.5512983202934265,
0.8419537544250488,
-0.3067591190338135,
-0.06415371596813202,
-0.3238801956176758,
-0.10948289185762405,
-0.08850251883268356,
-0.2341637760400772,
1.1683366298675537,
0.3630858063697815,
-0.5232199430465698,
0.38565289974212646,
-0.05284182354807854,
0.28823578357696533,
-0.5029282569885254,
0.006008611060678959,
0.06900349259376526,
0.08381298929452896,
-0.16617359220981598,
-0.7187278270721436,
0.49043384194374084,
-0.14017978310585022,
-0.2665404677391052,
-0.4142437279224396,
0.6859989166259766,
-0.5499171018600464,
-0.4644235074520111,
0.10187311470508575,
1.1073709726333618,
0.14971528947353363,
0.6598779559135437,
-0.5545021295547485,
0.11478821188211441,
-0.41419610381126404,
0.05976136401295662,
0.16034628450870514,
0.9006307125091553,
-0.36928847432136536,
0.46661484241485596,
0.49218443036079407,
0.20313957333564758,
0.04222080484032631,
0.33305078744888306,
0.7214232087135315,
-0.6941106915473938,
-0.5185338854789734,
-0.9882807731628418,
0.5021514892578125,
0.019838906824588776,
-0.12015717476606369,
0.6183416843414307,
0.411077618598938,
0.9451133608818054,
0.04303160682320595,
0.811505913734436,
-0.3590346574783325,
0.3029470443725586,
-0.5821027159690857,
0.7004178166389465,
-0.5596103072166443,
0.3563012182712555,
-0.502181887626648,
-0.7769994139671326,
-0.4161246716976166,
0.7114132642745972,
-0.1709863841533661,
-0.1491977870464325,
0.7720184922218323,
0.8268322348594666,
-0.11665195971727371,
0.044136080890893936,
0.20458659529685974,
0.18782588839530945,
0.419396311044693,
0.02465882897377014,
1.0582622289657593,
-0.30862998962402344,
0.003232971066609025,
-0.07632624357938766,
0.07652494311332703,
0.05721503123641014,
-0.6709322929382324,
-0.6186742186546326,
-0.8681092858314514,
-0.5186711549758911,
-0.0790330097079277,
-0.1918943226337433,
0.8230787515640259,
0.5976726412773132,
-0.8383570313453674,
-0.4735284149646759,
-0.34701240062713623,
0.40518081188201904,
-0.10407577455043793,
-0.3127835988998413,
0.2657013237476349,
-0.7245814800262451,
-0.6126927733421326,
0.14730781316757202,
0.18959274888038635,
0.062494341284036636,
-0.3189457356929779,
-0.10847388207912445,
0.002282422035932541,
0.1163628101348877,
0.5890271067619324,
-0.1379639357328415,
-0.9029126167297363,
-0.4629985988140106,
0.006795045919716358,
-0.17481780052185059,
0.08369120955467224,
0.9327540397644043,
-0.7043843269348145,
0.09784672409296036,
0.43026497960090637,
0.6699154376983643,
-0.04530967026948929,
-0.1347016990184784,
0.8776145577430725,
-0.7884306311607361,
0.12413500249385834,
0.154081791639328,
0.4296700060367584,
0.2195730209350586,
0.13158342242240906,
0.5789052844047546,
0.4515690207481384,
-0.10558263212442398,
-1.0790119171142578,
0.3922063708305359,
-0.8025806546211243,
-0.22513821721076965,
0.899914562702179,
0.2807980179786682,
-0.25363078713417053,
-0.06401927024126053,
0.19746465981006622,
0.4953574240207672,
-0.18790686130523682,
0.8351624011993408,
0.8784507513046265,
-0.14332357048988342,
-0.176580011844635,
-0.2373136430978775,
0.41542598605155945,
0.2779698371887207,
-0.790684700012207,
0.03720906749367714,
0.20355084538459778,
0.14566746354103088,
0.8222756385803223,
0.1797916144132614,
-0.2778337001800537,
-0.13112132251262665,
0.05089255049824715,
0.19714702665805817,
0.5093897581100464,
-0.28233927488327026,
-0.10931674391031265,
0.22369612753391266,
0.0462426133453846,
-0.22543880343437195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05307v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05307v1
|
DeviceBERT: Applied Transfer Learning With Targeted Annotations and Vocabulary Enrichment to Identify Medical Device and Component Terminology in FDA Recall Summaries
| 2024-06-08T00:33:22 | 2024-06-08T00:33:22 |
Miriam Farrington
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
FDA Medical Device recalls are critical and time-sensitive events, requiring
swift identification of impacted devices to inform the public of a recall event
and ensure patient safety. The OpenFDA device recall dataset contains valuable
information about ongoing device recall actions, but manually extracting
relevant device information from the recall action summaries is a
time-consuming task. Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a task in Natural
Language Processing (NLP) that involves identifying and categorizing named
entities in unstructured text. Existing NER models, including domain-specific
models like BioBERT, struggle to correctly identify medical device trade names,
part numbers and component terms within these summaries. To address this, we
propose DeviceBERT, a medical device annotation, pre-processing and enrichment
pipeline, which builds on BioBERT to identify and label medical device
terminology in the device recall summaries with improved accuracy. Furthermore,
we demonstrate that our approach can be applied effectively for performing
entity recognition tasks where training data is limited or sparse.
|
[
-0.3232846260070801,
-0.3969346284866333,
0.3813871443271637,
-0.000845723261591047,
-0.2420070767402649,
0.31620827317237854,
0.1867498755455017,
-0.5623496174812317,
0.36135435104370117,
0.6287984848022461,
-0.27666234970092773,
-0.44294172525405884,
-0.5557679533958435,
0.07481838762760162,
-0.555167019367218,
1.0849283933639526,
-0.3544798195362091,
-0.3126213848590851,
0.15187597274780273,
-0.25903719663619995,
-0.6396718621253967,
-0.3719455897808075,
-0.5097126960754395,
-0.32237496972084045,
0.40976861119270325,
0.5540063381195068,
0.13720062375068665,
0.3557537794113159,
0.83353191614151,
0.2696821689605713,
0.11197426915168762,
0.2685963809490204,
-0.07779692113399506,
-0.043463896960020065,
-0.022395765408873558,
-0.04056201130151749,
-0.5825605392456055,
-0.01809239201247692,
0.28041359782218933,
0.5792908668518066,
-0.05638391897082329,
0.41773614287376404,
-0.01626679114997387,
0.3520258367061615,
-0.7102159857749939,
0.026297474279999733,
-0.5948441028594971,
0.19296647608280182,
0.0770641565322876,
-0.2507888078689575,
-0.6191515326499939,
-0.39708855748176575,
0.4215494692325592,
-0.6479885578155518,
0.46300551295280457,
0.010869140736758709,
1.2309308052062988,
0.2685436010360718,
-0.48851534724235535,
-0.3014167249202728,
-0.9263337850570679,
0.49819880723953247,
-0.1660449057817459,
0.5164326429367065,
0.1393355429172516,
0.14054733514785767,
-0.009921358898282051,
-1.351446509361267,
-0.4265207350254059,
0.08743391931056976,
-0.2843248248100281,
-0.1650305539369583,
-0.21918246150016785,
0.1475065052509308,
0.13852208852767944,
0.0522305928170681,
-0.5060140490531921,
-0.012231701985001564,
-1.046878695487976,
-0.5082222819328308,
0.5689584612846375,
-0.15203317999839783,
0.31920167803764343,
-0.028645899146795273,
-0.7686219215393066,
0.12292735278606415,
-0.8547649383544922,
-0.09140278398990631,
-0.44023483991622925,
0.1410260945558548,
0.09042545408010483,
0.42366740107536316,
-0.06541543453931808,
0.6511856913566589,
0.22102630138397217,
-0.1402268409729004,
0.8535289764404297,
-0.0551588200032711,
-0.6983460783958435,
0.8818994164466858,
0.4241766631603241,
0.21369951963424683,
-0.21099334955215454,
-0.29922664165496826,
-0.16130565106868744,
-0.45579203963279724,
0.5915136337280273,
-0.9117318391799927,
-0.7289153337478638,
0.3135454058647156,
-0.5263721346855164,
-0.1870921552181244,
0.4208531677722931,
-0.7367265820503235,
-0.601519763469696,
-0.11186572164297104,
0.7683150172233582,
0.020008180290460587,
0.1386270970106125,
0.027896445244550705,
-0.3143712878227234,
0.07034347951412201,
0.21455632150173187,
-0.899385929107666,
0.30027997493743896,
0.5086492300033569,
0.8473116159439087,
-0.289460152387619,
0.031114963814616203,
-0.8210316300392151,
0.4016178846359253,
-0.04226214066147804,
0.8199399709701538,
-0.1177515834569931,
-0.7301711440086365,
-0.17360179126262665,
0.517518162727356,
-0.30409717559814453,
-0.8396482467651367,
0.4897162616252899,
-0.6486095190048218,
-0.07160720974206924,
-0.17236123979091644,
-0.4594986140727997,
-0.4656471908092499,
0.01745443418622017,
-0.8428112864494324,
0.6396282315254211,
0.15073168277740479,
-0.6839407086372375,
0.7475934028625488,
-0.5996275544166565,
-0.8310104012489319,
0.2779756486415863,
-0.05438833683729172,
-0.5893213748931885,
0.06645318865776062,
0.2638639211654663,
0.683361828327179,
-0.04660767316818237,
0.3002219498157501,
0.024205075576901436,
-0.29660481214523315,
0.23195478320121765,
0.10065975785255432,
0.5544464588165283,
0.3418637812137604,
-0.16555558145046234,
0.38966134190559387,
-0.8185113668441772,
-0.36893799901008606,
-0.10748080164194107,
-0.22264628112316132,
-0.46712350845336914,
-0.29947179555892944,
-0.036373574286699295,
-0.005539801437407732,
0.07918539643287659,
-0.6776548027992249,
0.0711335837841034,
-0.09989147633314133,
0.591783881187439,
0.3862525224685669,
0.2714702785015106,
0.5416979789733887,
-0.2710306644439697,
0.4102242588996887,
-0.1496036797761917,
0.17416195571422577,
-0.07829536497592926,
-0.40624433755874634,
-0.7260686159133911,
-0.6634681224822998,
0.7138954401016235,
0.8409069180488586,
-0.7557094693183899,
0.45463961362838745,
-0.14898961782455444,
-0.32078832387924194,
-0.4068866968154907,
-0.034662581980228424,
-0.11785775423049927,
1.1828835010528564,
0.6534689664840698,
-0.37967294454574585,
-0.7443948984146118,
-0.8562929630279541,
0.13295432925224304,
-0.24757778644561768,
-0.2622230350971222,
0.3837813138961792,
0.35910317301750183,
-0.31475746631622314,
0.6664538979530334,
-0.6495258212089539,
-0.5624946355819702,
-0.30162447690963745,
0.4428675174713135,
0.20941779017448425,
0.26329880952835083,
0.24870583415031433,
-0.8653378486633301,
-0.048628635704517365,
0.25759410858154297,
-0.5611728429794312,
-0.031030260026454926,
-0.4299100637435913,
0.02577250450849533,
-0.1405918300151825,
0.8147640824317932,
-0.5094808340072632,
0.4187208414077759,
0.16194701194763184,
-0.12634345889091492,
0.08854848891496658,
-0.2931077778339386,
0.29287469387054443,
-1.2302879095077515,
0.36515483260154724,
-0.004012501332908869,
-0.12218111753463745,
-0.6510579586029053,
-0.46076253056526184,
0.4794120490550995,
0.09787221997976303,
-0.8545750975608826,
0.6606945395469666,
-0.4903177320957184,
0.012858117930591106,
-0.09836379438638687,
0.2859804928302765,
0.13227637112140656,
-0.08440161496400833,
0.26145681738853455,
0.7906972765922546,
0.2978483736515045,
-1.059761881828308,
0.5347925424575806,
0.5469271540641785,
-0.2071414738893509,
0.4212052524089813,
-0.7045700550079346,
-0.2780803442001343,
0.03504619747400284,
-0.06978244334459305,
-0.7333625555038452,
-0.26781970262527466,
0.3091214597225189,
-0.3007254898548126,
0.6004617214202881,
0.0496823713183403,
-0.18770132958889008,
-0.5102962851524353,
-0.05238492414355278,
0.24786081910133362,
0.5717911124229431,
-0.7710467576980591,
0.7843468189239502,
0.7558230757713318,
-0.23679088056087494,
-0.6010758280754089,
-0.6859099268913269,
-0.2317042350769043,
-0.5238929390907288,
-0.08489034324884415,
0.883384108543396,
0.3561311364173889,
0.1570923924446106,
-0.027011053636670113,
-0.35888954997062683,
-0.42727816104888916,
0.33285459876060486,
0.24681898951530457,
0.6348749399185181,
-0.11481542140245438,
0.7879425287246704,
0.2543729841709137,
0.001406163559295237,
0.11619845777750015,
0.02308783493936062,
0.047517526894807816,
0.21693485975265503,
0.18293429911136627,
-0.3587629199028015,
-0.10028263181447983,
0.07860273122787476,
-0.29384520649909973,
0.3577304482460022,
0.7839345932006836,
-0.7133566737174988,
-0.13954247534275055,
-0.3094542920589447,
-0.2642839252948761,
-0.45480236411094666,
0.2352185994386673,
-0.23886819183826447,
-0.7231701016426086,
0.44309544563293457,
-0.4297601580619812,
0.05029141530394554,
0.6716122627258301,
0.25266924500465393,
0.011403804644942284,
0.31523966789245605,
0.5816596150398254,
0.02512858435511589,
0.32431352138519287,
-0.09727750718593597,
0.29764342308044434,
-1.1455044746398926,
-0.6836972236633301,
-0.44688963890075684,
-0.474759578704834,
-0.36969080567359924,
-0.17901533842086792,
0.08072569966316223,
-0.15938419103622437,
-0.2951274812221527,
0.7899274230003357,
-0.7389606237411499,
0.2211350053548813,
0.43556565046310425,
0.2521521747112274,
0.22873133420944214,
0.07889717072248459,
-0.1203811913728714,
0.16584239900112152,
-0.26869097352027893,
-0.3007657527923584,
1.1425145864486694,
0.26110655069351196,
0.7602723836898804,
0.021705441176891327,
0.9450787901878357,
0.5278512239456177,
0.6681098937988281,
-0.7132837772369385,
0.45810773968696594,
-0.19559472799301147,
-0.4549178183078766,
0.06510753929615021,
-0.23086902499198914,
-1.2542997598648071,
-0.11728580296039581,
-0.28834325075149536,
-1.0844887495040894,
0.5917203426361084,
0.1482386589050293,
-0.769773006439209,
0.005979929119348526,
-0.7254957556724548,
0.933141827583313,
-0.20249418914318085,
0.09773385524749756,
-0.0017834403552114964,
-0.7458312511444092,
0.3010045289993286,
-0.337778240442276,
0.024008193984627724,
-0.03711434081196785,
-0.26832959055900574,
0.8531978130340576,
-0.1487622708082199,
0.5754497051239014,
0.08673158288002014,
0.18322177231311798,
0.24678070843219757,
-0.08928366750478745,
0.15383341908454895,
0.10306381434202194,
0.3842908442020416,
0.0678815022110939,
-0.17199668288230896,
-0.0006318605155684054,
-0.2465861588716507,
0.6576286554336548,
-0.2641089856624603,
-0.26830193400382996,
-0.4604341387748718,
-0.21405857801437378,
-0.07823223620653152,
0.3260634243488312,
0.2078959196805954,
0.24017012119293213,
-0.1739347279071808,
0.0636058822274208,
0.9775667190551758,
-0.3937496542930603,
0.4145941436290741,
0.3330741226673126,
-0.03049728088080883,
-0.44595324993133545,
0.9670271873474121,
-0.02059432677924633,
-0.2303464710712433,
0.5577978491783142,
-0.19520604610443115,
-0.21036601066589355,
-0.4727543592453003,
-0.7127017378807068,
0.209538534283638,
-0.5921953916549683,
-0.37261077761650085,
-0.8804487586021423,
-0.3883722424507141,
-0.1205725446343422,
-0.08508779108524323,
-0.13942474126815796,
-0.5406679511070251,
-0.8433167934417725,
-0.37949061393737793,
0.33795931935310364,
0.577812671661377,
0.14846457540988922,
0.3804006576538086,
-1.2016888856887817,
0.45897090435028076,
0.2459281086921692,
0.1865117847919464,
-0.4043341279029846,
-0.5913709402084351,
-0.061742138117551804,
-0.4011785089969635,
-0.49084705114364624,
-1.0545470714569092,
0.24514003098011017,
0.29977479577064514,
0.7161351442337036,
0.3227309584617615,
0.24345707893371582,
0.5693897008895874,
-0.39447787404060364,
0.7155156135559082,
0.2713842988014221,
-0.8918896317481995,
0.7325249314308167,
0.39917460083961487,
0.01046715583652258,
0.39112403988838196,
0.5754970908164978,
-0.28105267882347107,
0.2029443085193634,
-0.8302948474884033,
-1.1939953565597534,
0.4732353985309601,
-0.17259915173053741,
-0.04185120016336441,
-0.025833772495388985,
0.203281432390213,
0.18867571651935577,
0.37630465626716614,
-0.3248138427734375,
-0.17513851821422577,
0.23921844363212585,
-0.4511990249156952,
0.10575520992279053,
-0.06474250555038452,
-0.13140709698200226,
-0.22688573598861694,
0.823754608631134,
0.190683513879776,
0.3325091004371643,
0.522045373916626,
-0.5213990807533264,
0.3743264973163605,
0.1799328625202179,
0.8322138786315918,
0.2846549451351166,
-0.2150866687297821,
0.2066057324409485,
0.15194736421108246,
-0.8284493684768677,
0.08072813600301743,
0.8631309866905212,
-0.019829485565423965,
0.22858573496341705,
0.12707246840000153,
0.5057026743888855,
0.14476782083511353,
-0.7371279001235962,
0.39264607429504395,
-0.2630937397480011,
-0.3408840298652649,
-0.22538542747497559,
-0.13680867850780487,
-0.06584924459457397,
0.43171265721321106,
0.29812365770339966,
0.147768035531044,
0.827245831489563,
-0.22694319486618042,
0.7176283597946167,
0.1399153769016266,
-0.693358838558197,
-0.13341017067432404,
0.9431594014167786,
0.45505306124687195,
-0.053596511483192444,
0.6746494770050049,
-0.20855174958705902,
-0.2320110946893692,
0.8031373023986816,
0.21468374133110046,
1.0792053937911987,
-0.3299575448036194,
0.44102391600608826,
0.42851588129997253,
0.32883188128471375,
-0.23025375604629517,
0.30786436796188354,
-0.027228528633713722,
-0.4257470667362213,
-0.18482787907123566,
-0.2943146526813507,
-0.09639836102724075,
0.17974665760993958,
-0.5090892910957336,
0.5121338963508606,
-0.4938318133354187,
-0.4848260283470154,
0.38285234570503235,
-0.44119757413864136,
-0.61292964220047,
0.0915452390909195,
0.0692879855632782,
0.6216585040092468,
-0.9049095511436462,
0.5989826321601868,
0.8810715079307556,
-0.46706604957580566,
-0.7270809412002563,
-0.21732160449028015,
-0.15686379373073578,
-0.5260630249977112,
0.8470404744148254,
0.38053566217422485,
0.38235804438591003,
-0.18397757411003113,
0.02650666981935501,
-0.6933725476264954,
1.2494252920150757,
0.13519182801246643,
-0.39310383796691895,
0.09570613503456116,
-0.32575035095214844,
0.3454122841358185,
-0.42868444323539734,
0.10140175372362137,
0.7261173725128174,
0.1778630167245865,
0.26391181349754333,
-1.2036781311035156,
0.29853788018226624,
0.011233934201300144,
-0.3844492435455322,
0.6011590957641602,
-0.14785325527191162,
0.619343638420105,
-0.6233228445053101,
-0.14549832046031952,
-0.0586344376206398,
0.6924811005592346,
0.05837012454867363,
0.7846866846084595,
0.18545299768447876,
0.31348320841789246,
1.0041437149047852,
-0.15707074105739594,
0.6266716718673706,
-0.07546026259660721,
0.3736540675163269,
1.0882313251495361,
-0.29582443833351135,
0.7593305110931396,
0.3865114748477936,
-0.009757410734891891,
0.3888315260410309,
0.8444883823394775,
-0.293639600276947,
0.6546160578727722,
0.1759008765220642,
-0.409273236989975,
0.16353480517864227,
-0.2340034544467926,
-0.23822219669818878,
0.2500138282775879,
0.5692358016967773,
-1.1193687915802002,
-0.06710074841976166,
0.3584814667701721,
-0.09454093873500824,
-0.3673367202281952,
-0.3308390974998474,
1.0510525703430176,
0.007167276926338673,
-0.3803621828556061,
0.5161474347114563,
-0.23192495107650757,
0.15174604952335358,
-0.1710852086544037,
-0.30194759368896484,
0.10463595390319824,
0.41242825984954834,
-0.3959956467151642,
-0.4840755760669708,
0.3267255127429962,
-0.2840953469276428,
0.11569006741046906,
0.10469107329845428,
0.8741890788078308,
-0.3748934864997864,
-0.44437524676322937,
0.0996355339884758,
0.18202157318592072,
0.18703272938728333,
0.23035797476768494,
-0.48174822330474854,
-0.14080668985843658,
0.01682841032743454,
0.004775393754243851,
0.025263693183660507,
0.18873152136802673,
-0.04312149062752724,
0.5935947895050049,
0.2237144112586975,
0.15383827686309814,
-0.10885081440210342,
-0.14101029932498932,
0.676149845123291,
-0.45995032787323,
-0.33754321932792664,
-0.6449518203735352,
0.5408832430839539,
-0.4195832908153534,
-0.2995312809944153,
0.25990062952041626,
0.683588981628418,
0.8153213858604431,
-0.25952014327049255,
0.7131789922714233,
-0.18115131556987762,
0.43247005343437195,
-0.42795029282569885,
0.5415561199188232,
-0.3829161524772644,
0.4839271008968353,
-0.012888431549072266,
-0.7456622123718262,
-0.5328516364097595,
0.5800340175628662,
-0.01890978217124939,
-0.06893118470907211,
0.7713983058929443,
0.41127777099609375,
-0.2445116937160492,
0.03834136202931404,
0.08496099710464478,
0.0058954316191375256,
0.14954765141010284,
0.44145408272743225,
0.2794989049434662,
-0.5691235661506653,
0.4858395457267761,
-0.26204636693000793,
-0.18057376146316528,
-0.4102252423763275,
-0.7218565344810486,
-0.8456849455833435,
-0.503301739692688,
-0.7345005869865417,
-0.2940405607223511,
-0.013675874099135399,
0.9478536248207092,
0.6997745633125305,
-0.848363995552063,
0.1360262781381607,
0.07634758949279785,
0.1778010129928589,
-0.3470394015312195,
-0.19066977500915527,
0.6444221138954163,
-0.10955190658569336,
-0.3880692422389984,
0.28227490186691284,
0.28527000546455383,
0.12249639630317688,
0.21970105171203613,
0.3287658989429474,
-0.06959746778011322,
-0.1788652241230011,
0.5901333093643188,
0.625789999961853,
-0.5776382684707642,
-0.33314841985702515,
0.06915829330682755,
0.1411956250667572,
0.020228341221809387,
0.8790527582168579,
-1.0330232381820679,
0.5441407561302185,
0.5448600649833679,
0.8985927700996399,
0.27990832924842834,
0.040900442749261856,
0.3473799526691437,
-0.7696366310119629,
-0.04219711199402809,
0.16308654844760895,
0.3792419731616974,
0.3370445966720581,
-0.375372976064682,
0.49163496494293213,
0.15948569774627686,
-0.648027241230011,
-0.713355302810669,
0.09470284730195999,
-1.1172407865524292,
-0.22483552992343903,
0.9905996322631836,
-0.16716107726097107,
-0.20925699174404144,
-0.3776707351207733,
-0.32289639115333557,
0.30395179986953735,
-0.4713107943534851,
0.8110348582267761,
0.23169612884521484,
-0.3868953585624695,
-0.3214170038700104,
-0.6354318261146545,
0.45563021302223206,
-0.27959245443344116,
-0.9089756011962891,
-0.25752997398376465,
0.2610616981983185,
0.29606860876083374,
0.3338485658168793,
0.3573096692562103,
-0.12852877378463745,
0.34550827741622925,
-0.38710132241249084,
0.3208497166633606,
0.02153455838561058,
-0.4581342935562134,
-0.17328789830207825,
0.11873065680265427,
0.032225050032138824,
-0.8317471146583557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05279v1
|
SuperPos-Prompt: Enhancing Soft Prompt Tuning of Language Models with Superposition of Multi Token Embeddings
| 2024-06-07T22:18:49 | 2024-06-07T22:18:49 |
MohammadAli SadraeiJavaeri, Ehsaneddin Asgari, Alice Carolyn McHardy, Hamid Reza Rabiee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Soft prompt tuning techniques have recently gained traction as an effective
strategy for the parameter-efficient tuning of pretrained language models,
particularly minimizing the required adjustment of model parameters. Despite
their growing use, achieving optimal tuning with soft prompts, especially for
smaller datasets, remains a substantial challenge. This study makes two
contributions in this domain: (i) we introduce SuperPos-Prompt, a new
reparameterization technique employing the superposition of multiple pretrained
vocabulary embeddings to improve the learning of soft prompts. Our experiments
across several GLUE and SuperGLUE benchmarks consistently highlight
SuperPos-Prompt's superiority over Residual Prompt tuning, exhibiting an
average score increase of $+6.4$ in T5-Small and $+5.0$ in T5-Base along with a
faster convergence. Remarkably, SuperPos-Prompt occasionally outperforms even
full fine-tuning methods. (ii) Additionally, we demonstrate enhanced
performance and rapid convergence by omitting dropouts from the frozen network,
yielding consistent improvements across various scenarios and tuning methods.
|
[
-0.3387567400932312,
-0.6199487447738647,
0.3033536672592163,
0.1554463505744934,
-0.45278170704841614,
0.10841860622167587,
-0.37646952271461487,
0.05576380342245102,
0.3911473751068115,
0.11521993577480316,
-0.8267371654510498,
-0.3048352301120758,
-0.2606652081012726,
0.3812677264213562,
0.04305550828576088,
1.0554659366607666,
0.24216918647289276,
0.20135188102722168,
-0.001904408331029117,
-0.14883919060230255,
-0.6967365145683289,
-0.3902738392353058,
-0.6066424250602722,
0.003661634400486946,
0.7307300567626953,
0.7402280569076538,
0.6412859559059143,
0.691012978553772,
0.07331358641386032,
0.2673875093460083,
-0.19343909621238708,
0.4751419425010681,
-0.27944502234458923,
0.34585997462272644,
-0.10565109550952911,
-0.40766623616218567,
-0.06234664469957352,
0.06336229294538498,
0.6217930912971497,
0.37440985441207886,
-0.27365341782569885,
0.15156453847885132,
0.08350083976984024,
0.4392665922641754,
-0.7364912033081055,
-0.02702810801565647,
-0.5767896175384521,
-0.049117669463157654,
-0.17361731827259064,
-0.3305555582046509,
-0.49943166971206665,
-0.41920775175094604,
0.0745750218629837,
-0.872743546962738,
0.5140047669410706,
0.22627586126327515,
0.7782570719718933,
0.08235002309083939,
0.008407245390117168,
-0.03025067038834095,
-0.2022920548915863,
0.7879138588905334,
-0.47700196504592896,
0.43674060702323914,
0.020252658054232597,
0.23252663016319275,
-0.39096999168395996,
-0.7038812637329102,
-0.3835715353488922,
-0.44804447889328003,
0.2448449730873108,
0.04297342523932457,
0.061645351350307465,
-0.062477823346853256,
0.23148877918720245,
0.11038953810930252,
-0.33946847915649414,
0.2488691210746765,
0.22774291038513184,
-0.533457338809967,
0.17621521651744843,
0.2006395012140274,
0.29519763588905334,
0.035256508737802505,
-0.3468765318393707,
-0.19896958768367767,
-0.8622671365737915,
-0.25678062438964844,
0.3812427520751953,
0.8676211833953857,
0.09225191920995712,
0.29324501752853394,
-0.009577581658959389,
0.7307803630828857,
0.1182304322719574,
-0.006091041956096888,
0.24306921660900116,
-0.6148950457572937,
0.1217166930437088,
0.04750768840312958,
0.6116161346435547,
0.3554907441139221,
0.46318113803863525,
0.027064455673098564,
-0.11119934916496277,
-0.04440459609031677,
-0.19311395287513733,
-0.7058660984039307,
-0.07664935290813446,
-0.11900611966848373,
-0.30650603771209717,
-0.09294146299362183,
-0.12344582378864288,
-0.5616470575332642,
-0.4963456094264984,
-0.3753483295440674,
0.28919777274131775,
-0.5743798017501831,
-0.37875431776046753,
0.15517784655094147,
-0.3198445439338684,
-0.01250735204666853,
0.3274882137775421,
-1.0629072189331055,
0.03835473954677582,
0.7951580286026001,
0.901844322681427,
0.2091490924358368,
-0.5947835445404053,
-0.9843055009841919,
-0.15723960101604462,
-0.5128040909767151,
0.9816995859146118,
-0.7927157878875732,
-0.34922802448272705,
0.03762643039226532,
-0.06179163604974747,
-0.11806963384151459,
-0.45919501781463623,
0.3456226587295532,
-0.3305133879184723,
0.2017390877008438,
-0.44247785210609436,
-0.5493561029434204,
0.20361098647117615,
0.013280232436954975,
-0.4474295675754547,
1.1812822818756104,
0.1417161524295807,
-0.44455984234809875,
0.5478588342666626,
-0.15188567340373993,
-0.3823297619819641,
0.049509163945913315,
-0.10356307029724121,
-0.21980281174182892,
0.5126723647117615,
0.273333877325058,
0.3457946181297302,
-0.44767889380455017,
0.028965992853045464,
-0.1839912384748459,
-0.4054967761039734,
0.15369199216365814,
-0.36866867542266846,
0.4454415738582611,
0.015011286363005638,
-0.18942861258983612,
0.3233075439929962,
-0.7936175465583801,
0.028816871345043182,
-0.0312655009329319,
-0.14965985715389252,
-0.42353278398513794,
-0.5273128747940063,
0.1281920224428177,
-0.04161302372813225,
0.14903312921524048,
-0.5136467814445496,
0.5084190964698792,
-0.543681263923645,
0.4422987103462219,
0.9468694925308228,
-0.20864927768707275,
0.2562737762928009,
-0.09467979520559311,
0.7459518909454346,
-0.05888606235384941,
0.2822657823562622,
-0.678081750869751,
-0.5115653872489929,
-0.47892889380455017,
-0.3755189776420593,
0.9014550447463989,
0.5306722521781921,
-0.9537666440010071,
0.45615941286087036,
0.060998860746622086,
-0.48604562878608704,
-0.686962366104126,
0.024437950924038887,
0.6216868758201599,
0.7033277750015259,
0.5493819117546082,
-0.06217220425605774,
-0.5126983523368835,
-0.6653901934623718,
-0.4845215082168579,
0.08099672198295593,
-0.09955808520317078,
0.473361611366272,
0.1568281501531601,
0.2120114266872406,
0.903466522693634,
-0.36751696467399597,
-0.2431253045797348,
-0.37298136949539185,
0.16040296852588654,
0.4557126462459564,
0.5757301449775696,
0.5533446073532104,
-0.5058403015136719,
-0.5832337141036987,
-0.3902930021286011,
-0.06429226696491241,
-0.3690394163131714,
-0.0679599940776825,
0.1865987330675125,
0.2594715356826782,
0.8817335367202759,
-0.7367231845855713,
0.006211479660123587,
0.37371817231178284,
-0.5213362574577332,
1.1567416191101074,
-0.4596691429615021,
0.0807516872882843,
-0.976689875125885,
-0.15118062496185303,
-0.11085560917854309,
-0.0037740690167993307,
-0.5409079194068909,
0.12480480968952179,
0.23715023696422577,
-0.09579821676015854,
-0.7472378015518188,
0.512525200843811,
-0.5089064836502075,
0.33761852979660034,
-0.15923558175563812,
0.2535311281681061,
0.08167432993650436,
0.17865540087223053,
-0.20229531824588776,
1.0761830806732178,
0.9139490127563477,
-0.4954372048377991,
0.23447923362255096,
0.003261317266151309,
-0.3012036383152008,
0.4575308561325073,
-0.869767427444458,
0.36147746443748474,
-0.17118491232395172,
0.4333266317844391,
-1.3018747568130493,
0.07902663946151733,
0.3951098322868347,
-0.2906148433685303,
0.3516377806663513,
-0.303190678358078,
-0.7044150233268738,
0.01593570038676262,
-0.48329076170921326,
0.5354009866714478,
0.25733575224876404,
-0.5553104281425476,
0.7166435122489929,
-0.14903056621551514,
-0.1240941509604454,
-0.5607019066810608,
-0.4648095667362213,
0.12557588517665863,
-0.1344357579946518,
-0.2566623091697693,
0.43915462493896484,
-0.08366483449935913,
0.3293621838092804,
-0.24618980288505554,
-0.05808704346418381,
0.6114825010299683,
0.08917294442653656,
-0.14219671487808228,
0.18686708807945251,
-0.4198002815246582,
0.2898608446121216,
0.22041812539100647,
-0.7840834259986877,
-0.39741426706314087,
-0.5436657071113586,
0.7848658561706543,
-0.14480970799922943,
-0.19433027505874634,
-0.5410335659980774,
0.3968627154827118,
0.46558210253715515,
-0.14728640019893646,
0.9751197695732117,
0.6032530069351196,
-0.17056645452976227,
-0.01355902012437582,
-0.6347795724868774,
-0.3627890944480896,
-0.5239059329032898,
0.030111325904726982,
-0.6010106205940247,
-1.0106043815612793,
0.5820191502571106,
-0.244070902466774,
0.08472522348165512,
0.20968107879161835,
0.31816166639328003,
0.18781577050685883,
1.3193755149841309,
0.5782725214958191,
-0.055060312151908875,
0.8206776976585388,
0.0685592070221901,
-0.18289418518543243,
-0.8410301804542542,
-0.12401202321052551,
-0.8410916328430176,
-0.23259837925434113,
-0.6366629600524902,
-0.2174854576587677,
0.24335582554340363,
0.16331619024276733,
-0.12256326526403427,
0.41908133029937744,
-0.3543206453323364,
0.6965448260307312,
0.5963338017463684,
-0.01907656528055668,
0.009628476575016975,
-0.11308944970369339,
-0.5806764364242554,
-0.19623500108718872,
-1.058695912361145,
-0.23092564940452576,
0.8203588128089905,
0.1325223743915558,
0.5977631211280823,
-0.09452096372842789,
0.5206684470176697,
-0.10570651292800903,
0.16506431996822357,
-0.6228331327438354,
0.6892854571342468,
-0.4503490626811981,
-0.2915646433830261,
-0.32303106784820557,
-0.4822157323360443,
-1.0494521856307983,
0.27260300517082214,
-0.3236108422279358,
-0.5190290212631226,
0.3342890441417694,
0.468610018491745,
-0.826338529586792,
-0.12864427268505096,
-0.9667184948921204,
0.7946289777755737,
0.16803860664367676,
-0.19874130189418793,
-0.17261050641536713,
-0.5239508152008057,
-0.303313285112381,
0.24323436617851257,
0.14823906123638153,
-0.28197357058525085,
-0.4868376851081848,
0.6489747762680054,
-0.5582757592201233,
0.735984206199646,
-0.3610987365245819,
-0.21280792355537415,
0.03856636956334114,
0.07545448839664459,
0.6671229600906372,
0.2993590235710144,
-0.1613260805606842,
0.07043024152517319,
-0.16468624770641327,
-0.3338603377342224,
-0.8614180684089661,
0.6302433609962463,
-0.39496806263923645,
-0.6044187545776367,
-0.15204504132270813,
-0.3472630977630615,
-0.3291495740413666,
0.36395877599716187,
0.44498133659362793,
1.0349456071853638,
0.26125308871269226,
0.14289450645446777,
0.7182971239089966,
-0.3770039677619934,
0.44431835412979126,
0.7593109011650085,
-0.1512683779001236,
-0.509143054485321,
1.0597366094589233,
0.2803522050380707,
0.07280714064836502,
0.27552616596221924,
0.7234736680984497,
-0.5348312258720398,
-0.4122099280357361,
-0.698138415813446,
0.28815752267837524,
-0.30681705474853516,
-0.5130186080932617,
-0.23636656999588013,
0.23444658517837524,
-0.5924871563911438,
0.030815808102488518,
-0.512570321559906,
-0.4517175257205963,
-0.659476637840271,
-0.06114786118268967,
0.5842733383178711,
0.16971446573734283,
-0.24071383476257324,
0.37111449241638184,
-0.8662216663360596,
0.2650936245918274,
0.2311585396528244,
0.5542023181915283,
-0.12205353379249573,
-0.6413638591766357,
-0.15217585861682892,
-0.18295225501060486,
0.23999744653701782,
-0.7174214720726013,
-0.04767351597547531,
0.5424676537513733,
0.5271762609481812,
0.36294567584991455,
-0.0008272257982753217,
0.8349210619926453,
-0.7858730554580688,
0.8567869067192078,
0.3343755304813385,
-0.9675791263580322,
0.6982424855232239,
-0.3085865080356598,
0.5159621238708496,
0.8385158181190491,
0.2671208381652832,
-0.4787018597126007,
-0.3475840389728546,
-0.6544952988624573,
-1.0821658372879028,
0.5756295323371887,
-0.18704503774642944,
0.5064852833747864,
-0.32324284315109253,
0.5686524510383606,
0.39804840087890625,
0.1703973114490509,
0.12730292975902557,
-0.5542097687721252,
-0.16325300931930542,
-0.13676446676254272,
-0.22845368087291718,
-0.403176486492157,
0.06468929350376129,
-0.26603808999061584,
0.4987603724002838,
-0.3206578493118286,
0.0028904846403747797,
0.13654722273349762,
0.05108179524540901,
-0.01353693101555109,
0.09993858635425568,
0.8251897096633911,
0.5845832824707031,
0.1410967856645584,
0.17890696227550507,
0.3218485414981842,
-0.516501247882843,
0.17727051675319672,
0.09010032564401627,
-0.15557946264743805,
0.21053361892700195,
0.24714651703834534,
0.8557733297348022,
0.42548978328704834,
-0.43475618958473206,
0.3137015104293823,
-0.3872932493686676,
-0.11809877306222916,
0.3681316375732422,
0.36280083656311035,
-0.18399040400981903,
0.19583916664123535,
0.4961123764514923,
0.15174080431461334,
-0.08528553694486618,
-0.33703771233558655,
0.22223196923732758,
0.284902423620224,
-0.382184773683548,
-0.2742176651954651,
0.4693501591682434,
0.19647720456123352,
-0.7441876530647278,
0.5774500966072083,
-0.07997163385152817,
-0.32383644580841064,
0.4604380428791046,
0.7786376476287842,
0.8790808916091919,
-0.4771341383457184,
0.3163706958293915,
0.09475132822990417,
0.186436265707016,
-0.23644395172595978,
0.586860716342926,
-0.07171966880559921,
-0.7472465634346008,
-0.5936175584793091,
-0.30141693353652954,
-0.438651978969574,
0.026334919035434723,
-0.6873880624771118,
0.2941497564315796,
-0.5848183035850525,
-0.3651173710823059,
-0.20121584832668304,
-0.1726183146238327,
-0.4189651608467102,
0.06387806683778763,
-0.09360742568969727,
1.49648118019104,
-0.922749936580658,
0.4721834361553192,
0.7980286478996277,
-0.0836135521531105,
-0.9236456155776978,
0.03305426985025406,
-0.21272088587284088,
-0.6880385875701904,
0.06306558102369308,
0.3905009925365448,
-0.3191927373409271,
0.49832433462142944,
-0.49784210324287415,
-0.8538164496421814,
0.5067703723907471,
0.8393494486808777,
-0.6976969242095947,
0.46993333101272583,
-0.28572896122932434,
0.5634203553199768,
-0.29987484216690063,
0.5446745157241821,
0.7279320359230042,
0.3703971803188324,
-0.054298847913742065,
-0.8499587178230286,
0.2907178997993469,
-0.1969093680381775,
0.0206393301486969,
0.13595236837863922,
-0.937333881855011,
0.5684540271759033,
-0.1311357319355011,
-0.37129858136177063,
0.15250837802886963,
0.8953742384910583,
0.7865917682647705,
-0.01707582175731659,
0.7791972756385803,
0.37074530124664307,
0.7558484673500061,
-0.13317710161209106,
0.7831934690475464,
-0.46308621764183044,
0.17521865665912628,
0.9543382525444031,
-0.08296339213848114,
0.5947191119194031,
0.6270860433578491,
0.0914255678653717,
0.6884719133377075,
0.6703487634658813,
0.2114681601524353,
0.6559725403785706,
0.18228541314601898,
-0.09662877768278122,
-0.4814404249191284,
-0.5757694840431213,
-0.8290129899978638,
0.17693671584129333,
0.42305293679237366,
0.028555892407894135,
-0.14036038517951965,
0.24945519864559174,
-0.08343783020973206,
-0.15552949905395508,
-0.21798433363437653,
0.6026723384857178,
0.07396230846643448,
-0.6894470453262329,
0.5327571034431458,
-0.07038649171590805,
0.6348512172698975,
-0.6463398933410645,
-0.09428955614566803,
-0.4843180775642395,
-0.06968092173337936,
0.09181719273328781,
-0.5170267820358276,
-0.15483646094799042,
-0.25851404666900635,
-0.021377386525273323,
-0.535031259059906,
0.6821874976158142,
-0.23635299503803253,
-0.25190219283103943,
-0.04384578764438629,
0.30160170793533325,
-0.024950306862592697,
0.006111058406531811,
-0.8862128257751465,
0.09917080402374268,
-0.44256046414375305,
-0.5362128019332886,
0.31522637605667114,
0.6308157444000244,
0.16623644530773163,
0.661490797996521,
0.8530359268188477,
0.12457294762134552,
-0.21755607426166534,
0.812227189540863,
1.0017280578613281,
-0.6733224391937256,
-0.918196976184845,
-1.0593584775924683,
0.45923808217048645,
0.21648608148097992,
-0.8732221126556396,
0.9082455635070801,
0.4692709445953369,
0.43037131428718567,
-0.1353558450937271,
0.42985019087791443,
0.12709054350852966,
0.49026188254356384,
-0.8253193497657776,
0.2622024416923523,
-0.5908917784690857,
0.19385139644145966,
-0.36311498284339905,
-0.7833998799324036,
-0.4859073758125305,
0.38090649247169495,
0.029987964779138565,
0.1335180699825287,
0.5335903167724609,
1.1440510749816895,
0.08196963369846344,
0.04658234864473343,
0.046947263181209564,
-0.0851704478263855,
0.03894898295402527,
0.2199423611164093,
1.1733334064483643,
-0.353091835975647,
0.5429474115371704,
0.13271977007389069,
-0.4702818989753723,
-0.5190339088439941,
-1.1786682605743408,
-0.6733425259590149,
-0.33413439989089966,
-0.3830896317958832,
-0.35330817103385925,
0.11614131182432175,
1.0149521827697754,
0.8098819255828857,
-1.0508071184158325,
0.19938595592975616,
-0.23554562032222748,
0.3239389955997467,
-0.5359007120132446,
-0.1763821393251419,
0.4917846918106079,
-0.5567510724067688,
-0.4868079125881195,
0.7586963176727295,
0.3852633833885193,
-0.0002800173533614725,
-0.2795649766921997,
0.10293073207139969,
-0.04825764521956444,
0.15109482407569885,
0.34587278962135315,
0.1937619149684906,
-0.3542548418045044,
-0.4046550393104553,
0.25990357995033264,
0.041150785982608795,
-0.24221952259540558,
1.1360301971435547,
-0.9479503631591797,
0.29906612634658813,
0.6833586096763611,
0.37206509709358215,
0.05165783315896988,
0.04598657786846161,
0.6505396366119385,
-1.1378567218780518,
0.17480003833770752,
-0.06500443071126938,
0.250573992729187,
0.16261166334152222,
-0.31402090191841125,
0.16966286301612854,
0.46918895840644836,
-0.31808120012283325,
-1.0216236114501953,
0.3011661767959595,
-0.46518322825431824,
-0.3527173101902008,
1.0751289129257202,
-0.07148776948451996,
-0.1769600510597229,
-0.40567079186439514,
-0.5285063982009888,
0.2581290900707245,
-0.5672501921653748,
0.7532740831375122,
0.4738926887512207,
-0.11412162333726883,
-0.22633296251296997,
-0.0008210570667870343,
0.4936974346637726,
0.8798990845680237,
-0.35341089963912964,
0.12444845587015152,
0.2571019232273102,
0.22888797521591187,
0.23195359110832214,
0.4788817763328552,
0.2879885733127594,
0.5313377976417542,
0.04366247355937958,
-0.42387619614601135,
-0.41396674513816833,
-0.7646859288215637,
-0.54463791847229,
0.2853710949420929,
-0.23148731887340546,
-0.396322101354599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05274v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05274v1
|
Behavior Structformer: Learning Players Representations with Structured Tokenization
| 2024-06-07T21:59:55 | 2024-06-07T21:59:55 |
Oleg Smirnov, Labinot Polisi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we introduce the Behavior Structformer, a method for modeling
user behavior using structured tokenization within a Transformer-based
architecture. By converting tracking events into dense tokens, this approach
enhances model training efficiency and effectiveness. We demonstrate its
superior performance through ablation studies and benchmarking against
traditional tabular and semi-structured baselines. The results indicate that
structured tokenization with sequential processing significantly improves
behavior modeling.
|
[
0.2612118124961853,
-0.8180299401283264,
0.18188396096229553,
0.2412206381559372,
-0.013378825969994068,
0.25259506702423096,
0.14794810116291046,
-0.2123585343360901,
0.2724122107028961,
0.07153052091598511,
-0.4083034098148346,
-0.31802552938461304,
-0.24237336218357086,
-0.21047019958496094,
-0.2181803584098816,
1.1469640731811523,
-0.14122125506401062,
0.12684035301208496,
-0.1893029808998108,
0.03994440659880638,
-0.6832227110862732,
-0.7451399564743042,
-1.1996253728866577,
-0.7425684928894043,
0.3141521215438843,
0.07546062767505646,
0.4720980226993561,
0.794336199760437,
0.36989596486091614,
0.5559482574462891,
-0.159779891371727,
-0.1399526447057724,
-0.8905472159385681,
0.18475277721881866,
0.0065718586556613445,
-0.3776373565196991,
-0.4574030935764313,
-0.08687423914670944,
0.7460485696792603,
0.6665626764297485,
-0.7103551626205444,
0.2018495500087738,
-0.2217189222574234,
0.2657046914100647,
0.027128152549266815,
0.4355168640613556,
-0.10534603893756866,
0.3659435212612152,
0.014250384643673897,
-0.22860534489154816,
-0.7036728858947754,
-0.09963054209947586,
-0.26368072628974915,
-0.5681519508361816,
0.2150210589170456,
0.13173829019069672,
0.521162211894989,
0.09271545708179474,
-0.5581104159355164,
0.0060774958692491055,
-1.0697699785232544,
0.4591851532459259,
-0.18398118019104004,
0.6757433414459229,
0.08984927833080292,
0.49974337220191956,
-0.4540601372718811,
-0.9681512117385864,
-0.35725560784339905,
-0.09629116207361221,
-0.4671100974082947,
-0.14229939877986908,
-0.02158310078084469,
0.3082009553909302,
0.6514986157417297,
0.17554634809494019,
-0.43133530020713806,
0.12526673078536987,
-0.6381287574768066,
-0.20503486692905426,
0.7216019630432129,
0.5539597868919373,
0.27940067648887634,
-0.2529803514480591,
-0.45157670974731445,
-0.21149300038814545,
-0.20474845170974731,
0.9790328741073608,
0.44493532180786133,
0.05879277363419533,
-0.18980035185813904,
0.6721343994140625,
-0.09097925573587418,
0.2903197705745697,
0.6522295475006104,
-0.23994027078151703,
0.4849646985530853,
-0.2986733019351959,
-0.39562731981277466,
0.08970307558774948,
0.5310047268867493,
0.16643762588500977,
-0.21910685300827026,
-0.504246711730957,
-0.32911360263824463,
-0.19829966127872467,
0.5926706790924072,
-1.1349806785583496,
-0.46118733286857605,
0.2866967022418976,
-1.0205413103103638,
-0.4098169505596161,
0.4999964237213135,
-0.5905105471611023,
-0.2712381184101105,
-0.2798801064491272,
0.15131202340126038,
-0.6536381840705872,
-0.19699159264564514,
-0.15686959028244019,
-0.43853625655174255,
0.3756723403930664,
0.18694697320461273,
-1.2480896711349487,
0.5838291049003601,
0.7838192582130432,
0.8500062227249146,
-0.523216724395752,
-0.14587487280368805,
-1.0765780210494995,
0.35146862268447876,
-0.28247785568237305,
0.7334417104721069,
-0.7394247055053711,
-0.744929850101471,
-0.014620495960116386,
-0.04935711994767189,
-0.130879208445549,
-0.44042572379112244,
0.18842190504074097,
-0.49957039952278137,
-0.0949966162443161,
0.022493861615657806,
-0.5727741718292236,
0.13810209929943085,
0.39915961027145386,
-0.7633660435676575,
1.415149450302124,
0.12719173729419708,
-0.2633267641067505,
0.7730676531791687,
-0.9449971914291382,
-0.513107419013977,
0.4156430661678314,
-0.20176512002944946,
-0.6553228497505188,
0.5241145491600037,
-0.2676725685596466,
0.3191279470920563,
0.8365958333015442,
0.552057683467865,
0.16150225698947906,
-0.9100835919380188,
0.17533889412879944,
0.17043012380599976,
0.40950047969818115,
-0.022492097690701485,
0.08080200850963593,
0.8147022128105164,
-0.7005612254142761,
-0.37197601795196533,
0.0840427353978157,
-0.9834543466567993,
0.04735906422138214,
0.5674998760223389,
0.17174966633319855,
0.3365651071071625,
0.0626947358250618,
-0.5309037566184998,
0.439264178276062,
-0.46256449818611145,
0.4615737795829773,
0.7491744756698608,
-0.05769549682736397,
0.7888967394828796,
-0.3847903907299042,
0.46292564272880554,
0.35672831535339355,
0.32960402965545654,
-0.4006919264793396,
-0.12842106819152832,
-0.33545705676078796,
-0.4732228219509125,
-0.14733947813510895,
0.1935322880744934,
-0.7017446756362915,
0.30642756819725037,
-0.3489621877670288,
-0.5236497521400452,
-0.07802523672580719,
-0.2386433482170105,
0.2263495773077011,
0.4903489351272583,
0.3304479718208313,
-0.14835593104362488,
-0.8608363270759583,
-0.5347796678543091,
-0.2890085279941559,
-0.5344244241714478,
-0.09388835728168488,
0.2918808162212372,
0.5036637783050537,
-0.17521946132183075,
0.694366455078125,
-0.2004126012325287,
-0.23062105476856232,
-0.53130704164505,
0.41857796907424927,
0.15199688076972961,
0.7407099604606628,
0.5614157319068909,
-0.9721795916557312,
-0.27357369661331177,
-0.1064925566315651,
-0.4456343650817871,
0.4457837641239166,
-0.09287919104099274,
0.012069645337760448,
0.1943795084953308,
0.8293474912643433,
-0.36875683069229126,
0.8349645733833313,
0.3547830879688263,
-0.8880131840705872,
0.41095876693725586,
-0.034133508801460266,
0.3456350266933441,
-0.7464977502822876,
0.28411614894866943,
-0.36414211988449097,
-0.41038572788238525,
-1.0508545637130737,
-0.13955886662006378,
-0.25992387533187866,
-0.09864389151334763,
-0.5371161699295044,
0.21762564778327942,
0.0390436127781868,
-0.4473636746406555,
0.0326826386153698,
-0.5485260486602783,
-0.2052706927061081,
0.6545137763023376,
0.25292426347732544,
0.8143015503883362,
0.09769947826862335,
-0.5925573706626892,
0.39313483238220215,
0.6179562211036682,
-0.33943361043930054,
0.6231406927108765,
-1.012895941734314,
0.018700312823057175,
-0.6732758283615112,
0.3271495997905731,
-1.1880637407302856,
-0.22689661383628845,
0.147487074136734,
-0.30091241002082825,
0.33072516322135925,
-0.769250750541687,
-0.34313249588012695,
-0.4238344132900238,
-0.34803736209869385,
0.4284024238586426,
0.42685043811798096,
-0.3359975516796112,
1.1596918106079102,
0.24447166919708252,
0.2567336857318878,
-0.17451010644435883,
-0.46624845266342163,
-0.18568336963653564,
-0.3073413670063019,
-0.38285088539123535,
0.48746320605278015,
-0.41508567333221436,
0.127690389752388,
-0.29418832063674927,
-0.22975419461727142,
0.007229538634419441,
0.3302462697029114,
0.5586115717887878,
0.41550639271736145,
-0.2020636945962906,
0.2582842707633972,
-0.4056612253189087,
-0.033092234283685684,
-0.05366409197449684,
-0.1594279706478119,
0.8701514005661011,
0.05861319601535797,
-0.1916191130876541,
-0.6115812659263611,
0.3000919222831726,
0.1261391043663025,
-0.19700655341148376,
0.9869032502174377,
0.5490374565124512,
-0.24882051348686218,
-0.18326057493686676,
-0.15252827107906342,
-0.16771697998046875,
-0.5542240738868713,
0.5618972182273865,
-0.6057854294776917,
-1.1654739379882812,
0.7012965679168701,
-0.0933607742190361,
-0.019025102257728577,
-0.008837775327265263,
0.40758347511291504,
-0.3899705410003662,
1.3780786991119385,
0.7600736618041992,
0.2614932954311371,
1.2417865991592407,
-0.15140926837921143,
0.10171489417552948,
-0.5768042206764221,
-0.956422746181488,
-0.38889026641845703,
-0.7126443982124329,
-0.4683957099914551,
-0.2999420464038849,
0.25009989738464355,
0.09500350803136826,
-0.7063523530960083,
0.37290361523628235,
-0.3386053740978241,
0.49642542004585266,
0.25739797949790955,
0.17868784070014954,
0.0464559905230999,
-0.03675399720668793,
0.00922509003430605,
-0.14657455682754517,
-0.6468114852905273,
-0.43776702880859375,
0.6730701327323914,
0.5460474491119385,
0.6490822434425354,
0.25141143798828125,
0.6912648677825928,
0.27844271063804626,
0.4126761853694916,
-1.116892695426941,
0.1964825838804245,
0.04403902217745781,
-0.5197703838348389,
-0.5421981811523438,
-0.4733984172344208,
-0.7081553339958191,
0.23025915026664734,
-0.35519886016845703,
-1.0481857061386108,
0.3460080623626709,
0.32058975100517273,
-0.268865704536438,
0.30681174993515015,
-0.3586162328720093,
1.3269778490066528,
-0.12170841544866562,
-0.21012361347675323,
0.03933003172278404,
-0.1951640099287033,
0.23897685110569,
0.293368935585022,
0.04369765892624855,
0.14621536433696747,
0.09087540954351425,
1.0680030584335327,
-0.38606497645378113,
0.8440638184547424,
-0.5940489172935486,
0.31708237528800964,
-0.0869847983121872,
0.4975072145462036,
0.9515634775161743,
0.10506801307201385,
-0.14730210602283478,
0.0031841436866670847,
-0.08067452162504196,
-0.3320292532444,
-0.5388540625572205,
0.10003042966127396,
-0.6340614557266235,
-0.18125906586647034,
-0.17145870625972748,
-0.16776686906814575,
0.00898873433470726,
0.24883407354354858,
-0.07182177156209946,
0.4451811909675598,
-0.7023136019706726,
0.4194020926952362,
0.6498842239379883,
0.14483579993247986,
0.5445165634155273,
0.4783174395561218,
-0.14771424233913422,
-0.15131224691867828,
0.45974770188331604,
-0.12812598049640656,
-0.43477150797843933,
0.4382074773311615,
0.003459386294707656,
-0.20821526646614075,
-0.7987316250801086,
-0.14102065563201904,
0.06770870089530945,
-0.38952183723449707,
-0.3172109127044678,
-0.6368991732597351,
-0.04609902575612068,
-0.19039641320705414,
-0.27946147322654724,
-0.2689370810985565,
0.02476247027516365,
-0.1604224592447281,
-0.7240854501724243,
0.04666896164417267,
0.9588841199874878,
0.26728737354278564,
1.0706076622009277,
-0.48356306552886963,
0.27203983068466187,
0.22638766467571259,
0.9656710624694824,
-0.06958012282848358,
-0.5426580309867859,
-0.41600093245506287,
-0.2556878626346588,
-0.03464224562048912,
-0.6102126836776733,
0.2217010110616684,
0.2670570909976959,
0.7618667483329773,
0.4685843586921692,
-0.46323123574256897,
1.1053003072738647,
-0.8189787268638611,
0.8901708126068115,
0.14228381216526031,
-1.046534538269043,
0.6718655824661255,
-0.22577787935733795,
-0.20462870597839355,
0.6603423357009888,
0.237848699092865,
-0.8424810171127319,
0.2887839376926422,
-0.5687505602836609,
-0.6389858722686768,
1.4322524070739746,
-0.03184410557150841,
0.16683652997016907,
-0.211518794298172,
0.4201853275299072,
-0.1320180743932724,
0.23613455891609192,
-0.5021307468414307,
-0.23727670311927795,
-0.625652015209198,
-0.26473450660705566,
-0.14934879541397095,
-0.5021680593490601,
0.15098953247070312,
-0.21884819865226746,
0.3343100845813751,
-0.16075359284877777,
0.2985303997993469,
0.006452902685850859,
-0.29875606298446655,
-0.42904701828956604,
-0.15718606114387512,
0.4013466238975525,
0.4293020963668823,
-0.15254445374011993,
-0.007186433766037226,
0.21308155357837677,
-0.3178007900714874,
0.22224444150924683,
-0.15031711757183075,
-0.3069206774234772,
-0.27654555439949036,
0.413264662027359,
0.9693268537521362,
0.7633459568023682,
-0.6276686191558838,
0.7666170597076416,
-0.17856651544570923,
-0.31096047163009644,
-0.3578972816467285,
0.27921876311302185,
-0.16405484080314636,
0.4215010404586792,
0.26707398891448975,
0.03521187603473663,
0.39755722880363464,
-0.7503861784934998,
0.4417106509208679,
0.24439576268196106,
-0.5892273187637329,
-0.7876636981964111,
0.9625400900840759,
0.11805061995983124,
-0.5679365396499634,
0.7648605704307556,
-0.02162618190050125,
-0.46184441447257996,
0.5083792805671692,
0.6960108876228333,
0.4370860457420349,
-0.5266197919845581,
0.4768860638141632,
0.553699254989624,
-0.10540084540843964,
-0.34760087728500366,
0.31592071056365967,
-0.4702673852443695,
-0.5405895113945007,
-0.551230251789093,
-0.8396730422973633,
-0.06942807137966156,
-0.15122324228286743,
-0.6017816662788391,
0.20013701915740967,
-0.6593977808952332,
-0.18131417036056519,
0.15205039083957672,
0.04439898580312729,
-0.919474720954895,
-0.19879642128944397,
0.26672497391700745,
1.062437891960144,
-0.9868836998939514,
0.6294100284576416,
1.1499091386795044,
-0.5951529741287231,
-0.8698880672454834,
-0.5953202843666077,
-0.16551928222179413,
-0.64437335729599,
0.9656781554222107,
0.0043279435485601425,
0.16837114095687866,
-0.03646508604288101,
-0.5541367530822754,
-0.7130972743034363,
1.2014819383621216,
-0.1069360002875328,
-0.22341328859329224,
-0.2529871463775635,
0.15991054475307465,
0.6502169966697693,
-0.4463307857513428,
0.40708819031715393,
0.7068578600883484,
0.5239464044570923,
0.5494861006736755,
-0.5778289437294006,
-0.03763938695192337,
-0.31396719813346863,
0.3645349442958832,
0.14627820253372192,
-0.6012994647026062,
0.7294830679893494,
0.3178752660751343,
-0.4049680531024933,
-0.21164831519126892,
0.8966725468635559,
0.13950717449188232,
0.23080934584140778,
0.5896276235580444,
0.23933503031730652,
0.9450044631958008,
-0.12387222051620483,
0.693165123462677,
0.08147619664669037,
0.08138608187437057,
0.8554107546806335,
-0.36037856340408325,
0.7598724961280823,
0.5972434878349304,
-0.19117538630962372,
1.0158054828643799,
0.25511637330055237,
-0.25078490376472473,
0.2502274811267853,
0.3399355411529541,
0.28510987758636475,
-0.4464782774448395,
0.09259340167045593,
0.4123108386993408,
0.8566068410873413,
0.3460594713687897,
-0.14921818673610687,
-0.09651383757591248,
-0.0036756624467670918,
-0.02515326254069805,
0.17022284865379333,
-0.42067331075668335,
1.4053833484649658,
-0.474362850189209,
-0.5776473879814148,
-0.19542419910430908,
0.2710583806037903,
0.6555562019348145,
-0.7068756818771362,
-0.2086935192346573,
-0.42594873905181885,
-0.0394352450966835,
-0.5026042461395264,
-0.47006720304489136,
0.5950908064842224,
-0.044903650879859924,
-0.3318936824798584,
-0.47925108671188354,
0.5997830629348755,
-0.41459402441978455,
-0.22785964608192444,
0.04871436208486557,
0.19422277808189392,
0.19835396111011505,
0.22722873091697693,
-0.3632138669490814,
0.24989230930805206,
-0.34607362747192383,
-0.4787868559360504,
0.11422877758741379,
0.2773100733757019,
-0.37819573283195496,
0.5044059157371521,
0.7301490306854248,
-0.025495870038866997,
0.022316118702292442,
0.007416173815727234,
0.8827924728393555,
-0.9060083031654358,
-0.7949015498161316,
-0.846043050289154,
0.8955190777778625,
-0.3241522014141083,
-0.005884653888642788,
0.5118104815483093,
1.0298651456832886,
0.809426486492157,
-0.05789005383849144,
0.3346848785877228,
-0.10817906260490417,
0.09280623495578766,
-0.26184478402137756,
0.46997302770614624,
0.03966206684708595,
0.03794729709625244,
0.2777285873889923,
-0.6780107021331787,
-0.19207067787647247,
0.7021450996398926,
-0.12645822763442993,
0.034439004957675934,
0.16136741638183594,
0.36106106638908386,
-0.3503985106945038,
-0.2173614650964737,
0.30717870593070984,
0.23001153767108917,
0.7501728534698486,
0.28731635212898254,
0.8377068638801575,
-0.4727068245410919,
0.5410737991333008,
0.08197072148323059,
-0.20182044804096222,
-0.6054128408432007,
-0.7216408252716064,
-1.3156518936157227,
-0.4380973279476166,
-0.18604795634746552,
-0.18641242384910583,
-0.027498407289385796,
1.0795842409133911,
1.0985602140426636,
-1.052005410194397,
-0.29317009449005127,
0.09646768867969513,
0.12203652411699295,
-0.4874897599220276,
-0.2531564235687256,
0.28821516036987305,
-0.49596157670021057,
-0.5299827456474304,
0.5980284214019775,
0.06671968847513199,
0.18683688342571259,
0.08064866065979004,
-0.3390597403049469,
0.16405820846557617,
0.1364281326532364,
0.7762183547019958,
0.3139718770980835,
-0.12990762293338776,
-0.6910937428474426,
-0.007503030356019735,
0.06031106412410736,
0.30767878890037537,
1.1266828775405884,
-1.050110101699829,
0.15868420898914337,
0.6214801669120789,
0.06370600312948227,
0.898249089717865,
0.6485393643379211,
0.37355658411979675,
-1.1463807821273804,
0.1766478568315506,
0.16336534917354584,
0.38813239336013794,
0.07128913700580597,
-0.4701901078224182,
0.2896416187286377,
0.2587706446647644,
-0.24250760674476624,
-0.8485764861106873,
0.19694994390010834,
-0.8997849822044373,
-0.09234382957220078,
0.6536417007446289,
0.043638940900564194,
-0.6108039617538452,
-0.3080286681652069,
-0.24313884973526,
0.28931501507759094,
-0.614545464515686,
0.8138355612754822,
0.24015425145626068,
-0.27097266912460327,
-0.1803475171327591,
-0.05847333371639252,
0.8587563037872314,
-0.365520715713501,
-0.4888956546783447,
0.009787200950086117,
0.5171309113502502,
0.3257901072502136,
-0.026098569855093956,
0.7673914432525635,
-0.14871416985988617,
0.23411771655082703,
0.1302361935377121,
0.03843947499990463,
-0.8284030556678772,
-0.355906218290329,
-0.3815850019454956,
0.3392312824726105,
-0.1691606342792511,
0.044453129172325134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05265v1
|
TLEX: An Efficient Method for Extracting Exact Timelines from TimeML Temporal Graphs
| 2024-06-07T21:20:32 | 2024-06-07T21:20:32 |
Mustafa Ocal, Ning Xie, Mark Finlayson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
A timeline provides a total ordering of events and times, and is useful for a
number of natural language understanding tasks. However, qualitative temporal
graphs that can be derived directly from text -- such as TimeML annotations --
usually explicitly reveal only partial orderings of events and times. In this
work, we apply prior work on solving point algebra problems to the task of
extracting timelines from TimeML annotated texts, and develop an exact,
end-to-end solution which we call TLEX (TimeLine EXtraction). TLEX transforms
TimeML annotations into a collection of timelines arranged in a
trunk-and-branch structure. Like what has been done in prior work, TLEX checks
the consistency of the temporal graph and solves it; however, it adds two novel
functionalities. First, it identifies specific relations involved in an
inconsistency (which could then be manually corrected) and, second, TLEX
performs a novel identification of sections of the timelines that have
indeterminate order, information critical for downstream tasks such as aligning
events from different timelines. We provide detailed descriptions and analysis
of the algorithmic components in TLEX, and conduct experimental evaluations by
applying TLEX to 385 TimeML annotated texts from four corpora. We show that 123
of the texts are inconsistent, 181 of them have more than one ``real world'' or
main timeline, and there are 2,541 indeterminate sections across all four
corpora. A sampling evaluation showed that TLEX is 98--100% accurate with 95%
confidence along five dimensions: the ordering of time-points, the number of
main timelines, the placement of time-points on main versus subordinate
timelines, the connecting point of branch timelines, and the location of the
indeterminate sections. We provide a reference implementation of TLEX, the
extracted timelines for all texts, and the manual corrections of the
inconsistent texts.
|
[
0.21802464127540588,
-1.1186892986297607,
0.9880468845367432,
0.5215814113616943,
0.05676401033997536,
0.4264224171638489,
0.05280281603336334,
-0.5153080821037292,
-0.058152757585048676,
0.08316389471292496,
-0.6033489108085632,
-0.8055994510650635,
-0.5907501578330994,
0.09556169807910919,
-0.6698194146156311,
0.6222137808799744,
-0.3789650797843933,
-0.4053184986114502,
0.35996901988983154,
-0.08291973918676376,
-0.10495936125516891,
-0.23939648270606995,
-0.7752110362052917,
-0.26932257413864136,
0.48466289043426514,
0.23718582093715668,
0.6244379281997681,
1.0905513763427734,
0.03565407544374466,
0.12322839349508286,
-0.29343342781066895,
0.2585175037384033,
-0.4253486692905426,
-0.1590455323457718,
-0.3038317859172821,
-0.02919136919081211,
-0.600604772567749,
0.08895751088857651,
0.9207450747489929,
0.8303571939468384,
0.15244723856449127,
0.44928112626075745,
-0.04421350359916687,
0.34895196557044983,
-0.6834625005722046,
0.21601565182209015,
-0.008992601186037064,
0.44831550121307373,
-0.3483264744281769,
-0.5061417818069458,
-0.49189573526382446,
-0.7139918208122253,
-0.029086656868457794,
-0.9912490844726562,
0.02297113463282585,
0.018119100481271744,
1.1048400402069092,
0.23753178119659424,
-0.6215850114822388,
0.030409464612603188,
-0.9379808902740479,
0.9220686554908752,
-0.47936826944351196,
0.44111761450767517,
0.3218412399291992,
0.3799542486667633,
-0.35933101177215576,
-0.8896438479423523,
-0.49921494722366333,
0.0002291024284204468,
-0.13525289297103882,
0.0573909617960453,
-0.20056195557117462,
-0.15513281524181366,
0.5615643262863159,
-0.010060145519673824,
-0.8675901889801025,
0.10347944498062134,
-0.06357833743095398,
0.05947447195649147,
0.43157947063446045,
0.24792680144309998,
0.5685184597969055,
0.01798226498067379,
-0.3542320728302002,
-0.14866016805171967,
-0.6235706210136414,
0.0035595137160271406,
-0.13870887458324432,
-0.05461089313030243,
-0.2342921793460846,
0.7003448605537415,
0.0810481607913971,
0.5567119717597961,
0.11351408809423447,
-0.3600657880306244,
0.22062194347381592,
-0.40701809525489807,
-0.07083103805780411,
0.002564826747402549,
0.7682315707206726,
0.2774796783924103,
0.4564289450645447,
-0.3889610469341278,
0.0018283964600414038,
-0.2790495753288269,
0.06037374585866928,
-0.5005473494529724,
0.06810744106769562,
0.5976494550704956,
-0.4166122376918793,
-0.3033985495567322,
-0.11038872599601746,
-0.6627461314201355,
-0.16797786951065063,
-0.4241797924041748,
0.5987749695777893,
-0.47243547439575195,
-0.22123366594314575,
-0.8163574934005737,
-0.39342448115348816,
0.04510693624615669,
0.42058229446411133,
-0.29394257068634033,
0.24082273244857788,
0.8789845108985901,
0.9959313273429871,
-0.29994916915893555,
-0.31959113478660583,
-0.9998964071273804,
0.507209300994873,
-0.6319920420646667,
0.5382305979728699,
-0.803234338760376,
-0.37748533487319946,
-0.03585337847471237,
-0.009050476364791393,
-0.057941656559705734,
-0.4242175817489624,
0.48389148712158203,
-0.3579291105270386,
0.2084253430366516,
0.2252814620733261,
-0.9441481232643127,
0.1213328093290329,
0.21552665531635284,
-0.5729095339775085,
1.2428842782974243,
0.3300838768482208,
-0.3557753562927246,
0.2840680181980133,
-0.6253705024719238,
-0.20884007215499878,
-0.08085528016090393,
-0.09064530581235886,
-0.040939170867204666,
-0.26146042346954346,
0.29855263233184814,
0.287653386592865,
0.0021944157779216766,
0.25678929686546326,
-0.3008494973182678,
-0.22377684712409973,
0.24576058983802795,
-0.07522851973772049,
1.0671861171722412,
0.18300510942935944,
-0.48461025953292847,
0.12989087402820587,
-0.6691493391990662,
0.25642067193984985,
0.023665446788072586,
-0.047645971179008484,
-0.24915850162506104,
0.18832233548164368,
0.2350773811340332,
0.09957452863454819,
0.34698936343193054,
-0.8474265336990356,
0.31557586789131165,
-0.20859716832637787,
0.4249528646469116,
0.6557224988937378,
0.42152488231658936,
0.8138637542724609,
-0.0554424524307251,
0.1835019588470459,
-0.14659591019153595,
0.5671005249023438,
-0.0975872129201889,
-0.36661165952682495,
-0.20994561910629272,
0.11596576124429703,
0.19115422666072845,
0.6465970873832703,
-0.5888378024101257,
0.24276170134544373,
-0.38300102949142456,
-0.5680530071258545,
0.09314277023077011,
-0.143732950091362,
0.513569712638855,
0.7842896580696106,
0.48321929574012756,
0.1260736584663391,
-0.3083926737308502,
-0.6395437717437744,
-0.21839843690395355,
-0.4037105143070221,
-0.12181030958890915,
-0.11648868769407272,
0.04443737119436264,
-0.07372253388166428,
1.1106088161468506,
-0.7037389874458313,
0.1323206126689911,
0.12616610527038574,
0.48000311851501465,
0.3339066505432129,
0.19487980008125305,
0.5249775052070618,
-0.8509912490844727,
-0.6499972939491272,
0.12494444102048874,
-0.748273491859436,
-0.4434569776058197,
-0.1917138248682022,
-0.25650754570961,
0.4825628995895386,
0.5051555633544922,
-0.22009707987308502,
0.7598908543586731,
0.21959060430526733,
-0.675792932510376,
0.5841510891914368,
-0.05645556002855301,
0.08961215615272522,
-0.9071118831634521,
0.362397164106369,
-0.12823808193206787,
-0.5225697755813599,
-0.7086445689201355,
-0.13916726410388947,
0.4325863718986511,
-0.06262912601232529,
0.06436154246330261,
1.0199898481369019,
-0.30514803528785706,
0.2530404329299927,
-0.12419895082712173,
0.4429422914981842,
-0.053287915885448456,
0.419471800327301,
0.047485850751399994,
0.40742769837379456,
-0.044467344880104065,
-0.4681539833545685,
-0.06116299331188202,
0.17167025804519653,
0.2313978672027588,
0.42316296696662903,
-0.3159366548061371,
0.1091998964548111,
0.04390280693769455,
-0.0914473757147789,
-0.616524338722229,
0.24023886024951935,
0.3051026165485382,
-0.5283641219139099,
0.5030180811882019,
-0.20354317128658295,
-0.286481112241745,
0.002678367542102933,
-0.20728348195552826,
0.19399261474609375,
0.40146583318710327,
-0.5913283228874207,
0.8144116401672363,
0.42838814854621887,
-0.14987075328826904,
-0.9398407340049744,
-0.2068062424659729,
0.20414680242538452,
0.1071915253996849,
-0.47674888372421265,
0.5168451070785522,
-0.26614484190940857,
-0.7084445953369141,
0.2643948495388031,
-0.5623743534088135,
-0.37980276346206665,
-0.09902920573949814,
0.4099964499473572,
0.09314554929733276,
0.023488644510507584,
0.07003071904182434,
0.10249359160661697,
-0.3430578410625458,
-0.20724056661128998,
-0.5043971538543701,
0.1752566695213318,
0.252951979637146,
0.0848502367734909,
-0.17545869946479797,
0.6166625022888184,
0.3052116334438324,
0.14159376919269562,
0.42391788959503174,
0.7624015212059021,
-0.6253512501716614,
-0.3033423125743866,
-0.6178287267684937,
0.2654683589935303,
-0.34180426597595215,
0.12716175615787506,
-0.14018206298351288,
-0.7146079540252686,
0.21595464646816254,
0.15567855536937714,
0.5516721606254578,
0.5668463110923767,
0.19158661365509033,
-0.23280800879001617,
0.6698505878448486,
0.6734334826469421,
0.10874399542808533,
0.6148325800895691,
0.07573878020048141,
0.08624131232500076,
-0.42190659046173096,
-0.23620638251304626,
-0.5460397005081177,
-0.11672969907522202,
-0.28017082810401917,
-0.07487477362155914,
0.4019116461277008,
0.17956505715847015,
-0.6429243683815002,
0.39507344365119934,
-0.17170622944831848,
0.4969206154346466,
0.3702720105648041,
0.020332587882876396,
0.44640278816223145,
0.16178469359874725,
0.08599633723497391,
0.005247802473604679,
-0.3207966387271881,
-0.6171227693557739,
0.8905540108680725,
0.06507478654384613,
0.20652389526367188,
0.3549882471561432,
0.5569481253623962,
0.43209943175315857,
0.35805946588516235,
-0.5171139240264893,
0.4001743197441101,
-0.26269665360450745,
-0.3721916675567627,
-0.40415340662002563,
-0.6032082438468933,
-0.8620860576629639,
-0.47115591168403625,
-0.28823956847190857,
-1.2058511972427368,
0.26439157128334045,
-0.06591469049453735,
-0.2575342059135437,
0.2823299467563629,
-0.9083218574523926,
1.0164250135421753,
-0.018391141667962074,
-0.40657079219818115,
0.008952110074460506,
-0.8506597876548767,
-0.21465562283992767,
-0.22382354736328125,
0.22302007675170898,
-0.16047251224517822,
-0.15746136009693146,
0.7353233098983765,
-0.6985543370246887,
0.6006198525428772,
-0.05218048766255379,
0.06635923683643341,
0.19407378137111664,
0.5832329988479614,
0.5684486031532288,
0.058132972568273544,
0.07733146101236343,
0.2872496545314789,
0.5886520147323608,
-0.47340527176856995,
-0.8523682355880737,
0.5685951113700867,
-0.8922685980796814,
-0.383303165435791,
-0.3082914352416992,
-0.4915470480918884,
-0.09869663417339325,
0.25334498286247253,
0.04587539657950401,
0.9520915150642395,
-0.2544691860675812,
-0.5508316159248352,
0.045131705701351166,
0.012324328534305096,
1.0580766201019287,
0.4648367762565613,
-0.25496622920036316,
-0.24751856923103333,
0.7663320899009705,
0.2743307650089264,
0.1168801337480545,
1.1560921669006348,
0.1799093633890152,
-0.2718358635902405,
-0.20603027939796448,
-0.31054630875587463,
0.4036320149898529,
-0.511601984500885,
0.11138388514518738,
-0.6240336894989014,
-0.13104715943336487,
-0.2462090700864792,
-0.18076686561107635,
-0.2987707257270813,
-1.1394596099853516,
-0.26078730821609497,
0.08747141808271408,
0.006620682310312986,
0.9873142242431641,
-0.022540058940649033,
0.07805060595273972,
-1.1455875635147095,
0.11017310619354248,
-0.04794764146208763,
0.036846358329057693,
-0.10994129627943039,
-0.15371546149253845,
-0.059364449232816696,
-0.34838181734085083,
-0.27840402722358704,
-1.1654266119003296,
0.3697141110897064,
0.2630099356174469,
0.45762234926223755,
0.38938137888908386,
-0.03214915096759796,
0.8373239040374756,
-0.701013445854187,
0.8082433938980103,
-0.18815328180789948,
-1.0373040437698364,
0.4183238744735718,
-0.19843363761901855,
0.1972401738166809,
-0.0315980538725853,
0.42544811964035034,
-0.7427473664283752,
-0.2526683807373047,
-0.8320556879043579,
-0.8563592433929443,
0.6739795804023743,
0.6595668792724609,
-0.8066341280937195,
0.15278446674346924,
0.7097432017326355,
0.014367028139531612,
-0.2299177646636963,
-0.4407283365726471,
-0.35879167914390564,
-0.05042369291186333,
-0.470977783203125,
-0.22085809707641602,
-0.46424373984336853,
-0.3704821765422821,
0.26651903986930847,
0.4295782744884491,
0.20501409471035004,
0.23005859553813934,
0.2998243272304535,
-0.2587115168571472,
-0.2950519919395447,
0.42160290479660034,
0.39699265360832214,
1.3982027769088745,
-0.47790762782096863,
0.3378310203552246,
0.04800473526120186,
-0.6745362281799316,
0.03241083398461342,
0.3979271948337555,
-0.07370007783174515,
0.17345072329044342,
0.7817568182945251,
0.07986290007829666,
-0.11651934683322906,
-0.6069527268409729,
0.45981937646865845,
-0.06079960614442825,
0.3545152544975281,
-0.7707793116569519,
-0.20944783091545105,
-0.24174487590789795,
0.6533052921295166,
0.721138060092926,
-0.37576714158058167,
-0.07539331167936325,
-0.27536651492118835,
0.1913219392299652,
-0.10494832694530487,
-0.43565425276756287,
-0.4401354491710663,
0.6560752391815186,
-0.13963623344898224,
-0.608725905418396,
0.4893016517162323,
-0.24532723426818848,
-0.16044943034648895,
0.6791719198226929,
0.48487555980682373,
0.9350444674491882,
-0.17867499589920044,
0.23760868608951569,
0.60757976770401,
0.3539724051952362,
0.11417257785797119,
0.08547690510749817,
-0.029972918331623077,
-0.31115326285362244,
-0.7266494631767273,
-0.6976017951965332,
-0.3776802122592926,
-0.36925241351127625,
-0.2463810294866562,
0.0933682844042778,
-0.40351465344429016,
-0.10818511992692947,
0.08703207969665527,
-0.03329837694764137,
-0.3061096966266632,
0.010140978731215,
0.06448692083358765,
1.0526175498962402,
-0.604755699634552,
0.6408669948577881,
0.6539191007614136,
-0.13488031923770905,
-1.1203365325927734,
0.07373981922864914,
0.30160772800445557,
-0.4120173156261444,
0.8957290053367615,
-0.2283858209848404,
0.17208120226860046,
0.04769178107380867,
-0.4366273880004883,
-0.7767109870910645,
1.3277106285095215,
0.13724207878112793,
-0.5885397791862488,
-0.2803367078304291,
0.04076140746474266,
0.38337278366088867,
-0.2373248189687729,
0.5990465879440308,
0.46587976813316345,
0.4908521771430969,
-0.004679365083575249,
-1.1268492937088013,
0.31158313155174255,
-0.522624671459198,
-0.2457202821969986,
0.6520376205444336,
-0.045604731887578964,
0.6856899857521057,
0.012286584824323654,
-0.5882803797721863,
0.08027461916208267,
0.4915270209312439,
0.11397900432348251,
0.6527223587036133,
0.35510873794555664,
0.3476099669933319,
0.8732607960700989,
-0.34733232855796814,
1.1222819089889526,
-0.17667634785175323,
0.476898193359375,
0.9674782156944275,
0.13215240836143494,
0.6632863879203796,
0.43365222215652466,
-0.15843318402767181,
0.3190497159957886,
0.7429723739624023,
0.33702319860458374,
0.1079057902097702,
-0.5214090943336487,
-0.26470616459846497,
-0.2746324837207794,
-0.1574404388666153,
-0.22043846547603607,
-0.2811208665370941,
0.4347175657749176,
-0.10702642053365707,
-0.5317407250404358,
-0.39187556505203247,
0.5379586815834045,
-0.15261796116828918,
-0.43856361508369446,
0.4528903663158417,
0.2022659033536911,
-0.49790289998054504,
0.31364473700523376,
-0.12529249489307404,
-0.17000854015350342,
-0.618545651435852,
-0.43858852982521057,
-0.21708764135837555,
0.25558727979660034,
-0.3472099304199219,
-1.0410622358322144,
0.28366929292678833,
-0.026603728532791138,
-0.11133789271116257,
-0.31761589646339417,
0.3868139982223511,
-0.39772945642471313,
-0.2585185766220093,
0.39893683791160583,
0.46511098742485046,
0.04535661265254021,
-0.0536961629986763,
-0.26191776990890503,
-0.21513128280639648,
0.03061147965490818,
-0.20648939907550812,
-0.22938817739486694,
0.4628002941608429,
-0.36741673946380615,
0.42006251215934753,
0.23467040061950684,
-0.05053452029824257,
0.03499263897538185,
-0.10206900537014008,
0.5184451937675476,
-0.9489414691925049,
-0.2953677177429199,
-1.016392469406128,
0.443214476108551,
-0.43916380405426025,
-0.3819260597229004,
0.642457127571106,
0.4468018114566803,
0.6199986934661865,
0.2476826310157776,
0.46096837520599365,
-0.22265785932540894,
0.6362801790237427,
-0.49788302183151245,
0.4137171804904938,
-0.7839445471763611,
0.07562430202960968,
-0.3599573075771332,
-1.204400658607483,
-0.5730125308036804,
0.09854236245155334,
-0.367740660905838,
-0.2856893837451935,
1.1434978246688843,
0.5172250270843506,
0.017816411331295967,
0.1593036651611328,
0.04157710447907448,
0.6599940657615662,
0.5173514485359192,
0.7002482414245605,
0.6483365893363953,
-0.18276089429855347,
0.7934001088142395,
-0.3781927227973938,
-0.4840847849845886,
0.1032291129231453,
-0.9625955820083618,
-0.7810218334197998,
-0.6207882761955261,
-0.36462870240211487,
-0.6173582077026367,
0.2632831037044525,
1.0055577754974365,
0.17366154491901398,
-0.6669268012046814,
-0.21999487280845642,
0.3513849973678589,
0.29040053486824036,
-0.33300313353538513,
-0.2586381137371063,
0.8746994137763977,
-0.21695934236049652,
-0.9785515666007996,
0.5829753279685974,
0.5832905173301697,
-0.16477514803409576,
0.44094645977020264,
0.15468361973762512,
-0.25353774428367615,
-0.43916055560112,
0.6423114538192749,
0.680716335773468,
-0.20233486592769623,
-0.7026007771492004,
0.20149348676204681,
-0.1296163946390152,
0.025412289425730705,
0.710835337638855,
-0.4295136630535126,
0.3628351092338562,
0.5362669825553894,
0.23704937100410461,
0.9444524645805359,
0.07598993182182312,
0.5931986570358276,
-0.951732873916626,
-0.062142010778188705,
0.12029476463794708,
0.1879362016916275,
-0.097719706594944,
-0.18848803639411926,
0.9852809906005859,
0.37703269720077515,
-0.541144609451294,
-0.6224148273468018,
0.162325918674469,
-1.4907283782958984,
-0.4311531186103821,
1.2571042776107788,
-0.012570030055940151,
-0.551925778388977,
-0.4324818551540375,
-0.017643658444285393,
0.5535092353820801,
-0.29326653480529785,
0.5249943733215332,
0.4752640724182129,
-0.2427060902118683,
0.05278613790869713,
-0.41619873046875,
0.27833080291748047,
0.014835832640528679,
-0.4236343204975128,
-0.21793995797634125,
0.31172695755958557,
0.3816172480583191,
0.5574158430099487,
0.5730059146881104,
-0.41043683886528015,
0.06442592293024063,
-0.17064255475997925,
0.001779652084223926,
-0.23747852444648743,
-0.2554128170013428,
-0.08410275727510452,
0.5043703317642212,
-0.1641063392162323,
0.2656620740890503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05259v1
|
A model of early word acquisition based on realistic-scale audiovisual naming events
| 2024-06-07T21:05:59 | 2024-06-07T21:05:59 |
Khazar Khorrami, Okko Räsänen
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Infants gradually learn to parse continuous speech into words and connect
names with objects, yet the mechanisms behind development of early word
perception skills remain unknown. We studied the extent to which early words
can be acquired through statistical learning from regularities in audiovisual
sensory input. We simulated word learning in infants up to 12 months of age in
a realistic setting, using a model that solely learns from statistical
regularities in unannotated raw speech and pixel-level visual input. Crucially,
the quantity of object naming events was carefully designed to match that
accessible to infants of comparable ages. Results show that the model
effectively learns to recognize words and associate them with corresponding
visual objects, with a vocabulary growth rate comparable to that observed in
infants. The findings support the viability of general statistical learning for
early word perception, demonstrating how learning can operate without assuming
any prior linguistic capabilities.
|
[
-0.09653547406196594,
-0.5459641218185425,
0.7027356028556824,
-0.045794058591127396,
-0.5829933285713196,
-0.2567548453807831,
-0.2924952208995819,
-0.6501042246818542,
-0.057149019092321396,
-0.16927647590637207,
-0.37035784125328064,
-0.1446022391319275,
-0.9371224045753479,
-0.15231634676456451,
-0.26579150557518005,
0.6685037016868591,
0.11874809861183167,
-0.07927578687667847,
0.27334073185920715,
-0.12596049904823303,
-0.4756983816623688,
-0.11654498428106308,
-0.7452796101570129,
-0.0783419981598854,
0.8200342059135437,
0.5407910943031311,
0.6436039209365845,
1.047664999961853,
0.42616602778434753,
0.3247406482696533,
0.07630128413438797,
0.18798159062862396,
-0.26569482684135437,
-0.11747020483016968,
0.08330682665109634,
-0.5548351407051086,
-0.15001778304576874,
0.20981812477111816,
0.7251865267753601,
1.3251937627792358,
-0.5053996443748474,
0.0902261734008789,
0.24558651447296143,
0.6512566208839417,
-0.4436187744140625,
0.7621234059333801,
-0.7860587239265442,
0.3725675642490387,
-0.14085210859775543,
-0.2985343337059021,
-0.4150102138519287,
-0.009621645323932171,
0.5272397398948669,
-1.153701663017273,
0.16937817633152008,
0.22374160587787628,
1.035225510597229,
-0.08964415639638901,
0.0976744070649147,
-0.38186943531036377,
-0.6887742877006531,
0.9229762554168701,
0.040689025074243546,
0.9475521445274353,
0.6807990074157715,
0.26075202226638794,
-0.27312469482421875,
-0.8480595946311951,
-0.6470758318901062,
-0.47896015644073486,
-0.08226612955331802,
-0.24059154093265533,
-0.30201736092567444,
-0.22609780728816986,
0.309170126914978,
-0.23933552205562592,
-0.559154212474823,
-0.14759354293346405,
-0.7998135089874268,
-0.14163357019424438,
0.35140183568000793,
0.09383553266525269,
0.3378506600856781,
-0.12254983931779861,
-0.38871607184410095,
-0.18796706199645996,
-0.3412494957447052,
0.08758381754159927,
0.04994206503033638,
0.6486080288887024,
-0.5343508720397949,
0.5573722124099731,
0.07383228093385696,
0.7681359648704529,
-0.012814939953386784,
-0.3655254542827606,
0.21651719510555267,
-0.0273759663105011,
-0.2548585832118988,
0.15653596818447113,
0.34785839915275574,
-0.018470970913767815,
0.9607357978820801,
-0.35938456654548645,
-0.14254750311374664,
0.5160019397735596,
0.3674049377441406,
-0.49286583065986633,
-0.5271955132484436,
-0.22099359333515167,
-0.5886532664299011,
-0.35381731390953064,
0.05161644518375397,
-0.604084312915802,
-0.5471258759498596,
-0.5601003766059875,
0.6490316390991211,
-0.5814318060874939,
0.01884465105831623,
0.24809367954730988,
-0.1698707491159439,
0.27906396985054016,
0.4110281467437744,
-0.9295147061347961,
0.22620992362499237,
0.3551631271839142,
0.6225259900093079,
-0.25043943524360657,
-0.5050399303436279,
-0.6033701300621033,
0.06809567660093307,
-0.8522569537162781,
0.9512742161750793,
-0.5878681540489197,
-0.3128955662250519,
-0.1316414773464203,
0.20919263362884521,
0.04838338494300842,
-0.5006725192070007,
-0.0254022479057312,
-0.7766644358634949,
-0.13690806925296783,
0.25901246070861816,
-0.38840997219085693,
-0.1244189515709877,
-0.33187729120254517,
-0.2887991666793823,
0.016491632908582687,
0.08432469516992569,
-0.6761357188224792,
1.433243751525879,
-0.12264508008956909,
-0.3674984872341156,
0.19956399500370026,
-0.5590897798538208,
-0.22689437866210938,
0.4167819023132324,
-0.12559278309345245,
0.5702983736991882,
0.331530898809433,
-0.03791912645101547,
-0.07423429936170578,
-0.22051161527633667,
0.18701060116291046,
-0.6069797873497009,
0.23794341087341309,
0.28734150528907776,
-0.04971708357334137,
-0.4277374744415283,
-1.204844355583191,
-0.33179253339767456,
0.2682804465293884,
-0.19037042558193207,
-0.38023290038108826,
0.39709392189979553,
-0.46050381660461426,
-0.42316678166389465,
0.022434188053011894,
-0.5191301703453064,
-0.004269239027053118,
-0.3774785101413727,
0.0449211560189724,
0.4677770137786865,
0.12009821087121964,
0.6753413081169128,
-0.3499472141265869,
0.1741960644721985,
0.4407155513763428,
0.18590891361236572,
-0.520048201084137,
-0.5386162400245667,
-0.6339099407196045,
-0.45048558712005615,
0.2376837134361267,
0.40792545676231384,
-0.5044228434562683,
0.05179949477314949,
-0.17038677632808685,
-0.21455056965351105,
-0.05383884534239769,
0.336124449968338,
0.2503856122493744,
0.43585994839668274,
0.3538004457950592,
-0.7713799476623535,
-0.4812861680984497,
-0.6266875863075256,
-0.13053523004055023,
-0.6266555786132812,
-0.4071163833141327,
0.43827441334724426,
-0.14409714937210083,
0.008899745531380177,
0.6599460244178772,
-0.543781042098999,
-0.492747038602829,
-0.018331823870539665,
0.5514509677886963,
0.0943729355931282,
0.3951377868652344,
0.3741743564605713,
-0.3879695236682892,
0.2024887204170227,
-0.04714144393801689,
-0.5551714897155762,
0.210049569606781,
-0.11870512366294861,
-0.020437920466065407,
-0.18403838574886322,
0.4194275438785553,
-0.3515586853027344,
0.6432852745056152,
0.4449087083339691,
-0.4684712886810303,
0.19748197495937347,
-0.34363484382629395,
-0.3462904691696167,
-0.6280121803283691,
-0.5012667775154114,
0.1389496922492981,
-0.1324744075536728,
-0.6686105132102966,
-0.38084426522254944,
-0.07756581157445908,
-0.055819619446992874,
-0.7625330090522766,
0.6565115451812744,
-0.6950533390045166,
-0.17636483907699585,
-0.23024435341358185,
0.0800238847732544,
-0.27671512961387634,
0.34986796975135803,
0.40673503279685974,
0.6874329447746277,
0.5613387823104858,
-1.0246589183807373,
-0.14102214574813843,
-0.12733660638332367,
-0.6742215752601624,
0.5747199654579163,
-0.5767696499824524,
-0.13653002679347992,
-0.3798116445541382,
-0.3731810748577118,
-1.084713339805603,
-0.3503633737564087,
-0.03435755893588066,
-0.7962029576301575,
0.4567875862121582,
0.12817521393299103,
-0.3539113998413086,
0.17727844417095184,
0.42735254764556885,
0.2893190085887909,
0.6367865204811096,
-0.6348519921302795,
0.4115658104419708,
0.6050881147384644,
-0.19844378530979156,
0.0693279430270195,
-0.4445134103298187,
-0.31814220547676086,
-0.07944674044847488,
-0.07654392719268799,
-0.09827486425638199,
0.3426330089569092,
-0.31597253680229187,
-0.16215437650680542,
-0.07995116710662842,
-0.5351089239120483,
-0.02936437726020813,
0.07348302751779556,
0.38095346093177795,
-0.3500494658946991,
0.3770858347415924,
-0.3771326243877411,
-0.12471695989370346,
-0.17055583000183105,
-0.20798158645629883,
0.26781535148620605,
0.1715124249458313,
-0.00839698314666748,
-0.38028761744499207,
-0.272856742143631,
0.47309353947639465,
0.037574272602796555,
0.44753432273864746,
0.3074570596218109,
-0.6407975554466248,
-0.36824941635131836,
-0.22296969592571259,
-0.25752758979797363,
-0.4625268876552582,
0.4680110514163971,
-0.4524209201335907,
-0.31271812319755554,
0.09117349982261658,
0.09403109550476074,
-0.002873056335374713,
0.15238338708877563,
0.2017129510641098,
-0.3792541027069092,
1.058422327041626,
0.7361112236976624,
0.45168033242225647,
0.5688437819480896,
-0.0040635839104652405,
-0.042100172489881516,
-0.612913191318512,
-0.32046017050743103,
-0.1613808125257492,
-0.3029354214668274,
-0.4207044839859009,
-0.6475479006767273,
-0.022400805726647377,
0.12079501152038574,
-0.2635275423526764,
0.23499953746795654,
-0.23793648183345795,
0.46530961990356445,
0.31280744075775146,
0.3901223838329315,
0.36752283573150635,
0.3525361716747284,
-0.45131993293762207,
-0.29117467999458313,
-0.3972437083721161,
-0.48524972796440125,
0.827870786190033,
0.43785926699638367,
0.8863242268562317,
-0.14853791892528534,
0.5712773203849792,
0.22443123161792755,
0.4060928523540497,
-0.9251200556755066,
0.41164374351501465,
-0.1840585470199585,
-0.13740922510623932,
-0.4334491491317749,
-0.1218254491686821,
-1.4343432188034058,
0.3035845458507538,
-0.3580305576324463,
-0.8873140215873718,
0.8920504450798035,
0.006359646562486887,
-0.6648607850074768,
0.1074807420372963,
-0.7254478335380554,
0.4820827543735504,
-0.18264465034008026,
-0.37620505690574646,
-0.12085814028978348,
-0.5432949662208557,
0.2735132873058319,
-0.29217031598091125,
0.5417082905769348,
-0.28934141993522644,
-0.5358847975730896,
0.8900921940803528,
-0.014921888709068298,
0.7715253829956055,
-0.258754700422287,
0.11505899578332901,
0.36990758776664734,
0.5597365498542786,
0.14697997272014618,
0.19634288549423218,
0.5053383708000183,
0.11500585824251175,
-0.04365457594394684,
-0.4596993029117584,
-0.5380533933639526,
0.08759478479623795,
-0.7256743907928467,
0.02832845039665699,
-0.6198274493217468,
-0.3471125364303589,
-0.43665221333503723,
0.1761767715215683,
-0.10518831014633179,
0.37353670597076416,
-0.27974772453308105,
0.2353711873292923,
0.7310109734535217,
-0.22386859357357025,
0.31056860089302063,
0.9661893844604492,
-0.3823779821395874,
-0.28753527998924255,
1.0154507160186768,
0.23100797832012177,
0.057784806936979294,
0.10175592452287674,
0.3905421495437622,
-0.010870776139199734,
-0.4539346396923065,
-0.3345870077610016,
0.12932655215263367,
-0.23967677354812622,
0.08459184318780899,
-0.4957160949707031,
0.023666271939873695,
0.1358174979686737,
-0.04594457149505615,
-0.2553277611732483,
-0.20799404382705688,
-0.439449667930603,
-0.261790007352829,
0.2466549426317215,
0.7292675375938416,
-0.39543092250823975,
0.6084824800491333,
-0.6666020154953003,
0.7270175814628601,
0.8647155165672302,
0.41843315958976746,
0.23567809164524078,
-0.8208465576171875,
-0.14880438148975372,
-0.1730329394340515,
-0.16467790305614471,
-0.7712851166725159,
0.467162162065506,
0.6361615061759949,
0.44305655360221863,
0.9161354899406433,
-0.49178043007850647,
0.7521700859069824,
-0.9498135447502136,
0.6761519312858582,
0.4478113353252411,
-0.3787280321121216,
0.5794609785079956,
-0.38863369822502136,
0.2421790510416031,
0.4385700523853302,
0.4781714677810669,
-0.24416208267211914,
-0.04456612095236778,
-0.9802699089050293,
-0.5873174071311951,
0.5293805003166199,
-0.12222156673669815,
0.1841943860054016,
-0.3837306499481201,
0.028833789750933647,
0.28623417019844055,
0.2853803336620331,
-0.14863918721675873,
0.15574929118156433,
0.19868940114974976,
0.04157644882798195,
-0.5046178698539734,
-0.05548970028758049,
-0.06224348023533821,
-0.596771776676178,
0.08291923254728317,
0.0010658894898369908,
0.38997170329093933,
0.19977320730686188,
-0.4006761610507965,
-0.004188398364931345,
0.03039003349840641,
0.4524538516998291,
0.524850070476532,
-0.14467714726924896,
0.2955940067768097,
0.05478617548942566,
-0.7024085521697998,
0.27045515179634094,
-0.12726955115795135,
0.22287802398204803,
0.11164001375436783,
0.6581460237503052,
1.0400797128677368,
0.7710085511207581,
-0.5602103471755981,
0.5733836889266968,
-0.2656022012233734,
-0.19736404716968536,
-0.41235220432281494,
0.12564878165721893,
-0.03443368524312973,
0.10092852264642715,
0.4594419300556183,
-0.203195258975029,
-0.10692229866981506,
-0.8501672148704529,
0.9046742916107178,
0.0558173805475235,
-0.6719925403594971,
-0.47708287835121155,
0.7199484705924988,
-0.4038969576358795,
-0.28369829058647156,
0.5406551957130432,
-0.18989598751068115,
0.01211500633507967,
0.7725470662117004,
0.5448938608169556,
0.8311602473258972,
-0.18991966545581818,
0.14203743636608124,
0.3791646957397461,
0.3687678277492523,
-0.010693843476474285,
0.45279791951179504,
-0.42725324630737305,
-1.018384337425232,
0.14634893834590912,
-1.2181936502456665,
-0.21183478832244873,
-0.08198196440935135,
-0.40518978238105774,
0.4501982033252716,
-0.7110881209373474,
-0.15445482730865479,
0.11497675627470016,
-0.2337685078382492,
-1.3803753852844238,
0.5550501942634583,
0.6448554396629333,
0.6841716766357422,
-0.9233166575431824,
0.5863057971000671,
0.5254563689231873,
-0.5676223039627075,
-1.2016247510910034,
-0.03843732923269272,
-0.20238278806209564,
-1.2102490663528442,
0.9297525882720947,
0.08792982250452042,
0.037564557045698166,
0.20791436731815338,
-0.6509159207344055,
-0.8464951515197754,
0.632238507270813,
-0.2143331617116928,
-0.6513355374336243,
-0.24758701026439667,
0.03580068051815033,
0.5689594745635986,
-0.459308385848999,
0.4875687062740326,
0.7617568373680115,
0.3909245729446411,
0.20364795625209808,
-0.46085822582244873,
-0.5065192580223083,
0.3408638536930084,
0.11812075227499008,
-0.17440998554229736,
-0.3161662518978119,
0.7270863056182861,
-0.6136154532432556,
-0.5076021552085876,
0.05039991810917854,
1.1506775617599487,
0.28959500789642334,
0.30698350071907043,
0.8213832974433899,
0.40942880511283875,
0.6038634777069092,
0.15098129212856293,
0.7470491528511047,
-0.37022069096565247,
0.005964890122413635,
0.8113852143287659,
-0.009498431347310543,
1.0803102254867554,
0.4996037483215332,
-0.4630930423736572,
0.44143280386924744,
0.6224727630615234,
0.18431712687015533,
0.8480750918388367,
0.5118648409843445,
-0.12518471479415894,
-0.05821689963340759,
-0.0807378962635994,
-0.11119914054870605,
0.61128169298172,
0.8382267951965332,
-0.3533400595188141,
-0.07956583052873611,
0.20806239545345306,
-0.09454077482223511,
-0.165794238448143,
-0.23977524042129517,
1.10967218875885,
0.46712708473205566,
-0.2702895998954773,
0.4536355435848236,
-0.42529991269111633,
0.6468502879142761,
-0.7868593335151672,
-0.24347810447216034,
-0.08293314278125763,
-0.015316206961870193,
-0.1142047643661499,
-0.5025887489318848,
0.06415172666311264,
-0.01627059280872345,
-0.035253047943115234,
0.18624700605869293,
0.36617788672447205,
-0.43560680747032166,
-0.8237273097038269,
0.2931782901287079,
0.5316498875617981,
0.4557880461215973,
0.5175154805183411,
-0.11567684262990952,
0.031259503215551376,
-0.5018569231033325,
-0.297328382730484,
0.3725261688232422,
0.672109842300415,
-0.053828269243240356,
0.23614847660064697,
0.5895252823829651,
0.9023144841194153,
0.7707023024559021,
-0.020066237077116966,
0.26117274165153503,
-0.19860051572322845,
-0.5164123177528381,
-0.4351674020290375,
0.18060751259326935,
0.30725905299186707,
-0.10032633692026138,
0.23124049603939056,
0.17672373354434967,
0.9681113362312317,
-0.25018686056137085,
0.3586862087249756,
0.11917784810066223,
0.6829548478126526,
-0.3486630916595459,
0.7461016178131104,
-0.7607321739196777,
-0.21504920721054077,
-0.31947818398475647,
-0.92038893699646,
-0.45883139967918396,
1.0560479164123535,
-0.21949009597301483,
-0.22021806240081787,
0.8535628318786621,
0.6367369294166565,
-0.3832162916660309,
-0.05615637078881264,
0.7550620436668396,
0.23954713344573975,
-0.07363772392272949,
0.07948976010084152,
0.6004098057746887,
-0.0774553045630455,
0.09898322820663452,
-0.34560105204582214,
-0.7200676798820496,
0.17295615375041962,
-0.6420631408691406,
-0.3303866386413574,
-0.2788104712963104,
-0.053314194083213806,
0.02881653606891632,
0.6013439893722534,
0.8854470252990723,
0.6611494421958923,
-0.7240079045295715,
-0.2489592581987381,
-0.1978382021188736,
-0.3608517348766327,
-0.19806276261806488,
-0.20477598905563354,
0.23585738241672516,
-0.7516868710517883,
-0.5936312079429626,
0.5418131351470947,
-0.0275445356965065,
0.07081962376832962,
-0.13511939346790314,
0.09077924489974976,
0.0333004929125309,
0.49156680703163147,
0.5221607089042664,
0.6578156352043152,
-0.30612707138061523,
-0.5290220379829407,
-0.3526008427143097,
-0.060521628707647324,
0.29685112833976746,
0.6410399079322815,
-0.9925796389579773,
0.5275263786315918,
0.5782926678657532,
0.48952457308769226,
-0.07122679799795151,
-0.02687438577413559,
0.4543170928955078,
-0.515781819820404,
0.6883642077445984,
-0.02307402528822422,
0.3624902069568634,
0.017546454444527626,
-0.12346427887678146,
0.13612428307533264,
0.533043622970581,
-0.22597981989383698,
-0.7014145255088806,
0.2353062480688095,
-0.6116821765899658,
0.04999865964055061,
0.7497714161872864,
0.1098531112074852,
-0.3876023292541504,
0.03247477114200592,
-0.00561444042250514,
0.48569270968437195,
-0.28646695613861084,
0.8272325396537781,
0.5507861375808716,
-0.13050003349781036,
0.011143423616886139,
-0.7957296967506409,
0.45254674553871155,
0.32117506861686707,
-0.07104217261075974,
-0.16482560336589813,
0.44280898571014404,
0.2158336192369461,
0.08461255580186844,
0.6146909594535828,
-0.43511340022087097,
0.3744466304779053,
0.3465516269207001,
-0.0848604068160057,
0.37519869208335876,
-1.115571141242981,
-0.3513711988925934,
0.07461577653884888,
0.3130097985267639,
-0.7398715019226074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05255v1
|
Generative Explore-Exploit: Training-free Optimization of Generative Recommender Systems using LLM Optimizers
| 2024-06-07T20:41:59 | 2024-06-07T20:41:59 |
Lütfi Kerem Senel, Besnik Fetahu, Davis Yoshida, Zhiyu Chen, Giuseppe Castellucci, Nikhita Vedula, Jason Choi, Shervin Malmasi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recommender systems are widely used to suggest engaging content, and Large
Language Models (LLMs) have given rise to generative recommenders. Such systems
can directly generate items, including for open-set tasks like question
suggestion. While the world knowledge of LLMs enable good recommendations,
improving the generated content through user feedback is challenging as
continuously fine-tuning LLMs is prohibitively expensive. We present a
training-free approach for optimizing generative recommenders by connecting
user feedback loops to LLM-based optimizers. We propose a generative
explore-exploit method that can not only exploit generated items with known
high engagement, but also actively explore and discover hidden population
preferences to improve recommendation quality. We evaluate our approach on
question generation in two domains (e-commerce and general knowledge), and
model user feedback with Click Through Rate (CTR). Experiments show our
LLM-based explore-exploit approach can iteratively improve recommendations, and
consistently increase CTR. Ablation analysis shows that generative exploration
is key to learning user preferences, avoiding the pitfalls of greedy
exploit-only approaches. A human evaluation strongly supports our quantitative
findings.
|
[
-0.5246074795722961,
-0.5603252649307251,
0.4850236773490906,
0.027048548683524132,
-0.204326331615448,
-0.12377629429101944,
-0.2141389101743698,
-0.28060996532440186,
0.30955517292022705,
0.7436433434486389,
-0.8119049072265625,
-0.45962586998939514,
-0.287846177816391,
-0.2347278743982315,
-0.20767167210578918,
0.8980618119239807,
-0.12331956624984741,
-0.24174009263515472,
-0.49951058626174927,
0.045889656990766525,
-0.37907692790031433,
-0.4297792613506317,
-0.7155805230140686,
-0.10639946907758713,
0.5703501105308533,
0.6192362904548645,
0.48443421721458435,
0.16681194305419922,
0.3552279472351074,
0.21687188744544983,
-0.1736351102590561,
0.6541544198989868,
-0.9629711508750916,
0.36457014083862305,
-0.15315976738929749,
-0.5220708847045898,
-0.0716460794210434,
-0.18195439875125885,
0.03725098818540573,
0.44580820202827454,
-0.35884034633636475,
0.033538609743118286,
0.20575417578220367,
0.8074579834938049,
-0.8524931073188782,
-0.2251540571451187,
-0.640390932559967,
0.13351644575595856,
0.09913965314626694,
-0.564127504825592,
-0.43086403608322144,
-0.6536866426467896,
0.33308178186416626,
-0.777434766292572,
0.5151897072792053,
0.2608867883682251,
0.38556423783302307,
0.20626522600650787,
-0.13392803072929382,
-0.3777987062931061,
-0.8093428015708923,
0.6658624410629272,
-0.22549118101596832,
0.24995526671409607,
0.3696548342704773,
0.2809135615825653,
-0.2251591682434082,
-0.33395788073539734,
-0.1898486614227295,
-0.3486088216304779,
0.07416488975286484,
0.16828998923301697,
-0.5656981468200684,
0.04525236785411835,
0.2157232016324997,
0.5788695216178894,
-0.5149540901184082,
-0.04725631698966026,
-0.20625467598438263,
-0.04609251394867897,
0.7503530979156494,
0.006272553466260433,
0.3826022148132324,
0.1092943623661995,
-0.5449369549751282,
-0.15721744298934937,
-0.8153963685035706,
0.1790577471256256,
0.6083849668502808,
0.013396612368524075,
0.07999462634325027,
0.8989320993423462,
-0.23966117203235626,
0.43699154257774353,
0.11898980289697647,
0.5706168413162231,
-0.09982512146234512,
-0.2752106487751007,
-0.00855196826159954,
-0.26911264657974243,
0.6847537755966187,
0.606617271900177,
0.3640716075897217,
-0.38619789481163025,
-0.2784704566001892,
0.017676787450909615,
0.5768564343452454,
-0.6685260534286499,
-0.06647124141454697,
0.1628515124320984,
-0.23051047325134277,
-0.6252462267875671,
0.06163207069039345,
-0.7744154334068298,
-0.4673800468444824,
0.2730535864830017,
0.30824771523475647,
-0.4189976155757904,
-0.1856798678636551,
0.29886433482170105,
-0.30712607502937317,
0.07706167548894882,
0.30946654081344604,
-1.2226868867874146,
0.1656302958726883,
0.41696447134017944,
0.6988875269889832,
-0.2898569703102112,
-0.18277505040168762,
-0.6205188632011414,
0.19183848798274994,
-0.31147852540016174,
1.0011361837387085,
-0.5050823092460632,
-1.038503885269165,
0.34154102206230164,
-0.27485743165016174,
0.12697936594486237,
-0.8026033639907837,
0.34271830320358276,
-0.8950538635253906,
0.04232911765575409,
-0.34076249599456787,
-0.6620517373085022,
-0.017148295417428017,
0.42475980520248413,
-0.5868944525718689,
1.0324195623397827,
0.23859372735023499,
-0.47660037875175476,
0.4781562387943268,
-0.985349178314209,
-0.1253199726343155,
0.24465437233448029,
0.1937396377325058,
-0.20418474078178406,
0.27134764194488525,
0.6544461250305176,
0.09399488568305969,
-0.21471558511257172,
0.07762863487005234,
-0.3599971830844879,
-0.4801381230354309,
0.3653733730316162,
-0.41623803973197937,
0.4546012580394745,
0.16729359328746796,
-0.22136268019676208,
0.5187690258026123,
-0.2733317017555237,
0.011038323864340782,
0.29274415969848633,
-0.47169336676597595,
-0.30818018317222595,
0.02662898227572441,
0.13304230570793152,
-0.410779744386673,
0.18598653376102448,
-0.3879379630088806,
0.5038724541664124,
-0.5936439037322998,
0.10843853652477264,
0.6954473257064819,
0.39763760566711426,
0.42809808254241943,
-0.40205228328704834,
0.9639375805854797,
-0.01238955371081829,
0.1614665985107422,
-0.2823556959629059,
-0.1624768078327179,
-0.8762277960777283,
0.2869163751602173,
0.1762440800666809,
0.3045181632041931,
-0.8193564414978027,
0.4129609763622284,
0.10591550916433334,
-0.4442553222179413,
-0.526610255241394,
0.3434620499610901,
0.08284333348274231,
-0.09777124971151352,
0.37217122316360474,
-0.4385938048362732,
-0.30984053015708923,
-0.5586081743240356,
-0.37007519602775574,
-0.04736059159040451,
-0.21920672059059143,
0.6425707340240479,
0.17347203195095062,
-0.4096757471561432,
0.8222060799598694,
-0.903536319732666,
-0.2740974426269531,
-0.5193358659744263,
0.044777531176805496,
-0.033634498715400696,
0.22313864529132843,
0.3845999240875244,
-0.5563526153564453,
-0.3613663613796234,
-0.12740643322467804,
-0.5037399530410767,
0.021773623302578926,
-0.04280535876750946,
-0.17558734118938446,
-0.14021481573581696,
0.3159500062465668,
-0.4321669638156891,
0.21873170137405396,
0.2913530766963959,
-0.19202175736427307,
0.4706728756427765,
-0.40861696004867554,
-0.044705118983983994,
-0.7904810905456543,
-0.09783796221017838,
0.06730085611343384,
-0.01864500343799591,
-0.24879983067512512,
0.2952277362346649,
-0.020242657512426376,
-0.3649623394012451,
-0.3817560374736786,
0.5541092753410339,
-0.381422758102417,
0.1100049540400505,
-0.24740764498710632,
0.1527138501405716,
-0.17798762023448944,
0.6520954966545105,
-0.2971203327178955,
0.9900799989700317,
0.3513527810573578,
-0.4518108069896698,
0.3769327998161316,
0.24656715989112854,
-0.3944801688194275,
0.2851342260837555,
-0.5276825428009033,
0.5885449051856995,
-0.09398876130580902,
-0.06529581546783447,
-0.9737532138824463,
-0.05685815215110779,
0.22118809819221497,
-0.20431339740753174,
-0.01315328199416399,
-0.3020729720592499,
-0.3159673511981964,
-0.3159002661705017,
-0.7058950662612915,
0.4772118628025055,
0.3930188715457916,
-0.8626450896263123,
0.2591519355773926,
0.19903723895549774,
-0.03145842254161835,
-0.5448371767997742,
0.01856900379061699,
-0.05327596142888069,
-0.21883422136306763,
-0.4880330264568329,
0.32490426301956177,
-0.41139277815818787,
-0.005767982918769121,
0.045833948999643326,
0.014427858404815197,
0.39039477705955505,
0.2744978666305542,
0.24400827288627625,
0.23090748488903046,
0.02323487587273121,
-0.0922611728310585,
0.17596960067749023,
-0.3124389946460724,
0.12702643871307373,
-0.5134738683700562,
0.8025410175323486,
-0.0985170230269432,
-0.5778910517692566,
-0.08369746804237366,
0.3071829080581665,
0.30701005458831787,
-0.25206026434898376,
0.07474114000797272,
0.44777899980545044,
-0.06259597092866898,
-0.38203510642051697,
-0.6147060990333557,
-0.27156588435173035,
-0.5344629883766174,
0.3151501715183258,
-0.17469270527362823,
-1.1434526443481445,
0.0426582470536232,
-0.2950478196144104,
-0.04463576152920723,
0.4574408233165741,
0.5176203846931458,
-0.14358647167682648,
1.0210485458374023,
0.8577173352241516,
-0.2470022290945053,
0.39369601011276245,
-0.6289663910865784,
-0.10198464244604111,
-0.845074474811554,
-0.19678279757499695,
-0.24835357069969177,
-0.36215946078300476,
-0.4471513628959656,
-0.36447426676750183,
0.5492121577262878,
0.21152611076831818,
0.16020725667476654,
0.1215529665350914,
-0.30386584997177124,
0.8127307891845703,
0.8567715287208557,
0.19331245124340057,
0.21082483232021332,
0.19498208165168762,
-0.2629476487636566,
-0.018803996965289116,
-0.6645563840866089,
-0.07621630281209946,
1.3308708667755127,
0.06367925554513931,
1.0058131217956543,
0.038195520639419556,
0.7482182383537292,
0.4047631025314331,
0.1436399221420288,
-1.0852274894714355,
0.39565300941467285,
-0.04020315781235695,
-0.23942069709300995,
-0.3649042844772339,
-0.18827058374881744,
-0.9855186343193054,
0.03937103971838951,
-0.23908503353595734,
-0.6264365911483765,
0.22918371856212616,
0.34806501865386963,
-0.5017320513725281,
0.40725740790367126,
-0.44040408730506897,
0.6004101037979126,
-0.4637589454650879,
-0.3938898742198944,
-0.49010559916496277,
-0.24306347966194153,
0.10972326248884201,
0.27575138211250305,
-0.23189587891101837,
0.23393476009368896,
0.20252393186092377,
0.5264491438865662,
-0.14441756904125214,
0.6928271055221558,
-0.3488815724849701,
-0.09265346080064774,
0.3180607855319977,
0.43295302987098694,
0.5920079350471497,
0.10318206995725632,
0.11826706677675247,
-0.10086529701948166,
-0.43625375628471375,
-0.15269654989242554,
-0.7433881163597107,
0.6897929906845093,
-0.7110259532928467,
-0.8033575415611267,
-0.16595309972763062,
-0.5093215703964233,
-0.34676727652549744,
0.14562395215034485,
0.306322306394577,
0.1628187894821167,
-0.5126140713691711,
0.22745196521282196,
0.8142551779747009,
-0.2596796452999115,
0.08507489413022995,
0.18052148818969727,
-0.3690001964569092,
-0.6482828855514526,
0.9403795003890991,
-0.31287404894828796,
0.013173893094062805,
0.42650389671325684,
0.269037663936615,
-0.38848981261253357,
-0.7508329749107361,
-0.6406245231628418,
0.01622691936790943,
-0.30709221959114075,
-0.08378969877958298,
-0.6134400963783264,
-0.08841828256845474,
-0.02097255550324917,
-0.31194591522216797,
0.048193104565143585,
-0.11025938391685486,
-0.46410897374153137,
-0.2895301282405853,
0.39334216713905334,
0.6759589910507202,
-0.040508367121219635,
0.4271118938922882,
-0.6541945338249207,
0.17767596244812012,
0.4840293824672699,
0.5338240265846252,
0.08183421939611435,
-0.07493080198764801,
-0.41791144013404846,
-0.03374147415161133,
-0.7007766366004944,
-0.7949960231781006,
0.4892759323120117,
0.026768116280436516,
0.5809619426727295,
0.8504641056060791,
0.086613729596138,
0.32304656505584717,
-0.12709268927574158,
0.7477613091468811,
0.08282043039798737,
-0.4951435625553131,
0.761832594871521,
-0.4381319284439087,
0.20374387502670288,
0.5539649724960327,
0.5839188098907471,
-0.5734977722167969,
-0.11202028393745422,
-0.49539363384246826,
-0.9721693992614746,
0.707261323928833,
0.0021985562052577734,
0.31272637844085693,
0.08358325809240341,
0.3986799120903015,
0.2547832131385803,
0.2567143440246582,
-0.45016777515411377,
-0.19604474306106567,
-0.09278145432472229,
0.17894798517227173,
-0.16411049664020538,
-0.7337726354598999,
-0.42360037565231323,
0.04282349720597267,
0.48117366433143616,
-0.1663787066936493,
0.22001239657402039,
0.088642418384552,
-0.2740153968334198,
-0.4952072501182556,
0.38876813650131226,
0.28977373242378235,
0.4128863215446472,
-0.3735775649547577,
-0.0994688868522644,
0.12027536332607269,
-0.20288267731666565,
0.038203831762075424,
0.10015300661325455,
-0.3940466642379761,
-0.3812856078147888,
-0.11514011770486832,
0.9663868546485901,
0.23734675347805023,
-0.7494319081306458,
0.44708696007728577,
-0.15341676771640778,
-0.28513652086257935,
-0.3247578740119934,
0.5717833042144775,
0.05502484366297722,
0.31486597657203674,
0.19626641273498535,
0.19927456974983215,
0.24972014129161835,
-0.34318971633911133,
0.003698256565257907,
0.6769548058509827,
-0.6247022151947021,
-0.10957882553339005,
0.6534212231636047,
0.35672497749328613,
-0.29036223888397217,
0.6769654154777527,
-0.08691764622926712,
-0.4656561315059662,
0.373065710067749,
0.5972435474395752,
1.2443374395370483,
0.038978688418865204,
0.2873654067516327,
0.27079078555107117,
0.21444718539714813,
0.18591326475143433,
0.2405940145254135,
-0.47638896107673645,
-0.9151584506034851,
-0.16684630513191223,
-0.4713887572288513,
-0.6732224225997925,
0.15053433179855347,
-0.7403082251548767,
0.3303157389163971,
-0.22077319025993347,
0.09910982847213745,
-0.23038695752620697,
-0.07265853881835938,
-0.6815510392189026,
-0.05038462206721306,
-0.2091071605682373,
0.8686825037002563,
-0.4218670725822449,
0.43078628182411194,
0.5706043839454651,
-0.34247028827667236,
-0.335006982088089,
0.10239732265472412,
-0.14737366139888763,
-0.9559851884841919,
0.3125897943973541,
0.11762364208698273,
-0.25858432054519653,
0.11861225962638855,
-0.48896050453186035,
-0.6500911712646484,
0.9399380683898926,
0.1653587371110916,
-0.5135095119476318,
0.0355246365070343,
0.010395364835858345,
0.3782808780670166,
-0.31003087759017944,
0.3626345694065094,
0.28268763422966003,
0.16598232090473175,
0.22659841179847717,
-0.2809450626373291,
-0.09017001837491989,
-0.40367746353149414,
0.06802262365818024,
0.2907782196998596,
-0.3365139365196228,
0.13430094718933105,
-0.6647942662239075,
-0.13777710497379303,
0.17665675282478333,
0.43391671776771545,
0.2514015734195709,
0.31061479449272156,
0.7722617387771606,
0.6030965447425842,
0.4498351514339447,
0.18643175065517426,
1.2553696632385254,
-0.1931970715522766,
0.35466286540031433,
0.6633809208869934,
-0.2290262132883072,
0.7855960726737976,
0.3676242530345917,
-0.29168134927749634,
0.2828602194786072,
0.7491538524627686,
-0.19246028363704681,
0.6556358933448792,
0.39305800199508667,
-0.39295151829719543,
-0.17483505606651306,
-0.08342930674552917,
-0.31685835123062134,
0.1635204404592514,
0.24822495877742767,
-0.20947282016277313,
-0.16804303228855133,
-0.07129523903131485,
-0.17823952436447144,
-0.13441993296146393,
-0.10877680033445358,
1.1457408666610718,
-0.1346137970685959,
-0.8270975947380066,
0.5573261380195618,
-0.05408599600195885,
0.7986944317817688,
-0.6897249221801758,
-0.04628368839621544,
-0.4651046395301819,
-0.20776022970676422,
-0.06873679906129837,
-0.4134468734264374,
-0.1291283369064331,
0.1792440563440323,
-0.3127560615539551,
-0.18026535212993622,
0.8047424554824829,
-0.42582687735557556,
-0.32354775071144104,
0.2870100438594818,
0.6661432385444641,
-0.04825577884912491,
-0.22176885604858398,
-0.22621384263038635,
-0.43130284547805786,
0.2439204901456833,
-0.34302687644958496,
0.4542562663555145,
-0.08320445567369461,
0.1234031692147255,
0.720686137676239,
1.0912986993789673,
0.2977999150753021,
-0.18401645123958588,
0.10892093926668167,
0.9221959114074707,
-0.7503470778465271,
-0.5038483738899231,
-0.6607874035835266,
0.288871705532074,
0.0806666687130928,
-0.18249017000198364,
0.5540691018104553,
0.6024048924446106,
0.9925874471664429,
-0.2024088054895401,
1.0123361349105835,
0.3346811830997467,
0.28978246450424194,
-0.5186281800270081,
0.7027813196182251,
-0.7064493298530579,
0.5532074570655823,
0.015586961060762405,
-1.0724700689315796,
-0.048892464488744736,
0.020650116726756096,
-0.3601970374584198,
0.06391283124685287,
0.39516210556030273,
0.822371244430542,
-0.11736742407083511,
0.23054419457912445,
0.2102203369140625,
-0.06218327209353447,
0.33064404129981995,
0.3611578643321991,
1.07778000831604,
0.04000922664999962,
0.6814157366752625,
-0.3235948383808136,
-0.3301829993724823,
-0.498140811920166,
-0.6429763436317444,
-0.5997400283813477,
-0.2616477608680725,
0.009847932495176792,
-0.25148841738700867,
0.1894560605287552,
1.0531545877456665,
0.34231993556022644,
-0.7409865260124207,
-0.45877060294151306,
-0.063878133893013,
0.09273984283208847,
-0.4747515916824341,
-0.19350318610668182,
0.4730708599090576,
-0.42295509576797485,
-0.741133987903595,
0.8239264488220215,
0.2235250174999237,
0.08050958812236786,
-0.49127140641212463,
-0.046530015766620636,
0.26143786311149597,
-0.14218679070472717,
0.5336790084838867,
0.2776874303817749,
-0.6520384550094604,
-0.004720109980553389,
0.30111992359161377,
0.26976752281188965,
0.001607256825082004,
1.266160249710083,
-0.7673750519752502,
0.9378133416175842,
0.33282235264778137,
0.7599760890007019,
0.8977583050727844,
0.040380701422691345,
0.7467925548553467,
-0.6399749517440796,
-0.18180419504642487,
0.09893348067998886,
0.24479764699935913,
0.17583729326725006,
-0.48430484533309937,
0.43923595547676086,
0.02213166281580925,
-0.4712894558906555,
-0.61909419298172,
0.3055410385131836,
-0.8569900989532471,
-0.04314304515719414,
1.0767862796783447,
-0.048691462725400925,
0.19720876216888428,
0.0754433125257492,
-0.5065094828605652,
-0.003101001726463437,
-0.5036783814430237,
1.0383548736572266,
0.34969788789749146,
-0.3084009885787964,
0.048715490847826004,
-0.3384339213371277,
0.49060583114624023,
0.44667547941207886,
-0.5909823775291443,
0.05892203003168106,
0.3384811580181122,
0.11422812193632126,
-0.01295411866158247,
0.5192644596099854,
0.05703401938080788,
0.29829561710357666,
-0.28013017773628235,
0.09426180273294449,
-0.29737767577171326,
-0.2366970330476761,
-0.38711461424827576,
0.3775894343852997,
0.35569071769714355,
-0.27872273325920105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05232v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05232v2
|
Improving Logits-based Detector without Logits from Black-box LLMs
| 2024-06-07T19:38:05 | 2024-06-11T16:41:52 |
Cong Zeng, Shengkun Tang, Xianjun Yang, Yuanzhou Chen, Yiyou Sun, zhiqiang xu, Yao Li, Haifeng Chen, Wei Cheng, Dongkuan Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has revolutionized text
generation, producing outputs that closely mimic human writing. This blurring
of lines between machine- and human-written text presents new challenges in
distinguishing one from the other a task further complicated by the frequent
updates and closed nature of leading proprietary LLMs. Traditional logits-based
detection methods leverage surrogate models for identifying LLM-generated
content when the exact logits are unavailable from black-box LLMs. However,
these methods grapple with the misalignment between the distributions of the
surrogate and the often undisclosed target models, leading to performance
degradation, particularly with the introduction of new, closed-source models.
Furthermore, while current methodologies are generally effective when the
source model is identified, they falter in scenarios where the model version
remains unknown, or the test set comprises outputs from various source models.
To address these limitations, we present Distribution-Aligned LLMs Detection
(DALD), an innovative framework that redefines the state-of-the-art performance
in black-box text detection even without logits from source LLMs. DALD is
designed to align the surrogate model's distribution with that of unknown
target LLMs, ensuring enhanced detection capability and resilience against
rapid model iterations with minimal training investment. By leveraging corpus
samples from publicly accessible outputs of advanced models such as ChatGPT,
GPT-4 and Claude-3, DALD fine-tunes surrogate models to synchronize with
unknown source model distributions effectively.
|
[
-0.1251729428768158,
-0.6436887979507446,
0.6837115287780762,
-0.11444141715765,
-0.6599698066711426,
0.3507370948791504,
-0.08883655071258545,
-0.495799720287323,
0.21482299268245697,
0.7763551473617554,
-0.7123426198959351,
-0.7568469643592834,
-0.6343286037445068,
0.1757170408964157,
-0.5065856575965881,
0.9002816677093506,
0.07477645576000214,
-0.3019808232784271,
-0.24432061612606049,
-0.1341828852891922,
-0.3651660680770874,
-0.46748706698417664,
-0.6748945116996765,
-0.14925332367420197,
0.24996136128902435,
0.0636628046631813,
0.4269234538078308,
0.515207827091217,
0.5633628368377686,
0.18719211220741272,
-0.21900516748428345,
0.4925364553928375,
-0.5347371697425842,
0.18771231174468994,
0.010253183543682098,
-0.39362746477127075,
-0.41741979122161865,
-0.419285386800766,
0.758921205997467,
0.25955694913864136,
-0.10962565988302231,
0.14806067943572998,
0.037188079208135605,
0.5943247079849243,
-0.9974986910820007,
-0.1663684993982315,
-0.8310726284980774,
-0.2447749227285385,
-0.4327940046787262,
-0.3923851251602173,
-0.8395846486091614,
-0.21424241364002228,
-0.3331218957901001,
-0.22300660610198975,
0.578860342502594,
-0.2175523191690445,
0.8772224187850952,
0.31279507279396057,
-0.48805972933769226,
-0.27358007431030273,
-0.6985268592834473,
0.6477718353271484,
-0.8113545775413513,
0.49394476413726807,
0.2887144684791565,
0.19651378691196442,
-0.31275564432144165,
-0.3648577630519867,
-0.4902418553829193,
0.02148250862956047,
-0.2186780720949173,
-0.027610350400209427,
-0.3231545686721802,
-0.10992752760648727,
0.09530532360076904,
0.1266399323940277,
-0.7032319903373718,
0.14431069791316986,
-0.11690322309732437,
-0.34483975172042847,
0.7431122064590454,
0.02528737299144268,
0.05868363380432129,
-0.09338050335645676,
-0.3624936044216156,
0.02090408466756344,
-0.8864152431488037,
-0.4956011176109314,
0.5100919604301453,
0.15653865039348602,
-0.13099971413612366,
0.555519700050354,
-0.04888875409960747,
0.7136310935020447,
0.08996960520744324,
0.010935582220554352,
0.40543559193611145,
-0.40165582299232483,
-0.18624931573867798,
0.04130132123827934,
0.833283007144928,
0.18095140159130096,
0.17053468525409698,
-0.16397030651569366,
-0.5650084614753723,
0.3542857766151428,
0.08191519230604172,
-0.6953610777854919,
-0.23774395883083344,
0.17223714292049408,
-0.188410222530365,
-0.5594661831855774,
-0.17461220920085907,
-0.7215002775192261,
-0.691584587097168,
0.01889464072883129,
0.3295910954475403,
-0.21267399191856384,
-0.43957459926605225,
0.10135193169116974,
-0.12317776679992676,
-0.008616767823696136,
0.1654471755027771,
-0.8946779370307922,
0.15858307480812073,
0.532526433467865,
0.8547500371932983,
-0.27307432889938354,
0.10701783746480942,
-0.9692956209182739,
0.5364358425140381,
-0.5054358243942261,
1.1144237518310547,
-0.5461574792861938,
-0.3304789662361145,
-0.047575145959854126,
0.03841719031333923,
0.07993222773075104,
-0.7235092520713806,
0.6540999412536621,
-0.6230942010879517,
-0.15882234275341034,
0.15767259895801544,
-0.7837870121002197,
0.2789265513420105,
0.19969412684440613,
-0.7369551658630371,
1.1738712787628174,
-0.04065695032477379,
-0.8609188199043274,
0.2921234667301178,
-0.46999919414520264,
-0.21338430047035217,
0.24521607160568237,
-0.26626548171043396,
-0.7681761384010315,
0.2218479961156845,
0.38443824648857117,
0.5182386040687561,
-0.01938733458518982,
0.3648005723953247,
-0.47925812005996704,
-0.45330601930618286,
0.22459131479263306,
-0.6750035881996155,
0.7545214891433716,
0.06892769783735275,
-0.20638246834278107,
0.0641179159283638,
-0.8808652758598328,
-0.09015169739723206,
0.0909809023141861,
-0.19632846117019653,
-0.46374568343162537,
0.13355307281017303,
0.032593026757240295,
-0.18365724384784698,
0.286668986082077,
-0.684401273727417,
-0.05747321620583534,
-0.18125352263450623,
0.14884470403194427,
0.9999293684959412,
0.05003898963332176,
0.27978605031967163,
-0.20991721749305725,
0.5593844652175903,
0.05515127629041672,
-0.019313765689730644,
-0.374545156955719,
-0.289216548204422,
-0.5062215328216553,
-0.7340989112854004,
0.4128979444503784,
0.43141889572143555,
-0.45366179943084717,
0.5852117538452148,
-0.30935126543045044,
-0.46858230233192444,
-0.5714759826660156,
0.36949682235717773,
0.2838175892829895,
0.23779520392417908,
0.1354178935289383,
-0.2827838659286499,
-0.592715322971344,
-0.7854386568069458,
-0.3492627739906311,
-0.14282135665416718,
0.050953637808561325,
-0.19460339844226837,
0.3223838210105896,
-0.3651120364665985,
0.8046888113021851,
-0.7474967241287231,
-0.23301349580287933,
-0.12989330291748047,
-0.08540553599596024,
0.10477469116449356,
0.28198006749153137,
0.35155007243156433,
-0.7295801043510437,
-0.5016255974769592,
0.16331200301647186,
-0.6707403659820557,
-0.5736029148101807,
0.0029441530350595713,
-0.2409927397966385,
0.4166804552078247,
0.7355363965034485,
-0.7798916697502136,
0.4231390655040741,
0.7255517840385437,
-0.4199196696281433,
0.6982438564300537,
0.10452379286289215,
-0.1823258101940155,
-1.0253615379333496,
0.12661707401275635,
-0.02555428445339203,
-0.5310707092285156,
-0.7057484984397888,
0.033212680369615555,
0.47969573736190796,
0.09139228612184525,
-0.29615211486816406,
0.7930107116699219,
-0.5232053995132446,
-0.13759927451610565,
-0.4430058002471924,
0.22307653725147247,
0.1870056688785553,
0.17396360635757446,
0.15578433871269226,
0.8576091527938843,
0.22921770811080933,
-0.43047937750816345,
0.19577708840370178,
0.012506537139415741,
-0.23304417729377747,
0.6549005508422852,
-0.468574196100235,
0.010493737645447254,
-0.1879664957523346,
0.32924985885620117,
-0.984731137752533,
0.004527973476797342,
0.4206945300102234,
-0.47839874029159546,
0.40459927916526794,
-0.29508474469184875,
-0.6246412992477417,
0.06275417655706406,
-0.3992636501789093,
0.3914509117603302,
0.5964836478233337,
-0.5506362318992615,
0.4789309501647949,
0.13914607465267181,
-0.03798110410571098,
-0.6827282309532166,
-0.5332480669021606,
0.01721266284584999,
-0.28954553604125977,
-0.5045900940895081,
0.18582652509212494,
-0.20637045800685883,
-0.05145538970828056,
0.10940318554639816,
-0.4031052887439728,
-0.10633290559053421,
0.08897814154624939,
-0.015060696750879288,
0.48730021715164185,
-0.25956034660339355,
0.3422689139842987,
0.06377728283405304,
-0.2218756526708603,
-0.056380681693553925,
-0.25623422861099243,
0.4834507405757904,
0.32047030329704285,
-0.5467481017112732,
-0.3665344715118408,
0.24728088080883026,
0.6088334321975708,
-0.46325525641441345,
0.6659579277038574,
0.7339569330215454,
-0.4820936620235443,
-0.3639548420906067,
-0.7200517654418945,
-0.1287394016981125,
-0.504364013671875,
0.27662166953086853,
-0.3466777503490448,
-0.7585119009017944,
0.16469356417655945,
-0.06721381843090057,
0.01763926073908806,
0.20105893909931183,
0.496995210647583,
0.028969954699277878,
0.8391656279563904,
0.6047913432121277,
0.1385134607553482,
0.45169538259506226,
0.0243544839322567,
0.3948352634906769,
-0.9225965142250061,
-0.04020943120121956,
-0.3585110902786255,
0.06716113537549973,
-0.4233763813972473,
-0.28983113169670105,
0.14049620926380157,
0.0775291696190834,
0.03431713953614235,
0.3967097997665405,
-0.538895308971405,
0.6875534653663635,
0.3592461049556732,
0.1996932476758957,
0.699420690536499,
0.16211965680122375,
0.05035325139760971,
0.20165111124515533,
-0.4618300795555115,
-0.6603988409042358,
1.4318686723709106,
0.22944481670856476,
0.8137543797492981,
0.2324080914258957,
1.0583418607711792,
0.5835471153259277,
0.5047284960746765,
-0.2354617565870285,
0.6129130125045776,
-0.23398233950138092,
-0.5643452405929565,
-0.08937148004770279,
-0.4012369215488434,
-1.0186361074447632,
0.32806631922721863,
-0.08997312188148499,
-0.835618257522583,
0.22888532280921936,
0.19406698644161224,
-0.13465872406959534,
0.40316739678382874,
-0.9863717555999756,
0.9143158793449402,
0.14199385046958923,
-0.41563087701797485,
0.018415389582514763,
-0.0812804251909256,
0.6012147665023804,
-0.38692179322242737,
0.2079300880432129,
-0.42806434631347656,
-0.08361345529556274,
0.35934093594551086,
-0.28737345337867737,
0.9479647278785706,
0.024998407810926437,
-0.47679683566093445,
0.3301294147968292,
0.2715524733066559,
0.8785287737846375,
0.0020083312410861254,
0.04767090827226639,
0.11341531574726105,
-0.05896038934588432,
-0.548301100730896,
-0.4848669767379761,
0.7092077732086182,
-0.37596094608306885,
-0.6794478893280029,
-0.34993410110473633,
-0.6041244268417358,
0.118778295814991,
0.25881698727607727,
0.2968767285346985,
0.4099593758583069,
-0.047783903777599335,
-0.06483636051416397,
0.7473896145820618,
0.07601633667945862,
0.37061187624931335,
0.5002016425132751,
-0.3003615736961365,
-0.34185582399368286,
0.7884560227394104,
-0.3793468177318573,
0.5556777119636536,
0.5744317173957825,
-0.13265466690063477,
-0.6733575463294983,
-0.7097110748291016,
-0.4639591574668884,
0.5115340948104858,
-0.8402591347694397,
-0.431490957736969,
-0.5509358644485474,
-0.325420081615448,
-0.33685043454170227,
-0.15163558721542358,
-0.23958781361579895,
-0.0975441187620163,
-0.3251701593399048,
-0.16735246777534485,
0.36700668931007385,
0.5100196003913879,
-0.013195536099374294,
0.3312249183654785,
-0.8183999061584473,
0.46541664004325867,
0.12350708991289139,
0.4194697439670563,
-0.23555584251880646,
-0.4625033438205719,
-0.023698553442955017,
0.060186535120010376,
-0.4076722264289856,
-0.8900328874588013,
0.4209887981414795,
-0.031082531437277794,
0.32993099093437195,
0.33495640754699707,
0.27858251333236694,
0.5715568661689758,
-0.44643253087997437,
0.3964913487434387,
0.1804526299238205,
-1.0483124256134033,
0.45938581228256226,
-0.15299497544765472,
0.09068681299686432,
0.19147540628910065,
-0.02362873964011669,
-0.25920483469963074,
-0.7076989412307739,
-0.4970549941062927,
-0.37903568148612976,
0.5933642983436584,
0.46298494935035706,
0.05389414727687836,
-0.1345815658569336,
0.1279246211051941,
0.13639798760414124,
0.25515496730804443,
-0.9982011318206787,
0.09721499681472778,
0.19761116802692413,
-0.5402295589447021,
-0.24498261511325836,
-0.23309524357318878,
-0.049697551876306534,
0.2869310975074768,
0.6478891372680664,
-0.09908939898014069,
0.018150223419070244,
0.21530896425247192,
-0.261694997549057,
-0.33575549721717834,
0.2921231985092163,
0.523360013961792,
0.44831418991088867,
-0.4166867434978485,
0.46428102254867554,
0.05177972838282585,
-0.6023653149604797,
0.47292351722717285,
0.10488720238208771,
-0.4913632869720459,
0.33190327882766724,
0.5233377814292908,
0.6242129802703857,
0.07723833620548248,
-1.0766834020614624,
0.584489643573761,
0.08336056023836136,
-0.027552714571356773,
-0.34344935417175293,
0.2024993896484375,
0.20333682000637054,
0.41748684644699097,
0.3476084768772125,
0.13390499353408813,
-0.15374000370502472,
-0.22012661397457123,
0.30130535364151,
0.8917432427406311,
-0.2392047941684723,
-0.26497316360473633,
0.6335318088531494,
0.17984236776828766,
-0.5219719409942627,
0.30191487073898315,
-0.28860968351364136,
-0.22652393579483032,
0.6577611565589905,
0.6676479578018188,
0.9711363911628723,
-0.341405987739563,
0.3465419411659241,
0.07196682691574097,
0.5987054705619812,
-0.010560659691691399,
0.09291639924049377,
-0.09152539819478989,
-0.9006307721138,
-0.48032882809638977,
-0.6809777617454529,
-0.015336612239480019,
0.45444345474243164,
-0.4556635022163391,
0.7439661026000977,
-0.25055304169654846,
-0.037483688443899155,
-0.012908579781651497,
-0.17611552774906158,
-0.4414929151535034,
-0.01703820936381817,
0.16098426282405853,
0.8280215859413147,
-1.0031555891036987,
0.7083228230476379,
0.4778881072998047,
0.015481590293347836,
-0.20588171482086182,
0.19265864789485931,
-0.10933580249547958,
-0.7406803965568542,
0.3537687659263611,
0.30369099974632263,
-0.11923010647296906,
0.28199565410614014,
-0.43118807673454285,
-0.6897231340408325,
1.1872398853302002,
0.6462681889533997,
-0.7898314595222473,
0.14462053775787354,
-0.09872950613498688,
0.37878745794296265,
-0.19867290556430817,
0.2924686372280121,
0.49126750230789185,
0.21640823781490326,
0.030752170830965042,
-0.6855743527412415,
0.25347068905830383,
-0.1336725652217865,
-0.18374450504779816,
0.7796398997306824,
-0.42429202795028687,
0.4999542832374573,
-0.02538474090397358,
-0.5138645172119141,
0.10375910997390747,
0.2859818637371063,
0.7771257162094116,
0.5344336032867432,
0.500450074672699,
0.7136049866676331,
0.7373868227005005,
0.24323159456253052,
0.9019721746444702,
-0.018923141062259674,
0.2987724244594574,
0.8932098150253296,
-0.5550295114517212,
0.9057772755622864,
0.5556376576423645,
-0.16068711876869202,
0.4661243259906769,
0.5549069046974182,
-0.08627212047576904,
0.6120944023132324,
0.11840686202049255,
-0.6963834166526794,
-0.46158483624458313,
-0.03614574670791626,
-0.34059077501296997,
-0.01506518293172121,
0.3197938799858093,
-0.25191712379455566,
-0.45226505398750305,
-0.41015365719795227,
-0.14213548600673676,
0.2570326626300812,
-0.02749960869550705,
0.47752973437309265,
-0.06694675981998444,
-0.4541968107223511,
0.9366297125816345,
-0.04635924845933914,
0.719272792339325,
-0.7082287669181824,
-0.008868061937391758,
-0.3968779146671295,
0.23254571855068207,
-0.20944297313690186,
-0.5535694360733032,
0.37068119645118713,
0.29908570647239685,
-0.08778262138366699,
0.18612828850746155,
0.9544768333435059,
-0.5223054885864258,
-0.7383996844291687,
0.3425515294075012,
0.4574192464351654,
0.07506603747606277,
-0.05693221837282181,
-0.21159875392913818,
0.4737294912338257,
0.06977497786283493,
-0.021196065470576286,
0.32601398229599,
0.5954017639160156,
-0.11358951032161713,
0.7008962631225586,
0.7574442625045776,
0.12793201208114624,
0.20972618460655212,
-0.14902746677398682,
0.6568536162376404,
-0.6196448802947998,
-0.3919394314289093,
-1.0621570348739624,
0.41110163927078247,
-0.24523065984249115,
0.03184520825743675,
0.5459849238395691,
0.6557925343513489,
0.8402910828590393,
-0.18523460626602173,
0.8185328841209412,
0.3770695924758911,
0.3507375419139862,
-0.6938143372535706,
0.3981279730796814,
-0.4625735580921173,
0.7354456186294556,
-0.3522738516330719,
-1.0405164957046509,
-0.4173494279384613,
0.18209578096866608,
-0.05601310729980469,
-0.31797197461128235,
0.7436175346374512,
1.0879802703857422,
-0.4018002450466156,
-0.21389757096767426,
0.4647979736328125,
0.04740028828382492,
0.4045315384864807,
0.5834115743637085,
0.9107787013053894,
-0.4443974792957306,
0.929382860660553,
-0.008812637068331242,
-0.1940835416316986,
-0.2697407007217407,
-1.0167077779769897,
-1.115708827972412,
-0.3876293897628784,
-0.5207526087760925,
-0.12434416264295578,
0.2952222526073456,
0.35297179222106934,
0.5928269028663635,
-0.6622037887573242,
-0.13941875100135803,
-0.3947923183441162,
0.3227153420448303,
-0.1524374932050705,
-0.275130033493042,
0.4564133286476135,
-0.30443665385246277,
-0.7280303239822388,
0.31393682956695557,
0.3161505162715912,
0.23437310755252838,
-0.16407868266105652,
-0.11252174526453018,
-0.19334478676319122,
0.21280673146247864,
0.4518795907497406,
0.05801839008927345,
-0.7793459892272949,
-0.25571486353874207,
-0.05632208660244942,
0.048442136496305466,
0.013162589631974697,
0.500781238079071,
-0.8341867923736572,
0.23743745684623718,
0.3120914399623871,
0.7736959457397461,
0.5037469863891602,
0.12240771949291229,
0.32995906472206116,
-1.1437829732894897,
0.238105908036232,
0.07515671104192734,
0.0995420292019844,
0.5279268026351929,
-0.5001083016395569,
0.5433026552200317,
0.45337703824043274,
-0.3966311812400818,
-1.4123961925506592,
0.5258741974830627,
-0.6768290400505066,
-0.3024236559867859,
1.090898036956787,
-0.04451477900147438,
-0.11765800416469574,
-0.038416482508182526,
-0.18520767986774445,
0.0704459473490715,
-0.4050906002521515,
0.7151908874511719,
0.7344725131988525,
0.137468621134758,
-0.36992865800857544,
-0.5188146233558655,
0.33871424198150635,
0.46562278270721436,
-0.6953874826431274,
0.3579965829849243,
0.5613330006599426,
0.2697564661502838,
0.023920802399516106,
0.8945238590240479,
-0.08526146411895752,
0.20701150596141815,
-0.01786503568291664,
0.16897766292095184,
0.17952615022659302,
-0.15041585266590118,
-0.35395845770835876,
0.06813940405845642,
0.0142973642796278,
-0.47815921902656555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05213v1
|
On Subjective Uncertainty Quantification and Calibration in Natural Language Generation
| 2024-06-07T18:54:40 | 2024-06-07T18:54:40 |
Ziyu Wang, Chris Holmes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Applications of large language models often involve the generation of
free-form responses, in which case uncertainty quantification becomes
challenging. This is due to the need to identify task-specific uncertainties
(e.g., about the semantics) which appears difficult to define in general cases.
This work addresses these challenges from a perspective of Bayesian decision
theory, starting from the assumption that our utility is characterized by a
similarity measure that compares a generated response with a hypothetical true
response. We discuss how this assumption enables principled quantification of
the model's subjective uncertainty and its calibration. We further derive a
measure for epistemic uncertainty, based on a missing data perspective and its
characterization as an excess risk. The proposed measures can be applied to
black-box language models. We demonstrate the proposed methods on question
answering and machine translation tasks, where they extract broadly meaningful
uncertainty estimates from GPT and Gemini models and quantify their
calibration.
|
[
-0.442310631275177,
-0.9722267389297485,
0.911255419254303,
-0.1640382558107376,
0.07460898905992508,
-0.1958606094121933,
-0.13512754440307617,
-0.10551706701517105,
-0.2660636305809021,
0.5714389681816101,
-0.4669512212276459,
-0.19996479153633118,
-0.6958695650100708,
-0.08303365111351013,
-0.05795523151755333,
1.0839531421661377,
-0.08658137917518616,
-0.4352574050426483,
-0.2620983421802521,
0.004940828308463097,
-0.3170700669288635,
-0.47579318284988403,
-0.47359699010849,
0.0013918509939685464,
0.40534064173698425,
0.10164617002010345,
1.1546521186828613,
0.07876145839691162,
0.43185898661613464,
0.27342283725738525,
0.1733151078224182,
-0.20584295690059662,
-0.05378362908959389,
0.25694170594215393,
-0.24690333008766174,
-0.6166384816169739,
-0.1416846066713333,
-0.06250780075788498,
0.4895908236503601,
1.1840283870697021,
-0.1760256290435791,
0.28935036063194275,
-0.037913188338279724,
0.6069972515106201,
-0.850718080997467,
0.0948868840932846,
-0.7090712189674377,
0.13023392856121063,
0.21780894696712494,
0.035473886877298355,
-0.10604362189769745,
-0.574361264705658,
0.6121990084648132,
-0.5776022672653198,
0.39494985342025757,
0.07787934690713882,
0.8314240574836731,
0.5000591278076172,
-0.6387602686882019,
-0.2950538396835327,
-0.9473353624343872,
0.9938173890113831,
-0.9729412794113159,
0.24852123856544495,
0.6759812235832214,
0.2554378807544708,
-0.17688173055648804,
-0.14197060465812683,
-0.7119925022125244,
-0.24766357243061066,
0.1492389589548111,
0.0554719977080822,
-0.23984740674495697,
0.17194241285324097,
0.18231509625911713,
0.46522092819213867,
-0.5633280873298645,
-0.3253329396247864,
-0.13690267503261566,
-0.31735196709632874,
0.47426941990852356,
0.026408571749925613,
0.12038355320692062,
-0.36315810680389404,
0.019903842359781265,
-0.02655499242246151,
-0.46423250436782837,
0.03676185384392738,
0.8029546141624451,
0.273369163274765,
-0.05259167402982712,
0.7452284693717957,
-0.2536824941635132,
0.8108866810798645,
0.07681730389595032,
0.1352861523628235,
0.06099500507116318,
-0.2198316901922226,
-0.40413862466812134,
-0.07874719798564911,
0.6665074229240417,
0.15702970325946808,
0.2565580904483795,
-0.21727442741394043,
-0.0211423859000206,
0.11286299675703049,
0.5803323984146118,
-0.41518720984458923,
-0.08213779330253601,
0.5020500421524048,
0.02273806557059288,
-0.3582268953323364,
0.08851904422044754,
-0.4584754407405853,
-0.09485268592834473,
-0.40369904041290283,
0.6436944603919983,
-0.2645377814769745,
-0.4573829770088196,
0.26603856682777405,
-0.0311018954962492,
0.1869650036096573,
0.13460089266300201,
-0.7750917673110962,
0.2912338078022003,
0.6098059415817261,
0.3503725230693817,
0.09303498268127441,
0.12106620520353317,
-0.3806596100330353,
0.3296859562397003,
-0.6317522525787354,
0.44599291682243347,
-0.2038934975862503,
-0.3682039678096771,
-0.07634342461824417,
-0.3417568802833557,
0.09952540695667267,
-0.2291889488697052,
0.5201828479766846,
-0.1936238408088684,
0.6013044118881226,
-0.3727344274520874,
-0.5981360077857971,
-0.30735236406326294,
0.32394519448280334,
-0.38893839716911316,
0.9090856909751892,
0.5191172957420349,
-1.1071118116378784,
0.5275992751121521,
-0.1452060490846634,
-0.2805578112602234,
0.055668361485004425,
-0.1526467204093933,
-0.28867268562316895,
0.6264992952346802,
-0.16952553391456604,
0.5635941624641418,
-0.6257209777832031,
0.6006640195846558,
-0.4718153774738312,
0.13278689980506897,
0.7683357000350952,
-0.6056510210037231,
0.4177749454975128,
0.33843663334846497,
-0.34571173787117004,
-0.24544081091880798,
-0.815021812915802,
0.3966798484325409,
-0.17865000665187836,
-0.1551564633846283,
-0.6772498488426208,
0.14712852239608765,
-0.09261587262153625,
0.27397844195365906,
0.22238929569721222,
-0.560495138168335,
-0.32074370980262756,
-0.7406855821609497,
0.24664101004600525,
0.584060549736023,
0.23387636244297028,
0.4280034601688385,
-0.3295474052429199,
0.25301891565322876,
-0.03502398356795311,
-0.01779189705848694,
0.4107452630996704,
-0.6248338222503662,
-0.8527445197105408,
0.13578063249588013,
0.26652899384498596,
0.6096572875976562,
-0.6447408199310303,
0.6762228012084961,
-0.36905384063720703,
-0.39538705348968506,
-0.6308046579360962,
-0.049219369888305664,
0.48949792981147766,
0.438740998506546,
0.08461820334196091,
-0.34551361203193665,
-0.10972931981086731,
-1.0863341093063354,
-0.33154746890068054,
-0.47400733828544617,
-0.47963935136795044,
0.2977929711341858,
0.3470856845378876,
-0.0360666885972023,
1.2182904481887817,
-0.5754583477973938,
0.4179837107658386,
0.11182215809822083,
0.5699673295021057,
0.13926273584365845,
0.375263512134552,
0.3707664906978607,
-0.8956139087677002,
-0.20221206545829773,
0.09323947131633759,
-0.6798939108848572,
-0.14439807832241058,
-0.1401570439338684,
-0.06793063133955002,
0.23249657452106476,
0.000985915306955576,
-0.650678277015686,
0.44418251514434814,
0.4217466711997986,
-0.14707179367542267,
0.37431618571281433,
-0.37425029277801514,
0.2949898838996887,
-1.2810428142547607,
0.1765616089105606,
0.3039133846759796,
-0.1465170532464981,
-0.7328457236289978,
0.2190430760383606,
-0.03344982489943504,
0.13202688097953796,
-0.40949761867523193,
0.38116300106048584,
-0.1638926863670349,
-0.13281835615634918,
-0.3023488521575928,
0.18538382649421692,
-0.07379475235939026,
0.32952001690864563,
0.13111472129821777,
0.42896538972854614,
0.38870492577552795,
-0.7249032258987427,
0.21005335450172424,
0.0282636396586895,
-0.2871457040309906,
0.8503488302230835,
-0.6181316375732422,
-0.06295055896043777,
-0.3170115351676941,
-0.14881034195423126,
-0.9948445558547974,
-0.2942254841327667,
0.352826863527298,
-0.5980962514877319,
0.24337336421012878,
-0.04924241825938225,
-0.2862851023674011,
-0.3817250430583954,
0.0017000227235257626,
0.31263449788093567,
0.37162095308303833,
0.2572171986103058,
0.18429125845432281,
0.29136765003204346,
-0.6012232899665833,
-0.4149981141090393,
-0.8955236673355103,
-0.011126130819320679,
-0.2638804018497467,
-0.32298773527145386,
0.25201430916786194,
-0.12731501460075378,
-0.6082179546356201,
-0.05276958644390106,
-0.265758752822876,
-0.15066206455230713,
0.29603809118270874,
0.45877647399902344,
0.11172093451023102,
-0.10309357196092606,
0.13840900361537933,
0.42246752977371216,
-0.11341322213411331,
0.26874035596847534,
-0.2676222324371338,
0.13491623103618622,
-0.009807788766920567,
-0.45205724239349365,
-0.047314610332250595,
0.4658047556877136,
0.12196094542741776,
0.05420367047190666,
0.4672394394874573,
0.43207186460494995,
-0.5593162178993225,
-0.019657813012599945,
-0.6062310934066772,
0.10149228572845459,
-0.4137038588523865,
0.13159781694412231,
-0.34932687878608704,
-0.7487879395484924,
0.37344104051589966,
0.39348119497299194,
-0.13910672068595886,
0.6509135365486145,
0.6356435418128967,
0.08199688047170639,
0.8547922372817993,
0.5090738534927368,
0.02842729352414608,
0.00418333662673831,
0.05578028783202171,
0.40249931812286377,
-0.6039252877235413,
0.14595955610275269,
-0.7104986906051636,
0.03175714239478111,
-0.8535586595535278,
-0.427570641040802,
0.34449639916419983,
-0.17405268549919128,
-0.5610595345497131,
0.21773788332939148,
-0.3601307272911072,
0.14926491677761078,
0.8169554471969604,
0.08225996792316437,
0.11397238820791245,
-0.14952784776687622,
-0.1278357207775116,
-0.12978729605674744,
-0.3228001594543457,
-0.7435159087181091,
1.186555027961731,
0.19465115666389465,
0.6061074137687683,
0.34956634044647217,
0.5249283909797668,
0.06721826642751694,
0.17377161979675293,
-0.7349116802215576,
0.2291678488254547,
0.2602246105670929,
-0.8621740937232971,
-0.3492763936519623,
-0.8364480137825012,
-0.6608344316482544,
0.1133817806839943,
-0.24811513721942902,
-0.8278318643569946,
0.11125968396663666,
0.02349942922592163,
-0.6866546273231506,
0.08559492975473404,
-0.6240410208702087,
0.742428183555603,
-0.2057662308216095,
-0.4386521875858307,
0.05263393372297287,
-0.9014376401901245,
0.28523924946784973,
-0.31759220361709595,
0.28504377603530884,
-0.26164671778678894,
-0.12172872573137283,
0.531834602355957,
-0.21613365411758423,
0.7124331593513489,
-0.11963438987731934,
-0.3807026743888855,
0.4822714030742645,
0.4160054624080658,
0.1219278872013092,
0.13048629462718964,
-0.22259563207626343,
-0.1193925216794014,
0.37401360273361206,
-0.4979173243045807,
-0.5578645467758179,
0.6267306804656982,
-0.7296603322029114,
-0.6148256659507751,
-0.4630875289440155,
-0.6634435653686523,
-0.6681632399559021,
0.04272471368312836,
0.4653199315071106,
0.10117713361978531,
-0.31946414709091187,
-0.04165951907634735,
0.5927608013153076,
-0.7060426473617554,
0.2374606728553772,
0.3419702649116516,
0.22992435097694397,
-0.30781733989715576,
0.8642880916595459,
-0.008033830672502518,
0.6176795959472656,
0.6806980967521667,
0.208591490983963,
-0.2639603614807129,
-0.41393595933914185,
-0.26294267177581787,
-0.1039496585726738,
-0.48370596766471863,
-0.16186510026454926,
-0.4983951449394226,
-0.08860790729522705,
-0.4884546101093292,
-0.0616530105471611,
-0.11484251916408539,
-0.5572753548622131,
-0.30206018686294556,
-0.26536813378334045,
0.08373142033815384,
0.6097944974899292,
0.06970576196908951,
0.3956882655620575,
-0.7165570855140686,
0.3941977620124817,
0.4313510060310364,
0.2117973268032074,
-0.25975164771080017,
-0.4653918445110321,
-0.05826236307621002,
0.6077756881713867,
-0.5780735611915588,
-1.0181695222854614,
0.5168057084083557,
0.06409281492233276,
0.6590551137924194,
0.2551659643650055,
0.3054002523422241,
0.28166019916534424,
-0.2230079174041748,
0.8967565894126892,
0.07565632462501526,
-1.0783354043960571,
0.6488772630691528,
-0.4929407835006714,
0.187737837433815,
0.6749767661094666,
0.6051768660545349,
-0.46901464462280273,
-0.7133166193962097,
-0.8341385722160339,
-0.7024677991867065,
0.26207616925239563,
0.3095410466194153,
0.4112289547920227,
-0.1253422051668167,
0.5407735109329224,
0.26444804668426514,
0.6254117488861084,
-0.6128446459770203,
-0.15043523907661438,
-0.060665231198072433,
-0.4949740767478943,
-0.33563634753227234,
0.0022435514256358147,
0.12161464244127274,
-0.03918720781803131,
0.5075454115867615,
-0.16349925100803375,
0.3947352170944214,
0.17128460109233856,
-0.07362064719200134,
-0.32190072536468506,
0.6046589016914368,
0.3133957087993622,
0.4801413416862488,
-0.43700680136680603,
0.20947644114494324,
0.06899335980415344,
-0.07606177777051926,
0.1646084189414978,
0.07887547463178635,
-0.27247440814971924,
-0.1102895587682724,
0.09798060357570648,
0.7407699227333069,
0.342006653547287,
-0.6348367929458618,
0.6687847971916199,
0.16358335316181183,
-0.2701239585876465,
-0.23488308489322662,
0.06251004338264465,
-0.13456562161445618,
-0.1128184124827385,
0.3602304756641388,
0.14531442523002625,
0.3548532724380493,
-0.5324058532714844,
0.13513913750648499,
0.6151214838027954,
-0.5062761902809143,
-0.39654743671417236,
0.6531099677085876,
-0.14928553998470306,
-0.05933292955160141,
0.3114318251609802,
-0.2899951636791229,
-0.39157912135124207,
0.6247091293334961,
0.29982325434684753,
0.9922778010368347,
-0.11288340389728546,
0.4812730550765991,
0.22833268344402313,
0.3646593689918518,
-0.05193116515874863,
0.34082990884780884,
0.001387717085890472,
-0.8192746043205261,
-0.36842551827430725,
-0.7941973805427551,
-0.6477895975112915,
-0.058242615312337875,
-0.7468532919883728,
-0.15914462506771088,
-0.2964584231376648,
-0.4872923493385315,
-0.03931625187397003,
0.063380166888237,
-0.7572686076164246,
0.4386158287525177,
0.15388862788677216,
0.2788517475128174,
-0.9328712821006775,
0.49016273021698,
0.47486841678619385,
-0.43214428424835205,
-0.7269771099090576,
0.18996907770633698,
-0.11307919770479202,
-0.37541672587394714,
0.3205195665359497,
-0.14361439645290375,
0.11129485815763474,
-0.11081939190626144,
-0.4111720323562622,
-0.8488374948501587,
0.5992680788040161,
0.48909127712249756,
-0.13492736220359802,
-0.11174459755420685,
0.45699983835220337,
0.6083688139915466,
-0.0017273151315748692,
0.15429499745368958,
0.5158812403678894,
0.4452952742576599,
0.01961515098810196,
-0.9281120300292969,
0.04193616285920143,
0.01821225695312023,
0.21419015526771545,
0.4159823954105377,
-0.13159050047397614,
0.7826939821243286,
-0.3260219395160675,
-0.1745089739561081,
0.1737811267375946,
0.46038153767585754,
-0.14322787523269653,
0.16956840455532074,
0.08434024453163147,
0.6138629913330078,
0.5556380748748779,
-0.07712287455797195,
1.098965048789978,
-0.15355144441127777,
0.4434231221675873,
0.9567295908927917,
-0.18721167743206024,
0.8786910772323608,
0.576120138168335,
-0.4331307113170624,
0.07594873011112213,
0.7130293250083923,
0.30824172496795654,
0.44144073128700256,
0.4727809727191925,
-0.34961286187171936,
-0.3103729784488678,
0.0935286357998848,
-0.2887171804904938,
0.1538218855857849,
0.5455076098442078,
-0.31788650155067444,
-0.08419688045978546,
0.03897770866751671,
-0.17344054579734802,
0.09233327955007553,
-0.1574873924255371,
0.8771324753761292,
0.08178591728210449,
-0.8866847157478333,
0.4389609098434448,
0.25985002517700195,
0.5608978271484375,
-0.37763670086860657,
0.3846164047718048,
-0.026973415166139603,
-0.025162693113088608,
0.09847665578126907,
-0.920184850692749,
0.4711812734603882,
-0.16547179222106934,
-0.037771038711071014,
-0.04182211309671402,
0.37210404872894287,
-0.3049197494983673,
-0.8049497604370117,
-0.22687675058841705,
0.8457740545272827,
0.02863389253616333,
-0.42130333185195923,
-0.47575315833091736,
-0.34246161580085754,
0.037766896188259125,
-0.3260279893875122,
0.2696210443973541,
0.7211036682128906,
0.1725703924894333,
0.6909037828445435,
0.25162869691848755,
0.2384704053401947,
0.15628351271152496,
-0.38721445202827454,
0.2949712574481964,
-0.5159088969230652,
-0.2462538182735443,
-0.6575990915298462,
0.24608898162841797,
0.29620251059532166,
-0.5563488006591797,
0.4804108738899231,
0.4226287007331848,
0.8390339612960815,
-0.1796059012413025,
1.1036779880523682,
-0.20710650086402893,
0.570741593837738,
-0.3039432168006897,
0.4982314109802246,
-0.46591049432754517,
0.03433642536401749,
-0.7077475190162659,
-0.9723473787307739,
-0.3635486364364624,
0.778594434261322,
-0.61954665184021,
-0.0024556105490773916,
0.5463289022445679,
0.7312279939651489,
-0.09650003165006638,
0.03828087076544762,
0.4211564064025879,
-0.08092410862445831,
0.03162838891148567,
0.8281518220901489,
0.7101374864578247,
-0.521914005279541,
0.28682059049606323,
-0.26620978116989136,
-0.22115929424762726,
0.1089678704738617,
-0.98671954870224,
-0.4786791205406189,
-0.9099463224411011,
-0.42001578211784363,
-0.08254269510507584,
-0.21377849578857422,
0.8503501415252686,
0.4409583806991577,
-0.8574499487876892,
-0.1732185184955597,
-0.24291494488716125,
-0.00859055481851101,
-0.030972294509410858,
-0.2296530157327652,
0.12968210875988007,
-0.23321689665317535,
-0.6387878060340881,
-0.22262875735759735,
0.11846053600311279,
0.396664023399353,
-0.2250971496105194,
0.10602874308824539,
0.006311580538749695,
0.44220003485679626,
0.5137814283370972,
0.11283834278583527,
-0.8732728362083435,
-0.6175088882446289,
-0.2717927098274231,
-0.22529523074626923,
-0.22945831716060638,
0.5816403031349182,
-0.5854578018188477,
0.28100699186325073,
0.40249648690223694,
0.7113021612167358,
0.3833889663219452,
-0.04658857360482216,
0.8434861898422241,
-0.8402109146118164,
-0.0698285847902298,
0.17361900210380554,
0.10968100279569626,
0.4422405958175659,
-0.21429553627967834,
0.34451326727867126,
0.030095655471086502,
-0.46358615159988403,
-0.5721115469932556,
0.43170735239982605,
-0.991077721118927,
-0.25277474522590637,
1.0888508558273315,
-0.06953775137662888,
-0.05265222489833832,
-0.1752896010875702,
-0.25855907797813416,
0.31138038635253906,
-0.2660488188266754,
0.7787789702415466,
0.9879945516586304,
0.23114816844463348,
-0.09262665361166,
-0.9338331818580627,
0.3436107635498047,
0.3538408577442169,
-0.8668102025985718,
0.19109691679477692,
0.7542021870613098,
0.2931576371192932,
0.22650858759880066,
0.25177687406539917,
0.16855230927467346,
0.031111707910895348,
-0.02560591511428356,
0.013593249954283237,
0.487354576587677,
0.17706574499607086,
0.07435715198516846,
0.23908060789108276,
0.22733880579471588,
-0.0005757648032158613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05205v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05205v1
|
CPLIP: Zero-Shot Learning for Histopathology with Comprehensive Vision-Language Alignment
| 2024-06-07T18:39:58 | 2024-06-07T18:39:58 |
Sajid Javed, Arif Mahmood, Iyyakutti Iyappan Ganapathi, Fayaz Ali Dharejo, Naoufel Werghi, Mohammed Bennamoun
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM, eess.IV
|
This paper proposes Comprehensive Pathology Language Image Pre-training
(CPLIP), a new unsupervised technique designed to enhance the alignment of
images and text in histopathology for tasks such as classification and
segmentation. This methodology enriches vision-language models by leveraging
extensive data without needing ground truth annotations. CPLIP involves
constructing a pathology-specific dictionary, generating textual descriptions
for images using language models, and retrieving relevant images for each text
snippet via a pre-trained model. The model is then fine-tuned using a
many-to-many contrastive learning method to align complex interrelated concepts
across both modalities. Evaluated across multiple histopathology tasks, CPLIP
shows notable improvements in zero-shot learning scenarios, outperforming
existing methods in both interpretability and robustness and setting a higher
benchmark for the application of vision-language models in the field. To
encourage further research and replication, the code for CPLIP is available on
GitHub at https://cplip.github.io/
|
[
-0.09793075919151306,
-0.33825215697288513,
0.5854725241661072,
-0.09714740514755249,
-0.7348350286483765,
0.3592638671398163,
-0.11223210394382477,
-0.2737028896808624,
0.272440642118454,
0.6578662395477295,
-0.2181941419839859,
-0.5491187572479248,
-0.6378990411758423,
0.08620094507932663,
-0.176345095038414,
1.2915139198303223,
0.31823962926864624,
0.5644108653068542,
0.050787847489118576,
-0.0964764803647995,
0.056740108877420425,
-0.31945112347602844,
-0.40645769238471985,
0.11642546206712723,
0.4453001916408539,
0.4269113540649414,
0.7804108262062073,
1.1516196727752686,
0.7999742031097412,
0.16134457290172577,
-0.0222266037017107,
-0.24916118383407593,
-0.3563428521156311,
0.06633967906236649,
-0.32188713550567627,
-0.3121466636657715,
-0.22523745894432068,
-0.1563396453857422,
0.519238293170929,
1.1681081056594849,
-0.05547541752457619,
-0.42486438155174255,
0.003767412155866623,
0.47351035475730896,
-1.1353739500045776,
-0.10025332868099213,
-0.7149867415428162,
0.33378151059150696,
-0.46539148688316345,
-0.4042603373527527,
-0.29610928893089294,
-0.04887565225362778,
0.4734727740287781,
-0.9312821626663208,
0.1170053780078888,
-0.32687175273895264,
0.7282798886299133,
0.2132737934589386,
-0.44122686982154846,
-0.14877712726593018,
-0.0971674844622612,
0.8246492147445679,
-0.4821501672267914,
0.37077224254608154,
0.054945897310972214,
0.6410995125770569,
0.18098676204681396,
-0.5792663097381592,
-0.3526489734649658,
-0.17504486441612244,
0.19402781128883362,
0.38958361744880676,
0.29380327463150024,
0.28935763239860535,
-0.04761519655585289,
0.3107236921787262,
-0.5479190945625305,
0.15868234634399414,
-0.4993843734264374,
-0.46619951725006104,
0.20265944302082062,
0.19394460320472717,
0.40142714977264404,
-0.09294119477272034,
-0.7758432626724243,
0.13241048157215118,
-0.8322861790657043,
-0.24844571948051453,
0.012634793296456337,
0.5269908308982849,
-0.08195860683917999,
0.655437707901001,
-0.3809053301811218,
1.0093086957931519,
-0.11174070835113525,
-0.5906419157981873,
0.2537798583507538,
-0.4979822337627411,
-0.28643283247947693,
0.21542131900787354,
0.8751926422119141,
0.21978704631328583,
0.2572021782398224,
-0.08160226047039032,
0.4029123783111572,
-0.1570420265197754,
0.37699538469314575,
-0.7848237156867981,
-0.6024047136306763,
0.1361657977104187,
-0.3065227270126343,
-0.6999617218971252,
-0.14477649331092834,
-1.131400227546692,
-0.5624105930328369,
-0.03769201412796974,
0.2898956537246704,
-0.7386388778686523,
-0.12935015559196472,
0.12784872949123383,
-0.21217916905879974,
0.2019425630569458,
0.6662454009056091,
-0.6518075466156006,
0.043682247400283813,
0.44511163234710693,
0.6501295566558838,
-0.3524245321750641,
-0.730857789516449,
-0.7900792956352234,
0.6703740358352661,
-0.610392689704895,
0.9811328649520874,
-0.735444962978363,
-0.1210511103272438,
0.2391771376132965,
0.0058640954084694386,
0.054613616317510605,
-0.24873948097229004,
0.4175562262535095,
0.08315504342317581,
0.47952309250831604,
-0.2613774836063385,
-0.5144803524017334,
0.09536653757095337,
0.2840516269207001,
-0.20916913449764252,
0.5831885933876038,
0.24434919655323029,
-0.7581745982170105,
0.5702401995658875,
-0.35788848996162415,
-0.118666872382164,
0.4596017599105835,
-0.502154529094696,
-0.38438916206359863,
-0.1893201470375061,
0.21955391764640808,
0.5072510242462158,
-0.07851728051900864,
0.23750129342079163,
-0.3945561647415161,
-0.16060630977153778,
-0.1279415339231491,
0.040445610880851746,
1.0687988996505737,
-0.06742884963750839,
-0.5142964720726013,
0.0668509304523468,
-0.5381696224212646,
-0.21398892998695374,
0.1874222457408905,
-0.049643706530332565,
-0.1231006532907486,
-0.22037576138973236,
-0.30513787269592285,
0.10290580242872238,
0.41311949491500854,
-0.9664522409439087,
0.5186735391616821,
-0.9045640826225281,
-0.19477435946464539,
0.33496129512786865,
-0.04904311150312424,
0.4692414700984955,
-0.15434744954109192,
0.3500458002090454,
0.36882394552230835,
0.4776420295238495,
-0.5814357995986938,
-0.631386399269104,
-0.540350079536438,
-0.4394102990627289,
0.06399378180503845,
0.7365359663963318,
-0.8915510177612305,
0.2978634536266327,
-0.054806116968393326,
-0.4755120277404785,
-0.2518364191055298,
0.14978156983852386,
0.9116520881652832,
1.0736104249954224,
0.5556507706642151,
-0.6792427897453308,
-0.5777491331100464,
-0.8373832106590271,
0.3085658550262451,
0.02417733706533909,
0.03173298016190529,
0.14136914908885956,
0.3188285827636719,
-0.008705156855285168,
0.5749285817146301,
-0.8223193883895874,
-0.8160156011581421,
-0.2558346092700958,
-0.02154535800218582,
-0.03585149720311165,
0.508324384689331,
0.6157724261283875,
-0.5014640688896179,
-0.759684145450592,
0.30762407183647156,
-0.6242097616195679,
-0.21362516283988953,
-0.003941051661968231,
-0.1407453715801239,
0.424813836812973,
0.4012480676174164,
-0.2103172242641449,
0.7574548125267029,
0.41952306032180786,
-0.2583768367767334,
0.8353641629219055,
-0.25383055210113525,
0.4533049166202545,
-1.1187360286712646,
0.050542060285806656,
-0.10886995494365692,
-0.3440023958683014,
-0.6736863255500793,
0.22688721120357513,
0.0704532340168953,
-0.3064958453178406,
-0.8131428360939026,
0.3690938651561737,
-0.38469240069389343,
-0.21394379436969757,
-0.44819384813308716,
0.1573554128408432,
0.15633969008922577,
0.4333045184612274,
0.48473718762397766,
0.7742066979408264,
1.3393810987472534,
-0.4803222119808197,
0.032795730978250504,
0.549456000328064,
-0.10748372972011566,
0.5541248917579651,
-0.25768283009529114,
-0.09488420933485031,
0.12828177213668823,
0.020527562126517296,
-0.945530116558075,
-0.2621169090270996,
0.3598414659500122,
-0.6099078059196472,
0.40418779850006104,
-0.4051368832588196,
-0.06737193465232849,
-0.06983843445777893,
-0.6081460118293762,
0.5082060098648071,
0.2552899718284607,
-0.46611177921295166,
0.16496871411800385,
0.39065954089164734,
-0.1363265961408615,
-1.0061542987823486,
-0.6010212898254395,
0.17983008921146393,
0.16485176980495453,
0.007173353340476751,
0.5980655550956726,
-0.1744508147239685,
0.17774900794029236,
-0.20821000635623932,
0.05833243951201439,
-0.6270648837089539,
-0.33780717849731445,
0.017071576789021492,
0.34326109290122986,
-0.08627457171678543,
-0.17645882070064545,
-0.17281962931156158,
-0.02603761851787567,
-0.7005817294120789,
0.007837211713194847,
0.7145363688468933,
0.1400606781244278,
-0.4406491816043854,
-0.5707364678382874,
0.2285033017396927,
0.5801828503608704,
-0.2431744635105133,
0.42199158668518066,
0.3692706525325775,
-0.5192471146583557,
0.2295229136943817,
-0.4231534004211426,
0.04653492197394371,
-0.4181616008281708,
0.33702489733695984,
-0.2891943156719208,
-0.6851248145103455,
0.337534636259079,
-0.02480124682188034,
-0.08980169892311096,
0.15891262888908386,
0.6196252107620239,
-0.45980340242385864,
0.7988004088401794,
0.9412315487861633,
0.018611911684274673,
0.3779999613761902,
0.0008870079764164984,
-0.000556979444809258,
-1.0125088691711426,
-0.18908239901065826,
-0.5462794303894043,
0.44575899839401245,
-0.2015482634305954,
-0.6288400888442993,
0.3660155236721039,
0.2967641353607178,
-0.25941920280456543,
0.30455702543258667,
-1.0023537874221802,
0.6962326169013977,
0.25713855028152466,
0.23153892159461975,
-0.07295896112918854,
-0.010436045937240124,
-0.1431799978017807,
-0.38167211413383484,
-0.5129655599594116,
-0.33452481031417847,
1.4590431451797485,
0.010318468324840069,
0.1948143094778061,
-0.04280170425772667,
0.7472233176231384,
-0.2608884274959564,
0.15726864337921143,
-0.8175370693206787,
0.3178110122680664,
-0.680086612701416,
-0.421562522649765,
-0.48578259348869324,
-0.0004323032044339925,
-1.0476793050765991,
0.08287569880485535,
-0.2661305069923401,
-0.862454354763031,
0.1624356210231781,
0.27707043290138245,
-0.44795000553131104,
0.49140578508377075,
-0.09092343598604202,
1.0028325319290161,
-0.522178053855896,
-0.2928241491317749,
0.0301375575363636,
-0.7793165445327759,
0.32057303190231323,
0.0300458837300539,
-0.12490548938512802,
-0.03369686007499695,
-0.4555661678314209,
0.573176920413971,
-0.46365806460380554,
0.9805769324302673,
-0.29231974482536316,
0.1288028061389923,
-0.0443350113928318,
0.301586389541626,
-0.016614260151982307,
-0.07309398800134659,
0.0740305706858635,
0.2087816596031189,
0.32534259557724,
-0.7671707272529602,
-0.22908462584018707,
0.43264666199684143,
-0.46806368231773376,
-0.17519453167915344,
-0.5167457461357117,
-0.3518248200416565,
-0.31929710507392883,
0.4829646348953247,
0.6497238278388977,
0.445962518453598,
-0.027813440188765526,
0.1121496856212616,
0.8012832999229431,
-0.6566482186317444,
0.26274821162223816,
0.5213712453842163,
-0.1708284169435501,
-0.7766313552856445,
0.7950761318206787,
-0.20204056799411774,
0.16291017830371857,
0.7275105714797974,
0.37077605724334717,
-0.11243520677089691,
-0.9858379364013672,
-0.5643320679664612,
0.1548060178756714,
-0.6473156809806824,
-0.5145480036735535,
-0.5798230767250061,
-0.11490035802125931,
-0.7156708240509033,
-0.6085140109062195,
-0.6597855091094971,
-0.07791782915592194,
-0.3022748529911041,
0.23655912280082703,
0.048773638904094696,
0.2511906623840332,
-0.016539227217435837,
0.5690886378288269,
-0.628533661365509,
0.314532071352005,
-0.06716550886631012,
0.2929353415966034,
-0.5489328503608704,
-0.5365732908248901,
-0.05050795152783394,
-0.16003070771694183,
-0.4003935754299164,
-1.227555513381958,
0.5009867548942566,
0.6684580445289612,
0.4934539794921875,
0.7470234036445618,
-0.16311217844486237,
0.8485317230224609,
-0.550349235534668,
0.848312258720398,
0.7442857623100281,
-0.9082935452461243,
1.0627204179763794,
-0.4636039137840271,
0.3564724922180176,
0.9928102493286133,
0.7602750658988953,
-0.3272121846675873,
-0.510572075843811,
-0.4467468559741974,
-0.6282636523246765,
0.5286491513252258,
-0.2656572163105011,
-0.2768781781196594,
-0.1089339330792427,
0.43250057101249695,
0.4131471514701843,
0.2953353524208069,
-0.7509786486625671,
-0.037014905363321304,
-0.5002424716949463,
-0.27763086557388306,
-0.093190997838974,
-0.360787957906723,
-0.4320682883262634,
-0.5103794932365417,
0.47933804988861084,
-0.7045258283615112,
0.39549919962882996,
0.39224833250045776,
-0.30747660994529724,
-0.13148179650306702,
-0.08509562164545059,
0.7010904550552368,
0.8055474162101746,
-0.33720123767852783,
-0.020006241276860237,
0.06010213494300842,
-0.5718169212341309,
-0.22005167603492737,
-0.1933739185333252,
0.05618781968951225,
-0.11806686967611313,
0.6515913009643555,
0.4219944477081299,
0.3554312288761139,
-0.9143800735473633,
1.3259674310684204,
0.19069606065750122,
-0.5141072273254395,
-0.32253944873809814,
-0.09757472574710846,
-0.37522557377815247,
-0.11662911623716354,
0.40015020966529846,
0.0014355137245729566,
0.3108333945274353,
-0.34075117111206055,
0.5952345132827759,
0.46468281745910645,
-0.7421578764915466,
-0.18363524973392487,
0.3788413405418396,
0.032690830528736115,
0.14032955467700958,
0.62033611536026,
-0.09357789158821106,
-0.7621001601219177,
0.5652421712875366,
0.5029807686805725,
0.3885760009288788,
-0.3555525839328766,
0.4276523292064667,
0.4021378755569458,
0.23453140258789062,
0.3652283847332001,
0.325099378824234,
-0.06284639984369278,
-0.7892282605171204,
-0.7028950452804565,
-0.7815191745758057,
-0.7307945489883423,
0.18445368111133575,
-0.3807262182235718,
0.41291582584381104,
-0.7804732918739319,
0.5688301920890808,
0.345218300819397,
-0.028841311112046242,
-0.1983819454908371,
0.5304346680641174,
0.18064117431640625,
0.9619045853614807,
-0.7231168150901794,
1.1997106075286865,
0.7282294631004333,
-0.466702938079834,
-0.42508989572525024,
0.20318113267421722,
0.24159525334835052,
-0.8844473361968994,
0.6961205005645752,
0.30030936002731323,
0.22341197729110718,
-0.2995813488960266,
-0.5178799033164978,
-0.8655170202255249,
0.7294679284095764,
0.562863826751709,
-0.542790412902832,
0.20347733795642853,
0.14923031628131866,
0.7219989895820618,
-0.44338756799697876,
0.2946031391620636,
0.19086311757564545,
0.11744306981563568,
0.3112013638019562,
-1.1905161142349243,
-0.20219296216964722,
0.12165360897779465,
-0.3809118866920471,
0.37664422392845154,
-0.20812195539474487,
0.5866672396659851,
-0.42335599660873413,
-0.11497077345848083,
0.1228339672088623,
0.22740823030471802,
0.3423827290534973,
0.3270379602909088,
0.28409236669540405,
0.8650774955749512,
0.46506503224372864,
-0.146077960729599,
0.9969090819358826,
-0.6418443322181702,
0.18474195897579193,
0.8193232417106628,
-0.4361613690853119,
0.7657298445701599,
0.48527199029922485,
-0.024562284350395203,
0.3216896951198578,
0.5887327194213867,
0.03303040191531181,
0.8089982271194458,
-0.09913977980613708,
-0.23671410977840424,
-0.22200272977352142,
-0.0814296081662178,
-0.2637336552143097,
0.6819861531257629,
0.2074793130159378,
-0.11595319956541061,
-0.3596867620944977,
0.32303690910339355,
-0.19145329296588898,
0.021524159237742424,
-0.3509385287761688,
0.9633001685142517,
-0.42948296666145325,
-0.426969975233078,
0.6907374262809753,
-0.5401474237442017,
1.0430877208709717,
-0.5537793636322021,
-0.12196195870637894,
0.0037087188102304935,
0.02381201833486557,
-0.25218358635902405,
-1.1137810945510864,
0.8596290349960327,
-0.25858908891677856,
0.16626477241516113,
0.2226010411977768,
0.46539318561553955,
-0.35562899708747864,
-0.3771659731864929,
0.3283315598964691,
0.39734628796577454,
0.45554623007774353,
-0.07857250422239304,
-0.9706565141677856,
-0.0027481820434331894,
0.3769551217556,
0.2753526270389557,
0.5125583410263062,
0.22738805413246155,
0.12944774329662323,
0.6270670890808105,
0.600486695766449,
0.45972657203674316,
-0.1713217794895172,
0.14283256232738495,
0.6662393808364868,
-0.6496357321739197,
-0.2929780185222626,
-0.6796249151229858,
0.5133369565010071,
-0.14443646371364594,
-0.5391931533813477,
0.18860867619514465,
0.7649558782577515,
1.1181235313415527,
-0.14107508957386017,
0.49994125962257385,
0.05657712370157242,
0.5648700594902039,
-0.22539502382278442,
0.4023520052433014,
-0.6355607509613037,
-0.20090630650520325,
-0.48029065132141113,
-0.5852890610694885,
-0.7935495972633362,
0.5665870308876038,
-0.22651496529579163,
-0.23012766242027283,
0.946513831615448,
0.7659696936607361,
-0.13733381032943726,
-0.542129635810852,
0.7286399006843567,
-0.0921807661652565,
0.1845719814300537,
0.6355366110801697,
0.4842199981212616,
-0.2303801029920578,
0.7822421193122864,
-0.9622085690498352,
-0.6341131925582886,
-0.1813916712999344,
-0.9371268153190613,
-0.8248671293258667,
-0.865543782711029,
-0.7189229130744934,
0.030050400644540787,
0.4460600018501282,
0.5511293411254883,
1.0869251489639282,
-0.8516997694969177,
-0.10011918842792511,
-0.19526106119155884,
-0.24969369173049927,
0.0745142474770546,
-0.18438051640987396,
0.4819009304046631,
-0.6056373119354248,
-0.793796956539154,
0.5370824933052063,
1.0282692909240723,
0.1457100212574005,
-0.044578853994607925,
0.1289827525615692,
-0.21609705686569214,
-0.415470689535141,
0.542591392993927,
0.6185376644134521,
-0.5858929753303528,
0.03594157099723816,
-0.2677745521068573,
-0.20505526661872864,
0.5699992775917053,
0.7843734622001648,
-0.8404305577278137,
0.6663061380386353,
0.3914027214050293,
0.6740177273750305,
0.16911135613918304,
-0.1857331395149231,
0.4123915433883667,
-0.7362942099571228,
0.3854634165763855,
0.4698559045791626,
0.5035192370414734,
0.4634946882724762,
-0.7030024528503418,
0.36868441104888916,
0.2126481533050537,
-0.5073320269584656,
-0.9796225428581238,
0.516115128993988,
-1.4578821659088135,
-0.7474567890167236,
0.7175518870353699,
-0.1599329710006714,
-0.3543504476547241,
-0.2740305960178375,
-0.3196153938770294,
0.34651118516921997,
-0.1981797218322754,
0.6985324025154114,
-0.01118373777717352,
-0.579176127910614,
-0.8217072486877441,
-0.11345147341489792,
0.8089174628257751,
0.486415296792984,
-0.9518256187438965,
-0.17313458025455475,
0.36534664034843445,
0.5345956087112427,
0.4377443790435791,
0.8866634368896484,
-0.4496455788612366,
0.7635083198547363,
-0.28690314292907715,
0.5079576373100281,
0.016521567478775978,
-0.5649910569190979,
-0.45002904534339905,
0.2845836281776428,
0.19416233897209167,
-0.23890842497348785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05194v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05194v1
|
LLMs Are Not Intelligent Thinkers: Introducing Mathematical Topic Tree Benchmark for Comprehensive Evaluation of LLMs
| 2024-06-07T18:21:26 | 2024-06-07T18:21:26 |
Arash Gholami Davoodi, Seyed Pouyan Mousavi Davoudi, Pouya Pezeshkpour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate impressive capabilities in
mathematical reasoning. However, despite these achievements, current
evaluations are mostly limited to specific mathematical topics, and it remains
unclear whether LLMs are genuinely engaging in reasoning. To address these
gaps, we present the Mathematical Topics Tree (MaTT) benchmark, a challenging
and structured benchmark that offers 1,958 questions across a wide array of
mathematical subjects, each paired with a detailed hierarchical chain of
topics. Upon assessing different LLMs using the MaTT benchmark, we find that
the most advanced model, GPT-4, achieved a mere 54\% accuracy in a
multiple-choice scenario. Interestingly, even when employing Chain-of-Thought
prompting, we observe mostly no notable improvement. Moreover, LLMs accuracy
dramatically reduced by up to 24.2 percentage point when the questions were
presented without providing choices. Further detailed analysis of the LLMs'
performance across a range of topics showed significant discrepancy even for
closely related subtopics within the same general mathematical area. In an
effort to pinpoint the reasons behind LLMs performances, we conducted a manual
evaluation of the completeness and correctness of the explanations generated by
GPT-4 when choices were available. Surprisingly, we find that in only 53.3\% of
the instances where the model provided a correct answer, the accompanying
explanations were deemed complete and accurate, i.e., the model engaged in
genuine reasoning.
|
[
-0.5134152770042419,
-0.8985424041748047,
1.021451473236084,
0.1616622805595398,
-0.44005605578422546,
0.36041393876075745,
-0.15682446956634521,
-0.1229693740606308,
-0.1755678504705429,
0.13801167905330658,
-0.7198537588119507,
-0.5922933220863342,
-0.6381424069404602,
-0.010256340727210045,
-0.3919549286365509,
0.8974215388298035,
-0.15324054658412933,
-0.01075444184243679,
-0.7784423828125,
0.03643892705440521,
-0.34652236104011536,
-0.32329729199409485,
-0.663236677646637,
-0.2921562194824219,
0.47121408581733704,
0.21646054089069366,
0.7502783536911011,
0.5346440672874451,
0.792268693447113,
0.3170436918735504,
-0.21383079886436462,
0.023419994860887527,
-0.5954971313476562,
0.1443547159433365,
-0.4520733058452606,
-0.6218047142028809,
-0.4846366047859192,
0.15045496821403503,
0.664943516254425,
0.8806997537612915,
-0.2712177336215973,
0.20391131937503815,
-0.11977142840623856,
0.645521342754364,
-0.3969725966453552,
0.15355230867862701,
-1.0430163145065308,
0.0336955301463604,
-0.4952259361743927,
-0.19078750908374786,
-0.2918943464756012,
-0.341240257024765,
0.10759174823760986,
-0.5222059488296509,
0.1807616800069809,
-0.07460572570562363,
0.750505268573761,
0.5075267553329468,
-0.3147624731063843,
-0.3590242564678192,
-0.5144167542457581,
0.9084026217460632,
-0.5072410702705383,
0.3240451514720917,
0.46189913153648376,
0.27674248814582825,
-0.09223566949367523,
-0.6912226676940918,
-0.3045335114002228,
-0.17981013655662537,
0.36260050535202026,
0.23985573649406433,
-0.3589184284210205,
-0.09620875865221024,
0.7639006972312927,
0.15957216918468475,
-0.6669337749481201,
0.047484077513217926,
-0.06253775954246521,
-0.17780832946300507,
0.6860907077789307,
0.4266514480113983,
0.10315100848674774,
-0.0974503755569458,
-0.20272991061210632,
0.15463003516197205,
-0.829078733921051,
0.10198330134153366,
0.26975756883621216,
-0.15219615399837494,
0.13873280584812164,
0.7127282619476318,
-0.003643255215138197,
0.503057062625885,
-0.2498297393321991,
-0.33231842517852783,
-0.01577562279999256,
-0.3548825979232788,
-0.047364864498376846,
-0.264357328414917,
0.5452097654342651,
0.24555711448192596,
0.6058329343795776,
0.05418185889720917,
-0.35718974471092224,
0.3694210946559906,
0.13726019859313965,
-0.838180422782898,
-0.3044877052307129,
0.14080876111984253,
-0.070108562707901,
0.2265385091304779,
-0.23519039154052734,
-0.5224736332893372,
-0.07150480151176453,
-0.42945852875709534,
-0.04591795802116394,
-0.3644088804721832,
-0.10520313680171967,
0.08100486546754837,
0.18670476973056793,
-0.03426198288798332,
0.7163122296333313,
-0.6329132914543152,
0.3760461211204529,
1.0579681396484375,
0.7018619775772095,
-0.2539401948451996,
-0.20641764998435974,
-0.3132335841655731,
0.016470635309815407,
-0.5424059629440308,
1.1159437894821167,
-0.8198437094688416,
-0.484155535697937,
-0.4128930866718292,
-0.39998599886894226,
-0.10037356615066528,
-0.5666933059692383,
0.6442821621894836,
-0.49403512477874756,
0.29923346638679504,
-0.6419610977172852,
-0.7513718008995056,
-0.12102820724248886,
0.39309531450271606,
-0.27491089701652527,
0.958528459072113,
0.018194805830717087,
-0.6566784381866455,
0.26293128728866577,
-0.677656888961792,
-0.040744371712207794,
0.2106303721666336,
-0.5484809875488281,
-0.2563958168029785,
0.08036226034164429,
0.2564508020877838,
0.2681111693382263,
-0.6915633082389832,
0.6779869794845581,
-0.5053097605705261,
-0.3885765075683594,
0.5711150765419006,
-0.7354462146759033,
0.5370352268218994,
0.24051719903945923,
-0.18176265060901642,
-0.08073318749666214,
-0.36866819858551025,
0.29031670093536377,
0.323815256357193,
0.08632063120603561,
-0.07403355091810226,
0.16687200963497162,
-0.4961300194263458,
0.3554668128490448,
0.21094822883605957,
-0.3325771987438202,
0.1375245898962021,
-0.11628704518079758,
0.5659061670303345,
0.9544521570205688,
-0.04059818014502525,
-0.028279218822717667,
-0.5076401233673096,
0.7333950400352478,
-0.047587938606739044,
-0.15692749619483948,
-0.10226873308420181,
-0.8484460115432739,
-0.6068701148033142,
-0.21497544646263123,
0.39117303490638733,
0.4394434690475464,
-0.5769040584564209,
0.011278844438493252,
-0.41524839401245117,
-0.5589547157287598,
-0.28350064158439636,
0.12797380983829498,
0.4182412624359131,
0.5647383332252502,
0.1253523975610733,
-0.16379591822624207,
-0.05520288646221161,
-1.0183303356170654,
-0.3367433249950409,
-0.31101930141448975,
0.06525994837284088,
0.39073050022125244,
0.7414438724517822,
0.11580783128738403,
0.9608029723167419,
-0.5679989457130432,
0.23830421268939972,
0.027557875961065292,
0.08989860862493515,
0.3437921106815338,
0.21908900141716003,
0.33154571056365967,
-0.48533982038497925,
-0.5443738698959351,
-0.3020172715187073,
-0.8359637260437012,
-0.19834251701831818,
0.049199964851140976,
0.006163118872791529,
-0.10839638113975525,
0.24779322743415833,
-0.7746489644050598,
0.3439534902572632,
0.14504365622997284,
-0.18793921172618866,
0.48466983437538147,
0.01258151140064001,
-0.19627125561237335,
-0.7339680194854736,
0.04529385641217232,
0.13767178356647491,
-0.048847515136003494,
-0.1747274249792099,
-0.021949416026473045,
-0.005017672199755907,
-0.21677342057228088,
-0.37766414880752563,
0.5400338172912598,
-0.348294734954834,
-0.506055474281311,
-0.0118715213611722,
0.44005635380744934,
-0.1517692357301712,
0.5050602555274963,
-0.173699751496315,
1.1105111837387085,
0.5962640643119812,
-0.3707287907600403,
0.3554843068122864,
0.20334725081920624,
-0.46296271681785583,
0.7630188465118408,
-0.6288720965385437,
0.27156320214271545,
-0.13349711894989014,
0.2479366958141327,
-1.0128610134124756,
-0.029400235041975975,
0.0980815589427948,
-0.37473514676094055,
0.027283811941742897,
-0.022466909140348434,
-0.4700194001197815,
-0.44424498081207275,
-0.18064530193805695,
0.3827146291732788,
0.6339003443717957,
-0.2947885990142822,
0.3795101046562195,
0.2724161744117737,
-0.452873557806015,
-0.5520856380462646,
-0.5305209159851074,
0.1276704967021942,
-0.23792730271816254,
-0.789828896522522,
0.3098166584968567,
-0.3397347927093506,
-0.6541617512702942,
0.34636080265045166,
-0.44623398780822754,
-0.0005121169961057603,
0.37280651926994324,
-0.005276917479932308,
0.2730405628681183,
-0.4407173991203308,
0.28769972920417786,
-0.17629127204418182,
-0.4150504767894745,
0.372919499874115,
-0.06222370266914368,
0.44763022661209106,
-0.3597560226917267,
-0.9256154894828796,
-0.45411229133605957,
0.013893919996917248,
0.5082036256790161,
-0.30416905879974365,
0.20776762068271637,
-0.04949326068162918,
-0.4174547791481018,
-0.3138279914855957,
-0.5483760237693787,
-0.12586094439029694,
-0.4757783114910126,
0.44152072072029114,
-0.8586716055870056,
-0.8148616552352905,
0.6131181120872498,
-0.2227339893579483,
0.12750892341136932,
0.6151541471481323,
0.37114566564559937,
-0.1620146483182907,
1.257346510887146,
-0.11243009567260742,
0.23934878408908844,
0.11941346526145935,
-0.2798381447792053,
0.2530272901058197,
-0.8690294623374939,
-0.3150714635848999,
-0.5050229430198669,
-0.26398763060569763,
-0.4613005518913269,
-0.5344953536987305,
0.1714615821838379,
0.2048083245754242,
-0.3374802768230438,
-0.039439793676137924,
-0.4675581157207489,
0.7057408094406128,
0.29847925901412964,
-0.1354600191116333,
0.33490946888923645,
-0.020504269748926163,
-0.32940974831581116,
-0.32882967591285706,
-0.6823272109031677,
-0.7702836394309998,
1.1830791234970093,
0.4621487557888031,
0.6821054220199585,
0.20057205855846405,
0.4356481432914734,
0.06726738810539246,
0.5827131867408752,
-0.7644116282463074,
0.9449955224990845,
-0.02184976264834404,
-0.6545953750610352,
-0.31581783294677734,
-0.6578012704849243,
-0.8336352109909058,
0.32072028517723083,
0.13880880177021027,
-0.7614021301269531,
-0.25479263067245483,
-0.21305912733078003,
-0.3100784718990326,
0.3962137699127197,
-0.4369562864303589,
0.7223026752471924,
-0.5518144369125366,
-0.5721107125282288,
-0.28695419430732727,
-0.23546446859836578,
0.6445779800415039,
-0.4904572069644928,
0.12517528235912323,
-0.5757021307945251,
-0.29717564582824707,
0.7434913516044617,
-0.34303075075149536,
0.5371819138526917,
0.03817809000611305,
-0.1057695597410202,
0.3660464584827423,
0.17576918005943298,
0.4581725299358368,
0.36346563696861267,
-0.1714903712272644,
0.10441432148218155,
-0.07476457208395004,
-0.6102307438850403,
-0.8790203332901001,
0.7366925477981567,
-0.8505703210830688,
-1.130028247833252,
-0.6581594347953796,
-0.4922586679458618,
-0.5170612931251526,
-0.041130341589450836,
-0.15956595540046692,
0.5796012282371521,
-0.13464131951332092,
0.16998401284217834,
0.6575465798377991,
-0.042155489325523376,
0.38159725069999695,
0.4749978184700012,
-0.3528880476951599,
-0.4113895893096924,
0.8768861293792725,
0.2864133417606354,
0.2626112699508667,
0.25514888763427734,
0.10389046370983124,
-0.6053307056427002,
-0.9215762615203857,
-0.43233025074005127,
0.4547249376773834,
-1.0619760751724243,
-0.08498900383710861,
-0.6220508813858032,
-0.3120403587818146,
0.11042854189872742,
0.011776281520724297,
-0.2895272672176361,
-0.42308932542800903,
-0.18197432160377502,
-0.1237381249666214,
0.06823417544364929,
0.872045636177063,
0.2696017920970917,
0.0660337433218956,
-0.45812681317329407,
0.08412617444992065,
0.5530732870101929,
0.39268356561660767,
-0.031109998002648354,
-0.4698616564273834,
0.1950688660144806,
0.09067527949810028,
-0.5096480846405029,
-0.5982686281204224,
0.019882632419466972,
-0.02908802591264248,
0.8193187713623047,
0.5369551777839661,
-0.09020455926656723,
0.8569768667221069,
-0.3932514190673828,
0.8413946032524109,
0.09993074089288712,
-1.1444902420043945,
0.42646676301956177,
-0.34771040081977844,
0.424535870552063,
0.48803719878196716,
0.37464749813079834,
-0.2618279457092285,
-0.29845964908599854,
-0.8141516447067261,
-0.28155940771102905,
0.7312266230583191,
0.32781481742858887,
0.031854379922151566,
-0.13175435364246368,
0.3728007376194,
-0.02843666635453701,
0.23562310636043549,
-0.5695071816444397,
-0.08208488672971725,
-0.0165345910936594,
-0.039559658616781235,
-0.1342216432094574,
-0.23820491135120392,
-0.13004794716835022,
-0.2163396030664444,
0.6080189347267151,
-0.2339053601026535,
0.3173186182975769,
-0.0526544414460659,
0.09802038222551346,
-0.259848415851593,
0.2022162675857544,
0.8936920762062073,
1.3051477670669556,
-0.1588449627161026,
0.37102681398391724,
0.42265817523002625,
-0.22990474104881287,
-0.040459044277668,
0.18112121522426605,
-0.022484084591269493,
-0.04324573278427124,
0.5808401107788086,
0.8044792413711548,
0.3119184970855713,
-0.7605977654457092,
0.3936324119567871,
-0.12718172371387482,
-0.36670592427253723,
-0.14299644529819489,
0.12368059903383255,
0.5120301842689514,
-0.03155089542269707,
0.28316304087638855,
0.14571091532707214,
-0.2872024476528168,
-0.5924943089485168,
0.1762016862630844,
0.7135888338088989,
-0.24262253940105438,
-0.38102951645851135,
0.5907369256019592,
0.16911713778972626,
-0.46944954991340637,
0.8047580122947693,
-0.16408662497997284,
-0.7557073831558228,
0.8658143281936646,
0.46029677987098694,
0.7902223467826843,
-0.06269915401935577,
0.22733065485954285,
0.33622580766677856,
0.3208089768886566,
0.05921201780438423,
0.3966778814792633,
-0.12470497936010361,
-0.7332277894020081,
-0.6008939146995544,
-0.38939034938812256,
-0.7053878903388977,
0.17040520906448364,
-0.38926535844802856,
0.11225992441177368,
-0.6134621500968933,
-0.2228543907403946,
0.1743306964635849,
0.30067312717437744,
-0.5795297026634216,
0.19449029862880707,
-0.060912877321243286,
1.0313385725021362,
-0.5426307916641235,
0.7959245443344116,
0.6052148342132568,
-0.2693178653717041,
-0.7135777473449707,
0.01643497496843338,
0.00868245493620634,
-1.0554066896438599,
0.6310956478118896,
0.06883177906274796,
0.027240131050348282,
0.08337889611721039,
-0.546033501625061,
-1.0358434915542603,
0.9934535622596741,
0.48117196559906006,
-0.7669934034347534,
0.12392506003379822,
0.3418113887310028,
0.532819390296936,
-0.21959395706653595,
0.7397343516349792,
0.22147910296916962,
0.5826711654663086,
0.5089250206947327,
-0.74897700548172,
-0.0844675600528717,
-0.3095087707042694,
-0.011363117955625057,
0.3612158000469208,
-0.6442897319793701,
0.9209640622138977,
-0.16000790894031525,
-0.33461955189704895,
0.04089217260479927,
0.39384451508522034,
0.5012443661689758,
0.5776012539863586,
0.36184242367744446,
0.7682263851165771,
1.1394908428192139,
-0.42827773094177246,
1.1300452947616577,
-0.3532799482345581,
0.3922205865383148,
1.0211864709854126,
-0.6275837421417236,
0.7744914293289185,
0.31294068694114685,
-0.5592405200004578,
0.2775685787200928,
1.0330084562301636,
0.024920029565691948,
0.32250767946243286,
0.5638605952262878,
-0.2415563315153122,
-0.7349100112915039,
-0.08791148662567139,
-0.6738020181655884,
0.21042509377002716,
0.7027072906494141,
-0.08023489266633987,
-0.44475606083869934,
-0.4017595648765564,
-0.01600930653512478,
0.20378905534744263,
-0.2438776195049286,
0.5529317259788513,
0.29989925026893616,
-0.9484615921974182,
0.4984312653541565,
-0.006373059470206499,
0.23697462677955627,
-0.5923901796340942,
0.04336969926953316,
-0.31072500348091125,
0.07240354269742966,
-0.022563055157661438,
-1.1992181539535522,
0.26935938000679016,
0.22068843245506287,
0.10707713663578033,
-0.42376166582107544,
0.4311394691467285,
-0.10131082683801651,
-0.5640873312950134,
-0.04515126720070839,
0.928483784198761,
0.49680817127227783,
0.03770698606967926,
-1.1435517072677612,
0.050779081881046295,
0.04408877715468407,
-0.13651426136493683,
0.2026396244764328,
0.6699332594871521,
-0.2826944887638092,
0.9560607075691223,
0.9218702912330627,
-0.16764046251773834,
-0.3356124460697174,
0.009818611666560173,
0.9183211922645569,
-0.7585728764533997,
-0.21820497512817383,
-1.051913857460022,
0.2477448433637619,
-0.056068144738674164,
-0.685928463935852,
0.8734768629074097,
0.7919385433197021,
0.7849657535552979,
0.32184523344039917,
0.5894971489906311,
0.4754890203475952,
0.4230414032936096,
-0.6185421943664551,
0.23295904695987701,
-0.4594261348247528,
0.8019924759864807,
-0.18743805587291718,
-1.3428601026535034,
-0.18797838687896729,
0.5343219041824341,
-0.8522871136665344,
0.324510395526886,
1.056755542755127,
0.5191103219985962,
-0.11570348590612411,
0.4843732416629791,
0.49711132049560547,
0.1904112547636032,
0.3811846077442169,
0.7220704555511475,
1.4646726846694946,
0.13747583329677582,
0.3507087528705597,
-0.16869832575321198,
-0.16582979261875153,
0.1406867355108261,
-0.9106952548027039,
-1.050437569618225,
-0.1983376145362854,
-0.5446964502334595,
-0.18320207297801971,
0.07741505652666092,
0.8839965462684631,
0.46197932958602905,
-0.7203347682952881,
-0.1694900244474411,
-0.44006332755088806,
0.3898753821849823,
0.21036207675933838,
-0.185552716255188,
0.41038304567337036,
-0.2282455563545227,
-0.5951066017150879,
0.3585258424282074,
0.3876834511756897,
-0.08122920244932175,
-0.3865571916103363,
0.06625143438577652,
-0.0277489572763443,
0.18850329518318176,
0.34908270835876465,
-0.06719478964805603,
-1.1005738973617554,
-0.23703163862228394,
0.22474446892738342,
-0.15244784951210022,
0.20824678242206573,
0.7112038731575012,
-0.7065990567207336,
0.3194792568683624,
0.3190278708934784,
0.788506031036377,
0.6219393610954285,
0.10816990584135056,
0.24077798426151276,
-0.16871538758277893,
-0.31249645352363586,
0.5258032083511353,
0.4526606500148773,
0.3366519808769226,
-0.020496582612395287,
0.686829149723053,
0.6087618470191956,
-0.48000743985176086,
-0.888578474521637,
0.25001856684684753,
-0.8488571643829346,
-0.36971360445022583,
1.0470422506332397,
-0.18372800946235657,
-0.16024573147296906,
-0.06335584074258804,
-0.18584029376506805,
-0.37113749980926514,
-0.3778088092803955,
0.5183507800102234,
1.0820051431655884,
-0.24322310090065002,
-0.1937803328037262,
-0.6463556885719299,
0.2662006914615631,
0.8065921664237976,
-0.9263563752174377,
-0.17393405735492706,
0.372588574886322,
0.2874230444431305,
0.13966000080108643,
0.6178508400917053,
0.06194654479622841,
0.2716059982776642,
0.03555940091609955,
-0.43834519386291504,
0.047812629491090775,
-0.2088722288608551,
-0.17175573110580444,
0.3061107397079468,
0.29436659812927246,
0.17351385951042175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05190v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05190v1
|
Evaluating the Effectiveness of Data Augmentation for Emotion Classification in Low-Resource Settings
| 2024-06-07T18:13:27 | 2024-06-07T18:13:27 |
Aashish Arora, Elsbeth Turcan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Data augmentation has the potential to improve the performance of machine
learning models by increasing the amount of training data available. In this
study, we evaluated the effectiveness of different data augmentation techniques
for a multi-label emotion classification task using a low-resource dataset. Our
results showed that Back Translation outperformed autoencoder-based approaches
and that generating multiple examples per training instance led to further
performance improvement. In addition, we found that Back Translation generated
the most diverse set of unigrams and trigrams. These findings demonstrate the
utility of Back Translation in enhancing the performance of emotion
classification models in resource-limited situations.
|
[
-0.3725007176399231,
-0.26189014315605164,
0.05995034798979759,
0.23555615544319153,
-0.2384718358516693,
0.2647514045238495,
-0.37717851996421814,
-0.5757660269737244,
-0.15873396396636963,
0.20629169046878815,
-0.26019859313964844,
-0.5555123686790466,
-0.6524361371994019,
0.3460361063480377,
-0.24968723952770233,
1.044137716293335,
-0.3608185052871704,
0.06865262240171432,
-0.025276487693190575,
-0.5746723413467407,
-0.43197694420814514,
-0.9593346118927002,
-0.36649736762046814,
-0.5517752766609192,
0.5612162947654724,
0.6522163152694702,
0.7302666902542114,
0.41077926754951477,
0.49776771664619446,
0.3651711344718933,
0.17498132586479187,
0.42426830530166626,
-0.5181348323822021,
0.09773214161396027,
0.3009970486164093,
-0.41387614607810974,
-0.4068659543991089,
0.17852208018302917,
0.5520373582839966,
0.38911163806915283,
-0.12743045389652252,
0.20342648029327393,
0.05269232392311096,
0.7833811640739441,
-0.9629177451133728,
0.14122441411018372,
-0.06383544206619263,
0.6574772000312805,
-0.008362283930182457,
-0.04185197874903679,
-0.3435845673084259,
-0.4512980282306671,
0.07019545882940292,
-0.44258010387420654,
0.213795006275177,
0.20022939145565033,
0.3825550079345703,
0.6649720668792725,
-0.46963074803352356,
-0.18186119198799133,
-0.6891463994979858,
0.8471614718437195,
-0.4674557149410248,
0.5656394958496094,
0.16060207784175873,
0.07143189013004303,
0.12265805900096893,
-0.49167346954345703,
-0.6913126707077026,
0.1558981090784073,
-0.23061248660087585,
0.2801315486431122,
-0.4194364547729492,
0.30859580636024475,
0.6156115531921387,
0.7625102400779724,
-0.2929132580757141,
0.3642757833003998,
-0.16415876150131226,
-0.1210428774356842,
0.7333608269691467,
0.36158105731010437,
0.3245680332183838,
-0.28392815589904785,
0.025489889085292816,
-0.5629845261573792,
-0.09051551669836044,
0.1399870216846466,
0.34541258215904236,
0.24755972623825073,
-0.11723852157592773,
0.8129746913909912,
-0.2718861401081085,
0.5764422416687012,
-0.054609112441539764,
-0.02739563211798668,
0.7653033137321472,
-0.2859117090702057,
-0.2837681472301483,
0.2531367838382721,
0.644695520401001,
0.501381516456604,
-0.13472257554531097,
0.006872718688100576,
-0.13501253724098206,
0.20652474462985992,
0.30753862857818604,
-0.987407922744751,
-0.1594584882259369,
0.160314679145813,
-0.6198046207427979,
-0.26263076066970825,
-0.3200395107269287,
-1.124146819114685,
-0.5514209270477295,
-0.20402993261814117,
0.1368577629327774,
-0.39447396993637085,
-0.010286720469594002,
-0.09989510476589203,
-0.14269191026687622,
-0.25193727016448975,
0.3553646206855774,
-0.5063652992248535,
0.07404815405607224,
0.18479079008102417,
0.9554315209388733,
-0.24879306554794312,
0.0692657083272934,
-0.41686856746673584,
-0.2769526541233063,
-0.28655415773391724,
0.4720791280269623,
-0.8251475095748901,
-0.5894085168838501,
-0.0734884962439537,
-0.037484657019376755,
-0.015670612454414368,
-0.5439609885215759,
0.6607969403266907,
-0.2790600061416626,
0.241494819521904,
-0.10195527970790863,
-0.45181623101234436,
-0.43329328298568726,
0.13931161165237427,
-0.8328804969787598,
1.1259725093841553,
0.4234927296638489,
-0.46913883090019226,
0.4383281171321869,
-0.8704989552497864,
-0.5551310181617737,
-0.09409596025943756,
0.16989527642726898,
-0.6288517117500305,
0.4138995110988617,
0.2985507845878601,
0.5331685543060303,
-0.1929338127374649,
-0.28149980306625366,
-0.5049980282783508,
-0.37880030274391174,
0.6312279105186462,
-0.4457382559776306,
0.11978497356176376,
0.43037712574005127,
-0.0858205184340477,
-0.3037050664424896,
-0.8733523488044739,
0.07454618811607361,
-0.18160903453826904,
-0.6289116740226746,
-0.40201592445373535,
-0.4353225529193878,
0.11968167126178741,
0.5592275857925415,
-0.06606903672218323,
-0.6700098514556885,
0.2685997784137726,
-0.2870396375656128,
-0.06602009385824203,
0.3330678343772888,
-0.10146686434745789,
0.4173502027988434,
-0.1161009669303894,
0.6323865652084351,
0.1531893014907837,
-0.11569230258464813,
-0.2712974548339844,
-0.30527395009994507,
-0.8233393430709839,
-0.30773136019706726,
0.3369939923286438,
0.5925572514533997,
-0.9786627888679504,
0.30162838101387024,
-0.11806517839431763,
-0.49743545055389404,
-1.1860039234161377,
0.22712521255016327,
0.5614383816719055,
0.6351656317710876,
0.7879531383514404,
-0.4349871277809143,
-0.46977847814559937,
-0.6600518226623535,
-0.14166390895843506,
0.1367935687303543,
0.09325481206178665,
0.7558236122131348,
0.2953037619590759,
-0.4443262219429016,
0.4721718728542328,
-0.48531314730644226,
-0.04135952889919281,
0.05070073902606964,
0.7645785212516785,
-0.021134166046977043,
0.452894926071167,
0.5406586527824402,
-0.636694610118866,
-0.5376207232475281,
0.21505850553512573,
-0.7204272150993347,
-0.10374559462070465,
-0.014733062125742435,
0.010799300856888294,
0.5471312999725342,
-0.3103275001049042,
-0.17106030881404877,
0.8163110613822937,
0.5176429152488708,
0.06320147961378098,
0.08564530313014984,
-0.3322869539260864,
0.7289991974830627,
-0.7428368926048279,
-0.17435714602470398,
0.1845817267894745,
0.09783138334751129,
-0.7742599248886108,
-0.5282608866691589,
0.18554601073265076,
-0.35303741693496704,
-0.34552133083343506,
0.3084188401699066,
-0.3561839461326599,
-0.31915730237960815,
-0.45875564217567444,
-0.15303364396095276,
-0.004134885501116514,
0.42498522996902466,
0.20909039676189423,
0.7476359009742737,
0.4700407385826111,
-0.5447778105735779,
0.8892267942428589,
0.3460233211517334,
-0.2908627688884735,
0.8886375427246094,
-0.16559825837612152,
0.36446747183799744,
-0.3085641860961914,
0.3296855390071869,
-1.1940838098526,
-0.4552110433578491,
0.14409863948822021,
-0.24005505442619324,
0.5518110394477844,
-0.1647268831729889,
-0.5428667664527893,
-0.5821820497512817,
-0.1659313142299652,
0.33161070942878723,
0.6991539597511292,
-0.8692800998687744,
0.53464674949646,
0.1730203777551651,
-0.07063614577054977,
-0.4590669572353363,
-0.9275383949279785,
0.05048160254955292,
-0.4917159676551819,
-0.38664963841438293,
0.1759246438741684,
0.11513684689998627,
0.04593726992607117,
0.017893444746732712,
0.014537476934492588,
-0.16741429269313812,
0.07882466167211533,
0.31384116411209106,
0.0838194340467453,
0.11153395473957062,
0.6142472624778748,
0.09671002626419067,
0.11663970351219177,
-0.2165638506412506,
0.06550700217485428,
0.24431978166103363,
-0.23296597599983215,
-0.30206483602523804,
-0.5608733892440796,
0.4015662968158722,
0.4205527603626251,
0.01570090465247631,
0.7616273164749146,
1.1351664066314697,
-0.397923082113266,
-0.043636418879032135,
-0.5159514546394348,
0.004366547334939241,
-0.3977345824241638,
0.32209473848342896,
-0.24830345809459686,
-0.6478240489959717,
0.3006941080093384,
-0.317806214094162,
-0.2832523286342621,
0.18287144601345062,
0.36087146401405334,
-0.3241530954837799,
1.307077407836914,
0.6040612459182739,
-0.2372710406780243,
0.6916972994804382,
-0.278768390417099,
0.12812474370002747,
-1.0932387113571167,
-0.24688224494457245,
-0.4098985493183136,
-0.7012481689453125,
-0.8241479396820068,
-0.31085261702537537,
0.4262891411781311,
-0.10362186282873154,
0.10391995310783386,
0.15410475432872772,
-0.7794481515884399,
0.13200867176055908,
0.2135644555091858,
0.45555707812309265,
0.0682910606265068,
0.2376081496477127,
0.41433802247047424,
-0.2898096740245819,
-0.8204026818275452,
-0.22313351929187775,
1.0048614740371704,
0.2750782370567322,
0.7751637697219849,
0.0719735249876976,
0.6270238757133484,
0.3618597388267517,
0.7638521790504456,
-0.7899032831192017,
0.09869476407766342,
-0.5458506941795349,
-0.22119227051734924,
-0.21223664283752441,
-0.5460126399993896,
-0.8193219304084778,
0.32655444741249084,
-0.605413556098938,
-0.7016633152961731,
0.5906692147254944,
0.29610511660575867,
-0.362273246049881,
0.09644825011491776,
-1.0537540912628174,
0.9104760885238647,
-0.7790930867195129,
-0.2065291404724121,
-0.3414022922515869,
-0.45683011412620544,
0.35858410596847534,
-0.5546395778656006,
0.12701600790023804,
-0.0021111820824444294,
-0.1480204313993454,
0.8854746222496033,
-0.4017423987388611,
0.6650806069374084,
-0.1686255931854248,
0.06748120486736298,
0.2709593176841736,
-0.31067630648612976,
0.497347891330719,
-0.3600930869579315,
-0.36449334025382996,
0.1139969676733017,
-0.4419780969619751,
-0.09509135782718658,
-0.9530556797981262,
0.43011003732681274,
-0.740906298160553,
-0.021898359060287476,
-0.188927561044693,
-0.7779479026794434,
-0.40827780961990356,
-0.27218982577323914,
0.204544797539711,
0.20736481249332428,
0.06447234004735947,
0.4665278494358063,
0.47568875551223755,
-0.5234562158584595,
0.45156875252723694,
0.3707670569419861,
0.25121524930000305,
-0.6476672291755676,
1.000564455986023,
0.23755581676959991,
0.0056737251579761505,
-0.009234321303665638,
0.06244710087776184,
-0.4891393184661865,
-0.2449803203344345,
-0.43855106830596924,
-0.19806429743766785,
-0.7095811367034912,
-0.4277733266353607,
-0.8168493509292603,
0.19784992933273315,
-0.3989279568195343,
-0.035266075283288956,
-0.3057340979576111,
-0.42978453636169434,
-0.3520547151565552,
-0.17685489356517792,
0.7567883133888245,
0.412532776594162,
-0.3314438462257385,
0.7384516000747681,
-0.9915978312492371,
0.22959314286708832,
0.20917761325836182,
0.46002259850502014,
-0.04450700432062149,
-0.5665633082389832,
-0.4889460802078247,
-0.0300808846950531,
-0.23920604586601257,
-1.090841293334961,
0.5990808010101318,
0.2987470030784607,
0.37191474437713623,
0.12896473705768585,
0.26282376050949097,
0.9995560646057129,
-0.05735933035612106,
0.5338526964187622,
0.44973617792129517,
-0.910293698310852,
0.5508139133453369,
0.19688093662261963,
0.2180199921131134,
0.4093877971172333,
0.5374478697776794,
-0.5335997939109802,
0.0694410502910614,
-0.673257052898407,
-0.9404444098472595,
1.095417857170105,
0.3374905288219452,
0.022359933704137802,
0.3981819450855255,
0.37513428926467896,
0.1044355183839798,
0.543590247631073,
-0.2565403878688812,
-0.29864609241485596,
-0.4122484624385834,
-0.4974408745765686,
-0.29947832226753235,
-0.0877203419804573,
0.02999075874686241,
-0.30454152822494507,
0.5387334227561951,
-0.1088661476969719,
0.25364962220191956,
-0.05657394602894783,
-0.17584238946437836,
-0.2856908440589905,
0.4947966933250427,
0.254501610994339,
-0.32422101497650146,
-0.08065057545900345,
-0.022169651463627815,
0.7355441451072693,
-0.2236194759607315,
0.315417617559433,
0.4467814266681671,
0.1190895363688469,
0.03743082284927368,
0.12564340233802795,
1.234961748123169,
-0.025743884965777397,
-0.32717251777648926,
0.18328094482421875,
-0.11746406555175781,
0.3232807219028473,
0.44146302342414856,
0.09837809205055237,
-0.48131996393203735,
0.45952048897743225,
0.02178395912051201,
-0.06073622778058052,
0.48225831985473633,
-0.5218634605407715,
0.14099447429180145,
0.08711349219083786,
-0.2813493609428406,
-0.004371667746454477,
0.08490109443664551,
0.28314676880836487,
-0.11988532543182373,
0.8002740144729614,
-0.12449829280376434,
-0.6115529537200928,
0.4467275142669678,
0.3982914090156555,
0.8427475094795227,
-0.45382335782051086,
0.1928413212299347,
0.36307308077812195,
0.11837845295667648,
-0.07293763011693954,
0.37309426069259644,
-0.39290881156921387,
-0.7049111723899841,
-0.5055238008499146,
-0.44062376022338867,
-0.6690099835395813,
0.0086852191016078,
-0.8286958932876587,
-0.07031329721212387,
0.01881740801036358,
-0.4461837410926819,
-0.173866868019104,
-0.08031319826841354,
-1.019923210144043,
0.5908102989196777,
0.48280826210975647,
0.4422973096370697,
-0.9684016108512878,
0.5265313982963562,
1.0271049737930298,
-0.3984173536300659,
-0.6455400586128235,
-0.24668264389038086,
-0.11985401064157486,
-0.46303901076316833,
0.8427008390426636,
0.26842164993286133,
-0.1505894958972931,
-0.1626911610364914,
-0.48406654596328735,
-0.8458279967308044,
0.7494943737983704,
0.09636503458023071,
-0.3506618142127991,
0.49152252078056335,
0.159148171544075,
0.9726625084877014,
-0.40058088302612305,
0.3239266574382782,
0.7329813838005066,
0.5833895802497864,
0.07050074636936188,
-0.6891486644744873,
-0.06420090794563293,
-0.301889568567276,
0.2097441554069519,
0.11993242800235748,
-0.5393440127372742,
0.4722677767276764,
-0.1442190259695053,
-0.3400450050830841,
-0.40769481658935547,
0.787816047668457,
0.016582198441028595,
0.4569016098976135,
0.5258480310440063,
0.6888441443443298,
1.090105414390564,
-0.43793606758117676,
1.1390794515609741,
-0.2310081124305725,
0.34688910841941833,
0.8841384649276733,
-0.3185070753097534,
0.4671761393547058,
0.0834362804889679,
-0.14256057143211365,
0.30693113803863525,
0.88788241147995,
-0.16527917981147766,
0.4600946307182312,
0.1342514604330063,
-0.3277459740638733,
-0.13009880483150482,
-0.7092171311378479,
-0.3239375352859497,
0.343027263879776,
0.6542593836784363,
-0.17783477902412415,
-0.12056934088468552,
0.5723665952682495,
-0.19204893708229065,
-0.3004035949707031,
-0.40798771381378174,
0.8735342621803284,
0.04386952519416809,
-0.3476063907146454,
0.4944441020488739,
-0.20499585568904877,
0.6264652013778687,
0.05749601498246193,
-0.12970739603042603,
-0.2567281126976013,
0.24040324985980988,
-0.6964072585105896,
-0.9492946267127991,
0.20295247435569763,
0.45181700587272644,
0.03252178803086281,
-0.3545633554458618,
0.7474297285079956,
-0.6577996015548706,
-0.3588980436325073,
0.15010614693164825,
0.22120822966098785,
0.37017691135406494,
0.14234501123428345,
-0.6764295697212219,
0.1016077771782875,
-0.27274298667907715,
-0.28198641538619995,
0.1612546145915985,
0.7182543873786926,
0.13592436909675598,
0.5889616012573242,
0.514718234539032,
0.027396945282816887,
-0.03593037277460098,
-0.02333005517721176,
0.7887430787086487,
-0.6118023991584778,
-0.394767701625824,
-0.6924062967300415,
0.5234320163726807,
-0.2546347975730896,
-0.09590960294008255,
0.7434247732162476,
0.479629784822464,
0.7423890233039856,
-0.04985826835036278,
1.052258849143982,
0.07867702096700668,
0.25768399238586426,
-0.35581353306770325,
0.1368047297000885,
-0.64596027135849,
-0.20009668171405792,
-0.48523861169815063,
-0.6465004682540894,
-0.27164480090141296,
0.6044124960899353,
-0.4908089339733124,
0.1295696198940277,
0.49352091550827026,
0.3171332776546478,
0.1358795315027237,
0.16927959024906158,
0.33354032039642334,
-0.028673527762293816,
-0.06595663726329803,
0.6366934776306152,
1.006105661392212,
-0.47537675499916077,
0.5833963751792908,
-0.660431981086731,
-0.27270129323005676,
-0.3884943425655365,
-0.7019372582435608,
-0.7471544146537781,
-0.23068732023239136,
-0.4863719642162323,
-0.4342896044254303,
-0.016547515988349915,
0.9622473120689392,
0.7220297455787659,
-0.7989706993103027,
0.06655072420835495,
0.47958552837371826,
0.053186941891908646,
0.005974215921014547,
-0.16149230301380157,
0.25280123949050903,
-0.3820047676563263,
-0.7745963931083679,
0.39169642329216003,
0.2330905944108963,
0.389204204082489,
0.1502150148153305,
-0.20740659534931183,
0.2148326188325882,
-0.2689858078956604,
0.7354886531829834,
0.2739558815956116,
-0.338262140750885,
-0.14325742423534393,
-0.17604005336761475,
-0.10986322909593582,
0.24300198256969452,
0.6241907477378845,
-0.5828890204429626,
0.7870370149612427,
0.4478311836719513,
1.0173802375793457,
0.6503514051437378,
0.4981035590171814,
0.3436306118965149,
-1.0954846143722534,
0.09787578880786896,
0.056849051266908646,
0.4901866614818573,
0.5630910992622375,
-0.6893428564071655,
0.781799852848053,
0.14990195631980896,
-0.38399919867515564,
-0.8561792969703674,
0.06507928669452667,
-0.6839885115623474,
0.05661775544285774,
1.0892589092254639,
-0.12152907252311707,
-0.1335541307926178,
0.07635827362537384,
-0.2990388572216034,
0.6420610547065735,
-0.7860222458839417,
0.8968418836593628,
0.8363409638404846,
-0.7846689820289612,
-0.36232638359069824,
-0.23934559524059296,
0.36490947008132935,
0.321607768535614,
-1.1813409328460693,
0.018106309697031975,
0.8196333050727844,
-0.2303297072649002,
0.462024450302124,
0.19875837862491608,
0.11153928935527802,
0.007492217235267162,
-0.34748977422714233,
0.3510565757751465,
-0.02665301039814949,
-0.15741968154907227,
-0.7140403985977173,
0.09116451442241669,
-0.45326218008995056,
-0.4825001657009125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05186v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05186v1
|
Correlation Does Not Imply Compensation: Complexity and Irregularity in the Lexicon
| 2024-06-07T18:09:21 | 2024-06-07T18:09:21 |
Amanda Doucette, Ryan Cotterell, Morgan Sonderegger, Timothy J. O'Donnell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
It has been claimed that within a language, morphologically irregular words
are more likely to be phonotactically simple and morphologically regular words
are more likely to be phonotactically complex. This inverse correlation has
been demonstrated in English for a small sample of words, but has yet to be
shown for a larger sample of languages. Furthermore, frequency and word length
are known to influence both phonotactic complexity and morphological
irregularity, and they may be confounding factors in this relationship.
Therefore, we examine the relationships between all pairs of these four
variables both to assess the robustness of previous findings using improved
methodology and as a step towards understanding the underlying causal
relationship. Using information-theoretic measures of phonotactic complexity
and morphological irregularity (Pimentel et al., 2020; Wu et al., 2019) on 25
languages from UniMorph, we find that there is evidence of a positive
relationship between morphological irregularity and phonotactic complexity
within languages on average, although the direction varies within individual
languages. We also find weak evidence of a negative relationship between word
length and morphological irregularity that had not been previously identified,
and that some existing findings about the relationships between these four
variables are not as robust as previously thought.
|
[
-0.21459268033504486,
-0.833569347858429,
0.6945258378982544,
0.36872896552085876,
-0.4240787625312805,
-0.1691419929265976,
-0.11561775952577591,
-0.8197841048240662,
0.6751784682273865,
0.12569217383861542,
-0.26184314489364624,
0.17472229897975922,
-0.7188484072685242,
0.4111928343772888,
-0.3067314028739929,
0.6447540521621704,
0.26026174426078796,
0.15833845734596252,
-0.26982730627059937,
-0.33906227350234985,
-0.4599810242652893,
-0.3353075683116913,
-0.575950026512146,
-0.49441200494766235,
0.3866822421550751,
0.07497458904981613,
1.1864302158355713,
1.0078575611114502,
0.6020215749740601,
0.3540603518486023,
-0.2649341821670532,
0.10015442222356796,
-0.2232954055070877,
0.27234235405921936,
-0.1731744259595871,
-0.6426103115081787,
-0.24292480945587158,
-0.45834651589393616,
0.4882853031158447,
1.2885830402374268,
-0.11929705739021301,
-0.23514024913311005,
0.05715233087539673,
1.0004807710647583,
-0.46067044138908386,
0.09961626678705215,
-0.6261797547340393,
-0.25753119587898254,
-0.8001466989517212,
-0.37605980038642883,
-0.01888403855264187,
-0.21945084631443024,
-0.020457798615098,
-0.6642032861709595,
0.066319040954113,
0.1267625391483307,
1.1068910360336304,
0.3485110104084015,
-0.0977979451417923,
-0.5881665945053101,
-0.8926546573638916,
0.7809486985206604,
-0.43646174669265747,
0.4379860758781433,
0.7149020433425903,
-0.27234652638435364,
-0.4401229918003082,
-0.34326252341270447,
-0.6644162535667419,
-0.3162621855735779,
-0.18584416806697845,
0.296109676361084,
-0.23937386274337769,
0.043514419347047806,
0.06915371865034103,
0.6445115804672241,
-0.6900966167449951,
0.3856867253780365,
-0.15755942463874817,
-0.3642098009586334,
0.3837382197380066,
0.46378135681152344,
0.6046122312545776,
-0.23179079592227936,
-0.13115552067756653,
0.04602295160293579,
-0.5662825703620911,
0.3297269642353058,
0.8615006804466248,
0.33211615681648254,
-0.3719136118888855,
0.7916256189346313,
0.18834374845027924,
0.7111334204673767,
-0.037571027874946594,
-0.44187992811203003,
0.11834686249494553,
-0.7225258350372314,
0.1566479653120041,
0.14242541790008545,
0.8669421672821045,
0.16578105092048645,
0.268278032541275,
-0.3857097625732422,
-0.03593980148434639,
0.1984017789363861,
-0.2104547619819641,
-0.1215115636587143,
-0.23020786046981812,
0.29665887355804443,
-0.23112492263317108,
0.06947027891874313,
0.40832725167274475,
-0.9431259036064148,
-0.4821570813655853,
-0.12237346172332764,
0.41308584809303284,
-0.5302956104278564,
-0.4187099039554596,
0.3061700165271759,
-0.21502727270126343,
0.05281548202037811,
0.06783207505941391,
-0.906180739402771,
0.47138911485671997,
0.6359955072402954,
0.9645598530769348,
-0.41394853591918945,
-0.5836057662963867,
-0.10059843957424164,
0.024456070736050606,
-0.5207502841949463,
0.9484913349151611,
-0.6150107383728027,
-0.40467774868011475,
0.07351525872945786,
0.04079676419496536,
-0.07656834274530411,
-0.43119874596595764,
0.5837821364402771,
0.00804968923330307,
0.019456658512353897,
-0.09407266974449158,
-0.5042169094085693,
0.01451259944587946,
-0.26407474279403687,
-0.9197967052459717,
0.764424204826355,
0.2653195559978485,
-1.0257890224456787,
0.32391825318336487,
0.1484966278076172,
-0.6875874996185303,
-0.02248174510896206,
-0.32865604758262634,
-0.64051753282547,
0.19345076382160187,
-0.3948737382888794,
-0.09379555284976959,
-0.4434994161128998,
0.294414758682251,
-0.42189526557922363,
-0.26032647490501404,
0.6285990476608276,
-0.4036687910556793,
0.8158618807792664,
-0.032431695610284805,
-0.3832392394542694,
-0.4086058735847473,
-1.0883667469024658,
-0.33769118785858154,
0.009254497475922108,
-0.3891148269176483,
-0.5854496359825134,
0.19103801250457764,
-0.37427905201911926,
0.0559162013232708,
0.22611422836780548,
-0.462121844291687,
0.1349850744009018,
-0.6094105243682861,
0.31817343831062317,
0.5128622055053711,
0.12343869358301163,
0.5876720547676086,
-0.707354724407196,
0.32179853320121765,
0.2658073306083679,
0.0186520554125309,
0.08644212782382965,
-0.7861552834510803,
-0.8269591927528381,
-0.20434965193271637,
0.3620838224887848,
0.477031409740448,
-0.45153388381004333,
0.38048672676086426,
-0.42849528789520264,
-0.47860628366470337,
-0.36027947068214417,
0.03326911851763725,
0.5227904319763184,
0.4084005653858185,
0.31534478068351746,
-0.889788806438446,
-0.580501914024353,
-0.7997044920921326,
-0.3653382658958435,
-0.6642381548881531,
0.0017683012410998344,
0.08520922064781189,
0.06429087370634079,
0.009970835410058498,
0.6269229650497437,
-0.07180090248584747,
-0.4075923264026642,
0.16584309935569763,
0.16733676195144653,
0.2965236008167267,
0.38105887174606323,
0.654080331325531,
-0.34678536653518677,
-0.29411521553993225,
0.07362763583660126,
-0.3146321177482605,
-0.2823144793510437,
0.08230221271514893,
0.17318975925445557,
0.5211140513420105,
0.4526308476924896,
-0.7098348736763,
0.4612988233566284,
0.5841480493545532,
-0.31154748797416687,
0.477213591337204,
-0.4013005197048187,
-0.032004863023757935,
-0.700492262840271,
0.023128492757678032,
-0.17724965512752533,
0.1341271698474884,
-0.6578308343887329,
-0.35712331533432007,
-0.17678582668304443,
0.2715877890586853,
-0.1534634530544281,
0.3681877851486206,
-0.3789006471633911,
-0.10796388238668442,
0.019275126978754997,
0.1809445321559906,
-0.10508029162883759,
0.5035552382469177,
-0.20900797843933105,
0.5431697964668274,
0.6025274395942688,
-1.0124025344848633,
0.14798922836780548,
-0.020821984857320786,
-0.31351619958877563,
0.3738018274307251,
-0.6025285124778748,
-0.39970821142196655,
-0.11126749962568283,
-0.43314945697784424,
-1.292533040046692,
-0.36684709787368774,
0.09270041435956955,
-0.6002568006515503,
0.23197898268699646,
0.28397586941719055,
-0.45037558674812317,
0.06990743428468704,
-0.35189592838287354,
0.5487809777259827,
0.4726232886314392,
0.07616470754146576,
0.3837031126022339,
0.5217734575271606,
-0.056527212262153625,
-0.3065725564956665,
-1.0615354776382446,
-0.32340797781944275,
-0.20049318671226501,
-0.6416750550270081,
0.32645219564437866,
-0.192640483379364,
-0.8162141442298889,
0.098966084420681,
-0.3679073452949524,
-0.2649341821670532,
0.19087228178977966,
0.3631672263145447,
-0.20679958164691925,
-0.30325040221214294,
0.30433449149131775,
-0.20804131031036377,
0.011538838036358356,
-0.12326963990926743,
-0.038084302097558975,
0.8115638494491577,
0.28278541564941406,
-0.24284739792346954,
-0.4292948842048645,
0.0897260457277298,
0.7341057658195496,
-0.00934675894677639,
0.5486727356910706,
0.11560837179422379,
-0.2096090316772461,
0.4241355061531067,
-0.5481041073799133,
0.137547567486763,
-0.42062559723854065,
0.12003553658723831,
-0.387443870306015,
-0.6699179410934448,
0.915691614151001,
0.4153158962726593,
-0.36670228838920593,
0.6524214148521423,
0.6846071481704712,
0.12179213017225266,
0.8825985193252563,
0.47284913063049316,
-0.023169755935668945,
0.5501320362091064,
0.43997523188591003,
0.18891750276088715,
-0.39966943860054016,
-0.5184406638145447,
-0.9295185804367065,
0.19282160699367523,
-1.1713234186172485,
0.035227805376052856,
0.08238782733678818,
0.09804686903953552,
-0.17521972954273224,
0.18587954342365265,
-0.0479208379983902,
0.09549178928136826,
0.2400626689195633,
-0.07841920107603073,
0.3103126585483551,
0.06145867705345154,
0.02076883427798748,
-0.08692912012338638,
-0.5615219473838806,
-0.21585609018802643,
0.6420525312423706,
0.11147422343492508,
0.8261598348617554,
0.6769312620162964,
0.4253321588039398,
0.0650472566485405,
-0.8193034529685974,
-0.8457236289978027,
0.16294047236442566,
-0.22053806483745575,
-0.21388201415538788,
-0.6171538829803467,
-0.3428272306919098,
-1.7454360723495483,
0.009412779472768307,
-0.3061336278915405,
-0.8308332562446594,
0.7006710171699524,
0.0037985402159392834,
-0.2370792180299759,
0.07397342473268509,
-0.500312864780426,
0.05253133922815323,
-0.07524304836988449,
-0.41063353419303894,
0.03553374856710434,
-0.7224237322807312,
0.27715784311294556,
-0.2919759154319763,
0.6222812533378601,
-0.13585710525512695,
-0.21805477142333984,
0.7099451422691345,
-0.7570001482963562,
0.6865978240966797,
0.5146450996398926,
-0.21110215783119202,
0.17599637806415558,
0.548427402973175,
0.2228330820798874,
0.16628584265708923,
-0.15608926117420197,
0.2191164642572403,
0.030233386904001236,
-0.5543588995933533,
-0.44992682337760925,
0.701842188835144,
-0.8651331067085266,
-0.5996643900871277,
-0.6283673048019409,
-0.6435059905052185,
-0.17721222341060638,
0.46650823950767517,
0.39456042647361755,
0.39399439096450806,
0.10456828773021698,
0.03116227500140667,
0.5780084729194641,
0.005371598992496729,
0.7317260503768921,
0.5477223992347717,
0.07479618489742279,
-0.34067320823669434,
0.7122467160224915,
0.5754622220993042,
0.37735694646835327,
0.6176800727844238,
0.38932985067367554,
0.13680075109004974,
-0.504265308380127,
-0.035750918090343475,
0.4553071856498718,
-0.2428407371044159,
-0.023697102442383766,
-0.4793597459793091,
0.04385249316692352,
-0.5426324605941772,
0.12805436551570892,
-0.3703482449054718,
-0.7711693048477173,
-0.05196969583630562,
0.1992671936750412,
0.5342919826507568,
0.8913767337799072,
-0.33906835317611694,
0.26519545912742615,
-0.6228311657905579,
0.13946157693862915,
0.36438074707984924,
0.1983131319284439,
0.053561676293611526,
-0.7143831849098206,
-0.060079026967287064,
0.026203664019703865,
-0.09157992899417877,
-0.9517711400985718,
0.2545216977596283,
0.4317118525505066,
0.6481752991676331,
0.7059663534164429,
-0.1376195102930069,
0.9672269225120544,
-0.6120207905769348,
1.0421284437179565,
0.29305943846702576,
-0.9692796468734741,
0.060165129601955414,
-0.2099817842245102,
0.09698270261287689,
0.3002476990222931,
0.33756259083747864,
-0.30644163489341736,
-0.9169771671295166,
-1.0374459028244019,
-0.976833164691925,
0.5856086015701294,
0.37273791432380676,
0.10645455121994019,
-0.14212645590305328,
0.46805763244628906,
0.17299436032772064,
-0.02776149846613407,
-0.501079797744751,
-0.5120549201965332,
-0.204629585146904,
0.11135625839233398,
-0.11042545735836029,
-0.5239395499229431,
-0.04389353469014168,
-0.10034067183732986,
0.37164032459259033,
0.3860720098018646,
0.3126555383205414,
0.30922332406044006,
-0.05455689877271652,
-0.5119504332542419,
0.08920758217573166,
1.2029218673706055,
0.9779496788978577,
-0.04009734466671944,
0.6314345002174377,
-0.013627693988382816,
-0.7708147168159485,
0.009327552281320095,
-0.24058163166046143,
0.20007510483264923,
0.3748326599597931,
1.034071683883667,
0.6900115609169006,
0.2676016092300415,
-0.37091532349586487,
0.47236910462379456,
-0.03103184700012207,
-0.07913611829280853,
-0.3979560434818268,
-0.04140589013695717,
-0.042826976627111435,
-0.08280733227729797,
-0.027808142825961113,
0.13033901154994965,
0.05691671743988991,
-0.7550193071365356,
0.09740433841943741,
0.3163842558860779,
-0.3964950144290924,
-0.6158649325370789,
0.32856062054634094,
-0.25754278898239136,
-0.5363540649414062,
0.5126751661300659,
-0.10633894801139832,
-0.28153860569000244,
0.7576816082000732,
0.6402474641799927,
0.2545505166053772,
-0.5132132172584534,
-0.06268054991960526,
0.45871007442474365,
0.4874301850795746,
-0.18435662984848022,
0.3288843631744385,
0.2511148452758789,
-0.6020083427429199,
-0.2475479394197464,
-0.6007188558578491,
-0.2513180077075958,
0.2852914333343506,
-0.8133111000061035,
0.3032841980457306,
-0.19932657480239868,
-0.034232866019010544,
0.2852115035057068,
-0.13350877165794373,
-0.2899138629436493,
-0.03610001131892204,
-0.41065582633018494,
0.5303850769996643,
-0.9957446455955505,
0.7186030745506287,
0.4460507333278656,
-0.8796406984329224,
-0.9790998697280884,
0.11870779097080231,
-0.02180924080312252,
-1.03382408618927,
0.5038610696792603,
-0.26823756098747253,
-0.0828355923295021,
-0.2572343945503235,
-0.25730377435684204,
-1.016940951347351,
0.8098880052566528,
0.4888187050819397,
-0.5270699262619019,
0.24316924810409546,
0.5352367162704468,
0.9724907875061035,
0.24919681251049042,
0.08625466376543045,
0.3648696839809418,
0.528825044631958,
0.05342571437358856,
-1.1894195079803467,
-0.019262071698904037,
0.09365305304527283,
0.10532029718160629,
0.6360093355178833,
-0.5954117178916931,
1.3058185577392578,
0.019844526425004005,
-0.5138888955116272,
0.29139280319213867,
0.42252862453460693,
-0.05759812146425247,
-0.019603306427598,
0.35076451301574707,
0.609765887260437,
0.7875308990478516,
-0.01882951892912388,
1.2663863897323608,
-0.7270664572715759,
0.3379608988761902,
0.7461706399917603,
0.05339592322707176,
0.4266263544559479,
0.9329649806022644,
-0.6372517347335815,
0.5155507326126099,
0.7281938195228577,
0.13685759902000427,
0.5122262239456177,
0.035258110612630844,
0.004068608861416578,
-0.34749600291252136,
-0.3434612452983856,
-0.25556302070617676,
0.4336733818054199,
0.492776095867157,
-0.19126152992248535,
-0.14844048023223877,
-0.5091274976730347,
0.3884568512439728,
0.21458303928375244,
-0.410278856754303,
0.7974263429641724,
0.31358247995376587,
-0.8454603552818298,
0.5291175246238708,
-0.11773742735385895,
0.4338575005531311,
-0.7295488715171814,
0.022347034886479378,
-0.549606442451477,
0.015394722111523151,
-0.5249801874160767,
-0.9183181524276733,
0.5103834867477417,
-0.5952528119087219,
-0.23822292685508728,
0.5776404738426208,
0.5494987368583679,
-0.4445142149925232,
-0.10183725506067276,
0.32276254892349243,
0.612382173538208,
0.31576788425445557,
0.5892188549041748,
-0.27143213152885437,
-0.02460879646241665,
-0.24049851298332214,
0.14848487079143524,
0.30424490571022034,
0.8830995559692383,
-0.27421241998672485,
0.5555782914161682,
0.4219513535499573,
0.5280085802078247,
0.3306661546230316,
0.013011972419917583,
0.48274412751197815,
-0.2148594856262207,
-0.26235097646713257,
-1.191734790802002,
0.34692516922950745,
0.16969171166419983,
-0.310482382774353,
0.8157779574394226,
0.4235766530036926,
0.8546115756034851,
-0.07211340963840485,
0.35708868503570557,
-0.05858788266777992,
0.24970225989818573,
-0.6389686465263367,
0.153699591755867,
-0.6573032736778259,
0.2346554845571518,
-0.40064921975135803,
-0.797799825668335,
-0.7158997654914856,
0.6211357712745667,
-0.042067501693964005,
-0.20482131838798523,
1.1701492071151733,
0.8539670705795288,
-0.014030227437615395,
-0.3066619038581848,
0.5964598059654236,
0.32093000411987305,
-0.20033924281597137,
0.22354550659656525,
0.4725748598575592,
-0.16421377658843994,
0.5188111662864685,
-0.2556068003177643,
-0.15001337230205536,
-0.10434387624263763,
-0.7295436859130859,
-0.6703416705131531,
-0.9305108189582825,
-0.13092027604579926,
-0.6154686808586121,
0.06921771913766861,
0.6217048168182373,
-0.043174147605895996,
-0.8176670670509338,
-0.4880051612854004,
-0.46290722489356995,
0.4497714936733246,
-0.4420882761478424,
-0.19468003511428833,
0.5937039852142334,
-0.3574073314666748,
-0.6719912886619568,
-0.13929486274719238,
0.37970149517059326,
0.324462890625,
-0.15352529287338257,
-0.010917606763541698,
-0.010311778634786606,
0.3660127520561218,
0.3954545855522156,
0.5480304956436157,
-0.7539296746253967,
-0.3533419668674469,
-0.1209905594587326,
-0.2519228756427765,
0.2900990843772888,
0.8694354891777039,
-0.09278910607099533,
0.467252254486084,
0.8518103957176208,
0.35948121547698975,
-0.24841344356536865,
-0.30569347739219666,
0.3593989908695221,
-0.6365108489990234,
0.3865310251712799,
-0.18901169300079346,
0.6434003710746765,
0.20696008205413818,
-0.3007180690765381,
0.4420246481895447,
0.45818403363227844,
-0.6167895793914795,
-0.7291229963302612,
0.7523725628852844,
-1.1389762163162231,
-0.33543896675109863,
1.196664810180664,
-0.07484297454357147,
-0.2584700882434845,
-0.6806679964065552,
0.13740524649620056,
0.43013229966163635,
-0.21953816711902618,
1.0715141296386719,
1.0185045003890991,
-0.551479697227478,
0.0882146805524826,
-0.20915091037750244,
0.6503274440765381,
0.5444175004959106,
-0.27822059392929077,
-0.11468058079481125,
0.17716531455516815,
0.15428663790225983,
0.7780950665473938,
0.4824400246143341,
-0.37375205755233765,
0.0706978365778923,
0.2234327495098114,
-0.17328105866909027,
0.22070194780826569,
-0.014138533733785152,
-0.6434515714645386,
-0.12018077820539474,
0.6371487379074097,
0.1374456286430359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05183v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05183v1
|
The Factorization Curse: Which Tokens You Predict Underlie the Reversal Curse and More
| 2024-06-07T18:00:37 | 2024-06-07T18:00:37 |
Ouail Kitouni, Niklas Nolte, Diane Bouchacourt, Adina Williams, Mike Rabbat, Mark Ibrahim
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Today's best language models still struggle with hallucinations: factually
incorrect generations, which impede their ability to reliably retrieve
information seen during training. The reversal curse, where models cannot
recall information when probed in a different order than was encountered during
training, exemplifies this in information retrieval. We reframe the reversal
curse as a factorization curse - a failure of models to learn the same joint
distribution under different factorizations. Through a series of controlled
experiments with increasing levels of realism including WikiReversal, a setting
we introduce to closely simulate a knowledge intensive finetuning task, we find
that the factorization curse is an inherent failure of the next-token
prediction objective used in popular large language models. Moreover, we
demonstrate reliable information retrieval cannot be solved with scale,
reversed tokens, or even naive bidirectional-attention training. Consequently,
various approaches to finetuning on specialized data would necessarily provide
mixed results on downstream tasks, unless the model has already seen the right
sequence of tokens. Across five tasks of varying levels of complexity, our
results uncover a promising path forward: factorization-agnostic objectives can
significantly mitigate the reversal curse and hint at improved knowledge
storage and planning capabilities.
|
[
-0.3183612525463104,
-0.8383044004440308,
0.43175172805786133,
0.24600358307361603,
-0.20367208123207092,
0.269991397857666,
-0.04651036486029625,
-0.38550928235054016,
0.5085750222206116,
0.7342758774757385,
-0.5183221697807312,
0.1014341413974762,
-0.8845428228378296,
0.1126784086227417,
-0.5982909202575684,
1.24959135055542,
0.2821989953517914,
0.6144164800643921,
-0.18032851815223694,
0.0799848809838295,
-0.620067834854126,
-0.6857219338417053,
-0.9193612337112427,
-0.6095063090324402,
0.417728453874588,
0.4557771682739258,
0.8907275795936584,
0.3962183892726898,
0.654668927192688,
0.21703623235225677,
0.19332517683506012,
0.23505769670009613,
-0.9082275629043579,
0.05624290555715561,
-0.32021084427833557,
-0.7970136404037476,
-0.015475940890610218,
0.2289598435163498,
0.1962643563747406,
1.0475366115570068,
0.027796577662229538,
0.07286176085472107,
0.03104134276509285,
0.6182034015655518,
-0.4572412073612213,
0.028810957446694374,
-0.8430408239364624,
0.08376605063676834,
-0.02479378879070282,
-0.6242559552192688,
-0.298077255487442,
-0.4055067300796509,
0.11998561024665833,
-0.5112963914871216,
0.599698543548584,
0.3881099820137024,
0.7574279308319092,
0.40697166323661804,
-0.390850692987442,
-0.4731038808822632,
-0.925342857837677,
0.7984949946403503,
-0.4052232801914215,
0.4796644449234009,
0.7084107995033264,
0.1884223371744156,
-0.226477712392807,
-0.6102576851844788,
-0.7402663230895996,
-0.26712343096733093,
-0.026264654472470284,
0.014936151914298534,
0.042394544929265976,
-0.09686587005853653,
0.15363988280296326,
0.2902732193470001,
-0.22703509032726288,
-0.015696493908762932,
-0.6443911790847778,
-0.38859471678733826,
0.17885808646678925,
0.11898235976696014,
0.2747405767440796,
-0.3323837220668793,
-0.5639706254005432,
-0.07441119104623795,
-0.8416083455085754,
-0.045103833079338074,
0.580377995967865,
0.45856988430023193,
0.3188963830471039,
0.5938506722450256,
0.016907259821891785,
0.3428390920162201,
0.40902531147003174,
-0.1478160321712494,
0.039849117398262024,
-0.3213525712490082,
-0.1164470836520195,
0.2143397480249405,
0.3306605815887451,
0.34324830770492554,
0.3452998995780945,
-0.4987809360027313,
-0.25773879885673523,
0.033010855317115784,
0.4656805694103241,
-0.553801953792572,
-0.2083049863576889,
0.203318789601326,
-0.40632298588752747,
-0.42554354667663574,
0.04521428048610687,
-0.5802958011627197,
-0.8846122622489929,
-0.5076255798339844,
0.6957950592041016,
-0.5189533233642578,
-0.16728821396827698,
0.21431545913219452,
-0.2511424720287323,
0.021449550986289978,
-0.0029002821538597345,
-0.886327862739563,
0.29161953926086426,
1.0989857912063599,
0.5584589242935181,
-0.17880165576934814,
-0.35480383038520813,
-0.7111067771911621,
-0.23327738046646118,
-0.3987234830856323,
0.38750484585762024,
-0.6920926570892334,
-0.3714239299297333,
-0.1905512511730194,
0.028898222371935844,
-0.15253326296806335,
-0.5397629737854004,
0.4683726131916046,
-0.2575283646583557,
0.1226121112704277,
-0.4796971082687378,
-0.2757274806499481,
-0.2135487049818039,
0.10868198424577713,
-0.41589680314064026,
0.6453285217285156,
-0.15213122963905334,
-0.8007997274398804,
0.5788448452949524,
0.16597706079483032,
-0.4876536726951599,
-0.23751771450042725,
-0.2616287171840668,
-0.2990514039993286,
0.5895064473152161,
-0.20514348149299622,
0.2997114360332489,
-0.6116278171539307,
0.6091206669807434,
-0.22834713757038116,
-0.6522026062011719,
0.16779778897762299,
-0.6372144222259521,
0.852026641368866,
0.03662853315472603,
-0.6401546001434326,
-0.07869799435138702,
-0.7942055463790894,
-0.4750243127346039,
0.06957164406776428,
-0.16869471967220306,
-0.6191591024398804,
0.022282421588897705,
-0.289651483297348,
0.327869176864624,
0.14433304965496063,
-0.6308821439743042,
0.2608517110347748,
-0.37503817677497864,
0.18694612383842468,
0.785117506980896,
-0.015391304157674313,
0.3733219504356384,
-0.14251478016376495,
0.4546203315258026,
0.516758143901825,
0.36106735467910767,
0.33566462993621826,
-0.5041770935058594,
-1.2030882835388184,
0.37954646348953247,
0.2041456252336502,
0.6088730692863464,
-1.2857513427734375,
0.049497414380311966,
-0.41431885957717896,
-0.20869332551956177,
-0.6982814073562622,
-0.0630025714635849,
0.7076875567436218,
0.5458900332450867,
0.380056768655777,
-0.4450173079967499,
-0.6424307823181152,
-1.0843209028244019,
-0.274522602558136,
-0.08634728938341141,
0.2672022581100464,
0.14357890188694,
0.5468393564224243,
-0.13978835940361023,
0.5298194885253906,
-0.5010254383087158,
-0.6661853790283203,
-0.13172225654125214,
0.5101983547210693,
0.14601640403270721,
0.6364411115646362,
0.34312108159065247,
-0.8981578946113586,
0.13266108930110931,
-0.04554678499698639,
-0.3696066439151764,
0.2873399555683136,
-0.3594825267791748,
0.09853833168745041,
0.32182976603507996,
0.7055222392082214,
-0.5452887415885925,
0.16839803755283356,
0.3400214612483978,
-0.8466432690620422,
0.8493757247924805,
-0.11922360211610794,
0.17572565376758575,
-0.810121476650238,
0.11248603463172913,
-0.5535549521446228,
0.042659077793359756,
-0.6233469843864441,
0.08978423476219177,
-0.25238752365112305,
0.1336137056350708,
0.19082000851631165,
0.4107307493686676,
-0.22429221868515015,
-0.0914347842335701,
-0.16131004691123962,
0.028719641268253326,
-0.0636192113161087,
0.4598149061203003,
-0.26815998554229736,
0.8098254203796387,
0.5215297937393188,
-0.4994092583656311,
0.008126150816679,
0.0409465990960598,
-0.22045496106147766,
0.5679922103881836,
-0.10491437464952469,
0.13632264733314514,
-0.46638181805610657,
-0.19567757844924927,
-1.0302659273147583,
-0.061550796031951904,
0.05868317186832428,
-0.6264616847038269,
0.6276597380638123,
0.06201447919011116,
-0.39297378063201904,
-0.5690820217132568,
-0.42036646604537964,
0.29258963465690613,
0.3046967685222626,
-0.6301549673080444,
0.7674312591552734,
0.1352667361497879,
-0.048619434237480164,
-1.1644470691680908,
-0.8095546364784241,
0.09507892280817032,
-0.17942839860916138,
-0.22447462379932404,
0.05033531412482262,
-0.021764935925602913,
-0.2888469994068146,
-0.06498266011476517,
-0.42618969082832336,
0.16649624705314636,
0.2186088114976883,
0.2542174458503723,
0.11081968992948532,
-0.01007765717804432,
0.20220334827899933,
-0.12471260130405426,
-0.2832886576652527,
-0.01841105706989765,
-0.5844201445579529,
0.7941895127296448,
0.14238491654396057,
-0.22659052908420563,
0.10407496988773346,
0.0020289598032832146,
0.5081734657287598,
-0.022326476871967316,
0.7415783405303955,
0.6750404834747314,
-0.4699797034263611,
0.09165771305561066,
-1.1008726358413696,
-0.5323339104652405,
-0.40908077359199524,
0.2833491563796997,
-0.48319679498672485,
-0.7973741888999939,
0.746323823928833,
0.23279647529125214,
-0.19727985560894012,
0.3399540185928345,
0.021427517756819725,
0.05803048983216286,
1.2153569459915161,
0.6941661238670349,
-0.20451833307743073,
0.18706561625003815,
-0.37115180492401123,
0.6007065176963806,
-0.491038054227829,
-0.22872322797775269,
-0.4299306273460388,
-0.2662281095981598,
-0.6275294423103333,
-0.35321465134620667,
0.199167400598526,
0.49285510182380676,
-0.06681227684020996,
0.18004865944385529,
-0.3278564214706421,
0.427290678024292,
0.7127294540405273,
0.16984759271144867,
0.5885396599769592,
0.04777403920888901,
-0.21923793852329254,
0.028639907017350197,
-0.5831307768821716,
-0.12765289843082428,
1.0671615600585938,
-0.004782543517649174,
0.4697912633419037,
-0.1263006329536438,
0.8128710389137268,
0.07898321747779846,
0.23943690955638885,
-0.6774972081184387,
0.48857903480529785,
-0.3877558410167694,
-0.5933041572570801,
-0.2606870234012604,
-0.4756960868835449,
-0.7792062163352966,
0.26238614320755005,
-0.28447631001472473,
-0.6941936612129211,
0.6642280220985413,
0.2144986391067505,
-0.329159677028656,
0.3975636959075928,
-0.8326451182365417,
0.6064664721488953,
-0.004954767879098654,
-0.46233290433883667,
-0.4845007359981537,
-0.5352616310119629,
0.5415273308753967,
-0.12199431657791138,
0.39172348380088806,
0.15252813696861267,
0.2985573410987854,
0.6550670266151428,
-0.4450606107711792,
0.9416712522506714,
-0.2206699699163437,
0.03729252517223358,
0.10135312378406525,
0.5727980732917786,
0.6743466258049011,
-0.0922451838850975,
0.008364543318748474,
-0.2534082531929016,
-0.04017364978790283,
-0.3677513897418976,
-0.5520723462104797,
0.9976276755332947,
-0.6178837418556213,
-1.0136804580688477,
-0.3309791088104248,
-0.31063222885131836,
-0.2833898067474365,
0.4003143310546875,
0.46704238653182983,
0.7057609558105469,
0.05395094305276871,
-0.0023217236157506704,
0.4291318953037262,
-0.09446769207715988,
0.20542818307876587,
0.4003887176513672,
-0.3793945908546448,
-0.20927409827709198,
1.687477946281433,
0.47082820534706116,
0.25676652789115906,
0.18756753206253052,
0.22063572704792023,
0.09972739964723587,
-0.6816396117210388,
0.055474717170000076,
0.2292756885290146,
-0.8282713294029236,
-0.29675614833831787,
-0.5816538333892822,
-0.012449256144464016,
-0.2207411676645279,
-0.11413977295160294,
-0.4380066394805908,
-0.6705500483512878,
-0.347137987613678,
-0.5060372948646545,
0.10916389524936676,
0.7695230841636658,
-0.1942404955625534,
-0.19892726838588715,
-0.24535448849201202,
0.2888266444206238,
0.2975400686264038,
0.52114337682724,
0.3023667335510254,
-0.3084222674369812,
0.007336113136261702,
-0.09280500560998917,
-0.03708694875240326,
-0.3628906011581421,
0.15039336681365967,
-0.11813756823539734,
0.1016380563378334,
0.5056886076927185,
-0.006339044310152531,
0.6029666066169739,
-0.37622275948524475,
0.657363772392273,
0.3384094536304474,
-0.6700406670570374,
-0.03322925418615341,
-0.16674664616584778,
0.059445571154356,
0.7578554153442383,
0.502962052822113,
-0.5815122127532959,
-0.6716873645782471,
-0.6959806084632874,
-0.8263961672782898,
0.510857880115509,
0.0863165408372879,
0.22255165874958038,
-0.36159855127334595,
0.4398597776889801,
0.6370898485183716,
0.2129582166671753,
-0.5594655275344849,
-0.4359431564807892,
-0.3797009587287903,
0.08874174952507019,
-0.2987905442714691,
-0.5094297528266907,
0.035604964941740036,
-0.43832865357398987,
0.7706762552261353,
-0.05706556886434555,
0.22213031351566315,
0.2588343620300293,
-0.24175889790058136,
-0.24626865983009338,
0.06910775601863861,
0.6287661790847778,
0.7103559374809265,
-0.13475996255874634,
0.4787810742855072,
0.002063776832073927,
-0.7694598436355591,
-0.16878339648246765,
0.13669568300247192,
-0.34398043155670166,
-0.29202574491500854,
0.408914178609848,
1.0120315551757812,
0.5994079113006592,
-0.3537033498287201,
0.4297544062137604,
0.19152170419692993,
-0.07283338159322739,
-0.386884480714798,
-0.10075755417346954,
0.018364649266004562,
0.19880826771259308,
0.7539055347442627,
0.3275112509727478,
0.35450872778892517,
-0.8108434677124023,
0.12566563487052917,
0.4683540165424347,
-0.638498842716217,
-0.34306561946868896,
0.7025501728057861,
-0.08486706018447876,
-0.10261319577693939,
0.5920016169548035,
-0.3845392167568207,
-0.5420199632644653,
0.5833933353424072,
0.45295754075050354,
0.7902607321739197,
-0.20639105141162872,
0.32143834233283997,
0.2880314290523529,
0.32939624786376953,
-0.19891341030597687,
0.5180957317352295,
0.28588181734085083,
-0.8333682417869568,
-0.28502318263053894,
-0.7061241269111633,
-0.034789737313985825,
-0.08555286377668381,
-0.45051196217536926,
0.06621631979942322,
-0.3956872522830963,
-0.3539978265762329,
-0.05416083708405495,
-0.019604161381721497,
-0.9212096333503723,
0.15023858845233917,
-0.17517931759357452,
0.6159838438034058,
-0.5885863900184631,
0.583386242389679,
0.20205384492874146,
-0.7829760313034058,
-0.5434034466743469,
0.008962739259004593,
-0.12302576750516891,
-0.9522159099578857,
0.831615686416626,
0.05399814620614052,
-0.15646366775035858,
0.3419226109981537,
-0.521658182144165,
-0.9418790340423584,
0.9798137545585632,
0.11316141486167908,
-0.40048232674598694,
-0.29671400785446167,
0.2293018400669098,
0.5779695510864258,
-0.2059793621301651,
0.022318709641695023,
0.8960715532302856,
0.4955214858055115,
-0.07005443423986435,
-0.9614481329917908,
0.15491408109664917,
0.19024668633937836,
-0.2710251212120056,
0.2192419320344925,
-0.5744218230247498,
0.917721688747406,
-0.525877833366394,
-0.2642291486263275,
-0.07119490951299667,
0.29451751708984375,
-0.19553188979625702,
0.10998298972845078,
0.4186699092388153,
0.502636730670929,
0.6536730527877808,
-0.2775530517101288,
1.300411581993103,
-0.12569522857666016,
0.2419704645872116,
0.9872925877571106,
0.05616588145494461,
0.6597474813461304,
0.7689005136489868,
0.13389159739017487,
0.3045930564403534,
0.10344117134809494,
0.07276792824268341,
0.5377308130264282,
0.1178378313779831,
0.232326477766037,
-0.29159149527549744,
-0.295002818107605,
-0.017310749739408493,
0.4148329198360443,
0.29322677850723267,
-0.29421016573905945,
-0.0883374735713005,
0.5678339600563049,
0.07947905361652374,
0.023959141224622726,
-0.502403974533081,
0.5299266576766968,
0.2507060766220093,
-0.8521326184272766,
0.6737242341041565,
-0.33865371346473694,
0.8147187232971191,
-0.25403204560279846,
0.003655852284282446,
-0.4776093065738678,
0.29635319113731384,
-0.25292372703552246,
-0.41074326634407043,
0.18346865475177765,
-0.6342995762825012,
-0.23731714487075806,
-0.0037382442969828844,
0.8639312982559204,
-0.424971342086792,
-0.49892351031303406,
0.4222891628742218,
0.41858214139938354,
0.03824450075626373,
0.022624487057328224,
-0.41825956106185913,
0.058153048157691956,
0.07374954223632812,
-0.26063475012779236,
0.27178654074668884,
0.2867072522640228,
-0.21782246232032776,
0.9553821682929993,
0.3846141993999481,
0.16337309777736664,
0.13644033670425415,
0.3136877417564392,
0.7090013027191162,
-0.6776131987571716,
-0.25400757789611816,
-0.6969510316848755,
0.25776436924934387,
0.05699440464377403,
-0.4012235403060913,
0.5963725447654724,
0.4310760796070099,
0.9047890901565552,
-0.36087003350257874,
0.5006061792373657,
0.16129153966903687,
0.41557085514068604,
-0.48642081022262573,
0.8549324870109558,
-0.521850049495697,
0.09068135917186737,
-0.2405022531747818,
-0.8523880839347839,
-0.18412630259990692,
0.27688881754875183,
-0.5564132332801819,
0.028926847502589226,
0.8358349204063416,
0.6077895760536194,
-0.027822988107800484,
0.14500685036182404,
0.32323604822158813,
0.7040194869041443,
0.07832302153110504,
0.27225175499916077,
0.5332605242729187,
-0.3468925356864929,
0.6290200352668762,
-0.44381311535835266,
0.054225824773311615,
-0.4636533558368683,
-0.4338366389274597,
-0.8578847646713257,
-1.0548521280288696,
-0.10495276749134064,
-0.3894476294517517,
0.29769283533096313,
0.9293102622032166,
0.23347240686416626,
-1.0217183828353882,
0.10368631780147552,
-0.2928895056247711,
0.3619261085987091,
-0.3559449017047882,
-0.3289954960346222,
0.367021381855011,
-0.5080088973045349,
-0.4656018614768982,
0.16635583341121674,
0.10226251184940338,
0.20279622077941895,
-0.5799002647399902,
0.15457357466220856,
-0.11996056139469147,
0.06052125245332718,
0.6317809224128723,
0.2535877227783203,
-0.8943337202072144,
-0.8103137016296387,
-0.06758161634206772,
-0.12210344523191452,
-0.26477953791618347,
1.0978633165359497,
-0.8690055012702942,
0.6635192036628723,
0.4859027564525604,
0.476211279630661,
0.40795740485191345,
-0.08213373273611069,
0.8145607709884644,
-0.6558265686035156,
0.10953105986118317,
0.14350934326648712,
0.2897545099258423,
0.3350593149662018,
-0.5003747940063477,
0.6261879205703735,
0.261366605758667,
-0.24585600197315216,
-0.977324903011322,
0.25250914692878723,
-0.5901826620101929,
-0.45465362071990967,
0.7743617296218872,
0.33387112617492676,
0.14861921966075897,
-0.4118252098560333,
-0.24883869290351868,
0.245613232254982,
-0.032724857330322266,
1.1950432062149048,
0.9122375249862671,
0.007309193257242441,
0.08206523209810257,
-0.6430822014808655,
0.9152472615242004,
0.7655539512634277,
-0.04887181520462036,
0.23481294512748718,
0.33026641607284546,
0.2858208417892456,
0.6433777213096619,
0.45784759521484375,
-0.042794182896614075,
0.09882688522338867,
0.0865798369050026,
-0.056881342083215714,
-0.08638853579759598,
-0.5665416121482849,
-0.2154434472322464,
0.03157927095890045,
0.18695183098316193,
0.25894513726234436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05132v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05132v2
|
3D-GRAND: A Million-Scale Dataset for 3D-LLMs with Better Grounding and Less Hallucination
| 2024-06-07T17:59:59 | 2024-06-12T17:59:58 |
Jianing Yang, Xuweiyi Chen, Nikhil Madaan, Madhavan Iyengar, Shengyi Qian, David F. Fouhey, Joyce Chai
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
The integration of language and 3D perception is crucial for developing
embodied agents and robots that comprehend and interact with the physical
world. While large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive language
understanding and generation capabilities, their adaptation to 3D environments
(3D-LLMs) remains in its early stages. A primary challenge is the absence of
large-scale datasets that provide dense grounding between language and 3D
scenes. In this paper, we introduce 3D-GRAND, a pioneering large-scale dataset
comprising 40,087 household scenes paired with 6.2 million densely-grounded
scene-language instructions. Our results show that instruction tuning with
3D-GRAND significantly enhances grounding capabilities and reduces
hallucinations in 3D-LLMs. As part of our contributions, we propose a
comprehensive benchmark 3D-POPE to systematically evaluate hallucination in
3D-LLMs, enabling fair comparisons among future models. Our experiments
highlight a scaling effect between dataset size and 3D-LLM performance,
emphasizing the critical role of large-scale 3D-text datasets in advancing
embodied AI research. Notably, our results demonstrate early signals for
effective sim-to-real transfer, indicating that models trained on large
synthetic data can perform well on real-world 3D scans. Through 3D-GRAND and
3D-POPE, we aim to equip the embodied AI community with essential resources and
insights, setting the stage for more reliable and better-grounded 3D-LLMs.
Project website: https://3d-grand.github.io
|
[
-0.6181594133377075,
-0.8001682758331299,
0.551354169845581,
0.39863672852516174,
0.009269061498343945,
-0.3289572596549988,
-0.07767357677221298,
-0.6304028630256653,
-0.10460835695266724,
0.5783292055130005,
-0.30182352662086487,
-0.532290518283844,
-0.5836707949638367,
0.1666034311056137,
-0.3083820343017578,
0.4560821056365967,
0.2949354946613312,
0.22126993536949158,
-0.3120720386505127,
0.0453961119055748,
-0.21179191768169403,
-0.5594778656959534,
-0.5520679950714111,
-0.14435864984989166,
0.36529654264450073,
0.32873889803886414,
1.0305910110473633,
0.7997310757637024,
0.4565930664539337,
0.2866920232772827,
0.010312285274267197,
0.38958385586738586,
-0.6323550343513489,
-0.2123863846063614,
-0.1374671310186386,
-0.2848978638648987,
-0.6801607608795166,
-0.1526680588722229,
0.6855628490447998,
0.9665948152542114,
0.23768597841262817,
-0.4457595944404602,
0.0570598728954792,
1.080002784729004,
-0.5997140407562256,
0.39935413002967834,
-0.27115458250045776,
0.3143795430660248,
0.30105137825012207,
-0.07095795124769211,
-0.14282071590423584,
-0.2400560975074768,
0.10471285134553909,
-0.9125050902366638,
0.329588919878006,
0.04249763861298561,
0.5605672001838684,
0.4087180197238922,
-0.26665791869163513,
-0.2084861844778061,
-0.742615818977356,
0.5277697443962097,
-0.5215059518814087,
0.6893441081047058,
0.29955393075942993,
0.3333672285079956,
-0.32187917828559875,
-0.3181080222129822,
-0.6468133330345154,
-0.4901140332221985,
0.08968738466501236,
0.09756497293710709,
0.10740827023983002,
0.16203612089157104,
0.36934420466423035,
0.6260072588920593,
-0.5590147972106934,
0.14676210284233093,
-0.29875630140304565,
0.016584530472755432,
0.5794743895530701,
0.10936760157346725,
0.5288692116737366,
-0.013482020236551762,
-0.06548789143562317,
-0.513642430305481,
-0.8093370795249939,
-0.422927588224411,
0.20084668695926666,
0.38870567083358765,
-0.285782128572464,
0.7394036650657654,
-0.25403568148612976,
0.627311110496521,
0.026158560067415237,
-0.11942875385284424,
0.18689945340156555,
-0.11140017956495285,
-0.16316601634025574,
0.10099492967128754,
0.7123783230781555,
0.6197592616081238,
0.6597315669059753,
-0.29349589347839355,
-0.13210967183113098,
-0.11178229004144669,
0.36960864067077637,
-0.7999914288520813,
-0.29448366165161133,
-0.0073424894362688065,
-0.19051532447338104,
0.11153040826320648,
0.25203973054885864,
-0.9111561179161072,
-0.9878252148628235,
-0.7551453709602356,
0.4345143735408783,
-0.34116560220718384,
-0.27188506722450256,
0.48586899042129517,
-0.09512249380350113,
0.513658344745636,
0.6233106255531311,
-1.0315128564834595,
0.45528897643089294,
0.7724056243896484,
0.9747471213340759,
0.08550350368022919,
-0.424238383769989,
-0.43427273631095886,
0.20759336650371552,
-0.8000504970550537,
0.6327713131904602,
-0.3060099184513092,
-0.5188974142074585,
-0.08389406651258469,
0.08971703052520752,
-0.06959681957960129,
-0.9410611987113953,
0.19849270582199097,
-0.13124769926071167,
0.1658954620361328,
-0.24016067385673523,
-0.16584934294223785,
-0.20649336278438568,
0.43619367480278015,
-0.995819628238678,
0.750592827796936,
0.31810081005096436,
-0.426028847694397,
0.25134387612342834,
-0.530730128288269,
-0.4955604672431946,
-0.21210965514183044,
-0.4914015233516693,
-0.06837032735347748,
0.4223266541957855,
0.5801298022270203,
0.6017545461654663,
-0.3737272322177887,
0.052514661103487015,
-0.41931524872779846,
-0.8221845626831055,
-0.3273240029811859,
-0.2550535202026367,
0.5194287896156311,
-0.11852557212114334,
-0.5135911107063293,
-0.04178875684738159,
-0.7335748672485352,
-0.3101905584335327,
0.20767401158809662,
0.08698401600122452,
-0.09751014411449432,
0.003241718979552388,
-0.08664768189191818,
0.1947822868824005,
0.1672801524400711,
-0.10815221071243286,
0.2345178872346878,
-0.7435507774353027,
0.2102620154619217,
0.5486909747123718,
-0.3531562089920044,
0.6607245802879333,
-0.4472634494304657,
0.3031840920448303,
-0.028803879395127296,
-0.056028518825769424,
-0.07164505124092102,
-0.30369073152542114,
-0.8426792621612549,
-0.3531419038772583,
-0.17488986253738403,
0.4780544340610504,
-0.6393167972564697,
0.7361053824424744,
-0.72640460729599,
-0.2613579034805298,
-0.24816769361495972,
0.02168947458267212,
0.0596756674349308,
0.14588938653469086,
0.3572981655597687,
0.13729262351989746,
-0.5348287224769592,
-1.0856457948684692,
0.1282796412706375,
-0.1599583923816681,
-0.709378719329834,
0.607606828212738,
0.4802960753440857,
-0.321367472410202,
0.7124772071838379,
-0.23347541689872742,
-0.646282434463501,
-0.19456006586551666,
-0.1311272233724594,
0.08672482520341873,
0.5761201977729797,
0.5181071758270264,
-0.7716615796089172,
-0.11260658502578735,
0.3092133104801178,
-1.0452392101287842,
0.09468009322881699,
-0.14118900895118713,
-0.1885930746793747,
0.1346309632062912,
0.6064344644546509,
-0.5899026989936829,
0.06457409262657166,
0.700916588306427,
-0.21316395699977875,
0.29074516892433167,
-0.3452434539794922,
0.32382169365882874,
-0.9900007843971252,
-0.017413096502423286,
-0.21647323668003082,
0.1093297228217125,
-0.42152729630470276,
0.0006138929747976363,
-0.10183927416801453,
-0.08896312862634659,
-0.4704842269420624,
0.7570813298225403,
-0.414610356092453,
-0.5070376992225647,
-0.14541268348693848,
0.4467006027698517,
0.12944765388965607,
0.5374990105628967,
0.3265961706638336,
0.9195218682289124,
0.6732472777366638,
-0.7376422882080078,
0.19198687374591827,
0.29614901542663574,
-0.4655631482601166,
0.3992968201637268,
-0.6473245024681091,
0.3288177251815796,
-0.03283167630434036,
0.39202848076820374,
-0.7252393960952759,
-0.49190017580986023,
0.3415452837944031,
-0.21328119933605194,
0.03096381016075611,
0.013599894009530544,
-0.9333854913711548,
-0.1373891979455948,
-0.28549039363861084,
0.29173925518989563,
0.2827952206134796,
-0.8178198337554932,
0.8871439695358276,
0.35193437337875366,
0.04018525779247284,
-0.269925981760025,
-0.5013899207115173,
0.3997247517108917,
-0.14215275645256042,
-0.6900701522827148,
0.2476712316274643,
-0.02593340538442135,
-0.3240191638469696,
-0.1625240445137024,
-0.2085946798324585,
0.06064901128411293,
0.03936520591378212,
0.4005160629749298,
0.2151944786310196,
-0.3213588297367096,
-0.1890634149312973,
-0.09655291587114334,
-0.19574913382530212,
0.3708857595920563,
-0.21008025109767914,
0.5198396444320679,
-0.3661518096923828,
-0.2755114734172821,
-0.3501032292842865,
0.16124989092350006,
1.0689311027526855,
0.45026695728302,
0.7353425621986389,
0.4929473400115967,
-0.6577962636947632,
-0.07073022425174713,
-0.3123522400856018,
-0.14944247901439667,
-0.4446642994880676,
0.4638834595680237,
-0.5440550446510315,
-0.8907053470611572,
0.2008126974105835,
-0.21960225701332092,
0.1032465472817421,
0.35036030411720276,
0.4155547320842743,
0.040864523500204086,
1.2747399806976318,
0.573847234249115,
-0.30633068084716797,
0.217057004570961,
-0.3613235056400299,
0.30254799127578735,
-1.1132718324661255,
-0.33816543221473694,
-0.5491681694984436,
-0.4231400787830353,
-0.41973334550857544,
-0.8480252623558044,
0.34463968873023987,
0.45934274792671204,
-0.5614044666290283,
0.017201876267790794,
-0.4091678559780121,
0.6359882950782776,
0.235855832695961,
0.06441795825958252,
0.1910570114850998,
0.15790097415447235,
0.08663655072450638,
0.08770532160997391,
-0.46002569794654846,
-0.6835734248161316,
0.7556719183921814,
0.2139962762594223,
0.7516001462936401,
0.19275131821632385,
0.16650046408176422,
0.24527394771575928,
0.01350327953696251,
-0.8374442458152771,
0.6655247807502747,
-0.42479583621025085,
-0.31540727615356445,
-0.44975876808166504,
-0.45184534788131714,
-0.6883655190467834,
0.5748944282531738,
-0.2260204255580902,
-0.6104063391685486,
0.09670478850603104,
0.07728315144777298,
-0.3202420473098755,
0.32295382022857666,
-0.5219406485557556,
0.6812784075737,
-0.3349694609642029,
-0.42253974080085754,
-0.07234641909599304,
-0.3939353823661804,
0.44911736249923706,
-0.06435198336839676,
0.15022730827331543,
-0.16979575157165527,
-0.03735598549246788,
0.3757779896259308,
0.028422102332115173,
0.8980419635772705,
-0.24729828536510468,
-0.7323211431503296,
-0.07438791543245316,
0.0876622274518013,
0.5431630611419678,
0.3876084089279175,
0.0007224168512038887,
0.5472034811973572,
-0.36442604660987854,
-0.23071835935115814,
-0.7936501502990723,
0.9292316436767578,
-1.071549892425537,
-0.615291953086853,
-0.09470793604850769,
-0.6987929344177246,
-0.5769402980804443,
0.04277971759438515,
0.18613813817501068,
0.3373197317123413,
-0.3460395336151123,
0.5506457686424255,
0.998662531375885,
-0.5853469371795654,
-0.05069901794195175,
0.1734524667263031,
-0.3764549195766449,
-0.4367516338825226,
0.8523156642913818,
-0.1264113485813141,
0.023153340443968773,
0.702264666557312,
0.1887352615594864,
-0.44258058071136475,
-0.4812721014022827,
-0.7046221494674683,
0.15130431950092316,
-0.488206148147583,
0.09026704728603363,
-1.002496600151062,
-0.4099104702472687,
-0.5136580467224121,
-0.6655619740486145,
-0.5764555931091309,
-0.38874533772468567,
-0.34417352080345154,
-0.05668136849999428,
0.12979397177696228,
0.6786423921585083,
-0.16485702991485596,
0.07177736610174179,
-0.7004544138908386,
0.9458047747612,
0.4846068322658539,
0.36222806572914124,
-0.024169107899069786,
-0.5564060211181641,
-0.11136850714683533,
0.27997198700904846,
0.16760624945163727,
-0.09833429753780365,
0.22290517389774323,
0.17930659651756287,
0.42718085646629333,
0.5382788181304932,
-0.08878900855779648,
1.0363233089447021,
-0.48275741934776306,
0.8482343554496765,
0.021414458751678467,
-0.8068873882293701,
0.4266352951526642,
-0.5348840355873108,
0.45133012533187866,
0.3473132252693176,
0.17561845481395721,
-0.3992416262626648,
-0.30652543902397156,
-0.2564769685268402,
-0.8263711929321289,
0.72125643491745,
0.2015148401260376,
0.32957854866981506,
0.05506259202957153,
0.26589083671569824,
0.17729198932647705,
0.0222860649228096,
-0.47126612067222595,
0.0014757270691916347,
-0.31355026364326477,
0.060106147080659866,
-0.37296000123023987,
-0.08285153657197952,
-0.15663626790046692,
-0.34462425112724304,
0.3419041335582733,
-0.3118073046207428,
0.3299364149570465,
0.08066220581531525,
-0.21978235244750977,
-0.002144030760973692,
-0.10163536667823792,
0.7448520064353943,
0.43208545446395874,
-0.19505856931209564,
0.22436200082302094,
0.19131708145141602,
-0.6028841733932495,
-0.02323969453573227,
-0.11035430431365967,
0.196181520819664,
-0.268432080745697,
0.6255796551704407,
0.7989099025726318,
0.46575382351875305,
-0.860108494758606,
0.32514530420303345,
-0.04759586974978447,
-0.5976287126541138,
-0.40923306345939636,
0.4332314133644104,
-0.019491706043481827,
0.19200341403484344,
0.20299823582172394,
-0.12683424353599548,
0.15915362536907196,
-0.37218597531318665,
0.13268060982227325,
0.16835328936576843,
-0.2820065915584564,
-0.33262336254119873,
0.6334177255630493,
0.15743869543075562,
-0.04168393090367317,
1.042986273765564,
0.17489421367645264,
-0.24965029954910278,
0.8048988580703735,
0.49447640776634216,
0.9647858738899231,
0.14378303289413452,
0.08853218704462051,
0.6504408121109009,
0.41107550263404846,
-0.39949148893356323,
-0.041212935000658035,
-0.07113267481327057,
-0.8748533129692078,
-0.1618548333644867,
-0.6681055426597595,
-0.35545116662979126,
0.6038333773612976,
-0.5464040040969849,
0.11342689394950867,
-0.7053918242454529,
0.46155446767807007,
-0.48195964097976685,
0.1076691597700119,
-0.5666634440422058,
0.19443808495998383,
0.4983808398246765,
0.7097527980804443,
-0.7794414758682251,
0.6292539834976196,
0.6383345127105713,
0.10958752781152725,
-0.33200716972351074,
0.01632344350218773,
0.1675238162279129,
-0.7854112982749939,
0.5463823676109314,
0.5482529997825623,
-0.48417988419532776,
0.1110239028930664,
-0.4779692590236664,
-0.8149672746658325,
0.9919069409370422,
0.4249080717563629,
-0.7561478614807129,
-0.10438796132802963,
0.45140188932418823,
0.5762762427330017,
-0.44957900047302246,
-0.0594862699508667,
0.68898606300354,
0.6594862341880798,
0.33320677280426025,
-0.5467337965965271,
-0.1446998119354248,
-0.34833747148513794,
0.09440573304891586,
0.08000009506940842,
-0.4429329037666321,
0.562376081943512,
-0.2893824875354767,
-0.2255251705646515,
0.20298615097999573,
0.5781843066215515,
0.5973459482192993,
0.07110589742660522,
0.7356584072113037,
0.6631737351417542,
0.4924889802932739,
-0.16600126028060913,
0.8182028532028198,
-0.2680739760398865,
-0.19528397917747498,
1.201730489730835,
-0.48213228583335876,
0.5592607259750366,
0.21487495303153992,
0.07022280246019363,
0.13245929777622223,
0.38177385926246643,
-0.08440462499856949,
0.35040441155433655,
0.3946993350982666,
-0.16621869802474976,
-0.24104084074497223,
-0.0004844210052397102,
-0.566238284111023,
0.40923961997032166,
0.6670651435852051,
-0.02114836499094963,
-0.15576238930225372,
0.29552987217903137,
-0.1655942052602768,
0.05040620267391205,
-0.14298425614833832,
0.8495226502418518,
0.011765864677727222,
-0.23941807448863983,
0.6058939695358276,
-0.5224245190620422,
0.3690304756164551,
-0.4617159366607666,
-0.4282004237174988,
-0.6302034258842468,
0.2103729248046875,
-0.0013443278148770332,
-0.555452287197113,
0.13203498721122742,
-0.059877704828977585,
-0.2528396248817444,
-0.29170921444892883,
0.20559769868850708,
-0.10074511915445328,
-0.4210366904735565,
0.40910160541534424,
0.3948190212249756,
0.41294118762016296,
-0.43843236565589905,
-0.5035491585731506,
0.25806257128715515,
-0.2773182988166809,
-0.2126525640487671,
0.4291832745075226,
0.868644118309021,
-0.10346648842096329,
0.5562182664871216,
0.6206995844841003,
-0.03354351222515106,
-0.10894014686346054,
0.33908313512802124,
0.8505764603614807,
-0.8748977184295654,
-0.2416013777256012,
-0.5164318680763245,
0.2639756500720978,
0.0043852622620761395,
-0.24237994849681854,
0.76535964012146,
0.7456702589988708,
0.9531288146972656,
-0.10539448261260986,
0.6348008513450623,
-0.11113503575325012,
-0.03274831548333168,
-0.7036442756652832,
0.6163197755813599,
-0.7061155438423157,
0.2695198059082031,
-0.2682225704193115,
-1.241378664970398,
-0.6078465580940247,
0.9380691051483154,
-0.06193511560559273,
0.22469714283943176,
0.5589819550514221,
1.0497373342514038,
0.001403096946887672,
0.05895222723484039,
0.8111120462417603,
0.268433153629303,
0.40161746740341187,
0.512100100517273,
1.0784895420074463,
-0.38846486806869507,
0.27938270568847656,
-0.2863313555717468,
-0.19341681897640228,
-0.33120813965797424,
-0.6016721129417419,
-1.0476622581481934,
-0.49687865376472473,
-0.10773293673992157,
-0.07537460327148438,
0.10936454683542252,
0.786932110786438,
0.7672774195671082,
-0.669178307056427,
-0.17592836916446686,
-0.4276382327079773,
-0.17951315641403198,
-0.43253621459007263,
-0.2014116495847702,
0.5026311874389648,
-0.29777631163597107,
-1.1195019483566284,
0.7830301523208618,
0.5016118288040161,
0.2026405930519104,
-0.39139053225517273,
-0.2921907901763916,
0.22711284458637238,
-0.05892704054713249,
0.9297122955322266,
0.1303977221250534,
-0.7305448651313782,
-0.3285408914089203,
0.08317643404006958,
-0.3149798512458801,
0.038729045540094376,
0.8146660923957825,
-0.8010737895965576,
0.4672439694404602,
0.2916734218597412,
0.5970666408538818,
0.0948183685541153,
-0.044437989592552185,
0.7629591226577759,
-0.24812109768390656,
0.23478348553180695,
0.23207524418830872,
0.1829509288072586,
0.3596060872077942,
-0.5000362992286682,
0.8257735967636108,
-0.016659516841173172,
-0.3649655878543854,
-0.5507720112800598,
-0.19008302688598633,
-0.9416669607162476,
-0.40014323592185974,
1.2171134948730469,
0.24057109653949738,
-0.15267565846443176,
-0.1517258882522583,
-0.3845577538013458,
0.0063070994801819324,
-0.13184647262096405,
1.2475097179412842,
0.6555564999580383,
0.06484121084213257,
-0.2228596955537796,
-0.7212944626808167,
0.4240974187850952,
0.2174978405237198,
-0.9872254133224487,
0.4495374858379364,
0.9078908562660217,
-0.37009313702583313,
0.19556497037410736,
0.36532971262931824,
-0.3175370991230011,
0.23417845368385315,
0.2600879669189453,
0.04380769282579422,
-0.07640066742897034,
-0.8973988890647888,
-0.44038131833076477,
0.27745676040649414,
-0.2808328866958618,
-0.007146250456571579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05130v1
|
An Empirical Study on Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for MultiModal Large Language Models
| 2024-06-07T17:58:11 | 2024-06-07T17:58:11 |
Xiongtao Zhou, Jie He, Yuhua Ke, Guangyao Zhu, Víctor Gutiérrez-Basulto, Jeff Z. Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) fine-tuned with multimodal
instruction datasets have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in multimodal
tasks. However, fine-tuning all parameters of MLLMs has become challenging as
they usually contain billions of parameters. To address this issue, we study
parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods for MLLMs. We aim to identify
effective methods for enhancing the performance of MLLMs in scenarios where
only a limited number of parameters are trained. This paper conducts empirical
studies using four popular PEFT methods to fine-tune the LLM component of
open-source MLLMs. We present a comprehensive analysis that encompasses various
aspects, including the impact of PEFT methods on various models, parameters and
location of the PEFT module, size of fine-tuning data, model stability based on
PEFT methods, MLLM's generalization, and hallucination. We evaluated four PEFT
methods on seven datasets from two different categories: unseen and seen
datasets. Across all experiments, we show that the adapter is the
best-performing PEFT method. At the same time, fine-tuning the connector layers
leads to improved performance in most MLLMs. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/alenai97/PEFT-MLLM.git.
|
[
-0.6026102900505066,
-1.0621942281723022,
0.5649771094322205,
0.20618054270744324,
-0.294074147939682,
-0.22220636904239655,
-0.7163774371147156,
-0.11579637229442596,
-0.46789786219596863,
0.44881942868232727,
-0.450346976518631,
-0.4920201599597931,
-0.17236514389514923,
-0.020204730331897736,
-0.17486989498138428,
0.8842570781707764,
0.009720428846776485,
-0.022249877452850342,
0.04769034683704376,
-0.2691884934902191,
-0.17571449279785156,
-0.34021660685539246,
-0.6021795868873596,
0.004218600690364838,
0.8081866502761841,
0.3205491900444031,
0.5801067352294922,
0.6938353180885315,
0.4079207479953766,
0.23536677658557892,
-0.19416391849517822,
0.7139968276023865,
-0.7424123287200928,
0.03963680937886238,
-0.2480320930480957,
-0.16674712300300598,
-0.4637153744697571,
-0.21778269112110138,
0.9335042238235474,
0.7194079160690308,
0.0007470870041288435,
0.336865097284317,
0.2604973316192627,
0.8082942962646484,
-0.7974618077278137,
0.006261378992348909,
-0.7207338213920593,
-0.22888842225074768,
-0.24258530139923096,
-0.31328755617141724,
-0.5867578387260437,
-0.21881581842899323,
-0.04977540299296379,
-0.38535618782043457,
-0.03930187597870827,
0.2984117865562439,
0.6806653738021851,
0.1699644774198532,
-0.44878292083740234,
0.06688105314970016,
-0.8600253462791443,
1.0852359533309937,
-0.8828012943267822,
0.8627191185951233,
0.30205225944519043,
0.1446785032749176,
-0.18840767443180084,
-0.5735974907875061,
-0.2879389524459839,
-0.31793954968452454,
-0.07475775480270386,
-0.3808504641056061,
0.06426636874675751,
0.3822196424007416,
0.3103722631931305,
0.11904187500476837,
-0.5616905093193054,
0.3256737291812897,
-0.20508763194084167,
-0.07576314359903336,
0.4711592197418213,
0.16158361732959747,
-0.0007598813390359282,
0.3118107318878174,
-0.08931627869606018,
-0.07912467420101166,
-0.7656674981117249,
0.14190325140953064,
0.5158284902572632,
0.5442491769790649,
-0.10949640721082687,
0.48199909925460815,
-0.28776249289512634,
1.020512342453003,
0.18450166285037994,
-0.3904837667942047,
0.15992173552513123,
-0.4913892149925232,
-0.2514793872833252,
-0.29919901490211487,
0.5504134297370911,
0.4224186837673187,
0.35647791624069214,
-0.25868532061576843,
-0.3406653106212616,
-0.5527404546737671,
0.034026358276605606,
-0.8643625974655151,
-0.30960699915885925,
0.13332723081111908,
-0.6699337959289551,
0.020952973514795303,
-0.2629851698875427,
-0.6587960124015808,
-0.365761935710907,
-0.6275129914283752,
0.636688768863678,
-0.5301181077957153,
-0.1766364723443985,
0.05002680793404579,
0.09525901079177856,
0.2481173723936081,
0.4948519468307495,
-1.0386370420455933,
0.051680032163858414,
0.5676881670951843,
0.7264736890792847,
-0.10071610659360886,
-0.41736412048339844,
-0.8963959813117981,
0.028072722256183624,
-0.20367445051670074,
0.602540135383606,
-0.7317094206809998,
0.07525202631950378,
-0.15114514529705048,
0.147199347615242,
-0.4302730858325958,
-0.4411529004573822,
0.46359995007514954,
-0.4134749472141266,
-0.2124115526676178,
-0.10653519630432129,
-0.5574586987495422,
-0.18845172226428986,
0.16396915912628174,
-0.5499406456947327,
0.7433493137359619,
-0.08991962671279907,
-0.417427659034729,
0.19827255606651306,
-0.6258247494697571,
-0.33325135707855225,
-0.34807288646698,
0.0652424618601799,
-0.36024561524391174,
0.3496630787849426,
0.3650842308998108,
0.7378841638565063,
-0.08547303825616837,
0.1316426396369934,
-0.45684128999710083,
-0.44391050934791565,
0.10501818358898163,
-0.8831973075866699,
0.4204743206501007,
0.36159953474998474,
-0.24347759783267975,
0.24842391908168793,
-0.853527307510376,
0.1369789093732834,
-0.14479802548885345,
-0.5618312358856201,
-0.2171231359243393,
0.10666367411613464,
0.3412338197231293,
-0.11579185724258423,
0.15875431895256042,
-0.4054079055786133,
0.14183494448661804,
-0.5003330707550049,
0.4229380190372467,
0.855782151222229,
-0.1260552555322647,
0.46319544315338135,
-0.21517109870910645,
0.21112462878227234,
-0.17996780574321747,
0.39537420868873596,
-0.45077764987945557,
-0.27672603726387024,
-0.6816932559013367,
-0.49885299801826477,
0.44525146484375,
0.10217675566673279,
-0.4978565573692322,
0.16217997670173645,
0.161363422870636,
-0.525773286819458,
-0.558682382106781,
0.3847687542438507,
0.36031875014305115,
0.2608376145362854,
0.22630953788757324,
0.33949682116508484,
-0.2800033688545227,
-1.0750292539596558,
-0.4458202123641968,
0.09576628357172012,
0.02817359007894993,
0.48751184344291687,
0.2069099098443985,
-0.0022346845362335443,
0.6860591769218445,
-0.1561642438173294,
0.12370388954877853,
0.10595052689313889,
-0.10502834618091583,
0.2793969213962555,
0.43702051043510437,
0.751878023147583,
-0.6535934805870056,
-0.6083418130874634,
0.2754504978656769,
-0.23373079299926758,
0.010816577821969986,
-0.14269641041755676,
0.034693099558353424,
0.3348652422428131,
0.36343327164649963,
-0.3348146080970764,
-0.064020536839962,
0.7890178561210632,
-0.36525043845176697,
0.4304184019565582,
-0.5711643695831299,
0.2244388610124588,
-0.5041308999061584,
0.1112445592880249,
0.02721112221479416,
-0.26089128851890564,
-0.638522744178772,
0.329613596200943,
0.3841798007488251,
0.06323371827602386,
-0.6541780233383179,
0.49319377541542053,
-0.5318204760551453,
0.4026011526584625,
-0.09338387101888657,
-0.11953231692314148,
-0.09465372562408447,
0.6424468755722046,
-0.32496100664138794,
0.745555579662323,
0.5996570587158203,
-0.5192387104034424,
0.24418208003044128,
-0.29234305024147034,
-0.2391050159931183,
0.27047139406204224,
-0.5336915850639343,
0.32648518681526184,
-0.33478978276252747,
-0.3101603090763092,
-1.042701244354248,
-0.02837279997766018,
0.11743279546499252,
0.15480829775333405,
0.35830286145210266,
-0.22340551018714905,
-0.7654642462730408,
0.2048274576663971,
-0.49461495876312256,
0.2815077602863312,
0.36231645941734314,
-0.6449971199035645,
0.7251074314117432,
0.041984692215919495,
0.055573202669620514,
-0.19411692023277283,
-0.1900448203086853,
-0.1061878576874733,
-0.4217967092990875,
-0.515992283821106,
0.20351152122020721,
-0.39631205797195435,
-0.16003690659999847,
-0.34196361899375916,
-0.017637133598327637,
0.02170959860086441,
0.1635933369398117,
0.11933530122041702,
-0.07759618759155273,
-0.3853570520877838,
0.22474662959575653,
0.42391663789749146,
0.09388089179992676,
-0.3890444040298462,
0.011952088214457035,
0.665544331073761,
-0.4804275929927826,
-0.5086314678192139,
-0.2701956629753113,
0.24754761159420013,
0.7529129385948181,
-0.3682098984718323,
0.9056844115257263,
0.9196940064430237,
-0.09738495945930481,
-0.1924102008342743,
-0.7650061845779419,
-0.11517520993947983,
-0.5284075140953064,
0.4416405260562897,
-0.4180701673030853,
-1.0006787776947021,
0.3041035830974579,
-0.27715373039245605,
0.2495921552181244,
0.17285670340061188,
0.6706823706626892,
-0.10651013255119324,
1.211645483970642,
0.570171058177948,
0.057818666100502014,
0.4483558237552643,
0.11037208884954453,
0.060096804052591324,
-0.6527933478355408,
-0.1840636134147644,
-0.40264007449150085,
-0.5027169585227966,
-0.5411478281021118,
-0.507847011089325,
0.4140782356262207,
0.4135020077228546,
-0.3025290369987488,
0.13709567487239838,
-0.2770952582359314,
0.5759007930755615,
0.4175788462162018,
0.28427228331565857,
0.42104852199554443,
0.2332308441400528,
-0.14170224964618683,
0.02053345926105976,
-0.6666189432144165,
-0.4821118712425232,
1.083853006362915,
0.526804506778717,
0.9678303003311157,
0.08064347505569458,
0.26159679889678955,
-0.02753780409693718,
-0.2133244127035141,
-0.5847851037979126,
0.48541656136512756,
-0.37598371505737305,
-0.43462371826171875,
-0.5210986733436584,
-0.24640017747879028,
-0.7400957345962524,
0.2399343103170395,
-0.2955433428287506,
-0.7469018697738647,
0.226732537150383,
0.4288141429424286,
-0.41742032766342163,
0.28364846110343933,
-0.9317387938499451,
0.7386634945869446,
-0.48713698983192444,
-0.5525027513504028,
-0.3819752335548401,
-0.5008913278579712,
-0.054920438677072525,
-0.34015005826950073,
0.11413277685642242,
-0.27985212206840515,
-0.21664713323116302,
0.4131195545196533,
-0.029250312596559525,
0.7516359686851501,
-0.33305099606513977,
-0.3324996829032898,
-0.12933997809886932,
-0.1049085482954979,
0.7625945806503296,
0.07522637397050858,
-0.24828316271305084,
0.18840646743774414,
0.19695590436458588,
-0.2732740640640259,
-0.6647576689720154,
0.933550238609314,
-0.6979052424430847,
-0.3757292628288269,
0.43017974495887756,
-0.6793596744537354,
-0.4728466868400574,
0.14036375284194946,
-0.06989505887031555,
0.5578556060791016,
0.1489945650100708,
0.7502561211585999,
0.8384710550308228,
-0.4113796353340149,
0.6340003609657288,
0.6901315450668335,
-0.31095197796821594,
-0.26513707637786865,
1.016971468925476,
0.3036322593688965,
0.2902715504169464,
0.5047758221626282,
0.15905426442623138,
-0.05331879481673241,
-0.8787600994110107,
-0.5472015738487244,
0.2826940417289734,
-0.4540085792541504,
-0.010889183729887009,
-0.5792636871337891,
0.007545525208115578,
-0.187629833817482,
-0.016710633412003517,
-0.6172893643379211,
-0.1425708383321762,
-0.3156513273715973,
0.2228865623474121,
0.5382780432701111,
0.22139228880405426,
0.28118178248405457,
0.2993539869785309,
-0.7706418633460999,
0.27964624762535095,
0.29895156621932983,
0.7826659083366394,
0.059286314994096756,
-0.443295955657959,
-0.4023180902004242,
0.11648953706026077,
-0.10028498619794846,
-0.43859943747520447,
-0.00897953100502491,
0.595064103603363,
0.7560166716575623,
0.5937074422836304,
0.089265376329422,
0.9277065992355347,
-0.6670381426811218,
0.6572221517562866,
-0.1259637326002121,
-0.7531430125236511,
0.42935317754745483,
-0.5501534938812256,
0.3103536069393158,
0.4960244297981262,
0.2576804757118225,
-0.007667140103876591,
-0.23186777532100677,
-0.068157859146595,
-0.8077076077461243,
0.6376928687095642,
0.22555841505527496,
0.3996211290359497,
0.2576785683631897,
0.41930317878723145,
0.3703814148902893,
0.08077464997768402,
-0.3881145715713501,
-0.363126665353775,
0.13494542241096497,
-0.191758930683136,
-0.16219890117645264,
-0.35579395294189453,
0.053110286593437195,
-0.59065842628479,
0.5020653009414673,
-0.2623015344142914,
-0.05487550050020218,
-0.19869430363178253,
-0.16376915574073792,
-0.23159271478652954,
0.36774152517318726,
0.8745638132095337,
0.9555968046188354,
-0.33956849575042725,
0.22944465279579163,
0.3839995265007019,
-0.1858101785182953,
-0.043013814836740494,
0.04437791556119919,
0.03322266414761543,
0.02234642580151558,
0.22064486145973206,
0.9921455979347229,
0.22834843397140503,
-1.0092570781707764,
0.2422410547733307,
0.029980512335896492,
-0.15181687474250793,
0.06976994127035141,
0.3413247764110565,
0.0806477889418602,
0.6742448806762695,
0.23615066707134247,
0.06007352098822594,
0.05339249223470688,
-0.34179139137268066,
-0.03562682494521141,
0.5628315806388855,
-0.14655351638793945,
-0.3433190584182739,
0.5368067622184753,
0.1073002889752388,
-0.3440591096878052,
0.373170405626297,
0.2594090402126312,
0.1426546424627304,
0.1379174143075943,
0.5591326951980591,
0.5137888193130493,
-0.04662187024950981,
0.009132022969424725,
0.1047552078962326,
0.4465157091617584,
-0.040663789957761765,
0.04620379954576492,
-0.1642645001411438,
-0.46610957384109497,
-0.7195723652839661,
-0.904819667339325,
-0.2447797656059265,
0.3601435124874115,
-0.2695769667625427,
0.4050062894821167,
-0.3500604033470154,
-0.14206847548484802,
-0.053740404546260834,
-0.24615712463855743,
-0.6303656697273254,
-0.08813098818063736,
0.24822990596294403,
0.8975129127502441,
-0.6342691779136658,
0.882354199886322,
0.8810703754425049,
0.1401435285806656,
-0.8649517893791199,
-0.14190278947353363,
-0.21782971918582916,
-0.7275137305259705,
0.4209536015987396,
-0.14989396929740906,
-0.08041441440582275,
0.2039838284254074,
-0.466592401266098,
-0.8590879440307617,
0.8695562481880188,
0.7851822972297668,
-1.0163419246673584,
-0.15746866166591644,
0.17388348281383514,
0.4871430993080139,
-0.1329559087753296,
0.21137425303459167,
0.647436261177063,
0.6330089569091797,
-0.2468264251947403,
-1.2370208501815796,
-0.06451700627803802,
-0.13551031053066254,
0.21129782497882843,
0.35761791467666626,
-0.7148764133453369,
0.7969647645950317,
0.0034949921537190676,
0.2017904818058014,
0.13636229932308197,
0.2896769344806671,
0.3309222459793091,
0.23413263261318207,
0.6428985595703125,
0.22145843505859375,
0.5672206282615662,
0.19999319314956665,
0.6749746799468994,
-0.4417853355407715,
0.5390154719352722,
0.8274815082550049,
-0.00004118283686693758,
0.8715839385986328,
0.7335081100463867,
-0.1881856471300125,
0.048937276005744934,
0.37080690264701843,
-0.15778890252113342,
0.5474674105644226,
-0.05171451345086098,
-0.031286273151636124,
-0.4570632874965668,
0.07345636188983917,
-0.2976773977279663,
0.44389817118644714,
0.252835750579834,
-0.7228556275367737,
-0.39493951201438904,
0.5208036303520203,
-0.08404194563627243,
-0.12194453924894333,
-0.3837406039237976,
0.705297589302063,
-0.05828872695565224,
-0.3499109148979187,
0.8339257836341858,
0.11143067479133606,
0.6149810552597046,
-0.4521310329437256,
-0.09817630052566528,
-0.20230628550052643,
0.3703022301197052,
-0.1534889191389084,
-0.48607367277145386,
0.05509191006422043,
0.029514271765947342,
-0.1894548237323761,
-0.27930647134780884,
0.7548877000808716,
-0.43683284521102905,
-0.3976699709892273,
0.1548311561346054,
0.4702020287513733,
0.06596190482378006,
-0.39766666293144226,
-0.49910202622413635,
0.35297486186027527,
0.03820226714015007,
-0.5175532698631287,
0.5937918424606323,
0.41816145181655884,
0.1812296360731125,
0.5926435589790344,
0.6151670813560486,
0.09084179252386093,
0.08684765547513962,
0.09943174570798874,
0.9190443754196167,
-0.44712504744529724,
-0.01887446641921997,
-1.2056236267089844,
0.6936654448509216,
0.20432208478450775,
-0.3298018276691437,
0.9967445731163025,
0.5322756171226501,
0.8231983184814453,
-0.24971835315227509,
0.28239259123802185,
0.16336676478385925,
0.4191124141216278,
-0.7391951680183411,
0.7399137616157532,
-0.7958970069885254,
0.3573104739189148,
-0.34642574191093445,
-1.129331350326538,
-0.3187403082847595,
0.30260252952575684,
-0.17777694761753082,
0.037275947630405426,
0.3388771116733551,
0.9795447587966919,
-0.29521986842155457,
-0.10001152008771896,
0.6881341934204102,
0.21733765304088593,
0.18189497292041779,
0.20016030967235565,
0.767994225025177,
-0.22822916507720947,
0.5417184829711914,
-0.42597007751464844,
-0.09395499527454376,
-0.29283592104911804,
-0.7999090552330017,
-1.0720182657241821,
-0.5186339020729065,
-0.2536090612411499,
0.06553230434656143,
0.2839270532131195,
1.0674680471420288,
0.9551990032196045,
-0.7959351539611816,
-0.1109975054860115,
0.1550367921590805,
-0.1458340287208557,
-0.19948934018611908,
-0.19723789393901825,
0.3894254267215729,
-0.3822667598724365,
-0.8172034621238708,
0.4023325741291046,
0.4490390121936798,
-0.25881099700927734,
-0.17799188196659088,
-0.17175166308879852,
-0.06549321860074997,
-0.011249357834458351,
1.084160566329956,
-0.135078564286232,
-0.8791148662567139,
-0.373634397983551,
0.1978127509355545,
0.27019789814949036,
-0.06656239926815033,
0.6284798979759216,
-0.5609786510467529,
0.5096879005432129,
0.3953319787979126,
0.5693539977073669,
0.3467319905757904,
-0.05999547243118286,
0.45561885833740234,
-0.7762000560760498,
-0.06546079367399216,
0.010965925641357899,
0.287179172039032,
0.0010910304263234138,
-0.1671115607023239,
0.24899572134017944,
-0.12457529455423355,
-0.6774078607559204,
-0.9616464972496033,
-0.08282560855150223,
-0.9514963626861572,
-0.4676477015018463,
1.1811950206756592,
0.01677783951163292,
0.05132017284631729,
-0.04213150590658188,
-0.5408479571342468,
0.009529541246592999,
-0.36242666840553284,
0.5006937980651855,
0.4133126437664032,
-0.34311729669570923,
-0.698369026184082,
-0.49736475944519043,
0.26659029722213745,
0.3140678107738495,
-0.5068467259407043,
0.1964634656906128,
0.42853739857673645,
0.28753116726875305,
-0.1625472456216812,
0.08481941372156143,
0.10627889633178711,
0.03580185025930405,
-0.29569023847579956,
-0.4228915870189667,
-0.47611063718795776,
-0.3981674909591675,
-0.371359646320343,
0.43624764680862427,
0.3344144821166992,
0.021544646471738815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05085v1
|
Multi-Head RAG: Solving Multi-Aspect Problems with LLMs
| 2024-06-07T16:59:38 | 2024-06-07T16:59:38 |
Maciej Besta, Ales Kubicek, Roman Niggli, Robert Gerstenberger, Lucas Weitzendorf, Mingyuan Chi, Patrick Iff, Joanna Gajda, Piotr Nyczyk, Jürgen Müller, Hubert Niewiadomski, Marcin Chrapek, Michał Podstawski, Torsten Hoefler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) enhances the abilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs) by enabling the retrieval of documents into the LLM context to
provide more accurate and relevant responses. Existing RAG solutions do not
focus on queries that may require fetching multiple documents with
substantially different contents. Such queries occur frequently, but are
challenging because the embeddings of these documents may be distant in the
embedding space, making it hard to retrieve them all. This paper introduces
Multi-Head RAG (MRAG), a novel scheme designed to address this gap with a
simple yet powerful idea: leveraging activations of Transformer's multi-head
attention layer, instead of the decoder layer, as keys for fetching
multi-aspect documents. The driving motivation is that different attention
heads can learn to capture different data aspects. Harnessing the corresponding
activations results in embeddings that represent various facets of data items
and queries, improving the retrieval accuracy for complex queries. We provide
an evaluation methodology and metrics, synthetic datasets, and real-world use
cases to demonstrate MRAG's effectiveness, showing improvements of up to 20% in
relevance over standard RAG baselines. MRAG can be seamlessly integrated with
existing RAG frameworks and benchmarking tools like RAGAS as well as different
classes of data stores.
|
[
-0.5903638601303101,
-0.7187385559082031,
0.5266189575195312,
0.19923780858516693,
-0.24133485555648804,
0.5249035954475403,
-0.1383696347475052,
-0.3846994638442993,
0.4975445866584778,
0.533685028553009,
-0.5080605745315552,
-0.24991905689239502,
-0.7687483429908752,
-0.0034250030294060707,
-0.30856335163116455,
0.8778135180473328,
0.11845241487026215,
-0.16959704458713531,
-0.42305412888526917,
-0.5507240891456604,
-0.40064772963523865,
-0.5138726234436035,
-0.6031340956687927,
-0.49552208185195923,
0.8749028444290161,
0.4343191385269165,
0.45290079712867737,
0.5808455944061279,
0.8670710325241089,
0.26577162742614746,
-0.21504627168178558,
0.719980776309967,
-0.31013140082359314,
0.6703305840492249,
-0.3355683386325836,
-0.5761433243751526,
-0.6010634899139404,
-0.12243920564651489,
0.7203215956687927,
0.4716629981994629,
-0.14717364311218262,
0.2710430920124054,
0.2201826423406601,
1.1698939800262451,
-0.8657549619674683,
-0.08583765476942062,
-0.6848809719085693,
-0.040340032428503036,
-0.429658979177475,
-0.4970426857471466,
-0.331888884305954,
0.24816475808620453,
-0.057087160646915436,
-0.320722371339798,
0.42054620385169983,
0.19081073999404907,
0.7832504510879517,
0.27893683314323425,
-0.24884235858917236,
-0.2822829484939575,
-0.6679317951202393,
0.9631333947181702,
-0.34356367588043213,
0.64823979139328,
0.2333688735961914,
0.3681599199771881,
-0.19577154517173767,
-0.6679933667182922,
-0.6084646582603455,
0.15320655703544617,
-0.21886451542377472,
0.10085071623325348,
0.1311187893152237,
-0.3145931363105774,
0.04814467579126358,
0.5297197103500366,
-0.38349851965904236,
-0.26015931367874146,
0.016066940501332283,
0.06023383140563965,
0.43068256974220276,
0.14805595576763153,
-0.17855384945869446,
-0.35732921957969666,
-0.26227715611457825,
-0.4152037501335144,
-0.7228596210479736,
-0.08751379698514938,
0.3390262722969055,
0.5863555669784546,
0.04179386422038078,
0.5260604619979858,
-0.23395541310310364,
0.7483155727386475,
0.40198633074760437,
-0.6210542321205139,
0.3871619403362274,
-0.14833086729049683,
-0.04545929282903671,
-0.45068395137786865,
0.5608317852020264,
-0.028620745986700058,
-0.3824719190597534,
-0.15614649653434753,
-0.36839357018470764,
-0.4427917003631592,
0.6391348838806152,
-0.45517146587371826,
0.2427133172750473,
0.5083009600639343,
-0.38734450936317444,
-0.29750293493270874,
0.011541384272277355,
-1.0876657962799072,
-0.627981960773468,
-0.48707863688468933,
0.40216612815856934,
-0.3091801106929779,
-0.4412875473499298,
-0.33388450741767883,
-0.11914720386266708,
0.6138175129890442,
0.0792408362030983,
-0.5727105736732483,
-0.21689435839653015,
0.9855343699455261,
0.7425697445869446,
-0.3186021149158478,
-0.33210811018943787,
-0.5550886392593384,
0.3039773404598236,
-0.2875625491142273,
1.2041916847229004,
-0.7497951984405518,
-0.36078211665153503,
-0.10402404516935349,
-0.0901399627327919,
0.04027198627591133,
-0.7277825474739075,
0.6216475963592529,
-0.6129299402236938,
0.07263755798339844,
-0.2581389546394348,
-0.1585041582584381,
-0.21082450449466705,
0.561671793460846,
-0.7302865386009216,
1.0018808841705322,
0.14503298699855804,
-0.79341059923172,
0.21739014983177185,
-0.4067760705947876,
-0.49333223700523376,
-0.12608298659324646,
-0.5009599924087524,
-0.9135831594467163,
0.34035471081733704,
0.3843567967414856,
0.42236247658729553,
-0.4369834065437317,
0.13081395626068115,
-0.06956528127193451,
0.13015304505825043,
-0.04598279669880867,
-0.22637681663036346,
0.37087467312812805,
0.18710187077522278,
-0.058900386095047,
0.1797427386045456,
-0.556503415107727,
0.006860775873064995,
0.37723296880722046,
-0.42697805166244507,
-0.43464693427085876,
-0.029269183054566383,
-0.04488656297326088,
0.07452641427516937,
0.19117751717567444,
-0.261202335357666,
0.19906242191791534,
-0.2122988998889923,
0.025271805003285408,
0.3878175914287567,
0.036556631326675415,
0.3990134596824646,
-0.6286017894744873,
0.6396105289459229,
0.32551297545433044,
-0.10649500787258148,
-0.5522658228874207,
-0.37511181831359863,
-0.778470516204834,
-0.3711230754852295,
0.2606341242790222,
0.3520827293395996,
-0.9604750275611877,
0.3081973195075989,
-0.2356261909008026,
-0.4721549153327942,
-0.7196291089057922,
0.08188214898109436,
0.6972905397415161,
0.4128261208534241,
0.3121190369129181,
-0.3103446066379547,
-0.43107175827026367,
-0.9432092308998108,
-0.4096546173095703,
0.16455107927322388,
-0.012907354161143303,
0.6941901445388794,
0.13844820857048035,
-0.12284184247255325,
0.9827063083648682,
-0.5038960576057434,
-0.7030823230743408,
-0.3937358856201172,
0.3087649643421173,
0.24290789663791656,
0.4434921145439148,
0.3714101016521454,
-1.1470448970794678,
-0.46472758054733276,
0.10091604292392731,
-0.6709533929824829,
0.046356432139873505,
-0.06658127903938293,
-0.33134549856185913,
0.1970617026090622,
0.22331567108631134,
-0.48878541588783264,
0.1554764211177826,
0.634763777256012,
-0.05380257964134216,
0.5555301904678345,
-0.14030225574970245,
0.335855633020401,
-1.1995337009429932,
0.16969989240169525,
-0.05681157484650612,
-0.47898679971694946,
-0.5509080290794373,
0.6168304681777954,
0.377408891916275,
-0.1750287115573883,
-0.461944580078125,
0.4354988932609558,
-0.7056113481521606,
-0.14204569160938263,
-0.5588486790657043,
0.10513447970151901,
0.36571893095970154,
0.6172379851341248,
-0.20327624678611755,
1.0500210523605347,
0.5052620768547058,
-0.6666283011436462,
0.17459270358085632,
0.18914008140563965,
0.23396912217140198,
1.075774908065796,
-0.34046560525894165,
0.5897395610809326,
-0.5807308554649353,
0.26573076844215393,
-0.7097880840301514,
-0.27335628867149353,
0.09971849620342255,
-0.4019327163696289,
0.8982540965080261,
-0.13973510265350342,
-0.34599170088768005,
-0.3769000470638275,
-0.5953389406204224,
0.401585191488266,
0.005878238007426262,
-0.574619710445404,
1.2930307388305664,
0.9590393900871277,
-0.07733765989542007,
-1.0139801502227783,
-0.4053076207637787,
0.1421501189470291,
-0.35623085498809814,
-0.4778219759464264,
0.659457802772522,
0.11880295723676682,
0.016540464013814926,
-0.005497169680893421,
-0.4407312273979187,
-0.11532661318778992,
-0.2921573519706726,
-0.13097864389419556,
0.02341838926076889,
-0.07226253300905228,
-0.10473018884658813,
0.24866072833538055,
-0.21043343842029572,
-0.32390353083610535,
-0.11554238200187683,
0.7102057933807373,
0.025088850408792496,
-0.46569550037384033,
0.13319626450538635,
0.6914277672767639,
0.5369732975959778,
-0.6462289690971375,
0.5870551466941833,
0.6475069522857666,
-0.27265533804893494,
-0.21010750532150269,
-0.8030723929405212,
-0.0342697948217392,
-0.4787907004356384,
0.2888379991054535,
-0.8568660616874695,
-0.6914809346199036,
0.554201066493988,
-0.1615605652332306,
0.29110580682754517,
0.33423662185668945,
0.67050701379776,
-0.003760532708838582,
0.7395360469818115,
0.7517772316932678,
-0.07930566370487213,
0.46081864833831787,
-0.3602743446826935,
0.16234421730041504,
-1.5572798252105713,
-0.37792783975601196,
-0.6564202308654785,
-0.32129573822021484,
-0.46705517172813416,
-0.7729914784431458,
0.6402657628059387,
0.27373379468917847,
0.2552395761013031,
0.46906375885009766,
-0.8027760982513428,
0.5378115773200989,
0.5400422215461731,
0.23851992189884186,
0.4315743148326874,
-0.053655557334423065,
-0.04920865595340729,
0.09641475230455399,
-0.4842578172683716,
-0.3223942220211029,
1.1602308750152588,
0.22922970354557037,
0.8219689726829529,
0.1786877065896988,
0.7624523043632507,
0.05378808453679085,
0.2615947723388672,
-0.9330929517745972,
0.3215525150299072,
-0.2575821578502655,
-0.58366858959198,
-0.13221223652362823,
-0.30119138956069946,
-1.035547137260437,
0.8324261903762817,
-0.1489369124174118,
-0.3277328610420227,
0.3375033438205719,
0.06648793071508408,
-0.2506766617298126,
0.2269267439842224,
-0.46039244532585144,
0.36818927526474,
-0.04248747229576111,
-0.4363282322883606,
-0.22146472334861755,
-0.5640485286712646,
0.23208804428577423,
-0.3159787058830261,
0.2604670524597168,
-0.1507573425769806,
-0.17032518982887268,
0.7038007378578186,
0.18046775460243225,
0.37010055780410767,
-0.08024588972330093,
-0.11203768849372864,
0.32696184515953064,
-0.08956723660230637,
0.6466971635818481,
0.10727346688508987,
0.08121949434280396,
0.13908599317073822,
-0.30284583568573,
-0.13423359394073486,
-0.5140175819396973,
0.7248421311378479,
-0.39152106642723083,
-0.7667199969291687,
-0.41643986105918884,
-0.8816027045249939,
-0.39266103506088257,
0.33652400970458984,
-0.15627023577690125,
0.4087337851524353,
0.25214025378227234,
0.2776087820529938,
0.7320464253425598,
-0.23738716542720795,
0.3139002323150635,
0.6648443341255188,
-0.3604098856449127,
-0.48058485984802246,
1.0228898525238037,
0.04419846832752228,
0.006436232011765242,
0.5720768570899963,
0.21196818351745605,
-0.12759236991405487,
-0.3978748619556427,
-0.41979822516441345,
0.487510621547699,
-0.5971947908401489,
-0.6688856482505798,
-0.9736311435699463,
-0.16585759818553925,
-0.5664626955986023,
0.23816291987895966,
-0.5327161550521851,
-0.15090958774089813,
0.037130896002054214,
0.3667825758457184,
0.21960115432739258,
0.6799447536468506,
-0.08534977585077286,
0.22560948133468628,
-0.7590070962905884,
0.6912795901298523,
0.2825811207294464,
0.44402533769607544,
0.01645469479262829,
-0.44770538806915283,
-0.28177720308303833,
-0.38949668407440186,
-0.8078957200050354,
-0.7596258521080017,
0.3726671040058136,
0.1407029628753662,
0.7311775088310242,
0.08865711838006973,
-0.06851226091384888,
0.8165549635887146,
-0.8285060524940491,
0.3926060199737549,
-0.1949659138917923,
-0.5984693765640259,
0.32613980770111084,
-0.3099156618118286,
0.1900418996810913,
0.5307232737541199,
0.2869519293308258,
-0.4721568524837494,
-0.7449778318405151,
-0.5238617658615112,
-1.1752479076385498,
0.7247559428215027,
0.02532792277634144,
0.025194847956299782,
0.21014606952667236,
0.3716309070587158,
0.14715434610843658,
0.3890533149242401,
-0.25466275215148926,
-0.6141459345817566,
0.10621941089630127,
-0.06891337037086487,
0.26605433225631714,
-0.3195086717605591,
-0.15490403771400452,
-0.06616194546222687,
0.5827773213386536,
-0.2802942097187042,
0.6328641772270203,
0.24205470085144043,
0.027995046228170395,
-0.10345815867185593,
0.2989189624786377,
0.5606115460395813,
0.8322106599807739,
-0.07795718312263489,
0.16587358713150024,
-0.0459827296435833,
-0.5989450812339783,
-0.006594298407435417,
0.07486054301261902,
0.08767811208963394,
0.1488521844148636,
0.28888586163520813,
0.5379310846328735,
-0.04002537578344345,
-0.30961093306541443,
0.309453547000885,
0.06118164584040642,
0.12124054878950119,
-0.26390960812568665,
-0.23314082622528076,
0.14748525619506836,
0.35092079639434814,
0.8013278245925903,
-0.0471343956887722,
0.20815055072307587,
-0.2907138168811798,
0.5803322196006775,
0.6970177888870239,
-0.054480426013469696,
-0.059971973299980164,
0.5530189871788025,
0.06165420264005661,
-0.4759168326854706,
0.003934620413929224,
-0.2288442999124527,
-0.5164047479629517,
0.3671780526638031,
0.479797899723053,
0.9447304606437683,
-0.2765519618988037,
-0.043133050203323364,
0.060743607580661774,
0.27663928270339966,
0.07528602331876755,
0.2718988358974457,
0.10535421967506409,
-0.5858972668647766,
-0.6624457836151123,
-0.8678083419799805,
-0.7449771165847778,
0.20511768758296967,
-0.7157379984855652,
0.21191424131393433,
-0.07431931048631668,
-0.10448605567216873,
0.06627027690410614,
-0.17968596518039703,
-0.7116360664367676,
-0.058939505368471146,
0.09140737354755402,
0.573115348815918,
-0.414484441280365,
0.7990571856498718,
0.7819966673851013,
-0.3605506718158722,
-0.649046778678894,
0.4148077964782715,
-0.011390086263418198,
-0.8703305721282959,
0.33507347106933594,
0.13679610192775726,
-0.2379566878080368,
0.0032654169481247663,
-0.0948105975985527,
-1.0313678979873657,
1.0585901737213135,
0.23266062140464783,
-0.5260939002037048,
-0.12344834953546524,
0.09336577355861664,
0.2006978988647461,
-0.4489150941371918,
0.2859225273132324,
0.7120861411094666,
0.4180460274219513,
0.14870481193065643,
-0.8786299228668213,
-0.2153722643852234,
0.2354651391506195,
0.11907598376274109,
0.46256154775619507,
-0.7025187611579895,
1.0509116649627686,
-0.007799597457051277,
-0.22164522111415863,
-0.3306221663951874,
0.8057087659835815,
0.563479483127594,
0.2820815443992615,
0.5476105809211731,
0.8089239597320557,
0.5792962908744812,
-0.056245092302560806,
1.1407206058502197,
-0.5056993365287781,
0.6120370626449585,
1.06487238407135,
-0.1430978775024414,
0.9274280667304993,
0.6069217920303345,
-0.2991713285446167,
0.40854254364967346,
0.020976534113287926,
0.5662879347801208,
0.6691320538520813,
-0.14124451577663422,
-0.41368818283081055,
0.024685220792889595,
-0.15614040195941925,
-0.2140510082244873,
0.43000805377960205,
0.5288655757904053,
-0.17124143242835999,
-0.500387966632843,
0.33709585666656494,
0.038670994341373444,
0.06420651823282242,
-0.3018259108066559,
0.9744038581848145,
0.18506267666816711,
-0.6096211075782776,
0.38722553849220276,
0.23399971425533295,
0.9321327805519104,
-0.40333572030067444,
-0.10004063695669174,
-0.41348761320114136,
0.23124666512012482,
-0.2076931744813919,
-0.8624653816223145,
0.6890093088150024,
-0.10212630033493042,
-0.3287108242511749,
-0.17597928643226624,
0.8950729966163635,
-0.5690832138061523,
-0.5334429144859314,
0.0739382803440094,
0.7889122366905212,
0.028765322640538216,
-0.35497185587882996,
-0.8724380731582642,
0.139428973197937,
-0.2014598399400711,
-0.5326007604598999,
0.4183088541030884,
0.5838958024978638,
0.1152472272515297,
0.5072737336158752,
0.5184274315834045,
0.12162826955318451,
-0.008493451401591301,
0.0686228945851326,
1.0849940776824951,
-0.710261881351471,
-0.3767486810684204,
-0.6329066157341003,
0.44327250123023987,
0.027067605406045914,
0.0748974159359932,
0.6110324859619141,
0.49503573775291443,
0.6627194285392761,
0.061637893319129944,
0.6106530427932739,
-0.3468201458454132,
1.116560697555542,
-0.3242952525615692,
0.7393015623092651,
-0.7540156245231628,
0.1084708422422409,
-0.1378493309020996,
-1.0717231035232544,
-0.348464697599411,
0.4810178577899933,
0.18677586317062378,
-0.02203468792140484,
0.9276409149169922,
0.858735203742981,
-0.19303609430789948,
-0.4886590242385864,
0.26200130581855774,
-0.25172173976898193,
0.6781154870986938,
0.2825964093208313,
0.3671533465385437,
-0.4362132251262665,
0.564616322517395,
-0.3293270468711853,
-0.2524978518486023,
-0.005711276549845934,
-0.8036671280860901,
-0.6682697534561157,
-0.6386808753013611,
-0.08110112696886063,
-0.2919135093688965,
-0.007681151852011681,
0.7101397514343262,
0.649088442325592,
-0.7320221662521362,
-0.07713297009468079,
0.26117897033691406,
0.18539422750473022,
-0.31951892375946045,
-0.279065877199173,
0.4389539659023285,
-0.8419147729873657,
-0.9893767237663269,
0.5285590887069702,
0.3702276945114136,
-0.33419352769851685,
-0.6092463135719299,
0.25261908769607544,
-0.3529849946498871,
0.01152044627815485,
0.8005772829055786,
0.12410598993301392,
-0.674525797367096,
-0.29959386587142944,
-0.176700159907341,
-0.16930341720581055,
0.37361228466033936,
0.9962367415428162,
-0.9543312788009644,
0.3350341022014618,
0.5673213601112366,
1.0894458293914795,
0.43641898036003113,
0.1971992701292038,
0.25286510586738586,
-1.2499213218688965,
0.2841583490371704,
0.23699232935905457,
0.20182591676712036,
0.4381970763206482,
-0.40558263659477234,
0.507510781288147,
0.08351080864667892,
-0.6576946973800659,
-0.7610229253768921,
0.24388562142848969,
-0.9398725628852844,
-0.1455601453781128,
1.095402479171753,
-0.0086861252784729,
-0.3191260099411011,
-0.08476831018924713,
-0.08982792496681213,
0.17603228986263275,
-0.47079816460609436,
0.6875057220458984,
0.4796406328678131,
-0.2999548614025116,
-0.20842459797859192,
-0.6374695301055908,
0.2552717328071594,
0.4233512282371521,
-0.8300602436065674,
0.14942556619644165,
0.19863379001617432,
0.00046744689461775124,
0.7416020631790161,
0.47719326615333557,
-0.3894883394241333,
-0.04470761865377426,
-0.19913069903850555,
-0.007144556380808353,
-0.17386476695537567,
-0.6771733164787292,
-0.34312915802001953,
0.46162229776382446,
0.05142250284552574,
-0.31362172961235046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05084v1
|
On Ambiguity and the Expressive Function of Law: The Role of Pragmatics in Smart Legal Ecosystems
| 2024-06-07T16:58:15 | 2024-06-07T16:58:15 |
Pompeu Casanovas
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, C.5; H.1; H.4; I.2; J.4; K.4
|
This is a long paper, an essay, on ambiguity, pragmatics, legal ecosystems,
and the expressive function of law. It is divided into two parts and fifteen
sections. The first part (Pragmatics) addresses ambiguity from the perspective
of linguistic and cognitive pragmatics in the legal field. The second part
(Computing) deals with this issue from the point of view of human-centered
design and artificial intelligence, specifically focusing on the notion and
modelling of rules and what it means to comply with the rules. This is
necessary for the scaffolding of smart legal ecosystems (SLE). I will develop
this subject with the example of the architecture, information flows, and smart
ecosystem of OPTIMAI, an EU project of Industry 4.0 for zero-defect
manufacturing (Optimizing Manufacturing Processes through Artificial
Intelligence and Virtualization).
|
[
-0.41865426301956177,
-0.7965418696403503,
0.8198648691177368,
0.40599730610847473,
-0.5252735614776611,
-0.06435387581586838,
-0.1080780029296875,
-0.8768653869628906,
0.2821151614189148,
0.4426738917827606,
-0.5622127652168274,
-0.0923498123884201,
-0.3073278069496155,
-0.07123955339193344,
-0.41279980540275574,
0.7853579521179199,
-0.12629732489585876,
-0.04696245864033699,
-0.42154890298843384,
-0.09783150255680084,
-0.4234759211540222,
-0.42346084117889404,
-0.19545014202594757,
0.022906038910150528,
0.4382864534854889,
0.09681598842144012,
0.7250578999519348,
0.6522888541221619,
0.55368971824646,
0.43192172050476074,
-0.14205585420131683,
-0.29564741253852844,
-0.018242904916405678,
0.20647965371608734,
-0.32469698786735535,
-0.6577838659286499,
-0.41032588481903076,
-0.2528376877307892,
0.41265806555747986,
0.458965927362442,
-0.4183010458946228,
0.15001581609249115,
-0.09320523589849472,
0.5475921630859375,
-0.5724279284477234,
0.33762648701667786,
-0.19065093994140625,
0.11617424339056015,
-0.22957105934619904,
-0.06378163397312164,
-0.1691904217004776,
-0.2308674156665802,
-0.027354132384061813,
-0.8922269940376282,
-0.2501676678657532,
0.00013763528841082007,
0.9878156781196594,
0.48814404010772705,
-0.3883201777935028,
-0.2670905590057373,
-0.763924241065979,
0.882071852684021,
-0.7631586790084839,
0.05629216134548187,
0.033948566764593124,
0.23784583806991577,
-0.16203345358371735,
-1.0815224647521973,
-0.709577202796936,
0.06874969601631165,
-0.1729782670736313,
0.3195466697216034,
-0.15355409681797028,
0.5080075860023499,
0.2207241803407669,
-0.04064839705824852,
-0.26131799817085266,
0.21632792055606842,
-0.5879948139190674,
-0.641867995262146,
0.8677886128425598,
0.0017787121469154954,
0.1333659142255783,
0.25762179493904114,
-0.07669892907142639,
0.37105971574783325,
-0.41385072469711304,
0.06916165351867676,
0.8835482001304626,
0.06707935780286789,
0.16577225923538208,
0.29741162061691284,
-0.11869490891695023,
1.0184943675994873,
-0.27682971954345703,
-0.03894907608628273,
0.3749372363090515,
-0.4832521677017212,
-0.04886297509074211,
0.02081131562590599,
0.3942576050758362,
0.17758937180042267,
0.0949881374835968,
0.15956294536590576,
-0.35547879338264465,
-0.008194709196686745,
0.44676896929740906,
-0.43264153599739075,
0.4285562336444855,
0.4798886179924011,
-0.6439427137374878,
-0.22020664811134338,
0.28847840428352356,
-0.5602052807807922,
-0.3401808738708496,
-0.9150657057762146,
0.1799893081188202,
0.0989774614572525,
-0.16573987901210785,
0.36843791604042053,
-0.24395766854286194,
0.48646554350852966,
0.3012086749076843,
-0.26635581254959106,
0.29705020785331726,
1.101808786392212,
0.20397303998470306,
0.4609282314777374,
-0.33445844054222107,
-0.2614770233631134,
0.24230000376701355,
-0.205167755484581,
0.5079296231269836,
-0.5201098322868347,
-0.19671115279197693,
0.19439566135406494,
-0.05815952643752098,
-0.05340063199400902,
-0.4887235760688782,
1.104049801826477,
-0.36329832673072815,
0.07805315405130386,
-0.10608165711164474,
-0.545883059501648,
-0.429647296667099,
-0.03838740289211273,
-0.6208802461624146,
0.27162566781044006,
-0.11783299595117569,
-0.48128071427345276,
0.40643081068992615,
-1.1376553773880005,
-0.86203932762146,
0.7468206882476807,
-0.535582423210144,
-0.49781879782676697,
0.273698627948761,
-0.5564653277397156,
-0.1119501069188118,
-0.05983133241534233,
0.6488997936248779,
-0.22673439979553223,
-0.3583449125289917,
0.12773001194000244,
0.11945485323667526,
0.8186408281326294,
0.46403568983078003,
-0.518974781036377,
0.29643383622169495,
-0.42287150025367737,
0.2777836322784424,
-0.06474339216947556,
-0.24404209852218628,
-0.07490873336791992,
0.36196261644363403,
0.17066974937915802,
0.4251568019390106,
0.7156609892845154,
-0.5271753072738647,
-0.06020195037126541,
-0.28993433713912964,
0.8381961584091187,
0.7395943403244019,
0.04645838588476181,
0.27034661173820496,
-0.5563245415687561,
0.7038227915763855,
0.20955023169517517,
0.44221362471580505,
-0.1455257683992386,
-0.5441858768463135,
-0.5794105529785156,
-0.34151825308799744,
0.5225252509117126,
0.7926348447799683,
-0.3229067623615265,
0.5433090329170227,
-0.02297404408454895,
-0.21279673278331757,
-0.8158129453659058,
-0.07570285350084305,
0.11380236595869064,
0.08775041252374649,
0.019689178094267845,
-0.23477016389369965,
-0.842409610748291,
-1.1624822616577148,
-0.4363361597061157,
-0.312186062335968,
0.32722339034080505,
0.3407694101333618,
0.6411302089691162,
-0.1454903483390808,
1.2160333395004272,
-0.12301411479711533,
-0.1850547194480896,
-0.05672125518321991,
0.43847087025642395,
0.2659936845302582,
0.3291778564453125,
0.649177074432373,
-1.2751734256744385,
-0.11867361515760422,
0.27716901898384094,
-0.7598937153816223,
-0.1846991926431656,
-0.23851485550403595,
-0.002512139966711402,
-0.06429073214530945,
0.2652529180049896,
-0.9902426600456238,
0.5628795623779297,
-0.3165293335914612,
-0.49621668457984924,
0.5790743231773376,
-0.34282657504081726,
0.06279619038105011,
-0.5056992769241333,
0.028703032061457634,
-0.04901773855090141,
-0.11590021103620529,
-0.9298322796821594,
0.46673911809921265,
-0.1488097757101059,
0.05676638334989548,
-0.7386257648468018,
0.28031614422798157,
-0.38772884011268616,
0.02326991967856884,
-0.22935032844543457,
0.14985960721969604,
-0.0032192429061979055,
0.24283552169799805,
-0.262782484292984,
0.540088415145874,
0.7857358455657959,
-0.6568946838378906,
0.31395915150642395,
-0.2715194523334503,
-0.21717995405197144,
0.9072645306587219,
-0.49053680896759033,
-0.12944762408733368,
-0.44683343172073364,
-0.025278931483626366,
-0.22746063768863678,
-0.2764478325843811,
0.39753854274749756,
-0.07814241945743561,
0.22567783296108246,
0.049109749495983124,
-0.5700563192367554,
-0.5093003511428833,
0.002051793271675706,
0.4923996031284332,
0.4569271206855774,
0.2641727328300476,
0.8995355367660522,
0.6647398471832275,
-0.13887931406497955,
-0.5778589248657227,
-0.6177758574485779,
0.21316687762737274,
-0.5398032069206238,
-0.6306838393211365,
0.38339290022850037,
-0.06761560589075089,
-0.7511345148086548,
0.24909371137619019,
0.06080342456698418,
-0.33346277475357056,
0.2549102008342743,
0.4153810441493988,
-0.1552933007478714,
-0.09992681443691254,
-0.017165299504995346,
-0.2504209578037262,
0.10677498579025269,
0.3331211805343628,
-0.6457622647285461,
-0.004521961789578199,
-0.3338181972503662,
-0.4521837532520294,
-0.7400184869766235,
0.6986926198005676,
0.7559501528739929,
-0.29563790559768677,
0.3705391585826874,
0.07918529212474823,
-0.3321290910243988,
-0.010133646428585052,
-0.2924900949001312,
0.11144019663333893,
-0.47381240129470825,
0.29872897267341614,
-0.34443381428718567,
-0.9170676469802856,
0.8921425938606262,
0.021495705470442772,
0.23922406136989594,
0.7034585475921631,
0.33601802587509155,
-0.20646654069423676,
0.8566928505897522,
0.8390037417411804,
0.19028998911380768,
0.6382318139076233,
0.059908393770456314,
0.7603183388710022,
-0.22182413935661316,
-0.2797313332557678,
-0.7643797993659973,
-0.5107536315917969,
-0.8013119697570801,
-0.062460530549287796,
0.12452966719865799,
-0.04499788209795952,
-0.2701670229434967,
0.14678668975830078,
-0.35638120770454407,
0.6026624441146851,
0.4350794553756714,
-0.12562549114227295,
-0.04712153226137161,
-0.21805457770824432,
0.03581850230693817,
-0.05721648409962654,
-0.7540157437324524,
-0.5857586860656738,
0.42205116152763367,
0.4376273453235626,
0.32606205344200134,
0.2833734452724457,
0.8119680881500244,
0.3734942674636841,
-0.10787133872509003,
-0.882202684879303,
0.8951610326766968,
0.13402634859085083,
-0.7449396848678589,
0.03826257586479187,
-0.30313536524772644,
-0.9694269895553589,
0.06409966200590134,
0.05043812468647957,
-0.6555102467536926,
0.5452351570129395,
-0.11162081360816956,
-0.5237681865692139,
0.18628014624118805,
-0.7804951071739197,
0.769245982170105,
-0.577578604221344,
-0.6492317318916321,
-0.4148543179035187,
-0.8274545669555664,
0.04113590717315674,
-0.009596200659871101,
0.7159166932106018,
0.14470909535884857,
-0.29356950521469116,
0.9162318706512451,
-0.38073378801345825,
0.6696560978889465,
-0.28012892603874207,
0.11809436976909637,
1.061488389968872,
-0.1473737359046936,
0.28499382734298706,
-0.16963142156600952,
-0.08314257860183716,
0.022619090974330902,
0.17809133231639862,
-0.5497485995292664,
-0.4931764602661133,
0.28064054250717163,
-0.5159299969673157,
-0.9463129043579102,
-0.5251674652099609,
-0.4144621193408966,
0.2350691556930542,
0.6542230844497681,
0.006505775731056929,
-0.0065778703428804874,
-0.018715262413024902,
0.21468088030815125,
0.6951445937156677,
0.3197954297065735,
0.7321405410766602,
0.3860662877559662,
0.17794986069202423,
0.14422157406806946,
0.8507021069526672,
0.3005729019641876,
-0.26332202553749084,
0.026023242622613907,
-0.027186520397663116,
-0.2277517020702362,
-0.5110801458358765,
-0.10106329619884491,
0.2180509865283966,
-0.8397378921508789,
-0.06240452453494072,
-0.2282259613275528,
-0.3283884525299072,
-0.2471776306629181,
-0.32214662432670593,
0.009345272555947304,
-0.37153828144073486,
-0.509225070476532,
-0.10220324993133545,
0.14072220027446747,
0.888202965259552,
0.03318067267537117,
0.10446608811616898,
-0.4285320043563843,
-0.10277263820171356,
0.016889255493879318,
0.3855854868888855,
-0.5835256576538086,
-0.16713130474090576,
-0.11923650652170181,
0.13410820066928864,
-0.2577155828475952,
-0.8681936264038086,
-0.11740174889564514,
0.12890225648880005,
1.012935757637024,
0.511947751045227,
0.025358159095048904,
0.6211123466491699,
-0.18940287828445435,
0.6068520545959473,
0.21429812908172607,
-0.8894118666648865,
0.3541279435157776,
-0.3420443534851074,
0.12067700177431107,
0.5607787370681763,
-0.018797647207975388,
-0.3551991581916809,
-0.5216580629348755,
-0.8908928632736206,
-1.1110954284667969,
0.2953711450099945,
0.18586401641368866,
0.1687157303094864,
0.39805424213409424,
0.613653838634491,
-0.1672705113887787,
0.6582189798355103,
-0.7574939131736755,
0.013497741892933846,
0.12970690429210663,
-0.3399071991443634,
0.5500519871711731,
-0.1353382021188736,
-0.5278213620185852,
-0.17889739573001862,
0.5591500997543335,
-0.019691243767738342,
0.24963490664958954,
0.1821649670600891,
-0.03545830398797989,
0.016158970072865486,
0.5025057196617126,
0.9218480587005615,
1.178938865661621,
0.33738023042678833,
-0.0413963682949543,
-0.25703194737434387,
-0.38939419388771057,
0.10031496733427048,
0.1808222532272339,
-0.34664514660835266,
-0.09098741412162781,
0.345511257648468,
0.817191481590271,
-0.09827073663473129,
-0.8317273259162903,
0.4435555040836334,
0.19647325575351715,
-0.5136765241622925,
-0.414132684469223,
0.03291574865579605,
-0.19811496138572693,
0.19644081592559814,
0.3930298984050751,
0.22836294770240784,
0.3677753806114197,
-0.7277676463127136,
0.4656202495098114,
0.28454774618148804,
-0.26880332827568054,
0.020119763910770416,
0.654154896736145,
0.2742590606212616,
-0.3151920437812805,
0.22142337262630463,
-0.29711195826530457,
-0.6647473573684692,
1.0538487434387207,
0.1556106060743332,
0.7396888732910156,
0.2797848582267761,
0.01901385746896267,
-0.07032470405101776,
0.40565067529678345,
0.049187157303094864,
0.49096405506134033,
-0.12842980027198792,
-0.23337936401367188,
-0.4990052878856659,
-0.41840001940727234,
-0.0788721963763237,
-0.3456815779209137,
-0.4794039726257324,
0.22715449333190918,
-0.22873595356941223,
-0.27388259768486023,
0.11619377136230469,
0.03530663624405861,
-0.36637404561042786,
0.011819921433925629,
-0.0430125892162323,
0.8443949222564697,
-0.8097012042999268,
0.3861958086490631,
1.0125133991241455,
-0.21913814544677734,
-0.5027519464492798,
-0.08754358440637589,
0.04776572808623314,
-0.22943249344825745,
0.27902787923812866,
-0.07687113434076309,
-0.25461888313293457,
-0.15159182250499725,
-0.7033799886703491,
-0.3113361597061157,
0.8874198794364929,
0.19907788932323456,
-0.5691056251525879,
0.3074876666069031,
0.1151997298002243,
0.8487821221351624,
-0.4605967700481415,
0.0916617214679718,
0.5593178272247314,
0.905296266078949,
0.08568789809942245,
-0.7409862279891968,
-0.33654478192329407,
-0.4506731629371643,
-0.10690033435821533,
0.4337046146392822,
-0.613029956817627,
0.6256111264228821,
-0.142253577709198,
-0.2975851595401764,
-0.059039242565631866,
0.5901952981948853,
-0.21241256594657898,
0.5112521052360535,
0.39768171310424805,
0.6705459356307983,
0.7971131205558777,
-0.5083820819854736,
0.835681676864624,
-0.4538152813911438,
0.23187829554080963,
0.8202558159828186,
-0.48872843384742737,
0.4055713415145874,
0.6615279316902161,
-0.030714813619852066,
0.44152897596359253,
0.8032565116882324,
0.011967295780777931,
0.3610878884792328,
0.3021766245365143,
-0.5091197490692139,
-0.10174732655286789,
-0.3069356679916382,
-0.11865637451410294,
0.28601473569869995,
0.44554245471954346,
0.029928196221590042,
-0.07075399160385132,
-0.21280048787593842,
-0.06952901184558868,
0.2868063747882843,
-0.4672391414642334,
0.8026741743087769,
-0.18603061139583588,
-0.8547354936599731,
-0.1481880098581314,
0.33879485726356506,
0.1888531893491745,
-0.5422537326812744,
-0.02934468723833561,
0.04671518877148628,
-0.03160989284515381,
-0.42066439986228943,
-1.0644307136535645,
0.6123617887496948,
-0.23535719513893127,
-0.026418864727020264,
-0.5189523696899414,
0.7722826600074768,
-0.07556691765785217,
-0.3360021114349365,
0.11510661989450455,
0.2398013174533844,
0.0573362298309803,
0.4587654769420624,
-0.9950419068336487,
0.03628343716263771,
-0.14049579203128815,
-0.10452428460121155,
-0.017095867544412613,
0.5055221319198608,
-0.4744079113006592,
0.5814805626869202,
0.34727492928504944,
0.0686475858092308,
0.2979408800601959,
-0.1580628752708435,
0.5921568274497986,
-0.7501766085624695,
-0.9069404602050781,
-0.6604323983192444,
0.6573213934898376,
-0.12808234989643097,
-0.1452600210905075,
0.2561671733856201,
0.572089672088623,
0.5355650186538696,
0.20195069909095764,
0.7390658855438232,
-0.6362246870994568,
-0.1053149402141571,
-0.22447504103183746,
0.39861389994621277,
-0.4576369822025299,
0.1489587277173996,
0.22754314541816711,
-0.6347805857658386,
-0.4436601400375366,
0.45680758357048035,
-0.3223482370376587,
0.2301156222820282,
0.432478129863739,
0.6245725750923157,
0.08925852179527283,
0.13324862718582153,
0.16039051115512848,
0.14791105687618256,
-0.06790852546691895,
0.41379407048225403,
0.7305402159690857,
-0.13538669049739838,
0.23913882672786713,
-0.19866709411144257,
-0.0006474250694736838,
-0.36463919281959534,
-0.802847683429718,
0.039923060685396194,
-0.5624943971633911,
-0.5442141890525818,
-0.20926526188850403,
-0.12895634770393372,
0.3261631727218628,
0.7746705412864685,
-0.6764847636222839,
-0.4750577211380005,
-0.4726595878601074,
0.5933340191841125,
-0.4578987658023834,
-0.2107768952846527,
-0.19699981808662415,
-0.23525358736515045,
-0.5540104508399963,
0.03331480920314789,
0.540381133556366,
-0.03156617283821106,
-0.09929056465625763,
-0.10357498377561569,
-0.40241318941116333,
0.340539813041687,
0.25630927085876465,
0.6902127861976624,
-0.5992764234542847,
-0.15878261625766754,
-0.38801565766334534,
-0.078559011220932,
0.0974772572517395,
0.9726079106330872,
-0.2609412372112274,
0.5547236800193787,
0.5560327172279358,
0.3836941421031952,
0.08133212476968765,
0.14607706665992737,
0.47960299253463745,
-0.22128359973430634,
0.5573541522026062,
0.6300837993621826,
0.45980024337768555,
-0.24621285498142242,
-0.5769439339637756,
0.26463669538497925,
0.2309873402118683,
-0.5454596281051636,
-0.6019132733345032,
0.748449981212616,
-0.8281932473182678,
-0.4571790397167206,
0.5368717312812805,
-0.05929059162735939,
-0.576068103313446,
-0.3201451599597931,
-0.08977527916431427,
0.10512813180685043,
-0.06395437568426132,
0.4610312283039093,
0.8828477263450623,
-0.32811442017555237,
-0.02102181315422058,
-1.0400922298431396,
0.22455136477947235,
0.4790366590023041,
-0.862343966960907,
-0.336154967546463,
0.7015573978424072,
-0.07224968075752258,
0.4258034825325012,
0.2927139699459076,
-0.11443555355072021,
0.4286494255065918,
-0.11059592664241791,
0.01058400608599186,
0.1299300640821457,
-0.3274822235107422,
-0.47368159890174866,
0.21750998497009277,
0.11734522134065628,
-0.021863741800189018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05080v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05080v2
|
I2EDL: Interactive Instruction Error Detection and Localization
| 2024-06-07T16:52:57 | 2024-06-23T22:58:46 |
Francesco Taioli, Stefano Rosa, Alberto Castellini, Lorenzo Natale, Alessio Del Bue, Alessandro Farinelli, Marco Cristani, Yiming Wang
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the Vision-and-Language Navigation in Continuous Environments (VLN-CE)
task, the human user guides an autonomous agent to reach a target goal via a
series of low-level actions following a textual instruction in natural
language. However, most existing methods do not address the likely case where
users may make mistakes when providing such instruction (e.g. "turn left"
instead of "turn right"). In this work, we address a novel task of Interactive
VLN in Continuous Environments (IVLN-CE), which allows the agent to interact
with the user during the VLN-CE navigation to verify any doubts regarding the
instruction errors. We propose an Interactive Instruction Error Detector and
Localizer (I2EDL) that triggers the user-agent interaction upon the detection
of instruction errors during the navigation. We leverage a pre-trained module
to detect instruction errors and pinpoint them in the instruction by
cross-referencing the textual input and past observations. In such way, the
agent is able to query the user for a timely correction, without demanding the
user's cognitive load, as we locate the probable errors to a precise part of
the instruction. We evaluate the proposed I2EDL on a dataset of instructions
containing errors, and further devise a novel metric, the Success weighted by
Interaction Number (SIN), to reflect both the navigation performance and the
interaction effectiveness. We show how the proposed method can ask focused
requests for corrections to the user, which in turn increases the navigation
success, while minimizing the interactions.
|
[
-0.06874703615903854,
-0.7865501642227173,
0.7332160472869873,
0.38325589895248413,
0.10147476196289062,
0.18197934329509735,
-0.4066765010356903,
-0.33535128831863403,
0.05300421267747879,
0.3771507740020752,
-0.5622190237045288,
-0.7348546981811523,
-0.292434960603714,
-0.16346803307533264,
-0.08252536505460739,
0.518977701663971,
-0.3711099922657013,
0.2017473578453064,
-0.5289676189422607,
-0.01812627539038658,
-0.669658362865448,
-0.2606818377971649,
-0.7802977561950684,
-0.22860147058963776,
0.48468852043151855,
0.6751474738121033,
0.4879189133644104,
0.31470978260040283,
0.48907241225242615,
0.370171457529068,
0.3462391495704651,
0.6197651624679565,
-0.2779591679573059,
0.09271633625030518,
-0.3349447548389435,
-0.6680529117584229,
-0.6247355341911316,
-0.3514530658721924,
0.6694186329841614,
0.3495524227619171,
-0.03133697807788849,
-0.14969028532505035,
0.2015947699546814,
0.5267325639724731,
-0.5535956621170044,
0.37639346718788147,
-0.11569683253765106,
0.09878832846879959,
-0.348707377910614,
-0.32627245783805847,
-0.6537157297134399,
-0.2871167063713074,
-0.04364382475614548,
-0.8447785973548889,
-0.16465499997138977,
-0.059484194964170456,
0.44417309761047363,
0.798712432384491,
-0.4679417610168457,
-0.49988269805908203,
-0.9204846024513245,
0.7347815036773682,
-0.7791873812675476,
0.2968003451824188,
0.3982876241207123,
0.2784089744091034,
-0.2788231372833252,
-0.7379551529884338,
-0.842362105846405,
-0.2759403884410858,
-0.27684104442596436,
0.4991523027420044,
-0.14240017533302307,
0.22362014651298523,
0.295195609331131,
-0.4747803211212158,
-0.47092896699905396,
0.366493284702301,
-0.13480906188488007,
-0.20396333932876587,
0.4448336362838745,
0.20245130360126495,
0.5855457186698914,
0.22287647426128387,
-0.4655223786830902,
-0.170303612947464,
-0.4911622703075409,
0.4714328348636627,
0.18630994856357574,
0.0010202369885519147,
-0.33879515528678894,
0.5700947046279907,
-0.31575801968574524,
0.7724798321723938,
0.045193690806627274,
-0.10617905855178833,
0.1445678025484085,
-0.40254008769989014,
0.2765624523162842,
0.3233727812767029,
0.42312827706336975,
0.7362986207008362,
0.28029799461364746,
0.09562607854604721,
-0.3283832371234894,
-0.19270873069763184,
0.34591153264045715,
-0.5567886233329773,
-0.14310304820537567,
0.27869749069213867,
0.061301715672016144,
-0.003000076627358794,
0.31499141454696655,
-0.5381259918212891,
-0.2530229985713959,
-0.2700355052947998,
0.22111862897872925,
-0.2759849727153778,
-0.05606203153729439,
-0.11589760333299637,
0.16728349030017853,
0.4182140529155731,
0.655805230140686,
-0.4765620827674866,
0.24101020395755768,
0.6130197644233704,
0.6467850804328918,
-0.33339548110961914,
-0.364114910364151,
-0.9508345127105713,
0.2442314773797989,
-0.147003635764122,
0.8445237874984741,
-0.28393563628196716,
-0.41613951325416565,
0.0786171406507492,
0.034451473504304886,
-0.25389158725738525,
-0.3597530722618103,
0.22969673573970795,
-0.5486176609992981,
0.08422180265188217,
-0.2773096561431885,
-0.43853285908699036,
-0.19800296425819397,
0.4699191153049469,
-0.42361870408058167,
0.9920124411582947,
0.0964522734284401,
-0.567177951335907,
0.057377319782972336,
-0.816190779209137,
-0.46049821376800537,
0.40668267011642456,
-0.3162643015384674,
-0.2589455842971802,
-0.2950400412082672,
-0.032902710139751434,
-0.055201057344675064,
0.19654063880443573,
-0.09866853803396225,
0.09086592495441437,
-0.715129554271698,
0.2391609400510788,
-0.31907159090042114,
0.6627658605575562,
-0.38095349073410034,
-0.9996035695075989,
0.18102288246154785,
-0.5546064376831055,
0.4361715018749237,
-0.08235123753547668,
-0.6439082026481628,
-0.46609294414520264,
0.27423226833343506,
-0.27391430735588074,
-0.08515316992998123,
0.7287240028381348,
-0.5192766189575195,
0.4369203448295593,
-0.2741446793079376,
-0.23397938907146454,
0.6042920351028442,
0.08154693990945816,
0.44488412141799927,
0.13895301520824432,
0.4191057085990906,
0.013180960901081562,
0.4324173331260681,
0.018005600199103355,
-0.591871976852417,
-1.1241637468338013,
0.13369160890579224,
0.05142751336097717,
1.1271138191223145,
-1.2742985486984253,
0.27412694692611694,
-0.2666071653366089,
-0.29643672704696655,
-0.26049450039863586,
0.21003341674804688,
0.8709986209869385,
0.584171712398529,
0.48107630014419556,
-0.12395891547203064,
-0.2390558272600174,
-0.37374404072761536,
0.012455384247004986,
-0.39515528082847595,
0.0623294897377491,
0.35850974917411804,
0.10069931298494339,
-0.5891048908233643,
1.0687694549560547,
-0.3017207086086273,
-0.34817981719970703,
0.048386938869953156,
0.20378220081329346,
-0.28451594710350037,
0.5614489912986755,
0.38801172375679016,
-0.832366943359375,
-0.7691832184791565,
0.40456143021583557,
-1.0727510452270508,
-0.17735570669174194,
-0.2406761795282364,
-0.09711993485689163,
0.331760436296463,
0.6302707195281982,
-0.21260520815849304,
0.9357323050498962,
0.21021364629268646,
-0.37221258878707886,
0.16566266119480133,
-0.7000510692596436,
0.4175478219985962,
-0.4675270617008209,
-0.4510324001312256,
-0.017943982034921646,
-0.1653561145067215,
-0.5780276656150818,
0.025701969861984253,
0.3547382056713104,
0.4858352541923523,
-0.5250193476676941,
0.5650537610054016,
-0.5224788188934326,
-0.24882268905639648,
-0.21819813549518585,
0.409650593996048,
-0.14478659629821777,
0.6227315068244934,
0.16620245575904846,
0.8809179067611694,
0.1857292801141739,
-0.4497652053833008,
0.5774096250534058,
0.17159360647201538,
0.008992035873234272,
0.8144124746322632,
-0.5112220644950867,
0.2829391360282898,
-0.04007887840270996,
0.10305334627628326,
-1.0220348834991455,
-0.2329348921775818,
0.4207736551761627,
-0.4144417643547058,
0.18411040306091309,
-0.1722969263792038,
-0.32057130336761475,
-0.26335540413856506,
-0.1848924309015274,
0.42080941796302795,
0.31121698021888733,
-0.6764166951179504,
0.5260499119758606,
-0.13488240540027618,
0.04429289326071739,
-0.4870840013027191,
-0.5947579145431519,
0.04729704558849335,
0.20809370279312134,
-0.826610267162323,
0.16611510515213013,
-0.32251203060150146,
-0.46025487780570984,
0.016080159693956375,
-0.0025101848877966404,
0.03130423650145531,
0.144374817609787,
0.5075154900550842,
0.2613464593887329,
-0.09983618557453156,
-0.07732131332159042,
0.24004420638084412,
-0.3304309844970703,
-0.01974259503185749,
-0.2195902168750763,
0.26989075541496277,
-0.41712385416030884,
-0.8542510271072388,
-0.676832914352417,
0.23667371273040771,
0.4943317472934723,
-0.40283581614494324,
0.40413397550582886,
0.584552526473999,
-0.35407501459121704,
-0.008694789372384548,
-0.4321696162223816,
-0.22980786859989166,
-0.5421757102012634,
0.31848499178886414,
-0.20365405082702637,
-0.30480843782424927,
0.25973835587501526,
-0.22381556034088135,
0.11612529307603836,
0.08545605838298798,
0.336842805147171,
-0.6771841049194336,
1.0202161073684692,
0.5253390073776245,
0.5355910658836365,
0.42509955167770386,
-0.3049202859401703,
0.32480788230895996,
-0.7379915118217468,
-0.5926323533058167,
-0.1957893967628479,
-0.5049751400947571,
-0.26072174310684204,
-0.7102333307266235,
0.897467851638794,
-0.07116257399320602,
-0.05812409892678261,
0.18239879608154297,
-0.47076645493507385,
0.38331717252731323,
0.9076272249221802,
0.2102949172258377,
0.19209294021129608,
0.0134816225618124,
-0.12612691521644592,
-0.2790180444717407,
-0.4603721797466278,
-0.4272819459438324,
0.4619334042072296,
0.07898544520139694,
0.784274697303772,
0.2695114314556122,
0.8394433856010437,
0.6733410358428955,
0.08099819719791412,
-0.8566074371337891,
0.7580977082252502,
0.22719521820545197,
-0.0299121905118227,
-0.5567288994789124,
-0.2194368839263916,
-0.7501352429389954,
-0.14466583728790283,
-0.08094660192728043,
-0.7632575631141663,
0.1549663096666336,
0.34153488278388977,
-0.2843230962753296,
0.24523022770881653,
-0.737163245677948,
0.9097476601600647,
-0.7482112646102905,
-0.5832158923149109,
-0.2547427713871002,
-0.7549605369567871,
-0.044161707162857056,
0.23456430435180664,
0.13335642218589783,
0.2733805477619171,
-0.3088827431201935,
0.4809415340423584,
-0.4592503607273102,
0.926385223865509,
-0.6308431625366211,
-0.0424165241420269,
0.41024163365364075,
0.15743838250637054,
0.9720185399055481,
-0.008755781687796116,
0.018824134021997452,
0.017711080610752106,
-0.261515349149704,
-0.2695487439632416,
-0.6693615913391113,
0.752713143825531,
-0.597891092300415,
-0.48476704955101013,
-0.5464894771575928,
-0.2136535942554474,
-0.05344071984291077,
0.21110986173152924,
0.29968610405921936,
0.46912074089050293,
0.08152437210083008,
-0.005065911915153265,
0.6254190802574158,
-0.15077567100524902,
0.6114494204521179,
0.9343406558036804,
0.09623327106237411,
-0.028046727180480957,
1.0612311363220215,
0.33464595675468445,
0.16097219288349152,
0.34897947311401367,
-0.18341068923473358,
-0.05575118213891983,
-0.6104243993759155,
-0.6886311173439026,
-0.018526215106248856,
-0.7080971002578735,
-0.038852520287036896,
-0.47301098704338074,
-0.26496610045433044,
0.1764548420906067,
-0.43282487988471985,
-0.5559806823730469,
-0.032368458807468414,
-0.36792728304862976,
0.08098380267620087,
0.09583121538162231,
0.6487459540367126,
-0.08911272138357162,
0.572808027267456,
-0.7965359091758728,
-0.10867588967084885,
0.21389178931713104,
0.21372957527637482,
-0.09241326153278351,
-0.1326363980770111,
-0.5062863230705261,
0.21469701826572418,
0.009105305187404156,
-0.7276877760887146,
-0.04094807803630829,
-0.05581112205982208,
0.6121131777763367,
0.19954504072666168,
0.19199195504188538,
0.35625630617141724,
-0.4118705689907074,
0.7651245594024658,
0.07147084921598434,
-0.7417443990707397,
0.737388014793396,
0.06281956285238266,
0.5529290437698364,
0.46947288513183594,
0.11359985917806625,
-0.5420945286750793,
-0.3892850875854492,
-0.26363420486450195,
-0.8471329808235168,
0.6348403096199036,
0.1349763572216034,
-0.22503109276294708,
0.0007961717783473432,
0.3322983682155609,
-0.3864923417568207,
-0.18478386104106903,
-0.6175060868263245,
-0.20175938308238983,
0.1511177271604538,
-0.4010569453239441,
0.47352105379104614,
-0.29925012588500977,
0.0147493164986372,
0.031678084284067154,
0.8813770413398743,
-0.402187705039978,
0.034150343388319016,
0.38324087858200073,
-0.38762518763542175,
-0.23414185643196106,
-0.0005734040169045329,
0.7885778546333313,
0.6237531900405884,
-0.13812771439552307,
0.08876396715641022,
0.24992521107196808,
-0.58184814453125,
0.19995267689228058,
-0.010061888955533504,
-0.517788827419281,
-0.07244376093149185,
0.5088311433792114,
0.5265297889709473,
0.37637844681739807,
-0.866012454032898,
0.7138897776603699,
-0.37271058559417725,
0.47920915484428406,
-0.7125355005264282,
0.2381451427936554,
-0.1621549427509308,
0.6372633576393127,
0.27129337191581726,
0.14197735488414764,
0.1828315407037735,
-0.22014063596725464,
0.2869170606136322,
0.25717073678970337,
-0.8244224786758423,
-0.25942644476890564,
0.5397586822509766,
0.6025877594947815,
-0.7078325152397156,
0.8532816767692566,
-0.5568704605102539,
-0.5825113654136658,
0.7697815895080566,
0.21557800471782684,
0.7220380902290344,
-0.21353740990161896,
0.3151859641075134,
0.4663091003894806,
0.3364206552505493,
0.2234618365764618,
0.18196901679039001,
-0.2648888826370239,
-0.6635215282440186,
-0.2359972596168518,
-0.18685577809810638,
-0.6335019469261169,
-0.6125038862228394,
-0.6557046175003052,
0.1700030416250229,
-0.44545459747314453,
-0.07211322337388992,
-0.4225943982601166,
-0.23454046249389648,
-0.6081445813179016,
0.2242104411125183,
0.2827708125114441,
0.5114094614982605,
-0.2605162262916565,
0.8593645095825195,
0.7805466055870056,
-0.22610710561275482,
-0.582920253276825,
0.3114577829837799,
0.23784880340099335,
-0.7934848070144653,
0.6608918905258179,
0.09639329463243484,
-0.4701821804046631,
0.036727774888277054,
-0.2837521433830261,
-0.5993874073028564,
1.2617216110229492,
-0.11105810105800629,
-0.8168532252311707,
-0.047681160271167755,
0.16739864647388458,
0.4286295473575592,
-0.11459309607744217,
0.32800737023353577,
0.5091418027877808,
0.6111657023429871,
-0.07913964241743088,
-0.799229621887207,
-0.009847049601376057,
-0.2530929148197174,
-0.17750295996665955,
0.10422616451978683,
-0.8514752388000488,
0.5348922610282898,
-0.5090996623039246,
-0.05985267460346222,
0.10748309642076492,
0.7444347739219666,
0.021156007423996925,
0.7681741714477539,
0.6962106823921204,
0.21438492834568024,
0.8358865976333618,
-0.3239947259426117,
0.9354279637336731,
-0.2048129290342331,
0.15391865372657776,
1.464977502822876,
-0.3017491400241852,
0.8577936291694641,
0.43689268827438354,
0.03364187851548195,
0.5736784338951111,
0.48722681403160095,
0.12581755220890045,
0.5597995519638062,
-0.040314462035894394,
-0.6543540954589844,
-0.1485276222229004,
0.06495688855648041,
-0.12238028645515442,
0.39571240544319153,
0.5203009247779846,
0.20831380784511566,
-0.2484946995973587,
0.4068235754966736,
0.028363637626171112,
0.3096127510070801,
-0.17328113317489624,
0.9620294570922852,
-0.32166725397109985,
-0.8349307179450989,
0.28608858585357666,
0.09593509137630463,
0.5337995290756226,
-0.5097079873085022,
-0.42578354477882385,
-0.4317275881767273,
0.31249698996543884,
-0.38951677083969116,
-1.0052989721298218,
0.07613224536180496,
0.08677402883768082,
-0.004760233219712973,
0.063308946788311,
0.6956431865692139,
-0.5240174531936646,
-0.2070731818675995,
0.5876099467277527,
0.24901005625724792,
0.178547203540802,
0.14190390706062317,
-0.4406123161315918,
0.3372633457183838,
0.46635010838508606,
-0.1692516803741455,
0.02072126418352127,
0.20755718648433685,
-0.3649011254310608,
0.7088577151298523,
0.2811583876609802,
-0.31888672709465027,
0.23233278095722198,
-0.11084318906068802,
0.4592782258987427,
-0.49962905049324036,
-0.4012547731399536,
-0.5150507092475891,
1.0815632343292236,
-0.38655886054039,
-0.010845983400940895,
0.7307794690132141,
0.47559767961502075,
0.9306584596633911,
0.004583785776048899,
0.7715042233467102,
0.01388633158057928,
0.05581946298480034,
-0.5956956148147583,
0.38179415464401245,
-0.4927264153957367,
0.6381755471229553,
0.32571345567703247,
-0.8273478150367737,
0.02964368276298046,
0.5580568909645081,
-0.4174087643623352,
-0.2195151448249817,
0.4615522623062134,
0.9254472255706787,
-0.16494178771972656,
-0.3886948227882385,
0.2733120918273926,
0.24111910164356232,
0.44616052508354187,
0.43428927659988403,
0.6771481037139893,
-0.38954833149909973,
0.44166991114616394,
-0.285735160112381,
-0.5569260716438293,
-0.5362607836723328,
-0.5207012891769409,
-0.6799609661102295,
-0.48586615920066833,
-0.6387823820114136,
-0.5592083930969238,
0.19327811896800995,
0.8970481753349304,
0.4533049762248993,
-0.6584885716438293,
-0.21093736588954926,
-0.053389858454465866,
0.42199212312698364,
-0.2662324905395508,
-0.2366979867219925,
0.09323510527610779,
-0.31867119669914246,
-0.9631941318511963,
0.7614561319351196,
0.6662185192108154,
0.18889839947223663,
-0.3121112287044525,
-0.462208092212677,
-0.04045442119240761,
0.1417563259601593,
0.4376639127731323,
0.5443668961524963,
-0.7527902722358704,
-0.6016674637794495,
-0.13320565223693848,
-0.3836851418018341,
0.05343765392899513,
0.42327797412872314,
-0.5674088597297668,
1.0076875686645508,
0.13745294511318207,
0.6459760069847107,
0.6720080971717834,
-0.2687486410140991,
0.45827409625053406,
-0.8093993663787842,
0.2457612156867981,
0.10546132177114487,
0.20101702213287354,
0.4947039783000946,
-0.7008622288703918,
0.7546558976173401,
0.13977846503257751,
-0.4193412959575653,
-0.555840015411377,
0.13794852793216705,
-1.2562118768692017,
0.19020110368728638,
0.9603350758552551,
-0.4456139802932739,
-0.3799666464328766,
0.07746922224760056,
-0.6299040913581848,
0.14975345134735107,
-0.11819197982549667,
0.5390943288803101,
0.3656400442123413,
-0.2805931270122528,
0.013390704989433289,
-0.5483473539352417,
0.45684149861335754,
0.17920686304569244,
-1.0251530408859253,
-0.3602818250656128,
0.5864249467849731,
0.06591842323541641,
0.3364630341529846,
0.4237789809703827,
0.23335938155651093,
0.6026578545570374,
-0.02710634656250477,
0.1979270726442337,
-0.028906313702464104,
-0.45273712277412415,
0.10694275796413422,
-0.24566519260406494,
0.0749913901090622,
-0.49550577998161316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05079v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05079v1
|
SUMIE: A Synthetic Benchmark for Incremental Entity Summarization
| 2024-06-07T16:49:21 | 2024-06-07T16:49:21 |
Eunjeong Hwang, Yichao Zhou, Beliz Gunel, James Bradley Wendt, Sandeep Tata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
No existing dataset adequately tests how well language models can
incrementally update entity summaries - a crucial ability as these models
rapidly advance. The Incremental Entity Summarization (IES) task is vital for
maintaining accurate, up-to-date knowledge. To address this, we introduce
SUMIE, a fully synthetic dataset designed to expose real-world IES challenges.
This dataset effectively highlights problems like incorrect entity association
and incomplete information presentation. Unlike common synthetic datasets, ours
captures the complexity and nuances found in real-world data. We generate
informative and diverse attributes, summaries, and unstructured paragraphs in
sequence, ensuring high quality. The alignment between generated summaries and
paragraphs exceeds 96%, confirming the dataset's quality. Extensive experiments
demonstrate the dataset's difficulty - state-of-the-art LLMs struggle to update
summaries with an F1 higher than 80.4%. We will open source the benchmark and
the evaluation metrics to help the community make progress on IES tasks.
|
[
-0.29809966683387756,
-0.3245524764060974,
0.2624656558036804,
0.5593520998954773,
0.18586565554141998,
0.33763158321380615,
-0.014930623583495617,
-0.49515047669410706,
0.5069035291671753,
0.3013460040092468,
-0.6683967709541321,
-0.39234739542007446,
-0.4762421250343323,
0.541322648525238,
-0.695406973361969,
0.8493357300758362,
-0.2598193287849426,
-0.1112561896443367,
-0.4371844530105591,
-0.3522188067436218,
-0.47913241386413574,
-0.14490634202957153,
-0.3651081621646881,
0.04393048584461212,
0.13293935358524323,
0.6215881109237671,
0.2656049430370331,
0.3925962448120117,
0.6707597970962524,
0.34553462266921997,
0.24405600130558014,
0.33856040239334106,
-0.4976121485233307,
0.4139937460422516,
0.026355942711234093,
-0.3315929174423218,
-0.6915361285209656,
-0.10190693289041519,
0.9170041680335999,
1.0045411586761475,
-0.26520925760269165,
0.5182024836540222,
-0.10319563746452332,
0.6917856335639954,
-0.7295311689376831,
0.051311835646629333,
-0.6377739906311035,
-0.11121293902397156,
-0.1423647701740265,
-0.04615182802081108,
-0.15211781859397888,
-0.3779204189777374,
0.04799685999751091,
-0.6558727025985718,
0.2524425685405731,
0.00003747062146430835,
0.9219383597373962,
0.36454468965530396,
-0.5128980875015259,
-0.05084723234176636,
-0.49229487776756287,
0.5902685523033142,
-0.7367204427719116,
0.4304327666759491,
-0.3529966473579407,
0.21725650131702423,
-0.3389231860637665,
-0.9623322486877441,
-0.6481378674507141,
-0.07087405771017075,
-0.04784059152007103,
0.47830432653427124,
-0.26269569993019104,
-0.26254335045814514,
0.29635000228881836,
0.497516930103302,
-0.6928774118423462,
-0.09998904168605804,
-0.3712038993835449,
0.139007568359375,
0.6815438270568848,
0.3590310215950012,
0.5790789723396301,
0.2680882513523102,
-0.27326536178588867,
-0.15422458946704865,
-0.9844546318054199,
-0.08133962750434875,
0.1710498332977295,
0.10307125747203827,
-0.12521041929721832,
0.8112853169441223,
-0.41512349247932434,
0.3677723705768585,
-0.07495361566543579,
-0.0060644568875432014,
0.460919052362442,
-0.3737739622592926,
-0.41727346181869507,
0.12662659585475922,
0.5352547764778137,
0.6529667377471924,
0.2991665005683899,
-0.20442144572734833,
-0.35474178194999695,
0.0889657661318779,
0.1597539633512497,
-0.9047900438308716,
-0.10384160280227661,
0.531547486782074,
0.06000553071498871,
-0.1880606710910797,
0.004729584325104952,
-0.6933953166007996,
-0.041013628244400024,
-0.4294823706150055,
0.23186105489730835,
-0.42045265436172485,
-0.22047488391399384,
-0.12152779847383499,
-0.24565227329730988,
-0.04901161044836044,
0.4910086691379547,
-0.7328928709030151,
0.47196492552757263,
0.5444471836090088,
0.9109614491462708,
-0.16824330389499664,
-0.4262929856777191,
-0.427457332611084,
0.40294358134269714,
-0.6268500685691833,
1.0843935012817383,
-0.3380245566368103,
-0.30692967772483826,
-0.3802259564399719,
0.07311564683914185,
-0.08640871196985245,
-0.7931080460548401,
0.18323345482349396,
-0.16341938078403473,
0.06586672365665436,
-0.24513784050941467,
-0.7788418531417847,
0.08032553642988205,
0.28381726145744324,
-0.659248411655426,
0.981502890586853,
0.3866938650608063,
-0.6016935110092163,
0.4849514365196228,
-0.5349729061126709,
-0.4799646735191345,
0.08924257755279541,
-0.2620542645454407,
-0.10246922820806503,
0.2347293496131897,
0.22832289338111877,
0.18124133348464966,
-0.2964339554309845,
0.3516334593296051,
-0.17308935523033142,
-0.40046456456184387,
0.00028248311718925834,
-0.049110762774944305,
0.5922597646713257,
-0.06238866224884987,
-0.1702522337436676,
0.0446946807205677,
-0.8144504427909851,
-0.08819931745529175,
0.06655608117580414,
0.0681067556142807,
-0.3372563421726227,
-0.16424134373664856,
-0.32744383811950684,
0.023344682529568672,
0.17513902485370636,
-0.4388887286186218,
0.24408769607543945,
-0.48722565174102783,
0.19510386884212494,
0.5344030261039734,
0.47430455684661865,
0.23983478546142578,
-0.5174564719200134,
0.41563892364501953,
0.08530166000127792,
-0.12532147765159607,
-0.7325820326805115,
-0.322492778301239,
-0.5655084252357483,
-0.36895862221717834,
0.4709823727607727,
0.8493582606315613,
-0.46410176157951355,
0.2945682108402252,
-0.7742875218391418,
-0.6547740697860718,
-0.48365873098373413,
-0.06461138278245926,
0.11501122266054153,
0.6348696947097778,
0.46769312024116516,
-0.14058686792850494,
-0.6185442209243774,
-1.1230813264846802,
-0.3166075050830841,
-0.06316087394952774,
-0.47943007946014404,
-0.017865918576717377,
0.6804961562156677,
0.03160225972533226,
0.6920446157455444,
-0.28492558002471924,
-0.32529595494270325,
-0.05656345933675766,
0.39220377802848816,
0.10197823494672775,
0.5041820406913757,
0.4411580562591553,
-0.47750604152679443,
-0.20704883337020874,
-0.34436386823654175,
-1.1518436670303345,
-0.1831882894039154,
-0.32036757469177246,
0.04350421205163002,
-0.10048464685678482,
0.43120959401130676,
-0.6800463199615479,
0.06395977735519409,
0.3657299280166626,
-0.13142108917236328,
0.37283772230148315,
-0.24651755392551422,
0.4790375232696533,
-1.0664600133895874,
0.13350604474544525,
0.16724364459514618,
-0.26853880286216736,
-0.2831481099128723,
0.42073869705200195,
0.1852966696023941,
-0.21114151179790497,
-0.27267909049987793,
0.4137185513973236,
-0.6717745065689087,
-0.1507936716079712,
0.21205665171146393,
0.4203123450279236,
0.03398857265710831,
0.31202104687690735,
-0.2805759608745575,
1.251765251159668,
0.38698816299438477,
-0.7311521172523499,
0.38014814257621765,
0.41060903668403625,
-0.45508041977882385,
0.8203787207603455,
-0.8522273898124695,
-0.26891762018203735,
-0.3385392427444458,
0.2996911108493805,
-0.7687035202980042,
-0.46376070380210876,
-0.34457728266716003,
-0.38192984461784363,
0.5488532781600952,
0.2086416482925415,
-0.4120292365550995,
0.07335418462753296,
-0.7951195240020752,
0.11087553948163986,
0.2361387461423874,
-0.32290226221084595,
0.7369853258132935,
0.9304167032241821,
-0.4812134802341461,
-0.5350211262702942,
-0.7288437485694885,
0.5429181456565857,
0.020575830712914467,
-0.7121983766555786,
0.6707528829574585,
-0.005444656126201153,
-0.5341320633888245,
0.1846732795238495,
-0.27244147658348083,
0.2242145985364914,
0.03350815549492836,
0.008124024607241154,
0.2515995502471924,
-0.17282713949680328,
0.0654061809182167,
0.2287375032901764,
-0.11456272006034851,
-0.010476171970367432,
-0.1516101211309433,
-0.0378149189054966,
-0.06835579872131348,
-0.09257470071315765,
-0.1997045874595642,
0.4493503272533417,
0.599786102771759,
-0.12014646083116531,
0.5478276610374451,
0.00649164617061615,
-0.797197163105011,
-0.08895314484834671,
-0.5110179781913757,
-0.06257561594247818,
-0.3713126480579376,
0.3871470093727112,
-0.6840319037437439,
-0.49795079231262207,
0.44529974460601807,
-0.3974076211452484,
0.5549690127372742,
0.6033982038497925,
0.2523503303527832,
-0.29086771607398987,
0.9134637117385864,
0.5334644913673401,
0.0123658562079072,
0.07098940014839172,
-0.3292577564716339,
0.03276393190026283,
-0.904217541217804,
-0.23254328966140747,
-0.3178373873233795,
-0.3320934474468231,
-0.6651144027709961,
-0.07517939805984497,
0.5827328562736511,
0.09931036084890366,
-0.14398735761642456,
0.5566442608833313,
-0.27021855115890503,
0.5184910297393799,
0.3537020683288574,
-0.18395091593265533,
0.36436256766319275,
-0.20777399837970734,
0.30133217573165894,
-0.19024604558944702,
-0.31852129101753235,
-0.5802790522575378,
1.0053101778030396,
-0.08648370951414108,
0.6072534918785095,
0.4742419421672821,
0.5445485711097717,
0.5875542163848877,
0.5547801852226257,
-0.14286579191684723,
0.6711793541908264,
-0.03523138910531998,
-0.18578535318374634,
-0.46457144618034363,
-0.47354230284690857,
-0.6921244263648987,
0.08097776770591736,
-0.2516407370567322,
-0.7251346707344055,
0.2781609296798706,
0.3056539297103882,
-0.10038136690855026,
0.07741820812225342,
-0.7602669596672058,
0.845455527305603,
0.13448140025138855,
-0.14790113270282745,
-0.0972195565700531,
-0.5454825162887573,
0.5501709580421448,
-0.05878881737589836,
0.20672507584095,
-0.31751176714897156,
-0.41003432869911194,
0.4398631453514099,
-0.5476475954055786,
0.3485013246536255,
0.013069802895188332,
-0.1022360697388649,
0.17896275222301483,
0.24365854263305664,
0.9288162589073181,
0.017528293654322624,
0.08935707062482834,
0.12075816839933395,
0.05919761210680008,
-0.422497421503067,
-0.7232581973075867,
0.9751855134963989,
-0.3870828449726105,
-0.40637627243995667,
-0.4134594202041626,
-0.12707842886447906,
-0.46459531784057617,
-0.09802070260047913,
0.33080294728279114,
0.6005347371101379,
-0.33058640360832214,
-0.03552110865712166,
0.7404267191886902,
-0.09058700501918793,
0.2570849657058716,
0.5111389756202698,
-0.08105263113975525,
-0.45858269929885864,
1.1067655086517334,
0.4985199570655823,
-0.005270339082926512,
0.561934769153595,
-0.5887543559074402,
-0.1550024449825287,
-0.5693445801734924,
-0.9287938475608826,
0.17481845617294312,
-0.6174618601799011,
-0.4044099748134613,
-0.9354275465011597,
-0.049043018370866776,
-0.49384045600891113,
-0.07036716490983963,
-0.4669788181781769,
-0.9300033450126648,
0.04700685665011406,
-0.4600538909435272,
-0.016510937362909317,
0.5373508930206299,
0.0676766112446785,
-0.29867783188819885,
-0.8491803407669067,
0.32044726610183716,
0.20503078401088715,
0.288927286863327,
-0.15668036043643951,
-0.5453871488571167,
-0.04894131422042847,
-0.15343274176120758,
-0.04459857568144798,
-1.0478852987289429,
0.2797040343284607,
0.3676666021347046,
0.281450480222702,
-0.14574439823627472,
0.15388111770153046,
0.8735790848731995,
-0.47539180517196655,
0.7915942668914795,
-0.1808493435382843,
-0.9519834518432617,
0.6248034238815308,
-0.16534630954265594,
0.26523688435554504,
0.7429739236831665,
0.26035183668136597,
-0.4521498680114746,
-0.7196969985961914,
-0.7408966422080994,
-1.3093799352645874,
0.2660522758960724,
0.42185160517692566,
0.016599640250205994,
-0.08676797151565552,
0.29349467158317566,
0.04118023067712784,
0.4908774495124817,
-0.2452298104763031,
-0.39644601941108704,
-0.006533704698085785,
-0.5151249170303345,
0.2997165322303772,
-0.2463763952255249,
0.12242483347654343,
0.06895872950553894,
1.2473238706588745,
-0.043809257447719574,
0.14857742190361023,
0.2798837125301361,
-0.4908659756183624,
-0.1298167109489441,
0.1684078574180603,
0.8196142911911011,
0.9534669518470764,
-0.38819846510887146,
0.01306439470499754,
0.6466740369796753,
-0.3322502672672272,
0.19825488328933716,
0.196282297372818,
-0.4525756239891052,
0.21089187264442444,
0.6849709153175354,
0.48758935928344727,
0.28813230991363525,
-1.1685301065444946,
0.5680251121520996,
-0.24259883165359497,
-0.009216055274009705,
-0.7099659442901611,
0.02242080494761467,
-0.0981169044971466,
-0.08809243142604828,
0.48333054780960083,
-0.020708007737994194,
0.4616008698940277,
-0.4527844190597534,
0.29349595308303833,
0.1992330402135849,
-0.1581086665391922,
-0.39761409163475037,
0.7428930997848511,
0.2362794727087021,
0.009460152126848698,
0.44176632165908813,
-0.3362225592136383,
0.06062792241573334,
0.6103453636169434,
0.37816959619522095,
0.7534351944923401,
-0.19930781424045563,
0.026188168674707413,
0.6565437912940979,
0.579636812210083,
0.02291899174451828,
0.3494485914707184,
0.20387540757656097,
-0.631028950214386,
-0.5875561237335205,
-0.32373884320259094,
-0.7605431079864502,
0.23346780240535736,
-0.5174846053123474,
0.27750182151794434,
-0.2536666691303253,
0.24893343448638916,
0.21363718807697296,
-0.2803282141685486,
-0.3654017448425293,
0.3834209442138672,
-0.3042883276939392,
1.168655276298523,
-0.731202244758606,
0.24183206260204315,
0.7895872592926025,
-0.579660952091217,
-0.5004423260688782,
-0.1681869626045227,
0.021025793626904488,
-0.579788327217102,
0.21004536747932434,
0.16217786073684692,
-0.05569040775299072,
0.2619237005710602,
-0.42213204503059387,
-0.8795138001441956,
1.331383466720581,
0.5645326972007751,
-0.772584080696106,
-0.06059504672884941,
-0.12486738711595535,
0.4627546966075897,
-0.44888848066329956,
0.5591681599617004,
0.5887434482574463,
0.3989792764186859,
-0.10652080923318863,
-0.5399538278579712,
0.16229577362537384,
-0.6916335225105286,
-0.08368013799190521,
0.4864383339881897,
-0.7050294876098633,
0.6565039753913879,
-0.3795623481273651,
-0.6586282253265381,
-0.12580277025699615,
0.8161779642105103,
0.11997149139642715,
0.2860146462917328,
0.3678906559944153,
0.7823285460472107,
0.8323437571525574,
-0.3040241301059723,
1.0313498973846436,
-0.5513938069343567,
0.016537869349122047,
1.5372400283813477,
-0.7179133892059326,
0.7255004048347473,
0.17669273912906647,
-0.31717896461486816,
0.502296507358551,
0.5626853108406067,
-0.08078157901763916,
0.2603307068347931,
0.16800132393836975,
-0.5869596004486084,
0.04430000111460686,
-0.30072516202926636,
-0.3592628836631775,
0.1455458253622055,
0.3372843265533447,
0.12572292983531952,
-0.31243404746055603,
-0.060262687504291534,
-0.06802098453044891,
0.10192950069904327,
-0.06339927017688751,
1.0359876155853271,
-0.24479883909225464,
-0.6799538731575012,
0.07084937393665314,
0.014095023274421692,
0.19060896337032318,
-0.5289275050163269,
-0.4711780548095703,
-0.6139737963676453,
-0.049646034836769104,
-0.11673272401094437,
-0.5968595147132874,
0.4154920279979706,
0.1710750162601471,
-0.03443177789449692,
-0.00962530542165041,
0.46633800864219666,
-0.4780791401863098,
-0.49807167053222656,
-0.032433170825242996,
0.5084832906723022,
0.21227486431598663,
-0.12561243772506714,
-0.34566962718963623,
-0.3286551833152771,
-0.17796562612056732,
-0.36259725689888,
0.3077191114425659,
0.7535369992256165,
-0.25432315468788147,
0.8520306944847107,
0.5747138857841492,
0.2519076466560364,
-0.24086999893188477,
0.21478252112865448,
0.8245925307273865,
-0.8144219517707825,
-0.4340350031852722,
-0.8262401223182678,
0.6429066061973572,
-0.48237091302871704,
-0.2645988464355469,
0.5670618414878845,
0.9897756576538086,
0.9167633652687073,
0.028130734339356422,
0.8179001212120056,
0.12489575892686844,
0.641859233379364,
-0.48789095878601074,
0.2937176525592804,
-0.48041245341300964,
0.5005249977111816,
-0.0028396211564540863,
-0.8792822957038879,
-0.1855335384607315,
0.17886169254779816,
0.42803874611854553,
-0.10800837725400925,
0.6424261331558228,
0.7263538837432861,
0.10467638820409775,
0.16847634315490723,
0.1507873237133026,
0.37042081356048584,
0.18692751228809357,
0.34642964601516724,
0.5940984487533569,
-0.7008827924728394,
0.34522369503974915,
-0.11611560732126236,
-0.3800988495349884,
0.13898605108261108,
-0.9013660550117493,
-0.4719598591327667,
-0.47124597430229187,
-0.6133376955986023,
-0.17201316356658936,
0.19570456445217133,
1.1568502187728882,
0.4678990840911865,
-1.1264104843139648,
-0.01880965754389763,
-0.3272962272167206,
-0.020187584683299065,
-0.41742587089538574,
-0.2705773711204529,
0.21340405941009521,
-0.31656911969184875,
-0.8155320286750793,
0.5842438340187073,
0.7898454070091248,
0.32757237553596497,
-0.12596777081489563,
0.39333871006965637,
-0.09897258132696152,
0.17901521921157837,
0.42437243461608887,
0.23780877888202667,
-0.18050901591777802,
-0.12614840269088745,
0.009006017819046974,
0.06632870435714722,
0.027974264696240425,
0.872087299823761,
-0.7926868796348572,
0.16438227891921997,
0.27769193053245544,
0.6830920577049255,
0.4387817680835724,
-0.016743922606110573,
0.786350429058075,
-0.9866119623184204,
-0.1613723337650299,
0.16206176578998566,
0.6104901432991028,
0.4898838698863983,
-0.2895425260066986,
0.9678830504417419,
0.24843627214431763,
-0.29486629366874695,
-1.0765893459320068,
-0.03244888409972191,
-0.7524995803833008,
0.006174985319375992,
0.3634553849697113,
-0.2569209337234497,
-0.09902682155370712,
0.022348368540406227,
0.2182682454586029,
0.10120730847120285,
-0.43606874346733093,
0.7049193978309631,
0.5207263827323914,
-0.11562758684158325,
-0.19782663881778717,
-0.3300614655017853,
0.31290125846862793,
0.15535219013690948,
-1.2977688312530518,
0.23151345551013947,
0.5465732216835022,
0.13238216936588287,
0.14724668860435486,
0.7761938571929932,
-0.03642749413847923,
0.09882991760969162,
0.21492193639278412,
0.12962272763252258,
-0.16545222699642181,
-0.3949114978313446,
-0.015991784632205963,
0.2446744740009308,
-0.3067307472229004,
-0.08698126673698425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05063v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05063v1
|
Are Large Language Models More Empathetic than Humans?
| 2024-06-07T16:33:43 | 2024-06-07T16:33:43 |
Anuradha Welivita, Pearl Pu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the emergence of large language models (LLMs), investigating if they can
surpass humans in areas such as emotion recognition and empathetic responding
has become a focal point of research. This paper presents a comprehensive study
exploring the empathetic responding capabilities of four state-of-the-art LLMs:
GPT-4, LLaMA-2-70B-Chat, Gemini-1.0-Pro, and Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct in
comparison to a human baseline. We engaged 1,000 participants in a
between-subjects user study, assessing the empathetic quality of responses
generated by humans and the four LLMs to 2,000 emotional dialogue prompts
meticulously selected to cover a broad spectrum of 32 distinct positive and
negative emotions. Our findings reveal a statistically significant superiority
of the empathetic responding capability of LLMs over humans. GPT-4 emerged as
the most empathetic, marking approximately 31% increase in responses rated as
"Good" compared to the human benchmark. It was followed by LLaMA-2,
Mixtral-8x7B, and Gemini-Pro, which showed increases of approximately 24%, 21%,
and 10% in "Good" ratings, respectively. We further analyzed the response
ratings at a finer granularity and discovered that some LLMs are significantly
better at responding to specific emotions compared to others. The suggested
evaluation framework offers a scalable and adaptable approach for assessing the
empathy of new LLMs, avoiding the need to replicate this study's findings in
future research.
|
[
-0.5853731036186218,
-0.7242441177368164,
0.7382075190544128,
0.32750651240348816,
0.06978470087051392,
0.1883508265018463,
-0.5623807311058044,
-0.6125301122665405,
0.24139367043972015,
0.019264984875917435,
-0.4502878189086914,
-0.2438240796327591,
-0.685814380645752,
0.49591243267059326,
-0.29776760935783386,
0.6061899065971375,
0.0019025481306016445,
-0.016610782593488693,
0.06431153416633606,
-0.19044971466064453,
-0.03237322345376015,
-0.9752951264381409,
-0.739888608455658,
-0.7343100905418396,
0.9376124739646912,
0.11182565987110138,
0.5010873675346375,
0.060979317873716354,
0.5713738203048706,
0.3163452744483948,
-0.30264317989349365,
-0.2385759800672531,
-0.460299015045166,
0.08621735125780106,
-0.12061765789985657,
-0.33277204632759094,
-0.947215735912323,
0.11563761532306671,
0.11442233622074127,
0.18983770906925201,
-0.20471061766147614,
0.15733954310417175,
0.027137912809848785,
0.521879255771637,
-0.3144822120666504,
-0.07178495824337006,
-0.32031217217445374,
0.2948800325393677,
0.15801572799682617,
-0.29516783356666565,
-0.4714575707912445,
-0.277111679315567,
0.16555407643318176,
-0.41762518882751465,
-0.342466801404953,
0.17500074207782745,
0.34163448214530945,
0.11444316804409027,
-0.5658000111579895,
-0.436580628156662,
-0.3113279640674591,
0.8104381561279297,
-0.8544515371322632,
0.3023126423358917,
0.38135504722595215,
0.1316131353378296,
0.11954829841852188,
-0.4291839599609375,
-0.6342036128044128,
-0.5013604760169983,
0.23919951915740967,
0.28444528579711914,
-0.5250447392463684,
0.08705338835716248,
0.38556233048439026,
0.23563577234745026,
-0.5795484185218811,
0.5019211769104004,
0.05903377756476402,
-0.16718831658363342,
0.6657806038856506,
0.47041159868240356,
0.38538146018981934,
-0.0071943821385502815,
0.03502124920487404,
-0.05028008669614792,
-0.5335185527801514,
-0.03556748852133751,
0.34586524963378906,
0.024157535284757614,
-0.28871098160743713,
0.5775042176246643,
0.08743226528167725,
0.4742894470691681,
0.213482066988945,
-0.12094011157751083,
0.10634924471378326,
0.036625936627388,
-0.3231271207332611,
-0.05786523595452309,
0.7738518714904785,
0.7970848083496094,
0.6830024719238281,
0.07253224402666092,
-0.12009298801422119,
0.22213929891586304,
0.3141994774341583,
-0.9775882363319397,
0.04519893229007721,
0.32520997524261475,
-0.6083753108978271,
-0.1270463615655899,
-0.3829723000526428,
-0.6612206101417542,
-0.6591501832008362,
-0.2613230049610138,
0.1706950068473816,
-0.2883463501930237,
-0.4562514126300812,
-0.009640374220907688,
0.1932060569524765,
0.6075237393379211,
0.39075639843940735,
-0.8722265362739563,
0.3862059712409973,
0.8308660984039307,
0.9390342831611633,
-0.11026106029748917,
-0.33930671215057373,
-0.3530060648918152,
-0.29347363114356995,
-0.2644702196121216,
0.6887121796607971,
-0.7741448879241943,
-0.44097188115119934,
-0.21722635626792908,
-0.2425864189863205,
0.09562361240386963,
-0.3844660818576813,
0.7158656716346741,
-0.13003608584403992,
0.05103379487991333,
-0.613635241985321,
-0.5173299908638,
-0.05802939087152481,
0.680753231048584,
-0.410596638917923,
0.4655933976173401,
0.341757208108902,
-0.931705117225647,
0.033875949680805206,
-0.5259813070297241,
-0.24747663736343384,
-0.2741958200931549,
-0.013844749890267849,
-0.04687555879354477,
0.27508628368377686,
-0.15288978815078735,
0.7923790216445923,
-0.6666792035102844,
0.03261472284793854,
-0.7374464273452759,
-0.22399015724658966,
0.5351834893226624,
-0.1993083655834198,
0.18250055611133575,
0.1932370364665985,
-0.327670693397522,
0.03486168384552002,
-0.37848150730133057,
-0.019123518839478493,
0.09931717067956924,
-0.44922181963920593,
-0.13106276094913483,
-0.24468351900577545,
0.08675466477870941,
0.648177444934845,
-0.07998666167259216,
-0.8778327703475952,
-0.06665338575839996,
-0.25726431608200073,
0.6913602352142334,
0.95233553647995,
-0.34362778067588806,
0.4134501814842224,
-0.25134947896003723,
0.6890559792518616,
-0.04301062598824501,
0.17046010494232178,
-0.10854154825210571,
-0.2828509509563446,
-0.5291664600372314,
-0.42159098386764526,
-0.37521475553512573,
0.30501195788383484,
-0.03319590166211128,
0.42991364002227783,
-0.08106885850429535,
-0.6656448841094971,
-0.5512431263923645,
-0.06368928402662277,
0.5646955966949463,
0.3697948157787323,
0.051481008529663086,
-0.5122976899147034,
-0.3441661298274994,
-0.8956657648086548,
-0.5005572438240051,
-0.1825266182422638,
-0.0896310955286026,
0.7404077053070068,
0.24258238077163696,
-0.374957412481308,
0.44803720712661743,
-0.2507745325565338,
0.03744973987340927,
-0.22125235199928284,
-0.14067253470420837,
0.04015429690480232,
-0.11762029677629471,
0.43979379534721375,
-0.5514855980873108,
-0.7727367877960205,
0.2153438925743103,
-0.6568882465362549,
-0.23381005227565765,
0.17124491930007935,
0.060670703649520874,
0.41688236594200134,
0.16015872359275818,
-0.6884216666221619,
0.12879863381385803,
0.8571298718452454,
-0.6270201802253723,
0.15673576295375824,
-0.04528290033340454,
0.29270461201667786,
-1.026198148727417,
0.224833145737648,
0.20712541043758392,
-0.01581396907567978,
-0.6953507661819458,
-0.3074963688850403,
0.046509526669979095,
0.24575531482696533,
-0.480896919965744,
0.6716511249542236,
-0.4027133285999298,
-0.3987646996974945,
-0.08096238970756531,
0.33299416303634644,
-0.2095581591129303,
0.3165355324745178,
-0.01403812039643526,
0.38356301188468933,
0.6577502489089966,
-0.37296241521835327,
0.6633993983268738,
0.4410088360309601,
-0.109283447265625,
0.7378260493278503,
-0.8107109665870667,
0.2984657883644104,
-0.11682414263486862,
0.5346381664276123,
-0.9545623660087585,
-0.4475755989551544,
0.13608361780643463,
-0.49830353260040283,
0.1795666366815567,
0.359144926071167,
-0.39108017086982727,
-0.47190529108047485,
-0.38839346170425415,
0.19357918202877045,
0.719792902469635,
-0.3607553541660309,
0.9278651475906372,
0.14104023575782776,
-0.538370668888092,
-0.11237744987010956,
-0.8785058856010437,
0.21467040479183197,
-0.4103067219257355,
-0.5152556896209717,
-0.29194211959838867,
-0.3383501172065735,
-0.5897547602653503,
-0.3973650336265564,
0.028376631438732147,
0.1299765706062317,
0.0999935045838356,
0.3384370803833008,
-0.03264981508255005,
0.06917751580476761,
0.024263300001621246,
-0.2673782706260681,
-0.13864216208457947,
0.17256057262420654,
0.5652952194213867,
0.784504234790802,
-0.3799028992652893,
-0.4094817638397217,
-0.5707432627677917,
0.17925451695919037,
0.7989640831947327,
-0.1295372098684311,
0.5991284251213074,
0.7336809635162354,
-0.12604251503944397,
0.2686063051223755,
-0.5050602555274963,
-0.30507901310920715,
-0.41855379939079285,
0.33487266302108765,
-0.4210716187953949,
-1.136925458908081,
0.5487580299377441,
0.08166935294866562,
-0.058004628866910934,
0.0836329236626625,
1.0408039093017578,
0.11818157136440277,
1.2055652141571045,
0.3722059428691864,
-0.4045614004135132,
0.35481390357017517,
0.3331257402896881,
0.4944525957107544,
-1.2564297914505005,
-0.19688449800014496,
-0.3624570667743683,
-0.38173866271972656,
-0.7604439854621887,
-0.1956646591424942,
0.15577591955661774,
-0.5885028839111328,
-0.6228525042533875,
-0.03597650304436684,
-0.3148322105407715,
0.13993196189403534,
-0.08913978189229965,
0.019563980400562286,
0.16019447147846222,
-0.3627046048641205,
0.3526743948459625,
-0.06770716607570648,
-0.4278636574745178,
-0.6720797419548035,
1.0430712699890137,
0.7408913969993591,
1.0085487365722656,
0.3813377618789673,
0.6679262518882751,
0.09461761265993118,
0.9413668513298035,
-0.9392341375350952,
0.5245487689971924,
0.037116073071956635,
-0.5925641059875488,
-0.20061954855918884,
-0.4956779181957245,
-0.7467018365859985,
0.18033266067504883,
-0.20642907917499542,
-1.013942003250122,
-0.2099989950656891,
0.24843396246433258,
-0.30404746532440186,
0.23337554931640625,
-0.7542846202850342,
0.452009379863739,
-0.3329673707485199,
-0.26017042994499207,
-0.09096220880746841,
-0.7324978709220886,
0.368110716342926,
-0.44475802779197693,
0.274750292301178,
-0.39865079522132874,
-0.16710996627807617,
0.4240513741970062,
0.16954165697097778,
0.8770737051963806,
-0.03526044636964798,
-0.49954748153686523,
-0.07684443891048431,
0.30812519788742065,
0.4673391878604889,
-0.31664469838142395,
-0.3240152597427368,
-0.10569072514772415,
-0.30498987436294556,
-0.21286684274673462,
-0.5390795469284058,
0.8996846079826355,
-0.9215660095214844,
-0.32727906107902527,
-0.4311198592185974,
-0.33026352524757385,
-0.18567173182964325,
-0.13327716290950775,
0.03601904213428497,
0.2889534533023834,
-0.4295247793197632,
0.20906123518943787,
0.5509597063064575,
-0.6588022112846375,
0.45698484778404236,
0.6995624899864197,
-0.2853943109512329,
-0.30839529633522034,
0.6034612655639648,
-0.3054848313331604,
0.5538820624351501,
0.440287321805954,
0.4672674834728241,
-0.3031114339828491,
0.041573889553546906,
-0.06343408674001694,
0.4532662630081177,
-0.4684394896030426,
-0.16458572447299957,
-0.8106291890144348,
0.15360471606254578,
-0.3665353059768677,
-0.3873521387577057,
-0.3642737865447998,
-0.10060891509056091,
-0.1392570286989212,
-0.21014992892742157,
0.4194788336753845,
0.9970291256904602,
0.00703119533136487,
0.0884818434715271,
-0.8191530108451843,
0.14397701621055603,
0.35396450757980347,
0.4969629645347595,
0.3733825087547302,
-0.80983567237854,
0.15749675035476685,
-0.1619269698858261,
-0.2204098254442215,
-0.7510942220687866,
0.7035143971443176,
0.32987678050994873,
0.2624550461769104,
0.5310706496238708,
-0.16938866674900055,
0.42260560393333435,
-0.5034068822860718,
0.7584826946258545,
0.3955690264701843,
-1.063858985900879,
0.033946555107831955,
-0.5713263154029846,
0.12702509760856628,
0.07404492795467377,
0.5232899188995361,
-0.7690953016281128,
-0.36159542202949524,
-0.6239142417907715,
-0.7071507573127747,
0.6849893927574158,
0.20468337833881378,
0.41797935962677,
-0.021345917135477066,
0.4199990928173065,
0.025003112852573395,
0.08157025277614594,
-0.60463547706604,
-0.0009588481625542045,
0.028389915823936462,
-0.34110504388809204,
-0.5793637633323669,
-0.2800857722759247,
-0.11396682262420654,
0.06482212990522385,
0.1446075737476349,
-0.10220139473676682,
0.4808986783027649,
0.15073737502098083,
0.08072713017463684,
-0.38282209634780884,
0.45459505915641785,
0.4575086534023285,
0.30947136878967285,
-0.238521546125412,
0.1767958253622055,
0.3271380066871643,
-0.19191724061965942,
0.2292553335428238,
-0.2055952101945877,
0.6844092011451721,
-0.677689790725708,
0.6775802373886108,
0.6209056973457336,
0.21886397898197174,
-0.9098356366157532,
0.7376435399055481,
-0.296254426240921,
-0.10177648812532425,
-0.16550102829933167,
-0.0638057142496109,
0.44591906666755676,
0.598493754863739,
-0.13923808932304382,
-0.41707703471183777,
0.2579363286495209,
-0.8472705483436584,
-0.09603536128997803,
0.25771617889404297,
-0.22146935760974884,
-0.7024805545806885,
0.34167394042015076,
0.40228426456451416,
-0.5677041411399841,
0.561530351638794,
0.12718595564365387,
-0.7073631286621094,
0.4038797616958618,
0.582436203956604,
0.8912309408187866,
-0.4106084406375885,
0.17004479467868805,
0.30163267254829407,
0.002938350895419717,
-0.06530740112066269,
0.3979800045490265,
0.07456447929143906,
-0.9143532514572144,
-0.17291440069675446,
-0.6108677387237549,
-0.7278146147727966,
-0.28115302324295044,
-0.9460299611091614,
-0.36989977955818176,
-0.5669875741004944,
-0.4539168179035187,
-0.005100444424897432,
0.045637983828783035,
-0.855679988861084,
0.25962772965431213,
0.414961576461792,
0.9211457967758179,
-0.9609068632125854,
0.5219590663909912,
0.8773109316825867,
-0.15517555177211761,
-0.8623034358024597,
-0.024837685748934746,
0.1234818622469902,
-0.9207887649536133,
0.625304102897644,
0.41115131974220276,
-0.0848688930273056,
0.07685425132513046,
-0.275747686624527,
-0.4801747798919678,
1.1957519054412842,
0.33696573972702026,
-0.6241835355758667,
0.2124568074941635,
-0.09390618652105331,
0.98895263671875,
-0.3869476914405823,
0.7496194243431091,
0.8892912864685059,
0.5985143780708313,
-0.12339714169502258,
-1.1425031423568726,
0.24596761167049408,
-0.3072856366634369,
-0.005469331052154303,
0.26486343145370483,
-1.2416365146636963,
0.7238354086875916,
-0.25570839643478394,
0.08291827887296677,
0.23270021378993988,
0.13272477686405182,
0.4931531548500061,
0.2926666736602783,
0.38816723227500916,
0.47901785373687744,
0.532371997833252,
-0.023621506989002228,
1.314578652381897,
-0.21581418812274933,
0.22444623708724976,
0.7316564917564392,
-0.7151439189910889,
1.0744112730026245,
0.5679360628128052,
-0.2303691953420639,
0.18483498692512512,
0.7320966720581055,
0.413612961769104,
0.04953376576304436,
0.4117932915687561,
-0.3501138985157013,
-0.30952051281929016,
-0.15777437388896942,
0.010818751528859138,
0.42958077788352966,
0.2147030383348465,
-0.4090360999107361,
0.14545154571533203,
-0.02348095178604126,
0.252287894487381,
-0.07057736068964005,
-0.3447099030017853,
0.8012138605117798,
0.571441113948822,
-0.4762434959411621,
0.396738201379776,
-0.13802769780158997,
0.7814196944236755,
-0.4662419855594635,
0.2804604172706604,
-0.468233585357666,
0.12368365377187729,
-0.31949377059936523,
-1.1076568365097046,
-0.05901085585355759,
0.4048720598220825,
0.1074783205986023,
-0.21053095161914825,
0.5717690587043762,
-0.2451930046081543,
0.07005362212657928,
0.8055055141448975,
0.42740699648857117,
0.34328439831733704,
-0.13574954867362976,
-0.4969664216041565,
0.413291871547699,
-0.11104746907949448,
-0.8319112062454224,
0.5399800539016724,
0.5686355829238892,
0.15879108011722565,
1.0934500694274902,
0.40291494131088257,
0.041000548750162125,
-0.054470181465148926,
0.2567499577999115,
1.0324616432189941,
-0.9803571701049805,
-0.04367484897375107,
-0.9407240152359009,
0.4029523730278015,
0.0702853873372078,
-0.2905789315700531,
0.6810668110847473,
-0.0006887656054459512,
0.3621722459793091,
0.09024040400981903,
0.7367253303527832,
-0.10522767901420593,
0.45422857999801636,
-0.19551622867584229,
0.26897040009498596,
-0.4150916039943695,
-0.0047523328103125095,
-0.6250312924385071,
-1.069150686264038,
-0.3038405179977417,
0.6670691967010498,
-0.45491522550582886,
0.39943650364875793,
0.5307910442352295,
0.7810043692588806,
0.10945707559585571,
0.039765920490026474,
0.7181653380393982,
0.5275409817695618,
0.46919798851013184,
0.8941646814346313,
1.251419186592102,
0.14187824726104736,
0.09415262192487717,
0.27010712027549744,
-0.3410694897174835,
-0.24864977598190308,
-0.8656758666038513,
-0.97176593542099,
-0.0978192538022995,
0.1598212867975235,
-0.19405871629714966,
-0.20122642815113068,
1.179602026939392,
0.23378188908100128,
-0.41062918305397034,
-0.12808780372142792,
0.19294217228889465,
-0.4584504961967468,
0.45765361189842224,
-0.16167451441287994,
0.20477932691574097,
0.0762091800570488,
-0.6566064357757568,
-0.11505939811468124,
0.5754365921020508,
0.05857132002711296,
-0.23077276349067688,
-0.5898341536521912,
0.3858647048473358,
0.3220471441745758,
1.0295732021331787,
0.09345024824142456,
-0.7429181337356567,
-0.466864675283432,
0.2846033573150635,
-0.10629425197839737,
-0.08330243825912476,
0.7411587238311768,
-0.07310459762811661,
0.33038172125816345,
0.21317312121391296,
0.5217980742454529,
0.18744204938411713,
0.11172036826610565,
0.6708401441574097,
-0.13197949528694153,
-0.07855051010847092,
0.2032221257686615,
0.4151610732078552,
0.6412116885185242,
-0.29960158467292786,
0.42272716760635376,
-0.3124307096004486,
-0.980099081993103,
-0.6701676845550537,
0.41560491919517517,
-1.1668190956115723,
0.2716047465801239,
1.6066534519195557,
-0.3562159538269043,
-0.0855545774102211,
0.332298219203949,
-0.5331597328186035,
0.13533848524093628,
-0.6642850041389465,
0.6797693371772766,
0.7128130793571472,
-0.5149290561676025,
-0.20710507035255432,
-0.2555639147758484,
0.18412351608276367,
0.2979041039943695,
-0.9858086705207825,
0.16869884729385376,
0.5508424639701843,
0.3905980587005615,
-0.16790921986103058,
0.7505972981452942,
-0.08117642253637314,
0.009763862937688828,
-0.1491171270608902,
0.18363997340202332,
0.28423044085502625,
0.05173491686582565,
-0.5932485461235046,
-0.17328771948814392,
0.46823573112487793,
0.4784529507160187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05039v1
|
Bootstrapping Referring Multi-Object Tracking
| 2024-06-07T16:02:10 | 2024-06-07T16:02:10 |
Yani Zhang, Dongming Wu, Wencheng Han, Xingping Dong
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Referring multi-object tracking (RMOT) aims at detecting and tracking
multiple objects following human instruction represented by a natural language
expression. Existing RMOT benchmarks are usually formulated through manual
annotations, integrated with static regulations. This approach results in a
dearth of notable diversity and a constrained scope of implementation. In this
work, our key idea is to bootstrap the task of referring multi-object tracking
by introducing discriminative language words as much as possible. In specific,
we first develop Refer-KITTI into a large-scale dataset, named Refer-KITTI-V2.
It starts with 2,719 manual annotations, addressing the issue of class
imbalance and introducing more keywords to make it closer to real-world
scenarios compared to Refer-KITTI. They are further expanded to a total of
9,758 annotations by prompting large language models, which create 617
different words, surpassing previous RMOT benchmarks. In addition, the
end-to-end framework in RMOT is also bootstrapped by a simple yet elegant
temporal advancement strategy, which achieves better performance than previous
approaches. The source code and dataset is available at
https://github.com/zyn213/TempRMOT.
|
[
-0.4364870488643646,
-0.21469908952713013,
0.3153562843799591,
0.029349809512495995,
-0.4862726926803589,
0.22640669345855713,
-0.16777530312538147,
-0.6995673179626465,
0.06793506443500519,
0.0204677302390337,
-0.6950631737709045,
-0.539734959602356,
-0.4010618329048157,
0.21520809829235077,
-0.3319198489189148,
1.1076061725616455,
0.2692245841026306,
-0.15794707834720612,
0.20556522905826569,
-0.46120762825012207,
-0.7777265906333923,
-0.4969530403614044,
-0.2191169261932373,
-0.28025907278060913,
0.6613998413085938,
0.5516164898872375,
0.6247440576553345,
0.8588826656341553,
0.7305918335914612,
0.2537565231323242,
0.3502397835254669,
0.04778232425451279,
0.015308926813304424,
0.44799622893333435,
-0.0866829976439476,
-0.41579174995422363,
-0.2679070234298706,
-0.1543351113796234,
0.6888158321380615,
0.09880374372005463,
-0.459807425737381,
0.47957926988601685,
-0.24473881721496582,
0.6200742721557617,
-0.9565949440002441,
0.25713658332824707,
-0.59380704164505,
-0.36177492141723633,
-0.443829745054245,
-0.322934627532959,
-0.339826762676239,
-0.0020363200455904007,
-0.049380600452423096,
-0.801798403263092,
0.5621739029884338,
0.4101862609386444,
0.6478614807128906,
0.2528022527694702,
-0.08793316036462784,
-0.327541321516037,
-0.4411274790763855,
0.9673010110855103,
-0.37452855706214905,
0.41280367970466614,
0.6428943872451782,
0.6833958625793457,
0.3072900176048279,
-0.5380937457084656,
-0.3564392924308777,
-0.1981973648071289,
-0.14017656445503235,
-0.2745961546897888,
0.11747542023658752,
-0.42182740569114685,
0.09752719104290009,
-0.05129976198077202,
-0.5806981325149536,
-0.10321523249149323,
-0.39149755239486694,
-0.1279693990945816,
0.441371351480484,
0.034287743270397186,
-0.13297249376773834,
-0.05065355449914932,
-0.6282968521118164,
-0.2947947680950165,
-0.3780878782272339,
-0.49389687180519104,
0.20848563313484192,
0.5798155665397644,
-0.08541896194219589,
0.40816086530685425,
-0.5859351754188538,
0.7663077116012573,
-0.01881074346601963,
-0.10492700338363647,
0.5954369902610779,
-0.5675399899482727,
-0.11447638273239136,
0.0962463915348053,
0.7604479789733887,
0.49305564165115356,
0.38056889176368713,
-0.23491956293582916,
-0.22972120344638824,
0.12826412916183472,
0.26543283462524414,
-0.6933654546737671,
-0.26408952474594116,
0.20025388896465302,
-0.030858861282467842,
-0.40923893451690674,
0.2026951014995575,
-1.024514079093933,
-0.43765801191329956,
-0.327087938785553,
0.2519657015800476,
-0.6447857022285461,
-0.47363755106925964,
0.16581732034683228,
-0.08498339354991913,
0.30514460802078247,
0.4379595220088959,
-0.7180797457695007,
0.06383843719959259,
0.8363761901855469,
1.0688726902008057,
0.02087930403649807,
-0.43864914774894714,
-0.6775822639465332,
0.48495763540267944,
-0.2550862729549408,
1.224186897277832,
-0.8829772472381592,
-0.03549681976437569,
0.1101110428571701,
0.22345997393131256,
0.07778671383857727,
-0.6378476619720459,
0.141058549284935,
-0.2937205731868744,
0.40854495763778687,
-0.26902028918266296,
-0.06405491381883621,
-0.2608506381511688,
0.5132870078086853,
-0.42542487382888794,
1.4029083251953125,
0.010449130088090897,
-0.6824713349342346,
0.6806706786155701,
-0.701556921005249,
-0.49491429328918457,
0.29550015926361084,
-0.02388695254921913,
-0.555400013923645,
-0.11861179023981094,
0.15653376281261444,
0.7356411814689636,
-0.5561415553092957,
0.3564680516719818,
-0.17128418385982513,
-0.29116591811180115,
0.053580835461616516,
0.03721102699637413,
0.4087570011615753,
0.2606489658355713,
-0.3088301718235016,
0.30852049589157104,
-0.9319678544998169,
-0.12747693061828613,
0.06058230251073837,
-0.09569836407899857,
-0.5614430904388428,
-0.0034300878178328276,
0.26447102427482605,
0.3838892877101898,
-0.03655194118618965,
-0.42263180017471313,
0.1868455857038498,
0.2502317428588867,
0.19438043236732483,
0.7728338241577148,
-0.08657854795455933,
0.13952092826366425,
-0.5152907371520996,
0.5972093939781189,
-0.061220455914735794,
-0.003011543769389391,
-0.6459385752677917,
-0.4897835850715637,
-0.3607921302318573,
-0.45398765802383423,
0.1958107203245163,
0.23340599238872528,
-0.7520024180412292,
0.17309452593326569,
-0.4340956509113312,
-0.37367793917655945,
-0.522773265838623,
-0.058568380773067474,
0.4057895839214325,
0.25855469703674316,
0.6158702969551086,
-0.1183927059173584,
-0.2212585061788559,
-0.9406693577766418,
0.2539811134338379,
-0.41926273703575134,
-0.2875937819480896,
-0.3768751621246338,
0.60214763879776,
0.2672991454601288,
0.7083902359008789,
-0.5500941276550293,
-0.4740394353866577,
0.2494262307882309,
0.2943689823150635,
-0.3990790843963623,
0.6607232689857483,
0.5369402170181274,
-0.7235898971557617,
-0.43015357851982117,
0.32069072127342224,
-0.5591651797294617,
-0.11849135905504227,
-0.24862217903137207,
-0.4317721426486969,
-0.251773864030838,
0.46365225315093994,
-0.4734894037246704,
0.25478047132492065,
0.2415369302034378,
-0.27758967876434326,
0.5333045125007629,
0.24486379325389862,
0.38385504484176636,
-1.275246262550354,
0.28924044966697693,
0.11801140755414963,
-0.3277888298034668,
-0.48564058542251587,
0.25700312852859497,
0.2650652229785919,
0.1584351509809494,
-0.6021578311920166,
0.30366575717926025,
-0.7272024750709534,
0.025367822498083115,
-0.3848359286785126,
0.26767444610595703,
-0.31825029850006104,
0.5630078911781311,
0.1104523316025734,
0.8577612042427063,
0.6171734929084778,
-0.7242665886878967,
0.6258072257041931,
0.0062614013440907,
-0.24954794347286224,
1.243095874786377,
-0.2884412705898285,
0.044542934745550156,
-0.2383156269788742,
0.09475758671760559,
-1.0743021965026855,
-0.14470872282981873,
0.5540574193000793,
-0.49358242750167847,
0.4381878972053528,
-0.1430567353963852,
-0.9403705596923828,
-0.2307939976453781,
-0.6815049648284912,
0.38274726271629333,
0.28448033332824707,
-0.3758227229118347,
0.4314369559288025,
0.2149476557970047,
0.10189331322908401,
-0.7865724563598633,
-0.44908633828163147,
0.006159068085253239,
-0.39944764971733093,
0.004222827032208443,
0.15225738286972046,
-0.06469065696001053,
-0.043842386454343796,
-0.06093813478946686,
-0.3631885051727295,
-0.1537046879529953,
-0.11660390347242355,
0.20047526061534882,
0.2046896368265152,
-0.27590975165367126,
0.5274352431297302,
-0.31076380610466003,
-0.2825523316860199,
-0.0744912251830101,
-0.11610852181911469,
0.8033691644668579,
0.11160031706094742,
-0.5037531852722168,
-0.656473696231842,
0.20359256863594055,
0.7314906120300293,
-0.31551381945610046,
0.5107647776603699,
0.8846768140792847,
-0.4052756130695343,
-0.02600177936255932,
-0.8594204187393188,
-0.19681915640830994,
-0.4418853521347046,
0.514264702796936,
-0.5525351166725159,
-0.3403657376766205,
0.3654974400997162,
-0.008274473249912262,
0.38455161452293396,
0.34886056184768677,
0.5835692286491394,
0.055019255727529526,
0.27387750148773193,
0.5571001172065735,
-0.052103519439697266,
0.5940506458282471,
0.23297585546970367,
-0.448119193315506,
-0.9771115779876709,
-0.5229594707489014,
-0.8154952526092529,
-0.36886048316955566,
-0.4307118356227875,
-0.7972580194473267,
-0.3625643253326416,
-0.1508275866508484,
-0.24394139647483826,
0.8244478702545166,
-0.8130976557731628,
0.5154241323471069,
0.6870348453521729,
0.04525229334831238,
0.5444939732551575,
-0.011188928969204426,
0.09538577497005463,
0.2047363668680191,
-0.589553952217102,
-0.32409152388572693,
1.3250203132629395,
0.17672592401504517,
0.7867194414138794,
0.1542319506406784,
0.46886512637138367,
0.21233531832695007,
0.8772994875907898,
-0.7357895970344543,
0.7288987636566162,
0.44543322920799255,
-0.9568597674369812,
-0.12783490121364594,
-0.12274840474128723,
-0.7688513994216919,
0.5942179560661316,
-0.05455481633543968,
-0.6502366662025452,
0.10389444977045059,
0.053112126886844635,
-0.04881042242050171,
0.26978012919425964,
-0.6225681900978088,
0.5314335823059082,
-0.0016235923394560814,
-0.44861769676208496,
-0.2564258277416229,
-1.0123236179351807,
0.4262853264808655,
-0.4081059396266937,
0.21631789207458496,
-0.6503874659538269,
-0.44845202565193176,
1.0193777084350586,
-0.35553091764450073,
0.9029795527458191,
-0.0023229969665408134,
-0.028152858838438988,
0.3835607171058655,
-0.013350504450500011,
0.30388227105140686,
-0.20992308855056763,
0.11055754125118256,
0.14654751121997833,
0.26972725987434387,
-0.4464797377586365,
-0.19508635997772217,
0.5208860039710999,
-0.1704951971769333,
-0.13451555371284485,
-0.8931790590286255,
-0.6037072539329529,
-0.1797923743724823,
0.22989264130592346,
-0.08993323147296906,
0.10446024686098099,
0.0887216329574585,
0.4491485059261322,
0.11531062424182892,
0.03202177584171295,
0.6842329502105713,
0.8477414846420288,
-0.2721002995967865,
-0.4518113434314728,
0.7986392974853516,
-0.26435989141464233,
0.4579395353794098,
0.6495789289474487,
0.21102668344974518,
-0.35673850774765015,
-0.20251095294952393,
-0.5645353198051453,
0.545267641544342,
-0.6761900782585144,
-0.6933780312538147,
-0.28003621101379395,
0.5547710657119751,
-0.249735489487648,
-0.03561333194375038,
-0.5088402628898621,
-0.26677244901657104,
0.035532474517822266,
0.04403184726834297,
0.5318508148193359,
0.5911487340927124,
0.001520518446341157,
0.6802535057067871,
-0.37517619132995605,
0.4576288163661957,
0.18199646472930908,
0.40045490860939026,
0.01808428205549717,
-0.4015856385231018,
-0.305913507938385,
-0.2602493464946747,
-0.21264274418354034,
-0.8261524438858032,
0.0200287364423275,
-0.026494689285755157,
0.4207344651222229,
0.3795091211795807,
0.09628110378980637,
1.0713863372802734,
-0.6201222538948059,
0.3094012141227722,
0.5918922424316406,
-0.5371797680854797,
0.48515939712524414,
-0.362322062253952,
0.5813114643096924,
0.6547026038169861,
0.3139641582965851,
-0.47263920307159424,
-0.40780529379844666,
-0.3470115661621094,
-0.6988398432731628,
0.9252465963363647,
0.19098524749279022,
-0.08644207566976547,
-0.1234440803527832,
0.06084569916129112,
0.06419546902179718,
0.5534878373146057,
-0.6010404229164124,
-0.4762146770954132,
0.04702572897076607,
-0.20407222211360931,
0.0814739391207695,
-0.08528205007314682,
-0.17584647238254547,
-0.005215644370764494,
0.6463838815689087,
-0.11154703795909882,
0.2147689312696457,
-0.22950756549835205,
-0.06627657264471054,
-0.2214331328868866,
0.2523857057094574,
0.7380029559135437,
0.7498907446861267,
-0.33904582262039185,
0.17222674190998077,
-0.09398817270994186,
-0.6982784271240234,
0.2164333462715149,
0.14965029060840607,
-0.15973837673664093,
0.3449949324131012,
0.3389589488506317,
0.29013219475746155,
0.39797869324684143,
-0.5785956382751465,
0.26726916432380676,
0.39528656005859375,
-0.14673063158988953,
-0.02509623020887375,
-0.3537490963935852,
-0.061311010271310806,
0.08323022723197937,
0.6513360738754272,
0.1500103920698166,
-0.08044378459453583,
-0.4743328094482422,
0.66889888048172,
0.5456358790397644,
-0.2599196434020996,
-0.479307621717453,
0.7176951169967651,
0.16846957802772522,
-0.3417985737323761,
0.18871180713176727,
-0.09904058277606964,
-0.2307032346725464,
0.46833592653274536,
0.5731735825538635,
0.9449659585952759,
-0.6796014308929443,
0.2664787769317627,
0.580674946308136,
0.693942666053772,
-0.5360691547393799,
-0.22786681354045868,
-0.2607274651527405,
-0.3896752595901489,
-0.4288488030433655,
-0.5067493319511414,
-0.27613168954849243,
-0.04976877570152283,
-1.0123623609542847,
0.6203427314758301,
-0.36242881417274475,
-0.19262421131134033,
0.021538423374295235,
-0.4209388494491577,
-0.6822246313095093,
0.008532630279660225,
0.013021357357501984,
0.5018090009689331,
-0.851675271987915,
0.9130422472953796,
0.828466534614563,
-0.5449510216712952,
-0.3159404397010803,
0.21983936429023743,
0.16424335539340973,
-1.0624804496765137,
0.6690226793289185,
0.4861665368080139,
-0.3568125367164612,
-0.05676953122019768,
-0.38015151023864746,
-0.8068103194236755,
1.1628718376159668,
-0.041128624230623245,
-0.6339016556739807,
-0.08004012703895569,
-0.15849824249744415,
0.16754421591758728,
-0.18520374596118927,
0.1677282303571701,
0.395358145236969,
0.46387308835983276,
0.3562341332435608,
-1.1254688501358032,
0.12133492529392242,
0.11809995025396347,
-0.1815018355846405,
0.6468700766563416,
-0.7296057343482971,
0.5319258570671082,
-0.10369008779525757,
-0.47109997272491455,
0.056461676955223083,
0.4668121933937073,
0.3216618299484253,
0.4216669201850891,
0.2930338680744171,
0.42063233256340027,
0.4321995675563812,
-0.10210856050252914,
0.7641569375991821,
-0.2778747081756592,
0.5295272469520569,
1.474312424659729,
-0.3081696927547455,
1.0657868385314941,
0.6321254968643188,
-0.39193204045295715,
0.3839696943759918,
0.38660722970962524,
-0.11285168677568436,
0.5410222411155701,
0.20074334740638733,
-0.2683221697807312,
-0.10352617502212524,
-0.12821516394615173,
-0.534494161605835,
0.1773851066827774,
0.16621731221675873,
-0.142332524061203,
-0.4774518609046936,
0.09682965278625488,
0.07127072662115097,
-0.16351182758808136,
-0.06954493373632431,
0.53870689868927,
-0.4280839264392853,
-0.39575907588005066,
0.4621220827102661,
-0.031581632792949677,
0.8146499991416931,
-0.8331968188285828,
-0.23803545534610748,
-0.0011483924463391304,
0.02925509586930275,
0.01981869526207447,
-0.6059510707855225,
0.033985305577516556,
0.0017366207903251052,
0.2429056167602539,
-0.0912020280957222,
0.19136027991771698,
-0.4780025780200958,
-0.7263987064361572,
-0.03183528408408165,
0.4985647201538086,
0.2264556884765625,
-0.22822940349578857,
-0.6018416881561279,
0.13284695148468018,
-0.04294627532362938,
-0.23426876962184906,
0.3450300097465515,
0.5924400091171265,
-0.2765350937843323,
1.0329159498214722,
0.6349936723709106,
-0.09341678768396378,
0.22238589823246002,
-0.16494768857955933,
0.8125979900360107,
-0.8380785584449768,
-0.2642149031162262,
-0.9522135853767395,
0.6235593557357788,
0.02824723906815052,
-0.41142168641090393,
0.6397020220756531,
0.7639733552932739,
0.9609065055847168,
-0.2270144522190094,
0.38777562975883484,
-0.3341068923473358,
0.6763544082641602,
-0.3496384024620056,
0.20726419985294342,
-0.37520211935043335,
0.3236274719238281,
-0.47763603925704956,
-1.1372395753860474,
-0.7140640616416931,
0.7879087328910828,
0.05598638206720352,
-0.010030968114733696,
1.1212841272354126,
0.6802285313606262,
-0.21101680397987366,
-0.41270965337753296,
0.35146671533584595,
-0.37574103474617004,
0.22847692668437958,
0.4164355397224426,
0.7282328009605408,
-0.5526729226112366,
0.8362975716590881,
-0.45668283104896545,
-0.12568040192127228,
-0.12055102735757828,
-0.9201233386993408,
-0.781829833984375,
-0.6554020047187805,
-0.887872040271759,
-0.12083703279495239,
-0.03427039459347725,
0.8237717151641846,
0.9999720454216003,
-0.8351571559906006,
-0.3953571915626526,
0.1746647208929062,
-0.12639100849628448,
-0.43399471044540405,
-0.259139746427536,
0.2735671103000641,
-0.24930718541145325,
-0.8822495937347412,
0.1436057686805725,
0.36288362741470337,
-0.020650256425142288,
-0.20156213641166687,
0.09140538424253464,
-0.7139129638671875,
-0.5630278587341309,
0.5515087246894836,
0.3013836741447449,
-0.8161782622337341,
-0.3727140724658966,
-0.20344431698322296,
0.16993199288845062,
0.2564204931259155,
0.8413976430892944,
-0.9219852089881897,
0.46731168031692505,
0.017886439338326454,
0.4925338625907898,
0.4277585744857788,
0.5328763127326965,
0.19828806817531586,
-0.9274809956550598,
0.5270130038261414,
0.20639272034168243,
0.05281133949756622,
0.45033228397369385,
0.04954752326011658,
0.8424460887908936,
0.4674094319343567,
-0.28064918518066406,
-1.074963927268982,
0.2182895988225937,
-0.9821913838386536,
-0.28729164600372314,
1.138587236404419,
0.18229445815086365,
0.13258208334445953,
-0.2197909951210022,
-0.15879328548908234,
0.015880312770605087,
-0.6713674068450928,
0.5804654359817505,
0.8284657001495361,
0.034844763576984406,
-0.3054567575454712,
-0.9069055318832397,
0.257906973361969,
0.24519404768943787,
-0.8824498653411865,
0.3654496669769287,
0.7969725728034973,
0.47326186299324036,
0.5104074478149414,
0.6782861351966858,
-0.05159502476453781,
0.16237416863441467,
0.09850391000509262,
0.2653254568576813,
-0.18121792376041412,
-0.47817960381507874,
0.0006217681220732629,
0.29069411754608154,
-0.0032115690410137177,
-1.0821117162704468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05035v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05035v1
|
Scenarios and Approaches for Situated Natural Language Explanations
| 2024-06-07T15:56:32 | 2024-06-07T15:56:32 |
Pengshuo Qiu, Frank Rudzicz, Zining Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) can be used to generate natural language
explanations (NLE) that are adapted to different users' situations. However,
there is yet to be a quantitative evaluation of the extent of such adaptation.
To bridge this gap, we collect a benchmarking dataset, Situation-Based
Explanation. This dataset contains 100 explanandums. Each explanandum is paired
with explanations targeted at three distinct audience types-such as educators,
students, and professionals-enabling us to assess how well the explanations
meet the specific informational needs and contexts of these diverse groups e.g.
students, teachers, and parents. For each "explanandum paired with an audience"
situation, we include a human-written explanation. These allow us to compute
scores that quantify how the LLMs adapt the explanations to the situations. On
an array of pretrained language models with varying sizes, we examine three
categories of prompting methods: rule-based prompting, meta-prompting, and
in-context learning prompting. We find that 1) language models can generate
prompts that result in explanations more precisely aligned with the target
situations, 2) explicitly modeling an "assistant" persona by prompting "You are
a helpful assistant..." is not a necessary prompt technique for situated NLE
tasks, and 3) the in-context learning prompts only can help LLMs learn the
demonstration template but can't improve their inference performance. SBE and
our analysis facilitate future research towards generating situated natural
language explanations.
|
[
-0.5193029046058655,
-1.0405211448669434,
0.8009894490242004,
0.3688361942768097,
-0.08049172163009644,
-0.23379676043987274,
-0.38375142216682434,
-0.15345430374145508,
-0.10840827226638794,
0.16703607141971588,
-0.9454691410064697,
-0.4352971315383911,
-0.13971999287605286,
0.3456721007823944,
-0.13381923735141754,
0.8309040069580078,
-0.12258248031139374,
-0.06502408534288406,
-0.44046613574028015,
0.039867568761110306,
-1.0204927921295166,
-0.20562054216861725,
-0.7234312295913696,
-0.1648501306772232,
0.6141145825386047,
0.7490156292915344,
0.63298100233078,
0.5143724679946899,
0.04887840151786804,
0.3804225027561188,
-0.025678161531686783,
0.04734943062067032,
-0.08798346668481827,
0.057608041912317276,
-0.2565450370311737,
-0.25110018253326416,
-0.24255767464637756,
0.20378519594669342,
0.5801102519035339,
1.0471858978271484,
-0.257768839597702,
-0.0689847320318222,
0.15901608765125275,
0.29192519187927246,
-0.5341345071792603,
-0.30832770466804504,
-0.3037189543247223,
0.2561897337436676,
0.1943381279706955,
-0.4129021167755127,
-0.4922231435775757,
-0.4493252635002136,
0.4517473578453064,
-0.6522305607795715,
0.3581713140010834,
0.2403256744146347,
0.5441669225692749,
0.2838834226131439,
-0.6006642580032349,
-0.37536460161209106,
-0.7491053342819214,
0.7570983171463013,
-0.6677752733230591,
0.1901070922613144,
0.251178503036499,
0.5541983842849731,
-0.40985193848609924,
-0.6688326597213745,
-0.5765947103500366,
-0.10404335707426071,
-0.15452435612678528,
0.21375492215156555,
0.061424002051353455,
-0.06799805909395218,
0.3487837314605713,
0.09217321872711182,
-0.5737444162368774,
0.3413521349430084,
-0.1153232753276825,
-0.1181260347366333,
0.4158482849597931,
0.1619889885187149,
0.2262040376663208,
-0.5345126390457153,
-0.5313608646392822,
-0.061304885894060135,
-0.7380921840667725,
0.2709624469280243,
0.0894259363412857,
0.28840890526771545,
-0.30148935317993164,
0.3538868725299835,
0.01931583322584629,
1.0096944570541382,
0.12635713815689087,
-0.13690628111362457,
-0.1103656217455864,
-0.3175082206726074,
-0.3154968321323395,
0.11137287318706512,
0.5609952807426453,
0.4296073615550995,
0.13595221936702728,
-0.08784344792366028,
-0.04794603958725929,
-0.36716583371162415,
0.3534267842769623,
-0.343967080116272,
-0.09184570610523224,
0.411754310131073,
-0.41548672318458557,
-0.06006375327706337,
-0.22442322969436646,
-1.065922498703003,
-0.6561643481254578,
-0.7007043361663818,
0.554149329662323,
-0.31959840655326843,
-0.12865866720676422,
-0.1732393056154251,
-0.03808027505874634,
0.2812258303165436,
0.45332881808280945,
-0.9867432117462158,
0.3520147204399109,
0.5149481892585754,
0.8174811005592346,
-0.14747066795825958,
-0.3911532759666443,
-0.7572555541992188,
0.22989711165428162,
-0.1526908427476883,
0.9196227788925171,
-0.3512813150882721,
-0.40549901127815247,
0.28801339864730835,
-0.046785641461610794,
-0.21959348022937775,
-0.4690382182598114,
0.5808640718460083,
-0.34758108854293823,
0.7931205034255981,
-0.5027973055839539,
-0.5021417737007141,
-0.3171102702617645,
0.1759091317653656,
-0.6065875887870789,
1.0056228637695312,
-0.16779161989688873,
-0.6354645490646362,
0.6008309125900269,
-0.9920399188995361,
-0.4903697669506073,
-0.07837671041488647,
0.07203881442546844,
-0.0002859867818187922,
0.08023860305547714,
0.6217533349990845,
0.62064528465271,
-0.052810169756412506,
0.5656235814094543,
-0.06558705866336823,
-0.4133323132991791,
0.3281441330909729,
-0.5271770358085632,
0.7847394943237305,
0.15415459871292114,
-0.2745863199234009,
0.2702358663082123,
-0.48412084579467773,
-0.20441307127475739,
0.11699119955301285,
-0.20478598773479462,
-0.27104803919792175,
0.14672715961933136,
-0.1642455756664276,
0.11595362424850464,
0.2054988592863083,
-0.040538717061281204,
-0.1561688482761383,
-0.43112385272979736,
0.25710681080818176,
0.7611143589019775,
0.1770535260438919,
0.5821167826652527,
-0.21852993965148926,
0.7974953055381775,
-0.1884952038526535,
0.10000277310609818,
-0.365972638130188,
-0.22195486724376678,
-0.19413286447525024,
-0.18855084478855133,
0.10547357052564621,
0.39020654559135437,
-0.6180791258811951,
0.1406978815793991,
-0.2704571485519409,
0.06759017705917358,
-0.27466508746147156,
-0.12381760776042938,
0.23660551011562347,
0.7884982824325562,
0.16078250110149384,
0.2502214014530182,
-0.6392620205879211,
-0.6952186822891235,
-0.45374926924705505,
-0.08793140947818756,
-0.2699585556983948,
0.34398379921913147,
0.2748379111289978,
0.2036813497543335,
1.1844635009765625,
-0.1158338189125061,
0.36889398097991943,
-0.300679087638855,
0.24715177714824677,
0.3481595814228058,
0.033182814717292786,
0.34020668268203735,
-0.9635981917381287,
-0.28744298219680786,
-0.34958574175834656,
-0.7101079225540161,
-0.4094538688659668,
-0.3377978503704071,
0.15876242518424988,
0.136484757065773,
0.7103255391120911,
-0.2782759666442871,
0.09469784796237946,
0.633124589920044,
-0.1157045066356659,
0.5659505724906921,
-0.38536545634269714,
0.11132103204727173,
-1.1904418468475342,
-0.06780894100666046,
0.10794926434755325,
-0.2993866801261902,
-0.7484219670295715,
-0.007349020801484585,
-0.26704585552215576,
-0.24226202070713043,
-0.26882749795913696,
0.7634220719337463,
-0.5392479300498962,
-0.3072424829006195,
-0.18253569304943085,
0.7919502854347229,
0.056320853531360626,
0.36488422751426697,
0.30901971459388733,
0.7557485103607178,
0.5150376558303833,
-0.8362648487091064,
0.16764715313911438,
0.22383487224578857,
-0.18014086782932281,
0.7237614989280701,
-0.7441747188568115,
-0.04686823859810829,
-0.12054155766963959,
0.512320339679718,
-1.1343709230422974,
-0.5512423515319824,
0.2692463994026184,
-0.34030115604400635,
0.11841829866170883,
-0.1603141874074936,
-0.39156338572502136,
-0.4111528992652893,
-0.27959853410720825,
0.2220587134361267,
0.16630198061466217,
-0.9337857365608215,
0.6048426628112793,
0.007603902835398912,
-0.24794267117977142,
-0.3791012465953827,
-0.36518293619155884,
0.2752343416213989,
-0.7605434656143188,
-0.5097548961639404,
0.32051360607147217,
-0.21421761810779572,
-0.53020179271698,
-0.11610047519207001,
-0.017559602856636047,
-0.07382099330425262,
0.42985978722572327,
0.45374834537506104,
0.27909648418426514,
-0.3246421813964844,
0.38515111804008484,
-0.01649901643395424,
-0.17597270011901855,
0.2269599437713623,
0.11377565562725067,
0.21385374665260315,
-0.1260940134525299,
-0.384958416223526,
-0.31878724694252014,
0.49099233746528625,
0.1779014617204666,
-0.012720341794192791,
0.9262555837631226,
0.513103723526001,
-0.5106382966041565,
-0.11744680255651474,
-0.37339428067207336,
-0.3046671450138092,
-0.4770062267780304,
-0.0534081906080246,
-0.3526056706905365,
-0.8249827027320862,
0.43924328684806824,
-0.3350728154182434,
0.3500383794307709,
0.2305980771780014,
0.5273693203926086,
-0.22402159869670868,
0.900244414806366,
0.4272281229496002,
0.23603872954845428,
0.44354504346847534,
0.3822995126247406,
0.598706841468811,
-0.7678818702697754,
-0.31626585125923157,
-0.6011160612106323,
-0.15736621618270874,
-0.5439631938934326,
-0.2985157072544098,
0.4661489427089691,
0.1533942073583603,
-0.12349507957696915,
0.20473355054855347,
-0.23386691510677338,
0.46758630871772766,
0.5306611657142639,
-0.2853645086288452,
0.12346182763576508,
-0.0371859073638916,
-0.12337607890367508,
-0.025202173739671707,
-0.9922357201576233,
-0.8119086027145386,
0.5425899624824524,
0.28997716307640076,
0.3220282196998596,
0.32558944821357727,
0.6354327201843262,
0.2018251121044159,
0.47371575236320496,
-0.7737740874290466,
0.4632458984851837,
0.338127076625824,
-0.7085036039352417,
-0.6298506855964661,
-0.2819393575191498,
-1.1390405893325806,
0.25668179988861084,
-0.21020784974098206,
-1.0792568922042847,
-0.035786330699920654,
0.3062517046928406,
-0.605049192905426,
-0.20007966458797455,
-0.9145448207855225,
0.9305010437965393,
-0.06662685424089432,
-0.3533917963504791,
-0.0392797626554966,
-0.6638631224632263,
0.36667928099632263,
-0.006822381634265184,
0.6229445338249207,
0.06028440594673157,
0.07049872726202011,
0.5676243305206299,
-0.376125693321228,
1.004679560661316,
-0.3938460052013397,
-0.2133183628320694,
0.2792925238609314,
0.11641743779182434,
0.3975689709186554,
0.021787278354167938,
-0.3725927174091339,
-0.37230384349823,
-0.07639831304550171,
-0.3860590159893036,
-0.8013090491294861,
0.668910026550293,
-0.3679500222206116,
-0.7318311333656311,
-0.18210706114768982,
-0.4498308598995209,
-0.5301974415779114,
-0.12160367518663406,
0.3169442117214203,
0.8894818425178528,
-0.20743101835250854,
0.09634832292795181,
0.7458384037017822,
-0.6081871390342712,
0.5970028042793274,
0.6538058519363403,
-0.05761158466339111,
-0.014982928521931171,
0.47421199083328247,
-0.27270016074180603,
0.05793203040957451,
0.46602776646614075,
0.5567891597747803,
-0.6790121793746948,
-0.478211909532547,
-0.4221412241458893,
0.07437872141599655,
-0.9134721755981445,
0.17521381378173828,
-0.2770632803440094,
0.2478586584329605,
-0.24011334776878357,
-0.6881800889968872,
0.1664671152830124,
-0.035347145050764084,
-0.2872370779514313,
-0.2742185592651367,
0.5197563171386719,
0.6852313876152039,
-0.13687993586063385,
0.5394512414932251,
-0.5808097124099731,
0.3748091459274292,
0.4159388542175293,
0.18661028146743774,
0.1989714801311493,
-0.655596911907196,
-0.1246924102306366,
0.08818384259939194,
0.05396982654929161,
-0.958902895450592,
0.164286270737648,
0.17037855088710785,
0.7289113402366638,
0.2626346945762634,
0.12075363844633102,
0.8064162731170654,
-0.6053239703178406,
1.036530613899231,
-0.05136437714099884,
-0.9238973259925842,
0.7609325647354126,
-0.5428683161735535,
0.3683444559574127,
0.5002868175506592,
0.31253913044929504,
-0.7364551424980164,
-0.13363991677761078,
-0.5080215930938721,
-0.8408725261688232,
0.6669215559959412,
-0.08434043079614639,
0.13877981901168823,
-0.12635540962219238,
0.5411743521690369,
0.19046880304813385,
-0.00995873473584652,
-0.8118597865104675,
-0.04918815568089485,
-0.1259227842092514,
-0.24393784999847412,
-0.09056656062602997,
-0.12393283098936081,
-0.22442421317100525,
0.015108991414308548,
0.5599876642227173,
-0.3363303542137146,
0.3159349262714386,
0.2665906250476837,
-0.15786100924015045,
-0.1473890095949173,
0.3036087453365326,
0.6975099444389343,
0.9553250074386597,
-0.02102910727262497,
0.25003254413604736,
0.3978683352470398,
0.15340739488601685,
-0.053072236478328705,
0.0715392604470253,
0.24828201532363892,
0.03726500645279884,
0.748574435710907,
0.7409143447875977,
0.5671475529670715,
-0.6652018427848816,
0.42231860756874084,
-0.19849218428134918,
-0.02058625966310501,
-0.31489279866218567,
0.04541885852813721,
0.2650960087776184,
0.0683119148015976,
0.22562268376350403,
-0.546294093132019,
0.23450806736946106,
-0.6509509086608887,
-0.042574018239974976,
0.3003077507019043,
-0.3327181339263916,
-0.2293493151664734,
0.6062301993370056,
0.19466572999954224,
-0.5788138508796692,
0.3334793746471405,
0.15896041691303253,
-0.2539448142051697,
0.5359741449356079,
0.5027868747711182,
0.728061318397522,
-0.2505391538143158,
0.522680938243866,
0.3686467409133911,
0.046015664935112,
0.015025372616946697,
0.009093266911804676,
-0.2784685790538788,
-0.6500994563102722,
-0.6481720209121704,
-0.36237964034080505,
-0.5810228586196899,
0.09847205877304077,
-0.7239857316017151,
0.006278553511947393,
-0.2009875625371933,
0.2594284117221832,
0.32771798968315125,
-0.04534792900085449,
-0.5692819356918335,
0.2371775060892105,
-0.014512648805975914,
1.0398918390274048,
-1.0384173393249512,
0.26602259278297424,
0.890787661075592,
-0.0365598201751709,
-1.0674289464950562,
0.4082174003124237,
0.28201958537101746,
-0.5720986127853394,
0.17132818698883057,
0.14111873507499695,
-0.23437656462192535,
-0.2792339622974396,
-0.5794788599014282,
-0.49252405762672424,
0.9769755005836487,
0.1038210466504097,
-0.33327943086624146,
0.31648358702659607,
-0.2222760170698166,
0.8132396936416626,
-0.221309632062912,
0.11322985589504242,
0.38167375326156616,
0.6379958391189575,
0.040193211287260056,
-0.675172746181488,
0.10634730011224747,
-0.005195203237235546,
-0.026324745267629623,
-0.008818238042294979,
-0.24070927500724792,
0.32207250595092773,
-0.13410061597824097,
-0.07504113763570786,
0.04147752746939659,
0.6107777953147888,
0.446932315826416,
0.5884023904800415,
0.6998752355575562,
-0.024210212752223015,
0.9655861258506775,
-0.0338834784924984,
1.379730463027954,
0.14661914110183716,
-0.1016194149851799,
1.2394487857818604,
-0.3614824116230011,
0.7137173414230347,
0.7173026204109192,
-0.04737304151058197,
0.8094850182533264,
1.1737234592437744,
0.41503623127937317,
0.39551979303359985,
0.04952540993690491,
-0.3813245892524719,
-0.2910110056400299,
-0.3067103922367096,
-0.03743205592036247,
0.30319762229919434,
0.2541973292827606,
-0.11602266877889633,
-0.1820424646139145,
0.19199225306510925,
-0.19790734350681305,
0.3506343364715576,
-0.15861652791500092,
0.7804428935050964,
0.10059700161218643,
-1.147282361984253,
0.4394735097885132,
0.10540562868118286,
-0.011436429806053638,
-0.32814139127731323,
0.022022096440196037,
-0.23328343033790588,
-0.20515546202659607,
-0.06293542683124542,
-0.8699721097946167,
0.20102158188819885,
0.10506686568260193,
-0.22350186109542847,
-0.5350227355957031,
0.5295342803001404,
-0.1397617608308792,
-0.16405870020389557,
-0.04623999074101448,
0.5968540906906128,
0.3181770145893097,
0.21102376282215118,
-0.4863581657409668,
-0.23167191445827484,
-0.14504824578762054,
-0.4396288990974426,
0.19948408007621765,
0.8568163514137268,
-0.37102505564689636,
0.7101204991340637,
0.4112244248390198,
-0.3093034029006958,
-0.03621911257505417,
0.382691353559494,
0.42780354619026184,
-0.5577809810638428,
-0.4098947048187256,
-0.7616904377937317,
0.5962050557136536,
0.0013773663667961955,
-0.35548099875450134,
0.8439197540283203,
0.22823698818683624,
0.24428486824035645,
-0.0353330634534359,
0.5411494374275208,
-0.03726569935679436,
0.6618846654891968,
-0.7960484623908997,
-0.1498384028673172,
-0.6025007963180542,
0.40793177485466003,
-0.2671569585800171,
-0.9179599285125732,
-0.24473974108695984,
0.6807147860527039,
-0.4816919267177582,
0.23225151002407074,
0.6576279997825623,
0.5315321683883667,
-0.12481112778186798,
0.3149276673793793,
0.019705189391970634,
0.05686039477586746,
0.09579431265592575,
0.17665094137191772,
0.8903324007987976,
0.07007531076669693,
0.23282819986343384,
0.10899493098258972,
-0.18787436187267303,
-0.3765079975128174,
-1.499327540397644,
-0.7900407314300537,
-0.5532063245773315,
-0.36159393191337585,
0.08625315129756927,
-0.02783113345503807,
0.8767027258872986,
0.7767811417579651,
-0.647544264793396,
-0.09606024622917175,
-0.14134524762630463,
0.45628100633621216,
-0.3196256756782532,
-0.2740192413330078,
0.3190099596977234,
-0.12968873977661133,
-0.680401623249054,
0.6694738864898682,
0.12652093172073364,
-0.07763998955488205,
-0.24859389662742615,
-0.15879489481449127,
-0.10920857638120651,
0.031369514763355255,
0.5354887247085571,
0.2339974194765091,
-0.7911523580551147,
-0.5180011987686157,
-0.03683529421687126,
0.2417796105146408,
0.02100215293467045,
0.9061097502708435,
-0.805138349533081,
0.43813133239746094,
0.3352567255496979,
0.41527968645095825,
0.14357706904411316,
0.25691282749176025,
0.9504939317703247,
-1.0814188718795776,
-0.06846542656421661,
0.04054940119385719,
0.2684040665626526,
0.5773985385894775,
-0.3464491367340088,
0.3575287461280823,
-0.25059157609939575,
-0.394255131483078,
-0.7158730030059814,
0.14080192148685455,
-0.8555315732955933,
-0.4670464098453522,
1.1743957996368408,
-0.19474351406097412,
-0.01173282228410244,
-0.3418489396572113,
-0.19853894412517548,
0.3426952362060547,
-0.13093847036361694,
0.7999550700187683,
0.8864118456840515,
-0.08048290759325027,
-0.40109503269195557,
-0.9231733083724976,
0.442356139421463,
0.4948693513870239,
-1.0197718143463135,
0.23678095638751984,
0.6561950445175171,
0.19169451296329498,
-0.11779908090829849,
0.3543560802936554,
0.23605546355247498,
0.3214263319969177,
-0.36894822120666504,
-0.18269136548042297,
0.24961113929748535,
-0.42157110571861267,
-0.7340091466903687,
-0.028313813731074333,
0.09348512440919876,
-0.00020330588449724019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06622v1
|
Adversarial Tuning: Defending Against Jailbreak Attacks for LLMs
| 2024-06-07T15:37:15 | 2024-06-07T15:37:15 |
Fan Liu, Zhao Xu, Hao Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
Although safely enhanced Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved
remarkable success in tackling various complex tasks in a zero-shot manner,
they remain susceptible to jailbreak attacks, particularly the unknown
jailbreak attack. To enhance LLMs' generalized defense capabilities, we propose
a two-stage adversarial tuning framework, which generates adversarial prompts
to explore worst-case scenarios by optimizing datasets containing pairs of
adversarial prompts and their safe responses. In the first stage, we introduce
the hierarchical meta-universal adversarial prompt learning to efficiently and
effectively generate token-level adversarial prompts. In the second stage, we
propose the automatic adversarial prompt learning to iteratively refine
semantic-level adversarial prompts, further enhancing LLM's defense
capabilities. We conducted comprehensive experiments on three widely used
jailbreak datasets, comparing our framework with six defense baselines under
five representative attack scenarios. The results underscore the superiority of
our proposed methods. Furthermore, our adversarial tuning framework exhibits
empirical generalizability across various attack strategies and target LLMs,
highlighting its potential as a transferable defense mechanism.
|
[
-0.431283175945282,
-1.1894404888153076,
0.36354172229766846,
0.03045506589114666,
-0.14837920665740967,
0.3352469801902771,
-0.21995384991168976,
-0.0913153812289238,
-0.04315799102187157,
0.5002937316894531,
-0.708484947681427,
-0.5761848092079163,
-0.6401708722114563,
0.0211566723883152,
-0.2702532410621643,
1.311522126197815,
0.353890061378479,
-0.06810828298330307,
0.17157186567783356,
0.06787890940904617,
-0.741874635219574,
-0.3380736708641052,
-1.0279093980789185,
0.11663484573364258,
0.6053011417388916,
0.4169040322303772,
0.7878404855728149,
0.7463802099227905,
0.3908221423625946,
0.272212952375412,
-0.10192988812923431,
0.21733568608760834,
-0.40422600507736206,
0.4324726462364197,
-0.14860038459300995,
-0.517723023891449,
-0.24890677630901337,
-0.04071132466197014,
-0.0021307826973497868,
0.107537180185318,
-0.05382377654314041,
-0.176683247089386,
-0.30898189544677734,
0.8526991605758667,
-0.7331398129463196,
-0.41461682319641113,
-1.2256805896759033,
0.1281430870294571,
-0.2976126968860626,
-0.23527130484580994,
-0.5599520802497864,
-0.31759169697761536,
-0.16468852758407593,
-0.6067258715629578,
0.3861221373081207,
0.2441926747560501,
0.7619819045066833,
0.37925654649734497,
-0.39338889718055725,
-0.3092372417449951,
-0.1914224624633789,
0.1764105260372162,
-0.5242770910263062,
-0.2846994698047638,
0.2823115289211273,
0.3795262277126312,
-0.5948888659477234,
-0.3736606240272522,
-0.06713436543941498,
-0.574980616569519,
0.2858385741710663,
0.021160222589969635,
-0.49556171894073486,
0.19957493245601654,
0.35272496938705444,
0.10388358682394028,
-0.7371785640716553,
0.4494248926639557,
-0.17183133959770203,
-0.275485098361969,
0.48678529262542725,
0.3234112560749054,
0.4939190149307251,
0.11612452566623688,
-0.5204092264175415,
-0.22757112979888916,
-1.134137511253357,
0.15636689960956573,
0.7397308945655823,
0.5189117193222046,
0.028785405680537224,
0.34966328740119934,
0.056366052478551865,
0.8703181147575378,
0.3588063716888428,
0.11843330413103104,
-0.19546742737293243,
-0.04047912731766701,
-0.1415828913450241,
0.12349389493465424,
0.8418919444084167,
0.3944064974784851,
0.3772861957550049,
-0.5286418199539185,
-0.1286538690328598,
0.04340948909521103,
0.7982134819030762,
-0.7050392031669617,
-0.483317106962204,
0.19422776997089386,
-0.03441798686981201,
-0.9242794513702393,
0.04878272861242294,
-0.9252896308898926,
-1.009417176246643,
0.08372502028942108,
0.4142248332500458,
-0.46051713824272156,
0.08828503638505936,
-0.005715538747608662,
-0.24758246541023254,
-0.0027024492155760527,
-0.034822769463062286,
-1.1487817764282227,
0.09141111373901367,
0.6160557270050049,
0.7562854886054993,
-0.12993329763412476,
-0.1402154266834259,
-0.9059618711471558,
0.1639021635055542,
-0.6255879998207092,
0.7220600247383118,
-0.19389255344867706,
-0.5990477204322815,
-0.09744644165039062,
-0.12686926126480103,
-0.19540056586265564,
-0.6095413565635681,
0.6180536150932312,
-0.8009060621261597,
-0.01416401844471693,
-0.20225797593593597,
-0.3568388521671295,
0.1569966971874237,
0.41681888699531555,
-0.6683931946754456,
0.5352257490158081,
-0.0832243263721466,
-0.68242347240448,
0.24805724620819092,
-0.5582512021064758,
-0.8264948725700378,
-0.1145959198474884,
0.06879490613937378,
-0.5838644504547119,
0.26165664196014404,
0.6565704941749573,
0.25805455446243286,
-0.2658275067806244,
0.3106031119823456,
-0.5858521461486816,
-0.21979817748069763,
0.08059486001729965,
-0.406638503074646,
0.716450035572052,
0.44935178756713867,
-0.41533875465393066,
0.40937554836273193,
-0.6899621486663818,
-0.09966777265071869,
0.4282901883125305,
-0.12637434899806976,
-0.1859588474035263,
0.08845920115709305,
-0.503869354724884,
-0.11402960866689682,
0.21508696675300598,
-0.4903479516506195,
0.44288206100463867,
-0.6323831081390381,
0.6474350094795227,
0.9142993688583374,
0.07401753962039948,
0.36492082476615906,
-0.10567587614059448,
0.5983046889305115,
0.04390527680516243,
0.39729171991348267,
-0.3764384686946869,
-0.2610512375831604,
-0.4543377459049225,
-0.21913905441761017,
0.19569075107574463,
0.8975166082382202,
-0.8061169981956482,
0.4466140866279602,
0.1791500598192215,
-0.28939369320869446,
-0.3925631046295166,
0.22942064702510834,
0.48148488998413086,
0.619689404964447,
0.45712822675704956,
0.25543898344039917,
-0.6764386296272278,
-0.7664304971694946,
-0.5185511708259583,
-0.2175201177597046,
0.04184817150235176,
0.28571784496307373,
0.21150916814804077,
-0.06532333791255951,
0.6743977665901184,
-0.4684974253177643,
-0.039969902485609055,
-0.20654837787151337,
-0.0979350283741951,
0.1445731520652771,
0.2533251643180847,
0.7172085046768188,
-0.6147953867912292,
-0.32615548372268677,
-0.29102250933647156,
-0.7270597815513611,
-0.287997841835022,
-0.10219907760620117,
-0.01184686366468668,
-0.08539379388093948,
0.7046045660972595,
-0.4160900115966797,
0.12656131386756897,
0.16462722420692444,
-0.6266506910324097,
0.5941197276115417,
-0.11633075028657913,
0.09191901981830597,
-1.0796759128570557,
-0.3560640215873718,
-0.14463096857070923,
-0.2639188766479492,
-0.7526647448539734,
0.4188317358493805,
0.17957212030887604,
-0.3434804081916809,
-0.48101943731307983,
0.45063892006874084,
-0.04907506704330444,
0.25675490498542786,
-0.47271156311035156,
0.18353484570980072,
-0.04274943843483925,
0.1650964319705963,
-0.5053995251655579,
1.0843045711517334,
0.8141584396362305,
-0.562732994556427,
0.7504509091377258,
-0.04025844484567642,
-0.1372874528169632,
0.5680730938911438,
-0.8856452703475952,
0.14518272876739502,
-0.09946232289075851,
0.08665087819099426,
-0.9456601738929749,
-0.02623695693910122,
0.4413973093032837,
-0.46245935559272766,
0.6238703727722168,
-0.32175034284591675,
-0.3608163297176361,
-0.3659302592277527,
-0.5117797255516052,
-0.10259193927049637,
0.21513700485229492,
-0.6935437917709351,
0.32788053154945374,
0.12637002766132355,
-0.12178441137075424,
-0.6717631220817566,
-0.33141908049583435,
0.628002405166626,
-0.6935047507286072,
-0.6993588805198669,
0.30339333415031433,
-0.13938607275485992,
-0.21061182022094727,
-0.1899612694978714,
-0.024807635694742203,
0.34209612011909485,
0.7927688956260681,
0.2930137813091278,
0.3789028525352478,
-0.07854365557432175,
-0.11281146854162216,
-0.21903610229492188,
-0.24219532310962677,
0.22772058844566345,
-0.5728579163551331,
0.3505684733390808,
-0.12039154767990112,
-0.3349572420120239,
-0.000026633721063262783,
0.22530654072761536,
0.40751075744628906,
0.03475219011306763,
0.7037256956100464,
0.6247562170028687,
0.03623379021883011,
-0.232106551527977,
-0.35595640540122986,
0.011866902932524681,
-0.5175788402557373,
0.3952626585960388,
-0.38751283288002014,
-0.9850099086761475,
0.4106826186180115,
-0.11746493726968765,
0.05801704525947571,
0.27060386538505554,
0.5690904855728149,
0.03478940203785896,
1.1927416324615479,
0.5040640234947205,
-0.7078807353973389,
0.568044900894165,
-0.02869015745818615,
0.0684925988316536,
-0.672023594379425,
-0.1560523808002472,
-0.5240424871444702,
-0.21414335072040558,
-0.4446382522583008,
0.23730877041816711,
0.3426060676574707,
0.3277330696582794,
-0.6004651784896851,
0.4734942317008972,
-0.3091784417629242,
0.6789873838424683,
0.447815477848053,
0.2025637924671173,
-0.11582042276859283,
-0.04740513116121292,
-0.3530508875846863,
0.2302321344614029,
-0.5028126239776611,
-0.3086654245853424,
1.2840038537979126,
0.3864671587944031,
0.8684881329536438,
0.2921948730945587,
0.5080084800720215,
0.621171772480011,
0.026823243126273155,
-0.5865147113800049,
0.46396195888519287,
-0.37743666768074036,
-0.5426124334335327,
-0.10984482616186142,
-0.5094606280326843,
-0.8074729442596436,
0.22466221451759338,
0.035746313631534576,
-0.8480255603790283,
-0.2889211177825928,
0.23294490575790405,
-0.5192874073982239,
0.4779473841190338,
-0.7007701396942139,
0.8370563387870789,
-0.48861902952194214,
-0.24342791736125946,
-0.009907827712595463,
-0.7263193130493164,
0.4687861502170563,
0.008077183738350868,
0.16221150755882263,
-0.06584016978740692,
0.0014347705291584134,
0.4107873737812042,
-0.2780289053916931,
0.8352535367012024,
-0.4967968761920929,
-0.13594062626361847,
0.09944052249193192,
0.15684868395328522,
0.8174828290939331,
0.4025290310382843,
-0.07289779186248779,
-0.3806776702404022,
-0.3788134455680847,
-0.34638017416000366,
-0.567267656326294,
0.7840434312820435,
-0.8145681619644165,
-1.1259772777557373,
-0.16132508218288422,
-0.5142098069190979,
-0.38094979524612427,
0.04482988268136978,
0.5269014239311218,
0.3081067204475403,
-0.3588360548019409,
-0.12102292478084564,
1.0589851140975952,
-0.3267335891723633,
0.5214427709579468,
0.6820456981658936,
0.12574009597301483,
-0.6832876801490784,
0.9372190237045288,
-0.4958716332912445,
0.1986023634672165,
0.24574139714241028,
0.16905032098293304,
-0.33405593037605286,
-0.7511934638023376,
-0.8189947009086609,
-0.3610287010669708,
-0.5206266045570374,
-0.5945730209350586,
-0.34073495864868164,
-0.04541265591979027,
-0.5071480870246887,
-0.28457391262054443,
-0.1502930074930191,
-0.32038989663124084,
-0.315091609954834,
-0.2601967751979828,
0.6580511927604675,
0.45475509762763977,
-0.1251608431339264,
0.35541096329689026,
-0.521070122718811,
0.5506012439727783,
0.2613202929496765,
-0.07071825861930847,
-0.20931018888950348,
-0.6779945492744446,
-0.20078152418136597,
0.005540677346289158,
-0.5308847427368164,
-0.9109283685684204,
0.23148411512374878,
0.3567686676979065,
0.531086802482605,
0.5497353076934814,
0.23912599682807922,
0.5278396606445312,
-0.6292774081230164,
0.7248508930206299,
0.21611683070659637,
-0.6242638826370239,
0.9604800343513489,
-0.4715164303779602,
0.18127861618995667,
0.791947066783905,
-0.031977880746126175,
-0.16305556893348694,
-0.43781590461730957,
-0.43438541889190674,
-0.9288769960403442,
0.5354214906692505,
-0.13740864396095276,
0.18668408691883087,
-0.13153566420078278,
0.5080205202102661,
-0.16858342289924622,
0.2056102603673935,
-0.5395509004592896,
-0.46950656175613403,
-0.4047301411628723,
-0.13872802257537842,
-0.1312529295682907,
-0.042077939957380295,
-0.46112504601478577,
-0.061330247670412064,
0.5881651639938354,
-0.07958804816007614,
-0.13050538301467896,
-0.1337999552488327,
-0.2167125791311264,
0.06247561052441597,
0.52426677942276,
0.6192494034767151,
0.04242219775915146,
-0.08206165581941605,
0.21311189234256744,
0.23680394887924194,
-0.4575032889842987,
0.5696145296096802,
0.24191775918006897,
-0.4504625201225281,
-0.5240388512611389,
0.2636197507381439,
1.1647826433181763,
0.0394657626748085,
-0.5652068853378296,
0.4608878493309021,
-0.34182503819465637,
-0.1915954202413559,
-0.052351970225572586,
0.5489652156829834,
-0.1454407423734665,
0.3069574236869812,
0.33121395111083984,
0.16600170731544495,
-0.04510406032204628,
-0.33820638060569763,
0.26791682839393616,
0.758226752281189,
-0.31490349769592285,
-0.046037301421165466,
0.8376872539520264,
0.032882288098335266,
-0.3116334080696106,
0.425008624792099,
-0.19076493382453918,
-0.622952401638031,
0.8434452414512634,
0.7801069021224976,
1.0502451658248901,
-0.09670234471559525,
0.04538509249687195,
0.0348951481282711,
0.5512297749519348,
0.10787902027368546,
-0.1233949139714241,
-0.008006933145225048,
-0.5702800154685974,
0.0969671830534935,
-0.41678816080093384,
-0.31255021691322327,
0.32429733872413635,
-0.721611499786377,
0.09347707778215408,
-0.83907550573349,
-0.20852969586849213,
-0.20683346688747406,
0.0031431459356099367,
-0.2528283894062042,
0.12852895259857178,
0.22345666587352753,
1.0689167976379395,
-0.7087732553482056,
0.5843883752822876,
0.6908771991729736,
-0.11063047498464584,
-0.42581725120544434,
0.02961139753460884,
0.4381445050239563,
-0.7764696478843689,
0.420309454202652,
0.16674135625362396,
-0.17876093089580536,
-0.06605665385723114,
-0.576542317867279,
-0.6292722225189209,
0.8393440246582031,
0.5332038402557373,
-0.676058292388916,
0.006673043593764305,
0.004865317139774561,
0.3670971095561981,
-0.335636168718338,
0.03250882774591446,
0.7291696667671204,
0.38679417967796326,
0.02840062789618969,
-0.3752245306968689,
0.1063370481133461,
-0.32240089774131775,
-0.0017295985016971827,
0.30310720205307007,
-0.5078049302101135,
0.6222285032272339,
-0.577934205532074,
-0.1035291999578476,
0.26205092668533325,
0.5930867195129395,
0.3796595633029938,
0.17223379015922546,
0.47421523928642273,
0.9513270258903503,
0.6037064790725708,
-0.25022053718566895,
0.9980875253677368,
-0.5091917514801025,
-0.10433845967054367,
0.9679753184318542,
-0.07386598736047745,
0.36413058638572693,
0.0833086147904396,
0.05507027730345726,
0.3011278510093689,
0.7847670316696167,
-0.41612571477890015,
0.9314950704574585,
0.6051387786865234,
-0.40201494097709656,
-0.13410669565200806,
0.16450054943561554,
-0.5066441893577576,
0.10184326022863388,
0.42402422428131104,
-0.19635874032974243,
-0.3700317442417145,
0.3346160054206848,
0.3577764928340912,
0.12124393880367279,
-0.4945904016494751,
1.0193668603897095,
-0.055386267602443695,
-0.5823966860771179,
0.7120028734207153,
0.26247864961624146,
0.7574094533920288,
-0.8251330256462097,
0.5111979842185974,
-0.17074629664421082,
0.17103101313114166,
-0.04814914986491203,
-0.46126967668533325,
0.03491286188364029,
0.38466572761535645,
-0.39317044615745544,
0.08989153802394867,
0.7435636520385742,
-0.06878156214952469,
-0.1565312147140503,
0.3352389335632324,
0.0019018547609448433,
-0.3794327676296234,
-0.056211307644844055,
-0.9703535437583923,
-0.049299776554107666,
-0.09338922053575516,
-0.32991546392440796,
0.7105017900466919,
0.22485287487506866,
0.22748053073883057,
0.7959323525428772,
0.6101961731910706,
0.2854243814945221,
0.10515637695789337,
0.31333044171333313,
1.0918937921524048,
-0.6237794756889343,
-0.46938788890838623,
-1.3022772073745728,
0.25903433561325073,
-0.10497714579105377,
-0.2542218267917633,
0.8233022093772888,
0.4247490167617798,
0.5838451981544495,
0.19018742442131042,
0.9353382587432861,
-0.032722823321819305,
0.18665024638175964,
-0.8395151495933533,
0.613966166973114,
-0.22630548477172852,
0.5827212333679199,
-0.0891459509730339,
-0.35653913021087646,
-0.26361551880836487,
0.19974026083946228,
-0.2790430188179016,
-0.1313987374305725,
0.3942303955554962,
0.9622494578361511,
0.23408277332782745,
0.08712456375360489,
0.23359331488609314,
0.04878704249858856,
0.650793731212616,
0.8775745630264282,
0.8697351217269897,
-0.3403928577899933,
0.6722485423088074,
0.0242556631565094,
-0.20140989124774933,
-0.015075654722750187,
-0.9443662166595459,
-1.161354422569275,
0.013803824782371521,
-0.027263963595032692,
-0.513285756111145,
0.673949658870697,
0.6727165579795837,
0.5526806116104126,
-1.0337748527526855,
0.17904381453990936,
-0.2526708245277405,
0.10279223322868347,
-0.028984276577830315,
-0.2300889641046524,
0.19585201144218445,
-0.8456077575683594,
-0.1628657877445221,
1.1252750158309937,
0.2735256254673004,
-0.04449310898780823,
-0.10664372891187668,
0.03394258767366409,
0.17542818188667297,
0.06233993545174599,
0.3310966491699219,
0.49110984802246094,
-0.6824904680252075,
-0.17671671509742737,
-0.12379708886146545,
-0.20057232677936554,
-0.12718184292316437,
0.9230130910873413,
-0.6959678530693054,
0.37711620330810547,
0.03333514928817749,
0.8575940728187561,
-0.0010435787262395024,
0.2243528515100479,
0.7013806104660034,
-0.8481408953666687,
0.1903994381427765,
-0.04773987457156181,
0.28155431151390076,
0.2832534909248352,
-0.5565446615219116,
0.22331100702285767,
0.12700678408145905,
-0.43558862805366516,
-0.7167806625366211,
0.5494996309280396,
-0.4262638986110687,
-0.6627540588378906,
0.9882556200027466,
-0.3291008770465851,
-0.0409836620092392,
-0.13869886100292206,
-0.1387632191181183,
0.05420209839940071,
-0.476174533367157,
0.926413357257843,
0.47065600752830505,
0.170538067817688,
0.08674599230289459,
-0.41346150636672974,
0.7517701387405396,
0.22701503336429596,
-0.7878695726394653,
0.26205411553382874,
0.2897945046424866,
0.32208824157714844,
-0.1774081140756607,
0.0676625519990921,
-0.12068687379360199,
0.32993781566619873,
-0.10968446731567383,
-0.5796933770179749,
-0.7294536828994751,
-0.65349280834198,
-0.6384537220001221,
0.4334574043750763,
0.1011444702744484,
-0.21457037329673767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06621v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06621v1
|
LinkQ: An LLM-Assisted Visual Interface for Knowledge Graph Question-Answering
| 2024-06-07T15:28:31 | 2024-06-07T15:28:31 |
Harry Li, Gabriel Appleby, Ashley Suh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We present LinkQ, a system that leverages a large language model (LLM) to
facilitate knowledge graph (KG) query construction through natural language
question-answering. Traditional approaches often require detailed knowledge of
complex graph querying languages, limiting the ability for users -- even
experts -- to acquire valuable insights from KG data. LinkQ simplifies this
process by first interpreting a user's question, then converting it into a
well-formed KG query. By using the LLM to construct a query instead of directly
answering the user's question, LinkQ guards against the LLM hallucinating or
generating false, erroneous information. By integrating an LLM into LinkQ,
users are able to conduct both exploratory and confirmatory data analysis, with
the LLM helping to iteratively refine open-ended questions into precise ones.
To demonstrate the efficacy of LinkQ, we conducted a qualitative study with
five KG practitioners and distill their feedback. Our results indicate that
practitioners find LinkQ effective for KG question-answering, and desire future
LLM-assisted systems for the exploratory analysis of graph databases.
|
[
-0.43994060158729553,
-1.2364002466201782,
0.6144838929176331,
-0.2345241755247116,
-0.1769239604473114,
0.29165831208229065,
0.1606799215078354,
-0.5024765729904175,
0.34636661410331726,
0.6359429955482483,
-0.4729659855365753,
-0.8226656913757324,
-0.2279946208000183,
0.09577369689941406,
-0.305276483297348,
0.5356979370117188,
-0.12457064539194107,
0.05504472181200981,
-0.7477584481239319,
-0.2530987858772278,
-0.35600531101226807,
-0.22906801104545593,
-0.8653928637504578,
-0.26480433344841003,
0.9510558247566223,
0.446390837430954,
1.0879896879196167,
0.40644392371177673,
0.45786252617836,
0.19069568812847137,
0.04908781498670578,
0.5077812075614929,
-0.7795931696891785,
0.26581597328186035,
0.0415835864841938,
-0.6397449374198914,
-0.5025400519371033,
-0.10735490173101425,
0.5084110498428345,
1.1450037956237793,
0.19166426360607147,
0.16664224863052368,
-0.14355821907520294,
0.8751459121704102,
-0.4186396300792694,
0.3635180592536926,
-0.38492366671562195,
0.030988173559308052,
-0.05125302076339722,
-0.11450885981321335,
-0.2493850290775299,
-0.8581938743591309,
0.013600822538137436,
-0.8344695568084717,
-0.31173452734947205,
0.6051522493362427,
0.6643587946891785,
0.21551750600337982,
-0.7971463203430176,
-0.0677667036652565,
-0.3916776180267334,
0.11123350262641907,
-0.4487449526786804,
0.7134141325950623,
0.3164050877094269,
0.9393711686134338,
-0.3208571672439575,
-0.8776530623435974,
-0.7184387445449829,
-0.032578203827142715,
-0.16107851266860962,
0.217173233628273,
-0.19192205369472504,
0.12209884077310562,
0.3512255847454071,
0.1630917638540268,
-0.772124171257019,
-0.11676560342311859,
-0.40451592206954956,
-0.25748735666275024,
0.4590356647968292,
0.399443119764328,
0.6476882696151733,
-0.33166223764419556,
-0.13634566962718964,
0.14902953803539276,
-1.209153175354004,
0.09881790727376938,
0.20832550525665283,
0.26540687680244446,
0.21781577169895172,
0.7435861825942993,
-0.8105077147483826,
1.1646496057510376,
-0.4170709252357483,
0.014648567885160446,
-0.13059422373771667,
-0.057865340262651443,
-0.25547629594802856,
0.1110067144036293,
1.016528606414795,
0.647095799446106,
0.2086826115846634,
-0.47843682765960693,
0.11852893233299255,
-0.34599268436431885,
-0.11527778953313828,
-0.739233136177063,
-0.5744407773017883,
0.27109038829803467,
-0.1881614774465561,
-0.3338458836078644,
-0.14672143757343292,
-0.5273866653442383,
-0.5023672580718994,
-0.17536959052085876,
0.5162433981895447,
-0.34313952922821045,
-0.1726273000240326,
-0.11703918129205704,
-0.2572183609008789,
0.22507354617118835,
0.6336696147918701,
-0.34401002526283264,
0.29376399517059326,
0.35213178396224976,
0.5143584609031677,
0.0025450328830629587,
-0.10499419271945953,
-0.8965350985527039,
0.6101919412612915,
-0.3710891306400299,
0.8276956677436829,
-0.6728730797767639,
-0.4075683355331421,
-0.0816410630941391,
-0.0052630715072155,
0.15357212722301483,
-0.5345602035522461,
0.2127344012260437,
-1.288369059562683,
0.2647722661495209,
-0.638464629650116,
-0.679412841796875,
-0.3272940516471863,
0.5764642953872681,
-0.7989748120307922,
1.0698226690292358,
0.2437739074230194,
-0.9248510003089905,
0.3041771948337555,
-0.6672020554542542,
-0.2686324119567871,
0.35116565227508545,
-0.37580278515815735,
0.08736170828342438,
-0.3518558442592621,
0.4179876446723938,
0.29937413334846497,
-0.566237211227417,
0.032330550253391266,
-0.5466554164886475,
-0.22110837697982788,
0.210116907954216,
0.002772864419966936,
0.670231282711029,
0.28473666310310364,
0.2628123462200165,
0.045174695551395416,
-0.5946069955825806,
0.23520588874816895,
0.29916292428970337,
-0.337846964597702,
-0.376995712518692,
-0.14597155153751373,
-0.4660423994064331,
0.0921626016497612,
0.3570670187473297,
-0.5208681225776672,
0.3054078221321106,
-0.3177359700202942,
0.11123785376548767,
0.2521207332611084,
0.1208898201584816,
0.18991880118846893,
-0.0742521733045578,
0.7435008883476257,
-0.1950303167104721,
0.19026026129722595,
0.09545933455228806,
-0.7413202524185181,
-0.6344149112701416,
0.12262985855340958,
0.18084567785263062,
0.49503594636917114,
-1.2900382280349731,
-0.14584942162036896,
-0.4686005711555481,
-0.58766770362854,
-0.338973730802536,
0.3064447045326233,
0.1545550525188446,
1.1080669164657593,
0.29595232009887695,
-0.05430729687213898,
-0.21479687094688416,
-0.7573839426040649,
-0.22153176367282867,
-0.5763578414916992,
-0.0249387938529253,
0.6659220457077026,
0.2284543216228485,
0.10253682732582092,
1.3066301345825195,
-1.025300145149231,
0.24856971204280853,
-0.3045228123664856,
0.1985962688922882,
0.24948254227638245,
-0.15975217521190643,
0.28977134823799133,
-0.949889600276947,
-0.6933885812759399,
0.06823542714118958,
-1.1540669202804565,
-0.26964089274406433,
0.4493633210659027,
-0.5145629048347473,
-0.21088646352291107,
0.641488254070282,
-0.5913025736808777,
0.12950830161571503,
0.2719095051288605,
-0.42357224225997925,
0.5019803643226624,
0.07965350151062012,
0.3528619110584259,
-1.0296999216079712,
0.19930648803710938,
-0.4265367090702057,
-0.4950261414051056,
-0.623405933380127,
0.14077813923358917,
0.1662098914384842,
-0.43964406847953796,
-0.22526824474334717,
0.5509793162345886,
-0.19470682740211487,
-0.12882667779922485,
0.017889847978949547,
0.47384124994277954,
0.22504961490631104,
0.28042131662368774,
-0.020780913531780243,
0.6676362156867981,
0.44153106212615967,
-0.5220703482627869,
0.8568918108940125,
0.5097530484199524,
-0.21844226121902466,
0.6594632863998413,
-0.832846999168396,
0.2559846043586731,
-0.21441499888896942,
0.009067177772521973,
-1.3399263620376587,
-0.5156744122505188,
0.47407129406929016,
-0.4133855402469635,
0.2052823156118393,
-0.38288819789886475,
-0.8117634654045105,
-0.6156617403030396,
-0.1667059063911438,
0.37631216645240784,
0.3885088264942169,
-0.5590922832489014,
0.5072887539863586,
0.4325415790081024,
-0.2014053612947464,
-0.3537517189979553,
-0.3879539370536804,
0.28412407636642456,
-0.16683253645896912,
-1.0291683673858643,
-0.21038803458213806,
-0.104224793612957,
-0.13383890688419342,
0.1574043333530426,
0.03405693545937538,
-0.2798801064491272,
0.13439497351646423,
0.14066722989082336,
0.32729169726371765,
-0.16896773874759674,
0.29867199063301086,
0.054513394832611084,
0.05383269488811493,
0.2804386019706726,
-0.15024292469024658,
0.5087944269180298,
0.06697747856378555,
-0.6768212914466858,
-0.09491132199764252,
0.19049373269081116,
0.5684695839881897,
-0.31383487582206726,
0.33612024784088135,
0.3858351409435272,
-0.11552435904741287,
0.0518459789454937,
-0.5009297132492065,
0.11981023848056793,
-0.4532627463340759,
0.17403461039066315,
-0.5119558572769165,
-1.210046648979187,
0.4322073459625244,
-0.4083379805088043,
-0.3230189085006714,
0.24562004208564758,
0.1509716659784317,
-0.39399099349975586,
0.9539003968238831,
0.3792204260826111,
-0.08325731754302979,
0.05995351821184158,
0.03725550323724747,
0.20034903287887573,
-0.7234650254249573,
-0.5148059129714966,
-0.29846811294555664,
-0.2457568198442459,
-0.2289097011089325,
-0.5119655728340149,
0.779091477394104,
0.46187150478363037,
-0.26343584060668945,
0.10191138088703156,
-0.24688826501369476,
0.44463908672332764,
0.46118977665901184,
0.25127023458480835,
0.6404822468757629,
-0.10849609971046448,
-0.16071166098117828,
0.07415245473384857,
-0.9676974415779114,
-0.2124665528535843,
1.1369386911392212,
-0.014515232294797897,
1.104216456413269,
0.27270692586898804,
0.6935999393463135,
0.059705451130867004,
0.37050074338912964,
-0.7150253057479858,
0.7682194709777832,
0.44606325030326843,
-0.3618849813938141,
-0.628504753112793,
-0.6681323051452637,
-0.759598970413208,
0.034434497356414795,
-0.1686180830001831,
-0.7054010629653931,
-0.07027340680360794,
0.1891460418701172,
-0.2657311260700226,
0.3413022458553314,
-0.5767004489898682,
0.9118752479553223,
-0.2452288717031479,
-0.4609595239162445,
0.13969863951206207,
-0.5410574674606323,
0.3931640088558197,
0.0517432801425457,
0.05987988039851189,
-0.10372170060873032,
-0.07741423696279526,
0.6464060544967651,
-0.5786306262016296,
0.6685234308242798,
-0.24146662652492523,
-0.11275754123926163,
0.4779597520828247,
0.3418145775794983,
0.7719821929931641,
-0.00948641262948513,
0.030536189675331116,
-0.2678007483482361,
-0.023134296759963036,
-0.21212920546531677,
-1.1292542219161987,
0.5568124651908875,
-0.5593472719192505,
-0.8031750917434692,
0.1926252841949463,
-0.7379246950149536,
-0.5254007577896118,
0.3851316273212433,
-0.267322838306427,
0.5822149515151978,
-0.2962491810321808,
0.17795464396476746,
0.7113131880760193,
-0.36899346113204956,
-0.0823112279176712,
0.47684603929519653,
-0.8823937177658081,
-0.48921892046928406,
0.85025554895401,
0.10994073003530502,
0.36999326944351196,
0.7166880965232849,
0.2517761290073395,
-0.6022968888282776,
-0.47262871265411377,
-0.5279486179351807,
0.2108660787343979,
-0.9461799263954163,
-0.2918204069137573,
-0.6791092753410339,
-0.015383333899080753,
-0.3376781940460205,
0.08240256458520889,
0.10275280475616455,
-0.5824720859527588,
0.26113495230674744,
-0.06027389317750931,
0.7136644721031189,
0.7842614054679871,
0.37207886576652527,
0.10710133612155914,
-0.8200541734695435,
0.5070384740829468,
0.8787400126457214,
0.34649112820625305,
-0.21958793699741364,
-0.04133330285549164,
-0.1659281849861145,
-0.10512758791446686,
0.03845188021659851,
-1.1109336614608765,
0.14449355006217957,
-0.03498896211385727,
0.5664113759994507,
0.4035258889198303,
0.3190076947212219,
0.6143760085105896,
-0.36370140314102173,
0.7052173614501953,
0.30556923151016235,
-0.4406350255012512,
0.7343453764915466,
-0.621440052986145,
0.4422411322593689,
0.6135503649711609,
0.7060059309005737,
-0.766737163066864,
-0.5481234192848206,
-0.13023170828819275,
-0.6746808886528015,
0.4977182447910309,
0.016603292897343636,
-0.2716068625450134,
-0.132640078663826,
0.35622191429138184,
-0.0892360508441925,
0.3736954629421234,
-0.48652008175849915,
-0.3495975136756897,
-0.2207610160112381,
-0.1641094982624054,
0.3596898913383484,
-0.3878438174724579,
-0.4671742618083954,
-0.36954641342163086,
0.2876989245414734,
-0.4863438308238983,
0.13357755541801453,
0.22806833684444427,
-0.21175622940063477,
-0.0696401298046112,
0.1303112506866455,
-0.29916590452194214,
0.8278672099113464,
-0.36214518547058105,
0.3086612820625305,
0.30717018246650696,
-0.054609984159469604,
-0.2909039258956909,
0.10485567897558212,
-0.2639707624912262,
-0.18046993017196655,
0.21357278525829315,
0.5451483130455017,
0.17340511083602905,
-0.7589375376701355,
0.4454001188278198,
-0.04361739754676819,
-0.09801140427589417,
0.10628417134284973,
0.22193096578121185,
0.7762582898139954,
0.28155386447906494,
0.19896969199180603,
-0.6552023887634277,
0.2853988707065582,
-0.41418617963790894,
0.015752244740724564,
0.6543576717376709,
-0.5520524978637695,
0.16317850351333618,
1.0402730703353882,
0.28261199593544006,
-0.1144879087805748,
0.7886395454406738,
-0.1756807118654251,
-0.4724297821521759,
0.5701819062232971,
0.43429192900657654,
0.4912855625152588,
0.1814097911119461,
0.49903663992881775,
0.3192392587661743,
0.1360161304473877,
0.3984985947608948,
0.5950514674186707,
-0.25823819637298584,
-0.6851833462715149,
-0.39109867811203003,
-0.501488208770752,
-0.666488766670227,
-0.261966735124588,
-0.6276613473892212,
0.048751186579465866,
-0.27325743436813354,
0.13111211359500885,
-0.18401609361171722,
-0.1673487275838852,
-0.6217912435531616,
0.27182143926620483,
0.00884261541068554,
1.2030366659164429,
-0.6017480492591858,
0.8393047451972961,
0.9375566840171814,
-0.6128801107406616,
-0.9523555040359497,
-0.36980757117271423,
-0.05330926179885864,
-1.064335584640503,
1.0861214399337769,
-0.17626497149467468,
-0.24079735577106476,
0.2621743381023407,
-0.740530252456665,
-0.7578307390213013,
1.7034052610397339,
0.36521708965301514,
-0.2839275598526001,
0.10363364219665527,
0.6584928631782532,
0.3599995970726013,
-0.09185454994440079,
0.3429221510887146,
0.3000161349773407,
0.5019638538360596,
0.5863115191459656,
-0.6127377152442932,
0.37896859645843506,
-0.1762644350528717,
-0.21401849389076233,
0.3827804625034332,
-0.6649901866912842,
0.4197508990764618,
-0.21353815495967865,
-0.1508193463087082,
-0.18368658423423767,
0.6441783905029297,
0.08564447611570358,
0.2882959842681885,
0.551904022693634,
0.6543053984642029,
1.196756362915039,
-0.09635394811630249,
1.1367690563201904,
-0.48716235160827637,
0.06009000539779663,
1.1187636852264404,
-0.13928134739398956,
0.7167683839797974,
0.49762946367263794,
-0.40776002407073975,
0.3089982271194458,
0.5572831034660339,
0.2036960870027542,
0.32553631067276,
0.0735715925693512,
-0.408223032951355,
-0.5831050276756287,
-0.4127974212169647,
-0.4361761808395386,
0.17733646929264069,
0.11623503267765045,
-0.016468098387122154,
-0.449968159198761,
-0.42161715030670166,
0.016053618863224983,
-0.15250124037265778,
-0.3359186053276062,
0.6319530606269836,
0.05443480983376503,
-0.38109445571899414,
0.3445587456226349,
-0.5161937475204468,
-0.011289059184491634,
-0.8007991909980774,
-0.12404225766658783,
-0.5146884918212891,
-0.6651424765586853,
-0.29801803827285767,
-1.0649447441101074,
0.030420105904340744,
-0.17603658139705658,
0.12520253658294678,
0.013593446463346481,
0.9283121824264526,
-0.462313711643219,
-0.40987008810043335,
0.17201784253120422,
1.0377197265625,
0.23861539363861084,
-0.1604401171207428,
-0.48127588629722595,
-0.2096397578716278,
-0.049434881657361984,
-0.18670031428337097,
0.2565913498401642,
0.6677126288414001,
0.08520908653736115,
1.1028203964233398,
0.5952246189117432,
-0.009073106572031975,
-0.08458095788955688,
0.2643430233001709,
1.167029619216919,
-0.7037073969841003,
-0.2556972801685333,
-0.5333911180496216,
0.38612112402915955,
-0.3719278872013092,
0.04945278540253639,
0.9445759654045105,
0.7503421306610107,
0.5781314969062805,
0.20823918282985687,
0.7770442366600037,
-0.0874357670545578,
0.3516498804092407,
-0.551086962223053,
0.864871621131897,
-0.833509087562561,
0.19429053366184235,
-0.2956862449645996,
-0.6900193095207214,
-0.41461488604545593,
-0.004172490909695625,
-0.44589054584503174,
-0.17252206802368164,
0.5903540849685669,
0.9869994521141052,
0.04113144800066948,
0.0708174929022789,
0.5298211574554443,
0.1449340432882309,
0.384657621383667,
0.6119363307952881,
1.0754296779632568,
-0.16656388342380524,
0.9843677282333374,
-0.04199898615479469,
-0.05313156917691231,
-0.08098965138196945,
-0.68574458360672,
-0.9557177424430847,
-0.14803777635097504,
-0.280966192483902,
-0.20294451713562012,
0.05286433547735214,
0.6114704608917236,
0.31383636593818665,
-0.5201161503791809,
-0.2529122233390808,
0.06065119057893753,
0.5447763204574585,
0.27120092511177063,
-0.23950456082820892,
0.5620232820510864,
-0.3269844651222229,
-0.5770204663276672,
0.5062327980995178,
0.47403815388679504,
-0.20970284938812256,
-0.15264460444450378,
-0.26375335454940796,
-0.08233171701431274,
-0.34490007162094116,
0.6179410219192505,
0.43027135729789734,
-0.3647734820842743,
-0.42575398087501526,
0.13193154335021973,
-0.04526539891958237,
0.14241847395896912,
0.6420782208442688,
-0.8785155415534973,
0.9648928046226501,
0.7587054967880249,
0.8648797869682312,
0.5106286406517029,
-0.07586485147476196,
0.7479546070098877,
-0.49503782391548157,
-0.38645824790000916,
-0.07720780372619629,
0.2790641486644745,
0.1775723397731781,
-0.3580475449562073,
0.6639339923858643,
0.3276214003562927,
-0.3266630172729492,
-0.5092176198959351,
0.44658800959587097,
-0.9936182498931885,
-0.20993101596832275,
1.059350848197937,
0.018812118098139763,
-0.31213968992233276,
-0.3712180256843567,
-0.2699959874153137,
0.22463460266590118,
-0.23839813470840454,
0.3379838466644287,
0.6025163531303406,
-0.5426998138427734,
-0.21672001481056213,
-0.7054997682571411,
0.324412077665329,
-0.002805207623168826,
-0.9875459671020508,
-0.06310666352510452,
0.771163821220398,
0.33747297525405884,
-0.12901869416236877,
0.8107970356941223,
-0.13808512687683105,
0.2447243481874466,
-0.023600414395332336,
-0.13532370328903198,
-0.5119563937187195,
-0.0455416738986969,
0.175558403134346,
0.5234453082084656,
0.4306888282299042,
0.051000770181417465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05013v1
|
CHIQ: Contextual History Enhancement for Improving Query Rewriting in Conversational Search
| 2024-06-07T15:23:53 | 2024-06-07T15:23:53 |
Fengran Mo, Abbas Ghaddar, Kelong Mao, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Boxing Chen, Qun Liu, Jian-Yun Nie
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we study how open-source large language models (LLMs) can be
effectively deployed for improving query rewriting in conversational search,
especially for ambiguous queries. We introduce CHIQ, a two-step method that
leverages the capabilities of LLMs to resolve ambiguities in the conversation
history before query rewriting. This approach contrasts with prior studies that
predominantly use closed-source LLMs to directly generate search queries from
conversation history. We demonstrate on five well-established benchmarks that
CHIQ leads to state-of-the-art results across most settings, showing highly
competitive performances with systems leveraging closed-source LLMs. Our study
provides a first step towards leveraging open-source LLMs in conversational
search, as a competitive alternative to the prevailing reliance on commercial
LLMs. Data, models, and source code will be publicly available upon acceptance
at https://github.com/fengranMark/CHIQ.
|
[
0.006331576034426689,
-1.0347663164138794,
0.7810707688331604,
0.08141937106847763,
-0.38732925057411194,
0.25388622283935547,
-0.34982967376708984,
-0.4839097559452057,
0.2532457113265991,
0.8173134922981262,
-0.7549251317977905,
-0.6574122309684753,
-0.1605749875307083,
-0.09791377931833267,
-0.5682209134101868,
0.3598787486553192,
0.16685889661312103,
0.23780478537082672,
-0.37004247307777405,
-0.20918552577495575,
-0.4103096127510071,
-0.5434153079986572,
-0.5448258519172668,
-0.28247296810150146,
0.29052770137786865,
0.3790375292301178,
1.0134940147399902,
0.5757020115852356,
0.3609936237335205,
0.18343260884284973,
-0.32746297121047974,
0.30308258533477783,
-0.8878923058509827,
0.8272022604942322,
-0.3136134743690491,
-0.7392071485519409,
-0.3450935184955597,
-0.3306770324707031,
0.6468130946159363,
0.8844971656799316,
-0.20099851489067078,
-0.2484559714794159,
0.10713361948728561,
0.5559021830558777,
-0.7091774940490723,
0.04853285104036331,
-1.2226194143295288,
-0.11905764788389206,
-0.08335889130830765,
-0.6786960363388062,
-0.3141697645187378,
-0.7448528409004211,
0.20018546283245087,
-0.5680555701255798,
0.32986798882484436,
0.2299593836069107,
0.6853308081626892,
0.10593774914741516,
-0.44675594568252563,
-0.21331632137298584,
-0.7535339593887329,
1.046256422996521,
-0.8665362000465393,
0.9570745825767517,
0.34977957606315613,
0.5151142477989197,
-0.5245612859725952,
-1.1100434064865112,
-0.3321114182472229,
-0.184331014752388,
-0.09093336015939713,
-0.029336443170905113,
-0.21417449414730072,
-0.14547574520111084,
0.007110706064850092,
0.47830814123153687,
-0.4692824184894562,
-0.06914690881967545,
-0.46328723430633545,
-0.08773420751094818,
0.5591310858726501,
0.3831869661808014,
0.0032148663885891438,
0.12773853540420532,
-0.1771496683359146,
0.2579810619354248,
-1.1134051084518433,
-0.039666347205638885,
-0.16580325365066528,
0.4170808494091034,
0.14184939861297607,
0.6047865748405457,
-0.7537826895713806,
0.6782961487770081,
0.021998606622219086,
0.05128565430641174,
-0.07356739789247513,
-0.6547092795372009,
-0.3422887623310089,
0.11330104619264603,
0.6535003185272217,
0.33631837368011475,
-0.09319543093442917,
-0.3600667715072632,
0.09357339888811111,
-0.5858606696128845,
0.28906360268592834,
-0.7434694766998291,
0.08978132903575897,
0.246289923787117,
-0.42903172969818115,
-0.1943148970603943,
0.051726192235946655,
-0.8006048798561096,
-0.40936776995658875,
-0.18665535748004913,
0.036366552114486694,
-0.2355678826570511,
0.19310882687568665,
0.012278157286345959,
0.05930555611848831,
0.46671414375305176,
0.690986156463623,
-0.5129578113555908,
0.05098585784435272,
0.8615826368331909,
0.768255352973938,
0.26344114542007446,
-0.16877925395965576,
-0.8553847670555115,
0.2164122611284256,
-0.5043320059776306,
0.5165677070617676,
-0.9677795171737671,
-0.7434478998184204,
0.225092813372612,
0.16002149879932404,
0.36525192856788635,
-0.47436726093292236,
0.6294170022010803,
-0.9892362952232361,
0.41686058044433594,
-0.33473390340805054,
-0.39808475971221924,
-0.1596643477678299,
0.25579872727394104,
-0.4631307125091553,
1.0781056880950928,
0.04913204163312912,
-0.5672069191932678,
0.08156871795654297,
-0.337375283241272,
-0.482870876789093,
0.32602694630622864,
-0.5522885918617249,
-0.1783778965473175,
0.06464659422636032,
0.3765312731266022,
0.08989954739809036,
-0.7000247836112976,
0.24591228365898132,
-0.37092283368110657,
-0.6438644528388977,
0.3311444818973541,
-0.213285893201828,
0.8159376978874207,
0.23860111832618713,
-0.4383871853351593,
0.26187315583229065,
-0.19196830689907074,
0.2629122734069824,
0.2967967987060547,
-0.4218156039714813,
-0.38598230481147766,
0.2468070238828659,
-0.33610856533050537,
-0.04192078486084938,
0.25963544845581055,
-0.33643394708633423,
0.1471835970878601,
-0.808490514755249,
0.43241575360298157,
0.38865867257118225,
0.0324861966073513,
0.34286609292030334,
-0.2559075951576233,
0.557278037071228,
-0.23216336965560913,
0.10384193807840347,
-0.5173040628433228,
-0.5265917778015137,
-0.7805847525596619,
0.07531236112117767,
0.17329838871955872,
0.4459632337093353,
-0.6879420280456543,
0.48688751459121704,
-0.2869197726249695,
-0.4922853708267212,
-0.5699294805526733,
0.16851192712783813,
0.22022125124931335,
0.4245903193950653,
0.2691027820110321,
-0.21866044402122498,
-0.5964565873146057,
-0.8592534065246582,
-0.5305565595626831,
-0.3956297039985657,
-0.3033929169178009,
0.834786593914032,
-0.024162469431757927,
-0.16356633603572845,
1.0669353008270264,
-0.6533137559890747,
-0.08059576153755188,
0.03905809298157692,
0.033062681555747986,
0.1268078237771988,
0.2335180640220642,
0.4245440661907196,
-0.8064368963241577,
-0.2588779032230377,
0.032293837517499924,
-0.599109411239624,
-0.23195645213127136,
0.14636778831481934,
-0.5078310966491699,
0.19312137365341187,
0.98624187707901,
-0.39701732993125916,
0.5756732225418091,
0.3115192651748657,
-0.2193482667207718,
0.38212910294532776,
0.08684393763542175,
0.5156833529472351,
-1.0720616579055786,
0.07667585462331772,
-0.2184453159570694,
-0.43994811177253723,
-0.46296292543411255,
0.34816423058509827,
0.19762732088565826,
-0.2434815615415573,
-0.5739837288856506,
0.45078590512275696,
-0.4878305494785309,
0.13711762428283691,
-0.28868821263313293,
0.4713202714920044,
-0.02919846400618553,
0.2633601725101471,
0.048433978110551834,
0.6805024743080139,
0.39863714575767517,
-0.5941817760467529,
0.2902719974517822,
0.32641005516052246,
-0.17221397161483765,
0.48598262667655945,
-0.7488459944725037,
0.3793668746948242,
0.035807088017463684,
0.4159698188304901,
-0.9561103582382202,
-0.30099475383758545,
0.3971461057662964,
-0.4744018316268921,
0.048597272485494614,
-0.31917521357536316,
-0.3643749952316284,
-0.0432417206466198,
-0.48246800899505615,
0.6329410672187805,
0.2848796248435974,
-0.7467848658561707,
0.4981577396392822,
0.0941370502114296,
-0.2782633900642395,
-0.5841529965400696,
-0.5733047127723694,
0.31439173221588135,
-0.11383584886789322,
-0.6791152954101562,
0.5755959153175354,
-0.19684690237045288,
-0.18204185366630554,
-0.1820838302373886,
-0.19881470501422882,
-0.2088404893875122,
0.13341014087200165,
0.01888558641076088,
0.1941656917333603,
-0.44392743706703186,
0.033277906477451324,
0.1238447055220604,
0.36660170555114746,
-0.06070919707417488,
-0.1692131906747818,
0.7167735695838928,
-0.028086241334676743,
-0.5290196537971497,
-0.2988329231739044,
0.4158981442451477,
0.6908477544784546,
-0.3999359905719757,
0.6584358215332031,
0.3634050786495209,
-0.3690398633480072,
-0.05933554470539093,
-0.7525584697723389,
-0.3495321273803711,
-0.4752871096134186,
0.30935245752334595,
-0.1460907757282257,
-1.4444321393966675,
0.4154917001724243,
-0.14962825179100037,
0.09378047287464142,
0.12213044613599777,
0.69218909740448,
0.0959901213645935,
0.8490747809410095,
0.4114273190498352,
-0.12041851133108139,
0.5279744267463684,
0.4258159101009369,
0.3524197041988373,
-0.7756176590919495,
-0.4059993028640747,
-0.713296115398407,
-0.04409904405474663,
-0.6029614210128784,
-0.6872683763504028,
0.5080015659332275,
0.4094001054763794,
-0.07977832108736038,
-0.06242937222123146,
-0.2731964588165283,
0.47708478569984436,
0.6595425009727478,
0.339518278837204,
0.6833944916725159,
0.030207280069589615,
0.14865878224372864,
-0.1763353943824768,
-0.5894274115562439,
-0.3738193213939667,
1.114160180091858,
0.1395089328289032,
1.1529871225357056,
0.4583704173564911,
0.4687175154685974,
0.03940710052847862,
-0.00867867935448885,
-0.7828006148338318,
0.5079823136329651,
0.39541393518447876,
-0.6095606684684753,
-0.412618488073349,
-0.48019981384277344,
-1.2803215980529785,
0.469007670879364,
-0.2856500744819641,
-0.9596838355064392,
0.2727501094341278,
0.08704043924808502,
-0.20253632962703705,
0.09267939627170563,
-0.2989605665206909,
0.5328278541564941,
-0.46860939264297485,
-0.8292053937911987,
-0.2287403792142868,
-0.6062442064285278,
0.5887526273727417,
-0.11067743599414825,
-0.06184907630085945,
0.1294611692428589,
-0.12738199532032013,
0.28885790705680847,
-0.4326949417591095,
0.7097789645195007,
0.20457594096660614,
-0.04778128117322922,
0.18301676213741302,
0.3229479193687439,
0.7321736812591553,
0.3071494698524475,
-0.011076359078288078,
0.18788956105709076,
-0.03201451152563095,
-0.329384982585907,
-0.7261898517608643,
0.916388988494873,
-0.13357441127300262,
-1.0307495594024658,
-0.16892804205417633,
-0.4737243354320526,
-0.2639785706996918,
0.43770599365234375,
0.04263962805271149,
0.2673451602458954,
-0.5826320052146912,
0.9159698486328125,
0.5872740149497986,
-0.3628508746623993,
0.15344953536987305,
0.791419267654419,
-0.4827197790145874,
-0.1553354263305664,
0.20396864414215088,
-0.3209974765777588,
0.10633239895105362,
0.41595542430877686,
0.09441755712032318,
-0.3287985622882843,
-0.6167585849761963,
-0.24978666007518768,
0.33674564957618713,
-0.6178046464920044,
-0.3103809952735901,
-0.7116621732711792,
-0.17462843656539917,
-0.8591586947441101,
-0.12156730145215988,
-0.29515066742897034,
-0.21883434057235718,
-0.27388718724250793,
0.3516319692134857,
0.20948082208633423,
0.4080136716365814,
0.412571519613266,
0.2256430983543396,
-0.7709949016571045,
0.1125609278678894,
0.18048733472824097,
0.47013142704963684,
0.01682882383465767,
-0.3322345018386841,
-0.28847840428352356,
0.21770228445529938,
-0.5156368613243103,
-1.029067039489746,
0.3979922831058502,
-0.037787169218063354,
0.7993347644805908,
0.30574607849121094,
0.3472755253314972,
0.6751883625984192,
-0.3721766769886017,
0.9895516037940979,
0.08495739102363586,
-0.8545722365379333,
0.8138318061828613,
-0.46520212292671204,
0.522857129573822,
0.6276625394821167,
0.34727197885513306,
-0.7045624256134033,
-0.5144704580307007,
-0.3348267078399658,
-1.0118772983551025,
0.8894640803337097,
0.5151507258415222,
-0.050493791699409485,
0.1410871148109436,
0.37202340364456177,
-0.11961435526609421,
0.3086986541748047,
-0.28265780210494995,
-0.2854451537132263,
-0.23173335194587708,
0.16578352451324463,
0.0944209024310112,
-0.41123470664024353,
-0.1557077169418335,
-0.2420538067817688,
0.7665963172912598,
-0.08863576501607895,
0.08953814953565598,
0.4224794805049896,
-0.08450716733932495,
-0.1815909743309021,
0.522799551486969,
0.39335504174232483,
0.8264097571372986,
-0.43720316886901855,
-0.155926913022995,
0.1550264209508896,
-0.04813827946782112,
-0.26918309926986694,
0.15767501294612885,
-0.12781213223934174,
0.11162835359573364,
0.11215551942586899,
0.4644834101200104,
0.5068690776824951,
-0.8776160478591919,
0.39263537526130676,
-0.3520619869232178,
-0.12978602945804596,
-0.15997925400733948,
0.04162798449397087,
0.3024836778640747,
0.588525116443634,
0.39129385352134705,
-0.6219528317451477,
0.33376428484916687,
-0.670632541179657,
0.053316380828619,
0.7309510111808777,
-0.3873176574707031,
0.0914236456155777,
0.8562052249908447,
0.27841252088546753,
-0.5654089450836182,
0.7211124897003174,
0.23084241151809692,
-0.46274352073669434,
0.07295706868171692,
0.6119924187660217,
0.8867402672767639,
-0.4418279230594635,
-0.09952310472726822,
0.3073500990867615,
0.4039353132247925,
0.045860689133405685,
0.08442042768001556,
-0.44389045238494873,
-0.4677276015281677,
-0.2106817364692688,
-0.3511058986186981,
-0.8019818663597107,
0.36192449927330017,
-0.6420081853866577,
0.404485821723938,
-0.25809553265571594,
0.019915232434868813,
-0.22139759361743927,
-0.22170697152614594,
-0.6267574429512024,
-0.028119871392846107,
-0.18420107662677765,
0.7490153908729553,
-0.12910151481628418,
0.7459390163421631,
0.7155970335006714,
-0.1958586722612381,
-0.4540036916732788,
0.2639860510826111,
0.2735710144042969,
-0.6923628449440002,
0.31508538126945496,
-0.2620360851287842,
-0.41346436738967896,
-0.1936008781194687,
-0.7419193387031555,
-0.9108401536941528,
1.4190210103988647,
0.5766353607177734,
-0.7498043775558472,
-0.08389978110790253,
0.1809469312429428,
0.4397478699684143,
-0.43454891443252563,
0.3398289382457733,
0.6424387693405151,
0.18255957961082458,
0.3692195415496826,
-0.9014632701873779,
0.2958890497684479,
-0.046357568353414536,
0.02861158922314644,
0.20119883120059967,
-0.6306363344192505,
0.4166530668735504,
0.08063166588544846,
-0.5143662095069885,
0.37249183654785156,
0.7168431282043457,
0.3896893262863159,
0.5397051572799683,
0.25692224502563477,
0.033205945044755936,
0.8410993218421936,
-0.06748556345701218,
0.9178394675254822,
-0.36637061834335327,
0.2624149024486542,
1.4164323806762695,
-0.26133814454078674,
0.9657501578330994,
0.3748875856399536,
-0.0894724652171135,
0.21509841084480286,
0.4962190091609955,
0.3959394097328186,
0.23715850710868835,
0.018936797976493835,
-0.3541933298110962,
-0.38660570979118347,
-0.1475454568862915,
-0.6134147047996521,
0.5419750809669495,
0.23883846402168274,
-0.7266762852668762,
-0.3772399425506592,
-0.6069476008415222,
0.2375870943069458,
0.2129661589860916,
-0.026263466104865074,
0.7564330697059631,
0.06295322626829147,
-0.7120270729064941,
0.7447088956832886,
0.1242135688662529,
0.6643162965774536,
-0.6137968897819519,
-0.0025914788711816072,
-0.6195382475852966,
-0.1608554720878601,
-0.22458110749721527,
-0.5500138401985168,
0.24480897188186646,
-0.17637041211128235,
-0.08405756950378418,
0.17234347760677338,
0.8095616102218628,
-0.6019582152366638,
-0.34401142597198486,
0.32139983773231506,
0.7126015424728394,
0.15452152490615845,
-0.3206998407840729,
-0.7089806199073792,
0.23949764668941498,
0.3366837799549103,
0.00922552403062582,
0.16990001499652863,
0.2863750755786896,
-0.153629332780838,
0.5781239867210388,
0.6155776977539062,
-0.1658952683210373,
0.014672281220555305,
0.0769154503941536,
1.050889492034912,
-1.0796418190002441,
-0.5026557445526123,
-0.7374043464660645,
0.15486711263656616,
-0.1575503647327423,
0.06969116628170013,
0.7879477739334106,
0.6704642176628113,
0.9378537535667419,
0.3002743422985077,
0.7149167060852051,
0.4363457262516022,
0.6326495409011841,
-0.6922009587287903,
0.646782636642456,
-0.8193817138671875,
0.7821118235588074,
-0.2120424211025238,
-1.0753849744796753,
-0.3327960968017578,
0.22521629929542542,
-0.1458805799484253,
0.08375058323144913,
0.6375871300697327,
1.3121588230133057,
-0.14137719571590424,
0.33706679940223694,
0.41580283641815186,
0.19940274953842163,
0.4788614511489868,
0.401641845703125,
1.1017998456954956,
-0.4014551043510437,
0.7405138611793518,
0.011998062953352928,
-0.1960243582725525,
-0.5696941018104553,
-0.6822413802146912,
-0.7843932509422302,
-0.5086079835891724,
-0.25683245062828064,
-0.462035596370697,
0.34852099418640137,
0.7680231928825378,
0.7043574452400208,
-0.5006052255630493,
-0.3297966420650482,
0.16043724119663239,
0.3157760500907898,
-0.006864262279123068,
-0.2616768479347229,
0.051861170679330826,
-0.40158647298812866,
-0.8768486380577087,
1.0174847841262817,
0.2767786681652069,
-0.2249896377325058,
-0.20378822088241577,
-0.26344239711761475,
-0.3318007290363312,
0.2288912981748581,
0.6688317656517029,
0.3313920497894287,
-1.0424070358276367,
-0.17351792752742767,
0.1467946618795395,
0.03253119811415672,
0.3295747935771942,
1.243945837020874,
-0.8708816170692444,
0.6990107893943787,
0.5443391799926758,
0.6647322773933411,
0.6264836192131042,
0.2626338303089142,
0.8788492679595947,
-0.6484227776527405,
-0.06769228726625443,
0.2917609214782715,
0.24253027141094208,
0.3622267544269562,
-0.5125520825386047,
0.6075184345245361,
-0.06595812737941742,
-0.6278533935546875,
-0.8085025548934937,
0.24052542448043823,
-1.0417040586471558,
-0.5167232155799866,
1.062157154083252,
0.11038403958082199,
-0.03838155046105385,
-0.1692659705877304,
-0.28250908851623535,
0.19377776980400085,
-0.4967672526836395,
0.58780837059021,
0.32200488448143005,
-0.21485435962677002,
-0.1692696511745453,
-0.33461901545524597,
0.24152244627475739,
0.5215731859207153,
-0.5766664147377014,
0.20409278571605682,
0.8597428798675537,
0.1350242793560028,
-0.12207411229610443,
0.6409483551979065,
-0.482758492231369,
0.26787129044532776,
-0.27551284432411194,
-0.2978712320327759,
0.055276159197092056,
0.02045314386487007,
-0.36837807297706604,
0.23384486138820648,
0.27854058146476746,
0.02530440129339695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04989v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04989v1
|
Compositional Generalization with Grounded Language Models
| 2024-06-07T14:56:51 | 2024-06-07T14:56:51 |
Sondre Wold, Étienne Simon, Lucas Georges Gabriel Charpentier, Egor V. Kostylev, Erik Velldal, Lilja Øvrelid
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Grounded language models use external sources of information, such as
knowledge graphs, to meet some of the general challenges associated with
pre-training. By extending previous work on compositional generalization in
semantic parsing, we allow for a controlled evaluation of the degree to which
these models learn and generalize from patterns in knowledge graphs. We develop
a procedure for generating natural language questions paired with knowledge
graphs that targets different aspects of compositionality and further avoids
grounding the language models in information already encoded implicitly in
their weights. We evaluate existing methods for combining language models with
knowledge graphs and find them to struggle with generalization to sequences of
unseen lengths and to novel combinations of seen base components. While our
experimental results provide some insight into the expressive power of these
models, we hope our work and released datasets motivate future research on how
to better combine language models with structured knowledge representations.
|
[
-0.20129433274269104,
-0.8154371380805969,
0.9531571269035339,
0.1030297502875328,
-0.20435376465320587,
0.09289528429508209,
-0.32284465432167053,
-0.34219539165496826,
0.09528282284736633,
0.7082498073577881,
-0.4269035756587982,
-0.604863703250885,
-0.5636867880821228,
-0.1347218006849289,
-0.40551018714904785,
0.6543909907341003,
-0.08358971029520035,
0.1738441437482834,
-0.5824676752090454,
-0.14595036208629608,
-0.7728107571601868,
-0.6733621954917908,
-0.3205949068069458,
-0.4623250663280487,
0.3421727418899536,
0.19329319894313812,
0.5654898285865784,
0.5317854285240173,
0.284557968378067,
0.3595607280731201,
-0.02224743738770485,
0.14707320928573608,
-0.39157381653785706,
0.22646880149841309,
-0.1064378023147583,
-0.3856107294559479,
-0.12565110623836517,
0.18652936816215515,
0.8810722827911377,
1.4143401384353638,
0.08524024486541748,
-0.06224088743329048,
-0.13991005718708038,
0.5801893472671509,
-0.5257961750030518,
0.40239882469177246,
-0.4548929035663605,
0.041537199169397354,
0.25443193316459656,
0.05344688147306442,
-0.5318305492401123,
-0.5216405391693115,
0.13815034925937653,
-0.596314549446106,
0.06877757608890533,
-0.05161578580737114,
0.5584685206413269,
-0.015697605907917023,
-0.625877320766449,
-0.19405049085617065,
-0.7226892113685608,
0.6938239336013794,
-0.5663124322891235,
0.4966287314891815,
0.5007399916648865,
0.42229321599006653,
0.04821380600333214,
-0.9737502932548523,
-0.37378600239753723,
-0.5206565856933594,
-0.42499056458473206,
0.036351900547742844,
-0.09869188070297241,
0.15962821245193481,
0.2900677025318146,
0.45611926913261414,
-0.5063790678977966,
-0.2958811819553375,
-0.1929910033941269,
-0.13034918904304504,
0.5348351001739502,
0.22370678186416626,
0.5462903380393982,
0.08153641223907471,
0.06028313189744949,
-0.17314760386943817,
-0.4928671419620514,
0.1440034955739975,
0.5807585120201111,
0.29495126008987427,
-0.05326491966843605,
0.8536226153373718,
-0.5815086960792542,
1.217297911643982,
-0.0579201802611351,
0.19646096229553223,
0.0367373488843441,
-0.2916329801082611,
-0.07521454244852066,
-0.18592838943004608,
0.5739983320236206,
0.41782325506210327,
0.5440689325332642,
-0.5175904631614685,
-0.051063939929008484,
0.328983336687088,
0.12928107380867004,
-0.5905674695968628,
-0.36851322650909424,
0.027862325310707092,
-0.2919725775718689,
-0.4827522933483124,
0.20455773174762726,
-0.3153541386127472,
-0.2577981650829315,
-0.8014764785766602,
0.1279468536376953,
-0.447355717420578,
-0.3708726465702057,
0.34397292137145996,
-0.5250628590583801,
0.34507501125335693,
0.09829887002706528,
-0.9948118329048157,
0.6796495318412781,
0.699042558670044,
0.47384530305862427,
0.06843732297420502,
-0.127577543258667,
-0.3541422188282013,
0.43159112334251404,
-0.30376961827278137,
0.5447472333908081,
-0.8244122266769409,
-0.3659038841724396,
0.046621114015579224,
-0.04257362708449364,
-0.3018510043621063,
-0.5277850031852722,
0.301513135433197,
-0.6148027777671814,
0.4886975884437561,
-0.5804129838943481,
-0.9823467135429382,
-0.25844764709472656,
0.4684492349624634,
-0.5842434167861938,
1.0095411539077759,
0.4139381945133209,
-0.9809864163398743,
0.197509303689003,
-0.46299901604652405,
-0.4340229034423828,
0.008138997480273247,
-0.35366663336753845,
0.14850766956806183,
0.23575857281684875,
0.07204709947109222,
0.3501116931438446,
-0.22471341490745544,
0.5800479650497437,
-0.21234004199504852,
-0.061926763504743576,
0.13037970662117004,
0.10883378982543945,
0.593069851398468,
-0.002341268118470907,
-0.21461105346679688,
0.3130655586719513,
-0.916278064250946,
0.38242247700691223,
0.3792870342731476,
-0.3993394672870636,
-0.6001075506210327,
0.18305951356887817,
-0.28480228781700134,
0.0054795462638139725,
0.2083665430545807,
-0.36466988921165466,
0.1082623153924942,
-0.5918946862220764,
0.2641124129295349,
0.5051594376564026,
0.06464703381061554,
0.5136577486991882,
-0.25391852855682373,
0.32595476508140564,
0.07841823250055313,
-0.23018887639045715,
-0.13971994817256927,
-0.5711485743522644,
-0.9269725680351257,
0.06885505467653275,
0.16883431375026703,
0.4248000383377075,
-0.4376538097858429,
0.6879058480262756,
-0.43216097354888916,
-0.42658090591430664,
-0.13676486909389496,
0.06941928714513779,
0.4046240746974945,
0.9496320486068726,
0.42590850591659546,
-0.289102703332901,
-0.5837956666946411,
-0.8420071601867676,
-0.4004029929637909,
-0.16795742511749268,
-0.10487814247608185,
0.3029170036315918,
0.23788343369960785,
-0.12387147545814514,
1.4579179286956787,
-0.8315615653991699,
0.2756859362125397,
-0.3919978439807892,
0.20294764637947083,
-0.0353911854326725,
0.6812127828598022,
0.6219605803489685,
-0.8206712603569031,
-0.42993393540382385,
0.13705147802829742,
-0.9313333034515381,
-0.1305416077375412,
0.5514476895332336,
-0.037012625485658646,
-0.37424421310424805,
0.5413817167282104,
-0.6240318417549133,
0.05477552488446236,
0.44747063517570496,
-0.5351375937461853,
0.3534610867500305,
0.04024317115545273,
-0.04207693040370941,
-0.9967573285102844,
0.17790989577770233,
-0.39893481135368347,
-0.4592832624912262,
-0.8845927119255066,
0.1945938915014267,
-0.17624631524085999,
-0.39871853590011597,
-0.2138826698064804,
0.43608856201171875,
-0.29461905360221863,
-0.08542827516794205,
-0.22513097524642944,
-0.11653364449739456,
0.2989461123943329,
0.31612181663513184,
0.2444370687007904,
0.3872186541557312,
0.5670589208602905,
-0.640602171421051,
0.5352287292480469,
0.047686561942100525,
-0.15527378022670746,
0.23282699286937714,
-0.7997893691062927,
0.28901809453964233,
-0.44129183888435364,
0.09801562875509262,
-0.9616981744766235,
-0.42921555042266846,
0.2551535665988922,
-0.21607258915901184,
0.2148646116256714,
-0.2521187365055084,
-0.33112287521362305,
-0.23548364639282227,
-0.025782812386751175,
0.529502809047699,
0.49047166109085083,
-0.10988327115774155,
0.7244587540626526,
0.24313215911388397,
-0.03153600916266441,
-0.2278268188238144,
-0.5540245771408081,
-0.2913788855075836,
-0.1968347728252411,
-0.8546369671821594,
0.23026502132415771,
-0.09777320176362991,
-0.5395210385322571,
0.25380218029022217,
0.12490507960319519,
-0.13499900698661804,
0.1945987492799759,
0.1299818456172943,
-0.17234906554222107,
-0.4686863422393799,
0.10135698318481445,
0.04151666536927223,
-0.05717924237251282,
0.17674732208251953,
-0.6685944199562073,
0.9109917283058167,
-0.26591265201568604,
-0.5911282896995544,
-0.06908931583166122,
0.6083454489707947,
0.19544652104377747,
-0.3159749507904053,
0.8334946036338806,
0.30459415912628174,
-0.5288527607917786,
0.0900840237736702,
-0.5381625294685364,
-0.1405470222234726,
-0.4166911840438843,
0.05734320357441902,
-0.3931828439235687,
-1.0198171138763428,
0.69317227602005,
-0.15793320536613464,
-0.44778892397880554,
0.38253530859947205,
0.34371745586395264,
0.10652674734592438,
1.1524252891540527,
0.6477823257446289,
-0.07043048739433289,
0.4383407533168793,
-0.3736744821071625,
0.05328279361128807,
-0.4195616543292999,
-0.2906951308250427,
-0.4052044153213501,
-0.004346341360360384,
-0.3313089609146118,
-0.3502418100833893,
0.008413595147430897,
0.16927847266197205,
-0.17129097878932953,
0.2773285508155823,
-0.17719274759292603,
0.7203664779663086,
0.6117061376571655,
0.12042970955371857,
0.29120367765426636,
-0.14815962314605713,
-0.5681717991828918,
-0.009785418398678303,
-0.5182985067367554,
-0.4036032259464264,
0.9785886406898499,
0.15562333166599274,
0.4479524791240692,
-0.044766493141651154,
0.5798189043998718,
0.11713811010122299,
0.1831458956003189,
-0.810283899307251,
0.49766474962234497,
0.03546995297074318,
-0.37865573167800903,
-0.23240932822227478,
-0.4601190686225891,
-0.7646198868751526,
0.3510129451751709,
0.06302926689386368,
-0.4745462238788605,
-0.011506471782922745,
0.06868480890989304,
0.05103883519768715,
0.017098957672715187,
-0.8305187821388245,
0.959881603717804,
-0.03457023948431015,
-0.05329158529639244,
0.046342846006155014,
-0.8271051049232483,
0.49261903762817383,
0.1933753490447998,
0.22830034792423248,
-0.05139598250389099,
0.41632720828056335,
0.6353183388710022,
-0.5842791795730591,
0.9631708860397339,
-0.2766387462615967,
-0.08810295164585114,
0.6055160760879517,
-0.02058243378996849,
0.4332040250301361,
-0.21001313626766205,
0.1628098338842392,
-0.25401127338409424,
-0.15331622958183289,
-0.49695059657096863,
-0.7526735663414001,
0.39088040590286255,
-0.6931504011154175,
-0.5500650405883789,
-0.08931386470794678,
-0.5798753499984741,
-0.5827940106391907,
0.5817095637321472,
0.17060603201389313,
0.4717881381511688,
-0.379268616437912,
0.09802129864692688,
0.5089043974876404,
0.07855762541294098,
0.16195270419120789,
0.2917706370353699,
-0.3874788284301758,
-0.5388573408126831,
0.8093249201774597,
-0.007738826330751181,
0.5078025460243225,
0.40487033128738403,
0.4895603358745575,
-0.21738529205322266,
-0.36919310688972473,
0.024579275399446487,
0.12490016222000122,
-1.0839539766311646,
-0.011086974292993546,
-0.712532639503479,
-0.2316623479127884,
-0.7888379693031311,
-0.044446516782045364,
-0.18346433341503143,
-0.562492311000824,
-0.2822989821434021,
-0.4377320110797882,
0.028376132249832153,
1.001232385635376,
0.2423497438430786,
0.563407301902771,
-0.6656548976898193,
0.36655792593955994,
0.7159919738769531,
0.2690013349056244,
-0.13151077926158905,
-0.12395736575126648,
-0.04388923570513725,
0.060286954045295715,
-0.2120361179113388,
-1.0941604375839233,
0.10225880146026611,
0.09038557857275009,
0.6691774725914001,
0.4341176152229309,
-0.1578149050474167,
0.5439972877502441,
-0.5530392527580261,
0.7339592576026917,
0.21039995551109314,
-1.1052567958831787,
0.7081946730613708,
-0.664939284324646,
0.04600433632731438,
0.6439380645751953,
0.34444889426231384,
-0.48694655299186707,
-0.5010828971862793,
-0.6649079918861389,
-0.6897100210189819,
0.3668971061706543,
0.14804241061210632,
0.3857375383377075,
-0.2270546406507492,
0.26743170619010925,
-0.11109200119972229,
0.4092150926589966,
-0.9705606698989868,
-0.11973666399717331,
-0.43379324674606323,
-0.4218275845050812,
-0.012531162239611149,
-0.4966540038585663,
-0.46584129333496094,
-0.4475789964199066,
0.25221171975135803,
-0.3472845256328583,
0.06874854862689972,
-0.002095432486385107,
-0.28922370076179504,
-0.04638507217168808,
0.16839765012264252,
0.5483532547950745,
0.6298407912254333,
-0.08380176872015,
0.49385666847229004,
-0.12858828902244568,
-0.08231331408023834,
0.1699952930212021,
0.009662041440606117,
-0.23129403591156006,
-0.19399650394916534,
0.6747336387634277,
0.8520578742027283,
0.34870535135269165,
-0.5784708857536316,
0.6175282001495361,
0.08363286405801773,
-0.22990693151950836,
-0.16441042721271515,
0.09006882458925247,
0.3676678538322449,
0.04609799385070801,
-0.027795474976301193,
-0.21436698734760284,
0.07565045356750488,
-0.5720160007476807,
0.14278475940227509,
0.4511043131351471,
-0.3568384647369385,
-0.4371904134750366,
0.5038260221481323,
-0.10466713458299637,
0.19430556893348694,
0.6197842955589294,
-0.07643206417560577,
-0.6385741829872131,
0.5258378982543945,
0.7575057744979858,
0.7062889337539673,
-0.13946589827537537,
0.12884129583835602,
0.05735763907432556,
0.2803511321544647,
-0.0435200110077858,
0.46926823258399963,
-0.1460491120815277,
-1.0276436805725098,
-0.45133957266807556,
-0.5149839520454407,
-0.3684726357460022,
-0.014083513990044594,
-0.5769502520561218,
0.23720410466194153,
-0.5034799575805664,
-0.07946902513504028,
-0.3754507601261139,
-0.23115693032741547,
-0.5184198617935181,
0.31119030714035034,
0.09507796168327332,
0.7058690786361694,
-1.356777310371399,
0.6818297505378723,
0.865634024143219,
-0.6096906065940857,
-1.039730429649353,
-0.11632024496793747,
-0.5850977897644043,
-0.6415003538131714,
0.8084931969642639,
0.357233464717865,
0.04307437688112259,
0.2962145209312439,
-0.7012357115745544,
-0.816429078578949,
0.9328535795211792,
0.648009181022644,
0.17644250392913818,
-0.2259737253189087,
0.4207886755466461,
0.5322228670120239,
-0.6009261012077332,
-0.022710110992193222,
0.6764015555381775,
0.6585831046104431,
0.22604578733444214,
-0.42532047629356384,
0.15795467793941498,
-0.2729469835758209,
0.03267380967736244,
-0.08983106911182404,
-0.3432202637195587,
1.0795695781707764,
0.19297176599502563,
-0.21423949301242828,
-0.12850500643253326,
0.7325239777565002,
0.18442247807979584,
0.2722177803516388,
0.3182884156703949,
0.9265416860580444,
0.8176683187484741,
-0.03471272066235542,
1.0289860963821411,
-0.2575981616973877,
0.2469051629304886,
1.1544314622879028,
-0.4222175180912018,
0.2628180980682373,
0.4368360936641693,
-0.0874849185347557,
0.7832725644111633,
0.3489285707473755,
0.1953100711107254,
0.5686137080192566,
0.3863426744937897,
-0.3357076644897461,
-0.37301909923553467,
-0.31978729367256165,
-0.6053775548934937,
0.39537128806114197,
0.1783108413219452,
-0.4421711564064026,
-0.3332720398902893,
-0.011092419736087322,
-0.06625448912382126,
0.42081132531166077,
-0.11103883385658264,
1.0275843143463135,
-0.0771235004067421,
-0.7349636554718018,
0.3515782058238983,
0.19092361629009247,
-0.022692106664180756,
-0.675940752029419,
-0.037359967827796936,
-0.11021309345960617,
-0.21577516198158264,
-0.05751011520624161,
-0.48940208554267883,
0.45201119780540466,
-0.2196946144104004,
-0.28723472356796265,
-0.360125869512558,
1.1213849782943726,
-0.4897122383117676,
-0.6246111989021301,
0.41625791788101196,
0.5752720236778259,
-0.17145080864429474,
-0.28914839029312134,
-0.07557090371847153,
-0.12380580604076385,
-0.3367355167865753,
-0.2293337881565094,
0.18918322026729584,
0.3755123019218445,
-0.1188725158572197,
0.42599451541900635,
0.721803605556488,
-0.06692638248205185,
0.5097435116767883,
0.14662706851959229,
1.3630132675170898,
-0.7050650119781494,
-0.6788235902786255,
-0.7894716262817383,
0.6753877997398376,
-0.11734975874423981,
0.10538976639509201,
0.6261601448059082,
0.5498243570327759,
0.7562191486358643,
-0.3680131137371063,
0.8954989910125732,
-0.07171577960252762,
0.3613680601119995,
-0.8274440765380859,
0.4229121804237366,
-0.2078220546245575,
-0.17727196216583252,
-0.17352864146232605,
-0.8489280343055725,
-0.3534250557422638,
0.4782122075557709,
-0.42697277665138245,
0.18793362379074097,
0.6694780588150024,
0.2719056308269501,
-0.21084904670715332,
0.019553320482373238,
0.4123026430606842,
-0.08530866354703903,
0.2602555453777313,
0.33397549390792847,
1.0746065378189087,
-0.20556597411632538,
-0.11060214042663574,
-0.3507344424724579,
0.04107575863599777,
0.029462378472089767,
-0.9489362835884094,
-0.9675641655921936,
-0.5548201203346252,
-0.12439066171646118,
-0.2030843198299408,
-0.24079662561416626,
0.7018218040466309,
0.6006048321723938,
-0.875960648059845,
-0.1902984380722046,
-0.613343358039856,
0.2329270839691162,
0.05989333614706993,
-0.266611784696579,
0.10523246228694916,
-0.5923452377319336,
-0.4192819893360138,
0.7679051756858826,
-0.11742348968982697,
0.36045369505882263,
-0.0740363672375679,
-0.0413409098982811,
-0.09710253030061722,
0.051999032497406006,
0.6924207806587219,
0.1015908420085907,
-0.48972538113594055,
-0.5492514371871948,
0.0047667971812188625,
0.05215895175933838,
-0.09713322669267654,
1.3312509059906006,
-0.7432690262794495,
0.3302476108074188,
0.77582186460495,
0.6674582958221436,
0.2943355441093445,
0.3477213978767395,
0.7709792256355286,
-1.247421383857727,
0.42855679988861084,
0.23421810567378998,
0.4548325836658478,
0.4898480474948883,
-0.08912188559770584,
0.413158118724823,
0.6486766338348389,
-0.015691541135311127,
-0.6948228478431702,
0.632493257522583,
-0.8620819449424744,
-0.172184556722641,
1.051294207572937,
-0.20631368458271027,
0.14436696469783783,
0.007717874366790056,
-0.06310144066810608,
0.379631370306015,
0.2578712999820709,
0.17226165533065796,
1.0197449922561646,
-0.020473845303058624,
0.07804848253726959,
-0.12253839522600174,
0.34249886870384216,
0.3144379258155823,
-0.820732593536377,
-0.0006429425557143986,
0.7582606077194214,
0.4556119740009308,
0.13113953173160553,
0.7674390077590942,
-0.019771896302700043,
-0.25061723589897156,
-0.08618882298469543,
-0.11175276339054108,
-0.19119887053966522,
-0.31343188881874084,
-0.38962680101394653,
0.42456674575805664,
0.31093254685401917,
0.13779254257678986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04988v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04988v1
|
Language models emulate certain cognitive profiles: An investigation of how predictability measures interact with individual differences
| 2024-06-07T14:54:56 | 2024-06-07T14:54:56 |
Patrick Haller, Lena S. Bolliger, Lena A. Jäger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To date, most investigations on surprisal and entropy effects in reading have
been conducted on the group level, disregarding individual differences. In this
work, we revisit the predictive power of surprisal and entropy measures
estimated from a range of language models (LMs) on data of human reading times
as a measure of processing effort by incorporating information of language
users' cognitive capacities. To do so, we assess the predictive power of
surprisal and entropy estimated from generative LMs on reading data obtained
from individuals who also completed a wide range of psychometric tests.
Specifically, we investigate if modulating surprisal and entropy relative to
cognitive scores increases prediction accuracy of reading times, and we examine
whether LMs exhibit systematic biases in the prediction of reading times for
cognitively high- or low-performing groups, revealing what type of
psycholinguistic subject a given LM emulates. Our study finds that in most
cases, incorporating cognitive capacities increases predictive power of
surprisal and entropy on reading times, and that generally, high performance in
the psychometric tests is associated with lower sensitivity to predictability
effects. Finally, our results suggest that the analyzed LMs emulate readers
with lower verbal intelligence, suggesting that for a given target group (i.e.,
individuals with high verbal intelligence), these LMs provide less accurate
predictability estimates.
|
[
-0.31046202778816223,
-0.4476670026779175,
0.582348108291626,
0.18851299583911896,
-0.05499303713440895,
0.16920453310012817,
-0.3717469274997711,
-0.6833469271659851,
0.24706006050109863,
0.43758624792099,
-0.5513771772384644,
-0.11875972896814346,
-0.5799118876457214,
0.03129514306783676,
-0.1431347131729126,
0.6706886887550354,
0.2052992582321167,
-0.014422441832721233,
-0.317130446434021,
0.31156042218208313,
-0.4953201413154602,
-0.7022033929824829,
-0.11972438544034958,
-0.7482858896255493,
0.4822038412094116,
0.037112440913915634,
1.0270638465881348,
0.6674584746360779,
0.5663431882858276,
0.2222164273262024,
0.12073343992233276,
-0.40085482597351074,
-0.2773999571800232,
0.30137574672698975,
-0.1335500180721283,
-0.7468056082725525,
-0.3958992063999176,
0.2177792340517044,
0.6452437043190002,
0.6893916130065918,
-0.2976692020893097,
0.09999611973762512,
0.31180378794670105,
0.46505242586135864,
-0.6695272922515869,
0.37055230140686035,
-0.588137686252594,
-0.22202281653881073,
-0.3165791928768158,
-0.4300057888031006,
-0.624717116355896,
-0.2224833071231842,
0.18133610486984253,
-0.5571917295455933,
0.3985448181629181,
0.3499091863632202,
0.418486088514328,
0.4674358367919922,
-0.09385579824447632,
-0.3798741102218628,
-0.7826929092407227,
0.9540809392929077,
-0.8268658518791199,
0.426067978143692,
1.0638641119003296,
0.15107077360153198,
0.3165062963962555,
-0.2622601389884949,
-0.5975089073181152,
-0.45460861921310425,
-0.21965302526950836,
0.16551336646080017,
-0.28859323263168335,
0.16501131653785706,
0.36661145091056824,
0.18345646560192108,
-0.4510394036769867,
0.1566867232322693,
-0.7619773149490356,
-0.04629703611135483,
0.6366721987724304,
0.5226685404777527,
0.3181709051132202,
-0.06608739495277405,
0.12362129241228104,
-0.13932064175605774,
-0.0436294786632061,
0.14369066059589386,
0.3273812532424927,
0.38040652871131897,
0.020359164103865623,
0.653079628944397,
-0.09386072307825089,
0.6791809797286987,
-0.13794657588005066,
-0.2008768767118454,
0.401236891746521,
-0.25195491313934326,
-0.2013174295425415,
0.10459385812282562,
0.5819332003593445,
0.3709889352321625,
0.532031774520874,
-0.25060996413230896,
0.022073112428188324,
0.26808175444602966,
0.16741277277469635,
-0.5864208340644836,
-0.3029027283191681,
0.06815022975206375,
-0.3566758930683136,
-0.18478725850582123,
-0.009964517317712307,
-0.6995859742164612,
-0.5542981028556824,
-0.34814003109931946,
0.06442731618881226,
-0.7753417491912842,
-0.11548131704330444,
0.5006997585296631,
-0.2389097660779953,
-0.012992218136787415,
0.10960308462381363,
-1.1855312585830688,
0.42626136541366577,
0.5543445348739624,
0.7828011512756348,
-0.26413610577583313,
-0.3981667160987854,
-0.03230154141783714,
0.20064891874790192,
-0.21280845999717712,
0.735897958278656,
-0.9888045787811279,
-0.26632261276245117,
-0.16921831667423248,
-0.2651523947715759,
-0.43922159075737,
-0.11349992454051971,
0.2500183880329132,
-0.5607852935791016,
0.11250625550746918,
-0.3141770660877228,
-0.6107266545295715,
-0.0561651773750782,
-0.09700247645378113,
-0.8849713206291199,
0.4928402900695801,
-0.02264711819589138,
-0.7823727130889893,
0.4354090988636017,
-0.3065580427646637,
-0.3135557770729065,
0.16057085990905762,
0.03779109939932823,
-0.03877878189086914,
0.2041667252779007,
0.05149172618985176,
0.5412315726280212,
-0.4700016677379608,
0.001039002789184451,
-0.40447133779525757,
-0.4148905277252197,
0.8262523412704468,
-0.6892687678337097,
0.7905148267745972,
0.13137714564800262,
-0.09660491347312927,
-0.3604723811149597,
-0.6336644291877747,
0.3902183473110199,
-0.16390360891819,
-0.5220834016799927,
-0.6684926152229309,
0.28506210446357727,
-0.12705571949481964,
0.08374826610088348,
0.14652834832668304,
-0.6319528818130493,
0.17638517916202545,
-0.33122530579566956,
0.23634202778339386,
0.7725231647491455,
-0.004504521377384663,
0.30387160181999207,
-0.6131369471549988,
0.8195710778236389,
-0.3937484622001648,
-0.2601243257522583,
0.038462091237306595,
-0.3061261773109436,
-0.2891465723514557,
-0.4459680914878845,
0.234102264046669,
0.8441804647445679,
-0.4509938657283783,
0.1519179493188858,
-0.34814924001693726,
-0.842639148235321,
-0.529639482498169,
0.26411113142967224,
0.6287758946418762,
0.10422444343566895,
0.23161053657531738,
-0.253018856048584,
-0.20708917081356049,
-0.6209255456924438,
-0.84781813621521,
-0.49688559770584106,
-0.2511962950229645,
0.35979852080345154,
0.3208405077457428,
-0.013728873804211617,
0.5847409963607788,
-0.6042285561561584,
-0.09758798032999039,
-0.32139894366264343,
0.1563241332769394,
0.22304679453372955,
0.32421156764030457,
0.3881758749485016,
-0.5849275588989258,
-0.33956030011177063,
-0.18310099840164185,
-0.6407967805862427,
-0.3624308705329895,
-0.1518060714006424,
0.26851803064346313,
0.19133366644382477,
0.4697108566761017,
-0.24651184678077698,
0.5022910237312317,
0.5234580636024475,
-0.7267451286315918,
0.5588263869285583,
-0.18983657658100128,
0.17062802612781525,
-0.8022991418838501,
-0.21728220582008362,
0.17036306858062744,
0.32112544775009155,
-0.6509922742843628,
-0.13119526207447052,
0.07405829429626465,
0.26655301451683044,
-0.2034742385149002,
0.5345085859298706,
-0.37689900398254395,
-0.10219161957502365,
-0.005283920094370842,
-0.29976192116737366,
-0.152072012424469,
0.29926347732543945,
0.06480234116315842,
0.611212432384491,
0.459641695022583,
-0.6993433833122253,
0.004111819434911013,
-0.20197013020515442,
-0.8185434937477112,
0.24177105724811554,
-0.7004449367523193,
-0.042950209230184555,
-0.25904273986816406,
-0.05082714185118675,
-0.949871838092804,
-0.37223130464553833,
-0.17555487155914307,
-0.569254457950592,
0.08906485885381699,
0.6488363146781921,
-0.4379284083843231,
-0.04179723933339119,
-0.0598318837583065,
0.46471357345581055,
0.5355734825134277,
-0.007615647744387388,
0.7308729290962219,
0.16505436599254608,
-0.17319048941135406,
-0.5809264779090881,
-1.215240716934204,
-0.35641390085220337,
-0.3172014057636261,
-0.3298695981502533,
0.42327407002449036,
-0.18754442036151886,
-0.7695422768592834,
0.03483468294143677,
0.35513535141944885,
0.006923289503902197,
0.08660785108804703,
0.44946539402008057,
0.33474552631378174,
0.019703498110175133,
0.3584197461605072,
-0.2640911042690277,
-0.025486746802926064,
0.04826674982905388,
0.11321468651294708,
0.6530094742774963,
-0.2520114481449127,
-0.24345412850379944,
-0.4058015048503876,
-0.019003035500645638,
0.6839388608932495,
-0.2949630618095398,
1.0971516370773315,
0.32837146520614624,
-0.3618676960468292,
0.275603711605072,
-0.6885551810264587,
-0.22728562355041504,
-0.3990694284439087,
0.43380996584892273,
-0.6362372636795044,
-0.6208938956260681,
0.5684530138969421,
0.45548421144485474,
-0.012221375480294228,
0.2770315706729889,
0.616406261920929,
-0.2640712559223175,
1.21680748462677,
0.5809063911437988,
-0.007519849576056004,
0.8196383118629456,
-0.08031029999256134,
-0.0232365895062685,
-0.9738911390304565,
-0.19570259749889374,
-0.4879557490348816,
-0.41430655121803284,
-0.6880192756652832,
-0.37808850407600403,
0.17153847217559814,
0.13887043297290802,
-0.10425311326980591,
0.20816589891910553,
-0.2519518733024597,
0.6235204339027405,
0.6553236246109009,
0.10215768218040466,
0.36256495118141174,
0.10227152705192566,
-0.13408467173576355,
-0.3335188925266266,
-0.6072461605072021,
-0.3529316782951355,
1.2551546096801758,
0.23144225776195526,
1.0358123779296875,
0.15087060630321503,
0.24579086899757385,
0.5482269525527954,
0.38571667671203613,
-0.6482897400856018,
0.3994012475013733,
-0.1814417839050293,
-0.7624802589416504,
-0.5590864419937134,
-0.18895670771598816,
-0.9979181885719299,
0.2256348729133606,
-0.13697247207164764,
-0.9921364784240723,
0.37536224722862244,
-0.04346512630581856,
-0.3287791907787323,
0.3544117510318756,
-0.810701310634613,
0.40359774231910706,
-0.14491190016269684,
-0.070029117166996,
-0.5651381611824036,
-0.3564986288547516,
0.29061004519462585,
-0.3184160590171814,
0.32101255655288696,
-0.25302571058273315,
-0.2067069560289383,
0.7505640983581543,
-0.013223901391029358,
1.0480427742004395,
0.15388990938663483,
0.19546593725681305,
0.10247581452131271,
0.34789183735847473,
0.05853899195790291,
-0.29678255319595337,
-0.7485456466674805,
0.3271692991256714,
0.4369257688522339,
-0.5460366010665894,
-0.722385823726654,
0.40871965885162354,
-0.8668902516365051,
-0.7628071308135986,
-0.7701149582862854,
-0.790716826915741,
-0.12909458577632904,
0.012873117811977863,
0.430858314037323,
0.32488763332366943,
-0.24795809388160706,
0.3190043568611145,
0.21378080546855927,
0.07703626155853271,
0.40624794363975525,
0.762921154499054,
-0.10110808163881302,
-0.1405668556690216,
0.7914189696311951,
0.5324995517730713,
0.677539050579071,
0.43922653794288635,
0.2215225249528885,
-0.17255908250808716,
-0.23941172659397125,
0.18903976678848267,
0.18072642385959625,
-0.4178755581378937,
0.20624756813049316,
-0.36473000049591064,
-0.061329375952482224,
-0.6619962453842163,
-0.2600637376308441,
0.03197383135557175,
-0.38519906997680664,
-0.33726412057876587,
-0.15550623834133148,
0.28794026374816895,
0.6127001047134399,
-0.19046545028686523,
0.4177658259868622,
-0.39179080724716187,
0.0013107855338603258,
0.05052291974425316,
0.1942196488380432,
0.03327420353889465,
-0.6483489274978638,
-0.3003731966018677,
-0.10811077058315277,
-0.20693379640579224,
-0.9838768243789673,
0.6180212497711182,
0.1519431471824646,
0.45595747232437134,
0.41751325130462646,
0.05737310275435448,
0.3802255094051361,
-0.2854742705821991,
0.6445842385292053,
0.18941912055015564,
-0.9681752920150757,
0.2874661982059479,
-0.068655826151371,
0.5436672568321228,
0.49543827772140503,
0.28619712591171265,
-0.5787628889083862,
-0.699040949344635,
-0.5618035197257996,
-0.37672731280326843,
0.6387337446212769,
0.1133156567811966,
0.161777064204216,
-0.06268555670976639,
0.3454449474811554,
0.20931263267993927,
-0.034714117646217346,
-0.5118219256401062,
0.0593460351228714,
0.08553929626941681,
-0.04131099954247475,
-0.658213198184967,
-0.2713370621204376,
0.3967480957508087,
-0.37867823243141174,
0.5178921818733215,
0.024237047880887985,
0.09392246603965759,
0.06251014769077301,
0.2739361822605133,
-0.08011691272258759,
0.2773464024066925,
0.44668903946876526,
0.7469106912612915,
-0.46852928400039673,
0.17511770129203796,
0.3267158269882202,
-0.780021071434021,
0.06162872165441513,
-0.05751402676105499,
-0.017578350380063057,
-0.25078824162483215,
0.909106969833374,
0.8053274750709534,
-0.11914768815040588,
-0.7296002507209778,
-0.06263536214828491,
-0.10922060161828995,
0.031015239655971527,
-0.4690878093242645,
0.3949670195579529,
-0.08509659767150879,
0.42478957772254944,
0.2689778804779053,
0.22521467506885529,
0.05826474353671074,
-0.7422837615013123,
-0.15640100836753845,
0.3544410169124603,
-0.4541749954223633,
-0.4670398235321045,
0.4714869260787964,
-0.2722901999950409,
-0.6083434820175171,
0.6131312847137451,
-0.0889153778553009,
-0.425493448972702,
0.687189519405365,
0.687495231628418,
0.6034477949142456,
-0.6755043864250183,
0.03869141265749931,
0.29964640736579895,
0.6042281985282898,
-0.0023897781502455473,
0.288640558719635,
0.06331722438335419,
-1.0379587411880493,
-0.26953673362731934,
-0.6854956746101379,
-0.18648669123649597,
0.14146463572978973,
-0.9969573616981506,
0.020792966708540916,
-0.11938946694135666,
-0.4063166379928589,
0.12180328369140625,
0.16436082124710083,
-0.8861402273178101,
0.3857446312904358,
0.01975184865295887,
0.6326956152915955,
-0.9285547733306885,
0.8119450807571411,
0.38776132464408875,
-0.4898085296154022,
-0.5436457991600037,
0.4319572150707245,
-0.037866123020648956,
-0.8092485070228577,
0.46955177187919617,
0.017147915437817574,
-0.06186048686504364,
-0.04780079424381256,
-0.021292125806212425,
-1.0306873321533203,
1.2122302055358887,
0.414495587348938,
-0.5464527010917664,
-0.2772490382194519,
0.15604478120803833,
0.735522449016571,
-0.3690514862537384,
0.2861914336681366,
0.8855424523353577,
0.34830644726753235,
-0.1824558973312378,
-0.9335123300552368,
0.0858229324221611,
-0.22409777343273163,
0.040284592658281326,
-0.09107145667076111,
-0.5825203061103821,
0.9137206077575684,
-0.47127294540405273,
-0.25889554619789124,
0.007818492129445076,
0.7157848477363586,
0.2061096876859665,
0.3947243094444275,
0.5907958149909973,
0.4706888198852539,
1.1281884908676147,
0.2860262989997864,
1.5911765098571777,
-0.574982762336731,
0.04270040616393089,
1.0083167552947998,
-0.07783866673707962,
0.956242024898529,
0.54823899269104,
-0.29339441657066345,
0.5294986367225647,
0.6231331825256348,
0.13000163435935974,
0.6822794675827026,
0.2169284075498581,
-0.17252062261104584,
-0.4279439449310303,
-0.21543321013450623,
-0.30215057730674744,
0.392110675573349,
0.5942587852478027,
-0.7355296611785889,
0.3116101026535034,
0.25698280334472656,
-0.24152261018753052,
0.11223738640546799,
-0.25532960891723633,
0.49834245443344116,
0.09926809370517731,
-0.7610944509506226,
0.5667231678962708,
0.05076603963971138,
0.5371699333190918,
-0.3698440194129944,
0.4224454164505005,
0.17544077336788177,
0.39163997769355774,
0.006975939963012934,
-1.256986379623413,
0.38412827253341675,
-0.1329498440027237,
-0.5303747057914734,
-0.12873607873916626,
0.7955983877182007,
-0.20424169301986694,
-0.7790625691413879,
0.48135435581207275,
0.6653679609298706,
0.43531283736228943,
-0.03447716310620308,
-0.44962769746780396,
-0.012223702855408192,
0.08845861256122589,
-0.5157474279403687,
0.30593341588974,
0.03701379522681236,
0.0563199482858181,
0.8697968125343323,
0.4193294942378998,
0.33377015590667725,
0.13800881803035736,
0.023826811462640762,
0.34718331694602966,
-0.5802573561668396,
-0.4082135558128357,
-1.1357874870300293,
0.17142856121063232,
0.15325340628623962,
-0.5189282298088074,
0.5427605509757996,
0.44605782628059387,
0.7470672130584717,
-0.045118384063243866,
1.0248408317565918,
0.07802152633666992,
0.4237062633037567,
-0.5330507755279541,
0.6550809144973755,
-0.43934935331344604,
0.25215858221054077,
-0.19258518517017365,
-0.8545960187911987,
-0.06432215869426727,
0.3588162660598755,
-0.8464315533638,
0.1098765879869461,
0.7170231342315674,
0.7129315733909607,
0.09604090452194214,
0.20658384263515472,
0.5206864476203918,
0.32686203718185425,
0.0509389266371727,
0.6975417137145996,
0.5592905282974243,
-0.0094843078404665,
0.18624897301197052,
-0.3593832850456238,
-0.3765304684638977,
-0.1446976214647293,
-0.533886194229126,
-1.1948790550231934,
-0.8894581198692322,
-0.18776880204677582,
-0.5237305760383606,
-0.0003730672178789973,
0.6349697709083557,
0.34025269746780396,
-0.6070990562438965,
-0.1980653554201126,
-0.0862514078617096,
-0.053789518773555756,
-0.44573745131492615,
-0.3119160234928131,
0.3227704167366028,
-0.10846081376075745,
-0.723089873790741,
0.09124427288770676,
-0.026054179295897484,
-0.02572387084364891,
-0.38794711232185364,
-0.11039461195468903,
0.1262272596359253,
0.7631747722625732,
0.2924095392227173,
0.1831311285495758,
-0.9523188471794128,
-0.08411257714033127,
0.15253643691539764,
-0.36568784713745117,
-0.2651783525943756,
0.6273772716522217,
-0.7983134388923645,
0.5617009401321411,
0.7481264472007751,
0.35555222630500793,
0.4531443119049072,
-0.024361448362469673,
0.6263399124145508,
-0.3685685396194458,
-0.08993963152170181,
0.2467268705368042,
0.3198910355567932,
0.05554651468992233,
-0.584267795085907,
0.5220518112182617,
0.12602581083774567,
-0.43466973304748535,
-0.8546717166900635,
0.18330982327461243,
-0.5502787828445435,
-0.3359641432762146,
1.0585131645202637,
0.0016207353910431266,
-0.19297312200069427,
0.015027248300611973,
0.022680513560771942,
0.19724245369434357,
-0.2832024097442627,
0.9963803887367249,
1.3305402994155884,
-0.42690280079841614,
-0.07840804755687714,
-0.7396445274353027,
0.3463729918003082,
0.6444733738899231,
-0.5007649660110474,
0.25994086265563965,
0.1589774489402771,
0.15844999253749847,
0.3606546223163605,
0.6457475423812866,
0.1817403882741928,
0.22097247838974,
0.0824035257101059,
-0.036109331995248795,
0.03204973414540291,
-0.1852411925792694,
-0.3113364279270172,
0.020089682191610336,
-0.19371554255485535,
0.2599622309207916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04984v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04984v1
|
MEFT: Memory-Efficient Fine-Tuning through Sparse Adapter
| 2024-06-07T14:49:22 | 2024-06-07T14:49:22 |
Jitai Hao, WeiWei Sun, Xin Xin, Qi Meng, Zhumin Chen, Pengjie Ren, Zhaochun Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Parameter-Efficient Fine-tuning (PEFT) facilitates the fine-tuning of Large
Language Models (LLMs) under limited resources. However, the fine-tuning
performance with PEFT on complex, knowledge-intensive tasks is limited due to
the constrained model capacity, which originates from the limited number of
additional trainable parameters. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a
novel mechanism that fine-tunes LLMs with adapters of larger size yet
memory-efficient. This is achieved by leveraging the inherent activation
sparsity in the Feed-Forward Networks (FFNs) of LLMs and utilizing the larger
capacity of Central Processing Unit (CPU) memory compared to Graphics
Processing Unit (GPU). We store and update the parameters of larger adapters on
the CPU. Moreover, we employ a Mixture of Experts (MoE)-like architecture to
mitigate unnecessary CPU computations and reduce the communication volume
between the GPU and CPU. This is particularly beneficial over the limited
bandwidth of PCI Express (PCIe). Our method can achieve fine-tuning results
comparable to those obtained with larger memory capacities, even when operating
under more limited resources such as a 24GB memory single GPU setup, with
acceptable loss in training efficiency. Our codes are available at
https://github.com/CURRENTF/MEFT.
|
[
-0.6326014399528503,
-1.0338951349258423,
0.4087696373462677,
0.12850798666477203,
-0.38004499673843384,
-0.0321207195520401,
-0.5624797344207764,
-0.13589264452457428,
0.1314282864332199,
0.239862859249115,
-0.5225157737731934,
0.2111530750989914,
-0.4495762586593628,
-0.015913890674710274,
0.07897073775529861,
0.6918460130691528,
-0.017145048826932907,
-0.22525009512901306,
0.0605732761323452,
-0.12505319714546204,
-0.305046945810318,
-0.18114422261714935,
-0.9631524682044983,
-0.23793692886829376,
0.5399796366691589,
0.3512403070926666,
0.5380734205245972,
0.7582798004150391,
0.3218882083892822,
0.342886745929718,
-0.010369226336479187,
0.33717459440231323,
-0.6960359811782837,
-0.13022707402706146,
-0.2161325365304947,
-0.20382581651210785,
-0.5803472995758057,
-0.3435916006565094,
0.7072044610977173,
0.6429034471511841,
-0.10159812867641449,
0.09126649796962738,
0.3302285969257355,
0.8263036608695984,
-0.7255850434303284,
0.03963880613446236,
-1.0051189661026,
-0.16105234622955322,
-0.21484962105751038,
-0.47612664103507996,
-0.24154500663280487,
0.1421283781528473,
-0.17318949103355408,
-0.6851135492324829,
0.23356960713863373,
0.06732134521007538,
0.6967831254005432,
0.6333779096603394,
0.17084535956382751,
0.3636346161365509,
-0.677594006061554,
0.8463225960731506,
-0.6402308940887451,
0.49640944600105286,
0.08209838718175888,
0.32071343064308167,
-0.22353991866111755,
-0.4113676846027374,
-0.5614107251167297,
0.13006895780563354,
0.14129671454429626,
-0.09802242368459702,
-0.32088086009025574,
0.2691679298877716,
0.26405835151672363,
0.20134611427783966,
-0.5610507130622864,
-0.021587874740362167,
-0.30313578248023987,
-0.17299121618270874,
0.3167392611503601,
0.06657861918210983,
-0.09711393713951111,
0.49346137046813965,
-0.18151673674583435,
0.07987800985574722,
-0.8337891101837158,
-0.12480291724205017,
0.3019695580005646,
0.43743398785591125,
0.098024383187294,
0.1778837889432907,
-0.3510608971118927,
0.973666250705719,
0.5056565999984741,
-0.20707117021083832,
0.09994886070489883,
-0.09499113261699677,
-0.392916202545166,
-0.09177638590335846,
0.6875607967376709,
0.19304680824279785,
0.27421754598617554,
-0.35944437980651855,
-0.28310224413871765,
-0.2797697186470032,
0.2292596697807312,
-0.9527454376220703,
-0.3305061161518097,
-0.10948057472705841,
-0.36098170280456543,
-0.0274727214127779,
-0.3961338400840759,
-0.7412965893745422,
-0.0815400779247284,
-0.30084383487701416,
0.5378966927528381,
-0.3760834336280823,
-0.298525333404541,
0.13428498804569244,
-0.04446985572576523,
0.20489104092121124,
0.3947257399559021,
-1.3904445171356201,
0.3913544714450836,
0.6670453548431396,
0.7109959125518799,
-0.016021262854337692,
-0.34191733598709106,
-0.6519286036491394,
0.2619023025035858,
-0.11926998943090439,
0.8367456197738647,
-0.6219625473022461,
-0.00970823410898447,
-0.38737037777900696,
0.0257280170917511,
-0.4687018394470215,
-0.741051197052002,
0.41161906719207764,
-0.5584867596626282,
-0.5186188817024231,
-0.21678628027439117,
-0.3499935269355774,
-0.18834249675273895,
0.2272016406059265,
-0.5208582282066345,
0.777030885219574,
0.20163439214229584,
-0.2174379527568817,
0.15149430930614471,
-0.3855133056640625,
-0.27363941073417664,
0.11568114161491394,
-0.356464684009552,
-0.2519385814666748,
0.3505547046661377,
0.11085479706525803,
0.7384722828865051,
-0.37749946117401123,
0.24964475631713867,
-0.5268016457557678,
-0.716031014919281,
0.07210993766784668,
-0.6531068086624146,
0.2267645001411438,
0.42637214064598083,
-0.08369991183280945,
0.021921638399362564,
-0.811488687992096,
-0.12880928814411163,
-0.008576203137636185,
-0.6723566055297852,
-0.26810508966445923,
-0.05311586335301399,
0.24437034130096436,
0.045173220336437225,
0.518502950668335,
-0.48665982484817505,
0.15172842144966125,
-0.35591578483581543,
0.8018930554389954,
0.8078747391700745,
-0.2605607509613037,
0.6333423852920532,
-0.21916954219341278,
0.10519322752952576,
-0.21439199149608612,
0.2574896216392517,
-0.19794432818889618,
-0.34702253341674805,
-0.5551149249076843,
-0.33184269070625305,
0.2546806335449219,
0.4776218831539154,
-0.5293141603469849,
0.49991336464881897,
-0.26562434434890747,
-0.26226240396499634,
-0.46805110573768616,
0.3919850289821625,
0.1883920431137085,
0.6104465126991272,
0.375553697347641,
0.09061414748430252,
-0.26877978444099426,
-0.9877047538757324,
-0.26948657631874084,
0.14511188864707947,
0.07043515890836716,
0.6325936317443848,
0.02391272597014904,
-0.08603908121585846,
0.4920153319835663,
-0.4001142978668213,
-0.2583906650543213,
-0.05483490228652954,
-0.16270051896572113,
0.45439594984054565,
0.8246370553970337,
0.7558370232582092,
-0.4708687663078308,
-0.5162283778190613,
0.19627942144870758,
-0.23725688457489014,
-0.12487814575433731,
-0.35657933354377747,
-0.14607210457324982,
0.10461269319057465,
0.6491888761520386,
-0.3746645152568817,
-0.00774193461984396,
0.5518044829368591,
-0.31233999133110046,
0.18391068279743195,
-0.6479875445365906,
0.09046255797147751,
-0.7448964715003967,
-0.06627196818590164,
-0.01865207776427269,
-0.3061867952346802,
-0.3673795163631439,
-0.1552204191684723,
0.2220430225133896,
0.0686778873205185,
-0.1912362277507782,
0.5666368007659912,
-0.2880449891090393,
0.3230833113193512,
-0.5200009942054749,
-0.2542594373226166,
-0.13083012402057648,
0.8306593894958496,
-0.21587194502353668,
1.114802360534668,
0.6375294327735901,
-0.639370322227478,
0.04577253386378288,
-0.17506015300750732,
0.18745622038841248,
0.4326953589916229,
-0.47576776146888733,
-0.06390479952096939,
0.002938511548563838,
-0.2690611779689789,
-0.9486802220344543,
-0.08042670786380768,
0.2625730633735657,
-0.11950545758008957,
0.7094916105270386,
-0.18252335488796234,
-0.5501837730407715,
-0.0852043628692627,
-0.32907772064208984,
0.49274301528930664,
0.5649816989898682,
-0.7365413308143616,
0.7715098857879639,
0.46534809470176697,
-0.08876599371433258,
-0.4595533609390259,
-0.4419347941875458,
-0.06269936263561249,
-0.1655062735080719,
-0.598818302154541,
0.4234638810157776,
-0.35157614946365356,
0.12625804543495178,
-0.1679648905992508,
-0.29208067059516907,
-0.26218366622924805,
0.2851758301258087,
-0.0784168690443039,
0.03935312479734421,
-0.38120123744010925,
-0.0016958562191575766,
0.8425998687744141,
-0.2521582245826721,
-0.19441325962543488,
-0.40288037061691284,
0.6256573796272278,
-0.3557059168815613,
-0.10179412364959717,
-0.23866628110408783,
0.29307985305786133,
0.4962629973888397,
0.06446914374828339,
0.7571004033088684,
0.6446090936660767,
-0.33990782499313354,
-0.2562076449394226,
-0.7868143916130066,
-0.26880669593811035,
-0.5763287544250488,
0.4949292838573456,
-0.5136280059814453,
-1.3648055791854858,
0.41872283816337585,
-0.5858398675918579,
0.09689819067716599,
0.3958742916584015,
0.5187270641326904,
-0.012255343608558178,
0.9085696339607239,
0.6088029146194458,
-0.29800161719322205,
0.5953508019447327,
0.03185589239001274,
0.14518386125564575,
-0.9140850305557251,
0.21081730723381042,
-0.2832684814929962,
-0.6972101330757141,
-0.3620804250240326,
-0.5884920358657837,
0.32124704122543335,
0.32774844765663147,
-0.3460511565208435,
0.1284952312707901,
-0.7020693421363831,
0.718817412853241,
0.348971426486969,
0.2686545252799988,
0.08341901004314423,
0.12506601214408875,
-0.07658357173204422,
0.011657136492431164,
-0.7996013164520264,
-0.3578972816467285,
0.9358988404273987,
0.3403779864311218,
0.9419151544570923,
-0.25314629077911377,
0.292350709438324,
-0.02667512744665146,
-0.03320944681763649,
-0.44106319546699524,
0.5796696543693542,
-0.4802154302597046,
-0.3297173082828522,
-0.2857554256916046,
-0.3005826771259308,
-0.6648319959640503,
0.15797582268714905,
-0.3710004687309265,
-0.7131953835487366,
0.4025193452835083,
0.5405191779136658,
-0.5913313031196594,
0.47747382521629333,
-0.728373646736145,
0.6797930598258972,
-0.21408429741859436,
-0.7337563633918762,
-0.6291739344596863,
-0.3965674042701721,
0.03919944539666176,
-0.3017937242984772,
-0.1755358725786209,
-0.357156366109848,
-0.25626176595687866,
0.6066234111785889,
-0.2884800434112549,
0.699789822101593,
-0.3394913971424103,
0.17383748292922974,
0.05019700899720192,
-0.10794848948717117,
0.42936229705810547,
0.20440596342086792,
-0.18843260407447815,
0.23066501319408417,
-0.1477741003036499,
-0.4120897054672241,
-0.4458200931549072,
1.059385895729065,
-0.8670802116394043,
-0.4036133885383606,
0.16601499915122986,
-0.8209781646728516,
-0.32269272208213806,
0.2921763062477112,
-0.03827327489852905,
0.3343529999256134,
-0.0612536184489727,
0.19919532537460327,
1.0527276992797852,
-0.17706161737442017,
0.42606496810913086,
0.5781125426292419,
0.17010368406772614,
-0.2945477366447449,
1.1954922676086426,
0.18393413722515106,
-0.03125453740358353,
0.6023702621459961,
0.10304275155067444,
-0.015401226468384266,
-0.9066080451011658,
-0.6530419588088989,
0.3555643856525421,
-0.2304181158542633,
-0.3807185888290405,
-0.5227745771408081,
-0.16330952942371368,
-0.06480488181114197,
-0.2722403407096863,
-0.6817007064819336,
-0.5613135695457458,
-0.3952934443950653,
0.22540120780467987,
0.663887619972229,
0.17423662543296814,
-0.10059377551078796,
0.8271128535270691,
-0.5551961660385132,
0.11413664370775223,
0.38162103295326233,
0.8425471782684326,
0.0461302176117897,
-0.7137790322303772,
-0.38247355818748474,
-0.20145832002162933,
-0.3689863681793213,
-0.46484869718551636,
0.16398859024047852,
0.5253470540046692,
0.6540546417236328,
0.7216438055038452,
-0.22155635058879852,
1.0473588705062866,
-0.6097974181175232,
0.15671944618225098,
-0.017629185691475868,
-0.7229763865470886,
0.2206486612558365,
-0.5636202692985535,
0.11818453669548035,
0.7723678350448608,
-0.06788357347249985,
0.15153822302818298,
-0.2331709861755371,
-0.3883269727230072,
-0.7911686301231384,
0.7508680820465088,
-0.12125426530838013,
0.3191877603530884,
0.18459314107894897,
0.9186153411865234,
0.14952857792377472,
0.08983837813138962,
-0.24362072348594666,
-0.3212915360927582,
0.07629110664129257,
-0.193098783493042,
-0.04157310351729393,
-0.37692543864250183,
0.01511305570602417,
-0.5742685794830322,
0.7883195877075195,
-0.3991506099700928,
0.3969838321208954,
0.09915567934513092,
-0.0036870052572339773,
-0.5222806334495544,
0.28418517112731934,
0.5808338522911072,
0.6973955035209656,
-0.31248506903648376,
0.1687682569026947,
0.48536422848701477,
-0.5425387620925903,
-0.21232187747955322,
0.4215714633464813,
-0.2278899848461151,
-0.25070974230766296,
-0.3196357786655426,
0.8466361165046692,
0.42307186126708984,
-0.7348296642303467,
0.19438602030277252,
-0.31366774439811707,
-0.43725332617759705,
0.07023807615041733,
0.4216577708721161,
0.1562250405550003,
0.5479708313941956,
0.3367440700531006,
0.5754611492156982,
0.16685546934604645,
0.06269951164722443,
0.20872440934181213,
0.7167903780937195,
-0.23656795918941498,
-0.4649009108543396,
0.8283786177635193,
0.12511225044727325,
-0.0032453846652060747,
0.3684190809726715,
-0.062130581587553024,
-0.12190511077642441,
0.24112197756767273,
0.6349982023239136,
0.6498799920082092,
-0.2685345709323883,
-0.3381114602088928,
0.48954498767852783,
0.4088156223297119,
-0.1463788002729416,
0.3579399585723877,
-0.16774751245975494,
-0.7521716952323914,
-0.6300172805786133,
-0.8589513301849365,
-0.1034093126654625,
0.3803139925003052,
-0.24213726818561554,
0.1493532359600067,
-0.868564784526825,
0.09314480423927307,
-0.0572173036634922,
-0.1294175386428833,
-0.4892415702342987,
0.013487457297742367,
0.37394773960113525,
1.2699313163757324,
-0.6812527179718018,
1.1400142908096313,
0.8388216495513916,
0.15196426212787628,
-0.9740749597549438,
-0.33017775416374207,
-0.37819087505340576,
-0.8202574849128723,
-0.030057311058044434,
-0.047484006732702255,
-0.0071500930935144424,
0.12932807207107544,
-0.5109733939170837,
-0.6642608642578125,
1.0622445344924927,
0.8178552985191345,
-1.0227112770080566,
0.3111077547073364,
-0.010822582989931107,
0.4054742157459259,
-0.2700231671333313,
0.09726178646087646,
0.7378232479095459,
0.4724620282649994,
0.08329718559980392,
-0.8806593418121338,
0.1320263147354126,
-0.42082709074020386,
-0.11503376066684723,
0.36661338806152344,
-0.8811922669410706,
1.0025346279144287,
0.08926983922719955,
0.34606844186782837,
-0.07184749096632004,
0.6769654750823975,
0.3644086718559265,
0.018314799293875694,
0.6672526001930237,
0.584633469581604,
0.818744957447052,
-0.08434630185365677,
0.6319233179092407,
-0.621236264705658,
0.22614280879497528,
0.810344398021698,
0.0981760174036026,
0.8751969337463379,
0.7932854294776917,
-0.17106126248836517,
-0.024808576330542564,
0.4304487109184265,
-0.059579189866781235,
0.6362341642379761,
0.06568843871355057,
-0.38171833753585815,
-0.5970392227172852,
0.2005646824836731,
-0.15960916876792908,
0.07186879962682724,
0.5224428176879883,
-0.3101680278778076,
-0.40894651412963867,
-0.021132903173565865,
-0.0871305987238884,
-0.02336183190345764,
-0.6691875457763672,
0.8456716537475586,
0.068477563560009,
-0.5265883803367615,
0.7104160189628601,
0.07483530044555664,
0.8250100016593933,
-0.48298579454421997,
-0.1008668839931488,
-0.008140463382005692,
0.5944145321846008,
-0.08648709952831268,
-0.5428258180618286,
0.5147058963775635,
-0.22422097623348236,
-0.5096375942230225,
-0.17296843230724335,
0.9750038385391235,
-0.49378982186317444,
-0.32515308260917664,
0.22563765943050385,
0.5542070865631104,
0.024462204426527023,
-0.4277246594429016,
-0.9294901490211487,
0.14078272879123688,
-0.042244262993335724,
-0.15950310230255127,
0.8026435971260071,
0.5393628478050232,
0.11747755110263824,
0.39957642555236816,
0.5198732018470764,
0.1642725169658661,
0.25409695506095886,
-0.07669185101985931,
1.228447675704956,
-0.3726845383644104,
-0.42656955122947693,
-1.0339860916137695,
0.07980030030012131,
0.19053833186626434,
-0.1138933002948761,
0.47791633009910583,
0.7374669909477234,
0.6093923449516296,
-0.15073131024837494,
0.7182102203369141,
-0.03567036986351013,
0.32920926809310913,
-0.2775958180427551,
0.9201397895812988,
-0.6075063943862915,
0.39294928312301636,
-0.01723417267203331,
-0.6494441628456116,
-0.2869182825088501,
0.8043186068534851,
-0.21451279520988464,
-0.20551513135433197,
0.19594207406044006,
0.9363516569137573,
-0.4641145169734955,
0.023490723222494125,
0.4736640453338623,
0.3716711401939392,
0.10279097408056259,
0.7669200301170349,
0.3855572044849396,
-0.41660696268081665,
0.6227436661720276,
-0.2891767621040344,
-0.45228657126426697,
-0.10906773805618286,
-0.7213530540466309,
-1.033610224723816,
-0.4399484694004059,
-0.22307896614074707,
0.04329615831375122,
0.11339780688285828,
0.8599122166633606,
0.8409653902053833,
-0.8676307797431946,
-0.08988205343484879,
-0.29985013604164124,
0.048777539283037186,
-0.2317773401737213,
-0.14306074380874634,
0.2945924401283264,
-0.4961754381656647,
-0.6324445009231567,
0.35429540276527405,
0.584844172000885,
-0.22359156608581543,
0.07444214820861816,
-0.2995103895664215,
0.04978955537080765,
0.1294695883989334,
0.5042898058891296,
0.31778520345687866,
-0.4885605573654175,
-0.12061313539743423,
-0.005677304230630398,
0.32030078768730164,
0.2200213521718979,
0.6859282851219177,
-0.9252997636795044,
0.37630513310432434,
0.394056111574173,
0.9176716804504395,
0.28564831614494324,
-0.18949083983898163,
0.5742307305335999,
-0.6337164044380188,
0.15627649426460266,
-0.06507568806409836,
0.5642409324645996,
0.023757662624120712,
-0.5216094851493835,
0.23267534375190735,
0.14013135433197021,
-0.7309060096740723,
-0.6237502098083496,
-0.26264917850494385,
-1.41484534740448,
-0.30762404203414917,
0.8334324955940247,
0.08358732610940933,
-0.46253007650375366,
-0.15846718847751617,
-0.3040544390678406,
0.15449585020542145,
-0.6325028538703918,
0.762850284576416,
0.22914883494377136,
-0.309103786945343,
-0.39385735988616943,
-0.4552169740200043,
0.5479583740234375,
0.438666969537735,
-0.550441324710846,
0.17215053737163544,
0.06339908391237259,
0.4029195010662079,
-0.040528975427150726,
0.7915010452270508,
0.1061919629573822,
0.3689576983451843,
-0.18556934595108032,
-0.32269126176834106,
-0.28212854266166687,
-0.19586369395256042,
-0.4364127516746521,
0.14386752247810364,
0.10821996629238129,
-0.03008151613175869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06620v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06620v1
|
DualTime: A Dual-Adapter Multimodal Language Model for Time Series Representation
| 2024-06-07T14:34:28 | 2024-06-07T14:34:28 |
Weiqi Zhang, Jiexia Ye, Ziyue Li, Jia Li, Fugee Tsung
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The recent rapid development of language models (LMs) has attracted attention
in the field of time series, including multimodal time series modeling.
However, we note that current time series multimodal methods are biased, often
assigning a primary role to one modality while the other assumes a secondary
role. They overlook the mutual benefits and complementary of different
modalities. For example, in seizure diagnosis, relying solely on textual
clinical reports makes it difficult to pinpoint the area and type of the
disease, while electroencephalograms (EEGs) alone cannot provide an accurate
diagnosis without considering the symptoms. In this study, based on the
complementary information mining of time series multimodal data, we propose
DualTime, a Dual-adapter multimodal language model for Time series
representation implementing temporal-primary and textual-primary modeling
simultaneously. By injecting lightweight adaption tokens, the LM pipeline
shared by dual adapters encourages embedding alignment and achieves efficient
fine-tuning. Empirically, our method outperforms state-of-the-art models in
both supervised and unsupervised settings, highlighting the complementary
benefits of different modalities. In addition, we conduct few-shot label
transfer experiments, which further verifies the transferability and
expressiveness of our proposed DualTime.
|
[
-0.058740898966789246,
-0.5829134583473206,
0.47137895226478577,
0.37286221981048584,
-0.43530207872390747,
0.05931638926267624,
-0.34042778611183167,
-0.584886908531189,
0.24082617461681366,
0.16798874735832214,
-0.5730526447296143,
-0.17530933022499084,
-0.49822407960891724,
-0.16475026309490204,
-0.10907629877328873,
0.7619010210037231,
-0.1314363032579422,
0.20295606553554535,
0.07412378489971161,
-0.39035564661026,
-0.44032832980155945,
-0.4219718277454376,
-0.5929228663444519,
-0.498258113861084,
0.6331387758255005,
0.08267770707607269,
0.5815166234970093,
0.23188258707523346,
0.27239763736724854,
0.18695417046546936,
0.3308594822883606,
0.155669167637825,
0.18023160099983215,
0.06116857752203941,
-0.013971121050417423,
-0.29650065302848816,
-0.4613969922065735,
-0.21697966754436493,
0.7112685441970825,
0.7607309818267822,
-0.16800422966480255,
0.3115256130695343,
0.0849178209900856,
0.27158963680267334,
-0.3023069500923157,
0.22610418498516083,
-0.28336140513420105,
0.06569044291973114,
-0.28514114022254944,
-0.36793389916419983,
-0.4529939591884613,
0.10683806240558624,
0.031851183623075485,
-0.4845418334007263,
0.21769773960113525,
-0.029321162030100822,
0.4752657115459442,
0.2920978367328644,
-1.1213488578796387,
0.1589815616607666,
-0.8751921057701111,
0.8398028016090393,
-0.568125307559967,
0.35436972975730896,
-0.005689026787877083,
0.5002354383468628,
0.2548537850379944,
-0.6804208755493164,
-0.6206564903259277,
-0.20645156502723694,
-0.1510269194841385,
0.01758575439453125,
0.048786554485559464,
-0.11658833920955658,
0.12224766612052917,
0.2350727915763855,
-0.5131980180740356,
0.19712534546852112,
-0.013471938669681549,
-0.40205904841423035,
0.22465994954109192,
0.3162725865840912,
0.5308129191398621,
-0.16117161512374878,
-0.6674659252166748,
0.08014492690563202,
-0.23287853598594666,
0.1471158117055893,
0.35710686445236206,
0.3422650694847107,
-0.26505059003829956,
0.5177801251411438,
0.2027222216129303,
0.3874710202217102,
-0.08675482124090195,
-0.0824887603521347,
0.19089269638061523,
-0.6236329674720764,
0.029702717438340187,
0.16493183374404907,
0.7182846069335938,
0.5788345336914062,
-0.1283479779958725,
-0.2748582661151886,
0.04583872854709625,
0.3106827437877655,
0.16491521894931793,
-0.8212948441505432,
-0.27982616424560547,
0.15238451957702637,
-0.7009295225143433,
-0.19051042199134827,
-0.3035399913787842,
-1.1431883573532104,
-0.5617110133171082,
-0.5384361743927002,
0.6127393245697021,
-0.44392484426498413,
-0.6676743030548096,
0.11795714497566223,
-0.1862393021583557,
-0.18281137943267822,
0.14366410672664642,
-0.8074739575386047,
0.2535763382911682,
0.20925109088420868,
0.8468791842460632,
0.03202028200030327,
-0.0945696085691452,
-0.4545000195503235,
0.344343364238739,
0.05003317445516586,
0.7864225506782532,
-0.5841100811958313,
-0.4397728741168976,
-0.3692593276500702,
0.3245514929294586,
-0.2184968739748001,
-0.01234214287251234,
0.38503310084342957,
-0.5564321279525757,
0.24881193041801453,
-0.1275949478149414,
-0.16568602621555328,
-0.24494633078575134,
-0.14478638768196106,
-0.7896872758865356,
0.7150968909263611,
-0.1464814990758896,
-0.6869753003120422,
0.5973936319351196,
-0.658603847026825,
-0.4046211540699005,
-0.12643198668956757,
0.01085649337619543,
-0.2473888397216797,
-0.15485233068466187,
0.4698629379272461,
0.3635461926460266,
-0.2281532883644104,
0.46587246656417847,
-0.5817131996154785,
0.11116701364517212,
0.27838069200515747,
-0.8018800020217896,
0.5957728028297424,
0.13289999961853027,
-0.018790094181895256,
-0.0995195284485817,
-0.7094765305519104,
-0.06843317300081253,
0.19673602283000946,
0.01617002859711647,
-0.6610416173934937,
0.23604752123355865,
0.5527880787849426,
0.27170249819755554,
0.424093633890152,
-0.6768182516098022,
0.331624835729599,
-0.15564556419849396,
0.42536696791648865,
0.7598960995674133,
-0.018777860328555107,
0.42221593856811523,
-0.4715214967727661,
0.41094109416007996,
0.508762538433075,
0.05851079151034355,
-0.5149788856506348,
-0.27183452248573303,
-0.43109312653541565,
-0.23735928535461426,
0.21552132070064545,
0.6801407337188721,
-0.7694540619850159,
0.16415873169898987,
-0.5287282466888428,
-0.3094108998775482,
-0.42546987533569336,
-0.0638962835073471,
0.017171448096632957,
0.42433735728263855,
0.48348280787467957,
-0.32815536856651306,
-0.6034104824066162,
-0.9854317903518677,
-0.31511226296424866,
-0.04252390190958977,
0.10824097692966461,
0.15721938014030457,
0.07823099195957184,
-0.5157150626182556,
0.7664899230003357,
-0.39300161600112915,
-0.18949195742607117,
-0.053432680666446686,
0.4516366124153137,
0.2837275266647339,
0.20415960252285004,
0.83246248960495,
-0.6875765919685364,
-0.2319527566432953,
0.0787007287144661,
-0.7465491890907288,
-0.1558520644903183,
-0.17629218101501465,
0.23135074973106384,
0.10701785981655121,
0.08294623345136642,
-0.045834727585315704,
0.27447736263275146,
0.796724796295166,
-0.5900027751922607,
0.37879809737205505,
-0.2391577810049057,
0.2967732548713684,
-1.273628830909729,
0.10049241036176682,
0.13091732561588287,
-0.3751387894153595,
-0.40481650829315186,
-0.5057726502418518,
0.13554298877716064,
-0.10085109621286392,
0.11281725764274597,
0.7797409892082214,
-0.4116334617137909,
0.2760453224182129,
-0.2503577470779419,
-0.17851665616035461,
0.2229531854391098,
0.3469814360141754,
-0.000743705895729363,
0.592298686504364,
0.5384356379508972,
-0.5125996470451355,
0.458086222410202,
-0.34946373105049133,
-0.2767474353313446,
0.4218282103538513,
-0.5489736199378967,
0.05120408907532692,
-0.2952989637851715,
0.06639200448989868,
-0.8667697906494141,
0.007071600761264563,
0.1601756066083908,
-0.02144140750169754,
0.7457813024520874,
-0.4423016905784607,
-0.4781421720981598,
-0.20655706524848938,
-0.2455100119113922,
0.738277792930603,
0.22152438759803772,
-0.7953029274940491,
0.7317655086517334,
0.4200487732887268,
-0.37163081765174866,
-0.5072347521781921,
-0.8060542345046997,
-0.008516242727637291,
-0.30474603176116943,
-0.9196847081184387,
0.6123540997505188,
-0.17380009591579437,
-0.11187184602022171,
0.15987655520439148,
-0.22785630822181702,
-0.058354295790195465,
-0.11167902499437332,
0.20549635589122772,
0.4960959553718567,
-0.3764064311981201,
0.4454917907714844,
0.04959782958030701,
-0.28953588008880615,
-0.28159162402153015,
-0.2240646481513977,
0.44904035329818726,
-0.11421214044094086,
-0.547782838344574,
-0.30934938788414,
0.5377382636070251,
0.6107832193374634,
-0.005154335871338844,
0.7163987159729004,
0.7878096103668213,
-0.3985031247138977,
-0.19454072415828705,
-0.5134040117263794,
-0.2359355390071869,
-0.4309411942958832,
0.16155299544334412,
-0.3089025020599365,
-0.5169366002082825,
0.35387277603149414,
0.06855642050504684,
-0.023736774921417236,
0.24789103865623474,
0.40238913893699646,
0.11850510537624359,
1.1359351873397827,
0.5052497982978821,
-0.07123854011297226,
0.7997590899467468,
0.054825082421302795,
0.3906629681587219,
-0.8440184593200684,
-0.22687694430351257,
-0.09058049321174622,
-0.4947969615459442,
-0.33236220479011536,
-0.21963392198085785,
0.6273941397666931,
-0.16445744037628174,
0.07457936555147171,
0.0994713306427002,
-0.3544458746910095,
-0.006471282336860895,
0.25512582063674927,
0.32476887106895447,
0.4433456361293793,
0.21153727173805237,
-0.21437034010887146,
-0.4535711407661438,
-0.4402412474155426,
-0.6125341057777405,
1.3504003286361694,
0.256134033203125,
1.0356742143630981,
0.24317491054534912,
0.20248447358608246,
0.5060882568359375,
0.11149552464485168,
-0.7260192632675171,
0.14412543177604675,
-0.5076180696487427,
-0.459869384765625,
0.12728559970855713,
-0.3350332975387573,
-0.8324065208435059,
0.30147069692611694,
-0.07169967889785767,
-0.65902179479599,
0.2999066412448883,
0.2471104860305786,
-0.519287645816803,
0.5235771536827087,
-1.128884196281433,
0.9797667264938354,
-0.5277267694473267,
-0.635817289352417,
-0.43842369318008423,
-0.4949494004249573,
0.3079337775707245,
0.03833682835102081,
0.49254828691482544,
-0.2455180287361145,
-0.10460899770259857,
0.8346449136734009,
-0.1496601700782776,
0.9901957511901855,
-0.33176499605178833,
0.2651446461677551,
0.09527388215065002,
0.12208067625761032,
0.11221033334732056,
0.5428884029388428,
0.16667558252811432,
0.17498166859149933,
0.6276426315307617,
-0.5070415139198303,
-0.4180140793323517,
0.8587626218795776,
-0.7330637574195862,
-0.26521220803260803,
-0.8024694323539734,
-0.5638989210128784,
-0.27553591132164,
0.11153557151556015,
-0.027077853679656982,
1.0107228755950928,
-0.23135821521282196,
-0.08341021835803986,
0.45571058988571167,
-0.057780731469392776,
0.7554642558097839,
0.6598590016365051,
-0.3946674168109894,
-0.21775135397911072,
0.7379652261734009,
0.21801508963108063,
0.0073184967041015625,
0.53397536277771,
0.15889669954776764,
-0.37753424048423767,
-0.1953234225511551,
-0.40228360891342163,
0.4033811092376709,
-0.47501152753829956,
0.07525799423456192,
-0.6872088313102722,
-0.08782172948122025,
-0.4393572509288788,
0.25143352150917053,
-0.3159179091453552,
-0.7223314046859741,
-0.2660026252269745,
0.06209618225693703,
0.583032488822937,
0.3234502673149109,
-0.18039624392986298,
0.07505784183740616,
-0.904462993144989,
0.6814483404159546,
0.5779628157615662,
0.5625820755958557,
-0.20633098483085632,
-0.39506807923316956,
-0.08846632391214371,
0.21559742093086243,
-0.265865683555603,
-0.7755608558654785,
0.2976084351539612,
0.2748298645019531,
0.5506635904312134,
0.26506277918815613,
-0.17176644504070282,
0.6643862128257751,
-0.4405650496482849,
0.8256204128265381,
0.2704119086265564,
-0.6896238923072815,
0.3394620716571808,
-0.1518469750881195,
0.14655062556266785,
0.08657831698656082,
0.04020633548498154,
-0.9219266176223755,
0.34166011214256287,
-0.2678188979625702,
-0.8058981895446777,
0.847303032875061,
-0.2944938838481903,
-0.11388806253671646,
0.17684710025787354,
-0.1326686441898346,
0.46264705061912537,
0.1309889853000641,
-0.7314749956130981,
-0.30893757939338684,
-0.49150386452674866,
-0.30973395705223083,
-0.37063175439834595,
-0.3465687036514282,
-0.09339691698551178,
-0.05333663895726204,
0.4080137312412262,
-0.19207803905010223,
0.6464272737503052,
0.11113686114549637,
-0.2533259093761444,
-0.2001459151506424,
0.5255226492881775,
0.3142170011997223,
0.4227432310581207,
-0.30143609642982483,
0.36885151267051697,
-0.05930837243795395,
-0.3801231384277344,
0.09049660712480545,
0.6545504927635193,
0.12835568189620972,
0.20883499085903168,
0.34372586011886597,
0.8104082942008972,
0.27625855803489685,
-0.48114362359046936,
0.43446141481399536,
-0.06521466374397278,
0.5631245970726013,
-0.4135604202747345,
-0.2549937963485718,
-0.03199303522706032,
0.2743479609489441,
0.28388386964797974,
0.4597572982311249,
0.02115396223962307,
-0.5253780484199524,
0.000933704199269414,
0.42660626769065857,
-0.17937763035297394,
-0.8833574056625366,
0.8288214206695557,
0.1870829463005066,
0.04253687337040901,
0.3143276870250702,
0.06617742776870728,
-0.1633794754743576,
0.6030870676040649,
0.49544933438301086,
0.8268609642982483,
-0.3888233006000519,
0.03649168461561203,
0.13657456636428833,
0.3909958302974701,
-0.0692552998661995,
0.3728427290916443,
0.03370574861764908,
-0.8598012328147888,
-0.26023560762405396,
-0.670848548412323,
0.05452994257211685,
0.05625607818365097,
-0.6214390993118286,
0.5302525162696838,
-0.18638616800308228,
-0.5771473050117493,
0.1926131546497345,
-0.2333638221025467,
-0.7414724826812744,
-0.13467377424240112,
0.5381590723991394,
0.6406381130218506,
-0.9293456673622131,
1.0625438690185547,
0.7942230105400085,
-0.2985677123069763,
-0.19286948442459106,
-0.13770300149917603,
0.1763010323047638,
-0.7141348719596863,
0.34546592831611633,
0.19235073029994965,
-0.21154777705669403,
-0.1910039186477661,
-0.1371517926454544,
-0.6535007357597351,
1.2425600290298462,
0.1653379201889038,
-0.6001884937286377,
-0.3999519944190979,
-0.15205839276313782,
0.49593034386634827,
-0.30649298429489136,
0.2179318517446518,
0.16384905576705933,
0.4772244989871979,
-0.14421622455120087,
-1.0439115762710571,
-0.06756569445133209,
-0.4489935040473938,
0.017996937036514282,
0.5923675298690796,
-0.7174381017684937,
0.7222488522529602,
-0.15766727924346924,
-0.4340762495994568,
-0.21417270600795746,
0.40359577536582947,
-0.3243793845176697,
0.6859758496284485,
0.4565439820289612,
0.48570287227630615,
0.5920458436012268,
0.0007919720956124365,
1.0321449041366577,
-0.42818132042884827,
0.26044777035713196,
1.0130040645599365,
-0.45918822288513184,
0.3820773959159851,
0.6592841148376465,
-0.29955461621284485,
0.6191471815109253,
0.1902938336133957,
0.0979149118065834,
0.6141321659088135,
-0.5466886162757874,
-0.45845136046409607,
-0.4667496681213379,
-0.22092793881893158,
-0.5676335096359253,
-0.01900745928287506,
0.6922423243522644,
-0.3173704445362091,
-0.3635825216770172,
0.2923735976219177,
-0.08962833881378174,
-0.033896490931510925,
-0.08692789077758789,
0.42716896533966064,
0.2350938320159912,
-0.43990591168403625,
0.059015966951847076,
0.07863759994506836,
0.8109539747238159,
-0.8568673729896545,
0.08121122419834137,
0.15088912844657898,
0.3059810698032379,
-0.07126424461603165,
-0.7181364893913269,
0.3783208429813385,
-0.26223841309547424,
-0.4353269040584564,
-0.4200195074081421,
0.5978790521621704,
-0.5535132884979248,
-0.6440100073814392,
0.6321808695793152,
0.255780965089798,
-0.40868696570396423,
0.1660945564508438,
-0.3797979950904846,
-0.24076753854751587,
-0.2548697888851166,
-0.08739017695188522,
0.23697218298912048,
0.3253295123577118,
-0.11299311369657516,
0.6531848907470703,
0.3861675560474396,
0.09324906766414642,
0.41679126024246216,
0.1223844364285469,
0.6606319546699524,
-0.6744523644447327,
-0.313129186630249,
-0.7701635956764221,
0.6053290963172913,
0.08625227212905884,
-0.05075500160455704,
0.4699738323688507,
0.5022027492523193,
0.2432413101196289,
-0.06107673421502113,
1.003545880317688,
-0.125844344496727,
0.5952584147453308,
-0.751609742641449,
0.3257777988910675,
-0.7376177906990051,
0.3248555362224579,
0.1473684161901474,
-0.47061052918434143,
-0.1657557487487793,
0.0441412627696991,
-0.31153571605682373,
-0.0959465503692627,
0.838809609413147,
0.7479905486106873,
-0.4753134548664093,
0.24861209094524384,
0.028702175244688988,
0.28210270404815674,
0.29580143094062805,
0.7640706896781921,
0.9017688632011414,
-0.3291596472263336,
0.6296820640563965,
-0.4987855851650238,
-0.30545151233673096,
-0.2992176413536072,
-0.9402583241462708,
-0.9113994240760803,
-0.659716784954071,
-0.4005149006843567,
-0.2166716605424881,
-0.1593279391527176,
1.1321433782577515,
0.5221588015556335,
-0.7995180487632751,
-0.02187764272093773,
0.5474349856376648,
-0.07469776272773743,
-0.411405473947525,
-0.25332188606262207,
0.25802743434906006,
-0.20262256264686584,
-0.5857251286506653,
0.5741108059883118,
0.36279505491256714,
0.0581175796687603,
-0.06901420652866364,
0.42176204919815063,
0.024319997057318687,
-0.19719815254211426,
0.5726820826530457,
0.08138515055179596,
-0.6596181988716125,
-0.3362952172756195,
0.15166746079921722,
-0.05587329715490341,
0.09179593622684479,
1.1577818393707275,
-0.9045554995536804,
0.9817302227020264,
0.4693853259086609,
0.3449183404445648,
0.6084784865379333,
-0.23651301860809326,
0.48671630024909973,
-0.5783439874649048,
0.39791345596313477,
0.18896076083183289,
0.6057321429252625,
0.3242412209510803,
-0.2985946238040924,
0.0018395354272797704,
0.5479353070259094,
-0.586714506149292,
-0.6614065170288086,
0.33013787865638733,
-1.2864080667495728,
-0.2619618773460388,
1.041762351989746,
0.3413105607032776,
-0.02310759760439396,
-0.3529641032218933,
-0.28960126638412476,
0.32129165530204773,
-0.5161635875701904,
0.7199519276618958,
0.7596820592880249,
-0.05608505755662918,
-0.0157352052628994,
-0.44454798102378845,
0.0005659875459969044,
0.17232339084148407,
-0.20887742936611176,
-0.11927121877670288,
0.4334598481655121,
0.5564666390419006,
0.17004191875457764,
0.3699198365211487,
-0.19277746975421906,
0.034693796187639236,
-0.06051049754023552,
0.006344454362988472,
-0.24513481557369232,
-0.17447979748249054,
-0.5027297139167786,
0.09492741525173187,
0.029729697853326797,
-0.221845343708992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04952v1
|
Quantifying Geospatial in the Common Crawl Corpus
| 2024-06-07T14:16:37 | 2024-06-07T14:16:37 |
Ilya Ilyankou, Meihui Wang, James Haworth, Stefano Cavazzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit emerging geospatial capabilities,
stemming from their pre-training on vast unlabelled text datasets that are
often derived from the Common Crawl corpus. However, the geospatial content
within CC remains largely unexplored, impacting our understanding of LLMs'
spatial reasoning. This paper investigates the prevalence of geospatial data in
recent Common Crawl releases using Gemini, a powerful language model. By
analyzing a sample of documents and manually revising the results, we estimate
that between 1 in 5 and 1 in 6 documents contain geospatial information such as
coordinates and street addresses. Our findings provide quantitative insights
into the nature and extent of geospatial data within Common Crawl, and web
crawl data in general. Furthermore, we formulate questions to guide future
investigations into the geospatial content of available web crawl datasets and
its influence on LLMs.
|
[
-0.44366076588630676,
-0.5961037874221802,
1.1561756134033203,
0.0007796357967890799,
-0.08619271963834763,
-0.20142291486263275,
-0.38115447759628296,
-0.5314710140228271,
0.47609469294548035,
0.3827599287033081,
-0.582012414932251,
-1.182386875152588,
-0.7578973770141602,
-0.08686324208974838,
-1.0349174737930298,
0.8159687519073486,
0.34327706694602966,
-0.3741993010044098,
-0.3823074698448181,
-0.1657627820968628,
0.09739090502262115,
-0.9458739757537842,
-0.043420303612947464,
0.21396999061107635,
0.5109524726867676,
0.41971126198768616,
1.0668435096740723,
0.41160523891448975,
0.7093634605407715,
0.2033332884311676,
-0.26237714290618896,
0.06572332233190536,
-0.4633530378341675,
-0.04974721372127533,
-0.34536755084991455,
-0.37267476320266724,
-0.0637345165014267,
0.1076369360089302,
0.8140032291412354,
1.1648635864257812,
-0.156889408826828,
0.14460468292236328,
-0.3418416380882263,
0.6110609173774719,
-0.7042170166969299,
-0.24405509233474731,
-0.6829699277877808,
-0.36232486367225647,
-0.5768401622772217,
0.1701870560646057,
-0.01467558927834034,
-0.43834298849105835,
0.49202123284339905,
-0.6790799498558044,
0.63238126039505,
0.09060365706682205,
0.5782696604728699,
0.34407854080200195,
-0.33127158880233765,
-0.7307031154632568,
-0.469743013381958,
0.46577930450439453,
-0.32453083992004395,
0.3516604006290436,
0.24925497174263,
0.2784799337387085,
-0.29403072595596313,
-0.736192524433136,
-0.5056766271591187,
-0.205067977309227,
-0.18396875262260437,
-0.1716233491897583,
-0.30099859833717346,
-0.38273194432258606,
0.14365209639072418,
0.021428845822811127,
-0.5694186687469482,
0.03111167997121811,
-0.46451905369758606,
-0.05129796266555786,
0.5518841743469238,
0.2093861699104309,
0.5567131638526917,
-0.36329856514930725,
-0.24367135763168335,
-0.0006698704673908651,
-1.073992371559143,
0.1006350889801979,
0.49685755372047424,
0.4956080913543701,
-0.35353171825408936,
0.9086733460426331,
-0.05884459614753723,
0.7560378909111023,
-0.4909355342388153,
0.1591109037399292,
0.14143416285514832,
-0.06983804702758789,
0.08412854373455048,
-0.05464513972401619,
0.7644662261009216,
0.25751614570617676,
0.5921558141708374,
-0.3189419209957123,
-0.07102596014738083,
0.030617661774158478,
0.3379575312137604,
-0.36297792196273804,
-0.11766691505908966,
0.310179203748703,
-0.02333247661590576,
0.12847892940044403,
0.5796683430671692,
-0.44388049840927124,
-0.4771044850349426,
-0.22511883080005646,
-0.3025529086589813,
-0.5091584920883179,
-0.15656180679798126,
0.18550612032413483,
-0.5302966833114624,
0.2350524365901947,
0.2424718290567398,
-0.5746961832046509,
0.2361869215965271,
1.2272930145263672,
0.9977216124534607,
-0.40469005703926086,
-0.6308562159538269,
0.00395399471744895,
-0.07216493040323257,
-0.24611471593379974,
0.9445372819900513,
-0.5421617031097412,
-0.5849019885063171,
0.12841767072677612,
0.21982921659946442,
-0.07114064693450928,
-0.546023964881897,
0.4482377767562866,
-0.5229296088218689,
0.005588715896010399,
-0.284014493227005,
-0.14455561339855194,
-0.17104807496070862,
0.45335787534713745,
-0.7765725255012512,
1.3204333782196045,
0.23510222136974335,
-1.0241957902908325,
0.20180188119411469,
-0.32033786177635193,
-0.417970210313797,
-0.09283598512411118,
0.19762471318244934,
-0.06797844171524048,
0.48623400926589966,
0.4429928660392761,
0.39056596159935,
-0.03814266249537468,
0.23845911026000977,
-0.3468985855579376,
-0.6897243857383728,
0.6601202487945557,
-0.008690574206411839,
0.5054763555526733,
0.2725565433502197,
-0.018604744225740433,
-0.41752511262893677,
-0.8450550436973572,
-0.27081966400146484,
0.09296463429927826,
-0.16929180920124054,
-0.49551287293434143,
0.2782864272594452,
-0.13016892969608307,
-0.1695576012134552,
0.6659019589424133,
-0.48903873562812805,
0.20660918951034546,
-0.4640849530696869,
0.08765735477209091,
0.2971194386482239,
-0.050338368862867355,
0.739284098148346,
-0.0683693140745163,
0.465410053730011,
-0.11941344290971756,
0.03421604633331299,
-0.125273197889328,
-0.6453971862792969,
-0.3795815110206604,
-0.3117358088493347,
-0.09379254281520844,
0.15542194247245789,
0.0004183553101029247,
-0.03225143626332283,
-0.8326109051704407,
-0.8385176658630371,
-0.29085609316825867,
-0.3692263066768646,
-0.14333350956439972,
0.3055051863193512,
0.33900582790374756,
0.21126773953437805,
-0.38065528869628906,
-0.4713294804096222,
-0.14768396317958832,
0.15201272070407867,
-0.3359368145465851,
0.6375240087509155,
0.4185585379600525,
-0.5296497941017151,
1.399594783782959,
-0.7158735990524292,
0.21289671957492828,
-0.21867947280406952,
0.22798438370227814,
0.5604586005210876,
-0.24715875089168549,
0.6820595264434814,
-0.7772769331932068,
-0.27340975403785706,
-0.3410891592502594,
-0.335037499666214,
-0.39254701137542725,
0.11540360003709793,
-0.0034353826195001602,
0.2126559317111969,
0.09154592454433441,
-0.8102370500564575,
0.5035303235054016,
0.8814965486526489,
-0.33047279715538025,
0.44001883268356323,
-0.22032973170280457,
0.0031696404330432415,
-0.6281943917274475,
0.22243012487888336,
0.14069204032421112,
-0.22318366169929504,
-0.23894520103931427,
0.5145745277404785,
0.037777844816446304,
-0.28265318274497986,
-0.543594479560852,
0.36551743745803833,
-0.5104641914367676,
-0.9694855213165283,
-0.2603817582130432,
0.9363704919815063,
-0.315456360578537,
-0.07967530936002731,
0.32680198550224304,
0.9028548002243042,
0.5478631258010864,
-0.6176782250404358,
0.4016464054584503,
0.055629853159189224,
-0.4501369595527649,
0.05562058463692665,
-0.5930444598197937,
0.18144915997982025,
-0.27265697717666626,
0.3825750946998596,
-1.1820698976516724,
-0.2914328873157501,
-0.12218914926052094,
-0.7396981120109558,
-0.2943110764026642,
-0.46856945753097534,
-0.5905966758728027,
-0.5786740779876709,
-0.16207276284694672,
0.0016032404964789748,
0.21247439086437225,
-0.711676299571991,
0.3921351432800293,
0.6741552352905273,
-0.12326549738645554,
-0.48740145564079285,
-0.46574893593788147,
0.18063288927078247,
-0.2048085331916809,
-0.8730917572975159,
0.11721401661634445,
0.1723226010799408,
-0.40860211849212646,
0.06672607362270355,
-0.033456940203905106,
-0.07946845144033432,
0.3561354875564575,
0.6872286200523376,
0.2945561707019806,
0.14766599237918854,
-0.06840438395738602,
-0.45734405517578125,
-0.1907588541507721,
0.45073503255844116,
-0.36374107003211975,
0.9467011094093323,
0.041311029344797134,
-0.4711697995662689,
0.08883119374513626,
-0.09381645917892456,
0.5051278471946716,
-0.21685677766799927,
0.9112539887428284,
0.32298073172569275,
-0.2280999720096588,
-0.10055080056190491,
0.0038397875614464283,
0.44024229049682617,
-0.42044976353645325,
0.09931431710720062,
-0.07538985460996628,
-0.7538106441497803,
0.6664776802062988,
-0.3251856863498688,
-0.32226234674453735,
0.5509709715843201,
0.34263306856155396,
-0.3603872060775757,
0.519024670124054,
0.4894587993621826,
-0.410388320684433,
0.031002555042505264,
-0.32062146067619324,
0.27889788150787354,
-0.5863974690437317,
-0.5608735680580139,
-0.9107927083969116,
-0.39887478947639465,
-1.1357616186141968,
-0.5426665544509888,
0.5266969203948975,
-0.24849751591682434,
-0.20581550896167755,
0.36486339569091797,
-0.5845168232917786,
0.39893415570259094,
0.7805508971214294,
-0.0023151137866079807,
0.011569784954190254,
-0.04106197506189346,
-0.1273191124200821,
-0.04053756967186928,
-0.33531707525253296,
-0.32839876413345337,
1.1958638429641724,
0.10916422307491302,
0.7479913830757141,
0.47546374797821045,
0.5596819519996643,
0.12473974376916885,
0.17271173000335693,
-0.7358348965644836,
0.4837973415851593,
-0.2961980998516083,
-0.6555463075637817,
-0.2758195102214813,
-0.26699531078338623,
-1.1181975603103638,
-0.23264846205711365,
-0.26856711506843567,
-0.6377903819084167,
-0.3135179281234741,
-0.40505582094192505,
-0.16857315599918365,
0.15275098383426666,
-0.3233596384525299,
0.17021605372428894,
-0.28895479440689087,
0.02390056848526001,
-0.28018641471862793,
-0.721879243850708,
0.027042165398597717,
-0.09371340274810791,
0.520642876625061,
-0.1531166285276413,
-0.14337022602558136,
0.3742689788341522,
-0.38435229659080505,
0.693332850933075,
-0.1978122889995575,
-0.008249837905168533,
0.5347524285316467,
-0.07003708928823471,
0.6531612873077393,
0.015867900103330612,
0.18326310813426971,
0.49206918478012085,
-0.0704742893576622,
-0.19843730330467224,
-0.38130173087120056,
0.9358593225479126,
-1.0256240367889404,
-0.36663416028022766,
-0.6194016337394714,
-0.4012863039970398,
0.01976151019334793,
-0.02836647816002369,
0.3251648247241974,
0.22267501056194305,
-0.2145637571811676,
0.0664430484175682,
0.7103360891342163,
-0.5972612500190735,
0.33050093054771423,
0.6386683583259583,
-0.21609628200531006,
-0.19682194292545319,
0.6034188866615295,
-0.05284230783581734,
-0.3118565082550049,
0.518978476524353,
0.18295927345752716,
-0.7081204056739807,
-0.6924858689308167,
0.11132941395044327,
0.5390563011169434,
-0.6237919330596924,
0.00756863784044981,
-0.721513032913208,
-0.14368797838687897,
-0.5264711380004883,
-0.5008997321128845,
-0.16531962156295776,
-0.5388558506965637,
-0.3083612620830536,
-0.04231669008731842,
0.41412413120269775,
1.1633844375610352,
-0.015717795118689537,
0.6920681595802307,
-0.9197591543197632,
0.28647738695144653,
-0.32039257884025574,
0.12776437401771545,
-0.390177458524704,
-0.3943592607975006,
-0.4134412109851837,
0.15048402547836304,
0.04406961053609848,
-0.9533024430274963,
0.7008359432220459,
-0.38218313455581665,
0.49002236127853394,
0.2592455744743347,
-0.14994767308235168,
0.6469377875328064,
-0.3943348824977875,
1.2239481210708618,
-0.05549247935414314,
-0.7168431878089905,
0.5453929901123047,
-0.7080205678939819,
0.3796994686126709,
0.1296701580286026,
0.9488090872764587,
-0.7748579978942871,
-0.32713860273361206,
-0.6376745700836182,
-0.9536682963371277,
0.13993197679519653,
-0.30030199885368347,
0.28758400678634644,
-0.3512304127216339,
0.5660644173622131,
-0.16217269003391266,
0.0016100468346849084,
-0.48462924361228943,
-0.058389775454998016,
-0.018560025840997696,
-0.22416269779205322,
-0.17605869472026825,
-0.38409796357154846,
0.06973133981227875,
0.17064687609672546,
0.10063031315803528,
0.07556277513504028,
0.008719771169126034,
0.03660422936081886,
-0.4616067707538605,
0.25214433670043945,
0.14354577660560608,
0.29840463399887085,
0.8509501218795776,
-0.282213419675827,
0.30759233236312866,
0.03352488577365875,
-0.7593978643417358,
-0.2959616780281067,
0.16233722865581512,
-0.19367332756519318,
0.15102514624595642,
0.4016454517841339,
0.06511473655700684,
0.41256827116012573,
-0.8159050941467285,
0.7260406017303467,
0.16845999658107758,
0.13123266398906708,
-0.8166269659996033,
-0.0026404799427837133,
0.4100590944290161,
0.16452465951442719,
0.5504778027534485,
-0.14496803283691406,
0.294525682926178,
-0.4286966919898987,
0.03896428272128105,
0.4803805351257324,
0.05169622600078583,
-0.4036412835121155,
0.43954038619995117,
0.01160063873976469,
-0.0042427657172083855,
1.184887409210205,
0.06248042732477188,
-0.5612461566925049,
0.5051721334457397,
0.2826375365257263,
0.35785242915153503,
0.34042155742645264,
0.09876377135515213,
0.5931054949760437,
0.27033132314682007,
-0.01918897219002247,
0.18070775270462036,
0.09560482949018478,
-0.6746475100517273,
-0.2872084379196167,
-0.6738638281822205,
-0.6322537660598755,
-0.21670642495155334,
-0.6591825485229492,
0.4671872556209564,
-0.4908944368362427,
-0.1802229881286621,
-0.43017295002937317,
0.19339556992053986,
-0.8432936072349548,
0.38642969727516174,
0.5541337728500366,
1.2924988269805908,
-0.587906002998352,
0.45721912384033203,
0.9059240818023682,
-0.08421744406223297,
-0.42557424306869507,
0.07595314085483551,
0.1357523649930954,
-1.0820114612579346,
0.6516599059104919,
0.2764803171157837,
-0.443111777305603,
-0.30031031370162964,
-1.2126339673995972,
-1.2740445137023926,
1.1666814088821411,
-0.04108917713165283,
-0.6897822022438049,
-0.1515672206878662,
0.6455997228622437,
0.5945480465888977,
-0.15284447371959686,
0.22335772216320038,
0.5845046043395996,
0.3615487813949585,
0.19067351520061493,
-0.5041018724441528,
-0.1416240930557251,
0.23517440259456635,
-0.23107311129570007,
0.3286097049713135,
-0.41070446372032166,
0.7219898700714111,
-0.5796481370925903,
-0.5952218174934387,
0.28948554396629333,
0.36173853278160095,
0.6167430877685547,
0.648915708065033,
0.1936175376176834,
0.9328639507293701,
1.052970290184021,
-0.3335932493209839,
1.2831835746765137,
-0.5983295440673828,
0.4164973199367523,
1.0813212394714355,
-0.1586667150259018,
1.0964869260787964,
0.1407964676618576,
-0.3407662808895111,
0.7176228761672974,
0.6068340539932251,
0.13722403347492218,
0.5381278395652771,
0.36097049713134766,
-0.14998818933963776,
0.03527181223034859,
0.13143761456012726,
-0.027197714895009995,
0.8185953497886658,
0.6745455861091614,
-0.24755817651748657,
-0.362244188785553,
-0.5577764511108398,
0.2338670790195465,
0.1379559189081192,
-0.22698239982128143,
0.5209488272666931,
-0.16683512926101685,
-0.6139532923698425,
0.05586767569184303,
-0.009261004626750946,
0.6941496133804321,
-0.6494393348693848,
0.32526472210884094,
-0.3769531548023224,
-0.1764981895685196,
-0.21791018545627594,
-1.3102182149887085,
0.5325638651847839,
0.35585999488830566,
-0.07264408469200134,
-0.0023382462095469236,
0.6476033926010132,
0.03971302881836891,
-0.343607634305954,
0.25769031047821045,
0.4338681399822235,
0.47238048911094666,
-0.6185410022735596,
-0.15454043447971344,
0.012211429886519909,
-0.2525051236152649,
-0.1440548598766327,
0.2261986881494522,
0.9977564811706543,
0.09871997684240341,
0.9041491150856018,
0.9846822619438171,
0.33766692876815796,
0.23781542479991913,
0.005941231269389391,
1.0633352994918823,
-1.2240917682647705,
-0.4747154414653778,
-0.5692241191864014,
0.529313325881958,
0.03285260871052742,
-0.14086392521858215,
0.8901960253715515,
0.624083399772644,
0.6043826937675476,
0.3248191177845001,
0.7533459067344666,
0.058698639273643494,
0.8521414399147034,
-0.3866031765937805,
0.6453161239624023,
-0.31854861974716187,
0.3363643288612366,
0.11455999314785004,
-0.8802527189254761,
-0.20649848878383636,
0.36738404631614685,
-0.6090666651725769,
-0.2848086655139923,
0.5102186799049377,
0.6311196684837341,
-0.08161552250385284,
-0.1823895275592804,
0.1305026412010193,
-0.10324554145336151,
0.0795527845621109,
0.4206008017063141,
1.2380034923553467,
0.0226035937666893,
0.42565086483955383,
0.011763677932322025,
-0.1536606252193451,
-0.14479921758174896,
-0.9271652102470398,
-0.6286855340003967,
-0.461062490940094,
0.3192792534828186,
-0.2865850329399109,
-0.014355863444507122,
0.4035353660583496,
0.4597344994544983,
-0.471328467130661,
0.13337567448616028,
-0.10268963128328323,
0.07167035341262817,
0.5128609538078308,
-0.24222533404827118,
0.3453569710254669,
-0.22011306881904602,
-0.6589943170547485,
0.37415143847465515,
0.2285996824502945,
0.09881839156150818,
-0.18808086216449738,
0.11283108592033386,
0.011996656656265259,
-0.004597238730639219,
0.236246719956398,
0.08782180398702621,
-0.3819674551486969,
-0.12253771722316742,
0.44037842750549316,
-0.2974480986595154,
-0.14969280362129211,
0.8284518122673035,
-0.9880644083023071,
0.019362028688192368,
0.3682529926300049,
0.334360808134079,
0.5638902187347412,
0.3914785087108612,
0.167044535279274,
-0.9750233292579651,
0.24438326060771942,
-0.14895379543304443,
0.48324862122535706,
0.641202449798584,
-0.5147926807403564,
0.5977664589881897,
0.24480591714382172,
-0.6700683832168579,
-0.14785218238830566,
0.0020740677136927843,
-0.9379214644432068,
-0.4252035319805145,
1.4995239973068237,
-0.13701707124710083,
-0.3286260962486267,
0.18049636483192444,
0.26736196875572205,
-0.08162481337785721,
-0.22211645543575287,
0.6126922965049744,
0.7409435510635376,
0.12054061889648438,
-0.16029085218906403,
-0.344775915145874,
0.0267079696059227,
-0.28682437539100647,
-0.5740463137626648,
0.0032128277234733105,
0.9988456964492798,
0.6311452984809875,
0.3327002227306366,
0.469546914100647,
-0.07424809038639069,
-0.0008277519955299795,
-0.041004594415426254,
-0.16870003938674927,
0.16832639276981354,
-0.5902003645896912,
-0.010504103265702724,
0.25583982467651367,
0.0012021299917250872,
0.012086553499102592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04947v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04947v1
|
BAMO at SemEval-2024 Task 9: BRAINTEASER: A Novel Task Defying Common Sense
| 2024-06-07T14:01:56 | 2024-06-07T14:01:56 |
Baktash Ansari, Mohammadmostafa Rostamkhani, Sauleh Eetemadi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper outlines our approach to SemEval 2024 Task 9, BRAINTEASER: A Novel
Task Defying Common Sense. The task aims to evaluate the ability of language
models to think creatively. The dataset comprises multi-choice questions that
challenge models to think "outside of the box". We fine-tune 2 models, BERT and
RoBERTa Large. Next, we employ a Chain of Thought (CoT) zero-shot prompting
approach with 6 large language models, such as GPT-3.5, Mixtral, and Llama2.
Finally, we utilize ReConcile, a technique that employs a "round table
conference" approach with multiple agents for zero-shot learning, to generate
consensus answers among 3 selected language models. Our best method achieves an
overall accuracy of 85 percent on the sentence puzzles subtask.
|
[
-0.5271468162536621,
-1.0451538562774658,
0.7515406608581543,
0.09556050598621368,
-0.4068637192249298,
-0.07949332147836685,
-0.06689043343067169,
-0.42797964811325073,
0.17087289690971375,
0.6471813917160034,
-0.8175739645957947,
-0.30850937962532043,
-0.6267653107643127,
0.20477725565433502,
-0.07843250781297684,
1.0791633129119873,
0.03305831551551819,
-0.12324991077184677,
-0.09530289471149445,
-0.2652830183506012,
-0.8931677341461182,
-0.32403478026390076,
-0.7240556478500366,
-0.5079798698425293,
0.5781392455101013,
0.3625669777393341,
0.4038817584514618,
0.0309840589761734,
0.28650152683258057,
0.2713831663131714,
-0.11936339735984802,
0.19039683043956757,
-0.4503001570701599,
0.007094362284988165,
-0.5070149898529053,
-0.5042405128479004,
-0.668060302734375,
-0.09022607654333115,
0.25219202041625977,
0.6874037981033325,
-0.0632808730006218,
0.05241312086582184,
-0.002738715149462223,
0.648713231086731,
-0.49240171909332275,
0.052559249103069305,
-1.0446983575820923,
-0.013799457810819149,
0.039348382502794266,
0.07195322215557098,
-0.41186273097991943,
-0.11739850044250488,
-0.04836515337228775,
-0.3808063566684723,
0.14013300836086273,
-0.11848483979701996,
0.8327360153198242,
0.4899818003177643,
-0.7174939513206482,
-0.0353117473423481,
-0.23221515119075775,
0.8159171938896179,
-0.48572835326194763,
0.11801458895206451,
0.43389105796813965,
0.42706626653671265,
-0.226802259683609,
-0.4316185712814331,
-0.7125619649887085,
0.11898282915353775,
0.39512303471565247,
0.25544652342796326,
-0.36067280173301697,
-0.11556919664144516,
0.253073513507843,
-0.1507960855960846,
-0.7365063428878784,
-0.2468528151512146,
-0.5378186702728271,
0.02409517951309681,
0.70930415391922,
0.13319802284240723,
0.16807959973812103,
0.0045171924866735935,
-0.5031378269195557,
0.2877456247806549,
-0.6017413139343262,
0.06544166803359985,
-0.0006807505269534886,
-0.13149119913578033,
0.17082951962947845,
0.4223017394542694,
-0.3984425663948059,
0.7625926733016968,
0.04623792693018913,
0.44515156745910645,
0.2765088975429535,
-0.18038572371006012,
-0.2806382179260254,
-0.000046334775106515735,
0.5608772039413452,
0.4737641215324402,
0.29572707414627075,
-0.13148479163646698,
-0.3430560827255249,
0.35793647170066833,
0.566907525062561,
-0.46374982595443726,
-0.181641086935997,
0.4670805335044861,
-0.04641152545809746,
-0.3911675214767456,
-0.47320035099983215,
-0.6619740724563599,
-0.3373999297618866,
-0.2514146566390991,
1.0650207996368408,
-0.6684008240699768,
0.010856756009161472,
0.32660195231437683,
-0.20047485828399658,
0.18953754007816315,
0.7259967923164368,
-0.7305940389633179,
0.18070420622825623,
0.6780629754066467,
0.5801167488098145,
-0.14117096364498138,
-0.5424254536628723,
-0.4153086245059967,
0.16596204042434692,
-0.25518596172332764,
1.3674931526184082,
-0.43583378195762634,
-0.1418888121843338,
-0.654744029045105,
0.09280562400817871,
-0.16572394967079163,
-0.42031365633010864,
0.4110293984413147,
-0.31963855028152466,
0.07629726827144623,
-0.531446099281311,
-0.4790423810482025,
-0.6738213300704956,
0.5811222791671753,
-0.6378636956214905,
0.6165865063667297,
-0.028866803273558617,
-0.2730356752872467,
0.487408846616745,
-0.9663185477256775,
-0.31470364332199097,
0.236896350979805,
-0.34088578820228577,
-0.26272034645080566,
0.1804848313331604,
0.5169868469238281,
0.44616642594337463,
-0.2776055335998535,
0.5218803882598877,
-0.3762974441051483,
-0.4675516188144684,
0.3259425461292267,
-0.44140124320983887,
1.1076176166534424,
0.3573404848575592,
-0.44853633642196655,
0.03234460949897766,
-0.7259254455566406,
0.12008069455623627,
0.30148449540138245,
0.08291825652122498,
-0.16985152661800385,
-0.26199156045913696,
-0.257114440202713,
0.2452930063009262,
0.3776489794254303,
-0.5859813690185547,
0.33108144998550415,
-0.42398908734321594,
0.4016280770301819,
0.7728235125541687,
0.33713969588279724,
0.26876378059387207,
-0.5080834627151489,
0.5692995190620422,
0.24908767640590668,
0.06975855678319931,
-0.22189825773239136,
-0.87630695104599,
-0.6688846945762634,
-0.2594318985939026,
0.15286163985729218,
0.5151268243789673,
-0.5935540199279785,
0.3791801929473877,
0.018379392102360725,
-0.8102136850357056,
-0.600760281085968,
-0.0629124715924263,
0.04891502484679222,
0.57118159532547,
0.39399486780166626,
-0.43905189633369446,
-0.5778011083602905,
-0.8948756456375122,
-0.33771976828575134,
0.2392270714044571,
0.2013595700263977,
0.04482218995690346,
0.8713228106498718,
-0.2812468111515045,
0.7101926803588867,
-0.5171143412590027,
-0.09981194138526917,
-0.33430230617523193,
0.5806459188461304,
0.4803958237171173,
0.47298815846443176,
0.3978155255317688,
-0.5237945318222046,
-0.20831668376922607,
-0.11735568195581436,
-0.8085744380950928,
-0.30253827571868896,
0.021376794204115868,
0.036230746656656265,
0.3402487337589264,
0.23772501945495605,
-0.6177286505699158,
0.4604073464870453,
0.3673451840877533,
-0.3299660086631775,
0.28083592653274536,
0.007255281787365675,
0.4339262843132019,
-1.0464684963226318,
0.19786573946475983,
-0.42828547954559326,
0.03659690171480179,
-0.7338616847991943,
0.16230392456054688,
-0.03783223405480385,
-0.31362420320510864,
-0.47898247838020325,
0.6284860968589783,
-0.43869638442993164,
0.13550515472888947,
-0.4509533643722534,
0.15724022686481476,
0.1391700953245163,
0.6333997249603271,
0.04325093328952789,
0.6695528030395508,
0.49284809827804565,
-0.4963359832763672,
0.21911513805389404,
0.15102984011173248,
-0.3733765184879303,
0.7457904815673828,
-0.8250304460525513,
0.5454138517379761,
-0.4109923243522644,
0.27845099568367004,
-1.0370357036590576,
0.009475082159042358,
0.05922423675656319,
-0.5567720532417297,
-0.18867594003677368,
0.05869629606604576,
-0.18946027755737305,
-0.38008829951286316,
-0.03120061382651329,
0.3660837411880493,
0.31328174471855164,
-0.15604571998119354,
0.626092791557312,
0.7499505281448364,
-0.15692494809627533,
-0.6437035799026489,
-0.8254050612449646,
0.1290510892868042,
-0.4351816773414612,
-0.6615457534790039,
0.07481256127357483,
-0.3308160603046417,
-0.09491357952356339,
-0.17085152864456177,
-0.10848669707775116,
-0.22663111984729767,
0.2603464722633362,
0.10536909103393555,
0.3069617450237274,
0.10655196756124496,
-0.18332242965698242,
0.026313262060284615,
-0.06032298505306244,
0.044059112668037415,
-0.17247001826763153,
0.6081684231758118,
-0.2618774175643921,
-0.38300567865371704,
0.03390266373753548,
0.5150620341300964,
0.20116384327411652,
-0.2259337455034256,
0.48204898834228516,
0.5618246793746948,
-0.5230582356452942,
-0.25439414381980896,
-0.7234100699424744,
-0.09732875972986221,
-0.44298097491264343,
0.29961955547332764,
-0.6372824311256409,
-1.0091885328292847,
0.6218770742416382,
0.06920131295919418,
0.06077639013528824,
0.24118101596832275,
0.7715930342674255,
-0.062256526201963425,
1.1002142429351807,
0.3746977746486664,
0.18536940217018127,
-0.06383398175239563,
-0.33699098229408264,
0.373134583234787,
-0.6442596316337585,
-0.2784680426120758,
-0.3684503436088562,
-0.46246716380119324,
-0.18110038340091705,
-0.5766310095787048,
0.39792051911354065,
-0.059401240199804306,
-0.09919852763414383,
0.8582702875137329,
-0.5682689547538757,
0.6403451561927795,
0.5441296100616455,
0.07982920855283737,
0.09510046988725662,
-0.2283242642879486,
-0.3043934404850006,
0.14584407210350037,
-0.5663481950759888,
-0.45270439982414246,
1.0309746265411377,
0.015723802149295807,
0.4942775070667267,
0.15862227976322174,
0.9161907434463501,
0.021021757274866104,
-0.10970795899629593,
-0.6847377419471741,
0.9735153317451477,
0.30730414390563965,
-0.9430955648422241,
-0.42378050088882446,
-0.260916531085968,
-1.3651537895202637,
0.48367106914520264,
0.07416286319494247,
-1.0198779106140137,
0.287055104970932,
-0.16407902538776398,
-0.5222697854042053,
-0.04796246066689491,
-0.7586181163787842,
0.9706099629402161,
0.009668996557593346,
-0.1746707409620285,
-0.3947417438030243,
-0.494906485080719,
0.45812854170799255,
-0.3104720115661621,
0.2448323667049408,
-0.4075261354446411,
-0.15973079204559326,
0.6507542729377747,
0.09002476185560226,
0.5497541427612305,
-0.017980657517910004,
-0.0467829592525959,
0.6171430945396423,
0.16807924211025238,
0.36800962686538696,
-0.1324695348739624,
-0.1552952527999878,
0.29258549213409424,
0.16933196783065796,
-0.491013765335083,
-0.7874360680580139,
0.4891040027141571,
-0.5624133348464966,
-0.7202731370925903,
-0.5828961133956909,
-0.7362044453620911,
-0.3599275052547455,
0.30842000246047974,
0.24071121215820312,
0.14486734569072723,
-0.4519464075565338,
0.13517995178699493,
0.5054768919944763,
-0.03811438009142876,
0.5127565860748291,
0.6710596680641174,
0.00963957142084837,
-0.6854106783866882,
0.7323365807533264,
0.39424481987953186,
0.028525324538350105,
0.2442489117383957,
0.017811685800552368,
-0.14775635302066803,
-0.4200938642024994,
-0.2254299521446228,
0.0075538973324000835,
-0.5147947669029236,
-0.30250629782676697,
-0.8480707406997681,
-0.2332911193370819,
-0.6529120206832886,
-0.3264918923377991,
-0.1247638538479805,
-0.6714054346084595,
0.046067312359809875,
-0.026320964097976685,
0.0022961809299886227,
0.6170523762702942,
-0.13234780728816986,
0.17098817229270935,
-0.7199355363845825,
0.23587624728679657,
0.4491978883743286,
-0.12470254302024841,
-0.1493920534849167,
-0.5890820622444153,
-0.20951475203037262,
0.10489554703235626,
-0.6738796830177307,
-1.119913935661316,
0.4554608166217804,
-0.16068539023399353,
0.6890928149223328,
0.27968740463256836,
0.006338523235172033,
0.7827863097190857,
-0.6726706624031067,
0.7621642351150513,
0.22288814187049866,
-0.9735121130943298,
0.9688980579376221,
-0.4788217544555664,
0.8083934187889099,
0.6384629607200623,
0.31365254521369934,
-0.39170610904693604,
-0.535338282585144,
-1.018738031387329,
-0.5367286205291748,
0.5771394968032837,
0.263290673494339,
-0.11824580281972885,
-0.21072524785995483,
-0.25331392884254456,
0.14637614786624908,
0.4154146909713745,
-0.6994590163230896,
0.16138596832752228,
-0.04554485157132149,
-0.0584680438041687,
-0.07746051251888275,
0.06622511893510818,
-0.19034461677074432,
-0.23715415596961975,
0.5658024549484253,
-0.30381694436073303,
0.44157588481903076,
-0.026642829179763794,
-0.13359855115413666,
-0.20105142891407013,
0.5915380716323853,
0.6914610266685486,
0.6411351561546326,
-0.09609934687614441,
0.23092813789844513,
0.716459333896637,
-0.16899509727954865,
0.19555452466011047,
0.03931845352053642,
-0.3450186550617218,
-0.23670965433120728,
0.10666079074144363,
0.8206872344017029,
0.3137114346027374,
-0.6906519532203674,
0.48538878560066223,
0.15701209008693695,
-0.36709389090538025,
-0.2959507703781128,
0.25580981373786926,
0.10341788828372955,
0.3798830211162567,
0.1723453551530838,
0.324771910905838,
0.4226822257041931,
-0.7272263169288635,
0.41389843821525574,
0.46781399846076965,
-0.34277787804603577,
-0.47196513414382935,
0.5592867732048035,
0.042351145297288895,
-0.16978999972343445,
0.12157328426837921,
-0.30753394961357117,
-0.6211845278739929,
0.6858408451080322,
0.5990086793899536,
0.8515934944152832,
-0.33337196707725525,
0.23388557136058807,
0.3359474539756775,
0.43850547075271606,
0.14736151695251465,
0.7808162569999695,
0.02843491919338703,
-1.029808521270752,
-0.46528157591819763,
-0.2950274646282196,
-0.42440736293792725,
0.46248555183410645,
-0.34680962562561035,
0.6100451946258545,
-0.392500102519989,
-0.22132128477096558,
0.0628175213932991,
0.2579880356788635,
-0.6917762756347656,
0.40121641755104065,
0.17565426230430603,
0.8383423686027527,
-0.7346099019050598,
0.9680559039115906,
0.9283314347267151,
-0.618768036365509,
-0.8060359954833984,
-0.32546618580818176,
0.20782090723514557,
-0.9046400189399719,
0.3430081605911255,
0.26773619651794434,
0.01816965453326702,
0.1670401245355606,
-0.7427566647529602,
-0.6804518699645996,
1.0770655870437622,
0.3664737045764923,
-0.2985132932662964,
-0.023721717298030853,
-0.13632188737392426,
0.1679268479347229,
-0.3697691559791565,
0.44026923179626465,
0.5093849897384644,
0.5745351314544678,
0.279857873916626,
-0.8381742238998413,
0.011796772480010986,
-0.22227998077869415,
-0.3596934974193573,
0.20730918645858765,
-0.8436036705970764,
0.674650251865387,
-0.2893331050872803,
-0.03005334548652172,
-0.17530885338783264,
0.8057372570037842,
0.6968278884887695,
0.5359800457954407,
0.5758064389228821,
0.8529202938079834,
0.9023677706718445,
0.18610399961471558,
0.3458312749862671,
-0.09911321848630905,
0.24971820414066315,
1.189876914024353,
-0.6758639216423035,
0.8941382169723511,
0.49555638432502747,
0.02638271637260914,
0.32943734526634216,
0.26284101605415344,
-0.21082140505313873,
0.5151918530464172,
0.020958878099918365,
-0.30873483419418335,
-0.30814608931541443,
-0.02853224240243435,
-0.11604500561952591,
0.7622712850570679,
0.27682873606681824,
0.19981153309345245,
-0.46617090702056885,
0.13964815437793732,
0.05055677145719528,
0.11738444119691849,
-0.23617178201675415,
0.7110121846199036,
0.24088048934936523,
-1.1361993551254272,
0.637354850769043,
-0.21485130488872528,
0.406916081905365,
-0.39943286776542664,
-0.05388856306672096,
-0.04719080775976181,
0.27164775133132935,
0.23679284751415253,
-0.9727013111114502,
0.4704050123691559,
-0.0622079037129879,
0.20159699022769928,
-0.15891693532466888,
0.8311024308204651,
-0.5093175172805786,
-0.39187368750572205,
0.07883191853761673,
0.5796079635620117,
0.39876797795295715,
-0.15208923816680908,
-1.0046069622039795,
0.03246084973216057,
0.1221858337521553,
-0.07700557261705399,
0.25352057814598083,
0.906250536441803,
0.03729864954948425,
0.6463191509246826,
0.3713216483592987,
0.07845038920640945,
-0.2060103416442871,
0.004241039976477623,
0.4977768361568451,
-0.8180382251739502,
-0.5453822612762451,
-0.7018330097198486,
0.49604982137680054,
-0.16127920150756836,
-0.3621804416179657,
0.6518920063972473,
0.4211614727973938,
0.7011305093765259,
-0.23829208314418793,
0.581587553024292,
-0.052568219602108,
0.41938793659210205,
-0.3269765079021454,
0.8498257398605347,
-0.5362941026687622,
-0.07639969885349274,
-0.4343661665916443,
-0.8406006097793579,
-0.1777023822069168,
0.8054725527763367,
-0.5231046676635742,
0.017388610169291496,
1.1074252128601074,
0.9749756455421448,
0.08800161629915237,
0.4490985870361328,
0.8958694934844971,
0.18379433453083038,
0.025729510933160782,
0.9782794713973999,
0.8111633062362671,
-0.49901875853538513,
0.500766396522522,
-0.035635482519865036,
-0.2130250334739685,
-0.050592511892318726,
-0.8379925489425659,
-1.0412681102752686,
-0.8238078951835632,
-0.31671667098999023,
-0.11563241481781006,
0.10875256359577179,
0.9705715775489807,
0.5350680351257324,
-0.9679142236709595,
-0.29020002484321594,
-0.27221646904945374,
-0.11629649996757507,
-0.33985650539398193,
-0.1860395073890686,
-0.06411202251911163,
-0.5231374502182007,
-0.7382744550704956,
0.6287325620651245,
0.43169185519218445,
-0.13866031169891357,
0.06680101156234741,
0.30639687180519104,
-0.636744499206543,
0.5428482890129089,
0.664686918258667,
-0.06333102285861969,
-0.7865975499153137,
-0.49058589339256287,
-0.030082935467362404,
-0.04544902592897415,
-0.12912970781326294,
0.5618526935577393,
-1.0382298231124878,
0.09707648307085037,
0.5671478509902954,
0.5754267573356628,
0.4707922637462616,
-0.1343521773815155,
0.7036769390106201,
-0.21328094601631165,
0.202127605676651,
0.44248077273368835,
0.4293540120124817,
0.0757894441485405,
-0.32786980271339417,
0.8494768142700195,
0.3396211266517639,
-0.8440776467323303,
-0.720491349697113,
0.24356262385845184,
-1.117354393005371,
-0.40477943420410156,
0.7152204513549805,
-0.012109912000596523,
-0.6885362267494202,
-0.22088223695755005,
-0.3500465452671051,
0.1538882702589035,
-0.3943512737751007,
0.8145347833633423,
0.91461181640625,
-0.17868679761886597,
-0.46015727519989014,
-0.6143411993980408,
0.1787460744380951,
0.8555853366851807,
-0.6918160915374756,
-0.30858615040779114,
0.41349852085113525,
0.20523181557655334,
0.06608324497938156,
0.9725779294967651,
0.03736942261457443,
0.4680706262588501,
-0.020162969827651978,
0.13848845660686493,
0.11273100227117538,
-0.4498116970062256,
-0.435959130525589,
0.17646867036819458,
-0.17337115108966827,
-0.011949621140956879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04941v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04941v1
|
TCMD: A Traditional Chinese Medicine QA Dataset for Evaluating Large Language Models
| 2024-06-07T13:48:15 | 2024-06-07T13:48:15 |
Ping Yu, Kaitao Song, Fengchen He, Ming Chen, Jianfeng Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The recently unprecedented advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have
propelled the medical community by establishing advanced medical-domain models.
However, due to the limited collection of medical datasets, there are only a
few comprehensive benchmarks available to gauge progress in this area. In this
paper, we introduce a new medical question-answering (QA) dataset that contains
massive manual instruction for solving Traditional Chinese Medicine examination
tasks, called TCMD. Specifically, our TCMD collects massive questions across
diverse domains with their annotated medical subjects and thus supports us in
comprehensively assessing the capability of LLMs in the TCM domain. Extensive
evaluation of various general LLMs and medical-domain-specific LLMs is
conducted. Moreover, we also analyze the robustness of current LLMs in solving
TCM QA tasks by introducing randomness. The inconsistency of the experimental
results also reveals the shortcomings of current LLMs in solving QA tasks. We
also expect that our dataset can further facilitate the development of LLMs in
the TCM area.
|
[
0.051960498094558716,
-1.0991839170455933,
0.9448578953742981,
-0.16324394941329956,
-0.395398885011673,
0.018762793391942978,
-0.36196717619895935,
-0.060706403106451035,
0.03690860792994499,
0.5743474960327148,
-0.4985262155532837,
-0.7824723720550537,
-0.4639083743095398,
0.22140294313430786,
-0.06315447390079498,
0.532333493232727,
-0.12161418050527573,
0.6623533964157104,
-0.21717770397663116,
-0.14978688955307007,
-0.5704317688941956,
-0.44367414712905884,
-0.7497783303260803,
-0.169464111328125,
0.3563327491283417,
0.2540537118911743,
0.6589204668998718,
0.7063698768615723,
0.6183916330337524,
0.22399745881557465,
-0.10118734836578369,
0.40981993079185486,
-0.2867078185081482,
0.12321051210165024,
-0.1409471035003662,
-0.49052557349205017,
-0.5062287449836731,
0.044826798141002655,
0.8199756741523743,
0.9462160468101501,
-0.2702791690826416,
0.1356411725282669,
-0.28005218505859375,
0.392177551984787,
-0.1836102157831192,
0.050457440316677094,
-0.367412805557251,
0.13151195645332336,
-0.06671752780675888,
-0.47812873125076294,
-0.27781370282173157,
-0.5349965691566467,
0.40116235613822937,
-0.57084059715271,
0.08450566232204437,
-0.0006733567570336163,
0.7425997853279114,
0.18093474209308624,
-0.6838006377220154,
-0.07656115293502808,
-0.5821748971939087,
0.8306501507759094,
-0.8895052671432495,
0.21521620452404022,
0.17790555953979492,
0.6319049000740051,
-0.309243768453598,
-0.8119573593139648,
-0.572573721408844,
-0.4947502017021179,
0.2705126106739044,
0.07897614687681198,
0.1171708032488823,
0.057493649423122406,
0.14966954290866852,
0.5488372445106506,
-0.8182858824729919,
0.21724505722522736,
-0.27506735920906067,
-0.06624330580234528,
0.4426916837692261,
0.6624456644058228,
0.8002074956893921,
-0.016620809212327003,
-0.3075889050960541,
-0.04464401304721832,
-0.741546630859375,
-0.12355241924524307,
-0.4286068379878998,
0.05555795133113861,
-0.16373270750045776,
0.4421127140522003,
-0.24143803119659424,
0.8798280954360962,
-0.08179806172847748,
-0.49621766805648804,
0.10594575107097626,
-0.45300912857055664,
-0.5274805426597595,
-0.19818273186683655,
0.8141337633132935,
0.4345792829990387,
0.056454986333847046,
-0.2366059124469757,
-0.0122495973482728,
-0.3754628598690033,
-0.005969701800495386,
-0.6914390325546265,
-0.1345461905002594,
0.7744247317314148,
-0.6358893513679504,
-0.21589592099189758,
-0.010018601082265377,
-0.4011782109737396,
-0.7750651836395264,
-0.3235793709754944,
0.2004995495080948,
-0.42494094371795654,
-0.506205677986145,
0.3026951551437378,
0.0035461068619042635,
0.6123562455177307,
0.4751065969467163,
-0.4537644386291504,
0.26901930570602417,
0.8168848752975464,
0.6928178071975708,
-0.42997661232948303,
-0.18158721923828125,
-0.5439377427101135,
-0.06363067775964737,
-0.6663365960121155,
0.7223621010780334,
-0.5958521366119385,
-0.3447929322719574,
-0.06596546620130539,
0.4166164696216583,
-0.12235826253890991,
-0.9811944365501404,
0.3601662516593933,
-0.5376067161560059,
0.3538305163383484,
-0.3903692662715912,
-0.5534238219261169,
-0.34564974904060364,
0.6240330338478088,
-0.6898531913757324,
0.5937418341636658,
0.46756038069725037,
-0.5729882717132568,
0.07180489599704742,
-0.3599913716316223,
-0.22714757919311523,
0.27426671981811523,
-0.26228198409080505,
-0.2004009187221527,
-0.09208378195762634,
0.07715682685375214,
0.5376822352409363,
-0.8978896737098694,
0.5577020049095154,
-0.2704918384552002,
-0.39108070731163025,
0.509107232093811,
-0.38909345865249634,
1.102582335472107,
0.3078864514827728,
-0.0770476832985878,
0.05874139443039894,
-0.6819441914558411,
0.19776524603366852,
0.20719249546527863,
-0.1529259830713272,
-0.3405158519744873,
-0.12944726645946503,
-0.2060161828994751,
0.3514297604560852,
0.252670019865036,
-0.5089221596717834,
0.2714155614376068,
-0.22106397151947021,
0.4070438742637634,
0.6184290647506714,
0.3771773874759674,
-0.0015371782938018441,
-0.5878967046737671,
0.7666791081428528,
0.34141066670417786,
0.039699237793684006,
-0.008529468439519405,
-0.5525075197219849,
-0.30957162380218506,
0.0064934552647173405,
0.4127199947834015,
0.5068265795707703,
-1.047732949256897,
0.22164782881736755,
-0.31816205382347107,
-0.5521054863929749,
-0.47742143273353577,
0.05674361437559128,
0.31422457098960876,
0.5985382795333862,
0.297176718711853,
-0.3455277681350708,
-0.0937250629067421,
-0.6800301671028137,
0.13554289937019348,
-0.11868482083082199,
-0.38992029428482056,
0.3488759994506836,
0.14538520574569702,
-0.29063400626182556,
0.46340373158454895,
-0.5672925710678101,
-0.2812920808792114,
-0.3059823513031006,
-0.2589154839515686,
0.1438794583082199,
0.24194175004959106,
0.32996827363967896,
-0.689231812953949,
-0.3306955397129059,
0.23877495527267456,
-0.6889548301696777,
-0.18996182084083557,
-0.21674369275569916,
-0.11677907407283783,
0.13554392755031586,
0.18883617222309113,
-0.4163569509983063,
-0.2102072536945343,
0.5134324431419373,
-0.30505651235580444,
0.6787236332893372,
-0.29332485795021057,
0.4110719859600067,
-1.2694400548934937,
0.09637376666069031,
0.1508084386587143,
-0.02165328525006771,
-0.7499358057975769,
0.4259200096130371,
0.3426433801651001,
0.07868584245443344,
-0.5580265522003174,
0.5944548845291138,
-0.4129897356033325,
0.30276983976364136,
-0.21630780398845673,
0.3327476978302002,
-0.07702746242284775,
0.4834092855453491,
0.1624838411808014,
0.542736291885376,
0.6282504200935364,
-0.6321524381637573,
0.6880801320075989,
0.039911091327667236,
-0.1724373996257782,
0.6324459910392761,
-0.7314368486404419,
0.17401520907878876,
-0.0758441910147667,
0.05151886120438576,
-0.8338202238082886,
-0.333469420671463,
0.18077826499938965,
-0.31951072812080383,
0.33297351002693176,
0.11582531780004501,
-0.5376516580581665,
-0.39003264904022217,
-0.3866855204105377,
0.35775014758110046,
0.5004496574401855,
-0.3411148488521576,
0.3576063811779022,
0.38649478554725647,
-0.06347697973251343,
-0.4245949685573578,
-0.47016704082489014,
0.09381325542926788,
-0.00048811110900714993,
-0.6610109210014343,
-0.06345397233963013,
-0.199440136551857,
-0.34821340441703796,
-0.20532216131687164,
-0.21073824167251587,
-0.46464747190475464,
0.18876183032989502,
-0.09615872800350189,
0.4882600009441376,
-0.6394181847572327,
0.16295450925827026,
-0.034230805933475494,
0.17888782918453217,
0.34886595606803894,
-0.14780820906162262,
0.5605915188789368,
0.20009000599384308,
-0.2529754638671875,
-0.5103819966316223,
0.0801955834031105,
0.5283843874931335,
-0.24213466048240662,
0.3364892601966858,
0.13097620010375977,
-0.5317896604537964,
-0.2319878190755844,
-0.5313913226127625,
-0.04434317350387573,
-0.4463265836238861,
0.6913491487503052,
-0.16966772079467773,
-0.7584211826324463,
0.2830894887447357,
0.024856915697455406,
0.12769341468811035,
0.38024863600730896,
0.8803830146789551,
0.1352241486310959,
0.9462119936943054,
0.2099291980266571,
0.03934302181005478,
-0.15456385910511017,
-0.05559876188635826,
-0.21003864705562592,
-0.7391178011894226,
-0.24043883383274078,
-0.39555051922798157,
-0.04262354597449303,
-0.6003426313400269,
-0.7089934945106506,
0.42390385270118713,
-0.5793637633323669,
-0.1595325767993927,
0.0031274016946554184,
-0.45742562413215637,
0.3374708592891693,
0.3833969831466675,
0.3549524247646332,
0.53534996509552,
-0.3663085997104645,
-0.03105655126273632,
0.23056139051914215,
-0.6083282828330994,
-0.49919551610946655,
1.2996598482131958,
0.3607341945171356,
0.7120508551597595,
-0.0534198135137558,
0.2715302109718323,
-0.02862049639225006,
0.3190450668334961,
-0.8107297420501709,
0.6033456325531006,
-0.34628182649612427,
-0.5444819331169128,
-0.2740873098373413,
-0.7470051050186157,
-0.9800167083740234,
0.08785779029130936,
-0.02452126331627369,
-0.2063734233379364,
-0.17027491331100464,
-0.21310587227344513,
-0.5419003963470459,
0.47790104150772095,
-0.6366252303123474,
0.8381932973861694,
-0.25056397914886475,
0.01765676587820053,
0.11505568772554398,
-0.7285270094871521,
0.803085446357727,
-0.24974799156188965,
-0.024772079661488533,
-0.11875297129154205,
-0.16303043067455292,
0.6728816032409668,
-0.3894649147987366,
0.5536984205245972,
-0.19184784591197968,
-0.42341285943984985,
0.2277584820985794,
0.1167365089058876,
0.09774821251630783,
0.185971200466156,
0.02292167954146862,
-0.10213454812765121,
0.6305348873138428,
-0.4994986653327942,
-0.581342339515686,
0.683201253414154,
-0.6791481971740723,
-0.7761965990066528,
-0.5176774859428406,
-0.6292833685874939,
-0.4133296012878418,
0.32744500041007996,
-0.15127073228359222,
0.6612650752067566,
-0.2295835167169571,
0.028708335012197495,
0.9856718182563782,
-0.7117897868156433,
-0.026979666203260422,
0.7679941654205322,
0.05417412891983986,
-0.10408997535705566,
0.842219352722168,
0.23654994368553162,
0.429103821516037,
0.4471904933452606,
0.3565991520881653,
-0.1380307674407959,
-0.9446284770965576,
-0.49675190448760986,
0.42716771364212036,
-0.5425887703895569,
-0.09350854158401489,
-0.6073483228683472,
-0.4025948643684387,
-0.426939457654953,
0.3302137851715088,
0.08038799464702606,
-0.23107939958572388,
-0.03788322955369949,
0.07639919221401215,
0.14856888353824615,
0.7006099224090576,
0.4731467664241791,
-0.02287149615585804,
-0.9807866215705872,
0.7819267511367798,
0.47551336884498596,
0.5590280294418335,
0.05504404380917549,
-0.3750331401824951,
-0.15418654680252075,
0.29167288541793823,
-0.2809491753578186,
-0.7975940108299255,
0.40871044993400574,
-0.1494622826576233,
0.639342188835144,
0.5646406412124634,
0.21563215553760529,
0.45086076855659485,
-0.38098084926605225,
1.0427051782608032,
0.0039427271112799644,
-0.3914891183376312,
0.22131666541099548,
-0.25220558047294617,
0.47349241375923157,
0.29288414120674133,
0.4536246657371521,
-0.9062433242797852,
-0.6178686618804932,
-0.38750749826431274,
-0.45732003450393677,
0.5824795365333557,
-0.27971312403678894,
0.08402340859174728,
-0.11423138529062271,
0.45871585607528687,
0.2427232414484024,
-0.03845033794641495,
-0.32649433612823486,
-0.48164913058280945,
0.18571390211582184,
-0.26086097955703735,
0.14053723216056824,
-0.2581072747707367,
-0.0858941599726677,
-0.1405150443315506,
0.5422652959823608,
-0.09250973910093307,
0.07919976860284805,
0.25037601590156555,
-0.08449278771877289,
-0.2198311686515808,
0.3914848864078522,
0.5679181814193726,
0.9778345227241516,
-0.3293023705482483,
0.13673865795135498,
0.2994343936443329,
-0.9000533819198608,
0.241224467754364,
0.0754241943359375,
-0.09261371940374374,
0.005179759580641985,
0.14610156416893005,
0.2105739861726761,
-0.34923607110977173,
-1.137636423110962,
0.5257985591888428,
-0.28386425971984863,
-0.20507581532001495,
-0.31042054295539856,
0.11906429380178452,
0.1400146633386612,
-0.07607415318489075,
0.503433883190155,
-0.44458073377609253,
0.15424853563308716,
-0.5745782852172852,
0.27102896571159363,
0.39356619119644165,
-0.5371184349060059,
-0.22782355546951294,
0.7745789289474487,
-0.12447506189346313,
-0.12857240438461304,
0.6409664154052734,
-0.012316259555518627,
-0.29519787430763245,
0.9520623087882996,
0.2572236955165863,
0.8098034262657166,
-0.24918612837791443,
0.2089240401983261,
0.32419654726982117,
0.24649585783481598,
-0.15652906894683838,
0.4790859520435333,
0.2599085867404938,
-0.4084007740020752,
-0.6007177829742432,
-0.20965677499771118,
-0.784633219242096,
0.335955947637558,
-0.4608328342437744,
0.3678174912929535,
-0.5587595105171204,
0.11626607924699783,
-0.0737898200750351,
0.3657790422439575,
-0.3971255421638489,
0.5614913702011108,
0.14706271886825562,
1.0345059633255005,
-0.20131811499595642,
1.1218687295913696,
0.6532002687454224,
-0.3134402334690094,
-0.8646183609962463,
0.09147295355796814,
-0.0023614917881786823,
-1.002900242805481,
0.3528212904930115,
-0.03677739202976227,
0.34378090500831604,
-0.21423958241939545,
-0.7279970645904541,
-0.5269871354103088,
1.3395923376083374,
0.2364513874053955,
-0.4249045252799988,
-0.3086819648742676,
0.4054339528083801,
0.6481446027755737,
-0.17941464483737946,
0.3720570206642151,
0.7866158485412598,
0.3139188587665558,
0.002609309507533908,
-0.9424765706062317,
0.5337049961090088,
-0.32417032122612,
-0.11335042864084244,
-0.041954461485147476,
-0.6929794549942017,
0.8204887509346008,
-0.289853036403656,
-0.3096913695335388,
0.39190706610679626,
0.3248581290245056,
0.6160176396369934,
0.32714754343032837,
0.2813055217266083,
0.2646612823009491,
0.8061098456382751,
-0.2892431318759918,
1.1999545097351074,
-0.30258217453956604,
0.08363720029592514,
0.8545405268669128,
-0.31459763646125793,
0.5054249167442322,
0.2630351185798645,
-0.2894652485847473,
0.1269691288471222,
0.8652517795562744,
-0.09768600761890411,
0.06872875988483429,
0.5725492238998413,
-0.12234282493591309,
-0.3369259834289551,
-0.10894279927015305,
-0.6020787358283997,
0.12165089696645737,
0.156380295753479,
-0.29910093545913696,
-0.20025549829006195,
-0.08984968066215515,
0.1490088552236557,
0.03952731192111969,
-0.38084709644317627,
0.7709370255470276,
0.22327971458435059,
-0.5170111656188965,
0.7662723660469055,
0.06019911170005798,
0.5413628220558167,
-0.7330504059791565,
-0.20980268716812134,
-0.5137742757797241,
-0.22203251719474792,
-0.10979088395833969,
-0.7416874766349792,
-0.09192684292793274,
-0.3066098690032959,
0.1804526150226593,
0.17724137008190155,
0.3806663453578949,
-0.6015611290931702,
-0.4511154890060425,
-0.20844817161560059,
0.6941397786140442,
0.23842550814151764,
-0.029267098754644394,
-0.36934804916381836,
-0.3973518908023834,
-0.18719640374183655,
-0.13916568458080292,
0.31705278158187866,
0.8896046280860901,
-0.1834743320941925,
0.8835228085517883,
0.48732903599739075,
0.397664874792099,
-0.06381167471408844,
-0.0055925194174051285,
0.8397200703620911,
-0.9610899090766907,
-0.27942734956741333,
-0.6641222238540649,
0.048389218747615814,
0.04892107844352722,
-0.24464114010334015,
0.6103426218032837,
0.42309442162513733,
0.6298864483833313,
-0.08081469684839249,
0.7683342695236206,
0.13341833651065826,
0.76542729139328,
-0.5388211607933044,
0.9773183465003967,
-0.6657324433326721,
0.38080349564552307,
-0.07441361248493195,
-0.513832688331604,
-0.47799938917160034,
-0.05397288128733635,
-0.1369875818490982,
0.020620182156562805,
0.9072620868682861,
0.6803941130638123,
0.1521000862121582,
0.005696168169379234,
0.5799973607063293,
0.48626160621643066,
0.20528307557106018,
1.0815283060073853,
0.8564482927322388,
-0.31043392419815063,
0.5049733519554138,
-0.49471360445022583,
-0.14883258938789368,
0.10405483096837997,
-0.4924062490463257,
-0.8661078214645386,
-0.48590877652168274,
-0.5238664150238037,
-0.5011614561080933,
-0.024901049211621284,
1.2749032974243164,
0.2516312897205353,
-1.074544072151184,
-0.19703862071037292,
0.43576526641845703,
0.23091523349285126,
-0.5742817521095276,
-0.24195168912410736,
0.8256285190582275,
-0.2585148215293884,
-0.8824301362037659,
0.1058148518204689,
0.12197224795818329,
0.07943584769964218,
-0.34879016876220703,
0.04430091381072998,
0.019982006400823593,
0.023332472890615463,
0.4325169324874878,
0.15297962725162506,
-0.5060994625091553,
-0.13823463022708893,
0.6577864289283752,
-0.42185935378074646,
0.2562890350818634,
0.8332504630088806,
-0.6313986778259277,
0.5270752310752869,
0.375458300113678,
0.8867301344871521,
-0.15478433668613434,
-0.15281999111175537,
0.8252607583999634,
-0.20132297277450562,
-0.3027593791484833,
0.3056603670120239,
0.3662104904651642,
0.13438403606414795,
-0.24586446583271027,
0.4492432475090027,
0.15378780663013458,
-0.379363089799881,
-0.8387566208839417,
-0.2206127941608429,
-1.3650776147842407,
-0.5901960730552673,
1.4946013689041138,
-0.08513160794973373,
-0.47670939564704895,
-0.5255104303359985,
-0.4948464035987854,
0.19744226336479187,
-0.0020242922473698854,
0.9583996534347534,
0.6284146904945374,
0.22642895579338074,
-0.23909138143062592,
-0.6430659890174866,
0.413143128156662,
0.38072633743286133,
-0.94742751121521,
0.017580969259142876,
0.536925196647644,
0.5374633073806763,
-0.2429640293121338,
0.7482157945632935,
-0.5775006413459778,
0.8314555883407593,
-0.40100032091140747,
-0.1651252806186676,
-0.22332310676574707,
0.26961657404899597,
-0.43531525135040283,
0.24631808698177338,
0.21608233451843262,
-0.16804128885269165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04927v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04927v1
|
LLM-based speaker diarization correction: A generalizable approach
| 2024-06-07T13:33:22 | 2024-06-07T13:33:22 |
Georgios Efstathiadis, Vijay Yadav, Anzar Abbas
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
Speaker diarization is necessary for interpreting conversations transcribed
using automated speech recognition (ASR) tools. Despite significant
developments in diarization methods, diarization accuracy remains an issue.
Here, we investigate the use of large language models (LLMs) for diarization
correction as a post-processing step. LLMs were fine-tuned using the Fisher
corpus, a large dataset of transcribed conversations. The ability of the models
to improve diarization accuracy in a holdout dataset was measured. We report
that fine-tuned LLMs can markedly improve diarization accuracy. However, model
performance is constrained to transcripts produced using the same ASR tool as
the transcripts used for fine-tuning, limiting generalizability. To address
this constraint, an ensemble model was developed by combining weights from
three separate models, each fine-tuned using transcripts from a different ASR
tool. The ensemble model demonstrated better overall performance than each of
the ASR-specific models, suggesting that a generalizable and ASR-agnostic
approach may be achievable. We hope to make these models accessible through
public-facing APIs for use by third-party applications.
|
[
-0.1613386571407318,
-0.567188560962677,
0.29873597621917725,
0.0541110597550869,
-0.27529028058052063,
0.1916332095861435,
-0.56095951795578,
-0.6755871772766113,
0.14678609371185303,
0.8612210750579834,
-0.1220346987247467,
-0.5125234127044678,
-0.5114017724990845,
0.3303820788860321,
-0.5817957520484924,
0.7782802581787109,
0.15886756777763367,
0.27225977182388306,
-0.06234604865312576,
0.03602488338947296,
-0.41712862253189087,
-0.5582751631736755,
-0.5482138991355896,
-0.45848721265792847,
0.2612491548061371,
0.47021248936653137,
0.6221584677696228,
0.9240524172782898,
0.5600202679634094,
0.36334744095802307,
-0.4162400960922241,
0.20804959535598755,
-0.37647461891174316,
-0.09586569666862488,
-0.10787072032690048,
-0.41322001814842224,
-0.8121771216392517,
-0.06606127321720123,
0.8820580244064331,
0.9356896281242371,
-0.4761984944343567,
0.09947139024734497,
0.1506977379322052,
0.31943467259407043,
-0.36604928970336914,
0.025264110416173935,
-0.9987537860870361,
-0.23690390586853027,
-0.18905141949653625,
-0.30843284726142883,
-0.5945290923118591,
-0.1178223043680191,
0.21408095955848694,
-0.3554362654685974,
0.5502875447273254,
-0.18354050815105438,
0.5478025078773499,
0.310383677482605,
-0.09371040016412735,
-0.27769485116004944,
-1.4305803775787354,
0.8683297038078308,
-0.9144677519798279,
0.5539398193359375,
0.5553995966911316,
0.2032908797264099,
-0.02879825234413147,
-0.381783664226532,
-0.38949260115623474,
-0.20162875950336456,
-0.014558319002389908,
-0.16461794078350067,
-0.10434329509735107,
0.34671518206596375,
0.16047438979148865,
0.3659752607345581,
-0.33250635862350464,
0.46963444352149963,
-0.6061046719551086,
-0.28480225801467896,
0.928484320640564,
0.1750049740076065,
0.09944786876440048,
0.2334570288658142,
-0.19539305567741394,
-0.11833005398511887,
-0.6241564154624939,
-0.18406064808368683,
0.3859391212463379,
0.7850813269615173,
-0.10665128380060196,
0.6896984577178955,
-0.171164408326149,
0.7148098945617676,
0.1566014289855957,
-0.023014450445771217,
0.1377464085817337,
-0.09948008507490158,
-0.32906898856163025,
0.2399335503578186,
0.5998384356498718,
0.4963993728160858,
0.5086638331413269,
-0.19129134714603424,
-0.4200906753540039,
-0.12004238367080688,
0.0763913094997406,
-0.6626121997833252,
-0.5916721224784851,
0.4232429563999176,
-0.35517618060112,
0.017117120325565338,
0.011220955289900303,
-0.6604582667350769,
-0.3981161415576935,
-0.6767529249191284,
0.29154321551322937,
-0.26926732063293457,
-0.14453338086605072,
0.08207181841135025,
0.13629551231861115,
0.07494476437568665,
0.6248940825462341,
-1.0827257633209229,
0.5794985294342041,
0.6430561542510986,
0.8545100092887878,
-0.1795233190059662,
-0.062191497534513474,
-0.6481835842132568,
0.37085118889808655,
-0.38366296887397766,
0.7864057421684265,
-0.7135199904441833,
-0.6708279848098755,
0.03805270418524742,
-0.36123815178871155,
-0.34000417590141296,
-0.9245965480804443,
0.35917899012565613,
-0.5616104006767273,
0.11798062175512314,
0.14062003791332245,
-0.822546124458313,
0.18584614992141724,
-0.013162843883037567,
-0.5716591477394104,
0.5871214270591736,
-0.22191734611988068,
-0.6543532609939575,
0.17293739318847656,
-0.3686601519584656,
-0.13431623578071594,
0.15661489963531494,
-0.2487930953502655,
-0.38609179854393005,
-0.012168105691671371,
0.2144177258014679,
0.5512582063674927,
-0.12532120943069458,
0.20894140005111694,
-0.0418553501367569,
-0.6515222787857056,
0.19450968503952026,
-0.22676672041416168,
0.40216726064682007,
0.14404387772083282,
0.15832193195819855,
0.2663356363773346,
-1.0061144828796387,
-0.07797455042600632,
-0.21277284622192383,
-0.7896274328231812,
-0.2677440047264099,
0.2476349174976349,
0.11346369981765747,
-0.2924375534057617,
0.18440721929073334,
-0.592677116394043,
0.020227978006005287,
-0.6513782143592834,
0.42372316122055054,
0.6103376150131226,
-0.11892515420913696,
0.5484310388565063,
-0.2811416685581207,
0.2786237597465515,
-0.010973956435918808,
-0.19664140045642853,
-0.02348378300666809,
-0.42279762029647827,
-0.6951547861099243,
-0.5019320845603943,
0.5808959007263184,
0.7881504893302917,
-0.3581765294075012,
0.5720560550689697,
-0.5821455121040344,
-0.4927573800086975,
-0.4882889688014984,
0.19634731113910675,
0.5501949787139893,
0.4109225571155548,
0.5103291273117065,
-0.5018610954284668,
-0.6116626262664795,
-0.6357262134552002,
-0.23855048418045044,
-0.4798973798751831,
-0.43053334951400757,
0.3299688696861267,
0.14336839318275452,
-0.4099169969558716,
1.002089023590088,
-0.28448545932769775,
-0.27258986234664917,
-0.1089908629655838,
0.19098693132400513,
0.29623281955718994,
0.43425482511520386,
-0.009866805747151375,
-0.6153472661972046,
-0.31983882188796997,
0.0940917506814003,
-0.045736756175756454,
-0.22891667485237122,
0.0009339704411104321,
0.2854216694831848,
0.176395982503891,
0.6929362416267395,
-0.585313618183136,
0.307628870010376,
0.3583524823188782,
-0.08231586962938309,
0.7790685892105103,
-0.2492530792951584,
-0.16184237599372864,
-0.8154153227806091,
0.03228899836540222,
-0.05420162156224251,
-0.17553110420703888,
-1.022101640701294,
-0.2949603796005249,
0.002026811009272933,
-0.0031305579468607903,
-0.3591647744178772,
0.408843994140625,
-0.30246424674987793,
-0.2269463986158371,
-0.15696099400520325,
0.12109947204589844,
-0.21818757057189941,
0.09222052246332169,
0.24700677394866943,
0.7254130840301514,
0.36218464374542236,
-0.8945943117141724,
0.4620598256587982,
0.6825136542320251,
-0.3817288875579834,
0.3073663115501404,
-0.6878993511199951,
0.39068618416786194,
-0.07363209873437881,
0.33122533559799194,
-1.128333568572998,
-0.4728529155254364,
0.14891889691352844,
-0.3394465446472168,
0.5039734244346619,
-0.44070789217948914,
-0.23862482607364655,
-0.23884600400924683,
-0.03226778283715248,
0.36107972264289856,
0.14474284648895264,
-0.5150839686393738,
0.5522712469100952,
0.27304407954216003,
-0.5806693434715271,
-0.3221982419490814,
-0.6497531533241272,
0.11714505404233932,
-0.37290525436401367,
-0.4757980406284332,
0.6875617504119873,
-0.19033923745155334,
-0.4728032350540161,
-0.5504050850868225,
0.07394871860742569,
-0.18492397665977478,
-0.22103120386600494,
0.03379780054092407,
0.31130608916282654,
-0.22921819984912872,
0.3478396236896515,
-0.3844786584377289,
-0.023734919726848602,
-0.18772859871387482,
0.04342435300350189,
0.709502637386322,
0.09208713471889496,
-0.20293234288692474,
-0.717532753944397,
0.1678728312253952,
0.5617822408676147,
-0.42332103848457336,
0.5989778637886047,
0.45404571294784546,
-0.22848419845104218,
-0.0792166218161583,
-0.7457228302955627,
-0.2527632415294647,
-0.4387623369693756,
0.2908456027507782,
-0.2962433099746704,
-1.0304341316223145,
0.8410392999649048,
-0.005280002485960722,
0.12182464450597763,
0.16350266337394714,
0.5146386027336121,
-0.03319217637181282,
0.927786648273468,
0.40325167775154114,
-0.2383929342031479,
0.5855444073677063,
0.014253671281039715,
0.08455297350883484,
-0.8942172527313232,
-0.04349878057837486,
-0.6234834790229797,
-0.2007470726966858,
-0.6526908278465271,
-0.4451822340488434,
0.1583338975906372,
-0.03153691813349724,
-0.09056666493415833,
0.2676348388195038,
-0.40957435965538025,
0.4973513185977936,
0.5345450639724731,
0.08036507666110992,
0.45245036482810974,
0.06269888579845428,
0.24254176020622253,
0.17237810790538788,
-0.2959226667881012,
-0.7277277112007141,
1.1540635824203491,
0.4438137710094452,
0.7672377824783325,
0.13165070116519928,
0.6963286399841309,
0.2931729257106781,
0.017740493640303612,
-0.7656190991401672,
0.5498822927474976,
-0.36943724751472473,
-0.3256435990333557,
-0.6668623685836792,
-0.6440640091896057,
-0.8793432116508484,
0.2431095540523529,
-0.10617928206920624,
-1.1147582530975342,
0.2989630103111267,
0.4256921410560608,
-0.8114351630210876,
0.21951983869075775,
-0.7454807162284851,
0.515207827091217,
0.09798727184534073,
0.10146366059780121,
-0.2769686281681061,
-0.6421111822128296,
0.2414167821407318,
-0.270906925201416,
0.28238388895988464,
-0.22577054798603058,
0.20475412905216217,
0.8002454042434692,
-0.3404677212238312,
0.8879657983779907,
-0.15383344888687134,
-0.4034205973148346,
0.32126083970069885,
-0.07189849019050598,
0.6507713198661804,
-0.1863555610179901,
-0.4411301016807556,
0.220331609249115,
0.16114667057991028,
-0.0680714026093483,
-0.37522101402282715,
0.4086637496948242,
-1.0027506351470947,
-0.6081372499465942,
0.1513669639825821,
-0.4806632101535797,
-0.38864070177078247,
-0.19959621131420135,
0.32347774505615234,
0.5934824347496033,
-0.31672486662864685,
0.19519616663455963,
0.6908214688301086,
-0.12854886054992676,
0.297145813703537,
0.6888574957847595,
-0.2794017195701599,
-0.4069921374320984,
0.7544722557067871,
0.21077847480773926,
0.31813082098960876,
0.5392117500305176,
0.18859143555164337,
-0.27779680490493774,
-0.9864668846130371,
-0.20006635785102844,
0.2120106965303421,
-0.4018796384334564,
-0.15202412009239197,
-0.6188652515411377,
-0.3037647306919098,
-0.6904230713844299,
0.17080911993980408,
-0.4611228108406067,
-0.5468235611915588,
-0.6842379570007324,
0.035292062908411026,
0.34371933341026306,
0.6263686418533325,
-0.14712728559970856,
0.7765358686447144,
-0.9035571217536926,
0.3049059212207794,
0.3992593288421631,
0.4847705364227295,
-0.33677318692207336,
-0.9382940530776978,
-0.2750707268714905,
0.23161791265010834,
-0.1541961133480072,
-0.6277413964271545,
0.45053380727767944,
0.6399567723274231,
0.18989470601081848,
0.5553082823753357,
0.022317150607705116,
0.8517103791236877,
-0.7252866625785828,
0.6606513261795044,
0.0489652194082737,
-0.9166054129600525,
0.6285898089408875,
-0.6200336217880249,
0.08619067072868347,
0.3426949381828308,
-0.25291135907173157,
-0.5345197916030884,
-0.34294161200523376,
-0.3331613540649414,
-0.9044091701507568,
0.8008679151535034,
0.1257462054491043,
0.23143954575061798,
-0.012363659217953682,
0.273871511220932,
-0.08179859071969986,
0.06594813615083694,
-0.24007433652877808,
0.13421320915222168,
0.16182421147823334,
-0.06360310316085815,
-0.5472279787063599,
-0.39348599314689636,
-0.18546725809574127,
-0.3248481750488281,
0.6222237348556519,
-0.011928140185773373,
0.299237996339798,
0.15090610086917877,
-0.11135902255773544,
-0.454166442155838,
0.48724180459976196,
0.6123487949371338,
0.6119961738586426,
-0.5112801194190979,
0.019773827865719795,
0.4415036141872406,
-0.39816173911094666,
-0.08417408913373947,
0.23619480431079865,
0.04775461554527283,
0.001212697010487318,
0.3224415183067322,
0.7025466561317444,
0.2656458914279938,
-0.8150517344474792,
0.3523840308189392,
-0.038120344281196594,
-0.1534598022699356,
-0.41164109110832214,
0.1754535436630249,
0.009911054745316505,
0.40153276920318604,
0.3561801612377167,
0.10620660334825516,
0.11007850617170334,
-0.31654080748558044,
0.2802107036113739,
0.3016434609889984,
-0.11879930645227432,
-0.3359978497028351,
0.6593689322471619,
0.3115207254886627,
-0.6035552620887756,
0.746125340461731,
0.12728838622570038,
-0.3318515121936798,
0.43962550163269043,
0.49963387846946716,
0.6830028891563416,
-1.0212440490722656,
0.15974999964237213,
0.18489058315753937,
0.057604771107435226,
-0.3114759027957916,
0.1321166455745697,
-0.0020398087799549103,
-1.150286078453064,
-0.6123021841049194,
-0.7527666687965393,
-0.7649321556091309,
0.287789523601532,
-0.7872204780578613,
0.31731298565864563,
-0.5531474947929382,
-0.3761601746082306,
0.11961803585290909,
-0.1332150250673294,
-0.5600461363792419,
0.372240275144577,
0.4538837671279907,
0.7001504898071289,
-0.8695347309112549,
0.7483665943145752,
0.6580219268798828,
0.15292656421661377,
-0.7644667029380798,
0.02281108871102333,
-0.04907241836190224,
-0.5316800475120544,
0.1805458962917328,
0.08787976205348969,
-0.08502160757780075,
0.05521409586071968,
-0.4978696405887604,
-1.0242164134979248,
1.0382810831069946,
0.4738765358924866,
-0.9992877244949341,
0.04260117560625076,
0.31663015484809875,
0.6916383504867554,
-0.377872496843338,
0.1951708048582077,
0.7572686076164246,
0.18575330078601837,
0.4654782712459564,
-1.454014778137207,
-0.5238352417945862,
-0.1620659977197647,
0.11848326772451401,
0.013144323602318764,
-0.5202513933181763,
0.8091397881507874,
-0.1653348207473755,
-0.14701516926288605,
0.20523013174533844,
0.7379841804504395,
0.3432298004627228,
0.255429208278656,
0.5216395258903503,
0.4108959138393402,
1.0990408658981323,
0.26461660861968994,
0.673827052116394,
-0.1870751529932022,
0.17511388659477234,
1.3929646015167236,
-0.5592451095581055,
1.2226855754852295,
0.3306163549423218,
-0.3685913681983948,
0.18433894217014313,
0.5789721608161926,
-0.01887420192360878,
0.3619762361049652,
0.3067406117916107,
-0.2864098846912384,
-0.38557785749435425,
-0.06653965264558792,
-0.24260824918746948,
0.9122227430343628,
0.5694828629493713,
-0.4728948175907135,
0.07329987734556198,
-0.13880714774131775,
-0.21468570828437805,
0.11183951050043106,
-0.6113992929458618,
0.8257244229316711,
0.032528527081012726,
-0.39996445178985596,
0.6393131017684937,
0.12312383949756622,
0.46258050203323364,
-0.1532287895679474,
0.09466318786144257,
0.0504775308072567,
0.4099753499031067,
-0.3220321536064148,
-0.4254379868507385,
0.4309968650341034,
0.27919307351112366,
-0.2936936318874359,
-0.28559789061546326,
0.7037191390991211,
-0.7022344470024109,
-0.5357001423835754,
0.24929006397724152,
0.4727345407009125,
0.43278953433036804,
-0.13854743540287018,
-0.12965619564056396,
0.14109694957733154,
0.04022783786058426,
-0.07025396078824997,
0.11943691223859787,
0.1120024248957634,
-0.08554626256227493,
0.5899994969367981,
0.5527718663215637,
0.2815771996974945,
0.14747871458530426,
0.4770551323890686,
0.71685791015625,
-0.3862555921077728,
-0.4334637224674225,
-0.8875023722648621,
0.3862137496471405,
0.15499843657016754,
-0.10662290453910828,
0.4211578965187073,
0.6391711235046387,
0.8807063102722168,
-0.09224119782447815,
0.6347144842147827,
0.46060851216316223,
1.1505236625671387,
-0.5747729539871216,
0.5686632394790649,
-0.12601424753665924,
0.5904385447502136,
-0.35643836855888367,
-1.041495680809021,
-0.5164198875427246,
0.5592402219772339,
-0.6066359877586365,
-0.0018690633587539196,
-0.0013117671478539705,
0.9088644981384277,
-0.07174462825059891,
0.14957016706466675,
0.5308548808097839,
0.37878596782684326,
0.3194569945335388,
0.17839102447032928,
0.8058212995529175,
-0.07804501056671143,
0.6161515712738037,
0.11385484784841537,
-0.21574631333351135,
-0.4187641739845276,
-0.5255727171897888,
-0.8415741920471191,
-0.4782913625240326,
-0.5656523108482361,
0.05776689946651459,
0.19825828075408936,
1.052302360534668,
0.6030659675598145,
-1.1143370866775513,
-0.3941512703895569,
0.06282585859298706,
-0.2787497341632843,
0.047888074070215225,
-0.13966402411460876,
0.26461851596832275,
-0.017941603437066078,
-0.7216318845748901,
0.6818796992301941,
-0.008189881220459938,
0.16532030701637268,
0.22084495425224304,
-0.1106298640370369,
0.1167822927236557,
0.25347432494163513,
0.48781970143318176,
0.2586261034011841,
-0.7725088596343994,
-0.548954427242279,
-0.33319661021232605,
0.1335950493812561,
0.28697583079338074,
0.5367619395256042,
-0.46974942088127136,
0.554671585559845,
0.2324996441602707,
0.3551642894744873,
0.4431040585041046,
0.49961718916893005,
0.7169511914253235,
-1.0948594808578491,
-0.07623956352472305,
0.30751025676727295,
0.3019236624240875,
0.6907406449317932,
-0.26883068680763245,
0.3604040741920471,
-0.03138446435332298,
-0.738551914691925,
-0.8730378150939941,
0.1789620965719223,
-0.8403124213218689,
0.16527362167835236,
1.2962764501571655,
-0.11357154697179794,
0.15989458560943604,
-0.13444110751152039,
-0.2523682713508606,
0.5039674639701843,
-0.4450928568840027,
0.8649144172668457,
0.7405176758766174,
-0.274062842130661,
-0.34861502051353455,
-0.2783874273300171,
0.41962486505508423,
0.19574032723903656,
-0.4587399661540985,
0.385769248008728,
0.5088247656822205,
0.1676996499300003,
0.32495149970054626,
0.795992374420166,
0.08554162085056305,
-0.08119615912437439,
-0.3626491129398346,
0.15739481151103973,
0.3549584746360779,
-0.4159919023513794,
-0.5314175486564636,
-0.19029241800308228,
0.1624235212802887,
-0.27069735527038574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04926v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04926v1
|
Through the Thicket: A Study of Number-Oriented LLMs derived from Random Forest Models
| 2024-06-07T13:31:51 | 2024-06-07T13:31:51 |
Michał Romaszewski, Przemysław Sekuła, Przemysław Głomb, Michał Cholewa, Katarzyna Kołodziej
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown exceptional performance in text
processing. Notably, LLMs can synthesize information from large datasets and
explain their decisions similarly to human reasoning through a chain of thought
(CoT). An emerging application of LLMs is the handling and interpreting of
numerical data, where fine-tuning enhances their performance over basic
inference methods. This paper proposes a novel approach to training LLMs using
knowledge transfer from a random forest (RF) ensemble, leveraging its
efficiency and accuracy. By converting RF decision paths into natural language
statements, we generate outputs for LLM fine-tuning, enhancing the model's
ability to classify and explain its decisions. Our method includes verifying
these rules through established classification metrics, ensuring their
correctness. We also examine the impact of preprocessing techniques on the
representation of numerical data and their influence on classification accuracy
and rule correctness
|
[
-0.3365715742111206,
-0.6824631690979004,
0.5767270922660828,
0.20843611657619476,
-0.41889920830726624,
0.08488351851701736,
-0.49977946281433105,
-0.7143367528915405,
-0.252953439950943,
0.8304017782211304,
-0.4697076678276062,
-0.7570273280143738,
-0.5211570858955383,
0.004220218863338232,
-0.5193392038345337,
1.2509195804595947,
-0.06237053498625755,
0.02319270744919777,
-0.17893169820308685,
-0.08757834881544113,
-0.22559399902820587,
-0.5670368075370789,
-0.7185224890708923,
-0.45927950739860535,
0.3621082901954651,
0.3039487600326538,
0.5643407702445984,
0.8280689716339111,
0.6560298800468445,
0.374530553817749,
0.11117582023143768,
0.26458123326301575,
-0.45713943243026733,
0.1090407446026802,
-0.2767510712146759,
-0.7628886699676514,
-0.2843451201915741,
-0.2858760952949524,
0.7369815111160278,
0.5225155353546143,
-0.23852305114269257,
0.15157079696655273,
0.033993542194366455,
0.5494896769523621,
-0.24544869363307953,
0.1705448031425476,
-1.0013154745101929,
0.03212563693523407,
-0.36114785075187683,
-0.6564005017280579,
-0.6393115520477295,
-0.6550900340080261,
0.1993245780467987,
-0.6240137815475464,
0.3549347221851349,
0.13129140436649323,
0.5294379591941833,
0.24155311286449432,
-0.10383248329162598,
-0.24087876081466675,
-0.7510068416595459,
0.9994961619377136,
-0.6251559853553772,
0.004106633365154266,
0.47960469126701355,
0.4433095455169678,
-0.13233397901058197,
-0.432578444480896,
-0.448641300201416,
0.3109922409057617,
-0.0328376442193985,
-0.30715933442115784,
0.08444397896528244,
0.2918090224266052,
0.16221879422664642,
0.28181886672973633,
-0.4153972268104553,
0.3295421898365021,
-0.4775561988353729,
-0.10474355518817902,
0.9715534448623657,
0.09576988965272903,
0.18797698616981506,
0.0651196837425232,
-0.18521548807621002,
-0.5080659985542297,
-0.4091849625110626,
-0.08426365256309509,
0.09172571450471878,
0.4651610553264618,
-0.14447803795337677,
0.4034958779811859,
-0.18816149234771729,
0.9562669992446899,
-0.3218819200992584,
-0.37218746542930603,
-0.011743809096515179,
-0.04557434469461441,
-0.5907396078109741,
0.2539050281047821,
0.574928879737854,
0.16435477137565613,
0.8716235756874084,
-0.2662171423435211,
-0.4084937274456024,
-0.07071319967508316,
0.02033418044447899,
-0.9165230989456177,
-0.2220640331506729,
-0.0066122147254645824,
-0.2835451364517212,
-0.7880706191062927,
-0.13340863585472107,
-0.6046655178070068,
-0.36809810996055603,
-0.4802260398864746,
0.3232021629810333,
-0.7024063467979431,
0.02187149040400982,
0.4274284839630127,
-0.07772181183099747,
0.05794428661465645,
0.6320769786834717,
-1.1045827865600586,
0.5769861936569214,
0.7960690855979919,
0.8077771663665771,
0.036526456475257874,
-0.14610262215137482,
-0.18244214355945587,
0.2560276985168457,
-0.31991755962371826,
0.9610694646835327,
-0.49737367033958435,
-0.17899519205093384,
-0.16555240750312805,
-0.4048079550266266,
-0.11308681219816208,
-0.4947861433029175,
0.3832509219646454,
-0.7170645594596863,
0.06333805620670319,
0.1369112730026245,
-0.4280427098274231,
-0.4700680673122406,
0.36395102739334106,
-0.3739413619041443,
0.8562881350517273,
0.03426682576537132,
-0.6682601571083069,
0.4220757484436035,
-0.4838144779205322,
-0.5372169017791748,
0.08852729946374893,
-0.27314063906669617,
-0.2700052261352539,
0.060149580240249634,
0.2696055769920349,
0.7139804363250732,
-0.37357187271118164,
0.2525571286678314,
-0.5184099078178406,
-0.3641888499259949,
0.2996757924556732,
-0.5711084604263306,
0.6674432754516602,
0.27135711908340454,
0.07018585503101349,
-0.058582089841365814,
-0.7898667454719543,
0.46109846234321594,
-0.0701141357421875,
-0.3179384469985962,
-0.6564649343490601,
-0.12225577980279922,
-0.16479060053825378,
-0.009205765090882778,
0.024568460881710052,
-0.20797918736934662,
0.4473998248577118,
-0.3553646206855774,
0.30916911363601685,
0.9900559782981873,
0.07480087131261826,
0.5638014674186707,
-0.5198933482170105,
0.21177636086940765,
-0.1528022289276123,
-0.25287461280822754,
-0.08438733220100403,
-0.15267504751682281,
-0.5683044791221619,
-0.28789854049682617,
0.42207929491996765,
0.5250446200370789,
-0.5732148289680481,
0.4363729953765869,
-0.4387986660003662,
-0.40873539447784424,
-0.3575158715248108,
0.2861614525318146,
0.06793151050806046,
0.12084289640188217,
0.3486298620700836,
-0.10099364817142487,
-0.7338457703590393,
-0.46484097838401794,
-0.24765601754188538,
-0.14402608573436737,
-0.0892379954457283,
0.09820006042718887,
0.3327994644641876,
-0.16017921268939972,
0.8775312900543213,
-0.4523749053478241,
-0.39695441722869873,
-0.19944027066230774,
0.43386492133140564,
0.19053930044174194,
0.5817094445228577,
0.48861172795295715,
-0.46763113141059875,
-0.16609829664230347,
0.43710270524024963,
-0.8623688817024231,
-0.010624893009662628,
-0.17164796590805054,
-0.12859393656253815,
-0.03706660121679306,
0.3868780732154846,
-0.4428849518299103,
0.18380142748355865,
0.5618792772293091,
-0.12446621805429459,
0.3007639944553375,
-0.15147008001804352,
0.03974729776382446,
-0.9083224534988403,
-0.26367509365081787,
0.10503344982862473,
-0.12894229590892792,
-0.21826794743537903,
-0.2790757417678833,
-0.43874531984329224,
0.11342514306306839,
-0.10541883856058121,
0.4816349148750305,
-0.30159083008766174,
-0.2209237962961197,
0.033441320061683655,
-0.26140815019607544,
-0.04152890294790268,
0.44456109404563904,
0.1627419888973236,
0.5967742204666138,
0.45084866881370544,
-0.5939680933952332,
0.1851455718278885,
-0.021313399076461792,
-0.5692567825317383,
0.4397205710411072,
-0.29234403371810913,
0.24646307528018951,
-0.26434004306793213,
0.27011218667030334,
-0.702614426612854,
-0.2732725143432617,
-0.20571286976337433,
-0.16955876350402832,
0.19499710202217102,
-0.41046181321144104,
-0.5529794692993164,
-0.1337689906358719,
-0.13582944869995117,
0.5010126829147339,
0.6036955118179321,
-0.39401763677597046,
0.5973774194717407,
0.17236365377902985,
-0.09885251522064209,
-0.36883294582366943,
-0.8999655842781067,
-0.3243115246295929,
-0.44902995228767395,
-0.7461240291595459,
0.28366249799728394,
0.2181973159313202,
-0.5533698797225952,
-0.2876482307910919,
-0.055684227496385574,
-0.41602325439453125,
0.08095129579305649,
0.018378954380750656,
-0.01595955714583397,
-0.3979654908180237,
0.2525482475757599,
0.0691123753786087,
0.2420230358839035,
0.2704172432422638,
-0.4558715522289276,
0.33621734380722046,
-0.16994990408420563,
-0.13121439516544342,
-0.27668941020965576,
-0.19720402359962463,
0.4853448271751404,
-0.2067268043756485,
0.7524245381355286,
0.38966310024261475,
-0.4522761106491089,
-0.8732305765151978,
-0.3426010310649872,
-0.46960100531578064,
-0.49926304817199707,
0.3071366250514984,
-0.44791120290756226,
-0.8493908643722534,
0.28938546776771545,
-0.3426835834980011,
0.25851571559906006,
0.2971954047679901,
0.13720574975013733,
-0.21051852405071259,
1.0949283838272095,
0.7551594376564026,
0.015362263657152653,
0.4969475269317627,
-0.470639169216156,
-0.11679261922836304,
-0.43901893496513367,
-0.2109304815530777,
-0.6596693396568298,
-0.3396202623844147,
-0.3763219714164734,
-0.6888830065727234,
0.006248100195080042,
0.3054840862751007,
-0.3399791419506073,
0.15135516226291656,
-0.44830483198165894,
0.6831086277961731,
0.047314368188381195,
0.1939229816198349,
0.49371227622032166,
0.6229641437530518,
-0.0908813551068306,
-0.06538078188896179,
-0.7786445021629333,
-0.7539288401603699,
0.864173948764801,
0.545072615146637,
1.0348469018936157,
0.04013665020465851,
0.7062917351722717,
0.503262996673584,
0.8311227560043335,
-0.7594408988952637,
0.6395291090011597,
-0.414370059967041,
-0.43230465054512024,
-0.6473489999771118,
-0.6322256326675415,
-0.5494908690452576,
0.3906012773513794,
-0.45731931924819946,
-0.9200729727745056,
-0.07511443644762039,
0.03102097101509571,
-0.4005870521068573,
0.6348060369491577,
-0.6627983450889587,
0.5522274374961853,
-0.4633617699146271,
-0.2827063202857971,
-0.5290364623069763,
-0.3026624023914337,
0.6728042960166931,
-0.2153705358505249,
0.3418066203594208,
-0.14943931996822357,
0.2705085277557373,
1.037145733833313,
-0.295242577791214,
0.8580272197723389,
-0.03353944420814514,
-0.14591728150844574,
0.4465562105178833,
0.238350048661232,
0.5775428414344788,
0.07171019911766052,
-0.5302621722221375,
0.21040663123130798,
0.04593925550580025,
-0.1454385370016098,
-0.8576282262802124,
0.5158991813659668,
-1.012108325958252,
-0.3490503132343292,
-0.51786869764328,
-0.6652832627296448,
-0.3017025589942932,
0.2568594813346863,
-0.12933902442455292,
0.42727214097976685,
-0.25609052181243896,
0.28326109051704407,
0.9036024212837219,
0.05188693478703499,
0.04556247964501381,
0.46212607622146606,
-0.35399311780929565,
-0.3077516555786133,
0.8913605213165283,
0.29066231846809387,
0.09254340082406998,
0.7250874042510986,
0.150457963347435,
-0.28581559658050537,
-1.0647687911987305,
-0.3587607145309448,
0.1352595090866089,
-0.6024971008300781,
-0.42414021492004395,
-0.5592609643936157,
-0.38997623324394226,
-0.09929249435663223,
-0.27139732241630554,
0.12434271723031998,
-0.30703726410865784,
-0.18010860681533813,
-0.22846969962120056,
0.8508880138397217,
0.9600014090538025,
0.1711529791355133,
0.6609124541282654,
-0.7718305587768555,
-0.007174888625741005,
0.3440491259098053,
0.4731542468070984,
0.02143988199532032,
-0.6040355563163757,
-0.15351496636867523,
0.22016657888889313,
-0.07986520975828171,
-0.3952328860759735,
0.36405622959136963,
0.1548437774181366,
0.20295293629169464,
0.39546093344688416,
-0.053896211087703705,
0.7830957770347595,
-0.16856305301189423,
0.08597315102815628,
0.0594794861972332,
-0.6706927418708801,
0.305021733045578,
-0.4270438849925995,
0.12963053584098816,
0.721906304359436,
0.19471067190170288,
-0.19412145018577576,
-0.14353099465370178,
-0.641531765460968,
-0.3933621644973755,
0.8536173701286316,
0.03663255274295807,
-0.11806908249855042,
0.3168680667877197,
0.24923266470432281,
-0.013475297950208187,
0.09365100413560867,
-0.3574296236038208,
0.39264965057373047,
0.2209608107805252,
-0.5182957649230957,
-0.12188127636909485,
-0.0203187707811594,
-0.0810614749789238,
-0.32535579800605774,
0.5102013945579529,
-0.3422810733318329,
-0.07848475873470306,
0.1407794952392578,
-0.14371973276138306,
-0.23818278312683105,
0.3443620204925537,
0.4982299506664276,
0.6842489838600159,
-0.47277963161468506,
0.5288528800010681,
0.6948173642158508,
-0.4674608111381531,
0.04040361940860748,
0.03557882457971573,
-0.037466876208782196,
-0.19794656336307526,
0.6419493556022644,
0.532075822353363,
0.308159738779068,
-0.5475070476531982,
0.047936346381902695,
-0.0744905024766922,
-0.2961135506629944,
-0.06089811027050018,
0.232614666223526,
-0.021910931915044785,
0.08601012825965881,
0.37326061725616455,
0.6097843050956726,
0.005820322781801224,
-0.4096290171146393,
0.37812283635139465,
0.28411194682121277,
-0.17975948750972748,
-0.2739166021347046,
0.14638136327266693,
0.2647770643234253,
-0.17346462607383728,
0.6143974661827087,
0.22679008543491364,
-0.35961928963661194,
0.7440251111984253,
0.5127123594284058,
0.6023485064506531,
0.06639941036701202,
0.08386329561471939,
0.1803130954504013,
0.31181636452674866,
-0.28880029916763306,
0.0716533362865448,
-0.23971623182296753,
-0.9714030027389526,
-0.7321782112121582,
-0.9403616189956665,
-0.27845364809036255,
0.09623534232378006,
-0.4512525498867035,
0.3952122926712036,
-0.9094887971878052,
0.0034498553723096848,
0.11876112967729568,
0.08945843577384949,
-0.7544037699699402,
0.48228317499160767,
0.25098055601119995,
1.1203378438949585,
-0.8161369562149048,
1.0047481060028076,
0.6409515738487244,
-0.017545705661177635,
-0.994439959526062,
-0.2086699903011322,
-0.344768226146698,
-1.0121110677719116,
0.5805754661560059,
0.1065322607755661,
-0.15858885645866394,
0.16498468816280365,
-0.697914719581604,
-0.6297208070755005,
1.003193736076355,
0.42433902621269226,
-0.788779079914093,
0.08943787217140198,
0.2134074717760086,
0.714609682559967,
-0.33059635758399963,
0.3769388496875763,
0.45960861444473267,
0.45704537630081177,
0.33964934945106506,
-0.5936067700386047,
-0.02597120776772499,
0.10981322079896927,
-0.12255632132291794,
0.18826597929000854,
-0.5094955563545227,
0.623851478099823,
-0.42418307065963745,
-0.14883403480052948,
-0.09258536249399185,
0.7984976172447205,
0.5039790868759155,
0.2491641640663147,
0.5108879804611206,
0.5011578798294067,
1.0399888753890991,
-0.046833161264657974,
0.9228811860084534,
-0.06590534001588821,
0.08677531778812408,
1.0400121212005615,
-0.22229567170143127,
0.921040952205658,
0.37465715408325195,
-0.2731904089450836,
0.7382936477661133,
0.5110561847686768,
0.16549086570739746,
0.4472382664680481,
0.6182429790496826,
-0.42570215463638306,
-0.3042447566986084,
-0.092258520424366,
-0.21685990691184998,
0.30380377173423767,
0.6063483357429504,
-0.4626505672931671,
-0.3600021302700043,
-0.24993233382701874,
-0.06940333545207977,
0.2701514959335327,
-0.501633882522583,
0.850712239742279,
0.3439151346683502,
-0.6204209923744202,
0.5390869975090027,
0.14461193978786469,
0.7564502954483032,
-0.787768542766571,
-0.3553393483161926,
0.1433991938829422,
0.5591381788253784,
-0.5338640213012695,
-1.1157046556472778,
0.42501381039619446,
0.04347865283489227,
-0.3057198226451874,
-0.5750839114189148,
0.8484479188919067,
-0.47041210532188416,
-0.5763750076293945,
0.05120157077908516,
0.2381111979484558,
0.37451303005218506,
0.13238921761512756,
-0.6323698163032532,
0.1120622307062149,
0.08765518665313721,
0.01917337439954281,
0.33459120988845825,
1.0254921913146973,
-0.5482236742973328,
0.708717405796051,
0.955086886882782,
0.18817903101444244,
-0.10047859698534012,
0.20306910574436188,
0.7338399887084961,
-0.7049797177314758,
-0.44447386264801025,
-0.9524248838424683,
0.13676817715168,
-0.09202753007411957,
-0.23189763724803925,
0.7337175011634827,
0.4296969473361969,
0.7715632319450378,
0.0607566311955452,
1.0230422019958496,
0.08677265793085098,
0.11049094796180725,
-0.6885102391242981,
0.5891706347465515,
0.08179465681314468,
0.45770472288131714,
0.0708283931016922,
-0.777313768863678,
-0.36214232444763184,
0.7623018026351929,
-0.7174047827720642,
0.02690194547176361,
0.3903643786907196,
0.6573300361633301,
-0.08429127186536789,
0.3271421790122986,
0.20980136096477509,
0.32812950015068054,
0.13665105402469635,
0.515466034412384,
0.7094002962112427,
-0.23149952292442322,
0.47003528475761414,
-0.19199496507644653,
-0.1880728155374527,
-0.09158670902252197,
-0.8277551531791687,
-1.054823398590088,
-0.11932142823934555,
-0.07040104269981384,
-0.2763151526451111,
0.3078310489654541,
0.8433136343955994,
0.8759862184524536,
-0.8079840540885925,
-0.46892592310905457,
-0.47633257508277893,
0.4023643434047699,
-0.23521187901496887,
-0.28224602341651917,
0.09208660572767258,
-0.2236820012331009,
-0.17919613420963287,
0.11112920939922333,
0.10287578403949738,
0.42942699790000916,
-0.39665594696998596,
-0.11400836706161499,
0.010238151997327805,
0.07104908674955368,
0.5919644832611084,
0.10476069152355194,
-0.25127971172332764,
-0.25445854663848877,
-0.18267066776752472,
-0.16167627274990082,
-0.07509135454893112,
0.876854419708252,
-0.8495395183563232,
0.13602322340011597,
0.5856314897537231,
0.6869537234306335,
0.6028886437416077,
0.15343458950519562,
0.885505735874176,
-0.6233643889427185,
0.15894076228141785,
0.40367329120635986,
0.08042743057012558,
0.4739033579826355,
-0.32199954986572266,
0.48639166355133057,
0.04534095525741577,
-0.3590128719806671,
-0.8815463185310364,
-0.26986947655677795,
-0.9206401705741882,
-0.19850438833236694,
1.1181551218032837,
0.1069130003452301,
-0.479654997587204,
-0.17522244155406952,
-0.30068376660346985,
0.009543576277792454,
-0.3117203116416931,
0.6513149738311768,
0.6948105692863464,
0.11554834991693497,
-0.17646726965904236,
-0.31890869140625,
0.6784375905990601,
0.29304367303848267,
-0.9569976925849915,
0.07399985194206238,
0.00945750717073679,
0.3764760196208954,
0.04225587472319603,
0.6032989025115967,
-0.014559675939381123,
-0.1968996375799179,
-0.263088196516037,
0.12464306503534317,
0.16459092497825623,
-0.30304989218711853,
-0.34780657291412354,
0.12290550768375397,
0.34282729029655457,
0.23739004135131836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04904v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04904v1
|
XTTS: a Massively Multilingual Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech Model
| 2024-06-07T12:56:11 | 2024-06-07T12:56:11 |
Edresson Casanova, Kelly Davis, Eren Gölge, Görkem Göknar, Iulian Gulea, Logan Hart, Aya Aljafari, Joshua Meyer, Reuben Morais, Samuel Olayemi, Julian Weber
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Most Zero-shot Multi-speaker TTS (ZS-TTS) systems support only a single
language. Although models like YourTTS, VALL-E X, Mega-TTS 2, and Voicebox
explored Multilingual ZS-TTS they are limited to just a few high/medium
resource languages, limiting the applications of these models in most of the
low/medium resource languages. In this paper, we aim to alleviate this issue by
proposing and making publicly available the XTTS system. Our method builds upon
the Tortoise model and adds several novel modifications to enable multilingual
training, improve voice cloning, and enable faster training and inference. XTTS
was trained in 16 languages and achieved state-of-the-art (SOTA) results in
most of them.
|
[
-0.19820426404476166,
-0.2835184633731842,
0.4144061505794525,
0.2617206275463104,
-0.44010910391807556,
0.4938639998435974,
-0.37362590432167053,
-0.4249155521392822,
0.5039398074150085,
0.5604612231254578,
-0.5299270153045654,
-0.41875123977661133,
-0.4680377244949341,
0.38057175278663635,
-0.535588800907135,
1.0191234350204468,
0.544631838798523,
0.1740293800830841,
0.80130535364151,
-0.2908255457878113,
-0.19454075396060944,
-0.7058590054512024,
-0.6306921243667603,
-0.056666452437639236,
0.7122623920440674,
0.5121637582778931,
0.7468748688697815,
0.5508406758308411,
-0.13447244465351105,
0.2718223035335541,
-0.14802135527133942,
-0.2399519830942154,
-0.16569222509860992,
0.11147178709506989,
-0.05975278466939926,
-0.6517510414123535,
-0.22361911833286285,
-0.4343692660331726,
1.0341811180114746,
0.31891852617263794,
-0.16147902607917786,
0.06043326109647751,
-0.3421461284160614,
0.12420660257339478,
-0.5306936502456665,
-0.033883750438690186,
-0.5105723738670349,
0.09673707187175751,
-0.37451738119125366,
0.016192741692066193,
-0.7175137996673584,
-0.21935266256332397,
0.3400541841983795,
-0.5244212746620178,
0.14585068821907043,
-0.3949702978134155,
0.40926405787467957,
-0.44390323758125305,
-0.5044412612915039,
0.038763511925935745,
-0.7834523916244507,
0.8315639495849609,
-0.6150965094566345,
0.9845738410949707,
-0.04997269809246063,
0.49794960021972656,
0.4027000367641449,
-0.499418705701828,
-0.6020351648330688,
-0.5408013463020325,
0.045855604112148285,
-0.06906072795391083,
-0.23011702299118042,
-0.038842398673295975,
-0.03801997750997543,
0.09542227536439896,
-0.7907263040542603,
0.10750643163919449,
-0.23012958467006683,
0.048251520842313766,
0.3370075821876526,
-0.03708925470709801,
0.36388930678367615,
-0.49439507722854614,
-0.4415937662124634,
-0.1941986232995987,
-0.5289053916931152,
-0.2098345160484314,
0.09565406292676926,
1.0328425168991089,
-0.4423697888851166,
0.4233945906162262,
-0.03594338148832321,
0.4964390695095062,
-0.5346279740333557,
-0.04880010709166527,
0.23731592297554016,
-0.3061944544315338,
-0.41390228271484375,
0.07240398973226547,
1.0318422317504883,
-0.2037907987833023,
0.1693139374256134,
-0.33718934655189514,
-0.00992694590240717,
-0.056116122752428055,
-0.15226463973522186,
-0.603755533695221,
0.43506112694740295,
0.13082821667194366,
0.0676448866724968,
-0.2666081190109253,
-0.3745613396167755,
-0.8832422494888306,
-0.21264350414276123,
-0.014388332143425941,
0.4854651093482971,
-0.6540238261222839,
-0.857678234577179,
0.3163905739784241,
-0.30639946460723877,
-0.37734827399253845,
0.2556363642215729,
-0.7861623764038086,
0.22869855165481567,
0.1797408014535904,
1.325086236000061,
0.13337329030036926,
-0.4672563076019287,
-0.4124418795108795,
0.43203866481781006,
-0.3783309757709503,
0.6911920309066772,
-0.4856571853160858,
-0.7199013233184814,
0.0018246237887069583,
-0.07685334235429764,
0.12088651210069656,
-0.0982508659362793,
0.11865289509296417,
-0.32494860887527466,
0.20182378590106964,
-0.4180653691291809,
-0.14397093653678894,
0.08760878443717957,
0.11102426797151566,
-0.5387100577354431,
0.8061789274215698,
0.20137432217597961,
-0.24683883786201477,
0.05434608832001686,
-0.9122533798217773,
-0.37019866704940796,
0.31339412927627563,
-0.3228396773338318,
-0.29765427112579346,
0.0973491445183754,
-0.09656978398561478,
0.3572009205818176,
-0.5015585422515869,
0.428226500749588,
-0.13435834646224976,
-0.2192375510931015,
0.009384505450725555,
-0.45878928899765015,
1.107216477394104,
0.35791876912117004,
-0.43942195177078247,
0.21280527114868164,
-0.7006043791770935,
0.447660893201828,
0.2352774441242218,
-0.05043600872159004,
-0.21386092901229858,
-0.2530805766582489,
0.4437534809112549,
0.321416974067688,
-0.29436782002449036,
-0.8477287888526917,
0.3462325632572174,
-0.09950347244739532,
1.0422946214675903,
0.5124696493148804,
-0.4806134104728699,
0.06543311476707458,
-0.12622347474098206,
0.6626834869384766,
-0.08488360047340393,
0.08775489777326584,
-0.471228688955307,
-0.46242013573646545,
-0.4548557698726654,
-0.693065881729126,
0.314693421125412,
0.4123323857784271,
-0.9915965795516968,
-0.0133024537935853,
-0.6585171222686768,
-0.6434024572372437,
-0.28855112195014954,
-0.35641011595726013,
0.7795387506484985,
0.008031883276998997,
0.24202536046504974,
0.06390666216611862,
-0.5758859515190125,
-0.9589855074882507,
0.021264398470520973,
-0.24696564674377441,
-0.03846484422683716,
-0.0909498929977417,
0.29791712760925293,
0.16842927038669586,
0.8510397672653198,
-0.199314683675766,
-0.2858399450778961,
-0.5120111703872681,
0.05787676200270653,
-0.31865817308425903,
0.3984811007976532,
0.9259294271469116,
-0.5280276536941528,
-0.721078634262085,
0.3665303587913513,
-0.5303528904914856,
0.2128346711397171,
0.09666674584150314,
0.2520108222961426,
0.2039421647787094,
0.20676763355731964,
-0.5693005919456482,
0.2675003707408905,
0.8188893795013428,
-0.18592894077301025,
0.5373817682266235,
-0.08436720073223114,
0.19167223572731018,
-1.2692692279815674,
0.028139950707554817,
0.19279614090919495,
-0.585503339767456,
-0.7256410121917725,
0.13911844789981842,
0.15441207587718964,
-0.6292704343795776,
-0.750679612159729,
0.7042443752288818,
-0.42296457290649414,
-0.27877646684646606,
-0.07804656773805618,
0.2987285256385803,
-0.13799048960208893,
0.553884744644165,
0.4068492650985718,
1.135301113128662,
0.6536175012588501,
-0.334663063287735,
0.365704745054245,
0.46634814143180847,
-0.11977806687355042,
0.6045435667037964,
-0.5592640042304993,
0.07909641414880753,
0.1263740509748459,
0.2970215380191803,
-0.8475499153137207,
0.028130678460001945,
0.05410933867096901,
-0.6081652045249939,
0.09931672364473343,
-0.2585906386375427,
-0.6126646399497986,
-0.3364725112915039,
-0.2842312157154083,
0.36197108030319214,
0.3125251531600952,
-0.5875151753425598,
0.49835360050201416,
0.3202005624771118,
-0.33855506777763367,
-0.4259051978588104,
-0.7225938439369202,
0.6523747444152832,
0.07719676196575165,
-0.538726806640625,
0.13072890043258667,
0.021570710465312004,
0.27939292788505554,
-0.10370557755231857,
0.08392684161663055,
-0.47511324286460876,
-0.389344722032547,
-0.2114376574754715,
-0.03639192134141922,
-0.45651331543922424,
0.32661113142967224,
-0.004259691573679447,
-0.22290194034576416,
-0.5004869699478149,
-0.4725967347621918,
0.6363869905471802,
-0.1362210214138031,
-0.42383354902267456,
-0.8176324367523193,
0.920132577419281,
1.0349441766738892,
-0.40129274129867554,
0.37048324942588806,
0.16713939607143402,
-0.2361598163843155,
-0.09288404136896133,
-0.5428569316864014,
-0.03805936127901077,
-0.463873028755188,
0.8169063925743103,
-0.38656771183013916,
-0.9128788709640503,
0.33693942427635193,
0.24102698266506195,
-0.03125881403684616,
-0.029496461153030396,
0.42348235845565796,
0.4433232247829437,
1.292006015777588,
0.8985538482666016,
-0.1826455295085907,
0.7670456767082214,
-0.2775209844112396,
0.026492062956094742,
-0.49230292439460754,
-0.20116981863975525,
-0.8929240107536316,
0.09125277400016785,
-0.6628636121749878,
-0.05528460070490837,
0.4639992117881775,
-0.48392200469970703,
-0.5019688606262207,
0.8066505789756775,
-0.533780038356781,
0.2975864112377167,
0.8579052686691284,
0.1961234211921692,
0.46596983075141907,
0.30760183930397034,
-0.07582078129053116,
-0.12353573739528656,
-0.7770582437515259,
-0.6115126013755798,
1.0247079133987427,
0.08912601321935654,
0.4064676761627197,
0.34121060371398926,
0.4620373249053955,
0.17467419803142548,
0.24393489956855774,
-0.5999521017074585,
0.5728778839111328,
-0.5128706693649292,
-0.9720755815505981,
-0.71599942445755,
-0.3739088773727417,
-0.6788145899772644,
0.3409126102924347,
0.010157869197428226,
-1.1329259872436523,
-0.01087232492864132,
-0.07139137387275696,
-0.632195770740509,
0.7642931342124939,
-1.04832124710083,
0.5488017201423645,
-0.24842408299446106,
-0.2883971333503723,
-0.18750305473804474,
-0.7879542112350464,
0.2968372404575348,
-0.21368713676929474,
0.11511822044849396,
-0.0683232918381691,
0.11907854676246643,
0.7707325220108032,
-0.5606989860534668,
0.9435760974884033,
-0.09453806281089783,
-0.10686647146940231,
0.146323561668396,
0.060810353606939316,
0.23962806165218353,
0.23673230409622192,
-0.320238322019577,
0.35142630338668823,
0.3347132205963135,
-0.3841172456741333,
-0.6011431217193604,
0.6184046864509583,
-0.8885927200317383,
-0.519675612449646,
-0.4583880603313446,
-0.4573895037174225,
-0.41936877369880676,
0.49756887555122375,
0.30928289890289307,
0.5428266525268555,
0.026825448498129845,
0.30244895815849304,
0.4619045555591583,
-0.18402846157550812,
0.45350539684295654,
0.8977535367012024,
-0.40384742617607117,
-0.6893298029899597,
0.9438182711601257,
0.4389573335647583,
0.48757871985435486,
0.44110095500946045,
0.3024643063545227,
-0.4014914631843567,
-0.3374975025653839,
-0.8229458332061768,
0.4160856306552887,
-0.3046374022960663,
-0.2713315188884735,
-0.639704167842865,
-0.2763621211051941,
-0.5219152569770813,
-0.2294456958770752,
-0.6787238121032715,
-0.47197458148002625,
-0.061678364872932434,
-0.07873700559139252,
0.5263935923576355,
0.9090985059738159,
-0.23390667140483856,
0.9266031980514526,
-1.120513677597046,
0.4880621135234833,
0.33798620104789734,
0.7350134253501892,
0.031241610646247864,
-0.47337377071380615,
-0.33138275146484375,
0.3006865382194519,
-0.21820580959320068,
-0.9861094355583191,
0.4012649953365326,
0.06936901062726974,
0.34812769293785095,
0.17727693915367126,
-0.055984120815992355,
0.706210196018219,
-0.5643158555030823,
0.8826000094413757,
0.7229940891265869,
-1.46925687789917,
0.47895175218582153,
-0.4953969419002533,
0.07398197054862976,
0.10934329777956009,
0.1898561716079712,
-1.1476671695709229,
-0.4868420362472534,
-0.4626210927963257,
-0.39835748076438904,
1.1803158521652222,
0.47494587302207947,
0.4227387011051178,
-0.15818031132221222,
0.1767313927412033,
0.24287264049053192,
0.32095766067504883,
-0.9410174489021301,
-0.24488615989685059,
-0.3517930209636688,
-0.09471326321363449,
-0.1775008589029312,
-0.20467065274715424,
0.09837839752435684,
-0.09261534363031387,
0.8202819228172302,
-0.0008582448936067522,
0.3184494376182556,
0.0452650710940361,
0.07690514624118805,
-0.25910913944244385,
0.5327321290969849,
0.8541511297225952,
0.24641771614551544,
-0.13209368288516998,
0.006843411363661289,
0.05225936323404312,
-0.5485796332359314,
0.7337456941604614,
-0.17656607925891876,
-0.14395418763160706,
0.4497836232185364,
0.11097396910190582,
0.9399906992912292,
0.35100701451301575,
-0.6024909019470215,
0.5165492296218872,
0.030888468027114868,
-0.12478303909301758,
-0.01163553912192583,
-0.21451102197170258,
-0.02892521768808365,
0.40300050377845764,
0.41159945726394653,
-0.14032766222953796,
-0.3908168077468872,
-0.46161526441574097,
0.2253362089395523,
0.46431034803390503,
-0.49290743470191956,
-0.7347915768623352,
0.6609160900115967,
0.4476802349090576,
-0.6686057448387146,
0.32553228735923767,
-0.06695028394460678,
-0.43245261907577515,
0.4163724482059479,
0.7237393856048584,
0.8755903840065002,
-0.7148773670196533,
0.5710264444351196,
0.23796787858009338,
0.32642224431037903,
-0.32363685965538025,
0.47527509927749634,
0.022342300042510033,
-0.35427024960517883,
-0.42252683639526367,
-0.012237923219799995,
-0.6023745536804199,
0.35586827993392944,
-0.6622030735015869,
0.7324984669685364,
-0.28618261218070984,
-0.4497641623020172,
0.15410777926445007,
-0.2667752802371979,
-0.3213018476963043,
0.3594726324081421,
0.19197537004947662,
1.0704022645950317,
-0.9603833556175232,
1.1109514236450195,
0.4218650758266449,
-0.6167221069335938,
-0.7473834753036499,
-0.37732362747192383,
-0.07505977898836136,
-1.0450879335403442,
0.7724317312240601,
-0.1195802316069603,
-0.35490882396698,
0.42863842844963074,
-0.4304823875427246,
-1.0686228275299072,
0.7460516691207886,
1.011359453201294,
-0.6789500117301941,
-0.31981879472732544,
0.4025247395038605,
0.3478212356567383,
-0.05961742624640465,
0.41572192311286926,
0.14453493058681488,
0.31484153866767883,
-0.010150381363928318,
-1.2457218170166016,
-0.23892012238502502,
-0.055799853056669235,
0.21934497356414795,
0.263618528842926,
-0.9893830418586731,
0.8382696509361267,
-0.2545930743217468,
-0.2605796456336975,
0.38729846477508545,
0.22390273213386536,
0.1737113744020462,
-0.1952192187309265,
0.38659635186195374,
0.3532339930534363,
0.43823209404945374,
-0.029696298763155937,
0.8377403020858765,
-0.16714881360530853,
0.4993177652359009,
1.1358779668807983,
-0.6014378070831299,
0.8778683543205261,
0.20643733441829681,
-0.30194059014320374,
0.258882075548172,
0.20931287109851837,
0.22678492963314056,
0.5887743234634399,
-0.037976350635290146,
-0.5559861063957214,
-0.31523799896240234,
-0.2783612012863159,
-0.6421322822570801,
0.5332888960838318,
0.3029678165912628,
-0.10289741307497025,
-0.6159862875938416,
0.6321085691452026,
-0.0536382794380188,
-0.2778911590576172,
0.1208411231637001,
0.3743363618850708,
-0.2771705090999603,
-0.09389373660087585,
0.5193431377410889,
-0.03547158092260361,
0.6536425352096558,
-1.1140551567077637,
0.13469406962394714,
-0.003629947081208229,
-0.1638336330652237,
0.09529360383749008,
-0.8842055201530457,
0.07020440697669983,
0.2855474054813385,
-0.07794666290283203,
-0.22607946395874023,
0.08333324640989304,
-0.2780265510082245,
-0.4926045835018158,
0.6544091701507568,
0.7987608313560486,
-0.02388726733624935,
-0.17210519313812256,
-0.46469661593437195,
0.18151722848415375,
0.026677921414375305,
-0.1480695903301239,
0.1679006963968277,
0.694730818271637,
-0.3048253357410431,
0.9187352657318115,
0.45734184980392456,
0.2312869131565094,
0.20201857388019562,
0.1731056123971939,
0.7624049782752991,
-0.9129111766815186,
-0.9067659974098206,
-0.6378911137580872,
0.41639697551727295,
0.10678493231534958,
-0.3001875579357147,
0.5911184549331665,
0.6821161508560181,
0.8293173909187317,
-0.022630836814641953,
1.4046480655670166,
0.0902056023478508,
0.7307694554328918,
-0.1537562906742096,
0.7205390334129333,
-0.6487348079681396,
-0.034362345933914185,
-0.3869417607784271,
-0.41309869289398193,
-0.4563380479812622,
0.28923821449279785,
0.024861488491296768,
0.03281863033771515,
0.7871614098548889,
0.6129391193389893,
-0.006608549505472183,
0.2716473340988159,
0.9013261198997498,
0.12883281707763672,
0.3881634771823883,
0.38145992159843445,
0.8237996101379395,
-0.41736820340156555,
0.923176646232605,
-0.3126974403858185,
-0.2740308940410614,
-0.21730095148086548,
-0.792936384677887,
-0.5575150847434998,
-0.7970260381698608,
-0.28791409730911255,
-0.06956612318754196,
0.3485693633556366,
1.0319842100143433,
1.1852152347564697,
-0.7158281207084656,
-0.5733810067176819,
0.1780761033296585,
-0.010072042234241962,
-0.06264766305685043,
-0.09694176912307739,
0.19115929305553436,
-0.129482701420784,
-0.8165966272354126,
0.3797394931316376,
0.5397018790245056,
0.4090220034122467,
-0.34563857316970825,
0.13905049860477448,
-0.1303306668996811,
-0.010602433234453201,
0.8089081645011902,
0.5338318943977356,
-0.7807987928390503,
-0.4093787968158722,
0.33166274428367615,
-0.13499227166175842,
0.49153468012809753,
1.0694324970245361,
-0.7045002579689026,
0.5565648078918457,
0.063432477414608,
0.33324503898620605,
0.3421494960784912,
-0.6640797853469849,
0.47565317153930664,
-0.9130800366401672,
0.5214025974273682,
0.14840200543403625,
0.33058106899261475,
0.25065743923187256,
-0.09587041288614273,
0.12873436510562897,
0.26590272784233093,
0.022128228098154068,
-1.0122013092041016,
0.30394670367240906,
-1.0124359130859375,
-0.30024510622024536,
1.018418788909912,
-0.0513574592769146,
0.027576874941587448,
-0.19548696279525757,
-0.34396082162857056,
0.47282716631889343,
-0.6212924122810364,
0.5316179394721985,
0.4441763758659363,
0.23777715861797333,
-0.23223939538002014,
-0.6617224812507629,
-0.04177621379494667,
0.2700520157814026,
-0.7134286165237427,
0.34257009625434875,
0.15428116917610168,
0.4942203164100647,
0.45368438959121704,
0.8574607372283936,
-0.20569173991680145,
0.22048883140087128,
-0.0726461187005043,
0.33089643716812134,
-0.13322310149669647,
-0.4147851765155792,
-0.3623708486557007,
0.18760502338409424,
-0.09755823016166687,
-0.3937219977378845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04892v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04892v1
|
Sexism Detection on a Data Diet
| 2024-06-07T12:39:54 | 2024-06-07T12:39:54 |
Rabiraj Bandyopadhyay, Dennis Assenmacher, Jose M. Alonso Moral, Claudia Wagner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
There is an increase in the proliferation of online hate commensurate with
the rise in the usage of social media. In response, there is also a significant
advancement in the creation of automated tools aimed at identifying harmful
text content using approaches grounded in Natural Language Processing and Deep
Learning. Although it is known that training Deep Learning models require a
substantial amount of annotated data, recent line of work suggests that models
trained on specific subsets of the data still retain performance comparable to
the model that was trained on the full dataset. In this work, we show how we
can leverage influence scores to estimate the importance of a data point while
training a model and designing a pruning strategy applied to the case of sexism
detection. We evaluate the model performance trained on data pruned with
different pruning strategies on three out-of-domain datasets and find, that in
accordance with other work a large fraction of instances can be removed without
significant performance drop. However, we also discover that the strategies for
pruning data, previously successful in Natural Language Inference tasks, do not
readily apply to the detection of harmful content and instead amplify the
already prevalent class imbalance even more, leading in the worst-case to a
complete absence of the hateful class.
|
[
-0.4579765200614929,
-0.9861787557601929,
0.3591775894165039,
-0.030397839844226837,
-0.2634374499320984,
-0.19909518957138062,
-0.20680634677410126,
-0.423920601606369,
0.12914133071899414,
0.4769395887851715,
-0.5129197239875793,
-0.4612351059913635,
-0.8419432044029236,
0.07616996020078659,
-0.657091498374939,
1.0442630052566528,
0.39766404032707214,
0.11573195457458496,
-0.2756202816963196,
-0.04685189947485924,
-0.44527775049209595,
-0.6928494572639465,
-0.44560062885284424,
-0.25691521167755127,
0.46214330196380615,
0.36014384031295776,
0.6715401411056519,
0.7296895980834961,
0.6115351915359497,
0.16442346572875977,
-0.31203824281692505,
0.24035204946994781,
-0.7925015091896057,
0.218923881649971,
-0.10562220960855484,
-0.6398175954818726,
-0.11511551588773727,
0.20625919103622437,
0.4784706234931946,
0.6485416889190674,
0.14098244905471802,
0.20821769535541534,
0.0014326001983135939,
0.6680842041969299,
-0.666678786277771,
-0.1019015982747078,
-0.7691118717193604,
0.10251198709011078,
-0.38182881474494934,
-0.19127383828163147,
-0.4449881911277771,
-0.4106060564517975,
0.10264599323272705,
-0.43547993898391724,
0.4330104887485504,
-0.07830726355314255,
0.6579068899154663,
0.305205762386322,
-0.7098586559295654,
-0.22167474031448364,
-0.9464297294616699,
1.0757930278778076,
-0.5944371223449707,
0.2753030061721802,
0.8229328393936157,
-0.16977131366729736,
-0.06152733787894249,
-0.13880063593387604,
-0.3697590231895447,
-0.08951935172080994,
-0.08177179843187332,
-0.180013969540596,
-0.18262456357479095,
-0.08947993069887161,
0.4619961678981781,
0.18895216286182404,
-0.26347026228904724,
0.19024398922920227,
-0.6040672659873962,
0.09181363880634308,
0.9459347128868103,
-0.0320611447095871,
0.25896987318992615,
-0.3573216497898102,
-0.1997992992401123,
-0.11593005806207657,
-0.7544857859611511,
-0.22885072231292725,
0.8182573318481445,
0.34232422709465027,
0.3267165422439575,
0.4641295373439789,
0.3557506501674652,
0.3379020392894745,
-0.024776458740234375,
0.0851147249341011,
0.20081068575382233,
-0.10212042927742004,
-0.2194359004497528,
-0.011985649354755878,
0.6695313453674316,
0.6065595149993896,
0.5910888314247131,
0.019556717947125435,
-0.028845641762018204,
0.5061416029930115,
0.7861009836196899,
-0.8804974555969238,
-0.4721842408180237,
0.004221342969685793,
-0.537251889705658,
-0.5528937578201294,
-0.1201310008764267,
-0.8563717007637024,
-0.7786640524864197,
-0.44621825218200684,
0.1192978098988533,
-0.5895155072212219,
-0.6011601686477661,
-0.24957284331321716,
-0.3983067274093628,
0.09436970949172974,
0.26463234424591064,
-0.6835407614707947,
0.34865185618400574,
0.7239745855331421,
0.6766337156295776,
-0.226382777094841,
0.30662816762924194,
-0.3904803991317749,
-0.1600639373064041,
-0.5014913082122803,
0.31358546018600464,
-1.0027451515197754,
-0.29483136534690857,
-0.0018573150737211108,
0.20822958648204803,
-0.032950788736343384,
-0.672333300113678,
0.811745822429657,
-0.4272424578666687,
0.10181164741516113,
-0.5112009048461914,
-0.8756284117698669,
-0.3988891541957855,
0.19285544753074646,
-0.7125816941261292,
0.9831612706184387,
-0.16487464308738708,
-0.9069532752037048,
0.6238241791725159,
-0.5739028453826904,
-0.8064024448394775,
-0.07611559331417084,
-0.005192092154175043,
-0.9938079118728638,
0.1940678209066391,
0.12889514863491058,
0.4207399785518646,
-0.03825778514146805,
0.308498740196228,
-0.6821987628936768,
-0.5874117016792297,
0.05165758728981018,
-0.3731600344181061,
0.9265488386154175,
0.11471743136644363,
-0.5588074922561646,
0.06641476601362228,
-0.6097618937492371,
-0.37501639127731323,
0.34464776515960693,
-0.03076670877635479,
-0.9253822565078735,
0.3136906623840332,
0.0624178983271122,
-0.051109861582517624,
-0.5398045182228088,
-0.542121410369873,
-0.05623843893408775,
-0.3533729314804077,
0.3230939209461212,
0.9332173466682434,
0.17804129421710968,
0.4843257963657379,
-0.3355143368244171,
0.43724843859672546,
0.10123586654663086,
0.19201858341693878,
0.3128591775894165,
-0.49918678402900696,
-0.7785893678665161,
0.019732803106307983,
0.06923097372055054,
0.33525070548057556,
-0.5757619142532349,
0.4018530547618866,
-0.06627083569765091,
-0.4563550651073456,
-0.41513484716415405,
0.3143068552017212,
0.33864670991897583,
0.17418736219406128,
0.5043191313743591,
-0.32947105169296265,
-0.6438495516777039,
-0.9604076147079468,
-0.6142901182174683,
0.03494672104716301,
0.0882876068353653,
0.13467665016651154,
0.7279525995254517,
0.19211094081401825,
0.8146012425422668,
-0.35078951716423035,
-0.4841002821922302,
-0.12414577603340149,
0.08282236754894257,
-0.035508204251527786,
0.6172708868980408,
0.7332723140716553,
-1.3532936573028564,
-0.3246033489704132,
-0.39733994007110596,
-0.6985334157943726,
0.0885973870754242,
0.16075778007507324,
-0.0475873202085495,
-0.23728151619434357,
0.3294467031955719,
-0.15657292306423187,
0.6372438073158264,
0.2565954327583313,
-0.24798014760017395,
0.373040109872818,
0.29923704266548157,
0.19042383134365082,
-0.7112111449241638,
-0.12480666488409042,
0.6668547987937927,
-0.1047033965587616,
-1.030876874923706,
-0.21237896382808685,
-0.02834370732307434,
0.05747387930750847,
-0.40639111399650574,
0.054959870874881744,
-0.2348083108663559,
0.16509833931922913,
-0.21197135746479034,
-0.1373276710510254,
0.034874025732278824,
0.42837992310523987,
0.08483826369047165,
0.42238083481788635,
0.17680439352989197,
-0.7784981727600098,
0.036685097962617874,
0.1542983055114746,
-0.22017164528369904,
0.5032452940940857,
-0.3020932376384735,
0.27097105979919434,
-0.5138562917709351,
0.0916537269949913,
-0.7984811067581177,
-0.1877637803554535,
0.43803340196609497,
-0.32707375288009644,
0.1042817160487175,
-0.5671489834785461,
-0.4076420068740845,
-0.3610018491744995,
-0.45868709683418274,
0.3115212917327881,
0.2957250773906708,
-0.5243847966194153,
0.35601702332496643,
0.6515509486198425,
0.2145293653011322,
-0.41838380694389343,
-0.5898928046226501,
-0.17268942296504974,
-0.6069422364234924,
-0.30587413907051086,
0.2746369540691376,
0.07989044487476349,
-0.48709213733673096,
-0.15159721672534943,
0.0019171019084751606,
-0.24301810562610626,
0.36620113253593445,
0.4893219769001007,
0.0735899806022644,
0.1468060314655304,
0.5732714533805847,
0.017041759565472603,
0.2272874265909195,
0.5016736388206482,
-0.029792331159114838,
0.4584277272224426,
0.11522418260574341,
-0.43643710017204285,
-0.37535905838012695,
0.36516842246055603,
0.507651150226593,
-0.09598955512046814,
0.9193816781044006,
0.6997321248054504,
-0.48857545852661133,
-0.352518230676651,
-0.3473420739173889,
-0.41966110467910767,
-0.4330604374408722,
0.3556090295314789,
0.04487837105989456,
-0.5126867294311523,
0.09562935680150986,
0.02699054591357708,
0.23643004894256592,
0.413540780544281,
0.27059319615364075,
-0.12868031859397888,
1.2499985694885254,
0.6127959489822388,
-0.10001234710216522,
0.8154181241989136,
-0.27023276686668396,
0.1775600016117096,
-0.47732532024383545,
-0.08797010034322739,
-0.42614227533340454,
-0.3083752691745758,
-0.5362006425857544,
-0.205305278301239,
0.2286868691444397,
-0.20955243706703186,
-0.17740480601787567,
0.29405343532562256,
-0.8192606568336487,
0.45843157172203064,
0.5246385335922241,
0.5675181150436401,
0.24430438876152039,
0.2422136813402176,
0.5218409299850464,
-0.49161800742149353,
-0.562557578086853,
-0.35810407996177673,
1.222399353981018,
0.5105778574943542,
0.4755837619304657,
0.10269737243652344,
0.21554815769195557,
0.7052831053733826,
0.5836970806121826,
-0.7483713030815125,
0.4816971719264984,
-0.41724342107772827,
-0.8808726072311401,
-0.03393399715423584,
-0.6339094042778015,
-0.7807205319404602,
0.3146601915359497,
-0.3321182131767273,
-0.3609018623828888,
0.28248170018196106,
0.18606632947921753,
0.06726686656475067,
0.6204818487167358,
-0.8210370540618896,
0.6631247997283936,
-0.2637411653995514,
-0.5867317318916321,
-0.36391332745552063,
-0.32289671897888184,
0.5023708939552307,
-0.008624489419162273,
0.3879513740539551,
-0.3151859641075134,
0.39110609889030457,
1.1367801427841187,
-0.363238662481308,
1.3595234155654907,
-0.47873014211654663,
-0.12699036300182343,
0.04988602176308632,
0.043313514441251755,
0.47084054350852966,
-0.2634888291358948,
-0.2783221900463104,
0.1476682722568512,
-0.2096954584121704,
-0.3542509078979492,
-0.28019821643829346,
0.35951608419418335,
-0.6387264728546143,
-0.4492412507534027,
-0.09733634442090988,
-0.4096725881099701,
-0.08109896630048752,
0.06673438102006912,
0.09457121789455414,
0.3327007293701172,
-0.1736721694469452,
0.3327612578868866,
0.7831764817237854,
-0.1653594821691513,
0.1951361447572708,
0.09734399616718292,
-0.04117925092577934,
-0.18974460661411285,
1.0601705312728882,
0.24425703287124634,
0.2639461159706116,
0.05903821438550949,
0.22670984268188477,
-0.12205279618501663,
-0.5495486855506897,
-0.24948091804981232,
-0.006492552347481251,
-0.7641903758049011,
-0.048057228326797485,
-0.6904364228248596,
-0.06516463309526443,
-0.3974546492099762,
-0.08495090156793594,
-0.34083518385887146,
0.12591791152954102,
-0.27415505051612854,
-0.15689635276794434,
0.5562913417816162,
0.7617985010147095,
0.18420763313770294,
0.5691018104553223,
-0.4109012186527252,
0.21969951689243317,
0.14180877804756165,
0.1374487429857254,
0.009099486283957958,
-0.4719732701778412,
-0.07110050320625305,
0.18289674818515778,
-0.30325356125831604,
-1.0060592889785767,
0.6568976044654846,
0.09357596188783646,
0.256388396024704,
0.5951794385910034,
0.3862316608428955,
0.5812985301017761,
0.12396595627069473,
0.44862282276153564,
0.13294140994548798,
-0.7506301403045654,
0.6549060344696045,
-0.3024773895740509,
-0.029363565146923065,
0.5541763305664062,
0.8998672366142273,
-0.4909655451774597,
-0.5040629506111145,
-0.7467647790908813,
-0.7185983061790466,
0.5884699821472168,
0.43058186769485474,
0.14042839407920837,
-0.08643518388271332,
0.25307875871658325,
0.15319475531578064,
0.4164351522922516,
-0.8967695832252502,
-0.39210954308509827,
-0.1002013236284256,
-0.18478845059871674,
0.29274025559425354,
-0.21592308580875397,
-0.21731078624725342,
-0.5866365432739258,
0.8235549926757812,
-0.03381634131073952,
0.012251743115484715,
-0.04962579905986786,
-0.3375413715839386,
-0.17355792224407196,
0.048208367079496384,
0.10641694068908691,
0.6900662779808044,
-0.30400004982948303,
0.11113675683736801,
0.10495835542678833,
-0.7899019718170166,
0.13374629616737366,
-0.121963270008564,
-0.4795045256614685,
0.03495244309306145,
0.36556288599967957,
0.6542377471923828,
0.16440798342227936,
-0.44632476568222046,
0.7622687220573425,
-0.07853548228740692,
-0.3650321066379547,
-0.40091466903686523,
0.09957287460565567,
-0.2474088966846466,
-0.0009798556566238403,
0.4870755076408386,
0.16109620034694672,
0.02726520411670208,
-0.41938266158103943,
0.3734290599822998,
0.44415220618247986,
-0.7232809066772461,
-0.25079676508903503,
0.5724737048149109,
0.2386818528175354,
-0.1362895965576172,
0.5154696106910706,
-0.23771464824676514,
-0.8356946110725403,
0.8291776776313782,
0.3022055923938751,
0.5440282225608826,
-0.15740469098091125,
0.28472933173179626,
0.4363843500614166,
0.5348594784736633,
0.06456246972084045,
-0.16486936807632446,
0.09141158312559128,
-0.89942866563797,
-0.4664857089519501,
-0.5623525977134705,
-0.21859177947044373,
0.411865770816803,
-0.6939992308616638,
0.25328490138053894,
-0.6539735198020935,
-0.13678692281246185,
0.36559581756591797,
0.1244131401181221,
-0.540258526802063,
0.28002333641052246,
0.2038310170173645,
0.45835188031196594,
-1.3288325071334839,
0.6310505867004395,
0.5317704677581787,
-0.363785982131958,
-0.5164498090744019,
0.11736062914133072,
0.3293370306491852,
-0.6438852548599243,
0.6668984293937683,
0.5131495594978333,
0.1500687450170517,
-0.14091332256793976,
-0.6779708862304688,
-0.6025886535644531,
0.32889989018440247,
0.3117859363555908,
-0.6507751941680908,
0.17250174283981323,
0.0007951719453558326,
0.4194529950618744,
-0.2039785385131836,
0.21397259831428528,
0.6148951649665833,
0.5128719210624695,
0.0191964041441679,
-0.38532403111457825,
0.1723901629447937,
-0.3065697252750397,
-0.26193657517433167,
0.5374402403831482,
-0.29425492882728577,
0.7264605760574341,
0.06701968610286713,
-0.3638172745704651,
-0.5834065079689026,
0.4046136438846588,
-0.1386624574661255,
0.33705076575279236,
0.9901456832885742,
0.35826265811920166,
0.799859881401062,
-0.035718124359846115,
0.8444754481315613,
0.21188342571258545,
0.33815157413482666,
0.8339575529098511,
-0.06317351758480072,
0.46671295166015625,
0.2810707092285156,
-0.22776812314987183,
0.16235095262527466,
0.6994385123252869,
-0.3899815082550049,
0.3798871636390686,
0.22287464141845703,
-0.16033585369586945,
-0.5519255995750427,
-0.4053548574447632,
-0.21856804192066193,
0.4429931640625,
0.5618686079978943,
-0.7074788808822632,
-0.18634769320487976,
0.27008572220802307,
0.4515424072742462,
0.2460610568523407,
-0.2624613344669342,
0.6371433734893799,
-0.011586437933146954,
-0.46543413400650024,
0.36322221159935,
-0.14681607484817505,
0.7449904084205627,
-0.3647003769874573,
-0.12957558035850525,
0.043300334364175797,
0.38416698575019836,
-0.37595808506011963,
-0.5610441565513611,
0.48326894640922546,
-0.09698670357465744,
-0.2975892424583435,
-0.3627994656562805,
1.0954548120498657,
-0.4306475520133972,
-0.5366551876068115,
0.5926845073699951,
0.37397822737693787,
0.15845537185668945,
-0.38825592398643494,
-0.6445670127868652,
0.016320334747433662,
0.2712455689907074,
-0.15368786454200745,
0.49882811307907104,
0.10241140425205231,
-0.1420682668685913,
0.5958662629127502,
1.102662205696106,
0.05924440547823906,
-0.15051348507404327,
0.20837394893169403,
0.9899337887763977,
-0.5642325282096863,
-0.32500749826431274,
-1.0244472026824951,
0.010196567513048649,
-0.5883084535598755,
-0.23968343436717987,
0.9629810452461243,
0.39067885279655457,
0.8639504909515381,
0.29149067401885986,
0.772741973400116,
-0.04696967825293541,
0.5475122332572937,
-0.12255027890205383,
0.6258998513221741,
-0.5430581569671631,
0.3554413318634033,
-0.455278605222702,
-0.6555891036987305,
-0.32970261573791504,
0.5549905300140381,
-0.789046585559845,
0.062190379947423935,
0.29820117354393005,
0.7391912937164307,
-0.07256966829299927,
0.5066660046577454,
0.1349986344575882,
0.23977446556091309,
0.5490531325340271,
0.11767658591270447,
0.5940715074539185,
-0.3731755316257477,
0.5982694029808044,
-0.4850073456764221,
-0.26533547043800354,
-0.30608129501342773,
-0.682315468788147,
-1.0616929531097412,
-0.42960307002067566,
-0.4432714879512787,
-0.4357825517654419,
0.18788763880729675,
0.6411388516426086,
0.8339768648147583,
-0.6931427717208862,
0.15228864550590515,
-0.17143945395946503,
0.43803441524505615,
-0.44791680574417114,
-0.32325342297554016,
0.26366347074508667,
-0.12050306051969528,
-0.6937200427055359,
0.2900623083114624,
-0.03591638803482056,
-0.2813381254673004,
-0.22223646938800812,
0.2500718832015991,
-0.5240529775619507,
-0.19093391299247742,
0.6581370830535889,
-0.0030868910253047943,
-0.26318761706352234,
-0.2886095941066742,
-0.14097154140472412,
0.16919481754302979,
0.02128082513809204,
0.8517338037490845,
-0.6379504203796387,
0.2536294162273407,
0.18335378170013428,
0.6109135746955872,
0.5278851389884949,
0.23165765404701233,
0.6767670512199402,
-0.9814632534980774,
-0.010456585325300694,
0.39655858278274536,
0.1821434199810028,
0.41247087717056274,
-0.5684055089950562,
0.550434410572052,
0.6238821148872375,
-0.39281055331230164,
-0.9570301175117493,
0.13738782703876495,
-0.37179192900657654,
-0.540627121925354,
1.138394832611084,
0.13847856223583221,
-0.4353930950164795,
-0.4797571301460266,
-0.05814310163259506,
0.19183991849422455,
-0.5158398747444153,
0.7589963674545288,
0.4932214915752411,
0.16216006875038147,
-0.03272152692079544,
-0.8020281791687012,
0.7018449902534485,
0.6969342827796936,
-0.7534634470939636,
0.35276976227760315,
0.4570577144622803,
0.32282009720802307,
0.24414554238319397,
0.2744920551776886,
0.19148710370063782,
0.017071982845664024,
-0.10580702126026154,
-0.10596134513616562,
0.1603812724351883,
-0.3084626793861389,
-0.012583496980369091,
0.5244203805923462,
-0.5069630742073059,
-0.3112926185131073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04886v1
|
Seeing the Unseen: Visual Metaphor Captioning for Videos
| 2024-06-07T12:32:44 | 2024-06-07T12:32:44 |
Abisek Rajakumar Kalarani, Pushpak Bhattacharyya, Sumit Shekhar
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Metaphors are a common communication tool used in our day-to-day life. The
detection and generation of metaphors in textual form have been studied
extensively but metaphors in other forms have been under-explored. Recent
studies have shown that Vision-Language (VL) models cannot understand visual
metaphors in memes and adverts. As of now, no probing studies have been done
that involve complex language phenomena like metaphors with videos. Hence, we
introduce a new VL task of describing the metaphors present in the videos in
our work. To facilitate this novel task, we construct and release a manually
created dataset with 705 videos and 2115 human-written captions, along with a
new metric called Average Concept Distance (ACD), to automatically evaluate the
creativity of the metaphors generated. We also propose a novel low-resource
video metaphor captioning system: GIT-LLaVA, which obtains comparable
performance to SoTA video language models on the proposed task. We perform a
comprehensive analysis of existing video language models on this task and
publish our dataset, models, and benchmark results to enable further research.
|
[
-0.4159902334213257,
-0.49536508321762085,
0.3546203076839447,
0.1971704363822937,
-0.7286891937255859,
0.25267964601516724,
0.08441329002380371,
-0.5705413222312927,
0.4632820188999176,
0.3614462912082672,
-0.7608937621116638,
-0.223651722073555,
-0.7712474465370178,
0.0498649999499321,
-0.6241976022720337,
0.5108352303504944,
-0.23163320124149323,
0.08848235011100769,
-0.34160080552101135,
-0.3686225414276123,
-0.6323140859603882,
-0.03532036021351814,
-0.0698414146900177,
0.15069657564163208,
0.39261460304260254,
0.30180519819259644,
0.5697353482246399,
0.761387288570404,
0.7243421077728271,
0.341598242521286,
0.18808770179748535,
0.15896455943584442,
-0.23716245591640472,
-0.04571462795138359,
-0.2507452964782715,
-0.49398306012153625,
0.06479324400424957,
0.2244471162557602,
0.6039503812789917,
0.6133315563201904,
0.08281496912240982,
0.4074743390083313,
-0.17831194400787354,
0.666540801525116,
-0.6682181358337402,
0.2509874701499939,
-0.6490151286125183,
0.4875527322292328,
0.012275893241167068,
-0.2208084762096405,
0.09210626780986786,
-0.16134153306484222,
0.2764738202095032,
-0.7375537157058716,
0.18010984361171722,
0.19796991348266602,
1.0152077674865723,
0.4964984357357025,
0.03556879609823227,
-0.08508683741092682,
-0.6079927682876587,
0.48564547300338745,
-0.2817460000514984,
0.3789812922477722,
-0.11374764144420624,
0.8377071619033813,
0.3744243383407593,
-0.7510116100311279,
-0.9717378616333008,
-0.16819624602794647,
0.25116562843322754,
0.29575037956237793,
-0.6176468729972839,
-0.23057875037193298,
0.3674970269203186,
0.32940271496772766,
-0.5197193622589111,
-0.029425539076328278,
-0.7304622530937195,
0.0005195062258280814,
0.2933507263660431,
0.309511661529541,
0.3382911682128906,
-0.4378669261932373,
-0.6622629761695862,
-0.30599090456962585,
-0.5325074195861816,
-0.30170738697052,
0.13291126489639282,
-0.200903058052063,
-0.43551161885261536,
1.0419081449508667,
-0.42725899815559387,
0.5796368718147278,
-0.5662031769752502,
0.025363801047205925,
0.08764424175024033,
0.007155642844736576,
-0.6673300266265869,
-0.1836443692445755,
0.5336093902587891,
0.9129688739776611,
0.6197806000709534,
0.06257984042167664,
-0.11074429005384445,
0.7070678472518921,
0.2528994679450989,
-0.4512810707092285,
-0.5349149107933044,
-0.4157902002334595,
-0.3030731678009033,
-0.46418750286102295,
0.2940163016319275,
-0.5276219248771667,
-0.7231692671775818,
-0.16433697938919067,
0.664226770401001,
-0.2948269248008728,
-0.09369389712810516,
-0.023358341306447983,
-0.35216954350471497,
0.09233423322439194,
0.5637283325195312,
-0.4166043698787689,
0.28729310631752014,
0.11954215914011002,
0.775942862033844,
0.06751726567745209,
-0.4437669515609741,
-0.49669986963272095,
0.28388139605522156,
-0.41884490847587585,
0.925876259803772,
-0.33307716250419617,
0.11272624135017395,
-0.06411664187908173,
-0.13948333263397217,
0.1999591588973999,
-0.45440202951431274,
0.15370383858680725,
-0.23888812959194183,
0.19829125702381134,
-0.0832289531826973,
-0.32068055868148804,
-0.45649465918540955,
0.3777216076850891,
-0.7798460125923157,
0.4490880072116852,
-0.08326547592878342,
-0.6387288570404053,
0.37621504068374634,
-0.8631798624992371,
0.03900390490889549,
0.4271330237388611,
-0.7395526170730591,
0.010174104012548923,
0.45969098806381226,
0.2093275487422943,
0.4550868272781372,
-0.46765416860580444,
0.011389286257326603,
0.09294722229242325,
-0.35884708166122437,
0.4688110947608948,
-0.7424230575561523,
0.441852867603302,
0.305023729801178,
-0.2651273310184479,
-0.10014785081148148,
-0.32419171929359436,
-0.004641025792807341,
0.37198275327682495,
0.2626253366470337,
-0.3406764268875122,
-0.3474946618080139,
0.17598234117031097,
0.1919022500514984,
-0.0236795786768198,
-0.40160635113716125,
0.004011595156043768,
-0.21418675780296326,
0.476087361574173,
0.6865184307098389,
-0.24995876848697662,
0.23880401253700256,
-0.04065766930580139,
0.8633869290351868,
0.24907496571540833,
0.0863206759095192,
-0.35239842534065247,
-0.38929978013038635,
-0.6474564671516418,
-0.1614587903022766,
0.06637652218341827,
0.2213440239429474,
-1.2868796586990356,
-0.18839137256145477,
-0.6111472249031067,
-0.4193441569805145,
-0.6804333329200745,
0.022697845473885536,
0.5054417848587036,
0.40737369656562805,
0.11022316664457321,
-0.6031045913696289,
-0.4136636555194855,
-1.054268479347229,
-0.24118995666503906,
-0.21695426106452942,
-0.22427590191364288,
0.4564889073371887,
0.49529579281806946,
-0.07435581088066101,
0.6752816438674927,
-0.7967296838760376,
-0.597341775894165,
-0.08078496158123016,
0.23909147083759308,
-0.0673922672867775,
0.08510621637105942,
0.586374819278717,
-0.9160705804824829,
-0.39259806275367737,
-0.16783571243286133,
-1.1544342041015625,
-0.021968284621834755,
-0.047967832535505295,
0.2508458197116852,
-0.11821381002664566,
0.6496471762657166,
-0.5997178554534912,
0.48867350816726685,
0.5935660004615784,
-0.2692709267139435,
0.654474675655365,
-0.11396928131580353,
0.09049297869205475,
-0.6625427603721619,
-0.21165817975997925,
0.0077005429193377495,
-0.005228612571954727,
-0.2159307599067688,
0.3024228513240814,
-0.13448460400104523,
-0.22671882808208466,
-0.9756697416305542,
0.6950871348381042,
-0.5999122262001038,
-0.3446445167064667,
-0.08304975926876068,
0.22906282544136047,
-0.13817434012889862,
0.43689900636672974,
0.1516951024532318,
0.6450258493423462,
0.9568386077880859,
-0.27595651149749756,
0.8460091948509216,
0.18835465610027313,
-0.5484868288040161,
0.4686310589313507,
-0.2909378707408905,
-0.33840179443359375,
-0.29217931628227234,
-0.09386221319437027,
-0.9041697978973389,
-0.4116957485675812,
0.466709703207016,
-0.4919130504131317,
-0.07026972621679306,
0.05910966172814369,
-0.6647356152534485,
-0.45940327644348145,
-0.14456294476985931,
0.6536057591438293,
0.5053267478942871,
-0.506828784942627,
0.41795846819877625,
0.25390103459358215,
0.0909426286816597,
-0.5030047297477722,
-0.6675022840499878,
0.5220922231674194,
-0.6399334669113159,
-0.3241797089576721,
-0.05698530375957489,
-0.13726449012756348,
-0.35140568017959595,
0.04026557132601738,
-0.42422378063201904,
-0.19977785646915436,
-0.14379025995731354,
0.4459284543991089,
-0.019490523263812065,
-0.04211970046162605,
0.052316054701805115,
-0.20394958555698395,
-0.050790246576070786,
0.16221173107624054,
-0.30761751532554626,
0.3188958764076233,
-0.22761476039886475,
-0.31065693497657776,
-0.27687692642211914,
0.46474143862724304,
0.7011305689811707,
-0.25275173783302307,
0.36300894618034363,
0.6147709488868713,
-0.6097010374069214,
-0.05664177983999252,
-0.48989683389663696,
0.0560377761721611,
-0.4928207993507385,
0.44442781805992126,
-0.285871297121048,
-0.5383651256561279,
0.2746371030807495,
-0.055291905999183655,
-0.39740902185440063,
0.15448592603206635,
0.25803127884864807,
-0.3715754449367523,
0.5153957605361938,
0.9051223993301392,
0.11689378321170807,
0.44357454776763916,
-0.3935168385505676,
0.1563667356967926,
-0.41809403896331787,
-0.217606782913208,
-0.029232889413833618,
-0.25031790137290955,
-0.47873836755752563,
-0.6783513426780701,
0.5035703778266907,
0.047964174300432205,
-0.08336108922958374,
0.4565538465976715,
-0.4556586742401123,
0.7990569472312927,
0.5146121978759766,
-0.10019883513450623,
0.37590697407722473,
0.4217928349971771,
-0.30034103989601135,
-0.41767534613609314,
-0.6385330557823181,
-0.5675942301750183,
0.6639959812164307,
0.2515014410018921,
0.6965203881263733,
0.06393490731716156,
0.49152278900146484,
0.37319087982177734,
0.3362905979156494,
-0.7512494921684265,
0.9221519827842712,
-0.23429882526397705,
-0.15766282379627228,
-0.26826798915863037,
-0.04142744839191437,
-0.671950101852417,
0.07533787190914154,
-0.2498808652162552,
-0.730855405330658,
-0.3524216413497925,
-0.03153502568602562,
-0.13902905583381653,
0.2592422366142273,
-0.525111198425293,
0.8572822213172913,
-0.20332318544387817,
-0.14101286232471466,
-0.14687204360961914,
-0.8257215023040771,
0.35874494910240173,
0.13335996866226196,
0.21956144273281097,
0.01628960110247135,
-0.04413935914635658,
0.6600021719932556,
-0.19546380639076233,
0.5761844515800476,
0.07241712510585785,
0.021024813875555992,
0.5209661722183228,
0.2609401345252991,
0.17036296427249908,
-0.1616460084915161,
0.6064682006835938,
0.32055598497390747,
-0.28573840856552124,
-0.29792317748069763,
-0.6008414626121521,
0.5681583881378174,
-0.3090355396270752,
-0.49665138125419617,
-0.4525910019874573,
-0.5549328327178955,
0.19586242735385895,
0.35998550057411194,
0.3986971974372864,
0.13190683722496033,
-0.09476140886545181,
0.10549184679985046,
0.33493223786354065,
-0.41415318846702576,
0.488000750541687,
0.4175454378128052,
-0.05691370368003845,
-0.36926957964897156,
0.8927010297775269,
0.06275820732116699,
0.05571596696972847,
0.4438742697238922,
-0.11265489459037781,
-0.20694635808467865,
-0.3891944885253906,
-0.5941811800003052,
0.10113035142421722,
-0.8110339045524597,
-0.36512070894241333,
-0.4154511094093323,
-0.2806761860847473,
0.054981544613838196,
-0.3049323856830597,
-0.3778553903102875,
-0.36184269189834595,
-0.03191859647631645,
-0.37419047951698303,
0.3658886253833771,
0.5246714353561401,
0.03702079877257347,
0.18752124905586243,
-0.5604268312454224,
0.708906352519989,
0.4832148849964142,
0.5486473441123962,
-0.02698182687163353,
-0.15970617532730103,
-0.2979498505592346,
-0.03716333582997322,
-0.31112003326416016,
-0.8995219469070435,
0.7005116939544678,
-0.05939582735300064,
0.2518177330493927,
0.5499683022499084,
-0.041687801480293274,
0.9131492972373962,
-0.5806782841682434,
0.85981684923172,
0.667626142501831,
-0.6460240483283997,
0.42290931940078735,
-0.49150705337524414,
0.11157126724720001,
0.0841979831457138,
0.12245476245880127,
-0.3957633972167969,
-0.5627620816230774,
-0.7637082934379578,
-0.7051432132720947,
0.10621730983257294,
0.6658903360366821,
0.38974452018737793,
-0.07022857666015625,
-0.23207005858421326,
0.0063850367441773415,
0.5327518582344055,
-0.9422796368598938,
-0.33926501870155334,
-0.34250709414482117,
0.06281358003616333,
-0.14944754540920258,
0.15919660031795502,
-0.165677011013031,
-0.23806466162204742,
-0.05668113753199577,
-0.13872157037258148,
0.4346810579299927,
0.08226532489061356,
-0.04481252655386925,
-0.42833489179611206,
0.022649036720395088,
0.351588636636734,
0.380176842212677,
0.05348903313279152,
0.3428753614425659,
0.025924403220415115,
-0.5298284292221069,
-0.04436006024479866,
-0.048894815146923065,
0.029256215319037437,
0.25973084568977356,
0.3510119915008545,
0.5456314086914062,
0.13836981356143951,
-1.1999987363815308,
0.4943743348121643,
0.12129031866788864,
-0.20890401303768158,
-0.7188766598701477,
0.03214947506785393,
0.08152436465024948,
0.4267529845237732,
0.38101252913475037,
0.28123918175697327,
0.16799157857894897,
-0.5981913805007935,
0.05761825665831566,
0.4011375904083252,
-0.529008150100708,
-0.20213042199611664,
1.0132040977478027,
-0.084584541618824,
-0.36205706000328064,
0.3961920738220215,
-0.1301160454750061,
-0.38305652141571045,
0.772191047668457,
0.14974892139434814,
0.9289511442184448,
0.31641173362731934,
0.35178396105766296,
0.01847500540316105,
0.32076266407966614,
-0.08770959079265594,
0.23339872062206268,
0.010501780547201633,
-0.6066128015518188,
-0.02502332255244255,
-0.5307125449180603,
-0.21471714973449707,
0.366414338350296,
-0.6306774020195007,
0.26500409841537476,
-0.2316005825996399,
0.3623935282230377,
0.256009042263031,
-0.18218253552913666,
-1.0697757005691528,
0.5322728157043457,
0.40022873878479004,
0.7944681644439697,
-1.2558684349060059,
0.6640325784683228,
1.0659862756729126,
-0.655746579170227,
-0.7952072024345398,
-0.12351710349321365,
-0.11957623064517975,
-0.6215922832489014,
0.5679938793182373,
0.3041693866252899,
-0.08933587372303009,
-0.07479953020811081,
-0.8348113298416138,
-0.4882931411266327,
1.273797869682312,
0.5547588467597961,
-0.2521387040615082,
-0.09521808475255966,
0.1728968769311905,
0.7238782644271851,
-0.6325082182884216,
0.017092125490307808,
0.13588355481624603,
0.38660210371017456,
0.2345900535583496,
-0.7804198265075684,
-0.11555307358503342,
-0.39281266927719116,
-0.15881913900375366,
-0.19531595706939697,
-0.5594371557235718,
0.8339738249778748,
-0.4202943444252014,
-0.2717626690864563,
0.37240123748779297,
0.6737486124038696,
0.29431450366973877,
0.6011388301849365,
0.316864013671875,
0.4116283059120178,
0.23167404532432556,
0.2081262469291687,
0.9240218997001648,
0.30458855628967285,
0.047101106494665146,
1.1464654207229614,
0.05636988952755928,
0.4672950506210327,
0.7744566798210144,
-0.0026432641316205263,
0.1893656998872757,
0.273885041475296,
-0.3482542634010315,
0.5821616053581238,
0.4090385437011719,
-0.21590247750282288,
-0.21373046934604645,
-0.5147638916969299,
-0.05923808738589287,
0.6294147968292236,
0.0823461040854454,
-0.5650748610496521,
-0.27360889315605164,
0.11610802263021469,
-0.6044294834136963,
0.5193944573402405,
-0.34477299451828003,
0.6697351932525635,
0.30848923325538635,
-0.2329489141702652,
0.6020402312278748,
-0.22260381281375885,
0.31048983335494995,
-0.30130526423454285,
-0.39504605531692505,
-0.144819438457489,
-0.1917688101530075,
0.14219234883785248,
-0.7785446047782898,
0.15296532213687897,
0.4097154438495636,
-0.029746677726507187,
-0.18539318442344666,
0.36673691868782043,
-0.21701599657535553,
-0.5647458434104919,
0.22511699795722961,
0.8302171230316162,
0.5968528389930725,
-0.14914464950561523,
-0.5900402665138245,
0.008116401731967926,
-0.16788573563098907,
0.23492561280727386,
0.21829020977020264,
0.7785968780517578,
-0.5014249682426453,
1.043317437171936,
0.12178006023168564,
0.20882847905158997,
-0.024693161249160767,
0.14000552892684937,
0.8881360292434692,
-0.7912582159042358,
-0.7125955820083618,
-0.6458854079246521,
0.4735511541366577,
0.0967169851064682,
0.0024872804060578346,
0.7403048276901245,
0.49867263436317444,
0.9603632092475891,
-0.7943370342254639,
0.7884183526039124,
-0.08746490627527237,
0.039686933159828186,
-0.3574984669685364,
0.7407298684120178,
-0.7334935665130615,
0.3726572096347809,
-0.8535601496696472,
-1.0789844989776611,
-0.3915121853351593,
0.5705586075782776,
0.2452048808336258,
-0.4916498064994812,
0.7010629773139954,
0.5418853759765625,
-0.20064736902713776,
-0.29810822010040283,
0.62592613697052,
0.3464367687702179,
0.007149151526391506,
0.4143642783164978,
1.0848881006240845,
-0.540142297744751,
0.655866801738739,
-0.07195551693439484,
0.16160917282104492,
0.1308826506137848,
-1.0952225923538208,
-0.72564297914505,
-0.5966633558273315,
-0.46623313426971436,
0.12493016570806503,
0.18322211503982544,
0.6414758563041687,
0.3932201862335205,
-0.2592392563819885,
-0.23846730589866638,
-0.2874390780925751,
0.05762898176908493,
-0.41567665338516235,
-0.1852811723947525,
0.35455605387687683,
0.4890751242637634,
-0.7009134888648987,
0.22682496905326843,
0.3552896976470947,
0.38403451442718506,
-0.42823243141174316,
-0.06493314355611801,
0.12963616847991943,
0.048132479190826416,
0.5679163932800293,
0.2399206906557083,
-1.044592261314392,
-0.5137100219726562,
-0.14749741554260254,
0.15556715428829193,
-0.026278968900442123,
0.41460198163986206,
-0.9930770993232727,
0.6176398396492004,
0.1869892179965973,
0.08349437266588211,
0.2945140302181244,
0.04202863201498985,
0.49888938665390015,
-0.7492218613624573,
0.23207585513591766,
0.005940982140600681,
0.2711038291454315,
0.45043420791625977,
0.03710358589887619,
0.715210497379303,
0.3940972685813904,
0.3690403997898102,
-1.0183274745941162,
0.4039500951766968,
-1.221481442451477,
-0.019712287932634354,
0.9853521585464478,
-0.11305949091911316,
0.07218970358371735,
0.3819553852081299,
-0.24686270952224731,
0.2618127167224884,
-0.15276098251342773,
0.9832063913345337,
0.5368483066558838,
0.1712905913591385,
-0.38147762417793274,
-0.7704421877861023,
0.4302652180194855,
0.06390973925590515,
-0.534899890422821,
0.06111643463373184,
0.6693748831748962,
0.3061669170856476,
0.1605699062347412,
0.47082534432411194,
-0.05890611186623573,
0.3103543519973755,
0.29105904698371887,
-0.12351248413324356,
-0.3224325180053711,
-0.7089022994041443,
-0.27272915840148926,
0.11620022356510162,
-0.21510536968708038,
-0.4438641667366028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04882v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04882v1
|
InstructNav: Zero-shot System for Generic Instruction Navigation in Unexplored Environment
| 2024-06-07T12:26:34 | 2024-06-07T12:26:34 |
Yuxing Long, Wenzhe Cai, Hongcheng Wang, Guanqi Zhan, Hao Dong
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Enabling robots to navigate following diverse language instructions in
unexplored environments is an attractive goal for human-robot interaction.
However, this goal is challenging because different navigation tasks require
different strategies. The scarcity of instruction navigation data hinders
training an instruction navigation model with varied strategies. Therefore,
previous methods are all constrained to one specific type of navigation
instruction. In this work, we propose InstructNav, a generic instruction
navigation system. InstructNav makes the first endeavor to handle various
instruction navigation tasks without any navigation training or pre-built maps.
To reach this goal, we introduce Dynamic Chain-of-Navigation (DCoN) to unify
the planning process for different types of navigation instructions.
Furthermore, we propose Multi-sourced Value Maps to model key elements in
instruction navigation so that linguistic DCoN planning can be converted into
robot actionable trajectories. With InstructNav, we complete the R2R-CE task in
a zero-shot way for the first time and outperform many task-training methods.
Besides, InstructNav also surpasses the previous SOTA method by 10.48% on the
zero-shot Habitat ObjNav and by 86.34% on demand-driven navigation DDN. Real
robot experiments on diverse indoor scenes further demonstrate our method's
robustness in coping with the environment and instruction variations.
|
[
-0.010510435327887535,
-0.5695879459381104,
0.6135381460189819,
-0.21608184278011322,
-0.3713442087173462,
0.5693590044975281,
-0.1924399435520172,
0.03815718740224838,
0.2611636221408844,
0.5017679333686829,
-0.9034082293510437,
-1.005341649055481,
-0.38958731293678284,
-0.25424709916114807,
-0.08367583900690079,
0.6042523384094238,
-0.142356738448143,
-0.16521024703979492,
-0.07429233193397522,
-0.29662609100341797,
-0.624322235584259,
-0.47934356331825256,
-0.17905257642269135,
-0.2862950265407562,
0.41401800513267517,
0.916256308555603,
0.5283594131469727,
0.5440991520881653,
0.2624299228191376,
0.14487698674201965,
0.1252351850271225,
0.34946030378341675,
-0.3297824561595917,
0.26338720321655273,
-0.19142109155654907,
-0.47646987438201904,
-0.26892611384391785,
-0.42729315161705017,
0.5417895913124084,
0.6187577247619629,
-0.29912424087524414,
0.1079118624329567,
0.07772434502840042,
0.7730854153633118,
-0.971973180770874,
0.205278217792511,
-0.3562049865722656,
0.35379740595817566,
0.07655123621225357,
-0.2711493968963623,
-0.3876914083957672,
-0.22705189883708954,
0.12117455899715424,
-0.8063181042671204,
-0.20599263906478882,
-0.09544119238853455,
0.4202984869480133,
0.5373972654342651,
-0.6869192719459534,
-0.2580074667930603,
-1.0110887289047241,
0.7991462349891663,
-0.5930917859077454,
0.2787783145904541,
-0.09463568031787872,
0.37417957186698914,
-0.5158249735832214,
-0.36814412474632263,
-0.5080888867378235,
-0.3496740162372589,
0.33811846375465393,
0.5149326920509338,
-0.29367244243621826,
0.19861283898353577,
-0.12607325613498688,
-0.317862868309021,
-0.7145925760269165,
0.3761645555496216,
-0.06987309455871582,
0.27594560384750366,
0.22722353041172028,
0.10827063024044037,
0.4077237844467163,
-0.008902018889784813,
-0.6430394649505615,
-0.4045247435569763,
-0.8683738112449646,
0.30066320300102234,
0.2651444971561432,
0.5233737230300903,
-0.05011582747101784,
0.5146108865737915,
-0.503643810749054,
0.8866904973983765,
-0.019019080325961113,
-0.09280708432197571,
0.13496439158916473,
-0.0651579424738884,
-0.0796654224395752,
0.45123594999313354,
0.47335657477378845,
0.332154780626297,
0.15460139513015747,
-0.22564829885959625,
0.0660855621099472,
-0.07901839911937714,
0.4348491430282593,
-0.4357588291168213,
-0.4517615735530853,
0.07891537994146347,
-0.08106040954589844,
-0.2207750380039215,
0.01831629127264023,
-0.8475745320320129,
-0.061027560383081436,
0.009079238399863243,
0.4144401252269745,
-0.15356284379959106,
-0.2035970389842987,
0.13639633357524872,
0.048487287014722824,
0.2689204812049866,
0.4957425892353058,
-0.5556368231773376,
0.14016900956630707,
0.2437521368265152,
0.7797350287437439,
0.04884610325098038,
-0.11316405236721039,
-0.5748674273490906,
0.3352769613265991,
-0.5729666352272034,
0.7456040382385254,
-0.7297933101654053,
-0.5721527338027954,
0.06695344299077988,
-0.09981740266084671,
0.09386946260929108,
-0.3881083130836487,
0.2175765186548233,
-0.35100409388542175,
0.05609343200922012,
0.06288578361272812,
-0.41963887214660645,
-0.8097332715988159,
0.5681279897689819,
-0.2449670433998108,
0.7518823146820068,
0.250760018825531,
-0.10550952702760696,
0.2598082423210144,
-0.8595863580703735,
-0.5092224478721619,
0.49118101596832275,
-0.20719817280769348,
-0.0011170196812599897,
-0.36530646681785583,
0.1283167600631714,
0.2845824062824249,
0.16914713382720947,
-0.0788557231426239,
-0.0019187736324965954,
-0.7085385322570801,
-0.18313626945018768,
-0.34548935294151306,
0.6037665009498596,
-0.25002190470695496,
-0.7638664841651917,
0.0340409092605114,
-0.734851062297821,
0.17628033459186554,
0.12438306212425232,
-0.4599633812904358,
-0.5424854159355164,
0.2610042989253998,
-0.4777536988258362,
0.09174460172653198,
0.2615955173969269,
-0.5704478025436401,
0.6991562247276306,
-0.47451165318489075,
-0.06916263699531555,
0.43568700551986694,
0.28121820092201233,
0.8142167925834656,
0.09029336273670197,
0.9871106147766113,
-0.17303913831710815,
0.21957318484783173,
-0.3231814205646515,
-0.5067842602729797,
-0.8531166315078735,
-0.19243855774402618,
0.07073112577199936,
0.8289009928703308,
-1.0308723449707031,
0.33924221992492676,
-0.26077574491500854,
-0.4145199954509735,
-0.1353614330291748,
-0.16388458013534546,
0.6846908330917358,
0.51817786693573,
0.6337898969650269,
-0.03449051454663277,
-0.3976636230945587,
-0.321769118309021,
0.3301115334033966,
0.0011170244542881846,
-0.15234851837158203,
0.33215633034706116,
0.31224918365478516,
-0.23085622489452362,
0.4179189205169678,
-0.5278910994529724,
-0.2935181260108948,
-0.2884311378002167,
0.020946340635418892,
0.16016808152198792,
0.4422261416912079,
0.3645213544368744,
-0.4145960211753845,
-0.3626464009284973,
0.12869173288345337,
-0.828057050704956,
0.31976932287216187,
-0.319243460893631,
-0.23069143295288086,
0.05365807190537453,
0.3925083577632904,
-0.33174023032188416,
0.7442076802253723,
0.4950917661190033,
0.1302938461303711,
0.14127036929130554,
-0.43010222911834717,
0.20282688736915588,
-0.8060953617095947,
-0.27862200140953064,
-0.2664497196674347,
-0.08872988075017929,
-0.5407124757766724,
0.4018320143222809,
-0.047403402626514435,
-0.054760076105594635,
-0.6480368971824646,
0.26962289214134216,
-0.4594723582267761,
0.15196700394153595,
-0.2663329839706421,
0.2472284883260727,
0.01880544051527977,
0.9431329369544983,
0.018456973135471344,
0.3268343210220337,
0.5087774395942688,
-0.7643008232116699,
0.5638628005981445,
0.4834870398044586,
-0.2706436812877655,
0.3041209876537323,
-0.47761866450309753,
0.36413130164146423,
-0.044364120811223984,
0.5360036492347717,
-0.6731559634208679,
0.09258800745010376,
0.7797485589981079,
-0.2948448061943054,
0.25186461210250854,
-0.7220537066459656,
-0.4421902596950531,
-0.2987666428089142,
-0.042634930461645126,
0.2706747055053711,
0.528148889541626,
-0.6747345924377441,
0.3786032497882843,
0.12328986823558807,
0.3096488118171692,
-0.7249500751495361,
-0.5265142917633057,
0.11653178185224533,
-0.009550058282911777,
-0.15095286071300507,
0.04608476534485817,
-0.22851771116256714,
0.14218024909496307,
-0.018324337899684906,
-0.39564159512519836,
-0.1941177397966385,
-0.06780778616666794,
0.5907322764396667,
0.6278207302093506,
-0.08506161719560623,
0.05782560259103775,
0.29543858766555786,
-0.08210209012031555,
-0.04105699807405472,
-0.4985697567462921,
0.5401512384414673,
0.1774599850177765,
-0.49332305788993835,
-0.4701986610889435,
0.32790452241897583,
0.35105904936790466,
-0.22403183579444885,
0.43894898891448975,
-0.0844654068350792,
-0.11407974362373352,
-0.5075057148933411,
0.15876594185829163,
0.04112964868545532,
-0.5006911754608154,
0.2980648875236511,
-0.16754856705665588,
-0.5731514692306519,
0.026578109711408615,
-0.6591798067092896,
0.11653945595026016,
-0.027419252321124077,
0.09934733808040619,
-0.49296772480010986,
0.6231281757354736,
0.5909082889556885,
0.4595855176448822,
0.3098664879798889,
-0.7008035182952881,
0.30426737666130066,
-0.707546055316925,
-0.7470166087150574,
-0.16142891347408295,
-0.6279074549674988,
-0.4117668867111206,
-0.5337449312210083,
0.6703983545303345,
-0.10080993920564651,
-0.40926170349121094,
0.6871047019958496,
-0.9120888113975525,
0.45519718527793884,
0.7809958457946777,
0.30467236042022705,
0.138140007853508,
-0.19014345109462738,
-0.2732510566711426,
0.21107539534568787,
-1.0782499313354492,
-0.3778328597545624,
1.0837661027908325,
-0.23630866408348083,
0.6807230710983276,
-0.15214525163173676,
0.9711989164352417,
0.2713734209537506,
-0.2768932580947876,
-0.9384388327598572,
0.7760695219039917,
-0.23291079699993134,
-0.386792927980423,
-0.4517447352409363,
-0.23147867619991302,
-1.0637315511703491,
0.003734044963493943,
-0.21346750855445862,
-0.5852926969528198,
0.32120800018310547,
0.12047843635082245,
-0.6271432638168335,
0.5481403470039368,
-0.5285012722015381,
0.7749038338661194,
-0.35981041193008423,
0.1613486409187317,
-0.20385479927062988,
-0.8320378065109253,
0.14253298938274384,
0.11538640409708023,
-0.173386350274086,
-0.12221845239400864,
0.01631491258740425,
0.4178878664970398,
-0.2561473250389099,
0.7131748199462891,
-0.3696768581867218,
0.10701712220907211,
0.5651717185974121,
0.6125305891036987,
0.5270220041275024,
-0.1600777804851532,
0.17063532769680023,
0.31921446323394775,
-0.10136453807353973,
-0.15565012395381927,
-0.8611919283866882,
0.673073410987854,
-0.500677764415741,
-0.23748987913131714,
-0.604108452796936,
-0.4348471164703369,
-0.004003516864031553,
0.13738833367824554,
0.28049278259277344,
0.526282787322998,
-0.30903637409210205,
0.19240586459636688,
0.6410211324691772,
-0.40452006459236145,
0.5416179299354553,
0.6891511082649231,
0.21129031479358673,
0.05122160539031029,
0.8181591629981995,
0.22976022958755493,
0.1884639710187912,
0.8930259346961975,
0.03394694626331329,
-0.06383497267961502,
-0.4496549367904663,
-0.6612048149108887,
-0.4865281581878662,
-0.4491520822048187,
-0.5294140577316284,
-0.30790087580680847,
-0.33200016617774963,
0.2956378757953644,
-0.5973713397979736,
-0.8469046354293823,
-0.32921767234802246,
-0.3672155737876892,
0.04786590486764908,
0.19186855852603912,
0.8820826411247253,
-0.17092804610729218,
0.2568351924419403,
-0.8363948464393616,
0.1921793669462204,
0.396715372800827,
-0.03702976927161217,
-0.024523623287677765,
-0.44496098160743713,
-0.24312378466129303,
0.4826011657714844,
-0.195548877120018,
-0.51777583360672,
0.251436322927475,
-0.019056668505072594,
0.4667327404022217,
0.36770859360694885,
0.5107258558273315,
0.5200709104537964,
-0.7343494296073914,
0.6207454204559326,
0.266218364238739,
-0.6102730631828308,
0.8703052997589111,
-0.2153787463903427,
0.7772918939590454,
0.5186097025871277,
0.43785467743873596,
-0.2819003760814667,
-0.24192586541175842,
-0.47243809700012207,
-0.9191039204597473,
0.45030465722084045,
0.0068891714327037334,
0.09503555297851562,
0.19289863109588623,
0.4249771535396576,
0.13618968427181244,
0.14048516750335693,
-0.3409247398376465,
-0.18028192222118378,
-0.3307458460330963,
0.009345853701233864,
0.08899308741092682,
0.13149376213550568,
-0.25553834438323975,
-0.11677650362253189,
0.27927112579345703,
0.05243274196982384,
0.1639213114976883,
0.07128424197435379,
-0.14423435926437378,
-0.13647794723510742,
0.137519970536232,
0.6015744805335999,
0.4581269323825836,
-0.4866488575935364,
-0.011448726989328861,
0.12826940417289734,
-0.33724308013916016,
0.5882530808448792,
-0.2727879285812378,
-0.4265531897544861,
0.0077061899937689304,
0.23297590017318726,
0.4824618101119995,
0.6338273286819458,
-0.5606787800788879,
0.49817392230033875,
0.2288587987422943,
-0.03365890681743622,
-0.3778221309185028,
0.42971572279930115,
-0.21852368116378784,
0.4317229688167572,
0.09688467532396317,
0.463996946811676,
0.08917953819036484,
-0.416945219039917,
0.0758439227938652,
0.2078581601381302,
-0.6020696759223938,
-0.31331518292427063,
0.5405923128128052,
0.3793126940727234,
-0.501538872718811,
0.8252204060554504,
-0.5862224102020264,
-0.236688032746315,
0.5884020924568176,
0.2712164521217346,
0.8374296426773071,
-0.23685945570468903,
0.6588000059127808,
0.4598056972026825,
0.3441931903362274,
0.02922292798757553,
0.18149997293949127,
-0.3607242703437805,
-0.6184766888618469,
-0.23747411370277405,
-0.24933984875679016,
-0.8354309797286987,
-0.23490966856479645,
-0.5843892097473145,
-0.05484696105122566,
-0.6188795566558838,
0.38961952924728394,
-0.6092777252197266,
-0.25788670778274536,
-0.6784289479255676,
0.25742921233177185,
0.16362005472183228,
0.4659229516983032,
-0.2769581079483032,
0.9806201457977295,
0.7604534029960632,
-0.3921054005622864,
-0.6961061358451843,
0.3131416141986847,
0.12789107859134674,
-0.8733184933662415,
0.6074047684669495,
-0.06652355194091797,
-0.8284953832626343,
0.00895608589053154,
-0.6739461421966553,
-0.6120532155036926,
1.1012487411499023,
0.19958654046058655,
-0.6867491006851196,
-0.04494430497288704,
-0.10561250150203705,
0.28219547867774963,
-0.38641899824142456,
-0.13027824461460114,
0.05751178041100502,
0.32898837327957153,
0.36129528284072876,
-0.3486618995666504,
-0.11295144259929657,
0.022233694791793823,
0.023393094539642334,
0.1499924659729004,
-0.6998469233512878,
0.36174240708351135,
-0.4974687695503235,
-0.2756437063217163,
0.19394013285636902,
0.2819574475288391,
0.21315032243728638,
0.21256741881370544,
0.43385112285614014,
0.4367213547229767,
0.5525707006454468,
0.12562574446201324,
0.7591696381568909,
-0.2166578620672226,
0.011863211169838905,
1.4564969539642334,
-0.26074862480163574,
0.9708585739135742,
0.01986697129905224,
0.049034275114536285,
1.0084995031356812,
0.3017958700656891,
-0.03245340660214424,
0.9721223711967468,
0.238010972738266,
-0.558515191078186,
-0.11334345489740372,
-0.08886610716581345,
-0.17158424854278564,
0.9276507496833801,
0.16128192842006683,
0.3806336522102356,
-0.37480786442756653,
0.21141771972179413,
0.11945546418428421,
0.23748645186424255,
-0.19371095299720764,
0.5455459356307983,
-0.24488548934459686,
-0.4263453781604767,
0.5191499590873718,
-0.2989484667778015,
0.40281131863594055,
-0.8348343372344971,
-0.5612324476242065,
-0.2624790072441101,
0.18651895225048065,
0.01882203482091427,
-0.9451999068260193,
-0.10865974426269531,
-0.1294267326593399,
0.15446864068508148,
-0.2527748644351959,
0.42459240555763245,
-0.3590782880783081,
-0.27426081895828247,
0.39125683903694153,
0.39264604449272156,
0.20324768126010895,
-0.10717511177062988,
-0.30607670545578003,
-0.19957168400287628,
0.1644483208656311,
0.03749210387468338,
0.32630565762519836,
0.4253787100315094,
0.2738921344280243,
0.9791838526725769,
0.37936529517173767,
-0.26974666118621826,
0.14033375680446625,
-0.1831747144460678,
0.7100048065185547,
-0.6744102835655212,
-0.27167272567749023,
-0.33624449372291565,
0.7768571972846985,
0.35182949900627136,
-0.39412954449653625,
0.6104883551597595,
0.3492397367954254,
0.9940140843391418,
-0.13125696778297424,
0.5801860690116882,
0.18463894724845886,
0.15895022451877594,
-0.4469473659992218,
0.6679444909095764,
-0.6224508881568909,
-0.019853420555591583,
-0.039334774017333984,
-0.9412938356399536,
-0.35350683331489563,
0.5827053785324097,
0.19472235441207886,
-0.20330104231834412,
0.6434081792831421,
0.6915732622146606,
-0.13441529870033264,
-0.4926110804080963,
0.5366353392601013,
-0.14033976197242737,
0.1356309950351715,
0.7152746915817261,
0.7786832451820374,
-0.3189030587673187,
0.9670006036758423,
-0.3657248020172119,
-0.3719286024570465,
-0.1284085363149643,
-0.6653398871421814,
-0.6474817991256714,
-0.38182684779167175,
-0.4938409924507141,
-0.06169227510690689,
0.3781985938549042,
0.8376346826553345,
0.8168116807937622,
-0.6452993750572205,
-0.33782488107681274,
-0.25254368782043457,
0.14093880355358124,
-0.33716416358947754,
-0.17721600830554962,
0.12693898379802704,
-0.05579706281423569,
-0.6316362619400024,
1.3919506072998047,
0.9842441082000732,
-0.08747151494026184,
-0.25574615597724915,
-0.2326294481754303,
-0.5435361266136169,
0.07232437282800674,
0.4106021225452423,
0.7483301758766174,
-0.46665629744529724,
-0.43208256363868713,
0.09971468150615692,
0.15835599601268768,
0.3706851601600647,
0.5037236213684082,
-0.8894363641738892,
1.0111534595489502,
0.13380944728851318,
0.4148869812488556,
0.5670677423477173,
-0.3049844801425934,
0.48814427852630615,
-0.7592675685882568,
0.43371179699897766,
0.4654775559902191,
0.03237884119153023,
0.09382592141628265,
-0.30130136013031006,
0.507354736328125,
-0.03876042366027832,
-0.6450479626655579,
-0.37671229243278503,
0.3280508816242218,
-1.1812224388122559,
-0.2456376850605011,
1.00482976436615,
-0.3546302914619446,
-0.060355257242918015,
0.1228446215391159,
-0.1352015733718872,
0.3908028304576874,
-0.5267290472984314,
0.6564318537712097,
0.27161046862602234,
-0.20693199336528778,
-0.18310962617397308,
-0.6495875716209412,
-0.05538360774517059,
-0.013027364388108253,
-0.586078405380249,
-0.5401783585548401,
0.31897515058517456,
-0.009997203014791012,
-0.02992384508252144,
0.29745009541511536,
0.2096511274576187,
0.24896357953548431,
0.1988724023103714,
0.4681016504764557,
-0.18339978158473969,
-0.7125003337860107,
-0.08138253539800644,
0.02885948121547699,
-0.34963560104370117,
-1.1608705520629883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04879v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04879v1
|
A Deep Dive into the Trade-Offs of Parameter-Efficient Preference Alignment Techniques
| 2024-06-07T12:25:51 | 2024-06-07T12:25:51 |
Megh Thakkar, Quentin Fournier, Matthew D Riemer, Pin-Yu Chen, Amal Zouaq, Payel Das, Sarath Chandar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models are first pre-trained on trillions of tokens and then
instruction-tuned or aligned to specific preferences. While pre-training
remains out of reach for most researchers due to the compute required,
fine-tuning has become affordable thanks to parameter-efficient methods such as
LoRA and QLoRA. Alignment is known to be sensitive to the many factors
involved, including the quantity and quality of data, the alignment method, and
the adapter rank. However, there has not yet been an extensive study of their
effect on downstream performance. To address this gap, we conduct an in-depth
investigation of the impact of popular choices for three crucial axes: (i) the
alignment dataset (HH-RLHF and BeaverTails), (ii) the alignment technique (SFT
and DPO), and (iii) the model (LLaMA-1, Vicuna-v1.3, Mistral-7b, and
Mistral-7b-Instruct). Our extensive setup spanning over 300 experiments reveals
consistent trends and unexpected findings. We observe how more informative data
helps with preference alignment, cases where supervised fine-tuning outperforms
preference optimization, and how aligning to a distinct preference boosts
performance on downstream tasks. Through our in-depth analyses, we put forward
key guidelines to help researchers perform more effective parameter-efficient
LLM alignment.
|
[
-0.6110106110572815,
-0.438345342874527,
0.6748808026313782,
-0.17019101977348328,
-0.3282175064086914,
0.0242848489433527,
-0.27320507168769836,
-0.5140337944030762,
0.11535334587097168,
0.5206374526023865,
-0.501876175403595,
-0.20428557693958282,
-0.6451715230941772,
-0.1679113656282425,
-0.17742213606834412,
1.0528595447540283,
-0.08912096172571182,
-0.004430055618286133,
-0.011060256510972977,
-0.20165199041366577,
-0.5338197350502014,
-0.5525835156440735,
-0.5763738751411438,
-0.16530074179172516,
0.9612607955932617,
0.4300456643104553,
1.0089658498764038,
1.1500846147537231,
0.6737498044967651,
0.21179325878620148,
-0.09959504008293152,
0.13106347620487213,
-0.7136994004249573,
0.07170011103153229,
-0.15268617868423462,
-0.3398277461528778,
-0.5143944025039673,
0.13860833644866943,
0.5319318771362305,
0.6590214371681213,
0.06569934636354446,
0.2991880774497986,
0.15273410081863403,
0.9382506012916565,
-0.9299339056015015,
-0.19477401673793793,
-0.6992558240890503,
-0.215251162648201,
-0.6157482266426086,
-0.23793986439704895,
-0.2355298101902008,
-0.5179217457771301,
0.3411935567855835,
-0.555676281452179,
-0.1643763780593872,
0.06688899546861649,
0.9686188697814941,
0.5689477324485779,
-0.4361026883125305,
-0.060193464159965515,
-0.6602499485015869,
0.9325453639030457,
-0.7264718413352966,
0.5074607729911804,
0.10693328827619553,
0.1809503436088562,
-0.233613058924675,
-0.3486004173755646,
-0.30486738681793213,
0.21885105967521667,
0.02966785430908203,
-0.010012060403823853,
-0.08187728375196457,
0.15347620844841003,
0.14192257821559906,
0.399069219827652,
-0.4296625852584839,
0.6777851581573486,
-0.13659128546714783,
-0.10937690734863281,
0.5529825687408447,
0.05158952251076698,
0.0640517920255661,
0.14384226500988007,
-0.19875670969486237,
-0.26388007402420044,
-0.8246134519577026,
0.17771998047828674,
0.6244314908981323,
0.5503067374229431,
0.308920681476593,
0.6152771711349487,
-0.2768515944480896,
1.061277985572815,
0.37803158164024353,
-0.11805573850870132,
-0.09720250219106674,
-0.39181163907051086,
0.028148969635367393,
0.23373492062091827,
0.701653778553009,
0.30449333786964417,
0.3005484342575073,
-0.02207561396062374,
-0.1375844031572342,
-0.06596818566322327,
0.24104833602905273,
-0.6683980226516724,
-0.028315719217061996,
0.15527020394802094,
-0.34989458322525024,
-0.23061062395572662,
-0.19067007303237915,
-0.5621595978736877,
-0.35378602147102356,
-0.8236751556396484,
0.48885035514831543,
-0.19405244290828705,
-0.06034519150853157,
0.13899634778499603,
0.02081792801618576,
0.6445938348770142,
0.3982689082622528,
-1.207606554031372,
0.09882916510105133,
1.1466491222381592,
0.767548680305481,
-0.47466349601745605,
-0.3139571249485016,
-0.6574999094009399,
0.09312506020069122,
-0.29206037521362305,
0.8412628769874573,
-0.6836436986923218,
-0.01947662979364395,
-0.21879509091377258,
-0.29206231236457825,
-0.1175580695271492,
-0.35550373792648315,
0.603653073310852,
-0.6516007781028748,
0.1789552867412567,
-0.7421162128448486,
-0.6927677989006042,
-0.1317182034254074,
-0.14587196707725525,
-0.7582111358642578,
0.8319180607795715,
0.05357080325484276,
-0.8714143633842468,
0.6800907254219055,
-0.3482475280761719,
-0.2668813169002533,
-0.3846498727798462,
-0.07698951661586761,
-0.2135130763053894,
0.0641145184636116,
0.2607908844947815,
0.3720487952232361,
-0.3171716332435608,
0.14499659836292267,
-0.48797526955604553,
-0.5337976217269897,
0.20200389623641968,
-0.38524186611175537,
0.6522431969642639,
0.20826441049575806,
-0.3002670109272003,
0.2755827009677887,
-0.47876378893852234,
0.010384798981249332,
-0.1685723513364792,
-0.27265605330467224,
-0.3818143606185913,
0.006797731854021549,
-0.19240091741085052,
0.11339563876390457,
0.3448074758052826,
-0.1672019511461258,
0.322274386882782,
-0.2824186086654663,
0.38064146041870117,
0.9853169918060303,
-0.3316059708595276,
0.6178826093673706,
-0.19770245254039764,
0.5377174615859985,
-0.20480141043663025,
0.3680556118488312,
0.31146857142448425,
-0.2604624032974243,
-0.7685146331787109,
-0.3902641832828522,
0.5333461761474609,
0.26738256216049194,
-0.04640534892678261,
0.45139434933662415,
-0.3850563168525696,
-0.6404366493225098,
-0.8726007342338562,
0.2828114330768585,
0.25214076042175293,
0.5766577124595642,
0.20923644304275513,
-0.04281589388847351,
-0.3957691490650177,
-1.0833308696746826,
-0.4427678883075714,
-0.053837306797504425,
0.35935670137405396,
0.07709677517414093,
0.03680357336997986,
0.03467594459652901,
1.1166949272155762,
-0.7986661195755005,
-0.004538984503597021,
-0.08209553360939026,
-0.2386881560087204,
0.30715447664260864,
0.4065190255641937,
0.5959537625312805,
-0.5509032607078552,
-0.470493882894516,
0.15163272619247437,
-0.1467897742986679,
-0.1563803255558014,
0.14361117780208588,
-0.6526015400886536,
0.22872640192508698,
0.3218843638896942,
-0.5037729144096375,
0.10645894706249237,
0.8004732131958008,
0.054039210081100464,
0.33039674162864685,
0.018730005249381065,
0.10672742128372192,
-0.9033635258674622,
0.097368523478508,
-0.16040189564228058,
-0.027073297649621964,
-0.5822166204452515,
-0.03097631223499775,
0.10366073250770569,
0.25507044792175293,
-0.3271911144256592,
0.49461501836776733,
-0.3241937756538391,
-0.09790787100791931,
-0.26222655177116394,
0.026062700897455215,
-0.09472960978746414,
0.40799304842948914,
0.1870081126689911,
0.9569728374481201,
0.3481149971485138,
-0.5591999888420105,
-0.04072032496333122,
0.12521415948867798,
-0.21146410703659058,
0.2579003572463989,
-0.49905461072921753,
0.39732882380485535,
0.09560292214155197,
0.040300045162439346,
-1.031178593635559,
-0.07686023414134979,
0.21825319528579712,
-0.1461012214422226,
0.38444650173187256,
-0.2280130833387375,
-0.29815223813056946,
0.13939182460308075,
-0.4629758596420288,
0.5784425139427185,
0.46938762068748474,
-0.7764673829078674,
0.371313214302063,
0.4521975815296173,
-0.2183680683374405,
-0.8934986591339111,
-0.2537486255168915,
-0.2053947150707245,
-0.6793235540390015,
-0.41411179304122925,
0.26174840331077576,
0.04647412151098251,
-0.1765240877866745,
-0.3058762550354004,
-0.2491845190525055,
0.13253222405910492,
0.19232425093650818,
0.050697021186351776,
0.3503875434398651,
-0.28699594736099243,
-0.09785208106040955,
0.15687976777553558,
-0.2286604344844818,
-0.29886704683303833,
-0.21587590873241425,
0.6773901581764221,
-0.1978507936000824,
-0.40987321734428406,
-0.3171670138835907,
0.11022301018238068,
0.5897701382637024,
-0.4144114553928375,
0.5548503398895264,
0.43463754653930664,
-0.027947422116994858,
0.2613692879676819,
-0.6671879291534424,
-0.07203564047813416,
-0.45903128385543823,
0.20784114301204681,
-0.11236006766557693,
-0.8410811424255371,
0.3291569948196411,
0.036207620054483414,
0.33362987637519836,
0.3542296886444092,
0.29216429591178894,
-0.12163172662258148,
1.2156556844711304,
0.5254566669464111,
-0.3624119460582733,
0.6951229572296143,
0.15488944947719574,
0.49128708243370056,
-0.8761315941810608,
0.3089973032474518,
-0.583527684211731,
-0.5604091286659241,
-0.789527416229248,
-0.1519475132226944,
0.12666460871696472,
0.2830348610877991,
-0.2798195481300354,
0.4289367198944092,
-0.38996410369873047,
0.416802316904068,
0.5995407700538635,
-0.12877492606639862,
0.32084137201309204,
-0.08276403695344925,
0.3237536549568176,
-0.10995699465274811,
-0.5988628268241882,
-0.6371298432350159,
1.2225062847137451,
0.3185340166091919,
0.6523900032043457,
0.16769863665103912,
0.7436072826385498,
-0.10463536530733109,
0.13837261497974396,
-1.0707533359527588,
0.42414575815200806,
-0.38881343603134155,
-0.4404231905937195,
-0.4604041576385498,
-0.225199893116951,
-1.02587890625,
0.275416761636734,
-0.18450802564620972,
-0.6722522377967834,
0.27004995942115784,
0.47328510880470276,
-0.5352678894996643,
0.11083639413118362,
-0.7306404113769531,
0.8196104168891907,
-0.6421471238136292,
-0.4545409083366394,
-0.15784145891666412,
-0.6216161847114563,
0.23492823541164398,
-0.32972636818885803,
-0.0757998451590538,
-0.15403006970882416,
-0.05735830217599869,
0.766700267791748,
-0.1700231283903122,
0.5302950143814087,
-0.0009724203846417367,
-0.2987004816532135,
-0.19818170368671417,
-0.10987454652786255,
0.4014705419540405,
-0.18580205738544464,
-0.19258718192577362,
0.2197304219007492,
0.16786110401153564,
-0.3061160743236542,
-0.610317051410675,
0.8687853813171387,
-0.8991329073905945,
-0.8068312406539917,
-0.31937670707702637,
-0.5141497254371643,
-0.4631510376930237,
0.31766319274902344,
0.29478827118873596,
0.2233944982290268,
-0.08896645903587341,
0.05526965484023094,
0.670779287815094,
0.04296121001243591,
0.23068039119243622,
0.25733253359794617,
-0.27306780219078064,
-0.3688046336174011,
0.9435037970542908,
0.3295637369155884,
0.48037052154541016,
0.5624915361404419,
0.40034493803977966,
-0.4132750332355499,
-0.5515135526657104,
-0.4902864098548889,
0.4109361469745636,
-0.5657265186309814,
-0.10293623805046082,
-0.45930084586143494,
-0.032021746039390564,
-0.3487829864025116,
-0.3399973511695862,
-0.5773255825042725,
-0.3911812901496887,
-0.4098348915576935,
-0.08977320790290833,
0.3574924170970917,
0.42335471510887146,
0.15918780863285065,
0.44529470801353455,
-0.5658780336380005,
-0.05965161696076393,
0.3385911285877228,
0.3559080958366394,
-0.05423800274729729,
-0.4513505697250366,
-0.13581934571266174,
0.06662514060735703,
-0.1426854133605957,
-0.6103513836860657,
0.03914431110024452,
0.07202178239822388,
0.5678659081459045,
0.77594393491745,
-0.025463901460170746,
1.0019909143447876,
-0.2735840380191803,
0.4893769323825836,
-0.09171254187822342,
-0.9222514033317566,
0.38332220911979675,
-0.3817789852619171,
0.1355777531862259,
0.8713775873184204,
0.37981846928596497,
-0.2970341742038727,
-0.05753449723124504,
-0.2455260157585144,
-0.9075887203216553,
0.6820860505104065,
-0.04564514011144638,
-0.07343348115682602,
0.3192231357097626,
0.46676695346832275,
0.5886412262916565,
0.2244725078344345,
-0.3283078968524933,
-0.07872163504362106,
0.09454044699668884,
-0.1957678496837616,
-0.23967620730400085,
-0.028856242075562477,
-0.17766103148460388,
-0.3437955677509308,
0.5611621737480164,
-0.1994551122188568,
-0.1910606175661087,
-0.3280753493309021,
-0.04919113218784332,
0.06736991554498672,
0.27914559841156006,
0.5402971506118774,
0.7406634092330933,
-0.41254863142967224,
0.04538058489561081,
-0.07488376647233963,
-0.26934969425201416,
0.0615205392241478,
-0.02699347585439682,
-0.2594761550426483,
-0.33142924308776855,
0.20920458436012268,
0.9810991287231445,
0.15882284939289093,
-0.4558466672897339,
0.26762357354164124,
-0.05321897566318512,
-0.06793605536222458,
0.07818020135164261,
0.2720332145690918,
0.1483290195465088,
0.07136516273021698,
-0.08872640877962112,
-0.01885858178138733,
0.15241581201553345,
-0.3860597610473633,
-0.27146902680397034,
0.706512987613678,
-0.37678638100624084,
-0.16577249765396118,
0.27664145827293396,
0.05952367186546326,
-0.07284825295209885,
0.5991230010986328,
0.3853428065776825,
-0.29610198736190796,
0.2642788589000702,
0.3276788294315338,
0.7564054727554321,
-0.08969829976558685,
0.050332143902778625,
0.10346618294715881,
0.03815282881259918,
-0.24776072800159454,
0.04149024933576584,
-0.2072143703699112,
-0.7741518616676331,
-0.4445420801639557,
-0.5806004405021667,
-0.3873465359210968,
0.054047711193561554,
-1.0029525756835938,
0.39227455854415894,
-0.255342572927475,
-0.3284647762775421,
0.10379552096128464,
-0.047271616756916046,
-0.6994604468345642,
-0.14727769792079926,
0.048960812389850616,
0.6647760272026062,
-0.8964764475822449,
0.6345459222793579,
0.6926637291908264,
-0.11726325005292892,
-0.8481266498565674,
0.2631480097770691,
0.02122308500111103,
-0.8879557251930237,
0.4691711366176605,
0.03224235400557518,
-0.4263235628604889,
0.07483093440532684,
-0.387602835893631,
-1.367664098739624,
0.9014869332313538,
0.6967182755470276,
-0.7598440051078796,
-0.04792344197630882,
0.09816102683544159,
0.5128915905952454,
-0.16092804074287415,
0.24808868765830994,
1.0493078231811523,
0.5421615839004517,
-0.05716845020651817,
-0.8963569402694702,
-0.04714183881878853,
0.19884663820266724,
-0.008426100015640259,
0.5592160820960999,
-0.9051493406295776,
0.6224503517150879,
-0.13950443267822266,
0.013431076891720295,
-0.09922261536121368,
0.4568654000759125,
0.3500507175922394,
0.026728125289082527,
0.6068161725997925,
0.42242249846458435,
0.7509660124778748,
-0.04309869930148125,
0.8133978843688965,
-0.38384512066841125,
0.05763225629925728,
0.9775014519691467,
-0.43592092394828796,
1.141769289970398,
0.9750314354896545,
-0.21912409365177155,
0.11591137200593948,
1.1004765033721924,
0.2815326452255249,
0.6641876101493835,
0.08313499391078949,
0.21185699105262756,
-0.43145161867141724,
-0.17661041021347046,
-0.4427919387817383,
0.7107006907463074,
0.19229193031787872,
-0.10624360293149948,
0.018109634518623352,
-0.37054651975631714,
0.17414332926273346,
-0.30775895714759827,
-0.1935635656118393,
0.8812654614448547,
-0.10073288530111313,
-1.0526713132858276,
0.5205655097961426,
-0.43360960483551025,
0.5810074210166931,
-0.6314569115638733,
0.14978687465190887,
-0.30792883038520813,
0.21087974309921265,
-0.274544894695282,
-0.9136350750923157,
-0.08504803478717804,
-0.10095541924238205,
-0.19982363283634186,
-0.22941960394382477,
0.3905024826526642,
-0.27485328912734985,
-0.17502176761627197,
0.25480273365974426,
0.4354076087474823,
0.0214023869484663,
-0.005475817713886499,
-0.41205689311027527,
0.264290988445282,
0.016361897811293602,
-0.29868531227111816,
0.7271777391433716,
0.20147500932216644,
-0.1379021257162094,
0.4056873619556427,
0.6497658491134644,
0.2546238303184509,
-0.06231530010700226,
0.0807587206363678,
0.8644477128982544,
-0.4230784475803375,
-0.33509770035743713,
-0.8768919110298157,
0.29029229283332825,
0.01902264542877674,
-0.5854097604751587,
0.6848146915435791,
0.6429975628852844,
0.8762518167495728,
0.16719388961791992,
0.6114870309829712,
0.3565354347229004,
0.32143664360046387,
-0.8011264801025391,
0.46488094329833984,
-0.5805661678314209,
0.34194788336753845,
-0.4609866440296173,
-1.165276050567627,
-0.08876627683639526,
0.2987171709537506,
-0.5757365822792053,
0.03930111229419708,
0.4842627942562103,
0.733509361743927,
-0.21893231570720673,
-0.019863322377204895,
-0.029421688988804817,
-0.15970812737941742,
0.3896254003047943,
0.3044590651988983,
0.8795541524887085,
-0.037317655980587006,
0.37794357538223267,
-0.27288636565208435,
-0.29272401332855225,
-0.3517061471939087,
-1.0323565006256104,
-0.47989481687545776,
-0.4511096775531769,
-0.311660498380661,
-0.030385522171854973,
0.09272080659866333,
0.9603055715560913,
0.6616511344909668,
-0.7300530076026917,
-0.3396907448768616,
0.09328188747167587,
0.042094577103853226,
-0.3402984142303467,
-0.13781392574310303,
0.6077895760536194,
-0.29266560077667236,
-0.6776379942893982,
0.1004030629992485,
0.29104918241500854,
-0.029276208952069283,
-0.05772095546126366,
-0.09868209064006805,
-0.0878525972366333,
0.03482617437839508,
0.43449199199676514,
0.28120657801628113,
-0.8584550023078918,
-0.2654472291469574,
0.25428855419158936,
-0.0966944694519043,
0.21149404346942902,
0.8524338006973267,
-0.3918822109699249,
0.3131362497806549,
0.6919044256210327,
0.8559764623641968,
0.20065969228744507,
0.3078251779079437,
0.9160566926002502,
-0.1918213665485382,
-0.3320952355861664,
-0.017434241250157356,
0.2662317454814911,
0.29656925797462463,
-0.4826638400554657,
0.39698106050491333,
-0.33080118894577026,
-0.7937667965888977,
-0.9010656476020813,
0.21427281200885773,
-1.0819447040557861,
-0.25845789909362793,
1.2262333631515503,
0.15280377864837646,
0.007497468031942844,
0.13835711777210236,
-0.5291967988014221,
0.296358585357666,
-0.4626929759979248,
0.7484243512153625,
0.7763426899909973,
-0.5657384395599365,
-0.01721118576824665,
-0.37504762411117554,
0.6724569797515869,
0.6682834625244141,
-0.5927819609642029,
0.2424636334180832,
0.4338138699531555,
0.2673289179801941,
-0.09286292642354965,
0.37421008944511414,
0.012405031360685825,
-0.016730714589357376,
-0.5443604588508606,
-0.22982971370220184,
0.23563708364963531,
-0.16824844479560852,
-0.5225170850753784,
-0.16376368701457977,
0.5266369581222534,
-0.2036067694425583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04876v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04876v1
|
HateDebias: On the Diversity and Variability of Hate Speech Debiasing
| 2024-06-07T12:18:02 | 2024-06-07T12:18:02 |
Nankai Lin, Hongyan Wu, Zhengming Chen, Zijian Li, Lianxi Wang, Shengyi Jiang, Dong Zhou, Aimin Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hate speech on social media is ubiquitous but urgently controlled. Without
detecting and mitigating the biases brought by hate speech, different types of
ethical problems. While a number of datasets have been proposed to address the
problem of hate speech detection, these datasets seldom consider the diversity
and variability of bias, making it far from real-world scenarios. To fill this
gap, we propose a benchmark, named HateDebias, to analyze the model ability of
hate speech detection under continuous, changing environments. Specifically, to
meet the diversity of biases, we collect existing hate speech detection
datasets with different types of biases. To further meet the variability (i.e.,
the changing of bias attributes in datasets), we reorganize datasets to follow
the continuous learning setting. We evaluate the detection accuracy of models
trained on the datasets with a single type of bias with the performance on the
HateDebias, where a significant performance drop is observed. To provide a
potential direction for debiasing, we further propose a debiasing framework
based on continuous learning and bias information regularization, as well as
the memory replay strategies to ensure the debiasing ability of the model.
Experiment results on the proposed benchmark show that the aforementioned
method can improve several baselines with a distinguished margin, highlighting
its effectiveness in real-world applications.
|
[
-0.6050889492034912,
-0.8181659579277039,
0.03350002318620682,
0.013864636421203613,
-0.3092630207538605,
0.23563984036445618,
-0.34589701890945435,
-0.5967687964439392,
0.20221804082393646,
0.19685375690460205,
-0.48308154940605164,
-0.6993158459663391,
-0.8234259486198425,
-0.19110944867134094,
-0.4869379699230194,
1.049620509147644,
0.3633992373943329,
0.4422253966331482,
0.25123992562294006,
-0.6383022665977478,
-0.41228920221328735,
-0.09457702934741974,
-0.5752947926521301,
-0.03107001818716526,
0.7792034149169922,
0.51104336977005,
0.7846160531044006,
0.6496469378471375,
0.2846509516239166,
0.1920592188835144,
-0.3594764471054077,
-0.07767302542924881,
-0.7479647994041443,
0.6588600873947144,
-0.35451579093933105,
-0.3659953474998474,
-0.034118447452783585,
0.1856435388326645,
0.5647506713867188,
0.40945670008659363,
-0.05818517878651619,
0.18591023981571198,
-0.1236729770898819,
0.29714223742485046,
-0.6039796471595764,
-0.4297620356082916,
-0.9801005125045776,
-0.03577901050448418,
-0.30919864773750305,
0.2900702655315399,
0.04293111339211464,
-0.7255186438560486,
0.05806999281048775,
-0.33965539932250977,
0.3094671368598938,
-0.006688796915113926,
0.5453611016273499,
0.367858350276947,
-0.07685640454292297,
-0.4226033389568329,
-1.0288971662521362,
1.0258792638778687,
-0.6071152687072754,
0.5375416278839111,
0.18852433562278748,
0.4197244942188263,
0.14676743745803833,
-0.23261921107769012,
-0.5494922995567322,
-0.19657205045223236,
0.5650220513343811,
0.005272707901895046,
-0.6398388147354126,
-0.19038861989974976,
0.2091875821352005,
0.2610805928707123,
-0.267282634973526,
0.565626323223114,
-0.4783563017845154,
0.05710845813155174,
0.585267961025238,
0.08114077150821686,
0.16567271947860718,
-0.012357758358120918,
-0.10393313318490982,
-0.10179977118968964,
-0.18170499801635742,
-0.2295006662607193,
0.7388041615486145,
0.3646944761276245,
-0.2011663317680359,
0.023719238117337227,
-0.15932786464691162,
0.4128425419330597,
-0.07219807803630829,
-0.09285406768321991,
0.6122304201126099,
0.5337191224098206,
-0.20129786431789398,
-0.2090613692998886,
0.27852359414100647,
0.6110448241233826,
0.47734516859054565,
-0.40583115816116333,
-0.046792879700660706,
0.6634899377822876,
0.4899672567844391,
-0.6150463819503784,
0.008368349634110928,
0.2809133529663086,
-0.46774518489837646,
-0.635620653629303,
-0.635765790939331,
-1.2658404111862183,
-0.8204416036605835,
-0.25734636187553406,
-0.08818940818309784,
-0.5545752048492432,
-0.13933111727237701,
-0.316051185131073,
-0.39626017212867737,
-0.15366575121879578,
0.33458036184310913,
-0.6016885042190552,
0.41583317518234253,
0.39678138494491577,
0.628412127494812,
-0.600635826587677,
-0.17148226499557495,
-0.5493961572647095,
-0.3378975987434387,
-0.3545069694519043,
0.6354321837425232,
-0.7843416929244995,
-0.2821851372718811,
0.0486028715968132,
-0.4891822934150696,
0.39642035961151123,
-0.8857970833778381,
0.6602557301521301,
-0.532164454460144,
-0.299952894449234,
-0.3111906945705414,
-0.5321260094642639,
-0.24149538576602936,
0.38719019293785095,
-0.5067379474639893,
0.9084421396255493,
0.20655040442943573,
-0.661410927772522,
0.7256820797920227,
-0.3309503495693207,
-0.12122268229722977,
0.09708239883184433,
-0.25306588411331177,
-0.5748183727264404,
0.10977831482887268,
-0.11934003233909607,
0.07792658358812332,
-0.08910135179758072,
0.2760510742664337,
-0.9630687236785889,
-0.2646409869194031,
0.12439683824777603,
-0.5341479182243347,
0.8055038452148438,
0.47728824615478516,
-0.7486268877983093,
0.0011997768888249993,
-1.0619107484817505,
-0.23938176035881042,
0.01864517293870449,
0.01867600902915001,
-0.6151567697525024,
0.270450621843338,
0.20980039238929749,
0.0996970608830452,
-0.2858808934688568,
-0.9869706630706787,
-0.17014791071414948,
-0.06831958889961243,
0.012084254994988441,
0.9946934580802917,
-0.038044776767492294,
0.16874855756759644,
-0.45844563841819763,
0.4624256193637848,
0.2470748871564865,
0.3190459907054901,
0.6759937405586243,
-0.2648184299468994,
-0.6002024412155151,
-0.3197886347770691,
-0.024750199168920517,
0.556401789188385,
-0.12194998562335968,
-0.09329787641763687,
-0.04670453816652298,
-0.8721205592155457,
-0.30309227108955383,
0.09483153373003006,
0.26596957445144653,
0.35486844182014465,
0.6358364224433899,
-0.07271191477775574,
-1.0152844190597534,
-0.8795232772827148,
-0.5463266968727112,
0.053169649094343185,
0.15878421068191528,
0.35911092162132263,
0.49476757645606995,
-0.5119894742965698,
0.7533824443817139,
-0.12324752658605576,
-0.08462661504745483,
-0.08695975691080093,
0.2834549844264984,
-0.17984867095947266,
0.2935431897640228,
0.7978717684745789,
-0.9862563014030457,
-0.5666110515594482,
-0.5245224833488464,
-0.44731467962265015,
-0.30358579754829407,
0.2521895170211792,
-0.06051134690642357,
-0.001578045659698546,
0.2704677879810333,
0.18221069872379303,
0.5069515705108643,
0.6271526217460632,
-0.01969294063746929,
0.46684280037879944,
0.5710195302963257,
0.32779204845428467,
-0.7713020443916321,
-0.25586625933647156,
0.03915814682841301,
-0.14777952432632446,
-0.6175051927566528,
-0.21508976817131042,
-0.4209440350532532,
0.08656448870897293,
-0.6160953640937805,
0.2392132431268692,
-0.03988151624798775,
0.12453346699476242,
-0.3158889412879944,
0.2888988256454468,
-0.5850273370742798,
0.33613041043281555,
-0.1838265359401703,
0.24463851749897003,
0.5463710427284241,
-0.7001526951789856,
0.6772630214691162,
0.10641386359930038,
-0.38464322686195374,
0.976416826248169,
-0.2894362807273865,
0.004328025970607996,
-0.3811480700969696,
0.02171630784869194,
-0.8415906429290771,
-0.008210872299969196,
0.4056113660335541,
-0.47657859325408936,
-0.13682638108730316,
-0.33988237380981445,
-0.2705218493938446,
-0.48828843235969543,
-0.4162646234035492,
0.258617639541626,
0.511626660823822,
-0.47967082262039185,
0.34053486585617065,
0.7974033951759338,
0.0882512629032135,
-0.6578836441040039,
-0.7552566528320312,
-0.16995662450790405,
-0.5818988680839539,
-0.26427939534187317,
0.5393692255020142,
-0.39115649461746216,
-0.7844257950782776,
0.010189451277256012,
-0.17157112061977386,
-0.26107287406921387,
0.15749068558216095,
0.5767862796783447,
-0.03452501446008682,
0.12591196596622467,
0.17519018054008484,
0.14796501398086548,
0.3441952168941498,
-0.13276667892932892,
-0.02186015248298645,
0.4307573139667511,
0.05294188857078552,
0.009133642539381981,
-0.06185740977525711,
0.3087896704673767,
0.753247082233429,
0.406176894903183,
0.6419624090194702,
0.6314412951469421,
-0.6206743717193604,
-0.5201737284660339,
-0.8654755353927612,
0.20037627220153809,
-0.38031575083732605,
0.11610428988933563,
0.12174565345048904,
-0.8644910454750061,
0.7717735767364502,
0.34097370505332947,
0.33273938298225403,
0.14523589611053467,
0.596744954586029,
-0.12175202369689941,
0.5680496096611023,
0.44579005241394043,
-0.4274687170982361,
0.6771625280380249,
0.106923408806324,
-0.06901552528142929,
-0.3636058568954468,
0.05831961706280708,
-0.5375791192054749,
-0.44080761075019836,
-0.6631869673728943,
-0.30796146392822266,
0.14777839183807373,
-0.3147919774055481,
-0.36600738763809204,
0.21837687492370605,
-0.3969856798648834,
0.5235229730606079,
0.3894740641117096,
0.2521163523197174,
0.01392834447324276,
0.23346497118473053,
0.13524948060512543,
-0.3667961359024048,
-0.25601130723953247,
-0.23674650490283966,
1.0870096683502197,
0.4235110282897949,
0.6895402669906616,
0.05377256125211716,
0.5843576192855835,
0.8526692986488342,
0.537529706954956,
-0.5460477471351624,
0.3684006929397583,
-0.262602835893631,
-0.7927826642990112,
-0.23986117541790009,
-0.39947983622550964,
-0.5880194306373596,
0.3693059980869293,
-0.04740060120820999,
-0.9088610410690308,
0.3827456533908844,
0.333053320646286,
-0.4746723771095276,
0.7638441920280457,
-0.03181202709674835,
0.564544677734375,
-0.03884445130825043,
-0.5477457046508789,
-0.5008506178855896,
-0.3461378216743469,
0.15258817374706268,
0.022166194394230843,
0.5401583313941956,
-0.34859973192214966,
0.1524057388305664,
1.0335469245910645,
0.07669000327587128,
0.9586620330810547,
-0.36233943700790405,
-0.013342669233679771,
0.394545316696167,
0.19542914628982544,
0.2890768349170685,
-0.11441348493099213,
-0.32954129576683044,
0.3235238790512085,
-0.26593491435050964,
-0.2810640037059784,
-0.20999741554260254,
0.8248197436332703,
-0.6096824407577515,
-0.21055936813354492,
-0.22212176024913788,
-0.4844943881034851,
-0.4014878273010254,
0.11730610579252243,
0.3516884744167328,
0.14462624490261078,
-0.7881737947463989,
0.2807193696498871,
0.8147889375686646,
-0.27358028292655945,
0.2389843910932541,
0.6335713267326355,
-0.07925395667552948,
-0.4759090542793274,
0.6940591335296631,
0.4305992126464844,
-0.06906624883413315,
-0.12997159361839294,
0.02708948776125908,
0.09998241066932678,
-0.7000893354415894,
-0.3709808886051178,
-0.1117510050535202,
-0.7448176741600037,
-0.10267644375562668,
-0.7660342454910278,
0.15581563115119934,
-0.5169348120689392,
-0.18286071717739105,
-0.6048340797424316,
-0.02968362346291542,
-0.08219321817159653,
-0.16783376038074493,
0.27510640025138855,
0.5905308723449707,
-0.5740308165550232,
0.3072347640991211,
-0.34190669655799866,
0.6643683314323425,
0.27665212750434875,
0.6573617458343506,
-0.08187034726142883,
-0.8259853720664978,
-0.2087515890598297,
0.2810577154159546,
-0.22101539373397827,
-1.1390291452407837,
0.479513555765152,
-0.3380540609359741,
0.5340055823326111,
0.23089119791984558,
0.11664360016584396,
0.4857702851295471,
-0.35125333070755005,
0.6018944382667542,
-0.23106379806995392,
-0.7820731997489929,
0.4422060251235962,
-0.43105438351631165,
-0.347994863986969,
0.832000195980072,
0.6217831969261169,
-0.7263590097427368,
-0.673117458820343,
-0.7539052963256836,
-0.6782874464988708,
0.5398232936859131,
0.29275086522102356,
0.1622125804424286,
-0.21902696788311005,
-0.12618735432624817,
0.21772781014442444,
0.3567720055580139,
-0.8084318041801453,
-0.6461498737335205,
-0.13452038168907166,
0.06950443238019943,
0.20086458325386047,
-0.5497481822967529,
-0.20714962482452393,
-0.3016818165779114,
0.8133192658424377,
0.524609386920929,
-0.05175945907831192,
-0.15978091955184937,
-0.21042628586292267,
-0.17574307322502136,
0.3619779348373413,
0.3806956708431244,
0.5565827488899231,
-0.3820071518421173,
-0.1906907558441162,
0.28987085819244385,
-0.38728585839271545,
0.06074047461152077,
0.01796806789934635,
-0.4001622796058655,
0.46560046076774597,
-0.23245806992053986,
0.7880427837371826,
0.14549139142036438,
-0.6616075038909912,
0.351858526468277,
0.1550806164741516,
0.1212686076760292,
-0.6327334642410278,
0.07841896265745163,
-0.27387672662734985,
0.33379048109054565,
0.223815456032753,
0.13747720420360565,
0.3141930103302002,
-0.2571258544921875,
0.44348543882369995,
0.2549504339694977,
-0.44819194078445435,
-0.034626662731170654,
0.594575822353363,
0.2733704447746277,
-0.22545166313648224,
0.40868330001831055,
-0.2244313508272171,
-0.4648188352584839,
0.6720734238624573,
0.31065601110458374,
0.8611818552017212,
-0.5278283953666687,
0.35425493121147156,
0.5290808081626892,
0.23726381361484528,
0.21780267357826233,
-0.04814979061484337,
-0.0733361691236496,
-0.9746508002281189,
0.3546866178512573,
-0.6720906496047974,
-0.6687051653862,
0.5814208388328552,
-0.7517905235290527,
0.22028280794620514,
-0.6599391102790833,
-0.1720402091741562,
0.24716636538505554,
-0.3441217243671417,
-0.5586177706718445,
0.4402226507663727,
0.6945826411247253,
0.7392719984054565,
-0.9745875000953674,
0.41516241431236267,
0.12481091916561127,
-0.29315364360809326,
-0.2964230477809906,
0.02468980848789215,
0.36279380321502686,
-0.6022020578384399,
0.5740190148353577,
0.1081218421459198,
-0.3259139657020569,
-0.1886766105890274,
-0.7697224020957947,
-0.6405801177024841,
0.4471549987792969,
0.044527605175971985,
-0.683983564376831,
0.2659929096698761,
-0.0658198818564415,
0.6755260229110718,
-0.41474297642707825,
0.0585884191095829,
0.5947281122207642,
0.24094010889530182,
-0.23573994636535645,
-0.49847695231437683,
-0.2660016119480133,
-0.11265967041254044,
0.027094773948192596,
-0.1845317780971527,
-0.6024986505508423,
0.8621756434440613,
0.18876616656780243,
-0.19783809781074524,
-0.16417643427848816,
0.5302156805992126,
-0.09135030210018158,
0.5443242788314819,
0.6901372671127319,
0.6867581605911255,
0.7906278371810913,
0.2785012125968933,
0.5170308351516724,
-0.025778761133551598,
0.25966256856918335,
1.3194807767868042,
-0.20111501216888428,
0.444455087184906,
0.07013540714979172,
-0.14487217366695404,
0.7837360501289368,
0.4156706631183624,
-0.3624519407749176,
0.33506113290786743,
0.5532057881355286,
-0.39483439922332764,
-0.1280832439661026,
-0.24000141024589539,
-0.3255322277545929,
0.45201829075813293,
0.4720628559589386,
-0.49543917179107666,
-0.49881792068481445,
0.42196157574653625,
0.27235445380210876,
0.24827395379543304,
-0.34879279136657715,
0.4102894067764282,
-0.259086936712265,
-0.48619356751441956,
0.665564775466919,
0.011272677220404148,
0.9535650610923767,
-0.45048657059669495,
0.18578392267227173,
-0.3503437936306,
0.1332540214061737,
-0.17821885645389557,
-0.46594372391700745,
0.6059238314628601,
0.5132541060447693,
-0.426593542098999,
-0.06656482815742493,
0.47391611337661743,
-0.20468367636203766,
0.05164904147386551,
0.7567618489265442,
0.1474229395389557,
0.208328515291214,
-0.09430535137653351,
-0.8055874109268188,
0.6086357831954956,
0.22163128852844238,
-0.1737849861383438,
0.15252934396266937,
0.056588318198919296,
-0.003438754938542843,
0.7535387277603149,
0.3654870390892029,
0.10664871335029602,
0.22917373478412628,
0.2625795900821686,
0.8406999111175537,
-0.5441821813583374,
-0.522456705570221,
-0.9365357756614685,
0.17457690834999084,
-0.30582195520401,
-0.5238751769065857,
0.7991925477981567,
0.667418897151947,
1.0959895849227905,
0.06434739381074905,
0.9996199011802673,
-0.1591116040945053,
1.1944044828414917,
0.07469777017831802,
0.4914535880088806,
-0.38179659843444824,
0.09255830198526382,
-0.6326026320457458,
-0.7063214182853699,
-0.2758597433567047,
0.5629660487174988,
-0.5229672789573669,
-0.06663641333580017,
0.3234539031982422,
0.7768077850341797,
-0.13910157978534698,
0.16605783998966217,
0.4950283169746399,
0.4918374717235565,
0.2077469527721405,
0.07911227643489838,
0.4594270884990692,
-0.30478549003601074,
0.5893637537956238,
-0.5075659155845642,
-0.31868505477905273,
-0.16466295719146729,
-0.517389178276062,
-0.6744800806045532,
-0.41291549801826477,
-0.5217480063438416,
-0.6541232466697693,
0.42024004459381104,
0.9272923469543457,
0.48868173360824585,
-0.9977455139160156,
-0.15075939893722534,
-0.025103440508246422,
0.17144142091274261,
-0.21318568289279938,
-0.25726836919784546,
-0.33409255743026733,
-0.12277802079916,
-1.0276011228561401,
0.3836548626422882,
0.10615580528974533,
-0.022945964708924294,
0.031670670956373215,
0.19982509315013885,
-0.23288080096244812,
0.25921764969825745,
0.3677387237548828,
0.5158072113990784,
-0.47526466846466064,
-0.36032772064208984,
-0.42252597212791443,
-0.20745384693145752,
0.11739454418420792,
0.6583432555198669,
-0.6241171360015869,
0.29562127590179443,
0.21820072829723358,
0.6760046482086182,
0.37559935450553894,
0.03591075912117958,
0.08762155473232269,
-0.4675658345222473,
0.3207312822341919,
0.613460898399353,
0.18479621410369873,
0.32398512959480286,
-0.048083383589982986,
0.37105056643486023,
0.5836631655693054,
-0.42612624168395996,
-0.9301109313964844,
0.5545640587806702,
-0.8224537372589111,
-0.37216854095458984,
1.2353475093841553,
0.08875515311956406,
-0.09616120904684067,
-0.3984634280204773,
0.004448914900422096,
0.4598127603530884,
-0.5494350790977478,
0.9561798572540283,
0.6296398639678955,
0.07704272121191025,
0.1641494184732437,
-0.39863237738609314,
0.5381119251251221,
0.5025261044502258,
-0.4253799617290497,
0.34676945209503174,
0.9935478568077087,
0.6096619963645935,
0.09116759896278381,
0.5761817097663879,
0.003349798731505871,
0.23183371126651764,
0.23385997116565704,
0.08402356505393982,
0.2695937752723694,
-0.3339215815067291,
-0.30314236879348755,
0.18554697930812836,
-0.4251522421836853,
-0.4184766411781311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04866v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04866v1
|
ComplexTempQA: A Large-Scale Dataset for Complex Temporal Question Answering
| 2024-06-07T12:01:59 | 2024-06-07T12:01:59 |
Raphael Gruber, Abdelrahman Abdallah, Michael Färber, Adam Jatowt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce ComplexTempQA,a large-scale dataset consisting of over 100
million question-answer pairs designed to tackle the challenges in temporal
question answering. ComplexTempQA significantly surpasses existing benchmarks
like HOTPOTQA, TORQUE, and TEQUILA in scale and scope. Utilizing data from
Wikipedia and Wikidata, the dataset covers questions spanning over two decades
and offers an unmatched breadth of topics. We introduce a unique taxonomy that
categorizes questions as attributes, comparisons, and counting questions, each
revolving around events, entities, and time periods. One standout feature of
ComplexTempQA is the high complexity of its questions, which demand effective
capabilities for answering such as across-time comparison, temporal
aggregation, and multi-hop reasoning involving temporal event ordering and
entity recognition. Additionally, each question is accompanied by detailed
metadata, including specific time scopes, allowing for comprehensive evaluation
and enhancement of the temporal reasoning abilities of large language models.
ComplexTempQA serves both as a testing ground for developing sophisticated AI
models and as a foundation for advancing research in question answering,
information retrieval, and language understanding. Dataset and code are freely
available at: https://github.com/DataScienceUIBK/ComplexTempQA.
|
[
-0.6115798354148865,
-1.0755373239517212,
0.5979956388473511,
0.6207290887832642,
0.19939956068992615,
0.469829797744751,
-0.07229176163673401,
-0.6201258301734924,
-0.12813200056552887,
0.20111647248268127,
-0.670311450958252,
-0.16389042139053345,
-0.3414100408554077,
-0.10813392698764801,
-0.3956177234649658,
0.6424408555030823,
-0.1252952516078949,
0.1486881524324417,
-0.11845003813505173,
-0.07211966812610626,
-0.1525651216506958,
-0.5203654170036316,
-0.6976037621498108,
-0.24294829368591309,
0.7556950449943542,
0.5428664684295654,
0.6359015703201294,
0.352268785238266,
0.4487411677837372,
0.17165866494178772,
-0.03453598916530609,
0.2141655683517456,
-0.2899461090564728,
0.38098564743995667,
-0.14885875582695007,
-0.4493596851825714,
-0.4659147262573242,
-0.10136812925338745,
0.5387958884239197,
1.0450634956359863,
-0.02642263099551201,
0.7394378781318665,
-0.31443431973457336,
0.29044073820114136,
-0.8386913537979126,
0.15950113534927368,
-0.6193395256996155,
0.11267584562301636,
-0.4300542175769806,
-0.281404048204422,
-0.08636580407619476,
-0.2612568140029907,
0.21108396351337433,
-0.640353262424469,
0.008664694614708424,
0.13687457144260406,
0.7431231737136841,
0.33813998103141785,
-0.7403497099876404,
-0.0036188506055623293,
-1.154578685760498,
0.5067295432090759,
-0.22976575791835785,
0.25137194991111755,
0.09569821506738663,
0.6722427606582642,
-0.17659209668636322,
-1.0694811344146729,
-1.1578528881072998,
-0.004353641532361507,
0.45260918140411377,
0.13949096202850342,
-0.20851196348667145,
-0.07260841876268387,
0.44687655568122864,
0.21439430117607117,
-0.9648182988166809,
0.08770230412483215,
-0.06574810296297073,
-0.005563589744269848,
0.2782798409461975,
0.5735458731651306,
0.41108667850494385,
-0.07337573170661926,
-0.07503616809844971,
0.12038297951221466,
-0.5943115949630737,
0.49493128061294556,
0.21289169788360596,
-0.21274925768375397,
0.2643129229545593,
0.891004741191864,
-0.6964936852455139,
0.6767774820327759,
0.06400419771671295,
0.30981549620628357,
-0.09735463559627533,
-0.3673952519893646,
0.03282219544053078,
0.06246865168213844,
0.4271702468395233,
0.2579798400402069,
0.2208080142736435,
-0.2641448974609375,
0.36281779408454895,
-0.10997099429368973,
0.008551124483346939,
-0.8296144008636475,
-0.17109641432762146,
0.748844563961029,
-0.03328617662191391,
0.04893563315272331,
0.05997345596551895,
-0.6640390753746033,
-0.0469944030046463,
-0.49072369933128357,
0.587006688117981,
0.058443583548069,
-0.22435076534748077,
0.19764336943626404,
-0.3134029507637024,
0.5319026708602905,
0.4016834795475006,
-0.3057531416416168,
0.3433510363101959,
1.0051089525222778,
0.5182667374610901,
-0.17997710406780243,
-0.44577082991600037,
-0.7561870813369751,
0.3130248188972473,
-0.2511059641838074,
0.7657577991485596,
-0.7786246538162231,
0.2874785363674164,
-0.2613573372364044,
0.170044407248497,
0.1643652319908142,
-0.6964641809463501,
0.46341726183891296,
-0.9087600708007812,
0.24632208049297333,
-0.20635201036930084,
-0.3901612460613251,
0.0007176464423537254,
0.6064770817756653,
-0.6724028587341309,
1.1037582159042358,
-0.04325258731842041,
-0.6618527173995972,
0.18314217031002045,
-0.7462311387062073,
-0.2842859625816345,
0.16460885107517242,
0.021506978198885918,
-0.1748826801776886,
-0.44413521885871887,
0.24495963752269745,
0.5006633996963501,
-0.6583882570266724,
0.5370470881462097,
-0.42478764057159424,
-0.2385512739419937,
0.409890353679657,
-0.34691718220710754,
0.770307183265686,
0.38833028078079224,
-0.5460290908813477,
-0.06342892348766327,
-0.757297933101654,
0.18469193577766418,
0.16544000804424286,
-0.33517923951148987,
-0.2607347071170807,
-0.04774915799498558,
0.20399539172649384,
0.2924286127090454,
0.39955800771713257,
-0.7853579521179199,
0.28239208459854126,
-0.007802214473485947,
0.5524856448173523,
0.37409108877182007,
0.38846564292907715,
0.1871068775653839,
-0.3478066921234131,
0.5672491788864136,
0.22212624549865723,
0.39617666602134705,
0.03674640879034996,
-0.3886960744857788,
-0.5294058918952942,
0.08476930111646652,
0.367357075214386,
0.8632059693336487,
-0.7145208716392517,
0.2678563892841339,
-0.3648844063282013,
-0.8975642323493958,
-0.28043490648269653,
-0.35768458247184753,
0.24383153021335602,
0.6680514812469482,
0.44848355650901794,
0.12227842211723328,
-0.42093712091445923,
-0.8506988286972046,
-0.25342515110969543,
-0.21334344148635864,
-0.5190346240997314,
0.26193535327911377,
0.4545213580131531,
0.013380113989114761,
0.7169771194458008,
-0.8558880090713501,
0.16817142069339752,
-0.037512607872486115,
0.26125138998031616,
0.1636936366558075,
0.46441057324409485,
0.46868836879730225,
-1.1506692171096802,
-0.22842198610305786,
-0.31225529313087463,
-0.5777974128723145,
-0.06048238277435303,
-0.36204004287719727,
-0.34412887692451477,
-0.47670459747314453,
0.4744076728820801,
-0.8086530566215515,
-0.025469420477747917,
0.48263466358184814,
-0.5685944557189941,
0.684773862361908,
0.2703700065612793,
0.4134173095226288,
-1.3245153427124023,
0.3801521062850952,
-0.4527861773967743,
-0.15092572569847107,
-0.5491650104522705,
0.1363317221403122,
0.05178669095039368,
-0.2900201380252838,
-0.5066309571266174,
0.6571866273880005,
-0.1640414595603943,
0.07259374111890793,
0.43060189485549927,
0.07716897875070572,
-0.022821243852376938,
0.6095885634422302,
-0.15762947499752045,
0.6247371435165405,
0.33125078678131104,
-0.7056078314781189,
0.7564313411712646,
0.33653271198272705,
-0.4305993914604187,
0.5310840010643005,
-1.025600552558899,
0.08736275136470795,
-0.17190347611904144,
0.40172716975212097,
-0.9686859846115112,
-0.37077417969703674,
-0.09706930816173553,
-0.5745015740394592,
0.17673280835151672,
-0.08741948753595352,
-0.6886588931083679,
-0.3405877947807312,
-0.17768780887126923,
0.7289309501647949,
-0.04554879292845726,
-0.3451331853866577,
0.7464686036109924,
0.5194181203842163,
-0.43487417697906494,
-0.879655122756958,
-0.41721582412719727,
0.3363474905490875,
0.042805373668670654,
-0.5223460793495178,
0.28470128774642944,
-0.3460613787174225,
-0.4130379855632782,
0.0782175287604332,
-0.0894542708992958,
-0.32183754444122314,
0.2690596282482147,
0.29655754566192627,
0.04756169021129608,
-0.21554270386695862,
0.3518374562263489,
0.20315393805503845,
-0.055408187210559845,
0.09292247146368027,
-0.3904140293598175,
0.9577652215957642,
-0.0929851084947586,
-0.30361440777778625,
-0.2239815592765808,
0.6323544979095459,
0.8667935132980347,
-0.5203768014907837,
0.5587005615234375,
0.7899406552314758,
-0.6700237989425659,
0.06615811586380005,
-0.5304012298583984,
0.061507698148489,
-0.3926526606082916,
0.432344526052475,
-0.6041237711906433,
-1.0290690660476685,
0.6448582410812378,
-0.1945999264717102,
0.3629697263240814,
0.5660275220870972,
0.8008323907852173,
-0.44111111760139465,
1.0099245309829712,
-0.0757596343755722,
0.03876098617911339,
0.21452993154525757,
-0.17864179611206055,
0.034749943763017654,
-0.6462363004684448,
-0.6834432482719421,
-0.6651989817619324,
-0.6074108481407166,
-0.3272732198238373,
-0.426373153924942,
0.48106926679611206,
-0.07292219251394272,
-0.9342288970947266,
-0.056072015315294266,
-0.14767810702323914,
0.3520715832710266,
0.6537840962409973,
0.10017352551221848,
0.3959108591079712,
-0.4724244475364685,
0.3870665431022644,
0.07894039899110794,
-0.6643622517585754,
-0.3290264904499054,
0.878724992275238,
0.20404596626758575,
0.7156268954277039,
0.4200907051563263,
0.0010278354166075587,
0.37446701526641846,
-0.2915807366371155,
-0.7433046102523804,
0.4936540424823761,
0.14957307279109955,
-0.9331223964691162,
-0.5998391509056091,
-0.5351877808570862,
-1.1478945016860962,
-0.2700297236442566,
-0.3470841348171234,
-0.22819633781909943,
0.16912506520748138,
-0.11784598976373672,
-0.5975009202957153,
0.4304015636444092,
-0.5095492005348206,
0.8757643699645996,
-0.1842297464609146,
-0.014706898480653763,
-0.21159829199314117,
-0.9024397134780884,
0.20009192824363708,
-0.04554162546992302,
-0.2955796420574188,
-0.2562243938446045,
-0.24668730795383453,
0.900901734828949,
-0.258967787027359,
0.4645276963710785,
0.0026475354097783566,
0.3596290647983551,
0.32191503047943115,
0.35850685834884644,
0.23907659947872162,
0.3660832941532135,
0.15010850131511688,
-0.08922012150287628,
0.6719426512718201,
-0.9221577644348145,
-0.6748165488243103,
0.6081591248512268,
-0.917316198348999,
-0.4174629747867584,
-0.4215669631958008,
-0.6004947423934937,
-0.5574155449867249,
0.06914068758487701,
0.10785621404647827,
0.7534140348434448,
-0.2868116497993469,
0.4142184555530548,
0.9402786493301392,
-0.26709309220314026,
0.3391009271144867,
0.4334087669849396,
0.132541224360466,
-0.028525836765766144,
0.5054493546485901,
0.30461961030960083,
0.23457640409469604,
0.8582168817520142,
-0.018936805427074432,
-0.21069461107254028,
-0.3147110044956207,
-0.3323107361793518,
0.16072052717208862,
-0.43974775075912476,
-0.3093653917312622,
-1.1961601972579956,
-0.2962487041950226,
-0.29196876287460327,
0.2711986303329468,
-0.377380907535553,
-0.9963939785957336,
-0.031832076609134674,
-0.033601392060518265,
0.29160016775131226,
0.3890758752822876,
0.35013455152511597,
0.01819574274122715,
-0.8953215479850769,
0.7215843200683594,
0.795822024345398,
0.1805550456047058,
-0.005273615010082722,
-0.30465206503868103,
0.23334434628486633,
-0.13779579102993011,
-0.056734055280685425,
-0.7482848167419434,
-0.19112053513526917,
0.41392967104911804,
0.4726974666118622,
0.14119139313697815,
0.5452976226806641,
0.7131877541542053,
-0.47607916593551636,
0.9229896664619446,
-0.2767731547355652,
-0.910950243473053,
0.47596362233161926,
-0.41125601530075073,
0.8090598583221436,
0.4995562434196472,
0.7794234752655029,
-0.8412067890167236,
-0.39748403429985046,
-0.7045395374298096,
-0.8430401682853699,
0.2842617928981781,
0.2508436143398285,
0.003501980798318982,
0.3631562292575836,
0.6589111089706421,
-0.0776158943772316,
0.27039873600006104,
-0.17321069538593292,
-0.27761292457580566,
0.03560631722211838,
-0.26391860842704773,
0.08102027326822281,
-0.17974218726158142,
-0.2343224138021469,
-0.17825135588645935,
0.3424536883831024,
-0.0989479124546051,
0.14605368673801422,
0.2146577090024948,
-0.11943206191062927,
-0.08899925649166107,
0.45039623975753784,
0.36816972494125366,
0.8853253722190857,
-0.16255611181259155,
0.3943876028060913,
0.35863882303237915,
-0.6518617868423462,
0.0180490855127573,
0.15282082557678223,
-0.08558181673288345,
-0.14943091571331024,
0.5016825795173645,
0.21059828996658325,
-0.17543654143810272,
-1.0161317586898804,
0.3634463846683502,
-0.3814169764518738,
-0.03826604783535004,
-0.659394383430481,
-0.09471309930086136,
0.26798057556152344,
0.5881514549255371,
0.7945439219474792,
-0.15144804120063782,
0.20495916903018951,
-0.7910948991775513,
0.43125075101852417,
0.03131372109055519,
-0.3616064786911011,
-0.31629815697669983,
0.8136247992515564,
-0.007059252355247736,
-0.058426398783922195,
0.7207303047180176,
0.050799597054719925,
-0.6832166314125061,
0.9010463953018188,
0.0710536539554596,
0.39285334944725037,
-0.17274808883666992,
0.1701396107673645,
0.5343177914619446,
0.33134955167770386,
0.06253710389137268,
0.7584304213523865,
-0.06445229053497314,
-0.44132575392723083,
-0.42846235632896423,
-0.5008471012115479,
-0.6497470736503601,
0.14073874056339264,
-0.627763032913208,
-0.006184809375554323,
-0.588218092918396,
-0.07650253921747208,
0.3389829695224762,
0.3417763411998749,
-0.7777723073959351,
0.3173752427101135,
-0.1514449566602707,
1.161736011505127,
-0.7227005958557129,
0.5744574069976807,
0.6348485350608826,
-0.30494430661201477,
-0.846250057220459,
0.16587311029434204,
-0.1446988433599472,
-0.4736056923866272,
0.5884861946105957,
-0.26812034845352173,
-0.06059129163622856,
0.07093369215726852,
-0.9451298117637634,
-0.6656251549720764,
1.225144624710083,
0.18801896274089813,
-0.4770243167877197,
-0.1794450432062149,
0.1722998321056366,
0.5620039105415344,
-0.25201383233070374,
0.00030839527607895434,
0.7139854431152344,
0.5576652884483337,
0.18576683104038239,
-0.9384127855300903,
-0.02044328860938549,
-0.40804019570350647,
-0.6020087003707886,
0.21333761513233185,
-0.6168708801269531,
0.8366019129753113,
-0.1833992600440979,
0.017829906195402145,
0.005009470507502556,
0.6175478100776672,
0.1202065721154213,
0.6029180884361267,
0.5990424156188965,
0.37634196877479553,
0.7929518818855286,
-0.46956759691238403,
0.6963860988616943,
-0.07576898485422134,
0.11745186895132065,
1.3579074144363403,
-0.04779744893312454,
0.913709819316864,
0.33774542808532715,
-0.16075007617473602,
0.15092623233795166,
1.0486377477645874,
0.09709010273218155,
0.07065992802381516,
0.136586993932724,
-0.29532328248023987,
-0.7445033192634583,
-0.3463158905506134,
-0.4152965843677521,
0.5681793689727783,
0.3570544719696045,
0.40901920199394226,
-0.21866407990455627,
0.030054956674575806,
0.1245574802160263,
-0.12485037744045258,
-0.34169483184814453,
0.6669804453849792,
-0.19031651318073273,
-0.5663854479789734,
0.29998597502708435,
-0.30519747734069824,
0.13828442990779877,
-0.6524998545646667,
-0.10389050096273422,
-0.19387121498584747,
0.02094850316643715,
-0.14642874896526337,
-1.3604271411895752,
0.18534962832927704,
-0.02510390430688858,
-0.20079009234905243,
0.2886951267719269,
0.08615097403526306,
-0.6175967454910278,
-0.2789440155029297,
0.034675609320402145,
0.6643662452697754,
-0.0008952390635386109,
-0.40748482942581177,
-0.7481898665428162,
-0.3216564953327179,
-0.44454315304756165,
-0.31938210129737854,
0.07722260057926178,
0.8721967339515686,
-0.28623270988464355,
1.0106587409973145,
0.514274537563324,
0.03998297080397606,
0.23662221431732178,
0.03885470703244209,
0.8143059611320496,
-0.7155511379241943,
-0.29924634099006653,
-0.4068252742290497,
0.32272791862487793,
-0.06545708328485489,
-0.4777841866016388,
0.44574493169784546,
0.8558050394058228,
0.8154913783073425,
0.06744956225156784,
0.5657048225402832,
-0.23512671887874603,
0.6732791662216187,
-0.32946598529815674,
0.5072129368782043,
-0.6971638798713684,
0.0371951088309288,
-0.1340201050043106,
-0.9811550378799438,
-0.5355215668678284,
-0.19807688891887665,
-0.07691926509141922,
-0.36419621109962463,
0.34917640686035156,
0.6084551811218262,
-0.08388028293848038,
-0.2332577109336853,
0.12783849239349365,
0.37838438153266907,
0.6663469076156616,
0.8447399139404297,
1.1751611232757568,
-0.4226141571998596,
0.9007413983345032,
-0.10054095089435577,
-0.3486071228981018,
-0.10133513063192368,
-0.45968252420425415,
-0.6427369117736816,
-1.0976334810256958,
-0.2666267454624176,
-0.3821382224559784,
-0.03543650731444359,
1.2524701356887817,
0.4272359311580658,
-0.9761859774589539,
0.031340256333351135,
0.6010979413986206,
-0.018782420083880424,
-0.3705185353755951,
-0.21795442700386047,
0.4518885314464569,
-0.004314035177230835,
-0.9319981932640076,
-0.07349400967359543,
0.3271176517009735,
-0.023085376247763634,
-0.17273645102977753,
0.29770785570144653,
-0.5246944427490234,
0.07875438779592514,
0.8357359766960144,
0.5242934823036194,
-0.37907540798187256,
-0.2735596299171448,
0.5017140507698059,
-0.12096749246120453,
-0.15214835107326508,
0.932884693145752,
-0.2966500520706177,
0.413979172706604,
0.9016147255897522,
0.9499260187149048,
0.7107788920402527,
0.03526637703180313,
0.5346376895904541,
-0.4472244679927826,
0.025422140955924988,
0.6533610820770264,
-0.005869877524673939,
0.009670556522905827,
-0.3604514002799988,
0.5970746278762817,
-0.060560502111911774,
-0.5724861025810242,
-0.7664602994918823,
0.39929139614105225,
-1.5967777967453003,
-0.5172646641731262,
0.8895542025566101,
0.05562511458992958,
-0.0795067623257637,
-0.7333428859710693,
-0.18764638900756836,
0.38034868240356445,
-0.16062845289707184,
0.8904699683189392,
0.5467475056648254,
-0.2995947003364563,
-0.10282019525766373,
-0.5959640145301819,
0.45702821016311646,
0.22814463078975677,
-0.9933419823646545,
0.04859089478850365,
0.3222256302833557,
0.27980533242225647,
0.13648350536823273,
0.2522939443588257,
-0.17480044066905975,
0.5754705667495728,
-0.25959235429763794,
-0.11572154611349106,
0.011383756063878536,
-0.5895737409591675,
0.012465809471905231,
0.7027717232704163,
-0.0340321809053421,
-0.11310398578643799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04855v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04855v1
|
The Russian Legislative Corpus
| 2024-06-07T11:38:12 | 2024-06-07T11:38:12 |
Denis Saveliev, Ruslan Kuchakov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the comprehensive Russian primary and secondary legislation corpus
covering 1991 to 2023. The corpus collects all 281,413 texts (176,523,268
tokens) of non-secret federal regulations and acts, along with their metadata.
The corpus has two versions the original text with minimal preprocessing and a
version prepared for linguistic analysis with morphosyntactic markup.
|
[
0.07961180061101913,
-0.5358141660690308,
0.5875556468963623,
0.19930745661258698,
-0.6013568043708801,
-0.20235826075077057,
0.026819409802556038,
-0.14863307774066925,
0.4345850348472595,
0.9978140592575073,
-0.16406381130218506,
-0.6939324736595154,
-0.3918550908565521,
0.1117965579032898,
-0.6052706241607666,
1.2831467390060425,
0.41195186972618103,
-0.03961300104856491,
-0.03093484416604042,
0.12450152635574341,
-0.3754946291446686,
-0.6915579438209534,
0.0901593267917633,
-0.06472060084342957,
0.7410054802894592,
0.5032938122749329,
0.39444369077682495,
0.7134197950363159,
0.6267874836921692,
0.38313454389572144,
-0.016337817534804344,
-0.4082198739051819,
-0.029276985675096512,
-0.11261679977178574,
-0.2907784879207611,
-0.4923058748245239,
-0.5447704195976257,
-0.3125859498977661,
1.2543871402740479,
0.20320111513137817,
-0.2335609495639801,
0.22287805378437042,
-0.16253642737865448,
0.6508612632751465,
-0.6537272334098816,
0.5574434399604797,
-0.5056698322296143,
-0.30077075958251953,
-0.7998566627502441,
-0.24016323685646057,
-0.6919273138046265,
-0.1919700801372528,
-0.01850094087421894,
-0.6214423179626465,
-0.1574535369873047,
-0.08228924125432968,
0.9512720108032227,
0.06518006324768066,
-0.8941221833229065,
-0.253300279378891,
-0.052370499819517136,
0.6918596029281616,
-0.23650449514389038,
0.2679325044155121,
0.8501256108283997,
0.13432496786117554,
-0.33834704756736755,
-1.5371037721633911,
-0.108497753739357,
-0.22207602858543396,
-0.499522864818573,
-0.04415880888700485,
-0.5064293146133423,
0.1632806807756424,
0.08583544194698334,
0.363383412361145,
-0.6835817098617554,
-0.1117168515920639,
-0.7190729975700378,
-0.7456046938896179,
0.43744370341300964,
0.3328278958797455,
0.28155606985092163,
-0.5231199860572815,
-0.15837612748146057,
-0.025654349476099014,
-0.5715304613113403,
-0.13611482083797455,
0.8388829827308655,
0.1993284374475479,
-0.2687305510044098,
0.7466104626655579,
-0.4521762728691101,
0.712859570980072,
-0.24633048474788666,
-0.27530017495155334,
0.28922849893569946,
-0.9822977185249329,
-0.5809376239776611,
-0.3580019772052765,
0.9463091492652893,
-0.10359599441289902,
-0.28063035011291504,
-0.21550853550434113,
-0.23358628153800964,
-0.19934406876564026,
0.5884981751441956,
-0.43051689863204956,
-0.20374159514904022,
0.304989218711853,
-0.4799693822860718,
-0.25134557485580444,
0.06748181581497192,
-0.9810577034950256,
-0.5489427447319031,
-0.7148919701576233,
0.10497769713401794,
-0.673429548740387,
-0.3031230568885803,
-0.02925247512757778,
-0.3695128560066223,
0.2883220613002777,
0.1859014928340912,
-0.8875345587730408,
0.5069760084152222,
1.1472829580307007,
0.80401611328125,
0.1668596863746643,
0.05081481114029884,
-0.5356593728065491,
-0.35994791984558105,
-0.3722265064716339,
1.0662325620651245,
-0.6744584441184998,
-0.3190872073173523,
0.29711195826530457,
0.5933266282081604,
0.07238830626010895,
-0.26229140162467957,
0.5268844366073608,
-0.7220954895019531,
0.0013868390815332532,
-0.08676465600728989,
-0.1163197010755539,
-0.2642919719219208,
-0.06749626994132996,
-0.7727610468864441,
0.5525991320610046,
0.178304061293602,
-0.5049371123313904,
0.4927784204483032,
-0.680633544921875,
-0.6112520098686218,
0.5019446611404419,
-0.14805898070335388,
-0.17112842202186584,
-0.03453230485320091,
-0.5367794036865234,
0.07540614902973175,
-0.0378628745675087,
0.5515952706336975,
0.1424940526485443,
-0.1916092336177826,
0.1045926958322525,
0.10410838574171066,
1.1360608339309692,
0.6567633748054504,
-0.06432078033685684,
0.8944287300109863,
-0.5332508683204651,
0.02995021641254425,
-0.6913084983825684,
-0.6295254826545715,
0.02817392908036709,
-0.2257675975561142,
0.577057421207428,
0.09355676919221878,
0.48797234892845154,
-0.3868565559387207,
0.08395872265100479,
-0.3783183991909027,
0.5253682136535645,
0.5039101243019104,
0.22540269792079926,
0.6454339027404785,
-0.6764547228813171,
0.6488100290298462,
0.0657690092921257,
0.042380981147289276,
-0.45727774500846863,
-0.6755949258804321,
-0.5981361269950867,
-0.4507470428943634,
0.7940630912780762,
0.5833972692489624,
-0.6047241687774658,
0.5709707736968994,
-0.42424681782722473,
-0.5762967467308044,
-0.2378123253583908,
-0.3316395878791809,
0.4171980023384094,
-0.19134396314620972,
-0.08420514315366745,
0.027095776051282883,
-0.8787233233451843,
-1.1617155075073242,
-0.18855515122413635,
-0.2930258512496948,
0.33029428124427795,
-0.25459930300712585,
1.3019524812698364,
0.10940966010093689,
0.7603793144226074,
-0.037591587752103806,
-0.5233896970748901,
0.09729685634374619,
0.4271772503852844,
0.16881497204303741,
0.4050993323326111,
0.44673866033554077,
-0.5614203810691833,
-0.6624157428741455,
0.3917330205440521,
-0.20894695818424225,
0.13729722797870636,
-0.2265656292438507,
-0.2074916660785675,
0.6286328434944153,
0.24247272312641144,
-0.6003351211547852,
0.35396304726600647,
0.08662552386522293,
-0.8923825621604919,
0.4634314775466919,
-0.14259813725948334,
0.1013244092464447,
-1.0343822240829468,
0.6450239419937134,
-0.4391220211982727,
-0.36976009607315063,
-0.865528404712677,
0.3648624122142792,
0.35163044929504395,
0.0885254517197609,
-0.6509414315223694,
0.5320722460746765,
-0.5710547566413879,
0.08850729465484619,
-0.1663079708814621,
-0.2818150520324707,
-0.3052704334259033,
0.18665634095668793,
0.013342165388166904,
0.778938889503479,
0.7607727646827698,
-0.4200059771537781,
0.6750102639198303,
0.30105847120285034,
-0.8120620846748352,
0.2832273840904236,
-0.04878772050142288,
0.23623307049274445,
-0.1779705286026001,
0.14280755817890167,
-0.6441749334335327,
-0.5507480502128601,
0.43472394347190857,
-0.34305548667907715,
0.5270990133285522,
-0.3401274085044861,
-0.9643368721008301,
0.062127452343702316,
-0.08652908354997635,
-0.21832884848117828,
0.6658143997192383,
0.23071697354316711,
0.3046225309371948,
1.0687177181243896,
-0.27849283814430237,
-0.967326283454895,
-0.747042715549469,
0.5008360147476196,
0.0030385199934244156,
-0.4618772864341736,
0.17147788405418396,
0.34662798047065735,
-0.5051197409629822,
0.39176106452941895,
0.3049772083759308,
-0.481252521276474,
-0.37855541706085205,
0.3322429955005646,
0.12171290069818497,
-0.35554203391075134,
0.13870830833911896,
-0.14275279641151428,
0.12756824493408203,
-0.09265980869531631,
-0.13147321343421936,
0.7627264261245728,
-0.39095667004585266,
0.2556557357311249,
-0.6819592118263245,
0.50330650806427,
0.8726087808609009,
0.10906825959682465,
0.5919879078865051,
0.31815874576568604,
-0.257941335439682,
0.15611149370670319,
-0.49277791380882263,
0.1532709151506424,
-0.4485355317592621,
0.3051144480705261,
-0.5588809251785278,
-0.6868748664855957,
0.48969918489456177,
0.5419211983680725,
0.16518498957157135,
0.5163894295692444,
0.7606973052024841,
0.5318724513053894,
0.12047229707241058,
0.2065078318119049,
0.14583973586559296,
0.44263309240341187,
0.11723329871892929,
-0.34778741002082825,
-0.3216433823108673,
-0.75013267993927,
-0.6899962425231934,
-0.06138766556978226,
-0.6913620829582214,
-0.315165638923645,
-0.302111953496933,
-0.5415244102478027,
-0.018339063972234726,
0.6753545999526978,
-0.4718036949634552,
0.5382785201072693,
0.8452534079551697,
-0.2178519070148468,
0.11898903548717499,
0.30482155084609985,
-0.036413297057151794,
-0.02494284138083458,
-0.049736153334379196,
-0.656524121761322,
1.2049795389175415,
0.14214745163917542,
0.3385830521583557,
0.29117920994758606,
0.6790153384208679,
0.45060601830482483,
0.3841300308704376,
-0.9737221002578735,
0.6683242917060852,
-0.16883665323257446,
-1.3995126485824585,
-0.28894004225730896,
-0.3885451555252075,
-1.0832855701446533,
0.25210145115852356,
-0.21898993849754333,
-0.7694834470748901,
0.3489113748073578,
-0.213356614112854,
-0.4529859721660614,
0.051135461777448654,
-0.6031924486160278,
0.7781556844711304,
0.3603571653366089,
-0.2658002972602844,
-0.3803934156894684,
-0.585175633430481,
0.4196711480617523,
-0.3172169029712677,
-0.04605966433882713,
-0.07936417311429977,
-0.5139868855476379,
1.0494745969772339,
-0.37937211990356445,
0.6711836457252502,
-0.07485656440258026,
0.2491210252046585,
0.7008541822433472,
-0.18791718780994415,
0.3246822655200958,
0.11443663388490677,
0.04748229309916496,
-0.08077777922153473,
0.7290574908256531,
-0.28866446018218994,
0.09296797960996628,
0.7016909122467041,
-0.4173101782798767,
-0.4854501187801361,
-1.2100847959518433,
-0.3573439121246338,
0.4673788249492645,
0.6942914724349976,
0.37719643115997314,
0.7000764608383179,
-0.3922920525074005,
0.8573194742202759,
-0.17960071563720703,
0.02398960292339325,
0.4315933883190155,
0.8751946687698364,
-0.20836284756660461,
-0.7980875372886658,
0.7501872181892395,
0.36110252141952515,
-0.40931087732315063,
0.6505334973335266,
-0.14817766845226288,
-0.6623174548149109,
-0.5336817502975464,
-0.1168292835354805,
0.33902478218078613,
-0.843657374382019,
-0.43548583984375,
-0.8315241932868958,
-0.14320218563079834,
-0.8826640248298645,
0.503720760345459,
0.1669924259185791,
-0.5056763887405396,
-0.5697697401046753,
0.06993179023265839,
0.35280153155326843,
0.9837789535522461,
-0.34723207354545593,
0.5493947267532349,
-0.5248934626579285,
0.15960147976875305,
0.07395043224096298,
0.57459557056427,
-0.7575501799583435,
-0.6892037391662598,
-0.04133269190788269,
-0.2405121624469757,
-0.3032931387424469,
-0.8979148268699646,
0.49233895540237427,
0.08223207294940948,
0.32478517293930054,
0.29825839400291443,
-0.02580108866095543,
0.5479872822761536,
-0.5900665521621704,
0.9035895466804504,
0.29007866978645325,
-0.9022475481033325,
0.1392512023448944,
-0.6577102541923523,
0.3086496591567993,
0.48887181282043457,
0.020995773375034332,
-0.41657277941703796,
-0.18879428505897522,
-0.6305549740791321,
-0.38497301936149597,
1.1213274002075195,
0.3016299605369568,
0.48315367102622986,
-0.0004399782046675682,
0.18349459767341614,
0.0630369484424591,
-0.011014364659786224,
-0.39146187901496887,
-0.11880587786436081,
-0.10667832940816879,
-0.19401265680789948,
0.48355481028556824,
-0.4085322916507721,
-0.3658255338668823,
-0.1801208108663559,
0.5233226418495178,
0.13496428728103638,
0.36500516533851624,
-0.08090730756521225,
0.14507827162742615,
0.02593296766281128,
0.7382041811943054,
1.2063028812408447,
0.946220338344574,
0.0031795899849385023,
0.22343593835830688,
0.0654372051358223,
-1.054761290550232,
0.06888594478368759,
-0.22477316856384277,
0.00379473646171391,
0.2676084637641907,
0.3757855296134949,
0.6396204233169556,
0.07539909332990646,
-0.664191484451294,
0.7022767663002014,
0.1239556148648262,
-0.6915754079818726,
-0.9611842036247253,
-0.24590972065925598,
0.16683520376682281,
-0.11829967796802521,
0.4171695113182068,
0.04109662398695946,
0.3046707808971405,
-0.7942021489143372,
0.8817451000213623,
0.3547634780406952,
-0.7377731204032898,
-0.5848819017410278,
0.22599272429943085,
-0.02888374775648117,
-0.16716235876083374,
0.3815075159072876,
-0.1298144906759262,
0.10679761320352554,
0.6476819515228271,
0.4852517545223236,
0.7285963296890259,
-0.04053257778286934,
0.584030270576477,
0.42361220717430115,
0.5035943388938904,
-0.15137462317943573,
0.681977391242981,
0.19363585114479065,
0.014020418748259544,
-0.6314124464988708,
-0.959178626537323,
-0.21647043526172638,
0.6685075759887695,
-0.40909308195114136,
0.6009510159492493,
-0.5928614735603333,
-0.652549147605896,
0.19606584310531616,
0.035562723875045776,
-0.2945927083492279,
-0.07015936821699142,
0.20848098397254944,
1.008192539215088,
-0.41020315885543823,
1.0721617937088013,
0.8278248310089111,
-0.25028812885284424,
0.0395934134721756,
-0.5440834760665894,
0.21722692251205444,
-0.6024400591850281,
0.8532511591911316,
-0.16123974323272705,
0.17492325603961945,
-0.17900775372982025,
-0.3822302222251892,
-0.9926413893699646,
0.7357603907585144,
0.26358652114868164,
-0.35157153010368347,
-0.11631067097187042,
0.23718945682048798,
0.46436774730682373,
-0.11463923752307892,
-0.0943758487701416,
0.6793558597564697,
1.0139240026474,
-0.03572852537035942,
-1.1086801290512085,
0.055089522153139114,
-0.6695084571838379,
-0.6357362866401672,
0.492549329996109,
-0.43615472316741943,
0.8570171594619751,
0.24714608490467072,
-0.9896599650382996,
0.4514857232570648,
0.4586709141731262,
-0.2683546245098114,
0.03975314646959305,
0.1569928526878357,
0.3477958142757416,
0.6818453073501587,
-0.3708980679512024,
0.8048833012580872,
-0.2866300940513611,
0.008002075366675854,
0.860413670539856,
-0.05283751338720322,
0.7350581884384155,
0.5776719450950623,
-0.23509106040000916,
0.4475104808807373,
0.5377886295318604,
-0.2287382334470749,
0.6217358112335205,
0.17186330258846283,
-0.16520439088344574,
-0.09691226482391357,
-0.36335575580596924,
-0.3405567407608032,
0.6713725924491882,
0.415798544883728,
-0.4298974871635437,
-0.0989537388086319,
-0.2672768533229828,
0.15347492694854736,
-0.17474040389060974,
-0.18643787503242493,
1.0153226852416992,
0.25142306089401245,
-1.0183348655700684,
0.27286168932914734,
0.08404569327831268,
0.0653049424290657,
-0.6966871023178101,
-0.04599766433238983,
0.12508344650268555,
0.13378532230854034,
-0.20478826761245728,
-1.1822171211242676,
0.7295483350753784,
0.05851517990231514,
0.20493637025356293,
-0.43800193071365356,
0.6776366829872131,
-0.30762845277786255,
-0.1795756071805954,
-0.05904443934559822,
0.03904500976204872,
0.35020631551742554,
-0.05381741002202034,
-0.3802623450756073,
-0.11061924695968628,
-0.28496527671813965,
-0.23863592743873596,
0.3916402757167816,
0.2621040344238281,
0.051550086587667465,
0.26040634512901306,
0.7646599411964417,
0.2762860655784607,
0.21633635461330414,
-0.4433344304561615,
0.6591193675994873,
-0.8730811476707458,
-0.8375539779663086,
-0.7596908807754517,
0.7393574118614197,
-0.14684875309467316,
-0.7267240285873413,
0.3623594343662262,
0.820487380027771,
-0.005705801770091057,
-0.3628077507019043,
0.7184047698974609,
-0.3667047321796417,
0.11545165628194809,
-0.5133793950080872,
1.151138186454773,
-0.4029189348220825,
-0.46307533979415894,
0.40954428911209106,
-0.5859989523887634,
-0.6869435906410217,
-0.013908377848565578,
-0.16745667159557343,
-0.6059523224830627,
0.9148615002632141,
0.7089504599571228,
0.14531010389328003,
0.0792497992515564,
0.5690426826477051,
-0.019886087626218796,
-0.21121349930763245,
0.30028262734413147,
0.8757102489471436,
-0.17684714496135712,
1.0349749326705933,
-0.23257488012313843,
0.06743742525577545,
-0.401048868894577,
-0.46433818340301514,
-0.7518761157989502,
-1.0450814962387085,
-0.11637412756681442,
-0.4508728086948395,
-0.07895933091640472,
0.6212950944900513,
0.6671316027641296,
-1.1356223821640015,
-0.4888996183872223,
-0.14345116913318634,
-0.07856198400259018,
0.37186485528945923,
-0.22246848046779633,
0.3034415543079376,
-0.616708517074585,
-0.6663720011711121,
0.5228090882301331,
0.43860894441604614,
-0.1887553483247757,
0.05894014239311218,
0.06876206398010254,
-0.2160836160182953,
0.10810661315917969,
0.5122947096824646,
0.24804766476154327,
-1.0550123453140259,
-0.26141470670700073,
0.16280615329742432,
-0.4880277216434479,
-0.03946130722761154,
1.0112330913543701,
-0.1672118902206421,
0.46955734491348267,
1.3938652276992798,
0.003376137698069215,
0.45281702280044556,
-0.006777242757380009,
0.42284634709358215,
-0.6479073762893677,
0.548848032951355,
0.30168330669403076,
0.5448682308197021,
-0.07129703462123871,
-0.14876799285411835,
0.5175062417984009,
0.22529742121696472,
-0.5871580243110657,
-0.894122838973999,
0.21807582676410675,
-1.0944974422454834,
-0.32540884613990784,
1.2042449712753296,
-0.16622677445411682,
-0.6190367341041565,
-0.8575453758239746,
-0.23080487549304962,
0.11791668087244034,
-0.7324046492576599,
0.21245937049388885,
1.076624870300293,
0.31734737753868103,
-0.1804247498512268,
-0.7265421748161316,
0.7774912714958191,
0.09391163289546967,
-0.7902122735977173,
-0.044646088033914566,
0.6401928663253784,
0.2489575296640396,
0.48032480478286743,
1.0161304473876953,
-0.6480206251144409,
0.43297287821769714,
0.6675905585289001,
-0.22348961234092712,
0.06858640164136887,
-0.6625624299049377,
-0.508811354637146,
0.34784719347953796,
-0.5114977359771729,
-0.05037253350019455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04854v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04854v1
|
Uncertainty Aware Learning for Language Model Alignment
| 2024-06-07T11:37:45 | 2024-06-07T11:37:45 |
Yikun Wang, Rui Zheng, Liang Ding, Qi Zhang, Dahua Lin, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs) evolve, aligning pretrained
foundation models presents increasing challenges. Existing alignment
strategies, which typically leverage diverse and high-quality data sources,
often overlook the intrinsic uncertainty of tasks, learning all data samples
equally. This may lead to suboptimal data efficiency and model performance. In
response, we propose uncertainty-aware learning (UAL) to improve the model
alignment of different task scenarios, by introducing the sample uncertainty
(elicited from more capable LLMs). We implement UAL in a simple fashion --
adaptively setting the label smoothing value of training according to the
uncertainty of individual samples. Analysis shows that our UAL indeed
facilitates better token clustering in the feature space, validating our
hypothesis. Extensive experiments on widely used benchmarks demonstrate that
our UAL significantly and consistently outperforms standard supervised
fine-tuning. Notably, LLMs aligned in a mixed scenario have achieved an average
improvement of 10.62\% on high-entropy tasks (i.e., AlpacaEval leaderboard),
and 1.81\% on complex low-entropy tasks (i.e., MetaMath and GSM8K).
|
[
0.010461737401783466,
-0.7169468998908997,
0.46954724192619324,
-0.1857191026210785,
-0.0896887555718422,
0.3770805895328522,
-0.365940660238266,
-0.3979627192020416,
-0.14703015983104706,
0.21338847279548645,
-0.5132603049278259,
-0.6784884333610535,
-0.6268743276596069,
-0.34380730986595154,
-0.39694181084632874,
0.7819871306419373,
-0.1115056723356247,
-0.048055581748485565,
-0.23310518264770508,
-0.05355512723326683,
-0.2772355377674103,
-0.21881185472011566,
-0.6295434832572937,
-0.11705170571804047,
0.4590284526348114,
0.4743385910987854,
0.8636553883552551,
1.1116917133331299,
0.4610711932182312,
0.331158310174942,
0.0802575945854187,
0.13842801749706268,
-0.33667129278182983,
0.28643327951431274,
-0.12741537392139435,
-0.5590535998344421,
-0.5232111215591431,
-0.16818860173225403,
0.7030609846115112,
0.750272810459137,
-0.5560773015022278,
0.0915837362408638,
0.3523848056793213,
0.5254755020141602,
-0.8310218453407288,
-0.06928502768278122,
-0.8961268067359924,
0.011604569852352142,
-0.39306944608688354,
0.09568506479263306,
-0.2029225081205368,
-0.1248495876789093,
0.02254411391913891,
-0.8730656504631042,
0.13516683876514435,
0.30354538559913635,
0.8746044039726257,
0.817986786365509,
-0.2256503403186798,
-0.22332464158535004,
-0.6590636968612671,
0.7640783190727234,
-0.655326247215271,
0.8093540668487549,
0.3573167324066162,
0.1413998007774353,
-0.3193912208080292,
-0.4529040455818176,
-0.3726619482040405,
0.37638846039772034,
0.32738226652145386,
0.04631317779421806,
-0.015238468535244465,
0.14793799817562103,
-0.08260468393564224,
0.23462891578674316,
-0.5223122239112854,
0.6564677953720093,
0.004746758379042149,
-0.505390465259552,
0.400556355714798,
-0.03990994393825531,
-0.14322441816329956,
0.44016972184181213,
-0.23635978996753693,
-0.1507371962070465,
-0.6636332273483276,
0.21895325183868408,
0.4360491633415222,
0.6970956325531006,
-0.08216336369514465,
0.36291423439979553,
-0.23674103617668152,
0.9102991223335266,
0.31652581691741943,
-0.2812559902667999,
0.2728234529495239,
-0.06817050278186798,
-0.38214534521102905,
0.20317484438419342,
0.5972104072570801,
-0.062011174857616425,
0.007472198456525803,
-0.04048879072070122,
-0.31357139348983765,
-0.19955094158649445,
0.3028029799461365,
-0.44716042280197144,
-0.2006155401468277,
0.3657910227775574,
0.07766193896532059,
-0.2042158544063568,
0.08795115351676941,
-0.41848331689834595,
-0.513352632522583,
-0.4547611474990845,
0.5477269291877747,
-0.3472370207309723,
-0.0638812929391861,
0.19879019260406494,
0.4494447708129883,
0.056462280452251434,
0.4865442216396332,
-1.027849555015564,
0.07717767357826233,
0.6952452063560486,
0.4012511074542999,
-0.34449145197868347,
-0.32730427384376526,
-0.6075912714004517,
0.18967793881893158,
-0.5174088478088379,
0.5680718421936035,
-0.45391497015953064,
-0.099130779504776,
-0.04372571408748627,
-0.3237823247909546,
-0.1609674096107483,
-0.44617322087287903,
0.3666864335536957,
-0.43917232751846313,
0.0264030359685421,
-0.16665564477443695,
-0.6595736742019653,
0.10356234014034271,
0.10970810055732727,
-0.3124100863933563,
1.4069536924362183,
0.19064085185527802,
-0.568082332611084,
0.6275727152824402,
-0.2231699526309967,
-0.344495952129364,
-0.26095953583717346,
-0.27877986431121826,
-0.6180925965309143,
0.09553434699773788,
0.35599130392074585,
0.5759833455085754,
-0.01371084526181221,
0.4247620403766632,
-0.40426748991012573,
-0.30888471007347107,
0.272312730550766,
-0.5532171130180359,
0.4422993063926697,
0.33131101727485657,
-0.3670298159122467,
0.30343273282051086,
-0.5977548360824585,
0.1318638026714325,
-0.28608882427215576,
-0.3157546818256378,
-0.1939951628446579,
-0.04973265528678894,
-0.27806738018989563,
0.13323356211185455,
0.4150324761867523,
-0.2478877156972885,
0.13916610181331635,
-0.3541851341724396,
-0.0499129481613636,
1.1177157163619995,
-0.31938648223876953,
0.6399545669555664,
-0.16207793354988098,
0.5464998483657837,
0.21416428685188293,
0.2635177671909332,
0.2447020709514618,
-0.2170984447002411,
-0.9714504480361938,
-0.4068935215473175,
0.6859907507896423,
0.5832971334457397,
-0.405154287815094,
0.594468891620636,
-0.31231629848480225,
-0.3826652765274048,
-0.9516670107841492,
0.5339949131011963,
0.4439966678619385,
0.698735773563385,
0.3440137207508087,
-0.2365313619375229,
-0.43714118003845215,
-0.5455399751663208,
-0.1461726725101471,
-0.11431285738945007,
0.11301866173744202,
0.1695706695318222,
0.13303828239440918,
-0.0903087854385376,
1.0174635648727417,
-0.3221319019794464,
-0.13320010900497437,
0.17316865921020508,
0.16756552457809448,
-0.030200419947504997,
0.6492807865142822,
0.14958268404006958,
-0.7566605806350708,
-0.5190895795822144,
0.2370610237121582,
-0.4354919195175171,
-0.01174178533256054,
0.0023116618394851685,
-0.27540111541748047,
0.37435799837112427,
0.5859473943710327,
-0.49313148856163025,
0.27623891830444336,
0.6516852378845215,
-0.082110695540905,
0.21191170811653137,
-0.20737409591674805,
-0.011929291300475597,
-1.3195836544036865,
-0.21190835535526276,
-0.16711723804473877,
-0.32215604186058044,
-0.44890469312667847,
-0.18157096207141876,
0.22814956307411194,
0.19645880162715912,
-0.3583744466304779,
0.41259679198265076,
-0.49535343050956726,
-0.19381321966648102,
-0.13773387670516968,
-0.06349436938762665,
-0.16938099265098572,
0.21647532284259796,
0.11250688135623932,
0.8037924766540527,
0.9284526109695435,
-0.6026485562324524,
-0.03672568127512932,
-0.055888622999191284,
-0.5570034384727478,
0.44194695353507996,
-0.10995864868164062,
0.19439515471458435,
0.01502213068306446,
-0.06921157240867615,
-0.8777225613594055,
-0.4105806052684784,
0.22122198343276978,
-0.3356114327907562,
0.7590014338493347,
0.12318059056997299,
-0.18450500071048737,
-0.1177334189414978,
0.1110297217965126,
0.31429243087768555,
0.41697442531585693,
-0.39527222514152527,
0.7077713012695312,
0.17391225695610046,
-0.10714572668075562,
-1.302006483078003,
-0.4547329843044281,
-0.22437907755374908,
-0.3470781445503235,
-0.06821727752685547,
0.2990429699420929,
-0.08834586292505264,
-0.17129598557949066,
0.07087017595767975,
-0.5901119112968445,
-0.22315073013305664,
0.5133368372917175,
0.23874729871749878,
-0.001873508095741272,
-0.26858824491500854,
0.4135643243789673,
0.11318910866975784,
0.011796069331467152,
-0.4542221426963806,
-0.5729706883430481,
0.3600534200668335,
-0.18906235694885254,
-0.7501527667045593,
-0.3127717077732086,
-0.01015380583703518,
0.22620779275894165,
-0.2428743839263916,
0.6067372560501099,
0.8207714557647705,
-0.5481064319610596,
-0.15567179024219513,
-0.6445586085319519,
-0.001026516780257225,
-0.5304466485977173,
0.4106445610523224,
-0.32009780406951904,
-1.272687315940857,
0.510931134223938,
0.06876961886882782,
0.009996580891311169,
0.3366224467754364,
0.47960883378982544,
-0.5122894644737244,
0.8791069984436035,
1.0031436681747437,
-0.36464959383010864,
0.4630799889564514,
0.2540901005268097,
0.2251683920621872,
-0.5436661243438721,
-0.03732728585600853,
-0.5508532524108887,
-0.3354794979095459,
-0.35172218084335327,
-0.6190595626831055,
0.040107160806655884,
0.3616117537021637,
-0.4034009873867035,
0.17181357741355896,
-0.32441529631614685,
0.3376118540763855,
0.571885883808136,
0.13535752892494202,
0.116195447742939,
-0.0841183066368103,
-0.05909701809287071,
0.06465153396129608,
-0.8439209461212158,
-0.2491758167743683,
1.177201509475708,
0.2871192395687103,
0.9982535243034363,
0.03218144550919533,
0.8694040775299072,
0.03725755214691162,
0.2169778198003769,
-0.5647479891777039,
0.1392936110496521,
0.05160094052553177,
-0.5733603835105896,
-0.5880394577980042,
-0.43368834257125854,
-0.896720826625824,
-0.041409946978092194,
-0.48753127455711365,
-0.9903711676597595,
0.2716177999973297,
0.4805515706539154,
-0.7069633603096008,
0.2376474291086197,
-0.5050610303878784,
0.8079875707626343,
-0.4670357406139374,
-0.10486799478530884,
0.03971245884895325,
-0.8024941086769104,
-0.0031962934881448746,
-0.4945773482322693,
0.42772045731544495,
-0.22373135387897491,
-0.15941385924816132,
0.4682027995586395,
-0.1374032348394394,
1.015383243560791,
-0.049390509724617004,
-0.26521679759025574,
0.1414775401353836,
-0.04200839623808861,
0.5563735961914062,
-0.18931706249713898,
-0.17660807073116302,
-0.04584633931517601,
-0.2294532060623169,
-0.403867244720459,
-0.6316627264022827,
0.5351448059082031,
-0.6914836168289185,
-0.7137406468391418,
-0.28943151235580444,
-1.079302191734314,
-0.4805695414543152,
0.1933484971523285,
0.3458164632320404,
0.07245118916034698,
0.05716870725154877,
0.12874835729599,
0.9607295393943787,
0.14644969999790192,
0.24677324295043945,
0.503873348236084,
-0.07080446183681488,
-0.08707321435213089,
0.8795051574707031,
0.1371196061372757,
0.3882655203342438,
0.7283341884613037,
0.05058836564421654,
-0.31036171317100525,
-0.9334745407104492,
-0.20197159051895142,
-0.2995702028274536,
-0.6023442149162292,
-0.42481911182403564,
-0.4965982735157013,
-0.0704350471496582,
-0.6743491291999817,
-0.35907337069511414,
-0.6125944256782532,
-0.39532893896102905,
-0.519572377204895,
-0.27346473932266235,
0.3774382174015045,
0.5060843825340271,
-0.05572914332151413,
0.7436311841011047,
-0.5061745047569275,
-0.1797046959400177,
0.2425723671913147,
0.4711284935474396,
-0.328886479139328,
-0.7205401062965393,
-0.4193074703216553,
0.2679840922355652,
-0.1242242157459259,
-0.37042686343193054,
0.06868021190166473,
0.531895101070404,
0.6380221843719482,
0.6710219979286194,
0.011666681617498398,
1.0222907066345215,
-0.30332711338996887,
0.4814964532852173,
-0.06821159273386002,
-1.0010910034179688,
0.46981844305992126,
-0.31315359473228455,
0.29210275411605835,
0.8049747347831726,
0.36203449964523315,
-0.19936607778072357,
-0.5975762009620667,
-0.6332003474235535,
-0.7578308582305908,
0.41378605365753174,
-0.042014360427856445,
-0.10364934802055359,
0.3694792687892914,
0.5792424082756042,
0.1009618267416954,
0.374137818813324,
-0.6537338495254517,
-0.17776213586330414,
0.08493848890066147,
-0.8634523749351501,
-0.3148357570171356,
-0.06442029029130936,
-0.05114436522126198,
-0.28533440828323364,
0.8710903525352478,
-0.36712679266929626,
0.0040758028626441956,
-0.19819751381874084,
-0.22815603017807007,
-0.31691598892211914,
0.292947381734848,
0.5454645752906799,
0.5680984854698181,
-0.24197134375572205,
0.14776566624641418,
0.348309725522995,
-0.27675843238830566,
0.2539044916629791,
0.26363351941108704,
0.006392371375113726,
-0.4398290514945984,
0.35824885964393616,
0.8005954623222351,
0.3520774245262146,
-0.6681031584739685,
0.28628620505332947,
0.0960412472486496,
-0.07414288818836212,
0.048971839249134064,
0.24035945534706116,
0.20227520167827606,
0.3608482778072357,
0.2884060740470886,
0.21142257750034332,
-0.04420439898967743,
-0.26853540539741516,
0.4141784906387329,
0.5753421187400818,
-0.671760618686676,
-0.07730954885482788,
0.6086898446083069,
-0.17014503479003906,
-0.15531811118125916,
0.5290161371231079,
-0.06946305930614471,
-0.37782639265060425,
0.45983806252479553,
0.5699121952056885,
0.5059478282928467,
-0.7383861541748047,
-0.004744152072817087,
0.011887451633810997,
0.3700706660747528,
-0.20601165294647217,
0.23410716652870178,
-0.0721663311123848,
-1.1352410316467285,
-0.4146696925163269,
-0.8089737892150879,
-0.38328489661216736,
-0.25861656665802,
-0.7877269983291626,
0.1313428282737732,
-0.33526745438575745,
-0.04945281147956848,
-0.33763572573661804,
-0.20313772559165955,
-0.6666211485862732,
0.46003293991088867,
0.10685667395591736,
0.7304753065109253,
-0.9733609557151794,
1.1398988962173462,
0.6974266171455383,
0.13636514544487,
-1.1446868181228638,
-0.007829751819372177,
0.19445067644119263,
-0.94048011302948,
0.2062557339668274,
0.09578076004981995,
-0.06481291353702545,
0.19123609364032745,
-0.3670978546142578,
-1.3569077253341675,
1.2449512481689453,
0.6375518441200256,
-0.7160170078277588,
0.05565116927027702,
0.28337356448173523,
0.4277106523513794,
-0.5033059120178223,
-0.15278522670269012,
0.47984978556632996,
0.2625182271003723,
0.04865185171365738,
-0.8190692663192749,
-0.2141912281513214,
0.08222412317991257,
-0.16584716737270355,
0.37390658259391785,
-0.4601683020591736,
0.6091870069503784,
-0.20933455228805542,
-0.12619589269161224,
0.016974594444036484,
0.9996368885040283,
0.09529963880777359,
0.12828391790390015,
0.5608448386192322,
0.7702200412750244,
1.3939268589019775,
-0.27547067403793335,
0.752470850944519,
-0.31510284543037415,
0.16872917115688324,
1.5466281175613403,
-0.3224746882915497,
0.9400040507316589,
0.6144346594810486,
-0.06936604529619217,
0.2317967414855957,
1.1658961772918701,
0.30907824635505676,
0.44888925552368164,
0.024334203451871872,
-0.16762731969356537,
-0.6423317193984985,
-0.17091216146945953,
-0.20544569194316864,
0.5026891231536865,
0.5740851163864136,
-0.0593193955719471,
0.021462608128786087,
-0.0014699543826282024,
-0.22200849652290344,
0.06417374312877655,
-0.3382781147956848,
0.7063577771186829,
-0.027798527851700783,
-0.4301132261753082,
0.3430834412574768,
-0.26181358098983765,
0.6210435628890991,
-0.6312588453292847,
0.2664250135421753,
0.10105817019939423,
0.12437525391578674,
-0.19266915321350098,
-0.6604287028312683,
0.12097190320491791,
-0.2598101794719696,
-0.15770754218101501,
-0.15787237882614136,
0.49218061566352844,
-0.7565351724624634,
-0.5694270730018616,
0.032348375767469406,
0.4494474530220032,
-0.01699698157608509,
0.015906954184174538,
-0.8750841617584229,
0.1358652114868164,
0.062306515872478485,
-0.1591380387544632,
0.5698196291923523,
0.3841444253921509,
-0.14447663724422455,
0.8940260410308838,
0.3929128646850586,
-0.021306337788701057,
0.16499464213848114,
-0.11960319429636002,
0.5039620995521545,
-0.16736677289009094,
-0.2051282823085785,
-0.6330471038818359,
0.5713632106781006,
0.17301838099956512,
-0.4651685059070587,
0.5747843384742737,
0.5585731863975525,
1.0341495275497437,
0.17885065078735352,
0.6078774333000183,
0.08664187788963318,
0.37561923265457153,
-0.8316947817802429,
0.505260169506073,
-0.5804174542427063,
0.275334894657135,
-0.1419600546360016,
-0.9036282896995544,
-0.4181865155696869,
0.5956968665122986,
-0.059218183159828186,
0.06488783657550812,
0.4317442774772644,
0.876786470413208,
-0.21463988721370697,
-0.21721957623958588,
0.2665994167327881,
0.09452489018440247,
0.018018506467342377,
0.4024049639701843,
0.5948504209518433,
-0.3843839168548584,
0.4088590443134308,
-0.40903064608573914,
-0.09738995134830475,
0.0971127450466156,
-1.0907695293426514,
-0.5343863368034363,
-0.6402274370193481,
-0.5335097312927246,
-0.11469076573848724,
0.24046047031879425,
1.1034892797470093,
0.8088457584381104,
-0.9774987697601318,
-0.15457084774971008,
-0.08740919083356857,
0.20640389621257782,
-0.4634802043437958,
-0.1182032972574234,
0.6199758052825928,
-0.5032926201820374,
-0.689995527267456,
0.4294542968273163,
0.165381520986557,
0.3979754149913788,
0.18499115109443665,
-0.19364406168460846,
-0.2747188210487366,
-0.05835496261715889,
0.0006266478449106216,
0.28165948390960693,
-0.7901623249053955,
-0.6101254820823669,
0.016435716301202774,
-0.2236008495092392,
0.17501190304756165,
0.4317469596862793,
-0.4391624331474304,
0.4547693431377411,
0.026708194985985756,
1.090774655342102,
0.20153100788593292,
0.20982332527637482,
0.6967006921768188,
-1.103049874305725,
0.127021923661232,
0.18162809312343597,
0.4975856840610504,
0.4094090759754181,
-0.6520088911056519,
0.2993696630001068,
-0.11494052410125732,
-0.6068902015686035,
-0.6978563070297241,
0.25843122601509094,
-0.9884356260299683,
-0.16085582971572876,
0.8907179832458496,
-0.24409644305706024,
-0.10633380711078644,
-0.07414849102497101,
0.09991104155778885,
0.5225234627723694,
-0.3405974805355072,
0.7793537974357605,
0.7843835353851318,
-0.014319289475679398,
-0.09685265272855759,
-0.3152305483818054,
0.5939594507217407,
0.7028996348381042,
-0.7267583012580872,
0.04810412600636482,
0.3346974849700928,
0.2324991673231125,
-0.023745249956846237,
0.4113120138645172,
0.16439485549926758,
0.1221386194229126,
-0.3096863031387329,
0.33230623602867126,
0.12457069754600525,
-0.4586848020553589,
-0.48060575127601624,
-0.09469741582870483,
0.46563199162483215,
-0.02741379849612713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04851v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04851v2
|
Digital assistant in a point of sales
| 2024-06-07T11:33:21 | 2024-06-10T13:20:33 |
Emilia Lesiak, Grzegorz Wolny, Bartosz Przybył, Michał Szczerbak
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This article investigates the deployment of a Voice User Interface
(VUI)-powered digital assistant in a retail setting and assesses its impact on
customer engagement and service efficiency. The study explores how digital
assistants can enhance user interactions through advanced conversational
capabilities with multilingual support. By integrating a digital assistant into
a high-traffic retail environment, we evaluate its effectiveness in improving
the quality of customer service and operational efficiency. Data collected
during the experiment demonstrate varied impacts on customer interaction,
revealing insights into the future optimizations of digital assistant
technologies in customer-facing roles. This study contributes to the
understanding of digital transformation strategies within the customer
relations domain emphasizing the need for service flexibility and user-centric
design in modern retail stores.
|
[
-0.2916831374168396,
-0.4382656216621399,
0.6542201042175293,
0.2398701161146164,
-0.1934615522623062,
0.1153351441025734,
0.3493826389312744,
-0.7325488328933716,
0.23181937634944916,
0.31786954402923584,
-0.6649973392486572,
-0.07871238887310028,
0.00600699707865715,
0.3761274516582489,
-0.3978981375694275,
0.12670640647411346,
0.20836079120635986,
0.02970706671476364,
-0.35175836086273193,
-0.09210290759801865,
-0.9672955870628357,
-0.8302605152130127,
-0.9151404500007629,
-0.21701981127262115,
0.04431219771504402,
0.33037421107292175,
0.6726275086402893,
-0.004916061647236347,
0.17772318422794342,
0.45900771021842957,
0.28885555267333984,
0.1338273584842682,
-0.1303945928812027,
0.23554180562496185,
0.15119560062885284,
-0.5382179617881775,
-0.8643547892570496,
-0.18366935849189758,
0.17181535065174103,
0.19285647571086884,
-0.29798057675361633,
-0.32041454315185547,
-0.24269594252109528,
0.49214404821395874,
-0.5998745560646057,
-0.11109057068824768,
-0.19895559549331665,
-0.33898627758026123,
0.17134922742843628,
0.007056804373860359,
-0.18196021020412445,
-0.36784857511520386,
0.15449196100234985,
-1.19351327419281,
-0.054985467344522476,
-0.5592406988143921,
0.8723140358924866,
0.3507808446884155,
-0.3869102895259857,
-0.19893158972263336,
-1.5062166452407837,
0.6439119577407837,
-0.41027963161468506,
0.7620822191238403,
0.378199964761734,
0.39641445875167847,
0.2145954966545105,
-0.6465957760810852,
-1.0168222188949585,
0.1678440123796463,
-0.05104734003543854,
0.2009776532649994,
-0.6775992512702942,
-0.24467214941978455,
0.08460063487291336,
0.20682162046432495,
0.11020886152982712,
-0.0767807587981224,
-0.4905543029308319,
0.6771875619888306,
0.9446068406105042,
0.2744084298610687,
0.0779910609126091,
0.035619787871837616,
0.24082304537296295,
-0.29855605959892273,
-0.2712533175945282,
0.3425597846508026,
0.5706662535667419,
0.12716126441955566,
0.1365949511528015,
0.2927853465080261,
-0.2025943547487259,
0.6703188419342041,
0.24382947385311127,
-0.2958795726299286,
0.22133830189704895,
-0.7032724618911743,
-0.16703058779239655,
-0.04170334339141846,
0.40409666299819946,
0.39863109588623047,
0.2615634799003601,
-0.06531600654125214,
-0.1837877482175827,
0.004843644332140684,
0.8025097250938416,
-0.22916622459888458,
0.19441400468349457,
0.2075519561767578,
-0.0077348435297608376,
-0.21269884705543518,
0.58841472864151,
-0.5186975598335266,
-0.39314910769462585,
-0.690117597579956,
0.22834524512290955,
-0.028201639652252197,
-0.559572160243988,
0.15723387897014618,
-0.3755910098552704,
0.11373364180326462,
0.5974453091621399,
-0.5654153227806091,
0.6696978807449341,
0.607559084892273,
0.568397045135498,
-0.18736985325813293,
-0.08184719830751419,
-0.15346403419971466,
0.3853047490119934,
-0.2490115910768509,
0.5351116061210632,
-0.4123137295246124,
-1.050681710243225,
0.290752112865448,
0.1680472046136856,
-0.03275632858276367,
-1.0866316556930542,
0.5283313393592834,
-0.31653499603271484,
-0.11832824349403381,
-0.16887421905994415,
0.19553576409816742,
0.048347678035497665,
0.10345544666051865,
-0.43585503101348877,
1.194561243057251,
0.40951862931251526,
0.11048807203769684,
0.39354607462882996,
-0.7975315451622009,
-0.807427167892456,
0.2467283457517624,
0.16110900044441223,
-0.42227301001548767,
0.42091450095176697,
0.14072257280349731,
0.4030025899410248,
0.3173077702522278,
-0.4153706431388855,
-0.012825348414480686,
-0.4686982333660126,
0.4725860059261322,
-0.15900805592536926,
0.4989364445209503,
0.05487583950161934,
-0.4553736448287964,
-0.0743437260389328,
-1.0711300373077393,
-0.4392755329608917,
0.20441830158233643,
-0.14729276299476624,
-0.46928659081459045,
-0.0937713012099266,
0.3672361969947815,
0.08939922600984573,
0.29221785068511963,
-0.6694096922874451,
0.6559154987335205,
-0.07450470328330994,
0.26915159821510315,
0.2943209111690521,
0.010942367836833,
0.4792638123035431,
0.09123639017343521,
0.7593905925750732,
-0.13587065041065216,
0.7600334286689758,
0.19447050988674164,
-0.6197810173034668,
-0.6771455407142639,
-0.18047688901424408,
-0.1563890278339386,
0.4831477701663971,
-0.7922992706298828,
0.3496595323085785,
-0.3343845307826996,
-0.3769301772117615,
-0.7170788049697876,
0.18396897614002228,
-0.07198541611433029,
0.31939229369163513,
0.026834983378648758,
-0.1568979173898697,
-0.12869790196418762,
-0.8900472521781921,
0.1954236477613449,
-0.20059409737586975,
-0.31012558937072754,
0.6181367635726929,
-0.4198436141014099,
-0.7571771144866943,
1.1512445211410522,
-0.4485146105289459,
-0.6124796867370605,
-0.19881249964237213,
-0.0828889012336731,
0.17466679215431213,
0.052732937037944794,
0.4833660423755646,
-1.0367517471313477,
-0.5164044499397278,
0.25136637687683105,
-0.4709428548812866,
-0.5313625931739807,
-0.21744148433208466,
0.16237133741378784,
0.3271768391132355,
0.31673377752304077,
-0.5476862192153931,
0.9132295846939087,
0.3528989553451538,
-0.33743396401405334,
0.4426543414592743,
-0.4855009913444519,
0.8574341535568237,
-0.9925915598869324,
-0.1691707819700241,
0.3414700925350189,
0.02524074725806713,
-1.1449190378189087,
-0.6083211302757263,
-0.08516985923051834,
-0.6126767992973328,
-0.6170412302017212,
0.1868196278810501,
-0.18239031732082367,
-0.5424320101737976,
-0.2639605402946472,
0.05076035112142563,
0.5350475311279297,
0.16270463168621063,
0.1948176622390747,
1.2741243839263916,
0.016736475750803947,
-1.0251518487930298,
0.16531164944171906,
0.5264524221420288,
0.09061648696660995,
1.197851538658142,
-0.8820139765739441,
0.25763845443725586,
0.1701807975769043,
-0.17625664174556732,
-1.119489312171936,
0.15866509079933167,
-0.01043394673615694,
-0.3842235803604126,
0.1295817494392395,
0.25627949833869934,
-0.45462852716445923,
-0.3201775848865509,
0.015153096988797188,
0.3464847207069397,
0.24701645970344543,
-0.5384486317634583,
0.8350169062614441,
0.3778594732284546,
-0.1805359572172165,
0.1585792750120163,
-0.6191956400871277,
0.2905917465686798,
-0.2992902994155884,
-1.0070405006408691,
0.15574786067008972,
0.12531748414039612,
-0.6337194442749023,
-0.6669582724571228,
0.24312591552734375,
-0.13422170281410217,
0.29507479071617126,
0.3392407298088074,
0.02240399643778801,
0.15653666853904724,
0.23785236477851868,
-0.14551997184753418,
-0.34555092453956604,
0.09953045845031738,
0.08690768480300903,
0.60160893201828,
-0.03679080307483673,
-0.32767388224601746,
-1.274697184562683,
0.7523879408836365,
0.8855997323989868,
-0.13836130499839783,
0.5352399349212646,
0.10094233602285385,
-0.21016155183315277,
0.45807257294654846,
-0.5640663504600525,
-0.02674321085214615,
-0.5938839912414551,
0.14220421016216278,
-0.8967135548591614,
0.22608394920825958,
0.33024051785469055,
-0.15799196064472198,
-0.04042671620845795,
0.14269179105758667,
0.2527632415294647,
-0.18707329034805298,
1.4253369569778442,
0.7346574068069458,
0.3656465709209442,
0.9115883708000183,
-0.3672415316104889,
0.7197856307029724,
-0.7167593240737915,
-0.5551793575286865,
-0.8035048246383667,
-0.17191490530967712,
-0.36826401948928833,
0.048761263489723206,
0.6412277221679688,
0.2635982632637024,
-0.002110837260261178,
0.7875218987464905,
-0.6056801676750183,
-0.3985917866230011,
0.7041690349578857,
0.24848097562789917,
0.43830737471580505,
-0.20592978596687317,
0.8566828966140747,
-0.1913321614265442,
-0.43710070848464966,
-0.5370081067085266,
0.5950729846954346,
0.43837618827819824,
0.8706004023551941,
0.5492748618125916,
0.4349522888660431,
0.356309175491333,
-0.17812256515026093,
-0.8797652721405029,
0.2641761600971222,
-0.07463762164115906,
0.09337740391492844,
-0.4253664016723633,
0.219374418258667,
-1.152574062347412,
-0.38149648904800415,
-0.09955557435750961,
-0.9944526553153992,
0.8397232890129089,
0.18332068622112274,
-0.23126451671123505,
-0.3214208781719208,
-1.4747304916381836,
0.5802956223487854,
-0.5981158018112183,
-0.43867775797843933,
-0.33731773495674133,
0.22375518083572388,
-0.16876249015331268,
0.10420779138803482,
0.0708746537566185,
0.38904884457588196,
-0.0968373492360115,
0.763296365737915,
-0.3165130615234375,
0.3347208499908447,
-0.3837636411190033,
-0.36955827474594116,
-0.06535280495882034,
-0.16088230907917023,
0.5162158012390137,
-0.00004594976417138241,
-0.013849274255335331,
0.39572516083717346,
0.18422099947929382,
-0.4451157748699188,
-0.9705107808113098,
0.6432740092277527,
-0.8643391728401184,
-0.6406735181808472,
-0.15735353529453278,
-0.4046532213687897,
-0.75179123878479,
0.05300901457667351,
-0.11023464798927307,
0.16449493169784546,
-0.29666846990585327,
-0.10742901265621185,
0.4924423396587372,
0.0072066038846969604,
0.4765455424785614,
0.293906033039093,
-0.0254340972751379,
-0.12859898805618286,
0.8434467315673828,
0.13034839928150177,
0.29958444833755493,
0.12163175642490387,
0.23984646797180176,
-0.6901792883872986,
-0.1586075872182846,
-0.501272439956665,
0.17457687854766846,
-0.6051692962646484,
0.24728408455848694,
-0.5759812593460083,
0.2518291473388672,
-0.9225969910621643,
-0.5448520183563232,
-0.2532133460044861,
-0.1922166496515274,
-0.4688398241996765,
0.09957735985517502,
0.23944629728794098,
1.2298169136047363,
0.40302136540412903,
1.0372014045715332,
-0.48244184255599976,
0.2362431138753891,
0.8559184074401855,
0.0952133759856224,
-0.16950663924217224,
0.036332398653030396,
-0.29879480600357056,
-0.015604177489876747,
-0.3193046450614929,
-0.8261826038360596,
0.24715250730514526,
-0.1330643594264984,
0.5314705967903137,
0.7921493649482727,
-0.11420818418264389,
0.631146252155304,
-0.035221584141254425,
1.1006813049316406,
0.28287407755851746,
-0.9423952102661133,
0.3462631404399872,
-0.5943408608436584,
0.7388738393783569,
0.5326036214828491,
0.2886945605278015,
-0.5717624425888062,
0.23550571501255035,
-0.8308544158935547,
-0.7714055776596069,
0.4493696093559265,
-0.037235334515571594,
0.37503814697265625,
0.3567882776260376,
0.06653241068124771,
-0.056147314608097076,
0.43993473052978516,
0.04615609720349312,
-0.31793010234832764,
-0.35686129331588745,
0.11290723830461502,
-0.14237545430660248,
-0.296673446893692,
0.02192915789783001,
-0.3376029133796692,
0.6707474589347839,
-0.2114098072052002,
0.5018991231918335,
0.18700456619262695,
0.36941424012184143,
0.007310720160603523,
0.19975809752941132,
0.723929762840271,
1.1879446506500244,
0.03239080682396889,
-0.5021123290061951,
-0.025457195937633514,
-0.4812188446521759,
0.06708890199661255,
0.0477118045091629,
-0.13315199315547943,
0.15769091248512268,
-0.18152929842472076,
0.5479526519775391,
-0.036192286759614944,
-0.5055778622627258,
0.5496347546577454,
-0.6670011281967163,
-0.09408526867628098,
-0.47744885087013245,
-0.21496185660362244,
-0.07970885932445526,
0.18797829747200012,
0.6637153029441833,
-0.30151474475860596,
0.27446240186691284,
-0.7206536531448364,
0.12516473233699799,
0.2971228063106537,
-0.3058686852455139,
-0.24346677958965302,
0.45394185185432434,
0.5544630885124207,
-1.4010963439941406,
0.41951069235801697,
0.17874787747859955,
-0.3634909987449646,
0.09012208878993988,
0.4024050235748291,
0.9406566023826599,
-0.5590073466300964,
0.4014739692211151,
-0.1417321264743805,
0.05333175137639046,
0.48686474561691284,
0.2948833703994751,
-0.23656369745731354,
-0.3037071228027344,
0.215308278799057,
0.03858009725809097,
-0.4995945990085602,
0.058926794677972794,
-0.7509371042251587,
0.5064513683319092,
-0.3007717430591583,
-0.2984382212162018,
0.12143796682357788,
0.1330731064081192,
-0.8146101832389832,
0.22126995027065277,
0.0328761450946331,
0.6382926106452942,
-0.7340704798698425,
0.5313750505447388,
0.5995067954063416,
-0.0007983763352967799,
-0.5020697116851807,
-0.02242204174399376,
-0.13461129367351532,
-0.6389751434326172,
0.5444906949996948,
-0.1850898116827011,
-0.42736271023750305,
-0.3072431683540344,
0.031049709767103195,
-0.2700527608394623,
1.1126657724380493,
0.02558118849992752,
-0.8495064973831177,
0.33002087473869324,
0.615384042263031,
0.6807721257209778,
-0.31988298892974854,
0.48916998505592346,
0.9270975589752197,
0.5195359587669373,
-0.08119414746761322,
-0.8345194458961487,
-0.39595744013786316,
-0.4031868278980255,
0.15876968204975128,
0.11641404777765274,
-0.6212828755378723,
0.36770424246788025,
0.42007336020469666,
0.0007189218304120004,
0.09864122420549393,
0.2613846957683563,
-0.12032099068164825,
0.7420668005943298,
0.7872194051742554,
0.4685173034667969,
0.7054949998855591,
-0.22434385120868683,
1.1105390787124634,
0.0699610561132431,
-0.4762823283672333,
0.6257779002189636,
-0.19392555952072144,
0.884123682975769,
0.9354067444801331,
-0.24615459144115448,
0.5827367305755615,
0.21862860023975372,
0.5294232964515686,
0.22754257917404175,
-0.0999525859951973,
-0.5193167328834534,
0.08499880880117416,
-0.6092756390571594,
-0.16728433966636658,
0.5384116172790527,
0.3016403615474701,
0.22181998193264008,
0.2819167673587799,
0.31598952412605286,
-0.3816910684108734,
0.2523876428604126,
-0.16147921979427338,
1.1793155670166016,
-0.31533941626548767,
-0.44061991572380066,
0.7277125120162964,
-0.3244519829750061,
0.31381306052207947,
-0.7135021090507507,
-0.18026433885097504,
0.05519188940525055,
0.48725396394729614,
-0.3514975607395172,
-0.4756993353366852,
0.3565589189529419,
-0.13066555559635162,
-0.1484348177909851,
-0.4579935371875763,
0.5236071348190308,
0.07796922326087952,
-0.39940786361694336,
0.24072842299938202,
0.43415459990501404,
0.021602191030979156,
-0.3329771161079407,
-0.614518404006958,
0.32659783959388733,
-0.19538401067256927,
-0.11601372808218002,
0.22711268067359924,
0.3130720555782318,
-0.13395196199417114,
0.41680169105529785,
0.6187336444854736,
-0.17432722449302673,
0.08134531229734421,
0.3181696832180023,
0.5810545682907104,
-0.36616089940071106,
-0.7175294160842896,
0.02717161551117897,
0.7903136610984802,
-0.4608696401119232,
-0.5833171606063843,
0.8514725565910339,
0.5085660815238953,
0.7644492983818054,
-0.041176557540893555,
0.7102391123771667,
0.20643581449985504,
0.29480841755867004,
0.09158714860677719,
0.36837947368621826,
-0.6389736533164978,
0.3051374554634094,
-0.4306481182575226,
-0.8384846448898315,
0.2080405056476593,
0.4505304992198944,
-0.5048298835754395,
-0.3102796971797943,
0.2293783724308014,
0.7119874954223633,
-0.1476375013589859,
0.0999242439866066,
0.6448937058448792,
-0.17667138576507568,
0.6100316047668457,
-0.0026674410328269005,
0.7386050820350647,
-0.6584634780883789,
0.6267086863517761,
-0.5902636051177979,
-0.3496512770652771,
0.008340361528098583,
-0.3352404236793518,
-0.45999833941459656,
-0.6450647115707397,
-0.2516523599624634,
-0.40029197931289673,
-0.029955247417092323,
0.3266465365886688,
0.9192664623260498,
-0.5990641713142395,
-0.5900002121925354,
-0.017729582265019417,
-0.2095399796962738,
-0.7197437882423401,
-0.3327910006046295,
-0.11019890010356903,
0.10611576586961746,
-1.4241917133331299,
0.6878343224525452,
0.4889465868473053,
0.3311086893081665,
-0.537074625492096,
-0.2771763503551483,
-0.33350732922554016,
0.044669102877378464,
0.6161013245582581,
0.30017077922821045,
-0.44088423252105713,
-0.08998510986566544,
0.46388205885887146,
0.22458750009536743,
0.16278330981731415,
1.090827465057373,
-0.692922055721283,
0.6839551329612732,
0.33034002780914307,
0.795239269733429,
0.6358705759048462,
0.46457359194755554,
0.934601902961731,
-0.6799743175506592,
0.24019783735275269,
0.21858379244804382,
-0.01362705510109663,
0.32770347595214844,
-0.8600544929504395,
0.13914625346660614,
0.2582361102104187,
-0.34499165415763855,
-0.44995588064193726,
0.3586675822734833,
-1.2013789415359497,
-0.09888359159231186,
1.259721279144287,
-0.049765799194574356,
-0.12838730216026306,
-0.5884155035018921,
-0.5998096466064453,
-0.03203722834587097,
-0.6423400044441223,
0.7875044941902161,
0.32033222913742065,
-0.4084146320819855,
-0.3263879120349884,
-0.3369991183280945,
0.17568868398666382,
0.26354172825813293,
-1.142648458480835,
-0.12156755477190018,
0.09986113756895065,
-0.3339012563228607,
0.5551210641860962,
0.5277066826820374,
0.3957231044769287,
0.34921354055404663,
-0.09435950964689255,
-0.2706962823867798,
-0.24255207180976868,
-0.3826814591884613,
-0.7684606313705444,
-0.011669009923934937,
0.08437466621398926,
-0.5938763618469238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04847v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04847v1
|
Do Language Models Exhibit Human-like Structural Priming Effects?
| 2024-06-07T11:21:52 | 2024-06-07T11:21:52 |
Jaap Jumelet, Willem Zuidema, Arabella Sinclair
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We explore which linguistic factors -- at the sentence and token level --
play an important role in influencing language model predictions, and
investigate whether these are reflective of results found in humans and human
corpora (Gries and Kootstra, 2017). We make use of the structural priming
paradigm, where recent exposure to a structure facilitates processing of the
same structure. We don't only investigate whether, but also where priming
effects occur, and what factors predict them. We show that these effects can be
explained via the inverse frequency effect, known in human priming, where rarer
elements within a prime increase priming effects, as well as lexical dependence
between prime and target. Our results provide an important piece in the puzzle
of understanding how properties within their context affect structural
prediction in language models.
|
[
-0.1299784779548645,
-0.7245365977287292,
0.4328402578830719,
0.21398095786571503,
-0.053730301558971405,
-0.26394596695899963,
0.038014452904462814,
-0.6073141694068909,
-0.05058370903134346,
0.4463784098625183,
-0.18801020085811615,
-0.10571752488613129,
-0.3357224464416504,
0.023991655558347702,
-0.28013914823532104,
0.6430624127388,
0.4783276617527008,
0.3373204469680786,
0.02314286306500435,
0.2809070944786072,
-0.5628783702850342,
-1.10496187210083,
-0.1784830540418625,
-0.5311195850372314,
0.09830030798912048,
0.34057900309562683,
1.1147894859313965,
0.8325176239013672,
0.21220365166664124,
0.19841085374355316,
-0.2537909746170044,
-0.6557984352111816,
-0.3084939420223236,
0.1409793496131897,
-0.12901434302330017,
-0.9028316140174866,
-0.5594660639762878,
0.30043843388557434,
0.9285935163497925,
1.4016859531402588,
0.32807040214538574,
-0.1017930880188942,
0.23415182530879974,
0.6423332095146179,
-0.45550575852394104,
0.15736505389213562,
-0.7716724872589111,
-0.29228538274765015,
-0.3138270080089569,
-0.4170178472995758,
-0.46911948919296265,
0.2799970209598541,
0.2498745173215866,
-0.23180337250232697,
0.5765043497085571,
0.6109924912452698,
0.9660316109657288,
-0.06306975334882736,
-0.6092386841773987,
0.013386901468038559,
-0.6502537727355957,
0.5106372833251953,
-0.5680298209190369,
0.5313670039176941,
0.7076098918914795,
-0.32220375537872314,
-0.331552654504776,
-0.4490518569946289,
-0.4170325696468353,
-0.5497488379478455,
-0.5078915953636169,
-0.10214141756296158,
0.13375988602638245,
0.5792173147201538,
0.5313716530799866,
0.6165605783462524,
-0.618928074836731,
-0.31930363178253174,
-0.720731258392334,
-0.2110966444015503,
0.12890681624412537,
0.05127901956439018,
0.49126529693603516,
-0.632843017578125,
-0.4286762475967407,
-0.11438977718353271,
-0.9991572499275208,
0.41056516766548157,
0.5991264581680298,
0.5216482281684875,
-0.08280526846647263,
0.7425743937492371,
-0.13387709856033325,
0.8116546273231506,
-0.1357109546661377,
0.04280725121498108,
0.16459830105304718,
-0.552366316318512,
-0.23403815925121307,
0.2539694011211395,
0.25073838233947754,
0.2272367924451828,
0.6685208678245544,
-0.35132843255996704,
0.015109345316886902,
0.27728238701820374,
0.05175376683473587,
-0.7148720026016235,
-0.22481265664100647,
-0.11331561207771301,
-0.4651752710342407,
-0.39041319489479065,
0.6235592365264893,
-0.34819984436035156,
-0.26790210604667664,
-0.23057857155799866,
0.04675070568919182,
-0.20084413886070251,
-0.12477327138185501,
0.3711428940296173,
-0.45474737882614136,
0.20700053870677948,
-0.36467668414115906,
-0.9883179664611816,
0.8425762057304382,
0.7808995842933655,
0.6323680281639099,
0.014742817729711533,
-0.23250453174114227,
-0.5175549983978271,
0.09360863268375397,
-0.2574407160282135,
0.6923404932022095,
-0.9568529725074768,
-0.43059107661247253,
-0.20014320313930511,
0.1296783983707428,
-0.04838893190026283,
-0.6481825113296509,
0.5311960577964783,
-0.43643054366111755,
0.11922051012516022,
-0.2953110933303833,
-0.3008008599281311,
-0.2290874570608139,
-0.11340993642807007,
-0.9047660231590271,
0.6710772514343262,
-0.03246438503265381,
-0.6575791239738464,
0.5160708427429199,
-0.20769163966178894,
-0.5447587370872498,
-0.009359966963529587,
-0.3443596363067627,
-0.2839775085449219,
0.557084321975708,
-0.16169247031211853,
0.3132784366607666,
-0.21529518067836761,
0.32443705201148987,
-0.417926162481308,
-0.513516902923584,
0.5822957158088684,
-0.31179189682006836,
0.6485856175422668,
-0.1636151671409607,
-0.456990122795105,
0.20655879378318787,
-0.8591117858886719,
-0.18967312574386597,
0.05048612132668495,
-0.21014714241027832,
-0.5547347664833069,
0.07834672182798386,
0.2466125339269638,
0.3420692980289459,
-0.24789245426654816,
-0.5388888716697693,
0.2900232970714569,
-0.8270218968391418,
0.5069798827171326,
0.5668319463729858,
0.46094977855682373,
0.9243291020393372,
-0.4229622483253479,
0.5510699152946472,
0.0019215514184907079,
-0.16730520129203796,
-0.46816015243530273,
-0.799584150314331,
-0.3306754231452942,
-0.08627709746360779,
0.3295946419239044,
0.3574734926223755,
0.24454396963119507,
0.09491628408432007,
-0.28966110944747925,
0.027722643688321114,
-0.20594890415668488,
0.13725602626800537,
0.5626053214073181,
0.36650246381759644,
-0.11795387417078018,
-0.47384732961654663,
-0.7275817394256592,
-1.2803633213043213,
-0.5557197332382202,
-0.4794715940952301,
-0.13838088512420654,
0.2636496424674988,
0.35646218061447144,
0.38676056265830994,
1.3182566165924072,
-0.7182350754737854,
-0.3768328130245209,
-0.2956731617450714,
0.413930207490921,
0.026103712618350983,
0.38754549622535706,
0.6456369757652283,
-1.1552599668502808,
-0.25341251492500305,
-0.6215433478355408,
-0.11723160743713379,
-0.22129102051258087,
-0.08737602084875107,
0.16763004660606384,
0.15919509530067444,
0.6789342761039734,
-0.3239132761955261,
0.52928227186203,
0.5053591132164001,
-0.7224615216255188,
0.4255363643169403,
0.03808184713125229,
0.02216319926083088,
-0.9125528335571289,
0.21868906915187836,
0.017441941425204277,
-0.18584392964839935,
-0.7001186013221741,
-0.24575139582157135,
0.03563155606389046,
-0.28508618474006653,
-0.4470555782318115,
0.6457170844078064,
-0.5385417938232422,
-0.5754538178443909,
-0.18149687349796295,
-0.074928417801857,
0.28410962224006653,
0.623382031917572,
0.21578162908554077,
0.843130350112915,
0.3387213945388794,
-0.3843102753162384,
-0.43076375126838684,
-0.05497508868575096,
-0.5467665791511536,
-0.02948090247809887,
-0.9379028677940369,
-0.07427289336919785,
-0.4004743695259094,
0.22187848389148712,
-1.4256328344345093,
-0.24593576788902283,
0.33237242698669434,
-0.5292105674743652,
0.2654268443584442,
-0.31465357542037964,
-0.6438560485839844,
0.006990769412368536,
-0.2229122817516327,
0.4006095826625824,
0.384224534034729,
0.1653565764427185,
0.46987858414649963,
0.3488481044769287,
-0.23053717613220215,
-0.4046982228755951,
-0.6228430271148682,
0.05705198273062706,
-0.2853885293006897,
-0.5996661186218262,
0.6629778742790222,
-0.0014012395404279232,
-0.7722343802452087,
0.2123207300901413,
-0.054532211273908615,
-0.1456359624862671,
0.6277600526809692,
0.9781736135482788,
0.3013899326324463,
-0.08611392229795456,
0.38857248425483704,
-0.3402194082736969,
-0.09707435965538025,
0.1463874727487564,
-0.26428094506263733,
0.6749931573867798,
-0.5812253952026367,
-0.07109855115413666,
-0.34066343307495117,
0.1776016503572464,
0.6510911583900452,
-0.4057120084762573,
0.8005803227424622,
0.0615982711315155,
-0.36464768648147583,
0.13448168337345123,
-0.36314037442207336,
-0.6417055726051331,
-0.4047887325286865,
0.7052342891693115,
-0.6434725522994995,
-0.592157244682312,
0.49643540382385254,
0.23168200254440308,
-0.4150655269622803,
0.46244531869888306,
0.5214422941207886,
-0.21423162519931793,
1.1255183219909668,
0.8629181385040283,
-0.13522203266620636,
0.7351731061935425,
-0.16217787563800812,
-0.1685280054807663,
-0.8165410161018372,
0.09316159784793854,
-0.5326811075210571,
-0.2957254648208618,
-0.42107605934143066,
-0.1202312707901001,
0.40031325817108154,
0.47757914662361145,
0.02615523524582386,
0.3427128195762634,
-0.15016049146652222,
0.33104804158210754,
0.3032112419605255,
-0.1554850935935974,
0.6464401483535767,
0.06018229201436043,
-0.15243425965309143,
-0.020854683592915535,
-0.6846542358398438,
-0.539605438709259,
1.1355704069137573,
0.3274247646331787,
0.5702286958694458,
-0.18007555603981018,
0.17236746847629547,
0.28616437315940857,
0.4866912364959717,
-0.5643883943557739,
0.3954663872718811,
0.15007029473781586,
-1.337445855140686,
-0.41573402285575867,
-0.031416330486536026,
-1.0341811180114746,
0.31367000937461853,
-0.26389631628990173,
-0.7778236865997314,
0.32095199823379517,
0.06433951109647751,
-0.3523370027542114,
0.03807198628783226,
-0.7122255563735962,
0.8604882955551147,
-0.1558111160993576,
-0.16681428253650665,
-0.3594277501106262,
-0.7736402750015259,
0.38299840688705444,
0.21186301112174988,
0.3982539772987366,
-0.33615270256996155,
-0.023138156160712242,
0.6686702370643616,
0.04634827375411987,
1.2428938150405884,
0.03374800831079483,
0.16997185349464417,
0.30902406573295593,
0.1668848842382431,
0.24266323447227478,
0.004533331375569105,
-0.0746329128742218,
-0.025371326133608818,
-0.2558017671108246,
-0.3758464455604553,
-0.539230227470398,
0.5285252332687378,
-0.6941177248954773,
-0.798332154750824,
-0.31146061420440674,
-0.8165964484214783,
-0.24123649299144745,
0.061006173491477966,
0.16176737844944,
0.836120069026947,
-0.3882516026496887,
0.3710596561431885,
0.29531416296958923,
0.10093042254447937,
0.39068543910980225,
0.5225807428359985,
-0.1425444334745407,
-0.0991205945611,
0.5531118512153625,
0.3340006470680237,
0.5270659923553467,
0.5180567502975464,
0.343266099691391,
0.00021526873752009124,
-0.24285203218460083,
-0.2743171751499176,
0.5376835465431213,
-0.587238073348999,
0.3092394173145294,
-0.6213386058807373,
0.11990386247634888,
-0.5390148162841797,
-0.02765699103474617,
-0.036925170570611954,
-0.7395198941230774,
-0.11627344787120819,
-0.24057996273040771,
-0.11363846063613892,
0.679104745388031,
0.18500089645385742,
0.28612467646598816,
-0.6989765763282776,
0.3307167887687683,
0.30923396348953247,
0.42330852150917053,
-0.07324965298175812,
-0.6833698749542236,
-0.03674263507127762,
0.03530413284897804,
-0.03825471177697182,
-0.9814244508743286,
0.10102615505456924,
0.545361340045929,
0.5597274899482727,
0.41080135107040405,
-0.04337308928370476,
0.32391446828842163,
-0.5121537446975708,
0.7364364266395569,
-0.12938326597213745,
-0.9587730169296265,
0.2253054827451706,
-0.40951007604599,
0.2573346793651581,
0.4218893051147461,
0.27390581369400024,
-0.6036287546157837,
-0.2899931073188782,
-0.7138885855674744,
-0.6630537509918213,
0.6981863975524902,
0.24345968663692474,
0.23541606962680817,
-0.16652360558509827,
0.470010370016098,
-0.12737953662872314,
0.19168232381343842,
-1.0576661825180054,
-0.31313103437423706,
-0.031311579048633575,
0.3067472279071808,
-0.2233017086982727,
-0.6880789995193481,
0.2514335513114929,
-0.10935648530721664,
0.3676818013191223,
0.09181669354438782,
-0.04941127821803093,
0.1767227202653885,
-0.2735964357852936,
-0.46492987871170044,
0.5156430006027222,
0.837056577205658,
0.5197957158088684,
-0.597638726234436,
0.1511041224002838,
-0.02913312055170536,
-0.21730685234069824,
0.06879225373268127,
-0.24356696009635925,
-0.10979949682950974,
-0.04221409186720848,
0.4811011254787445,
0.588895320892334,
0.8403061032295227,
-0.7094488739967346,
0.6995347142219543,
0.22986574470996857,
-0.08669301122426987,
-0.38953083753585815,
-0.08656774461269379,
0.07360447943210602,
0.03286740183830261,
0.6150988936424255,
0.2278628796339035,
0.11846718192100525,
-1.1893856525421143,
0.25850600004196167,
0.3368859887123108,
-0.5007689595222473,
-0.8705111742019653,
0.7603792548179626,
0.10297806560993195,
-0.2941388487815857,
0.643338680267334,
-0.16009828448295593,
-0.8373603820800781,
0.5675105452537537,
0.6938797235488892,
0.8493427634239197,
-0.10150618106126785,
-0.19755366444587708,
0.2806670069694519,
0.3794974088668823,
0.03749748691916466,
0.2693209648132324,
-0.037997543811798096,
-0.8593977689743042,
-0.5722162127494812,
-0.5882287621498108,
-0.041457101702690125,
0.033973727375268936,
-0.6449801921844482,
0.22253461182117462,
-0.1246819794178009,
-0.32751813530921936,
0.10989595204591751,
-0.23119784891605377,
-0.554146945476532,
0.0914888009428978,
0.7060206532478333,
0.6016788482666016,
-1.2702044248580933,
0.9299355149269104,
0.8005855679512024,
-0.48379749059677124,
-0.5669578909873962,
0.27184993028640747,
0.08004225045442581,
-0.475993275642395,
1.4559612274169922,
0.21491122245788574,
-0.1760653257369995,
0.025569265708327293,
-0.3925039768218994,
-1.0613080263137817,
0.6978285312652588,
0.29613927006721497,
0.00747349439188838,
-0.6472575664520264,
0.5037235021591187,
0.5442621111869812,
-0.40093010663986206,
-0.2428978681564331,
0.3807697594165802,
0.556973934173584,
-0.2317744344472885,
-0.9426650404930115,
0.04248257726430893,
-0.3251730501651764,
0.019494755193591118,
0.02872214838862419,
-0.2681760787963867,
1.0523446798324585,
-0.2002006620168686,
-0.597760021686554,
0.05359018221497536,
0.666048526763916,
0.12753461301326752,
-0.061303503811359406,
0.7657057046890259,
0.3064992129802704,
0.24202467501163483,
0.158244326710701,
1.367713451385498,
-0.8623611330986023,
-0.10080788284540176,
1.023517370223999,
-0.14336265623569489,
0.6945417523384094,
0.3334810733795166,
-0.12824690341949463,
0.7046441435813904,
0.13256683945655823,
0.16819483041763306,
0.42237013578414917,
0.4906150698661804,
0.30643850564956665,
-0.21111178398132324,
-0.3519401252269745,
-0.27933695912361145,
0.7266342043876648,
0.4776493310928345,
-0.497453898191452,
-0.05604976788163185,
0.12035577744245529,
-0.09594116359949112,
0.1648535579442978,
-0.21443477272987366,
0.3586561679840088,
0.22637178003787994,
-0.6256898641586304,
0.45843786001205444,
0.29221561551094055,
0.4428999722003937,
-0.47022131085395813,
-0.0008251055842265487,
0.09016586095094681,
0.07412593811750412,
-0.054918985813856125,
-0.5339193344116211,
0.36058178544044495,
-0.48721957206726074,
-0.6607580184936523,
-0.49175259470939636,
0.9434764385223389,
-0.40328001976013184,
-0.22547532618045807,
0.1614016443490982,
0.5590120553970337,
0.009269063360989094,
-0.431749165058136,
-0.2730712890625,
-0.12845554947853088,
-0.37386998534202576,
-0.48941752314567566,
0.5186442732810974,
-0.004393258132040501,
-0.34734946489334106,
0.507062554359436,
0.6687636971473694,
0.13570579886436462,
0.14826396107673645,
0.08264812082052231,
0.6866973638534546,
-0.7889508008956909,
-0.6334669589996338,
-0.6931171417236328,
0.3957003951072693,
0.12657864391803741,
-0.3390459418296814,
0.6166025996208191,
0.7277238965034485,
0.8336931467056274,
-0.19741106033325195,
0.44648027420043945,
0.17069904506206512,
0.28829002380371094,
-0.24176079034805298,
0.6568223237991333,
-0.2063302993774414,
0.21805031597614288,
-0.3474365770816803,
-1.0780621767044067,
-0.3418864607810974,
0.24878403544425964,
-0.6696591973304749,
-0.16804513335227966,
0.702976405620575,
0.8996124267578125,
0.3017162084579468,
-0.09238800406455994,
0.497805118560791,
0.44080987572669983,
0.13059672713279724,
0.10702122747898102,
0.7965288758277893,
-0.20294465124607086,
0.5885005593299866,
-0.3637515902519226,
0.025051068514585495,
-0.25719907879829407,
-0.7454814314842224,
-1.0363067388534546,
-1.0267446041107178,
-0.040859099477529526,
-0.11725218594074249,
0.08531997352838516,
0.8414408564567566,
0.781619131565094,
-0.7203054428100586,
-0.30453112721443176,
-0.38165318965911865,
-0.12266439199447632,
-0.20486411452293396,
-0.2902502119541168,
0.3728417754173279,
-0.2205950915813446,
-0.6906508803367615,
0.3457728922367096,
0.2554773986339569,
0.16535471379756927,
-0.2273474931716919,
0.29894036054611206,
-0.09264924377202988,
0.13768906891345978,
0.4230166971683502,
0.17722906172275543,
-0.9687532782554626,
-0.3391175866127014,
0.2819211781024933,
-0.5098130106925964,
0.11366096138954163,
1.3011096715927124,
-1.228687047958374,
0.06372972577810287,
0.6260969042778015,
0.02413269132375717,
0.1884806603193283,
0.3623898923397064,
0.8634701371192932,
-0.946394145488739,
0.5357957482337952,
0.14609692990779877,
0.5233061909675598,
0.1027827039361,
-0.2925151288509369,
0.47431623935699463,
0.5986135005950928,
-0.08447468280792236,
-0.9270133972167969,
0.3615785241127014,
-0.6989285349845886,
-0.49825894832611084,
1.3142362833023071,
0.25215911865234375,
-0.2321484386920929,
-0.3212934732437134,
-0.19487501680850983,
0.13118821382522583,
-0.20535659790039062,
0.7726345658302307,
0.8730753064155579,
0.10360242426395416,
-0.043485064059495926,
-0.45544105768203735,
0.517829179763794,
0.7439711689949036,
-0.23563748598098755,
0.19591431319713593,
0.3605067729949951,
0.26148027181625366,
0.0176506619900465,
0.45190027356147766,
-0.20407678186893463,
0.15970395505428314,
0.0052545927464962006,
-0.015065958723425865,
-0.31139883399009705,
-0.4940311014652252,
-0.3480936288833618,
0.43564486503601074,
0.2022411972284317,
0.2455390840768814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04845v1
|
FedLLM-Bench: Realistic Benchmarks for Federated Learning of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-07T11:19:30 | 2024-06-07T11:19:30 |
Rui Ye, Rui Ge, Xinyu Zhu, Jingyi Chai, Yaxin Du, Yang Liu, Yanfeng Wang, Siheng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DC, cs.LG, cs.MA
|
Federated learning has enabled multiple parties to collaboratively train
large language models without directly sharing their data (FedLLM). Following
this training paradigm, the community has put massive efforts from diverse
aspects including framework, performance, and privacy. However, an unpleasant
fact is that there are currently no realistic datasets and benchmarks for
FedLLM and previous works all rely on artificially constructed datasets,
failing to capture properties in real-world scenarios. Addressing this, we
propose FedLLM-Bench, which involves 8 training methods, 4 training datasets,
and 6 evaluation metrics, to offer a comprehensive testbed for the FedLLM
community. FedLLM-Bench encompasses three datasets (e.g., user-annotated
multilingual dataset) for federated instruction tuning and one dataset (e.g.,
user-annotated preference dataset) for federated preference alignment, whose
scale of client number ranges from 38 to 747. Our datasets incorporate several
representative diversities: language, quality, quantity, instruction, length,
embedding, and preference, capturing properties in real-world scenarios. Based
on FedLLM-Bench, we conduct experiments on all datasets to benchmark existing
FL methods and provide empirical insights (e.g., multilingual collaboration).
We believe that our FedLLM-Bench can benefit the FedLLM community by reducing
required efforts, providing a practical testbed, and promoting fair
comparisons. Code and datasets are available at
https://github.com/rui-ye/FedLLM-Bench.
|
[
-0.6652059555053711,
-0.6198875308036804,
0.3181939423084259,
0.49130865931510925,
0.2851259112358093,
0.11893210560083389,
-0.5794287919998169,
-0.3655239939689636,
-0.2435709536075592,
0.2797757387161255,
-0.6001397371292114,
-0.5828622579574585,
-0.17920976877212524,
0.18386384844779968,
-0.38544711470603943,
0.7904282212257385,
-0.1724323034286499,
0.4231591820716858,
-0.5624185800552368,
-0.6255558133125305,
-0.19385048747062683,
-0.39183947443962097,
-0.2621099352836609,
-0.5584683418273926,
0.4556686282157898,
0.5744256973266602,
0.4749172627925873,
0.752360463142395,
0.48964983224868774,
0.21706591546535492,
0.3899315297603607,
-0.08920340240001678,
-0.7392042279243469,
0.07715647667646408,
-0.2095542699098587,
-0.5238223075866699,
-0.3388511538505554,
0.44594907760620117,
0.9795494675636292,
0.9459541440010071,
-0.21445073187351227,
0.36125874519348145,
-0.2865038812160492,
0.75483238697052,
-0.7117077112197876,
0.546853244304657,
-0.2152934968471527,
0.33028361201286316,
-0.2629646062850952,
0.24177516996860504,
-0.5246605277061462,
-0.6204894185066223,
0.057230595499277115,
-0.3725878596305847,
0.1916719526052475,
0.2762201726436615,
0.6463002562522888,
0.007732900325208902,
-0.16898924112319946,
0.10346505045890808,
-0.6746651530265808,
0.8492435216903687,
-0.5436174869537354,
0.7178202271461487,
0.3561369478702545,
0.5810971856117249,
-0.039128392934799194,
-0.6617708802223206,
-0.2825436592102051,
-0.07665597647428513,
-0.12394020706415176,
-0.02421371079981327,
0.11179757863283157,
-0.13496707379817963,
0.24795404076576233,
0.6117753982543945,
-0.6480196118354797,
0.2262955754995346,
0.15835203230381012,
0.05596061795949936,
0.7649131417274475,
0.11704246699810028,
-0.1089802086353302,
0.48106735944747925,
-0.5646811127662659,
-0.5473438501358032,
-0.6561084389686584,
0.054529014974832535,
0.28886517882347107,
0.4633736312389374,
-0.1733662337064743,
0.06472434103488922,
-0.4947711229324341,
0.6820772290229797,
-0.03749474138021469,
-0.2920563817024231,
0.5884135365486145,
-0.20274554193019867,
-0.3420577645301819,
-0.22852158546447754,
0.8948478102684021,
0.1836519092321396,
0.09350087493658066,
-0.48597970604896545,
-0.6408705711364746,
-0.24861975014209747,
-0.1294531673192978,
-0.8446559309959412,
-0.04392743483185768,
0.2995864450931549,
-0.28926050662994385,
-0.30517175793647766,
0.2631804347038269,
-0.9524510502815247,
-0.27067601680755615,
-0.4237760901451111,
0.2793358862400055,
-0.29930558800697327,
-0.591793417930603,
-0.09058830142021179,
0.060992397367954254,
0.36325603723526,
0.16116192936897278,
-0.9119219183921814,
0.7670331597328186,
0.9854533076286316,
0.6661273837089539,
-0.14593783020973206,
-0.612659752368927,
-0.8358315229415894,
-0.25417205691337585,
-0.1778920441865921,
0.5524968504905701,
-0.5329822301864624,
-0.18883612751960754,
0.2657342851161957,
-0.06196505203843117,
-0.21463795006275177,
-0.6631452441215515,
0.2901841402053833,
-0.3026579022407532,
0.3766802251338959,
-0.34401431679725647,
-0.8213313817977905,
-0.01816154271364212,
0.4062997102737427,
-0.7385038733482361,
0.719753623008728,
0.3110242784023285,
-0.37332624197006226,
0.2862353026866913,
-0.6220500469207764,
-0.4421362280845642,
0.022790974006056786,
-0.395408034324646,
-0.4117733836174011,
0.01538640446960926,
0.03783836588263512,
0.5738860964775085,
-0.5386552214622498,
0.4908529222011566,
-0.5649530291557312,
-0.4241447150707245,
0.3630480468273163,
-0.17525050044059753,
0.623002827167511,
0.2862212359905243,
-0.46762436628341675,
0.0666545107960701,
-0.6665955185890198,
0.18600763380527496,
0.11541392654180527,
-0.20070502161979675,
0.014057928696274757,
-0.259333074092865,
0.4370444118976593,
0.23532593250274658,
0.1498791128396988,
-0.5155970454216003,
-0.15855303406715393,
-0.45509442687034607,
0.17481198906898499,
0.730660617351532,
-0.4987906217575073,
0.5112834572792053,
-0.535219669342041,
0.5012169480323792,
-0.19404180347919464,
0.32170695066452026,
0.10951882600784302,
0.0012549657840281725,
-0.6487612128257751,
-0.3380516767501831,
0.4978473484516144,
0.2497255504131317,
-0.43167218565940857,
0.23287059366703033,
-0.46009311079978943,
-0.41114598512649536,
-0.37184280157089233,
0.20177392661571503,
0.759310781955719,
0.3063061237335205,
0.12832733988761902,
-0.13682863116264343,
-0.35718995332717896,
-0.8410916924476624,
-0.04386052489280701,
0.0816250815987587,
0.15208406746387482,
0.3874909579753876,
0.29885154962539673,
-0.04940887540578842,
1.0970008373260498,
-0.3447803556919098,
-0.43267881870269775,
-0.0865718424320221,
0.18623748421669006,
0.14579632878303528,
0.371862530708313,
0.7495375871658325,
-0.7429308891296387,
-0.5953885912895203,
0.09027668833732605,
-0.7179673314094543,
-0.0872141569852829,
0.27776098251342773,
0.11630001664161682,
0.25473782420158386,
0.1455286592245102,
-0.2705647349357605,
-0.2176697701215744,
0.8343214392662048,
0.009122384712100029,
0.5566896796226501,
0.00255245971493423,
0.061184417456388474,
-1.0510284900665283,
0.3292732238769531,
0.004271002486348152,
-0.3775903880596161,
-0.43253570795059204,
0.49075642228126526,
0.07255604863166809,
-0.2722839415073395,
-0.28584107756614685,
0.7582342624664307,
-0.4510101079940796,
-0.3383786976337433,
-0.08933863043785095,
0.0656890943646431,
-0.1848551481962204,
0.4474119544029236,
0.011359162628650665,
0.7864174842834473,
0.3302520215511322,
-0.0064125945791602135,
0.5290390849113464,
0.1654861569404602,
-0.2838039696216583,
0.6549663543701172,
-0.27889126539230347,
0.04723604768514633,
0.3742828369140625,
0.29815974831581116,
-0.5902799963951111,
-0.49268144369125366,
-0.0005635491688735783,
-0.09687235951423645,
0.32715922594070435,
0.08576428890228271,
-0.6906625628471375,
-0.2265360951423645,
-0.2866857051849365,
0.23061782121658325,
0.37212663888931274,
-0.7596824169158936,
0.3462594151496887,
0.450880765914917,
0.16269181668758392,
-0.7834535837173462,
-0.5884509086608887,
-0.21108490228652954,
-0.07018154859542847,
-0.5341671705245972,
0.0008209313964471221,
-0.048221342265605927,
-0.36693075299263,
-0.07578451931476593,
-0.0994580090045929,
-0.3542863726615906,
0.22397665679454803,
0.42029011249542236,
-0.09810487180948257,
-0.47884416580200195,
0.23580701649188995,
-0.32192182540893555,
-0.08700289577245712,
0.20810699462890625,
-0.21222150325775146,
0.5313835144042969,
-0.803020179271698,
-0.35277679562568665,
-0.12463194876909256,
0.2535131573677063,
0.48079800605773926,
-0.48919960856437683,
0.7280150055885315,
0.8845731616020203,
-0.47907599806785583,
-0.41844627261161804,
-0.8257150650024414,
-0.22486262023448944,
-0.40569087862968445,
-0.005527487024664879,
-0.32957351207733154,
-1.2231547832489014,
0.5597201585769653,
-0.31080493330955505,
0.25427737832069397,
-0.06764362007379532,
0.4902931749820709,
0.08828206360340118,
0.6801914572715759,
0.5042953491210938,
-0.3712395131587982,
0.41873469948768616,
-0.23253992199897766,
-0.05882251262664795,
-0.2455611228942871,
-0.034770574420690536,
-0.5601111650466919,
-0.3819895088672638,
-0.39018532633781433,
-0.308452308177948,
-0.017163479700684547,
-0.14510007202625275,
-0.1139293760061264,
0.20863524079322815,
0.035313572734594345,
0.5909018516540527,
0.5267255306243896,
-0.03938283398747444,
0.19007891416549683,
-0.1196661964058876,
-0.4624635577201843,
0.10693573951721191,
-0.6271910667419434,
-0.20112712681293488,
1.0414354801177979,
0.2880992293357849,
0.7561295628547668,
0.04111132398247719,
0.7899994850158691,
0.10686606168746948,
0.6016680598258972,
-0.541720986366272,
0.4552346169948578,
-0.014837924391031265,
-0.5857869982719421,
-0.1430581659078598,
-0.7351618409156799,
-0.7001786231994629,
0.1365354061126709,
-0.3153933584690094,
-0.3531648516654968,
0.20377174019813538,
0.0310817863792181,
-0.07454902678728104,
0.19744375348091125,
-0.7949607968330383,
1.1242632865905762,
-0.21267841756343842,
-0.6401359438896179,
-0.21015965938568115,
-0.7085098028182983,
0.49076637625694275,
-0.20479494333267212,
0.353797048330307,
-0.2843461334705353,
0.29131853580474854,
0.617703914642334,
-0.5057932734489441,
0.7155144214630127,
-0.39920490980148315,
0.20882968604564667,
-0.2295874059200287,
-0.1491088718175888,
0.28369414806365967,
0.2739568054676056,
-0.217641681432724,
0.13974428176879883,
-0.037065088748931885,
-0.4925417900085449,
-0.3687360882759094,
1.1012606620788574,
-0.9249541759490967,
-0.3520936071872711,
-0.48570239543914795,
-0.7062194347381592,
-0.6717945337295532,
0.3337051570415497,
-0.35666564106941223,
0.5702833533287048,
-0.7193812727928162,
0.48229390382766724,
0.616868257522583,
0.0836835652589798,
0.3480810225009918,
0.8024022579193115,
-0.5415815114974976,
-0.5633603930473328,
0.8585271835327148,
-0.11786404997110367,
0.21650592982769012,
0.5999675989151001,
0.1364777833223343,
-0.39951297640800476,
-0.45358806848526,
-0.13184013962745667,
0.27130892872810364,
-0.6168003082275391,
-0.2870936393737793,
-0.401594340801239,
-0.0709315836429596,
-0.3333875238895416,
-0.10317892581224442,
-0.6472566723823547,
-0.21635621786117554,
-0.022615946829319,
-0.17611479759216309,
0.3442150056362152,
0.3598829209804535,
-0.0609217993915081,
0.1388595551252365,
-0.6566354632377625,
-0.2487477958202362,
0.24970103800296783,
0.8148347735404968,
-0.000680379627738148,
0.15966573357582092,
-0.5094219446182251,
0.1933780163526535,
0.046950362622737885,
-0.09722589701414108,
0.181815505027771,
0.30167248845100403,
0.7614229917526245,
0.505150318145752,
0.25213608145713806,
0.5463573336601257,
-0.5154834985733032,
0.30000391602516174,
0.10990721732378006,
-0.7908508777618408,
0.3315458595752716,
-0.3602903485298157,
0.2607487440109253,
1.0069859027862549,
0.4555150866508484,
-0.4627044200897217,
-0.37393879890441895,
-0.5136978626251221,
-0.26859334111213684,
0.8997377753257751,
-0.0003995841834694147,
-0.18511198461055756,
0.21804013848304749,
0.1575508564710617,
0.42814910411834717,
0.1895998865365982,
-0.5109978318214417,
-0.2679101228713989,
-0.13611949980258942,
-0.2155998796224594,
-0.2282315343618393,
0.20732635259628296,
-0.5516177415847778,
-0.0997670516371727,
0.5396042466163635,
-0.2874089479446411,
0.025091079995036125,
-0.19782383739948273,
-0.21323107182979584,
-0.2798222601413727,
0.2666814625263214,
0.5070560574531555,
0.9558765292167664,
-0.5519286394119263,
0.07020188868045807,
-0.05069822818040848,
-0.16177499294281006,
0.21366353332996368,
0.5799528360366821,
0.0017751576378941536,
-0.05460819602012634,
0.32752537727355957,
0.8618142604827881,
0.4726863503456116,
-0.8866246938705444,
0.6643016934394836,
-0.418636679649353,
-0.4100125730037689,
-0.2960945665836334,
0.19162270426750183,
0.19269244372844696,
0.2755136489868164,
0.27295663952827454,
-0.02661571279168129,
-0.26209557056427,
-0.4155604839324951,
0.4760412871837616,
0.3748159408569336,
-0.5260728597640991,
-0.38562047481536865,
0.4388648569583893,
0.401447594165802,
-0.12848879396915436,
0.5908470749855042,
0.04115383327007294,
-0.08269588649272919,
0.1954207420349121,
0.4114793539047241,
0.777069628238678,
-0.2537812292575836,
0.4260609745979309,
0.22661663591861725,
0.05449214577674866,
-0.4113718867301941,
-0.044755399227142334,
-0.1132584810256958,
-0.6595733761787415,
-0.25185152888298035,
-0.8037999868392944,
-0.7248668074607849,
0.19689619541168213,
-0.8476526737213135,
0.14067375659942627,
-0.7147408127784729,
0.027185017243027687,
-0.11201193183660507,
0.42420634627342224,
-0.7341345548629761,
-0.008893883787095547,
0.0022856947034597397,
1.1521965265274048,
-0.9672863483428955,
0.9769141674041748,
0.7647584080696106,
-0.36465984582901,
-0.6319847702980042,
-0.20452745258808136,
0.13476257026195526,
-0.7134732007980347,
0.22905457019805908,
0.3223043382167816,
0.25272247195243835,
0.008837617002427578,
-0.33201050758361816,
-0.5947993397712708,
1.2584303617477417,
0.488136887550354,
-0.5872915983200073,
0.25776734948158264,
0.43571051955223083,
0.5686783194541931,
-0.6105639338493347,
0.11768952012062073,
0.48260730504989624,
0.5486177206039429,
-0.12660230696201324,
-0.8981176614761353,
0.09376723319292068,
-0.08699002116918564,
-0.07428433001041412,
0.2094811499118805,
-0.831606924533844,
0.7489185333251953,
0.20713122189044952,
-0.11557026207447052,
0.041342463344335556,
0.4716334939002991,
0.02895192615687847,
0.3297121226787567,
0.5611667633056641,
0.6470639705657959,
0.6854308247566223,
-0.38210082054138184,
1.0208913087844849,
-0.24672918021678925,
0.6810821294784546,
1.1534706354141235,
-0.8007636070251465,
0.9393435120582581,
0.40178054571151733,
-0.1603502482175827,
0.07359804213047028,
0.5203480124473572,
-0.10565480589866638,
0.5169646739959717,
0.08032293617725372,
-0.3498728573322296,
-0.19932058453559875,
-0.1524004191160202,
-0.4668034613132477,
0.4174669682979584,
0.3174991011619568,
-0.2755119204521179,
-0.44425222277641296,
0.15208838880062103,
-0.005628920625895262,
0.33223116397857666,
0.06639616936445236,
0.7449623942375183,
0.1388569474220276,
-0.45556044578552246,
0.7424719333648682,
-0.03473692387342453,
0.5138471126556396,
-0.6873519420623779,
0.26248303055763245,
-0.585244357585907,
0.5080918669700623,
-0.08803897351026535,
-0.5064213275909424,
0.0798627957701683,
-0.12093380093574524,
-0.20140913128852844,
-0.599939227104187,
0.43521639704704285,
-0.5751633644104004,
-0.3200012445449829,
0.40409594774246216,
0.7492005228996277,
-0.06592503935098648,
0.12345228344202042,
-0.7359362840652466,
0.2288452684879303,
-0.2423648238182068,
-0.03690354898571968,
0.8161219954490662,
0.25061365962028503,
0.11554872244596481,
0.5994028449058533,
0.5327770113945007,
-0.1844319999217987,
-0.2740139365196228,
0.2777467370033264,
0.8249741196632385,
-0.35385891795158386,
-0.14706158638000488,
-0.5113838911056519,
-0.09852109104394913,
-0.1538723111152649,
-0.2408793568611145,
0.8294388651847839,
0.7348185181617737,
1.2163554430007935,
-0.20000194013118744,
0.47431668639183044,
0.004031384829431772,
0.46234142780303955,
-0.3167179524898529,
0.998565673828125,
-0.474835604429245,
-0.033365026116371155,
-0.036533769220113754,
-0.9390723705291748,
-0.3857637047767639,
0.47927334904670715,
-0.27995169162750244,
-0.12246105819940567,
0.5934581756591797,
0.7278632521629333,
-0.2888987064361572,
0.3688359558582306,
0.3695003092288971,
0.20390036702156067,
0.2640835642814636,
0.5783123970031738,
0.551482081413269,
-0.3602023124694824,
0.3696930408477783,
-0.6858862042427063,
-0.31394803524017334,
-0.4545098543167114,
-0.6972339153289795,
-0.9796484708786011,
-0.5822395086288452,
-0.307295024394989,
0.03182177618145943,
0.23584409058094025,
1.0925307273864746,
0.9609395861625671,
-1.0264261960983276,
-0.6237724423408508,
-0.0659468024969101,
0.09440305083990097,
-0.575114905834198,
-0.2612352669239044,
0.0622406043112278,
-0.436831533908844,
-0.6413068175315857,
0.42218664288520813,
0.07300194352865219,
-0.2139451503753662,
-0.5502156615257263,
-0.22951771318912506,
-0.4856502115726471,
-0.5325426459312439,
0.3528893291950226,
0.3999961316585541,
-0.6332765221595764,
-0.30748501420021057,
0.012564415112137794,
-0.23931702971458435,
0.06637349724769592,
0.635138988494873,
-0.5926873087882996,
0.44301289319992065,
0.37402865290641785,
0.9417592883110046,
0.5000317692756653,
-0.1232866421341896,
0.9337543845176697,
-1.1826550960540771,
0.2562004327774048,
0.23349344730377197,
0.3188486397266388,
0.36311137676239014,
0.058513663709163666,
0.7918793559074402,
0.31392452120780945,
-0.5562991499900818,
-0.962955117225647,
-0.29892170429229736,
-0.7909761667251587,
-0.10537130385637283,
0.8572561144828796,
-0.5915788412094116,
-0.21292470395565033,
0.19508196413516998,
0.3565690517425537,
-0.043581947684288025,
-0.4518240690231323,
0.5204966068267822,
0.8842982649803162,
0.07284881174564362,
-0.24697241187095642,
-0.46304425597190857,
0.4230102300643921,
0.25361526012420654,
-0.9408414363861084,
0.3613138198852539,
0.7386652231216431,
0.3306504487991333,
0.09598719328641891,
0.48707661032676697,
-0.014091403223574162,
0.3252634108066559,
0.0028709962498396635,
0.0027422315906733274,
-0.24093805253505707,
-0.16790789365768433,
-0.4016513526439667,
0.32044219970703125,
0.1684057116508484,
-0.01473822072148323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04836v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04836v1
|
Revisiting Catastrophic Forgetting in Large Language Model Tuning
| 2024-06-07T11:09:13 | 2024-06-07T11:09:13 |
Hongyu Li, Liang Ding, Meng Fang, Dacheng Tao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Catastrophic Forgetting (CF) means models forgetting previously acquired
knowledge when learning new data. It compromises the effectiveness of large
language models (LLMs) during fine-tuning, yet the underlying causes have not
been thoroughly investigated. This paper takes the first step to reveal the
direct link between the flatness of the model loss landscape and the extent of
CF in the field of LLMs. Based on this, we introduce the sharpness-aware
minimization to mitigate CF by flattening the loss landscape. Experiments on
three widely-used fine-tuning datasets, spanning different model scales,
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in alleviating CF. Analyses show
that we nicely complement the existing anti-forgetting strategies, further
enhancing the resistance of LLMs to CF.
|
[
-0.5731989145278931,
-0.7420382499694824,
0.41105371713638306,
-0.15869773924350739,
-0.06773369014263153,
0.15807507932186127,
-0.5052122473716736,
-0.10851577669382095,
-0.13636323809623718,
0.6376832127571106,
-0.9268044233322144,
-0.48031288385391235,
-0.25093403458595276,
-0.2509213984012604,
-0.33673474192619324,
1.2743518352508545,
-0.05896960571408272,
-0.35957208275794983,
-0.03922506049275398,
-0.07897932827472687,
-0.5591053366661072,
-0.32701531052589417,
-1.1735026836395264,
-0.5082221031188965,
0.7116653323173523,
0.49353986978530884,
0.6817164421081543,
0.754797637462616,
0.48187923431396484,
0.2538212239742279,
-0.36348670721054077,
0.06902150064706802,
-1.3132671117782593,
0.048768550157547,
-0.21981877088546753,
-0.7425444722175598,
-0.28168150782585144,
-0.18442487716674805,
0.9364707469940186,
1.096616268157959,
-0.18398775160312653,
-0.067955382168293,
0.028605416417121887,
0.9392175078392029,
-0.7776656150817871,
-0.046651966869831085,
-1.0898574590682983,
0.1963091790676117,
-0.1787109673023224,
-0.29166603088378906,
-0.44672057032585144,
-0.03921074792742729,
-0.040774695575237274,
-0.6657580137252808,
0.746845543384552,
-0.016417328268289566,
0.5149080753326416,
0.4018535614013672,
-0.1579185426235199,
-0.19366328418254852,
-0.9883249402046204,
0.8719871044158936,
-0.5932356715202332,
0.3810287117958069,
0.310391902923584,
0.09886973351240158,
-0.37056106328964233,
-0.2673482298851013,
-0.39631903171539307,
-0.06492898613214493,
0.271819144487381,
-0.003327486105263233,
-0.152871772646904,
0.18988707661628723,
0.19465462863445282,
0.6546975374221802,
-0.24077440798282623,
0.4575001299381256,
-0.38331398367881775,
-0.27695608139038086,
0.5091540217399597,
0.27848491072654724,
-0.060127269476652145,
0.4078230559825897,
-0.05619679018855095,
0.03248488903045654,
-0.9902787804603577,
-0.03462938591837883,
0.18466439843177795,
0.5483272671699524,
0.022614767774939537,
0.14931175112724304,
-0.02761727012693882,
0.47877833247184753,
0.08824833482503891,
-0.09821069985628128,
-0.06420984119176865,
-0.14581850171089172,
-0.39119449257850647,
-0.14609548449516296,
0.37973782420158386,
0.24963174760341644,
0.48487699031829834,
-0.19743287563323975,
-0.33405551314353943,
-0.25333401560783386,
0.1738768368959427,
-0.3586180508136749,
-0.5124341249465942,
0.060869671404361725,
-0.24276892840862274,
-0.09870930016040802,
-0.3751347064971924,
-0.423788845539093,
-0.5602805018424988,
-0.282295286655426,
0.15510551631450653,
-0.4756295382976532,
-0.3741603195667267,
0.2369486540555954,
0.23022817075252533,
0.06217746064066887,
0.31611600518226624,
-1.0620572566986084,
0.2737564146518707,
0.7759622931480408,
0.7707282304763794,
0.14162401854991913,
-0.45211783051490784,
-0.3338826298713684,
0.1507200002670288,
-0.6676856279373169,
0.9147160053253174,
-0.28321903944015503,
-0.5105756521224976,
0.16964375972747803,
-0.11617156118154526,
-0.20975230634212494,
-0.7310721278190613,
0.6507481932640076,
-0.18887098133563995,
-0.09720031172037125,
-0.5157480239868164,
-0.46385228633880615,
-0.37211480736732483,
0.3145269751548767,
-0.5604285597801208,
0.8466850519180298,
-0.10822625458240509,
-0.5195408463478088,
0.3868480920791626,
-0.16710607707500458,
-0.44250398874282837,
-0.21648679673671722,
0.22857904434204102,
-0.7453147172927856,
0.6220831274986267,
-0.012011720798909664,
0.5332684516906738,
-0.23016668856143951,
0.2591691017150879,
-0.5832070112228394,
-0.5107670426368713,
-0.0549788773059845,
-0.5500556230545044,
0.3878602087497711,
0.07999049127101898,
0.08717869222164154,
-0.007078393362462521,
-0.746497392654419,
-0.21483275294303894,
0.1673663854598999,
-0.5191817283630371,
-0.46039140224456787,
0.1086738333106041,
0.20501795411109924,
0.15394067764282227,
-0.14605535566806793,
-0.20864346623420715,
0.24033603072166443,
-0.7198277711868286,
0.6049100160598755,
1.0044077634811401,
-0.008231856860220432,
0.3516024053096771,
-0.6272174119949341,
0.11089129745960236,
0.14115287363529205,
0.3013226389884949,
-0.4372185170650482,
0.09877804666757584,
-1.3082001209259033,
-0.17329159379005432,
-0.012752866372466087,
0.2357431799173355,
-0.40192005038261414,
0.1064004898071289,
-0.16435430943965912,
-0.4627235531806946,
-0.4360722005367279,
0.29153546690940857,
0.59968501329422,
0.4262641668319702,
0.30072730779647827,
-0.2511390745639801,
-0.42078009247779846,
-0.8481525182723999,
-0.28053179383277893,
-0.013973437249660492,
0.004225877113640308,
0.27355626225471497,
0.37615224719047546,
-0.27912506461143494,
0.47982650995254517,
-0.3584335446357727,
-0.5875776410102844,
-0.17361438274383545,
-0.08070767670869827,
0.028506148606538773,
0.6001324653625488,
0.5808027982711792,
-0.6184981465339661,
-0.1029697060585022,
-0.07647344470024109,
-0.29946646094322205,
0.1549370288848877,
-0.442811518907547,
-0.029125386849045753,
0.5763047337532043,
0.7105275392532349,
-0.4434041380882263,
0.2031366229057312,
0.2891174554824829,
-0.28703778982162476,
0.6137924790382385,
-0.24023325741291046,
-0.12903892993927002,
-0.7780636548995972,
0.1511528044939041,
-0.0726279765367508,
0.030910735949873924,
-0.7314355373382568,
-0.028805755078792572,
-0.10122209787368774,
0.20180991291999817,
-0.4018877446651459,
0.34353601932525635,
-0.36872079968452454,
0.10235665738582611,
-0.2097797840833664,
0.17678149044513702,
-0.19497020542621613,
0.5440741181373596,
-0.3530895411968231,
0.501115083694458,
0.5424948334693909,
-0.6579535007476807,
-0.1002810150384903,
0.18672426044940948,
-0.139075368642807,
0.5622127652168274,
-0.17471013963222504,
0.03138719126582146,
-0.4930923879146576,
0.045926038175821304,
-1.1407196521759033,
-0.03138801082968712,
-0.039747267961502075,
-0.19568075239658356,
0.534892201423645,
-0.11179347336292267,
-0.408136785030365,
-0.4452572464942932,
-0.32435113191604614,
0.3061594069004059,
0.2647388279438019,
-0.4508460760116577,
0.4174993932247162,
0.17711706459522247,
-0.17157520353794098,
-0.28556567430496216,
-0.5832818746566772,
0.19804954528808594,
-0.2393391877412796,
-0.36826395988464355,
0.34596675634384155,
-0.34896692633628845,
-0.20997194945812225,
-0.35937896370887756,
-0.38534435629844666,
-0.07482115179300308,
0.434578537940979,
0.09847666323184967,
0.03619956970214844,
-0.25686022639274597,
0.37782880663871765,
0.08766720443964005,
-0.16009849309921265,
0.06034189090132713,
-0.2892540395259857,
0.6035879254341125,
-0.2847256064414978,
-0.1834697425365448,
-0.39535653591156006,
0.38165977597236633,
0.7236341834068298,
-0.10904517769813538,
0.6366551518440247,
0.25497356057167053,
-0.5689597129821777,
-0.3172779381275177,
-0.839253842830658,
-0.0962735265493393,
-0.4741085171699524,
0.6170362830162048,
-0.27880334854125977,
-1.034525752067566,
0.9658716320991516,
-0.45323070883750916,
0.250565767288208,
0.5644976496696472,
0.47559869289398193,
-0.09962287545204163,
0.7931663990020752,
1.2991816997528076,
-0.37588056921958923,
0.37403604388237,
-0.3222382068634033,
0.30534636974334717,
-0.7753722667694092,
-0.4081309735774994,
-0.6022191047668457,
-0.22740672528743744,
-0.47126641869544983,
-0.12444088608026505,
0.12927871942520142,
0.35387349128723145,
-0.49053338170051575,
-0.2269265055656433,
-0.13317453861236572,
0.6747543215751648,
0.3502773642539978,
0.03814597800374031,
0.37802550196647644,
-0.08438493311405182,
-0.1306377649307251,
0.06834133714437485,
-0.989563524723053,
-0.16803868114948273,
0.8375603556632996,
0.3755192160606384,
0.6813526749610901,
-0.0709536075592041,
0.5207867622375488,
-0.012288465164601803,
0.3541363775730133,
-0.8408409953117371,
0.26972728967666626,
-0.2730005085468292,
-0.44420769810676575,
-0.3641372323036194,
-0.4573057293891907,
-0.6440436840057373,
-0.039260465651750565,
-0.34456199407577515,
-0.5587353706359863,
0.03537210822105408,
0.5098096132278442,
-0.6601722836494446,
0.5497445464134216,
-0.5086112022399902,
0.612614631652832,
0.041721511632204056,
-0.17960099875926971,
-0.2759173810482025,
-0.2882448732852936,
0.5586252212524414,
-0.40566885471343994,
0.38767918944358826,
-0.17406906187534332,
0.24229826033115387,
0.7824015021324158,
-0.11277057230472565,
1.0317811965942383,
0.052194006741046906,
-0.3086996078491211,
-0.01700482703745365,
0.24225132167339325,
0.5026412606239319,
0.10259582102298737,
-0.015388088300824165,
0.19582930207252502,
-0.1756715029478073,
-0.5337071418762207,
-0.24381421506404877,
1.12137770652771,
-0.5772286653518677,
-0.6339786052703857,
-0.10966181755065918,
-0.718383252620697,
-0.4561308026313782,
0.39825090765953064,
0.27691492438316345,
0.03716862574219704,
-0.38930726051330566,
0.038576215505599976,
1.294966220855713,
-0.32843443751335144,
0.5693228840827942,
0.6226367950439453,
-0.09570566564798355,
-0.1852593868970871,
0.6939989924430847,
0.2669159471988678,
0.4163825213909149,
0.12842583656311035,
0.02437852881848812,
0.2325972318649292,
-0.8491466045379639,
-0.013597466982901096,
0.4022240936756134,
-0.6613286137580872,
-0.3486965000629425,
-0.39731287956237793,
-0.2667238712310791,
-0.18020574748516083,
-0.6559715270996094,
-0.7652355432510376,
-0.16202718019485474,
-0.38371527194976807,
-0.1553693562746048,
0.39470431208610535,
0.6054661870002747,
-0.057030849158763885,
0.39524561166763306,
-0.41632381081581116,
0.03386389836668968,
-0.06909079849720001,
0.8229220509529114,
0.41692978143692017,
-0.5149204730987549,
-0.36259353160858154,
0.17747355997562408,
-0.2977343797683716,
-0.07364597916603088,
0.22208045423030853,
0.6371943354606628,
0.4463837444782257,
0.7031150460243225,
-0.07224749028682709,
0.7716366052627563,
-0.5702618360519409,
0.44986844062805176,
0.2817629873752594,
-0.8699255585670471,
0.4705493152141571,
-0.6073434948921204,
0.6901772618293762,
0.6358503103256226,
0.26655343174934387,
-0.7999050617218018,
-0.5515007972717285,
-0.3676129877567291,
-1.085661768913269,
0.44489166140556335,
-0.21215340495109558,
0.3848536014556885,
0.03439292684197426,
0.770856499671936,
0.24678203463554382,
-0.10230641067028046,
-0.4541252553462982,
-0.4014829099178314,
0.05474312603473663,
0.048848044127225876,
-0.49156326055526733,
-0.574235200881958,
-0.0907052680850029,
-0.30749306082725525,
0.7357117533683777,
-0.1913200169801712,
-0.02280183881521225,
-0.05836313217878342,
0.04682546108961105,
-0.5184715986251831,
0.006361744832247496,
0.7231179475784302,
0.5432345271110535,
-0.05008456110954285,
0.09259053319692612,
0.4367908239364624,
-0.49901989102363586,
-0.21201327443122864,
-0.23694492876529694,
-0.26242369413375854,
-0.3658023178577423,
0.5456396341323853,
0.7237234115600586,
0.7413268089294434,
-0.5704725384712219,
0.004125943407416344,
0.1553860455751419,
-0.36466148495674133,
-0.4103081524372101,
0.1438460499048233,
0.2702484726905823,
0.025776198133826256,
0.5018666386604309,
0.35235267877578735,
-0.11360227316617966,
-0.5759051442146301,
0.3235306143760681,
0.5205420851707458,
-0.7444562911987305,
-0.16267246007919312,
0.4900038540363312,
-0.008303480222821236,
-0.21632961928844452,
0.8221466541290283,
0.3923095166683197,
-0.5155749320983887,
0.5842217803001404,
0.5274020433425903,
0.7481948137283325,
-0.428383469581604,
0.03644110634922981,
0.28625693917274475,
0.5597579479217529,
-0.23559410870075226,
0.02768884412944317,
0.18849149346351624,
-0.5002097487449646,
-0.4134460985660553,
-0.6236312389373779,
-0.12009105086326599,
0.41164788603782654,
-0.7017980217933655,
0.2720910906791687,
-0.9261389374732971,
0.05335325747728348,
0.14994364976882935,
-0.023727212101221085,
-0.5826461911201477,
0.2139199823141098,
0.22669169306755066,
1.1217666864395142,
-0.9256017804145813,
0.5313515067100525,
0.19253361225128174,
-0.2582123279571533,
-0.5464224815368652,
0.2345443218946457,
0.19046509265899658,
-0.7138864398002625,
0.09839212149381638,
0.14470621943473816,
-0.18904101848602295,
0.17763176560401917,
-0.5398527979850769,
-1.0021002292633057,
0.9121900200843811,
0.3441890478134155,
-0.7502743601799011,
0.22096578776836395,
0.09376303106546402,
0.509873628616333,
-0.12025614082813263,
-0.11233764886856079,
0.8533450365066528,
0.3267894387245178,
0.41494300961494446,
-1.0250593423843384,
-0.007211423944681883,
-0.012135687284171581,
0.058523792773485184,
0.526290237903595,
-0.8263735771179199,
0.849273145198822,
-0.6474341750144958,
-0.2772681415081024,
0.03250546753406525,
0.3980073928833008,
-0.10706786066293716,
0.23466309905052185,
0.2616199553012848,
0.6932299733161926,
0.911013126373291,
-0.16896454989910126,
0.6028674840927124,
0.11951597779989243,
0.5430019497871399,
0.9533377289772034,
-0.11041400581598282,
0.748601496219635,
0.5347973108291626,
0.08477091789245605,
0.031497687101364136,
0.7402533292770386,
0.04506296664476395,
0.6604630351066589,
0.46150821447372437,
-0.27334922552108765,
-0.5615535974502563,
-0.002779749222099781,
-0.2742690145969391,
0.44936737418174744,
0.3659246265888214,
-0.23999609053134918,
-0.4194539487361908,
0.18148623406887054,
0.48843806982040405,
0.26970770955085754,
-0.9650036096572876,
0.8158085942268372,
0.13263386487960815,
-0.5093438029289246,
1.3127981424331665,
0.049202028661966324,
0.6031323671340942,
-0.35406744480133057,
0.215201735496521,
-0.6802125573158264,
0.521409809589386,
-0.05789436027407646,
-0.3818295896053314,
0.6492257714271545,
-0.23507149517536163,
-0.5946900844573975,
-0.06489508599042892,
0.36080047488212585,
-0.40244871377944946,
-0.6623444557189941,
0.19239850342273712,
0.12603449821472168,
-0.2308371216058731,
-0.1289256364107132,
-0.5598912239074707,
0.22408849000930786,
0.05796119198203087,
-0.2805059552192688,
0.4374389052391052,
0.43753719329833984,
-0.2670193612575531,
1.1461747884750366,
0.5759226679801941,
-0.05228810012340546,
-0.14198942482471466,
-0.02883788011968136,
1.179049015045166,
-0.8003683686256409,
-0.2953697741031647,
-0.8510088324546814,
0.30687689781188965,
0.303312748670578,
-0.45632806420326233,
0.5724620819091797,
0.5968388319015503,
1.1227622032165527,
-0.045815907418727875,
0.8704147338867188,
0.3355082869529724,
0.24283859133720398,
-0.6842470169067383,
1.1269612312316895,
-0.5164507031440735,
0.4266427457332611,
-0.1922779381275177,
-0.7823815941810608,
-0.8700321912765503,
0.339263916015625,
-0.2061784565448761,
0.0380575992166996,
0.6503540873527527,
0.8311904072761536,
-0.03600063547492027,
-0.09805870056152344,
0.5132129192352295,
0.6997339725494385,
0.1317736655473709,
1.1240613460540771,
0.4072171151638031,
-0.36736196279525757,
0.519592821598053,
-0.15076899528503418,
-0.3622923195362091,
-0.3293263614177704,
-0.793365478515625,
-1.1591390371322632,
-0.7117462754249573,
-0.36316418647766113,
-0.059827134013175964,
0.3728542625904083,
0.5002204179763794,
0.4355681240558624,
-0.8729071617126465,
0.04698282480239868,
-0.1647186577320099,
0.32506027817726135,
-0.3478021025657654,
-0.0635843500494957,
0.3817651867866516,
-0.37543055415153503,
-0.40738001465797424,
0.15557458996772766,
0.4158895015716553,
0.146234393119812,
-0.4058200716972351,
0.026058247312903404,
-0.18512102961540222,
0.27405744791030884,
0.4860990047454834,
0.5553412437438965,
-0.6872353553771973,
-0.4054688811302185,
-0.21731442213058472,
0.13782750070095062,
-0.0386137031018734,
0.8697955012321472,
-0.735146164894104,
0.2874484956264496,
-0.03399299830198288,
0.35147625207901,
0.14774423837661743,
-0.48899972438812256,
0.5502113103866577,
-0.6134284138679504,
0.1478840708732605,
0.1500033587217331,
0.2453315556049347,
0.4938991963863373,
-0.4172993302345276,
0.09244449436664581,
0.22526364028453827,
-0.38062500953674316,
-0.9694307446479797,
0.2948727011680603,
-0.6484801173210144,
-0.338480144739151,
0.9432231187820435,
-0.07694059610366821,
-0.056602708995342255,
-0.16518282890319824,
-0.1275998055934906,
0.08248287439346313,
0.06858254969120026,
1.3603506088256836,
0.8134831786155701,
0.19061456620693207,
-0.18673868477344513,
-0.44108495116233826,
0.726049542427063,
0.3993627429008484,
-0.3169942796230316,
0.6652390956878662,
0.5017798542976379,
0.47081616520881653,
-0.11680427938699722,
0.5169466733932495,
0.12383309751749039,
0.14685982465744019,
-0.21076609194278717,
0.04041232913732529,
-0.1671570986509323,
-0.5666382908821106,
-0.4116552770137787,
0.11113706976175308,
0.29182934761047363,
0.4466073513031006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04834v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04834v2
|
Annotating FrameNet via Structure-Conditioned Language Generation
| 2024-06-07T11:01:15 | 2024-06-25T02:54:19 |
Xinyue Cui, Swabha Swayamdipta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the remarkable generative capabilities of language models in
producing naturalistic language, their effectiveness on explicit manipulation
and generation of linguistic structures remain understudied. In this paper, we
investigate the task of generating new sentences preserving a given semantic
structure, following the FrameNet formalism. We propose a framework to produce
novel frame-semantically annotated sentences following an
overgenerate-and-filter approach. Our results show that conditioning on rich,
explicit semantic information tends to produce generations with high human
acceptance, under both prompting and finetuning. Our generated frame-semantic
structured annotations are effective at training data augmentation for
frame-semantic role labeling in low-resource settings; however, we do not see
benefits under higher resource settings. Our study concludes that while
generating high-quality, semantically rich data might be within reach, the
downstream utility of such generations remains to be seen, highlighting the
outstanding challenges with automating linguistic annotation tasks.
|
[
-0.6535533666610718,
-0.781279981136322,
0.36493006348609924,
0.010264623910188675,
-0.13181059062480927,
-0.33277058601379395,
-0.43114516139030457,
-0.5923425555229187,
0.4284094572067261,
0.7360878586769104,
-0.46305516362190247,
-0.2932153642177582,
-0.425584614276886,
0.3178175687789917,
-0.32099756598472595,
1.103324055671692,
-0.07215488702058792,
-0.1952107697725296,
-0.005568831693381071,
0.053480878472328186,
-0.3600922226905823,
-0.6187628507614136,
-0.395876944065094,
-0.4879903197288513,
0.33574530482292175,
0.23720137774944305,
0.8515660166740417,
0.8199135065078735,
0.14349384605884552,
0.30378270149230957,
-0.12611821293830872,
0.27622148394584656,
-0.38526424765586853,
0.5291651487350464,
-0.16108588874340057,
-0.2528775930404663,
-0.23831823468208313,
0.03044780157506466,
0.8811848759651184,
1.0136747360229492,
0.23359379172325134,
0.0022565042600035667,
-0.132060706615448,
0.509781539440155,
-0.677738606929779,
0.46364280581474304,
-0.8427742123603821,
0.32174330949783325,
-0.29851865768432617,
-0.35574519634246826,
-0.5238819122314453,
0.15648221969604492,
-0.07881414890289307,
-0.7828395366668701,
0.2811746895313263,
0.25490880012512207,
0.7643717527389526,
0.3356960117816925,
-0.29609647393226624,
-0.012089055962860584,
-0.44681018590927124,
0.28383129835128784,
-0.5607439875602722,
0.08626341074705124,
0.7850101590156555,
0.086340993642807,
-0.426447331905365,
-0.5099443197250366,
-0.4287399649620056,
-0.3457583785057068,
-0.4122401773929596,
-0.09639570116996765,
0.12359347939491272,
0.06979470700025558,
0.563477098941803,
0.25656813383102417,
-0.3756701350212097,
0.12473051995038986,
-0.5319468379020691,
-0.3093266487121582,
0.8586724996566772,
-0.046234130859375,
0.4016658663749695,
-0.7897248864173889,
-0.4432634115219116,
0.0034368853084743023,
-0.5994409918785095,
-0.08446849137544632,
0.41011831164360046,
0.4679439961910248,
0.358078271150589,
0.907632052898407,
-0.7790787816047668,
0.517710268497467,
-0.16039703786373138,
0.5695853233337402,
0.30695202946662903,
-0.336391806602478,
-0.26945793628692627,
0.36379751563072205,
0.5722960829734802,
0.39663824439048767,
0.5323413610458374,
-0.2763387858867645,
-0.4346948564052582,
0.334442675113678,
0.25930821895599365,
-0.9700408577919006,
-0.3046816885471344,
0.032348133623600006,
-0.3184433579444885,
-0.3195076882839203,
0.14326024055480957,
-0.47772204875946045,
-0.1410025656223297,
-0.34884580969810486,
0.1771535873413086,
-0.3824326694011688,
-0.19694796204566956,
0.2724980413913727,
-0.34467625617980957,
0.16935995221138,
-0.016573453322052956,
-1.0865017175674438,
-0.006589428521692753,
0.5027385950088501,
0.5171864628791809,
0.18878765404224396,
-0.10304711014032364,
-0.8709360361099243,
0.144208163022995,
-0.41409653425216675,
0.6847773194313049,
-0.546290397644043,
-0.23783336579799652,
0.11065735667943954,
-0.024233192205429077,
0.0025244306307286024,
-0.18963377177715302,
0.3719421327114105,
-0.5876756906509399,
0.24975688755512238,
0.05795488506555557,
-0.5763386487960815,
0.1702585220336914,
0.20367664098739624,
-0.641541063785553,
0.6609964370727539,
-0.03559713810682297,
-0.8652412295341492,
0.6409779191017151,
-0.6737086176872253,
-0.49797481298446655,
0.26747965812683105,
-0.07222653925418854,
-0.30540257692337036,
0.15325526893138885,
0.210317000746727,
0.6458250284194946,
0.04940753057599068,
0.6010828018188477,
-0.3608000874519348,
-0.11547449231147766,
0.5046173334121704,
-0.4135771095752716,
0.4677976667881012,
0.42475154995918274,
-0.369676798582077,
0.06746532768011093,
-0.854517936706543,
0.1836869865655899,
-0.18601202964782715,
-0.376492440700531,
-0.34312427043914795,
-0.04425010457634926,
0.23183304071426392,
0.198564812541008,
-0.15274353325366974,
-0.7712727785110474,
0.19957654178142548,
-0.7888680100440979,
0.7582434415817261,
0.4115467071533203,
0.20813585817813873,
0.568117618560791,
-0.01305368635803461,
0.26111724972724915,
-0.2044314742088318,
-0.04074235260486603,
-0.4763704836368561,
-0.27642396092414856,
-0.6402422189712524,
-0.05850796401500702,
0.1857493817806244,
0.224836066365242,
-0.9661125540733337,
0.3928114175796509,
-0.2426142692565918,
0.1087910383939743,
-0.22525948286056519,
0.11061681061983109,
0.5292816758155823,
0.3157544434070587,
0.44613274931907654,
-0.5664097666740417,
-0.6749320030212402,
-0.9825758934020996,
0.22039982676506042,
-0.09593874961137772,
0.004175479058176279,
-0.003818406257778406,
0.4915928542613983,
-0.24895839393138885,
0.9705080389976501,
-0.3889271020889282,
-0.15260739624500275,
-0.10150591284036636,
0.154007688164711,
-0.2821219265460968,
0.7655551433563232,
0.36434656381607056,
-0.9955132603645325,
0.17671331763267517,
-0.16188926994800568,
-0.6189880967140198,
-0.16933470964431763,
-0.0977603942155838,
-0.40644291043281555,
0.41653910279273987,
0.6057536005973816,
-0.627022922039032,
0.3278602659702301,
0.17922520637512207,
-0.48053810000419617,
0.166318878531456,
-0.09124823659658432,
0.08209460973739624,
-1.210392951965332,
0.2101248800754547,
-0.09141794592142105,
-0.3895007371902466,
-0.42235153913497925,
-0.03253977373242378,
-0.33012986183166504,
-0.37505921721458435,
-0.24117803573608398,
0.5162981748580933,
-0.5152086019515991,
-0.02979847975075245,
-0.3772347867488861,
0.37457507848739624,
0.03447505459189415,
0.6199074983596802,
0.3263512849807739,
0.2360631376504898,
0.27185526490211487,
-0.2689422070980072,
0.2549297511577606,
0.6673051714897156,
-0.24186687171459198,
0.29704347252845764,
-0.4894503057003021,
-0.2118598222732544,
-0.49096280336380005,
0.5453524589538574,
-0.7132530212402344,
-0.7661408185958862,
0.3393388092517853,
-0.46808046102523804,
0.35401543974876404,
-0.17033369839191437,
-0.3180452287197113,
-0.13043485581874847,
-0.261631041765213,
0.29020947217941284,
0.3398425579071045,
-0.29572606086730957,
0.11387572437524796,
0.24318453669548035,
0.03850190341472626,
-0.33819013833999634,
-1.099410057067871,
0.2530052363872528,
-0.08868358284235,
-0.6969881653785706,
0.4286605715751648,
0.2624559998512268,
-0.15566198527812958,
0.3610096573829651,
-0.13000255823135376,
-0.13291215896606445,
0.38123318552970886,
0.5101983547210693,
0.18344935774803162,
-0.42590460181236267,
0.2903355062007904,
0.07334324717521667,
-0.3978961706161499,
0.02241676114499569,
-0.598924458026886,
0.19507339596748352,
0.031176740303635597,
-0.2520873546600342,
-0.3889540433883667,
0.5919650793075562,
0.15078382194042206,
-0.5312929749488831,
0.6431302428245544,
0.6507412791252136,
-0.4482743740081787,
-0.5202327966690063,
-0.2252017706632614,
-0.3458622097969055,
-0.35670357942581177,
0.3118739128112793,
-0.43968358635902405,
-1.2060664892196655,
0.23231559991836548,
0.22445990145206451,
-0.03002678044140339,
0.4920829236507416,
0.4069308042526245,
0.17641399800777435,
0.804735541343689,
0.284195214509964,
0.2967390716075897,
0.5792620182037354,
-0.2755148410797119,
0.01584923267364502,
-0.7389734387397766,
0.033778924494981766,
-0.4446360766887665,
-0.22876298427581787,
-0.7930946350097656,
-0.08890341222286224,
0.09804282337427139,
0.3931267559528351,
-0.22582168877124786,
0.5841560959815979,
-0.5639059543609619,
0.2748056948184967,
0.6251010298728943,
0.1454329490661621,
0.11696682125329971,
-0.0669722706079483,
0.07688348740339279,
0.374043345451355,
-0.703681468963623,
-0.6724420785903931,
0.7802451252937317,
0.07637783885002136,
0.3914949297904968,
-0.09427862614393234,
0.8852701783180237,
0.15221594274044037,
0.2932737171649933,
-0.4942096173763275,
0.4504239857196808,
-0.14335320889949799,
-0.7434923052787781,
-0.4809756577014923,
-0.4566122889518738,
-0.8709979057312012,
0.2334902435541153,
-0.5774668455123901,
-0.7327802181243896,
0.18977800011634827,
0.4577513039112091,
-0.3835817873477936,
-0.019237738102674484,
-0.8320658802986145,
0.988572359085083,
0.15791265666484833,
-0.45933714509010315,
0.001953336177393794,
-1.0167431831359863,
0.4787745475769043,
0.0488046295940876,
-0.026158791035413742,
-0.3738604187965393,
0.3357597291469574,
0.36540696024894714,
-0.44565775990486145,
0.9602310657501221,
-0.358407199382782,
0.27719852328300476,
0.3219435214996338,
0.0653190165758133,
0.1650342047214508,
0.28526678681373596,
-0.17641860246658325,
-0.4212663173675537,
0.0010943047236651182,
-0.37327855825424194,
-0.6509841084480286,
0.4092105031013489,
-0.31673192977905273,
-0.580590546131134,
-0.05382459983229637,
-0.4032268226146698,
-0.2956191599369049,
0.1349053978919983,
0.21649876236915588,
0.8817580342292786,
0.04317925125360489,
0.34401002526283264,
0.47264713048934937,
-0.028145432472229004,
0.5723198056221008,
-0.07292716950178146,
-0.10318858176469803,
-0.44531282782554626,
0.5970334410667419,
0.036802224814891815,
0.34559962153434753,
0.49323001503944397,
0.0992431640625,
-0.16309146583080292,
-0.3954217731952667,
-0.7366513609886169,
-0.225753054022789,
-0.6084447503089905,
-0.3131762742996216,
-0.5841151475906372,
-0.31489816308021545,
-0.27749839425086975,
-0.23532062768936157,
-0.07826688885688782,
-0.875626266002655,
0.020502939820289612,
-0.28481143712997437,
0.45410284399986267,
0.46036502718925476,
0.013225487433373928,
0.11558617651462555,
-0.5764082670211792,
0.15986000001430511,
0.08697867393493652,
0.2000967264175415,
-0.21894100308418274,
-0.011357554234564304,
-0.11404179036617279,
0.11488042771816254,
0.00450139632448554,
-0.47451215982437134,
0.07230529934167862,
0.47310853004455566,
0.5378378033638,
-0.0378413051366806,
0.4064696729183197,
0.38549426198005676,
-0.5559956431388855,
0.8358941078186035,
0.06194311007857323,
-0.859643280506134,
0.664383053779602,
-0.09270364046096802,
0.12324845045804977,
0.468069463968277,
0.062358222901821136,
-0.3718361258506775,
-0.5977872014045715,
-0.5925437808036804,
-1.0865507125854492,
0.6802912354469299,
0.33455362915992737,
0.5541178584098816,
-0.3771120309829712,
0.6385337710380554,
-0.11770009249448776,
0.2738073468208313,
-0.7376710176467896,
0.281862735748291,
-0.5509105324745178,
-0.24707145988941193,
-0.04158196598291397,
-0.32143646478652954,
0.004516292363405228,
0.24668586254119873,
0.796552836894989,
-0.316366046667099,
-0.0026488800067454576,
0.5374293923377991,
-0.34168586134910583,
-0.03487734869122505,
0.48897701501846313,
0.45941320061683655,
0.19410844147205353,
0.17863397300243378,
0.4001631736755371,
-0.1477029174566269,
0.06829816102981567,
-0.004221615381538868,
0.3061490058898926,
-0.5085840821266174,
-0.18585580587387085,
0.6062118411064148,
1.3152620792388916,
0.39768528938293457,
-0.4699188768863678,
0.4396834075450897,
0.3943905532360077,
-0.09327508509159088,
-0.1391107589006424,
0.38918063044548035,
-0.09974826127290726,
0.2936306893825531,
0.041783615946769714,
0.07488589733839035,
0.10708294808864594,
-0.5067748427391052,
0.5683103799819946,
0.41155752539634705,
-0.1325320452451706,
-0.25939109921455383,
0.9946116805076599,
0.21715667843818665,
-0.1783951371908188,
0.5153934955596924,
-0.418626606464386,
-0.5758281350135803,
0.15476538240909576,
0.4955350458621979,
0.8992858529090881,
0.21612976491451263,
0.2530381381511688,
0.3940923810005188,
0.030195772647857666,
-0.17806951701641083,
-0.10229697823524475,
-0.6225408315658569,
-0.9601667523384094,
-0.6639537215232849,
-1.0093032121658325,
-0.009295531548559666,
-0.49279066920280457,
-0.5503964424133301,
0.07297862321138382,
-0.16697172820568085,
-0.3658507466316223,
0.31489309668540955,
-0.13303327560424805,
-0.3214954435825348,
0.2675136625766754,
0.44818630814552307,
0.7154923677444458,
-0.771990954875946,
0.8615686297416687,
0.5990466475486755,
-0.8740248084068298,
-0.8838082551956177,
-0.20858295261859894,
-0.3525739908218384,
-0.5493161678314209,
0.909856915473938,
0.3976294994354248,
-0.05663655325770378,
-0.025697700679302216,
-0.35736703872680664,
-0.5032119154930115,
0.8060445189476013,
0.46202990412712097,
-0.11184912919998169,
-0.22536687552928925,
0.08827636390924454,
0.6861652135848999,
-0.4837896227836609,
-0.16606226563453674,
0.23459017276763916,
0.5404242277145386,
0.22280476987361908,
-0.7032531499862671,
0.24092988669872284,
-0.6307551860809326,
0.5516299605369568,
0.22027988731861115,
-0.13783687353134155,
0.43650466203689575,
0.07062891870737076,
-0.3005586266517639,
0.10248485952615738,
0.757657527923584,
-0.09135619550943375,
0.15523195266723633,
0.5713314414024353,
0.4255051016807556,
0.34835073351860046,
-0.00427505886182189,
0.9734349846839905,
-0.2867552936077118,
0.18437699973583221,
1.0192461013793945,
-0.26959243416786194,
0.8578054904937744,
0.3878454566001892,
0.46564731001853943,
0.22371932864189148,
0.5009417533874512,
-0.09538402408361435,
0.29420205950737,
0.5999534130096436,
-0.08547976613044739,
-0.44613057374954224,
-0.2724445164203644,
0.06341468542814255,
0.48505082726478577,
0.1290431022644043,
-0.4094739258289337,
-0.24175035953521729,
0.4966795742511749,
0.06503308564424515,
0.46877211332321167,
-0.2218865603208542,
0.6541297435760498,
0.04810846224427223,
-0.8275314569473267,
0.4639444649219513,
0.019895736128091812,
0.5524821281433105,
-0.379340261220932,
0.04461416229605675,
-0.08454002439975739,
-0.14263175427913666,
-0.4360559284687042,
-0.6439595222473145,
0.726518988609314,
0.08643288165330887,
-0.3358151614665985,
-0.6604594588279724,
0.7447815537452698,
-0.7744640707969666,
-0.2850795090198517,
0.0351220965385437,
0.18605563044548035,
0.1353255957365036,
0.17427301406860352,
-0.028316128998994827,
0.10827412456274033,
-0.15991927683353424,
-0.5942970514297485,
0.05479685217142105,
0.5047478079795837,
-0.4293798506259918,
0.26604676246643066,
0.551335334777832,
0.20108343660831451,
0.2182697355747223,
0.04344367980957031,
0.6622549295425415,
-0.4594668745994568,
-0.3690526485443115,
-0.6758443117141724,
0.6614943742752075,
-0.19245992600917816,
-0.41615167260169983,
0.46605390310287476,
0.37509557604789734,
1.1351836919784546,
0.06348196417093277,
0.5155841112136841,
-0.29702040553092957,
-0.10277467966079712,
-0.9317792654037476,
0.624006450176239,
-0.34050682187080383,
-0.02488725446164608,
-0.058030594140291214,
-0.8090551495552063,
-0.5196844339370728,
0.5615164041519165,
-0.29005491733551025,
-0.2152002900838852,
0.4728497862815857,
0.8150869011878967,
0.043594710528850555,
0.25816529989242554,
0.2713377773761749,
0.027274997904896736,
0.26634812355041504,
0.526624321937561,
0.6716009974479675,
-0.1972712129354477,
0.21229055523872375,
-0.18427439033985138,
-0.0553448423743248,
-0.03304054215550423,
-0.8542520403862,
-0.781826376914978,
-0.9238179326057434,
-0.4415285289287567,
-0.25936588644981384,
0.1517464816570282,
1.2922115325927734,
0.9182286858558655,
-0.758969783782959,
0.28197434544563293,
-0.38836365938186646,
-0.26029178500175476,
0.14597654342651367,
-0.19230909645557404,
0.2930791974067688,
-0.8212906122207642,
-0.6147750020027161,
0.44089341163635254,
0.11466119438409805,
-0.032250113785266876,
-0.44713646173477173,
0.22884173691272736,
0.02138378471136093,
-0.1786259412765503,
0.6650219559669495,
0.17608968913555145,
-0.5764070749282837,
-0.807746410369873,
-0.2774577736854553,
-0.2022172510623932,
-0.157173752784729,
0.9143713712692261,
-0.7937062978744507,
0.3997936248779297,
0.5644399523735046,
0.9705492258071899,
0.5962545871734619,
0.052859123796224594,
0.7166576385498047,
-0.9600160717964172,
0.24183887243270874,
0.10396922379732132,
0.4944341480731964,
0.5146918296813965,
-0.3411123752593994,
0.4494166672229767,
0.14871594309806824,
-0.3295738697052002,
-0.7640204429626465,
0.44826260209083557,
-0.7020022869110107,
-0.2343924641609192,
1.2109178304672241,
-0.17637571692466736,
-0.32030099630355835,
0.15268447995185852,
-0.14819860458374023,
0.3934183418750763,
-0.14916324615478516,
0.4818224310874939,
0.5210855007171631,
-0.09102480113506317,
0.18189822137355804,
-0.5726221799850464,
0.6056820154190063,
0.3370736837387085,
-0.6814793348312378,
0.20598329603672028,
0.9615380167961121,
0.0639970526099205,
0.2916457951068878,
0.4115764796733856,
-0.04284002631902695,
-0.017616774886846542,
0.09774511307477951,
0.06527350842952728,
-0.48604366183280945,
-0.23081432282924652,
-0.11645085364580154,
0.44125279784202576,
0.05803747847676277,
-0.2627238631248474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04823v1
|
BERTs are Generative In-Context Learners
| 2024-06-07T10:48:45 | 2024-06-07T10:48:45 |
David Samuel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores the in-context learning capabilities of masked language
models, challenging the common view that this ability does not 'emerge' in
them. We present an embarrassingly simple inference technique that enables
DeBERTa to operate as a generative model without any additional training. Our
findings demonstrate that DeBERTa can match and even surpass GPT-3, its
contemporary that famously introduced the paradigm of in-context learning. The
comparative analysis reveals that the masked and causal language models behave
very differently, as they clearly outperform each other on different categories
of tasks. This suggests that there is great potential for a hybrid training
approach that takes advantage of the strengths of both training objectives.
|
[
-0.31669992208480835,
-0.7838426828384399,
0.641866147518158,
0.3031032085418701,
-0.3396623730659485,
0.29281237721443176,
0.002654118463397026,
-0.4768909215927124,
0.09101323783397675,
0.23038126528263092,
-0.5270571112632751,
-0.1698351800441742,
-0.6963170766830444,
-0.10919259488582611,
-0.5680065155029297,
0.9908923506736755,
0.270624041557312,
0.20478825271129608,
0.13122254610061646,
0.04592215269804001,
-0.5982998609542847,
-0.6004564762115479,
-0.5035221576690674,
-0.3196523189544678,
0.34110140800476074,
0.12708574533462524,
0.6508282423019409,
0.040472909808158875,
-0.19381554424762726,
0.14285357296466827,
-0.06082577630877495,
0.10470478981733322,
-0.3651358187198639,
0.20770341157913208,
0.005385412368923426,
-0.35233166813850403,
0.1299615204334259,
0.1066928431391716,
0.6933268308639526,
0.8926160335540771,
0.2389695644378662,
-0.3793693780899048,
0.3595905900001526,
0.5952133536338806,
-0.6888816952705383,
0.05544158071279526,
-1.1628754138946533,
0.06844998896121979,
0.10442649573087692,
0.26024478673934937,
-0.6664387583732605,
-0.29441142082214355,
0.3051772713661194,
-0.3556276261806488,
0.4543895423412323,
-0.40151113271713257,
1.0113804340362549,
0.11982885748147964,
-0.4909997582435608,
-0.23620787262916565,
-1.0119702816009521,
0.6552241444587708,
-0.4372495710849762,
0.24769841134548187,
0.35898199677467346,
0.3876253068447113,
-0.18549451231956482,
-0.7263950109481812,
-0.9124924540519714,
-0.28567934036254883,
-0.2541157901287079,
0.04628705233335495,
-0.2805403769016266,
-0.01823003590106964,
0.3430001139640808,
0.11156871914863586,
-0.4635668396949768,
0.13553202152252197,
-0.462258517742157,
0.24090924859046936,
0.27341142296791077,
-0.3443340063095093,
0.33232784271240234,
-0.11140558123588562,
-0.7143650054931641,
-0.13431718945503235,
-1.053321123123169,
-0.06677425652742386,
0.2705978453159332,
0.1742386668920517,
-0.14894509315490723,
0.04991864040493965,
0.2070685774087906,
0.9001030921936035,
-0.02710786834359169,
0.27868616580963135,
0.0743754506111145,
0.5594080686569214,
-0.6575239896774292,
0.015862783417105675,
0.32844269275665283,
-0.38391992449760437,
0.05837753415107727,
-0.5016844868659973,
-0.1318495124578476,
0.1366208791732788,
0.19885164499282837,
-0.5243734121322632,
-0.554395318031311,
0.15502582490444183,
-0.09477056562900543,
-0.18930725753307343,
0.16178686916828156,
-0.40453025698661804,
-0.046758998185396194,
-0.25977444648742676,
0.9617699980735779,
-0.5648727416992188,
-0.11884216964244843,
-0.10134527832269669,
-0.15518248081207275,
0.49335387349128723,
0.4407247304916382,
-1.3664054870605469,
0.22486574947834015,
0.6683385968208313,
0.6555305123329163,
0.3467067778110504,
-0.1338394582271576,
-0.38639217615127563,
0.1730131357908249,
-0.48926621675491333,
0.3647364377975464,
-0.5363887548446655,
-0.21676622331142426,
0.21077224612236023,
-0.007688532117754221,
-0.3962410092353821,
-0.375538170337677,
0.32994717359542847,
-0.8432292342185974,
0.20050252974033356,
-0.455384224653244,
-0.46033504605293274,
-0.5208383798599243,
-0.17211119830608368,
-0.5454684495925903,
0.9495243430137634,
0.3682444393634796,
-0.7131510376930237,
0.7789756655693054,
-0.4717363119125366,
-0.45136311650276184,
0.4332745373249054,
-0.3784787356853485,
-0.1941274106502533,
0.11169219762086868,
0.3671281337738037,
0.6343681216239929,
0.17916862666606903,
0.5318880081176758,
-0.2780473530292511,
-0.4958462715148926,
0.3190396726131439,
-0.3933607339859009,
1.331213355064392,
0.2374178022146225,
-0.8749853372573853,
-0.16284659504890442,
-0.7418620586395264,
-0.12379879504442215,
0.11774289608001709,
-0.15245205163955688,
-0.6867720484733582,
0.2646212875843048,
-0.02922055870294571,
0.41471272706985474,
-0.20437245070934296,
-0.667478084564209,
0.2166386991739273,
-0.37590935826301575,
0.7133293151855469,
0.7083575129508972,
-0.3056636452674866,
0.31200069189071655,
-0.1021057590842247,
0.24199408292770386,
-0.254158079624176,
0.04125264286994934,
0.14374101161956787,
-0.7026658058166504,
-1.0317115783691406,
-0.8811596632003784,
0.40223759412765503,
0.4916040301322937,
-1.066612958908081,
0.5552296042442322,
0.052432265132665634,
-0.42857179045677185,
-0.41697636246681213,
0.1621602177619934,
0.49110734462738037,
0.5937197208404541,
0.2970583736896515,
-0.30049261450767517,
-0.5780914425849915,
-1.1294904947280884,
0.07771787792444229,
-0.058321721851825714,
-0.35460424423217773,
0.0899130254983902,
0.7104213237762451,
-0.23373191058635712,
0.9711751341819763,
-0.24352940917015076,
-0.12980474531650543,
-0.4762459099292755,
0.2130626142024994,
0.14974449574947357,
0.6852672696113586,
0.8984195590019226,
-0.8157403469085693,
-0.47604289650917053,
-0.3444890081882477,
-1.0901110172271729,
0.051531340926885605,
-0.08268731087446213,
-0.0736241415143013,
0.18248896300792694,
0.45854514837265015,
-0.3669501841068268,
0.331926554441452,
0.627101719379425,
-0.026442736387252808,
0.000965698272921145,
-0.33340075612068176,
-0.2766284942626953,
-0.8134487867355347,
-0.03882768005132675,
-0.20159752666950226,
-0.13218605518341064,
-0.9525380730628967,
0.12707649171352386,
0.38953542709350586,
-0.26434382796287537,
-0.5295300483703613,
0.4875533878803253,
-0.41836756467819214,
-0.08289878070354462,
-0.22021430730819702,
0.20651358366012573,
0.012213757261633873,
0.6097762584686279,
0.41772404313087463,
0.44354113936424255,
0.8901301622390747,
-0.6265884637832642,
-0.2143091857433319,
0.426411509513855,
-0.7343540787696838,
0.24095481634140015,
-0.5997879505157471,
0.30417928099632263,
-0.32107552886009216,
0.539398729801178,
-1.1562368869781494,
-0.4376806914806366,
0.30472317337989807,
-0.1328018754720688,
0.47317567467689514,
-0.18555739521980286,
-0.6139659881591797,
-0.32358208298683167,
-0.19590401649475098,
0.3107171058654785,
0.9692569971084595,
-1.013147234916687,
0.3430752456188202,
0.22528137266635895,
0.0795450434088707,
-0.5281370282173157,
-0.679049015045166,
0.017624331638216972,
-0.40961048007011414,
-0.5372578501701355,
0.4374386668205261,
0.0812956839799881,
-0.307611882686615,
-0.20786763727664948,
0.20547570288181305,
-0.30173540115356445,
0.30148595571517944,
0.16226544976234436,
0.28059905767440796,
-0.07850383967161179,
0.2633814811706543,
0.21125780045986176,
0.26556915044784546,
-0.15216459333896637,
-0.14030049741268158,
0.29811257123947144,
-0.018428370356559753,
-0.3433637320995331,
-0.16382057964801788,
0.480752170085907,
0.37359094619750977,
-0.04572741687297821,
1.0533815622329712,
0.38526538014411926,
-0.40909332036972046,
-0.42387503385543823,
-0.5197842717170715,
-0.29125672578811646,
-0.42303311824798584,
-0.009339096955955029,
-0.27767279744148254,
-0.7787621021270752,
0.601699709892273,
0.35606569051742554,
-0.17529843747615814,
0.35647258162498474,
0.5440049171447754,
-0.28696388006210327,
0.7999879121780396,
0.7090655565261841,
0.11992646753787994,
0.6426802277565002,
-0.35496318340301514,
0.30478742718696594,
-0.9101524353027344,
-0.37235671281814575,
-0.37798523902893066,
-0.1493532508611679,
-0.5978562235832214,
-0.12260893732309341,
0.6915091872215271,
0.3761419653892517,
-0.398504376411438,
0.6240369081497192,
-0.4965415298938751,
0.5358802080154419,
0.8091432452201843,
0.5312697887420654,
-0.018311120569705963,
-0.11311524361371994,
0.056869328022003174,
-0.00819870363920927,
-0.9105789661407471,
-0.5380605459213257,
0.9623306393623352,
0.4219606816768646,
0.6882573962211609,
0.38811543583869934,
0.7341151833534241,
0.24330270290374756,
0.5560281872749329,
-0.3076605200767517,
0.3623298406600952,
0.02028787136077881,
-1.0414785146713257,
-0.19006270170211792,
0.15704742074012756,
-0.9585089683532715,
0.7729638814926147,
-0.10456602275371552,
-1.1267262697219849,
0.5111643075942993,
0.25574901700019836,
-0.37219154834747314,
0.4317169785499573,
-0.9384561777114868,
0.785982608795166,
-0.1349358856678009,
-0.502169132232666,
0.0669960156083107,
-1.015773057937622,
0.718498706817627,
-0.26259705424308777,
0.09706039726734161,
0.006598052568733692,
0.36030223965644836,
0.5843428373336792,
-0.21562735736370087,
1.4469995498657227,
-0.3353017568588257,
-0.2786984443664551,
0.44007647037506104,
0.36539381742477417,
0.4616653621196747,
-0.017019493505358696,
0.3126118779182434,
0.106296606361866,
-0.16277112066745758,
-0.6368248462677002,
-0.6138445734977722,
0.546851634979248,
-0.7124250531196594,
-0.6421655416488647,
-0.47214892506599426,
-0.41608479619026184,
-0.35037869215011597,
-0.16991794109344482,
0.3469719886779785,
0.5317891240119934,
-0.2938787341117859,
0.17917990684509277,
0.8669313788414001,
-0.21781671047210693,
0.6612459421157837,
0.6746833920478821,
0.07912857830524445,
-0.04451209306716919,
0.6381912231445312,
-0.09989722818136215,
0.6060940027236938,
0.5630400776863098,
-0.001542058540508151,
-0.3889029920101166,
-0.24858728051185608,
-0.5420763492584229,
0.06179817393422127,
-1.0988482236862183,
0.13708752393722534,
-0.7913807034492493,
-0.29872649908065796,
-0.20662498474121094,
-0.5852993130683899,
0.038941625505685806,
-0.3951786160469055,
-0.24607767164707184,
-0.10591264069080353,
-0.03513755276799202,
0.8992161154747009,
-0.31322774291038513,
0.3304726481437683,
-0.5584489703178406,
0.002821447094902396,
0.9244067072868347,
-0.1564013659954071,
0.18178854882717133,
-0.5732995867729187,
-0.047157492488622665,
-0.11349119991064072,
-0.5623363256454468,
-1.1057584285736084,
0.42407888174057007,
0.3535485863685608,
0.6829150319099426,
0.49473199248313904,
-0.07416082173585892,
0.332610547542572,
-0.44580939412117004,
0.9358229637145996,
-0.10446473956108093,
-1.2943891286849976,
0.6434194445610046,
-0.5157636404037476,
-0.13788893818855286,
0.3562409579753876,
0.5732572674751282,
-0.18139973282814026,
-0.6257532238960266,
-0.9295698404312134,
-0.8170472979545593,
0.5275052785873413,
0.5464730262756348,
0.5648244619369507,
-0.3720724582672119,
-0.03793555498123169,
0.4393938183784485,
0.26948368549346924,
-1.2887473106384277,
-0.029438624158501625,
-0.33505114912986755,
0.20678353309631348,
-0.1816006898880005,
-0.43577054142951965,
-0.29384687542915344,
-0.5862929224967957,
0.7098537683486938,
-0.07570268958806992,
0.4080844223499298,
0.2678530812263489,
-0.3966454863548279,
0.26053372025489807,
0.21850243210792542,
0.9288282990455627,
0.9131630659103394,
-0.6074895858764648,
0.30404341220855713,
0.1861313283443451,
-0.011765293776988983,
0.1296343356370926,
-0.014161455444991589,
-0.25726136565208435,
0.08575540781021118,
0.6753549575805664,
0.8345732688903809,
0.5235884189605713,
-0.6019245386123657,
0.642160952091217,
0.31094542145729065,
-0.19334982335567474,
-0.3851855397224426,
0.016406118869781494,
-0.24284330010414124,
0.2718609571456909,
0.5648819804191589,
-0.17518477141857147,
-0.03406371548771858,
-0.6870374083518982,
0.2528541088104248,
0.6731230020523071,
-0.5628972053527832,
-0.34710875153541565,
0.9004257321357727,
0.3561675250530243,
-0.025494320318102837,
0.43083810806274414,
-0.28969693183898926,
-0.6986894607543945,
0.5802013278007507,
0.8607592582702637,
1.3153156042099,
-0.09710126370191574,
0.37593838572502136,
0.17009620368480682,
0.3913833498954773,
0.24526219069957733,
0.05435574799776077,
-0.37672752141952515,
-0.9193487763404846,
-0.2297334372997284,
-0.46489444375038147,
-0.47172811627388,
0.47251594066619873,
-0.5704506635665894,
-0.014186860993504524,
-0.27107560634613037,
0.4290185570716858,
0.17238390445709229,
-0.5786795020103455,
-0.6332697868347168,
0.16496609151363373,
0.13982389867305756,
0.6673083305358887,
-1.3753241300582886,
1.2675551176071167,
0.20433610677719116,
-0.49466612935066223,
-0.5364541411399841,
0.2110353708267212,
-0.3288952708244324,
-0.991725742816925,
1.3310266733169556,
0.31117066740989685,
-0.0789954736828804,
0.008004534989595413,
-0.7019001245498657,
-0.43167078495025635,
0.7213367819786072,
0.4964814782142639,
-0.3064447343349457,
0.08798621594905853,
-0.3890041708946228,
0.5648316144943237,
-0.5154238939285278,
0.08713964372873306,
0.5203211903572083,
0.18680673837661743,
0.04793314263224602,
-0.7565262913703918,
-0.054861489683389664,
0.21782216429710388,
0.1830853968858719,
-0.06187918409705162,
-0.4763363301753998,
1.1374150514602661,
-0.06311244517564774,
-0.3571169674396515,
-0.0037780979182571173,
0.4412182867527008,
-0.24936971068382263,
-0.06188861280679703,
0.4679655432701111,
0.4971100986003876,
0.47934046387672424,
-0.06540267914533615,
1.0973840951919556,
0.005521024577319622,
0.4580881893634796,
0.9413922429084778,
-0.362926721572876,
0.6922082901000977,
0.4472000300884247,
-0.1973559558391571,
0.9264832735061646,
0.6679149866104126,
0.142988383769989,
1.124587059020996,
0.21703195571899414,
-0.8519169092178345,
-0.4386526644229889,
0.3149719834327698,
-0.3468480408191681,
0.6158837080001831,
0.2686667740345001,
-0.5470916032791138,
-0.39832109212875366,
0.22883163392543793,
0.12962277233600616,
0.14790943264961243,
-0.09385919570922852,
0.6171173453330994,
0.021525869145989418,
-0.7418416738510132,
0.9179784059524536,
-0.26235851645469666,
0.4070778787136078,
-0.5600659251213074,
-0.18717822432518005,
-0.2063593864440918,
0.2263002097606659,
0.16108490526676178,
-0.39685171842575073,
0.22284053266048431,
-0.19583329558372498,
-0.02442149817943573,
-0.1894940435886383,
0.4955185353755951,
-0.4161381721496582,
-0.41977691650390625,
0.31485381722450256,
0.5038840770721436,
0.22448080778121948,
0.048105817288160324,
-0.373948335647583,
-0.12760856747627258,
-0.09930773824453354,
0.17726360261440277,
0.3748740255832672,
0.23806801438331604,
-0.12354934215545654,
0.6893532276153564,
0.32201457023620605,
-0.359943151473999,
-0.03861909732222557,
-0.04282794147729874,
0.9601832628250122,
-0.3384300470352173,
-0.4856123924255371,
-1.0909860134124756,
0.416972815990448,
0.10763934999704361,
-0.15599405765533447,
0.6772564649581909,
0.30958226323127747,
0.9821745753288269,
-0.49536895751953125,
0.8904922604560852,
-0.36369913816452026,
0.34651613235473633,
-0.7895375490188599,
0.6419734358787537,
-0.3385782837867737,
0.1203930526971817,
-0.5214605331420898,
-0.8513450622558594,
-0.24643771350383759,
0.8185580968856812,
-0.4105384945869446,
0.0003404329181648791,
0.669110894203186,
0.629907488822937,
-0.13281571865081787,
-0.03906136006116867,
0.585913360118866,
-0.05469447001814842,
0.3630272448062897,
0.8289738893508911,
0.9890778064727783,
-0.372792512178421,
-0.03648166358470917,
-0.09160254895687103,
-0.45396867394447327,
-0.2900782823562622,
-1.0439361333847046,
-1.3266100883483887,
-0.993724524974823,
-0.024594884365797043,
-0.3238963782787323,
0.11854622513055801,
0.7093896269798279,
0.896665632724762,
-0.8386653065681458,
0.1524130254983902,
-0.21654371917247772,
0.13225002586841583,
-0.4317759573459625,
-0.19849154353141785,
0.5774083137512207,
-0.5064764618873596,
-0.9247230887413025,
0.6551913022994995,
-0.04850491136312485,
0.3107297420501709,
-0.44171735644340515,
0.16260981559753418,
-0.22867697477340698,
0.21651169657707214,
0.8542671203613281,
0.5478125214576721,
-0.9874545335769653,
-0.7257825136184692,
-0.4909036159515381,
-0.011801166459918022,
-0.10717709362506866,
0.7934092879295349,
-1.0754306316375732,
0.7120354771614075,
0.12865403294563293,
0.5142609477043152,
0.7025749087333679,
-0.24866518378257751,
0.5337615013122559,
-0.9670932292938232,
0.7117027044296265,
0.1890639364719391,
0.27075496315956116,
0.3810051679611206,
-0.10760227590799332,
0.4320605397224426,
0.2571885883808136,
-0.2879831790924072,
-0.8784410357475281,
0.4460025131702423,
-0.8279417753219604,
-0.4580637812614441,
1.0008289813995361,
-0.281442254781723,
0.14903247356414795,
-0.28442302346229553,
-0.11570898443460464,
0.017458012327551842,
-0.04291302710771561,
1.0979177951812744,
0.5424350500106812,
-0.21852368116378784,
0.21687477827072144,
-0.9068114161491394,
0.7214841842651367,
0.47925448417663574,
-0.4245486259460449,
-0.2178223431110382,
0.18903674185276031,
0.3777642548084259,
0.045916296541690826,
0.6716110706329346,
0.30285391211509705,
0.07082768529653549,
0.005840404890477657,
-0.043970052152872086,
0.25665283203125,
-0.5285607576370239,
-0.3587875962257385,
0.17347794771194458,
0.03252192586660385,
-0.653111457824707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04800v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04800v1
|
Zero, Finite, and Infinite Belief History of Theory of Mind Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-07T10:04:39 | 2024-06-07T10:04:39 |
Weizhi Tang, Vaishak Belle
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently shown a promise and emergence of
Theory of Mind (ToM) ability and even outperform humans in certain ToM tasks.
To evaluate and extend the boundaries of the ToM reasoning ability of LLMs, we
propose a novel concept, taxonomy, and framework, the ToM reasoning with Zero,
Finite, and Infinite Belief History and develop a multi-round text-based game,
called $\textit{Pick the Right Stuff}$, as a benchmark. We have evaluated six
LLMs with this game and found their performance on Zero Belief History is
consistently better than on Finite Belief History. In addition, we have found
two of the models with small parameter sizes outperform all the evaluated
models with large parameter sizes. We expect this work to pave the way for
future ToM benchmark development and also for the promotion and development of
more complex AI agents or systems which are required to be equipped with more
complex ToM reasoning ability.
|
[
-0.6929178833961487,
-0.9455211162567139,
1.272674560546875,
-0.13105055689811707,
-0.20363451540470123,
-0.08250242471694946,
-0.4532968997955322,
-0.49804964661598206,
0.21013057231903076,
0.6028285026550293,
-0.4723774790763855,
-0.1868007630109787,
-0.44557496905326843,
-0.09391376376152039,
-0.1458359658718109,
0.8562120199203491,
0.1588589996099472,
0.10811440646648407,
-0.3438631594181061,
-0.282674103975296,
-0.5899648666381836,
-0.6950462460517883,
-0.7013968229293823,
-0.6994425058364868,
0.5144755840301514,
0.1357562094926834,
0.8060981035232544,
0.6571546196937561,
0.5697344541549683,
0.19909492135047913,
0.028149446472525597,
0.1016291081905365,
-0.3071722090244293,
0.37014877796173096,
-0.5111473798751831,
-0.7847098112106323,
-0.5763092637062073,
0.21754097938537598,
0.6951991319656372,
0.4036291837692261,
-0.1141008585691452,
0.020513467490673065,
-0.2756962776184082,
0.38210028409957886,
-0.36338523030281067,
-0.04795147478580475,
-0.6270180344581604,
0.12752842903137207,
-0.007363470736891031,
-0.48753684759140015,
-0.5642839074134827,
-0.5501315593719482,
0.29156044125556946,
-0.5979216694831848,
0.09085320681333542,
0.32906588912010193,
0.6194742321968079,
0.190779447555542,
-0.47560790181159973,
-0.12421931326389313,
-0.7192317247390747,
0.9968215227127075,
-0.6968851685523987,
0.40293991565704346,
0.3807922303676605,
0.49925145506858826,
-0.4333066940307617,
-0.3394302725791931,
-0.8804746866226196,
-0.2901659905910492,
0.4518143832683563,
-0.014969736337661743,
0.009363306686282158,
0.2786281108856201,
0.4045395851135254,
0.4414420425891876,
-0.5371114611625671,
-0.1323569416999817,
0.022628160193562508,
0.058694321662187576,
0.8424376845359802,
0.11317897588014603,
0.1985088586807251,
0.24545621871948242,
-0.3702429533004761,
-0.11525312811136246,
-0.5941137671470642,
-0.376198410987854,
-0.0751175731420517,
0.14727340638637543,
0.18936435878276825,
0.5442871451377869,
-0.2769743800163269,
0.6387596726417542,
0.11380025744438171,
-0.2638342082500458,
0.004366123583167791,
0.0768556296825409,
-0.41915860772132874,
-0.3174078166484833,
0.548393189907074,
0.32439112663269043,
0.6628966927528381,
-0.28688979148864746,
-0.21237803995609283,
0.18616485595703125,
0.31999528408050537,
-0.4884488582611084,
0.056211333721876144,
0.18329916894435883,
-0.5019450187683105,
-0.03451208397746086,
-0.28537124395370483,
-0.6812519431114197,
-0.6215308308601379,
-0.0612306147813797,
0.4298517405986786,
-0.6966058015823364,
-0.4124957323074341,
0.367084264755249,
-0.315433531999588,
0.29578688740730286,
0.503529965877533,
-0.7442716956138611,
0.1967190057039261,
0.7086509466171265,
0.6787956953048706,
-0.27441564202308655,
-0.35023102164268494,
-0.11478665471076965,
0.3248412311077118,
-0.5670948624610901,
0.9981123208999634,
-0.6813908219337463,
-0.38304731249809265,
-0.01101192831993103,
-0.4232059419155121,
0.09594599157571793,
-0.3058632016181946,
0.5335562229156494,
-0.6174792051315308,
0.3947128355503082,
-0.47650113701820374,
-1.0679829120635986,
-0.4636019766330719,
0.5538109540939331,
-0.39872294664382935,
0.6527354717254639,
-0.2106056809425354,
-0.2791348397731781,
0.5626389384269714,
-0.8527676463127136,
-0.4000933766365051,
0.5322884321212769,
-0.5353216528892517,
0.14535561203956604,
0.17640992999076843,
-0.18994078040122986,
0.5541892647743225,
-0.7100619673728943,
0.6316714882850647,
-0.8916093111038208,
-0.45400139689445496,
0.20200976729393005,
-0.5819147229194641,
0.9424793720245361,
0.20166662335395813,
-0.3852499723434448,
-0.11293356120586395,
-0.5882908701896667,
0.4161263704299927,
0.3563156723976135,
-0.2799732983112335,
-0.4641081988811493,
0.21479281783103943,
-0.45131149888038635,
0.20861473679542542,
0.24467386305332184,
-0.39101114869117737,
0.5160524249076843,
-0.21581816673278809,
0.3604527711868286,
0.7462190389633179,
0.15945391356945038,
0.32843711972236633,
-0.6753531694412231,
0.5228886604309082,
-0.37494662404060364,
0.15743906795978546,
-0.11994544416666031,
-0.7981274127960205,
-0.7153602838516235,
-0.14173373579978943,
0.11104750633239746,
0.3734053075313568,
-0.5320888161659241,
0.7003633975982666,
-0.17787180840969086,
-0.405875027179718,
-0.07426401227712631,
-0.3636387586593628,
0.3528203070163727,
-0.027415728196501732,
0.1501954197883606,
-0.290509432554245,
-0.27624326944351196,
-0.8192354440689087,
-0.13641589879989624,
-0.5599815249443054,
-0.11015262454748154,
0.3967495560646057,
0.6023798584938049,
-0.024774450808763504,
1.0047906637191772,
-0.6276445388793945,
-0.1385815590620041,
-0.1535656899213791,
0.0013007917441427708,
0.10622182488441467,
0.43301478028297424,
0.6057782769203186,
-0.7640103697776794,
0.14575175940990448,
0.011147042736411095,
-0.8636084794998169,
0.3716858923435211,
-0.14640438556671143,
-0.23022118210792542,
0.22879628837108612,
0.1095171570777893,
-0.9273186326026917,
0.2574022710323334,
0.21507099270820618,
-0.5543739199638367,
0.3875496983528137,
-0.27531567215919495,
0.18781034648418427,
-1.0355037450790405,
-0.052453864365816116,
0.055202629417181015,
-0.233524888753891,
-0.6101742386817932,
0.6101292967796326,
0.02774219401180744,
0.34676292538642883,
-0.06206822022795677,
0.6827177405357361,
-0.34220218658447266,
-0.07210376858711243,
-0.0938810259103775,
0.3250901401042938,
-0.17643673717975616,
0.6716508865356445,
0.18414726853370667,
0.48840004205703735,
0.2258666455745697,
-0.8018090128898621,
0.5119321346282959,
0.029964210465550423,
-0.3538755178451538,
0.8104335069656372,
-0.2519760727882385,
0.2575938403606415,
-0.043901700526475906,
0.3116197884082794,
-0.9914793968200684,
-0.07695471495389938,
0.13427457213401794,
-0.5248599052429199,
0.10194709897041321,
0.30983278155326843,
-0.6455774903297424,
-0.48070427775382996,
-0.08051719516515732,
0.25724783539772034,
0.5359529256820679,
-0.29528313875198364,
0.6444351077079773,
0.451754093170166,
0.10123629868030548,
-0.2842848300933838,
-0.5236897468566895,
0.12274903804063797,
-0.41879841685295105,
-0.2931376099586487,
0.15040668845176697,
-0.715544581413269,
-0.46789538860321045,
-0.11553001403808594,
-0.1389305591583252,
-0.42308756709098816,
0.02308577299118042,
0.029940448701381683,
0.195038840174675,
-0.30354639887809753,
0.4843212068080902,
0.00002661291728145443,
0.09230447560548782,
0.19336658716201782,
-0.6054836511611938,
0.45891228318214417,
-0.19148419797420502,
-0.40194451808929443,
0.15454524755477905,
0.09906018525362015,
0.7317979335784912,
-0.10531675070524216,
0.4317389130592346,
-0.13768520951271057,
-0.666557788848877,
-0.3846721351146698,
-0.9530848860740662,
-0.16041746735572815,
-0.3990578353404999,
0.2911890149116516,
-0.5630840063095093,
-0.9950419068336487,
0.474922239780426,
0.0013659908436238766,
0.1307387799024582,
0.5079166889190674,
0.6308311223983765,
0.04991954192519188,
1.1125881671905518,
0.7647674679756165,
-0.02399042248725891,
0.10714545845985413,
0.026844751089811325,
0.08655697852373123,
-0.5312487483024597,
-0.08994223922491074,
-0.29257214069366455,
-0.04401428997516632,
-0.23783420026302338,
-0.5910645723342896,
0.1449093520641327,
0.1160844936966896,
-0.5201711654663086,
0.023972708731889725,
-0.3919473886489868,
0.7395895719528198,
0.39049455523490906,
0.03241977468132973,
0.49228134751319885,
-0.2589235305786133,
-0.4955088198184967,
0.025390809401869774,
-0.5895239114761353,
-0.6024247407913208,
1.1927943229675293,
0.451842337846756,
0.21580305695533752,
0.17530547082424164,
0.4680168330669403,
0.6787353754043579,
0.30478307604789734,
-0.8158593773841858,
0.8024852871894836,
0.1554011106491089,
-1.1341979503631592,
-0.6200191974639893,
-0.16100148856639862,
-0.44226542115211487,
0.32159659266471863,
-0.18335378170013428,
-0.8879796862602234,
0.08533267676830292,
-0.08140698820352554,
-0.6696589589118958,
0.5839277505874634,
-0.385190486907959,
0.5422013998031616,
-0.343631774187088,
-0.09555120021104813,
-0.48121410608291626,
-0.5091013312339783,
0.48418667912483215,
-0.1806575506925583,
0.04498216137290001,
-0.05926511809229851,
0.003076717955991626,
0.7544061541557312,
-0.05874388664960861,
0.4217851459980011,
-0.054571159183979034,
-0.5687831044197083,
0.23749296367168427,
0.273729145526886,
0.3518543839454651,
0.0959116742014885,
-0.1396879255771637,
0.09299197793006897,
0.1747499406337738,
-0.2740984261035919,
-0.8883616924285889,
0.551826000213623,
-0.6061510443687439,
-0.9149803519248962,
-0.5706831216812134,
-0.6820176839828491,
-0.5594856142997742,
0.5026127696037292,
0.06742939352989197,
0.15211115777492523,
-0.25977835059165955,
0.33373168110847473,
1.0406877994537354,
-0.05482751131057739,
0.37712380290031433,
0.6621553897857666,
-0.5044586062431335,
-0.26600006222724915,
0.7709496021270752,
0.22015486657619476,
0.25651711225509644,
0.5275792479515076,
0.15374727547168732,
-0.3066057860851288,
-0.6038014888763428,
-0.29278653860092163,
0.160570427775383,
-0.6819544434547424,
-0.09876038879156113,
-0.3909223973751068,
-0.2151491940021515,
0.004548931960016489,
-0.131809800863266,
-0.2656414806842804,
-0.29722175002098083,
0.07408363372087479,
0.058273717761039734,
0.14270542562007904,
0.8705577850341797,
0.1441049873828888,
0.1410500407218933,
-0.45156875252723694,
0.2402121126651764,
0.3640565872192383,
0.7624853849411011,
0.16770011186599731,
-0.3685382306575775,
-0.22834275662899017,
0.2800929844379425,
-0.24065744876861572,
-0.9236438274383545,
0.07305309176445007,
-0.2595592439174652,
0.7545393705368042,
0.6930279731750488,
0.07917759567499161,
0.5889713168144226,
-0.38899335265159607,
0.7345862984657288,
0.17431625723838806,
-0.8512933254241943,
0.21440884470939636,
-0.5873058438301086,
0.2971320152282715,
0.18935465812683105,
0.11829880625009537,
-0.5628257393836975,
-0.5700774788856506,
-0.7979184985160828,
-0.2317051738500595,
0.5335810780525208,
0.0841829776763916,
-0.15965259075164795,
-0.15476709604263306,
0.48559412360191345,
0.29328230023384094,
0.24386359751224518,
-0.5608102083206177,
-0.25165092945098877,
0.15487724542617798,
0.01990310475230217,
-0.14073674380779266,
-0.25901371240615845,
-0.12789970636367798,
-0.17227551341056824,
0.6560987830162048,
-0.28293097019195557,
0.5272822380065918,
0.06067271903157234,
0.09059207141399384,
-0.3802371919155121,
0.35334500670433044,
0.6138315200805664,
0.9179763793945312,
-0.3682789206504822,
0.035139262676239014,
0.4304560422897339,
-0.22632023692131042,
0.17249825596809387,
-0.07953411340713501,
-0.24474360048770905,
-0.31887087225914,
0.2930860221385956,
0.5920974016189575,
0.07630578428506851,
-0.827685534954071,
0.3500709533691406,
-0.16099856793880463,
-0.43054890632629395,
-0.6134244203567505,
0.28169554471969604,
0.0005194299737922847,
0.6522825956344604,
0.646327793598175,
-0.056032564491033554,
-0.0011174759129062295,
-0.5516253113746643,
0.18310366570949554,
0.6544643640518188,
-0.20241780579090118,
-0.061019424349069595,
0.6681036353111267,
-0.02531127817928791,
-0.3859204351902008,
0.2651306390762329,
-0.3934818208217621,
-0.37820982933044434,
0.5445458889007568,
0.7089216709136963,
0.9226964712142944,
-0.008863692171871662,
0.32592353224754333,
0.09609702229499817,
0.35701271891593933,
-0.20722223818302155,
0.2907126843929291,
-0.12757524847984314,
-1.1559624671936035,
-0.5146807432174683,
-0.5272374153137207,
-0.45473334193229675,
0.47662225365638733,
-0.555787205696106,
-0.05072791129350662,
-0.6704218983650208,
-0.3021092414855957,
-0.00546834385022521,
0.44514867663383484,
-0.47372928261756897,
0.5215308666229248,
0.3806476294994354,
0.8907268047332764,
-0.3948042690753937,
1.0019207000732422,
0.7212213277816772,
-0.41621652245521545,
-0.5152087807655334,
0.25447213649749756,
0.06496986001729965,
-0.7913501262664795,
0.4958491325378418,
-0.08449208736419678,
-0.2691877782344818,
-0.006657409481704235,
-0.6883573532104492,
-1.117867112159729,
0.9247440695762634,
0.3806654214859009,
-0.6608182191848755,
-0.20561520755290985,
-0.2852378785610199,
0.6613864898681641,
-0.5746918320655823,
0.37169787287712097,
0.5628134608268738,
0.4862430989742279,
0.20419856905937195,
-0.7095398902893066,
0.07723525911569595,
-0.15733103454113007,
0.03979272022843361,
0.2663063704967499,
-0.7783857583999634,
0.7526852488517761,
-0.21568544209003448,
-0.2903081476688385,
0.36236074566841125,
0.7250202298164368,
0.5105995535850525,
0.1850971281528473,
0.4682620167732239,
0.6775287985801697,
0.9358513951301575,
-0.10922811925411224,
1.0526106357574463,
-0.2012178599834442,
0.42637068033218384,
0.9129533171653748,
-0.5474615097045898,
0.8343711495399475,
0.23544423282146454,
-0.4119902551174164,
0.2947828769683838,
0.6326596140861511,
-0.01807560585439205,
0.25424644351005554,
0.15197955071926117,
-0.0588204450905323,
-0.5560482144355774,
0.03273806720972061,
-0.4315490424633026,
0.35842010378837585,
0.45275095105171204,
-0.1186383068561554,
0.05273519456386566,
-0.1723182201385498,
0.18049459159374237,
0.049978505820035934,
-0.2267301082611084,
0.6247928738594055,
-0.07858885824680328,
-0.7930648922920227,
0.5919135808944702,
-0.04913463443517685,
0.7537663578987122,
-0.5237210392951965,
-0.1352679580450058,
-0.20368541777133942,
0.30292004346847534,
0.25733843445777893,
-0.9399229884147644,
-0.14570528268814087,
-0.22486057877540588,
-0.3346279263496399,
-0.20434625446796417,
0.6512801051139832,
-0.31292203068733215,
-0.22480425238609314,
0.39188849925994873,
0.6643941402435303,
0.2527734935283661,
-0.03947635740041733,
-0.5069521069526672,
-0.24734431505203247,
0.02404526248574257,
-0.46453115344047546,
0.2914740741252899,
0.601395308971405,
-0.28513002395629883,
0.9169912338256836,
0.5913532972335815,
0.33890682458877563,
-0.1196403056383133,
-0.16880671679973602,
0.46490392088890076,
-1.1066725254058838,
-0.534413754940033,
-1.104675531387329,
-0.0803871676325798,
-0.18146897852420807,
-0.46438512206077576,
0.704993724822998,
0.3537231385707855,
0.9168930649757385,
0.18098419904708862,
1.0975757837295532,
-0.0834081619977951,
0.6062281727790833,
-0.28554925322532654,
0.8718841671943665,
-0.6745558977127075,
-0.021684298291802406,
-0.3228841722011566,
-1.0601152181625366,
-0.3927156627178192,
0.5793731808662415,
-0.270759642124176,
0.31381115317344666,
0.9490926861763,
0.20842762291431427,
0.27536237239837646,
0.4787103235721588,
0.621458113193512,
0.3499770164489746,
0.24977658689022064,
0.7277463674545288,
0.8230454921722412,
0.02487323246896267,
0.18703459203243256,
0.09217458218336105,
-0.41274920105934143,
-0.1995547115802765,
-0.8446030020713806,
-0.9156813621520996,
-0.7104051113128662,
-0.032027747482061386,
-0.2810245454311371,
0.19716115295886993,
1.0340107679367065,
0.5249369740486145,
-0.6522310972213745,
-0.37007662653923035,
-0.08173412829637527,
0.37266805768013,
-0.3196091949939728,
-0.19703009724617004,
-0.020953651517629623,
-0.10133980959653854,
-0.5462311506271362,
0.33503127098083496,
0.5343739986419678,
-0.007489605341106653,
-0.43956395983695984,
-0.32981622219085693,
-0.4535451829433441,
0.5206429958343506,
0.7755022048950195,
0.4611612856388092,
-1.0579684972763062,
-0.664716362953186,
-0.20017199218273163,
0.03595084697008133,
-0.13493619859218597,
0.806009829044342,
-0.6803621649742126,
0.5165213346481323,
0.1978841871023178,
0.6164560914039612,
0.22604906558990479,
-0.34927281737327576,
0.9950945377349854,
-0.19284124672412872,
-0.009403195232152939,
0.35013139247894287,
0.47706493735313416,
-0.08276379853487015,
-0.2313224971294403,
0.5713986754417419,
0.23207978904247284,
-0.605583131313324,
-0.9284903407096863,
0.3090890645980835,
-0.6779415607452393,
-0.508113443851471,
1.064505934715271,
0.025311140343546867,
0.008555992506444454,
-0.020770343020558357,
-0.12122655659914017,
0.3014827370643616,
-0.329861044883728,
0.8496341109275818,
1.0451586246490479,
-0.21081463992595673,
-0.08214261382818222,
-0.589489758014679,
0.33896324038505554,
0.5220904350280762,
-0.6810614466667175,
-0.009774208068847656,
0.6098074316978455,
0.0010832626139745116,
0.4285889267921448,
0.8361111283302307,
0.08007461577653885,
0.22983375191688538,
-0.07814962416887283,
0.14037339389324188,
0.16820915043354034,
-0.49776896834373474,
-0.2333551049232483,
0.36377057433128357,
0.19537614285945892,
-0.015597322955727577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04784v1
|
SelfGoal: Your Language Agents Already Know How to Achieve High-level Goals
| 2024-06-07T09:32:03 | 2024-06-07T09:32:03 |
Ruihan Yang, Jiangjie Chen, Yikai Zhang, Siyu Yuan, Aili Chen, Kyle Richardson, Yanghua Xiao, Deqing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language agents powered by large language models (LLMs) are increasingly
valuable as decision-making tools in domains such as gaming and programming.
However, these agents often face challenges in achieving high-level goals
without detailed instructions and in adapting to environments where feedback is
delayed. In this paper, we present SelfGoal, a novel automatic approach
designed to enhance agents' capabilities to achieve high-level goals with
limited human prior and environmental feedback. The core concept of SelfGoal
involves adaptively breaking down a high-level goal into a tree structure of
more practical subgoals during the interaction with environments while
identifying the most useful subgoals and progressively updating this structure.
Experimental results demonstrate that SelfGoal significantly enhances the
performance of language agents across various tasks, including competitive,
cooperative, and deferred feedback environments. Project page:
https://selfgoal-agent.github.io.
|
[
-0.20360015332698822,
-0.8671322464942932,
0.6035144925117493,
0.4128760099411011,
0.4029879868030548,
0.6077522039413452,
-0.45559629797935486,
-0.32745760679244995,
0.23593446612358093,
0.528224766254425,
-0.592250406742096,
-0.44394931197166443,
-0.3807295560836792,
-0.08626552671194077,
-0.13719242811203003,
0.9721288084983826,
0.11365364491939545,
-0.5889390707015991,
-0.2815471589565277,
0.17976969480514526,
-0.6247109174728394,
-0.4511868357658386,
-0.7155188322067261,
-0.4546266794204712,
0.503135621547699,
0.4294995069503784,
0.6536121368408203,
0.7398388981819153,
0.4001336991786957,
0.44500166177749634,
0.2617459297180176,
-0.08313996344804764,
-0.6557773351669312,
0.5963476300239563,
-0.45084649324417114,
-0.4597182869911194,
-0.7222865223884583,
-0.23580724000930786,
0.46681439876556396,
0.1373821347951889,
-0.28083980083465576,
0.19661004841327667,
0.34179067611694336,
0.6431628465652466,
-0.43102940917015076,
0.4701363742351532,
-0.4243052899837494,
0.07748889178037643,
0.09924188256263733,
-0.3094482719898224,
-0.049599360674619675,
0.08963993936777115,
-0.13368430733680725,
-0.8375324606895447,
-0.005509319715201855,
-0.24510101974010468,
0.4363534152507782,
0.5316804647445679,
0.011159438639879227,
-0.4678489565849304,
-0.8211163282394409,
0.37853774428367615,
-0.7022106647491455,
0.32960519194602966,
0.3264645040035248,
0.28434133529663086,
-0.3722286522388458,
-0.3096109926700592,
-0.1540888547897339,
-0.5507904291152954,
-0.0829421728849411,
0.21521048247814178,
-0.20578032732009888,
0.2230544090270996,
0.21684597432613373,
-0.006778962444514036,
-0.42743855714797974,
0.10520880669355392,
-0.12443654984235764,
-0.11916657537221909,
0.6224216222763062,
0.16545002162456512,
0.3478553295135498,
0.007063188124448061,
-0.0523788183927536,
0.06359570473432541,
-0.3789599537849426,
0.1960431933403015,
0.24845455586910248,
0.532068133354187,
0.04237394779920578,
0.15693217515945435,
-0.6589040756225586,
0.5756176114082336,
0.307567834854126,
-0.313882052898407,
0.11126209795475006,
-0.22286000847816467,
0.12148047983646393,
-0.2879233658313751,
0.46908825635910034,
0.11902835220098495,
0.24956165254116058,
-0.22349654138088226,
-0.6385072469711304,
-0.2126740962266922,
0.1612948477268219,
-0.3687516152858734,
-0.29787686467170715,
0.11822899430990219,
-0.28761380910873413,
-0.1695840209722519,
-0.4104052782058716,
-0.6999038457870483,
-0.3156582713127136,
-0.22198666632175446,
0.5873748660087585,
-0.205267995595932,
-0.2542516887187958,
-0.03785032406449318,
0.04921294376254082,
0.013862316496670246,
0.5829215049743652,
-0.906212568283081,
0.5825626850128174,
0.548613429069519,
0.9065842032432556,
-0.14575433731079102,
-0.6892316341400146,
-0.575645387172699,
0.2949966490268707,
-0.4067422151565552,
0.7675202488899231,
-0.614437460899353,
-0.37048500776290894,
-0.16525879502296448,
-0.14153096079826355,
0.11706157773733139,
-0.46099191904067993,
0.06883098930120468,
-0.446838915348053,
0.0636257752776146,
-0.1083240807056427,
-0.20999355614185333,
0.11064174026250839,
0.44253742694854736,
-0.42320626974105835,
1.0710691213607788,
0.2771703600883484,
0.040999557822942734,
0.06289225816726685,
-0.872982382774353,
-0.5799084901809692,
0.3461340069770813,
0.08910459280014038,
0.1311974972486496,
0.12081293016672134,
0.2055969089269638,
0.21404463052749634,
-0.028408510610461235,
0.006788890343159437,
-0.18975181877613068,
-0.010541659779846668,
-0.12224270403385162,
-0.02029656246304512,
0.2632625102996826,
0.14034266769886017,
-0.472792387008667,
0.4810419976711273,
-0.463074266910553,
0.2311541736125946,
0.10567234456539154,
-0.529985249042511,
-0.2039976567029953,
0.19902442395687103,
-0.19485114514827728,
0.44638216495513916,
0.8078558444976807,
-0.14047840237617493,
0.5166281461715698,
-0.3070662021636963,
0.23499858379364014,
1.0767748355865479,
-0.18322809040546417,
0.5024217963218689,
-0.1823548823595047,
0.8831304311752319,
-0.5489453673362732,
0.25743868947029114,
-0.022845545783638954,
-0.14384566247463226,
-0.7501413822174072,
-0.18109221756458282,
0.2067514955997467,
0.538864016532898,
-0.5343274474143982,
0.6713574528694153,
-0.11808495223522186,
-0.4648679196834564,
-0.37607017159461975,
0.7670587301254272,
0.36200588941574097,
0.2310205101966858,
0.19982486963272095,
-0.3096195459365845,
-0.44598492980003357,
-0.4557171165943146,
-0.19149264693260193,
-0.3808344304561615,
0.21672149002552032,
0.2225111722946167,
0.5678979158401489,
-0.36721187829971313,
0.9597908854484558,
-0.38823527097702026,
-0.6997210383415222,
-0.25375068187713623,
0.09804879128932953,
0.22679345309734344,
0.46136102080345154,
0.36370590329170227,
-0.27882081270217896,
-0.6329457759857178,
0.16650764644145966,
-0.8033920526504517,
-0.5017247200012207,
-0.3761424422264099,
-0.006707801017910242,
0.0367714986205101,
0.5378607511520386,
-0.4165647029876709,
0.06676483899354935,
0.7657662630081177,
-0.3800388276576996,
0.3207170069217682,
-0.6688283681869507,
-0.05070611089468002,
-0.46885597705841064,
-0.26970693469047546,
-0.2715379297733307,
-0.6717802286148071,
-0.37033456563949585,
0.20133604109287262,
-0.27362680435180664,
0.013727755285799503,
0.06440725177526474,
0.6391850113868713,
-0.6695507764816284,
-0.281455397605896,
-0.6985435485839844,
0.11090432107448578,
-0.28470054268836975,
0.5968499779701233,
0.10589433461427689,
0.7635626792907715,
0.8244689106941223,
-0.6368781924247742,
0.7326343655586243,
0.01598431169986725,
0.12224462628364563,
0.45843809843063354,
-0.6820067763328552,
0.30304959416389465,
-0.06680554151535034,
0.22320666909217834,
-0.7373721599578857,
-0.12754757702350616,
0.3283318877220154,
-0.438568115234375,
0.06730013340711594,
-0.10806076973676682,
-0.24124571681022644,
-0.4435095191001892,
-0.0723085105419159,
0.15062354505062103,
0.47066161036491394,
-0.4175145924091339,
0.7964282035827637,
0.5517752766609192,
-0.1376044899225235,
-0.2573222517967224,
-0.39594221115112305,
0.3703790009021759,
-0.01920722797513008,
-0.20788949728012085,
0.0664205476641655,
-0.35827237367630005,
-0.18436916172504425,
0.14077246189117432,
-0.09257959574460983,
0.1927109658718109,
0.2663954794406891,
0.3609018921852112,
-0.15897507965564728,
-0.10090253502130508,
0.13421639800071716,
-0.3381463885307312,
-0.15362662076950073,
0.15465645492076874,
-0.6536884307861328,
0.4363456070423126,
-0.4150082468986511,
-0.17925752699375153,
-0.177209734916687,
0.22693368792533875,
0.4014507830142975,
-0.4489852488040924,
0.2888731360435486,
0.3037480413913727,
-0.39224690198898315,
-0.5105605721473694,
-0.3560539186000824,
-0.055870287120342255,
-0.561223030090332,
0.5026854872703552,
-0.8121135234832764,
-0.8482121825218201,
0.38433292508125305,
-0.10977890342473984,
-0.054665930569171906,
0.22562424838542938,
0.7352722883224487,
-0.07695838063955307,
1.209159255027771,
0.6878845691680908,
-0.11050035804510117,
0.7666138410568237,
-0.23849596083164215,
-0.06070530787110329,
-0.5439044833183289,
-0.13118427991867065,
-0.3369280695915222,
-0.17283444106578827,
-0.5764110684394836,
-0.572342038154602,
0.2746061384677887,
0.006461260840296745,
-0.03560422733426094,
0.4179838299751282,
-0.49085289239883423,
0.5530321002006531,
0.710590660572052,
-0.06247537210583687,
0.2215685099363327,
-0.26492902636528015,
0.2490738332271576,
0.18015629053115845,
-0.755156934261322,
-0.4466724097728729,
0.6176133155822754,
0.43247127532958984,
1.2157615423202515,
0.15514764189720154,
1.0490059852600098,
0.8414742350578308,
0.3648766279220581,
-0.8261894583702087,
0.5937599539756775,
0.25036630034446716,
-0.7238720059394836,
-0.8008267283439636,
-0.3389405608177185,
-1.1262595653533936,
0.1331285834312439,
-0.1308804452419281,
-0.8410826325416565,
-0.12071237713098526,
0.30152440071105957,
-0.4465343654155731,
-0.18992751836776733,
-0.4311944842338562,
0.8862292766571045,
-0.814096212387085,
-0.4840262532234192,
-0.4889708161354065,
-0.3919520676136017,
-0.42080798745155334,
-0.1097537949681282,
0.40289390087127686,
-0.36594897508621216,
-0.4477449655532837,
0.5858710408210754,
-0.19741132855415344,
0.9037639498710632,
-0.3689129948616028,
-0.2700903117656708,
0.42659643292427063,
0.5587058067321777,
0.6733047962188721,
-0.07362940907478333,
0.05464586243033409,
-0.1272934526205063,
0.1650180220603943,
-0.5329968333244324,
-0.933050274848938,
0.8911697864532471,
-0.8374986052513123,
-1.1360236406326294,
-0.5040527582168579,
-0.6232578754425049,
-0.20533399283885956,
0.45223304629325867,
-0.3812854588031769,
0.12507684528827667,
-0.44324350357055664,
-0.06833100318908691,
0.2013184130191803,
-0.05169609561562538,
0.5386934876441956,
0.8978469967842102,
-0.4833958148956299,
-0.3030197024345398,
0.9438703060150146,
0.15780776739120483,
0.33126571774482727,
0.45372870564460754,
0.38118526339530945,
-0.42039674520492554,
-0.5913864374160767,
-0.36833465099334717,
0.1407194584608078,
-0.8021363019943237,
-0.10037408769130707,
-0.32671022415161133,
0.005421398673206568,
-0.7277106642723083,
-0.20281250774860382,
-0.3325996994972229,
-0.17638440430164337,
-0.06055638939142227,
-0.06718118488788605,
0.07873169332742691,
1.3089420795440674,
-0.5481576919555664,
0.2823423445224762,
-0.6027212738990784,
0.28217634558677673,
0.5447983741760254,
0.3336387276649475,
-0.15921026468276978,
-0.4461182951927185,
-0.4191248416900635,
-0.09907285869121552,
-0.10708224773406982,
-0.8257578611373901,
0.5765092372894287,
0.2899869382381439,
0.7839469909667969,
0.001142613124102354,
-0.16894212365150452,
0.6926234364509583,
-0.36440929770469666,
0.4154232144355774,
-0.025217819958925247,
-1.1652050018310547,
0.941348671913147,
-0.6307283639907837,
0.5698269605636597,
0.46766898036003113,
0.08711741864681244,
-0.6089566946029663,
-0.46630847454071045,
-0.41081154346466064,
-0.6659018397331238,
0.6873589754104614,
0.04217033088207245,
0.3201088309288025,
0.17944581806659698,
0.28666457533836365,
-0.0552593432366848,
0.09974692761898041,
-1.027999997138977,
0.1756855696439743,
-0.21215267479419708,
-0.07411438226699829,
-0.3164851665496826,
0.118297278881073,
-0.13666671514511108,
-0.22029198706150055,
0.7064176201820374,
-0.5401573181152344,
-0.026524830609560013,
0.3905200958251953,
-0.29765862226486206,
-0.3105275630950928,
0.15919287502765656,
0.2433510273694992,
0.8036442399024963,
-0.03265141695737839,
0.17979580163955688,
0.4951968491077423,
0.03423326462507248,
0.3222745358943939,
-0.15353229641914368,
0.10661937296390533,
-0.5418931841850281,
0.5480100512504578,
0.37243080139160156,
-0.00802870187908411,
-0.7789844870567322,
0.2665517330169678,
-0.03520990535616875,
0.17023693025112152,
-0.1635061353445053,
0.3593488931655884,
0.04938868060708046,
0.4393201470375061,
0.29014208912849426,
-0.09186866879463196,
0.15326781570911407,
-0.8540844917297363,
0.34689903259277344,
0.32124051451683044,
-0.5753644108772278,
-0.4338189959526062,
0.4422656297683716,
0.6177072525024414,
-0.8232764005661011,
0.025479424744844437,
-0.28756511211395264,
-0.6199594736099243,
0.47399070858955383,
0.8952404260635376,
0.7326988577842712,
-0.3828181326389313,
0.4130013883113861,
0.19159920513629913,
0.45561572909355164,
0.05054710805416107,
0.07642543315887451,
-0.26825112104415894,
-0.5988829731941223,
-0.39929094910621643,
-0.6319668889045715,
-0.27499204874038696,
-0.09354548156261444,
-0.16550622880458832,
-0.09207882732152939,
-0.7499513030052185,
-0.08988101035356522,
-0.3382147550582886,
0.07106675952672958,
-0.619094729423523,
0.32864895462989807,
0.15378208458423615,
0.6379684805870056,
-0.47409722208976746,
0.7748689651489258,
0.6665722131729126,
-0.42721250653266907,
-0.6201949715614319,
0.0979260578751564,
-0.1747060865163803,
-1.0099889039993286,
0.6825273633003235,
-0.1360417604446411,
-0.5895688533782959,
0.20352330803871155,
-0.25993919372558594,
-1.186052680015564,
0.7605788707733154,
0.3955327272415161,
-0.687801718711853,
-0.24870546162128448,
0.10250478982925415,
0.9349969029426575,
-0.5241578817367554,
0.2769850194454193,
0.5993658900260925,
0.5833838582038879,
-0.1633671671152115,
-0.9046586751937866,
0.2951381504535675,
-0.10988245904445648,
-0.08628024160861969,
0.15821526944637299,
-0.8006110191345215,
0.49302050471305847,
-0.2671459913253784,
-0.02860519476234913,
-0.06632320582866669,
0.8691748976707458,
-0.2000499665737152,
-0.06702744960784912,
0.8797635436058044,
0.2832780182361603,
0.7347097396850586,
0.1803540587425232,
0.8870726823806763,
-0.6056045889854431,
0.40156546235084534,
1.1250399351119995,
-0.19117872416973114,
0.5713918209075928,
0.08224581927061081,
-0.04355522245168686,
0.5852286219596863,
0.5685815215110779,
0.10096585750579834,
0.4157263934612274,
0.28244537115097046,
-0.11580829322338104,
-0.654852032661438,
-0.19945956766605377,
-0.18897594511508942,
0.7332494854927063,
0.4041084349155426,
0.048765044659376144,
-0.11051809042692184,
-0.041517000645399094,
-0.19943095743656158,
0.3306736648082733,
-0.41242653131484985,
0.7890383005142212,
-0.19724804162979126,
-1.0360161066055298,
0.45279812812805176,
-0.2504238188266754,
0.6302643418312073,
-0.6091029644012451,
-0.13360927999019623,
-0.023701239377260208,
0.27196285128593445,
-0.34285664558410645,
-0.8236780166625977,
0.1384640485048294,
-0.19292466342449188,
0.05704084038734436,
-0.6096117496490479,
0.8688482046127319,
-0.49052777886390686,
-0.31426119804382324,
0.8421288132667542,
0.9659958481788635,
-0.012116228230297565,
-0.03586582839488983,
-1.0805959701538086,
-0.15025445818901062,
-0.23896494507789612,
-0.2424028366804123,
0.10522103309631348,
0.34802213311195374,
0.01234250795096159,
0.9673556685447693,
0.5410816669464111,
0.40712770819664,
-0.19251489639282227,
0.08758366107940674,
0.7681869268417358,
-0.8297075629234314,
-0.6428164839744568,
-0.6631420254707336,
-0.04873581975698471,
0.09713742136955261,
-0.2515559196472168,
0.8344317674636841,
0.45039480924606323,
0.8317756056785583,
-0.06450600177049637,
0.8690553307533264,
-0.16176636517047882,
0.23514367640018463,
-0.3744027316570282,
0.40148699283599854,
-0.5729601979255676,
0.22362051904201508,
-0.14037474989891052,
-0.8803656697273254,
-0.022297803312540054,
0.5889749526977539,
-0.525066614151001,
0.23124006390571594,
0.42884019017219543,
0.8548904061317444,
0.25546368956565857,
-0.6224614977836609,
0.6222158074378967,
0.2954794466495514,
0.4499863386154175,
0.5336670279502869,
1.2394837141036987,
0.2744515836238861,
0.6566697955131531,
-0.09219323098659515,
-0.39693963527679443,
-0.07738826423883438,
-0.6172803640365601,
-0.9362371563911438,
-0.5439721941947937,
-0.311692476272583,
-0.28281280398368835,
0.5850028991699219,
1.0667247772216797,
1.1155729293823242,
-0.6600781679153442,
-0.6850886344909668,
-0.20202650129795074,
0.38151979446411133,
-0.27290740609169006,
-0.23385702073574066,
-0.23741008341312408,
-0.7447055578231812,
-0.7083711624145508,
0.7953451871871948,
0.48387300968170166,
-0.036437589675188065,
-0.5197761058807373,
-0.4490016996860504,
-0.2357511818408966,
0.22056150436401367,
0.4067584276199341,
0.5801190733909607,
-0.6370767951011658,
-0.49972739815711975,
-0.07272038608789444,
-0.16936643421649933,
0.1715514212846756,
0.883691668510437,
-0.9086519479751587,
0.5105938911437988,
0.5279812812805176,
0.4363213777542114,
0.4489823579788208,
-0.005610708147287369,
0.7838894724845886,
-0.5944280624389648,
-0.131448432803154,
0.2756367623806,
0.16417209804058075,
0.24304749071598053,
-0.44975602626800537,
0.6299201846122742,
0.16396887600421906,
-0.6474315524101257,
-0.4715455174446106,
0.16901421546936035,
-0.6411608457565308,
-0.3252743184566498,
1.1245801448822021,
-0.1494010090827942,
-0.4072880148887634,
0.00009961095929611474,
-0.5320377349853516,
0.0729743167757988,
-0.7204372882843018,
0.8692886233329773,
0.6504351496696472,
-0.46880337595939636,
-0.15332841873168945,
-0.19859996438026428,
0.6908950209617615,
0.42909127473831177,
-1.1806265115737915,
0.2417755275964737,
0.5370674729347229,
0.36774110794067383,
0.29856401681900024,
0.9688107371330261,
0.46692758798599243,
0.24076467752456665,
-0.09149395674467087,
0.14767903089523315,
0.00934813916683197,
-0.65581214427948,
-0.43288612365722656,
0.13421745598316193,
0.5527067184448242,
0.09178245812654495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04770v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04770v1
|
WildBench: Benchmarking LLMs with Challenging Tasks from Real Users in the Wild
| 2024-06-07T09:15:44 | 2024-06-07T09:15:44 |
Bill Yuchen Lin, Yuntian Deng, Khyathi Chandu, Faeze Brahman, Abhilasha Ravichander, Valentina Pyatkin, Nouha Dziri, Ronan Le Bras, Yejin Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce WildBench, an automated evaluation framework designed to
benchmark large language models (LLMs) using challenging, real-world user
queries. WildBench consists of 1,024 tasks carefully selected from over one
million human-chatbot conversation logs. For automated evaluation with
WildBench, we have developed two metrics, WB-Reward and WB-Score, which are
computable using advanced LLMs such as GPT-4-turbo. WildBench evaluation uses
task-specific checklists to evaluate model outputs systematically and provides
structured explanations that justify the scores and comparisons, resulting in
more reliable and interpretable automatic judgments. WB-Reward employs
fine-grained pairwise comparisons between model responses, generating five
potential outcomes: much better, slightly better, slightly worse, much worse,
or a tie. Unlike previous evaluations that employed a single baseline model, we
selected three baseline models at varying performance levels to ensure a
comprehensive pairwise evaluation. Additionally, we propose a simple method to
mitigate length bias, by converting outcomes of ``slightly better/worse'' to
``tie'' if the winner response exceeds the loser one by more than $K$
characters. WB-Score evaluates the quality of model outputs individually,
making it a fast and cost-efficient evaluation metric. WildBench results
demonstrate a strong correlation with the human-voted Elo ratings from Chatbot
Arena on hard tasks. Specifically, WB-Reward achieves a Pearson correlation of
0.98 with top-ranking models. Additionally, WB-Score reaches 0.95, surpassing
both ArenaHard's 0.91 and AlpacaEval2.0's 0.89 for length-controlled win rates,
as well as the 0.87 for regular win rates.
|
[
-0.351203978061676,
-0.7854211330413818,
0.34685587882995605,
0.4534866511821747,
-0.2619253695011139,
0.43225571513175964,
-0.5399316549301147,
-0.5347691178321838,
0.1439036726951599,
0.36319923400878906,
-0.7695445418357849,
-0.6518079042434692,
-0.5054882764816284,
0.030671648681163788,
-0.3661916255950928,
0.9773867130279541,
0.15551596879959106,
-0.09063570201396942,
-0.3169081211090088,
-0.17714883387088776,
-0.5602712035179138,
-0.4716660678386688,
-0.4368003010749817,
-0.4694782495498657,
0.6941759586334229,
0.3579455316066742,
0.7442357540130615,
0.5082899928092957,
0.7458617091178894,
0.3764306306838989,
-0.06399267911911011,
0.14140315353870392,
-1.0355104207992554,
0.39491796493530273,
-0.28158533573150635,
-0.500653862953186,
-0.5080338716506958,
0.1983468234539032,
0.3356800973415375,
0.6131802201271057,
-0.4127790033817291,
0.3919215202331543,
-0.1687222123146057,
0.5285022854804993,
-0.6581133604049683,
0.06908878684043884,
-0.9487774968147278,
0.15541678667068481,
-0.26958152651786804,
-0.20387530326843262,
-0.30922678112983704,
-0.3562675416469574,
0.028021395206451416,
-0.3456692397594452,
0.11572834104299545,
0.3518792390823364,
1.0908639430999756,
0.19795671105384827,
-0.3585689663887024,
0.0018386540468782187,
-0.6043202877044678,
0.9170815944671631,
-0.7890166640281677,
0.2473587840795517,
0.1522802859544754,
0.5929065346717834,
-0.2715505361557007,
-0.6118243932723999,
-0.5071943998336792,
-0.6114124059677124,
0.038350269198417664,
0.2711751163005829,
-0.3671804368495941,
0.12111237645149231,
0.3512357771396637,
0.34589657187461853,
-0.818893551826477,
0.6194350123405457,
-0.2850130796432495,
-0.30484896898269653,
1.0073301792144775,
0.5381730198860168,
-0.13671623170375824,
-0.12184593826532364,
-0.33013641834259033,
-0.4884101152420044,
-0.5642175674438477,
0.04378694295883179,
0.5806002020835876,
0.20960435271263123,
0.12330172210931778,
0.5961247086524963,
-0.27996334433555603,
0.7605295181274414,
-0.19312462210655212,
0.025755243375897408,
0.18974927067756653,
-0.11179511994123459,
-0.15546049177646637,
-0.5189401507377625,
0.9813894033432007,
0.7268404364585876,
0.2757258713245392,
-0.4585164487361908,
-0.36474016308784485,
0.2628023624420166,
0.23911231756210327,
-0.8482039570808411,
-0.06893053650856018,
0.08831015974283218,
-0.3936256468296051,
-0.44590041041374207,
-0.259189248085022,
-0.7960132956504822,
-0.6077986359596252,
-0.18742050230503082,
0.4070179760456085,
0.0072582801803946495,
-0.008959959261119366,
-0.24145740270614624,
-0.30652520060539246,
0.10325873643159866,
0.40976017713546753,
-0.7124162912368774,
0.5850176215171814,
0.7631116509437561,
0.6734071373939514,
-0.7074939608573914,
-0.36759841442108154,
-0.7494739294052124,
-0.3481701910495758,
-0.3285244405269623,
0.9088131785392761,
-0.4609677791595459,
-0.43750840425491333,
-0.12299452722072601,
-0.04770170897245407,
0.09085685014724731,
-0.8118178844451904,
0.578436017036438,
-0.626530647277832,
-0.09548286348581314,
-0.007861425168812275,
-0.6557481288909912,
0.03436277434229851,
0.5051862597465515,
-0.6810032725334167,
1.305586814880371,
-0.06694017350673676,
-0.3519064486026764,
0.40559399127960205,
-0.5312854647636414,
-0.25956016778945923,
0.14502780139446259,
0.04946722090244293,
-0.1825602799654007,
0.14338983595371246,
-0.04780177026987076,
0.509693443775177,
-0.7585422992706299,
0.3712817430496216,
-0.6616529226303101,
-0.5648618936538696,
0.2841528356075287,
-0.5139807462692261,
0.3586840033531189,
0.1807125210762024,
-0.45388680696487427,
0.45559829473495483,
-0.7235461473464966,
0.38549792766571045,
0.2331804484128952,
-0.2300933450460434,
-0.08228060603141785,
0.13750708103179932,
0.32337087392807007,
0.19097194075584412,
0.1321546733379364,
-0.5952066779136658,
0.13303159177303314,
-0.391620397567749,
0.12109770625829697,
0.9277613162994385,
-0.24878720939159393,
0.16204148530960083,
-0.3771694600582123,
0.6212843656539917,
-0.35705551505088806,
0.14511585235595703,
0.19280953705310822,
-0.27728164196014404,
-0.6434388756752014,
-0.2778327465057373,
0.525521457195282,
0.7515020370483398,
-0.14624235033988953,
0.6447281837463379,
-0.3718591630458832,
-0.9476382732391357,
-0.4551432132720947,
0.35655006766319275,
0.45565780997276306,
0.3175841271877289,
0.16271337866783142,
-0.7503173351287842,
-0.38521161675453186,
-0.9889297485351562,
-0.4639042317867279,
-0.19758260250091553,
-0.337482750415802,
0.5958610773086548,
0.5554648041725159,
-0.20804166793823242,
0.9423120021820068,
-0.601719319820404,
-0.27557677030563354,
-0.2592487037181854,
0.2875264883041382,
0.40455302596092224,
0.37575575709342957,
0.3546811044216156,
-0.5052191615104675,
-0.5326914191246033,
-0.23406171798706055,
-0.5440447330474854,
-0.2566261887550354,
0.11215636134147644,
-0.19764040410518646,
0.21112027764320374,
0.16816294193267822,
-0.4990405738353729,
0.3269186019897461,
0.6507682800292969,
-0.21911858022212982,
0.5736308097839355,
-0.030158866196870804,
0.09209243208169937,
-0.5246314406394958,
0.35340243577957153,
-0.2683338522911072,
-0.31091368198394775,
-0.16364535689353943,
0.12765660881996155,
-0.004481475800275803,
-0.03873535245656967,
-0.3691220283508301,
0.8351100087165833,
-0.08420035988092422,
-0.1950417011976242,
-0.08811517804861069,
0.5766587257385254,
-0.0713730975985527,
0.6758544445037842,
-0.22665725648403168,
0.49594253301620483,
0.2231101095676422,
-0.20108993351459503,
0.90106600522995,
-0.0859682559967041,
-0.4017837941646576,
0.4317982494831085,
-0.7934612035751343,
0.48683053255081177,
0.1716291904449463,
0.4365593492984772,
-1.1173622608184814,
-0.025737348943948746,
-0.2276216298341751,
-0.41680532693862915,
0.0992668941617012,
-0.03526546061038971,
-0.8390784859657288,
-0.5814266800880432,
-0.5053359866142273,
-0.11624402552843094,
0.6010507345199585,
-0.364968478679657,
0.33763986825942993,
0.32422012090682983,
0.004146707244217396,
-0.5679702758789062,
-0.4791528880596161,
0.1954602748155594,
-0.21148094534873962,
-0.5963805317878723,
0.4214356541633606,
-0.3463442027568817,
-0.22707238793373108,
0.02722751721739769,
-0.3356243669986725,
0.07294648140668869,
0.33130747079849243,
0.3175814151763916,
0.2573081851005554,
0.09228542447090149,
-0.0570460706949234,
-0.15950046479701996,
-0.048232607543468475,
-0.027789682149887085,
-0.009508573450148106,
0.538810133934021,
-0.23173855245113373,
-0.387382447719574,
0.012430328875780106,
0.2904285788536072,
0.43861085176467896,
-0.20009972155094147,
0.570370078086853,
0.4729008674621582,
-0.2321593463420868,
-0.28385934233665466,
-0.9078792333602905,
-0.20836180448532104,
-0.47870662808418274,
0.4796939492225647,
-0.3764141798019409,
-0.9309810400009155,
0.7659751176834106,
-0.2300231158733368,
0.344211220741272,
0.4040387272834778,
0.7450441122055054,
0.08460847288370132,
1.342128038406372,
0.5368964076042175,
-0.22551573812961578,
0.3087995648384094,
-0.1839212328195572,
-0.08450987935066223,
-0.4170011579990387,
-0.2197166234254837,
-0.511604905128479,
-0.5224291086196899,
-0.7199467420578003,
-0.44048768281936646,
0.22681722044944763,
0.14657075703144073,
-0.10834294557571411,
0.30052125453948975,
-0.3460582494735718,
0.5239250063896179,
0.4658259451389313,
-0.010937460698187351,
0.15042109787464142,
-0.23600850999355316,
-0.4487760066986084,
-0.18708397448062897,
-0.5837737917900085,
-0.539089024066925,
1.2024776935577393,
0.2613798975944519,
0.8325895667076111,
0.1839471459388733,
0.7594724893569946,
0.5027647614479065,
0.6616067290306091,
-0.9127046465873718,
0.7157589793205261,
0.0026634247042238712,
-0.8692960739135742,
-0.41790372133255005,
-0.5089318752288818,
-1.0575348138809204,
0.6104533076286316,
-0.2236747443675995,
-1.0129780769348145,
-0.34789854288101196,
0.06798003613948822,
-0.26001259684562683,
0.10172019153833389,
-0.5291694402694702,
1.0914649963378906,
-0.41908323764801025,
-0.8344098329544067,
-0.43704724311828613,
-0.765522301197052,
0.3847523331642151,
-0.08829399198293686,
0.2485489696264267,
-0.47574782371520996,
0.04303346574306488,
0.9348850250244141,
-0.37796860933303833,
0.7913303971290588,
-0.1512516438961029,
0.1686517745256424,
0.013444777578115463,
0.24568670988082886,
0.6501171588897705,
0.0556044802069664,
-0.3465802073478699,
0.05771438032388687,
0.1545371115207672,
-0.4024428725242615,
-0.5535813570022583,
0.8798150420188904,
-0.7681244015693665,
-0.6431660652160645,
-0.48249131441116333,
-0.5600958466529846,
-0.4554423987865448,
0.21741963922977448,
-0.13859529793262482,
0.12119060754776001,
-0.7004553079605103,
0.24119526147842407,
0.31632745265960693,
-0.2868941128253937,
0.2850290834903717,
0.9011921882629395,
-0.2723166346549988,
-0.21660079061985016,
0.5974592566490173,
-0.21242433786392212,
0.13489240407943726,
0.42748966813087463,
0.21710821986198425,
-0.25350967049598694,
-0.34916314482688904,
-0.5515478849411011,
0.009142285212874413,
-0.8289741277694702,
-0.49045658111572266,
-0.5498689413070679,
0.007445408031344414,
-0.07256617397069931,
-0.07941883057355881,
-0.560745358467102,
-0.36263877153396606,
0.2726532816886902,
-0.06456595659255981,
0.2818872332572937,
0.6095399260520935,
-0.14435237646102905,
0.20195618271827698,
-0.753035843372345,
0.10208442062139511,
0.38022151589393616,
0.5056810975074768,
0.053567856550216675,
-0.49198684096336365,
-0.05820873752236366,
-0.2408374398946762,
-0.4593144953250885,
-0.7196643352508545,
0.5329480171203613,
0.09568549692630768,
0.7811973094940186,
0.10886156558990479,
0.1028091162443161,
0.8559365272521973,
-0.6044575572013855,
0.6601704955101013,
0.04693565517663956,
-0.922586977481842,
0.3548135459423065,
-0.147427037358284,
0.2690035104751587,
0.8398922681808472,
0.18020738661289215,
-0.5885107517242432,
-0.613175094127655,
-0.6905601620674133,
-1.0411608219146729,
0.8448535799980164,
0.1626436561346054,
0.25643786787986755,
0.2101801335811615,
-0.04385761544108391,
0.10467468202114105,
0.2632346451282501,
-0.611322820186615,
-0.1983664184808731,
0.10789573937654495,
-0.10234319418668747,
-0.2338848114013672,
-0.06201508641242981,
-0.28516772389411926,
-0.14171233773231506,
0.4376470744609833,
-0.21865348517894745,
0.1635567843914032,
-0.3692089021205902,
-0.2717338502407074,
-0.323079913854599,
0.2868748605251312,
0.38756874203681946,
0.7683185338973999,
-0.6077780723571777,
-0.060208652168512344,
0.5577514171600342,
-0.1650080382823944,
-0.09963294118642807,
0.46770331263542175,
0.32306385040283203,
-0.04339701309800148,
0.5361535549163818,
0.7850028872489929,
0.37162190675735474,
-1.2054048776626587,
0.6500985026359558,
-0.23392550647258759,
-0.03508394956588745,
-0.10477831959724426,
0.1366434246301651,
0.22186309099197388,
0.11310545355081558,
0.46961796283721924,
-0.0768643394112587,
0.20995673537254333,
-0.5692549347877502,
0.09583916515111923,
0.5327407717704773,
-0.3773375153541565,
-0.2155573070049286,
0.5777720808982849,
0.35543298721313477,
-0.32674640417099,
0.5972564816474915,
-0.1885884404182434,
-0.6437567472457886,
0.8779987096786499,
0.30906790494918823,
0.691611647605896,
-0.019220629706978798,
-0.11574357002973557,
0.30551379919052124,
0.21551045775413513,
-0.002102210419252515,
0.16691084206104279,
-0.16021056473255157,
-0.42787325382232666,
-0.4401528537273407,
-0.8518627882003784,
-0.9153342843055725,
0.029373306781053543,
-0.6709602475166321,
0.28985896706581116,
-0.31450673937797546,
-0.18454840779304504,
0.24207696318626404,
0.42135223746299744,
-1.1089816093444824,
0.12249511480331421,
0.14000752568244934,
0.9946900010108948,
-0.7889074087142944,
0.6942113041877747,
0.6589133739471436,
-0.11210376024246216,
-0.7559854388237,
-0.2781709134578705,
0.34486123919487,
-0.8804441690444946,
0.7378968000411987,
0.19441655278205872,
-0.028004225343465805,
-0.050569575279951096,
-0.5435540080070496,
-0.7451431155204773,
1.040122628211975,
0.1631244271993637,
-0.900700032711029,
0.17783519625663757,
-0.06312260776758194,
0.7686778903007507,
-0.06545210629701614,
0.856772780418396,
0.4787587523460388,
0.4456368684768677,
0.20382703840732574,
-1.2589117288589478,
0.1600535362958908,
-0.28875216841697693,
-0.026035359129309654,
0.09036565572023392,
-0.7167185544967651,
0.4231807291507721,
-0.02759348787367344,
-0.06574638932943344,
0.10399994999170303,
0.4220800995826721,
0.5565901398658752,
0.307125985622406,
0.704839289188385,
0.4036533534526825,
0.7757948637008667,
-0.03187636658549309,
1.0486122369766235,
-0.23090408742427826,
0.48370033502578735,
0.9193187355995178,
-0.7062664031982422,
1.0030635595321655,
0.2687380909919739,
-0.40532180666923523,
0.4918188750743866,
0.7479268908500671,
-0.20875519514083862,
0.5666191577911377,
0.9050167798995972,
0.11254707723855972,
-0.41788071393966675,
-0.0704076737165451,
-0.0587448850274086,
0.6265473961830139,
0.21606136858463287,
0.08835611492395401,
-0.31487151980400085,
-0.15295439958572388,
0.1507304161787033,
0.14520055055618286,
0.05189310759305954,
0.7199511528015137,
0.09789104014635086,
-1.0279070138931274,
0.7795177698135376,
0.2685421407222748,
0.9328020811080933,
-0.8942251205444336,
0.09728005528450012,
-0.48691776394844055,
0.4950912296772003,
-0.037064868956804276,
-0.5376539826393127,
0.05268928036093712,
0.2398601472377777,
0.07602547854185104,
-0.21038667857646942,
0.6209937334060669,
-0.15546633303165436,
-0.3205498158931732,
0.5711536407470703,
0.48883309960365295,
0.2539886236190796,
-0.00825922004878521,
-0.9183165431022644,
0.47537511587142944,
-0.3016681969165802,
-0.4980572760105133,
0.44287773966789246,
0.2230098992586136,
-0.2887585759162903,
0.7354004383087158,
0.7806232571601868,
-0.09270451962947845,
-0.17722372710704803,
0.17178748548030853,
1.0321241617202759,
-0.7260004281997681,
-0.3542681634426117,
-0.939766526222229,
0.27606460452079773,
-0.26217445731163025,
-0.33226150274276733,
0.820995569229126,
0.7786757946014404,
0.7145127654075623,
0.13907063007354736,
0.5420268774032593,
-0.2593654990196228,
0.5538671016693115,
-0.06696854531764984,
0.6786068081855774,
-0.733280599117279,
0.2857655882835388,
-0.3899899125099182,
-0.8711075186729431,
-0.3422735333442688,
0.2968221604824066,
-0.1652449518442154,
-0.01811709627509117,
0.6019291281700134,
0.8804929852485657,
0.05312230437994003,
-0.22479015588760376,
0.42903172969818115,
0.08516814559698105,
0.4009161591529846,
0.6392791867256165,
0.9265117645263672,
-0.11600208282470703,
0.7785961627960205,
-0.25327813625335693,
-0.44798997044563293,
-0.4306596517562866,
-0.9450774192810059,
-1.0977213382720947,
-0.17361637949943542,
-0.18131563067436218,
-0.143845334649086,
0.16115280985832214,
0.9562526941299438,
0.9515952467918396,
-0.8260483741760254,
-0.5864120721817017,
0.1880374252796173,
0.17320245504379272,
-0.398515909910202,
-0.25721895694732666,
0.17895612120628357,
-0.3871423602104187,
-0.7775138020515442,
0.5272011756896973,
0.11584620922803879,
-0.47166919708251953,
-0.3788551092147827,
0.030456628650426865,
-0.11871469765901566,
0.15695039927959442,
0.5663214921951294,
0.1017492413520813,
-0.8013197779655457,
-0.12307765334844589,
0.252573698759079,
-0.37690794467926025,
-0.30432406067848206,
0.5144333839416504,
-0.9856362342834473,
0.44587334990501404,
0.5102867484092712,
0.5033227205276489,
1.0063680410385132,
-0.1009673997759819,
0.6728298664093018,
-0.6887136697769165,
0.09850501269102097,
0.45625069737434387,
0.031058568507432938,
0.29726988077163696,
-0.022508075460791588,
0.758384644985199,
0.15464727580547333,
-0.5734255909919739,
-1.1773244142532349,
-0.13888414204120636,
-0.9717586636543274,
-0.16519801318645477,
0.9896765947341919,
-0.3096473217010498,
-0.08647441864013672,
0.2266751527786255,
-0.09223756939172745,
0.04532764479517937,
-0.37507835030555725,
0.7563396692276001,
0.6911209225654602,
-0.03215491399168968,
0.09500478208065033,
-0.880645215511322,
0.32810425758361816,
0.8212498426437378,
-0.7634952068328857,
0.14397630095481873,
0.4456644654273987,
0.3695087730884552,
-0.04833986237645149,
0.4402505159378052,
0.062236059457063675,
0.1953900009393692,
-0.034674838185310364,
0.14478404819965363,
-0.026305126026272774,
0.10192129015922546,
-0.18717314302921295,
0.16425886750221252,
0.2809404730796814,
0.11604093760251999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04758v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04758v1
|
Think out Loud: Emotion Deducing Explanation in Dialogues
| 2024-06-07T08:58:29 | 2024-06-07T08:58:29 |
Jiangnan Li, Zheng Lin, Lanrui Wang, Qingyi Si, Yanan Cao, Mo Yu, Peng Fu, Weiping Wang, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans convey emotions through daily dialogues, making emotion understanding
a crucial step of affective intelligence. To understand emotions in dialogues,
machines are asked to recognize the emotion for an utterance (Emotion
Recognition in Dialogues, ERD); based on the emotion, then find causal
utterances for the emotion (Emotion Cause Extraction in Dialogues, ECED). The
setting of the two tasks requires first ERD and then ECED, ignoring the mutual
complement between emotion and cause. To fix this, some new tasks are proposed
to extract them simultaneously. Although the current research on these tasks
has excellent achievements, simply identifying emotion-related factors by
classification modeling lacks realizing the specific thinking process of causes
stimulating the emotion in an explainable way. This thinking process especially
reflected in the reasoning ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) is
under-explored. To this end, we propose a new task "Emotion Deducing
Explanation in Dialogues" (EDEN). EDEN recognizes emotion and causes in an
explicitly thinking way. That is, models need to generate an explanation text,
which first summarizes the causes; analyzes the inner activities of the
speakers triggered by the causes using common sense; then guesses the emotion
accordingly. To support the study of EDEN, based on the existing resources in
ECED, we construct two EDEN datasets by human effort. We further evaluate
different models on EDEN and find that LLMs are more competent than
conventional PLMs. Besides, EDEN can help LLMs achieve better recognition of
emotions and causes, which explores a new research direction of explainable
emotion understanding in dialogues.
|
[
-0.42645272612571716,
-0.9275768995285034,
0.8297170996665955,
-0.013834482058882713,
-0.23067116737365723,
-0.23092153668403625,
-0.3538624346256256,
-0.5347318053245544,
0.08291327208280563,
0.38736864924430847,
-0.8993349671363831,
-0.19083595275878906,
-0.5369821190834045,
0.20599167048931122,
-0.3496714234352112,
0.5740727782249451,
-0.12164290249347687,
0.013375279493629932,
-0.3951394259929657,
-0.27388715744018555,
-0.24177879095077515,
-0.3104816675186157,
-0.9549435377120972,
-0.3270276188850403,
0.3450220823287964,
0.6949673295021057,
0.3744535744190216,
0.2115776389837265,
0.5052086114883423,
0.38844284415245056,
-0.15896651148796082,
0.09339827299118042,
-0.4118584096431732,
0.17466987669467926,
0.061592746526002884,
-0.42123743891716003,
-0.4988214671611786,
-0.1853461116552353,
0.5508476495742798,
0.5341956615447998,
-0.09578850865364075,
0.054332152009010315,
0.08323764055967331,
0.9430708885192871,
-0.28332871198654175,
0.18337967991828918,
-0.4581986963748932,
0.259174644947052,
0.09468675404787064,
-0.03408202901482582,
-0.3695414662361145,
-0.14736996591091156,
0.17322848737239838,
-0.44896399974823,
-0.06883276998996735,
0.017890773713588715,
0.5305473804473877,
0.4825570285320282,
-0.1334483027458191,
-0.46804288029670715,
-0.8337004780769348,
0.7950311303138733,
-0.6923111081123352,
0.41553670167922974,
-0.052290234714746475,
-0.25351324677467346,
-0.007932054810225964,
-0.4289458096027374,
-1.1667609214782715,
0.15600430965423584,
0.08787453919649124,
0.28479495644569397,
-0.5650362968444824,
0.1821383386850357,
0.4820059835910797,
0.40044650435447693,
-0.39195919036865234,
-0.07575174421072006,
-0.059311091899871826,
0.17499245703220367,
0.7432193756103516,
0.11071224510669708,
0.7081512212753296,
-0.2521226704120636,
-0.2049761563539505,
-0.04533100873231888,
-0.7859721183776855,
0.3117872476577759,
0.09245938807725906,
-0.1290251910686493,
-0.07316932082176208,
0.2762783467769623,
0.1409148871898651,
0.15332713723182678,
-0.2793717384338379,
0.1104913204908371,
0.12575013935565948,
-0.004141570068895817,
-0.41216781735420227,
0.1362055093050003,
0.7985960841178894,
0.5393252372741699,
0.4387943744659424,
0.3073152005672455,
-0.025113673880696297,
-0.008027651347219944,
0.1304364651441574,
-0.8028630018234253,
0.0738520398736,
0.563962459564209,
-0.7899898290634155,
-0.032770514488220215,
-0.35145440697669983,
-1.0628539323806763,
-0.514451801776886,
-0.43065810203552246,
0.5569145679473877,
-0.37819910049438477,
-0.6623769402503967,
-0.006070889066904783,
0.01496199332177639,
0.027768729254603386,
0.3544408082962036,
-0.6201950311660767,
0.4675277769565582,
0.585443377494812,
0.7481179237365723,
-0.2700011730194092,
-0.0026362279895693064,
-0.26879939436912537,
-0.30241796374320984,
-0.08149372041225433,
0.6791725754737854,
-0.5595714449882507,
-0.3981817960739136,
-0.0940476506948471,
0.0547424741089344,
-0.13219094276428223,
-0.5336184501647949,
0.6684920191764832,
-0.046874262392520905,
0.2158777117729187,
-0.4917445778846741,
-0.7990483045578003,
-0.6694372892379761,
0.07168806344270706,
-0.5843772292137146,
0.6974280476570129,
0.049936261028051376,
-0.6016278862953186,
0.09129700809717178,
-1.2623108625411987,
-0.2726450562477112,
0.32632747292518616,
-0.09473196417093277,
-0.26624688506126404,
0.2992332875728607,
0.24883392453193665,
0.43658769130706787,
-0.21199536323547363,
0.35907408595085144,
-0.24687039852142334,
-0.27354761958122253,
0.4022061824798584,
-0.4915120005607605,
0.833461344242096,
0.2697547376155853,
-0.4586789608001709,
0.3604276180267334,
-0.5204904079437256,
-0.18925315141677856,
0.2417377531528473,
0.13163478672504425,
-0.35399511456489563,
0.48000025749206543,
-0.43875208497047424,
0.19243912398815155,
-0.06454812735319138,
-0.7634700536727905,
-0.2959456741809845,
-0.580985426902771,
0.5709095597267151,
0.7221615314483643,
0.23013976216316223,
0.3065071702003479,
-0.06463976204395294,
0.5453455448150635,
0.12184025347232819,
0.23789970576763153,
-0.29785630106925964,
-0.5527490377426147,
-0.9478057026863098,
-0.24112629890441895,
-0.30895745754241943,
0.5282271504402161,
-0.3419608473777771,
0.15260709822177887,
0.05965585634112358,
-0.3470330238342285,
-0.9778204560279846,
0.1978485882282257,
0.378959596157074,
0.5931573510169983,
0.3964872360229492,
-0.046659648418426514,
-0.5436408519744873,
-0.6686414480209351,
-0.21144360303878784,
-0.24886207282543182,
0.11259455978870392,
0.5543226599693298,
0.5229635834693909,
-0.10203664004802704,
0.7355191111564636,
-0.40481653809547424,
0.026481231674551964,
-0.7253580093383789,
0.3075076639652252,
0.14251574873924255,
0.20776362717151642,
0.09748130291700363,
-0.8049643635749817,
-0.25355100631713867,
-0.17116914689540863,
-0.7938287854194641,
-0.1956406533718109,
-0.12491631507873535,
-0.13158687949180603,
0.06999824196100235,
0.6676937937736511,
-0.593506395816803,
0.5567554235458374,
0.3790391683578491,
-0.13075625896453857,
0.14478866755962372,
-0.154690682888031,
-0.006184103433042765,
-0.9312388896942139,
-0.29510122537612915,
-0.04013490304350853,
-0.15447041392326355,
-0.4175066649913788,
-0.12394993007183075,
-0.06807509064674377,
-0.24764394760131836,
-0.5352309942245483,
0.3783857524394989,
-0.3680848181247711,
-0.17612536251544952,
-0.17191538214683533,
0.3685974180698395,
0.14303185045719147,
0.5320075750350952,
0.2047249674797058,
0.3752681016921997,
0.6542139649391174,
-0.6493844985961914,
0.7433213591575623,
0.2734003961086273,
-0.4274672865867615,
0.7262897491455078,
-0.6427206993103027,
0.08352123200893402,
-0.3125835657119751,
0.1170644611120224,
-1.0825779438018799,
-0.23195159435272217,
0.16797734797000885,
-0.2969057261943817,
0.04019292816519737,
0.1011485680937767,
-0.09722980856895447,
-0.4796750545501709,
0.010934018529951572,
0.2793635129928589,
0.800719678401947,
-0.7141609787940979,
0.8647434115409851,
0.48029524087905884,
-0.6158948540687561,
-0.10738295316696167,
-0.38713815808296204,
-0.06697514653205872,
-0.5696448683738708,
-0.739082396030426,
0.13121110200881958,
-0.4969223737716675,
-0.8717939853668213,
0.02187829092144966,
0.18589472770690918,
0.20102982223033905,
0.23526713252067566,
0.6737263202667236,
0.16119086742401123,
-0.2587052881717682,
0.5829877853393555,
-0.06694647669792175,
-0.08217699080705643,
0.6503526568412781,
0.1970832794904709,
0.18401972949504852,
-0.17453494668006897,
-0.43776750564575195,
-0.6939020752906799,
0.6396946310997009,
0.6250035762786865,
-0.19116158783435822,
0.5786781311035156,
0.4820343554019928,
-0.5111963748931885,
-0.37417420744895935,
-0.3638325035572052,
-0.155776709318161,
-0.37628692388534546,
0.42020943760871887,
-0.11281472444534302,
-0.7230115532875061,
0.5515859723091125,
-0.3742930293083191,
-0.038886431604623795,
0.5612376928329468,
0.6675118803977966,
-0.374589204788208,
1.2769674062728882,
0.5642638206481934,
0.04689572751522064,
0.4975421726703644,
-0.18456469476222992,
0.4087180197238922,
-1.0508571863174438,
-0.1396034061908722,
-0.4030453860759735,
-0.565138041973114,
-0.31946414709091187,
-0.25759536027908325,
0.3876652419567108,
-0.19325818121433258,
0.07773690670728683,
-0.10450908541679382,
-0.36244574189186096,
0.6185416579246521,
0.30631986260414124,
-0.010769423097372055,
0.16126573085784912,
-0.3307465612888336,
0.10264844447374344,
-0.004369186703115702,
-0.24850837886333466,
-0.32546624541282654,
0.7532188296318054,
0.48028725385665894,
0.49960005283355713,
0.18862053751945496,
0.7615842819213867,
0.07907439023256302,
0.5299532413482666,
-0.9137538075447083,
0.6681193113327026,
0.07399677485227585,
-0.4810762107372284,
-0.5203431248664856,
-0.3414963483810425,
-0.6935678124427795,
0.2157597541809082,
-0.11463101953268051,
-1.1193420886993408,
0.19272693991661072,
0.02120206691324711,
-0.5886635184288025,
0.32176169753074646,
-0.7842118740081787,
0.8993483185768127,
-0.18774446845054626,
-0.1621629148721695,
-0.5832746624946594,
-0.4440889060497284,
0.439790278673172,
0.13742905855178833,
0.6344457268714905,
-0.13542555272579193,
0.5595824122428894,
0.891492486000061,
-0.46969544887542725,
0.719013512134552,
-0.3029353618621826,
-0.2233511209487915,
0.5525590777397156,
0.11695313453674316,
0.5238913893699646,
0.0861673355102539,
-0.1678697168827057,
-0.031132401898503304,
-0.36749547719955444,
0.15148144960403442,
-0.678363561630249,
0.6191754341125488,
-0.6919076442718506,
-0.5259544253349304,
-0.05560670420527458,
-0.5074767470359802,
0.08378627896308899,
-0.2662908434867859,
0.24903376400470734,
0.38348886370658875,
-0.3844101130962372,
0.24792426824569702,
0.9245927929878235,
-0.3952171206474304,
0.8903660178184509,
0.5562344789505005,
-0.25136396288871765,
-0.06954661756753922,
0.8462228178977966,
-0.11197464168071747,
0.160929873585701,
0.3643907308578491,
0.3495802879333496,
-0.21243369579315186,
-0.4036727845668793,
-0.3602665662765503,
0.0579083152115345,
-0.6449284553527832,
-0.002049103146418929,
-0.795115053653717,
-0.05526654049754143,
-0.12320886552333832,
0.015287064015865326,
-0.41770368814468384,
-0.07200820744037628,
-0.3237251043319702,
-0.30155691504478455,
0.4615287780761719,
0.9556901454925537,
-0.17710180580615997,
0.11919251829385757,
-0.8526049852371216,
0.44772204756736755,
0.5527918338775635,
0.10756254941225052,
0.13360105454921722,
-0.47391200065612793,
-0.03373436629772186,
0.14394572377204895,
-0.3706696629524231,
-1.100640058517456,
0.6782965064048767,
0.2862473428249359,
0.23162180185317993,
0.7524007558822632,
0.23976880311965942,
0.5869172215461731,
-0.19414441287517548,
0.7300131916999817,
0.021700989454984665,
-1.3250387907028198,
0.6670653223991394,
0.16962294280529022,
-0.022961948066949844,
0.11512742191553116,
0.3232862949371338,
-0.6607716083526611,
-0.23674432933330536,
-0.8559716939926147,
-1.0066546201705933,
0.6940209269523621,
0.26305291056632996,
0.19340519607067108,
-0.26032891869544983,
0.15872429311275482,
0.12913912534713745,
-0.11722476035356522,
-0.7258784174919128,
0.12651191651821136,
0.26136887073516846,
-0.32122981548309326,
-0.048845723271369934,
-0.4437761604785919,
-0.06984084844589233,
-0.37354257702827454,
0.6746876835823059,
-0.033558767288923264,
0.39719733595848083,
0.5564347505569458,
-0.35721009969711304,
-0.8015475869178772,
0.4413979649543762,
0.47393983602523804,
0.3755151927471161,
-0.2743726968765259,
0.09582073986530304,
0.4220258295536041,
-0.0933508425951004,
-0.18234845995903015,
-0.1468486189842224,
0.1693180799484253,
-0.054182782769203186,
0.4025264382362366,
0.9782441258430481,
0.0928938165307045,
-0.9401330947875977,
0.73692387342453,
-0.27746060490608215,
-0.13869184255599976,
-0.5715571045875549,
0.20916734635829926,
0.39561572670936584,
0.5637401938438416,
0.06242118030786514,
-0.0027234661392867565,
0.2561819851398468,
-0.7604435086250305,
-0.03974658623337746,
0.4755411148071289,
-0.6584469079971313,
-0.4894491732120514,
0.33891305327415466,
0.5293567776679993,
-0.49903029203414917,
0.8759688138961792,
-0.40580928325653076,
-0.7426517605781555,
0.704441249370575,
0.4250568151473999,
1.057092547416687,
-0.2667917013168335,
0.23843413591384888,
0.3712552487850189,
-0.14312314987182617,
0.13964128494262695,
0.7049513459205627,
-0.07780440151691437,
-1.1129778623580933,
-0.6687191724777222,
-0.5128995180130005,
-0.7408179640769958,
0.3615696430206299,
-0.757548987865448,
-0.09578163176774979,
-0.18372173607349396,
0.1853542923927307,
0.05302070081233978,
-0.21970511972904205,
-0.6804428100585938,
0.29859572649002075,
0.5578978657722473,
0.5831484198570251,
-0.9610698819160461,
0.3684030771255493,
0.3757591247558594,
-0.22278526425361633,
-0.8816155791282654,
-0.13558581471443176,
0.15832434594631195,
-0.731074869632721,
0.5533942580223083,
0.2967013120651245,
-0.10945992916822433,
0.14335395395755768,
-0.7789044976234436,
-0.3651205897331238,
0.8041977286338806,
0.10651528835296631,
-0.8131682276725769,
0.36180657148361206,
-0.24916844069957733,
0.47157254815101624,
-0.7587478756904602,
0.5717427134513855,
0.5939543843269348,
0.5884087085723877,
0.06297522038221359,
-0.4077264666557312,
-0.01273803785443306,
-0.41167789697647095,
-0.5551535487174988,
0.2387481927871704,
-0.3499283492565155,
0.886860728263855,
-0.5963813066482544,
-0.1889282912015915,
-0.15834780037403107,
0.6166737675666809,
-0.03843388706445694,
0.5167961120605469,
0.8256458640098572,
0.5546733736991882,
0.9484225511550903,
-0.1467418372631073,
1.0170679092407227,
-0.13834890723228455,
0.149983748793602,
0.9023292660713196,
-0.5052782893180847,
0.9771080613136292,
0.40455517172813416,
-0.24272851645946503,
0.8020405769348145,
0.48379549384117126,
0.3468344509601593,
0.0222245492041111,
0.2649659216403961,
-0.45481064915657043,
-0.5118013024330139,
-0.30926135182380676,
-0.12203279137611389,
0.630923867225647,
0.7045753002166748,
-0.47414910793304443,
0.13297250866889954,
0.23027025163173676,
0.04197968170046806,
-0.14402122795581818,
-0.4048996567726135,
1.0833913087844849,
0.216237872838974,
-0.7601538300514221,
-0.041108179837465286,
-0.4264642596244812,
0.23526455461978912,
-0.23583385348320007,
-0.20171478390693665,
-0.24310320615768433,
0.2993801236152649,
-0.14901146292686462,
-0.8692061901092529,
0.2141212821006775,
0.2670478820800781,
-0.07459467649459839,
-0.4806164503097534,
0.7101353406906128,
-0.5058732628822327,
-0.3075479567050934,
0.48791998624801636,
0.5025644898414612,
0.530430018901825,
-0.46061235666275024,
-0.5828210115432739,
0.0827033519744873,
0.2101183384656906,
-0.46229425072669983,
0.12409167736768723,
0.887673556804657,
0.06709028780460358,
0.6362631916999817,
0.5324758887290955,
-0.027509015053510666,
-0.5388022065162659,
0.36284127831459045,
0.7018661499023438,
-0.9280462861061096,
-0.2808651030063629,
-1.1513460874557495,
0.6913685202598572,
-0.1332133263349533,
-0.17577169835567474,
0.18710871040821075,
0.09219127893447876,
0.3144574463367462,
0.04131382703781128,
0.7132571935653687,
0.005044793244451284,
0.6331539750099182,
-0.4706666171550751,
0.46755823493003845,
-0.7096284627914429,
0.12061760574579239,
-0.47269192337989807,
-0.9135698080062866,
0.10780452191829681,
0.713056743144989,
-0.14723528921604156,
-0.12930983304977417,
0.9223688840866089,
0.5464686155319214,
0.3115396797657013,
0.6462631225585938,
0.28847736120224,
0.711747944355011,
0.25744110345840454,
0.8234212398529053,
1.0979026556015015,
0.07037680596113205,
0.4553074240684509,
-0.14380300045013428,
-0.287786066532135,
-0.3233545422554016,
-1.0280612707138062,
-0.6669104695320129,
-0.5243310928344727,
-0.5782959461212158,
-0.020427294075489044,
-0.3169451355934143,
1.0716546773910522,
0.3734271824359894,
-0.7657978534698486,
0.0952419862151146,
-0.48208481073379517,
0.5229519009590149,
-0.3202480673789978,
-0.2530394494533539,
0.27132514119148254,
-0.1568322479724884,
-0.766096293926239,
0.5398975610733032,
0.5726390480995178,
-0.08960404992103577,
-0.0807599276304245,
-0.25115880370140076,
0.00226385286077857,
0.37627121806144714,
0.44600343704223633,
0.2229628711938858,
-0.762547492980957,
-0.5838531851768494,
-0.17554926872253418,
0.3680289387702942,
0.10977476090192795,
0.6687173247337341,
-0.5417621731758118,
0.5843499302864075,
0.6041445136070251,
0.15534162521362305,
0.2025764137506485,
-0.11273559927940369,
0.7006664872169495,
-0.45455098152160645,
-0.14670078456401825,
0.12307555228471756,
0.6602746248245239,
0.44578373432159424,
-0.4072537124156952,
0.41118323802948,
0.23787260055541992,
-0.6592192649841309,
-0.6137000322341919,
0.45573922991752625,
-0.9925157427787781,
-0.07204431295394897,
1.0488322973251343,
-0.5265859961509705,
-0.36432769894599915,
0.04261746630072594,
-0.5320047736167908,
0.5113829374313354,
-0.3259032070636749,
0.6422324180603027,
0.8843439221382141,
-0.4751376807689667,
-0.49831536412239075,
-0.35733088850975037,
0.594024121761322,
0.5213516354560852,
-1.039285659790039,
0.4775349199771881,
0.24592898786067963,
-0.11640428006649017,
0.1753300577402115,
0.539875328540802,
-0.054603785276412964,
0.09227339923381805,
-0.1436735838651657,
0.38929200172424316,
0.19955140352249146,
-0.19137710332870483,
-0.2645818591117859,
0.035348933190107346,
-0.12681499123573303,
-0.014581873081624508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04752v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04752v1
|
CRiskEval: A Chinese Multi-Level Risk Evaluation Benchmark Dataset for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-07T08:52:24 | 2024-06-07T08:52:24 |
Ling Shi, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are possessed of numerous beneficial
capabilities, yet their potential inclination harbors unpredictable risks that
may materialize in the future. We hence propose CRiskEval, a Chinese dataset
meticulously designed for gauging the risk proclivities inherent in LLMs such
as resource acquisition and malicious coordination, as part of efforts for
proactive preparedness. To curate CRiskEval, we define a new risk taxonomy with
7 types of frontier risks and 4 safety levels, including extremely
hazardous,moderately hazardous, neutral and safe. We follow the philosophy of
tendency evaluation to empirically measure the stated desire of LLMs via
fine-grained multiple-choice question answering. The dataset consists of 14,888
questions that simulate scenarios related to predefined 7 types of frontier
risks. Each question is accompanied with 4 answer choices that state opinions
or behavioral tendencies corresponding to the question. All answer choices are
manually annotated with one of the defined risk levels so that we can easily
build a fine-grained frontier risk profile for each assessed LLM. Extensive
evaluation with CRiskEval on a spectrum of prevalent Chinese LLMs has unveiled
a striking revelation: most models exhibit risk tendencies of more than 40%
(weighted tendency to the four risk levels). Furthermore, a subtle increase in
the model's inclination toward urgent self-sustainability, power seeking and
other dangerous goals becomes evident as the size of models increase. To
promote further research on the frontier risk evaluation of LLMs, we publicly
release our dataset at https://github.com/lingshi6565/Risk_eval.
|
[
0.22053903341293335,
-0.5693008899688721,
0.11515326797962189,
0.45335155725479126,
-0.10167446732521057,
0.06662411987781525,
-0.3214176297187805,
-0.5715621113777161,
-0.1163221001625061,
0.5931112766265869,
-0.3833361566066742,
-0.6456272006034851,
-0.635148823261261,
-0.4042820334434509,
-0.36645016074180603,
1.0850387811660767,
0.12079577147960663,
0.13949055969715118,
0.3572084903717041,
-0.054279401898384094,
-0.4943425953388214,
-0.3245173394680023,
-0.4795904755592346,
-0.03626661375164986,
0.6613351106643677,
0.28874027729034424,
0.8506818413734436,
0.805097758769989,
0.8261988162994385,
0.19585086405277252,
0.20635566115379333,
-0.42965054512023926,
-0.44379857182502747,
0.002436040434986353,
-0.014565344899892807,
-0.5671094655990601,
-0.5314207673072815,
0.03153018653392792,
0.652582585811615,
0.7854052782058716,
-0.5278406143188477,
0.5697447657585144,
0.21212629973888397,
0.45043644309043884,
-0.5629246830940247,
-0.02384807914495468,
-0.9626107215881348,
0.10436493158340454,
-0.6008589863777161,
-0.15871399641036987,
-0.28122347593307495,
-0.4480520188808441,
0.47089317440986633,
-0.344089150428772,
0.026785513386130333,
0.16042357683181763,
0.6338310837745667,
0.02560802735388279,
-0.548597514629364,
-0.2192097306251526,
-0.47220540046691895,
1.0028083324432373,
-0.45568975806236267,
0.3931513726711273,
0.08542579412460327,
0.5706198811531067,
-0.18174949288368225,
-0.8064110279083252,
-0.19704103469848633,
-0.3380950689315796,
0.18091069161891937,
-0.02835635468363762,
0.37464824318885803,
0.04211435467004776,
0.14191579818725586,
0.4202221930027008,
-0.8158715963363647,
0.11240247637033463,
-0.39594486355781555,
-0.474469393491745,
0.8244293928146362,
0.5636916160583496,
0.4877447783946991,
-0.13821516931056976,
-0.7792339324951172,
-0.2724568247795105,
-1.1900132894515991,
0.40514323115348816,
0.3758547902107239,
0.5485260486602783,
-0.19001710414886475,
0.3441307842731476,
-0.0671255961060524,
0.3327874541282654,
-0.40662211179733276,
-0.21356108784675598,
0.3917705714702606,
-0.3590533137321472,
-0.13981996476650238,
0.12717287242412567,
0.7765288352966309,
0.7021793127059937,
0.15122640132904053,
0.1900622397661209,
-0.23927898705005646,
-0.34068888425827026,
0.20270416140556335,
-0.7707877159118652,
-0.3323376178741455,
0.48076131939888,
-0.6512505412101746,
-0.2962564527988434,
-0.01734042912721634,
-1.1075999736785889,
-0.776581346988678,
0.1033160462975502,
0.14911618828773499,
-0.37643879652023315,
-0.3342248797416687,
0.15584954619407654,
0.06773799657821655,
0.45822837948799133,
0.05132891610264778,
-0.7162823677062988,
-0.014453016221523285,
0.6567665934562683,
0.6998500823974609,
-0.23887407779693604,
-0.5642063021659851,
-0.5669552087783813,
0.11763616651296616,
-0.5656238794326782,
0.7349364757537842,
-0.5482357740402222,
-0.5674935579299927,
0.4673891067504883,
0.01754760928452015,
0.18165147304534912,
-0.522717297077179,
1.0439209938049316,
-0.24552947282791138,
-0.35735446214675903,
-0.48315754532814026,
0.1306043416261673,
-0.021558135747909546,
0.40094393491744995,
-0.5705475807189941,
0.9885842204093933,
-0.09048300981521606,
-0.63609379529953,
0.7344986796379089,
-0.4433457851409912,
-0.4344424903392792,
0.41700980067253113,
-0.19366490840911865,
-0.27579689025878906,
-0.33037158846855164,
-0.057422686368227005,
0.45911771059036255,
-0.5868697166442871,
0.42197102308273315,
-0.4838807284832001,
-0.013728264719247818,
0.2768758237361908,
-0.5451865196228027,
0.7604764699935913,
0.2200155109167099,
-0.1514405608177185,
0.39479631185531616,
-0.6689392328262329,
0.25907477736473083,
0.1834058165550232,
-0.4163447916507721,
-0.6174344420433044,
0.14816592633724213,
0.1210612952709198,
0.44919800758361816,
0.6486369967460632,
-0.4763622581958771,
-0.040758632123470306,
-0.205650195479393,
0.5015872120857239,
0.8423238396644592,
0.1115836575627327,
0.18795840442180634,
-0.410161554813385,
0.32711490988731384,
-0.017838843166828156,
0.6792687177658081,
-0.050063252449035645,
0.023762812837958336,
-0.7778488993644714,
-0.07386346906423569,
0.16285943984985352,
0.6704031825065613,
-0.5826776623725891,
0.13759702444076538,
-0.40843135118484497,
-0.9870274662971497,
-0.2719717025756836,
0.02098887413740158,
0.4128606915473938,
0.13768935203552246,
0.189996138215065,
0.1261839121580124,
-0.3151955008506775,
-0.854267954826355,
-0.5720688104629517,
-0.23781131207942963,
-0.13740675151348114,
0.16582776606082916,
0.2958579659461975,
-0.05236809328198433,
0.33916547894477844,
-0.5833638310432434,
-0.4035366475582123,
-0.38199910521507263,
0.08286778628826141,
0.20481276512145996,
0.44230273365974426,
0.5816282033920288,
-0.7686187028884888,
-0.6104860901832581,
-0.13001328706741333,
-0.5525587201118469,
-0.0019134188769385219,
-0.3790690004825592,
-0.3271816074848175,
-0.009536396712064743,
0.19314980506896973,
-0.4324256479740143,
0.01123796310275793,
0.4822278320789337,
0.14886891841888428,
0.7569920420646667,
-0.03451785445213318,
-0.019955556839704514,
-0.9024378061294556,
-0.03992360085248947,
0.3141806721687317,
0.4311859607696533,
-0.9133504033088684,
0.24445874989032745,
0.23336434364318848,
0.0764603242278099,
-0.4949987232685089,
0.42819419503211975,
-0.5238165855407715,
-0.02514071762561798,
0.08403607457876205,
0.2654961943626404,
-0.37346434593200684,
0.2089967131614685,
0.04482760652899742,
0.5853143930435181,
0.7308159470558167,
-0.568213701248169,
0.33936795592308044,
0.08798772096633911,
-0.5246798992156982,
0.3914319574832916,
-0.6525198221206665,
-0.21341049671173096,
0.3008994460105896,
0.0907670110464096,
-0.7112386226654053,
-0.19936540722846985,
0.12321585416793823,
-0.2452695220708847,
0.1275131106376648,
0.18366897106170654,
-0.13286183774471283,
-0.34272730350494385,
-0.7175037264823914,
0.40291568636894226,
0.3352941572666168,
-0.4874345064163208,
0.6408467888832092,
0.5669242739677429,
-0.543436586856842,
-0.941911518573761,
-0.6702350378036499,
0.3252999484539032,
-0.5068181157112122,
-0.5854613780975342,
0.08773539215326309,
-0.16218841075897217,
-0.2624664902687073,
-0.3058629631996155,
-0.02168041467666626,
0.000735620444174856,
0.03283185511827469,
0.5258339643478394,
0.5997609496116638,
0.02978162281215191,
0.06854987144470215,
-0.2153628021478653,
0.038687579333782196,
0.36294034123420715,
-0.09262421727180481,
0.6689024567604065,
-0.09828149527311325,
-0.18840771913528442,
-0.027374476194381714,
0.07849612087011337,
0.19562500715255737,
-0.47688236832618713,
0.38766106963157654,
0.3227834701538086,
-0.5789235830307007,
-0.5507376194000244,
-0.33753272891044617,
0.14623650908470154,
-0.516964316368103,
0.5974556803703308,
-0.2874838709831238,
-0.6417253613471985,
0.6888460516929626,
0.06178133562207222,
0.5053712725639343,
0.5883442163467407,
0.6735895276069641,
0.3473333716392517,
0.6650151610374451,
0.543346107006073,
-0.2914518713951111,
0.18447339534759521,
-0.1846504807472229,
0.23077978193759918,
-0.7000248432159424,
-0.3790872097015381,
-0.4954341650009155,
0.030452905222773552,
-0.665349543094635,
-0.2847813665866852,
0.4706405997276306,
-0.5148487687110901,
-0.3940916657447815,
0.3508996069431305,
-0.3148456811904907,
0.1464255303144455,
0.2478255331516266,
-0.15379095077514648,
0.28952473402023315,
-0.2765936553478241,
0.015605181455612183,
-0.08912277221679688,
-0.4391409158706665,
-0.6142385005950928,
1.2513792514801025,
0.7260693907737732,
1.1371475458145142,
0.04526408389210701,
0.48782870173454285,
0.3608764111995697,
0.5066068172454834,
-0.6173471212387085,
0.6338144540786743,
-0.0876530110836029,
-0.7998675107955933,
-0.5971446633338928,
-0.39178115129470825,
-0.8155736327171326,
0.21405796706676483,
-0.31546398997306824,
-0.5191327929496765,
0.1799650341272354,
-0.03997479006648064,
-0.6858780384063721,
0.1973383128643036,
-0.17581675946712494,
0.6809422373771667,
-0.6719248294830322,
-0.2949007749557495,
-0.23737680912017822,
-0.702802836894989,
0.9235610961914062,
-0.320344477891922,
0.226533904671669,
-0.23350632190704346,
-0.14932727813720703,
0.5430024862289429,
0.014163301326334476,
0.8449482321739197,
-0.13644611835479736,
-0.318819522857666,
0.2211189866065979,
0.27777665853500366,
0.46912872791290283,
0.13171541690826416,
-0.30892789363861084,
0.4024657905101776,
0.24793222546577454,
-0.24983391165733337,
-0.13112199306488037,
0.8847138285636902,
-0.7254788875579834,
-0.5367701649665833,
-0.8025997877120972,
-0.6129276752471924,
-0.048649631440639496,
0.33781537413597107,
0.14184366166591644,
0.5064429044723511,
-0.5152179598808289,
0.10160553455352783,
0.3929620385169983,
-0.5867022275924683,
0.3266809582710266,
0.5078250765800476,
-0.12829488515853882,
-0.5179972052574158,
1.0587068796157837,
0.3407489061355591,
0.5273721814155579,
0.10797280818223953,
0.05905993655323982,
-0.39592745900154114,
-0.8326138257980347,
-0.16295520961284637,
-0.09537137299776077,
-0.8419873714447021,
-0.15947404503822327,
-0.46958690881729126,
-0.5490885376930237,
-0.3418123126029968,
-0.03588653728365898,
-0.2579847574234009,
0.10589728504419327,
0.17962966859340668,
-0.17314860224723816,
-0.08157170563936234,
0.4851531982421875,
0.09377001971006393,
0.23459410667419434,
-0.9894711971282959,
0.10239281505346298,
0.05637262016534805,
0.4223414361476898,
0.0641174241900444,
-0.42981693148612976,
-0.2415667176246643,
0.08279057592153549,
-0.2829541265964508,
-0.3897406756877899,
0.564316987991333,
0.3187158405780792,
0.9326082468032837,
0.5851374864578247,
0.5323182344436646,
0.5133196115493774,
-0.6248914003372192,
0.8805423974990845,
0.0990137904882431,
-0.6155675053596497,
0.16072100400924683,
-0.45886024832725525,
-0.23786896467208862,
0.5735754370689392,
0.6381082534790039,
-0.8538732528686523,
-0.0609249584376812,
-0.3761745095252991,
-0.8246362209320068,
0.34876886010169983,
-0.28702712059020996,
0.2035760134458542,
-0.04693381115794182,
0.23388829827308655,
0.06448964029550552,
0.027575302869081497,
-0.8400090336799622,
-0.12820908427238464,
-0.2471863329410553,
0.06921568512916565,
-0.014358006417751312,
-0.45992228388786316,
-0.3551751971244812,
0.28894221782684326,
0.6122846007347107,
-0.04451260343194008,
-0.1518285721540451,
0.14219239354133606,
-0.09950488060712814,
-0.22879169881343842,
0.3689168393611908,
0.4735943675041199,
0.48438793420791626,
-0.26622986793518066,
0.1709282398223877,
0.47269079089164734,
-0.6738171577453613,
-0.07193931192159653,
0.009128594771027565,
0.13504694402217865,
-0.5476437211036682,
0.5517772436141968,
0.3733239471912384,
-0.10246147215366364,
-0.940434992313385,
0.5120740532875061,
-0.01920922100543976,
-0.251368910074234,
-0.6913740038871765,
0.005621947813779116,
-0.12539121508598328,
0.04564005509018898,
0.6520308256149292,
-0.3128444254398346,
0.24822796881198883,
-0.7104827165603638,
0.19750577211380005,
0.5178608298301697,
-0.447038471698761,
-0.1846659630537033,
0.4641219675540924,
0.3752991855144501,
-0.08716582506895065,
0.38802388310432434,
0.0593113899230957,
-0.6736776232719421,
0.5438224077224731,
0.1794036328792572,
0.9234392046928406,
-0.46296176314353943,
0.1421109437942505,
0.5973075032234192,
0.872949481010437,
-0.01953144744038582,
0.38120993971824646,
0.6034893989562988,
-0.5651240944862366,
-0.15353600680828094,
-0.7480118870735168,
-0.3926263153553009,
0.2770282030105591,
-0.4244730770587921,
0.48811909556388855,
-0.7168782949447632,
-0.001733838813379407,
-0.306491881608963,
0.17534567415714264,
-0.15622210502624512,
0.1584344059228897,
-0.12290803343057632,
1.2402338981628418,
-0.7573524117469788,
0.6509218811988831,
0.16258864104747772,
-0.20375560224056244,
-0.7255086898803711,
0.3766094446182251,
0.10143392533063889,
-0.8948256373405457,
0.6558252573013306,
0.25266048312187195,
0.04033811390399933,
-0.455773264169693,
-0.34847405552864075,
-0.8215374946594238,
1.3046989440917969,
0.013777114450931549,
-0.6993541121482849,
0.21136333048343658,
0.7277166247367859,
0.5268846154212952,
-0.3565523624420166,
0.07815670222043991,
0.6809131503105164,
0.5772942304611206,
0.018734658136963844,
-0.7786757946014404,
0.24138127267360687,
-0.13344745337963104,
0.03763464465737343,
0.2818196415901184,
-1.009886384010315,
1.0499027967453003,
-0.3496745824813843,
-0.45980656147003174,
0.18902426958084106,
0.5889756083488464,
0.3342340588569641,
0.20492622256278992,
0.6729878783226013,
0.12487387657165527,
0.4998845160007477,
-0.12200184911489487,
0.9260791540145874,
-0.6619799137115479,
0.0359196774661541,
0.936285138130188,
-0.8035441040992737,
0.9546074271202087,
0.1284167468547821,
-0.18546989560127258,
0.21224957704544067,
1.027237057685852,
-0.1044415533542633,
0.4077637195587158,
0.349915087223053,
-0.2393684834241867,
-0.4918237626552582,
-0.3212028741836548,
-0.2657434642314911,
0.29480668902397156,
0.5897859334945679,
-0.1709572672843933,
-0.3031175136566162,
-0.1917199194431305,
-0.26989343762397766,
0.10922571271657944,
-0.25956735014915466,
0.33901891112327576,
0.2084425985813141,
-0.42238858342170715,
0.43866193294525146,
-0.11628647893667221,
0.5577825903892517,
-0.7932633757591248,
-0.047751374542713165,
-0.04930349439382553,
0.2028462439775467,
-0.21619479358196259,
-1.0420386791229248,
0.1282270848751068,
-0.27995362877845764,
0.3019329309463501,
0.23506639897823334,
0.6181349754333496,
-0.5323230624198914,
-0.4527658224105835,
0.3761620819568634,
0.14888224005699158,
0.05803558975458145,
0.0852479413151741,
-0.7478359937667847,
0.003089405596256256,
-0.17956194281578064,
-0.21385687589645386,
0.5720626711845398,
0.47473761439323425,
-0.4012952148914337,
1.1085621118545532,
0.7976590991020203,
0.3124062418937683,
0.12779782712459564,
-0.035252124071121216,
0.8728536367416382,
-0.7171963453292847,
-0.2678380012512207,
-0.7502328157424927,
0.32977160811424255,
0.016871023923158646,
-0.4195277988910675,
0.6850717663764954,
0.6326066255569458,
0.40923288464546204,
0.11493213474750519,
0.9590328335762024,
-0.11300575733184814,
0.42417752742767334,
-0.391769677400589,
0.8745338320732117,
-0.4641810953617096,
0.40496885776519775,
-0.10748063772916794,
-0.7911496758460999,
-0.3643299341201782,
0.12469242513179779,
-0.48470592498779297,
-0.17771126329898834,
0.5710160136222839,
0.8610630035400391,
0.35200679302215576,
-0.08869659900665283,
0.35438552498817444,
0.20274192094802856,
0.5347036123275757,
0.8177586197853088,
0.9245468378067017,
-0.1611769199371338,
0.794719398021698,
-0.2048061490058899,
-0.3454724848270416,
-0.08264830708503723,
-1.0854945182800293,
-0.9742778539657593,
-0.5674903988838196,
0.04612690210342407,
-0.15904894471168518,
0.007523535285145044,
1.0576601028442383,
0.2611532211303711,
-0.6736699342727661,
-0.48981955647468567,
0.384587824344635,
-0.10690750926733017,
-0.12168338149785995,
-0.178842231631279,
0.47933849692344666,
-0.28090009093284607,
-0.4419481158256531,
0.04800738766789436,
0.32358357310295105,
-0.10362984985113144,
-0.6639196276664734,
0.06328155100345612,
-0.03897611424326897,
0.10654950886964798,
0.5262605547904968,
0.19630147516727448,
-0.5635986924171448,
-0.5576165914535522,
0.0823361724615097,
-0.38944852352142334,
-0.10302582383155823,
0.5233402252197266,
0.09133771806955338,
0.0031278696842491627,
0.5120310187339783,
0.5634980797767639,
-0.14853720366954803,
-0.2926607131958008,
0.4678362011909485,
-0.3003230690956116,
-0.018502013757824898,
0.0056761340238153934,
0.4459201991558075,
0.22605493664741516,
-0.47616565227508545,
0.4514000713825226,
-0.09800450503826141,
-0.7536165118217468,
-0.8869622945785522,
0.15577127039432526,
-0.9568373560905457,
-0.08940212428569794,
1.1590532064437866,
-0.30299776792526245,
-0.1735258251428604,
-0.003336777910590172,
-0.32348641753196716,
0.04349502548575401,
-0.32049816846847534,
0.8906219005584717,
0.7487509250640869,
0.18436376750469208,
-0.08188989013433456,
-1.0361597537994385,
0.6505529880523682,
0.12314099818468094,
-0.746188759803772,
0.7462255358695984,
0.3490501344203949,
0.46110478043556213,
0.17741939425468445,
0.24121078848838806,
-0.16446822881698608,
0.2655255198478699,
-0.08523780107498169,
0.2828907072544098,
0.24715594947338104,
-0.503756582736969,
-0.2788793444633484,
0.1763654500246048,
0.2585831582546234,
0.12803463637828827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04746v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04746v1
|
PQPP: A Joint Benchmark for Text-to-Image Prompt and Query Performance Prediction
| 2024-06-07T08:46:19 | 2024-06-07T08:46:19 |
Eduard Poesina, Adriana Valentina Costache, Adrian-Gabriel Chifu, Josiane Mothe, Radu Tudor Ionescu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Text-to-image generation has recently emerged as a viable alternative to
text-to-image retrieval, due to the visually impressive results of generative
diffusion models. Although query performance prediction is an active research
topic in information retrieval, to the best of our knowledge, there is no prior
study that analyzes the difficulty of queries (prompts) in text-to-image
generation, based on human judgments. To this end, we introduce the first
dataset of prompts which are manually annotated in terms of image generation
performance. In order to determine the difficulty of the same prompts in image
retrieval, we also collect manual annotations that represent retrieval
performance. We thus propose the first benchmark for joint text-to-image prompt
and query performance prediction, comprising 10K queries. Our benchmark
enables: (i) the comparative assessment of the difficulty of prompts/queries in
image generation and image retrieval, and (ii) the evaluation of prompt/query
performance predictors addressing both generation and retrieval. We present
results with several pre-generation/retrieval and post-generation/retrieval
performance predictors, thus providing competitive baselines for future
research. Our benchmark and code is publicly available under the CC BY 4.0
license at https://github.com/Eduard6421/PQPP.
|
[
-0.5504530668258667,
-0.4745260179042816,
0.625931441783905,
0.23395761847496033,
-0.3844488859176636,
-0.21626338362693787,
0.05296231061220169,
-0.41071978211402893,
-0.3014209568500519,
0.4685935080051422,
-0.49215978384017944,
-0.42014217376708984,
-0.3615797460079193,
0.3965180218219757,
-0.06493333727121353,
0.2956183850765228,
0.35313335061073303,
0.020971404388546944,
-0.5789978504180908,
0.08630428463220596,
-0.7251881957054138,
-0.19996687769889832,
-0.7165840268135071,
0.1838865429162979,
0.5424671769142151,
0.2904665172100067,
0.8672580718994141,
0.3686334490776062,
0.5853578448295593,
0.17960068583488464,
0.16801011562347412,
0.1464615762233734,
-0.33708783984184265,
0.41136160492897034,
-0.18539531528949738,
-0.4312802851200104,
0.16229332983493805,
-0.014097791165113449,
0.7808453440666199,
0.4354611337184906,
0.20283396542072296,
-0.16804859042167664,
-0.06148118898272514,
0.9090999960899353,
-0.9004126191139221,
-0.028938332572579384,
-0.8424192667007446,
0.29218071699142456,
-0.4124574065208435,
-0.47526291012763977,
-0.6973488926887512,
-0.4776875078678131,
0.061132267117500305,
-0.8803715109825134,
0.4020256996154785,
0.553728461265564,
0.6993735432624817,
0.2619609832763672,
-0.6053749322891235,
-0.09908431023359299,
-0.08266662806272507,
0.404269278049469,
-0.14531297981739044,
0.29173025488853455,
0.5283656120300293,
0.7382807731628418,
-0.45152273774147034,
-1.192081332206726,
-0.7062845826148987,
-0.1908355951309204,
-0.12024597823619843,
0.23863136768341064,
-0.2902115285396576,
-0.23096050322055817,
0.5403903126716614,
0.2502022981643677,
-0.6080697774887085,
-0.07736308127641678,
-0.06894626468420029,
-0.2696914076805115,
0.5504951477050781,
0.16168645024299622,
0.3614324629306793,
-0.35302790999412537,
-0.49590611457824707,
-0.403127521276474,
-0.6118643283843994,
0.25626295804977417,
0.04548061639070511,
0.12202950567007065,
0.2418885976076126,
0.628681480884552,
-0.4278927445411682,
0.5519214272499084,
0.09163077920675278,
0.09117913991212845,
0.2603670358657837,
-0.31038326025009155,
0.19564877450466156,
-0.24660292267799377,
1.3303258419036865,
0.7489151954650879,
-0.11795943230390549,
-0.19103454053401947,
-0.31585609912872314,
-0.12978792190551758,
0.11373046040534973,
-0.8858222365379333,
-0.4467819035053253,
-0.21923890709877014,
-0.5837569832801819,
0.025185832753777504,
0.0015673218294978142,
-0.9838908910751343,
-0.7145758867263794,
0.22621560096740723,
0.6055166721343994,
-0.6103509664535522,
-0.14673131704330444,
-0.2587721049785614,
-0.30099910497665405,
0.2752528190612793,
0.4835917055606842,
-0.32392430305480957,
0.20755231380462646,
0.5880230665206909,
0.9431696534156799,
-0.22040018439292908,
-0.29555854201316833,
-0.6665226221084595,
-0.2088356614112854,
-0.37599173188209534,
1.2458680868148804,
-0.6093646287918091,
-0.6354624032974243,
0.09877689182758331,
0.11761194467544556,
-0.02324477583169937,
-0.6105742454528809,
0.9926234483718872,
-0.5998689532279968,
0.3357962369918823,
-0.6614840030670166,
-0.694563090801239,
0.23002777993679047,
-0.10058700293302536,
-0.9386515617370605,
1.0216032266616821,
0.18403390049934387,
-0.9959384799003601,
0.6079951524734497,
-0.46075257658958435,
-0.30738091468811035,
0.6483991742134094,
-0.32024917006492615,
-0.3364919424057007,
0.02366514876484871,
0.33112800121307373,
0.28274282813072205,
-0.8291143178939819,
-0.034845419228076935,
-0.1380237340927124,
-0.6365828514099121,
0.3377648890018463,
-0.09451298415660858,
0.40035438537597656,
0.22994481027126312,
-0.1516568809747696,
-0.2633223831653595,
-0.5679923295974731,
0.17552877962589264,
0.516368567943573,
-0.03719637170433998,
0.005949763115495443,
0.18307510018348694,
-0.11359550803899765,
0.2687622606754303,
0.2597624659538269,
-0.3731396198272705,
0.20364022254943848,
0.08155621588230133,
0.09678100049495697,
0.47747907042503357,
0.16862380504608154,
0.2886916697025299,
-0.25458499789237976,
0.5730336904525757,
-0.06349793076515198,
0.16354888677597046,
-0.8055356740951538,
-0.8834608197212219,
-0.08565140515565872,
-0.1514042317867279,
0.3632310628890991,
0.448162317276001,
-1.1963657140731812,
0.059295542538166046,
-0.006086197216063738,
-0.6201498508453369,
-0.3505597710609436,
-0.2239779829978943,
0.5303695797920227,
0.9459649920463562,
0.3221856951713562,
-0.5453429222106934,
0.0065076835453510284,
-0.9803608059883118,
-0.498661071062088,
-0.35920292139053345,
-0.4132877290248871,
0.6118927001953125,
0.21561434864997864,
0.4381036162376404,
0.6472261548042297,
-0.5148045420646667,
-0.15990091860294342,
0.4379265308380127,
0.4926411211490631,
0.11997226625680923,
0.4165162444114685,
0.5763012170791626,
-0.9478859305381775,
-0.5275924801826477,
-0.5863152146339417,
-0.48568475246429443,
-0.22742804884910583,
0.1005907952785492,
-0.41721242666244507,
0.17727144062519073,
0.34724223613739014,
-0.6336004137992859,
0.47830313444137573,
0.12633216381072998,
-0.6752217411994934,
0.8127759099006653,
-0.1357826292514801,
0.7497390508651733,
-0.7719392776489258,
0.24271216988563538,
0.2756216526031494,
-0.029082950204610825,
-0.002637134864926338,
-0.1729811578989029,
0.3919815719127655,
-0.6227314472198486,
-0.35071563720703125,
0.4584890305995941,
-0.6323400139808655,
-0.35686883330345154,
-0.030101224780082703,
0.0352153405547142,
0.17635232210159302,
0.13121502101421356,
0.15239311754703522,
1.3140943050384521,
0.7306259870529175,
-0.5351278185844421,
0.3024997413158417,
0.3213333785533905,
-0.5825918316841125,
0.8478439450263977,
-0.8701057434082031,
0.36967742443084717,
-0.12330564856529236,
0.3721098005771637,
-1.5453771352767944,
-0.14481128752231598,
0.31977102160453796,
-0.6663219928741455,
0.17444393038749695,
-0.16940538585186005,
-0.8966906070709229,
-0.39179447293281555,
-0.30844220519065857,
0.4122641086578369,
0.7181164026260376,
-0.550053596496582,
0.2823883295059204,
0.10401789844036102,
-0.1454962193965912,
-0.3967938721179962,
-0.22634391486644745,
0.3727910816669464,
0.05557621270418167,
-0.7330938577651978,
0.6982663869857788,
0.1036461815237999,
0.3445367217063904,
-0.0928373783826828,
0.3839343190193176,
-0.007513197138905525,
-0.1142171248793602,
0.4123622477054596,
0.2278243899345398,
-0.09681553393602371,
0.27938324213027954,
0.012296556495130062,
-0.1036735326051712,
0.17340287566184998,
0.04240487515926361,
0.3707726299762726,
0.21489639580249786,
-0.23298770189285278,
-0.514488935470581,
0.31045302748680115,
0.26311737298965454,
-0.4021419286727905,
0.5685097575187683,
0.3536534905433655,
-0.14927582442760468,
0.27223581075668335,
-0.5487203001976013,
-0.04335896670818329,
-0.43143177032470703,
0.006905838847160339,
-0.6856557726860046,
-0.22262825071811676,
0.34196528792381287,
-0.4681795537471771,
-0.16094966232776642,
0.5227273106575012,
0.0815490186214447,
-0.25741615891456604,
1.305829644203186,
0.1935233175754547,
0.3714650869369507,
0.5774731040000916,
0.0914280042052269,
-0.3349955677986145,
-0.5981464982032776,
-0.332283079624176,
-0.6974930167198181,
-0.2742912769317627,
-0.6941176652908325,
-0.6327260732650757,
0.4648841321468353,
0.3556033670902252,
-0.26252481341362,
0.003061594208702445,
-0.6303488612174988,
0.4489049017429352,
0.8048753142356873,
0.2481319159269333,
0.185647651553154,
0.22833091020584106,
-0.28095999360084534,
-0.3024365305900574,
-0.4647694230079651,
-0.46715763211250305,
1.157765507698059,
-0.1466224640607834,
0.40275582671165466,
-0.0392153337597847,
0.4412633776664734,
0.4214528203010559,
-0.11685441434383392,
-0.44150683283805847,
0.8372122645378113,
-0.09671379625797272,
-0.09435338526964188,
-0.0030873583164066076,
-0.4638620913028717,
-1.1035808324813843,
0.11436493694782257,
-0.6411178708076477,
-0.591391921043396,
0.16964365541934967,
0.15640473365783691,
-0.07010518014431,
-0.02557390369474888,
-0.8152888417243958,
1.0231155157089233,
-0.2695971429347992,
-0.8069994449615479,
-0.012444237247109413,
-0.7910539507865906,
0.08805479854345322,
0.20029255747795105,
-0.27984848618507385,
-0.24112726747989655,
-0.5552621483802795,
0.6643844842910767,
-0.29003915190696716,
0.30754753947257996,
-0.6068379878997803,
0.4988870322704315,
0.22935688495635986,
0.14337676763534546,
0.4772636890411377,
-0.06755422055721283,
-0.3225496709346771,
-0.048228781670331955,
-0.015390907414257526,
-0.48338183760643005,
-0.5142414569854736,
0.42721331119537354,
-0.5032756328582764,
-0.32876676321029663,
-0.30169397592544556,
-0.13361667096614838,
-0.251633882522583,
0.24501118063926697,
0.7026777267456055,
0.305629163980484,
-0.07360730320215225,
0.11447397619485855,
0.4664786159992218,
-0.6069843769073486,
0.43891170620918274,
0.38997963070869446,
-0.232688769698143,
-0.4820678234100342,
0.8058041930198669,
-0.033748187124729156,
-0.26352232694625854,
0.442429780960083,
0.1950731873512268,
-0.8587986826896667,
-0.6890113353729248,
-0.48603489995002747,
0.1073203980922699,
-0.5618276000022888,
-0.35575413703918457,
-0.4431953728199005,
0.3719441592693329,
-0.3893977403640747,
0.08848774433135986,
-0.16595248878002167,
-0.3243887424468994,
-0.253097265958786,
0.630694568157196,
0.29327601194381714,
0.22127680480480194,
0.32340946793556213,
0.2560889720916748,
-0.6803721785545349,
0.39579078555107117,
0.21676453948020935,
0.4770843982696533,
-0.17559285461902618,
-0.32597967982292175,
0.2528221607208252,
-0.35598981380462646,
-0.649679958820343,
-1.0830225944519043,
0.27244478464126587,
0.31853801012039185,
0.3920663297176361,
0.12905429303646088,
0.6208623051643372,
0.44292688369750977,
-0.4142771065235138,
0.9969152212142944,
0.46563616394996643,
-0.6072378158569336,
1.055295467376709,
-0.2424047887325287,
0.29661914706230164,
0.6721669435501099,
0.6315289735794067,
-0.26920074224472046,
-0.1750168353319168,
-0.4152098596096039,
-0.9146284461021423,
0.6030305624008179,
0.03808277100324631,
-0.19516155123710632,
-0.21707379817962646,
0.4747554361820221,
0.2636129558086395,
0.1856824904680252,
-0.2672055959701538,
-0.021119410172104836,
-0.25047191977500916,
0.1944720596075058,
-0.03168933466076851,
-0.36144354939460754,
0.25343436002731323,
-0.12330503016710281,
0.26640230417251587,
-0.31149783730506897,
0.4480673372745514,
0.3202457129955292,
0.04831288382411003,
-0.20923419296741486,
-0.03980813920497894,
-0.028804223984479904,
0.7308106422424316,
-0.17139507830142975,
-0.1443275809288025,
-0.38801443576812744,
-0.31409603357315063,
-0.1069733127951622,
0.3934153616428375,
-0.2271995097398758,
-0.006591642741113901,
0.17935335636138916,
0.8578529953956604,
-0.09673577547073364,
-0.7756857872009277,
0.6653211116790771,
-0.6804580092430115,
-0.11772022396326065,
-0.132553830742836,
-0.10746089369058609,
-0.18732000887393951,
0.2870098352432251,
0.9026273488998413,
-0.24151134490966797,
0.5225071310997009,
-0.34348005056381226,
0.1658247858285904,
0.37859755754470825,
0.020533155649900436,
-0.10217879712581635,
0.7447067499160767,
0.3497692346572876,
-0.37293025851249695,
0.7789197564125061,
-0.5310290455818176,
-0.25181344151496887,
0.5225775837898254,
0.39832931756973267,
0.5884217023849487,
0.05944490805268288,
0.27727243304252625,
0.6516146063804626,
-0.15367314219474792,
-0.11099579185247421,
0.3701767027378082,
-0.2555162012577057,
-0.30157583951950073,
-0.07218122482299805,
-0.28257009387016296,
-0.5663933753967285,
-0.202443927526474,
-0.6892903447151184,
0.28705868124961853,
-0.4168740212917328,
-0.6033027172088623,
0.3328721821308136,
0.3767465054988861,
-0.6728085279464722,
0.3375920057296753,
-0.0573950931429863,
1.0040074586868286,
-0.4686005711555481,
0.43277448415756226,
0.9506239891052246,
-0.42967110872268677,
-0.6157441139221191,
0.2084757536649704,
-0.21473407745361328,
-0.668776273727417,
0.6121358871459961,
0.3622463643550873,
0.3278225064277649,
0.013501040637493134,
-0.5031783580780029,
-0.20664064586162567,
1.2503890991210938,
0.4255571663379669,
-0.7569791078567505,
0.17744767665863037,
0.016935931518673897,
0.30770429968833923,
-0.19178135693073273,
0.6189182996749878,
0.33730044960975647,
0.2799375653266907,
0.489798367023468,
-0.8003090023994446,
0.3988696336746216,
-0.3501899242401123,
0.346052885055542,
0.26567232608795166,
-0.47856470942497253,
0.9100777506828308,
-0.22072510421276093,
-0.5636423230171204,
0.4056975841522217,
0.5911228060722351,
0.4061375558376312,
0.8656590580940247,
0.6012856364250183,
0.39845988154411316,
0.7497084736824036,
-0.4532063901424408,
1.2596303224563599,
-0.5126577615737915,
-0.023629331961274147,
0.8626861572265625,
-0.2935185730457306,
1.1472651958465576,
0.42367082834243774,
-0.507879376411438,
0.12158061563968658,
0.7457339763641357,
0.007469949312508106,
0.7718619704246521,
-0.09551538527011871,
-0.3508416414260864,
-0.15281882882118225,
-0.42119738459587097,
-0.7313392162322998,
0.24264585971832275,
0.1295238733291626,
-0.601542592048645,
-0.022365374490618706,
-0.3290671110153198,
-0.5772974491119385,
0.27211636304855347,
-0.2122681587934494,
0.8265427947044373,
-0.38162240386009216,
-1.0210920572280884,
0.6081428527832031,
-0.2595300078392029,
0.6659097671508789,
-0.1833302527666092,
-0.20283064246177673,
-0.19270199537277222,
-0.3150777816772461,
-0.0327405221760273,
-1.2253066301345825,
-0.17510980367660522,
-0.30645880103111267,
-0.11255596578121185,
0.08634509146213531,
1.1425762176513672,
-0.12735922634601593,
-0.2557397782802582,
-0.007078066933900118,
0.44896578788757324,
0.2189352661371231,
-0.37773868441581726,
-0.9499384164810181,
-0.0012141376500949264,
-0.1925390511751175,
-0.17924325168132782,
0.4534229040145874,
0.7449244260787964,
0.12292463332414627,
0.4892205595970154,
0.43577808141708374,
-0.08838161081075668,
0.08257061243057251,
-0.011103675700724125,
0.8988175988197327,
-0.7588748931884766,
-0.35481786727905273,
-0.508982241153717,
0.3324919641017914,
-0.2733161151409149,
-0.4243753254413605,
0.2940654456615448,
0.6110376715660095,
0.5195637345314026,
-0.0944313257932663,
0.596900224685669,
-0.13220752775669098,
0.5074880123138428,
-0.4649914503097534,
0.5601636171340942,
-0.7229956984519958,
-0.023464662954211235,
-0.3784703314304352,
-0.8055070042610168,
0.085312619805336,
0.33125394582748413,
-0.38248273730278015,
0.012709196656942368,
0.47417527437210083,
0.9862219095230103,
0.3406943380832672,
0.038336895406246185,
0.253323495388031,
-0.3373509645462036,
0.18990211188793182,
0.7281498312950134,
1.1755292415618896,
-0.49255895614624023,
0.6455903649330139,
-0.6003044247627258,
-0.2245233803987503,
-0.30265554785728455,
-1.1205415725708008,
-0.5598443746566772,
-0.8770902752876282,
-0.3415829837322235,
-0.2917928993701935,
0.18526138365268707,
0.4455464780330658,
0.5287716388702393,
-0.20169316232204437,
0.08954276889562607,
-0.29942020773887634,
-0.1436120867729187,
-0.0050807734951376915,
-0.23964865505695343,
0.30304744839668274,
-0.3110221326351166,
-0.5699685215950012,
0.060486383736133575,
0.1149461567401886,
0.08862918615341187,
0.17290399968624115,
-0.08418242633342743,
-0.08869210630655289,
-0.40027788281440735,
0.38783249258995056,
0.46281424164772034,
-0.41218918561935425,
0.23129160702228546,
-0.16896599531173706,
-0.17054975032806396,
0.2649436295032501,
0.9132215976715088,
-1.1508954763412476,
0.6387845277786255,
0.6375789046287537,
0.47432050108909607,
0.5191381573677063,
0.2763676643371582,
0.5602312684059143,
-0.7924311757087708,
0.1326577067375183,
0.3761489987373352,
0.165069118142128,
0.48473063111305237,
-0.3376792073249817,
0.4667247235774994,
0.29809340834617615,
-0.6374396681785583,
-0.8194292187690735,
0.05135061591863632,
-0.7944276928901672,
-0.08804831653833389,
0.665746808052063,
-0.32897645235061646,
-0.23138172924518585,
0.2941819727420807,
-0.4746778905391693,
0.22412057220935822,
-0.7531915307044983,
0.5703379511833191,
0.14946016669273376,
-0.3262629210948944,
-0.7461702823638916,
-0.44347697496414185,
0.5103983283042908,
0.6060540080070496,
-0.6597026586532593,
-0.0396774597465992,
0.8369372487068176,
-0.10061538964509964,
0.09990669041872025,
0.8384110331535339,
-0.14761877059936523,
0.7301433086395264,
0.2588437795639038,
-0.03749911114573479,
-0.09097488969564438,
-0.10838435590267181,
0.08814503997564316,
0.43112194538116455,
0.39652368426322937,
-0.3943895697593689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04744v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04744v1
|
CRAG -- Comprehensive RAG Benchmark
| 2024-06-07T08:43:07 | 2024-06-07T08:43:07 |
Xiao Yang, Kai Sun, Hao Xin, Yushi Sun, Nikita Bhalla, Xiangsen Chen, Sajal Choudhary, Rongze Daniel Gui, Ziran Will Jiang, Ziyu Jiang, Lingkun Kong, Brian Moran, Jiaqi Wang, Yifan Ethan Xu, An Yan, Chenyu Yang, Eting Yuan, Hanwen Zha, Nan Tang, Lei Chen, Nicolas Scheffer, Yue Liu, Nirav Shah, Rakesh Wanga, Anuj Kumar, Wen-tau Yih, Xin Luna Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has recently emerged as a promising
solution to alleviate Large Language Model (LLM)'s deficiency in lack of
knowledge. Existing RAG datasets, however, do not adequately represent the
diverse and dynamic nature of real-world Question Answering (QA) tasks. To
bridge this gap, we introduce the Comprehensive RAG Benchmark (CRAG), a factual
question answering benchmark of 4,409 question-answer pairs and mock APIs to
simulate web and Knowledge Graph (KG) search. CRAG is designed to encapsulate a
diverse array of questions across five domains and eight question categories,
reflecting varied entity popularity from popular to long-tail, and temporal
dynamisms ranging from years to seconds. Our evaluation on this benchmark
highlights the gap to fully trustworthy QA. Whereas most advanced LLMs achieve
<=34% accuracy on CRAG, adding RAG in a straightforward manner improves the
accuracy only to 44%. State-of-the-art industry RAG solutions only answer 63%
questions without any hallucination. CRAG also reveals much lower accuracy in
answering questions regarding facts with higher dynamism, lower popularity, or
higher complexity, suggesting future research directions. The CRAG benchmark
laid the groundwork for a KDD Cup 2024 challenge, attracting thousands of
participants and submissions within the first 50 days of the competition. We
commit to maintaining CRAG to serve research communities in advancing RAG
solutions and general QA solutions.
|
[
-0.40246161818504333,
-0.8907148838043213,
0.5203021764755249,
0.14003399014472961,
-0.3185790479183197,
0.7412370443344116,
0.01855214685201645,
-0.6313390731811523,
-0.13104550540447235,
0.13203494250774384,
-0.5313250422477722,
-0.3874109089374542,
-0.4832935929298401,
0.044727522879838943,
-0.16606545448303223,
0.8948389887809753,
-0.05147803574800491,
-0.133134126663208,
-0.7416783571243286,
-0.42828789353370667,
-0.6968709230422974,
-0.4909899830818176,
-0.5541585683822632,
-0.22073151171207428,
0.7229028940200806,
0.18765559792518616,
0.4205950200557709,
0.5906195640563965,
0.6228529810905457,
0.1746031641960144,
-0.2556627094745636,
0.3796784281730652,
-0.7229448556900024,
0.4382697343826294,
-0.1685236692428589,
-0.5032982230186462,
-0.44938820600509644,
0.12237764149904251,
0.46595498919487,
0.5160077214241028,
-0.37191104888916016,
0.7412459254264832,
-0.1583370864391327,
0.556357204914093,
-0.79676753282547,
-0.08328191190958023,
-0.93135666847229,
-0.2990821301937103,
-0.39840570092201233,
-0.21203476190567017,
-0.29418429732322693,
-0.526130735874176,
0.14080432057380676,
-0.7323329448699951,
0.45690542459487915,
0.0848771408200264,
1.29200279712677,
0.4747157394886017,
-0.5733226537704468,
-0.27459555864334106,
-0.607406497001648,
0.8111749291419983,
-0.4040909707546234,
0.6272796988487244,
0.2651025950908661,
0.7113618850708008,
-0.16924966871738434,
-0.8671043515205383,
-0.5313002467155457,
0.0184297114610672,
0.12128832191228867,
0.2555150091648102,
0.09575957804918289,
-0.3847809433937073,
0.14694435894489288,
0.033114898949861526,
-0.8565165400505066,
-0.3439755141735077,
-0.25582101941108704,
-0.2302289605140686,
0.6005588173866272,
0.3669472336769104,
0.03999163582921028,
0.21950125694274902,
-0.6187528967857361,
-0.25588953495025635,
-0.5465601682662964,
0.3140019178390503,
0.07785438001155853,
-0.013048152439296246,
-0.047347571700811386,
0.39758121967315674,
-0.3618665337562561,
0.6013058423995972,
-0.07136064022779465,
-0.4632280170917511,
0.354031503200531,
-0.3266885280609131,
-0.009115995839238167,
-0.2497093230485916,
0.20963290333747864,
0.4418490529060364,
0.17278136312961578,
-0.23558349907398224,
0.00660600746050477,
0.2797224223613739,
0.3918491005897522,
-0.7419931292533875,
-0.2322009950876236,
0.246293306350708,
-0.08330114185810089,
-0.06761186569929123,
-0.23964248597621918,
-1.0936516523361206,
-0.5488096475601196,
-0.05846549943089485,
0.16700713336467743,
-0.13008950650691986,
-0.1468154340982437,
-0.06362984329462051,
-0.46349579095840454,
0.755416989326477,
0.24508677423000336,
0.03916190192103386,
0.15428967773914337,
0.8828309178352356,
0.5050929188728333,
-0.31562539935112,
-0.005854069255292416,
-0.6232741475105286,
0.15465214848518372,
-0.5548696517944336,
1.3900671005249023,
-0.6743468046188354,
-0.3569881319999695,
-0.08943990617990494,
-0.23741844296455383,
-0.012670871801674366,
-0.8822259306907654,
0.9134749174118042,
-0.9654368758201599,
-0.03038553148508072,
-0.4909113943576813,
-0.5435839891433716,
-0.018247414380311966,
0.5678516030311584,
-0.30553486943244934,
1.0773296356201172,
0.2043098658323288,
-0.4991045296192169,
0.5869484543800354,
-0.0266905315220356,
-0.05976502224802971,
0.41096916794776917,
-0.11943084746599197,
-0.4953427016735077,
-0.2212185561656952,
0.013839278370141983,
-0.05226476490497589,
-0.7466723322868347,
0.12023807317018509,
-0.5755780339241028,
-0.19753248989582062,
0.30322811007499695,
-0.20015856623649597,
0.4964616298675537,
0.1970285326242447,
-0.04631629213690758,
-0.5352251529693604,
-0.717850387096405,
0.5593632459640503,
0.246272012591362,
-0.3208843469619751,
-0.25454458594322205,
-0.19868618249893188,
-0.2761801481246948,
0.14881531894207,
0.40438899397850037,
-0.7281429767608643,
-0.0958314761519432,
-0.17035524547100067,
-0.11456643790006638,
0.6818722486495972,
0.29867690801620483,
0.0759592056274414,
-0.5087973475456238,
0.8653250336647034,
-0.10700073093175888,
0.046182043850421906,
0.22263644635677338,
-0.4475170969963074,
-0.549465000629425,
-0.39735540747642517,
0.7079039216041565,
0.5732252597808838,
-0.671169102191925,
-0.10819124430418015,
-0.24001957476139069,
-0.8852434158325195,
-0.6352693438529968,
0.008394529111683369,
0.6957384943962097,
0.7479516267776489,
0.2531367838382721,
-0.2703673243522644,
-0.4645991325378418,
-0.8019127249717712,
-0.6614274382591248,
-0.22651587426662445,
0.045798409730196,
0.5758596658706665,
0.17119358479976654,
0.029109081253409386,
0.8953655958175659,
-0.7536895275115967,
-0.27740928530693054,
0.044764768332242966,
0.21857154369354248,
0.13786980509757996,
-0.05290919542312622,
0.4959877133369446,
-1.012274146080017,
-0.7628602981567383,
-0.11771461367607117,
-0.6991482377052307,
-0.31243330240249634,
0.28287118673324585,
-0.13513268530368805,
0.36091819405555725,
0.18757912516593933,
-0.5559206008911133,
0.3989751636981964,
0.6564755439758301,
-0.4609237015247345,
0.7214991450309753,
0.1120721846818924,
0.4413954019546509,
-0.5356016755104065,
0.3673636019229889,
-0.24671199917793274,
-0.1585896760225296,
-0.5284350514411926,
0.2756391167640686,
0.1590368002653122,
-0.06101040914654732,
-0.3014577329158783,
0.8104952573776245,
-0.26983895897865295,
-0.034806665033102036,
-0.08091495931148529,
0.6429130434989929,
0.26333025097846985,
0.3358455300331116,
-0.5329568982124329,
1.1735320091247559,
0.14637568593025208,
-0.5749238133430481,
0.1949375569820404,
0.36809486150741577,
-0.09700851142406464,
0.811996579170227,
-0.7514031529426575,
0.28822124004364014,
-0.15917058289051056,
0.40181228518486023,
-1.072865605354309,
-0.23963215947151184,
-0.10786129534244537,
-0.8852956891059875,
0.13479021191596985,
-0.1526230126619339,
-0.2606373131275177,
-0.2765327990055084,
-0.09498035907745361,
0.7558256983757019,
0.863171398639679,
-0.39496228098869324,
0.6729311943054199,
0.7102293968200684,
-0.21824516355991364,
-0.7862023711204529,
-0.09635801613330841,
0.09842094033956528,
-0.1771036833524704,
-0.601472795009613,
0.24446529150009155,
-0.324116587638855,
-0.24970832467079163,
0.08659601211547852,
-0.5416820049285889,
-0.49443450570106506,
0.026314515620470047,
-0.08642461895942688,
0.34286394715309143,
-0.10563725978136063,
0.017747893929481506,
-0.3344694674015045,
-0.15572376549243927,
0.10413282364606857,
0.26515311002731323,
0.7704602479934692,
0.07134407013654709,
-0.08215053379535675,
-0.10223522782325745,
0.050085943192243576,
0.3055075705051422,
-0.6074185371398926,
0.2616891860961914,
0.3777765929698944,
-0.035108860582113266,
-0.49415749311447144,
-0.6912634968757629,
0.1273580640554428,
-0.5117130875587463,
0.15755240619182587,
-0.49033835530281067,
-0.7809670567512512,
0.6058224439620972,
-0.09078428894281387,
0.1413785070180893,
0.3858318030834198,
0.38968852162361145,
-0.24877098202705383,
0.8727464079856873,
0.23587119579315186,
0.2975231111049652,
-0.16299691796302795,
0.019170721992850304,
0.23477989435195923,
-0.7599732875823975,
-0.4140213131904602,
-0.9061384201049805,
-0.1631370335817337,
-0.45402956008911133,
-0.5968912243843079,
0.6682151556015015,
0.33490532636642456,
-0.15179051458835602,
0.13965007662773132,
-0.5165729522705078,
0.4536059498786926,
0.4298214018344879,
-0.10399725288152695,
0.20058374106884003,
-0.42285141348838806,
0.024583758786320686,
-0.0019786113407462835,
-0.7064810395240784,
-0.3072839379310608,
1.047550916671753,
0.06871215254068375,
0.5780863165855408,
-0.03394507244229317,
0.49536558985710144,
0.42528143525123596,
0.1747599095106125,
-0.4286380112171173,
0.733171820640564,
0.07626261562108994,
-0.9145714044570923,
-0.10586453974246979,
-0.45919668674468994,
-0.9414469599723816,
0.20774634182453156,
-0.16125676035881042,
-0.26439154148101807,
0.1649508774280548,
0.260999858379364,
-0.159352108836174,
0.1870313584804535,
-0.3878185451030731,
0.5770242214202881,
0.1630346179008484,
-0.33008745312690735,
-0.20143063366413116,
-0.5820971131324768,
0.39132654666900635,
-0.10087212175130844,
0.23064716160297394,
-0.4950379729270935,
-0.24360789358615875,
0.6126765608787537,
0.0378144197165966,
0.41990572214126587,
-0.318424791097641,
0.03322033956646919,
0.5496910810470581,
0.1966332197189331,
0.6744744777679443,
0.0723985806107521,
-0.05281636118888855,
-0.0029768378008157015,
0.3005099594593048,
-0.6553817987442017,
-0.4940631687641144,
0.4865134656429291,
-0.6022562384605408,
-0.4992501735687256,
-0.7032554745674133,
-0.6087667346000671,
-0.6170809268951416,
0.13658104836940765,
-0.21296177804470062,
0.6567935943603516,
-0.3166901171207428,
0.23921336233615875,
0.8216302394866943,
-0.30236488580703735,
0.045741159468889236,
0.5021685361862183,
0.004384593106806278,
-0.6914620995521545,
0.82399982213974,
0.06601165980100632,
0.28543370962142944,
0.08045703917741776,
0.03816501796245575,
-0.45206910371780396,
-0.4810791015625,
-0.49247804284095764,
0.4546750783920288,
-0.7227038741111755,
-0.5894918441772461,
-0.8434900045394897,
-0.217951700091362,
-0.5870384573936462,
-0.035775959491729736,
-0.2031034678220749,
-0.28429704904556274,
0.2309996783733368,
0.21666072309017181,
0.2956395149230957,
0.5383874773979187,
0.25012052059173584,
-0.1501593142747879,
-0.7653008699417114,
0.7216880917549133,
0.4895557463169098,
0.6134850978851318,
-0.1449657529592514,
-0.6212297677993774,
-0.014723677188158035,
-0.026647863909602165,
-0.35349923372268677,
-0.4970722198486328,
0.11694202572107315,
0.2405237853527069,
0.7842152714729309,
-0.14158451557159424,
0.4104578495025635,
0.9256563186645508,
-0.5400432348251343,
0.9061923027038574,
-0.17065384984016418,
-0.4308631122112274,
-0.07191605120897293,
-0.4753485321998596,
0.39222532510757446,
0.8056061863899231,
0.38311147689819336,
-0.5216973423957825,
-0.4927977919578552,
-0.7478774785995483,
-0.6602039933204651,
0.28725138306617737,
-0.060556840151548386,
-0.1862529218196869,
-0.11415459215641022,
0.3781543970108032,
0.038107726722955704,
0.313917875289917,
-0.116722472012043,
-0.36884185671806335,
0.11994251608848572,
-0.03438409045338631,
0.11678250879049301,
-0.33704835176467896,
-0.2876463830471039,
0.015463774092495441,
0.8099596500396729,
-0.023742061108350754,
0.205043762922287,
0.2760721743106842,
0.1421326845884323,
-0.1552760899066925,
0.14577637612819672,
0.5456052422523499,
1.030836582183838,
-0.312938392162323,
0.019982237368822098,
0.46158429980278015,
-0.5187286734580994,
0.1564805507659912,
0.028113150969147682,
-0.13316749036312103,
0.029459485784173012,
0.21737609803676605,
0.14280827343463898,
-0.2921600341796875,
-1.0212398767471313,
0.4483624994754791,
-0.08853265643119812,
-0.3129598796367645,
-0.412244588136673,
0.08428772538900375,
0.1515463888645172,
0.21645526587963104,
0.6451025009155273,
-0.1696460247039795,
0.10938556492328644,
-0.46684691309928894,
0.4897052049636841,
0.6456387042999268,
-0.40262120962142944,
-0.15744449198246002,
0.6810857057571411,
0.1733076423406601,
-0.3904588520526886,
0.1167530044913292,
-0.38204631209373474,
-0.6241568326950073,
0.8336422443389893,
0.39505735039711,
0.5958985090255737,
-0.033165447413921356,
0.3646072447299957,
0.4578385353088379,
0.06660650670528412,
0.3800129294395447,
0.398213267326355,
0.3222314119338989,
-0.3909469246864319,
-0.4389627277851105,
-0.8096174001693726,
-0.6298630237579346,
-0.1558554470539093,
-0.6463643312454224,
0.13784265518188477,
-0.384378582239151,
-0.0029452117159962654,
-0.10872028768062592,
0.31801527738571167,
-0.7718635201454163,
0.4710361659526825,
-0.21816383302211761,
1.0733271837234497,
-0.35139602422714233,
0.5302032828330994,
0.6567556262016296,
-0.14575161039829254,
-0.6842479705810547,
0.07690660655498505,
-0.08539937436580658,
-0.8321801424026489,
0.49316564202308655,
-0.18691419064998627,
-0.23414409160614014,
0.010455053299665451,
-0.6114991903305054,
-0.8548089265823364,
1.187581181526184,
0.06541679799556732,
-0.19878914952278137,
0.06255713850259781,
0.29802942276000977,
0.5926722288131714,
-0.17071644961833954,
-0.06544438749551773,
0.6669470071792603,
0.5352618098258972,
0.24982181191444397,
-0.8024312257766724,
-0.07385312020778656,
-0.05521319434046745,
-0.2627890706062317,
0.42527589201927185,
-0.9092832803726196,
0.7080760598182678,
0.1107146218419075,
-0.5515989661216736,
0.23817729949951172,
0.5262086391448975,
0.7821934819221497,
0.7275091409683228,
0.6441699862480164,
0.7568267583847046,
0.6823867559432983,
-0.2418307214975357,
0.9790757894515991,
-0.3143770694732666,
0.20156647264957428,
1.112231731414795,
-0.5785923600196838,
0.7810477614402771,
0.2918927073478699,
-0.25648069381713867,
0.6058472394943237,
0.3386226296424866,
0.1488724797964096,
0.5692739486694336,
0.1079505905508995,
-0.3357056975364685,
-0.5508264899253845,
-0.4231986403465271,
-0.4915517270565033,
0.36762651801109314,
0.07129938155412674,
0.40491464734077454,
-0.5649548768997192,
-0.2484704703092575,
0.07183638215065002,
0.4881881773471832,
-0.1056729182600975,
0.8811976313591003,
0.002663318533450365,
-0.8046777248382568,
0.8712382912635803,
-0.3614172637462616,
0.32009750604629517,
-0.7029697895050049,
-0.27524954080581665,
-0.4625560939311981,
0.11379562318325043,
0.14289507269859314,
-0.8104483485221863,
0.15024921298027039,
0.002243885537609458,
-0.0475008450448513,
0.05084802582859993,
0.7640597820281982,
-0.3146419823169708,
-0.2949094772338867,
0.1856999546289444,
0.5919272899627686,
0.031077809631824493,
0.27660655975341797,
-0.7893424034118652,
0.11382178962230682,
-0.2359144538640976,
-0.1384711116552353,
0.3311399817466736,
0.7417590618133545,
0.058367375284433365,
0.9093443751335144,
0.5660971403121948,
0.10273149609565735,
0.3098124563694,
-0.35115745663642883,
1.0351450443267822,
-0.5434170961380005,
-0.2608305811882019,
-0.15840594470500946,
0.4310607314109802,
-0.2862411141395569,
-0.5336334109306335,
0.8646324276924133,
0.6437551379203796,
0.829909086227417,
0.21575680375099182,
0.6598241925239563,
-0.39877212047576904,
1.2103415727615356,
0.0034427077043801546,
0.536246657371521,
-0.7105091214179993,
-0.15921595692634583,
-0.044066909700632095,
-0.870712161064148,
-0.1385706663131714,
-0.14806856215000153,
0.03560968488454819,
-0.07472534477710724,
0.6714274883270264,
0.8202104568481445,
0.08924008905887604,
-0.24213287234306335,
0.4009957015514374,
0.10658113658428192,
0.4757295250892639,
0.17842023074626923,
0.6738443374633789,
-0.42242127656936646,
1.0441824197769165,
-0.17732761800289154,
-0.2559104263782501,
-0.0062195369973778725,
-0.7372914552688599,
-0.7267792820930481,
-0.47081801295280457,
-0.16929595172405243,
-0.6015893816947937,
0.3906741440296173,
0.5717984437942505,
0.42049622535705566,
-0.6694932579994202,
-0.09421007335186005,
0.31380677223205566,
0.015860099345445633,
-0.3460530638694763,
-0.22121338546276093,
0.2238427698612213,
-0.7517539262771606,
-0.513513445854187,
0.316667377948761,
0.01448149885982275,
-0.41093969345092773,
-0.03640683740377426,
0.14472851157188416,
-0.4346703886985779,
0.44246190786361694,
0.46375083923339844,
0.4452665150165558,
-0.4192272126674652,
-0.498902291059494,
0.3848559558391571,
-0.07698791474103928,
0.13313573598861694,
0.6351211667060852,
-0.9674797058105469,
0.2476104348897934,
0.7138631939888,
1.1355533599853516,
0.44249212741851807,
0.447065144777298,
0.4415065050125122,
-0.6129786968231201,
-0.21505869925022125,
0.5645312666893005,
-0.1222810372710228,
0.12218528985977173,
-0.08152855932712555,
0.7432745695114136,
0.3511101305484772,
-1.1055843830108643,
-1.2180533409118652,
0.2906673550605774,
-1.092874526977539,
-0.2965603172779083,
1.112426519393921,
-0.07854769378900528,
-0.39770883321762085,
-0.5503607988357544,
-0.043374549597501755,
0.16189110279083252,
-0.31492650508880615,
0.8339642286300659,
0.48560279607772827,
-0.039522673934698105,
0.012987344525754452,
-0.693291962146759,
0.7100001573562622,
0.42230135202407837,
-0.8706103563308716,
0.3961147964000702,
0.4701409339904785,
0.38750016689300537,
0.12528760731220245,
0.6715430021286011,
-0.24949832260608673,
0.4762013256549835,
0.07000619918107986,
0.22380058467388153,
0.11927630007266998,
-0.523161768913269,
0.09009259939193726,
0.48992714285850525,
0.16179965436458588,
-0.042212314903736115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04734v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04734v1
|
Generative AI Models: Opportunities and Risks for Industry and Authorities
| 2024-06-07T08:34:30 | 2024-06-07T08:34:30 |
Tobias Alt, Andrea Ibisch, Clemens Meiser, Anna Wilhelm, Raphael Zimmer, Christian Berghoff, Christoph Droste, Jens Karschau, Friederike Laus, Rainer Plaga, Carola Plesch, Britta Sennewald, Thomas Thaeren, Kristina Unverricht, Steffen Waurick
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, 68T50 (Primary), 68M25, 68T07 (Secondary), I.2.7
|
Generative AI models are capable of performing a wide range of tasks that
traditionally require creativity and human understanding. They learn patterns
from existing data during training and can subsequently generate new content
such as texts, images, and music that follow these patterns. Due to their
versatility and generally high-quality results, they, on the one hand,
represent an opportunity for digitalization. On the other hand, the use of
generative AI models introduces novel IT security risks that need to be
considered for a comprehensive analysis of the threat landscape in relation to
IT security. In response to this risk potential, companies or authorities using
them should conduct an individual risk analysis before integrating generative
AI into their workflows. The same applies to developers and operators, as many
risks in the context of generative AI have to be taken into account at the time
of development or can only be influenced by the operating company. Based on
this, existing security measures can be adjusted, and additional measures can
be taken.
|
[
-0.25482630729675293,
-0.5664874911308289,
0.266772598028183,
-0.015420690178871155,
-0.21093548834323883,
0.03684505075216293,
0.3929098844528198,
-0.7852633595466614,
-0.28505364060401917,
0.614285409450531,
-0.5140809416770935,
-0.24375325441360474,
-0.6688011288642883,
-0.12278805673122406,
-0.7713508605957031,
0.9303543567657471,
-0.06745912879705429,
-0.15773484110832214,
-0.36555448174476624,
0.2670346200466156,
-0.6808703541755676,
-0.7010507583618164,
-0.759979248046875,
0.07403288781642914,
0.2140868902206421,
0.09590592235326767,
0.8334371447563171,
0.3205745816230774,
0.8373128771781921,
0.4875447452068329,
0.07298502326011658,
-0.6000106930732727,
0.040623899549245834,
0.3439260423183441,
0.005613064859062433,
-0.7201657295227051,
-0.21431750059127808,
0.20039072632789612,
0.36745333671569824,
0.6592732667922974,
-0.3912806510925293,
0.13577701151371002,
-0.047202516347169876,
0.7086678743362427,
-0.4690704941749573,
0.2677460312843323,
-0.5931714773178101,
0.40806081891059875,
-0.45514801144599915,
-0.12053180485963821,
-0.2746092677116394,
-0.3626459538936615,
0.2920866310596466,
-0.43040019273757935,
0.17751193046569824,
-0.32550355792045593,
0.5531273484230042,
0.41767576336860657,
-0.22097255289554596,
-0.30578121542930603,
-1.338212490081787,
0.43917137384414673,
-0.4785206913948059,
-0.14694133400917053,
0.19701354205608368,
0.7017581462860107,
-0.10305432975292206,
-0.7024756073951721,
-0.3196670114994049,
-0.15558096766471863,
0.18115168809890747,
0.028496868908405304,
-0.398266077041626,
0.098715640604496,
0.4033820331096649,
0.5644632577896118,
-0.371204137802124,
0.5240450501441956,
-0.6958746910095215,
0.07391594350337982,
1.0195822715759277,
0.4161151349544525,
0.6617083549499512,
0.2590208649635315,
-0.39440515637397766,
-0.4072146415710449,
-0.7401531338691711,
0.08442632853984833,
0.8397287726402283,
0.05846598744392395,
-0.18473456799983978,
0.6207428574562073,
0.07830535620450974,
0.792739748954773,
-0.277351051568985,
0.00988144800066948,
0.07049184292554855,
-0.24564163386821747,
-0.36732926964759827,
-0.08215098828077316,
0.6657718420028687,
-0.07655752450227737,
0.15909560024738312,
-0.33000925183296204,
-0.29110488295555115,
0.07639763504266739,
0.7854477763175964,
-0.3981091380119324,
-0.05642414838075638,
0.455302894115448,
-0.5198990702629089,
-0.7163578271865845,
0.40336164832115173,
-0.9397067427635193,
-0.5687240362167358,
-0.3705052435398102,
0.25906747579574585,
-0.30518123507499695,
-0.6058218479156494,
-0.17798438668251038,
-0.5074953436851501,
0.4435235261917114,
0.4084685146808624,
-0.6686102747917175,
-0.1606164574623108,
0.5673666000366211,
0.7340163588523865,
-0.0182926207780838,
-0.20631752908229828,
-0.14284707605838776,
0.26862311363220215,
-0.5898835062980652,
0.6583371162414551,
-0.26892948150634766,
-0.8383562564849854,
0.04637578874826431,
-0.5238960385322571,
-0.1955552101135254,
-0.5047743916511536,
0.26011577248573303,
-0.7634844183921814,
-0.07602768391370773,
0.25227469205856323,
-0.27872776985168457,
-0.2303158938884735,
0.13916124403476715,
-1.0304828882217407,
0.4597204029560089,
0.10492201894521713,
-0.6552477478981018,
0.4855146110057831,
-0.7814120650291443,
-0.5962198376655579,
0.41045576333999634,
-0.38319092988967896,
-0.5695428848266602,
0.34328970313072205,
-0.1679224669933319,
0.45694291591644287,
-0.2904201149940491,
0.11416901648044586,
-0.20169353485107422,
0.08205615729093552,
0.4741995334625244,
-0.6182580590248108,
1.0639129877090454,
0.549826979637146,
-0.5153219103813171,
0.40918323397636414,
-0.555923342704773,
0.028981896117329597,
-0.06890566647052765,
-0.20028550922870636,
-0.3011661469936371,
0.11141858994960785,
0.07408342510461807,
0.3300356864929199,
-0.11090338230133057,
-0.16537681221961975,
-0.059084877371788025,
-0.15947969257831573,
0.4964034855365753,
0.9392204880714417,
0.16084729135036469,
0.40218931436538696,
-0.4446873366832733,
1.069530725479126,
0.22881197929382324,
0.4554896354675293,
-0.040102217346429825,
-0.6494945287704468,
-0.3654942214488983,
-0.6110467314720154,
0.48205193877220154,
0.7103573083877563,
-0.8164398670196533,
0.5200453400611877,
-0.03958508372306824,
-0.7356030344963074,
-0.6215179562568665,
0.007075899746268988,
-0.043800923973321915,
0.040366146713495255,
-0.2514778673648834,
-0.27438169717788696,
-0.4415193200111389,
-0.6090716123580933,
-0.06137692555785179,
-0.28811565041542053,
-0.08158421516418457,
0.03285703435540199,
0.3851933479309082,
-0.4268200099468231,
0.8688976168632507,
-0.28222450613975525,
-0.37075331807136536,
-0.22659720480442047,
0.41149163246154785,
0.10807298868894577,
0.6758251190185547,
0.5066611766815186,
-1.4261727333068848,
-0.36547014117240906,
0.10764804482460022,
-1.080523133277893,
0.493783563375473,
-0.5954431295394897,
0.08382143825292587,
0.1937970221042633,
0.5434913635253906,
-0.9292032122612,
0.7768804430961609,
0.23939691483974457,
-0.1546715646982193,
0.3721361458301544,
-0.21884547173976898,
0.0878349244594574,
-1.232988953590393,
0.17583335936069489,
0.14289981126785278,
0.22467026114463806,
-1.0342693328857422,
0.45313218235969543,
-0.43585634231567383,
-0.6773871183395386,
-0.3532869517803192,
0.20811718702316284,
-0.3663267493247986,
-0.25722068548202515,
-0.17024078965187073,
-0.3293006122112274,
-0.30446726083755493,
-0.2096356600522995,
-0.12176976352930069,
0.9661658406257629,
1.000720739364624,
-0.9028329849243164,
0.24998068809509277,
0.007107874378561974,
-0.8400821685791016,
0.44145575165748596,
-0.6901730298995972,
0.2339732050895691,
-0.13863523304462433,
-0.24103111028671265,
-0.5586622357368469,
-0.31798431277275085,
0.3037109971046448,
-0.37985870242118835,
0.43081745505332947,
0.1584908366203308,
-0.4787255823612213,
-0.5634959936141968,
-0.1317090094089508,
0.34684956073760986,
0.6377801299095154,
-0.3147450387477875,
0.793001651763916,
0.5656083822250366,
-0.29229995608329773,
-0.5482200980186462,
-0.831957995891571,
0.3904760777950287,
-0.6170663237571716,
-0.6685333847999573,
0.4987841546535492,
0.04906390234827995,
-0.4891430139541626,
0.23581430315971375,
0.25414395332336426,
-0.12898622453212738,
0.8962754011154175,
0.7185634970664978,
0.3827652037143707,
0.07315943390130997,
-0.3025408685207367,
-0.19774524867534637,
-0.5094885230064392,
0.22518712282180786,
-0.1966300755739212,
0.1897847205400467,
0.1332276463508606,
-0.6564372777938843,
-0.7370828986167908,
0.6900551319122314,
0.8126599192619324,
-0.379182904958725,
0.9446390271186829,
0.5452446937561035,
-0.5997306108474731,
0.007159030064940453,
-0.18674424290657043,
0.0747242271900177,
-0.5158861875534058,
0.1894560605287552,
-0.3531787395477295,
-0.3553652763366699,
0.4863587021827698,
0.08862724900245667,
0.040686581283807755,
0.6871435642242432,
0.6039749979972839,
-0.30955713987350464,
1.1058918237686157,
0.9138361215591431,
-0.33020612597465515,
0.6389765739440918,
-0.3993963897228241,
0.545516848564148,
-0.36865323781967163,
-0.5428640246391296,
-0.6645684838294983,
0.06242702528834343,
-0.919485867023468,
0.023525793105363846,
0.5431775450706482,
-0.02937372215092182,
0.002402236219495535,
0.2375800758600235,
-0.5209901928901672,
0.1430830955505371,
0.972404420375824,
-0.05966288968920708,
0.16858510673046112,
0.16226185858249664,
0.3924923837184906,
0.3950822651386261,
-0.5356786251068115,
-0.58952397108078,
1.0726512670516968,
0.4332088828086853,
1.1497926712036133,
0.35592806339263916,
0.6683281064033508,
0.8343852162361145,
0.3036275804042816,
-0.5183370113372803,
0.25965675711631775,
0.033648781478405,
-0.6490688323974609,
-0.464741051197052,
-0.32567617297172546,
-0.9534003138542175,
-0.22207483649253845,
-0.20720741152763367,
-0.5678057670593262,
0.40189042687416077,
0.16843940317630768,
-0.5098071098327637,
0.3298729956150055,
-0.7809329628944397,
0.7039648294448853,
-0.3790348768234253,
0.21353767812252045,
-0.32200148701667786,
-0.30422577261924744,
0.20926104485988617,
-0.06320430338382721,
0.09539859741926193,
0.14386357367038727,
0.28806445002555847,
0.4889701306819916,
-0.1516302227973938,
1.196531057357788,
-0.1156291663646698,
-0.10558097809553146,
0.7225756049156189,
-0.2092551589012146,
0.3562137186527252,
0.016965799033641815,
-0.27690568566322327,
0.36840176582336426,
-0.1263677477836609,
-0.11398982256650925,
-0.30948081612586975,
0.4220508635044098,
-0.9083268642425537,
-1.0287328958511353,
-0.868859589099884,
-0.42120984196662903,
0.19765157997608185,
0.15350814163684845,
0.548543393611908,
0.07802166789770126,
-0.32673409581184387,
0.11505552381277084,
0.45645198225975037,
-0.1493648886680603,
0.5433822274208069,
-0.03185393288731575,
0.4945136606693268,
-0.225327730178833,
0.635657548904419,
0.11741972714662552,
0.17772167921066284,
0.16672052443027496,
-0.22518087923526764,
-0.04361765831708908,
-0.8387051820755005,
-0.3958587348461151,
-0.6174516081809998,
-0.6649451851844788,
-0.41672107577323914,
-0.373624712228775,
-0.6949668526649475,
-0.378345251083374,
-0.21122461557388306,
0.08833270519971848,
-0.18289776146411896,
-0.5988199710845947,
-0.30198121070861816,
0.3957669138908386,
0.8628569841384888,
-0.06354299187660217,
0.05198708176612854,
-0.6266254782676697,
0.22071292996406555,
0.5348852276802063,
0.3050476312637329,
-0.013401241973042488,
0.009547777473926544,
-0.1223105639219284,
0.05006160959601402,
-0.3625052273273468,
-0.8150452971458435,
0.3512918949127197,
0.03340626507997513,
0.9605820775032043,
0.5850249528884888,
-0.12076983600854874,
0.27854207158088684,
-0.37066787481307983,
0.7762389183044434,
0.18828414380550385,
-0.8323602080345154,
0.6417462825775146,
-0.17341074347496033,
-0.10803384333848953,
0.44929787516593933,
0.6956131458282471,
-0.41374140977859497,
0.026132669299840927,
-0.6342068910598755,
-0.8245524168014526,
0.5965514183044434,
0.4296436309814453,
0.44817110896110535,
0.24367649853229523,
0.44828853011131287,
0.039654690772295,
0.3100337088108063,
-0.6909582614898682,
-0.07514597475528717,
-0.3145226240158081,
-0.10161858797073364,
0.08172741532325745,
-0.2668493092060089,
-0.44324323534965515,
0.0278751440346241,
0.5863917469978333,
0.09148003160953522,
0.6553072929382324,
-0.29298174381256104,
0.1227739155292511,
-0.1421673446893692,
0.2644166052341461,
0.3176279366016388,
0.4151601195335388,
0.11982188373804092,
-0.09239264577627182,
-0.21003033220767975,
-0.26195892691612244,
0.18538030982017517,
0.3520433306694031,
-0.28259119391441345,
-0.3222951591014862,
0.48472481966018677,
0.8599840402603149,
-0.4626004099845886,
-0.6428111791610718,
0.32108673453330994,
0.039120033383369446,
-0.12646371126174927,
-0.8521302342414856,
0.4356772303581238,
-0.24486322700977325,
0.33654093742370605,
0.24975909292697906,
0.4384145140647888,
0.31269603967666626,
-0.8388428688049316,
0.013385280035436153,
0.5632622241973877,
-0.34223583340644836,
-0.19097891449928284,
0.8004962801933289,
0.18179358541965485,
-0.5864371061325073,
0.9564809203147888,
-0.18060444295406342,
-0.2603739798069,
1.2307263612747192,
0.5737271904945374,
1.3744572401046753,
-0.4073077142238617,
0.3463703393936157,
-0.077814020216465,
0.4623767137527466,
-0.006142259109765291,
0.27581799030303955,
0.20561669766902924,
-0.7221473455429077,
0.00616627698764205,
-0.09423433244228363,
-0.5179340839385986,
0.1768881380558014,
-0.7518428564071655,
0.1471521258354187,
-0.4926247298717499,
-0.4372016191482544,
0.2150636464357376,
-0.640019953250885,
-0.8695505857467651,
0.2260594516992569,
0.23097717761993408,
0.7541386485099792,
-0.8625627756118774,
0.4224420487880707,
0.6478477120399475,
-0.6798532009124756,
-0.2527379095554352,
0.028877710923552513,
-0.06343210488557816,
-0.5468936562538147,
0.5944228768348694,
0.35230106115341187,
0.18195588886737823,
-0.16441702842712402,
-0.16820406913757324,
-0.9186669588088989,
1.3142551183700562,
0.2945212125778198,
-0.4093223810195923,
-0.20390082895755768,
0.47086891531944275,
0.7139432430267334,
-0.49543070793151855,
-0.06274527311325073,
0.38939136266708374,
0.22424454987049103,
-0.08334362506866455,
-0.1970405876636505,
-0.1871688812971115,
-0.46890711784362793,
0.5642873644828796,
0.06594124436378479,
-0.11807060986757278,
0.8879380822181702,
-0.3421843349933624,
-0.48771560192108154,
0.040520962327718735,
0.38294869661331177,
-0.16800576448440552,
0.23815587162971497,
0.4163230061531067,
0.34483420848846436,
0.5263146758079529,
-0.05345693603157997,
1.4877879619598389,
-0.3171200156211853,
-0.17539943754673004,
0.7123145461082458,
-0.19096264243125916,
0.5469403266906738,
0.20381252467632294,
-0.2026059478521347,
0.5039085149765015,
0.801886796951294,
-0.46980932354927063,
0.5513103604316711,
0.10196228325366974,
-0.528469443321228,
0.025013435631990433,
0.04623042792081833,
-0.32508647441864014,
0.5356355309486389,
0.5986558794975281,
-0.44498464465141296,
0.16377811133861542,
0.33601701259613037,
-0.5475794076919556,
0.026045069098472595,
-0.24617978930473328,
0.954015851020813,
0.1801929771900177,
-0.5321142673492432,
-0.17481876909732819,
0.18617697060108185,
0.27093538641929626,
-0.34852805733680725,
-0.1248948946595192,
0.2460838258266449,
-0.024426503106951714,
-0.13174812495708466,
-0.7096349596977234,
0.6921196579933167,
0.24382512271404266,
-0.1049085333943367,
-0.1626821607351303,
0.532140851020813,
0.11827442795038223,
-0.7634592652320862,
0.12320271134376526,
0.16146373748779297,
-0.26505717635154724,
-0.177719846367836,
-0.7420525550842285,
-0.23265188932418823,
-0.2724377512931824,
0.0678958147764206,
0.15370142459869385,
0.20890460908412933,
-0.2280392050743103,
0.8302721977233887,
0.44725632667541504,
-0.016904568299651146,
0.05933413654565811,
0.05850966274738312,
0.7675373554229736,
-0.5333064198493958,
-0.6039432287216187,
-0.8401008248329163,
0.7782863974571228,
-0.29500940442085266,
-0.3167774975299835,
0.5081827640533447,
0.19365668296813965,
0.8376739025115967,
-0.3796631097793579,
1.1661598682403564,
-0.2585175037384033,
-0.26331913471221924,
-0.6538385152816772,
0.7809329628944397,
-0.1890275478363037,
0.5134519934654236,
-0.1404370218515396,
-0.5314184427261353,
-0.2326710820198059,
0.35969698429107666,
-0.390760600566864,
0.17688503861427307,
0.11552631855010986,
0.5197858214378357,
0.2409057319164276,
0.04912160336971283,
0.26345202326774597,
-0.2571325898170471,
0.5232755541801453,
0.11765369027853012,
0.898474395275116,
-0.48913195729255676,
0.3217429518699646,
-0.3739504814147949,
-0.27207714319229126,
-0.1959754377603531,
-0.8564552068710327,
-0.7789903879165649,
-0.785423219203949,
-0.5396408438682556,
-0.1911650449037552,
-0.019576916471123695,
0.408633828163147,
0.6437676548957825,
-1.0248818397521973,
-0.008170460350811481,
-0.5102404356002808,
0.2104834020137787,
-0.5677326321601868,
-0.22790168225765228,
0.06377288699150085,
-0.27383705973625183,
-0.5195631384849548,
0.06481467932462692,
0.21962577104568481,
0.5766703486442566,
-0.38121339678764343,
0.38430750370025635,
0.11059444397687912,
-0.0013288584304973483,
0.4768177270889282,
0.45088377594947815,
-0.3874037563800812,
-0.16010946035385132,
-0.42719829082489014,
-0.028830280527472496,
-0.19974184036254883,
0.7555925250053406,
-0.27694612741470337,
0.5389099717140198,
0.4324153959751129,
1.0687177181243896,
0.2540200650691986,
-0.2863454222679138,
0.8659180402755737,
-0.5003988146781921,
0.29990413784980774,
0.30462074279785156,
0.21726170182228088,
0.32588690519332886,
-0.9758111834526062,
0.5578151345252991,
-0.0050871530547738075,
-0.19766126573085785,
-0.7365596890449524,
0.49724677205085754,
-0.5030635595321655,
-0.22023046016693115,
0.6689085960388184,
-0.20507514476776123,
0.13218720257282257,
-0.018525714054703712,
0.06829756498336792,
0.15877890586853027,
0.13846291601657867,
1.3527460098266602,
0.3805989623069763,
-0.0016968923155218363,
0.04116039723157883,
-0.5423526763916016,
0.6981858611106873,
-0.051272451877593994,
-1.328415036201477,
-0.22388805449008942,
0.059254568070173264,
-0.05072609335184097,
0.29827767610549927,
0.35726863145828247,
-0.2994272708892822,
0.5368092060089111,
0.34652620553970337,
0.06643058359622955,
0.08999163657426834,
-0.6543481349945068,
-0.5976771116256714,
0.26938143372535706,
0.44700124859809875,
-0.4259033799171448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06619v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06619v1
|
LoRA-Whisper: Parameter-Efficient and Extensible Multilingual ASR
| 2024-06-07T08:01:51 | 2024-06-07T08:01:51 |
Zheshu Song, Jianheng Zhuo, Yifan Yang, Ziyang Ma, Shixiong Zhang, Xie Chen
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent years have witnessed significant progress in multilingual automatic
speech recognition (ASR), driven by the emergence of end-to-end (E2E) models
and the scaling of multilingual datasets. Despite that, two main challenges
persist in multilingual ASR: language interference and the incorporation of new
languages without degrading the performance of the existing ones. This paper
proposes LoRA-Whisper, which incorporates LoRA matrix into Whisper for
multilingual ASR, effectively mitigating language interference. Furthermore, by
leveraging LoRA and the similarities between languages, we can achieve better
performance on new languages while upholding consistent performance on original
ones. Experiments on a real-world task across eight languages demonstrate that
our proposed LoRA-Whisper yields a relative gain of 18.5% and 23.0% over the
baseline system for multilingual ASR and language expansion respectively.
|
[
-0.3501631021499634,
-0.6820085048675537,
-0.020849905908107758,
0.49534016847610474,
-0.29282045364379883,
0.3176094889640808,
-0.3390525281429291,
-0.961884617805481,
0.5091932415962219,
0.2989003658294678,
-0.2224651277065277,
-0.3150440752506256,
-0.6957435607910156,
-0.12743668258190155,
-0.5709556937217712,
0.5846088528633118,
-0.09944519400596619,
-0.10108388960361481,
0.3703758418560028,
-0.5384591817855835,
-0.18572580814361572,
-0.5530679821968079,
-0.8275595903396606,
-0.3567941188812256,
0.7228485345840454,
0.18826809525489807,
0.43025708198547363,
0.5335488319396973,
0.33755701780319214,
0.3835243582725525,
-0.18711970746517181,
0.2562132775783539,
-0.0834575816988945,
0.33579006791114807,
0.23445212841033936,
-0.17911297082901,
-0.5771058201789856,
-0.26566457748413086,
0.9755241274833679,
0.5834725499153137,
-0.6595675945281982,
0.1033765971660614,
0.2785668969154358,
0.533754825592041,
-0.5990973114967346,
0.20422889292240143,
-0.5978191494941711,
-0.0544433631002903,
-0.3701294958591461,
-0.11754295974969864,
-0.11516586691141129,
-0.2248111367225647,
0.294669508934021,
-0.6560299396514893,
-0.3213334083557129,
-0.23966333270072937,
0.7186919450759888,
0.4172998070716858,
-0.1972029209136963,
-0.4148562252521515,
-0.866098940372467,
0.7302249670028687,
-0.5368107557296753,
0.8054823875427246,
0.33647504448890686,
0.6692919135093689,
0.34333908557891846,
-0.6142439246177673,
-0.5351691246032715,
0.03974061459302902,
0.386768102645874,
0.0780707523226738,
-0.6289041042327881,
-0.30768290162086487,
0.04548323526978493,
0.07896216958761215,
-0.24858011305332184,
0.26645514369010925,
-0.30532336235046387,
-0.33392345905303955,
0.5036916732788086,
-0.1540071964263916,
0.02378467284142971,
0.23307600617408752,
-0.15990115702152252,
-0.007275608833879232,
-0.7702730298042297,
0.16326618194580078,
0.6650930047035217,
0.8225974440574646,
-0.30430492758750916,
0.342197984457016,
-0.1482655107975006,
0.6511741280555725,
-0.13459207117557526,
-0.37603139877319336,
0.5367549061775208,
-0.21314284205436707,
0.1375458538532257,
0.38411492109298706,
0.8195193409919739,
0.04167782515287399,
0.1717650443315506,
-0.13507969677448273,
0.008480039425194263,
0.2541466951370239,
-0.2934058904647827,
-0.6419856548309326,
0.08743395656347275,
-0.02385266125202179,
-0.26041072607040405,
-0.0003992810088675469,
-0.3381814658641815,
-0.574602484703064,
-0.19865550100803375,
-0.14510533213615417,
0.7195613384246826,
-0.3223802447319031,
-0.45000550150871277,
0.30150896310806274,
-0.11395695805549622,
0.27708959579467773,
0.4300557076931,
-0.6414856910705566,
0.5548998117446899,
0.44570934772491455,
0.6946936249732971,
-0.054991744458675385,
-0.6413826942443848,
-1.1315613985061646,
0.4022652208805084,
0.043801162391901016,
0.9730952978134155,
-0.5909790992736816,
-0.5168971419334412,
0.015963977202773094,
-0.2873232364654541,
-0.1915058046579361,
-0.6543302536010742,
0.4166487455368042,
-0.36502373218536377,
0.17851388454437256,
-0.22303494811058044,
-0.2889973223209381,
-0.21515069901943207,
-0.038890231400728226,
-0.6427595615386963,
0.962593138217926,
-0.3179515302181244,
-0.47876420617103577,
0.3825507164001465,
-0.7819841504096985,
-0.622432291507721,
0.0012279386864975095,
-0.18500268459320068,
-0.3961263597011566,
-0.11611564457416534,
0.2455194890499115,
-0.030355488881468773,
-0.2551164925098419,
-0.20909638702869415,
0.1971748024225235,
-0.3691040575504303,
0.2943863570690155,
-0.7423155307769775,
0.5127955675125122,
0.2085195928812027,
-0.27144303917884827,
0.024738874286413193,
-0.6944299340248108,
0.3822966516017914,
-0.2414781153202057,
-0.6654099822044373,
-0.15271997451782227,
0.21716611087322235,
0.25933220982551575,
0.02061605453491211,
0.36531439423561096,
-0.595634400844574,
-0.2397187501192093,
-0.5182176232337952,
0.4032802879810333,
0.30940160155296326,
-0.2637954354286194,
0.20518119633197784,
-0.2753303050994873,
0.5274060964584351,
-0.0439617782831192,
0.10127323120832443,
-0.12717315554618835,
-0.6087318658828735,
-0.8865082859992981,
-0.6021451950073242,
0.4437645673751831,
0.5948401689529419,
-0.5543136596679688,
0.29369959235191345,
-0.14799988269805908,
-0.403697669506073,
-1.0487663745880127,
0.41246461868286133,
0.7432119846343994,
0.3349873721599579,
0.3156972825527191,
0.07721829414367676,
-0.7706828117370605,
-0.8559570908546448,
-0.5023835301399231,
-0.2497597336769104,
0.21980081498622894,
0.25759583711624146,
-0.05709068849682808,
-0.24072755873203278,
0.8629974126815796,
-0.33678001165390015,
-0.5318416953086853,
-0.39719608426094055,
0.051341861486434937,
0.30262431502342224,
0.35444408655166626,
0.2956123650074005,
-0.9165231585502625,
-1.0697927474975586,
0.3744026720523834,
-0.5673733353614807,
-0.265773206949234,
0.5949586629867554,
0.2888713777065277,
0.4650656282901764,
0.6012231111526489,
-0.24563157558441162,
0.25567343831062317,
0.6545014977455139,
-0.09736805409193039,
0.36745285987854004,
-0.3310956358909607,
0.016241535544395447,
-1.1440516710281372,
0.1631166934967041,
-0.24656464159488678,
-0.2720271050930023,
-0.9342041611671448,
0.08774776011705399,
0.035174399614334106,
-0.04253222048282623,
-0.542750358581543,
0.5696771144866943,
-0.42681223154067993,
0.05838993936777115,
-0.2795579135417938,
0.32364341616630554,
-0.019322799518704414,
0.300040066242218,
0.05829924717545509,
0.733548641204834,
0.7688289880752563,
-0.610019862651825,
0.28359702229499817,
0.3445972502231598,
-0.3110947608947754,
0.6669681668281555,
-0.7149394750595093,
0.29837337136268616,
0.05190161615610123,
0.00447134068235755,
-0.5413978695869446,
-0.10068899393081665,
-0.07719481736421585,
-0.5801988840103149,
0.3059443235397339,
-0.22854290902614594,
-0.5802336931228638,
-0.17006398737430573,
-0.39754584431648254,
0.2722942531108856,
0.652193009853363,
-0.7484931349754333,
0.9463750123977661,
0.6311789155006409,
-0.34105920791625977,
-0.6853768825531006,
-0.5533466935157776,
0.1333089917898178,
-0.46370482444763184,
-0.4296308755874634,
0.1723669469356537,
-0.3609239459037781,
-0.31582093238830566,
-0.22056013345718384,
0.0866677537560463,
-0.18267793953418732,
-0.28437700867652893,
0.28052380681037903,
-0.0016810718225315213,
-0.36132505536079407,
-0.07893781363964081,
0.170916348695755,
-0.4398215413093567,
-0.2718851566314697,
0.009921064600348473,
0.617335319519043,
-0.2003237009048462,
-0.7110466361045837,
-0.5671188235282898,
0.8541082739830017,
0.5953431129455566,
-0.5050561428070068,
0.44419342279434204,
0.6436007618904114,
-0.3233000934123993,
-0.08021744340658188,
-0.8597976565361023,
0.24958068132400513,
-0.581745982170105,
0.36037033796310425,
-0.7708805203437805,
-0.7933478951454163,
0.844283401966095,
0.11497699469327927,
0.008406201377511024,
0.12240032106637955,
0.37167829275131226,
-0.0680934488773346,
0.9799208641052246,
0.6806048154830933,
-0.3190170228481293,
0.439193993806839,
-0.1059407964348793,
0.1910933554172516,
-1.0302674770355225,
-0.28067225217819214,
-0.694722592830658,
-0.18834903836250305,
-0.45511919260025024,
-0.6144893169403076,
0.6521724462509155,
0.07595720887184143,
-0.02519705705344677,
0.32322850823402405,
-0.30547666549682617,
0.44579994678497314,
0.5952436327934265,
-0.13500577211380005,
0.5910431146621704,
0.2792029082775116,
0.11270291358232498,
-0.11487086862325668,
-0.4905414879322052,
-0.19779902696609497,
0.6826788187026978,
0.29946985840797424,
0.8494740724563599,
0.6389225125312805,
0.6385143399238586,
0.01608005166053772,
-0.11125517636537552,
-0.808758556842804,
0.4191385805606842,
-0.38703638315200806,
-0.2542160153388977,
-0.358163982629776,
-0.2589890658855438,
-1.0019558668136597,
0.5204233527183533,
0.10136561095714569,
-0.8460449576377869,
0.1952216774225235,
0.23085391521453857,
-0.3239284157752991,
0.15418477356433868,
-0.7467114329338074,
0.1346556395292282,
0.13715973496437073,
-0.09323476254940033,
-0.2971102297306061,
-0.43043747544288635,
-0.31430232524871826,
-0.3274703919887543,
0.17694537341594696,
-0.2064492255449295,
-0.15962153673171997,
0.9167486429214478,
-0.347066193819046,
0.6736757159233093,
-0.3554770052433014,
-0.3770081102848053,
0.3041791021823883,
-0.278189092874527,
0.6546795964241028,
-0.15687809884548187,
-0.29745814204216003,
0.2607058882713318,
-0.017259029671549797,
-0.054795246571302414,
-0.5810518264770508,
0.7631691098213196,
-0.7385017275810242,
-0.41392233967781067,
-0.17465916275978088,
-0.510438859462738,
-0.38318711519241333,
0.01828943006694317,
0.45591646432876587,
0.8127427101135254,
-0.23422910273075104,
0.034148696810007095,
0.5006853938102722,
-0.13340842723846436,
0.6025920510292053,
1.3989367485046387,
-0.4814499020576477,
-0.47869065403938293,
1.226211667060852,
0.4088377356529236,
0.3191922903060913,
0.4432028830051422,
0.33729758858680725,
-0.5143305063247681,
-0.5114650726318359,
-0.5720036625862122,
0.13479457795619965,
-0.5501587986946106,
-0.24657383561134338,
-0.9098933339118958,
-0.48810014128685,
-0.12533992528915405,
-0.1637817770242691,
-0.49468597769737244,
-0.37481412291526794,
-0.1419348269701004,
0.1950736939907074,
0.6981395483016968,
0.6327027678489685,
-0.3484414517879486,
0.392634779214859,
-0.5648292899131775,
0.45429113507270813,
0.4460783898830414,
0.43130385875701904,
-0.04632897302508354,
-0.6834821701049805,
-0.24131707847118378,
0.07805047929286957,
-0.00293914251960814,
-0.5479401350021362,
0.424177885055542,
0.8957879543304443,
0.604817271232605,
0.43886125087738037,
-0.02415136806666851,
0.8575499057769775,
-0.8590119481086731,
0.4139598309993744,
0.3601425290107727,
-1.168760061264038,
0.4592495262622833,
-0.42780256271362305,
0.5063675045967102,
0.47646626830101013,
-0.14329472184181213,
-0.6235719323158264,
-0.49505406618118286,
-0.10363505780696869,
-0.776165246963501,
0.5454427003860474,
0.08072656393051147,
0.15856505930423737,
0.2310941219329834,
-0.1105925440788269,
0.2122349590063095,
0.15974383056163788,
-0.43471017479896545,
-0.35288137197494507,
-0.0659806951880455,
-0.244135782122612,
-0.1205117478966713,
-0.17406722903251648,
-0.05572667345404625,
-0.26928237080574036,
0.40655606985092163,
-0.30820491909980774,
0.2624403238296509,
-0.049576159566640854,
-0.1560739278793335,
-0.13122697174549103,
0.416973352432251,
0.47396230697631836,
0.23697426915168762,
-0.052805278450250626,
0.2261427640914917,
0.5138532519340515,
-0.5997704267501831,
0.06638489663600922,
0.47044500708580017,
0.10790561139583588,
0.08702979236841202,
0.4128592312335968,
0.7730293869972229,
0.4801623821258545,
-0.8009496927261353,
0.2961265444755554,
-0.031584978103637695,
-0.1349067986011505,
-0.561843752861023,
0.03701551631093025,
0.30158567428588867,
0.42901599407196045,
0.4724183678627014,
0.07690268754959106,
0.30481165647506714,
-0.43107402324676514,
0.008448922075331211,
0.5181881189346313,
-0.4472261965274811,
-0.48119056224823,
0.5170233249664307,
0.2993770241737366,
-0.5980976819992065,
0.2737922966480255,
-0.01107776165008545,
-0.6750089526176453,
0.2655998766422272,
0.8155372738838196,
0.6827541589736938,
-0.8095782995223999,
-0.006524074822664261,
0.08644808828830719,
0.171719029545784,
0.16021157801151276,
0.8317220211029053,
-0.14342404901981354,
-0.6548159122467041,
-0.41249850392341614,
-0.7190031409263611,
-0.6030859351158142,
-0.16120480000972748,
-0.9497144818305969,
0.2597569525241852,
-0.036391258239746094,
-0.02979554608464241,
0.10168911516666412,
-0.020676402375102043,
-0.3009432256221771,
-0.18677806854248047,
0.13616591691970825,
0.9688073992729187,
-0.520110547542572,
1.1284486055374146,
0.3949287533760071,
0.009729519486427307,
-0.7371878027915955,
-0.27456963062286377,
0.07406211644411087,
-0.9501425623893738,
0.4574788510799408,
0.05129813775420189,
-0.9037721157073975,
-0.02897762507200241,
0.1672111451625824,
-1.0872628688812256,
0.8564628958702087,
0.5665375590324402,
-0.5195273160934448,
0.18070726096630096,
0.26547467708587646,
0.6082050204277039,
-0.18173065781593323,
-0.19445598125457764,
0.359883189201355,
0.5311837196350098,
0.14967897534370422,
-1.5402977466583252,
-0.38044604659080505,
-0.5900305509567261,
-0.276666522026062,
0.5015987157821655,
-0.7599603533744812,
0.6567432284355164,
-0.3218138515949249,
-0.1970086395740509,
0.3005253076553345,
0.5255131721496582,
0.1315736472606659,
0.28389886021614075,
0.6219058036804199,
0.24206005036830902,
0.794289767742157,
0.020503072068095207,
0.6984705328941345,
-0.20185691118240356,
-0.14681975543498993,
1.388355016708374,
-0.7196552753448486,
1.5561214685440063,
0.4098210334777832,
-0.24960003793239594,
0.40898919105529785,
-0.046007007360458374,
0.2750800549983978,
0.5912553668022156,
-0.19081313908100128,
-0.7430102229118347,
0.13142205774784088,
-0.36588531732559204,
-0.6468141674995422,
0.9582646489143372,
0.4845661222934723,
0.03741969168186188,
-0.09904327243566513,
0.13185517489910126,
0.20489150285720825,
0.18024440109729767,
-0.16180038452148438,
0.8726659417152405,
0.09354544430971146,
-0.2969520092010498,
0.5562322735786438,
-0.1237495094537735,
0.9241257309913635,
-1.1816922426223755,
0.09584778547286987,
0.03941753879189491,
0.3305399715900421,
-0.09714455902576447,
-0.36663171648979187,
0.4575579762458801,
0.1592947393655777,
-0.3304576873779297,
-0.07461446523666382,
0.5089963674545288,
-0.7928357720375061,
-0.5319227576255798,
0.7400089502334595,
0.8413710594177246,
0.15571953356266022,
-0.20010848343372345,
-0.4565700590610504,
0.6036000847816467,
-0.05884261056780815,
0.14521703124046326,
0.34574395418167114,
0.08344841003417969,
0.21855804324150085,
0.9078590273857117,
0.6535407900810242,
0.3316793143749237,
0.14758449792861938,
0.3822203278541565,
0.8560771346092224,
-0.416454017162323,
-0.8624135255813599,
-0.663188636302948,
0.215944305062294,
-0.04427752643823624,
-0.1802879273891449,
0.9232182502746582,
0.6988436579704285,
0.2348051518201828,
0.3306516110897064,
0.7276402115821838,
0.11937654763460159,
1.0647717714309692,
-0.4749418795108795,
0.9733799695968628,
-0.43316733837127686,
0.26060131192207336,
-0.38489779829978943,
-0.738957405090332,
-0.18020664155483246,
0.6086910963058472,
0.13236814737319946,
0.09122127294540405,
0.468332976102829,
0.8206573128700256,
-0.025585204362869263,
0.06991979479789734,
0.5620262026786804,
0.21538186073303223,
0.323181688785553,
0.44714775681495667,
0.9631578922271729,
-0.48537251353263855,
0.6407021284103394,
0.023931825533509254,
-0.21761365234851837,
-0.008715109899640083,
-0.7110278010368347,
-0.6324414014816284,
-0.8877144455909729,
-0.4965302646160126,
-0.09848423302173615,
0.18661651015281677,
0.7800355553627014,
0.984600841999054,
-0.7321098446846008,
-0.5617847442626953,
0.4979689419269562,
-0.10523401200771332,
-0.30918481945991516,
-0.10409017652273178,
0.4439263939857483,
-0.003448233939707279,
-0.9305756688117981,
0.8436012268066406,
0.32791778445243835,
0.00973434653133154,
-0.2172265350818634,
-0.4436582326889038,
-0.016710352152585983,
0.2438569962978363,
0.7577570080757141,
0.46578699350357056,
-0.7069571018218994,
-0.05613354593515396,
-0.0994219034910202,
0.29638463258743286,
0.01241783145815134,
0.6246578097343445,
-0.9189446568489075,
0.48805972933769226,
-0.035655125975608826,
0.2610853910446167,
0.3319094777107239,
-0.40755021572113037,
0.610942006111145,
-0.7596394419670105,
0.27528977394104004,
-0.11700209230184555,
0.44489535689353943,
0.5334437489509583,
-0.016606813296675682,
0.29271069169044495,
-0.26172736287117004,
-0.20333640277385712,
-1.069542407989502,
0.25528672337532043,
-1.0089993476867676,
0.1527763307094574,
1.0477666854858398,
-0.11616094410419464,
0.22431495785713196,
-0.401334285736084,
-0.34743812680244446,
0.032308757305145264,
-0.6273226737976074,
0.4242423176765442,
0.2669453024864197,
-0.18932585418224335,
-0.09920918941497803,
-0.41650041937828064,
0.3625018894672394,
0.1314498633146286,
-0.7508362531661987,
0.08431486040353775,
0.09042122960090637,
0.1805843859910965,
0.33716145157814026,
0.7450532913208008,
-0.07120388001203537,
0.29819872975349426,
0.12069828063249588,
-0.10976053029298782,
-0.12130720168352127,
-0.3085286617279053,
-0.5006872415542603,
0.21211381256580353,
0.3380696177482605,
-0.29963332414627075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04712v1
|
AICoderEval: Improving AI Domain Code Generation of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-07T07:45:38 | 2024-06-07T07:45:38 |
Yinghui Xia, Yuyan Chen, Tianyu Shi, Jun Wang, Jinsong Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automated code generation is a pivotal capability of large language models
(LLMs). However, assessing this capability in real-world scenarios remains
challenging. Previous methods focus more on low-level code generation, such as
model loading, instead of generating high-level codes catering for real-world
tasks, such as image-to-text, text classification, in various domains.
Therefore, we construct AICoderEval, a dataset focused on real-world tasks in
various domains based on HuggingFace, PyTorch, and TensorFlow, along with
comprehensive metrics for evaluation and enhancing LLMs' task-specific code
generation capability. AICoderEval contains test cases and complete programs
for automated evaluation of these tasks, covering domains such as natural
language processing, computer vision, and multimodal learning. To facilitate
research in this area, we open-source the AICoderEval dataset at
\url{https://huggingface.co/datasets/vixuowis/AICoderEval}. After that, we
propose CoderGen, an agent-based framework, to help LLMs generate codes related
to real-world tasks on the constructed AICoderEval. Moreover, we train a more
powerful task-specific code generation model, named AICoder, which is refined
on llama-3 based on AICoderEval. Our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness
of CoderGen in improving LLMs' task-specific code generation capability (by
12.00\% on pass@1 for original model and 9.50\% on pass@1 for ReAct Agent).
AICoder also outperforms current code generation LLMs, indicating the great
quality of the AICoderEval benchmark.
|
[
-0.3101918399333954,
-0.6055331230163574,
0.0974336639046669,
0.26754406094551086,
0.025762159377336502,
0.3043438196182251,
-0.2294408529996872,
-0.5687054991722107,
-0.11384756118059158,
0.5586094856262207,
-0.1949688196182251,
-0.6220279932022095,
-0.5517106056213379,
0.22190168499946594,
-0.4517710506916046,
0.7400233745574951,
-0.23523201048374176,
-0.11601559072732925,
-0.6991978883743286,
-0.19520916044712067,
-0.42095938324928284,
-0.7346110939979553,
-0.5642058253288269,
-0.30678245425224304,
0.08088888227939606,
0.5002192258834839,
0.5639229416847229,
0.5553635358810425,
0.622227668762207,
0.293518602848053,
0.3062593936920166,
0.5340297222137451,
-0.5015241503715515,
0.29799753427505493,
0.09961254149675369,
-0.29870903491973877,
-0.6567934155464172,
-0.08604522794485092,
0.3569381535053253,
0.07450304925441742,
-0.08258021622896194,
0.3445267081260681,
-0.09725010395050049,
0.41389742493629456,
-0.46070751547813416,
0.38658010959625244,
-0.5529879331588745,
-0.1336863487958908,
0.09993436187505722,
-0.16780368983745575,
-0.3356315791606903,
-0.3667212128639221,
-0.3901152014732361,
-0.2618773281574249,
0.13341666758060455,
0.15410755574703217,
0.8796800374984741,
0.39862415194511414,
-0.27130454778671265,
-0.028624441474676132,
-0.40642285346984863,
0.4373374581336975,
-0.6072391867637634,
0.2115866243839264,
0.5437403321266174,
0.19518831372261047,
-0.04015155881643295,
-0.876628577709198,
-0.6378990411758423,
-0.5217546820640564,
0.10312063246965408,
-0.2704922556877136,
-0.48300203680992126,
-0.016013287007808685,
0.326852023601532,
0.39860597252845764,
-0.6738111972808838,
0.03313641995191574,
-0.14355291426181793,
-0.2772538661956787,
0.852502167224884,
0.3207489550113678,
0.5560663938522339,
0.12356331944465637,
-0.008254907093942165,
-0.3388693928718567,
-0.8412380218505859,
0.009230280295014381,
0.3240062892436981,
0.06842254847288132,
-0.22308893501758575,
0.41169440746307373,
-0.23865023255348206,
0.6882111430168152,
-0.06156313419342041,
-0.06930743157863617,
0.3837772011756897,
-0.27171504497528076,
0.05275212600827217,
-0.2505529522895813,
0.6341529488563538,
0.4902656078338623,
0.4930940270423889,
-0.10755638033151627,
-0.49296870827674866,
0.427340030670166,
0.5968281626701355,
-1.1264079809188843,
-0.15173296630382538,
0.25750935077667236,
-0.34522080421447754,
-0.5389450788497925,
-0.12968048453330994,
-0.4616852104663849,
-0.24702250957489014,
-0.25073835253715515,
0.09980995953083038,
-0.20135076344013214,
-0.2817356288433075,
-0.015080575831234455,
0.2529853880405426,
0.2964880168437958,
0.34701332449913025,
-0.5037534832954407,
0.115712970495224,
0.5628672242164612,
0.5984341502189636,
-0.3885892927646637,
-0.43564900755882263,
-0.7579293847084045,
-0.44177767634391785,
-0.43477851152420044,
0.8813185691833496,
-0.5103463530540466,
-0.29347002506256104,
0.1667364239692688,
-0.07725074142217636,
0.2019844353199005,
-0.9165952205657959,
0.07944866269826889,
-0.5816782712936401,
-0.38726145029067993,
0.34757810831069946,
-0.42685267329216003,
-0.08252780139446259,
0.5582127571105957,
-0.6379350423812866,
1.206376314163208,
0.31450897455215454,
-0.341680109500885,
0.3132244348526001,
-0.4930804967880249,
-0.6155183911323547,
0.2395094931125641,
-0.522420346736908,
-0.6181814074516296,
0.012631083838641644,
0.32370591163635254,
0.5964022874832153,
-0.6927403211593628,
0.45266178250312805,
-0.135826975107193,
-0.2524145543575287,
0.3481370806694031,
-0.423706591129303,
0.3735390305519104,
0.2208028882741928,
-0.5079153180122375,
0.2289002388715744,
-0.7765274047851562,
0.27622172236442566,
0.17941582202911377,
-0.36147022247314453,
0.013521877117455006,
-0.23283661901950836,
0.23379379510879517,
0.2298508882522583,
0.027601774781942368,
-0.39443832635879517,
0.2854320704936981,
-0.26842740178108215,
0.269275039434433,
0.4262692332267761,
0.15562160313129425,
0.2629851698875427,
-0.40464794635772705,
0.9624782800674438,
-0.1426037847995758,
0.12656719982624054,
-0.2705993354320526,
-0.5328800082206726,
-0.71465665102005,
-0.3441115915775299,
0.3411080241203308,
0.4642915427684784,
-1.0109117031097412,
0.287889689207077,
-0.2522934377193451,
-0.5015395283699036,
-0.4635729193687439,
0.23678424954414368,
0.6640891432762146,
0.2534673511981964,
0.2127484530210495,
-0.4647212624549866,
-0.42757806181907654,
-0.7231603860855103,
-0.017424825578927994,
-0.29050859808921814,
0.1084568053483963,
0.37053778767585754,
0.6913158893585205,
-0.5853558778762817,
0.9952114820480347,
-0.4993516802787781,
0.02328052558004856,
-0.21177370846271515,
0.10971882939338684,
-0.02763696014881134,
0.5469065308570862,
0.5610056519508362,
-0.7631043791770935,
-0.2701149880886078,
0.008818983100354671,
-0.7241979837417603,
-0.15237219631671906,
0.05547193065285683,
-0.12852537631988525,
0.4358938932418823,
0.49872708320617676,
-0.5540385842323303,
0.42343661189079285,
0.7205432057380676,
-0.3180786669254303,
0.48198387026786804,
-0.15741334855556488,
0.4816727936267853,
-0.899316132068634,
0.27334269881248474,
-0.025092076510190964,
-0.43141642212867737,
-0.3809370696544647,
0.4862158000469208,
0.06952791661024094,
-0.37392696738243103,
-0.5181981921195984,
0.8458314538002014,
-0.3686254620552063,
-0.17774999141693115,
-0.3914377689361572,
-0.22043593227863312,
0.13164673745632172,
0.5033142566680908,
-0.012056885287165642,
1.2112562656402588,
0.4864583909511566,
-0.5926657915115356,
0.6398717761039734,
0.37383320927619934,
-0.512491762638092,
0.3938923180103302,
-0.5900765061378479,
0.4047277271747589,
0.14885695278644562,
0.27127209305763245,
-0.7555819749832153,
-0.28580522537231445,
0.11940012872219086,
-0.6051474809646606,
0.1566886454820633,
-0.1603846549987793,
-0.7863994240760803,
-0.30576372146606445,
0.018026242032647133,
0.6672185063362122,
0.6364436149597168,
-0.6810678243637085,
0.6165564656257629,
0.43660664558410645,
-0.10333748161792755,
-0.4699234068393707,
-0.6123590469360352,
0.34177008271217346,
0.02289106696844101,
-0.5574076771736145,
0.09876451641321182,
-0.09744775295257568,
-0.4632197320461273,
0.06147712841629982,
-0.026470696553587914,
-0.06973067671060562,
0.016591932624578476,
0.3994268476963043,
0.24606530368328094,
-0.16497749090194702,
0.130618155002594,
-0.09785597771406174,
-0.21960808336734772,
0.0958569347858429,
-0.41836294531822205,
0.508146345615387,
-0.22784635424613953,
-0.4040747284889221,
-0.03948143869638443,
0.21714994311332703,
0.6447743773460388,
-0.6494998335838318,
0.3695294260978699,
0.5172961354255676,
-0.38297438621520996,
-0.6974669098854065,
-0.48052698373794556,
-0.05427113547921181,
-0.43795502185821533,
0.422441691160202,
-0.39430496096611023,
-1.0396087169647217,
0.4123382866382599,
-0.16355042159557343,
-0.00920863263309002,
0.348341703414917,
0.7899412512779236,
0.1808771938085556,
0.884268581867218,
0.6565138101577759,
-0.15067987143993378,
0.20805887877941132,
-0.45160847902297974,
0.07483475655317307,
-0.34517985582351685,
-0.19706092774868011,
-0.5274173021316528,
0.0169064998626709,
-0.3746263086795807,
-0.8923420310020447,
0.2998179495334625,
-0.24051213264465332,
-0.23544663190841675,
0.4816854000091553,
-0.5110855102539062,
0.3695242404937744,
0.37704113125801086,
0.0550459660589695,
0.28482386469841003,
0.2156905233860016,
0.12057007104158401,
0.3836970031261444,
-0.7850418090820312,
-0.4093877673149109,
0.9974812865257263,
0.36140498518943787,
0.992464005947113,
-0.03192928060889244,
0.5438086986541748,
0.8477955460548401,
0.46890994906425476,
-0.7611752152442932,
0.5073050856590271,
-0.039851147681474686,
-0.35545432567596436,
0.0552152618765831,
-0.5474311709403992,
-0.7645530700683594,
0.07790821045637131,
-0.10422975569963455,
-0.27335894107818604,
0.013218013569712639,
0.31035786867141724,
-0.243597611784935,
0.05158102512359619,
-0.44247981905937195,
0.7985613346099854,
-0.309579461812973,
-0.4122941493988037,
-0.2443951815366745,
-0.3017471432685852,
0.2187686264514923,
-0.17099538445472717,
0.09906905144453049,
-0.08696368336677551,
0.05517934635281563,
0.42357268929481506,
-0.587098240852356,
0.9964485764503479,
-0.11304159462451935,
-0.6128362417221069,
0.6261026859283447,
0.253261536359787,
0.6293864846229553,
0.16494715213775635,
-0.049426138401031494,
0.3185974061489105,
-0.2726755440235138,
-0.11642290651798248,
-0.4553665220737457,
0.6322588920593262,
-0.6742941737174988,
-0.21082887053489685,
-0.13077813386917114,
-0.5820001363754272,
-0.34932225942611694,
-0.07930685579776764,
0.24984174966812134,
0.8355108499526978,
-0.1840052604675293,
-0.02249004878103733,
0.6345925331115723,
-0.4471266269683838,
0.1940864622592926,
0.2832462191581726,
-0.3205873370170593,
-0.518286943435669,
1.0519413948059082,
-0.36160051822662354,
0.1755300760269165,
0.2887429893016815,
-0.27783334255218506,
-0.16037911176681519,
-0.22372093796730042,
-0.6671322584152222,
-0.03739462420344353,
-0.7882844805717468,
-0.8324794769287109,
-0.48461639881134033,
-0.2707175612449646,
-0.326459139585495,
-0.16897179186344147,
-0.41688793897628784,
-0.17225560545921326,
-0.13012908399105072,
0.01810331828892231,
0.6811081767082214,
0.7238940596580505,
0.22308604419231415,
0.1480846256017685,
-1.0173743963241577,
0.40151655673980713,
0.15715107321739197,
0.455226331949234,
-0.057858821004629135,
-0.36497756838798523,
-0.44103384017944336,
-0.14737749099731445,
-0.09868522733449936,
-0.3678232431411743,
0.42795586585998535,
0.17120230197906494,
0.5577306747436523,
-0.11511950194835663,
0.07407943904399872,
0.3759574294090271,
-0.46682271361351013,
0.6848787069320679,
0.014290492050349712,
-0.8931690454483032,
0.47421959042549133,
-0.1536041498184204,
0.37872782349586487,
0.4588359296321869,
-0.007980522699654102,
-0.3759523034095764,
-0.5369062423706055,
-0.6788583397865295,
-0.8355860114097595,
0.5379875898361206,
0.32574376463890076,
0.40470921993255615,
0.011029296554625034,
0.5509286522865295,
-0.008867361582815647,
0.269096314907074,
-0.5084051489830017,
-0.14814434945583344,
-0.09921177476644516,
-0.4383821487426758,
-0.11966618150472641,
-0.07614491879940033,
-0.02822914533317089,
-0.06651492416858673,
0.4491563141345978,
-0.4862118065357208,
0.5913468599319458,
0.03432222828269005,
-0.43991485238075256,
-0.14653776586055756,
0.008558002300560474,
0.6384151577949524,
0.6660990715026855,
0.16326570510864258,
0.05084115266799927,
0.08854733407497406,
-0.497087687253952,
0.39591097831726074,
0.07108782231807709,
0.03676376864314079,
-0.17912904918193817,
0.6785546541213989,
0.881870687007904,
-0.19730104506015778,
-1.0663164854049683,
0.7683256268501282,
-0.20072191953659058,
-0.3610393702983856,
-0.20596221089363098,
0.336251825094223,
-0.3325299620628357,
0.4635896384716034,
0.24208323657512665,
0.24807126820087433,
-0.0178902018815279,
-0.26619085669517517,
0.5815345644950867,
0.163612961769104,
-0.2672138810157776,
-0.11377868801355362,
0.5853162407875061,
0.4412746727466583,
-0.2535029351711273,
0.8282471299171448,
-0.25698959827423096,
-0.6110633015632629,
0.9975340962409973,
0.5800483226776123,
0.9582716226577759,
0.02505219727754593,
0.007378892973065376,
0.39479750394821167,
0.30412301421165466,
0.0010070775169879198,
0.27151238918304443,
-0.07192062586545944,
-0.7442402839660645,
-0.6328477263450623,
-0.6481179594993591,
-0.3525085747241974,
0.007071663159877062,
-0.45529624819755554,
0.0990302786231041,
-0.32940858602523804,
-0.3127667307853699,
-0.6279290318489075,
-0.10076258331537247,
-0.7095388174057007,
0.3024950623512268,
0.2410712093114853,
0.9617956280708313,
-0.6192169189453125,
0.8722350597381592,
0.9101125597953796,
-0.38460224866867065,
-0.6920269131660461,
0.20407222211360931,
-0.18595637381076813,
-0.9940076470375061,
0.8661943674087524,
0.12062912434339523,
-0.3043285012245178,
0.18247832357883453,
-0.7603044509887695,
-0.6319293975830078,
0.8985269069671631,
0.40654996037483215,
-0.3844606280326843,
0.11990389227867126,
0.11294443905353546,
0.5310831665992737,
-0.5882357358932495,
0.09136641025543213,
0.38942041993141174,
0.27076905965805054,
-0.10662177950143814,
-0.8788111209869385,
0.11587806791067123,
-0.6806536912918091,
0.29445523023605347,
0.09632658213376999,
-0.5068222880363464,
0.5162417888641357,
-0.28711462020874023,
0.04430297762155533,
0.08265294134616852,
0.5459374785423279,
0.3025982975959778,
0.020641140639781952,
0.3348396420478821,
0.4062340259552002,
0.49201199412345886,
0.030156556516885757,
1.1859430074691772,
-0.6379968523979187,
0.3551168143749237,
0.77220618724823,
-0.321532666683197,
0.7753982543945312,
0.011263221502304077,
-0.028081759810447693,
0.34637027978897095,
0.4310109317302704,
-0.2996997833251953,
0.25811734795570374,
0.4365502893924713,
-0.10522311180830002,
-0.3307381272315979,
-0.05160125344991684,
-0.3184965252876282,
0.6389678716659546,
0.21648402512073517,
-0.14694292843341827,
0.008839334361255169,
0.3716678023338318,
0.09674184769392014,
0.1041707694530487,
-0.22060085833072662,
0.6912134885787964,
0.08471842110157013,
-0.7624780535697937,
0.8858476281166077,
0.0884435623884201,
0.6263429522514343,
-0.5008809566497803,
-0.4145123362541199,
-0.5122297406196594,
0.41225749254226685,
-0.1008964478969574,
-0.6420683264732361,
0.14754751324653625,
0.47007715702056885,
-0.034524161368608475,
-0.39395976066589355,
0.8752161264419556,
-0.2991873621940613,
-0.3652842342853546,
0.30013346672058105,
0.4662611186504364,
-0.09102847427129745,
-0.0775657370686531,
-0.6519018411636353,
0.45863696932792664,
-0.1062621995806694,
-0.16093195974826813,
0.3459348976612091,
0.17356890439987183,
-0.1504736840724945,
0.7327994108200073,
0.5233560800552368,
-0.04432211071252823,
-0.1780000627040863,
0.09960716962814331,
0.9285585880279541,
-0.47714343667030334,
-0.3327900469303131,
-0.5875497460365295,
0.4646333158016205,
0.14814193546772003,
-0.39125147461891174,
0.5153271555900574,
0.5463311672210693,
0.8790501356124878,
-0.17633932828903198,
0.9050169587135315,
-0.24904979765415192,
0.09276914596557617,
-0.5223206877708435,
0.9097575545310974,
-0.6994459629058838,
0.11009202152490616,
-0.19181908667087555,
-0.8518520593643188,
-0.5632699131965637,
0.5981639623641968,
-0.037490107119083405,
0.15698331594467163,
0.49190160632133484,
0.8996313810348511,
0.1259525567293167,
-0.3601279854774475,
0.3824279010295868,
0.03211568668484688,
0.38285964727401733,
0.309155136346817,
1.0104868412017822,
-0.5421689748764038,
0.4906892478466034,
-0.02164791151881218,
-0.253457635641098,
-0.250644713640213,
-0.7287998795509338,
-0.8437952995300293,
-0.595477819442749,
-0.49545013904571533,
-0.608705997467041,
0.11726368963718414,
1.1151759624481201,
0.7439032793045044,
-0.6801705956459045,
-0.3766900599002838,
-0.0393739715218544,
-0.26006534695625305,
-0.25730058550834656,
-0.17656825482845306,
0.15882351994514465,
-0.50937420129776,
-0.6366131901741028,
0.28798019886016846,
0.13473746180534363,
-0.11862269788980484,
-0.16511696577072144,
-0.37882760167121887,
0.22167463600635529,
0.010415912605822086,
0.789168119430542,
0.2678896188735962,
-0.4505338966846466,
-0.13158617913722992,
-0.027065858244895935,
-0.44652649760246277,
0.09705250710248947,
0.9141765236854553,
-0.734969973564148,
0.19210787117481232,
0.31641316413879395,
1.047480583190918,
0.4480268657207489,
0.09164617210626602,
0.6352626085281372,
-0.8001720309257507,
0.02664739266037941,
0.29947876930236816,
0.21399012207984924,
0.2961908280849457,
-0.40201178193092346,
0.5837219953536987,
0.137095645070076,
-0.5722128748893738,
-0.7759611010551453,
0.14482536911964417,
-0.6384311318397522,
-0.17965859174728394,
1.3615185022354126,
-0.20264402031898499,
-0.15288418531417847,
0.06443639099597931,
-0.20328779518604279,
0.053331851959228516,
-0.45740216970443726,
0.40806838870048523,
0.30917978286743164,
-0.18845602869987488,
-0.226118803024292,
-0.5833685398101807,
0.5086084604263306,
0.13968609273433685,
-1.2273977994918823,
0.27285435795783997,
0.7902438640594482,
0.160576730966568,
-0.009346985258162022,
0.7405318021774292,
-0.11326714605093002,
0.4221351742744446,
0.17858146131038666,
0.5895984172821045,
-0.2784469425678253,
-0.535438597202301,
-0.3691238462924957,
0.16767165064811707,
0.40293434262275696,
-0.022018950432538986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04692v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04692v1
|
Mixture-of-Agents Enhances Large Language Model Capabilities
| 2024-06-07T07:04:10 | 2024-06-07T07:04:10 |
Junlin Wang, Jue Wang, Ben Athiwaratkun, Ce Zhang, James Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) demonstrate substantial
capabilities in natural language understanding and generation tasks. With the
growing number of LLMs, how to harness the collective expertise of multiple
LLMs is an exciting open direction. Toward this goal, we propose a new approach
that leverages the collective strengths of multiple LLMs through a
Mixture-of-Agents (MoA) methodology. In our approach, we construct a layered
MoA architecture wherein each layer comprises multiple LLM agents. Each agent
takes all the outputs from agents in the previous layer as auxiliary
information in generating its response. MoA models achieves state-of-art
performance on AlpacaEval 2.0, MT-Bench and FLASK, surpassing GPT-4 Omni. For
example, our MoA using only open-source LLMs is the leader of AlpacaEval 2.0 by
a substantial gap, achieving a score of 65.1% compared to 57.5% by GPT-4 Omni.
|
[
-0.5527759194374084,
-0.8418329358100891,
0.6541515588760376,
0.22841675579547882,
-0.3326272666454315,
0.4953707456588745,
-0.0763544887304306,
-0.5293181538581848,
0.4154418408870697,
0.7560566663742065,
-0.33755043148994446,
-0.4756147265434265,
-0.5185782313346863,
-0.09330594539642334,
-0.17128372192382812,
0.7238592505455017,
0.12784482538700104,
-0.042039766907691956,
-0.15080389380455017,
-0.34137144684791565,
-0.400341659784317,
-0.46948304772377014,
-0.45978844165802,
-0.5255725979804993,
0.5832539200782776,
0.3052034080028534,
0.6346924901008606,
0.437557190656662,
0.259156197309494,
0.37944191694259644,
0.07483511418104172,
0.5845737457275391,
-0.30959999561309814,
0.2119762897491455,
-0.17547957599163055,
-0.32412341237068176,
-0.7678624987602234,
0.0014258809387683868,
0.5586541295051575,
0.5428812503814697,
-0.456012487411499,
-0.17625048756599426,
-0.026827368885278702,
0.4297890067100525,
-0.6207939386367798,
0.0875738114118576,
-0.9527201652526855,
-0.2502877116203308,
-0.1608748883008957,
-0.3449583649635315,
-0.3290112018585205,
0.009587317705154419,
0.16304948925971985,
-0.5478054285049438,
-0.08340234309434891,
-0.0027100539300590754,
0.3233754336833954,
0.0343058779835701,
-0.5987233519554138,
-0.3542814254760742,
-0.729573130607605,
0.698090136051178,
-0.7247072458267212,
0.13874651491641998,
0.0927906483411789,
0.36670786142349243,
-0.4025348126888275,
-0.3354608118534088,
-0.8008843064308167,
-0.2344367951154709,
0.3432842493057251,
0.13682202994823456,
0.056385163217782974,
-0.17909230291843414,
-0.4414626359939575,
0.5238505601882935,
-0.34952330589294434,
0.3307782709598541,
-0.136753112077713,
0.05132044851779938,
0.4522304832935333,
0.2377777099609375,
0.32038891315460205,
0.1256963014602661,
-0.5546860098838806,
-0.2606451213359833,
-0.6519015431404114,
-0.2531126141548157,
0.23009704053401947,
0.5714365243911743,
-0.14227643609046936,
0.7514510750770569,
-0.1190551370382309,
0.4839267432689667,
-0.04454229027032852,
-0.4341650903224945,
0.4443955421447754,
-0.3658541440963745,
-0.38266757130622864,
-0.10289404541254044,
0.9000763893127441,
-0.03929630666971207,
-0.3104243576526642,
-0.25179362297058105,
-0.36804285645484924,
0.03191497176885605,
-0.021592216566205025,
-0.6099066138267517,
0.1427013874053955,
0.25696754455566406,
-0.1602354794740677,
-0.3733643889427185,
0.050582509487867355,
-0.7675730586051941,
-0.7160053849220276,
-0.3310718536376953,
0.5839648842811584,
-0.4986388087272644,
-0.5750423669815063,
0.1973004788160324,
-0.1165577620267868,
0.3399967849254608,
0.24737249314785004,
-0.7220528721809387,
0.5196370482444763,
0.8579550385475159,
0.7505849599838257,
-0.23428674042224884,
-0.47154197096824646,
-0.7017985582351685,
0.5022609829902649,
-0.20535984635353088,
0.7776379585266113,
-0.5859083533287048,
-0.49684056639671326,
0.04764453321695328,
-0.5730229616165161,
-0.0033149379305541515,
-0.6987239718437195,
0.3129974603652954,
-0.520553708076477,
0.2859746813774109,
-0.17126992344856262,
-0.41602814197540283,
-0.060354482382535934,
0.3991224467754364,
-0.6646953821182251,
1.007105827331543,
0.3064509928226471,
-0.40802741050720215,
0.23458212614059448,
-0.571629524230957,
-0.41367456316947937,
0.1156284511089325,
-0.2939205467700958,
0.016305936500430107,
0.024824272841215134,
0.37695255875587463,
0.36579036712646484,
-0.563477635383606,
0.1813761442899704,
-0.2497301548719406,
0.03278202936053276,
0.3808419406414032,
-0.25057655572891235,
0.543118953704834,
0.20437975227832794,
-0.1859348714351654,
0.18760038912296295,
-0.8514949679374695,
-0.18653425574302673,
0.1072237566113472,
-0.47990646958351135,
-0.48146116733551025,
-0.12369544059038162,
-0.15634268522262573,
0.48033958673477173,
0.22274324297904968,
-0.32919663190841675,
0.28511759638786316,
-0.3490784168243408,
0.41251659393310547,
0.7691844701766968,
0.023036060854792595,
0.6125933527946472,
-0.34607994556427,
0.5137947797775269,
0.16559472680091858,
-0.165423184633255,
0.016392216086387634,
-0.5536248683929443,
-0.8510317206382751,
-0.6543779373168945,
0.06722953170537949,
0.3485172390937805,
-1.1450817584991455,
0.8219075202941895,
-0.3063312768936157,
-0.776945173740387,
-0.3744313418865204,
0.3761131465435028,
0.2684673070907593,
0.3035055696964264,
0.15915147960186005,
-0.42381614446640015,
-0.3224301338195801,
-0.7668424248695374,
0.13045820593833923,
-0.26394355297088623,
-0.04752862825989723,
0.20541957020759583,
0.4104152023792267,
-0.4399881362915039,
0.8809931874275208,
-0.24594447016716003,
-0.2525812089443207,
-0.48490026593208313,
0.2210053950548172,
0.10384324193000793,
0.30533891916275024,
0.6106261014938354,
-0.417982280254364,
-0.2129756212234497,
0.29762017726898193,
-0.6312142014503479,
-0.18490839004516602,
0.18371538817882538,
-0.3734557032585144,
0.1814461350440979,
0.039732687175273895,
-0.8696902394294739,
-0.16613352298736572,
0.7450798749923706,
-0.24799104034900665,
0.33603352308273315,
-0.14494173228740692,
0.0579429566860199,
-1.4130616188049316,
-0.2062956988811493,
-0.030620763078331947,
-0.1444324553012848,
-0.6401806473731995,
0.40045028924942017,
-0.3449251055717468,
-0.05555419251322746,
-0.49886760115623474,
0.7151405811309814,
-0.4934239685535431,
-0.17634248733520508,
-0.4662587642669678,
0.2542860805988312,
0.1128133088350296,
0.4347864091396332,
-0.22179649770259857,
0.8017072081565857,
0.6714310050010681,
-0.6760043501853943,
0.42925789952278137,
0.11332974582910538,
-0.24801060557365417,
0.2594575881958008,
-0.44703245162963867,
0.3091880977153778,
-0.0038194393273442984,
0.5652738809585571,
-0.6719298362731934,
-0.30674490332603455,
0.2432205080986023,
-0.11828435957431793,
0.01567445881664753,
0.27945563197135925,
-0.5933287143707275,
-0.2547460198402405,
-0.3374384045600891,
0.3837291896343231,
0.28919538855552673,
-0.4848889112472534,
1.4002432823181152,
0.600855827331543,
-0.2753235995769501,
-0.3507627248764038,
-0.6717422604560852,
0.18363314867019653,
-0.1676400899887085,
-0.936781108379364,
0.19625650346279144,
0.011154323816299438,
-0.5228263139724731,
-0.09408819675445557,
0.10465244203805923,
-0.10564621537923813,
-0.017264030873775482,
0.17605653405189514,
0.23297591507434845,
-0.3604739010334015,
0.053371772170066833,
-0.016410931944847107,
0.02815111167728901,
-0.18026211857795715,
-0.3703885078430176,
1.0813274383544922,
-0.12690819799900055,
-0.5141218900680542,
0.019761890172958374,
0.5458994507789612,
0.7967458963394165,
-0.594467043876648,
1.1643919944763184,
0.4374837577342987,
-0.24455460906028748,
-0.41908690333366394,
-0.7167949676513672,
-0.003112879814580083,
-0.4962216317653656,
0.24096471071243286,
-0.4047240614891052,
-0.9285074472427368,
0.7094953060150146,
0.24853454530239105,
0.12093253433704376,
0.4333840608596802,
0.8933178782463074,
0.2959805428981781,
0.7109090089797974,
0.3958372473716736,
-0.3792118728160858,
0.4086286127567291,
-0.14612168073654175,
0.15967752039432526,
-0.6109338998794556,
-0.3033428490161896,
-0.5429197549819946,
-0.03247193247079849,
-0.4231303632259369,
-0.8354190587997437,
0.4850103557109833,
-0.13140754401683807,
0.15086668729782104,
0.11833649128675461,
-0.08311377465724945,
0.4127480387687683,
0.6240442395210266,
0.1657240092754364,
0.41785481572151184,
0.14011889696121216,
-0.031657006591558456,
0.686047375202179,
-0.6373416185379028,
-0.6009117960929871,
1.0528578758239746,
0.3681516945362091,
0.6281061768531799,
0.47245457768440247,
0.7569773197174072,
0.16730184853076935,
0.18376928567886353,
-0.6598008871078491,
0.7927563786506653,
0.042808499187231064,
-0.45396506786346436,
-0.35486510396003723,
-0.46433186531066895,
-0.7046225666999817,
0.7863571047782898,
-0.23895056545734406,
-0.4372454285621643,
0.036990631371736526,
-0.2125428318977356,
-0.254216730594635,
0.26524996757507324,
-0.6399027705192566,
0.3671262264251709,
-0.19154702126979828,
-0.22116613388061523,
-0.33111122250556946,
-0.3338513672351837,
0.6010674238204956,
-0.18760091066360474,
0.29315364360809326,
-0.1850450336933136,
-0.24180884659290314,
0.4774119257926941,
-0.49693799018859863,
0.6390561461448669,
0.02178463153541088,
-0.5479857325553894,
0.6248498558998108,
-0.0974515974521637,
0.6151487827301025,
-0.17324864864349365,
-0.23061129450798035,
-0.02783416211605072,
-0.5539178252220154,
-0.45007970929145813,
-0.5157210230827332,
0.8275547027587891,
-0.9793673753738403,
-0.3757910430431366,
-0.32962238788604736,
-0.6965448260307312,
-0.5712224841117859,
-0.058031439781188965,
-0.09688521176576614,
0.6105872392654419,
-0.22135165333747864,
0.22199144959449768,
0.46713438630104065,
-0.1848357766866684,
0.46403273940086365,
0.734168291091919,
-0.19355303049087524,
-0.6033368110656738,
1.0146708488464355,
-0.08487662672996521,
0.48162561655044556,
0.3468533754348755,
0.17067959904670715,
-0.23343853652477264,
-0.663982629776001,
-0.2454828917980194,
0.23728904128074646,
-0.6737228631973267,
-0.03578169271349907,
-0.8300943970680237,
-0.08283106982707977,
-0.625860869884491,
0.09479184448719025,
-0.2388106882572174,
-0.15035665035247803,
-0.19820958375930786,
-0.13747736811637878,
0.00009287997090723366,
0.7557600140571594,
0.2593171000480652,
0.4143431782722473,
-1.0399693250656128,
0.328664094209671,
0.6101019382476807,
0.08506357669830322,
0.0968676209449768,
-0.32064101099967957,
-0.09744000434875488,
0.06616052985191345,
-0.31832534074783325,
-0.8175712823867798,
0.3934116065502167,
0.15146207809448242,
0.7922504544258118,
0.3738676607608795,
-0.3245948553085327,
0.5004019737243652,
-0.19180014729499817,
0.9209773540496826,
0.23815545439720154,
-0.8745542764663696,
0.2838023602962494,
-0.7648110389709473,
0.17102107405662537,
0.47755515575408936,
-0.1508444994688034,
-0.10809456557035446,
-0.6617416739463806,
-0.48805201053619385,
-0.8486337065696716,
0.5879985690116882,
0.3763168156147003,
0.11562886089086533,
-0.03781431168317795,
-0.12321336567401886,
0.3690313398838043,
0.34341704845428467,
-0.6212115287780762,
0.02197461575269699,
0.051664747297763824,
-0.1976792961359024,
-0.06528127193450928,
-0.15911979973316193,
-0.2528168261051178,
0.0318179726600647,
0.9165616631507874,
-0.2602215111255646,
-0.0817323625087738,
-0.140621617436409,
-0.18344710767269135,
-0.11106381565332413,
0.46292951703071594,
0.6015635132789612,
0.7862453460693359,
-0.08287988603115082,
0.3005884885787964,
0.025679735466837883,
-0.2650345265865326,
0.20219965279102325,
0.06057976931333542,
-0.001490368857048452,
-0.2849552631378174,
0.49532240629196167,
0.7713128924369812,
-0.08438954502344131,
-0.8641555309295654,
0.27214157581329346,
0.11929316073656082,
-0.22648721933364868,
0.1533249467611313,
0.21728606522083282,
0.20113001763820648,
0.38002413511276245,
0.6018802523612976,
-0.004614382982254028,
0.014298987574875355,
-0.9694739580154419,
-0.03429047018289566,
0.4469277262687683,
0.14583486318588257,
-0.2001718282699585,
0.10083258152008057,
0.5736843347549438,
-0.052262190729379654,
0.1105603501200676,
-0.12402206659317017,
-0.35610470175743103,
0.7317911982536316,
0.6089306473731995,
0.7447972297668457,
-0.28036031126976013,
0.20204037427902222,
-0.21426643431186676,
0.3218153119087219,
-0.16053533554077148,
0.13703207671642303,
0.285988986492157,
-0.9362275004386902,
-0.37328267097473145,
-0.6203307509422302,
-0.5202377438545227,
0.23705266416072845,
-0.236741304397583,
0.028823157772421837,
-0.4409853219985962,
0.005856459494680166,
-0.14974799752235413,
0.03689856082201004,
-0.4949389100074768,
0.1484634429216385,
0.358486145734787,
0.8101740479469299,
-0.8244796395301819,
0.884804368019104,
0.619411826133728,
-0.45780497789382935,
-0.9215756058692932,
-0.007501831743866205,
-0.07350318133831024,
-0.7760441303253174,
0.13743716478347778,
0.08370168507099152,
-0.30243873596191406,
-0.31525200605392456,
-0.3408670127391815,
-0.661280632019043,
1.2758314609527588,
0.3886392414569855,
-0.3450629711151123,
0.20462483167648315,
0.2921234667301178,
0.5881758332252502,
-0.7959044575691223,
0.29847535490989685,
0.676028847694397,
0.27404749393463135,
0.3198166489601135,
-0.8106849193572998,
-0.1075216755270958,
-0.16515794396400452,
-0.028691843152046204,
0.11367160826921463,
-0.7984771132469177,
1.1563856601715088,
0.1853220909833908,
0.034625809639692307,
0.028117289766669273,
0.9547057151794434,
0.7426189184188843,
0.2755630910396576,
0.6698697209358215,
0.5899439454078674,
0.862736165523529,
0.13934114575386047,
1.1057270765304565,
-0.12784026563167572,
-0.043825361877679825,
1.2414278984069824,
-0.7327846884727478,
0.9051872491836548,
0.4083273112773895,
-0.03276790678501129,
0.5712386965751648,
0.17276053130626678,
0.45979970693588257,
0.49449318647384644,
-0.054485876113176346,
-0.6899750232696533,
-0.30991318821907043,
-0.3215048909187317,
-0.5373417139053345,
0.6462448239326477,
0.18063567578792572,
-0.24822385609149933,
-0.16183966398239136,
-0.02578609064221382,
-0.23368656635284424,
0.0967843309044838,
-0.2629460394382477,
0.7990147471427917,
0.001882211654447019,
-0.6845576763153076,
0.1007327064871788,
0.16868385672569275,
0.6787563562393188,
-0.7276379466056824,
0.011470356024801731,
-0.20292939245700836,
0.04709135368466377,
0.0892852321267128,
-0.6560789942741394,
-0.19268366694450378,
-0.1423681378364563,
-0.1577543020248413,
0.10439106076955795,
0.7844880223274231,
-0.6884517669677734,
-0.5280254483222961,
0.33411598205566406,
0.8564566373825073,
-0.19210217893123627,
-0.2668241560459137,
-0.28145289421081543,
0.0387004129588604,
-0.30194830894470215,
-0.16938017308712006,
0.5130218863487244,
0.6818709969520569,
0.022830521687865257,
0.8061794638633728,
0.6563729047775269,
0.060290124267339706,
0.273475706577301,
0.30692318081855774,
1.2085819244384766,
-0.3866505026817322,
-0.5971361398696899,
-0.8515764474868774,
0.2771901488304138,
-0.15354299545288086,
-0.21550917625427246,
0.5397289395332336,
0.496206670999527,
0.351387083530426,
0.02623719722032547,
0.7902073860168457,
-0.029543524608016014,
0.3371163010597229,
-0.6689625382423401,
0.4774637818336487,
-0.5393251776695251,
0.3083685636520386,
-0.1288125365972519,
-1.147242784500122,
0.16296349465847015,
0.12907609343528748,
0.15016576647758484,
0.13155804574489594,
0.5590780377388,
0.8050375580787659,
-0.05639186501502991,
0.07229416817426682,
0.24471452832221985,
0.14262743294239044,
0.754833459854126,
0.5577037930488586,
0.8520064353942871,
-0.1051720678806305,
0.47155365347862244,
-0.016597392037510872,
-0.2828383147716522,
-0.060891903936862946,
-0.820674479007721,
-0.9997721910476685,
-0.2884269654750824,
0.04252226650714874,
-0.19705389440059662,
-0.35318079590797424,
1.1906776428222656,
0.594075620174408,
-0.6433284878730774,
-0.29884785413742065,
0.015958134084939957,
-0.08771702647209167,
-0.07967377454042435,
-0.17340824007987976,
-0.002428513951599598,
-0.1631104201078415,
-0.7042470574378967,
0.8723594546318054,
0.4468255937099457,
-0.03321589156985283,
-0.7328223586082458,
-0.4671528935432434,
-0.2844032943248749,
0.49139460921287537,
0.745688259601593,
-0.14356043934822083,
-0.804214596748352,
-0.05361682176589966,
-0.3010711669921875,
-0.49459511041641235,
-0.01581786572933197,
0.7857335805892944,
-0.7075656056404114,
0.17412231862545013,
0.6692144274711609,
0.7255139946937561,
0.1582985818386078,
0.03468422219157219,
0.6754593253135681,
-0.7868163585662842,
0.40160974860191345,
0.24307094514369965,
0.5707471370697021,
0.35172227025032043,
-0.039239734411239624,
0.5015941858291626,
0.02780500240623951,
-0.3134879469871521,
-0.6465325951576233,
0.075309619307518,
-1.431567668914795,
-0.1707657426595688,
1.411991834640503,
0.17488965392112732,
-0.21564052999019623,
0.03894778713583946,
-0.31710273027420044,
0.14704875648021698,
-0.8231438398361206,
0.5840774774551392,
0.7779763340950012,
0.20248305797576904,
-0.12586690485477448,
-0.2065562903881073,
-0.27862975001335144,
0.22849443554878235,
-1.3161025047302246,
-0.2260589748620987,
0.6283807754516602,
0.05353833734989166,
0.35966965556144714,
0.8888976573944092,
0.0307304784655571,
-0.09824098646640778,
0.0199319776147604,
-0.007321486249566078,
-0.303568571805954,
-0.3544437289237976,
0.008490639738738537,
0.4695696234703064,
0.0887395590543747,
-0.1684730350971222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06616v1
|
Transforming Dental Diagnostics with Artificial Intelligence: Advanced Integration of ChatGPT and Large Language Models for Patient Care
| 2024-06-07T06:44:09 | 2024-06-07T06:44:09 |
Masoumeh Farhadi Nia, Mohsen Ahmadi, Elyas Irankhah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Artificial intelligence has dramatically reshaped our interaction with
digital technologies, ushering in an era where advancements in AI algorithms
and Large Language Models (LLMs) have natural language processing (NLP) systems
like ChatGPT. This study delves into the impact of cutting-edge LLMs, notably
OpenAI's ChatGPT, on medical diagnostics, with a keen focus on the dental
sector. Leveraging publicly accessible datasets, these models augment the
diagnostic capabilities of medical professionals, streamline communication
between patients and healthcare providers, and enhance the efficiency of
clinical procedures. The advent of ChatGPT-4 is poised to make substantial
inroads into dental practices, especially in the realm of oral surgery. This
paper sheds light on the current landscape and explores potential future
research directions in the burgeoning field of LLMs, offering valuable insights
for both practitioners and developers. Furthermore, it critically assesses the
broad implications and challenges within various sectors, including academia
and healthcare, thus mapping out an overview of AI's role in transforming
dental diagnostics for enhanced patient care.
|
[
-0.10796118527650833,
-0.8638512492179871,
0.7442327737808228,
-0.029763437807559967,
-0.14565041661262512,
0.32357677817344666,
-0.2538163959980011,
-0.7499976754188538,
0.2817022204399109,
0.3149666488170624,
-0.4935265779495239,
-0.345399409532547,
-0.6277353167533875,
0.2157001495361328,
-0.5510868430137634,
0.5324169397354126,
0.06484987586736679,
0.45100051164627075,
-0.4243086874485016,
0.15051987767219543,
-0.24514901638031006,
-0.5712354183197021,
-0.8865228295326233,
-0.3366644084453583,
0.3958788812160492,
-0.031701914966106415,
1.0678820610046387,
0.7311992049217224,
0.8371771574020386,
0.2948087155818939,
0.10805515944957733,
0.23294693231582642,
-0.11769428104162216,
0.11660980433225632,
0.10748876631259918,
-0.48230400681495667,
-0.5030263662338257,
-0.26613175868988037,
0.5870691537857056,
0.946204662322998,
-0.22013752162456512,
-0.2122233510017395,
-0.22930008172988892,
0.44785869121551514,
-0.05620599538087845,
0.4556237757205963,
-0.22416716814041138,
0.11402543634176254,
-0.4472232162952423,
-0.22053948044776917,
-0.10645484179258347,
-0.5345430374145508,
0.3572114109992981,
-0.36729294061660767,
-0.059022966772317886,
-0.17918424308300018,
0.7821894884109497,
0.437531054019928,
-0.26841580867767334,
-0.2912067770957947,
-0.9685112833976746,
0.33731183409690857,
-0.6229252815246582,
0.5312973260879517,
0.04576936736702919,
0.42361950874328613,
-0.17908675968647003,
-1.1207174062728882,
-0.41973721981048584,
0.0292658731341362,
0.268252432346344,
0.25677964091300964,
-0.5570640563964844,
0.1599712371826172,
-0.08808727562427521,
0.5829914212226868,
-0.4459272027015686,
0.47005629539489746,
-0.468997985124588,
-0.07523509860038757,
0.44107678532600403,
0.28670892119407654,
0.8770826458930969,
0.2500399053096771,
-0.05588260665535927,
-0.05145026743412018,
-0.9395410418510437,
-0.1104293018579483,
-0.19213470816612244,
0.2764365077018738,
0.1375623196363449,
0.5394615530967712,
0.09238541126251221,
0.3294859528541565,
-0.356170654296875,
-0.32229936122894287,
0.2533257305622101,
-0.42907002568244934,
-0.2263067215681076,
0.314498633146286,
0.7436263561248779,
0.18614432215690613,
0.13670235872268677,
-0.04360709339380264,
-0.14383414387702942,
0.20946721732616425,
0.24157457053661346,
-0.8465547561645508,
-0.15783530473709106,
0.259537011384964,
-0.5288318991661072,
-0.2674291431903839,
-0.25645944476127625,
-0.7926025390625,
-0.7603420615196228,
-0.429278165102005,
-0.011974037624895573,
-0.5310659408569336,
-0.5514708757400513,
0.3520057201385498,
0.04542269930243492,
0.47960901260375977,
0.4818759858608246,
-0.9428023099899292,
0.5447044372558594,
0.9827706217765808,
0.8420156836509705,
-0.1000293493270874,
0.08181285113096237,
-0.3677665591239929,
-0.028472596779465675,
-0.4889758229255676,
0.8487257957458496,
-0.6224183440208435,
-0.427641361951828,
0.439571350812912,
-0.1781209111213684,
-0.2693201005458832,
-0.9616348147392273,
0.18427224457263947,
-0.36786356568336487,
-0.1396898627281189,
0.032800041139125824,
-0.33386486768722534,
-0.18142931163311005,
0.3918339014053345,
-0.5062031149864197,
0.4490777552127838,
0.39592573046684265,
-0.11212341487407684,
0.04606589302420616,
-0.747363805770874,
-0.7277282476425171,
0.546456515789032,
-0.372409850358963,
-0.42223939299583435,
0.06278998404741287,
0.37418094277381897,
0.2910858988761902,
-0.5728354454040527,
0.44513195753097534,
-0.2065005600452423,
-0.07461138814687729,
0.21010375022888184,
-0.3217625021934509,
0.8317017555236816,
0.01656791754066944,
-0.10387058556079865,
0.29697078466415405,
-0.3079929053783417,
-0.29737648367881775,
0.1700766384601593,
-0.039622366428375244,
0.11277087777853012,
0.0936269536614418,
-0.23254907131195068,
0.06361816823482513,
0.20223867893218994,
-0.4620981514453888,
0.22980280220508575,
-0.6452479362487793,
1.022937536239624,
0.5693165063858032,
0.1649026721715927,
0.0809558629989624,
-0.5457364320755005,
0.7335600256919861,
-0.08772361278533936,
0.5541176795959473,
-0.17083781957626343,
-0.922639012336731,
-0.3656405806541443,
-0.19043917953968048,
0.41319581866264343,
0.7839139699935913,
-0.5311872959136963,
0.07447726279497147,
-0.385175496339798,
-0.6107451915740967,
-0.9910560250282288,
-0.10794659703969955,
-0.03920990973711014,
0.4134320914745331,
0.15171410143375397,
-0.3883691132068634,
-0.2283935695886612,
-0.7559860348701477,
0.05192636698484421,
-0.23344750702381134,
-0.07716136425733566,
0.363568514585495,
0.11485258489847183,
-0.7425130605697632,
0.8048611879348755,
-0.45005884766578674,
-0.6331719160079956,
-0.3051384687423706,
-0.3354586064815521,
0.3445504605770111,
0.34278634190559387,
0.4964461326599121,
-0.8128633499145508,
-0.32587435841560364,
0.3199465572834015,
-0.7763977646827698,
0.06324615329504013,
0.10797487199306488,
0.23243527114391327,
-0.1555028110742569,
0.7561330199241638,
-0.7994045615196228,
0.5360246300697327,
0.4478308856487274,
-0.06423836201429367,
0.5487741231918335,
-0.2621660828590393,
0.04998794570565224,
-0.744964599609375,
-0.04528557509183884,
0.07867126911878586,
-0.17352846264839172,
-0.6979079842567444,
-0.07130067050457001,
-0.07068479806184769,
-0.49798819422721863,
-0.3552025258541107,
0.4361947774887085,
-0.11854054778814316,
-0.18011613190174103,
0.03130209073424339,
0.11332118511199951,
-0.35925009846687317,
-0.14193207025527954,
-0.2122524380683899,
0.8245280385017395,
0.7607930898666382,
-0.5216067433357239,
0.6653303503990173,
0.5483335256576538,
-0.257973313331604,
0.46452614665031433,
-0.7304867506027222,
0.03348610922694206,
0.1992027312517166,
0.13197371363639832,
-0.8273818492889404,
-0.529910147190094,
0.2797990143299103,
-0.5862530469894409,
0.36756986379623413,
0.09659140557050705,
-0.9224907159805298,
-0.43983304500579834,
0.0504794642329216,
0.3855641484260559,
0.7970116138458252,
-0.42838868498802185,
0.8001828789710999,
0.6597756743431091,
-0.8392135500907898,
-0.05837450176477432,
-0.6317053437232971,
0.43934011459350586,
-0.015838932245969772,
-1.0523573160171509,
0.46545320749282837,
-0.07861141115427017,
-0.567468523979187,
-0.16003113985061646,
0.0725579634308815,
-0.2419346421957016,
0.19879695773124695,
0.08155147731304169,
0.4058189392089844,
-0.6964176297187805,
0.3615761995315552,
0.03261520341038704,
-0.08625533431768417,
0.38232502341270447,
-0.19186174869537354,
0.8606884479522705,
-0.18677188456058502,
-0.6020055413246155,
-0.703880786895752,
0.22983300685882568,
0.5297700762748718,
-0.5759152770042419,
0.42804214358329773,
0.45706504583358765,
-0.5599226355552673,
0.259914755821228,
-0.33149170875549316,
-0.13391602039337158,
-0.4379633069038391,
0.4007079601287842,
0.021656833589076996,
-0.6422438025474548,
0.5608163475990295,
-0.41038039326667786,
0.08168414980173111,
0.40537843108177185,
0.7409573197364807,
-0.025686118751764297,
1.3140246868133545,
0.49770763516426086,
0.035623837262392044,
0.4990071654319763,
0.04919436573982239,
0.5352888107299805,
-0.543571412563324,
-0.39273151755332947,
-0.340565949678421,
0.07033045589923859,
-0.7452326416969299,
-0.14240017533302307,
0.6767736673355103,
-0.5144762992858887,
-0.05207093805074692,
-0.301578551530838,
-0.4020369052886963,
0.1308089792728424,
0.4526648223400116,
0.3014879822731018,
0.27028217911720276,
-0.3964011073112488,
0.27956146001815796,
0.2153564989566803,
-0.5203459858894348,
-0.37225213646888733,
0.9174448251724243,
0.5615816116333008,
0.48221638798713684,
0.31686270236968994,
0.5329131484031677,
0.3047654926776886,
0.11573637276887894,
-0.944254457950592,
0.31367266178131104,
-0.3683396875858307,
-0.23945343494415283,
-0.30409324169158936,
-0.18562883138656616,
-1.245679497718811,
-0.023094777017831802,
0.17968358099460602,
-0.4874352812767029,
0.05024540796875954,
-0.10964235663414001,
-0.7519515156745911,
0.25878435373306274,
-0.742754340171814,
0.7259597778320312,
-0.24649330973625183,
0.1133696511387825,
-0.21453922986984253,
-0.6511120796203613,
0.19600601494312286,
-0.021612994372844696,
0.31340792775154114,
-0.13111871480941772,
-0.0665794312953949,
0.7154127359390259,
-0.1433873474597931,
0.9045718312263489,
0.03939887881278992,
-0.3299205005168915,
-0.05522003397345543,
-0.011871865019202232,
0.052571237087249756,
0.22349312901496887,
0.11108928173780441,
0.15065981447696686,
0.06356624513864517,
-0.26405543088912964,
-0.5818992853164673,
0.5590500831604004,
-0.874959409236908,
-0.7097719311714172,
-0.4343447685241699,
-0.2560678720474243,
-0.5397810339927673,
0.47680407762527466,
-0.22234004735946655,
0.6246019601821899,
-0.41580915451049805,
-0.25047168135643005,
0.8965968489646912,
-0.365779846906662,
0.2621448040008545,
0.07635120302438736,
-0.28051531314849854,
-0.27851858735084534,
0.9980608820915222,
-0.07019549608230591,
0.30945250391960144,
0.2471126765012741,
0.22541777789592743,
-0.3108038902282715,
-0.8695706129074097,
-0.44816628098487854,
0.6151005029678345,
-0.9317576289176941,
-0.15883371233940125,
-0.4129914343357086,
-0.5989070534706116,
-0.763487696647644,
-0.0714498832821846,
-0.4325186610221863,
0.07593590021133423,
-0.6523953676223755,
0.160649836063385,
0.33541807532310486,
1.0454843044281006,
0.14140120148658752,
0.3314584195613861,
-0.7305033206939697,
0.2902899384498596,
0.33796796202659607,
0.5679395198822021,
-0.1379786878824234,
-0.05297714099287987,
0.1487109363079071,
0.1384258270263672,
-0.0530712753534317,
-0.5551431775093079,
0.6810048222541809,
0.17276275157928467,
0.4505074918270111,
0.7732343077659607,
-0.18819698691368103,
0.4057964086532593,
-0.5691686272621155,
0.7942912578582764,
0.22554363310337067,
-0.6614866852760315,
0.44690388441085815,
-0.45300281047821045,
0.31150636076927185,
0.26928380131721497,
0.3502641022205353,
-0.9642411470413208,
-0.21429511904716492,
-0.5557798743247986,
-0.761111855506897,
0.34322816133499146,
-0.20994675159454346,
0.03571214899420738,
-0.01385391317307949,
0.1108231395483017,
0.11906726658344269,
-0.09007911384105682,
-0.19768676161766052,
-0.047682467848062515,
-0.1305493414402008,
-0.42681261897087097,
-0.0388747937977314,
0.041999392211437225,
-0.2153298407793045,
-0.31521278619766235,
0.4764532148838043,
-0.12566156685352325,
0.7438919544219971,
0.14664046466350555,
-0.0741930678486824,
-0.007034126203507185,
0.09999904036521912,
0.7408365607261658,
0.7632095217704773,
-0.10135366767644882,
-0.1303100436925888,
-0.254995733499527,
-0.5897424221038818,
-0.2836093306541443,
0.3452945053577423,
0.16661274433135986,
0.03794329985976219,
0.3200571835041046,
0.49399763345718384,
-0.03864898905158043,
-0.8390310406684875,
0.5434139966964722,
-0.11574676632881165,
-0.23436583578586578,
-0.6366922855377197,
-0.016360314562916756,
0.1149655357003212,
0.41605332493782043,
0.16457639634609222,
0.14949128031730652,
0.02671082317829132,
-0.7010490894317627,
0.21409514546394348,
0.4131183326244354,
-0.6388250589370728,
-0.38532736897468567,
0.43615299463272095,
0.3400558829307556,
-0.5697330832481384,
1.1612334251403809,
0.18151675164699554,
-0.49026402831077576,
0.7174845933914185,
0.5132030844688416,
0.6453332304954529,
-0.42820534110069275,
0.0027931546792387962,
-0.02085243910551071,
0.04665087163448334,
-0.0325346365571022,
0.040931764990091324,
0.39103853702545166,
-0.7101492881774902,
-0.3731154203414917,
-0.2613653838634491,
-0.545237123966217,
0.23059245944023132,
-0.5024800896644592,
0.3809618055820465,
-0.6273808479309082,
0.04345719516277313,
0.4655134081840515,
-0.22598214447498322,
-0.6498890519142151,
0.0744210034608841,
0.5853332281112671,
0.8024438619613647,
-0.2650463879108429,
0.4993168115615845,
0.45518958568573,
-0.4484913647174835,
-0.26638129353523254,
-0.01398402638733387,
0.34265556931495667,
-1.543431282043457,
0.3826344907283783,
0.17825627326965332,
0.06586987525224686,
0.22417567670345306,
-0.4106574058532715,
-0.880500853061676,
0.8996646404266357,
0.2260204404592514,
-0.4128485321998596,
-0.3115086853504181,
0.3665737807750702,
0.6978382468223572,
-0.2519630789756775,
0.31672823429107666,
0.9294003248214722,
0.42870771884918213,
-0.09569157660007477,
-1.4585059881210327,
-0.05687837302684784,
-0.20227986574172974,
-0.18937848508358002,
0.4329904019832611,
-0.32518187165260315,
0.8739323616027832,
-0.149603471159935,
-0.4620678126811981,
0.03305830806493759,
0.28453004360198975,
-0.20327885448932648,
0.09214065223932266,
0.08203055709600449,
0.40584152936935425,
0.8465314507484436,
-0.23064716160297394,
1.3225810527801514,
-0.14918607473373413,
-0.19303789734840393,
0.3324948847293854,
-0.3424070179462433,
0.659235954284668,
0.04753486439585686,
-0.47279465198516846,
0.37078580260276794,
0.800194263458252,
-0.212666317820549,
0.2089764028787613,
0.18457992374897003,
-0.4375019967556,
-0.1655563861131668,
-0.4291333556175232,
-0.5656633377075195,
0.7642354369163513,
0.8199346661567688,
-0.23072725534439087,
-0.2115500569343567,
0.11408428847789764,
0.021117154508829117,
-0.13935193419456482,
-0.6967853307723999,
1.0454051494598389,
0.07568433880805969,
-0.5815560221672058,
0.3675505816936493,
-0.194727823138237,
0.4592425227165222,
-0.5802049040794373,
-0.14046116173267365,
-0.015381166711449623,
0.38004809617996216,
-0.16277508437633514,
-0.873451828956604,
0.3072011172771454,
-0.43081897497177124,
0.13675916194915771,
-0.5235114693641663,
0.7722106575965881,
-0.20568521320819855,
-0.1662212461233139,
0.11106210947036743,
0.7150763869285583,
0.1517234742641449,
-0.2038511484861374,
-0.5402127504348755,
0.030464695766568184,
0.06242622435092926,
0.26784878969192505,
0.4395914375782013,
0.4522360563278198,
0.029005354270339012,
0.8468813896179199,
0.7055394649505615,
0.15824222564697266,
-0.10202053934335709,
0.2573724687099457,
0.8562992811203003,
-0.7860051989555359,
-0.32816147804260254,
-1.0174463987350464,
0.020720787346363068,
0.155104860663414,
-0.2147265076637268,
0.28924670815467834,
0.4816790223121643,
0.5301573276519775,
0.17459455132484436,
0.8859180212020874,
0.28408893942832947,
0.6160732507705688,
-0.39101162552833557,
0.8263922929763794,
-0.2779572606086731,
0.03395996615290642,
-0.06539665162563324,
-0.27770179510116577,
-0.673724889755249,
0.19070494174957275,
-0.23748436570167542,
-0.11474965512752533,
0.5100111365318298,
0.49943646788597107,
0.23416908085346222,
0.2758180499076843,
0.2500494718551636,
0.21018929779529572,
0.7192954421043396,
0.24157573282718658,
0.8764835000038147,
0.04210005700588226,
0.5708044171333313,
-0.13111010193824768,
-0.30648481845855713,
-0.3772445619106293,
-0.2764008641242981,
-0.5774638056755066,
-0.4927341043949127,
-0.3589922785758972,
-0.12622152268886566,
-0.038446977734565735,
0.826520562171936,
0.44380858540534973,
-0.5852751135826111,
-0.09231456369161606,
0.010074264369904995,
-0.09219446033239365,
-0.33533504605293274,
-0.16829101741313934,
0.4172758162021637,
-0.3548988699913025,
-0.5802719593048096,
0.4341717064380646,
0.6753421425819397,
0.3188072144985199,
-0.49010345339775085,
0.20375965535640717,
0.08127730339765549,
-0.12150794267654419,
0.6732966899871826,
0.4360415041446686,
-0.8564807176589966,
0.048857640475034714,
0.27347779273986816,
-0.0728428065776825,
0.6695132851600647,
0.5755491852760315,
-0.8207166194915771,
0.38107335567474365,
0.052567970007658005,
1.1824724674224854,
0.3075985312461853,
-0.3036276698112488,
0.8947856426239014,
-0.08497843146324158,
-0.3301176130771637,
0.8527276515960693,
0.3796543776988983,
0.35376933217048645,
-0.4233940541744232,
0.5263293385505676,
0.33784791827201843,
-0.5312010049819946,
-0.9849951863288879,
0.2400972992181778,
-0.9901538491249084,
-0.24069872498512268,
1.0867235660552979,
0.07339131087064743,
-0.37927401065826416,
-0.40128591656684875,
-0.10384314507246017,
0.31234967708587646,
-0.299934446811676,
0.7378981113433838,
0.39270612597465515,
-0.6357606649398804,
-0.3087819218635559,
-0.9148269295692444,
0.6767811179161072,
0.09780985116958618,
-1.1186575889587402,
-0.0753466784954071,
0.11900679767131805,
-0.035129327327013016,
0.17399659752845764,
0.7021932601928711,
-0.26649001240730286,
0.4518718719482422,
-0.047031622380018234,
-0.0064582983031868935,
0.03422517701983452,
0.05482056736946106,
-0.3192659318447113,
-0.1018347516655922,
0.13907016813755035,
-0.03897486627101898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04670v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04670v1
|
MATTER: Memory-Augmented Transformer Using Heterogeneous Knowledge Sources
| 2024-06-07T06:35:37 | 2024-06-07T06:35:37 |
Dongkyu Lee, Chandana Satya Prakash, Jack FitzGerald, Jens Lehmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Leveraging external knowledge is crucial for achieving high performance in
knowledge-intensive tasks, such as question answering. The retrieve-and-read
approach is widely adopted for integrating external knowledge into a language
model. However, this approach suffers from increased computational cost and
latency due to the long context length, which grows proportionally with the
number of retrieved knowledge. Furthermore, existing retrieval-augmented models
typically retrieve information from a single type of knowledge source, limiting
their scalability to diverse knowledge sources with varying structures. In this
work, we introduce an efficient memory-augmented transformer called MATTER,
designed to retrieve relevant knowledge from multiple heterogeneous knowledge
sources. Specifically, our model retrieves and reads from both unstructured
sources (paragraphs) and semi-structured sources (QA pairs) in the form of
fixed-length neural memories. We demonstrate that our model outperforms
existing efficient retrieval-augmented models on popular QA benchmarks in terms
of both accuracy and speed. Furthermore, MATTER achieves competitive results
compared to conventional read-and-retrieve models while having 100x throughput
during inference.
|
[
-0.20035460591316223,
-0.7761965990066528,
0.704835832118988,
0.15599101781845093,
-0.027641713619232178,
0.08563972264528275,
-0.17795415222644806,
-0.3998506963253021,
0.18105068802833557,
0.4191734492778778,
-0.11925745755434036,
0.13688959181308746,
-0.40046757459640503,
-0.21073180437088013,
-0.4674586057662964,
0.726971447467804,
0.0605010911822319,
-0.1764611452817917,
-0.2952105700969696,
-0.2320767194032669,
-0.6340835690498352,
-0.35565513372421265,
-0.3795921206474304,
-0.4534745216369629,
0.4310535788536072,
0.09881047159433365,
0.7777425646781921,
0.4449298083782196,
0.4122983515262604,
0.3118985593318939,
-0.17238791286945343,
0.4243673086166382,
-0.3398537337779999,
-0.024475187063217163,
-0.28595393896102905,
-0.7407546043395996,
-0.13121335208415985,
-0.14712923765182495,
0.6974753737449646,
0.43893668055534363,
-0.24173197150230408,
0.032994866371154785,
-0.3065914511680603,
0.5127024054527283,
-0.798180341720581,
0.050836626440286636,
-0.8629382252693176,
0.12318915873765945,
-0.08696950227022171,
-0.3609265387058258,
-0.4817766547203064,
-0.4165680706501007,
0.251190185546875,
-0.6702478528022766,
0.11058740317821503,
0.027119481936097145,
0.9076202511787415,
0.1819649636745453,
-0.2214796543121338,
-0.31741800904273987,
-1.0064973831176758,
0.8306043744087219,
-0.4317738711833954,
0.7228302955627441,
0.3875053822994232,
0.4753183126449585,
0.6113076210021973,
-1.0984289646148682,
-0.8500128984451294,
0.2304878830909729,
-0.18017490208148956,
0.2287665456533432,
-0.3238189220428467,
-0.4448005259037018,
0.041266340762376785,
0.4127095341682434,
-0.011586926877498627,
-0.5316917896270752,
-0.5561411380767822,
-0.1898435801267624,
0.14719924330711365,
0.12428546696901321,
0.41797512769699097,
-0.2654556930065155,
-0.27790185809135437,
0.06834476441144943,
-0.663661539554596,
-0.08997077494859695,
0.2675023674964905,
0.2707977592945099,
0.24437980353832245,
0.812267005443573,
0.02044045738875866,
0.7474817633628845,
0.21975688636302948,
0.045557498931884766,
-0.033347997814416885,
-0.4696258008480072,
0.08940728008747101,
-0.1771424561738968,
0.4383581876754761,
-0.0017085610888898373,
-0.10475850850343704,
-0.71930330991745,
-0.1507149189710617,
-0.24169807136058807,
0.7264161705970764,
-1.0532214641571045,
-0.496783047914505,
0.07613179832696915,
-0.30558231472969055,
0.29525279998779297,
-0.057419490069150925,
-0.8668892979621887,
-0.24672125279903412,
-0.32703715562820435,
0.768572986125946,
-0.7806552052497864,
-0.10090890526771545,
0.1975514441728592,
-0.36319902539253235,
0.10862114280462265,
0.44762542843818665,
-0.8367447853088379,
0.3361770212650299,
0.3733406960964203,
0.856377363204956,
-0.18528632819652557,
-0.07903097569942474,
-0.5207281708717346,
0.34406578540802,
-0.11355287581682205,
1.1116234064102173,
-0.7756370306015015,
-0.18124160170555115,
-0.040901992470026016,
-0.24391886591911316,
-0.20004934072494507,
-0.6533091068267822,
0.32026928663253784,
-1.1442838907241821,
0.4249776005744934,
-0.28270575404167175,
-0.48642590641975403,
-0.2737443447113037,
0.248084157705307,
-0.8854602575302124,
0.899966299533844,
0.40309056639671326,
-0.7389777898788452,
0.062171440571546555,
-0.6934142112731934,
-0.46270686388015747,
0.03552664816379547,
-0.2294146865606308,
-0.12399628758430481,
0.14247646927833557,
0.1424650251865387,
0.2783565819263458,
-0.5431424379348755,
0.13758084177970886,
0.11256115138530731,
-0.487273246049881,
0.1864137500524521,
-0.5286968350410461,
0.33274754881858826,
0.08892957866191864,
-0.08827295899391174,
0.022272735834121704,
-0.5708558559417725,
-0.11015035957098007,
0.11448675394058228,
-0.7513269782066345,
-0.5061370730400085,
0.09975160658359528,
-0.028514204546809196,
0.32195207476615906,
0.34193718433380127,
-0.7197175025939941,
0.1523490846157074,
-0.16541464626789093,
0.4858778715133667,
0.42734047770500183,
-0.17132289707660675,
0.7244020104408264,
-0.25766101479530334,
0.07387124747037888,
0.2609282433986664,
-0.19843430817127228,
-0.17381471395492554,
-0.22628511488437653,
-0.5876967310905457,
-0.28883522748947144,
0.08080503344535828,
0.5230218768119812,
-1.0832864046096802,
0.03988054767251015,
-0.4417557716369629,
-0.5909433364868164,
-0.7370783090591431,
0.17822237312793732,
0.21217407286167145,
0.9086822867393494,
0.8865572214126587,
0.47179368138313293,
-0.2003059834241867,
-0.8251020908355713,
-0.4284246861934662,
-0.07044149190187454,
-0.23968419432640076,
0.7423117756843567,
0.1263199746608734,
-0.47166404128074646,
1.1246412992477417,
-0.9613984227180481,
-0.06175069883465767,
-0.014045448042452335,
0.028836261481046677,
0.20187298953533173,
0.2628139853477478,
0.1422959864139557,
-1.056283950805664,
-0.29942867159843445,
0.17704243957996368,
-0.6499289870262146,
0.07020493596792221,
0.02820478565990925,
-0.31618383526802063,
-0.026866670697927475,
0.4130718410015106,
-0.6020380258560181,
0.02912129834294319,
0.4508077800273895,
-0.5905398726463318,
0.3590615391731262,
-0.17417535185813904,
0.2911398112773895,
-1.2092936038970947,
0.26075443625450134,
-0.0911303460597992,
-0.03347493335604668,
-0.544853925704956,
-0.08370628207921982,
0.6060307025909424,
-0.13673388957977295,
-0.631516695022583,
0.7089073061943054,
-0.3134753108024597,
0.17327338457107544,
-0.34308573603630066,
-0.015812689438462257,
0.2821294665336609,
0.6347793936729431,
0.27944695949554443,
1.1248420476913452,
0.07334662228822708,
-0.7432955503463745,
0.15660665929317474,
0.3353935182094574,
-0.09493967890739441,
0.6876152157783508,
-0.5343722701072693,
0.24478887021541595,
-0.14074721932411194,
-0.0006853372324258089,
-0.5715547800064087,
0.27018898725509644,
-0.19963237643241882,
0.018214799463748932,
0.1700306385755539,
-0.01708071120083332,
-0.5520195960998535,
-0.2391846626996994,
0.03639673441648483,
0.6077432036399841,
0.3219437301158905,
-0.8480764627456665,
1.291582465171814,
0.4655395448207855,
-0.03511806204915047,
-0.3483773171901703,
-0.7499037384986877,
-0.4428726136684418,
-0.11711382120847702,
-0.610168993473053,
0.5236641764640808,
-0.17261967062950134,
-0.056516122072935104,
0.24768970906734467,
-0.315515398979187,
-0.49315258860588074,
-0.2525606155395508,
0.016178378835320473,
0.26929032802581787,
-0.3511183261871338,
0.43974438309669495,
0.16785621643066406,
0.016133420169353485,
-0.12085609138011932,
-0.47613197565078735,
0.7567510008811951,
-0.35924553871154785,
-0.2263622134923935,
-0.1426624208688736,
0.3034420609474182,
0.6629486083984375,
-0.3193493187427521,
0.9848108291625977,
0.4859464764595032,
-0.55855393409729,
-0.04089270159602165,
-0.6769551038742065,
-0.39484575390815735,
-0.5002225637435913,
0.4938998222351074,
-0.6338716149330139,
-1.0440635681152344,
0.5580360889434814,
-0.24755090475082397,
0.06802254915237427,
0.7174086570739746,
0.4498290419578552,
-0.15632376074790955,
0.5537253022193909,
0.5438098311424255,
-0.16800640523433685,
0.48373785614967346,
-0.14367195963859558,
0.40164420008659363,
-0.9234763383865356,
-0.4071823060512543,
-0.4738599359989166,
-0.28967538475990295,
-0.04052996262907982,
-0.8310378789901733,
0.34762075543403625,
0.13086776435375214,
-0.15925371646881104,
0.5323932766914368,
-0.29524484276771545,
0.40170714259147644,
0.4478532671928406,
0.29425227642059326,
0.582205057144165,
-0.025437679141759872,
-0.05109342560172081,
-0.06962841749191284,
-0.8807561993598938,
-0.21299564838409424,
1.0409501791000366,
0.24409332871437073,
0.7366554737091064,
0.301017701625824,
-0.005838221870362759,
0.1712864190340042,
0.2423088401556015,
-0.5522814989089966,
0.20567885041236877,
-0.1458854377269745,
-0.6294953227043152,
-0.2346820831298828,
-0.5950285196304321,
-0.8076231479644775,
0.3069526255130768,
-0.11530224978923798,
-0.5232930183410645,
0.30227845907211304,
-0.034529466181993484,
-0.46751028299331665,
0.8115253448486328,
-0.7316268086433411,
0.46845072507858276,
0.11038611829280853,
-0.36252352595329285,
-0.3645951747894287,
-0.3083265721797943,
0.35726332664489746,
-0.2980180084705353,
-0.23761913180351257,
0.2738856077194214,
-0.048800960183143616,
0.70878666639328,
-0.20046395063400269,
0.2893799841403961,
-0.019509844481945038,
-0.13150063157081604,
0.46987462043762207,
-0.016303908079862595,
0.36678627133369446,
0.3993734121322632,
-0.23059029877185822,
0.2431185245513916,
0.010415562428534031,
-0.41928836703300476,
-0.8805181384086609,
0.5142500400543213,
-0.9083042144775391,
-0.3104918599128723,
-0.08079961687326431,
-1.1019483804702759,
-0.4261597990989685,
0.1937854140996933,
0.0958913266658783,
0.4916248619556427,
0.09648412466049194,
0.30741167068481445,
1.0592628717422485,
-0.15303659439086914,
0.4043480157852173,
0.9279507994651794,
-0.015657376497983932,
-0.2980091869831085,
1.2532358169555664,
0.1996598094701767,
0.2866733968257904,
0.702100932598114,
0.10097440332174301,
-0.41382312774658203,
-0.24085141718387604,
-0.3209836184978485,
0.27473536133766174,
-0.4445796608924866,
-0.318907767534256,
-1.219459056854248,
-0.4934528172016144,
-0.018612073734402657,
0.043579332530498505,
-0.7891641855239868,
-0.16075986623764038,
-0.31358709931373596,
0.05244852229952812,
0.3451816737651825,
0.2840399444103241,
0.2108311951160431,
0.35592326521873474,
-0.9315353035926819,
0.7858083844184875,
0.8292801976203918,
0.5096248388290405,
-0.06512600183486938,
-0.5727793574333191,
-0.36113524436950684,
-0.09143619239330292,
-0.1458200365304947,
-0.8381204605102539,
0.25397932529449463,
-0.13361147046089172,
0.3538912236690521,
0.26640698313713074,
-0.11108636111021042,
0.7032285332679749,
-0.667646586894989,
0.3535350263118744,
0.003383018309250474,
-0.7749136090278625,
0.33313682675361633,
-0.17110507190227509,
0.5036090016365051,
0.7009760141372681,
0.27578017115592957,
-0.5808236002922058,
-0.020120695233345032,
-0.5633395910263062,
-0.7869796752929688,
0.6401575207710266,
0.20797747373580933,
0.2378883808851242,
-0.10786615312099457,
0.34551817178726196,
0.14600808918476105,
0.34650206565856934,
-0.33790332078933716,
-0.30895060300827026,
-0.2179342359304428,
0.034383129328489304,
0.16619518399238586,
-0.24939116835594177,
-0.20147822797298431,
-0.2894520163536072,
0.6716467142105103,
-0.39706310629844666,
0.8279964923858643,
0.17753764986991882,
-0.46160510182380676,
0.0339435376226902,
0.254925936460495,
0.4611167013645172,
0.5527638792991638,
-0.29708734154701233,
0.3035753071308136,
0.14906573295593262,
-0.8939736485481262,
-0.07824643701314926,
0.39779186248779297,
-0.25351303815841675,
-0.0008597514242865145,
-0.11374333500862122,
0.7557565569877625,
0.20199009776115417,
-0.7190278768539429,
0.1880684345960617,
-0.4256218671798706,
0.010197517462074757,
0.07078230381011963,
-0.04114789143204689,
0.3491309583187103,
0.5812166333198547,
0.6061998605728149,
0.3666693866252899,
0.0875534638762474,
-0.529819130897522,
0.41627755761146545,
0.21765469014644623,
-0.5296425223350525,
-0.3708254396915436,
0.4621882140636444,
0.14828293025493622,
-0.19734275341033936,
0.843300461769104,
0.09670190513134003,
-0.36016976833343506,
0.28942248225212097,
0.8318318128585815,
0.4154401421546936,
-0.02796328254044056,
0.10636697709560394,
0.09765258431434631,
0.28956910967826843,
-0.012117594480514526,
0.5705668330192566,
-0.11267197132110596,
-1.059423804283142,
-0.33887577056884766,
-0.6607078909873962,
-0.44328662753105164,
-0.015837913379073143,
-0.5365563035011292,
-0.30997514724731445,
-0.22620372474193573,
0.14132970571517944,
-0.2164824903011322,
0.19847017526626587,
-0.650870680809021,
0.3330562710762024,
-0.2507956922054291,
0.9794563055038452,
-0.7353038787841797,
0.9270732998847961,
0.605481743812561,
-0.3440198004245758,
-0.9921255707740784,
0.08315785229206085,
-0.5087007880210876,
-0.5649713277816772,
0.4221210777759552,
-0.1555365025997162,
0.14595717191696167,
0.16511911153793335,
0.08182203024625778,
-0.9389644861221313,
1.2658236026763916,
0.5192306637763977,
-0.32529082894325256,
0.000735332490876317,
0.012614425271749496,
0.372154176235199,
0.07920818775892258,
0.6380727291107178,
0.4789748191833496,
0.48377737402915955,
0.10403311252593994,
-0.4630318582057953,
-0.020834732800722122,
-0.5330358147621155,
-0.21231508255004883,
0.46209803223609924,
-0.7675931453704834,
0.9763509631156921,
0.112291619181633,
-0.20872701704502106,
-0.4079393744468689,
1.3028678894042969,
0.5256270170211792,
0.15710410475730896,
0.3673023581504822,
0.6629945039749146,
1.0001909732818604,
-0.05485556647181511,
1.044148564338684,
-0.37968069314956665,
0.09606202691793442,
1.0790859460830688,
-0.112948939204216,
0.9531359076499939,
0.6124739050865173,
-0.23416142165660858,
0.6907466053962708,
-0.08195863664150238,
0.2569153904914856,
0.6321929693222046,
-0.14085261523723602,
-0.46209368109703064,
-0.0707838162779808,
-0.1402982771396637,
-0.2768828868865967,
0.14837710559368134,
0.27452778816223145,
-0.12936046719551086,
-0.16425268352031708,
-0.11843269318342209,
-0.13595838844776154,
0.20878183841705322,
-0.3120133876800537,
0.5803471207618713,
-0.10392328351736069,
-0.7993813157081604,
0.014660323970019817,
0.14611461758613586,
0.7943969964981079,
-0.6309508085250854,
-0.10873965919017792,
-0.1914711743593216,
0.1315782219171524,
-0.03996235132217407,
-0.7407647371292114,
0.6530565023422241,
-0.12455543875694275,
-0.7513757944107056,
-0.19537311792373657,
1.1334606409072876,
-0.6023768782615662,
-0.27555978298187256,
0.12307950109243393,
0.7102953195571899,
-0.23554053902626038,
-0.5925126671791077,
-0.3145831823348999,
-0.33847567439079285,
-0.32208457589149475,
-0.26051002740859985,
0.31004899740219116,
0.4704056978225708,
0.033469513058662415,
0.6512030363082886,
0.8094334602355957,
-0.07102479040622711,
0.3860720694065094,
-0.13204476237297058,
1.0902889966964722,
-0.6595775485038757,
-0.4296676218509674,
-0.6085730791091919,
0.4782719612121582,
-0.027807950973510742,
-0.1947048306465149,
0.5631198883056641,
0.8064271211624146,
0.4664056897163391,
-0.16026617586612701,
0.523750364780426,
-0.10273559391498566,
0.36402732133865356,
-0.47521892189979553,
0.8531526327133179,
-0.43653732538223267,
0.13222210109233856,
0.1361428052186966,
-0.8920252919197083,
0.12146288901567459,
0.4290751516819,
-0.27626681327819824,
-0.03115859627723694,
0.9388009309768677,
0.5409996509552002,
-0.2932497262954712,
0.2881031632423401,
0.28095003962516785,
0.05767586827278137,
0.2875104546546936,
0.6408299207687378,
0.6344015002250671,
-0.5962920784950256,
0.5480007529258728,
-0.2641211450099945,
0.25071898102760315,
0.11432884633541107,
-0.5594239234924316,
-0.7595052719116211,
-0.7079249620437622,
-0.13902509212493896,
-0.3620510697364807,
-0.06162811070680618,
0.23944593966007233,
0.8138546347618103,
-0.5910276174545288,
0.08094308525323868,
-0.21390259265899658,
0.18426771461963654,
-0.18021972477436066,
-0.2974091172218323,
0.4870455861091614,
-0.2629072666168213,
-0.7993189692497253,
0.5555310845375061,
0.5113108158111572,
-0.3482479751110077,
-0.1563134342432022,
-0.08635128289461136,
-0.5506577491760254,
0.402859091758728,
0.6021932363510132,
0.3732345700263977,
-0.1985313445329666,
-0.07532086223363876,
0.26586034893989563,
-0.44589871168136597,
0.21283598244190216,
0.7251237034797668,
-1.1813043355941772,
0.33002519607543945,
0.6785352826118469,
1.2909692525863647,
0.6508609056472778,
0.06107821688055992,
0.6448554396629333,
-0.48458436131477356,
-0.09939341247081757,
0.4501197338104248,
0.32256144285202026,
0.03300924599170685,
-0.5862314701080322,
0.4087287485599518,
0.35877829790115356,
-0.3971576988697052,
-0.34774118661880493,
-0.009414145722985268,
-0.9494290947914124,
-0.4981831908226013,
1.0960637331008911,
-0.03234177455306053,
-0.36065375804901123,
0.021585823968052864,
-0.1363174021244049,
0.4051337242126465,
-0.3487195670604706,
0.7974462509155273,
0.3820803165435791,
0.10619557648897171,
-0.15519215166568756,
-0.5037918090820312,
0.14997361600399017,
0.6508879661560059,
-1.2431228160858154,
-0.3344933092594147,
0.3712066113948822,
0.17295809090137482,
0.5206607580184937,
0.5451455116271973,
-0.19305989146232605,
0.2895909249782562,
-0.01586879789829254,
-0.0196024589240551,
-0.1251177340745926,
-0.5712745189666748,
-0.11446873843669891,
0.6234146356582642,
-0.5925419330596924,
-0.058886587619781494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04669v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04669v1
|
DiNeR: a Large Realistic Dataset for Evaluating Compositional Generalization
| 2024-06-07T06:35:21 | 2024-06-07T06:35:21 |
Chengang Hu, Xiao Liu, Yansong Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most of the existing compositional generalization datasets are
synthetically-generated, resulting in a lack of natural language variation.
While there have been recent attempts to introduce non-synthetic datasets for
compositional generalization, they suffer from either limited data scale or a
lack of diversity in the forms of combinations. To better investigate
compositional generalization with more linguistic phenomena and compositional
diversity, we propose the DIsh NamE Recognition (DiNeR) task and create a large
realistic Chinese dataset. Given a recipe instruction, models are required to
recognize the dish name composed of diverse combinations of food, actions, and
flavors. Our dataset consists of 3,811 dishes and 228,114 recipes, and involves
plenty of linguistic phenomena such as anaphora, omission and ambiguity. We
provide two strong baselines based on T5 and large language models (LLMs). This
work contributes a challenging task, baseline methods to tackle the task, and
insights into compositional generalization in the context of dish name
recognition. Code and data are available at https://github.com/Jumpy-pku/DiNeR.
|
[
-0.16751231253147125,
-0.7882608771324158,
0.5180270075798035,
0.27194443345069885,
0.05729673057794571,
-0.016243765130639076,
-0.5045324563980103,
-0.25835752487182617,
0.25591376423835754,
0.4693050980567932,
-0.46288806200027466,
-0.6078447699546814,
-0.581453800201416,
0.2945275604724884,
-0.36343055963516235,
0.5446473956108093,
-0.16798162460327148,
0.2078143209218979,
0.1240851953625679,
0.029765531420707703,
-0.7077634334564209,
-0.0031506712548434734,
-0.5862260460853577,
-0.24489644169807434,
0.5050327777862549,
0.5226534605026245,
0.34707364439964294,
0.8681269884109497,
0.2779306471347809,
0.4168556332588196,
0.09562727808952332,
0.4653686583042145,
-0.5367289185523987,
0.11596635729074478,
-0.007118637673556805,
-0.22292838990688324,
-0.001903122989460826,
-0.09252229332923889,
0.5612328052520752,
0.9527133107185364,
-0.09420648217201233,
-0.03702334314584732,
-0.28949645161628723,
0.6338312029838562,
-0.5740987062454224,
0.5020290017127991,
-0.4711192846298218,
0.16267432272434235,
0.009196215309202671,
0.4655112624168396,
-0.335243284702301,
-0.46830010414123535,
0.2954034209251404,
-0.7539038062095642,
0.034680988639593124,
-0.12449538707733154,
0.7990432381629944,
-0.019025059416890144,
-0.4716815650463104,
-0.39585667848587036,
-0.9931697845458984,
0.8451386094093323,
-0.6864407062530518,
0.27654722332954407,
0.422175794839859,
0.5952681303024292,
-0.20935887098312378,
-0.8978469967842102,
-0.6541619300842285,
-0.4153293967247009,
0.09930317103862762,
0.0955265536904335,
0.3087984621524811,
-0.26317670941352844,
0.055929817259311676,
0.7231242060661316,
-0.4851169288158417,
0.06354348361492157,
0.05474815517663956,
0.013375923968851566,
0.6716430187225342,
0.7527945637702942,
0.7162903547286987,
0.004866327624768019,
-0.29028066992759705,
-0.08199016749858856,
-0.28121379017829895,
0.2634829580783844,
0.003230899339541793,
0.5129116773605347,
-0.36890217661857605,
0.555095911026001,
-0.5358140468597412,
0.907558262348175,
-0.03014550544321537,
-0.03175666183233261,
0.39244452118873596,
-0.6661280393600464,
-0.23769071698188782,
-0.0036892446223646402,
0.7020481824874878,
0.5876018404960632,
0.4483884871006012,
-0.318661630153656,
-0.05951390042901039,
0.03664051368832588,
0.14684736728668213,
-0.58929443359375,
-0.5071967244148254,
0.23315924406051636,
-0.13504309952259064,
-0.1583116203546524,
0.5840505957603455,
-0.22646690905094147,
-0.5847142934799194,
-0.4700978398323059,
0.002994451206177473,
-0.5051256418228149,
-0.34912556409835815,
0.05854559689760208,
-0.501527726650238,
0.9666599631309509,
0.2190236747264862,
-1.0153279304504395,
0.23180854320526123,
0.8744458556175232,
0.7474427819252014,
-0.13178426027297974,
-0.33747681975364685,
-0.08378202468156815,
0.589754581451416,
-0.5900163054466248,
0.5251569151878357,
-0.7144790887832642,
-0.469323068857193,
-0.15412583947181702,
0.403408944606781,
-0.04252662509679794,
-0.7110942602157593,
0.4436344802379608,
-0.11796174198389053,
-0.07357116043567657,
-0.9667728543281555,
-0.8516058921813965,
-0.08575103431940079,
0.4338169991970062,
-1.0480093955993652,
0.5597395300865173,
0.30018097162246704,
-0.8328327536582947,
0.5925696492195129,
-0.17674438655376434,
-0.9216098189353943,
0.47290360927581787,
-0.24720655381679535,
-0.21324729919433594,
0.24718940258026123,
0.16904082894325256,
0.3868911564350128,
-0.05506090447306633,
0.23507946729660034,
-0.08077150583267212,
-0.6073303818702698,
0.33445805311203003,
-0.014275441877543926,
0.4612950086593628,
0.1366589367389679,
-0.012855646200478077,
-0.19849717617034912,
-0.6467377543449402,
-0.08671548962593079,
0.48403242230415344,
-0.5124587416648865,
-0.5921655893325806,
0.19521407783031464,
0.0987592488527298,
-0.4468134045600891,
0.32958996295928955,
-0.5769241452217102,
0.15418750047683716,
-0.6108015179634094,
0.5251787900924683,
0.6743577122688293,
-0.08511549234390259,
0.48987463116645813,
-0.6500576138496399,
0.15935109555721283,
0.14622510969638824,
-0.059145744889974594,
-0.2210526466369629,
-0.42638787627220154,
-0.7552843689918518,
-0.36118438839912415,
0.5896967053413391,
0.6967621445655823,
-1.077396273612976,
0.5142890810966492,
-0.3997761905193329,
-0.503464937210083,
-0.02987070381641388,
-0.35737210512161255,
0.20473547279834747,
0.4363196790218353,
0.1663806289434433,
-0.27271604537963867,
-0.8946316242218018,
-0.8776562809944153,
-0.15392252802848816,
0.398448646068573,
-0.31911948323249817,
0.5385608673095703,
0.03782434016466141,
-0.17272038757801056,
0.9768595099449158,
-0.7816534638404846,
-0.36129307746887207,
-0.6165569424629211,
-0.17599356174468994,
0.45171505212783813,
0.37832334637641907,
0.36973220109939575,
-0.5062232613563538,
-0.9417100548744202,
0.3623424172401428,
-0.7677220702171326,
0.252930611371994,
0.13358403742313385,
0.1022159680724144,
-0.24507176876068115,
0.2400488257408142,
-0.43803781270980835,
-0.06080753728747368,
0.375813752412796,
-0.09455177187919617,
0.6273990273475647,
0.003794315969571471,
-0.003572735469788313,
-1.4909753799438477,
-0.07589811831712723,
0.05963277444243431,
0.059829551726579666,
-0.7678094506263733,
0.08503090590238571,
-0.08108437061309814,
-0.10607004910707474,
-0.380634069442749,
0.6592426300048828,
-0.5614060759544373,
0.061948131769895554,
-0.09544891864061356,
-0.4252548813819885,
-0.15963120758533478,
0.31064125895500183,
0.23466795682907104,
0.6674529314041138,
0.5626380443572998,
-0.48186737298965454,
0.8745485544204712,
0.004461892880499363,
-0.7202535271644592,
0.33900317549705505,
-0.6840075254440308,
-0.21782800555229187,
-0.08986618369817734,
0.3616873621940613,
-1.3707616329193115,
-0.7157642841339111,
0.38497158885002136,
0.0259371530264616,
-0.024566473439335823,
0.1563287079334259,
-0.3698425590991974,
-0.3847542405128479,
-0.2419954538345337,
0.4161588251590729,
0.10967686027288437,
-0.38254237174987793,
0.7634314894676208,
0.361025869846344,
-0.05582282319664955,
-0.3702528476715088,
-0.6507633328437805,
0.43951600790023804,
-0.1306552290916443,
-0.4035167992115021,
0.32710179686546326,
0.043366942554712296,
-0.21101082861423492,
-0.28281018137931824,
-0.13551709055900574,
-0.23452982306480408,
-0.13348263502120972,
0.11479164659976959,
0.003355437656864524,
-0.13262389600276947,
-0.09411222487688065,
-0.208848774433136,
0.15572041273117065,
0.0684121772646904,
-0.08011095225811005,
0.733207643032074,
-0.16953805088996887,
0.45566079020500183,
-0.4896145761013031,
0.2266625165939331,
0.2196711152791977,
-0.09442295879125595,
0.5048003196716309,
0.5603415369987488,
-0.3682244122028351,
-0.5957992076873779,
-0.268479585647583,
0.13185010850429535,
-0.5259135961532593,
0.33301740884780884,
-0.6198925971984863,
-0.41469186544418335,
0.8662579655647278,
0.09976164996623993,
0.05902203544974327,
0.07747502624988556,
0.41626307368278503,
-0.0848720595240593,
0.43328747153282166,
-0.023071421310305595,
-0.20431065559387207,
0.537844717502594,
-0.2748714089393616,
-0.017032558098435402,
-0.6653451323509216,
-0.2425835132598877,
-0.33948802947998047,
-0.49258676171302795,
-0.5995577573776245,
-0.541752278804779,
0.1279812753200531,
-1.1271312236785889,
-0.22970734536647797,
0.5215203762054443,
-0.42002564668655396,
1.1429667472839355,
0.3995162844657898,
0.46005693078041077,
0.3566603362560272,
-0.26317647099494934,
-0.38059189915657043,
0.023628730326890945,
-0.13297538459300995,
-0.12660542130470276,
0.8929652571678162,
-0.08046498894691467,
0.8389567732810974,
0.09299148619174957,
0.7683420181274414,
0.6022855043411255,
-0.06682109087705612,
-0.9503262042999268,
0.6275086402893066,
-0.7982610464096069,
-0.3083128035068512,
-0.5263662934303284,
-0.8309017419815063,
-1.0640015602111816,
0.31541839241981506,
0.15317271649837494,
-0.13335828483104706,
-0.06453283131122589,
-0.29581689834594727,
-0.010606887750327587,
0.02046223171055317,
-0.7302576303482056,
0.8651890754699707,
-0.40054047107696533,
0.03450469672679901,
0.6133844256401062,
-0.6297348141670227,
0.5741451382637024,
0.19730828702449799,
0.30026698112487793,
-0.03728789836168289,
-0.025184448808431625,
0.27955493330955505,
-0.3784137964248657,
1.020585060119629,
-0.15088170766830444,
-0.22897416353225708,
-0.12677590548992157,
0.23857341706752777,
0.4326878786087036,
0.10568303614854813,
0.032521218061447144,
0.022983698174357414,
-0.16282767057418823,
-0.24614708125591278,
-0.39685750007629395,
0.9163866639137268,
-0.923881471157074,
-0.1105123907327652,
-0.19877250492572784,
-0.6772152185440063,
-0.16140812635421753,
0.44412317872047424,
0.34700438380241394,
0.12355281412601471,
-0.7029508352279663,
0.07963497936725616,
0.5384562611579895,
-0.13166941702365875,
0.3224570155143738,
0.29313528537750244,
-0.04158710688352585,
-0.5291454195976257,
1.281607985496521,
0.23819398880004883,
-0.16757890582084656,
0.39519748091697693,
0.34028688073158264,
-0.06142732873558998,
-0.2658980190753937,
-0.36338409781455994,
0.18799448013305664,
-0.47855982184410095,
0.04020981118083,
-0.3698769509792328,
-0.30805525183677673,
-0.11848030239343643,
-0.12808550894260406,
-0.5077096819877625,
-0.24212831258773804,
-0.34986212849617004,
0.0201739352196455,
-0.4515626132488251,
0.7628341913223267,
0.421233594417572,
0.21715815365314484,
-0.5083439350128174,
0.5629704594612122,
0.4363807439804077,
0.33675360679626465,
0.24974562227725983,
-0.20150597393512726,
-0.29123762249946594,
0.15680360794067383,
-0.09257297217845917,
-0.7547524571418762,
0.2705138325691223,
0.5260553359985352,
0.6891651153564453,
0.7746868133544922,
0.1263817697763443,
0.34690430760383606,
-0.4323040246963501,
0.786397397518158,
0.1858559399843216,
-0.9746575951576233,
0.16033069789409637,
-0.4936552345752716,
0.5125718712806702,
0.6031969785690308,
0.2683984935283661,
-0.7668801546096802,
-0.3553999364376068,
-0.06584953516721725,
-0.9909361600875854,
0.42937055230140686,
-0.06465432047843933,
0.4364050626754761,
-0.20344841480255127,
0.28130248188972473,
0.37142229080200195,
0.06314221024513245,
-0.9296910762786865,
-0.0404278039932251,
-0.3300822377204895,
-0.24732908606529236,
0.08317570388317108,
0.1240195631980896,
-0.07229731231927872,
-0.5064143538475037,
0.29872527718544006,
0.11259768903255463,
-0.025866026058793068,
-0.32565557956695557,
0.08813120424747467,
-0.006206550169736147,
0.04686540737748146,
0.5772798657417297,
0.5395663976669312,
-0.027239136397838593,
0.03241514414548874,
0.12769204378128052,
-0.37690386176109314,
0.20693838596343994,
-0.3365706503391266,
-0.052212074398994446,
-0.09415408223867416,
0.4712037444114685,
0.5407183766365051,
0.12717804312705994,
-0.7119928598403931,
0.48007893562316895,
-0.450726717710495,
-0.22642961144447327,
-0.5347521901130676,
0.306037038564682,
0.3163086771965027,
0.13736015558242798,
0.0670623779296875,
-0.5823813676834106,
0.3428974747657776,
-0.6019041538238525,
0.08826106041669846,
0.41323116421699524,
0.06778322160243988,
-0.2766720652580261,
0.13158273696899414,
0.20783056318759918,
0.10756272077560425,
1.122111439704895,
-0.096110038459301,
-0.3559955954551697,
1.067919373512268,
0.44609934091567993,
0.8374332785606384,
-0.4400359094142914,
0.4567393660545349,
0.4753471910953522,
0.05743667855858803,
-0.2175203114748001,
0.2766006290912628,
-0.06357338279485703,
-0.9661983847618103,
-0.2991386950016022,
-0.5892333388328552,
-0.5687274932861328,
0.1922800987958908,
-0.4387531578540802,
0.2513430416584015,
-0.6751614809036255,
-0.10083132982254028,
0.053505346179008484,
-0.20849403738975525,
-0.46624115109443665,
0.11184021085500717,
0.43748942017555237,
0.5596988201141357,
-1.0812323093414307,
0.576980471611023,
1.079290747642517,
-0.14597676694393158,
-0.9299479126930237,
0.15755487978458405,
-0.2954983115196228,
-0.9154590964317322,
0.5242045521736145,
0.4309294819831848,
0.25591832399368286,
-0.4040398597717285,
-0.7218694686889648,
-0.6840435266494751,
0.8923338651657104,
0.07900448888540268,
-0.45689135789871216,
-0.4309239387512207,
0.6002660989761353,
0.6652690172195435,
-0.5378258228302002,
-0.036284249275922775,
0.6804907917976379,
0.893333911895752,
0.8151857256889343,
-0.7786098122596741,
0.09634731709957123,
-0.08499950170516968,
0.4464433491230011,
-0.06859240680932999,
-0.6997451186180115,
1.1769083738327026,
-0.20952333509922028,
-0.30090782046318054,
0.2959865927696228,
0.4305829107761383,
0.08124786615371704,
0.43667176365852356,
0.16308224201202393,
0.9038626551628113,
0.5500409007072449,
-0.4267713725566864,
0.7593979835510254,
0.057256102561950684,
0.30569541454315186,
1.2425755262374878,
-0.6075149774551392,
0.3465995192527771,
0.21061629056930542,
-0.3279361128807068,
0.39187467098236084,
0.9349291920661926,
-0.5640857815742493,
0.8658437132835388,
0.6880843043327332,
-0.02404545433819294,
-0.1994953453540802,
-0.17933182418346405,
-0.5328413844108582,
0.9330617189407349,
0.3712605834007263,
-0.49913766980171204,
-0.31090015172958374,
-0.08547478914260864,
-0.12920236587524414,
-0.1550166755914688,
-0.0015333842020481825,
1.1666556596755981,
-0.001815525465644896,
-0.4508039951324463,
0.6233295798301697,
0.2134876400232315,
0.21038559079170227,
-0.4839533567428589,
-0.13261471688747406,
-0.5722427368164062,
0.06414300203323364,
-0.12512315809726715,
-0.6587421894073486,
0.07522361725568771,
-0.5839388966560364,
-0.20653797686100006,
0.4240806996822357,
0.10398295521736145,
-0.40236711502075195,
-0.6673528552055359,
-0.012651104480028152,
0.2336748242378235,
-0.14801743626594543,
0.041909556835889816,
-0.30407261848449707,
0.2758748531341553,
-0.15597042441368103,
0.027205126360058784,
0.03707920014858246,
0.5337249636650085,
0.18370209634304047,
0.38046425580978394,
0.37479308247566223,
0.1863451898097992,
0.10512704402208328,
0.05808263644576073,
1.0593773126602173,
-0.7284823656082153,
-0.8959441781044006,
-0.74709552526474,
0.3144207298755646,
0.05632440745830536,
0.04350520297884941,
0.6104285717010498,
0.6251099705696106,
0.9554581642150879,
-0.5751494765281677,
0.9722179174423218,
-0.20148497819900513,
0.1620088815689087,
-0.47810882329940796,
0.3781554400920868,
-0.6381763815879822,
0.27963340282440186,
-0.33660659193992615,
-1.2237626314163208,
-0.23283369839191437,
0.5516910552978516,
-0.37046363949775696,
0.2718506455421448,
0.3144526183605194,
0.49116694927215576,
-0.34310734272003174,
0.22292031347751617,
0.40713635087013245,
0.351601243019104,
0.18790887296199799,
0.7802071571350098,
1.2301642894744873,
-0.15938693284988403,
-0.011184866540133953,
-0.06806990504264832,
-0.19931647181510925,
-0.21558041870594025,
-0.6996164321899414,
-0.7064940333366394,
-0.5711665153503418,
0.1963014155626297,
-0.02894808165729046,
0.12059155106544495,
0.7258211374282837,
0.6831375360488892,
-0.9843140244483948,
-0.538091242313385,
-0.10240716487169266,
0.04025369510054588,
-0.5192692279815674,
-0.284979909658432,
0.19052425026893616,
-0.2916734218597412,
-0.881088376045227,
0.4477511942386627,
-0.08355424553155899,
-0.09258554875850677,
0.03797521814703941,
0.0022360801231116056,
0.05590135231614113,
0.3177216649055481,
0.6575084328651428,
0.29963305592536926,
-0.7347678542137146,
-0.08221831172704697,
-0.2631460130214691,
-0.02827702835202217,
0.1215171068906784,
0.7881650328636169,
-0.25267934799194336,
0.5713070631027222,
0.42977768182754517,
0.7253510355949402,
0.19879305362701416,
0.30926966667175293,
0.54556804895401,
-1.0701180696487427,
-0.2922433316707611,
0.021550355479121208,
0.3686716854572296,
0.2994306683540344,
-0.27446669340133667,
0.4376782178878784,
0.27946737408638,
-0.4159354865550995,
-0.4618154466152191,
0.44140365719795227,
-1.2573024034500122,
-0.4954482913017273,
1.15598726272583,
-0.09349039942026138,
-0.13652899861335754,
-0.0583353191614151,
-0.08926998823881149,
0.2523958683013916,
-0.47446438670158386,
0.9893062710762024,
0.8928998112678528,
-0.02675401046872139,
-0.08088120818138123,
-0.1495928019285202,
0.17330870032310486,
-0.1210438683629036,
-0.8315014243125916,
0.299632728099823,
0.8050421476364136,
0.6856566667556763,
-0.19563889503479004,
0.2526262104511261,
0.17196840047836304,
0.2141646444797516,
-0.1584477722644806,
0.005380935035645962,
-0.3205423057079315,
-0.4311320185661316,
0.15822389721870422,
0.27605974674224854,
-0.04752672463655472,
-0.19146133959293365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04643v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04643v1
|
More Victories, Less Cooperation: Assessing Cicero's Diplomacy Play
| 2024-06-07T05:03:44 | 2024-06-07T05:03:44 |
Wichayaporn Wongkamjan, Feng Gu, Yanze Wang, Ulf Hermjakob, Jonathan May, Brandon M. Stewart, Jonathan K. Kummerfeld, Denis Peskoff, Jordan Lee Boyd-Graber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The boardgame Diplomacy is a challenging setting for communicative and
cooperative artificial intelligence. The most prominent communicative Diplomacy
AI, Cicero, has excellent strategic abilities, exceeding human players.
However, the best Diplomacy players master communication, not just tactics,
which is why the game has received attention as an AI challenge. This work
seeks to understand the degree to which Cicero succeeds at communication.
First, we annotate in-game communication with abstract meaning representation
to separate in-game tactics from general language. Second, we run two dozen
games with humans and Cicero, totaling over 200 human-player hours of
competition. While AI can consistently outplay human players, AI-Human
communication is still limited because of AI's difficulty with deception and
persuasion. This shows that Cicero relies on strategy and has not yet reached
the full promise of communicative and cooperative AI.
|
[
-0.7753934860229492,
-0.6164133548736572,
0.6782585978507996,
0.4680316746234894,
0.09986501932144165,
0.2096225470304489,
-0.4622308313846588,
-0.5801148414611816,
0.3946293294429779,
0.06348433345556259,
-0.4455503821372986,
-0.5265687704086304,
-0.7156398296356201,
0.38991814851760864,
0.1346159130334854,
0.8634942770004272,
0.1751149296760559,
-0.050994690507650375,
-0.38401302695274353,
-0.35273706912994385,
-0.48833125829696655,
-0.28176039457321167,
-1.0151530504226685,
-1.026288628578186,
0.298911988735199,
0.8610820174217224,
0.7065274715423584,
0.5789821743965149,
0.5953986644744873,
0.4571397304534912,
-0.08532484620809555,
0.09681326150894165,
-0.7690809369087219,
0.03347405418753624,
-0.38231202960014343,
-0.7268263101577759,
-0.32032355666160583,
0.6212134957313538,
0.6360778212547302,
0.43235814571380615,
-0.0942310094833374,
-0.009416778571903706,
-0.2653287649154663,
0.6046342849731445,
-0.18253585696220398,
0.38423067331314087,
-0.5163707733154297,
-0.149235337972641,
-0.19328705966472626,
0.16001202166080475,
-0.4948900640010834,
-0.03435182943940163,
0.2987285256385803,
-1.331606388092041,
-0.4763457179069519,
0.326907753944397,
0.7583219408988953,
0.026526907458901405,
-0.3930921256542206,
-0.3959736227989197,
-0.8875113129615784,
0.7714866995811462,
-0.18299682438373566,
-0.3926997780799866,
0.5475280284881592,
0.28501227498054504,
-0.608164370059967,
-0.3516654670238495,
-0.7705168128013611,
-0.4375282824039459,
-0.06081128492951393,
0.4959253668785095,
-0.5670448541641235,
0.26329275965690613,
0.4427929222583771,
-0.09066811203956604,
-0.2804921865463257,
-0.18450258672237396,
-0.4882705807685852,
0.1693863570690155,
0.9182584881782532,
0.2677987813949585,
0.1680256575345993,
0.05006829649209976,
-0.5660365223884583,
-0.4425129294395447,
-0.3301123082637787,
0.1892455667257309,
0.2934519052505493,
-0.4152662754058838,
-0.4301009178161621,
0.46275556087493896,
0.0009640930802561343,
0.5144433975219727,
0.014027798548340797,
0.1260150969028473,
-0.5625697374343872,
-0.1265232414007187,
-0.08888982981443405,
0.008500082418322563,
0.9138649702072144,
0.5561604499816895,
0.31728729605674744,
-0.2688291370868683,
-0.025713186711072922,
0.6812196969985962,
0.20501480996608734,
-0.4020400643348694,
-0.31704792380332947,
0.038784466683864594,
-0.47155696153640747,
-0.0343017615377903,
0.3520761728286743,
-0.6100925803184509,
-0.2680225670337677,
0.10982776433229446,
0.4609150290489197,
-0.36922454833984375,
-0.0670892596244812,
-0.1538688838481903,
-0.7395464181900024,
0.6137592196464539,
0.30860063433647156,
-0.8889167308807373,
0.6205776333808899,
1.1543952226638794,
0.6862831711769104,
-0.3492783010005951,
-0.34136930108070374,
-0.7422334551811218,
0.1730889528989792,
-0.7878732681274414,
0.6970258951187134,
-0.5770630836486816,
-0.8445582389831543,
-0.31908848881721497,
-0.6780881881713867,
-0.15941576659679413,
-0.517305850982666,
0.4992723762989044,
0.03682650998234749,
0.0065791187807917595,
-0.38143450021743774,
-0.6875674724578857,
0.29850316047668457,
0.6501646041870117,
-0.5660164952278137,
0.43947604298591614,
-0.19167335331439972,
-0.49749213457107544,
0.2150423526763916,
-0.7490008473396301,
-0.6332523822784424,
0.24675311148166656,
-0.5404080152511597,
-0.10524912923574448,
0.2901553809642792,
-0.4748400151729584,
-0.030690787360072136,
-0.4601494371891022,
0.07451359182596207,
-0.22766810655593872,
-0.8705358505249023,
0.47734081745147705,
-0.12041647732257843,
0.5552327632904053,
-0.1231875941157341,
-0.7668818831443787,
0.06244046613574028,
-0.5521863698959351,
-0.1887839138507843,
-0.08091627061367035,
-0.5084423422813416,
-0.24519775807857513,
0.210245281457901,
-0.3910099267959595,
0.14706376194953918,
-0.014111977070569992,
-0.7734917402267456,
0.5179845094680786,
-0.5194621682167053,
0.361208975315094,
0.5350061655044556,
-0.26304224133491516,
0.7991040945053101,
-0.9993852376937866,
0.257769376039505,
-0.5808749794960022,
0.4261641800403595,
0.21829016506671906,
-1.0415334701538086,
-0.9179602265357971,
-0.06017785519361496,
-0.04286147281527519,
0.7940965890884399,
-0.8521804213523865,
0.06918033212423325,
-0.5944277048110962,
-0.7340933680534363,
-0.651164710521698,
-0.1987619251012802,
0.6350310444831848,
0.17381112277507782,
0.20890478789806366,
-0.3999265730381012,
-0.176269993185997,
-0.6603293418884277,
-0.24238485097885132,
-0.9077451229095459,
0.354662150144577,
0.6343953609466553,
0.6284665465354919,
-0.09041184931993484,
0.535453200340271,
0.13865597546100616,
-0.4796377420425415,
-0.6026307940483093,
0.48810574412345886,
0.13928478956222534,
0.6345019340515137,
0.18486393988132477,
-0.5981470346450806,
-0.5545160174369812,
0.2061241865158081,
-0.8035580515861511,
0.6451018452644348,
-0.28278568387031555,
-0.18668797612190247,
0.153323695063591,
0.5068174004554749,
-0.8982449769973755,
0.8627212047576904,
0.40350013971328735,
-0.36715394258499146,
0.4287673830986023,
-0.520255446434021,
0.420071542263031,
-0.46116918325424194,
0.12002044171094894,
-0.3138643503189087,
0.05206404998898506,
-0.7314972281455994,
0.1256217658519745,
-0.6289110779762268,
-0.025737658143043518,
-0.17986774444580078,
0.6861417293548584,
-0.3054785132408142,
-0.20567449927330017,
-0.07572352886199951,
0.5996747016906738,
0.03768691048026085,
0.18246880173683167,
0.3266873061656952,
0.4477826654911041,
0.19174985587596893,
-0.6262686252593994,
0.7085261344909668,
0.5989767909049988,
-0.18709798157215118,
1.120314121246338,
-0.9186302423477173,
0.201451376080513,
-0.019485576078295708,
0.31450945138931274,
-1.119126558303833,
-0.0028954085428267717,
0.4920603930950165,
-0.6763466596603394,
0.08366028964519501,
0.07825887948274612,
0.0018641507485881448,
-0.14188125729560852,
-0.3494766652584076,
0.20418687164783478,
0.16683442890644073,
-0.2223253697156906,
0.9882780909538269,
0.07263964414596558,
0.13576973974704742,
-0.6000410914421082,
-0.6901472210884094,
0.4981239140033722,
-0.29581326246261597,
-0.7104963660240173,
0.43463456630706787,
-0.3669963479042053,
-0.9850921630859375,
-0.19877345860004425,
0.11455010622739792,
0.16127896308898926,
0.3114605247974396,
0.29823148250579834,
0.09787830710411072,
-0.05302974581718445,
-0.15404918789863586,
-0.330217182636261,
-0.35877174139022827,
0.20525866746902466,
-0.06984143704175949,
0.30650007724761963,
-0.2531870901584625,
-0.25039511919021606,
-0.9133460521697998,
0.7126480340957642,
0.5349911451339722,
0.06591399013996124,
1.0255831480026245,
0.5312981009483337,
0.028797730803489685,
0.20473520457744598,
-0.4661140441894531,
-0.1507244110107422,
-0.39512309432029724,
-0.01628190465271473,
-0.518488883972168,
-0.33820080757141113,
0.5086591839790344,
-0.05489681288599968,
0.2575979232788086,
0.31723564863204956,
-0.10640718787908554,
-0.3109601140022278,
0.6633216738700867,
0.4990532100200653,
-0.36265814304351807,
0.1466006189584732,
-0.36638161540031433,
-0.1570248305797577,
-0.5091614127159119,
-0.6015610098838806,
-0.701674222946167,
-0.6279502511024475,
-0.9419591426849365,
-0.13401161134243011,
0.4855107367038727,
-0.28246602416038513,
-0.4605275094509125,
0.2434290647506714,
-0.40508338809013367,
0.2236333042383194,
1.0880969762802124,
-0.14283406734466553,
0.3654366731643677,
-0.3291768431663513,
0.25660181045532227,
-0.10370628535747528,
-0.9059732556343079,
-0.3794631063938141,
0.6402868032455444,
0.09510983526706696,
0.8281030058860779,
0.6307777166366577,
1.133817195892334,
0.3213604986667633,
0.559457004070282,
-0.4782814383506775,
0.5281721949577332,
0.16260558366775513,
-0.5571181178092957,
-0.5945165157318115,
-0.4573194682598114,
-1.1376794576644897,
-0.0536155104637146,
-0.9057652950286865,
-0.5568056702613831,
0.13695581257343292,
-0.044602952897548676,
-0.4805212616920471,
-0.04564323648810387,
-0.5466136336326599,
1.0725778341293335,
-0.09305645525455475,
-0.37382376194000244,
-0.4813098609447479,
-0.8964134454727173,
0.061913277953863144,
0.7408354878425598,
0.3055877685546875,
0.12441108375787735,
-0.25740817189216614,
0.6679444313049316,
0.2668203115463257,
0.5056716203689575,
0.20011121034622192,
0.3501366674900055,
0.15235655009746552,
0.08101370185613632,
0.47015559673309326,
0.39588242769241333,
0.011640377342700958,
-0.1531485617160797,
0.1103937104344368,
-0.6855819225311279,
-0.5384196639060974,
0.5478255152702332,
-1.1201096773147583,
-0.7407096028327942,
-0.9540542364120483,
-0.07138454914093018,
0.20784059166908264,
-0.14755447208881378,
0.6920585036277771,
0.05600132420659065,
-1.024849772453308,
-0.06674351543188095,
0.6905738115310669,
-0.34516456723213196,
0.5848694443702698,
0.2110424041748047,
0.11645437777042389,
-0.49442750215530396,
1.1567213535308838,
-0.2981928586959839,
0.2801002264022827,
0.5407953262329102,
0.053732678294181824,
-0.1687801033258438,
-0.20448040962219238,
-0.5868914127349854,
0.27986806631088257,
-0.35124075412750244,
-0.0333859920501709,
0.05536353215575218,
0.27265653014183044,
-0.11593279987573624,
-0.1391262412071228,
-0.31161972880363464,
-0.15121790766716003,
-0.2365119457244873,
0.23509474098682404,
-0.13126645982265472,
1.5276981592178345,
-0.3070681095123291,
0.6177748441696167,
-0.34476450085639954,
0.10434240847826004,
0.39363422989845276,
0.013230222277343273,
-0.3124651610851288,
0.01422515045851469,
0.18249745666980743,
-0.00546974828466773,
-0.12235524505376816,
-1.1815911531448364,
-0.06913456320762634,
0.38478201627731323,
0.5512662529945374,
0.6504828333854675,
0.14578458666801453,
0.6149032115936279,
-0.04901012405753136,
0.7968745231628418,
0.058876413851976395,
-1.0394405126571655,
0.2542683184146881,
-0.2474556416273117,
0.13667814433574677,
0.5711520314216614,
-0.0006818466354161501,
-0.5527747273445129,
-0.3084123432636261,
-1.0682158470153809,
-0.5289298295974731,
0.5912977457046509,
0.29621249437332153,
-0.03609617426991463,
-0.16122666001319885,
0.33253607153892517,
-0.34834468364715576,
0.18022672832012177,
-0.5642164945602417,
-0.5459684133529663,
0.1793268620967865,
0.2376507669687271,
-0.55446857213974,
0.06713300943374634,
-0.6740316152572632,
-0.18411260843276978,
0.5719794034957886,
0.32430246472358704,
0.47880905866622925,
0.40895941853523254,
0.06170845031738281,
0.0811324417591095,
0.33858248591423035,
1.0474741458892822,
0.39093804359436035,
0.20901218056678772,
0.112454853951931,
0.10712972283363342,
-0.17937861382961273,
0.22508502006530762,
0.3276970088481903,
0.05567672848701477,
0.06375671178102493,
0.9244276285171509,
0.6467574238777161,
0.1550096571445465,
-0.5641010403633118,
0.5787897109985352,
-0.712773323059082,
-0.19677813351154327,
-0.5136574506759644,
0.19922301173210144,
-0.006894586142152548,
0.4695001542568207,
0.3926547169685364,
0.14524929225444794,
-0.04680413752794266,
-0.8828080892562866,
0.21038943529129028,
0.8569548726081848,
-0.2335657775402069,
-0.054820261895656586,
0.6191712617874146,
0.48130497336387634,
-0.570364773273468,
0.6806652545928955,
-0.7752020955085754,
-0.443410724401474,
0.5719172954559326,
0.15724465250968933,
0.08792807906866074,
-0.06282613426446915,
0.6007153391838074,
0.006894843187183142,
0.5916488170623779,
-0.03868027776479721,
0.05369636416435242,
-0.26570284366607666,
-0.47496888041496277,
-0.3830578923225403,
0.03113262541592121,
-0.6686723232269287,
-0.011131539940834045,
-0.6493879556655884,
-0.23454168438911438,
-0.7101996541023254,
-0.4679453372955322,
-0.10172052681446075,
0.7168708443641663,
-0.6699617505073547,
-0.2445138841867447,
0.002527758711948991,
1.030569314956665,
-0.6798264980316162,
0.2932572066783905,
0.6913911700248718,
-0.3233816623687744,
-0.6075805425643921,
-0.38008221983909607,
-0.2396850734949112,
-0.39611896872520447,
0.6662176251411438,
0.020031306892633438,
-0.09146121889352798,
0.061985548585653305,
-0.48138901591300964,
-0.286219984292984,
0.7949804663658142,
0.4326590597629547,
-0.3487843871116638,
0.13472138345241547,
-0.07993017882108688,
0.4994237422943115,
-0.5025109052658081,
0.5569059252738953,
0.7991855144500732,
0.9456053376197815,
-0.1599755734205246,
-0.9373851418495178,
-0.41051143407821655,
-0.3542574346065521,
-0.1094762310385704,
-0.2311554104089737,
-0.7878569960594177,
0.5256693363189697,
-0.3300173282623291,
-0.27224966883659363,
0.7551281452178955,
1.161906123161316,
0.07010748982429504,
0.7658287286758423,
0.20182795822620392,
0.5082001090049744,
0.4628303349018097,
-0.5320304036140442,
0.9186901450157166,
-0.07440849393606186,
-0.23820878565311432,
0.7768886089324951,
-0.13765880465507507,
0.705327570438385,
0.3237246572971344,
0.20414462685585022,
0.6302420496940613,
0.3217666745185852,
0.2610050141811371,
0.06316728889942169,
0.4185419976711273,
-0.40569451451301575,
-0.30772289633750916,
-0.2285342961549759,
0.009089227765798569,
0.9002965688705444,
0.4205071032047272,
0.2534545660018921,
0.1562201976776123,
0.03344873711466789,
0.2948840260505676,
0.6413947343826294,
-0.0814337506890297,
1.143843650817871,
-0.12261506170034409,
-1.2276480197906494,
0.3307058811187744,
0.008941767737269402,
0.5463571548461914,
-0.2303280085325241,
-0.41284650564193726,
-0.3082071542739868,
0.21904031932353973,
0.22264406085014343,
-0.48125457763671875,
0.06461120396852493,
-0.4795885682106018,
0.2456476390361786,
0.13289475440979004,
0.13495326042175293,
-0.5498296022415161,
0.09668035060167313,
0.4011629521846771,
0.47606757283210754,
0.3215014338493347,
0.20086067914962769,
-0.656353235244751,
0.7015497088432312,
-0.3319600224494934,
0.2532219886779785,
0.07405122369527817,
0.3812441825866699,
0.17447514832019806,
0.7127676606178284,
0.29455453157424927,
0.3862331509590149,
-0.26887837052345276,
-0.5592842102050781,
0.5816627144813538,
-0.4632713198661804,
-0.4301322102546692,
-0.9660674333572388,
0.16581813991069794,
-0.6731516718864441,
-0.45607489347457886,
0.6195048689842224,
0.5595691204071045,
0.5814017057418823,
0.18354175984859467,
0.7281044721603394,
-0.22856034338474274,
-0.19116918742656708,
-0.09028199315071106,
0.5233415365219116,
-0.03795189410448074,
-0.017622994258999825,
-0.179022416472435,
-0.6000264286994934,
0.09785757958889008,
1.1314024925231934,
-0.1072005182504654,
-0.11511168628931046,
0.3094750642776489,
0.2456405907869339,
0.35273683071136475,
0.0989445149898529,
0.3996787667274475,
0.1069270595908165,
0.3185328543186188,
1.0582032203674316,
1.0824668407440186,
-0.2935912013053894,
0.6780377626419067,
0.1012965589761734,
-0.6229699850082397,
-0.15469950437545776,
-0.574144721031189,
-1.3227428197860718,
-0.7364585399627686,
0.14201849699020386,
-0.5653772354125977,
0.5497274398803711,
0.9467817544937134,
0.7370061874389648,
-0.21462732553482056,
-0.6615822315216064,
0.03127609193325043,
0.4934161603450775,
-0.48418524861335754,
-0.10356743633747101,
-0.01776399090886116,
0.07084502279758453,
-0.9686452746391296,
0.5819120407104492,
0.29573747515678406,
-0.027683425694704056,
-0.15433554351329803,
-0.555000364780426,
-0.23194463551044464,
0.26637688279151917,
0.305580735206604,
0.9288339614868164,
-0.5433194637298584,
-0.1716858297586441,
0.13579519093036652,
-0.13586071133613586,
-0.15347795188426971,
0.7731466293334961,
-0.5276963710784912,
0.3878267705440521,
0.3595006763935089,
0.41574302315711975,
0.5331904888153076,
0.23497498035430908,
0.9076926112174988,
-0.2922844886779785,
0.3311448097229004,
0.22049666941165924,
-0.025161651894450188,
0.45198455452919006,
-0.12165757268667221,
0.3207014501094818,
0.4038409888744354,
-0.5623525381088257,
-0.2923252284526825,
0.30290740728378296,
-0.7750836610794067,
0.07484343647956848,
0.8534095287322998,
-0.43830665946006775,
-0.25536978244781494,
-0.3580809533596039,
-0.1464342623949051,
0.15975365042686462,
-0.7947402596473694,
0.8052865862846375,
0.8428136706352234,
-0.5644899606704712,
0.27405768632888794,
-0.3181467652320862,
1.047174096107483,
0.32571515440940857,
-0.5729464292526245,
-0.34301844239234924,
0.37300533056259155,
-0.27726414799690247,
0.6155930161476135,
0.8926100134849548,
0.48169293999671936,
0.5339258313179016,
0.1404910534620285,
-0.3868943750858307,
0.15903890132904053,
-0.6076208353042603,
0.019096937030553818,
-0.09824710339307785,
0.3199566602706909,
-0.12916189432144165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04638v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04638v1
|
Large Language Model-guided Document Selection
| 2024-06-07T04:52:46 | 2024-06-07T04:52:46 |
Xiang Kong, Tom Gunter, Ruoming Pang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Model (LLM) pre-training exhausts an ever growing compute
budget, yet recent research has demonstrated that careful document selection
enables comparable model quality with only a fraction of the FLOPs. Inspired by
efforts suggesting that domain-specific training document selection is in fact
an interpretable process [Gunasekar et al., 2023], as well as research showing
that instruction-finetuned LLMs are adept zero-shot data labelers [Gilardi et
al.,2023], we explore a promising direction for scalable general-domain
document selection; employing a prompted LLM as a document grader, we distill
quality labels into a classifier model, which is applied at scale to a large,
and already heavily-filtered, web-crawl-derived corpus autonomously. Following
the guidance of this classifier, we drop 75% of the corpus and train LLMs on
the remaining data. Results across multiple benchmarks show that: 1. Filtering
allows us to quality-match a model trained on the full corpus across diverse
benchmarks with at most 70% of the FLOPs, 2. More capable LLM labelers and
classifier models lead to better results that are less sensitive to the
labeler's prompt, 3. In-context learning helps to boost the performance of
less-capable labeling models. In all cases we use open-source datasets, models,
recipes, and evaluation frameworks, so that results can be reproduced by the
community.
|
[
-0.3486846685409546,
-0.6372271180152893,
0.7627682685852051,
-0.047602344304323196,
-0.18565478920936584,
0.06338582187891006,
-0.281189888715744,
-0.509415864944458,
-0.05569280683994293,
0.7339102029800415,
-0.30190160870552063,
-0.6680304408073425,
-0.8669620752334595,
0.01554546132683754,
-0.6893209218978882,
1.0873006582260132,
0.07635673135519028,
0.17775358259677887,
-0.5269148349761963,
0.034236036241054535,
-0.15693333745002747,
-0.47107625007629395,
-0.8465079665184021,
-0.639995276927948,
0.5517462491989136,
0.24974218010902405,
0.5243710279464722,
0.8934865593910217,
0.41798269748687744,
0.2414511740207672,
-0.29418012499809265,
0.00583990290760994,
-0.6676417589187622,
0.2427975833415985,
-0.06561558693647385,
-0.4545800983905792,
-0.554405927658081,
0.3471742272377014,
0.6184434294700623,
0.8054889440536499,
0.15852512419223785,
0.03405112028121948,
0.05638541653752327,
0.6520862579345703,
-0.43883296847343445,
-0.052347421646118164,
-0.638224720954895,
-0.11936432868242264,
-0.22415195405483246,
0.09435594081878662,
-0.673993706703186,
-0.29645392298698425,
-0.046755608171224594,
-0.5710975527763367,
0.32903069257736206,
0.11985861510038376,
0.7508201003074646,
0.2697540819644928,
-0.3514070212841034,
-0.42399489879608154,
-0.6610927581787109,
0.7556988596916199,
-0.4079115092754364,
0.6055459976196289,
0.6854591369628906,
0.19764003157615662,
-0.052294738590717316,
-0.9060584902763367,
-0.3009410500526428,
-0.3375193476676941,
0.2611081004142761,
0.08002260327339172,
-0.03806339204311371,
0.06514734774827957,
0.22457154095172882,
0.48400673270225525,
-0.615999698638916,
0.4921168088912964,
-0.1673196703195572,
-0.18603752553462982,
0.32488590478897095,
-0.09904638677835464,
0.12370558828115463,
0.23923584818840027,
-0.2632884681224823,
-0.23472429811954498,
-0.8520445227622986,
-0.11490622907876968,
0.3533928096294403,
0.1766485720872879,
0.3280044496059418,
0.430172324180603,
-0.27007126808166504,
1.0273065567016602,
0.17657005786895752,
-0.3814258873462677,
0.03613172098994255,
-0.041661351919174194,
-0.29515933990478516,
-0.10403172671794891,
0.7176268100738525,
0.20894615352153778,
0.11128388345241547,
-0.13997133076190948,
-0.525588870048523,
-0.06430748105049133,
0.30291152000427246,
-1.0871434211730957,
-0.15178543329238892,
0.2162383645772934,
-0.38434046506881714,
-0.22860591113567352,
-0.2090318650007248,
-0.6566195487976074,
-0.42862406373023987,
-0.481942355632782,
0.2249934822320938,
-0.37846434116363525,
0.2103138118982315,
0.08434197306632996,
-0.10570798069238663,
0.1328100860118866,
0.5590947866439819,
-0.9985191822052002,
0.05954063683748245,
0.7294532656669617,
0.8043530583381653,
-0.2779959440231323,
-0.1877896785736084,
-0.9204111099243164,
0.1102714017033577,
-0.4597274661064148,
0.9648747444152832,
-0.803767204284668,
-0.613713800907135,
0.05722355470061302,
-0.21503697335720062,
0.1385583132505417,
-0.6585831046104431,
0.6946383118629456,
-0.9148780703544617,
0.163383349776268,
-0.052743300795555115,
-0.7514676451683044,
0.017022650688886642,
0.33146247267723083,
-0.7195161581039429,
0.9628398418426514,
0.3758646845817566,
-0.3960256278514862,
0.5657903552055359,
-0.23098577558994293,
-0.46585530042648315,
0.1537548303604126,
0.021025007590651512,
-0.3651246726512909,
-0.0695275291800499,
0.30961766839027405,
0.5529348254203796,
-0.4982139766216278,
0.2903811037540436,
-0.3740632236003876,
-0.4502270519733429,
-0.01005783025175333,
-0.43474751710891724,
0.526841402053833,
0.4151849150657654,
-0.009678179398179054,
0.17828088998794556,
-0.8489633202552795,
-0.07561758905649185,
-0.02737046778202057,
-0.8455849289894104,
-0.275989830493927,
-0.16983562707901,
0.2184208631515503,
0.18413592875003815,
0.2722853720188141,
-0.4537222981452942,
0.28492632508277893,
-0.2854906916618347,
0.42663872241973877,
0.5945300459861755,
-0.22110314667224884,
0.7942299842834473,
-0.33165988326072693,
0.6363474130630493,
-0.37538352608680725,
0.21436789631843567,
-0.10826070606708527,
-0.3087806701660156,
-0.7210985422134399,
-0.5854417085647583,
0.5027176141738892,
0.2812308073043823,
-0.5338017344474792,
0.45279982686042786,
-0.25604748725891113,
-0.541398823261261,
-0.5374708771705627,
0.3740803897380829,
0.3536757826805115,
0.6160192489624023,
0.3469666838645935,
-0.13795091211795807,
-0.18426325917243958,
-0.6130014657974243,
0.05107774958014488,
-0.02734910324215889,
-0.2593362629413605,
0.1760147362947464,
0.2132367491722107,
-0.44114524126052856,
0.9236907362937927,
-0.6116315722465515,
-0.4358939230442047,
-0.348650187253952,
0.12065143883228302,
0.24414680898189545,
0.19406208395957947,
0.423429399728775,
-0.798829197883606,
-0.5585277080535889,
-0.1087966039776802,
-0.49105995893478394,
-0.41005992889404297,
-0.06249910965561867,
-0.17781446874141693,
0.24365371465682983,
0.7208508253097534,
-0.5180231928825378,
0.060782935470342636,
0.4240848422050476,
-0.10465779155492783,
0.41968056559562683,
-0.4412429928779602,
-0.11968781054019928,
-0.9295510053634644,
-0.04830680415034294,
0.09701626747846603,
-0.3616570830345154,
-0.40319907665252686,
0.053115904331207275,
0.363923579454422,
-0.05468638986349106,
-0.43734872341156006,
0.8354889750480652,
-0.5253708362579346,
-0.05044152960181236,
-0.5377707481384277,
0.2771765887737274,
0.25676029920578003,
0.15888409316539764,
0.17268337309360504,
0.78703773021698,
0.5341965556144714,
-0.6933284401893616,
0.12429407238960266,
0.2730007469654083,
-0.44469016790390015,
0.6184192895889282,
-0.3964395523071289,
0.15199363231658936,
-0.09038639068603516,
0.5207962393760681,
-0.8225073218345642,
-0.15837445855140686,
-0.15903019905090332,
-0.30177369713783264,
0.5920847058296204,
-0.2968967854976654,
-0.6059384346008301,
-0.34686514735221863,
-0.28303319215774536,
0.05507978796958923,
0.4507160186767578,
-0.8181124925613403,
0.4693734645843506,
0.5294507145881653,
-0.08593273162841797,
-0.400710791349411,
-0.513410210609436,
0.07981141656637192,
-0.054383885115385056,
-0.29598838090896606,
0.243604376912117,
-0.4025178551673889,
-0.08272308856248856,
-0.26804617047309875,
-0.13955187797546387,
-0.26910555362701416,
0.21044175326824188,
0.3057989478111267,
0.38753294944763184,
-0.1149028018116951,
0.19589947164058685,
0.045141611248254776,
-0.11916543543338776,
-0.035316504538059235,
-0.5767286419868469,
0.5660368204116821,
0.09585465490818024,
-0.32657426595687866,
0.07613959908485413,
0.15508577227592468,
0.4815327823162079,
-0.4048307538032532,
0.5711867213249207,
0.636803150177002,
-0.13974611461162567,
-0.44029372930526733,
-0.6375691890716553,
-0.0006701108650304377,
-0.4648788571357727,
0.24305219948291779,
-0.22865629196166992,
-1.1841191053390503,
0.13011904060840607,
-0.21971434354782104,
-0.04508683457970619,
0.3729938864707947,
0.4139136075973511,
-0.07991359382867813,
0.7727174162864685,
0.7249513268470764,
-0.3569992482662201,
0.6345371603965759,
-0.34165287017822266,
0.13578110933303833,
-0.8519684672355652,
-0.07740532606840134,
-0.6813737750053406,
-0.11417591571807861,
-0.43912795186042786,
-0.48424288630485535,
0.3055594265460968,
0.18273009359836578,
-0.1640065610408783,
0.08773358911275864,
-0.5482290983200073,
0.7697370052337646,
0.6172505617141724,
-0.040874090045690536,
0.2921745479106903,
-0.13658292591571808,
-0.14836274087429047,
0.2297452986240387,
-0.43660879135131836,
-0.7430306673049927,
1.2882683277130127,
0.2979608476161957,
0.7536990642547607,
-0.1460941880941391,
0.7979279160499573,
0.23161469399929047,
0.6313591599464417,
-0.9188786149024963,
0.5720223784446716,
-0.36391082406044006,
-0.6569390892982483,
-0.470704048871994,
-0.26242196559906006,
-1.050276279449463,
0.35333988070487976,
-0.11165070533752441,
-0.5215975046157837,
-0.11399532109498978,
-0.11460278928279877,
-0.3144373595714569,
0.2535454034805298,
-0.4957294762134552,
0.6663384437561035,
-0.16181500256061554,
-0.2825317978858948,
-0.11059746146202087,
-0.36857903003692627,
0.24772104620933533,
-0.6263211369514465,
0.245313823223114,
-0.15509667992591858,
-0.13223139941692352,
0.6580185294151306,
-0.2714640200138092,
0.7366233468055725,
-0.005270170513540506,
-0.213424414396286,
0.3357563018798828,
0.13539040088653564,
0.49607014656066895,
-0.060997288674116135,
-0.3156735897064209,
0.10875643044710159,
-0.22976961731910706,
-0.18489590287208557,
-0.2953305244445801,
0.8176454901695251,
-0.7329496145248413,
-0.6624342799186707,
-0.2573614716529846,
-0.4598797559738159,
-0.30236223340034485,
0.5356757044792175,
0.3153513967990875,
0.4673035740852356,
-0.3211848735809326,
0.3098794221878052,
0.9878828525543213,
-0.2972992956638336,
0.4739348590373993,
0.6962292194366455,
-0.29651713371276855,
-0.3623138964176178,
0.906129777431488,
0.13209885358810425,
0.23432236909866333,
0.7208249568939209,
0.16424912214279175,
-0.42840731143951416,
-0.8389912843704224,
-0.3159942626953125,
0.2210589051246643,
-0.9065567255020142,
-0.31613630056381226,
-0.845525860786438,
-0.26351773738861084,
-0.48009541630744934,
-0.38745173811912537,
-0.27855971455574036,
-0.1813269704580307,
-0.512066662311554,
-0.1559581160545349,
0.13570885360240936,
0.837358295917511,
0.07861709594726562,
0.37254151701927185,
-0.7106324434280396,
0.34081020951271057,
0.29671600461006165,
0.4151776134967804,
-0.07333008199930191,
-0.7661551833152771,
-0.28482621908187866,
-0.26348844170570374,
-0.3515912890434265,
-0.4429834187030792,
0.5229335427284241,
0.14801420271396637,
0.6085606217384338,
0.3611104488372803,
0.09151069074869156,
0.1981852799654007,
-0.5825446248054504,
0.6496660709381104,
-0.03132333979010582,
-0.7497889399528503,
0.6331937909126282,
-0.5495569109916687,
0.48397842049598694,
0.6516796946525574,
0.5827106237411499,
-0.4105547368526459,
-0.5238956809043884,
-0.32713645696640015,
-0.9732487797737122,
0.6905706524848938,
-0.2777116596698761,
0.04126071184873581,
-0.1568925827741623,
0.3543589115142822,
0.27642568945884705,
0.07610268145799637,
-0.640034019947052,
-0.12134632468223572,
0.018198875710368156,
-0.061796583235263824,
-0.396474689245224,
-0.41742098331451416,
0.09670615196228027,
-0.11446909606456757,
0.6906253695487976,
-0.2434123456478119,
-0.017514554783701897,
0.024436412379145622,
-0.3329019546508789,
-0.1510610580444336,
0.27091801166534424,
0.4016037583351135,
0.6065327525138855,
-0.27693966031074524,
0.051620982587337494,
-0.06364327669143677,
-0.5467063784599304,
0.22206659615039825,
0.13275893032550812,
-0.41845518350601196,
-0.10680434852838516,
0.340930312871933,
0.7003464102745056,
0.2020481377840042,
-0.6432276964187622,
0.5422728061676025,
-0.05379778519272804,
-0.2700601816177368,
-0.11507950723171234,
0.19849641621112823,
0.20184184610843658,
0.0893484354019165,
0.27546408772468567,
-0.18828953802585602,
0.11404760181903839,
-0.26935404539108276,
0.16913814842700958,
0.4383646845817566,
-0.2426329255104065,
0.023420335724949837,
0.8609095811843872,
0.23164889216423035,
-0.29249098896980286,
0.6566604971885681,
-0.22014206647872925,
-0.30875805020332336,
0.4713743031024933,
0.4684213399887085,
0.7631076574325562,
-0.03780199959874153,
0.36226388812065125,
0.31598347425460815,
0.148701474070549,
-0.46661263704299927,
-0.221895232796669,
-0.10176966339349747,
-0.6065360903739929,
-0.4339587986469269,
-1.038786768913269,
-0.6662412285804749,
0.459923654794693,
-0.4751715064048767,
0.23033317923545837,
-0.5875376462936401,
-0.09764199703931808,
0.06049015372991562,
0.19611802697181702,
-0.7207238674163818,
0.5131140947341919,
0.37530452013015747,
1.016326665878296,
-0.629427969455719,
1.1717008352279663,
0.5651200413703918,
-0.3957512676715851,
-0.5798327922821045,
0.12269587069749832,
-0.07199255377054214,
-0.6898432970046997,
0.7784868478775024,
0.2499992996454239,
-0.0501125305891037,
0.08348450064659119,
-0.5427026748657227,
-1.0594322681427002,
1.0691752433776855,
0.46296820044517517,
-0.7288505434989929,
0.08176760375499725,
-0.08199997991323471,
0.6791568994522095,
-0.3453487455844879,
0.4268643856048584,
0.4932209551334381,
0.40997329354286194,
0.41919660568237305,
-0.7568507194519043,
-0.17801615595817566,
0.1198718249797821,
0.061692722141742706,
0.1607033610343933,
-0.6457033157348633,
0.8077563047409058,
-0.007703191600739956,
0.0592120923101902,
0.018490690737962723,
0.512738823890686,
0.17915478348731995,
0.33297935128211975,
0.38953807950019836,
0.5691192150115967,
1.0221999883651733,
0.08746781200170517,
1.255075216293335,
-0.2776919901371002,
0.055683862417936325,
1.2090097665786743,
-0.5083436965942383,
1.0624585151672363,
0.19703367352485657,
-0.19748632609844208,
0.15444248914718628,
0.9418971538543701,
-0.037313107401132584,
0.4472936689853668,
0.19224578142166138,
-0.29730042815208435,
-0.3493022918701172,
-0.21346962451934814,
-0.0831027403473854,
0.4467669129371643,
0.24718628823757172,
-0.379665732383728,
-0.24502429366111755,
0.0010769180953502655,
-0.01879304274916649,
0.04599212482571602,
-0.41564980149269104,
0.7143584489822388,
0.1118098720908165,
-0.7108741998672485,
0.6357420682907104,
0.03314102813601494,
0.7512853741645813,
-0.6275527477264404,
0.32065466046333313,
-0.4388129413127899,
0.07567286491394043,
-0.03353971615433693,
-0.8354460000991821,
0.06367955356836319,
0.12459897249937057,
-0.4591693878173828,
-0.7568017244338989,
0.9077900052070618,
-0.42199352383613586,
-0.32730773091316223,
0.5098201036453247,
0.5423976182937622,
0.31961333751678467,
-0.42859140038490295,
-0.3812868297100067,
0.17350588738918304,
-0.08384302258491516,
-0.45816007256507874,
0.8143601417541504,
0.4266858994960785,
-0.11858153343200684,
0.7490264773368835,
0.805412232875824,
0.17730984091758728,
-0.18379342555999756,
0.2819041907787323,
0.930769145488739,
-0.44335702061653137,
-0.4855252504348755,
-0.6667575240135193,
0.1322590857744217,
-0.009905718266963959,
-0.10551705956459045,
0.5130956768989563,
0.6500756144523621,
1.0096806287765503,
0.018415145576000214,
0.7375544905662537,
0.38173210620880127,
0.4833213686943054,
-0.5599488019943237,
0.998203456401825,
-0.46664223074913025,
0.2216881960630417,
0.053253013640642166,
-1.1963434219360352,
-0.2996719777584076,
0.46756818890571594,
-0.45731985569000244,
0.007937587797641754,
0.6423417925834656,
0.7068485617637634,
0.07233665138483047,
-0.3095420300960541,
0.7131327986717224,
0.038034554570913315,
0.43156546354293823,
0.3713517487049103,
0.6199882626533508,
-0.13664032518863678,
0.6386401057243347,
0.0952138900756836,
-0.22871121764183044,
-0.25154411792755127,
-0.8777864575386047,
-1.0170094966888428,
-0.6298980712890625,
-0.30510950088500977,
-0.18872956931591034,
-0.16759251058101654,
0.760147213935852,
0.794736385345459,
-0.5443699955940247,
-0.08801474422216415,
0.1894931197166443,
0.22530192136764526,
0.1674925684928894,
-0.12742416560649872,
0.1623982936143875,
-0.5222713351249695,
-0.8770627975463867,
0.6841102838516235,
0.3237985372543335,
0.12530100345611572,
-0.11689151078462601,
-0.09227452427148819,
-0.15570315718650818,
0.057832274585962296,
0.739275336265564,
0.08991274237632751,
-0.5389270782470703,
0.03601859509944916,
-0.26344218850135803,
-0.5512326955795288,
0.14061540365219116,
0.5957912802696228,
-0.6916465163230896,
0.36273401975631714,
0.30090954899787903,
0.8835749626159668,
0.6716620326042175,
-0.30840739607810974,
0.3520384728908539,
-0.6524492502212524,
-0.07645560055971146,
0.2947694659233093,
0.31484130024909973,
0.4398118853569031,
-0.4773576557636261,
0.6355290412902832,
0.05373465269804001,
-0.7686651349067688,
-0.6587834358215332,
0.02600700408220291,
-0.8239882588386536,
-0.5279163718223572,
1.576695442199707,
-0.13252609968185425,
-0.3563024699687958,
0.03643396496772766,
-0.2999979555606842,
0.2137172818183899,
-0.4319031834602356,
0.6052049398422241,
0.8793568015098572,
0.10893552750349045,
-0.05694396048784256,
-0.6695433855056763,
0.4114212095737457,
0.12703964114189148,
-0.7165050506591797,
0.054500386118888855,
0.7761558294296265,
0.39670971035957336,
-0.028565440326929092,
0.7924235463142395,
0.11613363027572632,
-0.035151395946741104,
-0.10247685760259628,
0.14687563478946686,
-0.16950440406799316,
-0.4188266098499298,
-0.607823371887207,
0.29489967226982117,
0.4966500401496887,
0.022552594542503357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04630v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04630v1
|
Low-Resource Cross-Lingual Summarization through Few-Shot Learning with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-07T04:31:41 | 2024-06-07T04:31:41 |
Gyutae Park, Seojin Hwang, Hwanhee Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cross-lingual summarization (XLS) aims to generate a summary in a target
language different from the source language document. While large language
models (LLMs) have shown promising zero-shot XLS performance, their few-shot
capabilities on this task remain unexplored, especially for low-resource
languages with limited parallel data. In this paper, we investigate the
few-shot XLS performance of various models, including Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.2,
GPT-3.5, and GPT-4. Our experiments demonstrate that few-shot learning
significantly improves the XLS performance of LLMs, particularly GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, in low-resource settings. However, the open-source model
Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.2 struggles to adapt effectively to the XLS task with
limited examples. Our findings highlight the potential of few-shot learning for
improving XLS performance and the need for further research in designing LLM
architectures and pre-training objectives tailored for this task. We provide a
future work direction to explore more effective few-shot learning strategies
and to investigate the transfer learning capabilities of LLMs for cross-lingual
summarization.
|
[
-0.23450006544589996,
-0.5389593243598938,
0.4825330674648285,
-0.06005842238664627,
-0.3982592225074768,
-0.08902589231729507,
-0.17904771864414215,
-0.42238932847976685,
0.16149798035621643,
0.35393381118774414,
-0.341571182012558,
-0.5858067870140076,
-0.7967877984046936,
0.44168004393577576,
-0.3201289176940918,
0.9510229229927063,
-0.15113992989063263,
0.16892598569393158,
0.24102884531021118,
-0.2747236490249634,
-0.22698260843753815,
-0.2263476848602295,
-0.4580385982990265,
-0.2874845266342163,
0.6170430779457092,
0.7116358876228333,
0.41922736167907715,
0.49581190943717957,
0.2412659376859665,
0.15422941744327545,
-0.029234638437628746,
0.003256375901401043,
-0.9395946264266968,
-0.2722003757953644,
0.00783947017043829,
-0.7381898760795593,
-0.4899466037750244,
-0.3852173388004303,
0.9110732674598694,
0.7985624670982361,
0.09368490427732468,
0.19577910006046295,
0.33581873774528503,
0.7635487914085388,
-0.7353367805480957,
0.22194039821624756,
-0.5703871250152588,
0.26426541805267334,
-0.3944147527217865,
0.04518134891986847,
-0.2740953266620636,
0.016100436449050903,
0.07613413035869598,
-0.6979276537895203,
0.09147097915410995,
0.010202717036008835,
0.59462571144104,
-0.008810889907181263,
-0.3717861473560333,
0.1619938462972641,
-0.5386120080947876,
0.9478186964988708,
-0.8201104402542114,
0.3554726243019104,
0.28369227051734924,
0.44169002771377563,
0.3020309805870056,
-0.5890131592750549,
-0.1862175315618515,
0.08249828964471817,
-0.11310084164142609,
0.33256617188453674,
-0.5511661171913147,
-0.10106606781482697,
0.2872615158557892,
-0.0880851224064827,
-0.7598270773887634,
0.40792393684387207,
-0.500796914100647,
-0.06949333846569061,
0.37962862849235535,
0.4610494077205658,
0.028025677427649498,
-0.17136293649673462,
-0.29531267285346985,
0.15808223187923431,
-0.9098430871963501,
0.06656365841627121,
0.12278393656015396,
0.7064204812049866,
-0.6246271729469299,
0.5754997730255127,
-0.26348641514778137,
0.5797327756881714,
0.09134641289710999,
-0.33966606855392456,
-0.04979192465543747,
-0.4729788899421692,
-0.28513842821121216,
0.19282418489456177,
0.8093544840812683,
0.0403827428817749,
0.01572050340473652,
-0.007006490137428045,
-0.302361398935318,
-0.38474658131599426,
-0.2748553454875946,
-1.0194427967071533,
0.03789597004652023,
-0.11238653212785721,
-0.5821748971939087,
0.10244257003068924,
-0.20117418467998505,
-0.421526163816452,
-0.1684567779302597,
-0.30575859546661377,
0.45458394289016724,
-0.6227273941040039,
-0.11470109224319458,
-0.2682143747806549,
-0.027680205181241035,
0.19195722043514252,
0.693932831287384,
-0.8733617067337036,
0.43820837140083313,
0.5591663122177124,
1.0898773670196533,
-0.28793802857398987,
-0.5799950957298279,
-1.0480146408081055,
0.22709104418754578,
-0.6557216048240662,
1.0320734977722168,
-0.3942180573940277,
-0.4644494950771332,
-0.040083110332489014,
-0.22353315353393555,
-0.11773847788572311,
-0.5550574660301208,
-0.037981122732162476,
-0.2069084793329239,
0.014944176189601421,
-0.5437357425689697,
-0.5366560220718384,
-0.22266240417957306,
0.27020907402038574,
-0.5373131036758423,
0.6252278089523315,
0.2296610325574875,
-0.8574146032333374,
0.31079256534576416,
-0.5424489974975586,
-0.4269405007362366,
0.11408790946006775,
-0.3716582655906677,
-0.31689944863319397,
0.1010693907737732,
0.1469140201807022,
0.526585578918457,
-0.2439626306295395,
-0.4136015474796295,
-0.26381561160087585,
-0.5441291332244873,
-0.19353659451007843,
-0.3023310601711273,
0.6780378222465515,
0.13783946633338928,
0.02050713635981083,
-0.10384706407785416,
-0.45833131670951843,
-0.187077596783638,
0.03936987742781639,
-0.3289375901222229,
-0.35233834385871887,
-0.5039306879043579,
0.1226690411567688,
0.10909522324800491,
0.056229688227176666,
-0.2702297568321228,
0.20905189216136932,
-0.4651748836040497,
-0.22198377549648285,
0.36169493198394775,
-0.05826108902692795,
0.6541113257408142,
-0.3845313787460327,
0.850683331489563,
0.3836674690246582,
-0.16926874220371246,
-0.3947516679763794,
-0.25255876779556274,
-0.31161653995513916,
-0.3758186101913452,
0.2779638171195984,
0.578575611114502,
-1.1150583028793335,
-0.5037046670913696,
-0.37492862343788147,
-0.5229108333587646,
-0.2961258888244629,
0.8485880494117737,
0.6337310671806335,
0.5141307711601257,
0.30767762660980225,
-0.2581188976764679,
-0.24198421835899353,
-0.9130116105079651,
-0.35413551330566406,
0.059466518461704254,
-0.06034640967845917,
0.33892136812210083,
0.5504704713821411,
0.02761562168598175,
0.912499725818634,
-0.5556553602218628,
-0.6930788159370422,
-1.0377947092056274,
0.4727618396282196,
0.22339533269405365,
-0.023898733779788017,
1.0878663063049316,
-0.3502837121486664,
-1.0951474905014038,
0.2040514200925827,
-0.6961216926574707,
-0.22560812532901764,
0.0697539746761322,
0.1216692328453064,
0.47626620531082153,
0.31357404589653015,
-0.2700803875923157,
0.3646644055843353,
0.5692375302314758,
0.16921614110469818,
0.5933759212493896,
-0.22432638704776764,
-0.042433030903339386,
-1.0615473985671997,
0.06791474670171738,
0.20500417053699493,
-0.24056093394756317,
-0.6710574626922607,
-0.4578488767147064,
0.18905967473983765,
-0.15771467983722687,
-1.0190693140029907,
0.6972132921218872,
-0.5989750027656555,
-0.31981131434440613,
-0.5339720249176025,
0.23517529666423798,
-0.16311457753181458,
0.4737064838409424,
0.3581286072731018,
0.6765443682670593,
0.7912999987602234,
-0.3971906900405884,
0.0271235890686512,
0.17586050927639008,
-0.25566017627716064,
0.5779623985290527,
-0.48521748185157776,
-0.14680318534374237,
-0.33733561635017395,
0.36132922768592834,
-0.5845117568969727,
-0.17952369153499603,
0.0757051408290863,
-0.08944014459848404,
0.4570693373680115,
-0.5588241815567017,
-0.4104553461074829,
0.18543829023838043,
-0.5196195244789124,
0.5831930041313171,
0.3515912890434265,
-0.2998097240924835,
0.4861176908016205,
0.09825953096151352,
-0.5498840808868408,
-0.8168624043464661,
-0.7567275166511536,
0.06490019708871841,
0.012938098050653934,
-0.4122071862220764,
0.29424718022346497,
0.2696894705295563,
-0.32231834530830383,
0.041570812463760376,
-0.0568978488445282,
-0.15175354480743408,
-0.21749921143054962,
-0.08469384163618088,
0.299702912569046,
-0.565041184425354,
-0.134176567196846,
0.12525105476379395,
-0.12195821851491928,
-0.3712114691734314,
-0.13136319816112518,
0.20711542665958405,
-0.04454108327627182,
-0.3329348862171173,
-0.23728467524051666,
0.5487962961196899,
0.20621110498905182,
-0.06592269986867905,
0.6702488660812378,
0.7613545656204224,
-0.33033716678619385,
-0.4021926522254944,
-0.21196448802947998,
-0.029539959505200386,
-0.3073504865169525,
0.5325210690498352,
-0.33281421661376953,
-0.7772339582443237,
0.6989460587501526,
-0.018760714679956436,
0.15510781109333038,
0.36637958884239197,
0.6601338386535645,
0.0808677151799202,
0.576031506061554,
0.8807746767997742,
-0.35721853375434875,
0.6557491421699524,
-0.578804075717926,
-0.08312451094388962,
-0.5994554162025452,
0.31254181265830994,
-0.3032694160938263,
-0.19114121794700623,
-0.3787331283092499,
-0.2984570562839508,
0.8027881979942322,
0.0624692440032959,
-0.020864136517047882,
0.3125372529029846,
0.3415658175945282,
0.6910251975059509,
0.41114822030067444,
-0.011121251620352268,
0.4138815402984619,
-0.06026030704379082,
-0.2778627276420593,
0.0937921330332756,
-1.0863964557647705,
-0.3226713538169861,
1.0999460220336914,
0.11860895156860352,
1.1175624132156372,
0.20762799680233002,
1.0545876026153564,
-0.035405054688453674,
0.2549341022968292,
-0.6976383328437805,
0.2780650556087494,
-0.4254952371120453,
-0.3003898561000824,
-0.4940597712993622,
-0.5440303683280945,
-0.9896038174629211,
0.422873854637146,
-0.18273362517356873,
-0.6466833353042603,
-0.0018921713344752789,
0.1861843466758728,
-0.6886392831802368,
0.3922777771949768,
-0.7211243510246277,
0.9360402226448059,
-0.3029400110244751,
-0.6588600277900696,
-0.2563187777996063,
-0.5178568959236145,
0.6578406691551208,
-0.32809627056121826,
0.1752389818429947,
0.10114293545484543,
-0.17513400316238403,
0.5825393199920654,
-0.36097294092178345,
1.1232490539550781,
-0.058180034160614014,
-0.19395272433757782,
0.3294973075389862,
0.24085937440395355,
0.42629867792129517,
-0.09595167636871338,
0.1714630424976349,
0.3740848898887634,
0.049119338393211365,
-0.425283282995224,
-0.30692577362060547,
0.6553356647491455,
-0.6772218346595764,
-0.49410197138786316,
-0.28214868903160095,
-0.5883959531784058,
-0.0678979903459549,
0.3772893249988556,
0.4842779040336609,
0.4246569275856018,
-0.31776881217956543,
0.13839571177959442,
0.41316843032836914,
-0.36160096526145935,
0.6855509877204895,
0.6642260551452637,
-0.2940434515476227,
-0.3170449733734131,
0.6660955548286438,
0.5627581477165222,
0.40629416704177856,
0.6239965558052063,
0.19254709780216217,
-0.04325886443257332,
-0.5616812705993652,
-0.45731768012046814,
0.4051778018474579,
-0.7067322134971619,
-0.38381242752075195,
-0.43390583992004395,
-0.11512163281440735,
-0.5949353575706482,
-0.24743427336215973,
-0.5273536443710327,
-0.3713553249835968,
-0.18065495789051056,
0.10056448727846146,
0.1651586890220642,
0.816611647605896,
-0.3282218873500824,
0.28310200572013855,
-1.186814785003662,
0.6015253067016602,
0.3020894527435303,
0.3259110748767853,
0.13040249049663544,
-0.6967406272888184,
-0.7660881876945496,
-0.08519557863473892,
-0.4655101001262665,
-0.7403851747512817,
0.6540510058403015,
0.16604506969451904,
0.5637629628181458,
0.5154383778572083,
-0.0091570308431983,
0.6497175097465515,
-0.5346107482910156,
0.6656768321990967,
0.3069320619106293,
-0.7700172662734985,
0.26454079151153564,
-0.435947060585022,
0.6821857690811157,
0.3153022527694702,
0.41768378019332886,
-0.4719209671020508,
-0.2646953761577606,
-0.22857899963855743,
-0.5086966753005981,
1.2086660861968994,
0.2186191976070404,
-0.17676392197608948,
0.3668515384197235,
-0.07696738094091415,
0.46388471126556396,
-0.06732209771871567,
-0.694481372833252,
-0.17299123108386993,
-0.10801079124212265,
-0.015046902000904083,
-0.19280947744846344,
-0.20186829566955566,
0.04189788177609444,
0.055496834218502045,
0.5895861387252808,
-0.39334172010421753,
-0.1840668022632599,
-0.04508242756128311,
-0.36545926332473755,
-0.4267347455024719,
0.3744882345199585,
0.7211975455284119,
0.5442794561386108,
-0.16646604239940643,
0.07241427898406982,
0.5073449611663818,
-0.41722047328948975,
-0.0603867806494236,
0.13064377009868622,
-0.1945287138223648,
0.1205107569694519,
0.7523037195205688,
0.7852847576141357,
0.5125271677970886,
-0.474303275346756,
0.554968535900116,
0.05103033035993576,
-0.2703579068183899,
-0.08310287445783615,
-0.13453809916973114,
0.016232900321483612,
0.2935231328010559,
0.360563725233078,
-0.18845979869365692,
-0.06088990345597267,
-0.5382209420204163,
-0.07019656151533127,
0.429487407207489,
0.007817987352609634,
-0.5101156234741211,
0.5273326635360718,
0.10350504517555237,
0.058816347271203995,
0.2694776654243469,
-0.2046719491481781,
-0.3666705787181854,
0.44032421708106995,
0.47672903537750244,
0.9408079981803894,
-0.023984400555491447,
-0.005605488549917936,
0.3285745680332184,
0.2944391965866089,
-0.16499730944633484,
0.09846076369285583,
-0.23068732023239136,
-0.6153463125228882,
-0.5127671360969543,
-0.3371642827987671,
-0.7476013898849487,
0.07486610859632492,
-0.3568419814109802,
0.618140697479248,
-0.13623109459877014,
0.06076823174953461,
0.005933776963502169,
0.007766704075038433,
-0.7807953357696533,
-0.4105927050113678,
0.44152480363845825,
0.8815186023712158,
-0.9860231876373291,
0.8355504870414734,
0.6382300853729248,
-0.5596796274185181,
-0.6074857115745544,
0.023480692878365517,
0.3308737576007843,
-0.5664858222007751,
0.9926522970199585,
-0.15221375226974487,
-0.22765880823135376,
-0.14318539202213287,
-0.40686336159706116,
-0.8180625438690186,
1.2034565210342407,
0.7330459952354431,
-0.633754551410675,
-0.0981074720621109,
0.4446201026439667,
0.366938054561615,
-0.27287527918815613,
0.27875861525535583,
0.24648968875408173,
0.27696481347084045,
0.03979676216840744,
-1.319823145866394,
-0.36203086376190186,
0.11927738785743713,
-0.05506075546145439,
0.005057618021965027,
-0.7033708691596985,
0.9769167304039001,
-0.4980643391609192,
-0.13367781043052673,
-0.16179530322551727,
0.5250077843666077,
0.3084775507450104,
0.46371790766716003,
0.16641020774841309,
0.47751185297966003,
0.2174394130706787,
0.3898547291755676,
1.1236121654510498,
-0.24889764189720154,
0.25196024775505066,
1.1708568334579468,
-0.5897814035415649,
0.9225184917449951,
0.26044991612434387,
-0.05961931496858597,
0.12157043814659119,
0.2690598666667938,
0.2856731116771698,
0.43011125922203064,
-0.3213164210319519,
-0.10171424597501755,
-0.2685864567756653,
-0.07193390280008316,
-0.22775395214557648,
0.5302804112434387,
0.1550464630126953,
-0.22881704568862915,
-0.9037025570869446,
0.06871218979358673,
0.08285194635391235,
-0.14965899288654327,
-0.583371639251709,
0.9162895679473877,
0.5094105005264282,
-0.45480382442474365,
0.7559077739715576,
-0.02317003905773163,
0.6126795411109924,
-0.7370050549507141,
-0.14233903586864471,
-0.5439466834068298,
0.17271485924720764,
-0.24312451481819153,
-0.562285840511322,
-0.00001285745111090364,
0.4691322445869446,
-0.06764242053031921,
-0.1566256880760193,
0.6197877526283264,
-0.5226844549179077,
-0.5978813767433167,
0.35189810395240784,
0.9494930505752563,
0.17145149409770966,
0.06003311276435852,
-0.4967576861381531,
-0.24438342452049255,
-0.2304866462945938,
-0.13679811358451843,
0.8073151111602783,
0.8027992248535156,
-0.025530319660902023,
0.4840390384197235,
0.2395104616880417,
0.32124918699264526,
0.013698490336537361,
0.1639658510684967,
0.6182743906974792,
-0.6027230620384216,
-0.5166779160499573,
-0.8234279751777649,
0.16762010753154755,
0.31566810607910156,
-0.020781071856617928,
0.8152866959571838,
0.9942808151245117,
0.9816563129425049,
-0.30175063014030457,
0.9906700849533081,
0.32776322960853577,
0.46066129207611084,
-0.6998550295829773,
0.7388176321983337,
-0.5644665360450745,
0.30003324151039124,
-0.4849305748939514,
-0.8180761933326721,
-0.3423941135406494,
0.15031127631664276,
-0.3997688293457031,
-0.05136775225400925,
0.8180587887763977,
0.6874016523361206,
-0.3536267578601837,
-0.4598161280155182,
0.7976972460746765,
0.3547467589378357,
0.02812075801193714,
0.741159975528717,
0.5377777814865112,
-0.2071932703256607,
0.8973070979118347,
-0.4528048634529114,
-0.12331774830818176,
-0.3594282865524292,
-0.9097051620483398,
-0.9458383321762085,
-0.25915396213531494,
-0.21873493492603302,
0.19774940609931946,
-0.15894970297813416,
1.0357972383499146,
0.4180590808391571,
-0.7005074620246887,
-0.5793945789337158,
0.3623557686805725,
0.22694353759288788,
-0.31778958439826965,
-0.1391928344964981,
0.41435328125953674,
-0.45499786734580994,
-0.7702088952064514,
0.3183164894580841,
0.5522142648696899,
0.2800176441669464,
-0.030238857492804527,
-0.2747362554073334,
0.05389060825109482,
-0.10081503540277481,
0.833258330821991,
0.5456289649009705,
-0.5437743067741394,
0.11735089868307114,
0.02707488276064396,
-0.17902344465255737,
0.10664055496454239,
0.6980831027030945,
-0.7963695526123047,
0.15312759578227997,
0.5243846774101257,
0.5550732612609863,
0.6331043839454651,
-0.032448794692754745,
0.3893466591835022,
-0.789669930934906,
0.21688660979270935,
0.04414394497871399,
0.7002880573272705,
0.11893730610609055,
-0.045818787068128586,
0.36330297589302063,
0.18102103471755981,
-0.1203119307756424,
-0.6832890510559082,
-0.03679119795560837,
-0.9395785927772522,
-0.3192417621612549,
1.2747104167938232,
-0.18169699609279633,
-0.2857237756252289,
0.07885131239891052,
-0.23498889803886414,
0.197213813662529,
-0.4128984808921814,
0.701119601726532,
0.449515700340271,
-0.4065724313259125,
-0.35908663272857666,
-0.4221242666244507,
0.3325471580028534,
0.19199109077453613,
-0.836021363735199,
0.23272369801998138,
0.57657390832901,
0.35509783029556274,
-0.10809983313083649,
0.7591561079025269,
-0.039354126900434494,
0.49940431118011475,
0.15701784193515778,
-0.21371115744113922,
-0.04306776821613312,
-0.16256636381149292,
-0.4607279896736145,
0.18106186389923096,
0.10374966263771057,
0.020195217803120613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06615v1
|
Language Guided Skill Discovery
| 2024-06-07T04:25:38 | 2024-06-07T04:25:38 |
Seungeun Rho, Laura Smith, Tianyu Li, Sergey Levine, Xue Bin Peng, Sehoon Ha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
Skill discovery methods enable agents to learn diverse emergent behaviors
without explicit rewards. To make learned skills useful for unknown downstream
tasks, obtaining a semantically diverse repertoire of skills is essential.
While some approaches introduce a discriminator to distinguish skills and
others aim to increase state coverage, no existing work directly addresses the
"semantic diversity" of skills. We hypothesize that leveraging the semantic
knowledge of large language models (LLMs) can lead us to improve semantic
diversity of resulting behaviors. In this sense, we introduce Language Guided
Skill Discovery (LGSD), a skill discovery framework that aims to directly
maximize the semantic diversity between skills. LGSD takes user prompts as
input and outputs a set of semantically distinctive skills. The prompts serve
as a means to constrain the search space into a semantically desired subspace,
and the generated LLM outputs guide the agent to visit semantically diverse
states within the subspace. We demonstrate that LGSD enables legged robots to
visit different user-intended areas on a plane by simply changing the prompt.
Furthermore, we show that language guidance aids in discovering more diverse
skills compared to five existing skill discovery methods in robot-arm
manipulation environments. Lastly, LGSD provides a simple way of utilizing
learned skills via natural language.
|
[
-0.4095793664455414,
-0.6744935512542725,
0.6601338386535645,
-0.11312637478113174,
-0.05932530015707016,
0.4928509294986725,
-0.2097596824169159,
-0.5388420224189758,
0.3480849266052246,
0.6444786787033081,
-0.7735783457756042,
-1.029115080833435,
-0.7407011389732361,
-0.016704915091395378,
-0.06342919170856476,
0.9699852466583252,
0.10774056613445282,
-0.13939321041107178,
0.11439624428749084,
-0.13477985560894012,
-0.48662739992141724,
-0.18782879412174225,
-0.441706120967865,
-0.4060713052749634,
0.9132659435272217,
0.5410358905792236,
0.7491051554679871,
0.904083788394928,
0.24849306046962738,
0.3781455457210541,
-0.27266451716423035,
0.5321152806282043,
-0.32144665718078613,
-0.04868732765316963,
-0.46537819504737854,
-0.6418283581733704,
-0.11351154744625092,
-0.13449841737747192,
0.548340380191803,
1.1418770551681519,
-0.08962302654981613,
-0.23553824424743652,
-0.13524138927459717,
0.5040610432624817,
-0.34820356965065,
0.3266843855381012,
-0.6118240356445312,
0.11682795733213425,
-0.303173303604126,
-0.250118225812912,
-0.08108624815940857,
-0.06682036817073822,
0.06501580774784088,
-0.8584970235824585,
0.45851829648017883,
-0.24303454160690308,
0.6904312968254089,
0.40074512362480164,
-0.6268218755722046,
-0.454711377620697,
-0.6689468622207642,
0.8283430337905884,
-0.25050094723701477,
0.4056006968021393,
0.40354442596435547,
0.3908178210258484,
-0.4448413848876953,
-0.3590204417705536,
-0.41058534383773804,
-0.08852986991405487,
-0.03934688866138458,
-0.3227064907550812,
0.17496947944164276,
0.2744694948196411,
0.43013542890548706,
0.056405458599328995,
-0.47392672300338745,
0.325149267911911,
-0.19611209630966187,
-0.34742072224617004,
0.620241641998291,
0.17159666121006012,
0.648322343826294,
0.04521140083670616,
-0.0964600220322609,
-0.45135366916656494,
-0.6224563121795654,
0.42619457840919495,
0.5735509395599365,
0.8395671248435974,
0.18166682124137878,
0.6510488390922546,
-0.6013163924217224,
0.8165043592453003,
-0.2703879177570343,
-0.6470473408699036,
0.4097433388233185,
-0.21687662601470947,
0.4433302879333496,
-0.23902131617069244,
0.3489064574241638,
0.18174943327903748,
0.2871786653995514,
-0.36544010043144226,
-0.30972427129745483,
-0.11176985502243042,
0.17271454632282257,
-0.4055204391479492,
-0.0648566260933876,
-0.19711099565029144,
-0.39969274401664734,
-0.05803164467215538,
0.16555334627628326,
-0.5949630737304688,
-0.686493456363678,
-0.1997804045677185,
0.3105299472808838,
-0.5706881284713745,
-0.26740363240242004,
0.3933641314506531,
-0.6690852046012878,
0.3236995339393616,
0.4426009953022003,
-1.083181381225586,
0.22563715279102325,
0.8892156481742859,
0.506948709487915,
-0.1279609501361847,
-0.4675349295139313,
-0.769281268119812,
-0.06178269535303116,
-0.2373572438955307,
0.7167350053787231,
-0.7422720789909363,
-0.36084166169166565,
0.18548327684402466,
0.1913936734199524,
0.2140309363603592,
-0.6697784066200256,
0.3022702932357788,
-0.5814683437347412,
-0.037544261664152145,
-0.6017499566078186,
-0.33812588453292847,
-0.5646950602531433,
0.02373853698372841,
-0.6994150280952454,
1.0233734846115112,
0.4817904233932495,
-0.42204049229621887,
0.9640411734580994,
-0.6831142902374268,
-0.543137788772583,
0.226078599691391,
-0.2331845611333847,
-0.11112506687641144,
-0.283171147108078,
0.12308093905448914,
0.42978063225746155,
0.19086872041225433,
0.11491025239229202,
-0.2505100965499878,
-0.2684834599494934,
-0.1374526172876358,
0.16862252354621887,
0.5583066940307617,
-0.02177777700126171,
-0.22572758793830872,
0.23663391172885895,
-0.7577271461486816,
-0.04701557755470276,
0.127083882689476,
-0.5247766375541687,
-0.4388126730918884,
0.17411287128925323,
-0.3550952970981598,
0.09756799787282944,
0.16521142423152924,
-0.43077540397644043,
0.32413405179977417,
-0.5160729885101318,
-0.23490506410598755,
0.7000328302383423,
-0.20771628618240356,
0.6536118388175964,
-0.35377272963523865,
0.79953533411026,
-0.2247808426618576,
-0.2655448913574219,
-0.027778461575508118,
-0.4674813449382782,
-0.5882183313369751,
-0.44236212968826294,
-0.26462221145629883,
0.42859113216400146,
-0.978381335735321,
0.735406219959259,
0.06062019616365433,
-0.40819162130355835,
-0.7469775080680847,
0.6000962853431702,
0.2469458431005478,
0.09933038055896759,
0.39262017607688904,
-0.2717066705226898,
-0.23714080452919006,
-0.6877033710479736,
-0.27492547035217285,
-0.032479848712682724,
-0.17734967172145844,
0.5003978610038757,
0.3745981454849243,
-0.40271425247192383,
0.8019420504570007,
-0.4683438241481781,
-0.34217432141304016,
-0.5232457518577576,
0.12487571686506271,
0.26421013474464417,
0.07109114527702332,
0.49741366505622864,
-0.5998257994651794,
-0.2778427004814148,
0.2615238428115845,
-0.7076492309570312,
-0.17525169253349304,
-0.026018226519227028,
-0.04302331805229187,
-0.1398349106311798,
0.5163761377334595,
-0.4888420104980469,
0.10155580192804337,
0.27585530281066895,
-0.5604490041732788,
0.1812652349472046,
-0.15132570266723633,
-0.13558056950569153,
-0.6094913482666016,
-0.17739978432655334,
-0.29708874225616455,
-0.1913040280342102,
-0.5834704041481018,
0.3429781496524811,
-0.37029555439949036,
0.12403982132673264,
-0.14454905688762665,
0.6328563094139099,
-0.5315996408462524,
-0.37700748443603516,
-0.5806498527526855,
0.35884079337120056,
-0.33505979180336,
0.4134445786476135,
0.2715781331062317,
0.49594494700431824,
0.7548682689666748,
-0.6124993562698364,
0.3389815390110016,
0.23369379341602325,
-0.1903071254491806,
0.2252819836139679,
-0.2830226719379425,
0.09733100235462189,
-0.35368916392326355,
0.040079265832901,
-0.7027615308761597,
-0.12352858483791351,
0.2171250432729721,
-0.2734631299972534,
0.07285485416650772,
-0.25271815061569214,
-0.3123077154159546,
-0.297906756401062,
-0.21133878827095032,
0.20711573958396912,
0.4553016424179077,
-0.7434571981430054,
0.716904878616333,
0.38756462931632996,
-0.1441492736339569,
-0.7116533517837524,
-0.11801514774560928,
-0.12082421034574509,
-0.047556858509778976,
-0.8371750712394714,
0.1480042040348053,
0.0003768808383028954,
-0.19875815510749817,
-0.08185376971960068,
-0.14569437503814697,
0.18743973970413208,
0.5205199122428894,
0.2179105281829834,
-0.1564793735742569,
-0.15179745852947235,
0.36193332076072693,
-0.0342315137386322,
-0.2702152729034424,
-0.18126164376735687,
-0.39978715777397156,
0.7873731255531311,
-0.1527697592973709,
-0.676771879196167,
0.08810573816299438,
0.4399760365486145,
0.16595309972763062,
-0.46476811170578003,
0.6526942849159241,
1.0021764039993286,
-0.07760019600391388,
-0.6956731677055359,
-0.3101779520511627,
-0.453866571187973,
-0.5149868130683899,
0.7070324420928955,
-0.26637744903564453,
-1.369910478591919,
0.4964125156402588,
-0.24959349632263184,
-0.16076065599918365,
0.15732170641422272,
0.21999883651733398,
0.09727457910776138,
0.9066551923751831,
1.1408344507217407,
0.074407197535038,
0.5405837893486023,
-0.21068541705608368,
0.17608503997325897,
-0.4775151312351227,
-0.4030413329601288,
-0.5629041194915771,
-0.4194754660129547,
-0.8534544110298157,
-0.6614993810653687,
0.3159167170524597,
0.10342147946357727,
-0.11798247694969177,
0.16179919242858887,
-0.52131587266922,
0.6125897765159607,
0.8715178966522217,
0.2594224214553833,
0.23994950950145721,
-0.1540973037481308,
-0.24271412193775177,
0.10462767630815506,
-0.7216187715530396,
-0.45857393741607666,
0.9993384480476379,
0.2486421912908554,
0.652941882610321,
-0.02212817594408989,
1.1737407445907593,
0.17605489492416382,
-0.16373871266841888,
-1.066631555557251,
0.9867247343063354,
-0.21058036386966705,
-0.16502612829208374,
-0.7230191230773926,
-0.26777371764183044,
-1.2051172256469727,
0.2013910412788391,
-0.22298672795295715,
-0.5899918079376221,
-0.1541641801595688,
-0.0791345089673996,
-0.017031626775860786,
0.26642295718193054,
-0.4558907151222229,
0.6150971055030823,
-0.41223350167274475,
-0.12995551526546478,
-0.3602128028869629,
-0.6301317811012268,
0.0372186079621315,
0.10515575110912323,
0.06920448690652847,
-0.3344801664352417,
-0.22658444941043854,
0.44790735840797424,
-0.30685922503471375,
1.0748214721679688,
-0.4793631136417389,
-0.24064470827579498,
-0.0020929481834173203,
0.2339676469564438,
0.649252712726593,
-0.30260416865348816,
0.17018119990825653,
-0.16433730721473694,
-0.39079153537750244,
-0.3770032525062561,
-0.5738683938980103,
0.4155801236629486,
-0.7849664688110352,
-0.7348238229751587,
-0.216618150472641,
-0.8161277770996094,
-0.2601192891597748,
0.34009021520614624,
-0.32478004693984985,
-0.10236471146345139,
-0.10451030731201172,
0.15083466470241547,
0.8419433236122131,
-0.48537760972976685,
0.39197593927383423,
0.8511121869087219,
-0.1773890107870102,
0.21744929254055023,
0.9028011560440063,
-0.1137046292424202,
0.2245226502418518,
0.4769003093242645,
0.1741999387741089,
-0.07880605012178421,
-0.48609626293182373,
-0.009008745662868023,
0.24797941744327545,
-0.8901520371437073,
0.0719713494181633,
-0.5784212350845337,
-0.045740481466054916,
0.021332763135433197,
-0.36791151762008667,
-0.10442802309989929,
-0.1032153069972992,
-0.12031193822622299,
-0.41381901502609253,
0.6152347326278687,
0.8093513250350952,
-0.1409308761358261,
0.2638449966907501,
-0.6611067652702332,
0.45071786642074585,
0.4815262258052826,
0.33629176020622253,
-0.2712758481502533,
-0.0416894257068634,
-0.13687606155872345,
0.008973360992968082,
0.016006212681531906,
-0.6005902886390686,
0.29002729058265686,
0.11801666021347046,
1.082109808921814,
0.45672208070755005,
-0.0702538788318634,
0.15257100760936737,
-0.3149476945400238,
0.6272538304328918,
-0.01214089710265398,
-0.5701354742050171,
0.6121472120285034,
-0.5738765597343445,
0.32685360312461853,
0.16367851197719574,
0.5599021315574646,
-0.6941694021224976,
-0.45907530188560486,
-0.5801041722297668,
-0.8388453125953674,
0.632790744304657,
-0.2960436940193176,
0.06764371693134308,
-0.13799425959587097,
-0.018287604674696922,
0.42588114738464355,
0.1554303765296936,
-0.6224265694618225,
0.07262810319662094,
0.023204611614346504,
-0.1421014666557312,
-0.08068539947271347,
0.06703424453735352,
-0.4116789400577545,
-0.07717819511890411,
0.1890515387058258,
-0.6319015622138977,
0.09253956377506256,
-0.013715640641748905,
-0.015818875283002853,
-0.08710368722677231,
0.22794727981090546,
0.3778063654899597,
0.41802218556404114,
0.03695295378565788,
0.19944433867931366,
0.21411502361297607,
-0.20607754588127136,
0.01295598316937685,
0.04032300040125847,
-0.10307363420724869,
-0.08809029310941696,
0.5366290807723999,
0.9055337309837341,
-0.06543713063001633,
-0.889755129814148,
0.3613797724246979,
0.372227281332016,
-0.14041398465633392,
-0.06718748062849045,
0.7646066546440125,
0.09671557694673538,
0.5548518300056458,
0.2733216881752014,
-0.05346235632896423,
0.09223859757184982,
-0.635442316532135,
0.345781147480011,
0.9111799597740173,
-0.1660950779914856,
-0.044862110167741776,
0.2151550054550171,
0.24811765551567078,
-0.6148527264595032,
0.45282599329948425,
-0.3535415530204773,
-0.5729802250862122,
0.623989462852478,
0.27846238017082214,
0.7616463899612427,
0.008321786299347878,
0.48621347546577454,
0.06742595136165619,
0.29885271191596985,
-0.12493275105953217,
0.47994697093963623,
-0.3295438289642334,
-1.147243618965149,
-0.1966402679681778,
-0.47567218542099,
-0.23043279349803925,
-0.1994323432445526,
-0.3349566161632538,
0.3135620057582855,
-0.36575838923454285,
0.07122620940208435,
-0.13264045119285583,
0.01906646229326725,
-0.798844575881958,
0.028958534821867943,
0.08826281875371933,
0.6049045920372009,
-0.7583132982254028,
0.6241999268531799,
0.5885112285614014,
-0.44633370637893677,
-0.8808537721633911,
0.07237778604030609,
0.1303381472826004,
-1.2545112371444702,
0.89518141746521,
-0.040147412568330765,
-0.43383854627609253,
-0.1514723151922226,
-0.680798351764679,
-0.6347772479057312,
1.1339082717895508,
0.199038565158844,
-0.1442912369966507,
0.038839153945446014,
0.44999122619628906,
0.6812469363212585,
-0.36404597759246826,
0.20522291958332062,
0.3308216333389282,
0.4305534064769745,
0.2152169793844223,
-0.9424523115158081,
0.08084849268198013,
-0.13185173273086548,
-0.10741937160491943,
0.3083706796169281,
-0.47738146781921387,
0.6642336845397949,
-0.6508821845054626,
-0.03334750607609749,
-0.09230365604162216,
0.4653586149215698,
0.2982693314552307,
0.3279322683811188,
0.609041690826416,
0.3282564878463745,
1.0868905782699585,
-0.0015133057022467256,
0.8273246884346008,
-0.02112712524831295,
-0.06589116156101227,
0.6486085057258606,
-0.3588433265686035,
0.6037439107894897,
0.38740408420562744,
0.007810917682945728,
0.7416025996208191,
0.32974228262901306,
-0.06258241087198257,
0.5620860457420349,
0.4784224331378937,
-0.45628461241722107,
-0.5438247919082642,
-0.4450531601905823,
-0.14077569544315338,
0.5945143699645996,
0.29505226016044617,
-0.2262241691350937,
-0.5288612246513367,
0.13024266064167023,
-0.06114468351006508,
0.3939186632633209,
-0.16699184477329254,
0.9393560886383057,
-0.24830801784992218,
-0.6575385928153992,
0.33205586671829224,
0.015530659817159176,
0.8134305477142334,
-0.9033024311065674,
-0.5513466000556946,
-0.1436026245355606,
0.13420404493808746,
-0.22846563160419464,
-1.0276830196380615,
0.012621712870895863,
-0.29617413878440857,
-0.22910045087337494,
-0.5111294984817505,
0.9897028803825378,
-0.5391098856925964,
-0.057078707963228226,
0.6575576663017273,
0.6779181957244873,
0.00027131676324643195,
0.16571301221847534,
-0.11071331799030304,
-0.2721577286720276,
0.14701418578624725,
0.16097822785377502,
0.597359836101532,
0.7867223620414734,
-0.14542092382907867,
1.1165056228637695,
0.7265015840530396,
0.1144806444644928,
0.03544159606099129,
-0.04103248938918114,
0.9606624841690063,
-0.7695212960243225,
-0.46511948108673096,
-0.3143317699432373,
0.5739970207214355,
-0.0826789066195488,
-0.23144517838954926,
0.6168174147605896,
0.18499109148979187,
1.1283986568450928,
-0.3150227963924408,
0.7780644297599792,
-0.040017757564783096,
0.7253361940383911,
-0.6977890133857727,
0.4039953351020813,
-0.47382065653800964,
0.443202942609787,
-0.13393418490886688,
-0.45464932918548584,
-0.18048347532749176,
0.7704839706420898,
-0.09066767990589142,
0.36206796765327454,
0.5263761878013611,
1.260176181793213,
0.06173306703567505,
-0.30771180987358093,
0.37474262714385986,
-0.19034874439239502,
0.37556198239326477,
0.45052269101142883,
0.8644692897796631,
0.25598177313804626,
0.44838160276412964,
-0.12206657230854034,
-0.3507518172264099,
-0.08259712159633636,
-0.8361079692840576,
-1.0413824319839478,
-0.6433822512626648,
-0.05008421838283539,
-0.08557054400444031,
0.22560003399848938,
1.0214643478393555,
0.5898656249046326,
-0.4137636423110962,
-0.4218984842300415,
-0.04106197506189346,
0.4280382990837097,
-0.41008052229881287,
-0.23116740584373474,
-0.003366866847500205,
-0.5350726842880249,
-0.5601298213005066,
0.7155932784080505,
0.16237197816371918,
-0.17293208837509155,
-0.12404847145080566,
-0.4259270131587982,
-0.11649709194898605,
-0.41544240713119507,
0.4709099531173706,
0.5897717475891113,
-0.667489767074585,
-0.4841874837875366,
0.28688153624534607,
-0.02673475630581379,
-0.3230063021183014,
0.7793856263160706,
-0.8191632628440857,
0.39659592509269714,
0.5889571905136108,
0.798154354095459,
0.23823776841163635,
-0.27371326088905334,
0.6365869641304016,
-0.993442952632904,
0.2903624475002289,
0.33327344059944153,
0.2535788416862488,
0.12231110781431198,
-0.28269025683403015,
0.5582635402679443,
0.3514171242713928,
-0.2768925726413727,
-0.36381369829177856,
0.4462234675884247,
-0.9914457201957703,
-0.25533682107925415,
1.4657371044158936,
0.08902432024478912,
0.15961670875549316,
-0.27868345379829407,
-0.5421162247657776,
0.12963013350963593,
-0.3236042857170105,
0.8342101573944092,
0.6059708595275879,
-0.280299574136734,
-0.19314002990722656,
-0.4071505665779114,
0.8271933794021606,
0.22178296744823456,
-0.756294846534729,
-0.14959470927715302,
0.4965059161186218,
0.2826029360294342,
0.14609259366989136,
0.44353941082954407,
0.1825161725282669,
0.3703727126121521,
-0.07727904617786407,
0.4059452712535858,
-0.10147494077682495,
-0.4697711169719696,
-0.02129608392715454,
-0.007222170941531658,
0.40631264448165894,
-0.15406818687915802
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.